question
stringlengths
37
38.8k
group_id
stringlengths
2
6
sentence_embeddings
listlengths
768
768
<p>I recently read a paper in which the authors claim that in order to compare the forecasting performance of two non-nested models, models A and B, a valid procedure is to fit models A and B on the same data set, and compare the average likelihood of the fitted models computed on the hold-out data set. All that is required is that models A and B are expressed as probability densities for the same variable. I am using the language of the paper: strictly speaking the quantities being compared are fitted models evaluated at data points, not likelihoods. Accepting this likelihood as the forecasting accuracy metric, this method for checking forecast accuracy has some intuitive appeal, although I have misgivings. Can these likelihoods be meaningfully compared without some sort of normalization? The out of sample probabilities will not add up to one. I'm not able to come up with a straightforward example in which this test would give a spurious result.</p> <p>update: I was able to produce a simple example in which direct comparison of out of sample likelihoods gave a misleading result: let the dependent variable y be a linear trend plus normally distributed error term, and let the explanatory variable x be a linear trend plus independent normally distributed error term. Generate 100 points for y and x. Model A is a linear regression, while for model B I used a regression with Student t-distributed errors (with two degrees of freedom). I trained on the first 50 points and tested on the second set of 50 points, and repeated with training and test sets interchanged. I repeated with three choices of variance for the data generating process. Model B gave higher average out of sample likelihoods in all cases. This example is a bit contrived but does illustrate my concern.</p>
g74016
[ 0.02345934882760048, -0.09122113138437271, 0.0118392463773489, 0.02273717150092125, 0.0024441273417323828, 0.002564618829637766, -0.02175305038690567, 0.010630516335368156, -0.03681521117687225, -0.016202058643102646, 0.0640338659286499, -0.02378583699464798, 0.03837823495268822, 0.01376467663794756, -0.05916618928313255, 0.034560803323984146, 0.03595702350139618, -0.02155376970767975, 0.01263134740293026, -0.007089346181601286, -0.018695544451475143, 0.04793081805109978, 0.011853012256324291, 0.006231152918189764, -0.11794265359640121, -0.04270964115858078, -0.06105223298072815, 0.019800882786512375, -0.07020360976457596, 0.007941128686070442, 0.03810304030776024, -0.012225312180817127, 0.08028504997491837, -0.05746296048164368, -0.0481557734310627, 0.008699030615389347, 0.055988118052482605, 0.01123519241809845, -0.017077216878533363, -0.020307868719100952, 0.026882831007242203, 0.054265011101961136, 0.032428961247205734, -0.0007022474310360849, -0.008045296184718609, -0.020323146134614944, 0.038430966436862946, -0.00590186333283782, 0.016108518466353416, -0.03275325894355774, -0.04297307878732681, -0.003996599465608597, 0.03465203940868378, -0.01591852493584156, -0.02181541547179222, 0.042913369834423065, 0.0300816148519516, 0.03904873877763748, -0.019757499918341637, 0.007725228555500507, 0.06693746149539948, -0.014646526426076889, -0.03795487806200981, -0.029889045283198357, -0.03378445282578468, 0.018051384016871452, -0.061578042805194855, 0.0030632501002401114, -0.012012897990643978, -0.02203928679227829, -0.012877456843852997, 0.00927671231329441, 0.0013096003094688058, -0.064499132335186, -0.06157554313540459, -0.00735363969579339, 0.017473803833127022, -0.011057840660214424, -0.0385129489004612, 0.0493599995970726, -0.03253769129514694, 0.05722678452730179, 0.06242993846535683, 0.0636826753616333, 0.05495426431298256, -0.019707942381501198, 0.005962827708572149, 0.04358535632491112, 0.015479122288525105, 0.027312230318784714, 0.02070002444088459, 0.027193302288651466, 0.0104186050593853, 0.11308073997497559, -0.04564030468463898, 0.004691078793257475, -0.08904926478862762, -0.01999131217598915, 0.021166978403925896, 0.01671549491584301, -0.0344720333814621, 0.053135864436626434, 0.007749514188617468, -0.010716593824326992, -0.0395948700606823, -0.06140103191137314, 0.007995896972715855, 0.008407353423535824, -0.05957651138305664, -0.04906543344259262, -0.013021004386246204, 0.035951416939496994, -0.07053450495004654, -0.03239884227514267, -0.08255572617053986, -0.04269510135054588, 0.02823324128985405, -0.017904501408338547, 0.0011876097414642572, -0.027752753347158432, 0.06175527721643448, -0.006267188582569361, 0.030067211017012596, 0.03192070871591568, 0.008250509388744831, -0.010625806637108326, -0.04778970032930374, 0.044903986155986786, -0.002793623134493828, -0.050832293927669525, 0.0075899409130215645, 0.020392049103975296, 0.031004758551716805, 0.041092004626989365, -0.013394473120570183, 0.02028641477227211, -0.0035173071082681417, -0.008690199814736843, 0.02234208956360817, 0.022205471992492676, -0.016448643058538437, -0.0009446063777431846, 0.035226836800575256, -0.006338683422654867, -0.020214011892676353, 0.05923762544989586, -0.0072426218539476395, 0.0041900682263076305, -0.050710029900074005, 0.07392441481351852, 0.018392860889434814, 0.02413627877831459, 0.022770266979932785, 0.02662089839577675, -0.004905118141323328, 0.05807303637266159, 0.0007157159270718694, 0.041390616446733475, 0.05167289078235626, 0.01343824714422226, 0.0360063835978508, -0.01828797161579132, 0.03225855156779289, -0.04012913256883621, 0.04049106314778328, -0.004692088812589645, 0.05957043915987015, -0.03245263919234276, -0.023759042844176292, -0.03127097710967064, -0.009601018391549587, -0.0002464450662955642, 0.005470098927617073, 0.007620466873049736, 0.01888776198029518, 0.023250581696629524, 0.04862413927912712, 0.004989047069102526, 0.013031118549406528, 0.01206192933022976, 0.01332926657050848, 0.06747458875179291, -0.022704359143972397, -0.006767061538994312, -0.024503033608198166, -0.022857854142785072, 0.031666483730077744, 0.020872849971055984, -0.01882181689143181, -0.008161098696291447, -0.006717171985656023, -0.01937451958656311, -0.05468062683939934, -0.006984562613070011, 0.016779271885752678, -0.011261622421443462, 0.034973520785570145, -0.03302018716931343, 0.0400364063680172, 0.05020732805132866, 0.006998143158853054, 0.008691364899277687, -0.009331544861197472, -0.018022488802671432, 0.022386951372027397, 0.04189486429095268, 0.029364654794335365, -0.006369513459503651, 0.022192291915416718, 0.021346058696508408, -0.03682982921600342, -0.011991155333817005, 0.0031232857145369053, -0.001181328552775085, 0.08164042979478836, -0.05195536091923714, 0.007425461895763874, 0.05414985492825508, -0.05214676260948181, -0.07332044839859009, -0.07138065993785858, -0.029436815530061722, 0.04000575840473175, -0.032619453966617584, 0.053421612828969955, 0.0322037935256958, 0.027029026299715042, 0.05153590068221092, 0.042219944298267365, 0.02504579722881317, 0.007693083491176367, -0.03144925460219383, -0.03489815443754196, -0.021849840879440308, 0.018735371530056, -0.00020760724146384746, 0.03682014346122742, -0.005335694644600153, 0.05128725990653038, 0.037267107516527176, 0.008266514167189598, 0.01583639159798622, -0.07643009722232819, 0.0368683822453022, -0.00005728430915041827, -0.026244105771183968, 0.038298193365335464, -0.0199287049472332, 0.027950970456004143, 0.058721162378787994, -0.004541732836514711, 0.04036816954612732, 0.036864008754491806, -0.026232091709971428, -0.0004617565718945116, -0.0041181957349181175, 0.031761012971401215, -0.019800301641225815, 0.05461341515183449, -0.010457559488713741, -0.03073648177087307, -0.01979934424161911, -0.026785315945744514, 0.03709917888045311, 0.021373311057686806, -0.03281479701399803, 0.053163863718509674, -0.011464732699096203, -0.006787520367652178, -0.015989266335964203, 0.027773408219218254, -0.03205997869372368, 0.035296425223350525, 0.06286861002445221, 0.0226567592471838, 0.05494427680969238, -0.027219662442803383, 0.009113650768995285, 0.017988024279475212, -0.021238114684820175, 0.006521504372358322, -0.06405219435691833, -0.016071626916527748, 0.018440108746290207, 0.04151171073317528, -0.014766214415431023, 0.03315296396613121, -0.0259292833507061, 0.030358215793967247, 0.045990124344825745, -0.05373184010386467, 0.06032171845436096, 0.045156773179769516, 0.020103080198168755, -0.01822241209447384, 0.024080103263258934, -0.010175325907766819, -0.0662197470664978, 0.04588537663221359, 0.003048200160264969, -0.051115863025188446, 0.05110955983400345, 0.01170230470597744, 0.02144898846745491, 0.08074977993965149, -0.0069975717924535275, -0.029571302235126495, 0.008922189474105835, 0.033144596964120865, -0.050709016621112823, -0.02022348903119564, 0.01336673554033041, -0.03144184127449989, -0.03313878923654556, -0.016362037509679794, -0.022196948528289795, 0.0333126001060009, 0.031659599393606186, -0.00884129386395216, -0.028731493279337883, 0.02578796073794365, -0.006640629377216101, 0.011423184536397457, 0.03831285238265991, 0.0013055243762210011, 0.027402110397815704, 0.005276052746921778, 0.05250875651836395, -0.09131705015897751, -0.029996436089277267, 0.03976084664463997, -0.024621903896331787, 0.016549542546272278, -0.005596032366156578, 0.0007018829346634448, -0.0811288133263588, 0.03599412366747856, -0.017298754304647446, -0.0017222395399585366, 0.02635333687067032, 0.04801427572965622, 0.03677866607904434, -0.022834448143839836, 0.007946071214973927, -0.017073608934879303, -0.01170411892235279, -0.010125445201992989, 0.0087796775624156, -0.00792895071208477, 0.02727951854467392, 0.0014713803539052606, -0.020303204655647278, 0.004580077715218067, 0.010319231078028679, 0.005502042360603809, 0.028188670054078102, 0.04739943519234657, -0.04418913275003433, 0.06229843944311142, -0.0009879465214908123, 0.06411673128604889, -0.022021977230906487, 0.02538452297449112, -0.03990145027637482, -0.01071111485362053, -0.061957407742738724, 0.0735665038228035, 0.037100695073604584, 0.04420426860451698, 0.009627686813473701, 0.007320993114262819, 0.027934622019529343, 0.02401885762810707, -0.014354679733514786, 0.0827532708644867, -0.015003508888185024, 0.06873514503240585, 0.027637505903840065, -0.012368169613182545, 0.04447752237319946, 0.029790423810482025, 0.018242187798023224, -0.07250314205884933, 0.012930306605994701, -0.029133178293704987, -0.08458277583122253, -0.0006571653066202998, 0.028536392375826836, -0.0090536093339324, -0.019208062440156937, -0.011321015655994415, -0.07952308654785156, -0.04310934618115425, 0.039400238543748856, 0.04058793559670448, -0.034600310027599335, 0.012897630222141743, 0.03036394901573658, 0.025143392384052277, 0.045784734189510345, -0.036474522203207016, -0.017488697543740273, -0.04447144642472267, 0.01889076828956604, -0.012766493484377861, -0.02459062822163105, -0.07292862981557846, 0.031386446207761765, -0.08667933940887451, -0.07234321534633636, -0.011538861319422722, 0.019275806844234467, -0.044617123901844025, 0.00055832345969975, 0.0059451148845255375, 0.009239235892891884, 0.056760359555482864, -0.013492194935679436, 0.047845326364040375, 0.06042991951107979, -0.013291659764945507, 0.07355909049510956, -0.07027149200439453, 0.00121961603872478, 0.06907457113265991, 0.036333054304122925, 0.017314037308096886, 0.010345780290663242, 0.04309743270277977, -0.059970151633024216, 0.06446269154548645, -0.011073406785726547, 0.04725392535328865, 0.08154162019491196, 0.026597652584314346, 0.01394462026655674, -0.000017464919437770732, 0.07203332334756851, 0.036401569843292236, -0.056949738413095474, -0.04797593504190445, -0.03276422619819641, 0.0027974206022918224, 0.006313803605735302, -0.006479118950664997, 0.024967903271317482, -0.01474068034440279, 0.00847521424293518, 0.014638358727097511, 0.004449624568223953, -0.02371055819094181, 0.0211264006793499, -0.0015796617371961474, 0.0078038605861365795, 0.011904330924153328, 0.04049351438879967, 0.01270927581936121, 0.02293729968369007, -0.022243507206439972, -0.0015611315611749887, 0.03863714262843132, -0.018669506534934044, 0.028479618951678276, -0.04170069843530655, -0.00835278071463108, -0.024468332529067993, -0.04553794115781784, -0.05165787786245346, 0.027033252641558647, -0.022230833768844604, 0.007198426406830549, -0.020907942205667496, 0.04058007523417473, -0.004701744765043259, -0.004319534637033939, -0.014732071198523045, 0.008454153314232826, -0.031448643654584885, -0.06545403599739075, -0.012701760977506638, -0.017546752467751503, -0.03024987317621708, 0.045657042413949966, 0.04645811393857002, -0.03735379874706268, -0.009430843405425549, 0.008727780543267727, -0.04357961565256119, 0.06977774202823639, -0.019268712028861046, 0.019042637199163437, 0.01374088879674673, 0.033957161009311676, 0.015104754827916622, -0.02016078121960163, -0.03678984194993973, 0.029978059232234955, -0.02220107614994049, -0.03245082497596741, -0.02320040389895439, -0.06611376255750656, 0.06277211755514145, 0.0009741332032717764, -0.024626024067401886, 0.016962332651019096, 0.028484651818871498, 0.01201796904206276, 0.016931280493736267, -0.011429266072809696, 0.016541408374905586, 0.0004979476216249168, 0.022210247814655304, 0.03691580891609192, 0.005284787155687809, -0.002217541914433241, -0.06119527295231819, -0.020454997196793556, -0.03262864053249359, -0.02056460827589035, -0.06419287621974945, 0.08586151152849197, 0.02570711262524128, 0.03850974515080452, -0.017239784821867943, 0.010034484788775444, -0.05797146260738373, -0.07593846321105957, -0.0267760269343853, -0.04465381056070328, -0.0015151636907830834, 0.028290018439292908, 0.027629509568214417, -0.017129972577095032, -0.04085218161344528, -0.002348322421312332, -0.0027522423770278692, -0.004818375688046217, 0.0029024872928857803, -0.033559758216142654, -0.016464274376630783, -0.03313520550727844, -0.008055812679231167, 0.018754469230771065, -0.002324905712157488, -0.09053599089384079, -0.011173787526786327, -0.014879685826599598, -0.01956181973218918, 0.0282351803034544, -0.017784463241696358, -0.026318779215216637, -0.016410820186138153, -0.056313518434762955, -0.00020087073789909482, 0.024205952882766724, 0.009987941011786461, -0.0422038696706295, -0.01565096341073513, -0.03410215303301811, 0.0006903261528350413, -0.015835346654057503, -0.10376214236021042, 0.011065514758229256, 0.0004189276078250259, -0.020105592906475067, 0.005395594052970409, -0.061356592923402786, -0.010830085724592209, -0.03943559154868126, -0.011733923107385635, 0.026544321328401566, -0.07677601277828217, -0.02793988212943077, 0.032901592552661896, -0.03069649264216423, -0.039818789809942245, 0.0013206412550061941, 0.025943763554096222, 0.038023337721824646, -0.05458945408463478, -0.001054031541571021, -0.050929225981235504, -0.02826644666492939, 0.027939848601818085, -0.028810463845729828, 0.056007616221904755, -0.05621735006570816, -0.023600243031978607, 0.0035789075773209333, -0.0023260724265128374, -0.024977780878543854, 0.014085480011999607, 0.01647518388926983, -0.008423183113336563, -0.0011226886417716742, -0.06027631089091301, -0.014070482924580574, 0.07450641691684723, -0.02430593967437744, -0.04131452739238739, -0.04006250947713852, -0.07736051827669144, 0.044680848717689514, -0.05180056765675545, 0.012903270311653614, 0.020774876698851585, -0.004279647022485733, -0.0045127272605896, -0.01090177334845066, -0.03771171718835831, -0.049795981496572495, 0.02597220614552498, 0.005609751679003239, 0.061379335820674896, 0.01602175086736679, -0.035060033202171326, -0.08317805081605911, -0.02078772708773613, -0.025968264788389206, 0.0045063691213727, 0.031186189502477646, -0.029285259544849396, 0.024851784110069275, -0.007787184789776802, -0.008639965206384659, 0.0271905567497015, -0.027308428660035133, -0.002972939284518361, 0.06582058221101761, 0.03503669053316116, -0.02481437847018242, -0.015973608940839767, -0.07078798115253448, -0.027069512754678726, -0.01716487854719162, 0.026045799255371094, -0.036970146000385284, 0.0656609907746315, 0.0017027754802256823, 0.0035265330225229263, -0.01971660554409027, 0.01868804730474949, -0.017669791355729103, -0.00448879599571228, -0.002078537130728364, -0.004921928979456425, 0.03795884549617767, -0.00034011193201877177, -0.057029176503419876, 0.024691114202141762, -0.0047911107540130615, 0.03389387205243111, -0.04595835879445076, -0.03920277580618858, 0.01685442589223385, 0.043731689453125, 0.015309473499655724, 0.057985272258520126, 0.011848833411931992, -0.021308617666363716, -0.019231706857681274, -0.051439739763736725, 0.0064141214825212955, -0.011680500581860542, 0.013484954833984375, 0.0032865346875041723, -0.013864223845303059, -0.03344276174902916, 0.0014849872095510364, -0.027750441804528236, 0.038749244064092636, -0.007699005771428347, -0.02467433549463749, -0.011938843876123428, -0.00721483351662755, -0.02012922614812851, -0.02525177225470543, 0.008539941161870956, 0.012355746701359749, -0.035659901797771454, 0.02638215385377407, -0.03512796387076378, 0.04350908473134041, 0.07468049228191376, 0.04278821498155594, 0.06914521753787994, 0.04732237383723259, -0.047043342143297195, 0.03490106388926506, 0.0023779557086527348, -0.025736305862665176, -0.04793998599052429, 0.044396769255399704, -0.014661283232271671, -0.07017867267131805, 0.04569045081734657, 0.012328757904469967, -0.019333839416503906, 0.016916193068027496, 0.013473937287926674, -0.022385690361261368, 0.03175756335258484, -0.021863842383027077, 0.017434338107705116, -0.03373425453901291, -0.024103550240397453, 0.05514973774552345, -0.023407308384776115, 0.0013456238666549325, -0.03445469215512276, 0.07529997825622559, 0.024694669991731644, 0.005522354040294886, 0.028045842424035072, 0.002772659296169877, -0.08262467384338379, -0.021597983315587044, -0.04303198307752609, -0.03379451110959053, -0.03295420855283737, -0.04364682361483574, 0.008718079887330532, 0.031592074781656265, 0.043087948113679886, 0.06648454815149307, -0.05179564282298088, -0.020941421389579773, 0.053478386253118515, -0.06019476428627968, 0.03888367861509323, -0.017794128507375717, -0.015031903050839901, -0.06778404861688614, 0.03547394275665283, 0.04816151782870293, 0.041426993906497955, 0.0050353785045444965, 0.03600539639592171, -0.10733895003795624, -0.014853976666927338, -0.07559854537248611, 0.027564799413084984, 0.033766813576221466, 0.012683519162237644, -0.01933067850768566, 0.024271966889500618, -0.03112551011145115, 0.03339593857526779, 0.0038966864813119173, -0.016775844618678093, -0.06792869418859482, -0.0032720621675252914, -0.050098370760679245, 0.022913210093975067, -0.004615790210664272, -0.016661832109093666, -0.023794081062078476, 0.01382821798324585, 0.007607257459312677, 0.010667773894965649, -0.03418150916695595, -0.009361868724226952, -0.02025502175092697, -0.0014902881812304258, 0.014020196162164211, 0.0391726940870285, -0.028250161558389664, 0.08749869465827942 ]
<p>Which 2-tailed test is best to use to compare means/medians when one variable has a normal distribution and the other does not?</p>
g39451
[ 0.02843853272497654, -0.054225191473960876, 0.007680897135287523, -0.012770295143127441, -0.01497593056410551, -0.006656664423644543, -0.0074359457939863205, -0.04227004945278168, 0.02853916399180889, -0.05566730350255966, 0.04111472889780998, 0.05916520580649376, -0.002119504613801837, 0.002206594916060567, -0.043805886059999466, 0.0465652234852314, 0.0062004029750823975, -0.014789537526667118, 0.03484082594513893, 0.001344015239737928, -0.0842081755399704, 0.014757199212908745, 0.004125380422919989, 0.04268530756235123, 0.0032588602043688297, -0.040135715156793594, -0.13615895807743073, 0.077354796230793, -0.03385515883564949, -0.0005828800494782627, -0.001934806234203279, -0.0014154352247714996, 0.047651439905166626, -0.039281561970710754, -0.021923422813415527, 0.033929187804460526, 0.06126408278942108, 0.030740533024072647, -0.06949780881404877, -0.026417326182127, -0.04088469594717026, 0.04861966893076897, 0.0032599379774183035, -0.058668214827775955, -0.024018755182623863, -0.06919514387845993, -0.003142913104966283, 0.04313981160521507, 0.03501073271036148, -0.026706041768193245, 0.00025133247254416347, 0.023484468460083008, 0.07862444967031479, -0.014377361163496971, 0.01589067466557026, -0.0367429293692112, 0.031749553978443146, 0.07369209080934525, -0.041755691170692444, 0.01026110164821148, 0.05579329654574394, 0.02422546036541462, -0.05802145600318909, -0.010445079766213894, -0.051883403211832047, 0.0034828309435397387, -0.007294963579624891, -0.004593579564243555, 0.014025837182998657, 0.008097454905509949, -0.028180988505482674, -0.04473590478301048, 0.04904599487781525, 0.00970564316958189, -0.09868329763412476, -0.08309652656316757, 0.0042443354614079, -0.012261335738003254, -0.022785698994994164, 0.040763359516859055, -0.024588342756032944, 0.022836824879050255, 0.03706374764442444, 0.020634057000279427, 0.011390182189643383, 0.0069467355497181416, -0.008845306001603603, -0.00038558762753382325, 0.05584033206105232, 0.06246861442923546, -0.011125477962195873, -0.004091599490493536, 0.015273128636181355, 0.05010693147778511, -0.052260622382164, 0.004996542818844318, -0.01047045923769474, 0.024075131863355637, -0.0016510245623067021, 0.034605398774147034, 0.006211031693965197, 0.002952695358544588, -0.04558476060628891, 0.02919735573232174, -0.015725059434771538, -0.021087249740958214, 0.033475447446107864, -0.024969015270471573, -0.06437094509601593, -0.0067384676076471806, -0.04064280539751053, -0.003316278802230954, -0.034634340554475784, 0.025232551619410515, -0.006544401869177818, 0.018087629228830338, 0.03671914339065552, -0.04647664725780487, 0.026491697877645493, -0.014700978063046932, 0.027126502245664597, 0.07115274667739868, -0.012917494401335716, 0.020418420433998108, -0.01367406826466322, 0.0060673425905406475, -0.030603135004639626, 0.055814627557992935, -0.023106902837753296, 0.001106477458961308, -0.005884491838514805, -0.020136984065175056, 0.023943081498146057, 0.01356372982263565, 0.007356018293648958, 0.08159918338060379, 0.013066199608147144, 0.016054943203926086, -0.05041512846946716, 0.0010381805477663875, -0.040706783533096313, -0.024567581713199615, 0.0019388674991205335, 0.0035265081096440554, -0.004161660559475422, 0.021195782348513603, 0.01625746116042137, -0.0034468010999262333, -0.04189072921872139, -0.005901568569242954, 0.055481042712926865, -0.01936950720846653, 0.05842345952987671, -0.0017061365069821477, -0.051356296986341476, 0.0332782156765461, 0.07516705989837646, 0.01794983632862568, 0.038422033190727234, -0.005268783308565617, -0.06841862201690674, -0.04063645377755165, -0.028984371572732925, -0.014447796158492565, 0.03761276975274086, -0.028280530124902725, 0.005139168817549944, 0.011652291752398014, 0.035299353301525116, 0.018772291019558907, 0.00828886404633522, -0.012572193518280983, 0.00246377638541162, 0.00931052677333355, 0.01685776561498642, 0.04746494069695473, -0.014593152329325676, -0.009017962031066418, 0.011588391847908497, 0.018767384812235832, 0.01628958247601986, 0.050386931747198105, -0.048033591359853745, -0.040871068835258484, 0.004182708449661732, -0.03540394455194473, 0.014530026353895664, -0.021032661199569702, -0.04479832947254181, 0.00883499439805746, 0.017557885497808456, -0.046775177121162415, -0.03082074038684368, 0.03816442936658859, -0.08280317485332489, -0.04409099370241165, 0.020987501367926598, 0.005910308100283146, 0.03329101949930191, 0.004736409988254309, 0.04492505267262459, 0.004775392357259989, 0.0010130847804248333, -0.010435030795633793, -0.0759057104587555, -0.021633801981806755, 0.038254592567682266, -0.021659759804606438, 0.03620223328471184, -0.052335627377033234, -0.008406504057347775, -0.014771482907235622, 0.0057146609760820866, -0.020792193710803986, 0.02339695207774639, 0.0012931544333696365, -0.038823068141937256, 0.056122321635484695, -0.03417521342635155, -0.03896349295973778, -0.030420074239373207, -0.01845497637987137, 0.06325287371873856, -0.07417876273393631, 0.04186149314045906, 0.053740859031677246, 0.014667393639683723, 0.009569504298269749, 0.0008299945038743317, 0.03185437619686127, -0.00378401973284781, -0.06589354574680328, 0.06366395950317383, -0.008186210878193378, -0.0036097229458391666, 0.02190324291586876, 0.020386597141623497, 0.029463909566402435, 0.03783561661839485, 0.011799356900155544, -0.0014319553738459945, 0.014186829328536987, 0.012086520902812481, 0.06797895580530167, 0.008943763561546803, 0.03509984165430069, -0.0007949834689497948, 0.003000671975314617, 0.06441434472799301, 0.04378515109419823, -0.03865044191479683, 0.0898280218243599, 0.015995342284440994, -0.02209840714931488, 0.023666365072131157, -0.04689453914761543, 0.04699934273958206, -0.0461275614798069, -0.008151890709996223, -0.01316380687057972, -0.023489823564887047, 0.028820199891924858, 0.011439705267548561, -0.03909717872738838, 0.022387545555830002, -0.025366462767124176, 0.001476312754675746, -0.00858105905354023, 0.009097211994230747, -0.029273200780153275, 0.025892049074172974, -0.018061110749840736, -0.04221508651971817, 0.02967490814626217, 0.08579716831445694, 0.05620182678103447, 0.00145312852691859, -0.048127755522727966, -0.012470528483390808, -0.019557103514671326, 0.06058075278997421, -0.013688912615180016, 0.06561523675918579, 0.02477322146296501, 0.0679020807147026, 0.01495665218681097, 0.0018977208528667688, -0.01054893434047699, -0.002705494174733758, 0.018015870824456215, -0.03174692764878273, 0.05910171568393707, 0.007334062363952398, -0.0365239754319191, 0.0023049807641655207, -0.01868596114218235, 0.05354970693588257, -0.032383885234594345, 0.04733922332525253, -0.04594464972615242, -0.00511679332703352, -0.0014873292529955506, -0.016826162114739418, 0.0034759589470922947, 0.07894695550203323, -0.0343177430331707, -0.011254786513745785, 0.033883173018693924, 0.033246442675590515, 0.022619053721427917, -0.061673376709222794, 0.006664646323770285, 0.024794213473796844, -0.01947515830397606, 0.009435225278139114, -0.0032141334377229214, 0.007310825865715742, 0.023745404556393623, 0.010309280827641487, 0.038965992629528046, 0.005148333963006735, 0.02150767110288143, 0.03601544722914696, 0.021868877112865448, -0.05624252185225487, -0.0033511093351989985, -0.016010986641049385, 0.04175213351845741, -0.0907963216304779, -0.00945681519806385, 0.022332359105348587, 0.0423470064997673, -0.01875694841146469, -0.0020590475760400295, 0.05983482301235199, -0.020512575283646584, 0.050546687096357346, 0.01881006360054016, -0.026585690677165985, 0.0553630068898201, -0.00941786915063858, -0.020284956321120262, -0.05745438113808632, -0.014253269881010056, -0.0182106364518404, -0.05944870784878731, 0.03885532543063164, 0.052991073578596115, 0.02283381298184395, -0.003734386758878827, -0.006225009448826313, 0.0019468441605567932, 0.0523647777736187, 0.0007044545491226017, 0.03449981287121773, -0.018200533464550972, 0.026346081867814064, -0.017446836456656456, 0.02496282383799553, -0.027164440602064133, 0.0532870888710022, -0.0005964901647530496, -0.0032558816019445658, 0.03087945096194744, 0.010958736762404442, -0.027292203158140182, 0.02193993702530861, -0.0001684699091129005, -0.014260928146541119, -0.022640831768512726, -0.03189476951956749, 0.06141740828752518, 0.0464894138276577, -0.016120681539177895, 0.055307529866695404, 0.02783920243382454, 0.030222153291106224, 0.0419878289103508, -0.012578860856592655, 0.012739826925098896, 0.06724788248538971, 0.013595636002719402, -0.03526804968714714, -0.005901035852730274, -0.03344423696398735, -0.08976802974939346, -0.008999182842671871, 0.016205886378884315, 0.01678396761417389, 0.01991560123860836, 0.00760180177167058, -0.03208548575639725, -0.07025269418954849, -0.002858501160517335, 0.019691219553351402, -0.049952469766139984, 0.017263127490878105, 0.02029264345765114, 0.001702775596641004, 0.023419586941599846, -0.028222497552633286, 0.0318378321826458, -0.031310684978961945, -0.033781178295612335, -0.05458187311887741, -0.006149328779429197, -0.007897160947322845, -0.02298828959465027, -0.026296425610780716, -0.015617785975337029, 0.00034479674650356174, 0.0027042836882174015, 0.026643626391887665, 0.014189700596034527, 0.014763988554477692, -0.04600385203957558, -0.014555050060153008, -0.010455932468175888, -0.014458450488746166, 0.034373100847005844, -0.0018518739379942417, 0.0004790745151694864, 0.007968434132635593, -0.06340081989765167, -0.0048537952825427055, -0.03296864777803421, -0.009745101444423199, 0.052069276571273804, 0.0015212914440780878, -0.018429063260555267, -0.020123012363910675, -0.0006703830440528691, -0.034313324838876724, 0.019899582490324974, 0.03556801751255989, 0.022458724677562714, -0.013154208660125732, 0.0024828752502799034, -0.03170729801058769, -0.09219955652952194, 0.00748016033321619, -0.007448636461049318, -0.0758364349603653, 0.03943472355604172, -0.02707221917808056, 0.049227453768253326, 0.0048828027211129665, -0.013465660624206066, -0.01772325299680233, -0.04830177500844002, -0.032211627811193466, 0.0296309944242239, 0.010423542000353336, -0.07432257384061813, -0.03812837600708008, -0.03829098865389824, 0.054290033876895905, -0.021842539310455322, 0.02127324976027012, -0.015575453639030457, -0.03514598309993744, -0.017194712534546852, 0.01827920414507389, -0.050398148596286774, 0.04699273407459259, 0.007873271591961384, -0.08124777674674988, -0.01243948470801115, 0.008686327375471592, -0.0415523424744606, -0.01665314845740795, -0.05957479774951935, 0.06000291556119919, -0.013136420398950577, 0.013524506241083145, 0.06339529156684875, 0.02929706498980522, -0.0088689299300313, 0.0076880245469510555, -0.01953197456896305, -0.007000538520514965, -0.04738345369696617, -0.021627459675073624, 0.00898813921958208, 0.0379103384912014, -0.014095922000706196, 0.011561401188373566, -0.057669758796691895, 0.09996944665908813, 0.002261312212795019, 0.016006657853722572, -0.039240941405296326, 0.04513339698314667, -0.054334405809640884, 0.012832166627049446, -0.05837725102901459, 0.006576183717697859, -0.01985427364706993, -0.011050435714423656, -0.01735270582139492, -0.06174323335289955, 0.032434891909360886, -0.01685994304716587, 0.043214667588472366, 0.01863093674182892, -0.02923295460641384, 0.03787153586745262, 0.01809420809149742, 0.0012206260580569506, 0.09074969589710236, -0.04389451444149017, -0.07941842824220657, 0.030913665890693665, -0.029017014428973198, -0.015617371536791325, 0.02556123211979866, 0.08221544325351715, -0.04242456331849098, 0.001808146946132183, -0.04720432311296463, 0.0689554437994957, -0.022743914276361465, 0.05117931216955185, 0.0007651487248949707, 0.020336177200078964, -0.05346296355128288, -0.03668951615691185, -0.04047831892967224, -0.037005793303251266, -0.04204760491847992, -0.009652760811150074, -0.0032265305053442717, 0.022851964458823204, 0.006446921732276678, -0.020612452179193497, -0.05394935980439186, 0.010541079565882683, 0.054396409541368484, -0.03967931121587753, 0.0014751149574294686, -0.00960351713001728, -0.01696315035223961, 0.006162605714052916, 0.011394129134714603, -0.01562555879354477, -0.024124005809426308, -0.02264336310327053, -0.05452714487910271, 0.009828214533627033, -0.01175275444984436, -0.006692933384329081, 0.005196579732000828, -0.0776677057147026, 0.026953278109431267, -0.019866103306412697, 0.03674563020467758, 0.054757218807935715, 0.030810900032520294, 0.030780212953686714, 0.005493296310305595, -0.04647205024957657, -0.038922492414712906, 0.04762222617864609, 0.030997484922409058, -0.015111791901290417, -0.03493718430399895, -0.06464042514562607, 0.026442714035511017, 0.008888891898095608, -0.0397757962346077, -0.015492626465857029, 0.0207356009632349, 0.016334090381860733, 0.0042939200066030025, 0.069960817694664, -0.013011938892304897, -0.014182290062308311, 0.023646194487810135, 0.07758117467164993, -0.052098553627729416, -0.014571753330528736, -0.030078427866101265, -0.041438426822423935, 0.05197795107960701, -0.019808663055300713, 0.027456024661660194, 0.017859715968370438, -0.0022279080003499985, 0.006279090419411659, -0.007677377667278051, 0.004915331955999136, -0.005846902262419462, 0.012980121187865734, -0.014802062883973122, 0.014523165300488472, -0.04638487473130226, -0.03197710961103439, -0.007835033349692822, -0.026175683364272118, 0.009814197197556496, 0.010508988052606583, -0.05882074683904648, 0.04705813527107239, 0.0022803430911153555, 0.015275698155164719, 0.05033055692911148, 0.044074635952711105, 0.025581706315279007, -0.002249334705993533, 0.013817647472023964, -0.04983906447887421, 0.023685844615101814, 0.03436664864420891, 0.030238820239901543, -0.006114454008638859, 0.025180790573358536, -0.11879459023475647, -0.030604515224695206, 0.0026667665224522352, 0.03497648611664772, 0.0286551546305418, -0.04905105009675026, -0.0003844246384687722, 0.008280365727841854, 0.0756123960018158, 0.0612560398876667, -0.013320229016244411, -0.047491654753685, 0.038359954953193665, -0.014522283338010311, 0.0015388278989121318, 0.0016200868412852287, -0.038440585136413574, 0.00773368775844574, -0.01865764893591404, -0.04985524341464043, -0.03687099739909172, 0.04056484252214432, 0.02116507478058338, 0.030102206394076347, 0.01255397405475378, 0.0840390995144844, 0.010961187072098255, -0.009368226863443851, 0.044662974774837494, -0.0007588733569718897, 0.05137854814529419, 0.0157744400203228, -0.01740393415093422, -0.03929002955555916, -0.015752943232655525, 0.053713977336883545, 0.039044175297021866, -0.03835589066147804, 0.01940440945327282, 0.018951477482914925, 0.06877367943525314, 0.041391827166080475, 0.02213471755385399, -0.04723053053021431, 0.03068963810801506, 0.0024615724105387926, -0.03947339206933975, 0.0019855815917253494, -0.042288266122341156, 0.0346493273973465, -0.01985165849328041, 0.011279497295618057, -0.012925482355058193, 0.0009124493808485568, 0.02689359523355961, -0.02182880789041519, -0.032613739371299744, 0.011118941009044647, 0.06976743042469025, -0.04470502957701683, -0.05371253937482834, -0.015142840333282948, -0.014288202859461308, -0.05156056955456734, 0.02718082070350647, -0.05636873096227646, -0.01903972402215004, -0.0472705140709877, -0.020658191293478012, 0.01252060104161501, -0.006468892563134432, -0.012572718784213066, 0.07607787847518921, -0.005281087011098862, -0.03675304725766182, -0.033525820821523666, 0.022272974252700806, 0.0025387415662407875, -0.015016721561551094, 0.010430947877466679, -0.012224660255014896, 0.024310091510415077, 0.023387469351291656, 0.0260924082249403, -0.052840281277894974, 0.020080987364053726, -0.04471433907747269, 0.0780736580491066, 0.008131586015224457, -0.02262823097407818, 0.09506642818450928, -0.0008976245881058276, -0.04467998445034027, -0.10401342809200287, 0.050506360828876495, 0.045846935361623764, 0.037576135247945786, 0.06203814968466759, -0.010720943100750446, -0.03658410534262657, 0.004861188121140003, -0.042833130806684494, 0.02918819524347782, 0.0047414968721568584, -0.037511084228754044, -0.010285576805472374, 0.03632581979036331, -0.0035572657361626625, -0.0330716148018837, -0.05114627629518509, -0.01560347992926836, 0.03789449855685234, -0.021342195570468903, -0.01734873652458191, -0.024051595479249954, 0.009302176535129547, -0.030558595433831215, -0.02845161408185959, -0.04346450790762901, -0.023451626300811768, -0.005727245006710291, 0.09700513631105423, 0.013616228476166725, -0.0052101402543485165, -0.08305534720420837, 0.05261984467506409, 0.04787473753094673, -0.011497574858367443, -0.02273927815258503, 0.043162498623132706, 0.053967345505952835, 0.021547123789787292, -0.009016446769237518, -0.07674381881952286, -0.030767204239964485, -0.02190813422203064, -0.031347066164016724, 0.09266440570354462, 0.030702074989676476, -0.0367700457572937, 0.03181402012705803, -0.021996598690748215, 0.009103585965931416, -0.0005486333393491805, -0.030772870406508446, -0.026541693136096, -0.056988928467035294, -0.016937553882598877, -0.002734412206336856, -0.02337898686528206, 0.007413230836391449, 0.013841367326676846 ]
<p>Is there a difference between ANCOVA (as performed under the 'General Linear Model (GLM)') and Hierarchical Regression (as performed under 'Regression') in SPSS?</p> <p>I am testing the main effects and interaction of X1 (continuous) and X2 (categorical) on Y (continuous).</p> <p>I understand GLM incorporates regression and one of the main advantages of using GLM over the regression function is that GLM (factor) creates dummy coding. In regression, this must be done prior to inputting the categorical factor in the analysis box. The same also applies to the interaction product.</p> <p>I personally find GLM (ANCOVA) output easier to understand.</p>
g74017
[ 0.05268927663564682, -0.015657827258110046, -0.020462948828935623, 0.00435293884947896, -0.009341282770037651, -0.00717679038643837, 0.064568892121315, 0.007313590031117201, -0.05581163987517357, -0.0208157729357481, -0.029085766524076462, 0.04248467832803726, 0.03163978084921837, -0.011611427180469036, 0.0029529640451073647, 0.02575080469250679, 0.04623139277100563, 0.02354659140110016, -0.01939166709780693, -0.004079990554600954, -0.020299142226576805, -0.016467154026031494, 0.03073098510503769, -0.0371001772582531, 0.016666559502482414, -0.04204506427049637, -0.03654227778315544, 0.0429900698363781, -0.041313279420137405, 0.05362201854586601, -0.025667229667305946, 0.020756050944328308, 0.042386848479509354, -0.022084223106503487, -0.044271886348724365, -0.03195177763700485, 0.048935580998659134, 0.02722814492881298, 0.0025281019043177366, -0.030117077752947807, 0.015012863092124462, 0.03408725559711456, 0.04488944262266159, 0.02071547694504261, -0.055840957909822464, -0.016176072880625725, -0.037493571639060974, -0.03348264470696449, -0.00851031206548214, 0.019488193094730377, 0.011725888587534428, 0.02336205169558525, -0.03527398034930229, 0.05274970084428787, 0.031079048290848732, -0.004211429040879011, -0.0031608054414391518, 0.013665861450135708, -0.018450746312737465, -0.03354441747069359, 0.012787078507244587, 0.00676367525011301, -0.021857384592294693, -0.0038255415856838226, -0.03843666613101959, -0.005979051347821951, -0.03567225858569145, -0.048219334334135056, -0.05679907649755478, -0.024285996332764626, 0.038012247532606125, -0.042631980031728745, 0.05411176383495331, -0.023332051932811737, -0.03149450942873955, -0.017271745949983597, 0.025521786883473396, -0.02858605422079563, -0.007826907560229301, 0.06643261760473251, -0.01402774266898632, -0.014474273659288883, 0.07410845160484314, 0.008555636741220951, 0.0431416817009449, -0.019596120342612267, -0.02758021466434002, 0.015900274738669395, 0.028730297461152077, -0.0032125136349350214, -0.004517682828009129, 0.03467591106891632, -0.010859997943043709, 0.05863494798541069, -0.07408201694488525, -0.01719885878264904, -0.06583352386951447, 0.005472187884151936, 0.041125502437353134, 0.01641065813601017, -0.01812330260872841, 0.02288723737001419, -0.031155871227383614, 0.013230008073151112, -0.024479759857058525, -0.04605996608734131, 0.028058813884854317, 0.018298642709851265, -0.06319873034954071, -0.07305637747049332, -0.021576667204499245, 0.036640480160713196, -0.07354451715946198, 0.023718345910310745, 0.0045636603608727455, -0.10595405846834183, 0.07355878502130508, -0.01645401492714882, 0.010754131712019444, -0.060333382338285446, -0.011889404617249966, 0.0032133744098246098, 0.04526615887880325, 0.028023023158311844, -0.03350790962576866, 0.004481850657612085, -0.017819810658693314, 0.09008682519197464, 0.04880942031741142, -0.02544514089822769, 0.043636057525873184, 0.03873994201421738, -0.06085433438420296, 0.030583424493670464, 0.07331817597150803, 0.012130656279623508, -0.014564751647412777, 0.03948994725942612, 0.001988265896216035, -0.03790619969367981, -0.028303666040301323, -0.009727392345666885, 0.0004697663534898311, 0.0007952438900247216, 0.04780108854174614, 0.010900989174842834, 0.02728576399385929, 0.015231836587190628, -0.035558898001909256, -0.003958261571824551, 0.004873126745223999, 0.030538566410541534, 0.03748670592904091, 0.017792759463191032, -0.07584953308105469, 0.018566392362117767, -0.03761553019285202, -0.04033274948596954, 0.057434383779764175, 0.028391286730766296, -0.004734497983008623, -0.00768786296248436, -0.012409134767949581, 0.03654205799102783, -0.03627585992217064, -0.06500068306922913, 0.0042919074185192585, -0.03202950209379196, -0.036296673119068146, 0.013192466460168362, 0.039520762860774994, 0.02053004875779152, 0.0006917902501299977, 0.02880140207707882, 0.05184776708483696, 0.046421825885772705, 0.023584242910146713, -0.03065931424498558, 0.050438184291124344, -0.0585092157125473, 0.025187240913510323, 0.024757862091064453, -0.006775232497602701, -0.02085946872830391, 0.03712036833167076, 0.034108079969882965, -0.04801959916949272, 0.070623978972435, -0.0933968797326088, 0.015381203033030033, -0.056953128427267075, -0.019624007865786552, -0.048238590359687805, -0.01595185324549675, -0.015429662540555, -0.06951240450143814, 0.06290686130523682, 0.004136438015848398, -0.04770195111632347, -0.010550172068178654, 0.006005863193422556, -0.002808919409289956, 0.022001324221491814, -0.02147664502263069, -0.032803986221551895, 0.017069822177290916, -0.024654807522892952, -0.005295413080602884, -0.05464624986052513, -0.016548946499824524, -0.006716903764754534, -0.013844669796526432, 0.02094518207013607, 0.01890893653035164, 0.03569954261183739, -0.08589979261159897, -0.03710576891899109, 0.018644116818904877, -0.02489517070353031, 0.00818992592394352, -0.0204705111682415, -0.017973825335502625, 0.019597221165895462, 0.00719280494377017, -0.012950963340699673, 0.002718675183132291, 0.00476451450958848, 0.06554447114467621, 0.009283015504479408, 0.0063728769309818745, -0.04478750005364418, -0.038014497607946396, -0.035069141536951065, -0.06746892631053925, -0.02503768913447857, -0.018873637542128563, 0.010354733094573021, -0.020053856074810028, 0.0017947423039004207, 0.07505005598068237, 0.012272895313799381, 0.03880460187792778, 0.009177696891129017, -0.00927744247019291, 0.043580785393714905, -0.035545844584703445, 0.02385684847831726, -0.0021650863345712423, 0.02410558983683586, 0.0057471757754683495, -0.09691131860017776, 0.09555847942829132, 0.0037632733583450317, -0.07724568992853165, 0.04217853769659996, -0.0195943433791399, -0.03709189221262932, 0.011396722868084908, -0.023005925118923187, -0.010930410586297512, 0.015743102878332138, 0.019256576895713806, 0.029567405581474304, 0.01200601551681757, -0.026775585487484932, -0.07552611082792282, -0.03130350634455681, -0.005752115044742823, 0.001294387737289071, -0.0232046227902174, -0.04018744081258774, 0.01740768924355507, 0.028369002044200897, -0.03450047969818115, -0.008224996738135815, 0.02969084121286869, -0.028010595589876175, -0.015430344268679619, 0.004673821851611137, -0.08697324991226196, 0.014979318715631962, -0.04108940064907074, -0.004225020296871662, -0.057750847190618515, 0.06326880306005478, -0.019240429624915123, 0.05314323678612709, -0.022902298718690872, -0.029281139373779297, -0.013139278627932072, 0.008024182170629501, 0.046136077493429184, -0.017113611102104187, 0.016398398205637932, 0.0025098638143390417, -0.037053853273391724, 0.02533833496272564, -0.05716338008642197, -0.02224673330783844, 0.06910190731287003, 0.006020302418619394, -0.06834685802459717, -0.01554710604250431, 0.025191346183419228, 0.013686110265552998, -0.0795515924692154, -0.0004651116905733943, -0.024834219366312027, -0.0033108796924352646, -0.027485616505146027, -0.008959642611443996, 0.0153854014351964, -0.002267996082082391, -0.02325829118490219, 0.025213561952114105, -0.07879675179719925, 0.027632758021354675, 0.041581619530916214, -0.043586160987615585, 0.048426467925310135, 0.05608583614230156, -0.0579448863863945, -0.03540873900055885, 0.013725310564041138, -0.023908384144306183, 0.0342533215880394, -0.010157306678593159, 0.023430192843079567, -0.012233029119670391, -0.033375270664691925, 0.01574133150279522, 0.028807809576392174, 0.0716499462723732, 0.016951909288764, 0.07349954545497894, -0.031834591180086136, -0.046008650213479996, -0.0573689304292202, -0.04984205588698387, 0.02627239190042019, 0.026054617017507553, -0.021524198353290558, 0.03729651868343353, 0.020555419847369194, 0.019317762926220894, -0.029274333268404007, 0.0034174839965999126, 0.037609051913022995, -0.028624922037124634, 0.021763663738965988, -0.05548664182424545, -0.02049059048295021, 0.02144133672118187, 0.0048197065480053425, 0.006163982208818197, -0.027979493141174316, 0.05417138710618019, 0.017557356506586075, -0.035561803728342056, 0.00840415246784687, 0.045790139585733414, -0.017626391723752022, -0.014379963278770447, 0.03843202441930771, 0.04089993238449097, 0.02799728326499462, 0.07394493371248245, 0.04614870250225067, -0.019848646596074104, 0.015254813246428967, 0.0496995784342289, 0.0512959323823452, 0.026515863835811615, -0.0488724485039711, 0.02928546816110611, 0.002971937647089362, 0.09254591912031174, 0.029522651806473732, 0.005894041154533625, 0.0072441985830664635, 0.06397397071123123, 0.01136496476829052, 0.022775772958993912, -0.010160242207348347, 0.022265389561653137, -0.12280476093292236, 0.0005365124670788646, 0.04077354446053505, 0.04128359258174896, -0.0037712841294705868, -0.00025221810210496187, 0.047298360615968704, -0.011631709523499012, 0.061947669833898544, 0.031201526522636414, 0.03607325628399849, -0.023314889520406723, 0.029031813144683838, 0.018057145178318024, -0.003975465428084135, -0.019185811281204224, -0.007962403818964958, 0.04090719297528267, 0.010678802616894245, 0.02602427825331688, -0.044644441455602646, 0.01522047445178032, -0.029958834871649742, -0.10508706420660019, -0.04292355105280876, -0.02611437253654003, 0.00575946643948555, -0.03605060651898384, -0.009221704676747322, 0.05334504693746567, -0.011742201633751392, -0.0010187195148319006, -0.011683104559779167, -0.001188482390716672, -0.04436449334025383, 0.026047632098197937, -0.003337073838338256, -0.055586569011211395, -0.013591974973678589, 0.029060399159789085, 0.036016471683979034, -0.010183227248489857, 0.01857132837176323, 0.004338611848652363, -0.0173505749553442, 0.05086544528603554, 0.06701118499040604, -0.01008068397641182, 0.013674437068402767, 0.011040426790714264, 0.03860774636268616, -0.030330119654536247, -0.006742774974554777, 0.0004497940535657108, -0.04580805078148842, 0.021661577746272087, 0.008178752847015858, -0.04135029762983322, 0.018814409151673317, 0.018093282356858253, 0.011700085364282131, 0.006269653793424368, -0.006880788132548332, -0.06524857133626938, -0.01721365936100483, -0.02804734744131565, 0.019586578011512756, -0.02533336542546749, 0.006670644506812096, -0.005575753282755613, -0.008992982096970081, 0.028369998559355736, 0.004786409437656403, -0.001103063696064055, -0.007013995666056871, 0.012960506603121758, -0.04114871099591255, -0.07238289713859558, -0.0408695824444294, 0.021062519401311874, -0.06483624875545502, -0.06680431216955185, -0.03283851593732834, 0.0075856526382267475, 0.05813353508710861, 0.024428144097328186, -0.05366676673293114, 0.019536161795258522, 0.013110402040183544, 0.006767850369215012, 0.014874996617436409, 0.02218731865286827, 0.01668880321085453, 0.0083316033706069, 0.012868626043200493, -0.02084134705364704, -0.05442250892519951, 0.03480600565671921, -0.017767032608389854, -0.009555869735777378, -0.008181409910321236, -0.02219986915588379, -0.03990136459469795, 0.03948276862502098, 0.01644045300781727, -0.0036710649728775024, 0.019784405827522278, 0.008969930931925774, -0.016063768416643143, 0.005795822013169527, 0.03669535741209984, 0.0030795822385698557, -0.037115342915058136, -0.0412943959236145, 0.007943296805024147, -0.004536486230790615, -0.031828079372644424, 0.06918270885944366, 0.018675560131669044, -0.039659757167100906, 0.019387660548090935, 0.06476443260908127, -0.02157140150666237, 0.01759098842740059, 0.05572394281625748, -0.018285000696778297, -0.013570125214755535, 0.010395588353276253, 0.055945683270692825, -0.035904183983802795, 0.011453819461166859, 0.03405122458934784, 0.06196191534399986, 0.010442891158163548, -0.013250403106212616, 0.0538933165371418, 0.03852807730436325, -0.015420692972838879, 0.010745363309979439, 0.0306098572909832, -0.013638490810990334, 0.00510631175711751, -0.06391195952892303, 0.07979818433523178, 0.01984521374106407, 0.02643473446369171, 0.009344215504825115, -0.021718807518482208, 0.01805690862238407, 0.038419220596551895, -0.052980102598667145, -0.04946748912334442, 0.07992594689130783, -0.02731146477162838, -0.01685643382370472, -0.046181198209524155, 0.034730833023786545, -0.0008569055353291333, 0.013752295635640621, 0.006129908375442028, -0.0014254775596782565, 0.08527666330337524, -0.003934912849217653, 0.004045608453452587, -0.0820971131324768, -0.024782223626971245, -0.02887801267206669, 0.0012439657002687454, 0.0732455626130104, -0.008945046924054623, 0.007553030736744404, -0.014118204824626446, 0.038740456104278564, 0.016353664919734, -0.0003033891844097525, -0.06444371491670609, -0.020439492538571358, 0.02855679951608181, -0.0706673264503479, 0.019574463367462158, -0.05069027841091156, -0.025924446061253548, -0.014426128007471561, 0.002075085649266839, 0.03580110892653465, 0.04222891479730606, -0.035697273910045624, 0.007288872729986906, 0.06739109754562378, -0.07698128372430801, 0.0019239545799791813, -0.014840919524431229, 0.05668260157108307, 0.02365667186677456, 0.06154150515794754, 0.0385705791413784, -0.050164684653282166, 0.022187557071447372, 0.009055456146597862, -0.025645142421126366, 0.006881156470626593, -0.04027291387319565, -0.004738542251288891, 0.008232622407376766, 0.08525704592466354, -0.02571815997362137, -0.0068142046220600605, 0.04590433090925217, 0.04429423063993454, 0.011756633408367634, -0.02597278542816639, -0.028278889134526253, 0.06791437417268753, 0.011377108283340931, -0.011574799194931984, 0.026318857446312904, -0.005836275406181812, 0.04615453630685806, 0.004392452538013458, 0.08652810752391815, 0.052572205662727356, -0.027640998363494873, 0.010520543903112411, -0.015684377402067184, 0.0549304224550724, -0.06946320086717606, 0.024739840999245644, 0.013090162537992, 0.030451273545622826, 0.08261802792549133, 0.007325603626668453, -0.07013336569070816, -0.016866620630025864, -0.006564011797308922, 0.03117460384964943, -0.026122672483325005, -0.033530864864587784, -0.04231935366988182, -0.03211827203631401, 0.020495504140853882, 0.05053817853331566, -0.022189317271113396, -0.0007604749407619238, 0.013755773194134235, 0.012048500590026379, -0.07723646610975266, -0.01625058986246586, -0.04533667117357254, -0.01609192229807377, -0.03634412959218025, 0.013972211629152298, -0.041341956704854965, 0.039747826755046844, -0.0052656568586826324, 0.03340869024395943, 0.026852227747440338, 0.02598651498556137, -0.02313135378062725, 0.006342822220176458, 0.01634315773844719, 0.00350003014318645, 0.00976529996842146, 0.025707293301820755, -0.03705628961324692, 0.05918991565704346, 0.02490224689245224, 0.03796558827161789, 0.05333837866783142, -0.11227188259363174, 0.023217594251036644, 0.004563342779874802, 0.038279421627521515, 0.027206411585211754, -0.015408913604915142, 0.06464523077011108, -0.03887094929814339, 0.018225127831101418, -0.050824880599975586, 0.03925657644867897, -0.03244893625378609, 0.016113268211483955, -0.010611124336719513, 0.0025972763542085886, 0.04090460389852524, -0.04071694239974022, -0.044640008360147476, -0.02059839852154255, 0.024035895243287086, 0.022012703120708466, 0.030409613624215126, 0.02685961313545704, -0.017483409494161606, -0.04530163109302521, -0.0513785146176815, -0.018003910779953003, 0.014604444615542889, -0.00795687548816204, 0.07524046301841736, 0.03267047554254532, -0.033851686865091324, 0.01931900531053543, -0.024504516273736954, 0.026987044140696526, 0.02894681692123413, -0.04377878084778786, -0.041436031460762024, -0.028944257646799088, 0.013516800478100777, 0.015593011863529682, -0.008570598438382149, 0.01623096875846386, -0.0351640060544014, 0.09292641282081604, -0.04387228563427925, 0.04955132305622101, 0.01754418946802616, 0.0862841084599495, -0.048863865435123444, -0.04704277962446213, 0.03595428541302681, -0.030148398131132126, 0.0035918394569307566, -0.019527481868863106, -0.012325464747846127, -0.017651109024882317, -0.10620199888944626, 0.022317957133054733, -0.009008514694869518, 0.0797017365694046, -0.02201974391937256, -0.0013971860753372312, 0.04012889415025711, -0.04964633658528328, -0.0477917417883873, 0.02572268806397915, -0.025358647108078003, -0.03096170350909233, 0.02034635841846466, 0.03877338394522667, -0.027137814089655876, -0.0037762403953820467, 0.006475463509559631, -0.010539722628891468, 0.0036698547191917896, 0.027192285284399986, -0.01624586433172226, -0.0607638955116272, -0.03932539001107216, -0.0027530030347406864, 0.03514685481786728, 0.0017586944159120321, 0.03047170490026474, -0.024483872577548027, -0.041371140629053116, -0.03717340528964996, -0.006114596035331488, -0.03282306343317032, 0.016846468672156334, -0.0007803693297319114, 0.020065518096089363, 0.024015991017222404, -0.012105360627174377, 0.02877727337181568, -0.02765330858528614, -0.03150739148259163, 0.007330968044698238, 0.006616953294724226, 0.0034687037114053965, 0.013566290028393269, -0.010266497731208801, -0.004359078593552113, -0.02935846708714962, 0.018472613766789436, -0.02075934037566185, -0.03226221725344658, 0.006449965760111809, 0.01546395756304264, -0.03202972933650017, 0.017271175980567932, 0.014500088058412075, -0.013115602545440197, -0.028129171580076218, 0.02739320509135723 ]
<p>Can anyone tell me what exactly a cross-validation analysis gives as result? Is it just the average accuracy or does it give any model with parameters tuned? </p> <p>Because, I heard somewhere that cross-validation is used for parameter tuning.</p>
g36638
[ -0.008454062044620514, -0.04210912808775902, 0.011093271896243095, 0.009127022698521614, 0.031815044581890106, 0.01770169846713543, 0.052827343344688416, 0.02471761591732502, -0.021297764033079147, 0.04200977087020874, -0.021274015307426453, 0.02731817215681076, 0.0003132798883598298, -0.024696949869394302, -0.04634532704949379, -0.05640041455626488, 0.04138009995222092, 0.015683284029364586, -0.02655859850347042, 0.03236500173807144, -0.0009257484343834221, -0.017638709396123886, 0.006740800105035305, -0.03859393298625946, -0.03968682140111923, -0.01490863412618637, -0.05251634865999222, 0.026300370693206787, -0.09238369017839432, 0.03960355371236801, 0.023346837610006332, -0.03073049709200859, 0.05021640658378601, -0.01590539515018463, -0.016309818252921104, -0.006066258531063795, 0.03805328905582428, 0.06322812288999557, 0.0220728050917387, 0.04088594764471054, -0.024448879063129425, 0.01861478202044964, 0.007071890402585268, 0.03051331266760826, 0.018478600308299065, -0.041501734405756, 0.04686645045876503, 0.025036651641130447, 0.008463469333946705, -0.04509146884083748, -0.06561508029699326, -0.012764343060553074, 0.06404870748519897, 0.03358980268239975, 0.06745471060276031, -0.003873294685035944, 0.04640468209981918, 0.07759098708629608, -0.01727578602731228, -0.001204523490741849, 0.04567629098892212, -0.04416070133447647, -0.022003579884767532, 0.006129802204668522, -0.024081604555249214, -0.06134245544672012, 0.021253861486911774, -0.008585525676608086, -0.021307913586497307, -0.03311574086546898, -0.008716708980500698, 0.0376167818903923, 0.004420940298587084, -0.0026944114360958338, -0.017202919349074364, -0.013169652782380581, -0.015913289040327072, -0.017572514712810516, -0.005269712768495083, 0.010302451439201832, 0.03691508620977402, -0.03934434801340103, -0.004467720631510019, 0.020685140043497086, 0.021565185859799385, -0.015972459688782692, -0.05171797797083855, 0.054029934108257294, -0.09207452833652496, 0.03356330469250679, 0.037808965891599655, 0.020307529717683792, 0.0020323696080595255, 0.004486811812967062, 0.010762520134449005, 0.00007637799717485905, -0.10633964091539383, 0.007632514927536249, 0.0424315519630909, 0.07482060045003891, 0.015760574489831924, 0.0024881481658667326, 0.016840171068906784, 0.0027180796023458242, -0.01663995534181595, 0.07291261106729507, 0.03076578862965107, -0.015042205341160297, -0.008939968422055244, -0.011502101086080074, -0.07669517397880554, -0.005402867216616869, -0.025505706667900085, 0.019550945609807968, -0.0776553526520729, -0.07284914702177048, 0.0318012461066246, 0.042731355875730515, 0.04896150156855583, -0.028024040162563324, 0.05569029599428177, 0.004537705332040787, 0.015298573300242424, 0.06696109473705292, -0.05944043770432472, -0.04512077569961548, -0.0030516250990331173, 0.04487700015306473, -0.04156557470560074, 0.013276655226945877, 0.047880660742521286, -0.04757283255457878, -0.009891988709568977, 0.001559711992740631, 0.03988553211092949, 0.003132628044113517, 0.005007148254662752, 0.017509816214442253, 0.00734123308211565, -0.019989019259810448, -0.06920175999403, -0.009321126155555248, 0.013486898504197598, -0.06087271496653557, -0.007336342241615057, 0.013659044168889523, -0.0058758254162967205, 0.0042625609785318375, 0.00556554738432169, 0.04644114896655083, 0.028107771649956703, 0.03343958035111427, 0.05797438696026802, 0.010255880653858185, -0.039077725261449814, -0.01691625453531742, -0.08409976959228516, -0.002454408910125494, 0.01375175453722477, -0.004823473747819662, 0.045725543051958084, -0.02269413322210312, -0.0014346058014780283, 0.006048104260116816, -0.02213842235505581, 0.020258838310837746, -0.01631244644522667, -0.025699688121676445, -0.0023890966549515724, -0.037207551300525665, 0.0500243715941906, 0.03432647883892059, 0.05475641041994095, -0.03758698329329491, 0.02195022627711296, 0.018268946558237076, 0.07652408629655838, -0.03591056168079376, 0.06219359487295151, 0.02735985815525055, 0.03111346811056137, 0.06562277674674988, -0.0017807153053581715, -0.009375031106173992, 0.008444772101938725, -0.07122017443180084, -0.032824739813804626, -0.014373883605003357, -0.02928338386118412, -0.04462805390357971, 0.0540827214717865, -0.011304543353617191, -0.02942659892141819, -0.017929015681147575, 0.0235796757042408, -0.03067168965935707, 0.0476418174803257, 0.000924721360206604, 0.03131062909960747, 0.027859961614012718, 0.02308795228600502, -0.007710595149546862, 0.043406352400779724, 0.018232498317956924, 0.02456899918615818, 0.005636564921587706, -0.014124082401394844, -0.043579284101724625, -0.025054654106497765, 0.014329349622130394, -0.04001472890377045, -0.00806101132184267, 0.08264359086751938, 0.07547903805971146, -0.0355013832449913, 0.033190950751304626, 0.011518200859427452, -0.019593974575400352, 0.0017583522712811828, 0.00592816062271595, -0.019512908533215523, -0.04255426302552223, -0.006276755128055811, -0.0178848747164011, -0.024274734780192375, 0.04909496754407883, 0.016845304518938065, 0.04258299991488457, 0.04953378066420555, 0.033653102815151215, -0.007152121979743242, -0.056841205805540085, -0.01677553541958332, -0.027356283739209175, -0.039639249444007874, -0.006092074327170849, -0.025523826479911804, -0.03229046240448952, -0.01358359307050705, 0.023619255051016808, 0.016455737873911858, -0.021549589931964874, -0.01250479556620121, 0.016379255801439285, -0.00941268540918827, 0.013377598486840725, 0.0034859227016568184, -0.02710757777094841, 0.00822555460035801, -0.02106187865138054, -0.044006671756505966, 0.06555427610874176, 0.012903139926493168, -0.05498708784580231, 0.013088083826005459, -0.031586166471242905, 0.015369349159300327, 0.02368989773094654, 0.022125180810689926, 0.08645185083150864, 0.0380808487534523, 0.008450961671769619, -0.019432054832577705, -0.028056448325514793, 0.04113050550222397, -0.031798381358385086, 0.01601777784526348, 0.006481492426246405, -0.005231339950114489, -0.03059876337647438, -0.03144366294145584, -0.024216262623667717, 0.05145763233304024, 0.11118470877408981, 0.013463106006383896, 0.023334382101893425, -0.10061851888895035, -0.026064647361636162, 0.0041752764955163, -0.03902341052889824, -0.015740839764475822, -0.06745289266109467, 0.006264406256377697, 0.05089567229151726, -0.02309407852590084, 0.030753467231988907, 0.003996729850769043, 0.0017377049662172794, -0.00938187912106514, 0.04244024306535721, -0.01208889577537775, 0.010365850292146206, -0.03169536963105202, -0.048876408487558365, -0.026507435366511345, 0.040245119482278824, 0.0656270682811737, -0.0758155882358551, 0.055153630673885345, 0.03230315074324608, -0.0024507460184395313, 0.03503457456827164, -0.005487935151904821, 0.06638631224632263, -0.02254077047109604, 0.008018993772566319, 0.013571178540587425, -0.0014403603272512555, -0.023187294602394104, 0.03712283819913864, -0.0026190495118498802, -0.02784622088074684, 0.012589733116328716, -0.028528794646263123, 0.012645403854548931, -0.014358345419168472, -0.016508523374795914, 0.009536602534353733, -0.020563313737511635, -0.013724105432629585, 0.045620568096637726, -0.04575653374195099, 0.031553443521261215, 0.0026908419094979763, -0.05349304899573326, -0.0577208437025547, -0.03305334597826004, -0.010364609770476818, 0.01287213433533907, -0.022888919338583946, 0.04082858934998512, 0.007005620747804642, 0.01077791303396225, 0.06982729583978653, 0.00542340986430645, 0.014130479656159878, 0.027775390073657036, 0.02360885962843895, 0.01621175743639469, -0.004837062209844589, 0.014332669787108898, -0.05708356201648712, 0.013623985461890697, -0.0022663630079478025, -0.011333858594298363, 0.017740093171596527, 0.011641416698694229, -0.02773328870534897, -0.015046189539134502, 0.01376171875745058, 0.012934605590999126, 0.0016580949304625392, -0.059497736394405365, -0.022258097305893898, 0.05036567524075508, 0.008619097992777824, 0.008187931962311268, -0.05199803411960602, -0.06537520885467529, 0.024289941415190697, 0.053253669291734695, 0.004120706580579281, 0.03432890772819519, 0.00573613541200757, 0.03055453486740589, 0.028414716944098473, 0.00796477124094963, 0.03632652759552002, 0.02602476067841053, -0.01733064092695713, -0.02454841509461403, 0.06299302726984024, -0.0035047780256718397, 0.02485230378806591, 0.029632627964019775, 0.009104648604989052, 0.03998596593737602, -0.032749198377132416, -0.017678653821349144, 0.008401135914027691, 0.046105094254016876, 0.06506994366645813, -0.06760146468877792, 0.04423930495977402, 0.008417279459536076, -0.09965350478887558, -0.0017672458197921515, 0.022689107805490494, -0.0030489808414131403, -0.006783297285437584, 0.02241903729736805, -0.017069457098841667, -0.0582699291408062, -0.010103370994329453, 0.06959222257137299, -0.07267631590366364, 0.02802388370037079, -0.007595601491630077, 0.04358227550983429, 0.03786160424351692, -0.01213293056935072, -0.037299320101737976, 0.01346253976225853, -0.012168843299150467, 0.038295067846775055, -0.031383905559778214, -0.03691823408007622, 0.02415873296558857, -0.07379639148712158, 0.012331560254096985, -0.03078128769993782, -0.006045113317668438, -0.0037064284551888704, -0.04363754764199257, 0.0036441150587052107, 0.005433713551610708, 0.004139852710068226, -0.03422713279724121, 0.013157430104911327, -0.007733266334980726, -0.012387228198349476, 0.02397053875029087, 0.004964698106050491, -0.00673020351678133, 0.031094826757907867, -0.013204453513026237, 0.05154331400990486, -0.0010457293828949332, -0.016956929117441177, -0.022158753126859665, 0.010824819095432758, 0.007288164924830198, -0.05031653866171837, 0.026012888178229332, 0.01664775051176548, 0.06124275550246239, -0.027257094159722328, -0.011276365257799625, 0.017970850691199303, -0.04189598932862282, -0.032244402915239334, 0.031919270753860474, 0.02331465110182762, 0.02683062106370926, -0.06475700438022614, 0.006755002308636904, 0.031019926071166992, -0.0166091937571764, -0.01907300390303135, 0.014887128956615925, -0.036459214985370636, -0.02338329702615738, -0.020998038351535797, 0.008165589533746243, -0.046184372156858444, 0.04156884923577309, 0.05732201039791107, 0.02217084728181362, 0.004622158128768206, 0.0020897872745990753, -0.006238769274204969, -0.09348869323730469, -0.01714041456580162, 0.0035320951137691736, 0.010967081412672997, 0.029742838814854622, -0.040355850011110306, -0.01903749257326126, -0.010045252740383148, 0.0035914210602641106, 0.005780778359621763, -0.026620907709002495, 0.0759819746017456, 0.048630017787218094, 0.002569219097495079, -0.014939638786017895, -0.007944892160594463, 0.0076141320168972015, -0.06342864781618118, -0.006110496819019318, 0.014352004043757915, -0.017539817839860916, 0.029010185971856117, 0.006094585172832012, -0.023595284670591354, -0.03320656716823578, 0.017946161329746246, 0.010636317543685436, 0.024735968559980392, -0.004807546269148588, 0.0015508391661569476, 0.07335439324378967, 0.038144391030073166, -0.027645956724882126, -0.06909516453742981, -0.041011735796928406, -0.027435924857854843, 0.0016237986274063587, 0.0056026349775493145, 0.00926850363612175, -0.02154439687728882, 0.026830758899450302, 0.020968910306692123, -0.006183498539030552, -0.05564148724079132, 0.04512637108564377, 0.010321425274014473, -0.07187516242265701, -0.00609219167381525, -0.0117034912109375, 0.014906179159879684, 0.04049590602517128, -0.00046422798186540604, -0.01046892162412405, 0.0018151666736230254, -0.008886243216693401, -0.06764592230319977, -0.003326059551909566, -0.05353275313973427, -0.04513540491461754, 0.020510554313659668, 0.01145148929208517, 0.04216979071497917, -0.023942796513438225, 0.03905324637889862, -0.026274660602211952, -0.0007400471949949861, 0.01146241370588541, 0.04262903332710266, -0.09962814301252365, 0.018101084977388382, 0.07753831893205643, 0.013418887741863728, 0.05791599676012993, 0.02327759936451912, -0.058595724403858185, -0.012232834473252296, -0.03681543096899986, -0.005995456129312515, 0.004299388732761145, -0.035213690251111984, 0.04208763688802719, 0.012044288218021393, -0.007163115777075291, 0.0034160269424319267, -0.017618665471673012, -0.0205190721899271, 0.07068581879138947, -0.048095814883708954, -0.02939143031835556, -0.007424795068800449, -0.053008146584033966, 0.003441005013883114, -0.06172134354710579, 0.006148849613964558, 0.07964517921209335, 0.0006939367740415037, -0.02331426739692688, 0.04292886704206467, -0.004680338315665722, -0.007421455346047878, 0.004520113114267588, 0.014434491284191608, 0.0057387989945709705, -0.0153047489002347, 0.004729120060801506, -0.05969102680683136, -0.000055606291425647214, -0.02764899656176567, -0.03753387928009033, -0.024687306955456734, -0.03578607738018036, 0.0112298047170043, 0.0034587590489536524, -0.049966417253017426, 0.04894692078232765, -0.05340576171875, 0.032747358083724976, 0.0210600346326828, -0.08631474524736404, 0.05068499222397804, 0.01247254479676485, -0.054170507937669754, -0.01365590002387762, -0.09242188930511475, 0.02168862521648407, -0.05665809288620949, 0.05709763243794441, -0.011296762153506279, -0.012384566478431225, -0.08076585829257965, -0.024200646206736565, -0.021276889368891716, -0.01714954897761345, 0.04211371764540672, -0.02383301965892315, -0.0013781787129119039, 0.061174824833869934, -0.015180036425590515, -0.03238575533032417, -0.0052885995246469975, 0.045348070561885834, 0.047013331204652786, 0.00963122583925724, -0.008304772898554802, 0.013336570002138615, 0.011632084846496582, -0.031429827213287354, -0.061746060848236084, 0.02936343289911747, -0.016680045053362846, 0.010958564467728138, 0.07037670910358429, 0.005593651439994574, -0.08440523594617844, -0.021084517240524292, -0.028903167694807053, -0.05195322260260582, -0.06107879430055618, -0.014956417493522167, 0.002584692556411028, -0.024350818246603012, -0.005098499823361635, -0.028050824999809265, -0.00032577806268818676, 0.022622954100370407, 0.005734078586101532, -0.024230415001511574, 0.023663775995373726, -0.06964998692274094, -0.04738209769129753, 0.027966083958745003, -0.017499078065156937, -0.008147063665091991, -0.03958868235349655, 0.08741000294685364, -0.02151043340563774, 0.0441451370716095, -0.00020750607654917985, 0.06654983758926392, 0.023673539981245995, 0.050153881311416626, -0.017811650410294533, -0.059762608259916306, -0.06844089925289154, 0.027794627472758293, -0.042274486273527145, -0.0004085120453964919, -0.037103310227394104, -0.010749598033726215, 0.029784733429551125, 0.015066681429743767, -0.060893796384334564, 0.008832071907818317, 0.048793356865644455, 0.06239872798323631, 0.015401549637317657, 0.0673200711607933, -0.0013063669903203845, -0.022516855970025063, 0.005569174885749817, -0.039937861263751984, -0.00024387842859141529, 0.06043243780732155, 0.023561391979455948, 0.0020802796352654696, -0.040450792759656906, -0.0659782811999321, 0.05012570694088936, 0.007403469644486904, 0.03193146362900734, 0.033497072756290436, -0.0016166585264727473, 0.059739116579294205, 0.02733580954372883, -0.001297550625167787, -0.07478580623865128, 0.04488492012023926, 0.003692503785714507, 0.02868734858930111, 0.050290338695049286, 0.013815440237522125, 0.04493122175335884, -0.017768343910574913, -0.06234651431441307, 0.05696839094161987, 0.008178800344467163, 0.027316933497786522, -0.057724591344594955, -0.03939947858452797, 0.002760997274890542, -0.05940019339323044, 0.029273483902215958, -0.03500327840447426, -0.05806570500135422, 0.01049534697085619, -0.02039768546819687, -0.026887277141213417, 0.053210798650979996, 0.050322942435741425, 0.10657618194818497, 0.019480183720588684, 0.012800220400094986, -0.014344139024615288, -0.007945203222334385, 0.00243264134041965, -0.04650323465466499, -0.02164442464709282, 0.030572740361094475, -0.029366442933678627, -0.016661521047353745, -0.03870026022195816, 0.017064908519387245, -0.009410753846168518, -0.05427740886807442, -0.019392888993024826, 0.0076345279812812805, -0.04824826121330261, -0.06486333161592484, 0.008624646812677383, -0.03152959421277046, -0.02625247836112976, 0.11731401830911636, 0.029594870284199715, 0.061506666243076324, -0.006279637571424246, -0.09345611929893494, 0.033652111887931824, -0.036135900765657425, 0.04017028585076332, -0.007028245832771063, 0.002994191600009799, -0.05002212896943092, 0.007671238388866186, -0.03424307703971863, 0.0021775278728455305, 0.06446518748998642, 0.03508478030562401, -0.02804219350218773, 0.029586879536509514, -0.02249685674905777, 0.02688869833946228, -0.015639597550034523, 0.07010269165039062, -0.037842731922864914, -0.030852165073156357, 0.027907950803637505, 0.040013909339904785, 0.03285295516252518, -0.005545352585613728, -0.0013725439785048366, -0.0012008630437776446, 0.0318097285926342, 0.025819851085543633, -0.02073783054947853, 0.0019800562877207994, 0.0028380444273352623, -0.012540183030068874, -0.012465082108974457, 0.03542427346110344, -0.031136350706219673, -0.009477744810283184, 0.021487778052687645, 0.035179734230041504, 0.004876531660556793, -0.03705857694149017, -0.006530465092509985, 0.013564269058406353 ]
<p>I am studying a population of individuals who all begin with a measureable score of interest (ranging from -2 to 2) [call it "old"], then they all undergo a change to a new score (also ranging from -2 to 2) ["new"]. Thus all the variation is in the change (which can be positive or negative), and there are also a variety of predictors that help to explain variation in the amount of change.</p> <p>My initial model is simply:</p> <pre><code>change = a + bx + e </code></pre> <p>where x is my vector of predictors.</p> <p>But now I'm concerned that some of these predictors could be correlated with the baseline (old) score. Is this, then, a better specification?</p> <pre><code>change = a + bx + old + e </code></pre> <p>Or perhaps</p> <pre><code>new = a + bx + old + e </code></pre> <p>Thanks!</p>
g74018
[ -0.008257230743765831, -0.02250642515718937, -0.011529709212481976, -0.01791471056640148, 0.014618371613323689, -0.03207273408770561, 0.02500956691801548, 0.020738612860441208, -0.049491483718156815, 0.0031054196879267693, -0.020775841549038887, 0.06429889053106308, 0.043793171644210815, 0.004654379095882177, -0.023329254239797592, -0.0009713377221487463, 0.06822837889194489, -0.01951739937067032, 0.005275632254779339, 0.02859894372522831, -0.007646853104233742, -0.04425361752510071, 0.06486433744430542, -0.019095776602625847, -0.039321620017290115, -0.06418274343013763, 0.006505480967462063, 0.08155167102813721, -0.0633663460612297, 0.028612367808818817, 0.03435856103897095, 0.022576870396733284, 0.014673056080937386, -0.06362976878881454, -0.03405587375164032, 0.006358525715768337, 0.06772521138191223, 0.04123321548104286, 0.007134393788874149, 0.030298642814159393, 0.0131082059815526, 0.06072775274515152, 0.0028638949152082205, 0.02217073179781437, -0.013919176533818245, -0.04168706759810448, 0.06207520142197609, -0.034346021711826324, -0.04300767183303833, 0.00909413956105709, -0.003324930090457201, 0.042320720851421356, 0.0032759045716375113, 0.02541653998196125, 0.026015302166342735, 0.03234050050377846, -0.050078313797712326, 0.021589601412415504, 0.017954375594854355, 0.01907486841082573, -0.009405097924172878, 0.02223733253777027, 0.0037422101013362408, 0.006460600066930056, 0.007416716776788235, 0.039400145411491394, -0.020940717309713364, -0.03400624543428421, -0.006458846386522055, -0.02444508858025074, -0.005227985791862011, -0.015062439255416393, -0.023301901295781136, 0.030833663418889046, -0.03183295950293541, -0.03869112581014633, -0.040259335190057755, 0.021716121584177017, 0.017439953982830048, -0.009240268729627132, 0.001911034807562828, 0.012709947302937508, -0.010199394077062607, 0.04518498480319977, 0.07564793527126312, -0.016432147473096848, 0.011748353019356728, 0.004793106112629175, -0.010489444248378277, -0.03671478107571602, 0.010220559313893318, -0.02285505086183548, 0.037159498780965805, 0.030966246500611305, -0.02721841260790825, -0.002158569172024727, -0.07087895274162292, 0.01615079678595066, 0.02780025824904442, -0.010943644680082798, 0.010170486755669117, 0.04070822149515152, -0.007458647713065147, -0.0254670362919569, -0.11314694583415985, -0.002513288985937834, 0.04093256592750549, -0.039005547761917114, -0.006018778309226036, -0.02834894508123398, -0.007106334902346134, -0.015099683776497841, -0.07803185284137726, -0.0048124827444553375, -0.06927737593650818, -0.04685989022254944, 0.017513571307063103, -0.0015493554528802633, -0.053445782512426376, -0.016516324132680893, -0.0011211578967049718, -0.053666386753320694, 0.07647562772035599, 0.06047854572534561, -0.046051111072301865, -0.007789646275341511, -0.04361137002706528, 0.068386510014534, 0.06274191290140152, -0.0025732351932674646, 0.015926837921142578, 0.054950930178165436, -0.04150049388408661, 0.03874249756336212, 0.051399070769548416, 0.006262887269258499, -0.0008640821906737983, 0.036623548716306686, -0.027025172486901283, 0.04538322240114212, -0.009505392983555794, 0.026295846328139305, 0.026629481464624405, -0.038187965750694275, -0.05132700875401497, 0.0035027703270316124, 0.030439095571637154, -0.02633792906999588, 0.028439680114388466, 0.009053832851350307, -0.007977332919836044, 0.03861972689628601, -0.05886717885732651, -0.003632093546912074, -0.02839255891740322, 0.0063504409044981, -0.0435907319188118, 0.002552076242864132, -0.039061639457941055, -0.023221004754304886, 0.0343681164085865, -0.06295476108789444, 0.10988941788673401, -0.013303227722644806, 0.001418434432707727, -0.03315605968236923, -0.03492068499326706, -0.03829936310648918, -0.026532122865319252, 0.03618067875504494, 0.030825495719909668, -0.005285034421831369, 0.0007005638908594847, -0.0059463162906467915, 0.0338655561208725, 0.013780439272522926, 0.07762819528579712, 0.008212135173380375, 0.07841373980045319, 0.0029098838567733765, -0.06206211447715759, 0.024596408009529114, 0.008306999690830708, 0.003985193558037281, 0.011693766340613365, -0.02104036696255207, -0.0136311249807477, 0.06118237227201462, -0.05938416346907616, -0.04113519564270973, -0.030215522274374962, -0.04116722196340561, -0.030050279572606087, -0.006350333336740732, -0.02177182212471962, -0.01876269094645977, -0.010130707174539566, -0.015062244608998299, -0.02649320475757122, 0.033996645361185074, 0.013902416452765465, 0.06255627423524857, -0.041680801659822464, 0.06125536561012268, -0.04788203909993172, -0.0024014306254684925, 0.05217038840055466, -0.0043466114439070225, 0.0027629281394183636, 0.0031358697451651096, 0.012288011610507965, -0.004896450322121382, -0.058500584214925766, 0.06003553420305252, 0.0006096624420024455, -0.0306390430778265, 0.02318946272134781, 0.06862407922744751, 0.01069850567728281, 0.04060345143079758, -0.11764546483755112, -0.02375711314380169, 0.04382172226905823, 0.044322118163108826, -0.01218411885201931, 0.04332808777689934, 0.07596759498119354, -0.017144640907645226, -0.0021638066973537207, 0.021950233727693558, 0.013553722761571407, -0.001136520877480507, 0.01285426877439022, -0.007700507994741201, 0.009387930855154991, 0.038305480033159256, 0.03658197075128555, -0.016990801319479942, 0.02695685438811779, -0.0026502220425754786, 0.058518871665000916, 0.026021620258688927, 0.024787992238998413, 0.0356457382440567, 0.02686961181461811, -0.04140317812561989, 0.02576526254415512, 0.025355571880936623, 0.03355361893773079, 0.05729581043124199, -0.034071702510118484, 0.0068324655294418335, -0.027745552361011505, -0.01279942411929369, 0.010317430831491947, -0.04912908747792244, 0.021176328882575035, 0.049651212990283966, -0.01988735795021057, 0.016729863360524178, -0.01785622537136078, 0.025848835706710815, 0.015522254630923271, 0.0443672351539135, 0.0004349660885054618, 0.0022928696125745773, 0.0186700988560915, -0.04311079904437065, -0.02129420079290867, 0.008591772057116032, -0.0175795815885067, -0.00893374253064394, -0.024196282029151917, 0.08881191909313202, 0.01508297584950924, -0.01066877692937851, -0.06689094007015228, -0.0285575520247221, 0.03246369585394859, -0.011854985728859901, 0.022827625274658203, 0.039850492030382156, -0.05831754580140114, -0.04225414991378784, 0.06506603211164474, 0.04429507628083229, 0.02110709249973297, -0.016101090237498283, -0.03926530107855797, 0.04994006082415581, -0.005319906398653984, 0.021107928827404976, 0.054416339844465256, -0.040674421936273575, 0.01649877429008484, 0.010881204158067703, -0.030495360493659973, -0.07680656015872955, 0.004534849897027016, 0.059787217527627945, -0.06477265059947968, 0.0023113880306482315, -0.021160518750548363, 0.0074957129545509815, 0.09094343334436417, -0.04434854909777641, -0.061285506933927536, 0.05040905624628067, 0.03118990547955036, -0.0641327053308487, 0.0023814637679606676, -0.046787671744823456, -0.035118743777275085, -0.052186526358127594, -0.034029509872198105, -0.020714623853564262, 0.014130975119769573, 0.030829068273305893, 0.023466045036911964, -0.040359992533922195, -0.057920802384614944, -0.023271620273590088, 0.0127011239528656, 0.008826696313917637, 0.006965168286114931, 0.03683993220329285, 0.019529590383172035, -0.01612870581448078, -0.07052404433488846, -0.0015552513068541884, 0.0234480332583189, 0.051385119557380676, -0.0056144678965210915, -0.0031454707495868206, 0.016205651685595512, -0.07438243180513382, -0.006324357353150845, -0.010906529612839222, -0.042459290474653244, 0.0789211243391037, -0.025742273777723312, -0.01768409088253975, -0.00003473147444310598, -0.00023629108909517527, -0.027259115129709244, -0.02763255126774311, 0.05624675005674362, -0.031600095331668854, 0.00798700749874115, -0.029569366946816444, -0.002445438178256154, -0.04621872678399086, 0.006589764729142189, 0.049449849873781204, -0.020445406436920166, -0.015631837770342827, 0.04827429726719856, -0.04680848866701126, -0.05887049436569214, 0.01753963902592659, 0.04124709963798523, -0.04046151414513588, -0.02592453546822071, 0.03842912241816521, 0.038608208298683167, 0.057534463703632355, 0.022765154018998146, -0.023827729746699333, 0.03324747458100319, 0.009794548153877258, 0.02150338888168335, 0.03501369059085846, 0.01558513194322586, 0.006815743166953325, -0.03939449414610863, 0.03546825423836708, 0.021385440602898598, 0.021574893966317177, -0.005774986930191517, 0.04424700513482094, 0.07521290332078934, -0.04532483220100403, -0.027726270258426666, -0.022878261283040047, -0.036889709532260895, -0.01925315335392952, 0.026682566851377487, -0.03591295704245567, 0.0299636609852314, 0.017604900524020195, -0.024428103119134903, 0.020349496975541115, -0.022520486265420914, 0.0459156334400177, 0.039238493889570236, -0.01180029846727848, -0.0038305209018290043, 0.027285035699605942, 0.042745817452669144, 0.03552835062146187, -0.062487319111824036, 0.030310869216918945, 0.04717593640089035, -0.020674152299761772, -0.008762258104979992, -0.03481835871934891, -0.010038843378424644, -0.02864094078540802, -0.0020659363362938166, -0.034837156534194946, -0.011063838377594948, 0.0076330481097102165, 0.01643277145922184, -0.026951393112540245, 0.01759827882051468, 0.02238294668495655, 0.033886101096868515, 0.023572508245706558, 0.007503652945160866, 0.02192477323114872, 0.003804541891440749, 0.048183687031269073, 0.019608698785305023, 0.0037933902349323034, 0.04977982118725777, -0.018736163154244423, -0.03030337393283844, -0.010719824582338333, 0.03519756346940994, -0.03324998915195465, 0.01381043903529644, 0.06001868098974228, -0.03459440916776657, 0.013827761635184288, -0.04029184579849243, 0.054383471608161926, -0.01992005854845047, -0.017225859686732292, -0.08768466860055923, -0.04782911762595177, -0.012159682810306549, -0.029243355616927147, -0.01567726768553257, -0.02281474694609642, 0.04304656386375427, 0.010851342231035233, -0.08524058014154434, 0.0018682321533560753, 0.059605520218610764, 0.05295444279909134, -0.0012485148617997766, 0.06213466078042984, 0.08330512791872025, -0.01617349497973919, 0.025162793695926666, -0.007851717993617058, 0.06271051615476608, -0.014389409683644772, 0.02549896016716957, 0.019250646233558655, -0.006969769950956106, -0.021502040326595306, -0.016723694279789925, -0.03171201050281525, -0.01159757561981678, -0.037281956523656845, -0.04463717341423035, -0.007530386559665203, 0.0417906828224659, -0.021514777094125748, 0.026664186269044876, -0.04057024419307709, -0.005854882765561342, -0.00995822437107563, -0.04192894697189331, 0.04969530180096626, -0.021453453227877617, -0.020377174019813538, 0.02407885156571865, -0.000723511737305671, -0.009303697384893894, 0.04164751246571541, -0.008145051077008247, -0.017731614410877228, 0.02478940226137638, -0.03781784698367119, 0.019806619733572006, -0.06372274458408356, 0.03580011799931526, 0.0031781315337866545, 0.02100471407175064, 0.04613005369901657, 0.052287545055150986, 0.023991454392671585, 0.013159342110157013, 0.007687999401241541, 0.032405734062194824, -0.010920851491391659, 0.015141626819968224, -0.0021917943377047777, -0.06891395151615143, 0.0867147445678711, 0.04157642275094986, -0.037355873733758926, 0.020792927592992783, 0.025846730917692184, 0.03589891269803047, -0.044751111418008804, 0.019224610179662704, 0.06888999044895172, -0.042347535490989685, 0.05994580686092377, 0.07202936708927155, 0.0015738653019070625, -0.04611571133136749, 0.01653732918202877, -0.003947984427213669, 0.020666182041168213, -0.05183359235525131, -0.00659389840438962, 0.037628065794706345, -0.07806313782930374, 0.003347177989780903, 0.019795868545770645, -0.015200422145426273, 0.025310520082712173, 0.01892048679292202, -0.037577755749225616, 0.02894592098891735, -0.014341352507472038, 0.011294562369585037, 0.02502269297838211, 0.014367913827300072, 0.012217450886964798, 0.022760607302188873, -0.015983670949935913, -0.054445620626211166, 0.02637069672346115, 0.02875547669827938, -0.050751637667417526, -0.0500008724629879, 0.027439864352345467, 0.037201154977083206, -0.03623093664646149, 0.002401764737442136, 0.0037130583077669144, -0.05704554542899132, -0.014690538868308067, -0.02434997819364071, -0.07903322577476501, 0.007713028229773045, 0.010552461259067059, -0.014852388761937618, 0.007785772904753685, -0.06328485161066055, 0.02124096266925335, 0.029590828344225883, 0.025115175172686577, 0.061179082840681076, -0.029318228363990784, -0.04424620047211647, -0.07364362478256226, -0.012129321694374084, -0.025145648047327995, 0.02964407578110695, -0.049265868961811066, 0.005130050703883171, -0.00038607866736128926, 0.0404212661087513, 0.0027671961579471827, 0.012123510241508484, -0.04409177228808403, 0.05201563984155655, -0.01126868650317192, -0.03642420098185539, -0.006842374335974455, -0.06631626933813095, 0.009431404992938042, 0.03328108787536621, 0.02994729019701481, -0.024127377197146416, -0.07833470404148102, -0.05439558997750282, -0.03117806650698185, 0.02360786497592926, 0.03245638683438301, 0.0003144838847219944, -0.004716056399047375, -0.02519894950091839, 0.05435726046562195, -0.03568769991397858, 0.008363206870853901, 0.05502363294363022, -0.027432115748524666, -0.002090321620926261, 0.03219803795218468, -0.051131974905729294, -0.011530973948538303, -0.0007398065645247698, 0.004573191981762648, 0.03393740579485893, 0.0023176975082606077, 0.015253322198987007, -0.0006494589615613222, 0.0035308438818901777, 0.03356437385082245, -0.030349407345056534, 0.03434709459543228, 0.04266105219721794, 0.02120383456349373, -0.015604567714035511, -0.02255197986960411, 0.028457893058657646, 0.012378333136439323, 0.022051505744457245, 0.007937503047287464, 0.0035208421759307384, 0.028853418305516243, -0.03842626512050629, 0.027659157291054726, 0.035982877016067505, 0.010550076141953468, -0.007506744936108589, -0.015438604168593884, -0.006392531096935272, 0.013020013459026814, 0.0012629631673917174, -0.028439011424779892, 0.03233639523386955, 0.024161219596862793, -0.03340412303805351, 0.054000549018383026, -0.07187960296869278, 0.0579809732735157, -0.07159880548715591, 0.02038237452507019, -0.056572325527668, 0.06780436635017395, -0.0187185388058424, 0.019133703783154488, 0.024224283173680305, 0.040979135781526566, -0.04333428293466568, 0.03027070313692093, -0.007082625292241573, -0.020532948896288872, 0.06987179815769196, 0.044857610017061234, -0.0739714726805687, 0.023478031158447266, -0.0032170128542929888, 0.010772707872092724, -0.005663637071847916, 0.002745560137555003, 0.00007148132135625929, 0.01030167005956173, 0.04876280203461647, 0.012011894956231117, 0.027634568512439728, -0.009769310243427753, -0.003230899339541793, -0.04202628880739212, -0.03650951758027077, 0.034597549587488174, 0.015547974035143852, 0.047753967344760895, 0.027855757623910904, -0.060051996260881424, -0.032215625047683716, -0.04411131143569946, 0.01027426216751337, -0.05165902525186539, -0.02023616060614586, -0.01943867653608322, 0.014301548711955547, 0.03431210666894913, -0.04819592460989952, -0.00997840240597725, -0.031112678349018097, -0.017062541097402573, 0.018561525270342827, -0.03247421979904175, 0.02631198987364769, 0.03198840841650963, -0.05556316301226616, 0.08886760473251343, -0.037370096892118454, -0.003941609524190426, -0.006998133845627308, -0.004681790247559547, -0.07262297719717026, -0.04822881147265434, 0.05051332339644432, -0.01043667457997799, -0.01757843792438507, -0.019993413239717484, -0.037561897188425064, 0.022980228066444397, -0.046852003782987595, 0.03360257297754288, 0.03613022342324257, 0.020828574895858765, -0.020390359684824944, -0.04291486367583275, 0.007808732334524393, -0.023928821086883545, 0.03283271938562393, -0.05637224018573761, 0.002768546110019088, -0.06862713396549225, -0.093257375061512, 0.0008831645827740431, -0.012130148708820343, 0.01717991940677166, -0.06261054426431656, 0.010336869396269321, -0.0289930310100317, -0.039087459444999695, -0.01607503369450569, 0.003790087765082717, -0.06248963251709938, -0.0014552115462720394, -0.02434021420776844, -0.013290067203342915, -0.01563851162791252, -0.05957477167248726, -0.005508228205144405, 0.024889390915632248, -0.011194145306944847, 0.01126942690461874, -0.09662505239248276, -0.06465058028697968, -0.09910450875759125, 0.030071081593632698, 0.02109849639236927, 0.04267625883221626, 0.004202475771307945, 0.06735994666814804, -0.029376760125160217, -0.033027470111846924, -0.058988381177186966, -0.0146951200440526, 0.037101902067661285, 0.025013966485857964, -0.0002662008919287473, 0.03336421772837639, 0.04501686617732048, 0.004498773720115423, -0.03431539982557297, -0.00635857880115509, -0.016541562974452972, 0.008056572638452053, -0.022376803681254387, 0.047799091786146164, 0.01746118813753128, 0.04173686355352402, -0.00931693334132433, 0.016658835113048553, -0.009265675209462643, -0.025961844250559807, 0.019222885370254517, -0.010918372310698032, -0.0320456437766552, -0.02773151732981205, -0.07681184262037277, -0.014439242891967297, 0.003521260805428028, 0.04661468043923378 ]
<p>I ran a within subjects repeated measures experiment, where the independent variable had 3 levels. The dependent variable is a measure of correctness and is recorded as either correct / incorrect. Time taken to provide an answer was also recorded.</p> <p>A within subjects repeated measures ANOVA is used to establish whether there is significant differences in correctness (DV) between the 3 levels of the IV, there is significant. Now, I'd like to analyze whether there is significant differences in the time taken to provide the answers when the answers are 1) correct, and 2) incorrect.</p> <p>My problem is: Across the levels there are different numbers of correct / incorrect answers, e.g. level 1 has 67 correct answers, level 2 has 30, level 3 has 25. </p> <p>How can I compare the time take taken for all correct answers across the 3 levels? I think this means its unbalanced? Can I do 3 one way ANOVAS to do a pairwise comparison, while adjusting p downwards to account for each comparison?</p> <p>Thanks</p>
g38142
[ -0.04569392651319504, -0.04931348189711571, -0.022642573341727257, -0.016951709985733032, 0.025006717070937157, 0.0013685342855751514, 0.039491523057222366, -0.04126160219311714, -0.04311517998576164, 0.06374076008796692, -0.027658620849251747, -0.00028925915830768645, -0.03439083695411682, 0.07601276785135269, -0.005282657686620951, 0.005957544315606356, 0.09752283990383148, -0.008728481829166412, 0.0396597757935524, -0.02027682214975357, 0.01545880176126957, 0.02662726677954197, -0.008838805370032787, 0.030905064195394516, -0.023507580161094666, -0.02867387793958187, -0.008762042969465256, 0.042858853936195374, -0.0726422592997551, -0.007284316699951887, -0.026441868394613266, -0.010014147497713566, -0.0015694348840042949, 0.012850158847868443, -0.03129038214683533, -0.019419413059949875, 0.04674174636602402, 0.03582994267344475, -0.00511518307030201, 0.05974868685007095, 0.020305246114730835, 0.00832084659487009, 0.04772428423166275, 0.013745675794780254, 0.0027421782724559307, 0.017829345539212227, -0.020701369270682335, -0.0018655153689906001, -0.02772529050707817, -0.00924106128513813, -0.002825212897732854, 0.004587958566844463, 0.02396414242684841, 0.04518306255340576, 0.026352526620030403, -0.029218781739473343, 0.0017851106822490692, 0.008461366407573223, 0.01765211671590805, 0.060920599848032, -0.007745290175080299, -0.05496262013912201, 0.002752324566245079, -0.02491825446486473, 0.0389305055141449, 0.004763740114867687, -0.03635994717478752, 0.006250864360481501, -0.05658692866563797, -0.02321571670472622, -0.021627936512231827, -0.05328820273280144, -0.013677040114998817, -0.037217896431684494, -0.0329756923019886, -0.01268472895026207, 0.02667444571852684, -0.030632315203547478, 0.005865850951522589, 0.03541653975844383, -0.03029104508459568, 0.038652535527944565, 0.06766312569379807, 0.01780436746776104, 0.09477383643388748, -0.014012699015438557, 0.0409265011548996, 0.032208893448114395, -0.004244138021022081, 0.06327186524868011, 0.009213464334607124, -0.004469848703593016, 0.08760683238506317, 0.057071421295404434, -0.07433376461267471, -0.05422568321228027, -0.04616336151957512, 0.0532221794128418, 0.01634586602449417, 0.02272464707493782, -0.049056366086006165, 0.026273103430867195, -0.03450111299753189, -0.03340345248579979, -0.09263879060745239, -0.024597903713583946, 0.0718332901597023, 0.0052689420990645885, -0.06411556899547577, -0.049157384783029556, -0.06507537513971329, -0.03654886409640312, -0.05591664835810661, 0.028470288962125778, -0.021584076806902885, 0.0145307881757617, 0.02089259959757328, 0.0016831023385748267, -0.04124780371785164, -0.008781523443758488, 0.04651932790875435, 0.011799921281635761, -0.041496049612760544, 0.07505065947771072, -0.026143750175833702, 0.03695940971374512, -0.06475319713354111, 0.048441898077726364, 0.02003994770348072, 0.05893338471651077, 0.0016218608943745494, -0.0063577815890312195, -0.0007978277280926704, 0.03192143514752388, -0.014782341197133064, -0.01796598732471466, 0.01063141506165266, 0.07932717353105545, -0.02643953263759613, -0.021465729922056198, -0.06654345989227295, -0.005275292322039604, 0.011169252917170525, 0.017084378749132156, 0.030694233253598213, -0.016757134348154068, -0.003915491979569197, -0.023840589448809624, -0.015591825358569622, -0.007465077098459005, 0.05831298977136612, 0.06931410729885101, 0.0131188640370965, -0.013309662230312824, -0.048499394208192825, -0.0005456300568766892, -0.051534391939640045, 0.030745193362236023, 0.04021557420492172, 0.03859017416834831, 0.024459563195705414, -0.03224092721939087, -0.007860780693590641, -0.002402513287961483, 0.029966987669467926, 0.08449613302946091, 0.036130983382463455, -0.01250629685819149, -0.006808783393353224, -0.009102245792746544, -0.050239600241184235, -0.025734763592481613, 0.03095867857336998, -0.052279893308877945, 0.04405868425965309, 0.052061449736356735, 0.03420054912567139, -0.06851118057966232, 0.012619269080460072, 0.017648937180638313, 0.006362390238791704, 0.06524252891540527, -0.013119692914187908, 0.005494566168636084, 0.0002222830371465534, -0.051043879240751266, -0.02681800350546837, -0.05663716048002243, -0.10670880228281021, -0.010945520363748074, 0.03353029862046242, -0.0382615327835083, -0.043850380927324295, -0.010521198622882366, -0.025285575538873672, -0.057175181806087494, -0.013198946602642536, -0.0400879867374897, -0.033012524247169495, 0.020984208211302757, 0.01868973672389984, -0.027630915865302086, 0.03167792782187462, 0.05705192685127258, 0.003443752648308873, 0.01678287982940674, 0.01465712022036314, -0.01997162587940693, -0.0167781300842762, -0.023427214473485947, 0.01986866258084774, 0.035305656492710114, 0.013742897659540176, 0.04261196032166481, 0.000686311221215874, 0.02197621949017048, 0.05198727548122406, 0.007950442843139172, 0.01940087229013443, 0.006431445479393005, -0.04632580280303955, -0.030708592385053635, 0.02330399863421917, -0.049430087208747864, -0.01187167689204216, -0.02811773493885994, 0.02765619568526745, -0.048003654927015305, -0.01191486231982708, -0.03116394393146038, -0.02613639459013939, 0.009437804110348225, 0.029205048456788063, -0.040813833475112915, 0.06300179660320282, 0.03969165310263634, 0.012251080945134163, 0.02450295351445675, -0.04123125225305557, 0.014982438646256924, -0.02977040782570839, 0.025390831753611565, -0.02403000369668007, 0.07232734560966492, -0.000007655357876501512, 0.008546022698283195, 0.01948562264442444, -0.0062078870832920074, -0.008870820514857769, 0.05382167920470238, -0.033167436718940735, 0.018050245940685272, 0.014314898289740086, -0.009372574277222157, -0.015387310646474361, -0.013106225058436394, 0.01179735641926527, 0.06750743836164474, 0.030705997720360756, 0.02520880103111267, 0.02071673609316349, -0.0015418663388118148, 0.026112139225006104, 0.02377421036362648, 0.04385511949658394, -0.02230030484497547, 0.019132617861032486, -0.02615491673350334, -0.037290822714567184, -0.01896635815501213, -0.031663112342357635, 0.02799643948674202, 0.03393977880477905, 0.035383764654397964, 0.003299456089735031, 0.017738642171025276, -0.0461689829826355, -0.0444200299680233, 0.0657864436507225, -0.034237511456012726, 0.022869177162647247, 0.03690578415989876, -0.021526196971535683, 0.01690942980349064, 0.061694130301475525, 0.05813642963767052, 0.07451891899108887, -0.040445320308208466, -0.04514222592115402, 0.036444373428821564, -0.026028400287032127, 0.04296369105577469, -0.002818390727043152, 0.0025493460707366467, -0.03667307272553444, 0.00886522512882948, 0.03179634362459183, -0.09010306000709534, 0.003138232510536909, 0.022062188014388084, -0.04752182960510254, -0.012918774969875813, -0.0038531820755451918, 0.006900440901517868, 0.050940971821546555, -0.025705553591251373, -0.00200095702894032, 0.04333712160587311, 0.02398005686700344, 0.01613016240298748, -0.03093271516263485, -0.041085824370384216, -0.03935623541474342, -0.06966786831617355, 0.000632923562079668, -0.049347393214702606, -0.03400714695453644, -0.0050448584370315075, 0.0040602353401482105, 0.03305409476161003, 0.003427275689318776, -0.02772543393075466, -0.024638574570417404, 0.0590033158659935, -0.026359237730503082, 0.000815525942016393, -0.0012355758808553219, -0.007767380680888891, -0.11421668529510498, 0.019727252423763275, 0.056302327662706375, 0.046228744089603424, 0.04386153817176819, -0.048550475388765335, 0.03987864777445793, 0.001787964953109622, -0.0053480262868106365, -0.04735579714179039, 0.005370724480599165, 0.03903042525053024, -0.016014011576771736, -0.022102201357483864, 0.007966813631355762, -0.0009907500352710485, 0.027278371155261993, -0.0052866144105792046, 0.0193401500582695, 0.015046107582747936, 0.008859553374350071, -0.02437632903456688, 0.030883410945534706, 0.012182552367448807, 0.00375659903511405, -0.07455843687057495, 0.06243208423256874, -0.0028553996235132217, 0.09872891008853912, 0.036377325654029846, -0.01722114533185959, -0.003164758672937751, 0.018467698246240616, 0.0005791356670670211, -0.0691908746957779, -0.025212205946445465, -0.014531174674630165, 0.015245593152940273, 0.020489666610956192, 0.0471867136657238, 0.08954351395368576, -0.013125591911375523, 0.013662813231348991, 0.05476706102490425, -0.026755379512906075, -0.08292902261018753, 0.033472124487161636, -0.052238866686820984, 0.08942355960607529, 0.03179754316806793, -0.006448817905038595, 0.06901506334543228, 0.08483058214187622, 0.023730117827653885, -0.00051390245789662, -0.029381131753325462, 0.009156433865427971, -0.00400169100612402, 0.013042912818491459, 0.021705003455281258, -0.03461626172065735, 0.012338122352957726, -0.025879187509417534, -0.007495828904211521, -0.10520677268505096, 0.07535804808139801, 0.0011460089590400457, -0.01855299435555935, -0.01931624487042427, 0.03530965745449066, -0.01118447445333004, 0.05951250344514847, -0.019980190321803093, -0.038814958184957504, -0.01715957373380661, -0.0023016619961708784, -0.06598702818155289, 0.02005157619714737, 0.03680911660194397, -0.01603703200817108, -0.1026693731546402, 0.030927792191505432, -0.055532924830913544, -0.024689046666026115, 0.00027708878042176366, -0.04947990924119949, -0.01034613512456417, 0.023567546159029007, 0.0325806625187397, -0.020208187401294708, -0.008385405875742435, -0.017152173444628716, 0.041658900678157806, 0.042865123599767685, 0.011045308783650398, -0.057514738291502, 0.04955662414431572, 0.05516611784696579, -0.007455172948539257, 0.03357355669140816, 0.07644923776388168, -0.020304491743445396, 0.05381341278553009, -0.020003365352749825, -0.02482912689447403, 0.0023683274630457163, 0.024941230192780495, 0.017072254791855812, -0.011058330535888672, 0.011978252790868282, -0.011332244612276554, -0.015367156825959682, 0.015392912551760674, -0.01693911664187908, -0.03310501575469971, 0.001617515692487359, -0.012017476372420788, 0.02304098941385746, -0.03016018122434616, -0.01206200197339058, 0.006330064497888088, 0.027099568396806717, -0.05435062199831009, 0.036036115139722824, 0.000790851132478565, -0.023809095844626427, 0.011286801658570766, -0.0067676217295229435, 0.04152531176805496, -0.025946874171495438, -0.014989200979471207, 0.004651197697967291, -0.02578553557395935, -0.012888772413134575, -0.05281929299235344, -0.02882218547165394, 0.014522791840136051, -0.05951685085892677, -0.024058083072304726, -0.002653742441907525, -0.054600898176431656, 0.004806144628673792, 0.008655660785734653, -0.055766161531209946, -0.02590365707874298, 0.03688163682818413, -0.00711650587618351, -0.03890971839427948, 0.058397918939590454, 0.013424579985439777, 0.004367838613688946, -0.027320735156536102, 0.006319018546491861, -0.05895496532320976, 0.04473518207669258, -0.006472784094512463, -0.03207018971443176, -0.05034767836332321, -0.0499761700630188, -0.05696770176291466, 0.01757456362247467, -0.03398628160357475, 0.0064439172856509686, 0.03791710361838341, 0.0871160551905632, -0.04781987890601158, -0.0007263153092935681, 0.00786655768752098, -0.04239160940051079, -0.0031378453131765127, 0.007075788453221321, -0.05525605380535126, -0.04203488305211067, 0.0552932545542717, 0.0381351001560688, -0.017497889697551727, 0.016843575984239578, -0.009507053531706333, 0.0010934424353763461, -0.023746812716126442, 0.009580870158970356, 0.006741879507899284, -0.009135437197983265, 0.0016191333997994661, 0.044081587344408035, 0.03369976580142975, -0.037701867520809174, 0.028257515281438828, 0.05202501267194748, 0.008713781833648682, 0.02435612678527832, -0.043443553149700165, 0.036080047488212585, 0.03805200755596161, 0.0006067247595638037, 0.037808045744895935, 0.040404725819826126, -0.0497107096016407, -0.016915256157517433, -0.03849482908844948, -0.004759579431265593, -0.03497743234038353, 0.004496593959629536, -0.029590068385004997, -0.01068258099257946, -0.010045035742223263, -0.06631908565759659, -0.002981453202664852, -0.01480813231319189, -0.01082424446940422, -0.03443845734000206, 0.0026105509605258703, -0.004970721434801817, 0.024573709815740585, 0.010603870265185833, -0.01022928487509489, -0.007553806062787771, -0.04482097178697586, -0.07822725176811218, -0.030190104618668556, -0.0073877256363630295, -0.009777910076081753, -0.06675262004137039, 0.03110184334218502, -0.03327491879463196, 0.016359196975827217, 0.009233091957867146, 0.008795026689767838, 0.004834704101085663, -0.03161225467920303, 0.015497442334890366, -0.008425367064774036, -0.010411358438432217, -0.04598100110888481, 0.044153373688459396, 0.04828718304634094, -0.04388793185353279, -0.04919358342885971, -0.061973635107278824, -0.0339212641119957, -0.006257985718548298, -0.02212434820830822, 0.01994415558874607, -0.03832682594656944, -0.012095382437109947, -0.006738306488841772, -0.0180948656052351, 0.022972840815782547, -0.008435639552772045, 0.04215692728757858, 0.018902769312262535, -0.010650091804564, -0.006926089059561491, 0.011066115461289883, 0.017571043223142624, 0.042656056582927704, -0.028206558898091316, 0.06303468346595764, -0.04800821840763092, 0.04456411302089691, -0.014784653671085835, -0.06705264747142792, -0.023058585822582245, -0.002719481475651264, 0.002634058939293027, -0.027548758313059807, -0.015139920637011528, -0.012918551452457905, 0.02116679586470127, 0.025304490700364113, -0.021405428647994995, 0.07057318836450577, 0.019980421289801598, 0.004829304292798042, 0.012715441174805164, -0.03177427873015404, 0.00101122644264251, -0.00015973873087204993, 0.002238442189991474, 0.013673226349055767, -0.033824674785137177, 0.0029419278725981712, 0.009464764967560768, 0.005528403911739588, 0.05898673087358475, 0.06369338929653168, -0.029115065932273865, 0.02492585778236389, -0.04570477455854416, -0.07688117772340775, 0.03661775961518288, 0.00998783204704523, 0.024672796949744225, -0.0335090309381485, 0.009936070069670677, -0.023204999044537544, 0.024456825107336044, 0.02677011303603649, -0.01358106080442667, 0.02089107036590576, -0.003097439417615533, 0.0243078526109457, -0.01801552250981331, -0.00037837453419342637, -0.015058983117341995, 0.0234878808259964, -0.024016937240958214, 0.0404188446700573, -0.01637943834066391, 0.05959285795688629, -0.036159683018922806, 0.04305839538574219, -0.0017404702957719564, 0.06165065988898277, -0.010894997045397758, 0.03883334994316101, 0.013074462302029133, -0.005488106980919838, 0.058963146060705185, 0.015096589922904968, -0.007369881495833397, 0.021149665117263794, 0.061663299798965454, 0.0476352758705616, -0.02504250966012478, -0.05743976682424545, 0.007220827974379063, 0.049342598766088486, 0.0663803294301033, -0.008129664696753025, 0.08309899270534515, 0.02810203842818737, 0.03313576057553291, -0.021621033549308777, -0.01599748618900776, 0.04393840581178665, -0.002071077236905694, 0.03696657717227936, -0.043142300099134445, -0.022231893613934517, 0.016357095912098885, -0.03980589658021927, 0.04310891032218933, -0.02014106698334217, 0.0005375284818001091, 0.014652069658041, -0.029675444588065147, -0.008614045567810535, -0.016047725453972816, 0.044268544763326645, -0.05157333239912987, -0.011300509795546532, 0.022326970472931862, -0.0714004710316658, 0.02365782856941223, -0.004694752395153046, -0.04695948585867882, 0.04445917159318924, 0.030858788639307022, 0.006795163732022047, 0.011119863949716091, -0.04818590357899666, -0.03727281838655472, -0.010581225156784058, 0.006973150186240673, 0.003957729320973158, -0.04173149913549423, 0.05116283893585205, 0.03205942362546921, -0.022236812859773636, -0.030942976474761963, -0.022259676828980446, 0.04036590829491615, 0.01141298282891512, 0.0052493540570139885, 0.048560548573732376, -0.048949066549539566, 0.003914998844265938, -0.055484749376773834, 0.004551547579467297, -0.006645031273365021, 0.00023140238772612065, -0.019933784380555153, -0.018166400492191315, -0.03465445339679718, 0.015793126076459885, 0.007127311080694199, -0.08092296868562698, -0.04204533249139786, -0.02593957632780075, -0.055388398468494415, -0.034915726631879807, -0.050472766160964966, -0.005312814377248287, 0.0070769949816167355, -0.007955696433782578, -0.012601685710251331, -0.032991502434015274, -0.008390793576836586, 0.037540558725595474, -0.026370534673333168, 0.010085215792059898, 0.0002750232524704188, -0.016082508489489555, -0.08552461862564087, 0.04094727337360382, 0.09046809375286102, 0.04425903409719467, 0.04146748408675194, 0.05901234969496727, -0.07090631872415543, -0.019221559166908264, -0.007786410860717297, 0.013213169761002064, 0.00874100998044014, 0.014685645699501038, 0.024645008146762848, 0.017443466931581497, -0.0006948546506464481, 0.04098224639892578, 0.05437403544783592, -0.09191440045833588, -0.01905703917145729, -0.021088633686304092, 0.006148795131593943, 0.05948180332779884, 0.012521651573479176, 0.0681287869811058, 0.05312776193022728, -0.010621381923556328, 0.03283551335334778, -0.0025589766446501017, -0.04756965488195419, -0.03356318920850754, -0.08179474622011185, 0.011404169723391533, 0.01559069100767374, -0.023443080484867096, -0.025703027844429016, 0.002416714560240507 ]
<p>Based on the responses from the question <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/28086/how-to-draw-a-side-by-side-plot-mentioned-in-graphical-display-as-an-aid-to-ana">How to draw a side-by-side plot mentioned in &quot;Graphical Display as an Aid to Analysis&quot;</a>, I am considering implementing the function myself. The problem is that I don't know how to utilize the result of <code>aov()</code> function. I have to see how many factors there are, the names of factors, what are their main effects and interaction effects, etc. I can get residuals from <code>aov(y~x)$residuals</code>. I consulted the documentation for <code>aov()</code>, but I still have no clue how to do this. There must be some other way much complex than something like <code>t.test(x,y)$p.value</code>.</p> <p>Would you help me?</p>
g41740
[ -0.03194865211844444, 0.02675529010593891, -0.011528844013810158, -0.09178461134433746, -0.04587298259139061, -0.04261018708348274, 0.05535542592406273, -0.040312040597200394, -0.02679794281721115, 0.007754674647003412, 0.020022926852107048, 0.03832148388028145, 0.07187063992023468, -0.004753182176500559, 0.012618836015462875, 0.00943914707750082, -0.012844519689679146, -0.0052872090600430965, 0.028299910947680473, 0.005723700858652592, 0.020148348063230515, -0.013917431235313416, 0.04255613312125206, -0.02107050269842148, 0.017332570627331734, -0.02804810181260109, -0.029030224308371544, 0.08820496499538422, -0.08224983513355255, 0.046071141958236694, -0.031401608139276505, 0.001110532903112471, 0.011287858709692955, -0.01594722829759121, -0.010433344170451164, 0.009343866258859634, -0.014199765399098396, 0.04755503311753273, -0.0029336288571357727, -0.0012492919340729713, -0.10937787592411041, 0.046557117253541946, 0.021963737905025482, 0.032864805310964584, -0.025260863825678825, -0.003707924857735634, -0.056955721229314804, 0.0008051043841987848, -0.0048070945776999, -0.0002001374086830765, -0.0042313942685723305, 0.03519878163933754, 0.03628239780664444, -0.018655216321349144, -0.016918372362852097, -0.024541418999433517, 0.00042171546374447644, 0.035757485777139664, 0.07120828330516815, -0.021036548539996147, 0.0069510661996901035, 0.08536958694458008, 0.001739789848215878, -0.026898633688688278, 0.04579047113656998, 0.005052138119935989, -0.03299687057733536, -0.01262503769248724, -0.06720875948667526, -0.014421149156987667, -0.013622666709125042, -0.02200179547071457, -0.007209904957562685, 0.0025231176987290382, -0.06942048668861389, 0.010753191076219082, 0.002206954173743725, 0.013110656291246414, -0.05297308787703514, 0.1310441941022873, 0.02228173427283764, -0.08527794480323792, -0.011184757575392723, 0.023589463904500008, 0.059983689337968826, -0.049705710262060165, 0.023622410371899605, -0.06683794409036636, -0.013134738430380821, -0.023941295221447945, -0.006986364256590605, 0.04370742663741112, 0.0250223558396101, 0.06052697077393532, -0.005397153552621603, -0.03252403438091278, -0.06425517797470093, 0.029657747596502304, -0.026473823934793472, 0.03045164793729782, 0.00030931999208405614, 0.01269579865038395, -0.005499138496816158, -0.039350904524326324, -0.05508362501859665, -0.00732542434707284, 0.0729612484574318, 0.05028735101222992, -0.05864435434341431, -0.03662652149796486, -0.04776269942522049, -0.023041807115077972, -0.07082992047071457, -0.005414269864559174, -0.014395725913345814, -0.10845021903514862, 0.023737473413348198, -0.003363021183758974, -0.04559098929166794, -0.026105687022209167, -0.009799075312912464, 0.011724608950316906, 0.065789133310318, 0.016109557822346687, 0.014052021317183971, -0.015935532748699188, 0.0058418158441782, 0.07490189373493195, 0.05818157270550728, -0.03254792094230652, 0.02673777937889099, -0.020015520974993706, -0.0027575765270739794, 0.022802479565143585, 0.008025199174880981, 0.041964516043663025, -0.04207083210349083, 0.04273458570241928, -0.05035486817359924, 0.004278550390154123, -0.03301694616675377, -0.0014786528190597892, -0.04017678648233414, -0.00211540050804615, 0.03774964064359665, -0.0077173165045678616, 0.01393619179725647, 0.05011440068483353, -0.0016468827379867435, -0.05905073508620262, -0.014599615707993507, 0.02839760109782219, -0.042636387050151825, -0.017239689826965332, 0.037429701536893845, -0.045115843415260315, 0.002028473187237978, -0.021191593259572983, -0.05928434431552887, 0.025460606440901756, 0.03544528782367706, 0.02465660311281681, 0.05396396666765213, -0.0011058012023568153, -0.0003728692536242306, -0.055000532418489456, 0.013989856466650963, -0.04449508711695671, 0.01190541498363018, -0.014195269905030727, 0.017806820571422577, 0.024906670674681664, 0.0013495866442099214, -0.07553023099899292, 0.04251816123723984, 0.03887013718485832, 0.0182405523955822, 0.022013986483216286, 0.08288007229566574, 0.030036522075533867, 0.019797135144472122, 0.020852534100413322, -0.01935635879635811, 0.011947927065193653, -0.019682737067341805, -0.05788009241223335, -0.021802829578518867, 0.046739254146814346, -0.07865823805332184, 0.0005609663785435259, -0.03730245307087898, -0.0022343930322676897, -0.04299941286444664, 0.021060163155198097, -0.034566354006528854, -0.030550697818398476, 0.010141215287148952, -0.01925617642700672, -0.006692914757877588, -0.006430069450289011, -0.06391961127519608, 0.020424338057637215, 0.04471798613667488, 0.06961444020271301, -0.0366210900247097, 0.005775026511400938, -0.022320320829749107, -0.027711085975170135, 0.005572092719376087, -0.02098168060183525, 0.04020724073052406, 0.01603183150291443, 0.060514677315950394, 0.034496910870075226, -0.026190076023340225, -0.012042227201163769, -0.02045329473912716, -0.029161173850297928, -0.04672661051154137, 0.04061124473810196, 0.0013991731684654951, 0.0031099061015993357, -0.02880549430847168, 0.05069436505436897, -0.018512362614274025, -0.015360486693680286, 0.026465335860848427, 0.024014294147491455, 0.020113706588745117, 0.010700193233788013, -0.03719853609800339, 0.01048095989972353, 0.036642998456954956, -0.01442203763872385, -0.009210201911628246, -0.03836644068360329, -0.055324114859104156, 0.0464952252805233, -0.012157321907579899, 0.03202098608016968, 0.04557346552610397, 0.016468988731503487, 0.046994324773550034, 0.060803186148405075, 0.07860712707042694, 0.025068292394280434, 0.04748613014817238, -0.010208480060100555, 0.005953921936452389, 0.058033231645822525, -0.03704993426799774, 0.06502999365329742, -0.004927827510982752, 0.03042205236852169, -0.011812372133135796, -0.029477408155798912, -0.04453575983643532, 0.03400978818535805, 0.05337683483958244, -0.00364520400762558, -0.06360070407390594, 0.0553695447742939, 0.04078793153166771, 0.005204916000366211, -0.015783773735165596, 0.01713034324347973, -0.00983249582350254, -0.00736128818243742, -0.006370069459080696, -0.028222018852829933, -0.07391250133514404, -0.013066965155303478, -0.0005341218784451485, 0.02062379941344261, 0.009123443625867367, 0.03442985564470291, 0.041505806148052216, 0.00650132168084383, -0.013393094763159752, -0.019681889563798904, 0.04515386372804642, 0.031889282166957855, 0.02026432380080223, 0.04352862387895584, 0.03014623560011387, 0.0529714897274971, 0.06542467325925827, 0.02448621764779091, -0.03800032287836075, -0.02168864756822586, -0.026818379759788513, 0.022820420563220978, -0.003523248480632901, -0.04620452597737312, -0.04279455542564392, -0.0540442019701004, -0.0026932437904179096, -0.0414741113781929, 0.0008415719494223595, -0.009018922224640846, -0.028541600331664085, -0.01593337021768093, 0.04586675390601158, 0.015428386628627777, 0.03374921903014183, -0.09185042977333069, -0.08334331214427948, -0.0212152898311615, 0.027016032487154007, -0.004613620229065418, 0.01295503694564104, -0.016935789957642555, -0.04720408469438553, -0.08595110476016998, -0.030003635212779045, -0.03365536034107208, 0.027813808992505074, -0.015478620305657387, 0.006223462056368589, 0.005460952874273062, 0.01972070336341858, -0.01293977815657854, 0.053977206349372864, 0.029603170230984688, -0.03785005956888199, -0.011056404560804367, 0.014193437062203884, 0.0006975752185098827, -0.0003096424334216863, 0.010916908271610737, 0.03886885568499565, 0.04147300124168396, 0.01283674594014883, 0.01640205644071102, 0.02854454517364502, 0.03057635761797428, -0.010275065898895264, -0.0143002113327384, -0.043965596705675125, 0.016535047441720963, 0.02942555397748947, -0.06673513352870941, -0.012723890133202076, -0.006547227036207914, -0.023547139018774033, -0.04326166585087776, 0.031918447464704514, 0.02626851573586464, 0.05335758253931999, -0.04768950864672661, -0.010930507443845272, -0.0638146623969078, 0.0036667990498244762, -0.0251197200268507, 0.07335755228996277, -0.009033501148223877, 0.029986681416630745, -0.07203406095504761, -0.024670472368597984, 0.021704455837607384, 0.0126627953723073, -0.03068174608051777, -0.008952765725553036, 0.018681636080145836, 0.014069048687815666, 0.0227965135127306, 0.0046117790043354034, 0.10270146280527115, -0.009514447301626205, -0.014650546945631504, 0.06341124325990677, -0.012917770072817802, 0.015808289870619774, -0.005275121424347162, -0.06310470402240753, -0.0534001924097538, 0.0071991258300840855, 0.014637179672718048, 0.04715263471007347, 0.07067356258630753, 0.04799463227391243, 0.01264773216098547, -0.02288834936916828, 0.007240979000926018, 0.004899508785456419, 0.004417289514094591, -0.02390911430120468, -0.011892092414200306, 0.0789451152086258, -0.02156611531972885, -0.03182478994131088, -0.009274930693209171, -0.013805316761136055, -0.008947977796196938, 0.019610628485679626, -0.03330117091536522, 0.013502238318324089, 0.02894291654229164, -0.02705276571214199, 0.021997207775712013, -0.030227119103074074, 0.012768623419106007, 0.04360656067728996, -0.0067189037799835205, 0.0074086980894207954, -0.0025272199418395758, -0.0011715812142938375, -0.06973950564861298, 0.015153835527598858, -0.03728124126791954, -0.008258705958724022, -0.0015679714269936085, 0.04845220968127251, -0.04229285195469856, 0.022685136646032333, 0.03840569779276848, 0.04240606352686882, 0.016448374837636948, -0.05642254278063774, -0.04607640951871872, -0.0022276395466178656, 0.0454520545899868, -0.005435111466795206, -0.026693305000662804, 0.0007191387703642249, -0.021456506103277206, -0.02480337582528591, -0.015227632597088814, 0.023500211536884308, -0.0003614580782596022, -0.02211557701230049, 0.08275410532951355, -0.023073097690939903, -0.0041026887483894825, -0.012263583019375801, 0.03651457652449608, -0.03040478751063347, 0.03813748434185982, 0.001280077500268817, -0.030575910583138466, -0.021629512310028076, -0.036442115902900696, -0.010146538726985455, -0.0004946584813296795, -0.027603838592767715, 0.08565908670425415, -0.020044125616550446, 0.002707317704334855, -0.016029419377446175, -0.010745625011622906, -0.03536507859826088, -0.0032827372197061777, -0.0145916398614645, -0.03360920771956444, 0.012374097481369972, 0.01054495107382536, 0.05639027804136276, -0.010438515804708004, 0.005180737003684044, 0.0220603346824646, -0.013835743069648743, -0.016163760796189308, -0.039971258491277695, -0.060320720076560974, -0.002201816998422146, -0.015102577395737171, -0.026272306218743324, 0.009585775434970856, 0.02467331290245056, -0.021390918642282486, -0.03789546713232994, -0.027077363803982735, 0.06439942866563797, -0.04730713739991188, -0.0149628184735775, -0.033882927149534225, 0.03830026090145111, 0.028639979660511017, 0.037750083953142166, 0.07578207552433014, -0.037620916962623596, -0.03137185424566269, 0.014189078472554684, 0.025112634524703026, 0.00245317118242383, -0.059608157724142075, -0.05854083225131035, -0.04327593743801117, 0.02898448146879673, 0.008850259706377983, -0.011904308572411537, 0.005704146344214678, 0.014574836939573288, -0.026917966082692146, -0.021471915766596794, -0.04218311980366707, 0.0326785147190094, -0.007028457708656788, 0.04828118905425072, -0.03236579895019531, 0.025423957034945488, 0.04669952020049095, -0.033324822783470154, -0.00436242762953043, 0.010472199879586697, -0.014739364385604858, 0.03099433332681656, -0.06024762988090515, -0.018173202872276306, 0.05551513284444809, -0.04409885033965111, 0.001058516907505691, 0.008338961750268936, -0.030632900074124336, -0.02468653954565525, 0.03015005961060524, 0.015607794746756554, 0.0029031159356236458, -0.08465467393398285, -0.0005293290596455336, 0.05327136814594269, 0.004414580762386322, -0.0635201632976532, -0.01168008055537939, 0.02378334477543831, -0.005226636305451393, 0.008822331205010414, -0.08370344340801239, 0.04478809982538223, -0.0019596880301833153, -0.05909952148795128, 0.022293420508503914, -0.07024635374546051, -0.015611887909471989, -0.047099336981773376, -0.05540657043457031, 0.0014860591618344188, -0.05962071567773819, 0.02063579671084881, -0.019960055127739906, 0.009565265849232674, 0.07987344264984131, -0.0218378733843565, 0.029183991253376007, -0.024702399969100952, -0.0317409411072731, 0.016321666538715363, 0.004688276443630457, 0.026392243802547455, 0.021193968132138252, 0.0013505269307643175, 0.03535159304738045, -0.009618652984499931, -0.013268010690808296, -0.004246596712619066, -0.0180752445012331, -0.011891284957528114, -0.02814667858183384, 0.044173695147037506, 0.004811540711671114, 0.011783660389482975, 0.015222742222249508, 0.02108290046453476, 0.00224519451148808, -0.011498494073748589, 0.023033902049064636, 0.03573911637067795, 0.02559230849146843, 0.030914798378944397, 0.034554217010736465, 0.0341058112680912, -0.09528420120477676, -0.00643954100087285, -0.004869244992733002, 0.00505133718252182, 0.06968533992767334, -0.02647954411804676, 0.0364963673055172, -0.0014089751057326794, 0.034591153264045715, 0.00874654296785593, -0.04843379184603691, -0.03366049751639366, -0.02542763203382492, -0.0344686284661293, 0.020025070756673813, -0.03858558088541031, -0.03813458979129791, -0.026332687586545944, 0.0010103832464665174, -0.04627585783600807, 0.020378567278385162, 0.012155398726463318, -0.008503424003720284, 0.019419368356466293, -0.01524786651134491, 0.013066715560853481, 0.09459313750267029, 0.025403887033462524, 0.016685064882040024, -0.017221936956048012, 0.02448134496808052, 0.025809084996581078, -0.07533519715070724, 0.02704405039548874, 0.02071242965757847, 0.01018959004431963, -0.004620986059308052, -0.006527059245854616, -0.08407075703144073, -0.06274823844432831, 0.014841380529105663, 0.04276096820831299, 0.047432318329811096, 0.07091457396745682, -0.018008820712566376, -0.011304025538265705, -0.006369035225361586, -0.0228290818631649, -0.019019242376089096, 0.02802278660237789, -0.0007001085323281586, 0.011045635677874088, 0.015353946946561337, 0.03973010182380676, 0.0851520225405693, -0.055977120995521545, 0.0193914957344532, 0.04027286171913147, -0.02485908381640911, -0.021971505135297775, 0.04244449362158775, -0.02314712665975094, -0.03658713400363922, -0.028584890067577362, 0.04998615011572838, -0.037329986691474915, 0.06472335010766983, 0.037734534591436386, 0.08706244081258774, -0.056983575224876404, 0.07191241532564163, -0.01309126801788807, -0.004446230363100767, -0.010115307755768299, -0.07803496718406677, 0.016913026571273804, 0.048720285296440125, -0.09563802182674408, 0.02195839397609234, 0.061709899455308914, 0.02976183034479618, 0.038212381303310394, -0.012575880624353886, 0.03294822946190834, 0.05790988355875015, 0.03131590783596039, -0.006274924613535404, 0.02264651097357273, -0.02579207345843315, -0.05205291137099266, -0.046357981860637665, 0.010504109784960747, 0.048937417566776276, -0.01516038365662098, 0.07284243404865265, -0.013208208605647087, 0.04162784293293953, 0.016199743375182152, -0.00217633368447423, -0.027516184374690056, 0.005474904552102089, 0.018675656989216805, 0.04937407001852989, 0.011397047899663448, -0.01547239813953638, -0.004112970549613237, 0.01011622417718172, -0.017967255786061287, -0.029990186914801598, -0.04337456077337265, -0.018870340660214424, 0.0233132466673851, 0.007818873040378094, -0.03915837034583092, -0.04274958744645119, -0.04658617824316025, -0.007319492753595114, -0.016345437616109848, 0.015596763230860233, -0.03064853698015213, -0.022549329325556755, 0.001206963206641376, -0.004168493673205376, 0.024240588769316673, 0.025478558614850044, 0.008971024304628372, 0.01643378846347332, -0.014646013267338276, 0.09479591250419617, 0.07447370886802673, 0.022852659225463867, 0.005679232068359852, -0.03822822868824005, 0.08369303494691849, -0.024278011173009872, -0.010077252052724361, 0.0048214104026556015, -0.00657889898866415, -0.05853363871574402, -0.05255722999572754, 0.03852390497922897, -0.00691776629537344, 0.035157475620508194, -0.005879123695194721, 0.028924906626343727, 0.018140170723199844, -0.029797499999403954, -0.008969075977802277, 0.029874514788389206, -0.06713906675577164, -0.028704386204481125, -0.005628897808492184, 0.011365757323801517, -0.011692609637975693, -0.0068087587133049965, 0.012570621445775032, 0.024834169074892998, 0.008912541903555393, 0.007506454363465309, 0.016488438472151756, 0.032783929258584976, -0.01239782851189375, 0.04541213437914848, -0.010087854228913784, -0.06569352000951767, 0.042270295321941376, -0.02644471824169159, -0.021251104772090912, -0.0018893697997555137, 0.05124230682849884, -0.033126089721918106, 0.0067167943343520164, -0.01675872504711151, 0.03474966064095497, 0.012796154245734215, -0.001085001160390675, 0.005522219929844141, 0.014412391930818558, -0.027809584513306618, 0.006780687253922224, 0.04408267140388489, -0.02291492186486721, -0.011361783370375633, 0.018932653591036797, 0.03557468205690384, -0.024829421192407608, -0.015085195191204548, 0.07614083588123322, -0.011035412549972534, 0.010666046291589737, -0.014598318375647068, -0.09531250596046448, 0.021355364471673965, -0.01549356710165739, -0.00674230745062232, -0.03207675740122795, 0.008214790374040604 ]
<p>Standard deck has 52 cards, 26 Red and 26 Black. A run is a maximum contiguous block of cards, which has the same color.</p> <p>Eg.</p> <ul> <li>(R,B,R,B,...,R,B) has 52 runs.</li> <li>(R,R,R,...,R,B,B,B,...,B) has 2 runs.</li> </ul> <p>What is the expected number of runs in a shuffled deck of cards?</p>
g74019
[ -0.01582713983952999, 0.0744360089302063, -0.01306504849344492, -0.060867734253406525, 0.03172719106078148, -0.0504903569817543, 0.012163503095507622, 0.05201984569430351, 0.024488547816872597, -0.01731378398835659, -0.017196979373693466, 0.034826405346393585, -0.01173518504947424, 0.05755972862243652, 0.04537775740027428, -0.0014574786182492971, 0.0416269488632679, -0.06016924977302551, 0.034727729856967926, -0.04511583596467972, -0.02022676169872284, 0.07188260555267334, 0.0038797257002443075, 0.02219085395336151, -0.005832201801240444, 0.010519633069634438, 0.01605968549847603, -0.02515549398958683, -0.05968605726957321, -0.053458280861377716, 0.07840132713317871, -0.010229871608316898, 0.0373661182820797, -0.016031257808208466, -0.014280271716415882, 0.03323715925216675, 0.027643432840704918, -0.022788885980844498, 0.021074926480650902, -0.007475649006664753, 0.007267501670867205, 0.06861143559217453, 0.028734195977449417, -0.026252903044223785, 0.007498731836676598, -0.004511324223130941, -0.02633078023791313, 0.06580372154712677, 0.017794860526919365, 0.03190038725733757, -0.06883372366428375, 0.022840145975351334, -0.01973816193640232, -0.00023157951363828033, -0.008932248689234257, 0.05277859419584274, -0.050855014473199844, 0.0009629001724533737, -0.02388722635805607, 0.04417964443564415, 0.0628444105386734, -0.07787789404392242, -0.060910914093256, -0.02917773835361004, -0.018498912453651428, 0.004009763710200787, 0.056299202144145966, 0.038374707102775574, 0.05276240035891533, 0.008093970827758312, 0.014464223757386208, -0.07429071515798569, 0.03570500388741493, -0.032468803226947784, -0.035744380205869675, 0.001062908093445003, 0.009898651391267776, 0.0738058015704155, -0.001896967296488583, 0.09823449701070786, -0.03972994163632393, -0.021345561370253563, -0.013329303823411465, 0.007602824363857508, 0.041200973093509674, 0.010142200626432896, 0.02494228444993496, -0.018630409613251686, -0.01683616079390049, 0.07531014829874039, -0.0000198894485947676, 0.021600987762212753, 0.04454223811626434, 0.020719608291983604, -0.02164353057742119, -0.009431685321033001, -0.05212664604187012, 0.024316614493727684, 0.004545844160020351, 0.012613114900887012, 0.017768366262316704, 0.027731606736779213, 0.03193346783518791, -0.09152530133724213, -0.01161867007613182, -0.011852569878101349, 0.0021804720163345337, 0.061546795070171356, -0.037910617887973785, 0.0034647383727133274, -0.023433497175574303, -0.03620276600122452, -0.043734196573495865, -0.04686944931745529, -0.014915230683982372, 0.046971291303634644, -0.005061911419034004, 0.06041752174496651, 0.029956195503473282, 0.007564585190266371, 0.07313109934329987, -0.035307515412569046, -0.018012847751379013, 0.03078020177781582, 0.034283485263586044, -0.03421269357204437, -0.004946868401020765, 0.030291924253106117, 0.025233646854758263, 0.09611805528402328, 0.01189767848700285, -0.038836631923913956, -0.0013981612864881754, -0.0040176245383918285, 0.04740973562002182, -0.023689676076173782, 0.06739205867052078, 0.08079900592565536, 0.014854710549116135, -0.07543482631444931, 0.030917547643184662, 0.022846495732665062, 0.009555856697261333, -0.019572077319025993, -0.03861347958445549, -0.006235418375581503, 0.045212965458631516, -0.01169546414166689, -0.06063549220561981, 0.038317568600177765, -0.05174000933766365, 0.01994457095861435, 0.018190011382102966, 0.01251812931150198, -0.014795537106692791, 0.06591668725013733, -0.004033572971820831, -0.01621847413480282, -0.04383854568004608, 0.02882465533912182, 0.02614486590027809, -0.08691508322954178, 0.007161654066294432, 0.0331416055560112, -0.08400479704141617, -0.02446720190346241, 0.030607372522354126, -0.012498627416789532, 0.021351978182792664, 0.030201196670532227, -0.017968470230698586, 0.04323286563158035, -0.03094790317118168, 0.053627073764801025, 0.025442255660891533, 0.0176547858864069, 0.11636081337928772, 0.0163168553262949, -0.011538584716618061, 0.024274300783872604, 0.004155040252953768, -0.05653797835111618, 0.019170626997947693, 0.008063008077442646, 0.026738930493593216, -0.07362199574708939, -0.012463475577533245, -0.041210174560546875, -0.03049437887966633, -0.0030419500544667244, -0.032440707087516785, 0.02747308276593685, -0.013072281144559383, -0.012074540369212627, -0.022317519411444664, 0.020644409582018852, -0.036697711795568466, 0.019071530550718307, 0.002761022886261344, 0.005165427457541227, 0.032562386244535446, -0.0047586397267878056, 0.005719429813325405, -0.002661915263161063, -0.050553083419799805, 0.008007102645933628, -0.03745618835091591, 0.01793692633509636, -0.008696249686181545, -0.000864887610077858, 0.0017646467313170433, -0.0034261085093021393, -0.013807971961796284, 0.057586364448070526, 0.04427254945039749, 0.012061167508363724, 0.048679277300834656, -0.0034953926224261522, -0.029412198811769485, 0.02900340035557747, 0.042096976190805435, -0.010630834847688675, -0.0316087082028389, -0.038536060601472855, 0.007258587516844273, 0.02316603623330593, 0.03043060190975666, 0.03878065571188927, 0.031218519434332848, -0.006099484395235777, -0.01872064173221588, -0.007789724040776491, 0.026991786435246468, -0.04778623208403587, -0.06133570522069931, 0.014551598578691483, -0.005101000424474478, 0.0069938646629452705, 0.060011737048625946, 0.013719750568270683, 0.0738188847899437, 0.0536554791033268, -0.06191212683916092, 0.012254910543560982, -0.028585193678736687, 0.0008306668023578823, 0.022439125925302505, -0.004708030726760626, -0.04925314709544182, 0.08192072063684464, -0.05166101083159447, -0.01585947722196579, 0.05585603043437004, 0.022512396797537804, -0.03220643103122711, 0.0020597472321242094, -0.06883208453655243, -0.015854105353355408, -0.06541205942630768, -0.043579887598752975, 0.015035551972687244, 0.03765800967812538, 0.04355859383940697, 0.04276552051305771, -0.013605357147753239, 0.0035144733265042305, -0.009743960574269295, -0.02508818358182907, -0.005258369725197554, 0.023755144327878952, 0.011652435176074505, -0.04808243364095688, 0.02505776286125183, -0.0021337501239031553, -0.0013777556596323848, -0.06498812139034271, -0.0038226586766541004, -0.04302874580025673, -0.015104946680366993, 0.036046359688043594, 0.025747928768396378, -0.04780563712120056, 0.0029563400894403458, 0.07158796489238739, -0.021982790902256966, -0.05541619285941124, -0.03652454540133476, -0.05317679047584534, -0.01113102212548256, 0.07582706212997437, -0.08207686245441437, 0.038096509873867035, 0.04383211210370064, 0.024266613647341728, 0.013263760134577751, 0.006617658771574497, -0.022743046283721924, -0.0049520498141646385, -0.004495804198086262, 0.02864868938922882, -0.043555475771427155, 0.008863745257258415, -0.03911855071783066, -0.03749450668692589, -0.030641473829746246, 0.012525059282779694, -0.003523570252582431, -0.017552804201841354, -0.02510877326130867, -0.033218204975128174, 0.022710058838129044, 0.006738760974258184, 0.03966049477458, -0.03459123149514198, -0.04224986582994461, -0.02292311191558838, 0.06282581388950348, 0.04029040411114693, -0.023229528218507767, -0.0338369645178318, 0.004166982136666775, -0.05533731356263161, 0.0334913544356823, -0.03462843969464302, 0.0058349985629320145, -0.020184043794870377, -0.025478698313236237, 0.08940814435482025, -0.02582431770861149, 0.010708870366215706, -0.03673997148871422, 0.03446656093001366, -0.03653499484062195, 0.043239858001470566, -0.018739109858870506, 0.005044493358582258, -0.01625765860080719, -0.054566048085689545, 0.04788585007190704, 0.004911025520414114, -0.03579063341021538, -0.029135296121239662, -0.04129953309893608, -0.02810738980770111, 0.03138837590813637, 0.007454853504896164, 0.02467857487499714, 0.0015132559929043055, 0.006896021775901318, 0.033582452684640884, 0.00742477597668767, -0.06381742656230927, -0.01537367980927229, 0.007293468341231346, 0.027494750916957855, 0.00607293751090765, -0.06134732812643051, 0.04926517978310585, 0.0713055357336998, 0.012428908608853817, 0.0023120539262890816, -0.013605406507849693, -0.010476243682205677, -0.0611940398812294, 0.019189512357115746, 0.020224448293447495, 0.009955774992704391, 0.027323227375745773, 0.028306985273957253, -0.018932605162262917, 0.007525239139795303, -0.0748324766755104, 0.03800269216299057, -0.046630822122097015, 0.051567211747169495, 0.004629075061529875, 0.015763847157359123, 0.016142023727297783, -0.0007757846615277231, 0.11171863228082657, 0.05532126873731613, 0.019955972209572792, -0.005890843458473682, -0.04491967707872391, -0.019223665818572044, -0.03702254965901375, 0.011350225657224655, -0.021132417023181915, -0.0007120527443476021, -0.021679919213056564, -0.05711352452635765, -0.002450586063787341, -0.03815487027168274, 0.001243399572558701, -0.01879272051155567, -0.04241642728447914, 0.032493799924850464, 0.02672838792204857, -0.0344860665500164, 0.06720855832099915, 0.03262403607368469, -0.019583649933338165, 0.00846816599369049, 0.012233450077474117, -0.016370316967368126, -0.005530781578272581, -0.017710929736495018, 0.035386424511671066, 0.06143943592905998, 0.03349967300891876, -0.022248711436986923, -0.006195339374244213, -0.07524920254945755, -0.04061376303434372, 0.001702871872112155, -0.0025019787717610598, 0.07203651964664459, 0.005451282951980829, -0.06699641793966293, 0.053061068058013916, 0.01431345660239458, -0.003960848320275545, -0.022000601515173912, -0.018067002296447754, 0.003870275802910328, -0.033964842557907104, 0.01739594340324402, 0.030746908858418465, -0.018292684108018875, -0.00950623769313097, 0.010642832145094872, 0.007503482047468424, -0.05924294516444206, 0.0322163924574852, -0.03957223519682884, -0.029717199504375458, -0.022908160462975502, 0.010958515107631683, 0.010969075374305248, 0.044909004122018814, -0.018536685034632683, -0.0306572075933218, -0.00884450227022171, 0.02438708394765854, 0.02936614118516445, 0.040695663541555405, -0.04302394390106201, -0.07726078480482101, -0.02774694375693798, -0.014451686292886734, 0.06232214346528053, -0.016332078725099564, -0.03644496947526932, -0.005903759505599737, -0.010503126308321953, 0.0001826459774747491, -0.01989138126373291, 0.04759606346487999, 0.01811554841697216, -0.005075913388282061, 0.019352275878190994, -0.007314721122384071, -0.017269453033804893, -0.028808502480387688, -0.024486161768436432, 0.007565842475742102, 0.0033000728581100702, 0.039948828518390656, -0.0031641453970223665, 0.049434807151556015, 0.03772793337702751, -0.028594445437192917, 0.03666895255446434, -0.02632072940468788, -0.011982251890003681, 0.02038852497935295, -0.013147865422070026, 0.041318830102682114, -0.04727374017238617, -0.03827398270368576, -0.03160669282078743, -0.05755564197897911, -0.018024690449237823, -0.022200731560587883, 0.0013264643494039774, 0.006349046714603901, 0.01232215203344822, -0.07173113524913788, 0.04272831976413727, 0.06556030362844467, -0.034008271992206573, 0.00792914628982544, 0.02670533023774624, 0.04932202771306038, 0.014961253851652145, -0.03933533653616905, 0.029207875952124596, -0.023883415386080742, -0.007362760603427887, 0.02338721975684166, -0.0038531713653355837, 0.006361094303429127, 0.014417200349271297, -0.07322535663843155, -0.005124377086758614, -0.016862038522958755, -0.028145011514425278, -0.03937472775578499, -0.004740271717309952, -0.000650613394100219, -0.03070741891860962, -0.018140140920877457, 0.06553464382886887, -0.0035688045900315046, 0.015686383470892906, 0.021006686612963676, 0.009523252956569195, -0.03811917081475258, 0.031037230044603348, 0.07525885850191116, -0.01135540846735239, -0.030270544812083244, 0.04180780053138733, -0.011851389892399311, -0.05957796797156334, -0.02236771769821644, -0.022746942937374115, 0.02044231817126274, -0.04876168444752693, 0.03193812072277069, 0.03956006094813347, 0.027759719640016556, -0.016696348786354065, -0.027401555329561234, -0.02155815251171589, -0.0039161136373877525, 0.02255408465862274, -0.01034412533044815, -0.018230361863970757, 0.03696385398507118, -0.01902949810028076, 0.005512013100087643, -0.033448588103055954, 0.01945336163043976, -0.012186439707875252, -0.03566257283091545, -0.04904394969344139, -0.04645026847720146, 0.028513183817267418, -0.050988707691431046, -0.027540728449821472, 0.023774515837430954, 0.010283625684678555, -0.002492358908057213, 0.03621474280953407, -0.008023854345083237, -0.0049918657168745995, 0.005451011937111616, 0.02540963515639305, 0.07544684410095215, 0.010603973641991615, -0.042996130883693695, -0.01959192380309105, 0.004164005164057016, 0.018160920590162277, -0.065567247569561, -0.012782653793692589, 0.00043264066334813833, 0.022501494735479355, 0.01782480999827385, 0.04119208827614784, -0.04806434363126755, 0.0107585359364748, 0.0519602969288826, 0.040421657264232635, 0.03579861298203468, -0.01621929742395878, -0.012014861218631268, 0.01615465246140957, 0.001516518066637218, -0.04929463937878609, 0.006886117625981569, -0.04728587716817856, 0.02304457500576973, -0.013060645200312138, 0.03472134470939636, 0.010987630113959312, -0.002400763798505068, 0.011558199301362038, 0.0029730971436947584, 0.0198881346732378, 0.027277428656816483, -0.028888991102576256, 0.03709368035197258, 0.0160528477281332, 0.061872635036706924, -0.038693077862262726, -0.017845796421170235, 0.048159159719944, -0.025408919900655746, 0.015172619372606277, 0.05973978713154793, 0.009601803496479988, -0.021204406395554543, -0.025773078203201294, -0.034848425537347794, -0.0823737308382988, -0.029634755104780197, -0.018039913848042488, 0.059434179216623306, 0.02958432212471962, -0.018301833420991898, 0.03356156498193741, 0.013089709915220737, -0.08494745939970016, -0.027117835357785225, -0.0014387639239430428, -0.007414754945784807, 0.034221429377794266, -0.030772212892770767, 0.016210664063692093, -0.04889237508177757, -0.05910396948456764, -0.07942869514226913, -0.005189852323383093, -0.00047749505029059947, 0.0010791326640173793, -0.0276603065431118, 0.1023220345377922, -0.03534877672791481, 0.03542305529117584, -0.04756499081850052, -0.02914026379585266, 0.016046583652496338, 0.03861495479941368, -0.04308415576815605, -0.15167932212352753, 0.05676744133234024, 0.007883626967668533, 0.05301776900887489, -0.005496477708220482, 0.025657767429947853, -0.016801392659544945, 0.04744147136807442, 0.03558693826198578, 0.019354257732629776, 0.047311268746852875, 0.04294260963797569, -0.013786504976451397, -0.05487827956676483, 0.004702528472989798, 0.07310444116592407, -0.024539442732930183, -0.024848928675055504, -0.07591388374567032, 0.009311642497777939, 0.033990778028964996, -0.0199163518846035, -0.01633308455348015, -0.010514937341213226, 0.007024899125099182, -0.021656453609466553, -0.04632960259914398, -0.014964737929403782, 0.0017403822857886553, -0.059894636273384094, 0.018662575632333755, -0.0662982240319252, 0.01827826350927353, -0.012880638241767883, -0.008703367784619331, -0.07310909032821655, -0.05828658118844032, 0.005303897429257631, -0.018259376287460327, 0.00023418500495608896, -0.05809001624584198, -0.002843772992491722, -0.011798913590610027, -0.024028554558753967, -0.024949509650468826, 0.06552503257989883, -0.0035216466058045626, 0.005001617595553398, -0.0022932561114430428, 0.03775690868496895, -0.009538599289953709, -0.031858012080192566, 0.04607158899307251, -0.0190487802028656, 0.04163258895277977, 0.034652721136808395, 0.051429301500320435, -0.021525193005800247, 0.009137095883488655, 0.05699855089187622, -0.05980174243450165, -0.02969812974333763, 0.06320861726999283, 0.006917253136634827, -0.026788858696818352, -0.015156924724578857, -0.051066964864730835, 0.02838272787630558, -0.010050619021058083, -0.024108409881591797, 0.016927247866988182, -0.009090490639209747, -0.009558050893247128, -0.08565697818994522, 0.007075103931128979, -0.03673966974020004, -0.007267603650689125, 0.02746555581688881, -0.016614383086562157, 0.025138938799500465, -0.018433434888720512, 0.002510580001398921, 0.011093378998339176, 0.026125723496079445, 0.0021378707606345415, 0.02715066634118557, 0.01170068234205246, 0.01842609979212284, -0.022945355623960495, -0.02273043803870678, 0.0326581634581089, -0.011410939507186413, 0.019083818420767784, 0.013059870339930058, -0.023577872663736343, -0.0711677074432373, -0.024156171828508377, 0.0445864200592041, -0.018122293055057526, 0.006614831741899252, -0.00011568936315597966, 0.06141424551606178, 0.032313890755176544, -0.01446532178670168, -0.030219819396734238, 0.06461019814014435, -0.019381824880838394, 0.03234577551484108, 0.0020380974747240543, 0.03994176909327507, -0.05762799084186554, -0.060932058840990067, -0.0037098522298038006, 0.032680124044418335, 0.015210641548037529, 0.04092288017272949, 0.02662253938615322, 0.05953166261315346, 0.06317467987537384, -0.028015414252877235, 0.02834075316786766, -0.04233351722359657, -0.059192974120378494, -0.010499119758605957, -0.0035369389224797487, 0.02185075357556343, -0.005432283505797386, -0.005474115256220102, -0.013095834292471409, 0.022038999944925308, -0.0006637335172854364, -0.010698468424379826 ]
<p>Following to the recent questions we had <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/1818/how-to-determine-the-sample-size-needed-for-repeated-measurement-anova/1823#1823">here</a>.</p> <p>I was hopping to know if anyone had come across or can share <strong>R code for performing a custom power analysis based on simulation for a linear model?</strong></p> <p>Later I would obviously like to extend it to more complex models, but lm seems to right place to start. Thanks.</p>
g74020
[ -0.0051574488170444965, -0.026897914707660675, -0.002257553394883871, -0.024160832166671753, -0.05650114268064499, -0.06393330544233322, -0.04096633195877075, -0.0004389425157569349, -0.03156342729926109, 0.005032186862081289, 0.008741550147533417, 0.018069401383399963, 0.028844643384218216, 0.016464924439787865, -0.013059361837804317, 0.03105371817946434, 0.07015743106603622, -0.0059374067932367325, 0.024867525324225426, 0.026663774624466896, 0.003171066055074334, -0.05060918629169464, 0.033632684499025345, -0.047403257340192795, -0.01939144730567932, -0.00797616969794035, -0.013694774359464645, 0.06792689114809036, -0.06847357749938965, -0.01917416602373123, -0.03562381863594055, -0.032156553119421005, -0.01056557148694992, -0.030165640637278557, -0.04174834489822388, 0.029237743467092514, 0.006760297808796167, -0.015391556546092033, 0.006132595706731081, 0.0419648177921772, 0.043185096234083176, 0.0008602443267591298, 0.039079077541828156, 0.06149400398135185, -0.02052362449467182, -0.05103294178843498, 0.0020282312761992216, 0.019061334431171417, -0.003222311846911907, 0.03237923979759216, -0.016965754330158234, -0.007836107164621353, 0.051674261689186096, -0.00931693147867918, 0.052224643528461456, 0.055675208568573, -0.04591962695121765, 0.009595673531293869, 0.030263036489486694, 0.027786260470747948, 0.018887575715780258, -0.009161397814750671, -0.05663641542196274, -0.028616763651371002, 0.006359957158565521, 0.026045210659503937, 0.004671370144933462, -0.03930116072297096, -0.039582714438438416, -0.052637502551078796, -0.02082643285393715, -0.0075878240168094635, -0.03021356835961342, -0.03675200790166855, -0.05211944505572319, -0.009042961522936821, 0.0021556890569627285, 0.003047454170882702, 0.0002901799452956766, 0.01356947049498558, -0.03976712003350258, -0.025544846430420876, 0.03680979833006859, 0.014038166031241417, 0.02149675227701664, -0.015182189643383026, -0.0030295036267489195, 0.0388619601726532, 0.06224518641829491, -0.0047757928259670734, 0.03630140796303749, 0.03502838686108589, 0.059791047126054764, 0.023524994030594826, -0.010668603703379631, -0.04198867455124855, -0.08729750663042068, 0.020683653652668, 0.039387047290802, -0.020871572196483612, 0.014325285330414772, 0.04061261937022209, -0.035998810082674026, -0.014937995001673698, -0.043877921998500824, -0.009731309488415718, -0.00896427035331726, -0.005715613253414631, -0.013537784107029438, -0.029190948233008385, -0.04735185578465462, -0.05459083244204521, -0.06023293361067772, 0.015156798996031284, -0.03142606094479561, -0.059667881578207016, 0.08089130371809006, -0.024269619956612587, -0.022899923846125603, 0.032370127737522125, -0.031281713396310806, 0.002758397487923503, 0.0067652445286512375, -0.011424737982451916, -0.08185884356498718, 0.010790353640913963, 0.003990688361227512, 0.001043756608851254, -0.005609297659248114, 0.017313791438937187, 0.040554508566856384, -0.03314470499753952, -0.061340007930994034, 0.022734597325325012, 0.054366834461688995, 0.02866312675178051, -0.0035699261352419853, -0.0001847334497142583, 0.0073459395207464695, 0.015126314014196396, -0.02887541614472866, -0.03878716006875038, 0.03913702070713043, 0.0170427393168211, 0.052386607974767685, 0.01255823951214552, 0.018646985292434692, -0.006547866389155388, -0.006262258626520634, 0.05525076016783714, 0.0237334743142128, 0.06544866412878036, -0.021787503734230995, -0.04487638548016548, 0.004621691536158323, 0.026925258338451385, -0.04519238322973251, -0.011923020705580711, 0.002957046264782548, -0.007574148941785097, 0.022043053060770035, 0.0011926953447982669, 0.0002478435344528407, -0.018334530293941498, 0.003112561535090208, -0.01797383278608322, 0.017781192436814308, -0.04455617070198059, -0.021650563925504684, -0.020716939121484756, -0.004564391449093819, -0.029554782435297966, 0.04832634702324867, -0.03178402781486511, 0.015267386101186275, 0.0053664459846913815, 0.03910012170672417, -0.03459708392620087, 0.06290008127689362, -0.0018765616696327925, 0.01881265826523304, 0.02515218034386635, 0.01650678552687168, -0.02829539217054844, -0.06647910177707672, -0.050502628087997437, -0.0038790388498455286, 0.0100883012637496, -0.011040791869163513, -0.079472616314888, -0.06373458355665207, 0.004983155522495508, -0.02295682206749916, -0.012812233529984951, -0.024241968989372253, 0.004004502668976784, 0.031159769743680954, -0.04056057706475258, -0.03129523992538452, 0.027469174936413765, 0.060233671218156815, -0.013684695586562157, 0.02968117967247963, 0.04739883542060852, -0.009220114909112453, -0.03655243292450905, -0.01639600098133087, -0.041886553168296814, 0.004527677781879902, 0.060026902705430984, 0.02668173611164093, 0.011317622847855091, 0.018959103152155876, 0.06572003662586212, 0.030846087262034416, 0.01080775074660778, -0.007051241118460894, -0.006128794513642788, -0.022275445982813835, 0.042976733297109604, -0.013216027058660984, -0.04455484822392464, -0.0011064953869208694, 0.0414016917347908, -0.005026031285524368, 0.024928884580731392, 0.05535467714071274, 0.04318762198090553, 0.011311615817248821, -0.003329618601128459, -0.027395691722631454, 0.07266784459352493, 0.006012815982103348, -0.015614941716194153, 0.017421642318367958, -0.006575009785592556, -0.04995865747332573, 0.011201569810509682, -0.04779114946722984, -0.008673417381942272, 0.03514743596315384, 0.016149263828992844, 0.01908755861222744, 0.0535183809697628, 0.03695077449083328, 0.0011982708238065243, 0.06964129954576492, -0.03097635507583618, 0.020867493003606796, -0.03396909311413765, -0.041457973420619965, 0.03768821805715561, 0.03541535884141922, 0.011436112225055695, -0.029190802946686745, -0.09964189678430557, 0.02541443705558777, 0.05708795785903931, 0.007498768623918295, 0.002012285403907299, 0.007028167601674795, 0.07000390440225601, -0.00798975769430399, 0.013964295387268066, 0.022425450384616852, 0.0015362296253442764, -0.03888905048370361, -0.04733169078826904, -0.023314200341701508, 0.002115902490913868, 0.004508248995989561, 0.0194097850471735, 0.09896871447563171, 0.023579705506563187, 0.03879887983202934, -0.05014090985059738, 0.0002485086733940989, -0.05391225218772888, 0.07512716948986053, -0.02679949440062046, 0.003664460266008973, -0.06842432171106339, 0.005492095369845629, -0.001329509075731039, 0.018634481355547905, -0.026150397956371307, 0.06457170844078064, -0.0218471921980381, -0.03385454788804054, -0.0019382424652576447, -0.019509026780724525, -0.02091343328356743, -0.04790235310792923, -0.03964652866125107, -0.05394250527024269, 0.01743398979306221, -0.0072168526239693165, -0.046168528497219086, 0.07068657875061035, 0.02835083194077015, 0.029236285015940666, -0.03152111545205116, 0.009073307737708092, 0.03156878799200058, -0.04461928829550743, -0.012255906127393246, -0.030367543920874596, -0.01292269118130207, 0.009742471389472485, 0.0636403039097786, 0.040317602455616, -0.06400159746408463, -0.020743248984217644, 0.028285503387451172, -0.050370316952466965, -0.06491335481405258, -0.031749628484249115, -0.02934798039495945, 0.046017374843358994, 0.0032683638855814934, 0.0637478455901146, -0.0806415006518364, 0.026881201192736626, 0.004561110865324736, -0.00818938110023737, 0.07390124350786209, -0.07920874655246735, 0.02812625654041767, -0.008379636332392693, -0.05210435017943382, 0.045030899345874786, 0.043087877333164215, 0.05271723493933678, 0.028655067086219788, -0.020235225558280945, -0.03863673284649849, -0.02670668065547943, -0.014922400936484337, 0.05153424292802811, 0.007943504489958286, -0.0038195247761905193, -0.05399187281727791, 0.01127712707966566, -0.012717519886791706, 0.011727035976946354, -0.009543956257402897, -0.003343715565279126, -0.0059187463484704494, 0.022386832162737846, -0.032697953283786774, -0.005671164486557245, -0.011810672469437122, 0.042964376509189606, -0.10578876733779907, 0.0510186068713665, 0.009798809885978699, 0.07155881822109222, -0.06297624856233597, 0.01801898144185543, 0.021865326911211014, -0.000026306335712433793, -0.04246271029114723, -0.035947877913713455, 0.04214989021420479, 0.01717304065823555, 0.047867193818092346, 0.0041517289355397224, 0.013920933939516544, 0.012222426012158394, -0.03497828543186188, 0.024757403880357742, 0.05049135908484459, -0.009047848172485828, 0.0024270566646009684, 0.011789444833993912, -0.00803300179541111, 0.03805731609463692, 0.042967528104782104, -0.004562792833894491, 0.048274945467710495, 0.07584661990404129, 0.05075811594724655, 0.015048191882669926, -0.05463966354727745, -0.06664936244487762, -0.0448760949075222, -0.002462359145283699, 0.015331060625612736, -0.007991663180291653, -0.063074491918087, -0.03187313303351402, -0.04769977927207947, -0.09584519267082214, -0.03395787999033928, 0.01397393923252821, -0.04855792224407196, 0.004611975979059935, -0.01926623284816742, -0.009937377646565437, 0.02779790759086609, -0.0701397955417633, 0.0009999058675020933, 0.012887914665043354, 0.045724961906671524, -0.023684468120336533, -0.017462246119976044, 0.05030418559908867, -0.0063844360411167145, -0.0635976791381836, 0.014427551999688148, -0.056129880249500275, 0.026087114587426186, 0.008755217306315899, -0.09951996803283691, 0.02589375339448452, -0.061264537274837494, 0.01982506737112999, -0.0014070654287934303, -0.01412736251950264, 0.0051067243330180645, -0.01837369054555893, -0.006712545640766621, 0.02282421663403511, -0.021042659878730774, 0.04029606282711029, -0.0011882460676133633, 0.0162328090518713, 0.017241179943084717, 0.01086591836065054, -0.0505078062415123, 0.004676021169871092, 0.0021801770199090242, -0.03307908773422241, -0.01963084191083908, 0.02405288629233837, -0.01876392960548401, -0.03707647696137428, 0.020612072199583054, -0.021150825545191765, -0.053708676248788834, -0.03482755646109581, 0.009453133679926395, 0.08574198931455612, -0.035449132323265076, -0.04299408569931984, 0.028359225019812584, 0.0051571764051914215, 0.04211155325174332, -0.011358283460140228, 0.07773514837026596, 0.00030012280330993235, -0.0028104649391025305, -0.0177542082965374, 0.04516959190368652, -0.010852050967514515, -0.011005762033164501, 0.024285370483994484, 0.0259046982973814, 0.05741781368851662, 0.03117017261683941, -0.048691388219594955, 0.0032798447646200657, -0.07833749055862427, -0.030076757073402405, -0.056867815554142, -0.025070112198591232, -0.04187830165028572, 0.005479862913489342, 0.006819601636379957, -0.00711798295378685, -0.007688224781304598, -0.04079122096300125, -0.005020634271204472, 0.04388086870312691, -0.017329640686511993, -0.015337865799665451, 0.02643163502216339, 0.01410584431141615, 0.04942050576210022, 0.01946835406124592, -0.026809798553586006, -0.04602242633700371, 0.005147726275026798, 0.004102310631424189, 0.05080545321106911, 0.012755977921187878, -0.06435173004865646, -0.038620904088020325, -0.02152031846344471, 0.019582366570830345, -0.07461736351251602, 0.06962373852729797, 0.06649911403656006, -0.06613141298294067, 0.013685840182006359, 0.036578912287950516, 0.0674639418721199, -0.02294202335178852, -0.06312160193920135, 0.01578431762754917, 0.019155938178300858, 0.04072662815451622, -0.008910801261663437, -0.036993563175201416, -0.0029090256430208683, 0.036283161491155624, 0.040289439260959625, 0.0008105846936814487, 0.003828188870102167, 0.002326773479580879, -0.002351906383410096, 0.060800861567258835, 0.07737467437982559, 0.02621358260512352, -0.0050520943477749825, -0.00956175196915865, -0.022660089656710625, 0.06207624822854996, -0.030949639156460762, -0.07793045789003372, 0.07739689201116562, -0.05228649079799652, 0.07497760653495789, -0.02179286815226078, 0.026578783988952637, -0.006194517016410828, 0.017520982772111893, -0.04749302938580513, 0.03598102554678917, -0.0461549274623394, -0.015248522162437439, 0.03437555581331253, -0.049138594418764114, -0.00733572244644165, -0.05070149153470993, -0.015964796766638756, -0.011370440013706684, -0.013576348312199116, -0.0019209937890991569, -0.05840056762099266, -0.012786858715116978, 0.059008464217185974, 0.023145511746406555, -0.016203338280320168, -0.018933968618512154, -0.039345208555459976, 0.04257999733090401, 0.004161085467785597, 0.03788759559392929, -0.05341929569840431, -0.016228187829256058, -0.031558651477098465, 0.04487479850649834, 0.03665761649608612, -0.011346939019858837, 0.015353201888501644, 0.00387445162050426, -0.0619468092918396, -0.0001274857495445758, 0.044244203716516495, -0.042141303420066833, -0.00000532136982656084, 0.04957122355699539, -0.0031742616556584835, -0.026623869314789772, -0.0037718757521361113, 0.011620872654020786, -0.0351812019944191, 0.005297412630170584, 0.0031038105953484774, 0.023387692868709564, -0.0015545192873105407, -0.010585385374724865, -0.012633565813302994, 0.0044975862838327885, 0.0014313129941001534, 0.03033837117254734, 0.06680893152952194, 0.04941774159669876, -0.05610501393675804, 0.020451540127396584, 0.022359833121299744, 0.02960611879825592, 0.019852858036756516, 0.015028778463602066, 0.00917779840528965, -0.03997650370001793, 0.025518232956528664, -0.01633390039205551, -0.02119540236890316, -0.02619444951415062, -0.00033531273948028684, -0.02095961943268776, -0.06086864322423935, -0.057924605906009674, 0.004561588633805513, 0.024175534024834633, -0.014962589368224144, 0.028719190508127213, 0.04239699989557266, 0.0008651447715237737, 0.05942476540803909, -0.0013513043522834778, -0.05467528477311134, 0.015884028747677803, -0.029268598183989525, 0.007568818051367998, -0.030959157273173332, -0.008166533894836903, -0.004497302696108818, -0.05027873441576958, -0.0298268124461174, 0.035022471100091934, 0.015258810482919216, -0.012057305313646793, -0.02046092413365841, 0.012217939831316471, -0.010606990195810795, -0.0005454096244648099, 0.02598520740866661, 0.031033096835017204, -0.02825385518372059, -0.016936292871832848, -0.042294807732105255, 0.028604699298739433, 0.06529312580823898, 0.006804316304624081, 0.03610539063811302, 0.030822666361927986, -0.05687575414776802, -0.0036561032757163048, -0.011096716858446598, -0.006078873295336962, 0.08172925561666489, -0.04265952855348587, 0.06201294809579849, -0.016146505251526833, 0.03541870415210724, 0.06698721647262573, 0.031885966658592224, -0.005613469518721104, 0.05133732408285141, -0.02822205424308777, -0.017465027049183846, -0.04078949987888336, 0.0007585133425891399, 0.020811302587389946, 0.07145777344703674, 0.021743128076195717, 0.01710795983672142, 0.06170119717717171, 0.023599931970238686, -0.00857485644519329, -0.05455479770898819, -0.013065306469798088, 0.03260793164372444, -0.014208349399268627, 0.027961384505033493, 0.0628223791718483, -0.0354311503469944, 0.011522913351655006, -0.005945027805864811, 0.01781870797276497, -0.0270596444606781, 0.023145532235503197, -0.0026059451047331095, -0.002417606068775058, 0.011880951933562756, 0.09337181597948074, 0.002388349501416087, 0.0005584777100011706, 0.007249499671161175, -0.03709155321121216, 0.05855212360620499, -0.01956349052488804, -0.012428046204149723, -0.008093640208244324, 0.008847096934914589, -0.01052422821521759, 0.0027508263010531664, 0.0004191754851490259, 0.011399853974580765, -0.027932263910770416, 0.013476881198585033, 0.017557762563228607, 0.0037973904982209206, -0.026157354936003685, 0.018061377108097076, -0.01005510613322258, 0.022205442190170288, -0.0391475111246109, 0.043975163251161575, 0.027983933687210083, 0.01617266982793808, -0.02840087004005909, 0.02899402379989624, -0.03766264766454697, -0.00564994290471077, 0.0639028549194336, 0.09904751181602478, 0.05144599452614784, 0.028168343007564545, -0.018178444355726242, -0.023458071053028107, 0.038208309561014175, -0.04433564841747284, -0.06930255144834518, -0.020717347040772438, 0.0069389957934618, -0.07736168801784515, -0.07801590859889984, 0.019254162907600403, 0.011607633903622627, 0.020276103168725967, -0.02362287975847721, 0.020209189504384995, -0.02280581369996071, -0.0341072753071785, -0.01070571132004261, -0.012757239863276482, -0.02890390157699585, -0.047320056706666946, 0.004214554559439421, 0.05085351690649986, 0.034190595149993896, -0.06136593967676163, -0.046937376260757446, 0.11332352459430695, -0.035916734486818314, 0.007026751060038805, -0.042295414954423904, -0.07744546234607697, -0.0351160429418087, 0.04302879422903061, 0.03892504423856735, 0.013403203338384628, 0.010976558551192284, 0.02244390919804573, 0.019454026594758034, 0.02907363884150982, 0.03375060483813286, -0.023647015914320946, 0.0670357197523117, 0.023052064701914787, 0.04819771274924278, -0.026126805692911148, -0.04658110439777374, 0.038250457495450974, 0.031739525496959686, -0.026472993195056915, -0.049667198210954666, 0.008999302983283997, 0.012026119977235794, 0.005595671944320202, 0.017057474702596664, 0.015882158651947975, 0.029838213697075844, 0.03233840689063072, 0.044061534106731415, -0.02421475388109684, 0.02411634847521782, -0.03254986181855202, -0.040989793837070465, 0.007074733264744282, 0.04476633667945862, -0.07307977229356766, 0.008665110915899277, -0.0034865315537899733 ]
<p>What is the distribution of the following monomial? $$X^a \cdot Y^b$$ where $X$ and $Y$ are normal random variables and $a$ and $b$ are natural numbers.</p> <p>For example, when $X \sim N(0,1)$, $a=2$, and $b=0$ it is a Chi-squared distribution, which has a variance of 2.</p> <p>What if we have $n$ independent variables $X_1, X_2, \dots , X_n$, with $X_i \sim N(0,\sigma^2)$ and some natural numbers $p_1, p_2, \dots,p_n$. What can we say about the variance of the following r.v.?</p> <p>$$X_1^{p_1} \cdot X_2^{p_2} \cdots X_n^{p_n}$$</p>
g74021
[ 0.019516095519065857, 0.020750053226947784, -0.0328703336417675, 0.01232078019529581, 0.028217220678925514, -0.0006529807578772306, -0.014874391257762909, -0.06690225750207901, 0.042539019137620926, 0.003059393959119916, -0.05573665723204613, 0.07399038970470428, -0.023714464157819748, 0.009157398715615273, -0.029430195689201355, -0.03240048140287399, -0.030164578929543495, 0.016480054706335068, 0.0692671462893486, -0.03284718096256256, -0.09274722635746002, -0.03521319106221199, 0.00579740758985281, 0.015372054651379585, 0.0834297314286232, 0.042853232473134995, -0.06331486999988556, 0.07945290952920914, -0.01637907698750496, -0.043352458626031876, -0.04496736451983452, 0.007888980209827423, 0.12184108048677444, 0.00881324615329504, -0.02075289934873581, 0.08164259791374207, 0.0250740647315979, -0.06714725494384766, 0.06260313093662262, -0.0002425902202958241, -0.0618082731962204, 0.0051872143521904945, 0.043326810002326965, 0.014343698509037495, -0.05836076661944389, 0.046864040195941925, -0.010935815051198006, 0.027834147214889526, -0.012339645065367222, -0.04273327440023422, 0.04434690997004509, 0.03989304602146149, 0.06063563749194145, 0.02630569599568844, 0.012389161624014378, -0.044446911662817, -0.016182295978069305, -0.0469885990023613, -0.014336762949824333, 0.0639193132519722, 0.0022654037456959486, 0.012197722680866718, -0.025646530091762543, 0.021641304716467857, 0.06278923153877258, 0.03262859955430031, -0.05161512643098831, 0.014859837479889393, -0.00567465927451849, 0.02753119170665741, 0.01367925014346838, -0.022103823721408844, 0.009617962874472141, 0.0011127422330901027, -0.05415097251534462, -0.0635467916727066, 0.07153335213661194, 0.03430873900651932, -0.026083333417773247, 0.020262664183974266, -0.034533314406871796, 0.020840900018811226, 0.04151533916592598, 0.00495804101228714, 0.035533782094717026, -0.014595693908631802, 0.09294681996107101, -0.03940802067518234, -0.028410015627741814, 0.0690082237124443, 0.041522540152072906, -0.025599809363484383, -0.018568001687526703, 0.037228092551231384, -0.010621108114719391, 0.0032277959398925304, -0.05772395059466362, 0.006127279717475176, -0.01980137825012207, -0.011012732982635498, 0.004985111765563488, 0.019088780507445335, 0.0008625962072983384, -0.05284174904227257, -0.0373905673623085, 0.08282934874296188, 0.04701364412903786, -0.009135771542787552, 0.002995466347783804, 0.038396768271923065, -0.04402806609869003, -0.034668486565351486, -0.06033829599618912, -0.019752055406570435, 0.002325846115127206, -0.018383970484137535, -0.001042800024151802, 0.009930537082254887, 0.005543770268559456, 0.04175688698887825, 0.015434108674526215, 0.028247082605957985, 0.02303779125213623, 0.0468464195728302, -0.001995248021557927, 0.04664631560444832, -0.014344004914164543, 0.030825555324554443, 0.01920441910624504, -0.045592572540044785, 0.012663458473980427, -0.03287887200713158, -0.0012527286307886243, 0.022286739200353622, -0.008874666877090931, 0.0032556361984461546, -0.015001046471297741, 0.04579520225524902, 0.020662102848291397, -0.02542908862233162, -0.016413798555731773, -0.0025982465595006943, 0.03575319051742554, -0.010679577477276325, -0.007887509651482105, -0.006730161141604185, 0.0660625472664833, -0.052881691604852676, -0.02812078408896923, 0.010668273083865643, 0.0005156497936695814, 0.032121676951646805, -0.05993248149752617, -0.03177312761545181, -0.061479341238737106, 0.03858036547899246, -0.018206654116511345, 0.03685983642935753, -0.06932922452688217, 0.00436194846406579, 0.07313816994428635, -0.028506271541118622, -0.07506248354911804, 0.03904356062412262, -0.016845177859067917, -0.005985868629068136, 0.08167201280593872, 0.0005994045059196651, 0.023682549595832825, 0.019546136260032654, 0.04804663732647896, 0.007378891576081514, -0.07404419034719467, 0.01823623850941658, 0.026315080001950264, 0.004616437945514917, -0.04646248742938042, 0.037751875817775726, 0.03773965314030647, 0.02542283944785595, -0.019068855792284012, 0.04245029017329216, -0.017770690843462944, -0.05663159489631653, 0.0013870142865926027, -0.07252669334411621, -0.005152791738510132, -0.04646714776754379, 0.00671769306063652, 0.006880191154778004, -0.014295250177383423, -0.021071946248412132, 0.006962215062230825, -0.041470129042863846, -0.013955941423773766, -0.0015806874725967646, 0.012559721246361732, 0.021722326055169106, 0.0036869761534035206, -0.017298299819231033, 0.03971542418003082, -0.011480684392154217, 0.01708061806857586, 0.04236837103962898, -0.00010026920062955469, 0.04397642984986305, 0.0070936232805252075, -0.019010251387953758, 0.0281975194811821, 0.019516652449965477, -0.012601334601640701, -0.07254658639431, -0.013083095662295818, 0.06513545662164688, 0.028746770694851875, -0.047655973583459854, 0.03956533223390579, 0.001870707026682794, 0.009000152349472046, -0.015102799981832504, -0.03599407151341438, -0.025224732235074043, 0.04992331936955452, -0.006242366041988134, 0.023753751069307327, 0.08264977484941483, 0.01870896853506565, 0.009399691596627235, 0.08968762308359146, 0.05039246380329132, -0.05118558183312416, -0.028768258169293404, 0.018290771171450615, -0.08585550636053085, -0.040584880858659744, 0.03262101113796234, -0.0391618013381958, 0.0003616452740970999, 0.023967556655406952, -0.003052519168704748, -0.03479096665978432, 0.004431991372257471, 0.028030047193169594, 0.07475299388170242, -0.07082731276750565, 0.04584633558988571, -0.008963544853031635, 0.015658728778362274, 0.005922908429056406, -0.012688755989074707, 0.014813045039772987, -0.00921960175037384, -0.01004380639642477, 0.0071932910941541195, 0.0177767351269722, 0.014049037359654903, 0.026957102119922638, -0.01895391009747982, -0.054987046867609024, -0.03322518989443779, 0.009321317076683044, -0.0603192038834095, 0.002869891468435526, -0.027553265914320946, 0.03851311281323433, 0.0017278261948376894, 0.0049932110123336315, 0.053060006350278854, -0.012820557691156864, 0.031798556447029114, 0.05319379270076752, 0.011232866905629635, -0.04624670371413231, 0.056572847068309784, 0.010347563773393631, -0.0060776458121836185, -0.030688142403960228, -0.03705165907740593, -0.009890551678836346, -0.011924218386411667, 0.05348562076687813, 0.04340212792158127, -0.007711621467024088, -0.01680910959839821, 0.021007046103477478, -0.017665360122919083, 0.03917519375681877, -0.0038337816949933767, 0.014078482985496521, 0.015675032511353493, 0.022792503237724304, 0.000023343778593698516, 0.024674467742443085, -0.026570018380880356, 0.01899319887161255, 0.023867379873991013, 0.03823576122522354, -0.050142791122198105, 0.031197693198919296, 0.014312815852463245, -0.05150923132896423, 0.008916239254176617, 0.009377427399158478, 0.03166645020246506, 0.022799745202064514, -0.04355126619338989, 0.037370465695858, 0.020546279847621918, -0.00619343901053071, -0.05306749790906906, -0.017079085111618042, 0.01195775531232357, 0.007722544949501753, -0.042179547250270844, -0.01699310541152954, -0.031039973720908165, -0.0038769999518990517, 0.01096134539693594, 0.01281850878149271, -0.034509286284446716, 0.03944338485598564, -0.02865263633430004, -0.007949013262987137, 0.07782886922359467, 0.03018270991742611, -0.024617457762360573, -0.005055504851043224, 0.06249992921948433, -0.028249720111489296, -0.019185857847332954, -0.010048872791230679, 0.010193017311394215, -0.01302050519734621, 0.01015327125787735, 0.014558432623744011, -0.042147282510995865, 0.024549540132284164, -0.037793681025505066, 0.02822048030793667, -0.007120238151401281, 0.018512504175305367, 0.007791777607053518, -0.02709280326962471, -0.0071054925210773945, -0.03041069023311138, -0.0823633000254631, -0.0366230234503746, 0.005600293166935444, -0.005912524648010731, 0.03526854142546654, 0.02869381569325924, -0.04518952593207359, 0.09180734306573868, -0.03997716307640076, 0.03357797861099243, 0.08102992922067642, 0.028168337419629097, -0.04053312540054321, -0.023415159434080124, -0.01744663342833519, 0.018537873402237892, -0.04747398942708969, 0.023885957896709442, 0.014232700690627098, 0.01898099295794964, -0.01776972971856594, 0.020529182627797127, 0.012174186296761036, 0.014081400819122791, 0.029687613248825073, 0.0038645840249955654, 0.06136445328593254, 0.0256790891289711, 0.04277631267905235, 0.010550440289080143, 0.025791490450501442, 0.0012571208644658327, 0.060478437691926956, 0.03015768900513649, -0.015991074964404106, 0.028244860470294952, -0.01555542927235365, -0.004477998707443476, 0.019859662279486656, -0.01269817166030407, -0.03579135984182358, -0.044020671397447586, -0.021920913830399513, 0.05603765696287155, -0.09854486584663391, 0.0020472905598580837, -0.0031366548500955105, -0.04950276389718056, -0.005107909440994263, 0.0024425664450973272, -0.0557953417301178, 0.06423822045326233, 0.023831302300095558, -0.0028046316001564264, 0.008335323072969913, 0.033896997570991516, -0.016981426626443863, 0.03711920604109764, -0.04817571863532066, 0.010980432853102684, 0.046506378799676895, 0.02202841453254223, 0.004718927200883627, 0.058296117931604385, 0.010667210444808006, -0.03295598924160004, -0.017344526946544647, 0.0159987211227417, 0.007314593065530062, 0.05066597834229469, 0.050877299159765244, 0.05452483892440796, -0.014062244445085526, -0.023449864238500595, -0.007900101132690907, 0.03736855462193489, -0.007123521529138088, 0.031337086111307144, -0.01553830411285162, 0.010161763057112694, -0.04686277359724045, 0.022224092856049538, -0.010315710678696632, 0.024831973016262054, -0.030150512233376503, -0.00850051548331976, 0.036856044083833694, -0.04808591306209564, -0.0051901680417358875, 0.020731471478939056, 0.0026724059134721756, -0.02930721826851368, -0.06298733502626419, -0.04117198660969734, 0.042715806514024734, -0.019005602225661278, -0.024901246652007103, -0.003513094736263156, -0.040467213839292526, 0.04429282620549202, 0.007265234831720591, -0.021538017317652702, 0.02850862219929695, 0.028959017246961594, 0.026538854464888573, -0.00926212128251791, 0.014976020902395248, 0.02916690707206726, -0.062236588448286057, 0.02574995718896389, -0.026888780295848846, -0.028819380328059196, -0.007587761152535677, 0.03287787735462189, 0.010574470274150372, -0.03615489602088928, -0.06986396759748459, -0.002017922466620803, -0.036033567041158676, 0.0042657931335270405, 0.022200876846909523, -0.08974198251962662, 0.021046701818704605, -0.01606559008359909, -0.020017847418785095, -0.012509479187428951, -0.012832459062337875, -0.017921749502420425, -0.0034393519163131714, -0.03170895576477051, 0.0344792902469635, -0.029888244345784187, 0.011758904904127121, 0.0355507992208004, -0.03423367813229561, 0.009976583532989025, -0.013927913270890713, -0.022817127406597137, 0.036834605038166046, 0.09136142581701279, -0.017489196732640266, 0.02338939532637596, -0.05417831614613533, 0.03300758823752403, -0.04257655143737793, -0.05912667512893677, 0.022493045777082443, 0.0406746044754982, 0.00041309697553515434, -0.012101017870008945, -0.05171831697225571, 0.037507638335227966, -0.07845700532197952, 0.01788022369146347, -0.0051969802007079124, -0.06706966459751129, 0.022148096933960915, 0.009586854837834835, -0.008689867332577705, 0.02663900889456272, 0.04583530128002167, 0.04098031297326088, -0.039657771587371826, -0.03407995030283928, 0.030532289296388626, 0.028455795720219612, -0.0032310469541698694, 0.05805528536438942, -0.050336286425590515, -0.022510027512907982, -0.038523007184267044, -0.019771259278059006, -0.028621157631278038, 0.025714589282870293, 0.021188484504818916, 0.02084929868578911, -0.025801105424761772, 0.05295875668525696, 0.005019714590162039, -0.021625179797410965, -0.05121181160211563, -0.0721299797296524, -0.08235900849103928, 0.022816574200987816, 0.01747615821659565, -0.06448115408420563, -0.016999434679746628, 0.0036524715833365917, -0.06572983413934708, 0.0012665109243243933, -0.01920953206717968, -0.016002289950847626, 0.019060801714658737, 0.014380327425897121, 0.030361030250787735, -0.06484518200159073, -0.052343182265758514, 0.016426464542746544, -0.02502567321062088, -0.07768651098012924, -0.0012655778555199504, -0.04191360995173454, -0.03393847122788429, 0.019189918413758278, -0.05698365345597267, 0.01197928935289383, 0.029043246060609818, -0.03691335394978523, -0.011564741842448711, -0.03137684985995293, 0.0065118372440338135, 0.012471266090869904, 0.04139935225248337, 0.02403850667178631, -0.005884563084691763, -0.021798452362418175, -0.0436098612844944, 0.004240660462528467, 0.016936585307121277, -0.021993737667798996, -0.039465297013521194, 0.02839568257331848, 0.0052046445198357105, 0.020190110430121422, 0.05223841220140457, 0.013896515592932701, 0.0582810677587986, 0.03535078093409538, -0.02304738387465477, 0.10409219563007355, -0.021167563274502754, -0.00629337877035141, 0.020057201385498047, -0.0057477569207549095, -0.033090345561504364, -0.0038794572465121746, 0.016958951950073242, 0.00018261131481267512, 0.013307594694197178, -0.012996402569115162, 0.05348818376660347, 0.04797518625855446, -0.005078692454844713, -0.03770769014954567, -0.0021623631473630667, -0.01171500887721777, 0.030534790828824043, -0.015049900859594345, -0.005509656388312578, -0.03514432907104492, -0.01666508987545967, -0.05220838263630867, -0.04440714418888092, 0.0014201137237250805, -0.012277739122509956, -0.027747593820095062, -0.009188511408865452, 0.03837259113788605, -0.016211435198783875, 0.03294561430811882, -0.013453498482704163, -0.013700267300009727, -0.015497279353439808, 0.0008501174743287265, 0.03326965868473053, 0.026196278631687164, 0.03686944395303726, 0.0009407682809978724, 0.025189466774463654, -0.007949301972985268, -0.039089102298021317, -0.07256346195936203, -0.018975885584950447, -0.058155447244644165, 0.014062243513762951, 0.02758341282606125, -0.020187368616461754, -0.04045518860220909, -0.014488504268229008, 0.02425731159746647, 0.0155896982178092, -0.016076643019914627, 0.02617383375763893, 0.11506465077400208, 0.025252560153603554, 0.019731732085347176, 0.016911573708057404, -0.004084407351911068, 0.0458843968808651, -0.06129361316561699, -0.02342108078300953, -0.10850519686937332, 0.05386634171009064, 0.01566244103014469, -0.008697407320141792, 0.015398927964270115, 0.048865657299757004, 0.006206481251865625, 0.0020507038570940495, 0.07780452817678452, -0.005662531591951847, 0.05622110515832901, 0.04413844645023346, -0.01728445291519165, -0.025231115520000458, -0.006249597761780024, 0.053087424486875534, -0.02377009205520153, -0.026694314554333687, -0.050288841128349304, -0.007239262107759714, 0.06270557641983032, 0.06160855293273926, -0.029362736269831657, -0.035708267241716385, 0.005770294927060604, -0.0030632237903773785, -0.03898139297962189, 0.009813619777560234, -0.002574800979346037, 0.04269814491271973, 0.005915180314332247, -0.010008228942751884, -0.05689217522740364, -0.024512551724910736, -0.03719882294535637, -0.04437584802508354, -0.03140249848365784, 0.031011661514639854, -0.01710999570786953, 0.022351078689098358, -0.012481989338994026, 0.05934212729334831, -0.05122842639684677, -0.06792076677083969, 0.008301950991153717, 0.014394807629287243, -0.02643565833568573, -0.06569597125053406, -0.02576378732919693, 0.046867772936820984, -0.013259416446089745, -0.0449240617454052, 0.028959427028894424, -0.019451025873422623, 0.013868787325918674, -0.056838128715753555, 0.05051364749670029, -0.02017715759575367, -0.005472857970744371, 0.011587153188884258, -0.025781037285923958, 0.035557765513658524, 0.004883534740656614, 0.08132604509592056, 0.04261741787195206, 0.002643646439537406, -0.03499165177345276, -0.028973866254091263, 0.002847649622708559, -0.07565952837467194, 0.017027026042342186, -0.023570647463202477, -0.031142454594373703, -0.08002232015132904, 0.015715714544057846, -0.03783420845866203, 0.03584977611899376, 0.01163320243358612, 0.020286187529563904, -0.02682354673743248, -0.022157635539770126, 0.04719582945108414, -0.024770300835371017, -0.004120882134884596, -0.02884804643690586, 0.045438770204782486, 0.02091813273727894, -0.0016449685208499432, -0.029676469042897224, -0.04470490664243698, -0.04414792358875275, -0.036134954541921616, 0.02413884736597538, -0.00883096270263195, -0.0466637946665287, 0.004320378880947828, -0.033374231308698654, 0.04914313927292824, -0.014089435338973999, -0.008901736699044704, 0.02512039616703987, 0.01597965881228447, -0.012409680522978306, 0.0051847901195287704, -0.0183010995388031, -0.011393285356462002, 0.0884392112493515, 0.01858367584645748, -0.005454363767057657, 0.027928438037633896, -0.03803342580795288, 0.0301931444555521, -0.041422855108976364, -0.038913384079933167, -0.006704757921397686, -0.036194391548633575, -0.014606655575335026, 0.0572032555937767, 0.04193867743015289, -0.023449955508112907, 0.04715137183666229, 0.027405034750699997, 0.03172747418284416, -0.02875870279967785, -0.05713139474391937, -0.035486482083797455, -0.0722154900431633, 0.0662556067109108, -0.03683177009224892, -0.02834632247686386, 0.020276201888918877, -0.00010266249591950327 ]
<p>When studying time series, I once heard the statement that</p> <blockquote> <p>unit root test is less powerful.</p> </blockquote> <p>I hereby have two questions:</p> <ol> <li>What does it mean for a test to be powerful?</li> <li>What causes the unit root test to be less powerful?</li> </ol>
g36642
[ 0.014579182490706444, 0.06936866044998169, -0.006910996045917273, -0.0025673711206763983, 0.06148650497198105, -0.04169699549674988, 0.006967712659388781, 0.03133482486009598, -0.010100536048412323, 0.02207433432340622, -0.01341082714498043, 0.0694022923707962, 0.015217970125377178, 0.0037514930590987206, 0.02667822316288948, -0.014335955493152142, 0.10957244038581848, -0.01698823645710945, 0.013120471499860287, 0.024995097890496254, -0.01107450295239687, 0.0035283691249787807, -0.03341234475374222, -0.03158416971564293, 0.03691203519701958, -0.055307675153017044, -0.05783252418041229, -0.015555476769804955, -0.07626519352197647, -0.004692751448601484, 0.08651986718177795, 0.03438660502433777, 0.034259576350450516, -0.04435651749372482, -0.05219114571809769, 0.02107536420226097, 0.06746991723775864, 0.031090160831809044, 0.048192571848630905, -0.000012324664567131549, 0.050586435943841934, 0.04565777629613876, 0.01966152712702751, -0.04137508198618889, -0.0029356996528804302, -0.04939085617661476, -0.022197503596544266, 0.06432699412107468, 0.04453575238585472, -0.011676360853016376, -0.10096606612205505, -0.06273845583200455, 0.06493955850601196, 0.022580668330192566, 0.009600731544196606, 0.026183295994997025, -0.04786614701151848, 0.03371921554207802, -0.006078370381146669, -0.006333368364721537, 0.02698320895433426, -0.02876734547317028, 0.017243945971131325, -0.0055885324254632, 0.032020650804042816, -0.04590294882655144, 0.05984940007328987, -0.017693903297185898, 0.05501110851764679, 0.042950499802827835, -0.009355609305202961, -0.046703025698661804, -0.0017077857628464699, -0.04856112226843834, 0.01264870073646307, -0.007355132605880499, 0.0021240697242319584, -0.007695138454437256, 0.0032928811851888895, 0.05463913455605507, 0.050855573266744614, 0.029296785593032837, -0.05512914061546326, 0.027142470702528954, 0.033504098653793335, 0.019080044701695442, -0.009896600618958473, -0.010708540678024292, 0.03750009834766388, 0.08311513066291809, 0.03780142217874527, -0.04637783020734787, 0.037767741829156876, 0.028798773884773254, -0.055544063448905945, -0.030237840488553047, 0.0115509033203125, -0.02143516205251217, 0.035980548709630966, 0.09636875987052917, 0.002688347129151225, 0.03353307768702507, 0.03572451323270798, -0.009387679398059845, 0.016431014984846115, 0.0016271962085738778, -0.00897984765470028, -0.02312634326517582, -0.06526195257902145, -0.010713043622672558, -0.0475851446390152, 0.0348135270178318, -0.0596938319504261, -0.013365184888243675, -0.051354218274354935, -0.0016265022568404675, 0.06581957638263702, -0.027233392000198364, -0.023305682465434074, -0.009691109880805016, -0.013779062777757645, 0.027733901515603065, -0.008556685410439968, 0.01909673400223255, -0.015192203223705292, 0.019197139889001846, -0.0159502774477005, 0.03595997765660286, 0.0015133609995245934, 0.03933285176753998, 0.04340539500117302, 0.028721939772367477, -0.09496822953224182, 0.002810656325891614, 0.06365779042243958, 0.037074729800224304, -0.01890735700726509, 0.032227594405412674, 0.001184046734124422, -0.024522533640265465, -0.05846862122416496, -0.006667754612863064, 0.02379406802356243, -0.019781483337283134, -0.02138008363544941, -0.026425866410136223, 0.009243444539606571, -0.04118495434522629, -0.05662933364510536, -0.027589861303567886, 0.016415953636169434, -0.009938816539943218, -0.004526423756033182, -0.032527483999729156, 0.04842277616262436, 0.015711048617959023, 0.00874014850705862, -0.01775956340134144, 0.003800557227805257, 0.034844137728214264, -0.02848697267472744, -0.008938905782997608, -0.01950577273964882, -0.018155643716454506, -0.04985126480460167, -0.05483253672719002, 0.01061162818223238, -0.04929695650935173, 0.058033645153045654, -0.06498048454523087, 0.012159464880824089, -0.0453379824757576, 0.010333934798836708, 0.03519034758210182, -0.008023836649954319, 0.02656085044145584, 0.07269511371850967, -0.02391556091606617, 0.028360022231936455, 0.014700244180858135, -0.024925149977207184, -0.021994436159729958, 0.018247194588184357, 0.016375495120882988, -0.032965924590826035, 0.009584606625139713, 0.018519975244998932, -0.010979829356074333, -0.08044779300689697, 0.02021627500653267, -0.11899544298648834, -0.06586703658103943, 0.0269837137311697, 0.053325802087783813, -0.037258390337228775, -0.05814002454280853, -0.014963658526539803, -0.012190250679850578, -0.0003540399775374681, -0.025995109230279922, 0.0024322099052369595, -0.022040851414203644, -0.04297006130218506, 0.0290287546813488, -0.005894914269447327, -0.008758735843002796, -0.09157232940196991, 0.01473733875900507, 0.00010053138976218179, -0.030923765152692795, 0.05582126975059509, -0.013803480193018913, 0.017183853313326836, 0.033321358263492584, -0.029298001900315285, 0.010022742673754692, 0.03244941681623459, 0.03480731323361397, 0.013284517452120781, 0.02866484969854355, -0.024149099364876747, -0.00719893304631114, 0.023071488365530968, 0.021859584376215935, -0.0016297048423439264, -0.02144457958638668, 0.02139328233897686, -0.0013064868981018662, -0.04485504701733589, 0.01973332092165947, -0.06994761526584625, -0.05014212056994438, 0.02198006398975849, -0.02096017450094223, 0.03040173649787903, 0.0022363702300935984, 0.04080364853143692, 0.001989739714190364, -0.0012166405795142055, 0.02550044097006321, -0.002435271395370364, -0.032235655933618546, 0.034393299371004105, 0.0002937626850325614, 0.047738537192344666, -0.054522935301065445, 0.004356222692877054, -0.06436154246330261, -0.0038076788187026978, 0.06791335344314575, -0.038942478597164154, 0.03331299126148224, 0.024866409599781036, 0.025717929005622864, -0.00937681645154953, 0.007828626781702042, 0.010892833583056927, 0.0070304530672729015, -0.014933242462575436, -0.008685832843184471, 0.01931602880358696, 0.007389858830720186, -0.03420668840408325, 0.02209722064435482, 0.016637323424220085, -0.04680275544524193, -0.0419270321726799, -0.04167909920215607, 0.04207491874694824, 0.009625518694519997, 0.013404359109699726, 0.08434285968542099, 0.06114654615521431, 0.06910667568445206, 0.030728204175829887, -0.05837908014655113, 0.020798008888959885, -0.007642801385372877, -0.01125818770378828, -0.03486127406358719, 0.00979084987193346, 0.030063051730394363, -0.06356461346149445, 0.04018678143620491, 0.03413458913564682, -0.041624944657087326, -0.037110984325408936, -0.012835187837481499, 0.0408376008272171, 0.017891013994812965, -0.05424589291214943, 0.018829600885510445, 0.03968675807118416, -0.02689080499112606, 0.013143115676939487, 0.001550805289298296, -0.0669998973608017, -0.08524324744939804, -0.023619038984179497, -0.009998762048780918, -0.0018228417029604316, -0.03246413916349411, -0.003637052606791258, 0.006345330271869898, 0.0366111658513546, -0.016765139997005463, 0.03857477009296417, -0.034100666642189026, -0.028507651761174202, 0.045754335820674896, -0.006660479120910168, 0.011667569167912006, 0.010379713959991932, -0.027005093172192574, -0.008890239521861076, -0.019819293171167374, -0.05901975929737091, 0.061646249145269394, -0.006310328375548124, -0.05677809938788414, -0.009922309778630733, -0.03543322533369064, 0.010466315783560276, 0.007349606137722731, -0.07646156847476959, 0.009227084927260876, -0.0568804033100605, 0.05104945972561836, -0.0615064837038517, -0.02638530544936657, 0.009530662558972836, 0.00804461445659399, 0.030511559918522835, 0.045512229204177856, -0.0269416943192482, -0.03712639585137367, 0.012269790284335613, 0.051322877407073975, -0.008317717351019382, 0.0413786955177784, 0.02557806856930256, -0.01988818123936653, -0.008248447440564632, 0.004243853501975536, -0.011621660552918911, 0.021647486835718155, 0.01713225618004799, 0.014146426692605019, -0.019837679341435432, 0.04106471687555313, 0.028011592105031013, 0.00534242857247591, -0.01242786180227995, -0.055383481085300446, 0.10092668980360031, 0.001485633198171854, -0.001074293744750321, 0.03942752629518509, -0.02205423079431057, -0.0150330550968647, -0.0016804795013740659, -0.030747389420866966, 0.03786022588610649, -0.0019759719725698233, 0.0006334903300739825, 0.06176023557782173, 0.020007910206913948, 0.037340905517339706, -0.034280676394701004, 0.027984704822301865, -0.023071549832820892, 0.008909592404961586, 0.0193308237940073, 0.04627249762415886, 0.047601886093616486, 0.019806411117315292, 0.026981942355632782, -0.0009716958156786859, -0.04537719115614891, 0.007761597633361816, 0.01525605283677578, -0.02739376202225685, 0.05265871062874794, 0.02856520749628544, 0.0214534942060709, -0.037847742438316345, -0.011229093186557293, -0.028982391580939293, 0.015586178749799728, -0.05162438750267029, -0.03956589475274086, 0.013256083242595196, -0.07900594174861908, 0.04951045662164688, -0.0013671384658664465, -0.03660618141293526, 0.029225477948784828, 0.0708463117480278, -0.025800591334700584, 0.025073889642953873, -0.020991191267967224, -0.012708323076367378, -0.02409270778298378, 0.026681488379836082, -0.034066323190927505, -0.024335328489542007, 0.030993184074759483, -0.004550471901893616, -0.027331508696079254, 0.03905099630355835, 0.007351013831794262, -0.0059691136702895164, -0.02498660236597061, -0.09242687374353409, -0.005768768955022097, 0.002403314458206296, 0.0626603290438652, 0.05420257896184921, 0.00948454812169075, 0.028117867186665535, -0.024850646033883095, 0.009768531657755375, -0.009180618450045586, -0.01322880107909441, 0.017477551475167274, 0.03235840052366257, 0.0033810767345130444, -0.010681137442588806, 0.02462620660662651, 0.008769710548222065, 0.010394938290119171, 0.03294878825545311, -0.024459414184093475, -0.014898094348609447, 0.03308441489934921, -0.005384868010878563, -0.016980808228254318, 0.06321371346712112, -0.024809299036860466, -0.000961241836193949, 0.01890639029443264, -0.03342084214091301, -0.06264650076627731, 0.056889090687036514, 0.030221065506339073, 0.007493263576179743, 0.0263091791421175, 0.023358456790447235, -0.011577818542718887, 0.005006806459277868, -0.0560966432094574, 0.06546499580144882, 0.025973452255129814, -0.0590260773897171, 0.009609920904040337, 0.015792720019817352, 0.03229167312383652, -0.017151664942502975, 0.0285499207675457, 0.03626718744635582, -0.05216216295957565, 0.0011847865534946322, 0.030248990282416344, 0.025320490822196007, 0.025330800563097, -0.02388402260839939, -0.09110172092914581, -0.01793484389781952, -0.045395608991384506, -0.00023941534163895994, -0.006583984009921551, -0.08290529251098633, 0.06749948114156723, 0.02451048605144024, -0.01603154093027115, 0.026261983439326286, -0.018818523734807968, 0.019878406077623367, 0.0022973441518843174, -0.011401212774217129, 0.023088833317160606, -0.04135172814130783, -0.047214288264513016, -0.019848203286528587, -0.006766767241060734, 0.0036434221547096968, -0.012016108259558678, -0.03196918964385986, 0.03766563907265663, -0.012538471259176731, -0.004799345042556524, 0.032464493066072464, 0.06091634929180145, 0.010922483168542385, -0.014557193033397198, 0.029546789824962616, 0.022030826658010483, -0.012228921987116337, -0.019322652369737625, -0.012990951538085938, -0.05566626414656639, 0.02037849836051464, -0.05169243365526199, 0.025140078738331795, -0.014869693666696548, -0.035025667399168015, 0.06852085888385773, -0.02958380989730358, 0.007739128079265356, 0.004514281637966633, 0.008481153286993504, 0.023578206077218056, 0.017239728942513466, -0.012961316853761673, 0.03464939072728157, -0.006411616690456867, -0.052184510976076126, 0.030112242326140404, -0.03622512146830559, 0.012854786589741707, -0.008557228371500969, -0.024835361167788506, 0.054819367825984955, -0.06066545844078064, 0.052753109484910965, -0.023811448365449905, -0.014956977218389511, -0.024289069697260857, 0.06472660601139069, -0.009773211553692818, 0.05132491514086723, 0.027753416448831558, 0.05825173854827881, -0.010560167022049427, 0.02473408170044422, 0.003453421639278531, 0.02615351974964142, -0.016069909557700157, -0.08047047257423401, -0.01321724709123373, -0.016494570299983025, -0.0038594764191657305, -0.004110715351998806, -0.011143325828015804, -0.003385173389688134, -0.010872895829379559, 0.012921864166855812, -0.020597826689481735, 0.030431674793362617, -0.03241254761815071, -0.0198159608989954, 0.019967632368206978, -0.04952525347471237, 0.012569686397910118, -0.004491208586841822, 0.017064467072486877, 0.046733636409044266, -0.026950765401124954, -0.01118549145758152, -0.018601413816213608, -0.031545475125312805, -0.002108548069372773, -0.005753491539508104, 0.029909297823905945, 0.09895149618387222, -0.11131063103675842, -0.011521044187247753, 0.04909302294254303, 0.044460032135248184, 0.013636041432619095, 0.07409802079200745, 0.010996580123901367, 0.026646688580513, -0.0024260913487523794, -0.02188580296933651, 0.03267437592148781, 0.02409060113132, 0.04837410897016525, 0.008593916893005371, 0.021244438365101814, -0.08062000572681427, -0.017898375168442726, 0.014559384435415268, 0.01815253682434559, 0.045299023389816284, -0.04292807728052139, 0.018230047076940536, 0.07287275791168213, 0.019287915900349617, 0.028405629098415375, -0.015559240244328976, -0.022394564002752304, -0.006391133647412062, 0.020573187619447708, 0.01211270596832037, 0.02997339516878128, -0.0022775225806981325, 0.024145809933543205, -0.03446165844798088, -0.08696011453866959, 0.021552326157689095, -0.008866527117788792, 0.04026494175195694, -0.06109320744872093, 0.0029487700667232275, 0.05203257501125336, 0.027312476187944412, -0.004027492366731167, -0.03939652070403099, -0.0064253914169967175, 0.03707769513130188, -0.01189686544239521, 0.05594785884022713, 0.009528540074825287, 0.020286113023757935, -0.01447584480047226, -0.005149891600012779, -0.018443623557686806, -0.04571395367383957, 0.01823640614748001, 0.06582009792327881, -0.02716384083032608, 0.024687064811587334, -0.06986882537603378, 0.006542163901031017, 0.04288851469755173, -0.00998626183718443, -0.005989869125187397, -0.03415601700544357, 0.0018080638255923986, -0.045926209539175034, -0.03541570529341698, -0.06525716930627823, 0.004188783932477236, -0.056564245373010635, 0.0049962676130235195, -0.03777121379971504, 0.023359743878245354, 0.004590109921991825, -0.0034972254652529955, -0.015513413585722446, 0.012866654433310032, -0.006126362830400467, -0.03339683637022972, -0.008581106550991535, -0.010810784995555878, 0.06074674054980278, 0.047324731945991516, 0.02252313122153282, -0.016593482345342636, 0.024222904816269875, 0.022970687597990036, 0.033017490059137344, -0.079786516726017, 0.025175591930747032, 0.020943913608789444, 0.022146305069327354, 0.025204038247466087, 0.011169854551553726, -0.02925337851047516, -0.050015904009342194, -0.016504261642694473, -0.014203430153429508, 0.06311137974262238, -0.0050189015455543995, 0.09360186010599136, -0.003397687105461955, -0.011197294108569622, 0.02397983707487583, -0.03587530925869942, -0.015623723156750202, -0.009367060847580433, -0.02643599547445774, -0.029379546642303467, 0.06814990937709808, 0.032742250710725784, -0.03534189239144325, 0.007100660353899002, 0.012195033021271229, 0.00925624743103981, -0.0647505521774292, -0.039881449192762375, -0.011983435600996017, -0.07966256141662598, -0.026177294552326202, -0.03933999314904213, -0.10225650668144226, -0.04286782816052437, 0.04803793132305145, -0.004808977246284485, -0.035796161741018295, 0.025258703157305717, 0.020589131861925125, 0.04144956171512604, -0.005014094058424234, -0.021643200889229774, -0.016358153894543648, -0.026169029995799065, -0.03702615201473236, 0.014286012388765812, -0.05189014971256256, -0.002392006339505315, -0.00027843230054713786, -0.027514155954122543, 0.037566546350717545, -0.05207154527306557, 0.018248559907078743, 0.050314199179410934, -0.08057760447263718, 0.007649363949894905, -0.024612780660390854, 0.028132807463407516, -0.03362470492720604, -0.0324607752263546, -0.014598359353840351, -0.01448405534029007, 0.01277522835880518, -0.010943938046693802, -0.034892741590738297, 0.03019888326525688, 0.009876224212348461, -0.0667358785867691, 0.02461268939077854, -0.022207016125321388, -0.010140690952539444, -0.03906809166073799, 0.09123187512159348, 0.007843418046832085, -0.023221030831336975, 0.029627662152051926, -0.018836863338947296, -0.043313972651958466, 0.011924747377634048, -0.02039424516260624, 0.028348425403237343, 0.019648995250463486, -0.008531932719051838, 0.02009025402367115, -0.03271041810512543, 0.0203842930495739, -0.0020799224730581045, 0.06261859834194183, -0.06035083159804344, 0.02492128498852253, 0.0013198822271078825, -0.04341958835721016, -0.03872369974851608, 0.06577007472515106, 0.02567843720316887, -0.044516708701848984, -0.015578153543174267, 0.06310222297906876, -0.059761498123407364, 0.06045759469270706, -0.015187746845185757, -0.0011181557783856988, -0.034136585891246796, 0.036514487117528915, 0.03427286073565483, -0.05405711382627487, 0.00012686186528299004, 0.04090387374162674, 0.019971970468759537, -0.05038005858659744, 0.03605059161782265, -0.050302863121032715, -0.024097857996821404, -0.023029157891869545 ]
<p>My lecturer just covered the <strong>Lindberg-Levy central limit theorem</strong> and the multivariate version, the <strong>Lindberg-fuller CLT</strong>. I understood the basic concept and I can derive it, etc. But it would help my understanding a lot if someone could explain how all this used in real life applications of <strong>econometric</strong> analysis?</p> <p>Ive read some claims that the CLT is nice only on a piece of paper.</p> <p>Some really cool industry applications or references would be appreciated.</p>
g74022
[ 0.04147300124168396, -0.011156601831316948, 0.011037125252187252, -0.011516083963215351, -0.015756191685795784, -0.032709524035453796, 0.021158020943403244, -0.007118631154298782, -0.016778001561760902, 0.018407870084047318, -0.03830061852931976, -0.009049596264958382, 0.051742058247327805, -0.02519083209335804, 0.021161988377571106, -0.03576561436057091, 0.020396308973431587, 0.02867564558982849, 0.019848346710205078, -0.002229636535048485, 0.02642323449254036, 0.03586011752486229, 0.016980549320578575, -0.055740829557180405, -0.05874626711010933, -0.0020289772655814886, -0.00005204226908972487, 0.0482705794274807, 0.02001069113612175, -0.04066091775894165, -0.0029162114951759577, -0.0010300035355612636, 0.03127281740307808, -0.056601397693157196, -0.04504048824310303, -0.03682265803217888, 0.05730241537094116, 0.036475446075201035, -0.06204277276992798, 0.007211749907582998, 0.021501651033759117, 0.05569693073630333, 0.04881831631064415, -0.011671011336147785, -0.059896696358919144, 0.014366399496793747, -0.041675254702568054, 0.017800621688365936, 0.007497879210859537, -0.023707468062639236, -0.00400575902312994, 0.0070480769500136375, 0.042781978845596313, -0.0071929157711565495, 0.05990920960903168, 0.01762184500694275, -0.01761879026889801, 0.023100025951862335, 0.04415830597281456, -0.05350926145911217, 0.02771356888115406, -0.002520199166610837, -0.002534396480768919, 0.014862395823001862, 0.03545908257365227, -0.0014832046581432223, 0.023876778781414032, -0.00636424170807004, -0.018204765394330025, 0.0211490485817194, 0.038011711090803146, -0.0629284456372261, 0.015981238335371017, -0.027448687702417374, -0.06297341734170914, -0.048216719180345535, -0.04059266671538353, -0.0349675789475441, 0.01613449864089489, -0.01684059575200081, -0.06347144395112991, 0.0006540826288983226, -0.005767373833805323, 0.050657350569963455, 0.020525043830275536, -0.043800238519907, 0.05120329558849335, -0.05964788421988487, 0.05278516188263893, -0.0493280403316021, 0.08703123778104782, 0.02499322220683098, 0.0011541752610355616, -0.0027697307523339987, -0.01697792299091816, -0.04382118955254555, 0.007206065580248833, -0.031317535787820816, -0.031238200142979622, 0.00671400735154748, -0.009368391707539558, 0.015402685850858688, -0.017549173906445503, 0.006787199527025223, -0.014682968147099018, 0.029232975095510483, 0.029999498277902603, -0.022608473896980286, -0.011771946214139462, 0.011538803577423096, -0.06272785365581512, 0.029334694147109985, -0.040191374719142914, -0.018483538180589676, -0.045664817094802856, 0.05037849396467209, 0.04264271259307861, -0.0018312454922124743, 0.0005713512655347586, 0.022517772391438484, 0.02255655825138092, 0.04006626829504967, 0.0675366073846817, -0.02423856034874916, -0.002610810799524188, 0.01578003726899624, 0.004004525952041149, 0.026706380769610405, 0.014019952155649662, -0.01849452592432499, 0.011501741595566273, 0.04698701575398445, 0.009381599724292755, -0.009359822608530521, 0.0373602919280529, 0.050201062113046646, -0.024533728137612343, 0.0573023222386837, -0.00118478131480515, 0.03086002543568611, -0.022098394110798836, -0.049805186688899994, 0.0023724203929305077, 0.009825264103710651, -0.03914825618267059, 0.036795925348997116, 0.035742927342653275, 0.0009393874788656831, 0.013461930677294731, 0.0020673105027526617, 0.00429140729829669, 0.04409452900290489, -0.04112415388226509, -0.02159084379673004, -0.012810476124286652, 0.033854346722364426, 0.025792527943849564, -0.046299807727336884, 0.03501543030142784, 0.006977875716984272, 0.019572170451283455, -0.007988500408828259, -0.0005951060447841883, -0.00555071048438549, -0.0712502971291542, -0.005984063260257244, 0.038531430065631866, 0.003008301602676511, 0.09617917984724045, 0.0343412309885025, -0.0642571747303009, 0.006722473073750734, -0.013426209799945354, 0.0001290913496632129, 0.024876242503523827, 0.0273505337536335, 0.03329072147607803, -0.006542440969496965, 0.0035078562796115875, 0.022231698036193848, -0.03038417175412178, 0.018484951928257942, -0.0016157453646883368, -0.04356510192155838, -0.01340856309980154, -0.016655858606100082, -0.026303520426154137, -0.021831022575497627, -0.016193263232707977, 0.045487239956855774, -0.031771861016750336, 0.020563391968607903, -0.004335977137088776, 0.016223307698965073, -0.03580757603049278, -0.021112674847245216, -0.008174857124686241, -0.0271066352725029, -0.04407675191760063, -0.013620594516396523, 0.009553315117955208, -0.009278833866119385, 0.02630734071135521, 0.042027540504932404, -0.031016085296869278, 0.04351719468832016, -0.07885828614234924, -0.026780402287840843, -0.03482186794281006, 0.010532760061323643, 0.0038763806223869324, -0.015763383358716965, -0.004412271082401276, 0.031008319929242134, 0.03808612376451492, 0.02446851320564747, -0.04712248966097832, -0.00363226979970932, -0.004520137328654528, -0.02304103411734104, 0.03998814895749092, -0.07985702902078629, 0.05377981811761856, 0.07016260176897049, -0.017342811450362206, 0.0037091136910021305, -0.00011072878260165453, 0.00023411965230479836, -0.007956549525260925, 0.039902541786432266, -0.05822440981864929, -0.0008782604709267616, 0.023045262321829796, 0.05575841665267944, 0.05851458013057709, 0.0395774319767952, 0.004804667551070452, -0.03539180010557175, -0.002743461634963751, 0.07130223512649536, 0.0005294678267091513, 0.01341234426945448, 0.009110718965530396, 0.012820988893508911, 0.0028374730609357357, -0.04846325144171715, 0.05302641913294792, -0.05733579397201538, 0.06126287579536438, 0.01471132505685091, -0.0351949967443943, 0.005486984271556139, 0.024564391002058983, 0.033868592232465744, -0.0039813462644815445, -0.040796324610710144, -0.005407088436186314, 0.022783078253269196, -0.0642213299870491, 0.0046600159257650375, 0.024749523028731346, 0.052060965448617935, -0.0053374553099274635, 0.009442456997931004, 0.017293483018875122, -0.05222725868225098, -0.010195760987699032, -0.034928906708955765, -0.024964280426502228, -0.00896531343460083, -0.058593541383743286, 0.030491039156913757, -0.045267585664987564, 0.0656697228550911, 0.020934784784913063, -0.010985473170876503, -0.029889367520809174, -0.020499659702181816, -0.0016986895352602005, -0.014113164506852627, 0.025988072156906128, -0.05013221129775047, 0.000060678932641167194, 0.001132748438976705, -0.014197937212884426, 0.001613999716937542, 0.01557028479874134, 0.03861965611577034, -0.00709614809602499, -0.004326277412474155, 0.001373200211673975, 0.0005277270101942122, 0.010201912373304367, -0.020954200997948647, 0.008552812039852142, -0.024429697543382645, 0.017851177603006363, -0.030577896162867546, 0.012008638121187687, 0.00016497346223331988, -0.013271280564367771, 0.01298396848142147, -0.0032264378387480974, 0.040467631071805954, 0.00397017877548933, 0.03084038943052292, -0.016306214034557343, -0.03156805783510208, 0.008208074606955051, -0.0021723825484514236, -0.015133283101022243, 0.005106740165501833, -0.024143235757946968, -0.037935465574264526, 0.004679376259446144, 0.005115749780088663, 0.06571975350379944, 0.02987242117524147, 0.10660374164581299, -0.06606405973434448, 0.02729235775768757, -0.06466501206159592, -0.03392321616411209, -0.009004540741443634, -0.000566747214179486, -0.05231165140867233, -0.03290090337395668, 0.02755269780755043, -0.06142675131559372, -0.00984548032283783, 0.02704758197069168, 0.007361177820712328, 0.012689050287008286, 0.0392918735742569, -0.0292978398501873, -0.036306917667388916, 0.01201123557984829, -0.011208822950720787, 0.014451221562922001, -0.014652134850621223, 0.02526150643825531, -0.062208447605371475, -0.04992517828941345, 0.036155153065919876, -0.05587424337863922, -0.019342951476573944, 0.04562770575284958, 0.006493156775832176, 0.026509055867791176, 0.0019165342673659325, 0.010512975975871086, -0.01285938173532486, 0.051273930817842484, -0.0352650061249733, 0.03053892031311989, -0.0053825946524739265, 0.047672078013420105, 0.028178047388792038, 0.029226528480648994, 0.000060211881645955145, -0.005213570315390825, -0.030479762703180313, 0.038388632237911224, 0.1132098063826561, -0.011691768653690815, -0.007352784276008606, 0.07688282430171967, 0.10052158683538437, 0.03209782764315605, -0.02334132045507431, 0.03238014876842499, 0.09077505022287369, 0.0009262729436159134, 0.01859288662672043, -0.01865963079035282, -0.037786051630973816, 0.006212248466908932, 0.04958267882466316, -0.01909044198691845, 0.04726323485374451, 0.09598050266504288, -0.012751764617860317, 0.05556356534361839, -0.0006411885842680931, 0.029010741040110588, -0.051984481513500214, -0.04254688695073128, 0.022654280066490173, -0.008457828313112259, -0.049652643501758575, 0.01137767918407917, -0.03356726095080376, -0.0504264235496521, 0.03383863344788551, 0.02029961347579956, -0.03412158042192459, 0.06690722703933716, -0.01217136811465025, 0.03401573747396469, 0.056712955236434937, -0.012187070213258266, -0.00579849723726511, -0.02371416985988617, -0.01858721300959587, -0.003792431438341737, -0.030101537704467773, -0.04159867763519287, -0.03081408701837063, -0.05354545637965202, -0.0027372892946004868, 0.012544739060103893, -0.05365542322397232, -0.011351004242897034, -0.10593969374895096, 0.049887366592884064, -0.0246221162378788, 0.04248883202672005, -0.009452096186578274, -0.00471469946205616, -0.006577490828931332, 0.046804897487163544, -0.004396406002342701, -0.06905257701873779, -0.0387849323451519, -0.018878433853387833, 0.06645616888999939, 0.025998154655098915, 0.039742495864629745, 0.03714357689023018, -0.07238885015249252, 0.03437179699540138, -0.004683729261159897, 0.013689453713595867, -0.01475865300744772, 0.05196760594844818, 0.010758846066892147, -0.0012932695681229234, 0.04268268868327141, -0.0640215277671814, -0.01464362908154726, 0.020308759063482285, -0.004303759895265102, 0.03596188500523567, 0.03709029778838158, -0.05860457196831703, -0.0018676683539524674, -0.0663284957408905, -0.007145855575799942, 0.000840276712551713, -0.048448022454977036, -0.03612688183784485, 0.013124511577188969, -0.0418924055993557, -0.0029543235432356596, -0.002045742003247142, -0.05841981992125511, 0.042923711240291595, 0.02773636020720005, 0.07828307151794434, 0.03179418295621872, -0.03220135718584061, -0.023069262504577637, -0.004747082944959402, -0.06440901011228561, 0.013194252736866474, 0.021300142630934715, -0.07100978493690491, -0.019307633861899376, -0.012658013962209225, -0.014590281061828136, 0.03250902146100998, 0.03477967157959938, 0.05095775052905083, -0.07938533276319504, -0.04569363221526146, -0.043231237679719925, 0.02153986506164074, 0.021814988926053047, 0.019933955743908882, -0.05216307193040848, 0.026514453813433647, -0.03771486133337021, -0.0012881956063210964, -0.014285781420767307, -0.05235018581151962, -0.03360757604241371, 0.022969817742705345, -0.04862941801548004, -0.032203033566474915, -0.01187316793948412, -0.029029563069343567, 0.02087174914777279, 0.05944913625717163, 0.030398063361644745, -0.014378826133906841, 0.06155458837747574, 0.029040833935141563, -0.052567776292562485, -0.022520815953612328, -0.08121513575315475, -0.06463672965765, 0.024551894515752792, -0.013824956491589546, -0.04331561550498009, -0.01750771701335907, 0.007453155238181353, 0.06983669102191925, -0.03473423793911934, -0.014609958976507187, 0.07101577520370483, 0.008035088889300823, 0.054496001452207565, 0.011840098537504673, 0.004388837143778801, 0.041530001908540726, -0.013938588090240955, -0.04753490537405014, 0.07398862391710281, 0.01588490605354309, 0.062436994165182114, 0.00855815876275301, 0.05705102160573006, 0.008118808269500732, 0.04161643609404564, 0.006666440051048994, -0.07555374503135681, -0.02093440108001232, 0.01920284517109394, 0.006173054222017527, 0.02058769389986992, -0.05236620083451271, 0.0015707312850281596, 0.023449890315532684, 0.016088470816612244, -0.020413780584931374, 0.010430814698338509, 0.01996508054435253, 0.0317637175321579, -0.036071088165044785, 0.004215857479721308, -0.022491686046123505, -0.018456703051924706, -0.04395410045981407, 0.005499924533069134, -0.0036316642072051764, -0.021794676780700684, -0.01695515215396881, -0.05472036078572273, 0.047786690294742584, 0.003393131773918867, 0.007602591998875141, 0.005584056954830885, 0.004806581884622574, -0.038733966648578644, 0.014169581234455109, -0.05308815836906433, -0.0328972227871418, -0.03301467001438141, -0.019224781543016434, 0.00415233476087451, -0.0026509971357882023, 0.005122173577547073, 0.05324842035770416, -0.00573199475184083, -0.016742561012506485, -0.0016028648242354393, -0.05398927628993988, 0.026419512927532196, 0.024589475244283676, 0.04997716471552849, -0.010093805380165577, 0.01083402056246996, 0.05838305875658989, 0.0024342841934412718, 0.02266278676688671, 0.059507112950086594, -0.011892931535840034, 0.02095216140151024, -0.01255838479846716, -0.04992428049445152, 0.01916487142443657, 0.03809985890984535, -0.016891254112124443, -0.04481342434883118, -0.025207553058862686, 0.0012097042053937912, -0.027740508317947388, 0.053496457636356354, -0.06119058281183243, -0.009909546002745628, -0.022271117195487022, 0.03479017689824104, -0.00005065140067017637, -0.024352360516786575, 0.005185993388295174, -0.05769633129239082, 0.011281541548669338, 0.0016482783248648047, -0.017829451709985733, -0.06441253423690796, 0.0023447072599083185, 0.027541231364011765, -0.019483979791402817, -0.036922723054885864, 0.02057621255517006, -0.011031522415578365, 0.046970341354608536, -0.05951846390962601, 0.010792865417897701, 0.03753869980573654, -0.015793021768331528, -0.00010906194802373648, 0.04391098767518997, 0.026141216978430748, 0.03181857615709305, -0.00959783885627985, -0.07082254439592361, -0.03832058236002922, 0.005894764326512814, -0.04850398749113083, -0.011399025097489357, -0.039425432682037354, -0.01395570021122694, -0.008985627442598343, -0.005161138251423836, 0.0826432853937149, -0.038256872445344925, -0.015845995396375656, 0.03153365105390549, 0.018154235556721687, 0.007101348601281643, -0.007250126451253891, 0.04818428307771683, 0.008795174770057201, -0.07134943455457687, 0.048554811626672745, -0.060285236686468124, 0.0013458250323310494, 0.03960201144218445, -0.012971824035048485, -0.04036782309412956, 0.02548305317759514, 0.020248085260391235, -0.045950718224048615, 0.010495868511497974, -0.015071443282067776, 0.061371322721242905, -0.005725522991269827, -0.036821842193603516, -0.004433654248714447, 0.02779254876077175, -0.03569371625781059, -0.043035026639699936, -0.010496855713427067, -0.006802933756262064, 0.04283605515956879, 0.033683061599731445, 0.031297117471694946, 0.03984178230166435, -0.04094923287630081, -0.024526020511984825, 0.026276081800460815, -0.014005660079419613, -0.037144869565963745, -0.012920844368636608, 0.09106575697660446, 0.04850609600543976, -0.007150868885219097, -0.03641589730978012, 0.01730012148618698, 0.004406682215631008, -0.07153607159852982, -0.030568527057766914, 0.07330405712127686, 0.04636891186237335, 0.008833254687488079, -0.05041110888123512, 0.0072207762859761715, -0.0537111759185791, -0.03239171579480171, -0.014723707921802998, 0.02628192864358425, -0.016328243538737297, -0.018196463584899902, -0.03698436915874481, -0.010194745846092701, -0.0005122410366311669, 0.08422474563121796, 0.029045987874269485, -0.011418827809393406, 0.026121340692043304, -0.020277712494134903, 0.041350509971380234, -0.03092462383210659, 0.04813118278980255, 0.05162820219993591, -0.05290595069527626, 0.059949275106191635, 0.02186274714767933, 0.12934845685958862, 0.02020319364964962, 0.003906107507646084, -0.07442725449800491, 0.0161461029201746, 0.05178995430469513, -0.01926983892917633, -0.006978512275964022, -0.10951496660709381, -0.007506475318223238, 0.02111695520579815, -0.00989457406103611, 0.01687966100871563, 0.04753098636865616, -0.004309319891035557, 0.08620768785476685, -0.013859443366527557, -0.0028567281551659107, 0.01282309740781784, 0.02776588499546051, 0.04804185777902603, 0.029896965250372887, -0.030847148969769478, 0.01094596553593874, 0.023647118359804153, -0.00001236766911461018, -0.029001813381910324, -0.050324466079473495, -0.0011056505609303713, -0.0435057207942009, 0.019288387149572372, -0.04062681272625923, -0.02513512596487999, -0.06774982810020447, 0.06714729964733124, 0.020644616335630417, -0.0037977786269038916, 0.01563861407339573, 0.01540442369878292, 0.03422490134835243, 0.04618391767144203, -0.0016750483773648739, -0.062484391033649445, -0.03158590942621231, -0.040945280343294144, -0.04425259679555893, 0.053905975073575974, -0.05091175064444542, -0.06319936364889145, -0.06786400079727173, 0.004577185492962599, -0.01801212504506111, 0.020405562594532967, -0.01941589266061783, 0.05249554291367531, 0.04124952480196953, -0.07653750479221344, 0.026294788345694542, -0.007352090440690517, 0.05005786195397377, -0.001982237445190549, 0.0008875066414475441, -0.007784179877489805, 0.014622393064200878, 0.0015626868698745966, -0.0058997804298996925, -0.0857531800866127, -0.059807948768138885, 0.01911497302353382 ]
<p>I tried to find some relation between these distance (loss) measures, but couldn't find any references. However, I think it must something like this: $$ \sqrt 2*D_{KL} &lt; L_1 &lt; L_2 $$ Is that right?</p>
g36644
[ -0.024435460567474365, -0.03563337400555611, -0.017505941912531853, -0.016321679577231407, -0.014307903125882149, -0.001646027434617281, -0.04599572718143463, -0.07696270942687988, -0.014799156226217747, -0.028418321162462234, -0.04090123623609543, 0.030966805294156075, 0.055907778441905975, 0.012612605467438698, -0.03231297805905342, 0.0020077964290976524, 0.05080331861972809, -0.022051939740777016, -0.0060542868450284, 0.021197153255343437, -0.019100483506917953, -0.0008236901485361159, -0.03905072808265686, -0.0327681303024292, 0.06481765955686569, -0.05773945525288582, 0.03434854373335838, 0.008677907288074493, -0.0719459056854248, 0.026707423850893974, 0.04479233920574188, -0.026433167979121208, 0.05819462984800339, -0.05276630446314812, -0.022794798016548157, -0.00887514278292656, 0.05539799481630325, -0.007970372214913368, 0.022009344771504402, 0.007905766367912292, 0.031593844294548035, -0.02810177579522133, 0.03041890822350979, 0.009813763201236725, 0.03252103179693222, -0.05972049757838249, -0.08507588505744934, 0.014509551227092743, -0.0002978625998366624, 0.0017623391468077898, 0.0025743169244378805, 0.03366765379905701, 0.04942132160067558, -0.0013432941632345319, -0.002216140041127801, -0.02779383584856987, -0.01442386582493782, 0.005893144756555557, 0.01975066587328911, 0.023037850856781006, 0.00692595262080431, -0.02904893457889557, -0.02192222699522972, 0.008780794218182564, 0.09448280185461044, 0.0021652241703122854, 0.04212850704789162, -0.01085764728486538, -0.025630958378314972, 0.012682538479566574, 0.02511921338737011, 0.005235707852989435, 0.03979106619954109, 0.014296692796051502, -0.04210329428315163, -0.029314879328012466, 0.03439218923449516, 0.023176131770014763, 0.055912502110004425, -0.0035777639131993055, -0.06638706475496292, 0.008600451052188873, 0.03130456060171127, 0.051089417189359665, 0.01713486760854721, 0.07587140798568726, 0.01568082720041275, 0.03850483149290085, -0.030701031908392906, 0.05436183884739876, -0.041855473071336746, -0.060254115611314774, 0.05945989862084389, 0.034324441105127335, -0.046047091484069824, -0.020416194573044777, -0.014979781582951546, 0.01032087579369545, 0.01894744299352169, -0.017177002504467964, 0.02357146143913269, 0.020163683220744133, -0.016326935961842537, -0.018269412219524384, -0.03683305159211159, -0.00523722218349576, 0.05468832701444626, 0.015415161848068237, 0.022072942927479744, -0.0026405570097267628, 0.0007506853435188532, -0.014640150591731071, -0.05466762185096741, -0.06149262189865112, 0.07164105027914047, -0.05965562164783478, 0.018373461440205574, -0.0578899011015892, 0.0483153760433197, 0.03101571463048458, 0.044135645031929016, 0.04192066565155983, 0.06167665123939514, 0.07929068058729172, 0.03575076535344124, 0.046291835606098175, 0.0021286981645971537, -0.006453441455960274, 0.05676892027258873, 0.039674773812294006, 0.007710781414061785, -0.03562651202082634, 0.009767546318471432, 0.01912449114024639, 0.011769293807446957, 0.019809871912002563, 0.016007445752620697, 0.08091859519481659, -0.006875425577163696, -0.030137093737721443, -0.06068512052297592, -0.01788673922419548, 0.030104100704193115, -0.027108412235975266, -0.02985372021794319, 0.019268585368990898, 0.034467387944459915, -0.029003560543060303, -0.030619097873568535, -0.0646117702126503, 0.0315420888364315, 0.01025138795375824, -0.04525681585073471, 0.04805312678217888, 0.0033273622393608093, 0.001787171815522015, 0.01913856528699398, 0.030032722279429436, -0.001337473513558507, -0.032393164932727814, -0.03659140691161156, 0.006186085753142834, 0.021357614547014236, 0.016108384355902672, -0.019699858501553535, -0.018996594473719597, 0.045834217220544815, 0.006747834850102663, -0.011849419213831425, -0.04074385389685631, -0.005390841979533434, 0.008086249232292175, 0.06304022669792175, 0.040467768907547, -0.01088144164532423, 0.013576948083937168, -0.018888987600803375, 0.04715337976813316, -0.0009238313068635762, -0.049371205270290375, -0.019174881279468536, 0.02386303059756756, 0.03134150058031082, -0.014438413083553314, 0.01340410578995943, 0.01356098148971796, -0.00014717374870087951, -0.01377479825168848, -0.032442279160022736, 0.007296128198504448, 0.022925060242414474, -0.03824320062994957, 0.0353088416159153, 0.02513415366411209, -0.040687013417482376, 0.0629541203379631, 0.004649429116398096, 0.012806019745767117, -0.02386736124753952, -0.022993436083197594, 0.024561669677495956, 0.025750530883669853, 0.00970415398478508, -0.018857955932617188, 0.016329050064086914, -0.02431008592247963, 0.025498004630208015, 0.005040366668254137, 0.033884380012750626, -0.015110721811652184, -0.047443173825740814, -0.042881302535533905, -0.03765763342380524, -0.011247154325246811, 0.053934354335069656, -0.015241052955389023, -0.020192576572299004, 0.06687605381011963, 0.01160501316189766, -0.0009274767362512648, -0.05830618739128113, -0.002541914116591215, 0.05127662047743797, -0.044429149478673935, 0.00788517389446497, 0.06554014980792999, 0.00723771657794714, -0.02203109860420227, -0.04478222504258156, -0.0073431311175227165, -0.04550747945904732, -0.07060330361127853, 0.014551942236721516, 0.019548112526535988, 0.028650224208831787, 0.050455816090106964, 0.04535451903939247, 0.0394950769841671, -0.013543550856411457, 0.034702569246292114, 0.03822803497314453, -0.036734145134687424, -0.026542803272604942, 0.09425771981477737, 0.022001080214977264, 0.028162702918052673, -0.011415905319154263, 0.055823057889938354, -0.011480598710477352, 0.036048438400030136, -0.028885724022984505, 0.06321655958890915, 0.02932511642575264, -0.047956861555576324, 0.046657733619213104, -0.001026080222800374, 0.016504041850566864, -0.011791610158979893, 0.004835509229451418, -0.027154909446835518, -0.07908271253108978, -0.00009481609595241025, -0.04269197955727577, -0.017782101407647133, 0.0038329255767166615, -0.03199957311153412, 0.023411769419908524, 0.003164964960888028, 0.004812142346054316, -0.019772086292505264, -0.028526535257697105, 0.03363053873181343, 0.03895898535847664, 0.02285918779671192, 0.02336968295276165, -0.062326811254024506, -0.015360089018940926, -0.03158052638173103, -0.004466500133275986, -0.025910688564181328, 0.04040202870965004, -0.0015752800973132253, -0.019047003239393234, -0.025138508528470993, 0.022559350356459618, -0.021438317373394966, 0.022173136472702026, 0.05470658466219902, 0.011982991360127926, 0.028577489778399467, -0.008969705551862717, 0.021753987297415733, 0.03590407222509384, 0.001305488869547844, 0.01672929897904396, -0.017525674775242805, 0.028205174952745438, -0.0013636305229738355, 0.04341060295701027, -0.062294986099004745, -0.00036705535603687167, 0.022277988493442535, -0.041793495416641235, -0.022044073790311813, 0.018168164417147636, -0.00018678528431337327, -0.000002968451326523791, -0.057425353676080704, -0.025974439457058907, -0.009507711976766586, 0.0414389967918396, -0.025317540392279625, 0.04991660267114639, 0.021392822265625, -0.016684813424944878, -0.031933847814798355, 0.0103713758289814, 0.040834348648786545, -0.04166710749268532, 0.0016692510107532144, 0.029202111065387726, -0.08771366626024246, -0.020805392414331436, -0.0018751784227788448, -0.025545286014676094, -0.010589205659925938, -0.12978896498680115, 0.021226035431027412, -0.0256425179541111, -0.002579638734459877, -0.02465842291712761, 0.045613113790750504, 0.014375426806509495, -0.050099603831768036, -0.026730980724096298, 0.015667302533984184, -0.022613108158111572, 0.008191069588065147, 0.02118978276848793, 0.0395243763923645, -0.0364830307662487, 0.017272677272558212, -0.05894935503602028, 0.005851572845131159, -0.02511618472635746, -0.005188704468309879, 0.030830351635813713, 0.04513568431138992, -0.004589139949530363, -0.08463606983423233, -0.029849590733647346, -0.049888115376234055, 0.04469390586018562, 0.006656758487224579, 0.00539360148832202, 0.062300898134708405, 0.0010389317758381367, -0.03516906127333641, -0.017901619896292686, -0.02559720166027546, 0.03330250829458237, -0.020239312201738358, -0.02018698863685131, -0.013482124544680119, -0.006839407607913017, -0.07888785004615784, 0.018893767148256302, 0.04243336245417595, 0.004949015565216541, 0.010347755625844002, 0.011720232665538788, 0.03332138434052467, -0.004481073003262281, 0.030284304171800613, -0.027981644496321678, -0.04208748787641525, -0.017989855259656906, 0.01375401858240366, -0.08381911367177963, 0.0200960636138916, 0.054150283336639404, 0.05167009308934212, 0.0028925968799740076, 0.054341092705726624, 0.0062800063751637936, -0.08659674972295761, -0.025353873148560524, -0.0037721043918281794, 0.03825192153453827, -0.02005498670041561, -0.06362918764352798, -0.04840018227696419, -0.04695042595267296, 0.014727245084941387, 0.004701524972915649, 0.012809762731194496, 0.028812697157263756, 0.058032650500535965, 0.028344620019197464, 0.04878440499305725, -0.060978859663009644, 0.005172406788915396, 0.022759633138775826, -0.01420174352824688, 0.03905365243554115, -0.058919649571180344, 0.04499591141939163, 0.023548699915409088, 0.01237587258219719, 0.02078966796398163, -0.042103078216314316, -0.022247033193707466, -0.015295819379389286, -0.04207761213183403, 0.042666297405958176, -0.012482928112149239, -0.01850161887705326, -0.014500575140118599, 0.014854352921247482, 0.02109076827764511, -0.025452669709920883, -0.030519936233758926, -0.018914617598056793, -0.0013899197801947594, -0.010187692940235138, -0.0012925484916195273, 0.013869869522750378, -0.005459545645862818, 0.0175977423787117, -0.0046627274714410305, 0.002084810985252261, 0.02884548529982567, 0.0148469228297472, 0.060052257031202316, 0.015688272193074226, 0.00805396307259798, -0.0031560342758893967, 0.013608961366117, -0.020129231736063957, -0.04100632667541504, -0.033145174384117126, 0.002729930682107806, -0.014035528525710106, -0.02546439692378044, 0.0015515765408053994, -0.0026518225204199553, 0.0010615502251312137, 0.0035482861567288637, 0.02637992985546589, -0.019873127341270447, -0.016874877735972404, 0.0456153079867363, 0.010203621350228786, -0.026952706277370453, 0.0296959038823843, -0.03443777933716774, 0.0102472435683012, 0.009475919418036938, 0.016860883682966232, 0.024031639099121094, 0.007293655537068844, 0.024046309292316437, 0.010828880593180656, -0.01884118653833866, 0.027394430711865425, -0.02185695804655552, -0.08327799290418625, -0.004308342467993498, -0.08055276423692703, -0.04235836863517761, 0.009507391601800919, -0.012354575097560883, -0.025092408061027527, -0.021049706265330315, 0.00113043247256428, 0.026200734078884125, -0.05727457255125046, 0.014690949581563473, 0.0007369163795374334, -0.03247945010662079, -0.013049830682575703, -0.021766990423202515, -0.07282541692256927, -0.018960015848279, -0.0309755802154541, 0.02980785258114338, -0.009665992110967636, -0.056372079998254776, 0.03729003667831421, 0.031159520149230957, 0.0130577702075243, -0.01270981039851904, 0.030500322580337524, 0.0702243521809578, 0.004720349330455065, 0.057348910719156265, -0.0014797300100326538, -0.00637966301292181, 0.0232983510941267, 0.021317699924111366, -0.004792922176420689, 0.019763197749853134, 0.0035498258657753468, -0.031903937458992004, 0.002112838439643383, 0.016441740095615387, 0.07793301343917847, 0.030885687097907066, -0.011909285560250282, -0.003215497126802802, -0.025928622111678123, 0.05915079265832901, -0.0009276653872802854, 0.03736073151230812, 0.0327247753739357, 0.027418602257966995, 0.01997005194425583, 0.02764575183391571, -0.04196649417281151, 0.10082002729177475, 0.051002733409404755, 0.0111496951431036, -0.004893288481980562, 0.0017775752348825336, 0.04658079147338867, -0.015705157071352005, -0.0573447085916996, 0.00765728484839201, -0.01358829252421856, -0.0050868988037109375, 0.02135429158806801, 0.010491072200238705, -0.035629525780677795, -0.052598562091588974, -0.036130115389823914, -0.06658724695444107, 0.003992992453277111, 0.01301233284175396, -0.04040363430976868, -0.020777959376573563, -0.004207094199955463, 0.015206552110612392, -0.06139820069074631, 0.08215958625078201, 0.025180742144584656, 0.01798732578754425, 0.0360494889318943, -0.09633868932723999, 0.02012716606259346, -0.031452372670173645, 0.025752568617463112, -0.019008563831448555, 0.007181404624134302, -0.016080008819699287, -0.003255743533372879, -0.015670083463191986, 0.04230254143476486, -0.04970845952630043, -0.053247470408678055, -0.004877839237451553, 0.013261493295431137, -0.016186418011784554, -0.01722930558025837, -0.016044167801737785, 0.034603677690029144, -0.08369961380958557, 0.013929381035268307, 0.04515261575579643, 0.06406369805335999, 0.06391724944114685, -0.024340230971574783, -0.057512588798999786, 0.003358751768246293, -0.029712216928601265, -0.012769107706844807, 0.048716951161623, -0.0340159609913826, -0.09409447759389877, 0.06071588024497032, -0.0482260137796402, -0.01518171839416027, 0.007494976278394461, 0.02094023860991001, -0.059023864567279816, -0.0492636077105999, 0.06377600133419037, 0.056655991822481155, -0.0217246375977993, 0.045144032686948776, 0.0332234725356102, -0.048959143459796906, 0.028664223849773407, -0.015614981763064861, -0.05972990766167641, -0.06895989924669266, 0.022409718483686447, 0.007749358657747507, 0.014824597164988518, -0.007252983748912811, -0.05274311080574989, -0.010342130437493324, -0.007261825725436211, 0.05293027684092522, -0.10458271205425262, -0.019729508087038994, 0.06971704959869385, 0.007112366613000631, -0.009266541339457035, -0.004330575466156006, 0.015333733521401882, -0.044574204832315445, 0.07624006271362305, 0.024515600875020027, 0.08215023577213287, 0.014591054990887642, -0.05666586756706238, -0.02260812558233738, -0.021392809227108955, -0.07641579955816269, -0.015369645319879055, 0.051905557513237, -0.03404052183032036, -0.031238630414009094, 0.01690364070236683, 0.009350763633847237, 0.07046438753604889, -0.06619299948215485, 0.017327355220913887, -0.025742219761013985, 0.018903974443674088, -0.04619729891419411, -0.03728313744068146, 0.06187469884753227, -0.023390913382172585, -0.02203521691262722, 0.04938744753599167, -0.018184199929237366, 0.030720463022589684, 0.05912376940250397, 0.04325852543115616, 0.03145447000861168, 0.0367879681289196, -0.01662473753094673, -0.030742669478058815, -0.04797682538628578, -0.03789408132433891, 0.010156420059502125, -0.06538061052560806, -0.043599266558885574, 0.011934073641896248, 0.013322052545845509, 0.07206232845783234, -0.04071500152349472, -0.012083630077540874, -0.003976841922849417, -0.022177163511514664, 0.03795526549220085, -0.03627384454011917, 0.030104873701930046, -0.029907364398241043, -0.006600275170058012, -0.06014513969421387, -0.03970568627119064, -0.007380234077572823, -0.008044487796723843, 0.07597873359918594, -0.0617964081466198, -0.051073379814624786, -0.035961952060461044, -0.03706606104969978, 0.05603131651878357, 0.029858028516173363, -0.015527057461440563, 0.009268321096897125, -0.04908287152647972, 0.04275697097182274, 0.012797258794307709, 0.00997777096927166, -0.018553055822849274, 0.00236340775154531, 0.042689889669418335, -0.004218151792883873, -0.02509140782058239, 0.0019291742937639356, -0.04904193803668022, 0.05404718592762947, 0.005144926719367504, -0.019047239795327187, 0.041786789894104004, 0.029107173904776573, -0.05461990088224411, -0.03621073067188263, -0.0019455229630693793, 0.0018021201249212027, 0.004538214299827814, -0.0019626824650913477, 0.039662301540374756, 0.049837082624435425, -0.03252101317048073, -0.008337754756212234, 0.018956614658236504, 0.033715371042490005, -0.02304937317967415, 0.06311839818954468, 0.035405561327934265, -0.025601588189601898, 0.02336476929485798, -0.07974216341972351, -0.0005711423582397401, 0.01699996367096901, -0.007755650207400322, -0.006749921943992376, -0.009252232499420643, -0.035307638347148895, 0.0552753210067749, 0.05797535926103592, 0.035942722111940384, -0.01570654660463333, 0.000744474760722369, -0.04516865313053131, 0.06541574001312256, -0.02953259088099003, 0.05344105884432793, -0.05694799870252609, -0.02557428553700447, -0.058508165180683136, 0.06282864511013031, 0.021058350801467896, -0.00911567360162735, 0.0147242471575737, -0.02569425106048584, -0.020721126347780228, -0.03542991355061531, -0.02982494793832302, 0.009829623624682426, 0.013196831569075584, -0.004972879774868488, 0.042941492050886154, 0.0465303510427475, 0.06476209312677383, -0.08406046032905579, 0.011058634147047997, 0.04738999530673027, 0.03675003722310066, 0.015154073014855385, -0.08208900690078735, 0.04937661811709404, 0.030407903715968132, 0.000940959551371634, -0.02735808864235878, -0.007016458082944155, 0.013673551380634308, 0.0005457440856844187, 0.03769788146018982, -0.0035771247930824757, 0.0032145248260349035, -0.04948083683848381, 0.02273005060851574, -0.005681100767105818, -0.03935036435723305, -0.016791874542832375, -0.04641015827655792, -0.05884111300110817, 0.044896140694618225, -0.03433121740818024, -0.007060015574097633, -0.027207735925912857, 0.02421671524643898 ]
<p>Which correlation coefficient is the most appropriate to compare 2 time series? I want to compare the variation of one variable for 2 regions, have regional data for the last 30 years. Is Pearson correlation ok or should I rely on Kendall's tau b or Spearman's rho and why? I tried to google it and analyse what I found, but I'm still not sure.</p>
g74023
[ 0.05905720219016075, -0.04165223240852356, -0.0026841277722269297, -0.06365576386451721, -0.013106233440339565, 0.02624663896858692, 0.05343884974718094, -0.02249729633331299, -0.0010129738366231322, -0.034554265439510345, 0.04735926538705826, 0.039220526814460754, -0.006873146165162325, -0.020206134766340256, -0.02400527149438858, -0.030690601095557213, 0.0038369183894246817, -0.0053606219589710236, -0.015545194037258625, -0.015279068611562252, -0.057639576494693756, 0.010388210415840149, 0.012323921546339989, 0.017208360135555267, 0.024081405252218246, -0.025257647037506104, 0.021377762779593468, 0.0000672753740218468, -0.038934167474508286, 0.010615579783916473, 0.0679033100605011, -0.00303240236826241, 0.0368296317756176, -0.06287584453821182, -0.028266694396734238, -0.0021422377321869135, -0.0238344743847847, 0.01049785502254963, 0.010007500648498535, 0.009814906865358353, -0.049899544566869736, 0.041892584413290024, 0.04840531572699547, 0.02687108889222145, 0.039597488939762115, -0.026024186983704567, -0.0506625659763813, 0.013174055144190788, -0.08749671280384064, -0.013770464807748795, -0.03260204195976257, 0.05407173931598663, 0.04051561281085014, -0.04034316912293434, 0.0017467194702476263, -0.03064725734293461, 0.057656724005937576, 0.044359948486089706, 0.04382769763469696, 0.06145250052213669, 0.03343919664621353, -0.00457576010376215, -0.0679195374250412, -0.038728341460227966, -0.011790015734732151, 0.033926282078027725, 0.022908203303813934, 0.012424629181623459, -0.0006955243879929185, 0.013147427700459957, -0.008631196804344654, -0.06861351430416107, 0.05295075103640556, 0.02205013297498226, -0.05659426003694534, -0.005095669534057379, -0.02311093918979168, -0.025118932127952576, 0.028614433482289314, 0.03341739997267723, -0.00608612596988678, 0.017094867303967476, -0.023321308195590973, 0.07565050572156906, 0.02384977787733078, -0.03954501822590828, 0.007070325314998627, -0.003441666951403022, -0.0008544005104340613, 0.007775920443236828, 0.027473902329802513, 0.06325916200876236, 0.05777857452630997, 0.05965781956911087, 0.016240278258919716, -0.0435454398393631, -0.043394070118665695, 0.03306131064891815, -0.008364380337297916, 0.03548109158873558, -0.026329051703214645, 0.01036226935684681, -0.01888212375342846, 0.041037220507860184, -0.05689436197280884, -0.07486199587583542, 0.030261076986789703, -0.022679468616843224, -0.06148112937808037, -0.05311562865972519, -0.07206917554140091, 0.02988991141319275, -0.010498161427676678, -0.0077952113933861256, 0.00462793605402112, -0.043724361807107925, -0.0046539753675460815, -0.0629015862941742, 0.027305731549859047, -0.00019672319467645139, -0.03839650750160217, 0.0021404875442385674, 0.03131226822733879, 0.08824599534273148, -0.04118974134325981, 0.029011273756623268, -0.026402220129966736, 0.02793487161397934, -0.011196712963283062, -0.002303455024957657, 0.02761431224644184, -0.06365054845809937, -0.0335509218275547, 0.04955938085913658, 0.004809417761862278, 0.03205930441617966, -0.017761914059519768, 0.0737147256731987, -0.042048078030347824, 0.028860511258244514, -0.003984734416007996, -0.030499618500471115, 0.005499207880347967, -0.03843415528535843, -0.05583764985203743, 0.07256884127855301, 0.04847101494669914, -0.06185319274663925, -0.014477969147264957, 0.03048081323504448, 0.07084289193153381, -0.015435784123837948, -0.024832645431160927, 0.018401052802801132, -0.06600505858659744, 0.024000540375709534, 0.05123579502105713, 0.009286269545555115, 0.04002435877919197, 0.0364714190363884, -0.07144517451524734, 0.004616999998688698, 0.10198386758565903, 0.055555880069732666, 0.03236749395728111, -0.03378782793879509, 0.011720504611730576, -0.009715693071484566, -0.026887349784374237, -0.0973576232790947, 0.01214111689478159, -0.0306224524974823, 0.036767058074474335, -0.03414147347211838, 0.03239818662405014, -0.04763320833444595, 0.020818646997213364, -0.004371020011603832, 0.0253522377461195, 0.04389693960547447, -0.019277971237897873, 0.030834462493658066, -0.011747372336685658, 0.0029152941424399614, 0.006737117189913988, -0.07320685684680939, -0.0033793265465646982, -0.033202700316905975, -0.04337148368358612, 0.005542673636227846, -0.026446519419550896, -0.06959967315196991, -0.07026232033967972, -0.05097860097885132, -0.03839139640331268, 0.005915295798331499, 0.034124188125133514, -0.037226997315883636, -0.006529310252517462, 0.00420332420617342, 0.029049409553408623, -0.014381429180502892, 0.04488884285092354, 0.055337414145469666, -0.0026880146469920874, 0.009674341417849064, -0.007033792790025473, 0.01903567649424076, -0.012411300092935562, -0.025957182049751282, -0.02869224362075329, 0.03839508071541786, -0.06410916894674301, 0.03410019725561142, 0.02413632720708847, 0.010897364467382431, -0.011173436418175697, 0.09063316881656647, -0.003022401127964258, 0.019744837656617165, -0.09657707810401917, 0.0213755015283823, 0.03629668056964874, -0.04353463649749756, 0.01426162663847208, 0.024110203608870506, 0.028884291648864746, 0.0017981770215556026, 0.023201139643788338, -0.0009568528039380908, -0.027095898985862732, -0.00836779922246933, 0.029090464115142822, -0.029423752799630165, -0.00917566753923893, 0.004195905290544033, 0.010975099168717861, 0.005479552783071995, 0.005296207498759031, 0.02828947827219963, -0.01944781094789505, -0.0003348370373714715, 0.013243576511740685, 0.08285293728113174, 0.02433435246348381, -0.0371539369225502, 0.009412762708961964, 0.008700515143573284, 0.007644585333764553, 0.032027311623096466, 0.01330751832574606, 0.02508075349032879, -0.018642384558916092, -0.007365263067185879, 0.0279048103839159, -0.009767940267920494, 0.01602831482887268, 0.0651056095957756, -0.015316612087190151, 0.007520610000938177, -0.035705648362636566, 0.003076909575611353, -0.0005009174346923828, -0.0024981494061648846, 0.025459133088588715, 0.029351137578487396, -0.019779952242970467, -0.02197837270796299, -0.023265432566404343, -0.054908256977796555, -0.006201550830155611, 0.03447086364030838, 0.04071851447224617, 0.05886589735746384, 0.01323204766958952, -0.03251026198267937, -0.03515729308128357, -0.024057069793343544, -0.001739006256684661, -0.04349902644753456, 0.0220531914383173, -0.025737106800079346, 0.04782703146338463, 0.03412095457315445, 0.04144832491874695, -0.004819735884666443, 0.07445985078811646, 0.04910639300942421, -0.05273432657122612, 0.019160635769367218, 0.03275449573993683, 0.05771994963288307, -0.04733311012387276, -0.011004902422428131, 0.0016973387682810426, 0.048147980123758316, 0.028393536806106567, -0.09060224145650864, 0.037874072790145874, 0.010453440248966217, 0.031967248767614365, -0.05314915254712105, -0.025604650378227234, 0.0038098380900919437, 0.07740453630685806, -0.004621281288564205, -0.02649051696062088, -0.03819677233695984, 0.042675409466028214, -0.03155805543065071, -0.03852995112538338, -0.011645922437310219, 0.017057549208402634, 0.006536634173244238, 0.025745028629899025, 0.011378128081560135, 0.037485841661691666, 0.061599068343639374, -0.005778882186859846, 0.034451842308044434, 0.053469397127628326, -0.0678931325674057, 0.03412541747093201, 0.014415988698601723, -0.005031188018620014, 0.03256659954786301, -0.02693050168454647, 0.04630865901708603, -0.08811838179826736, 0.055120229721069336, -0.03311466798186302, -0.0068251644261181355, 0.023332718759775162, -0.043041568249464035, -0.04281884431838989, 0.016599565744400024, 0.035397451370954514, -0.01713433302938938, -0.06081884726881981, 0.0440242625772953, -0.0380171500146389, -0.029764017090201378, 0.02098744735121727, 0.01581152155995369, 0.009222921915352345, -0.0035722434986382723, 0.06577854603528976, 0.0015296123456209898, 0.038591232150793076, 0.002585394075140357, -0.0005405804258771241, 0.046239223331213, 0.025197064504027367, 0.0006085518398322165, 0.03252498805522919, -0.03805870562791824, 0.02199247106909752, 0.010136432945728302, 0.0174392182379961, -0.0354764498770237, 0.03983493521809578, -0.024141592904925346, -0.046909838914871216, -0.045112065970897675, -0.052435919642448425, -0.017139585688710213, -0.012085468508303165, 0.05457844212651253, 0.004984039347618818, -0.023303557187318802, 0.03414805233478546, 0.098404161632061, 0.030387433245778084, -0.05313444882631302, -0.03692465275526047, 0.0002906052104663104, -0.044931162148714066, 0.04527678340673447, 0.013784539885818958, 0.04322678595781326, 0.011451130732893944, -0.0307201836258173, 0.015062744729220867, 0.02330378256738186, -0.02719387598335743, -0.042444366961717606, 0.017653105780482292, 0.012600268237292767, -0.0016209526220336556, -0.07482217997312546, 0.0019678976386785507, -0.031588003039360046, -0.007994432002305984, 0.000027523159587872215, 0.06635866314172745, 0.029874511063098907, 0.019056538119912148, 0.05488097667694092, 0.06631018221378326, 0.003141526598483324, -0.07935333251953125, -0.03188709169626236, 0.010504880920052528, 0.03479659557342529, -0.03854323551058769, -0.01235562190413475, -0.025391370058059692, -0.03451206162571907, -0.002876745304092765, -0.04290076717734337, -0.03010035865008831, 0.05264677479863167, 0.021331848576664925, -0.019870443269610405, -0.025308366864919662, -0.01097183208912611, 0.012323546223342419, -0.0019608314614742994, 0.015747863799333572, 0.0263572596013546, -0.04752962291240692, -0.01066711638122797, -0.0017784563824534416, -0.04307170212268829, 0.012659764848649502, -0.06465525180101395, 0.00964618194848299, -0.014006659388542175, -0.032066378742456436, 0.023506352677941322, 0.0566999688744545, 0.023322833701968193, 0.02211335301399231, 0.004120297264307737, -0.043033991008996964, 0.017659775912761688, 0.010304644703865051, -0.01711178943514824, 0.0010859932517632842, -0.07195647060871124, 0.009965416043996811, -0.034456025809049606, 0.005305607803165913, 0.03968270868062973, -0.062485579401254654, 0.03727717697620392, 0.020846085622906685, -0.0034173207823187113, 0.006073645316064358, -0.007472570054233074, -0.01257762685418129, 0.02180800586938858, 0.04287419840693474, -0.03316580876708031, -0.04324553906917572, 0.0015813258942216635, 0.0647580698132515, -0.0018041343428194523, 0.022745702415704727, 0.026048559695482254, -0.06110496446490288, -0.0440070740878582, -0.003194981487467885, -0.05921872332692146, 0.038076940923929214, -0.024705639109015465, -0.05122232437133789, -0.017238367348909378, -0.033490438014268875, 0.002594036515802145, -0.008659275248646736, -0.05852532386779785, -0.004143542144447565, -0.024443838745355606, -0.0010334892431274056, -0.013183637522161007, -0.022145509719848633, -0.04495694488286972, 0.041139498353004456, -0.006207239348441362, -0.011730378493666649, 0.003016685601323843, 0.0036528808996081352, 0.0004971754970028996, -0.0032458824571222067, -0.047329917550086975, -0.00348397227935493, -0.05025171488523483, 0.053891632705926895, -0.00840755645185709, 0.01413756050169468, 0.02502007782459259, 0.08370871841907501, 0.05476684123277664, 0.043061088770627975, -0.014481420628726482, 0.005212440155446529, -0.041409995406866074, 0.021539073437452316, 0.003985163755714893, -0.04297293350100517, 0.07481931895017624, 0.017151763662695885, 0.002908875932916999, -0.009344149380922318, -0.018514089286327362, 0.06607456505298615, -0.041152697056531906, 0.022558216005563736, 0.0776033103466034, -0.006779020186513662, 0.015000500716269016, 0.0305216945707798, 0.021362993866205215, -0.03516757860779762, 0.0316171757876873, 0.00482474360615015, 0.05808336287736893, -0.014152157120406628, -0.07416506111621857, 0.01614120416343212, -0.0038230824284255505, 0.033154964447021484, 0.027617959305644035, -0.0320039764046669, -0.020891087129712105, -0.020556313917040825, -0.007730946410447359, -0.034270189702510834, -0.06239493563771248, 0.004808647092431784, 0.022921934723854065, 0.023172153159976006, -0.011611844412982464, 0.0029220646247267723, -0.026227915659546852, -0.06890006363391876, -0.0009016399271786213, -0.014293836429715157, 0.0048731546849012375, -0.048004571348428726, 0.006967498920857906, 0.014640132896602154, -0.019283805042505264, 0.03415082022547722, -0.008874872699379921, 0.014301282353699207, -0.05331221967935562, -0.04101080447435379, -0.021466484293341637, -0.029484320431947708, 0.02034696191549301, -0.0062297191470861435, -0.02235659770667553, 0.0036914583761245012, -0.017127173021435738, 0.08869463950395584, -0.020508980378508568, -0.005856658797711134, 0.036765288561582565, -0.01374771073460579, -0.04852066561579704, 0.02272389829158783, 0.08695737272500992, -0.03082953952252865, -0.06162821501493454, -0.021572783589363098, 0.014686808921396732, 0.01827491819858551, 0.011691289022564888, -0.00858750194311142, -0.01900581456720829, -0.013715828768908978, 0.0033578285947442055, 0.028285110369324684, 0.0449027456343174, 0.01566416770219803, -0.014348668046295643, 0.024737998843193054, -0.019112104550004005, 0.021557392552495003, -0.05290767922997475, -0.03296324238181114, 0.01550175528973341, -0.05453827232122421, 0.05553542450070381, 0.005618472117930651, -0.016405122354626656, 0.015604197978973389, 0.02464951016008854, 0.0031964778900146484, -0.011201119981706142, 0.027473393827676773, -0.019316649064421654, 0.03530925139784813, -0.044532835483551025, -0.004539932124316692, 0.017118362709879875, -0.04025903716683388, -0.08122893422842026, 0.007392727769911289, -0.0032990570180118084, 0.03351541981101036, -0.04378300532698631, -0.00023122572747524828, 0.018963215872645378, 0.03293249011039734, 0.0014936842489987612, -0.014112093485891819, -0.02403351292014122, 0.01432099286466837, 0.011194514110684395, 0.027375105768442154, 0.021443651989102364, 0.001059437170624733, -0.02863900549709797, -0.03716496378183365, 0.01178255956619978, -0.06453883647918701, -0.01324630156159401, 0.035679180175065994, -0.05361802130937576, -0.034374386072158813, -0.03745137155056, 0.031704697757959366, 0.09414021670818329, -0.026903608813881874, 0.02634703926742077, -0.05123095586895943, -0.020506849512457848, 0.000992021756246686, 0.03062928467988968, -0.02811390906572342, 0.04829299449920654, -0.054403360933065414, -0.013667186722159386, -0.03702756017446518, 0.016752561554312706, -0.036037877202034, 0.019156988710165024, -0.02162393555045128, 0.025359375402331352, -0.024006571620702744, 0.008042555302381516, -0.012010044418275356, -0.006880417466163635, 0.08804800361394882, 0.02400815114378929, -0.07853154838085175, 0.02494318038225174, -0.015162447467446327, 0.005520214792340994, 0.012056919746100903, -0.08309122920036316, 0.047812312841415405, 0.005176599137485027, 0.0649944394826889, 0.001059293863363564, 0.10243339836597443, -0.007283810060471296, -0.025800200179219246, -0.004219123162329197, -0.05237487703561783, -0.023159416392445564, 0.0067842332646250725, 0.0749964490532875, -0.0007544616819359362, -0.02457793802022934, 0.07229094952344894, -0.04071050509810448, 0.040055807679891586, -0.005694921128451824, 0.009501677937805653, -0.013377226889133453, 0.03476199880242348, 0.03743366897106171, -0.0029445167165249586, -0.01214787270873785, 0.0006696933414787054, 0.03743818774819374, 0.026275483891367912, -0.06628017127513885, 0.00013141604722477496, -0.04383958876132965, -0.0021910087671130896, 0.06942307204008102, -0.028426598757505417, -0.03361980617046356, 0.0440295934677124, -0.056165896356105804, -0.03291330114006996, -0.016367511823773384, -0.0310013797134161, 0.0073030185885727406, -0.019123556092381477, 0.025002291426062584, 0.0102304108440876, -0.022288212552666664, -0.004919501952826977, -0.025558272376656532, 0.006198789458721876, 0.0223676897585392, -0.08554696291685104, -0.00879736989736557, -0.014538346789777279, 0.009377801790833473, 0.05370606854557991, -0.04269551485776901, -0.05280151963233948, -0.026262929663062096, 0.03787199780344963, 0.03185102343559265, 0.0745890811085701, 0.0042632692493498325, -0.0006860210560262203, -0.040558066219091415, 0.005026581231504679, -0.06000446155667305, 0.00917409360408783, 0.005409594159573317, -0.03696088120341301, -0.010512681677937508, 0.008467278443276882, -0.053519029170274734, -0.039909228682518005, -0.012009882368147373, 0.016707714647054672, 0.02837047353386879, 0.024539770558476448, -0.04163585230708122, -0.01174600888043642, -0.06459265947341919, -0.08479996025562286, 0.05814462527632713, 0.0027040336281061172, 0.04031125828623772, 0.046166133135557175, 0.0332515686750412, -0.028402933850884438, 0.02466735430061817, -0.021987885236740112, 0.033999163657426834, 0.027641136199235916, 0.05854388326406479, -0.01609671488404274, -0.04180263727903366, 0.031169265508651733, 0.05981960520148277, 0.008292311802506447, -0.04273926839232445, -0.026188857853412628, 0.05019373074173927, -0.03410017117857933, 0.016797035932540894, 0.0012777050724253058, 0.032507866621017456, 0.010361853986978531, 0.007081917487084866, 0.06194407120347023, 0.006870347540825605, 0.016002563759684563, 0.00937888864427805, -0.047915268689394, 0.006429309956729412, -0.006449321284890175, 0.0009985651122406125, -0.009330530650913715, 0.03623592108488083 ]
<p>I have learnt the definition of AIC for parametric model. But, what I want to know is that is there a semi-parametric version of AIC? Have you heard about it? And if you know, please show me a link, so I can have a look. </p>
g41742
[ -0.004432042594999075, 0.001152885495685041, 0.0010313935345038772, -0.0396188385784626, 0.030480727553367615, -0.03757186233997345, 0.047383688390254974, -0.008357602171599865, -0.05878978595137596, -0.007233605720102787, -0.03370875120162964, 0.0074004135094583035, 0.06704642623662949, -0.04019220918416977, 0.004439073149114847, -0.021595587953925133, 0.003459409112110734, -0.03424503281712532, 0.02855413779616356, -0.027722947299480438, 0.062468256801366806, -0.041326798498630524, 0.07475044578313828, -0.008095487020909786, -0.05040348693728447, 0.09472063928842545, -0.015754548832774162, 0.04003424569964409, -0.017699994146823883, -0.04203535616397858, -0.031187638640403748, -0.019083451479673386, 0.06528324633836746, -0.0027657076716423035, -0.06337542831897736, -0.006880887318402529, 0.06332790106534958, -0.03896242380142212, -0.0006021467852406204, 0.056893255561590195, 0.006275226827710867, 0.043403249233961105, 0.00878891721367836, 0.00812283530831337, 0.010944615118205547, -0.020102348178625107, -0.007288969587534666, 0.024295179173350334, -0.01714424602687359, 0.024525905027985573, 0.01764148473739624, 0.0015079618897289038, -0.01367185078561306, 0.012407718226313591, 0.0035077889915555716, -0.011392607353627682, -0.001484650420024991, 0.019684767350554466, -0.009919333271682262, -0.030872048810124397, -0.031659360975027084, 0.06316155940294266, 0.00804715882986784, -0.030572732910513878, 0.03014451265335083, 0.007365770637989044, 0.010959109291434288, -0.08390364050865173, -0.0027772707398980856, 0.008361466228961945, -0.004183038603514433, -0.009990818798542023, 0.012626837007701397, -0.029231805354356766, -0.06885712593793869, -0.024350540712475777, -0.013597548939287663, -0.0011036288924515247, 0.020133232697844505, 0.022275129333138466, -0.009449794888496399, 0.02115987427532673, 0.03487187996506691, 0.033017393201589584, 0.033853210508823395, 0.0021285531111061573, -0.048344437032938004, -0.0259537436068058, 0.011415197513997555, -0.03857396915555, 0.010206935927271843, 0.028438936918973923, 0.008378131315112114, 0.006416090298444033, -0.03777306154370308, 0.004202609416097403, -0.0870557501912117, 0.051137298345565796, -0.050863370299339294, 0.05952952802181244, 0.019532574340701103, 0.011356653645634651, 0.046381864696741104, 0.014283356256783009, -0.016879715025424957, -0.037196699529886246, 0.001256143325008452, -0.005602359771728516, 0.0976756364107132, -0.0762285441160202, 0.02466609515249729, 0.005490116775035858, -0.02522795833647251, -0.031234892085194588, -0.06530129164457321, -0.01823999732732773, 0.023139145225286484, 0.048400696367025375, 0.008021784014999866, 0.024770274758338928, 0.04089304059743881, 0.04349508881568909, 0.0012766702566295862, 0.02116762101650238, -0.010494640097022057, -0.011749900877475739, -0.03643311187624931, 0.03222348168492317, -0.10664011538028717, 0.0525071956217289, 0.09728289395570755, 0.042303796857595444, 0.01187786366790533, 0.030065126717090607, -0.04396694153547287, 0.04196219518780708, -0.03417643904685974, -0.06015508621931076, -0.02770295925438404, 0.03359636291861534, -0.028390053659677505, 0.005806894041597843, -0.027606824412941933, 0.03015320934355259, -0.015313361771404743, 0.006050570867955685, 0.02115999534726143, 0.0023153601214289665, -0.07485789060592651, 0.013555738143622875, 0.05651358887553215, 0.056517500430345535, -0.028168518096208572, -0.019077125936746597, 0.0030859343241900206, -0.013441186398267746, -0.02690170705318451, -0.0005828054854646325, 0.0064776185899972916, -0.034441880881786346, 0.0026256265118718147, 0.040335338562726974, 0.019138744100928307, -0.019130637869238853, -0.026182003319263458, 0.027926309034228325, -0.019061939790844917, -0.021394990384578705, 0.011264017783105373, -0.03390242159366608, -0.024736449122428894, -0.011114888824522495, 0.032484106719493866, 0.004933715332299471, 0.008473485708236694, -0.007529685273766518, 0.04257640987634659, -0.022226670756936073, 0.014209589920938015, -0.012040454894304276, -0.017253125086426735, -0.028986802324652672, -0.0018634342122823, -0.06300134211778641, -0.039090774953365326, -0.028582558035850525, 0.05691659450531006, 0.04172797501087189, 0.007142683491110802, -0.013214072212576866, -0.010563037358224392, -0.04748165234923363, -0.03354654833674431, -0.044390078634023666, -0.033292077481746674, -0.0006761015974916518, 0.03430653735995293, -0.03270793706178665, 0.03100384771823883, 0.0064030056819319725, 0.061048198491334915, -0.01851809024810791, 0.0707039088010788, 0.04457422345876694, -0.013859763741493225, 0.03471991419792175, -0.020386915653944016, -0.010774253867566586, 0.051402561366558075, 0.036041297018527985, 0.013912218622863293, 0.010555045679211617, 0.03807444870471954, 0.0308474600315094, 0.005631990265101194, 0.039001770317554474, 0.01177887711673975, 0.0040663727559149265, -0.008340594358742237, -0.0098906010389328, 0.006993228569626808, -0.038040440529584885, -0.00813526101410389, -0.01710149087011814, -0.00778750516474247, -0.015943096950650215, 0.01461099274456501, 0.02420913800597191, 0.022977562621235847, -0.009190228767693043, 0.002438001800328493, -0.060995299369096756, 0.014827843755483627, -0.05269923061132431, 0.07745661586523056, 0.04895825684070587, 0.005107932258397341, -0.0003994895960204303, 0.005190604366362095, -0.0422612689435482, 0.04158148169517517, 0.018372735008597374, 0.04029491916298866, 0.024491479620337486, -0.012445826083421707, -0.010789799503982067, -0.004927197936922312, 0.021264562383294106, 0.04584050178527832, -0.03005741722881794, 0.02601047046482563, 0.012331578880548477, -0.012004728429019451, -0.06081242859363556, 0.025937825441360474, -0.021689530462026596, 0.03391879051923752, 0.036426570266485214, 0.01977982372045517, 0.05896822735667229, 0.035127706825733185, -0.024864409118890762, 0.019692203029990196, 0.0031864168122410774, 0.020912518724799156, 0.029464181512594223, 0.0034540712367743254, -0.014638951048254967, -0.029012173414230347, 0.051243383437395096, -0.00895658228546381, 0.06340902298688889, -0.00878373347222805, 0.007974659092724323, -0.03963271528482437, -0.002354198833927512, -0.04638984799385071, -0.027929143980145454, -0.016141299158334732, -0.06459841132164001, -0.017936434596776962, -0.02608361653983593, 0.0205882266163826, -0.015119370073080063, 0.053152650594711304, 0.017662888392806053, 0.06325144320726395, 0.03481507673859596, -0.09059339016675949, -0.008374645374715328, -0.04420642927289009, -0.043303098529577255, -0.018287837505340576, -0.020805250853300095, -0.0467463918030262, 0.030738312751054764, -0.028081823140382767, -0.004662797786295414, 0.027528123930096626, -0.006142111029475927, -0.075806625187397, -0.023966994136571884, 0.014408383518457413, -0.006738226395100355, 0.06558043509721756, 0.0023410350549966097, -0.008358204737305641, 0.002736068097874522, 0.018352363258600235, 0.02994154952466488, -0.06139250472187996, -0.03963329270482063, -0.015303085558116436, 0.0034061172045767307, 0.018125081434845924, -0.018133416771888733, -0.001034431392326951, -0.024259405210614204, 0.0028647645376622677, -0.008815620094537735, -0.012704338878393173, -0.10996097326278687, 0.004979360848665237, 0.04892357438802719, 0.014664141461253166, 0.04362420737743378, 0.02981770783662796, -0.00019149981380905956, -0.05184435844421387, -0.05595525726675987, 0.0430767759680748, -0.012841516174376011, 0.02161739207804203, 0.0380769819021225, -0.008585328236222267, -0.040486179292201996, -0.022891249507665634, 0.004656373057514429, 0.00016451087140012532, 0.017498629167675972, 0.0679229274392128, 0.0455440878868103, 0.05040633678436279, 0.004469246603548527, -0.033826541155576706, 0.012788352556526661, 0.049524880945682526, 0.01856623962521553, -0.014588182792067528, -0.020564772188663483, 0.004945916123688221, -0.006553578190505505, 0.028315488249063492, -0.06770242005586624, -0.007160594686865807, 0.028925785794854164, -0.015882177278399467, -0.048942532390356064, -0.0009952241089195013, 0.018279869109392166, -0.004894048906862736, -0.045830611139535904, 0.08401381969451904, -0.0015086648054420948, 0.003766390960663557, -0.016416937112808228, 0.05536004900932312, 0.06161470711231232, -0.012634600512683392, -0.0019994210451841354, 0.019144585356116295, -0.004102315288037062, 0.028023749589920044, -0.006490355357527733, -0.040742579847574234, 0.02683163993060589, -0.016968566924333572, -0.0012353530619293451, -0.02240702323615551, -0.012950046919286251, 0.014365505427122116, 0.008542346768081188, -0.013872621580958366, 0.039562612771987915, 0.0660162940621376, 0.01274131890386343, 0.02223169431090355, -0.012252463959157467, 0.042108893394470215, -0.09181030094623566, 0.02011893130838871, -0.014517402276396751, -0.033705174922943115, -0.04155822843313217, 0.008454766124486923, -0.0271926149725914, -0.047950971871614456, -0.027338778600096703, -0.0056719402782619, -0.00905146449804306, -0.07690270245075226, -0.027499524876475334, 0.016457442194223404, 0.025715583935379982, -0.016797108575701714, -0.04451557248830795, -0.05635518953204155, -0.030719757080078125, 0.014243670739233494, -0.00017829886928666383, 0.009627027437090874, 0.049880869686603546, -0.0022131854202598333, -0.0551145039498806, 0.01944340579211712, 0.02978149987757206, -0.0005853849579580128, 0.004473055712878704, 0.03046766109764576, 0.009153409861028194, -0.001385439420118928, 0.02621171809732914, -0.043583910912275314, -0.01236716378480196, 0.009878372773528099, 0.013222195208072662, -0.012093102559447289, -0.008694491349160671, 0.008662126958370209, -0.0429651141166687, 0.017339464277029037, -0.04586139693856239, -0.007848639972507954, 0.04603734239935875, -0.04778332635760307, 0.010498564690351486, 0.016836121678352356, 0.03193756565451622, -0.015261291526257992, -0.0946001410484314, 0.01585494913160801, 0.0721849575638771, 0.049973323941230774, -0.05469520762562752, 0.013670534826815128, -0.02850162796676159, 0.08274543285369873, -0.019240602850914, -0.10629470646381378, -0.01770663447678089, 0.005535193253308535, 0.07512514293193817, -0.0478491447865963, 0.030606552958488464, 0.03408108279109001, -0.008784118108451366, 0.021407704800367355, 0.023040730506181717, 0.06376626342535019, -0.03725051507353783, -0.055184997618198395, -0.022762734442949295, 0.07251381874084473, -0.012026271782815456, -0.00800638273358345, -0.03635193035006523, -0.09875006228685379, -0.03147139772772789, -0.05241404101252556, -0.007906956598162651, -0.02222474478185177, 0.02759673446416855, 0.042308565229177475, 0.02449811063706875, 0.010298984125256538, 0.033559706062078476, 0.025640958920121193, 0.05898262560367584, 0.02552182972431183, 0.00017082324484363198, -0.0025349499192088842, -0.020267484709620476, -0.02415028214454651, -0.04265594109892845, 0.015598728321492672, 0.023905452340841293, 0.017630979418754578, -0.03494493290781975, -0.06897617876529694, -0.022749755531549454, 0.0037432019598782063, 0.020065298303961754, -0.06701479107141495, -0.041630759835243225, -0.029921403154730797, -0.018824411556124687, 0.03123263083398342, 0.016306769102811813, 0.07384030520915985, 0.018124306574463844, -0.08178414404392242, -0.018904076889157295, 0.09805168211460114, -0.00983992125838995, -0.05257046967744827, 0.02158689685165882, 0.01537961233407259, -0.01992902159690857, -0.044051025062799454, 0.06256315112113953, 0.0033567151986062527, -0.0018935938132926822, 0.009319313801825047, 0.04179467633366585, -0.0012659145286306739, 0.015455356799066067, -0.00006020773798809387, 0.05884842574596405, -0.01570715196430683, -0.11432082951068878, 0.01764022558927536, -0.04363500699400902, -0.009945838712155819, 0.06344636529684067, -0.019930215552449226, -0.02012353017926216, -0.05129408463835716, -0.06392066180706024, 0.060897476971149445, -0.024328241124749184, -0.008408110588788986, 0.031203074380755424, 0.038870178163051605, 0.011575873009860516, -0.0003105290816165507, 0.027216836810112, -0.028340613469481468, 0.0399492010474205, 0.04675029590725899, -0.014480269514024258, 0.036307599395513535, -0.02896650694310665, 0.04749872535467148, 0.0069289300590753555, 0.04280148819088936, -0.005090042483061552, -0.0628155916929245, 0.06080598011612892, 0.0032799846958369017, -0.0354144349694252, 0.07124485820531845, 0.016423694789409637, 0.0388464592397213, -0.002230849117040634, 0.05742192640900612, -0.03499295935034752, -0.08824766427278519, -0.056458622217178345, 0.05358245223760605, 0.015591935254633427, -0.027096716687083244, 0.0483039990067482, 0.03053067997097969, -0.02793685905635357, -0.01235899142920971, -0.006948034279048443, -0.023873189464211464, 0.03730044141411781, 0.07676276564598083, 0.03445057198405266, 0.027202758938074112, -0.05350303277373314, 0.03688753396272659, -0.0007039052434265614, 0.004822921473532915, 0.028747696429491043, 0.025676120072603226, -0.04537537693977356, 0.00795694999396801, -0.009183038957417011, 0.022782472893595695, -0.06476049870252609, 0.0013546025147661567, 0.011266139335930347, 0.008845946751534939, 0.005124705843627453, 0.03577623516321182, 0.01647033356130123, -0.028892697766423225, 0.016806673258543015, -0.05743587389588356, -0.034558311104774475, -0.012823891825973988, -0.026570657268166542, 0.0739109218120575, 0.07904309779405594, -0.021311745047569275, 0.021210042759776115, 0.0178475771099329, -0.0672125592827797, -0.040985867381095886, 0.018109023571014404, -0.016417255625128746, -0.05596743896603584, 0.019997460767626762, 0.02114601992070675, 0.04485969990491867, 0.0027918454725295305, 0.0044872392900288105, -0.03989848494529724, -0.08942589163780212, 0.00613710843026638, 0.0044854991137981415, 0.017735661938786507, 0.005584191996604204, -0.07382354885339737, -0.04100007563829422, 0.02467881701886654, -0.03723827749490738, -0.03706745430827141, -0.03909445181488991, -0.07964394241571426, 0.017680883407592773, -0.006158547941595316, -0.029119960963726044, 0.019680391997098923, -0.015369727276265621, 0.06678960472345352, -0.046107035130262375, -0.001850249944254756, -0.06958767026662827, -0.03686084225773811, -0.0027835427317768335, -0.015284113585948944, -0.013121597468852997, 0.029021697118878365, -0.0641341358423233, 0.024013621732592583, 0.03731914609670639, 0.05802227184176445, 0.03639700263738632, -0.02094855345785618, -0.023138584569096565, -0.007243139669299126, 0.027051372453570366, -0.0489981509745121, 0.017591044306755066, 0.03270132839679718, -0.06578812748193741, -0.01159314252436161, 0.03749281167984009, 0.03404061868786812, -0.08414201438426971, -0.008959999307990074, -0.011357534676790237, 0.029875021427869797, -0.009204750880599022, 0.004840375855565071, 0.02495865523815155, 0.0011157867265865207, 0.007850704714655876, -0.01466235239058733, 0.00656463298946619, -0.0005529980990104377, 0.04663834348320961, 0.007763669826090336, -0.008312300778925419, -0.044217292219400406, -0.03296312689781189, 0.0016219097888097167, -0.04629978910088539, -0.038314227014780045, 0.015079274773597717, -0.007601471152156591, 0.017815828323364258, 0.052772510796785355, 0.043405067175626755, 0.025828396901488304, -0.016612213104963303, -0.085420623421669, -0.020057056099176407, 0.02361004799604416, 0.04667467251420021, -0.05350751057267189, -0.012567879632115364, -0.015077858231961727, -0.0038979407399892807, -0.03871777653694153, 0.012794511392712593, -0.060863006860017776, -0.004909886978566647, -0.01988193765282631, 0.054918378591537476, 0.015277653001248837, -0.01382378488779068, 0.032364580780267715, -0.005912405904382467, 0.07960495352745056, -0.0177012886852026, 0.035079602152109146, 0.0879189670085907, 0.02448292449116707, 0.014716938138008118, -0.014222375117242336, 0.017070716246962547, -0.026464415714144707, -0.037293098866939545, 0.03429257497191429, -0.018136469647288322, -0.012953586876392365, -0.024352438747882843, 0.04085731878876686, 0.03277745842933655, 0.029101625084877014, -0.023889603093266487, -0.0636502206325531, -0.06474961340427399, -0.009526544250547886, -0.021110547706484795, 0.0008626786293461919, 0.021951431408524513, -0.016065239906311035, -0.0256291925907135, -0.045412976294755936, -0.003418503561988473, -0.016035830602049828, -0.048869431018829346, -0.038536716252565384, 0.04041292890906334, 0.049327023327350616, -0.024424826726317406, 0.018168218433856964, -0.027838490903377533, 0.007039484567940235, 0.02475767768919468, 0.009505135007202625, 0.04878994822502136, 0.02289971336722374, -0.005798483267426491, 0.03027978166937828, -0.0695117935538292, -0.01756875030696392, 0.056835733354091644, 0.014463861472904682, 0.08358369767665863, 0.01983955316245556, -0.00893482193350792, 0.023194579407572746, 0.009191323071718216, 0.008913742378354073, 0.013733250088989735, 0.08184273540973663, -0.0003393702208995819, 0.0017995707457885146, 0.008675445802509785, 0.022101713344454765, -0.02307477407157421, 0.017076633870601654, -0.04103853553533554, -0.020891224965453148, 0.010740348137915134, -0.028097448870539665, 0.029443886131048203, 0.03336680680513382, -0.007760763168334961, 0.024561574682593346, -0.02892518974840641, 0.018598128110170364 ]
<p>Here is the problem: I am making a machine learning algorithm that takes the inputs and outputs of some software I've written, and I don't know how many datalines to produce to get results that are a 'good' fit. I realize the answer is 'the more the better' but I'm looking for any sort of minimum requirement. I also realize that the greater the number of variables the greater the number of datalines required. </p> <p>So I'm looking for a rule of thumb for number of variables to number of datalines. </p>
g74024
[ 0.0173981674015522, 0.016400843858718872, 0.004578893072903156, -0.07795079797506332, -0.02458069659769535, -0.049573563039302826, -0.01945577934384346, 0.03580586239695549, -0.07261693477630615, -0.03613981232047081, -0.034470777958631516, 0.008198697119951248, 0.04261085391044617, 0.045749031007289886, -0.003501615719869733, -0.020469000563025475, 0.008448897860944271, 0.023216167464852333, 0.002945315558463335, -0.00510186655446887, 0.03381868824362755, -0.016120795160531998, -0.002915015211328864, -0.02193545550107956, -0.05811981111764908, -0.02781188301742077, -0.06469833850860596, 0.027806822210550308, -0.04396443068981171, 0.054136212915182114, -0.03201168775558472, 0.01591441035270691, 0.05984516069293022, -0.07983127236366272, -0.032254986464977264, -0.011107553727924824, 0.003429759293794632, 0.021745510399341583, 0.030300268903374672, -0.03293660283088684, -0.028861263766884804, 0.017322847619652748, 0.03346234932541847, 0.0633368194103241, -0.027974817901849747, -0.0373314693570137, -0.0009809831390157342, -0.013109422288835049, 0.013685766607522964, -0.06015920639038086, -0.052208855748176575, -0.025454165413975716, -0.02758115902543068, -0.003422186244279146, -0.0043146670795977116, 0.028453709557652473, -0.030552146956324577, -0.0367320291697979, 0.0219590961933136, 0.025080373510718346, 0.09033339470624924, -0.05552377924323082, -0.07540132850408554, 0.020675096660852432, -0.010257852263748646, 0.04684630408883095, 0.01120203360915184, -0.0007808812661096454, 0.002399064600467682, 0.07244309782981873, -0.02387731894850731, -0.05020209401845932, 0.028754672035574913, -0.020914599299430847, -0.014483599923551083, -0.046294063329696655, -0.028276732191443443, 0.006666238885372877, -0.03311685845255852, 0.07498296350240707, 0.021598754450678825, -0.04343016818165779, -0.023727577179670334, 0.035514120012521744, 0.05491485819220543, 0.0004513435414992273, 0.02908460982143879, -0.02644195407629013, 0.013596560806035995, 0.07269373536109924, -0.029276469722390175, 0.02162039838731289, 0.06504302471876144, 0.007552446331828833, -0.002447925042361021, 0.01477410551160574, 0.002185262506827712, 0.006321299355477095, -0.023089338093996048, -0.0621313601732254, 0.021585658192634583, -0.01983608305454254, -0.014545864425599575, -0.06797481328248978, -0.014902601018548012, -0.018759367987513542, 0.05960685387253761, -0.04795244336128235, -0.03622639551758766, -0.030702900141477585, -0.04985585808753967, -0.005825843196362257, -0.041372328996658325, -0.07397415488958359, -0.0902644470334053, -0.0031247506849467754, 0.021623831242322922, 0.012378495186567307, 0.0033167977817356586, 0.038194723427295685, -0.030805354937911034, -0.042387112975120544, 0.06926123797893524, 0.03615240380167961, 0.03032444603741169, -0.056643564254045486, -0.07615768164396286, 0.08651094138622284, 0.014270126819610596, 0.01978703774511814, -0.014494890347123146, -0.04153717681765556, -0.004522013943642378, 0.010144079104065895, -0.017665889114141464, 0.04854394868016243, -0.017245769500732422, 0.037357147783041, 0.015041318722069263, 0.018682925030589104, 0.0038837608881294727, 0.017099997028708458, 0.001655431929975748, -0.028322549536824226, -0.0488937683403492, 0.028380101546645164, 0.005675312131643295, 0.04358450323343277, 0.016710704192519188, 0.014704248867928982, 0.04738515615463257, 0.013196311891078949, -0.0014476642245426774, -0.02076529711484909, -0.024562491104006767, -0.006887894589453936, 0.016098465770483017, -0.011580715887248516, 0.0012347099836915731, -0.02897636964917183, 0.009727650322020054, -0.07239867746829987, -0.06580790132284164, 0.048015303909778595, -0.035954177379608154, 0.020295822992920876, -0.030589455738663673, 0.02462572418153286, -0.010602185502648354, -0.006376142613589764, 0.029020650312304497, 0.004186776466667652, 0.02364451438188553, -0.01853259466588497, 0.06744255125522614, 0.024221573024988174, 0.047966111451387405, -0.06440681964159012, 0.06528636068105698, 0.0231960266828537, 0.013968542218208313, -0.02980079874396324, 0.00923047587275505, -0.014394814148545265, 0.007418341003358364, -0.05143153294920921, -0.037441547960042953, -0.019430913031101227, -0.024526624009013176, -0.0019530183635652065, -0.00986248068511486, 0.017775077372789383, 0.06423580646514893, -0.022666579112410545, -0.007797259371727705, 0.01103923749178648, 0.024530863389372826, -0.03171892091631889, -0.013823756016790867, -0.017533613368868828, 0.05051075294613838, 0.03194135054945946, -0.02127964235842228, 0.042502183467149734, -0.06904738396406174, 0.005942472256720066, -0.005446235649287701, 0.023437852039933205, 0.03453121706843376, -0.033248040825128555, 0.029981447383761406, -0.023176325485110283, -0.015758642926812172, 0.05015181005001068, -0.04635687917470932, 0.03716885671019554, -0.018016759306192398, 0.023337939754128456, 0.04260444641113281, -0.006799573078751564, -0.0013525766553357244, -0.024555474519729614, 0.04446662217378616, 0.06876436620950699, 0.00655237166211009, 0.009354052133858204, 0.024923844262957573, -0.011476093903183937, -0.03365258499979973, -0.055576298385858536, -0.045104339718818665, -0.0652875006198883, 0.07044785469770432, -0.049113836139440536, -0.004662246908992529, -0.023498354479670525, 0.009568676352500916, 0.03984549269080162, 0.024591222405433655, 0.0633753165602684, 0.009549361653625965, -0.011448497883975506, -0.01410683337599039, 0.03694640472531319, 0.035463932901620865, -0.016359997913241386, -0.010631079785525799, 0.0017901520477607846, -0.005832514725625515, 0.046228550374507904, -0.07013356685638428, 0.045185692608356476, 0.008149750530719757, -0.017634859308600426, -0.027456944808363914, -0.03752332180738449, 0.05792205408215523, 0.057800766080617905, 0.028321171179413795, 0.004718655254691839, -0.011401342228055, -0.01582934521138668, -0.00930272787809372, -0.024150973185896873, -0.029824336990714073, 0.02853289805352688, -0.02985646203160286, -0.008937778882682323, 0.013778697699308395, 0.017613882198929787, -0.06589325517416, -0.03732404485344887, -0.008986911736428738, -0.0073642064817249775, 0.025643963366746902, 0.004687771201133728, 0.021535299718379974, 0.0009280547383241355, 0.008330327458679676, -0.011313107796013355, -0.006710934452712536, -0.08208668231964111, -0.041651736944913864, 0.02778904139995575, 0.023776359856128693, 0.012667262926697731, 0.011130659841001034, -0.011982874944806099, -0.007882327772676945, 0.07238653302192688, -0.0058210259303450584, 0.019321605563163757, 0.022274596616625786, -0.0374942347407341, 0.03487192839384079, -0.029439624398946762, -0.014914613217115402, 0.0584527924656868, 0.06275574862957001, 0.013617442920804024, -0.04643665626645088, 0.062483105808496475, -0.007445564027875662, -0.06404457241296768, 0.013333032839000225, -0.030363110825419426, -0.02488631010055542, 0.01814625784754753, -0.031193751841783524, -0.017919369041919708, 0.027479263022542, -0.022209778428077698, -0.022519908845424652, -0.04259039834141731, 0.004681607708334923, 0.017271723598241806, -0.012997008860111237, 0.025224173441529274, -0.04910380765795708, -0.018257873132824898, 0.056399084627628326, -0.08014079183340073, 0.10599248111248016, 0.006282951682806015, 0.010710672475397587, 0.050639558583498, -0.00217025401070714, -0.024612251669168472, -0.02967100776731968, 0.04037220776081085, 0.0826357826590538, 0.030077720060944557, -0.06460616737604141, 0.02689945697784424, -0.013077386654913425, -0.03070070967078209, 0.016582924872636795, -0.028498228639364243, 0.05310741811990738, 0.05556589737534523, -0.059285007417201996, 0.03766309469938278, -0.046946991235017776, -0.028838057070970535, 0.021725080907344818, -0.03243924304842949, 0.012097449041903019, 0.05858711153268814, -0.00570334866642952, 0.016247695311903954, -0.007408840581774712, -0.020727071911096573, -0.052284128963947296, -0.027481937780976295, 0.03341083973646164, 0.0026799633633345366, -0.025486953556537628, 0.0314498133957386, -0.028127150610089302, 0.00015516333223786205, 0.017463751137256622, -0.041711099445819855, -0.02991027757525444, -0.04256536811590195, -0.006373838521540165, 0.0014677912695333362, -0.007982898503541946, 0.07571737468242645, -0.006755331996828318, 0.0008365786052308977, 0.05012918636202812, -0.03593385964632034, -0.027446569874882698, 0.02284555695950985, -0.05686892941594124, -0.07049322873353958, 0.03310396894812584, 0.01268771942704916, 0.0040947743691504, -0.005882574710994959, 0.0015933484537526965, 0.0769081711769104, -0.06253504753112793, -0.02311541512608528, -0.0033072219230234623, -0.01876552402973175, 0.023148298263549805, 0.04005090892314911, 0.03882618993520737, -0.014914941973984241, -0.028605550527572632, -0.05323474109172821, -0.05178340896964073, 0.027679529041051865, -0.0029193528462201357, -0.007949468679726124, -0.01258483063429594, 0.046526871621608734, -0.018074020743370056, 0.0042585828341543674, 0.01376913208514452, 0.021349653601646423, 0.015139196999371052, 0.05430729314684868, -0.003057636320590973, -0.02141059935092926, -0.005300702527165413, -0.018800750374794006, -0.021176660433411598, 0.025411546230316162, -0.03729339689016342, -0.037336111068725586, -0.027194617316126823, 0.01716298609972, -0.01073605939745903, 0.0015245684189721942, 0.01071947067975998, -0.030014196410775185, 0.001299165072850883, 0.007736228872090578, -0.0002479586109984666, 0.01442622672766447, -0.03371396288275719, -0.03962502256035805, -0.01795511320233345, -0.04029911011457443, 0.031861256808042526, -0.007669379469007254, 0.004543772432953119, -0.025748329237103462, 0.012873165309429169, -0.03686678409576416, -0.053488388657569885, 0.00006974271673243493, -0.017481274902820587, 0.058548759669065475, -0.004791140090674162, -0.0007069759303703904, -0.03441399708390236, -0.029582343995571136, -0.03869711235165596, -0.022426225244998932, -0.019561145454645157, 0.025090564042329788, 0.01686984859406948, 0.08419762551784515, 0.017198879271745682, 0.015549175441265106, -0.04421556368470192, 0.036356884986162186, 0.013322195969522, -0.008938228711485863, 0.00485850777477026, -0.0332568995654583, 0.04064926877617836, 0.02116936817765236, -0.0023592179641127586, 0.01139986701309681, 0.0401594303548336, 0.052357904613018036, 0.03791176900267601, -0.01634237915277481, -0.034509412944316864, 0.015656888484954834, 0.043412044644355774, -0.016102829948067665, -0.04970806464552879, -0.04333611950278282, 0.0046335915103554726, 0.047584861516952515, 0.024895425885915756, -0.0353865846991539, 0.05962211638689041, 0.05021655932068825, -0.0016837440198287368, -0.0286545492708683, -0.04662574827671051, 0.00351105653680861, 0.02797537110745907, -0.01372579950839281, -0.06145307794213295, -0.0177825428545475, 0.013757404871284962, 0.07097755372524261, 0.017004193738102913, -0.008111324161291122, 0.026323990896344185, -0.027538135647773743, 0.0944238156080246, -0.059691496193408966, -0.03598560020327568, 0.013733873143792152, 0.09549354016780853, 0.00751640135422349, -0.054489266127347946, -0.002377394586801529, -0.04057225212454796, -0.03827469050884247, 0.025151286274194717, -0.01573224365711212, -0.08248427510261536, -0.006133242975920439, 0.028250519186258316, -0.01997414417564869, -0.05687392130494118, -0.07642240077257156, 0.014944829978048801, -0.021901162341237068, -0.0027175643481314182, 0.04135069251060486, -0.00791185162961483, -0.0009049540967680514, 0.02389957197010517, -0.016706600785255432, -0.02614731527864933, -0.06318338960409164, 0.016743553802371025, 0.05525641143321991, -0.006892143748700619, 0.035832200199365616, 0.09621652215719223, -0.024953363463282585, 0.008217565715312958, -0.006013528909534216, 0.007670839317142963, -0.015159721486270428, -0.058726876974105835, -0.02738955058157444, 0.020781107246875763, -0.03619583323597908, 0.08555134385824203, 0.021119551733136177, -0.06419738382101059, -0.013345454819500446, -0.01279481127858162, 0.021773554384708405, 0.007728005759418011, 0.0045370133593678474, 0.04431859031319618, -0.0013934175949543715, 0.0010050737764686346, 0.03169209882616997, 0.021999429911375046, 0.0035869930870831013, 0.031061522662639618, -0.033484574407339096, 0.013023880310356617, -0.00023382750805467367, -0.015864040702581406, 0.01255016028881073, -0.003940952010452747, 0.03937308117747307, -0.012866123579442501, 0.019531648606061935, 0.05811574310064316, 0.06175261735916138, 0.01595952920615673, 0.027765793725848198, 0.02161407470703125, 0.04365084320306778, -0.06400031596422195, -0.013613029383122921, -0.0018114476697519422, 0.022972559556365013, -0.06107889115810394, 0.00011203943722648546, -0.02308039925992489, 0.018676459789276123, -0.015784256160259247, 0.028838185593485832, -0.0006029491778463125, -0.06136222183704376, 0.025628264993429184, 0.02518349327147007, 0.029592763632535934, 0.03736766055226326, 0.011270701885223389, -0.04062715545296669, 0.027701299637556076, -0.020904915407299995, -0.01394740492105484, -0.00807423610240221, -0.008166476152837276, 0.008887991309165955, -0.0024865467566996813, 0.06683464348316193, -0.023000571876764297, 0.03581652790307999, -0.01683107763528824, 0.0022448264062404633, 0.010827528312802315, 0.0013145130360499024, 0.026850707828998566, -0.059180766344070435, 0.03855643421411514, -0.03457016870379448, 0.020275725051760674, -0.027449628338217735, -0.015878379344940186, -0.01522489171475172, 0.059489332139492035, 0.052743956446647644, 0.07586799561977386, -0.023639462888240814, -0.06199808418750763, 0.006864862982183695, -0.002106041181832552, -0.0027657421305775642, -0.0418715626001358, -0.01360270194709301, -0.06002885103225708, 0.00007168821321101859, 0.011603989638388157, 0.09035912156105042, 0.01484628114849329, 0.03755512833595276, 0.005119879264384508, 0.0027084110770374537, -0.00615056324750185, -0.04056357219815254, -0.02498791366815567, -0.040984563529491425, 0.0335555300116539, -0.022104497998952866, -0.011841743253171444, 0.03695403039455414, 0.058134108781814575, -0.002655262593179941, 0.030054520815610886, 0.019832784309983253, 0.010135919786989689, -0.012569204904139042, -0.05777433142066002, -0.0010933419689536095, -0.03148677200078964, 0.04125044494867325, -0.022476758807897568, -0.007640912663191557, -0.019131414592266083, 0.06428343057632446, -0.0017477215733379126, -0.009363400749862194, -0.010619896464049816, 0.04329833388328552, 0.05732213705778122, -0.020427873358130455, 0.06920389086008072, 0.054439958184957504, -0.006563077215105295, -0.023318221792578697, 0.011706500314176083, 0.041485730558633804, 0.0010912452125921845, -0.010371374897658825, -0.04377269372344017, 0.05653101205825806, -0.008130721747875214, -0.02772034890949726, 0.07199565321207047, -0.015099839307367802, -0.0025629918090999126, -0.0429377444088459, -0.036276742815971375, -0.004504213575273752, 0.04636272042989731, 0.05995147302746773, -0.020543254911899567, 0.05612071976065636, 0.023949695751070976, -0.08140265941619873, -0.001383987837471068, -0.004760849755257368, -0.0030454471707344055, 0.045321911573410034, 0.010653046891093254, 0.04308539256453514, -0.006346006877720356, -0.031160123646259308, 0.007349027786403894, -0.03402816131711006, 0.012186091393232346, -0.058935198932886124, -0.0242332611232996, 0.01201730128377676, -0.0038593655917793512, -0.03868105635046959, -0.04126645624637604, -0.05432765185832977, 0.04781131073832512, -0.009584121406078339, -0.0353018157184124, -0.06135794147849083, 0.01852172613143921, -0.09191551804542542, -0.055433910340070724, 0.017688918858766556, -0.00202543823979795, 0.025135589763522148, 0.07002369314432144, 0.05374552682042122, 0.052036408334970474, 0.05359882488846779, -0.036918848752975464, 0.0162101648747921, -0.01853235997259617, 0.041320305317640305, -0.004414174240082502, -0.020459676161408424, 0.005147125571966171, -0.04290008544921875, 0.026648804545402527, -0.028445158153772354, -0.0241507887840271, 0.07368630170822144, 0.0125041538849473, -0.0008591592777520418, -0.02219475246965885, 0.00874383095651865, -0.042412903159856796, 0.021822743117809296, -0.03220747411251068, 0.02683955244719982, 0.03868625685572624, 0.017414938658475876, -0.028319397941231728, -0.05262201651930809, -0.0033765549305826426, 0.019109755754470825, -0.03296929597854614, 0.04940151795744896, -0.004788603167980909, -0.05335703119635582, -0.02588479593396187, 0.010668426752090454, 0.0020931297913193703, -0.04052731394767761, -0.04591282084584236, 0.0614551343023777, -0.04959158971905708, 0.048332348465919495, 0.037246767431497574, -0.013775833882391453, 0.007543754298239946, -0.013361645862460136, 0.020692288875579834, -0.013387695886194706, -0.0509333498775959, 0.11798296123743057, 0.06221619248390198, -0.05136662349104881, -0.05095893144607544, -0.04404222592711449, 0.02413867600262165, 0.05965542793273926, -0.02019023895263672, 0.023648349568247795, 0.04314941167831421, 0.010169303975999355, 0.025509968400001526, -0.006255690474063158, 0.02656378783285618, -0.0053480095230042934, -0.04316467046737671, 0.04196373373270035, 0.01832948811352253, 0.08037121593952179, 0.01470361277461052, -0.03854794427752495 ]
<p>I have implemented a three-way anova with type III sum of squares in c++. Since some of my experiments (observations) are more important (more informative), I want to give them a higher weight in my analysis. For example, an experiment which is very important has a weight of 10, and a relatively important one has a weight of 5, and so on. To implement it, I repeat such observations in respect to its corresponding weight, 10 times, 5 times, ...<br> I used the same concept in 2way anova, but there I used the conventional formulas of Sum of Squares, because my design was balanced. So there I just multiplied the value of each observation and the number of times I have seen that to the weight.<br> Here, repeating the items makes the design matrix so big and increase the computational complexity. Now the problem is that what if I don't want to repeat them, but use a weight matrix? and what if the weights are not integer values (so I really can't repeat one item 0.3 times)?<br> I found this formula <a href="http://www.stat.umn.edu/pub/macanova/docs/manual/manchp03.pdf" rel="nofollow">here</a>: </p> <pre><code>H^=X(X'WX)-1XW </code></pre> <p>So I put my weights into W matrix and used this formula. To check if it works, I used the conventional method and repeated observations as often as the weight value, and gave it to MATLAB. But I got different SS values.</p> <p>Could you please kindly tell me how I should change this formula? </p> <p>Thanks,</p>
g74025
[ -0.03094538301229477, 0.008676494471728802, -0.004035481717437506, -0.01850770227611065, 0.004246406257152557, 0.006553135812282562, 0.014414540491998196, 0.01850096322596073, -0.06914127618074417, 0.01210833340883255, -0.035493962466716766, 0.024798255413770676, 0.03335122391581535, 0.023039376363158226, -0.017680933699011803, 0.023001093417406082, 0.05782062187790871, 0.00636125635355711, 0.014432177878916264, 0.018233871087431908, -0.026881903409957886, 0.0026991586200892925, -0.015775218605995178, -0.03450322151184082, -0.0029554159846156836, -0.022274727001786232, -0.02814233861863613, 0.08020047843456268, -0.09203367680311203, 0.045849304646253586, -0.03761222958564758, -0.03269743546843529, -0.002941620536148548, 0.0022988496348261833, 0.0012817351380363107, -0.001721484586596489, 0.06342311948537827, 0.026991093531250954, -0.018227145075798035, 0.013522173278033733, -0.046165961772203445, -0.034170880913734436, 0.04970373585820198, 0.06301908940076828, 0.0027841331902891397, -0.034436196088790894, -0.0105473343282938, -0.05525657534599304, 0.01692885532975197, 0.005713930819183588, -0.01647735759615898, 0.03323151171207428, 0.0011877057841047645, -0.019678091630339622, 0.024280492216348648, 0.03563304990530014, -0.05982242524623871, -0.029900914058089256, -0.0011578749399632215, 0.021073533222079277, -0.0022506860550493, -0.07941693812608719, -0.0005196140264160931, 0.019085438922047615, 0.002972785383462906, 0.01694061979651451, -0.04066601023077965, 0.015067150816321373, -0.0987931564450264, -0.017813390120863914, 0.020851202309131622, -0.02251456119120121, 0.02544296905398369, -0.05644027143716812, -0.008550054393708706, -0.019618874415755272, 0.023242339491844177, 0.06783591955900192, 0.004249617923051119, 0.009197680279612541, 0.00251901731826365, -0.0031854533590376377, 0.009371059946715832, -0.010738207958638668, 0.023986246436834335, 0.023030797019600868, 0.04677469655871391, 0.007872017100453377, 0.011884734965860844, -0.036694079637527466, -0.008893127553164959, -0.059592414647340775, 0.026907099410891533, 0.047357089817523956, -0.015177995897829533, -0.05080941319465637, -0.010638847947120667, 0.03178148344159126, 0.0304801557213068, 0.007682219613343477, 0.01162874698638916, 0.00005531301940209232, -0.01199861615896225, -0.011416417546570301, -0.07524118572473526, -0.024976160377264023, 0.009366655722260475, 0.0650569424033165, -0.05661361292004585, -0.033804405480623245, -0.055840201675891876, -0.037564717233181, -0.0034906540531665087, -0.004348539747297764, -0.020853321999311447, -0.0031222582329064608, 0.04098857566714287, -0.006804338656365871, 0.005618041381239891, -0.009441305883228779, -0.029047874733805656, -0.034687452018260956, 0.015646355226635933, 0.012184497900307178, -0.011966384015977383, -0.05372709035873413, 0.06578570604324341, 0.059230513870716095, 0.05092288926243782, -0.017415104433894157, 0.01678416319191456, -0.02408513054251671, -0.030583202838897705, 0.0496770404279232, -0.020205771550536156, 0.007825476117432117, 0.0221308171749115, 0.04368169233202934, 0.04123256728053093, 0.000554144848138094, -0.0785081535577774, -0.020661119371652603, 0.004326206166297197, -0.0008336807368323207, 0.06785764545202255, 0.0014464075211435556, -0.021748675033450127, -0.06976912915706635, 0.04157914221286774, 0.020303471013903618, 0.009182422421872616, 0.0798051580786705, -0.0516340509057045, -0.02441146969795227, -0.06733227521181107, -0.05006273835897446, -0.028384830802679062, 0.00827792938798666, 0.011093450710177422, 0.025704415515065193, 0.051696088165044785, -0.019025808200240135, -0.012670990079641342, -0.04727889597415924, 0.05051325261592865, 0.053373947739601135, -0.03178217634558678, -0.043955247849226, -0.03243260458111763, -0.030834754928946495, -0.021439578384160995, 0.009164917282760143, 0.041702114045619965, -0.028769290074706078, 0.03690067306160927, 0.02813120186328888, 0.014088664203882217, -0.03189513459801674, 0.039655253291130066, -0.0018578731687739491, -0.03646306321024895, 0.0709347352385521, 0.004358327016234398, -0.04093893989920616, 0.01921999454498291, 0.04303949326276779, 0.048318106681108475, -0.004568012896925211, -0.10179196298122406, 0.01049098651856184, -0.04164525866508484, 0.03672316297888756, -0.0037536772433668375, 0.020609503611922264, -0.026536308228969574, 0.030828675255179405, -0.01325806975364685, 0.004122073296457529, -0.029339633882045746, 0.022151365876197815, 0.03148113191127777, 0.007943851873278618, -0.013527240604162216, 0.027379585430026054, -0.06504116952419281, 0.018810655921697617, 0.037849556654691696, -0.00912407599389553, -0.046612534672021866, 0.0434357225894928, 0.01093872357159853, -0.04133003577589989, 0.011891662143170834, 0.06310649961233139, 0.006336237769573927, 0.06293871253728867, 0.01653182879090309, -0.028028199449181557, 0.00468443613499403, 0.0160108283162117, -0.02518552355468273, -0.06837103515863419, -0.0036564136389642954, 0.009274771437048912, -0.04836220294237137, 0.005474709440022707, 0.016835365444421768, -0.05834338814020157, 0.04932665079832077, -0.030065806582570076, -0.03789365664124489, 0.0228035356849432, -0.022100577130913734, -0.0016712936339899898, 0.08408473432064056, 0.026125051081180573, 0.006956251338124275, 0.0425935834646225, 0.046714670956134796, 0.05652691796422005, 0.02882610447704792, 0.03486238047480583, 0.029533889144659042, -0.01841849461197853, 0.05523282289505005, -0.009999219328165054, 0.04398506507277489, -0.027771171182394028, 0.03528235852718353, 0.03637026250362396, -0.06905385851860046, 0.003885845886543393, -0.001944062765687704, -0.040872082114219666, -0.0009215679601766169, 0.03722604364156723, -0.007423650939017534, 0.005923321470618248, 0.023000074550509453, -0.011296667158603668, 0.01341288909316063, -0.04643302038311958, 0.025049839168787003, 0.0029233507812023163, -0.000623614527285099, -0.014872287400066853, -0.028304433450102806, -0.05644800141453743, 0.0017415349138900638, 0.03839265555143356, -0.06619760394096375, -0.029230600222945213, 0.05245577543973923, 0.03585118427872658, -0.003555906005203724, -0.04545848071575165, 0.006898581515997648, -0.008134289644658566, 0.05927380919456482, -0.008203777484595776, 0.03509914129972458, -0.017388466745615005, 0.013802058063447475, 0.031469788402318954, 0.05152178555727005, 0.012140141800045967, 0.03888486325740814, -0.030266771093010902, 0.011266166344285011, 0.030436549335718155, 0.0022399656008929014, 0.026618001982569695, -0.04948943108320236, -0.07602021098136902, 0.019002661108970642, -0.024932121858000755, 0.010757542215287685, -0.043057847768068314, 0.021242909133434296, 0.009428075514733791, -0.03359879553318024, 0.012640071101486683, 0.022101525217294693, -0.01983509212732315, 0.07978685200214386, 0.0014013989130035043, 0.03498373180627823, 0.04568460211157799, 0.07803861051797867, 0.0477052666246891, 0.0536990612745285, -0.04257234185934067, -0.0456092432141304, -0.01744137331843376, -0.04775560274720192, -0.037791185081005096, -0.010004689916968346, -0.028739966452121735, 0.0020151217468082905, -0.06021839752793312, 0.013800404965877533, -0.017298370599746704, -0.0021137718576937914, 0.043024975806474686, -0.06685083359479904, 0.050500329583883286, 0.0014934048522263765, 0.05334485322237015, 0.015271604061126709, -0.02304503321647644, 0.026714853942394257, 0.07171069830656052, 0.01309924479573965, -0.036006174981594086, -0.020212676376104355, -0.03494589030742645, 0.019079118967056274, -0.038543906062841415, 0.05269750580191612, -0.00469014560803771, -0.019349893555045128, -0.003541442798450589, -0.04780254513025284, -0.036150962114334106, 0.010082912631332874, 0.007585262414067984, -0.00722990557551384, 0.011679548770189285, -0.009085842408239841, -0.050335418432950974, 0.07055611908435822, 0.033622171729803085, -0.013860275968909264, -0.03671562299132347, 0.005722564645111561, 0.029264144599437714, 0.019478006288409233, 0.007090622093528509, 0.012727686204016209, -0.041610993444919586, -0.06409823149442673, -0.03340153023600578, -0.07422829419374466, 0.0011598162818700075, 0.009972747415304184, 0.014959199354052544, 0.040258657187223434, 0.06789922714233398, 0.07101603597402573, -0.009601601399481297, 0.0055196527391672134, -0.028552373871207237, 0.009533501230180264, -0.07866460084915161, 0.0037871771492064, -0.017009444534778595, 0.06711013615131378, -0.011858665384352207, 0.01849909871816635, 0.1144508495926857, 0.04181406646966934, -0.04447975382208824, -0.04669611155986786, -0.048821188509464264, -0.04930988326668739, 0.017981860786676407, -0.019730282947421074, -0.019815009087324142, 0.018716001883149147, -0.009945148602128029, -0.022821441292762756, 0.01536645833402872, -0.05661118030548096, -0.030548976734280586, 0.01574336364865303, -0.022811593487858772, -0.004877567291259766, -0.01845717802643776, -0.05129237473011017, 0.0038535369094461203, -0.0484161451458931, 0.0362045057117939, 0.06132279336452484, 0.007662300020456314, -0.038346629589796066, -0.023059139028191566, 0.052709564566612244, 0.014959419146180153, -0.06906818598508835, 0.04393499344587326, -0.04512552544474602, 0.010842829942703247, 0.06265150010585785, -0.07852408289909363, 0.017606552690267563, -0.02006462961435318, 0.026367008686065674, -0.030254321172833443, -0.04564223065972328, -0.005456283688545227, 0.0004159076779615134, 0.021561209112405777, -0.018143758177757263, -0.027151834219694138, 0.022682899609208107, 0.04538770020008087, -0.026579104363918304, -0.06198031082749367, 0.04050759598612785, -0.021385155618190765, 0.006014485843479633, 0.010316804982721806, -0.04855116829276085, 0.02794923447072506, 0.0024411494378000498, 0.0019499390618875623, 0.01331141497939825, 0.03517989441752434, -0.019866520538926125, 0.03719718009233475, -0.019441088661551476, 0.04009697958827019, -0.030262457206845284, -0.00480999331921339, -0.0018432820215821266, 0.0016657786909490824, -0.03882819041609764, 0.027578145265579224, 0.04729607328772545, 0.07116616517305374, -0.043150514364242554, -0.006106569431722164, 0.028248297050595284, -0.004996261093765497, 0.05146566033363342, 0.0023805005475878716, -0.01956474781036377, -0.01521152351051569, -0.002217252040281892, 0.042611632496118546, -0.04311372712254524, 0.024191496893763542, -0.08022426068782806, -0.023417985066771507, -0.015849081799387932, -0.027782833203673363, -0.04386099800467491, -0.025546273216605186, 0.012496978044509888, -0.051791660487651825, 0.013785293325781822, -0.012120623141527176, -0.00484423665329814, 0.061962611973285675, -0.0023340764455497265, -0.01227803248912096, 0.042727116495370865, 0.0650002732872963, -0.017239034175872803, 0.03499975800514221, 0.006778939161449671, -0.033999744802713394, 0.010758151300251484, 0.00932091660797596, 0.039650436490774155, -0.029680367559194565, -0.02653653919696808, -0.04936251416802406, 0.010865752585232258, -0.018267259001731873, -0.012213652953505516, 0.015238331630825996, 0.06029120832681656, -0.06014058366417885, 0.0025226371362805367, -0.014013299718499184, 0.015735089778900146, -0.004566414747387171, -0.0003484213084448129, -0.04265705868601799, -0.0323016420006752, -0.01571609266102314, 0.009483647532761097, 0.015287109650671482, 0.01970808207988739, -0.026379726827144623, 0.03897787630558014, -0.00862829852849245, 0.03299726918339729, 0.03848813846707344, 0.00840088538825512, 0.0070403628051280975, 0.07021041959524155, 0.0011085370788350701, -0.006422602105885744, 0.023688964545726776, 0.04242679104208946, -0.003516590455546975, -0.020361440256237984, -0.052632641047239304, 0.06542167067527771, -0.0395844541490078, -0.01218938734382391, 0.02461067959666252, 0.030045628547668457, -0.029745956882834435, -0.02440584823489189, -0.030729493126273155, 0.05346843600273132, -0.010811318643391132, -0.02322717197239399, -0.009272324852645397, -0.027268413454294205, 0.007777653634548187, -0.04456739127635956, -0.02263210341334343, -0.009700395166873932, 0.014837898313999176, 0.020620811730623245, -0.050055306404829025, 0.008314044214785099, 0.002772136125713587, 0.028475487604737282, 0.0082189766690135, 0.011298788711428642, -0.02997935749590397, -0.014566290192306042, -0.040504492819309235, 0.04989293962717056, 0.007645901758223772, -0.06064402312040329, 0.06416317075490952, 0.0213923379778862, 0.0005342444637790322, 0.050404828041791916, 0.016111290082335472, -0.03778120502829552, -0.023768914863467216, 0.012365602888166904, -0.008239110931754112, -0.011358545161783695, 0.007248192094266415, -0.030260125175118446, 0.032472193241119385, 0.010945401154458523, -0.04185497760772705, -0.06586555391550064, 0.04505406692624092, -0.01307872124016285, 0.04569943621754646, 0.013307532295584679, 0.031763240694999695, -0.04837394133210182, -0.01639450341463089, 0.058037228882312775, 0.032493989914655685, 0.007021162658929825, -0.00427958695217967, -0.0067566013894975185, -0.06034078821539879, -0.006098059006035328, 0.021756812930107117, -0.014130891300737858, 0.003497190773487091, -0.019893208518624306, 0.03100702166557312, -0.00871687475591898, -0.0032928718719631433, 0.023478321731090546, -0.09074828028678894, -0.08968092501163483, 0.018868453800678253, -0.06451357901096344, 0.04118937626481056, -0.033269528299570084, -0.004304055590182543, -0.04783773049712181, 0.07637782394886017, 0.03291666507720947, -0.009406069293618202, 0.015276025049388409, 0.022601226344704628, 0.019552132114768028, -0.039615605026483536, -0.0208482313901186, 0.04139402508735657, 0.0034906803630292416, -0.027726981788873672, -0.020520886406302452, 0.022455427795648575, -0.01762514002621174, 0.0015944751212373376, 0.04955476522445679, 0.08008036017417908, -0.025734279304742813, -0.002001919550821185, -0.0037621341180056334, 0.047950778156518936, 0.015065385028719902, -0.00041891125147230923, -0.014887216500937939, -0.041767820715904236, -0.013892765156924725, -0.029409237205982208, 0.044445350766181946, 0.05551471561193466, 0.04623965173959732, 0.01800519786775112, 0.03457188233733177, 0.029267752543091774, -0.010311431251466274, 0.012067203409969807, -0.030783427879214287, 0.03687233477830887, -0.03212318196892738, 0.012428280897438526, -0.012643164023756981, 0.06649507582187653, -0.028493110090494156, 0.06916514039039612, -0.057870808988809586, 0.08084608614444733, -0.013784064911305904, -0.02579984813928604, -0.056783951818943024, -0.0094296270981431, 0.05515754595398903, 0.030229803174734116, -0.035601768642663956, 0.050931889563798904, 0.05306704342365265, 0.015009880997240543, 0.0009410156635567546, -0.028075464069843292, -0.00914064422249794, 0.029186641797423363, 0.09295555204153061, -0.0028366409242153168, 0.044169168919324875, -0.001537915552034974, -0.044815659523010254, 0.0026762858033180237, 0.011335894465446472, 0.016540510579943657, -0.03702688589692116, 0.052799928933382034, -0.039003629237413406, -0.0003788860631175339, -0.01260182075202465, 0.030345261096954346, 0.03858480602502823, -0.015273901633918285, -0.02338026836514473, 0.0600181445479393, 0.013794570229947567, -0.016439292579889297, -0.027140939608216286, 0.03479274734854698, -0.09180089831352234, 0.021017257124185562, 0.006158026866614819, -0.05358949303627014, -0.0664883404970169, 0.012668988667428493, 0.021942632272839546, 0.009126069955527782, -0.031231524422764778, 0.014790249057114124, -0.03548896312713623, -0.031298134475946426, 0.033088091760873795, 0.006085942033678293, 0.051080405712127686, 0.01503988541662693, -0.06035143882036209, 0.043770141899585724, 0.021382734179496765, -0.0060339816845953465, 0.03835173323750496, 0.06742484122514725, 0.03122665174305439, -0.012664022855460644, 0.020659614354372025, -0.018120834603905678, -0.04063596948981285, 0.020019102841615677, -0.05527031794190407, -0.006818962749093771, -0.012573817744851112, 0.0026336945593357086, -0.03381264954805374, -0.011755067855119705, -0.028302958235144615, 0.01603987254202366, -0.03269665688276291, -0.02761964313685894, -0.019904905930161476, -0.01793038472533226, -0.08604589849710464, -0.0198347270488739, -0.07882505655288696, 0.038834769278764725, -0.03890910744667053, 0.0021911535877734423, -0.0028191604651510715, 0.020706893876194954, -0.028672000393271446, 0.02204432524740696, -0.0004298112471587956, 0.039929211139678955, -0.03395024687051773, -0.045982085168361664, -0.08514858037233353, 0.024545494467020035, 0.07275887578725815, 0.03229494392871857, 0.07552766799926758, 0.03833116218447685, -0.02326689288020134, -0.021069888025522232, 0.01943163573741913, -0.014774487353861332, 0.03763191029429436, -0.03389712795615196, -0.01492544449865818, 0.03896445408463478, -0.041811298578977585, -0.00026452227029949427, 0.04864075407385826, -0.07543443888425827, -0.06262299418449402, 0.030270438641309738, -0.009542425163090229, 0.03476359695196152, 0.012282168492674828, 0.07548552006483078, 0.06222953647375107, -0.0003262076643295586, 0.011478632688522339, -0.023903150111436844, 0.012531756423413754, -0.025145167484879494, -0.11077171564102173, 0.03189520910382271, 0.015281816944479942, -0.05263854190707207, -0.014878932386636734, -0.019379619508981705 ]
<p>I iterated my 10-fold cross validation 100 times for several methods. Now I want to use a t-test to test if the results are significant. However, I'm not sure what the sample size is. Is the sample size the original amount of samples, or is it the original amount of samples x 100?</p> <h2>edit:</h2> <p>For university we need to classify 3 cancer types and give an estimation of how well our model will perform. We received a dataset with 100 samples. We split the data up into a training and test set using stratified sampling with a ratio of 0.3 and 0.7. The resulting training set consists of 69 samples, and the test set out of 31 samples.</p> <p>We used repeated cross validation because of this paper: <a href="http://www.cse.iitb.ac.in/~tarung/smt/papers_ppt/ency-cross-validation.pdf" rel="nofollow">http://www.cse.iitb.ac.in/~tarung/smt/papers_ppt/ency-cross-validation.pdf</a></p> <p>The repeated cross-validation is done on the same training set, but with the folds are randomly chosen every time, so they should be different every time.</p> <p>The significance we want to test is if the accuracy of one model is significantly better than the accuracy of a different model. </p>
g46718
[ -0.013416329398751259, -0.014227845706045628, 0.00789816863834858, -0.050659120082855225, 0.022610511630773544, -0.029513869434595108, 0.004353750497102737, 0.054080210626125336, -0.04494713619351387, 0.050705548375844955, 0.019114872440695763, 0.013183532282710075, 0.033308278769254684, -0.010552434250712395, -0.005574338603764772, -0.01757950894534588, 0.06869246065616608, -0.01772114634513855, -0.014284346252679825, 0.044573839753866196, -0.07242672145366669, -0.002338084625080228, -0.006456516683101654, -0.07080623507499695, -0.027120303362607956, 0.011480221524834633, -0.031974032521247864, 0.059660106897354126, -0.07912193238735199, 0.025355307385325432, 0.0135619156062603, -0.04188104718923569, 0.030658550560474396, -0.06416364759206772, -0.023380856961011887, 0.038654327392578125, 0.046313975006341934, 0.012353376485407352, 0.021380247548222542, 0.021416116505861282, -0.003365175100043416, 0.05000441148877144, 0.01764843240380287, -0.02848009020090103, 0.023732369765639305, 0.00963599793612957, -0.003266706597059965, 0.04483717679977417, 0.06638408452272415, -0.019535932689905167, -0.01714690588414669, 0.02780545875430107, 0.0258110910654068, 0.03305937349796295, 0.020617157220840454, -0.02375400811433792, -0.013645445927977562, 0.05060660094022751, -0.0016404082998633385, 0.02690144255757332, -0.006459576543420553, -0.009906542487442493, -0.06075672060251236, -0.024994974955916405, -0.013062041252851486, 0.031220192089676857, 0.010335547849535942, -0.007364080753177404, -0.04358448460698128, -0.0783310979604721, -0.04590451717376709, -0.010163167491555214, 0.0313875712454319, 0.03129054605960846, -0.06413283199071884, -0.020464066416025162, -0.020768698304891586, 0.05024557188153267, -0.02085060626268387, 0.03780025616288185, -0.006388698238879442, -0.046725720167160034, 0.007029231637716293, 0.03480728343129158, 0.008830017410218716, -0.009275337681174278, -0.03714163601398468, 0.018656138330698013, -0.012363004498183727, 0.09092098474502563, 0.027228226885199547, 0.03660162538290024, 0.036326512694358826, 0.07904399186372757, 0.03178732097148895, -0.0008286420488730073, -0.023348255082964897, 0.017521997913718224, -0.005673339124768972, 0.04141775891184807, -0.02494935877621174, 0.021874351426959038, 0.008301367983222008, 0.011177005246281624, -0.027584180235862732, 0.05168000981211662, -0.020426882430911064, 0.008507669903337955, -0.029774995520710945, -0.017695453017950058, -0.04419345408678055, -0.018976828083395958, -0.0840597078204155, 0.037759874016046524, -0.05253755673766136, -0.027656646445393562, 0.012011834420263767, 0.01514377724379301, -0.04192999377846718, -0.03412904962897301, 0.02476481907069683, -0.04776458069682121, 0.049860719591379166, -0.00824738573282957, -0.0698687955737114, -0.05253618583083153, -0.04758840799331665, 0.02331727370619774, -0.006873351521790028, 0.0186479352414608, 0.0118769695982337, -0.01187486108392477, 0.011881663464009762, 0.03949836641550064, 0.035141073167324066, 0.06339357793331146, -0.014322021044790745, 0.00041661973227746785, -0.023023927584290504, 0.0063518136739730835, -0.08626395463943481, 0.03631279617547989, 0.05314629524946213, 0.02421998791396618, 0.03780466690659523, -0.03508605808019638, 0.0036846615839749575, -0.0075987279415130615, -0.02669437788426876, 0.020231345668435097, 0.03982485458254814, 0.0336160808801651, -0.021405242383480072, -0.01674140989780426, -0.041085828095674515, -0.0055738636292517185, -0.022071491926908493, -0.04850751906633377, -0.03788533806800842, 0.03916279971599579, -0.022295789793133736, -0.01682995818555355, 0.030772432684898376, 0.00008347475522896275, 0.036079708486795425, 0.023540813475847244, -0.01185598224401474, -0.06268247961997986, -0.03277856856584549, -0.0058824955485761166, 0.04986073821783066, 0.010126468725502491, 0.08216021209955215, -0.05572193115949631, 0.020917212590575218, -0.008625510148704052, 0.03863925859332085, -0.010685311630368233, 0.08625857532024384, 0.029339708387851715, 0.04171285778284073, 0.0574047826230526, 0.009164012037217617, -0.0011910127941519022, -0.005545813590288162, -0.046121563762426376, 0.013001782819628716, 0.05476868897676468, 0.010539688169956207, -0.05046635866165161, -0.0017860877560451627, -0.05684886500239372, -0.030171871185302734, -0.05902344733476639, -0.0017337142489850521, -0.004860001616179943, 0.043928902596235275, -0.03316720575094223, 0.024000264704227448, -0.008580639958381653, 0.009654517285525799, 0.021259445697069168, -0.005189748015254736, 0.05690190568566322, -0.032976169139146805, 0.0004320930747780949, -0.005726307164877653, -0.046149738132953644, -0.07612885534763336, 0.022301848977804184, -0.04008319973945618, -0.008667118847370148, -0.0029051639139652252, 0.04700668528676033, 0.0010424916399642825, -0.012470168061554432, -0.008764905855059624, 0.04060928896069527, -0.0262732096016407, 0.0418582446873188, -0.02540283091366291, -0.05293100327253342, -0.006970845628529787, -0.07678260654211044, 0.016858739778399467, 0.03790629282593727, 0.008395859971642494, -0.018912367522716522, 0.028995011001825333, 0.0010966658592224121, 0.01827707327902317, -0.04006882384419441, 0.006306539289653301, -0.02522609569132328, -0.022167405113577843, -0.04418663680553436, -0.010008612647652626, -0.033134691417217255, -0.021422691643238068, 0.010250166989862919, 0.028544392436742783, 0.05447357892990112, -0.004543279763311148, -0.04538236930966377, 0.040554530918598175, -0.04153865575790405, -0.0017715557478368282, -0.04102478548884392, 0.06098261475563049, 0.01934308372437954, -0.048030488193035126, 0.01864880695939064, -0.011529652401804924, -0.00010440205369377509, -0.048842716962099075, -0.0010149262379854918, 0.04815789312124252, 0.015696639195084572, 0.0028530110139399767, 0.12726688385009766, 0.051854208111763, 0.00918668881058693, 0.018210338428616524, 0.02920224890112877, 0.03266077861189842, -0.03173837065696716, -0.009153755381703377, -0.04256093129515648, -0.016973353922367096, -0.014767908491194248, -0.0010977506171911955, 0.04219968244433403, 0.06387150287628174, 0.044239532202482224, 0.05561225488781929, 0.018662091344594955, -0.049774330109357834, -0.027591656893491745, -0.007180521264672279, -0.03367192670702934, 0.017320604994893074, -0.009428166784346104, 0.02009257674217224, 0.062308721244335175, 0.02351284958422184, 0.02169116586446762, -0.011378086172044277, -0.019688652828335762, -0.07048217952251434, 0.043809473514556885, -0.009818511083722115, 0.0011556659592315555, 0.03448398783802986, -0.03642163798213005, -0.027916423976421356, -0.017414052039384842, 0.025917254388332367, -0.09350429475307465, 0.08076968789100647, -0.008027758449316025, -0.012927772477269173, 0.002038114471361041, 0.04285348951816559, 0.03570235148072243, 0.04649213328957558, -0.0331798791885376, -0.023141199722886086, -0.00837785005569458, 0.04388633370399475, 0.048545386642217636, -0.024084609001874924, 0.012489797547459602, 0.00198531337082386, -0.012407107278704643, -0.015840912237763405, -0.03517061099410057, 0.014666380360722542, 0.0041337390430271626, -0.0007686492754146457, 0.0015959407901391387, 0.08072856068611145, -0.050039418041706085, 0.005357110407203436, 0.040870726108551025, -0.014504318125545979, 0.01087738573551178, -0.017199508845806122, 0.026714041829109192, -0.01127557922154665, -0.03548087552189827, 0.04619864001870155, 0.056040942668914795, 0.0177896860986948, 0.03396536037325859, 0.0448235422372818, -0.031251028180122375, 0.017567550763487816, 0.004774346947669983, 0.037593353539705276, -0.0027681877836585045, -0.0052813016809523106, -0.01891881786286831, 0.028225162997841835, -0.044863510876894, -0.024650998413562775, 0.013309008441865444, 0.01448703184723854, -0.007976535707712173, -0.04024394974112511, 0.003085247939452529, -0.009919942356646061, -0.00983936246484518, -0.022173713892698288, -0.023443175479769707, 0.058180954307317734, 0.009208098985254765, -0.015182833187282085, -0.032673608511686325, 0.035165537148714066, -0.03729543089866638, 0.03062453120946884, -0.020802874118089676, 0.020763983950018883, 0.02486022375524044, 0.0018093804828822613, 0.06004997715353966, 0.0043930066749453545, 0.04879128187894821, 0.05111982673406601, -0.03995872288942337, -0.07111406326293945, 0.014880823902785778, -0.009690776467323303, -0.030988657847046852, 0.05485294759273529, -0.0017328992253169417, 0.04319014400243759, 0.007025383412837982, 0.034712400287389755, 0.04051117226481438, 0.05291777849197388, 0.024594923481345177, -0.09869767725467682, -0.04240044206380844, -0.025851968675851822, -0.054060354828834534, -0.0326005183160305, -0.00709545286372304, 0.02604452706873417, 0.0065011922270059586, 0.020248642191290855, 0.0008274629944935441, -0.08026468753814697, -0.0013221018016338348, -0.0018857986433431506, -0.0312105230987072, 0.05795304849743843, -0.0015476264525204897, 0.045196257531642914, 0.038780611008405685, -0.0028354094829410315, -0.023603249341249466, 0.020779259502887726, 0.016297610476613045, -0.018512461334466934, 0.0023742082994431257, 0.019407030194997787, 0.013082928024232388, -0.059310175478458405, 0.03084062598645687, -0.031109753996133804, -0.043231572955846786, 0.01292297150939703, -0.05349703133106232, 0.014083586633205414, -0.04226341471076012, 0.015136786736547947, -0.06930878758430481, -0.02228458598256111, 0.018723441287875175, -0.0035487692803144455, 0.010075775906443596, 0.019858956336975098, -0.01179547794163227, 0.033588483929634094, -0.021753376349806786, 0.01902603916823864, 0.03966619074344635, -0.03726741671562195, -0.03241314738988876, -0.026251869276165962, 0.06046270206570625, -0.08450351655483246, 0.026012524962425232, 0.014072365127503872, 0.027584590017795563, 0.017096830531954765, 0.0005356184556148946, -0.0586843267083168, -0.034894172102212906, -0.016484159976243973, -0.01351642981171608, -0.0435216911137104, 0.03728826344013214, -0.02117300219833851, 0.009763436391949654, -0.013861455023288727, -0.0230023842304945, 0.00260370341129601, 0.0328366719186306, -0.061461158096790314, 0.028874360024929047, -0.023855913430452347, 0.020480727776885033, -0.007730583660304546, 0.05440984293818474, 0.016284987330436707, 0.014655256643891335, 0.011043721809983253, 0.022961415350437164, 0.005631497595459223, -0.0061371056362986565, 0.03150305896997452, 0.005970386788249016, -0.00524249067530036, -0.027546903118491173, -0.10311172157526016, 0.03293875604867935, 0.07859024405479431, -0.015347558073699474, -0.025795968249440193, -0.05660848692059517, 0.04002298787236214, -0.008621450513601303, -0.03240149840712547, 0.08028542250394821, 0.015539288520812988, -0.028387123718857765, -0.039262864738702774, -0.020566752180457115, -0.012307068333029747, -0.0799456387758255, 0.0037548202089965343, -0.03522004559636116, 0.027227358892560005, -0.030718902125954628, -0.01835637353360653, -0.020284749567508698, 0.11874514818191528, -0.018466705456376076, -0.0031284017022699118, 0.0015503898030146956, 0.0709536001086235, 0.011984373442828655, -0.006300467997789383, -0.05415172129869461, 0.0443708561360836, -0.04613124951720238, 0.010290619917213917, -0.017827752977609634, 0.0027968906797468662, 0.02175056003034115, -0.020149124786257744, -0.03074209950864315, -0.04122297465801239, 0.01505212765187025, 0.04759390652179718, -0.024861957877874374, -0.015421020798385143, 0.01807195320725441, -0.046685222536325455, -0.014461643993854523, 0.02973322756588459, 0.022410275414586067, -0.005955109838396311, -0.01318044401705265, 0.0019102813675999641, 0.030288774520158768, 0.01048048585653305, -0.02011965960264206, 0.06496536731719971, -0.021323975175619125, 0.09091237187385559, 0.02732147090137005, 0.03877986967563629, -0.053688663989305496, -0.04727655276656151, -0.0689597874879837, 0.03309183940291405, -0.03937685862183571, 0.014301354065537453, 0.03252540901303291, -0.029708433896303177, 0.044573523104190826, -0.0027178428135812283, -0.03650409355759621, 0.006569485180079937, -0.00953477993607521, -0.02592700533568859, -0.044419340789318085, -0.019640766084194183, -0.00978095829486847, -0.013424997217953205, -0.023130591958761215, -0.023742826655507088, -0.041563089936971664, -0.01120892632752657, 0.009516407735645771, -0.012759234756231308, -0.03141184523701668, -0.014989427290856838, 0.0018655670573934913, 0.029870569705963135, -0.025333095341920853, 0.012948667630553246, 0.038359135389328, 0.024536726996302605, -0.010594448074698448, 0.041952650994062424, -0.007214127108454704, -0.013388179242610931, -0.0669974535703659, -0.002933385781943798, -0.031228099018335342, 0.019823802635073662, -0.03331572934985161, -0.055738240480422974, -0.03915998712182045, -0.049691084772348404, -0.053234320133924484, 0.02707010507583618, -0.008783846162259579, -0.021978694945573807, 0.004254878032952547, 0.02735995128750801, 0.04275789484381676, -0.005806098226457834, 0.060920946300029755, 0.04587522894144058, -0.06263281404972076, 0.016621358692646027, -0.005586845334619284, 0.03859774023294449, -0.01134998258203268, -0.017498480156064034, 0.027266204357147217, -0.04038285091519356, 0.016926761716604233, -0.011374473571777344, 0.01141117699444294, -0.01729138195514679, -0.008287370204925537, -0.020886071026325226, -0.029103752225637436, 0.002620409708470106, -0.05102204158902168, 0.0233919620513916, 0.005338748451322317, 0.02091294154524803, 0.01847497746348381, -0.014935905113816261, 0.06295140087604523, 0.03298419341444969, -0.0724295824766159, 0.006668198388069868, 0.007828579284250736, 0.0069872112944722176, -0.03415616601705551, 0.017013920471072197, -0.001142699271440506, 0.003706118790432811, -0.03579193726181984, 0.016723254695534706, 0.0294104665517807, -0.07714275270700455, -0.0785372406244278, -0.029033152386546135, -0.0251326784491539, 0.031151756644248962, -0.007630911655724049, 0.04857376962900162, -0.05788959935307503, 0.023671764880418777, 0.009830061346292496, -0.0010425696382299066, 0.05298105999827385, 0.022550825029611588, 0.06640852242708206, 0.07061272859573364, -0.07547297328710556, -0.05805927515029907, 0.05228371545672417, -0.026667684316635132, 0.021719370037317276, -0.12932583689689636, 0.02055204100906849, -0.02322426438331604, 0.008164391852915287, 0.002522652968764305, 0.08203908801078796, -0.013778968714177608, 0.01944592408835888, 0.01362221222370863, -0.06702297925949097, 0.03815165534615517, 0.030350664630532265, 0.050352517515420914, 0.06389835476875305, -0.026965826749801636, -0.02961478941142559, 0.04147891327738762, 0.029018040746450424, -0.011598707176744938, -0.037932392209768295, 0.00808006338775158, 0.054679300636053085, 0.0526607520878315, 0.07254308462142944, -0.0022700056433677673, -0.02897738665342331, -0.00653048325330019, -0.051947418600320816, -0.05997634679079056, -0.044001199305057526, -0.007021981757134199, 0.021074598655104637, 0.009792588651180267, -0.04823024570941925, 0.021414048969745636, -0.03588185831904411, 0.04047929495573044, 0.057028599083423615, -0.06632940471172333, 0.041505105793476105, 0.06683529913425446, -0.053531188517808914, -0.014282588846981525, 0.05427701771259308, 0.00793591607362032, 0.03161902353167534, 0.0008239090675488114, -0.030632231384515762, 0.023303614929318428, 0.010371253825724125, 0.0027590396348387003, -0.0059579540975391865, -0.045149244368076324, -0.017168814316391945, 0.04615739732980728, -0.0185262318700552, -0.021668918430805206, -0.039499975740909576, -0.009655491448938847, 0.0374322272837162, -0.01053639780730009, 0.04506855830550194, -0.021952468901872635, -0.04133162274956703, 0.020697375759482384, 0.04238836467266083, 0.014450879767537117, 0.061723995953798294, -0.016461990773677826, -0.025729436427354813, -0.03451695293188095, 0.03141346946358681, -0.039982203394174576, 0.008097533136606216, 0.01595526933670044, -0.05860045924782753, -0.015457531437277794, 0.029735390096902847, 0.016560092568397522, 0.04257701337337494, -0.016254311427474022, -0.035113073885440826, -0.02951829321682453, -0.04844376817345619, -0.0012108060764148831, 0.004532621242105961, -0.023339560255408287, -0.029406709596514702, 0.018231654539704323, 0.031152548268437386, 0.03308596834540367, -0.029824163764715195, -0.061820439994335175, 0.04492529109120369, -0.006605413276702166, 0.0411352813243866, -0.05086010321974754, -0.07150417566299438, -0.052649956196546555, -0.012101586908102036, 0.012152177281677723, 0.013885102234780788, 0.09297916293144226, 0.010924791917204857, 0.007495969068259001, -0.013795179314911366, -0.008986612781882286, 0.021882710978388786, 0.004482838325202465, 0.058442842215299606, -0.02908526174724102, -0.033310018479824066, -0.02551129274070263, 0.025571808218955994, 0.0778098925948143, -0.037770725786685944, -0.03443669527769089, 0.00653497502207756, 0.03291337192058563, 0.060601238161325455, -0.04003645107150078, 0.013262487016618252, 0.02591085247695446, 0.0011463778791949153, 0.01662411354482174, 0.013191255740821362, -0.05812310427427292, 0.014493417926132679, 0.005960580427199602, 0.02987828478217125, -0.014921451918780804, -0.023869799450039864, 0.023093372583389282, 0.024875599890947342 ]
<p>I have a collection of $n$ datapoints $(y_i,\bf{x}_i)$ in $\mathbb{R}^{p+1}$ and would like to estimate the following model in <code>R</code>:</p> <p>$$\underset{\bf{b}\in\mathbb{R}^{p}}{\arg.\min}\;\sum_{i=1}^n(y_i-\bf{x}_i'\bf{b})^2$$ </p> <p>$$u.c.\;\;\;0\leq \bf{x}_i'\bf{b}\leq 1\;\;\;\forall i$$</p> <p>anybody has a pointer to an efficient way of doing this? is there a re-parametrization of the OLS problem that would allow for this? </p>
g74026
[ -0.024113669991493225, 0.004994356073439121, -0.04420626908540726, -0.04346022009849548, -0.006286696996539831, -0.07191735506057739, -0.0021943848114460707, -0.004930334165692329, -0.06080897897481918, 0.04100683704018593, -0.054524775594472885, 0.04669630900025368, 0.007976436987519264, 0.03985864669084549, 0.01763530634343624, 0.03670886158943176, -0.022085780277848244, -0.013423088006675243, 0.015979282557964325, -0.07940535992383957, 0.02467212826013565, -0.046566832810640335, 0.09667742997407913, -0.013416284695267677, 0.045720912516117096, -0.009589195251464844, 0.007556146942079067, 0.0556899830698967, -0.08204416185617447, 0.010152394883334637, -0.04885222017765045, -0.02646471932530403, 0.001928991638123989, -0.025073135271668434, -0.005487704183906317, 0.0011867607245221734, 0.02309386432170868, 0.022694751620292664, 0.0030528900679200888, 0.007834464311599731, 0.007232674863189459, -0.018417157232761383, 0.04576864466071129, 0.056638412177562714, -0.025265712291002274, -0.07667545229196548, 0.02698836475610733, -0.012317384593188763, 0.037001706659793854, -0.019209107384085655, 0.0009099825983867049, 0.027430657297372818, 0.01284854207187891, -0.001724761794321239, -0.02490932121872902, 0.014867769554257393, -0.05628454312682152, -0.05669631063938141, 0.004972570110112429, 0.019280144944787025, -0.0021051145158708096, 0.03109656274318695, -0.011360248550772667, -0.033582862466573715, -0.04110041260719299, 0.04581490159034729, -0.060641027987003326, -0.05740751326084137, -0.03379865735769272, -0.037306200712919235, -0.01631518453359604, 0.055561184883117676, 0.006517773028463125, -0.07113729417324066, -0.10747738927602768, -0.014579430222511292, -0.040869828313589096, 0.05038201063871384, 0.01206190139055252, 0.027540620416402817, -0.015568375587463379, 0.03473926708102226, -0.010359102860093117, -0.0117126340046525, -0.033958401530981064, -0.00889349915087223, 0.05350293964147568, 0.02705940045416355, -0.015587284229695797, 0.003008442698046565, -0.028478844091296196, -0.040920186787843704, -0.008724895305931568, -0.003519236808642745, 0.039359331130981445, -0.000759549904614687, -0.05740641430020332, 0.0019589529838413, -0.0007641586707904935, 0.021715594455599785, 0.02660219557583332, 0.05796894058585167, -0.02857307530939579, -0.0443727970123291, -0.03833789378404617, 0.0004179587704129517, 0.10664680600166321, -0.024924399331212044, -0.01387058850377798, -0.03293216601014137, -0.01230949629098177, -0.02861514687538147, -0.042769089341163635, -0.026419006288051605, -0.058789778500795364, -0.056704290211200714, 0.028025247156620026, 0.012419449165463448, -0.05474703758955002, 0.020764850080013275, -0.004475397989153862, -0.06507670879364014, 0.02928708679974079, 0.059478335082530975, 0.017918789759278297, 0.023413609713315964, -0.06302715092897415, 0.07659456878900528, 0.04002835229039192, 0.03806984797120094, 0.0630514845252037, -0.05478127673268318, 0.0034023718908429146, 0.034091901034116745, -0.022862499579787254, -0.052972957491874695, -0.030400440096855164, 0.020851418375968933, 0.001869453233666718, -0.01072229165583849, -0.024340813979506493, 0.00478125736117363, -0.011937661096453667, -0.025569161400198936, 0.0124535346403718, -0.035175930708646774, 0.022656287997961044, -0.0017682185862213373, 0.0194364283233881, -0.005263634491711855, -0.0006714203045703471, 0.09055405855178833, -0.005888745188713074, 0.04780184477567673, -0.036988239735364914, 0.007737362757325172, 0.023173566907644272, -0.02584463357925415, -0.016638342291116714, 0.0018244943348690867, 0.0047536371275782585, -0.01785414293408394, -0.012476176954805851, 0.01787443645298481, -0.038986120373010635, -0.004597431048750877, -0.019684918224811554, -0.013666043989360332, -0.013833525590598583, -0.05067373067140579, 0.020005181431770325, -0.032321423292160034, 0.008897736668586731, -0.03996482864022255, 0.03619321063160896, 0.008533591404557228, 0.00827069766819477, 0.024864191189408302, 0.061444010585546494, 0.0211296696215868, -0.0033872995991259813, -0.0390516072511673, 0.03804026544094086, -0.010647385381162167, -0.028711816295981407, -0.03734825924038887, -0.015633119270205498, 0.028994139283895493, 0.00408860994502902, -0.046794869005680084, -0.028895266354084015, 0.025614870712161064, -0.01619815267622471, 0.0010741858277469873, -0.01297053787857294, 0.03205447271466255, 0.08875531703233719, -0.06598466634750366, 0.027617009356617928, 0.02735627070069313, 0.04905193671584129, -0.004921543411910534, 0.03178894892334938, 0.00786065123975277, -0.01984580047428608, -0.030566619709134102, -0.005411157850176096, -0.03170301392674446, -0.02544396184384823, 0.06694933027029037, -0.0013430406106635928, -0.04759030416607857, 0.01441645622253418, 0.001572987181134522, -0.018536396324634552, -0.032720502465963364, -0.006099438760429621, 0.014507136307656765, -0.00726860947906971, -0.01238708570599556, -0.07801471650600433, -0.015599111095070839, 0.028280889615416527, 0.08678603172302246, 0.01192188635468483, 0.04287233203649521, 0.05744684860110283, 0.06494037061929703, -0.0276523157954216, 0.0151266660541296, -0.03326306492090225, -0.018418077379465103, -0.005532245617359877, -0.054612889885902405, 0.025004738941788673, 0.03171323612332344, -0.03443044796586037, 0.02502669207751751, 0.02253439463675022, 0.025117656216025352, -0.004438064526766539, -0.019015546888113022, -0.004977624863386154, 0.026604076847434044, 0.04175277799367905, 0.03326389193534851, 0.020924538373947144, 0.03376972675323486, -0.01586083695292473, -0.012652494944632053, -0.04638468101620674, 0.05581841990351677, 0.0198606438934803, -0.02801050804555416, -0.01931353472173214, -0.045124176889657974, 0.043274037539958954, 0.005421638023108244, 0.02820705808699131, -0.010992839001119137, -0.018532443791627884, -0.0075025116093456745, -0.014234231784939766, -0.0401434563100338, -0.04419460892677307, 0.00807154830545187, 0.016428189352154732, -0.07063551247119904, 0.048287346959114075, 0.03379388153553009, -0.03740815073251724, 0.0006988702807575464, 0.04533844441175461, 0.03316839411854744, -0.01528171543031931, -0.025084173306822777, -0.022319531068205833, 0.019879993051290512, -0.0031216333154588938, 0.05425449088215828, 0.04175236448645592, -0.06484097987413406, -0.018808158114552498, 0.030417846515774727, 0.011290187016129494, -0.01616382598876953, -0.03716137260198593, -0.0005263358470983803, 0.01693054847419262, 0.024460680782794952, 0.022196026518940926, 0.0245177261531353, 0.02199419029057026, -0.014160807244479656, -0.009736588224768639, -0.02423415705561638, -0.031121136620640755, -0.03231982886791229, 0.02294955402612686, 0.00457282830029726, -0.029714412987232208, 0.01946832425892353, -0.03090701811015606, -0.027800098061561584, 0.031854983419179916, -0.05824000760912895, 0.024725891649723053, 0.034095264971256256, 0.02006266638636589, -0.04399764910340309, 0.046620965003967285, -0.02240237593650818, 0.0003070163365919143, -0.034781549125909805, 0.025545410811901093, -0.06756901741027832, 0.0034461473114788532, -0.028986284509301186, 0.0276391189545393, -0.027002917602658272, 0.03305196017026901, -0.02892346680164337, 0.0861261636018753, 0.020279958844184875, 0.02987387590110302, 0.04837033525109291, -0.062138792127370834, 0.01136226486414671, -0.0096238749101758, 0.01000323984771967, 0.031479060649871826, -0.03565966337919235, 0.11685901880264282, -0.009463638998568058, -0.01812632754445076, -0.025992220267653465, -0.0010918554617092013, -0.009116542525589466, 0.04666639491915703, 0.005540390964597464, -0.06580349057912827, 0.08525753021240234, 0.005536530166864395, -0.05015487223863602, -0.00900053046643734, -0.006495164707303047, -0.0010061741340905428, 0.02370234578847885, 0.018899884074926376, -0.016492050141096115, -0.022212741896510124, -0.0005589837091974914, 0.024175187572836876, -0.050118960440158844, 0.034681323915719986, 0.0325491838157177, 0.015622232109308243, 0.006000244989991188, 0.030947936698794365, 0.01956111565232277, 0.04686809331178665, -0.04256371781229973, -0.01700453646481037, 0.013479032553732395, 0.008717188611626625, -0.04686401039361954, 0.08586041629314423, 0.0192042775452137, 0.013269459828734398, -0.010876664891839027, 0.00827052816748619, 0.022468270733952522, 0.0784679502248764, -0.004887004848569632, -0.03278347849845886, -0.07538756728172302, 0.011198962107300758, -0.0028994798194617033, 0.02978641912341118, 0.04206249862909317, 0.01673048734664917, 0.027041608467698097, -0.027792733162641525, 0.0013108453713357449, -0.03438873961567879, 0.03557351231575012, -0.0009767183801159263, -0.012943526729941368, 0.05523714795708656, -0.0022403851617127657, -0.013384166173636913, -0.020108461380004883, -0.00601062411442399, 0.04232320934534073, -0.010820464231073856, -0.10348717868328094, -0.005988015327602625, -0.058935754001140594, -0.044064827263355255, 0.04384622722864151, 0.034854955971241, -0.016690658405423164, 0.04064297676086426, -0.004716325085610151, -0.045564427971839905, -0.05075736716389656, -0.005159056279808283, 0.005094521678984165, -0.0074515677988529205, 0.02838011458516121, -0.043299853801727295, -0.03549275919795036, 0.008031615056097507, -0.03434184566140175, -0.018473820760846138, -0.014107497408986092, 0.04574456065893173, 0.00575216906145215, 0.019807059317827225, 0.04164649546146393, -0.024879392236471176, 0.0033484669402241707, -0.008358476683497429, -0.030609309673309326, 0.03733834624290466, 0.0276014506816864, -0.029469532892107964, 0.003244455438107252, 0.06166088208556175, -0.0405564121901989, -0.03130028769373894, 0.03703225404024124, -0.019496677443385124, 0.07949903607368469, -0.04104765132069588, -0.03161412477493286, -0.0501321516931057, 0.018589399755001068, -0.013621785677969456, -0.05312627926468849, -0.034086160361766815, -0.05351800099015236, -0.00021706029656343162, -0.019960690289735794, 0.0559825599193573, -0.020135097205638885, 0.005209534894675016, -0.031874898821115494, 0.0008305695373564959, 0.06617321819067001, 0.011667974293231964, 0.06574008613824844, 0.03645777329802513, 0.03873806446790695, 0.05228874087333679, -0.018688173964619637, 0.033404454588890076, 0.04857140779495239, 0.03106313943862915, 0.017759215086698532, 0.008813208900392056, -0.011666093952953815, -0.010927105322480202, -0.039812974631786346, -0.00914012175053358, -0.05932442471385002, -0.08144720643758774, -0.023795712739229202, 0.020144451409578323, -0.03236763924360275, 0.0317741334438324, 0.010393486358225346, 0.05764472112059593, -0.03914722427725792, 0.0047136591747403145, 0.009555366821587086, -0.03488423675298691, -0.006205262616276741, -0.016313346102833748, 0.04518521577119827, -0.04133005440235138, 0.00824124738574028, -0.041419852524995804, -0.02134671062231064, 0.03057665005326271, 0.013271121308207512, 0.03690566495060921, -0.04501238465309143, -0.0595252625644207, -0.025492213666439056, -0.01769084297120571, 0.01450425572693348, 0.03510359302163124, 0.022634686902165413, -0.03744228556752205, 0.02239818125963211, 0.008307927288115025, -0.021797148510813713, 0.03984474018216133, 0.020758168771862984, -0.07276694476604462, 0.04624816030263901, 0.0418536402285099, 0.029169602319598198, 0.014661210589110851, 0.0005922233103774488, 0.06241023913025856, 0.04462023079395294, -0.025575080886483192, 0.044148221611976624, 0.014298725873231888, 0.0253278948366642, 0.005250907503068447, 0.021732836961746216, -0.032772891223430634, 0.0035948024597018957, -0.029030170291662216, 0.08023092895746231, -0.05040982365608215, -0.0761447548866272, 0.09434140473604202, -0.10597632825374603, 0.032185643911361694, 0.05299628898501396, 0.025885986164212227, -0.006737221498042345, -0.05713697895407677, -0.030954524874687195, 0.02391859143972397, -0.001045192126184702, 0.03512369468808174, -0.05456484109163284, -0.035781439393758774, -0.04183551296591759, 0.06584352999925613, 0.016792597249150276, -0.0014830310828983784, -0.013374521397054195, 0.02961401268839836, 0.006822727154940367, 0.02374664694070816, 0.022726068273186684, 0.03277511149644852, 0.007249587215483189, -0.05046222358942032, -0.0036217044107615948, -0.0411350317299366, -0.02724379673600197, 0.031975969672203064, -0.05552968010306358, 0.03100658394396305, -0.014945815317332745, 0.020128611475229263, -0.026053888723254204, -0.003884087083861232, 0.04515407234430313, -0.010189791209995747, -0.02426357939839363, 0.03628823533654213, 0.03906567022204399, -0.05128450691699982, -0.03810872882604599, 0.03156987205147743, 0.028795979917049408, -0.026898900046944618, -0.009371672756969929, 0.04441957175731659, 0.026472702622413635, 0.010174132883548737, -0.007549449801445007, 0.017940755933523178, -0.057315893471241, 0.01112600602209568, 0.03069387935101986, 0.023056887090206146, 0.06108555942773819, 0.029346371069550514, 0.0035319000016897917, 0.03810160607099533, 0.015725528821349144, -0.04789889231324196, 0.00019282216089777648, -0.023661203682422638, 0.005419041030108929, 0.016464686021208763, 0.04739801213145256, -0.025121508166193962, 0.016783883795142174, 0.028298575431108475, 0.0018482895102351904, -0.003550752531737089, 0.004252306185662746, 0.003517664037644863, -0.036624353379011154, -0.0006049555377103388, 0.034684307873249054, 0.034398362040519714, 0.038575779646635056, 0.03691805154085159, -0.05650372430682182, 0.03406291827559471, 0.019468775019049644, 0.07877466082572937, -0.03379014879465103, -0.03208116441965103, -0.027806371450424194, -0.03290734067559242, -0.036485735327005386, -0.02163318730890751, -0.05087112635374069, -0.027296673506498337, 0.015752198174595833, 0.018443889915943146, 0.05780278891324997, -0.015660827979445457, 0.003763651940971613, 0.028544340282678604, 0.04812502861022949, -0.018492892384529114, -0.029721740633249283, 0.015035678632557392, -0.0490570105612278, -0.04654033109545708, -0.04330706596374512, 0.03238188847899437, -0.003879847936332226, 0.002440362237393856, -0.009077697992324829, 0.074361152946949, 0.008070042356848717, 0.026019738987088203, -0.02128910832107067, -0.07843896001577377, 0.031339529901742935, -0.04331672191619873, 0.027372868731617928, 0.050433915108442307, 0.052511654794216156, 0.030785324051976204, 0.08566293120384216, -0.02187631092965603, 0.02459678426384926, -0.01608586683869362, 0.002831172663718462, -0.060664061456918716, -0.06698686629533768, 0.01463674008846283, 0.025509659200906754, -0.019026394933462143, 0.0007767355418764055, 0.06733346730470657, 0.01388713251799345, 0.00016172949108295143, -0.024679934605956078, -0.042153388261795044, -0.040786392986774445, -0.02011640928685665, 0.03851841017603874, -0.010428604669868946, 0.03191995620727539, -0.07354731112718582, -0.013580137863755226, -0.03722752258181572, -0.03614027425646782, 0.06878367066383362, -0.012055894359946251, -0.028275413438677788, -0.03823572397232056, 0.02411029487848282, -0.06520965695381165, 0.0021598590537905693, -0.04437272623181343, -0.007630106061697006, 0.08294763416051865, 0.03101026639342308, 0.02080032043159008, 0.05958617851138115, 0.005664333235472441, -0.07061677426099777, -0.015081495977938175, 0.06849923729896545, 0.0054186307825148106, -0.02411814220249653, 0.0030572039540857077, 0.008694885298609734, 0.028265101835131645, 0.049308739602565765, 0.008396144956350327, 0.021211817860603333, -0.030004136264324188, -0.035164982080459595, 0.04286772385239601, 0.028496775776147842, 0.01929464563727379, -0.008982964791357517, 0.011278606951236725, -0.029049184173345566, -0.006023976020514965, 0.019301071763038635, 0.04032956436276436, 0.0362185463309288, -0.02926039882004261, 0.011451824568212032, -0.047742679715156555, -0.045412708073854446, -0.04662645608186722, 0.010837679728865623, -0.0484081394970417, 0.0647333487868309, -0.054990947246551514, -0.037861865013837814, 0.018172748386859894, -0.0024119883310049772, 0.014119773171842098, 0.095372274518013, 0.013501903042197227, -0.06850303709506989, 0.03395029157400131, -0.028108004480600357, -0.002256671665236354, -0.05674821883440018, -0.014719570986926556, 0.0016996783670037985, 0.02272961288690567, 0.02517339028418064, -0.06958630681037903, -0.015268191695213318, -0.006107491906732321, -0.0022783216554671526, 0.04022959619760513, 0.0015197210013866425, -0.03952036798000336, -0.04955738037824631, 0.04149400442838669, 0.0697711631655693, 0.012963676825165749, -0.040982481092214584, -0.025630176067352295, 0.027422361075878143, 0.001626694342121482, -0.06277363002300262, -0.029762666672468185, -0.004936942830681801, 0.04109567776322365, 0.016806473955512047, 0.015029842965304852, -0.03134625032544136, 0.0036423804704099894, 0.02740868367254734, -0.02154976688325405, -0.039182402193546295, 0.027213869616389275, -0.017729507759213448, 0.026636919006705284, -0.014126315712928772, 0.009503058157861233, 0.06540489941835403, 0.03701451048254967, -0.004448469262570143, -0.012080134823918343, -0.045678094029426575, -0.0497187040746212, -0.011940750293433666, 0.054170265793800354, 0.019458934664726257, -0.010056021623313427, 0.03608853369951248, -0.009254892356693745 ]
<p>Let's assume we have predictors x1-x5 and dependent variables y1-y9 in one dataset. We have a certain hypothesis about x1: it should have differently strong effects on our 9 dependent variables y1-y9. </p> <p>We perform 9 regressions, and find that x1 significantly predicts all y with p&lt;.001. Now we want to find out whether these (highly significant) effects are different from each other (just because they are significant effects does not mean they are equally strong). Two questions: </p> <p>(1) What information that a regression provides us with would give us insight into this question? Unstandardized beta? Standardized beta? t?</p> <p>(2) Is there a statistical test we can perform to find out whether the strengths of predictions are different between (y1 ON x1) and (y2 ON x1) and (y3 ON x1)? </p> <p>Software I can use is R and SPSS; field is psychology/medicine. </p>
g36649
[ 0.023590153083205223, -0.0230700746178627, -0.020401857793331146, -0.04514342546463013, 0.009005974978208542, -0.05551152303814888, 0.0028186591807752848, 0.021268673241138458, -0.01967827044427395, -0.0643855556845665, 0.010478921234607697, 0.018059443682432175, 0.018203631043434143, -0.013990402221679688, 0.04084140807390213, 0.015891771763563156, 0.07670576125383377, -0.03611408546566963, 0.04774592071771622, -0.01658245548605919, 0.003445109585300088, 0.010475548915565014, -0.021173493936657906, 0.007293988019227982, -0.04645424336194992, -0.017150143161416054, -0.02712615765631199, 0.028038034215569496, -0.060423046350479126, 0.040056705474853516, 0.0034312575589865446, 0.012920704670250416, 0.059446949511766434, -0.028792880475521088, -0.032237861305475235, 0.001978356158360839, 0.06091809272766113, 0.012395815923810005, -0.019641820341348648, 0.005536332260817289, 0.02834717556834221, 0.03718596324324608, 0.03640834614634514, -0.02733234129846096, -0.027816075831651688, -0.013125286437571049, 0.013356734067201614, 0.01042433362454176, 0.02584541030228138, 0.0239634457975626, -0.0006614185404032469, -0.013795780949294567, -0.014912913553416729, 0.021425189450383186, 0.043754421174526215, 0.01656349003314972, 0.05296097695827484, 0.023420941084623337, 0.027493903413414955, -0.04372786730527878, 0.024207066744565964, -0.018521413207054138, -0.052180126309394836, -0.004552335478365421, -0.01320537831634283, -0.009744832292199135, -0.02528630755841732, -0.048151034861803055, -0.047489233314991, -0.023908087983727455, 0.016607731580734253, 0.00296270870603621, 0.04834013059735298, 0.018085310235619545, -0.07354559004306793, 0.027318280190229416, -0.008832180872559547, -0.0030366943683475256, -0.030455417931079865, 0.008785448037087917, 0.05569788068532944, -0.03717927262187004, 0.03533739596605301, 0.09446565061807632, 0.00592273473739624, -0.014311815612018108, 0.035507626831531525, 0.025176774710416794, 0.062343746423721313, 0.03851906210184097, 0.035054951906204224, 0.021336866542696953, 0.02344217337667942, 0.1025857999920845, -0.022745953872799873, -0.015345880761742592, -0.015228739939630032, -0.02953265607357025, 0.007826261222362518, 0.011529547162353992, -0.014124538749456406, 0.04312751442193985, -0.006619530264288187, 0.006947875488549471, -0.023080086335539818, -0.00028859692974947393, 0.014691940508782864, -0.008431603200733662, -0.059703387320041656, -0.048853110522031784, 0.00433160737156868, -0.003127065021544695, -0.037726402282714844, -0.01814044453203678, -0.053064409643411636, -0.08384522050619125, 0.03885796666145325, -0.005118349567055702, -0.05627504736185074, -0.03690032288432121, 0.024439245462417603, -0.0009172033751383424, 0.03193085640668869, 0.052111901342868805, -0.028940197080373764, 0.008701588958501816, -0.021479520946741104, 0.07260900735855103, -0.007901035249233246, 0.0311026182025671, 0.046444132924079895, 0.0007156714564189315, 0.032693617045879364, 0.031680237501859665, 0.043134454637765884, 0.05375199019908905, -0.025083046406507492, 0.0329228974878788, -0.006062451284378767, 0.008434007875621319, -0.02716151252388954, 0.08027448505163193, -0.0035719985608011484, 0.01225201040506363, -0.033007171005010605, 0.0011828599963337183, 0.03669344261288643, 0.054027847945690155, -0.07753430306911469, 0.0038134902715682983, 0.03780458867549896, -0.02897910214960575, -0.020599136129021645, 0.03333577513694763, -0.10192268341779709, -0.038770560175180435, -0.05302330479025841, -0.013809376396238804, 0.017394334077835083, 0.005225450731813908, -0.014739269390702248, -0.021103817969560623, -0.003949600271880627, 0.02405662275850773, 0.0015128644881770015, 0.00014450555318035185, 0.005504894070327282, 0.006362361367791891, -0.003974888473749161, 0.05335729569196701, 0.0044875494204461575, -0.01927562616765499, 0.03682645410299301, -0.01986355520784855, 0.04694964364171028, 0.04099676385521889, 0.01640290766954422, -0.01796818897128105, 0.08108825236558914, 0.030794894322752953, -0.007704554591327906, 0.021547656506299973, 0.01612398400902748, -0.052809249609708786, -0.012483310885727406, -0.040248360484838486, -0.004405766725540161, -0.03237296640872955, -0.0888386145234108, -0.022676071152091026, -0.057358212769031525, -0.006098107434809208, 0.0021663822699338198, -0.02456442266702652, 0.0025737029500305653, -0.041157640516757965, 0.013817873783409595, -0.04412902146577835, -0.022631224244832993, -0.009222373366355896, -0.031012989580631256, 0.07530613988637924, -0.004284191876649857, 0.06453436613082886, -0.04053646698594093, 0.04199192300438881, 0.009324511513113976, -0.013931780122220516, 0.0031445445492863655, -0.007065832614898682, -0.03972051665186882, -0.005233223550021648, 0.03285030648112297, 0.02703217789530754, 0.037056222558021545, 0.0009929006919264793, 0.029852626845240593, 0.05699621140956879, -0.011158335953950882, -0.004885410889983177, -0.008444401435554028, -0.028390662744641304, 0.04304715245962143, -0.02149374783039093, -0.006867535877972841, 0.031979408115148544, 0.02659221924841404, 0.025246677920222282, -0.002410168992355466, -0.005091141909360886, -0.0045540472492575645, -0.032592371106147766, 0.010924468748271465, -0.03732982650399208, 0.03982064872980118, -0.02766300179064274, 0.03348810598254204, -0.03654412180185318, 0.006057895720005035, 0.06391028314828873, 0.019055983051657677, -0.05179700627923012, -0.039750635623931885, 0.03639114648103714, 0.02851533703505993, -0.027855977416038513, -0.010794049128890038, -0.014211279340088367, 0.03517632186412811, 0.06154966354370117, -0.02878708206117153, 0.11703666299581528, -0.060676246881484985, -0.012488202191889286, 0.013080598786473274, -0.029009299352765083, 0.020546995103359222, 0.013854081742465496, -0.03962385281920433, -0.014137161895632744, -0.0449141226708889, 0.01929599419236183, -0.0024984723422676325, 0.06274047493934631, 0.007935046218335629, -0.008566818200051785, 0.006365702487528324, -0.01552113238722086, -0.027696315199136734, -0.010565684176981449, -0.014185990206897259, 0.009597538970410824, 0.04091775044798851, 0.05561116337776184, 0.01625632867217064, 0.03954187035560608, -0.04878076910972595, 0.009904450736939907, 0.014989815652370453, -0.02155337855219841, 0.028388341888785362, -0.013442275114357471, -0.03610462695360184, 0.02175835333764553, 0.034980639815330505, 0.015500162728130817, 0.06941042095422745, -0.0035269379150122404, 0.0007422570488415658, 0.058721549808979034, -0.007357288151979446, 0.024822112172842026, 0.06073911488056183, -0.005160161294043064, -0.05161845684051514, -0.017147168517112732, 0.005865493789315224, -0.08456399291753769, 0.009438530541956425, 0.003747406182810664, -0.06488988548517227, 0.017632804811000824, 0.041455719619989395, 0.04102861136198044, 0.024073829874396324, -0.060566555708646774, -0.04314880445599556, 0.013557838276028633, 0.049113351851701736, -0.005628351587802172, -0.07777188718318939, 0.008747350424528122, 0.020389888435602188, -0.006714390125125647, -0.00825406052172184, -0.02265397645533085, 0.044888779520988464, 0.06386351585388184, 0.022905219346284866, 0.021912815049290657, 0.0342978872358799, -0.08610861748456955, -0.04135660454630852, 0.06019992753863335, 0.007089223712682724, 0.010521827265620232, -0.06169082596898079, 0.021728891879320145, -0.09255760908126831, 0.012510918080806732, 0.04675266519188881, 0.04850954934954643, -0.010812600143253803, -0.04019611328840256, -0.014707259833812714, -0.0007151032914407551, 0.03578503057360649, -0.03576745465397835, -0.021336518228054047, 0.031993500888347626, 0.0026502294931560755, 0.008191026747226715, -0.057183366268873215, 0.008894721046090126, -0.04697230085730553, 0.006281103938817978, 0.02892082743346691, 0.02552807703614235, 0.02120383083820343, -0.012184515595436096, -0.015348049812018871, -0.012438401579856873, 0.01673767901957035, -0.03475119173526764, 0.04342171922326088, -0.018648235127329826, 0.057812489569187164, -0.0033487204927951097, -0.012569291517138481, -0.002465031575411558, -0.005388513673096895, -0.017802421003580093, -0.007735160179436207, -0.040985699743032455, -0.0523248054087162, 0.03556482121348381, 0.02362251654267311, 0.02462119795382023, 0.017369886860251427, -0.02978576347231865, 0.018809504806995392, 0.04970899596810341, 0.02263561077415943, -0.015344778075814247, 0.0036519072018563747, -0.015989204868674278, 0.059219688177108765, 0.022533684968948364, -0.023337330669164658, 0.029562491923570633, 0.06761226803064346, 0.05079108849167824, -0.0035639507696032524, 0.037726376205682755, -0.005436604376882315, -0.07809649407863617, 0.014299935661256313, 0.012285950593650341, 0.02252272702753544, 0.0016237462405115366, 0.012120223604142666, -0.03898992761969566, -0.09554918110370636, 0.0674959346652031, 0.025714771822094917, -0.05005864426493645, 0.030318060889840126, 0.01918504759669304, 0.006784006487578154, -0.003973294515162706, -0.03938055783510208, 0.024541078135371208, -0.00030491940560750663, 0.04694673791527748, 0.009410579688847065, -0.055697664618492126, -0.021432414650917053, -0.00862662773579359, -0.0986722782254219, 0.015605214051902294, 0.004713645204901695, -0.04041098803281784, -0.00397682236507535, -0.07938175648450851, 0.004072118084877729, 0.015626661479473114, 0.053796619176864624, -0.05375389754772186, 0.021105095744132996, -0.004674272146075964, 0.012094310484826565, 0.032734375447034836, -0.02777218073606491, -0.02599620632827282, 0.036160096526145935, 0.0003667165001388639, -0.00488494336605072, 0.03214702755212784, 0.03679094836115837, -0.0015669434797018766, 0.07226093113422394, 0.03691771253943443, -0.05359730124473572, -0.004207564052194357, 0.025972699746489525, 0.03999044746160507, -0.03655405342578888, -0.059758156538009644, -0.015263923443853855, -0.048210568726062775, 0.0012283301912248135, -0.00824227835983038, 0.0012966761132702231, 0.03932688757777214, -0.02123539336025715, 0.03820980340242386, -0.04201340675354004, 0.002558453707024455, -0.014056183397769928, 0.02278534136712551, -0.09600387513637543, 0.009441555477678776, -0.0076946378685534, -0.0502743273973465, 0.010881255380809307, 0.015852754935622215, 0.051446329802274704, 0.02316940762102604, 0.005422116257250309, 0.06175927072763443, -0.03516136854887009, -0.047941360622644424, 0.004594015423208475, 0.020570330321788788, -0.0586373470723629, -0.0046683247201144695, -0.0880286917090416, -0.011166189797222614, -0.003399392357096076, 0.06358910351991653, -0.048022013157606125, -0.00021220142662059516, 0.0638524666428566, -0.010912159457802773, -0.021012263372540474, -0.001951655955053866, 0.0002993478556163609, -0.07741566002368927, -0.03822256624698639, -0.0010175652569159865, -0.035449519753456116, -0.039364010095596313, 0.008261348120868206, -0.0009025018662214279, 0.015456211753189564, -0.023936990648508072, -0.04235593229532242, -0.015677141025662422, 0.00763016939163208, -0.044788263738155365, 0.003932810388505459, 0.070003442466259, 0.03763213008642197, -0.011189932934939861, 0.017147261649370193, -0.04129762947559357, 0.04564385861158371, -0.01715944893658161, -0.018692536279559135, 0.018252192065119743, -0.03519764170050621, 0.027216611430048943, 0.05987371876835823, -0.00006728818698320538, -0.0508367121219635, 0.049580734223127365, 0.09526566416025162, -0.051808543503284454, -0.02287205308675766, 0.04053880274295807, -0.051108308136463165, -0.025979310274124146, 0.029718980193138123, -0.037953637540340424, -0.033814918249845505, 0.029290014877915382, -0.008338349871337414, 0.08032789081335068, -0.0016818810254335403, 0.0023125731386244297, 0.05427010729908943, -0.03585454076528549, 0.056603044271469116, 0.021619951352477074, 0.05055300146341324, -0.06521578878164291, -0.044527824968099594, -0.060567837208509445, -0.0221104733645916, -0.02070157788693905, 0.024068066850304604, 0.006075430661439896, -0.043368149548769, 0.025546036660671234, 0.07303702086210251, 0.002287271898239851, -0.023266414180397987, 0.000669775705318898, -0.033523064106702805, -0.0017705954378470778, -0.041089169681072235, 0.022950947284698486, 0.02635292150080204, -0.06808357685804367, -0.06834530085325241, -0.01969165913760662, -0.029778478667140007, -0.013136646710336208, -0.0130593441426754, 0.01466627512127161, -0.005682649090886116, 0.020614445209503174, -0.02296067774295807, 0.013650563545525074, -0.016996564343571663, -0.005466938018798828, 0.05332653224468231, -0.011311536654829979, 0.03616408258676529, 0.018829992040991783, -0.04972507804632187, -0.05701027065515518, 0.020251665264368057, -0.033425770699977875, 0.006183821242302656, -0.0639573410153389, -0.07114841789007187, -0.05319301038980484, 0.031037334352731705, 0.04135960340499878, 0.026533393189311028, 0.010513217188417912, 0.06108240410685539, -0.004709598142653704, -0.038806457072496414, -0.031016875058412552, -0.029326574876904488, 0.026303185150027275, 0.03211444988846779, -0.012859697453677654, -0.00937885046005249, -0.04057621583342552, 0.010986934415996075, 0.018707115203142166, 0.002452055225148797, 0.0894475132226944, -0.04930379241704941, 0.04672013595700264, -0.0310130026191473, -0.01898716203868389, 0.019710589200258255, -0.009081152267754078, 0.0319143608212471, -0.044144801795482635, 0.01899595931172371, -0.05255568027496338, -0.014762867242097855, 0.04501333832740784, 0.017626656219363213, 0.0003330118197482079, 0.029709089547395706, -0.03803229331970215, 0.05042998492717743, -0.005059737246483564, 0.032370589673519135, -0.028979090973734856, -0.022897129878401756, 0.0014286533696576953, -0.005433791782706976, -0.003091399557888508, -0.029123378917574883, 0.03080316074192524, 0.03747183457016945, 0.03999970853328705, -0.00491723557934165, -0.006296189967542887, -0.016402533277869225, 0.021328046917915344, -0.03935187682509422, -0.016285160556435585, 0.041131824254989624, -0.019702397286891937, -0.0411938913166523, -0.034220147877931595, 0.021430764347314835, 0.013633892871439457, -0.018155552446842194, -0.03923875465989113, 0.02254541777074337, 0.021743277087807655, 0.03231363743543625, 0.0025007999502122402, 0.005163515917956829, 0.011855116114020348, -0.05281134694814682, 0.034847017377614975, -0.060622163116931915, 0.06172255426645279, -0.05007355287671089, 0.05121013894677162, -0.001254374161362648, -0.00020618698908947408, -0.04803360626101494, 0.03553995490074158, 0.01650485210120678, 0.05215735733509064, 0.05422927066683769, 0.022184044122695923, -0.010108103975653648, -0.017890458926558495, 0.054298579692840576, 0.005658518057316542, 0.05130823329091072, -0.08898261189460754, 0.051458194851875305, 0.032346148043870926, 0.07288321852684021, 0.02258589118719101, 0.04587559401988983, 0.019418010488152504, -0.012790183536708355, -0.031369227916002274, -0.06941889226436615, 0.03038192167878151, -0.03220373019576073, 0.03892065957188606, -0.03920086845755577, -0.0173830334097147, 0.039587728679180145, -0.02234506979584694, 0.03717659041285515, -0.05206649377942085, 0.020274849608540535, 0.028792763128876686, 0.04818320646882057, -0.048722151666879654, -0.027217376977205276, -0.018743224442005157, -0.07150833308696747, 0.011497014202177525, -0.049352504312992096, 0.024047719314694405, 0.023138336837291718, 0.013932802714407444, -0.014622416347265244, 0.04408228397369385, -0.03682558611035347, -0.040192537009716034, 0.02230670303106308, -0.005594548303633928, -0.09790964424610138, -0.06756329536437988, -0.02581329643726349, -0.02126307785511017, -0.04197533801198006, 0.041114501655101776, -0.017186228185892105, 0.04257049411535263, -0.01134468987584114, 0.028704244643449783, -0.0266617089509964, 0.05306537449359894, -0.039917171001434326, -0.02993798814713955, 0.02086109295487404, 0.04083297401666641, -0.04987974092364311, -0.03473808243870735, -0.022335970774292946, -0.04139449819922447, -0.005484617780894041, 0.05243179202079773, 0.03386518731713295, 0.008528568781912327, -0.011572799645364285, 0.0027857511304318905, 0.00478465436026454, -0.06607920676469803, 0.03419104591012001, 0.0306836124509573, -0.05310686305165291, -0.04066158086061478, -0.008927276358008385, -0.023522721603512764, 0.012697270140051842, -0.03735997900366783, -0.051110126078128815, 0.02918965183198452, 0.027837667614221573, 0.018637584522366524, -0.023838527500629425, -0.046836256980895996, -0.028116391971707344, 0.0075040291994810104, 0.007902275770902634, 0.055148638784885406, 0.02401457354426384, 0.02768680639564991, -0.049722444266080856, -0.027714967727661133, -0.0031999535858631134, 0.013860722072422504, -0.014408755116164684, -0.05830656737089157, -0.0213109590113163, 0.034899841994047165, 0.0038825063966214657, 0.055470358580350876, 0.014161424711346626, -0.05992870777845383, -0.030819257721304893, 0.0018303580582141876, -0.01984562911093235, 0.0780857726931572, -0.02368227392435074, 0.018110990524291992, -0.044034771621227264, -0.007112783845514059, 0.02526806853711605, -0.015194524079561234, -0.019232451915740967, -0.019962303340435028, -0.022460851818323135, 0.020794572308659554, 0.04502232372760773, 0.009447996504604816, 0.014838703908026218, 0.02599390037357807 ]
<p>I'm trying to program impulse response functions for a VAR model using Cholesky decomposition. The thing is I do not completely understand how I should do this when I read in the literature. Suppose I have:</p> <p>$$ \begin{bmatrix}x_t\\y_t\\z_t\end{bmatrix}=\begin{bmatrix}\alpha_1\\\alpha_2\\\alpha_3\end{bmatrix}+\begin{bmatrix}b_{11}&amp;b_{12}&amp;b_{13}\\b_{21}&amp;b_{22}&amp;b_{23}\\b_{31}&amp;b_{32}&amp;b_{33}\end{bmatrix}\begin{bmatrix}x_{t-1}\\y_{t-1}\\z_{t-1}\end{bmatrix}+\begin{bmatrix}u_{1t}\\ u_{2t}\\ u_{3t}\end{bmatrix} $$ which we can write as $$ \mathbf{x}_t=\mathbf{a}+\mathbf{B}\mathbf{x}_{t-1}+\mathbf{u}_t. $$</p> <p>Further, suppose the covariance matrix of $\mathbf{u}_t$ is $$ Cov(\mathbf{u}_t)=\Sigma_u=PP^\prime. $$</p> <p>Now, let's say I want the impulse responses to a unit shock in $u_{1t}$. I want the effects then on say $\mathbf{x}_t, \, \mathbf{x}_{t+1}, \, \mathbf{x}_{t+2}$ and $\mathbf{x}_{t+3}$. As I understand it, the orthogonalization is done by multiplying the error vector with $P$. Let's call the responses in period $t$ to the shock $\mathbf{x}_t^*$. Would what I am interested in then be (assume unit shock in $u_{1t}$ such that $\mathbf{u}_t^*=\begin{bmatrix}1&amp;0&amp;0\end{bmatrix}^\prime$):</p> <p>$$ \mathbf{x}_t^*=P\mathbf{u}^*_t=P\begin{bmatrix}1\\0\\0\end{bmatrix}\\ \mathbf{x}_{t+1}^*=\mathbf{B}\mathbf{x}^*_t=\mathbf{B}P\mathbf{u}^*_t\\ \mathbf{x}_{t+2}^*=\mathbf{B}\mathbf{x}^*_{t+1}=\mathbf{B}\mathbf{B}P\mathbf{u}^*_t\\ \mathbf{x}_{t+3}^*=\mathbf{B}\mathbf{x}^*_{t+2}=\mathbf{B}\mathbf{B}\mathbf{B}P\mathbf{u}^*_t $$</p> <p>Now, extend this to include more lags (for example 4). The model is then $$ \mathbf{x}_t=\mathbf{a}+\sum_{k=1}^4\mathbf{B}_k\mathbf{x}_{t-k}+\mathbf{u}_t. $$</p> <p>Thus the impulses are:</p> <p>$$ \mathbf{x}_t^*=P\mathbf{u}^*_t=P\begin{bmatrix}1\\0\\0\end{bmatrix}\\ \mathbf{x}_{t+1}^*=\mathbf{B}_1\mathbf{x}^*_t=\mathbf{B}_1P\mathbf{u}^*_t\\ \mathbf{x}_{t+2}^*=\mathbf{B}_1\mathbf{x}^*_{t+1}+\mathbf{B}_2\mathbf{x}^*_t=\mathbf{B}_1\mathbf{B}_1P\mathbf{u}^*_t + \mathbf{B}_2P\mathbf{u}^*_t\\ \mathbf{x}_{t+3}^*=\mathbf{B}_1\mathbf{x}^*_{t+2}+\mathbf{B}_2\mathbf{x}^*_{t+1}+\mathbf{B}_3\mathbf{x}^*_{t}=\mathbf{B}_1\mathbf{B}_1\mathbf{B}_1P\mathbf{u}^*_t + \mathbf{B}_1\mathbf{B}_2P\mathbf{u}^*_t+\mathbf{B}_2\mathbf{B}_1P\mathbf{u}^*_t+\mathbf{B}_3P\mathbf{u}^*_t $$</p> <p>Is this line of thinking correct? If so, then this simple R code should be fine:</p> <pre><code>library(vars) set.seed(1) x &lt;- rnorm(100) set.seed(2) y &lt;- rnorm(100) set.seed(3) z &lt;- rnorm(100) data &lt;- cbind(x, y, z) model &lt;- VAR(data, p=4, type = "const") u &lt;- matrix(c(1, 0, 0), ncol=1) P &lt;- chol(cov(residuals(model))) B1 &lt;- Acoef(model)[[1]] B2 &lt;- Acoef(model)[[2]] B3 &lt;- Acoef(model)[[3]] B4 &lt;- Acoef(model)[[4]] xt &lt;- P %*% u xt1 &lt;- B1 %*% xt xt2 &lt;- B1 %*% xt1 + B2 %*% xt xt3 &lt;- B1 %*% xt2 + B2 %*% xt1 + B1 %*% xt </code></pre> <p>Any input would be very much appreciated!</p>
g36651
[ -0.0001572101900819689, -0.0349530465900898, -0.0076620010659098625, -0.011377290822565556, 0.03935371711850166, -0.03418456017971039, 0.06540914624929428, 0.04018907621502876, -0.01916871778666973, -0.006883473135530949, -0.006371818482875824, 0.003456423059105873, 0.03192761912941933, 0.000022984690076555125, 0.011984260752797127, -0.02556014433503151, 0.04218856617808342, -0.02229914627969265, -0.02426639012992382, -0.04245409369468689, 0.0020911814644932747, 0.024856144562363625, 0.029999805614352226, -0.02918107807636261, 0.012068341486155987, 0.0018041968578472733, 0.019567206501960754, 0.05088360980153084, -0.032515835016965866, 0.07541316002607346, -0.027559852227568626, 0.004822188057005405, 0.0034519261680543423, -0.0731467753648758, -0.04088086262345314, 0.023984700441360474, 0.04587370902299881, -0.011201872490346432, 0.02006566897034645, 0.00543726934120059, 0.01735127530992031, -0.06679075211286545, 0.05142626166343689, -0.0186651311814785, -0.020846650004386902, -0.022458519786596298, 0.00580478785559535, -0.06295834481716156, -0.03257917985320091, -0.001184609136544168, 0.019647592678666115, -0.01137295551598072, 0.032452698796987534, -0.03893192857503891, -0.060074977576732635, 0.05111423134803772, -0.021801317110657692, 0.007607766892760992, -0.02510322816669941, 0.03474077209830284, 0.02985844761133194, -0.02852025255560875, -0.008607864379882812, -0.05005713552236557, 0.0012726077111437917, 0.021425921469926834, -0.05851033702492714, -0.01636563241481781, 0.013532538898289204, -0.025693772360682487, 0.00830957293510437, 0.024601832032203674, -0.04706714302301407, -0.04163177311420441, -0.0545777790248394, -0.030138760805130005, -0.027740849182009697, -0.04163791984319687, -0.04374951124191284, 0.044859178364276886, 0.0016661720583215356, -0.004024404566735029, -0.06767109036445618, -0.00925369281321764, -0.008163407444953918, -0.05057346448302269, 0.003378176363185048, 0.024500923231244087, 0.009717971086502075, -0.030227230861783028, -0.04203014448285103, -0.012359504587948322, 0.04173588752746582, 0.04568960517644882, 0.005832795985043049, 0.027116121724247932, -0.07639358937740326, -0.0074132755398750305, 0.02924482338130474, -0.018211103975772858, -0.010947410948574543, 0.024196168407797813, 0.03324360400438309, -0.09704562276601791, -0.04955390840768814, -0.046771202236413956, 0.044653333723545074, 0.006813103333115578, -0.022517599165439606, -0.009873075410723686, -0.06493764370679855, 0.037529438734054565, -0.023539403453469276, -0.03094722516834736, -0.03623376786708832, -0.018841292709112167, 0.05205636844038963, -0.017030462622642517, -0.050215862691402435, 0.010173223912715912, 0.010544377379119396, -0.06366215646266937, 0.02519020438194275, 0.023312987759709358, 0.015711704269051552, -0.02064424380660057, -0.018888918682932854, 0.014133758842945099, -0.0029808597173541784, -0.04202695190906525, 0.008890420198440552, 0.01649077795445919, -0.009213589131832123, 0.05495719611644745, 0.023234540596604347, 0.009461482986807823, 0.008067627437412739, 0.036538850516080856, 0.024774940684437752, 0.045194413512945175, -0.031616393476724625, -0.06579265743494034, -0.07193741947412491, -0.0071554179303348064, -0.002768564037978649, 0.02751159854233265, 0.02441341057419777, -0.008308141492307186, -0.01146604958921671, -0.011465299874544144, -0.04051726311445236, 0.07045648247003555, -0.02259029820561409, 0.02252327837049961, 0.009167558513581753, -0.007866332307457924, 0.032402947545051575, -0.03430062159895897, -0.02838551253080368, -0.03451376408338547, 0.04720181226730347, 0.006847257725894451, 0.02288077585399151, 0.04037374258041382, -0.03939436376094818, 0.015207221731543541, 0.03665674477815628, -0.06967125833034515, -0.027553588151931763, -0.052358727902173996, 0.002831017132848501, 0.010021374560892582, 0.003923872485756874, -0.0462334081530571, 0.03490718454122543, 0.024467462673783302, 0.006155486684292555, 0.017864184454083443, 0.058888182044029236, -0.004614007193595171, -0.054160404950380325, 0.019010521471500397, -0.00330437277443707, -0.011985206976532936, -0.009252015501260757, 0.0032847910188138485, 0.015692539513111115, 0.041581813246011734, -0.0604066364467144, 0.023902997374534607, 0.02504783309996128, 0.05747541785240173, -0.0033966090995818377, 0.010984980501234531, -0.06949170678853989, 0.010954977944493294, -0.017927363514900208, -0.043830376118421555, -0.005474438890814781, 0.031220825389027596, -0.03542902320623398, 0.02449882961809635, 0.03819410875439644, 0.04101451858878136, -0.00046590305282734334, 0.036741703748703, -0.03803567588329315, -0.005407154094427824, -0.03695511445403099, 0.0070607103407382965, 0.06863239407539368, -0.04915721341967583, 0.010103401727974415, 0.026237256824970245, -0.00876340176910162, -0.07341856509447098, 0.049219463020563126, 0.01525930780917406, -0.01590809039771557, -0.047782111912965775, -0.015163044445216656, -0.039610542356967926, 0.0030420455150306225, -0.0021514541003853083, -0.05219292268157005, 0.03361211344599724, 0.05934320390224457, 0.03061791881918907, 0.04262573644518852, -0.009589091874659061, 0.020087948068976402, 0.0222492516040802, -0.029894648119807243, -0.060492515563964844, -0.022515257820487022, -0.0023799941409379244, -0.04262014850974083, 0.01540660671889782, -0.037944260984659195, 0.008011199533939362, 0.011524497531354427, 0.056828614324331284, 0.056240297853946686, 0.01613323763012886, 0.03439885005354881, -0.03841043636202812, -0.005601290613412857, 0.009687256067991257, -0.04086582735180855, -0.01575121469795704, -0.07897564023733139, 0.024970903992652893, -0.014465654268860817, -0.021931760013103485, 0.02483406849205494, -0.06989523768424988, 0.03445614501833916, -0.010588712990283966, 0.0060492693446576595, 0.014824867248535156, 0.009494571946561337, 0.05514172837138176, -0.01534129586070776, 0.008920257911086082, -0.055154599249362946, 0.01754693314433098, 0.045051008462905884, 0.02396972104907036, -0.005706964060664177, -0.03666495159268379, -0.03890903294086456, 0.010164332576096058, 0.032194312661886215, 0.05042131617665291, 0.024551566690206528, 0.0022838921286165714, -0.027751877903938293, 0.026972107589244843, 0.007586209569126368, -0.021533051505684853, 0.0011654463596642017, -0.02666410245001316, -0.009842542000114918, 0.01054392196238041, 0.04317794367671013, -0.028796089813113213, 0.03394297882914543, 0.08421684801578522, -0.011986869387328625, -0.03239735588431358, -0.08700034022331238, 0.02327570877969265, 0.004131385590881109, -0.021815435960888863, -0.038273073732852936, 0.012805411592125893, 0.04694140702486038, -0.06711944937705994, 0.022317446768283844, 0.025874536484479904, -0.016540469601750374, -0.014407867565751076, 0.022034823894500732, -0.020860370248556137, 0.007538491394370794, -0.025068044662475586, -0.0735507532954216, 0.034257013350725174, 0.03343993425369263, 0.0253594983369112, 0.04160718619823456, -0.032451700419187546, -0.03597824648022652, -0.05814898759126663, -0.018001172691583633, -0.06389413774013519, 0.008028804324567318, -0.040412530303001404, 0.04146427661180496, 0.020383097231388092, -0.05399089679121971, -0.08546649664640427, 0.021992024034261703, 0.024142103269696236, 0.030056439340114594, 0.04105907306075096, -0.01379595510661602, -0.010633034631609917, -0.0013026584638282657, 0.01954634301364422, 0.02189929597079754, -0.012724041007459164, 0.04691972956061363, 0.015095186419785023, 0.010196533985435963, -0.03753874823451042, -0.05629604309797287, 0.04543021321296692, 0.01335106510668993, -0.020917806774377823, 0.016668325290083885, -0.020867222920060158, 0.012643055059015751, -0.0003524082130752504, 0.011364618316292763, -0.001526704290881753, -0.008808989077806473, 0.0534156896173954, 0.031009558588266373, -0.0162592064589262, 0.04210371896624565, 0.06999877095222473, 0.02081276662647724, -0.009238170459866524, 0.01536285039037466, 0.0604754202067852, 0.019504811614751816, -0.01440191175788641, 0.02808932587504387, -0.0330028161406517, 0.0077217877842485905, -0.05327555164694786, -0.05985809117555618, 0.043919313699007034, 0.014415529556572437, 0.048968635499477386, 0.0768902450799942, 0.018243100494146347, -0.040542200207710266, -0.007458791136741638, 0.0310912374407053, -0.012531899847090244, 0.03536069765686989, 0.012676219455897808, 0.026361903175711632, -0.09810678660869598, 0.0058385515585541725, 0.011896911077201366, 0.025675060227513313, 0.05183961242437363, 0.011545542627573013, -0.008054224774241447, 0.011459063738584518, -0.010210474953055382, 0.0275824423879385, 0.0007551480084657669, 0.03756088390946388, 0.008102583698928356, -0.002636722521856427, 0.03422499820590019, 0.04878314211964607, -0.04153761267662048, -0.055253636091947556, 0.03731466457247734, 0.02513285167515278, -0.04277181997895241, 0.015117639675736427, 0.016778239980340004, -0.13802474737167358, 0.013635623268783092, -0.008988067507743835, -0.05118595063686371, 0.008166829124093056, -0.029489101842045784, -0.032374057918787, -0.018260743468999863, -0.031231380999088287, 0.016795048490166664, -0.008974562399089336, -0.017268894240260124, -0.021037565544247627, -0.031744543462991714, 0.004081464372575283, -0.08746078610420227, 0.07124170660972595, 0.01610538922250271, 0.06640827655792236, 0.05241519585251808, -0.019511964172124863, 0.014941824600100517, 0.029236821457743645, 0.014866791665554047, 0.02691851556301117, 0.024209538474678993, 0.0019704513251781464, 0.03545349836349487, 0.002140634460374713, -0.052783191204071045, 0.025067662820219994, -0.055350162088871, 0.008233866654336452, 0.04916096851229668, -0.030311524868011475, 0.054618507623672485, -0.0010576396016404033, -0.0035715585108846426, -0.08633635193109512, -0.019275039434432983, -0.005959709174931049, 0.041525330394506454, 0.02332591451704502, 0.0003413292288314551, -0.010070516727864742, -0.01774774305522442, 0.0029376973398029804, 0.016147613525390625, 0.02574000135064125, -0.04066544771194458, 0.015265285968780518, -0.023653917014598846, 0.010923417285084724, 0.054440997540950775, 0.04346520081162453, -0.004947292152792215, 0.04735945165157318, -0.004627176560461521, 0.027755256742239, 0.026254843920469284, 0.016531750559806824, 0.027284007519483566, -0.005440937355160713, -0.00989522784948349, -0.03598002716898918, -0.0594639852643013, 0.0007071083527989686, 0.0028506184462457895, -0.04204573109745979, -0.0209613349288702, 0.008756523951888084, -0.028774339705705643, 0.04958458989858627, -0.020859330892562866, 0.046466484665870667, -0.031448327004909515, -0.007599962875247002, 0.020536994561553, -0.058211103081703186, 0.0025783879682421684, 0.029254714027047157, 0.06131456047296524, 0.006299078464508057, -0.009685277938842773, 0.003226697677746415, 0.0372731015086174, 0.028025558218359947, 0.023388123139739037, 0.020079215988516808, -0.06659135222434998, -0.012732550501823425, 0.0023343623615801334, 0.02058890461921692, 0.10445594787597656, 0.03323303535580635, -0.013232576660811901, -0.00025738734984770417, -0.037073343992233276, 0.03904129937291145, -0.0021333806216716766, -0.03315272182226181, 0.025829827412962914, -0.03717217966914177, -0.03763718903064728, 0.004335248377174139, 0.01908147893846035, 0.02106434851884842, -0.025219593197107315, 0.0010928409174084663, 0.0002645586500875652, 0.03775373846292496, 0.004943859297782183, 0.035817958414554596, 0.029569050297141075, 0.036878231912851334, -0.018720658496022224, -0.1129470095038414, -0.006283347494900227, -0.03714049607515335, 0.007863511331379414, -0.028983457013964653, -0.1277788132429123, 0.04704971984028816, -0.10013703256845474, 0.030535589903593063, -0.0035172763746231794, 0.06300753355026245, 0.01774320751428604, 0.015110964886844158, -0.0725165382027626, -0.05538944527506828, 0.00652112765237689, -0.03374100849032402, -0.046798575669527054, -0.0437488853931427, -0.05541771277785301, -0.011646060273051262, -0.027388541027903557, -0.05005286633968353, -0.008217085152864456, 0.02274446375668049, -0.06209222972393036, -0.039487242698669434, -0.018465816974639893, 0.01942637376487255, -0.040458690375089645, -0.02087654359638691, 0.004665438551455736, -0.026364564895629883, -0.012824478559195995, -0.041372306644916534, -0.029646579176187515, -0.03155100345611572, -0.03552600368857384, 0.0032563924323767424, -0.019732872024178505, 0.05776887387037277, 0.05014931410551071, -0.03504377603530884, -0.05655214563012123, 0.02145584672689438, -0.008943979628384113, -0.01219076570123434, -0.011288534849882126, 0.015530526638031006, -0.04494210705161095, 0.08249478787183762, 0.01100887544453144, 0.028348764404654503, 0.0012021855218335986, 0.00410776911303401, 0.02512984722852707, 0.014467539265751839, -0.08499503135681152, -0.028442474082112312, -0.004522297531366348, 0.024382665753364563, 0.04555674269795418, -0.002250354504212737, -0.025357719510793686, -0.021863358095288277, 0.06807190924882889, 0.01891978830099106, -0.010681835934519768, -0.01455548033118248, 0.02107437327504158, -0.01184194628149271, 0.026515604928135872, 0.0065024918876588345, -0.006936206948012114, 0.02110479213297367, -0.060875095427036285, -0.03925132751464844, 0.026118570938706398, 0.0229849424213171, 0.01398400217294693, -0.02346353605389595, 0.038652434945106506, 0.007466350216418505, 0.05047477036714554, 0.024202976375818253, -0.008390668779611588, 0.02559242583811283, 0.03159109875559807, 0.046396370977163315, -0.03090641275048256, -0.03227309137582779, -0.006271650083363056, -0.026887506246566772, -0.001465297187678516, 0.021527234464883804, 0.054035816341638565, -0.058172356337308884, -0.003599336603656411, 0.04528588056564331, 0.038497649133205414, 0.05349217355251312, 0.026693124324083328, -0.016267767176032066, 0.018023904412984848, 0.01425944920629263, 0.030204521492123604, -0.002976211253553629, 0.050131019204854965, 0.09617415070533752, -0.0007581151439808309, 0.06997155398130417, 0.014315958134829998, 0.017533713951706886, 0.032621439546346664, 0.017267080023884773, -0.0002011939068324864, -0.0030871506314724684, -0.011114501394331455, -0.0368608795106411, 0.04344548285007477, -0.00695978244766593, 0.06330554932355881, -0.0018381605623289943, 0.09403270483016968, 0.0012087979121133685, 0.06582310795783997, 0.03681628406047821, 0.06726469844579697, -0.004846872761845589, 0.02547331713140011, -0.0524955615401268, 0.0013060589553788304, 0.04167015850543976, 0.022403046488761902, -0.07214004546403885, -0.021527793258428574, 0.014808028005063534, 0.029771743342280388, 0.016778187826275826, 0.0012446836335584521, -0.009895071387290955, 0.00991008710116148, 0.021103518083691597, 0.025736093521118164, 0.04599617421627045, 0.04153762012720108, -0.033562030643224716, -0.05659308657050133, -0.044638071209192276, -0.033363692462444305, 0.07108300179243088, 0.07949547469615936, 0.003636380657553673, 0.034652434289455414, 0.04676070436835289, -0.056679487228393555, -0.03281939774751663, -0.02857469581067562, 0.009332227520644665, 0.06870616227388382, 0.04085683077573776, 0.0033922933507710695, 0.028557196259498596, -0.00786928366869688, -0.03728295862674713, -0.05056937038898468, 0.012636448256671429, -0.01676020585000515, -0.034646205604076385, 0.007280952762812376, -0.00475406926125288, 0.038553137332201004, 0.01113236602395773, 0.01940414123237133, 0.06794250011444092, -0.010235612280666828, -0.03545480594038963, 0.09918815642595291, 0.04636169224977493, 0.012936956249177456, -0.03523282706737518, 0.02143298089504242, -0.01301370095461607, 0.031634509563446045, 0.001998964697122574, 0.11733955889940262, 0.015191052109003067, -0.015601444989442825, 0.048198215663433075, -0.02349487692117691, 0.007912879809737206, 0.0031787047628313303, -0.0650138109922409, -0.0565493106842041, -0.009376538917422295, -0.07909443974494934, -0.005562409292906523, 0.012657271698117256, -0.06897170841693878, 0.04501400887966156, -0.014066328294575214, 0.002174810506403446, -0.013241934590041637, 0.0028611349407583475, -0.03540915623307228, -0.04125997796654701, 0.0019817333668470383, -0.015269598923623562, -0.0017615368124097586, 0.08399797230958939, 0.03584093227982521, 0.013084227219223976, -0.058765385299921036, 0.034024905413389206, -0.010026373900473118, 0.023357195779681206, 0.006027908064424992, -0.0345563180744648, -0.06688699126243591, 0.032764237374067307, 0.020134009420871735, 0.0041778176091611385, 0.013238219544291496, 0.016314592212438583, 0.0018423200817778707, 0.05818098410964012, 0.02024976909160614, -0.05235235020518303, -0.02078692428767681, 0.05265182629227638, 0.02327200397849083, -0.023079223930835724, -0.024111462756991386, -0.009787184186279774, 0.005065807141363621, -0.01354458648711443, 0.005332006607204676, -0.031831685453653336, -0.007276900112628937, 0.044325243681669235, 0.01633920520544052, 0.004406968131661415, 0.0493958443403244, -0.02412698231637478, 0.006488789338618517, -0.05584675446152687, -0.032697852700948715, 0.0019437256269156933, -0.02537134476006031, 0.011198294349014759, -0.027918733656406403, -0.038350772112607956, -0.009371161460876465, -0.05385425314307213 ]
<p>I estimated a Partial Least Squares model where the X matrix had normalized columns. Now I want to predict the value for a new instance (which is a frequency vector summing to one.) I assume that if I just use the raw frequency values, the predicted value won't be on the same scale as the scenario where my 'new' instance was taken from the normalized X matrix. (i.e. Comparing the fitted values of the model with predicted value of new instance.)</p> <p>I was thinking of adding the new instance as the bottom row of the original non-normalized X matrix, normalizing, and then using the values from this new bottom row to predict.</p> <p>Alternatively, I could standardize by using the column means and standard deviations from the original non-normalized X. </p> <p>Is one method preferred to the other? Is there a better way?</p>
g50
[ 0.01931346207857132, -0.03755491226911545, 0.020156443119049072, -0.07598838210105896, -0.03468974679708481, -0.03497178852558136, -0.02483505755662918, -0.012830670922994614, -0.026507673785090446, -0.04396790638566017, 0.030720051378011703, -0.013901603408157825, 0.037710681557655334, 0.0030322850216180086, -0.04215293377637863, 0.05465845763683319, 0.03988942503929138, -0.04427698254585266, -0.027931218966841698, 0.010499107651412487, -0.02186698280274868, -0.004338342230767012, 0.07312372326850891, -0.01980776898562908, -0.09133751690387726, -0.044943831861019135, -0.02761175110936165, 0.08253425359725952, -0.013346382416784763, 0.026196200400590897, -0.05424737557768822, 0.02531384862959385, -0.002751584630459547, -0.00898829661309719, -0.026737673208117485, 0.002627457957714796, 0.04941198602318764, 0.025048930197954178, 0.011055493727326393, 0.035615257918834686, 0.004422296304255724, -0.00373001117259264, 0.0018725921399891376, 0.03469471260905266, 0.015968406572937965, -0.05002554506063461, -0.014816971495747566, -0.026938926428556442, 0.013445014134049416, 0.07234865427017212, -0.0008206304046325386, 0.003552063135430217, -0.019484853371977806, 0.012841527350246906, 0.021636350080370903, 0.03968120738863945, 0.02675660513341427, 0.038382720202207565, 0.015370568260550499, -0.0049532619304955006, 0.02425822801887989, -0.0384589359164238, -0.016584204509854317, -0.0321844257414341, -0.04919770732522011, 0.06071384623646736, -0.034506529569625854, 0.028106795623898506, -0.05766063556075096, -0.012598248198628426, -0.029989536851644516, 0.04768349975347519, -0.004648590926080942, -0.007556389085948467, -0.10964851826429367, -0.010083166882395744, 0.021748870611190796, -0.0030750224832445383, 0.03264980390667915, 0.0365261472761631, -0.005612003616988659, 0.057041000574827194, 0.055820561945438385, -0.0035998427774757147, 0.016736937686800957, 0.04536692798137665, -0.007469678297638893, -0.0028697296511381865, 0.023744169622659683, 0.018543019890785217, -0.034486476331949234, -0.007830540649592876, 0.01261128205806017, 0.0006423885351978242, 0.008725734427571297, -0.021662147715687752, -0.0519130676984787, -0.005897593684494495, 0.00516922352835536, -0.008929560892283916, 0.019519159570336342, 0.06472375243902206, 0.00027159546152688563, -0.0269768126308918, -0.07892341911792755, 0.05334092304110527, 0.031698137521743774, -0.030599992722272873, -0.0064370231702923775, -0.017475230619311333, -0.05217446759343147, -0.004613952245563269, -0.014269577339291573, -0.03644046559929848, -0.03778352960944176, -0.07664685696363449, 0.0508791022002697, -0.014790259301662445, 0.016333065927028656, 0.0005467174341902137, 0.04754545912146568, -0.03203434497117996, 0.05372866988182068, 0.07960066199302673, -0.01102514285594225, 0.031051820144057274, 0.009247194044291973, 0.06606800854206085, -0.010980663821101189, -0.04929850623011589, 0.013402963988482952, -0.022801585495471954, 0.02027163654565811, 0.04244410991668701, 0.04292062669992447, 0.058588478714227676, 0.050886522978544235, 0.017783919349312782, 0.01628826931118965, -0.013840039260685444, -0.02395024709403515, 0.04920105263590813, -0.003610393963754177, -0.014932241290807724, 0.007049817591905594, -0.0022778136190027, -0.03468095138669014, -0.06082351133227348, 0.007926351390779018, 0.06574313342571259, 0.0029327007941901684, 0.037578824907541275, -0.03860296681523323, 0.008269431069493294, -0.04291852191090584, 0.0659586638212204, 0.01397840864956379, 0.0123972836881876, -0.01587493345141411, -0.039774470031261444, 0.04939844831824303, -0.04983678460121155, 0.013455180451273918, -0.03785988315939903, 0.020508911460638046, -0.026035670191049576, 0.02743593044579029, -0.06835532933473587, -0.012288074940443039, -0.04911428317427635, 0.009208756498992443, -0.014570003375411034, 0.02685253508388996, -0.01453403104096651, 0.005331446882337332, 0.07144348323345184, 0.019347265362739563, -0.04362194612622261, 0.008668866939842701, -0.011196549981832504, -0.01607832871377468, 0.026232216507196426, -0.007620444521307945, -0.047058239579200745, 0.026997165754437447, -0.04491147771477699, -0.0002344338281545788, 0.045102808624506, -0.02966703288257122, 0.01674928516149521, -0.04404823109507561, 0.0433182492852211, -0.031706731766462326, 0.031102271750569344, -0.07314050197601318, -0.013722045347094536, 0.01457357406616211, 0.0232398584485054, -0.03362424671649933, 0.030844060704112053, 0.06382110714912415, 0.003421081230044365, -0.020999550819396973, 0.03420587256550789, -0.0035857222974300385, 0.04443112388253212, 0.010878841392695904, -0.07374865561723709, 0.02125791274011135, 0.06166897341609001, -0.06885150820016861, 0.008560266345739365, -0.031446509063243866, 0.039055779576301575, 0.007361197844147682, 0.04177609831094742, 0.004040648229420185, 0.07165773957967758, -0.02886270359158516, 0.003959860652685165, -0.0721873864531517, -0.05612965673208237, 0.018883293494582176, 0.027776304632425308, 0.04201912134885788, 0.03566780313849449, 0.04674244299530983, 0.052192650735378265, 0.03650279343128204, 0.010015660896897316, 0.0031255073845386505, -0.04461051896214485, -0.026585159823298454, -0.014176435768604279, 0.002906199311837554, 0.041136763989925385, 0.02566666342318058, -0.015470257960259914, 0.04726261645555496, -0.005733258556574583, 0.043295398354530334, -0.001703704590909183, 0.02290276810526848, -0.02705445885658264, -0.035502783954143524, -0.032022666186094284, 0.01848415657877922, -0.040456373244524, -0.01203877478837967, 0.022768329828977585, -0.049162816256284714, 0.06621228903532028, -0.028210071846842766, -0.045535895973443985, -0.03474844619631767, -0.04339062422513962, 0.03227018564939499, 0.010755302384495735, -0.01611040160059929, -0.014806002378463745, -0.030796315521001816, 0.004635151941329241, -0.03323638439178467, 0.005711084697395563, -0.020951667800545692, -0.010741060599684715, 0.03302077203989029, 0.02057729661464691, 0.02274920605123043, 0.020212294533848763, 0.04793477803468704, -0.019178885966539383, 0.048832591623067856, 0.029771871864795685, 0.05640929937362671, 0.044336169958114624, -0.016406778246164322, 0.0036033340729773045, -0.010747318156063557, -0.02887624315917492, -0.028678087517619133, -0.04253079369664192, -0.00028235986246727407, -0.0218371395021677, 0.023483432829380035, 0.0025575202889740467, 0.06286714971065521, -0.04285651817917824, -0.01033632643520832, 0.06597790867090225, -0.08990948647260666, 0.038544364273548126, -0.012341529130935669, -0.028176963329315186, 0.013691743835806847, 0.016093729063868523, 0.08737032115459442, -0.051611825823783875, 0.04605262354016304, 0.005506548564881086, -0.02019631490111351, -0.009291443042457104, 0.016800636425614357, -0.009342414326965809, 0.03892377018928528, -0.009805483743548393, -0.04879005253314972, 0.008549535647034645, 0.04888361692428589, -0.009384444914758205, -0.019485408440232277, -0.04863038659095764, -0.00548536516726017, -0.001169700874015689, -0.01869969815015793, -0.05910644307732582, -0.03449513763189316, 0.005885524675250053, 0.01254410669207573, -0.015775088220834732, 0.012941350229084492, -0.040868498384952545, 0.030455617234110832, 0.0290283914655447, -0.035158660262823105, 0.05119156464934349, -0.02878318354487419, 0.029684053733944893, -0.05259310081601143, 0.03899046406149864, 0.018039312213659286, 0.011522514745593071, -0.029481496661901474, 0.011981260031461716, 0.018239375203847885, -0.049520060420036316, -0.017489956691861153, 0.02040584199130535, 0.029263487085700035, 0.03180816024541855, -0.01849720999598503, -0.010353432968258858, 0.00770058948546648, -0.07368435710668564, -0.026766180992126465, -0.04020494222640991, -0.025240570306777954, -0.004785019438713789, -0.04188414663076401, -0.026490364223718643, -0.015325212851166725, -0.011720884591341019, 0.0008417070494033396, 0.03186554089188576, 0.006290169898420572, 0.08349080383777618, 0.03169412538409233, 0.021544788032770157, -0.029196737334132195, 0.037575799971818924, 0.024690726771950722, -0.0365411750972271, -0.022097816690802574, 0.04515781253576279, 0.015297872945666313, 0.011186862364411354, 0.030437303707003593, 0.05151914805173874, 0.001929445075802505, -0.07200264185667038, -0.003923560027033091, 0.03761797025799751, 0.08225242048501968, 0.023573584854602814, -0.01864852011203766, 0.03669993579387665, 0.1006515771150589, -0.006889715790748596, -0.01957753673195839, 0.04500982165336609, 0.0267166867852211, 0.018006781116127968, -0.053153831511735916, -0.040974609553813934, 0.029030177742242813, -0.031907711178064346, -0.01871887408196926, 0.05557727813720703, -0.04835159704089165, 0.03474286198616028, -0.01256043091416359, -0.026425346732139587, -0.0279086846858263, 0.02684715948998928, 0.0027241965290158987, 0.002487202174961567, 0.02338411845266819, -0.0023255322594195604, 0.011499489657580853, 0.03958698734641075, 0.01588979735970497, -0.00776137039065361, -0.015820393338799477, 0.028113272041082382, 0.011878089979290962, -0.006924893707036972, 0.00544791528955102, -0.014806555584073067, -0.01434408500790596, -0.01695919781923294, -0.00658818893134594, 0.03005245514214039, 0.024101819843053818, -0.05548034980893135, 0.020023001357913017, 0.021004516631364822, 0.04549030587077141, 0.01698126271367073, -0.010830705054104328, 0.009477205574512482, -0.038282956928014755, 0.042483001947402954, -0.06215173378586769, 0.02029319293797016, 0.03268740326166153, -0.04280955344438553, 0.00767661863937974, -0.022503243759274483, 0.008261285722255707, -0.057297561317682266, 0.0243724063038826, -0.03392945975065231, -0.07328776270151138, 0.039286695420742035, -0.018476765602827072, -0.05101276934146881, 0.016045162454247475, -0.01770828850567341, 0.0055468520149588585, -0.07363969087600708, -0.030493609607219696, -0.0044292486272752285, -0.013496293686330318, -0.02299291081726551, 0.013763041235506535, 0.001940504414960742, -0.011500204913318157, -0.00816590990871191, -0.00813289824873209, 0.06543945521116257, 0.00555290887132287, 0.025014163926243782, 0.04387195408344269, 0.03131018206477165, -0.024681830778717995, -0.029763726517558098, 0.034409210085868835, 0.056714463979005814, -0.005601824261248112, -0.013157802633941174, -0.025928538292646408, -0.017083754763007164, -0.09722311049699783, -0.05875515937805176, -0.0022272204514592886, -0.005835267249494791, -0.0661437138915062, -0.004786408971995115, 0.013379385694861412, -0.027013780549168587, 0.03172115981578827, -0.07922453433275223, 0.03248277306556702, 0.012025528587400913, 0.004801664501428604, 0.017729390412569046, 0.026839928701519966, 0.021975215524435043, -0.012959587387740612, 0.004238108638674021, -0.02102939784526825, -0.02477406896650791, 0.03317008167505264, -0.008806148543953896, 0.019481847062706947, -0.029729627072811127, -0.01206191536039114, -0.08115792274475098, 0.05225488170981407, 0.03073335625231266, -0.03140668943524361, 0.03513701260089874, -0.02521800436079502, 0.03623111546039581, -0.03507900610566139, 0.0066615925170481205, 0.013406431302428246, -0.03794175386428833, -0.01401288527995348, 0.006407758686691523, -0.05725587159395218, 0.09354643523693085, 0.045223284512758255, -0.031756553798913956, 0.07308425009250641, -0.017510434612631798, 0.02470351941883564, -0.016545487567782402, 0.03194713220000267, 0.07403083890676498, 0.01362699456512928, 0.021391844376921654, 0.0642787516117096, -0.008680848404765129, -0.014173582196235657, -0.03014846332371235, 0.07928135246038437, 0.06131695210933685, 0.008242329582571983, -0.07346546649932861, 0.033227454870939255, -0.032338641583919525, -0.010836328379809856, -0.022817853838205338, 0.010290507227182388, -0.09808387607336044, -0.01309931743890047, 0.0019257779931649566, -0.008114899508655071, -0.04211624339222908, 0.01056432444602251, 0.01712055131793022, -0.009878251701593399, 0.013773929327726364, -0.009456133469939232, -0.025205709040164948, -0.04700854420661926, 0.03642088174819946, -0.0025825712364166975, -0.0666331797838211, -0.04697905108332634, -0.0009318400407209992, 0.059682801365852356, -0.07842972874641418, 0.0028378176502883434, -0.032972753047943115, 0.003082673531025648, 0.01640229858458042, 0.005088950041681528, 0.020748313516378403, -0.02014925889670849, 0.013066980987787247, -0.03683554753661156, 0.022650817409157753, -0.0023464576806873083, -0.03910955786705017, 0.017366761341691017, -0.024305805563926697, 0.0017315297154709697, 0.03790466859936714, 0.00820961780846119, -0.04521911218762398, 0.05964586138725281, 0.02053925395011902, -0.048179566860198975, 0.02127910777926445, -0.012596270069479942, 0.04858430474996567, 0.019999146461486816, -0.03603513911366463, -0.018724210560321808, -0.055826663970947266, 0.05725938454270363, 0.036064136773347855, -0.03273259103298187, -0.0572064183652401, 0.08389563858509064, -0.025168506428599358, 0.05769762396812439, -0.003418533829972148, -0.04587863013148308, -0.03419685363769531, -0.003941239323467016, 0.05224836990237236, -0.01425121072679758, -0.012556379660964012, -0.007457939442247152, -0.01796860061585903, 0.046534519642591476, 0.010895452462136745, -0.01791096106171608, -0.010188820771872997, 0.017225494608283043, 0.059790585190057755, -0.012351488694548607, 0.00524537730962038, -0.0386648029088974, 0.032587699592113495, 0.04840640723705292, 0.003132103942334652, -0.021538473665714264, -0.013892189599573612, 0.015667732805013657, -0.05520892143249512, 0.03126106038689613, 0.008598890155553818, -0.025769798085093498, -0.02397172711789608, 0.018943272531032562, 0.03380048647522926, 0.007290144916623831, -0.04014766961336136, 0.013344524428248405, 0.04727807641029358, 0.008705823682248592, -0.02689887210726738, 0.01931030862033367, 0.031443025916814804, 0.004428453743457794, 0.02489481493830681, -0.016855232417583466, -0.01863657496869564, -0.044994253665208817, -0.019906410947442055, 0.03250781074166298, 0.029151402413845062, 0.0318116620182991, -0.008548349142074585, 0.08314859867095947, 0.015776395797729492, -0.02542581595480442, -0.0006937288562767208, -0.021922098472714424, -0.0027742849197238684, -0.07131374627351761, 0.037875380367040634, -0.029186315834522247, 0.049337081611156464, 0.02998761646449566, 0.014021674171090126, 0.029934575781226158, 0.05904499068856239, -0.005578282754868269, -0.008094023913145065, -0.07586979866027832, 0.029631104320287704, 0.05605993792414665, 0.03646206483244896, -0.05208740755915642, 0.0008802590891718864, 0.015033448114991188, -0.02257603406906128, 0.0026335525326430798, -0.010556433349847794, -0.00240329303778708, 0.027208801358938217, 0.06941645592451096, 0.009533782489597797, 0.05189603939652443, 0.029084568843245506, 0.0009641230572015047, -0.09427332133054733, 0.012043524533510208, -0.05715378373861313, 0.015012085437774658, 0.004361371509730816, -0.05760198459029198, -0.0557510070502758, -0.01737244240939617, -0.053114473819732666, 0.025134043768048286, -0.12868733704090118, -0.009195364080369473, 0.021994614973664284, 0.029378386214375496, -0.0058652074076235294, 0.008353921584784985, 0.023229451850056648, -0.06591707468032837, -0.003907875157892704, 0.05801291763782501, -0.06827939301729202, 0.009858300909399986, -0.012125642970204353, -0.00760528864338994, 0.028038375079631805, 0.023888101801276207, -0.007611437700688839, 0.01711096800863743, -0.0002554246748331934, -0.031146707013249397, -0.045858584344387054, 0.0019044921500608325, 0.0317055843770504, -0.019130364060401917, 0.01946408860385418, -0.049898430705070496, 0.02866235561668873, 0.005963296629488468, 0.03100651688873768, -0.03977162390947342, 0.04714147374033928, -0.03113282099366188, -0.01962285302579403, -0.03259582445025444, -0.0514257438480854, 0.05616428330540657, -0.07059941440820694, -0.0106468191370368, -0.09034080058336258, -0.020347122102975845, 0.02373354136943817, 0.014961513690650463, 0.03256805241107941, -0.024739248678088188, 0.013906138017773628, 0.029079608619213104, -0.052837781608104706, 0.03124067559838295, 0.0067896489053964615, -0.0928114801645279, 0.0023281527683138847, -0.01687891222536564, 0.012000408954918385, 0.05251592770218849, 0.021938687190413475, -0.027883442118763924, 0.043214671313762665, -0.006304724141955376, 0.01952436938881874, -0.05455143004655838, -0.0024160966277122498, -0.02535519376397133, 0.058101970702409744, 0.06089853122830391, 0.011633076705038548, -0.030697161331772804, 0.032001566141843796, -0.047228869050741196, 0.031705670058727264, -0.09096240252256393, -0.0010052568977698684, -0.02899874746799469, 0.022822929546236992, 0.01034544501453638, 0.07651610672473907, 0.013833021745085716, 0.005303387064486742, -0.025244615972042084, -0.013509711250662804, -0.031368646770715714, 0.007991521619260311, -0.030687512829899788, 0.052399542182683945, 0.04953016713261604, 0.004185592755675316, -0.023687399923801422, -0.008956057019531727, -0.023514624685049057, -0.08670247346162796, 0.013127235695719719, 0.012418859638273716, 0.0065165129490196705, 0.008981326594948769, -0.010228419676423073, -0.04357345402240753, 0.020382001996040344, 0.01486053317785263 ]
<p>My work involves building statistical / econometric models using R, SPSS modeler. I am also doing my PhD (part time) in econometrics. In order to do more advanced data / model visualisation I am thinking about to pick up another programming language. Any suggestion will be much appreciated. </p>
g74027
[ 0.05994054302573204, -0.04106178507208824, -0.00883496180176735, -0.030297527089715004, -0.03570173308253288, -0.03534658998250961, -0.01086081936955452, 0.02695348672568798, 0.010894715785980225, -0.04226429760456085, 0.04632599279284477, -0.006250343751162291, 0.1093667671084404, -0.004618427250534296, -0.03189733251929283, 0.02684928849339485, -0.004248746205121279, -0.02292614057660103, -0.0962642952799797, 0.008579914458096027, -0.003426744369789958, 0.008099531754851341, 0.07957059144973755, -0.024738002568483353, -0.010383624583482742, 0.005479210987687111, -0.02443413995206356, 0.03434929624199867, -0.021857764571905136, -0.002149897627532482, 0.009899301454424858, 0.0038458032067865133, -0.0662541463971138, -0.07934191077947617, -0.030685503035783768, -0.0202539823949337, 0.021488770842552185, 0.02302776835858822, -0.01932309940457344, 0.018448153510689735, 0.00896469410508871, 0.00994738470762968, 0.026540031656622887, -0.01352963037788868, 0.026229163631796837, -0.051183249801397324, 0.01254285592585802, -0.005734689068049192, 0.003793900366872549, 0.006885084323585033, 0.06302232295274734, -0.0032808510586619377, -0.01784338615834713, 0.008452928625047207, 0.026041274890303612, 0.0043903132900595665, -0.04042286053299904, 0.024659181013703346, 0.04109591618180275, -0.052943386137485504, 0.033696189522743225, 0.06121475249528885, -0.052068065851926804, -0.04232665151357651, -0.0003530413960106671, 0.016115669161081314, 0.025705089792609215, -0.06709668785333633, 0.025368744507431984, -0.04522215574979782, -0.030114581808447838, 0.0023114890791475773, 0.043729085475206375, -0.022853750735521317, -0.024077605456113815, -0.026074042543768883, 0.0029477684292942286, -0.03441867604851723, 0.029768502339720726, -0.0007794981938786805, -0.08302991092205048, -0.006861802190542221, -0.02967185527086258, 0.05826622247695923, 0.06334631890058517, -0.0575142465531826, -0.009640810079872608, -0.05229286476969719, 0.01071752980351448, -0.03394473344087601, -0.009421912021934986, -0.006482685916125774, 0.030042238533496857, 0.03930019214749336, -0.025526227429509163, -0.024790706112980843, -0.08684994280338287, 0.025854110717773438, -0.00014002180250827223, 0.0063881902024149895, -0.05543290823698044, -0.0568007230758667, 0.05679662153124809, -0.037616606801748276, -0.01657848432660103, -0.0524396114051342, -0.0030230784323066473, -0.058445997536182404, -0.03814881667494774, -0.021699512377381325, 0.012976218946278095, 0.006285716313868761, -0.05968853458762169, 0.061993129551410675, -0.04720688983798027, -0.011497793719172478, 0.0260247103869915, -0.07257454097270966, -0.002286277711391449, 0.010042632929980755, 0.018423005938529968, -0.0038363838102668524, 0.021142734214663506, 0.003370943246409297, -0.03531527891755104, -0.023787660524249077, 0.003558533499017358, 0.018245073035359383, -0.049872592091560364, -0.003472911426797509, 0.058515310287475586, 0.016917230561375618, -0.05233337730169296, 0.013105318881571293, 0.04814467951655388, 0.07747545838356018, -0.03587804734706879, 0.0072063119150698185, 0.0610349103808403, -0.03353269025683403, 0.006063197739422321, 0.023934122174978256, -0.005756665952503681, -0.04042290151119232, -0.05176853761076927, 0.014283274300396442, 0.0707879364490509, 0.05831301212310791, -0.04241195693612099, 0.0039522117003798485, -0.017318235710263252, -0.0034414592664688826, -0.03157374635338783, 0.012080826796591282, -0.044575415551662445, -0.01990688219666481, 0.004094487521797419, -0.025390751659870148, 0.010711288079619408, -0.018807005137205124, 0.011211592704057693, -0.004594180732965469, -0.02846725843846798, 0.03867920860648155, 0.024620933458209038, -0.0020697745494544506, 0.028063999488949776, -0.03708857670426369, -0.03396828472614288, 0.028302453458309174, -0.01525012869387865, 0.012921848334372044, 0.029790587723255157, -0.029281163588166237, 0.03196306154131889, -0.008018238469958305, -0.04297340288758278, 0.011795934289693832, 0.01926952227950096, -0.007434193976223469, -0.0034729652106761932, -0.05969838798046112, 0.02287295088171959, -0.06444375962018967, -0.022737381979823112, -0.040742676705121994, 0.01978193409740925, 0.005607751198112965, -0.02535266801714897, -0.002304330701008439, 0.001904146047309041, 0.0024467380717396736, -0.010758059099316597, -0.019555265083909035, 0.010783656500279903, -0.052148476243019104, -0.023465236648917198, -0.03160174563527107, 0.03216959163546562, 0.022388329729437828, 0.03890002891421318, 0.018565140664577484, -0.004525903612375259, 0.02307572402060032, -0.05068037658929825, -0.004828530363738537, -0.003168924944475293, -0.038298241794109344, -0.0030316761694848537, 0.06339108943939209, -0.013014030642807484, 0.011133256368339062, 0.040164049714803696, 0.03261079266667366, 0.1090715229511261, 0.027980919927358627, -0.0266906525939703, 0.05755193531513214, 0.02110837958753109, 0.031961459666490555, 0.019804801791906357, -0.0657309740781784, 0.0450592041015625, 0.06448164582252502, 0.03001069650053978, 0.012561917304992676, 0.02455444075167179, 0.05799064412713051, 0.04526631534099579, 0.020021535456180573, -0.00025311586796306074, -0.02155335061252117, 0.003691625315696001, -0.031972214579582214, 0.0718056708574295, 0.026641620323061943, 0.0367685966193676, -0.020941760390996933, -0.004489808809012175, 0.0031079603359103203, 0.013386759907007217, 0.014196601696312428, -0.028500569984316826, 0.0297207273542881, 0.016744308173656464, 0.022825997322797775, 0.029932616278529167, 0.04747774079442024, 0.05461285263299942, 0.02545754238963127, 0.020285142585635185, 0.022421883419156075, -0.009536882862448692, -0.018883448094129562, -0.006329756695777178, -0.013553004711866379, -0.0026678310241550207, 0.0027368583250790834, 0.03344336897134781, 0.01979033090174198, -0.02293410338461399, 0.04618615657091141, -0.03957591950893402, 0.007630724925547838, 0.017136042937636375, 0.059985097497701645, -0.03976772725582123, -0.0065933638252317905, -0.002405730076134205, 0.009850794449448586, -0.008140220306813717, 0.02212989516556263, -0.013852005824446678, -0.04357528313994408, 0.028461666777729988, 0.03141937404870987, -0.0024636248126626015, -0.05952276289463043, 0.05772797018289566, -0.027663592249155045, 0.02633284591138363, -0.07476262003183365, 0.04965272173285484, -0.006657544989138842, 0.025727545842528343, -0.011688611470162868, 0.0443420484662056, 0.0029496580827981234, -0.0069478778168559074, -0.0035946720745414495, -0.049155812710523605, 0.04459569230675697, -0.03620176389813423, -0.06480187177658081, -0.05653734877705574, -0.01945328898727894, -0.06450903415679932, 0.016716865822672844, 0.07681654393672943, 0.06930883228778839, -0.012705093249678612, -0.00425309594720602, 0.06185183301568031, 0.00816037692129612, 0.015558261424303055, -0.02863532491028309, -0.01671990565955639, -0.03221144899725914, 0.0021021952852606773, 0.0019177268259227276, -0.004519416019320488, -0.06264277547597885, -0.050279129296541214, 0.01006911788135767, -0.03189152106642723, -0.04256584495306015, -0.0259297676384449, -0.0054839858785271645, -0.014467519707977772, -0.01015322096645832, 0.04871710017323494, -0.027609845623373985, 0.06859876215457916, -0.043140310794115067, -0.006479920353740454, 0.08346681296825409, 0.019751396030187607, -0.045937564224004745, -0.08320925384759903, 0.03540560603141785, 0.015719611197710037, -0.02555377036333084, 0.03408154472708702, -0.013476511463522911, -0.027704497799277306, 0.014626502990722656, 0.0061976611614227295, -0.04822222515940666, -0.009083476848900318, -0.03897276148200035, 0.023844562470912933, -0.021806079894304276, 0.06521321088075638, 0.006952171213924885, -0.05225107818841934, 0.003717799438163638, 0.0406055673956871, -0.05590887367725372, 0.07123751938343048, -0.01733003556728363, -0.038140151649713516, 0.050213586539030075, 0.03151242807507515, -0.09660564363002777, -0.011744912713766098, -0.05976516380906105, 0.04536587744951248, -0.012247125618159771, 0.010038204491138458, -0.008843330666422844, -0.019287260249257088, -0.02269025146961212, -0.048141416162252426, 0.02206234261393547, -0.07225583493709564, 0.019704462960362434, 0.053262609988451004, 0.01284085400402546, 0.015691110864281654, -0.05887612700462341, 0.03120589256286621, 0.057207051664590836, 0.06862149387598038, -0.014900311827659607, 0.008270657621324062, -0.0011513737263157964, 0.018075378611683846, 0.0407397486269474, 0.02982928417623043, 0.05501095578074455, -0.004349128343164921, 0.014382611960172653, 0.004550575278699398, 0.02202487364411354, -0.038272179663181305, -0.05126727744936943, 0.009377517737448215, 0.05655936896800995, -0.03652913495898247, -0.007471835240721703, 0.013256673701107502, -0.026759812608361244, -0.026824887841939926, -0.012937802821397781, 0.00591802503913641, -0.014851294457912445, -0.007198129780590534, 0.012280690483748913, 0.015376961790025234, 0.01567056030035019, -0.09113772213459015, -0.049731504172086716, 0.045227717608213425, -0.010353033430874348, -0.01996345818042755, -0.06950552016496658, -0.04199356213212013, 0.011368666775524616, -0.08776921778917313, 0.0213454719632864, -0.04262883961200714, -0.005784704349935055, 0.04002639278769493, 0.015278169885277748, 0.01258372887969017, 0.028181198984384537, 0.03729403764009476, -0.04605183005332947, -0.01658187247812748, 0.05302304029464722, 0.01934216544032097, 0.009170577861368656, -0.005818346049636602, -0.03492960333824158, 0.04393945634365082, -0.004298544488847256, 0.05372646078467369, 0.07687890529632568, -0.02940107136964798, 0.04712843894958496, 0.011395172215998173, -0.02244120091199875, -0.014169358648359776, 0.01498896349221468, -0.013088478706777096, -0.0074568078853189945, 0.07882016152143478, -0.005651493556797504, -0.07724440842866898, -0.08505122363567352, -0.06685347855091095, -0.015373327769339085, 0.06640040129423141, -0.02966926619410515, -0.05648491904139519, 0.02520265430212021, 0.05406339839100838, -0.005901404656469822, -0.03263833001255989, 0.009426766075193882, -0.02928997576236725, 0.01714208349585533, -0.04167002812027931, 0.05913849547505379, 0.007272711489349604, 0.01624077744781971, 0.010915606282651424, -0.0023724031634628773, 0.011107093654572964, 0.03965053707361221, -0.000365023355698213, -0.011160578578710556, -0.052568260580301285, -0.03838763386011124, -0.05454583466053009, -0.02575516887009144, -0.09542031586170197, -0.025561735033988953, 0.07664058357477188, -0.022541740909218788, -0.06889741867780685, -0.0070854113437235355, 0.019252054393291473, -0.010497464798390865, 0.022432034835219383, -0.005516363307833672, -0.03233781456947327, -0.018553033471107483, 0.03995838016271591, 0.0331386961042881, -0.01012613344937563, 0.007032792549580336, 0.03172491863369942, -0.02318883128464222, -0.05430750921368599, -0.008279094472527504, 0.006480081472545862, 0.026915881782770157, -0.035884790122509, -0.008065505884587765, -0.004311907570809126, 0.007506949827075005, 0.06841667741537094, 0.025799348950386047, -0.0641845315694809, 0.040159884840250015, -0.021250367164611816, 0.03848710656166077, 0.02823590114712715, 0.034659285098314285, -0.010536733083426952, 0.041477300226688385, -0.05272924527525902, -0.02016325667500496, -0.019252972677350044, -0.05037113279104233, 0.023744404315948486, 0.01359739899635315, -0.020375575870275497, 0.031117748469114304, 0.09497810155153275, -0.02655753865838051, 0.014116818085312843, 0.0005111066275276244, -0.06401869654655457, -0.04227595031261444, -0.01868860051035881, 0.021167365834116936, -0.015317771583795547, -0.04951168969273567, 0.025415394455194473, -0.047781988978385925, 0.02267354726791382, 0.0685027614235878, 0.0264727845788002, -0.02097504213452339, 0.011044553481042385, 0.031182631850242615, 0.021552657708525658, -0.03680560737848282, 0.08462770283222198, 0.015733931213617325, 0.014403177425265312, 0.040754545480012894, -0.004852632060647011, -0.02553534507751465, -0.054167140275239944, 0.0019167441641911864, 0.007549502421170473, -0.051157984882593155, 0.03267715871334076, 0.020415877923369408, 0.04391280561685562, -0.013228358700871468, 0.028740499168634415, -0.03399641066789627, 0.0335717611014843, 0.010668890550732613, 0.08416176587343216, -0.04064303636550903, 0.012661570683121681, -0.03151053562760353, 0.04179126396775246, 0.020989783108234406, -0.01291663572192192, 0.009961951524019241, 0.01951381377875805, -0.018736833706498146, 0.026219744235277176, -0.012111105024814606, -0.028362631797790527, -0.034135010093450546, 0.03559960052371025, -0.022511331364512444, -0.053109243512153625, 0.011944914236664772, -0.038667164742946625, 0.001078019617125392, -0.03460351750254631, 0.060659412294626236, -0.031377747654914856, -0.01537729986011982, 0.016040891408920288, 0.04946926608681679, 0.005207809619605541, 0.04247009754180908, 0.09005913883447647, -0.0215541310608387, 0.03948861360549927, 0.027658456936478615, 0.05117321014404297, -0.03997664153575897, -0.01852423883974552, 0.0003834780945908278, -0.031275197863578796, 0.01914697326719761, -0.011443432420492172, -0.005313885398209095, -0.04204551503062248, 0.023050805553793907, -0.0474257729947567, 0.015088140964508057, 0.015454398468136787, 0.010693905875086784, 0.06530357152223587, -0.019996732473373413, 0.01504844892770052, 0.010785098187625408, 0.03522210195660591, -0.026491034775972366, -0.09916996210813522, 0.026214445009827614, 0.011677360162138939, 0.005116937682032585, 0.024528030306100845, -0.005921599455177784, 0.01423439010977745, 0.01039647776633501, -0.0036777772475034, 0.026388388127088547, -0.013014810159802437, 0.012929916381835938, 0.0023738876916468143, 0.08456548303365707, 0.010205821134150028, -0.003130645491182804, -0.029706597328186035, 0.042924679815769196, 0.027905652299523354, -0.0456339567899704, 0.016384052112698555, -0.04322559013962746, -0.007720224559307098, 0.002295468468219042, -0.009769502095878124, 0.03194824606180191, -0.04535293206572533, 0.008795484900474548, 0.016826890408992767, -0.03344227373600006, 0.020339159294962883, -0.0034218125510960817, 0.031199729070067406, 0.003931157756596804, -0.05007703974843025, 0.005728195421397686, 0.02811414748430252, 0.010917805135250092, 0.02394198253750801, 0.04234740883111954, -0.03698766231536865, 0.019156459718942642, -0.008281446993350983, -0.06557406485080719, 0.007848720997571945, -0.0570838637650013, 0.030535785481333733, 0.051803942769765854, -0.05794112756848335, 0.026420660316944122, 0.05007055774331093, 0.02428801916539669, 0.018376806750893593, -0.07181694358587265, -0.012558238580822945, 0.013423523865640163, 0.019545285031199455, 0.04386235028505325, 0.07421128451824188, 0.05113443359732628, -0.06836116313934326, 0.008368478156626225, -0.020475897938013077, -0.043473273515701294, 0.05599045008420944, 0.06127145513892174, -0.06592922657728195, 0.055597059428691864, -0.0391673780977726, 0.017373787239193916, -0.02300117164850235, -0.06954419612884521, -0.03182139992713928, -0.02761903591454029, 0.02677047811448574, 0.05941792204976082, -0.000850329699460417, -0.03308327868580818, 0.008713915944099426, 0.01253328938037157, 0.009111828170716763, -0.022534582763910294, 0.02052442356944084, 0.014571787789463997, 0.018515868112444878, 0.020684365183115005, 0.02334306202828884, -0.0018832568312063813, 0.01210835762321949, 0.003076049266383052, -0.015522921457886696, 0.07094363123178482, -0.03860563412308693, -0.010682037100195885, 0.07102035731077194, -0.02348848432302475, -0.02505088970065117, 0.014597945846617222, 0.051956724375486374, 0.04413697496056557, -0.006466826889663935, 0.04253310337662697, 0.010011788457632065, -0.0011178216664120555, -0.0023104650899767876, -0.010720117017626762, -0.008700008504092693, -0.02340143732726574, 0.00916441809386015, -0.06271252036094666, -0.005071701481938362, 0.02021319419145584, 0.07279049605131149, 0.030289100483059883, 0.007704771123826504, -0.023677663877606392, -0.04462101310491562, -0.04361560940742493, -0.05363520234823227, -0.013016613200306892, 0.05932815000414848, -0.029817132279276848, 0.011087068356573582, 0.010951248928904533, 0.003789573209360242, -0.030524417757987976, -0.06051208823919296, -0.033718422055244446, 0.009842135943472385, -0.015758274123072624, 0.0077055967412889, 0.028731826692819595, -0.05941401794552803, 0.01516566053032875, -0.005348010454326868, 0.0381828173995018, -0.010183749720454216, 0.011782358400523663, -0.0016820562304928899, 0.017621077597141266, 0.02689884789288044, -0.01780829019844532, 0.0400431863963604, 0.07226070016622543, -0.007252316921949387, -0.06460320949554443, 0.04646744579076767, 0.03807346150279045, 0.007101429160684347, -0.02491850033402443, -0.03269615024328232, 0.058185942471027374, -0.015109450556337833, -0.00413531856611371, -0.028982598334550858, -0.03682203218340874, 0.01937546581029892, -0.004813105799257755, -0.005925748031586409, -0.03871481865644455, -0.0015543277841061354, -0.02132338099181652, 0.023881791159510612, -0.02504248172044754, -0.012621376663446426, -0.012395056895911694, 0.00033171114046126604, 0.03547549620270729 ]
<p>A treatment was given to one hand of a subject, and a single outcome metric is measured for both hands, twice pre and several times post treatment. </p> <p>What is best practice for assessing effectiveness of treatment? </p> <p>Treated and Untreated "groups" really are paired.</p>
g74028
[ -0.0011520726839080453, -0.02186746336519718, -0.00679974677041173, -0.052817150950431824, 0.01936330832540989, -0.032089024782180786, 0.010755968280136585, 0.05948873609304428, -0.019046137109398842, -0.004933780059218407, 0.033325422555208206, 0.005104979500174522, -0.02038375847041607, 0.014370796270668507, -0.011597164906561375, -0.030077621340751648, 0.07228978723287582, -0.02829810418188572, -0.04955923184752464, 0.04979481175541878, -0.04650723189115524, -0.01560049969702959, -0.028104864060878754, 0.0001157759761554189, -0.09671134501695633, -0.04774469882249832, -0.00282380566932261, 0.037014372646808624, -0.09576461464166641, -0.0418769009411335, -0.006530345417559147, 0.05734499543905258, 0.024110525846481323, -0.010080873966217041, -0.021411504596471786, -0.00474210549145937, 0.04563996568322182, -0.015489962883293629, -0.016453709453344345, -0.050203632563352585, 0.03186411038041115, 0.030433086678385735, 0.02221672609448433, -0.03899196535348892, 0.02709924802184105, 0.019681662321090698, 0.019614411517977715, 0.010461860336363316, 0.04023633152246475, 0.040244169533252716, 0.017879744991660118, 0.0099315932020545, 0.011262155137956142, 0.03807377070188522, 0.03407064452767372, 0.02658088691532612, -0.027053093537688255, 0.04006635397672653, 0.0035944473929703236, 0.009410880506038666, 0.012326420284807682, -0.02206726372241974, -0.0455806665122509, -0.009600669145584106, 0.024943457916378975, 0.031998880207538605, 0.019353877753019333, 0.007878046482801437, -0.0006783401477150619, -0.03587904945015907, -0.019690558314323425, -0.021255550906062126, 0.048082854598760605, 0.053698427975177765, -0.0458582267165184, -0.004438225645571947, -0.0421641506254673, -0.03401128575205803, -0.024924442172050476, -0.002181845949962735, 0.0075996434316039085, -0.015694785863161087, 0.0035577144008129835, -0.030156876891851425, 0.03304388001561165, 0.0044027878902852535, -0.004284129478037357, -0.07642275094985962, -0.0652247816324234, 0.08237998187541962, 0.018547220155596733, 0.038804203271865845, 0.05646364763379097, 0.037427809089422226, -0.011013955809175968, -0.017913376912474632, -0.055512070655822754, -0.014060812070965767, -0.03825223818421364, 0.012742999941110611, -0.029474427923560143, 0.061454277485609055, -0.00809370819479227, -0.025038495659828186, -0.02699216641485691, 0.05738518759608269, 0.0879032239317894, 0.08890160918235779, -0.06876564025878906, -0.055901288986206055, -0.04571530967950821, 0.057325124740600586, 0.026002347469329834, -0.043654657900333405, 0.004542614333331585, -0.013563445769250393, 0.008465426973998547, -0.007403865456581116, -0.024109816178679466, -0.023059885948896408, 0.03519957885146141, -0.00041534588672220707, 0.06333055347204208, 0.019762655720114708, -0.03042369894683361, -0.02755390666425228, -0.020578201860189438, 0.0026796795427799225, 0.04462031275033951, 0.020462483167648315, -0.028779225423932076, -0.02243046648800373, 0.0302131287753582, 0.0374334342777729, -0.06159966066479683, 0.072845458984375, 0.044439222663640976, 0.08971390873193741, -0.0392674095928669, -0.05074195936322212, -0.032390180975198746, -0.02543019875884056, -0.0072412253357470036, 0.020952407270669937, 0.043196141719818115, -0.006216173991560936, 0.01420994196087122, -0.018112391233444214, -0.04027597978711128, 0.009064405225217342, 0.00662372587248683, 0.00680836895480752, 0.04622802510857582, 0.031349726021289825, -0.024186475202441216, 0.018891144543886185, -0.014626558870077133, 0.045295342803001404, -0.0038585509173572063, 0.05724739283323288, 0.04339302331209183, -0.020637398585677147, 0.0568702332675457, 0.001223779167048633, 0.009815066121518612, 0.025920763611793518, 0.01408312562853098, -0.05119095370173454, 0.02481064386665821, 0.012343361042439938, -0.009518803097307682, -0.06290453672409058, -0.006777849979698658, 0.02312813699245453, 0.08397693186998367, 0.047099530696868896, 0.03571711853146553, -0.004552172962576151, -0.020543133839964867, 0.04116617515683174, 0.00462873512879014, 0.02506273239850998, 0.012219984084367752, 0.011634749360382557, -0.028994260355830193, -0.025394553318619728, 0.019457077607512474, 0.015376671217381954, -0.06729891896247864, -0.019302653148770332, 0.009883585385978222, -0.00441960571333766, 0.01751597970724106, 0.0319838784635067, -0.05204332247376442, 0.018884912133216858, 0.05612661689519882, -0.007939870469272137, -0.057586781680583954, -0.008283828385174274, 0.00572403147816658, 0.02838318794965744, -0.06806407123804092, 0.06117938086390495, -0.07813437283039093, 0.03140652924776077, 0.010076657868921757, 0.008626263588666916, 0.004989904817193747, -0.048398856073617935, -0.034165602177381516, 0.02738407999277115, 0.040137071162462234, 0.0158685352653265, -0.025475990027189255, -0.01021954882889986, -0.03069283626973629, -0.023842724040150642, -0.04004889726638794, 0.006235345732420683, -0.0179886594414711, 0.018611010164022446, 0.034736890345811844, 0.0042076860554516315, 0.014494450762867928, 0.055551882833242416, -0.008565938100218773, 0.02002994529902935, -0.06739842146635056, -0.0020709047093987465, -0.04991970956325531, -0.008365367539227009, -0.047456059604883194, -0.11901415139436722, -0.014515158720314503, -0.02434014342725277, 0.00003983556234743446, -0.0005507029709406197, 0.017583731561899185, 0.06468936800956726, 0.01845771074295044, -0.024707535281777382, -0.003393090795725584, -0.02713465504348278, 0.006319783627986908, 0.03630621358752251, -0.009165964089334011, 0.02064286172389984, 0.0030554181430488825, 0.0602385476231575, -0.05784636363387108, 0.07061377167701721, -0.02313152886927128, -0.07358953356742859, 0.020173344761133194, 0.036224596202373505, 0.01712760142982006, -0.016841012984514236, -0.07207763195037842, 0.07500884681940079, -0.018131040036678314, 0.005771887023001909, 0.011312230490148067, 0.028649890795350075, -0.012634835205972195, -0.08865812420845032, 0.038944654166698456, -0.012833216227591038, -0.00176966970320791, -0.00895700417459011, -0.006258917041122913, 0.017516354098916054, -0.02952113375067711, 0.05507070571184158, 0.027224252000451088, -0.037982821464538574, 0.015123154036700726, -0.0037659956142306328, 0.036387547850608826, -0.03685835003852844, 0.09121812134981155, -0.012780928052961826, 0.019742872565984726, 0.031076164916157722, 0.034749433398246765, 0.0005757524631917477, 0.05764172226190567, -0.02615039050579071, -0.028114622458815575, 0.0678177997469902, -0.019481780007481575, 0.03509879112243652, 0.044913116842508316, -0.05050932243466377, -0.03410312160849571, 0.014802227728068829, 0.022540565580129623, -0.077511265873909, 0.02401755005121231, -0.013207177631556988, -0.00949263945221901, -0.0341787151992321, -0.04505203291773796, -0.03477555140852928, 0.022185267880558968, -0.029020562767982483, -0.0222175195813179, -0.006430140230804682, 0.0024495876859873533, -0.006826151628047228, 0.002864985028281808, 0.06835770606994629, -0.006845327094197273, -0.05841180309653282, -0.031403761357069016, -0.03957494720816612, 0.021531077101826668, -0.03640693426132202, -0.0545320026576519, 0.006494797766208649, 0.05663827806711197, 0.003649701364338398, 0.03452567383646965, -0.000792669306974858, 0.006471231114119291, 0.010714869946241379, -0.038706593215465546, 0.031212754547595978, -0.05415346100926399, 0.07227848470211029, 0.011274264194071293, 0.04109281301498413, 0.024440089240670204, -0.05066898092627525, 0.023873578757047653, -0.039033908396959305, -0.0677848532795906, 0.004750815685838461, 0.016044583171606064, 0.03252797573804855, -0.05236656591296196, -0.04315759614109993, -0.003944043535739183, 0.000552358222194016, 0.047609757632017136, 0.020595232024788857, 0.020204683765769005, 0.04647791385650635, -0.012440986931324005, -0.0435151644051075, 0.004464380908757448, -0.012177994474768639, -0.003464441979303956, 0.01595011167228222, 0.00029321579495444894, 0.01653093472123146, 0.02248612977564335, 0.014332327991724014, -0.06189612299203873, -0.04930645227432251, 0.010040323249995708, 0.06060614064335823, -0.08035912364721298, -0.03384886309504509, 0.01651163585484028, -0.017755402252078056, 0.07560437172651291, 0.0856420248746872, -0.04299621284008026, -0.018249064683914185, 0.01354107167571783, -0.011728004552423954, 0.036091264337301254, -0.017109232023358345, -0.04544060304760933, 0.008838295005261898, 0.008435821160674095, -0.018120963126420975, 0.01756635122001171, 0.05331185460090637, -0.0035306739155203104, -0.04238363355398178, -0.003482978092506528, 0.026563024148344994, -0.03605271875858307, -0.031124137341976166, -0.005280695389956236, 0.006854560226202011, 0.029567018151283264, -0.007963110692799091, -0.039051737636327744, -0.04778660461306572, -0.050093989819288254, 0.0501311719417572, 0.045775774866342545, -0.027269795536994934, 0.02696443721652031, -0.028953202068805695, 0.032776761800050735, 0.030055511742830276, -0.025629961863160133, -0.005474438890814781, 0.017484625801444054, 0.03171088173985481, -0.05888810381293297, -0.0012487758649513125, -0.023585282266139984, 0.028140416368842125, -0.026707947254180908, 0.0638238787651062, -0.027469776570796967, 0.02439618483185768, 0.025847839191555977, -0.06736377626657486, 0.04610467702150345, 0.011179205030202866, 0.03890862315893173, -0.032746635377407074, -0.012549744918942451, 0.001150819705799222, 0.00935117807239294, 0.04014461860060692, 0.023108944296836853, -0.04668052867054939, -0.015550706535577774, 0.09077361971139908, -0.013089346699416637, -0.013800745829939842, 0.032446011900901794, 0.0047399140894412994, 0.0922907367348671, -0.0029513565823435783, -0.04989255219697952, 0.012091457843780518, 0.021384404972195625, 0.010314191691577435, -0.017848869785666466, 0.05087887495756149, 0.004074884578585625, 0.013275375589728355, 0.017977207899093628, -0.022903315722942352, -0.05921117216348648, 0.029823794960975647, 0.011866450309753418, -0.01131014246493578, 0.03651098906993866, -0.022045567631721497, -0.01660767011344433, -0.03387806937098503, -0.05453957989811897, 0.034352220594882965, 0.021450316533446312, -0.06485550105571747, -0.06712490320205688, 0.0009707574499770999, 0.0303131565451622, 0.03867708519101143, 0.017908066511154175, 0.013302234932780266, -0.009471936151385307, -0.045244377106428146, -0.03655369579792023, -0.051306094974279404, -0.01884230226278305, 0.00000470506347483024, -0.0214086901396513, 0.02557472139596939, -0.000939985504373908, 0.021916218101978302, 0.004698712844401598, 0.016474107280373573, 0.013291526585817337, -0.09357813745737076, -0.008521772921085358, 0.011542844586074352, 0.015519283711910248, 0.012000723741948605, 0.03472733125090599, 0.028328482061624527, 0.023785699158906937, -0.01564195565879345, 0.015626339241862297, -0.030000710859894753, -0.0163247212767601, -0.007371004670858383, 0.017349526286125183, -0.05284074321389198, 0.06016641482710838, 0.004854382481426001, -0.02346506528556347, 0.02435988560318947, 0.057406678795814514, 0.010325567796826363, 0.0076813362538814545, 0.015797266736626625, -0.016048308461904526, 0.0630822405219078, 0.053081661462783813, -0.06891359388828278, -0.015847597271203995, 0.08635111898183823, 0.019463002681732178, -0.0008063311106525362, -0.002678964287042618, 0.022659018635749817, -0.00005491343472385779, -0.0769137591123581, 0.026218552142381668, 0.04445992410182953, 0.03028387390077114, -0.0336134098470211, 0.01616096682846546, 0.026465196162462234, -0.0031945290975272655, 0.028062721714377403, -0.007932533510029316, -0.004081763327121735, 0.005339662078768015, -0.06142452359199524, 0.05781753733754158, -0.0017954278737306595, -0.026502421125769615, 0.02831209823489189, 0.002736123977228999, -0.03800325468182564, -0.05227706581354141, 0.03017422743141651, -0.018301695585250854, 0.012335289269685745, 0.08896199613809586, 0.005882650148123503, -0.027416005730628967, 0.040699005126953125, 0.03585885465145111, -0.04557132348418236, 0.0013275782112032175, -0.019681230187416077, -0.003704348811879754, -0.013493090867996216, -0.07083700597286224, 0.02647503837943077, 0.007863935083150864, -0.009885121136903763, -0.025288408622145653, 0.008976654149591923, -0.013646019622683525, 0.028174659237265587, 0.014067978598177433, 0.013411318883299828, -0.0016395242419093847, -0.056045759469270706, -0.03656335920095444, -0.018508052453398705, 0.011884072795510292, 0.0006404121522791684, -0.027527116239070892, 0.00035515156923793256, 0.059846989810466766, -0.007521555759012699, 0.01497739553451538, -0.010666166432201862, -0.0014643585309386253, 0.04479757696390152, 0.028700729832053185, -0.10827465355396271, -0.016316823661327362, -0.04703425616025925, -0.022084688767790794, -0.016954395920038223, -0.03523790463805199, -0.012521885335445404, 0.04415002837777138, 0.013586513698101044, 0.021852271631360054, 0.06678588688373566, -0.051566820591688156, -0.0033635972067713737, -0.024573102593421936, 0.0036603491753339767, -0.05259652063250542, 0.027021031826734543, 0.0017261074390262365, 0.06490447372198105, 0.0017758499598130584, 0.024515632539987564, -0.045368585735559464, 0.0006549867684952915, 0.021803781390190125, 0.005515370052307844, 0.03297491371631622, -0.0123455710709095, 0.019997108727693558, 0.023382950574159622, 0.00968017615377903, -0.007682508789002895, 0.027176745235919952, 0.05231970176100731, -0.03695979714393616, -0.01760447584092617, -0.034766845405101776, -0.01907648704946041, 0.016224011778831482, -0.029170094057917595, 0.004570371471345425, 0.036764711141586304, 0.01581749878823757, -0.06586357951164246, 0.0315595306456089, -0.05596558004617691, -0.04047384485602379, -0.03178964927792549, 0.008297357708215714, 0.035586096346378326, 0.010142366401851177, -0.012636528350412846, 0.0020712953992187977, 0.004105085041373968, -0.022552024573087692, -0.030357610434293747, 0.0013060221681371331, -0.04706203565001488, 0.012342838570475578, 0.0031240093521773815, -0.021801374852657318, -0.018637793138623238, 0.0034269082825630903, -0.018663354218006134, -0.0021462426520884037, 0.05939715355634689, 0.04200900346040726, 0.040282029658555984, -0.012392815202474594, -0.025506092235445976, -0.08920225501060486, -0.00753270136192441, -0.05663831904530525, 0.057959944009780884, -0.0016804045299068093, 0.020376721397042274, -0.019348984584212303, 0.04632796347141266, -0.026129115372896194, 0.01731264963746071, -0.02965186908841133, -0.007139143534004688, 0.041113242506980896, 0.07796037197113037, -0.02660646289587021, 0.004700881894677877, -0.01174125261604786, -0.01920703798532486, 0.00024338430375792086, -0.015323267318308353, -0.04718468710780144, 0.04637075215578079, 0.031109975650906563, 0.016862405464053154, 0.0050102765671908855, 0.04886622354388237, -0.005726398900151253, -0.08589332550764084, -0.02268456481397152, 0.023772576823830605, -0.009997548535466194, -0.024756966158747673, 0.05146092548966408, 0.01820242591202259, -0.02201511524617672, -0.024594776332378387, 0.007511693984270096, 0.024180160835385323, 0.03143712505698204, 0.016413291916251183, 0.03947581723332405, -0.023089485242962837, 0.05307764932513237, 0.0011004990665242076, -0.06465519219636917, -0.015215922147035599, -0.023436829447746277, -0.04200145602226257, 0.07201738655567169, -0.004097871948033571, -0.004976269789040089, -0.013311749324202538, 0.002235192572697997, -0.019577855244278908, 0.020371926948428154, -0.025027187541127205, -0.032148268073797226, 0.008691972121596336, -0.027243763208389282, 0.003980190027505159, -0.023440159857273102, 0.032691590487957, 0.009713701903820038, 0.07130083441734314, -0.018538428470492363, 0.03844517096877098, -0.006403601262718439, 0.017023716121912003, 0.019238080829381943, 0.057937245815992355, 0.006296810694038868, 0.057828139513731, -0.022931931540369987, -0.004056612029671669, 0.038159843534231186, -0.04233044013381004, -0.07903722673654556, -0.041976187378168106, -0.030843261629343033, -0.021009860560297966, -0.04421097785234451, -0.03450590744614601, -0.06717663258314133, -0.051814932376146317, 0.07039884477853775, -0.01736443303525448, -0.013771096244454384, 0.0525994636118412, 0.028699463233351707, -0.0172109492123127, -0.03458145260810852, -0.0023891387972980738, -0.03669470548629761, 0.04721067473292351, 0.010213381610810757, 0.04220512881875038, -0.035931892693042755, -0.11583594232797623, -0.047554273158311844, 0.03544941172003746, 0.04153267666697502, 0.026803141459822655, 0.03786100819706917, 0.019068608060479164, -0.005617266986519098, 0.0851491391658783, 0.016511540859937668, -0.003952493891119957, -0.026686107739806175, 0.03643901273608208, -0.0019410836976021528, 0.027792558073997498, 0.008869444020092487, 0.0036500240676105022, 0.019332444295287132, -0.05365252122282982, -0.08587906509637833, 0.03842749446630478, -0.028459329158067703, 0.05415256693959236, 0.001400024862959981, -0.032490190118551254, 0.000695845577865839, -0.06381698697805405, 0.01798420585691929, 0.0164457019418478, -0.014424973167479038, -0.013255973346531391, -0.06690680235624313, -0.03157472610473633, -0.03637722134590149, -0.005915205460041761, 0.0017009004950523376, -0.028784526512026787 ]
<p>I have to design an experiment where tool wear is a factor (not a response). I'm not trying to study tool wear minimizing. I'm trying to study the effect of tool wear along with 3 other factors on the number of a certain defect type.</p> <p>What kind of design should I use? I considered dividing the tool wear into 3 conditions (low, med, high) and then running each treatment within the conditions. But I'm not sure that is a correct method. Tool wear is considered to be a highly significant contributor to the defect rate. Interactions are also important here.</p> <p>This is a forging operation. The other factors are billet temp, spotting location and pancake height. I have plenty of replication opportunities and plan at least 10 parts for each treatment.</p> <p>Many Thanks - Kelly</p>
g36653
[ 0.06385497003793716, -0.013594681397080421, -0.0029474087059497833, -0.02757423371076584, 0.0023116327356547117, -0.012565282173454762, 0.061851631850004196, 0.007168852724134922, -0.036121614277362823, -0.04536834731698036, 0.03683563694357872, 0.014273716136813164, 0.07479645311832428, 0.017557362094521523, -0.011245097033679485, -0.008539975620806217, 0.020162491127848625, -0.0025940919294953346, -0.0015857040416449308, 0.048468414694070816, 0.02053005062043667, 0.01318906620144844, -0.03043949045240879, 0.0014819884672760963, -0.03341955319046974, -0.04696651175618172, -0.0134358499199152, 0.05912407115101814, -0.07649995386600494, -0.029378125444054604, -0.011096018366515636, 0.010755160823464394, 0.036448657512664795, -0.014747214503586292, -0.02766764909029007, -0.001231621252372861, -0.005824684165418148, 0.06171828880906105, -0.0374113954603672, -0.0033292465377599, -0.021365370601415634, -0.013298733159899712, 0.04926665127277374, 0.020545128732919693, -0.03214891999959946, -0.015389440581202507, -0.0023847741540521383, -0.023471742868423462, 0.04130019247531891, -0.011484972201287746, -0.003233975498005748, -0.055380839854478836, 0.025103168562054634, -0.047815952450037, 0.015024355612695217, -0.018838709220290184, -0.036010656505823135, -0.02484527975320816, 0.008995985612273216, -0.04619256779551506, -0.00069261813769117, -0.0242155808955431, -0.05018332600593567, 0.06128189340233803, -0.042580921202898026, 0.010202026925981045, 0.0065475222654640675, 0.004385943524539471, 0.04219018295407295, -0.05449140816926956, -0.012826940976083279, -0.01417519897222519, 0.022308439016342163, -0.033830832690000534, 0.01656460389494896, 0.019320596009492874, -0.0012357603991404176, 0.001603078912012279, -0.04305322840809822, 0.03915273770689964, -0.015458793379366398, -0.02057654596865177, -0.015151833184063435, 0.0394858717918396, 0.02847631648182869, 0.021639322862029076, -0.016955608502030373, -0.027779845520853996, 0.00807240791618824, -0.022586679086089134, -0.005154799669981003, 0.047548435628414154, 0.07970433682203293, 0.05107913166284561, -0.04759320989251137, 0.05744374170899391, -0.028720540925860405, 0.06289862841367722, -0.007237826939672232, 0.04917248338460922, 0.03693186864256859, -0.04813813790678978, -0.06691515445709229, -0.013606667518615723, -0.008836807683110237, -0.009098163805902004, 0.04415549337863922, 0.0606410950422287, -0.030301721766591072, 0.020579934120178223, -0.0229619313031435, -0.046719711273908615, -0.06527715176343918, -0.029942957684397697, -0.015682194381952286, -0.012400045059621334, 0.01140871923416853, 0.022649647668004036, -0.005861599929630756, -0.03714720904827118, 0.058515436947345734, -0.031006962060928345, -0.01111831609159708, 0.014467079192399979, -0.02736244909465313, -0.018826132640242577, -0.028546243906021118, 0.012663459405303001, 0.024995572865009308, -0.0192709993571043, 0.030289851129055023, -0.009442017413675785, 0.00188932113815099, 0.04264995828270912, -0.0015044318279251456, 0.04631936922669411, -0.00391045119613409, 0.09175999462604523, -0.05619410425424576, -0.03455264866352081, -0.05599163472652435, 0.0015732028987258673, 0.004550468642264605, -0.001498777070082724, 0.0008923572022467852, 0.047834672033786774, -0.06747947633266449, 0.010876634158194065, 0.022398874163627625, 0.024648014456033707, 0.047742173075675964, -0.009967283345758915, -0.003794203046709299, -0.03492322191596031, 0.029609719291329384, 0.012596248649060726, -0.036934684962034225, -0.016546620056033134, 0.020624633878469467, 0.08643901348114014, -0.06759138405323029, -0.04752957075834274, -0.016423439607024193, 0.042676571756601334, -0.015427018515765667, 0.04636535421013832, -0.016388939693570137, -0.00762110436335206, 0.019374476745724678, -0.051172491163015366, 0.032574623823165894, -0.05547211319208145, 0.033824361860752106, -0.04923519119620323, 0.06297022849321365, 0.0267645251005888, 0.06387912482023239, 0.02059069462120533, -0.02209571748971939, -0.005913487169891596, 0.032900121062994, -0.001577478600665927, 0.016005143523216248, -0.08459129929542542, 0.011011912487447262, 0.012100134044885635, 0.031418576836586, -0.05093441158533096, -0.03216936066746712, -0.0032380244228988886, 0.03111843205988407, -0.0567907840013504, 0.007483147084712982, -0.04717281088232994, -0.0651627779006958, -0.038759566843509674, 0.008085152134299278, -0.015472098253667355, -0.00009713776671560481, -0.032766979187726974, -0.034499239176511765, 0.03435318171977997, -0.02761574648320675, 0.03644484654068947, -0.01853993535041809, -0.032258518040180206, -0.0152588477358222, 0.030352303758263588, -0.0036182808689773083, -0.02846709080040455, 0.004119662567973137, 0.007493383716791868, -0.016975097358226776, 0.07345261424779892, 0.0029071795288473368, 0.030505718663334846, 0.00921719428151846, 0.06107151508331299, -0.016482846811413765, 0.04113432392477989, 0.022261256352066994, 0.0005541963037103415, -0.020240530371665955, -0.009697448462247849, -0.01605973206460476, 0.04410723224282265, 0.018542088568210602, 0.03103030100464821, 0.008188051171600819, -0.04998849332332611, -0.0028532277792692184, -0.011922533623874187, 0.011304096318781376, -0.1134272888302803, 0.01588863506913185, 0.0022103465162217617, 0.02686680667102337, 0.005116207525134087, 0.021845322102308273, 0.05597712844610214, 0.027714982628822327, 0.07898180931806564, -0.060532715171575546, -0.05834418907761574, 0.06747499108314514, -0.03909697383642197, -0.0612151175737381, 0.04657166078686714, -0.006006109528243542, 0.048643048852682114, -0.030632244423031807, -0.00010710389324231073, 0.01913728378713131, -0.0716833844780922, -0.013436523266136646, 0.008939589373767376, -0.012482918798923492, 0.0660547986626625, 0.012104627676308155, 0.004813550505787134, -0.05443277582526207, 0.013434367254376411, 0.06290087103843689, 0.033601388335227966, -0.03345390036702156, -0.019002793356776237, -0.04206676036119461, -0.08269187062978745, -0.031113244593143463, 0.023418452590703964, -0.07763613015413284, -0.060880884528160095, 0.023574424907565117, 0.03173982724547386, 0.0054839905351400375, -0.03666426241397858, 0.041213538497686386, 0.005476875696331263, 0.00379313831217587, -0.0336821973323822, 0.06470584124326706, -0.03229459375143051, -0.025876881554722786, 0.023256642743945122, 0.052532196044921875, 0.042676810175180435, 0.03769993782043457, -0.050616554915905, -0.02174411527812481, 0.024171894416213036, -0.01758684404194355, -0.010913862846791744, 0.02577369287610054, -0.018523603677749634, 0.0021290178410708904, 0.020885424688458443, 0.008273652754724026, -0.06162656843662262, 0.06793544441461563, 0.03769269958138466, -0.052880339324474335, 0.04116145521402359, -0.0426764041185379, -0.014418688602745533, 0.009395563043653965, -0.000022143805836094543, 0.01189733762294054, -0.0497913658618927, 0.002494168234989047, 0.005631785839796066, -0.00524146668612957, -0.027609720826148987, -0.013167754746973515, -0.027709143236279488, -0.08836245536804199, 0.002729455940425396, -0.03562826290726662, -0.0022052309941500425, 0.04489380866289139, -0.0494176484644413, -0.015650611370801926, -0.02062050625681877, 0.021815210580825806, -0.01753922738134861, -0.02892531268298626, 0.06476719677448273, 0.02125733159482479, -0.0373169407248497, -0.004410662688314915, 0.048951294273138046, 0.014214331284165382, 0.08697526156902313, -0.0695662796497345, -0.06672002375125885, 0.054018374532461166, -0.030625680461525917, 0.03975554183125496, 0.00032012563315220177, 0.00609984714537859, 0.01583573780953884, 0.0182837825268507, -0.004813871346414089, -0.037203866988420486, -0.014372078701853752, 0.016933836042881012, -0.0701010599732399, -0.01195729710161686, 0.08906695246696472, 0.03373413905501366, 0.01388179324567318, 0.06903805583715439, -0.027212373912334442, -0.06644398719072342, 0.0005389672005549073, 0.024913787841796875, -0.004983066115528345, 0.050644055008888245, 0.005172579549252987, -0.055316902697086334, -0.032352615147829056, -0.0028495804872363806, 0.010355140082538128, -0.04457520693540573, -0.011790700256824493, -0.008162269368767738, 0.044610753655433655, 0.058619000017642975, 0.05868563801050186, 0.036733176559209824, -0.0041390215046703815, 0.01373283751308918, -0.04574616253376007, -0.0011225369526073337, -0.00006896082777529955, -0.000697946990840137, 0.03363092243671417, 0.02477087639272213, 0.06685582548379898, 0.010848353616893291, 0.06538143754005432, -0.02497556060552597, 0.005190791096538305, -0.015406078658998013, -0.036850228905677795, -0.02873711846768856, -0.019280286505818367, 0.04180452227592468, 0.02213132753968239, 0.006088751833885908, 0.030809467658400536, -0.04525395855307579, 0.012955674901604652, -0.06517662107944489, 0.030905792489647865, 0.01999141275882721, -0.009259573183953762, 0.03955633193254471, -0.01569637656211853, 0.0018713780445978045, -0.038975734263658524, 0.035809993743896484, 0.01354148332029581, 0.043142132461071014, 0.0889413133263588, 0.024999847635626793, -0.01885092630982399, -0.010062208399176598, 0.02235386148095131, -0.018022308126091957, 0.03556153178215027, -0.05823199450969696, -0.04111563041806221, -0.003399311564862728, -0.022110791876912117, 0.04478280991315842, -0.06935557723045349, 0.02992517501115799, 0.06574036926031113, -0.03347880765795708, 0.018484625965356827, -0.028354350477457047, 0.05185852572321892, -0.03222683444619179, -0.034579284489154816, 0.0234689898788929, -0.01794383116066456, -0.05060891434550285, -0.06323810666799545, 0.01344961766153574, -0.013349481858313084, 0.04382816329598427, 0.002702656202018261, -0.05174094811081886, -0.015332159586250782, 0.042385343462228775, 0.0064492421224713326, -0.016157016158103943, -0.008667771704494953, 0.033565059304237366, 0.025906212627887726, -0.058870021253824234, 0.013476117514073849, -0.03251016512513161, 0.02966531738638878, -0.008903009817004204, 0.0874980017542839, -0.053637322038412094, -0.023189129307866096, -0.05187126621603966, 0.005374336615204811, 0.020539909601211548, -0.019784821197390556, -0.025192201137542725, -0.03374483063817024, 0.007690412923693657, -0.02007022127509117, 0.035281162708997726, -0.01995157264173031, 0.015804177150130272, 0.04231622815132141, -0.03804996609687805, -0.018440043553709984, 0.02040054090321064, 0.007966802455484867, -0.026795459911227226, 0.04404928907752037, 0.00998794473707676, -0.009830804541707039, -0.06047971546649933, 0.02230139449238777, -0.06024152413010597, -0.021082106977701187, 0.041547056287527084, 0.019757939502596855, -0.03062143176794052, 0.028897451236844063, -0.022614607587456703, -0.013882393948733807, 0.0047733839601278305, 0.021137487143278122, 0.014643856324255466, -0.01980917900800705, 0.045431118458509445, -0.018893776461482048, -0.041873738169670105, -0.09341968595981598, -0.05506778135895729, -0.039568811655044556, 0.01966337114572525, -0.012508201412856579, 0.049371931701898575, 0.02275756001472473, 0.07139957696199417, 0.03243149816989899, -0.02060062065720558, -0.02372569590806961, 0.0653073713183403, 0.039319220930337906, 0.05604486167430878, -0.07910545915365219, -0.010520911775529385, -0.003698179265484214, -0.02766483835875988, -0.03962332755327225, -0.026270730420947075, 0.00602294597774744, 0.049789123237133026, -0.07512423396110535, 0.040852710604667664, 0.03464573621749878, -0.013992922380566597, 0.0316888689994812, 0.007702329661697149, -0.03600282967090607, -0.01576794683933258, 0.04745537042617798, 0.026218606159090996, 0.01959589496254921, -0.0224899984896183, -0.021631790325045586, 0.03183601424098015, 0.0034028999507427216, -0.006670595146715641, 0.009647932834923267, 0.01831256039440632, -0.051640670746564865, -0.021486803889274597, -0.019550204277038574, 0.02675606682896614, -0.04265865683555603, 0.027391787618398666, 0.09780231863260269, -0.009251328185200691, 0.03601664677262306, -0.04030648618936539, 0.019624721258878708, 0.07564426213502884, 0.0013667370658367872, -0.018338115885853767, -0.03076687641441822, -0.0018886838806793094, 0.03597090393304825, 0.08200790733098984, -0.04647167772054672, -0.0029699886217713356, -0.015549708157777786, 0.02219807170331478, 0.052299611270427704, 0.03992829471826553, -0.0062095290049910545, -0.019833825528621674, 0.04124465212225914, 0.008657315745949745, 0.018451718613505363, 0.017948804423213005, 0.0029071373865008354, -0.0008386098779737949, -0.012568819336593151, 0.03742527216672897, -0.062285520136356354, 0.0030844914726912975, -0.006869602482765913, 0.0003426900948397815, 0.005943929310888052, 0.053978219628334045, -0.023249788209795952, -0.07169396430253983, -0.010015379637479782, 0.030532894656062126, 0.04384799674153328, 0.03471142426133156, -0.060943882912397385, -0.007733612786978483, 0.027588771656155586, 0.02109242044389248, 0.04111117497086525, -0.030428865924477577, -0.030026258900761604, -0.019119787961244583, -0.0025490024127066135, 0.005643960554152727, 0.027905302122235298, -0.039651058614254, 0.04322795569896698, -0.017634635791182518, 0.062192149460315704, -0.008966317400336266, 0.004597016144543886, 0.007452761754393578, -0.0040799351409077644, 0.017395248636603355, 0.03420032188296318, 0.0018381566042080522, 0.03767412155866623, 0.06288740783929825, -0.021550962701439857, 0.01055519562214613, 0.0007617191295139492, -0.0012303838739171624, -0.014427736401557922, -0.02928578294813633, 0.0009973662672564387, 0.023174123838543892, -0.02443550154566765, 0.02847292646765709, 0.05663125962018967, 0.006913359742611647, -0.00707844877615571, 0.04596675559878349, 0.014490126632153988, -0.07418956607580185, 0.028593221679329872, 0.048218414187431335, 0.02470323257148266, -0.0006051277159713209, 0.0019603462424129248, -0.011204473674297333, -0.028532283380627632, 0.013679459691047668, -0.014399033971130848, 0.04838879033923149, 0.015153946354985237, -0.02688453160226345, -0.016678806394338608, -0.030422711744904518, 0.04338189959526062, -0.0075616780668497086, -0.03288145363330841, 0.04513521492481232, -0.009187267161905766, -0.009354019537568092, 0.02256464585661888, -0.09696413576602936, -0.018573248758912086, -0.039146725088357925, 0.02728814259171486, -0.0008858525543473661, 0.06573522835969925, 0.003913274500519037, 0.03999331220984459, -0.00313979247584939, 0.020738769322633743, -0.018499987199902534, 0.035078711807727814, 0.013060546480119228, -0.004313656594604254, -0.012732100673019886, 0.03560929000377655, 0.00493308762088418, 0.0027510281652212143, 0.017757989466190338, -0.006151868496090174, -0.04386616498231888, -0.044299110770225525, 0.056169502437114716, 0.026419751346111298, 0.005404338240623474, 0.03751782327890396, 0.028742486611008644, 0.00526381004601717, -0.05685778334736824, -0.0416225865483284, -0.024344781413674355, -0.05645870789885521, 0.017177416011691093, 0.010953606106340885, 0.002416776493191719, -0.003049107501283288, -0.0332634411752224, -0.02460481971502304, -0.03505580127239227, 0.016127752140164375, -0.026123521849513054, 0.04778045043349266, -0.02199220471084118, 0.004124775528907776, 0.005925904493778944, 0.04003399237990379, -0.056836552917957306, 0.006776256952434778, -0.04089835658669472, -0.038188058882951736, 0.05435824394226074, -0.06517866998910904, 0.012094040401279926, 0.007874254137277603, -0.028561735525727272, -0.03470495715737343, -0.006313891150057316, -0.0022855906281620264, 0.02489030919969082, -0.011209751479327679, -0.009522960521280766, 0.0007505010580644011, -0.01996789686381817, 0.021720437332987785, 0.04144647717475891, -0.03910445421934128, -0.0223982073366642, 0.06756392866373062, 0.013594593852758408, -0.0006158530595712364, 0.02900545671582222, 0.015194060280919075, 0.011449018493294716, 0.023026498034596443, -0.03922980651259422, -0.001619409304112196, -0.025277355685830116, -0.03025474026799202, 0.009332490153610706, 0.012287531979382038, -0.00034015433629974723, -0.022296834737062454, -0.043798040598630905, -0.017435222864151, -0.0021741532254964113, -0.08862938731908798, -0.009569717571139336, -0.029284555464982986, -0.064754918217659, 0.08652431517839432, 0.026730867102742195, 0.023430773988366127, -0.02070654183626175, -0.059712473303079605, -0.02226072922348976, 0.006992883514612913, -0.0399959534406662, 0.03976678475737572, 0.02134758047759533, -0.07926751673221588, -0.07292409241199493, 0.0930977463722229, 0.045897725969552994, 0.018411576747894287, 0.04386494308710098, 0.0030546332709491253, -0.07085073739290237, 0.051675666123628616, 0.028472570702433586, 0.018005728721618652, -0.04176446422934532, -0.04509000480175018, 0.022887306287884712, 0.00613451050594449, -0.006785375066101551, 0.03152972087264061, -0.019232405349612236, 0.0014153973897919059, -0.051767390221357346, 0.027314428240060806, -0.026157015934586525, -0.012293840758502483, -0.01490363385528326, -0.024910632520914078, 0.034859370440244675, -0.011871852912008762, 0.030497847124934196, -0.03029598668217659, 0.005567934829741716, 0.015707487240433693, -0.12294229865074158, 0.03730569779872894, 0.04056645929813385, -0.0060157193802297115, 0.05481572449207306, -0.030369510874152184 ]
<p>What is a good loss function for a predictive model used by gamblers?</p> <p>I've been reading a bit about loss functions recently. I've always just went with MSE (e.g., for a couple of neural network projects) and didn't ask questions. I didn't realize exactly how arbitrary MSE actually is. And speaking of this, could somebody explain a simple practical situation where MSE can be derived as the "correct" loss function?</p> <p>Anyway, I came across Log-Loss (which is the same as cross entropy) and am interested because I'm curious about some probabilistic models. I understand how one derives this loss function from information theory, but when we talk about probabilities, we're often involved in some form of gambling on an outcome. It's not clear to me that efficient transmission of information translates to the type of utility one is usually looking for in a predictive/probabilistic model.</p> <p>If, for example, I had a model that was meant to predict the winner of the 2012 US presidential election, and I had used this to move money around on a future's market like Intrade, how might I determine a loss function for my prediction - assuming I'm able to continue making bets as the market fluctuates? Same type of thing should apply for any market where I am able to make handicapped bets on the occurrence of some event.</p> <p>Or is this really regret, and is regret completely different than a loss function?</p>
g36654
[ -0.043832190334796906, -0.03350778669118881, 0.018034307286143303, 0.0021987208165228367, -0.020789166912436485, -0.03755108267068863, 0.04938926920294762, -0.011825855821371078, -0.04155166819691658, -0.03428507223725319, -0.021463466808199883, 0.02309773676097393, 0.1267697662115097, -0.005390475504100323, -0.004922714550048113, 0.01624429225921631, 0.024625139310956, 0.038378141820430756, 0.023831186816096306, 0.016324777156114578, 0.03982321545481682, 0.008301939815282822, 0.0315898135304451, 0.018368542194366455, -0.05139434337615967, -0.03773205354809761, -0.03985340893268585, 0.026974506676197052, 0.00169157306663692, 0.02723821811378002, -0.027209755033254623, 0.001192958909086883, 0.027344947680830956, -0.08250290155410767, -0.1212431937456131, 0.03899636119604111, 0.01619444042444229, -0.05320247262716293, 0.007971875369548798, 0.050041671842336655, -0.03251582756638527, 0.04247546195983887, -0.018646666780114174, 0.02151123620569706, 0.05574822053313255, 0.04341188073158264, 0.002110412809997797, -0.01373887900263071, 0.0026558274403214455, 0.012668823823332787, 0.017873987555503845, 0.017976630479097366, 0.07447192072868347, -0.0007256433600559831, 0.02930569276213646, 0.018407288938760757, 0.024653930217027664, 0.022803375497460365, 0.025765612721443176, 0.0126283448189497, 0.07057414948940277, 0.008581574074923992, -0.01607736200094223, -0.029255956411361694, 0.051774874329566956, -0.003996189218014479, -0.019707240164279938, 0.04051696136593819, 0.022394618019461632, 0.06973384320735931, 0.030028145760297775, 0.07852403074502945, 0.06153140589594841, 0.0021641927305608988, 0.04179259389638901, -0.010350537486374378, 0.024753225967288017, -0.010089226998388767, 0.024417536333203316, 0.008122075349092484, -0.0176954697817564, -0.0068458858877420425, 0.02101118490099907, 0.02403096854686737, -0.0018983177142217755, 0.0036951093934476376, -0.021987345069646835, -0.02854135073721409, 0.0005149439093656838, 0.020848000422120094, -0.017661932855844498, -0.0016486621461808681, 0.04326856881380081, 0.02840743586421013, -0.04527566581964493, 0.028429018333554268, -0.13214458525180817, 0.023201236501336098, 0.028957951813936234, 0.06345385313034058, 0.007542308419942856, -0.06689417362213135, -0.009540165774524212, 0.020060433074831963, -0.06997050344944, 0.016810452565550804, -0.03120993822813034, -0.018012255430221558, 0.06018299236893654, 0.048787813633680344, -0.011632835492491722, 0.019704706966876984, -0.03190675005316734, -0.045006200671195984, -0.033465802669525146, 0.002757106442004442, 0.03902832791209221, 0.012307161465287209, 0.016900818794965744, 0.030363958328962326, 0.025447048246860504, 0.028868956491351128, 0.0684485137462616, 0.03824332356452942, 0.012594737112522125, 0.08217041939496994, -0.009316189214587212, 0.024929657578468323, -0.022522563114762306, -0.026943664997816086, 0.036564163863658905, 0.02047659084200859, 0.012076645158231258, 0.03924962133169174, 0.07107626646757126, -0.003808633191511035, -0.01896875724196434, 0.025027597323060036, 0.08557573705911636, -0.0037407646887004375, 0.034038692712783813, 0.014636656269431114, 0.02073700539767742, -0.007241227198392153, -0.059018172323703766, 0.006330470088869333, -0.019270725548267365, -0.026210280135273933, -0.01464652456343174, -0.02135893888771534, 0.028282038867473602, 0.011746707372367382, -0.033580608665943146, -0.012391284108161926, 0.06367218494415283, -0.02469845674932003, -0.013442392461001873, -0.07387589663267136, -0.02456037327647209, -0.02342182956635952, 0.02504674158990383, -0.058560390025377274, 0.03788157179951668, 0.028697555884718895, -0.07829169183969498, -0.06857205927371979, 0.05303451418876648, -0.07418089359998703, -0.04913457855582237, -0.07143634557723999, -0.004848224576562643, 0.01191070955246687, 0.0544276162981987, 0.015231151133775711, 0.008324181661009789, -0.0114195067435503, -0.04884026199579239, 0.034943412989377975, 0.038728415966033936, -0.056757424026727676, 0.01750176027417183, -0.01090508233755827, 0.03135017305612564, 0.013248986564576626, -0.0397661067545414, -0.03146140277385712, -0.017991766333580017, 0.0620533786714077, -0.004141264595091343, -0.020652804523706436, 0.01478011067956686, -0.0166636910289526, -0.029837539419531822, -0.07136422395706177, 0.037228189408779144, 0.018268590793013573, 0.011476496234536171, -0.04008804261684418, -0.015449036844074726, 0.05069766938686371, 0.017673883587121964, 0.02894454449415207, -0.008866154588758945, 0.014940142631530762, -0.017964011058211327, 0.0267271026968956, 0.019175352528691292, -0.016712617129087448, -0.04138745740056038, -0.02689346857368946, 0.051937080919742584, -0.033650778234004974, -0.009803787805140018, -0.003162250155583024, 0.01457795687019825, 0.0123748779296875, -0.038428179919719696, 0.08573168516159058, 0.052065782248973846, -0.042382899671792984, -0.027820710092782974, -0.04601587355136871, -0.01062843669205904, 0.01483368594199419, -0.03860275447368622, 0.04761497676372528, -0.02020159736275673, -0.011579008772969246, -0.0008917597588151693, 0.005981172900646925, 0.0066535575315356255, -0.02508423663675785, -0.009904236532747746, -0.0004877361061517149, 0.002228419529274106, 0.07518437504768372, 0.044511232525110245, 0.041657090187072754, 0.04168626666069031, 0.013743716292083263, 0.0017517379019409418, 0.03890080004930496, -0.01619684137403965, 0.040812719613313675, -0.05113362520933151, -0.06252702325582504, -0.05025793984532356, -0.03489813953638077, 0.035643838346004486, 0.07264494150876999, 0.002643436659127474, 0.04237225279211998, -0.006293753162026405, -0.06425084173679352, -0.04501446336507797, -0.02372974529862404, 0.01989835686981678, -0.02117082104086876, 0.005028806626796722, 0.016909481957554817, -0.05086330324411392, 0.05444205179810524, 0.01627535931766033, -0.0064759813249111176, 0.01708507537841797, -0.053261321038007736, 0.004530276637524366, 0.008395935408771038, 0.008135913871228695, 0.016297023743391037, 0.023871708661317825, -0.009794043377041817, -0.008269315585494041, 0.03972654789686203, 0.06931457668542862, -0.02318868786096573, -0.08288474380970001, -0.02164454758167267, -0.016915250569581985, -0.028430188074707985, 0.06025273725390434, 0.005810977425426245, -0.06215473636984825, -0.034573979675769806, -0.005372074898332357, -0.03342613950371742, 0.03544021025300026, 0.059899456799030304, -0.0004467483377084136, 0.07807054370641708, -0.016910668462514877, 0.020325087010860443, 0.04075942933559418, -0.0012551009422168136, -0.033582158386707306, -0.027143649756908417, 0.03378840908408165, -0.00031656993087381124, 0.04160556197166443, -0.047627635300159454, -0.0569591298699379, 0.05198829993605614, -0.010295365937054157, 0.020325928926467896, 0.00841209664940834, -0.04067805036902428, -0.04393338784575462, 0.019185805693268776, -0.018721939995884895, -0.016620730981230736, -0.0035751396790146828, 0.009305735118687153, -0.017478816211223602, -0.0062860045582056046, -0.05207772180438042, -0.008987556211650372, 0.02490733191370964, 0.020150713622570038, -0.0059937965124845505, -0.03268938884139061, 0.022974152117967606, -0.05460432171821594, -0.025651849806308746, 0.02248779870569706, -0.009238381870090961, 0.007178543135523796, -0.03372121602296829, -0.0038135515060275793, -0.023003168404102325, -0.03279192000627518, 0.021265223622322083, -0.000766049895901233, 0.0044006044045090675, -0.024253198876976967, -0.018177932128310204, -0.048077721148729324, 0.04308630898594856, 0.028839120641350746, -0.0142775634303689, 0.034954462200403214, 0.055197808891534805, -0.01542800385504961, -0.007735180202871561, -0.015036677941679955, -0.05190758407115936, -0.051907554268836975, 0.0002493190113455057, 0.011020676232874393, 0.0381510853767395, -0.07467951625585556, -0.04522906616330147, -0.021817252039909363, -0.0041305613704025745, 0.04494745284318924, 0.008316097781062126, 0.021891582757234573, -0.01677635684609413, -0.04943229258060455, 0.008261635899543762, 0.040356092154979706, -0.004429166670888662, -0.009890817105770111, 0.010958311147987843, 0.023884329944849014, -0.013026556931436062, 0.018437815830111504, 0.044506777077913284, 0.04324487969279289, 0.011058499105274677, -0.016012998297810555, 0.06177195534110069, 0.07927587628364563, 0.0053872112184762955, 0.05056311935186386, -0.05498700588941574, -0.02112646959722042, 0.01355208270251751, 0.00982219260185957, -0.10683749616146088, -0.002096632495522499, 0.007480539381504059, -0.0037888572551310062, -0.0074911704286932945, 0.045748669654130936, 0.036408934742212296, -0.0537467785179615, -0.006741647142916918, -0.04732976853847504, 0.022519376128911972, -0.024535061791539192, 0.004312921315431595, -0.016844693571329117, -0.029412444680929184, 0.04764063283801079, 0.07215488702058792, 0.023174647241830826, 0.014665529131889343, -0.019165275618433952, 0.05888660252094269, 0.04034900665283203, 0.013236508704721928, -0.028951628133654594, 0.02240823581814766, -0.05115586891770363, 0.04859371483325958, -0.02834402024745941, 0.010182741098105907, -0.05675055831670761, -0.06201581656932831, -0.043232884258031845, 0.0462348572909832, -0.018198952078819275, -0.03831916302442551, 0.01163716521114111, 0.02789204753935337, 0.011120758019387722, 0.050007209181785583, -0.028934232890605927, 0.014988378621637821, -0.002720609772950411, 0.027912534773349762, 0.028197385370731354, -0.027067169547080994, 0.050503361970186234, -0.05115347355604172, -0.026398129761219025, 0.01962265372276306, -0.037234533578157425, 0.03485395014286041, -0.08590871095657349, 0.04037757217884064, 0.059227410703897476, -0.0560239739716053, 0.045961178839206696, -0.03834587708115578, 0.007007476408034563, 0.029823366552591324, -0.020220570266246796, -0.008712058886885643, 0.03607550635933876, -0.0019820930901914835, -0.04230431467294693, 0.01769101805984974, -0.0354420468211174, 0.027606934309005737, -0.06481987237930298, -0.0003986927622463554, 0.019748559221625328, -0.03766380622982979, -0.0059922197833657265, -0.009785603731870651, 0.01224611047655344, 0.030911477282643318, -0.02974519692361355, 0.03613743558526039, -0.011627762578427792, -0.012348216027021408, 0.06898827105760574, 0.022412477061152458, -0.021226176992058754, 0.016177358105778694, 0.008135021664202213, -0.023992016911506653, 0.00047197664389386773, -0.007235963828861713, 0.028015675023198128, -0.045813918113708496, -0.03170131891965866, 0.05368036404252052, 0.0018554899143055081, -0.012324281968176365, 0.026512188836932182, 0.0234978124499321, 0.01238920632749796, -0.08495895564556122, 0.0755872055888176, -0.02658713422715664, -0.06711135059595108, 0.0486447736620903, 0.02857823483645916, -0.048825155943632126, -0.021781064569950104, -0.005376141518354416, 0.004171975888311863, -0.06453829258680344, -0.055925823748111725, 0.045088157057762146, -0.030772114172577858, 0.022541435435414314, -0.001715624239295721, 0.03126346692442894, 0.06007445976138115, 0.03736519441008568, -0.027168579399585724, -0.03217018023133278, -0.038405563682317734, -0.016405712813138962, 0.04800397530198097, 0.006753891706466675, 0.016412338241934776, -0.02258697897195816, -0.02844909578561783, -0.04974595829844475, -0.025134490802884102, 0.01173652708530426, -0.02338489703834057, -0.029096050187945366, -0.04570256918668747, -0.011999910697340965, 0.044177088886499405, 0.017331982031464577, -0.009555859491229057, -0.01815825141966343, -0.01758703403174877, -0.031669728457927704, -0.03396031633019447, -0.03815293312072754, -0.01425157766789198, 0.009825533255934715, 0.045326732099056244, -0.02074272185564041, 0.06795596331357956, 0.05032837390899658, 0.043316904455423355, 0.015138456597924232, -0.08198193460702896, -0.036494310945272446, 0.014063920825719833, -0.05663162097334862, -0.01845221035182476, 0.005705384537577629, -0.008168164640665054, 0.03385891020298004, 0.011638772673904896, -0.015486478805541992, 0.006734005641192198, -0.01413263101130724, 0.03627382218837738, 0.04178043082356453, -0.007112044841051102, 0.0027076664846390486, 0.0381632074713707, -0.06243222951889038, 0.011396775022149086, 0.020071955397725105, 0.0019347367342561483, -0.028211580589413643, -0.02706788294017315, -0.03683855012059212, -0.06889834254980087, 0.03402750566601753, -0.0049582794308662415, 0.007741004228591919, -0.05167481303215027, 0.03927822783589363, -0.017018748447299004, 0.0008259621099568903, -0.012579641304910183, 0.06845827400684357, 0.006916902028024197, -0.02547529898583889, 0.0026335238944739103, -0.012635561637580395, 0.01273398194462061, 0.04834815859794617, -0.012290483340620995, -0.0025585894472897053, -0.027901597321033478, -0.010070445016026497, 0.09618779271841049, -0.047298602759838104, -0.030863981693983078, -0.012323020957410336, 0.04112156108021736, -0.012427515350282192, 0.01230622734874487, -0.02480419911444187, -0.09653410315513611, -0.00002720002521527931, -0.0025963529478758574, 0.01959337294101715, -0.034527722746133804, 0.03561491146683693, -0.004798003006726503, -0.02520996704697609, 0.05917678400874138, 0.0021268099080771208, -0.04110085591673851, -0.008638937026262283, 0.024353880435228348, -0.07124438136816025, 0.062326204031705856, 0.05632734298706055, -0.02230723202228546, -0.0009901971789076924, 0.012546255253255367, -0.07094144821166992, -0.008050208911299706, 0.007037591189146042, -0.012839228846132755, -0.07783293724060059, -0.038637805730104446, 0.05241309106349945, -0.0649891123175621, 0.010505350306630135, 0.0688583254814148, -0.017091646790504456, 0.029963932931423187, 0.017690259963274002, -0.020646296441555023, -0.10226894170045853, 0.003337022615596652, 0.031867001205682755, -0.005658959504216909, -0.007254695054143667, 0.008149610832333565, -0.06173932924866676, 0.024355875328183174, -0.050508033484220505, -0.0033967813942581415, -0.0008171105873771012, 0.02367027848958969, 0.004469878971576691, 0.0036964344326406717, 0.0017044381238520145, 0.049010954797267914, -0.013898423872888088, -0.013392857275903225, -0.030098265036940575, -0.015344072133302689, -0.04288943484425545, 0.018708104267716408, 0.02225440740585327, 0.03832951560616493, -0.04606284573674202, 0.05701346695423126, -0.06861062347888947, 0.01842425763607025, 0.036131132394075394, 0.03550773486495018, -0.01100791897624731, -0.00033013924257829785, -0.0038250507786870003, 0.024392105638980865, -0.041256941854953766, 0.006861498113721609, 0.03549665957689285, 0.012754213064908981, -0.03046126663684845, -0.016223914921283722, 0.032318100333213806, -0.015514631755650043, 0.006947518792003393, -0.021231794729828835, 0.0020201343577355146, 0.054033312946558, 0.05084918811917305, 0.037308577448129654, -0.001821461832150817, 0.030334658920764923, 0.02313660830259323, -0.026469461619853973, -0.001978956162929535, -0.008187302388250828, 0.05263976752758026, 0.015919676050543785, -0.06968580186367035, -0.07297393679618835, -0.010732959024608135, -0.013005170039832592, 0.005389036610722542, -0.015890879556536674, -0.04882430657744408, -0.0013754727551713586, -0.0076715946197509766, -0.02808050997555256, -0.0658521056175232, 0.014691565185785294, -0.033131349831819534, -0.005073125474154949, -0.027061451226472855, -0.0011779677588492632, 0.010246741585433483, -0.027371978387236595, -0.030068205669522285, 0.059479571878910065, -0.02826019376516342, 0.09277202188968658, -0.056716542690992355, -0.029198482632637024, -0.039870765060186386, 0.010470939800143242, 0.06616676598787308, -0.05659710243344307, -0.012309624813497066, 0.006972190458327532, -0.011357682757079601, 0.08261793851852417, -0.007200103253126144, 0.06586258113384247, 0.015174179337918758, 0.037964798510074615, 0.02357645519077778, -0.03942098841071129, 0.026013880968093872, -0.023753933608531952, -0.03657923638820648, -0.031225446611642838, 0.017542395740747452, -0.014713437296450138, 0.05396429821848869, -0.01046049315482378, 0.019821222871541977, 0.025540601462125778, -0.024292752146720886, 0.015292203985154629, 0.08173700422048569, -0.0286832507699728, -0.01338185090571642, -0.02285328321158886, -0.05101979523897171, -0.02890102006494999, 0.03277048096060753, 0.026882153004407883, -0.00927984993904829, -0.00881133321672678, -0.02916828542947769, -0.03157872334122658, -0.021017098799347878, -0.0027553150430321693, -0.029821103438735008, 0.01638348586857319, -0.03309590741991997, -0.009186828508973122, -0.012309686280786991, 0.0020219162106513977, -0.03068472631275654, 0.0017043122788891196, -0.020000366494059563, 0.04386116936802864, -0.018478715792298317, 0.017458613961935043, 0.01045768428593874, -0.0040437690913677216, 0.011714237742125988, -0.006433969363570213, -0.03545032814145088, -0.0398690328001976, -0.055378638207912445, 0.016736900433897972, -0.006423657760024071, -0.034099940210580826, 0.05233962461352348, 0.02818327397108078, -0.008727338165044785, -0.0005310698179528117, -0.014507451094686985, -0.0007045654929243028, 0.02017035149037838, 0.00516235176473856, -0.05087101459503174, 0.008373233489692211, 0.0069418358616530895, 0.04561132565140724, -0.0032544746063649654, -0.03239045664668083, 0.05584130808711052, 0.061935435980558395 ]
<p>I have hourly utility bills for two years. The first year's data are from before a retrofit was performed on a home and the second year is after the retrofit was performed. </p> <p>How do I compare the two time series statistically to make claims of demand savings during a specific time period of the day. Can this be done in R, if so how?</p>
g48321
[ 0.01824713498353958, -0.03425121307373047, -0.017189698293805122, 0.007085855584591627, -0.03800733759999275, -0.011223618872463703, 0.031157836318016052, -0.029095958918333054, -0.0631454661488533, 0.006313234567642212, 0.01204738486558199, 0.009951301850378513, 0.05359972268342972, 0.031939804553985596, -0.04916023463010788, 0.009774748235940933, -0.0033228362444788218, 0.039548322558403015, -0.019428696483373642, 0.0008672594558447599, 0.01075031142681837, -0.04915463551878929, -0.014562859199941158, -0.004289467819035053, -0.01986875757575035, 0.005376447457820177, -0.007635216694325209, 0.040670424699783325, -0.06648369878530502, -0.015367014333605766, 0.007437354885041714, 0.07960226386785507, 0.01958593726158142, -0.024813268333673477, -0.02478725276887417, -0.031949255615472794, 0.06853040307760239, -0.016112972050905228, -0.047743991017341614, 0.006103027146309614, -0.02259899489581585, 0.024295559152960777, 0.08506648242473602, 0.02701154351234436, 0.01148891169577837, -0.03543607145547867, 0.012798473238945007, -0.001698889653198421, -0.023715535178780556, 0.033647872507572174, 0.012717709876596928, 0.09978845715522766, -0.029199130833148956, 0.018720990046858788, -0.012706913985311985, -0.028023146092891693, 0.006936854682862759, 0.015675798058509827, 0.08847452700138092, 0.00102202408015728, -0.025634709745645523, 0.01919245719909668, 0.012709228321909904, 0.010557089932262897, 0.04215836152434349, 0.06689886748790741, 0.0478333905339241, 0.007416828535497189, -0.005636144429445267, -0.011160016991198063, -0.03241836652159691, -0.004991006106138229, -0.03489129990339279, -0.008761751465499401, 0.00382181815803051, 0.004488063510507345, -0.027555685490369797, -0.002480221213772893, 0.03394671529531479, 0.08512359857559204, -0.05525190383195877, 0.007993885315954685, -0.02220601588487625, 0.020210683345794678, 0.028686266392469406, 0.0029837226029485464, 0.05063309147953987, 0.002592966891825199, 0.025137102231383324, 0.0204906165599823, -0.0032919871155172586, 0.012630698271095753, 0.03839625045657158, 0.06929526478052139, -0.013028115965425968, 0.00022874931164551526, -0.08443212509155273, -0.04337110370397568, 0.022699402645230293, 0.031986065208911896, -0.06890111416578293, -0.005444976035505533, 0.02857336774468422, -0.040699902921915054, -0.049118902534246445, 0.023421740159392357, 0.00720410468056798, 0.013890931382775307, -0.036389753222465515, -0.01927683688700199, 0.00558685977011919, 0.010034765116870403, -0.03884989768266678, 0.04284413903951645, 0.05781282112002373, -0.0328301340341568, 0.0773853063583374, -0.035984888672828674, -0.0638415515422821, 0.00022365858603734523, -0.002538961824029684, -0.0230784360319376, -0.032573677599430084, 0.053922008723020554, -0.018967069685459137, 0.011283325031399727, -0.02779640071094036, 0.04192540422081947, 0.03718458488583565, 0.08187026530504227, 0.012486438266932964, 0.032474298030138016, 0.011916090734302998, 0.03154801204800606, 0.0007874525035731494, 0.042934972792863846, 0.016390152275562286, -0.003045945428311825, -0.0373493954539299, -0.0005807038396596909, -0.008568338118493557, -0.01667756401002407, 0.0039068651385605335, -0.06922122091054916, -0.008204173296689987, 0.021944567561149597, -0.008539914153516293, -0.02579968236386776, -0.004993373062461615, 0.05000615492463112, -0.019581936299800873, 0.037229184061288834, -0.0006713736220262945, 0.007422639522701502, 0.007667530328035355, -0.008699703961610794, -0.06492286175489426, -0.011907669715583324, -0.034880269318819046, 0.044156283140182495, -0.0219296682626009, 0.01488517690449953, 0.013150518760085106, 0.032886896282434464, 0.003853372298181057, -0.04448851943016052, -0.028265902772545815, -0.03420869633555412, 0.04140346497297287, -0.014951921068131924, 0.027239693328738213, -0.003930033650249243, 0.058942172676324844, -0.019457759335637093, 0.07873561233282089, 0.0016277646645903587, -0.04415418580174446, -0.05211246386170387, 0.04105018451809883, 0.0013539429055526853, -0.007702107075601816, -0.0017053521005436778, -0.005920395255088806, 0.04404565319418907, -0.009916888549923897, -0.04383157193660736, 0.006570071447640657, -0.017090948298573494, -0.0911395251750946, -0.016275815665721893, -0.05215368792414665, -0.03058761917054653, -0.04342423006892204, 0.037899527698755264, -0.028703831136226654, 0.00459361681714654, 0.028554238379001617, -0.008153720758855343, -0.056751783937215805, -0.03452730551362038, 0.09095025062561035, -0.02241828665137291, -0.000872175267431885, 0.01163751445710659, -0.018662555143237114, 0.03804900124669075, -0.04246606305241585, -0.04962814971804619, -0.03301505744457245, -0.032547272741794586, 0.008736349642276764, 0.00011040745448553935, -0.017963536083698273, -0.03388769552111626, 0.02831035666167736, 0.026206577196717262, -0.017595261335372925, 0.015543372370302677, 0.008064809255301952, -0.017051707953214645, -0.055962927639484406, 0.012439170852303505, 0.12141904979944229, 0.03965580835938454, 0.005550999194383621, 0.012360920198261738, 0.10471755266189575, 0.10026061534881592, 0.010207378305494785, -0.023421967402100563, 0.001991329248994589, -0.02981269359588623, -0.019815614446997643, -0.04507363587617874, 0.018759453669190407, 0.06922757625579834, 0.020698226988315582, -0.00797357689589262, 0.02988998405635357, -0.03417747840285301, 0.032877467572689056, 0.01759328320622444, -0.01135967392474413, 0.03624320775270462, 0.013390297070145607, -0.0393180251121521, 0.02571732923388481, 0.01511706318706274, 0.025362886488437653, 0.07646545022726059, 0.02283482812345028, 0.06585492938756943, -0.04050135985016823, -0.008157051168382168, 0.029677823185920715, -0.05589767172932625, -0.0018116255523636937, 0.016856463626027107, 0.007044609636068344, 0.01157109159976244, -0.03946473076939583, 0.020376693457365036, 0.041634492576122284, 0.026867801323533058, 0.0175729151815176, -0.03910766914486885, -0.030690288171172142, -0.04543067887425423, 0.00889767799526453, -0.04928644001483917, 0.011379968374967575, -0.008977805264294147, 0.017346376553177834, 0.044238779693841934, 0.022572079673409462, -0.005054250359535217, -0.05471782386302948, -0.012223929166793823, 0.03572901710867882, 0.014209749177098274, 0.03757832199335098, -0.11204999685287476, 0.014577265828847885, 0.07638730853796005, 0.036604393273591995, -0.019273459911346436, 0.021383389830589294, 0.06654597073793411, -0.053085941821336746, 0.03372621163725853, -0.04003377631306648, 0.049438100308179855, -0.0644456073641777, -0.014734509401023388, -0.014859977178275585, 0.00868596788495779, 0.01615246571600437, 0.005339290946722031, -0.0013183268019929528, 0.021570317447185516, -0.01407939288765192, -0.021454889327287674, -0.011689945124089718, 0.03950462117791176, 0.004097340628504753, -0.011485298164188862, -0.016539128497242928, -0.026662494987249374, 0.019207941368222237, 0.00031972231226973236, -0.0257613193243742, -0.03965653106570244, -0.022867176681756973, -0.027834376320242882, 0.022879140451550484, -0.03881622478365898, 0.06615184992551804, 0.015341861173510551, -0.0026021176017820835, 0.03729015216231346, -0.01716667413711548, 0.005725616589188576, 0.042051929980516434, -0.02747194841504097, -0.055612366646528244, 0.03174551576375961, -0.07240588217973709, 0.05453291907906532, -0.0545474998652935, 0.00674839923158288, -0.009661039337515831, -0.03533423691987991, -0.029281010851264, -0.06787773966789246, -0.00996301881968975, 0.017218632623553276, 0.005666504614055157, 0.010531621985137463, -0.021110210567712784, 0.07728446274995804, 0.0024386353325098753, -0.005021245218813419, -0.0018231887370347977, 0.0009460371220484376, -0.005016499198973179, -0.024351658299565315, -0.03647858276963234, 0.018472962081432343, 0.027882445603609085, 0.013734378851950169, -0.006857509259134531, -0.021174000576138496, 0.029544344171881676, -0.00892668403685093, 0.05615933984518051, 0.02046249806880951, 0.01871442049741745, -0.013042259961366653, -0.02140367031097412, -0.033762525767087936, -0.009069804102182388, -0.04398239776492119, -0.018800677731633186, -0.019320068880915642, -0.026712700724601746, 0.015278344973921776, 0.044657982885837555, 0.02169024758040905, 0.04730470851063728, -0.007168596610426903, 0.017098842188715935, 0.07820931822061539, 0.034489311277866364, -0.033511683344841, 0.020665869116783142, -0.04151095822453499, 0.04096449911594391, 0.019321104511618614, 0.06162376329302788, 0.1233556941151619, 0.018478689715266228, 0.02804691530764103, 0.0013900147750973701, 0.033312540501356125, -0.019861284643411636, -0.09927932173013687, -0.01450445968657732, 0.00023940698883961886, -0.002340738894417882, -0.06998562812805176, -0.03619026020169258, -0.009357503615319729, -0.04842055216431618, -0.021577002480626106, 0.0488896518945694, 0.022915596142411232, 0.07042158395051956, 0.0337621234357357, 0.005517170298844576, -0.0020956138614565134, -0.03654716908931732, 0.07102692127227783, 0.025319533422589302, 0.009820843115448952, -0.07909335941076279, -0.04285286366939545, 0.013745630159974098, -0.013028604909777641, -0.022581247612833977, -0.029123133048415184, -0.07523894309997559, -0.005986558739095926, 0.035476382821798325, -0.05059238150715828, 0.018440065905451775, -0.029345277696847916, 0.05533374845981598, -0.021690934896469116, 0.05768227577209473, 0.03602013736963272, -0.04147407039999962, 0.019047211855649948, -0.01810438558459282, -0.012469417415559292, 0.025805078446865082, 0.017453547567129135, 0.003972658887505531, -0.02935166098177433, 0.043939169496297836, -0.03372132033109665, -0.00534606259316206, 0.010335397906601429, -0.02247055619955063, 0.0013514376478269696, 0.010208269581198692, -0.004576035775244236, 0.0354984886944294, 0.0035374779254198074, -0.024285191670060158, -0.04676034674048424, 0.02112623304128647, -0.0809032991528511, 0.003593756817281246, 0.019459133967757225, -0.0111311050131917, 0.03689495474100113, 0.016990793868899345, -0.05674242973327637, 0.06822046637535095, 0.033678486943244934, -0.004788582678884268, 0.016677292063832283, 0.0282997265458107, -0.02428862452507019, 0.016556594520807266, -0.0016578511567786336, -0.0008359513012692332, 0.0004078188503626734, 0.05090703070163727, 0.06291428208351135, -0.026066046208143234, -0.04266957566142082, -0.008236950263381004, -0.04674822464585304, -0.04812236130237579, -0.0006737908697687089, -0.03365880250930786, -0.02287762053310871, 0.025052690878510475, 0.004707058425992727, 0.03948541358113289, -0.042412709444761276, -0.030620206147432327, -0.005275077186524868, 0.008534258231520653, -0.0246980469673872, 0.008963125757873058, -0.05286502465605736, 0.05469595640897751, 0.06325531750917435, -0.038555748760700226, -0.013378090225160122, 0.014767243526875973, -0.002828998723998666, 0.012092853896319866, -0.06466131657361984, 0.027370475232601166, -0.034712158143520355, 0.014512703754007816, 0.032569557428359985, -0.05533520132303238, 0.05877695232629776, 0.10188009589910507, 0.02843426913022995, 0.01348883006721735, 0.02953418903052807, 0.012975035235285759, 0.03386006876826286, -0.05879190191626549, 0.011205307208001614, -0.029905715957283974, 0.09064191579818726, 0.016510149464011192, -0.005801111925393343, 0.01516924798488617, 0.021174265071749687, -0.00835759099572897, 0.05255609005689621, -0.040784433484077454, 0.007267380133271217, -0.00849604420363903, 0.02531551569700241, -0.007183780428022146, -0.02228742279112339, 0.0010893024737015367, -0.004762942902743816, -0.02321167290210724, 0.014285038225352764, -0.03663521632552147, -0.08187618851661682, 0.03230840340256691, -0.01598438061773777, 0.07173962891101837, 0.033023472875356674, 0.006946983747184277, -0.033042628318071365, -0.010761843994259834, -0.07995937764644623, 0.06436608731746674, -0.060482874512672424, 0.01948392577469349, -0.022860661149024963, 0.027987632900476456, -0.011549743823707104, 0.002202018164098263, 0.02705482766032219, 0.016112910583615303, -0.03148820996284485, -0.026018336415290833, -0.06483282148838043, -0.0677008181810379, -0.00969463400542736, 0.07612448930740356, -0.03280828893184662, -0.01832587830722332, -0.09556491672992706, -0.0025650248862802982, -0.035778921097517014, -0.004615406971424818, 0.017362695187330246, 0.017888588830828667, 0.014889140613377094, -0.005082950461655855, 0.017068758606910706, 0.03997114673256874, -0.014268686063587666, 0.03829419985413551, -0.05326937511563301, -0.005255340598523617, 0.04263255000114441, -0.005824650637805462, -0.03423856198787689, 0.0233582966029644, 0.003419938264414668, 0.007623074110597372, 0.02562686800956726, 0.03372300788760185, 0.014025225304067135, 0.009202919900417328, 0.005504842847585678, 0.05505657196044922, -0.0023399272467941046, 0.10404249280691147, -0.05864087492227554, -0.0225997157394886, 0.03552088513970375, 0.025861317291855812, 0.0002655304269865155, -0.007262428291141987, -0.005995969288051128, 0.008614557795226574, -0.0364563949406147, -0.005580188240855932, 0.047085851430892944, -0.060242995619773865, 0.033725205808877945, 0.028501739725470543, -0.01331015769392252, -0.018781837075948715, 0.016587410122156143, -0.04534699395298958, -0.026919186115264893, 0.05061010643839836, -0.03077285923063755, 0.01524292677640915, -0.007433683145791292, -0.03363148495554924, -0.005046837497502565, 0.002778606256470084, 0.012232687324285507, -0.009077263996005058, -0.012145936489105225, 0.05635352060198784, -0.03809542953968048, -0.00005037234222982079, -0.035718273371458054, -0.01862236112356186, 0.034796055406332016, -0.03332293778657913, -0.021289771422743797, -0.05919870734214783, 0.034541141241788864, 0.02479073405265808, 0.045143820345401764, -0.00762522267177701, -0.008810712024569511, -0.046811558306217194, 0.03159046918153763, -0.0036586211062967777, -0.009684563614428043, 0.07302126288414001, 0.07030219584703445, 0.018822820857167244, -0.005342897027730942, 0.055473845452070236, 0.01370320562273264, -0.06473376601934433, 0.02074596658349037, 0.08076117187738419, -0.000010417641533422284, -0.012979865074157715, 0.02795397862792015, -0.04236049950122833, 0.0019583904650062323, -0.017433231696486473, 0.04066140577197075, -0.034189481288194656, 0.04479807987809181, -0.023532727733254433, 0.013105161488056183, 0.009783059358596802, 0.07305635511875153, -0.010684140026569366, -0.006825387943536043, -0.0006924170884303749, -0.03013322874903679, 0.041999202221632004, -0.04802844673395157, 0.004866102710366249, 0.0030402725096791983, 0.04312358424067497, 0.01970914751291275, 0.020021192729473114, -0.08295751363039017, -0.02758733555674553, 0.05557279288768768, -0.004746817518025637, 0.013149024918675423, 0.033769506961107254, -0.01443845871835947, 0.008428352884948254, -0.0435699000954628, -0.017147565260529518, -0.0015886176843196154, 0.07517162710428238, 0.024982480332255363, -0.030202463269233704, -0.0451502688229084, 0.04472624883055687, -0.05724671110510826, 0.0031941861379891634, -0.022491728886961937, -0.05765265226364136, 0.046962786465883255, 0.022517086938023567, 0.007029257249087095, 0.031017852947115898, 0.013239061459898949, -0.02215019054710865, -0.03576882556080818, -0.03605284541845322, -0.02029777318239212, -0.014654494822025299, -0.008452278561890125, 0.021772408857941628, 0.05219756439328194, -0.014985309913754463, -0.029321936890482903, 0.041220322251319885, -0.05578882619738579, 0.0011262282496318221, -0.03248419240117073, -0.039200399070978165, 0.022616222500801086, -0.009767742827534676, 0.016333892941474915, -0.039418090134859085, -0.047486647963523865, -0.029543526470661163, -0.024374397471547127, 0.02407759241759777, 0.05108724534511566, -0.020809154957532883, -0.025806495919823647, -0.0029985581059008837, -0.06973344087600708, -0.05837536230683327, -0.008327718824148178, -0.04039778932929039, -0.016592323780059814, 0.020109592005610466, 0.01568624936044216, 0.009042497724294662, -0.013849742710590363, -0.000309110531816259, -0.03882316127419472, 0.017147816717624664, -0.05313023179769516, -0.01961960829794407, -0.01885751634836197, -0.016128450632095337, -0.01647152006626129, -0.04437738284468651, -0.06030341237783432, -0.02747691608965397, 0.002960214391350746, -0.03138003125786781, -0.00795327965170145, -0.0400637611746788, -0.001552737201564014, -0.005197540856897831, -0.02915089577436447, -0.05987277626991272, 0.036201294511556625, 0.036464203149080276, 0.03945950046181679, -0.04666002839803696, 0.040655214339494705, -0.018705537542700768, -0.003192805452272296, -0.030727088451385498, 0.03805892914533615, -0.018143653869628906, 0.036725785583257675, -0.01578182727098465, 0.025718921795487404, -0.04929853230714798, 0.002889426192268729, -0.0014650081284344196, -0.04773934185504913, -0.020423389971256256, -0.01773950643837452, -0.10594973713159561, 0.03320490941405296, 0.015765519812703133, 0.03450246900320053, -0.02493903785943985, -0.03838345780968666, -0.013701232150197029, 0.0070231007412076, -0.0029530890751630068, 0.019731951877474785, -0.05619258061051369, -0.027059165760874748, 0.08201506733894348, -0.02789008803665638, 0.009621844626963139, -0.014309625141322613 ]
<p>My first and I think naive question here.</p> <p>I am trying to model a certain business, and the simplest model I am willing to test is: 1. there is a bag of differently biased coins. 2. every step, a single coin is chosen with equal probability. 3. the chosen coin is flipped and returned to the bag.</p> <p>The business goal is to predict the rate of heads in future trials (probably using Bayesian inference).</p> <p>This got me thinking - am I not over-complicating things? Isn't this process (observationally) equivalent to a single biased coin?</p> <p>Thanks in advance!</p>
g74029
[ -0.013959212228655815, 0.04277949780225754, 0.009597702883183956, -0.004344234708696604, 0.04411856830120087, -0.02943345159292221, 0.040224578231573105, 0.02549179270863533, -0.0314364992082119, 0.008930053561925888, 0.02206912264227867, 0.034502770751714706, 0.036484647542238235, -0.003370602149516344, -0.0190579853951931, -0.02597941644489765, 0.059048786759376526, 0.012077643536031246, 0.04859307035803795, 0.030500274151563644, -0.01080054696649313, 0.0015062588499858975, -0.007207877468317747, -0.027010947465896606, -0.028373679146170616, -0.11427886039018631, -0.00460214726626873, 0.008345137350261211, -0.07496679574251175, 0.028866657987236977, -0.024251634255051613, 0.0018926790216937661, 0.0645233765244484, -0.01001252606511116, -0.08320031315088272, -0.03500278294086456, 0.08155845105648041, -0.015094893053174019, 0.02930806390941143, 0.0339437797665596, -0.008794981054961681, 0.057478487491607666, 0.02232528105378151, -0.017438724637031555, 0.027944404631853104, 0.01921321079134941, 0.03757942467927933, 0.03136025369167328, 0.0674281120300293, -0.024928933009505272, -0.005417779088020325, 0.025994479656219482, 0.029410559684038162, 0.0360557995736599, -0.05256194993853569, 0.014899136498570442, -0.00350477104075253, 0.0633099377155304, -0.007982343435287476, 0.006549048703163862, 0.039730723947286606, -0.032934483140707016, -0.042326416820287704, 0.012292885221540928, 0.04369032010436058, 0.011541333049535751, 0.02070372924208641, -0.03052675724029541, 0.003369704121723771, -0.03783293068408966, -0.0012459899298846722, -0.0044166878797113895, 0.04590136930346489, -0.017897192388772964, -0.006621577311307192, -0.014300007373094559, 0.01550756860524416, 0.02104879356920719, -0.034405313432216644, 0.016644857823848724, -0.033446237444877625, 0.01835443265736103, 0.03217243403196335, 0.02801540307700634, 0.023917455226182938, 0.0027466020546853542, 0.02598688378930092, -0.062373168766498566, -0.024976689368486404, -0.029768330976366997, 0.00394184747710824, -0.0498865470290184, 0.05090074986219406, 0.061584483832120895, -0.03844336047768593, -0.010858973488211632, -0.11287751793861389, 0.04133986309170723, 0.028224235400557518, 0.029253406450152397, -0.00399619759991765, 0.016976844519376755, -0.030217748135328293, -0.03207054361701012, -0.08580007404088974, 0.019777871668338776, -0.010210882872343063, 0.08259241282939911, -0.013453816063702106, -0.06724655628204346, -0.029859498143196106, -0.005179850850254297, -0.015504037961363792, 0.0347796194255352, -0.028500281274318695, 0.019609466195106506, 0.04580352082848549, 0.04605599120259285, -0.03686735779047012, 0.003067118814215064, 0.017393749207258224, -0.034465327858924866, -0.014192979782819748, 0.0244330782443285, -0.056674301624298096, -0.004935234785079956, -0.04264632984995842, 0.07141312211751938, 0.02410600706934929, 0.05688105896115303, 0.0403115451335907, 0.004058835096657276, 0.06133008375763893, 0.03416325896978378, 0.07798289507627487, 0.02747245505452156, 0.026813294738531113, 0.041721586138010025, 0.029477257281541824, -0.0010544024407863617, 0.02635403722524643, -0.001889040577225387, 0.01205777283757925, -0.004173793364316225, -0.032703157514333725, -0.01837274059653282, -0.022348150610923767, 0.026306448504328728, -0.012097956612706184, 0.011522243730723858, -0.04054875299334526, 0.059083882719278336, -0.01336719747632742, 0.025798747316002846, -0.02883484773337841, -0.012773813679814339, 0.03194456174969673, -0.0021905056200921535, 0.01599079929292202, -0.003077598987147212, 0.07020881772041321, -0.041080180555582047, -0.016231533139944077, -0.04287621006369591, -0.06156443431973457, 0.024440137669444084, 0.0008599807624705136, -0.017137253656983376, 0.007380782160907984, -0.013195949606597424, -0.017795400694012642, -0.038452453911304474, -0.015007063746452332, -0.013402674347162247, 0.04542805999517441, 0.02443084493279457, 0.01969434879720211, 0.014357161708176136, 0.006860479712486267, -0.01896021142601967, -0.005894578993320465, 0.008453932590782642, 0.007464431691914797, 0.04107656329870224, 0.005793689750134945, -0.012906843796372414, 0.012164773419499397, 0.021528273820877075, -0.020982565358281136, -0.031106075271964073, 0.05094851553440094, 0.010337529703974724, -0.04439428076148033, 0.0060118939727544785, -0.022778794169425964, -0.058076560497283936, 0.07195236533880234, -0.03987005352973938, 0.0365491546690464, 0.010751750320196152, 0.04396151751279831, 0.058733414858579636, -0.033397525548934937, 0.07829272747039795, -0.02457287162542343, -0.0250918697565794, 0.013432934880256653, 0.01826436258852482, 0.006296090316027403, -0.013160014525055885, 0.0026694282423704863, 0.02138075977563858, -0.027458740398287773, 0.023961244150996208, -0.001970617799088359, 0.025221679359674454, 0.0650155246257782, 0.09513678401708603, -0.004484777804464102, -0.013272571377456188, -0.00572983967140317, -0.014396846294403076, 0.04433257132768631, -0.004721044097095728, -0.005931829567998648, -0.030247341841459274, 0.009698987938463688, -0.045330535620450974, 0.038516610860824585, 0.06691300123929977, -0.048255447298288345, -0.0242338627576828, 0.0011316491290926933, -0.0201884638518095, 0.05750756710767746, 0.06871308386325836, 0.04086506739258766, 0.017810851335525513, 0.0061469534412026405, -0.026891132816672325, -0.004182015545666218, -0.030925851315259933, -0.056709397584199905, -0.013233224861323833, 0.0007257236866280437, -0.04541030526161194, 0.03598201274871826, -0.021957291290163994, 0.04326794296503067, 0.018320241943001747, -0.04159454256296158, 0.03390898555517197, -0.005909595638513565, -0.07861600071191788, 0.03216180577874184, -0.021106712520122528, 0.03571942821145058, 0.010852995328605175, 0.01250771339982748, 0.05976904556155205, 0.024414202198386192, -0.020869266241788864, 0.04750802367925644, -0.005813176743686199, 0.0023223396856337786, -0.06921780109405518, -0.010287565179169178, -0.06584558635950089, 0.008501502685248852, 0.004843878094106913, 0.0027180970646440983, 0.011630277149379253, 0.006529691629111767, 0.0671471580862999, 0.013703925535082817, -0.0025136719923466444, -0.048997003585100174, -0.01252271793782711, 0.00832065287977457, 0.020175131037831306, 0.0030532379169017076, -0.02858983352780342, -0.06599670648574829, -0.037177156656980515, 0.05810936167836189, 0.015901872888207436, -0.005785662215203047, 0.0023426441475749016, 0.03382583335042, 0.035493798553943634, -0.0330684669315815, 0.06071582809090614, 0.045794591307640076, 0.03076203726232052, -0.013575179502367973, -0.005371809471398592, 0.018785428255796432, -0.005578861106187105, 0.0008884281269274652, 0.022159870713949203, -0.0779431015253067, 0.02565806172788143, -0.010831420309841633, 0.032703716307878494, 0.0648065060377121, 0.048516832292079926, -0.05003504455089569, 0.004513861611485481, -0.010342101566493511, -0.046161290258169174, -0.051396578550338745, 0.04067285731434822, -0.026652907952666283, -0.016930632293224335, -0.021493306383490562, -0.08335800468921661, -0.02101370505988598, 0.027807267382740974, -0.02593875862658024, -0.06666813045740128, 0.014917708933353424, 0.03931064531207085, -0.002892227377742529, 0.004074671305716038, 0.014312153682112694, 0.02105003036558628, -0.10411141812801361, -0.014382895082235336, -0.07621559500694275, -0.026479169726371765, 0.08565502613782883, 0.0012337531661614776, 0.012169955298304558, 0.002317532431334257, -0.01968466304242611, -0.0568607822060585, 0.033813826739788055, 0.009773344732820988, -0.0016636879881843925, 0.06239180639386177, -0.0005631629610434175, -0.011643404141068459, -0.003009327221661806, -0.04566546902060509, -0.014863465912640095, 0.0017873768229037523, 0.021574050188064575, 0.004117545206099749, 0.083777517080307, -0.04728298634290695, 0.04661630094051361, -0.020729312673211098, 0.009073756635189056, -0.00625957828015089, 0.02898302488029003, 0.010289108380675316, 0.07005966454744339, 0.005252165719866753, -0.010078063234686852, -0.017454542219638824, 0.03145793080329895, -0.049986209720373154, -0.0007707520853728056, 0.014433657750487328, 0.021357791498303413, 0.01465245895087719, 0.03327913209795952, -0.0017604883760213852, 0.04451649263501167, -0.020070506259799004, -0.025652604177594185, -0.004184122197329998, -0.002483349060639739, -0.007245483808219433, 0.05572278052568436, 0.018604420125484467, 0.07610729336738586, 0.08829527348279953, -0.022183047607541084, 0.039904456585645676, 0.03470781072974205, 0.02690773271024227, -0.05219898372888565, 0.006909589283168316, -0.03012114204466343, 0.03947008028626442, -0.040047090500593185, -0.038217078894376755, -0.01738363690674305, 0.0057037039659917355, -0.008373729884624481, -0.023412857204675674, -0.002235861262306571, 0.05502336099743843, 0.008675058372318745, 0.021292394027113914, 0.017165053635835648, -0.07250230759382248, 0.06870049983263016, 0.020090894773602486, -0.03864867985248566, -0.03774267062544823, 0.02182915434241295, 0.025072336196899414, -0.013521948829293251, -0.013234860263764858, -0.02539926953613758, -0.015605850145220757, -0.09875158965587616, 0.0212173480540514, -0.005463664419949055, -0.005837727803736925, -0.001004577148705721, 0.0537903718650341, 0.02323766238987446, 0.024283984676003456, 0.0348719097673893, 0.0019991386216133833, -0.02606566995382309, -0.026875147596001625, -0.014421646483242512, 0.03224482387304306, -0.008236655965447426, -0.04018028825521469, -0.011667374521493912, 0.057543233036994934, 0.05674446001648903, 0.029837140813469887, 0.018996164202690125, -0.05181971564888954, 0.015094016678631306, 0.019677339121699333, 0.013187550008296967, 0.013117537833750248, -0.04335900396108627, 0.0009303246042691171, 0.03943508118391037, -0.023726563900709152, -0.015806330367922783, -0.05045836418867111, 0.009070943109691143, -0.00019455239817034453, -0.053531136363744736, -0.041790056973695755, 0.014174972660839558, -0.012222935445606709, 0.002466212958097458, -0.028227539733052254, 0.024893520399928093, -0.04101168364286423, -0.0782124251127243, 0.06729842722415924, -0.033447809517383575, -0.011427006684243679, 0.03837171196937561, -0.021937178447842598, 0.01548261009156704, 0.030369115993380547, -0.0003266558633185923, 0.028074322268366814, -0.06495572626590729, 0.0018299840157851577, -0.017827797681093216, -0.00043353482033126056, -0.03316924721002579, -0.018409712240099907, -0.022098667919635773, -0.017999716103076935, 0.03882882371544838, -0.03950134664773941, -0.015354583971202374, 0.004783488344401121, 0.03426526486873627, 0.031287383288145065, -0.027820508927106857, -0.006129460409283638, -0.00905173271894455, 0.034081052988767624, 0.035526931285858154, -0.008752408437430859, -0.02031601592898369, -0.02877015247941017, 0.02276691608130932, -0.006940831895917654, -0.0016911181155592203, -0.026834268122911453, -0.01726335473358631, -0.06632053107023239, -0.004014918114989996, 0.004435142036527395, 0.016998257488012314, -0.019425049424171448, 0.029948296025395393, -0.05702932924032211, -0.02813313528895378, 0.0058700102381408215, 0.017471719533205032, 0.01643666997551918, -0.0016360327135771513, -0.012563247233629227, -0.08485030382871628, -0.006652363575994968, -0.0019882223568856716, -0.015676511451601982, 0.01823441870510578, -0.012826904654502869, -0.04073525592684746, -0.06265019625425339, -0.023818079382181168, 0.0562857948243618, -0.024717221036553383, 0.024485750123858452, 0.02172737568616867, 0.029599880799651146, -0.01729302853345871, -0.02444300428032875, -0.017331110313534737, -0.014620677568018436, -0.023186322301626205, -0.02008851245045662, 0.04359884187579155, 0.027400564402341843, 0.04606172442436218, 0.02092229761183262, 0.017125260084867477, -0.06842119246721268, -0.0557846799492836, -0.024208469316363335, 0.022466950118541718, -0.04699265584349632, 0.02336798422038555, 0.00007434554572682828, 0.01642192341387272, 0.05284015089273453, -0.04757073149085045, -0.006986791733652353, 0.027779236435890198, 0.051439736038446426, -0.013505721464753151, 0.02547234110534191, 0.00034792025689966977, -0.025041865184903145, 0.05697295069694519, -0.015287516638636589, -0.022857848554849625, -0.02189422957599163, -0.02337842434644699, -0.004722772631794214, -0.027834247797727585, -0.04771032929420471, 0.030704155564308167, 0.07197054475545883, 0.006990352179855108, 0.03806290775537491, -0.0007697526016272604, 0.017521874979138374, -0.0614701472222805, -0.018286405131220818, 0.03942826762795448, -0.011635790579020977, 0.014286869205534458, 0.005943662486970425, 0.036786362528800964, 0.049352265894412994, 0.029817795380949974, 0.026255309581756592, -0.06246892735362053, -0.012967472895979881, -0.01475237775593996, 0.05763150379061699, -0.014047598466277122, -0.011202337220311165, 0.017562340945005417, -0.009456674568355083, 0.0015004535671323538, 0.029062721878290176, -0.0012639667838811874, 0.022787217050790787, 0.017292246222496033, -0.008313757367432117, -0.007051908876746893, -0.06215581297874451, -0.027379516512155533, -0.0003450917429290712, 0.005122313741594553, 0.060125451534986496, -0.04198234900832176, -0.02753072790801525, -0.01673041842877865, 0.019984237849712372, -0.0575500912964344, -0.049531180411577225, -0.004991189111024141, -0.06358998268842697, 0.018693458288908005, 0.036872975528240204, 0.0025545998942106962, -0.039845094084739685, -0.05225866660475731, -0.060502052307128906, -0.07903727889060974, -0.07312016189098358, -0.012991161085665226, -0.05724874138832092, 0.02557346783578396, 0.05747499689459801, -0.04793098568916321, 0.04931330308318138, 0.007468417286872864, 0.02094988524913788, -0.011281132698059082, -0.07913928478956223, 0.021616816520690918, 0.02574833482503891, -0.03413913771510124, -0.010435120202600956, -0.010914287529885769, -0.014215830713510513, -0.002255479572340846, 0.014398652128875256, 0.037165943533182144, 0.01984311081469059, -0.013037685304880142, -0.027445876970887184, -0.03134916350245476, 0.03916153311729431, -0.02288050763309002, -0.011457346379756927, 0.029842594638466835, 0.03631092980504036, -0.015767943114042282, 0.01389636006206274, -0.04924376308917999, -0.0135945500805974, -0.05663948506116867, -0.005935358349233866, -0.022824378684163094, 0.04866766929626465, -0.02905835583806038, -0.002065704669803381, -0.01102475542575121, 0.03660597652196884, -0.009113859385251999, 0.04993155226111412, -0.0020343486685305834, 0.022104263305664062, 0.046037256717681885, 0.05954986438155174, -0.011073705740272999, -0.009939154610037804, 0.0026420303620398045, 0.0051711746491491795, -0.032020434737205505, -0.04759087413549423, -0.019517699256539345, 0.03389216586947441, 0.06592649221420288, 0.06921105086803436, 0.05726808309555054, -0.026364846155047417, -0.0638924092054367, -0.0507390983402729, -0.08141085505485535, -0.019074857234954834, 0.0012074555270373821, 0.011325533501803875, -0.029361924156546593, -0.058064673095941544, -0.0007592830224893987, -0.08022881299257278, 0.008794249966740608, -0.056892599910497665, -0.08044039458036423, 0.04968254268169403, 0.022004321217536926, -0.056468334048986435, 0.0026064300909638405, 0.0576484389603138, -0.004174561705440283, 0.007552896626293659, 0.035171907395124435, 0.00025728336186148226, 0.03585803508758545, 0.029281582683324814, -0.049353376030921936, 0.026406502351164818, -0.0010550563456490636, -0.05144985765218735, -0.02584768831729889, -0.018430860713124275, -0.03394678607583046, -0.08072570711374283, 0.05041784793138504, 0.03097648173570633, -0.03555290028452873, 0.053882502019405365, 0.026337390765547752, 0.03399474546313286, -0.014891045168042183, 0.09380220621824265, 0.0551467128098011, 0.06694624572992325, -0.01211790181696415, -0.008063025772571564, 0.016733568161725998, -0.026041772216558456, 0.044422198086977005, -0.01504851970821619, 0.0019068908877670765, -0.079511359333992, 0.04096494987607002, 0.05762552469968796, -0.03981281816959381, -0.007546533830463886, -0.018635937944054604, -0.07196927070617676, -0.056984685361385345, -0.021057406440377235, 0.020160207524895668, -0.03334222361445427, -0.03490026667714119, 0.02691938355565071, -0.02035115659236908, 0.04039276763796806, 0.017599208280444145, -0.08216783404350281, -0.03762078657746315, 0.011492869816720486, -0.001279978547245264, 0.0541408509016037, -0.040119122713804245, -0.0741347149014473, -0.06731497496366501, -0.00180573551915586, 0.07246650755405426, 0.03694450855255127, 0.028072450309991837, 0.003774794051423669, -0.05378534272313118, -0.004678430501371622, -0.05833663418889046, 0.025124624371528625, 0.02380441129207611, 0.0009346070582978427, -0.000048909667384577915, -0.015867551788687706, 0.01220721285790205, 0.006152777932584286, 0.0018849917687475681, -0.0004897240432910621, 0.011999178677797318, 0.06733258813619614, -0.02611982636153698, 0.02747710421681404, -0.011779573746025562, 0.02939756214618683, -0.012569605372846127, 0.0012561834882944822, -0.02524389512836933, -0.04312751069664955, -0.062095049768686295, -0.03292088955640793, -0.008652758784592152, -0.0286739319562912, -0.015378665179014206, -0.04698540270328522, 0.0328957661986351, 0.057857953011989594 ]
<p>I want to study relations between sites categories and species abundances through PCoA or CAP using vegan::capscale. For doing so, I overlay species scores on my ordination. However, I am getting confused with the different scaling options and their interpretation. From what I understood: With scaling=1, arrow shows the direction from the origin for which sites have larger abundances for this species. With scaling=2, we want to analyze the correlations among species. Species that have a small angle between their arrows are expected to be strongly positively correlated. With scaling=-2, const = sqrt(nrow(dune)-1), we get correlations between species and axes. This comes from <a href="https://stat.ethz.ch/pipermail/r-sig-ecology/2010-August/001448.html" rel="nofollow">Jari Oksanen</a>.</p> <p>I did compare the 3 different options (see codes below), differences seem to be only a matter of arrow length. Hence, by considering that the most important are the relative length of arrows (relative to each other), am I allowed to use scaling=-2 (species axes correlations) for both analyzing site-species associations and species-species correlations? One more questions, is there a well admitted threshold in the value of species-axes correlations, below which we consider that species are not correlated (I mean species don't differ in abundance across the sites, excluding the cases of non linear relationships). If yes, do this threshold change depending on the scaling method used and on either the ordination is constrained or not. Morover, if I want to overlay a vector for a quantitative environnemental variable, may I use also scaling=-2, from which correlation threshold?</p> <pre><code>library(vegan) library(ggplot2) library(grid) data(dune) data(dune.env) dune=sqrt(dune) mcap=capscale(dune~1,dist="bray") #PCoA #sites scores dims=c(1,2) site=scores(mcap,display="wa",choices=dims) site.env=cbind(site,dune.env) #spider for management levels dev.new();plot(mcap);coord_spider=with(dune.env,ordispider(mcap,Management,col="blue",label=F,choices=dims));dev.off() coord_spider=as.data.frame(cbind(coord_spider[,],site.env)) names(coord_spider)[1:4]=c("MDS1","MDS2","MDS1end","MDS2end") #species scores #scaling1 cor.min=0.6 #below this threshold, arrows will be not plotted because correlation is considered too much week cor_sp=as.data.frame(scores(mcap, dis="sp", scaling=1,choices=dims)) cor_sp$cor=with(cor_sp,sqrt(MDS1^2+MDS2^2)) cor_sp$sup=FALSE;cor_sp$sup[cor_sp$cor&gt;=cor.min]&lt;-TRUE cor_sp$lab=row.names(cor_sp) cor_sp=cor_sp[cor_sp$sup==TRUE,] cor_sp_s1=cor_sp #scaling2 cor.min=0.6 #below this threshold, arrows will be not plotted because correlation is considered too much week cor_sp=as.data.frame(scores(mcap, dis="sp", scaling=2,choices=dims)) cor_sp$cor=with(cor_sp,sqrt(MDS1^2+MDS2^2)) cor_sp$sup=FALSE;cor_sp$sup[cor_sp$cor&gt;=cor.min]&lt;-TRUE cor_sp$lab=row.names(cor_sp) cor_sp=cor_sp[cor_sp$sup==TRUE,] cor_sp_s2=cor_sp #scaling -2, correlations between species and axes #from Jari Oksanen at https://stat.ethz.ch/pipermail/r-sig-ecology/2010-August/001448.html cor.min=0.6 #below this threshold, arrows will be not plotted because correlation is considered too much week cor_sp=as.data.frame(scores(mcap, dis="sp", scaling=-2, const = sqrt(nrow(dune)-1),choices=dims)) cor_sp$cor=with(cor_sp,sqrt(MDS1^2+MDS2^2)) cor_sp$sup=FALSE;cor_sp$sup[cor_sp$cor&gt;=cor.min]&lt;-TRUE cor_sp$lab=row.names(cor_sp) cor_sp=cor_sp[cor_sp$sup==TRUE,] cor_sp_s3=cor_sp #plot mon.plot1=ggplot(data=site.env)+theme_bw()+ geom_point(aes(x=MDS1,y=MDS2,color=Management))# les sites #add spider mon.plot2=mon.plot1+ geom_segment(data=coord_spider,aes(x=MDS1,y=MDS2,xend=MDS1end,yend=MDS2end,colour=Management),lwd=0.5,alpha=1/3)+ geom_point(data=coord_spider,aes(x=MDS1,y=MDS2,colour=Management),cex=3,shape=19) #add species scores as vector #scaling1 mon.plot_s1=mon.plot2+ggtitle("Scaling 1")+ geom_point(aes(x=0,y=0),shape=21,fill="black",color="black",size=3)+#central point geom_segment(data=cor_sp_s1,aes(x=0,y=0,xend=MDS1,yend=MDS2),arrow = arrow(length = unit(0.3,"cm")))+#arrows geom_text(data = cor_sp_s1, aes(x = MDS1, y = MDS2, label = lab), size = 3)#labels #scaling2 mon.plot_s2=mon.plot2+ggtitle("Scaling 2")+ geom_point(aes(x=0,y=0),shape=21,fill="black",color="black",size=3)+#central point geom_segment(data=cor_sp_s2,aes(x=0,y=0,xend=MDS1,yend=MDS2),arrow = arrow(length = unit(0.3,"cm")))+#arrows geom_text(data = cor_sp_s2, aes(x = MDS1, y = MDS2, label = lab), size = 3)#labels #scaling -2, correlations between species and axes mon.plot_s3=mon.plot2+ggtitle("Scaling -2")+ geom_point(aes(x=0,y=0),shape=21,fill="black",color="black",size=3)+#central point geom_segment(data=cor_sp_s3,aes(x=0,y=0,xend=MDS1,yend=MDS2),arrow = arrow(length = unit(0.3,"cm")))+#arrows geom_text(data = cor_sp_s3, aes(x = MDS1, y = MDS2, label = lab), size = 3)#labels #plot everything grid.newpage() pushViewport(viewport(layout = grid.layout(2, 2))) print(mon.plot_s1,vp=viewport(layout.pos.row = 1, layout.pos.col = 1)) print(mon.plot_s2,vp=viewport(layout.pos.row = 2, layout.pos.col = 1)) print(mon.plot_s3,vp=viewport(layout.pos.row = 1, layout.pos.col = 2)) </code></pre>
g74030
[ 0.005482259672135115, -0.021309763193130493, -0.008099312894046307, -0.048143114894628525, 0.012544205412268639, -0.024417584761977196, 0.08267177641391754, -0.040672704577445984, -0.00933534000068903, 0.015275641344487667, 0.017430461943149567, 0.015621772967278957, 0.09262070804834366, -0.003521623555570841, -0.0011154103558510542, 0.010438438504934311, 0.03141789510846138, -0.006131419446319342, 0.020696589723229408, 0.012947244569659233, -0.043234825134277344, 0.01637321710586548, 0.022242648527026176, 0.011115452274680138, 0.03887704759836197, -0.02761453203856945, -0.011850811541080475, 0.008502543903887272, -0.08858820796012878, 0.008715497329831123, 0.012259823270142078, 0.053328171372413635, 0.018738742917776108, -0.0031257052905857563, 0.0024878818076103926, -0.016273820772767067, 0.021909210830926895, 0.0005293997237458825, -0.0025179574731737375, 0.05827333778142929, 0.01302739605307579, -0.029579736292362213, 0.050223156809806824, -0.011013408191502094, -0.04540282487869263, -0.03695421293377876, -0.03421388939023018, -0.02885047160089016, 0.06064398214221001, -0.015059812925755978, -0.007817215286195278, 0.06639818847179413, 0.01862265169620514, -0.024765651673078537, 0.01565100997686386, 0.07043790817260742, 0.018464280292391777, 0.04953766241669655, -0.0020004466641694307, 0.03853694722056389, 0.012282676063477993, 0.012703577987849712, 0.006946241017431021, 0.041002701967954636, 0.054734304547309875, 0.004402929916977882, -0.011975777335464954, -0.04522705078125, -0.03639007732272148, -0.09827876091003418, -0.02097407355904579, -0.0551951639354229, 0.029974697157740593, -0.022778159007430077, -0.040386538952589035, -0.03195643797516823, 0.01319432258605957, -0.008395546115934849, 0.03108019381761551, 0.028838420286774635, 0.004955227021127939, 0.019073832780122757, -0.0168765839189291, 0.04701004549860954, 0.05309108644723892, 0.005669530015438795, 0.00301862764172256, -0.02465498074889183, 0.034893862903118134, 0.023194506764411926, 0.03768257796764374, 0.012186647392809391, 0.03104202076792717, 0.024494880810379982, -0.028028199449181557, 0.027878405526280403, -0.05205406993627548, -0.023519808426499367, 0.005306494887918234, -0.05015027895569801, -0.01500547956675291, 0.04883946105837822, 0.03275628387928009, 0.015487437136471272, -0.07864563912153244, 0.0050422633066773415, 0.0155807975679636, -0.012828308157622814, -0.014191471971571445, 0.021183408796787262, -0.0778619572520256, 0.0031999575439840555, -0.07496214658021927, 0.015342610888183117, -0.00903658289462328, -0.07748720049858093, 0.05493317171931267, -0.032079216092824936, 0.0033665902446955442, -0.025024397298693657, 0.06574967503547668, -0.01798238605260849, 0.03643222525715828, 0.024589434266090393, -0.03864656388759613, -0.004136763047426939, 0.019312603399157524, 0.030955148860812187, 0.012471276335418224, -0.06788773834705353, 0.019676193594932556, -0.031192533671855927, -0.044498294591903687, 0.07893414795398712, 0.00045015595969744027, -0.015941660851240158, -0.04176560416817665, 0.024026991799473763, -0.022383812814950943, -0.008589477278292179, -0.08694390207529068, 0.00548067782074213, 0.024824952706694603, -0.039769578725099564, -0.031320806592702866, -0.003054042113944888, 0.033237189054489136, -0.0002830578596331179, 0.08278650790452957, -0.008028926327824593, 0.04183029755949974, 0.05385279655456543, -0.086112841963768, 0.002175974892452359, -0.04829535260796547, 0.03653518110513687, -0.010701077990233898, -0.03756038844585419, -0.036885183304548264, 0.0019017973681911826, 0.002457275753840804, -0.007255760487169027, 0.0972905233502388, 0.009930343367159367, -0.012303007766604424, -0.03844168409705162, 0.05418689548969269, -0.060743290930986404, -0.04515441507101059, 0.020024312660098076, -0.02229698747396469, 0.019264040514826775, 0.07277341187000275, -0.035682860761880875, 0.008347656577825546, 0.05157603695988655, 0.07589572668075562, -0.006757273338735104, 0.04172316938638687, -0.0026161030400544405, -0.024652743712067604, -0.0008134996751323342, 0.0006088134250603616, 0.030299322679638863, 0.05857790634036064, -0.018414178863167763, 0.03741472214460373, 0.008395220153033733, -0.02363915555179119, -0.006497278343886137, -0.0011527411406859756, -0.06000049412250519, -0.05652632191777229, -0.01535747479647398, -0.030889077112078667, -0.012101392261683941, -0.0068917241878807545, -0.03696247562766075, -0.03063395619392395, -0.076322041451931, 0.015349533408880234, -0.00001888735823740717, -0.07816652208566666, 0.0698617547750473, -0.03586537390947342, 0.013971319422125816, -0.044029351323843, 0.0032242422457784414, -0.027473697438836098, 0.021900007501244545, -0.015256996266543865, -0.03982854261994362, -0.057915013283491135, 0.053854089230298996, -0.027913469821214676, -0.010866736061871052, 0.01312208641320467, 0.009879929944872856, -0.05529676005244255, 0.028685472905635834, 0.04249695688486099, -0.08594296872615814, 0.0013782363384962082, -0.04150444641709328, 0.010160405188798904, 0.0521036721765995, -0.011018526740372181, 0.03012257069349289, 0.02173527330160141, 0.01893952116370201, -0.05240708217024803, 0.023667244240641594, -0.007446312811225653, -0.07985180616378784, -0.026967298239469528, 0.026141468435525894, 0.019453464075922966, 0.004997395444661379, -0.020251575857400894, -0.0035925302654504776, 0.031947698444128036, -0.017154905945062637, -0.03544962406158447, 0.03904283791780472, 0.03498339280486107, 0.027721554040908813, 0.0331055149435997, 0.0010702809086069465, -0.0014812815934419632, 0.06194445490837097, -0.011830552481114864, 0.03380675986409187, 0.03650961443781853, 0.04264761134982109, 0.021532360464334488, -0.01204503234475851, 0.015828551724553108, -0.0018827806925401092, 0.01790660060942173, 0.02063596434891224, 0.025449972599744797, -0.012807462364435196, 0.02007792890071869, -0.017395980656147003, 0.04378664866089821, -0.03037375956773758, -0.03850289061665535, -0.026095937937498093, -0.010764369741082191, -0.04762258753180504, 0.009920068085193634, -0.011928203515708447, -0.041482601314783096, -0.018782826140522957, 0.018007757142186165, 0.07293955981731415, 0.0039355033077299595, -0.0011682650074362755, 0.03049101121723652, 0.029173051938414574, -0.018614012748003006, -0.03031744435429573, -0.002544090384617448, 0.018894312903285027, 0.04776453971862793, 0.023995419964194298, 0.03580630198121071, 0.005680662579834461, -0.008217661641538143, 0.02475597709417343, 0.01436046976596117, -0.007550266571342945, -0.04137158766388893, 0.029051687568426132, 0.012580893002450466, -0.027978451922535896, 0.03982989117503166, -0.05468835309147835, 0.038978688418865204, 0.01752416230738163, -0.021401986479759216, -0.021091176196932793, 0.035548996180295944, 0.005721638444811106, 0.09824904054403305, 0.006838994566351175, -0.03046226128935814, -0.013471283949911594, 0.014833071269094944, 0.05849572271108627, -0.007008288986980915, -0.042165882885456085, 0.004870552569627762, -0.026138095185160637, 0.03060486726462841, 0.024123910814523697, -0.006522371433675289, 0.009187331423163414, -0.012930819764733315, -0.05026880279183388, -0.031777601689100266, -0.004683551844209433, -0.02051614224910736, 0.019231397658586502, -0.014827149920165539, 0.007809656672179699, -0.05654532462358475, 0.015085897408425808, -0.021729011088609695, 0.03534694015979767, 0.023366082459688187, 0.059945546090602875, 0.0574684776365757, 0.01769023761153221, -0.03593311831355095, -0.022770846262574196, -0.07882792502641678, -0.018356693908572197, -0.006734136957675219, -0.004425596911460161, -0.08171409368515015, -0.02967081591486931, -0.011742948554456234, -0.034519828855991364, -0.02689150907099247, 0.034670401364564896, 0.046481721103191376, 0.0262053944170475, -0.039626073092222214, -0.05595766380429268, -0.03363664075732231, -0.03260982781648636, 0.016281170770525932, 0.01029960811138153, -0.00593380443751812, -0.0013649101601913571, 0.030241116881370544, -0.0253730621188879, -0.019067682325839996, 0.04629364609718323, 0.01863725855946541, -0.003504414577037096, -0.04762372747063637, -0.037782538682222366, 0.020085901021957397, 0.06518188863992691, 0.029711846262216568, 0.056329164654016495, 0.04059378802776337, -0.021278273314237595, 0.0373985730111599, -0.04041339457035065, 0.024561768397688866, -0.05027075484395027, -0.0036216313019394875, 0.01706325076520443, 0.03823705390095711, 0.03647477924823761, 0.0013089602580294013, 0.01796184480190277, 0.027710825204849243, -0.012191002257168293, 0.036778662353754044, -0.06436538696289062, -0.013308396562933922, -0.03970523923635483, 0.024858728051185608, -0.010439863428473473, -0.033806316554546356, -0.014928094111382961, -0.03993326425552368, -0.05692143738269806, -0.05419526621699333, 0.036296743899583817, 0.04464811459183693, -0.04517960175871849, 0.0007692915387451649, 0.06340442597866058, 0.043114762753248215, 0.06763895601034164, -0.01975967176258564, -0.051873449236154556, 0.03193714842200279, 0.00450820941478014, -0.04390980675816536, -0.017917290329933167, -0.04547465220093727, 0.009427279233932495, -0.05955437198281288, -0.003551888046786189, -0.008392415940761566, 0.008609316311776638, 0.008284630253911018, -0.012912117876112461, -0.01242204662412405, -0.027052713558077812, 0.03938465192914009, -0.009872515685856342, -0.018470585346221924, -0.0038035556208342314, -0.010328587144613266, 0.05914057418704033, 0.0523327998816967, -0.06948000192642212, 0.004586160648614168, 0.00888221338391304, -0.062145527452230453, -0.020497946068644524, 0.05119950696825981, 0.06980118900537491, -0.01755867898464203, 0.04596022889018059, 0.01770438253879547, -0.028757870197296143, -0.05420149862766266, 0.050378791987895966, -0.009432286955416203, 0.0030394408386200666, 0.011211739853024483, -0.044701192528009415, -0.029196321964263916, -0.0008733263239264488, 0.0011034277267754078, -0.03817325830459595, -0.011992251500487328, 0.005758955609053373, -0.010183615610003471, -0.014031444676220417, 0.0067345076240599155, 0.006650860421359539, 0.023659760132431984, 0.03348167613148689, 0.03868299350142479, -0.064399853348732, 0.04490700364112854, -0.0388169102370739, 0.041599638760089874, 0.02073238044977188, 0.008967188186943531, -0.051260631531476974, -0.005810366477817297, 0.044308509677648544, -0.06580276787281036, -0.0857863649725914, 0.03803142532706261, -0.0017189871286973357, -0.03736182674765587, 0.0365949384868145, 0.01241013128310442, 0.010062654502689838, 0.009022904559969902, -0.0363234244287014, 0.022054113447666168, -0.005121191963553429, 0.013236269354820251, 0.060515668243169785, 0.04092711582779884, -0.005640685558319092, -0.007489332929253578, -0.017952952533960342, -0.04233880713582039, -0.01666596531867981, 0.0009414858068339527, 0.0031046730000525713, 0.007129710633307695, -0.04219965636730194, 0.03639528527855873, -0.07480360567569733, 0.02741563320159912, 0.08608236163854599, 0.012327625416219234, -0.014170232228934765, -0.0410362184047699, 0.07245338708162308, 0.0013519064523279667, -0.02076687477529049, 0.012651896104216576, -0.05730999633669853, 0.0429038442671299, -0.06719131022691727, 0.011071838438510895, 0.04286446049809456, -0.030529150739312172, 0.044608596712350845, -0.00940446462482214, -0.011175139807164669, 0.08845119178295135, -0.017599917948246002, 0.03669091314077377, 0.01126993540674448, -0.012161904014647007, 0.0814199447631836, 0.08409786224365234, 0.02064853347837925, -0.02701406180858612, -0.042074404656887054, 0.028184622526168823, 0.04340224713087082, -0.0713559165596962, -0.014288049191236496, 0.05290006846189499, 0.007788420654833317, 0.007172227371484041, -0.04155914485454559, -0.0003075352869927883, -0.001547246822156012, -0.0006617754697799683, -0.0413917601108551, 0.04375893250107765, -0.008105157874524593, -0.04804075136780739, 0.06005280092358589, -0.049563031643629074, -0.003984739072620869, 0.0020458169747143984, -0.07115262746810913, -0.07745658606290817, 0.02942712977528572, 0.01845717802643776, -0.024566413834691048, -0.005915605928748846, 0.0035984579008072615, 0.03492949903011322, -0.02217562310397625, -0.02816924825310707, -0.06750522553920746, -0.019667351618409157, -0.03776901587843895, -0.006032752338796854, 0.006318170111626387, -0.026682483032345772, -0.02727251872420311, 0.0013895872980356216, 0.012092694640159607, -0.013857471756637096, 0.0024134921841323376, 0.0239346232265234, 0.02320892922580242, 0.01266033761203289, 0.0010383615735918283, 0.03978260979056358, -0.008261384442448616, 0.044345781207084656, 0.006029780954122543, -0.024649742990732193, -0.013535874895751476, -0.04251134395599365, 0.00756602268666029, 0.014079624786973, 0.04561441391706467, -0.007585540413856506, -0.04179002344608307, 0.050837934017181396, 0.042525410652160645, 0.03449831157922745, 0.09240053594112396, -0.03363059088587761, 0.030575662851333618, 0.006675488781183958, -0.02942594699561596, 0.037771593779325485, -0.021338772028684616, -0.029386384412646294, 0.017607374116778374, -0.03373231366276741, 0.027337804436683655, -0.03621217980980873, -0.010359388776123524, -0.004502768162637949, -0.061642326414585114, -0.005960528273135424, 0.015093443915247917, -0.03891373053193092, -0.00498925568535924, -0.041428342461586, -0.023817798122763634, -0.035666175186634064, 0.0259944349527359, 0.014043109491467476, 0.045613743364810944, 0.05794568359851837, 0.0015189877012744546, 0.029454685747623444, -0.0005964755546301603, 0.02379949763417244, 0.0317959226667881, -0.06162894144654274, 0.02253536507487297, 0.006503880489617586, 0.01386875007301569, -0.004041872452944517, 0.0491497777402401, 0.05287587642669678, 0.09047728031873703, 0.004928254056721926, 0.009352853521704674, -0.04059150069952011, -0.03916076570749283, -0.07652195543050766, 0.03240365535020828, 0.007392643950879574, -0.0029528008308261633, -0.019286537542939186, 0.01776955835521221, -0.000006289339580689557, 0.025072131305933, 0.02228630520403385, -0.0011489157332107425, 0.01183964405208826, -0.0217321515083313, -0.024653680622577667, 0.07533006370067596, 0.0000850842334330082, -0.045886971056461334, -0.03500577434897423, -0.0036740158684551716, -0.048971302807331085, 0.07019112259149551, 0.057315643876791, 0.09197480976581573, -0.004914214368909597, 0.029384491965174675, 0.0012477292912080884, -0.016322912648320198, 0.1023186668753624, -0.011474293656647205, 0.01901113986968994, -0.027259916067123413, -0.051457956433296204, 0.00852703396230936, -0.004248064011335373, 0.04553850367665291, -0.004280535038560629, -0.028783101588487625, 0.0541989840567112, -0.010887328535318375, 0.03299057111144066, 0.044642940163612366, 0.020579032599925995, 0.02981472760438919, -0.0467999204993248, -0.000993126886896789, -0.005323175340890884, 0.04785040020942688, -0.05208443105220795, 0.05467548593878746, 0.004049314651638269, 0.020587265491485596, -0.07284318655729294, -0.023907940834760666, -0.023106282576918602, -0.020453376695513725, 0.020608512684702873, 0.04295000806450844, 0.02456478402018547, 0.0045805079862475395, -0.019186628982424736, -0.018192129209637642, -0.033974844962358475, 0.0029406133107841015, 0.03143845126032829, -0.02691715769469738, 0.027946127578616142, -0.053537242114543915, -0.049007803201675415, 0.0069200568832457066, -0.019219093024730682, -0.06577247381210327, 0.024950936436653137, -0.04737056791782379, -0.06339549273252487, -0.041473519057035446, 0.006410178262740374, 0.010561803355813026, 0.015998145565390587, -0.0009683846728876233, 0.026598064228892326, 0.016602646559476852, 0.01928642950952053, 0.0742117390036583, 0.07147547602653503, 0.0018518019933253527, -0.034563228487968445, 0.0024410614278167486, 0.036084357649087906, -0.002671755151823163, 0.04344974458217621, -0.0007392130210064352, -0.03022507019340992, -0.08561233431100845, -0.08322818577289581, 0.024406803771853447, -0.03137918561697006, 0.041449785232543945, -0.03603905439376831, 0.003577606054022908, 0.0057639931328594685, -0.0011854292824864388, -0.018471112474799156, 0.006825484335422516, -0.06768510490655899, -0.007320330012589693, 0.01022774912416935, -0.014494619332253933, 0.011385835707187653, -0.04427308589220047, 0.027418233454227448, 0.011174705810844898, -0.04047204181551933, -0.013042827136814594, -0.01758476532995701, -0.02422233857214451, -0.03598488122224808, 0.034656181931495667, -0.020036298781633377, 0.003724405076354742, -0.0037184646353125572, 0.017186125740408897, -0.07784086465835571, -0.01086069829761982, -0.000980130396783352, -0.010354437865316868, -0.0002620236191432923, 0.06022043153643608, -0.007542838808149099, 0.030564622953534126, 0.016405975446105003, 0.021373683586716652, -0.02760615199804306, 0.0016226201551035047, -0.027439730241894722, 0.029175149276852608, 0.009229720570147038, 0.009816505014896393, 0.016493501141667366, 0.027178816497325897, -0.014212322421371937, -0.0367032065987587, 0.02653961256146431, -0.004599661100655794, 0.013924416154623032, -0.02061501331627369, -0.04446423798799515, -0.010369089432060719, -0.03973790630698204, -0.034836769104003906, -0.12490192800760269, 0.02821926958858967 ]
<p>This is probably going to sound extremely stupid, but it's part of a larger question, about sample distribution of means, that I'm having problems understanding, so please bear with me.</p> <p>If I record the time between planes landing, and have 250 observations, are those 250 observations my "population", or does the term "population" refer to all the values, i.e. if I had sat there till the end of time recording?</p> <p>I'm assuming its the latter but just want to double check.</p>
g74031
[ -0.03210582956671715, 0.02105712890625, -0.01797422766685486, -0.05482646822929382, 0.0031204705592244864, 0.0013026235392317176, 0.02185679040849209, 0.002242924179881811, -0.034459177404642105, -0.04404660314321518, -0.034550584852695465, -0.021002553403377533, 0.005132532678544521, 0.04570653662085533, -0.001171266078017652, -0.028692815452814102, 0.048191994428634644, -0.06541521102190018, 0.000025563507733750157, 0.041280463337898254, 0.005664603319019079, -0.0033618342131376266, -0.044860921800136566, 0.035205405205488205, -0.012722274288535118, -0.027214815840125084, -0.02248789742588997, 0.049861833453178406, -0.0752684473991394, -0.04486505687236786, 0.022603312507271767, -0.0017494501080363989, 0.02579575777053833, 0.038174986839294434, -0.03393940255045891, -0.07014983147382736, -0.02420889213681221, -0.01469938550144434, 0.02720806375145912, -0.017975054681301117, 0.0467398576438427, -0.011158093810081482, 0.05687737837433815, -0.06253976374864578, 0.018713079392910004, 0.05150202661752701, -0.06641086935997009, 0.03884078562259674, 0.006345219444483519, -0.013715163804590702, 0.01222432404756546, 0.01402138639241457, -0.02959740348160267, 0.06900417804718018, 0.028409479185938835, -0.0054646143689751625, 0.008090658113360405, -0.03299564868211746, 0.03194594755768776, 0.027983734384179115, 0.034806232899427414, 0.000733064953237772, -0.05720372498035431, 0.057786472141742706, 0.03359335660934448, 0.08240968734025955, -0.03458762541413307, -0.027059124782681465, 0.10992872714996338, -0.03195248544216156, -0.007197805680334568, -0.008971871808171272, -0.00019653802155517042, -0.02991132065653801, -0.061921123415231705, 0.01149839535355568, -0.0147813456133008, 0.03283345326781273, 0.02313241735100746, 0.055191267281770706, -0.012527159415185452, -0.039368581026792526, 0.0022249852772802114, 0.00014343320799525827, 0.06391444802284241, 0.0374801829457283, -0.0009186372626572847, -0.05193280801177025, 0.017515381798148155, 0.05899509787559509, 0.012391350232064724, -0.03225952014327049, 0.10249172896146774, 0.059642914682626724, -0.011044081300497055, 0.0007211416959762573, -0.030892562121152878, 0.06544355303049088, -0.05431491881608963, 0.060689527541399, -0.028402438387274742, 0.023297661915421486, -0.03777159005403519, -0.05545242130756378, -0.009788709692656994, -0.022423090413212776, -0.022417981177568436, 0.04059482738375664, 0.009525826200842857, -0.034559741616249084, -0.044269219040870667, -0.004297615960240364, 0.01309017650783062, 0.0612061470746994, -0.05098098888993263, -0.011094572953879833, -0.009832048788666725, 0.009701377712190151, -0.06029132008552551, 0.01447440404444933, 0.050321128219366074, -0.038189034909009933, -0.008411761373281479, 0.009278541430830956, -0.03771365061402321, 0.02785686030983925, -0.008902577683329582, 0.03411494940519333, -0.04131849482655525, 0.04579319804906845, -0.012814662419259548, -0.00277501717209816, 0.028946353122591972, 0.0530984103679657, 0.02142384648323059, -0.01900072582066059, 0.00843772478401661, 0.03574748337268829, -0.01733856089413166, 0.03439256548881531, 0.02926735021173954, 0.0063856299966573715, 0.06662359833717346, -0.05469744652509689, -0.02847742661833763, 0.05121031403541565, -0.045550260692834854, -0.0576954148709774, 0.01598978042602539, 0.00488958228379488, -0.01640857569873333, 0.034296102821826935, -0.004464285913854837, -0.02053280919790268, -0.03468174487352371, -0.030497319996356964, -0.02903781458735466, 0.015100348740816116, 0.020516999065876007, 0.04787253588438034, 0.06788531690835953, -0.045404426753520966, 0.006399893667548895, 0.02761451154947281, -0.03371661156415939, 0.020970191806554794, 0.0033958100248128176, -0.055153246968984604, 0.002689643297344446, -0.014983507804572582, -0.005377687979489565, 0.022173462435603142, 0.0030410918407142162, -0.04741465672850609, 0.06520111858844757, 0.003430214012041688, 0.058824293315410614, 0.014305584132671356, 0.051810167729854584, 0.012908289209008217, 0.018305201083421707, -0.000628660898655653, -0.023832660168409348, -0.076347716152668, 0.016786890104413033, -0.04966200888156891, -0.004986411426216364, -0.05898606777191162, -0.0367545560002327, 0.020859645679593086, 0.0038009488489478827, -0.07599238306283951, -0.00703566987067461, 0.017106560990214348, -0.06084777042269707, -0.031359635293483734, 0.05831076204776764, -0.05440441519021988, -0.025633715093135834, -0.02878095768392086, 0.046239499002695084, -0.0027312154415994883, -0.03900435194373131, -0.002543241949751973, -0.04785854369401932, 0.020060669630765915, 0.035251911729574203, 0.02445339411497116, -0.0717025026679039, 0.019539015367627144, 0.006949471775442362, -0.03027368150651455, -0.015506074763834476, 0.08055562525987625, -0.05700530856847763, 0.03428419306874275, -0.02306419610977173, 0.00010660963016562164, 0.07159192860126495, -0.03388131409883499, -0.02775026112794876, 0.0053513445891439915, 0.002242704387754202, -0.017846055328845978, 0.06371018290519714, 0.02240207977592945, 0.010261437855660915, -0.025421401485800743, 0.03200633451342583, 0.030783282592892647, -0.030154390260577202, -0.03408197686076164, 0.008468822576105595, -0.039070844650268555, 0.01696229912340641, 0.045056626200675964, 0.03829542547464371, 0.02470654994249344, -0.002068802248686552, -0.03313155844807625, -0.05150187388062477, -0.0015629478730261326, 0.0018067376222461462, 0.0578862726688385, -0.05322770029306412, -0.0008976856479421258, -0.010219440795481205, -0.015214493498206139, 0.07151840627193451, 0.051073528826236725, 0.0131323067471385, -0.009082133881747723, 0.024337038397789, 0.008405494503676891, 0.027445517480373383, -0.05202097073197365, -0.017568716779351234, 0.01222304254770279, -0.042646367102861404, 0.018108932301402092, -0.022177988663315773, -0.04576057568192482, 0.007281589787453413, -0.015276756137609482, 0.010556969791650772, -0.028328441083431244, 0.027586741372942924, 0.07297690212726593, 0.047078970819711685, 0.005433517042547464, 0.016879970207810402, -0.007746842224150896, 0.0322788804769516, 0.06781613081693649, 0.02756294049322605, -0.0038877353072166443, -0.030656883493065834, -0.028689539059996605, 0.017271365970373154, -0.036309756338596344, 0.00445560971274972, -0.008868657052516937, -0.011547258123755455, 0.0019088081317022443, 0.044559843838214874, -0.015920041128993034, 0.028256013989448547, 0.013224310241639614, 0.018187591806054115, -0.011997818015515804, -0.009560642763972282, 0.001722182147204876, 0.10503606498241425, -0.01276914682239294, -0.06221619248390198, 0.010074488818645477, 0.0763721764087677, -0.0022892472334206104, 0.0559617355465889, 0.01990150660276413, -0.0483383946120739, -0.03483910858631134, 0.048307038843631744, -0.0199976097792387, 0.02583269216120243, 0.061793968081474304, 0.001015735906548798, -0.033151645213365555, -0.022442400455474854, -0.07071223109960556, -0.011603254824876785, -0.004248179495334625, -0.0071129994466900826, -0.053625814616680145, -0.013625015504658222, 0.01931462623178959, -0.009951664134860039, 0.018731167539954185, -0.0428062342107296, -0.046845488250255585, 0.0069946413859725, 0.016217665746808052, -0.027269504964351654, 0.025267940014600754, 0.012980293482542038, 0.02378210425376892, -0.010181412100791931, 0.029954059049487114, 0.003029655199497938, -0.009956978261470795, -0.03441008925437927, -0.018876006826758385, -0.008030646480619907, -0.018636832013726234, 0.005009403917938471, -0.03444256633520126, -0.011708548292517662, 0.030040064826607704, 0.03580746054649353, 0.05221486836671829, 0.02091095969080925, 0.0008963842410594225, 0.012783421203494072, -0.0033996934071183205, 0.02506273053586483, -0.05936867371201515, -0.0033892816863954067, 0.006515446584671736, 0.013586781919002533, -0.001261646393686533, 0.01934722065925598, 0.014139861799776554, -0.027213992550969124, -0.025293923914432526, 0.018356068059802055, 0.05654822662472725, 0.018548566848039627, -0.05962907522916794, 0.045737531036138535, 0.018610451370477676, 0.03792385384440422, -0.008956192061305046, 0.011775445193052292, -0.01730482280254364, -0.010908612981438637, -0.05251828581094742, -0.04735809192061424, 0.056323517113924026, 0.043657198548316956, -0.06870695948600769, -0.021917233243584633, 0.023540079593658447, -0.0153873972594738, 0.042518384754657745, -0.047880563884973526, -0.06690958887338638, 0.05365455150604248, 0.0121125103905797, -0.008658692240715027, 0.014631913974881172, 0.0794219970703125, 0.020552057772874832, 0.020262446254491806, -0.005370647646486759, 0.0500362366437912, -0.0005845081177540123, 0.0147161353379488, -0.016199687495827675, -0.012551841326057911, -0.017206665128469467, -0.03501598909497261, -0.08882452547550201, -0.057599157094955444, -0.02058928646147251, 0.020770831033587456, -0.02843623422086239, -0.038963764905929565, 0.005451101344078779, 0.04167524725198746, 0.04369504749774933, 0.014539866708219051, 0.03480910137295723, 0.020585205405950546, 0.030923519283533096, 0.014609623700380325, 0.058346349745988846, -0.009385219775140285, -0.010949875228106976, 0.009098428301513195, 0.035359933972358704, -0.0362885408103466, -0.024501457810401917, -0.030314790084958076, -0.06186557561159134, 0.04822241887450218, 0.04319160059094429, 0.05536491796374321, -0.012328697368502617, -0.008293846622109413, 0.039949674159288406, 0.014491011388599873, -0.04810985177755356, 0.007222509011626244, -0.07776746898889542, -0.050746724009513855, 0.03901127725839615, -0.06463560461997986, 0.05834643170237541, -0.041008394211530685, -0.040058743208646774, 0.016036497429013252, 0.03345205634832382, 0.02728085219860077, 0.0738353282213211, -0.0392536036670208, 0.03482426330447197, 0.005884137470275164, -0.03119192272424698, 0.024977989494800568, -0.06427369266748428, -0.00887122843414545, -0.026331927627325058, -0.06599026918411255, 0.025966979563236237, -0.05003564804792404, 0.006242299452424049, -0.00792741309851408, -0.05255226418375969, 0.06172716245055199, 0.0429295115172863, -0.005938094574958086, 0.04463616758584976, -0.06605025380849838, -0.00601325836032629, 0.026321137323975563, -0.03698837384581566, 0.013701800256967545, 0.027447916567325592, 0.02441379800438881, 0.017916522920131683, -0.030092773959040642, -0.038127969950437546, -0.016758820042014122, -0.01064274087548256, -0.0019832581747323275, 0.019184892997145653, -0.02722994051873684, -0.014574992470443249, -0.011813578195869923, -0.02275736816227436, -0.0425276905298233, -0.029545260593295097, -0.022956034168601036, -0.006179897114634514, 0.0003369801852386445, 0.019334323704242706, -0.03472435474395752, 0.008292152546346188, 0.018951628357172012, -0.036900803446769714, 0.022009946405887604, -0.05502612888813019, -0.03169216960668564, -0.024187900125980377, 0.029177982360124588, 0.004001804161816835, 0.025904828682541847, -0.0786629170179367, 0.0371059849858284, -0.006821580696851015, 0.017514405772089958, -0.03985913097858429, 0.03581725060939789, 0.012528140097856522, -0.01428950671106577, -0.03244835138320923, -0.030614156275987625, -0.08326942473649979, -0.01621326617896557, -0.07298582047224045, 0.020914213731884956, 0.06399725377559662, 0.02418341301381588, -0.000276601524092257, -0.025528671219944954, 0.041389234364032745, -0.0011974365916103125, -0.016847318038344383, 0.03360440582036972, 0.07660580426454544, -0.04548055678606033, 0.01336913462728262, 0.02160315029323101, 0.018350061029195786, 0.011799462139606476, -0.00441922340542078, -0.004744378384202719, 0.07249346375465393, -0.0315459705889225, 0.03736782819032669, 0.02475057914853096, -0.0044758194126188755, 0.05291183292865753, 0.014208990149199963, -0.08378729969263077, -0.0936875194311142, -0.03186975419521332, -0.02607675828039646, 0.037341415882110596, -0.005004976410418749, -0.0009304736158810556, 0.01569630391895771, 0.029519962146878242, -0.010692084208130836, -0.011498073115944862, 0.0026497847866266966, -0.057331837713718414, 0.0017755486769601703, 0.06329341232776642, -0.0027754332404583693, -0.05618822202086449, 0.07714789360761642, 0.014247561804950237, -0.0025855523999780416, 0.03305625542998314, 0.0017850131262093782, -0.041514184325933456, -0.0437978059053421, 0.0792861133813858, 0.042060744017362595, -0.03463473916053772, 0.006188697647303343, -0.00508508738130331, 0.02212994545698166, -0.02210232987999916, 0.06165551021695137, -0.034257590770721436, 0.03249181807041168, 0.00398579565808177, 0.04180348291993141, -0.016575461253523827, 0.024085715413093567, 0.027799511328339577, 0.03669621795415878, 0.04036509990692139, 0.004183598328381777, -0.027167867869138718, 0.0011455175699666142, -0.03217238187789917, -0.056867361068725586, 0.07983041554689407, -0.036795202642679214, 0.021753164008259773, -0.0005504431901499629, 0.014315438456833363, 0.05844145640730858, 0.04406925290822983, 0.020817570388317108, -0.015145602636039257, 0.0008761610952205956, -0.039104562252759933, -0.08507988601922989, 0.009642316028475761, -0.028663896024227142, -0.026825791224837303, 0.011699982918798923, 0.01284217368811369, -0.01783035509288311, -0.05461755767464638, -0.00036120324512012303, 0.014204333536326885, -0.002734800800681114, -0.017870761454105377, -0.00445699505507946, -0.0009557870798744261, -0.0024539600126445293, -0.003522909479215741, -0.021944167092442513, -0.0019930999260395765, -0.016649924218654633, 0.06239771097898483, -0.0308929905295372, 0.06284326314926147, -0.08301354199647903, 0.022559789940714836, 0.003776870435103774, -0.004363733343780041, -0.00829862430691719, 0.04383265972137451, -0.0018453437369316816, -0.03337863087654114, 0.048368316143751144, 0.03673752024769783, 0.03695053979754448, -0.03246410936117172, -0.004813467152416706, -0.04079936817288399, -0.027182739228010178, -0.00022595690097659826, 0.0304470956325531, 0.03686342015862465, -0.0209833774715662, -0.001919871661812067, 0.02614433504641056, 0.023225147277116776, 0.03499096632003784, 0.022851359099149704, -0.017742007970809937, 0.06286812573671341, 0.031826723366975784, 0.015735285356640816, -0.012424017302691936, -0.03599533066153526, 0.009535341523587704, -0.03921084105968475, 0.04712986573576927, -0.015566438436508179, 0.029110999777913094, 0.04281166195869446, -0.022773656994104385, -0.01790250465273857, 0.010637096129357815, -0.024916116148233414, -0.03794592246413231, -0.025240259245038033, -0.011213326826691628, 0.016310861334204674, -0.020388932898640633, -0.020316237583756447, -0.01186719723045826, -0.047276969999074936, 0.011125635355710983, 0.041336651891469955, 0.035178206861019135, 0.059763103723526, 0.057600025087594986, 0.05291794613003731, -0.024297503754496574, 0.013034257106482983, -0.023518869653344154, -0.0020478602964431047, -0.014361320063471794, -0.1343248188495636, -0.0014693980338051915, -0.03374658524990082, 0.043524663895368576, 0.010090810246765614, -0.06677526980638504, -0.02648921310901642, -0.05389297753572464, 0.004361594561487436, 0.011428825557231903, -0.020782141014933586, -0.04422915726900101, -0.006254472769796848, -0.010953018441796303, 0.0364980585873127, 0.02242555469274521, -0.012629644945263863, 0.04691915214061737, 0.017731258645653725, -0.026484539732336998, -0.024896031245589256, 0.004430339206010103, -0.04959528148174286, 0.027469821274280548, -0.06514500826597214, -0.06080446392297745, 0.00692803505808115, -0.0720938965678215, -0.02267911657691002, 0.019820958375930786, 0.02682170644402504, -0.024628646671772003, -0.027915485203266144, -0.04460470378398895, 0.03646363690495491, -0.016723722219467163, 0.016180770471692085, -0.0026477097999304533, 0.006392854731529951, 0.050051718950271606, 0.02949809469282627, 0.01693860813975334, 0.023269103839993477, -0.046982187777757645, 0.003513275645673275, 0.01735742762684822, -0.02044273354113102, -0.051079586148262024, 0.0014128800248727202, -0.020358840003609657, 0.01512522529810667, 0.05873671919107437, -0.03394729644060135, -0.05891997367143631, -0.049549661576747894, -0.04832214489579201, 0.0005584426689893007, -0.03133520856499672, -0.012154103256762028, 0.033380813896656036, -0.005055061541497707, -0.05844076722860336, -0.015018348582088947, -0.025874033570289612, -0.02934647724032402, 0.06703170388936996, 0.02615305595099926, -0.006361589767038822, -0.01811990700662136, 0.0015934532275423408, -0.051950205117464066, -0.005802675150334835, 0.03518357872962952, 0.03502214699983597, 0.08167463541030884, -0.030402719974517822, -0.006238061003386974, 0.008724169805645943, -0.04181750863790512, 0.048284053802490234, 0.07555271685123444, 0.01638067699968815, -0.015708468854427338, -0.012363842688500881, 0.013057398609817028, -0.03013528138399124, 0.010671942494809628, 0.008612165227532387, -0.04801487922668457, 0.05603385716676712, 0.018187470734119415, 0.05406436324119568, 0.04798869043588638, 0.011361310258507729, 0.07777976989746094, -0.015249986201524734, 0.05206311121582985, 0.01540432870388031, -0.021480264142155647, -0.007558093871921301, -0.02228652872145176, 0.005278897471725941, -0.04310434311628342, -0.0024574249982833862, -0.013598623685538769, 0.038192931562662125 ]
<p>I don't know a lot about sampling methods. </p> <p>I have a large population of size 2,000,000. I used one of those sample size calculators. It says that I need sample size of approximately 10,000.</p> <p>I am trying to find the probability <strong>p</strong> of success for the population. It is not feasible for me to test all 2,000,000 members of the population. That is why I am sampling.</p> <p>I assume that the sample size calculator means a simple random sample without replacement. I have read that a simple random sample with replacement ensures that the covariance between two variables is 0<strike>, i.e., independent</strike>. </p> <p>When should one choose with replacement instead of without replacement?</p> <p>If we sample with replacement, then we are simply performing Bernoulli trials. I suppose this makes applying statistical tools (which?) easier.</p> <p>Again, sampling ignoramus here.</p>
g74032
[ 0.04383181780576706, 0.0005037275841459632, 0.011420021764934063, 0.0010304978350177407, -0.04392809793353081, 0.00738168228417635, -0.032070040702819824, 0.024141695350408554, -0.005474792793393135, -0.02330099791288376, -0.014959592372179031, 0.005060461349785328, -0.006879072170704603, -0.0004862384230364114, -0.02169196680188179, 0.04986010864377022, 0.053900860249996185, -0.0038030617870390415, 0.07125052064657211, 0.08578839898109436, -0.019581487402319908, -0.04165203869342804, -0.0038851075805723667, -0.037291575223207474, -0.011964499019086361, -0.07277543842792511, -0.00946741458028555, 0.06286465376615524, -0.013113167136907578, -0.05773104727268219, -0.012650886550545692, 0.05952759087085724, 0.05317335203289986, -0.05158735811710358, -0.04652906209230423, 0.02151627652347088, 0.041978493332862854, 0.051848091185092926, 0.04176771268248558, -0.027121316641569138, -0.003440119558945298, 0.02572716400027275, 0.07743380963802338, 0.005722028203308582, 0.02037801407277584, -0.003643221687525511, -0.004483010154217482, 0.0031703030690550804, 0.043497614562511444, -0.07257220894098282, -0.014765319414436817, 0.021710827946662903, 0.040885619819164276, -0.02177799679338932, -0.03551027923822403, 0.03107895329594612, -0.0013927430845797062, -0.029883068054914474, -0.048524267971515656, -0.014754664152860641, 0.014065742492675781, -0.016507212072610855, -0.07413142174482346, -0.01757744885981083, -0.010025637224316597, 0.07973872125148773, -0.01975347101688385, -0.004003138281404972, 0.07138523459434509, 0.02621248923242092, -0.03723268583416939, -0.04208722710609436, 0.04271486774086952, -0.03653062880039215, -0.06518537551164627, -0.09621472656726837, -0.03783696889877319, 0.05897096171975136, 0.030325964093208313, 0.05429046228528023, 0.02512766607105732, -0.090491384267807, 0.008537301793694496, 0.0021369147580116987, 0.032796964049339294, -0.0114412447437644, -0.03370608016848564, -0.022178323939442635, -0.0008659145678393543, 0.020155025646090508, -0.019879017025232315, 0.04273584485054016, 0.014852151274681091, 0.02569003589451313, -0.01787070371210575, 0.01212640106678009, -0.03569396212697029, 0.05832476168870926, 0.007624365389347076, -0.002030137460678816, 0.014423036016523838, -0.023216554895043373, -0.07594192773103714, -0.010951598174870014, -0.01471490878611803, -0.0005049681640230119, 0.0370648130774498, 0.0043342639692127705, -0.05502256006002426, -0.0035362287890166044, -0.02263803780078888, -0.00979942362755537, -0.004082386381924152, -0.06448474526405334, -0.028631551191210747, 0.011896333657205105, 0.1259443461894989, 0.014299792237579823, 0.0373949259519577, 0.02335396595299244, -0.0005991142825223505, 0.02665110118687153, 0.026476874947547913, 0.032216787338256836, -0.03035622462630272, -0.032875142991542816, -0.020604116842150688, 0.0919138714671135, -0.010452852584421635, 0.004239581525325775, -0.0482650026679039, 0.04586097225546837, 0.044575151056051254, 0.026585759595036507, 0.020571541041135788, 0.02466275542974472, 0.018521083518862724, 0.018634483218193054, -0.0026367215905338526, 0.02467067912220955, -0.015598981641232967, 0.07542908936738968, 0.07360588759183884, 0.04412425681948662, 0.03762682154774666, 0.04391808062791824, -0.02063947729766369, -0.024855349212884903, -0.016649123281240463, 0.0022221324034035206, 0.010857569985091686, 0.04060034453868866, 0.02717507630586624, -0.029889525845646858, -0.05204214155673981, 0.04174911230802536, 0.01273188553750515, 0.0510125569999218, 0.03567132353782654, -0.019416119903326035, 0.02132653072476387, -0.02572040632367134, -0.027090752497315407, -0.01399745512753725, 0.03210706263780594, 0.022198040038347244, 0.040282443165779114, -0.07403027266263962, -0.04235447198152542, 0.0033982498571276665, 0.010481293313205242, -0.014806297607719898, 0.06837718933820724, -0.00715210335329175, -0.027675548568367958, 0.025419970974326134, -0.003827058244496584, 0.006476536393165588, -0.018800783902406693, -0.018525434657931328, -0.037515051662921906, -0.04296918958425522, 0.010913425125181675, -0.021732866764068604, 0.05050432309508324, -0.020646298304200172, 0.05076117813587189, 0.05867924913764, -0.009013799019157887, -0.0039582084864377975, -0.04964333027601242, -0.05524005368351936, -0.016544578596949577, 0.012687458656728268, -0.023555736988782883, 0.007522917352616787, 0.04612819850444794, -0.018618343397974968, -0.006842128466814756, 0.01806294173002243, -0.008922290988266468, 0.03365026041865349, -0.004868763033300638, 0.047494757920503616, -0.043336279690265656, -0.019871370866894722, 0.003578334115445614, 0.02937074936926365, -0.024390889331698418, 0.07380525022745132, -0.003395084058865905, 0.017594190314412117, -0.07378026843070984, 0.03540530055761337, -0.029585029929876328, 0.012791306711733341, -0.010597554966807365, 0.0545555017888546, -0.04681255668401718, 0.027269309386610985, 0.03813789039850235, -0.008189214393496513, 0.03545912355184555, 0.011279904283583164, 0.03233176842331886, 0.02604633755981922, 0.0032032965682446957, 0.03324618935585022, 0.025214094668626785, 0.03426457941532135, -0.03812875971198082, 0.013939321041107178, 0.0041071572341024876, -0.019937198609113693, -0.025026550516486168, 0.0033578830771148205, 0.011539442464709282, 0.006948493886739016, -0.022256452590227127, 0.016530869528651237, 0.02073679305613041, -0.05981279909610748, -0.03363582864403725, 0.030157554894685745, 0.018584970384836197, 0.003984426613897085, 0.015590567141771317, -0.027708565816283226, 0.004063687287271023, 0.028660878539085388, -0.026729905977845192, 0.0050651999190449715, -0.008365698158740997, -0.04643828421831131, -0.03259669244289398, -0.012149428017437458, 0.06208394095301628, 0.013935543596744537, -0.022595267742872238, 0.02194153144955635, -0.017302578315138817, -0.04692588374018669, 0.03471140190958977, 0.04861815273761749, -0.031840331852436066, -0.01854698732495308, -0.030529789626598358, -0.04598221927881241, -0.025227608159184456, -0.019589999690651894, 0.03774818778038025, 0.014279089868068695, -0.014912218786776066, 0.03831564635038376, 0.07747259736061096, 0.018628722056746483, -0.04253002256155014, 0.014802761375904083, 0.04488673061132431, 0.018219508230686188, 0.020925164222717285, -0.014893990010023117, -0.0027396217919886112, 0.024239487946033478, 0.10040323436260223, 0.00009728296572575346, 0.041762251406908035, -0.03645980730652809, 0.0016116256592795253, -0.020857246592640877, 0.012072003446519375, -0.03604041785001755, 0.019316568970680237, -0.029255598783493042, 0.04034964367747307, -0.035762108862400055, -0.011566558852791786, -0.060702428221702576, 0.003162390785291791, 0.00522757600992918, 0.0012032899539917707, 0.012283781543374062, -0.030425315722823143, 0.0009228943381458521, 0.027870506048202515, 0.018967056646943092, -0.05033079534769058, -0.016501402482390404, -0.049451809376478195, -0.002482074312865734, 0.03360362723469734, 0.04276096820831299, -0.013096973299980164, -0.014703291468322277, -0.04179595038294792, -0.043788883835077286, 0.03534507006406784, 0.021556086838245392, 0.054274387657642365, -0.020449461415410042, 0.02185562439262867, -0.011788629926741123, -0.0014164673630148172, -0.02770613692700863, -0.029891904443502426, 0.015406091697514057, -0.04000379517674446, -0.007807234767824411, -0.04652470350265503, 0.009354124777019024, -0.005045158322900534, 0.0951891615986824, -0.0677385926246643, -0.02082308754324913, -0.01194640714675188, -0.08836493641138077, 0.050415221601724625, -0.02598443441092968, 0.01926475763320923, 0.03212886303663254, -0.007514864671975374, -0.010715698823332787, -0.05316515639424324, -0.02209290862083435, 0.0065765161998569965, -0.05643075332045555, 0.04323853924870491, -0.011236101388931274, 0.01497585978358984, -0.022626137360930443, 0.04170854389667511, -0.017793377861380577, -0.032514650374650955, -0.031270790845155716, 0.004374893382191658, -0.0026948489248752594, 0.047188133001327515, -0.00569565873593092, 0.009993571788072586, -0.01995614543557167, 0.08262845873832703, -0.04436756670475006, 0.004901728592813015, 0.02688557840883732, 0.0018557233270257711, 0.06359638273715973, -0.0038275630213320255, -0.02075350284576416, 0.009101413190364838, 0.023829929530620575, -0.032858312129974365, -0.0019395266426727176, 0.029257219284772873, 0.017970610409975052, 0.016929863020777702, 0.024519385769963264, 0.060840047895908356, 0.08221254497766495, 0.019404970109462738, -0.014586315490305424, 0.0675104632973671, -0.012668993324041367, -0.04486123099923134, -0.07279747724533081, -0.013106211088597775, -0.08509065210819244, -0.02161608450114727, -0.004949631635099649, -0.02706797793507576, -0.04251622408628464, 0.03514509275555611, -0.06123991310596466, -0.013612133450806141, 0.042039260268211365, 0.02154054492712021, -0.05122373625636101, 0.017049990594387054, -0.008237822912633419, 0.039203859865665436, 0.0020412574522197247, -0.03725733980536461, 0.03335483372211456, 0.021678410470485687, 0.03438081219792366, 0.05112350359559059, -0.0061392816714942455, 0.021248050034046173, -0.01670002192258835, 0.0005905410507693887, 0.023998085409402847, -0.04289581999182701, -0.029044291004538536, -0.013060547411441803, -0.05988747626543045, -0.021747304126620293, -0.05525212362408638, -0.01984088309109211, 0.02757088653743267, 0.01311437040567398, 0.014694714918732643, -0.02935035154223442, -0.0038259876891970634, 0.02383309043943882, -0.03794053569436073, -0.019474495202302933, 0.025013798847794533, -0.009932179003953934, -0.0071960389614105225, 0.06696216017007828, -0.029004670679569244, -0.02440369687974453, 0.051829107105731964, 0.0024520806036889553, 0.028568372130393982, -0.0037330198101699352, 0.012629521079361439, -0.004298612009733915, -0.03168172389268875, -0.04096231609582901, -0.017347605898976326, -0.005236980505287647, -0.004850118886679411, -0.032926078885793686, 0.010370775125920773, 0.006219369824975729, 0.009229499846696854, 0.02610446885228157, 0.004749325104057789, 0.02145433984696865, -0.07705420255661011, -0.001731419120915234, 0.05203951895236969, 0.029392968863248825, -0.00170520122628659, -0.04507146775722504, 0.07066906243562698, -0.024577932432293892, 0.0035974960774183273, -0.005362410098314285, 0.06934323161840439, 0.002926117042079568, -0.005284903105348349, -0.024314086884260178, -0.011283733882009983, -0.010111450217664242, -0.012079202570021152, -0.07302515208721161, -0.0452544242143631, -0.032273128628730774, 0.03670303523540497, -0.029876673594117165, 0.0023401689250022173, 0.035926468670368195, -0.013385574333369732, -0.09188156574964523, 0.007673655170947313, -0.0244772769510746, -0.0051035452634096146, 0.038448791950941086, 0.0474710576236248, -0.0036497798282653093, -0.05512947961688042, 0.027924714609980583, -0.014799445867538452, 0.017617134377360344, -0.0371239148080349, -0.025235190987586975, -0.08532072603702545, 0.09976834803819656, -0.06717732548713684, -0.006721965502947569, 0.03918624669313431, 0.0822378471493721, 0.00996412429958582, -0.007250781636685133, -0.052804335951805115, 0.07833432406187057, -0.04103967919945717, 0.023162558674812317, -0.015796346589922905, 0.0091465525329113, -0.0062916954047977924, 0.013323375023901463, 0.010724526830017567, -0.02408183552324772, -0.030231956392526627, 0.061877068132162094, -0.004252531565725803, 0.012949435971677303, 0.05343855172395706, -0.008038785308599472, 0.023699820041656494, 0.025457505136728287, -0.0010145190171897411, -0.06989875435829163, 0.01921798847615719, -0.0005305946106091142, 0.0034463785123080015, -0.0628477931022644, -0.006063668988645077, 0.07678624987602234, 0.0033188974484801292, -0.008962062187492847, -0.0447896271944046, -0.019112439826130867, -0.04927536100149155, -0.03665850684046745, 0.008406329900026321, -0.024117235094308853, -0.01807991787791252, 0.015788137912750244, 0.00785813294351101, -0.03726167231798172, -0.01471839752048254, -0.07099106162786484, -0.042172085493803024, -0.03490174189209938, -0.04678792506456375, -0.04114900529384613, -0.02062719129025936, -0.009311460889875889, 0.026005856692790985, 0.05229151248931885, 0.017705673351883888, -0.05386356636881828, 0.0056202225387096405, -0.01347899716347456, 0.020682835951447487, 0.04603663086891174, -0.010662699118256569, -0.0459723100066185, 0.016974693164229393, -0.009632285684347153, 0.05736977607011795, -0.0039144172333180904, 0.024967608973383904, 0.024698082357645035, 0.016569064930081367, 0.014568527229130268, 0.008016251027584076, -0.03938823193311691, -0.07497380673885345, -0.024718021973967552, 0.008099811151623726, 0.025987567380070686, 0.001926335389725864, -0.020941833034157753, -0.042358264327049255, -0.05515531077980995, 0.019448310136795044, -0.0016966653056442738, -0.00981740653514862, -0.008217362686991692, -0.025547688826918602, 0.05629763379693031, -0.014218857511878014, -0.039031244814395905, 0.011953161098062992, -0.027393676340579987, -0.027464283630251884, -0.019897067919373512, -0.02854475937783718, 0.015661513432860374, 0.01709265261888504, -0.03114631399512291, 0.007658565416932106, -0.02208501286804676, -0.0031956688035279512, 0.042913857847452164, 0.017183123156428337, 0.04823298379778862, -0.00618611928075552, -0.0002441258548060432, -0.07757524400949478, -0.03646967560052872, -0.001083087525330484, -0.01373724639415741, -0.01172624435275793, -0.08270373940467834, -0.041709136217832565, -0.03635052219033241, -0.027276884764432907, 0.0014568233164027333, -0.04000190272927284, 0.009634720161557198, -0.06582185626029968, -0.029281528666615486, -0.012235087342560291, 0.002875048201531172, -0.007684516720473766, -0.055957015603780746, 0.026726355776190758, 0.014611348509788513, 0.016205916181206703, 0.019212238490581512, -0.014870749786496162, -0.08197718113660812, 0.0031329558696597815, 0.014995632693171501, -0.017954453825950623, 0.018623072654008865, -0.02202572301030159, 0.0551358126103878, 0.024627408012747765, 0.02552059479057789, 0.050380270928144455, 0.02994631975889206, 0.004412785172462463, 0.0972285345196724, -0.03374011814594269, 0.01874653436243534, 0.05087849125266075, -0.044264055788517, 0.050936680287122726, -0.06681051850318909, 0.06663836538791656, -0.066164530813694, 0.06185690686106682, 0.040138401091098785, 0.05179160460829735, -0.02077910117805004, 0.009640098549425602, 0.04877496883273125, -0.025078358128666878, 0.0072579714469611645, -0.03759850934147835, 0.03021971508860588, 0.026439489796757698, -0.014415176585316658, 0.014173309318721294, -0.03454119339585304, 0.060639578849077225, -0.02805626392364502, -0.016217293217778206, -0.028418200090527534, 0.03954596444964409, 0.04843415319919586, 0.08609895408153534, 0.012288970872759819, -0.01683112047612667, -0.009252576157450676, 0.00005518581747310236, -0.04035034775733948, -0.06829240918159485, 0.009548468515276909, 0.04808152839541435, -0.038211096078157425, -0.06649401783943176, 0.017487460747361183, -0.01598474569618702, -0.00767304515466094, 0.00013904154184274375, -0.06261633336544037, -0.03250618651509285, -0.028516795486211777, -0.005626805126667023, 0.034205641597509384, 0.05135994777083397, -0.02316458150744438, -0.02462213858962059, 0.030906466767191887, -0.038376275449991226, 0.013100665993988514, 0.028691262006759644, 0.041302457451820374, 0.012663657777011395, -0.03246575966477394, -0.03516504168510437, 0.01763106882572174, 0.009131100960075855, 0.0006403308361768723, -0.05609792843461037, 0.021102983504533768, 0.04420153796672821, -0.03623734042048454, 0.03720276430249214, -0.008197583258152008, -0.008517547510564327, 0.03879757225513458, 0.03134500980377197, -0.048436202108860016, 0.011850915849208832, 0.021924801170825958, -0.0117333410307765, 0.026349715888500214, 0.006695071700960398, -0.030194692313671112, -0.034716181457042694, -0.04919511452317238, -0.11367926746606827, 0.013577001169323921, 0.04048536345362663, 0.03776141628623009, -0.006956956349313259, 0.005134691949933767, -0.013224228285253048, -0.02016299031674862, 0.010494831018149853, 0.07302634418010712, 0.013501605950295925, -0.01209777221083641, 0.009723912924528122, 0.029055766761302948, 0.02365560084581375, -0.049094490706920624, -0.031016729772090912, 0.04743344336748123, 0.08009776473045349, -0.025142231956124306, 0.07482638210058212, -0.019688522443175316, -0.06447756290435791, -0.062237199395895004, 0.006788314785808325, 0.03789619356393814, -0.01453110296279192, 0.04844945669174194, 0.03784136474132538, -0.056828077882528305, 0.05868547782301903, -0.0059090242721140385, 0.034861620515584946, 0.045694749802351, 0.0073639219626784325, 0.015584096312522888, -0.010645207948982716, -0.001698985113762319, 0.026268191635608673, 0.030846795067191124, -0.04152509942650795, -0.03240838646888733, -0.009983355179429054, -0.020412301644682884, 0.006264218129217625, 0.007383323274552822, -0.0352853499352932, 0.044739414006471634, -0.006515203975141048, 0.023921793326735497, -0.050369638949632645, 0.05536934733390808, 0.01835307665169239, -0.07180136442184448, 0.004764482378959656, 0.006089202128350735, -0.026468550786376, 0.007679549977183342, 0.03728045895695686 ]
<p>I am trying to estimate the price elasticity of supply for small scale farmers in Malawi and I have time series data for 34 years. I have two problems: First, the prices are very low such that when I take their logs am getting negative values, as a remedy i added 1 to each value and i got positive logs but i don't know how to interprete the result with the 1 that I added. Second i want to find out the specific way of estimating the model in <code>Stata</code>, I just used regress. I will appreciate your help</p>
g74033
[ 0.016377173364162445, -0.026080956682562828, -0.021168071776628494, -0.05194389075040817, 0.01873375102877617, -0.030061911791563034, 0.0232852715998888, 0.02533656917512417, -0.049086421728134155, -0.0266854390501976, -0.03259628266096115, 0.02372177690267563, 0.01773921214044094, -0.001666150288656354, -0.01463447604328394, 0.023460902273654938, -0.020244797691702843, -0.04178498312830925, -0.04432845860719681, 0.016286425292491913, 0.05271243676543236, -0.012908062897622585, 0.04912327602505684, -0.021307826042175293, -0.00006105256034061313, -0.02526180073618889, 0.02283034287393093, 0.11015696823596954, -0.01444945577532053, -0.009800038300454617, -0.0016491558635607362, -0.025140294805169106, 0.0067939767614007, 0.0003498178848531097, -0.030832167714834213, -0.02156708762049675, 0.06661326438188553, 0.0509040392935276, 0.01360111590474844, -0.020078863948583603, 0.008198174647986889, -0.043972037732601166, 0.008411076851189137, 0.03823833167552948, -0.012803883291780949, -0.0003689188451971859, 0.018838956952095032, 0.021663568913936615, 0.013523091562092304, 0.0095509123057127, 0.028317056596279144, 0.057829368859529495, -0.02007957547903061, -0.05568480119109154, 0.013972719199955463, 0.03704208880662918, 0.002579837804660201, 0.000040949573303805664, 0.05905376374721527, -0.01850706711411476, -0.0033956565894186497, -0.04535706713795662, 0.03645411878824234, -0.006634375546127558, 0.02410477213561535, -0.009574075229465961, -0.015142588876187801, -0.05036638677120209, -0.03145736828446388, -0.042713310569524765, 0.02818383276462555, -0.04887497052550316, 0.001652851584367454, -0.050489380955696106, -0.02458513155579567, -0.020113838836550713, -0.03632143512368202, 0.025445615872740746, -0.006225445307791233, 0.02574610523879528, 0.007758365012705326, 0.052324555814266205, -0.05543636158108711, -0.004443996120244265, 0.014919753186404705, 0.0204449649900198, 0.08263640105724335, -0.009362926706671715, 0.022251252084970474, -0.06213284283876419, 0.006497648078948259, 0.02044404111802578, 0.08503389358520508, 0.019393442198634148, -0.014231126755475998, -0.014695774763822556, -0.06614097952842712, 0.03768562525510788, -0.0032592129427939653, 0.05406514182686806, 0.011747658252716064, 0.07953327894210815, -0.008494043722748756, -0.0668758973479271, -0.022594301030039787, -0.026349931955337524, 0.02085595205426216, -0.01956886053085327, -0.011876431293785572, -0.03166922181844711, -0.020725369453430176, -0.014121199026703835, -0.0063890377059578896, -0.06434160470962524, -0.0024619372561573982, -0.06334985792636871, 0.038866572082042694, -0.014470377936959267, 0.028242938220500946, -0.020353244617581367, 0.04444881156086922, 0.025013990700244904, 0.011808936484158039, 0.06889847666025162, 0.017690280452370644, -0.06096240133047104, -0.04973828047513962, 0.0861549898982048, 0.02129487879574299, 0.007364405784755945, -0.0043418314307928085, -0.007091970182955265, 0.013170174323022366, 0.019063800573349, 0.04573914781212807, -0.007003635633736849, -0.08544080704450607, 0.042178936302661896, -0.03346839174628258, 0.02489185519516468, 0.010219793766736984, 0.06207459792494774, 0.05519367754459381, 0.018079623579978943, 0.0001806955988286063, -0.03807266429066658, 0.03405562788248062, -0.03153842315077782, 0.021904872730374336, 0.010611172765493393, 0.00643519451841712, 0.055398128926754, -0.03711456060409546, 0.0945153757929802, -0.008042414672672749, 0.0530477836728096, 0.06020272150635719, -0.01721254363656044, 0.0017032886389642954, 0.050040826201438904, 0.02266128733754158, -0.0726391077041626, 0.043351612985134125, 0.10203791409730911, -0.003486549947410822, 0.004549825564026833, 0.0210372656583786, -0.0015891310758888721, 0.013752591796219349, -0.01917673461139202, -0.011723137460649014, -0.04781293123960495, 0.008975043892860413, -0.0490214042365551, 0.04871134087443352, -0.0021727713756263256, -0.03547210618853569, 0.0028891386464238167, 0.020460303872823715, -0.039684444665908813, 0.03145232051610947, 0.02498037926852703, 0.017784373834729195, 0.0074488637037575245, -0.008453572168946266, -0.050539083778858185, -0.0006005788454785943, 0.02352045476436615, -0.05048017203807831, -0.010760455392301083, -0.03445813059806824, 0.016139522194862366, -0.0466717891395092, -0.010235845111310482, 0.012335631996393204, -0.0016886681551113725, 0.07174009829759598, -0.04703753814101219, 0.014752226881682873, 0.0055503868497908115, 0.024255655705928802, -0.0319979265332222, -0.05432712286710739, 0.017041390761733055, -0.03585299476981163, -0.05556880682706833, -0.013538193888962269, -0.03667351230978966, -0.041360195726156235, 0.0025278450921177864, -0.01875869370996952, -0.02862739749252796, -0.06182078644633293, 0.050691694021224976, -0.0061597866006195545, -0.0024813844356685877, 0.027418892830610275, -0.001036556321196258, 0.034192003309726715, -0.011519861407577991, -0.038014356046915054, -0.006106224842369556, 0.03457721695303917, 0.02095755748450756, 0.04216746240854263, 0.00898432731628418, 0.046463992446660995, 0.026351816952228546, -0.04912763088941574, -0.03659563884139061, -0.029895905405282974, -0.001977795735001564, -0.02151024155318737, -0.015614108182489872, 0.05358848348259926, -0.023886505514383316, 0.04029927775263786, -0.017794156447052956, -0.05430836230516434, 0.00883772037923336, -0.021784624084830284, -0.01627996377646923, 0.03507067263126373, -0.022992463782429695, 0.059409234672784805, -0.015861304476857185, 0.0690314993262291, 0.038549695163965225, 0.07775355130434036, 0.0654451921582222, 0.03989332914352417, 0.048871926963329315, 0.04580037668347359, -0.008478483185172081, 0.011106602847576141, -0.0890318751335144, -0.04261475428938866, 0.08107053488492966, 0.03505370020866394, -0.02920999936759472, -0.019233308732509613, 0.02170540764927864, 0.03043997846543789, 0.027845293283462524, -0.018455706536769867, -0.050619225949048996, 0.06298673152923584, -0.04335694760084152, -0.02743355557322502, 0.0004099439538549632, -0.051865316927433014, -0.0316179096698761, 0.05886034667491913, 0.007916796021163464, 0.04975386708974838, 0.012200694531202316, -0.031170636415481567, 0.0250078234821558, 0.017674412578344345, -0.020961716771125793, 0.0023609832860529423, -0.04038103297352791, 0.005451640579849482, -0.01313956081867218, -0.011804835870862007, 0.0011941373813897371, -0.0006845828611403704, -0.00378775573335588, 0.006741563323885202, -0.009865870699286461, -0.03234034776687622, -0.003550383960828185, -0.017370138317346573, -0.024533413350582123, 0.04260529950261116, -0.02194828726351261, -0.015392560511827469, -0.049569446593523026, 0.06004057452082634, 0.0002925011212937534, -0.03991405665874481, -0.017502708360552788, 0.002517072018235922, -0.01350532565265894, 0.013930723071098328, -0.03832210972905159, -0.002151072258129716, -0.008876373991370201, 0.03428357094526291, 0.018592339009046555, -0.06495422124862671, 0.0000614626842434518, 0.037846531718969345, -0.033565521240234375, -0.04575439542531967, 0.028021758422255516, 0.012012873776257038, -0.007069831248372793, 0.04597771540284157, -0.020294591784477234, 0.002944141859188676, -0.08966796845197678, 0.016497978940606117, 0.026519671082496643, -0.05843573063611984, -0.0009955185232684016, -0.025897786021232605, 0.009958632290363312, -0.054641976952552795, -0.012366645969450474, -0.008986112661659718, -0.045671023428440094, -0.030414598062634468, -0.03955944627523422, 0.009645950049161911, -0.0479326955974102, -0.007911896333098412, -0.024176258593797684, -0.02820453979074955, 0.02614392526447773, -0.04325641319155693, -0.017493655905127525, -0.022285548970103264, -0.009396976791322231, -0.058235712349414825, 0.011286692693829536, -0.03394031897187233, 0.00512303039431572, -0.01191274356096983, 0.004998401738703251, -0.0060438490472733974, -0.07626055926084518, 0.07112715393304825, -0.018406908959150314, 0.015603494830429554, -0.012120290659368038, 0.05401865392923355, -0.022230373695492744, 0.039262447506189346, 0.011552472598850727, 0.05772216618061066, -0.02374999411404133, -0.030151741579174995, 0.007799635641276836, -0.007797743193805218, 0.013516616076231003, -0.006214129272848368, 0.10048506408929825, -0.006744976621121168, -0.0018613029969856143, 0.017977721989154816, 0.05368321016430855, 0.03225281089544296, -0.012081746011972427, -0.03117368184030056, -0.02148883417248726, -0.00944770872592926, 0.048624735325574875, -0.003936528693884611, 0.06747289001941681, 0.07051947712898254, 0.03414057940244675, -0.0006533607374876738, 0.04380590096116066, -0.008456454612314701, -0.08353167027235031, 0.05403707176446915, 0.019804440438747406, 0.0015082876197993755, -0.02881481871008873, 0.030534548684954643, -0.02275313064455986, -0.03654154762625694, 0.05435752123594284, -0.009742166846990585, -0.006243443116545677, 0.016224060207605362, 0.00250218971632421, -0.025164518505334854, -0.009442307986319065, -0.0369546115398407, -0.06466159969568253, 0.042373839765787125, 0.07651448249816895, -0.012315426953136921, 0.011770893819630146, 0.006406084634363651, 0.009884653612971306, -0.005907798185944557, 0.03423910215497017, -0.07376740872859955, 0.02501690573990345, -0.022422634065151215, -0.05157255753874779, -0.009808165021240711, 0.0009521489264443517, 0.10557284206151962, -0.030086245387792587, 0.036641575396060944, 0.020763954147696495, 0.0324786901473999, 0.04002147912979126, -0.0427129864692688, -0.06282041221857071, -0.026693398132920265, 0.04262183606624603, 0.03315480798482895, 0.018701856955885887, -0.011759426444768906, -0.02509440667927265, -0.036052804440259933, 0.034954022616147995, -0.03440233692526817, 0.003829853143543005, -0.02162339724600315, 0.019438259303569794, 0.05302974209189415, 0.0002665050560608506, -0.008493905887007713, -0.0644344612956047, -0.016472456976771355, -0.034771714359521866, -0.009370465762913227, 0.02677989937365055, 0.01218150369822979, 0.017398325726389885, -0.0024637433234602213, -0.007469708099961281, -0.02100008726119995, -0.01937514916062355, 0.02891194447875023, 0.008758202195167542, -0.052971601486206055, -0.019487464800477028, 0.039089832454919815, 0.005275554023683071, 0.027561264112591743, 0.0913596823811531, 0.05520949512720108, 0.061400752514600754, -0.03321194276213646, -0.034628622233867645, -0.07123979181051254, -0.05364811420440674, -0.049081411212682724, -0.009485284797847271, -0.01084641832858324, 0.011821230873465538, 0.08281856775283813, 0.012361557222902775, -0.03380109369754791, -0.028384743258357048, 0.027693819254636765, -0.01491847075521946, -0.03222070261836052, -0.003956126049160957, -0.020398981869220734, -0.027106184512376785, 0.014401585794985294, 0.04587168246507645, -0.02758932113647461, -0.038260847330093384, -0.02929975651204586, -0.00094062794232741, 0.008947880938649178, 0.020543616265058517, 0.048602692782878876, -0.03726769983768463, 0.04665747284889221, -0.028188901022076607, 0.025618452578783035, 0.03535681962966919, 0.0837143138051033, 0.05577021837234497, -0.04775669425725937, -0.04331445321440697, -0.025719469413161278, 0.016770899295806885, -0.006585178896784782, -0.014448663219809532, -0.058959007263183594, -0.0033577601425349712, -0.0648217424750328, 0.017343277111649513, 0.014932516030967236, -0.06604550778865814, 0.0714966356754303, 0.0030555438715964556, 0.045056093484163284, 0.025271352380514145, 0.009512058459222317, 0.025895504280924797, 0.0957341194152832, -0.008670742623507977, -0.0038196274545043707, -0.028915654867887497, 0.02380681410431862, 0.05621523782610893, -0.016584234312176704, 0.006632682401686907, 0.02776935324072838, -0.006499135866761208, 0.02142496034502983, -0.01064915582537651, 0.006140668410807848, -0.05010157823562622, -0.013668346218764782, -0.030548540875315666, 0.0018632103456184268, -0.10948565602302551, -0.016682960093021393, 0.03908888250589371, -0.038097698241472244, -0.0809921994805336, 0.036134157329797745, -0.012349117547273636, -0.013598280027508736, 0.0212026908993721, -0.0024494975805282593, -0.05491270497441292, -0.0215128306299448, -0.015286209993064404, 0.056644219905138016, -0.0709775760769844, 0.020949631929397583, -0.063043013215065, -0.034222815185785294, -0.015800723806023598, 0.0259251669049263, 0.0275763887912035, 0.009991372935473919, 0.021672183647751808, -0.0206342451274395, -0.03626859560608864, -0.0011358425254002213, 0.0367450937628746, -0.02912135422229767, -0.04274789243936539, -0.026846662163734436, -0.005973337218165398, -0.00826672837138176, -0.0035354378633201122, -0.016895432025194168, 0.0029912327881902456, -0.0321517176926136, -0.006118510849773884, -0.02622077614068985, 0.0070405518636107445, 0.016696132719516754, 0.01638663560152054, 0.042744461447000504, -0.013466413132846355, 0.06743419170379639, 0.04901140555739403, -0.009653696790337563, 0.039279259741306305, -0.0018221173668280244, -0.03104374371469021, 0.05076467618346214, 0.02539880760014057, -0.03883998095989227, -0.040343135595321655, -0.002248705131933093, 0.010764522477984428, -0.0063959457911551, -0.013457553461194038, 0.019048744812607765, 0.06162518635392189, -0.05894603952765465, 0.038333959877491, 0.021305829286575317, 0.008097756654024124, 0.03229329362511635, -0.05236434563994408, 0.008935576304793358, -0.025861138477921486, -0.020753176882863045, -0.015964888036251068, 0.028042802587151527, -0.06699150800704956, 0.03525758162140846, 0.005348553881049156, 0.07744644582271576, -0.04805182293057442, 0.03037891536951065, -0.05685178562998772, -0.022334232926368713, 0.028418349102139473, 0.02168780006468296, -0.015456103719770908, -0.01571051776409149, -0.012229087762534618, 0.0014693416887894273, 0.07283517718315125, 0.03788714483380318, 0.022002587094902992, -0.02966705895960331, 0.030819149687886238, -0.001590436208061874, -0.026506075635552406, 0.04195031896233559, -0.031417109072208405, 0.006462869234383106, -0.0465191975235939, 0.053991060703992844, 0.03919217362999916, -0.06151151657104492, 0.015341633930802345, 0.02847270667552948, -0.003765637055039406, -0.017830608412623405, 0.011955833993852139, -0.019870856776833534, 0.011166680604219437, -0.06095771864056587, 0.06542082130908966, -0.024047503247857094, 0.11235199123620987, 0.028597824275493622, 0.02793797105550766, -0.024412333965301514, 0.018215589225292206, -0.035989079624414444, -0.03509940207004547, -0.033845894038677216, 0.02734856680035591, 0.05214305594563484, -0.020951008424162865, -0.0134429931640625, 0.019412456080317497, 0.0013102494413033128, -0.008573951199650764, 0.06587447226047516, 0.0016392961842939258, 0.03190849721431732, -0.012774207629263401, -0.017475055530667305, 0.02255481295287609, 0.018959246575832367, 0.029838068410754204, -0.007989946752786636, -0.016725335270166397, -0.059746548533439636, -0.027360476553440094, 0.01983558014035225, 0.059727706015110016, 0.0020385205280035734, -0.029278995469212532, 0.018617313355207443, -0.036871783435344696, -0.03827483579516411, -0.04554702714085579, 0.01777210272848606, 0.006530459504574537, 0.011919789016246796, -0.02266574278473854, -0.021271301433444023, 0.03285784646868706, -0.044256921857595444, 0.023661507293581963, 0.0027030815836042166, -0.05064195767045021, -0.006633328273892403, -0.010524803772568703, -0.03450784459710121, 0.018847042694687843, 0.028601739555597305, 0.004207756835967302, 0.03914055600762367, -0.00455669779330492, -0.06283551454544067, -0.019541192799806595, -0.010839620605111122, 0.0006803821888752282, -0.0021011459175497293, 0.01639709807932377, -0.0441470742225647, 0.03000005893409252, -0.06728854775428772, 0.005237257573753595, 0.005056693684309721, 0.009575125761330128, 0.005948896985501051, 0.0033042053692042828, 0.025728993117809296, -0.02506508119404316, 0.01818346045911312, -0.02669955976307392, -0.0154821602627635, -0.060878854244947433, -0.05550963059067726, -0.007037556264549494, 0.03568173199892044, -0.0055916509591042995, 0.0648532435297966, 0.00890717189759016, 0.02352457493543625, -0.055458735674619675, -0.011763717979192734, -0.001361022237688303, -0.048992350697517395, -0.023399388417601585, -0.002486373297870159, 0.04671475291252136, -0.019250741228461266, -0.057741567492485046, -0.059537846595048904, 0.0600702129304409, 0.01171494834125042, 0.040851786732673645, -0.003948184661567211, -0.027405811473727226, -0.015916001051664352, 0.03741275146603584, 0.028813712298870087, 0.041774798184633255, 0.032050199806690216, -0.04384355992078781, -0.03190503641963005, 0.11468853056430817, -0.0793265551328659, 0.005686331074684858, -0.011358749121427536, 0.014076699502766132, -0.02310674823820591, -0.019689910113811493, 0.012750622816383839, 0.08286936581134796, -0.0027174220886081457, -0.06286607682704926, -0.009589334949851036, -0.03504117950797081, -0.05251269415020943, 0.06042877212166786, 0.0041671814396977425, 0.026157742366194725, -0.011507632210850716, 0.0028084702789783478, 0.0008987446199171245, -0.04029061645269394, 0.009977908805012703, 0.020601775497198105, -0.03329123556613922, 0.02194192446768284, 0.053551290184259415, -0.013344609178602695, 0.01978660747408867, -0.016389206051826477 ]
<p>In the English Championship division, there are 24 teams, 8 of which have names starting with the letter B (e.g.Bolton) Tonight, (5th March 2013) all 24 teams in this division are playing each other. By a coincidence, the 8 teams starting with B are playing each other, i.e. 4 of the games involve these 8 teams (there are 2 teams per game!) What is the probability of this happening ?</p>
g74034
[ 0.04333095625042915, 0.009746220894157887, 0.00636197067797184, 0.0011585851898416877, 0.08999829739332199, -0.036058295518159866, -0.011772587895393372, 0.025420060381293297, 0.0015378904063254595, 0.01692371256649494, -0.04652545228600502, 0.008962481282651424, 0.032283082604408264, -0.07776645570993423, 0.011292016133666039, 0.022982371971011162, 0.0007429455872625113, 0.001960902940481901, 0.007435790728777647, 0.029372768476605415, -0.008621949702501297, 0.0632326751947403, -0.046376220881938934, -0.0031358283013105392, -0.08137961477041245, -0.018478989601135254, -0.007263039238750935, -0.027095474302768707, -0.0858895406126976, -0.03776091709733009, 0.0000511043326696381, 0.05877275392413139, 0.03618364781141281, -0.051962047815322876, -0.040317971259355545, 0.003994660452008247, 0.010654177516698837, -0.0258602537214756, -0.018240025267004967, -0.015146054327487946, 0.008252231404185295, 0.05241174250841141, -0.003792200703173876, 0.021270863711833954, -0.02927543595433235, 0.008066356182098389, 0.034474968910217285, 0.026374492794275284, 0.04430356249213219, -0.030552387237548828, -0.0011762677459046245, 0.04055726155638695, 0.02297857217490673, 0.029202178120613098, -0.010229438543319702, 0.07677726447582245, 0.047247279435396194, 0.004811262246221304, -0.003314853645861149, 0.11347027868032455, 0.058115046471357346, 0.0015810132026672363, -0.04694894328713417, -0.00849912129342556, 0.017719779163599014, 0.0339251384139061, 0.010382394306361675, -0.02076735906302929, 0.03738105669617653, -0.0455489344894886, -0.008970838971436024, -0.058949410915374756, 0.0016924489755183458, -0.00224282662384212, -0.03175141289830208, 0.030704841017723083, 0.03590723127126694, 0.03911237418651581, 0.016484322026371956, 0.06630052626132965, -0.0018911187071353197, 0.01889048144221306, -0.02414209395647049, 0.05506059154868126, 0.02315322868525982, 0.022366875782608986, 0.024124277755618095, -0.011443408206105232, -0.06089369207620621, 0.0102833341807127, 0.04813313111662865, 0.005017916671931744, 0.033541981130838394, 0.012446875683963299, -0.06303425133228302, 0.003830061526969075, -0.017724251374602318, 0.03296317160129547, -0.05128279700875282, -0.06548706442117691, 0.01411338709294796, 0.055773138999938965, 0.015540770255029202, -0.015014256350696087, -0.046634092926979065, -0.03480420634150505, -0.026177052408456802, 0.0038635171949863434, -0.01666685752570629, 0.034975092858076096, -0.03317127749323845, 0.034129634499549866, -0.02394639514386654, 0.004333609249442816, 0.0035388190299272537, -0.01664763130247593, 0.012869540601968765, 0.0012797439703717828, 0.03719840198755264, -0.028846008703112602, -0.0251407939940691, -0.04319562390446663, -0.0540497750043869, -0.04084927961230278, -0.038890331983566284, 0.01489275973290205, 0.003906733356416225, 0.057580653578042984, 0.0484766960144043, -0.027958618476986885, -0.039238445460796356, 0.032557129859924316, 0.02744065597653389, 0.015879882499575615, 0.04675445705652237, -0.010243264026939869, 0.056720148772001266, 0.03364821523427963, 0.006240803748369217, 0.007527271751314402, -0.03980042412877083, 0.0033746857661753893, 0.02639896608889103, -0.056110601872205734, -0.03141775354743004, 0.02543378621339798, -0.00017134695372078568, -0.10120806843042374, -0.0642215684056282, 0.03135748580098152, -0.04281086102128029, -0.033633071929216385, 0.03865442052483559, -0.011006164364516735, 0.007883013226091862, 0.01307377777993679, -0.02422356605529785, 0.019908756017684937, -0.04926782846450806, -0.007054649759083986, 0.028300629928708076, -0.06544405966997147, -0.004876588936895132, 0.024362150579690933, -0.07995607703924179, 0.04512239247560501, -0.01981079950928688, 0.0035302340984344482, -0.03395823389291763, 0.05124592036008835, -0.01809805817902088, -0.023185713216662407, -0.04453541710972786, 0.021190812811255455, -0.00662318104878068, 0.021835749968886375, 0.019714294001460075, 0.0287549439817667, 0.07310297340154648, 0.022740280255675316, 0.00378500041551888, 0.043902430683374405, 0.06383449584245682, -0.01357581838965416, -0.019981825724244118, -0.0256891380995512, -0.06211413815617561, 0.031664252281188965, -0.02385333925485611, 0.00907435454428196, -0.03240868076682091, -0.02817234955728054, -0.010870546102523804, -0.045012228190898895, 0.009489860385656357, -0.00479892548173666, -0.00904056802392006, 0.011808768846094608, 0.01026308722794056, -0.027747293934226036, 0.03128722310066223, 0.019277630373835564, 0.002395282732322812, -0.005059854593127966, 0.029065238311886787, 0.053710900247097015, -0.056331291794776917, 0.08117520064115524, 0.0007923295488581061, -0.005224904045462608, -0.02635355293750763, -0.012351148761808872, -0.014570250175893307, 0.017661765217781067, 0.001793770119547844, 0.024528129026293755, 0.018151046708226204, 0.011388584040105343, 0.000781135109718889, 0.027181021869182587, -0.01692616008222103, 0.005780405830591917, -0.03569095581769943, -0.02908356487751007, -0.027050867676734924, 0.06392638385295868, -0.026142315939068794, 0.020640069618821144, -0.029429912567138672, 0.05024513229727745, 0.0314360111951828, -0.000009388989383296575, 0.01123055350035429, -0.033840566873550415, -0.0124367605894804, 0.05453947186470032, 0.01300211250782013, -0.02648422122001648, 0.02148677408695221, 0.02358415722846985, -0.0211494117975235, -0.009760081768035889, -0.03199036419391632, 0.06748610734939575, -0.026824016124010086, 0.03129680082201958, 0.05169817432761192, -0.04530474916100502, -0.023546971380710602, 0.03200303018093109, -0.01012717466801405, -0.06965654343366623, -0.014923244714736938, 0.0021266168914735317, 0.006568684242665768, 0.042379625141620636, -0.029132429510354996, 0.021536126732826233, -0.02829137071967125, -0.051902107894420624, 0.01185530237853527, -0.02253672108054161, 0.09435904771089554, -0.04575499892234802, -0.031962715089321136, -0.030012894421815872, -0.040935225784778595, -0.08900224417448044, -0.015248451381921768, 0.05350067839026451, -0.033668529242277145, 0.053372081369161606, -0.00303855212405324, 0.02206353098154068, -0.0203523188829422, 0.00862556230276823, -0.01033821515738964, -0.0449456050992012, -0.04086915776133537, 0.014225522056221962, -0.015415526926517487, 0.05794235318899155, -0.04760339856147766, -0.009336257353425026, 0.009666129015386105, 0.034823257476091385, 0.04565557837486267, -0.0040674516931176186, -0.0023467610590159893, 0.055405743420124054, 0.008963009342551231, 0.02747708559036255, 0.07129582017660141, 0.05194650590419769, 0.029649099335074425, 0.028524288907647133, 0.04556566849350929, -0.05091339349746704, -0.02377435564994812, 0.049552883952856064, -0.08441747725009918, 0.011162211187183857, -0.05114491656422615, -0.054532427340745926, 0.03902953490614891, 0.038899220526218414, -0.0751447081565857, 0.01901879720389843, 0.026215458288788795, -0.028273070231080055, 0.021649669855833054, 0.006957971025258303, 0.036111876368522644, 0.044148996472358704, -0.014721011742949486, -0.005128981079906225, 0.048473089933395386, 0.04199712723493576, -0.013875158503651619, -0.015533680096268654, -0.04697966203093529, -0.019788755103945732, 0.03511054441332817, -0.02166544646024704, -0.013948786072432995, -0.0045767733827233315, -0.06942775845527649, -0.012534369714558125, -0.04896476864814758, -0.0122385798022151, -0.04162878170609474, 0.01561746932566166, -0.008363775908946991, 0.061217278242111206, 0.005059942603111267, 0.013129573315382004, 0.048013173043727875, -0.07670571655035019, -0.00081800133921206, 0.0689806118607521, 0.06250948458909988, -0.032715167850255966, -0.022167110815644264, -0.0250083040446043, 0.01736140064895153, 0.04119740426540375, -0.013721073046326637, 0.02812359109520912, 0.03274059668183327, 0.01605273224413395, -0.019648633897304535, -0.08920279890298843, 0.01712017133831978, 0.009689736180007458, 0.02183995395898819, 0.0441838800907135, -0.005299807991832495, 0.014890887774527073, -0.01203363761305809, 0.009331686422228813, 0.017501674592494965, -0.0016866805963218212, -0.035420287400484085, -0.0008523251162841916, 0.009611306712031364, 0.04168718308210373, -0.02186340093612671, 0.04127437621355057, 0.05335193872451782, -0.0433688722550869, -0.013182153925299644, -0.07894311845302582, -0.02820977196097374, 0.08771833032369614, 0.11590619385242462, 0.023938177153468132, -0.0016268149483948946, -0.00827067717909813, -0.015422928147017956, -0.006492130924016237, -0.032450221478939056, 0.0811304897069931, 0.06508119404315948, -0.013897874392569065, 0.004204236902296543, -0.002942658495157957, -0.002410160144791007, -0.04902463033795357, 0.010702811181545258, 0.02927311696112156, -0.015898430719971657, 0.042417410761117935, 0.0027390012983232737, 0.039986398071050644, -0.01111831795424223, 0.005972527898848057, -0.05724010244011879, -0.004243891220539808, 0.019104955717921257, 0.000629507121630013, 0.005588214378803968, -0.018235420808196068, 0.040538180619478226, 0.0058110360987484455, -0.006058776751160622, -0.007799698039889336, -0.008138056844472885, 0.023737845942378044, 0.025922350585460663, 0.05847708135843277, 0.01445070281624794, -0.03962714970111847, -0.01094417180866003, -0.02161482535302639, 0.020941736176609993, 0.07208143919706345, 0.0625259280204773, 0.030317287892103195, -0.01704918034374714, 0.07996450364589691, 0.025585440918803215, -0.029814081266522408, -0.03507756069302559, 0.038341835141181946, -0.016004804521799088, -0.02306075021624565, -0.005684158764779568, -0.0064749158918857574, -0.015956783667206764, -0.02052813582122326, 0.03173407167196274, -0.008153064176440239, -0.005997783970087767, -0.010690509341657162, -0.03479590266942978, -0.020543605089187622, -0.02564634010195732, 0.040760338306427, 0.03939998894929886, 0.02070118673145771, -0.005472168792039156, -0.06325536221265793, -0.01795288920402527, -0.02747236005961895, 0.004090108443051577, 0.058484937995672226, -0.056375958025455475, -0.05804203823208809, 0.032082218676805496, 0.008793407119810581, 0.042345739901065826, 0.016493938863277435, 0.008491604588925838, -0.03071928210556507, 0.05999144911766052, -0.021025827154517174, -0.031155936419963837, 0.024105267599225044, 0.006034364458173513, -0.0074914079159498215, 0.022042151540517807, -0.03739578649401665, 0.08569766581058502, -0.0014536493690684438, -0.01754271611571312, -0.0191904678940773, 0.022645866498351097, -0.021923232823610306, -0.014948091469705105, -0.0005074111395515501, 0.045510005205869675, 0.03394521027803421, 0.019540050998330116, -0.0036098191048949957, 0.024796675890684128, -0.02944425866007805, -0.06053890660405159, -0.009636916220188141, 0.017244977876544, -0.06554795056581497, 0.01070072315633297, -0.011633160524070263, 0.005622994154691696, 0.03407222405076027, -0.0764879509806633, -0.04093296080827713, 0.017153125256299973, -0.02590753696858883, -0.013104398734867573, 0.015568027272820473, 0.04070916399359703, -0.0023792320862412453, -0.004383678548038006, 0.04181929677724838, 0.01165433507412672, -0.09657155722379684, -0.024067573249340057, -0.011456026695668697, 0.03171200305223465, -0.03527911379933357, -0.006436565890908241, 0.0807807520031929, 0.031724050641059875, -0.016783256083726883, 0.05017029494047165, 0.04987360164523125, -0.01837281696498394, 0.035315822809934616, -0.010807814076542854, 0.020817726850509644, -0.03959579020738602, -0.010099003091454506, -0.004167954903095961, -0.0018429962219670415, 0.011831872165203094, -0.008987479843199253, -0.02020513266324997, -0.026153894141316414, -0.006577451713383198, 0.0013814728008583188, 0.020407425239682198, -0.014875123277306557, -0.02940703183412552, -0.039319854229688644, -0.05810818448662758, -0.033851247280836105, -0.04510790854692459, -0.03463044390082359, 0.040970683097839355, -0.013201745226979256, 0.015330730937421322, 0.01518318522721529, -0.00011587642802624032, -0.0039253197610378265, 0.028119105845689774, -0.005731369834393263, 0.041526708751916885, -0.04423435404896736, 0.02002127841114998, 0.0567353293299675, -0.01942589320242405, -0.021990342065691948, 0.014125690795481205, 0.022934958338737488, 0.006343699526041746, -0.04012451320886612, -0.001921465969644487, 0.008210493251681328, -0.02291925996541977, 0.013799924403429031, -0.0035618264228105545, 0.07224331051111221, 0.056050918996334076, 0.0036976237315684557, 0.025064874440431595, -0.03212729096412659, -0.019418850541114807, -0.03879871591925621, 0.012582008726894855, 0.002365478780120611, 0.04232991859316826, -0.0075753615237772465, -0.05288831517100334, 0.04545952007174492, -0.011822101660072803, 0.037980519235134125, 0.018214024603366852, 0.029947903007268906, 0.004092322196811438, 0.05025453492999077, 0.05391127988696098, -0.022824730724096298, -0.0293112825602293, 0.02335897646844387, 0.014972264878451824, 0.0112829077988863, -0.01994159258902073, -0.022811153903603554, -0.034772347658872604, 0.0235503651201725, -0.002260917332023382, -0.012190845794975758, -0.0472412183880806, 0.0037652584724128246, -0.015081612393260002, 0.11114317923784256, -0.01481803972274065, -0.06886222958564758, 0.05862100049853325, 0.0011894686613231897, -0.002452191198244691, -0.07487962394952774, -0.018156321719288826, 0.05052058771252632, -0.028536899015307426, -0.04993779584765434, -0.029734203591942787, 0.0009470326476730406, -0.0314074344933033, 0.026868173852562904, 0.0004442671488504857, -0.00656462088227272, 0.017235351726412773, -0.04096633940935135, -0.02662341110408306, 0.03455071523785591, -0.07106651365756989, -0.04068668186664581, -0.013008452020585537, 0.05678390711545944, 0.029851118102669716, 0.07912024855613708, 0.04341525956988335, 0.026917189359664917, -0.006670378614217043, -0.042686011642217636, -0.017185255885124207, -0.04197800159454346, 0.02490207925438881, 0.003367966040968895, 0.07898584753274918, -0.028492765501141548, -0.05748247355222702, -0.062394965440034866, 0.029980894178152084, 0.03257191181182861, -0.051034118980169296, -0.023944688960909843, 0.02459348365664482, -0.02238376997411251, -0.014649736694991589, -0.06346025317907333, -0.017259055748581886, 0.012018329463899136, -0.02710109017789364, -0.0030412119813263416, -0.06460434198379517, 0.02467968314886093, -0.03720323368906975, 0.03280554711818695, -0.08145088702440262, -0.017473412677645683, 0.026456322520971298, 0.03368883207440376, 0.08265339583158493, 0.0012362130219116807, 0.010155884549021721, -0.03464481979608536, 0.00969105213880539, 0.014897149987518787, -0.06230037286877632, 0.00979051273316145, -0.025818636640906334, 0.021808812394738197, -0.04268157482147217, 0.011375382542610168, 0.03785420209169388, -0.004706737585365772, 0.009823220781981945, -0.019491801038384438, -0.016593163833022118, -0.07428820431232452, -0.05223020911216736, -0.06700114160776138, 0.013508506119251251, 0.008453547023236752, 0.028591176494956017, -0.08540493249893188, 0.005738465581089258, -0.07743733376264572, -0.027058597654104233, -0.01573757454752922, -0.0452696830034256, 0.017986606806516647, 0.007006836589425802, 0.008518450893461704, 0.022699054330587387, -0.0073728738352656364, 0.0422794483602047, 0.004110231064260006, 0.0191129669547081, -0.026626363396644592, -0.017382238060235977, -0.012856880202889442, 0.014370942488312721, 0.024639640003442764, -0.01804821565747261, 0.06143850460648537, -0.040145475417375565, -0.058991946280002594, 0.04921691492199898, -0.04387744516134262, 0.012269078753888607, -0.013657625764608383, 0.02415529079735279, -0.003865585895255208, -0.01913624256849289, -0.026518112048506737, 0.004928856156766415, -0.007727086544036865, 0.026013357564806938, 0.06717294454574585, -0.007116239983588457, -0.020779727026820183, 0.037559643387794495, 0.02864699251949787, -0.03826148808002472, -0.014149547554552555, 0.020447228103876114, -0.09388433396816254, -0.005805459804832935, -0.012896796688437462, 0.030869754031300545, -0.030094098299741745, -0.028370335698127747, -0.04109610244631767, -0.0014552848879247904, -0.06523976475000381, 0.04505462571978569, 0.04367553070187569, -0.05339889973402023, -0.02783311903476715, -0.0194355770945549, -0.035120148211717606, -0.012010762467980385, -0.028568383306264877, 0.051559723913669586, -0.0023477186914533377, 0.03176356106996536, 0.035216283053159714, -0.06278880685567856, -0.040719520300626755, -0.017904268577694893, 0.019811419770121574, 0.08161289244890213, -0.04824952408671379, -0.004381430801004171, 0.07843668758869171, 0.0015016571851447225, -0.04262653365731239, -0.030214956030249596, 0.04231378436088562, 0.07749970257282257, -0.027469005435705185, -0.010950964875519276, -0.033598676323890686, -0.05241243913769722, -0.02542443387210369, 0.04312068596482277, 0.02290278486907482, 0.0008513577631674707, 0.03832651302218437, -0.015471477061510086, 0.03423859179019928, 0.05443509668111801, 0.008635004051029682, -0.020175214856863022, -0.014994177967309952, -0.051819488406181335, -0.020133668556809425, -0.0004940842627547681, -0.01891373097896576, 0.01065786462277174, 0.024835631251335144, 0.0018243432277813554, -0.024747811257839203, -0.0467844195663929, 0.05386915057897568 ]
<p>I performed principal components analysis on continuous variables describing 16 languages. Using the first two axes, which explain 76% of variance, I need to calculate the distance between each pair of languages as appeared on the first two axes; to test in a Mantel test the correlation between distances in linguistic variables and geographic distances. Could anyone help me: how can I do that?</p> <p>cheers</p>
g74035
[ 0.04559488967061043, -0.019222935661673546, -0.017271170392632484, -0.07982280850410461, -0.03213994577527046, 0.0038899623323231936, 0.012304172851145267, 0.059818338602781296, -0.04540076479315758, -0.003355962224304676, -0.013762548565864563, 0.015836426988244057, -0.016978666186332703, 0.009955617599189281, 0.0032065738923847675, -0.03839923441410065, 0.04474026337265968, -0.02495097741484642, -0.009805089794099331, -0.023469367995858192, 0.03923836350440979, 0.036604467779397964, 0.041302528232336044, -0.011416545137763023, 0.012992361560463905, -0.039407551288604736, -0.03582160547375679, 0.05170777440071106, -0.0899517834186554, -0.025648267939686775, -0.01215185783803463, -0.016799645498394966, 0.014203610830008984, -0.03428312763571739, -0.03337938338518143, 0.023590076714754105, 0.018857168033719063, -0.026290016248822212, 0.03873005881905556, 0.05512189120054245, -0.035549283027648926, 0.033516790717840195, 0.005512821022421122, -0.0153736537322402, 0.031678635627031326, -0.025489995256066322, -0.07844620943069458, 0.009748991578817368, 0.026285510510206223, -0.024307966232299805, -0.03974727541208267, 0.061629001051187515, 0.02698746882379055, 0.03317078575491905, -0.0014706782530993223, -0.008197628892958164, 0.026209697127342224, -0.015083416365087032, 0.06786277890205383, -0.020297538489103317, 0.049616433680057526, -0.03899968042969704, -0.06529754400253296, 0.005158152896910906, 0.07491309195756912, -0.01836697943508625, -0.011416742578148842, -0.03245869278907776, -0.04368323087692261, -0.016125282272696495, -0.014845271594822407, -0.07887455075979233, 0.052008919417858124, 0.01055197138339281, -0.09444919973611832, -0.06676165759563446, 0.0015831112395972013, 0.01455219928175211, 0.04074530303478241, 0.024376073852181435, -0.024866709485650063, -0.012313342653214931, 0.032705653458833694, -0.00537843257188797, 0.05194048583507538, -0.039992935955524445, 0.04456133767962456, -0.032477445900440216, -0.04708152264356613, 0.00438919011503458, 0.0014350448036566377, -0.0014969106996431947, 0.05485829710960388, 0.08064665645360947, -0.02023860439658165, -0.062421903014183044, -0.07894141227006912, 0.045777637511491776, 0.00350533751770854, -0.04903729259967804, -0.019288158044219017, 0.05738745629787445, 0.04155615344643593, -0.02656610496342182, -0.013168217614293098, -0.02044585533440113, 0.012657797895371914, 0.03623102232813835, -0.024005193263292313, -0.003384132869541645, -0.061145178973674774, -0.013041842728853226, -0.06572353094816208, -0.006852708291262388, -0.027324959635734558, -0.05181216448545456, 0.025143904611468315, -0.03056151606142521, 0.061547573655843735, 0.021577566862106323, 0.034076184034347534, 0.021723750978708267, -0.0163387693464756, 0.03386380895972252, -0.017656560987234116, -0.010617503896355629, -0.06843315809965134, 0.0068605518899858, 0.05389873683452606, 0.016661370173096657, -0.005648146383464336, 0.010454785078763962, 0.04071024805307388, 0.0010543642565608025, -0.030315469950437546, 0.003936802037060261, -0.034273240715265274, 0.04117859899997711, 0.011061123572289944, 0.07244584709405899, -0.03603491559624672, -0.026690836995840073, 0.03849395364522934, -0.05790391191840172, 0.033732470124959946, -0.02443002536892891, 0.006870997603982687, -0.0705154612660408, 0.02957320399582386, -0.01803203485906124, 0.03231007605791092, 0.03834659233689308, 0.0034173396416008472, 0.03463722765445709, -0.007848580367863178, 0.009506679140031338, -0.043962880969047546, -0.003969529643654823, 0.00759148970246315, -0.013754992745816708, 0.016102047637104988, -0.052869729697704315, 0.057527001947164536, -0.024132343009114265, -0.0014624421019107103, -0.015203248709440231, -0.003516589989885688, 0.02154187485575676, -0.038567498326301575, -0.016668537631630898, -0.04103754833340645, 0.007406578864902258, 0.031182408332824707, -0.05057194456458092, 0.029657578095793724, 0.02682950161397457, -0.013806301169097424, -0.02076314389705658, 0.010673800483345985, 0.055003780871629715, -0.026059290394186974, 0.023372991010546684, 0.0019599348306655884, 0.022233745083212852, -0.006753398105502129, 0.004758730530738831, -0.034316692501306534, 0.012805829755961895, -0.06377183645963669, 0.001010760199278593, 0.031110282987356186, -0.037874531000852585, -0.04456763342022896, -0.025030743330717087, -0.00446759769693017, -0.038713861256837845, 0.055158380419015884, 0.006100713275372982, 0.017778340727090836, 0.00043756962986662984, -0.05348514765501022, 0.02939635142683983, 0.0008075239602476358, 0.04559021815657616, -0.019386587664484978, -0.01265354361385107, 0.016870208084583282, 0.012507913634181023, 0.02225666493177414, 0.0023065232671797276, -0.05364019796252251, -0.05779710039496422, -0.006605138070881367, 0.006090493872761726, 0.024465057998895645, -0.008047432638704777, 0.02158835344016552, -0.015285886824131012, 0.012548204511404037, 0.05486787110567093, 0.032197460532188416, -0.04191488027572632, 0.02181517705321312, -0.035866595804691315, -0.009237542748451233, 0.04422823339700699, -0.00837082602083683, 0.010186387225985527, -0.014837686903774738, -0.03023993968963623, -0.01199836004525423, -0.002181579126045108, 0.07943110167980194, -0.009753720834851265, 0.03340080752968788, 0.005517071112990379, 0.030420906841754913, 0.023040182888507843, -0.04662954807281494, 0.00394054688513279, -0.03081067092716694, -0.028019979596138, 0.03229887783527374, 0.06445547938346863, 0.07190621644258499, 0.024327930063009262, 0.04148707166314125, 0.00509665347635746, 0.030159270390868187, 0.03187063708901405, -0.03019959293305874, 0.0617402046918869, -0.02096511237323284, 0.0033558711875230074, -0.039461344480514526, -0.02087811753153801, -0.011080333031713963, 0.05406351760029793, 0.027270957827568054, -0.02460518293082714, -0.07042095065116882, -0.07143265753984451, -0.012758309952914715, -0.06021249294281006, 0.066703200340271, 0.009296419098973274, -0.030708424746990204, -0.0022300919517874718, -0.020927751436829567, -0.038595106452703476, -0.04961489140987396, 0.044710736721754074, 0.07920359820127487, 0.04991189017891884, -0.059421442449092865, -0.017267758026719093, 0.004136714152991772, -0.0007785090710967779, 0.007828345522284508, 0.08653745800256729, 0.008056427352130413, 0.042098239064216614, 0.0027709247078746557, -0.005343822296708822, 0.05682753026485443, 0.004032236058264971, 0.07680010050535202, 0.06576400250196457, 0.02843400649726391, -0.031237369403243065, 0.02810070849955082, 0.055611275136470795, 0.03385169431567192, 0.0025637922808527946, 0.002055511809885502, 0.02466924488544464, 0.06684141606092453, -0.038596756756305695, 0.04385890066623688, -0.021734820678830147, 0.005685882642865181, -0.045253533869981766, 0.024993235245347023, 0.004647272173315287, 0.03940396383404732, -0.05011960491538048, 0.017158977687358856, -0.026479562744498253, 0.047294989228248596, 0.030580976977944374, -0.018607215955853462, 0.008501948788762093, 0.054620370268821716, -0.027852676808834076, -0.02277103066444397, -0.031975582242012024, 0.003852732013911009, 0.03324572741985321, -0.03136979416012764, 0.0025492445565760136, 0.012028403580188751, -0.09423019737005234, -0.008340217173099518, -0.023825373500585556, 0.020207040011882782, 0.03490686044096947, -0.014766248874366283, 0.06302618980407715, -0.06377676129341125, 0.009152611717581749, 0.005800151266157627, 0.017222393304109573, 0.006084908731281757, -0.029340391978621483, -0.01606198027729988, -0.04781544953584671, -0.019035276025533676, -0.026174984872341156, -0.03963732346892357, 0.0279911607503891, -0.0300254188477993, -0.050044912844896317, -0.013465953059494495, 0.015846598893404007, -0.029038172215223312, 0.019871629774570465, 0.022065583616495132, 0.03701775521039963, 0.026193169876933098, -0.04705777391791344, -0.017299216240644455, -0.048000235110521317, 0.015382778830826283, -0.028093945235013962, 0.04039245843887329, -0.02647862769663334, -0.006835645530372858, -0.034734345972537994, 0.009861385449767113, 0.00792770553380251, 0.01861240528523922, -0.00807219184935093, -0.004924704320728779, -0.007656500209122896, -0.036143917590379715, -0.021555131301283836, 0.03330997750163078, 0.10615290701389313, 0.045375704765319824, -0.009033904410898685, 0.014242235571146011, -0.01889997534453869, -0.05372863635420799, -0.03144872188568115, 0.005544941406697035, 0.04088234901428223, 0.027528714388608932, -0.0020205904729664326, -0.09127161651849747, 0.10296472162008286, 0.01629219762980938, 0.005161129869520664, 0.034441426396369934, 0.03277254104614258, -0.009389410726726055, -0.07584945112466812, -0.0533854179084301, 0.026608992367982864, 0.014109126292169094, -0.017398271709680557, -0.0058235665783286095, -0.04560409486293793, -0.040891095995903015, 0.031973786652088165, 0.03340902924537659, -0.05326231196522713, -0.03164561837911606, 0.06958654522895813, -0.004188159946352243, 0.07345794141292572, -0.045764751732349396, -0.013643267564475536, 0.0675208568572998, 0.012045599520206451, -0.06806783378124237, -0.06493892520666122, 0.0005635623238049448, 0.04996456950902939, -0.0008491627522744238, 0.029005125164985657, -0.07271907478570938, -0.006592235062271357, 0.04729146137833595, -0.06640531867742538, -0.009123152121901512, 0.013116962276399136, 0.04896681755781174, -0.03472102805972099, -0.02950493060052395, 0.004009835887700319, -0.0024597314186394215, 0.0031147911213338375, -0.007394006010144949, -0.019740652292966843, 0.05821621045470238, 0.008349229581654072, 0.02503599040210247, -0.03147897496819496, -0.0011310968548059464, 0.030129041522741318, 0.020064808428287506, 0.02180895023047924, 0.0022555773612111807, -0.012425638735294342, -0.02160213515162468, 0.017866138368844986, 0.0007805742789059877, 0.020777549594640732, 0.014131514355540276, -0.045946087688207626, -0.04324130341410637, -0.008580707013607025, -0.006031564902514219, 0.01340924296528101, -0.006917602848261595, 0.023587072268128395, -0.03333443030714989, -0.06958132237195969, 0.02689661644399166, -0.025649486109614372, -0.00810609757900238, 0.03287273272871971, -0.03439284861087799, -0.020152533426880836, 0.07916021347045898, -0.0022489491384476423, 0.03563851863145828, 0.003482295898720622, 0.07330598682165146, 0.03625122085213661, 0.007115297019481659, 0.017301201820373535, -0.056190550327301025, -0.04241215065121651, 0.013023640029132366, -0.037881508469581604, 0.0037888414226472378, -0.06147918477654457, 0.010313672944903374, 0.005299870390444994, -0.007796057965606451, -0.002696540206670761, 0.009560281410813332, -0.04457502439618111, 0.011116528883576393, 0.06613242626190186, -0.016349373385310173, 0.07269280403852463, -0.006634528748691082, -0.02463681250810623, -0.036308106034994125, -0.006367265712469816, -0.015947863459587097, 0.027957195416092873, -0.02428574487566948, -0.025300294160842896, -0.026037219911813736, -0.07949837297201157, 0.02986994758248329, 0.04359246790409088, 0.0151066854596138, -0.036430370062589645, 0.02446901425719261, 0.007408525794744492, 0.030575286597013474, -0.016127001494169235, -0.06542409211397171, -0.0034620717633515596, 0.048665985465049744, 0.01218191534280777, 0.02059270441532135, 0.03605768457055092, 0.03055597096681595, -0.005680606234818697, -0.0009236420737579465, -0.003524074098095298, 0.0921129435300827, -0.015580297447741032, 0.0013210043543949723, 0.09931894391775131, -0.0006332503398880363, 0.0482422411441803, 0.030054325237870216, 0.0150228226557374, -0.03413163870573044, -0.009717561304569244, -0.0028474736027419567, 0.05120183899998665, -0.001564151025377214, 0.0026973653584718704, 0.06741086393594742, -0.0022210737224668264, 0.01806032657623291, 0.01887083612382412, -0.01732385717332363, -0.0043228198774158955, -0.04561735317111015, -0.06233072653412819, -0.04249770566821098, -0.006561686750501394, 0.003506643231958151, -0.017772648483514786, -0.01182514801621437, -0.04799998551607132, -0.012170004658401012, -0.0644247904419899, -0.021162420511245728, -0.02243693731725216, 0.015379281714558601, -0.010649540461599827, -0.03880176320672035, 0.006567994598299265, 0.020745810121297836, 0.035764049738645554, 0.018576839938759804, 0.013177569955587387, 0.024604525417089462, -0.035221487283706665, 0.016158660873770714, 0.023052535951137543, -0.0038075915072113276, -0.004364195745438337, 0.006260879337787628, -0.055435821413993835, 0.0379544161260128, 0.00012802415585611016, 0.009940693154931068, -0.041061703115701675, 0.04195289686322212, -0.011276697739958763, -0.012017566710710526, 0.009513447992503643, -0.01832088641822338, 0.01653349958360195, -0.033990319818258286, -0.009754272177815437, -0.0239404309540987, 0.053633660078048706, 0.019624562934041023, 0.06627440452575684, 0.019601386040449142, -0.06026199832558632, -0.0395440049469471, 0.017575783655047417, 0.003553314134478569, -0.00927725713700056, 0.010619767010211945, -0.007317465730011463, 0.01413741149008274, 0.0034771361388266087, 0.020319363102316856, 0.02018342725932598, 0.021126238629221916, -0.01969483308494091, -0.06829950213432312, 0.007884231396019459, -0.013590431772172451, 0.047625862061977386, -0.02330600470304489, -0.03152775019407272, -0.03464842587709427, 0.01825316809117794, 0.025769757106900215, -0.047986652702093124, 0.01996266283094883, -0.12598608434200287, -0.009228778071701527, 0.06312573701143265, -0.06452029198408127, -0.011218199506402016, 0.042265359312295914, 0.02770068496465683, 0.016984859481453896, 0.053124431520700455, -0.003118020948022604, 0.023049773648381233, -0.04137657582759857, -0.009054184891283512, -0.03107229433953762, -0.018621882423758507, -0.003973903134465218, 0.05249039828777313, 0.04071127995848656, 0.0661238580942154, 0.04858199879527092, 0.012667086906731129, -0.02478797547519207, -0.017810937017202377, -0.022257104516029358, 0.014749870635569096, 0.04910460114479065, -0.020701097324490547, -0.05544786527752876, -0.06989763677120209, 0.012123482301831245, 0.08535607159137726, -0.015605510212481022, -0.046443331986665726, -0.029939595609903336, 0.0069356271997094154, -0.034652337431907654, 0.041039809584617615, 0.007588883396238089, -0.02087138406932354, -0.07224807888269424, 0.03653253987431526, -0.03860769420862198, 0.042637553066015244, 0.04607237130403519, 0.07356494665145874, 0.03855418786406517, 0.0023400255013257265, -0.03640934079885483, 0.0026176569517701864, 0.037083692848682404, -0.03403853625059128, 0.00897898618131876, -0.02611907199025154, -0.0363602340221405, 0.02400956116616726, 0.037073004990816116, 0.054970674216747284, 0.03241565823554993, -0.017473474144935608, -0.024176426231861115, -0.005314511246979237, 0.06274976581335068, -0.016013963147997856, 0.0004238230176270008, 0.032554008066654205, -0.023232119157910347, -0.06059713661670685, -0.06707742810249329, -0.005337257403880358, -0.006257446017116308, 0.06260516494512558, 0.00413391413167119, -0.015671081840991974, 0.027716733515262604, -0.016730474308133125, -0.04797426611185074, -0.011675785295665264, -0.03924655541777611, 0.02815018780529499, 0.0008400368387810886, 0.042198296636343, 0.02942565828561783, 0.006760374642908573, -0.02886088937520981, -0.025455491617321968, 0.0382332019507885, 0.005348697770386934, -0.0659458190202713, -0.00453530577942729, 0.02161397784948349, -0.02779480069875717, 0.016235407441854477, 0.017199601978063583, 0.03350750356912613, 0.0038852309808135033, -0.0448596253991127, -0.018771784380078316, 0.021959468722343445, -0.038048893213272095, 0.005337524227797985, -0.014785203151404858, 0.034940846264362335, -0.00896559376269579, 0.020199060440063477, 0.036852892488241196, 0.007928092032670975, 0.07190895825624466, 0.03804405406117439, 0.033093784004449844, 0.017028145492076874, -0.01861466094851494, 0.039584681391716, -0.033670470118522644, -0.011845744214951992, -0.023603158071637154, 0.012951685115695, 0.027624623849987984, 0.009311135858297348, 0.08425528556108475, -0.02001168020069599, -0.017118390649557114, -0.003983341623097658, 0.009321805089712143, -0.05413304641842842, -0.024834753945469856, -0.01072884351015091, -0.06485205143690109, 0.008837664499878883, -0.023135319352149963, -0.046317365020513535, 0.004076369572430849, 0.008631967939436436, 0.0058075860142707825, 0.0037755451630800962, -0.01538123469799757, -0.04360579699277878, -0.03951169177889824, -0.08517581224441528, 0.03988202288746834, 0.013629548251628876, -0.028229745104908943, 0.02990778349339962, 0.028212254866957664, 0.0073834871873259544, 0.01174916885793209, -0.013775249943137169, -0.022831488400697708, 0.009046739898622036, -0.011926121078431606, 0.04759026691317558, -0.03653327748179436, 0.02069018967449665, 0.11042006313800812, 0.0530155748128891, -0.026576153934001923, -0.016130488365888596, 0.002065581502392888, -0.028346706181764603, 0.08108344674110413, 0.014681845903396606, 0.03709863871335983, -0.04411110281944275, 0.030158737674355507, 0.06297322362661362, -0.049228485673666, -0.027803093194961548, -0.008367538452148438, -0.03818740323185921, 0.013580012135207653, 0.00482206279411912, -0.057332415133714676, -0.039235979318618774, -0.0077397823333740234 ]
<p>I have time series data for a set of cities that goes back for about 10 years. I also have the data at the state level for almost 30 years. There was an event that occurred about 20 years ago, that is captured in the longer, state level data, but not the city data, that I would like to investigate at the city level. </p> <p>What I think might be useful is to create some kind of ARIMA model that regresses the state data as an exogenous variable. If I were to do this, how do I use the model to backfill the city data such that it ends at the same point as where the actual city data starts? Is there already a canonical method of doing something like this? Thanks for any help you can give (literature references, R libraries, etc.)</p>
g36659
[ 0.06978055834770203, -0.006711610592901707, 0.0014993473887443542, -0.06714504212141037, -0.017029069364070892, -0.007109496276825666, 0.00017783937801141292, 0.0036109420470893383, -0.04210207611322403, -0.005246481858193874, 0.021098192781209946, 0.0703529492020607, 0.06946148723363876, -0.00422675022855401, -0.03883399814367294, -0.04067761078476906, -0.04476483538746834, 0.027836529538035393, 0.020804625004529953, 0.0309650506824255, 0.039073292165994644, -0.007976235821843147, 0.0730452686548233, -0.01386950258165598, 0.013847509399056435, -0.007774023339152336, 0.057303864508867264, 0.018190832808613777, -0.003159469459205866, -0.011719662696123123, 0.028936386108398438, -0.039209045469760895, 0.025411929935216904, 0.01210888009518385, 0.02063811756670475, -0.03749017044901848, -0.01508849672973156, 0.00391434459015727, -0.017462197691202164, -0.009476329199969769, 0.011212962679564953, 0.02386011742055416, 0.044616758823394775, 0.064520463347435, -0.02199729159474373, -0.012015827000141144, -0.0027168183587491512, -0.049518801271915436, -0.0017101633129641414, 0.018950289115309715, -0.010352295823395252, 0.11091820150613785, -0.04072203487157822, -0.027166033163666725, -0.03925270214676857, 0.02658854052424431, 0.006761029828339815, -0.00011340297351125628, 0.053866948932409286, -0.011509387753903866, 0.004139341413974762, 0.02633143961429596, 0.03922276198863983, 0.0016488322289660573, 0.013372083194553852, 0.0360734798014164, -0.06119544059038162, -0.019210809841752052, -0.05263342335820198, 0.01867152377963066, 0.04160025715827942, 0.01780536212027073, -0.015232481062412262, -0.0023513638880103827, 0.0038090255111455917, 0.0030185964424163103, -0.013522734865546227, 0.026653259992599487, 0.008923348039388657, 0.0218708124011755, -0.00832626223564148, 0.024158900603652, -0.005010945722460747, 0.0060736085288226604, 0.02504901774227619, 0.007669560145586729, 0.0015969572123140097, -0.004079642705619335, -0.007489164359867573, -0.03707882761955261, -0.014183232560753822, 0.01880817487835884, 0.10148010402917862, 0.03774718567728996, -0.012057171203196049, -0.007811239454895258, -0.0492573045194149, 0.04332514852285385, -0.024655716493725777, 0.030999287962913513, -0.08264470845460892, 0.00869621429592371, 0.012305919080972672, -0.042968884110450745, -0.1010270044207573, -0.07863646000623703, 0.012637065723538399, -0.03968942165374756, 0.03375492990016937, -0.0017607980407774448, -0.006622841581702232, -0.004959629382938147, -0.0530150942504406, 0.033131904900074005, -0.039663609117269516, 0.008329913951456547, 0.018081067129969597, 0.04496317356824875, -0.03765223175287247, -0.021769924089312553, 0.01038585789501667, 0.009658935479819775, -0.005571268033236265, 0.026903755962848663, -0.037881068885326385, 0.020421037450432777, -0.022445514798164368, 0.01646004617214203, 0.011745871044695377, 0.021513918414711952, 0.021017443388700485, -0.0369424931704998, -0.0014231770765036345, 0.057863496243953705, 0.03611389920115471, 0.019665459170937538, -0.0686986893415451, -0.00352682638913393, 0.023562900722026825, 0.04587513580918312, 0.00034176456392742693, -0.01648976281285286, -0.024040766060352325, -0.01296981330960989, -0.01827212981879711, 0.044301219284534454, 0.049375176429748535, -0.040995363146066666, -0.019188066944479942, 0.02405123971402645, -0.005566678009927273, 0.05156795680522919, -0.05525398999452591, -0.016442114487290382, 0.026684055104851723, 0.04220983386039734, -0.031203273683786392, -0.05388837680220604, -0.06361065059900284, -0.058289431035518646, 0.048059165477752686, -0.026318352669477463, 0.025782449170947075, 0.017165616154670715, 0.03208506107330322, 0.0038058955688029528, -0.02349698729813099, -0.05067367106676102, -0.02099786326289177, -0.07350192964076996, -0.03854809328913689, -0.0076415445655584335, 0.0028971706051379442, -0.007489392068237066, -0.009203150868415833, -0.006927321664988995, -0.013186813332140446, -0.04111278057098389, 0.10692482441663742, -0.04470185935497284, 0.005142646376043558, -0.023743698373436928, -0.014788391068577766, 0.013476523570716381, 0.046963199973106384, -0.024954842403531075, -0.026665160432457924, 0.03760116174817085, -0.05018003284931183, -0.04942105710506439, 0.012612251564860344, 0.0195530466735363, -0.015462310053408146, -0.0011085078585892916, -0.023261800408363342, -0.033337950706481934, 0.03489449992775917, -0.039370957762002945, -0.019175592809915543, 0.0371398851275444, -0.0054739685729146, -0.008138526231050491, 0.012119665741920471, 0.06667808443307877, -0.03874373808503151, -0.017193693667650223, 0.007787719834595919, -0.03508862107992172, -0.05124105513095856, 0.02264283411204815, -0.04484391584992409, 0.014728139154613018, -0.03272240608930588, 0.033918336033821106, -0.013290301896631718, -0.022163743153214455, 0.0024289675056934357, 0.03712102398276329, 0.061727188527584076, -0.012793665751814842, -0.09293746948242188, 0.04440893232822418, 0.06954292953014374, 0.00452785100787878, -0.02607138082385063, 0.014207558706402779, 0.045664940029382706, 0.023137342184782028, -0.02907993085682392, -0.033776335418224335, 0.014452306553721428, -0.002221051836386323, -0.02718338742852211, -0.04833759367465973, 0.1091199442744255, 0.03273488208651543, -0.023728419095277786, -0.017094217240810394, -0.04503684490919113, 0.016362594440579414, -0.01944356970489025, 0.017607929185032845, 0.007748749107122421, -0.0030478874687105417, 0.032411955296993256, -0.054179124534130096, -0.000881523359566927, 0.02953396551311016, 0.005454615224152803, 0.023418359458446503, -0.046817369759082794, 0.0733998641371727, -0.02587667666375637, -0.03090766631066799, 0.05705544725060463, -0.12011827528476715, 0.004385674837976694, 0.07251083850860596, -0.0263593178242445, -0.039783183485269547, -0.03700638562440872, 0.051981549710035324, 0.020556023344397545, -0.008006193675100803, 0.03126052767038345, -0.00661575747653842, 0.03730737417936325, -0.05646323785185814, -0.03963574022054672, 0.009969634003937244, -0.02786162681877613, -0.0011236092541366816, 0.05995647609233856, 0.04778106510639191, 0.05133000388741493, 0.019856764003634453, 0.00746288662776351, -0.007007462438195944, 0.0053700171411037445, -0.01562560722231865, 0.008064365945756435, -0.04606502503156662, 0.04070072993636131, -0.004405882675200701, 0.012860139831900597, -0.03421063721179962, 0.02672777883708477, 0.07230246812105179, -0.00920580793172121, -0.0010147924767807126, 0.008837993256747723, 0.024585966020822525, -0.005035435780882835, 0.02358042448759079, -0.0006992584094405174, 0.01816692017018795, -0.028418200090527534, -0.049477286636829376, 0.06462381780147552, 0.04367882013320923, -0.038761697709560394, -0.1030290275812149, 0.016579443588852882, 0.03244774416089058, 0.004849126096814871, -0.03710660710930824, -0.007332960143685341, 0.0092289038002491, 0.01855289377272129, -0.003624162171036005, -0.051021091639995575, -0.053941644728183746, -0.04487824812531471, 0.015550990588963032, -0.009726080112159252, -0.027440622448921204, 0.03840908780694008, -0.00037642783718183637, -0.007197798695415258, 0.012514406815171242, 0.025960462167859077, -0.05370425060391426, 0.06088215485215187, 0.048664625734090805, 0.015067515894770622, 0.03232615441083908, -0.021147295832633972, 0.011424330994486809, -0.08446776121854782, 0.018815405666828156, 0.0038019735366106033, -0.012110376730561256, -0.003911898005753756, -0.05892388895153999, -0.028253883123397827, 0.011166113428771496, -0.0136071452870965, -0.03897939994931221, -0.009118872694671154, 0.07847652584314346, -0.014869702979922295, 0.017548440024256706, 0.03470662608742714, -0.042345110327005386, -0.020071709528565407, 0.028459778055548668, -0.017048435285687447, 0.029533708468079567, -0.0020580682903528214, 0.005192247685045004, -0.020870789885520935, 0.011997325345873833, -0.012585344724357128, -0.07606309652328491, -0.0037231938913464546, 0.0026067951694130898, 0.042830850929021835, -0.007596919778734446, 0.052933163940906525, -0.004450260195881128, 0.08108926564455032, -0.05080296844244003, -0.04186403751373291, -0.03775614872574806, -0.007639387622475624, -0.0017528615426272154, 0.019090641289949417, 0.06554169952869415, 0.08164852112531662, -0.007495510391891003, 0.06170616298913956, -0.005003596190363169, 0.02717803232371807, -0.01408128160983324, -0.059168197214603424, 0.02176465280354023, 0.06029872968792915, 0.058154456317424774, 0.010728205554187298, 0.07983189821243286, 0.024264615029096603, 0.017835186794400215, 0.01505893375724554, 0.05418871343135834, -0.003351436695083976, -0.007159402593970299, -0.0025511381682008505, 0.013398079201579094, 0.032269805669784546, 0.0030582372564822435, 0.006430170498788357, 0.008634195663034916, -0.01875169202685356, 0.01773954927921295, 0.020031068474054337, 0.008282158523797989, -0.02660519815981388, -0.009450566954910755, 0.007850736379623413, 0.03444131091237068, -0.06793608516454697, 0.06484297662973404, -0.011562510393559933, 0.07150431722402573, -0.038165464997291565, -0.03871051222085953, -0.017521196976304054, -0.06886459141969681, -0.05712774023413658, 0.003517531557008624, -0.06257988512516022, -0.0016704816371202469, 0.0014495868235826492, -0.061291441321372986, 0.031976670026779175, 0.008921640925109386, 0.13103528320789337, -0.004692057613283396, -0.013261614367365837, -0.005191878881305456, -0.009483681060373783, 0.0205056294798851, 0.016213515773415565, 0.06350068002939224, 0.006756054703146219, 0.04481949284672737, -0.028847647830843925, -0.015346064232289791, 0.015924977138638496, 0.04002368077635765, -0.006567732430994511, 0.017345920205116272, -0.024041330441832542, -0.0011486433213576674, -0.03404314070940018, -0.0405922494828701, -0.008444108068943024, 0.021014295518398285, -0.013162056915462017, -0.02909516915678978, -0.027062488719820976, -0.06510628014802933, 0.011457419954240322, 0.043205514550209045, -0.03559119999408722, 0.03722871094942093, -0.034436553716659546, -0.03708517178893089, 0.03753332421183586, 0.02796059660613537, -0.04175620898604393, 0.0516691654920578, 0.02126264199614525, 0.024531764909625053, 0.011432075873017311, 0.026957225054502487, -0.016383962705731392, 0.037294402718544006, -0.012753061950206757, 0.041512928903102875, -0.003957964479923248, -0.03375553339719772, -0.038360677659511566, -0.03525663539767265, -0.023875560611486435, -0.09932150691747665, -0.051498085260391235, 0.0003439650754444301, 0.03531143441796303, 0.00596932228654623, -0.036632467061281204, -0.005760053638368845, -0.011247017420828342, 0.030228236690163612, 0.0013291427167132497, -0.014278666116297245, -0.023627549409866333, -0.05188441276550293, 0.039998847991228104, 0.005055494140833616, -0.03612374886870384, -0.006702086888253689, -0.030993681401014328, -0.00364594510756433, 0.03504640981554985, 0.04074684903025627, -0.00652714166790247, -0.03220336139202118, 0.009099693968892097, -0.013944490812718868, -0.012467059306800365, 0.017599815502762794, 0.11266840249300003, 0.0097008952870965, 0.012465158477425575, -0.059616584330797195, -0.0048150913789868355, -0.03004171885550022, -0.04642200842499733, -0.04850492253899574, -0.02237251214683056, 0.06569498032331467, -0.0022840118035674095, 0.010548052377998829, -0.011419275775551796, -0.032519713044166565, -0.019390325993299484, 0.05975974351167679, -0.036113716661930084, -0.004436932969838381, 0.06023097783327103, -0.022416600957512856, 0.02065289579331875, -0.006475281435996294, 0.018873192369937897, 0.02740010991692543, -0.02716907672584057, 0.04082966968417168, -0.03323360159993172, -0.07381749153137207, -0.061007656157016754, 0.0010045546805486083, 0.033065471798181534, 0.04690929129719734, -0.01823386549949646, -0.0015853249933570623, 0.029142767190933228, -0.023538416251540184, 0.019056901335716248, -0.007988537661731243, -0.03871099278330803, -0.011786988005042076, 0.016508307307958603, -0.017153272405266762, -0.03201117739081383, 0.028631195425987244, -0.03120674379169941, 0.031766992062330246, 0.03759539872407913, -0.043499886989593506, -0.03195931389927864, -0.013793203048408031, 0.037522874772548676, -0.006128425244241953, 0.0022230828180909157, -0.024931268766522408, -0.03211755305528641, 0.03163441643118858, 0.04468918219208717, -0.019506556913256645, -0.03738648444414139, 0.020137598738074303, -0.00803570356220007, 0.0351204015314579, -0.03161932900547981, -0.021090270951390266, 0.03082249127328396, 0.011431239545345306, -0.060757383704185486, 0.021655036136507988, -0.010117592290043831, -0.020761027932167053, 0.10152281075716019, 0.03791059926152229, -0.02649889700114727, 0.010578000918030739, -0.02823255956172943, 0.002626912435516715, 0.045256514102220535, -0.026065990328788757, 0.03469671681523323, -0.0431065633893013, 0.050402481108903885, -0.003949171397835016, 0.005248680245131254, 0.02843066304922104, 0.0322258360683918, -0.01702623814344406, 0.016193900257349014, 0.017275644466280937, -0.06136374920606613, -0.037659138441085815, 0.04246268793940544, 0.019374238327145576, -0.008664336986839771, 0.031714171171188354, -0.0018149254610762, -0.018100829795002937, -0.018314601853489876, 0.03037068247795105, -0.011576158925890923, -0.03680819645524025, -0.0069936164654791355, -0.04417211934924126, 0.0027920850552618504, 0.018375881016254425, 0.010037011466920376, 0.02144136279821396, -0.03041570447385311, -0.07814408838748932, -0.00499753886833787, 0.01386369951069355, 0.024067411199212074, -0.026793932542204857, 0.004734450951218605, 0.008730508387088776, -0.005661290604621172, 0.003408180084079504, 0.05088998004794121, -0.039486076682806015, -0.03477031737565994, -0.014558281749486923, -0.0032588858157396317, 0.08170691877603531, -0.03181307390332222, -0.01020524837076664, 0.03268931061029434, 0.003580318531021476, -0.02747059054672718, 0.021814459934830666, 0.01386749092489481, 0.0037213661707937717, 0.039891406893730164, 0.00896664522588253, 0.03616074100136757, 0.045764729380607605, -0.061507027596235275, 0.056336287409067154, 0.050231195986270905, 0.03458930924534798, -0.016363250091671944, 0.02001958340406418, -0.05578702688217163, -0.018674440681934357, -0.06194120645523071, 0.04597277566790581, 0.01158028282225132, 0.0895477831363678, 0.023098062723875046, -0.012129583396017551, -0.011395979672670364, 0.05377882719039917, -0.005343468859791756, 0.02409326285123825, -0.03836268559098244, 0.001375084975734353, 0.010655262507498264, 0.0327150858938694, -0.020434673875570297, 0.011521345004439354, 0.07029230892658234, 0.04026312753558159, -0.04793451353907585, -0.037201400846242905, -0.00681057246401906, 0.025855600833892822, 0.013158543035387993, 0.03504657745361328, 0.05405091494321823, 0.045998699963092804, -0.029303431510925293, -0.021925801411271095, -0.0063592176884412766, -0.04842868074774742, 0.010986664332449436, 0.08179091662168503, 0.03173043951392174, -0.09640664607286453, 0.043265774846076965, -0.012693729251623154, -0.014543303288519382, -0.11058234423398972, -0.02695470117032528, 0.03174233064055443, 0.05195338651537895, 0.013417511247098446, 0.017995093017816544, 0.0828598216176033, -0.032464105635881424, 0.00040776783134788275, 0.04841575771570206, 0.027458257973194122, -0.0033989332150667906, -0.013933196663856506, -0.02166210301220417, 0.037293583154678345, 0.006210168823599815, 0.021351022645831108, 0.00614037225022912, -0.021079666912555695, 0.013850576244294643, 0.024196328595280647, -0.029939590021967888, 0.00646052323281765, 0.0032928527798503637, 0.005761182866990566, -0.01245379913598299, 0.009507836773991585, -0.03385871648788452, -0.002528277924284339, 0.024888524785637856, 0.04149026423692703, 0.020877573639154434, -0.015916967764496803, -0.015053747221827507, -0.05232354253530502, -0.034581661224365234, -0.03420720621943474, 0.0023235466796904802, -0.04052417725324631, -0.07619041204452515, 0.06404987722635269, -0.0032177786342799664, 0.02862400747835636, -0.022912709042429924, -0.045966316014528275, -0.030664309859275818, -0.004841397050768137, 0.05648838356137276, -0.04412976652383804, -0.11183126270771027, -0.02578076161444187, 0.0335337370634079, -0.03668918088078499, -0.0211640615016222, -0.021750716492533684, -0.040752582252025604, -0.004808634985238314, 0.023084379732608795, -0.008075697347521782, 0.0061048720963299274, -0.043408576399087906, -0.0729551911354065, 0.014660526998341084, 0.0672270730137825, -0.0284553375095129, -0.03159595653414726, -0.02119670994579792, -0.0016452564159408212, 0.009587506763637066, -0.048778045922517776, 0.008392203599214554, -0.0018755396595224738, 0.023233521729707718, 0.02007380872964859, -0.016495535150170326, -0.008555452339351177, 0.08210635930299759, 0.04345760494470596, -0.04594079405069351, -0.014798822812736034, -0.031536150723695755, -0.010520406998693943, 0.01883055828511715, -0.01358585525304079, 0.029335763305425644, 0.019063161686062813, -0.039503127336502075, 0.006605998147279024, -0.07719319313764572, 0.0018880084389820695, 0.000357210636138916, -0.0057382769882678986, 0.011359713971614838, -0.014514347538352013, -0.04406091943383217, 0.026480434462428093, -0.0025731436908245087 ]
<p>What is the best out-of-the-box 2-class classifier? Yes, I guess that's the million dollar question, and yes, I'm aware of the <a href="http://www.no-free-lunch.org/">no free lunch theorem</a>, and I've also read the previous questions:</p> <ul> <li><a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/258/poll-what-is-the-best-out-of-the-box-2-class-classifier-for-your-application">Poll: What is the best out-of-the-box 2-class classifier for your application?</a></li> <li>and <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/5987/worst-classifier">Worst classifier</a></li> </ul> <p>Still, I'm interested in reading more on the subject.</p> <p>What is a good source of information that includes a general comparison of the characteristics, advantage, and features of different classifiers?</p>
g48332
[ 0.028605809435248375, -0.023504283279180527, 0.006352762226015329, -0.00731854559853673, -0.0150475287809968, -0.04931733012199402, 0.02696513943374157, -0.002075236290693283, -0.014530929736793041, -0.030523287132382393, 0.026774967089295387, 0.07906126976013184, 0.055966030806303024, 0.0009991599945351481, 0.01544872671365738, -0.0504426509141922, 0.03976257145404816, -0.037156108766794205, 0.011274629272520542, 0.024101555347442627, 0.05135338008403778, -0.0004521173541434109, 0.040037479251623154, 0.006025811657309532, -0.0387287475168705, -0.007460814900696278, -0.048117704689502716, 0.015968842431902885, -0.0008494649664498866, -0.022680874913930893, -0.030803736299276352, -0.028303278610110283, 0.054481569677591324, -0.027874905616044998, -0.033904433250427246, 0.052856553345918655, 0.010077244602143764, -0.01303944643586874, -0.02185281738638878, 0.03361482173204422, -0.012390191666781902, 0.060741011053323746, 0.03817906603217125, 0.013591881841421127, 0.018992293626070023, -0.039064276963472366, 0.0023397936020046473, 0.0389859601855278, -0.02785908244550228, -0.01225582417100668, 0.004454921465367079, -0.061379510909318924, 0.0062905289232730865, 0.06517139822244644, -0.028307512402534485, -0.017131121829152107, -0.026608388870954514, 0.05476626381278038, -0.011603470891714096, -0.07259222865104675, 0.00678563816472888, 0.045212436467409134, -0.07674296945333481, 0.007854167371988297, -0.05515366047620773, 0.008089807815849781, -0.005344565957784653, 0.037760667502880096, -0.027312103658914566, -0.017778176814317703, 0.010426225140690804, -0.024074271321296692, 0.000774858461227268, 0.029710518196225166, -0.023302163928747177, -0.014523431658744812, -0.03658788651227951, 0.024045461788773537, 0.07713940739631653, 0.001119353692047298, 0.04867745563387871, 0.007658261340111494, -0.016753239557147026, -0.020393792539834976, -0.0009530471288599074, 0.0008711814298294485, 0.01801089383661747, 0.02815621718764305, 0.030509822070598602, 0.031099826097488403, -0.0955989882349968, 0.0027947358321398497, 0.03632234409451485, -0.004362091422080994, -0.04772556200623512, 0.07413370907306671, 0.02241063490509987, -0.04394396394491196, -0.025876251980662346, 0.00019388223881833255, 0.06712298840284348, -0.0028027461376041174, 0.0014308206737041473, 0.02545126900076866, -0.019633736461400986, -0.07099614292383194, 0.06916942447423935, -0.024286918342113495, -0.07725192606449127, -0.03704728186130524, -0.03285396471619606, 0.03659214451909065, -0.020942095667123795, -0.034723516553640366, 0.008520602248609066, 0.0010992350289598107, 0.03202354162931442, -0.061142802238464355, 0.017211129888892174, 0.008843413554131985, 0.024891160428524017, 0.00044044258538633585, 0.03630974516272545, -0.003402183996513486, 0.001834086375311017, 0.0029127865564078093, -0.005176327656954527, 0.023218009620904922, -0.07543712854385376, -0.01738935522735119, 0.03757568821310997, -0.0011422311654314399, 0.000418445240939036, -0.02395247295498848, -0.039338480681180954, 0.12678959965705872, -0.03097262606024742, -0.007015641778707504, 0.013544309884309769, -0.03238747641444206, -0.022485289722681046, -0.008567089214920998, -0.004546038806438446, 0.010246491990983486, 0.02272845059633255, 0.02867838926613331, -0.011236234568059444, 0.009130500257015228, 0.002003660425543785, 0.0765063613653183, 0.044363200664520264, -0.008896260522305965, 0.0033276432659476995, -0.026377832517027855, -0.01843894273042679, -0.0024566957727074623, 0.02700936794281006, -0.014003882184624672, 0.08300236612558365, -0.01898031122982502, 0.014265788719058037, -0.00867007952183485, 0.007583460304886103, -0.012107981368899345, 0.010323824360966682, -0.08405280113220215, -0.00997049268335104, -0.05992577597498894, -0.0028486624360084534, -0.017000088468194008, -0.011424482800066471, 0.0068863769993186, 0.03432546928524971, 0.016307365149259567, -0.009790724143385887, -0.03542260080575943, 0.010682324878871441, -0.036157771944999695, -0.014409814961254597, 0.02579059824347496, -0.019838517531752586, -0.011917944997549057, 0.02767965942621231, 0.02526041865348816, -0.007291445974260569, -0.06975813955068588, 0.02776046097278595, 0.030165638774633408, -0.01649431325495243, 0.01581178791821003, -0.005995127838104963, -0.08684731274843216, -0.013684447854757309, -0.0034513650462031364, -0.05834253504872322, -0.02250167913734913, -0.0002689675602596253, -0.010712509974837303, -0.0210677832365036, -0.029491640627384186, -0.013616696000099182, -0.0009593259892426431, -0.016428742557764053, 0.04374925419688225, -0.023960547521710396, 0.008204104378819466, 0.01949315145611763, -0.02920740470290184, 0.005180639214813709, 0.003854244016110897, 0.008400561287999153, 0.00855607446283102, 0.049115072935819626, 0.01491556130349636, 0.03802087903022766, 0.04130563139915466, -0.08312202244997025, 0.009826688095927238, 0.00043616528273560107, -0.04813656210899353, 0.035987578332424164, -0.019651276990771294, 0.044635988771915436, -0.048698730766773224, 0.017860423773527145, 0.05592300742864609, -0.041903261095285416, 0.012663692235946655, -0.023995213210582733, 0.0486416332423687, -0.008189760148525238, -0.04128902405500412, 0.010377210564911366, -0.04935417324304581, 0.05169067531824112, 0.006455566734075546, 0.036258723586797714, -0.028320908546447754, 0.020552117377519608, 0.025896498933434486, 0.02386075258255005, 0.06105712056159973, -0.019272327423095703, 0.027919592335820198, 0.01197455171495676, -0.08668165653944016, 0.00504856463521719, 0.009035357274115086, 0.060425810515880585, 0.029715055599808693, -0.07123676687479019, 0.031025927513837814, -0.0370103195309639, 0.014411050826311111, -0.0003151526325382292, -0.04449873045086861, 0.042856425046920776, -0.03035103715956211, -0.027999699115753174, 0.004622058942914009, 0.0563972033560276, 0.010763141326606274, -0.001343213371001184, 0.020825844258069992, -0.038386426866054535, -0.033181361854076385, 0.04421071335673332, 0.02885054238140583, -0.00015678325144108385, -0.041609376668930054, 0.012273860163986683, 0.019966837018728256, -0.05187723785638809, 0.0014823653036728501, 0.05272921547293663, 0.01631884276866913, -0.010810182429850101, -0.004556230269372463, 0.005695407744497061, 0.011301185004413128, 0.08133305609226227, -0.036844655871391296, -0.012912227772176266, 0.019656235352158546, 0.09745103865861893, 0.03351287916302681, -0.04935573413968086, -0.005821706261485815, 0.01883055828511715, -0.005844334606081247, 0.0032453222665935755, -0.002452774439007044, 0.010424219071865082, 0.01192555483430624, 0.0303938128054142, -0.04411734640598297, -0.0629672259092331, -0.008389133028686047, -0.009445732459425926, 0.010682972148060799, 0.002727277111262083, 0.003049222519621253, 0.04890342056751251, -0.037346236407756805, -0.0012488339561969042, -0.01054987870156765, -0.008191193453967571, -0.020684923976659775, 0.021520204842090607, 0.00520416721701622, -0.0028746307361871004, 0.04846133291721344, -0.021080706268548965, -0.04061057046055794, 0.028478136286139488, -0.02444271370768547, 0.00012918052379973233, 0.07627908140420914, 0.011087206192314625, -0.030147908255457878, 0.020205182954669, -0.0164109468460083, 0.01277103740721941, -0.04640519991517067, -0.005754711572080851, 0.03676971420645714, -0.003222578437998891, 0.03532405197620392, -0.011131403967738152, -0.02315245196223259, 0.0631265640258789, 0.06656119227409363, -0.016691554337739944, 0.0003225694235879928, 0.01815742626786232, -0.033649880439043045, 0.04006734490394592, 0.028090979903936386, -0.02914474718272686, 0.06944824010133743, 0.04607835412025452, 0.037523750215768814, 0.007956663146615028, -0.015588823705911636, -0.03561290726065636, -0.03412790596485138, 0.034516844898462296, -0.03202292323112488, -0.01019531674683094, -0.02050042897462845, -0.003458659863099456, -0.0058583542704582214, -0.01791139878332615, 0.03763863071799278, -0.01306295394897461, -0.007659229449927807, -0.020074831321835518, -0.06287559866905212, 0.03254501521587372, 0.048551663756370544, -0.02055227942764759, -0.012868406251072884, 0.08032125979661942, 0.01002736110240221, -0.013489659875631332, -0.06587877124547958, 0.033507831394672394, 0.007754071615636349, -0.01883235014975071, -0.02455480955541134, 0.005913042463362217, -0.019445333629846573, 0.02584131248295307, -0.016448095440864563, -0.0033717008773237467, 0.042531754821538925, 0.02134840376675129, 0.07578430324792862, 0.003843010403215885, -0.02408367581665516, 0.046227820217609406, -0.007621698547154665, 0.08609922230243683, -0.01123474258929491, 0.006901295389980078, -0.0395081602036953, -0.05845645070075989, -0.0070624747313559055, 0.015572311356663704, -0.0027930669020861387, -0.02125944383442402, -0.004812529776245356, -0.044297073036432266, 0.023482374846935272, 0.008149712346494198, 0.020822644233703613, 0.0020042601972818375, 0.0061348602175712585, 0.027156569063663483, 0.047191072255373, 0.010551324114203453, -0.009478583931922913, -0.045811690390110016, 0.01123200636357069, 0.015812039375305176, -0.01594226062297821, -0.0691872239112854, -0.011245730333030224, -0.05664185807108879, -0.06219898909330368, -0.04096732288599014, 0.019366106018424034, -0.0011958000250160694, -0.0005434943013824522, -0.01781480573117733, -0.013626485131680965, 0.006323408335447311, 0.0012705994304269552, -0.04942995682358742, -0.047272760421037674, 0.004813920706510544, -0.08364546298980713, -0.04068022966384888, -0.08134602010250092, -0.01902967132627964, -0.007645376957952976, 0.08133111894130707, 0.02580786496400833, -0.031993430107831955, 0.039729390293359756, 0.0802849605679512, -0.03369879350066185, 0.01452446449548006, 0.06928202509880066, 0.022672543302178383, -0.039192091673612595, 0.00432067783549428, 0.027982274070382118, -0.016919629648327827, -0.0632566586136818, 0.007601492572575808, -0.01244677510112524, 0.02518606185913086, 0.035716161131858826, -0.03241075202822685, -0.012220894917845726, 0.009561915881931782, 0.018352536484599113, -0.047682441771030426, 0.023988088592886925, 0.07120463997125626, 0.03176559507846832, 0.0312790647149086, -0.018963316455483437, -0.003030071733519435, 0.022198641672730446, 0.02504768595099449, 0.02765205129981041, 0.0002809182333294302, 0.02531410939991474, -0.038099683821201324, -0.08579988777637482, -0.016576683148741722, 0.03509063646197319, 0.010167606174945831, 0.04944349452853203, -0.08054472506046295, -0.04626553878188133, -0.013516302220523357, 0.031207973137497902, -0.047338321805000305, 0.02293277159333229, 0.016911163926124573, 0.014247646555304527, 0.04434975981712341, 0.036585330963134766, 0.03974371775984764, -0.029720507562160492, -0.00043514519347809255, -0.012831746600568295, -0.025453269481658936, -0.015405243262648582, 0.02246892638504505, -0.036593545228242874, -0.001384369796141982, 0.001583537319675088, 0.045994412153959274, 0.012044033035635948, 0.015967359766364098, -0.0365765318274498, 0.0038608096074312925, 0.0332813635468483, 0.013150305487215519, -0.10386025905609131, -0.029483627527952194, 0.04410119727253914, 0.02375667914748192, 0.038586199283599854, -0.002959183417260647, -0.042248357087373734, -0.13782081007957458, 0.021817995235323906, 0.026891658082604408, -0.03203099966049194, -0.02592558041214943, -0.07710046321153641, 0.10517530888319016, -0.03881600499153137, -0.008524511940777302, 0.03629104793071747, 0.045544736087322235, -0.004737056326121092, -0.01970808580517769, 0.0066531444899737835, 0.043355442583560944, 0.01660151593387127, 0.055154185742139816, 0.01624242216348648, 0.04773005098104477, 0.02471073344349861, -0.013511979952454567, -0.035936277359724045, 0.0547543540596962, 0.02396019920706749, -0.02127477526664734, -0.02890799753367901, -0.03213932737708092, -0.048066701740026474, -0.014734229072928429, -0.011724742129445076, 0.055096060037612915, 0.059830304235219955, -0.005021478049457073, 0.012917830608785152, -0.010553526692092419, 0.02486727014183998, -0.010858605615794659, 0.03530711680650711, -0.04927835613489151, 0.004851652309298515, 0.0006849815836176276, 0.0186570156365633, -0.02460348978638649, -0.03292170912027359, 0.0028711454942822456, -0.009688817895948887, -0.04812614247202873, 0.02230779454112053, -0.0024276874028146267, 0.01788402535021305, -0.003902565222233534, 0.0009309931192547083, 0.07592204958200455, -0.05063696950674057, 0.02832050248980522, -0.019071875140070915, 0.0019544335082173347, 0.020365823060274124, 0.05481807142496109, 0.02422185428440571, -0.04230013117194176, -0.019023695960640907, -0.0026459265500307083, -0.051602236926555634, 0.04380786046385765, -0.014459284022450447, -0.025000911206007004, -0.015620437450706959, 0.02292010374367237, 0.03148052468895912, -0.00266444799490273, -0.008223040029406548, 0.07137402892112732, -0.01795952022075653, -0.014570949599146843, -0.04517001286149025, 0.031102560460567474, -0.01886570081114769, 0.04192717373371124, -0.058945365250110626, 0.022052913904190063, -0.003594781504943967, -0.020280467346310616, -0.05902336537837982, -0.07083354145288467, 0.03920304402709007, 0.024528877809643745, 0.04602835327386856, -0.0481342077255249, -0.04601505398750305, 0.05783522129058838, -0.0063147032633423805, 0.018069978803396225, 0.013667101040482521, -0.005493305157870054, -0.034783098846673965, -0.04200073704123497, 0.013392639346420765, -0.03762806951999664, 0.04890663921833038, -0.02347022108733654, -0.037429265677928925, 0.0507928803563118, 0.011212880723178387, 0.01077862735837698, 0.03509604558348656, -0.012647714465856552, 0.0049963658675551414, -0.049209192395210266, -0.032028086483478546, -0.14095456898212433, 0.009365168400108814, -0.03292738273739815, 0.07475712895393372, -0.034605689346790314, -0.02184070646762848, -0.04037958011031151, -0.07470661401748657, 0.033821556717157364, -0.03626197203993797, -0.002432373119518161, -0.08609087765216827, 0.001849462860263884, -0.005628320388495922, 0.01895809732377529, 0.07161121070384979, 0.019245829433202744, 0.03436850756406784, 0.02155974879860878, 0.011648362502455711, 0.04929219186306, 0.01579502411186695, 0.06043260172009468, 0.028143296018242836, -0.07998929172754288, -0.0125264348462224, -0.004895469173789024, -0.008631204254925251, -0.017306599766016006, 0.08339587599039078, -0.032183632254600525, 0.054563213139772415, -0.03532110154628754, -0.014457286335527897, 0.025717783719301224, 0.004501475486904383, 0.05815893039107323, 0.020172324031591415, -0.049132633954286575, 0.018224982544779778, -0.014057772234082222, 0.01793608069419861, 0.022355942055583, -0.016584038734436035, -0.04463234916329384, 0.03819101303815842, 0.02469754032790661, 0.015967467799782753, 0.025908108800649643, -0.04943101853132248, 0.03133416175842285, -0.02363930642604828, -0.023931562900543213, 0.022259363904595375, 0.02673226222395897, 0.025051694363355637, -0.030434608459472656, 0.0009431913495063782, 0.045417942106723785, -0.015603776089847088, 0.06435985863208771, 0.042470719665288925, -0.016362616792321205, -0.04468629136681557, 0.05871101841330528, 0.0006419140263460577, -0.04272595793008804, -0.04598941653966904, -0.00770549988374114, -0.0496600866317749, -0.024964753538370132, 0.021851830184459686, -0.00804921519011259, -0.019748898223042488, -0.04741022363305092, -0.0016687501920387149, -0.057398103177547455, 0.0160993505269289, 0.055754952132701874, 0.0013470140984281898, -0.031057922169566154, -0.043229132890701294, 0.0017126823076978326, -0.05245194211602211, -0.034465041011571884, 0.003057347610592842, -0.019980432465672493, 0.03115023486316204, 0.07012982666492462, -0.002781467977911234, -0.04278765246272087, 0.009634834714233875, -0.060910750180482864, 0.027640450745821, 0.028678346425294876, 0.0003634778840932995, 0.007669796701520681, 0.025813814252614975, -0.0502953939139843, -0.038979191333055496, 0.06423408538103104, 0.046356286853551865, 0.03354194760322571, -0.04798325523734093, -0.05731286108493805, 0.02045689895749092, 0.013305163942277431, 0.036650389432907104, -0.011309231631457806, 0.028708869591355324, 0.021259799599647522, 0.01891668140888214, 0.03438112884759903, 0.0048930156044662, -0.021288296207785606, -0.06035967916250229, 0.020179789513349533, 0.0034064913634210825, -0.03449583798646927, -0.01677188090980053, -0.07572611421346664, -0.022767947986721992, 0.003410761710256338, 0.08229470252990723, -0.023057883605360985, 0.045604344457387924, 0.05614001303911209, 0.05208323895931244, -0.03388665243983269, 0.025189636275172234, -0.015888512134552002, 0.04370329901576042, 0.008802891708910465, -0.042131200432777405, -0.029470158740878105, -0.03817398473620415, -0.038814693689346313, 0.022409167140722275, 0.020673733204603195, -0.07840795814990997, -0.0668044462800026, 0.01801939122378826, -0.020126063376665115, 0.008054949343204498, 0.005951426923274994, -0.007530002389103174, 0.05214180424809456, 0.01337684877216816, 0.03984072431921959, 0.00577487051486969, 0.015353761613368988, -0.015196661464869976, -0.019589446485042572, -0.034976232796907425, 0.014707284048199654, -0.0016519639175385237, 0.020543595775961876, 0.028790155425667763 ]
<p>When estimating the confidence interval of mean, I think both the bootstrap t method and the nonparametric bootstrap method can apply, but the former requires a little more computation. </p> <p>I wonder what the advantages and disadvantages of bootstrap t over the normal nonparametric bootstrap are? Why? </p> <p>Are there some references for explaining this?</p>
g74036
[ 0.03250521793961525, 0.032440122216939926, 0.01656949520111084, 0.006172208581119776, -0.028536422178149223, 0.02015501633286476, 0.04310635104775429, -0.03421368449926376, -0.09321863949298859, 0.005435142200440168, 0.016420403495430946, -0.01056759711354971, 0.04730597510933876, 0.01916354149580002, -0.06521853059530258, -0.016996633261442184, 0.028795674443244934, -0.011941611766815186, 0.02795345149934292, -0.006382928695529699, -0.053764428943395615, -0.02473905310034752, 0.01837926357984543, -0.0029386943206191063, -0.09407061338424683, -0.024324551224708557, -0.06337905675172806, 0.09476032853126526, 0.017660673707723618, -0.059721361845731735, -0.01407922524958849, 0.0018331134924665093, 0.06233694404363632, 0.018745658919215202, -0.010347836650907993, -0.007277165073901415, 0.05663561820983887, 0.01887715980410576, 0.0491047203540802, -0.02760508470237255, -0.054861802607774734, 0.05279894173145294, -0.002911636605858803, 0.017713317647576332, -0.009973925538361073, -0.06836242228746414, -0.021812856197357178, -0.008801106363534927, 0.043819405138492584, 0.006428990513086319, -0.005820706952363253, 0.03822203353047371, 0.041267164051532745, -0.007846440188586712, 0.005475090350955725, -0.02571978233754635, 0.058774206787347794, -0.00579241244122386, -0.002728088991716504, 0.002702937927097082, 0.03681957349181175, -0.0027649803087115288, -0.014527370221912861, -0.021125633269548416, 0.03708554059267044, -0.0019338995916768909, -0.05441535636782646, -0.017095638439059258, 0.004885409492999315, 0.02301020361483097, 0.025654558092355728, 0.02302250638604164, -0.0384545661509037, -0.04236249998211861, -0.10532508045434952, -0.020172521471977234, -0.01228353288024664, 0.01605020835995674, 0.013059589080512524, 0.06598515808582306, 0.00439677806571126, -0.006204879842698574, -0.030014341697096825, 0.011300033889710903, -0.02062319591641426, 0.006949805188924074, -0.008712662383913994, -0.006601974833756685, 0.0019383166218176484, 0.02047143131494522, -0.03566135838627815, 0.010035688057541847, 0.046482570469379425, 0.0422394797205925, -0.06276465207338333, -0.01805441454052925, -0.03159398213028908, 0.016017869114875793, -0.0036830466706305742, 0.050210338085889816, 0.016831472516059875, 0.03364429622888565, -0.015722522512078285, -0.0035326580982655287, -0.00834585726261139, -0.042355213314294815, -0.028505612164735794, -0.005199940409511328, -0.022998495027422905, 0.029365209862589836, 0.0032951291650533676, -0.010936928912997246, -0.016731375828385353, -0.027449902147054672, -0.027142873033881187, 0.05945723131299019, 0.07719571143388748, -0.040208786725997925, 0.008831966668367386, 0.05317000299692154, 0.01337169948965311, 0.020825359970331192, -0.005941895302385092, 0.06127379834651947, -0.09430313855409622, 0.001015832182019949, -0.05998408794403076, 0.02179560996592045, 0.00012951188546139747, -0.01510581560432911, 0.05879107117652893, 0.017936471849679947, -0.040927451103925705, -0.018419919535517693, 0.02435360848903656, 0.04310018569231033, -0.03833938390016556, 0.01786458119750023, -0.014354486018419266, 0.02304641529917717, -0.05178040638566017, 0.01158817857503891, 0.038542620837688446, 0.0032378463074564934, 0.028346460312604904, 0.0028290485497564077, -0.04564428701996803, 0.028680549934506416, -0.050893351435661316, 0.06104695424437523, 0.02173371985554695, 0.0641913115978241, 0.04601515457034111, -0.042859580367803574, -0.019476983696222305, 0.009174312464892864, 0.032046571373939514, -0.019828880205750465, -0.03279796242713928, 0.039732012897729874, 0.00978296808898449, -0.0440051294863224, 0.034202225506305695, -0.0031144728418439627, 0.0016145751578733325, -0.048127640038728714, 0.053131066262722015, -0.06142204999923706, -0.047139886766672134, -0.04323356971144676, 0.06214671581983566, 0.011916516348719597, 0.03721575811505318, -0.044462841004133224, 0.002905268920585513, -0.07018493860960007, -0.023343876004219055, 0.011883602477610111, 0.027804862707853317, 0.017947353422641754, 0.06625646352767944, 0.031168216839432716, -0.04458998516201973, -0.0506553128361702, -0.00038913224125280976, -0.04434783756732941, 0.02430393174290657, 0.028548214584589005, -0.014208320528268814, -0.007537138182669878, 0.010556546971201897, -0.05032236874103546, 0.013580746948719025, 0.006640661973506212, -0.07870467752218246, -0.05004720389842987, 0.05266282334923744, 0.0035468970891088247, 0.014295494183897972, 0.022730350494384766, -0.018980542197823524, -0.03299737349152565, -0.015686413273215294, -0.018497273325920105, -0.024469856172800064, -0.0042495885863900185, 0.0034024007618427277, -0.00750709418207407, -0.009949191473424435, -0.016151687130331993, -0.012367939576506615, 0.04062127321958542, 0.0403052419424057, -0.01442241296172142, 0.007793830242007971, 0.015085144899785519, -0.03357969596982002, 0.02494879812002182, 0.033961232751607895, -0.01846325770020485, -0.008552859537303448, -0.0039839413948357105, -0.0004132044268772006, -0.05939212441444397, 0.02142714522778988, 0.090568907558918, 0.017369652166962624, -0.004598522558808327, -0.04153328388929367, 0.07307402044534683, -0.02119097299873829, -0.06529586762189865, -0.013973248191177845, 0.011848374269902706, 0.0065014660358428955, 0.016797708347439766, 0.06544957309961319, -0.014809818007051945, 0.017493363469839096, 0.07770434767007828, 0.056880827993154526, -0.009395340457558632, -0.008498870767652988, 0.02438616007566452, -0.062447626143693924, -0.05897815153002739, 0.00281606987118721, -0.05651075392961502, 0.04542514681816101, -0.04505358636379242, 0.021279020234942436, 0.0847044512629509, 0.0193695817142725, -0.05519667640328407, 0.02759680151939392, -0.01302969828248024, 0.0012569426326081157, -0.05217641219496727, -0.000874638557434082, -0.012928904965519905, -0.026187945157289505, 0.03866194561123848, -0.0003074589476455003, -0.02108869142830372, -0.003739318111911416, -0.034789226949214935, -0.03211218863725662, -0.005794725380837917, -0.034382328391075134, 0.014156665652990341, -0.01065121777355671, -0.0024433813523501158, -0.0018872282234951854, 0.026665162295103073, 0.01067841425538063, -0.02423032373189926, 0.04359392076730728, -0.03145047649741173, -0.017996342852711678, -0.016366951167583466, -0.06063743308186531, -0.023854410275816917, 0.018803970888257027, 0.025737861171364784, -0.011008069850504398, 0.0032183118164539337, 0.06438039988279343, -0.07873698323965073, -0.014360969886183739, -0.018962647765874863, 0.02139585092663765, -0.03740986809134483, -0.034285321831703186, 0.012586268596351147, -0.019218483939766884, -0.001813575392588973, 0.023347841575741768, -0.05404626578092575, 0.06887014210224152, -0.011312076821923256, -0.01895829103887081, 0.03247296065092087, -0.008007648400962353, -0.05234707519412041, 0.03201291337609291, 0.017817635089159012, -0.01416771486401558, -0.0151759572327137, 0.009328528307378292, 0.05147692933678627, 0.016879698261618614, 0.030455727130174637, -0.005546841770410538, 0.012069102376699448, -0.029924355447292328, -0.030482672154903412, 0.010080192238092422, 0.02670241706073284, 0.03082606941461563, 0.017303571105003357, 0.03078925423324108, -0.057070910930633545, -0.026518547907471657, 0.03107602521777153, 0.0051479400135576725, -0.019038178026676178, -0.027743859216570854, 0.040908850729465485, -0.0317576639354229, 0.0014341891510412097, 0.04472770169377327, -0.024671901017427444, 0.05980059131979942, 0.03505833446979523, -0.022466514259576797, -0.06066001206636429, 0.09655871987342834, 0.07542480528354645, -0.023806622251868248, -0.006704544648528099, 0.015168284066021442, -0.020510317757725716, -0.009371577762067318, -0.023688197135925293, -0.03535500913858414, -0.02462184801697731, 0.05941251665353775, -0.00670171994715929, 0.01420698594301939, -0.004173212684690952, -0.052114155143499374, -0.0051744855009019375, 0.011587214656174183, -0.009205659851431847, 0.05241762474179268, 0.033119410276412964, 0.002218111651018262, -0.005558830685913563, 0.09177084267139435, 0.019084058701992035, 0.027485713362693787, -0.017713498324155807, 0.031594716012477875, 0.04882460832595825, -0.015339150093495846, -0.017536448314785957, 0.01010097935795784, 0.060106534510850906, -0.011608332395553589, -0.04139653965830803, -0.050147734582424164, 0.07363412529230118, 0.037670135498046875, -0.017951600253582, -0.021429765969514847, 0.01001362968236208, 0.057106345891952515, -0.052806586027145386, 0.02057301066815853, -0.008157743141055107, 0.040408145636320114, -0.02458610013127327, -0.03587424382567406, -0.02096489630639553, 0.004203627817332745, -0.06843347102403641, -0.031547680497169495, -0.023859765380620956, 0.013099859468638897, -0.01808628812432289, 0.006958039943128824, -0.02688204124569893, -0.030163055285811424, 0.007160629145801067, -0.017995374277234077, 0.008955123834311962, -0.015762098133563995, 0.005311648827046156, 0.06399727612733841, 0.008350180462002754, 0.005142928566783667, -0.013721668161451817, 0.02537664771080017, 0.052783042192459106, -0.02138645574450493, -0.009712109342217445, 0.027900123968720436, -0.0028118668124079704, -0.010614918544888496, -0.019124941900372505, 0.031053390353918076, 0.03661100193858147, 0.045031581073999405, 0.013898788020014763, 0.027562057599425316, -0.03623748943209648, 0.03831900283694267, 0.019442327320575714, -0.00010341314919060096, 0.00998377799987793, 0.002054608426988125, -0.02018086425960064, -0.091402567923069, -0.03238080069422722, 0.014545402489602566, 0.036644913256168365, 0.0047169337049126625, -0.023925265297293663, -0.040175922214984894, -0.024935416877269745, -0.010307448916137218, 0.033159639686346054, -0.029387902468442917, 0.04159591719508171, 0.00007164913404267281, -0.0030487028416246176, 0.05062415823340416, 0.042714010924100876, -0.033602338284254074, -0.10234766453504562, -0.00585028575733304, 0.03453449904918671, -0.01706967130303383, -0.020280320197343826, -0.05964529886841774, 0.023052455857396126, -0.002639489248394966, -0.034730665385723114, -0.05398279428482056, -0.010190563276410103, -0.01445929054170847, 0.08534632623195648, -0.01991387829184532, -0.01447572186589241, 0.01697460189461708, -0.04282672330737114, -0.01738552749156952, 0.014411089941859245, 0.041113920509815216, 0.04889828711748123, 0.019213654100894928, -0.04882800206542015, -0.014249750413000584, -0.05020847171545029, 0.048133864998817444, 0.011484604328870773, -0.12809979915618896, -0.010832623578608036, 0.030061544850468636, 0.003936275839805603, -0.04406757652759552, -0.021490536630153656, 0.039740126579999924, 0.02430802397429943, 0.026880713179707527, 0.01181515958160162, 0.0030332470778375864, 0.02098044380545616, 0.01348489336669445, 0.0032453122548758984, 0.006649968214333057, 0.022516274824738503, 0.0065140314400196075, 0.04325985535979271, -0.019395258277654648, -0.022985881194472313, -0.002944603096693754, -0.10255400836467743, 0.022087134420871735, 0.012665477581322193, 0.012307406403124332, 0.055162910372018814, 0.05055605620145798, 0.004340583924204111, 0.0028449739329516888, -0.007224968168884516, 0.03849456459283829, 0.029956107959151268, -0.037532027810811996, 0.035798754543066025, -0.08051250874996185, -0.010224523022770882, 0.035982485860586166, -0.018535135313868523, -0.006898213177919388, 0.0010441082995384932, 0.07467835396528244, 0.03670394420623779, 0.03670575097203255, 0.09254169464111328, -0.010630824603140354, 0.0027068238705396652, -0.01637352630496025, -0.027114946395158768, 0.0003117347660008818, -0.017068451270461082, 0.015742596238851547, -0.03553677722811699, -0.02424171380698681, -0.03950934112071991, 0.02100970223546028, 0.004918274935334921, -0.03147295117378235, -0.019037136808037758, 0.025166122242808342, -0.047476500272750854, -0.013124721124768257, -0.011828158982098103, 0.015128952451050282, -0.03574241325259209, 0.005731285084038973, -0.0327129140496254, 0.033787839114665985, 0.039917953312397, -0.007730326149612665, -0.03215330094099045, -0.005653593689203262, 0.050385136157274246, 0.0007810657843947411, -0.04909701272845268, -0.04090083763003349, -0.022282883524894714, -0.009243530221283436, 0.005590104963630438, 0.08911365270614624, 0.009531372226774693, -0.010594208724796772, 0.03484741970896721, 0.0018724784022197127, -0.04531605541706085, 0.03263399749994278, 0.03176810219883919, -0.030231453478336334, -0.029813308268785477, -0.03260992467403412, 0.07166263461112976, 0.006561459507793188, 0.01799575425684452, -0.01797253079712391, 0.05156752094626427, -0.03400203213095665, -0.0033732112497091293, 0.007437854539602995, 0.025185370817780495, -0.0036346972920000553, 0.011988080106675625, -0.057249683886766434, 0.06000495329499245, -0.031084498390555382, -0.03061707690358162, 0.027091480791568756, -0.032496269792318344, 0.031181467697024345, 0.06156067177653313, -0.006943040527403355, -0.01197653729468584, -0.00563790462911129, 0.02791207656264305, 0.048506226390600204, -0.06178664043545723, -0.013207477517426014, -0.048421744257211685, -0.01883939653635025, -0.0034389833454042673, 0.018535545095801353, 0.014447445049881935, -0.005182190332561731, -0.03393769636750221, -0.03064439631998539, 0.0007280958816409111, 0.011728501878678799, -0.016418004408478737, -0.011555329896509647, -0.09008336067199707, 0.037157900631427765, -0.07470786571502686, -0.03647656366229057, -0.024191489443182945, -0.01853066496551037, -0.059589747339487076, -0.06489235162734985, -0.00839764904230833, 0.006579110398888588, -0.010805182158946991, 0.008789896965026855, 0.005140612833201885, 0.05310792103409767, 0.038481298834085464, 0.030549734830856323, 0.003024999052286148, -0.012196628376841545, 0.024558357894420624, 0.05833030492067337, 0.07849213480949402, 0.002184805227443576, 0.03376740962266922, -0.08557163923978806, 0.01898476667702198, -0.023464441299438477, 0.07976199686527252, -0.02093888260424137, -0.0615798681974411, -0.01790270209312439, 0.01995217800140381, 0.02031870000064373, 0.04883112385869026, -0.05596329644322395, 0.04333489015698433, -0.000017181908333441243, -0.0037263217382133007, -0.02367752231657505, -0.033706869930028915, 0.02578592672944069, 0.04353039711713791, -0.06954549998044968, 0.0818236917257309, -0.048846084624528885, 0.022679436951875687, 0.0081919701769948, 0.025712423026561737, -0.03905424475669861, 0.024973681196570396, 0.055188875645399094, -0.051911789923906326, -0.004514698870480061, 0.06285624951124191, -0.022322194650769234, 0.0309718307107687, -0.0862121507525444, -0.0007258664118126035, -0.01801685057580471, 0.053430866450071335, -0.053614143282175064, -0.04229948669672012, 0.01777879148721695, 0.04116624593734741, 0.0021136740688234568, 0.08321291208267212, 0.054760973900556564, -0.0702204778790474, 0.024272264912724495, -0.014234323054552078, -0.018994858488440514, 0.02419973909854889, 0.08019787818193436, 0.02175218053162098, 0.015596211887896061, -0.0033616479486227036, -0.023222114890813828, 0.008619007654488087, 0.002471142914146185, -0.019114088267087936, -0.0194474495947361, -0.018676750361919403, 0.022800901904702187, 0.018314052373170853, -0.0025212583132088184, -0.0005950521444901824, -0.04549822583794594, 0.002520345151424408, -0.05559058487415314, -0.007497705053538084, -0.03927554190158844, -0.03762924298644066, 0.006496008485555649, 0.048033177852630615, 0.04008324444293976, -0.0020117880776524544, 0.002968447981402278, -0.0008597343694418669, -0.07606261968612671, -0.0448233000934124, -0.009016049094498158, 0.02939019538462162, 0.011471215635538101, 0.026858694851398468, -0.06560149788856506, -0.01735331490635872, 0.03953677415847778, 0.002021990716457367, 0.0035667952615767717, 0.03711969777941704, -0.02734755538403988, -0.00787055678665638, 0.03625619783997536, -0.01262899674475193, -0.028197195380926132, -0.04653148725628853, -0.07112544775009155, -0.027574189007282257, 0.061861373484134674, 0.05502999946475029, 0.031972259283065796, -0.010604726150631905, -0.006042920984327793, -0.008629542775452137, -0.020934782922267914, -0.049750152975320816, -0.03550019860267639, -0.0013408936792984605, 0.041310880333185196, -0.06517007946968079, 0.009018528275191784, -0.010029425844550133, 0.008102607913315296, -0.031186558306217194, -0.04713989049196243, 0.05782109126448631, -0.0012395766098052263, -0.010685930959880352, 0.027988513931632042, -0.024393273517489433, -0.03793039545416832, 0.01410621590912342, 0.01836298406124115, 0.004702630918473005, 0.12897802889347076, -0.0031739985570311546, -0.02637256495654583, 0.03659309446811676, -0.05145084112882614, 0.04357064142823219, 0.040184393525123596, -0.011617222800850868, 0.0028104998636990786, 0.04207606986165047, -0.014510290697216988, 0.031994275748729706, 0.008207661099731922, -0.02569076232612133, -0.03979557380080223, 0.008325876668095589, 0.02576749585568905, 0.053730886429548264, -0.002052313182502985, 0.02070506475865841, -0.036583442240953445, 0.01343857403844595, 0.032472558319568634, -0.007656907197088003, 0.04349097982048988, -0.005127645097672939, 0.023920131847262383, -0.052913881838321686, 0.005389428697526455, -0.015359243378043175, -0.06240236014127731, 0.00976141169667244 ]
<p>I have a total population of 31, of these I have a treatment finishing population of 20.</p> <p>I want to run a test on SPSS to identify if there are any significant differences between the 20 individuals that completed the treatment and the group as a whole.</p> <p>The variables I am trying to compare are age, weight, height and BMI.</p> <p>I have run descriptives for both the entire population and the sub group seperatley, I can see there is little difference between the groups but would like to know the statistical significance</p>
g74037
[ -0.009027162566781044, -0.03371460363268852, -0.033459845930337906, -0.04596635326743126, -0.04587564244866371, -0.013592340983450413, 0.023293882608413696, 0.03809305652976036, 0.005021922290325165, -0.03364935517311096, 0.03635834529995918, 0.023140406236052513, 0.014472397975623608, 0.03424186632037163, -0.04090895503759384, -0.04362840577960014, 0.022627834230661392, -0.041129693388938904, -0.003695614403113723, -0.00015491755038965493, 0.011200515553355217, 0.01609363779425621, 0.005409753415733576, 0.009665914811193943, -0.004290139768272638, 0.006053002085536718, -0.030896617099642754, 0.0321342870593071, -0.04234236478805542, 0.007528346031904221, 0.011977341957390308, 0.048923805356025696, 0.0702519565820694, -0.030781274661421776, -0.012155354022979736, -0.060014508664608, 0.06108531355857849, 0.03614698722958565, 0.012078757397830486, 0.034047190099954605, 0.03029918484389782, 0.03089309111237526, 0.012091965414583683, -0.032000694423913956, -0.02519863471388817, 0.011645101942121983, 0.0023152881767600775, 0.009630012325942516, -0.026819806545972824, 0.021029790863394737, -0.0002630933013278991, 0.006557080894708633, -0.029647130519151688, 0.020390355959534645, -0.008804259821772575, -0.07738988101482391, 0.019278770312666893, 0.03865467756986618, 0.03511922433972359, 0.022673239931464195, 0.01679607853293419, 0.008768524043262005, -0.067930668592453, 0.016257330775260925, 0.03853437677025795, -0.04168802499771118, 0.06119992583990097, -0.04768339917063713, 0.00698702922090888, -0.02819456160068512, -0.040627673268318176, -0.011419776827096939, 0.0826181098818779, 0.0012852192157879472, -0.004743439611047506, -0.023062584921717644, -0.051615096628665924, 0.03013639710843563, -0.05917486920952797, 0.00913202203810215, 0.01977882906794548, -0.03219309076666832, -0.003745016176253557, 0.03741024434566498, 0.06025123596191406, -0.009168131276965141, -0.013652791269123554, -0.017145929858088493, -0.016640126705169678, 0.03222041577100754, 0.025822611525654793, 0.01302521675825119, 0.05031444877386093, 0.10303639620542526, -0.06327789276838303, 0.005989277269691229, -0.007103982847183943, -0.0010326311457902193, -0.005434158258140087, -0.003014268819242716, -0.0810585767030716, 0.012197495438158512, 0.01440065074712038, -0.021969592198729515, -0.036402568221092224, 0.005350429564714432, -0.0006177830509841442, 0.04656631126999855, -0.022851834073662758, 0.01210439670830965, 0.00787346065044403, -0.018061775714159012, -0.0551917739212513, 0.025644080713391304, -0.036197319626808167, -0.012388668023049831, 0.01880214735865593, -0.06496070325374603, -0.05894056335091591, -0.09864620864391327, 0.004382749553769827, 0.00036104032187722623, 0.019306594505906105, -0.0006788098835386336, -0.06013226881623268, 0.03680117428302765, -0.01858454756438732, 0.008603496477007866, 0.012291272170841694, 0.026528572663664818, 0.0071114664897322655, -0.0039346544072031975, -0.012969031929969788, 0.024569222703576088, 0.016519462689757347, 0.010193479247391224, 0.012356012128293514, 0.08071032166481018, -0.005373985506594181, -0.016079949215054512, -0.029087571427226067, 0.0431496798992157, -0.03051687590777874, 0.03185192123055458, -0.004814657382667065, 0.02130122482776642, -0.018176419660449028, 0.0006695428164675832, -0.04613325372338295, 0.013208316639065742, 0.07403203845024109, 0.004909512586891651, -0.008567665703594685, 0.011852550320327282, -0.1047058179974556, -0.03674257546663284, -0.0684753879904747, -0.005001867655664682, -0.01601365953683853, 0.037067875266075134, -0.050465136766433716, -0.029407372698187828, 0.032459624111652374, 0.015552899800240993, 0.007501185405999422, -0.004789785016328096, 0.002385698724538088, -0.00504295714199543, -0.0008292752900160849, 0.015695713460445404, -0.0068372138775885105, -0.018180079758167267, 0.02244466356933117, 0.03792809695005417, 0.07287268340587616, 0.037522487342357635, 0.05654340237379074, -0.05997190251946449, 0.06467065215110779, 0.026806484907865524, 0.018004097044467926, 0.006403799168765545, 0.004503208212554455, -0.035518795251846313, 0.015050468035042286, 0.025475479662418365, -0.054522570222616196, -0.015723273158073425, -0.07033480703830719, 0.019985437393188477, -0.03544396534562111, -0.025872712954878807, -0.009021688252687454, -0.006250941194593906, -0.009435724467039108, -0.023522023111581802, 0.0004953406169079244, 0.011721868067979813, -0.013325752690434456, -0.08026857674121857, 0.02286328375339508, 0.0740843340754509, -0.04593838006258011, 0.04645766690373421, -0.04692903533577919, -0.009749995544552803, -0.04343462362885475, -0.00818095076829195, -0.09119448810815811, 0.028144024312496185, -0.01506118569523096, -0.01573122851550579, 0.028142740949988365, 0.016455402597784996, 0.03588151931762695, -0.0015905931359156966, -0.003423158312216401, 0.034300290048122406, 0.030123630538582802, 0.03496754169464111, 0.0012849908089265227, 0.017903730273246765, 0.024469643831253052, -0.02121950499713421, 0.031783200800418854, 0.029386242851614952, 0.004721422214061022, 0.030039716511964798, -0.0030114075634628534, 0.01636693812906742, -0.03551764413714409, -0.03215671703219414, 0.05429825931787491, -0.08999404311180115, -0.044845350086688995, -0.005591315682977438, 0.05661075562238693, -0.029451368376612663, 0.01794256642460823, 0.08330902457237244, 0.015594718977808952, -0.026265699416399002, -0.0001996911014430225, 0.04068470001220703, 0.06661053746938705, 0.0036914320662617683, -0.0038669498171657324, 0.006641322281211615, -0.00558670237660408, 0.018236063420772552, -0.04195769876241684, 0.030127055943012238, -0.010067109018564224, 0.010435717180371284, 0.026746841147542, -0.0024230501148849726, -0.01147303357720375, -0.031148262321949005, -0.04756326600909233, -0.004732146859169006, -0.041118256747722626, -0.02814038097858429, 0.02866782806813717, 0.030139997601509094, 0.04489967226982117, -0.03718221187591553, 0.007741461042314768, -0.04229298606514931, -0.028473248705267906, 0.0026879790239036083, -0.006867271848022938, 0.016339169815182686, 0.03273172676563263, 0.0760176032781601, 0.005259452387690544, 0.005467060953378677, -0.011213324032723904, 0.004243948496878147, 0.03840775415301323, -0.004276816733181477, 0.04571613669395447, -0.007731342222541571, -0.021954067051410675, 0.03204318508505821, 0.031818341463804245, -0.011950206011533737, 0.08547444641590118, -0.04398858919739723, -0.09423863887786865, 0.022819753736257553, 0.034249428659677505, 0.01307649165391922, 0.0610082782804966, 0.022749876603484154, 0.04547916352748871, -0.005518889520317316, 0.03517572581768036, -0.048283837735652924, 0.030500462278723717, 0.014259574934840202, -0.050123680382966995, -0.056850507855415344, 0.04084089770913124, 0.008959939703345299, 0.0461927093565464, -0.01483825407922268, 0.029318861663341522, -0.01399359479546547, 0.015799380838871002, -0.06444211304187775, -0.016767358407378197, -0.0014177107950672507, 0.01469915546476841, -0.06596947461366653, -0.01972225308418274, -0.03304184600710869, 0.04954512044787407, 0.017358245328068733, -0.025160780176520348, -0.02161659114062786, 0.03236101567745209, -0.020005367696285248, 0.016626346856355667, 0.03277150169014931, 0.009023192338645458, -0.025281062349677086, -0.02244594320654869, 0.04825099557638168, -0.07362978160381317, 0.004556081257760525, -0.013703178614377975, 0.023298896849155426, -0.021769631654024124, -0.006245205644518137, 0.020741363987326622, -0.018160682171583176, -0.04439137130975723, -0.04925905913114548, -0.0031079170294106007, 0.001451003598049283, 0.04113622382283211, -0.06729544699192047, 0.011421678587794304, 0.03664271906018257, -0.026726022362709045, -0.02103312313556671, 0.07716263830661774, 0.006840796675533056, -0.001339116832241416, -0.056743405759334564, 0.006213774438947439, -0.039806872606277466, 0.01392211765050888, -0.03211596608161926, -0.004256448708474636, 0.005698598455637693, 0.07475420087575912, -0.020874330773949623, -0.03858283907175064, -0.011002076789736748, 0.03187597915530205, -0.031389787793159485, -0.024186713621020317, -0.028709776699543, 0.03873661160469055, 0.04941225424408913, 0.05849815160036087, 0.05955774337053299, -0.011781861074268818, -0.01782297156751156, -0.005747878924012184, 0.02356657385826111, 0.023572806268930435, -0.1011313945055008, -0.011555204167962074, -0.0018552959663793445, 0.04415453225374222, 0.02412395179271698, 0.0034687970764935017, 0.023963669314980507, 0.05151088535785675, -0.0036176256835460663, 0.020536549389362335, -0.01566188409924507, -0.02961503528058529, -0.06633982062339783, -0.037192873656749725, 0.045528512448072433, -0.043641336262226105, -0.007349675986915827, -0.008207556791603565, -0.0518067441880703, -0.08692043274641037, 0.010781200602650642, 0.03773026540875435, 0.01632760465145111, 0.011117840185761452, 0.011550065129995346, 0.03487561270594597, 0.08200394362211227, -0.09607290476560593, 0.006709704175591469, 0.04453343152999878, 0.05332104116678238, -0.04552053287625313, -0.04229193553328514, -0.025289887562394142, -0.010006677359342575, -0.06639785319566727, 0.06938246637582779, -0.034035682678222656, 0.021699652075767517, 0.06255584955215454, -0.04467110335826874, -0.0438271090388298, 0.006002266425639391, 0.04542757570743561, -0.03184407204389572, 0.017518404871225357, 0.025452323257923126, -0.004415079951286316, -0.004579455126076937, 0.01055623684078455, -0.017804836854338646, 0.023791447281837463, 0.0007406009244732559, 0.030010834336280823, 0.05602352321147919, 0.025230171158909798, 0.04508708789944649, -0.002172760432586074, 0.08728490769863129, -0.05069246143102646, 0.033422261476516724, 0.02911529131233692, 0.04128291830420494, -0.00047092989552766085, -0.018356671556830406, -0.02947581559419632, -0.020398559048771858, -0.024882815778255463, -0.006135757081210613, -0.015657473355531693, 0.03796364739537239, 0.017902599647641182, 0.029781872406601906, -0.025740906596183777, -0.04860515519976616, -0.028110191226005554, 0.04796821251511574, 0.006820679642260075, 0.059405870735645294, -0.06885809451341629, -0.015384509228169918, -0.03220229223370552, 0.0042193736881017685, 0.042058538645505905, -0.05085800960659981, 0.0015983377816155553, 0.03194383904337883, -0.016350790858268738, -0.08618981391191483, 0.025826703757047653, -0.0530799962580204, -0.024076897650957108, -0.04677525907754898, -0.027307741343975067, 0.02234485186636448, 0.04322495684027672, -0.005177550483494997, -0.020682884380221367, -0.0647488683462143, 0.012294317595660686, -0.04480326920747757, -0.040328897535800934, -0.003279241034761071, -0.020085027441382408, -0.0433286651968956, -0.0008653575787320733, 0.0188402459025383, 0.031231964007019997, -0.021710554137825966, 0.0018855601083487272, -0.014010239392518997, 0.003993721678853035, -0.012156030163168907, -0.03096187300980091, -0.030076945200562477, 0.010797123424708843, -0.020359748974442482, -0.029979659244418144, -0.01352577656507492, 0.0653553381562233, 0.037872351706027985, 0.016205163672566414, -0.04435451328754425, 0.014012888073921204, -0.06966081261634827, 0.005075034685432911, 0.02846229262650013, 0.0040615336038172245, 0.09474510699510574, 0.053430404514074326, 0.0013543788809329271, -0.02861917018890381, 0.044427841901779175, 0.0841357409954071, -0.01989334262907505, 0.02260773628950119, 0.09368129074573517, -0.040023401379585266, -0.048614636063575745, 0.02594796009361744, -0.02888207882642746, -0.026555458083748817, 0.019910011440515518, 0.06841225177049637, 0.04255123436450958, 0.026970287784934044, -0.012764623388648033, 0.03691566735506058, -0.002654138021171093, 0.004993912298232317, 0.02149289660155773, 0.0018634307198226452, -0.01673581823706627, -0.06301458925008774, 0.0029219165444374084, -0.004019401501864195, -0.040578246116638184, 0.03027806431055069, -0.02903146483004093, 0.038884472101926804, 0.009969525970518589, 0.04234841465950012, -0.0880642756819725, -0.014319991692900658, 0.008041812106966972, -0.019435778260231018, -0.0403001643717289, -0.08578546345233917, 0.009939951822161674, -0.004725360777229071, -0.03278264403343201, 0.009488148614764214, 0.01758813112974167, -0.046801596879959106, -0.04168969765305519, -0.020188719034194946, -0.01759929396212101, -0.005928655620664358, 0.04083161801099777, 0.029088569805026054, 0.01977098360657692, -0.03536505624651909, 0.009140647947788239, 0.07958988100290298, 0.03332513943314552, 0.021042773500084877, -0.014860079623758793, -0.03857472911477089, -0.09276644885540009, -0.02166791819036007, -0.0034802998416125774, 0.004955347627401352, -0.040242284536361694, -0.033851053565740585, -0.008004368282854557, -0.023697635158896446, -0.02329925447702408, 0.018034271895885468, -0.040594205260276794, 0.06623085588216782, -0.03108578361570835, -0.07352761924266815, -0.02233058772981167, 0.020879192277789116, 0.018523002043366432, 0.02765008807182312, 0.041104163974523544, -0.006630966905504465, -0.013122530654072762, -0.007310391403734684, 0.003918199799954891, 0.03756771981716156, 0.01794075407087803, -0.04799365997314453, 0.06978560239076614, -0.011846601963043213, 0.02664976753294468, 0.012336487881839275, -0.032311756163835526, -0.01873170956969261, 0.029815826565027237, 0.011155582964420319, -0.07157525420188904, 0.02767246961593628, -0.004272602964192629, 0.003547667758539319, -0.019620347768068314, 0.038095369935035706, -0.00010918782209046185, 0.005954005755484104, -0.00019434989371802658, 0.03436378389596939, -0.030952736735343933, 0.037006672471761703, -0.021657368168234825, -0.037803538143634796, -0.019537802785634995, 0.02610740065574646, 0.031075341627001762, 0.01671733148396015, 0.032830219715833664, 0.006936921272426844, 0.02864375151693821, -0.023975513875484467, 0.03312008082866669, -0.021269377321004868, -0.023571113124489784, 0.05871614068746567, -0.011628269217908382, 0.011178836226463318, -0.038817811757326126, 0.05830458179116249, 0.01058983150869608, -0.010953711345791817, -0.018588049337267876, -0.009194161742925644, 0.01198155153542757, 0.01610174961388111, 0.047280143946409225, 0.006477727554738522, -0.03438543155789375, -0.05424091964960098, 0.044844627380371094, -0.047340717166662216, 0.08387060463428497, 0.018717460334300995, 0.02016007900238037, 0.02194717898964882, -0.0003290435706730932, -0.012592215090990067, 0.039993684738874435, -0.012066598050296307, 0.02394600585103035, 0.060572825372219086, 0.06875298172235489, 0.0072426446713507175, 0.010012893937528133, 0.0679205060005188, 0.030286408960819244, 0.03800836205482483, -0.0017461994430050254, -0.010015657171607018, 0.036666203290224075, 0.020865965634584427, 0.0065504708327353, 0.08164972811937332, -0.0013362932950258255, 0.0038958899676799774, -0.012517197988927364, -0.04180694371461868, -0.00449332082644105, -0.018812360242009163, 0.04617989808320999, -0.027472885325551033, -0.01843610219657421, 0.03848210349678993, -0.017042003571987152, -0.023813795298337936, -0.017216209322214127, -0.023394346237182617, 0.012541353702545166, 0.04510141909122467, 0.002600391861051321, 0.014997034333646297, 0.01248347107321024, -0.03677981719374657, -0.045886605978012085, -0.0122988261282444, -0.0372563935816288, 0.0010737471748143435, 0.057500582188367844, -0.011549183167517185, 0.05723031237721443, -0.0306274201720953, -0.08359833061695099, 0.024256518110632896, 0.03821444883942604, -0.061719298362731934, -0.04181193932890892, -0.01291223056614399, 0.01577620767056942, 0.03660307452082634, 0.0056641073897480965, -0.017468174919486046, 0.05861809849739075, 0.02354074828326702, 0.003771458752453327, -0.014263938181102276, 0.03434264659881592, 0.01713581196963787, -0.002571306424215436, 0.005641538184136152, -0.027382684871554375, -0.08235247433185577, -0.04515402391552925, -0.013145684264600277, -0.046563226729631424, 0.047823090106248856, 0.056009791791439056, -0.018050767481327057, 0.03468875214457512, -0.02186257764697075, -0.019553806632757187, -0.03574817627668381, -0.07342471927404404, 0.013198251836001873, 0.006454545073211193, 0.03017559088766575, 0.02152145467698574, 0.02347947470843792, -0.04410663619637489, -0.04161367565393448, -0.026847366243600845, -0.059851936995983124, 0.04509461298584938, 0.061294496059417725, -0.06370701640844345, -0.05621716007590294, -0.029143337160348892, -0.05079251900315285, -0.019564848393201828, 0.020902587100863457, 0.024247759953141212, 0.03653056547045708, 0.007723627146333456, 0.019483352079987526, -0.013476941734552383, -0.010381728410720825, 0.015996307134628296, 0.04355547949671745, 0.006456587929278612, 0.02256794646382332, 0.010691488161683083, 0.005876839626580477, 0.030378790572285652, 0.03694305196404457, -0.011469180695712566, -0.036887090653181076, 0.004050333518534899, -0.0708746388554573, 0.05433936044573784, -0.029251830652356148, 0.00113523262552917, 0.03922272473573685, -0.023602323606610298, 0.0016078039770945907, -0.0445689931511879, -0.022133585065603256, -0.016596417874097824, -0.08050408959388733, 0.07069606333971024, -0.009532315656542778, -0.06404195725917816, 0.021174149587750435, -0.016709178686141968 ]
<p>(Possibly related to <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/17342/is-there-a-nonparametric-equivalent-of-tukey-hsd">Is there a nonparametric equivalent of Tukey HSD?</a>)</p> <p>Given a set of several exponentially distributed variables (representing data which is modeled this way), I'd like to check whether one of them has a significantly higher mean than the others. If the variables were normally distributed, I would have used Tukey's test; however, this is not the case, and I'm looking for as simple alternative as possible. </p> <p><strong>Some background on the data</strong> </p> <p>Alternative methods and markets from which we buy goods are compared every day. Data is aggregated on a daily basis (i.e. I only have prices and number of transactions per day, which translate to a mean). The distribution of funds for the next day is based on previous' day analysis: best method gets most of the funds, and the other methods share the rest. Typically, 5-10 alternative methods are compared, with 10,000 and more transactions per method per day.</p> <p><strong>Current Alternatives</strong></p> <p>Based on my limited knowledge, I came up with two possible ways of comparing methods:</p> <ol> <li><p>Based on the referenced question above, a nonparametric versions of Tukey's test can be used.</p></li> <li><p>Since only the highest-mean variable is compared to the rest of the variables, I think it can be compared to the second highest with <em>bonferroni correction</em>. i.e. use effective alpha = 0.05 / number of variables. This might be very conservative, but since the numbers are high, the results are usable (i.e. most days have significent results).</p></li> </ol> <p><strong>My questions</strong></p> <ol> <li><p>Do the methods above make sense as solutions to the presented case? specifically, method (2) is simple and yields usable results, but I'm not sure it's statistically sound.</p></li> <li><p>I'm interested in any other suggestions for performing this analysis. As noted, I'm more interested in simplicity and generalization, and less on getting the best significance values.</p></li> </ol>
g74038
[ -0.026473257690668106, -0.03117414377629757, -0.01752270944416523, -0.05038713663816452, 0.0052492995746433735, -0.0482574999332428, 0.04004669189453125, -0.02329353801906109, -0.017930632457137108, 0.0286002978682518, 0.03985795006155968, -0.052653923630714417, 0.06229761242866516, 0.06533544510602951, -0.0349312350153923, -0.0005138842388987541, 0.09027070552110672, -0.012837919406592846, 0.007693245075643063, -0.02336777187883854, 0.013134167529642582, 0.02731066569685936, 0.02489624172449112, 0.009588642045855522, -0.013915781863033772, -0.03136852756142616, -0.07194223999977112, 0.05489130690693855, -0.041524436324834824, 0.028108051046729088, -0.06732673943042755, -0.02103024162352085, 0.07783222198486328, -0.05727054178714752, -0.0544172041118145, 0.032301295548677444, 0.03621862083673477, 0.0661836564540863, -0.008320956490933895, 0.02137150801718235, -0.025018222630023956, 0.026666659861803055, 0.06622686982154846, 0.015179800800979137, -0.013771723955869675, -0.06826349347829819, 0.013460549525916576, 0.00948482844978571, 0.0572240874171257, -0.02408011443912983, -0.05106871947646141, 0.009199367836117744, 0.05455675348639488, -0.0077705541625618935, 0.0011343297082930803, 0.0507223941385746, 0.002208192367106676, 0.04565592482686043, 0.04187487065792084, 0.051064662635326385, 0.007038538809865713, 0.00360845192335546, 0.023477081209421158, -0.06257647275924683, -0.013780705630779266, 0.04459721967577934, -0.030326083302497864, 0.001092438935302198, -0.01666261814534664, -0.025652209296822548, 0.02740645967423916, -0.00904121994972229, -0.0016944428207352757, -0.02458764985203743, -0.038621921092271805, -0.016822414472699165, -0.024510739371180534, -0.027555180713534355, 0.038224466145038605, 0.0028240748215466738, 0.0031796274706721306, -0.03169365972280502, 0.061224427074193954, 0.034963980317115784, -0.001088074641302228, -0.07728362828493118, 0.049695491790771484, -0.013056240044534206, 0.05968732014298439, 0.00503076147288084, 0.016466008499264717, 0.07381448149681091, 0.05970160290598869, 0.07076568156480789, -0.09656429290771484, 0.01290921214967966, -0.002357189077883959, 0.025667643174529076, -0.040045030415058136, -0.0007963991956785321, 0.003049930790439248, 0.02138913981616497, -0.020366491749882698, 0.03310403600335121, -0.0409746915102005, -0.017726564779877663, -0.012428073212504387, 0.03993421047925949, -0.06176677718758583, 0.011522484943270683, -0.02044609561562538, -0.0030239331535995007, -0.03822104632854462, -0.06274612247943878, 0.013929278589785099, -0.01906188577413559, 0.007095107343047857, 0.0008685656939633191, -0.051559120416641235, -0.03484419733285904, -0.018834009766578674, 0.04181710258126259, 0.006241065450012684, 0.03737824410200119, -0.005647286307066679, 0.027927182614803314, -0.017826510593295097, 0.05435292795300484, 0.0016002969350665808, 0.001885575009509921, 0.03681390732526779, 0.005202128551900387, 0.00224870047532022, 0.026526575908064842, 0.02000097557902336, 0.02890550158917904, -0.032307837158441544, 0.048705995082855225, -0.025364451110363007, -0.013219807296991348, -0.07020086795091629, -0.013681097887456417, 0.019689662382006645, 0.011722714640200138, -0.0315997377038002, 0.07230748981237411, 0.022088196128606796, -0.015240012668073177, 0.003996237646788359, 0.026027202606201172, 0.03884363919496536, 0.05153137072920799, -0.012850119732320309, 0.00823330320417881, -0.06446375697851181, -0.0009079214069060981, 0.009355193935334682, 0.013341022655367851, 0.001677679130807519, 0.01949215494096279, -0.02128780633211136, -0.03208421915769577, 0.0477820448577404, -0.02035640925168991, 0.05257613956928253, -0.029214678332209587, 0.03297683596611023, 0.026672590523958206, 0.010684756562113762, 0.009649047628045082, -0.05326935276389122, 0.0042551434598863125, 0.024303875863552094, -0.029074838384985924, -0.00043513221316970885, 0.014881591312587261, 0.000611569092143327, -0.019499149173498154, 0.05246339365839958, 0.02865658514201641, 0.015533390454947948, -0.007476005703210831, 0.07867264747619629, -0.051028668880462646, 0.013059290125966072, -0.053495462983846664, 0.01644762046635151, -0.010165843181312084, -0.02574721723794937, 0.018918683752417564, -0.0324162095785141, -0.030304906889796257, -0.012274361215531826, 0.060282301157712936, -0.02063732035458088, -0.029064368456602097, 0.018495559692382812, -0.056204453110694885, -0.024514054879546165, 0.0223945714533329, 0.023220380768179893, 0.07050672918558121, -0.022216608747839928, 0.006383394822478294, 0.0015631079440936446, 0.0652301162481308, 0.018484042957425117, 0.006453417241573334, 0.008731710724532604, -0.0049538929015398026, 0.016987355425953865, -0.022357331588864326, -0.0019623776897788048, 0.04469817504286766, 0.01889668218791485, 0.030465973541140556, -0.006369258277118206, 0.03830324485898018, -0.019528785720467567, 0.005378909409046173, -0.0738995298743248, -0.04130696505308151, -0.011238038539886475, -0.015127322636544704, 0.016524959355592728, 0.0667116791009903, 0.022817717865109444, -0.008195420727133751, 0.003394185798242688, 0.07317465543746948, -0.04991315305233002, -0.04575091600418091, -0.024725621566176414, -0.05767524987459183, 0.02005459927022457, 0.008796793408691883, -0.011303886771202087, -0.017706358805298805, -0.01930060051381588, 0.024457793682813644, 0.03585262969136238, -0.018409308046102524, -0.027596667408943176, 0.06695443391799927, 0.03468107804656029, -0.034347616136074066, -0.013673396781086922, 0.011370828375220299, 0.045352667570114136, 0.07590201497077942, -0.04499746114015579, 0.06667246669530869, 0.009889607317745686, -0.045956820249557495, 0.08360964059829712, 0.025925038382411003, 0.01605108007788658, 0.018565736711025238, 0.04226504638791084, 0.05070764943957329, -0.022565744817256927, -0.009036706760525703, 0.050614625215530396, -0.02082243002951145, 0.0476212278008461, 0.002010543132200837, 0.003638092428445816, -0.07039548456668854, -0.016977624967694283, 0.0028873574919998646, -0.0013229335891082883, 0.03751716390252113, 0.0035001947544515133, 0.05455867946147919, 0.0010988983558490872, 0.03010852262377739, 0.007738904096186161, -0.01544097438454628, -0.025898657739162445, 0.024533824995160103, 0.0507756732404232, -0.0005646485951729119, -0.003064654767513275, -0.019627274945378304, 0.05552111938595772, 0.0219775028526783, 0.0851772204041481, 0.004386039450764656, -0.032933905720710754, -0.004592896904796362, 0.048066020011901855, 0.04063904285430908, -0.07034555077552795, -0.0014744760701432824, -0.06750351935625076, 0.00956964585930109, 0.046158935874700546, -0.07322607189416885, 0.02996664121747017, -0.03867752104997635, -0.017197538167238235, 0.013446887955069542, 0.07307283580303192, 0.017748180776834488, 0.07766804099082947, 0.02918533980846405, -0.07526274770498276, -0.03173518180847168, 0.0026354817673563957, -0.004032779019325972, 0.024621443822979927, 0.014365719631314278, -0.04424024745821953, -0.028668934479355812, -0.0576016828417778, -0.027701063081622124, 0.003951115533709526, 0.003732376266270876, -0.0014506947482004762, -0.02459155023097992, 0.007572377100586891, -0.032742053270339966, 0.014688780531287193, -0.013989247381687164, 0.04015364497900009, 0.04782549664378166, -0.04895763099193573, 0.06612876057624817, -0.10492565482854843, -0.023589925840497017, 0.007396429777145386, 0.0520530641078949, 0.02819288894534111, 0.0019337162375450134, -0.01375681720674038, -0.04645896330475807, 0.03223152831196785, 0.03977110981941223, 0.035811860114336014, 0.0640651062130928, -0.02137845754623413, -0.04214932769536972, 0.017024977132678032, 0.0012323299888521433, -0.059361908584833145, -0.07662450522184372, 0.038406431674957275, 0.05236684903502464, -0.0032224911265075207, 0.017645621672272682, -0.021649109199643135, 0.02226451225578785, 0.02555723302066326, -0.08501361310482025, 0.06432006508111954, -0.00988241471350193, 0.01825098879635334, 0.017711564898490906, 0.03157404810190201, -0.008821760304272175, 0.03506849706172943, -0.03828630968928337, 0.00007255854143295437, 0.01033077109605074, -0.011694185435771942, 0.06083463877439499, 0.04385421425104141, 0.03260575234889984, 0.006005621049553156, -0.03714064136147499, -0.005907412618398666, 0.03812792897224426, 0.07050570100545883, -0.07307545840740204, 0.03163766488432884, -0.030815785750746727, 0.0132682453840971, 0.006361129693686962, 0.02655724249780178, 0.024567632004618645, 0.04521949216723442, 0.009431651793420315, 0.014901228249073029, -0.0032377743627876043, -0.017761237919330597, -0.05636228248476982, -0.05374825373291969, 0.010949189774692059, -0.034358587116003036, -0.025159776210784912, -0.02903108112514019, -0.03679211437702179, -0.013232079334557056, 0.04773598909378052, 0.03934377804398537, -0.015661902725696564, 0.03449653461575508, 0.01879817619919777, 0.007538917940109968, 0.03181073069572449, -0.010512344539165497, -0.04090343788266182, 0.04230278730392456, 0.009312599897384644, -0.008992847986519337, -0.036624304950237274, -0.01549340970814228, -0.002474556677043438, -0.04671485722064972, -0.027577394619584084, -0.036248285323381424, -0.03578700125217438, 0.027190733700990677, -0.03168580308556557, 0.008040747605264187, -0.010313647799193859, 0.0320325568318367, -0.02906091883778572, -0.0166461281478405, 0.005300538148730993, 0.01958571933209896, -0.025543412193655968, -0.030042806640267372, -0.04327875003218651, 0.002637674566358328, 0.04355604946613312, 0.06300120055675507, 0.02939431555569172, 0.033778149634599686, -0.014062013477087021, -0.007265276741236448, 0.06589455902576447, -0.00600610813125968, 0.002015477977693081, 0.04642659053206444, -0.05117863789200783, 0.012037217617034912, -0.0005537914694286883, 0.033561043441295624, -0.05082522705197334, -0.009017201140522957, 0.01893189549446106, -0.018191447481513023, 0.00922324787825346, -0.04361354932188988, 0.019184302538633347, -0.0145857073366642, 0.020042473450303078, -0.004833347629755735, -0.060740794986486435, -0.05148113891482353, 0.030385982245206833, -0.005872427020221949, 0.030005572363734245, -0.006829210091382265, -0.027463005855679512, 0.03531404584646225, 0.024605639278888702, 0.012364189140498638, 0.02222815901041031, -0.08202863484621048, -0.056486841291189194, 0.03861379250884056, -0.05212654545903206, 0.032311491668224335, 0.019245905801653862, -0.06570973992347717, 0.004067893140017986, -0.0008302913047373295, -0.02087603323161602, -0.009942591190338135, -0.022113272920250893, 0.02559320256114006, -0.01126087550073862, -0.03907952085137367, -0.004233389161527157, 0.0014550825580954552, 0.000585930363740772, 0.011739583685994148, -0.025842510163784027, -0.022954119369387627, -0.01853915862739086, -0.006466452497988939, 0.03866813704371452, -0.0005662468611262739, -0.03586107864975929, -0.014211609959602356, -0.06238995119929314, 0.043959151953458786, -0.036620378494262695, -0.018111109733581543, -0.029578281566500664, 0.06268983334302902, 0.01838274672627449, -0.02574032172560692, -0.033661387860774994, 0.045559726655483246, -0.03679617866873741, -0.04423455893993378, -0.006365506909787655, -0.07453345507383347, 0.05405023321509361, -0.010249889455735683, 0.0015371929621323943, 0.03914705663919449, -0.030629580840468407, 0.025066984817385674, 0.03282305970788002, 0.013002612628042698, 0.059019602835178375, -0.014788830652832985, 0.017558271065354347, 0.029117019847035408, -0.05226621776819229, -0.04979607090353966, 0.030230192467570305, -0.007329488173127174, -0.018660901114344597, 0.0021145176142454147, -0.052195437252521515, 0.06534521281719208, -0.029567865654826164, 0.025586377829313278, 0.02303510718047619, -0.014052564278244972, -0.10749702900648117, -0.019948437809944153, -0.028482895344495773, -0.010381657630205154, -0.05241871625185013, -0.002322935266420245, 0.03423206880688667, 0.007657092995941639, 0.0058459071442484856, -0.019562073051929474, 0.017871972173452377, -0.010936013422906399, 0.015151183120906353, -0.05810649320483208, -0.023444363847374916, -0.01387991663068533, -0.018405044451355934, 0.03736015781760216, -0.03653673827648163, -0.04075891897082329, -0.06993725150823593, -0.006980756763368845, -0.025668136775493622, 0.006713515147566795, -0.061725471168756485, -0.016470368951559067, 0.00226675346493721, -0.02054087445139885, -0.006383042316883802, 0.011370792053639889, -0.0314362458884716, 0.006043527275323868, -0.05630304291844368, 0.04411729425191879, 0.02355460450053215, 0.024575388059020042, -0.04547809064388275, 0.008539332076907158, 0.005948305130004883, 0.057575661689043045, 0.00026631943183019757, -0.08617442101240158, -0.0397140309214592, -0.012982246465981007, 0.04506392776966095, 0.005579935386776924, 0.013188598677515984, 0.05133684724569321, -0.039819929748773575, 0.00153880356810987, -0.02572578750550747, -0.036998044699430466, 0.000040705253923079, 0.00732087530195713, 0.008672730065882206, -0.0478426031768322, -0.045435983687639236, 0.041959404945373535, 0.07215125113725662, -0.012439525686204433, -0.02475993148982525, -0.0019417551811784506, 0.015420617535710335, -0.03616439551115036, -0.026889987289905548, -0.009937752038240433, -0.008791063912212849, 0.023771468549966812, -0.05290664732456207, 0.05544450879096985, 0.014868573285639286, -0.0019255595980212092, 0.028880631551146507, -0.05037788674235344, -0.042397767305374146, -0.01840868592262268, -0.03841356560587883, 0.02785746566951275, -0.04981414973735809, -0.014770430512726307, 0.021059099584817886, 0.000010973182725138031, 0.026807649061083794, -0.02756604552268982, -0.016693446785211563, -0.017585093155503273, 0.06419916450977325, 0.006669404450803995, 0.0888308584690094, -0.045537061989307404, 0.017800668254494667, -0.05705444514751434, -0.031150517985224724, 0.02123282663524151, 0.019869886338710785, 0.027254121378064156, 0.01599128171801567, 0.004828957840800285, -0.002013950375840068, 0.04417957738041878, 0.0826214998960495, -0.02867160737514496, -0.06480208039283752, -0.012815266847610474, -0.00020373186271172017, -0.006401130463927984, 0.010310732759535313, 0.049730848520994186, 0.011381500400602818, -0.046562980860471725, 0.03770037740468979, -0.0730762928724289, 0.08409678936004639, -0.05399610474705696, 0.038359589874744415, -0.03192037716507912, -0.0015286874258890748, 0.02832353673875332, 0.03290250897407532, 0.023442935198545456, -0.01376219280064106, 0.009241052903234959, 0.05744025111198425, -0.05779420956969261, 0.01518602017313242, 0.07028168439865112, 0.05649833008646965, 0.0021472503431141376, -0.022361425682902336, -0.03009297512471676, 0.024172788485884666, 0.04625823348760605, 0.02322114072740078, 0.021789150312542915, -0.039989374577999115, 0.006608812138438225, -0.005844376049935818, 0.012232343666255474, 0.035216931253671646, 0.001660380163230002, 0.06246387958526611, -0.04592159762978554, -0.050738316029310226, -0.02255069650709629, 0.011056886985898018, 0.05865328758955002, -0.05341644212603569, -0.01270823273807764, -0.0004967187996953726, -0.0017974517541006207, -0.01265693362802267, 0.030694518238306046, -0.00450122868642211, -0.04969094321131706, 0.02272447571158409, -0.03609354421496391, -0.00731612229719758, 0.019844364374876022, 0.02839270606637001, -0.022894490510225296, 0.0448836013674736, -0.04652943089604378, 0.01351976953446865, 0.018415918573737144, -0.004137955605983734, -0.06342669576406479, -0.03956368938088417, 0.03598687797784805, 0.020223310217261314, -0.025434456765651703, 0.06335156410932541, -0.030769536271691322, -0.04411570355296135, -0.030377255752682686, 0.013379414565861225, -0.007498987019062042, 0.06207350268959999, -0.03879723697900772, -0.010858865454792976, 0.008027500472962856, 0.019880658015608788, 0.02135191671550274, -0.020666873082518578, -0.043200209736824036, -0.06340224295854568, 0.03951803594827652, 0.08120675384998322, -0.03689678758382797, -0.0177201796323061, 0.01860850863158703, -0.06368982046842575, 0.01695113629102707, -0.10380441695451736, -0.021429551765322685, 0.035615742206573486, -0.0023610100615769625, 0.013529157266020775, 0.028747595846652985, -0.012988559901714325, 0.019505726173520088, -0.05299772694706917, -0.06409234553575516, 0.03422938659787178, -0.037149444222450256, 0.040903277695178986, -0.008978958241641521, -0.04187457263469696, -0.04769681766629219, 0.02795146219432354, 0.017223631963133812, 0.012113709934055805, -0.028322549536824226, 0.04393518716096878, -0.00006036751074134372, -0.011877764947712421, -0.05895610153675079, -0.006651897449046373, 0.0014241739409044385, 0.003160817315801978, 0.007728424854576588, -0.0020737003069370985, -0.007599679287523031, 0.03504127264022827, 0.01743282563984394, -0.02544468641281128, -0.048846568912267685, 0.0027663044165819883, -0.03893343359231949, 0.04181484133005142, 0.013286102563142776, 0.024792306125164032, 0.029737362638115883, -0.04815337434411049, 0.020462986081838608, -0.030439667403697968, -0.031606659293174744, -0.021892037242650986, -0.020130999386310577, 0.022954342886805534, 0.014334118925035, -0.08365888148546219, -0.0489981546998024, 0.0012417210964486003 ]
<p>In the following problem, check that it is appropriate to use the normal approximation to the binomial. Then use the normal distribution to estimate the requested probabilities.</p> <p>It is known that 85% of all new products introduced in grocery stores fail (are taken off the market) within 2 years. If a grocery store chain introduces 68 new products, find the following probabilities. (Round your answers to four decimal places.)</p> <p>(a) within 2 years 47 or more fail</p> <p>(b) within 2 years 58 or fewer fail . </p> <p>(c) within 2 years 15 or more succeed . </p> <p>(d) within 2 years fewer than 10 succeed</p>
g36663
[ -0.00848456285893917, 0.02750895358622074, -0.006383336614817381, 0.025171775370836258, -0.052326906472444534, 0.013789018616080284, 0.04474911838769913, -0.006025905255228281, -0.0300213024020195, -0.008204319514334202, -0.0011687777005136013, 0.01831401325762272, -0.00513146398589015, -0.007762743625789881, -0.01432436890900135, 0.0434628389775753, 0.03631957620382309, -0.017531411722302437, 0.017121363431215286, 0.02264147251844406, 0.005015957169234753, -0.01872912049293518, -0.003057202324271202, -0.04156629368662834, -0.06486973911523819, -0.01867680996656418, -0.04803614318370819, 0.049836501479148865, -0.06565257161855698, 0.019483787938952446, -0.06722757965326309, 0.01607486419379711, -0.016080375760793686, -0.050698064267635345, 0.008843000046908855, -0.02420639619231224, 0.07794582098722458, 0.006667700596153736, -0.018012775108218193, -0.021212872117757797, -0.06071148440241814, 0.05772814154624939, -0.012765285558998585, -0.009672802872955799, -0.03146396577358246, -0.006354364566504955, -0.008142776787281036, 0.053966209292411804, 0.04574969783425331, -0.06576832383871078, -0.04169049859046936, 0.035688698291778564, 0.017461389303207397, -0.008865752257406712, -0.054403286427259445, 0.06067951023578644, -0.0014385241083800793, -0.06622784584760666, -0.0037051928229629993, -0.01737583428621292, -0.0005188769428059459, -0.04642820358276367, 0.025338755920529366, -0.0010470141423866153, 0.01874120719730854, 0.05124922841787338, 0.007838207297027111, 0.07970879226922989, 0.028342286124825478, 0.0019594840705394745, 0.017803218215703964, -0.037293046712875366, 0.02832774631679058, -0.04419420287013054, -0.020680250599980354, -0.03477361053228378, -0.05350499600172043, 0.02978888526558876, 0.018721330910921097, 0.08572043478488922, -0.021816106513142586, 0.020568983629345894, -0.0270768404006958, -0.01969946175813675, -0.015295695513486862, -0.015199965797364712, 0.040025319904088974, -0.0032771152909845114, 0.004175728652626276, 0.013686020858585835, 0.044446028769016266, 0.04343634098768234, 0.0015663554659113288, 0.012358457781374454, -0.0438387468457222, 0.022091558203101158, -0.054200679063797, -0.0024729231372475624, -0.006598712410777807, -0.0006060677696950734, 0.04831041768193245, -0.01725544035434723, -0.027896257117390633, -0.05625361576676369, -0.05752524733543396, 0.027444422245025635, 0.09095548093318939, 0.030477380380034447, 0.019101278856396675, 0.018869908526539803, -0.009073970839381218, 0.017213279381394386, -0.06846769154071808, -0.02817295677959919, 0.029445011168718338, 0.03595190867781639, 0.044109784066677094, -0.038974255323410034, 0.04403095692396164, 0.02560531347990036, -0.03567388653755188, 0.00065849837847054, -0.0019204647978767753, -0.03403632715344429, -0.00898168794810772, -0.04871644824743271, -0.08055845648050308, 0.0590924397110939, 0.045483361929655075, 0.013916089199483395, 0.0589371994137764, 0.04628334939479828, 0.05373314023017883, -0.0005575820105150342, 0.017230402678251266, 0.01205505058169365, 0.05958099290728569, 0.04166104644536972, 0.042856615036726, 0.03155325725674629, -0.015014913864433765, 0.005619893781840801, 0.06169140338897705, -0.00009222140943165869, -0.021402979269623756, 0.0015729229198768735, 0.03492671251296997, 0.012070451863110065, -0.027225354686379433, -0.012106092646718025, -0.061756573617458344, 0.039808593690395355, 0.026096560060977936, 0.04912319406867027, 0.0007895302842371166, 0.021632658317685127, 0.03314845263957977, 0.0377391092479229, -0.01747157983481884, 0.015076731331646442, 0.039558008313179016, -0.011807779781520367, -0.05604926496744156, 0.010245674289762974, -0.026266412809491158, 0.024883748963475227, 0.05518447235226631, 0.008937414735555649, 0.001653520273976028, -0.028958888724446297, -0.0027489939238876104, -0.018404515460133553, -0.004290544427931309, 0.012860918417572975, 0.003627895377576351, 0.03721902519464493, 0.04059412702918053, 0.030318956822156906, 0.029130812734365463, -0.008709592744708061, 0.0238262377679348, -0.01443549245595932, 0.02572222426533699, 0.02120314911007881, 0.002163813216611743, -0.02439398132264614, 0.0512138195335865, 0.07405087351799011, -0.03623533248901367, -0.024130849167704582, 0.013484855182468891, 0.06161655858159065, 0.007407269440591335, -0.007587676867842674, -0.0131553765386343, 0.006058990024030209, 0.048260219395160675, -0.04738191142678261, 0.02979920245707035, -0.015299960039556026, 0.02377966418862343, 0.0032489639706909657, -0.035544537007808685, -0.0376734621822834, -0.005693573970347643, 0.02358403615653515, -0.02628125250339508, -0.0027398860547691584, -0.0017568065086379647, 0.03805483877658844, -0.005584615282714367, -0.08618845045566559, -0.041545506566762924, 0.01702924817800522, 0.03175141289830208, -0.03524482995271683, -0.0008562971488572657, 0.05542144551873207, -0.0035408774856477976, -0.012388925999403, -0.022535696625709534, 0.006739199161529541, 0.048487111926078796, 0.008128833025693893, 0.07070191204547882, 0.03395887091755867, 0.03909420594573021, -0.01778990961611271, 0.01487154420465231, -0.0024250182323157787, -0.007959342561662197, 0.03003363497555256, -0.0017460430972278118, -0.07190211117267609, 0.0026527135632932186, 0.01108852680772543, -0.019535567611455917, -0.03235649690032005, 0.053483061492443085, 0.0020037563517689705, 0.03680973872542381, 0.03222796320915222, -0.015726175159215927, 0.054358288645744324, -0.047497596591711044, -0.06873002648353577, 0.032655443996191025, -0.027402067556977272, 0.034718047827482224, 0.04374448210000992, -0.010727937333285809, 0.009157516993582249, 0.001955166459083557, -0.04667709395289421, 0.03184845671057701, -0.006349711678922176, 0.002702604979276657, 0.011708056554198265, -0.04731708765029907, -0.0504654236137867, -0.04842139035463333, 0.00010686248424462974, 0.09913719445466995, -0.05445820465683937, -0.02976568415760994, 0.01319822296500206, -0.025972401723265648, -0.011622951366007328, 0.015932170674204826, 0.04434642195701599, 0.014513173140585423, 0.02198711782693863, 0.00030957703711465, 0.02844030037522316, 0.01247347891330719, -0.03233357146382332, 0.014323349110782146, 0.002844184171408415, 0.01327245682477951, 0.09807607531547546, 0.0028115923050791025, -0.05073074996471405, -0.017807386815547943, 0.04592222347855568, -0.008956216275691986, 0.027265597134828568, 0.01822092942893505, 0.030288899317383766, 0.007693636231124401, 0.03602707386016846, -0.058600008487701416, 0.019327150657773018, 0.013928623870015144, -0.006403161212801933, 0.060524873435497284, 0.010826400481164455, 0.0049048615619540215, -0.028574513271450996, -0.014412625692784786, -0.022772444412112236, 0.019519126042723656, 0.0092430729418993, -0.03705069050192833, -0.05807320401072502, -0.016006872057914734, -0.00006717926589772105, -0.02056444063782692, 0.003020120318979025, 0.016078876331448555, -0.009526612237095833, 0.046846069395542145, 0.0203326977789402, -0.017845235764980316, -0.017084727063775063, -0.010554671287536621, -0.03203105926513672, 0.030794894322752953, 0.08060712367296219, 0.03648810833692551, -0.01775483414530754, 0.03004341945052147, 0.0072171324864029884, 0.0020797913894057274, 0.02364177443087101, 0.008597166277468204, 0.01192405354231596, -0.04395166411995888, 0.06577834486961365, -0.054356079548597336, -0.03730536252260208, 0.01916165091097355, -0.009132537059485912, -0.0278554018586874, -0.04351375624537468, -0.03361941874027252, -0.039377354085445404, 0.015949426218867302, -0.000040933049604063854, -0.010760015808045864, 0.07318450510501862, 0.0245504267513752, -0.001455963240005076, -0.05233131721615791, -0.011836474761366844, -0.01271107792854309, -0.06614159047603607, -0.039465535432100296, 0.03374800831079483, 0.02320033125579357, 0.010276667773723602, 0.03729289397597313, -0.09312094748020172, 0.011926855891942978, -0.011940333060920238, 0.006535377353429794, 0.05933189019560814, 0.0005721133202314377, -0.05023691803216934, 0.08058902621269226, 0.026260286569595337, 0.07917275279760361, -0.04915953800082207, -0.012604844756424427, 0.07444246858358383, 0.031530991196632385, 0.020598547533154488, 0.03484999015927315, 0.04343140125274658, 0.012728993780910969, -0.010126855224370956, -0.03254629299044609, 0.030382299795746803, 0.08278698474168777, -0.01855098456144333, 0.009245415218174458, 0.014140733517706394, -0.04847094416618347, -0.01008483488112688, 0.018721560016274452, 0.014288811013102531, 0.029933631420135498, 0.002370665082708001, -0.031184623017907143, -0.05442988872528076, 0.017611941322684288, -0.07496132701635361, -0.033039338886737823, -0.03272427245974541, 0.03313368931412697, -0.020905394107103348, -0.006621040869504213, -0.050387997180223465, 0.04686044156551361, 0.019110944122076035, -0.00862332247197628, -0.07742900401353836, 0.006257184781134129, -0.0038000692147761583, -0.007553018629550934, 0.0007033825968392193, -0.01181583758443594, -0.014012569561600685, 0.00027870433405041695, 0.024313751608133316, -0.005880735814571381, 0.03182496130466461, 0.0036866168957203627, -0.02341977134346962, 0.028764374554157257, -0.015150168910622597, -0.030506551265716553, 0.0037016943097114563, -0.020070577040314674, -0.019416792318224907, 0.04527278244495392, -0.049225013703107834, 0.07528632879257202, -0.011543569155037403, -0.047270890325307846, 0.016669394448399544, 0.004133314825594425, 0.014888936653733253, -0.043095361441373825, -0.020757969468832016, 0.017009448260068893, 0.033841948956251144, 0.04239356145262718, -0.02107137069106102, 0.09872886538505554, -0.035971060395240784, 0.01295134425163269, 0.02398236095905304, -0.04622028023004532, 0.05307863652706146, -0.03220868855714798, -0.067908376455307, -0.0016241471748799086, -0.04099033400416374, 0.002747763879597187, -0.03128776326775551, -0.0441557876765728, -0.03526904806494713, -0.056839101016521454, -0.004799597430974245, 0.03878866508603096, 0.06950623542070389, 0.016438813880085945, -0.03651704639196396, 0.07687243074178696, 0.009181741625070572, 0.05295895040035248, 0.01854671910405159, 0.03744972497224808, -0.009602716192603111, 0.018181465566158295, 0.02078966237604618, 0.017447393387556076, 0.010058929212391376, -0.0204264298081398, 0.11766517162322998, 0.015427197329699993, -0.0075207906775176525, -0.055590156465768814, -0.038679931312799454, -0.01636888086795807, 0.012322935275733471, 0.031027084216475487, -0.0036321808584034443, 0.006923963315784931, -0.030737992376089096, 0.0167829729616642, -0.027351051568984985, 0.032020796090364456, -0.04539304971694946, -0.06059259548783302, -0.012095717713236809, -0.01579727604985237, 0.05126818269491196, 0.026611512526869774, 0.040781810879707336, -0.03189001604914665, -0.05229280889034271, 0.007974893786013126, 0.012686020694673061, -0.009663418866693974, -0.05714860558509827, 0.033254873007535934, -0.09099701046943665, 0.08284381777048111, -0.058560311794281006, 0.027536598965525627, 0.006877997424453497, 0.017251908779144287, 0.003292649984359741, -0.008649053052067757, -0.01763915829360485, 0.026668841019272804, 0.03623485192656517, 0.0027388681191951036, -0.008105025626718998, -0.0758451521396637, 0.05520802363753319, -0.0029588236939162016, -0.03327789157629013, 0.0064924550242722034, 0.0023117626551538706, 0.002270965836942196, 0.006657004356384277, -0.0050198910757899284, 0.09384086728096008, 0.048186637461185455, 0.06258717179298401, 0.050134092569351196, 0.018550993874669075, -0.020948924124240875, -0.011631006374955177, -0.014069629833102226, -0.047497570514678955, -0.01619548909366131, -0.0028723038267344236, 0.05175149068236351, 0.008027426898479462, -0.015564322471618652, -0.021461421623826027, -0.017729269340634346, -0.05052347481250763, -0.07925935834646225, -0.016654005274176598, 0.003726355964317918, -0.06784948706626892, 0.023155562579631805, 0.022796744480729103, -0.023924440145492554, -0.0456695631146431, -0.04855090007185936, 0.0379701592028141, 0.004058254882693291, -0.010811824351549149, 0.01185197290033102, -0.05249311774969101, -0.02597326971590519, -0.04137443006038666, -0.010134672746062279, 0.004693991504609585, -0.003411988727748394, 0.0001873653382062912, -0.029287485405802727, -0.04479585960507393, -0.02728979103267193, -0.047010812908411026, 0.008358662948012352, 0.08255276829004288, 0.02173548750579357, -0.010424615815281868, -0.011147462762892246, 0.05317625775933266, -0.0291668102145195, 0.004244438372552395, -0.019505910575389862, 0.05548545718193054, -0.027578186243772507, -0.03832469508051872, -0.00239669531583786, 0.012079271487891674, 0.006914050783962011, -0.08300724625587463, -0.02615261822938919, 0.025135047733783722, -0.006773569155484438, 0.05462384596467018, 0.024581240490078926, -0.032801516354084015, -0.0032836436294019222, 0.02979441173374653, 0.035052891820669174, -0.002686312422156334, 0.01799735054373741, -0.07260529696941376, 0.009476780891418457, -0.022779809311032295, -0.06283994764089584, -0.03782833740115166, -0.022243473678827286, 0.058470580726861954, -0.03753295913338661, 0.020585862919688225, 0.0006662968080490828, 0.02918975241482258, 0.010573838837444782, -0.059722449630498886, 0.003184693632647395, 0.00866875983774662, -0.00004725917460746132, -0.030394159257411957, -0.011789803393185139, 0.01384040154516697, -0.011621571145951748, -0.04750170186161995, -0.01956653594970703, -0.05562698468565941, -0.06000126153230667, -0.01937131956219673, 0.058346204459667206, -0.03648001700639725, -0.021919524297118187, -0.0050273737870156765, -0.032909806817770004, -0.014651501551270485, 0.0019197349902242422, -0.016436876729130745, 0.007097980473190546, -0.009717302396893501, 0.07848703116178513, 0.08554861694574356, 0.0660531222820282, -0.024592025205492973, -0.005631590727716684, -0.0007899815682321787, -0.0011500389082357287, 0.030921591445803642, -0.030821019783616066, -0.04795350506901741, 0.005066386424005032, 0.01978810876607895, 0.007707746233791113, 0.016325494274497032, 0.01361502893269062, -0.05889085680246353, 0.043733470141887665, 0.03135945647954941, 0.0727420225739479, -0.044866811484098434, 0.005149667151272297, 0.030942659825086594, -0.04836512729525566, 0.040876228362321854, -0.06157897412776947, 0.05497443303465843, -0.04879515618085861, -0.02618490532040596, 0.04032381623983383, -0.01738111488521099, 0.01712830550968647, 0.004384562838822603, -0.008339065127074718, 0.031833913177251816, 0.05536791682243347, 0.022358927875757217, 0.03752896189689636, -0.012385615147650242, -0.02170402929186821, 0.016894344240427017, 0.013619530014693737, 0.0038219522684812546, 0.019298462197184563, 0.012135811150074005, 0.02393943816423416, 0.04542374610900879, -0.01516044232994318, -0.020212577655911446, -0.018427275121212006, -0.06409852206707001, -0.03181103989481926, -0.04362158477306366, -0.009096523746848106, 0.006113707087934017, 0.016722334548830986, -0.030369242653250694, -0.03522079065442085, -0.05911873281002045, -0.011326796375215054, -0.005519986618310213, -0.07260993123054504, -0.00448221992701292, -0.030997969210147858, -0.018113508820533752, -0.0002757812035270035, 0.022111179307103157, -0.0015795391518622637, -0.030978919938206673, 0.0117951026186347, -0.04397696629166603, -0.05169087275862694, 0.00009556242730468512, 0.047860316932201385, 0.027580291032791138, 0.013930908404290676, 0.0010586678981781006, 0.06782682985067368, 0.008807624690234661, 0.003306926693767309, -0.08919280767440796, -0.0017425130354240537, -0.009891590103507042, -0.03393537923693657, 0.05794760212302208, 0.02046208083629608, -0.021158546209335327, 0.043210435658693314, 0.04127541184425354, -0.009747765958309174, 0.0768018364906311, -0.04365004599094391, -0.052982594817876816, 0.0021476857364177704, 0.01979997754096985, -0.007740609347820282, -0.05898869410157204, -0.011206219904124737, -0.021004563197493553, 0.09229374676942825, 0.01593482308089733, -0.0012712066527456045, 0.007662864401936531, -0.044318120926618576, -0.05682352930307388, 0.03545656055212021, -0.08181316405534744, -0.022034000605344772, -0.042723506689071655, -0.005888786166906357, 0.003597303992137313, -0.01893296092748642, 0.05860991030931473, -0.03349166363477707, -0.006007975898683071, -0.0699259415268898, 0.014729614369571209, -0.04068542271852493, -0.03341788053512573, -0.03385600075125694, -0.03516269847750664, -0.09582678228616714, 0.04563423991203308, 0.04704897478222847, -0.005034320522099733, -0.018580643460154533, -0.050417277961969376, 0.010479085147380829, 0.0068137976340949535, -0.013840444386005402, -0.004743911791592836, 0.027377884835004807, 0.03311043977737427, 0.014145160093903542, -0.025363199412822723, 0.014475521631538868, -0.01052982546389103, 0.025564629584550858, 0.010921137407422066, -0.06847478449344635, -0.05114114284515381, -0.08252400904893875, 0.04792726784944534, 0.024710768833756447, -0.022960923612117767, 0.06776435673236847, -0.00963535439223051, -0.017706774175167084, -0.004449909087270498, 0.00034426673664711416, 0.025552954524755478, -0.017272857949137688, -0.005557840224355459, 0.041055966168642044, -0.03294803574681282, -0.008127435110509396, 0.020693795755505562 ]
<p>I am trying to grasp what exactly is "estimated" in the E-step of the algorithm. </p> <p>According to all definitions, in E-step the "conditional expectation values , or posterior probabilities of the hidden variables" are computed, using the Bayes formula ( posterior probability=prior( or marginal prob.) x likelihood/probability of evidence). Now, my question is, are these posterior probabilities, that I "estimate" or "compute", actually numbers or are they functions with respect to the current iteration's parameters ( and they are the ones I need to plug into M-step)? Where the probability of evidence would be likelihood, calculated with the previous argmax , calculated in previous M-step. </p>
g36664
[ 0.022192055359482765, -0.0467846654355526, 0.0010587513679638505, -0.012510992586612701, -0.016715817153453827, 0.024040553718805313, 0.012151501141488552, 0.07795889675617218, -0.080384261906147, -0.01182138454169035, -0.021490756422281265, 0.037084855139255524, 0.031219221651554108, 0.058411743491888046, -0.025567958131432533, -0.03286827355623245, 0.00328220147639513, -0.04622418433427811, -0.006694035604596138, -0.009919878095388412, 0.015294183045625687, 0.037946369498968124, -0.004767295438796282, -0.012324432842433453, -0.0169682539999485, 0.007052438799291849, -0.010171101428568363, 0.06265010684728622, -0.05464252829551697, -0.006910319440066814, 0.01670420728623867, -0.014904114417731762, 0.08217141777276993, -0.03498153015971184, -0.05212058126926422, -0.01022866740822792, 0.08878722041845322, 0.026361828669905663, 0.06970920413732529, -0.0639229416847229, -0.03370101749897003, 0.028358211740851402, 0.029550937935709953, 0.010370273143053055, -0.038521092385053635, -0.005996507592499256, -0.018318384885787964, 0.02494880184531212, 0.0429360531270504, -0.02295749820768833, 0.007814073003828526, 0.030760863795876503, 0.07821419835090637, -0.03830786421895027, -0.006082903128117323, 0.037221383303403854, 0.0018639679765328765, 0.018628975376486778, 0.06530609726905823, 0.03435918316245079, 0.06114424765110016, -0.10031883418560028, -0.03948293998837471, -0.0361715629696846, 0.007627971936017275, 0.0328962467610836, -0.08757279068231583, 0.023803194984793663, -0.06918591260910034, -0.014449695125222206, -0.03591456636786461, -0.01399680320173502, 0.007631352636963129, -0.03953912854194641, -0.0313759371638298, -0.03469259664416313, 0.009587622247636318, 0.0028756067622452974, -0.03195639327168465, 0.02063116431236267, 0.030624840408563614, -0.0010988607537001371, 0.044627781957387924, 0.017605112865567207, 0.014826816506683826, 0.002705654129385948, 0.002513876184821129, 0.019746951758861542, 0.035134878009557724, 0.01047543715685606, -0.016207221895456314, 0.0018385760486125946, 0.059513453394174576, 0.049185387790203094, -0.03049010969698429, -0.014577836729586124, -0.07339229434728622, 0.024797851219773293, 0.022254295647144318, 0.0029195051174610853, -0.04258526489138603, -0.03981957212090492, 0.0329621322453022, -0.07025844603776932, -0.030431078746914864, 0.021580221131443977, 0.001044605509378016, -0.03545098379254341, -0.01649831049144268, -0.023650145158171654, -0.014716033823788166, 0.016472503542900085, -0.035793062299489975, -0.05301268771290779, -0.10272274911403656, -0.0006679182988591492, 0.02526385523378849, 0.023484474048018456, -0.027118997648358345, 0.024584313854575157, -0.018501339480280876, 0.02614218182861805, 0.008157861419022083, 0.0578177310526371, 0.002226579003036022, -0.0036132903769612312, -0.06419782340526581, 0.007336533162742853, 0.024650337174534798, 0.014569468796253204, 0.02821781486272812, 0.0192789938300848, 0.029391342774033546, 0.04073216766119003, 0.021784614771604538, 0.017455818131566048, 0.017205771058797836, 0.01764008030295372, 0.033559221774339676, 0.02989886701107025, -0.060379136353731155, 0.01781632751226425, 0.017742235213518143, -0.05559505149722099, -0.027351750060915947, 0.024658147245645523, -0.0051386733539402485, 0.019602788612246513, -0.05084789916872978, 0.03145900368690491, -0.003993056248873472, 0.06887073814868927, 0.04491707682609558, 0.00334663363173604, 0.022502871230244637, 0.0072387997061014175, -0.012089586816728115, -0.06465964019298553, -0.04160549119114876, 0.08668825030326843, 0.09152176231145859, 0.04047791287302971, 0.018452320247888565, 0.017117071896791458, -0.024436086416244507, -0.01912258006632328, 0.040387071669101715, -0.06307986378669739, -0.028682488948106766, 0.010796691291034222, 0.02588331140577793, 0.03691592440009117, 0.004013119265437126, 0.005941636394709349, 0.013059832155704498, 0.01703815348446369, 0.06760399043560028, 0.020384477451443672, 0.0006880017463117838, 0.04289873316884041, -0.009293636307120323, 0.07703117281198502, 0.005036211106926203, -0.010865154676139355, -0.021212050691246986, -0.027234656736254692, -0.019141314551234245, 0.0024255539756268263, 0.0497010238468647, -0.020243946462869644, -0.058100566267967224, -0.027113445103168488, -0.10904663801193237, -0.020921790972352028, -0.011416973546147346, 0.02360994927585125, 0.019544927403330803, -0.024510396644473076, 0.0341021791100502, 0.027954068034887314, -0.013958032242953777, 0.007176804821938276, 0.02059137262403965, 0.015455137938261032, 0.06527575105428696, 0.04789205640554428, -0.03110959567129612, -0.10488155484199524, -0.029974527657032013, 0.04792633280158043, 0.002552749589085579, 0.008594350889325142, 0.002956059528514743, 0.039656661450862885, 0.02231258898973465, -0.01274592150002718, -0.023596106097102165, 0.05779371038079262, 0.04190424084663391, -0.08148028701543808, 0.023155521601438522, -0.0796990841627121, 0.026101423427462578, -0.022148197516798973, 0.021112190559506416, 0.07971702516078949, -0.007794850505888462, 0.02182062342762947, 0.0049154325388371944, 0.04748084023594856, -0.030001940205693245, -0.06950903683900833, -0.04174770042300224, -0.029176659882068634, 0.05941595509648323, -0.020716601982712746, -0.02958948165178299, -0.022903643548488617, 0.055825039744377136, 0.08425742387771606, 0.021814454346895218, 0.01254342868924141, 0.03803509101271629, 0.03006906807422638, 0.0481194369494915, 0.043765924870967865, 0.08720472455024719, 0.03007514961063862, 0.020787358283996582, 0.0472676083445549, -0.014206628315150738, 0.001046117627993226, -0.023895738646388054, 0.04227494075894356, -0.028303179889917374, 0.0000663102837279439, 0.002533192979171872, -0.027585046365857124, -0.018526852130889893, 0.0034395756665617228, -0.02972238138318062, 0.02988949604332447, -0.020553279668092728, 0.02536742202937603, 0.002582944929599762, -0.01556247379630804, -0.015497549436986446, -0.007190065458416939, 0.03695594519376755, -0.020565694198012352, -0.0045730844140052795, 0.039004676043987274, -0.005166427697986364, 0.03760538995265961, 0.01914563961327076, -0.01006067730486393, 0.03838619962334633, 0.018503298982977867, 0.0018017154652625322, -0.010195066221058369, -0.03815047815442085, -0.06596075743436813, 0.06935285031795502, 0.015843482688069344, -0.057706139981746674, 0.018814699724316597, 0.04455776512622833, -0.027834322303533554, 0.012889276258647442, 0.04844451695680618, 0.0038395465817302465, -0.046051621437072754, 0.014826977625489235, -0.006734713912010193, -0.04254316911101341, 0.006923317443579435, 0.020723458379507065, -0.017772844061255455, 0.04522579163312912, -0.06793177127838135, -0.04273587092757225, 0.011935866437852383, 0.014704791828989983, -0.08622758090496063, 0.057329609990119934, -0.033998262137174606, 0.005189954303205013, -0.01689479872584343, -0.01984289102256298, -0.04992414638400078, -0.04881663993000984, -0.007566139567643404, -0.025113152340054512, -0.06686294823884964, -0.03282177075743675, 0.025899633765220642, -0.009404432959854603, 0.015406549908220768, -0.07497642934322357, 0.017166316509246826, 0.020699260756373405, -0.012681320309638977, -0.020425284281373024, -0.02363365888595581, 0.055709537118673325, 0.004205488599836826, -0.012252314016222954, 0.040866293013095856, 0.039675794541835785, -0.06292472779750824, 0.05868593975901604, -0.011899307370185852, -0.028839005157351494, 0.03586769476532936, 0.061192579567432404, -0.049399975687265396, 0.006130056455731392, 0.03547625243663788, -0.051332537084817886, 0.012991245836019516, 0.04385514184832573, 0.022544782608747482, -0.03937029838562012, 0.008549724705517292, 0.025810537859797478, -0.03009301982820034, 0.0475613996386528, 0.04765991494059563, 0.0012368840398266912, -0.0675874724984169, 0.028606604784727097, -0.009280430153012276, -0.012006553821265697, 0.0015742683317512274, 0.01927596516907215, 0.05616593360900879, -0.034116555005311966, -0.045791950076818466, 0.04670557379722595, 0.020161205902695656, 0.017612088471651077, -0.04983522370457649, 0.03215121477842331, 0.03637941926717758, 0.03533782437443733, -0.06998240202665329, 0.0006711138412356377, 0.03760330379009247, -0.014977776445448399, -0.03774544969201088, 0.03466637060046196, 0.021392256021499634, -0.0008090866613201797, -0.006405072286725044, 0.028718210756778717, -0.028399957343935966, 0.04926416277885437, 0.007982192561030388, 0.014565091580152512, -0.030640991404652596, 0.000780335278250277, 0.031667448580265045, 0.023957476019859314, 0.0313405841588974, 0.0025382107123732567, -0.01183345727622509, -0.04218177869915962, 0.026942579075694084, 0.0153231555595994, -0.012683302164077759, 0.024165742099285126, 0.014754122123122215, -0.04865345358848572, -0.01062675192952156, 0.014919575303792953, 0.0010884477524086833, -0.04519709572196007, -0.016363639384508133, 0.02343827858567238, 0.01753554493188858, 0.02059103362262249, 0.014262368902564049, 0.045476291328668594, 0.02970932051539421, -0.016685066744685173, -0.01651759445667267, -0.024239473044872284, -0.0548371784389019, -0.008363462053239346, 0.008898725733160973, 0.02190747670829296, 0.0280474741011858, -0.010334477759897709, -0.003571938257664442, 0.008502205833792686, -0.010386968031525612, 0.019228477030992508, -0.08554833382368088, -0.022356407716870308, 0.031270019710063934, 0.03731992840766907, -0.049368709325790405, -0.021722329780459404, -0.010802830569446087, -0.053068503737449646, 0.0578288696706295, 0.049792636185884476, 0.028145048767328262, -0.014402293600142002, -0.025902139022946358, 0.013180582784116268, 0.0391281396150589, 0.04095711186528206, 0.029427766799926758, -0.032368723303079605, 0.004137543961405754, 0.005040840711444616, 0.03426439315080643, -0.010081917978823185, -0.04111780226230621, -0.026749031618237495, 0.012080058455467224, -0.029762448742985725, 0.053849078714847565, 0.01022302731871605, -0.007059015333652496, 0.0008414667099714279, 0.005322759039700031, 0.025310181081295013, 0.039164893329143524, -0.023469332605600357, 0.03312477469444275, 0.003030539723113179, 0.01086741778999567, 0.09234508872032166, 0.031407855451107025, -0.0868261307477951, -0.020461296662688255, -0.001131925848312676, -0.006091186311095953, 0.0330573208630085, -0.007402461022138596, -0.05652395263314247, 0.04725363478064537, -0.010950878262519836, -0.06405062228441238, -0.09292557835578918, -0.051761694252491, 0.049934543669223785, 0.05287450551986694, -0.002591830212622881, -0.03223508968949318, 0.00308845192193985, -0.004321127664297819, -0.0033382021356374025, -0.02273670956492424, -0.034856610000133514, 0.03637627512216568, -0.022091839462518692, 0.04616178199648857, -0.04583452641963959, 0.014631276950240135, -0.033736445009708405, 0.035204268991947174, -0.06300187110900879, 0.016931520774960518, -0.008266860619187355, -0.07941297441720963, 0.023974545300006866, 0.021439770236611366, 0.032107338309288025, 0.04191876947879791, 0.06585279852151871, -0.06019540876150131, 0.005955352447926998, -0.06282886862754822, 0.01610737107694149, 0.011233407072722912, -0.005090925842523575, 0.028130607679486275, -0.07577519118785858, 0.015586121007800102, 0.055366262793540955, -0.05404960736632347, 0.061107415705919266, 0.00030049122869968414, 0.016065632924437523, -0.03110993653535843, -0.033626068383455276, -0.011410738341510296, 0.040754154324531555, 0.0017569275805726647, -0.003197475103661418, -0.021068667992949486, -0.05285095050930977, -0.0612129308283329, 0.014371263794600964, -0.00961961317807436, -0.0388672910630703, 0.004918668419122696, 0.0509759895503521, 0.052663493901491165, 0.016027700155973434, 0.00039277668111026287, 0.03973234072327614, -0.07261504232883453, -0.032182324677705765, -0.002972944639623165, -0.06434065103530884, 0.03298133611679077, 0.010997559875249863, 0.008435851894319057, -0.0399162694811821, -0.005156321916729212, -0.05515684559941292, -0.02630687691271305, -0.01626376248896122, -0.04449209198355675, 0.0317627489566803, -0.0005036694346927106, -0.027093801647424698, -0.032672956585884094, 0.021678371354937553, -0.0010447804816067219, -0.00443239975720644, -0.001973568694666028, 0.06007277965545654, -0.008916514925658703, 0.05188869684934616, -0.05197027698159218, 0.016878560185432434, 0.020713794976472855, 0.013120697811245918, -0.03930339589715004, -0.02356898784637451, 0.04401370510458946, 0.011568364687263966, -0.025542544201016426, 0.0062097529880702496, -0.010533743537962437, 0.0019923618528991938, -0.04154059290885925, -0.03644108399748802, 0.024162758141756058, -0.021365530788898468, 0.028944270685315132, 0.03399698808789253, 0.030005982145667076, -0.04525348171591759, 0.007560078054666519, -0.02941097505390644, -0.08095104247331619, -0.012146545574069023, -0.0000812142388895154, 0.03157797455787659, -0.010233215056359768, -0.0021717287600040436, -0.050468288362026215, 0.015225972048938274, -0.02223852463066578, -0.020170744508504868, 0.01507895439863205, -0.04039815813302994, 0.004967561922967434, 0.013012738898396492, 0.0027016503736376762, -0.07595407217741013, -0.005303335376083851, -0.016505219042301178, -0.01703503727912903, -0.00019906663510482758, 0.06043475493788719, -0.031134646385908127, -0.003022861899808049, 0.006388260051608086, 0.01778900809586048, 0.0083460733294487, 0.0187884122133255, 0.030957842245697975, -0.018187545239925385, 0.011807582341134548, -0.01659604348242283, 0.05950898304581642, -0.0663769394159317, 0.02047848328948021, -0.008126283064484596, -0.026986338198184967, 0.027715610340237617, 0.016956865787506104, -0.006112393457442522, 0.018113020807504654, -0.05289733409881592, 0.00981496274471283, 0.005390028934925795, 0.010072462260723114, 0.0019176265923306346, -0.06213455647230148, -0.01592080481350422, -0.03229175880551338, 0.04100402817130089, 0.02729145623743534, -0.0024292138405144215, -0.027399426326155663, -0.019195737317204475, -0.00488660205155611, 0.008578266948461533, -0.005133232567459345, -0.005401416681706905, 0.04344046860933304, -0.01768627017736435, -0.02021186053752899, -0.05826237425208092, 0.004485585261136293, -0.019062530249357224, 0.02014223113656044, 0.03393467515707016, -0.009916640818119049, 0.10327081382274628, 0.009824900887906551, 0.06445690989494324, 0.03516140952706337, -0.010643339715898037, -0.0739036351442337, 0.013158767484128475, -0.009564832784235477, -0.042689599096775055, -0.003357016947120428, 0.047030508518218994, -0.024468688294291496, -0.006105881650000811, 0.00034615484764799476, -0.015992680564522743, 0.0012319033266976476, -0.002356634009629488, -0.025727910920977592, 0.016840513795614243, 0.04785553365945816, 0.002857134910300374, 0.05596362054347992, -0.014596533961594105, -0.06310053169727325, -0.06579176336526871, -0.04194174334406853, 0.028160763904452324, 0.062219422310590744, -0.05268022045493126, 0.024983836337924004, 0.008662247098982334, -0.047428637742996216, -0.04306267574429512, -0.02955440618097782, -0.054518625140190125, -0.05852733924984932, 0.009129821322858334, -0.023327240720391273, 0.024897588416934013, 0.03703608736395836, 0.031393565237522125, -0.056172847747802734, -0.009351909160614014, -0.0023768222890794277, 0.07483189553022385, -0.05279375985264778, 0.0214652381837368, -0.009454306215047836, -0.015448671765625477, -0.04595571011304855, -0.0555824413895607, -0.03391631320118904, -0.05700313299894333, 0.018392149358987808, -0.051014725118875504, 0.024481631815433502, 0.01641472801566124, -0.01297883503139019, 0.00989375077188015, 0.014002283103764057, -0.032638996839523315, 0.04057364538311958, 0.017597530037164688, 0.0021878634579479694, 0.03255429491400719, 0.016598431393504143, 0.046948157250881195, 0.0014624762116000056, -0.014497309923171997, 0.007740604691207409, -0.006571867968887091, 0.014695669524371624, -0.043220918625593185, -0.03925873711705208, -0.008761289529502392, -0.02209031581878662, 0.0014326985692605376, -0.05042586475610733, -0.030232803896069527, -0.004497822839766741, -0.017876820638775826, -0.004442792385816574, -0.011781277135014534, 0.004234196152538061, 0.02497834339737892, -0.01370682567358017, 0.039738815277814865, 0.028249245136976242, -0.03271620348095894, -0.01699282042682171, 0.10359929502010345, -0.024285482242703438, 0.008041957393288612, 0.015621388331055641, -0.06299381703138351, -0.02072921209037304, -0.0023173855151981115, 0.048637114465236664, -0.03905025124549866, 0.042313508689403534, -0.025119483470916748, 0.02410810999572277, 0.000583371554967016, -0.030212098732590675, -0.060192834585905075, 0.0616416335105896, -0.020000584423542023, 0.005378176923841238, -0.02744227461516857, -0.016473352909088135, 0.017709173262119293, 0.0862739086151123, 0.06441425532102585, 0.031703684478998184, -0.00715953204780817, -0.04798218235373497, 0.06633777171373367, -0.010047699324786663, 0.02357550896704197, 0.005856088362634182, -0.007083054631948471, 0.011706313118338585, -0.021341843530535698, 0.04683603718876839, -0.014173504896461964, -0.06588035821914673, -0.006706139072775841, -0.005005347542464733, -0.007108436431735754, 0.019409706816077232, 0.05875192582607269 ]
<p>I like to set up a 2 way repeated measures anova. I compare 4 models with 4 ages and see if the results differ, this should result in around 16 groups, since 4*4=16 (so far so good)</p> <p>However from some groups I don't have the data so I still have 2 factors to test for but not longer 16 groups but 15-14.</p> <p>This is not due to mistakes but due to the fact that the groups under this condition are just bad and don't meet standard recommondations. </p> <p>If however I'll try to do 2 way repeated measurments including my missing groups, I can't execute it.</p> <p>Is there a way to handle this missing groups?</p> <p>Greetings </p>
g36665
[ -0.051332924515008926, -0.03981238603591919, -0.029975024983286858, -0.005867141764611006, 0.014144135639071465, 0.036455873399972916, 0.015014381147921085, -0.03282685950398445, -0.04227530583739281, -0.011654060333967209, -0.03557775169610977, -0.004231875296682119, -0.05779465287923813, 0.042437415570020676, -0.007660266477614641, 0.0020009761210530996, 0.09023541212081909, 0.007971360348165035, 0.010378122329711914, 0.04202410951256752, 0.021602336317300797, 0.011246084235608578, 0.02220555953681469, -0.030512019991874695, -0.004285050090402365, -0.03163350000977516, -0.027102962136268616, 0.05244022235274315, -0.09809406101703644, -0.02603873610496521, -0.010578365065157413, 0.006667626556009054, 0.029552239924669266, -0.02575739100575447, -0.022011548280715942, -0.020858999341726303, 0.08044697344303131, 0.025668734684586525, -0.021374568343162537, -0.019525665789842606, 0.028470849618315697, 0.035176366567611694, 0.02252090908586979, 0.07187371701002121, 0.005410472396761179, 0.016925176605582237, -0.011703360825777054, -0.044119302183389664, 0.006721995770931244, -0.06950461119413376, 0.009699326939880848, -0.021877504885196686, 0.019541800022125244, -0.02939322404563427, -0.011253961361944675, 0.007178776897490025, -0.052212104201316833, 0.04087258130311966, 0.030560944229364395, 0.021591458469629288, -0.0011084888828918338, -0.020689228549599648, 0.004698979202657938, -0.03700834885239601, 0.016642622649669647, 0.04866752400994301, -0.06917431205511093, 0.03162698820233345, -0.04932480305433273, -0.037865787744522095, -0.01911098323762417, 0.028909945860505104, 0.009657745249569416, -0.04317976534366608, -0.018477128818631172, -0.005908808205276728, -0.061546772718429565, 0.028273537755012512, -0.0021063541062176228, 0.05899979919195175, -0.014642611145973206, 0.03881153091788292, 0.06300478428602219, -0.034242045134305954, 0.032666053622961044, 0.05219757556915283, 0.016286486759781837, 0.009359657764434814, 0.014820640906691551, 0.02516269125044346, 0.04425738751888275, -0.008813141845166683, 0.053158365190029144, 0.004519051872193813, 0.019665366038680077, 0.008406043983995914, -0.025050878524780273, 0.05299397557973862, -0.03208901733160019, 0.030045058578252792, -0.0008699992322362959, 0.07546136528253555, -0.06593666970729828, -0.0017121357377618551, -0.04057188332080841, -0.04317528381943703, 0.07231026142835617, 0.027156535536050797, -0.0218973308801651, -0.018798206001520157, -0.04329098016023636, -0.024767061695456505, -0.0549389123916626, 0.06559349596500397, -0.008519953116774559, 0.023998426273465157, 0.030215518549084663, -0.030774403363466263, -0.0022254742216318846, -0.013822609558701515, -0.02707700990140438, -0.004697057418525219, 0.054353028535842896, -0.0016213858034461737, 0.023275457322597504, 0.019317692145705223, -0.014030496589839458, 0.030381541699171066, 0.026476599276065826, -0.009073414839804173, 0.016618072986602783, 0.01748831570148468, 0.013222620822489262, 0.02613634057343006, -0.01904994435608387, 0.0054969172924757, 0.01200019009411335, 0.10382857173681259, -0.02027876302599907, 0.03899074345827103, -0.060414258390665054, 0.01566562056541443, 0.07154588401317596, -0.005115388892591, 0.055102575570344925, -0.061429254710674286, 0.0005241039907559752, -0.0593760684132576, -0.011030753143131733, -0.03350125625729561, 0.012742443010210991, 0.022488301619887352, 0.045914988964796066, 0.041764430701732635, -0.006938250735402107, -0.03166225552558899, -0.02033890038728714, 0.03321472927927971, 0.03115333802998066, 0.017992058768868446, 0.002792186103761196, -0.009630778804421425, 0.038325805217027664, -0.0006049830699339509, -0.003510757815092802, 0.09937193989753723, -0.01586751453578472, -0.009455493651330471, -0.002290590200573206, 0.03593327850103378, -0.05670112743973732, 0.022210540249943733, 0.0577082596719265, -0.008290489204227924, 0.010312237776815891, 0.06341468542814255, -0.009428826160728931, -0.03750788792967796, -0.004450603853911161, 0.011370757594704628, -0.001640980364754796, 0.04107946529984474, 0.0064232321456074715, -0.024783173575997353, -0.022073907777667046, -0.039821185171604156, -0.05985088273882866, 0.018167268484830856, -0.033193234354257584, -0.04342963919043541, 0.023257136344909668, -0.03099019266664982, -0.052385374903678894, -0.03460230678319931, 0.03981160372495651, -0.02452095039188862, 0.0056828949600458145, -0.020568864420056343, -0.039207376539707184, 0.024749187752604485, 0.02251935563981533, 0.011939612217247486, -0.006020748987793922, -0.012642567977309227, -0.015334578230977058, -0.013202637434005737, -0.01791348122060299, 0.047646552324295044, -0.00953394453972578, -0.049064457416534424, 0.013806333765387535, 0.007052829023450613, -0.030079199001193047, 0.05568834766745567, -0.005306239705532789, -0.004007988143712282, 0.07882732897996902, -0.006715039256960154, 0.01035643182694912, 0.004874575883150101, -0.04096580669283867, 0.012505856342613697, -0.0033720480278134346, 0.006996201816946268, 0.028473876416683197, 0.028585415333509445, 0.03478315472602844, 0.024836480617523193, -0.03247237578034401, 0.022841840982437134, -0.001791694900020957, -0.011502958834171295, 0.03911750391125679, -0.04373105987906456, 0.04048125818371773, 0.03400728479027748, -0.010594002902507782, 0.008254198357462883, 0.0023357882164418697, 0.02695980854332447, 0.03543856739997864, 0.013754462823271751, -0.03991135209798813, 0.03174390271306038, 0.013869564980268478, -0.010547696612775326, 0.017791105434298515, 0.018497001379728317, 0.02184567041695118, 0.02105683647096157, -0.039527777582407, 0.025278499349951744, -0.01943483203649521, -0.03744812682271004, -0.011835848912596703, -0.011977598071098328, 0.031166430562734604, 0.05691716820001602, 0.004856896121054888, 0.008936513215303421, -0.007985280826687813, 0.04085657373070717, 0.04687006399035454, 0.023654215037822723, -0.01022821944206953, -0.002847542753443122, -0.0054946583695709705, -0.059333134442567825, -0.051075734198093414, -0.03355478122830391, -0.019549952819943428, -0.0017745133955031633, 0.03684720769524574, 0.06931029260158539, 0.027001937851309776, 0.03468403220176697, -0.007529420778155327, 0.017833169549703598, 0.020585134625434875, 0.04443202540278435, 0.0581391341984272, -0.03726525604724884, 0.031008079648017883, -0.029764816164970398, 0.02479996532201767, 0.06064707785844803, 0.049508240073919296, -0.011327162384986877, -0.047444868832826614, 0.01730888895690441, -0.02358725294470787, 0.02408846840262413, 0.029658600687980652, -0.021565457805991173, 0.013821611180901527, -0.03742269054055214, -0.0006975444266572595, -0.03713766485452652, 0.017433498054742813, -0.022709157317876816, -0.023921560496091843, -0.01906614564359188, -0.02253103442490101, -0.0319172702729702, 0.05941375717520714, -0.08926942944526672, -0.003756777150556445, 0.041761260479688644, 0.042628850787878036, 0.011158778332173824, 0.07292863726615906, -0.025741804391145706, -0.017515426501631737, 0.00996443908661604, 0.016316866502165794, -0.04628358408808708, 0.018492335453629494, -0.01539701595902443, 0.03929482772946358, -0.01153731718659401, -0.000023670316295465454, -0.044207748025655746, 0.040985528379678726, 0.03915929049253464, -0.02725081890821457, 0.02774164266884327, -0.05225970596075058, 0.03447411209344864, -0.07827004045248032, 0.012987025082111359, 0.020745068788528442, 0.0339493453502655, -0.025865517556667328, -0.03601061925292015, -0.011047919280827045, -0.02153877727687359, -0.048601262271404266, -0.028851408511400223, 0.04716186597943306, 0.016259511932730675, -0.04414324089884758, -0.00835384614765644, -0.009057351388037205, 0.005186495371162891, -0.06127232685685158, -0.06781558692455292, -0.019066596403717995, 0.018575729802250862, 0.015936587005853653, -0.044724807143211365, 0.010890860110521317, 0.026065858080983162, -0.022839488461613655, -0.024708297103643417, 0.041284408420324326, 0.031668588519096375, 0.07469360530376434, -0.04524257779121399, 0.01413161214441061, -0.03042609989643097, -0.030347704887390137, -0.03328834846615791, -0.06039821729063988, 0.04191184043884277, 0.025405634194612503, 0.05137930065393448, 0.026158083230257034, 0.08749997615814209, 0.07123963534832001, -0.03867393732070923, 0.08489427715539932, 0.0012187677202746272, -0.00098252238240093, -0.055751118808984756, -0.03841092810034752, -0.04905995354056358, 0.05743859335780144, 0.01468556746840477, 0.006577893625944853, 0.06677816808223724, 0.09171469509601593, 0.0032365063671022654, -0.0017551427008584142, -0.036429986357688904, -0.03466304764151573, -0.07465575635433197, -0.03601212799549103, 0.003379963571205735, -0.08556675165891647, -0.020151110365986824, -0.03785747289657593, 0.034277480095624924, -0.0491313636302948, 0.0614212229847908, 0.009789001196622849, -0.08961091935634613, -0.00966097041964531, 0.008671506308019161, 0.03323914855718613, 0.03826439380645752, -0.054027047008275986, 0.003592005930840969, 0.0647372454404831, 0.02694060653448105, -0.07020165771245956, -0.014101236127316952, -0.01199857797473669, 0.034655991941690445, 0.007823921740055084, 0.06191755458712578, -0.11810252815485, -0.005041776690632105, 0.03389444947242737, -0.036438681185245514, 0.04627258703112602, -0.03277968615293503, 0.0531604140996933, -0.026076965034008026, -0.015369150787591934, 0.015768621116876602, -0.033906131982803345, 0.059284552931785583, -0.018637366592884064, -0.07291792333126068, 0.006840165704488754, 0.06507885456085205, -0.02347932569682598, -0.020719092339277267, 0.03362824767827988, -0.085585817694664, -0.011139897629618645, 0.010433781892061234, -0.028234608471393585, -0.03877183049917221, 0.0053678820841014385, 0.019148170948028564, 0.0037043613847345114, -0.004064628854393959, -0.027187315747141838, -0.014031460508704185, -0.005642424803227186, -0.012646964751183987, -0.002074957126751542, 0.009155815467238426, -0.03315797075629234, 0.025921963155269623, 0.03198432922363281, 0.010763668455183506, 0.00361442007124424, 0.056769613176584244, 0.01873336359858513, -0.023863235488533974, 0.04317239671945572, 0.013141194358468056, -0.03870507329702377, -0.013533631339669228, -0.015469325706362724, 0.05960734561085701, -0.029202304780483246, 0.04738661274313927, -0.06970115005970001, -0.04813489690423012, 0.031419020146131516, -0.011714369058609009, -0.008956498466432095, -0.09917603433132172, -0.004964879713952541, 0.004609378054738045, -0.041302941739559174, -0.03118310682475567, 0.025450391694903374, -0.06422414630651474, -0.03988295793533325, 0.023017115890979767, -0.04213744401931763, -0.005902083124965429, 0.04307453706860542, 0.05788453668355942, 0.008490539155900478, -0.022305715829133987, 0.02362610213458538, -0.04897721856832504, 0.050892993807792664, -0.013067143969237804, 0.013238802552223206, 0.0038168663159012794, -0.025094807147979736, -0.02324817329645157, 0.046048130840063095, -0.04747406393289566, -0.017460115253925323, 0.021497566252946854, 0.01914706826210022, -0.07827774435281754, -0.00483432412147522, 0.04790332913398743, -0.012566805817186832, -0.03160213679075241, -0.017974048852920532, -0.033830370754003525, -0.033966630697250366, 0.04790966212749481, 0.0536850169301033, -0.010030347853899002, 0.03015988878905773, 0.02650635875761509, 0.0077250381000339985, -0.028824632987380028, -0.006115726660937071, 0.03870858624577522, -0.011842220090329647, -0.0020574727095663548, 0.07354345917701721, -0.004045787733048201, -0.008403309620916843, 0.013529009185731411, 0.05929085239768028, 0.004243266303092241, -0.02527732215821743, -0.055029358714818954, 0.06137733906507492, 0.0056403339840471745, 0.03663169965147972, -0.006877000909298658, 0.04119168221950531, -0.007444225717335939, -0.05347171053290367, -0.034966643899679184, 0.04257500544190407, -0.020758923143148422, 0.05635449290275574, -0.05770008638501167, 0.009031609632074833, -0.018847862258553505, 0.033309970051050186, -0.05394032597541809, 0.02280973456799984, -0.0008039774256758392, -0.024027535691857338, -0.07789682596921921, -0.023890862241387367, 0.039090439677238464, 0.006810007616877556, -0.018482141196727753, 0.02592914178967476, 0.014562316238880157, 0.028496986255049706, -0.03258790448307991, 0.03567332774400711, -0.016552293673157692, -0.013681923970580101, 0.025102000683546066, -0.00740414671599865, 0.05191259831190109, -0.031292375177145004, -0.03243715316057205, -0.04455021396279335, -0.008903346955776215, 0.008825499564409256, -0.0028740460984408855, -0.019286686554551125, -0.03758867457509041, 0.015123187564313412, 0.007847887463867664, -0.01656966283917427, -0.008502432145178318, -0.013589583337306976, 0.014697706326842308, -0.032987646758556366, -0.018891746178269386, 0.00898170005530119, -0.021876491606235504, 0.024046743288636208, 0.015756098553538322, -0.0033210054971277714, 0.014997988939285278, -0.010600189678370953, 0.05117034539580345, 0.026286030188202858, -0.054665256291627884, -0.010097721591591835, 0.037216491997241974, -0.00999091099947691, 0.059794869273900986, -0.00780890928581357, 0.05246729031205177, -0.018764015287160873, -0.025206981226801872, 0.0013645455474033952, -0.024660957977175713, -0.0954386442899704, 0.02282596006989479, -0.010425197891891003, -0.005961574148386717, -0.061716943979263306, 0.011460197158157825, -0.013636145740747452, 0.00632138317450881, -0.021544601768255234, -0.004608490504324436, 0.0014556803507730365, -0.04009444639086723, 0.03612678870558739, -0.04990715533494949, 0.033599913120269775, -0.017003444954752922, -0.011973666027188301, 0.03432344272732735, 0.02114742621779442, 0.01907462812960148, -0.05259011685848236, -0.025513172149658203, 0.03291592374444008, 0.07777980715036392, -0.0059896414168179035, -0.029756521806120872, -0.03578690066933632, -0.051860786974430084, -0.04992469772696495, 0.016541162505745888, 0.07671485841274261, -0.04443373903632164, 0.07294002920389175, -0.02733531780540943, 0.04195309802889824, 0.04231391102075577, -0.023328371345996857, -0.021175311878323555, 0.010821846313774586, -0.017369339242577553, -0.010064871050417423, -0.04075517877936363, 0.01214172039180994, 0.038719043135643005, -0.01478724554181099, 0.029650572687387466, -0.018396897241473198, 0.08736010640859604, 0.011823327280580997, -0.022012392058968544, -0.00035676974221132696, 0.0565810389816761, -0.01305865403264761, 0.01665680482983589, -0.015908846631646156, -0.048180799931287766, 0.021606681868433952, 0.01842569187283516, -0.03388158231973648, -0.01249465998262167, 0.026501575484871864, 0.0048884982243180275, 0.024473344907164574, -0.03322770819067955, -0.00639499444514513, 0.042142949998378754, 0.05499286204576492, 0.002666015410795808, 0.030587146058678627, 0.02902955561876297, -0.043141599744558334, 0.005772266071289778, -0.01568607985973358, -0.01522751059383154, -0.03454981744289398, 0.0314381942152977, -0.05555674806237221, -0.010878225788474083, 0.03231830894947052, -0.00863431952893734, -0.004285127390176058, 0.01551771629601717, 0.013994323089718819, 0.0105808200314641, -0.010117895901203156, -0.03821997717022896, 0.026529505848884583, 0.05830230191349983, 0.008504290133714676, -0.020052723586559296, -0.023139795288443565, -0.06978007405996323, -0.004842154681682587, 0.05868032947182655, -0.008240915834903717, 0.0072113871574401855, 0.03870123624801636, 0.02675202116370201, 0.022042732685804367, -0.022131774574518204, -0.017198804765939713, -0.03946239501237869, 0.013764400966465473, -0.006343153305351734, -0.05671408027410507, 0.020627908408641815, -0.0011245168279856443, 0.005368642043322325, -0.023714058101177216, 0.000439120369264856, 0.05388554185628891, -0.005267100874334574, 0.013072285801172256, -0.03422953933477402, 0.029293939471244812, 0.009349188767373562, -0.03979752957820892, 0.009521174244582653, -0.02081015519797802, -0.06640005111694336, -0.04070182889699936, 0.09087109565734863, -0.05460060387849808, 0.029958166182041168, -0.001710230833850801, -0.04468446597456932, -0.07343623787164688, -0.03369317948818207, 0.007681629154831171, -0.07082583010196686, -0.015584152191877365, -0.0595015250146389, 0.0000461837844341062, -0.005304589867591858, -0.049356117844581604, -0.057008035480976105, -0.05292340740561485, 0.04977170750498772, -0.0015253234887495637, -0.0028821025043725967, -0.015339392237365246, 0.026851532980799675, -0.06103866174817085, 0.041583266109228134, 0.03520117700099945, 0.023645369336009026, 0.05997387319803238, 0.005937580019235611, 0.007321515120565891, 0.006219920702278614, -0.045660801231861115, 0.032053396105766296, 0.011896640993654728, 0.03436462953686714, 0.014515100978314877, -0.01761387288570404, -0.05425340309739113, -0.007103549782186747, 0.023795630782842636, -0.041178084909915924, -0.07389229536056519, 0.06309694796800613, -0.005187127739191055, 0.02615305408835411, 0.005107705947011709, 0.04093712940812111, 0.11349199712276459, 0.0011287584202364087, -0.0429329015314579, -0.0129819605499506, 0.02239026315510273, 0.015052256174385548, -0.07405376434326172, 0.046944793313741684, 0.014280112460255623, -0.030668631196022034, -0.04265093803405762, -0.022603556513786316 ]
<p>I have a textual classification problem that consists of two categories- zero an one. Up until now I tried solving it by creating a Document Term Matrix, and to run it through SVM (using RTextTools package). Here's a code snippet: (R)</p> <pre><code>models &lt;- train_models(container, algorithms=c("SVM")) results &lt;- classify_models(container, models) analytics &lt;- create_analytics(container, results) View(summary(analytics)) &gt;&gt;ALGORITHM PERFORMANCE &gt;&gt;SVM_PRECISION SVM_RECALL SVM_FSCORE &gt;&gt; 0.64 0.63 0.63 </code></pre> <p>My questions are as follows:</p> <ol> <li><p>Why are all the predicted values in the result matrix between 0.5-1? isn't it supposed to be 0-1? </p></li> <li><p>How can I see (in R) under which <strong><em>threshold</em></strong> are these precision and recall values being calculated? How can I change this threshold to get different values?</p></li> <li>How exactly are the recall/precision scores being calculated? I mean, supposed we have <em>theta</em> to separate that all scores above it are of class 1, and the rest are 0. Are these output scores just a simple mean of the two classes precision/recall? Is it a weighted average?</li> <li>How can I create in R two different thresholds values for each class (with what's left in between labeled as "unidentified")? </li> </ol>
g74039
[ -0.03457857295870781, -0.02234647423028946, -0.019615765661001205, 0.001092166523449123, 0.042168453335762024, -0.07144694030284882, 0.000027865929951076396, 0.07243282347917557, -0.04021533206105232, 0.016944827511906624, -0.04213665798306465, 0.019890250638127327, 0.13012969493865967, -0.02853764407336712, -0.025083404034376144, -0.0535576306283474, 0.05714691802859306, -0.027175387367606163, 0.00563874701038003, -0.006365345790982246, -0.02940092608332634, 0.035927604883909225, -0.012617144733667374, -0.04646473005414009, -0.015779953449964523, 0.004001752007752657, -0.06410465389490128, 0.07294852286577225, -0.058979425579309464, 0.07192215323448181, 0.007471814751625061, 0.023786602541804314, -0.03265995904803276, -0.06416936963796616, 0.018316468223929405, 0.0015360096003860235, 0.03754919022321701, 0.0429343655705452, -0.037647124379873276, 0.007348265964537859, 0.04067906737327576, -0.026318607851862907, 0.016689179465174675, -0.07170183956623077, -0.004390844143927097, -0.017485519871115685, -0.004873137455433607, -0.022902866825461388, 0.0030734846368432045, 0.030103594064712524, 0.0217346902936697, -0.012061145156621933, 0.01899833418428898, -0.034689027816057205, 0.005998415406793356, 0.026248393580317497, -0.03805433586239815, 0.02031319960951805, 0.011356049217283726, 0.03808952495455742, 0.012243743054568768, -0.020759619772434235, -0.014698391780257225, 0.01816275157034397, 0.03325260430574417, 0.03097275085747242, -0.0039733643643558025, -0.004094582982361317, -0.025609349831938744, -0.03667481243610382, -0.020383264869451523, 0.0535944327712059, -0.025761615484952927, 0.02631525695323944, -0.113716721534729, -0.03144169971346855, -0.03468197584152222, -0.0007804431370459497, 0.060031499713659286, 0.05909651517868042, 0.032045748084783554, 0.016848579049110413, 0.00031304406002163887, 0.04349411278963089, -0.0341293141245842, 0.035918738692998886, -0.023762855678796768, 0.06262830644845963, 0.009885691106319427, 0.06167500838637352, 0.002516479231417179, -0.01184804830700159, 0.02132744900882244, 0.0541379339993, -0.002290974138304591, 0.04337269812822342, -0.020223120227456093, -0.01514273602515459, 0.01242250856012106, -0.04854219779372215, 0.02140488289296627, 0.028163693845272064, 0.09312829375267029, -0.0647529810667038, -0.011729314923286438, 0.04280504584312439, 0.034273307770490646, -0.0038289385847747326, -0.032423753291368484, -0.033044494688510895, -0.015929851680994034, 0.014045066200196743, -0.07172594219446182, -0.002964809536933899, -0.03936928138136864, -0.03262453153729439, 0.05657411739230156, -0.004829059354960918, -0.019017107784748077, -0.04635421186685562, 0.027300462126731873, -0.025746168568730354, 0.07358015328645706, 0.05521243438124657, -0.0009521606261841953, -0.012670747004449368, 0.012833072803914547, 0.02626710757613182, -0.012373920530080795, -0.034096889197826385, 0.011386094614863396, -0.017198355868458748, 0.014589727856218815, 0.039564039558172226, 0.022504258900880814, 0.04539044201374054, -0.017056552693247795, 0.028505856171250343, 0.007611686363816261, -0.051853589713573456, -0.04816076532006264, -0.017033692449331284, -0.031254712492227554, -0.0209161639213562, -0.050012484192848206, -0.09070863574743271, -0.08186893910169601, 0.02529427781701088, 0.006569196004420519, -0.005191909149289131, 0.057528428733348846, 0.04853391274809837, -0.06822790205478668, 0.04760921001434326, -0.027962874621152878, -0.006435262970626354, 0.07499553263187408, -0.08938438445329666, -0.091557577252388, -0.0178111232817173, 0.07266048341989517, 0.021954182535409927, 0.09859976917505264, -0.019702961668372154, -0.09127302467823029, -0.02482532523572445, -0.02439560368657112, -0.09481791406869888, -0.008193905465304852, -0.008912080898880959, -0.025574514642357826, -0.016635222360491753, 0.023584851995110512, -0.0194169320166111, -0.004925659857690334, 0.017890574410557747, 0.06940528005361557, 0.0008034665952436626, 0.08390217274427414, 0.02899085357785225, -0.014941384084522724, 0.013389370404183865, 0.03421273082494736, -0.04539273679256439, -0.032081861048936844, -0.042210981249809265, -0.010816683061420918, 0.01883811689913273, -0.04520096629858017, 0.0027080459985882044, -0.01399048138409853, 0.00010351619130233303, 0.016779588535428047, -0.01883085072040558, -0.047343529760837555, 0.0001942394592333585, -0.021442515775561333, -0.04234384372830391, -0.03376036509871483, -0.04872367903590202, 0.045909952372312546, 0.037028718739748, -0.10768578201532364, 0.03956077992916107, -0.03902895376086235, 0.015470260754227638, 0.03689897432923317, -0.009246893227100372, -0.07186321914196014, 0.06318323314189911, 0.044616445899009705, -0.021319128572940826, -0.019474318251013756, 0.030169378966093063, -0.001912853796966374, -0.003826918313279748, -0.018441440537571907, -0.006035212427377701, 0.01749517023563385, 0.01662946306169033, -0.023772673681378365, -0.035935331135988235, -0.027053313329815865, 0.024601010605692863, -0.09136685729026794, 0.03319362923502922, 0.05438956990838051, 0.06299473345279694, 0.014734815806150436, 0.0013923231745138764, -0.012755085714161396, 0.0013208051677793264, -0.024688348174095154, -0.04124873876571655, -0.0021624474320560694, -0.021206485107541084, 0.003730658208951354, 0.05099549517035484, -0.05826235190033913, -0.00949990376830101, 0.042020928114652634, 0.020041536539793015, 0.012315256521105766, -0.0011670456733554602, 0.0127799017354846, -0.05359071493148804, 0.06138410046696663, -0.0021155234426259995, 0.008004074916243553, 0.0622609443962574, -0.09016706049442291, 0.02818111516535282, -0.04910330846905708, 0.0546494759619236, 0.008684923872351646, -0.03162922337651253, 0.03596761077642441, 0.03028835915029049, 0.003967462573200464, 0.033544231206178665, -0.01890912838280201, 0.03508636727929115, 0.015232459641993046, 0.05339571088552475, -0.007533395662903786, -0.0027313947211951017, 0.00278996373526752, -0.05606677755713463, 0.043167561292648315, -0.01395335141569376, -0.06315962225198746, 0.02608231082558632, 0.059580300003290176, -0.01693023182451725, 0.019305899739265442, 0.022463930770754814, -0.015858234837651253, 0.008842109702527523, 0.03439105674624443, 0.014447055757045746, -0.07409284263849258, -0.0365450456738472, 0.03332153335213661, -0.013325835578143597, -0.013546810485422611, -0.04294411092996597, -0.010587961412966251, 0.029965415596961975, 0.036331657320261, 0.006318020634353161, -0.009049268439412117, 0.028083546087145805, -0.004223259631544352, -0.05045683681964874, 0.005968818906694651, -0.01619776524603367, -0.007030298933386803, -0.05593862012028694, 0.010606586933135986, 0.016701946035027504, -0.06873046606779099, -0.0038875776808708906, 0.03108999878168106, 0.0015444773016497493, 0.0044921268709003925, -0.04752204194664955, -0.02629525400698185, 0.03869904205203056, -0.03913618251681328, -0.006174885202199221, -0.01680079847574234, -0.02231423184275627, 0.04027789458632469, -0.05573960393667221, 0.02898387610912323, 0.042002297937870026, -0.018608640879392624, 0.01905280351638794, -0.01595381088554859, -0.008110562339425087, -0.03004937432706356, -0.014439914375543594, 0.05408944562077522, -0.004953606519848108, -0.03662661835551262, 0.016356581822037697, -0.02794533595442772, 0.005693737417459488, -0.03471941500902176, 0.010864227078855038, 0.05301819369196892, 0.016301268711686134, -0.01687471754848957, -0.044165246188640594, 0.050042297691106796, -0.006719097960740328, -0.029706737026572227, -0.013606885448098183, 0.021967271342873573, -0.005806718021631241, -0.009524334222078323, 0.026403382420539856, 0.07553322613239288, -0.005355852656066418, 0.016887735575437546, 0.021565834060311317, 0.0026511065661907196, -0.01078588142991066, -0.006405329797416925, 0.014435810968279839, 0.017295630648732185, -0.0037681367248296738, -0.010688211768865585, -0.028865423053503036, -0.015066456981003284, 0.05220550298690796, 0.007672076113522053, 0.02916819043457508, -0.010548897087574005, -0.028725137934088707, 0.02459092065691948, 0.0002494952059350908, -0.061016764491796494, 0.013450024649500847, 0.0058957492001354694, -0.0023532004561275244, 0.03140658140182495, 0.033857036381959915, 0.001393368118442595, -0.01833800971508026, 0.06327266246080399, -0.07144259661436081, 0.02245962806046009, -0.05943358317017555, -0.04395854100584984, -0.016217058524489403, -0.003310392377898097, 0.04582823067903519, 0.006149660795927048, 0.0624399371445179, -0.003102158196270466, -0.04097198322415352, 0.0032891430892050266, 0.019254788756370544, -0.020348429679870605, 0.009308450855314732, 0.009116927161812782, -0.00509358337149024, -0.001319657894782722, -0.03616892546415329, -0.0044268169440329075, 0.002409097971394658, -0.041473638266325, 0.044898174703121185, 0.0033771833404898643, 0.0011410583974793553, 0.036479271948337555, 0.0562828965485096, -0.03257540613412857, 0.0758286714553833, -0.037254463881254196, 0.038031868636608124, 0.010901502333581448, -0.02812528982758522, -0.05103731527924538, -0.02245405502617359, -0.046963587403297424, 0.016377367079257965, 0.002953461604192853, 0.06040741130709648, -0.02986193262040615, -0.03466106206178665, -0.006612552795559168, -0.061053551733493805, 0.01522891502827406, 0.020614195615053177, 0.04161961004137993, 0.00587347662076354, -0.037861812859773636, 0.02029082179069519, -0.02116963267326355, 0.057592641562223434, -0.0018093872349709272, -0.05241665989160538, 0.027313232421875, 0.007225255016237497, 0.03246185928583145, 0.024962762370705605, 0.05622464790940285, -0.014875102788209915, 0.01975884474813938, 0.015129176899790764, -0.03380827605724335, 0.057535186409950256, 0.025620322674512863, 0.033071793615818024, 0.025020211935043335, 0.0006509264349006116, -0.009861367754638195, -0.024152254685759544, -0.01470225676894188, -0.042090192437171936, 0.005991622805595398, 0.02042999304831028, -0.008885585702955723, -0.015020538121461868, 0.026916278526186943, 0.01511017419397831, -0.042739126831293106, 0.02143193408846855, -0.06808442622423172, 0.06268574297428131, -0.010689995251595974, -0.014670776203274727, 0.007984178140759468, -0.02163652703166008, -0.02744157612323761, 0.049076490104198456, 0.019538260996341705, -0.028754619881510735, 0.00675327330827713, -0.032143108546733856, -0.018574444577097893, -0.007495665457099676, -0.032922495156526566, -0.07515115290880203, -0.034254323691129684, -0.0050669568590819836, 0.0689205527305603, -0.011394555680453777, 0.013748597353696823, -0.05792594701051712, -0.0052549042738974094, -0.01661541685461998, 0.044704992324113846, 0.04186859726905823, -0.013785993680357933, -0.024413589388132095, 0.004473627544939518, -0.026541611179709435, -0.046752966940402985, 0.02762131579220295, 0.026909509673714638, 0.05495681241154671, 0.047416649758815765, 0.007994912564754486, 0.029779158532619476, -0.0643121525645256, 0.05934278294444084, 0.0010342539753764868, -0.03184645250439644, 0.05037607625126839, -0.032200101763010025, -0.008076095953583717, 0.027415715157985687, -0.026647863909602165, 0.03140359744429588, 0.016981415450572968, -0.0675513967871666, -0.004182430449873209, -0.00493869511410594, 0.024962957948446274, 0.006429075263440609, -0.024363601580262184, 0.04356967285275459, -0.06304407864809036, 0.04339098557829857, -0.013458914123475552, 0.04688370227813721, -0.007812606170773506, 0.006389413494616747, 0.023136412724852562, -0.003907895181328058, 0.02099803276360035, 0.000314317672746256, -0.011411280371248722, 0.011441455222666264, 0.0221631471067667, -0.06755180656909943, 0.02219388633966446, -0.005413217004388571, -0.07881935685873032, 0.006823007948696613, 0.006831551436334848, -0.020731842145323753, -0.07230696082115173, -0.009874749928712845, -0.08073266595602036, 0.0354008749127388, -0.002870346652343869, 0.0028970895800739527, 0.01607639715075493, -0.019127819687128067, -0.008068064227700233, 0.058873508125543594, -0.011359056457877159, 0.007045165169984102, -0.012577047571539879, 0.005900107324123383, -0.006563705392181873, -0.002313876524567604, 0.04087303206324577, -0.021288052201271057, 0.01883625239133835, -0.012139374390244484, -0.06127447262406349, 0.0211038738489151, -0.03912621736526489, 0.014062727801501751, -0.032566484063863754, -0.05623728781938553, -0.0020978525280952454, -0.005957928020507097, -0.003518169280141592, 0.041849859058856964, 0.09436621516942978, 0.03222128003835678, -0.028795605525374413, -0.00529182655736804, -0.010790761560201645, 0.02074645832180977, -0.04349193722009659, 0.011678929440677166, 0.07109126448631287, 0.007453941740095615, 0.05042524263262749, -0.0215389896184206, -0.006040538661181927, 0.025587156414985657, 0.015215779654681683, 0.05630302429199219, -0.036219798028469086, 0.043375950306653976, -0.03316788002848625, -0.02183954231441021, 0.023477377369999886, 0.01610497571527958, 0.07356639951467514, 0.010000080801546574, -0.039092887192964554, 0.026441270485520363, 0.02609092742204666, 0.035752903670072556, -0.02318994142115116, -0.02308286912739277, 0.010585585609078407, -0.05679263547062874, -0.03552065044641495, 0.007513063959777355, 0.04149046912789345, -0.018653227016329765, 0.0006313991616480052, -0.002594559220597148, -0.005205190274864435, -0.02584945224225521, 0.04260481148958206, -0.00458791246637702, 0.027366146445274353, -0.03491609916090965, 0.040514279156923294, 0.01895049773156643, 0.036401260644197464, 0.06308510899543762, -0.047433413565158844, 0.013258915394544601, 0.013740926049649715, -0.03611217811703682, 0.04896033555269241, -0.0159443486481905, 0.023631151765584946, -0.04865455627441406, -0.0030457116663455963, 0.023966088891029358, 0.0793064683675766, -0.009694243781268597, -0.026294216513633728, -0.03036496415734291, 0.013650806620717049, -0.042254045605659485, -0.017797505483031273, 0.021647673100233078, -0.04307183250784874, 0.048339102417230606, -0.019704187288880348, 0.06628315150737762, 0.027403922751545906, 0.009258284233510494, 0.022022856399416924, 0.02985806204378605, 0.0057554119266569614, -0.0540827140212059, -0.05375200882554054, -0.006894376594573259, 0.04005027189850807, -0.0009514160919934511, -0.016005748882889748, -0.02757921628654003, 0.0195421501994133, 0.05803593993186951, 0.07786336541175842, 0.026439398527145386, 0.02307693287730217, -0.06572926789522171, -0.023785943165421486, 0.017590584233403206, 0.005533726420253515, 0.05712335184216499, -0.019039636477828026, -0.08783380687236786, 0.015193545259535313, -0.006280877161771059, 0.03422054275870323, 0.027239257469773293, -0.024271849542856216, -0.011835203506052494, 0.005654417909681797, 0.03126990422606468, -0.0005979353445582092, 0.050168052315711975, -0.017933959141373634, -0.009615262039005756, -0.056451790034770966, -0.01895728148519993, -0.018383286893367767, 0.07388944923877716, 0.016930101439356804, -0.020888442173600197, 0.01576688140630722, -0.001580202835611999, -0.05341913178563118, 0.02074604667723179, -0.00541226752102375, -0.0012109248200431466, -0.007826225832104683, 0.023692669346928596, 0.014880627393722534, -0.016077745705842972, 0.007549318019300699, -0.024104423820972443, -0.03234429657459259, -0.03259426727890968, -0.021897561848163605, 0.0001434233709005639, -0.043803371489048004, 0.017509572207927704, 0.04567417502403259, -0.002244760049507022, 0.002698402153328061, 0.036960482597351074, -0.06888709962368011, 0.03844828903675079, 0.011653559282422066, -0.0066757299937307835, 0.04228290915489197, -0.03848453238606453, -0.03818840906023979, -0.008550030179321766, 0.04422221705317497, 0.029260512441396713, 0.04664020240306854, 0.020987963303923607, 0.056566108018159866, 0.009000337682664394, 0.056724727153778076, -0.03311813622713089, 0.0595645010471344, -0.03265490010380745, -0.013478482142090797, 0.010470257140696049, -0.05300462618470192, -0.062340252101421356, 0.05538787692785263, -0.003505260217934847, -0.005962358321994543, -0.02096947655081749, 0.027120985090732574, 0.004940804559737444, -0.0008070995099842548, -0.0161772258579731, 0.03200755640864372, -0.03436565026640892, 0.007762723136693239, -0.01636524870991707, -0.012443006969988346, 0.02568107843399048, 0.008912630379199982, 0.05515400692820549, 0.03719606623053551, 0.00856157299131155, -0.017466405406594276, -0.03052620030939579, -0.029927344992756844, -0.0771053209900856, 0.045173753052949905, 0.0011580329155549407, 0.00729713449254632, 0.03016483411192894, 0.0266097504645586, -0.013893642462790012, 0.049486950039863586, -0.05143294483423233, -0.0006637066835537553, 0.010972881689667702, 0.046133801341056824, 0.004146618768572807, -0.025485007092356682, -0.01676584780216217, 0.03896992653608322, -0.03302989527583122, -0.1093488484621048, -0.04646438732743263, 0.037508800625801086, -0.07673371583223343, 0.051635563373565674, -0.004082638770341873, -0.022590436041355133, -0.0179649218916893, -0.015765348449349403, 0.06423288583755493, -0.05375003442168236, 0.0026309932582080364, -0.007400141563266516, -0.02407052554190159, 0.023060467094182968, -0.017578458413481712, -0.016560059040784836, -0.0016931367572396994, 0.015308228321373463 ]
<p>If I would like to fit random intercept and slope and if I write it as (color|writer) compared to (1+color|writer), are they the same?</p>
g74040
[ 0.00781705416738987, -0.06375198811292648, -0.019004110246896744, -0.055488258600234985, 0.035342659801244736, -0.03693385794758797, 0.056081146001815796, -0.0028090011328458786, -0.049598727375268936, -0.04961337149143219, 0.010158490389585495, 0.0044477107003331184, 0.0026145551819354296, 0.023692656308412552, -0.02044820412993431, 0.015185167081654072, 0.08716192841529846, -0.017936579883098602, -0.0018991115503013134, -0.008165268227458, -0.09399088472127914, -0.028432514518499374, 0.0035437936894595623, -0.0015178581234067678, 0.014877108857035637, -0.08707410097122192, -0.05555133521556854, -0.02627873234450817, -0.06958578526973724, 0.005253876559436321, -0.006619541440159082, 0.02201364003121853, -0.01332984957844019, -0.03617003932595253, -0.04642581567168236, 0.016111047938466072, 0.014665510505437851, -0.006849355064332485, -0.00850894208997488, 0.010620742104947567, 0.012069012969732285, 0.0752834901213646, 0.031464699655771255, -0.006455522496253252, 0.009096029214560986, -0.008822753094136715, -0.014963068999350071, 0.031032871454954147, 0.010338174179196358, -0.03196696192026138, -0.02432417869567871, 0.041791822761297226, -0.03665682300925255, -0.011942015960812569, -0.021426722407341003, 0.0700397714972496, 0.01269584521651268, -0.039613641798496246, -0.01890740543603897, 0.06631451100111008, -0.013391083106398582, 0.01290174201130867, -0.06100290268659592, 0.011156981810927391, 0.03633234277367592, -0.0017118079122155905, 0.01945498026907444, 0.0012598928296938539, -0.0452437624335289, -0.060441676527261734, 0.0015387891326099634, -0.03182237967848778, 0.016350895166397095, -0.0816493034362793, -0.07643754035234451, 0.008948524482548237, 0.039210084825754166, 0.0014175968244671822, 0.01638900861144066, 0.08001241832971573, -0.058480843901634216, 0.016492661088705063, 0.00820700079202652, 0.009627478197216988, 0.11131825298070908, 0.010014367289841175, 0.05486774072051048, 0.008022868074476719, -0.011014468036592007, 0.01419784501194954, -0.011735992506146431, -0.06302466988563538, 0.026449335739016533, 0.04004434123635292, -0.0025637028738856316, -0.015895700082182884, -0.08723177015781403, 0.01677112653851509, -0.006606831215322018, -0.0016152028692886233, -0.024266451597213745, 0.01176992617547512, -0.01588599942624569, -0.04711573198437691, -0.025332702323794365, -0.053400300443172455, 0.015362019650638103, 0.01798310875892639, -0.0077019622549414635, -0.07419432699680328, 0.0027000175323337317, -0.009852631017565727, -0.009196639060974121, -0.050974421203136444, 0.011868134140968323, 0.017449913546442986, 0.042293351143598557, -0.035205043852329254, 0.0016124334651976824, 0.08464714884757996, 0.004733572248369455, -0.0004505719698499888, -0.005174430552870035, 0.016429107636213303, 0.04491151124238968, 0.008957481011748314, 0.010831428691744804, 0.020802345126867294, 0.022132160142064095, -0.012444823980331421, -0.00982249528169632, 0.0039290026761591434, 0.004031043965369463, -0.03009706549346447, -0.042470090091228485, -0.0021209276746958494, -0.011045355349779129, 0.030610278248786926, -0.036622680723667145, -0.034221403300762177, 0.0197810810059309, 0.012826230376958847, -0.03136381879448891, -0.004108363762497902, -0.0658329427242279, -0.028373124077916145, -0.0333210751414299, -0.04682505875825882, 0.00361834280192852, -0.02618575654923916, -0.02075476571917534, -0.024640917778015137, -0.017364444211125374, 0.01756535843014717, -0.06350959092378616, 0.05823640152812004, 0.03149282932281494, 0.006838638801127672, 0.006842293776571751, -0.023233959451317787, -0.004523046780377626, -0.03884559124708176, 0.0965038537979126, 0.025352517142891884, -0.01299707405269146, -0.04386226087808609, -0.013614319264888763, 0.01630377396941185, -0.08779880404472351, -0.046315792948007584, 0.02171015553176403, 0.038130443543195724, 0.02985982783138752, -0.031018009409308434, 0.04949306696653366, 0.04413731396198273, -0.028820155188441277, -0.002627801848575473, 0.008828211575746536, -0.02976907230913639, 0.01178076583892107, 0.03365437686443329, 0.03022276982665062, -0.07135474681854248, 0.03635210171341896, -0.04810256138443947, -0.016780398786067963, -0.019646629691123962, -0.022132953628897667, 0.022697091102600098, -0.00328201986849308, -0.018376030027866364, -0.015161699615418911, 0.010072117671370506, -0.0064199576154351234, 0.012119038961827755, -0.035589270293712616, -0.006238378118723631, -0.057901475578546524, 0.05458999425172806, 0.022050730884075165, 0.059658508747816086, -0.016431275755167007, 0.00002340810897294432, -0.023934874683618546, 0.010600661858916283, 0.053093522787094116, -0.011341133154928684, -0.001282727811485529, -0.025565311312675476, 0.07134240120649338, 0.035741303116083145, 0.04581514373421669, 0.03912757709622383, -0.006093610543757677, 0.015507723204791546, 0.022192485630512238, -0.018275927752256393, 0.006119040306657553, -0.041325584053993225, 0.03361285850405693, -0.044859763234853745, 0.037241969257593155, -0.029447561129927635, -0.00008305099618155509, 0.02210686355829239, -0.025819558650255203, 0.03174735978245735, 0.056124936789274216, -0.012724867090582848, -0.06174219027161598, -0.015513735823333263, 0.03870518133044243, -0.026205044239759445, 0.05956157296895981, 0.02124473825097084, 0.06238230690360069, -0.007604572921991348, -0.002748672617599368, -0.023327747359871864, 0.024181773886084557, -0.002175737638026476, -0.035148292779922485, 0.06691987067461014, -0.020439932122826576, 0.053578127175569534, -0.02200879529118538, -0.017869023606181145, -0.003523462451994419, 0.0803677961230278, -0.03789430856704712, -0.0007064529927447438, -0.026675565168261528, 0.023697949945926666, -0.025029068812727928, -0.059616148471832275, 0.04513778164982796, -0.04839055612683296, -0.019572006538510323, 0.00136495940387249, -0.016764743253588676, 0.013150403276085854, -0.03899206221103668, 0.012673572637140751, -0.049434106796979904, 0.030280349776148796, 0.04542330279946327, 0.041236717253923416, 0.01951093040406704, 0.004507803823798895, 0.0037867301143705845, -0.020541688427329063, 0.010502532124519348, 0.026041623204946518, 0.006272295955568552, 0.03832291066646576, -0.04135280102491379, -0.1085795983672142, 0.024504054337739944, -0.026418905705213547, 0.012318157590925694, 0.028767570853233337, -0.036574918776750565, 0.009532990865409374, -0.014668733812868595, -0.022328780964016914, 0.051000453531742096, -0.021941399201750755, -0.05772004649043083, 0.058516599237918854, -0.0761488527059555, 0.010634741745889187, 0.060580942779779434, -0.01738140545785427, -0.004315664060413837, -0.0021371878683567047, 0.03757612407207489, -0.007101790513843298, 0.07859766483306885, 0.01732729934155941, -0.07049316167831421, 0.03812767192721367, 0.007799722719937563, -0.01637514866888523, 0.0392029769718647, -0.00905078649520874, -0.032747454941272736, -0.010368851944804192, 0.03296227753162384, -0.003906347788870335, -0.06438589096069336, 0.019130874425172806, -0.02813599817454815, 0.006548861972987652, 0.013802929781377316, -0.0581740140914917, 0.025556327775120735, 0.0376092791557312, -0.0039550610817968845, 0.03597456216812134, -0.06009729579091072, -0.04250852018594742, 0.01926279254257679, 0.016154956072568893, -0.054302528500556946, -0.030257506296038628, 0.003779651829972863, 0.05130263790488243, -0.008139541372656822, 0.015050294809043407, 0.06175631284713745, 0.05472453311085701, 0.01889949105679989, 0.011918499134480953, 0.09608332067728043, -0.018189622089266777, 0.06777548044919968, -0.00953508261591196, -0.01202201098203659, -0.02425113320350647, -0.042803701013326645, -0.010702459141612053, -0.004993091337382793, -0.021597417071461678, -0.008562318049371243, -0.011564018204808235, 0.06877157837152481, -0.013959528878331184, -0.011520150117576122, -0.004761019721627235, 0.03060581535100937, 0.00840250588953495, 0.021431317552924156, -0.030759382992982864, 0.008396842516958714, 0.019173111766576767, -0.010707882232964039, 0.04862207546830177, -0.025579525157809258, 0.07680519670248032, 0.06732108443975449, -0.035575009882450104, 0.016562674194574356, 0.02959778718650341, -0.0038318794686347246, 0.0038484239485114813, -0.02501693367958069, 0.028430145233869553, -0.02093031257390976, 0.032693371176719666, -0.004349710885435343, 0.02172476425766945, 0.08135083317756653, 0.0014411706943064928, -0.013608628883957863, 0.019637996330857277, 0.022629892453551292, 0.0036289901472628117, 0.008078084327280521, -0.016765518113970757, 0.0411200076341629, -0.02620876580476761, 0.01343968790024519, 0.0031904445495456457, 0.012948870658874512, 0.0014229407534003258, -0.018188990652561188, -0.025149136781692505, 0.04719284549355507, -0.06422597169876099, -0.0121097257360816, -0.04572555795311928, -0.048427436500787735, 0.033435821533203125, 0.0025137034244835377, -0.006454422604292631, -0.01163483690470457, 0.04823669418692589, -0.0451577864587307, 0.0274826567620039, -0.013898482546210289, 0.0009461185545660555, -0.00015810568584129214, 0.002078434219583869, -0.019891608506441116, 0.008495955727994442, 0.03277624770998955, 0.0465473048388958, -0.058775030076503754, -0.03609621524810791, -0.04439252242445946, -0.026159925386309624, -0.011387799866497517, 0.00033293446176685393, 0.029497463256120682, -0.018096832558512688, 0.005349496379494667, 0.05676892399787903, 0.023867785930633545, -0.026148585602641106, 0.008476445451378822, 0.011975392699241638, -0.036800313740968704, -0.003231951268389821, 0.043258730322122574, -0.018904143944382668, 0.0002251360274385661, 0.03324417769908905, 0.028181711211800575, 0.010420453734695911, 0.012132296338677406, 0.014302465133368969, 0.025321241468191147, 0.026732347905635834, -0.003082575974985957, -0.0043122414499521255, 0.0013405079953372478, 0.047526322305202484, -0.001689641154371202, 0.04024948924779892, -0.007081174291670322, -0.04277082905173302, -0.026502758264541626, -0.05645289272069931, 0.07412273436784744, 0.03068780153989792, -0.01613040640950203, -0.005129536148160696, -0.02019411139190197, 0.06435462087392807, -0.009908901527523994, -0.02614668942987919, -0.057453397661447525, -0.04697310924530029, 0.010236470960080624, 0.003686205018311739, -0.005249764304608107, -0.016530223190784454, 0.06335124373435974, 0.040725573897361755, 0.027145786210894585, -0.004658723250031471, 0.02277829870581627, -0.031706612557172775, -0.043204378336668015, -0.0201234333217144, -0.060038767755031586, -0.025169994682073593, -0.027120236307382584, 0.025304539129137993, -0.051064275205135345, 0.0088950889185071, -0.003918112255632877, 0.005622494965791702, 0.0033713977318257093, -0.01138992328196764, 0.02458164654672146, 0.005192299373447895, -0.01875939965248108, 0.0008365495596081018, -0.03963373601436615, -0.03127944841980934, -0.014636672101914883, -0.01059733796864748, 0.0008510879706591368, -0.002221287926658988, -0.03771625831723213, -0.03440640866756439, 0.02325308695435524, -0.04789328575134277, 0.033632609993219376, 0.014191881753504276, 0.02507183700799942, 0.04153335466980934, -0.054192233830690384, -0.02947004698216915, 0.03975464031100273, 0.004906856920570135, 0.0037772576324641705, 0.014054538682103157, -0.012725397013127804, -0.022166913375258446, 0.01635371893644333, 0.05049234256148338, 0.00019082491053268313, 0.04595492035150528, 0.034324582666158676, 0.03137905150651932, -0.005715717561542988, 0.05241817608475685, 0.022691477090120316, -0.037596892565488815, 0.05057911202311516, 0.002397796604782343, -0.00034608147689141333, 0.013838271610438824, -0.021618565544486046, 0.05584504082798958, -0.01718856766819954, -0.021800369024276733, 0.03636929392814636, -0.03612367436289787, -0.06602387875318527, 0.037386294454336166, 0.015515357255935669, -0.017188064754009247, -0.0860312357544899, -0.06174199655652046, -0.0008883558912202716, -0.019664281979203224, 0.023954415693879128, 0.02818591333925724, -0.013559945859014988, -0.0005609843065030873, 0.028190836310386658, -0.058726947754621506, -0.03804267197847366, -0.002375091426074505, 0.006984320003539324, 0.002791214268654585, -0.08388526737689972, 0.0436486154794693, 0.013880336657166481, 0.02303476817905903, -0.02639809250831604, 0.010662326589226723, -0.0313117578625679, 0.02743544429540634, -0.018943432718515396, -0.08464477211236954, 0.012177611701190472, 0.05786320939660072, 0.0019995681941509247, 0.020864056423306465, 0.002319521037861705, -0.023477958515286446, -0.011808316223323345, -0.027069756761193275, 0.05144958198070526, -0.039519745856523514, -0.015268713235855103, -0.08875013887882233, -0.0010738171404227614, 0.011231927201151848, -0.03814496845006943, 0.008162587881088257, 0.004163677338510752, 0.01589156873524189, -0.021893741562962532, -0.008111165836453438, 0.02149420790374279, -0.076056107878685, 0.015374014154076576, 0.04807724803686142, -0.051677245646715164, -0.013396295718848705, -0.02726081758737564, 0.027440492063760757, 0.017890818417072296, 0.053850654512643814, 0.026303304359316826, -0.03618774935603142, -0.02452927827835083, 0.03795871138572693, -0.0276491641998291, 0.01799912564456463, -0.06869660317897797, 0.003459509462118149, 0.032173845916986465, -0.030947428196668625, -0.073651984333992, -0.02044702135026455, 0.025438325479626656, -0.019736750051379204, -0.08031336963176727, 0.007277192082256079, -0.0037508723326027393, 0.062419790774583817, -0.01594645529985428, -0.03430118411779404, 0.03230556473135948, -0.00603738846257329, 0.0468255840241909, -0.07538145780563354, 0.05013700947165489, -0.009355311281979084, -0.026538947597146034, -0.023247454315423965, 0.024607116356492043, -0.040086567401885986, 0.012874681502580643, 0.06181837618350983, 0.01934582181274891, 0.030954942107200623, 0.002493513748049736, -0.0529748909175396, -0.058390889316797256, 0.009674523025751114, -0.05088621377944946, -0.07042090594768524, 0.09904925525188446, -0.020721958950161934, -0.0627906545996666, -0.03688918054103851, 0.012067874893546104, 0.07814093679189682, 0.017326224595308304, 0.030450811609625816, 0.05584484711289406, -0.012156438082456589, -0.01902206987142563, 0.029543351382017136, 0.0007022790960036218, -0.020421044901013374, 0.03397098183631897, 0.025965616106987, -0.05728326737880707, 0.020721955224871635, 0.03871845081448555, 0.10629624128341675, 0.024811167269945145, 0.10326647758483887, 0.044147126376628876, -0.006345455534756184, 0.022448057308793068, 0.051088593900203705, 0.033630821853876114, 0.019322067499160767, -0.039277445524930954, 0.036920927464962006, 0.01232391782104969, 0.031248802319169044, 0.00965852476656437, -0.0177992582321167, 0.054945334792137146, 0.05854242295026779, 0.01702098362147808, 0.02338264510035515, -0.008422870188951492, -0.02105512097477913, 0.002225999254733324, -0.041373442858457565, -0.018549030646681786, -0.054633647203445435, 0.009764895774424076, 0.030693354085087776, 0.02014780230820179, 0.00879709143191576, 0.025679806247353554, -0.016379764303565025, -0.003969570156186819, -0.09707167744636536, 0.02860972471535206, 0.018429985269904137, 0.06318001449108124, -0.029124435037374496, -0.06016744673252106, 0.02423037588596344, 0.043117668479681015, 0.03447434678673744, 0.11272545903921127, -0.02218947373330593, 0.04465879127383232, -0.015942692756652832, -0.003548126434907317, -0.04130556806921959, -0.019998600706458092, 0.01010571513324976, 0.0220969058573246, -0.004249805584549904, 0.007629412692040205, 0.005181920249015093, 0.02665511704981327, -0.023661654442548752, -0.032620981335639954, 0.02420971915125847, -0.08968063443899155, 0.08455188572406769, -0.05195242911577225, -0.0004530469886958599, -0.02143486961722374, 0.033630192279815674, 0.01479005441069603, -0.03395526111125946, 0.05674270913004875, -0.001917175017297268, -0.031361792236566544, 0.006182463373988867, -0.04054160788655281, -0.05568151921033859, -0.003955408930778503, 0.012220678851008415, -0.04620177298784256, 0.043164804577827454, -0.003823511768132448, 0.028000127524137497, -0.02067999728024006, -0.06137663871049881, 0.017862141132354736, -0.021319760009646416, -0.07213286310434341, -0.05181543901562691, 0.016162952408194542, -0.005064209923148155, 0.007364514749497175, -0.009723986499011517, -0.008507813327014446, 0.060726553201675415, 0.007162983063608408, 0.04159140959382057, 0.005804399959743023, -0.028258532285690308, -0.041290707886219025, 0.061869021505117416, 0.02504420466721058, 0.05485793203115463, 0.006851509213447571, 0.06560198217630386, -0.0010549977887421846, 0.01096274983137846, 0.004019734915345907, 0.03282030299305916, -0.025042105466127396, 0.04290606454014778, -0.03205123916268349, 0.013874699361622334, 0.04220666363835335, -0.008057991042733192, -0.044724106788635254, -0.02748916670680046, 0.0520588755607605, 0.032460588961839676, -0.05042793229222298, 0.020724616944789886, 0.055470921099185944, -0.01796005293726921, 0.004495523404330015, 0.0010394440032541752, 0.018294353038072586, -0.042112067341804504, 0.01949327625334263, -0.021121768280863762, -0.05112060531973839, 0.0006881721783429384, -0.06304409354925156, 0.030976543202996254, 0.016261564567685127, 0.027154160663485527 ]
<p>For example, the lists can be something like: $$\{1.123213, 5.154543, 2.134121, 7.34534, 12.223432, 8.16571, 100.45645, 222.423\}$$ I want to remove $\{100.45645, 222.423\}$.</p> <p>$$\{232.123213, 323.154543, 232.134121, 123.34534, 222.223432, 8545.16571,\\ 4335.45645, 1222.423\}$$ I want to remove $\{8545.16571, 4335.45645, 1222.423\}$.</p> <p>The size is not fixed, and the range may vary. Are there any ways to remove these "abnormally large" values from my lists?</p>
g36666
[ -0.005917999427765608, 0.04505738988518715, 0.018631696701049805, -0.058592189103364944, 0.006944126449525356, -0.017774969339370728, -0.018419794738292694, 0.024862853810191154, -0.0016564588295295835, 0.03388525918126106, 0.0021731858141720295, 0.019014978781342506, -0.02031988650560379, 0.04257537052035332, -0.0009331315523013473, -0.02694840356707573, 0.07007326185703278, -0.03837979584932327, -0.01929546520113945, 0.046441949903964996, 0.012367716059088707, -0.020305845886468887, -0.008424068801105022, -0.018620077520608902, -0.022225329652428627, -0.045697007328271866, -0.04626970738172531, 0.07865019887685776, 0.017180508002638817, 0.05006776377558708, -0.09680120646953583, 0.007002238184213638, -0.009419762529432774, -0.009507864713668823, 0.011265025474131107, 0.040494274348020554, 0.06712356209754944, 0.015198327600955963, 0.04770873859524727, 0.004090904723852873, -0.019925763830542564, -0.013332495465874672, 0.048288390040397644, -0.016361085698008537, 0.012025685980916023, 0.01145181804895401, -0.010927579365670681, 0.022427039220929146, 0.016626670956611633, -0.014748254790902138, 0.022565243765711784, 0.03435153886675835, 0.019552286714315414, 0.04940222203731537, 0.00029342540074139833, 0.03149581700563431, -0.03533988445997238, 0.0481448769569397, 0.030887173488736153, 0.038436077535152435, 0.02766898274421692, -0.06228499487042427, 0.03963564708828926, 0.013533876277506351, -0.031336814165115356, 0.021294554695487022, -0.0033237698953598738, -0.01985977590084076, -0.03520110622048378, -0.0312497578561306, 0.013652827590703964, 0.0468253456056118, -0.059056367725133896, -0.03488827124238014, -0.10841361433267593, 0.0407298281788826, 0.013737622648477554, 0.025024721398949623, 0.006996002048254013, 0.07060589641332626, -0.06322956085205078, -0.03335259482264519, -0.008495587855577469, -0.04026195779442787, -0.030514877289533615, 0.009898305870592594, 0.07053826749324799, 0.009771103039383888, -0.025025371462106705, -0.005721008870750666, -0.012085316702723503, -0.03242079168558121, 0.012938769534230232, 0.043168846517801285, 0.012476344592869282, 0.017914768308401108, -0.024439560249447823, 0.06347291171550751, -0.050845030695199966, -0.019531935453414917, 0.04478379711508751, 0.10392208397388458, 0.053083039820194244, -0.0662994384765625, -0.05656982585787773, 0.00008323714428115636, 0.07125211507081985, 0.014007091522216797, -0.00021213397849351168, 0.013019262813031673, -0.009235412813723087, -0.02589329332113266, -0.006911140866577625, -0.06808621436357498, -0.024182289838790894, -0.028540952131152153, 0.008217832073569298, 0.010937985964119434, -0.03181358054280281, 0.026490231975913048, 0.06601041555404663, -0.07744556665420532, 0.045258644968271255, 0.05834866315126419, 0.038427118211984634, -0.09078247100114822, -0.06163351610302925, 0.0755627378821373, 0.13128958642482758, -0.04721125215291977, 0.04995371028780937, -0.044919703155756, 0.019160736352205276, 0.027043849229812622, -0.00004267400436219759, 0.025256305932998657, 0.026513170450925827, 0.01892969012260437, -0.025812745094299316, -0.08553983271121979, -0.0015179013134911656, 0.08293472230434418, 0.05267053097486496, 0.02064555697143078, 0.00260185613296926, -0.02510649710893631, -0.04803679138422012, 0.021311115473508835, 0.02078281342983246, 0.00041983736446127295, 0.0694604441523552, 0.017507201060652733, -0.003188807051628828, 0.017155079171061516, -0.08593251556158066, 0.05105599761009216, 0.014418162405490875, 0.030220624059438705, -0.06341321766376495, 0.0372479222714901, 0.008530475199222565, -0.008538746275007725, 0.02088211663067341, 0.020105350762605667, 0.009609044529497623, 0.05741152912378311, 0.023825308308005333, 0.0008463491685688496, -0.03866618126630783, -0.00387350982055068, -0.05018140375614166, -0.013709993101656437, 0.02113720215857029, -0.012424700893461704, 0.018393365666270256, 0.014536912553012371, 0.05046520382165909, 0.008308123797178268, 0.02747054025530815, -0.008222498930990696, 0.0008563059382140636, 0.036336708813905716, 0.009588327258825302, -0.03830546513199806, -0.003310396568849683, 0.012485017068684101, -0.02216019667685032, 0.0030516928527504206, -0.017922455444931984, -0.002214614301919937, -0.0021278036292642355, -0.011562286876142025, 0.028347622603178024, -0.009559194557368755, 0.011363474652171135, -0.05322708562016487, -0.04407072067260742, -0.027578426524996758, -0.029080834239721298, -0.018355585634708405, 0.003680403111502528, -0.025300847366452217, -0.05163740739226341, -0.0032485362607985735, 0.029877614229917526, -0.03908739238977432, -0.029889943078160286, -0.019246134907007217, -0.02529481239616871, -0.02050955966114998, 0.021357441321015358, -0.06892465054988861, -0.034627754241228104, 0.04408174380660057, -0.02829652465879917, -0.030507056042551994, -0.04861326515674591, 0.03778161108493805, 0.000453240645583719, 0.024762211367487907, 0.02309417724609375, 0.02682769112288952, -0.009083068929612637, 0.01083306036889553, 0.017852038145065308, 0.03784841299057007, 0.014385370537638664, 0.02511242777109146, -0.014908081851899624, -0.017657924443483353, -0.0342557467520237, 0.03773041069507599, 0.001298920949921012, -0.031216859817504883, -0.035879213362932205, 0.01085524633526802, 0.026448167860507965, -0.012372905388474464, -0.07777684926986694, 0.047290559858083725, 0.013163600116968155, 0.0045156595297157764, 0.02274392545223236, 0.048448048532009125, -0.008445722050964832, -0.013926772400736809, -0.05665082111954689, 0.026346102356910706, -0.014384645037353039, 0.04249518737196922, 0.0017546397866681218, 0.017103226855397224, -0.02567060850560665, 0.0393960177898407, 0.022556999698281288, 0.007003751117736101, 0.004845057614147663, 0.06048565357923508, 0.07331200689077377, -0.012286164797842503, -0.07716230303049088, 0.0514577217400074, 0.028681082651019096, 0.0075906310230493546, -0.017947563901543617, -0.04900519922375679, -0.0026103316340595484, -0.028764627873897552, 0.0038882538210600615, 0.10416107624769211, 0.035862796008586884, -0.013386541977524757, 0.06885237991809845, 0.06153076887130737, 0.05172756314277649, 0.006251491606235504, 0.012749703601002693, -0.05316278338432312, -0.001544243423268199, 0.06665804982185364, 0.00022641080431640148, 0.028290849179029465, -0.022102324292063713, 0.026133453473448753, 0.02154809795320034, -0.004205347504466772, -0.04585060104727745, -0.032603971660137177, -0.014196374453604221, 0.018819738179445267, 0.020498597994446754, -0.0017321077175438404, 0.016025956720113754, -0.049427345395088196, 0.05092739313840866, -0.010149179957807064, -0.05349048972129822, -0.03279237821698189, -0.042601000517606735, 0.0034701526165008545, 0.01838315837085247, -0.0247881431132555, 0.03470773994922638, 0.041805192828178406, -0.062368735671043396, 0.035876598209142685, -0.0249879602342844, 0.0765622928738594, -0.0322023406624794, -0.014743689447641373, 0.051687091588974, 0.035931698977947235, 0.01533117238432169, -0.005976295098662376, -0.009304990991950035, 0.016696956008672714, 0.07244738191366196, -0.049071528017520905, 0.027180593460798264, -0.02768039144575596, -0.05101410299539566, -0.04967954754829407, 0.007153220474720001, 0.0021949103102087975, -0.018755121156573296, 0.027219610288739204, -0.04164036363363266, 0.007459267973899841, -0.04727901145815849, 0.014341716654598713, 0.012824910692870617, 0.004008861258625984, -0.013379623182117939, -0.07578939199447632, -0.05640104413032532, -0.025819042697548866, 0.06772935390472412, 0.003055043751373887, 0.08935317397117615, -0.01729641668498516, 0.00420547928661108, 0.015239405445754528, -0.02808571048080921, -0.046896450221538544, -0.024403411895036697, 0.031388986855745316, -0.000026863075618166476, -0.018396200612187386, -0.001762624946422875, -0.039436936378479004, -0.008985801599919796, -0.019924839958548546, 0.035637568682432175, -0.039769649505615234, 0.028860900551080704, 0.004900761414319277, -0.034593671560287476, 0.00011589808855205774, -0.006014612969011068, -0.011443963274359703, 0.00784164760261774, -0.05185050517320633, -0.033343538641929626, 0.06685828417539597, -0.018898937851190567, 0.015687374398112297, -0.022428162395954132, 0.00652736471965909, -0.0018626125529408455, -0.02373633161187172, 0.05389507859945297, 0.0015762964030727744, 0.07512395828962326, -0.06871843338012695, -0.007688683457672596, 0.07399801164865494, 0.03221362829208374, 0.07009083032608032, -0.025746023282408714, 0.047205641865730286, 0.03660617768764496, -0.053342562168836594, -0.038334187120199203, -0.03884626924991608, -0.027534693479537964, -0.06366776674985886, -0.005118743050843477, -0.01813296228647232, -0.022187767550349236, -0.009798855520784855, -0.02453729882836342, -0.001032187370583415, 0.035935524851083755, 0.008395612239837646, -0.03762493655085564, 0.0024115287233144045, -0.016674432903528214, -0.015609445050358772, -0.06291886419057846, 0.02609945274889469, 0.026488954201340675, -0.01246168464422226, -0.0317886620759964, 0.01860285922884941, -0.0032676805276423693, -0.005898667499423027, -0.0030609946697950363, 0.03364149108529091, -0.006995102856308222, 0.007175474427640438, -0.0742809996008873, -0.007115894462913275, -0.019848715513944626, -0.00424933061003685, 0.03265412524342537, -0.044082313776016235, 0.0185609832406044, 0.007039712741971016, 0.053172554820775986, -0.004494157154113054, -0.03767425939440727, 0.03909314051270485, -0.00997847318649292, -0.010184449143707752, 0.037041131407022476, 0.05602006986737251, 0.019731469452381134, -0.020190726965665817, 0.03177532181143761, -0.01375100389122963, 0.011448192410171032, 0.017083987593650818, -0.050394829362630844, -0.0007919828058220446, -0.004082413390278816, -0.02415633387863636, -0.03075445629656315, -0.03359530493617058, 0.02504562959074974, -0.05049613490700722, -0.012128147296607494, 0.02674274519085884, -0.026864927262067795, 0.03546848148107529, -0.0016748402267694473, 0.007521325722336769, -0.01252785138785839, 0.059185538440942764, -0.06325411796569824, 0.0015308646252378821, -0.019444892182946205, -0.04702898859977722, -0.010459774173796177, -0.03836461156606674, -0.0029012635350227356, -0.044179871678352356, -0.04454205185174942, 0.04050104692578316, 0.021912595257163048, 0.02280551753938198, 0.0026808741968125105, -0.020760705694556236, -0.052534859627485275, -0.0030625707004219294, -0.005586746148765087, 0.011319703422486782, -0.06590195000171661, -0.0038662170991301537, -0.04760253429412842, 0.025658773258328438, -0.03188404068350792, 0.004666924010962248, 0.01928599737584591, 0.01658179983496666, -0.07306067645549774, -0.024043310433626175, -0.01433976273983717, -0.006924191955476999, -0.0568666011095047, -0.014763744547963142, -0.05407951772212982, -0.019901074469089508, 0.00647985702380538, -0.006726115010678768, -0.007619999814778566, 0.02787592262029648, -0.0219134408980608, -0.04914967715740204, 0.02598091959953308, -0.022017987444996834, 0.010991586372256279, 0.033070143312215805, 0.038847774267196655, 0.003990285098552704, 0.008522151969373226, -0.10409296303987503, 0.026115411892533302, -0.004216283559799194, 0.017017655074596405, -0.04676629602909088, 0.03132540360093117, 0.008572976104915142, 0.04977372661232948, -0.03333977982401848, -0.017301730811595917, 0.0019709602929651737, 0.03883152827620506, 0.06207741051912308, 0.004549477715045214, -0.03925895318388939, 0.011314962059259415, 0.008104859851300716, 0.05852745845913887, 0.024803373962640762, -0.002231382764875889, -0.016856130212545395, -0.015118666924536228, -0.021258048713207245, -0.02999497950077057, 0.0009055600967258215, 0.022564295679330826, -0.06569915264844894, 0.03318820521235466, -0.05344777926802635, 0.02523559145629406, 0.009204198606312275, 0.01617671363055706, -0.055497415363788605, -0.006023392081260681, -0.035315342247486115, -0.026622017845511436, -0.005378082860261202, -0.09864643216133118, -0.054246578365564346, -0.06090289354324341, -0.017369607463479042, -0.03825376555323601, -0.04903709888458252, 0.0013442863710224628, -0.010882941074669361, 0.03813038393855095, 0.009470706805586815, -0.01413686666637659, -0.008547782897949219, 0.02193470485508442, -0.0809028148651123, 0.04211750626564026, -0.06188583001494408, 0.0164731927216053, -0.0016483390936627984, 0.009775624610483646, -0.0041747805662453175, -0.009609653614461422, -0.04455013945698738, 0.03172224387526512, 0.022620609030127525, 0.03762729838490486, -0.003769082948565483, 0.025893663987517357, -0.06288326531648636, -0.02530364878475666, -0.07689201086759567, 0.007375641260296106, -0.025365663692355156, 0.05508662015199661, -0.0023319872561842203, -0.009462551213800907, -0.006263884250074625, 0.04259755089879036, 0.03571707755327225, -0.0034720213152468204, 0.00153788598254323, 0.002567526651546359, 0.00019357888959348202, 0.019039008766412735, 0.015321466140449047, 0.0010495181195437908, 0.044916022568941116, 0.047818731516599655, -0.043822310864925385, -0.07637923955917358, 0.015506262890994549, -0.03970718756318092, -0.03998706489801407, -0.05395496264100075, 0.02679390273988247, -0.016416968777775764, 0.010690458118915558, -0.007301358971744776, -0.027933528646826744, -0.0019486540695652366, -0.007481113541871309, -0.061322469264268875, -0.013526114635169506, 0.05053175985813141, -0.056575559079647064, -0.006626367103308439, 0.05978724732995033, 0.013298166915774345, 0.005462839268147945, 0.01332584023475647, 0.04538220539689064, 0.05801254138350487, -0.022326955571770668, 0.05107980594038963, 0.02769087813794613, 0.022011015564203262, 0.10945533961057663, -0.026478486135601997, 0.011662431061267853, -0.0024576024152338505, 0.006538720801472664, -0.033364731818437576, -0.006990404333919287, -0.015511052682995796, -0.035011183470487595, 0.0012151021510362625, 0.02971711941063404, 0.007208537310361862, -0.02168108895421028, -0.002869114512577653, 0.0016506562242284417, -0.05464416369795799, 0.03216484934091568, -0.00991540402173996, 0.029350684955716133, 0.00558954244479537, -0.027758199721574783, 0.03660350292921066, -0.01859830506145954, -0.01713401824235916, -0.023811455816030502, 0.005701511632651091, -0.02757960930466652, -0.0426359623670578, 0.06542302668094635, -0.08666473627090454, 0.051380742341279984, -0.046983424574136734, 0.04973559081554413, 0.01973695307970047, 0.019002599641680717, 0.052111219614744186, -0.03288863226771355, -0.021426258608698845, 0.014824891462922096, 0.00914811622351408, 0.0008771559223532677, -0.023552656173706055, 0.03605007007718086, 0.05189133435487747, 0.023254724219441414, -0.035125959664583206, 0.017710411921143532, 0.03731674328446388, 0.004722946789115667, -0.07383349537849426, -0.0466764010488987, -0.011523902416229248, 0.008261323906481266, 0.0037461912725120783, -0.0038688324857503176, 0.029282743111252785, -0.01650993339717388, 0.027498850598931313, 0.017731431871652603, 0.015881560742855072, 0.010079477913677692, -0.001460190280340612, -0.013421697542071342, -0.04092664271593094, -0.030152220278978348, -0.04630227014422417, 0.015723763033747673, 0.0640181452035904, 0.0004901744541712105, 0.021303679794073105, -0.039090998470783234, -0.004821042064577341, 0.007129211910068989, 0.01121494174003601, -0.019909484311938286, 0.05512062460184097, -0.06770036369562149, 0.04914194345474243, 0.03374207764863968, -0.0046795266680419445, 0.03357594460248947, 0.03893791139125824, -0.02395794168114662, 0.025296449661254883, -0.02750362642109394, -0.006116876378655434, 0.010876190848648548, 0.054659727960824966, -0.017751546576619148, -0.0172271691262722, -0.019638512283563614, 0.0624164342880249, -0.029008490964770317, 0.02495039999485016, 0.02017746865749359, -0.051143672317266464, -0.06231711059808731, 0.012057426385581493, 0.10039051622152328, -0.004273978527635336, 0.013712149113416672, -0.013520974665880203, -0.07120803743600845, -0.025379175320267677, -0.03035883978009224, 0.02950151078402996, 0.0024408765602856874, 0.06163742020726204, -0.0393378771841526, 0.05219486355781555, -0.009614314883947372, -0.03275156021118164, -0.017384810373187065, -0.029358284547924995, 0.0035732684191316366, -0.0031948331743478775, 0.006922584492713213, -0.020294154062867165, 0.00018834065122064203, 0.024986350908875465, 0.019631031900644302, -0.0047662025317549706, 0.037803441286087036, -0.06264599412679672, -0.02752630040049553, -0.022182419896125793, 0.02118304744362831, 0.0235613826662302, -0.021048156544566154, -0.04543568938970566, -0.005374707747250795, 0.021381277590990067, 0.016594570130109787, -0.02107497677206993, 0.032495103776454926, 0.06314592808485031, 0.010039870627224445, 0.035431984812021255, 0.019694549962878227, -0.021640026941895485, -0.02036120556294918, -0.017110653221607208, -0.017160015180706978, -0.04862496629357338, -0.0073905219323933125, -0.0045062704011797905, 0.07965578883886337, -0.050504665821790695, 0.061195213347673416, 0.06015342101454735, 0.004313732497394085, 0.043213363736867905, -0.03522484004497528, 0.012055335566401482, -0.02525060810148716, -0.021800028160214424, 0.08101505786180496, 0.07745800912380219, 0.0034106827806681395, 0.031524673104286194, -0.023354314267635345 ]
<p>Let's say that I have a picture like the one in figure. This look like an histogram, but actually is not, in the sense that I did not produce the figure starting from a dataset of values. In fact, I only have the probability (the y axis) for each bar. I also have the center point of each bin, and the bin width of each bin. Notice that the graph is normalized such that the area under the bins is equal to one. </p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/CQWGd.jpg" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>What I want to do now, is to calculate the reciprocal of this probabilities. Usually I would use this formula: </p> <p>$g(y) = \frac{ 1 }{ y^2 } f\left( \frac{ 1 }{ y } \right) $</p> <p>But I cannot do that now, since I do not want to assume any f(x). Having an histogram, I would just plot the (1./dataset) to get the reciprocal (in histogram form), and then I would normalize (assuming that the original dataset was not already normalized like the one in the example), so to have a good approximation of the rate distribution. However, in this case, I don't have the dataset. I only have the y points (the p(x), actually) and the x (bin center for each bin).</p> <p>I have been adviced to use the following formula (in MATLAB): plot(1./x, y) And this will give me a function with the same shape as the reciprocal function, but not normalized. I <em>think</em> I could take this result and normalize it, and that should work fine. However, I wonder if there is another method that uses only the x and the p(x) in order to get the reciprocal values.</p> <p>Thank you. </p>
g74041
[ 0.023165414109826088, 0.047405824065208435, -0.006900424603372812, -0.03870932385325432, 0.00021932875097263604, -0.02618619240820408, 0.012762961909174919, 0.038326699286699295, -0.036929383873939514, -0.05034171789884567, -0.006248769350349903, 0.04562756419181824, 0.044799719005823135, -0.009511393494904041, 0.017742661759257317, 0.034558944404125214, 0.02901638299226761, -0.03132922202348709, 0.03770453855395317, 0.057197455316782, 0.008993935771286488, -0.04104553535580635, 0.059576600790023804, -0.008239232003688812, -0.007602730765938759, -0.08484388142824173, 0.015468012541532516, 0.015027118846774101, -0.0470048151910305, 0.018633471801877022, -0.028071735054254532, 0.032349757850170135, -0.0019592035096138716, -0.03830241039395332, 0.010228434577584267, -0.00786587968468666, -0.0307842418551445, 0.042433176189661026, 0.016354016959667206, 0.00572211155667901, -0.04116217419505119, 0.014895914122462273, 0.06388763338327408, -0.005176784470677376, -0.014780944213271141, -0.014786278828978539, -0.0059769186191260815, 0.046697575598955154, 0.034398630261421204, -0.03516262769699097, -0.017253940925002098, 0.08857087790966034, -0.013670814223587513, -0.01940053142607212, 0.027150457724928856, 0.05883338302373886, 0.001790065667591989, -0.03973265364766121, 0.014780676923692226, -0.013870416209101677, -0.009062173776328564, 0.011617460288107395, 0.017385583370923996, 0.019022934138774872, 0.0028992947190999985, 0.06133534014225006, -0.047772664576768875, -0.009195972234010696, -0.031891077756881714, -0.01926909200847149, -0.017360854893922806, 0.003916187211871147, -0.0027619495522230864, 0.036596234887838364, -0.07593342661857605, -0.015750518068671227, -0.00642269104719162, -0.0035843912046402693, -0.016518475487828255, 0.020527951419353485, -0.0035176659002900124, 0.011904164217412472, 0.018550308421254158, 0.012708747759461403, 0.0011315648443996906, -0.006117172539234161, 0.050445135682821274, -0.011412512511014938, -0.038671787828207016, -0.022584673017263412, 0.0365290530025959, -0.007959747686982155, 0.05224982649087906, -0.0076798079535365105, 0.03945564851164818, 0.03369763866066933, -0.07376566529273987, 0.06194029748439789, -0.053842127323150635, -0.010176575742661953, -0.001770542934536934, 0.07000225782394409, 0.07541757076978683, -0.029078839346766472, -0.0758429616689682, 0.01283358782529831, 0.04084915667772293, 0.007477398496121168, 0.03188220039010048, -0.016014186665415764, -0.0216273982077837, -0.030562343075871468, -0.045620083808898926, -0.06663598120212555, 0.013960456475615501, -0.04814508557319641, 0.07941681146621704, -0.03983228653669357, -0.0054742139764130116, 0.0336918905377388, 0.0009977647569030523, 0.010306070558726788, 0.00008442623948212713, 0.059195514768362045, -0.04969239607453346, 0.022587502375245094, -0.03591928631067276, 0.06732922047376633, 0.035383474081754684, 0.05562774837017059, 0.05065717548131943, -0.017273886129260063, 0.0064797354862093925, 0.04417068883776665, -0.035801589488983154, 0.03047206625342369, -0.015742352232336998, 0.004681040998548269, -0.008858875371515751, 0.01576729118824005, -0.059058643877506256, 0.02869013510644436, -0.01578795537352562, -0.04146726429462433, -0.03547286242246628, 0.021913573145866394, 0.007292778696864843, -0.044853273779153824, -0.007464820984750986, -0.02358298934996128, 0.012155692093074322, 0.014055386185646057, 0.01949787139892578, 0.05477858707308769, -0.002924984088167548, -0.03826643154025078, 0.011589431203901768, 0.011683754622936249, -0.0009646298713050783, 0.03500644117593765, 0.03170667216181755, -0.026239747181534767, 0.005689127836376429, -0.04808357357978821, 0.02579723671078682, -0.036577142775058746, 0.03934474661946297, 0.00824862439185381, -0.04364226758480072, -0.07161983847618103, 0.007961247116327286, -0.0524614118039608, -0.038798727095127106, -0.013812602497637272, 0.0021090966183692217, 0.029081594198942184, -0.005913867149502039, 0.04257514700293541, 0.0464266873896122, 0.06216893717646599, -0.023586008697748184, 0.05282997339963913, 0.007871078327298164, -0.04023996740579605, 0.025917530059814453, -0.026167185977101326, 0.05123704671859741, 0.08499579131603241, -0.028239121660590172, -0.007418130524456501, -0.012102432548999786, -0.002592073054984212, -0.050272706896066666, -0.019674431532621384, -0.03898826986551285, 0.01810295693576336, 0.030238844454288483, 0.03629433363676071, 0.0018538555596023798, -0.009690949693322182, -0.009673560969531536, 0.03995422273874283, 0.006058930419385433, -0.012381408363580704, -0.021476436406373978, -0.018559224903583527, -0.03356514126062393, -0.023634063079953194, 0.019779300317168236, 0.012801808305084705, -0.07128481566905975, -0.05938881263136864, 0.02123301662504673, 0.04248633608222008, -0.0020577837713062763, 0.001533332746475935, -0.006884307134896517, 0.016477320343255997, -0.04524526000022888, -0.017963038757443428, -0.0135974595323205, -0.0007992034079506993, -0.023128286004066467, 0.03447761759161949, 0.02241927571594715, 0.017395753413438797, 0.09335345029830933, 0.00919904001057148, -0.01882854849100113, 0.04206661880016327, 0.007845865562558174, -0.057453643530607224, -0.056459493935108185, -0.019936971366405487, 0.010441532358527184, -0.0023910272866487503, -0.050359535962343216, 0.038291580975055695, 0.033618826419115067, -0.040280237793922424, -0.006808740086853504, -0.0293843075633049, -0.02689915895462036, 0.017329178750514984, 0.045072827488183975, -0.012070595286786556, 0.02800336480140686, -0.015577815473079681, 0.042057521641254425, 0.04452000558376312, -0.004418511409312487, 0.04202456399798393, -0.017035502940416336, -0.037087760865688324, -0.015442165546119213, -0.04306812584400177, -0.03126520663499832, -0.047892652451992035, 0.0005275547155179083, -0.003818971337750554, -0.046053025871515274, -0.031193852424621582, 0.06792166084051132, -0.01714477874338627, -0.06756970286369324, -0.053346727043390274, 0.02239837870001793, 0.021924538537859917, 0.017186788842082024, 0.021515337750315666, -0.014199760742485523, 0.014736978337168694, 0.05698464810848236, 0.07219961285591125, 0.006628778297454119, 0.03135491907596588, 0.07741284370422363, -0.012831919826567173, -0.044454220682382584, -0.005644583143293858, 0.0695437416434288, -0.032921887934207916, 0.013832656666636467, -0.00008144648745656013, 0.007715742569416761, -0.023297537118196487, 0.03295904025435448, 0.018595706671476364, -0.0031307958997786045, 0.03872103989124298, -0.02352108247578144, -0.029334692284464836, -0.019831601530313492, 0.01946444809436798, 0.013062281534075737, -0.0013896282762289047, 0.02733130380511284, -0.034784168004989624, 0.03662256523966789, 0.021060533821582794, -0.024663344025611877, -0.03274666517972946, -0.0018313255859538913, 0.008197950199246407, 0.0728234276175499, -0.07858121395111084, -0.026389744132757187, -0.04501921683549881, 0.032656095921993256, 0.01293157134205103, -0.0021791730541735888, 0.0336681567132473, -0.057608287781476974, 0.009866610169410706, 0.014452045783400536, 0.0034501038026064634, 0.004846872296184301, -0.007251249626278877, -0.041389405727386475, -0.026104725897312164, 0.03217541053891182, 0.013594768941402435, -0.006161462049931288, 0.037724316120147705, -0.030298955738544464, 0.04686887562274933, -0.01249204482883215, 0.06197746470570564, -0.005695895291864872, 0.04451516643166542, 0.07858003675937653, 0.05039942264556885, -0.021669920533895493, -0.04892623797059059, -0.04900990054011345, -0.012780080549418926, -0.011283885687589645, 0.00686601921916008, 0.07874491065740585, 0.05780485272407532, -0.027904337272047997, -0.05286158248782158, -0.017994875088334084, -0.0857018232345581, -0.00015321349201258272, 0.009508674964308739, -0.06068284437060356, 0.04423098638653755, 0.05041118711233139, -0.03628179430961609, -0.020464973524212837, -0.03185153752565384, 0.0501425676047802, -0.01231453102082014, 0.037839505821466446, 0.033189091831445694, -0.03904179111123085, 0.0001418409519828856, 0.01912037655711174, 0.018474431708455086, 0.011915868148207664, -0.05270782485604286, -0.02480776235461235, 0.04629895091056824, 0.015288887545466423, -0.0029843891970813274, -0.0023084799759089947, 0.06671043485403061, 0.0015553563134744763, -0.0014865159755572677, -0.038235247135162354, -0.011457713320851326, 0.09539894759654999, 0.02809821628034115, 0.007246998138725758, -0.03303292766213417, -0.030938278883695602, 0.013236197642982006, 0.010009555146098137, 0.08611014485359192, -0.02631259150803089, -0.0022319359704852104, -0.014558825641870499, -0.025539150461554527, 0.013200100511312485, -0.04378882050514221, 0.019507842138409615, 0.01091514341533184, 0.08110305666923523, 0.014693855307996273, -0.00007831290713511407, -0.02102178893983364, -0.04818068817257881, 0.01829005777835846, 0.023887038230895996, -0.03191716596484184, -0.0014523888239637017, -0.012208039872348309, -0.002402996178716421, 0.03726565092802048, -0.019818134605884552, 0.009751719422638416, 0.03941905125975609, 0.028535647317767143, -0.0329570546746254, -0.05951876938343048, 0.010426344349980354, -0.030647624284029007, 0.06080484390258789, 0.013517486862838268, -0.07814477384090424, -0.06012275442481041, 0.0795547366142273, -0.05088682472705841, 0.04365091770887375, -0.017540864646434784, 0.08532053232192993, -0.03752018138766289, -0.0044048018753528595, 0.008826648816466331, 0.0030191787518560886, 0.03880421817302704, -0.006167980842292309, -0.03196999803185463, -0.009354127570986748, 0.029010169208049774, 0.027716048061847687, 0.0004235040978528559, -0.0011811009608209133, 0.017059966921806335, 0.044867295771837234, 0.03498908132314682, -0.0019921008497476578, -0.029021110385656357, -0.055607084184885025, -0.047972697764635086, 0.00872884038835764, -0.02841930463910103, -0.022748874500393867, -0.042195308953523636, -0.031790491193532944, -0.054769326001405716, -0.04122393950819969, -0.012398183345794678, 0.01766236498951912, 0.041545044630765915, -0.03858010098338127, -0.0066421153023839, 0.06282021850347519, -0.012835362926125526, -0.039242759346961975, 0.03868139535188675, -0.005239160265773535, 0.008930790238082409, 0.01231294497847557, -0.016545264050364494, 0.017156552523374557, -0.0006154439179226756, 0.04900375008583069, 0.013711916282773018, 0.015561915002763271, 0.034545112401247025, -0.04240916296839714, -0.05211992561817169, -0.0047844815999269485, -0.0031954983714967966, -0.08386994153261185, 0.03655035048723221, 0.045831210911273956, -0.03358149155974388, -0.0139199523255229, -0.02007092721760273, 0.0520622693002224, -0.048935193568468094, -0.05286739021539688, 0.02141924574971199, 0.012622405774891376, 0.0056892335414886475, 0.04261075705289841, 0.02099471725523472, -0.05524042248725891, -0.04809296503663063, 0.008352616801857948, -0.027304338291287422, 0.017183713614940643, -0.004751384258270264, -0.011644791811704636, -0.011866542510688305, 0.04582706838846207, -0.011896244250237942, -0.044860512018203735, -0.09487500041723251, 0.04607909172773361, 0.052583981305360794, 0.02709398977458477, -0.05106053501367569, -0.00833837129175663, -0.0028603733517229557, 0.05389201268553734, 0.022568805143237114, -0.03293048217892647, 0.041804712265729904, -0.07956437021493912, -0.02686590887606144, 0.03452739864587784, -0.013112095184624195, -0.0003960623580496758, -0.001973578240722418, -0.03945045545697212, 0.0810563862323761, 0.03039455972611904, -0.04269341006875038, 0.09410128742456436, 0.026536423712968826, 0.012566658668220043, -0.0462254099547863, -0.017204372212290764, 0.015925008803606033, -0.028320344164967537, -0.012313023209571838, 0.056604932993650436, 0.009859716519713402, 0.002720715943723917, -0.01283175777643919, 0.013910969719290733, -0.04183415323495865, -0.02746187523007393, -0.027877379208803177, 0.039115630090236664, -0.025652853772044182, -0.009704607538878918, -0.0038326610811054707, -0.059917476028203964, -0.02767043374478817, -0.02736063115298748, -0.007784431800246239, -0.031100783497095108, -0.009021200239658356, 0.01165751088410616, -0.019517388194799423, 0.016284925863146782, 0.07044708728790283, -0.009240128099918365, -0.004722774960100651, -0.06614180654287338, -0.022394651547074318, -0.007004986517131329, -0.033671680837869644, -0.0035052793100476265, -0.036077745258808136, -0.02380479872226715, 0.026630602777004242, -0.05515206605195999, -0.012313537299633026, -0.02198226936161518, 0.0241794865578413, -0.01778542250394821, -0.006991223897784948, -0.006133923772722483, -0.019765498116612434, 0.009286003187298775, -0.031668271869421005, 0.047033071517944336, 0.06775890290737152, -0.022664308547973633, -0.019478438422083855, 0.01896188035607338, -0.006705167703330517, -0.059897586703300476, 0.021245446056127548, -0.003437085309997201, -0.05285250395536423, 0.007542345207184553, 0.060800619423389435, 0.08712578564882278, 0.03667289391160011, 0.03469051048159599, -0.05723484978079796, 0.04113026708364487, 0.022630183026194572, -0.028578560799360275, -0.004166869446635246, -0.009434115141630173, 0.01714339293539524, -0.0338766872882843, 0.052970800548791885, 0.013744656927883625, -0.023451780900359154, -0.029519103467464447, -0.06193976849317551, -0.002427373779937625, -0.006868098862469196, -0.02093556523323059, -0.036905184388160706, -0.0028913081623613834, -0.008766215294599533, -0.028633514419198036, 0.06692761927843094, -0.0037876591086387634, -0.020923392847180367, -0.046303436160087585, 0.055074989795684814, 0.07049192488193512, -0.042297590523958206, 0.028655752539634705, -0.008643541485071182, 0.008768932893872261, 0.005158239509910345, 0.02147611230611801, 0.011722157709300518, 0.037881478667259216, 0.04450355842709541, -0.0037452245596796274, 0.06370550394058228, 0.018727364018559456, -0.029655711725354195, 0.012888425029814243, -0.019431041553616524, -0.050709258764982224, 0.020297417417168617, -0.013331333175301552, -0.0597689263522625, -0.0077152252197265625, -0.020850999280810356, 0.028252921998500824, 0.06440134346485138, -0.04096439480781555, -0.030042998492717743, 0.0173496101051569, -0.0005015595816075802, 0.0064774672500789165, 0.009425478056073189, -0.08542242646217346, 0.03688521683216095, -0.010127358138561249, 0.026638314127922058, -0.020873162895441055, 0.05044027790427208, 0.06665743142366409, 0.03655177727341652, -0.03377937525510788, -0.006881922949105501, 0.03802148252725601, -0.017769014462828636, -0.03554072976112366, -0.031181836500763893, 0.046065885573625565, -0.0128701813519001, -0.04914258047938347, 0.032652128487825394, 0.03493010625243187, 0.04161716625094414, -0.002903772285208106, 0.023129630833864212, 0.0089707737788558, 0.0313325971364975, 0.040287215262651443, 0.0461571142077446, 0.008708278648555279, -0.04152465611696243, -0.0836884155869484, -0.06516172736883163, -0.008416466414928436, -0.08958300203084946, 0.009253871627151966, 0.0035339868627488613, -0.01058482937514782, 0.00262943166308105, -0.0339246466755867, -0.04089510068297386, -0.004621955566108227, -0.0829358920454979, -0.008114897646009922, 0.059316158294677734, -0.0011840761872008443, 0.013406346552073956, 0.05685132369399071, 0.020638559013605118, -0.04456893727183342, -0.016518864780664444, -0.0009718454093672335, 0.0024393778294324875, 0.0016727183246985078, 0.02790742740035057, 0.01239015907049179, 0.013558738864958286, -0.023817341774702072, -0.03621412813663483, 0.03480532020330429, -0.0011699242750182748, -0.054076846688985825, -0.00004517939669312909, -0.000040021230233833194, 0.003214897820726037, 0.002446686150506139, -0.01200495008379221, -0.052060265094041824, 0.024855077266693115, -0.0073835114017128944, 0.005600649863481522, 0.06705046445131302, -0.04164279252290726, -0.04334942623972893, -0.04058518633246422, 0.029573742300271988, -0.026232048869132996, 0.020805172622203827, 0.024818412959575653, 0.018023328855633736, -0.04878448694944382, 0.058876801282167435, 0.05461388826370239, -0.01585414446890354, -0.007496536243706942, -0.09249576181173325, 0.00685080885887146, -0.05750584602355957, 0.01529256347566843, 0.0288526751101017, 0.004308732692152262, -0.07330707460641861, -0.016283025965094566, 0.011506693437695503, 0.017559221014380455, -0.009599504992365837, 0.03024079091846943, -0.057225365191698074, -0.04363168403506279, -0.005194300785660744, 0.06994929164648056, 0.015241924673318863, -0.004575831349939108, -0.04719442501664162, 0.043541181832551956, 0.005332589615136385, 0.014469063840806484, -0.017770886421203613, -0.028304312378168106, -0.04452240839600563, 0.0214467104524374, 0.0008429511217400432, 0.029622327536344528, -0.03337382525205612, 0.0032081676181405783, -0.0022230446338653564, 0.04723167046904564, -0.02317838743329048, 0.038904111832380295, 0.06246929615736008, -0.03978009149432182, -0.06929779052734375, 0.07108581811189651, -0.045928917825222015, 0.04142894968390465, 0.020065324380993843, -0.06271572411060333, 0.06337393820285797, 0.03680092841386795, -0.011739997193217278, -0.06884541362524033, -0.02249985747039318, -0.00937588606029749, -0.03937491029500961, 0.052890460938215256, 0.003942697308957577, 0.031026072800159454, -0.0029566329903900623, 0.056116983294487 ]
<p>Im newbie in Image Processing field, and I got many term that wierd. There are :</p> <ol> <li><p>Moments</p></li> <li><p>Local and global characteristic</p></li> <li><p>Energy of Image</p></li> <li><p>Color Temperature</p></li> </ol> <p>What each of them represent in Image??</p>
g36670
[ 0.03139191493391991, -0.02810576744377613, -0.033659715205430984, -0.07127238065004349, 0.0833701640367508, -0.024730917066335678, -0.012769343331456184, 0.040787335485219955, -0.04567725211381912, 0.024572134017944336, -0.027396144345402718, 0.06618516147136688, 0.015503491275012493, 0.0016068589175119996, -0.025747785344719887, -0.04712895303964615, 0.06472618877887726, -0.0046846927143633366, 0.043492238968610764, 0.026155928149819374, -0.03074651211500168, 0.00704227527603507, -0.03484422340989113, -0.010411492548882961, 0.05895966291427612, 0.03590307757258415, 0.00040825275937095284, 0.04234570264816284, -0.04825243726372719, -0.033086031675338745, -0.020006399601697922, -0.03719688579440117, 0.01447999756783247, -0.11346615850925446, 0.0060567776672542095, 0.07629027962684631, 0.07826278358697891, 0.03296049311757088, 0.05480293929576874, 0.020008323714137077, 0.0038670492358505726, 0.012377792038023472, 0.05990251526236534, 0.027031252160668373, -0.0024162440095096827, 0.0185101181268692, -0.0676850825548172, -0.012754992581903934, -0.029253778979182243, -0.014877880923449993, -0.004380140453577042, 0.022241249680519104, 0.007673399057239294, -0.02339751087129116, 0.019399398937821388, -0.03243417665362358, -0.01621902361512184, 0.020974265411496162, 0.04394729435443878, 0.020944729447364807, 0.01219737995415926, -0.04094579443335533, -0.05751486495137215, 0.01679818145930767, 0.03126698359847069, -0.04754408076405525, -0.014873544685542583, -0.018229149281978607, 0.0241033174097538, -0.015920957550406456, -0.004274397157132626, -0.03896587714552879, -0.017396848648786545, 0.0017636849079281092, -0.04888371750712395, -0.07153685390949249, -0.031275488436222076, 0.0380302369594574, 0.010318021290004253, 0.05813631787896156, -0.02058541029691696, -0.006402689963579178, 0.02741829864680767, 0.033388979732990265, 0.05599724128842354, -0.030873527750372887, -0.020574837923049927, 0.05949217826128006, 0.023180002346634865, -0.0017554420046508312, -0.01725313812494278, -0.0483468733727932, 0.040329284965991974, 0.04987296089529991, 0.006938057951629162, 0.0084537323564291, 0.009746705181896687, 0.044168759137392044, 0.023137297481298447, -0.001437063910998404, -0.009260287508368492, -0.00635042367503047, -0.001243707723915577, -0.023274855688214302, 0.011798718944191933, 0.0322568342089653, -0.01840204931795597, -0.018405279144644737, -0.05300767719745636, 0.0352296456694603, -0.028139160946011543, -0.003919287119060755, -0.025831446051597595, -0.026340927928686142, -0.039441801607608795, -0.05153035372495651, 0.05079580098390579, -0.06990612298250198, 0.001401530927978456, 0.05828050896525383, 0.028129030019044876, 0.019317762926220894, 0.053986430168151855, 0.01879255473613739, 0.04234945774078369, 0.024826331064105034, 0.07295626401901245, -0.04816048964858055, -0.012278675101697445, -0.026542730629444122, 0.030215933918952942, -0.0065150996670126915, -0.029450375586748123, 0.025221403688192368, 0.0009863842278718948, 0.00984885822981596, 0.002661613281816244, 0.056336525827646255, -0.036778055131435394, 0.04116055369377136, 0.005956844426691532, -0.027119450271129608, -0.0020180358551442623, -0.002436624141409993, -0.023808235302567482, -0.03861246258020401, 0.0008535555680282414, -0.03311029449105263, 0.05592013895511627, -0.022811351343989372, 0.0322912223637104, 0.048168815672397614, -0.027183329686522484, -0.035847827792167664, 0.01869039610028267, -0.02956399880349636, 0.013115514069795609, 0.008346911519765854, -0.019886808469891548, -0.012838359922170639, -0.03846612572669983, -0.022365771234035492, 0.11295367032289505, 0.004439854063093662, -0.030797304585576057, -0.056491486728191376, 0.079314686357975, -0.04621249809861183, 0.023882808163762093, -0.017642157152295113, 0.018721576780080795, 0.040313806384801865, -0.041966941207647324, -0.028791237622499466, 0.03956782817840576, -0.019728709012269974, -0.002238467102870345, 0.0007744048489257693, 0.07900898903608322, 0.04167797416448593, -0.08424718677997589, -0.0013854687567800283, 0.026734115555882454, -0.10578978806734085, 0.010346736758947372, -0.0153801953420043, 0.011012540198862553, -0.010837769135832787, -0.020141206681728363, 0.06806463748216629, -0.05617963895201683, 0.02509499154984951, -0.005312545690685511, 0.008611110970377922, -0.01195557788014412, -0.05557757243514061, 0.011469611898064613, -0.01197919063270092, -0.08935150504112244, -0.014075563289225101, 0.04359520226716995, 0.011434054933488369, -0.029435185715556145, 0.06919103115797043, -0.019381826743483543, 0.026943255215883255, -0.031524598598480225, 0.059355027973651886, 0.008537081070244312, -0.03346450254321098, -0.008759686723351479, -0.08816099911928177, 0.0008028756128624082, 0.0549149289727211, 0.015305052511394024, -0.009193390607833862, -0.0029017548076808453, -0.013486320152878761, 0.00024202486383728683, -0.03135298937559128, 0.005454427562654018, 0.04729745164513588, 0.021943343803286552, -0.04320375248789787, 0.010009403340518475, 0.013673233799636364, -0.01205036323517561, 0.0034444869961589575, 0.033194612711668015, 0.02849809266626835, -0.11846031248569489, 0.008201578631997108, 0.05666773021221161, 0.030738405883312225, 0.03191040828824043, 0.030255865305662155, -0.020414035767316818, -0.029074128717184067, -0.01866544969379902, 0.03786914795637131, 0.014279460534453392, 0.003320396179333329, -0.007625843398272991, 0.04960978403687477, -0.03362608700990677, 0.029012760147452354, 0.03408050164580345, -0.03425758704543114, 0.0014436255441978574, 0.04682205244898796, -0.04896194487810135, -0.01010596938431263, -0.019343052059412003, 0.008563813753426075, -0.01651833765208721, -0.024528013542294502, -0.010746626183390617, -0.0094385277479887, -0.024276547133922577, -0.002061045728623867, -0.007541249971836805, 0.02700185403227806, -0.014932656660676003, 0.010608762502670288, 0.0021855749655514956, -0.036663513630628586, 0.016658412292599678, 0.026841944083571434, 0.0008751677814871073, 0.0365278497338295, 0.016977759078145027, 0.04952840879559517, 0.003445989452302456, 0.032471105456352234, 0.02786201424896717, -0.050310004502534866, 0.06368015706539154, -0.02187049388885498, -0.04831311106681824, -0.061758462339639664, 0.013681173324584961, -0.013221561908721924, -0.014294078573584557, -0.01878269761800766, 0.006597354542464018, -0.04835677146911621, 0.0311991348862648, 0.03237476572394371, 0.03558212146162987, -0.01839817687869072, -0.026334308087825775, 0.024557597935199738, 0.023299362510442734, -0.031408388167619705, -0.07106897234916687, -0.035042453557252884, 0.08510854095220566, -0.06431741267442703, 0.023039784282445908, 0.04357748106122017, 0.006459641736000776, -0.06462524086236954, 0.0004858600441366434, -0.014429965987801552, 0.06254122406244278, -0.00322817824780941, -0.008596107363700867, -0.02735672891139984, -0.012117402628064156, -0.030935321003198624, -0.03364541009068489, -0.03457561880350113, -0.02103964053094387, 0.01485160831362009, -0.02291281893849373, -0.004060348030179739, -0.044488195329904556, 0.03053000010550022, 0.0341658778488636, -0.05070627108216286, -0.020052263513207436, -0.04384439438581467, 0.012159781530499458, 0.010490616783499718, -0.022330941632390022, 0.05448485538363457, -0.029233410954475403, 0.010081194341182709, 0.04493425041437149, 0.011440944857895374, -0.04504026472568512, 0.035691436380147934, -0.019490456208586693, 0.039311330765485764, 0.016215156763792038, -0.03351055458188057, -0.059479858726263046, -0.05585428699851036, 0.03886905312538147, 0.03181979060173035, -0.033007096499204636, 0.04130096361041069, -0.07180339843034744, -0.04031796380877495, 0.010473599657416344, -0.07579902559518814, -0.03432386741042137, -0.017689364030957222, -0.02680189162492752, -0.030623802915215492, -0.02340788021683693, 0.02650262787938118, 0.06080823391675949, -0.023099089041352272, -0.013801502995193005, 0.027084538713097572, -0.01304318755865097, 0.014679718762636185, 0.0004542232200037688, 0.05280543863773346, 0.05876237154006958, -0.010319831781089306, 0.02797582745552063, -0.021976733580231667, -0.026796864345669746, -0.008437731303274632, -0.005623658653348684, 0.044252268970012665, 0.00002577324448793661, -0.03942141309380531, 0.02451246604323387, 0.011285697109997272, -0.049830950796604156, -0.07742547988891602, 0.017145153135061264, 0.02483503706753254, -0.03574508801102638, -0.039055775851011276, -0.09030614793300629, -0.011286254972219467, -0.025762710720300674, -0.040845878422260284, 0.037378668785095215, 0.027020083740353584, 0.054764214903116226, -0.0026959336828440428, 0.034690286964178085, 0.014188517816364765, 0.013644594699144363, -0.048436131328344345, 0.04021056741476059, -0.059308502823114395, -0.04698000103235245, -0.022633979097008705, 0.02194293588399887, -0.04744405299425125, 0.043557681143283844, 0.04052455350756645, -0.0201414804905653, -0.0013559211511164904, -0.031175926327705383, 0.03390171378850937, 0.06269081681966782, -0.018359383568167686, 0.015643177554011345, 0.04543495923280716, 0.030494770035147667, -0.04627493396401405, 0.08799926191568375, -0.028621166944503784, -0.02739991620182991, -0.010391735471785069, 0.044266849756240845, -0.048790253698825836, -0.032897304743528366, 0.015798892825841904, 0.07342427223920822, -0.026259636506438255, -0.034539155662059784, 0.022763051092624664, 0.03741617128252983, 0.011288506910204887, -0.007649536244571209, -0.013779894448816776, 0.005164734553545713, 0.009753224439918995, 0.05678682401776314, 0.027666311711072922, -0.017958054319024086, -0.011380302719771862, 0.019780993461608887, 0.006595222745090723, 0.056463707238435745, 0.022197050973773003, -0.010313277132809162, 0.040996238589286804, -0.015029951930046082, 0.035819366574287415, -0.01281107496470213, -0.0075098564848303795, -0.008411468006670475, -0.025194253772497177, 0.05835885927081108, 0.018360964953899384, -0.008995188400149345, 0.07173771411180496, -0.051854852586984634, 0.025906957685947418, -0.03770928829908371, 0.03201329708099365, -0.04316920414566994, 0.038899801671504974, -0.06513909250497818, -0.02332921139895916, 0.06842941045761108, 0.04563221335411072, 0.00926940981298685, -0.035144370049238205, -0.03189363703131676, -0.03408047556877136, -0.06377779692411423, 0.021752730011940002, -0.008489028550684452, 0.0087412865832448, 0.03323224559426308, -0.05979866907000542, -0.0367879644036293, 0.020734015852212906, -0.009526205249130726, -0.02928847074508667, 0.01873483508825302, -0.028588948771357536, 0.03572963550686836, -0.039977047592401505, 0.052621789276599884, 0.04043560102581978, 0.006862204056233168, -0.03121797740459442, 0.0001986883144127205, -0.014550188556313515, -0.010120753198862076, -0.005719007458537817, -0.0094065573066473, 0.007767852395772934, -0.036490052938461304, 0.014765316620469093, -0.02498825080692768, 0.021490858867764473, 0.041950177401304245, 0.020296797156333923, -0.04167797416448593, -0.01037646271288395, 0.04332926496863365, 0.0095615703612566, 0.004885227419435978, 0.03198745846748352, 0.00021753052715212107, -0.02055780217051506, 0.0185598973184824, 0.02916012518107891, -0.015133379958570004, -0.011769858188927174, -0.049990538507699966, 0.010199747048318386, 0.033886950463056564, 0.05429079756140709, 0.058581169694662094, -0.05842109024524689, 0.018516015261411667, 0.06317705661058426, 0.008181750774383545, -0.03181891888380051, 0.10944477468729019, -0.023439649492502213, 0.021889550611376762, -0.03949872404336929, 0.003162849461659789, 0.02299930341541767, -0.014353189617395401, -0.03078089840710163, 0.04562131315469742, -0.03906445577740669, 0.007505893241614103, 0.01766699180006981, 0.025707216933369637, -0.03393717110157013, 0.0175437331199646, 0.0031971188727766275, 0.08435215055942535, 0.027080819010734558, -0.0306197851896286, 0.005011452827602625, 0.045683227479457855, -0.041574861854314804, 0.03035588562488556, -0.059016454964876175, 0.006789023522287607, 0.021415771916508675, -0.014864248223602772, -0.011728819459676743, 0.016929900273680687, 0.008055177517235279, -0.018399443477392197, -0.004991299472749233, -0.022157466039061546, 0.05054314061999321, -0.00716822687536478, 0.009971474297344685, -0.02343730442225933, 0.012560654431581497, 0.04298924282193184, 0.04609295353293419, 0.031882256269454956, 0.0009120291215367615, 0.01052023097872734, -0.007047517690807581, 0.036259930580854416, -0.019304098561406136, -0.03878539428114891, 0.016476992517709732, 0.028884492814540863, 0.006478282157331705, 0.005244487430900335, 0.01306114997714758, 0.02415548823773861, -0.0533953458070755, -0.002449951134622097, 0.024335358291864395, 0.05540408194065094, 0.03080911934375763, 0.00004648589310818352, 0.014782578684389591, 0.048479340970516205, -0.050839051604270935, 0.036394152790308, 0.005762739572674036, 0.02857319451868534, 0.02476249635219574, -0.023751232773065567, -0.022485297173261642, -0.007847004570066929, 0.018711140379309654, -0.06735129654407501, -0.02910168096423149, -0.0064537180587649345, -0.00638274010270834, 0.010305280797183514, -0.02678343839943409, 0.015059753321111202, -0.06491422653198242, 0.03569161519408226, -0.0036192545667290688, -0.005390682723373175, -0.02896139957010746, -0.0007559264195151627, 0.010569563135504723, -0.04000292718410492, -0.02913196012377739, -0.0391024574637413, -0.02749135158956051, 0.011973715387284756, -0.005693872459232807, 0.03443705663084984, -0.03906353563070297, -0.007610033266246319, 0.03811808302998543, -0.042218949645757675, -0.03923795744776726, -0.03888421878218651, 0.043183889240026474, 0.010475688613951206, 0.029092352837324142, 0.002378282602876425, 0.024809585884213448, -0.020916199311614037, -0.02531754970550537, -0.022210633382201195, 0.021486517041921616, -0.019720371812582016, -0.030924124643206596, -0.024616247043013573, -0.046004973351955414, -0.029557114467024803, -0.0437651164829731, 0.08442959189414978, 0.06370440125465393, -0.0796147882938385, 0.08542018383741379, -0.0033511139918118715, -0.004189306870102882, 0.015076751820743084, 0.009126505814492702, 0.005239755846560001, 0.06458505243062973, -0.013205715455114841, 0.015802284702658653, -0.1103573814034462, -0.0003676372580230236, 0.013491884805262089, 0.011944619007408619, 0.040896978229284286, -0.0192993376404047, 0.01778009720146656, -0.029722291976213455, -0.0002977751428261399, 0.05531829223036766, -0.007341775111854076, 0.001715408987365663, 0.03926977515220642, -0.006607598625123501, 0.004873019643127918, 0.032162249088287354, 0.05525573715567589, 0.05471359193325043, -0.04810700938105583, 0.0008214727859012783, 0.0339505672454834, -0.04439350217580795, 0.03117583878338337, -0.04415562376379967, -0.0398176833987236, -0.02143503911793232, -0.05324999615550041, -0.025281118229031563, -0.01736896112561226, 0.0634114071726799, 0.04535064846277237, -0.06099439412355423, 0.00004189561150269583, -0.03507133200764656, -0.045759089291095734, -0.033149223774671555, -0.031184695661067963, 0.03497112914919853, -0.021502140909433365, 0.014811384491622448, -0.0333627387881279, 0.0406777560710907, -0.00682166637852788, -0.01725691929459572, 0.021687643602490425, 0.051285311579704285, -0.03294077143073082, -0.06863901764154434, -0.040941037237644196, -0.0071605537086725235, 0.0002487266610842198, -0.022724194452166557, 0.055061545222997665, -0.0068883528001606464, -0.023154519498348236, 0.03744024410843849, 0.03614490106701851, -0.06875298917293549, 0.018117785453796387, -0.009759544394910336, -0.0048482283018529415, 0.046437960118055344, 0.020442510023713112, -0.012625309638679028, 0.03290347382426262, 0.010399428196251392, 0.0038097610231488943, -0.006570395082235336, -0.048762738704681396, -0.02646254003047943, -0.0306687131524086, 0.013858537189662457, -0.024682344868779182, 0.029947780072689056, -0.021678507328033447, 0.006810261867940426, 0.08050590008497238, 0.021344086155295372, 0.005768447648733854, 0.02954060025513172, 0.0026811512652784586, -0.001334804343059659, -0.0723886787891388, 0.05412416532635689, 0.06734959781169891, 0.011668626219034195, -0.01933753862977028, -0.039766013622283936, 0.03475116193294525, 0.00830142479389906, 0.0033773095346987247, 0.03700408339500427, 0.019484905526041985, -0.06050291657447815, -0.07554285228252411, 0.005373005289584398, -0.03097335435450077, 0.03779565915465355, -0.02406846545636654, 0.09249601513147354, 0.06910397112369537, -0.05751520395278931, 0.0699935182929039, -0.004739443305879831, 0.005048804916441441, -0.035851117223501205, -0.002072411822155118, -0.005088458769023418, -0.03293885290622711, -0.04030187800526619, -0.08125359565019608, -0.006133479997515678, 0.025689998641610146, 0.030030369758605957, -0.04315309226512909, 0.03452683240175247, 0.015317999757826328, 0.0012765101855620742, 0.010817118920385838, -0.004222825635224581, -0.013563567772507668, 0.02803852967917919, 0.05732286348938942, -0.021774854511022568, -0.05197072774171829, -0.044003598392009735, 0.03332902863621712, 0.023094523698091507, -0.008744205348193645, -0.015282837674021721, -0.0496416836977005, -0.0029293762054294348 ]
<p>Particles are suspended in a liquid medium at a concentration of 4 particles per mL. A large amount of the suspension is thoroughly agitated, and then 3 mL are withdrawn . Let $X$ be the number of the particles in the 3 mL. Answer the following:</p> <p>a- The distribution of X is a Poisson distribution, what is its parameter ($\lambda$)?</p> <p>b- Find the probability that no particle is withdrawn from the 3 mL.</p> <p>c- Find the probability that one particle is withdrawn from the 3 mL.</p>
g74042
[ 0.06613481789827347, 0.03233965113759041, 0.0003349056059960276, -0.06370279937982559, 0.03822585195302963, 0.025797564536333084, 0.02898731268942356, 0.016640132293105125, -0.050725460052490234, -0.00977125484496355, -0.06872694194316864, -0.01655198447406292, -0.06663792580366135, -0.037730176001787186, -0.018317928537726402, -0.024051029235124588, 0.05083833262324333, -0.014993207529187202, -0.057084549218416214, 0.012817072682082653, -0.009204895235598087, -0.024404721334576607, -0.005584848113358021, -0.07128940522670746, 0.03681280091404915, -0.02970024384558201, -0.028594885021448135, 0.006327140610665083, -0.035104405134916306, 0.02780267223715782, -0.07556450366973877, 0.0026521990075707436, -0.010303971357643604, -0.03980330377817154, -0.010391571559011936, 0.0004563064721878618, 0.10197488963603973, 0.026904897764325142, -0.05573514476418495, -0.0174521766602993, 0.009987538680434227, 0.018548408523201942, 0.04878523573279381, 0.0444885715842247, 0.019970957189798355, 0.09165199846029282, -0.01884489133954048, 0.03288043290376663, -0.02236781269311905, -0.008833087049424648, -0.006627070251852274, 0.028865767642855644, -0.07486966997385025, 0.016311204060912132, -0.07992207258939743, 0.05854364112019539, 0.012122878804802895, -0.026966799050569534, -0.006568023003637791, 0.07600746303796768, 0.05566856637597084, -0.051016345620155334, -0.0730736032128334, -0.03557409718632698, -0.015987562015652657, -0.018517233431339264, -0.025343285873532295, 0.047907546162605286, 0.019261902198195457, -0.0004960883525200188, 0.014164293184876442, -0.02857634797692299, 0.025738349184393883, -0.05145387724041939, -0.11646699905395508, -0.011308514513075352, -0.033174969255924225, -0.008885686285793781, 0.0041977292858064175, -0.01793988049030304, -0.050111401826143265, 0.028184114024043083, 0.02236257866024971, -0.0383402444422245, -0.0016730064526200294, 0.045660167932510376, 0.006328204646706581, -0.029977798461914062, -0.05135837197303772, 0.02282811887562275, 0.0228577870875597, -0.014079928398132324, 0.03964928165078163, 0.03186488896608353, -0.032916441559791565, 0.00261560152284801, 0.004449810367077589, 0.05472596362233162, -0.04506729543209076, -0.08031851798295975, 0.05143411085009575, -0.008263734169304371, -0.036985356360673904, -0.04003871977329254, 0.005639669019728899, 0.03380372002720833, 0.029518375173211098, 0.028592856600880623, 0.006174818612635136, 0.020422600209712982, -0.033557627350091934, -0.023854948580265045, -0.06632520258426666, -0.015123815275728703, 0.012611625716090202, -0.044280294328927994, 0.07108205556869507, 0.03320784121751785, -0.016696173697710037, -0.004370891954749823, -0.05368346348404884, -0.005122306291013956, 0.02592379041016102, 0.05155359208583832, 0.03114691749215126, -0.007816671393811703, 0.01727641560137272, 0.10233377665281296, 0.024000460281968117, 0.041306547820568085, 0.010481349192559719, -0.015555132180452347, 0.042220842093229294, -0.030807117000222206, -0.029097098857164383, 0.05437343940138817, 0.013777879066765308, 0.041227076202631, 0.03914223611354828, 0.023948082700371742, 0.05452858656644821, 0.026802292093634605, 0.013621586374938488, 0.005824797786772251, -0.035597749054431915, 0.008401133120059967, 0.05112846940755844, -0.04644758254289627, -0.012900538742542267, -0.0024479259736835957, -0.013267263770103455, 0.06281214952468872, -0.005299936980009079, 0.0173188466578722, -0.004362110979855061, 0.04521198198199272, 0.01967601105570793, -0.008389690890908241, -0.0008560892893001437, 0.010788608342409134, 0.016880249604582787, -0.051002442836761475, -0.038938552141189575, 0.05218887701630592, -0.03314414620399475, 0.038529619574546814, 0.013636849820613861, -0.01701127365231514, -0.05179114639759064, -0.036314867436885834, -0.03496573865413666, -0.039355773478746414, -0.0179748497903347, -0.023901591077446938, -0.001530736219137907, 0.005029012914747, 0.008088365197181702, -0.012321311049163342, -0.011737879365682602, -0.00042411318281665444, 0.02512798272073269, 0.015945222228765488, 0.027824025601148605, -0.015594758093357086, 0.041001368314027786, -0.02371915429830551, 0.029992319643497467, 0.06946740299463272, -0.02889426425099373, 0.017730606719851494, 0.0196229200810194, 0.026081159710884094, -0.017287777736783028, -0.06273245066404343, -0.03889653459191322, -0.03999833017587662, 0.04231644421815872, -0.022531036287546158, 0.0250403955578804, 0.0004285973554942757, 0.06419814378023148, -0.03153732791543007, 0.03899802267551422, 0.005988672375679016, 0.08304765820503235, -0.09536169469356537, 0.029202595353126526, 0.06683605909347534, -0.023009955883026123, -0.032142918556928635, 0.012489951215684414, -0.03182398900389671, 0.0014207238564267755, 0.06716367602348328, 0.03469556197524071, -0.003560417564585805, 0.02240481972694397, 0.036025743931531906, 0.05847194790840149, 0.0512985996901989, -0.08198100328445435, -0.060065772384405136, -0.012564657256007195, -0.0007534210453741252, -0.0018343572737649083, 0.08246605843305588, 0.027963964268565178, -0.016395974904298782, -0.05695807933807373, 0.06025012955069542, -0.052545152604579926, -0.025594286620616913, 0.04265406355261803, -0.01940738782286644, 0.0339689701795578, -0.018545176833868027, -0.05078443884849548, -0.0064879911951720715, -0.037074875086545944, -0.005366028752177954, -0.004846857860684395, -0.0047608548775315285, -0.01984292082488537, -0.04700595885515213, -0.018452094867825508, -0.0068821688182652, -0.03120964951813221, -0.008382203057408333, 0.0643458217382431, 0.015323829837143421, -0.022923516109585762, 0.0006225957768037915, 0.04172343760728836, 0.00584883987903595, 0.04083101451396942, 0.018490782007575035, 0.0043441480956971645, -0.0008962450665421784, -0.040057823061943054, -0.019535470753908157, -0.032961148768663406, -0.02761121466755867, 0.05021126940846443, -0.059915851801633835, -0.02133522741496563, 0.014534950256347656, -0.01027591060847044, -0.00456441892310977, 0.049885332584381104, 0.040320899337530136, 0.030766302719712257, -0.03406567499041557, 0.010307139717042446, 0.06862670928239822, 0.020575784146785736, 0.02938709780573845, 0.034211415797472, -0.030508549883961678, 0.013385573402047157, 0.03149941936135292, 0.00482003903016448, -0.01968088187277317, -0.035821087658405304, -0.017159676179289818, 0.03433864936232567, -0.0193585567176342, 0.06586023420095444, 0.006072117481380701, 0.004230213351547718, 0.026405606418848038, -0.0009984590578824282, 0.07272998988628387, -0.025579040870070457, 0.03926118090748787, -0.011991938576102257, 0.028654640540480614, -0.002736147493124008, -0.03505970537662506, 0.019214218482375145, -0.027161240577697754, 0.015176531858742237, -0.02984124794602394, -0.02124350517988205, -0.029665565118193626, 0.01813598908483982, 0.017031259834766388, -0.023612050339579582, 0.07735336571931839, 0.007650912739336491, -0.020080963149666786, -0.030650757253170013, 0.04089980944991112, 0.0400538370013237, 0.008132441900670528, -0.036896511912345886, 0.028687937185168266, 0.04000138118863106, -0.008194523863494396, 0.02681499347090721, -0.01819191873073578, 0.03034236468374729, 0.02822047844529152, 0.07288683205842972, -0.02455097809433937, 0.002690625609830022, -0.04016679897904396, -0.056657228618860245, 0.06077297776937485, 0.016485139727592468, -0.0075151436030864716, 0.010688185691833496, -0.01798134855926037, 0.06187606230378151, -0.06243700534105301, -0.008204632438719273, -0.0683104619383812, -0.009331892244517803, -0.022258702665567398, 0.02702801302075386, -0.04041587933897972, 0.0158254262059927, -0.03148694708943367, -0.025085341185331345, -0.02759222313761711, -0.07917595654726028, -0.018018629401922226, 0.037243761122226715, 0.030642308294773102, 0.06576170772314072, 0.012041267938911915, 0.040486305952072144, -0.004017864819616079, 0.03809412568807602, -0.013293915428221226, 0.054861441254615784, -0.030604517087340355, -0.05245005339384079, 0.012306577526032925, 0.03738512471318245, -0.031026525422930717, 0.019696371629834175, -0.09162869304418564, -0.024825848639011383, 0.005640811752527952, 0.03585990145802498, -0.029195671901106834, -0.05913813039660454, 0.07337349653244019, -0.024475207552313805, -0.02622177079319954, -0.016874708235263824, -0.018690617755055428, -0.00787210650742054, -0.00017248700896743685, 0.024818599224090576, -0.0049207331612706184, -0.015183059498667717, 0.05590740591287613, -0.03919939696788788, -0.01734081283211708, 0.007907243445515633, -0.025582479313015938, -0.013921106234192848, -0.04525730758905411, -0.014571159146726131, 0.06431237608194351, -0.05089040473103523, 0.015680892392992973, -0.04432341828942299, -0.05510449782013893, 0.08162621408700943, -0.030075393617153168, -0.05348801985383034, -0.01119337510317564, 0.021551955491304398, -0.017100144177675247, 0.032101940363645554, -0.022617259994149208, 0.003944068681448698, -0.005565933883190155, -0.015258102677762508, -0.04800538346171379, 0.014738195575773716, 0.024395648390054703, 0.0058526089414954185, 0.05277581885457039, 0.0275224968791008, -0.0033892467617988586, 0.04296140745282173, -0.010984844528138638, -0.04711390286684036, 0.0174493957310915, -0.01470515038818121, -0.016747718676924706, -0.010327344760298729, -0.041229188442230225, 0.008598623797297478, 0.017909446731209755, -0.00959137175232172, 0.017089173197746277, 0.03016616590321064, 0.0021542084868997335, -0.013068685308098793, -0.002735530026257038, -0.0068000564351677895, 0.008941251784563065, 0.02515467442572117, 0.012529284693300724, -0.04886800795793533, -0.01534572895616293, 0.03362056985497475, 0.01251643430441618, 0.0010728598572313786, 0.055389404296875, 0.019460855051875114, 0.006794765125960112, -0.02433784119784832, -0.015511552803218365, 0.0004974936018697917, -0.025380464270710945, -0.02700943499803543, 0.01844761334359646, -0.04718836769461632, -0.002569903153926134, 0.01854928582906723, 0.012498118914663792, 0.06575983762741089, -0.037013936787843704, 0.047634556889534, 0.011416277848184109, 0.03292081505060196, 0.01921001635491848, -0.04681088402867317, -0.055988527834415436, 0.0012336078798398376, 0.026947222650051117, -0.007605726830661297, -0.006188797298818827, 0.010689743794500828, 0.012334099039435387, 0.021879376843571663, -0.014472268521785736, 0.0070548467338085175, -0.027165831997990608, -0.031218431890010834, -0.02966967038810253, -0.024531491100788116, 0.018076440319418907, 0.003403129056096077, -0.03236563503742218, -0.05018887296319008, 0.012006856501102448, 0.06420216709375381, 0.011237137019634247, -0.012124605476856232, -0.016398180276155472, -0.014936044812202454, 0.03316299244761467, 0.06356486678123474, 0.0006668729474768043, 0.053990982472896576, -0.0032980735413730145, -0.007005965802818537, -0.00980004295706749, -0.008098241873085499, -0.0077691590413451195, 0.02596314251422882, -0.04102391004562378, -0.006766092497855425, -0.007869676686823368, 0.019734464585781097, 0.011578884907066822, -0.01181616261601448, 0.0005631688400171697, 0.00351930083706975, -0.07672391086816788, 0.02813483215868473, -0.005149915348738432, 0.04631943255662918, 0.04544331878423691, -0.026136841624975204, -0.059023428708314896, -0.013170832768082619, 0.020847881212830544, -0.08704178780317307, 0.005603575613349676, 0.006864484399557114, -0.03683745861053467, -0.02793792635202408, 0.05654865503311157, 0.037514928728342056, -0.04710115119814873, 0.04478665068745613, -0.015537493862211704, -0.025999795645475388, 0.029991839081048965, -0.01418305467814207, 0.019214969128370285, -0.003139772452414036, 0.06455805897712708, 0.053439222276210785, 0.041344963014125824, -0.006055000238120556, 0.022547522559762, -0.05689627304673195, -0.10763326287269592, -0.03330568969249725, 0.06670675426721573, -0.03444129228591919, -0.041955891996622086, 0.010295364074409008, 0.024074124172329903, -0.017740795388817787, 0.01349685713648796, -0.039089635014534, -0.011043764650821686, -0.014948518946766853, -0.02068948559463024, 0.03222854062914848, -0.025720853358507156, -0.07080581784248352, 0.003731127828359604, 0.009001216851174831, 0.05535627901554108, 0.038578398525714874, 0.07813325524330139, -0.03712039068341255, -0.02246703952550888, 0.00575282284989953, -0.03832392394542694, 0.05111508443951607, 0.008625440299510956, -0.015411811880767345, 0.018694201484322548, -0.0054885512217879295, 0.029889177531003952, -0.002326181624084711, 0.02516947127878666, 0.007653180509805679, 0.008873510174453259, -0.03358174115419388, -0.045346617698669434, 0.019502097740769386, -0.009445564821362495, -0.008744945749640465, -0.08937527984380722, -0.05123594030737877, 0.03519824892282486, -0.006579238455742598, 0.04810355231165886, -0.002654249081388116, 0.032437972724437714, -0.020598554983735085, -0.002378791803494096, 0.05994219332933426, 0.02610541321337223, -0.00031979967025108635, -0.03265467658638954, -0.03229885920882225, 0.02678719162940979, -0.014671927317976952, 0.031227773055434227, 0.01909930258989334, -0.02584480307996273, -0.056393157690763474, 0.015685664489865303, -0.034054409712553024, -0.007285290863364935, 0.02694126032292843, -0.015435608103871346, 0.06098141893744469, -0.037515029311180115, -0.029953405261039734, -0.01661248505115509, -0.004479066003113985, -0.03200850263237953, -0.031989771872758865, -0.0030964012257754803, -0.022201700136065483, -0.03329765424132347, 0.010454166680574417, -0.00019047112436965108, -0.0042863208800554276, -0.02908599004149437, 0.03697194159030914, 0.017350826412439346, 0.007101927883923054, -0.01582287810742855, -0.023390207439661026, -0.003673039609566331, 0.07603117823600769, 0.02368338219821453, 0.041798584163188934, 0.021382827311754227, 0.03637366369366646, -0.03566145896911621, -0.026287764310836792, 0.0048957765102386475, -0.0007422530907206237, -0.03234877809882164, 0.02599809132516384, 0.004881640896201134, 0.02732773870229721, -0.07171609252691269, 0.035715583711862564, -0.009037110023200512, -0.011715903878211975, -0.04470464959740639, 0.03400435671210289, 0.034629907459020615, 0.05060873553156853, -0.03558092936873436, -0.007236512377858162, -0.0195179246366024, -0.06767238676548004, 0.017891915515065193, -0.055360883474349976, 0.04566962271928787, 0.05526839941740036, 0.014078076928853989, -0.0008103958680294454, -0.0036189306993037462, 0.041258662939071655, 0.0011041946709156036, -0.04318772256374359, 0.008259665220975876, 0.04224304109811783, 0.07434608042240143, -0.006792332977056503, 0.051636792719364166, -0.02943749912083149, 0.05430910363793373, 0.019046710804104805, -0.017241694033145905, 0.012884574010968208, 0.0442342683672905, 0.024585649371147156, 0.016285521909594536, 0.01049476396292448, -0.010201425291597843, -0.05678180605173111, -0.08634588867425919, -0.05531121790409088, -0.053737983107566833, 0.002585147274658084, 0.042720481753349304, 0.037120576947927475, -0.044536519795656204, 0.0006136708543635905, -0.06605170667171478, -0.001749316812492907, 0.017153523862361908, -0.08879416435956955, 0.03165910765528679, 0.022221283987164497, 0.01955745555460453, 0.04531349986791611, 0.04042878374457359, 0.018884334713220596, 0.011437869630753994, -0.0012978153536096215, -0.05155346170067787, -0.03121321275830269, -0.020688626915216446, -0.012215014547109604, 0.02832726016640663, -0.010605024173855782, 0.01984385959804058, 0.05302407592535019, 0.009100928902626038, -0.0134830167517066, 0.017776984721422195, 0.01762264221906662, -0.05792686343193054, 0.009292367845773697, 0.00654395530000329, 0.07832789421081543, -0.028869792819023132, 0.08731698244810104, 0.028345366939902306, 0.019228368997573853, -0.009149812161922455, 0.0002455963985994458, -0.006788883823901415, -0.05702169984579086, 0.013957742601633072, 0.006993419956415892, 0.02017398737370968, -0.011941957287490368, -0.03193426877260208, -0.03669329732656479, -0.027166100218892097, -0.038872119039297104, -0.010796953924000263, 0.0023430639412254095, -0.04291796311736107, -0.044455528259277344, 0.016933182254433632, -0.0007851434056647122, -0.0037445814814418554, -0.02468971163034439, 0.02332601323723793, -0.061802975833415985, 0.008470757864415646, -0.015271946787834167, -0.029597219079732895, -0.012060657143592834, 0.052670542150735855, -0.03581564873456955, 0.051225729286670685, -0.06601555645465851, -0.043024126440286636, -0.0652783215045929, 0.009630017913877964, 0.03404480218887329, -0.003146424191072583, -0.006418657023459673, 0.0476490780711174, -0.00984722189605236, -0.007474921178072691, -0.020203186199069023, 0.020965401083230972, 0.03274395689368248, 0.03632506728172302, 0.04235619306564331, -0.028650693595409393, -0.04260643571615219, 0.0535910502076149, 0.03825952112674713, -0.032195162028074265, -0.024096274748444557, 0.008972284384071827, 0.026179252192378044, 0.07600338757038116, 0.01713673211634159, -0.06887765228748322, 0.047883808612823486, -0.016828997060656548, -0.021636875346302986, -0.09165269136428833, -0.02340291067957878, -0.06543593853712082, 0.02076885662972927, 0.07564066350460052, -0.055574968457221985, 0.013939212076365948, 0.032660022377967834, 0.04211372137069702 ]
<p>I noticed that in the Normal distribution, the probability $P(x=c)$ equals zero, while for the Poisson distribution, it will not equal zero when $c$ is a non-negative integer.</p> <p>My question is: Does the probability of any constant in the normal distribution equal zero because it represents the area under any curve? Or it is just only a rule to memorize? </p>
g36675
[ 0.059306636452674866, 0.013153345324099064, 0.006170503329485655, -0.04504932835698128, 0.024127637967467308, 0.008390295319259167, -0.011268864385783672, 0.04222135245800018, -0.009700647555291653, -0.02099425718188286, -0.011623818427324295, 0.0037895836867392063, -0.013319803401827812, -0.06441102921962738, 0.0034103759098798037, 0.00785701535642147, -0.015001574531197548, 0.015624051913619041, 0.036385148763656616, 0.008176714181900024, -0.0443941205739975, -0.019235223531723022, -0.01312436256557703, 0.000057373214076505974, -0.03390653803944588, -0.025397954508662224, -0.03345876932144165, -0.015275118872523308, -0.036651719361543655, -0.0152193708345294, -0.005867233965545893, 0.03190542384982109, 0.03541010990738869, -0.06470102816820145, -0.01900164596736431, -0.00892583280801773, 0.02040787786245346, 0.008162939921021461, -0.011035759001970291, 0.004710908513516188, -0.016026794910430908, 0.07815199345350266, 0.03434400260448456, -0.01620345003902912, -0.046711210161447525, 0.06398889422416687, -0.03662130981683731, 0.05353420600295067, 0.017874082550406456, 0.018059412017464638, -0.0030700804200023413, 0.0036507900804281235, 0.01321247685700655, -0.025969382375478745, -0.035987697541713715, 0.01770935393869877, 0.08230561763048172, -0.04853380471467972, 0.0025953499134629965, 0.028544045984745026, 0.044087059795856476, -0.008055207319557667, -0.00044626486487686634, 0.0033341816160827875, 0.032709069550037384, 0.02661740407347679, -0.044210441410541534, 0.036494527012109756, -0.0033924051094800234, 0.014113526791334152, -0.01132204569876194, -0.01231138501316309, -0.023592207580804825, -0.0629461407661438, -0.06838736683130264, -0.026709262281656265, 0.0590490885078907, 0.03702239692211151, 0.016906479373574257, 0.014410738833248615, -0.078069768846035, 0.017270293086767197, 0.059333983808755875, -0.011172588914632797, 0.029785538092255592, 0.019292837008833885, 0.020249569788575172, -0.022953815758228302, -0.04867886006832123, 0.07853706181049347, -0.01837441325187683, 0.004473240580409765, 0.06293484568595886, 0.042342960834503174, 0.006028575822710991, -0.008304968476295471, -0.029514996334910393, 0.1080625131726265, -0.11000074446201324, 0.03992369398474693, -0.0004173407796770334, 0.04189123213291168, 0.013726943172514439, 0.015825418755412102, -0.03148524835705757, 0.05016263946890831, -0.02509656548500061, -0.002832082100212574, 0.07214310020208359, -0.03344063088297844, -0.004086572676897049, 0.022334186360239983, -0.05016772449016571, -0.02295989729464054, -0.009147592820227146, 0.003288292558863759, 0.10375063121318817, -0.036912016570568085, 0.025263577699661255, 0.07338152080774307, -0.042041681706905365, 0.019551629200577736, 0.022035952657461166, 0.03084726072847843, -0.00005193401011638343, -0.008681307546794415, 0.029621273279190063, 0.03868833929300308, 0.03451143205165863, -0.030568914487957954, 0.024364693090319633, 0.03608516976237297, -0.03966904804110527, 0.023806152865290642, 0.0037983120419085026, 0.021275313571095467, -0.012077569030225277, 0.021066837012767792, 0.028647562488913536, 0.07771261036396027, -0.054566171020269394, 0.027136025950312614, 0.018811246380209923, -0.035846199840307236, -0.008439699187874794, -0.015379006043076515, 0.0020326850935816765, -0.003361935494467616, -0.05040666460990906, 0.0102118831127882, -0.01562667079269886, -0.02514265663921833, -0.0508979894220829, -0.09242258220911026, -0.06425733119249344, 0.0429685078561306, 0.011349109932780266, 0.023188939318060875, -0.0020335002336651087, 0.05215012654662132, 0.024135533720254898, -0.006359845399856567, 0.0500643253326416, 0.017745936289429665, -0.05985463783144951, -0.0681726485490799, 0.028321901336312294, -0.02736395038664341, -0.06317334622144699, -0.02103380300104618, 0.016050681471824646, -0.00541914626955986, -0.025907494127750397, -0.025285078212618828, 0.005522998981177807, 0.00297358725219965, 0.0018971656681969762, 0.024471808224916458, 0.04390249028801918, -0.006005153991281986, -0.03852914273738861, 0.055328793823719025, -0.0040726931765675545, -0.09379144012928009, -0.02326083742082119, -0.029330549761652946, 0.007413753308355808, 0.0472167506814003, 0.002082320163026452, 0.006569322664290667, -0.043813373893499374, 0.003783924737945199, -0.03534270450472832, 0.02780649997293949, -0.040401384234428406, -0.00008750009146751836, 0.02027045376598835, -0.015818560495972633, 0.0013186776777729392, -0.013223683461546898, 0.043031107634305954, 0.015612267889082432, 0.04308107867836952, -0.06456054747104645, 0.049348898231983185, -0.029767926782369614, 0.04935385286808014, -0.02760878950357437, -0.012584620155394077, 0.013343516737222672, -0.003104395465925336, -0.050060663372278214, -0.004175629001110792, 0.05124088004231453, 0.06063135340809822, -0.016094863414764404, -0.014092694036662579, -0.019528796896338463, 0.013950042426586151, -0.04641897976398468, -0.009109445847570896, -0.010150286369025707, 0.0035880114883184433, -0.062239401042461395, -0.011001816019415855, 0.05529291555285454, 0.04381696879863739, -0.02961578406393528, -0.023580897599458694, 0.08004485070705414, -0.039084356278181076, -0.07433822751045227, 0.007498894818127155, 0.004571576602756977, -0.015597552992403507, -0.004773365333676338, 0.00364688434638083, 0.02198140323162079, 0.00314657692797482, 0.02212459221482277, -0.0021129560191184282, -0.0567341111600399, -0.04097025841474533, 0.03335532546043396, -0.02078995108604431, -0.030626321211457253, 0.00035757943987846375, -0.0524163544178009, 0.006089534144848585, 0.05039183050394058, -0.012080490589141846, 0.04594450443983078, -0.02261270396411419, 0.05557222291827202, 0.026759423315525055, -0.03200255706906319, -0.027881409972906113, -0.09013500064611435, -0.03489088639616966, -0.05839785933494568, -0.011090338230133057, 0.03505934029817581, 0.01387777179479599, -0.002759218215942383, -0.02177499607205391, -0.03462548181414604, -0.02587810717523098, 0.01567809283733368, 0.025521598756313324, 0.051778923720121384, 0.03828093037009239, 0.05479918047785759, -0.03840319812297821, 0.02004730887711048, 0.05804796144366264, -0.035844460129737854, -0.01126172300428152, -0.013960089534521103, -0.01050383411347866, -0.031716469675302505, 0.02811439521610737, 0.016113262623548508, -0.03536820784211159, 0.008725618943572044, -0.029147658497095108, -0.005116649437695742, 0.0030737179331481457, -0.0036355089396238327, 0.0022887862287461758, 0.05706511810421944, -0.041058748960494995, 0.032116733491420746, 0.045247066766023636, -0.0117953484877944, 0.03848860412836075, 0.03821863979101181, 0.05453488603234291, -0.04041405767202377, 0.015892431139945984, 0.04525405168533325, -0.0116189606487751, -0.03134317696094513, -0.05364220216870308, 0.006191636901348829, 0.013382394798099995, -0.041423335671424866, -0.0014471701579168439, -0.022717807441949844, -0.002368746092543006, 0.0029268856160342693, -0.02534288913011551, 0.037043362855911255, 0.004854848142713308, -0.03081207349896431, -0.0173878725618124, 0.0636024996638298, -0.002179780276492238, 0.020431475713849068, 0.009466107934713364, 0.008951644413173199, -0.019026758149266243, 0.001930969418026507, -0.03573831170797348, 0.012996969744563103, -0.00048554420936852694, -0.00728859007358551, -0.0017257112776860595, 0.02019476890563965, -0.003972243517637253, 0.016685236245393753, -0.007617794442921877, -0.013727563433349133, -0.014123322442173958, 0.00926909875124693, 0.024606265127658844, -0.05969799682497978, 0.01597188040614128, -0.01351290661841631, -0.0008351019350811839, 0.01743672415614128, 0.036472439765930176, -0.004613412544131279, -0.05741876736283302, -0.025633610785007477, -0.05480771139264107, 0.031668659299612045, 0.022761793807148933, 0.00959044974297285, 0.02664664015173912, 0.012489621527493, 0.031140467151999474, -0.04004574567079544, 0.027711275964975357, -0.04744105786085129, 0.01756240613758564, 0.02124708890914917, -0.05910046398639679, 0.01544047612696886, -0.018779786303639412, 0.008107108995318413, 0.01933746598660946, -0.080112025141716, 0.021843256428837776, 0.018924355506896973, 0.022651951760053635, -0.04268389195203781, -0.047420646995306015, 0.026945272460579872, 0.027495207265019417, -0.009177080355584621, -0.009765306487679482, 0.005178818944841623, 0.04794233664870262, -0.0498635396361351, 0.0744505301117897, -0.011493454687297344, -0.05197031423449516, 0.04822536185383797, -0.030615774914622307, 0.006742792669683695, 0.04545239731669426, -0.028700003400444984, 0.041902896016836166, -0.012336342595517635, 0.012614823877811432, -0.018057934939861298, -0.013769427314400673, -0.022361941635608673, 0.0391029492020607, -0.07505104690790176, 0.03105873614549637, -0.025695815682411194, -0.015207472257316113, -0.012783709913492203, 0.04961695894598961, -0.04782421141862869, -0.0014113441575318575, -0.01835031248629093, -0.055028121918439865, 0.015919392928481102, -0.02246922068297863, -0.01113269291818142, 0.038880567997694016, -0.01279435120522976, 0.07647550851106644, 0.041340019553899765, 0.044912464916706085, -0.0034488574601709843, 0.011303319595754147, -0.05315517634153366, -0.000608926871791482, -0.043214283883571625, -0.033111702650785446, -0.03235321491956711, 0.059921689331531525, -0.014416877180337906, 0.002559412270784378, 0.03276577219367027, 0.02638520486652851, 0.0019988645799458027, 0.018884584307670593, 0.017799383029341698, -0.01672697253525257, 0.010569758713245392, 0.008178267627954483, -0.00043158268090337515, 0.03268936648964882, 0.01283137034624815, 0.0328705795109272, -0.050220340490341187, 0.03640758618712425, 0.06915668398141861, 0.015064992010593414, 0.04651953652501106, -0.041541386395692825, 0.018589036539196968, 0.002850881777703762, 0.045761965215206146, -0.033589255064725876, -0.04820377379655838, 0.001380105852149427, 0.028155669569969177, -0.02539473958313465, 0.01879824884235859, 0.01861778274178505, 0.02168634906411171, -0.0003946679935324937, -0.02195512130856514, -0.015588922426104546, 0.009200116619467735, 0.03338531404733658, 0.023337265476584435, -0.020246833562850952, -0.06470868736505508, -0.003029679646715522, -0.02869507297873497, 0.01976100169122219, -0.003964564763009548, 0.02231297269463539, 0.013137449510395527, -0.0205207709223032, -0.01741628535091877, 0.008475749753415585, 0.011992023326456547, 0.027472108602523804, -0.04556757211685181, -0.11869212239980698, -0.012756719253957272, 0.026730753481388092, 0.022033683955669403, 0.009792743250727654, 0.015812834724783897, 0.04076676443219185, -0.023107783868908882, -0.005780087783932686, 0.010678091086447239, 0.010129407979547977, 0.005062852520495653, -0.014767632819712162, -0.01653997041285038, -0.031636618077754974, -0.010788933373987675, -0.016847718507051468, -0.02761666104197502, 0.013215177692472935, -0.0007799083250574768, -0.03681742027401924, -0.013297447003424168, 0.06840408593416214, -0.03024471551179886, 0.050940319895744324, 0.003109605284407735, 0.06835231184959412, 0.05248149856925011, -0.01568553037941456, -0.1186986193060875, -0.032287683337926865, -0.013744908384978771, 0.0004978509387001395, -0.031570907682180405, -0.06442421674728394, 0.026674533262848854, 0.026121292263269424, -0.023569775745272636, -0.0198824442923069, -0.0057062110863626, 0.021848656237125397, 0.03267591446638107, -0.02264053374528885, 0.04568938538432121, 0.05989901348948479, -0.0036431183107197285, 0.08187588304281235, -0.02721482142806053, 0.006513258442282677, -0.04447026923298836, -0.1209394782781601, -0.02898717299103737, -0.03533114120364189, 0.03811805695295334, 0.038939859718084335, 0.049496572464704514, -0.00253112381324172, -0.013944167643785477, -0.012037469074130058, -0.07830534130334854, -0.079360730946064, -0.06098238378763199, 0.0013152551837265491, 0.010951334610581398, 0.05001164227724075, 0.021994879469275475, 0.012302801944315434, 0.01549461204558611, -0.04569769278168678, -0.012689108960330486, -0.03507445380091667, -0.002822672249749303, 0.07852550595998764, 0.002836262807250023, -0.025647882372140884, -0.04856794327497482, 0.010254417546093464, 0.03038218803703785, -0.023438893258571625, 0.019722208380699158, -0.0677218958735466, 0.001593786757439375, 0.005798232741653919, -0.08405862748622894, 0.030817193910479546, 0.08236689865589142, -0.012938267551362514, -0.00861366093158722, -0.07210194319486618, 0.05756540969014168, 0.04333247244358063, 0.02949533239006996, 0.00961280521005392, -0.04951733723282814, -0.01132129319012165, -0.05187232047319412, 0.020024562254548073, 0.029114767909049988, 0.009605759754776955, -0.04946817457675934, -0.0037125193048268557, -0.001289633451960981, 0.003142767120152712, 0.01126252394169569, 0.05665142834186554, 0.0059743840247392654, 0.0031763187143951654, 0.023716557770967484, 0.01551563199609518, -0.03839666023850441, -0.021481532603502274, -0.056191347539424896, -0.010314038023352623, -0.013358005322515965, 0.017538364976644516, 0.01093126181513071, -0.012927966192364693, -0.05597015470266342, -0.038894668221473694, 0.0753198117017746, 0.031066693365573883, -0.030225997790694237, 0.05844062566757202, -0.03475136309862137, -0.0326031856238842, -0.0029268315993249416, -0.0106984693557024, -0.00875281821936369, -0.031582143157720566, 0.016366485506296158, -0.021509643644094467, -0.07836513221263885, -0.021195601671934128, -0.038711629807949066, -0.03691664710640907, 0.05474836751818657, 0.035189542919397354, -0.012088057585060596, 0.03095392696559429, -0.012416359968483448, 0.02808832749724388, 0.02126987650990486, 0.007464615628123283, 0.03930060192942619, 0.040316712111234665, 0.06093341112136841, 0.024628812447190285, -0.013170618563890457, 0.015104666352272034, -0.021031077951192856, -0.044114235788583755, -0.05070599913597107, -0.018945109099149704, -0.000024062675947789103, 0.020687730982899666, -0.011002149432897568, -0.04749048873782158, -0.017490018159151077, 0.06757745891809464, 0.04801810532808304, -0.01720818132162094, -0.0012664827518165112, 0.05582784116268158, -0.01801374740898609, -0.01307966560125351, 0.02748732641339302, -0.0699990838766098, 0.09636525064706802, -0.05121808871626854, 0.02910701371729374, -0.05797848105430603, 0.03768666833639145, 0.06453865766525269, -0.00798763521015644, -0.0011608030181378126, 0.006052602082490921, 0.05539911985397339, -0.03165150061249733, -0.02263757213950157, 0.001653500716201961, 0.014743396081030369, 0.03104260377585888, -0.024181688204407692, 0.004783495329320431, 0.03555180877447128, 0.09546693414449692, 0.06192157790064812, -0.006605528760701418, -0.029280493035912514, 0.03595983237028122, 0.03674551472067833, 0.027019020169973373, -0.016646206378936768, -0.03771286457777023, -0.01730291172862053, -0.02851162478327751, -0.04007444903254509, -0.04108588024973869, 0.027624880895018578, 0.031400617212057114, 0.007894052192568779, 0.009347372688353062, -0.05091794580221176, -0.03491707518696785, -0.013690556399524212, -0.03896136209368706, -0.015602284111082554, 0.019772455096244812, 0.06934917718172073, 0.0193600133061409, -0.03361457213759422, 0.022936930879950523, -0.02404729649424553, -0.019587602466344833, 0.04488099738955498, -0.004699305165559053, -0.026879094541072845, -0.09383681416511536, 0.03477717936038971, 0.014845588244497776, -0.03369775414466858, -0.03485845774412155, 0.02664240077137947, 0.019203366711735725, 0.015535397455096245, -0.10726630687713623, 0.046607788652181625, -0.024105824530124664, -0.03331281244754791, -0.006932107266038656, 0.027632219716906548, 0.08904649317264557, 0.03318025544285774, -0.0098866056650877, 0.03974692523479462, -0.030478106811642647, -0.04923698678612709, -0.004042940214276314, 0.03012542426586151, -0.027020679786801338, 0.021220704540610313, 0.0011302342172712088, -0.035260677337646484, -0.037495553493499756, 0.04558168724179268, 0.03173768147826195, -0.006957624573260546, 0.01056361012160778, 0.00577417341992259, -0.004193122498691082, -0.023561252281069756, -0.04395940899848938, -0.015976348891854286, 0.003129013814032078, -0.06194659695029259, -0.021746234968304634, -0.012873347848653793, -0.005287608597427607, 0.0280161090195179, 0.047924675047397614, -0.03856026381254196, 0.017230059951543808, 0.001177147263661027, 0.061361171305179596, -0.04903971403837204, -0.008144554682075977, -0.06306368112564087, -0.029410747811198235, -0.03156156837940216, -0.04353520646691322, 0.014039014466106892, 0.04678409546613693, -0.02297085151076317, 0.011490880511701107, 0.03622199222445488, 0.020505007356405258, 0.05653781443834305, 0.018266960978507996, -0.01182758342474699, 0.011965864337980747, -0.017113303765654564, 0.02518422156572342, 0.039823196828365326, 0.011882984079420567, -0.07541347295045853, -0.00973654817789793, -0.015550322830677032, 0.07814338803291321, 0.024719897657632828, -0.055319081991910934, 0.05157266557216644, 0.006996150128543377, 0.06497754156589508, 0.0033026544842869043, -0.000664848368614912, -0.020446278154850006, 0.02197696827352047, 0.04004542529582977, -0.04403185471892357, 0.010712698101997375, 0.030123746022582054, 0.04914900287985802 ]
<p>I've studied machine learning and statistics only very briefly. I've used linear regression to solve problems with fixed sets of variables, but I'm not sure how to approach the following problem.</p> <p>Given a bunch of tagged photos, I'd like to use the tags to estimate the probability that a specific object is contained within the photo. </p> <p>I have access to a wealth of data which has already been classified as either containing the objects we're looking for or not (however note that this is not a classification problem; the probabilities are being used to rank photos).</p> <p>For example. If a photo is tagged with <em>coke</em> and <em>drink</em>, there is a high probability it contains coca-cola. However if a photo is tagged with <em>coke</em> and <em>crack</em>, there is a high probability it does not contain coca-cola. If a photo is tagged with either <em>crack</em> or <em>drink</em> separately, that doesn't tell us much about what might be in the photo.</p> <p>How would one go about building a hypothesis formula for this problem?</p>
g74043
[ -0.015995755791664124, 0.0022401742171496153, -0.014156392775475979, -0.05831238999962807, -0.014429876580834389, -0.05524817481637001, 0.028839504346251488, 0.0317380428314209, -0.06167123466730118, -0.033735502511262894, 0.00533838989213109, 0.014639575034379959, 0.09253762662410736, 0.009132621809840202, -0.09035035222768784, 0.04318340867757797, -0.0006936087738722563, -0.015887483954429626, 0.0003822686558123678, 0.048219259828329086, 0.04905997961759567, 0.03952735662460327, 0.029089845716953278, 0.02218206226825714, -0.0678483173251152, -0.010491161607205868, -0.013404441066086292, 0.029759204015135765, -0.03283242508769035, 0.04332030564546585, -0.04037570580840111, -0.03182652220129967, 0.03568108379840851, -0.028744125738739967, 0.010897334665060043, -0.04119841381907463, 0.051503200083971024, 0.009091172367334366, 0.018601490184664726, 0.00461730919778347, -0.0013527153059840202, 0.05213216692209244, 0.04709166660904884, 0.029429441317915916, -0.03464183211326599, 0.007687274366617203, -0.0010174111230298877, 0.007508355192840099, 0.05946538224816322, 0.02693857066333294, -0.005708957556635141, 0.039002902805805206, -0.02123037539422512, 0.03948535397648811, 0.020128367468714714, 0.010736116208136082, 0.02469651773571968, 0.009339846670627594, -0.01738806441426277, -0.006453350186347961, 0.07822214812040329, -0.049161944538354874, -0.04798118770122528, 0.017430441454052925, 0.0356287881731987, 0.060290463268756866, -0.03416033461689949, -0.06002792716026306, 0.029554123058915138, -0.07850049436092377, 0.006254687439650297, 0.005306462291628122, 0.025130724534392357, -0.012331063859164715, -0.07163317501544952, -0.011834068223834038, -0.06553643941879272, 0.06056053936481476, 0.024368032813072205, 0.07001465559005737, 0.05872941389679909, 0.05298297479748726, 0.010145819745957851, 0.009664401412010193, 0.04786765202879906, -0.013829740695655346, -0.03195168823003769, -0.004004143178462982, -0.014756543561816216, -0.004011782351881266, 0.04078691825270653, -0.010940340347588062, 0.032913804054260254, 0.014152276329696178, 0.04242081567645073, 0.007270404603332281, -0.05478989705443382, 0.021926069632172585, 0.031691379845142365, -0.0038368082605302334, -0.027852224186062813, 0.0464051179587841, -0.0416349321603775, 0.008883235044777393, -0.031928472220897675, -0.014018110930919647, 0.01594340242445469, 0.02468801662325859, -0.0467260479927063, -0.018396681174635887, 0.015673695132136345, 0.040166765451431274, -0.009684398770332336, 0.016812484711408615, -0.10568630695343018, -0.0613504983484745, 0.035931311547756195, -0.001630203565582633, 0.01302153430879116, -0.02277730591595173, -0.01904922164976597, 0.016516568139195442, -0.00955202430486679, 0.059649307280778885, -0.009002923965454102, 0.011316138319671154, -0.018251929432153702, 0.0598532035946846, 0.06758857518434525, 0.0061081768944859505, 0.022505518049001694, -0.0030026822350919247, 0.05444246903061867, 0.022314082831144333, 0.013344730250537395, 0.033863477408885956, 0.013375826179981232, 0.002016698243096471, 0.04575073719024658, 0.031026022508740425, -0.06654941290616989, 0.07882729917764664, 0.015747329220175743, -0.0018504863837733865, -0.025508467108011246, 0.004157151095569134, 0.014212933368980885, -0.014342274516820908, 0.0004369873786345124, -0.05083092674612999, -0.042672861367464066, 0.040695980191230774, -0.04715094715356827, -0.058528028428554535, 0.008324254304170609, -0.0023574659135192633, 0.0016682941932231188, -0.056905053555965424, 0.0208392683416605, -0.0019554097671061754, 0.03140416741371155, -0.025325823575258255, 0.05520333722233772, -0.023832829669117928, -0.011433875188231468, 0.002289746655151248, 0.0619930662214756, -0.014515949413180351, -0.04279865324497223, -0.0386376678943634, 0.004966523963958025, -0.005366146098822355, -0.0217262152582407, -0.0028314513619989157, 0.0570545569062233, 0.046685799956321716, 0.011395296081900597, -0.03405219316482544, 0.06358593702316284, 0.040318090468645096, 0.02615077793598175, -0.04201941564679146, 0.037996623665094376, 0.0269064512103796, 0.0001975670747924596, -0.06018861383199692, -0.018435068428516388, 0.01138278003782034, -0.05708720162510872, -0.01641678251326084, -0.045780036598443985, 0.024329688400030136, 0.034407638013362885, -0.026633793488144875, -0.05578143149614334, -0.0400712750852108, 0.00587611086666584, -0.034064650535583496, -0.02109464816749096, 0.012588570825755596, 0.004197335336357355, 0.011265743523836136, -0.06966393440961838, 0.03295769914984703, 0.0033336372580379248, -0.002367901848629117, -0.03642462193965912, -0.01490960642695427, -0.012626392766833305, 0.08333706855773926, 0.008733424358069897, -0.05823148414492607, -0.013296215794980526, 0.044209592044353485, -0.03377675265073776, 0.010004011914134026, 0.045789361000061035, 0.038549914956092834, 0.0719580128788948, -0.02706143632531166, 0.014727452769875526, 0.01715700700879097, 0.06372936815023422, -0.0024355740752071142, 0.019492747262120247, 0.07417985051870346, 0.06109290197491646, -0.00948636420071125, -0.01533933449536562, 0.03623782843351364, -0.02461049146950245, -0.06464648246765137, 0.020154530182480812, -0.01717410422861576, -0.0021270636934787035, -0.012755046598613262, -0.057847507297992706, -0.014321733266115189, 0.0076424372382462025, 0.013965670019388199, -0.044486530125141144, 0.02370864897966385, -0.02456183172762394, -0.021496953442692757, 0.047727588564157486, -0.02343551255762577, 0.007902780547738075, 0.035256363451480865, 0.018849894404411316, 0.15725280344486237, -0.011094830930233002, -0.013120581395924091, -0.013400421477854252, -0.0864836573600769, 0.033224016427993774, -0.04414802044630051, 0.054165519773960114, 0.02264530211687088, 0.009938681498169899, 0.017941517755389214, 0.02807314321398735, -0.045580875128507614, 0.012030758894979954, -0.040568433701992035, -0.006843723356723785, -0.05065486952662468, 0.0058539933525025845, -0.010255781002342701, 0.03820011764764786, 0.03393878415226936, -0.06821294128894806, -0.01408594474196434, 0.06767861545085907, -0.03495796024799347, 0.07872004061937332, 0.06708820909261703, 0.0029127802699804306, -0.008675222285091877, -0.038223959505558014, -0.01121057104319334, 0.01422360260039568, -0.03775789961218834, -0.02510528266429901, -0.020396923646330833, -0.04970748350024223, 0.017073845490813255, 0.04383224621415138, -0.022767022252082825, 0.08121134340763092, 0.03787762671709061, 0.009161800146102905, 0.0639750137925148, 0.05204179883003235, -0.022936196997761726, 0.015018590725958347, -0.00860042404383421, 0.007267492823302746, 0.02374621294438839, 0.02687244676053524, -0.0012876136461272836, -0.049144063144922256, 0.03671138361096382, 0.07648302614688873, -0.06982916593551636, 0.02771683968603611, -0.0024175974540412426, -0.06877260655164719, -0.026004686951637268, 0.01809564046561718, -0.04429549351334572, -0.04615931957960129, 0.0671185702085495, 0.0021792997140437365, -0.046309154480695724, 0.012014981359243393, -0.03478680178523064, -0.026993228122591972, -0.014365608803927898, 0.015979543328285217, -0.09257756918668747, 0.007493583019822836, -0.016480939462780952, 0.014034898951649666, 0.009652514010667801, 0.0228487029671669, -0.0341666005551815, -0.03575660660862923, 0.010361500084400177, 0.02002815157175064, 0.04497360810637474, 0.05443389713764191, 0.03633691370487213, 0.02960118092596531, 0.0024930802173912525, -0.0643022358417511, -0.027365494519472122, 0.044134411960840225, -0.014846188947558403, 0.03199441358447075, 0.015934275463223457, -0.010871092788875103, 0.04534841701388359, 0.020252475515007973, -0.056843750178813934, 0.004109265748411417, 0.03691084310412407, -0.040897224098443985, 0.012015048414468765, 0.0464165024459362, -0.003886639606207609, -0.027550138533115387, -0.013449029996991158, 0.02311120741069317, -0.007394809741526842, 0.02051636204123497, 0.05867811292409897, -0.0006573408027179539, -0.052138037979602814, 0.012580720707774162, 0.012473694048821926, 0.05017928406596184, -0.012342900037765503, 0.05073613300919533, -0.055012721568346024, 0.028753846883773804, -0.012648891657590866, 0.06426987051963806, 0.04733508825302124, -0.022251712158322334, -0.02618476189672947, 0.05796848610043526, -0.0021621030755341053, 0.02896488457918167, 0.02927154302597046, 0.016774781048297882, -0.001849592081271112, 0.05353042483329773, -0.04676814749836922, -0.011576983146369457, -0.0021897777915000916, -0.013025210238993168, 0.01676766946911812, -0.0010315863182768226, 0.009991878643631935, 0.04411907121539116, -0.06359269469976425, 0.027600374072790146, 0.03890243172645569, 0.03981025889515877, 0.046501997858285904, -0.0330318845808506, 0.01271450612694025, -0.08651608228683472, 0.061065398156642914, -0.04498479515314102, -0.0671745017170906, -0.0007745273760519922, 0.03160381689667702, 0.005194725003093481, -0.021282481029629707, -0.005221872124820948, 0.06546002626419067, 0.005317027680575848, -0.031198732554912567, 0.004991124849766493, 0.009387808851897717, -0.024081483483314514, 0.013894753530621529, 0.03877122700214386, -0.0034102769568562508, -0.032738879323005676, -0.03478061035275459, 0.00010882966307690367, -0.015326783061027527, 0.036869022995233536, -0.03579488396644592, 0.09071236103773117, -0.0252535417675972, -0.03249366953969002, -0.009316486306488514, -0.027256540954113007, 0.005103124305605888, -0.057636767625808716, -0.03604850172996521, -0.03775496035814285, -0.061618056148290634, 0.06229887157678604, 0.056571654975414276, 0.029981693252921104, -0.029610496014356613, 0.02761472389101982, -0.009573581628501415, -0.013777827844023705, -0.02078218385577202, 0.016882194206118584, -0.05661048740148544, -0.012826479971408844, -0.02852272056043148, 0.02026989497244358, -0.05568229407072067, -0.06670607626438141, -0.0311784278601408, 0.024344436824321747, 0.03248289227485657, 0.033822912722826004, 0.12330296635627747, 0.008814390748739243, 0.011092904023826122, -0.011442062444984913, 0.0665283128619194, -0.006025173235684633, -0.02315385639667511, -0.011703678406774998, 0.02310883440077305, 0.038020942360162735, -0.006967456545680761, -0.041252732276916504, -0.016878871247172356, 0.08217836171388626, 0.025264766067266464, 0.010267669335007668, -0.036674220114946365, -0.012932333163917065, -0.021131183952093124, -0.04569120705127716, -0.06400764733552933, -0.03405320271849632, -0.007622820325195789, 0.055340398102998734, 0.0018525444902479649, -0.0447363555431366, 0.041226282715797424, 0.02272682636976242, -0.009476115927100182, 0.014166547916829586, 0.043194934725761414, 0.012403897009789944, -0.006842382717877626, -0.0040819644927978516, -0.034007202833890915, -0.03414148464798927, 0.03115929290652275, 0.010869670659303665, -0.025849150493741035, -0.06000044569373131, -0.02517576515674591, -0.004069182090461254, -0.035795293748378754, 0.008685646578669548, -0.04672854766249657, -0.004492504056543112, 0.009622607380151749, 0.03983215615153313, 0.009544978849589825, -0.03931817784905434, -0.055156853049993515, -0.0000573198776692152, 0.05671577528119087, 0.012065188959240913, 0.008013731800019741, -0.028550563380122185, 0.0016654296778142452, -0.006150060798972845, -0.004646181594580412, 0.053118158131837845, -0.010141788981854916, 0.0023946103174239397, -0.011616019532084465, -0.0028735895175486803, 0.052805304527282715, 0.02223513275384903, 0.012525432743132114, -0.033855170011520386, 0.005009740591049194, -0.0344492569565773, -0.006095091812312603, -0.032268982380628586, 0.06486047804355621, 0.01743430644273758, -0.014409100636839867, 0.07532842457294464, 0.011941606178879738, -0.0010325509356334805, 0.03486672788858414, 0.00885857455432415, -0.05883513763546944, -0.03718730807304382, -0.034319959580898285, 0.0206937063485384, -0.012586357071995735, 0.011569914408028126, -0.0019905378576368093, -0.015295956283807755, -0.06369990855455399, -0.0077574183233082294, 0.0032755634747445583, 0.0377216674387455, 0.049187809228897095, -0.040903739631175995, 0.034248530864715576, 0.02753969095647335, -0.04242956265807152, 0.018327688798308372, -0.04470648244023323, -0.05588749051094055, -0.043347250670194626, 0.0025635145138949156, -0.012575807049870491, -0.02116592600941658, -0.02599659189581871, 0.013564861379563808, 0.03545157238841057, 0.008036834187805653, -0.0358942449092865, -0.013277760706841946, -0.050356119871139526, -0.030486946925520897, -0.003634076565504074, 0.01364745944738388, -0.017574332654476166, -0.003967476077377796, -0.022303976118564606, 0.014798502437770367, 0.014177651144564152, 0.004510097671300173, 0.08424606174230576, -0.04733123257756233, -0.042065802961587906, -0.0391877181828022, 0.019597264006733894, 0.008879068307578564, -0.03772313892841339, 0.03837418183684349, 0.06099705770611763, 0.005004317034035921, -0.04177877679467201, -0.0014974031364545226, 0.002719922922551632, 0.041443832218647, -0.04651802033185959, -0.010074973106384277, 0.0038544395938515663, -0.028159214183688164, -0.017671484500169754, -0.027407480403780937, 0.016120288521051407, -0.03676321357488632, -0.017657725140452385, -0.054294899106025696, -0.03828774020075798, 0.006447168067097664, -0.00007618968083988875, -0.009220657870173454, -0.02171502634882927, 0.011503481306135654, -0.013968328945338726, 0.02972584217786789, -0.019571686163544655, -0.03708292916417122, 0.009428105317056179, -0.03505051136016846, -0.001769925351254642, 0.04621197655797005, 0.0075788339599967, 0.005170940421521664, -0.0021441576536744833, 0.04346189275383949, -0.0020185112953186035, -0.001011467189528048, -0.024632051587104797, -0.02519347332417965, -0.0196114182472229, 0.013942369259893894, 0.06958980858325958, 0.04266028478741646, -0.03681567683815956, -0.030148137360811234, 0.0008957004174590111, -0.017776500433683395, 0.022997403517365456, -0.020108766853809357, -0.0260568056255579, -0.01582515798509121, -0.06517916917800903, 0.033171381801366806, 0.0016068662516772747, -0.06172984465956688, -0.03666526451706886, 0.07709933817386627, 0.03678223490715027, -0.00873785000294447, -0.011355561204254627, -0.008890850469470024, -0.024386869743466377, -0.06044936925172806, 0.023330016061663628, -0.04008295014500618, 0.09149373322725296, -0.009385519661009312, 0.028359487652778625, -0.02299788035452366, 0.01695195958018303, -0.008511597290635109, 0.06268103420734406, 0.004476516507565975, 0.007971744984388351, 0.007736210711300373, 0.04529646039009094, -0.007417736575007439, -0.020260890945792198, -0.0020199213176965714, 0.0066460114903748035, -0.0015930957160890102, -0.03265690430998802, -0.024035386741161346, 0.026033440604805946, 0.02780877612531185, 0.0027217452879995108, 0.000428878323873505, -0.01449665054678917, -0.10609938204288483, -0.03016316518187523, -0.02635781094431877, -0.07738319039344788, -0.023764466866850853, 0.003915221896022558, -0.024015042930841446, -0.03264579549431801, -0.009765160270035267, -0.029971512034535408, 0.015286928042769432, -0.025395913049578667, -0.011036960408091545, 0.05135826766490936, 0.014296185225248337, 0.008770564571022987, 0.0001637469104025513, 0.01858154498040676, 0.0062567926943302155, -0.00543369073420763, 0.0012528192019090056, 0.03970007970929146, -0.01622375287115574, -0.02767990529537201, 0.03954393416643143, 0.007108643651008606, -0.03733754903078079, -0.007124957162886858, 0.059048257768154144, -0.010291021317243576, -0.021103307604789734, -0.06412387639284134, 0.044967908412218094, -0.013924863189458847, 0.001215255120769143, 0.002873421646654606, -0.0416407510638237, 0.010127143003046513, 0.06535748392343521, 0.09054718166589737, -0.04357318580150604, 0.05048181116580963, 0.014816037379205227, -0.022889813408255577, -0.044640641659498215, -0.03199826180934906, -0.01828835904598236, -0.040073782205581665, 0.024779444560408592, -0.03782283887267113, -0.028043130412697792, 0.03996207192540169, -0.05187464877963066, 0.019461093470454216, -0.013827391900122166, -0.01144155953079462, -0.06648711115121841, 0.007388832047581673, 0.00869753398001194, 0.018156155943870544, -0.04669872671365738, 0.00254345522262156, -0.012269473634660244, -0.005856987554579973, 0.021257847547531128, -0.049438945949077606, -0.004328104667365551, -0.014540668576955795, -0.053808704018592834, 0.0128166563808918, -0.03345569968223572, -0.031480155885219574, -0.04512527957558632, 0.013199505396187305, 0.037220798432826996, 0.0015506013296544552, 0.022935865446925163, -0.0413467139005661, 0.008836448192596436, 0.0008437578217126429, -0.04655052721500397, -0.03622070699930191, 0.0030156581196933985, -0.038060277700424194, -0.006677804049104452, 0.042835962027311325, -0.06806183606386185, -0.002015631878748536, 0.02104957215487957, -0.004539807327091694, -0.06954114884138107, -0.01693529635667801, 0.02405041642487049, 0.05031175538897514, -0.027956321835517883, 0.022098546847701073, -0.01437641866505146, 0.02470748871564865, 0.05098101124167442, -0.02988102100789547, 0.02703382819890976, 0.03928249329328537, -0.06945550441741943, 0.032075587660074234, 0.028769154101610184, 0.002401737030595541, -0.008668536320328712, 0.05190965533256531 ]
<p>There is quite some content online interpreting odds in a logistic model with a dichotomous predictor. My problem is understanding coefficients when there are more than 2 levels for a categorical variable. How do you <em>define the odds</em> then?</p> <pre><code>Data: X is a single categorical predictor with 4 levels: teenager, adult, mature, senior. Y: 1=smoking, 0=non smoking. LR: We use n-1 dummy variables. I chose adult as the reference bin as it had the highest concentration. (ok??) ________ | Intercepts | p adult | -4.3801 | 0 teenager | -0.32456 | 0 mature | 1.45119 | 0 old | -0.9891 | 0 </code></pre> <p><strong>Interpreting the coefficients</strong></p> <p>Teenager: Teen is less likely to smoke (w.r.t adult?). In fact, a teen is 28% (exp-0.32456 -1) less likely to smoke THAN AN ADULT. Is odds of teenager smoking always mentioned against the reference group?</p> <p>Mature: Matures is more to smoke (w.r.t adult?). In fact, a mature is 326% more likely to smoke THAN AN ADULT. Is odds of mature smoking always mentioned against the reference group? </p>
g33684
[ -0.03429447114467621, -0.04076581820845604, -0.008390828967094421, -0.0006510213133879006, 0.015057431533932686, -0.049089305102825165, 0.021010419353842735, 0.05481993407011032, -0.04807616025209427, -0.028170954436063766, -0.039349593222141266, -0.004547438584268093, 0.07509733736515045, 0.00718287006020546, 0.010772846639156342, 0.024138517677783966, 0.06294161081314087, -0.006604318972676992, 0.02050061523914337, -0.015352648682892323, -0.030295301228761673, 0.040902912616729736, 0.003461764194071293, -0.061162229627370834, -0.005313074681907892, -0.0527544729411602, 0.048491574823856354, 0.055240288376808167, -0.11609386652708054, 0.058734994381666183, -0.007964780554175377, 0.05858343467116356, 0.0637403056025505, -0.01618301495909691, -0.024759147316217422, -0.020717546343803406, 0.03354352340102196, -0.0033840020187199116, -0.00851585902273655, 0.0112742455676198, 0.01648344099521637, 0.06609012931585312, -0.00671347975730896, 0.040067438036203384, -0.07766904681921005, 0.03545694425702095, -0.025547700002789497, 0.022754164412617683, 0.04921469837427139, -0.04522530734539032, -0.00812210701406002, 0.018126215785741806, 0.008710199035704136, 0.008903252892196178, 0.03439589962363243, 0.02951417863368988, 0.014318865723907948, 0.019496344029903412, -0.006259072106331587, 0.03210251405835152, 0.04566461965441704, 0.010618184693157673, -0.007207321934401989, 0.005981257651001215, 0.012144415639340878, 0.054712098091840744, -0.0713837742805481, -0.01513703539967537, 0.04165568947792053, -0.014789586886763573, 0.06961145251989365, -0.016850028187036514, 0.008869391866028309, -0.05173265188932419, -0.014205227605998516, -0.09346158802509308, 0.0005613084067590535, 0.027367686852812767, 0.04520280659198761, 0.011695734225213528, 0.05058595538139343, 0.052390776574611664, 0.047667015343904495, 0.07141628861427307, -0.013235429301857948, 0.011336715891957283, 0.00525582255795598, 0.025807248428463936, 0.03474298119544983, -0.019830403849482536, 0.023479845374822617, 0.03631893917918205, 0.05798051506280899, 0.05417805537581444, 0.01147593092173338, -0.028609320521354675, -0.03479556366801262, 0.006331142038106918, -0.02257644385099411, -0.03106788545846939, -0.022172298282384872, 0.03164156898856163, -0.013418410904705524, 0.024858830496668816, -0.06022327020764351, 0.012239719741046429, 0.03995199128985405, -0.025274040177464485, -0.010133198462426662, -0.01753714494407177, -0.07034529000520706, 0.09242338687181473, -0.06543422490358353, -0.045639052987098694, -0.026092398911714554, -0.03318735212087631, 0.028603240847587585, -0.0296629648655653, 0.013866493478417397, -0.05735339969396591, 0.019071422517299652, 0.0003659482463262975, 0.02372235618531704, 0.045105379074811935, -0.040008071810007095, -0.04587089270353317, -0.04125291481614113, 0.07401919364929199, 0.021877199411392212, -0.05888419598340988, -0.0033230516128242016, -0.0059275636449456215, 0.04766993224620819, 0.03758407384157181, 0.030018799006938934, 0.025168510153889656, 0.0007954648463055491, 0.06610939651727676, -0.026295900344848633, 0.027551788836717606, 0.02026519365608692, 0.050867676734924316, 0.05667218193411827, -0.06478045880794525, -0.06324813514947891, -0.01386339869350195, 0.043920330703258514, -0.04690839722752571, -0.014113926328718662, -0.03162300959229469, 0.008129128254950047, 0.005239950492978096, -0.031723733991384506, 0.007358317729085684, -0.023859137669205666, 0.03290938213467598, -0.05059737339615822, -0.03887748718261719, -0.0243243295699358, 0.03807489201426506, 0.022573942318558693, -0.03151514381170273, -0.02592569775879383, 0.02858848311007023, -0.020527049899101257, 0.00003436221959418617, 0.013465183787047863, -0.047857578843832016, -0.0592501275241375, 0.016428392380475998, -0.033980827778577805, -0.00003239230500184931, -0.0022822702303528786, -0.04319619759917259, 0.08646927773952484, 0.03077167086303234, 0.05486490949988365, 0.004359718412160873, 0.009933937340974808, 0.04679490998387337, -0.024675101041793823, -0.0013910771813243628, -0.005420382134616375, 0.01981942169368267, 0.014671334065496922, -0.08897504955530167, -0.05642186105251312, 0.040923189371824265, -0.06217255815863609, 0.038742467761039734, -0.021185409277677536, 0.009064577519893646, 0.008057485334575176, -0.02042095735669136, -0.02119101956486702, -0.030531996861100197, 0.013508290983736515, -0.03270646184682846, 0.031141865998506546, -0.0465552844107151, -0.02551397681236267, 0.001663518138229847, -0.03340645506978035, 0.0737430602312088, 0.007352801505476236, 0.04349755868315697, -0.046224020421504974, 0.024583544582128525, -0.0412704199552536, -0.04334477335214615, 0.003989613149315119, -0.010528426617383957, -0.048942744731903076, 0.03757120668888092, 0.0339960902929306, -0.07850562781095505, 0.017141634598374367, 0.025365527719259262, -0.04482525214552879, 0.011997148394584656, -0.007444565650075674, -0.044815775007009506, 0.0850943773984909, 0.026660706847906113, -0.01848156750202179, -0.008807758800685406, 0.046790167689323425, -0.0125298872590065, -0.015159627422690392, 0.06921672821044922, -0.007728879805654287, -0.009408995509147644, 0.02374032884836197, -0.03369516879320145, 0.0029261144809424877, -0.019731799140572548, 0.032298002392053604, 0.008489282801747322, 0.0065097687765955925, 0.01936146430671215, -0.0009177134488709271, 0.0396677628159523, 0.025823626667261124, 0.012516663409769535, 0.018064286559820175, -0.0360756553709507, 0.037570543587207794, -0.043774910271167755, -0.03000451624393463, 0.09924397617578506, -0.03138471022248268, 0.06588660180568695, -0.060291409492492676, -0.010645346716046333, -0.03024788200855255, -0.038970451802015305, -0.02467535063624382, 0.041171979159116745, -0.04276987165212631, -0.04938306659460068, 0.00611393665894866, -0.00941245537251234, -0.013718027621507645, -0.020679637789726257, -0.02726701647043228, -0.020086975768208504, 0.010613465681672096, -0.08656777441501617, 0.03440352529287338, -0.04265020787715912, -0.03904992714524269, 0.01024171058088541, -0.050071947276592255, -0.03137648478150368, 0.02989746443927288, 0.03403525426983833, -0.005567808169871569, 0.011454707011580467, -0.0000970391120063141, 0.02268393151462078, 0.015276563353836536, 0.0048561859875917435, 0.016963783651590347, 0.023673411458730698, 0.08930347859859467, 0.019535016268491745, 0.0777023434638977, 0.040372397750616074, -0.0017346568638458848, 0.054688114672899246, -0.02030893601477146, 0.010182274505496025, 0.005126372445374727, -0.006329485215246677, 0.05198176950216293, 0.0018604465294629335, 0.012178648263216019, -0.059521693736314774, 0.005002911202609539, -0.029383786022663116, 0.002646599430590868, 0.028487553820014, 0.00037144930684007704, -0.02627967670559883, 0.03375028073787689, -0.05974816903471947, -0.05725628510117531, -0.002321742009371519, 0.03560580685734749, -0.05184603109955788, -0.021335721015930176, -0.034037601202726364, -0.020054547116160393, 0.014852786436676979, -0.022962091490626335, 0.0010648631723597646, 0.004742070566862822, 0.0060335444286465645, 0.041886769235134125, -0.04058372974395752, 0.03307449072599411, 0.01876772753894329, 0.00841753650456667, 0.024076096713542938, -0.02611871436238289, -0.02346600778400898, -0.03872685134410858, 0.05455360934138298, -0.028533529490232468, -0.005311428569257259, 0.06391986459493637, 0.019448526203632355, -0.03198444843292236, 0.041841473430395126, -0.04595119506120682, -0.06325682997703552, -0.016721079126000404, -0.030202198773622513, -0.010375188663601875, -0.0425642654299736, 0.01640419289469719, -0.020968757569789886, 0.008772441186010838, -0.007308773696422577, -0.025517359375953674, 0.001071005710400641, -0.011950158514082432, 0.021660292521119118, 0.03714141994714737, 0.0068733119405806065, -0.018281735479831696, -0.004734678193926811, -0.025459805503487587, 0.02549344301223755, -0.019070392474532127, -0.009608462452888489, 0.06641015410423279, 0.0014326304662972689, -0.03629963472485542, 0.017621371895074844, -0.0026492378674447536, 0.01278761774301529, -0.04319680482149124, 0.029742540791630745, 0.03644261881709099, 0.02514147199690342, 0.047098077833652496, 0.03515714406967163, 0.04752776399254799, 0.004294833168387413, 0.045736536383628845, 0.018944278359413147, -0.021971561014652252, 0.03804575279355049, 0.0013748541241511703, -0.010294520296156406, 0.06020151823759079, -0.017278099432587624, 0.0104215731844306, -0.0009464845643378794, 0.06176008656620979, 0.002140917582437396, 0.03963342308998108, -0.015123676508665085, -0.011174984276294708, -0.05334727093577385, 0.021328439936041832, 0.014697227627038956, 0.00637985160574317, -0.05267072468996048, 0.01595010980963707, 0.023983754217624664, -0.045778125524520874, 0.08074099570512772, 0.04079803451895714, -0.0721224695444107, -0.02027103863656521, 0.012693849392235279, 0.02054799161851406, 0.013832316733896732, 0.0050360169261693954, 0.01476177666336298, 0.022542575374245644, 0.04533551260828972, -0.05465269088745117, -0.007874015718698502, -0.006388401612639427, -0.03934044390916824, 0.023845357820391655, 0.008791492320597172, -0.00902578979730606, -0.014002468436956406, -0.044320229440927505, -0.04718853905797005, 0.03819649666547775, 0.005243993829935789, 0.12144723534584045, -0.029629085212945938, -0.025869213044643402, 0.0027862265706062317, 0.08329818397760391, 0.01751205138862133, -0.022421853616833687, -0.016132893040776253, -0.0012018709676340222, -0.0027420928236097097, 0.023405324667692184, -0.030813684687018394, 0.0047335573472082615, -0.0009778715902939439, 0.04745837673544884, 0.0005139997228980064, -0.03360819071531296, 0.004141815938055515, -0.0371832437813282, -0.006560309324413538, 0.003336213296279311, 0.02400708757340908, -0.007662474177777767, -0.003245645435526967, -0.03328856825828552, -0.029740041121840477, -0.02076870948076248, -0.004162732977420092, 0.023899784311652184, 0.014994014985859394, -0.01562296412885189, 0.006778631825000048, 0.055916380137205124, 0.03646906837821007, -0.010959811508655548, 0.01564401015639305, 0.018900174647569656, -0.012487722560763359, 0.03645304962992668, -0.05280134454369545, 0.06712254881858826, -0.00840245746076107, 0.0198016706854105, 0.045931376516819, -0.03318917006254196, -0.0630769208073616, -0.03321997821331024, -0.014815897680819035, -0.007570019923150539, -0.014226705767214298, -0.0392351932823658, 0.0005611394881270826, 0.06467143446207047, 0.032678425312042236, -0.018680935725569725, -0.02077074907720089, -0.02443910390138626, -0.04829913005232811, 0.03190179169178009, 0.08840443193912506, -0.027972837910056114, -0.002673560054972768, -0.014473721385002136, 0.03717928007245064, -0.058390069752931595, 0.021551009267568588, 0.034412603825330734, -0.019797204062342644, -0.043187376111745834, -0.008448460139334202, 0.002998877549543977, -0.03937610238790512, 0.009733593091368675, 0.012230097316205502, -0.016882264986634254, 0.04248796030879021, 0.017478065565228462, 0.04115736111998558, -0.05887451022863388, -0.006359823048114777, 0.025852572172880173, -0.0021156801376491785, 0.019731270149350166, -0.004755196627229452, -0.014384817332029343, 0.029394488781690598, 0.04614084213972092, -0.04811416566371918, -0.004585593938827515, 0.0073323664255440235, 0.03645100072026253, -0.034396637231111526, 0.0056900824420154095, 0.04713776335120201, -0.03289862349629402, 0.056864675134420395, 0.005689129699021578, -0.009725033305585384, -0.031167976558208466, -0.0013405665522441268, 0.007020804565399885, 0.07853098958730698, -0.007200316060334444, 0.016195878386497498, 0.07930175215005875, 0.00023310832330025733, 0.00029917198116891086, 0.013719994574785233, -0.04758636653423309, -0.046677812933921814, -0.0189458467066288, -0.08264867216348648, 0.03183625265955925, -0.008503015153110027, 0.030067913234233856, 0.019652416929602623, 0.010424523614346981, -0.005253777839243412, 0.006311254575848579, -0.01346325408667326, -0.04820223152637482, 0.01480906642973423, -0.027587765827775, -0.007901015691459179, -0.04121425747871399, -0.019878407940268517, 0.028517872095108032, -0.019566841423511505, 0.0651027262210846, -0.01750209555029869, -0.031578052788972855, -0.02399194985628128, -0.0019281678833067417, -0.027443455532193184, -0.0021293601021170616, 0.006298535969108343, -0.00876266323029995, 0.013127172365784645, -0.007331586442887783, -0.004605753347277641, 0.023896226659417152, -0.020041439682245255, 0.01933015137910843, 0.011913209222257137, -0.07138807326555252, 0.05282865837216377, -0.015101437456905842, -0.0059581296518445015, -0.0029318444430828094, -0.045679040253162384, -0.03653876855969429, -0.038310568779706955, 0.000008773810804996174, 0.006607149261981249, 0.0012301652459427714, -0.02779703214764595, 0.08132433891296387, 0.06087712571024895, -0.0047098672948777676, 0.007737327832728624, -0.015163775533437729, 0.018951427191495895, 0.05154174193739891, 0.011445598676800728, 0.006693716626614332, -0.03264245763421059, -0.006420458201318979, 0.01599234901368618, -0.04562655836343765, 0.028064990416169167, -0.03490132838487625, -0.015594400465488434, -0.034599002450704575, -0.02691311202943325, 0.031446512788534164, -0.011427115648984909, -0.002240631263703108, -0.016055233776569366, -0.072458915412426, 0.01602034457027912, 0.004422217141836882, 0.05081487447023392, -0.053339891135692596, -0.09643696993589401, 0.030384384095668793, -0.02716827765107155, -0.002421086886897683, -0.000007457598258042708, 0.015710333362221718, 0.003429794916883111, -0.04864221438765526, 0.009459637105464935, -0.023184841498732567, 0.013128022663295269, -0.0422830693423748, 0.022074248641729355, 0.03978412225842476, 0.022502772510051727, 0.03493029251694679, -0.0006068014772608876, -0.09179621189832687, 0.04098452627658844, -0.029718982055783272, 0.01569289341568947, 0.039126377552747726, -0.048145074397325516, 0.047843437641859055, -0.02117871306836605, 0.0015435825334861875, 0.036164261400699615, -0.004124915227293968, -0.024040691554546356, 0.026386724784970284, -0.0053808968514204025, 0.00905289314687252, -0.005978429690003395, 0.041869401931762695, -0.006095102522522211, -0.004881799686700106, 0.028043758124113083, -0.04461735486984253, 0.03851205110549927, -0.004744519013911486, 0.045909494161605835, -0.0011558489641174674, 0.02966778539121151, -0.014483955688774586, 0.04853355139493942, 0.03543476387858391, -0.033890340477228165, 0.07188383489847183, 0.0008628432988189161, -0.04655078426003456, -0.03600054606795311, 0.044951338320970535, -0.014405113644897938, 0.029855597764253616, -0.02070697583258152, 0.01522023044526577, 0.023014815524220467, 0.07414700090885162, 0.03299599885940552, 0.04402432218194008, 0.007470488082617521, -0.020914379507303238, -0.0485522598028183, -0.06579817831516266, 0.007415402214974165, -0.01863713748753071, 0.05509933456778526, 0.02849985845386982, -0.03409590572118759, -0.08257916569709778, -0.04831947386264801, -0.045864496380090714, -0.06205550953745842, -0.050222791731357574, -0.009476927109062672, -0.029613077640533447, -0.028898026794195175, -0.03782473877072334, 0.03196852281689644, -0.011671110056340694, -0.012904358096420765, -0.017685864120721817, 0.009339527226984501, -0.01091321837157011, 0.03022642433643341, 0.012717695906758308, 0.010311487130820751, 0.012525771744549274, -0.0251158457249403, 0.019452543929219246, -0.029955869540572166, -0.01675952412188053, -0.09230223298072815, 0.05222117528319359, -0.004225309006869793, -0.050478484481573105, 0.025365278124809265, -0.023150527849793434, 0.05342695862054825, 0.006012388970702887, 0.08150167763233185, 0.02628708817064762, 0.08385062962770462, -0.043501727283000946, -0.020083976909518242, 0.010976141318678856, -0.025498753413558006, -0.013820769265294075, -0.008528832346200943, -0.012236759066581726, -0.07889366149902344, -0.056732095777988434, 0.012306350283324718, -0.06405425071716309, -0.006951282732188702, -0.0197759959846735, -0.033137865364551544, -0.038613419979810715, -0.058709047734737396, 0.012304388917982578, 0.0683872252702713, -0.018663622438907623, -0.021531272679567337, -0.020229022949934006, 0.05911548435688019, -0.01736314594745636, -0.09343893080949783, -0.01943858526647091, 0.056146394461393356, -0.017481815069913864, 0.012526570819318295, -0.05430369824171066, -0.046434734016656876, -0.07721087336540222, 0.03807419538497925, 0.027995390817523003, 0.008185770362615585, 0.006974068004637957, 0.04334873706102371, -0.014115703292191029, 0.004381646402180195, -0.034307390451431274, 0.008632565848529339, 0.031028881669044495, 0.05943145230412483, -0.03126141056418419, 0.02408468909561634, -0.0012724961852654815, 0.007242982741445303, -0.017365392297506332, 0.028125517070293427, 0.004267809446901083, 0.017110923305153847, 0.017868198454380035, 0.06948111951351166, 0.048501353710889816, -0.021257029846310616, 0.006120762787759304, -0.029942935332655907, -0.009036057628691196, -0.04778998717665672, -0.02270159311592579, 0.026091458275914192, -0.025612110272049904, 0.027121122926473618, 0.009946918115019798, -0.03672446683049202, -0.09196116030216217, 0.06601423025131226 ]
<p>Let's say you have $X$ coins, each with a differing probability of landing heads (e.g. coin 1 has 10% chance of landing heads, coin 2 has 20% chance of landing heads, etc.).</p> <p>Now, let's say that you flip coin $i$ coin $Y_i$ times (each coin has a differing amount of flips). We know how many times each coin was flipped.</p> <p>Now let's say you do this every day for a really long time and record that info. Example, with 2 coins, on day 1: 50 flips total, 30 heads total, coin1 was flipped 20 times and coin2 flipped 30 times. Day 2: 80 flips, 66 heads total, coin1 60 flips, coin2 20 flips.</p> <p>What we know: total flips, total heads, how many times each coin was flipped.</p> <p>Given that, is there a way to determine an approximate probability that the given coin will flip heads? In the above example, coin1 has a 100% probability of heads and coin2 has a 33% probability.</p>
g74044
[ -0.027769505977630615, 0.029932653531432152, -0.007650383282452822, -0.03946410119533539, -0.006802715361118317, -0.024735622107982635, 0.034336794167757034, 0.012264946475625038, -0.06384679675102234, 0.023620836436748505, -0.013887270353734493, 0.0278675127774477, 0.04551326483488083, -0.02394208125770092, 0.011228526942431927, 0.025440499186515808, 0.05883104354143143, -0.029286084696650505, 0.035194966942071915, 0.05132531374692917, 0.03828907012939453, 0.006700178142637014, -0.028651315718889236, -0.0036711031571030617, -0.052867915481328964, -0.053180910646915436, -0.04620902240276337, -0.015635261312127113, -0.07678200304508209, 0.027506835758686066, -0.06507891416549683, 0.04227025434374809, 0.05201791226863861, 0.019923655316233635, -0.020072950050234795, -0.034172527492046356, 0.03168575093150139, -0.09355802088975906, 0.061535272747278214, 0.019909692928195, -0.021247345954179764, 0.009388383477926254, -0.002372961724177003, 0.029428953304886818, -0.02213142067193985, 0.009057772345840931, -0.012600159272551537, 0.015563021413981915, 0.021183397620916367, -0.07311036437749863, -0.020275520160794258, 0.051020924001932144, 0.05371060594916344, 0.026859823614358902, -0.026216642931103706, 0.02681455947458744, 0.028432371094822884, 0.01706814579665661, 0.010365037247538567, 0.012479698285460472, 0.07564797252416611, -0.07378445565700531, 0.01671762391924858, -0.00103097315877676, 0.009374033659696579, -0.005240240599960089, 0.02550019882619381, 0.023783951997756958, 0.012854552827775478, -0.018313881009817123, 0.0015361504629254341, 0.024652402848005295, 0.04547010734677315, -0.038292739540338516, -0.026958636939525604, 0.026584217324852943, 0.018930694088339806, 0.04000211879611015, -0.021371211856603622, 0.07707711309194565, -0.05869966000318527, -0.0008665602072142065, 0.039673175662755966, -0.005326726008206606, 0.04961366206407547, 0.03180573135614395, 0.01129133626818657, -0.022123822942376137, -0.03612039238214493, 0.009939370676875114, -0.017332373186945915, -0.0170443058013916, 0.07250239700078964, 0.05977553501725197, 0.01993279904127121, -0.006369553040713072, -0.03787319362163544, 0.04272463172674179, -0.015688639134168625, 0.06518552452325821, -0.007275631185621023, 0.01886788383126259, 0.02324521169066429, -0.00962843932211399, -0.03913299739360809, 0.007782095577567816, -0.0007821163744665682, 0.035185348242521286, 0.008671632967889309, -0.01585787907242775, -0.0026096468791365623, -0.0263019111007452, 0.028246596455574036, 0.0037884649354964495, 0.034696999937295914, 0.024077830836176872, 0.011914861388504505, 0.01952606998383999, -0.059950996190309525, 0.006505767814815044, -0.015578119084239006, -0.04190686345100403, -0.02868322841823101, 0.04140229523181915, -0.007358926814049482, 0.014011060819029808, -0.012653223238885403, 0.04086049646139145, 0.0416271798312664, 0.06434163451194763, -0.007452060468494892, 0.00644599087536335, 0.07782929390668869, 0.039578814059495926, 0.0012510661035776138, 0.004153449088335037, 0.03211921453475952, 0.058202266693115234, 0.03152981027960777, 0.043357860296964645, 0.004349810536950827, -0.018261075019836426, 0.036236368119716644, 0.011695216409862041, -0.0270694587379694, 0.01529584638774395, -0.008854157291352749, -0.043013691902160645, -0.02641938254237175, -0.031241554766893387, -0.012575825676321983, 0.009722044691443443, 0.07601035386323929, -0.013520940206944942, -0.01782803423702717, -0.018051739782094955, -0.049187663942575455, -0.04902450367808342, 0.001972756814211607, 0.050588458776474, 0.013404003344476223, -0.01913965307176113, -0.01709805615246296, 0.005890321917831898, 0.0021423005964607, 0.07469204068183899, -0.012267434038221836, -0.024688297882676125, -0.04842894896864891, 0.0022634947672486305, 0.02199259214103222, -0.007078635971993208, -0.005859591998159885, 0.0016659246757626534, 0.02192814275622368, 0.03960757702589035, 0.031962938606739044, 0.00869174674153328, 0.009951651096343994, 0.0488276481628418, 0.05429820343852043, 0.03339004889130592, -0.018860576674342155, 0.04538993909955025, 0.026839829981327057, 0.011943074874579906, 0.03256157413125038, -0.009732173755764961, -0.012252746149897575, -0.012348617427051067, 0.014420539140701294, 0.017406567931175232, -0.054352935403585434, -0.019654657691717148, -0.02378051169216633, -0.010777891613543034, 0.06134949252009392, -0.012248718179762363, 0.013449127785861492, -0.022111911326646805, 0.06066509336233139, 0.06177673116326332, -0.03232524171471596, -0.0004714148526545614, -0.04565251246094704, -0.006147655658423901, 0.0007215880905278027, 0.022696830332279205, -0.016232162714004517, 0.012764840386807919, 0.02914215810596943, 0.024898456409573555, -0.031217388808727264, 0.018920479342341423, 0.009624753147363663, 0.020371051505208015, 0.05849575251340866, 0.04786776751279831, 0.03482942283153534, -0.011191240511834621, 0.05258264020085335, 0.05371159687638283, 0.02956537716090679, 0.020888399332761765, 0.005348579958081245, 0.054887522011995316, 0.014798015356063843, 0.03742091357707977, 0.006120807491242886, 0.08304345607757568, -0.010866529308259487, 0.007643762975931168, -0.05163552239537239, -0.018521852791309357, 0.015425313264131546, 0.027368422597646713, 0.022960031405091286, 0.008274861611425877, 0.059151746332645416, 0.01250327005982399, -0.013119084760546684, 0.00477618956938386, -0.06709719449281693, -0.011615656316280365, -0.0364413745701313, -0.04125836491584778, -0.035321760922670364, -0.01833203062415123, 0.013970384374260902, 0.04649078845977783, -0.02042199671268463, 0.004992056172341108, -0.008741986937820911, -0.03294937685132027, 0.0148519491776824, -0.008135817013680935, -0.0006243986426852643, -0.024575861170887947, 0.030346019193530083, 0.05633166804909706, 0.03142065182328224, -0.026136048138141632, 0.06076817959547043, 0.030940929427742958, 0.013939948752522469, -0.04956767335534096, 0.019530652090907097, 0.009954611770808697, -0.013052830472588539, 0.025398781523108482, 0.005312774796038866, 0.0425134040415287, 0.013918489217758179, 0.0990629717707634, -0.003364359028637409, 0.02177911251783371, -0.018595734611153603, -0.06455394625663757, -0.01226656511425972, 0.016894780099391937, 0.009753696620464325, 0.012430423870682716, -0.03607722744345665, 0.020177112892270088, 0.047824427485466, -0.04434078186750412, 0.02570396289229393, -0.011025984771549702, 0.028586186468601227, 0.06590116024017334, 0.010608775541186333, 0.02176559902727604, 0.04582437127828598, -0.03393738716840744, -0.038171347230672836, 0.020034948363900185, 0.061344001442193985, -0.01055899914354086, -0.004046562127768993, 0.025861375033855438, -0.012458969838917255, 0.005456514190882444, -0.02876313589513302, 0.032042428851127625, 0.047351013869047165, 0.06022759899497032, 0.010032475925981998, 0.04677692800760269, 0.040175940841436386, -0.08610275387763977, 0.005678038578480482, 0.0199928916990757, 0.02307199127972126, -0.04068045690655708, -0.023139985278248787, -0.036643970757722855, 0.025058656930923462, 0.030580585822463036, -0.05993169918656349, -0.049646101891994476, 0.002982310252264142, 0.0046511488035321236, -0.02004370465874672, 0.04251427948474884, 0.040207039564847946, 0.036867305636405945, -0.11326971650123596, 0.008800835348665714, -0.025266943499445915, -0.029168864712119102, 0.02580057457089424, 0.013946997001767159, -0.01441706158220768, -0.05923870950937271, -0.022429415956139565, -0.03210015222430229, 0.06046237424015999, 0.01675826497375965, 0.01627800241112709, 0.06505294144153595, -0.009795671328902245, -0.010876757092773914, -0.04488031938672066, -0.042143888771533966, -0.006789138074964285, 0.017515329644083977, -0.01622162200510502, 0.04141739010810852, 0.041644949465990067, -0.043844014406204224, 0.024876484647393227, -0.058848049491643906, 0.00957230944186449, -0.005763423163443804, 0.05558828264474869, 0.03890790045261383, -0.022834764793515205, 0.028434161096811295, -0.008566264994442463, 0.0014675299171358347, -0.018378624692559242, 0.00026271562092006207, -0.024786897003650665, -0.00377641967497766, -0.007392852567136288, -0.07132919132709503, -0.0192234106361866, 0.011114666238427162, 0.00025649057351984084, -0.021208446472883224, -0.026903394609689713, 0.028568288311362267, 0.07076112926006317, -0.04161021485924721, 0.014193530194461346, -0.009616531431674957, 0.016460472717881203, 0.00795674417167902, 0.014958602376282215, 0.03473620489239693, 0.047149110585451126, 0.04899833723902702, 0.011838560923933983, -0.007389917504042387, -0.013355208560824394, 0.009356176480650902, -0.01124235987663269, -0.019446462392807007, -0.029447048902511597, -0.03374280780553818, -0.02304513193666935, -0.05093692988157272, -0.0135972173884511, 0.03985666111111641, 0.00039768771966919303, -0.03266134485602379, 0.010356519371271133, -0.01790577545762062, 0.02573584020137787, 0.015916787087917328, 0.0003546599473338574, 0.03488381579518318, 0.013420245610177517, 0.024588024243712425, 0.010379555635154247, 0.010173791088163853, -0.041793521493673325, -0.0014627857599407434, 0.003343042451888323, 0.04363447055220604, -0.01440322957932949, -0.0147103788331151, 0.009254387579858303, 0.015343434177339077, -0.019920459017157555, 0.005882566794753075, 0.05105389654636383, -0.054304033517837524, 0.02170916646718979, -0.04364853352308273, -0.03871683031320572, 0.006970454938709736, -0.023037631064653397, 0.004897932521998882, -0.05977128446102142, 0.014019645750522614, 0.06594672054052353, 0.039311692118644714, -0.014576048590242863, -0.05809101462364197, 0.03948172181844711, -0.003862507874146104, 0.024784591048955917, 0.00472245691344142, -0.051909592002630234, -0.06308890879154205, 0.022316336631774902, 0.0022259571123868227, 0.02936442755162716, -0.03619277477264404, -0.028229545801877975, -0.02834773249924183, -0.05705326050519943, 0.014500109478831291, 0.003666182979941368, 0.028670018538832664, -0.037789903581142426, -0.01928836666047573, 0.04981527477502823, -0.0066770464181900024, -0.057645466178655624, 0.005628976039588451, -0.02209920808672905, -0.0030045281164348125, 0.0034835569094866514, -0.024829361587762833, -0.029748449102044106, -0.012382722459733486, 0.024082886055111885, 0.046886809170246124, -0.01270417682826519, 0.014952030032873154, 0.0071631865575909615, -0.01934238150715828, -0.04503835365176201, 0.020969709381461143, 0.007219129707664251, -0.005673196632415056, -0.008112517185509205, -0.028147106990218163, -0.025910334661602974, 0.004020489286631346, 0.057681452482938766, 0.050938621163368225, -0.017743322998285294, -0.016634421423077583, -0.013367027044296265, -0.00297507643699646, 0.05575115233659744, -0.04106742888689041, -0.004131807945668697, -0.019802629947662354, -0.007858585566282272, 0.027514951303601265, -0.05803496018052101, 0.005738161038607359, 0.009969507344067097, -0.036922842264175415, 0.026369262486696243, -0.029986105859279633, -0.019374530762434006, -0.06553038954734802, 0.044713620096445084, -0.030149372294545174, -0.0568995326757431, -0.056312575936317444, -0.02032335102558136, 0.02170388400554657, -0.05941179022192955, -0.006471898872405291, -0.0587298683822155, 0.05569252371788025, 0.003175318008288741, -0.01910373941063881, -0.024391144514083862, 0.02626832202076912, 0.013056188821792603, -0.013609141111373901, -0.025465227663517, 0.0900472104549408, -0.06599768251180649, -0.031066525727510452, 0.03183164447546005, 0.02889370732009411, -0.024988727644085884, -0.003039866453036666, -0.036362722516059875, 0.016832852736115456, -0.019019629806280136, -0.013243657536804676, 0.08371182531118393, 0.009145213291049004, 0.03146234527230263, 0.00911964662373066, -0.008912144228816032, -0.10898919403553009, -0.0765191987156868, -0.0785277932882309, -0.019567282870411873, -0.026000458747148514, 0.046527475118637085, 0.016272608190774918, -0.043600209057331085, -0.05597228556871414, -0.0821499302983284, -0.01022257935255766, 0.028531700372695923, -0.04670490697026253, 0.005843117833137512, 0.016242465004324913, 0.05586935207247734, 0.01514493115246296, 0.024844639003276825, 0.025455893948674202, -0.023188550025224686, -0.054270561784505844, 0.002385173225775361, -0.03175581246614456, -0.022807423025369644, -0.04149197041988373, 0.004663995001465082, 0.07762344926595688, 0.002064695116132498, 0.03204376995563507, -0.03156184405088425, 0.039223529398441315, -0.008744856342673302, 0.023143727332353592, -0.003618489718064666, 0.01532535720616579, 0.05194666236639023, -0.04121013730764389, 0.0505007728934288, 0.03830679506063461, 0.03110636956989765, 0.032912153750658035, -0.08980630338191986, -0.03814922273159027, -0.04450060427188873, 0.08792629837989807, 0.0013707526959478855, 0.020864136517047882, -0.014214375987648964, -0.06291591376066208, 0.02607610635459423, 0.01773771271109581, -0.00954285915941, -0.06504862755537033, 0.011092962697148323, -0.04378654062747955, -0.048114337027072906, -0.06900476664304733, -0.03666491433978081, 0.0020367566030472517, -0.029511284083127975, 0.027309903874993324, -0.015460900962352753, 0.048540495336055756, -0.028204038739204407, 0.006070451810956001, -0.028496695682406425, -0.0028463290072977543, 0.02106311358511448, -0.0610419437289238, -0.0348648764193058, 0.049472954124212265, -0.037584371864795685, -0.016005167737603188, -0.016322048380970955, -0.04675517603754997, 0.0127405421808362, -0.03286679461598396, 0.05245186761021614, 0.023188209161162376, -0.0269155353307724, 0.055148251354694366, -0.03689054772257805, 0.01246721763163805, 0.010500426404178143, -0.01836061291396618, 0.023300528526306152, -0.013860350474715233, -0.016646577045321465, 0.09807571023702621, -0.07716923952102661, 0.019358674064278603, 0.017800284549593925, 0.016142500564455986, -0.03722776472568512, 0.004064157139509916, 0.07414441555738449, 0.006709746550768614, -0.026143813505768776, 0.020469864830374718, -0.01679421216249466, 0.04369419440627098, 0.015923619270324707, -0.03826185315847397, -0.011105716228485107, -0.008403296582400799, 0.07117821276187897, 0.008981775492429733, -0.006522465497255325, 0.036813706159591675, -0.03495347127318382, 0.0336274579167366, -0.01860574632883072, 0.024083444848656654, -0.06223371624946594, 0.027880674228072166, -0.02596391551196575, 0.0044193509966135025, -0.010536112822592258, 0.08847349882125854, -0.033169761300086975, -0.059002142399549484, 0.0014275569701567292, 0.01617557182908058, -0.000985124264843762, 0.014745591208338737, 0.010731659829616547, -0.041668906807899475, -0.025803139433264732, 0.010613790713250637, -0.010207656770944595, 0.05384407937526703, 0.06958384066820145, -0.039147090166807175, -0.06516838818788528, -0.016355067491531372, -0.060701701790094376, -0.07828914374113083, -0.07308460772037506, -0.06463528424501419, -0.03683493286371231, 0.003300843294709921, -0.01042203325778246, -0.041425783187150955, -0.025700319558382034, -0.0749443843960762, 0.008608023636043072, -0.03716686740517616, -0.11247798800468445, 0.0343979075551033, 0.009990460239350796, -0.037916067987680435, -0.01580941118299961, 0.017978189513087273, 0.014222278259694576, 0.02167963981628418, 0.023050788789987564, 0.010494692251086235, -0.04309207573533058, 0.014538172632455826, 0.04322164133191109, 0.025469809770584106, -0.05225642770528793, -0.0474085696041584, 0.013991099782288074, 0.007515834178775549, -0.03889630734920502, -0.09114298969507217, 0.026172755286097527, 0.019584501162171364, -0.021952856332063675, 0.04170363023877144, 0.06691297143697739, -0.0034325302112847567, 0.008418946526944637, 0.09178421646356583, 0.033413760364055634, 0.06596708297729492, 0.03922807797789574, -0.012997782789170742, -0.038933008909225464, -0.041867077350616455, 0.02948075160384178, 0.024195609614253044, -0.008986793458461761, -0.05142857879400253, 0.028283100575208664, -0.004677631892263889, 0.014463852159678936, -0.034058213233947754, -0.03598852828145027, -0.030321164056658745, -0.1073026955127716, -0.015085937455296516, 0.015165944583714008, 0.03866047039628029, -0.03240722417831421, 0.008488194085657597, -0.02168954350054264, 0.042737726122140884, 0.03347558528184891, -0.07473471760749817, -0.06340848654508591, 0.012826556339859962, -0.005132627207785845, 0.02083565853536129, 0.002516420092433691, -0.04766382649540901, -0.07187128812074661, -0.030258813872933388, 0.06104419380426407, -0.002777741989120841, 0.008750827983021736, 0.027168434113264084, -0.03660789504647255, -0.005468574818223715, -0.07871437817811966, -0.06020384654402733, 0.019099613651633263, 0.002792804269120097, -0.049385230988264084, -0.005676562432199717, 0.010501911863684654, 0.015904098749160767, 0.0037331811618059874, -0.043936848640441895, -0.050279270857572556, 0.027197444811463356, -0.031178252771496773, 0.06847251206636429, 0.03614114969968796, 0.03686375170946121, -0.008334877900779247, 0.021751979365944862, -0.03396538272500038, 0.006415674928575754, -0.026915377005934715, -0.028893012553453445, -0.03489643335342407, 0.030014123767614365, -0.01810874231159687, -0.0049003311432898045, -0.0375540517270565, 0.007786824367940426 ]
<p>Is it plausible to have a positive coefficient with a negative marginal / impact effect after running multinomial logit model?</p>
g1031
[ -0.056883808225393295, 0.013365798629820347, -0.010547065176069736, -0.00635323952883482, -0.017108622938394547, -0.02608051896095276, -0.01966220885515213, -0.021481087431311607, -0.007434428203850985, 0.0035412192810326815, -0.019297828897833824, 0.01863904669880867, 0.05805642902851105, -0.026747187599539757, -0.00042565332842059433, 0.0038583821151405573, 0.05663241073489189, 0.030621884390711784, 0.005829980596899986, 0.04538673162460327, -0.053815409541130066, 0.034746360033750534, -0.08258729428052902, -0.008529460988938808, 0.020241571590304375, -0.014747820794582367, 0.029887154698371887, 0.02220943383872509, -0.02640230767428875, 0.01483091153204441, 0.018409037962555885, 0.01852894015610218, -0.02529059909284115, -0.05046803504228592, -0.1239912360906601, 0.05582249537110329, -0.0093797342851758, 0.006694746669381857, -0.005146194715052843, -0.008712933398783207, 0.01820686273276806, -0.013302731327712536, 0.010396367870271206, -0.01379137858748436, -0.038899410516023636, 0.03419976308941841, 0.027508845552802086, 0.017918972298502922, -0.01570141315460205, -0.03284236416220665, 0.01716991513967514, -0.013571243733167648, 0.01082004513591528, 0.004311367869377136, 0.014362582936882973, 0.053855959326028824, 0.009568317793309689, 0.001180186285637319, -0.017715664580464363, 0.000016963451344054192, -0.00032835450838319957, -0.005066399462521076, -0.009489541873335838, 0.002034513046965003, 0.013480007648468018, -0.028725307434797287, -0.023348737508058548, -0.017822183668613434, 0.03629101812839508, 0.018475588411092758, 0.02642127498984337, 0.08973725885152817, 0.010723776184022427, -0.004524423740804195, 0.00933159701526165, 0.08505162596702576, 0.014531855471432209, 0.009471379220485687, -0.017859268933534622, 0.008629517629742622, -0.023584632202982903, -0.017614087089896202, 0.06367192417383194, 0.053559958934783936, -0.043027736246585846, -0.033132150769233704, 0.05440386384725571, -0.027562061324715614, 0.00305184512399137, -0.045329272747039795, 0.018220627680420876, 0.010040126740932465, -0.04917474091053009, 0.06897501647472382, -0.026987463235855103, -0.004153777379542589, 0.010959667153656483, 0.0012529502855613828, 0.01478011254221201, -0.015502102673053741, 0.02190251462161541, 0.03545509651303291, -0.0268784761428833, -0.014706774614751339, -0.02076582796871662, 0.01600481942296028, -0.04404348507523537, -0.0015411520143970847, 0.03736337646842003, 0.020334219560027122, -0.024394778534770012, 0.019974995404481888, -0.0647578164935112, -0.05223536491394043, 0.007422978524118662, -0.0701628178358078, 0.0073521812446415424, -0.0281202495098114, -0.05446275323629379, 0.011281140148639679, -0.0199954342097044, 0.0025522576179355383, 0.030082615092396736, 0.017883654683828354, -0.027804898098111153, -0.029721194878220558, -0.019162695854902267, 0.0684707760810852, 0.023182276636362076, 0.00891164131462574, 0.03719523176550865, -0.02338407002389431, 0.027660703286528587, 0.05590076744556427, 0.023934833705425262, 0.005325615871697664, -0.011653659865260124, 0.07797694206237793, -0.011897217482328415, 0.04987243562936783, -0.031292956322431564, 0.008539926260709763, -0.01314686331897974, 0.012890026904642582, -0.010300816036760807, 0.003625237848609686, 0.05500652641057968, 0.019647138193249702, 0.0051065776497125626, 0.006089906673878431, 0.031005382537841797, -0.023557843640446663, -0.04045712575316429, 0.0007928815321065485, 0.0010083616944029927, 0.06093892827630043, -0.032369013875722885, -0.011552990414202213, -0.025590628385543823, 0.0004373512347228825, 0.023410234600305557, -0.04184206202626228, 0.024766262620687485, 0.004450060892850161, -0.06297332048416138, 0.029244594275951385, 0.014321437105536461, -0.0337677001953125, -0.013969731517136097, 0.027191994711756706, 0.011639509350061417, -0.027605559676885605, -0.0024649857077747583, -0.0586625337600708, 0.012666398659348488, 0.023932281881570816, -0.05873037874698639, 0.00793689675629139, 0.035577964037656784, 0.022292781621217728, -0.0651511698961258, 0.0038866987451910973, -0.024318736046552658, -0.05962615832686424, 0.03148956969380379, -0.07496210187673569, -0.04348795861005783, 0.10003836452960968, -0.0342300646007061, 0.014698509126901627, 0.06406823545694351, 0.05369718372821808, 0.04431963711977005, -0.03935473412275314, -0.0016738828271627426, -0.0862354263663292, 0.01585349813103676, -0.020796243101358414, 0.0036585377529263496, -0.0664139911532402, 0.017095841467380524, 0.04145033285021782, 0.029898587614297867, -0.005282593425363302, -0.06629025936126709, -0.03553878143429756, 0.024073315784335136, -0.010103896260261536, 0.06008215248584747, -0.05110009387135506, -0.0218657273799181, -0.046949777752161026, -0.07320921123027802, 0.022428041324019432, 0.0011045153951272368, -0.021536624059081078, -0.0376608707010746, 0.013475334271788597, -0.027746571227908134, -0.029272332787513733, -0.02011587657034397, -0.011398223228752613, 0.032027821987867355, 0.024809449911117554, 0.005736655090004206, 0.03274811431765556, 0.07449355721473694, -0.04925641790032387, -0.0483974814414978, -0.0011176379630342126, -0.0761437863111496, -0.018892347812652588, 0.03056221269071102, -0.08355876058340073, 0.030869586393237114, 0.02526783011853695, 0.06029222533106804, -0.024714039638638496, 0.019471831619739532, -0.010640076361596584, 0.03441644832491875, -0.06725719571113586, -0.07014979422092438, 0.04242902621626854, -0.026856670156121254, -0.02959970198571682, -0.0228306632488966, 0.00990365818142891, 0.01290193758904934, 0.008985866792500019, 0.01578693278133869, 0.015512822195887566, -0.03301597386598587, -0.015103439800441265, -0.002157841809093952, -0.0015460229478776455, -0.04046624153852463, 0.06285981833934784, -0.025915250182151794, 0.04741019010543823, -0.05338243767619133, 0.030640561133623123, 0.019599834457039833, 0.025802262127399445, 0.04713539034128189, 0.02918389067053795, -0.0664624348282814, -0.12348947674036026, -0.020361291244626045, 0.0952022597193718, -0.0014477415243163705, -0.006430177949368954, 0.008108909241855145, 0.010165967978537083, 0.05494648963212967, 0.0019868751987814903, -0.07003889977931976, -0.01427588239312172, 0.02294660173356533, -0.054981932044029236, -0.006334412842988968, 0.0007275028037838638, -0.000918468926101923, -0.025844136252999306, 0.005432537756860256, 0.007223886903375387, 0.017284825444221497, 0.06329568475484848, -0.001454562647268176, 0.03227482736110687, 0.009417586959898472, 0.013171813450753689, -0.000053982708777766675, 0.013315749354660511, 0.02115410938858986, -0.039681389927864075, -0.005889300722628832, -0.08965552598237991, 0.03700098395347595, 0.048858892172575, -0.04137340560555458, -0.003932112827897072, 0.001390051213093102, 0.02653140388429165, 0.006194837391376495, -0.07710207253694534, -0.025785651057958603, 0.03556005656719208, -0.0051083629950881, -0.010000335052609444, -0.08172908425331116, -0.005605649668723345, -0.0059965322725474834, -0.005527887027710676, 0.0033196613658219576, 0.008858360350131989, -0.0038551134057343006, 0.02871101163327694, 0.05307632312178612, -0.015281951054930687, 0.04180283099412918, -0.1154545322060585, 0.006855564191937447, 0.040767502039670944, -0.010694323107600212, -0.0320962592959404, -0.07558700442314148, 0.0422247014939785, 0.030349789187312126, 0.05431625619530678, 0.0453319326043129, 0.02179582603275776, 0.02491016499698162, 0.003936021588742733, 0.002422669203951955, -0.024451803416013718, 0.02183724194765091, -0.01215230394154787, -0.005525562446564436, 0.0325964130461216, -0.0305799413472414, -0.07245814800262451, -0.0026433272287249565, -0.011748635210096836, -0.03579653054475784, -0.028358491137623787, -0.02932543307542801, -0.005105853080749512, 0.02303043007850647, 0.05576729401946068, 0.04162304103374481, -0.037893373519182205, 0.007295962423086166, -0.03830384835600853, 0.0817638635635376, -0.02344382368028164, 0.024793703109025955, 0.024870438501238823, -0.043586794286966324, 0.04439683258533478, 0.0036221558693796396, -0.02489086054265499, -0.048358991742134094, 0.013087705709040165, -0.0068635037168860435, 0.07801920920610428, -0.03041117638349533, 0.07283762842416763, -0.0029858958441764116, 0.043627187609672546, 0.0300312377512455, 0.007510957773774862, 0.013848386704921722, 0.019576584920287132, 0.027115290984511375, 0.019668975844979286, 0.0027365521527826786, -0.00042369746370241046, -0.030290180817246437, 0.0035644443705677986, 0.03597823902964592, -0.04229284077882767, 0.006124269682914019, 0.008075491525232792, -0.024383414536714554, 0.02093510888516903, 0.03572273626923561, -0.03832633048295975, -0.0007144053815864027, -0.043097034096717834, -0.0262296199798584, 0.03364243358373642, -0.044439077377319336, 0.0002574508253019303, 0.08668427169322968, 0.012392119504511356, -0.06884470582008362, -0.026437686756253242, 0.0548003613948822, 0.04490479826927185, -0.023722542449831963, 0.015294013544917107, 0.022254249081015587, 0.016948143020272255, -0.01880478486418724, -0.026200944557785988, 0.024782627820968628, 0.06351196765899658, -0.028239885345101357, -0.06508690863847733, -0.04891050234436989, -0.038100093603134155, -0.06440288573503494, -0.02794761024415493, 0.06907540559768677, -0.0017531923949718475, 0.07588154077529907, 0.006867594085633755, 0.04024156928062439, 0.0218278169631958, 0.08897875249385834, 0.038402874022722244, -0.016481710597872734, -0.03234716132283211, 0.04156980663537979, -0.05130927637219429, 0.03343292325735092, -0.04331572353839874, -0.019468771293759346, 0.03142017126083374, -0.01383586972951889, -0.0006130875553935766, -0.020288696512579918, 0.034430742263793945, 0.06865201890468597, 0.06812194734811783, -0.08782204985618591, 0.02795848809182644, 0.02651161141693592, 0.03515532985329628, -0.04209212586283684, -0.009494435973465443, -0.02074236422777176, -0.035504892468452454, 0.02965318225324154, 0.04494249448180199, 0.0375053808093071, -0.0616271048784256, 0.005213983356952667, -0.029450997710227966, -0.04816844314336777, -0.005101276561617851, 0.015198549255728722, -0.03428163006901741, 0.009735551662743092, 0.009068853221833706, 0.02059127576649189, 0.013500366359949112, 0.001997989369556308, 0.0603037029504776, -0.0035026855766773224, 0.012149808928370476, -0.059420108795166016, 0.01197462435811758, 0.029313333332538605, -0.058569081127643585, 0.018020838499069214, 0.03173568844795227, -0.011182024143636227, 0.017618844285607338, 0.029545757919549942, -0.002182565163820982, 0.050130996853113174, -0.01195842307060957, -0.02891238033771515, -0.0375123955309391, -0.09250698983669281, 0.009917567484080791, 0.042361438274383545, 0.013246715068817139, 0.043001703917980194, 0.0131198326125741, 0.030076585710048676, -0.018713925033807755, 0.0055028218775987625, 0.002923678606748581, -0.018193921074271202, -0.015310165472328663, 0.0034749899059534073, -0.03267159312963486, -0.002016396028921008, 0.006368628703057766, 0.06770551949739456, 0.016759756952524185, -0.07155977934598923, 0.0026414617896080017, 0.015826087445020676, 0.0426069051027298, -0.004786632489413023, 0.003285276237875223, -0.06583204865455627, 0.02310756780207157, 0.0406523272395134, -0.052081428468227386, -0.05377456173300743, 0.02782689407467842, 0.07296976447105408, -0.03749843314290047, 0.0037120527122169733, -0.005155972205102444, -0.030492104589939117, 0.03192412108182907, 0.0339401513338089, -0.02226981706917286, -0.0139550706371665, 0.0065755220130085945, -0.06121990829706192, 0.013615278527140617, -0.02013085037469864, -0.01237546931952238, 0.05153641104698181, -0.01622788980603218, -0.027523739263415337, -0.001665717107243836, 0.044416483491659164, -0.0555591881275177, 0.0014373889425769448, -0.06540416181087494, 0.0012974429409950972, 0.02644098363816738, -0.01285323966294527, 0.010843210853636265, -0.03004402667284012, 0.02534373849630356, 0.05427784472703934, -0.0689731165766716, -0.03678103908896446, -0.011204246431589127, -0.022123495116829872, -0.022457100450992584, 0.021026941016316414, -0.047718219459056854, 0.06798721849918365, -0.037878211587667465, 0.024676397442817688, -0.003737055929377675, -0.04607834666967392, -0.013373480178415775, -0.02525465376675129, -0.07347775995731354, 0.03161542862653732, 0.00921850185841322, -0.05665675550699234, 0.05801290273666382, 0.007741298992186785, -0.011498657055199146, 0.002216647146269679, 0.028111906722187996, 0.009371431544423103, -0.011158931069076061, -0.022143637761473656, -0.000802624155767262, 0.046641819179058075, 0.021881328895688057, 0.0014741347404196858, 0.012369777075946331, -0.021189231425523758, 0.0213587936013937, -0.002938260789960623, -0.016794774681329727, 0.055820491164922714, 0.03800074756145477, 0.04602458328008652, 0.023460401222109795, -0.00023741048062220216, 0.057890504598617554, -0.025701865553855896, -0.008675796911120415, 0.051707569509744644, -0.014079906977713108, 0.024308428168296814, -0.0438753105700016, 0.003363224444910884, -0.001372749567963183, 0.014648104086518288, -0.020869087427854538, 0.015403241850435734, 0.00006990458496147767, 0.012324961833655834, -0.007976907305419445, -0.01942281611263752, 0.002059736754745245, 0.04424241557717323, -0.05114337429404259, -0.022002452984452248, -0.06933650374412537, -0.0368078276515007, -0.03135312348604202, 0.01348651573061943, -0.06447811424732208, 0.028866887092590332, -0.003000635886564851, 0.0027187340892851353, -0.015182864852249622, 0.023179130628705025, 0.009276843629777431, -0.04409375414252281, -0.0000771230406826362, 0.026204761117696762, 0.0681094154715538, -0.04646290838718414, 0.04992300271987915, 0.004364839289337397, -0.011475671082735062, 0.041659142822027206, 0.010043412446975708, 0.012337259016931057, -0.017625536769628525, 0.002877035178244114, 0.002171926200389862, 0.027245650067925453, -0.009995166212320328, -0.005415682680904865, -0.0067243496887385845, 0.04134548455476761, 0.0711653083562851, -0.01826520264148712, -0.05063930153846741, 0.0014476599171757698, 0.021089250221848488, 0.023862915113568306, -0.006198866758495569, 0.0033009827602654696, 0.00509179662913084, -0.05370591953396797, 0.01585618034005165, 0.01600741222500801, 0.011498022824525833, 0.02619975246489048, 0.03424139320850372, 0.0026963981799781322, 0.03065323643386364, -0.04105955362319946, -0.06039314344525337, 0.024709731340408325, 0.025249384343624115, 0.016903512179851532, 0.009381952695548534, -0.049926284700632095, 0.011919724754989147, 0.029916319996118546, 0.03089664876461029, 0.004005419556051493, -0.021045349538326263, -0.009837513789534569, -0.033243030309677124, 0.006954438053071499, 0.06232355162501335, 0.07373113930225372, 0.047744933515787125, -0.028637902811169624, -0.060691844671964645, 0.010921092703938484, -0.004017081577330828, 0.020026858896017075, 0.01875089481472969, 0.02458924613893032, -0.06088602542877197, 0.047825124114751816, 0.0061091473326087, -0.027427224442362785, -0.09487689286470413, -0.031073953956365585, 0.04469329118728638, -0.04416116699576378, -0.022496948018670082, -0.009957562200725079, -0.00356666068546474, -0.05279548466205597, 0.04474944993853569, 0.008517631329596043, -0.03133636340498924, 0.04453215375542641, -0.06520941108465195, -0.02031819149851799, 0.021168459206819534, 0.026588913053274155, 0.03772495687007904, -0.006674793548882008, -0.019547773525118828, -0.038400113582611084, -0.013285315595567226, 0.07959660142660141, -0.036577485501766205, -0.009634501300752163, 0.04549241065979004, -0.044780295342206955, 0.1121092289686203, 0.0038540358655154705, 0.06834820657968521, -0.019984567537903786, -0.01940002106130123, -0.04601247236132622, -0.03448637202382088, 0.06542686372995377, -0.004488530568778515, -0.027820924296975136, 0.022465931251645088, 0.002991640707477927, -0.03173935413360596, -0.020916637033224106, 0.020279763266444206, -0.043470438569784164, 0.044696979224681854, 0.006977267097681761, -0.050323329865932465, 0.009964226745069027, -0.02630445919930935, 0.009979172609746456, 0.03688855841755867, -0.021039923653006554, 0.016292521730065346, -0.012463793158531189, 0.0018897401168942451, -0.035033244639635086, -0.06958375871181488, -0.08817221969366074, 0.04201943427324295, -0.018555255606770515, 0.03441239148378372, -0.044411420822143555, 0.0028629438020288944, -0.04995681717991829, 0.0101632596924901, 0.028067901730537415, -0.000481724098790437, -0.006338112987577915, 0.02493949979543686, 0.010401688516139984, 0.018053952604532242, -0.006358353421092033, -0.036116208881139755, 0.037787530571222305, -0.001714641461148858, -0.001080070622265339, 0.03021683357656002, 0.02882453426718712, 0.030909400433301926, -0.03641638904809952, 0.025420960038900375, 0.0007806855137459934, -0.076179139316082, 0.0031533516012132168, 0.039283208549022675, 0.06608831137418747, -0.005443698260933161, -0.05514362081885338, 0.004309468436986208, -0.010332450270652771, -0.03214382007718086, 0.04439465329051018, -0.0006785821169614792, -0.009489544667303562, -0.00014195943367667496, -0.03301984444260597, 0.011691139079630375, 0.008555581793189049, 0.03089495562016964 ]
<p>I need to calculate the temporal trends for some climate variables with missing values. For example, last frost days defines as the last day of year with minimum temperature less than 0C. However, there are no any frost days in some years. </p> <p>My data look like: </p> <pre><code>lfd &lt;- c(NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, 190, 192, 189, 200, 185, 205, 203, 200, 207, NA, NA, 205) years &lt;- seq(1957, length.out = length(lfd)) </code></pre> <p>Now I use the linear regression in R (function lm) to calculate temporal trend. It seems the results are unreasonable for datasets with many missing values.</p> <p>How could I calculate the temporal trends with missing values? Thanks for any suggestions. </p>
g74045
[ 0.06801489740610123, -0.05792001262307167, -0.006016804836690426, -0.049030497670173645, -0.016314450651407242, 0.020768769085407257, 0.025230569764971733, -0.01626579836010933, -0.0629025399684906, -0.03432851657271385, -0.05480680242180824, 0.013484056107699871, 0.04043238237500191, 0.015938490629196167, -0.007877957075834274, 0.0475296787917614, 0.00014604457828681916, -0.01501078624278307, 0.009857683442533016, 0.05102704092860222, 0.0658888891339302, 0.02777055650949478, 0.04520518705248833, 0.007900341413915157, -0.02237161435186863, -0.020472927019000053, 0.012413986027240753, 0.12092982232570648, -0.060066234320402145, 0.03130071610212326, 0.03913886472582817, 0.002425310667604208, -0.0219930000603199, -0.00661654956638813, 0.0022901385091245174, -0.07980900257825851, 0.043167389929294586, 0.04677688702940941, 0.0333106704056263, -0.01777452416718006, 0.031403589993715286, -0.0015267282724380493, 0.07351594418287277, 0.05312138423323631, 0.009005091153085232, -0.01893220655620098, -0.016608627513051033, -0.036979056894779205, -0.009084120392799377, -0.06591369956731796, -0.002275450387969613, 0.029990339651703835, -0.03374171257019043, -0.05195261165499687, -0.019884901121258736, -0.003094925545156002, 0.009917723946273327, -0.0009012689697556198, 0.03371835872530937, 0.03472145274281502, 0.05718570575118065, -0.020881030708551407, -0.03816530853509903, -0.030769675970077515, 0.01564357988536358, 0.026375601068139076, -0.03317528963088989, -0.045273471623659134, -0.00839960016310215, -0.017347346991300583, 0.005105399526655674, 0.04483089968562126, -0.0010643323184922338, -0.014325515367090702, -0.06465702503919601, 0.009611980058252811, -0.04433532431721687, 0.03908977657556534, 0.01012333482503891, 0.01649654097855091, -0.019160054624080658, 0.05777003988623619, -0.013090381398797035, 0.023270688951015472, 0.02978600189089775, 0.013793394900858402, 0.026394100859761238, 0.05024861544370651, 0.011911002919077873, 0.0016251750057563186, -0.033616803586483, 0.01764794997870922, 0.06563572585582733, -0.02783830650150776, 0.00670730322599411, -0.02857915684580803, -0.031168067827820778, 0.04099728539586067, 0.004503306932747364, 0.046085625886917114, 0.006522712763398886, -0.005776248872280121, -0.01516655832529068, -0.03356457129120827, -0.029236914590001106, -0.06073560565710068, 0.05230877548456192, -0.05498790740966797, -0.022151147946715355, -0.027615947648882866, 0.002042293781414628, 0.022666579112410545, -0.054369498044252396, 0.01754019781947136, 0.024599792435765266, -0.013140223920345306, 0.016983166337013245, -0.04478297382593155, 0.009290277026593685, 0.01928018219769001, -0.04802750423550606, -0.0011406788835301995, 0.04827947914600372, 0.02639249712228775, 0.03354296460747719, -0.024257276207208633, -0.05540205538272858, 0.029619673267006874, 0.08272888511419296, 0.024551834911108017, -0.02253587730228901, 0.033921897411346436, -0.0010449649998918176, 0.02389652468264103, -0.04298685863614082, -0.013074456714093685, -0.03818580508232117, 0.13147853314876556, -0.03616245463490486, -0.021278414875268936, 0.009075880981981754, -0.009371710941195488, 0.03602368012070656, -0.01155522558838129, -0.04359695687890053, 0.008446116000413895, -0.03761347383260727, -0.05203071981668472, -0.0018516735872253776, -0.038158614188432693, 0.01701582409441471, 0.04847775772213936, 0.009490306489169598, 0.04092617705464363, -0.027324538677930832, -0.00858991127461195, -0.002382356906309724, -0.04490365833044052, -0.05363360792398453, -0.039347004145383835, -0.001979165943339467, -0.011035478673875332, 0.07698962092399597, -0.001077694003470242, 0.004548523109406233, 0.024415694177150726, -0.026226237416267395, -0.007399148773401976, -0.029911497607827187, 0.023829706013202667, -0.015177479013800621, 0.03522147238254547, 0.01996528171002865, -0.07688762247562408, 0.02537626214325428, 0.05648528039455414, 0.04618152603507042, -0.039961859583854675, -0.002674279734492302, -0.006570891942828894, 0.03492468595504761, 0.024310091510415077, 0.07258043438196182, -0.03820537403225899, -0.028243884444236755, -0.08872252702713013, 0.020329874008893967, -0.0020248182117938995, -0.053602494299411774, -0.034402575343847275, -0.008517451584339142, -0.030889935791492462, -0.011875983327627182, -0.0027804230339825153, 0.008494258858263493, -0.03403164818882942, 0.016001839190721512, -0.05558021366596222, -0.05503746122121811, 0.0316600501537323, 0.04467056691646576, -0.029978638514876366, -0.03278901055455208, 0.004152946639806032, -0.05337938666343689, -0.00016699297702871263, -0.040289256721735, 0.012101883068680763, -0.051712289452552795, -0.01929975301027298, -0.022522497922182083, -0.045589517802000046, -0.049510352313518524, 0.034650444984436035, 0.0018092511454597116, 0.029004966840147972, -0.01362776942551136, 0.00841835979372263, 0.04987821355462074, 0.008368345908820629, -0.021461840718984604, 0.025261571630835533, -0.014361077919602394, 0.054557498544454575, 0.060747161507606506, 0.05224873498082161, 0.0116944070905447, -0.004024425987154245, 0.015306878834962845, -0.004203591495752335, 0.02226049266755581, 0.033131927251815796, -0.07933565974235535, 0.0155495535582304, 0.020358379930257797, 0.03862642124295235, 0.025287136435508728, -0.010034553706645966, 0.028300143778324127, 0.027294695377349854, -0.04558786749839783, 0.007114944513887167, -0.04387036710977554, 0.059859395027160645, 0.04876326397061348, -0.011022863909602165, 0.012201754376292229, 0.00904112495481968, 0.006746460217982531, 0.04827679321169853, -0.005354341119527817, 0.05177304893732071, -0.02908048778772354, -0.008185312151908875, 0.031108226627111435, -0.047449659556150436, -0.03605213016271591, 0.0032790477853268385, 0.020608916878700256, -0.011960719712078571, -0.020838219672441483, 0.023167520761489868, 0.019093353301286697, 0.003490735776722431, 0.011866377666592598, 0.005732659716159105, -0.032031621783971786, -0.015331276692450047, -0.00042114118696190417, -0.005114424508064985, -0.0032731229439377785, -0.06561608612537384, 0.06780479848384857, 0.040659960359334946, 0.03288981691002846, 0.018031099811196327, 0.0022977706976234913, 0.023851938545703888, 0.006210621912032366, 0.006203649565577507, 0.05808340013027191, -0.10317002236843109, 0.02769063413143158, 0.027530888095498085, -0.03775095194578171, 0.0011495617218315601, 0.013842998072504997, 0.07750585675239563, -0.03968382254242897, 0.024903038516640663, -0.0218027476221323, -0.02375507913529873, -0.000802651746198535, -0.03864862024784088, -0.014621105045080185, -0.00306586641818285, 0.00635706027969718, -0.0021601722110062838, 0.04111924394965172, -0.029039695858955383, 0.004086916800588369, 0.019097810611128807, -0.01986088417470455, -0.031855031847953796, 0.02343212254345417, -0.09663877636194229, -0.009603368118405342, -0.006593781989067793, 0.02916531451046467, -0.04682076722383499, 0.052273232489824295, -0.0016298717819154263, 0.0013674458023160696, 0.015240288339555264, -0.026718467473983765, 0.015560315921902657, 0.011406169272959232, 0.05919165909290314, 0.04272717610001564, 0.0009179425542242825, -0.007496593985706568, -0.037932299077510834, 0.04934043064713478, 0.005186914000660181, 0.021366694942116737, 0.04588938504457474, -0.020268535241484642, -0.014627056196331978, -0.04541347548365593, 0.027486808598041534, -0.005942466668784618, 0.025884442031383514, 0.019253578037023544, -0.02674519084393978, -0.04539371654391289, -0.02145954594016075, 0.020691314712166786, -0.002368721878156066, -0.02818121761083603, 0.020518487319350243, -0.037351951003074646, 0.024185331538319588, -0.04259559139609337, 0.025118524208664894, -0.008371210657060146, -0.044130418449640274, -0.01487055979669094, 0.03895469382405281, -0.010655250400304794, 0.047386426478624344, -0.04165070131421089, -0.033166803419589996, -0.018404316157102585, -0.009328129701316357, 0.004966895096004009, 0.10021582990884781, 0.012419152073562145, 0.019507547840476036, 0.09664806723594666, -0.012617887929081917, 0.010026322677731514, -0.026086950674653053, -0.024262579157948494, 0.022349491715431213, -0.004526342265307903, 0.0069256932474672794, 0.05395513027906418, 0.09443952888250351, 0.038696177303791046, -0.07734619826078415, 0.07156990468502045, 0.04342813789844513, 0.05298145115375519, -0.07016072422266006, -0.036365754902362823, -0.03981978818774223, 0.025435201823711395, 0.02091221511363983, -0.0018525489140301943, 0.10467410087585449, 0.016723133623600006, -0.010371497832238674, 0.032482944428920746, -0.013179648667573929, -0.011131340637803078, -0.12266378849744797, 0.014688991010189056, -0.006642599124461412, -0.020334705710411072, -0.02613261714577675, 0.011343879625201225, 0.001767885871231556, -0.0008551393402740359, 0.05575176700949669, -0.000025722873033373617, -0.048533037304878235, 0.055799055844545364, 0.09456092864274979, -0.024971911683678627, -0.025726092979311943, -0.018390405923128128, 0.019699862226843834, 0.07198435068130493, 0.0018283057725057006, 0.006327497772872448, 0.014441420324146748, 0.004040286410599947, -0.023325230926275253, -0.010394226759672165, 0.0003859822463709861, -0.05857187137007713, -0.02730588987469673, 0.00026101848925463855, -0.034279853105545044, 0.010664698667824268, -0.054118696600198746, 0.09767252206802368, -0.03675539791584015, 0.03838835656642914, -0.00007737981650279835, -0.03483275696635246, 0.04408019036054611, -0.06887912005186081, -0.016268005594611168, -0.011781832203269005, 0.051123522222042084, 0.031069984659552574, -0.03601149469614029, 0.005402047652751207, -0.03331812098622322, -0.004712773486971855, 0.014113240875303745, -0.03233015909790993, 0.0014526030281558633, 0.06367511302232742, 0.0024692672304809093, -0.006813437677919865, 0.01336293201893568, -0.023348787799477577, -0.024576788768172264, -0.03620695322751999, -0.010862953960895538, -0.007555526215583086, 0.02107357420027256, -0.0659400150179863, 0.00902670156210661, 0.05342346429824829, -0.04127034172415733, -0.024176329374313354, 0.07821103930473328, 0.03843064606189728, 0.04884011670947075, -0.021247975528240204, 0.046382732689380646, 0.031037505716085434, -0.050003353506326675, -0.011903220787644386, 0.08601666241884232, -0.009522523730993271, 0.07642287015914917, -0.03969184681773186, -0.047629695385694504, 0.00003526030559442006, -0.004680912010371685, -0.032607633620500565, -0.054521217942237854, 0.022200116887688637, -0.025822659954428673, 0.032579004764556885, -0.05862906575202942, -0.02732952870428562, 0.012870375998318195, -0.00776592968031764, 0.022938745096325874, -0.024401389062404633, -0.013931180350482464, -0.01299105305224657, -0.0005241376347839832, 0.03244328126311302, 0.03511480987071991, -0.040019866079092026, -0.03058728203177452, -0.016502082347869873, -0.009264024905860424, -0.020411858335137367, -0.018606970086693764, 0.0008209025836549699, -0.06202232837677002, 0.022719869390130043, -0.021695394068956375, -0.01684393174946308, 0.035924032330513, 0.034441012889146805, 0.03754616528749466, -0.02728845924139023, 0.011007010005414486, -0.019599711522459984, -0.015239200554788113, -0.003489547409117222, -0.01183293852955103, -0.003757341532036662, 0.05835810676217079, -0.010649056173861027, -0.029781095683574677, 0.03217763453722, -0.016208508983254433, 0.053282588720321655, 0.016803918406367302, -0.018368929624557495, 0.012801420874893665, 0.058252934366464615, 0.03899736329913139, 0.0562450997531414, 0.017224585637450218, -0.005392176564782858, -0.026501696556806564, -0.05383680760860443, -0.03804513439536095, -0.05125712603330612, -0.015756599605083466, -0.0010673711076378822, 0.012549483217298985, 0.07536059617996216, -0.008772838860750198, 0.016145093366503716, -0.05174950137734413, -0.056666117161512375, -0.053932007402181625, -0.047062307596206665, -0.058495186269283295, -0.016383107751607895, -0.005200535524636507, -0.008927295915782452, -0.018259365111589432, -0.0036302341613918543, 0.002585930749773979, -0.03441831097006798, -0.00014507552259601653, 0.0007813679985702038, -0.05312630534172058, -0.05433020740747452, 0.037993963807821274, -0.0033348200377076864, -0.0170008335262537, -0.031151555478572845, -0.03728621453046799, 0.0627620667219162, 0.019158849492669106, 0.052549730986356735, -0.016922099515795708, -0.029833881184458733, 0.04755223169922829, 0.013925798237323761, -0.015914330258965492, 0.009505296126008034, -0.012245497666299343, 0.03189583122730255, 0.013552498072385788, -0.05819984897971153, 0.013036633841693401, 0.0019748606719076633, -0.019513893872499466, 0.020064817741513252, 0.021815137937664986, -0.01662876084446907, 0.03524729982018471, -0.03300036862492561, 0.019117016345262527, -0.029687143862247467, -0.012565172277390957, 0.03716261684894562, -0.04557773098349571, 0.017510881647467613, 0.013300776481628418, 0.0292957853525877, 0.006633762735873461, 0.014295877888798714, -0.013914358802139759, -0.005629690829664469, -0.014857701025903225, -0.050096191465854645, -0.005264750681817532, -0.004469821695238352, -0.001215734169818461, -0.00005232835246715695, 0.014317433349788189, -0.005245051812380552, -0.013039018027484417, -0.013468269258737564, -0.005489503499120474, -0.03522632643580437, 0.028416460379958153, 0.004687097854912281, -0.0947895422577858, -0.007713055703788996, -0.013847796246409416, -0.06670483201742172, -0.02111070230603218, -0.007654185406863689, -0.027669241651892662, 0.0007730482611805201, 0.010409057140350342, 0.07811592519283295, -0.03208094835281372, 0.004647590219974518, -0.0328066311776638, 0.000599104561842978, 0.0028677345253527164, 0.030149023979902267, 0.01936817541718483, -0.03296870365738869, 0.022946568205952644, 0.014517598785459995, 0.037485383450984955, -0.020363416522741318, -0.05976539105176926, -0.020549021661281586, 0.02892536111176014, -0.09125819057226181, -0.03837646171450615, -0.013911612331867218, 0.0006562484777532518, -0.04360799491405487, -0.028789395466446877, 0.07360400259494781, 0.032691556960344315, -0.033989839255809784, 0.018445733934640884, 0.028806570917367935, -0.0537775456905365, -0.022321375086903572, -0.03977895528078079, 0.005520619451999664, 0.04629950225353241, -0.016034988686442375, 0.013965465128421783, -0.02105545997619629, 0.09139464050531387, 0.008330181241035461, 0.012520859017968178, 0.031130393967032433, 0.004048969130963087, -0.014530661515891552, -0.00749638956040144, -0.02870582602918148, 0.0015200268244370818, -0.01576414331793785, -0.021556533873081207, -0.044085245579481125, -0.03283488377928734, 0.01507831271737814, 0.013558750972151756, 0.054145440459251404, 0.01897784322500229, 0.04213165491819382, 0.0059752510860562325, 0.0023988543543964624, 0.004007465671747923, 0.03261621296405792, 0.040112514048814774, -0.06811657547950745, -0.04017263650894165, -0.028740286827087402, -0.00927884504199028, 0.10607121139764786, 0.06268054246902466, 0.06415874511003494, -0.04090718552470207, 0.055394306778907776, -0.021269813179969788, -0.03691387176513672, -0.023309849202632904, -0.01161694061011076, 0.026935262605547905, 0.02738693542778492, 0.02342608943581581, -0.002587808296084404, 0.025626448914408684, -0.015312152914702892, -0.0017355331219732761, 0.008295601233839989, 0.03301915153861046, -0.023757271468639374, -0.019845495000481606, 0.012852845713496208, 0.042590346187353134, 0.02841859497129917, 0.017096340656280518, 0.07734045386314392, -0.013386725448071957, -0.03791017085313797, -0.0037712682969868183, 0.008445845916867256, -0.005613106768578291, -0.005192790180444717, -0.05469011887907982, -0.01549341157078743, -0.06490565091371536, 0.00968319084495306, 0.042525459080934525, 0.04087470471858978, 0.037501927465200424, 0.03205759823322296, 0.010950793512165546, -0.0033604365307837725, 0.03110874816775322, -0.047715991735458374, -0.056349992752075195, 0.002503354102373123, 0.016160590574145317, -0.030529968440532684, 0.10384155809879303, 0.018333258107304573, 0.022095924243330956, 0.05224348604679108, 0.00623848894611001, 0.019107945263385773, 0.016171518713235855, -0.0010007882956415415, -0.04013461619615555, -0.10298606753349304, -0.046763259917497635, 0.006375462282449007, -0.024905091151595116, -0.04344131052494049, 0.030585067346692085, -0.07168716192245483, -0.021273497492074966, -0.0030640626791864634, -0.03113895282149315, 0.0292492788285017, -0.02859802544116974, -0.06667976081371307, 0.030871355906128883, 0.02985551208257675, -0.01902056112885475, 0.005959125701338053, 0.05053645372390747, 0.021606657654047012, 0.053812045603990555, -0.035352934151887894, -0.015974601730704308, 0.0020789382979273796, -0.0014842826640233397, -0.006846322678029537, 0.0198350939899683, -0.030953142791986465, 0.02878677099943161, 0.04559497907757759, -0.012423491105437279, -0.1142888143658638, 0.04890972375869751, -0.025951603427529335, 0.0029180748388171196, -0.013325528241693974, 0.027092870324850082, 0.001858597737737, -0.03681665658950806, -0.014293252490460873, -0.01118526328355074, 0.014382382854819298, 0.019191762432456017, 0.00573365855962038, 0.03799523413181305, 0.020500926300883293, -0.013927559368312359, -0.0027311795856803656, -0.041001904755830765 ]
<p>I am interested in developing a computational search of some types of non-coding RNAs (ncRNAs) on a new genome. I have some questions related to the nature of my experiment, because it is an exploratory study, and I can generate different results by applying different BLAST search strategies. The final output consists of different counts of each type of ncRNA for each BLAST strategy. </p> <p>How I can design good search strategies, taking into account that it is the first search on this new genome?</p> <p>References will be appreciated. </p> <p>Thanks!</p>
g48340
[ -0.015722187235951424, 0.003433023113757372, 0.012561658397316933, 0.0014033638872206211, 0.012925083748996258, -0.058223120868206024, -0.04201044514775276, -0.010903245769441128, -0.044993575662374496, -0.03617307171225548, -0.0021368633024394512, -0.03002309240400791, 0.040195729583501816, 0.047335829585790634, 0.02105974592268467, -0.019674919545650482, -0.004453543573617935, 0.030037879943847656, -0.017212139442563057, 0.04019587114453316, 0.012601410038769245, 0.039056021720170975, -0.013686378486454487, 0.06849128752946854, -0.07095596194267273, -0.031049685552716255, -0.0015973291592672467, -0.0082293301820755, -0.09266506880521774, -0.028452571481466293, -0.0006038001738488674, -0.0500740148127079, -0.010530066676437855, 0.007734084501862526, -0.010860555805265903, -0.023275714367628098, -0.06646896153688431, -0.03712424635887146, -0.05871523544192314, 0.024950919672846794, 0.042152442038059235, -0.05172237753868103, -0.02617643214762211, 0.015363991260528564, 0.040869615972042084, 0.007496844045817852, 0.013120969757437706, -0.041068751364946365, 0.06740111112594604, -0.08692386746406555, 0.056937072426080704, 0.04445751756429672, -0.015680966898798943, 0.0005925525329075754, 0.06163683533668518, 0.00024415567168034613, -0.03138631582260132, 0.05627574771642685, 0.0010086066322401166, -0.06962087750434875, 0.034559983760118484, -0.0006133027491159737, -0.029359299689531326, -0.06847109645605087, 0.03467775136232376, -0.0068363007158041, -0.018924234434962273, 0.03216665983200073, -0.015644442290067673, 0.04464680701494217, -0.017268886789679527, 0.03449968993663788, 0.01697413995862007, 0.04162566363811493, 0.013617424294352531, -0.01422081422060728, -0.018455971032381058, -0.03037634864449501, -0.018886296078562737, 0.01921546272933483, 0.019872358068823814, 0.033930454403162, -0.022448666393756866, -0.00021403306163847446, 0.07663563638925552, 0.0043217190541327, -0.043629810214042664, -0.014661706052720547, 0.03713911399245262, 0.0006841670256108046, 0.027444712817668915, 0.04364717751741409, 0.09136772900819778, -0.022857503965497017, 0.004502688534557819, 0.02546391263604164, -0.03093845210969448, 0.033013444393873215, 0.02922295592725277, 0.03671152889728546, 0.057767461985349655, -0.008568123914301395, 0.004072105512022972, -0.037180185317993164, -0.03344437852501869, 0.0023283720947802067, -0.011049176566302776, 0.01777510717511177, -0.10288716107606888, -0.03371619060635567, -0.04412677139043808, -0.020590947940945625, -0.02201669290661812, 0.02800443023443222, -0.03012263961136341, 0.04652220755815506, 0.052188750356435776, 0.048512957990169525, 0.054965924471616745, 0.03946427255868912, 0.012987831607460976, 0.019855109974741936, -0.018703991547226906, 0.014926370233297348, -0.042736560106277466, -0.006979641504585743, -0.012954161502420902, 0.017910899594426155, 0.025072533637285233, -0.013721817173063755, -0.02151786908507347, -0.004001413006335497, 0.033517174422740936, 0.07252991199493408, 0.05871012061834335, -0.0007367149228230119, -0.014752699062228203, 0.010322656482458115, 0.019453443586826324, 0.027272237464785576, -0.028850199654698372, -0.03113746829330921, 0.02740512415766716, -0.012857071124017239, 0.0326976515352726, -0.018516290932893753, -0.07660999894142151, 0.012988686561584473, -0.007928834296762943, 0.024578556418418884, -0.010103573091328144, -0.046892426908016205, 0.025729818269610405, -0.08897526562213898, 0.009250110946595669, 0.015175850130617619, -0.005008642561733723, 0.0473056435585022, -0.04151846095919609, 0.017176633700728416, -0.02066868543624878, -0.01710382290184498, -0.020346088334918022, 0.03604603558778763, -0.007735164370387793, 0.03507016971707344, -0.04723922908306122, -0.07060914486646652, 0.012885465286672115, -0.0011883493280038238, -0.008333820849657059, 0.02306792140007019, 0.02956179715692997, -0.018891366198658943, 0.02184896171092987, 0.03786446526646614, 0.09191516786813736, -0.01779734157025814, 0.005407769698649645, 0.001194522250443697, -0.04455333203077316, 0.004030183423310518, -0.023271556943655014, 0.035491690039634705, 0.029452884569764137, 0.002995241666212678, -0.01584029756486416, 0.004715839866548777, -0.011118000373244286, -0.022485332563519478, -0.004371318966150284, -0.023214636370539665, 0.02229847013950348, 0.00538391899317503, -0.029353031888604164, -0.00040095101576298475, -0.023141037672758102, -0.09617622941732407, -0.018446721136569977, -0.03184753283858299, -0.004154416732490063, -0.015269665978848934, -0.03244766220450401, 0.02533652074635029, -0.043570298701524734, -0.0336417555809021, 0.05265937000513077, 0.054483529180288315, 0.023243486881256104, 0.04451574757695198, -0.0013860553735867143, 0.01089145801961422, -0.013887298293411732, 0.03922097012400627, -0.011481869965791702, 0.04806393012404442, 0.025740312412381172, -0.019372858107089996, -0.020634319633245468, 0.006143960170447826, 0.023533832281827927, -0.007258513942360878, -0.065456323325634, 0.0444057397544384, -0.034463394433259964, 0.0366084985435009, 0.03813641890883446, -0.000577583909034729, 0.03002464771270752, 0.0029999841935932636, -0.019163785502314568, 0.0017843187088146806, -0.013786409981548786, -0.04084666073322296, -0.02376406081020832, -0.0031402974855154753, 0.03911106288433075, 0.04792128503322601, -0.018449196591973305, 0.03434302657842636, 0.01619029976427555, -0.004970856010913849, -0.004035970661789179, 0.0008009502780623734, 0.0005551185458898544, -0.1564536690711975, 0.008914667181670666, -0.006310174707323313, -0.07712695002555847, 0.018776578828692436, -0.02872484363615513, 0.013840164989233017, 0.01591571792960167, 0.012203178368508816, 0.023303162306547165, -0.0005188433569855988, 0.027025898918509483, 0.0012213459704071283, -0.014356317929923534, 0.056703805923461914, 0.046659812331199646, 0.025158178061246872, -0.03693618252873421, -0.03339719399809837, -0.05036711320281029, -0.0028580843936651945, -0.02439318597316742, -0.041756898164749146, -0.006527756806463003, 0.01052050944417715, -0.11461802572011948, -0.08616755157709122, 0.0033883622381836176, -0.0194214079529047, 0.012101680040359497, 0.0012351978803053498, 0.007019032724201679, 0.06966806948184967, 0.011910130269825459, 0.04031575843691826, 0.013702461495995522, 0.01729590818285942, 0.006477791350334883, 0.0433460995554924, 0.018551697954535484, -0.038348499685525894, -0.0035705510526895523, -0.011382005177438259, -0.013910061679780483, -0.02631968818604946, 0.011004108935594559, -0.0547487735748291, 0.005102840717881918, -0.00494043156504631, -0.014594824984669685, 0.0015760670648887753, -0.019252950325608253, -0.04248423129320145, -0.002726600505411625, 0.10360153019428253, -0.009836183860898018, -0.015253197401762009, 0.03732307255268097, -0.05677196383476257, -0.024116652086377144, -0.04309483990073204, -0.039334673434495926, -0.018945975229144096, 0.015922484919428825, 0.011465499177575111, -0.03541248291730881, 0.003539227182045579, 0.05934324860572815, -0.028126295655965805, 0.05267433822154999, -0.018940653651952744, 0.018684640526771545, 0.01319206040352583, 0.019746145233511925, 0.04434119910001755, -0.013207977637648582, -0.03678959608078003, 0.04205705225467682, -0.03312347084283829, 0.05489499494433403, 0.02856001816689968, 0.024770429357886314, -0.06372757256031036, -0.007216986268758774, -0.027007104828953743, 0.025929750874638557, 0.029263831675052643, -0.06921180337667465, 0.043016497045755386, -0.04455174133181572, 0.015094182454049587, 0.000784065923653543, 0.001633203006349504, 0.01201707124710083, -0.002647282788529992, -0.02227518893778324, -0.0067710126750171185, 0.01018624659627676, -0.05044834688305855, 0.009868166409432888, 0.023935137316584587, 0.03358453884720802, 0.03376879170536995, -0.01955006830394268, -0.0001368939265375957, -0.018513543531298637, -0.08459673821926117, -0.008926981128752232, -0.028229383751749992, -0.007321327459067106, 0.026988549157977104, 0.028766436502337456, 0.019870096817612648, 0.008201517164707184, -0.00519169494509697, 0.002011098200455308, -0.03386543691158295, -0.01624787226319313, -0.014184857718646526, -0.016291482374072075, -0.022359473630785942, 0.02533145248889923, -0.01496800221502781, 0.011729220859706402, 0.057366400957107544, 0.06697459518909454, 0.03289923444390297, 0.03533313795924187, -0.0720519945025444, -0.07358154654502869, 0.024199187755584717, -0.05387990549206734, -0.006017367821186781, 0.005023688077926636, 0.021568506956100464, -0.04391278326511383, -0.03269675746560097, 0.06169945001602173, -0.06299205869436264, 0.008485391736030579, -0.007315327879041433, -0.02477392740547657, -0.02006000280380249, -0.068520687520504, -0.015469425357878208, -0.04937702789902687, 0.010490300133824348, -0.08052903413772583, -0.011774134822189808, 0.017805946990847588, -0.03528890013694763, 0.004116466734558344, 0.014216895215213299, -0.0072781420312821865, -0.008237164467573166, 0.010559198446571827, -0.0009777722880244255, 0.049689386039972305, -0.04214370995759964, 0.03938354551792145, 0.026285341009497643, -0.005741374101489782, 0.040545541793107986, -0.07013995945453644, 0.026857703924179077, -0.04571205750107765, -0.00692010298371315, 0.02376401238143444, -0.057817235589027405, 0.0014428996946662664, -0.04364797845482826, 0.01862265169620514, -0.07048279792070389, -0.06274456530809402, 0.05285158380866051, -0.07037384063005447, -0.0043916525319218636, -0.016890577971935272, 0.023855358362197876, 0.011058082804083824, 0.022522471845149994, 0.056264739483594894, -0.05141327902674675, 0.08686292171478271, 0.055317241698503494, 0.038314059376716614, -0.010059789754450321, -0.003507315879687667, 0.0342404879629612, 0.011051920242607594, 0.0006095465505495667, 0.01715722121298313, -0.01410242635756731, 0.05508052185177803, -0.025731127709150314, 0.044508084654808044, 0.03347122669219971, -0.05577133595943451, 0.019624894484877586, 0.037371937185525894, 0.04036426916718483, -0.0022537601180374622, 0.03460882976651192, -0.04864700138568878, 0.08561038225889206, 0.07018669694662094, -0.013441315852105618, -0.04230700433254242, -0.053137023001909256, -0.006793998181819916, 0.01617218367755413, -0.016453763470053673, 0.00043496806756593287, 0.04119986295700073, 0.010216389782726765, 0.006816292181611061, 0.040191300213336945, 0.03232027217745781, -0.04971272125840187, 0.0432690866291523, -0.02414838597178459, 0.05768362432718277, -0.06556693464517593, -0.00770588917657733, -0.05919462814927101, -0.027161624282598495, -0.02148224227130413, -0.005358390975743532, -0.03446369990706444, -0.0009286405984312296, 0.034313611686229706, 0.04943856596946716, -0.023111946880817413, -0.037751659750938416, 0.07078895717859268, 0.005224310327321291, 0.0029669180512428284, -0.043546129018068314, 0.017706237733364105, 0.03153382986783981, -0.062504343688488, -0.012751101516187191, -0.033277738839387894, 0.029711632058024406, 0.021220354363322258, 0.023850174620747566, 0.020065749064087868, 0.007309924811124802, 0.02388342283666134, 0.0033926512114703655, -0.058952365070581436, 0.03402617201209068, 0.01008235476911068, -0.01686745323240757, -0.05995003134012222, 0.06774905323982239, -0.02057182975113392, -0.03998423367738724, 0.042210713028907776, 0.01807396300137043, 0.03956059738993645, 0.022694677114486694, 0.008545679971575737, -0.052230507135391235, -0.012089741416275501, 0.03900903835892677, -0.0047607868909835815, -0.06688890606164932, -0.01683136820793152, -0.021704545244574547, 0.02711113914847374, -0.015894001349806786, -0.0017701787874102592, -0.061958927661180496, -0.032509010285139084, -0.026974940672516823, 0.0030703614465892315, -0.002427726751193404, 0.005681778769940138, 0.0068587264977395535, -0.039275702089071274, 0.028729921206831932, -0.00009042035526363179, 0.035014569759368896, 0.013989092782139778, -0.034491244703531265, -0.010042892768979073, 0.008706452324986458, 0.047486644238233566, 0.02476765774190426, -0.013977530412375927, 0.0033838688395917416, 0.00838908739387989, -0.012866307981312275, -0.025450030341744423, -0.0034418636932969093, 0.042030397802591324, 0.035212479531764984, -0.037538446485996246, -0.03759577497839928, -0.027296315878629684, 0.03964557871222496, -0.0015067713102325797, -0.0028782717417925596, -0.016479244455695152, -0.022011660039424896, -0.017127303406596184, 0.025223437696695328, 0.00902542658150196, 0.004965117666870356, -0.00919333379715681, 0.04023553431034088, 0.021753443405032158, 0.011599487625062466, 0.027671996504068375, -0.10621307045221329, -0.06620749086141586, 0.04794244468212128, 0.015121123753488064, 0.049972373992204666, 0.014562001451849937, -0.07543423771858215, -0.08135975152254105, 0.0466940701007843, -0.000042092546209460124, 0.01902618631720543, -0.028319459408521652, -0.04981959983706474, 0.021824611350893974, 0.006021010223776102, 0.003980105277150869, -0.005230257753282785, 0.0005956963868811727, -0.006985432002693415, -0.005093404557555914, 0.05286890268325806, 0.01010918989777565, 0.0201762393116951, 0.038354139775037766, 0.011266612447798252, 0.04547186568379402, 0.05139380320906639, 0.031225083395838737, -0.06740530580282211, -0.00159592239651829, 0.015313842333853245, -0.0027099153958261013, 0.03339048847556114, -0.0678427591919899, -0.05796370655298233, -0.0010640030959621072, 0.05738666281104088, -0.005953928921371698, -0.017796561121940613, -0.0234649870544672, 0.041532959789037704, -0.06254547089338303, 0.020788894966244698, -0.012084591202437878, -0.04078330844640732, 0.010454805567860603, 0.005647431127727032, 0.01925666071474552, 0.006195851135998964, 0.057210687547922134, -0.04439646378159523, 0.005772384814918041, 0.013677363283932209, -0.030558094382286072, 0.00030836398946121335, -0.028635818511247635, -0.006770015694200993, -0.06776221096515656, 0.06912487745285034, 0.02865183912217617, 0.08414039015769958, -0.0004554910701699555, -0.01741231419146061, -0.043327752500772476, 0.036899134516716, 0.04885875806212425, -0.036327019333839417, -0.002344105625525117, 0.03762609511613846, 0.006064139772206545, 0.010575017891824245, 0.010306707583367825, -0.028369523584842682, 0.06447955220937729, -0.04668882116675377, -0.036038052290678024, -0.027641475200653076, 0.0687563419342041, -0.004898067098110914, -0.03416828438639641, -0.02106216549873352, -0.0026565042790025473, -0.008222292177379131, 0.006986092776060104, 0.045246247202157974, -0.007305458653718233, -0.0502341128885746, 0.08211273699998856, -0.008306646719574928, 0.016218110918998718, 0.015102934092283249, -0.0128907710313797, -0.02908330410718918, -0.011294486001133919, -0.016419684514403343, 0.0826837420463562, 0.02939745970070362, 0.01982991211116314, 0.032811474055051804, -0.02904445491731167, -0.020849552005529404, -0.030679157003760338, -0.018306784331798553, -0.04271697625517845, 0.041640762239694595, 0.010062609799206257, 0.007732907310128212, 0.012735550291836262, 0.023972773924469948, 0.018265165388584137, 0.03809966892004013, -0.00003108688906650059, -0.021075958386063576, 0.0038127650041133165, -0.013446190394461155, -0.07161562144756317, -0.05335034430027008, -0.027600813657045364, -0.01572505570948124, -0.027908483520150185, 0.02886272594332695, 0.018134092912077904, -0.009277541190385818, -0.007572531700134277, -0.0005212649120949209, 0.048597097396850586, -0.06416957825422287, 0.03633623197674751, 0.015789881348609924, 0.008232197724282742, -0.017746757715940475, -0.00485921511426568, 0.01616153120994568, -0.011960959993302822, -0.021439073607325554, 0.02007116563618183, 0.025134436786174774, -0.04201749339699745, 0.033223945647478104, 0.04746647924184799, -0.019450316205620766, 0.013243922032415867, -0.009373542852699757, 0.02181609719991684, -0.026668472215533257, 0.015581968240439892, -0.005914426874369383, -0.03762519732117653, -0.01286359317600727, -0.04885619506239891, -0.0074059790931642056, 0.0367593914270401, 0.014814062044024467, 0.017768267542123795, -0.03613788262009621, -0.006544733885675669, 0.02997196838259697, 0.031722575426101685, 0.024323884397745132, 0.06771281361579895, -0.06899572908878326, -0.004885471425950527, 0.02600082941353321, 0.04018913954496384, -0.0040710908360779285, -0.010250721126794815, -0.003252075519412756, 0.10147219151258469, -0.04846251383423805, 0.08584138005971909, -0.011602403596043587, -0.035290732979774475, -0.03790890425443649, -0.020730622112751007, 0.08257247507572174, 0.006576412823051214, -0.054558634757995605, 0.041402917355298996, 0.029852477833628654, 0.003305413294583559, -0.06493611633777618, 0.07698462158441544, -0.03941874951124191, -0.07438603788614273, 0.008275048807263374, -0.062267545610666275, 0.020712846890091896, 0.008959717117249966, 0.010618316940963268, 0.021320924162864685, 0.08894747495651245, -0.049359891563653946, 0.04475947842001915, 0.04275389015674591, 0.0038456262554973364, 0.011910275556147099, 0.017758809030056, 0.05097830295562744, -0.007443898357450962, -0.02247881144285202, 0.0568012073636055, 0.005454509984701872, -0.012653465382754803, 0.03816499933600426, 0.022438807412981987, -0.010314727202057838, 0.0073369406163692474, -0.04302666708827019 ]
<p>Let's say I ask a robot a question: "Why is partial differential equations no fun at all?" </p> <p>Suppose the robot is stupid and categorizes my question inside the class of "cats" so it replies with: "Cats are fluffy and awesome."</p> <p>So I reword my question over and over and sadly the robot keeps hitting the "cats" class. Sequential hits is an example of a risk factor. It indicates that perhaps something is wrong with the "cats" class in the robot's brain. Maybe the word "PDEs" appears as sample text under the class to draw from. </p> <p>Suppose I have a collection of classes (e.g. "cats", "dogs") that all share the same risk factors(e.g. "sequential hits","bad user scores",etc). </p> <p>Each risk factor has its own weight which I can adjust from 0-10 where 0 essentially means that I can completely drop the risk factor and 10 is the most important.</p> <p>For each class, I can multiply the occurrence of each risk factor by its respective weight and sum them all to obtain a risk score for the class.</p> <p>Thus, each class has a risk score and I can focus on fixing the classes with the highest risk scores.</p> <p>My question is this: How can I optimally choose the weights of the risk factors to give me what are truly the riskiest classes?</p> <p>This is a pretty open question. I am looking for ideas, papers, books, or statistical techniques that might be helpful to this endeavor. Much thanks.</p>
g36680
[ 0.03659592196345329, 0.0089051378890872, 0.009063642472028732, -0.020629143342375755, 0.06504266709089279, -0.02512863092124462, -0.028195016086101532, -0.0029683071188628674, -0.07866180688142776, -0.016200561076402664, 0.007098346017301083, 0.04518658295273781, 0.08683036267757416, 0.005851023364812136, -0.0007923837983980775, 0.023715509101748466, 0.0332830436527729, 0.013983415439724922, -0.010133123956620693, -0.022174863144755363, 0.045966874808073044, 0.012986849062144756, 0.040904950350522995, -0.023634735494852066, -0.03633502498269081, -0.012932009994983673, -0.026246696710586548, 0.023501388728618622, -0.05076976865530014, 0.044034626334905624, -0.07795080542564392, -0.014668391086161137, 0.009329444728791714, -0.04276254028081894, -0.026242466643452644, -0.016044285148382187, 0.04776245355606079, 0.026615725830197334, -0.03570571169257164, 0.024405723437666893, -0.019254256039857864, 0.03734789043664932, 0.056253582239151, -0.012896548956632614, -0.00995543785393238, -0.000007248475412779953, -0.020064624026417732, -0.027313152328133583, 0.026379629969596863, 0.021723847836256027, 0.023855993524193764, 0.013962173834443092, -0.011225654743611813, -0.03218236565589905, 0.03447532653808594, -0.011051311157643795, 0.0027941837906837463, 0.013860194943845272, -0.04311363771557808, -0.03613840788602829, -0.0009502238826826215, 0.02691260166466236, -0.049929436296224594, -0.03218792378902435, 0.003264839295297861, 0.03463366627693176, -0.024792233482003212, 0.049021098762750626, -0.0507347546517849, 0.013912465423345566, -0.0040419744327664375, 0.013119125738739967, 0.009237270802259445, 0.01772327907383442, -0.0389484204351902, 0.0014556559035554528, -0.007119473535567522, 0.01422810833901167, 0.030313672497868538, 0.05117722228169441, 0.010790281929075718, 0.0006802215939387679, 0.009062133729457855, -0.025338713079690933, 0.0005074195796623826, -0.000995645415969193, -0.010524533689022064, -0.041833002120256424, -0.0044616893865168095, -0.011282178573310375, -0.020760269835591316, -0.03244965150952339, 0.024066070094704628, 0.07401979714632034, -0.035845961421728134, 0.03189358860254288, -0.09456463903188705, 0.009639770723879337, 0.01878763735294342, -0.02975035086274147, 0.00971758272498846, 0.039507485926151276, 0.062096502631902695, -0.07491771131753922, -0.06880488991737366, -0.04775792360305786, 0.0673164650797844, -0.028471557423472404, -0.022134894505143166, -0.0002971290668938309, -0.014407791197299957, -0.019522441551089287, -0.06034379079937935, -0.034327227622270584, -0.016293853521347046, 0.0002932634961325675, 0.029996953904628754, 0.04658598080277443, -0.01917787827551365, 0.04161320626735687, -0.04543487727642059, -0.04519063979387283, -0.001958320615813136, 0.04074787721037865, -0.025568673387169838, -0.01006148848682642, -0.024752285331487656, 0.02361658215522766, 0.07807967811822891, -0.04372202605009079, 0.033275503665208817, -0.002607946749776602, 0.01523631252348423, 0.018712172284722328, -0.03450087830424309, 0.09909962862730026, -0.030005238950252533, 0.015001174993813038, 0.02152109518647194, -0.04940720647573471, 0.004599808249622583, 0.031017746776342392, 0.028705550357699394, 0.01227258425205946, 0.013642829842865467, 0.019702548161149025, -0.041184283792972565, 0.015466992743313313, -0.02272295393049717, -0.010451056994497776, 0.00366405863314867, 0.0065024844370782375, -0.09336792677640915, -0.007920224219560623, 0.027086704969406128, 0.024236587807536125, 0.027803506702184677, 0.007698519621044397, -0.0034865543711930513, 0.027071520686149597, 0.053459636867046356, -0.012658822350203991, -0.009809487499296665, -0.011521806940436363, -0.035413555800914764, 0.05871230736374855, 0.03947025537490845, -0.020473239943385124, -0.05128742754459381, 0.024360859766602516, -0.03249683603644371, -0.006382721941918135, 0.07307957857847214, 0.042137205600738525, 0.033717621117830276, 0.017121296375989914, -0.004912196658551693, -0.040446896106004715, 0.025733070448040962, 0.004665606189519167, 0.04033998027443886, -0.04054466634988785, 0.07795166224241257, 0.019871212542057037, -0.0016148575814440846, 0.0039948937483131886, -0.017437942326068878, 0.08376479148864746, -0.02317722514271736, 0.045674942433834076, -0.009840425103902817, -0.0010566317941993475, 0.024574873968958855, -0.06515569239854813, -0.004937932826578617, -0.03770379722118378, -0.0033629126846790314, -0.005335845984518528, -0.059580814093351364, 0.002032723743468523, 0.038541510701179504, 0.04261133447289467, -0.07029853016138077, 0.0152395935729146, -0.05908767133951187, -0.021030955016613007, 0.038173552602529526, -0.014228813350200653, -0.025810925289988518, -0.05503541976213455, 0.06891217082738876, -0.05410779267549515, -0.03627943620085716, 0.050116922706365585, -0.017572447657585144, 0.002240436617285013, -0.023547226563096046, -0.017396679148077965, 0.008322513662278652, -0.0050202179700136185, 0.017261669039726257, -0.00021795295469928533, 0.0017602016450837255, 0.0028192070312798023, -0.03927168250083923, 0.0846375897526741, -0.0006450099172070622, -0.019177226349711418, 0.0116023700684309, 0.02186180278658867, -0.04720304533839226, 0.009369987063109875, 0.00927872583270073, -0.046506404876708984, 0.032707687467336655, 0.022620629519224167, 0.04817308112978935, -0.0010430908296257257, 0.007953372783958912, 0.009038480930030346, 0.0712059810757637, 0.033947236835956573, 0.014271816238760948, 0.001565792947076261, -0.005583107937127352, -0.05776505172252655, -0.0006751379114575684, 0.009760763496160507, 0.021663546562194824, 0.08722181618213654, -0.033152900636196136, -0.053308308124542236, -0.04438185319304466, -0.00018397916574031115, 0.03201962262392044, -0.030864998698234558, 0.0022794182877987623, 0.024492992088198662, 0.04884034022688866, 0.006199801806360483, 0.03207680210471153, 0.022715086117386818, 0.014924997463822365, -0.00040139915654435754, -0.02467273361980915, 0.008146273903548717, -0.01877432130277157, -0.058481600135564804, -0.025923892855644226, 0.038984961807727814, -0.03425193205475807, -0.0084104984998703, 0.04506324604153633, 0.011373970657587051, -0.004980991128832102, 0.014012500643730164, -0.015825415030121803, -0.025181982666254044, -0.022608764469623566, 0.041221920400857925, 0.05551246553659439, -0.014401519671082497, -0.03560681268572807, 0.006285201758146286, 0.07271885126829147, 0.018072355538606644, 0.10989347100257874, 0.02874230034649372, -0.036634597927331924, -0.0000630421782261692, -0.03203690052032471, 0.04131649062037468, 0.06080085039138794, -0.014987886883318424, 0.014498350210487843, 0.04494834691286087, -0.016282211989164352, -0.047632548958063126, 0.03390905633568764, 0.007831694558262825, -0.034313932061195374, 0.01979583315551281, 0.03947547450661659, -0.005820156075060368, -0.027066316455602646, 0.014713374897837639, -0.007714930921792984, 0.044307176023721695, -0.01737217977643013, -0.020114032551646233, -0.01089499518275261, 0.035689935088157654, 0.008622851222753525, -0.02052907459437847, -0.013441444374620914, -0.011770096607506275, 0.029743732884526253, -0.04096030071377754, -0.029480913653969765, -0.08132936805486679, -0.03722437098622322, -0.051351238042116165, 0.011578245088458061, -0.028887055814266205, -0.020331449806690216, 0.07380397617816925, -0.0719507485628128, 0.032539572566747665, -0.03315676748752594, -0.01027788408100605, 0.08447138965129852, 0.06361804157495499, -0.014742798171937466, -0.005589951761066914, -0.018303610384464264, -0.027715768665075302, 0.025099370628595352, 0.025489136576652527, 0.02645074389874935, -0.008930511772632599, -0.040932103991508484, -0.07283452153205872, 0.0463077612221241, -0.058250874280929565, -0.03493750840425491, 0.024975115433335304, 0.07418949156999588, 0.04956674575805664, 0.08179652690887451, -0.0410505086183548, -0.01816241443157196, -0.02683350071310997, -0.01053084060549736, 0.05163329467177391, 0.08134273439645767, 0.02380559779703617, -0.0031129526905715466, -0.01695743203163147, -0.02239863947033882, 0.022126970812678337, -0.06094680726528168, -0.05133795365691185, -0.04243025928735733, 0.0225889440625906, 0.017892595380544662, -0.022962771356105804, 0.03464549779891968, 0.06113336607813835, -0.03504763916134834, -0.016754338517785072, 0.059945229440927505, -0.03558790683746338, 0.008553173393011093, -0.016831785440444946, -0.008173695765435696, 0.004922789521515369, -0.01469921413809061, 0.027548927813768387, 0.014939134940505028, -0.02822900377213955, 0.018410466611385345, 0.021101417019963264, 0.06947696208953857, -0.01491238921880722, 0.04369861260056496, 0.033955421298742294, -0.05833246558904648, -0.03333241492509842, 0.06090891361236572, 0.07703737914562225, -0.014037763699889183, -0.014108133502304554, -0.025700215250253677, 0.009747929871082306, 0.03952882066369057, -0.020376665517687798, -0.008988958783447742, -0.005282564088702202, 0.027871204540133476, 0.07283757627010345, -0.0330643467605114, -0.04036319628357887, 0.05465894564986229, 0.01692749373614788, -0.046090349555015564, -0.010246830992400646, 0.012762636877596378, -0.0176366176456213, -0.012864209711551666, 0.028125042095780373, -0.043012529611587524, -0.02257266826927662, -0.0285943690687418, -0.004996058065444231, 0.00476053636521101, -0.012586776167154312, 0.06846481561660767, -0.013211170211434364, 0.0012094578705728054, 0.024657921865582466, 0.013242289423942566, -0.04637308046221733, -0.10675179213285446, -0.06939574331045151, 0.00914138462394476, -0.032110463827848434, 0.05504860356450081, -0.00362103758379817, 0.05311830714344978, -0.005372508428990841, 0.04200787842273712, 0.028321560472249985, -0.06637781113386154, 0.07414829730987549, 0.028149882331490517, -0.0394565612077713, -0.019031470641493797, -0.007242346648126841, -0.051474057137966156, -0.010341820307075977, -0.0544331818819046, 0.007221536710858345, -0.07680521160364151, 0.01962856762111187, 0.02941170334815979, 0.07926733046770096, -0.02351003885269165, -0.012451480142772198, -0.019385965541005135, 0.05117712542414665, -0.020625710487365723, 0.012529637664556503, 0.05607228726148605, 0.010055799037218094, -0.0014903763076290488, -0.014398030936717987, -0.03336159139871597, -0.017828157171607018, 0.03985606133937836, 0.022024080157279968, 0.021761907264590263, 0.012614191509783268, -0.028577523306012154, 0.022690968587994576, -0.040068987756967545, -0.00774475047364831, -0.06206174194812775, -0.011069200932979584, -0.0055485619232058525, -0.01587163470685482, 0.005301746539771557, 0.04637504741549492, 0.008315513841807842, 0.02856486849486828, 0.016793863847851753, -0.02433357760310173, -0.02307465486228466, -0.027940070256590843, 0.014363761991262436, 0.028321826830506325, -0.04406796395778656, -0.007048787083476782, -0.009220724925398827, 0.030202344059944153, -0.03134952113032341, -0.026833614334464073, -0.004024870228022337, -0.05897561460733414, 0.022091105580329895, -0.039420340210199356, 0.004713494796305895, 0.08845163881778717, 0.053540896624326706, 0.0008063961286097765, -0.008906855247914791, -0.012610718607902527, 0.046983327716588974, 0.03657166287302971, 0.08758889883756638, -0.020499616861343384, -0.03296912461519241, 0.025999462231993675, 0.02745644934475422, -0.01132003404200077, -0.026320742443203926, 0.013399031944572926, -0.0003957412554882467, -0.027302231639623642, -0.04987802356481552, 0.037054747343063354, -0.011455798521637917, 0.03575443848967552, 0.04257376492023468, 0.03150363266468048, -0.027164092287421227, -0.019912801682949066, -0.008697286248207092, 0.004893559496849775, -0.039292652159929276, -0.003513593692332506, 0.05723639205098152, -0.06215948611497879, 0.007037297356873751, 0.04449236020445824, 0.020169585943222046, -0.060068529099226, 0.0057486617006361485, -0.0890941396355629, -0.006169646978378296, -0.028481047600507736, 0.03600788116455078, 0.004103129263967276, -0.04123149812221527, -0.006187167949974537, -0.055025774985551834, -0.0038593756034970284, 0.04752745479345322, 0.02647632174193859, -0.013248059898614883, 0.054535046219825745, 0.0020120961125940084, 0.022176215425133705, 0.039659105241298676, -0.04011773690581322, -0.0030505687464028597, -0.04479486867785454, -0.0003888397477567196, -0.004490983672440052, -0.04074793681502342, -0.04301224648952484, 0.020206356421113014, 0.03514380007982254, 0.047735776752233505, -0.01690482348203659, 0.03543800488114357, 0.00395056139677763, -0.008451169356703758, -0.014378264546394348, -0.009478362277150154, 0.011725110933184624, -0.02575261890888214, -0.02826077677309513, 0.0002685151994228363, -0.045300453901290894, -0.008022831752896309, 0.02409380115568638, -0.03225834667682648, -0.02927357330918312, 0.042705606669187546, 0.024400189518928528, 0.03309530392289162, 0.0028478484600782394, -0.028446940705180168, -0.007570838555693626, 0.01461382582783699, -0.06882929056882858, -0.0020756032317876816, -0.02506904862821102, 0.00028600962832570076, -0.02138153649866581, -0.07518099993467331, -0.005893303547054529, -0.04923192039132118, -0.035552628338336945, -0.04357806593179703, 0.05345674604177475, -0.0006351456395350397, -0.015535987913608551, -0.03268231824040413, -0.04292150214314461, -0.04109802842140198, -0.015006490051746368, -0.05607571080327034, -0.024782968685030937, -0.021289752796292305, -0.0238809734582901, 0.01749749295413494, 0.019518066197633743, -0.009336007758975029, 0.028490224853157997, -0.005024488549679518, 0.03739722818136215, 0.06261973083019257, 0.025160489603877068, -0.015174467116594315, 0.025842173025012016, -0.012800205498933792, 0.06458797305822372, -0.006020268891006708, 0.03796940669417381, -0.0753936842083931, 0.02093428187072277, 0.03143051639199257, 0.04587998986244202, -0.03171586990356445, 0.008901077322661877, -0.003873361274600029, -0.05940756946802139, -0.03710681200027466, 0.009898263029754162, 0.0326591320335865, -0.03277508541941643, 0.0456283800303936, -0.0550251305103302, 0.03585965931415558, 0.05710373818874359, -0.019839711487293243, -0.02061736024916172, 0.07016704976558685, 0.0526428148150444, 0.015963127836585045, 0.041839614510536194, 0.008859469555318356, 0.0970781072974205, -0.02899353764951229, 0.0677231103181839, -0.10054340213537216, 0.060510847717523575, 0.004650042857974768, 0.017576633021235466, 0.04447779431939125, 0.044074397534132004, -0.0668875053524971, 0.019238073378801346, 0.05275370553135872, -0.01970510743558407, 0.05855996906757355, 0.01428354624658823, -0.04724302142858505, -0.03201837092638016, 0.06107024848461151, -0.004355072043836117, 0.010259173810482025, -0.04510214924812317, -0.006007702089846134, 0.048285339027643204, 0.011042078956961632, -0.010240433737635612, 0.01987142488360405, 0.023082483559846878, 0.003954587038606405, -0.04791015014052391, 0.005276048555970192, -0.021745590493083, -0.05961497128009796, 0.04296884685754776, 0.0020023954566568136, -0.03638043254613876, -0.030452676117420197, -0.003672887571156025, -0.003162966575473547, -0.013159356079995632, -0.057817257940769196, -0.005231245420873165, 0.002911378862336278, -0.0030701649375259876, 0.02806236408650875, 0.013732747174799442, 0.04910726845264435, 0.001676090294495225, 0.022757330909371376, 0.007079271133989096, -0.024450203403830528, -0.02250143513083458, 0.0160334762185812, 0.018849588930606842, -0.016413480043411255, 0.024820571765303612, 0.006327101495116949, -0.06266012787818909, -0.04839496314525604, -0.05277737230062485, -0.006691074464470148, -0.022236382588744164, -0.08364512771368027, -0.010735630057752132, -0.0198284313082695, 0.05733656883239746, 0.10323891043663025, 0.036056384444236755, -0.006605058908462524, 0.04037769138813019, 0.007371576968580484, 0.013813566416501999, 0.014949439093470573, -0.019448168575763702, -0.0048145148903131485, -0.023639289662241936, -0.0036150061059743166, -0.03670685365796089, 0.037624917924404144, 0.00031454316922463477, 0.002335397992283106, -0.05746513977646828, -0.044485099613666534, -0.017993973568081856, -0.02397771179676056, 0.0220897626131773, -0.02287920191884041, 0.0508221834897995, -0.014572884887456894, 0.005647285375744104, 0.016175562515854836, 0.011552490293979645, -0.024791225790977478, -0.09804905951023102, -0.009820236824452877, -0.053800515830516815, -0.0007490802090615034, 0.03615674749016762, -0.009779080748558044, -0.05769210681319237, -0.059299059212207794, 0.05758538097143173, 0.0523439384996891, 0.026597268879413605, -0.015510154888033867, -0.0024963142350316048, -0.005417348351329565, 0.026568666100502014, 0.013696643523871899, 0.0005195094854570925, -0.0014173907693475485, -0.032027825713157654, 0.020530547946691513, 0.013471812941133976, -0.052031468600034714, -0.018651597201824188, 0.02741212770342827, -0.05288403481245041, -0.052921537309885025, -0.01449457835406065, 0.007007614243775606, 0.010445993393659592, -0.04649913311004639, -0.021571317687630653, 0.03510310873389244, 0.00442849937826395, -0.004631908144801855, -0.02580459602177143, 0.011040345765650272, -0.057032641023397446, -0.05589647591114044, 0.022630365565419197, -0.0023248756770044565, -0.003809266956523061, 0.03576263040304184, -0.014089759439229965 ]
<p>I was reading this <code>[paper][1]</code> related to sparse online gaussian processes. However, I didn't get how the denominator in the equation 1 was derived?<img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/vr3dG.png" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>It was supposed to be P(D). I didn't get how the denominator was obtained. Further, the paper is saying that the posterior may not be gaussian. I don't know why it is so?</p>
g36681
[ 0.04095380753278732, -0.051396746188402176, -0.02165164053440094, -0.06083358824253082, 0.017125079408288002, 0.03278849646449089, 0.014194081537425518, 0.03421006724238396, 0.043905820697546005, -0.04645342752337456, -0.053212374448776245, 0.003930938895791769, 0.04699385538697243, -0.004723843652755022, -0.03436429426074028, -0.03365127742290497, 0.06902901083230972, 0.01733490079641342, -0.0015314135234802961, 0.016517847776412964, -0.046761248260736465, -0.017448795959353447, 0.04894733056426048, -0.043306492269039154, 0.04541613906621933, -0.025735853239893913, 0.008149394765496254, 0.002146292943507433, -0.08279407024383545, -0.020575232803821564, 0.01441237237304449, 0.020378056913614273, 0.022894473746418953, -0.01626136153936386, 0.0007069699349813163, 0.0003766427980735898, 0.062037549912929535, -0.03668615221977234, -0.011076855473220348, 0.007930479012429714, -0.0003191528667230159, -0.030798299238085747, 0.055891964584589005, 0.022355886176228523, -0.036256805062294006, 0.04185313358902931, -0.05762355402112007, 0.04166499525308609, -0.0038370147813111544, -0.05337967723608017, 0.023735126480460167, 0.06148471683263779, -0.010603351518511772, -0.05332396551966667, -0.001099808607250452, 0.04830100014805794, -0.02354152500629425, 0.04210798442363739, -0.017383912578225136, -0.015927547588944435, -0.03083105944097042, -0.034257687628269196, -0.009829997085034847, 0.011503235436975956, 0.05569585785269737, -0.005258601158857346, -0.006605681963264942, -0.014602710492908955, 0.01632235199213028, 0.007730495650321245, 0.047705017030239105, 0.017150163650512695, -0.02297322079539299, -0.04293438792228699, -0.011923326179385185, -0.033867403864860535, 0.023527130484580994, -0.008424879051744938, -0.04168004170060158, -0.008732645772397518, -0.04505115747451782, 0.02744279056787491, 0.07164504379034042, 0.057681094855070114, 0.051956694573163986, -0.01256297156214714, 0.006342564709484577, -0.023830467835068703, -0.019160423427820206, -0.005948278587311506, -0.03715561702847481, -0.008379270322620869, 0.048247527331113815, 0.04681379720568657, -0.03453108295798302, 0.007385876029729843, -0.017811719328165054, 0.06139287352561951, -0.01573728583753109, -0.014254933223128319, 0.001436531194485724, -0.010706148110330105, 0.03841632232069969, -0.06005252152681351, 0.036840345710515976, 0.039642851799726486, 0.05278414487838745, 0.0024933454114943743, -0.0008421968086622655, -0.043214838951826096, 0.0017616309924051166, -0.04016288369894028, -0.06802430748939514, -0.02813553251326084, 0.02795168198645115, -0.03313789889216423, 0.027823716402053833, -0.011862128973007202, 0.03658943995833397, -0.03241502493619919, 0.026868168264627457, 0.05334493890404701, -0.03823506832122803, 0.02561909519135952, 0.003542165504768491, 0.05094688758254051, 0.010854911059141159, 0.012253627181053162, 0.043508633971214294, 0.01961440220475197, 0.06187698617577553, -0.015221861191093922, 0.050833649933338165, 0.035209834575653076, 0.024267928674817085, 0.07488010078668594, -0.03122520074248314, -0.03736402466893196, -0.017084982246160507, 0.014680934138596058, 0.020279351621866226, 0.000605217763222754, 0.007395861204713583, -0.04101123660802841, -0.0093237878754735, 0.012782064266502857, 0.013288569636642933, -0.014436403289437294, 0.01639357954263687, -0.009931710548698902, -0.0006458857096731663, 0.030487066134810448, 0.013335122726857662, -0.015244008041918278, 0.021455595269799232, 0.029768284410238266, 0.020617811009287834, 0.01029920019209385, -0.008820240385830402, 0.003915548324584961, 0.08346063643693924, 0.0069259111769497395, -0.0366700105369091, 0.04582945257425308, -0.035010382533073425, 0.04645196348428726, 0.019552668556571007, -0.06373476982116699, -0.018913056701421738, -0.054018352180719376, -0.010644004680216312, 0.016196420416235924, 0.039252325892448425, 0.01715179905295372, 0.021632451564073563, 0.05337757244706154, 0.038847483694553375, -0.005638398230075836, -0.048374421894550323, 0.08322996646165848, -0.002751842373982072, -0.025218717753887177, 0.01721182093024254, -0.049372825771570206, 0.008411617949604988, -0.018753692507743835, -0.013802011497318745, 0.06410656869411469, -0.014972638338804245, -0.0032781604677438736, 0.002770699793472886, 0.015224211849272251, -0.028762657195329666, 0.04956403002142906, -0.05928221717476845, 0.029798997566103935, 0.04634017124772072, -0.0671943798661232, 0.017624564468860626, -0.035453882068395615, -0.034486547112464905, 0.015327390283346176, 0.020731868222355843, 0.02221987023949623, 0.016549430787563324, -0.007502218708395958, -0.011083394289016724, -0.03231702372431755, 0.015147476457059383, -0.0014625485055148602, -0.03702976554632187, -0.007102344650775194, -0.058950383216142654, 0.022734439000487328, 0.053675148636102676, -0.039903897792100906, 0.0035953859332948923, 0.02079850807785988, -0.00375723117031157, 0.017743729054927826, -0.02968529425561428, -0.05662335827946663, 0.03329890966415405, 0.04642076417803764, -0.014589485712349415, 0.06355075538158417, 0.027550548315048218, 0.009774378500878811, -0.02775547280907631, 0.034551240503787994, -0.05484066531062126, -0.03233955428004265, -0.027450144290924072, -0.010596474632620811, 0.034000251442193985, 0.048915211111307144, 0.0018767332658171654, 0.04636569693684578, -0.01968546025454998, 0.07949395477771759, -0.012692930176854134, -0.044788192957639694, 0.036845751106739044, 0.055939968675374985, 0.011640094220638275, -0.03646812215447426, 0.022358722984790802, -0.01827842742204666, -0.026417754590511322, 0.008956478908658028, -0.0013599991798400879, -0.00854543223977089, -0.012624068185687065, -0.02343517355620861, 0.008941791020333767, -0.060316476970911026, 0.043344106525182724, 0.003074741456657648, 0.0068868715316057205, -0.02909868210554123, -0.0005578838754445314, -0.06766077131032944, -0.01045435480773449, 0.035326167941093445, -0.004471790511161089, 0.0349150188267231, 0.0222940593957901, -0.024877376854419708, 0.03491070866584778, 0.00021210174600128084, 0.00820182915776968, 0.040857944637537, -0.011058340780436993, 0.0014726564986631274, 0.012287934310734272, -0.028380613774061203, 0.01978544145822525, -0.016086211428046227, 0.06296493113040924, 0.0060971928760409355, 0.0018308465369045734, -0.05900299921631813, -0.03515428677201271, -0.021229691803455353, 0.011578443460166454, -0.06276149302721024, 0.03673763945698738, 0.07279011607170105, 0.006947627291083336, 0.024647586047649384, 0.0234342273324728, 0.00609226431697607, -0.008464334532618523, 0.011601235717535019, 0.0193951278924942, 0.007399135734885931, -0.019111528992652893, -0.07077312469482422, 0.01535018440335989, -0.05330644175410271, -0.06693768501281738, -0.0542139858007431, -0.004353183321654797, 0.03178706020116806, 0.044799696654081345, -0.021782737225294113, 0.013282322324812412, 0.006586479023098946, -0.02876407280564308, 0.01330422144383192, -0.043260786682367325, 0.00497944513335824, 0.017457490786910057, -0.043600618839263916, 0.010711668990552425, -0.0029816036112606525, -0.07022742927074432, -0.04050447419285774, 0.01383812166750431, -0.014006891287863255, -0.0363229438662529, -0.04942977428436279, -0.06859222054481506, -0.05903829634189606, 0.04043200612068176, -0.01660105772316456, -0.03783474490046501, 0.0009923636680468917, 0.058989182114601135, -0.024555791169404984, 0.03833593428134918, 0.005561179015785456, 0.02098323404788971, -0.057648614048957825, -0.0004661991260945797, -0.093241848051548, -0.011439383029937744, -0.014622875489294529, 0.0358116589486599, -0.08128994703292847, -0.020918548107147217, -0.014299784786999226, -0.0470786951482296, 0.013687551021575928, -0.028679121285676956, -0.0070800804533064365, 0.03427781164646149, 0.08384215086698532, 0.02820257842540741, -0.024597780779004097, 0.001613082829862833, -0.02287725917994976, -0.04676050320267677, -0.04276832565665245, -0.04850555583834648, 0.009199905209243298, -0.019825376570224762, 0.030022555962204933, 0.002017838414758444, 0.033948011696338654, 0.05393802374601364, -0.04497608542442322, -0.021161753684282303, 0.03617401421070099, 0.04429534822702408, -0.021466201171278954, 0.025635290890932083, 0.0828467458486557, -0.05389225110411644, 0.004551630932837725, 0.013488616794347763, -0.016928045079112053, -0.03306163474917412, 0.021522268652915955, -0.01395347248762846, 0.02531258389353752, 0.019095541909337044, 0.04512081295251846, 0.00362056284211576, -0.016641890630126, 0.09811647236347198, 0.02485446259379387, 0.04390140250325203, 0.03884098306298256, 0.022532695904374123, 0.037728238850831985, -0.06786967813968658, -0.024721484631299973, 0.03675448149442673, -0.05966708064079285, 0.01872817799448967, 0.023209281265735626, -0.056609828025102615, -0.00716255372390151, 0.021271130070090294, 0.01661595143377781, 0.0075143384747207165, 0.03790810704231262, 0.05743229389190674, 0.04688287526369095, -0.0545414537191391, 0.01157258078455925, -0.010309282690286636, -0.013016209937632084, 0.00526698213070631, 0.011913171969354153, 0.005696575623005629, 0.01141299493610859, -0.036063551902770996, 0.013001110404729843, -0.0851479321718216, 0.007542438805103302, -0.04772764816880226, -0.030805883929133415, 0.029405761510133743, -0.004409781191498041, 0.06576699018478394, -0.01232490036636591, -0.0731046125292778, -0.00175151985604316, 0.01016456913203001, -0.02226814441382885, -0.004739264491945505, -0.039306867867708206, -0.02056247740983963, -0.010776637122035027, 0.04847387969493866, 0.017556294798851013, 0.0028105094097554684, -0.036104585975408554, 0.02381434477865696, 0.009663958102464676, 0.0007545168045908213, 0.019338857382535934, -0.04320469871163368, 0.04038744419813156, -0.00023188679188024253, 0.06054555997252464, -0.0014962843852117658, 0.006017150357365608, 0.004020846914499998, 0.01845492422580719, 0.04933292791247368, -0.011268949136137962, 0.05864045396447182, 0.03992384672164917, -0.0010212252382189035, -0.030389143154025078, 0.022603418678045273, -0.015651937574148178, -0.01135271042585373, 0.005637724418193102, 0.02029481716454029, -0.0017284450586885214, 0.1122579500079155, 0.03203093260526657, -0.02535180374979973, 0.03503774106502533, -0.009727495722472668, 0.001965457107871771, -0.09694898128509521, -0.009966684505343437, -0.0610344298183918, -0.0027078522834926844, 0.0275246761739254, 0.0018948244396597147, -0.04049847647547722, 0.007837681099772453, 0.01308364886790514, -0.028460027649998665, -0.03718852996826172, -0.0058417487889528275, -0.01199390459805727, 0.005142425186932087, 0.00022239783720578998, 0.03660597279667854, 0.0673581212759018, 0.02495575323700905, 0.04216619208455086, 0.0011199702275916934, -0.05691060051321983, -0.00017375964671373367, 0.0376528836786747, -0.06753193587064743, -0.05600160360336304, 0.08211378753185272, 0.02267543412744999, -0.08376927673816681, -0.02448563277721405, -0.009825681336224079, 0.0101957768201828, 0.04448080062866211, -0.006049367133527994, -0.020920684561133385, -0.0250705573707819, -0.013976874761283398, 0.002426240826025605, 0.0067943064495921135, -0.0355040580034256, -0.018339887261390686, -0.14705057442188263, -0.000709563959389925, -0.05068281665444374, -0.003508400171995163, 0.0242986511439085, 0.08094742894172668, 0.07533843070268631, -0.03310480713844299, 0.014978964813053608, 0.03871704265475273, 0.03284331038594246, -0.027152104303240776, 0.034323614090681076, -0.006984076462686062, -0.04285622388124466, 0.023961752653121948, 0.015782907605171204, 0.019955923780798912, 0.0004940817016176879, 0.010056807659566402, 0.04441026970744133, 0.07314981520175934, 0.0065136682242155075, -0.03016100823879242, -0.03355754166841507, -0.08721193671226501, -0.03625626489520073, -0.050398945808410645, 0.022483082488179207, -0.01642264612019062, -0.05636046454310417, 0.02734680287539959, -0.0004761297022923827, -0.006706868298351765, -0.022845381870865822, -0.013485090807080269, -0.0789615660905838, 0.0208889227360487, 0.024120867252349854, -0.015315338969230652, 0.022789904847741127, 0.00785528402775526, 0.024691950529813766, 0.01956108771264553, -0.04667068272829056, -0.034492675215005875, 0.009338832460343838, 0.001882020616903901, 0.030514445155858994, -0.019849754869937897, 0.002156471600756049, 0.04847700893878937, -0.021726058796048164, -0.00239728856831789, -0.049785397946834564, -0.02268427051603794, -0.0016733657103031874, 0.0018790699541568756, 0.02925904653966427, -0.017313748598098755, -0.03616998717188835, -0.01618160866200924, -0.00906025804579258, -0.025398341938853264, 0.030462706461548805, -0.003276754403486848, -0.002929534763097763, -0.0036090058274567127, -0.023444462567567825, 0.040602829307317734, -0.00016675690130796283, -0.022101635113358498, 0.04623645916581154, 0.035484857857227325, -0.009583499282598495, -0.00279994891025126, 0.026252953335642815, -0.04005223140120506, -0.02340072952210903, -0.05306847766041756, -0.013107603415846825, 0.000989088206551969, 0.005165942944586277, 0.0009060715092346072, 0.03759298846125603, 0.008405758067965508, -0.004474966786801815, 0.030489342287182808, 0.02597665786743164, 0.02355247549712658, -0.018632424995303154, 0.0901651456952095, -0.011311753652989864, -0.02737467736005783, -0.006044376641511917, -0.010198934003710747, 0.01615188829600811, 0.05602356418967247, -0.051068566739559174, -0.015149489045143127, -0.045656848698854446, -0.014847650192677975, -0.030528085306286812, -0.00807638093829155, -0.009203272871673107, -0.005052048247307539, -0.016580330207943916, 0.06600048393011093, -0.018737995997071266, 0.03267579525709152, -0.02755773812532425, 0.02568252757191658, -0.027794556692242622, 0.034860946238040924, 0.05544454604387283, -0.03937328979372978, -0.017455287277698517, 0.05710331350564957, 0.056420862674713135, -0.03957353159785271, -0.006865418050438166, 0.014847186394035816, 0.05518348515033722, -0.00814729742705822, -0.033125683665275574, 0.03203963488340378, -0.03171837702393532, -0.04668746516108513, 0.047268737107515335, 0.042390014976263046, 0.01331879198551178, 0.021433552727103233, -0.0024570468813180923, 0.039599400013685226, -0.007133313454687595, 0.033399105072021484, -0.04381508007645607, 0.019473066553473473, 0.04894255846738815, 0.023906948044896126, 0.03859908506274223, 0.0084832226857543, -0.01194639503955841, -0.009747461415827274, -0.08624426275491714, -0.011951683089137077, 0.0310039259493351, 0.07669813930988312, -0.04798399657011032, -0.02405914105474949, 0.04226738587021828, 0.0586295947432518, 0.009887932799756527, -0.060977503657341, 0.007680509705096483, -0.018257418647408485, 0.04033663496375084, -0.01224839873611927, 0.04406148940324783, -0.042131207883358, -0.04024394229054451, -0.026669399812817574, -0.01937757432460785, 0.06869148463010788, 0.009077409282326698, -0.018420323729515076, -0.018438436090946198, -0.0138089032843709, 0.01247168518602848, -0.05538218095898628, -0.02121965028345585, -0.049131669104099274, -0.0024759764783084393, 0.01818515546619892, 0.007848287932574749, 0.04632493108510971, 0.02053930051624775, 0.0046999407932162285, -0.046429477632045746, 0.0214692410081625, 0.035017989575862885, 0.020609179511666298, -0.03912686929106712, -0.0275423564016819, -0.04070691391825676, -0.018750101327896118, 0.03374970704317093, -0.03920788690447807, -0.01290309801697731, 0.0016735624521970749, -0.017435334622859955, 0.015355272218585014, 0.05148591101169586, -0.006539491470903158, 0.022202804684638977, 0.03758895397186279, 0.005718155298382044, -0.006246834062039852, 0.028896884992718697, 0.04373505711555481, 0.029895218089222908, -0.039300691336393356, -0.0333891287446022, 0.015155300498008728, -0.011647176928818226, -0.03624334558844566, -0.0004446106613613665, -0.001025015371851623, 0.02712494321167469, -0.11363609880208969, 0.022827140986919403, -0.04219038039445877, -0.053425539284944534, -0.03190907463431358, 0.08302075415849686, -0.021483352407813072, -0.04663259908556938, 0.01910700649023056, -0.03835110738873482, -0.019013918936252594, 0.0293204877525568, 0.02200690098106861, -0.09784922003746033, -0.04910491034388542, -0.012147924862802029, -0.06364154070615768, 0.04350715130567551, -0.011162993498146534, 0.0010951173026114702, 0.035158753395080566, -0.09150660037994385, 0.020944833755493164, -0.05028344690799713, 0.04550920054316521, 0.010856051929295063, -0.00995832122862339, -0.005760660860687494, 0.020562125369906425, 0.07191361486911774, -0.010139981284737587, -0.03803268447518349, -0.024317186325788498, 0.11237138509750366, -0.048588696867227554, 0.0578719861805439, -0.02472657337784767, -0.0353204719722271, -0.00452564749866724, 0.013443516567349434, -0.0349203422665596, -0.02205302193760872, 0.01471848227083683, -0.03115801513195038, -0.005483295768499374, 0.06854464113712311, -0.01990106888115406, 0.04336288571357727, 0.05681755021214485, 0.05173439905047417, -0.038548585027456284, 0.0025782380253076553, -0.05776703730225563, -0.02794952504336834, 0.03015185333788395, -0.027981415390968323, -0.055269524455070496, -0.027383215725421906, 0.03867136687040329 ]
<p>Suppose I have a dataset with the following information:</p> <ul> <li>N objects, each of which can be rated</li> <li>The number of ratings per object is variable (raters are unidentified), e.g., there are 30 objects each with a unique id</li> <li>Each row has the predicted rating, the actual rating, and the difference between the two, which is an ordinal value, say between 0 and 10</li> </ul> <p>How do I measure the consistency of ratings per object and for the whole dataset? Basically, there is a distribution of "differences" per object. What are the various ways to approach this problem? Thank you. </p>
g6464
[ -0.003941552713513374, -0.003824254497885704, -0.015519032254815102, -0.08267205208539963, 0.026679378002882004, -0.03538558632135391, -0.042306628078222275, 0.021606765687465668, -0.039134152233600616, -0.01712888665497303, 0.005829394795000553, 0.006171883083879948, 0.033523932099342346, 0.014225064776837826, 0.017197400331497192, 0.06362500041723251, -0.002298085018992424, -0.07781427353620529, 0.048563845455646515, 0.026514017954468727, 0.040762338787317276, 0.03141961619257927, 0.062426045536994934, -0.013633638620376587, 0.024189379066228867, -0.002808509161695838, 0.022968299686908722, -0.009198232553899288, -0.045259058475494385, 0.047792185097932816, -0.02097427099943161, -0.01828041858971119, 0.01941976509988308, -0.046784408390522, -0.01093105785548687, -0.014136656187474728, 0.0010949682909995317, 0.05526220425963402, 0.03156145662069321, 0.06844504922628403, 0.002886625239625573, 0.023263992741703987, 0.08915858715772629, 0.007924244739115238, -0.0055315690115094185, -0.02686387114226818, -0.06852440536022186, -0.014649922028183937, 0.003863611724227667, 0.08315527439117432, -0.03968173637986183, 0.029539670795202255, 0.047261495143175125, 0.05883270502090454, 0.032554395496845245, 0.01839492842555046, -0.015874559059739113, 0.025929059833288193, 0.04912476986646652, 0.01170414686203003, 0.07195273786783218, -0.0394943468272686, -0.010696141980588436, -0.04200043901801109, 0.02400142326951027, 0.06342484056949615, -0.052974600344896317, 0.028168844059109688, -0.016926608979701996, -0.038013067096471786, -0.02559923380613327, 0.0414557047188282, -0.02015799470245838, -0.000020041330571984872, -0.08837524056434631, -0.009588961489498615, -0.009119386784732342, 0.020018579438328743, 0.021805649623274803, 0.04786253720521927, -0.016199827194213867, 0.026085468009114265, 0.028890402987599373, 0.012518567033112049, 0.009175147861242294, -0.04550545662641525, 0.006659912411123514, -0.006070365663617849, -0.020534098148345947, 0.026019670069217682, -0.013900338672101498, 0.014188268221914768, 0.042078178375959396, 0.01727866940200329, 0.0038438134361058474, -0.032691117376089096, -0.0624382384121418, 0.07985500246286392, -0.01908102259039879, -0.04121588543057442, -0.031674861907958984, 0.06430263072252274, -0.024723336100578308, -0.015444410964846611, -0.09020120650529861, 0.019131194800138474, 0.04994538798928261, 0.010755266062915325, 0.002645651111379266, -0.048457395285367966, -0.029023315757513046, -0.03360190987586975, -0.0617559440433979, -0.03528857231140137, -0.023018531501293182, 0.00018325373821426183, 0.056903090327978134, -0.05833665281534195, -0.05984194204211235, -0.05651293322443962, -0.02839886210858822, -0.025340193882584572, 0.0003674927866086364, 0.037788718938827515, 0.025983989238739014, 0.014245286583900452, 0.014172498136758804, 0.02621188387274742, 0.001510333502665162, 0.016153065487742424, 0.05665689334273338, -0.0322471559047699, -0.007185408379882574, -0.02025754749774933, -0.036528438329696655, 0.015043110586702824, 0.013921602629125118, 0.019924018532037735, 0.01571759209036827, 0.008934677578508854, -0.012797202914953232, 0.03039022535085678, -0.010546189732849598, -0.0213782899081707, 0.01547365915030241, -0.013161838985979557, 0.0006782524869777262, -0.002477551344782114, -0.015310973860323429, 0.014925302006304264, 0.08933679759502411, 0.030805181711912155, 0.025611896067857742, -0.023728998377919197, -0.09017019718885422, -0.06125708669424057, 0.007738269865512848, -0.018854280933737755, 0.019542133435606956, 0.017278647050261497, 0.027661949396133423, -0.007059516850858927, 0.08855188637971878, 0.026101969182491302, 0.01255821343511343, -0.003961921203881502, -0.0018481184961274266, 0.035529717803001404, 0.01523873582482338, -0.004892053548246622, 0.008604268543422222, -0.006377233192324638, -0.015301126055419445, 0.0020569658372551203, 0.03535846620798111, 0.055138036608695984, 0.029699737206101418, -0.004295667167752981, 0.020477406680583954, 0.050790730863809586, 0.008206148631870747, 0.007267635315656662, 0.05099724978208542, -0.017157455906271935, -0.03207751736044884, -0.06152071803808212, -0.014115005731582642, -0.04875967651605606, -0.003616008209064603, -0.006522480398416519, -0.02363382652401924, -0.028167378157377243, -0.008973375894129276, -0.029838688671588898, 0.0112150264903903, -0.002401749836280942, 0.025533851236104965, -0.06196605786681175, -0.045020151883363724, -0.08484144508838654, 0.028953861445188522, -0.005926466081291437, -0.02431827038526535, 0.07777271419763565, -0.04247887432575226, 0.033908575773239136, -0.03487639129161835, 0.003772375639528036, -0.006518097594380379, 0.04948943853378296, -0.003737939288839698, -0.01349479891359806, -0.02527519129216671, 0.01062912680208683, -0.01877044513821602, 0.0343930758535862, 0.01052766852080822, 0.003946598619222641, -0.02139497734606266, -0.02576264925301075, -0.058515068143606186, -0.04646870866417885, 0.016590215265750885, 0.01942950114607811, 0.014825028367340565, 0.03196323290467262, 0.05345255881547928, 0.01609957404434681, 0.06941322982311249, 0.02160678431391716, -0.008841181173920631, -0.04867568239569664, 0.033849235624074936, -0.005809679627418518, 0.021434558555483818, 0.048136770725250244, -0.060596976429224014, 0.01808336190879345, -0.016066955402493477, -0.047567181289196014, -0.012765897437930107, -0.02572786994278431, -0.0008595832041464746, 0.04423028603196144, 0.030506640672683716, 0.011577566154301167, 0.02033858373761177, 0.008599219843745232, 0.027524154633283615, 0.06558676809072495, -0.05342966690659523, 0.07104837149381638, -0.016096333041787148, 0.011506735347211361, 0.005047492682933807, -0.03917653113603592, 0.016449885442852974, 0.009521648287773132, -0.009343688376247883, -0.011374943889677525, -0.023069020360708237, -0.01008505281060934, 0.08229977637529373, -0.014485851861536503, -0.00008005979179870337, -0.03335290029644966, 0.04716673493385315, -0.004092929884791374, 0.04406023398041725, 0.018560292199254036, 0.016367681324481964, -0.021237412467598915, 0.017963871359825134, 0.040392499417066574, 0.0022825810592621565, 0.042461179196834564, -0.053777094930410385, -0.013656988739967346, -0.01571565307676792, 0.007569870445877314, 0.058230821043252945, 0.006894899066537619, -0.056147996336221695, -0.026828106492757797, 0.026649856939911842, 0.035263486206531525, 0.03334427252411842, -0.04283243417739868, 0.011901851743459702, 0.06297533214092255, -0.021776754409074783, 0.002495149150490761, 0.02623695693910122, -0.00995001383125782, -0.011010291986167431, -0.007416770793497562, 0.001964166294783354, 0.03310980647802353, 0.07144109904766083, -0.007310968358069658, -0.03370177373290062, -0.0024127326905727386, 0.031710244715213776, -0.006710464600473642, 0.040491849184036255, -0.022813856601715088, -0.04473811760544777, 0.02453007735311985, 0.0360894612967968, -0.04207790642976761, -0.020712150260806084, -0.010698662139475346, -0.03490135446190834, -0.05020318552851677, 0.03386560454964638, -0.047030121088027954, -0.010176468640565872, 0.034446507692337036, 0.0040100449696183205, -0.07203493267297745, 0.0007208273746073246, -0.03251185640692711, 0.0700225979089737, 0.041541870683431625, 0.007985840551555157, 0.007932189851999283, -0.06276045739650726, 0.0456673800945282, -0.029220381751656532, 0.032267551869153976, 0.016346551477909088, 0.09994187206029892, 0.030900420621037483, -0.01014837808907032, 0.00349026289768517, -0.029827164486050606, -0.03511827066540718, -0.027628961950540543, 0.06527141481637955, 0.08567307144403458, -0.05889049544930458, 0.0029074489139020443, -0.03766957297921181, -0.0110682537779212, -0.0364392064511776, 0.013603925704956055, 0.021551376208662987, -0.011089756153523922, 0.01736517623066902, 0.028371170163154602, 0.019345158711075783, -0.03316869959235191, -0.0012730550952255726, -0.005249695386737585, 0.03866622969508171, 0.00798778049647808, 0.0008195281261578202, 0.004574563819915056, 0.012864244170486927, 0.019628284499049187, 0.06808392703533173, -0.021799098700284958, -0.015821829438209534, -0.0331176333129406, -0.019566621631383896, 0.02128736674785614, 0.06348158419132233, 0.03364768624305725, 0.02932286635041237, -0.012810529209673405, 0.02999238297343254, 0.008216100744903088, 0.028438204899430275, -0.0712079405784607, 0.027878420427441597, -0.054918188601732254, 0.06397928297519684, 0.05902868136763573, 0.015569379553198814, 0.032033100724220276, -0.007131002843379974, 0.03754021227359772, -0.01896778680384159, -0.03761265426874161, -0.0538046769797802, -0.04311171546578407, 0.0018212228314951062, -0.006070615258067846, 0.028267402201890945, -0.05679481849074364, -0.06064855307340622, -0.049440305680036545, -0.05315615236759186, 0.06744888424873352, 0.05360441654920578, -0.06449191272258759, 0.02733004465699196, 0.04515243321657181, 0.029047541320323944, 0.07437216490507126, -0.06404262036085129, -0.016220061108469963, -0.03775271028280258, -0.05260225012898445, -0.013535650447010994, 0.017755728214979172, -0.012655180878937244, 0.027352888137102127, -0.012545336969196796, 0.02616911567747593, -0.028410809114575386, -0.028975792229175568, -0.0012767590815201402, -0.028583195060491562, -0.01329001970589161, -0.010319611988961697, 0.051989391446113586, 0.010658299550414085, -0.0015207557007670403, -0.017607219517230988, 0.007848957553505898, 0.09472032636404037, -0.03314201533794403, -0.03749283775687218, -0.028943881392478943, -0.03033706359565258, 0.006487073842436075, 0.06727853417396545, 0.05127885937690735, -0.0108875697478652, 0.024009378626942635, 0.013528146781027317, 0.019109008833765984, 0.03307855874300003, -0.019208015874028206, -0.036871496587991714, 0.013622134923934937, -0.004521816037595272, -0.053856804966926575, -0.04353858530521393, 0.004148824606090784, -0.009414362721145153, 0.024119900539517403, -0.010531019419431686, -0.028692055493593216, 0.03894393518567085, -0.03337574750185013, 0.015387585386633873, 0.03396018221974373, 0.0630931407213211, -0.010615618899464607, 0.03889074921607971, -0.012505319900810719, -0.01994672790169716, 0.02603987604379654, 0.01795797236263752, 0.10477247089147568, 0.034598685801029205, 0.027917444705963135, -0.019302671775221825, 0.025908775627613068, -0.05117769539356232, -0.0319671630859375, -0.04735825955867767, -0.0617816187441349, -0.026336058974266052, -0.014223101548850536, 0.021545298397541046, -0.000934186449740082, 0.00949239730834961, 0.0008563741575926542, 0.03332676365971565, -0.017631901428103447, -0.017380109056830406, -0.05396202206611633, 0.025328243151307106, 0.008352299220860004, -0.040716033428907394, 0.01780090108513832, -0.013572211377322674, -0.051733940839767456, 0.007669492159038782, 0.021284256130456924, -0.011409654282033443, 0.009665262885391712, -0.03234506770968437, 0.013678434304893017, -0.1019396111369133, 0.03402877599000931, 0.0002555328537710011, -0.007442649453878403, -0.006118860095739365, 0.022694354876875877, 0.05409673601388931, 0.00335996993817389, -0.015486794523894787, 0.02605009637773037, -0.047173161059617996, 0.029815133661031723, -0.04710466414690018, -0.03628304600715637, 0.07603612542152405, 0.04661424085497856, -0.03287317603826523, 0.019781427457928658, 0.008190697990357876, 0.07443645596504211, 0.011937580071389675, -0.022610323503613472, -0.03135162219405174, -0.019992781803011894, 0.06640888005495071, 0.05424805358052254, 0.035021111369132996, -0.06402960419654846, -0.016127677634358406, -0.005543755367398262, 0.04689659923315048, 0.001247238484211266, 0.005094860680401325, -0.016932833939790726, -0.01557134184986353, 0.011943786405026913, -0.031315214931964874, -0.027627667412161827, -0.04051279276609421, -0.03572893887758255, -0.07174352556467056, 0.020481573417782784, -0.015675224363803864, 0.009272652678191662, 0.046733029186725616, -0.050008222460746765, -0.06626180559396744, -0.02304375357925892, -0.03087301179766655, -0.0534757561981678, -0.032493241131305695, 0.029801052063703537, 0.013374144211411476, -0.007501153741031885, 0.05229764059185982, 0.063045434653759, -0.05945843458175659, -0.02548331767320633, -0.08215472847223282, -0.049687355756759644, -0.02177429385483265, 0.07811284065246582, 0.02890220284461975, 0.03415912389755249, 0.09966272860765457, -0.015126259997487068, -0.017206300050020218, 0.0490943007171154, -0.0126211978495121, 0.0670049712061882, -0.03458547219634056, 0.00039209602982737124, -0.02821086160838604, 0.01931593008339405, -0.07208287715911865, 0.03631642833352089, -0.03640235960483551, -0.01078494917601347, -0.019464725628495216, -0.053773194551467896, -0.009354664944112301, -0.05178585276007652, 0.031382765620946884, -0.0019776299595832825, -0.018538856878876686, 0.030171671882271767, 0.021129366010427475, -0.03456486389040947, 0.003304476384073496, -0.01521268580108881, -0.014683020301163197, 0.034237686544656754, -0.03753848001360893, 0.0024120763409882784, -0.02924821898341179, -0.012095145881175995, 0.0028593670576810837, -0.009740668348968029, 0.034039899706840515, 0.03757745027542114, -0.010184256359934807, -0.014195706695318222, -0.040822215378284454, 0.016270220279693604, -0.010774386115372181, 0.03581659868359566, -0.08305329084396362, -0.028134766966104507, -0.00093100406229496, 0.06950247287750244, 0.0260764192789793, 0.0013848065864294767, 0.030116062611341476, -0.01438217330724001, 0.0008371758740395308, -0.008728076703846455, -0.006484316196292639, 0.008924699388444424, -0.01693638227880001, -0.04189179465174675, -0.024268174543976784, 0.005398895125836134, -0.037342168390750885, 0.024267833679914474, 0.047717928886413574, 0.019894322380423546, 0.08428863435983658, -0.02774263732135296, -0.0007828386733308434, 0.012254842557013035, -0.0192442424595356, -0.0024786656722426414, -0.010100568644702435, -0.022792160511016846, -0.049139298498630524, 0.007316881325095892, -0.01779814437031746, 0.030743518844246864, -0.007857127115130424, -0.016347398981451988, -0.03129637613892555, 0.03295985609292984, 0.0017045249696820974, -0.030742358416318893, 0.00442343158647418, 0.029140248894691467, 0.04755159839987755, -0.034893542528152466, 0.04265587031841278, -0.057059407234191895, 0.054727550595998764, 0.019211269915103912, 0.0734281912446022, 0.04188837110996246, 0.041258104145526886, 0.028856970369815826, 0.039618298411369324, -0.017779946327209473, 0.011162982322275639, 0.05856569856405258, 0.04272919148206711, -0.0369340255856514, -0.010808028280735016, -0.008611674420535564, 0.0015689028659835458, 0.02259725145995617, 0.026132551953196526, -0.03332853317260742, 0.05721918120980263, -0.0015043499879539013, -0.020359165966510773, 0.028460772708058357, -0.03755073994398117, -0.03949267789721489, -0.054815810173749924, -0.001612114836461842, -0.026738207787275314, -0.016288967803120613, -0.01858701929450035, -0.07554692029953003, -0.057066258043050766, 0.016121871769428253, -0.03405183553695679, -0.012623577378690243, -0.057971831411123276, 0.04171475023031235, 0.012472238391637802, 0.08035124093294144, -0.004354081582278013, -0.03999318927526474, 0.03451729565858841, -0.016419613733887672, -0.015303774736821651, 0.012598587200045586, 0.006634498480707407, 0.010059923864901066, -0.02077804133296013, -0.028820572420954704, 0.016091516241431236, -0.0607488788664341, -0.03017193078994751, 0.07801222801208496, -0.04898964613676071, -0.06933564692735672, -0.061503197997808456, 0.002420473378151655, -0.0006031083757989109, -0.059840742498636246, 0.04413479194045067, -0.053311631083488464, 0.02116791158914566, 0.007642622105777264, -0.006161403842270374, 0.03263399749994278, -0.0004975895280949771, -0.006110878195613623, -0.008442023769021034, -0.0026389958802610636, 0.01247977465391159, -0.029344098642468452, -0.031052853912115097, 0.010256633162498474, -0.053401362150907516, -0.028017878532409668, -0.00892917811870575, -0.030808312818408012, -0.02197279967367649, -0.06162864342331886, -0.02387942560017109, -0.04554414376616478, 0.01582449860870838, 0.006485225632786751, -0.022638365626335144, -0.012793135829269886, -0.006736092735081911, 0.06663235276937485, 0.02373114787042141, 0.004133866634219885, -0.041102103888988495, -0.030602319166064262, -0.022460022941231728, 0.024508267641067505, 0.0180791225284338, 0.004007697105407715, 0.01312034111469984, -0.034450724720954895, 0.02416968159377575, 0.009556876495480537, 0.06504472345113754, -0.01634274423122406, 0.017743414267897606, 0.010809235274791718, 0.008114353753626347, 0.016919318586587906, 0.01996728777885437, -0.025699568912386894, -0.004257799591869116, -0.017923563718795776, 0.016383560374379158, -0.07455702126026154, 0.10170852392911911, 0.0005589263746514916, -0.0535542331635952, -0.08153294771909714, 0.0015645493986085057, -0.034927573055028915, 0.039925672113895416, -0.03263219818472862, 0.03055109828710556, 0.042331527918577194, -0.003096639411523938, -0.011692308820784092, 0.009797132574021816, -0.005603655241429806, 0.036155376583337784, -0.06059394031763077, 0.030200578272342682, -0.02751903608441353, 0.0021449029445648193, -0.042886748909950256, 0.013250528834760189 ]
<p>I'm trying to validate a series of words that are provided by users. I'm trying to come up with a scoring system that will determine the likelihood that the series of words are indeed valid words.</p> <p>Assume the following input:</p> <pre><code>xxx yyy zzz </code></pre> <p>The first thing I do is check each word individually against a database of words that I have. So, let's say that <code>xxx</code> was in the database, so we are 100% sure it's a valid word. Then let's say that <code>yyy</code> doesn't exist in the database, but a possible variation of its spelling exist (say <code>yyyy</code>). We don't give <code>yyy</code> a score of 100%, but maybe something lower (let's say 90%). Then <code>zzz</code> just doesn't exist at all in the database. So, <code>zzz</code> gets a score of 0%.</p> <p>So we have something like this:</p> <pre><code>xxx = 100% yyy = 90% zzz = 0% </code></pre> <p>Assume further that the users are either going to either:</p> <ol> <li>Provide a list of all valid words (most likely)</li> <li>Provide a list of all invalid words (likely)</li> <li>Provide a list of a mix of valid and invalid words (not likely)</li> </ol> <p>As a whole, what is a good scoring system to determine a confidence score that <code>xxx yyy zzz</code> is a series of valid words? I'm not looking for anything too complex, but getting the average of the scores doesn't seem right. If some words in the list of words are valid, I think it increases the likelihood that the word not found in the database is an actual word also (it's just a limitation of the database that it doesn't contain that particular word).</p> <p>NOTE: The input will generally be a minimum of 2 words (and mostly 2 words), but can be 3, 4, 5 (and maybe even more in some rare cases).</p> <p><strong>EXAMPLE 1:</strong></p> <p>Say the following scores:</p> <pre><code>xxx = 100% yyy = 100% zzz = 0% </code></pre> <p>The average is 66.66%. But since already two words in the list exist in the database, the chances are that <code>zzz</code> is also a real word. Scoring this series of words as just 66.66% seems low.</p>
g36683
[ -0.02134057506918907, 0.025126837193965912, 0.008055876940488815, -0.02796342968940735, -0.006303824950009584, 0.02718842215836048, -0.00466914800927043, 0.07948771119117737, 0.012186473235487938, 0.02279558591544628, -0.0039080725982785225, 0.02690051682293415, -0.0031156137119978666, 0.02067437581717968, -0.08901254087686539, 0.0036372567992657423, 0.012386172078549862, -0.03864491730928421, 0.03776603937149048, 0.038032371550798416, 0.010766766965389252, -0.02379785105586052, 0.045443322509527206, -0.04162804037332535, -0.06710602343082428, -0.0189987700432539, -0.013660059310495853, 0.042848050594329834, -0.050463009625673294, 0.0220671147108078, -0.005419360939413309, 0.05395689606666565, 0.047582823783159256, -0.03450819477438927, 0.032873015850782394, 0.009333256632089615, 0.03346326947212219, 0.04159874841570854, 0.002086398657411337, -0.03003831021487713, -0.014696851372718811, 0.058145929127931595, -0.0027495326939970255, 0.014834215864539146, -0.021657230332493782, 0.037310242652893066, -0.038276318460702896, 0.025108665227890015, 0.02788495644927025, -0.029086047783493996, -0.005260734353214502, -0.009766006842255592, 0.037743087857961655, 0.03833896294236183, 0.026730868965387344, 0.08128481358289719, -0.05401672422885895, -0.00010473012662259862, -0.033618394285440445, -0.01762215606868267, 0.009307663887739182, -0.00978273805230856, 0.02823268063366413, -0.01248350739479065, -0.015953823924064636, -0.013055279850959778, -0.03530926629900932, 0.00858727190643549, -0.01669309288263321, -0.03823484852910042, 0.01813741773366928, 0.016729019582271576, -0.026007389649748802, 0.014727744273841381, -0.07561188191175461, 0.020585620775818825, -0.07442136853933334, 0.07621264457702637, 0.010802021250128746, 0.05267840996384621, 0.05322425439953804, 0.009615526534616947, -0.024446357041597366, -0.007793505676090717, -0.05038747191429138, -0.004016214050352573, -0.027524974197149277, -0.042418863624334335, -0.03339344263076782, 0.01615702360868454, 0.02166386879980564, 0.0024037379771471024, 0.013576071709394455, 0.03930317610502243, -0.014875457622110844, 0.061130329966545105, -0.04955326020717621, -0.013318004086613655, 0.035257019102573395, -0.022128477692604065, 0.03444897383451462, 0.02374155819416046, 0.028533950448036194, -0.04044431447982788, -0.04040341451764107, -0.023886242881417274, -0.0036015789955854416, 0.016338206827640533, -0.05230492725968361, 0.028741935268044472, 0.009743429720401764, 0.03614015504717827, -0.051495809108018875, -0.0460490882396698, -0.019054671749472618, -0.008597901090979576, 0.05686040222644806, 0.010064439848065376, -0.0359702929854393, 0.025935616344213486, 0.02500692941248417, -0.015346969477832317, -0.03170043230056763, 0.0192489605396986, -0.04788011685013771, -0.030113210901618004, -0.020792236551642418, 0.03517814725637436, 0.06726609915494919, -0.053367190062999725, 0.007398642133921385, 0.009977574460208416, 0.0067753572948277, -0.0014741350896656513, -0.02214900590479374, -0.026749616488814354, 0.058003783226013184, 0.017726046964526176, -0.04490908980369568, -0.05094439163804054, -0.02119670808315277, 0.026830041781067848, 0.024836048483848572, -0.053821731358766556, 0.021746261045336723, -0.015818096697330475, -0.0073948935605585575, -0.03748456761240959, 0.018902091309428215, -0.0058576432056725025, 0.0020540496334433556, 0.06006992608308792, 0.05042489990592003, 0.00579999340698123, -0.037186238914728165, 0.02908071130514145, 0.024900119751691818, 0.004121637437492609, -0.029691580682992935, 0.04811180755496025, 0.03709077835083008, -0.01839725486934185, 0.04907073453068733, 0.01847965456545353, -0.07684406638145447, 0.011898856610059738, -0.03107604756951332, -0.0338747538626194, -0.034078892320394516, 0.010415740311145782, 0.0016555058537051082, 0.012772532179951668, 0.013733037747442722, -0.033182982355356216, 0.005480137187987566, -0.019071655347943306, 0.07167757302522659, 0.003972237464040518, 0.08321315050125122, 0.022626962512731552, -0.01927209459245205, -0.027771370485424995, 0.05117048695683479, 0.06253553926944733, -0.03169336915016174, 0.006451623979955912, 0.023448089137673378, 0.01371286902576685, -0.03141551837325096, -0.01100124791264534, -0.03995577618479729, -0.040254607796669006, -0.003838316770270467, -0.02036595344543457, -0.0015908490167930722, -0.03206175938248634, 0.019886761903762817, -0.035138946026563644, 0.04774746298789978, -0.03351931646466255, 0.019266506657004356, 0.06263435631990433, -0.06491662561893463, 0.037780821323394775, 0.0030766231939196587, 0.013902866281569004, -0.04928895831108093, 0.019282450899481773, -0.09994841367006302, 0.016689859330654144, 0.01480959728360176, -0.06366530060768127, 0.017903955653309822, 0.017736190930008888, -0.0008644290501251817, 0.001252771937288344, -0.01167609728872776, 0.04188739135861397, -0.014837829396128654, -0.015471281483769417, -0.012201903387904167, 0.04092279076576233, -0.028583252802491188, 0.06818711012601852, -0.062320586293935776, 0.09495414793491364, -0.04796844720840454, 0.05941147357225418, -0.03592325747013092, 0.04537418484687805, 0.008734220638871193, -0.04506463557481766, -0.02977732941508293, -0.04106280952692032, 0.011301337741315365, 0.011899534612894058, -0.025761611759662628, -0.05314960330724716, 0.026593951508402824, 0.03676941618323326, -0.04148052632808685, -0.03941166400909424, 0.012509992346167564, -0.006200843956321478, 0.059943657368421555, -0.04720984026789665, 0.02605327218770981, 0.02572799101471901, -0.012650097720324993, 0.053760334849357605, -0.06416116654872894, -0.0264347605407238, -0.012585029006004333, -0.00622985977679491, 0.005156365688890219, 0.01935177482664585, 0.04374527931213379, 0.027098407968878746, 0.05613231658935547, 0.050573937594890594, 0.04108082875609398, -0.02283407747745514, 0.02556375227868557, 0.026564108207821846, 0.01979023590683937, -0.003149577882140875, 0.0005740609485656023, -0.06500846892595291, 0.008326631970703602, 0.012391372583806515, -0.04291214048862457, 0.04012279585003853, 0.03845139592885971, 0.053793683648109436, 0.0255086962133646, 0.016379132866859436, -0.030652470886707306, -0.009588806889951229, 0.019269229844212532, 0.0727882981300354, -0.0009100263705477118, 0.027580564841628075, 0.028813090175390244, 0.04874676838517189, 0.00827205553650856, 0.037289202213287354, 0.018418243154883385, 0.022307556122541428, 0.03985963761806488, 0.010387696325778961, 0.06780865043401718, -0.03603268042206764, 0.0053415014408528805, -0.049342140555381775, -0.04499557986855507, 0.03226810693740845, -0.008917431347072124, -0.10246753692626953, 0.07264001667499542, 0.03216583654284477, -0.04011783003807068, 0.045598093420267105, 0.04860411956906319, -0.014663373120129108, -0.020451009273529053, 0.024830590933561325, -0.025788147002458572, 0.028772391378879547, 0.01607029139995575, -0.012452646158635616, -0.017044533044099808, 0.023885825648903847, -0.0002051876945188269, -0.0646308958530426, -0.01985710673034191, 0.06328819692134857, -0.006841733586043119, 0.01832178793847561, -0.015500692650675774, -0.10347776114940643, 0.002934598596766591, -0.03699737414717674, 0.0006362400599755347, -0.029210994020104408, 0.014641772024333477, 0.005277979653328657, 0.04257834702730179, -0.023892806842923164, -0.097438283264637, 0.009194748476147652, -0.003010887186974287, 0.060497358441352844, 0.013646172359585762, -0.013058390468358994, 0.006255337502807379, -0.08067233115434647, 0.03703648969531059, -0.048080991953611374, 0.04311127960681915, 0.035673659294843674, -0.004065127111971378, -0.005691979546099901, 0.06556868553161621, -0.02826818823814392, -0.029298143461346626, 0.01166745088994503, -0.01052829995751381, 0.04963063448667526, 0.033551644533872604, -0.018809787929058075, 0.026759635657072067, -0.0058669173158705235, -0.009357188828289509, -0.0016046074451878667, 0.03411956876516342, 0.055744484066963196, 0.005383595824241638, -0.0432802252471447, 0.020587332546710968, 0.005152754485607147, 0.01671794056892395, -0.004592525772750378, -0.010319545865058899, -0.03742888942360878, -0.008898965083062649, 0.04977826401591301, 0.05623538792133331, 0.07900480926036835, 0.01420031487941742, -0.01095560472458601, 0.013297672383487225, -0.0037269494496285915, 0.05045432597398758, -0.020711740478873253, 0.027605360373854637, 0.015940546989440918, 0.010871075093746185, 0.015383034013211727, 0.03756225109100342, 0.016650740057229996, 0.028374899178743362, -0.0017760640475898981, 0.052220020443201065, 0.0240276288241148, -0.031773801892995834, -0.06114620342850685, -0.008002262562513351, 0.004782736301422119, 0.05627460405230522, 0.038725946098566055, -0.01028627622872591, -0.0036595603451132774, -0.08654836565256119, 0.05474161356687546, 0.028002750128507614, -0.017152274027466774, -0.014270761050283909, 0.017487719655036926, 0.00880639348179102, 0.04006792604923248, -0.03637174144387245, 0.00977178756147623, 0.032045770436525345, -0.013872150331735611, -0.010659614577889442, -0.009768348187208176, -0.04039619490504265, 0.019162645563483238, 0.01915155164897442, 0.0017964241560548544, 0.010318770073354244, -0.0401272177696228, 0.018960734829306602, 0.029995577409863472, -0.032731760293245316, 0.02288440242409706, 0.0644608661532402, -0.04358064755797386, -0.030490219593048096, 0.02561972104012966, 0.0015510728117078543, 0.015229428187012672, -0.00715266028419137, -0.024927090853452682, -0.00455137062817812, -0.031474288552999496, 0.05761078745126724, -0.01749592088162899, 0.04729292914271355, 0.042186226695775986, 0.0015513707185164094, 0.05074623227119446, 0.009913969784975052, -0.005561658181250095, 0.03574435040354729, -0.025403346866369247, -0.014761951752007008, -0.028327759355306625, 0.01456055324524641, -0.014705351553857327, -0.019152823835611343, -0.0701739713549614, -0.031254302710294724, -0.03766566514968872, 0.017234206199645996, 0.038444068282842636, -0.08301093429327011, 0.044298961758613586, -0.010468470863997936, 0.0572916641831398, -0.03284619376063347, 0.03934497386217117, 0.04996158927679062, -0.03524242714047432, -0.008969860151410103, 0.05332695692777634, -0.04144234210252762, 0.008459687232971191, -0.000012440407772373874, -0.018033960834145546, 0.03230687975883484, -0.03685760498046875, 0.018917540088295937, -0.009455736726522446, -0.008394632488489151, -0.02605830319225788, -0.01244339905679226, -0.01187567412853241, 0.016071241348981857, -0.0682925134897232, 0.010952104814350605, 0.031347259879112244, 0.04487147927284241, -0.013313837349414825, 0.03384063020348549, 0.01593092642724514, -0.01714235544204712, -0.02256755344569683, -0.010998147539794445, 0.04210519790649414, -0.013715117238461971, 0.028215160593390465, -0.02494974434375763, 0.034975316375494, -0.011536975391209126, -0.029883330687880516, 0.05574553832411766, -0.0049970452673733234, 0.006511317100375891, 0.03179916366934776, 0.054799389094114304, 0.06368806958198547, 0.021583208814263344, 0.0004783637123182416, -0.03414897620677948, -0.06683891266584396, -0.07729464769363403, 0.02053300477564335, -0.05632069334387779, -0.01360447145998478, -0.06426659971475601, 0.028442837297916412, 0.01124470867216587, 0.017942819744348526, -0.019314387813210487, 0.0005339631461538374, 0.02304883301258087, 0.005524500738829374, 0.020968155935406685, 0.005727780982851982, 0.06944540143013, 0.049970269203186035, -0.01734432391822338, 0.023751474916934967, 0.0007847532397136092, -0.01777513325214386, -0.00126680638641119, 0.044868554919958115, -0.08592823147773743, -0.029018837958574295, 0.022146549075841904, 0.01646280288696289, 0.01472680177539587, -0.013240514323115349, -0.014082887209951878, -0.007384549826383591, -0.015216129831969738, -0.08060003817081451, -0.014438468962907791, -0.05611429736018181, 0.05413803085684776, 0.03350894898176193, -0.05049151927232742, -0.08075199276208878, 0.0064745680429041386, -0.05316675826907158, -0.027156395837664604, -0.052987512201070786, -0.026016604155302048, -0.009878026321530342, -0.0436173714697361, 0.008651357144117355, -0.04852747544646263, 0.01945352554321289, -0.007212579250335693, -0.0302890595048666, 0.02070433832705021, -0.018972694873809814, -0.009014545939862728, -0.06136238947510719, -0.014260772615671158, 0.004206751007586718, -0.05788165330886841, -0.003259149147197604, -0.008102363906800747, 0.00078299775486812, -0.023314518854022026, 0.018117139115929604, 0.012309374287724495, -0.020309308543801308, -0.006236229557543993, -0.0540122464299202, -0.010690991766750813, 0.008832055144011974, -0.0170558150857687, 0.03192618861794472, -0.053969450294971466, 0.01678674854338169, -0.07314550876617432, 0.019045300781726837, 0.0014495973009616137, -0.02369016595184803, -0.033890895545482635, -0.008510390296578407, 0.033118437975645065, -0.022398967295885086, -0.07017946988344193, 0.05947071313858032, 0.040570925921201706, 0.004971615970134735, -0.04473266005516052, -0.006210863124579191, -0.013158055022358894, 0.008540084585547447, -0.022646985948085785, -0.02998414635658264, -0.031819332391023636, 0.033275898545980453, -0.03292431682348251, 0.005700873676687479, -0.0035629093181341887, -0.00952952541410923, -0.030767075717449188, -0.05552392080426216, 0.039549071341753006, -0.008143344894051552, -0.029680348932743073, -0.015301285311579704, -0.04097753018140793, 0.010925214737653732, -0.014405096881091595, 0.009292230941355228, -0.00047959882067516446, -0.0016929393168538809, -0.02636808529496193, 0.014670837670564651, 0.01561210211366415, 0.015549223870038986, -0.06275518238544464, -0.005183404311537743, 0.021129611879587173, 0.037248268723487854, 0.009265432134270668, 0.07031967490911484, 0.019209107384085655, -0.027466608211398125, 0.04031238704919815, -0.04553636163473129, -0.029577285051345825, 0.006054582539945841, 0.0011954044457525015, -0.039393920451402664, 0.029947450384497643, -0.011628503911197186, 0.06847187131643295, -0.013877622783184052, -0.0517648309469223, 0.022339671850204468, 0.04087677225470543, 0.02175767347216606, -0.012743703089654446, 0.015050815418362617, 0.03659358248114586, 0.003959642257541418, -0.059470128268003464, 0.03433418646454811, -0.011498834937810898, 0.01622513309121132, -0.012044115923345089, 0.01268784049898386, -0.015876712277531624, 0.06575355678796768, -0.013998199254274368, 0.05928448215126991, 0.00943747814744711, -0.00014790103887207806, 0.010616561397910118, 0.03847399353981018, -0.0006440931465476751, 0.00708144111558795, 0.005568878259509802, -0.01081598736345768, 0.002488701371476054, -0.08362317085266113, 0.04602682963013649, 0.0717271938920021, 0.027950884774327278, 0.06687050312757492, -0.05040911212563515, -0.05817393213510513, 0.03417857736349106, -0.07154051959514618, 0.06514555960893631, 0.02376079559326172, -0.01786745712161064, 0.0644545704126358, -0.023677239194512367, -0.0623110756278038, 0.015006117522716522, -0.020586330443620682, 0.0032172505743801594, 0.025745771825313568, 0.01747327484190464, -0.031011125072836876, 0.07004087418317795, -0.0057127452455461025, -0.043750908225774765, -0.026918135583400726, 0.04601745679974556, -0.01967751234769821, -0.07952701300382614, -0.044661615043878555, -0.0623684898018837, -0.00994153693318367, 0.05463050678372383, 0.06685996055603027, 0.04249998554587364, 0.008563589304685593, 0.05526243895292282, -0.013161123730242252, -0.04581069573760033, -0.030732741579413414, 0.01770256832242012, -0.04564504325389862, -0.02861674875020981, 0.0031120425555855036, 0.024020809680223465, -0.02493315003812313, 0.029964784160256386, 0.018144570291042328, 0.03539976105093956, 0.0654701218008995, 0.032699935138225555, 0.0674496591091156, -0.017434921115636826, -0.02680366300046444, -0.008722791448235512, -0.009520857594907284, -0.024100415408611298, -0.07965923845767975, 0.013759545050561428, 0.03783480077981949, 0.003626674646511674, -0.04432111233472824, -0.06267712265253067, -0.05441578850150108, 0.0063401758670806885, -0.005772694479674101, -0.07715699821710587, -0.03987924009561539, -0.023683631792664528, -0.046431850641965866, 0.0317491739988327, 0.03957449644804001, -0.02427712455391884, -0.11439104378223419, 0.009683183394372463, 0.011968828737735748, -0.01606287620961666, -0.00690869614481926, 0.01648695021867752, -0.02540212869644165, -0.045915637165308, 0.029094427824020386, -0.019496172666549683, 0.00156044599134475, -0.08806990832090378, -0.004622729029506445, -0.04520444571971893, 0.003548369510099292, -0.01408643089234829, -0.008543680422008038, 0.04134213924407959, -0.03842974081635475, 0.04072848707437515, 0.028689002618193626, -0.047884825617074966, 0.07402727752923965, 0.015393815003335476, -0.02484302967786789, -0.07179863005876541, -0.05443082004785538, -0.032069142907857895, 0.014169193804264069, -0.013570317067205906, 0.07961970567703247, -0.015199737623333931, 0.02170531637966633, -0.01536920852959156, 0.006655365694314241, 0.03135034814476967, 0.00249454821459949, -0.034914370626211166, 0.04862097278237343, -0.05068942531943321, 0.011623646132647991, -0.017100902274250984, 0.038563478738069534 ]
<p>I have seen an apparently interesting quantity called the Bayesian complexity, which in this case is defined as $-2(\overline{\ln\mathfrak{L}} - \ln\mathfrak{L}_\mathrm{max})$. I am not sure what this is used for. I.e., what sorts of tests can be made on this quantity and what does it imply? </p>
g36684
[ -0.009017889387905598, 0.04182543233036995, -0.03131840378046036, -0.009426981210708618, -0.011875820346176624, -0.06058042123913765, 0.01659310981631279, -0.04106193780899048, -0.022409550845623016, -0.021078452467918396, -0.033678144216537476, 0.01532700378447771, 0.07435884326696396, -0.004469630308449268, 0.026090985164046288, -0.0529511421918869, 0.010431436821818352, 0.04343358799815178, 0.07164488732814789, -0.04189642146229744, -0.0125179598107934, 0.045057736337184906, 0.027771979570388794, -0.004575491417199373, 0.03528708964586258, -0.03268197923898697, 0.0025032437406480312, 0.011758225969970226, -0.048227593302726746, 0.02849859744310379, 0.016112342476844788, -0.05586643144488335, 0.04241309314966202, -0.06527166068553925, -0.04830635339021683, -0.02606966160237789, 0.06568697094917297, -0.016380196437239647, 0.10671126842498779, -0.010659552179276943, -0.035711634904146194, 0.05816063657402992, 0.05542227625846863, 0.019592681899666786, -0.05521057918667793, -0.001843348960392177, 0.008829141966998577, 0.07048416137695312, 0.013643059879541397, -0.047803375869989395, -0.007632183376699686, -0.022826360538601875, 0.079301618039608, 0.016746632754802704, 0.007878280244767666, -0.019434310495853424, -0.008480316027998924, 0.010025068186223507, 0.00832424033433199, 0.019952498376369476, 0.03658831864595413, -0.03093756176531315, -0.061916619539260864, 0.03652022406458855, 0.06122855469584465, 0.013346581719815731, 0.04646366834640503, -0.00766152935102582, -0.029562165960669518, -0.0061334120109677315, -0.02164919674396515, -0.03393933176994324, 0.03522563353180885, -0.053106144070625305, -0.005763362627476454, -0.024784686043858528, 0.0015059902798384428, 0.06798885017633438, 0.013194253668189049, 0.037549976259469986, 0.04637357220053673, -0.022595738992094994, 0.02066747657954693, -0.014935343526303768, 0.1029486209154129, -0.013582387007772923, 0.052913520485162735, -0.026575759053230286, -0.0029735437128692865, 0.04087646305561066, 0.0358721949160099, -0.04308709129691124, -0.010869108140468597, 0.0045878589153289795, -0.03718439117074013, 0.023643581196665764, -0.028953103348612785, 0.01205684244632721, -0.019047731533646584, 0.057916536927223206, 0.0044806902296841145, 0.009601984173059464, 0.03597619757056236, -0.048571985214948654, -0.05576707795262337, 0.056928981095552444, 0.019086776301264763, -0.015600860118865967, -0.004095737356692553, 0.02196306362748146, -0.015556246973574162, 0.004144409671425819, -0.0422065444290638, -0.029408203437924385, -0.03166210278868675, 0.013775701634585857, -0.0026932088658213615, 0.052519556134939194, 0.04894036054611206, 0.03310063108801842, 0.03268544375896454, -0.020878706127405167, 0.02082250639796257, 0.024259362369775772, -0.045898016542196274, 0.016304168850183487, -0.024391742423176765, 0.05577997490763664, 0.04454687610268593, 0.016437912359833717, 0.01311270147562027, 0.009701737202703953, 0.030367106199264526, -0.015655461698770523, -0.018417343497276306, 0.03872840106487274, -0.02263088896870613, 0.04513266682624817, 0.009285024367272854, -0.021175559610128403, -0.06818739324808121, -0.006553051061928272, 0.020064905285835266, -0.007978104054927826, -0.004640324041247368, 0.018585283309221268, 0.023551708087325096, 0.02408427745103836, -0.06986401230096817, -0.025213072076439857, -0.0011566501343622804, -0.02814585343003273, -0.014387997798621655, 0.002897585043683648, -0.013037478551268578, 0.03351588174700737, 0.0007075113244354725, 0.022878827527165413, -0.03315501660108566, 0.0198410302400589, -0.023181680589914322, 0.03728701174259186, -0.02456034906208515, -0.02418508753180504, -0.041830893605947495, 0.032604094594717026, 0.030555475503206253, 0.006902577821165323, -0.03206770122051239, 0.0021212399005889893, -0.0162553358823061, 0.006778046488761902, 0.07126622647047043, 0.004595317877829075, 0.06949813663959503, -0.009843532927334309, -0.019601382315158844, -0.008683353662490845, 0.042054176330566406, 0.011094312183558941, -0.006997938733547926, -0.012823911383748055, -0.007510001305490732, 0.005719187669456005, -0.04181205481290817, -0.009021799080073833, 0.009685093536973, -0.01139838993549347, 0.023050572723150253, 0.03035358525812626, 0.0038511783350259066, -0.0009083776385523379, 0.006678790785372257, -0.021182913333177567, 0.021004267036914825, -0.0017359501216560602, 0.05798286199569702, -0.0658111572265625, 0.04595459625124931, -0.04542239010334015, -0.0061913407407701015, 0.04725341871380806, 0.020746754482388496, 0.039202503859996796, -0.004137308336794376, 0.007524722255766392, 0.0025669047608971596, 0.03967057541012764, -0.023799864575266838, 0.06270482391119003, 0.021471964195370674, -0.04387444257736206, 0.012219271622598171, 0.026977436617016792, 0.050954606384038925, -0.018596680834889412, -0.069869264960289, 0.03104274906218052, 0.031001130118966103, -0.0038942149840295315, 0.05040634423494339, -0.05206964537501335, 0.09700480103492737, 0.014220834709703922, -0.002658234676346183, 0.05715049430727959, -0.020174764096736908, -0.04810222238302231, -0.014976384118199348, 0.04821159318089485, -0.0031498128082603216, -0.0677989199757576, 0.012030120007693768, 0.009053841233253479, 0.002006854396313429, 0.02155395783483982, -0.03232143446803093, 0.0380280502140522, 0.001453096978366375, 0.04667601361870766, 0.018049899488687515, -0.029057051986455917, 0.002938395831733942, 0.027155520394444466, 0.0730249360203743, -0.009149068035185337, -0.05835806578397751, 0.021366432309150696, -0.0016049366677179933, 0.06480110436677933, -0.05243806913495064, 0.005731722805649042, 0.010253717191517353, 0.01334537472575903, 0.03482421115040779, 0.00031689851311966777, 0.05060223862528801, -0.01523970440030098, -0.07170776277780533, -0.0003154976584482938, 0.03827209770679474, 0.0489555299282074, -0.0347641259431839, -0.021410049870610237, 0.009889153763651848, -0.01303849183022976, -0.048736441880464554, -0.010069119744002819, -0.0023646997287869453, 0.03187932074069977, 0.027328189462423325, 0.017495641484856606, 0.019822049885988235, 0.050502676516771317, -0.008267018012702465, -0.028752274811267853, -0.017073743045330048, -0.03557639569044113, 0.06294620037078857, -0.0038263073656708, -0.012137135490775108, -0.02225193940103054, -0.038901522755622864, 0.05878510698676109, 0.006043665576726198, -0.0313214547932148, -0.030899155884981155, 0.025095291435718536, -0.04597735404968262, 0.07917030155658722, 0.02935231290757656, 0.011628965847194195, 0.0017177959671244025, -0.04452397674322128, -0.003539836732670665, -0.03881719708442688, -0.037757523357868195, 0.005440578795969486, 0.0538923516869545, -0.04200301691889763, 0.004183799494057894, -0.01923711970448494, 0.00974454265087843, -0.0159938782453537, 0.07784439623355865, -0.0159419234842062, 0.007386708166450262, -0.013470632024109364, -0.021508531644940376, 0.03030434064567089, -0.03163008391857147, -0.019794372841715813, -0.006858262233436108, -0.0359586700797081, 0.0038124583661556244, -0.010139934718608856, 0.019645964726805687, 0.023602094501256943, -0.026814084500074387, -0.07771468162536621, 0.058431174606084824, -0.03987337276339531, -0.04583074897527695, 0.013106001541018486, 0.005094877909868956, -0.024791622534394264, -0.05634719133377075, 0.018540505319833755, -0.035129476338624954, -0.012441398575901985, 0.1282849907875061, 0.05692620202898979, -0.014180690050125122, 0.05425700545310974, -0.015294653363525867, -0.054824601858854294, 0.004787580110132694, 0.006571149453520775, 0.01605457440018654, 0.01108022965490818, -0.003131147939711809, 0.007182601373642683, -0.0299899410456419, -0.014375227503478527, -0.00035311252577230334, 0.022029366344213486, 0.01392048504203558, -0.013332921080291271, 0.0020059668458998203, -0.01900223083794117, -0.01403291616588831, -0.021097959950566292, -0.004520195536315441, -0.030101468786597252, 0.0888713151216507, 0.04443405568599701, 0.010831507854163647, 0.010522379539906979, 0.0022488718386739492, 0.0068542249500751495, 0.03875994309782982, -0.014690075069665909, 0.018227197229862213, 0.04619545862078667, 0.03671004995703697, -0.017974739894270897, 0.018116360530257225, 0.017336733639240265, -0.018603965640068054, 0.0013684156583622098, 0.007745703682303429, -0.0396108403801918, 0.023382380604743958, 0.04897221550345421, 0.0151293333619833, 0.000522557005751878, 0.014875596389174461, 0.010083751752972603, 0.02968142367899418, -0.006911907810717821, 0.03387613594532013, 0.02570732682943344, 0.043008312582969666, -0.047547318041324615, 0.03406977653503418, -0.019601397216320038, -0.048052676022052765, -0.06285283714532852, 0.023043617606163025, -0.03530903905630112, 0.00866764411330223, -0.08747710287570953, -0.032876186072826385, 0.03493736684322357, 0.07759217917919159, -0.06922844797372818, 0.00370121281594038, 0.01707320846617222, 0.0037107043899595737, 0.020421111956238747, 0.014680045656859875, 0.050605595111846924, -0.021669426932930946, -0.03315462917089462, -0.028952762484550476, -0.03446726128458977, 0.031936291605234146, 0.011144507676362991, -0.02775060571730137, -0.05431551858782768, 0.02060784585773945, -0.008918842300772667, -0.010030757635831833, -0.01696910336613655, -0.023639444261789322, 0.021073117852211, 0.003795728785917163, -0.026022180914878845, -0.02684147283434868, 0.019672464579343796, -0.021016037091612816, 0.01538857165724039, -0.012138493359088898, -0.04614674299955368, -0.009526352398097515, 0.017917916178703308, 0.07579943537712097, 0.04740208387374878, -0.02937275916337967, -0.0029560604598373175, 0.0006289015291258693, 0.012256911024451256, 0.004443814046680927, 0.017442692071199417, 0.02650899440050125, -0.03653404116630554, -0.05543781816959381, 0.0016884546494111419, -0.04495541378855705, -0.04000947251915932, -0.0006306839641183615, 0.026815883815288544, -0.016624417155981064, -0.014120800420641899, 0.06485800445079803, -0.02784346044063568, -0.016640109941363335, -0.061639122664928436, -0.018922820687294006, -0.016351154074072838, -0.06897572427988052, 0.002036160323768854, 0.009425918571650982, -0.03720593452453613, 0.042701464146375656, -0.02876482717692852, 0.008938963524997234, 0.03200498968362808, -0.0010564280673861504, 0.05900216102600098, -0.010683372616767883, -0.12497345358133316, 0.006158311385661364, 0.04955028370022774, 0.09184369444847107, -0.010785789228975773, -0.11872909963130951, -0.05568389967083931, -0.04409096762537956, 0.012469654902815819, -0.0456693097949028, 0.03640118986368179, 0.0893983244895935, 0.002877940656617284, -0.06252866238355637, -0.011798464693129063, -0.060644231736660004, 0.0723794624209404, -0.04566098004579544, -0.07429008185863495, -0.009522606618702412, 0.023468956351280212, -0.01982237957417965, -0.004823487717658281, -0.044414814561605453, 0.0338662751019001, -0.011874782852828503, -0.06761419028043747, 0.05134470388293266, -0.0024187229573726654, 0.004027625545859337, 0.04111717268824577, 0.03578122705221176, 0.006657766178250313, -0.004402839113026857, -0.06157911196351051, 0.05377516523003578, -0.05227174982428551, 0.03996892273426056, -0.013750183396041393, -0.05257030948996544, 0.01582651399075985, 0.08448904752731323, -0.0169568732380867, -0.0339953787624836, 0.018347658216953278, 0.04346594214439392, -0.03721875324845314, -0.07698073983192444, 0.045652493834495544, -0.022103622555732727, 0.022032486274838448, -0.021890372037887573, -0.0342947319149971, 0.013675261288881302, 0.0003155532758682966, 0.005110058467835188, -0.007623930927366018, -0.022583400830626488, -0.0017155841924250126, 0.06227564066648483, -0.015735013410449028, 0.07187344133853912, 0.0017839678330346942, 0.0019017161102965474, 0.0035301249008625746, -0.08827422559261322, -0.05409141629934311, -0.017410172149538994, 0.0003266134299337864, 0.025880981236696243, -0.0029813519213348627, -0.020152490586042404, -0.01149482000619173, -0.07316409051418304, -0.016595840454101562, 0.006143148057162762, 0.003712301841005683, 0.03875984251499176, 0.04268597811460495, 0.06495604664087296, -0.03961443528532982, -0.02054501883685589, 0.05335007235407829, -0.0003414008242543787, -0.01892545260488987, -0.04794278368353844, -0.025848928838968277, 0.004301188047975302, -0.015791678801178932, 0.0025969401467591524, -0.017408370971679688, -0.012565803714096546, -0.10207629948854446, -0.007332111243158579, 0.01879861205816269, 0.017402945086359978, 0.0324724018573761, -0.026899704709649086, 0.006507073063403368, -0.03994235768914223, 0.015423152595758438, 0.007290093693882227, 0.00734626455232501, -0.004418583121150732, -0.08540826290845871, -0.030538588762283325, 0.018220173195004463, 0.0006072868127375841, 0.051241617649793625, -0.00985577329993248, 0.01575045846402645, 0.07160427421331406, 0.008607362397015095, 0.05594653636217117, -0.007105917204171419, 0.02668132446706295, -0.02132021263241768, -0.013531959615647793, -0.038071710616350174, -0.007494504563510418, 0.024216149002313614, 0.014506310224533081, -0.04040974751114845, 0.018183520063757896, 0.06485370546579361, 0.004741444252431393, -0.012927448377013206, -0.0036710896529257298, -0.003929885569959879, -0.021581783890724182, -0.02890496514737606, -0.032154906541109085, -0.07080608606338501, 0.019430011510849, -0.005996316205710173, 0.05786914378404617, 0.005392095539718866, -0.04974958673119545, -0.020157160237431526, -0.0233279000967741, -0.034732501953840256, 0.0013887728564441204, -0.03229821100831032, -0.015100240707397461, 0.0632626935839653, -0.0008711683331057429, -0.0076978919096291065, -0.03866748511791229, 0.023324044421315193, -0.0005661916802637279, -0.007762388791888952, 0.011932110413908958, 0.08140470087528229, -0.025418264791369438, 0.0012314607156440616, 0.009765081107616425, -0.0869927927851677, -0.05552913621068001, 0.006432096939533949, 0.03538697585463524, -0.04535594582557678, -0.049291446805000305, -0.007124902680516243, -0.0277875903993845, 0.027236245572566986, 0.06730827689170837, -0.022722721099853516, 0.04593240097165108, 0.016022207215428352, 0.01690698228776455, 0.014902598224580288, 0.0034680066164582968, 0.023662935942411423, 0.016215864568948746, -0.025109292939305305, -0.10996845364570618, 0.04864001274108887, 0.0246820580214262, 0.02615351229906082, -0.01726166531443596, 0.05243338271975517, -0.025484604761004448, -0.016831031069159508, 0.043104417622089386, -0.023780154064297676, 0.022241242229938507, -0.0000320366452797316, -0.06419283896684647, -0.005956379231065512, -0.0022448194213211536, 0.04084669053554535, -0.0310947448015213, -0.027484174817800522, -0.049653589725494385, -0.01128143910318613, 0.027626534923911095, 0.00721396179869771, 0.030230358242988586, -0.004839589353650808, 0.007807578891515732, 0.04840487614274025, -0.013806948438286781, -0.02144521288573742, 0.022665005177259445, 0.04699213430285454, -0.020391471683979034, -0.08082512766122818, -0.052091289311647415, -0.07785160094499588, -0.004199059214442968, -0.041347797960042953, -0.03298092260956764, 0.030691977590322495, -0.008488127030432224, -0.003554458962753415, 0.015024369582533836, 0.04414496198296547, -0.04029815271496773, -0.00977527815848589, 0.022808216512203217, 0.015829240903258324, 0.020706448704004288, -0.04132378101348877, -0.026655759662389755, -0.01698184199631214, -0.08275268226861954, -0.010517861694097519, 0.0018506291089579463, -0.039787884801626205, 0.00799357146024704, -0.04223661869764328, 0.020736701786518097, -0.02591041475534439, 0.03919491171836853, 0.033140454441308975, -0.04228172451257706, 0.04448247700929642, 0.07597063481807709, 0.0635487511754036, -0.030015185475349426, 0.017284642904996872, -0.05399385467171669, -0.003546417225152254, 0.04788798838853836, -0.01343695167452097, 0.04981955140829086, 0.013706596568226814, 0.018656298518180847, -0.018271520733833313, -0.01600140891969204, 0.05660374090075493, -0.0482550710439682, -0.0457875020802021, 0.007263083476573229, -0.013528592884540558, -0.0032927989959716797, -0.013354748487472534, -0.018696283921599388, -0.03377839922904968, 0.035729460418224335, 0.02989530935883522, 0.006448018830269575, -0.0139131098985672, -0.030888624489307404, -0.04659661650657654, -0.048871882259845734, -0.038320619612932205, -0.02270931750535965, 0.012177761644124985, -0.02259540557861328, -0.030278220772743225, -0.042783692479133606, 0.026787446811795235, -0.0232260562479496, -0.016303053125739098, -0.005171678494662046, 0.08707939833402634, 0.0025082160718739033, 0.029858123511075974, -0.046328261494636536, 0.006983726751059294, 0.05974195897579193, -0.02852998673915863, 0.008200553245842457, -0.04587193951010704, -0.049821436405181885, 0.014659191481769085, 0.05861080810427666, -0.026711391285061836, -0.013644302263855934, 0.03103075735270977, 0.03801437467336655, 0.030462564900517464, 0.02721370756626129, -0.024338865652680397, -0.001045784680172801, -0.007470686454325914, 0.05754129961133003, -0.033058151602745056, -0.011351455934345722, -0.023928653448820114, -0.02855396829545498, 0.01280714850872755, -0.008729072287678719, -0.029750140383839607, 0.014633950777351856, 0.013231847435235977 ]
<p>I am currently working on a project in which I have to eliminate outliers from non-normally distributed data sets. </p> <p>The data sets are subsets of a fairly large database (order of millions of observations) segmented into groups ranging from 30-200+ observations based on the type of product being looked at.</p> <p>The data is pricing data which could be abnormal in the data set due to the possibility of rush orders and other types of abnormal circumstances under which purchases are made which can drive prices above or below a typical range). The difficulty in trying to identify these outlier values is that not every group of observations follows a normal distribution so tests for outliers based on normality are not accurate in testing for outliers in this type of data. </p> <p>My current approach to this problem is to measure the standard deviation from the mean to flag all values less than three deviations from the mean of the group, this is used to flag the observations for administrative review later.</p> <p>then I measure skewness using the Pearson's coefficient of skewness. If the value of this statistic is beyond a certain threshold ±.4 then I get rid of the 1st percentile (if skew is lower than -.4) or I remove the 99th percentile of data (if the skew is greater than .4).</p> <p>This measurement of skew is repeated with a new measurement of skew each iteration with the same type of observation removal based on the parameter listed in the previous paragraph. The removed values are then given over to administrative review to determine whether they are true outliers with special attention being paid to any values within 3 standard deviations. </p> <p>is this a good approach to removal of outliers in this case? I don't have much experience with outlier detection in data not belonging to a normal distribution. </p> <p>so the steps listed explicitly are</p> <ol> <li><p>Calculate deviation from mean for each observation</p></li> <li><p>Calculate skewness of the pool of observation if skew>.4 remove 99th percentile observations if skew&lt;.4 remove 1st percentile observations</p></li> <li><p>values removed are then put under review to determine outlier status with special attention paid to values falling within 3 standard deviations of mean.</p></li> </ol>
g74046
[ -0.03502654656767845, -0.022237855941057205, 0.028603969141840935, -0.01736709289252758, -0.031034642830491066, 0.0030502036679536104, 0.025433141738176346, 0.04637656360864639, -0.011355451308190823, 0.02866150066256523, 0.04968157038092613, 0.002927900990471244, -0.0035592757631093264, -0.029613664373755455, -0.037719666957855225, -0.006558157969266176, 0.015083703212440014, -0.028878770768642426, -0.04364337772130966, 0.054045964032411575, 0.019140461459755898, 0.06570747494697571, -0.007823377847671509, -0.011052967049181461, -0.0051786326803267, -0.00471087172627449, -0.05259770527482033, 0.032153885811567307, -0.02732836827635765, -0.0091824010014534, -0.013863581232726574, 0.022447695955634117, 0.011533637531101704, -0.017308341339230537, 0.03092026524245739, 0.01921304129064083, 0.07436908781528473, 0.04068475589156151, -0.004662031773477793, 0.019144417718052864, -0.02214166335761547, 0.028832221403717995, 0.04484090581536293, -0.007607195992022753, 0.04182080551981926, 0.010389265604317188, 0.054996851831674576, 0.031227633357048035, 0.033583540469408035, -0.024604080244898796, 0.000929107191041112, -0.02071351930499077, -0.031850576400756836, 0.036270879209041595, -0.061582569032907486, 0.08982427418231964, 0.01896641217172146, 0.018039681017398834, 0.05651432275772095, 0.02546495944261551, -0.019805235788226128, -0.04595637321472168, 0.02400611713528633, -0.029798148199915886, -0.02302601747214794, 0.029866009950637817, -0.0007320648874156177, -0.015403970144689083, -0.03960929438471794, -0.04061131924390793, 0.041913438588380814, 0.026053955778479576, -0.04484982416033745, 0.005278507713228464, -0.10114718973636627, 0.023573866114020348, -0.04971237853169441, -0.0018074826803058386, 0.023033643141388893, 0.028550388291478157, -0.06429079174995422, -0.022002723067998886, 0.011732388287782669, 0.016224760562181473, 0.05266980454325676, 0.04821494594216347, 0.01499321311712265, -0.016136137768626213, 0.014144280925393105, -0.014565147459506989, 0.0648450180888176, -0.10157067328691483, 0.02740674652159214, 0.005992295686155558, 0.025084709748625755, -0.04858458414673805, -0.034967511892318726, -0.05680733174085617, -0.011996325105428696, 0.007171510718762875, 0.03896046802401543, 0.0202939435839653, -0.049988389015197754, -0.06082315742969513, -0.04854794591665268, -0.024624837562441826, 0.040841639041900635, 0.031148279085755348, -0.010935092344880104, -0.008205867372453213, 0.06289487332105637, -0.016774937510490417, -0.03167441114783287, -0.04296005144715309, -0.005191459786146879, 0.012183299288153648, 0.04358622059226036, -0.00445652287453413, -0.06313236057758331, -0.06568662822246552, -0.009963310323655605, 0.005518984980881214, 0.06674820929765701, 0.031873323023319244, 0.01312814000993967, -0.07190645486116409, -0.07225258648395538, 0.0679006278514862, 0.06354917585849762, -0.014939283020794392, -0.0068593453615903854, -0.02853410877287388, 0.015113108791410923, 0.024916987866163254, -0.013208621181547642, 0.049939483404159546, 0.05808262899518013, 0.05009685084223747, 0.005112821701914072, -0.02274540439248085, 0.0010223588906228542, 0.053399257361888885, -0.002126870211213827, -0.0011754214065149426, -0.008902019821107388, -0.016071030870079994, -0.015587975271046162, 0.015004005283117294, -0.013456153683364391, 0.046439819037914276, -0.00563793396577239, -0.03174414485692978, -0.011640726588666439, -0.012335759587585926, -0.025049569085240364, 0.02155868150293827, 0.03508198261260986, 0.008744291961193085, -0.0061837369576096535, 0.044945791363716125, 0.006356386002153158, -0.028303584083914757, 0.04375723749399185, 0.012429585680365562, 0.04177231714129448, 0.02916502021253109, -0.024253636598587036, -0.017111698165535927, 0.04745946824550629, 0.023749863728880882, -0.055898986756801605, -0.001875717774964869, 0.04330679401755333, 0.023385897278785706, -0.023121636360883713, 0.05935963988304138, 0.019280534237623215, 0.000665015890263021, 0.01384952012449503, 0.06195679306983948, 0.05161149799823761, 0.08684248477220535, 0.05122639238834381, -0.022795293480157852, -0.024633344262838364, 0.003254552837461233, -0.007059989031404257, 0.011449765413999557, 0.02006835862994194, 0.00008942511340137571, 0.06857217848300934, -0.01831129379570484, 0.030285438522696495, -0.012103633023798466, -0.0337979681789875, -0.05421968922019005, -0.0175737664103508, -0.005103855859488249, -0.04394635185599327, -0.09876464307308197, -0.0168374665081501, -0.05527026578783989, -0.08025899529457092, 0.020872898399829865, 0.014342926442623138, -0.0765065923333168, -0.007883459329605103, -0.014032167382538319, 0.007693032268434763, 0.009996054694056511, -0.01235906407237053, -0.009863534942269325, 0.004989489912986755, 0.022329198196530342, 0.04015327990055084, 0.020729638636112213, -0.000003089490746788215, 0.06918716430664062, -0.009249978698790073, -0.002659796504303813, -0.034644678235054016, 0.028499344363808632, -0.017269186675548553, -0.027401283383369446, -0.01719021238386631, 0.051212944090366364, 0.008989912457764149, 0.0003928511869162321, 0.050775542855262756, -0.03267870843410492, -0.010579166002571583, 0.033476416021585464, -0.029466500505805016, -0.03283194079995155, 0.04799126833677292, 0.0016099935164675117, 0.014505874365568161, -0.05071229860186577, -0.015502320602536201, -0.02007134072482586, -0.03812944144010544, 0.03674420341849327, -0.040209777653217316, 0.022472715005278587, 0.01558293029665947, -0.02289021760225296, 0.004268676973879337, -0.002761261537671089, 0.0345580093562603, -0.02822696976363659, 0.0038968981243669987, 0.02438058704137802, 0.023297369480133057, -0.03105272352695465, 0.02008179947733879, -0.03129282221198082, 0.039906762540340424, 0.06564535945653915, 0.03817053884267807, -0.004011222627013922, -0.06801187247037888, 0.023188529536128044, 0.024375485256314278, -0.014645594172179699, 0.00478215329349041, -0.05236818268895149, 0.004487328696995974, 0.009215652011334896, 0.02541911043226719, 0.04245930165052414, 0.060327716171741486, 0.02903582714498043, 0.012460493482649326, 0.06841304153203964, 0.029672646895051003, 0.07494550943374634, -0.05796965956687927, 0.013537570834159851, 0.014458072371780872, 0.03367384895682335, 0.04043707996606827, -0.05148901045322418, -0.026749510318040848, 0.03293762728571892, 0.03419583663344383, 0.025397831574082375, -0.004675859585404396, -0.06824589520692825, 0.041742224246263504, 0.03035011515021324, -0.004927431233227253, 0.029137857258319855, -0.025202641263604164, -0.0460684597492218, 0.03511433303356171, 0.02649417705833912, -0.013336475938558578, -0.07092642784118652, 0.019142398610711098, -0.012667326256632805, -0.023693181574344635, -0.005071437917649746, 0.026988226920366287, -0.0024489155039191246, 0.007488858420401812, 0.018248802050948143, -0.026804856956005096, 0.06367544829845428, 0.019825244322419167, -0.0266470517963171, -0.0023657120764255524, -0.030484570190310478, -0.008437840268015862, -0.0008326888782903552, -0.018430819734930992, -0.009704645723104477, 0.007136985659599304, 0.007915540598332882, -0.004017891827970743, -0.03134647756814957, 0.01972169801592827, 0.0037982179783284664, -0.006923857610672712, 0.022644847631454468, 0.01763373613357544, 0.0335274301469326, -0.04533866047859192, -0.0038955125492066145, -0.04104724898934364, -0.025207189843058586, 0.037665583193302155, -0.02461065724492073, -0.005029456224292517, -0.04771589860320091, 0.013779622502624989, 0.000674462178722024, 0.022145293653011322, 0.0029951275791972876, 0.019787373021245003, 0.03403652831912041, 0.047400832176208496, -0.022645292803645134, -0.019533298909664154, -0.013659912161529064, -0.04931465908885002, -0.025219304487109184, 0.033371131867170334, 0.0338885635137558, -0.005242730025202036, -0.014431879855692387, 0.04211084172129631, -0.02952713705599308, 0.019451715052127838, -0.07971227914094925, 0.06958003342151642, 0.0064540752209723, 0.06605468690395355, -0.03266638517379761, -0.02982161194086075, -0.003868879983201623, 0.03565382584929466, -0.01154584251344204, -0.03153732419013977, 0.061632126569747925, -0.022369995713233948, -0.005893961526453495, 0.033050667494535446, 0.0558561272919178, 0.02234974503517151, -0.041679657995700836, -0.001954281236976385, -0.0026739374734461308, -0.002670274581760168, -0.07002890855073929, 0.0011353035224601626, 0.035035036504268646, 0.01747845485806465, 0.044749677181243896, 0.03365574777126312, 0.018086811527609825, 0.01702852174639702, -0.017732057720422745, -0.07303398102521896, -0.047501660883426666, 0.014627496711909771, -0.012823090888559818, -0.011282174848020077, -0.021701103076338768, 0.007701910100877285, -0.002795665292069316, -0.034851837903261185, 0.011281268671154976, -0.029942959547042847, 0.039043646305799484, 0.001716889557428658, -0.0016024152282625437, -0.004441786091774702, 0.0045666140504181385, -0.008003241382539272, 0.038688160479068756, 0.012324540875852108, -0.0710647776722908, 0.026132669299840927, 0.04105440899729729, -0.017563126981258392, -0.010592393577098846, -0.014312345534563065, -0.028024012222886086, -0.027473727241158485, 0.004149043932557106, -0.06357301026582718, -0.027817977592349052, -0.0322195403277874, -0.013016806915402412, 0.020832475274801254, 0.021060533821582794, 0.04560022056102753, 0.033136263489723206, -0.0226115882396698, -0.008883274160325527, -0.009917182847857475, 0.020033450797200203, -0.00270375469699502, -0.028131214901804924, 0.02654525823891163, 0.04728269577026367, -0.01783059537410736, -0.007683193311095238, -0.06283310055732727, -0.04358982294797897, 0.04566410928964615, 0.03436603024601936, -0.02984601818025112, 0.046940166503190994, 0.005691401660442352, -0.025612175464630127, 0.009674218483269215, -0.0363752655684948, -0.020785760134458542, -0.054988015443086624, -0.04524296149611473, -0.023770097643136978, -0.0728970319032669, -0.00009693422180134803, 0.004329527262598276, 0.04323552921414375, -0.015574909746646881, -0.006288083270192146, -0.005602983292192221, 0.03219795599579811, -0.014155896380543709, -0.0005060284747742116, -0.09404297173023224, 0.01687128283083439, 0.022956103086471558, -0.03782974183559418, -0.032435961067676544, 0.004649717826396227, -0.02510584332048893, 0.015232210978865623, 0.02667487971484661, -0.06436669081449509, -0.007773756515234709, -0.04942438006401062, -0.045563723891973495, 0.014663760550320148, -0.006750332657247782, -0.011760056018829346, -0.02911260724067688, -0.01062081940472126, -0.023542972281575203, 0.04620340093970299, 0.06283248215913773, -0.05132807046175003, -0.05335060507059097, 0.02030394785106182, 0.005721533205360174, 0.0028868308290839195, 0.009933685883879662, -0.01561641599982977, -0.006753055844455957, -0.010852566920220852, 0.031242914497852325, -0.04746345058083534, -0.011985781602561474, -0.02686954103410244, -0.006607487332075834, -0.08443035185337067, 0.009108434431254864, 0.0017243772745132446, 0.03504636883735657, 0.013004000298678875, 0.05019749701023102, -0.051433201879262924, 0.008700232021510601, 0.020330091938376427, 0.06778137385845184, 0.007343323901295662, 0.00933467224240303, -0.04797380045056343, -0.04540475830435753, 0.05859502777457237, -0.02177281863987446, -0.05378051847219467, -0.0664757490158081, -0.0015283992979675531, 0.04832983389496803, 0.027390042319893837, -0.016500169411301613, 0.03206111863255501, -0.009958617389202118, -0.02579488418996334, 0.046538081020116806, 0.016564764082431793, -0.024737084284424782, -0.004006202332675457, -0.03199217841029167, -0.03450930118560791, -0.01220888551324606, -0.07191970944404602, 0.03361530229449272, 0.00853817816823721, -0.016779517754912376, -0.025517897680401802, -0.010449007153511047, -0.048900097608566284, -0.04114275798201561, 0.0219286922365427, -0.02881433255970478, -0.021793415769934654, -0.017107244580984116, 0.039918407797813416, -0.03668485954403877, -0.03159259632229805, 0.027511032298207283, -0.04873838275671005, -0.019641218706965446, 0.030885787680745125, 0.033602964133024216, 0.012740599922835827, -0.025880854576826096, -0.009668265469372272, 0.026698552072048187, -0.0010835120920091867, -0.03831358626484871, -0.09356749057769775, -0.009424110874533653, -0.03149314224720001, 0.016059625893831253, -0.010771282948553562, 0.02960861288011074, 0.022400058805942535, 0.02735968492925167, 0.02897624857723713, -0.00662199454382062, 0.009740698151290417, -0.008606876246631145, 0.018706129863858223, 0.013404186815023422, -0.016715869307518005, -0.01543267723172903, -0.11254996061325073, 0.046125076711177826, -0.03145996853709221, 0.05156619846820831, -0.01839417777955532, -0.008552649058401585, -0.03563474118709564, -0.009567899629473686, 0.026858946308493614, -0.016504423692822456, -0.007281287107616663, 0.020001960918307304, 0.05331946536898613, 0.01393288653343916, 0.025468215346336365, -0.03341979905962944, 0.041723527014255524, 0.05249610170722008, -0.01653272472321987, -0.07198620587587357, 0.004230610094964504, 0.05135475471615791, -0.07032065093517303, -0.04977192357182503, 0.057536326348781586, -0.017473630607128143, -0.016326408833265305, -0.011981005780398846, -0.06987304240465164, -0.008473509922623634, 0.005222123581916094, -0.0378730446100235, 0.05048886314034462, 0.028002995997667313, -0.08139964938163757, 0.012116498313844204, 0.04180034250020981, 0.020930461585521698, -0.04085339605808258, -0.047365572303533554, -0.041057974100112915, 0.0052597178146243095, -0.0727115347981453, 0.046913061290979385, 0.03235122561454773, 0.0368550606071949, 0.04311761260032654, -0.015013182535767555, -0.06071557477116585, 0.0052707260474562645, -0.0081415930762887, 0.008782577700912952, 0.05567144975066185, 0.04435693100094795, -0.037775758653879166, -0.04351947084069252, 0.0280061736702919, 0.032429005950689316, 0.014065142720937729, -0.0021304364781826735, -0.028648341074585915, 0.00497491005808115, 0.028185084462165833, 0.012970024719834328, 0.09408354014158249, -0.02726464718580246, -0.07245130091905594, 0.046599313616752625, 0.0647178366780281, -0.057522326707839966, 0.03765680640935898, 0.05086805671453476, -0.0022374808322638273, -0.09578369557857513, -0.05511452630162239, -0.046966586261987686, 0.11323864758014679, -0.0007615041104145348, 0.0352088026702404, 0.040160179138183594, 0.03258118778467178, 0.024138765409588814, -0.04811280220746994, -0.05535787343978882, 0.029253140091896057, 0.07242393493652344, 0.07564985752105713, -0.012563072144985199, 0.0019169594161212444, -0.023473547771573067, -0.04495367780327797, 0.06396708637475967, -0.047870732843875885, 0.01240854524075985, 0.045011598616838455, 0.010106717236340046, 0.007747448980808258, 0.04215467721223831, -0.02559828944504261, -0.03804757073521614, 0.011458482593297958, -0.020245691761374474, -0.02844291925430298, -0.02383088506758213, -0.003024088451638818, -0.0002838318469002843, -0.023194069042801857, -0.03638290986418724, -0.009948676452040672, -0.007207710761576891, 0.0031002832110971212, 0.0021064719185233116, 0.005672958679497242, 0.06077941507101059, 0.005799404811114073, 0.008568494580686092, -0.006030354183167219, -0.03292449936270714, 0.021383177489042282, -0.0773196592926979, 0.015416225418448448, 0.04523728787899017, -0.049005161970853806, 0.017428075894713402, 0.08065138757228851, 0.002502553630620241, -0.011892498470842838, 0.13555170595645905, -0.022179219871759415, -0.019236603751778603, -0.020625924691557884, 0.04566331207752228, -0.031016619876027107, 0.03521040081977844, 0.015368137508630753, 0.02357623353600502, -0.04316085949540138, -0.007028061430901289, 0.0008332225843332708, -0.01600135676562786, 0.0692724660038948, 0.011123853735625744, -0.020376967266201973, -0.057728901505470276, 0.028565142303705215, 0.02622193843126297, -0.05429493635892868, 0.011297480203211308, 0.03076900541782379, -0.04776611179113388, 0.011915708892047405, 0.0742318406701088, 0.007990517653524876, 0.010489976033568382, -0.033181048929691315, 0.002432132139801979, -0.028460029512643814, 0.020701931789517403, -0.03700786828994751, -0.04900936037302017, 0.04225502908229828, -0.010254941880702972, 0.017529599368572235, -0.05128537490963936, -0.044033415615558624, -0.0010383574990555644, 0.08868099749088287, 0.006367475260049105, -0.05920139700174332, -0.02827310375869274, -0.028083575889468193, -0.044374916702508926, 0.03327503055334091, 0.005854754708707333, 0.02474570833146572, 0.03596077486872673, -0.02319549396634102, 0.020851682871580124, -0.0071286107413470745, 0.015491994097828865, 0.0355876199901104, 0.052308302372694016, 0.003250398440286517, -0.007380230817943811, -0.023362092673778534, 0.012793712317943573, 0.003182796062901616, -0.047929923981428146, 0.0339806042611599, -0.06369561702013016, -0.026888128370046616, -0.01753506064414978, 0.04639846831560135, -0.022530008107423782, 0.0301534291356802, 0.04464816302061081, -0.02657504752278328, 0.032181937247514725, -0.027761738747358322, -0.032547175884246826, -0.0024362134281545877, -0.0869942381978035, 0.06345461308956146, 0.02750711888074875, -0.014951021410524845, 0.010816609486937523, 0.005655559711158276 ]
<p>I am using R for data analysis. R provides a <code>corr</code> function for calculating the correlation. <a href="http://www.statmethods.net/stats/correlations.html">This function</a> provides three different approaches/algorithms to estimating the <code>corr</code> which are Pearson, Spearman and Kendall. When should I use each of each of these methods? What factors determine which method should be used?</p>
g74047
[ 0.08778776973485947, -0.046139828860759735, 0.0013384809717535973, -0.06753416359424591, 0.04671657457947731, -0.0033965674228966236, 0.08289611339569092, 0.0019357248675078154, -0.05665092170238495, 0.0039880103431642056, 0.015032604336738586, -0.0027271565049886703, 0.04468753561377525, 0.0159935113042593, -0.029984110966324806, -0.028864659368991852, 0.026705825701355934, -0.00126981595531106, -0.03988666459918022, 0.006398084573447704, -0.033569131046533585, 0.020624997094273567, 0.03794080391526222, -0.005764871370047331, 0.014731751754879951, -0.04379960894584656, -0.0598752386868, 0.042446646839380264, -0.03872203081846237, 0.003180122235789895, -0.01997174508869648, 0.046004898846149445, 0.03516886383295059, -0.0705040916800499, -0.010907851159572601, -0.03931572288274765, -0.01106744259595871, 0.04928931966423988, -0.023023290559649467, -0.047022007405757904, -0.034076955169439316, -0.03482680767774582, 0.04371555522084236, 0.05041857436299324, -0.02833150513470173, -0.0015952729154378176, -0.018088145181536674, -0.05382103845477104, -0.004386907909065485, -0.0016661302652209997, 0.01019575446844101, 0.032114364206790924, 0.000029352482670219615, -0.011893579736351967, 0.020284872502088547, 0.05587131902575493, 0.02379172295331955, 0.009189899079501629, 0.03433694690465927, 0.012171873822808266, 0.047563910484313965, -0.020898733288049698, -0.04824785143136978, -0.028578929603099823, 0.011865958571434021, 0.0627957284450531, 0.02288942225277424, -0.015707416459918022, 0.002735717222094536, -0.047962021082639694, 0.020263638347387314, -0.07844671607017517, 0.07347175478935242, 0.006528767291456461, -0.09062957018613815, -0.00011660949530778453, -0.00874386914074421, 0.006997104734182358, 0.03709759563207626, 0.05093852058053017, 0.03229067847132683, -0.026503823697566986, -0.00969082210212946, 0.06067965179681778, -0.0013618074590340257, 0.04937677085399628, -0.02099577896296978, 0.013928734697401524, 0.032239824533462524, -0.014176556840538979, 0.01794544793665409, 0.005895664449781179, 0.07381688803434372, 0.040832798928022385, -0.0488429069519043, 0.014062091708183289, -0.07492845505475998, 0.008322144858539104, 0.04041224345564842, 0.012450913898646832, -0.016643209382891655, 0.009442820213735104, -0.031036479398608208, -0.03821927309036255, -0.04264664277434349, -0.04048917442560196, 0.0853959321975708, 0.004553977400064468, -0.0709879919886589, -0.05350399762392044, -0.09169373661279678, 0.022609181702136993, -0.040442660450935364, -0.017150212079286575, -0.009680105373263359, -0.03926970064640045, 0.039585571736097336, -0.050643593072891235, 0.005858773831278086, 0.00897204503417015, 0.001116323983296752, -0.035284947603940964, 0.055107153952121735, 0.060350991785526276, -0.03065626695752144, -0.037858862429857254, -0.045818571001291275, -0.0027831271290779114, 0.009166402742266655, -0.022605495527386665, 0.010974626988172531, 0.016324341297149658, -0.01250485610216856, -0.0016297168331220746, 0.02235379070043564, 0.025704817846417427, -0.009039873257279396, 0.05715872719883919, -0.004450583830475807, 0.02049902454018593, 0.006513500120490789, -0.02570994757115841, 0.01537798997014761, -0.025353236123919487, -0.05593368038535118, 0.05620010942220688, -0.01702761836349964, 0.023035423830151558, -0.024318506941199303, 0.029905961826443672, 0.0516866073012352, 0.015023157000541687, -0.0144420200958848, 0.05273018777370453, -0.001242375117726624, -0.0188235342502594, 0.02244255505502224, -0.02514180913567543, -0.006119667552411556, 0.046409983187913895, 0.007804759778082371, -0.00859856978058815, 0.0732022076845169, 0.09241919964551926, -0.0012514544650912285, -0.011989145539700985, 0.041132695972919464, -0.03647908195853233, -0.001479738624766469, -0.060082826763391495, 0.06063030660152435, 0.023686451837420464, 0.00015187737881205976, -0.08764670044183731, -0.019711874425411224, 0.02279183827340603, 0.05199751257896423, -0.043537210673093796, 0.043270133435726166, 0.027709098532795906, 0.029105478897690773, -0.003567321226000786, 0.0205629151314497, 0.02306227572262287, -0.019577985629439354, -0.07434500753879547, 0.0384192168712616, -0.04344804212450981, -0.11888202279806137, -0.02060728520154953, -0.0238812193274498, -0.025340894237160683, -0.033539678901433945, -0.03275234252214432, -0.04584026336669922, -0.009966469369828701, 0.02586061879992485, -0.019801508635282516, 0.0020422302186489105, 0.028215475380420685, 0.00857592187821865, 0.03530341386795044, -0.06150747835636139, 0.057097986340522766, -0.018138067796826363, 0.0010076172184199095, 0.024087898433208466, -0.005718996282666922, 0.009919705800712109, 0.013001848012208939, -0.00669826939702034, 0.05048966780304909, -0.05724874511361122, 0.015890972688794136, 0.025242570787668228, 0.01630992256104946, -0.041840847581624985, 0.08145218342542648, -0.041125956922769547, 0.055756550282239914, -0.021914353594183922, -0.03668354079127312, 0.025398919358849525, 0.003083438379690051, -0.013376085087656975, 0.030144477263092995, -0.0372217632830143, 0.02662232331931591, -0.01868976466357708, 0.0034592102747410536, 0.002038466976955533, -0.04740016534924507, -0.020748408511281013, -0.007766358088701963, -0.011326957494020462, 0.002271889243274927, 0.023305295035243034, -0.04293240234255791, 0.03862369433045387, 0.08099651336669922, 0.0372878834605217, 0.04969353973865509, 0.03446149080991745, 0.056239597499370575, 0.04755067825317383, -0.0023636221885681152, 0.02938411384820938, -0.01894455775618553, -0.048059795051813126, 0.039343636482954025, -0.009522132575511932, 0.08384605497121811, -0.020674115046858788, -0.012742819264531136, 0.0005996742402203381, 0.00026228275964967906, 0.00021053798263892531, 0.05611153692007065, -0.024530595168471336, 0.029595591127872467, 0.04798842594027519, 0.017657874152064323, 0.0042429352179169655, 0.023833943530917168, -0.004391910508275032, 0.017500391229987144, -0.06726079434156418, -0.03161986917257309, 0.0010660008992999792, -0.028138654306530952, -0.06323723495006561, 0.010255281813442707, 0.022753668949007988, 0.011296900920569897, 0.0424540676176548, -0.004190211184322834, 0.037904076278209686, -0.02662367932498455, -0.010737190023064613, 0.0026693353429436684, 0.01637267880141735, -0.05471670255064964, 0.02959453873336315, 0.03397348150610924, 0.04997605085372925, 0.0410328172147274, 0.06947936862707138, 0.0017818462802097201, -0.02683854103088379, -0.010429133661091328, 0.039031609892845154, 0.018926678225398064, -0.040818002074956894, -0.03778652474284172, 0.009824134409427643, -0.0033922160509973764, 0.01988735981285572, -0.09671041369438171, 0.038770243525505066, -0.0058840494602918625, 0.008297773078083992, -0.016032418236136436, -0.01090293750166893, -0.022081762552261353, 0.048139624297618866, -0.020185129716992378, -0.003459241008386016, 0.002375060459598899, 0.02599511481821537, -0.003572803223505616, -0.013239546678960323, 0.000929584726691246, -0.03667784482240677, -0.008119521662592888, 0.02462422288954258, -0.005841612350195646, 0.05424320325255394, 0.03636254370212555, 0.046112485229969025, 0.050938770174980164, -0.011364865116775036, -0.037131402641534805, 0.01586073450744152, -0.04481477290391922, -0.009347664192318916, 0.0971267968416214, -0.012966734357178211, 0.01849931664764881, -0.02880255877971649, -0.0004387971421238035, -0.05150137096643448, 0.01943976618349552, 0.0018356428481638432, -0.021163783967494965, -0.008231204003095627, -0.00024149534874595702, 0.031004855409264565, 0.019302677363157272, -0.05384625494480133, 0.031410470604896545, -0.018732158467173576, -0.061094217002391815, -0.007646963000297546, -0.018271805718541145, 0.0018460145220160484, 0.0106421560049057, 0.05291854590177536, -0.0076039559207856655, 0.028547801077365875, -0.026316802948713303, -0.028375770896673203, 0.018703097477555275, -0.03499617427587509, -0.03698786348104477, -0.03332997485995293, -0.004312021192163229, -0.012342630885541439, 0.05934974551200867, -0.03388330340385437, 0.016942039132118225, 0.02266691066324711, -0.01616639457643032, -0.016410890966653824, 0.022670429199934006, -0.012869535945355892, 0.01862655207514763, 0.004847072530537844, 0.029689263552427292, -0.008810237050056458, -0.0021249032579362392, 0.011627081781625748, 0.03894059360027313, 0.006188637111335993, -0.02075858972966671, -0.03321278840303421, -0.023141026496887207, -0.021470490843057632, 0.005494426470249891, 0.022952953353524208, 0.04400138184428215, -0.00785587728023529, 0.07187405228614807, 0.009960402734577656, -0.00034387188497930765, -0.035950515419244766, -0.024560101330280304, -0.05449102446436882, 0.006443885155022144, 0.041556619107723236, -0.06989581137895584, -0.004873163998126984, -0.035753246396780014, 0.0023429004941135645, 0.040874507278203964, 0.03374842554330826, -0.018810171633958817, 0.006282373331487179, 0.02593293972313404, 0.07694054394960403, 0.018030941486358643, -0.04969094321131706, -0.029174992814660072, 0.030374888330698013, 0.0151505246758461, -0.032256972044706345, 0.018472518771886826, -0.053909722715616226, -0.08681665360927582, -0.020396733656525612, -0.0230878759175539, -0.04111457243561745, 0.053243331611156464, 0.022790446877479553, -0.002901452360674739, 0.027076344937086105, -0.038510166108608246, 0.05243414267897606, 0.05614224076271057, -0.038686610758304596, 0.013447970151901245, 0.006293304730206728, -0.01801959052681923, 0.005150933749973774, -0.03840882331132889, -0.0032491071615368128, 0.003327419748529792, 0.030756952241063118, 0.010637886822223663, 0.006996698211878538, -0.013399625197052956, 0.06578652560710907, 0.01724879816174507, 0.01321991067379713, -0.0013427681988105178, -0.009220809675753117, 0.03286931291222572, -0.0020331235136836767, -0.015211502090096474, 0.00416365172713995, -0.018741784617304802, -0.00685027614235878, -0.007590353023260832, 0.028764136135578156, 0.021781334653496742, -0.018589606508612633, 0.054682329297065735, -0.005529649555683136, 0.011284259147942066, 0.02248750813305378, -0.00035437196493148804, 0.03929751738905907, -0.0005832187598571181, -0.013013198040425777, 0.011874482035636902, -0.003934040665626526, -0.0011315441224724054, 0.04486803710460663, 0.006067326292395592, 0.05935575067996979, 0.05216328799724579, -0.03248662129044533, -0.0031167003326117992, -0.07567130774259567, -0.05671016499400139, -0.009772932156920433, 0.02027839608490467, -0.02108277939260006, -0.051030296832323074, 0.03277937322854996, 0.00942551251500845, -0.025468604639172554, -0.019158124923706055, 0.010778033174574375, 0.005446275230497122, 0.01335638016462326, 0.0008891061297617853, 0.0025520315393805504, -0.023644233122467995, 0.028104428201913834, 0.06458596140146255, -0.016566457226872444, 0.023701248690485954, -0.035158250480890274, -0.011838514357805252, -0.042684704065322876, 0.00426452374085784, 0.02674742415547371, -0.05531059578061104, -0.01746332459151745, 0.004544154740869999, -0.028114285320043564, 0.05887103080749512, 0.07440721243619919, 0.047938499599695206, 0.01505733747035265, 0.05979865416884422, 0.004446732345968485, -0.02044486068189144, -0.00403836602345109, -0.011908618733286858, -0.007858227007091045, 0.005088501609861851, -0.040503039956092834, 0.025603268295526505, -0.02495112270116806, -0.016051890328526497, 0.07582763582468033, -0.02245006151497364, 0.020994151011109352, 0.03356979414820671, -0.024130001664161682, 0.02537941187620163, 0.03608372062444687, 0.02113029733300209, -0.08300349116325378, 0.007338503375649452, 0.0018280965741723776, 0.04194258525967598, -0.07600713521242142, -0.027214093133807182, 0.017664257436990738, 0.037629369646310806, -0.003997833468019962, 0.014798494055867195, -0.030060915276408195, -0.03953487053513527, 0.035655248910188675, 0.0030416285153478384, 0.01095699891448021, -0.07129696011543274, -0.0025404414627701044, 0.011021300218999386, 0.0030749174766242504, 0.013833758421242237, -0.0164033230394125, -0.044632624834775925, -0.029182352125644684, -0.0004416308947838843, -0.012244705110788345, -0.013802088797092438, -0.021629419177770615, 0.05069969594478607, 0.0390053316950798, 0.009256432764232159, -0.030539311468601227, -0.07378610968589783, 0.01654772460460663, -0.057157207280397415, 0.01447166409343481, -0.04059387743473053, -0.03815750405192375, 0.02706073969602585, -0.026314161717891693, -0.0206438060849905, 0.023310035467147827, -0.03842020407319069, 0.05792658403515816, -0.02128848247230053, 0.009077837690711021, 0.04378528520464897, 0.010240206494927406, -0.08277536183595657, 0.028674818575382233, 0.03440246358513832, -0.007144466042518616, 0.022120479494333267, -0.056917954236269, -0.020640546455979347, -0.019817378371953964, 0.05390864983201027, -0.01885860785841942, -0.07719355076551437, -0.032099753618240356, 0.028570638969540596, 0.008465942926704884, 0.07356178760528564, -0.035812824964523315, 0.004548223223537207, -0.03767983242869377, 0.037965886294841766, 0.08001650124788284, -0.047458164393901825, -0.03178123012185097, -0.010929052717983723, -0.014928502030670643, 0.076768659055233, -0.018991047516465187, -0.03616517782211304, 0.0348697155714035, 0.022090410813689232, -0.0027559264563024044, 0.030091378837823868, -0.04977238178253174, -0.03942342847585678, 0.00077613047324121, -0.0599248893558979, -0.026741664856672287, 0.038297783583402634, -0.00797517504543066, -0.02562396228313446, -0.01660289615392685, 0.04296460002660751, 0.0829196348786354, -0.04749661684036255, 0.03239694982767105, -0.015608335845172405, 0.025083130225539207, -0.02100886031985283, -0.011500590480864048, -0.030323563143610954, -0.02210618369281292, -0.034946586936712265, 0.06503736227750778, 0.05401229485869408, 0.010480906814336777, 0.010625450871884823, -0.04201269522309303, -0.016631167382001877, 0.00020747949020005763, -0.0021518634166568518, 0.021366948261857033, -0.05698626488447189, -0.03812011331319809, -0.04818219691514969, 0.04517478495836258, 0.06245874986052513, -0.053465697914361954, -0.0006965923821553588, -0.023521199822425842, -0.023121749982237816, 0.004658218007534742, 0.01970774121582508, -0.0617612861096859, 0.018412534147500992, -0.09149841219186783, 0.011754912324249744, 0.015265408903360367, 0.06765285134315491, 0.009404018521308899, 0.10238754749298096, -0.008438491262495518, 0.03019930236041546, -0.011938458308577538, -0.007926097139716148, 0.0011764110531657934, 0.005978816654533148, 0.05923439934849739, 0.02510809898376465, -0.07502174377441406, 0.01382480002939701, 0.0011976142413914204, -0.020382298156619072, 0.006026428658515215, -0.043991513550281525, 0.02796185202896595, 0.061333607882261276, 0.04994041100144386, 0.02626168727874756, 0.09840678423643112, 0.015757715329527855, -0.04222498834133148, -0.0328945517539978, -0.05671803653240204, -0.026978349313139915, 0.06647903472185135, 0.014848257414996624, -0.05196146294474602, 0.005318224895745516, -0.023149946704506874, -0.045557521283626556, 0.006578737869858742, -0.002397809410467744, -0.025472883135080338, -0.009203150868415833, 0.047155845910310745, 0.039961524307727814, -0.0013568337308242917, -0.0353374145925045, -0.025214308872818947, 0.019237451255321503, -0.0724841058254242, -0.000678422162309289, 0.02063237875699997, -0.010297619737684727, -0.009086747653782368, 0.09027134627103806, -0.011625776067376137, -0.01580747216939926, 0.009636024944484234, -0.08422882109880447, -0.024824615567922592, 0.01774587482213974, -0.015087530948221684, -0.018770534545183182, -0.06344141811132431, 0.03850693628191948, 0.006497777532786131, -0.037976037710905075, 0.017333252355456352, 0.04982324689626694, -0.0023124716244637966, 0.02565077133476734, 0.002943933941423893, -0.041995830833911896, 0.0409044586122036, -0.00916630681604147, -0.030730754137039185, -0.04071288928389549, -0.011049365624785423, -0.04152733460068703, 0.0013179269153624773, 0.0002998057461809367, 0.011854665353894234, 0.01779642514884472, -0.037288617342710495, -0.0018454545643180609, 0.019056113436818123, -0.04573783278465271, -0.03378208354115486, -0.039451971650123596, -0.007806207984685898, -0.03746162727475166, -0.02737531252205372, -0.0309376772493124, -0.028098542243242264, -0.0475238636136055, 0.025182466953992844, 0.06166765093803406, -0.029666593298316002, -0.017986537888646126, 0.006811104714870453, -0.05922837182879448, -0.059556618332862854, 0.04505676403641701, 0.0035773664712905884, 0.02205919288098812, 0.01122942753136158, 0.028719771653413773, -0.0023421538062393665, 0.026665210723876953, -0.004212680738419294, -0.005479604005813599, 0.051409658044576645, 0.02673841081559658, 0.006029445677995682, -0.0292053185403347, 0.006369889248162508, 0.07344847172498703, -0.007284990511834621, -0.011183434166014194, -0.04842827841639519, 0.07781790941953659, 0.01107695046812296, 0.008190215565264225, -0.028288157656788826, 0.024040931835770607, -0.0695686861872673, -0.010670819319784641, 0.10138417035341263, 0.003868520725518465, 0.03738187626004219, -0.00543599110096693, -0.032496124505996704, -0.03710785135626793, -0.025124678388237953, 0.02309967577457428, -0.04928965866565704, -0.046059854328632355 ]
<p>I manipulate in R time series that can present <strong>revisions</strong>. I use in general the package 'xts' but it doesn't support revisions.</p> <p>Is there a package that deals with that?</p> <p>Alternatively, is there a best practice to store and manipulate revisions?</p>
g36687
[ -0.011206015013158321, -0.008683153428137302, -0.0013244260335341096, -0.028484193608164787, -0.008573764935135841, -0.013125378638505936, -0.0329669713973999, 0.033574674278497696, -0.02041705511510372, -0.008633560501039028, 0.06972457468509674, -0.011516604572534561, 0.0344136580824852, 0.0088305389508605, -0.0756223127245903, 0.03474196046590805, 0.06280326843261719, 0.050169311463832855, 0.012568144127726555, 0.03689732402563095, 0.04341154173016548, 0.01225192379206419, 0.04096489027142525, -0.011256000027060509, 0.06763291358947754, 0.017683731392025948, 0.023344704881310463, 0.00393665349110961, -0.039114583283662796, 0.022293709218502045, 0.06166500598192215, 0.008539672940969467, 0.002671272959560156, 0.007328108884394169, 0.017373912036418915, -0.08137261867523193, 0.01841876655817032, -0.034742001444101334, -0.006741044577211142, -0.019815027713775635, 0.03137939050793648, 0.05419575050473213, 0.015879878774285316, 0.005378096830099821, -0.005414951127022505, 0.0043123746290802956, 0.05810154229402542, 0.0319720022380352, -0.02776704728603363, 0.0012427140027284622, 0.020338695496320724, -0.02062171697616577, -0.018531061708927155, -0.003728943644091487, 0.05036170780658722, 0.05196918919682503, -0.02278147079050541, 0.014365448616445065, 0.000650774163659662, -0.03026161715388298, 0.02934383414685726, -0.06823334097862244, 0.013025222346186638, 0.024816611781716347, 0.007192651275545359, 0.06416111439466476, -0.01744437962770462, -0.032937489449977875, 0.008474156260490417, 0.0042872061021625996, 0.04775004833936691, 0.08794879168272018, 0.002398855285719037, 0.027516085654497147, -0.02442004159092903, -0.0023404648527503014, 0.01604008488357067, -0.00793519988656044, -0.018463043496012688, 0.02705163136124611, -0.06797900050878525, -0.017360100522637367, 0.03510475903749466, -0.06488468497991562, 0.01880864053964615, -0.05983807146549225, 0.08144907653331757, 0.04540891572833061, 0.07285656780004501, 0.012767131440341473, -0.0034357814583927393, -0.06559708714485168, 0.030472764745354652, 0.010437318123877048, -0.020834218710660934, -0.0016522107180207968, -0.07399773597717285, 0.04527083411812782, -0.02665843814611435, 0.00755217345431447, -0.001168076298199594, 0.026296500116586685, -0.0005424707778729498, -0.02460015006363392, -0.039302729070186615, 0.02498999983072281, 0.016728581860661507, -0.02817843109369278, 0.01197162363678217, -0.05470738559961319, 0.019267087802290916, -0.03517068549990654, 0.018471527844667435, 0.02234163135290146, -0.004262896254658699, -0.038373932242393494, -0.006587872747331858, -0.03746137395501137, -0.03811122104525566, 0.05835351347923279, -0.008561311289668083, -0.02713521383702755, 0.014318587258458138, 0.07254648953676224, 0.03940241038799286, -0.035469282418489456, -0.042566895484924316, -0.006075283978134394, 0.032862816005945206, -0.04704548791050911, -0.024854382500052452, 0.040208496153354645, -0.019674938172101974, 0.006861389148980379, 0.009927885606884956, -0.007773072924464941, -0.02800176478922367, 0.015440336428582668, -0.05303696170449257, -0.03199375048279762, 0.026238635182380676, 0.004951864946633577, 0.006596130318939686, 0.02516133338212967, -0.015414661727845669, -0.08147251605987549, 0.020449228584766388, -0.005966866854578257, 0.027118509635329247, -0.021081626415252686, -0.008226174861192703, 0.008722702041268349, -0.07199365645647049, 0.0015336666256189346, -0.006164717022329569, 0.01953386887907982, 0.05706220120191574, 0.01221917849034071, -0.0028562324587255716, 0.02274712175130844, 0.0012224401580169797, 0.015547017566859722, -0.0363132618367672, 0.015872318297624588, 0.0011626635678112507, -0.030334632843732834, -0.02246471308171749, -0.04976804926991463, -0.01344810426235199, -0.00227561523206532, 0.023487349972128868, 0.025321902707219124, 0.016903497278690338, 0.028826981782913208, -0.00347344228066504, -0.05856062471866608, 0.05204926058650017, -0.057344742119312286, -0.014588798396289349, -0.028010684996843338, -0.026737673208117485, -0.06077858433127403, -0.019124003127217293, -0.0403294675052166, 0.0035924483090639114, 0.012773877009749413, -0.04231040179729462, -0.02349764108657837, -0.05173243209719658, -0.01853887178003788, 0.03355928882956505, 0.03238339349627495, -0.016605466604232788, 0.054359421133995056, -0.030824292451143265, -0.03177611902356148, -0.02065345086157322, -0.038271062076091766, -0.03857799619436264, 0.038889072835445404, 0.07991314679384232, 0.045055050402879715, -0.001305818441323936, 0.0713835209608078, -0.027589967474341393, -0.019762001931667328, -0.052991677075624466, -0.012554896995425224, -0.04895468056201935, -0.012746850959956646, 0.08163902163505554, 0.018169961869716644, -0.014118555933237076, 0.018660936504602432, 0.022206278517842293, -0.015855936333537102, -0.027212128043174744, -0.020461250096559525, 0.060498423874378204, 0.03856135532259941, -0.07398394495248795, -0.03327060490846634, -0.012187719345092773, 0.020915014669299126, -0.03629925474524498, -0.02299557812511921, 0.042040880769491196, 0.0341472253203392, 0.019417745992541313, -0.04667011275887489, -0.058411337435245514, 0.058024272322654724, -0.04383758455514908, -0.0075509194284677505, 0.057484474033117294, -0.011954647488892078, -0.008662747219204903, -0.0007562527316622436, 0.03975420072674751, 0.07402022927999496, 0.038661785423755646, 0.014652498066425323, -0.016846351325511932, 0.04919679835438728, 0.0030590062960982323, -0.019906984642148018, 0.026869814842939377, 0.01642722450196743, 0.022857515141367912, -0.00929374061524868, 0.02626459300518036, 0.028542224317789078, 0.007611673790961504, -0.05818123370409012, 0.02886957861483097, -0.027218637987971306, 0.02106422558426857, 0.015114951878786087, -0.02114732749760151, -0.010577470064163208, -0.005969996098428965, 0.06202719360589981, -0.01924048364162445, 0.035674817860126495, 0.028467286378145218, -0.029057975858449936, 0.008770990185439587, -0.01998095028102398, 0.02449849434196949, 0.025234956294298172, 0.01492725033313036, 0.009202571585774422, 0.038341864943504333, 0.028055699542164803, -0.01198508683592081, 0.0038617062382400036, -0.0444970577955246, -0.019620411098003387, 0.007901115342974663, 0.048428282141685486, 0.09873327612876892, -0.01420561783015728, 0.014255759306252003, 0.031149394810199738, 0.02012660540640354, -0.019801907241344452, -0.06563705205917358, 0.00499870628118515, -0.021870596334338188, 0.046381380409002304, 0.008504994213581085, -0.002938042627647519, 0.00437648082152009, -0.042390670627355576, -0.021317126229405403, -0.0479644276201725, -0.02027897909283638, -0.0617501437664032, 0.02254573628306389, 0.048582810908555984, 0.016161222010850906, 0.017615918070077896, 0.019219592213630676, 0.05165930837392807, 0.048753079026937485, -0.05260610207915306, -0.007087222766131163, 0.02795691043138504, 0.010836982168257236, 0.0009263899410143495, -0.003031809814274311, -0.0018011356005445123, -0.04868366941809654, 0.029920972883701324, -0.06796745955944061, -0.004085978958755732, -0.026283331215381622, -0.03535471484065056, 0.07969929277896881, -0.01694798283278942, 0.006345677189528942, -0.04968230798840523, 0.03662889078259468, 0.03193461522459984, -0.013057186268270016, 0.026453860104084015, -0.012190477922558784, 0.0021216715686023235, -0.024146292358636856, -0.021228279918432236, 0.005754387937486172, 0.03952062502503395, 0.012925535440444946, -0.006210613995790482, -0.025019530206918716, 0.010574706830084324, 0.02796568162739277, -0.04431820660829544, 0.028155891224741936, 0.03974907472729683, 0.003305820282548666, -0.012247409671545029, 0.04576332867145538, 0.007634258829057217, 0.029554901644587517, -0.030332844704389572, -0.006847637705504894, -0.0009635188616812229, -0.001353652449324727, -0.011488225311040878, 0.019222142174839973, 0.02994411811232567, 0.028778791427612305, -0.04614722356200218, 0.022190265357494354, 0.00776662165299058, 0.013771576806902885, -0.000010630442375259008, 0.010013134218752384, -0.055207885801792145, 0.013583964668214321, -0.002993459813296795, -0.061549440026283264, 0.04860064759850502, -0.06690357625484467, 0.09725828468799591, 0.062096986919641495, 0.023304162546992302, -0.01117586437612772, 0.0037455339916050434, 0.02197025902569294, 0.03339939936995506, 0.041209544986486435, -0.03807757794857025, -0.009932137094438076, -0.025332434102892876, -0.012799457646906376, 0.0222870334982872, 0.01197762880474329, 0.05203336104750633, 0.041597213596105576, -0.06392699480056763, -0.018187418580055237, -0.01278744824230671, 0.009734129533171654, 0.0012915999395772815, 0.031710077077150345, -0.005252775736153126, 0.0198479276150465, -0.012633929960429668, -0.024457592517137527, -0.027839895337820053, -0.012770291417837143, -0.010515237227082253, -0.014633432030677795, -0.06352242082357407, 0.04396790638566017, 0.0308803990483284, -0.03475997596979141, -0.010813574306666851, -0.036199901252985, 0.017702169716358185, -0.04284537956118584, -0.051696281880140305, -0.05539070442318916, -0.016007835045456886, -0.01716790348291397, -0.06468532234430313, -0.02671683393418789, -0.01810653693974018, -0.010760974138975143, -0.061533067375421524, 0.02337443083524704, -0.0047677732072770596, 0.006298082415014505, -0.02909478358924389, 0.058775585144758224, 0.0012505663326010108, 0.015200984664261341, -0.04585522040724754, 0.004247498232871294, 0.05815926939249039, 0.03838128224015236, 0.024780726060271263, 0.06209932640194893, 0.09142666310071945, -0.03282291069626808, -0.01901274360716343, 0.03129670023918152, -0.015462962910532951, 0.02439996972680092, -0.019370991736650467, 0.0741274431347847, -0.004123641178011894, -0.010733382776379585, -0.046847034245729446, 0.07574694603681564, -0.0332324244081974, -0.06488187611103058, -0.06117143854498863, -0.008904554881155491, -0.04952029883861542, -0.011236202903091908, -0.07187832146883011, -0.07521218806505203, 0.06869594752788544, -0.0675264373421669, 0.00554748997092247, 0.030554335564374924, 0.0391327328979969, -0.059461526572704315, -0.025575462728738785, -0.00030649674590677023, 0.03825175762176514, 0.04185309261083603, 0.06565976142883301, 0.040854014456272125, 0.01025916077196598, -0.012564893811941147, -0.03594566881656647, -0.01311035268008709, -0.030660994350910187, 0.023922041058540344, 0.03322766721248627, -0.018735123798251152, 0.032756976783275604, -0.09021884202957153, 0.001077772118151188, 0.0513732023537159, 0.04298941418528557, 0.005506318993866444, -0.01683494634926319, -0.021766632795333862, 0.04204147309064865, 0.02802133932709694, 0.008984739892184734, 0.031466707587242126, -0.07656042277812958, 0.035072751343250275, 0.05606970563530922, -0.007548838388174772, 0.06647340208292007, -0.0000033253711535508046, -0.003949502948671579, -0.06286466866731644, -0.009337310679256916, -0.0011728721437975764, -0.014507857151329517, 0.014783116057515144, -0.049036186188459396, -0.037044137716293335, 0.06458712369203568, 0.06730077415704727, 0.06645332276821136, -0.0412517711520195, 0.08021023869514465, -0.04466899856925011, -0.030268456786870956, -0.007521999534219503, 0.009973754175007343, 0.03093462623655796, 0.00936158001422882, 0.05346793308854103, 0.04362430423498154, 0.0096552399918437, 0.013675940223038197, 0.022894101217389107, 0.020462103188037872, -0.029554178938269615, -0.01689477264881134, 0.010889185592532158, 0.010292718186974525, -0.016676142811775208, 0.005826421547681093, -0.0027259960770606995, 0.04314333572983742, -0.05935567989945412, 0.008401840925216675, -0.05060192197561264, -0.10314523428678513, -0.022669710218906403, -0.03351159766316414, 0.06935353577136993, -0.031179014593362808, -0.017313748598098755, 0.007135901600122452, -0.048294391483068466, -0.01662968471646309, 0.003755398327484727, -0.0036982197780162096, 0.024615934118628502, -0.01243348978459835, 0.023542944341897964, 0.011391260661184788, -0.04214762523770332, 0.0059575228951871395, 0.01844935677945614, 0.04436608403921127, -0.016566168516874313, -0.05940473452210426, 0.003841161262243986, 0.10057603567838669, -0.0077028642408549786, 0.010272187180817127, -0.011321363970637321, -0.0452021025121212, -0.017376311123371124, 0.023292522877454758, 0.03601797670125961, -0.0391872264444828, -0.030074430629611015, 0.030804315581917763, -0.0130054522305727, -0.04555771127343178, -0.0036076954565942287, 0.032222144305706024, 0.014945118688046932, -0.06657260656356812, 0.008103903383016586, 0.007420970126986504, -0.053592611104249954, -0.044533759355545044, 0.04324880242347717, -0.025734981521964073, -0.0064507946372032166, -0.029526256024837494, 0.022003429010510445, 0.008172707632184029, -0.01716063730418682, 0.09129668027162552, -0.036197684705257416, 0.027213649824261665, 0.0489395335316658, -0.018440214917063713, -0.018616143614053726, 0.0014595899265259504, 0.05623759329319, 0.01747734844684601, 0.04147108271718025, -0.035968899726867676, -0.07407297194004059, -0.01935540698468685, -0.009511872194707394, 0.010804611258208752, -0.004421609919518232, 0.0019078495679423213, -0.04437458515167236, 0.042217694222927094, 0.01959293894469738, 0.012570329010486603, -0.02715206891298294, 0.013837054371833801, -0.0217084139585495, 0.008194530382752419, 0.03352797031402588, 0.07202282547950745, -0.058954868465662, 0.027867300435900688, 0.03750685229897499, -0.004941107705235481, -0.06708186119794846, 0.006398434285074472, 0.06910230219364166, -0.00014941256085876375, -0.028712481260299683, -0.09036808460950851, 0.010908967815339565, 0.05822290852665901, 0.035355113446712494, 0.011681430041790009, 0.025617938488721848, 0.026813693344593048, -0.003252291353419423, 0.0507756844162941, 0.008459595032036304, -0.021531270816922188, 0.0039609335362911224, 0.006767324637621641, -0.01579471305012703, -0.044031787663698196, -0.014477604068815708, -0.0562245137989521, 0.01867547817528248, 0.013888522982597351, -0.0036748796701431274, -0.01712046004831791, 0.0003904537879861891, 0.014850128442049026, 0.001757881953381002, -0.06291671842336655, -0.04796430468559265, 0.00450835982337594, -0.038311053067445755, -0.03814895078539848, -0.04399373382329941, 0.05176958441734314, -0.08094581961631775, 0.0540868379175663, -0.01241038367152214, -0.02223239094018936, 0.0019727651961147785, 0.044606175273656845, -0.01978137157857418, 0.024569908156991005, -0.0362834706902504, -0.033335644751787186, 0.028679288923740387, 0.03552331402897835, 0.015425257384777069, 0.02706068940460682, 0.041748665273189545, 0.011678028851747513, -0.008470064960420132, -0.037909142673015594, 0.040748436003923416, 0.00937989167869091, 0.004911739379167557, -0.019026845693588257, 0.015488926321268082, 0.014538665302097797, -0.05774799734354019, -0.03748489171266556, -0.046022821217775345, -0.0005914248758926988, 0.018349681049585342, 0.055580686777830124, -0.011192885227501392, 0.029032839462161064, 0.04523690417408943, 0.00908586010336876, 0.025122523307800293, -0.020079486072063446, 0.05899886041879654, 0.02892284281551838, 0.06602054834365845, -0.08163930475711823, 0.009227140806615353, -0.03576800599694252, -0.034765392541885376, 0.007077992893755436, -0.02925570122897625, -0.02906949445605278, 0.02964545227587223, -0.0020519851241260767, 0.011656134389340878, -0.055758193135261536, -0.02478104643523693, 0.0021769963204860687, -0.03358234837651253, -0.051764342933893204, -0.002284557092934847, 0.08312362432479858, 0.007079518865793943, 0.060721106827259064, -0.014121039770543575, -0.025488995015621185, -0.004422352649271488, -0.05240967497229576, -0.0395418182015419, 0.009648038074374199, -0.015858445316553116, 0.05337842181324959, 0.019114257767796516, 0.000965669343713671, 0.018587278202176094, -0.0029433025047183037, -0.060791704803705215, -0.04120728373527527, -0.01847713813185692, -0.05526900291442871, -0.08819301426410675, 0.03195381164550781, 0.022260800004005432, -0.010775422677397728, 0.04505741596221924, 0.024426400661468506, 0.031276408582925797, -0.06065549701452255, -0.020044470205903053, 0.012751713395118713, -0.011451950296759605, -0.010216288268566132, -0.04194188863039017, -0.005797481629997492, 0.008888197131454945, -0.015423937700688839, -0.00031770378700457513, -0.02587048150599003, -0.033305585384368896, -0.0016784572508186102, 0.05700601637363434, -0.01924402266740799, -0.050548896193504333, 0.08000301569700241, 0.008846700191497803, 0.037360332906246185, -0.06261108815670013, 0.009299702011048794, -0.0021849123295396566, 0.011954836547374725, -0.03248339891433716, -0.05786960944533348, -0.07189875096082687, 0.0924958810210228, -0.017353544011712074, 0.01667453534901142, -0.013973359018564224, -0.03553406149148941, 0.002958577126264572, -0.03191964700818062, 0.004363922402262688, 0.01139698177576065, -0.047482047230005264, -0.018176259472966194, -0.08298282325267792, 0.016766512766480446, 0.06504466384649277, -0.037894245237112045, 0.009290559217333794, -0.011878437362611294, 0.0034606342669576406, -0.004860357381403446, -0.00010882799688261002, 0.020589135587215424, 0.03341454640030861, -0.027578085660934448, 0.025784485042095184, -0.015625955536961555 ]
<p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/qTI9v.jpg" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>How can I calculate the mean of the first schema? I don't have the individual values of the sample. Std. Deviation (B) is 0.6441.</p>
g74048
[ -0.015142366290092468, 0.031829074025154114, -0.007457822561264038, -0.034398071467876434, 0.0011134694796055555, 0.01210289541631937, 0.032575588673353195, 0.07141508907079697, -0.032128848135471344, -0.021926863119006157, -0.05287056043744087, 0.05027536302804947, 0.00228520343080163, -0.01104207243770361, -0.008967834524810314, 0.011393270455300808, 0.038445163518190384, 0.0017563137225806713, 0.03052672930061817, 0.04629148542881012, -0.07279543578624725, 0.028325481340289116, -0.03606481850147247, -0.027832863852381706, 0.047273971140384674, -0.046856749802827835, 0.015932731330394745, 0.08267835527658463, -0.05997605621814728, 0.05613796040415764, -0.038169704377651215, -0.007474852260202169, 0.036544762551784515, -0.027171915397047997, 0.01973443105816841, 0.028347907587885857, 0.0031086986418813467, 0.028657840564846992, 0.012438001111149788, -0.002028021262958646, -0.030275380238890648, -0.020428845658898354, 0.004465142264962196, -0.03723668307065964, -0.008241713978350163, 0.016959425061941147, -0.017981374636292458, 0.011587822809815407, 0.017955131828784943, -0.02996595948934555, 0.04949798434972763, 0.02208605408668518, 0.06987636536359787, 0.003272832138463855, 0.01257276814430952, -0.003394892904907465, 0.03339988738298416, -0.05282103642821312, 0.02668723091483116, 0.011905127204954624, -0.014819997362792492, -0.01866895519196987, -0.02494289167225361, 0.024654047563672066, 0.000518669025041163, 0.06335737556219101, -0.029642559587955475, -0.03681517019867897, -0.06445381790399551, 0.056711345911026, -0.01850476674735546, 0.00771627901121974, 0.03627252206206322, 0.01814352534711361, -0.09048427641391754, -0.02527604065835476, 0.01644343137741089, 0.01937718503177166, 0.0673968568444252, 0.04618165269494057, -0.015919329598546028, 0.026604028418660164, -0.02051328495144844, -0.0018430008785799146, 0.013599040918052197, 0.07413605600595474, 0.008920942433178425, 0.03389785811305046, 0.019618388265371323, 0.005560732446610928, 0.02735315077006817, -0.002741507487371564, -0.01444996241480112, 0.06810701638460159, 0.0432373471558094, -0.06191322207450867, -0.05609453096985817, 0.06546659022569656, 0.01644873432815075, 0.013241230510175228, 0.010174174793064594, 0.062060680240392685, 0.017763538286089897, -0.08439824730157852, -0.05322287604212761, -0.04666195064783096, 0.024386582896113396, -0.012612128630280495, -0.02732515148818493, -0.004604910500347614, -0.04140445590019226, -0.12411710619926453, -0.048009634017944336, 0.01860530860722065, 0.00073387281736359, -0.04075757414102554, 0.04421772435307503, -0.05586010217666626, -0.012570608407258987, -0.05500708892941475, -0.02513684704899788, -0.07967644184827805, 0.05874808877706528, 0.105437271296978, -0.030740415677428246, 0.032613977789878845, 0.003646207507699728, -0.010777388699352741, 0.03972944617271423, 0.009027988649904728, 0.014061999507248402, -0.03515898436307907, 0.0191479679197073, 0.03225152567028999, 0.022671883925795555, 0.018516113981604576, 0.016320204362273216, 0.06824852526187897, -0.01348344050347805, 0.02768787369132042, 0.0005752641009166837, 0.016123011708259583, 0.04745173454284668, -0.043829940259456635, 0.02375219762325287, -0.07713374495506287, 0.026564445346593857, -0.010722721926867962, 0.03481579199433327, 0.010562866926193237, 0.02186434715986252, 0.039207424968481064, -0.022610437124967575, 0.0529249869287014, -0.006746937055140734, -0.04711315035820007, 0.0502987764775753, 0.05379600077867508, -0.039921969175338745, -0.08532609790563583, 0.030522139742970467, -0.05127037689089775, -0.013420975767076015, -0.026422198861837387, 0.05122119188308716, 0.008879275992512703, -0.001989145064726472, -0.0342152900993824, -0.00675481092184782, -0.022880231961607933, 0.007433063350617886, -0.05818254500627518, -0.06845471262931824, -0.05633457377552986, 0.0013571633026003838, 0.04185720160603523, -0.051167648285627365, 0.019172830507159233, 0.03997810557484627, 0.08379384130239487, 0.0463961623609066, -0.025104066357016563, 0.05016501992940903, -0.06151581183075905, 0.02647240087389946, -0.016233405098319054, -0.01982005499303341, 0.008324536494910717, -0.00634759571403265, -0.03207475692033768, 0.03967875614762306, -0.020191209390759468, 0.04439299926161766, -0.030912285670638084, -0.024532843381166458, -0.03253013268113136, 0.011235712096095085, 0.00046989237307570875, -0.0028935312293469906, 0.021181315183639526, 0.010049999691545963, 0.05460500717163086, -0.05062292888760567, 0.0474860817193985, 0.004073512740433216, -0.012133562937378883, -0.009606667794287205, 0.027051428332924843, 0.0028447811491787434, 0.0019450330873951316, -0.03885500505566597, -0.00040848838398233056, -0.07772036641836166, 0.02567226067185402, -0.005852385424077511, 0.035366956144571304, 0.012727556750178337, -0.013330552726984024, 0.021386029198765755, 0.016341164708137512, 0.011147796176373959, 0.04171860218048096, -0.0001398370077367872, 0.00850675068795681, -0.011874275282025337, 0.09770972281694412, 0.0409722626209259, 0.0042645991779863834, 0.012366694398224354, -0.023612238466739655, -0.033608175814151764, -0.006085600703954697, -0.015510152094066143, -0.04838579148054123, 0.07447083294391632, 0.0036614451091736555, -0.002443380653858185, 0.00651384936645627, -0.015565219335258007, -0.00313473935239017, 0.04147334396839142, -0.07109937816858292, -0.00539987999945879, 0.03276996687054634, 0.012236393056809902, -0.04192167893052101, 0.019577503204345703, 0.02574930153787136, -0.011443163268268108, 0.019065789878368378, 0.005713717080652714, -0.007232946343719959, 0.007856006734073162, -0.012062160298228264, 0.01953558623790741, -0.016396505758166313, 0.030805261805653572, 0.016308307647705078, 0.0018557580187916756, -0.01761937327682972, -0.028368109837174416, -0.054615944623947144, 0.036067888140678406, 0.0106019526720047, 0.01826888509094715, -0.03596492484211922, 0.049682967364788055, -0.014871419407427311, 0.029980143532156944, 0.009381996467709541, -0.055370911955833435, 0.014921722002327442, 0.004798062611371279, 0.019122056663036346, -0.005630945786833763, 0.0432339571416378, -0.00530755240470171, 0.057300809770822525, -0.018221521750092506, 0.012931999750435352, -0.055244144052267075, 0.021919066086411476, 0.024340474978089333, 0.023975903168320656, 0.08306451141834259, 0.0025473085697740316, 0.013724767602980137, -0.07562670856714249, 0.009634030051529408, -0.018569933250546455, -0.024691114202141762, -0.002320236526429653, -0.004799606278538704, 0.009261512197554111, -0.04509245231747627, 0.002305937698110938, 0.0023051858879625797, -0.028151175007224083, 0.06731268018484116, 0.04578055068850517, -0.03306514769792557, 0.04289825260639191, 0.009054108522832394, 0.006085130386054516, -0.0013256464153528214, 0.008505475707352161, 0.02065948024392128, -0.017643321305513382, 0.045934226363897324, 0.0065791853703558445, 0.014953375793993473, -0.08303932100534439, 0.016273194923996925, -0.04309346526861191, -0.0003098245069850236, -0.02587965875864029, -0.0023045975249260664, 0.0028127895202487707, 0.007642693351954222, 0.01028649602085352, -0.008869189769029617, -0.05019683763384819, -0.01562012080103159, 0.04793311282992363, 0.008015722967684269, 0.020762765780091286, -0.08414576947689056, 0.05058989301323891, 0.0194688830524683, -0.018742412328720093, 0.016884934157133102, 0.027065670117735863, -0.012330027297139168, 0.01778177171945572, 0.018076656386256218, -0.02431069314479828, 0.02576622925698757, -0.030505474656820297, -0.05370623990893364, 0.03170115128159523, -0.0416630282998085, -0.05352791026234627, -0.0115895327180624, -0.08070942759513855, -0.04144744947552681, -0.022376082837581635, -0.0014230445958673954, 0.01861022412776947, 0.0001673720544204116, 0.010404977947473526, 0.05747270956635475, 0.012285981327295303, 0.02657962031662464, 0.0266911368817091, -0.01912160962820053, 0.0550600104033947, 0.027635810896754265, -0.03168734908103943, -0.002354829339310527, 0.046745143830776215, 0.019813114777207375, -0.019217513501644135, -0.03590603172779083, 0.02305419370532036, 0.030950075015425682, 0.020430712029337883, -0.031570542603731155, 0.06509075313806534, 0.04614228755235672, 0.01786782220005989, -0.08613231033086777, -0.015714237466454506, 0.055897828191518784, -0.014214685186743736, -0.019046496599912643, -0.00243968958966434, 0.0574081726372242, 0.0016925287200137973, -0.029772670939564705, 0.03305022791028023, 0.04562190920114517, -0.009851927869021893, -0.03627381846308708, -0.02701287716627121, -0.020931294187903404, -0.009616483002901077, -0.01587842032313347, -0.02205459028482437, -0.021415576338768005, -0.01685624197125435, 0.036811552941799164, -0.030461622402071953, -0.0560980886220932, 0.0075427452102303505, -0.006774703040719032, 0.02892528846859932, 0.03806186094880104, 0.0962950736284256, -0.04579837992787361, 0.04632026329636574, -0.010794649831950665, -0.03879276290535927, 0.03682344779372215, -0.014620320871472359, -0.010952300392091274, -0.03978155925869942, 0.009044015780091286, 0.003939855378121138, 0.058916497975587845, 0.06374463438987732, -0.0678592398762703, -0.059792567044496536, 0.03240585699677467, -0.012749232351779938, 0.06384959816932678, -0.019717242568731308, 0.05325696989893913, -0.0013958864146843553, -0.025778912007808685, 0.04187244176864624, -0.015230141580104828, -0.00011669279774650931, -0.014364381320774555, 0.0062576280906796455, -0.025051414966583252, -0.0604386106133461, -0.04571648687124252, 0.021617954596877098, 0.00719897635281086, -0.03107549622654915, 0.005818703677505255, 0.07557178288698196, -0.023183399811387062, 0.0186010729521513, -0.06109076738357544, -0.015191926620900631, 0.07913309335708618, 0.01920027658343315, -0.03906838968396187, -0.06427523493766785, -0.0028755341190844774, -0.004941487684845924, -0.005196395330131054, -0.011636581271886826, 0.053927771747112274, 0.03497958555817604, -0.04928983375430107, -0.03899857774376869, -0.03636970371007919, 0.009803574532270432, 0.011857309378683567, 0.009469510987401009, -0.09226454049348831, 0.023817697539925575, 0.043861471116542816, -0.006056411657482386, -0.007235999684780836, 0.05225512012839317, 0.01248150784522295, 0.0656888410449028, -0.02673448622226715, -0.04039151594042778, -0.024726318195462227, -0.014701799489557743, -0.05470825731754303, 0.012344381771981716, 0.01748083345592022, 0.020964885130524635, 0.036725785583257675, 0.03414363041520119, -0.046635113656520844, 0.005154017824679613, 0.02399386093020439, -0.014087713323533535, -0.0027970869559794664, 0.0852556899189949, -0.019388645887374878, -0.009543674997985363, -0.012422437779605389, -0.01232347171753645, -0.04703308269381523, 0.0169274490326643, 0.021310031414031982, 0.021386168897151947, 0.060998402535915375, -0.005803055129945278, 0.03211129456758499, -0.0729735940694809, 0.04025682061910629, -0.03279190883040428, -0.036949001252651215, 0.035610903054475784, 0.038189519196748734, -0.027153383940458298, 0.04590383917093277, -0.016941597685217857, 0.04873098433017731, -0.017902305349707603, -0.02617737650871277, -0.003755936399102211, -0.032875433564186096, 0.03466999903321266, -0.04292791709303856, -0.003964070696383715, -0.000808264478109777, 0.014126669615507126, 0.038767531514167786, -0.0033050531055778265, -0.006203521508723497, 0.014260699972510338, 0.06465990841388702, -0.01589977741241455, 0.05093282833695412, -0.05184684693813324, 0.09128259867429733, -0.003456291276961565, 0.017428381368517876, -0.021227100864052773, 0.01449065376073122, 0.012219180352985859, 0.03810640051960945, 0.005293678026646376, 0.02130921557545662, -0.05841660127043724, -0.02213459461927414, -0.0829395204782486, -0.0286218523979187, -0.05403480306267738, 0.0294149499386549, -0.004125126637518406, -0.025662625208497047, 0.03960096091032028, -0.03338013216853142, -0.02609224058687687, 0.04388382285833359, -0.04501362144947052, -0.026563525199890137, -0.010285008698701859, 0.0020310047548264265, -0.0200865026563406, -0.0026318358723074198, 0.07204126566648483, 0.03233785927295685, -0.05232098698616028, -0.00572990532964468, -0.015980293974280357, -0.024640286341309547, 0.014050054363906384, 0.006536021828651428, 0.04362188279628754, 0.0005033418419770896, 0.020584486424922943, 0.026627464219927788, -0.022352388128638268, -0.00620247283950448, 0.06425406038761139, -0.03742368891835213, -0.0013104721438139677, 0.011481261812150478, -0.024683641269803047, -0.01522442139685154, -0.035516951233148575, 0.038975901901721954, -0.02890838123857975, -0.05346895381808281, -0.044495921581983566, -0.01998814009130001, 0.016917135566473007, 0.010401969775557518, 0.017533572390675545, 0.033486027270555496, -0.025115085765719414, 0.03618835285305977, 0.00703221233561635, 0.016559749841690063, 0.051136650145053864, -0.01962236501276493, -0.043312039226293564, 0.029137270525097847, -0.02190166339278221, -0.08044275641441345, -0.006732396315783262, 0.036930788308382034, -0.0765535831451416, -0.05106665939092636, 0.04904709383845329, -0.01742473989725113, 0.022568749263882637, -0.013952271081507206, 0.03301660716533661, 0.03567890077829361, 0.014445744454860687, 0.0069150072522461414, -0.04018695279955864, 0.007441947236657143, -0.0414249449968338, 0.009291755966842175, -0.0029210238717496395, -0.00735835125669837, -0.0006413463852368295, 0.00039784389082342386, 0.006321909837424755, 0.01777656190097332, -0.03461097925901413, -0.005226297304034233, 0.00795533787459135, -0.04151247441768646, 0.0379047691822052, -0.0020434644538909197, -0.010004849173128605, 0.012235899455845356, 0.023539038375020027, -0.009687203913927078, 0.04962177202105522, 0.02563830092549324, -0.019809680059552193, -0.0542672798037529, 0.04343164339661598, -0.07834362238645554, 0.010473462752997875, -0.03729039058089256, -0.03805740922689438, -0.005249751731753349, -0.05558881163597107, -0.0034094860311597586, 0.06669587641954422, 0.010994677431881428, -0.02426709234714508, 0.0474432110786438, -0.06797248870134354, -0.06536492705345154, 0.03258431702852249, 0.001095831859856844, -0.002353143645450473, -0.06915634125471115, 0.03441499173641205, -0.0410003662109375, 0.07134174555540085, 0.07635263353586197, 0.020109687000513077, 0.008097057230770588, 0.03786269947886467, -0.01439712755382061, -0.03297419100999832, -0.014698631130158901, 0.00566660612821579, -0.008000030182301998, 0.007480432279407978, -0.006959760095924139, 0.00813636090606451, 0.060576170682907104, 0.01711440458893776, 0.022554051131010056, -0.011166799813508987, 0.008732746355235577, -0.005093115381896496, 0.061739709228277206, 0.006899781990796328, 0.04763341322541237, -0.05627847835421562, -0.06928317248821259, -0.045583393424749374, -0.007511551957577467, -0.052403733134269714, 0.03103427030146122, 0.008353481069207191, 0.000016915753803914413, -0.0012168583925813437, -0.005470246076583862, -0.051486652344465256, -0.050727877765893936, -0.00533869257196784, -0.04369158670306206, 0.016511674970388412, -0.016830557957291603, -0.058973509818315506, 0.025345342233777046, 0.05274522677063942, -0.037639763206243515, 0.008470691740512848, -0.029181700199842453, 0.018407559022307396, 0.01042683981359005, 0.0013328301720321178, -0.035754140466451645, -0.0016107463743537664, -0.02080145850777626, 0.05734489858150482, 0.08334194868803024, -0.020114190876483917, -0.07084451615810394, -0.04324385151267052, -0.027942083775997162, -0.018906181678175926, -0.00021931457740720361, -0.0034112012945115566, -0.022593986243009567, -0.0008273387793451548, 0.005080243572592735, -0.010649863630533218, 0.010752683505415916, 0.029900867491960526, -0.028839100152254105, 0.011374583467841148, -0.04177384823560715, -0.0562712661921978, 0.004372561350464821, -0.05335226282477379, -0.03261400759220123, -0.07563762366771698, -0.02803836576640606, 0.04411419481039047, -0.0016549784922972322, -0.03436349332332611, 0.03894183039665222, 0.02159276232123375, -0.027369951829314232, -0.009238346479833126, 0.005578195676207542, 0.010192799381911755, 0.027766123414039612, 0.06969950348138809, -0.0068826936185359955, -0.057930268347263336, -0.026438552886247635, -0.03904329612851143, 0.02034253068268299, 0.05480946600437164, -0.0002644154883455485, -0.05071196332573891, -0.036235030740499496, -0.01769922487437725, -0.03901498392224312, 0.024812249466776848, 0.022685950621962547, 0.06076637655496597, 0.014194159768521786, -0.002190602943301201, 0.04117685556411743, 0.016925860196352005, -0.054464153945446014, 0.04094797745347023, 0.03925090283155441, -0.003213925287127495, -0.01935671828687191, 0.023067805916070938, -0.05285921320319176, 0.0015888778725638986, 0.03031470626592636, -0.033532943576574326, 0.005581382196396589, -0.009582536295056343, 0.011800856329500675, 0.019187504425644875, -0.0038377942983061075, -0.0061765071004629135, -0.0039867376908659935, 0.009537461213767529, 0.02538749948143959, -0.00929157342761755, -0.04585149139165878, -0.09079812467098236, -0.046595651656389236, 0.09324274212121964, 0.0014118475373834372, -0.030626652762293816, -0.01797710545361042, -0.0109288040548563 ]
<p>This is an ill posed problem I'm faced with at work.</p> <p>I have observations $X_i$, $i = 1,2,3,...N &gt; M$. I need want to compute $S = \sum_{i=1}^M X_i$. Unfortunately, $M$ is random, and extremely noisy. It turns out, I have some rough "goodness" measures, $w_i$ for each of the $X_i$. That is, $w_i$ low, means I don't trust $X_i$ very much, $w_i$ high, means I trust $X_i$ a lot. </p> <p>Moreover, "generally" as $i$ gets large, the $X_i$ get small. (There's a lot of dependence between $M$ and the $X_i$)</p> <p>In this application, it turns out that the <em>average</em> of the $X_i$ can very reliably (i.e. with relatively small standard deviation) be computed by: $A = \frac{\sum_{i=1}^M w_i X_i}{\sum_{i=1}^M w_i}$. We know the standard deviation of $A$ is relatively small by running a number of independent trials, and computing the sample standard deviation.</p> <p>But, I similarly need a "good" estimate (i.e. small standard deviation) of the straight sum of the $X_i$ and the obvious approach: $M * A$ has far too much variance for our application.</p> <p>Understand this is pretty vague, but any thoughts on how to proceed?</p>
g74049
[ -0.027446990832686424, 0.02609333023428917, -0.03593472018837929, -0.0059919836930930614, -0.062298666685819626, -0.025018775835633278, 0.02663571946322918, -0.013042425736784935, -0.03537571430206299, -0.013224621303379536, -0.017325088381767273, 0.048762548714876175, 0.0025187740102410316, 0.004318101331591606, -0.05862899497151375, 0.03651032969355583, 0.05621383339166641, 0.022541478276252747, 0.009835805743932724, -0.016324758529663086, -0.03024228848516941, -0.01913614384829998, 0.03691470995545387, -0.013283626176416874, 0.04768946394324303, -0.060050416737794876, -0.005850549787282944, 0.060757510364055634, -0.05421247333288193, 0.00389077584259212, -0.032778311520814896, -0.023053981363773346, 0.034091077744960785, -0.035768233239650726, 0.017168603837490082, 0.022198272868990898, 0.01708570122718811, -0.03121442161500454, 0.0742604061961174, -0.02101934887468815, -0.06031504645943642, 0.006269596517086029, 0.05156100168824196, 0.03942858800292015, 0.02248215489089489, 0.026380494236946106, -0.013432998210191727, 0.0076237628236413, 0.01712341234087944, -0.05459703877568245, 0.02633662521839142, 0.008213698863983154, 0.07595345377922058, 0.011540252715349197, 0.010631469078361988, 0.04212440550327301, -0.024926772341132164, -0.02804948203265667, 0.014464463107287884, -0.0025017359293997288, 0.05411657691001892, -0.11194353550672531, -0.06320878863334656, -0.03856435790657997, -0.022909270599484444, 0.08566369116306305, -0.03171314671635628, -0.02473451755940914, 0.03879544511437416, 0.021661752834916115, 0.03246742859482765, -0.00045228659291751683, 0.05382636934518814, -0.06524799019098282, -0.0694265142083168, -0.0063273971900343895, 0.04669271036982536, 0.03376466780900955, -0.007074494380503893, 0.05354641005396843, -0.024519579485058784, -0.06309061497449875, 0.005137680098414421, 0.008554094471037388, -0.01773603819310665, -0.022032365202903748, 0.023352893069386482, 0.008571974001824856, 0.00005693653292837553, -0.027408037334680557, 0.032757341861724854, -0.005387071520090103, 0.013610497117042542, 0.055075984448194504, 0.06923442333936691, -0.04304187372326851, -0.09187566488981247, 0.00025289785116910934, -0.028774544596672058, -0.004185105208307505, 0.011801101267337799, 0.004178360104560852, 0.000578999170102179, -0.03122394159436226, -0.03298749774694443, -0.002534059574827552, 0.007898299023509026, 0.05762772634625435, 0.013825975358486176, -0.029559677466750145, -0.019318286329507828, 0.006933652795851231, 0.04487410560250282, -0.08849786967039108, -0.02184600755572319, -0.03573165461421013, -0.009580072946846485, 0.013499722816050053, -0.02918725088238716, 0.0148417167365551, -0.035427771508693695, -0.06120213493704796, 0.03596898168325424, 0.049263082444667816, -0.017473697662353516, 0.011095434427261353, 0.012335274368524551, 0.08040664345026016, 0.026490593329072, 0.028461936861276627, 0.015234523452818394, -0.03441794216632843, -0.005299184937030077, 0.014699142426252365, -0.04974968731403351, 0.0390525721013546, 0.0056178332306444645, 0.04379487782716751, -0.007508563809096813, 0.06366372108459473, -0.017946546897292137, 0.00009560050966683775, -0.0025063769426196814, -0.030498966574668884, -0.04198257252573967, 0.010753064416348934, -0.010711360722780228, -0.052737463265657425, 0.006289033219218254, -0.030832797288894653, 0.0038003313820809126, 0.05895073339343071, -0.030183732509613037, 0.009163463488221169, -0.009164669550955296, 0.03391975909471512, -0.005857796408236027, 0.05576721951365471, -0.004189608618617058, 0.0036029680632054806, 0.03560134768486023, 0.00005701871486962773, -0.017237823456525803, 0.00405142642557621, 0.034798137843608856, 0.0452321320772171, -0.045123953372240067, -0.06535139679908752, -0.02812858670949936, -0.0276288203895092, -0.008694338612258434, -0.044400010257959366, 0.03125074505805969, -0.029398100450634956, -0.024646153673529625, -0.000908601563423872, 0.022629430517554283, -0.013987613841891289, 0.03378172963857651, 0.07486545294523239, 0.009022664278745651, 0.04654211550951004, 0.022110195830464363, -0.09917938709259033, 0.0003009522333741188, -0.0035541043616831303, 0.030017929151654243, -0.029866650700569153, -0.03368271514773369, -0.043429162353277206, 0.013874951750040054, 0.0026391928549855947, 0.01363374013453722, -0.020876865833997726, -0.0300137959420681, 0.014503981918096542, 0.04529436305165291, -0.03281385451555252, 0.024520473554730415, -0.02087283879518509, 0.008148050867021084, 0.004525011871010065, 0.0033454233780503273, 0.05832067131996155, 0.011542847380042076, 0.03747384622693062, -0.00040949604590423405, -0.007679398637264967, -0.0374852754175663, 0.006468547508120537, -0.032445769757032394, -0.044931985437870026, -0.02305757626891136, -0.0025165618862956762, 0.02410937286913395, -0.02655048482120037, 0.013514258898794651, -0.027538232505321503, -0.00782910268753767, -0.017839305102825165, 0.028445515781641006, 0.0015854266239330173, 0.0852237343788147, -0.006648283451795578, 0.06320184469223022, 0.021140018478035927, -0.018102452158927917, 0.03330941125750542, 0.022338062524795532, 0.0027481766883283854, -0.02815299667418003, -0.014971812255680561, 0.012760426849126816, -0.03083368018269539, 0.03598953038454056, 0.02718781866133213, -0.0040586888790130615, -0.023173131048679352, 0.02605832926928997, 0.033088598400354385, 0.029315341264009476, -0.0593457967042923, -0.012156371027231216, -0.024600178003311157, 0.0003136661252938211, -0.004770055878907442, -0.00036052128416486084, -0.020986950024962425, 0.03138268366456032, -0.04447522386908531, -0.04955604299902916, 0.03657398372888565, 0.012072179466485977, -0.07239678502082825, -0.011993220075964928, 0.0018561027245596051, 0.043323539197444916, 0.03593472018837929, 0.05209202691912651, 0.03865279257297516, -0.04620620235800743, -0.04252798855304718, 0.027105458080768585, 0.018659180030226707, 0.032840970903635025, 0.005435792729258537, 0.03085622377693653, 0.007788083981722593, -0.004757935646921396, 0.028090335428714752, -0.03001730516552925, -0.003225925611332059, 0.07164525985717773, 0.08041080087423325, 0.037447694689035416, 0.01292792521417141, -0.04563950002193451, 0.04740685597062111, 0.015125028789043427, 0.04001723602414131, -0.0429542250931263, 0.01607149839401245, 0.03321687877178192, 0.009884667582809925, 0.038315825164318085, -0.070609450340271, -0.0004339048464316875, -0.07304392755031586, 0.04012972488999367, 0.03863104060292244, 0.018920250236988068, 0.02508297748863697, -0.0016183778643608093, 0.014195493422448635, -0.00032228976488113403, -0.03064553812146187, -0.013636528514325619, -0.02895495854318142, 0.026020284742116928, 0.026545904576778412, -0.0419597364962101, 0.05847645550966263, 0.02078993059694767, 0.004487453959882259, -0.004313225392252207, -0.03735823556780815, 0.013164596632122993, -0.022812681272625923, 0.031184637919068336, -0.028969407081604004, 0.02053101733326912, -0.04510267823934555, 0.034324340522289276, -0.012460757978260517, -0.051238883286714554, -0.01517611462622881, 0.02139323204755783, -0.014633188024163246, 0.010098842903971672, 0.0013388219522312284, 0.029497528448700905, -0.07213940471410751, -0.027014626190066338, -0.009846887551248074, -0.01747606135904789, -0.011468491517007351, -0.08518606424331665, 0.0012138196034356952, -0.007563112303614616, -0.016509022563695908, 0.06014517322182655, 0.02278023026883602, 0.008173705078661442, -0.005572398658841848, -0.045217327773571014, -0.06806980818510056, 0.044773492962121964, 0.009744146838784218, -0.001818892196752131, -0.002742261392995715, -0.08277037739753723, -0.005725574679672718, -0.06768268346786499, -0.023118287324905396, -0.042061060667037964, 0.027022065594792366, -0.030392006039619446, -0.015767263248562813, 0.025572557002305984, -0.0784343034029007, 0.019923552870750427, -0.0430917926132679, 0.001985239563509822, 0.0005446341820061207, 0.023754548281431198, 0.044052738696336746, 0.012034117244184017, -0.023386813700199127, -0.0013804713962599635, -0.04269694909453392, 0.019040994346141815, -0.04668755456805229, -0.052562691271305084, -0.015130585059523582, -0.0014098454266786575, -0.030719222500920296, -0.0010251776548102498, 0.060900986194610596, -0.0007662164862267673, 0.024555012583732605, -0.0463239923119545, 0.04292605072259903, 0.049347925931215286, 0.02859969437122345, -0.004656775388866663, 0.0049923621118068695, 0.04354004189372063, 0.026449548080563545, 0.002637309953570366, 0.034217651933431625, 0.029050976037979126, 0.04572976753115654, -0.05782673880457878, -0.026512213051319122, -0.025635890662670135, -0.005899570416659117, 0.007173039484769106, -0.010838951915502548, -0.011816376820206642, -0.04028966650366783, 0.005502242594957352, -0.10224457085132599, -0.014070183970034122, 0.03277764841914177, 0.003417614381760359, -0.1086103767156601, 0.02169014886021614, -0.0118157509714365, -0.008359238505363464, 0.038377828896045685, 0.02006697654724121, 0.012061260640621185, 0.032967716455459595, 0.018135715276002884, -0.0670173391699791, -0.022412877529859543, -0.01486813835799694, -0.001782465958967805, -0.02299855463206768, 0.044272005558013916, -0.007777309976518154, -0.021968837827444077, 0.07388769090175629, -0.03831925243139267, 0.006083997897803783, -0.04056284576654434, 0.026227915659546852, -0.04969233646988869, -0.022764280438423157, 0.002650335431098938, -0.03686830773949623, 0.029800791293382645, -0.02396760880947113, -0.013191679492592812, -0.016681598499417305, 0.006542217917740345, 0.00841147918254137, 0.013641628436744213, -0.015221000649034977, -0.0033522513695061207, 0.060922715812921524, 0.05189407616853714, -0.012842772528529167, 0.05839448422193527, 0.03392042964696884, 0.025617258623242378, 0.039481621235609055, 0.0035183473955839872, -0.05261942744255066, -0.013151193968951702, -0.04170434549450874, 0.0008267419179901481, -0.007511182222515345, -0.01765626110136509, 0.0438925139605999, 0.031521160155534744, -0.0161946602165699, -0.010569489561021328, 0.02714468725025654, 0.05771254003047943, -0.006953805685043335, 0.013078859075903893, 0.003687474876642227, -0.02588222734630108, 0.07916125655174255, -0.005058672279119492, -0.01985606551170349, 0.05969609320163727, 0.02481200359761715, 0.006355959456413984, 0.015808435156941414, 0.0015526383649557829, -0.038872167468070984, 0.01561869028955698, -0.05615578591823578, -0.0005570501089096069, -0.0675908550620079, -0.008334547281265259, 0.02489278092980385, 0.007390407845377922, -0.008218302391469479, 0.057394180446863174, 0.0068299234844744205, -0.021641582250595093, -0.04744917154312134, 0.009528166614472866, -0.0423516109585762, -0.028567589819431305, -0.055027324706315994, 0.0636083334684372, 0.010505677200853825, -0.007315520197153091, 0.02621268853545189, 0.02711106464266777, 0.0412447527050972, -0.024131257086992264, 0.02629861608147621, -0.05341293662786484, 0.010108091868460178, -0.03401004895567894, 0.030479630455374718, 0.06397408246994019, 0.05140477791428566, 0.03830781206488609, -0.039531487971544266, -0.02293401211500168, 0.07728102058172226, 0.000005651379524351796, -0.030733976513147354, 0.014244500547647476, -0.0593533031642437, 0.02998664230108261, -0.02892768569290638, 0.013896849937736988, 0.01588261127471924, -0.007103663869202137, 0.008414250798523426, 0.0019061784259974957, 0.00734300771728158, 0.053027309477329254, -0.00789989810436964, 0.01844385266304016, 0.058341044932603836, -0.006724899169057608, -0.027481991797685623, 0.033150073140859604, 0.03833109140396118, 0.031766582280397415, -0.028086040169000626, -0.04145021736621857, 0.09556429833173752, -0.03477110341191292, -0.05422259122133255, 0.037952836602926254, -0.022677944973111153, -0.041616290807724, -0.08172517269849777, -0.042043913155794144, -0.042604196816682816, -0.03809468448162079, 0.004409489221870899, -0.06335578113794327, -0.03404054045677185, -0.05122627690434456, 0.022618994116783142, 0.005416505038738251, 0.005236769560724497, -0.013212453573942184, -0.022341014817357063, 0.031975362449884415, 0.04176587238907814, 0.00806542206555605, 0.055770762264728546, -0.011769662611186504, -0.005730754230171442, -0.0010965242981910706, 0.04915572702884674, 0.0266475398093462, 0.07688336819410324, -0.0021350698079913855, 0.006177794653922319, 0.030724965035915375, -0.004930297844111919, -0.04777265712618828, -0.017165951430797577, 0.04148704186081886, -0.019367028027772903, -0.028524547815322876, -0.0031345852185040712, 0.05988466739654541, 0.009929821826517582, -0.04557602480053902, 0.029988054186105728, -0.003978114575147629, -0.03391246870160103, -0.017237588763237, -0.012814016081392765, -0.02536640129983425, -0.01583550125360489, 0.09063594788312912, -0.023939061909914017, 0.0023754998110234737, 0.04805394634604454, -0.014428182505071163, 0.026312561705708504, -0.006240850314497948, -0.0033819214440882206, 0.030650250613689423, 0.09753265976905823, -0.08489421010017395, 0.009082669392228127, -0.017737984657287598, 0.02698899805545807, -0.02851867489516735, -0.026739727705717087, 0.0013520577922463417, -0.02539576031267643, 0.0327104814350605, 0.0007371156825684011, -0.016157133504748344, 0.015698986127972603, 0.03250491991639137, -0.016523757949471474, -0.02679247409105301, -0.01762407086789608, -0.059619203209877014, 0.010140391997992992, -0.05492660775780678, -0.047382380813360214, -0.04417307674884796, 0.02001143991947174, -0.03440515697002411, 0.03636309877038002, -0.03248484060168266, -0.007942932657897472, 0.015688542276620865, -0.01240097638219595, 0.007570102345198393, -0.007184513844549656, 0.020577874034643173, -0.03649827837944031, 0.025010254234075546, 0.019211024045944214, 0.07521925866603851, -0.030694428831338882, -0.01039830781519413, -0.040849197655916214, 0.0037810702342540026, -0.026389705017209053, -0.047564610838890076, 0.03505902737379074, 0.023075532168149948, -0.01474007498472929, 0.01866946555674076, -0.03897671401500702, 0.035498496145009995, 0.0297173410654068, -0.05770154297351837, 0.03449464216828346, 0.005965079180896282, 0.07267868518829346, 0.02873113378882408, -0.00244264118373394, 0.034941576421260834, -0.0745990201830864, 0.034025732427835464, -0.04497649148106575, 0.09071647375822067, -0.025366492569446564, 0.07893132418394089, 0.009059447795152664, 0.023738542571663857, -0.009064788930118084, 0.020556636154651642, -0.03516261652112007, -0.00916420016437769, 0.04780543968081474, 0.05401184409856796, -0.016516609117388725, 0.04287223145365715, 0.01494094729423523, 0.0011229998199269176, 0.043848589062690735, -0.0739363580942154, 0.01262019295245409, -0.007984386757016182, 0.070850670337677, -0.009374967776238918, 0.06420620530843735, -0.05889483541250229, -0.016195036470890045, -0.02167627587914467, -0.023904498666524887, -0.0476745069026947, -0.0036591975949704647, 0.04604015871882439, -0.061134882271289825, 0.00038385772495530546, -0.026403265073895454, -0.08741262555122375, 0.0645022988319397, -0.022907158359885216, -0.025136370211839676, 0.052164267748594284, 0.01546091865748167, -0.019211702048778534, 0.004942585714161396, 0.05881621316075325, -0.05731017887592316, 0.015393642708659172, -0.015414400026202202, -0.04638291150331497, 0.004158191382884979, 0.024317769333720207, -0.009259511716663837, 0.04701131954789162, 0.02498736046254635, -0.002166647696867585, 0.0043559870682656765, -0.018083153292536736, -0.0464327409863472, -0.018228154629468918, 0.014979690313339233, 0.0072610992938280106, -0.007162892259657383, 0.0591927245259285, 0.00040171860018745065, -0.0004727497580461204, 0.030377952381968498, 0.058557767421007156, 0.027337508276104927, 0.04506324604153633, -0.016497207805514336, -0.007526170462369919, -0.050943247973918915, -0.002777774352580309, -0.0018767805304378271, -0.05213949829339981, 0.021467087790369987, -0.0361659899353981, 0.01824633590877056, 0.0258585587143898, -0.04262853041291237, -0.009966717101633549, -0.0017928654560819268, -0.05795437470078468, -0.01082137692719698, -0.016226617619395256, 0.021952198818325996, -0.057575520128011703, -0.01832542009651661, 0.08001773059368134, 0.007502028252929449, 0.023708542808890343, 0.016897214576601982, -0.06073230504989624, -0.04929143935441971, -0.0007479243795387447, 0.02610764093697071, -0.008178319782018661, 0.00029117363737896085, -0.07962822169065475, -0.003930485341697931, 0.0219112578779459, 0.031867966055870056, 0.04083115607500076, 0.05056110769510269, -0.008094699122011662, -0.029304640367627144, 0.04289590194821358, -0.06455110758543015, 0.014992372132837772, 0.018605081364512444, -0.01614471897482872, 0.025035053491592407, 0.008471623063087463, -0.02283230610191822, 0.018658297136425972, -0.02256506308913231, -0.06082313135266304, -0.037053968757390976, 0.007941045798361301, -0.014126138761639595, 0.060970038175582886, 0.02410082519054413, 0.025035466998815536, 0.018090251833200455, 0.059281736612319946, 0.022979795932769775, 0.012559480033814907, -0.04935899004340172, -0.07123246788978577, -0.11986485123634338, 0.07252727448940277, 0.0002913920325227082, -0.04030001536011696, -0.0092678964138031, 0.011301081627607346 ]
<p>Violin players were asked to rate 5 violins from least to most rich on a <code>[0 1]</code>, <code>0.05-increment</code> scale, <code>most always = 1</code> and <code>least always = 0</code>. They were then asked to set a "limit of acceptability," i.e., to set a point along the scale above which violins are considered acceptable in terms of richness. By setting <code>acceptable = 1</code> and <code>not acceptable = 0</code>, a binary variable is obtained for each player, in addition to their rating. So, as an example, for a player I have the variables <code>rating = [0.3 0.45 0 1 0.85]</code> and for a <code>limit = 0.45</code>, <code>acc = [0 1 0 1 1]</code>. I use Lin's concordance correlation coefficient to explore consistency within and between individuals for the case of ratings. However, this is not possible for the "acceptable" variable: when a player sets their <code>limit = 0</code>, then <code>acc = [1 1 1 1 1]</code> and hence the presence of zero variance becomes an issue. I am trying to figure out a good, interesting way to analyze the binary data, perhaps compare consistency in ratings with consistency in acceptability limits, or more in-depth relations between the two variables. I am not very experienced in statistics, so any suggestions and ideas are welcome. I primarily work with MATLAB.</p>
g74050
[ -0.019397765398025513, 0.009508907794952393, 0.015601146034896374, -0.06519784033298492, 0.018124161288142204, 0.03371468558907509, 0.019612373784184456, -0.011740732938051224, -0.025174863636493683, 0.04753848910331726, -0.021142994984984398, 0.05197605490684509, -0.05216800794005394, 0.016131697222590446, -0.015773499384522438, 0.007337489631026983, 0.014483941718935966, -0.013867299072444439, 0.01798551343381405, -0.018116602674126625, 0.02149026282131672, 0.056462228298187256, 0.05960572138428688, -0.040864381939172745, -0.003708181669935584, -0.020399438217282295, -0.02371891774237156, -0.010714025236666203, -0.07630231976509094, -0.009271053597331047, -0.008377529680728912, 0.05353108048439026, 0.027992868795990944, 0.010002239607274532, 0.006065607536584139, 0.053891558200120926, 0.000006096501692809397, -0.013494784012436867, 0.026505902409553528, 0.05212147533893585, -0.01211999449878931, 0.018190788105130196, 0.04390621930360794, 0.015014532022178173, -0.04739760980010033, 0.014139129780232906, -0.011806191876530647, -0.0173249002546072, 0.027960771694779396, -0.01410922221839428, -0.006236918270587921, 0.014280455186963081, 0.06151864305138588, 0.02189520187675953, 0.02743973769247532, 0.07309409230947495, -0.04344572499394417, 0.03341824561357498, 0.028988640755414963, 0.015391754917800426, -0.03345950320363045, -0.013085574842989445, -0.025669503957033157, 0.01997634954750538, 0.04382072389125824, 0.0350668728351593, -0.0126598309725523, -0.05136984586715698, 0.016923731192946434, -0.008428363129496574, 0.0039080847054719925, -0.05612720921635628, -0.03981516882777214, 0.010657012462615967, -0.09867041558027267, -0.011843308806419373, -0.032969847321510315, 0.0029265349730849266, -0.01406838744878769, 0.013735729269683361, -0.01724202185869217, -0.0009617035975679755, 0.06521373242139816, 0.02757418341934681, 0.09121376276016235, -0.04000931978225708, 0.02710127644240856, -0.013857707381248474, 0.008233664557337761, 0.0024591463152319193, 0.05599510669708252, 0.03505643829703331, 0.06345421075820923, 0.0306773129850626, 0.006392387207597494, 0.007808599155396223, -0.08317692577838898, 0.035135962069034576, -0.012577719055116177, -0.03255319967865944, -0.009375304915010929, 0.04948943480849266, 0.00437677837908268, 0.018685357645154, -0.06864041090011597, 0.009011239744722843, 0.01128802727907896, 0.035567786544561386, -0.05462528020143509, -0.0042440989054739475, -0.04404359310865402, -0.03824233263731003, -0.028892260044813156, -0.09217195212841034, 0.00806922186166048, -0.04575417935848236, 0.029852090403437614, -0.022196168079972267, -0.04134626314043999, -0.0025177409406751394, -0.015789242461323738, -0.07273229956626892, 0.048825912177562714, 0.04478741064667702, -0.01969626359641552, -0.011675911024212837, -0.021207626909017563, 0.05774058774113655, 0.07347439229488373, -0.053355176001787186, 0.05370244383811951, -0.013893348164856434, 0.005976067390292883, 0.015642421320080757, -0.0040673804469406605, 0.0019628871232271194, 0.004431106615811586, 0.006957781966775656, 0.00583754712715745, 0.029658427461981773, -0.022280970588326454, 0.005329100880771875, 0.0114954998716712, -0.03760838136076927, 0.017018083482980728, 0.028356067836284637, 0.03726028650999069, -0.04593491926789284, -0.0019168759463354945, -0.005397247616201639, 0.06084267795085907, 0.0685000941157341, -0.03229590132832527, -0.03568245843052864, -0.09691297262907028, 0.02551622875034809, 0.018667850643396378, -0.01992843672633171, -0.037706159055233, 0.028457963839173317, 0.04879593849182129, 0.0010993300238624215, 0.02790454402565956, 0.015161232091486454, 0.021868515759706497, 0.04315194487571716, -0.031563445925712585, -0.01264752633869648, -0.02028496563434601, 0.026847055181860924, -0.010280015878379345, -0.0235135555267334, -0.023555809631943703, 0.0025621294043958187, 0.03759884461760521, 0.0073358966037631035, 0.01796378567814827, 0.03425956144928932, 0.015921788290143013, 0.026194710284471512, -0.025217019021511078, 0.034858427941799164, 0.04422948136925697, -0.009470156393945217, -0.0028778871055692434, -0.033990222960710526, 0.05265677720308304, 0.003850914305076003, -0.035401687026023865, -0.05849703773856163, -0.005975802429020405, -0.052916090935468674, -0.00287376600317657, -0.016709715127944946, -0.010392886586487293, -0.023803789168596268, 0.010877823457121849, -0.04673938825726509, 0.006896556820720434, -0.05531990900635719, -0.002932218601927161, 0.017946923151612282, 0.014731383882462978, 0.04014977440237999, -0.033367689698934555, 0.00198709056712687, -0.028789231553673744, -0.034949589520692825, -0.012230785563588142, 0.019470518454909325, -0.031080160290002823, -0.024012237787246704, -0.05900855362415314, 0.06124746799468994, -0.023894550278782845, -0.030951006338000298, 0.014285346493124962, -0.021222582086920738, -0.04101474955677986, 0.04057203605771065, 0.02662530168890953, -0.049516428261995316, 0.03468446806073189, 0.0065480787307024, -0.052664607763290405, 0.011203036643564701, 0.03323465213179588, -0.002289272379130125, 0.010483385063707829, 0.02973971515893936, 0.001901861047372222, 0.018568377941846848, 0.026971088722348213, -0.02117050625383854, 0.006289105862379074, -0.003922926262021065, 0.007670842111110687, 0.033913567662239075, -0.005464192945510149, 0.01973431371152401, -0.01901688612997532, 0.002684461884200573, -0.04487793520092964, 0.047900110483169556, 0.038096990436315536, -0.0028517853934317827, 0.008641059510409832, 0.027889829128980637, 0.03300962597131729, 0.05629541352391243, -0.052517496049404144, 0.03555101528763771, -0.0010528899729251862, 0.014707307331264019, 0.005549860652536154, -0.05230952799320221, 0.03729686141014099, 0.007579130586236715, 0.03731122612953186, -0.011724262498319149, 0.03916975110769272, 0.006566349416971207, 0.010444976389408112, 0.029185039922595024, 0.047674305737018585, -0.018327953293919563, 0.03321992605924606, -0.07324693351984024, -0.04290394112467766, 0.008381575345993042, -0.02561698481440544, 0.004259251989424229, 0.042965926229953766, 0.05432075262069702, 0.03369579091668129, 0.015076194889843464, -0.048269301652908325, 0.045632340013980865, 0.02787727676331997, 0.02021944709122181, 0.0011479946551844478, -0.02029019221663475, -0.03584330528974533, -0.028774060308933258, 0.037387195974588394, 0.05317140743136406, 0.016820814460515976, 0.0011198088759556413, -0.013108332641422749, 0.058921415358781815, -0.016521470621228218, 0.013487394899129868, -0.03987080231308937, 0.025422977283596992, 0.002653974574059248, 0.004938136786222458, -0.037419337779283524, -0.049426257610321045, 0.029454898089170456, 0.05248047783970833, -0.051934126764535904, -0.031171202659606934, -0.0043416498228907585, -0.00020317506277933717, -0.012498180381953716, -0.013486861251294613, -0.0038456993643194437, 0.03695622459053993, 0.024125924333930016, -0.016086913645267487, -0.06362573057413101, -0.041504308581352234, -0.019718704745173454, -0.059995219111442566, 0.005377452354878187, 0.011705097742378712, 0.029329344630241394, 0.04374020919203758, 0.018640585243701935, -0.04515541344881058, 0.017893817275762558, -0.028571870177984238, 0.06168027222156525, 0.013303522951900959, 0.0189414843916893, 0.009913946501910686, -0.0631006583571434, 0.09899686276912689, -0.0620192289352417, 0.038690611720085144, 0.030202116817235947, 0.05401473492383957, 0.051596786826848984, 0.00526713440194726, 0.0027267334517091513, -0.07743342220783234, -0.003395975800231099, -0.055748194456100464, 0.014909792691469193, 0.00704190693795681, -0.09316827356815338, 0.003582834033295512, -0.001820470206439495, 0.039225466549396515, 0.012323505245149136, 0.019090525805950165, 0.018978865817189217, -0.0011499327374622226, 0.025026163086295128, -0.00818132795393467, -0.01669277623295784, -0.05831059813499451, 0.012192150577902794, -0.04141589626669884, 0.016105109825730324, 0.025057543069124222, 0.025720184668898582, 0.003002570243552327, 0.008897597901523113, -0.023711148649454117, 0.033742375671863556, -0.007943821139633656, -0.019082754850387573, 0.0010516942711547017, -0.0016847767401486635, 0.020465832203626633, 0.03667951375246048, 0.05047237500548363, 0.0575430765748024, 0.021751822903752327, 0.03106970526278019, 0.01812654547393322, 0.020584261044859886, -0.06796091049909592, -0.008442437276244164, -0.07100098580121994, -0.0024589626118540764, 0.04797074571251869, 0.008567600511014462, 0.07098584622144699, 0.005886621307581663, 0.017370549961924553, 0.019527697935700417, -0.04426218569278717, -0.06560733169317245, -0.015037650242447853, -0.010768944397568703, 0.004106208216398954, 0.011818038299679756, -0.042011111974716187, -0.044907961040735245, -0.05782653018832207, -0.0419033020734787, 0.06536717712879181, 0.032306086272001266, -0.05363519489765167, 0.011758054606616497, 0.04477525129914284, 0.06503821164369583, 0.05940788984298706, -0.012346714735031128, -0.00479145348072052, -0.004216872155666351, 0.0017574045341461897, -0.05403430759906769, 0.01420493796467781, -0.054148320108652115, -0.005390746518969536, -0.010948420502245426, -0.015286275185644627, -0.041895415633916855, 0.01231056172400713, -0.00817306898534298, -0.02470550872385502, -0.007929177023470402, 0.015639998018741608, 0.021310115233063698, -0.02209590934216976, -0.007401889655739069, 0.0061529166996479034, -0.003847201354801655, 0.01963174156844616, -0.06798091530799866, -0.0427824929356575, 0.028429921716451645, -0.0646541565656662, 0.05816780775785446, 0.009992864914238453, 0.013041983358561993, -0.0032454330939799547, 0.01616080477833748, 0.05458860844373703, 0.029114803299307823, -0.020562388002872467, -0.009880678728222847, 0.002774619497358799, 0.017682591453194618, 0.0052646854892373085, -0.018404845148324966, -0.012228154577314854, -0.032313477247953415, -0.027575023472309113, 0.004222765099257231, -0.007011765614151955, -0.03336906060576439, 0.02378883771598339, -0.03274330124258995, -0.046686965972185135, 0.007626951206475496, 0.022046083584427834, -0.012693027034401894, 0.012108820490539074, 0.023022271692752838, 0.0037854539696127176, 0.006906657014042139, -0.0036922318395227194, 0.028636246919631958, 0.024588102474808693, 0.03287535533308983, -0.040055375546216965, 0.04390539973974228, -0.054557546973228455, -0.08545830100774765, -0.050523873418569565, 0.008867326192557812, -0.0361194834113121, 0.011687918566167355, -0.026736054569482803, 0.04854970797896385, -0.011848068796098232, -0.020137200132012367, 0.039308905601501465, 0.041151437908411026, 0.0323617123067379, -0.0006678934441879392, -0.02499360963702202, -0.004545437637716532, 0.014709929935634136, -0.0031586713157594204, -0.042719416320323944, -0.05401456728577614, 0.037329304963350296, 0.028484752401709557, 0.03517435863614082, -0.0135765690356493, -0.034067727625370026, 0.034175191074609756, -0.04989545792341232, 0.03833698853850365, 0.038745466619729996, 0.022403215989470482, 0.0054255216382443905, 0.029890818521380424, 0.04001610726118088, -0.009148159064352512, -0.044308584183454514, 0.023462500423192978, -0.07032112777233124, 0.03105931542813778, -0.02501760795712471, -0.039337560534477234, 0.023394186049699783, 0.03939394652843475, 0.019985264167189598, -0.017954334616661072, -0.011038901284337044, 0.034832775592803955, -0.039831146597862244, -0.007057697977870703, 0.03026014007627964, -0.010995137505233288, 0.10501465946435928, 0.08613240718841553, 0.032562125474214554, -0.033885657787323, -0.003581005148589611, 0.002007752191275358, 0.06076173856854439, 0.00020002134260721505, -0.04329460859298706, 0.020780546590685844, 0.005959475412964821, -0.03224436938762665, -0.01585141010582447, -0.011171383783221245, -0.003077745670452714, 0.011342117562890053, -0.08427158743143082, -0.00023332830460276455, -0.0374126136302948, 0.008778231218457222, 0.07025739550590515, -0.012615486979484558, -0.029011135920882225, -0.020018339157104492, -0.03755047544836998, -0.06640725582838058, 0.011080256663262844, -0.03791704401373863, 0.03515121713280678, 0.015720831230282784, 0.10607930272817612, -0.021447554230690002, 0.01930900290608406, 0.03211551159620285, -0.01222455594688654, -0.023011308163404465, -0.011197147890925407, 0.014813989400863647, -0.035175126045942307, 0.00039235258009284735, 0.036261215806007385, -0.019479256123304367, 0.0003190446295775473, -0.004537966102361679, -0.009219595231115818, -0.016780801117420197, 0.022198406979441643, 0.0168331079185009, 0.040461841970682144, 0.04426490515470505, -0.05713528022170067, 0.013951366767287254, -0.00028949553961865604, -0.01266635674983263, -0.01911516860127449, -0.047038234770298004, -0.017104456201195717, -0.04922544211149216, 0.019617227837443352, -0.01161833107471466, -0.005757278297096491, 0.06839899718761444, 0.032286446541547775, -0.01001922506839037, -0.029737431555986404, -0.014179522171616554, -0.037718769162893295, 0.0318991057574749, -0.05778804421424866, -0.019827518612146378, 0.0016983404057100415, -0.04089514538645744, -0.014577609486877918, -0.08147092163562775, 0.06611161679029465, 0.010105173103511333, -0.023520706221461296, -0.06629205495119095, -0.043703995645046234, 0.0001862311182776466, -0.024547284469008446, 0.05815873667597771, -0.05093301087617874, 0.01757197640836239, -0.027821609750390053, -0.010532060638070107, -0.029764121398329735, -0.01695554330945015, 0.0009447119664400816, -0.0012504869373515248, 0.021830590441823006, 0.016410956159234047, 0.030670540407299995, 0.004910656251013279, 0.009418425150215626, -0.013990634121000767, -0.004905970301479101, -0.039134614169597626, -0.01776525191962719, -0.0036747853737324476, 0.05785917863249779, 0.014585301280021667, 0.08141901344060898, -0.007982036098837852, 0.005101916845887899, -0.0022105220705270767, 0.007168577052652836, -0.06400910019874573, -0.02490077167749405, -0.02208729460835457, -0.08708713203668594, 0.005519689526408911, 0.025873670354485512, -0.014096075668931007, 0.023435078561306, -0.01913551799952984, 0.0243336521089077, 0.0053013525903224945, -0.01917993277311325, -0.004488697741180658, 0.03355081379413605, 0.01815938390791416, 0.05616139993071556, -0.02269388921558857, 0.07735301554203033, -0.06762494146823883, 0.011941240169107914, -0.019142337143421173, 0.030992038547992706, 0.004322322551161051, 0.09488274902105331, 0.0020493336487561464, 0.019681375473737717, 0.055016010999679565, 0.0018505922053009272, 0.05296146124601364, -0.002631343202665448, -0.06144563853740692, 0.025860724970698357, -0.019128043204545975, 0.017943711951375008, 0.008559227921068668, -0.036439381539821625, -0.017481233924627304, -0.01399058848619461, 0.03969781845808029, -0.005557824391871691, 0.05455439165234566, 0.021014727652072906, -0.01207293476909399, -0.005007911007851362, 0.026084337383508682, -0.014105874113738537, -0.07317733019590378, -0.003973829094320536, 0.002950256457552314, -0.02841907925903797, -0.016120795160531998, -0.04688731208443642, 0.06485407054424286, -0.10311490297317505, 0.044770173728466034, 0.027669401839375496, 0.059380289167165756, -0.008257893845438957, -0.028919924050569534, 0.018129568547010422, -0.0013145521515980363, 0.013274414464831352, -0.03157583624124527, -0.05662775784730911, 0.045865945518016815, 0.04966580122709274, 0.00005243729901849292, 0.011708545498549938, -0.011185135692358017, -0.014701652340590954, 0.01967671886086464, -0.010506012476980686, -0.09973547607660294, 0.005695490166544914, 0.03701696917414665, -0.029337765648961067, 0.05140632390975952, -0.002748752012848854, -0.033644434064626694, 0.04417894035577774, 0.007442230824381113, 0.047272372990846634, 0.012741643004119396, -0.013394312001764774, -0.04972396045923233, -0.04640182852745056, -0.0064078439027071, 0.04178493097424507, 0.019250662997364998, -0.06495695561170578, -0.05303262174129486, -0.06197294965386391, -0.04996182397007942, 0.0370984748005867, -0.06586892902851105, -0.01423678733408451, 0.0030609576497226954, -0.007833663374185562, -0.02674003690481186, -0.02233634889125824, -0.05858087167143822, 0.0037766452878713608, -0.015184981748461723, 0.006797971669584513, 0.026805330067873, -0.017884157598018646, 0.030520064756274223, -0.09466823190450668, -0.07179927080869675, -0.025134872645139694, -0.02456088922917843, -0.014139236882328987, -0.02374904416501522, -0.04145844653248787, -0.009283877909183502, 0.063702292740345, 0.013350981287658215, 0.059855081140995026, -0.07165324687957764, 0.12575140595436096, -0.0787925124168396, -0.004263640381395817, -0.036188870668411255, 0.009671423584222794, 0.0008349282434210181, -0.001087657641619444, -0.012678686529397964, 0.01671154610812664, -0.05068941041827202, 0.05564325675368309, 0.019939491525292397, -0.029246892780065536, -0.031389735639095306, 0.029383696615695953, -0.0011595373507589102, 0.06667159497737885, 0.016994914039969444, 0.06878837198019028, 0.026263898238539696, 0.06676624715328217, 0.016036570072174072, 0.004594916012138128, -0.022361788898706436, -0.03396081551909447, -0.09014452993869781, 0.06745199859142303, -0.05909666791558266, -0.010712516494095325, -0.07900609821081161, 0.06662201881408691 ]
<p>I am computing SVD on a matrix which is the empirical version of $E[XY^{\top}]$ for some $X \in \mathbb{R}^{m \times 1}$ and $Y \in \mathbb{R}^{n \times 1}$.</p> <p>I am wondering if there are standard ways to preprocess $x_1,\ldots,x_l$ and $y_1,\ldots,y_l$ before doing that (other than subtracting the mean and dividing by standard deviation).</p> <p>This is related to the question here: <a href="http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/12200/normalizing-variables-for-svd-pca">&quot;Normalizing&quot; variables for SVD / PCA</a>.</p>
g162
[ 0.02321610413491726, 0.008669829927384853, -0.009535012766718864, -0.04893619194626808, -0.015479916706681252, -0.03095669485628605, 0.012664233334362507, 0.004621776752173901, 0.0010191895999014378, -0.0037688722368329763, 0.011874815449118614, 0.004107579588890076, 0.059122234582901, 0.011436795815825462, -0.05788592994213104, -0.00007966014527482912, 0.006767195649445057, -0.046988751739263535, 0.053902965039014816, -0.010306174866855145, -0.04370942339301109, -0.03001735359430313, 0.04446859657764435, -0.017167162150144577, 0.026407988741993904, -0.027396196499466896, -0.057315368205308914, 0.06277699768543243, -0.05519382283091545, 0.011588453315198421, 0.022937150672078133, 0.011934975162148476, 0.048457417637109756, -0.043617334216833115, -0.029488440603017807, 0.013431975618004799, 0.05191243439912796, 0.03836439177393913, 0.02723773755133152, -0.018900476396083832, -0.0036275149323046207, -0.02950066700577736, 0.04827514663338661, -0.02424042485654354, -0.015986815094947815, 0.014513851143419743, -0.010618842206895351, -0.03717983886599541, 0.00012554318527691066, -0.008757846429944038, 0.10501512140035629, 0.06881777942180634, -0.00424618786200881, -0.03423217311501503, 0.00317127862945199, 0.022002922371029854, -0.0009167618700303137, -0.00024700534413568676, 0.02897905372083187, 0.04383964464068413, -0.0014684349298477173, -0.08410727232694626, -0.007142357993870974, -0.0028416337445378304, 0.01156941894441843, 0.015670455992221832, 0.00955201219767332, -0.011938143521547318, -0.03311637043952942, 0.010941474698483944, 0.0064301094971597195, 0.03309948742389679, 0.039627090096473694, 0.007019595708698034, -0.11067380756139755, -0.019856426864862442, 0.05512244254350662, 0.019615041092038155, -0.01050267368555069, 0.05160226672887802, 0.0022898081224411726, 0.021239548921585083, 0.044524915516376495, 0.002768957521766424, -0.028616761788725853, 0.031785763800144196, 0.04977815970778465, 0.014715561643242836, 0.028531687334179878, 0.011616542004048824, 0.01870076172053814, -0.03410740941762924, 0.01544169895350933, 0.11087505519390106, -0.04159209504723549, 0.004924715030938387, -0.07721161097288132, 0.021365396678447723, 0.028306039050221443, -0.017123248428106308, 0.009655885398387909, 0.046116363257169724, 0.023028548806905746, -0.02337975986301899, -0.05398594215512276, -0.021965932101011276, 0.03889266401529312, -0.03628852590918541, 0.010117842815816402, -0.011059247888624668, -0.10497497022151947, 0.007675505708903074, -0.034001078456640244, -0.004947537090629339, -0.031706422567367554, -0.017653735354542732, 0.08666183054447174, -0.046869441866874695, -0.027280986309051514, -0.000645024876575917, -0.0033966382034122944, 0.007553526200354099, -0.006874470971524715, 0.08105256408452988, -0.026891717687249184, 0.05699390918016434, 0.0007790856761857867, 0.020270464941859245, 0.023230262100696564, 0.011988923884928226, 0.015839338302612305, 0.013897578231990337, -0.013944111764431, 0.011881010606884956, -0.014585197903215885, 0.06757479906082153, -0.027699356898665428, 0.047112151980400085, -0.03835951164364815, -0.012205089442431927, -0.016721563413739204, -0.003939239773899317, -0.01039411686360836, -0.037181269377470016, -0.024966618046164513, -0.03316398337483406, -0.01008221972733736, -0.024341115728020668, 0.013710140250623226, 0.01031216699630022, 0.0025765064638108015, 0.035335879772901535, -0.015938755124807358, 0.02076885662972927, -0.06437365710735321, 0.033966537564992905, 0.007415913976728916, 0.02459869720041752, 0.03638841584324837, -0.017937762662768364, 0.012159282341599464, -0.03312292695045471, -0.02850314788520336, -0.019492588937282562, 0.03281167522072792, 0.010913955047726631, 0.0059246644377708435, -0.0056300088763237, -0.01840987429022789, 0.007383880205452442, -0.01560024730861187, -0.030216503888368607, 0.04335648566484451, -0.03293332830071449, -0.00655323313549161, 0.0353274866938591, -0.05150090530514717, -0.02463315799832344, -0.030792756006121635, 0.036243923008441925, -0.0031897048465907574, 0.04658828303217888, -0.009694434702396393, -0.04526909068226814, 0.048795416951179504, -0.05431725084781647, -0.03419620543718338, 0.0071645877324044704, -0.03579626977443695, 0.024434620514512062, -0.01098177582025528, 0.04802446812391281, 0.012217297218739986, 0.009041293524205685, -0.03855300322175026, -0.044596776366233826, 0.020314589142799377, 0.014864571392536163, -0.05311281234025955, -0.014664472080767155, 0.018267257139086723, 0.01756458729505539, -0.06296094506978989, 0.024264756590127945, -0.025960251688957214, 0.06129021570086479, 0.01015071477741003, 0.005107027478516102, 0.018105965107679367, -0.011968518607318401, 0.0005633487598970532, 0.013150268234312534, -0.012459351681172848, 0.020857857540249825, -0.0015986646758392453, 0.005658168811351061, -0.02628280036151409, 0.0113865677267313, -0.0097499443218112, 0.020901121199131012, -0.058231547474861145, -0.02480020746588707, -0.01223716139793396, 0.03753440082073212, -0.011921542696654797, 0.044725771993398666, -0.000997561844997108, 0.013548831455409527, 0.006451892200857401, -0.009709212929010391, -0.053798332810401917, -0.040522392839193344, -0.01604713685810566, -0.07672806829214096, -0.0044900947250425816, 0.028964463621377945, -0.03760235384106636, -0.0007879019831307232, 0.009825040586292744, 0.06763770431280136, 0.09226242452859879, -0.007720242720097303, 0.04801056906580925, 0.06166403368115425, 0.06229626387357712, -0.05682499706745148, 0.0575685054063797, 0.013115990906953812, -0.007577613461762667, -0.046393685042858124, -0.06699085980653763, 0.05906781926751137, -0.030771847814321518, 0.020860034972429276, -0.010106796398758888, -0.020258072763681412, -0.03451928123831749, 0.026398690417408943, 0.031318239867687225, 0.0008121745195239782, -0.02847106009721756, 0.047948844730854034, -0.02419034205377102, -0.008212040178477764, -0.010573339648544788, 0.05221964418888092, -0.018511563539505005, -0.020719273015856743, 0.042581707239151, 0.009918508119881153, -0.013049289584159851, -0.01421209704130888, 0.09461583942174911, 0.07085739821195602, 0.06967184692621231, 0.022799599915742874, -0.0593927763402462, 0.0020775047596544027, -0.007429634220898151, 0.02000434137880802, -0.013021131046116352, -0.07508431375026703, 0.012450721114873886, 0.014307539910078049, 0.07297224551439285, 0.007797581143677235, 0.04832165688276291, -0.026420995593070984, -0.08079115301370621, -0.02683642879128456, -0.041693687438964844, 0.003930207341909409, -0.005730931181460619, -0.014591816812753677, 0.03590633347630501, 0.02270399034023285, 0.023930231109261513, -0.0201900415122509, 0.05812803655862808, 0.002476330380886793, -0.05889914184808731, -0.012505424208939075, 0.017118413001298904, 0.020964188501238823, 0.029208669438958168, -0.0232734065502882, 0.024102887138724327, 0.024143537506461143, -0.03868674859404564, -0.02646476961672306, 0.0018079911824315786, -0.010895436629652977, -0.009683857671916485, -0.011013421230018139, 0.002673341426998377, -0.033529382199048996, -0.006897533778101206, -0.04658333212137222, 0.06635142862796783, -0.008250958286225796, -0.04050827398896217, 0.032061174511909485, 0.04195817932486534, 0.01830953173339367, -0.020757313817739487, 0.04779992997646332, 0.016322044655680656, 0.05241231620311737, -0.008726267144083977, 0.05503785237669945, 0.03986503928899765, 0.07212187349796295, -0.04565821588039398, -0.006860936060547829, -0.0003300644748378545, -0.0015781268011778593, -0.07083556056022644, -0.025369422510266304, -0.025875018909573555, 0.002655354794114828, 0.006611047312617302, -0.007063054945319891, -0.022967375814914703, -0.019849957898259163, 0.018763931468129158, -0.054754238575696945, 0.010049010626971722, 0.0628974661231041, -0.010742081329226494, -0.0328751876950264, 0.03562042862176895, -0.03160911798477173, 0.012267645448446274, 0.015103602781891823, 0.02553708106279373, 0.06855563819408417, 0.08161009103059769, 0.004164164885878563, 0.0002870501484721899, -0.05000775307416916, 0.02256716415286064, -0.03283238038420677, 0.011332529596984386, 0.0455920435488224, -0.012379348278045654, 0.03257378563284874, 0.020318839699029922, 0.07740747928619385, 0.02675219252705574, -0.019307216629385948, 0.020424019545316696, 0.03802209720015526, 0.06170320883393288, -0.053132347762584686, -0.054213717579841614, -0.014826018363237381, 0.08402848988771439, 0.026464998722076416, 0.0077345967292785645, 0.02844391204416752, 0.027267813682556152, -0.004418293945491314, 0.012591090053319931, -0.027535121887922287, -0.00883572269231081, -0.009735511615872383, -0.026194652542471886, 0.044323038309812546, -0.00574685400351882, -0.004671639762818813, -0.02765105850994587, -0.03049044869840145, -0.02571198157966137, 0.03709745034575462, 0.01100401021540165, 0.0282411128282547, 0.036851853132247925, 0.0037225475534796715, -0.026139402762055397, -0.007955490611493587, -0.03591293841600418, 0.07113397121429443, 0.027395110577344894, -0.042941246181726456, -0.022381573915481567, -0.03471549227833748, -0.00439082644879818, 0.008975875563919544, 0.021907100453972816, 0.008465350605547428, -0.009326251223683357, -0.06082538142800331, 0.028606979176402092, -0.0069755567237734795, 0.019487110897898674, 0.016556458547711372, 0.003901249961927533, -0.025405200198292732, -0.036393433809280396, -0.034880537539720535, 0.007334970403462648, 0.02100195176899433, -0.036234691739082336, -0.002514549531042576, -0.02920343540608883, 0.01755327545106411, 0.007328880485147238, -0.03210180252790451, 0.006943651009351015, -0.007893659174442291, 0.062313418835401535, 0.02126125618815422, -0.0030973826069384813, -0.0052606877870857716, -0.03346089646220207, 0.002588255563750863, 0.02781056985259056, 0.031771983951330185, -0.0541217140853405, -0.09465456753969193, -0.03613731265068054, -0.05139438807964325, 0.000857032835483551, -0.02223247103393078, -0.016635742038488388, 0.005237915087491274, -0.027985939756035805, 0.010911813005805016, -0.0049026296474039555, -0.0032919486984610558, 0.00032748564262874424, 0.10018323361873627, -0.013943355530500412, -0.005131227429956198, 0.004727263934910297, -0.07979176193475723, 0.03803513944149017, 0.054992031306028366, 0.01665356010198593, 0.012428084388375282, -0.04938851296901703, -0.009768577292561531, -0.1032227873802185, -0.024633357301354408, -0.03285793215036392, -0.003752961987629533, -0.07320274412631989, -0.051030807197093964, 0.04337893798947334, -0.001194958109408617, 0.03178758546710014, -0.029162365943193436, -0.011126562021672726, -0.008487782441079617, 0.0005126338801346719, -0.0016817442374303937, -0.041143037378787994, -0.011218514293432236, 0.023878853768110275, 0.03435854986310005, -0.02124573290348053, 0.006116619799286127, -0.033705998212099075, -0.011871514841914177, 0.012251762673258781, -0.021171636879444122, 0.024203771725296974, -0.09925977140665054, 0.026423513889312744, 0.06041044741868973, -0.05692208185791969, 0.04802236333489418, 0.03765653818845749, 0.07350410521030426, -0.016425447538495064, -0.032827455550432205, 0.0014019185910001397, -0.08964458107948303, -0.028590509667992592, 0.016856376081705093, -0.01609034277498722, 0.03914980590343475, -0.022984173148870468, -0.004107547923922539, 0.08427507430315018, -0.014230276457965374, 0.03987124189734459, 0.0022526865359395742, -0.02719237469136715, 0.034978531301021576, 0.024839283898472786, 0.04763352498412132, 0.05679349973797798, 0.02905663289129734, -0.015343019738793373, 0.0027537206187844276, 0.031804922968149185, 0.028270689770579338, -0.014302462339401245, -0.10451245307922363, 0.050831139087677, -0.04498289152979851, -0.03688740357756615, 0.0033630183897912502, 0.0011033178307116032, -0.08688352257013321, -0.0127806281670928, -0.06043991446495056, 0.010820283554494381, -0.0575229711830616, -0.013852177187800407, -0.03874431923031807, -0.03703674301505089, 0.0072214058600366116, 0.00493605574592948, -0.05118037760257721, -0.05309117212891579, -0.005974243860691786, 0.013227873481810093, -0.03360801935195923, -0.03798286244273186, 0.01194990798830986, 0.05600440502166748, -0.01167664397507906, -0.05026374012231827, -0.05548432096838951, 0.04431590065360069, -0.03822898119688034, -0.008150815032422543, -0.009039506316184998, -0.03679439797997475, 0.0049714199267327785, -0.03019983135163784, 0.008697913028299809, -0.017078159376978874, 0.03310924768447876, 0.011571230366826057, -0.033491700887680054, 0.005670239683240652, 0.01223065610975027, -0.029646584764122963, -0.05449088662862778, 0.07254369556903839, -0.009534324519336224, -0.03267098218202591, -0.006968583911657333, 0.01604379527270794, -0.012196838855743408, 0.03297198563814163, 0.05685525760054588, -0.025396278128027916, -0.05768580362200737, 0.07205430418252945, 0.0035692723467946053, 0.03501254692673683, 0.012118217535316944, 0.003128528129309416, 0.012656409293413162, 0.035131946206092834, -0.013485188595950603, -0.003868731437250972, -0.04317057877779007, -0.05099107697606087, -0.02890891768038273, -0.020554615184664726, 0.03698382526636124, -0.017680639401078224, -0.02313486859202385, -0.058549199253320694, -0.021022720262408257, 0.004560080356895924, -0.013502714224159718, -0.045770831406116486, -0.024979062378406525, 0.0177981648594141, 0.021871784701943398, 0.020354624837636948, 0.041579216718673706, 0.02005043253302574, 0.0006002737209200859, -0.020324058830738068, 0.021483445540070534, 0.08507837355136871, 0.015237671323120594, -0.024886727333068848, 0.05538390204310417, -0.019216125831007957, 0.040337033569812775, 0.013639159500598907, -0.018072135746479034, -0.004151107277721167, -0.036571092903614044, 0.00449140602722764, 0.03651643916964531, -0.04555760324001312, -0.05360732972621918, -0.04070262238383293, 0.04861387610435486, 0.006943225394934416, 0.0031472048722207546, 0.014634800143539906, -0.015890125185251236, -0.013942737132310867, -0.0007229326292872429, -0.014594472013413906, 0.04310716316103935, 0.051684021949768066, -0.0742359310388565, 0.0627855733036995, -0.04986698180437088, 0.007786578498780727, 0.03436054289340973, 0.042054906487464905, 0.009426731616258621, -0.0054296888411045074, 0.07475876063108444, -0.037994060665369034, 0.07870180904865265, -0.0047271158546209335, 0.056647688150405884, 0.03549743816256523, 0.08786264806985855, 0.00003690632729558274, 0.009064165875315666, -0.016767458990216255, 0.03273976594209671, 0.023436933755874634, 0.06547851115465164, 0.02180730551481247, 0.028776604682207108, 0.07760001718997955, -0.011923651210963726, 0.008564161136746407, -0.059160131961107254, 0.007423936855047941, 0.04708094522356987, 0.053720541298389435, 0.02412761002779007, 0.0501483678817749, 0.01587291993200779, -0.049184005707502365, -0.049731701612472534, -0.011289786547422409, -0.0017410179134458303, 0.0325382761657238, 0.021923890337347984, -0.07184787094593048, 0.04256567358970642, -0.043461546301841736, -0.02551806904375553, -0.034842222929000854, -0.039099715650081635, 0.008368195034563541, -0.019372928887605667, 0.060391802340745926, -0.01529170386493206, 0.05480808764696121, 0.017976952716708183, -0.06751973181962967, 0.016979599371552467, -0.012337082996964455, -0.019781215116381645, -0.03615102544426918, -0.0270084198564291, -0.019716886803507805, 0.029544636607170105, -0.018680863082408905, -0.06380638480186462, -0.02293580211699009, -0.0018041640287265182, -0.07954129576683044, -0.0032203802838921547, -0.002518518129363656, 0.016216062009334564, 0.04846933111548424, -0.01951230876147747, -0.04427183046936989, 0.012224429287016392, -0.01650257222354412, 0.07311051338911057, -0.037518225610256195, 0.025530459359288216, -0.015240498818457127, 0.0173129104077816, -0.011934242211282253, 0.025735987350344658, -0.05485006421804428, -0.06840046495199203, -0.015450033359229565, -0.0551907978951931, -0.027933461591601372, -0.021818654611706734, -0.02782268077135086, -0.006154125090688467, 0.00638401135802269, 0.016810627654194832, 0.0029474389739334583, -0.056077685207128525, -0.003621448529884219, 0.016011668369174004, -0.04130818694829941, 0.035699471831321716, 0.029358506202697754, -0.00574273569509387, 0.03309622034430504, -0.04156197980046272, -0.029100632295012474, 0.04114411398768425, 0.015867410227656364, -0.011685337871313095, -0.005406391341239214, -0.0758490115404129, -0.021446960046887398, 0.05557849630713463, 0.02290169522166252, 0.008461854420602322, -0.036000173538923264, -0.012569076381623745, 0.013242293149232864, 0.05311660096049309, -0.06401751190423965, 0.006997406482696533, -0.014406321570277214, 0.015831852331757545, 0.03183257207274437, 0.029833298176527023, 0.050173819065093994, 0.030989108607172966, -0.052314724773168564, -0.050177160650491714, -0.030147647485136986, 0.037459567189216614, -0.04266617074608803, 0.05144438147544861, 0.0005643517943099141, 0.0015687538543716073, 0.003752017393708229, -0.037817709147930145, 0.04296842962503433, -0.0248089786618948, -0.0016664759023115039, -0.01423878874629736, -0.02011859230697155, 0.05004807561635971, -0.04481034353375435, -0.03679963946342468, 0.004121554084122181, 0.020478179678320885 ]
<p>I have two models. First, $$z=\alpha_1x+\alpha_2+\epsilon$$ and second, $$z=\beta_1x+\beta_2y+\beta_3+\epsilon.$$</p> <p>What factors affect whether $\alpha_1\approx\beta_1$? Note that I don't care how accurately either model predicts $z$. I only care about how similar the coefficient of the $x$ term is in both models.</p> <p>Assume both $x$ and $y$ actually predict $z$ and don't interact.</p>
g36691
[ -0.02831505611538887, -0.01443527638912201, 0.0178499985486269, 0.04088035225868225, 0.08856465667486191, -0.022866636514663696, 0.0589478500187397, 0.029836930334568024, -0.0016032326966524124, -0.03299456089735031, -0.03209323436021805, 0.03436615318059921, 0.005316081922501326, 0.029423123225569725, 0.03798589110374451, 0.055327337235212326, 0.10246298462152481, 0.020956287160515785, -0.026234440505504608, -0.02311684750020504, -0.018190527334809303, -0.008387339301407337, 0.012452727183699608, -0.033992309123277664, 0.02387797273695469, -0.015296519733965397, -0.03402245044708252, 0.03941050171852112, -0.03583545610308647, 0.022529970854520798, -0.0354960598051548, 0.06553526222705841, 0.04901700094342232, -0.029475929215550423, -0.03986658155918121, 0.012851868756115437, 0.05643755942583084, 0.016262635588645935, -0.017384598031640053, -0.024145327508449554, 0.01288655400276184, 0.06153988093137741, 0.03856126219034195, -0.00008694435382494703, -0.04346303269267082, -0.014296666719019413, -0.017155559733510017, 0.0005520544364117086, 0.01582477055490017, 0.037931859493255615, -0.0027346457354724407, -0.0157431960105896, 0.013177402317523956, 0.01039912085980177, 0.020710408687591553, 0.021727317944169044, 0.06875430792570114, -0.006263073068112135, 0.021694600582122803, 0.034188348799943924, 0.005175550933927298, 0.027571216225624084, -0.0038001530338078737, -0.02518591843545437, -0.015050570480525494, -0.035378485918045044, -0.03476858511567116, -0.002733855042606592, -0.010096482932567596, -0.003434461774304509, 0.011191371828317642, 0.058257415890693665, 0.0032364861108362675, -0.025863952934741974, -0.010030173696577549, 0.023766063153743744, 0.009983617812395096, -0.002227982971817255, -0.0127947349101305, 0.017508314922451973, 0.014815451577305794, 0.02639053575694561, 0.050757672637701035, 0.05279688909649849, -0.006393595598638058, 0.011498074047267437, -0.001269776839762926, -0.011744407005608082, -0.005257692653685808, -0.05437137559056282, -0.0347529798746109, -0.005435973405838013, -0.015316519886255264, 0.04107796773314476, 0.011845721863210201, -0.0020105671137571335, -0.011076556518673897, -0.009968210011720657, 0.014830639585852623, 0.018842283636331558, 0.0404699444770813, 0.07960500568151474, 0.02150723896920681, 0.02475872077047825, -0.04916634038090706, -0.0131700299680233, 0.027069229632616043, -0.04783323034644127, -0.009719915688037872, -0.017484230920672417, -0.0799514576792717, 0.020228488370776176, -0.022261157631874084, -0.05464397743344307, -0.013583706691861153, -0.0359128937125206, -0.021107062697410583, -0.009219993837177753, 0.02744048461318016, -0.03293657302856445, -0.013940486125648022, -0.0031700569670647383, 0.03633566200733185, 0.003106567310169339, -0.012365365400910378, 0.027900395914912224, -0.011764240451157093, 0.07912597805261612, 0.010624311864376068, -0.023565806448459625, 0.04018288850784302, 0.006937725469470024, 0.024915171787142754, 0.002780324313789606, -0.020055821165442467, 0.026221856474876404, -0.037226732820272446, -0.00037765494198538363, -0.014296641573309898, 0.030660584568977356, -0.019224904477596283, -0.010836394503712654, 0.02943234331905842, -0.020532581955194473, -0.05881023034453392, 0.02939409762620926, 0.0029577428940683603, -0.03044167347252369, -0.048260997980833054, -0.02190827950835228, -0.011818159371614456, 0.052361082285642624, -0.00029959576204419136, 0.04781731590628624, -0.05654788389801979, 0.009416899643838406, 0.00023772194981575012, 0.0010247158352285624, -0.01041398011147976, -0.018291031941771507, 0.030536284670233727, -0.04977813735604286, 0.046268198639154434, -0.014359090477228165, -0.04447827488183975, -0.023516865447163582, 0.004021814558655024, -0.07323107868432999, -0.057582177221775055, 0.04109741374850273, 0.010863486677408218, 0.008253481239080429, 0.020361756905913353, 0.03219139575958252, 0.03567798063158989, 0.03532996028661728, -0.03740793466567993, 0.010988588444888592, 0.07005538791418076, -0.03696732223033905, 0.008254597894847393, 0.0243312306702137, -0.010226713493466377, -0.017150525003671646, -0.02565864659845829, -0.04159336909651756, -0.01643260568380356, 0.05591091513633728, -0.08744228631258011, 0.03237805515527725, 0.0007781586609780788, -0.007056946400552988, 0.017375661060214043, -0.07779398560523987, -0.005414988379925489, -0.015529460273683071, 0.07378827035427094, -0.02704143337905407, -0.04063178598880768, 0.02992723137140274, -0.07004284113645554, 0.019195320084691048, 0.012361607514321804, -0.016008835285902023, -0.006491977721452713, 0.03535806015133858, -0.001703743590041995, 0.018723050132393837, 0.011252889409661293, -0.042736027389764786, -0.027913222089409828, -0.053813036531209946, -0.000885271409060806, 0.028460640460252762, 0.036158591508865356, -0.032902613282203674, 0.06289280205965042, 0.09231847524642944, -0.049768030643463135, -0.007333033252507448, -0.06097424775362015, -0.01976032182574272, 0.014278572984039783, 0.0014713299460709095, -0.01893409714102745, 0.006341989617794752, 0.038359466940164566, 0.055655039846897125, -0.017183102667331696, 0.06511101126670837, -0.04626738652586937, -0.041563428938388824, -0.021603809669613838, -0.009171027690172195, -0.0016826690407469869, -0.023836156353354454, 0.06260250508785248, 0.012278171256184578, 0.045120421797037125, -0.019015904515981674, 0.05920545384287834, 0.03134479746222496, -0.015055136755108833, 0.05199805274605751, -0.00002816663072735537, -0.025895263999700546, 0.0024208673276007175, -0.009322199039161205, -0.030913161113858223, 0.017081279307603836, -0.015138178132474422, 0.0964135155081749, -0.039679598063230515, 0.022619888186454773, -0.01569090038537979, -0.035497378557920456, 0.003867926774546504, 0.0381431058049202, -0.00814008992165327, 0.010529202409088612, -0.03573773056268692, 0.02795848622918129, 0.010485036298632622, -0.007299212738871574, -0.00829828530550003, -0.003773549571633339, 0.010722199454903603, -0.018000414595007896, -0.011120790615677834, -0.007818358950316906, 0.008115533739328384, 0.005248741712421179, 0.004929121118038893, 0.041425954550504684, 0.005098721012473106, -0.003743342589586973, -0.020259521901607513, -0.057048581540584564, -0.030773553997278214, -0.06398504972457886, -0.0019654836505651474, -0.015315479598939419, -0.016318829730153084, 0.027935195714235306, 0.04245845600962639, 0.05270615965127945, 0.05493277311325073, 0.048125866800546646, -0.0022675241343677044, 0.033069908618927, -0.03702466934919357, 0.09091354161500931, 0.020600060001015663, 0.0032337286975234747, 0.02207394875586033, -0.02666865848004818, 0.02263735979795456, -0.04749123007059097, 0.003841881873086095, 0.05119438096880913, 0.02654801495373249, -0.006938266102224588, -0.010418974794447422, 0.011503259651362896, 0.060354623943567276, -0.04942527785897255, -0.05506446212530136, 0.0473887138068676, -0.0005099765257909894, -0.008389990776777267, -0.05716847628355026, 0.003603053977712989, -0.002443747129291296, -0.0319637730717659, -0.035529669374227524, -0.005852856673300266, 0.010474598966538906, 0.0005823227111250162, 0.012851348146796227, 0.003570195287466049, 0.031912967562675476, -0.06172534078359604, 0.0158891212195158, 0.018291637301445007, -0.02514747530221939, -0.009020185098052025, -0.05802889168262482, -0.005953730549663305, -0.020839069038629532, 0.011429193429648876, 0.015067807398736477, 0.032240916043519974, 0.005578330252319574, -0.03752360865473747, -0.03151613473892212, -0.02625153958797455, 0.013381946831941605, 0.03933687135577202, -0.05692138522863388, 0.01181330531835556, -0.03438369557261467, -0.0059227109886705875, 0.07015315443277359, -0.017326992005109787, -0.007288134191185236, -0.04561738669872284, -0.01094362884759903, 0.00030216603772714734, 0.05864449962973595, -0.004879643674939871, 0.01180362980812788, 0.009493543766438961, 0.001011724234558642, 0.013741368427872658, 0.05372121185064316, -0.00849626213312149, 0.04977361112833023, -0.013564353808760643, -0.05727263540029526, 0.004025318194180727, 0.031968895345926285, -0.038524217903614044, -0.04627218842506409, -0.003204988781362772, -0.023838870227336884, 0.046935878694057465, -0.0038283539470285177, 0.04369497671723366, 0.002604158828034997, -0.010319425724446774, 0.0452413409948349, 0.09331588447093964, 0.05537848919630051, 0.050799813121557236, 0.0759393647313118, -0.015437380410730839, 0.05028630048036575, 0.018356531858444214, -0.04752393811941147, 0.008788537234067917, 0.044575285166502, 0.0261565912514925, -0.03762182965874672, 0.009711972437798977, 0.04233407974243164, -0.041503772139549255, 0.03201506659388542, -0.024354642257094383, -0.001103868125937879, -0.04707559570670128, -0.020560720935463905, 0.017610525712370872, 0.00839371420443058, 0.021444495767354965, 0.019616859033703804, -0.06104350462555885, 0.008598501794040203, 0.016625085845589638, 0.019058063626289368, -0.022806359454989433, -0.03237200528383255, 0.015750525519251823, -0.003759655635803938, -0.013079000636935234, 0.026691928505897522, -0.012971274554729462, -0.03489284589886665, 0.0012636929750442505, -0.00568676833063364, -0.07002008706331253, 0.0036605624482035637, 0.06777235120534897, -0.01921408250927925, -0.008511409163475037, 0.025355558842420578, 0.008047333918511868, -0.019853387027978897, -0.032357778400182724, 0.02423456683754921, 0.0014428652357310057, 0.0033720058854669333, 0.034766532480716705, -0.055098652839660645, -0.02918766252696514, 0.044946737587451935, -0.020968729630112648, 0.025039834901690483, 0.004122693091630936, -0.0376347117125988, -0.06138193979859352, 0.029936188831925392, 0.06398745626211166, -0.06661529093980789, 0.008220916613936424, -0.05548134073615074, 0.051595333963632584, -0.009059815667569637, 0.014056387357413769, 0.004822329618036747, -0.024462992325425148, 0.024118294939398766, 0.00224098633043468, -0.015581241808831692, 0.014641948975622654, 0.008012483827769756, 0.04320046678185463, -0.06892982870340347, -0.06589740514755249, -0.00655636889860034, 0.007012327201664448, -0.061820704489946365, 0.019345244392752647, 0.03685290366411209, -0.044355686753988266, 0.06494782865047455, 0.03603864833712578, 0.055120207369327545, 0.05034998804330826, 0.025857120752334595, 0.026013832539319992, -0.05045608803629875, -0.021741265431046486, 0.03292236849665642, 0.017063360661268234, 0.00027115957345813513, -0.03470316156744957, -0.002205260330811143, -0.01003305520862341, -0.026013996452093124, 0.03937521204352379, -0.012776779942214489, -0.02536606229841709, 0.05633470416069031, 0.040423691272735596, 0.0007866737432777882, -0.05833188444375992, -0.03766113147139549, -0.05223928019404411, -0.006586481351405382, -0.023052651435136795, -0.03317597508430481, -0.04505160450935364, 0.003956487402319908, -0.023830344900488853, -0.025125805288553238, 0.000022971977159613743, 0.010997788980603218, 0.0023871648591011763, 0.0490838922560215, -0.027633782476186752, 0.027871817350387573, 0.06878171116113663, 0.015428123995661736, -0.03367261216044426, -0.10204877704381943, -0.0006901096785441041, 0.014300664886832237, -0.016708115115761757, 0.029736340045928955, 0.032085783779621124, -0.051425013691186905, 0.03502882272005081, 0.04100019112229347, -0.036160048097372055, -0.04847269877791405, 0.059811778366565704, 0.036347728222608566, -0.040064066648483276, -0.0021798128727823496, 0.03132634237408638, -0.06890822947025299, -0.029125770553946495, 0.06635238975286484, 0.020117655396461487, -0.06490156799554825, 0.017227303236722946, -0.030321918427944183, 0.053377557545900345, -0.045045603066682816, -0.06322868168354034, 0.10361302644014359, -0.054489318281412125, -0.025729743763804436, 0.012288265861570835, 0.017722809687256813, -0.04448134824633598, -0.01883045770227909, -0.031151842325925827, 0.0074037895537912846, -0.012612853199243546, 0.011657439172267914, 0.018422089517116547, -0.04890672490000725, 0.00282675470225513, 0.09006448835134506, -0.022063862532377243, 0.016641022637486458, -0.04027389734983444, -0.0021736405324190855, 0.015749145299196243, 0.022104106843471527, 0.033018000423908234, 0.060839634388685226, 0.031412772834300995, -0.051384489983320236, 0.014141968451440334, 0.003960022237151861, 0.011903355829417706, 0.010354169644415379, -0.024670613929629326, 0.01039860025048256, -0.04257306829094887, -0.0064145405776798725, 0.06030035763978958, 0.007564544677734375, 0.021282313391566277, 0.06572907418012619, 0.03448420390486717, -0.023043641820549965, 0.021444858983159065, -0.027404146268963814, -0.0010688274633139372, -0.0018785519059747458, -0.012688837945461273, 0.003948146943002939, -0.08699895441532135, 0.027430186048150063, -0.009075826965272427, 0.035491496324539185, 0.008760422468185425, 0.00990007258951664, -0.03388792276382446, 0.0411771759390831, 0.0052992673590779305, -0.017710715532302856, 0.06719882786273956, -0.06084132194519043, 0.0025128028355538845, -0.017637012526392937, 0.010459624230861664, 0.02111583761870861, -0.03338328376412392, -0.019854264333844185, 0.007871829904615879, 0.04427768662571907, 0.08945376425981522, -0.011062624864280224, -0.048524610698223114, 0.03713952749967575, -0.025810113176703453, -0.00834471732378006, -0.04228680208325386, 0.03362477943301201, -0.0530867762863636, -0.03444847837090492, -0.017892688512802124, 0.010060896165668964, 0.013547239825129509, 0.0039278073236346245, -0.04654747620224953, 0.015334566123783588, -0.052070457488298416, 0.05253344029188156, -0.03282947838306427, -0.00462564779445529, 0.019741935655474663, 0.0070724887773394585, 0.04505310207605362, 0.043863099068403244, 0.031119702383875847, -0.06765829771757126, 0.02598085068166256, 0.031135838478803635, 0.032531142234802246, 0.02476821467280388, -0.05637011677026749, -0.026803964748978615, 0.05047912523150444, -0.07600551098585129, 0.010905981995165348, 0.05551237240433693, -0.026762347668409348, -0.049996789544820786, -0.026142684742808342, 0.023521019145846367, 0.021463872864842415, -0.020686380565166473, -0.01511042658239603, 0.010848605073988438, -0.02062143385410309, 0.03433789685368538, -0.025302765890955925, -0.027675380930304527, 0.07114967703819275, -0.020859887823462486, 0.03715888410806656, -0.05783773213624954, -0.0183112733066082, -0.029207956045866013, 0.030541125684976578, 0.057806964963674545, 0.07899780571460724, -0.011552234180271626, 0.08428742736577988, -0.026947172358632088, -0.048732832074165344, 0.009119083173573017, 0.012780277989804745, -0.09454373270273209, 0.030886027961969376, 0.055883072316646576, 0.011096342466771603, -0.012338411994278431, -0.04776766523718834, 0.019306842237710953, -0.012962732464075089, 0.004872634541243315, -0.0022803177125751972, 0.01722359098494053, 0.020883794873952866, -0.031749363988637924, -0.08116695284843445, 0.006820893846452236, 0.022138524800539017, -0.0086043206974864, 0.04306966811418533, -0.04370781406760216, -0.048033107072114944, -0.015420527197420597, -0.021494237706065178, -0.03280697017908096, -0.07773565500974655, -0.014033417217433453, 0.009214245714247227, -0.02499387599527836, 0.003126398427411914, -0.02179921418428421, -0.07252783328294754, 0.015263320878148079, -0.002633391646668315, 0.025826789438724518, -0.03194596618413925, -0.015127558261156082, -0.010386491194367409, -0.035304877907037735, 0.04834267497062683, 0.03785157576203346, -0.015702398493885994, -0.027041763067245483, 0.00835112202912569, -0.06816285848617554, -0.05298801511526108, 0.011498226784169674, -0.034394800662994385, -0.044415183365345, 0.01600888930261135, -0.03688760846853256, 0.10210392624139786, -0.0779484361410141, 0.061142537742853165, 0.02605176717042923, 0.013790499418973923, 0.002193526132032275, -0.05762374401092529, 0.04036976397037506, 0.012025917880237103, -0.0036421562545001507, 0.01174956001341343, 0.006749621592462063, -0.06706778705120087, 0.011534487828612328, 0.02636321634054184, 0.06885332614183426, -0.0027999316807836294, 0.03818795830011368, -0.009154945611953735, -0.034827589988708496, -0.08317539840936661, 0.00477742962539196, 0.037325870245695114, -0.02653566747903824, 0.005602234974503517, -0.001166607136838138, -0.06108875572681427, -0.004401026759296656, -0.08879856020212173, -0.038182009011507034, -0.041599154472351074, 0.021398145705461502, 0.04151782765984535, -0.04507414251565933, -0.03589958697557449, -0.071628637611866, 0.014567171223461628, -0.0795392245054245, 0.02954789809882641, 0.02486589178442955, 0.043287843465805054, -0.03234735131263733, -0.006492822431027889, -0.058009617030620575, -0.03463606536388397, 0.03676553815603256, 0.012899937108159065, 0.014867568388581276, 0.05650809407234192, 0.0034650221932679415, -0.008424554020166397, 0.009871582500636578, 0.029880763962864876, -0.025660978630185127, 0.0010139178484678268, -0.030416171997785568, 0.02893579751253128, 0.036396246403455734, -0.008439808152616024, -0.06749936193227768, -0.04281990975141525, -0.030923346057534218, -0.03598818555474281, -0.023273037746548653, -0.023776067420840263, -0.018771346658468246, 0.1057293638586998, -0.03589529171586037, 0.018409138545393944, -0.010674793273210526, 0.033254723995923996 ]
<p>We have two time series: $X_t$ and $R_t$, and a model saying that $R_{t+1} = (\mu(X_t) - \frac{1}{2}\sigma^2(X_t))\Delta T + \sigma(X_t) \sqrt{\Delta T} \epsilon_t$, where $\Delta T$ is given constant and $\epsilon_t$-s are independent normally distributed with zero mean and unit variance. Further we assume that the functions $\mu(x)$ and $\sigma(x)$ are linear for simplicity. I would like to use some standard method (MLE comes to my mind) to estimate parameters of functions $\mu(x)$ and $\sigma(x)$, but I am not sure how to do this. </p> <p>I would be grateful for detailed answers, because I am not really experienced with statistics.</p>
g74051
[ -0.029689937829971313, -0.034771163016557693, 0.004670409951359034, 0.0053306445479393005, 0.008658763952553272, 0.0007457322208210826, 0.003146527800709009, 0.009395328350365162, -0.05311278626322746, 0.03932809829711914, -0.04035709425806999, 0.038953546434640884, 0.04567575454711914, 0.009262903593480587, -0.009884930215775967, -0.00704016862437129, 0.031135352328419685, 0.010030855424702168, -0.014147614128887653, 0.008547130972146988, -0.003292865352705121, -0.019743673503398895, 0.05293823778629303, -0.01787322200834751, 0.08085691928863525, 0.007825711742043495, -0.042320605367422104, 0.10181456804275513, -0.020663689821958542, -0.001720165484584868, -0.016955984756350517, -0.008752149529755116, 0.0897841677069664, 0.006017387844622135, 0.02433033473789692, 0.029113026335835457, 0.05588268116116524, -0.04892691969871521, 0.04491649195551872, -0.040991634130477905, 0.00012362633424345404, -0.0317886583507061, 0.00937996432185173, 0.02758868783712387, -0.0000296042508125538, 0.0069996630772948265, -0.034750401973724365, 0.026903312653303146, 0.015864213928580284, 0.025958934798836708, 0.05860013887286186, 0.04116911441087723, 0.05373240262269974, 0.011075921356678009, -0.04324271157383919, -0.01620093733072281, 0.02291097491979599, -0.017491115257143974, 0.06396113336086273, 0.024266915395855904, -0.014478984288871288, -0.059770721942186356, -0.0408906489610672, -0.029426150023937225, 0.038415346294641495, 0.061799079179763794, 0.029277976602315903, -0.0094212107360363, 0.008524038828909397, -0.009526451118290424, -0.017223620787262917, -0.00655202753841877, 0.06662855297327042, -0.052771616727113724, -0.026342380791902542, -0.035742998123168945, 0.016842562705278397, -0.011072547174990177, -0.008043293841183186, -0.001643708790652454, -0.013611779548227787, 0.04161897674202919, 0.008621477521955967, 0.0074141863733530045, 0.030405331403017044, -0.016530582681298256, 0.03547197952866554, -0.0039045552257448435, 0.018497200682759285, 0.015867022797465324, 0.010101605206727982, -0.029388416558504105, -0.003945855889469385, 0.025968097150325775, 0.03344397246837616, -0.031748756766319275, -0.08471056818962097, -0.0023312910925596952, 0.019650990143418312, -0.0028741182759404182, 0.03098565712571144, 0.07202388346195221, 0.016371509060263634, -0.029547203332185745, -0.015138746239244938, 0.029903898015618324, -0.0018462807638570666, -0.002444284735247493, 0.006978827528655529, -0.023211367428302765, -0.051909543573856354, 0.015853695571422577, -0.058837924152612686, -0.018789110705256462, -0.0029230834916234016, -0.05372927337884903, 0.033459682017564774, -0.01210961677134037, -0.042314451187849045, -0.029804682359099388, -0.03315442055463791, 0.01851627044379711, 0.03406088799238205, 0.06797779351472855, -0.044710781425237656, 0.03868656978011131, 0.006402567494660616, 0.06755692511796951, 0.01095175463706255, 0.011562681756913662, -0.004224677570164204, -0.033565811812877655, 0.017758123576641083, -0.0016898114699870348, 0.005193947348743677, 0.027531426399946213, -0.06854766607284546, 0.04033505916595459, -0.012825982645154, 0.02876249887049198, -0.01281760074198246, 0.0008328643161803484, 0.016529280692338943, -0.028985897079110146, -0.045750103890895844, 0.038225021213293076, 0.01755499839782715, -0.056977253407239914, -0.04908909276127815, 0.037104763090610504, 0.03132699802517891, 0.08525571972131729, -0.042596183717250824, 0.041942697018384933, 0.0010645989095792174, -0.023254094645380974, -0.019770395010709763, -0.0434529185295105, -0.05535412207245827, -0.03308062255382538, 0.01839260570704937, -0.06374382972717285, 0.07848034054040909, -0.028834374621510506, -0.03558623045682907, 0.009028186090290546, 0.00328517472371459, -0.062000829726457596, 0.021567294374108315, -0.03437094762921333, 0.05250255763530731, -0.010040336288511753, 0.0003106558579020202, -0.018063897266983986, 0.017233194783329964, 0.017280705273151398, 0.004148960113525391, -0.016282513737678528, 0.03367328271269798, 0.028702760115265846, 0.07651971280574799, 0.0209151953458786, 0.02556602843105793, -0.06112050637602806, -0.03401585668325424, -0.033104777336120605, 0.06328178197145462, 0.018343649804592133, -0.031340960413217545, 0.0159950852394104, -0.028598573058843613, -0.00580391101539135, 0.012531292624771595, -0.02029716782271862, -0.016963327303528786, 0.05049500614404678, 0.02718675509095192, -0.07378321141004562, 0.03010229580104351, 0.03909244388341904, -0.007680598180741072, -0.0003374289663042873, 0.012559634633362293, -0.02219483070075512, 0.012966269627213478, -0.041458610445261, -0.0030141333118081093, -0.052442170679569244, -0.02404618076980114, 0.017715485766530037, -0.0385008379817009, -0.01378657203167677, -0.022192083299160004, 0.018056336790323257, 0.0168143417686224, -0.033688999712467194, 0.02333151176571846, 0.022333849221467972, 0.01970096305012703, -0.013697780668735504, -0.03315870091319084, -0.025419846177101135, 0.014945024624466896, 0.021149620413780212, 0.047491006553173065, -0.019111383706331253, 0.05281750112771988, 0.04370395466685295, -0.020749574527144432, 0.04595137760043144, -0.045837536454200745, -0.028135620057582855, 0.029988406226038933, 0.03788704425096512, 0.005281370598822832, 0.03377024456858635, -0.0105984415858984, 0.022622978314757347, 0.059647612273693085, 0.045248616486787796, -0.008667849004268646, 0.006886720657348633, -0.0024479397106915712, 0.031599778681993484, -0.020985201001167297, 0.005383246578276157, 0.0014069119933992624, 0.04344414174556732, 0.05750923231244087, 0.016282392665743828, 0.0011951220221817493, 0.07170412689447403, 0.006388921290636063, -0.011648617684841156, -0.03430407866835594, -0.07016272097826004, 0.01646999828517437, -0.010369585826992989, -0.03234719857573509, 0.015950605273246765, -0.030327394604682922, 0.02436440996825695, -0.015298995189368725, 0.02843049354851246, 0.007573762442916632, -0.01338866539299488, -0.006202662363648415, 0.0074491845443844795, 0.013293292373418808, -0.0024382316041737795, 0.028259893879294395, 0.025919418781995773, 0.05628494173288345, 0.07506345212459564, 0.044543132185935974, -0.017562268301844597, 0.020829999819397926, 0.0009251858573406935, 0.02241070196032524, -0.009927060455083847, 0.007166047114878893, -0.069416843354702, -0.008895065635442734, 0.0018009735504165292, 0.010902713052928448, -0.04932394623756409, 0.048612337559461594, 0.01767554320394993, 0.02074328251183033, 0.013785099610686302, 0.000044092972530052066, 0.03557417169213295, 0.025674043223261833, 0.03055412881076336, -0.07136022299528122, 0.015618175268173218, 0.01750592328608036, -0.08744436502456665, 0.04650072380900383, 0.007999707013368607, 0.004768282175064087, -0.022091278806328773, -0.008022074587643147, 0.025522124022245407, 0.007806730456650257, -0.05296500399708748, -0.015858853235840797, 0.0143367238342762, 0.045997075736522675, 0.011722293682396412, 0.055821292102336884, -0.000777746201492846, 0.04522372782230377, 0.008431599475443363, -0.03640126809477806, 0.015586206689476967, 0.0028500808402895927, 0.003932701423764229, -0.023236097767949104, 0.02756694331765175, 0.02221686951816082, -0.06578127294778824, -0.0016794940456748009, 0.02469152957201004, 0.0005423512193374336, 0.00786266103386879, -0.03424260392785072, 0.020860321819782257, -0.08417049050331116, -0.0014400522923097014, 0.039384085685014725, -0.019083276391029358, 0.060390181839466095, -0.04489335045218468, -0.010529669001698494, 0.004053096752613783, -0.010059695690870285, 0.027414100244641304, 0.007019798271358013, 0.008317341096699238, -0.06765713542699814, 0.025005729869008064, -0.04492312669754028, 0.012645328417420387, -0.02756986953318119, -0.07364382594823837, 0.011239237152040005, 0.04192202165722847, 0.027185644954442978, -0.01597532071173191, 0.0029218527488410473, 0.017902426421642303, 0.01988639496266842, -0.013474983163177967, 0.018159154802560806, 0.041402578353881836, 0.017125645652413368, 0.0000885125482454896, -0.005770524498075247, -0.052715200930833817, 0.07005228102207184, -0.09237554669380188, -0.026480529457330704, 0.051615048199892044, 0.012345842085778713, -0.037086259573698044, 0.03280802071094513, 0.08492852002382278, 0.012888169847428799, -0.004655645228922367, -0.01905340515077114, 0.10493647307157516, 0.08006816357374191, -0.0078019024804234505, 0.014287350699305534, -0.03341532126069069, 0.035713572055101395, 0.0055074128322303295, -0.10209193825721741, 0.05471862107515335, 0.050362326204776764, 0.0071825566701591015, -0.08799340575933456, 0.014458833262324333, 0.024834105744957924, -0.06395996361970901, -0.051049742847681046, -0.0026223717723041773, 0.01703653484582901, -0.07913798093795776, 0.05457143858075142, -0.05002262443304062, -0.06260521709918976, 0.016084562987089157, -0.016332531347870827, -0.04959879815578461, 0.10626866668462753, -0.0026489871088415384, -0.031091174110770226, -0.028248818591237068, 0.02498822845518589, -0.008990591391921043, 0.08075616508722305, 0.010212230496108532, -0.005200749728828669, 0.001461754203774035, -0.04337972030043602, -0.003759236540645361, 0.03665725141763687, 0.013225649483501911, -0.035090647637844086, -0.019530942663550377, -0.00009790254262043163, 0.010455705225467682, 0.012302572838962078, 0.007948064245283604, 0.05132654309272766, -0.053847793489694595, -0.05864511430263519, 0.01622392237186432, -0.009062008932232857, -0.04417348653078079, -0.01726655848324299, -0.007412245962768793, -0.05754677578806877, 0.02049749717116356, 0.0671248659491539, -0.01060379296541214, 0.022747091948986053, -0.07203757017850876, -0.01387427281588316, 0.01867985911667347, -0.05800578370690346, 0.04497237130999565, -0.00008997100667329505, -0.028429917991161346, 0.032864753156900406, -0.011358823627233505, -0.030531752854585648, -0.022749701514840126, -0.026834672316908836, -0.04528287425637245, 0.0011536023812368512, -0.022565625607967377, 0.010968314483761787, 0.014508239924907684, -0.0005285062361508608, -0.052553579211235046, 0.020251799374818802, 0.017396746203303337, -0.04339044541120529, 0.04204816743731499, 0.009159868583083153, -0.02114437334239483, 0.02530929446220398, -0.03521814942359924, -0.013549110852181911, 0.06308094412088394, 0.04192732647061348, -0.0021451397333294153, -0.03182050958275795, -0.03487692028284073, 0.01200001873075962, -0.043023671954870224, -0.01478148065507412, -0.01631760783493519, -0.11725777387619019, 0.06781218200922012, 0.05560976266860962, -0.01984286494553089, 0.003113392274826765, -0.008628002367913723, 0.051414307206869125, 0.01501107681542635, -0.020861642435193062, -0.05184059590101242, -0.03186642378568649, -0.03034723922610283, 0.0006925516645424068, 0.023889858275651932, 0.02208016626536846, -0.04776535928249359, -0.02276630327105522, -0.007270893082022667, 0.036784831434488297, 0.004455764777958393, 0.02984688989818096, -0.07290292531251907, 0.06337056308984756, -0.016640154644846916, -0.01746354065835476, 0.06804970651865005, 0.0666731521487236, -0.01001406367868185, -0.018312212079763412, -0.006372418720275164, 0.032141368836164474, -0.0012318644439801574, 0.022033654153347015, 0.03766299784183502, -0.04738446697592735, 0.02927424944937229, -0.01425379142165184, 0.01977630704641342, 0.04268356412649155, 0.014680881053209305, 0.016750337556004524, 0.012350131757557392, -0.04081656411290169, 0.08940375596284866, 0.018070368096232414, -0.00008777201583143324, 0.033199556171894073, -0.01584828458726406, -0.07207519561052322, 0.004832273814827204, -0.015383320860564709, 0.029959918931126595, -0.01902424730360508, -0.025008883327245712, 0.048843905329704285, -0.05770496651530266, 0.04013197496533394, -0.004466284066438675, -0.019757729023694992, -0.0767107829451561, -0.04060908779501915, -0.004662248305976391, 0.026735514402389526, -0.019593870267271996, -0.04583646357059479, -0.010606258176267147, -0.06457499414682388, -0.03478512912988663, 0.04079987481236458, -0.012343725189566612, -0.03236905857920647, 0.0033933608792722225, -0.08452602475881577, -0.031530093401670456, -0.06271582841873169, -0.011201933957636356, 0.02503572590649128, -0.0339219756424427, -0.05355675518512726, -0.019316837191581726, 0.02059202641248703, -0.004945587832480669, 0.015256831422448158, 0.0016873657004907727, -0.026677120476961136, -0.005898232106119394, -0.00812902208417654, -0.03289595618844032, -0.001932322047650814, 0.038853250443935394, 0.029784347862005234, -0.013053667731583118, -0.03145281597971916, 0.03722589835524559, 0.010332372039556503, -0.07119873911142349, 0.03272995725274086, -0.007580874487757683, -0.04810521751642227, -0.027258897200226784, 0.038274262100458145, 0.005953075364232063, -0.042983829975128174, 0.03230736404657364, 0.036405984312295914, -0.029305830597877502, -0.016722729429602623, 0.009962067939341068, 0.017779875546693802, 0.04497459903359413, 0.03183765709400177, -0.00755523145198822, -0.010353664867579937, 0.016641048714518547, -0.008784910663962364, 0.03860887140035629, -0.03407583013176918, -0.014971345663070679, -0.017835145816206932, 0.08281387388706207, 0.03180455043911934, -0.031379684805870056, -0.028032757341861725, 0.025534572079777718, 0.009577332064509392, -0.0015797947999089956, -0.027327217161655426, -0.03229331225156784, 0.02648734115064144, -0.04360073432326317, -0.021043134853243828, 0.016837941482663155, 0.03876752406358719, -0.004291802644729614, -0.012541783042252064, -0.05445843189954758, 0.0342659130692482, -0.06774070858955383, 0.014489616267383099, -0.07093151658773422, -0.00433629285544157, 0.02909722924232483, 0.01675325818359852, -0.02470437064766884, -0.03811029717326164, 0.00004424530561664142, 0.03809918463230133, 0.06811335682868958, -0.00140859663952142, -0.03795313090085983, -0.07163247466087341, 0.019302252680063248, -0.07616686075925827, 0.023228036239743233, 0.037494685500860214, -0.011226778849959373, -0.03442263975739479, -0.03720426559448242, 0.020611947402358055, 0.0024804663844406605, -0.025544563308358192, -0.02897067554295063, 0.029905496165156364, -0.026928680017590523, 0.02973693609237671, -0.010078104212880135, -0.009364038705825806, -0.002241993322968483, -0.041048888117074966, 0.042698174715042114, -0.03151962161064148, 0.06567852199077606, 0.005029361229389906, 0.043463438749313354, 0.0051549687050282955, 0.04928780719637871, 0.016650302335619926, -0.010835368186235428, -0.04327099025249481, -0.010504664853215218, 0.072329580783844, 0.037402328103780746, -0.02037997730076313, -0.013978363946080208, 0.030934982001781464, -0.03436652943491936, 0.03430166095495224, -0.008040088228881359, 0.013753082603216171, 0.0031499783508479595, 0.030342869460582733, 0.0054179346188902855, 0.019415399059653282, 0.028775418177247047, -0.02600599266588688, -0.023732133209705353, -0.002184407552704215, -0.028534576296806335, 0.038917601108551025, 0.07540126889944077, -0.00013029981346335262, -0.021899329498410225, -0.021018799394369125, -0.04952408745884895, -0.012842068448662758, -0.02456311136484146, -0.00467380415648222, 0.05302772298455238, 0.0005857529467903078, -0.038410164415836334, -0.04166334867477417, 0.06009995564818382, -0.0787963792681694, 0.020087188109755516, -0.0001588308223290369, -0.04218710586428642, -0.02642599679529667, -0.06854426115751266, 0.0016743391752243042, 0.020777329802513123, 0.028023282065987587, -0.028808163478970528, 0.02779160812497139, -0.004064859356731176, -0.09687072038650513, 0.026477981358766556, 0.04276033863425255, -0.019741473719477654, -0.03377270698547363, 0.02511889860033989, -0.04638901352882385, -0.01981440559029579, 0.006421619560569525, 0.04546360298991203, 0.03198728337883949, 0.021599994972348213, -0.008543389849364758, -0.047834329307079315, 0.025952443480491638, -0.05622274428606033, -0.015356620773673058, -0.07942869514226913, -0.008499993942677975, -0.033817168325185776, 0.006166749633848667, -0.005302400793880224, 0.030586738139390945, 0.0057334876619279385, 0.04186639189720154, -0.028930867090821266, -0.06863870471715927, 0.033814556896686554, 0.020378803834319115, -0.035568058490753174, -0.03528757393360138, -0.042428139597177505, 0.029749250039458275, -0.0007133407634682953, 0.046127498149871826, -0.022673465311527252, -0.07592611759901047, 0.030040225014090538, -0.004230710212141275, 0.030833663418889046, -0.034460920840501785, -0.00794447585940361, -0.01786928065121174, -0.009391922503709793, 0.021663708612322807, -0.005259881727397442, 0.03964543715119362, 0.00527558010071516, -0.0403113067150116, 0.0684446319937706, -0.07277507334947586, 0.0231296606361866, 0.04692202806472778, 0.10005367547273636, 0.006218079011887312, 0.0010554472682997584, 0.006379679311066866, 0.04019196331501007, -0.025084363296628, -0.01831432804465294, 0.013033336959779263, 0.009211855009198189, -0.06685042381286621, 0.036047983914613724, 0.04017740488052368, -0.019217444583773613, 0.004846413154155016, 0.004712265450507402, 0.001692602294497192, -0.02459302358329296, -0.07161244004964828, -0.07163025438785553, -0.03470390662550926, 0.04950765147805214, -0.004222816321998835, -0.036668624728918076, 0.04048798605799675, 0.024977846071124077 ]
<p>I'm only a linguist, so my knowledge of statistics is very basic.</p> <p>I fitted a logistic regression model with R (with <code>lrm(formula, y=T, x=T)</code>), and when I use the option <code>validate(lrm)</code>, I get some statistics I don't really understand.</p> <pre><code>index.orig training test optimism index.corrected n Dxy 0.5984 0.6112 0.5461 0.0651 0.5333 40 R2 0.3258 0.3676 0.2929 0.0747 0.2511 40 Intercept 0.0000 0.0000 -0.0105 0.0105 -0.0105 40 Slope 1.0000 1.0000 0.8427 0.1573 0.8427 40 Emax 0.0000 0.0000 0.0399 0.0399 0.0399 40 D 0.2713 0.3176 0.2394 0.0782 0.1931 40 U -0.0177 -0.0177 0.0092 -0.0269 0.0092 40 Q 0.2890 0.3353 0.2302 0.1051 0.1839 40 B 0.1864 0.1772 0.1972 -0.0201 0.2064 40 g 1.4632 1.6642 1.3460 0.3182 1.1449 40 gp 0.2840 0.3011 0.2703 0.0308 0.2532 40 </code></pre> <p>I don't really understand most of that. I think <code>R2</code> and <code>Dxy</code> are supposed to be statistics of how good the predictors are, but I'm not sure how I should interpret the values, does the corrected <code>Dyx = 0.651</code> mean that there is a strong correlation, while the corrected <code>R2 = 0.0747</code> means that the correlation is very weak? I think the model is overfitted, but I'm not sure if I'm right.</p> <p>Also, the other statistics are totally strange to me. What are <code>Emax, D, U, Q, B, g</code>, and <code>gp</code>?</p>
g1722
[ -0.001309855841100216, -0.06733883172273636, -0.010922908782958984, -0.02377636730670929, 0.06450086832046509, -0.01170265395194292, 0.0384163074195385, 0.02369527705013752, -0.005147833842784166, -0.03461114317178726, -0.025861259549856186, 0.04597260430455208, 0.040035430341959, -0.0031989202834665775, -0.011135854758322239, 0.02885316126048565, 0.05022415518760681, 0.012321370653808117, 0.02703002095222473, -0.02106843888759613, -0.03202865272760391, -0.023656286299228668, 0.010692153126001358, -0.05048481747508049, -0.02121180295944214, -0.05099568888545036, 0.020499195903539658, 0.06763585656881332, -0.0712314024567604, 0.009731884114444256, 0.01466163620352745, 0.049938347190618515, 0.06665933132171631, -0.05150512233376503, -0.017754361033439636, 0.003990576136857271, 0.030950790271162987, 0.013451952487230301, -0.004517951514571905, -0.008799397386610508, 0.007102845702320337, 0.04403693974018097, 0.048214610666036606, 0.03651084378361702, -0.019808126613497734, 0.015667561441659927, -0.03221568092703819, 0.037237465381622314, 0.02681538835167885, -0.0582556314766407, -0.038410913199186325, 0.04340970888733864, 0.043366048485040665, -0.01227544341236353, 0.05268619582056999, 0.08205679804086685, -0.03739682585000992, 0.033032093197107315, 0.028911232948303223, 0.01136932335793972, 0.043489083647727966, -0.05271616950631142, -0.025916097685694695, 0.013600915670394897, 0.044952552765607834, 0.013488384895026684, -0.035948172211647034, -0.0335068479180336, 0.03345600888133049, -0.05691215395927429, 0.039314597845077515, 0.041736941784620285, -0.02607710286974907, -0.011024816893041134, -0.09881830960512161, -0.025272443890571594, 0.009143959730863571, 0.03847554698586464, 0.011810779571533203, 0.01073476206511259, -0.011940437369048595, -0.003936209250241518, -0.022945955395698547, 0.05203615128993988, -0.026925617828965187, -0.0019944447558373213, 0.0009928237413987517, 0.0074936458840966225, 0.010288550518453121, 0.01088757161051035, 0.015984373167157173, -0.04247219115495682, 0.031302884221076965, 0.08145879209041595, -0.02284843474626541, 0.024237141013145447, -0.07708199322223663, -0.02304820343852043, 0.02896970324218273, -0.01647808589041233, 0.009198545478284359, 0.057838454842567444, -0.01043122261762619, -0.00043350871419534087, -0.0478052943944931, 0.023178664967417717, 0.022693848237395287, 0.007583058904856443, -0.03101288713514805, -0.04238918796181679, -0.06916006654500961, 0.04788719117641449, -0.03919249400496483, -0.07493273913860321, -0.004919106140732765, -0.055537063628435135, -0.0051180399022996426, -0.032200101763010025, 0.038985494524240494, -0.0071402909234166145, 0.08183591812849045, 0.01632115989923477, 0.014308426529169083, 0.019092032685875893, 0.012777861207723618, -0.03463859483599663, -0.01693095825612545, 0.03713550046086311, 0.032432325184345245, 0.006658563856035471, 0.05787414684891701, 0.024685479700565338, -0.02560064196586609, 0.03675632178783417, 0.006947868503630161, 0.06192922964692116, 0.021691463887691498, 0.07055041193962097, -0.04444675147533417, -0.030260957777500153, -0.06270232051610947, 0.013255865313112736, 0.016625456511974335, -0.06492767482995987, -0.022284090518951416, 0.039984241127967834, 0.018924498930573463, -0.001029742881655693, -0.0025893382262438536, 0.031247230246663094, 0.04539184644818306, 0.04305858910083771, -0.013261562213301659, 0.032901909202337265, -0.032123539596796036, 0.019543107599020004, -0.011966408230364323, -0.05398579314351082, -0.0008462975965812802, 0.05944793298840523, 0.013089132495224476, -0.010688291862607002, 0.031078672036528587, 0.0383756123483181, -0.02184179611504078, -0.04109199717640877, 0.027789363637566566, -0.09120618551969528, -0.026609186083078384, 0.01679796166718006, 0.0007563990657217801, -0.009099616669118404, 0.0245891734957695, -0.04885825887322426, 0.05202570557594299, 0.04806038364768028, 0.05880075320601463, 0.0055457171984016895, 0.052701618522405624, -0.00503767654299736, 0.010358303785324097, 0.009974788874387741, 0.035783495754003525, -0.04059279337525368, -0.05930495262145996, -0.08717474341392517, 0.04781246557831764, 0.000847440620418638, -0.08433463424444199, 0.00630981894209981, -0.006471522152423859, 0.004487591329962015, -0.03829008340835571, -0.003659201553091407, -0.012152494862675667, -0.04355975612998009, 0.0022813179530203342, -0.06822756677865982, -0.007784579880535603, 0.039528701454401016, 0.014782564714550972, -0.015290958806872368, 0.012099875137209892, 0.08556678891181946, -0.010432166047394276, -0.02209603600203991, -0.03185022249817848, 0.012002047151327133, -0.014829757623374462, -0.01887255162000656, 0.025009147822856903, -0.024552667513489723, 0.02137964777648449, 0.02913735993206501, 0.04291204363107681, -0.0539524182677269, 0.00024490884970873594, 0.04712803661823273, -0.03777311369776726, -0.022113218903541565, -0.035777341574430466, -0.09071866422891617, 0.02108241431415081, -0.0026478893123567104, -0.022377464920282364, 0.03214553743600845, -0.013697216287255287, 0.00040852022357285023, -0.01364970300346613, 0.016898436471819878, -0.00858284905552864, -0.04846961051225662, 0.020830806344747543, -0.0053177778609097, 0.00622297078371048, -0.015485335141420364, 0.024222901090979576, -0.03808252513408661, -0.014336619526147842, 0.03516622260212898, 0.03552430868148804, 0.0121674919500947, -0.02680983580648899, 0.024967430159449577, 0.038190726190805435, 0.004899931140244007, 0.06262020021677017, 0.04348365217447281, -0.0159236341714859, 0.08430854231119156, -0.0127241937443614, 0.09899197518825531, -0.06153012439608574, -0.01679343171417713, -0.004436742980033159, 0.01677585579454899, -0.05935398489236832, 0.027346475049853325, -0.00812533125281334, 0.027293981984257698, 0.007260200101882219, 0.01338222622871399, -0.0176930483430624, -0.019514910876750946, -0.054321955889463425, 0.006394250318408012, -0.02546805888414383, -0.029398227110505104, -0.014546778984367847, -0.018248176202178, -0.02113780565559864, -0.020203083753585815, 0.04896155372262001, 0.08663638681173325, 0.0427156463265419, 0.013037607073783875, -0.08506540954113007, 0.012002122588455677, 0.042462870478630066, -0.04050634801387787, 0.04044397920370102, -0.018565060570836067, -0.009973779320716858, 0.04584859311580658, 0.01873401179909706, 0.007768976967781782, 0.03183887526392937, 0.010971506126224995, -0.017934326082468033, 0.03544791415333748, 0.03843829408288002, 0.0033882418647408485, -0.016728917136788368, -0.03206998109817505, -0.047266636043787, -0.008498321287333965, 0.010923700407147408, -0.03163524344563484, 0.03479121997952461, 0.021159440279006958, -0.05268887057900429, 0.03546740487217903, 0.029525937512516975, 0.007974803447723389, 0.05972864478826523, -0.07033150643110275, -0.05097139999270439, 0.013873728923499584, 0.01214676909148693, -0.00298363552428782, -0.019874803721904755, 0.0008427686407230794, -0.04931749403476715, -0.02750255912542343, -0.013640019111335278, 0.021976497024297714, -0.04225488752126694, 0.022335877642035484, 0.03058817610144615, -0.022130178287625313, -0.012399544008076191, -0.04766373708844185, -0.024707429111003876, -0.006419618148356676, -0.006672328803688288, -0.05192377790808678, -0.018899502232670784, 0.0005963841103948653, -0.025219932198524475, 0.03018783964216709, 0.013078839518129826, 0.07823646813631058, 0.004166821949183941, -0.01592671312391758, -0.008230116218328476, -0.03518874570727348, -0.04040838032960892, 0.013829173520207405, -0.014134491793811321, -0.038221199065446854, 0.0076472824439406395, -0.013047059066593647, 0.05134119465947151, 0.052695441991090775, -0.00025006788200698793, 0.041527699679136276, -0.0017259232699871063, -0.06115938723087311, -0.02249826118350029, -0.018757592886686325, -0.03518170490860939, 0.05716881901025772, -0.03745746240019798, -0.02310013771057129, -0.00996756087988615, 0.04364119842648506, 0.033180542290210724, 0.011729937978088856, -0.014335780404508114, -0.00513645401224494, 0.020350217819213867, 0.00453055277466774, -0.029170935973525047, 0.023619497194886208, -0.0009561940678395331, 0.05173768103122711, 0.025306547060608864, 0.05213003233075142, 0.030040569603443146, 0.019185595214366913, 0.007432297803461552, 0.026954594999551773, 0.010934942401945591, 0.061855219304561615, 0.02433004230260849, 0.008528788574039936, 0.05974508449435234, 0.038111649453639984, -0.028274867683649063, 0.03316204622387886, 0.047695133835077286, -0.0005510717746801674, 0.014256942085921764, -0.009719008579850197, -0.015393816865980625, -0.07015042006969452, 0.022489020600914955, 0.0035275579430162907, 0.010182434692978859, -0.004099099896848202, -0.036594487726688385, -0.014232352375984192, -0.04332748055458069, 0.09149464964866638, 0.022144094109535217, -0.080839604139328, 0.064722940325737, 0.05455702170729637, -0.005262772552669048, -0.011096561327576637, -0.06836282461881638, 0.012809992767870426, 0.02643178589642048, -0.04230443760752678, -0.06866112351417542, 0.006607730407267809, -0.005440361797809601, 0.01407405361533165, 0.008593682199716568, 0.011986928060650826, 0.0018655334133654833, 0.04451413452625275, -0.004813398700207472, -0.07369612157344818, 0.059832021594047546, 0.04728315398097038, 0.0734538659453392, -0.010784031823277473, -0.0803920328617096, -0.018157802522182465, 0.038092467933893204, 0.05715669319033623, 0.02626078948378563, -0.06362926959991455, 0.05949568375945091, 0.020315319299697876, 0.017443930730223656, -0.024794960394501686, 0.0051144445315003395, -0.007981577888131142, 0.08429095149040222, -0.0021387399174273014, -0.020699484273791313, 0.0563175193965435, -0.004383104853332043, 0.05608636140823364, -0.026724282652139664, 0.02051917091012001, 0.0007049433188512921, 0.02013322152197361, -0.007585063576698303, -0.036293137818574905, -0.006925616879016161, -0.0000744656499591656, -0.005210038274526596, -0.03596516326069832, -0.053226619958877563, 0.03569304570555687, -0.02406996861100197, 0.08781008422374725, -0.023768072947859764, 0.04357060417532921, 0.049885429441928864, -0.028619136661291122, 0.08165524154901505, -0.031227927654981613, 0.07670974731445312, 0.032898593693971634, 0.026073982939124107, -0.013312013819813728, -0.026189666241407394, -0.0640866681933403, 0.00475270627066493, -0.025752950459718704, 0.024545779451727867, -0.012651712633669376, -0.0505792610347271, -0.046685632318258286, 0.007965892553329468, 0.0037064135540276766, -0.03945201262831688, -0.010680053383111954, 0.013179656118154526, -0.019009074196219444, 0.031753432005643845, 0.04350961372256279, 0.004486747086048126, -0.031285353004932404, 0.01724662259221077, -0.01874513365328312, -0.07952745258808136, 0.024063343182206154, -0.022410152480006218, -0.0450974777340889, -0.022753877565264702, -0.013908147811889648, 0.014861092902719975, -0.05188807100057602, 0.010383627377450466, 0.028694413602352142, 0.02694476582109928, 0.02635449357330799, 0.031577300280332565, 0.008546539582312107, -0.031628385186195374, 0.0059388987720012665, 0.029275154694914818, -0.00928578618913889, 0.005367709323763847, -0.0056899129413068295, -0.06725519150495529, -0.011208387091755867, 0.002393730916082859, -0.003711888799443841, -0.022299855947494507, 0.006083549465984106, 0.07656265795230865, -0.02071867510676384, 0.030449502170085907, 0.005846725311130285, -0.025710785761475563, 0.04134969413280487, 0.08019688725471497, 0.009151391685009003, -0.024003278464078903, -0.024831173941493034, -0.008560407906770706, 0.024982333183288574, -0.03689996898174286, 0.019026633352041245, -0.010924494825303555, -0.025248156860470772, 0.04238248988986015, -0.03769988194108009, -0.04529881477355957, -0.007549114525318146, -0.02839064411818981, -0.051138509064912796, 0.03422505781054497, -0.018408313393592834, 0.024301862344145775, 0.0027656101156026125, 0.05276370048522949, 0.03950232267379761, -0.002228753874078393, -0.02548450417816639, -0.02106858789920807, -0.04199331998825073, -0.012499661184847355, -0.044509075582027435, -0.017522774636745453, 0.028184037655591965, 0.00025196271599270403, -0.017661118879914284, -0.06377989798784256, 0.016887614503502846, -0.03267451748251915, -0.01894843392074108, 0.023653429001569748, -0.05965176969766617, 0.01415916159749031, -0.03729386255145073, -0.013502877205610275, -0.004127398133277893, -0.022657426074147224, -0.014150258153676987, 0.023731447756290436, -0.03259323164820671, 0.01355285570025444, 0.0006393945659510791, -0.05725222826004028, -0.02327352575957775, -0.017260165885090828, 0.0067892372608184814, 0.010782125405967236, -0.0035860745701938868, -0.04922979697585106, 0.023920509964227676, -0.016703667119145393, 0.006130405236035585, 0.005144620779901743, -0.019934624433517456, 0.03723261132836342, 0.05811718478798866, -0.06112077087163925, 0.021855901926755905, -0.0351092554628849, 0.0197712741792202, 0.04167436435818672, -0.036751218140125275, 0.018024006858468056, -0.023043090477585793, -0.0037951539270579815, -0.012222672812640667, -0.02988344430923462, 0.008430753834545612, -0.03399620205163956, -0.026615750044584274, -0.054911836981773376, -0.005739923566579819, -0.027749907225370407, 0.028861209750175476, -0.0009625336388126016, -0.057868894189596176, -0.014968703500926495, -0.012063194066286087, -0.012723663821816444, 0.015560602769255638, -0.00024555475101806223, -0.057367369532585144, 0.011945783160626888, 0.001833099639043212, 0.04800642654299736, -0.025927476584911346, 0.026292555034160614, -0.06728775054216385, -0.043963078409433365, 0.012228330597281456, -0.022901838645339012, 0.023013276979327202, 0.005599355325102806, 0.030022015795111656, 0.027623461559414864, 0.02478225901722908, 0.02992229536175728, -0.056092407554388046, -0.043767135590314865, 0.0549173504114151, -0.0294039323925972, -0.03776862844824791, 0.03562459349632263, -0.0016454027500003576, -0.00690812710672617, -0.03086930513381958, 0.005825363099575043, 0.0024170204997062683, 0.024150775745511055, -0.0031550165731459856, 0.047137267887592316, -0.034494757652282715, -0.07892901450395584, 0.02599719911813736, -0.02445884235203266, 0.002395974239334464, -0.07489302009344101, 0.03782717511057854, -0.035016775131225586, 0.048569612205028534, 0.05044441670179367, 0.09393812716007233, 0.014117259532213211, 0.07141604274511337, -0.03817213699221611, -0.013386973179876804, 0.025750819593667984, -0.02545263059437275, 0.08640924096107483, 0.039205402135849, -0.067446768283844, 0.015466022305190563, -0.010593478567898273, -0.00010533176100580022, -0.010628340765833855, -0.035837121307849884, 0.0758238136768341, 0.01593472808599472, -0.0054263523779809475, 0.08383625745773315, 0.03865969553589821, -0.04566458985209465, 0.007169400341808796, -0.03697818145155907, -0.06591227650642395, 0.020034408196806908, 0.005878102034330368, 0.03625994175672531, 0.009534534066915512, -0.074344202876091, -0.005437178537249565, -0.05100641027092934, -0.010589603334665298, -0.02610938623547554, 0.010862166993319988, -0.018478911370038986, 0.016293087974190712, 0.04419359564781189, -0.04705330356955528, -0.011835441924631596, -0.018012691289186478, 0.017067614942789078, -0.01799589954316616, -0.020203081890940666, -0.0014369896380230784, -0.02696121856570244, -0.016060318797826767, 0.058782368898391724, 0.017976272851228714, -0.021986592561006546, -0.00640623876824975, 0.016700437292456627, -0.04945704713463783, -0.06402917951345444, 0.02492024376988411, 0.02121667191386223, -0.027581393718719482, -0.016936972737312317, -0.105519138276577, 0.02877845987677574, 0.01017354428768158, 0.04419129714369774, 0.03175843879580498, 0.020562240853905678, -0.046256449073553085, 0.02159707061946392, 0.059012606739997864, 0.013401130214333534, -0.00023037420760374516, 0.005242076236754656, -0.01608871854841709, -0.049452412873506546, -0.020687652751803398, -0.03185310587286949, -0.006119896657764912, 0.036845579743385315, -0.01657877303659916, 0.026540379971265793, 0.007150150369852781, -0.040635887533426285, -0.019613858312368393, -0.011160777881741524, -0.04295625537633896, -0.0156568493694067, 0.004774037748575211, -0.005987661425024271, -0.03612930327653885, -0.04942946881055832, -0.05466390773653984, 0.04003545641899109, -0.0138175617903471, 0.03169981390237808, -0.02836945280432701, -0.027894608676433563, -0.09647777676582336, 0.03065430372953415, 0.010361011140048504, 0.028911197558045387, 0.018146861344575882, 0.03765246272087097, -0.03946230933070183, 0.04851625859737396, -0.013124722056090832, 0.009109437465667725, 0.031227659434080124, 0.07568313181400299, 0.009162827394902706, -0.0006461202283389866, -0.019400039687752724, 0.07025756686925888, 0.0018371116602793336, -0.009557540528476238, -0.04206307232379913, 0.01785297505557537, 0.0038402522914111614, 0.051304444670677185, -0.030720476061105728, -0.039053697139024734, -0.048842690885066986, 0.005383537150919437, 0.03865855932235718, -0.03491423651576042, 0.0067464751191437244, -0.04157816246151924, 0.021730316802859306, -0.029662130400538445, -0.013712240383028984, 0.037740401923656464, -0.0549839548766613, 0.04749762639403343 ]
<p>i try to implement a simple gaussian process regression in java. I almost got every step from the book <a href="http://www.GaussianProcess.org/gpml" rel="nofollow">http://www.GaussianProcess.org/gpml</a> .</p> <p>With my implementation of algorithm 2.1 on page 19 i'm able to produce results but:</p> <p>I have the strange behavior that all predicted datapoints where i do not have any target tend to be of zero value. Does anyone know this behavior or can explain where i could have taken a mistake?</p> <p>In my plot the red line marks the predicted values, black are the targets.</p> <p>Here is the prediction and covariance java code. The parameter array includes length scale and noise, I work with the idexes of the arrays as x inputs for the covaiance function:</p> <pre><code>private double generateCOV_RADIAL(int i, int j) { double covar = Math.pow(parameter[1], 2.0) * Math.exp(-1.0 * (Math.pow(i - j, 2.0)/(2 * Math.pow(parameter[0], 2.0)))); if(i==j) covar += Math.pow(parameter[2], 2); return covar; } public void predict(int predictFuture) throws IllegalArgumentException, IllegalAccessException, InvocationTargetException{ RealMatrix y = MatrixUtils.createColumnRealMatrix(this.targets); double mean = StatUtils.mean(this.targets); for(int i = 0; i &lt; this.targets.length;i++) { targets[i] -= mean; } RealMatrix K = MatrixUtils.createRealMatrix(cov); //identity matrix for I RealMatrix k_eye = MatrixUtils.createRealIdentityMatrix(cov.length); //choleski(K + sigman^2*I) CholeskyDecomposition L = null; try { L = new CholeskyDecompositionImpl( K.add( k_eye.scalarMultiply(Math.pow(parameter[2], 2)) ) ); } catch (NonSquareMatrixException e) { e.printStackTrace(); } catch (NotSymmetricMatrixException e) { e.printStackTrace(); } catch (NotPositiveDefiniteMatrixException e) { e.printStackTrace(); } //inverse of Ltranspose for left devision RealMatrix L_transpose_1 = new LUDecompositionImpl(L.getLT()).getSolver().getInverse(); //inverse of Ltranspose for left devision RealMatrix L_1 = new LUDecompositionImpl(L.getL()).getSolver().getInverse(); //alpha = L'\(L\y) RealMatrix alpha = L_transpose_1.multiply(L_1).multiply(y); double L_diag = 0.0; for(int i = 0; i &lt; L.getL().getColumnDimension();i++) { L_diag += Math.log(L.getL().getEntry(i, i)); } double logpyX = - y.transpose().multiply(alpha).scalarMultiply(0.5).getData()[0][0] - L_diag - predictFuture * Math.log(2 * Math.PI) * 0.5; double[] fstar = new double[targets.length + predictFuture]; double[] V = new double[targets.length + predictFuture]; for(int i = 0;i &lt; targets.length + predictFuture;i++) { double[] kstar = new double[targets.length]; for(int j = 0; j &lt; targets.length;j++) { double covar = (Double)covMethod.invoke(this,j,i); kstar[j] = covar; } //f*=k_*^T * alpha fstar[i] = MatrixUtils.createColumnRealMatrix(kstar).transpose().multiply(alpha).getData()[0][0]; fstar[i] += mean; //v = L\k_* RealMatrix v = L_1.multiply(MatrixUtils.createColumnRealMatrix(kstar)); //V[fstar] = k(x_*,x_*) - v^T*v double covar = (Double)covMethod.invoke(this,i,i); V[i] = covar - v.transpose().multiply(v).getData()[0][0] + Math.pow(parameter[2],2); } this.predicted_mean = fstar; this.predicted_variance = V; } </code></pre> <p>Thank you</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/hfjBL.jpg" alt="GP Example"></p>
g74052
[ 0.022612454369664192, -0.0593247227370739, 0.007692826446145773, -0.054106228053569794, 0.045960959047079086, 0.004790480248630047, 0.03619737923145294, 0.017959410324692726, -0.029846422374248505, -0.053221721202135086, 0.0025167709682136774, 0.03391740098595619, 0.014309395104646683, 0.02887912467122078, -0.012989378534257412, 0.01741648279130459, 0.07701748609542847, 0.012895247898995876, 0.05372392013669014, -0.01656065694987774, -0.021477775648236275, -0.00034977271570824087, 0.02314145117998123, -0.04900459945201874, -0.007029394153505564, -0.006070036441087723, 0.005266711115837097, 0.053631365299224854, -0.06374988704919815, 0.0052784825675189495, 0.0127428462728858, -0.010974138043820858, 0.0019122699741274118, -0.028748201206326485, 0.0023118325043469667, -0.002174446126446128, 0.03244216367602348, -0.013322178274393082, -0.024223070591688156, -0.0009661766234785318, 0.026109792292118073, -0.028925536200404167, 0.03670080006122589, 0.03743044659495354, -0.0060800826177001, 0.04494934901595116, 0.035435792058706284, 0.025116698816418648, 0.003948161844164133, 0.02457711473107338, 0.028391525149345398, 0.002489300910383463, -0.01257244497537613, -0.05903730168938637, 0.02091938629746437, 0.05437662452459335, -0.03902069106698036, 0.015516155399382114, -0.016958873718976974, 0.006363610737025738, 0.033670395612716675, -0.03139717876911163, -0.037195879966020584, 0.05119319632649422, 0.0044048805721104145, 0.04163886979222298, -0.06873433291912079, -0.026662804186344147, 0.006173577159643173, 0.07199569046497345, -0.006581771187484264, 0.027421602979302406, -0.011673406697809696, 0.002509394194930792, 0.0009699966176413, -0.026642827317118645, 0.00025300474953837693, 0.019641989842057228, -0.006262997630983591, 0.06514086574316025, -0.021642494946718216, 0.02898816578090191, -0.01167985424399376, 0.04690885543823242, 0.024421343579888344, -0.006122527178376913, 0.007148050703108311, 0.03440660238265991, -0.012395374476909637, 0.02932327426970005, 0.01962405815720558, 0.02216794528067112, 0.013283669017255306, 0.029719144105911255, -0.018731648102402687, -0.01804344169795513, -0.043424274772405624, 0.012733441777527332, 0.04257333278656006, -0.058866359293460846, 0.004168975166976452, 0.0750480443239212, 0.019416319206357002, -0.04813850671052933, -0.037959396839141846, -0.012273616157472134, 0.07508888840675354, 0.011261026374995708, -0.05021092668175697, -0.022484751418232918, -0.02307571843266487, 0.01774473302066326, -0.08307697623968124, -0.03493625298142433, 0.006034624297171831, -0.06392158567905426, 0.04694046452641487, -0.03735382854938507, 0.044696781784296036, 0.0005067480378784239, 0.034902505576610565, -0.0625424012541771, 0.07565071433782578, 0.05597051978111267, 0.009858551435172558, 0.006000746972858906, -0.035551704466342926, 0.020870614796876907, 0.017874807119369507, -0.014599609188735485, -0.019755685701966286, -0.007844028063118458, -0.051121387630701065, 0.06561509519815445, 0.00125398812815547, -0.009708825498819351, 0.002662135288119316, 0.02206096425652504, 0.031568996608257294, 0.013066321611404419, -0.013813948258757591, 0.019046176224946976, 0.026837211102247238, -0.05804356187582016, 0.015165695920586586, -0.022772103548049927, -0.00018900349095929414, -0.019437547773122787, 0.0547407791018486, 0.006135173607617617, -0.03817456215620041, 0.023227959871292114, -0.07605424523353577, 0.04576757922768593, -0.0590544193983078, 0.021632635965943336, -0.0012741838581860065, -0.003984583076089621, -0.018172141164541245, -0.025982925668358803, 0.10298419743776321, -0.008979476056993008, 0.05844668671488762, 0.042081210762262344, -0.052979517728090286, -0.015309365466237068, -0.02207571268081665, -0.005264177452772856, -0.029468843713402748, 0.006753134075552225, 0.005338839255273342, 0.028929702937602997, -0.005913031753152609, -0.06670505553483963, 0.0009581364574842155, 0.024572329595685005, 0.02810627408325672, 0.05558831989765167, 0.054892104119062424, 0.002813927363604307, -0.02067498117685318, -0.0478648915886879, 0.026666350662708282, -0.05790020152926445, -0.05353270471096039, -0.056798744946718216, -0.023519601672887802, 0.069465272128582, -0.0850299522280693, -0.020578764379024506, -0.008144539780914783, 0.030887769535183907, -0.025613699108362198, 0.02657816745340824, -0.0015514660626649857, -0.014511770568788052, 0.04404221475124359, -0.09471620619297028, -0.0596982017159462, -0.00849099364131689, 0.0008576324325986207, 0.04051519185304642, -0.03366529196500778, 0.08429114520549774, -0.056650131940841675, -0.0035222177393734455, 0.05547552928328514, 0.01623157039284706, -0.03547033295035362, 0.05124400928616524, -0.0235922671854496, 0.0038994213100522757, -0.08464175462722778, 0.02757340855896473, 0.0375153012573719, -0.02627747319638729, 0.003149285912513733, 0.009847716428339481, 0.0022857007570564747, -0.003917147871106863, -0.021886080503463745, 0.013880652375519276, -0.02624111995100975, 0.031240645796060562, 0.03091081604361534, 0.03567182272672653, 0.0631992518901825, -0.00219902116805315, 0.02626308612525463, -0.0437801368534565, 0.005301681347191334, -0.02412584237754345, -0.009640619158744812, -0.03378242626786232, 0.026286980137228966, -0.008563045412302017, -0.027184277772903442, 0.013587809167802334, 0.0010351031087338924, 0.07051035016775131, -0.014453627169132233, -0.03610651195049286, 0.03886374831199646, 0.001195001881569624, 0.020290734246373177, -0.0653780996799469, 0.01155586913228035, -0.0269600972533226, -0.005336362402886152, 0.05618961527943611, -0.07002279162406921, 0.07803504914045334, -0.020326819270849228, -0.014303477481007576, -0.018168073147535324, -0.04395739734172821, 0.06748190522193909, 0.0270973052829504, 0.024100905284285545, -0.056369926780462265, -0.02279060333967209, -0.05060146376490593, 0.02412339486181736, 0.0313449501991272, 0.02876657247543335, 0.009532902389764786, 0.03169870749115944, 0.020750969648361206, 0.010346557013690472, -0.0024012357462197542, -0.052444182336330414, 0.02505876123905182, 0.014681529253721237, 0.03382955119013786, 0.02100844867527485, 0.08337593823671341, -0.031816158443689346, 0.02040228433907032, 0.044776756316423416, 0.0421120710670948, -0.06062938645482063, -0.009262324310839176, -0.014283864758908749, 0.019957160577178, 0.04757935553789139, -0.014172017574310303, 0.004882492125034332, 0.05726834759116173, -0.005936106201261282, -0.007677231915295124, -0.009332087822258472, 0.013738200068473816, 0.02003750018775463, -0.049078330397605896, 0.02807682380080223, -0.00040210739825852215, 0.005453402642160654, -0.02197287417948246, 0.023340264335274696, 0.007759365253150463, -0.03376276418566704, 0.0076046837493777275, -0.031750015914440155, -0.016512321308255196, 0.036733079701662064, -0.06079370155930519, 0.01311146654188633, -0.005871893372386694, -0.0482955127954483, 0.0035238091368228197, 0.03411310538649559, -0.01197185181081295, 0.02649720385670662, -0.01639578863978386, -0.0127249239012599, -0.039277758449316025, -0.02456246130168438, -0.046891115605831146, 0.03601490706205368, 0.028949780389666557, -0.011210375465452671, -0.0011646323837339878, -0.00567558454349637, 0.014293617568910122, 0.015254017896950245, -0.0013383127516135573, -0.010240590199828148, -0.032105132937431335, 0.02227121591567993, 0.074884332716465, 0.015438642352819443, 0.04936503246426582, -0.012630213983356953, -0.007215999998152256, 0.049524519592523575, -0.08316277712583542, -0.02828112244606018, 0.00756640313193202, 0.02272139862179756, -0.017498839646577835, -0.0681842565536499, -0.06622010469436646, -0.01346953958272934, -0.008443351835012436, -0.02177364192903042, 0.004716918338090181, 0.040087275207042694, -0.018858972936868668, 0.010791976936161518, -0.028256163001060486, 0.01596860960125923, -0.02221061661839485, -0.020645806565880775, -0.013663929887115955, -0.020245688036084175, 0.04723154008388519, 0.028735904023051262, 0.022917695343494415, -0.04069194197654724, -0.020259911194443703, 0.012834823690354824, -0.014094940386712551, -0.08048629760742188, 0.00030175165738910437, 0.043642159551382065, 0.046844031661748886, -0.014298559166491032, 0.05691307783126831, 0.009865745902061462, 0.006202161777764559, 0.05736164003610611, -0.06554241478443146, 0.018218927085399628, -0.03603831306099892, -0.02886515110731125, -0.02362137660384178, 0.009537456557154655, 0.04082529619336128, -0.022124936804175377, 0.05469150096178055, 0.052836764603853226, -0.010144741274416447, -0.01023238804191351, 0.033118974417448044, -0.025574762374162674, -0.014952889643609524, 0.008044306188821793, 0.021832941100001335, 0.030840646475553513, -0.029243415221571922, -0.04199855029582977, -0.027004199102520943, 0.00022890724358148873, 0.006104066036641598, -0.013933650217950344, -0.009613078087568283, 0.024479690939188004, 0.016686251387000084, 0.0208413265645504, 0.020034991204738617, -0.050236452370882034, -0.016931697726249695, 0.017320021986961365, -0.02507871761918068, 0.033386822789907455, -0.02418842725455761, 0.006419075187295675, -0.00959938857704401, -0.018382368609309196, 0.00486048124730587, -0.019479140639305115, 0.0030690261628478765, 0.0019614510238170624, -0.09371326863765717, 0.03467739000916481, -0.02279115654528141, 0.011292027309536934, 0.07160057872533798, -0.06695576012134552, -0.05888531729578972, 0.017476633191108704, 0.08705545216798782, 0.05729195848107338, -0.038269706070423126, 0.06842611730098724, -0.026812810450792313, -0.023119868710637093, 0.004283859860152006, 0.04258129000663757, -0.004929614719003439, 0.00808868370950222, -0.029280846938490868, 0.035087548196315765, 0.012786713428795338, -0.0296934787184, 0.04291587322950363, -0.006622548680752516, -0.003896445268765092, 0.028304897248744965, -0.025539884343743324, 0.011005242355167866, 0.00473825354129076, 0.0011425234843045473, -0.013431476429104805, -0.015620697289705276, 0.02804025448858738, 0.005966439843177795, 0.0085505535826087, 0.00025378598365932703, 0.00424259714782238, 0.007676412351429462, 0.026951896026730537, -0.007837877608835697, 0.011483389884233475, 0.07902689278125763, -0.01975349895656109, -0.020480358973145485, 0.06285347789525986, 0.017527783289551735, 0.04596850275993347, -0.03489121049642563, -0.044365182518959045, -0.09898882359266281, 0.007907486520707607, -0.01023913361132145, -0.05806884169578552, -0.018183555454015732, -0.020761217921972275, 0.04909997433423996, -0.026746736839413643, -0.012642152607440948, -0.003157159546390176, 0.029128218069672585, 0.019584881141781807, 0.006245863623917103, 0.02272050641477108, -0.00007465184899047017, 0.014496296644210815, 0.020732225850224495, 0.03719930350780487, -0.04304904490709305, 0.03065902180969715, 0.034847475588321686, -0.05247931554913521, 0.05372682213783264, 0.021118443459272385, 0.03622841089963913, -0.06472576409578323, 0.03684619069099426, -0.009999359026551247, 0.04443889483809471, -0.007196295540779829, 0.00503548001870513, 0.007492424454540014, 0.012368458323180676, 0.04438534379005432, -0.02561587281525135, 0.0019093449227511883, -0.04831431806087494, 0.005728117655962706, -0.03805463761091232, 0.0028655030764639378, -0.016833685338497162, 0.022684670984745026, 0.0036380027886480093, -0.03495566174387932, 0.01776210404932499, -0.04821591451764107, 0.022942369803786278, 0.031192263588309288, -0.0010446467204019427, 0.018710613250732422, 0.06478755176067352, -0.0138099305331707, -0.032303083688020706, -0.005995199084281921, -0.01776180975139141, 0.01830085925757885, -0.07738713920116425, -0.04217112064361572, 0.042100027203559875, -0.01534235943108797, -0.03744620084762573, -0.0045051430352032185, 0.08010329306125641, 0.010142970830202103, 0.014760932885110378, -0.05034146457910538, -0.020616617053747177, 0.013277929276227951, -0.05103413015604019, 0.01579899527132511, -0.004615335259586573, -0.03077295981347561, -0.007190932985395193, -0.07565686851739883, -0.011908994056284428, 0.019668390974402428, 0.024714073166251183, -0.0580127015709877, 0.04750841110944748, 0.018021658062934875, 0.010188644751906395, -0.03539464250206947, -0.09462283551692963, -0.007662198971956968, -0.04297000169754028, 0.012811587192118168, 0.04723130539059639, -0.04055239260196686, -0.03210219740867615, 0.03777536749839783, -0.02268415503203869, -0.0009882727172225714, -0.0009748152806423604, 0.020874785259366035, 0.00958943273872137, -0.01815185323357582, -0.02025027573108673, 0.017457079142332077, -0.02547290548682213, 0.034115418791770935, 0.002926144516095519, 0.05944614112377167, 0.0553610622882843, -0.025366095826029778, -0.012673723511397839, -0.012517102994024754, 0.00571061484515667, 0.039536185562610626, 0.025659622624516487, -0.05675600841641426, 0.028055090457201004, 0.028873682022094727, -0.004199650138616562, 0.02866274118423462, -0.015338603407144547, -0.047956258058547974, -0.05958455801010132, -0.03226717188954353, -0.0346720851957798, -0.005972450599074364, 0.03945833072066307, -0.017617523670196533, 0.013344446197152138, 0.029756033793091774, -0.03568512946367264, -0.016639864072203636, 0.04628683254122734, -0.023774055764079094, -0.07840023934841156, 0.056567445397377014, 0.03970174863934517, -0.04417300224304199, -0.00017198288696818054, -0.03955501690506935, -0.031908631324768066, 0.046603355556726456, -0.020297318696975708, -0.07072307169437408, -0.005620214622467756, -0.00316385505720973, 0.060540571808815, -0.023195762187242508, -0.035693828016519547, -0.01698218658566475, -0.1026657223701477, 0.009416668675839901, -0.00206656102091074, 0.04879549518227577, -0.034309666603803635, 0.05699857696890831, 0.07522694021463394, 0.07404506206512451, 0.025469159707427025, -0.03142605349421501, 0.02075030282139778, 0.035179655998945236, -0.02925562486052513, -0.046287983655929565, 0.04241705313324928, 0.003778898622840643, 0.004063318017870188, -0.03826610743999481, 0.03202415257692337, 0.049638781696558, 0.016616275534033775, 0.0002776684705168009, 0.033359602093696594, 0.03856097161769867, -0.059693593531847, 0.03856945410370827, -0.06523855775594711, 0.002410555025562644, -0.08911900222301483, 0.05906009301543236, -0.013058626092970371, 0.08831492066383362, 0.08316490054130554, -0.006785551086068153, 0.008925181813538074, 0.006664035841822624, -0.05344991013407707, 0.013936861418187618, -0.06100552901625633, 0.049954771995544434, -0.026307620108127594, 0.0019449512474238873, -0.06052430719137192, 0.03932131826877594, 0.04271800071001053, 0.014800231903791428, 0.06940332800149918, -0.08909938484430313, 0.015979168936610222, 0.053528547286987305, 0.07064356654882431, 0.010120348073542118, 0.062465742230415344, -0.05692856386303902, -0.03523729741573334, -0.008526965975761414, -0.0744229182600975, -0.010454872623085976, 0.07198212295770645, 0.0318460650742054, -0.01126802060753107, -0.020102394744753838, -0.04286219924688339, -0.04687780141830444, 0.006291316356509924, -0.07521550357341766, 0.03739970922470093, 0.036704547703266144, 0.015709109604358673, 0.035609856247901917, 0.011174113489687443, 0.01448046788573265, -0.05089376121759415, -0.013638995587825775, -0.010371338576078415, 0.04370809346437454, 0.025721793994307518, 0.008554492145776749, -0.03491700068116188, 0.0527852401137352, -0.006595972925424576, -0.0027941742446273565, -0.06661149114370346, -0.04412304610013962, -0.017597785219550133, -0.01968340389430523, 0.03647872060537338, -0.04306868463754654, 0.003543324302881956, 0.019653666764497757, -0.004660461563616991, 0.004705933388322592, 0.024721480906009674, 0.05824471265077591, 0.038371868431568146, 0.0033222853671759367, -0.0404105968773365, -0.0036162438336759806, -0.013725158758461475, 0.010328308679163456, 0.006420132238417864, -0.03149702027440071, -0.006922184024006128, -0.07143354415893555, -0.02772779017686844, 0.047040242701768875, -0.00991793442517519, 0.04336322471499443, -0.00056978571228683, 0.023067668080329895, -0.008083788678050041, 0.0030703542288392782, -0.016322292387485504, -0.021199502050876617, -0.05861542001366615, -0.03871425241231918, -0.04851643368601799, -0.028783926740288734, -0.004678105935454369, -0.03051738254725933, -0.01446913555264473, 0.02804902382194996, 0.00027054574456997216, -0.01652275212109089, -0.04981699958443642, -0.007557316217571497, -0.0440845750272274, -0.01212473213672638, -0.0021126847714185715, -0.006289897486567497, -0.013304558582603931, 0.04859800636768341, -0.05281132459640503, 0.0022433411795645952, 0.014992102980613708, -0.013650329783558846, 0.05239960923790932, 0.03431006148457527, 0.03141731768846512, -0.029944950714707375, 0.014143763110041618, 0.03149546682834625, -0.019562825560569763, -0.05735002085566521, -0.003207951318472624, 0.041259121149778366, -0.06343746930360794, 0.025140220299363136, -0.039111703634262085, 0.009840987622737885, -0.04127070680260658, 0.013251245021820068, 0.06575611978769302, -0.0532316155731678, -0.027529440820217133, -0.026480045169591904, -0.08512376248836517, 0.006901678629219532, -0.026552192866802216, -0.033182382583618164, -0.010246487334370613, 0.012019569985568523 ]
<p>I want to create an equation that consists of two independent variables "duration" and "data_transferred", and one dependent variable "meeting_quality"</p> <p>This is what I want:</p> <p>meeting_quality would be good, if more data is transferred in less duration.</p> <p>meeting_quality would be bad, if less data is transferred in more duration.</p> <p>What should be the equation presentation of above sentence? Thanks in advance.</p> <p>In fact, I want to use the values above equation in regression analysis. I would really be grateful for any further advice.</p>
g74053
[ 0.021207697689533234, -0.018840568140149117, -0.03600994870066643, -0.019462695345282555, 0.008135228417813778, -0.00663310382515192, -0.008563259616494179, 0.002417426323518157, -0.0449506938457489, -0.0023651868104934692, -0.002731533721089363, 0.05286895111203194, 0.023652179166674614, -0.002642326056957245, 0.04610971361398697, 0.003162549575790763, 0.06347503513097763, -0.036609988659620285, -0.03748978674411774, 0.03863127529621124, 0.038116179406642914, -0.004456500988453627, 0.04474662244319916, -0.014108133502304554, -0.028239043429493904, -0.04319831728935242, -0.0016745711909607053, 0.02028598077595234, -0.0531311109662056, 0.010613384656608105, 0.020494189113378525, 0.03420480340719223, 0.01433549914509058, 0.013091335073113441, -0.03704259544610977, -0.034995805472135544, -0.03327670693397522, 0.034797295928001404, 0.027701113373041153, -0.0006321916589513421, -0.0016889130929484963, 0.008095975033938885, -0.014897416345775127, 0.01275597419589758, 0.018071383237838745, -0.05756935849785805, 0.012028050608932972, 0.00809090118855238, -0.007986769080162048, 0.012600022368133068, 0.028341924771666527, 0.03260881453752518, -0.02256656251847744, -0.010002817958593369, 0.031750649213790894, 0.04774393513798714, 0.014862244948744774, -0.033950433135032654, -0.0008408417343162, 0.05767655000090599, 0.009438754990696907, -0.0634797140955925, -0.03349864110350609, -0.004031526390463114, 0.08364217728376389, 0.02463781088590622, -0.0075137075036764145, -0.01665014959871769, -0.022269658744335175, 0.0193348228931427, 0.0008189892978407443, 0.020396051928400993, 0.022705260664224625, -0.05196502059698105, 0.02618783712387085, -0.04021000489592552, 0.02319508045911789, -0.012461590580642223, -0.021438077092170715, 0.034466687589883804, -0.013475732877850533, 0.08293210715055466, 0.024583710357546806, -0.017315169796347618, 0.041110601276159286, 0.03933251276612282, 0.06514131277799606, 0.0033709811978042126, 0.010486639104783535, -0.030825350433588028, -0.024957675486803055, -0.0009259272483177483, 0.01823398657143116, 0.021166032180190086, -0.04028543457388878, -0.06291983276605606, -0.09964112937450409, -0.019135732203722, -0.004578345455229282, 0.06391382217407227, -0.02084275148808956, -0.013842248357832432, -0.018509821966290474, -0.05301288142800331, -0.010952894575893879, -0.026272570714354515, 0.04918207600712776, 0.04275389015674591, -0.07279318571090698, -0.013049619272351265, -0.041929639875888824, 0.011563933454453945, -0.026094479486346245, 0.01901673711836338, -0.0211728997528553, -0.0659312829375267, 0.00496094673871994, -0.04701942205429077, -0.01053024735301733, -0.05810922011733055, 0.04693375155329704, -0.027561508119106293, 0.03235051408410072, 0.08717664331197739, 0.015342872589826584, -0.03596925735473633, -0.04804845154285431, 0.06465157866477966, 0.05717425420880318, 0.00693758949637413, 0.02534405328333378, -0.02356117032468319, -0.0029483619146049023, 0.036834605038166046, -0.02178175374865532, 0.014878902584314346, -0.0225082915276289, 0.05609140917658806, 0.005206151865422726, 0.048888932913541794, 0.0031378676649183035, 0.04049843177199364, -0.015223316848278046, 0.0026000761426985264, -0.09489404410123825, 0.05561184883117676, 0.01171096321195364, -0.04048986732959747, -0.03409958630800247, -0.027287879958748817, -0.0037036335561424494, 0.0027111400850117207, -0.06373558193445206, 0.00712946243584156, -0.0476309098303318, -0.027493927627801895, 0.046379655599594116, -0.053966399282217026, -0.01442719902843237, 0.007580900099128485, 0.07406739145517349, -0.015855031087994576, -0.0052410876378417015, 0.002384405815973878, -0.041757624596357346, 0.01654432713985443, -0.017130767926573753, -0.026868386194109917, -0.00709916977211833, 0.00719775864854455, 0.04235517233610153, -0.017745105549693108, -0.012104046531021595, 0.0019081711070612073, 0.08229681104421616, 0.04096668213605881, 0.07534107565879822, 0.00416803453117609, 0.01101953536272049, -0.028178274631500244, -0.03320690244436264, -0.0355517603456974, 0.007708250544965267, -0.07160647958517075, -0.010975698009133339, -0.045320577919483185, 0.01714473031461239, -0.049899790436029434, -0.1069919615983963, 0.0012034372193738818, -0.020143121480941772, -0.041560493409633636, 0.034602005034685135, -0.035037703812122345, -0.045104123651981354, -0.01020936481654644, 0.05005444958806038, -0.05889986455440521, -0.0006155887385830283, 0.07028475403785706, 0.03377795219421387, 0.014584217220544815, 0.0643807128071785, 0.04617266729474068, 0.009001661092042923, -0.005400118883699179, -0.03157477825880051, -0.0227461326867342, -0.022364581003785133, -0.034942399710416794, 0.029732394963502884, -0.0022842716425657272, 0.008782739751040936, -0.009852678515017033, -0.021611493080854416, -0.011555231176316738, 0.028946110978722572, 0.02063305675983429, -0.012401181273162365, 0.0288982130587101, -0.041621267795562744, 0.012525524944067001, 0.05786294490098953, 0.04575417563319206, 0.03199813887476921, 0.005282998085021973, 0.005413030739873648, -0.03873895853757858, -0.010525591671466827, -0.01655549369752407, 0.03161231800913811, -0.008310191333293915, -0.030905691906809807, -0.05455074459314346, 0.05406862497329712, -0.012097695842385292, -0.0033585175406187773, 0.05247823894023895, -0.00471010897308588, 0.03885757923126221, -0.017271075397729874, 0.016537964344024658, 0.04116937890648842, 0.03127308562397957, -0.034914664924144745, -0.02030070126056671, 0.021068783476948738, -0.029478225857019424, 0.03493301197886467, 0.05887506902217865, -0.051544755697250366, 0.0050270454958081245, -0.037051208317279816, -0.07181286811828613, 0.0052897389978170395, -0.056681856513023376, 0.02240254543721676, 0.06368047744035721, -0.053690794855356216, 0.026803595945239067, -0.034760817885398865, -0.05757661908864975, 0.05275135487318039, 0.024432092905044556, -0.005507823545485735, -0.03404037654399872, 0.03732628375291824, 0.009195701219141483, 0.0015948645304888487, 0.018241465091705322, -0.025496434420347214, 0.034540824592113495, -0.06275487691164017, 0.07271156460046768, 0.010608389042317867, -0.03280704468488693, -0.05055871605873108, -0.01807512156665325, -0.004073754884302616, -0.016418354585766792, 0.08468698710203171, -0.03461900353431702, -0.027419116348028183, 0.03498511016368866, -0.012230358086526394, 0.01038661040365696, 0.06653856486082077, 0.048099298030138016, 0.007813818752765656, 0.0645967498421669, 0.005992251913994551, 0.003140990622341633, -0.05077877640724182, -0.017693763598799706, -0.028597399592399597, -0.014863939955830574, 0.011598287150263786, -0.04198911041021347, 0.00543731776997447, -0.010621498338878155, -0.11983813345432281, 0.07670270651578903, 0.02568121626973152, 0.03681155666708946, -0.022266551852226257, -0.004052925854921341, 0.0010389091912657022, -0.01949324645102024, -0.004712236579507589, -0.013106429018080235, -0.03349177539348602, -0.06626231968402863, 0.021589092910289764, -0.008095182478427887, -0.05336261913180351, -0.022502446547150612, -0.0036215854343026876, -0.005162051413208246, 0.04077954962849617, -0.012158080004155636, 0.02323751337826252, -0.09175407886505127, 0.06128166988492012, 0.06881274282932281, -0.057500436902046204, -0.02204824797809124, -0.002548887161538005, 0.010918134823441505, -0.04531416669487953, 0.028381194919347763, 0.04042057693004608, 0.06161518022418022, -0.014787680469453335, -0.04691352695226669, 0.019091635942459106, -0.01664062589406967, -0.0067231785506010056, 0.008347935043275356, -0.051371436566114426, 0.01582525111734867, -0.024290822446346283, -0.011601286008954048, -0.03411984071135521, 0.0394873321056366, 0.002020447049289942, -0.053847528994083405, 0.0009379317052662373, 0.029447343200445175, 0.04141221195459366, -0.06593987345695496, -0.0573575422167778, 0.017686249688267708, 0.016498593613505363, -0.06091063469648361, -0.03819189593195915, 0.016526952385902405, 0.04434416815638542, 0.0013287614565342665, -0.041437096893787384, 0.004671595524996519, 0.046528540551662445, -0.06300944834947586, -0.03912747651338577, 0.036675918847322464, -0.012844936922192574, 0.005831260234117508, 0.006961128208786249, 0.0711403489112854, -0.002237945096567273, 0.030655108392238617, 0.05849948525428772, 0.00048712067655287683, 0.03703491762280464, -0.04387492313981056, -0.021884946152567863, -0.074833944439888, 0.034206271171569824, 0.00833801832050085, -0.004413260146975517, 0.0767144113779068, -0.0037321182899177074, -0.003049538005143404, -0.02058127336204052, 0.058719243854284286, 0.026530103757977486, -0.058130763471126556, 0.0046912007965147495, 0.012431999668478966, 0.036114443093538284, 0.04185507819056511, -0.01177232712507248, -0.025220418348908424, 0.0000040767031350696925, 0.0666455328464508, 0.04445033147931099, 0.034880585968494415, 0.005401274189352989, 0.06294659525156021, -0.024500545114278793, -0.015569898299872875, -0.09467846155166626, -0.006895275320857763, 0.03229883685708046, 0.03626670315861702, -0.03817238658666611, -0.010385648347437382, 0.04381132498383522, 0.014344225637614727, -0.04298949986696243, 0.08139123767614365, -0.025939276441931725, -0.06598325818777084, -0.011760297231376171, 0.00607737572863698, -0.0022773046512156725, -0.009855511598289013, 0.05062679201364517, -0.00871005654335022, -0.0168182160705328, 0.006767787039279938, 0.030100086703896523, 0.054961636662483215, -0.0012230342254042625, 0.030762754380702972, 0.031417135149240494, 0.027124708518385887, 0.0539078563451767, 0.023776546120643616, -0.02060508541762829, -0.0005141134024597704, 0.009897584095597267, 0.022721657529473305, -0.007124126423150301, 0.03764992207288742, 0.02786097303032875, 0.03897607699036598, -0.00008911969780456275, 0.0050710272043943405, 0.01897525042295456, -0.027648333460092545, -0.005932160187512636, -0.04240747541189194, 0.017482981085777283, 0.03440474346280098, 0.0017335953889414668, 0.02523023635149002, -0.007029918488115072, -0.06302937865257263, -0.029076524078845978, -0.025867242366075516, -0.016909439116716385, 0.07205092161893845, 0.027826420962810516, -0.03210075572133064, 0.004906201269477606, 0.0005778477643616498, 0.05321035534143448, 0.01273783203214407, 0.03633139282464981, 0.005519218277186155, -0.0031486658845096827, 0.034194786101579666, -0.045537326484918594, -0.038867149502038956, -0.010126742534339428, -0.051054876297712326, -0.04005832597613335, 0.02610289677977562, 0.019720250740647316, 0.013680974021553993, -0.032522689551115036, 0.005049287341535091, 0.0008099226397462189, 0.029729783535003662, 0.055447839200496674, 0.0019510562997311354, 0.02011709474027157, -0.02889011614024639, -0.01165615115314722, 0.022445742040872574, 0.02662339061498642, -0.023454032838344574, 0.06413920223712921, -0.034270815551280975, -0.00825006514787674, -0.0063447123393416405, 0.004645783919841051, -0.03231135010719299, 0.06346667557954788, -0.05393436923623085, 0.02343287318944931, 0.00479998579248786, 0.05302821472287178, 0.046112578362226486, -0.038393452763557434, 0.002966485917568207, -0.028919706121087074, -0.03912094980478287, 0.06818050146102905, -0.017284847795963287, -0.039205241948366165, 0.04287512227892876, -0.04506811499595642, 0.013139200396835804, -0.00983712263405323, -0.0012074378319084644, 0.04096996411681175, -0.004876847378909588, 0.006586500443518162, 0.06188344210386276, 0.08176945149898529, 0.029883326962590218, 0.030898120254278183, -0.039719853550195694, -0.02892691269516945, 0.009660257026553154, -0.013223804533481598, 0.045889370143413544, 0.060438044369220734, 0.01605563424527645, 0.055927928537130356, -0.017959699034690857, -0.015504460781812668, 0.04131818190217018, 0.04809911176562309, -0.019516538828611374, -0.07908564805984497, -0.06992796808481216, 0.02751046046614647, -0.09002699702978134, -0.0306464321911335, 0.0477927066385746, -0.0023936855141073465, -0.010103675536811352, 0.0266577061265707, -0.018973004072904587, -0.005866097752004862, 0.012877847999334335, -0.043438926339149475, -0.018684078007936478, -0.06108463555574417, -0.012558894231915474, -0.004725940525531769, 0.01402059942483902, 0.011385816149413586, -0.003969467245042324, 0.029147440567612648, -0.024600394070148468, 0.0028033843263983727, 0.02840782143175602, -0.0164114311337471, 0.020136892795562744, 0.002765011740848422, -0.01001677569001913, 0.03691165894269943, -0.02516396902501583, 0.07448874413967133, 0.03624913468956947, -0.0011652359971776605, 0.00261329161003232, 0.014127053320407867, -0.0031322543509304523, -0.00425155321136117, 0.030779318884015083, -0.032350122928619385, -0.05385315418243408, -0.007171450648456812, 0.005175180267542601, -0.013851144351065159, -0.014799718745052814, -0.011685413308441639, -0.013064445927739143, 0.03789951279759407, -0.024560868740081787, -0.061786163598299026, -0.019207458943128586, 0.03542453423142433, -0.0431206040084362, -0.00440624076873064, 0.009242315776646137, 0.001290047774091363, -0.00433586398139596, -0.005255728028714657, 0.05081852152943611, -0.03248219937086105, 0.00985585618764162, 0.000675877439789474, -0.010429343208670616, -0.08979834616184235, -0.02955092303454876, -0.032366130501031876, 0.0005585909821093082, -0.015924647450447083, -0.03627578541636467, 0.04246390238404274, -0.0017507298616692424, 0.002125433413311839, -0.02458133175969124, -0.0037000058218836784, -0.02469584532082081, -0.0042366464622318745, 0.02417885698378086, 0.037292130291461945, 0.011709047481417656, 0.002725383033975959, -0.009459278546273708, 0.02113930881023407, -0.013599528931081295, 0.006537595763802528, -0.018880899995565414, -0.03171907365322113, 0.04957688972353935, 0.04298388957977295, 0.08390061557292938, 0.03584708645939827, 0.04925452545285225, -0.04750265181064606, 0.04396364092826843, 0.019508689641952515, -0.04803134500980377, -0.0016417184378951788, -0.028431963175535202, 0.02003454975783825, -0.004751940723508596, 0.000689042208250612, 0.09999203681945801, -0.05086546018719673, 0.006869098171591759, -0.000726200349163264, -0.0026905026752501726, -0.004448591731488705, -0.01040099561214447, -0.05546022206544876, 0.0004903886001557112, -0.028181124478578568, 0.09894254058599472, -0.026631614193320274, 0.057017404586076736, -0.02243959903717041, -0.003267427673563361, 0.0006612724391743541, 0.04840382933616638, -0.020991375669836998, -0.0033031741622835398, -0.03843844681978226, 0.010806296020746231, 0.06610731780529022, -0.004592217039316893, -0.06675052642822266, 0.017325345426797867, 0.016048090532422066, -0.022755596786737442, -0.01676923967897892, -0.0429907888174057, 0.04372256621718407, -0.021791111677885056, 0.013727894052863121, 0.04355142265558243, 0.07001940906047821, 0.05557597801089287, 0.010913202539086342, -0.04992292448878288, -0.04346690699458122, 0.008045870810747147, 0.021930860355496407, 0.07269646972417831, 0.008572056889533997, 0.0025904199574142694, 0.027927476912736893, -0.009450207464396954, -0.0016206938307732344, 0.0003628474078141153, 0.03630663454532623, 0.012010229751467705, -0.007648708298802376, 0.009882582351565361, -0.007552859839051962, 0.02982616238296032, -0.03486863896250725, -0.00100917078088969, -0.017769409343600273, -0.023377010598778725, -0.013212778605520725, -0.05766274034976959, -0.04577101394534111, -0.013900160789489746, 0.06735298782587051, -0.003534674411639571, 0.020412582904100418, 0.009913894347846508, -0.08200224488973618, -0.06137910485267639, 0.028202593326568604, -0.003828268963843584, -0.005758813116699457, -0.005845865700393915, -0.005246213171631098, 0.05062272399663925, 0.02369636669754982, 0.04793126881122589, 0.06166805699467659, 0.03677317500114441, -0.02044907957315445, -0.019564425572752953, -0.016854887828230858, 0.012030075304210186, -0.030946439132094383, -0.09669286757707596, -0.0015784602146595716, -0.07610852271318436, -0.010474334470927715, 0.01661626808345318, 0.009761962108314037, 0.0029959166422486305, -0.007969730533659458, -0.0361294150352478, -0.03662582114338875, -0.004076954908668995, 0.02069901116192341, 0.004007664509117603, -0.06382222473621368, -0.05576672405004501, 0.01802349090576172, -0.04123425483703613, 0.005630350671708584, -0.04227700084447861, -0.03536874055862427, -0.02658902481198311, -0.039107177406549454, 0.008461285382509232, -0.018811995163559914, 0.008990087546408176, -0.03611163794994354, 0.031653400510549545, 0.03814690560102463, 0.00822259858250618, -0.008551793172955513, 0.027050284668803215, -0.052213992923498154, 0.04531370475888252, -0.00012599301408044994, -0.04686839133501053, -0.07603178173303604, 0.0065980833023786545, 0.016119297593832016, -0.016272474080324173, -0.011422805488109589, 0.06069311872124672, 0.04295149818062782, -0.07065492868423462, -0.02320028841495514, -0.016014451161026955, -0.06735752522945404, 0.019042588770389557, 0.031244046986103058, -0.07257845252752304, -0.02174445427954197, 0.07394984364509583, -0.026382017880678177, 0.0007478535990230739, -0.013438759371638298, 0.011060287244617939, -0.018400797620415688, 0.02878449857234955, -0.032969214022159576, 0.019794819876551628, -0.02037687413394451, 0.022898005321621895 ]
<p>I have a spreadsheet where the content is organized like that:</p> <pre> content | category1 | category2 | category3 | ... _________|___________|___________|___________| ... content 1| x | | x | ... content 2| | x | | ... ... </pre> <p>How can I present this information more effectively? For example, is there a Javascript library I could use or something like that, where we could choose to show only the rows which are associated to some categories, or set a category to a row, etc? Thanks in advance</p>
g36694
[ 0.015645042061805725, 0.053878653794527054, 0.0004465105012059212, -0.058747295290231705, -0.0026651998050510883, -0.05970723181962967, 0.04201509803533554, -0.06516622006893158, -0.038075633347034454, -0.042591534554958344, 0.07314150035381317, -0.0022854870185256004, 0.15998227894306183, 0.029154563322663307, 0.010278059169650078, -0.004266328644007444, -0.006405982654541731, -0.02931048907339573, 0.04754160717129707, 0.06711796671152115, 0.01714811846613884, 0.04532718285918236, 0.037123363465070724, 0.010754919610917568, -0.04106679558753967, -0.01920710690319538, -0.03313787654042244, 0.018887780606746674, -0.017666105180978775, 0.08755434304475784, -0.048220641911029816, 0.018117625266313553, -0.007968594320118427, -0.0187212061136961, 0.028376096859574318, 0.006920307874679565, -0.00271080294623971, 0.022263526916503906, -0.011491401121020317, 0.026425495743751526, 0.0036401606630533934, 0.014517919160425663, 0.04171931743621826, -0.0878826156258583, -0.01768580451607704, 0.002843261929228902, -0.014759241603314877, -0.009001040831208229, -0.00027588530792854726, -0.011454434134066105, -0.03682347759604454, 0.07109227776527405, -0.025283770635724068, -0.03551428020000458, 0.016752947121858597, 0.008360864594578743, 0.004514644388109446, -0.007742144167423248, 0.058224115520715714, -0.006989442277699709, 0.006171323824673891, 0.009815971367061138, 0.009620711207389832, -0.009638957679271698, 0.049491286277770996, 0.02672002837061882, -0.03191612660884857, 0.031888287514448166, -0.0017087634187191725, -0.003498489037156105, 0.03661327064037323, 0.08399204164743423, -0.01874137669801712, -0.018947232514619827, -0.040281444787979126, -0.005990039091557264, -0.03472241759300232, 0.021346570923924446, 0.037536654621362686, 0.01597815938293934, 0.015030995942652225, 0.012992850504815578, -0.0026439146604388952, -0.038834165781736374, 0.006857324857264757, -0.012534243986010551, 0.00980642531067133, -0.08059111982584, 0.007318473421037197, -0.0031031842809170485, -0.05055047944188118, -0.01637394167482853, 0.020796742290258408, 0.0725560113787651, -0.02375377155840397, 0.03169157728552818, -0.03905808925628662, -0.03323619067668915, 0.008203490637242794, -0.03295491263270378, 0.03546899929642677, -0.00033474306110292673, 0.007226595655083656, -0.014145496301352978, -0.057407211512327194, -0.00890703871846199, -0.0009100156021304429, -0.012677188031375408, -0.051713235676288605, -0.04346931353211403, 0.03971075266599655, 0.06342951208353043, -0.04373690113425255, 0.0482214093208313, -0.005321219097822905, -0.015708565711975098, 0.053578030318021774, -0.02455938793718815, -0.04710769280791283, -0.0036545011680573225, 0.010103990323841572, 0.0019429812673479319, 0.04886568710207939, 0.06758619099855423, 0.013857130892574787, -0.037469733506441116, 0.018763473257422447, 0.026828985661268234, 0.03152826055884361, -0.045195166021585464, -0.06343095004558563, -0.023549731820821762, 0.019097546115517616, 0.07308965921401978, -0.022091837599873543, -0.04324140399694443, 0.008229495957493782, 0.04304834082722664, -0.04080817848443985, 0.009472068399190903, -0.02063668891787529, 0.06125478819012642, -0.06208024546504021, -0.00560392951592803, -0.007516130339354277, -0.007585084531456232, -0.03375254198908806, 0.0069566285237669945, 0.027084529399871826, 0.031366992741823196, 0.03162702918052673, -0.017708487808704376, -0.07986272126436234, -0.04709203913807869, 0.01567704789340496, -0.04259434714913368, 0.01035081222653389, -0.07666870206594467, -0.02499067783355713, -0.017460428178310394, 0.018196864053606987, 0.03330225497484207, 0.020051995292305946, -0.007261757738888264, -0.030057599768042564, -0.03067731112241745, 0.007601903285831213, 0.02318754978477955, -0.03571144863963127, 0.019085709005594254, 0.03287847712635994, 0.013789038173854351, 0.004863558802753687, 0.0025543258525431156, 0.08563145250082016, 0.056362904608249664, 0.0643140897154808, 0.05807415023446083, 0.07171469181776047, 0.03163129836320877, -0.04874339699745178, 0.008595040999352932, 0.023193953558802605, 0.0530841201543808, 0.007067324593663216, -0.009077509865164757, -0.03670917823910713, 0.05397307872772217, -0.057029642164707184, -0.0024746961425989866, -0.042377304285764694, -0.004843885079026222, 0.014852114953100681, 0.0011733577121049166, 0.0160716250538826, -0.06334885209798813, -0.027679724618792534, -0.02826126478612423, -0.006760561838746071, -0.06431791186332703, 0.02670188620686531, -0.05467255041003227, -0.007902189157903194, 0.053274065256118774, -0.04167439416050911, 0.01388995349407196, -0.000422956480178982, 0.04089732468128204, -0.0010361609747633338, -0.0005683027557097375, 0.0337427519261837, -0.013650041073560715, 0.02224794030189514, 0.02354033663868904, -0.0595172755420208, -0.0011013749754056334, -0.005284970160573721, -0.012985335662961006, -0.00800670962780714, 0.02102755196392536, -0.061547573655843735, -0.033084142953157425, 0.030972907319664955, 0.004720386583358049, 0.008317140862345695, 0.008882679976522923, -0.0009431878570467234, 0.014834514819085598, -0.08154165744781494, 0.015189770609140396, -0.052455414086580276, -0.017306163907051086, -0.004669660702347755, -0.07525761425495148, -0.01975841261446476, 0.018718626350164413, -0.06775378435850143, 0.008706443011760712, 0.0119458744302392, 0.02627219818532467, -0.05381106585264206, -0.000843734887894243, 0.022911572828888893, -0.03723802790045738, 0.01754499040544033, -0.022730330005288124, 0.033977966755628586, 0.02652813494205475, -0.0023308873642235994, 0.06677945703268051, -0.04040030017495155, 0.00046027457574382424, -0.03798208385705948, -0.0009624060476198792, 0.011503851041197777, -0.023277783766388893, 0.041668374091386795, -0.002793889259919524, -0.01166247483342886, 0.00862616766244173, 0.0048946295864880085, 0.005125653930008411, 0.08983108401298523, 0.02504727430641651, 0.0010673870565369725, -0.032992348074913025, -0.003635096363723278, -0.03440796583890915, 0.029292089864611626, 0.009582467377185822, -0.01616457849740982, -0.01056703832000494, -0.04620567336678505, -0.022128285840153694, -0.01719420775771141, 0.04718385636806488, -0.05436849221587181, 0.01207743864506483, -0.015797128900885582, -0.015330404043197632, 0.08320881426334381, -0.0492151714861393, 0.03855638951063156, 0.021210599690675735, -0.00629949988797307, 0.06654313206672668, 0.011858893558382988, 0.007939605973660946, 0.023304615169763565, 0.03929821029305458, 0.020545823499560356, -0.01531703770160675, -0.013321032747626305, 0.02586323209106922, 0.0572797991335392, -0.05017119646072388, 0.017290273681282997, 0.05829251930117607, 0.020003875717520714, -0.03165161982178688, -0.07602410018444061, 0.026662684977054596, 0.041786983609199524, -0.03099558688700199, 0.025527356192469597, 0.00021745185949839652, -0.020095007494091988, -0.01620441861450672, 0.0059277769178152084, -0.030007725581526756, -0.001546385232359171, -0.03647797927260399, -0.05427485704421997, 0.04354890435934067, 0.00573790492489934, 0.002198190428316593, 0.015189586207270622, 0.05305999144911766, -0.0204218290746212, -0.006497988011687994, -0.06943495571613312, 0.027195502072572708, -0.02028876729309559, -0.04202669486403465, -0.015438955277204514, 0.028331633657217026, -0.02064012922346592, -0.0007645173463970423, -0.01367340236902237, -0.00649666041135788, -0.013497494161128998, 0.05745242163538933, 0.04671710729598999, -0.030890969559550285, 0.00039146034396253526, -0.045263949781656265, -0.04538111761212349, -0.07399477809667587, 0.007427886128425598, 0.05290960147976875, 0.06780625134706497, -0.005240644793957472, 0.01799973100423813, 0.004692095331847668, -0.03668535128235817, 0.05943942070007324, 0.013076136820018291, 0.018156180158257484, 0.022730235010385513, 0.00689474493265152, -0.055420130491256714, 0.03499777615070343, 0.017289157956838608, -0.03096868470311165, 0.005003808066248894, 0.07916504889726639, 0.010723329149186611, -0.045698974281549454, -0.02052002027630806, -0.004474579822272062, -0.044147443026304245, -0.040490392595529556, -0.025568362325429916, -0.009615620598196983, -0.013912701047956944, 0.033570293337106705, 0.07720745354890823, 0.01474059745669365, 0.04534652829170227, 0.07066192477941513, 0.09886344522237778, -0.024328675121068954, 0.017884137108922005, -0.0384351909160614, 0.03546680882573128, -0.027765925973653793, 0.01658327691257, 0.027890127152204514, 0.006849751807749271, 0.010974236764013767, 0.01959863118827343, 0.030506666749715805, 0.05385735258460045, -0.02296285890042782, 0.019016848877072334, -0.035898130387067795, 0.04549200087785721, 0.01574094593524933, 0.019977238029241562, 0.0738319680094719, -0.050228141248226166, -0.02631141059100628, -0.03373260796070099, 0.021672487258911133, -0.026676906272768974, 0.001247300999239087, -0.008274788036942482, 0.08973947167396545, -0.028760697692632675, 0.0300759207457304, -0.04946966469287872, 0.014028139412403107, 0.029390031471848488, -0.014066421426832676, 0.02143876440823078, 0.004588239826261997, -0.0030350962188094854, -0.03882294148206711, -0.003106409450992942, -0.04355621710419655, -0.004244950599968433, -0.0445573665201664, -0.030400173738598824, 0.05014479532837868, 0.0015554649289697409, -0.008996292017400265, 0.02419671230018139, -0.003958927001804113, 0.05249418318271637, 0.01955433562397957, 0.0020840801298618317, 0.06401327252388, -0.021460361778736115, -0.10013771802186966, -0.014417923986911774, -0.0032494182232767344, 0.01226313691586256, -0.052269451320171356, 0.06256092339754105, 0.04672643542289734, -0.028837690129876137, 0.03390726447105408, 0.05868687480688095, -0.01547850202769041, -0.02427765540778637, -0.01996145211160183, -0.032867368310689926, -0.017981858924031258, -0.01886211894452572, 0.013506806455552578, -0.014807058498263359, -0.01882179081439972, -0.008478322066366673, -0.04459349438548088, -0.04402557760477066, 0.024036113172769547, -0.023160269483923912, 0.014522634446620941, -0.06929565966129303, 0.008940918371081352, -0.001895248657092452, -0.022818850353360176, 0.008953957818448544, 0.002222214126959443, 0.0013405850622802973, -0.006757879629731178, 0.0023163354489952326, 0.006538416724652052, 0.01417839527130127, -0.026930436491966248, -0.01077498123049736, -0.00798532273620367, -0.003920243587344885, -0.04629373177886009, -0.04601776599884033, -0.07349923253059387, -0.051621485501527786, 0.0067042335867881775, 0.06907527893781662, -0.03093881905078888, 0.07130684703588486, 0.021392347291111946, 0.01722949743270874, -0.05044465884566307, 0.02862320840358734, 0.021654797717928886, -0.0008359006023965776, -0.012731281109154224, -0.01819419488310814, 0.024231400340795517, -0.05062706023454666, 0.009069029241800308, -0.0013301841681823134, -0.03191891685128212, 0.06013213098049164, 0.0036706074606627226, 0.011153236031532288, -0.05695292726159096, -0.03664368391036987, -0.01485134195536375, 0.004891205579042435, 0.014924433082342148, 0.006126592867076397, 0.038717783987522125, -0.015575959347188473, -0.06922993063926697, 0.022175438702106476, 0.0062473490834236145, 0.03083648905158043, 0.0025102091021835804, 0.0028704393189400434, 0.026094984263181686, 0.007840598002076149, 0.026600565761327744, 0.002798483707010746, -0.009125583805143833, 0.011996693909168243, 0.013124274089932442, 0.01681339740753174, 0.011252174153923988, -0.002069014823064208, 0.07841027528047562, -0.03779162839055061, 0.0499206967651844, -0.05419755354523659, 0.005169128533452749, 0.0033139626029878855, 0.07287253439426422, -0.05866225063800812, -0.012441787868738174, -0.01371830329298973, -0.026584209874272346, -0.006588433403521776, 0.03376796096563339, -0.037795428186655045, -0.005678679794073105, -0.07557151466608047, -0.07201188802719116, 0.0408274307847023, -0.03757966309785843, -0.013799354434013367, 0.030380886048078537, 0.035436008125543594, -0.028638944029808044, 0.005566114094108343, -0.07227551192045212, 0.0047881691716611385, 0.023775463923811913, 0.055325839668512344, -0.03288310021162033, -0.04646558687090874, -0.0565536767244339, 0.020752334967255592, -0.011990212835371494, 0.06320224702358246, -0.04855111986398697, -0.029824890196323395, -0.05497016757726669, 0.017613649368286133, -0.026559624820947647, 0.04967257380485535, 0.042710382491350174, 0.03355538845062256, -0.001052358653396368, -0.04790915176272392, -0.007051475346088409, 0.05958250164985657, -0.043413784354925156, 0.019852472469210625, 0.003872310509905219, -0.01570042409002781, -0.015058456920087337, -0.016781847923994064, 0.03173661231994629, -0.02549518272280693, 0.07897903770208359, -0.002303836867213249, -0.02870817482471466, -0.0352582186460495, 0.01919105462729931, -0.008828387595713139, -0.07036321610212326, 0.03921244293451309, 0.03697118163108826, 0.05592655763030052, -0.007603260688483715, 0.046688180416822433, 0.00046241693780757487, 0.06776828318834305, -0.009771975688636303, 0.007963339798152447, -0.004870234057307243, -0.006339221727102995, 0.040847647935152054, -0.009500795044004917, 0.051043134182691574, -0.026146909222006798, 0.028868837282061577, -0.04261146858334541, -0.06032782047986984, -0.01997588761150837, 0.0005496643134392798, -0.003962818533182144, -0.014893116429448128, 0.017580721527338028, 0.06224725767970085, 0.00599572854116559, 0.022023972123861313, 0.051190756261348724, 0.030428053811192513, -0.02037297561764717, -0.010303817689418793, 0.018661363050341606, 0.012135028839111328, -0.026949122548103333, 0.008950515650212765, 0.054480940103530884, -0.005301548168063164, 0.005647408310323954, 0.005115250591188669, 0.0025421211030334234, 0.018880311399698257, -0.026992443948984146, 0.0824936255812645, 0.008759813383221626, -0.054639458656311035, -0.04341155290603638, -0.02032455801963806, 0.036966629326343536, -0.001480784616433084, -0.08137623220682144, 0.01684548333287239, -0.01037247758358717, -0.01381615735590458, 0.03796996548771858, -0.028486521914601326, -0.022775808349251747, 0.06254301220178604, -0.011920725926756859, 0.01655680127441883, -0.006358906161040068, 0.05369896441698074, 0.0035334983840584755, 0.06913669407367706, 0.012996085919439793, -0.025477265939116478, 0.0006422903970815241, 0.022521216422319412, 0.005211450159549713, 0.06811174005270004, 0.047828707844018936, 0.004472427070140839, 0.030272364616394043, 0.04109625518321991, 0.01598067581653595, -0.014683093875646591, 0.0437280498445034, -0.053263161331415176, -0.04156143218278885, -0.01279173232614994, 0.014052274636924267, 0.030353238806128502, -0.022744357585906982, 0.005619928240776062, -0.024401284754276276, -0.012983575463294983, 0.01680811680853367, 0.012027349323034286, -0.07187435775995255, 0.017818085849285126, -0.011121864430606365, -0.010149224661290646, -0.04761173948645592, -0.01967642456293106, -0.0264118779450655, 0.05028654634952545, 0.003615183522924781, 0.10352160036563873, -0.050587818026542664, -0.004253531340509653, -0.041195619851350784, 0.004036754369735718, 0.04473820701241493, -0.008004172705113888, -0.020647965371608734, -0.013293544761836529, 0.00034760517883114517, -0.031239915639162064, -0.0031200468074530363, -0.002751508727669716, -0.007311712019145489, 0.01972557231783867, 0.05915917083621025, -0.030878569930791855, -0.019720545038580894, 0.009688309393823147, -0.045128580182790756, -0.019670775160193443, 0.006381182931363583, -0.031821537762880325, -0.0347830206155777, -0.0903576910495758, 0.024806208908557892, 0.003032265929505229, -0.026265926659107208, -0.03581143543124199, -0.0017533756326884031, 0.002337156794965267, -0.02232702262699604, 0.03595970571041107, 0.0651886984705925, 0.030745308846235275, 0.005750627256929874, -0.05050547420978546, -0.003415890270844102, -0.01461278460919857, -0.05431174859404564, -0.0014449196169152856, -0.07319457828998566, -0.05770353227853775, -0.059832073748111725, 0.019937310367822647, -0.01102907583117485, -0.03019782528281212, -0.027247468009591103, 0.04753171652555466, -0.049094878137111664, 0.07218568027019501, -0.039071742445230484, 0.09872036427259445, -0.04988730326294899, 0.006553221959620714, -0.007364808581769466, 0.00987283792346716, 0.04889127239584923, 0.00860411673784256, 0.009347358718514442, -0.043918728828430176, 0.006282981485128403, 0.06828369945287704, 0.0087415287271142, 0.036551717668771744, -0.009032154455780983, 0.05310025438666344, -0.038379963487386703, -0.008235513232648373, -0.017238430678844452, -0.06992863118648529, 0.007585525047034025, 0.028116978704929352, -0.032081689685583115, -0.00665830634534359, -0.08435986191034317, -0.026840640231966972, 0.015567932277917862, -0.0048906998708844185, -0.011428416706621647, 0.007471725344657898, 0.0033806536812335253, -0.051065731793642044, -0.07661952078342438, 0.019130749627947807, 0.02080491930246353, -0.018699681386351585, 0.0017035425407812, 0.021125303581357002, -0.005955567117780447, 0.004254704341292381, -0.012340910732746124, 0.00433387840166688, 0.02580896019935608, 0.014037862420082092, -0.020834490656852722, 0.05592624098062515, -0.021137762814760208, 0.0016939743654802442, -0.04770805686712265, -0.042349569499492645 ]
<p>In <code>R</code>, I would like to give multiline names to some data sets in <code>boxplot</code>, like this:</p> <pre><code>boxplot(rnorm(10), rnorm(10, mean=2), names=c("Normal", "Shifted\n*")) </code></pre> <p>Here, the names seem to be aligned with their bottom lines, which causes the text to overlap with the axis. How can I have multiline names which simply extend to the bottom instead of upwards?</p>
g36695
[ 0.023824917152523994, 0.02603278122842312, -0.010896063409745693, -0.03787948563694954, -0.021204138174653053, 0.012981944717466831, -0.05029755085706711, -0.03277139738202095, -0.050139762461185455, -0.03936636447906494, -0.015011616982519627, -0.0029879531357437372, 0.04650665447115898, 0.012044675648212433, 0.012516738846898079, 0.005491601303219795, 0.04181390255689621, 0.005157016683369875, 0.08863062411546707, 0.003383499337360263, 0.04449167475104332, 0.03330198675394058, 0.014492480084300041, -0.05312574282288551, -0.03138670325279236, -0.0557282492518425, 0.03702031075954437, -0.0038003441877663136, -0.09440102428197861, 0.0021313317120075226, -0.03690144419670105, 0.004092944320291281, 0.008471443317830563, -0.02744906023144722, 0.0006681872764602304, -0.026660235598683357, -0.016614502295851707, 0.017987415194511414, 0.01731671206653118, -0.011645032092928886, -0.0005150125361979008, 0.014133422635495663, 0.016251718625426292, 0.003515056101605296, -0.0028877505101263523, -0.055080678313970566, -0.05350121855735779, 0.029789919033646584, 0.004808574914932251, -0.0724206417798996, 0.010383257642388344, 0.022802986204624176, -0.01625615358352661, -0.02929646149277687, 0.03885068744421005, 0.02672288566827774, -0.028088359162211418, 0.04809729754924774, 0.020425114780664444, 0.036404646933078766, 0.020398670807480812, 0.04443381726741791, 0.012858875095844269, 0.007429124787449837, 0.027660217136144638, 0.027493681758642197, -0.05733637139201164, -0.03862433880567551, 0.03176037222146988, 0.009973309002816677, 0.0031853686086833477, 0.02135363593697548, -0.0262545645236969, 0.013543283566832542, -0.05763985961675644, -0.03381161019206047, -0.003054605796933174, 0.019752953201532364, 0.01515553705394268, 0.0006563935894519091, 0.02448119968175888, 0.005050010047852993, -0.07548530399799347, 0.023788107559084892, 0.023369109258055687, 0.029280653223395348, 0.05513039976358414, 0.03641378507018089, -0.04945584386587143, 0.007157413754612207, -0.006676731631159782, -0.016076385974884033, 0.00992561224848032, 0.06541433185338974, -0.007475701160728931, 0.02774963714182377, -0.02732309140264988, -0.005665606819093227, 0.012466419488191605, -0.014578406699001789, -0.039405856281518936, 0.06569512188434601, 0.04754247888922691, -0.013107560575008392, -0.05914905294775963, 0.0203100573271513, 0.050560902804136276, 0.008624403737485409, 0.0022198932711035013, -0.02625221014022827, -0.03920067101716995, -0.003937986679375172, -0.028637893497943878, -0.04949801415205002, 0.014548096805810928, -0.024387292563915253, 0.03837581351399422, -0.0010349013609811664, 0.02861359901726246, -0.0007308530621230602, 0.03140253201127052, -0.0026632887311279774, 0.021775037050247192, 0.0485377311706543, -0.016949208453297615, -0.040989212691783905, -0.029779544100165367, 0.017682846635580063, 0.04372110962867737, -0.02478543296456337, 0.006740497890859842, -0.01655178889632225, 0.05183817818760872, -0.008449782617390156, -0.045085128396749496, -0.020852386951446533, -0.03606884926557541, -0.0426919125020504, 0.04747239127755165, -0.049836643040180206, -0.03798827528953552, -0.017496729269623756, -0.033439867198467255, -0.05184037238359451, 0.0014770431444048882, -0.02530963160097599, -0.008025926537811756, -0.01392422802746296, -0.0016304872697219253, 0.06772717088460922, 0.03686411306262016, 0.07169626653194427, -0.006545622833073139, 0.009137280285358429, 0.011869072914123535, 0.03898167610168457, 0.044551607221364975, -0.046729665249586105, -0.02446204051375389, 0.029660459607839584, 0.008279704488813877, 0.027834618464112282, -0.06621064245700836, -0.004139191936701536, -0.028740575537085533, -0.000731391366571188, 0.005247300490736961, -0.007200801279395819, -0.028665505349636078, -0.035471703857183456, -0.0040206266567111015, 0.014789661392569542, 0.024849535897374153, -0.03984828665852547, 0.026211407035589218, 0.06465663760900497, 0.07498615980148315, 0.001612418214790523, 0.06879899650812149, -0.0080760158598423, -0.05673220008611679, -0.03126060590147972, -0.01833249256014824, -0.000387881911592558, 0.007871527224779129, 0.019294988363981247, -0.052427809685468674, -0.03685704991221428, -0.03490282967686653, -0.059443410485982895, 0.03144887462258339, 0.01661057025194168, 0.026333628222346306, -0.021991916000843048, 0.009243032895028591, -0.0422288216650486, 0.03602327033877373, 0.020320797339081764, 0.00112916121724993, 0.034850094467401505, 0.08900856971740723, 0.005286728497594595, -0.02358359470963478, 0.013904758729040623, -0.04519563168287277, 0.02816266380250454, -0.028740055859088898, 0.04132499173283577, -0.003270204644650221, 0.0376497358083725, 0.004488556180149317, -0.047717880457639694, -0.005511964205652475, 0.010280102491378784, 0.016629090532660484, 0.01045453455299139, -0.005447067320346832, 0.031002312898635864, -0.03928077593445778, 0.02974957413971424, -0.09787249565124512, 0.008524293079972267, -0.005819812882691622, 0.012280532158911228, -0.008744972757995129, -0.012232215143740177, 0.027076438069343567, 0.018741218373179436, -0.022218696773052216, -0.09182626008987427, -0.030791765078902245, 0.03216320648789406, 0.03695002198219299, -0.07988056540489197, 0.005892322398722172, 0.021859923377633095, -0.044786881655454636, 0.06128976494073868, -0.036217354238033295, 0.03995125740766525, -0.014720916748046875, 0.022526569664478302, 0.009397453628480434, 0.03803058713674545, 0.052395254373550415, -0.012436226941645145, 0.0677347332239151, -0.006853770464658737, -0.06524445116519928, 0.06307827681303024, -0.0351196825504303, 0.057934653013944626, -0.013455281034111977, 0.05614503473043442, 0.017998281866312027, -0.04149745777249336, -0.049635473638772964, 0.027708029374480247, 0.004774636588990688, -0.08547449111938477, -0.007181680761277676, 0.01633424684405327, -0.04303061589598656, -0.02698313258588314, -0.010392359457910061, 0.019288573414087296, 0.0172536913305521, -0.028424380347132683, 0.03501339629292488, 0.05953477323055267, -0.023703139275312424, 0.020433569326996803, 0.0502544641494751, 0.004874066915363073, -0.00384625606238842, -0.0038538635708391666, 0.00005540538040804677, -0.003015108173713088, 0.009145953692495823, 0.039260316640138626, 0.04800064489245415, -0.003528124885633588, 0.041241683065891266, -0.03225729987025261, 0.006428912281990051, 0.001332071959041059, -0.016758237034082413, 0.01195389311760664, -0.05420266091823578, 0.02977644093334675, 0.02560938149690628, -0.011997241526842117, 0.02673245221376419, -0.07582440972328186, 0.03125325217843056, -0.030260654166340828, -0.02815607376396656, 0.02998274937272072, -0.02089502662420273, 0.019400939345359802, -0.03957649692893028, 0.039800822734832764, 0.029294971376657486, -0.031529318541288376, -0.0628436729311943, -0.0006881732842884958, 0.018953686580061913, 0.022949248552322388, 0.01580166257917881, 0.004591797012835741, 0.049179647117853165, -0.029899001121520996, -0.05743598937988281, 0.06289032846689224, -0.05393458902835846, -0.057897984981536865, 0.018852651119232178, 0.027178259566426277, 0.02924501895904541, -0.011494051665067673, -0.016537867486476898, 0.0028129960410296917, 0.015908880159258842, 0.0671713799238205, -0.037485964596271515, -0.01841401308774948, 0.06878893077373505, -0.025254394859075546, -0.049905601888895035, 0.04540753737092018, -0.023896921426057816, 0.03139423578977585, -0.03785093128681183, 0.029280629009008408, 0.001317964750342071, 0.03982419893145561, 0.00029623167938552797, -0.003772473195567727, 0.0343075692653656, 0.02298368327319622, -0.00806864071637392, 0.006731520406901836, -0.00834107119590044, -0.02336828224360943, 0.00528744189068675, 0.05909531190991402, 0.05889562517404556, 0.027640188112854958, -0.016489868983626366, 0.009739656001329422, -0.0449359156191349, 0.035180144011974335, 0.011779794469475746, -0.041894156485795975, 0.022272655740380287, 0.05813858285546303, 0.0009231164585798979, 0.004088808782398701, -0.0016306692268699408, 0.01863984763622284, -0.019421391189098358, 0.03638610616326332, -0.029323142021894455, 0.04936174675822258, 0.0350419282913208, 0.02601337805390358, 0.060833461582660675, 0.09671507775783539, 0.05634608492255211, 0.00688741821795702, 0.04856995865702629, -0.036673154681921005, 0.03414773941040039, -0.03142792731523514, -0.01099148578941822, 0.002726141130551696, 0.03485038876533508, 0.029696518555283546, 0.03983393311500549, 0.07762164622545242, -0.029684696346521378, -0.01927752047777176, 0.0006985383806750178, 0.006968912202864885, -0.06389782577753067, 0.02338661439716816, -0.028395110741257668, -0.015464600175619125, 0.021947579458355904, 0.06487508118152618, -0.025096265599131584, -0.010122907347977161, 0.011348014697432518, -0.020717119798064232, -0.01885027438402176, -0.06526637822389603, 0.019191622734069824, 0.06411989033222198, -0.06362298876047134, 0.02237546816468239, -0.016303781419992447, -0.03277565911412239, -0.01662088744342327, -0.0013106660917401314, -0.00957084633409977, -0.035832419991493225, -0.01597568392753601, 0.003629152663052082, -0.0004966885317116976, 0.03495633974671364, 0.035300061106681824, -0.043622300028800964, 0.012867345474660397, 0.042640261352062225, 0.08747399598360062, 0.014862993732094765, 0.03251411020755768, 0.02318798564374447, -0.04794183373451233, 0.031102893874049187, 0.012987506575882435, 0.07079403102397919, -0.025616897270083427, -0.03293270245194435, 0.027459070086479187, -0.005634814966470003, 0.00020170805510133505, -0.05487358197569847, 0.06248509883880615, 0.07654713094234467, -0.03714529424905777, 0.022689690813422203, -0.05582505464553833, -0.026714516803622246, -0.037514716386795044, -0.07289492338895798, 0.013823351822793484, -0.04752453416585922, -0.01614004746079445, 0.026960138231515884, -0.02028472162783146, -0.04164945334196091, -0.020775984972715378, -0.020298196002840996, -0.0037380673456937075, -0.004585090093314648, -0.06676794588565826, 0.03849898651242256, -0.0621584877371788, 0.010095280595123768, -0.06653382629156113, -0.05509745702147484, 0.0430268794298172, 0.004228278063237667, 0.02359827421605587, -0.011574596166610718, -0.0011244042543694377, -0.018789570778608322, 0.04492335766553879, -0.05357728898525238, 0.012762283906340599, -0.017948154360055923, -0.03732650727033615, -0.03595944121479988, -0.013730435632169247, -0.052720192819833755, -0.06244245916604996, -0.05483654886484146, 0.030425237491726875, 0.004871415439993143, 0.01889067515730858, 0.007331863045692444, 0.0058025880716741085, 0.03897600620985031, 0.029076920822262764, 0.031597595661878586, -0.04160212352871895, -0.011180860921740532, -0.035199761390686035, -0.07131356745958328, -0.08141297101974487, 0.02225348725914955, -0.009338708594441414, -0.011666467413306236, -0.02087000012397766, -0.01953784190118313, 0.10474518686532974, -0.019250240176916122, 0.050503894686698914, 0.003118796506896615, -0.016624288633465767, -0.013823261484503746, 0.0394708625972271, 0.05089924857020378, -0.012394063174724579, 0.007774239405989647, -0.03819047287106514, -0.02247181534767151, 0.0012297295033931732, -0.061411429196596146, -0.023669501766562462, 0.026613285765051842, 0.0004601615946739912, 0.026449544355273247, 0.01709103211760521, 0.022045450285077095, -0.01701408624649048, 0.02666725404560566, -0.029874656349420547, -0.01712173782289028, -0.011085729114711285, -0.020388562232255936, 0.01257881335914135, 0.004846824333071709, -0.031216539442539215, -0.05437891557812691, -0.0709049254655838, 0.019823068752884865, -0.061071526259183884, -0.04878529906272888, 0.0030616235453635454, -0.06550721824169159, -0.008341400884091854, 0.021200165152549744, 0.08792494237422943, 0.055194467306137085, 0.009806482121348381, -0.04354744777083397, 0.030008500441908836, 0.0064345733262598515, -0.025033013895154, 0.012943852692842484, -0.003059615381062031, -0.030667828395962715, -0.04513360932469368, -0.02780429646372795, 0.013519760221242905, -0.005974407307803631, 0.04412051662802696, -0.025239374488592148, 0.016814151778817177, 0.011051773093640804, 0.025426138192415237, -0.009020580910146236, -0.03387840464711189, -0.04547891393303871, -0.029856277629733086, -0.014774493873119354, -0.012326069176197052, -0.021329015493392944, -0.0074680643156170845, 0.03817244619131088, -0.004663691855967045, 0.02393440715968609, -0.03547843545675278, 0.013584299944341183, 0.007083865348249674, -0.046545397490262985, 0.018370162695646286, -0.007574185729026794, 0.010070137679576874, -0.019434235990047455, 0.0012118230806663632, -0.009657789953052998, -0.035610951483249664, 0.04137793183326721, -0.04451555013656616, 0.034251052886247635, -0.006206021644175053, -0.03347626328468323, 0.016255836933851242, -0.03483109176158905, -0.03373853117227554, 0.026105524972081184, 0.009099593386054039, 0.0504690520465374, -0.03909476473927498, 0.01864057593047619, 0.021616198122501373, 0.021178070455789566, -0.07206039130687714, -0.017430130392313004, -0.05488062649965286, -0.02923111990094185, -0.027104509994387627, 0.03833513706922531, 0.001441373024135828, 0.01959867961704731, 0.055441394448280334, -0.05379343777894974, -0.023328658193349838, -0.038178250193595886, 0.004859882406890392, -0.035378050059080124, -0.017847733572125435, 0.0012985710054636002, -0.03561874106526375, 0.09131620824337006, 0.019076794385910034, -0.014452674426138401, -0.020755015313625336, 0.09654030203819275, 0.10316742211580276, 0.00006856006802991033, -0.012975946068763733, -0.031626105308532715, -0.028178848326206207, -0.07801181823015213, -0.018819039687514305, 0.01121070608496666, 0.034704845398664474, 0.04801902920007706, 0.004545737523585558, 0.06962395459413528, -0.016935279592871666, -0.01802206039428711, 0.011163595132529736, -0.009265657514333725, 0.016734875738620758, -0.04428550973534584, 0.037472017109394073, -0.0012224427191540599, -0.0133734829723835, -0.0308810006827116, -0.01774013414978981, -0.011169567704200745, 0.002583826892077923, -0.08309702575206757, -0.012052617035806179, 0.029039893299341202, -0.06169716268777847, 0.007598513271659613, -0.062052760273218155, -0.05777209252119064, 0.011003697291016579, 0.03231887146830559, 0.03439438343048096, 0.02985057793557644, 0.01927896775305271, 0.0709313154220581, -0.01952997036278248, 0.006581177935004234, 0.019211050122976303, 0.01792072504758835, 0.03926769644021988, -0.014655198901891708, 0.013823017477989197, 0.015903666615486145, -0.03776112198829651, 0.03728588670492172, 0.02655084617435932, 0.06527778506278992, -0.08879274129867554, 0.04807839170098305, -0.024813560768961906, 0.03317033872008324, 0.041787393391132355, -0.02918299287557602, 0.001916899112984538, -0.0014586842153221369, -0.00162506103515625, -0.019463272765278816, -0.03446780890226364, -0.02180633693933487, 0.014909622259438038, 0.008836972527205944, 0.04653944447636604, -0.020979460328817368, -0.047753192484378815, -0.02515675500035286, -0.025524495169520378, -0.051882803440093994, 0.0349779948592186, 0.07660871744155884, 0.023665335029363632, -0.009068768471479416, -0.022849375382065773, 0.026188554242253304, 0.011074394918978214, 0.00954271201044321, 0.05027925968170166, -0.04804886505007744, 0.01279523316770792, -0.0435916967689991, -0.044830743223428726, 0.03928935155272484, 0.07814810425043106, 0.055534061044454575, 0.012550639919936657, -0.013256375677883625, 0.04434964805841446, 0.0027817091904580593, -0.007692156825214624, -0.05842070281505585, -0.00954808946698904, -0.030306139960885048, -0.043411072343587875, -0.0001393054408254102, -0.008844937197864056, 0.02368825301527977, 0.036267396062612534, 0.0566585436463356, -0.021206099539995193, -0.015999076887965202, 0.0159711055457592, -0.01340363547205925, 0.014481062069535255, 0.02860221266746521, -0.011737029068171978, -0.08173593878746033, -0.011216833256185055, 0.06646139174699783, 0.06001729145646095, 0.033473894000053406, -0.011995559558272362, 0.05539284646511078, 0.02993512526154518, 0.04680555313825607, -0.02425520308315754, -0.0148607874289155, -0.14877371490001678, -0.008359260857105255, 0.011943310499191284, 0.01690211147069931, -0.012280642054975033, 0.022451411932706833, -0.01877213642001152, 0.005205332767218351, -0.049921005964279175, 0.0065155960619449615, -0.06817647069692612, 0.00413853395730257, -0.016012372449040413, 0.031148582696914673, 0.010435380041599274, 0.026658080518245697, -0.05789249390363693, 0.04319359362125397, 0.06489972025156021, -0.03134379908442497, 0.01150182168930769, -0.01839880831539631, 0.00885255727916956, 0.015627695247530937, 0.025033708661794662, -0.0013018265599384904, -0.029218466952443123, 0.0794314369559288, -0.003938211593776941, -0.03119564801454544, -0.01733679138123989, 0.084357850253582, 0.007166648283600807, 0.060158420354127884, 0.03551553189754486, 0.011337202042341232, 0.042553093284368515, 0.029370246455073357, 0.000998810981400311, 0.005770090967416763, -0.037377677857875824, -0.0188138484954834, -0.011344827711582184, -0.0011857978533953428, -0.021525688469409943, 0.007460711523890495, -0.05412251502275467, -0.023112047463655472 ]
<p>I wanted to create a bubble chart which means a scatter plot with a separate variable indicating diameter of bubble. Is there any way to use bubble then as pie chart? I would really like to do this in MS Excel but I just don't know whether it is possible. </p> <hr> <p>I have another problem with the code proposed earlier in the post. Now that the first problem appears to be solved there is a problem in the line </p> <p><code>Set rngRow = Range(ThisWorkbook.Names(“PieChartValues”).RefersTo)</code></p> <p>and I tried to replace PieChartValues with the range from the first row to the last in which the pie charts values ( the values from which the pie chart is generated) - like "A1:G12" and all the data are in that range. The tab in the sheet I am working in is called "B" without quotes should I write </p> <p><code>Set rngRow = Range(ThisWorkbook.Names(“B”).RefersTo)</code></p> <hr> <p>i tried to implement the code of a link proposed earlier in VBA this is</p> <pre><code>Sub PieMarkers() Dim chtMarker As Chart Dim chtMain As Chart Dim intPoint As Integer Dim rngRow As Range Dim lngPointIndex As Long Application.ScreenUpdating = False Set chtMarker = ActiveSheet.ChartObjects(“chtMarker”).Chart Set chtMain = ActiveSheet.ChartObjects(“chtMain”).Chart Set chtMain = ActiveSheet.ChartObjects(“chtMain”).Chart Set rngRow = Range(ThisWorkbook.Names(“PieChartValues”).RefersTo) For Each rngRow In Range(“PieChartValues”).Rows chtMarker.SeriesCollection(1).Values = rngRow chtMarker.Parent.CopyPicture xlScreen, xlPicture lngPointIndex = lngPointIndex + 1 chtMain.SeriesCollection(1).Points(lngPointIndex).Paste Next lngPointIndex = 0 Application.ScreenUpdating = True End Sub </code></pre> <p>when I execute the code I get an error pointing to the line Set chtMarker = ActiveSheet.ChartObjects(“chtMarker”).Chart</p> <p>does anybody have an idea why? I have an object a pie chart named exactly chtMarker so the object should be there</p>
g36696
[ 0.023319054394960403, -0.037009261548519135, 0.004579279106110334, -0.049136798828840256, -0.024852748960256577, 0.05869189649820328, 0.02237270027399063, -0.05425902456045151, -0.052879299968481064, 0.010811980813741684, 0.005197575781494379, 0.03228963539004326, 0.015346145257353783, -0.010032029822468758, 0.0011878901859745383, -0.0003976100997533649, 0.04019147902727127, -0.017452077940106392, -0.04708418622612953, 0.04650101438164711, -0.021068625152111053, 0.02328166551887989, 0.014844441786408424, -0.0643128827214241, -0.02601117081940174, -0.039774879813194275, 0.015063129365444183, 0.00949213095009327, -0.003737664083018899, 0.020699823275208473, 0.017044082283973694, 0.06053638830780983, 0.03080378659069538, -0.03494914993643761, 0.013498975895345211, -0.0165577232837677, -0.019497962668538094, 0.05809560790657997, -0.018063105642795563, 0.06625449657440186, -0.022036245092749596, 0.017953641712665558, 0.032961297780275345, 0.009002670645713806, 0.019378935918211937, -0.037735093384981155, -0.021360676735639572, 0.054133810102939606, 0.06668874621391296, -0.011769115924835205, -0.015921883285045624, -0.006529774516820908, 0.04378027468919754, -0.08154399693012238, 0.04247530922293663, 0.028494728729128838, 0.01514111552387476, 0.014736659824848175, -0.01793060265481472, 0.017191268503665924, -0.04885340854525566, 0.0033155009150505066, 0.032855454832315445, 0.013338702730834484, 0.013399945572018623, 0.0592692494392395, -0.06593738496303558, -0.06320924311876297, -0.07620784640312195, -0.05913518741726875, 0.00506054749712348, -0.04122934117913246, 0.007153037469834089, -0.04296787455677986, -0.05910549685359001, -0.0022821524180471897, -0.0736980140209198, -0.04063279926776886, -0.012616586871445179, 0.03138093650341034, 0.021614359691739082, 0.022002799436450005, -0.06005611643195152, 0.0551021434366703, -0.005063113756477833, -0.010934361256659031, 0.005970402620732784, -0.039991576224565506, -0.046998295933008194, -0.0017341687344014645, -0.034446414560079575, -0.04175063595175743, 0.03843187168240547, 0.02923651784658432, -0.01925624907016754, -0.004882849752902985, -0.04167664423584938, 0.017496559768915176, -0.0003794768708758056, 0.007437853142619133, 0.041656579822301865, -0.005321646109223366, 0.07845842838287354, 0.001977843465283513, -0.03163952752947807, -0.017022836953401566, 0.08146307617425919, -0.0069327810779213905, -0.06574905663728714, -0.0006648651324212551, 0.040691912174224854, -0.004705995786935091, -0.02318393439054489, -0.010653510689735413, 0.0008883715490810573, -0.045594558119773865, 0.06879203021526337, -0.017708532512187958, 0.000709319079760462, 0.06518277525901794, 0.03485605865716934, 0.018266577273607254, 0.08930957317352295, 0.05650964379310608, -0.017547443509101868, -0.030665893107652664, -0.02942817285656929, 0.03154299408197403, 0.05732784792780876, -0.008918029256165028, -0.05764646828174591, -0.015090570785105228, -0.031200801953673363, 0.05312446132302284, -0.00227560568600893, -0.01870688609778881, 0.032726626843214035, -0.025319533422589302, 0.0010242274729534984, -0.06310766190290451, -0.04336412996053696, 0.023243790492415428, -0.022705908864736557, -0.0368427112698555, 0.0024402705021202564, 0.026622837409377098, -0.05321343243122101, -0.03653643652796745, 0.02150479145348072, 0.00936234463006258, -0.005492507480084896, -0.011239051818847656, -0.06953194737434387, -0.014987131580710411, -0.023953987285494804, -0.04623587429523468, 0.01910313218832016, 0.024164654314517975, 0.025009753182530403, -0.05919095128774643, 0.006669565569609404, 0.007501451764255762, 0.08840072154998779, -0.00742003321647644, 0.03267574682831764, -0.013432740233838558, 0.0341864675283432, -0.041753772646188736, -0.03369500860571861, -0.06199784204363823, -0.026471581310033798, -0.032650187611579895, -0.017076335847377777, -0.049101490527391434, 0.01853548362851143, 0.04051599279046059, 0.02874632552266121, 0.021695930510759354, 0.03295926749706268, 0.008712340146303177, -0.01879432238638401, -0.04172603040933609, 0.015848102048039436, -0.01116885244846344, -0.03958636522293091, 0.07279017567634583, -0.019774608314037323, -0.05084811523556709, -0.03670591861009598, -0.0026236705016344786, -0.030381077900528908, -0.01950623095035553, 0.014671003445982933, 0.019786100834608078, 0.011250597424805164, -0.02921815775334835, 0.03670269250869751, -0.035132989287376404, -0.05354849621653557, 0.039827533066272736, 0.005857616197317839, 0.059361349791288376, -0.016369063407182693, -0.003281841054558754, -0.0367310531437397, 0.03666040673851967, 0.0033605799544602633, 0.01337631419301033, -0.024109654128551483, 0.02251075580716133, 0.061654750257730484, -0.013982366770505905, -0.0033284593373537064, 0.007052736822515726, -0.04434092715382576, -0.05533593147993088, 0.004938874859362841, -0.036946289241313934, -0.01525076013058424, 0.05869292840361595, -0.02134983241558075, -0.01724793203175068, 0.016387194395065308, -0.004632675554603338, 0.023180291056632996, 0.0010168300941586494, 0.03012090176343918, -0.02746906690299511, -0.011282884515821934, -0.030915331095457077, -0.01058328989893198, -0.007420483510941267, 0.011639614589512348, -0.048076972365379333, 0.00977899320423603, -0.02817971631884575, -0.01305697113275528, 0.02719152346253395, -0.054207731038331985, 0.012107495218515396, -0.011406185105443, -0.010262140072882175, 0.05622348189353943, 0.010584861971437931, 0.01764502003788948, 0.0007556175696663558, 0.061242152005434036, -0.03260331600904465, 0.009447687305510044, 0.09165482223033905, -0.021455910056829453, 0.05822133645415306, -0.015844551846385002, 0.015525243245065212, 0.03540037199854851, -0.0572219118475914, 0.039215199649333954, 0.014441038481891155, 0.0364961214363575, -0.03720690310001373, -0.013613812625408173, 0.014269709587097168, -0.01325575727969408, 0.012973788194358349, -0.02627299353480339, 0.003186683403328061, 0.015363791957497597, 0.0015212619910016656, 0.027406763285398483, -0.005293011665344238, -0.11782132089138031, 0.007881752215325832, 0.035170093178749084, 0.006613962352275848, 0.015080079436302185, -0.01423148438334465, 0.05270310118794441, 0.04802222177386284, 0.033762697130441666, 0.04192130267620087, 0.02628718875348568, -0.08236409723758698, -0.03914323076605797, 0.019109420478343964, -0.00019303671433590353, -0.00407401705160737, 0.020524175837635994, -0.015135199762880802, -0.048052556812763214, -0.010051812045276165, 0.030922386795282364, -0.08358371257781982, 0.026199081912636757, -0.027082057669758797, 0.014458315446972847, -0.029999813064932823, 0.012690172530710697, 0.04097485914826393, 0.08555438369512558, 0.055036500096321106, -0.05422808602452278, 0.01613130420446396, -0.036248814314603806, 0.016938859596848488, 0.015019536018371582, -0.026587409898638725, 0.00639697490260005, -0.04175039753317833, 0.02409505657851696, 0.01244051568210125, 0.04799190163612366, 0.019844084978103638, -0.04544968903064728, 0.005586457904428244, 0.012869234196841717, -0.014748991467058659, -0.031473275274038315, 0.0028026914224028587, 0.020528005436062813, 0.004933257587254047, -0.029528779909014702, 0.01112519484013319, -0.002771207597106695, 0.04611562192440033, -0.032568447291851044, -0.006472156383097172, 0.009930421598255634, 0.013525431975722313, -0.03723907098174095, 0.011325201019644737, -0.027554800733923912, 0.05374082922935486, -0.013706524856388569, 0.03152837976813316, 0.010546915233135223, -0.030223213136196136, -0.0051207225769758224, 0.006583458743989468, 0.01081704068928957, 0.0230756513774395, -0.02269158512353897, -0.05649475008249283, 0.02451496198773384, -0.02242312952876091, 0.03133896365761757, 0.010907911695539951, -0.007445456925779581, 0.017399972304701805, 0.01349289994686842, 0.004163902718573809, -0.00471595861017704, -0.03366823121905327, -0.0029840038623660803, -0.027640849351882935, 0.05070905387401581, 0.03268791735172272, 0.0004245602176524699, -0.002020865911617875, -0.06066518649458885, -0.03258490562438965, -0.05487201362848282, -0.004499298986047506, 0.022041834890842438, 0.05729535594582558, 0.023979779332876205, 0.030142098665237427, 0.04766217619180679, 0.03912791609764099, 0.005531394388526678, 0.0245098564773798, 0.04757647216320038, -0.02173152193427086, 0.0505562461912632, -0.03595970943570137, 0.01164610218256712, -0.054985225200653076, 0.005087149329483509, 0.006292345002293587, -0.00650800671428442, 0.09751031547784805, 0.011844518594443798, -0.02382012829184532, 0.01861509121954441, 0.018650373443961143, -0.03127392381429672, -0.02992912009358406, 0.037909265607595444, 0.016026224941015244, 0.05591659992933273, -0.031023668125271797, -0.07044630497694016, -0.06731048226356506, -0.03382051736116409, 0.06975813955068588, 0.006270385347306728, -0.0030175030697137117, -0.008766339160501957, 0.04603813961148262, -0.007788844872266054, 0.040760595351457596, -0.11058218777179718, -0.032573241740465164, 0.02139613777399063, 0.016462206840515137, 0.0009972077095881104, -0.04170646145939827, 0.0260220468044281, -0.027805987745523453, -0.014446821995079517, -0.00850093737244606, -0.025154776871204376, -0.08925851434469223, 0.010708183981478214, -0.001318788854405284, 0.02513940818607807, -0.08114521205425262, 0.05901643633842468, 0.04652777314186096, 0.0035266990307718515, 0.04356420785188675, -0.01846257783472538, 0.049327243119478226, 0.04306580126285553, -0.05746666342020035, 0.06230325251817703, 0.02092920057475567, 0.000037413665268104523, -0.06434431672096252, 0.03624190017580986, 0.022221283987164497, -0.05488795042037964, 0.03864561766386032, 0.024702487513422966, 0.02575976960361004, 0.00013018169556744397, -0.006295115686953068, -0.014460181817412376, -0.06884003430604935, 0.005234932526946068, -0.03502463549375534, -0.007780417334288359, -0.045149680227041245, -0.047011032700538635, -0.015449220314621925, 0.03424673154950142, 0.05082032084465027, -0.03202052414417267, 0.061298202723264694, 0.021328268572688103, 0.08823131769895554, 0.012839470990002155, -0.03898842632770538, 0.02743365615606308, 0.020011840388178825, 0.04664686694741249, 0.019205672666430473, 0.04674435034394264, -0.012256366200745106, 0.023353779688477516, -0.02047305554151535, 0.012579189613461494, 0.029055068269371986, -0.039912234991788864, 0.00464871060103178, 0.021837783977389336, -0.020749041810631752, -0.05110606551170349, -0.017348989844322205, -0.0014761248603463173, -0.00002806251541187521, -0.03386929631233215, 0.07859634608030319, 0.03209877759218216, 0.005264383275061846, 0.058074235916137695, 0.05308672413229942, 0.028707146644592285, 0.03357445448637009, 0.011913200840353966, -0.01673937402665615, -0.07560679316520691, -0.0004798189620487392, 0.02487068809568882, -0.0015721941599622369, 0.007188896182924509, 0.014882435090839863, -0.07353013753890991, -0.009326161816716194, 0.07076544314622879, 0.05373212695121765, 0.02648830972611904, -0.0017830070573836565, 0.007454097270965576, 0.014961603097617626, -0.005594240501523018, -0.04901217669248581, -0.006383876316249371, -0.026817062869668007, -0.005868591833859682, -0.03753785043954849, 0.04290226474404335, 0.012904679402709007, -0.05615485459566116, -0.003950522746890783, -0.010949656367301941, -0.002927280031144619, 0.03577207028865814, 0.019824953749775887, 0.03956789895892143, -0.03966260328888893, -0.01971837319433689, 0.0061708856374025345, 0.06380829960107803, 0.01015753485262394, -0.012088415212929249, -0.055456601083278656, -0.033925727009773254, 0.027066560462117195, -0.0601782463490963, -0.04781818389892578, 0.05245116725564003, -0.026127781718969345, 0.011261164210736752, -0.011471597477793694, 0.086452417075634, 0.06360278278589249, 0.03854871913790703, -0.06066616252064705, 0.10264173895120621, -0.011985346674919128, 0.014313538558781147, 0.028233926743268967, -0.015842802822589874, -0.025782082229852676, -0.05099872499704361, -0.009877056814730167, -0.042342279106378555, 0.015441365540027618, 0.060599517077207565, -0.03566380962729454, -0.05562148988246918, -0.02593166194856167, -0.024758849292993546, -0.03327734395861626, -0.020077219232916832, -0.029668454080820084, 0.0027896109968423843, -0.002866436494514346, -0.0005642645992338657, 0.023360593244433403, 0.035682257264852524, 0.059573568403720856, 0.019458318129181862, 0.04435309022665024, -0.0014023961266502738, -0.02577323652803898, 0.032235343009233475, -0.050882335752248764, -0.024902211502194405, -0.05345473438501358, -0.007637940347194672, 0.020862391218543053, 0.00962306559085846, 0.062262583523988724, 0.03291338309645653, 0.0009446984622627497, -0.008292583748698235, -0.003989195916801691, 0.022279271855950356, 0.023248890414834023, -0.04838068410754204, -0.029237357899546623, -0.010891599580645561, 0.014906984753906727, 0.024398507550358772, 0.010944239795207977, 0.03965252637863159, 0.04367562755942345, 0.0026026542764157057, 0.006153222639113665, -0.015437647700309753, 0.0029336181469261646, -0.01933787390589714, -0.013574464246630669, 0.0195474736392498, -0.0245610810816288, 0.0349687896668911, 0.034695759415626526, -0.038698554039001465, -0.03874880075454712, -0.011071497574448586, 0.00135658192448318, -0.005767077673226595, -0.005399372428655624, -0.03757654130458832, -0.007401269394904375, -0.0029627885669469833, 0.02564253844320774, -0.016029857099056244, -0.012442697770893574, -0.02179526351392269, 0.016402972862124443, -0.005996129475533962, -0.04367255046963692, -0.08388916403055191, -0.0449153371155262, -0.0014271988766267896, 0.009160194545984268, 0.020979128777980804, -0.030685842037200928, -0.05187031626701355, 0.08321928977966309, 0.03877411410212517, 0.050522707402706146, 0.06311512738466263, -0.03466879576444626, 0.008418708108365536, 0.044943783432245255, 0.018740173429250717, -0.04851628467440605, -0.025618556886911392, -0.010535737499594688, 0.02715354599058628, -0.021543147042393684, 0.041551947593688965, -0.018337242305278778, 0.016268035396933556, 0.07575006037950516, -0.019980914890766144, -0.00206166529096663, -0.05998851731419563, -0.0009049780783243477, -0.06940280646085739, -0.0007452683057636023, 0.010181627236306667, 0.030590662732720375, 0.0417167954146862, 0.025334754958748817, 0.0074832141399383545, 0.004998220130801201, -0.007104688789695501, 0.02248760312795639, -0.003504497231915593, 0.018346142023801804, -0.060930848121643066, -0.009964918717741966, 0.04831555485725403, -0.03908609226346016, -0.07944048941135406, 0.052229221910238266, 0.045506615191698074, 0.017933493480086327, -0.07490726560354233, -0.019400086253881454, -0.007738752290606499, 0.01744881458580494, 0.004830856341868639, 0.01554290484637022, -0.03597550466656685, -0.041307251900434494, -0.06775548309087753, -0.05274443328380585, 0.025413185358047485, -0.023652395233511925, 0.022716691717505455, 0.05890747904777527, 0.03869279846549034, 0.023121582344174385, -0.018959058448672295, -0.05195670202374458, -0.03414524719119072, -0.014833235181868076, 0.04707253351807594, 0.0005226360517553985, 0.02993858978152275, 0.04014621675014496, 0.01737688109278679, -0.03014414943754673, 0.021883610635995865, 0.03767506778240204, -0.004777656868100166, -0.014764172025024891, -0.0014424286782741547, 0.011973991058766842, 0.019079260528087616, 0.029148368164896965, -0.025564339011907578, 0.01817336119711399, 0.060404807329177856, -0.020389797165989876, -0.020090457051992416, -0.04312209039926529, 0.02233755961060524, -0.053337711840867996, 0.04169663041830063, -0.05464344844222069, -0.04137992486357689, 0.026065954938530922, -0.016029447317123413, -0.02303704246878624, 0.08986104279756546, 0.018527287989854813, -0.02715080976486206, -0.032099027186632156, 0.03847303241491318, 0.06367967277765274, 0.010533679276704788, 0.010697632096707821, -0.05189887806773186, -0.08721047639846802, -0.044649433344602585, -0.0033144576009362936, 0.02212423086166382, -0.0124244075268507, -0.0016039242036640644, 0.07199621200561523, 0.0019010250689461827, 0.06608017534017563, -0.022562021389603615, 0.028835786506533623, -0.021524090319871902, -0.047382902354002, -0.016235584393143654, -0.017181869596242905, 0.06897399574518204, -0.01793341338634491, 0.03664364665746689, -0.009490090422332287, -0.027416136115789413, -0.0318417027592659, -0.028848499059677124, 0.03183799982070923, -0.009944799356162548, 0.03626915067434311, -0.012282042764127254, -0.040215250104665756, -0.04449550434947014, 0.007795020937919617, 0.028235848993062973, -0.04129713028669357, 0.015087260864675045, -0.0589902363717556, 0.022951900959014893, -0.0053919171914458275, 0.02066885493695736, -0.008216583169996738, 0.038078971207141876, 0.007021569646894932, 0.009034928865730762, -0.08267312496900558, -0.04816129431128502, -0.01747911237180233, -0.07141232490539551, -0.01051018014550209, 0.01924729347229004, 0.0027596503496170044, -0.009318472817540169, 0.03603784367442131, 0.06936926394701004, -0.020411193370819092, -0.05190664902329445, 0.018391748890280724, -0.05501407012343407, 0.06276315450668335, -0.024455182254314423, -0.015122349373996258, 0.009434373117983341, 0.002656130585819483 ]
<p>What is the PDF of the difference of two i.i.d Laplace distributed random variables?</p> <p>I know that the difference of two i.i.d Normal variables is still the Normal distribution. Since the properties of the Laplace distribution are similar to the Normal distribution, I am guessing that the difference is also the Laplace distribution.</p> <p>I have tried to solve this using Mathematica. Neither <code>PDF</code> nor <code>Integrate</code> functions give a correct answer. Thank you!</p>
g74054
[ 0.04230391979217529, -0.0554443784058094, 0.005821458995342255, -0.09579689055681229, -0.009383340366184711, 0.030730750411748886, 0.03981650993227959, -0.00031730474438518286, -0.0481349341571331, -0.001458167564123869, 0.0015803013229742646, 0.02191256545484066, -0.005551340524107218, -0.05487809702754021, 0.033565375953912735, 0.018632495775818825, -0.0011333462316542864, -0.0035092628095299006, -0.01794620417058468, -0.026769515126943588, -0.0828801766037941, 0.02593301050364971, -0.01986507885158062, 0.0037796383257955313, -0.023613011464476585, -0.015863994136452675, -0.03670120984315872, -0.024392718449234962, -0.04789350926876068, 0.025146299973130226, -0.034635383635759354, 0.010111354291439056, 0.07835560292005539, -0.04815281927585602, 0.03914371877908707, 0.048218607902526855, 0.04200292378664017, 0.0453554131090641, 0.008286475203931332, -0.012819943018257618, -0.030472667887806892, 0.024720288813114166, -0.006836418062448502, -0.02588501013815403, -0.01574496179819107, 0.0033905578311532736, -0.04719505459070206, 0.012633215636014938, -0.02874518744647503, 0.02316574938595295, 0.023910347372293472, 0.04821682348847389, -0.02241198532283306, 0.0149809205904603, 0.027397461235523224, -0.002578065497800708, 0.02253693714737892, -0.06540146470069885, 0.017880329862236977, -0.0014661600580438972, 0.04216393828392029, -0.012478258460760117, -0.06686848402023315, -0.03216828405857086, -0.022841939702630043, -0.008062446489930153, 0.024964988231658936, -0.0091138556599617, 0.024609873071312904, -0.01283683069050312, -0.01764344424009323, -0.014387372881174088, 0.05236338824033737, -0.047296274453401566, 0.003285028738901019, -0.05398520827293396, 0.05324108526110649, -0.005164492409676313, -0.01763279177248478, 0.01893853023648262, -0.05896216630935669, 0.013239018619060516, 0.06265172362327576, -0.013384637422859669, 0.010288502089679241, -0.01899157464504242, 0.03665097430348396, 0.05915459990501404, -0.037328314036130905, 0.07132069766521454, -0.011201850138604641, -0.02851320616900921, 0.06455803662538528, 0.050383612513542175, -0.06300727277994156, -0.036852702498435974, -0.05071862041950226, 0.06316244602203369, -0.05414116010069847, -0.0004853812279179692, 0.020566876977682114, 0.021715469658374786, 0.048581358045339584, 0.03726482391357422, -0.007262562867254019, -0.02475508116185665, 0.06097102537751198, -0.0309135764837265, -0.018795480951666832, -0.0057656969875097275, -0.04860570654273033, -0.05258046090602875, -0.04002314805984497, 0.007007804233580828, 0.028617391362786293, -0.02474287897348404, 0.07209569960832596, -0.09470763057470322, -0.003269999986514449, -0.01206845510751009, -0.02364129014313221, 0.021062670275568962, 0.04990820214152336, -0.013666946440935135, 0.06745759397745132, -0.006119918543845415, -0.025095229968428612, 0.009457502514123917, 0.029165217652916908, -0.026929333806037903, 0.06293792277574539, 0.0435100719332695, -0.023850420489907265, -0.03834991157054901, -0.04954537749290466, 0.04378499090671539, -0.019854949787259102, 0.06284443289041519, -0.007578185759484768, 0.0724000558257103, 0.02207452617585659, -0.020426176488399506, 0.015403096564114094, 0.017258914187550545, 0.029931558296084404, -0.010560007765889168, -0.005076209548860788, -0.03466511145234108, -0.032801367342472076, -0.0024832021445035934, 0.05342807248234749, 0.018049975857138634, -0.029223689809441566, 0.013811773620545864, -0.0269196555018425, 0.020357700064778328, -0.011371441185474396, 0.017153143882751465, 0.013041804544627666, 0.014047311618924141, -0.04690788686275482, -0.013410181738436222, 0.04959198087453842, 0.012774894945323467, 0.007039699237793684, 0.020835375413298607, 0.06654322892427444, -0.010039963759481907, -0.03160623461008072, -0.0107413986697793, 0.07073543220758438, -0.05370590090751648, -0.02476819045841694, -0.008029959164559841, 0.026284998282790184, 0.0027744374237954617, -0.03232420235872269, -0.004001553636044264, -0.03044217824935913, 0.054709240794181824, 0.02533390000462532, 0.024922488257288933, 0.024438142776489258, -0.04888152703642845, 0.016088837757706642, -0.00002691208283067681, 0.009370490908622742, -0.015495166182518005, -0.026537809520959854, -0.02802039310336113, -0.08168704807758331, 0.010572792030870914, -0.02285117842257023, -0.02467159554362297, -0.04573630914092064, 0.0023172032088041306, 0.014969964511692524, -0.025599006563425064, -0.04901401326060295, 0.06416627019643784, 0.04020990803837776, 0.029075512662529945, 0.0421283096075058, -0.0019173629116266966, -0.007867018692195415, 0.007219537626951933, -0.012967627495527267, -0.027598554268479347, -0.01402602531015873, 0.02016184665262699, -0.04104187712073326, -0.01857326179742813, 0.02919696643948555, 0.030003540217876434, 0.06980680674314499, -0.05371228978037834, 0.0034017865546047688, 0.015180762857198715, -0.020436666905879974, -0.04414815455675125, -0.027226105332374573, -0.03731684759259224, -0.013623872771859169, -0.06907869130373001, -0.016065407544374466, -0.009328034706413746, -0.021145759150385857, 0.014649648219347, -0.01759437471628189, 0.059981271624565125, -0.029865972697734833, -0.01202691812068224, -0.01515701599419117, 0.04412975162267685, 0.022355344146490097, 0.041818950325250626, -0.02100382000207901, -0.005089147482067347, 0.036149151623249054, -0.024231716990470886, -0.04605517536401749, -0.013011674396693707, 0.046780675649642944, 0.0852811336517334, -0.002057059668004513, -0.024685649201273918, 0.028511542826890945, -0.05691762641072273, -0.018834101036190987, 0.04410998150706291, -0.01277512963861227, 0.04806547239422798, 0.028622006997466087, 0.0017522030975669622, 0.010110163129866123, -0.02106104977428913, -0.02093023620545864, -0.09691467881202698, -0.014792566187679768, -0.03380860015749931, -0.037014078348875046, 0.004693737719208002, 0.04753554239869118, 0.04964461550116539, -0.0425986610352993, 0.005040044896304607, 0.05949274078011513, 0.06427862495183945, 0.013036280870437622, -0.03936978057026863, 0.03292759135365486, 0.05343548208475113, 0.014014632441103458, 0.0065257553942501545, 0.021826615557074547, -0.01943983882665634, -0.029555391520261765, -0.06826669722795486, -0.03645429387688637, -0.001621452160179615, 0.0777096077799797, -0.033233340829610825, -0.026714999228715897, 0.018865762278437614, 0.01982855796813965, -0.1037212535738945, 0.03559156507253647, 0.012975698336958885, 0.003678820328786969, -0.005776815116405487, -0.0368606373667717, 0.051610127091407776, -0.013290692120790482, -0.03474646806716919, 0.010446446016430855, -0.009206820279359818, -0.020671790465712547, -0.025449581444263458, 0.002344585722312331, -0.02418431267142296, -0.0013027884997427464, -0.0076009007170796394, 0.01893221214413643, 0.039070870727300644, 0.022103087976574898, -0.03003760613501072, 0.03539152815937996, 0.020504912361502647, -0.04217563197016716, -0.00829363614320755, 0.027039671316742897, 0.013103238306939602, -0.017556477338075638, -0.029727477580308914, 0.017551442608237267, 0.012139811180531979, -0.012143213301897049, 0.011520883068442345, 0.023849869146943092, 0.008082453161478043, -0.04499587044119835, -0.06943584978580475, 0.01127561554312706, -0.009666035883128643, 0.058964721858501434, 0.013360175304114819, -0.04662910848855972, 0.038852740079164505, 0.017452379688620567, -0.04620224982500076, -0.02841363474726677, 0.03675328567624092, -0.041577715426683426, 0.0034714145585894585, 0.066565603017807, 0.009975139051675797, 0.007975811138749123, 0.03982940688729286, 0.027266688644886017, 0.021600738167762756, 0.06916583329439163, 0.010515420697629452, -0.05263838917016983, 0.008342967368662357, -0.04232009872794151, -0.07258255034685135, 0.05396394059062004, 0.06320085376501083, 0.038024645298719406, 0.09889614582061768, 0.01841709204018116, -0.001988505246117711, 0.1051681637763977, -0.04466468468308449, 0.005862197373062372, -0.02518700808286667, -0.010785438120365143, -0.0359630361199379, -0.015580158680677414, 0.004953596740961075, 0.04480764642357826, -0.06279554963111877, -0.006413924507796764, 0.08160144835710526, 0.002685447223484516, -0.048830028623342514, 0.04308602958917618, -0.010519496165215969, -0.03526539355516434, -0.001784310326911509, 0.019487302750349045, 0.03020750917494297, 0.04393208399415016, -0.050915949046611786, 0.03730997443199158, -0.0012557015288621187, -0.001861550728790462, -0.024277031421661377, 0.020490286871790886, 0.00313309277407825, 0.02804061956703663, -0.04405597597360611, -0.030664104968309402, 0.01785568706691265, 0.08718327432870865, -0.04942205920815468, -0.0009904730832204223, 0.022904299199581146, 0.0952112004160881, -0.09934992343187332, 0.013093632645905018, -0.04586804285645485, -0.056979358196258545, -0.021107850596308708, 0.04529483988881111, 0.019676873460412025, 0.005036511924117804, 0.045139774680137634, -0.015225720591843128, 0.038848619908094406, -0.048258472234010696, -0.03264594450592995, 0.019581519067287445, 0.0030951867811381817, -0.023837603628635406, -0.014686675742268562, 0.03319229930639267, -0.031790077686309814, 0.006356560159474611, -0.02186022698879242, -0.023006802424788475, 0.014537260867655277, 0.010492642410099506, -0.01335553266108036, -0.029388608410954475, -0.0331694595515728, -0.0005491047631949186, 0.0161266066133976, -0.023455357179045677, 0.002104043262079358, -0.03323915973305702, -0.015775619074702263, -0.038659874349832535, 0.03562435880303383, -0.047480303794145584, 0.007867335341870785, 0.039337873458862305, -0.0003234489122405648, 0.030200330540537834, -0.11120457202196121, -0.027964523062109947, 0.04836084693670273, -0.002812864724546671, 0.05074044317007065, -0.004852901212871075, 0.0009558928431943059, 0.04942703992128372, 0.00810034479945898, -0.032968390733003616, -0.017050497233867645, -0.011855848133563995, 0.014227455481886864, -0.034278739243745804, 0.04805411025881767, 0.027688458561897278, 0.053980473428964615, 0.06488505005836487, -0.015252054668962955, -0.060387905687093735, -0.0181109756231308, -0.0063522146083414555, 0.002055279677733779, -0.044824350625276566, 0.01270299218595028, -0.003488629823550582, 0.0269307903945446, 0.01842483878135681, 0.005055386573076248, 0.0134278554469347, -0.014034696854650974, -0.01833743415772915, 0.0022829785011708736, 0.020409300923347473, -0.05584082752466202, 0.012394524179399014, 0.04206192120909691, -0.060941170901060104, -0.020247796550393105, 0.0005056689260527492, 0.02331535331904888, 0.032652463763952255, 0.007969343103468418, 0.013382330536842346, -0.02436278574168682, 0.0512281134724617, -0.00973484292626381, 0.021596472710371017, 0.0014502978883683681, 0.01242209691554308, -0.006457935087382793, -0.03484107181429863, -0.02202584780752659, -0.017962073907256126, 0.005458231084048748, 0.05301472172141075, -0.015300288796424866, 0.02517922967672348, -0.05246322602033615, 0.03690653666853905, -0.06206973269581795, 0.030855244025588036, 0.07255886495113373, 0.034630171954631805, 0.037121012806892395, 0.010373098775744438, -0.054313041269779205, -0.005897074472159147, -0.05073999986052513, 0.03630627691745758, 0.03175952285528183, -0.10756999254226685, 0.014131131581962109, 0.011103101074695587, -0.010323789902031422, 0.008387216366827488, 0.0665150061249733, 0.012580973096191883, 0.06990484893321991, -0.04349132627248764, 0.07793502509593964, 0.01925382763147354, -0.033430054783821106, 0.022038783878087997, 0.014555448666214943, 0.000892308889888227, 0.027150172740221024, -0.0050504147075116634, -0.021073997020721436, 0.024516018107533455, -0.053297050297260284, 0.022321153432130814, -0.020219575613737106, 0.034035708755254745, -0.017985759302973747, 0.015852170065045357, -0.061285119503736496, -0.060892120003700256, -0.0465148501098156, -0.03793920576572418, -0.03077017329633236, -0.05592884495854378, 0.05540376156568527, 0.003672544378787279, -0.02909129485487938, -0.0780518501996994, 0.02083631046116352, -0.007261256687343121, -0.004540569614619017, 0.015973102301359177, 0.04742841050028801, 0.02619876340031624, -0.000685563194565475, -0.028967294842004776, 0.06970588117837906, -0.029595404863357544, -0.03897295147180557, -0.0026756019797176123, -0.022956592962145805, 0.00854167714715004, -0.062159717082977295, 0.013438623398542404, 0.01131729781627655, 0.007689416408538818, 0.0781698152422905, 0.04758702963590622, 0.0004167636507190764, 0.03681159391999245, -0.019137639552354813, 0.0006721707177348435, 0.019229432567954063, -0.01794867403805256, -0.053465586155653, 0.020366309210658073, -0.01837167702615261, 0.013808430172502995, -0.04685300588607788, 0.02711937390267849, 0.017453905194997787, -0.008298488333821297, 0.0021342202089726925, 0.025816306471824646, 0.0018865878228098154, 0.016566859558224678, 0.021005403250455856, 0.04186135530471802, -0.022500120103359222, 0.06845736503601074, -0.0592203214764595, 0.0031218978110700846, -0.05462052300572395, -0.030965521931648254, -0.0013300895225256681, 0.0046569728292524815, -0.03270038962364197, -0.0035112393088638783, 0.05168719217181206, 0.0261265616863966, -0.0061260913498699665, 0.04548448324203491, 0.03210039436817169, -0.0048959688283503056, -0.03651442006230354, 0.003062908072024584, -0.029003029689192772, -0.023306146264076233, -0.011298425495624542, 0.02949516288936138, 0.04634993150830269, 0.032654158771038055, -0.002603044267743826, 0.021800901740789413, 0.01248815469443798, 0.04983466863632202, -0.06975803524255753, -0.025555817410349846, -0.021471958607435226, 0.023124821484088898, -0.027848174795508385, -0.05527665093541145, -0.07027192413806915, 0.00041713437531143427, 0.04986521601676941, -0.037229277193546295, 0.0248258113861084, -0.002229771576821804, -0.007408378180116415, -0.08924933522939682, 0.012278943322598934, -0.000490043603349477, -0.018011363223195076, -0.012051750905811787, -0.07567955553531647, -0.06406186521053314, -0.01814757101237774, -0.028632985427975655, 0.013582836836576462, -0.03896646201610565, 0.001860754331573844, 0.029604563489556313, -0.01329018920660019, 0.03564000874757767, -0.0006687503191642463, -0.008408555760979652, 0.06303291767835617, 0.030045412480831146, -0.03783288598060608, -0.03192153945565224, 0.033131085336208344, 0.023262394592165947, 0.07485352456569672, 0.0002598371065687388, 0.003927811048924923, 0.08227367699146271, -0.014797534793615341, -0.009268653579056263, 0.059399642050266266, 0.05218159779906273, -0.045664940029382706, -0.046820905059576035, -0.04264693707227707, -0.004266826435923576, 0.022823290899395943, 0.002337572630494833, 0.046671219170093536, 0.03517105430364609, 0.026165667921304703, 0.037147406488657, 0.021328486502170563, -0.005816157907247543, 0.007900434546172619, -0.018109673634171486, 0.034135133028030396, -0.037758488208055496, -0.008140760473906994, -0.011018074117600918, 0.03758826479315758, -0.007092841435223818, 0.01613597385585308, -0.016227789223194122, 0.057416465133428574, -0.04885620251297951, -0.036529891192913055, 0.003955550026148558, 0.030459726229310036, 0.0666365772485733, 0.04101180285215378, 0.009059173986315727, -0.0008440361707471311, -0.04059484228491783, -0.053148820996284485, -0.010017075575888157, 0.0004893065197393298, 0.009793896228075027, -0.01792827434837818, -0.058001693338155746, -0.01103273220360279, -0.033095359802246094, -0.07520212233066559, -0.00676435511559248, 0.009850799106061459, -0.023499224334955215, -0.03542559593915939, 0.0167123731225729, 0.026899024844169617, -0.02214990183711052, 0.04482097923755646, 0.009362020529806614, 0.021313415840268135, -0.016281861811876297, -0.025318574160337448, 0.01818622462451458, -0.043328508734703064, -0.02472292073071003, -0.03409094735980034, 0.0004130349843762815, -0.010645324364304543, 0.011437207460403442, -0.0336875282227993, -0.01750238798558712, -0.06128952279686928, 0.01304375659674406, 0.0276383887976408, 0.03707560896873474, 0.05514749139547348, -0.0021183365024626255, 0.013198351487517357, -0.003177420934662223, 0.012421496212482452, -0.026067787781357765, -0.04222999885678291, 0.020522359758615494, -0.009896649979054928, 0.04110686480998993, -0.03820376098155975, 0.0014746489468961954, -0.008997603319585323, -0.02002837508916855, -0.04427684471011162, 0.0013075725873932242, 0.0002883597044274211, -0.013207100331783295, -0.028404971584677696, -0.007762921042740345, -0.03389117866754532, 0.005338061135262251, 0.023475689813494682, 0.044270168989896774, 0.02356564998626709, 0.06347285211086273, 0.005057653412222862, -0.02524895779788494, -0.0047560096718370914, 0.01990104839205742, 0.008230254054069519, -0.008474298752844334, -0.06157780811190605, -0.008786643855273724, 0.018018346279859543, 0.05748554319143295, 0.0019561215303838253, -0.044424910098314285, -0.04843026027083397, -0.07600945979356766, 0.05929236114025116, 0.0549682192504406, -0.05882871523499489, 0.015141666866838932, 0.04711974039673805, 0.06412036716938019, -0.043111369013786316, -0.04031647369265556, -0.019910195842385292, -0.03417764976620674, 0.06296364963054657, 0.018877344205975533, -0.005956556648015976, 0.015520413406193256, 0.07309478521347046 ]
<p>I am comparing energy expenditure outputs from two devices that track physical activity in a free-living setting over 10 days. Doubly labeled water is the accepted criterion measurement for this, but 1) This technique only gives total energy expenditure and 2) I did not use this in my study...</p> <p>Both of the devices I used have previously been validated against DLW. These devices give a lot more information than DLW, namely time spent at specific PA thresholds and number of 'bouts' at each threshold. </p> <p>I would like to assess the level of agreement between the two devices. I know that Bland-Altman plots are commonly used to assess agreement between measuring devices but I am struggling to decide which test to use without a reference/criterion measurement. I would guess that a basic correlation would provide some information but was wondering if anybody could offer some more information and/or guidance for a more sophisticated statistical anaylsis. Maybe a regression / sum of squares would be appropriated?</p> <p>Any help would be much appreciated.</p>
g74055
[ 0.00527887511998415, -0.0292387492954731, -0.01683017797768116, -0.005125000607222319, -0.0426633358001709, -0.034050047397613525, 0.07436966150999069, -0.03135262057185173, -0.010295539163053036, -0.018217092379927635, 0.06361369043588638, 0.027557529509067535, 0.02485823445022106, 0.01191653497517109, -0.05147380754351616, -0.055744968354701996, 0.049617499113082886, -0.05572362244129181, 0.04605707898736, 0.02181793935596943, -0.011550327762961388, 0.03509030118584633, -0.04607228934764862, -0.013198666274547577, -0.06035081297159195, -0.0990840420126915, 0.0011290023103356361, 0.035930585116147995, -0.030086558312177658, -0.022330034524202347, 0.003122535301372409, 0.024290960282087326, 0.028355227783322334, -0.006875726394355297, -0.05870947241783142, 0.010378440842032433, 0.04304150119423866, 0.03001885674893856, -0.05420353636145592, 0.04517089203000069, 0.003659034613519907, 0.03851940855383873, 0.02546711266040802, 0.052389539778232574, 0.014261079020798206, 0.003973921295255423, -0.009168162010610104, -0.026056412607431412, 0.02934529073536396, 0.011960186995565891, -0.006661074236035347, 0.021113509312272072, 0.001400362583808601, -0.03171403706073761, 0.019183732569217682, 0.0031270349863916636, -0.09023411571979523, 0.003127321135252714, -0.03925442323088646, 0.013829659670591354, 0.004939715377986431, 0.011359763331711292, -0.02520434744656086, 0.004961525555700064, 0.04125320166349411, 0.0003921968745999038, 0.010232021100819111, -0.03651130944490433, -0.010000976733863354, -0.019772140309214592, 0.02567865513265133, -0.06643182784318924, 0.0202412661164999, 0.015457423403859138, 0.036230918020009995, -0.02796798013150692, -0.02311713993549347, -0.028688330203294754, 0.029125306755304337, 0.020137250423431396, -0.0040533230639994144, -0.024565760046243668, 0.04459952190518379, 0.10515033453702927, 0.08619681000709534, -0.03368687629699707, -0.016834167763590813, -0.015194898471236229, 0.05215722322463989, 0.04852352291345596, 0.00594077305868268, 0.029264869168400764, 0.0530962198972702, 0.036643702536821365, -0.04796154797077179, -0.0019643050618469715, 0.016750749200582504, 0.03710746392607689, -0.005239477381110191, 0.04246923327445984, -0.0075627900660037994, 0.009017611853778362, -0.00893629714846611, 0.010948793031275272, 0.015762489289045334, -0.060203153640031815, 0.003297286108136177, 0.005626225844025612, -0.06873750686645508, -0.037179429084062576, -0.03879101946949959, 0.04032919183373451, 0.0030101414304226637, -0.01884404756128788, 0.01698475331068039, -0.07330439239740372, 0.02407502755522728, -0.005846863146871328, -0.030678311362862587, -0.08501005172729492, 0.009651568718254566, -0.0034803273156285286, 0.013237272389233112, 0.029874548316001892, -0.010951556265354156, -0.02123429626226425, -0.05535639449954033, -0.006652040407061577, -0.030210021883249283, 0.05611169710755348, -0.00480406591668725, -0.022591613233089447, -0.029593342915177345, 0.0013764805626124144, -0.01320563443005085, 0.009520166553556919, 0.03210211917757988, -0.02709558792412281, -0.06313750892877579, -0.022083168849349022, -0.009591036476194859, -0.0016475743614137173, -0.00938199833035469, 0.0007409579702652991, -0.0012258889619261026, 0.06422934681177139, 0.014385460875928402, -0.06663910299539566, 0.03882325440645218, 0.0631098598241806, 0.025876816362142563, 0.017872614786028862, -0.022021165117621422, -0.008155366405844688, 0.004752473905682564, -0.026494527235627174, -0.04852893203496933, -0.038409776985645294, -0.03139843791723251, 0.06825853884220123, 0.01293690875172615, 0.00871329102665186, 0.0790478065609932, 0.03565055504441261, 0.03492235019803047, -0.03498854860663414, 0.039356011897325516, -0.01447787880897522, 0.05759154632687569, -0.05781345069408417, 0.00557900732383132, -0.01087888516485691, -0.0037410473451018333, -0.03917980194091797, -0.008137291297316551, 0.05154037848114967, -0.00987869780510664, -0.007905618287622929, 0.03705620765686035, -0.025404267013072968, 0.009461303241550922, 0.06722380220890045, 0.03752471134066582, 0.03562859073281288, -0.05776136741042137, 0.011139602400362492, 0.06798885017633438, -0.08397763222455978, -0.06265705078840256, 0.010797563940286636, 0.008824440650641918, 0.002823484130203724, -0.03966553509235382, -0.005075117573142052, -0.05707256495952606, 0.02626885287463665, 0.033145200461149216, -0.03289846330881119, 0.07854647934436798, -0.10075046122074127, 0.0015346896834671497, -0.028065906837582588, -0.025199417024850845, 0.0028088781982660294, 0.013348285108804703, -0.02111225202679634, 0.034064341336488724, -0.07880045473575592, -0.01538017950952053, -0.033698368817567825, 0.0002075181546388194, 0.0645342543721199, -0.08516396582126617, 0.016285033896565437, 0.03652846813201904, -0.014959177933633327, -0.015358055010437965, 0.017440298572182655, -0.024148695170879364, -0.01438878569751978, -0.041958313435316086, -0.001900705974549055, 0.03348515182733536, -0.008157311007380486, -0.00008123116276692599, -0.01781642623245716, -0.019939415156841278, 0.030339356511831284, -0.033890195190906525, 0.015125969424843788, -0.01419326663017273, -0.008812609128654003, 0.03264628350734711, -0.003018583869561553, 0.021612752228975296, 0.007274378556758165, 0.023470550775527954, -0.043374598026275635, 0.009299226105213165, 0.02182088978588581, 0.010512102395296097, -0.008111536502838135, -0.03636940196156502, 0.022255336865782738, 0.005555433686822653, -0.0003091400722041726, -0.0025117655750364065, 0.02841351181268692, 0.01151704229414463, 0.04724832624197006, -0.035963933914899826, 0.054340049624443054, -0.010176585055887699, 0.01640181802213192, 0.00978895928710699, 0.04246865212917328, 0.03700273856520653, -0.022070283070206642, -0.029109284281730652, 0.015296769328415394, -0.02156836912035942, -0.026274237781763077, 0.01877458207309246, 0.04317663609981537, 0.02287714183330536, -0.1023445874452591, -0.000125472157378681, -0.03707250952720642, 0.0019439756870269775, -0.07496211677789688, 0.023413002490997314, 0.010509000159800053, 0.0377577468752861, 0.016272515058517456, 0.014344315975904465, 0.04210162162780762, 0.033022377640008926, -0.008909141644835472, 0.03994014114141464, -0.010970781557261944, 0.03208004683256149, 0.009456767700612545, -0.02161877229809761, 0.02779853530228138, 0.05641957372426987, -0.002366836881265044, 0.037579141557216644, -0.0032160994596779346, -0.019045082852244377, 0.01878483034670353, 0.02087542600929737, 0.028421297669410706, -0.05967068299651146, 0.000966969586443156, -0.03794916719198227, -0.0057326313108205795, 0.0536048524081707, -0.017574092373251915, 0.07445691525936127, 0.019615691155195236, 0.0015480738366022706, 0.006733444519340992, -0.003000571159645915, 0.035749178379774094, 0.030636776238679886, -0.012051401659846306, -0.05074511468410492, -0.0454929955303669, 0.004289879463613033, -0.006291833706200123, -0.007127359509468079, -0.047715913504362106, -0.015970692038536072, -0.019571179524064064, 0.0070624807849526405, -0.019800914451479912, 0.03706676512956619, -0.01187948975712061, 0.0022006065119057894, 0.0004232715582475066, 0.038010165095329285, 0.029542483389377594, 0.03496769815683365, -0.003096075262874365, -0.05081678926944733, -0.014665985479950905, -0.013097246177494526, -0.00047929605352692306, -0.07753001898527145, 0.06872379034757614, 0.013749025762081146, 0.05937059223651886, -0.01350709144026041, -0.011771494522690773, -0.019485492259263992, -0.04418785125017166, -0.003342593554407358, -0.005618826020509005, -0.0014280161121860147, 0.058814484626054764, -0.05190427973866463, 0.05562115088105202, -0.024227183312177658, -0.057031553238630295, 0.009546870365738869, 0.021931106224656105, -0.024612776935100555, 0.0031461897306144238, -0.04075483977794647, -0.005219761747866869, 0.03791676089167595, -0.004683858714997768, -0.020293856039643288, -0.026861626654863358, 0.042494792491197586, -0.03255542367696762, 0.004488666076213121, 0.020827999338507652, -0.06191810593008995, -0.014575814828276634, 0.028668779879808426, 0.05402978137135506, -0.021265646442770958, -0.03863704577088356, -0.020387496799230576, 0.005491245537996292, -0.028039826080203056, 0.049745310097932816, -0.02322022244334221, -0.0751030296087265, 0.00858902558684349, 0.02360684983432293, -0.005591964814811945, 0.010492789559066296, -0.024983666837215424, 0.002276892773807049, 0.06302426755428314, 0.024610135704278946, -0.0014790851855650544, 0.09144559502601624, 0.0020875369664281607, 0.017799729481339455, -0.029407991096377373, 0.03696795552968979, -0.04350539296865463, -0.10713401436805725, -0.019568156450986862, 0.024321794509887695, 0.030192678794264793, -0.0025800224393606186, -0.004210026003420353, -0.05520069599151611, -0.05557892844080925, 0.04872149974107742, 0.031368888914585114, -0.01422690786421299, 0.06068921834230423, 0.057084277272224426, 0.056229278445243835, 0.09239736944437027, 0.019323591142892838, 0.0407114177942276, -0.0011034918716177344, 0.0009087969665415585, -0.03166874125599861, -0.0018464273307472467, -0.018214067444205284, -0.04809146746993065, -0.031341712921857834, -0.05499976873397827, -0.0257532000541687, 0.03257736563682556, -0.0027153717819601297, 0.006062960717827082, 0.00354884285479784, 0.009724919684231281, -0.022921890020370483, -0.017352202907204628, 0.03807514160871506, 0.029017021879553795, -0.0485164113342762, 0.030720606446266174, -0.002216945169493556, -0.00820593535900116, -0.04055578261613846, 0.03281433880329132, -0.0218302384018898, 0.03838468715548515, -0.018576689064502716, -0.009958913549780846, 0.03603477030992508, 0.0223387461155653, -0.0029540061950683594, 0.03114328533411026, 0.026669172570109367, 0.02801728993654251, 0.013386378064751625, 0.04545613005757332, 0.024126620963215828, -0.05506587773561478, -0.030815133824944496, -0.0350605733692646, 0.02726140059530735, -0.029252681881189346, -0.005832299590110779, 0.06435300409793854, -0.03650972619652748, -0.03977213054895401, 0.03186997026205063, 0.012554183602333069, -0.002825153525918722, 0.06894748657941818, 0.03913063555955887, -0.01802530139684677, -0.04870588704943657, 0.05059150978922844, 0.016458291560411453, 0.0438680425286293, 0.001584884012117982, 0.019433556124567986, -0.037077438086271286, -0.044589653611183167, 0.021071407943964005, -0.04742475226521492, -0.011643260717391968, -0.013436062261462212, -0.02017935737967491, 0.020157882943749428, -0.042984187602996826, 0.0074768527410924435, 0.004301558248698711, -0.030485671013593674, 0.012545631267130375, 0.026028383523225784, -0.04782512038946152, -0.01442796178162098, -0.01628708653151989, -0.04600081220269203, -0.03837091103196144, 0.010028600692749023, -0.029788780957460403, 0.011730184778571129, -0.018828976899385452, -0.0067848507314920425, 0.04619280621409416, 0.0006307982257567346, -0.02152523770928383, -0.042252060025930405, 0.06334780901670456, 0.013146406039595604, 0.023214247077703476, -0.0326848067343235, 0.03729568421840668, -0.02077859826385975, -0.006204028148204088, 0.08678466081619263, 0.024569697678089142, -0.03160880133509636, -0.04384102299809456, 0.0328356996178627, -0.018702836707234383, 0.08330727368593216, 0.022945677861571312, -0.01793304830789566, 0.03067474439740181, 0.002145916223526001, 0.019895827397704124, -0.012317598797380924, 0.021006006747484207, 0.08886561542749405, -0.06634633243083954, 0.013590265065431595, -0.021121524274349213, 0.0281483493745327, -0.0021375727374106646, 0.04676606133580208, 0.07534302026033401, 0.048281118273735046, -0.025178438052535057, -0.019379012286663055, 0.08107951283454895, -0.016191501170396805, 0.005833098199218512, 0.030525969341397285, 0.020315255969762802, -0.07788189500570297, -0.018502622842788696, 0.019700994715094566, 0.02602532133460045, -0.028393371030688286, 0.054726872593164444, 0.039658378809690475, 0.015211802907288074, 0.0538940355181694, -0.004319849424064159, -0.041169751435518265, -0.05018170177936554, -0.03673417121171951, 0.03250059857964516, -0.0039008823223412037, -0.0498260036110878, 0.008797407150268555, 0.03262728080153465, -0.0193477813154459, -0.008283848874270916, 0.030402136966586113, 0.013986244797706604, -0.02244419790804386, -0.02679426036775112, -0.012996688485145569, -0.009008282795548439, 0.04290870204567909, -0.003977700602263212, -0.02129105105996132, 0.023888757452368736, -0.04699790105223656, 0.0787985548377037, 0.021032417193055153, -0.012049758806824684, 0.02442682720720768, 0.006838930770754814, -0.029564451426267624, 0.04622736573219299, 0.07478407770395279, 0.03383850306272507, -0.04650026932358742, -0.015663379803299904, -0.052200835198163986, -0.09454771131277084, -0.008354340679943562, 0.03511413186788559, -0.044024813920259476, 0.008322758600115776, -0.003717999439686537, -0.028079135343432426, 0.030312392860651016, 0.01073766965419054, 0.03811373561620712, 0.05588622763752937, 0.015912536531686783, 0.018015483394265175, 0.020915180444717407, -0.00843200646340847, 0.010512249544262886, 0.03300916776061058, 0.0464014932513237, -0.030575739219784737, 0.019866589456796646, -0.09664247930049896, -0.013408837839961052, -0.027884408831596375, -0.03500264510512352, 0.017248017713427544, -0.032666683197021484, -0.021499954164028168, -0.04832205921411514, -0.025900578126311302, -0.0032322080805897713, -0.00532493693754077, 0.009662487544119358, -0.04148786514997482, -0.03617917001247406, -0.0017272758996114135, -0.055206283926963806, -0.009645668789744377, 0.027148010209202766, 0.018224472180008888, -0.01387520506978035, -0.013448825106024742, -0.04328910633921623, -0.03331521153450012, 0.026981249451637268, 0.07007188349962234, 0.061961233615875244, 0.01457514613866806, -0.0002816735068336129, -0.038576964288949966, -0.024091273546218872, -0.06787053495645523, 0.03904180973768234, 0.07045096904039383, 0.007850668393075466, 0.008781957440078259, -0.0288890041410923, 0.00017824425594881177, 0.0032951468601822853, -0.006076008081436157, 0.035816747695207596, -0.04479434713721275, 0.016680778935551643, -0.03213873133063316, 0.0037924398202449083, -0.05462558940052986, 0.018426723778247833, -0.030928492546081543, 0.05824250727891922, -0.023904094472527504, 0.01623912900686264, 0.020240038633346558, 0.02285514771938324, -0.038147591054439545, 0.0353066623210907, 0.006024347618222237, 0.01485487911850214, -0.014785021543502808, -0.0034698343370109797, 0.033539313822984695, -0.002639902988448739, 0.003086566226556897, 0.04992236569523811, -0.0358244851231575, -0.04436967149376869, 0.037225812673568726, -0.05163460224866867, 0.009326253086328506, 0.07660366594791412, -0.016464127227663994, 0.004778190515935421, -0.009550473652780056, -0.009264997206628323, 0.02314961515367031, -0.05314762890338898, -0.01874973066151142, 0.013761510141193867, -0.006791059393435717, -0.014772200956940651, -0.06012384966015816, -0.010699224658310413, -0.002723965561017394, -0.06582950800657272, 0.08554363250732422, -0.026958968490362167, -0.03793765604496002, 0.04357330873608589, 0.048569127917289734, -0.004866901319473982, -0.004263200331479311, -0.031583257019519806, -0.055887620896101, -0.027112824842333794, -0.01098120678216219, -0.10320578515529633, 0.004900598432868719, 0.049079377204179764, -0.07476889342069626, 0.0626610592007637, 0.013288762420415878, -0.009686248376965523, 0.06980554759502411, 0.02934572659432888, -0.08679214119911194, -0.02595355547964573, 0.030495358631014824, 0.016610335558652878, 0.011355367489159107, -0.031865134835243225, 0.017046278342604637, -0.012593443505465984, 0.023589394986629486, -0.016153885051608086, 0.02600686624646187, 0.049588948488235474, -0.061961062252521515, 0.04765539988875389, 0.01479724794626236, 0.03558537736535072, 0.04959696903824806, -0.04443598911166191, -0.004152124281972647, -0.017490291967988014, -0.008900266140699387, 0.03526545688509941, -0.035318829119205475, -0.013312133960425854, 0.012108886614441872, -0.0035193327348679304, -0.060746513307094574, -0.01737911067903042, 0.050201259553432465, 0.02693801186978817, 0.01046015229076147, 0.02411871962249279, -0.023934833705425262, 0.0034133607987314463, 0.007321043871343136, -0.04064161702990532, -0.03213508427143097, 0.04796312376856804, -0.0002588795905467123, 0.019490420818328857, -0.028816567733883858, -0.060529790818691254, -0.030211687088012695, 0.024469833821058273, -0.042542703449726105, -0.0326363667845726, 0.06417182087898254, 0.08511828631162643, -0.07643421739339828, 0.007687688805162907, 0.012921293266117573, 0.0009240982471965253, -0.010900129564106464, -0.01568044349551201, -0.025137657299637794, -0.09801904112100601, 0.015116475522518158, 0.04830671846866608, 0.04866163432598114, -0.08251520246267319, -0.0027807853184640408, 0.006136162206530571, -0.03853602707386017, 0.009340113960206509, -0.01738971658051014, 0.03587332367897034, -0.002862627385184169, -0.026481077075004578, 0.02427903190255165, 0.034925296902656555, -0.009726030752062798, -0.06146432086825371, 0.0015243482775986195, 0.01211740542203188, -0.03962225466966629, 0.021470608189702034, -0.016157101839780807, 0.022867051884531975 ]
<p>I've used chi-square analysis in school, but was absent for the lesson, and I never quite got the hang of it. I've been successful with it in the past, but now I'm trying to use percentage values, and I'm not getting the answers I'm expecting. I'm doing a survey and comparing my findings with national averages, but when I use percentages (such as the percent of participants between the ages of 21 and 29) I get understandably tiny numbers (2.3% is 0.023). If I'm using percentages for the expected value, should it matter?</p> <p>Ex: Chi² for 21–29 age group is $(.084 - 0.1642)^2 / 0.1642 = .039187$</p> <p>The total chi-square value is 0.1368, which is much smaller than the 0.5% chi squared table value for 8 degrees of freedom, 17.535, but the numbers seem way off. Do I have to find the whole numbers?</p>
g74056
[ -0.004087010398507118, 0.014878521673381329, 0.016672074794769287, -0.010677793063223362, 0.014608758501708508, -0.053350452333688736, 0.02867492474615574, -0.008219914510846138, 0.028595782816410065, -0.020310617983341217, -0.007519784849137068, -0.023702524602413177, 0.028010377660393715, 0.00439265975728631, -0.0188582893460989, 0.01239694096148014, -0.01083865761756897, -0.03612740337848663, 0.015469645150005817, 0.10795458406209946, -0.00771211227402091, -0.014292658306658268, 0.024324966594576836, -0.042423322796821594, 0.002459850162267685, -0.006541505455970764, -0.012140858918428421, 0.023866211995482445, -0.0929211899638176, 0.04688259959220886, -0.024985672906041145, 0.0007450419943779707, 0.08614788204431534, -0.016889942809939384, -0.07461114972829819, 0.019680924713611603, 0.03896665573120117, 0.003207660047337413, 0.0026574451476335526, 0.01074240729212761, 0.017943106591701508, -0.017273886129260063, -0.024041015654802322, 0.01305724773555994, -0.030606022104620934, 0.024461276829242706, -0.008794089779257774, 0.008673612959682941, 0.0027939423453062773, 0.01884623058140278, -0.055222250521183014, 0.008034015074372292, 0.08783936500549316, 0.062679722905159, -0.00875330064445734, 0.04768243059515953, 0.05126601457595825, 0.0026031790766865015, 0.028255868703126907, 0.02457047440111637, 0.006264926865696907, 0.01657002419233322, -0.020461702719330788, -0.017359886318445206, 0.010709485970437527, 0.0489511713385582, -0.02771243266761303, -0.03026294894516468, -0.041884176433086395, -0.05941509082913399, -0.028121009469032288, -0.016146836802363396, 0.013260219246149063, -0.042344771325588226, -0.06403102725744247, -0.08068864047527313, 0.0313202403485775, -0.026601159945130348, -0.0029205181635916233, 0.042795877903699875, 0.004414597991853952, -0.009091012179851532, 0.011434412561357021, -0.008911147713661194, 0.03510529547929764, 0.024979425594210625, -0.006432496476918459, -0.04825007915496826, -0.03214092180132866, 0.061932243406772614, 0.009926549158990383, 0.02596248872578144, 0.020445456728339195, 0.010552668012678623, 0.007041346747428179, -0.0060777380131185055, 0.008880284614861012, -0.00564910750836134, 0.04320428520441055, 0.046734873205423355, -0.04167211428284645, 0.006507739424705505, -0.012346670962870121, -0.008653986267745495, -0.06957489252090454, 0.022694580256938934, 0.07318408042192459, 0.07407616078853607, -0.017512433230876923, 0.00868177879601717, -0.05084547400474548, 0.012710558250546455, -0.05255008488893509, -0.035824283957481384, 0.007829719223082066, -0.037472233176231384, 0.010519386269152164, -0.018470987677574158, 0.014675992541015148, -0.0012646407121792436, 0.028144996613264084, 0.05456608161330223, 0.05226092040538788, 0.010904558002948761, 0.006418682634830475, -0.029202785342931747, -0.012543908320367336, 0.05582869425415993, 0.039307817816734314, -0.007102073170244694, -0.04469771683216095, -0.0025060949847102165, -0.03828352689743042, 0.0009240075014531612, 0.01661083847284317, 0.07562337070703506, -0.052694838494062424, 0.05996506288647652, -0.013574845157563686, 0.009242325089871883, -0.022093405947089195, 0.029070911929011345, 0.050375163555145264, -0.07117484509944916, 0.006905534770339727, 0.016154449433088303, -0.04551884904503822, 0.001470739021897316, -0.004623245447874069, 0.01057859044522047, -0.0001954864856088534, -0.021562105044722557, 0.020192688331007957, 0.01466639805585146, -0.10478372871875763, 0.0225889440625906, -0.0234377384185791, 0.02057291381061077, -0.027034617960453033, -0.027563689276576042, 0.035800475627183914, 0.015550647862255573, 0.052098702639341354, 0.003434329992160201, -0.01236505527049303, -0.00293154688552022, -0.03543641418218613, -0.07707405835390091, 0.00970566924661398, 0.011620224453508854, 0.013324958272278309, -0.02336190454661846, -0.009703065268695354, -0.02677243761718273, -0.00870318990200758, 0.030676884576678276, 0.10434550046920776, -0.023181810975074768, 0.05956537276506424, 0.0485447458922863, 0.02275419607758522, 0.00563409086316824, 0.0163286030292511, -0.03333797678351402, 0.015606480650603771, -0.07934059947729111, 0.03148070350289345, 0.0206074770539999, -0.01031282264739275, 0.009911532513797283, 0.006578202359378338, -0.11121761053800583, -0.07766587287187576, 0.022618547081947327, 0.02628086879849434, -0.01332977693527937, -0.005999385379254818, 0.028086761012673378, -0.07916930317878723, 0.024554332718253136, 0.03223634511232376, 0.021675288677215576, 0.04461033642292023, -0.031554024666547775, 0.005316670518368483, 0.02619895339012146, -0.0472264438867569, 0.0050136735662817955, -0.02022738568484783, 0.008647819980978966, 0.01715821959078312, -0.014551940374076366, -0.030183561146259308, 0.1123938336968422, -0.044650495052337646, 0.015226949006319046, 0.021667279303073883, 0.019948123022913933, 0.007091476581990719, -0.0014262654585763812, -0.04869956150650978, -0.015007824636995792, 0.041672687977552414, -0.004265260882675648, 0.05413339287042618, 0.049088336527347565, -0.036526452749967575, 0.006456700153648853, 0.034607257694005966, 0.0539112351834774, -0.04958475008606911, 0.03473760560154915, 0.018984753638505936, -0.011887202039361, 0.02733689360320568, -0.010432274080812931, 0.007669131271541119, 0.017220454290509224, 0.008030974306166172, 0.027098948135972023, -0.038560621440410614, 0.004531358368694782, 0.04398469999432564, 0.03695027902722359, 0.035313930362463, 0.014701607637107372, -0.032403189688920975, -0.04174444079399109, -0.03806953504681587, -0.028618814423680305, -0.02837337739765644, 0.022733205929398537, -0.03680669888854027, 0.02144639566540718, -0.000018938300854642875, -0.019860271364450455, 0.005435433238744736, -0.014377867802977562, 0.003720677923411131, -0.02017342671751976, -0.03395308181643486, -0.04771002382040024, -0.0007201329572126269, 0.0005175375263206661, 0.012362965382635593, -0.011797360144555569, -0.010598394088447094, -0.008697799406945705, 0.007210915442556143, -0.016434550285339355, -0.011494556441903114, 0.10102508962154388, -0.0308645348995924, 0.09395743161439896, 0.024143477901816368, -0.12645569443702698, -0.014055461622774601, 0.0000832923615234904, 0.019730407744646072, -0.013555283658206463, 0.024430908262729645, 0.0125668840482831, -0.012211566790938377, 0.05675410106778145, 0.04345310479402542, 0.00295260944403708, 0.00034678447991609573, -0.011882835999131203, -0.009638386778533459, 0.02596733719110489, -0.023809807375073433, -0.003753834404051304, 0.015501067042350769, -0.0029685241170227528, 0.057724930346012115, -0.02562030218541622, 0.04832015559077263, -0.07783982902765274, 0.021051712334156036, 0.024485595524311066, 0.011605809442698956, -0.0041593220084905624, -0.014046690426766872, -0.002511334605515003, -0.025498222559690475, 0.008167465217411518, 0.021560056135058403, -0.0358402319252491, -0.02830667607486248, -0.009403705596923828, 0.039976686239242554, -0.005582357756793499, -0.018831755965948105, -0.028374940156936646, -0.05538777634501457, -0.003338740672916174, -0.0020811273716390133, 0.0025446168147027493, 0.004909075330942869, 0.03348478674888611, -0.0033567335922271013, -0.04488983377814293, 0.01648073084652424, 0.045168038457632065, 0.027181578800082207, 0.011944862082600594, -0.006272898055613041, 0.020574649795889854, -0.05311610549688339, -0.050463978201150894, 0.03385226055979729, -0.008407561108469963, -0.027098754420876503, 0.02119484171271324, -0.011029808782041073, -0.06313113868236542, -0.0077788992784917355, -0.06663060933351517, 0.028903406113386154, -0.00876424927264452, -0.05227123945951462, 0.01947183720767498, -0.0005056786467321217, -0.008629413321614265, -0.0168091282248497, -0.09370002895593643, -0.015330477617681026, 0.0011401637457311153, -0.036212652921676636, -0.00885473471134901, 0.013569464907050133, -0.029725132510066032, -0.05153929069638252, 0.017727216705679893, 0.03174697235226631, -0.0027046382892876863, 0.06678705662488937, 0.005306269507855177, -0.017897702753543854, 0.05626426264643669, 0.022477539256215096, 0.016280535608530045, 0.021467827260494232, 0.008613568730652332, 0.020021339878439903, 0.023668475449085236, 0.013026228174567223, 0.025106176733970642, -0.0006348988390527666, -0.007143924478441477, -0.043900515884160995, 0.01845121942460537, 0.05580267682671547, 0.039627641439437866, -0.012843630276620388, -0.05436436086893082, 0.05040143057703972, 0.018209785223007202, 0.02691316418349743, -0.024876700714230537, 0.015155291184782982, 0.03232363611459732, -0.028627855703234673, -0.06313411146402359, -0.015778565779328346, -0.058092840015888214, 0.016908841207623482, -0.015649933367967606, -0.03357745334506035, -0.05815552547574043, 0.050426896661520004, -0.04234044998884201, -0.01061815395951271, 0.09087643027305603, -0.0008553602965548635, -0.039494603872299194, -0.02905353158712387, 0.013667894527316093, 0.013356341049075127, 0.0482022650539875, -0.04559379816055298, 0.009295772761106491, 0.044240862131118774, 0.02255644090473652, 0.07788914442062378, 0.0026701262686401606, -0.02555311843752861, -0.012478743679821491, -0.006083958316594362, 0.02488512545824051, -0.02154051512479782, -0.032553818076848984, 0.00834120623767376, -0.054055213928222656, 0.033071815967559814, 0.03604394942522049, -0.019664902240037918, -0.06509294360876083, -0.0307730995118618, -0.000306409114273265, 0.018231241032481194, -0.017973175272345543, -0.03883865475654602, 0.022755339741706848, -0.004174370318651199, 0.015938743948936462, 0.020849859341979027, 0.028898658230900764, 0.043102115392684937, 0.007912596687674522, -0.006992224138230085, 0.033151913434267044, -0.009628205560147762, -0.027834327891469002, 0.027313891798257828, -0.0004652288625948131, 0.02872316911816597, 0.027857743203639984, -0.018476465716958046, 0.0023319574538618326, -0.06749475747346878, 0.06338141113519669, -0.05249049887061119, 0.014080868102610111, -0.03027690201997757, -0.011314090341329575, -0.07470518350601196, -0.015621844679117203, 0.010475298389792442, 0.013801589608192444, 0.017594410106539726, 0.002498144982382655, -0.04350607097148895, -0.00738880317658186, 0.04068148136138916, -0.037170492112636566, -0.0055137984454631805, 0.035835761576890945, 0.03413965180516243, 0.052219949662685394, -0.009307840839028358, -0.08274943381547928, -0.009343157522380352, -0.008092518895864487, 0.014845086261630058, 0.013071506284177303, 0.021068602800369263, 0.0016463040374219418, 0.005374500527977943, -0.008963719010353088, -0.05270665884017944, 0.003054992528632283, 0.04410581663250923, 0.0005183344474062324, -0.04565773531794548, 0.0289539135992527, 0.01891072280704975, 0.026039844378829002, 0.015715371817350388, 0.002733279252424836, -0.03800287842750549, -0.031511347740888596, 0.06627664715051651, 0.06241181492805481, 0.020817214623093605, -0.04772750660777092, 0.010140913538634777, -0.020740997046232224, 0.07159781455993652, -0.02202446758747101, 0.05051527917385101, 0.03088981844484806, 0.01821332983672619, -0.04661876708269119, -0.02952931821346283, -0.07286477088928223, 0.07193943858146667, -0.07889144122600555, -0.00009507255890639499, -0.02715933695435524, -0.016632085666060448, 0.09489675611257553, -0.05446895956993103, 0.006008854601532221, -0.00004525906115304679, -0.009354325011372566, 0.014462489634752274, -0.07972978800535202, -0.020359130576252937, 0.040706295520067215, 0.016186349093914032, -0.029596786946058273, 0.05960144102573395, -0.049364108592271805, -0.060498740524053574, -0.009456762112677097, 0.012955964542925358, 0.031394969671964645, 0.032174985855817795, 0.054485537111759186, 0.08369709551334381, 0.013045313768088818, -0.03324812650680542, 0.031154312193393707, 0.036622896790504456, -0.02370351552963257, 0.02459651604294777, -0.06429515779018402, 0.06791359931230545, -0.0009343245765194297, 0.005198522470891476, 0.021142199635505676, 0.0029839726630598307, 0.017890945076942444, 0.0011996999382972717, 0.035055797547101974, -0.06826082617044449, -0.004824685398489237, 0.0814620777964592, 0.006116436794400215, -0.04324024170637131, 0.02486388199031353, 0.0358114168047905, 0.02675914764404297, -0.009035727940499783, 0.0020524419378489256, 0.02360970713198185, -0.017836065962910652, 0.014138435013592243, 0.04591693729162216, 0.01905832625925541, 0.07185332477092743, 0.020780110731720924, -0.01167446281760931, -0.02233975939452648, 0.0365028940141201, 0.016810880973935127, 0.02993396297097206, 0.016310393810272217, -0.0053900727070868015, 0.005520912352949381, -0.028720902279019356, 0.0019698254764080048, 0.060340169817209244, 0.029257293790578842, 0.006840175949037075, -0.016039501875638962, -0.03959554433822632, -0.034374676644802094, 0.009502959437668324, -0.00542114581912756, -0.03191020339727402, 0.023040760308504105, 0.008772594854235649, -0.028526727110147476, 0.036047715693712234, -0.06321895122528076, -0.012091654352843761, -0.0070405201986432076, 0.02876218408346176, -0.006672179326415062, -0.03617183491587639, -0.005744480062276125, -0.0049324193969368935, 0.0036555947735905647, 0.032071299850940704, 0.001905063516460359, -0.010655978694558144, -0.015126622281968594, -0.014845412224531174, -0.028993094339966774, 0.050138916820287704, -0.023471307009458542, 0.04163103178143501, -0.000970472814515233, -0.05772433057427406, 0.011018797755241394, -0.021794281899929047, -0.06797805428504944, -0.04482962191104889, -0.004800307098776102, -0.02160848304629326, 0.036047372967004776, -0.02578902058303356, 0.019954651594161987, -0.04936450347304344, 0.037169914692640305, -0.00972954835742712, -0.02171451598405838, -0.01295290794223547, -0.06866230070590973, 0.05018855258822441, -0.033074118196964264, 0.04761900007724762, 0.05371938645839691, -0.06452156603336334, -0.017419230192899704, -0.020862452685832977, -0.0387435257434845, -0.07104729115962982, 0.016359832137823105, 0.00040952544077299535, -0.029951192438602448, -0.06000184640288353, 0.03566993400454521, 0.06033021956682205, -0.017287185415625572, 0.0004818238958250731, 0.05502248555421829, 0.026308145374059677, 0.020723536610603333, -0.01882726512849331, 0.046474941074848175, 0.00514000141993165, -0.04516012594103813, 0.05865621566772461, -0.03724392503499985, 0.030004050582647324, 0.043351735919713974, 0.020639879629015923, 0.0035811455454677343, -0.002452784450724721, -0.005492555908858776, 0.002783960197120905, -0.020003890618681908, -0.021809929981827736, -0.03777337819337845, 0.013275465928018093, -0.04355045035481453, 0.024106435477733612, 0.05426150932908058, 0.017870010808110237, -0.0223122276365757, -0.11159809678792953, 0.016552133485674858, -0.0033116773702204227, 0.0366843044757843, -0.030330227687954903, 0.044666748493909836, -0.062373943626880646, -0.01703716814517975, 0.006460583768785, -0.027369501069188118, 0.0500413216650486, -0.06299859285354614, 0.009145920164883137, 0.012906952761113644, 0.056156814098358154, 0.01630808785557747, -0.07737426459789276, -0.01340364757925272, -0.006320333573967218, -0.07380983978509903, 0.030940933153033257, 0.03691277652978897, 0.02414669468998909, -0.020721333101391792, -0.04953844100236893, 0.02388083189725876, 0.059901416301727295, 0.07031205296516418, -0.062346845865249634, -0.007293312344700098, 0.005351684056222439, -0.044579412788152695, 0.02819095551967621, -0.03445468842983246, -0.06434160470962524, 0.05120948329567909, -0.006299826316535473, -0.018817422911524773, -0.07249192893505096, 0.01448550634086132, -0.026717301458120346, -0.016690796241164207, -0.03693538159132004, 0.023776456713676453, 0.03430813178420067, 0.04489608854055405, 0.06310319155454636, 0.02508046291768551, -0.01374773494899273, 0.009785579517483711, -0.016261231154203415, 0.020055288448929787, 0.07484842836856842, 0.017143329605460167, -0.06076304614543915, -0.0379762127995491, -0.05314142629504204, -0.012889471836388111, 0.040803223848342896, 0.05579078197479248, -0.018481090664863586, 0.0476350300014019, -0.03846450522542, 0.002494129352271557, -0.037222810089588165, -0.021830672398209572, -0.03417636826634407, -0.06098012626171112, -0.013061050325632095, 0.011838281527161598, -0.04954463616013527, -0.0031403684988617897, -0.017357531934976578, -0.04475739970803261, 0.04091044142842293, -0.010874968022108078, 0.0043657016940414906, -0.04054536297917366, 0.011879716999828815, -0.0603710301220417, 0.043589912354946136, 0.0014726289082318544, -0.014161435887217522, 0.04076738283038139, 0.011538391932845116, -0.02200535498559475, 0.05439583957195282, 0.02443479187786579, 0.01618625782430172, 0.006078001577407122, 0.0333387553691864, -0.041608698666095734, 0.0476587675511837, -0.02286805957555771, 0.048865675926208496, -0.03173885494470596, -0.03574373945593834, -0.04469712823629379, 0.006671207491308451, -0.012607918120920658, 0.04144047573208809, 0.015928147360682487, -0.018089186400175095, 0.03963930532336235, -0.05379340052604675, 0.0028814557008445263, -0.0373208113014698, -0.006975825875997543, 0.020190652459859848, -0.05571891367435455, 0.025812532752752304, 0.010248062200844288, -0.09734559059143066, -0.00972248800098896, -0.023783789947628975 ]
<p>If we have two variables A={20 values} and B={20 values} and we want to measure the correlation between these two variables. Lets assume that the first n values are highly correlated but the remaining m values are not correlated. The overall correlation between A and B may not represent the importance of the relationship. Imagine that there is only weak correlation in some values, but several values show really good correspondence between A and B. Traditional correlation coefficients will not capture such relationship. Is there any measure or statistical method that can detect such relationship between A and B?</p>
g36700
[ 0.043695125728845596, -0.026446467265486717, -0.0013071532594040036, -0.06565529853105545, 0.006936261430382729, 0.0023194202221930027, -0.034482091665267944, 0.018083391711115837, 0.0000028861406917712884, -0.04709075018763542, -0.03817915916442871, -0.010636360384523869, -0.025801002979278564, 0.0870770812034607, -0.019571177661418915, -0.022512217983603477, 0.06501009315252304, -0.0318010039627552, -0.0013351954985409975, 0.013416586443781853, 0.05265945568680763, 0.04150810465216637, 0.04079529270529747, 0.01781182363629341, -0.042852334678173065, -0.042024847120046616, -0.008302124217152596, -0.025241538882255554, -0.0100272037088871, 0.04351748153567314, 0.02431829273700714, 0.009776473976671696, 0.06825903803110123, -0.01843702234327793, -0.028529001399874687, -0.00021498858404811472, 0.01611529290676117, 0.021754080429673195, -0.031763043254613876, 0.05623219534754753, -0.010853713378310204, 0.059016454964876175, 0.039680447429418564, -0.00204290309920907, -0.003592187073081732, 0.04971310496330261, 0.004957322962582111, 0.0343211330473423, -0.010636097751557827, -0.03633183613419533, -0.02970653772354126, 0.012665145099163055, 0.06292581558227539, 0.0062767937779426575, 0.030156880617141724, 0.02992166392505169, 0.07352204620838165, 0.051846787333488464, 0.030653830617666245, 0.039634525775909424, 0.08385119587182999, -0.004137001931667328, -0.014909558929502964, 0.045105140656232834, 0.007884991355240345, 0.044742655009031296, -0.014603250660002232, -0.08357422053813934, 0.02532949484884739, -0.004685758613049984, -0.020079469308257103, -0.015398327261209488, 0.0010645471047610044, -0.002120911842212081, -0.04442497715353966, 0.016013041138648987, 0.027502134442329407, -0.045194536447525024, 0.01599479839205742, 0.037053100764751434, 0.006592787802219391, -0.00009386434248881415, 0.03123539872467518, 0.08042628318071365, 0.07128053158521652, -0.035299625247716904, 0.009443636983633041, 0.004958515986800194, -0.012699826620519161, 0.013254345394670963, 0.0437895841896534, 0.04325660690665245, 0.036059074103832245, 0.015730151906609535, -0.054636869579553604, 0.0158592127263546, -0.02323305979371071, 0.029010239988565445, -0.03131187707185745, -0.07844795286655426, -0.005861734971404076, 0.04640139266848564, -0.006436980329453945, -0.019779201596975327, -0.018070992082357407, -0.04006905108690262, 0.024990642443299294, 0.040508586913347244, -0.053619157522916794, 0.01780150830745697, -0.026923680678009987, -0.009615834802389145, -0.07194104045629501, -0.019741015508770943, -0.0061502596363425255, -0.04191404581069946, 0.015082983300089836, -0.0492134690284729, -0.03040246292948723, -0.041308801621198654, 0.0213952474296093, 0.04667938873171806, 0.02249961718916893, 0.07526425272226334, -0.023769477382302284, 0.030345328152179718, -0.02084094099700451, 0.06355665624141693, -0.008300065994262695, 0.014834936708211899, 0.04652171954512596, -0.040777985006570816, 0.031617458909749985, 0.03252503648400307, -0.015099849551916122, 0.008150717243552208, 0.008751565590500832, 0.0629005879163742, 0.009208016097545624, 0.00498760212212801, -0.09105078876018524, 0.01083291880786419, 0.04296957701444626, 0.015270687639713287, -0.038725171238183975, 0.05914124473929405, 0.03666204959154129, 0.005483151413500309, -0.031161904335021973, 0.020995983853936195, 0.025456981733441353, -0.0070525831542909145, -0.009447752498090267, -0.028292126953601837, -0.05572095140814781, 0.033781036734580994, 0.010227801278233528, -0.08905389159917831, 0.019336972385644913, -0.02439519390463829, -0.013623411767184734, -0.02020924910902977, 0.07553950697183609, -0.02048483118414879, 0.040203869342803955, -0.021736448630690575, -0.024023860692977905, -0.03490690141916275, -0.028031233698129654, -0.02931205928325653, -0.04501892998814583, 0.00878283940255642, 0.004293785430490971, 0.01259540393948555, 0.0617588646709919, 0.06239073723554611, -0.0021910485811531544, -0.006325301248580217, 0.03355597332119942, 0.017007160931825638, -0.008730064146220684, 0.04208631440997124, 0.03414895385503769, -0.031282972544431686, -0.03248558193445206, -0.02056880295276642, 0.03533772751688957, 0.024308370426297188, -0.07227753847837448, 0.033211760222911835, -0.042675383388996124, -0.028227780014276505, -0.035001978278160095, -0.036029715090990067, -0.01943226344883442, -0.0147992093116045, 0.010179221630096436, -0.014232402667403221, 0.013472257182002068, -0.03050379827618599, -0.005071623716503382, -0.003178257495164871, 0.01621134765446186, 0.07145670801401138, -0.024047231301665306, -0.007450250443071127, -0.04926891252398491, -0.017118699848651886, -0.04799316078424454, -0.006538881454616785, -0.04553384333848953, -0.012214540503919125, -0.07210841774940491, 0.024353008717298508, 0.005301367957144976, -0.020491641014814377, -0.016813091933727264, 0.018090227618813515, -0.012999607250094414, 0.03912012279033661, -0.032138288021087646, -0.006936720572412014, 0.041172850877046585, -0.025590838864445686, -0.0009571763221174479, 0.07615640759468079, 0.030549172312021255, 0.04585327208042145, -0.012279439717531204, -0.030761754140257835, 0.0009125679498538375, -0.0030877641402184963, 0.020524999126791954, -0.019365612417459488, -0.01692020148038864, 0.016675882041454315, 0.06383714079856873, 0.017592310905456543, -0.05853475630283356, 0.09674473851919174, -0.05278545618057251, -0.012655412778258324, -0.01546487770974636, 0.06821047514677048, 0.05445786193013191, 0.011410023085772991, 0.014451270923018456, 0.01343326736241579, -0.0013866802910342813, 0.025838980451226234, -0.017176251858472824, 0.02639283798635006, 0.0025645997375249863, -0.03193405270576477, 0.0061579556204378605, 0.02883289009332657, 0.03518623113632202, 0.0583304725587368, -0.025902846828103065, -0.06905654072761536, -0.022940441966056824, -0.02767735719680786, 0.028334707021713257, -0.004643301945179701, 0.0574067123234272, -0.04312044382095337, -0.003597249509766698, -0.057314544916152954, -0.05332065746188164, -0.01559719629585743, -0.08374636620283127, 0.02789163403213024, 0.04718243330717087, 0.026685241609811783, -0.03694366663694382, -0.01583281345665455, -0.0036030986811965704, 0.04228000342845917, 0.03566759452223778, 0.0015331311151385307, 0.0036365557461977005, 0.05988915264606476, -0.07572318613529205, -0.019111542031168938, 0.018581222742795944, 0.01885177753865719, 0.06353127211332321, 0.016541941091418266, 0.03063155710697174, 0.05695590004324913, 0.015675164759159088, -0.01145913265645504, -0.047283630818128586, 0.05142148956656456, 0.0068986318074166775, 0.01627577282488346, 0.060800984501838684, -0.05552774667739868, 0.013729147613048553, -0.00888829305768013, -0.024901671335101128, -0.013590486720204353, 0.025812583044171333, -0.006895086728036404, 0.019319722428917885, -0.051796235144138336, -0.061596471816301346, -0.047481831163167953, -0.04630757495760918, 0.006448868662118912, -0.021992474794387817, -0.024822397157549858, 0.03729125112295151, 0.03083675354719162, -0.013305522501468658, 0.033486347645521164, 0.05313432589173317, 0.037482850253582, 0.014385989867150784, -0.03231264278292656, -0.002521172631531954, -0.07505469024181366, 0.0012236967450007796, -0.04765213653445244, 0.02275942638516426, -0.04291427507996559, -0.052067872136831284, 0.03344754874706268, -0.07526564598083496, 0.027907822281122208, -0.0010062603978440166, 0.03589297831058502, 0.015321526676416397, 0.009083235636353493, -0.04978349432349205, -0.02356346882879734, 0.03621203452348709, -0.03243185952305794, 0.004604549612849951, 0.055196862667798996, 0.030981993302702904, 0.003387587843462825, -0.02407381869852543, -0.0006925146444700658, -0.005235455464571714, -0.012640312314033508, 0.03185855969786644, 0.05049910396337509, 0.02167469449341297, -0.08381571620702744, 0.02685489133000374, -0.006696299184113741, 0.012557875365018845, -0.022390060126781464, -0.027071364223957062, 0.019132722169160843, 0.05055516958236694, -0.058724768459796906, -0.03421511501073837, -0.02720077522099018, 0.0038808996323496103, -0.0030077106785029173, 0.009885159321129322, 0.008123288862407207, -0.023726290091872215, 0.016761042177677155, -0.01363675482571125, 0.04670562595129013, 0.03226570039987564, -0.032267797738313675, 0.0006606319220736623, 0.0003175396122969687, 0.012834644876420498, -0.0017233430407941341, 0.009443266317248344, -0.02068408951163292, 0.06881950795650482, -0.017773551866412163, -0.001723998924717307, 0.08518727868795395, 0.04675258323550224, 0.0542040653526783, 0.007733201142400503, 0.0182352252304554, 0.05093098059296608, -0.08917411416769028, -0.040969934314489365, -0.012062340043485165, 0.04544975236058235, -0.005197244696319103, 0.0015533799305558205, 0.0010251135099679232, -0.027061166241765022, 0.08136548101902008, 0.03872077912092209, -0.033981673419475555, 0.03180517256259918, 0.02689404971897602, 0.07140962034463882, -0.005445112474262714, -0.06444592028856277, -0.014069723896682262, 0.012965673580765724, 0.01043945737183094, -0.011411862447857857, -0.03258184716105461, 0.019925279542803764, 0.0008576757973060012, -0.041847359389066696, 0.0022335252724587917, -0.03658813610672951, -0.050159770995378494, 0.035973381251096725, -0.02259783260524273, -0.025622615590691566, -0.013661587610840797, 0.006063519511371851, 0.010492010042071342, 0.05090310052037239, 0.020824143663048744, -0.0066705928184092045, 0.030159609392285347, -0.008367151953279972, 0.0028896185103803873, -0.023016799241304398, -0.014082735404372215, -0.004429962486028671, 0.010082493536174297, -0.0009797378443181515, 0.020777804777026176, 0.03544970974326134, 0.017258623614907265, 0.017042554914951324, 0.02262166701257229, 0.0006007718038745224, 0.009546786546707153, -0.03259233757853508, -0.022567259147763252, 0.024788247421383858, -0.05057770758867264, 0.0006648196722380817, 0.009288846515119076, 0.013350311666727066, 0.0270401518791914, -0.0502847284078598, 0.03298228606581688, -0.06822795420885086, 0.01069145929068327, 0.008865690790116787, -0.022512441501021385, 0.004975621588528156, 0.04376024752855301, -0.024717023596167564, -0.0522480271756649, -0.02676107920706272, -0.017152534797787666, 0.035247474908828735, 0.03328743577003479, 0.03066668100655079, 0.030273430049419403, 0.025582272559404373, -0.009123137220740318, 0.017537059262394905, -0.030139746144413948, -0.030908910557627678, -0.04488638415932655, -0.017434895038604736, -0.020413853228092194, -0.000001243343717760581, 0.004240246489644051, -0.02247515879571438, -0.0013929049018770456, 0.015837591141462326, 0.05903236195445061, 0.014235055074095726, -0.02651858888566494, 0.009335538372397423, -0.024362996220588684, 0.0063528926111757755, -0.05604160577058792, 0.009707498364150524, 0.05223836377263069, -0.030207598581910133, -0.02536805532872677, 0.02336312085390091, -0.03625459969043732, -0.0716174766421318, -0.03590664267539978, 0.013848185539245605, -0.0419614240527153, 0.0468309260904789, 0.028409896418452263, 0.014919647015631199, 0.07116268575191498, -0.011211619712412357, -0.07919461280107498, -0.03487582132220268, -0.05557820573449135, 0.049488507211208344, -0.00022526054817717522, -0.017347199842333794, 0.04852768033742905, 0.01708207279443741, 0.03113088570535183, 0.00960071012377739, 0.001986027928069234, 0.026087842881679535, -0.057531047612428665, -0.009672746993601322, 0.08295994997024536, -0.0577007532119751, 0.040108684450387955, 0.010989781469106674, 0.001306375372223556, -0.0500456802546978, 0.039375774562358856, 0.005572484340518713, 0.010952581651508808, -0.07084039598703384, -0.0383773148059845, 0.057180292904376984, -0.022653499618172646, 0.014207381755113602, -0.027105212211608887, -0.008563476614654064, -0.05406523868441582, -0.0652417540550232, 0.0036765567492693663, 0.0174908135086298, -0.04806344956159592, 0.04422731697559357, 0.002630324801430106, 0.0005893576890230179, 0.0017158646369352937, 0.0008319133776240051, -0.06571443378925323, 0.005084769334644079, 0.038261596113443375, -0.011777136474847794, 0.0566861554980278, 0.022704051807522774, 0.04050728678703308, 0.022339219227433205, 0.009637176990509033, 0.03997131809592247, -0.026180196553468704, -0.029484741389751434, -0.04148389399051666, 0.014533208683133125, 0.013663426041603088, -0.044289618730545044, 0.00755971297621727, -0.05822640657424927, 0.021684594452381134, 0.01849455200135708, -0.03236004337668419, 0.019381172955036163, -0.015446632169187069, -0.0010288562625646591, 0.029293769970536232, 0.02424176037311554, -0.021810999140143394, 0.03126112371683121, 0.023065129294991493, -0.08081485331058502, -0.033408068120479584, -0.03421041741967201, 0.004474693443626165, 0.005121304653584957, 0.06644491851329803, -0.019023777917027473, -0.06505007296800613, 0.03530221804976463, -0.004784351214766502, 0.016050323843955994, 0.012062743306159973, -0.05282127112150192, -0.004703469108790159, 0.017068983986973763, -0.060120753943920135, -0.03569997474551201, 0.014039008878171444, -0.004618966486304998, 0.03915654495358467, -0.01389787532389164, 0.033055614680051804, -0.004787737969309092, 0.05366150289773941, -0.03827815502882004, -0.032802850008010864, -0.0059848385863006115, 0.016292065382003784, -0.07664549350738525, -0.02063293755054474, -0.019640114158391953, -0.06745941936969757, -0.0003859441785607487, 0.004413717892020941, -0.020055925473570824, 0.0008861355017870665, 0.0282592810690403, -0.0011307249078527093, 0.05206107720732689, -0.02657672017812729, -0.050833508372306824, 0.025545472279191017, 0.01892711967229843, 0.010645848698914051, -0.028301222249865532, 0.007852557115256786, -0.020138446241617203, 0.06632896512746811, 0.056046612560749054, 0.06640893965959549, 0.001467113383114338, -0.02490883693099022, -0.005529886577278376, -0.017922889441251755, -0.0652293935418129, -0.00927953701466322, 0.011479965411126614, -0.043467555195093155, -0.01326428446918726, 0.006167280487716198, 0.02799825556576252, 0.0771280974149704, -0.028466226533055305, -0.04740423709154129, -0.006757293827831745, -0.03469674289226532, -0.030976491048932076, 0.023324500769376755, 0.05645717307925224, -0.017332078889012337, -0.034222107380628586, 0.04738209396600723, -0.05698685348033905, 0.029585445299744606, -0.021956240758299828, 0.03268226608633995, -0.004031575284898281, -0.0038807315286248922, -0.043657686561346054, 0.019463414326310158, -0.012173859402537346, -0.029463021084666252, 0.022762004286050797, 0.06625603139400482, -0.0709245428442955, -0.025737013667821884, 0.011664497666060925, 0.028588779270648956, 0.021469825878739357, -0.03838640823960304, -0.03741886094212532, 0.03373587876558304, 0.057426050305366516, 0.006913305725902319, 0.0717388466000557, -0.014078771695494652, -0.032037775963544846, -0.017901534214615822, -0.051205482333898544, -0.012861558236181736, -0.029642753303050995, 0.042296215891838074, 0.004806175362318754, -0.04297413304448128, -0.041698481887578964, -0.024167783558368683, 0.03921572118997574, -0.11180040240287781, 0.003942208364605904, 0.019010763615369797, -0.010658420622348785, -0.004518098663538694, -0.02133255824446678, -0.01107608899474144, -0.0157843679189682, -0.02132897637784481, -0.031173458322882652, 0.002622207859531045, 0.023975668475031853, 0.03882984071969986, -0.034933071583509445, 0.06887554377317429, 0.027753952890634537, 0.013132089748978615, 0.021560298278927803, -0.004260900896042585, -0.09287122637033463, -0.049883317202329636, 0.07419957220554352, -0.06372082978487015, -0.0032805989030748606, 0.05886264890432358, 0.06346293538808823, -0.021335899829864502, -0.023650582879781723, -0.012161598540842533, -0.02469606325030327, 0.011949116364121437, -0.0393841527402401, -0.007298015523701906, 0.004620632156729698, 0.03418169170618057, 0.015642138198018074, -0.05816422030329704, -0.05092666670680046, -0.03217986598610878, -0.01153404451906681, 0.05874457210302353, -0.0020313772838562727, -0.018169444054365158, -0.04980310797691345, -0.020229395478963852, -0.04420357942581177, -0.015341837890446186, -0.006670599337667227, 0.0070608314126729965, -0.024567466229200363, -0.0422707200050354, 0.0212850384414196, -0.06602514535188675, -0.05743783339858055, -0.036318089812994, 0.014516056515276432, 0.06667272001504898, 0.02160685881972313, 0.01889318972826004, 0.007715173531323671, -0.006751947104930878, 0.006931203883141279, 0.01642165146768093, -0.010103466920554638, -0.0240790955722332, 0.0006490133819170296, 0.05883977934718132, -0.04153469577431679, 0.009655560366809368, -0.04839253053069115, -0.007389500271528959, 0.015695616602897644, -0.048107076436281204, 0.061226002871990204, -0.05426808446645737, 0.025228777900338173, 0.07277616113424301, 0.022471310570836067, 0.002621664199978113, -0.03969826176762581, 0.06312984228134155, 0.0009008273482322693, 0.0619160458445549, 0.008650255389511585, 0.04516015574336052, -0.050395186990499496, -0.03116273134946823, -0.007394344545900822, -0.026282289996743202, 0.04920404404401779, 0.018610382452607155, -0.10491590201854706, 0.04006011411547661, -0.01665724627673626, -0.009365195408463478, -0.02365642972290516, 0.031638097018003464 ]
<p>Do you know of any study where researchers have used Statistical Parametric Mapping for <strong>spatial data only</strong>? I found a lot of studies that used it for time-series analysis, but does this analysis work for data that don't share a time dimension? </p>
g74057
[ 0.014403106644749641, 0.013341638259589672, 0.035447146743535995, -0.0022180613595992327, -0.10005013644695282, 0.008711243979632854, -0.008531279861927032, -0.01181399542838335, 0.0062261619605124, -0.027920708060264587, 0.02561159059405327, -0.028781389817595482, 0.05128779262304306, -0.00737749645486474, -0.09710553288459778, 0.010303654707968235, 0.03866149112582207, 0.01216982863843441, 0.0026719379238784313, 0.0009757844381965697, 0.009889212436974049, -0.03462835028767586, 0.08369022607803345, -0.0026423921808600426, -0.07567092031240463, 0.0047449348494410515, 0.020838560536503792, -0.025172444060444832, 0.016644660383462906, -0.04665351286530495, 0.020636113360524178, -0.01605379208922386, 0.03904283791780472, -0.019275646656751633, -0.0354410782456398, 0.007593096233904362, -0.03432287648320198, 0.01040662731975317, 0.038689203560352325, 0.019527211785316467, -0.010192058980464935, -0.0174004714936018, 0.03327400982379913, 0.03004208393394947, -0.015735236927866936, -0.002203413052484393, 0.013726422563195229, -0.0005073593347333372, 0.011342116631567478, -0.0399148166179657, -0.0706920325756073, 0.04380769282579422, -0.005782251711934805, 0.02144617587327957, 0.04145511984825134, -0.0011266287183389068, 0.014700968749821186, 0.04748142883181572, 0.044510677456855774, 0.0059173014014959335, -0.004541689995676279, -0.008428665809333324, 0.013714300468564034, 0.020724767819046974, 0.07393071800470352, -0.002112129470333457, -0.03495600447058678, -0.09148544073104858, -0.020477183163166046, -0.048307936638593674, 0.02668454684317112, 0.04776737466454506, -0.002455536276102066, -0.02903047204017639, -0.033482834696769714, -0.016926024109125137, 0.019582318142056465, 0.007244414184242487, -0.05218656361103058, 0.016808684915304184, 0.020366884768009186, 0.03177883103489876, 0.013618426397442818, 0.009971599094569683, 0.07601682096719742, 0.021494721993803978, 0.01572280004620552, 0.022735610604286194, 0.05207911133766174, -0.025766676291823387, 0.017744524404406548, 0.07506517320871353, 0.04181904345750809, 0.07692909985780716, -0.019078746438026428, -0.025790229439735413, -0.0004247358883731067, 0.02863837219774723, -0.04289444535970688, 0.027058923617005348, -0.043389420956373215, 0.05852383002638817, -0.004730546846985817, 0.040935344994068146, 0.006642669904977083, -0.01500667817890644, -0.015471828170120716, -0.004047361668199301, -0.029599355533719063, -0.03479951247572899, -0.03798931464552879, -0.0012220887001603842, -0.04578162729740143, 0.025933410972356796, 0.0010173707269132137, -0.00904911570250988, 0.07992778718471527, -0.08074097335338593, -0.030692148953676224, 0.012302705086767673, 0.006333622150123119, 0.008514922112226486, -0.00407638493925333, 0.04197219759225845, -0.06123695522546768, -0.003010999411344528, -0.0037176969926804304, 0.027833836153149605, 0.03094683215022087, 0.035123661160469055, 0.011582519859075546, 0.002948095789179206, 0.05619501322507858, 0.047507304698228836, 0.023697061464190483, -0.017583616077899933, -0.027570804581046104, 0.0065102712251245975, -0.03097699210047722, 0.06166939064860344, -0.07266899198293686, -0.03897060453891754, 0.01080926414579153, -0.045814983546733856, -0.021712370216846466, 0.006269910838454962, -0.00023993078502826393, 0.010209749452769756, -0.013498219661414623, 0.015497380867600441, 0.02023746818304062, 0.03263483941555023, 0.007047185208648443, -0.019214991480112076, -0.04363120719790459, -0.022573867812752724, -0.04265448823571205, -0.028792863711714745, 0.02748963050544262, -0.02351970039308071, -0.012043558992445469, 0.013636079616844654, 0.025905964896082878, -0.002569252159446478, 0.014768767170608044, -0.05153156444430351, 0.04857724905014038, -0.015856223180890083, 0.011612944304943085, -0.022520501166582108, -0.037803295999765396, -0.02547519840300083, 0.016673680394887924, -0.005360809620469809, -0.035076744854450226, -0.04078403487801552, -0.017070861533284187, -0.011534640565514565, 0.01526863593608141, 0.03607005625963211, 0.026214906945824623, 0.014658323489129543, -0.021053554490208626, -0.08193221688270569, 0.024806389585137367, -0.03889341652393341, -0.015766415745019913, 0.06724480539560318, -0.07824786752462387, -0.013863950036466122, -0.06692281365394592, -0.03158380836248398, -0.03591564670205116, 0.0017313201678916812, -0.039531394839286804, 0.01184997707605362, 0.05084134638309479, -0.02698315866291523, 0.005232793278992176, -0.006708489265292883, -0.031831298023462296, 0.014999731443822384, -0.0341925211250782, 0.05648742616176605, 0.025077491998672485, -0.04196178540587425, 0.008633061312139034, -0.0059639206156134605, -0.019191840663552284, 0.007300541270524263, 0.01710268296301365, 0.0752425417304039, -0.026541033759713173, 0.03707818686962128, -0.008533285930752754, -0.003825095249339938, -0.05233652889728546, -0.0008598752319812775, 0.031206687912344933, 0.025028595700860023, -0.05250278115272522, -0.003005076665431261, -0.030337950214743614, -0.0018177727470174432, 0.04289375990629196, -0.0076207746751606464, 0.019244013354182243, 0.033920448273420334, -0.017621459439396858, -0.03487946838140488, -0.017157642170786858, -0.05003446713089943, 0.02575495094060898, -0.03574346378445625, 0.02784445881843567, 0.0011615328257903457, 0.005424540024250746, -0.021791713312268257, 0.00047701995936222374, 0.01914909854531288, -0.030639732256531715, -0.07150658965110779, 0.012926734052598476, 0.00961772259324789, 0.03397196903824806, 0.003195387776941061, 0.028383761644363403, -0.03465500473976135, 0.04359130188822746, 0.009335721842944622, 0.022083936259150505, 0.04360524192452431, -0.0211990587413311, -0.02054612524807453, 0.03748239576816559, -0.0011774019803851843, 0.046019334346055984, 0.01706756465137005, -0.07499123364686966, -0.009514447301626205, -0.0005598593852482736, 0.03563966229557991, 0.0482436902821064, -0.03349119424819946, 0.07975183427333832, -0.04322364926338196, -0.010544859804213047, 0.027411015704274178, -0.03572962060570717, 0.017100803554058075, -0.030992800369858742, 0.05740933120250702, 0.03316760063171387, 0.0673041120171547, 0.004531539045274258, -0.0063284095376729965, -0.024912290275096893, -0.023307984694838524, -0.016150616109371185, 0.02870042622089386, -0.0005325089441612363, -0.03958578780293465, -0.017596084624528885, 0.05907242000102997, 0.012081217020750046, -0.041626837104558945, 0.04559699818491936, 0.0468454547226429, -0.010885498486459255, 0.0032297258730977774, 0.03514045476913452, 0.010933988727629185, 0.06767425686120987, 0.00488907378166914, -0.029779179021716118, 0.040796246379613876, -0.010887752287089825, -0.06879536062479019, 0.11713335663080215, -0.02275690995156765, -0.013163533061742783, 0.030329734086990356, 0.0377049446105957, 0.021240543574094772, 0.04811207577586174, 0.03864984214305878, -0.0405765101313591, -0.11413762718439102, -0.02467299997806549, -0.009191135875880718, 0.0576770044863224, 0.06610675901174545, -0.0371176153421402, 0.038574330508708954, -0.031660862267017365, 0.01095831859856844, 0.002181091345846653, -0.03042357973754406, -0.027908125892281532, 0.007891090586781502, 0.04719289764761925, -0.09231393784284592, 0.00024084330652840436, -0.010247493162751198, -0.0381736233830452, 0.027603477239608765, -0.04343971237540245, -0.009388741105794907, -0.07893652468919754, 0.07780754566192627, 0.004637743346393108, -0.009270885027945042, 0.06408296525478363, 0.025987187400460243, -0.0766836628317833, 0.009353786706924438, 0.008654028177261353, -0.003964389208704233, 0.03341607376933098, -0.015343235805630684, -0.05103874206542969, -0.034940168261528015, -0.022004639729857445, -0.021222485229372978, 0.01025156956166029, 0.033782269805669785, 0.04502730444073677, 0.019210858270525932, -0.029354194179177284, -0.00975676067173481, 0.0001531714224256575, 0.02649032510817051, 0.03598605841398239, -0.05536671727895737, 0.04386970028281212, 0.03297819569706917, 0.03907212242484093, -0.02641308307647705, 0.023683946579694748, -0.03372171148657799, 0.002161693759262562, -0.011223037727177143, 0.00679370341822505, -0.041720371693372726, -0.060347672551870346, 0.03244943544268608, 0.08932104706764221, 0.06173252686858177, 0.011492960155010223, 0.018629714846611023, 0.025383520871400833, 0.0655374526977539, 0.037409983575344086, -0.05497921258211136, 0.0047796242870390415, 0.01473093219101429, 0.0047617522068321705, 0.002143534831702709, -0.010003816336393356, 0.04765361547470093, 0.06156713142991066, 0.04680381342768669, 0.031318336725234985, 0.030253399163484573, 0.037373170256614685, -0.08982964605093002, -0.03197019174695015, 0.032263509929180145, -0.005842647049576044, -0.02048199437558651, 0.018671348690986633, -0.018572380766272545, -0.01968655176460743, -0.016585739329457283, 0.0002166695921914652, -0.05762078985571861, 0.021735474467277527, 0.009772744961082935, 0.026559973135590553, 0.023158930242061615, -0.04735898599028587, -0.015240361914038658, 0.0024887872859835625, 0.051711373031139374, -0.024255361407995224, -0.08652295172214508, -0.006201647687703371, 0.0365426242351532, -0.07366756349802017, 0.03471513092517853, -0.06453139334917068, -0.028944311663508415, 0.01706549897789955, -0.11094102263450623, 0.020427284762263298, -0.014228058978915215, 0.006868559867143631, -0.004019720479846001, -0.0062965163961052895, 0.010476898401975632, 0.003212737152352929, 0.046614523977041245, -0.0030809275340288877, 0.015174993313848972, 0.02436036430299282, -0.031208356842398643, 0.022638371214270592, 0.018264858052134514, 0.027265693992376328, 0.04069408401846886, 0.006164024118334055, 0.03408878669142723, 0.0016489452682435513, -0.012279580347239971, -0.003964156843721867, -0.06499933451414108, 0.02705543115735054, 0.03575736656785011, -0.017849860712885857, -0.06163293123245239, -0.029729163274168968, -0.028252601623535156, 0.09809329360723495, 0.027620872482657433, -0.0010069278068840504, -0.0022309364285320044, 0.014497943222522736, 0.0035096120554953814, -0.046751897782087326, 0.0145551273599267, 0.004729353357106447, 0.0757141262292862, -0.037239279597997665, 0.018836380913853645, -0.0011844761902466416, 0.004154547117650509, -0.013634356670081615, 0.05189661309123039, 0.04966956377029419, 0.007317183539271355, -0.00774920079857111, -0.04734382778406143, 0.023127920925617218, -0.046275801956653595, -0.05201440304517746, -0.04963041469454765, -0.10698670893907547, -0.03734683617949486, -0.006719665601849556, 0.010355480015277863, -0.024265101179480553, 0.03768468275666237, -0.0033981429878622293, -0.0016592200845479965, -0.024621089920401573, 0.031983114778995514, 0.015041561797261238, -0.02792399190366268, 0.008013440296053886, -0.04061777517199516, 0.009257882833480835, -0.025193745270371437, 0.028378106653690338, 0.013856936246156693, -0.007037736941128969, 0.014046765863895416, -0.031666360795497894, -0.02093161642551422, 0.0007152678444981575, -0.02713240310549736, -0.03809234872460365, -0.03228043392300606, 0.033455029129981995, 0.0372837595641613, -0.002213430590927601, -0.03771594166755676, 0.04433097690343857, -0.024971624836325645, -0.052483584731817245, -0.002406738931313157, -0.011836765334010124, 0.04079939424991608, 0.020228663459420204, 0.00599123677238822, -0.020357733592391014, -0.033708080649375916, 0.01178600825369358, 0.01240098848938942, -0.05951429530978203, 0.05671091377735138, 0.011370176449418068, 0.05279391258955002, -0.027815666049718857, -0.008112090639770031, 0.0016022571362555027, -0.012890641577541828, 0.021676769480109215, 0.06771950423717499, 0.01564921997487545, -0.05835433304309845, 0.031802453100681305, -0.018513143062591553, 0.05148671567440033, 0.03591405227780342, 0.08609772473573685, -0.026121925562620163, -0.040910504758358, 0.01754920184612274, 0.0015563508495688438, -0.0024316420312970877, 0.0035897528287023306, 0.001015160116367042, -0.005486767739057541, 0.026329405605793, 0.006942023057490587, -0.045187581330537796, 0.03299994394183159, 0.049649678170681, -0.028922051191329956, 0.004418708849698305, -0.05709372088313103, -0.03716207668185234, 0.03552958741784096, -0.036645397543907166, -0.016381673514842987, -0.023018844425678253, 0.016114741563796997, 0.01983839087188244, 0.005320743657648563, 0.004846884403377771, -0.004699862562119961, -0.026263635605573654, 0.005309531930834055, -0.018483882769942284, 0.009206372313201427, -0.02342863567173481, 0.0013097879709675908, -0.04646677523851395, 0.021489758044481277, -0.015441440977156162, -0.02124241553246975, 0.009034919552505016, 0.030452411621809006, 0.02436911314725876, 0.00010225335427094251, -0.0044267126359045506, 0.0054479120299220085, -0.00744475657120347, -0.03214787691831589, 0.02083049714565277, 0.005791210103780031, -0.03283538296818733, 0.056760795414447784, 0.03902840614318848, -0.028241045773029327, 0.005316962022334337, 0.03068416565656662, 0.030896414071321487, -0.01737350970506668, 0.025387007743120193, 0.01064854022115469, -0.05703417956829071, 0.04100250080227852, -0.03634336590766907, -0.039106715470552444, -0.00046256912173703313, 0.0298306867480278, 0.038740385323762894, -0.031098002567887306, -0.04811938479542732, -0.02508600801229477, -0.027018435299396515, 0.005510095506906509, -0.034048885107040405, 0.03129994496703148, -0.04015722870826721, 0.013121177442371845, 0.03712454065680504, -0.10095687955617905, -0.015008223243057728, -0.022174207493662834, -0.024711821228265762, 0.03263189271092415, -0.0008833884494379163, -0.04541119188070297, -0.013746851123869419, 0.06081606075167656, -0.020429592579603195, 0.01411004364490509, 0.0031094432342797518, -0.041915412992239, 0.05476565659046173, 0.010607447475194931, 0.05235935002565384, -0.01931656152009964, -0.056309349834918976, 0.026623092591762543, -0.03292035311460495, -0.07164651155471802, -0.047439612448215485, 0.024976694956421852, -0.019440770149230957, -0.025063371285796165, -0.027677256613969803, -0.038395337760448456, 0.01488513220101595, -0.03464562073349953, -0.05189291387796402, -0.02359563112258911, -0.01580549217760563, -0.012850765138864517, 0.019434310495853424, 0.011240633204579353, -0.027684172615408897, -0.1250000149011612, 0.02613554336130619, -0.03560442477464676, 0.046517107635736465, -0.0034346396569162607, -0.06696423888206482, 0.011372532695531845, -0.01790555566549301, -0.04855993762612343, -0.01194679643958807, -0.02048414759337902, -0.009518425911664963, -0.03838954493403435, 0.043239571154117584, -0.04986972361803055, 0.01723540760576725, 0.09337156265974045, 0.0061433035880327225, -0.055807214230298996, -0.03521335497498512, 0.006443685851991177, 0.05673275142908096, 0.006653365679085255, 0.05614819750189781, 0.0516703799366951, 0.019826356321573257, -0.005671349819749594, 0.026472484692931175, -0.06645937263965607, -0.001290182932280004, 0.05722913518548012, 0.051554951816797256, -0.003364569041877985, 0.023511853069067, 0.0301715936511755, -0.021259531378746033, 0.019283046945929527, 0.03381316363811493, 0.02040998823940754, 0.04723457247018814, 0.04902540519833565, 0.020024171099066734, 0.013195202685892582, 0.004034575540572405, -0.020895585417747498, -0.00854132417589426, 0.014002131298184395, 0.011849009431898594, -0.009119321592152119, 0.020405327901244164, -0.025365516543388367, 0.07660908997058868, -0.0657237321138382, -0.024802839383482933, 0.009895708411931992, -0.04183822125196457, -0.049373917281627655, -0.030950142070651054, -0.021422669291496277, 0.03872966021299362, 0.04039112851023674, 0.0032815230078995228, -0.023719074204564095, 0.014258576557040215, -0.0336972177028656, 0.017854118719697, 0.003347728867083788, 0.0425354428589344, -0.02951670251786709, -0.029200658202171326, 0.036406632512807846, -0.047846365720033646, -0.01888263411819935, -0.05692323297262192, 0.004550276789814234, 0.020986517891287804, -0.005360891576856375, 0.10168835520744324, 0.0003301726537756622, 0.012921245768666267, 0.03229705989360809, -0.06274977326393127, -0.024178506806492805, -0.07241300493478775, 0.08101513236761093, 0.01531811524182558, 0.005599781405180693, -0.027850979939103127, 0.04559291899204254, -0.03505571559071541, 0.01934930868446827, 0.0009663422242738307, -0.023712322115898132, -0.012901663780212402, 0.10962437093257904, 0.03599303960800171, -0.0046583982184529305, -0.027787288650870323, -0.006724957842379808, 0.0252781230956316, -0.009245405904948711, -0.03749875724315643, 0.011545855551958084, 0.03312382847070694, 0.0025258641690015793, 0.056217677891254425, -0.025655919685959816, 0.07035059481859207, -0.04330643266439438, -0.004422588273882866, 0.0075854226015508175, 0.017687443643808365, -0.03060648776590824, -0.03391241654753685, 0.015329685993492603, -0.05514143779873848, -0.017089812085032463, 0.02693748287856579, -0.07273051142692566, 0.034481581300497055, -0.023530250415205956, 0.009145721793174744, 0.0153210973367095, -0.06323405355215073, 0.023868422955274582, 0.0021127171348780394, 0.05541318282485008, -0.0026478907093405724, -0.024832526221871376, 0.0317179374396801, 0.029940485954284668, -0.05276063084602356, -0.009689988568425179, 0.042790234088897705 ]
<p>I have a time series $x_t$. If I use the transformation $u_t = log(x_t) - log(x_{t-1})$, my new time series $u_t$ has properties of white noise (random). I wonder whether there is any practical interpretation for $u_t$?</p> <p>Thanks for your help.</p>
g74058
[ -0.06009550392627716, 0.06076919287443161, 0.0023871823213994503, -0.052806153893470764, 0.027033910155296326, -0.008845880627632141, 0.030833277851343155, 0.005998854525387287, -0.015887603163719177, 0.02525738626718521, -0.04153306037187576, 0.02911200188100338, 0.049657486379146576, -0.04182315245270729, -0.04893026500940323, 0.0025434705894440413, 0.06891102343797684, 0.045147452503442764, -0.055932994931936264, 0.00892165582627058, 0.018139176070690155, 0.05724862217903137, -0.006313502322882414, 0.02949509397149086, 0.06022658944129944, -0.025009287521243095, -0.03351087495684624, 0.05948154628276825, -0.03200535103678703, -0.0017624725587666035, 0.05968776345252991, -0.004003978334367275, 0.04577380791306496, 0.019037844613194466, 0.011351602151989937, 0.03151509538292885, 0.011075977236032486, -0.060015663504600525, 0.05689050629734993, -0.002667156048119068, 0.015499835833907127, 0.0911729484796524, 0.009803197346627712, 0.0701032355427742, -0.00694306893274188, -0.0055456156842410564, -0.02682594396173954, 0.04186096787452698, -0.012783186510205269, 0.017058387398719788, 0.01020694337785244, 0.003987112082540989, 0.04351339861750603, 0.049024973064661026, 0.016313742846250534, -0.010566815733909607, 0.05778774991631508, -0.046079959720373154, 0.019152620807290077, 0.04020062834024429, 0.02881544642150402, -0.06039398908615112, -0.002555484650656581, 0.03575757518410683, 0.047315482050180435, -0.054934803396463394, 0.0459735244512558, 0.03086891397833824, 0.04636773467063904, 0.023978829383850098, 0.029124826192855835, 0.031679026782512665, 0.004915626719594002, 0.01370241679251194, -0.041369374841451645, 0.01665952242910862, 0.04689573869109154, 0.03810640051960945, -0.004182580392807722, -0.015991220250725746, -0.06016020476818085, -0.04870305210351944, -0.01301316823810339, -0.023087328299880028, 0.039461757987737656, -0.07418983429670334, 0.05295572429895401, 0.022216686978936195, 0.012785892002284527, 0.038945239037275314, -0.020532144233584404, -0.029685743153095245, 0.019585978239774704, 0.036275602877140045, 0.03674378991127014, -0.039721064269542694, -0.07392579317092896, 0.051978081464767456, -0.0008294039289467037, 0.005553474649786949, 0.0033832192420959473, 0.040528152137994766, -0.011348762549459934, -0.02759259007871151, -0.04041438177227974, 0.012631363235414028, -0.0337783582508564, -0.011593331582844257, -0.014011810533702374, -0.03831392899155617, -0.022780971601605415, 0.03948165848851204, 0.055629074573516846, -0.004616024438291788, 0.05185879021883011, -0.05056099221110344, -0.008013943210244179, 0.021921098232269287, 0.003592722350731492, 0.03340786695480347, 0.021989891305565834, -0.03766017407178879, -0.03936140239238739, 0.04702267423272133, -0.019531361758708954, 0.001812819391489029, 0.014230928383767605, 0.05303530767560005, 0.057367559522390366, -0.020401326939463615, -0.012271937914192677, 0.015979640185832977, -0.01484729815274477, 0.047954488545656204, 0.06829192489385605, -0.030095387250185013, -0.005686233285814524, 0.025377526879310608, -0.006013368256390095, 0.04200376570224762, -0.00019197587971575558, -0.01757231540977955, -0.01774095743894577, -0.04038769006729126, -0.03984163701534271, 0.02828596718609333, -0.03292706981301308, -0.05073586851358414, 0.030062636360526085, 0.05214494466781616, -0.06640878319740295, 0.002252704929560423, -0.04167895019054413, -0.019497646018862724, -0.04430272430181503, -0.008096088655292988, -0.038916680961847305, 0.02608579397201538, -0.015094469301402569, 0.013009905815124512, -0.029787281528115273, -0.019549813121557236, 0.06189309060573578, 0.01879647746682167, -0.03326519578695297, -0.06368817389011383, -0.015257750637829304, -0.049213338643312454, -0.02529221959412098, -0.04234248027205467, -0.0000812836442491971, 0.027716903015971184, 0.014082581736147404, -0.014363615773618221, 0.01137631107121706, -0.00009961342584574595, 0.010639859363436699, -0.022731158882379532, -0.06275837123394012, 0.02288627438247204, 0.013123751617968082, 0.006637866608798504, -0.045159727334976196, -0.07726024836301804, 0.009630557149648666, -0.07203236222267151, -0.020773377269506454, 0.014945803210139275, -0.04123729094862938, 0.051085252314805984, -0.03759011626243591, -0.04741604998707771, -0.036433592438697815, -0.04431521147489548, 0.014103705063462257, -0.00784929096698761, -0.003632319625467062, -0.04546314850449562, -0.004342149011790752, -0.0004419050528667867, 0.050646618008613586, 0.016944468021392822, -0.0032601391430944204, -0.022071391344070435, -0.000579428393393755, -0.018731962889432907, -0.027812566608190536, 0.00793550442904234, -0.018481681123375893, -0.030307870358228683, -0.02965622767806053, -0.07099871337413788, -0.01938195712864399, -0.02249811962246895, -0.024214841425418854, 0.007295216899365187, -0.0013699836563318968, -0.004040727857500315, -0.009059330448508263, -0.01771700568497181, 0.028569191694259644, -0.0011738375760614872, 0.020157869905233383, 0.04720562696456909, 0.023215169087052345, -0.021360773593187332, -0.0353965237736702, 0.00405312143266201, -0.012437818571925163, -0.001683345646597445, -0.033018194139003754, -0.02609841711819172, -0.014539807103574276, -0.04130373150110245, 0.053870201110839844, -0.011789563111960888, 0.029224665835499763, -0.021953968331217766, 0.0032980504911392927, 0.027477022260427475, -0.002153434557840228, -0.018143123015761375, -0.070294588804245, -0.014870835468173027, 0.048857782036066055, 0.01826249435544014, -0.0017750844126567245, -0.030079076066613197, 0.009802821092307568, 0.01973487064242363, -0.036056146025657654, 0.04512936621904373, 0.006029924377799034, -0.06237015128135681, -0.02031305618584156, -0.04469611495733261, 0.020012423396110535, 0.0027388844173401594, -0.019621072337031364, 0.022242270410060883, -0.04539114609360695, -0.02441444993019104, -0.04633665829896927, 0.04531553015112877, 0.026590406894683838, -0.046509310603141785, 0.014716190285980701, 0.04755076393485069, -0.025508156046271324, -0.024771058931946754, 0.012904242612421513, -0.02083089016377926, 0.05535228177905083, 0.059921152889728546, 0.00555418012663722, -0.005748811177909374, -0.008834246546030045, -0.03500083461403847, 0.034887056797742844, -0.0025501784402877092, -0.02694273181259632, -0.020101308822631836, -0.003634662600234151, 0.05637194961309433, -0.02991415001451969, -0.05871742591261864, -0.0075880554504692554, -0.008284608833491802, 0.055242497473955154, 0.08080710470676422, 0.028161389753222466, -0.0023418825585395098, 0.02312476560473442, 0.0017403672682121396, 0.0035433326847851276, 0.010246834717690945, 0.01721954345703125, -0.03754313662648201, 0.0579507015645504, 0.05552680045366287, -0.011843223124742508, -0.0022206963039934635, 0.018026860430836678, 0.03446374833583832, 0.030143795534968376, -0.031974729150533676, 0.016055159270763397, 0.02409147098660469, -0.060965899378061295, -0.0050412253476679325, -0.08902642875909805, 0.003785425564274192, 0.007669895887374878, 0.001964045688509941, -0.006394430994987488, 0.0349685475230217, -0.006052173208445311, -0.007227516733109951, 0.05141954869031906, 0.008957503363490105, -0.01760128326714039, -0.08863294124603271, 0.014384533278644085, 0.0017528942553326488, -0.017407609149813652, -0.03940778225660324, -0.0011810417054221034, 0.010651960037648678, -0.014499075710773468, -0.013825460337102413, 0.06198984757065773, 0.0033221121411770582, 0.006022075656801462, -0.007720650639384985, -0.02937442623078823, -0.06341227889060974, 0.008597524836659431, 0.014410480856895447, 0.0036821970716118813, -0.0055917054414749146, -0.07008861005306244, -0.00106229807715863, -0.0020207767374813557, 0.004307611845433712, -0.005395601969212294, -0.07471165806055069, 0.02334865927696228, 0.008286681026220322, 0.03665609285235405, -0.013678198680281639, 0.044698506593704224, 0.005530309397727251, 0.06366144865751266, 0.027112005278468132, 0.007171250879764557, 0.038417235016822815, -0.017919380217790604, 0.06615674495697021, 0.016347987577319145, -0.03460973501205444, -0.004554665181785822, -0.06294268369674683, -0.02253175899386406, 0.026227962225675583, -0.023464256897568703, -0.015869203954935074, -0.03964788839221001, 0.06304338574409485, 0.014976260252296925, 0.05054572597146034, 0.0061339326202869415, 0.011804526671767235, 0.05966327711939812, -0.003554366761818528, -0.020823922008275986, 0.0022793591488152742, -0.013612289912998676, 0.048115842044353485, -0.0230034701526165, 0.08447723835706711, 0.06407390534877777, -0.06708082556724548, -0.01255020685493946, -0.014075524173676968, 0.05880769342184067, -0.03059847466647625, -0.050755035132169724, 0.005849623586982489, -0.00919038150459528, -0.06101608648896217, -0.02512197755277157, -0.005937419831752777, -0.04364529252052307, -0.020564774051308632, 0.03019418939948082, -0.12660744786262512, -0.0009168487158603966, 0.021150825545191765, 0.010443386621773243, -0.013417942449450493, -0.007597950752824545, -0.0058022355660796165, -0.005491181742399931, 0.017723385244607925, 0.014186730608344078, 0.012352589517831802, 0.08968639373779297, -0.035751085728406906, 0.010304566472768784, -0.01213925052434206, -0.05484690144658089, -0.0580037496984005, 0.03805725648999214, -0.02973104827105999, -0.0043534329161047935, 0.011995823122560978, 0.04399096593260765, -0.03515203297138214, 0.015415883623063564, 0.045158129185438156, 0.022373776882886887, 0.01566235162317753, -0.016870832070708275, 0.004354046192020178, -0.08878152072429657, 0.01799085922539234, 0.07644088566303253, -0.016756966710090637, -0.04480653628706932, -0.02381354197859764, -0.016163457185029984, -0.0022253096103668213, -0.005165362264961004, 0.02196924388408661, -0.007274067960679531, 0.042582761496305466, 0.013644200749695301, 0.06633872538805008, 0.000886564957909286, 0.01742985099554062, 0.0332549624145031, -0.09511692076921463, 0.0032842415384948254, -0.013485115952789783, -0.051910124719142914, 0.00867366325110197, -0.016332080587744713, -0.056701116263866425, 0.019866520538926125, 0.03200601041316986, -0.06226665899157524, 0.017458556219935417, -0.03021310269832611, -0.03734459728002548, 0.05140511319041252, -0.019696589559316635, 0.004190198611468077, 0.03674561157822609, -0.028168220072984695, 0.038942206650972366, -0.04162723571062088, -0.07230568677186966, 0.034579046070575714, 0.009658150374889374, -0.04532824829220772, 0.015304303728044033, -0.09738773107528687, 0.0019175619818270206, 0.07151753455400467, 0.03440248966217041, 0.003379305126145482, 0.009534555487334728, 0.03342028707265854, 0.04251944273710251, -0.04874414950609207, 0.03900391608476639, 0.037571970373392105, -0.028561171144247055, -0.000755603308789432, 0.039336878806352615, 0.06648599356412888, -0.010509852319955826, 0.044884093105793, 0.004347371403127909, -0.02506973221898079, 0.04460975155234337, -0.014041656628251076, 0.0052380808629095554, 0.046169936656951904, -0.0038614810910075903, -0.0097741037607193, 0.08270610123872757, 0.0789513811469078, 0.026198366656899452, -0.02494514361023903, -0.03719528019428253, 0.016788529232144356, 0.03490397334098816, -0.00848332792520523, -0.021808305755257607, -0.06923241913318634, 0.008958408609032631, 0.01068290788680315, 0.017591044306755066, 0.02488897740840912, 0.0019263660069555044, 0.025224315002560616, 0.047096140682697296, -0.04919843003153801, 0.03407252952456474, 0.016493378207087517, -0.001619728747755289, -0.04790686070919037, 0.022235816344618797, -0.03717370703816414, 0.025817742571234703, -0.03840052708983421, 0.02322516404092312, -0.018181731924414635, -0.008637511171400547, 0.02366156317293644, 0.01567954383790493, 0.07078509777784348, -0.05084261670708656, -0.054886605590581894, -0.03553417697548866, -0.01589624583721161, -0.06913695484399796, -0.05330440774559975, 0.005855931900441647, -0.0017495793290436268, -0.024925803765654564, 0.013169758953154087, -0.01657039299607277, 0.006776853930205107, 0.014300990849733353, -0.0076926168985664845, 0.008726588450372219, -0.056987468153238297, -0.008552514016628265, -0.059356071054935455, 0.035740967839956284, 0.015754040330648422, -0.031248006969690323, -0.011651800945401192, 0.024083346128463745, -0.03313272446393967, 0.010534885339438915, -0.014268601313233376, -0.01190852839499712, 0.04344133660197258, -0.033004339784383774, -0.03925241902470589, -0.05749145895242691, 0.030149266123771667, 0.020527873188257217, 0.015259725973010063, -0.0096514280885458, 0.007866309955716133, -0.00699973851442337, 0.041854046285152435, 0.05173102021217346, 0.01903172954916954, -0.04176686331629753, 0.02069130726158619, -0.0448385514318943, 0.037612009793519974, -0.008107726462185383, -0.028270646929740906, 0.10529185086488724, 0.04271981865167618, 0.06709815561771393, 0.032102666795253754, 0.032277464866638184, -0.04110631346702576, 0.01861491985619068, 0.036852963268756866, 0.005851485766470432, -0.027083083987236023, -0.033123452216386795, -0.030128056183457375, -0.027156593278050423, 0.00006451999070122838, 0.02417561039328575, -0.03093688189983368, -0.03602609038352966, -0.011883114464581013, 0.008504901081323624, -0.027077024802565575, -0.0184664074331522, -0.07200782746076584, 0.0222091693431139, 0.013761111535131931, -0.04172417148947716, 0.03411063924431801, 0.015189528465270996, -0.0009375216322951019, 0.03151746094226837, -0.0020314257126301527, -0.10402896255254745, 0.035137154161930084, 0.014744734391570091, -0.003852511988952756, -0.033057648688554764, -0.03416145592927933, -0.04152381420135498, -0.017056019976735115, 0.0013019053731113672, 0.04942044988274574, -0.012651906348764896, 0.019086580723524094, 0.0192479956895113, 0.0041457428596913815, 0.11279218643903732, -0.026213884353637695, -0.03952819108963013, -0.019747445359826088, -0.020793085917830467, -0.007650646381080151, -0.010563432238996029, 0.09119020402431488, -0.015203560702502728, 0.0013561001978814602, 0.048972614109516144, 0.013505995273590088, 0.04723150283098221, -0.03519648313522339, 0.0011851616436615586, 0.01357246283441782, 0.008741406723856926, -0.004136734642088413, 0.03392890468239784, -0.01631985977292061, 0.0154736852273345, -0.05310576781630516, 0.0546051487326622, -0.06666800379753113, -0.01112290658056736, -0.006143778096884489, 0.08502823114395142, -0.01090999785810709, 0.07517408579587936, -0.008907263167202473, -0.02122432552278042, 0.0034532819408923388, 0.0759030431509018, 0.040707867592573166, -0.02339816465973854, -0.026155391708016396, 0.043271008878946304, 0.036054372787475586, 0.007688702549785376, -0.023643692955374718, -0.02901899255812168, 0.028004705905914307, -0.03547976166009903, 0.001234707422554493, 0.05783917009830475, 0.06966421008110046, 0.009893199428915977, -0.019519813358783722, -0.005523649509996176, -0.10892395675182343, 0.02349570207297802, 0.0532059408724308, 0.055803000926971436, 0.07464898377656937, 0.003090802812948823, -0.0009339085663668811, -0.030277522280812263, 0.041961006820201874, 0.006437892559915781, 0.02567850612103939, 0.02189434878528118, 0.07311820983886719, -0.015728145837783813, -0.024460002779960632, 0.06782250851392746, -0.048934467136859894, 0.07237278670072556, -0.05329229682683945, -0.04684308543801308, 0.021975398063659668, -0.019129697233438492, 0.02826486900448799, 0.019181126728653908, 0.020802227780222893, -0.004904023837298155, -0.03204948827624321, -0.012911545112729073, -0.034917835146188736, -0.008297951892018318, 0.03959948942065239, -0.05053180456161499, 0.02236993983387947, -0.023218540474772453, -0.05074368417263031, 0.03141218051314354, 0.0034018924925476313, 0.018160855397582054, 0.007308770902454853, 0.004552146885544062, -0.0744984820485115, -0.04235003516077995, 0.003003787947818637, -0.036232855170965195, 0.0003798947436735034, -0.06626860052347183, -0.021527839824557304, -0.00012126688670832664, -0.023507971316576004, 0.021632451564073563, 0.015808016061782837, -0.03283798694610596, 0.01368369348347187, -0.0032110344618558884, 0.031476400792598724, -0.02510111965239048, 0.006296108942478895, 0.030850958079099655, -0.016131926327943802, -0.058430347591638565, -0.009235422126948833, 0.026161769405007362, -0.004184188786894083, -0.02971627190709114, -0.011860614642500877, 0.06385229527950287, 0.006888182833790779, -0.003009590320289135, 0.004259548150002956, -0.02452784962952137, -0.030637647956609726, -0.024929435923695564, -0.04172012209892273, 0.02629133127629757, 0.017301827669143677, -0.00008816897025099024, -0.012347312644124031, 0.037224769592285156, -0.051338355988264084, 0.012956013903021812, 0.00759399076923728, 0.025476321578025818, -0.03141612932085991, -0.023455685004591942, -0.00044286559568718076, -0.0017216098494827747, -0.01910489611327648, -0.10471995174884796, 0.01421437133103609, -0.010504698380827904, -0.026010435074567795, 0.007651363033801317, -0.02480912394821644, -0.0274485033005476, -0.023777814581990242, -0.04002891108393669, 0.03269871696829796, -0.035192765295505524, 0.023227762430906296, -0.024957288056612015, -0.06122516840696335, 0.08211962133646011, -0.04352480173110962, 0.006598657462745905, 0.00023958623933140188, 0.008480018936097622 ]
<p>I am unclear about how to interpret the value of the Standard Error of the Mean (SEM) directly. For example, when a mean is reported as 5.00 + 0.50SEM, how do you directly relate the 0.50 to 5.00?</p> <p>To quickly run through the basic theory concerning the standard error: </p> <ol> <li>The standard deviation (SD) is a measure of dispersion around the mean </li> <li>The SEM is the SD of the sampling distribution for the sample mean</li> <li>This sampling distribution is derived from the means of an infinite number of samples from a statistical population and is normally distributed according to the Central Limit Theorem</li> <li>In a normal distribution, 68.3% of (randomly selected) values fall within +1SD, 95.4% +2SD and 99.7% +3SD</li> <li>The SEM decreases with increasing sample size</li> </ol> <p>QUESTION 1: Given points 2) and 4) is it correct to interpret the SEM in the same way as SD as a descriptive statistic? That is, for a sample with mean 5.00 and SEM 0.50, is it correct to conclude the true population mean lies between 4.50 and 5.50 with probability 68.3%?</p> <p>QUESTION 2: For a given statistical population being sampled, does the sampling distribution change with sample size (given point 5)? i.e. should point 3) be: "...derived from the means of an infinite number of samples of a given size from a statistical population..."? </p> <p>QUESTION 3: Since the SEM is not calculated directly but estimated from the SD of a sample, what effect does departure from a normal distribution of the sample have on calculation of the SEM? Put another way, if a sample has for example a highly skewed distribution, calculating the SD is inappropriate (it is a property of a normal distribution only), so can the SEM still be estimated reliably from the SD?</p>
g48370
[ 0.010367470793426037, -0.0434727780520916, -0.00460315914824605, -0.02477714978158474, -0.034056611359119415, 0.006539240945130587, -0.0036688244435936213, 0.05518519878387451, -0.03476259112358093, -0.024985894560813904, 0.004727169871330261, -0.02711605280637741, 0.05855031684041023, 0.005901483818888664, -0.006366169545799494, -0.028836697340011597, 0.06049544736742973, -0.032868195325136185, 0.016574013978242874, 0.04968087002635002, -0.016628922894597054, 0.014642449095845222, -0.010565207339823246, -0.10526135563850403, -0.004386056214570999, -0.015442747622728348, 0.019905075430870056, 0.10084003955125809, -0.02500516176223755, 0.013965182937681675, -0.040598101913928986, 0.005211821291595697, 0.03802885487675667, -0.03922133892774582, -0.002235961612313986, -0.026890696957707405, 0.0494268499314785, 0.04261845350265503, -0.011600370518863201, 0.020513178780674934, -0.002854754915460944, -0.06722532957792282, 0.04548834636807442, -0.020871620625257492, 0.037251830101013184, 0.020956819877028465, -0.027018198743462563, 0.026875929906964302, 0.04188399016857147, -0.0008158583077602088, -0.04397314041852951, -0.012325750663876534, 0.037914931774139404, 0.008383173495531082, 0.013670467771589756, 0.03238338977098465, 0.02359353005886078, 0.004226222168654203, 0.016849976032972336, -0.018756091594696045, 0.00013886303349863738, -0.029436253011226654, -0.06305590271949768, 0.00989928375929594, -0.006442611571401358, 0.0314461886882782, -0.010272946208715439, 0.013149628415703773, 0.0108320452272892, 0.021475203335285187, 0.0480806939303875, -0.07799407094717026, 0.024207426235079765, -0.0463569201529026, -0.11385403573513031, 0.00042833504267036915, -0.011465281248092651, -0.005930126179009676, 0.014498063363134861, 0.0396120548248291, -0.057732392102479935, -0.03240339085459709, -0.016002511605620384, -0.02034713886678219, 0.00704445643350482, 0.03812577575445175, -0.00846092402935028, 0.026072634384036064, 0.025362582877278328, 0.01738741621375084, -0.01814870536327362, -0.005102101713418961, 0.04312002286314964, 0.0348864309489727, -0.03959726169705391, -0.04716544970870018, 0.011292191222310066, -0.021625440567731857, 0.025150876492261887, -0.027389544993638992, 0.00025117112090811133, -0.023852484300732613, -0.020515283569693565, 0.02294955961406231, -0.032093435525894165, 0.06090419739484787, 0.04638185352087021, 0.0513559952378273, 0.01517935935407877, -0.0636456161737442, -0.020697278901934624, -0.06181725859642029, -0.06285832077264786, -0.060997869819402695, -0.055079907178878784, -0.01225005742162466, 0.03837873041629791, 0.016874173656105995, 0.01812695898115635, -0.00469871424138546, 0.01575564593076706, 0.007785187568515539, 0.04411220923066139, 0.07256422191858292, -0.03782730922102928, 0.001412565354257822, 0.01772020012140274, 0.010458809323608875, 0.009858591482043266, -0.009023449383676052, -0.02788069099187851, -0.007815401069819927, -0.022133253514766693, -0.004055652767419815, 0.04604586586356163, 0.022440828382968903, 0.029352063313126564, 0.03689251467585564, -0.013524983078241348, 0.015311496332287788, 0.012567524798214436, 0.020984167233109474, 0.039385706186294556, 0.011026417836546898, -0.0021115769632160664, 0.03264929726719856, 0.015482150949537754, 0.01149570383131504, -0.01558433286845684, 0.017621904611587524, -0.022344782948493958, 0.054479435086250305, -0.006030196789652109, 0.02647428773343563, -0.03834310919046402, 0.033257897943258286, -0.009526297450065613, -0.005556302610784769, -0.021161722019314766, -0.0313594713807106, 0.04261479154229164, -0.044736701995134354, -0.03973209112882614, 0.02745215594768524, -0.022665010765194893, -0.00461779348552227, 0.04152248054742813, -0.06470012664794922, -0.022485509514808655, 0.01827002689242363, -0.004004425834864378, 0.015745658427476883, -0.02436256781220436, -0.02807420864701271, -0.041273798793554306, 0.027975622564554214, 0.0336296409368515, -0.06503042578697205, 0.025871794670820236, 0.018298598006367683, -0.023700717836618423, 0.034178026020526886, 0.020224133506417274, -0.06586872041225433, 0.02785903587937355, -0.01336692925542593, 0.03017079085111618, -0.04772794991731644, 0.02858593314886093, -0.012883664108812809, -0.029142068699002266, -0.035691577941179276, 0.021226435899734497, 0.028299326077103615, -0.061014868319034576, -0.023882398381829262, 0.03906871750950813, -0.005790397524833679, -0.02322903648018837, -0.02423904277384281, -0.004008094780147076, 0.03359546884894371, -0.06343120336532593, -0.019329480826854706, 0.011912486515939236, -0.016631772741675377, -0.03683653846383095, -0.008464899845421314, -0.03308182582259178, 0.014135759323835373, 0.0013347876956686378, -0.012096862308681011, -0.058696843683719635, 0.018926406279206276, 0.038116198033094406, 0.005576525814831257, -0.04355662688612938, -0.018371084704995155, 0.007293618284165859, 0.02637982740998268, -0.003050683531910181, -0.011253819800913334, 0.03326529264450073, 0.032536838203668594, -0.001571409753523767, 0.0092411944642663, 0.024095244705677032, -0.0030299173668026924, 0.02062695287168026, 0.034673675894737244, -0.07225430756807327, -0.060998156666755676, 0.0013845263747498393, 0.02504918724298477, 0.007742776535451412, -0.010326159186661243, -0.006712921895086765, -0.019220830872654915, 0.0061564878560602665, -0.04283047094941139, 0.06278402358293533, -0.0071396129205822945, -0.04875939339399338, 0.01590004190802574, -0.02719825506210327, -0.03484193980693817, 0.07273021340370178, -0.029424214735627174, 0.0012475012335926294, -0.013939817436039448, -0.03692339360713959, 0.030151283368468285, 0.043458957225084305, -0.03798959031701088, 0.06076306477189064, -0.04791898652911186, 0.005390403792262077, 0.030254192650318146, 0.0059149195440113544, -0.013280992396175861, -0.07284344732761383, -0.013345841318368912, 0.0017967066960409284, 0.020119592547416687, 0.03311999514698982, -0.022670654579997063, 0.007929636165499687, 0.060642778873443604, 0.014378879219293594, -0.029775211587548256, 0.04680784419178963, 0.04028637707233429, 0.05095769837498665, 0.10368029773235321, 0.008924713358283043, -0.012076080776751041, -0.026550889015197754, -0.010969600640237331, 0.05558530613780022, -0.0467713288962841, -0.01889338716864586, -0.009722042828798294, 0.012823118828237057, 0.02913644351065159, 0.042430732399225235, -0.009262315928936005, -0.008471572771668434, -0.045074231922626495, 0.000360535632353276, -0.046616338193416595, -0.04896090179681778, 0.003766204696148634, -0.029011748731136322, 0.00985017605125904, 0.0062457057647407055, 0.0751350075006485, 0.0039605931378901005, -0.07422686368227005, 0.006157406605780125, 0.021465836092829704, -0.05130095034837723, 0.026449907571077347, -0.054645389318466187, 0.0301017165184021, 0.007755942642688751, 0.07383595407009125, -0.026341604068875313, 0.014105839654803276, 0.00513624120503664, -0.0034543564543128014, -0.023060530424118042, -0.013164578005671501, 0.027097072452306747, -0.0644649937748909, -0.043532706797122955, 0.03370549902319908, 0.038464006036520004, -0.023771880194544792, -0.002161287236958742, -0.017472591251134872, 0.035343021154403687, -0.011787344701588154, -0.02400275692343712, 0.05648014694452286, -0.008562134578824043, -0.0030855131335556507, -0.06354442238807678, 0.037279509007930756, -0.026399292051792145, -0.01578599028289318, 0.025205541402101517, -0.02141421101987362, -0.05242335796356201, 0.0005696892039850354, -0.005228014197200537, -0.021088263019919395, 0.008696743287146091, -0.020258093252778053, 0.046092987060546875, -0.007997773587703705, -0.012292519211769104, -0.029778629541397095, -0.08552692085504532, 0.005372888408601284, 0.0236823633313179, -0.05887294560670853, 0.021648403257131577, 0.01105564832687378, -0.027935771271586418, 0.01670173928141594, 0.05393097549676895, -0.008116696029901505, -0.03449228033423424, 0.00347558269277215, -0.018992919474840164, 0.05402035266160965, 0.03783123195171356, 0.03487326204776764, -0.02638770453631878, -0.0400405079126358, 0.08195597678422928, 0.0039281090721488, 0.0003443206660449505, 0.05143019184470177, 0.011815223842859268, 0.018124371767044067, 0.005639494862407446, 0.03779125586152077, 0.036007359623909, -0.07333866506814957, -0.06470581889152527, 0.020899953320622444, -0.0079380227252841, -0.04280754178762436, -0.0077818273566663265, -0.04892917722463608, 0.03221242502331734, 0.06228373572230339, -0.06287585198879242, 0.047453537583351135, 0.0765821635723114, 0.06327702105045319, -0.05958058312535286, -0.05794677138328552, 0.06840028613805771, -0.04883758723735809, -0.026885800063610077, -0.007096760906279087, -0.030025664716959, -0.036873526871204376, 0.024950208142399788, -0.06948639452457428, -0.014424373395740986, 0.03360775485634804, 0.07604862749576569, 0.007219450082629919, 0.03466746211051941, 0.06310669332742691, -0.009994082152843475, 0.05313415825366974, 0.04262528568506241, -0.0189779382199049, 0.01332301925867796, -0.0007580325473099947, -0.001002178410999477, 0.013789776712656021, -0.005617048591375351, -0.02812780626118183, -0.013466986827552319, 0.004971188493072987, -0.02201332151889801, 0.004433833062648773, -0.0066329678520560265, -0.01213875599205494, 0.06955616176128387, 0.025225035846233368, 0.012354899197816849, 0.00850705523043871, -0.029117673635482788, 0.04983402043581009, -0.032371290028095245, -0.02037977986037731, -0.030819447711110115, -0.03571806848049164, 0.00039396522333845496, 0.02172454446554184, -0.014314091764390469, 0.01653759367763996, 0.05357156693935394, -0.03503269702196121, 0.01997973397374153, 0.09583409875631332, -0.03148583322763443, 0.08131576329469681, -0.0013628136366605759, -0.0004522769886534661, 0.015435688197612762, 0.042746514081954956, -0.08700468391180038, -0.06913769245147705, -0.05196288973093033, 0.018679069355130196, 0.0005757733015343547, 0.014708947390317917, -0.008141370490193367, 0.022402267903089523, -0.04534810408949852, -0.026892410591244698, 0.00025359084247611463, -0.0016299240523949265, -0.006886414252221584, 0.06020546704530716, -0.058746837079524994, -0.02476593293249607, -0.022979598492383957, -0.011404817923903465, -0.021233489736914635, 0.07528027892112732, -0.03257085382938385, 0.022369029000401497, -0.02185136266052723, 0.013337807729840279, -0.09384311735630035, 0.00029835154418833554, -0.06983058899641037, -0.002900137798860669, -0.032473124563694, -0.0004464541270863265, -0.0033756231423467398, 0.010534081608057022, -0.03230307996273041, -0.014630436897277832, 0.0439249612390995, -0.07146112620830536, -0.001494983327575028, 0.040582578629255295, -0.04536282271146774, -0.04532549902796745, 0.003616333706304431, -0.03987037390470505, 0.017024727538228035, -0.08496272563934326, 0.03881693258881569, 0.020951461046934128, 0.026241572573781013, 0.02217690646648407, 0.030162382870912552, -0.09498560428619385, 0.0549510233104229, -0.02168515883386135, 0.003056213492527604, 0.026219801977276802, 0.0520659014582634, 0.0048412480391561985, -0.013306728564202785, -0.026533188298344612, 0.05156628414988518, -0.00657346285879612, -0.026731159538030624, 0.0013309731148183346, -0.0056318920105695724, 0.05499918758869171, -0.03619544953107834, -0.012672764249145985, 0.010209793224930763, -0.007212699856609106, 0.07193241268396378, 0.006516966503113508, 0.019945550709962845, 0.025678863748908043, 0.006396070588380098, 0.007379715796560049, 0.07316428422927856, -0.012182249687612057, -0.012032268568873405, -0.034887369722127914, -0.0367998406291008, -0.026831794530153275, -0.009248404763638973, 0.04873046651482582, 0.0322093740105629, 0.010688608512282372, 0.0018918088171631098, -0.06500888615846634, -0.016758529469370842, -0.08117863535881042, -0.00008111767965601757, 0.04028359055519104, 0.0005377299385145307, -0.018565598875284195, 0.019724564626812935, 0.06432392448186874, -0.01663045771420002, -0.01958903670310974, 0.029028212651610374, -0.025513270869851112, -0.05043019726872444, 0.025997525081038475, 0.020426752045750618, 0.006134615279734135, -0.009830638766288757, 0.009209323674440384, 0.027714360505342484, 0.038758158683776855, 0.0336320698261261, 0.02766546607017517, 0.035074833780527115, -0.011655357666313648, 0.05657213553786278, 0.002878231229260564, -0.010883880779147148, 0.09400912374258041, 0.0017818117048591375, 0.021397650241851807, -0.025467611849308014, 0.06225648522377014, 0.005133851896971464, 0.00931329745799303, 0.012695257551968098, 0.00723090348765254, 0.00732602272182703, -0.06327541917562485, 0.008018000051379204, -0.00906782690435648, 0.013678186573088169, -0.09213441610336304, -0.018595660105347633, -0.016274787485599518, -0.01616140827536583, 0.03957096487283707, 0.01927287131547928, 0.0038427161052823067, -0.0003056312270928174, 0.005843588151037693, 0.02895943820476532, -0.020291583612561226, -0.029092935845255852, 0.00202082353644073, 0.011377833783626556, -0.05876375362277031, -0.0192280150949955, -0.01865338161587715, 0.008107950910925865, -0.04128351807594299, -0.06276465207338333, 0.06525927037000656, -0.015119730494916439, -0.02682960033416748, 0.04518436640501022, -0.03326106071472168, 0.03983107581734657, 0.04225586727261543, 0.04039183631539345, -0.0036739278584718704, 0.0005901841213926673, -0.038069091737270355, 0.016318606212735176, -0.0567631796002388, -0.018942585214972496, -0.008093830198049545, 0.010221592150628567, 0.02493378520011902, 0.0003524680796544999, -0.03664327785372734, 0.03136809542775154, -0.0051507712341845036, -0.011776507832109928, -0.0004696384130511433, 0.014838294126093388, -0.021489739418029785, -0.017459921538829803, -0.033376675099134445, 0.04071952402591705, -0.003648979589343071, 0.027727151289582253, 0.017726220190525055, -0.08487172424793243, -0.00022438992164097726, -0.006317400373518467, 0.016101917251944542, 0.03144804388284683, -0.032936982810497284, 0.022654369473457336, 0.006555609405040741, -0.020308014005422592, 0.019484829157590866, 0.04031262546777725, 0.04418186843395233, 0.07002977281808853, -0.01651446521282196, -0.016708645969629288, 0.004507716279476881, 0.0033987867645919323, 0.019650394096970558, -0.044048476964235306, 0.026814868673682213, -0.018856223672628403, 0.06981803476810455, 0.04600498825311661, 0.04953792691230774, -0.049183301627635956, -0.0036783756222575903, 0.0038660287391394377, -0.015299108810722828, -0.09141039848327637, -0.056604042649269104, 0.0100790336728096, 0.05290781334042549, -0.009961636736989021, 0.009027981199324131, -0.0076650893315672874, -0.005960495211184025, -0.02543155662715435, 0.01150039117783308, 0.0690065547823906, 0.05610781908035278, 0.052157387137413025, 0.053891781717538834, 0.06721103191375732, -0.08991104364395142, 0.004272605758160353, 0.001648622564971447, 0.009294452145695686, -0.06450343877077103, -0.05504659563302994, 0.026907486841082573, 0.013426416553556919, -0.02511643059551716, -0.03998956456780434, -0.07266350835561752, 0.02422698587179184, -0.001847394392825663, 0.016769185662269592, -0.0032656530383974314, 0.008791192434728146, 0.030968939885497093, -0.058335836976766586, 0.04959047585725784, -0.050103023648262024, -0.0006924792542122304, 0.026024645194411278, -0.03630388155579567, -0.022301189601421356, 0.026457801461219788, -0.04173685237765312, 0.040477801114320755, -0.021675311028957367, -0.00033964469912461936, 0.04172743856906891, -0.016938073560595512, -0.0041924286633729935, -0.02380845695734024, 0.004582997411489487, 0.006706461310386658, -0.009435964748263359, 0.016947465017437935, 0.0229580607265234, 0.056848518550395966, 0.04370829835534096, 0.027694066986441612, 0.003581459866836667, -0.01120074838399887, 0.004619290120899677, 0.013819901272654533, -0.0037978996988385916, -0.06580175459384918, 0.012769120745360851, -0.025988860055804253, -0.04846525564789772, -0.09956769645214081, -0.02438732609152794, -0.01406294945627451, -0.002101222751662135, 0.03966977074742317, -0.002473159460350871, 0.025799183174967766, -0.016174467280507088, -0.03486808016896248, 0.01172975730150938, 0.004186950623989105, -0.008648140355944633, 0.07380208373069763, 0.03922360762953758, -0.005739252548664808, -0.025565695017576218, 0.000990876229479909, -0.011186004616320133, 0.05593733489513397, 0.048317115753889084, 0.002220338210463524, -0.032811038196086884, 0.03578197583556175, -0.05193726718425751, -0.03312857449054718, -0.026381025090813637, 0.028795571997761726, 0.06138859689235687, -0.025282878428697586, -0.05150007829070091, 0.025362089276313782, -0.05149218067526817, 0.06045469269156456, 0.06695359200239182, 0.017391076311469078, -0.02055092342197895, 0.010161240585148335, 0.002369459019973874, -0.06282039731740952, -0.06277940422296524, -0.008964723907411098, -0.032953739166259766, 0.029812095686793327, 0.005677460227161646, 0.0894496962428093, 0.011138827539980412, -0.018660113215446472, 0.0681387186050415, -0.02574453316628933, 0.05569180101156235, -0.020067395642399788, 0.0013025101507082582, -0.0851035937666893, -0.01140927616506815, 0.08253373950719833, -0.03230077773332596, -0.05584212765097618, -0.011276757344603539, 0.04252941161394119 ]
<p>I've been working with spatial autocorrelation for a while and now I'm trying to move from more traditional estimators such as Moran's I or Geary's C to the new APLE estimator. I read Li's papers on APLE and also the reference on R-project. But I am still missing something very basic, as I still didn't understand something: the results of the APLE statistic are said to have a closed form but I didn't figure which one it is.</p> <p>For instance, while Moran's I can gom from -1 to 1, I couldn't figure which are the possible boundaries of APLE statistics. More interesting, I've been running tests in my older data, using the spdep package in R, and it seems to me that APLE can go up to 2. Any one has any hint on that? Please, any insights here would be very much appreciated.</p>
g48374
[ 0.03045525588095188, -0.06888362020254135, 0.0072002112865448, -0.03441806882619858, -0.04602047801017761, -0.013826693408191204, 0.07921819388866425, 0.006354872602969408, -0.031297627836465836, -0.021508753299713135, 0.032254111021757126, 0.037131596356630325, 0.056255586445331573, -0.024376623332500458, 0.02192283421754837, -0.027692222967743874, 0.04137171432375908, -0.03675542399287224, -0.023855306208133698, -0.018911374732851982, 0.007408763747662306, -0.015700045973062515, 0.03284486010670662, -0.06450894474983215, 0.031186794862151146, -0.05074088275432587, -0.0030578062869608402, 0.01668563485145569, -0.05684857815504074, -0.023118918761610985, 0.09042670577764511, -0.05990345776081085, 0.03281170874834061, -0.10407771915197372, 0.00787037331610918, 0.03131566569209099, 0.07910872995853424, -0.007128078490495682, 0.016701584681868553, 0.04846281185746193, 0.021005742251873016, 0.010613912716507912, 0.04234390705823898, 0.025055212900042534, 0.010055474005639553, 0.0338759571313858, -0.0650087371468544, -0.016459990292787552, 0.011137585155665874, -0.01258770376443863, -0.04760931432247162, 0.10779936611652374, -0.019132673740386963, -0.008486907929182053, 0.010401155799627304, -0.006123831029981375, -0.01109256874769926, 0.0010954886674880981, 0.05937721207737923, -0.02821904607117176, 0.02378339320421219, -0.029774589464068413, 0.0021333503536880016, 0.01966572366654873, 0.07696694135665894, 0.006406303029507399, 0.015283401124179363, -0.04686889424920082, -0.01490487065166235, -0.02545340545475483, -0.004556337837129831, -0.028688576072454453, 0.03512101247906685, -0.05307885259389877, -0.05142425745725632, -0.07413146644830704, -0.00035841084900312126, -0.03268308565020561, 0.01322950329631567, 0.03628115355968475, -0.05300339683890343, -0.022899797186255455, 0.003908589016646147, -0.008173649199306965, 0.01750282570719719, 0.04515546187758446, 0.0701136514544487, 0.04113500192761421, -0.02630428969860077, 0.025373924523591995, 0.01169600524008274, 0.002244121627882123, 0.03241453692317009, 0.027722777798771858, -0.030298160389065742, 0.013419181108474731, -0.0674479752779007, 0.06599786132574081, 0.014091767370700836, 0.02178819105029106, -0.06252163648605347, 0.0030329034198075533, 0.059485550969839096, 0.04813976585865021, -0.028101526200771332, -0.028641019016504288, 0.026004193350672722, -0.039781928062438965, 0.020391395315527916, 0.01696798950433731, 0.0023249841760843992, 0.020962970331311226, -0.02663680911064148, 0.007783725392073393, -0.03039802424609661, -0.03605705127120018, 0.061881981790065765, -0.05060727521777153, 0.11922982335090637, 0.020273400470614433, 0.020170453935861588, 0.002035832265391946, 0.009917642921209335, 0.01861632615327835, -0.03051932528614998, -0.030335944145917892, 0.013887638226151466, 0.012132083997130394, -0.012404277920722961, 0.025256706401705742, 0.0038176311645656824, -0.025836294516921043, -0.014090737327933311, 0.01871194876730442, 0.04004059359431267, 0.0056345174089074135, -0.021045377478003502, -0.015299846418201923, 0.02303832396864891, -0.005784431006759405, -0.021674523130059242, 0.029307294636964798, 0.04157986491918564, 0.006792936474084854, -0.0037796092219650745, 0.013958727940917015, 0.015194544568657875, -0.0037804043386131525, -0.03267747536301613, 0.026392588391900063, 0.051688116043806076, 0.0008649814408272505, -0.04072509706020355, 0.07304149866104126, -0.06352583318948746, -0.009472424164414406, -0.08723057061433792, -0.0745868980884552, 0.028815289959311485, -0.03734859824180603, 0.0095522440969944, -0.04254943132400513, 0.007454811129719019, -0.02540564350783825, -0.012941369786858559, -0.016798056662082672, -0.0014400805812329054, -0.03993954136967659, -0.010254145599901676, -0.0637921541929245, 0.012380358763039112, 0.02165694162249565, 0.02286478504538536, -0.053263623267412186, -0.011180657893419266, 0.03219826519489288, -0.009721045382320881, -0.01866903342306614, 0.08050557225942612, -0.014789833687245846, 0.017853036522865295, -0.0005766895483247936, 0.039072588086128235, 0.0023861238732934, 0.017743892967700958, -0.044088125228881836, -0.09391423314809799, 0.013484928756952286, -0.04750405251979828, 0.005005181767046452, 0.0611959770321846, -0.03675202280282974, -0.03947155177593231, -0.03249186649918556, -0.03315136581659317, -0.00019047247769776732, -0.016696345061063766, -0.0671139732003212, -0.03478044271469116, -0.022037392482161522, 0.004959368612617254, 0.03654717281460762, -0.029928257688879967, 0.06457251310348511, 0.02788301184773445, -0.01964190974831581, -0.02769426256418228, 0.006064196582883596, -0.0065124304965138435, 0.03158741816878319, -0.02593247964978218, -0.0023292675614356995, -0.020671654492616653, 0.031583793461322784, 0.024150019511580467, 0.028157273307442665, -0.025119271129369736, 0.017585355788469315, 0.05720401182770729, -0.028252702206373215, -0.016438692808151245, -0.0256456658244133, 0.039773743599653244, 0.06152356415987015, 0.037489138543605804, 0.0020644867327064276, 0.05680413916707039, 0.04349666088819504, -0.014573948457837105, 0.0333133339881897, -0.03881269693374634, 0.012947827577590942, 0.016268853098154068, -0.049712177366018295, 0.021380368620157242, -0.0002543495502322912, -0.02868686616420746, 0.009705482982099056, -0.02469024248421192, -0.022899212315678596, -0.01871873252093792, 0.037803392857313156, -0.02101900987327099, -0.0008161276928149164, 0.0847100019454956, -0.001817008713260293, 0.04395199939608574, 0.03341948240995407, 0.006497637368738651, 0.09619013965129852, -0.009667973965406418, 0.057249706238508224, -0.0202633086591959, 0.02831200882792473, -0.005446738097816706, -0.014526747167110443, 0.033720724284648895, 0.03008132055401802, -0.05654068663716316, -0.009571503847837448, -0.0492728129029274, -0.01027517020702362, 0.04524916782975197, -0.031464941799640656, 0.011913442984223366, -0.026466045528650284, 0.03315487876534462, 0.02500341460108757, 0.06200973317027092, 0.01847526803612709, -0.026851454749703407, 0.02337304875254631, 0.04714982584118843, 0.01231550332158804, 0.010714908130466938, -0.008425120264291763, 0.025559652596712112, -0.05119485780596733, 0.018839817494153976, 0.02250533550977707, 0.008347046561539173, -0.05564308911561966, 0.04284915328025818, 0.024034935981035233, 0.033509835600852966, -0.055774543434381485, 0.0750768780708313, 0.01888084039092064, -0.020720478147268295, 0.025193285197019577, -0.012609145604074001, -0.011277718469500542, -0.03815847635269165, -0.011084242723882198, -0.020430270582437515, -0.03399411216378212, -0.05706365406513214, -0.009273652918636799, 0.08637165278196335, 0.005900803487747908, -0.031193863600492477, -0.02974354848265648, -0.02363804541528225, -0.04553529620170593, 0.043315593153238297, 0.003329123603180051, -0.026230070739984512, -0.04835233464837074, -0.014752484858036041, 0.026176119223237038, 0.01489131711423397, 0.031062887981534004, -0.04836364462971687, -0.06283853948116302, -0.004870839416980743, -0.03075903281569481, 0.04983846843242645, 0.027240650728344917, -0.06574764102697372, 0.003908411134034395, -0.002761343028396368, -0.06372092664241791, -0.012460148893296719, -0.03370150923728943, 0.008382809348404408, 0.036760181188583374, -0.07332509756088257, 0.031597722321748734, -0.056958358734846115, -0.01756969280540943, 0.05088285356760025, 0.020094918087124825, 0.02686573565006256, -0.00918114185333252, -0.02437198907136917, 0.041445303708314896, -0.006162104196846485, 0.06298235803842545, 0.016597524285316467, 0.023485032841563225, -0.02031651698052883, 0.004376669880002737, -0.062291622161865234, 0.021522555500268936, 0.020624492317438126, 0.057828307151794434, 0.011103852652013302, 0.0030712313018739223, -0.0033284518867731094, -0.018916044384241104, -0.002689348766580224, 0.03284129872918129, 0.03472474589943886, -0.016494443640112877, -0.011119156144559383, 0.051495373249053955, -0.03726959228515625, 0.004077827092260122, 0.050281427800655365, -0.008873231709003448, 0.005384292919188738, -0.012514002621173859, 0.02479427680373192, 0.018119795247912407, -0.0010226125596091151, -0.030245423316955566, -0.03279827907681465, 0.06358890980482101, 0.030298061668872833, -0.013748322613537312, 0.04706338793039322, -0.03688708320260048, 0.05106471851468086, 0.032126154750585556, -0.017917482182383537, 0.02559833601117134, 0.025023674592375755, 0.07316350191831589, -0.007587584666907787, 0.04017898440361023, -0.0001889012346509844, 0.047641269862651825, 0.017176078632473946, 0.06328821927309036, -0.047461383044719696, -0.05764353647828102, -0.012417272664606571, 0.031727585941553116, -0.028853043913841248, -0.07678879052400589, 0.07747688889503479, -0.054998740553855896, -0.006669918075203896, 0.02090713568031788, -0.005947939585894346, -0.030452489852905273, -0.023315824568271637, -0.011007891036570072, -0.01700894720852375, 0.012802344746887684, -0.05241955816745758, 0.023852944374084473, -0.027680018916726112, -0.004815709311515093, -0.0572773814201355, -0.0590018630027771, -0.02440752275288105, 0.005503664258867502, -0.015466365963220596, 0.045402441173791885, -0.05713186040520668, 0.026765016838908195, 0.037311263382434845, -0.08070287108421326, 0.053221579641103745, -0.03322732821106911, 0.028337804600596428, 0.0007154273916967213, -0.027143768966197968, 0.0500476136803627, -0.007141558453440666, 0.038689885288476944, -0.021853335201740265, 0.0006403502775356174, -0.019654303789138794, 0.0492686927318573, -0.024683162569999695, -0.023139646276831627, -0.002863961737602949, 0.021078987047076225, 0.02718144841492176, 0.0376468263566494, -0.005726144649088383, 0.03162122890353203, -0.050252608954906464, 0.009230331517755985, 0.049600809812545776, 0.017885731533169746, -0.02674053981900215, -0.09256073087453842, -0.02189146913588047, 0.00590858981013298, 0.07887051999568939, 0.0037469081580638885, 0.03883175179362297, 0.019837183877825737, -0.04490065574645996, -0.04447171837091446, 0.03583335503935814, -0.012517089024186134, -0.015458157286047935, -0.024593502283096313, -0.022372586652636528, 0.010886943899095058, 0.021564215421676636, -0.03430507704615593, -0.0055450513027608395, 0.03485501557588577, 0.007329424377530813, 0.03802013024687767, -0.00023152452195063233, -0.04529357701539993, -0.06732915341854095, -0.03368791192770004, 0.043389976024627686, 0.019674135372042656, -0.06297709792852402, -0.0752229243516922, 0.02160077542066574, -0.06268244981765747, -0.004655349534004927, 0.00896320678293705, -0.014580988325178623, -0.057694725692272186, -0.03470597788691521, 0.009419477544724941, -0.020674213767051697, -0.02492101863026619, -0.045923084020614624, -0.016075054183602333, -0.0347108319401741, 0.04727836698293686, -0.01601678878068924, 0.03066513128578663, -0.019969558343291283, 0.009131547063589096, -0.005408220458775759, -0.08616530895233154, 0.028612764552235603, -0.015705520287156105, -0.004156680777668953, -0.0010747896740213037, 0.01895897649228573, 0.04707762598991394, -0.022841932252049446, -0.0009277812205255032, 0.0195856261998415, 0.017844274640083313, 0.007271358743309975, 0.03426219895482063, -0.05153973400592804, 0.04062212258577347, 0.005505878012627363, -0.0017677715513855219, -0.008636076003313065, 0.010522546246647835, 0.027692120522260666, 0.005590961780399084, -0.019731735810637474, -0.06165691465139389, 0.02683967724442482, -0.014196332544088364, -0.015800390392541885, -0.035439182072877884, -0.00497646676376462, 0.02312895655632019, 0.011324462480843067, 0.07887177169322968, -0.04060708358883858, 0.014017663896083832, 0.05575728416442871, -0.011333306320011616, 0.02177472412586212, 0.029293831437826157, -0.016767103224992752, -0.010665166191756725, -0.00869460217654705, -0.00795077532529831, 0.03126749396324158, 0.0220507625490427, -0.017722034826874733, 0.018330179154872894, 0.0018411219352856278, -0.006564586888998747, -0.03385935723781586, -0.03337918967008591, -0.020787803456187248, 0.03365497291088104, 0.04788865149021149, 0.017529232427477837, 0.026790080592036247, 0.01171170361340046, -0.041477639228105545, -0.007854399271309376, -0.030223503708839417, -0.027381697669625282, 0.019616559147834778, 0.003274840535596013, -0.001234768657013774, -0.04586116969585419, 0.011434945277869701, -0.02690769173204899, -0.012980095110833645, -0.010369031690061092, -0.0353090800344944, -0.037714384496212006, 0.005778046324849129, -0.035526711493730545, -0.023450959473848343, 0.01111406460404396, -0.008348304778337479, -0.021020347252488136, 0.07614907622337341, 0.026826422661542892, -0.0558021143078804, -0.05314810201525688, 0.02794918231666088, 0.031865350902080536, -0.01994842104613781, 0.026954565197229385, 0.045442353934049606, -0.054911598563194275, 0.03871026635169983, 0.060884665697813034, 0.028696462512016296, 0.00307984440587461, 0.006988890469074249, 0.002001609653234482, 0.05530430004000664, 0.04198668524622917, 0.009468380361795425, -0.006581188645213842, 0.011774253100156784, -0.02906917594373226, -0.011080184020102024, 0.054351016879081726, -0.03811375051736832, 0.040101051330566406, -0.007033925037831068, -0.00930106546729803, -0.02966577559709549, -0.04091854393482208, 0.03868618980050087, 0.020831702277064323, -0.03499337285757065, 0.0030343763064593077, 0.014118948951363564, -0.000186574921826832, -0.007548126392066479, -0.005139641463756561, -0.0014442828251048923, 0.021322118118405342, 0.0855136513710022, -0.04251363128423691, -0.07297388464212418, 0.019831033423542976, 0.03204036131501198, 0.02510620839893818, 0.015565088018774986, -0.028629044070839882, -0.04179925099015236, 0.007013795431703329, 0.056069694459438324, 0.12702122330665588, 0.018379168584942818, -0.06439964473247528, -0.023945756256580353, -0.02136756107211113, -0.04754551127552986, 0.013026213273406029, 0.09062399715185165, -0.030943332239985466, -0.04045967012643814, 0.003707124385982752, 0.002842932939529419, -0.00829009898006916, -0.01581713557243347, -0.021227646619081497, 0.006254057865589857, -0.00396564370021224, -0.01754174567759037, 0.03302054479718208, -0.007847280241549015, 0.006706605665385723, -0.020276429131627083, 0.05226767435669899, -0.06735280901193619, 0.019060451537370682, 0.08130737394094467, 0.0422021821141243, 0.006185033358633518, 0.0007601200486533344, -0.00009845464228419587, -0.00801045261323452, 0.06296194344758987, -0.10834510624408722, 0.008084220811724663, 0.004109866917133331, -0.05906673148274422, 0.018833812326192856, 0.0581817701458931, -0.013959625735878944, -0.02265421487390995, -0.04328106716275215, 0.0125786317512393, 0.0018755702767521143, -0.000512334518134594, 0.055216822773218155, 0.031232241541147232, -0.007101485040038824, 0.027715299278497696, -0.018621671944856644, -0.0332043319940567, -0.034189995378255844, -0.03141017630696297, 0.017178239300847054, -0.003870734479278326, 0.012389457784593105, 0.005128368269652128, -0.03659211844205856, 0.013084781356155872, -0.05124877765774727, -0.03272610157728195, -0.01725579984486103, 0.022953957319259644, 0.09386000782251358, 0.020352844148874283, -0.02490743063390255, 0.00647812569513917, -0.008223621174693108, 0.005704798270016909, 0.0033507219050079584, 0.01940593682229519, 0.012308187782764435, -0.04317678511142731, 0.05038812756538391, -0.02832268550992012, 0.049718718975782394, 0.0021004732698202133, -0.03338880464434624, -0.026126673445105553, -0.024037059396505356, -0.040123097598552704, 0.0049449726939201355, -0.022242117673158646, -0.019347529858350754, -0.05280477926135063, 0.035032931715250015, -0.05293726176023483, 0.008609740994870663, 0.0364447645843029, 0.028523623943328857, -0.08570992201566696, 0.010259896516799927, 0.09811682999134064, 0.022005336359143257, -0.01994217000901699, -0.027176905423402786, 0.02153838984668255, -0.06643887609243393, -0.018696254119277, 0.044804226607084274, -0.026795409619808197, -0.027167797088623047, -0.013776375912129879, 0.026325952261686325, 0.036191176623106, -0.036122944205999374, -0.010389070957899094, -0.007230987306684256, 0.00031186110572889447, -0.016589056700468063, -0.022357825189828873, -0.005128800868988037, 0.036796934902668, 0.011268441565334797, 0.03635527193546295, 0.027533262968063354, 0.009904639795422554, -0.02166796289384365, -0.018188007175922394, -0.0034906170330941677, -0.0626935288310051, -0.04331424832344055, -0.02004018798470497, 0.03185085207223892, 0.049694012850522995, -0.03760246932506561, 0.010452781803905964, 0.025694360956549644, -0.05300735682249069, -0.02950335666537285, 0.10057448595762253, -0.02963491715490818, 0.0031051551923155785, -0.053417425602674484, 0.04781106859445572, 0.02618573047220707, 0.003835958195850253, -0.016789352521300316, -0.024948161095380783, 0.04241657629609108, -0.048409175127744675, 0.024226166307926178, 0.02512102574110031, -0.040693096816539764, -0.0001524431281723082, -0.021770363673567772, 0.05730656161904335, -0.004938035272061825, -0.0037344363518059254, -0.02088497206568718, -0.016277924180030823, 0.023485872894525528, 0.010794934816658497, -0.03664934262633324, -0.08046198636293411, -0.002357141114771366 ]
<p>My question might be easy for most of you to answer. I am starting to learn statistics and coding in R so my questions are on the basic level.</p> <p>I have a dataset of (two groups, replicates). My data is split based on the groups so I have 24 samples in group 1 and 20 samples in group 2. My data has replicates. So each set has 4 replicates, hence I have 6 sets in group 1 and 5 sets in group 2. Hence I have assigned indices to them to make it easier during permutation (indices from 1-11). What I want to do now is a routine permutation analysis to obtain the test statistic. I am using non paramteric method with resampling with replacement. </p> <p>My doubt\problem in R coding is that I have to pool the data together and then resample the groups. When I try to do this, <strong>I have to make sure I maintain the sample size for respective groups (that is after resampling the group lables, my new dataset should still contain 6 sets (24 samples) in group 1 and 5 sets (20 samples) in group 2.</strong> I am unable to achieve the latter. </p> <p>I tried something like this in my code:</p> <pre><code>n_resamples=100 permdat=function(dat){ for (i in 6:nc) { for (j in 1:n_resamples) { inds=unique(dat$ind) cc=dat$grp[dat$ind==inds] pcc=sample(cc,replace=T) ##for resampling with replacement #m&lt;-list() pdat=dat for(i in 1:length(inds)) { pdat$grp[pdat$ind==inds[i]]=pcc[i] #browser() } </code></pre> <p>This does not produce the desired result. Kindly help with R codes. </p> <p>Thanking you all for your help. :)</p> <p>Regards Ap</p>
g74059
[ -0.017154511064291, -0.047988880425691605, -0.004866970703005791, -0.07089653611183167, -0.05256957933306694, -0.030818991363048553, 0.004079139791429043, 0.016911327838897705, -0.051109783351421356, -0.0014770551351830363, 0.015028122812509537, -0.00017166926409117877, -0.041226498782634735, 0.0008414597832597792, -0.03280183672904968, 0.06569363921880722, 0.015743939206004143, -0.004239273257553577, -0.02027292177081108, 0.03727247193455696, -0.014139954932034016, -0.005078211426734924, 0.03231322020292282, -0.04050944373011589, -0.05988617613911629, -0.028182001784443855, 0.0350741408765316, 0.07365682721138, -0.035205114632844925, -0.06726342439651489, 0.009613562375307083, 0.04023982957005501, 0.042658835649490356, -0.04714584723114967, 0.01884087361395359, -0.01396984327584505, 0.026255588978528976, 0.05964898318052292, 0.04123592749238014, -0.004742387216538191, -0.016809333115816116, 0.053439121693372726, 0.05204655975103378, 0.0009041050216183066, 0.007239875383675098, -0.019973943009972572, 0.03141813725233078, -0.04403641074895859, 0.042807437479496, -0.033735569566488266, -0.008651208132505417, 0.06318192183971405, -0.030647963285446167, -0.015321342274546623, -0.008080952800810337, 0.052368391305208206, 0.002025993773713708, 0.026866130530834198, 0.02018757537007332, -0.013264240697026253, 0.029648039489984512, 0.0012767983134835958, -0.052813079208135605, -0.022073492407798767, -0.03007742390036583, 0.0012095635756850243, 0.030029144138097763, -0.03951726481318474, -0.00663586612790823, -0.028535129502415657, -0.04591693356633186, 0.0168389230966568, 0.010910548269748688, 0.0028319249395281076, -0.0507025420665741, -0.07895408570766449, 0.010071472264826298, 0.050006575882434845, 0.012211239896714687, -0.009218608029186726, 0.016774913296103477, -0.0170126985758543, 0.020133521407842636, 0.04944474995136261, -0.01598183438181877, 0.01784830540418625, -0.026043348014354706, -0.008540118113160133, 0.0004972674651071429, 0.07138489186763763, 0.026654856279492378, -0.07528325170278549, 0.05288024991750717, 0.0701739639043808, 0.00288348994217813, 0.013470250181853771, -0.05135932192206383, 0.07127579301595688, -0.03371037170290947, -0.02772778645157814, 0.07566015422344208, 0.028843676671385765, 0.03245740383863449, -0.06332845240831375, -0.03621956333518028, -0.03153550997376442, 0.04376047104597092, 0.010230020619928837, -0.022203227505087852, -0.007491234689950943, 0.0005388777353800833, -0.009739996865391731, -0.08231209963560104, -0.020767822861671448, -0.04746619984507561, -0.004844344686716795, 0.07222603261470795, -0.0030631464906036854, -0.07724280655384064, -0.03650161623954773, 0.03607379272580147, 0.009874550625681877, 0.046690069139003754, -0.0018168652895838022, 0.005104302428662777, -0.051579274237155914, -0.019709091633558273, 0.0678585097193718, 0.035090479999780655, 0.011087238788604736, -0.040624022483825684, -0.008335958234965801, -0.04672032967209816, 0.06819821149110794, 0.007730212062597275, 0.002416553208604455, 0.009179842658340931, 0.02394927479326725, -0.017461493611335754, -0.03823777288198471, -0.08152145892381668, 0.08693486452102661, 0.02887621708214283, -0.01622932218015194, 0.027522992342710495, -0.025987138971686363, -0.0062627121806144714, -0.034973591566085815, -0.012186410836875439, 0.04448607936501503, 0.08310205489397049, 0.014926313422620296, 0.0023431365843862295, -0.03801519796252251, -0.04328884929418564, 0.028019730001688004, -0.001456173020415008, -0.03606059402227402, 0.07384450733661652, 0.03484154865145683, 0.00018179604376200587, -0.050827573984861374, 0.007837104611098766, 0.016411153599619865, -0.016343137249350548, -0.00020840911020059139, 0.04630216956138611, -0.006915946025401354, -0.014384320005774498, -0.051772624254226685, -0.021190837025642395, 0.010589283891022205, -0.009368287399411201, -0.004031105898320675, -0.0772397592663765, 0.026574632152915, 0.011821058578789234, -0.004713866859674454, -0.02319677360355854, 0.032224010676145554, -0.008970890194177628, -0.03155679255723953, 0.0038786528166383505, -0.03944077342748642, 0.009829024784266949, 0.03681689500808716, -0.043383076786994934, -0.022459007799625397, -0.041242968291044235, -0.07356227189302444, -0.04564382880926132, -0.01286960020661354, 0.0018815823132172227, 0.008455016650259495, 0.009560231119394302, -0.008697157725691795, -0.019465560093522072, -0.06714028120040894, 0.001979649532586336, 0.05095589905977249, 0.01599827967584133, -0.000025947074391297065, -0.022307556122541428, 0.046326205134391785, 0.00990062952041626, -0.034688279032707214, -0.05097757652401924, -0.02422972582280636, -0.014771953225135803, 0.04725225269794464, 0.03439180925488472, 0.003513532457873225, 0.018353113904595375, 0.039298247545957565, 0.006661996245384216, 0.024008724838495255, -0.011953575536608696, 0.05414826050400734, 0.018528904765844345, 0.05052897706627846, -0.03418900817632675, 0.0027440316043794155, -0.03896855562925339, 0.03394356369972229, 0.015140886418521404, 0.02004760317504406, 0.04320603236556053, 0.03915964066982269, -0.029804997146129608, -0.003864111378788948, -0.0037851803936064243, 0.028400655835866928, -0.026938052847981453, -0.06855197995901108, -0.003353995969519019, 0.018141407519578934, 0.005205817986279726, -0.03113355115056038, -0.04648084565997124, -0.05431317910552025, -0.005428085569292307, -0.008912109769880772, -0.029354950413107872, 0.04361709952354431, 0.08531554788351059, 0.023167042061686516, 0.0607130266726017, -0.010094348341226578, 0.025161124765872955, 0.03275551274418831, 0.00442319642752409, -0.02415277250111103, -0.015254520811140537, 0.023719390854239464, 0.002964865183457732, -0.041574928909540176, 0.05978953093290329, 0.03646296262741089, 0.05528281256556511, 0.019080715253949165, -0.01515110395848751, 0.009316139854490757, 0.033369001001119614, 0.02135879546403885, -0.050424423068761826, 0.001900822389870882, -0.02970433048903942, -0.02872304432094097, -0.019157487899065018, 0.023044880479574203, -0.052634451538324356, -0.03082103095948696, 0.03449187055230141, 0.007177666760981083, 0.024187102913856506, 0.028479451313614845, -0.015010335482656956, 0.00009909614163916558, -0.06643051654100418, 0.01974729634821415, 0.03589494526386261, -0.01812996156513691, 0.038095537573099136, 0.004732346162199974, 0.04786143824458122, -0.007896004244685173, 0.07463639229536057, -0.04500691965222359, -0.020961862057447433, 0.05753743648529053, 0.022453323006629944, 0.0009712728206068277, 0.019218536093831062, -0.027667490765452385, 0.012210365384817123, -0.024216044694185257, -0.034889720380306244, -0.03299255669116974, 0.0513041727244854, -0.00420894380658865, -0.029643118381500244, 0.020583681762218475, -0.004239230416715145, 0.041621141135692596, 0.06403619050979614, -0.05414905399084091, -0.029506517574191093, 0.014729480259120464, -0.003210539696738124, 0.0147079573944211, 0.07404354214668274, -0.00169881631154567, -0.04806041345000267, -0.025058401748538017, -0.054424870759248734, -0.017451580613851547, 0.0049873292446136475, -0.052433669567108154, 0.040060579776763916, -0.05273997038602829, 0.008468523621559143, -0.009379827417433262, 0.0683910995721817, -0.01029042899608612, 0.005332910921424627, 0.0630788654088974, -0.03517178073525429, -0.005130185279995203, -0.02765778638422489, 0.00045104153105057776, -0.02808685041964054, 0.0275825634598732, 0.01389214489609003, -0.01829693838953972, -0.007660055533051491, -0.06097313389182091, -0.0026324084028601646, 0.01710290089249611, 0.03033105470240116, 0.024894485250115395, -0.01414499245584011, -0.008940576575696468, -0.028493545949459076, -0.020981663838028908, 0.01165328174829483, 0.04878191277384758, 0.0772143304347992, 0.005213885102421045, -0.007396663073450327, -0.014811890199780464, 0.002405360573902726, 0.0306220892816782, 0.028292013332247734, -0.07189574837684631, -0.04013824462890625, 0.042769063264131546, 0.004061026498675346, -0.04929301142692566, -0.00922861322760582, -0.007421816699206829, 0.040406014770269394, -0.04693462699651718, -0.03607090562582016, 0.02047557570040226, -0.009126866236329079, 0.04895849525928497, 0.052197545766830444, -0.00781422108411789, 0.06735385209321976, -0.008717496879398823, 0.019408265128731728, -0.03253208473324776, -0.020894596353173256, -0.008262882940471172, 0.008550354279577732, -0.005076639819890261, 0.05973222851753235, 0.03300270810723305, 0.015179823152720928, 0.06419935077428818, 0.009829401038587093, -0.0037489538080990314, 0.02393481321632862, -0.037859007716178894, -0.06489915400743484, -0.037147652357816696, 0.021138576790690422, 0.02821396104991436, -0.014291038736701012, 0.026075782254338264, -0.010243608616292477, -0.010867267847061157, -0.03582186996936798, 0.02175501361489296, 0.007166985888034105, -0.043236374855041504, -0.017695961520075798, 0.022925082594156265, -0.013498736545443535, 0.04788142815232277, -0.04546358808875084, -0.02917654998600483, 0.02508465014398098, -0.017646750435233116, -0.013717936351895332, -0.02312414161860943, -0.02817532606422901, 0.033030323684215546, -0.020157933235168457, 0.04677239805459976, -0.09675006568431854, -0.007867931388318539, 0.0019930205307900906, -0.037429552525281906, -0.0007306891493499279, 0.014771020971238613, 0.058358438313007355, 0.014813820831477642, 0.01943073607981205, 0.0023746415972709656, -0.09369030594825745, 0.04961817339062691, -0.002563789254054427, -0.004585994873195887, 0.023272905498743057, 0.047092143446207047, -0.021152757108211517, -0.0035831723362207413, 0.03827917203307152, -0.01868104189634323, -0.015621988102793694, 0.007614757400006056, -0.03868860751390457, 0.016623547300696373, -0.019165271893143654, -0.00007004301733104512, -0.052248649299144745, 0.021760335192084312, -0.07401446253061295, -0.043139927089214325, 0.040828414261341095, -0.03440024331212044, -0.02635066956281662, -0.006025548558682203, -0.004451109562069178, 0.03809024393558502, -0.06829272955656052, 0.06049575284123421, -0.004867576528340578, -0.009060998447239399, -0.005751700606197119, 0.031478047370910645, 0.04702185094356537, 0.002265690127387643, -0.005587006453424692, 0.01857692189514637, 0.009121990762650967, -0.03931715339422226, 0.000507450895383954, 0.05719446390867233, -0.01975393295288086, 0.005113313440233469, -0.0018587715458124876, -0.03596636280417442, -0.03126554191112518, -0.0007974448963068426, -0.037172846496105194, -0.03167679160833359, 0.03473952040076256, 0.012258574366569519, -0.0007062101503834128, -0.013976546004414558, -0.006038845516741276, -0.033400360494852066, 0.016750356182456017, 0.004559753462672234, 0.02774912491440773, -0.005187926813960075, 0.04043692722916603, 0.020269012078642845, 0.013763654045760632, -0.001258515054360032, 0.014290372841060162, 0.014229703694581985, 0.05368272587656975, -0.010885843075811863, -0.016426531597971916, -0.05704788118600845, -0.017191125079989433, -0.043257936835289, -0.052080318331718445, 0.01963140442967415, 0.047651443630456924, 0.03513361141085625, 0.016704900190234184, 0.0000385895291401539, 0.006543457042425871, -0.01587211713194847, -0.03458663448691368, -0.03750075772404671, 0.06281190365552902, 0.02062232419848442, 0.03747468441724777, -0.04947773367166519, -0.039564184844493866, -0.012996216304600239, 0.04085589572787285, 0.04488697275519371, 0.024466151371598244, 0.01033148355782032, -0.029255617409944534, 0.024084242060780525, 0.030947506427764893, -0.006467401050031185, -0.002961050719022751, 0.0001939435169333592, 0.006468026898801327, -0.002428286010399461, -0.062040798366069794, -0.07073205709457397, 0.0442872978746891, -0.01967841014266014, 0.06640318781137466, 0.05352620780467987, 0.050220925360918045, -0.02903391607105732, -0.06719469279050827, 0.006458141840994358, -0.029137473553419113, 0.02365490049123764, 0.03254244104027748, -0.023302307352423668, -0.015343616716563702, -0.04909008741378784, -0.010496078990399837, -0.06227575242519379, -0.035045795142650604, -0.05807691067457199, -0.003124208888038993, -0.023275744169950485, -0.01833481527864933, 0.041896115988492966, 0.04686689004302025, -0.012816527858376503, -0.0888572707772255, -0.05903252586722374, -0.0574762187898159, -0.01007908582687378, 0.05582226812839508, 0.019790995866060257, 0.03315874934196472, 0.010271890088915825, 0.008962680585682392, -0.01715143397450447, 0.024469928815960884, 0.021974287927150726, 0.014260265044867992, -0.028157172724604607, -0.0005621534073725343, -0.02305001951754093, -0.010943454690277576, -0.016902511939406395, -0.02492002584040165, 0.008739011362195015, 0.02894921973347664, 0.045286085456609726, -0.026029760017991066, -0.012144762091338634, -0.0031825131736695766, -0.028050512075424194, 0.004568283446133137, -0.03636776655912399, 0.07174358516931534, 0.003417198546230793, -0.007070115301758051, 0.016979515552520752, 0.00512448837980628, 0.023726115003228188, 0.027666568756103516, -0.022982018068432808, -0.026544781401753426, -0.03720739856362343, -0.007629394065588713, 0.04174674302339554, -0.0416778139770031, 0.00037643674295395613, -0.038393184542655945, 0.0113440016284585, -0.0034794288221746683, -0.006107245571911335, -0.006855930667370558, 0.06307768821716309, -0.034838419407606125, -0.008273172192275524, 0.026753397658467293, -0.0003948742523789406, -0.017676521092653275, 0.00994154717773199, 0.016459660604596138, -0.008721054531633854, -0.0017687046201899648, -0.0032968157902359962, 0.029702503234148026, -0.012444082647562027, -0.002170771127566695, -0.06802226603031158, -0.0405091792345047, -0.05699745938181877, 0.007599297910928726, 0.026326775550842285, -0.005881192162632942, 0.006848611403256655, 0.021176958456635475, 0.04679035767912865, 0.007006138563156128, -0.03374362364411354, -0.017275720834732056, 0.005164520349353552, 0.02410542219877243, -0.023363513872027397, 0.0002729601983446628, -0.03782130777835846, 0.0205854382365942, -0.034245699644088745, 0.013068156316876411, 0.10117187350988388, -0.01633870229125023, -0.014546459540724754, 0.056241557002067566, 0.0003190525167156011, -0.04093195125460625, 0.013716433197259903, -0.06617138534784317, 0.03748558834195137, -0.046043761074543, 0.03894050046801567, -0.04641280323266983, 0.09631381928920746, 0.06846499443054199, 0.05735589936375618, -0.03394236043095589, 0.028736498206853867, 0.03235860913991928, -0.06593818217515945, -0.043672025203704834, -0.04551324248313904, 0.058240290731191635, 0.056059885770082474, -0.016266189515590668, 0.03206687420606613, 0.04090333357453346, 0.07985933125019073, -0.036069486290216446, 0.035578276962041855, -0.010168622247874737, 0.05221995711326599, -0.006950062699615955, 0.016625577583909035, -0.00134424795396626, -0.004240103531628847, -0.0722820833325386, -0.0008000825182534754, 0.015905072912573814, -0.027987856417894363, 0.05247412249445915, 0.0039543770253658295, 0.004995088558644056, -0.012198585085570812, 0.022411193698644638, -0.03367142751812935, -0.03297710046172142, -0.012516685761511326, 0.0458703376352787, 0.02064315415918827, -0.000527449999935925, 0.037538573145866394, 0.08757747709751129, 0.02917511947453022, 0.03123953565955162, -0.003703645197674632, -0.023209834471344948, -0.025217732414603233, 0.0168972909450531, 0.02525935135781765, 0.023706883192062378, 0.06265582889318466, -0.0503854900598526, 0.00391026446595788, 0.09648231416940689, -0.04183678328990936, -0.012109952978789806, -0.02384873479604721, 0.0537007711827755, 0.07742148637771606, -0.02787855640053749, 0.03591977432370186, -0.028515856713056564, -0.07389332354068756, 0.03451003134250641, -0.016053542494773865, -0.018847128376364708, -0.007804407272487879, 0.0020001668017357588, 0.014467654749751091, 0.004327225033193827, -0.044005975127220154, -0.05700920522212982, -0.018578380346298218, 0.014741148799657822, -0.11331342160701752, -0.09510983526706696, 0.0186662208288908, -0.021974531933665276, 0.02436271496117115, 0.012505303137004375, -0.03855729475617409, -0.03955919295549393, -0.016149599105119705, 0.01981351710855961, 0.003353419480845332, -0.015774138271808624, -0.0712629109621048, 0.010284025222063065, 0.029443496838212013, -0.023679086938500404, -0.08561446517705917, 0.0062677436508238316, 0.04952188581228256, -0.007141570094972849, 0.048927027732133865, -0.05307980254292488, -0.01123440358787775, -0.11622884124517441, 0.009640405885875225, 0.04501719027757645, 0.05910280719399452, 0.05615881085395813, -0.01908397674560547, -0.028638223186135292, 0.014751479960978031, 0.014580911956727505, -0.005283877719193697, 0.017423611134290695, 0.026994554325938225, 0.022250771522521973, 0.00837860256433487, -0.04314284771680832, 0.042164091020822525, 0.034512244164943695, -0.05470841005444527, -0.085873544216156, 0.0023349830880761147, -0.01665550097823143, 0.035103458911180496, 0.023363860324025154, 0.007887906394898891, 0.07820094376802444, 0.03708488121628761, 0.014794398099184036, -0.02416747622191906, 0.021611535921692848, 0.035582248121500015, -0.06006905436515808, 0.017883434891700745, 0.037643663585186005, 0.017667284235358238, -0.029672488570213318, 0.027868200093507767 ]
<p>I have a logit model and am trying to understand and compare the predicted and observed values generated by the model. Let's say data set had 100 values and I generate all the predicted probabilities, and then I find the actual probabilities from the data set.</p> <p>If I'm comparing the predicted vs observed values, I'm thinking there are two ways to do it. One is to do it value by value, while the second would be to group by the 'predicted probabilities.'</p> <pre><code>Method 1: x_value pred_val obs_val 100 0.30 0.34 102 0.33 0.36 104 0.35 0.37 106 0.40 0.40 ... </code></pre> <p>I'm also thinking there has to some way to aggregate these values. So I'm thinking of aggregating all x values where the predicted probabilities is between 10 to 20% percent, then find the avg predicted value from that range, followed by the predicted value for that range.</p> <pre><code>Method 2: Pred_probs pred_val obs_val 10 to 20% vals 0.10 0.11 21 to 30% vals 0.12 0.16 31 to 50% vals 0.15 0.30 </code></pre> <p>What I'm wondering is:</p> <ol> <li><p>When there are a large number of data points, what use is having a list of the predicted and observed values for any given value of x?</p></li> <li><p>Does it ever make sense to do something as identified in 'Method 2'?</p></li> </ol>
g74060
[ -0.015183658339083195, -0.01414430607110262, -0.001888663275167346, -0.044260911643505096, 0.017708392813801765, -0.02544540911912918, 0.01047488208860159, 0.00226094969548285, -0.08523411303758621, -0.05691235139966011, 0.009454188868403435, -0.01224829163402319, 0.12520530819892883, 0.03360440582036972, -0.05794354900717735, -0.011647796258330345, 0.05770675837993622, 0.011704107746481895, -0.039883192628622055, 0.0027079316787421703, 0.07312017679214478, -0.029711781069636345, 0.04258538782596588, -0.0003914680564776063, -0.06739600747823715, -0.00929933600127697, -0.011257587932050228, 0.0648033618927002, -0.022533085197210312, 0.009180723689496517, -0.024930929765105247, 0.046052347868680954, 0.024543792009353638, -0.05210688337683678, -0.04244990274310112, -0.08089718967676163, -0.032133832573890686, 0.03184911236166954, -0.03140975907444954, -0.040548790246248245, 0.009827950038015842, 0.00650801369920373, 0.0659383162856102, -0.0089732576161623, -0.032056406140327454, -0.02663200907409191, 0.02417529933154583, -0.03255342319607735, -0.007864952087402344, 0.027803171426057816, 0.025975815951824188, 0.03680507466197014, 0.0157789196819067, 0.02437306009232998, 0.08754103630781174, 0.10277029871940613, -0.02600933238863945, 0.015605013817548752, 0.0004883951623924077, -0.018173927441239357, 0.060649383813142776, 0.027829909697175026, 0.005614441353827715, 0.01393167208880186, 0.03855909779667854, 0.004247895907610655, -0.03892537206411362, -0.004907284863293171, 0.04078740254044533, -0.02226300723850727, 0.02055959403514862, 0.0652196854352951, -0.0028117215260863304, -0.009828396141529083, -0.09190455079078674, 0.005040111485868692, 0.005506821442395449, 0.017927492037415504, 0.0016020159237086773, 0.06253467500209808, 0.03383935987949371, -0.03535151481628418, -0.00007745912444079295, -0.026275305077433586, -0.0174131840467453, -0.04362265393137932, 0.014080646447837353, 0.004752710461616516, 0.014925971627235413, 0.05073660984635353, -0.02383865974843502, -0.0027234849985688925, 0.08800707757472992, 0.06632755696773529, -0.07456798106431961, 0.02116803452372551, -0.0753500834107399, 0.03051908127963543, 0.03905833140015602, -0.024027878418564796, -0.0049401577562093735, 0.08978329598903656, -0.0027218542527407408, 0.0007622722187079489, -0.09678883850574493, -0.033577173948287964, -0.005584683269262314, -0.000667957472614944, 0.012154425494372845, 0.007754695601761341, -0.05291811376810074, 0.04164566099643707, -0.06275787204504013, -0.036269661039114, -0.0412331260740757, -0.03552206978201866, 0.05771356448531151, 0.05374985560774803, -0.05009447783231735, -0.0006264790426939726, 0.04390675574541092, -0.008877628482878208, -0.0022580898366868496, 0.026611194014549255, 0.007865485735237598, 0.035434845834970474, -0.03906844183802605, 0.03166903927922249, 0.004275641869753599, -0.002392377471551299, 0.027142571285367012, -0.04129744693636894, -0.010354015976190567, 0.009959452785551548, 0.034804899245500565, -0.012705257162451744, -0.030736848711967468, 0.03177323937416077, -0.03757988661527634, -0.004889281000941992, -0.025869380682706833, -0.003218025667592883, -0.058407291769981384, -0.024692822247743607, 0.006009614560753107, 0.011339027434587479, -0.04320015385746956, -0.007148498669266701, -0.045852165669202805, 0.04579504206776619, 0.016075899824500084, 0.001470834482461214, -0.023354804143309593, -0.0008578547858633101, 0.010875409469008446, 0.0025352679658681154, -0.029466386884450912, -0.017254963517189026, -0.006261349190026522, 0.010682189837098122, -0.015901310369372368, -0.019494416192173958, 0.05040562152862549, -0.009420596994459629, -0.028137069195508957, -0.009584851562976837, 0.009447826072573662, -0.043081045150756836, -0.014479290693998337, -0.003587985411286354, 0.015864338725805283, -0.02206750586628914, 0.0396389439702034, -0.030241115018725395, 0.0603070966899395, 0.026963992044329643, 0.04152721166610718, -0.05213082209229469, 0.03534752130508423, -0.016006797552108765, 0.026198619976639748, -0.024426227435469627, 0.02643580548465252, -0.012146148830652237, -0.0032632513903081417, -0.008706757798790932, -0.033101633191108704, 0.03413410112261772, -0.021143393591046333, -0.005660524591803551, -0.03686761483550072, 0.004316011909395456, -0.06297522038221359, 0.027108952403068542, 0.008924119174480438, 0.01116839051246643, 0.006669797468930483, -0.033999692648649216, -0.020253093913197517, 0.004731921479105949, 0.02493353933095932, 0.00002903132190112956, -0.061484795063734055, 0.04610142111778259, -0.02165728434920311, 0.04362702742218971, 0.01800849474966526, 0.03174426406621933, -0.03903907909989357, 0.05269535258412361, -0.008722257800400257, 0.001753745716996491, -0.011866472661495209, 0.061551790684461594, -0.09800346940755844, -0.015108693391084671, -0.007688217330724001, 0.08524196594953537, 0.01768566481769085, -0.01062796264886856, -0.04627978801727295, -0.0613500252366066, 0.011546029709279537, 0.05864185839891434, 0.0025374521501362324, 0.03510497882962227, -0.015478244051337242, 0.0200424212962389, 0.01501617580652237, 0.027300508692860603, -0.038408782333135605, -0.010502629913389683, -0.042053431272506714, -0.05406154692173004, 0.04543264955282211, 0.02203519642353058, 0.001382754067890346, -0.006724977400153875, 0.0012902822345495224, 0.013628026470541954, 0.013864115811884403, 0.005402554292231798, -0.0001709736679913476, 0.01252428162842989, 0.026354098692536354, -0.030918337404727936, 0.09623557329177856, 0.04376394301652908, 0.022063057869672775, 0.08659513294696808, -0.05391961336135864, 0.07508118450641632, -0.02377297542989254, -0.0513773038983345, 0.04873107746243477, 0.002067716559395194, 0.010904340073466301, 0.030053775757551193, 0.04886816442012787, 0.045105528086423874, -0.029310157522559166, -0.00875592976808548, -0.02019576169550419, 0.046279214322566986, -0.016647271811962128, -0.026741262525320053, 0.058343306183815, -0.0889081209897995, 0.022000443190336227, -0.004366385284811258, -0.010506703518331051, -0.03237496316432953, 0.044017307460308075, 0.04657398536801338, 0.03947202488780022, 0.014767819084227085, -0.014523093588650227, -0.06452193856239319, 0.02129312977194786, -0.035541705787181854, 0.0400841049849987, -0.0683097094297409, 0.00984901376068592, 0.038097575306892395, 0.07567168772220612, -0.01845472864806652, 0.07623334228992462, -0.025981174781918526, 0.03397161513566971, 0.0037954228464514017, 0.041247207671403885, -0.03305264562368393, -0.0172579288482666, -0.023987187072634697, -0.030469929799437523, -0.026932088658213615, 0.006103583611547947, -0.011431347578763962, 0.07882818579673767, -0.040280502289533615, -0.07527336478233337, 0.0030324356630444527, 0.06328839808702469, 0.007308853790163994, 0.02893158234655857, -0.02020467258989811, -0.04719109088182449, 0.009752275422215462, -0.013966723345220089, -0.040735792368650436, -0.039706144481897354, 0.017598198726773262, -0.047470781952142715, -0.08596575260162354, -0.0017716360744088888, -0.022526178508996964, -0.0062369899824261665, -0.0013193348422646523, 0.028729751706123352, -0.03972817584872246, -0.013814735226333141, -0.004309514537453651, 0.055821627378463745, -0.002204371616244316, 0.01210769172757864, 0.06704991310834885, -0.025406617671251297, 0.0321662575006485, -0.050520118325948715, -0.012949146330356598, 0.0035096979700028896, -0.002931212540715933, 0.014949426054954529, -0.0016407545190304518, 0.011694150976836681, -0.08335568010807037, 0.00044831098057329655, -0.04410635679960251, 0.06149258837103844, 0.027469540014863014, -0.011548865586519241, -0.00853784941136837, 0.02407936193048954, -0.019081011414527893, -0.029819948598742485, -0.029562683776021004, 0.0045501249842345715, -0.0016487975372001529, 0.060945041477680206, -0.028348630294203758, -0.028005104511976242, 0.01781160943210125, 0.010146785527467728, -0.011922286823391914, 0.03318629786372185, 0.05623979866504669, 0.037832893431186676, -0.019077222794294357, -0.02227051556110382, 0.0032815642189234495, 0.029250282794237137, 0.013839226216077805, -0.0056269289925694466, -0.03555245324969292, -0.03656171262264252, -0.021907268092036247, 0.03303603082895279, 0.006373456679284573, 0.06600496917963028, -0.01637994311749935, 0.05631120875477791, -0.0386040173470974, 0.010527150705456734, -0.06449664384126663, -0.008010538294911385, -0.02034488134086132, 0.08232024312019348, -0.021139930933713913, 0.022901933640241623, 0.014922494068741798, 0.025080841034650803, 0.026539700105786324, 0.009201092645525932, 0.011091676540672779, -0.05062028393149376, -0.029237475246191025, 0.020787272602319717, 0.05384061112999916, 0.017444467172026634, -0.03267715126276016, -0.0067870765924453735, -0.022281553596258163, -0.09172042459249496, 0.04982749745249748, 0.0034065681975334883, 0.0012977540027350187, -0.0028552976436913013, 0.05373133718967438, 0.024442246183753014, 0.053460534662008286, -0.035298533737659454, 0.02178758755326271, 0.020070165395736694, 0.0005976154352538288, -0.028908219188451767, -0.04818921908736229, -0.019907351583242416, -0.0508030466735363, -0.031519342213869095, 0.014803596772253513, -0.01496591605246067, 0.002493569627404213, 0.010840910486876965, -0.035363879054784775, 0.044244103133678436, 0.010966007597744465, 0.09786708652973175, -0.02547667734324932, -0.010927608236670494, -0.028758419677615166, 0.028824640437960625, -0.017098858952522278, -0.006736041512340307, -0.06352107971906662, -0.04836376756429672, 0.02395542524755001, -0.0281323604285717, 0.00725457863882184, 0.0026920244563370943, -0.049985386431217194, 0.01655626855790615, -0.03107914887368679, -0.031183360144495964, 0.0027258407790213823, -0.0029297317378222942, 0.00967345479875803, 0.038576073944568634, 0.007640271447598934, 0.0273375753313303, -0.028107134625315666, -0.016847142949700356, -0.050407521426677704, -0.03301621600985527, 0.005723082460463047, 0.0024047240149229765, 0.004061797168105841, -0.004927215166389942, 0.004192180000245571, 0.021187255159020424, 0.028044110164046288, 0.02765367552638054, -0.0012773631606251001, 0.007092430256307125, 0.024606922641396523, 0.05605537071824074, -0.01405871007591486, 0.054371416568756104, 0.036210089921951294, 0.023575427010655403, 0.004753619432449341, -0.04634327068924904, -0.03224518895149231, -0.036112990230321884, -0.004916615784168243, 0.06155819818377495, -0.009656205773353577, -0.06993643194437027, -0.02358623594045639, 0.035976801067590714, -0.012632300145924091, -0.016921624541282654, 0.002173883840441704, 0.04230048134922981, -0.03144250437617302, -0.006757399532943964, -0.016703741624951363, -0.024470346048474312, 0.02786005660891533, 0.03733813017606735, -0.009489793330430984, -0.05523861572146416, -0.011824202723801136, -0.012244523502886295, 0.0024168670643121004, -0.021024903282523155, -0.018337855115532875, 0.02392478473484516, -0.0819799080491066, 0.0318850614130497, -0.038705892860889435, 0.016172245144844055, 0.0032899293582886457, 0.11692200601100922, 0.03771191090345383, -0.03441805765032768, -0.05687021464109421, -0.009982462972402573, -0.024228744208812714, 0.0015647787367925048, -0.04135585576295853, -0.013181647285819054, 0.06496383994817734, -0.011238764971494675, -0.06323419511318207, 0.01794394478201866, 0.014272864907979965, 0.03972700238227844, 0.008291682228446007, 0.036054108291864395, 0.0077937087044119835, -0.0011053653433918953, 0.009890489280223846, 0.004899547901004553, -0.0068851616233587265, -0.03720710426568985, -0.004286576062440872, 0.02608967013657093, 0.043499235063791275, -0.05074162781238556, -0.01272149570286274, 0.05121105536818504, -0.014902779832482338, -0.04241715744137764, 0.012277008965611458, 0.0013118679635226727, -0.125440314412117, -0.0574989914894104, 0.0012326226569712162, 0.03592808544635773, -0.024255938827991486, 0.03413478285074234, -0.00036439913674257696, -0.01829935982823372, -0.014543820172548294, 0.00339825008995831, -0.006045988295227289, -0.06891227513551712, 0.030684731900691986, 0.03190440312027931, -0.03705880790948868, -0.008708837442100048, 0.041683733463287354, 0.011811185628175735, -0.03516634926199913, 0.035657308995723724, -0.03222636505961418, -0.01490509882569313, 0.017657512798905373, 0.032240431755781174, 0.007993093691766262, -0.00184191286098212, 0.03143826872110367, -0.04054290056228638, 0.006965396925806999, 0.009055833332240582, 0.03828053921461105, -0.018566956743597984, -0.07160110026597977, 0.02464740350842476, 0.03384019434452057, 0.00530141731724143, -0.040014978498220444, 0.004429326858371496, 0.023199211806058884, 0.05504278838634491, 0.0461588092148304, -0.04094309359788895, 0.018150921911001205, -0.018206775188446045, 0.05476996675133705, 0.07477466762065887, -0.054811812937259674, 0.031798072159290314, 0.035705529153347015, 0.002793082734569907, -0.0060652210377156734, 0.037721529603004456, 0.004278590902686119, 0.03955533355474472, -0.002093328395858407, -0.02976207807660103, -0.04984946921467781, -0.015338737517595291, -0.0001259448763448745, -0.0027959125582128763, -0.0015569006791338325, 0.013889233581721783, -0.03820852190256119, 0.006924622226506472, 0.018146056681871414, 0.002977544441819191, -0.01439829170703888, -0.003839953104034066, 0.004806083161383867, 0.017642496153712273, 0.029444856569170952, 0.032952502369880676, 0.025749823078513145, -0.0024348872248083353, -0.050439152866601944, -0.024135222658514977, -0.027457574382424355, -0.009475931525230408, -0.03155410662293434, 0.06215651333332062, -0.044156644493341446, -0.0738958865404129, 0.0070066605694592, 0.015836315229535103, 0.013250336050987244, -0.015096942894160748, 0.03534969687461853, -0.00955639872699976, 0.04023429751396179, -0.007899847812950611, 0.03183180093765259, -0.03560657054185867, 0.00497246952727437, 0.002139113377779722, 0.04416464641690254, 0.04276029393076897, 0.040424246340990067, -0.01840728335082531, 0.01093762181699276, 0.04375917464494705, 0.03348074108362198, -0.026626067236065865, -0.01049620471894741, 0.08295124024152756, 0.008886019699275494, -0.04491334408521652, 0.027466261759400368, 0.030169153586030006, 0.001913412124849856, -0.03386147692799568, 0.00881415605545044, -0.02451576478779316, 0.05012005567550659, 0.01152657438069582, 0.05574876815080643, 0.017995111644268036, 0.011915677227079868, -0.02609049156308174, 0.01266050711274147, -0.009986880235373974, 0.02627677284181118, -0.012649182230234146, -0.006160309538245201, -0.0007662943680770695, -0.003441030625253916, -0.032439082860946655, 0.010756916366517544, 0.0031666657887399197, -0.004849044140428305, -0.025047242641448975, 0.08823154866695404, 0.023673728108406067, 0.01454245112836361, 0.05158089101314545, 0.03840678930282593, -0.04727335274219513, -0.016663717105984688, -0.029041942209005356, -0.0017427927814424038, 0.0015007975744083524, -0.0027761757373809814, -0.025977615267038345, -0.022098930552601814, 0.0020713554695248604, -0.057419370859861374, -0.020305689424276352, -0.06863807141780853, -0.020768124610185623, -0.009827885776758194, -0.012058449909090996, -0.02605622448027134, 0.0269188042730093, -0.018143096938729286, -0.08915694802999496, 0.006798903923481703, -0.03768504410982132, -0.0011674197157844901, 0.005195529665797949, -0.02167399786412716, -0.009987814351916313, 0.09723053127527237, -0.055495280772447586, -0.014505845494568348, -0.0162377767264843, -0.0611274428665638, -0.0556899830698967, -0.06320027261972427, 0.017058948054909706, 0.0035048138815909624, -0.019791143015027046, -0.008091631345450878, -0.07542308419942856, 0.03468974307179451, -0.018243400380015373, 0.07488014549016953, 0.01755049265921116, 0.04420524090528488, 0.001276111463084817, -0.014235791750252247, -0.013749581761658192, -0.05097458139061928, 0.04649129882454872, 0.019521743059158325, 0.029406864196062088, -0.0534430667757988, -0.032229840755462646, 0.05439135059714317, 0.007230672519654036, 0.003187457798048854, -0.04307209700345993, -0.015468989498913288, -0.019409094005823135, -0.0010445547522976995, -0.0005195487174205482, 0.02791113220155239, -0.05683383718132973, -0.04307272657752037, 0.03579028323292732, 0.017242267727851868, 0.05761362612247467, -0.03119669109582901, -0.008281792514026165, 0.07263607531785965, -0.06921883672475815, 0.022124113515019417, -0.029940349981188774, -0.01729760318994522, -0.09287676960229874, 0.0001042158473865129, 0.02684815786778927, 0.07167590409517288, 0.019327178597450256, -0.013065679930150509, -0.058839719742536545, 0.01711929216980934, -0.02439081482589245, 0.014258540235459805, 0.03360249847173691, 0.027649451047182083, 0.00017432835011277348, 0.03550661355257034, 0.008913971483707428, 0.03736431151628494, -0.02220272272825241, -0.02396531216800213, -0.050677843391895294, 0.042618028819561005, -0.031064145267009735, 0.06701227277517319, 0.05622474104166031, -0.017173180356621742, 0.03333741053938866, -0.004965797998011112, 0.01881186105310917, -0.04595758765935898, -0.003309980733320117, 0.032719045877456665, -0.029744300991296768, 0.019932854920625687, 0.0025683697313070297, -0.016018442809581757, -0.046345919370651245, 0.0006677808705717325 ]
<p>I have a lot of data (gigs) that may be useful in predicting equity prices. I can import these as a series of features (columns) in a table where the companies are rows. I have time series information too.</p> <p>I have some machine learning experience but no experience as a trader.</p> <p>Is there some software or platform where I could easily import my data and it could backtest/forward test my data to see if it's useful?</p> <p>I understand that any machine learning system that's out there in public won't outperform the market enough to cover brokerage fees, but given my data, there's a chance it would. So I probably don't need state of the art in machine learning but I'd like to find a solution where I don't spend the next 6 months learning the stock market. I'd rather spend that time getting feedback on, and iterating on the input data, because as a data-oriented developer, that's where I can add value.</p> <p>Any help, much appreciated.</p>
g44147
[ 0.018617315217852592, 0.023337800055742264, 0.019816843792796135, -0.07806654274463654, -0.04264209046959877, -0.038018323481082916, 0.008009755983948708, -0.02505766786634922, -0.05256201699376106, -0.004567914176732302, 0.022665997967123985, 0.0543258860707283, 0.025746550410985947, -0.01506742648780346, -0.06329622864723206, -0.008668476715683937, 0.022555122151970863, 0.0022643280681222677, 0.0023877660278230906, 0.04565129801630974, 0.06315474212169647, 0.0301916915923357, -0.003628149861469865, -0.046085163950920105, -0.042501844465732574, -0.024358974769711494, -0.03340490162372589, 0.018894407898187637, 0.02768297679722309, 0.07138962298631668, -0.04094942286610603, 0.0035408958792686462, 0.03037312440574169, 0.0021792175248265266, -0.03754414990544319, -0.00846253614872694, -0.0018795523792505264, -0.04174746945500374, 0.024071190506219864, -0.007870595902204514, -0.0519191175699234, 0.011842134408652782, 0.026479069143533707, 0.07865151017904282, 0.0786309689283371, 0.08636996895074844, -0.00902596116065979, -0.03713865950703621, 0.051423270255327225, 0.02437341958284378, 0.044618621468544006, -0.0013539729407057166, -0.007751194294542074, 0.044110652059316635, -0.030078893527388573, 0.020201416686177254, -0.005608862731605768, 0.059367455542087555, 0.06229907274246216, -0.05616220459342003, 0.027343709021806717, -0.03250819072127342, -0.013402489945292473, -0.006921513471752405, 0.023251421749591827, 0.04012637585401535, 0.011753147467970848, -0.005447936709970236, -0.04066557437181473, 0.008880190551280975, 0.030683359131217003, 0.07528270781040192, -0.007066504564136267, -0.008963282220065594, -0.01318148523569107, -0.012204191647469997, -0.024753276258707047, 0.03201565146446228, -0.02036723494529724, 0.029984235763549805, -0.03848067298531532, -0.0316067636013031, -0.043241970241069794, 0.010370699688792229, 0.039483167231082916, -0.03723561763763428, 0.02307143248617649, -0.01741345413029194, 0.0204789899289608, 0.01793714240193367, 0.02691502682864666, 0.031731534749269485, 0.05830607935786247, 0.014296352863311768, 0.017340010032057762, 0.023169629275798798, -0.061564572155475616, 0.009622023440897465, -0.007282520178705454, -0.013985161669552326, -0.05695698782801628, 0.00009208125993609428, 0.0013829743256792426, -0.02777678705751896, -0.023055080324411392, -0.027527451515197754, -0.048523854464292526, -0.026513496413826942, -0.007033005356788635, 0.02733209915459156, -0.02415868639945984, 0.017312437295913696, -0.09027861058712006, 0.0439755953848362, -0.011801084503531456, -0.039724841713905334, 0.007589408662170172, 0.017178844660520554, -0.047458961606025696, 0.009672950021922588, 0.03679242357611656, -0.007990824058651924, 0.04975207895040512, 0.005063987802714109, 0.021046284586191177, 0.03185633197426796, -0.004455730319023132, 0.05644030496478081, -0.011862730607390404, -0.024417752400040627, 0.005818311125040054, 0.008463572710752487, -0.01800752431154251, 0.013949697837233543, 0.020909415557980537, 0.08652778714895248, 0.0003473404503893107, 0.013261295855045319, -0.0014834142057225108, 0.03234602138400078, -0.02640802599489689, 0.030756285414099693, -0.011863558553159237, 0.029258951544761658, -0.004649912007153034, 0.03435279428958893, 0.0011915653012692928, -0.00439847307279706, 0.03620914742350578, 0.06422024965286255, 0.02185404859483242, 0.025300130248069763, -0.01642865687608719, 0.020795414224267006, 0.06402637809515, 0.020821483805775642, 0.0037421518936753273, -0.032859571278095245, 0.05531632900238037, -0.004837886895984411, 0.047888386994600296, -0.03700629249215126, 0.01205295417457819, -0.0057189613580703735, 0.021855155006051064, -0.05781441554427147, -0.04299246892333031, -0.0012923869071528316, 0.052553147077560425, -0.024474164471030235, 0.0023933344054967165, -0.0064430455677211285, 0.041682202368974686, -0.008431081660091877, 0.0015207795659080148, -0.013101779855787754, 0.0019899755716323853, 0.018611013889312744, 0.08932038396596909, -0.043966442346572876, 0.005548526998609304, -0.014869551174342632, 0.016075091436505318, 0.03704238682985306, -0.0460880845785141, -0.047444261610507965, -0.047904789447784424, 0.03131413832306862, 0.03480079770088196, -0.06281071901321411, 0.04041318967938423, -0.033645473420619965, -0.03383375704288483, 0.015470223501324654, 0.011292793788015842, -0.07252843677997589, 0.024385271593928337, -0.02700970508158207, -0.006324730813503265, 0.0023993286304175854, 0.037559665739536285, 0.02640044502913952, -0.0056803408078849316, 0.0838136225938797, -0.016659483313560486, 0.02374410443007946, 0.02446042187511921, -0.06578675657510757, -0.027007967233657837, -0.015729200094938278, 0.02479095570743084, 0.004486480262130499, 0.00232604518532753, 0.05506947636604309, 0.027513068169355392, 0.06015705317258835, 0.0007870795670896769, 0.0012082174653187394, 0.06232621893286705, -0.02447049878537655, 0.0009153310675173998, -0.04666232317686081, 0.04509684816002846, -0.007321223616600037, 0.01030946709215641, -0.015015672892332077, 0.03826626017689705, 0.03567294403910637, 0.03373875096440315, 0.010915796272456646, -0.0375986248254776, -0.012768595479428768, 0.029562069103121758, -0.0023774676956236362, 0.09822388738393784, 0.013561498373746872, 0.0031546023674309254, -0.04587380960583687, -0.0518435463309288, 0.07042039930820465, 0.016948465257883072, 0.00016623747069388628, -0.024168992415070534, -0.040747594088315964, -0.0014874942135065794, -0.07607641816139221, 0.05850479006767273, 0.02029087021946907, 0.08260956406593323, -0.004808811936527491, -0.019670872017741203, 0.055840760469436646, 0.013389854691922665, -0.0015278746141120791, -0.04336018115282059, -0.021824298426508904, 0.025810830295085907, -0.007458885665982962, 0.013077644631266594, 0.04993201419711113, 0.002634397242218256, 0.027428656816482544, 0.04105281084775925, -0.009855185635387897, -0.020020747557282448, -0.029796956107020378, 0.0014377693878486753, 0.029768407344818115, 0.018264219164848328, 0.011146338656544685, 0.008038715459406376, -0.05774158984422684, 0.03361538425087929, -0.02618030458688736, 0.015776021406054497, 0.030066024512052536, -0.017453396692872047, 0.00934686791151762, 0.04017462581396103, -0.03179464489221573, -0.021820571273565292, -0.08842641115188599, -0.00255290768109262, -0.0017901754472404718, 0.01875794492661953, 0.08402294665575027, -0.00276228622533381, 0.04957422986626625, 0.02382527105510235, 0.05785927176475525, -0.017597690224647522, 0.0027248451951891184, 0.017246868461370468, -0.015550313517451286, -0.018492644652724266, -0.04527505487203598, 0.00020482273248489946, 0.025944264605641365, 0.015882760286331177, 0.020053435117006302, -0.06967658549547195, 0.007426092401146889, 0.11575140804052353, 0.0026910731103271246, -0.018948674201965332, -0.031567320227622986, -0.05303839221596718, -0.009829540736973286, 0.012501240707933903, -0.020312592387199402, -0.019902653992176056, -0.012797410599887371, -0.047306470572948456, -0.00932142324745655, -0.08348563313484192, -0.04369286075234413, 0.00895931851118803, 0.009509490802884102, -0.03414921090006828, -0.046239305287599564, 0.027735987678170204, -0.05390329286456108, -0.0037825563922524452, -0.04489193484187126, 0.02874871902167797, 0.019718870520591736, -0.05783311277627945, -0.022102823480963707, -0.06607332825660706, 0.011685008183121681, 0.05344603955745697, 0.017582636326551437, 0.009217344224452972, 0.02853919006884098, -0.0487833172082901, -0.055897630751132965, 0.055409401655197144, -0.06030316278338432, 0.02240452542901039, 0.05884632095694542, -0.06970753520727158, -0.020042750984430313, 0.049574561417102814, 0.003758700331673026, -0.0672207698225975, -0.09110875427722931, 0.03172621876001358, 0.024690426886081696, -0.005196123383939266, -0.045422106981277466, -0.07960963249206543, -0.005639167502522469, 0.03420308604836464, -0.0181326512247324, 0.026203911751508713, 0.025762196630239487, 0.00043628484127111733, 0.03933783993124962, -0.017177322879433632, 0.018403885886073112, -0.020733367651700974, -0.05728450044989586, 0.017686178907752037, -0.00028775641112588346, -0.015572214499115944, -0.003542024875059724, 0.01712459698319435, 0.07812002301216125, 0.0545017346739769, -0.013529406860470772, -0.0030726930126547813, -0.009800594300031662, 0.08744005858898163, -0.008081169798970222, -0.00870446115732193, -0.03572509065270424, 0.005602320656180382, 0.0066502816043794155, 0.011993193067610264, 0.05006139352917671, 0.025928113609552383, 0.013980254530906677, 0.006750400178134441, 0.03286217153072357, 0.003852910129353404, -0.01994009129703045, 0.005880478769540787, 0.03918841853737831, -0.033983264118433, 0.06262306869029999, 0.04507656767964363, -0.04885982722043991, -0.039288464933633804, 0.03714320808649063, 0.02113005332648754, -0.0411343015730381, -0.01867498829960823, 0.0440085306763649, 0.014049077406525612, -0.00048433704068884254, -0.030622845515608788, -0.04056103900074959, 0.024532213807106018, 0.019320780411362648, -0.04752118140459061, -0.007477541454136372, -0.023059166967868805, -0.029276225715875626, -0.061076708137989044, 0.015695463865995407, -0.06468472629785538, -0.06466151773929596, -0.011688058264553547, 0.03854593262076378, -0.011990120634436607, 0.04563914239406586, 0.11380747705698013, -0.04237055778503418, -0.035506471991539, -0.019481904804706573, -0.012513630092144012, 0.051387690007686615, -0.0367327556014061, -0.013875626027584076, 0.006190015003085136, -0.010091305710375309, 0.07777231931686401, -0.015528801828622818, 0.01241138856858015, 0.026928145438432693, 0.032953664660453796, -0.0317702516913414, -0.06720440834760666, -0.04469350352883339, -0.0491056814789772, 0.012815389782190323, 0.06312613189220428, -0.04266747459769249, -0.030452143400907516, -0.027205079793930054, -0.015860717743635178, -0.013970887288451195, 0.019975272938609123, -0.046231213957071304, -0.05363094061613083, 0.06805847585201263, -0.00929541327059269, 0.012152011506259441, 0.020967913791537285, 0.02889227494597435, 0.019381191581487656, -0.09877648204565048, 0.002075204625725746, 0.01024213433265686, 0.011186654679477215, 0.047056812793016434, 0.03961348906159401, 0.01579556241631508, 0.01834682933986187, 0.04503801837563515, 0.013123420998454094, 0.01200514379888773, -0.03894386813044548, -0.004071241710335016, -0.013239353895187378, 0.0006132394773885608, -0.013936183415353298, -0.008468215353786945, 0.0623033381998539, 0.03761257231235504, -0.05278966948390007, -0.004242199007421732, 0.056709468364715576, -0.013220171444118023, -0.018900899216532707, 0.03678898140788078, -0.022348996251821518, -0.009958632290363312, 0.018992936238646507, -0.010058718733489513, -0.037948861718177795, -0.002662705723196268, 0.06715723127126694, 0.02092127688229084, -0.030595991760492325, -0.045474208891391754, 0.0014840050134807825, 0.03226223587989807, 0.01163755264133215, -0.014764987863600254, -0.016019973903894424, -0.005863570608198643, 0.020308436825871468, -0.03070070594549179, -0.07953012734651566, 0.016622111201286316, 0.0025058190803974867, -0.0012276408961042762, -0.051990751177072525, -0.05295400321483612, -0.012370282784104347, -0.00019190135935787112, -0.056788425892591476, -0.030479954555630684, -0.009464656002819538, -0.05790664255619049, -0.035554587841033936, 0.009510548785328865, -0.008106058463454247, 0.05163146182894707, 0.03764825314283371, 0.002988585736602545, -0.014350101351737976, 0.006764608900994062, -0.004729027394205332, -0.047477997839450836, 0.01473982073366642, 0.0654514878988266, 0.03747057169675827, -0.03323013335466385, -0.030581071972846985, 0.027742953971028328, 0.0329374223947525, 0.06619106978178024, -0.004100301302969456, -0.05872488021850586, 0.005035402253270149, -0.0405069962143898, -0.0406414270401001, -0.05275778844952583, 0.04382584989070892, 0.03207528963685036, 0.05142698436975479, -0.07371819019317627, -0.007782951928675175, 0.019986961036920547, 0.02956327423453331, 0.008002047426998615, -0.04594689980149269, -0.049354758113622665, 0.005416921805590391, -0.0442892350256443, 0.004869149532169104, -0.005183715373277664, -0.0001188547394121997, -0.015615232288837433, -0.007568744942545891, -0.01224835216999054, 0.03066990338265896, -0.03766821697354317, 0.02920980378985405, 0.013183009810745716, 0.010963893495500088, -0.06093040853738785, -0.05702272802591324, 0.014410176314413548, -0.06234610825777054, 0.00022335065295919776, 0.02697443775832653, -0.011059611104428768, -0.022402647882699966, 0.03867914900183678, 0.018593166023492813, -0.022663822397589684, -0.007573404815047979, 0.06290273368358612, -0.04145874083042145, 0.01775929145514965, 0.013605882413685322, 0.030159974470734596, -0.03471596911549568, -0.031600333750247955, 0.002780338516458869, 0.049357425421476364, -0.006790230982005596, -0.04969070479273796, 0.06832968443632126, 0.007886814884841442, 0.05539538711309433, -0.007436308544129133, 0.00028408426442183554, -0.01656181924045086, 0.01278375182300806, 0.02415991574525833, -0.021299107000231743, -0.02240898087620735, -0.021985629573464394, 0.01883142627775669, -0.04674496874213219, -0.09430870413780212, -0.08434750884771347, 0.03377343341708183, 0.0035546445287764072, -0.03978736698627472, 0.03233460336923599, -0.01366597879678011, -0.04539969936013222, 0.008972772397100925, 0.019363075494766235, -0.012757998891174793, -0.0466754287481308, -0.006544528063386679, 0.011395583860576153, -0.011499223299324512, -0.018596775829792023, -0.04387514665722847, 0.013989079743623734, 0.04087772220373154, -0.022935286164283752, 0.026270393282175064, -0.05899757891893387, -0.02342299185693264, -0.06680629402399063, 0.07271915674209595, 0.019618088379502296, -0.03224766254425049, 0.0232261810451746, -0.016285059973597527, 0.037088532000780106, 0.01397491991519928, -0.031005803495645523, 0.02500210702419281, -0.012936998158693314, -0.018230479210615158, 0.003190060378983617, 0.023951997980475426, -0.044505711644887924, 0.03633474186062813, 0.0763603150844574, 0.019061541184782982, 0.04871485382318497, 0.01804906502366066, -0.026920607313513756, -0.009557061828672886, -0.06533420085906982, 0.010887195356190205, 0.03196069225668907, 0.01809336058795452, 0.046129260212183, 0.015849804505705833, -0.004040415398776531, 0.00563847878947854, -0.02280958741903305, 0.01569182798266411, 0.023057911545038223, -0.004725966136902571, 0.05904040485620499, 0.02859196811914444, -0.022296197712421417, -0.018422525376081467, -0.027337824925780296, -0.022468656301498413, 0.028709949925541878, -0.05499418452382088, 0.008371053263545036, 0.012793172150850296, 0.02857043407857418, 0.05788247659802437, 0.023395253345370293, 0.02303757518529892, -0.01679631695151329, -0.0891304612159729, -0.03046082891523838, -0.03158900886774063, 0.027302075177431107, 0.059379324316978455, -0.029290856793522835, 0.019527742639183998, 0.0365607887506485, -0.031220613047480583, 0.007998287677764893, -0.04198132082819939, -0.00612816633656621, 0.07337029278278351, 0.0810883641242981, 0.010996300727128983, 0.0023483706172555685, -0.009739057160913944, -0.03776992857456207, -0.005543983541429043, -0.05420263111591339, 0.008508813567459583, 0.038926657289266586, 0.01263309083878994, 0.024542897939682007, -0.02543267421424389, 0.018547121435403824, 0.000004097095825272845, -0.00658939266577363, -0.04194175451993942, -0.026295863091945648, -0.007331615313887596, -0.02631305530667305, -0.00033741845982149243, 0.003897374030202627, 0.014869216829538345, -0.02163301780819893, 0.0033456278033554554, 0.027749620378017426, 0.053260140120983124, -0.018261589109897614, 0.06209094449877739, -0.059270843863487244, -0.04730663821101189, -0.012745614163577557, 0.007782991509884596, 0.026285383850336075, -0.013793867081403732, -0.04968337342143059, -0.04215819388628006, 0.04196053370833397, 0.04824444651603699, -0.0025043690111488104, 0.030410850420594215, -0.025490084663033485, -0.011932174675166607, 0.06637454777956009, -0.019203854724764824, -0.02051987685263157, 0.008010358549654484, -0.013619708828628063, -0.03392552584409714, 0.006962951272726059, 0.044157449156045914, 0.016733622178435326, -0.0724157989025116, -0.07765065878629684, 0.022036585956811905, -0.06001945585012436, -0.0047284397296607494, 0.0053261686116456985, 0.0344538539648056, -0.019115038216114044, 0.02669508382678032, 0.031486671417951584, 0.016925156116485596, -0.06287191063165665, -0.02193594165146351, -0.022826727479696274, 0.04266972467303276, 0.015529530122876167, -0.020366907119750977, -0.04470961168408394, -0.004766478203237057, 0.010021131485700607, 0.008508325554430485, -0.015068207867443562, 0.07759478688240051, -0.00290071708150208, -0.08235953003168106, -0.04666745662689209, -0.03797384351491928, -0.002934683347120881, -0.005171951372176409, -0.05221305042505264, 0.059440527111291885, -0.0028156815096735954, -0.010310537181794643, 0.03985939919948578, -0.008540487848222256, -0.001903046271763742, -0.06931587308645248, 0.005353135988116264, 0.018704121932387352, 0.025793273001909256, -0.05435143783688545, -0.012379137799143791, 0.00020757743914145976 ]
<p>I read that the k-means algorithm only converges to a local minimum and not to a global minimum. Why is this? I can logically think of how initialization could affect the final clustering and there is a possibility of sub-optimum clustering, but I did not find anything that will mathematically prove that.</p> <p>Also, why is k-means an iterative process? Can't we just partially differentiate the objective function w.r.t. to the centroids, equate it to zero to find the centroids that minimizes this function? Why do we have to use gradient descent to reach the minimum step by step?</p>
g44377
[ 0.03230997920036316, 0.008686990477144718, 0.00766287837177515, 0.05695796385407448, 0.02993910200893879, 0.016029812395572662, -0.007927636615931988, 0.03759552165865898, -0.045481711626052856, -0.023341096937656403, -0.030047154054045677, 0.02629924565553665, 0.061991021037101746, 0.04178297519683838, -0.018027091398835182, -0.02675657719373703, -0.034732189029455185, -0.04075196385383606, 0.03675230219960213, 0.027014199644327164, -0.041342101991176605, 0.019679758697748184, -0.00851462222635746, -0.009588724002242088, -0.0048432317562401295, 0.022991124540567398, -0.020693056285381317, -0.002372860675677657, 0.019683994352817535, 0.0653628259897232, 0.046438563615083694, -0.018739264458417892, 0.00596287427470088, -0.07802886515855789, 0.024456804618239403, -0.004554372746497393, 0.08394260704517365, -0.022555338218808174, -0.010673223063349724, -0.033106133341789246, -0.008123337291181087, -0.015371782705187798, 0.05225495994091034, -0.015082321129739285, -0.05998937785625458, -0.017400644719600677, 0.04444300755858421, 0.03553568199276924, 0.07121442258358002, -0.04048183932900429, -0.053246933966875076, 0.03206764906644821, 0.012783779762685299, -0.029232239350676537, 0.014965558424592018, 0.00813024677336216, 0.0017755230655893683, 0.02810761332511902, 0.041999250650405884, 0.0066473037004470825, 0.042107392102479935, 0.012915028259158134, -0.004976247902959585, 0.07736951112747192, 0.008992099203169346, -0.056693773716688156, -0.04830740764737129, 0.011141499504446983, -0.007136633154004812, 0.05791975557804108, -0.012786022387444973, 0.020727287977933884, 0.03283600136637688, 0.033156733959913254, -0.08015469461679459, 0.01826348528265953, 0.02621803991496563, 0.005843276623636484, 0.028526514768600464, 0.04201102256774902, 0.0234858188778162, 0.01213531568646431, 0.0014976171078160405, -0.006682542152702808, -0.03018748201429844, 0.05794042721390724, -0.025545362383127213, -0.04003011807799339, 0.0861523449420929, 0.01574712060391903, 0.004887918476015329, -0.009844993241131306, 0.021246133372187614, -0.04398796707391739, -0.00755586801096797, -0.01994561403989792, -0.03587346151471138, 0.048993296921253204, 0.03199410438537598, -0.021894896402955055, 0.01641661860048771, -0.01627263054251671, 0.013842729851603508, -0.038066521286964417, -0.018062159419059753, -0.04734308645129204, 0.0014592512743547559, -0.02048116736114025, 0.0468168705701828, 0.016707586124539375, 0.004016345366835594, -0.005578090902417898, -0.09334544837474823, 0.0036900604609400034, -0.04086839407682419, 0.06228025257587433, 0.021353408694267273, 0.016851812601089478, 0.017524538561701775, 0.012819100171327591, -0.022454211488366127, -0.05587351694703102, 0.007683834992349148, -0.012902005575597286, -0.031644780188798904, 0.029931994155049324, 0.02255329117178917, -0.032590411603450775, -0.03905631974339485, -0.04135976731777191, -0.017010116949677467, 0.019418921321630478, -0.020724624395370483, 0.0609293095767498, 0.02840006723999977, 0.05570242926478386, -0.0513303168118, 0.03128497302532196, 0.001102015725336969, -0.0072104306891560555, -0.10228224098682404, 0.012253168039023876, -0.004741813987493515, -0.04342460632324219, -0.06257614493370056, 0.008564180694520473, 0.027334747835993767, 0.021174250170588493, 0.02991236187517643, 0.002557606901973486, 0.020353959873318672, 0.03336057811975479, 0.08247445523738861, 0.0023939923848956823, -0.007773711811751127, -0.016366705298423767, 0.07392142713069916, -0.012388900853693485, 0.07742509990930557, -0.04130265489220619, 0.01695568673312664, -0.020373888313770294, 0.07063290476799011, -0.010252663865685463, -0.06367513537406921, -0.004995058290660381, 0.00425942987203598, -0.03266346454620361, -0.004588690120726824, -0.07171517610549927, -0.03127719461917877, -0.04424181953072548, 0.028593897819519043, 0.04578720033168793, -0.028726860880851746, 0.05769127607345581, -0.008216824382543564, -0.0003511637623887509, 0.0187606792896986, 0.10256985574960709, 0.003666860284283757, -0.022195151075720787, -0.012190702371299267, -0.001924379263073206, 0.048415299504995346, -0.012386742979288101, -0.015961233526468277, 0.09073422104120255, 0.021672850474715233, -0.008221777155995369, 0.030395638197660446, 0.008687873370945454, 0.033026620745658875, 0.052246153354644775, -0.01788526028394699, 0.05594135820865631, -0.005595433991402388, -0.036935821175575256, -0.01823589950799942, -0.043072283267974854, 0.03235282748937607, -0.022280076518654823, 0.00084995839279145, 0.04511670768260956, -0.0028876690194010735, -0.028746768832206726, -0.005289949476718903, 0.0005388237186707556, 0.05628723278641701, 0.005447529722005129, -0.023342574015259743, -0.06367801129817963, 0.021001383662223816, 0.026846108958125114, -0.0369846485555172, 0.02641061507165432, 0.0062811896204948425, 0.012959283776581287, 0.09158755838871002, -0.023532606661319733, -0.06252335011959076, -0.05259666591882706, -0.029389915987849236, 0.029538806527853012, 0.012794204987585545, 0.05188532918691635, -0.04288984090089798, -0.0152615150436759, -0.03423389419913292, -0.004215576685965061, -0.07977744191884995, -0.02940130978822708, -0.010361871682107449, -0.0213390551507473, 0.04091319441795349, 0.016484050080180168, 0.026599779725074768, -0.02853556163609028, -0.019501231610774994, 0.0011541626881808043, 0.009100742638111115, -0.06744517385959625, 0.028806090354919434, 0.03953492268919945, -0.007112443912774324, -0.04460214823484421, 0.024036433547735214, -0.019414013251662254, -0.09147852659225464, -0.03744525462388992, 0.036343589425086975, 0.05308409407734871, -0.018089206889271736, -0.034938450902700424, 0.002831862773746252, -0.028098179027438164, -0.04486614465713501, 0.06466769427061081, 0.02998175285756588, 0.015333735384047031, -0.009614893235266209, 0.03834129497408867, 0.02859100140631199, -0.06322917342185974, -0.006144885439425707, 0.008192849345505238, 0.004044832196086645, -0.021660108119249344, 0.08323480933904648, -0.017287157475948334, -0.030011512339115143, 0.055573683232069016, 0.042340055108070374, 0.020788410678505898, -0.006464148871600628, 0.005890226922929287, -0.01627541333436966, 0.016334179788827896, 0.028181668370962143, 0.05229554697871208, -0.01400058250874281, -0.03547785058617592, -0.012061896733939648, -0.016733869910240173, -0.03390031307935715, -0.015343597158789635, 0.053487736731767654, 0.0490792877972126, 0.01918559893965721, -0.010465634055435658, 0.012086563743650913, -0.00045308528933674097, 0.06325656920671463, -0.026333501562476158, 0.05373062938451767, 0.014518664218485355, 0.03319291025400162, -0.04232756793498993, 0.01203312911093235, 0.028713902458548546, -0.017971351742744446, -0.008051538839936256, 0.0018220801139250398, -0.08008737117052078, 0.023739591240882874, -0.0012260384391993284, -0.009470921009778976, -0.052675988525152206, -0.04194556549191475, -0.01312242355197668, 0.020785000175237656, 0.031625475734472275, 0.007427466567605734, 0.0019395758863538504, 0.013078381307423115, 0.015213602222502232, -0.03250125050544739, 0.05822497978806496, -0.03584594279527664, -0.0032595584634691477, 0.002541301306337118, 0.02202627994120121, -0.039169859141111374, -0.006859654560685158, 0.024486403912305832, 0.03814208135008812, -0.04384709149599075, -0.04979568347334862, 0.023599756881594658, 0.007192820310592651, 0.02643750235438347, -0.0021941617596894503, -0.06374145299196243, 0.02389141544699669, -0.044815950095653534, -0.0955485850572586, -0.053439438343048096, -0.04183202236890793, -0.0026592544745653868, 0.08024811744689941, -0.019721420481801033, -0.023670556023716927, -0.015313287265598774, 0.0010272698709741235, -0.023219099268317223, 0.06869006901979446, 0.02111763507127762, -0.01816784217953682, -0.0026538600213825703, 0.027005933225154877, 0.035383209586143494, -0.05061198025941849, 0.017454341053962708, -0.054788582026958466, -0.013177696615457535, 0.05921030417084694, 0.014593087136745453, -0.010627559386193752, -0.059681762009859085, 0.006462796125560999, 0.0053515988402068615, 0.01750483363866806, -0.03768141195178032, 0.01927874982357025, -0.015823425725102425, -0.018639877438545227, 0.04649605602025986, 0.011246908456087112, 0.024292772635817528, 0.0015818666433915496, -0.03595542535185814, 0.031779058277606964, 0.014851424843072891, -0.03459092974662781, -0.02072599157691002, -0.0011928066378459334, -0.0007152727339416742, 0.038385022431612015, 0.018093522638082504, -0.023003915324807167, -0.0005355631001293659, -0.00994083657860756, -0.02238650992512703, -0.024667251855134964, 0.02871600165963173, 0.038861650973558426, -0.08293177932500839, -0.042290098965168, -0.012861935421824455, 0.03876076266169548, -0.004075825214385986, -0.0202828049659729, 0.018993500620126724, -0.012556196190416813, 0.05801958963274956, 0.03971239551901817, -0.01741676591336727, 0.01626185141503811, -0.01425573043525219, 0.028796739876270294, 0.02247116155922413, 0.011950002983212471, 0.03211382403969765, -0.0030753577593714, 0.05204041674733162, -0.05540132895112038, -0.04757514223456383, -0.002841609762981534, 0.0022470189724117517, -0.03569919615983963, 0.04868945851922035, 0.019651465117931366, 0.009648379869759083, -0.03518730029463768, 0.05736301839351654, -0.06914636492729187, -0.008845806121826172, 0.00014485925203189254, 0.0006377283716574311, -0.01812133938074112, 0.022121157497167587, -0.00920789036899805, -0.03380801901221275, -0.03562548756599426, -0.016925210133194923, 0.04624602198600769, -0.001917641144245863, 0.01839241199195385, 0.02315743826329708, -0.019353000447154045, 0.028957614675164223, -0.014025560580193996, 0.003487826557829976, -0.009563167579472065, -0.004232008475810289, -0.0323091596364975, 0.027759592980146408, 0.03095465712249279, -0.05132323130965233, -0.05589203163981438, 0.022862451151013374, 0.0032712146639823914, -0.03675470128655434, 0.06229481101036072, 0.00611082511022687, 0.014261586591601372, -0.011828138493001461, 0.009384860284626484, 0.013744034804403782, 0.031993620097637177, 0.03432135283946991, 0.05017152056097984, -0.00028743527946062386, -0.04372159019112587, 0.004631608724594116, 0.007004706189036369, -0.038564715534448624, 0.029464995488524437, 0.017804544419050217, 0.059124767780303955, 0.017009086906909943, -0.012313244864344597, -0.039929069578647614, 0.029215890914201736, 0.09034046530723572, -0.006990005262196064, -0.03466195985674858, 0.032668355852365494, -0.0653311163187027, 0.038165219128131866, 0.007075294386595488, 0.02493513561785221, 0.030512679368257523, -0.0415085032582283, 0.021288547664880753, 0.03573821112513542, -0.04657450690865517, 0.013305434957146645, 0.0562465526163578, -0.027372652664780617, -0.030941203236579895, -0.021565580740571022, -0.03092138096690178, 0.06054167076945305, -0.028830768540501595, 0.0539235956966877, -0.02417667582631111, -0.09469576179981232, 0.022660808637738228, 0.012704991735517979, 0.03540140390396118, 0.01985384151339531, 0.03874330222606659, -0.06456231325864792, 0.03576386719942093, 0.014617172069847584, 0.0040734317153692245, -0.03910558298230171, 0.02816266193985939, -0.01222944911569357, -0.058406662195920944, -0.05390075221657753, -0.012713023461401463, -0.051663730293512344, 0.01444980688393116, 0.024856852367520332, 0.09519989043474197, -0.06816516071557999, 0.04924169182777405, 0.09062669426202774, -0.0007729054195806384, 0.04710794985294342, 0.03513900190591812, 0.0304330512881279, -0.04217709228396416, -0.06739988178014755, 0.015755655243992805, 0.01509786956012249, -0.023665087297558784, -0.034527868032455444, 0.022624092176556587, -0.014602869749069214, -0.0431441031396389, 0.01933286525309086, 0.027173148468136787, -0.06925451755523682, -0.01749388873577118, -0.044432930648326874, 0.0010575433261692524, -0.01941288448870182, 0.007263175677508116, 0.03400490805506706, 0.0011526098242029548, 0.00725860008969903, -0.02180023118853569, -0.021957501769065857, 0.012399365194141865, 0.03791138157248497, 0.043639324605464935, -0.02891295962035656, -0.023957690224051476, -0.07127311825752258, -0.02559320069849491, -0.022493362426757812, -0.022715575993061066, -0.044869035482406616, 0.08603406697511673, 0.0421409010887146, -0.006075432989746332, -0.052291467785835266, -0.07343698292970657, -0.007814883254468441, -0.023688940331339836, 0.007862209342420101, -0.009875248186290264, -0.00315770017914474, -0.01798507571220398, 0.00515758479014039, 0.007981058210134506, -0.01141829788684845, 0.03753971680998802, -0.08183064311742783, -0.03360547870397568, 0.007178726140409708, 0.03971021994948387, -0.024276742711663246, -0.03232698142528534, 0.025884566828608513, 0.07149334996938705, -0.03491087257862091, -0.028961777687072754, -0.06355293095111847, -0.0006965398788452148, 0.03914186730980873, 0.026097355410456657, -0.02526181749999523, 0.014538481831550598, 0.018530650064349174, -0.017775021493434906, -0.0054310644045472145, 0.011624232865869999, -0.018735185265541077, 0.0336063951253891, -0.05050492659211159, 0.0434502512216568, 0.03933246433734894, -0.05431258678436279, 0.03469013422727585, 0.06181073933839798, 0.0330471470952034, -0.006850501522421837, 0.05799837410449982, 0.011074057780206203, -0.001621423987671733, -0.020919907838106155, -0.03176300972700119, -0.033129241317510605, -0.001094600884243846, -0.03542125225067139, -0.03407834842801094, 0.022770611569285393, -0.00029660292784683406, 0.02789057046175003, -0.0283284280449152, -0.10093734413385391, 0.07510565221309662, 0.0242219939827919, -0.028379688039422035, 0.053710732609033585, 0.047326210886240005, -0.05126386880874634, 0.02806929685175419, 0.04287198930978775, 0.009157039225101471, 0.08054479956626892, -0.019385622814297676, -0.05607185140252113, -0.030796775594353676, -0.03379205986857414, -0.09471544623374939, 0.03720271587371826, -0.01475017424672842, -0.012786620296537876, -0.022148560732603073, -0.024272285401821136, 0.0657055675983429, 0.03615349531173706, 0.03767745941877365, 0.026464736089110374, 0.03887397423386574, -0.037343449890613556, 0.06637712568044662, -0.032134026288986206, 0.02128286100924015, -0.004953247029334307, 0.004408273845911026, -0.02310904487967491, 0.04967121779918671, -0.021096764132380486, 0.01844623126089573, 0.027818331494927406, 0.03689089044928551, -0.025789089500904083, 0.00867892149835825, -0.01420831773430109, 0.009571888484060764, 0.009339941665530205, 0.02675728313624859, -0.062009286135435104, -0.03207593038678169, -0.031542014330625534, 0.0701339915394783, -0.015888426452875137, -0.05544834956526756, 0.028008485212922096, -0.0410681813955307, -0.039011452347040176, 0.008255956694483757, 0.04431402310729027, 0.025761235505342484, -0.05492808297276497, 0.02437783218920231, 0.0037131484132260084, 0.01911567524075508, 0.01796146295964718, 0.03039119392633438, 0.002291048178449273, -0.0167555995285511, -0.007937120273709297, -0.08145735412836075, 0.004045339301228523, -0.020507171750068665, -0.01998823508620262, -0.00927861500531435, 0.007322763558477163, 0.03820401430130005, -0.059584472328424454, -0.016714274883270264, -0.04886656627058983, 0.012515627779066563, 0.006477083079516888, -0.024785960093140602, 0.02687142975628376, -0.03872157260775566, -0.00928907748311758, 0.009683351963758469, -0.025560671463608742, -0.020767802372574806, -0.01888279989361763, -0.06729530543088913, -0.008785304613411427, 0.005925731733441353, 0.054489366710186005, 0.026362460106611252, -0.042829398065805435, 0.06025281548500061, -0.040419355034828186, 0.01759226806461811, 0.018156075850129128, 0.005282470490783453, 0.018384389579296112, -0.03472854569554329, 0.029350798577070236, 0.006732114590704441, 0.013773060403764248, -0.05092725530266762, -0.05357890948653221, -0.004073397256433964, -0.01206783764064312, -0.02765537053346634, 0.012521075084805489, 0.000598807237111032, -0.04938020184636116, -0.018267663195729256, -0.04301433637738228, -0.014369062148034573, -0.06977861374616623, -0.011755907908082008, -0.05508984625339508, 0.022501766681671143, 0.0463695302605629, 0.007954261265695095, 0.050861287862062454, -0.023865913972258568, -0.052568960934877396, 0.019037652760744095, 0.03336380049586296, -0.032342709600925446, -0.022077593952417374, 0.03205876052379608, -0.07073137164115906, -0.005180799402296543, -0.03586360812187195, -0.005434642545878887, 0.06490025669336319, -0.03474658355116844, -0.0044554718770086765, -0.014790160581469536, 0.02821943163871765, -0.022407332435250282, -0.061957139521837234, -0.027925580739974976, -0.03062409721314907, 0.03960692882537842, -0.000672239635605365, 0.012746438384056091, 0.02719566971063614, -0.003925655037164688, 0.05128484219312668, -0.039638396352529526, -0.02145485207438469, 0.012561486102640629, -0.012946772389113903, 0.0008544823504053056, 0.004355128854513168, -0.00493983831256628, 0.031111467629671097, 0.019700411707162857, 0.006740006152540445, -0.0307305995374918, -0.016118017956614494, -0.044609103351831436, -0.0329488068819046, 0.07646838575601578, 0.04555056616663933, 0.0022893233690410852, 0.025186611339449883, -0.01263202354311943 ]
<p>Could anyone suggest the best method to predict the time gap between two events?</p> <p>For example, given that diabetics are at higher risk of developing hypertension, I would like to predict the time gap until patients develop hypertension after being diagnosed with diabetes. </p> <p>I will have both time dependent and independent covariates. Does this require a longitudinal approach? </p>
g74061
[ 0.0752670019865036, -0.009579645469784737, 0.005720121320337057, -0.02673373743891716, -0.05496874451637268, -0.029308561235666275, 0.04400679096579552, 0.018356481567025185, -0.03356306999921799, -0.0019893241114914417, 0.05791134759783745, 0.03298436477780342, 0.05070523917675018, -0.029576726257801056, 0.05706125870347023, 0.00918546225875616, -0.00015827316383365542, -0.0161595456302166, -0.04964813217520714, -0.028211934491991997, -0.009817824698984623, 0.01557245384901762, -0.003028018167242408, 0.017479514703154564, -0.08334698528051376, -0.04461284354329109, 0.01139480248093605, 0.015912938863039017, -0.015329529531300068, 0.010322129353880882, 0.0034908826928585768, 0.016859237104654312, 0.05731547996401787, -0.008854573592543602, -0.0026265562046319246, -0.000299474602798, -0.012782823294401169, -0.0020410160068422556, -0.012552622705698013, -0.008601433597505093, 0.01974191702902317, 0.02497858554124832, 0.0020005989354103804, -0.001737178536131978, -0.009937170892953873, -0.0378294475376606, 0.00840951781719923, 0.006889766547828913, -0.030271295458078384, 0.03038625419139862, 0.032145511358976364, 0.04080105945467949, -0.04140830412507057, 0.022218631580471992, -0.0342993326485157, 0.017725173383951187, 0.005730281583964825, 0.021851859986782074, -0.013355933129787445, 0.018481964245438576, 0.03031141124665737, 0.017249708995223045, -0.05754288285970688, -0.006797571200877428, 0.06379035115242004, 0.003997139632701874, 0.004926044028252363, -0.02022738941013813, -0.004957466386258602, 0.007453028578311205, -0.025930391624569893, 0.033061183989048004, 0.01442931778728962, 0.046730998903512955, 0.03523140400648117, -0.014576375484466553, 0.06736693531274796, 0.02023009955883026, 0.026779284700751305, -0.014804672449827194, 0.045158226042985916, 0.02696288749575615, 0.05186752602458, -0.00988193228840828, 0.052496422082185745, -0.012512272223830223, -0.016359133645892143, 0.0040854038670659065, -0.0024038853589445353, 0.042497001588344574, 0.008187562227249146, 0.01284515019506216, 0.03676285222172737, 0.04754741117358208, -0.016576124355196953, -0.021213417872786522, -0.0478014200925827, 0.007213921286165714, 0.03033631481230259, -0.017798805609345436, -0.006860190536826849, 0.007425229996442795, 0.02931356616318226, -0.018709078431129456, -0.06058473885059357, -0.05113271623849869, -0.046007946133613586, -0.03152093291282654, -0.04995689541101456, -0.017200879752635956, -0.05032767727971077, 0.06064640358090401, -0.030855901539325714, 0.043950583785772324, 0.03403385356068611, -0.05926540121436119, -0.03776553273200989, -0.023639751598238945, -0.021330315619707108, -0.046073585748672485, 0.0064420755952596664, -0.021465685218572617, 0.013614797033369541, 0.0962325856089592, -0.04800527170300484, -0.0190934669226408, -0.02523081749677658, 0.0167174581438303, 0.025372831150889397, 0.03012855350971222, 0.03694808855652809, 0.03039848804473877, 0.06879257410764694, 0.08627057075500488, 0.01826944388449192, 0.03108358196914196, 0.037715885788202286, 0.03309226036071777, -0.015282112173736095, 0.030602499842643738, 0.009830296970903873, -0.013813921250402927, 0.034613534808158875, -0.026730194687843323, -0.024097248911857605, 0.06146378815174103, -0.012186362408101559, -0.03290721774101257, -0.06342453509569168, 0.016659226268529892, -0.029271308332681656, 0.00918574444949627, -0.022151624783873558, 0.05026310309767723, 0.02506907656788826, 0.021216824650764465, -0.04725216329097748, -0.00711435591802001, -0.026938356459140778, 0.019587943330407143, -0.004480463452637196, -0.00316900503821671, -0.008164932020008564, 0.030360274016857147, -0.029637515544891357, -0.07050041109323502, 0.04720669984817505, -0.0054127187468111515, -0.019591905176639557, -0.018072668462991714, 0.0078075663186609745, 0.011904592625796795, 0.028454748913645744, -0.024084003642201424, 0.05582224577665329, 0.05103931576013565, 0.011848879978060722, -0.039345987141132355, -0.012617095373570919, -0.003810371970757842, 0.014155490323901176, -0.04314973205327988, -0.014197180978953838, 0.015862831845879555, 0.006281513255089521, -0.04907245934009552, 0.02541251853108406, 0.004517402965575457, -0.04230556637048721, -0.03969589248299599, -0.014762965962290764, 0.0022565757390111685, 0.004105219151824713, 0.011577850207686424, -0.04997212439775467, 0.029089869931340218, 0.04718128219246864, -0.06139123812317848, -0.059217654168605804, 0.010970725677907467, -0.0076026455499231815, 0.05510460585355759, 0.007428365759551525, 0.06422040611505508, -0.07139652222394943, 0.05935661494731903, 0.038637351244688034, -0.02460002526640892, -0.01182696595788002, -0.02305767685174942, -0.0403287373483181, 0.06489641219377518, -0.041704703122377396, -0.010133798234164715, -0.009389527142047882, -0.05365501716732979, -0.03550814837217331, 0.049513861536979675, -0.013243230991065502, -0.050664592534303665, -0.03646143525838852, -0.053751230239868164, 0.029633743688464165, -0.026774706318974495, 0.015295370481908321, -0.035798024386167526, 0.004555557854473591, 0.037420108914375305, 0.01854630932211876, -0.015051881782710552, -0.02412181720137596, -0.0011693936539813876, -0.014155268669128418, -0.03579270467162132, 0.042423974722623825, 0.028682105243206024, -0.018448686227202415, -0.017992522567510605, 0.017431674525141716, 0.064549021422863, 0.0276966392993927, -0.028634848073124886, 0.032678715884685516, 0.06295141577720642, -0.02357998490333557, -0.08093755692243576, 0.056070130318403244, -0.013371182605624199, -0.018270764499902725, 0.026508599519729614, 0.0017013322794809937, 0.03818207606673241, -0.0768437385559082, -0.039483848959207535, 0.0002159763389499858, -0.07243666052818298, 0.020315496250987053, -0.0019304859451949596, -0.05293445661664009, -0.013553796336054802, -0.020239314064383507, 0.019062267616391182, 0.07347056269645691, -0.015390977263450623, 0.004412342794239521, -0.02691647596657276, 0.021532626822590828, -0.017486806958913803, -0.010224083438515663, -0.04528116434812546, -0.0025016397703438997, 0.016801977530121803, -0.008885715156793594, 0.002294086618348956, -0.01308357436209917, -0.01764184609055519, -0.048205383121967316, -0.0028297409880906343, -0.02933720499277115, 0.010980883613228798, 0.06528224796056747, -0.05292769521474838, 0.056788187474012375, 0.027308061718940735, 0.01829242892563343, 0.01323860976845026, 0.06889272481203079, 0.01737329177558422, 0.03196483850479126, 0.0895153060555458, -0.035895850509405136, 0.052079591900110245, -0.004055449273437262, -0.028599541634321213, -0.0009618503972887993, 0.0033312931191176176, 0.01226610504090786, -0.03533688560128212, 0.0030239850748330355, -0.0005546969478018582, -0.04125840216875076, -0.012674016878008842, 0.04802980646491051, -0.04155607894062996, 0.028471482917666435, -0.06590723991394043, -0.024574026465415955, -0.027800150215625763, -0.007335650268942118, -0.057219408452510834, 0.02026684582233429, -0.023416008800268173, -0.01869278773665428, 0.0007039755582809448, -0.021763017401099205, -0.03911000117659569, 0.019842693582177162, 0.02987992949783802, 0.05520639941096306, 0.059982072561979294, 0.03984864428639412, -0.015912510454654694, -0.005133837927132845, 0.04066881909966469, -0.06828813254833221, -0.04887967184185982, -0.009023196063935757, -0.06637201458215714, -0.07833296805620193, 0.05797925218939781, -0.018917858600616455, 0.007580199278891087, 0.018536219373345375, 0.00481512350961566, 0.08147495239973068, -0.042857129126787186, 0.034935083240270615, -0.004898493178188801, -0.005028182175010443, 0.037612076848745346, -0.02190392091870308, -0.060132090002298355, -0.04048420488834381, -0.004130784887820482, -0.02517911233007908, -0.023284723982214928, 0.06153085455298424, 0.04334504157304764, 0.0350889191031456, -0.03562074899673462, -0.028848636895418167, -0.07345306873321533, -0.01074458472430706, 0.010478183627128601, 0.005536677315831184, 0.0025913796853274107, 0.05484294518828392, -0.02306697703897953, -0.025330616161227226, 0.00866384245455265, -0.01107766106724739, -0.02519741840660572, -0.023461807519197464, 0.017076503485441208, -0.02938990108668804, 0.03197626397013664, 0.002068151719868183, 0.028790174052119255, 0.02592463791370392, -0.05776090547442436, 0.03421342745423317, 0.07344065606594086, 0.04651685059070587, -0.020063325762748718, 0.017099156975746155, -0.08215329051017761, 0.0367792472243309, 0.02158244140446186, 0.0084467688575387, 0.023806210607290268, 0.006740886252373457, 0.06632082909345627, 0.033294882625341415, 0.07201411575078964, 0.009482289664447308, -0.06456593424081802, 0.03549104928970337, -0.024667656049132347, 0.00506558595225215, -0.039049867540597916, 0.04569974169135094, 0.003249170258641243, -0.01149754785001278, -0.014729536138474941, 0.013265537098050117, 0.013932188972830772, -0.017788445577025414, 0.1000700518488884, 0.03833684325218201, -0.004180317744612694, -0.01685614138841629, 0.001488313777372241, 0.015565499663352966, 0.044186461716890335, -0.027951523661613464, 0.01786910556256771, -0.007693731691688299, -0.054106637835502625, -0.015313047915697098, 0.04797227680683136, 0.024111365899443626, -0.042161572724580765, -0.014283518306910992, 0.006533439736813307, 0.052430588752031326, -0.04533686488866806, 0.058747101575136185, -0.038893356919288635, 0.00032847069087438285, 0.060679323971271515, 0.0017527710879221559, 0.029248567298054695, -0.017725514248013496, 0.018352212384343147, 0.03703399747610092, -0.003049784805625677, 0.023950044065713882, -0.04138241335749626, -0.006839847657829523, 0.037481553852558136, 0.006165809463709593, 0.07457108050584793, -0.05118051916360855, 0.0066658081486821175, -0.009709207341074944, 0.039192669093608856, 0.05645689368247986, -0.019841380417346954, -0.029778312891721725, -0.09517818689346313, -0.005434034392237663, -0.013128835707902908, 0.0480838380753994, -0.012609974481165409, 0.045620813965797424, 0.08822264522314072, -0.015552844852209091, -0.05358549952507019, 0.02035088650882244, -0.027167221531271935, -0.02975117601454258, 0.0481858104467392, 0.003431056160479784, -0.01898365095257759, -0.022852372378110886, -0.052592914551496506, 0.003648162353783846, 0.016885284334421158, 0.032082073390483856, 0.07303746789693832, 0.010042267851531506, 0.01557468343526125, -0.05838871747255325, -0.04395535588264465, -0.041529349982738495, -0.040486305952072144, -0.0439470075070858, -0.039153601974248886, 0.029994474723935127, 0.08550827950239182, -0.027188187465071678, 0.011621898971498013, -0.004942704923450947, 0.029263947159051895, 0.01280873455107212, -0.01024635136127472, 0.013090797699987888, -0.012872553430497646, 0.011203477159142494, 0.04286038503050804, 0.014055656269192696, 0.00609159329906106, 0.041008446365594864, 0.01726257987320423, 0.03376464918255806, -0.010826868936419487, 0.02736474946141243, -0.07149121910333633, 0.05915588140487671, -0.0114364018663764, -0.012587116099894047, 0.030789261683821678, 0.07977208495140076, 0.04999898746609688, -0.017072755843400955, 0.004480893723666668, 0.06017187237739563, 0.026843875646591187, 0.0016573346219956875, -0.01713431067764759, -0.04271906986832619, 0.048454541712999344, 0.022258127108216286, -0.03197362273931503, 0.0493411086499691, 0.008202851749956608, 0.039171259850263596, -0.031337983906269073, -0.0199738759547472, 0.0673520490527153, 0.0005235289572738111, 0.03312525898218155, -0.020725291222333908, 0.04001713916659355, -0.05085734277963638, 0.03199555724859238, 0.005027553997933865, 0.021060848608613014, -0.014389528892934322, -0.046812161803245544, 0.03843146935105324, -0.010032301768660545, 0.032687027007341385, 0.07133864611387253, 0.027344679459929466, -0.051460061222314835, -0.03398185223340988, -0.06358268857002258, -0.007854582741856575, -0.06133251637220383, -0.006540594156831503, -0.04262104257941246, -0.01364592183381319, -0.044592708349227905, 0.014495059847831726, 0.002498529851436615, -0.02934185042977333, -0.0033169800881296396, 0.003705332288518548, -0.040558528155088425, -0.10770594328641891, 0.00462697260081768, 0.04642682150006294, -0.0658939778804779, -0.01913606747984886, -0.03740939870476723, -0.027800682932138443, 0.018090592697262764, 0.0016400158638134599, -0.012639347463846207, -0.0074128941632807255, -0.011211005970835686, 0.029403312131762505, 0.023718317970633507, 0.027166565880179405, 0.011532924138009548, 0.07212820649147034, -0.0025357110425829887, -0.015939325094223022, 0.01850186660885811, 0.01168814953416586, -0.005154743790626526, -0.02145926095545292, 0.03682330250740051, -0.06214245408773422, -0.015901044011116028, 0.007033615373075008, -0.023222506046295166, 0.024149123579263687, -0.01043021958321333, 0.04688849672675133, -0.06253589689731598, 0.054741837084293365, 0.011754991486668587, -0.07811763137578964, 0.018078312277793884, 0.016474217176437378, -0.019869567826390266, -0.005208098795264959, -0.028647521510720253, -0.04827000945806503, 0.04167740046977997, -0.028843898326158524, 0.05829814821481705, -0.010907690972089767, 0.04485832527279854, -0.009802090935409069, -0.007450784090906382, -0.0058777607046067715, 0.04157548025250435, 0.0011973022483289242, -0.03727109357714653, -0.041139159351587296, -0.017439914867281914, -0.011796298436820507, -0.005203994456678629, -0.04354848712682724, 0.0406871922314167, 0.025716057047247887, 0.031365860253572464, -0.031626682728528976, -0.01578512415289879, 0.02445453405380249, -0.049270156770944595, 0.01425167080014944, -0.02531030774116516, -0.02425374835729599, -0.02796044945716858, 0.020976096391677856, -0.03919672593474388, -0.04602306708693504, -0.0395653136074543, 0.062078479677438736, 0.002557791071012616, 0.016442598775029182, 0.038268081843853, -0.08290353417396545, 0.004859522450715303, -0.07754521071910858, 0.0016052179271355271, 0.020879274234175682, 0.04714685678482056, -0.03900179639458656, 0.015184011310338974, 0.03095974400639534, 0.024878792464733124, -0.01861671172082424, -0.06561270356178284, -0.0039206864312291145, 0.05495162680745125, 0.016571534797549248, -0.04603744298219681, -0.04201722890138626, 0.04514540731906891, -0.008833485655486584, 0.005349610932171345, -0.04357798397541046, 0.04386292025446892, -0.03380466252565384, -0.026883305981755257, 0.026269041001796722, 0.03594479709863663, -0.03569139540195465, 0.025741422548890114, 0.033509064465761185, -0.0009251122828572989, 0.06193191185593605, -0.025061700493097305, -0.038974788039922714, -0.024928255006670952, -0.0037618610076606274, -0.04031626135110855, 0.016438333317637444, -0.036886490881443024, -0.007697051856666803, 0.01126860175281763, 0.027719343081116676, 0.0012375765945762396, 0.02191883884370327, 0.060634270310401917, -0.010467896237969398, -0.03797140344977379, -0.027988329529762268, 0.007598116062581539, 0.02661311626434326, 0.04110663756728172, 0.00020349161059129983, -0.04555699974298477, 0.02015944942831993, -0.019670946523547173, 0.0028893600683659315, -0.0852385014295578, 0.029015524312853813, 0.020813215523958206, -0.02756430022418499, 0.036674197763204575, -0.038215894252061844, -0.011620044708251953, -0.033281873911619186, -0.027513567358255386, -0.08070515841245651, 0.010634664446115494, 0.04227057099342346, -0.019917849451303482, -0.006163257639855146, 0.14370016753673553, -0.026528047397732735, -0.05175309628248215, 0.027494071051478386, 0.029194166883826256, -0.08038146048784256, 0.028262870386242867, -0.04539499431848526, -0.001877287751995027, -0.01831122674047947, 0.019840575754642487, 0.024096721783280373, 0.031235160306096077, 0.018204137682914734, 0.07268369197845459, -0.04719410091638565, 0.04196285828948021, 0.03538750112056732, -0.06140454113483429, -0.001620443887077272, -0.005478695500642061, -0.0669318288564682, -0.032941821962594986, 0.001013099798001349, -0.013835275545716286, 0.04955761134624481, 0.049578387290239334, -0.04667586460709572, -0.03149372339248657, -0.029097946360707283, -0.03907568007707596, -0.02483353018760681, -0.06232886388897896, -0.0004310007207095623, 0.023203086107969284, -0.06024843826889992, -0.09234290570020676, -0.008065499365329742, -0.020089078694581985, 0.05981765687465668, -0.0064768423326313496, -0.0010206332663074136, -0.02655024640262127, -0.016310755163431168, -0.04644862934947014, 0.025016820058226585, 0.017133278772234917, 0.020602934062480927, -0.0009570915717631578, 0.0308524202555418, 0.004659890662878752, 0.016805259510874748, 0.05491884425282478, -0.0004328392678871751, 0.017835834994912148, -0.011413349770009518, -0.03714624047279358, -0.013830462470650673, -0.016018429771065712, 0.01646697148680687, -0.008821364492177963, 0.029886916279792786, 0.016657361760735512, 0.023719945922493935, 0.004651887342333794, -0.012767056003212929, 0.02187727391719818, -0.0010247051250189543, 0.036262452602386475, 0.01805909164249897, -0.02892550453543663, -0.07082982361316681, -0.021800924092531204, 0.014632199890911579, -0.04060954228043556, -0.0279354527592659, 0.03277822583913803, -0.04701307788491249, -0.024743255227804184, 0.005011582747101784, -0.013120782561600208, 0.020257582888007164, 0.022176632657647133 ]
<p>I have been using successfully DBNs for classification for MNIST and some other tasks.</p> <p>I was thinking of doing dimensionality reduction before training, in order to boost performance. However, when I tried out using the output of PCA to train a deep belief network the results were quite bad.</p> <p>I understand that DBNs learn features from the image and that PCA might project the data into a space where things do not look as similar anymore, but I was not expecting such a bad result.</p> <p>Any ideas why this could be? I was especially suprised because this paper has succesfully used it: <a href="http://cs.stanford.edu/people/ang/papers/nips07-sparsedeepbeliefnetworkv2.pdf" rel="nofollow">paper here</a></p> <p>Thank you!</p>
g74062
[ 0.00595533661544323, 0.0051537747494876385, 0.004467868246138096, -0.06683451682329178, -0.035988520830869675, -0.04167700931429863, 0.050033088773489, 0.061413686722517014, -0.04963602498173714, -0.11182022839784622, 0.040020957589149475, 0.018071122467517853, 0.03919396921992302, 0.025962363928556442, -0.03849472850561142, 0.003327529178932309, -0.013106058351695538, -0.020430803298950195, -0.012136846780776978, -0.03553445637226105, -0.005016395356506109, 0.017885595560073853, 0.07433310151100159, -0.03624704107642174, -0.03484024107456207, -0.05386658012866974, -0.03783091902732849, -0.009361010044813156, -0.05034693703055382, 0.02308695577085018, 0.023521943017840385, 0.010366082191467285, 0.004415086004883051, -0.010144338011741638, -0.02768821083009243, 0.0022860062308609486, 0.016706930473446846, 0.02281537838280201, 0.06715932488441467, 0.026335587725043297, -0.04374752566218376, -0.03611017391085625, 0.0013828795636072755, -0.030483420938253403, -0.03169900178909302, -0.0062242490239441395, -0.045527469366788864, -0.020937053486704826, 0.005307591054588556, 0.0042889793403446674, 0.016217121854424477, -0.01227759663015604, 0.04088792949914932, -0.0035689370706677437, 0.047542888671159744, 0.0351601243019104, -0.01848834566771984, 0.03466935455799103, 0.02452217787504196, -0.03201276808977127, -0.01984780840575695, 0.024088848382234573, -0.028525972738862038, 0.061855290085077286, -0.003282470628619194, -0.015822166576981544, -0.034052763134241104, 0.02767164818942547, 0.015702372416853905, 0.003250113921239972, -0.008244526572525501, 0.01776987686753273, -0.021411269903182983, 0.021479662507772446, 0.050510335713624954, -0.032191772013902664, -0.02118486538529396, -0.0017198532586917281, -0.03197917342185974, 0.05330002307891846, 0.049208108335733414, 0.015951519832015038, -0.040998298674821854, 0.011528415605425835, 0.03393708914518356, 0.058017559349536896, 0.03743622824549675, -0.010459615848958492, 0.03942515701055527, 0.046124737709760666, -0.0025972172152251005, -0.030246062204241753, 0.03467965126037598, 0.07020550966262817, 0.05039814114570618, 0.006097797770053148, 0.012726482935249805, 0.02057977393269539, -0.00800738949328661, 0.013307803310453892, -0.021739261224865913, 0.051337867975234985, 0.04291297122836113, 0.012566390447318554, 0.0023204574827104807, 0.04203189164400101, -0.041164886206388474, -0.007962746545672417, -0.053135499358177185, 0.049806565046310425, -0.008670940063893795, -0.023541724309325218, -0.05456150323152542, 0.035140715539455414, -0.0536978542804718, -0.02380850352346897, 0.0419192910194397, -0.009298205375671387, -0.0036918085534125566, -0.0149606354534626, 0.08106011897325516, -0.04229804873466492, 0.030487192794680595, 0.06799802929162979, 0.015015048906207085, 0.002718196716159582, -0.02872845157980919, 0.054286323487758636, 0.006313058082014322, -0.04821161925792694, 0.009016595780849457, 0.01584922894835472, 0.002282452769577503, 0.04406466335058212, 0.025356890633702278, 0.040191926062107086, -0.03994406759738922, -0.0689442902803421, 0.02454911358654499, 0.04158170893788338, -0.03792233765125275, 0.042352449148893356, -0.017158353701233864, 0.0027833518106490374, -0.009832996875047684, -0.06788665801286697, -0.014042024500668049, 0.019169162958860397, 0.048521243035793304, 0.042508382350206375, 0.0022494972217828035, 0.04247118905186653, 0.05447394400835037, -0.012092776596546173, 0.025705957785248756, 0.048574529588222504, -0.001457891776226461, -0.038432855159044266, 0.028898676857352257, -0.025258325040340424, 0.00807887688279152, 0.02507973648607731, 0.013843505643308163, -0.012815829366445541, -0.01811816729605198, -0.04185326769948006, 0.01126090157777071, -0.02997831255197525, -0.013374077156186104, 0.009531193412840366, -0.002114660572260618, 0.06077677384018898, 0.03687897324562073, 0.04203842207789421, 0.03503526747226715, 0.0055275121703743935, 0.01958126202225685, -0.00670381635427475, 0.012283110059797764, 0.004280461929738522, -0.032442230731248856, 0.0765305906534195, -0.044905535876750946, 0.026808971539139748, 0.06255023926496506, 0.06375042349100113, -0.03526579588651657, 0.06722383946180344, -0.02214187942445278, -0.03712310269474983, -0.026385638862848282, -0.052168671041727066, -0.016190124675631523, 0.07665835320949554, -0.0022966875694692135, -0.03399603068828583, -0.014608613215386868, -0.028269967064261436, -0.040425438433885574, -0.032019950449466705, 0.000059457550378283486, 0.0005835843039676547, -0.006202414631843567, 0.09448982030153275, -0.05406679958105087, -0.05325198546051979, -0.006857964675873518, 0.030334392562508583, 0.00091585359768942, -0.008041493594646454, 0.010978702455759048, 0.019472045823931694, -0.03265204280614853, 0.0018328221049159765, -0.01316084899008274, 0.04373856633901596, -0.04309840872883797, 0.06638678163290024, -0.0009027758496813476, 0.011636538431048393, -0.02306833676993847, -0.06975537538528442, 0.07436547428369522, -0.027680393308401108, -0.00702142296358943, -0.006103822961449623, 0.028307335451245308, 0.0395636186003685, 0.007944103330373764, 0.006299539003521204, -0.032412927597761154, -0.015388973988592625, 0.018675703555345535, -0.014337663538753986, 0.03830549120903015, -0.002432137029245496, 0.02265268564224243, -0.005412069149315357, -0.03505198657512665, 0.04380115866661072, -0.02179032377898693, -0.055174969136714935, 0.00005492474156199023, 0.0005038624512962997, 0.07701393961906433, -0.04936860874295235, 0.03255374729633331, 0.004544505849480629, 0.0042870803736150265, 0.0156361386179924, -0.02614458277821541, 0.0033226271625608206, -0.00768290413543582, 0.022638730704784393, -0.010721062310039997, -0.004619629122316837, 0.0475396104156971, -0.013167189434170723, 0.0880160704255104, 0.0013920878991484642, 0.011368121951818466, 0.00012100393360015005, -0.026597628369927406, 0.034063346683979034, 0.033068664371967316, -0.05809931829571724, 0.008471379056572914, 0.029002780094742775, 0.016207678243517876, 0.016349200159311295, -0.02237134426832199, 0.011351161636412144, 0.05504808574914932, -0.05661160126328468, 0.016266606748104095, 0.11149099469184875, -0.006439017131924629, 0.013793679885566235, -0.00583875784650445, 0.001350277685560286, -0.04380391910672188, 0.02980855479836464, -0.05911250784993172, -0.04508763924241066, -0.004348605405539274, 0.02909350022673607, 0.03758835420012474, -0.04304410517215729, -0.0022604125551879406, 0.009930776432156563, 0.0049925739876925945, 0.009944463148713112, 0.025896115228533745, 0.02412165328860283, 0.03699157014489174, -0.05485960468649864, 0.02457292191684246, -0.012732458300888538, 0.022631091997027397, 0.004900685045868158, -0.0944540724158287, -0.007760756649076939, 0.05928633362054825, -0.004789453931152821, -0.044144466519355774, -0.042230959981679916, -0.03772146627306938, 0.0033981886226683855, -0.06709688156843185, -0.007198965642601252, -0.007924321107566357, -0.0234825499355793, -0.02595847100019455, -0.0340711809694767, 0.055799975991249084, -0.02975277602672577, -0.023021074011921883, 0.034159526228904724, -0.004475162830203772, -0.018529586493968964, -0.010889536701142788, -0.01847824640572071, -0.053190313279628754, -0.002369051333516836, 0.014407658018171787, 0.042765792459249496, 0.019469128921628, 0.04774639755487442, -0.013271291740238667, 0.0037043625488877296, 0.07946060597896576, -0.04122476279735565, -0.05000912770628929, 0.002980572870001197, -0.04954797774553299, -0.05555707961320877, -0.024852870032191277, 0.003978602588176727, 0.08466079086065292, 0.012451446615159512, -0.01368158869445324, -0.011145124211907387, -0.05275150388479233, -0.03314051032066345, 0.024502666667103767, 0.05441320315003395, 0.0158747136592865, -0.04905964061617851, -0.026592064648866653, -0.024168221279978752, 0.0017306760419160128, -0.030747244134545326, 0.00879023689776659, -0.01050342246890068, 0.01777064986526966, -0.011343060061335564, 0.03413084149360657, -0.04039418697357178, -0.008687489666044712, 0.04421619698405266, 0.047381747514009476, 0.010658488608896732, -0.030944304540753365, 0.015672150999307632, -0.07675362378358841, 0.022340955212712288, 0.04391925409436226, 0.05753934010863304, -0.008761273697018623, 0.011067572981119156, 0.05027812719345093, -0.03796955943107605, -0.032290272414684296, -0.04110568016767502, -0.04955534264445305, 0.031196514144539833, 0.006836886052042246, 0.0066527193412184715, 0.015577856451272964, -0.00917531456798315, 0.02620389498770237, -0.011755944229662418, -0.035010188817977905, -0.012429513968527317, 0.003852970665320754, 0.000841947621665895, -0.015006545931100845, 0.04613856226205826, -0.016078753396868706, 0.03129568323493004, 0.030024651437997818, -0.053612589836120605, -0.03734029456973076, -0.02904251404106617, 0.03497130423784256, -0.0049184574745595455, -0.032792817801237106, 0.06310901790857315, 0.03535553440451622, 0.022891588509082794, -0.10756716132164001, -0.04872330278158188, 0.048333972692489624, -0.011363408528268337, -0.02084755338728428, -0.06913173198699951, -0.009818783961236477, 0.07433032244443893, -0.011901387944817543, 0.01659359782934189, -0.044539161026477814, -0.010144987143576145, -0.03386068344116211, -0.02234829030930996, 0.03759423643350601, -0.041583072394132614, 0.061269551515579224, 0.026919009163975716, 0.0009547293302603066, -0.006151909939944744, 0.008972973562777042, 0.06042931228876114, -0.04254264011979103, -0.001453845645301044, 0.03399505466222763, 0.03452455252408981, 0.059191249310970306, -0.0012424869928508997, -0.00797294545918703, 0.0808868408203125, 0.05395837128162384, -0.0139144416898489, -0.004908218514174223, 0.034537140280008316, -0.005612348672002554, 0.01178743690252304, 0.0321149118244648, 0.043875131756067276, 0.01786808669567108, -0.02758004143834114, -0.035853322595357895, -0.009210876189172268, 0.03503437340259552, -0.01715729385614395, 0.013568918220698833, 0.016896342858672142, -0.006796012632548809, 0.012836669571697712, -0.05658572167158127, 0.03646218776702881, 0.038613125681877136, 0.039667945355176926, 0.01737932302057743, -0.032773081213235855, 0.07363514602184296, -0.0025931247510015965, -0.016072113066911697, 0.01259324699640274, 0.012673556804656982, 0.03428102657198906, -0.02284182794392109, 0.021340517327189445, -0.16989493370056152, -0.041972387582063675, -0.01711832359433174, -0.04199736565351486, -0.02406303398311138, -0.05360264331102371, 0.016531599685549736, -0.023663971573114395, -0.01015718374401331, -0.00940022338181734, -0.001080996822565794, -0.014929713681340218, -0.028466828167438507, 0.050462182611227036, 0.06413054466247559, -0.05524975061416626, 0.06663357466459274, 0.00017689273227006197, -0.006005492992699146, -0.05341862142086029, 0.02171306684613228, -0.02372038923203945, -0.048167187720537186, 0.03559214249253273, -0.006832368206232786, -0.025491412729024887, 0.021223265677690506, 0.016406549140810966, -0.004901453852653503, -0.005117925349622965, -0.009324357844889164, 0.006506504025310278, -0.03336651995778084, 0.0021690160501748323, -0.007337513379752636, 0.02642505057156086, -0.02901851385831833, 0.02319434843957424, -0.08787793666124344, -0.011208735406398773, 0.049592312425374985, -0.09382718056440353, 0.011428454890847206, -0.0036432957276701927, 0.07974732667207718, -0.024658547714352608, 0.013854372315108776, 0.03241853415966034, 0.03675069287419319, 0.004943567328155041, 0.030160700902342796, 0.005493000149726868, -0.024580704048275948, -0.04514439404010773, 0.009858754463493824, 0.047376684844493866, 0.010118030942976475, -0.018951429054141045, 0.02008240297436714, -0.00756749277934432, 0.04083362966775894, -0.019380806013941765, 0.02596898190677166, -0.035901688039302826, 0.018425125628709793, -0.04240736365318298, -0.013930633664131165, 0.0002664914936758578, 0.03833247721195221, 0.053347136825323105, 0.017985334619879723, -0.03285523131489754, -0.018168559297919273, -0.04011541232466698, 0.01733335666358471, 0.028835972771048546, -0.0029720303136855364, -0.03072383813560009, 0.003245652187615633, -0.013602633960545063, -0.021488914266228676, -0.019700294360518456, -0.026820121333003044, -0.036633290350437164, 0.036798570305109024, -0.03985803201794624, -0.014050544239580631, -0.046025581657886505, 0.042287230491638184, 0.008725849911570549, -0.030124884098768234, -0.009035125374794006, -0.003260726574808359, 0.007107110694050789, -0.04299244284629822, 0.016980968415737152, 0.017645375803112984, -0.01844429224729538, -0.04199184477329254, 0.012173774652183056, -0.012762697413563728, -0.04941181465983391, -0.006103560794144869, 0.06139113008975983, -0.026416894048452377, 0.06006181985139847, 0.03359346464276314, 0.013202821835875511, -0.024992631748318672, -0.0009239093051292002, 0.0621323399245739, 0.023817341774702072, -0.00843791477382183, -0.047198355197906494, 0.1049664095044136, -0.061280738562345505, -0.032541804015636444, -0.06522992998361588, -0.007218018174171448, -0.03578495979309082, 0.035491250455379486, -0.004294515121728182, 0.006946447771042585, -0.027935253456234932, -0.0331319235265255, 0.078101746737957, -0.052527427673339844, 0.01990390196442604, -0.05287114158272743, -0.0007427064119838178, 0.033112768083810806, -0.018197020515799522, 0.0029904169496148825, -0.009112964384257793, 0.014942683279514313, 0.03367549926042557, -0.10720217227935791, -0.01886354759335518, -0.0013845026260241866, 0.009213541634380817, 0.04504747316241264, 0.030134156346321106, -0.03334689885377884, 0.08706151694059372, -0.03361951932311058, 0.01701943203806877, -0.04968419671058655, 0.03727596998214722, 0.00376077345572412, -0.0016373086255043745, -0.007429709192365408, 0.06399912387132645, 0.044554296880960464, -0.04891466721892357, -0.030655788257718086, 0.00560978427529335, 0.012006963603198528, -0.006316350307315588, -0.00826845783740282, 0.006227361503988504, 0.008401330560445786, 0.009582798928022385, -0.036016106605529785, 0.08174163848161697, -0.031259603798389435, -0.0027832004707306623, 0.02977512963116169, 0.08941766619682312, -0.03186064213514328, -0.005851412191987038, -0.012752274982631207, 0.014794230461120605, -0.08759292215108871, -0.005908600520342588, 0.015972798690199852, 0.08921215683221817, 0.03887612745165825, -0.027458839118480682, 0.004761394578963518, 0.0009113529231399298, -0.034301891922950745, -0.020389866083860397, 0.013437832705676556, 0.00846046395599842, -0.002615326549857855, 0.10317473113536835, -0.03539238125085831, -0.01768255978822708, 0.018212374299764633, 0.02278822660446167, 0.05066738650202751, -0.06414718925952911, -0.08698110282421112, -0.011975675821304321, 0.031619004905223846, 0.00005608194987871684, -0.014637927524745464, -0.03664257749915123, -0.03417330980300903, -0.036309123039245605, -0.031803425401449203, -0.014182128012180328, 0.04675036668777466, -0.006285100243985653, -0.03182234615087509, -0.007892676629126072, 0.02435469441115856, -0.0050083911046385765, -0.050953175872564316, 0.011693177744746208, 0.0009691449231468141, 0.013045157305896282, 0.009167376905679703, 0.03343333676457405, -0.012989630922675133, -0.05041476711630821, -0.02238522469997406, 0.02639859914779663, -0.016760896891355515, 0.06714441627264023, 0.02893993631005287, -0.0697595477104187, 0.008137895725667477, 0.03117530606687069, -0.04022923856973648, 0.011853456497192383, 0.0066963378340005875, -0.01383721549063921, -0.06298930197954178, -0.05683152750134468, 0.04597511142492294, -0.035532768815755844, 0.01960243657231331, 0.013845216482877731, 0.004927145317196846, 0.018067872151732445, 0.022095445543527603, -0.006033268757164478, -0.052077870815992355, 0.013473724015057087, -0.0009604861843399704, -0.013833841308951378, -0.005510987248271704, -0.01885640062391758, 0.005305605009198189, 0.03969455510377884, 0.055748917162418365, -0.058302585035562515, -0.05698555335402489, 0.010213611647486687, -0.02241547591984272, 0.005171490833163261, -0.009892494417726994, -0.005727103445678949, -0.0015306678833439946, -0.014226673170924187, 0.026055313646793365, 0.010986997745931149, -0.026186034083366394, -0.03352503105998039, -0.011105583049356937, 0.028146930038928986, 0.024378476664423943, -0.0689789429306984, 0.02669462375342846, -0.03485221788287163, -0.014126284047961235, 0.009282050654292107, -0.007009713910520077, 0.0012669971911236644, -0.014890549704432487, -0.002315998775884509, 0.009106815792620182, -0.05567781254649162, -0.05030546709895134, -0.02082826942205429, -0.01919957436621189, -0.012568661943078041, -0.047286875545978546, 0.01596042886376381, 0.01877768523991108, -0.04428078234195709, 0.04432127997279167, 0.020984487608075142, -0.03008115105330944, 0.004057941492646933, 0.012529125437140465, -0.07600360363721848, -0.05077241361141205, -0.026446375995874405, -0.015267811715602875, -0.0030507424380630255, -0.029595516622066498, 0.08332636207342148, 0.004856790415942669, 0.01622082106769085, 0.04821527376770973, -0.07514455169439316, 0.03773023933172226, -0.0024357137735933065, -0.023655913770198822, 0.0339268259704113, 0.004195537883788347, 0.025667060166597366, -0.043725140392780304, 0.029204092919826508 ]
<p>I am a little bit confused about the machine learning outcomes on my dataset. I would be grateful if anyone can enlighten me on this:</p> <p>When features are statistically different between two groups, shouldn't the machine learning able to predict the right class with a reasonable accuracy? The data consists of 9 features where 8 of them were significantly different between the groups (two tailed independent ttest). Total observations were 71 (30 and 41). However, the machine learning were only able to produce around 65% classification accuracy (10 fold cross validation). I have used SVM with RBF kernel, kNN, Random Forest, and Naive Bayes. My question is, is it normal? Is it possible to get higher classification accuracy when the features were not significantly different between the groups? Thanks.</p>
g36705
[ -0.012416413053870201, -0.060047827661037445, 0.028804311528801918, 0.010244295001029968, 0.02281624637544155, -0.006700375583022833, -0.026041463017463684, 0.03382051736116409, -0.0777960792183876, -0.007815826684236526, 0.06173935905098915, 0.03706514835357666, 0.05503878369927406, -0.0100052859634161, -0.02804211899638176, -0.015288302674889565, 0.06204666942358017, 0.02184942737221718, -0.005570503883063793, -0.0021905379835516214, -0.033714402467012405, 0.056884847581386566, -0.028677241876721382, 0.009028728120028973, -0.02889697626233101, 0.011911160312592983, -0.05917433649301529, 0.024049626663327217, -0.03274611011147499, 0.05639442428946495, -0.010930570773780346, 0.003192057367414236, 0.02788984403014183, -0.040654417127370834, -0.051701586693525314, 0.0273141972720623, 0.04767590016126633, -0.01834193430840969, 0.016979871317744255, -0.0005550697678700089, 0.009730962105095387, 0.05211429297924042, -0.01577514410018921, -0.002211707178503275, 0.012745482847094536, 0.005551065318286419, -0.005899474490433931, -0.0683465301990509, 0.027881676331162453, -0.011947907507419586, 0.0022812634706497192, 0.02747960016131401, 0.016326051205396652, 0.02598995342850685, 0.039790619164705276, 0.0207669734954834, 0.0028848962392657995, 0.04329968988895416, -0.02154519036412239, -0.03240199014544487, 0.05904022604227066, 0.01736985705792904, -0.03636198490858078, 0.030015135183930397, 0.03402922675013542, -0.004156738519668579, -0.0030219589825719595, -0.005713237915188074, -0.023895680904388428, 0.00865944940596819, -0.059084050357341766, 0.03419959917664528, -0.001011270796880126, 0.04077182710170746, -0.07649092376232147, -0.01542425062507391, -0.0467393696308136, 0.02696930430829525, -0.004387578461319208, 0.06824477761983871, 0.0783696174621582, -0.004156075417995453, -0.04668651148676872, 0.0025496180169284344, -0.034682780504226685, -0.015459616668522358, -0.08494705706834793, 0.03822581470012665, -0.015464694239199162, 0.09122613072395325, 0.005464581772685051, -0.024310633540153503, 0.04524904862046242, 0.03785669431090355, 0.030155250802636147, 0.03746572881937027, -0.06438390165567398, 0.023971131071448326, 0.010822235606610775, 0.021877150982618332, -0.010297860950231552, 0.0389569066464901, 0.04494307562708855, 0.01680201105773449, -0.03320356458425522, 0.0043833148665726185, -0.0057893614284694195, 0.03934728354215622, -0.047653451561927795, -0.001436808961443603, -0.037037819623947144, 0.03405483439564705, -0.05825522914528847, 0.029530908912420273, -0.10226815193891525, -0.08322244882583618, -0.011160614900290966, 0.02251923643052578, 0.04388223960995674, -0.05759786069393158, 0.058184295892715454, -0.011717944405972958, -0.007062224671244621, 0.012436185963451862, -0.005555063486099243, -0.03449949249625206, 0.001426519243977964, 0.0034220691304653883, -0.012489916756749153, -0.05836237221956253, -0.03290468826889992, -0.054352499544620514, 0.034164827316999435, 0.0012474958784878254, 0.05298124998807907, 0.03494543209671974, 0.044465843588113785, 0.0014363288646563888, 0.052818384021520615, -0.0028916937299072742, -0.010687078349292278, 0.08523067086935043, -0.0018834773218259215, -0.049217339605093, -0.024391047656536102, -0.034475427120923996, -0.04875212162733078, 0.017433784902095795, -0.01765921339392662, 0.053418729454278946, 0.04669584333896637, 0.02640264295041561, -0.0109954122453928, 0.0388491228222847, -0.042647480964660645, 0.015783563256263733, -0.018095023930072784, -0.010881460271775723, 0.04822560027241707, 0.020314959809184074, 0.004565440118312836, -0.020039018243551254, 0.06088336557149887, -0.026764506474137306, -0.0355689637362957, 0.023004697635769844, 0.057232338935136795, -0.04330800846219063, -0.019995538517832756, -0.0017825438408181071, 0.00864250585436821, 0.03916677087545395, 0.00224933959543705, 0.0011684702476486564, 0.049503348767757416, 0.046051930636167526, 0.018470026552677155, -0.045454688370227814, 0.04617965221405029, 0.04919998347759247, 0.01643286645412445, 0.08281374722719193, 0.015383298508822918, 0.0010944458190351725, 0.0026185736060142517, -0.010542108677327633, -0.008764524944126606, 0.004763225559145212, 0.022742338478565216, -0.05146219953894615, 0.0016123714158311486, -0.008024094626307487, -0.019323280081152916, -0.04028186947107315, 0.012150108814239502, 0.04205720126628876, -0.03301316499710083, -0.06241083890199661, -0.02292965166270733, -0.056376636028289795, -0.0213007852435112, 0.0227316003292799, -0.05222562700510025, 0.04549872502684593, -0.07321914285421371, 0.01123674213886261, 0.016300903633236885, 0.010979173704981804, -0.016270486637949944, -0.005464209709316492, -0.0070507037453353405, 0.00792650505900383, -0.019143473356962204, 0.025898369029164314, 0.01056491956114769, -0.0008436907664872706, -0.015331575646996498, 0.03350108489394188, 0.0012125485809519887, -0.02852182649075985, -0.02957884594798088, -0.024492967873811722, 0.024906771257519722, -0.012921598739922047, 0.00793419685214758, 0.022914491593837738, 0.0017616848926991224, -0.005648809019476175, 0.0034176120534539223, 0.020526979118585587, -0.02136104926466942, -0.008921094238758087, 0.03559397906064987, -0.06956156343221664, 0.016281461343169212, -0.02674003131687641, 0.03817048296332359, -0.03697097301483154, -0.008272736333310604, -0.009680273942649364, -0.011842616833746433, -0.006014886312186718, -0.0615091510117054, 0.0011242590844631195, 0.01161518506705761, -0.0026460003573447466, -0.009956011548638344, -0.030918139964342117, 0.0022418287117034197, 0.03553825616836548, -0.014662599191069603, 0.06011943146586418, -0.014340232126414776, -0.010023055598139763, -0.027997002005577087, -0.07271789759397507, 0.004682042170315981, -0.027931423857808113, 0.01857926696538925, 0.040496159344911575, -0.017328748479485512, 0.029522651806473732, 0.03329286351799965, -0.0038321679458022118, -0.011031516827642918, 0.003120177425444126, 0.04726036265492439, 0.03391442075371742, -0.03309965506196022, -0.03746423125267029, -0.0270429365336895, -0.012557155452668667, 0.033398695290088654, 0.022249281406402588, 0.009301804006099701, 0.07227075845003128, -0.05586835369467735, 0.04840214177966118, -0.027882777154445648, -0.01938278041779995, -0.029330754652619362, -0.07144490629434586, 0.03425339609384537, 0.024852128699421883, 0.003485384164378047, 0.008974248543381691, -0.018063215538859367, 0.028065349906682968, -0.02960394322872162, 0.08094774931669235, -0.05825157091021538, 0.02218688651919365, 0.09360531717538834, -0.010763752274215221, 0.019050613045692444, 0.008577506989240646, -0.05171389505267143, -0.06514470279216766, 0.045468926429748535, -0.013210666365921497, -0.05258900672197342, -0.024252457544207573, 0.02676248364150524, -0.01647823676466942, 0.0029955091886222363, -0.055756401270627975, -0.031657423824071884, 0.00797139573842287, -0.0443887859582901, -0.020665546879172325, -0.021834859624505043, 0.021286915987730026, -0.029185213148593903, -0.03729523718357086, 0.01997644640505314, -0.05006691440939903, -0.05458514019846916, 0.03488139435648918, -0.059633802622556686, 0.010498532094061375, -0.011696547269821167, -0.05580705404281616, -0.012983284890651703, 0.04955613240599632, 0.04281080886721611, -0.013934474438428879, -0.07762748748064041, -0.017885619774460793, -0.013113514520227909, 0.026299118995666504, 0.049672991037368774, 0.028881482779979706, -0.025324339047074318, -0.01831107959151268, -0.024413440376520157, 0.01537949126213789, 0.024712586775422096, 0.007298737298697233, 0.0009674746543169022, -0.03739199787378311, -0.030669711530208588, -0.05040012672543526, 0.02499144710600376, 0.010811998508870602, -0.039592642337083817, 0.02192818745970726, -0.0009605759987607598, -0.049785204231739044, -0.024064749479293823, 0.0491015799343586, -0.014501302503049374, -0.005495600868016481, 0.02357439324259758, 0.008136619813740253, 0.01683461293578148, -0.00016643460548948497, -0.008735795505344868, -0.06263476610183716, 0.01717795804142952, 0.013578134588897228, 0.05565284937620163, -0.018111158162355423, -0.022481486201286316, -0.041805967688560486, -0.03862346336245537, 0.016476547345519066, 0.06378556042909622, 0.03950832411646843, 0.04115883633494377, -0.02468567155301571, 0.04802347347140312, -0.027373436838388443, -0.020071454346179962, -0.006923470180481672, 0.029760627076029778, 0.036790039390325546, 0.0643036812543869, -0.010741517879068851, 0.033903639763593674, 0.012155363336205482, 0.0045015448704361916, 0.01653262786567211, -0.030914653092622757, 0.02764863707125187, 0.01871241256594658, -0.0025136463809758425, 0.007128281518816948, 0.025060897693037987, 0.007222597487270832, 0.019623130559921265, -0.035081811249256134, -0.030734652653336525, -0.12413917481899261, 0.004283957649022341, 0.05013979971408844, -0.07320578396320343, 0.03925207629799843, 0.0496787466108799, 0.07194006443023682, 0.017835211008787155, -0.0573604553937912, -0.012127304449677467, -0.034406717866659164, 0.004657434765249491, -0.0353584885597229, -0.020602431148290634, -0.016604017466306686, 0.0384204275906086, -0.051511410623788834, 0.018189730122685432, -0.04666643217206001, -0.012571410275995731, -0.00009340927499579266, -0.029251817613840103, 0.02208448201417923, 0.01439474057406187, 0.05776498094201088, -0.012898399494588375, -0.032974354922771454, -0.008404090069234371, 0.015189431607723236, 0.02717910148203373, -0.02462824620306492, -0.0023365640081465244, -0.022518573328852654, -0.026772374287247658, 0.057599056512117386, 0.001556836417876184, -0.01589999347925186, -0.01395387388765812, 0.08202256262302399, -0.015405712649226189, -0.06642504036426544, 0.007605346385389566, -0.007309506181627512, 0.025546615943312645, 0.04176994413137436, -0.020562928169965744, -0.019032221287488937, -0.01794128306210041, -0.009457332082092762, -0.027333099395036697, 0.003955506719648838, 0.018764600157737732, 0.02105516754090786, 0.01186857558786869, 0.016850480809807777, -0.0002603815228212625, -0.04988190531730652, 0.07535339891910553, -0.024011049419641495, 0.002245779847726226, 0.025571396574378014, 0.036046165972948074, 0.027138810604810715, -0.017325550317764282, 0.04961105436086655, 0.03140932321548462, -0.03252666816115379, -0.03438133746385574, -0.040054045617580414, -0.036567043513059616, -0.004586962517350912, -0.02334207482635975, 0.013858149759471416, -0.0024602145422250032, -0.02551986463367939, 0.009768676944077015, 0.044051393866539, 0.043533775955438614, 0.02514500916004181, 0.011141235940158367, 0.025707418099045753, -0.018478820100426674, -0.009426381438970566, 0.10128827393054962, 0.0008325249655172229, -0.06315615773200989, 0.05090292915701866, -0.011717021465301514, -0.00921100564301014, -0.0544063039124012, 0.08172379434108734, 0.05592023953795433, -0.022188207134604454, -0.01508676540106535, 0.032589592039585114, 0.021415280178189278, 0.04887407273054123, -0.017824765294790268, 0.0224511306732893, 0.031112153083086014, -0.007328985258936882, -0.04245089367032051, 0.002276946324855089, -0.016014980152249336, 0.005941298790276051, -0.026362009346485138, -0.02518537826836109, -0.0011549898190423846, -0.07376659661531448, 0.0888100415468216, 0.028213981539011, -0.026482634246349335, 0.003432805649936199, 0.0763382762670517, 0.06738398969173431, 0.0114833889529109, 0.02237546443939209, 0.08564002811908722, -0.011233343742787838, -0.005887046921998262, -0.019422322511672974, -0.0021163728088140488, -0.07098691165447235, -0.02439047582447529, 0.005495091900229454, 0.04919004812836647, 0.039407309144735336, -0.017124565318226814, 0.08860031515359879, 0.0036014479119330645, 0.03908758610486984, 0.03606540337204933, 0.015996459871530533, -0.05099772661924362, -0.02055799588561058, -0.03468981757760048, -0.05753592401742935, -0.009174727834761143, 0.06155458092689514, 0.013181207701563835, 0.024413757026195526, -0.022394683212041855, 0.06488808244466782, 0.02136959880590439, 0.017475347965955734, -0.017999203875660896, 0.020047174766659737, 0.011513324454426765, 0.02393197827041149, -0.05014228820800781, -0.021582527086138725, -0.058308377861976624, -0.02579767070710659, -0.026525678113102913, 0.010722548700869083, -0.025827832520008087, 0.012100258842110634, -0.04360631853342056, 0.009873207658529282, 0.03278409689664841, -0.0006059667794033885, 0.03311090171337128, 0.020471446216106415, 0.08002325892448425, -0.030997447669506073, -0.046408940106630325, 0.016845129430294037, -0.008257421664893627, 0.007044866681098938, -0.07461745291948318, 0.012804985977709293, -0.03751162812113762, 0.04360727593302727, 0.040923383086919785, -0.021498417481780052, -0.07699065655469894, -0.0464312918484211, -0.03264806792140007, 0.030042458325624466, -0.013742737472057343, 0.0756770521402359, 0.05504376068711281, -0.007679903879761696, 0.005411196034401655, 0.004191897809505463, 0.06034570932388306, 0.019983990117907524, -0.05962612107396126, 0.02456199936568737, -0.05271575227379799, -0.016409456729888916, -0.04141567274928093, -0.03987850248813629, 0.020482633262872696, -0.08029096573591232, 0.016902517527341843, 0.011312696151435375, 0.026698745787143707, -0.016157977283000946, -0.001792994560673833, 0.026993494480848312, 0.019421832635998726, 0.006271456368267536, -0.00881071574985981, -0.0034192141611129045, 0.03415670618414879, -0.0020100611727684736, -0.03188328444957733, 0.05818451941013336, 0.04242753982543945, 0.01850815676152706, 0.03187423571944237, 0.033287111669778824, -0.008905359543859959, 0.009943725541234016, 0.05997386947274208, 0.0018694561440497637, 0.013492422178387642, -0.04120160639286041, 0.033493395894765854, 0.012375753372907639, 0.07233957946300507, -0.020824376493692398, -0.009957661852240562, -0.055771831423044205, -0.05255670100450516, -0.04616793245077133, -0.024614013731479645, 0.03384147211909294, -0.03379524126648903, 0.009366359561681747, 0.01909174770116806, -0.007557621691375971, 0.02896473929286003, -0.024326471611857414, 0.04668501392006874, 0.05652370676398277, 0.003636335488408804, -0.02162490412592888, 0.01902773603796959, 0.010104035958647728, -0.022944388911128044, -0.052908070385456085, 0.011538189835846424, -0.08515976369380951, 0.028855236247181892, 0.004701153840869665, 0.028803329914808273, 0.04896819591522217, 0.04896373674273491, -0.0028271572664380074, -0.0328548438847065, 0.04655686765909195, -0.001290444633923471, 0.07059414684772491, 0.017012009397149086, -0.051047369837760925, -0.06625837832689285, -0.025857504457235336, 0.04003274068236351, 0.04052148759365082, -0.059105679392814636, -0.012208841741085052, -0.041060350835323334, -0.025698117911815643, 0.004095988813787699, 0.06375881284475327, -0.00806365441530943, -0.018111197277903557, -0.010399105958640575, -0.0655829906463623, -0.01636304147541523, 0.04368468374013901, -0.04604913666844368, -0.03780889883637428, -0.04575137421488762, -0.05556275323033333, -0.04346084222197533, -0.004826332442462444, 0.030569160357117653, 0.05290403589606285, 0.028297754004597664, 0.0012117158621549606, 0.0026869128923863173, -0.016759630292654037, 0.022427842020988464, -0.004778488073498011, 0.021171264350414276, -0.025923117995262146, -0.0099629582837224, 0.013713099993765354, 0.02653864212334156, -0.0399438850581646, 0.05070986971259117, -0.021714255213737488, -0.046229854226112366, 0.02132120169699192, -0.05836626887321472, -0.023564351722598076, -0.06020179018378258, -0.01599643938243389, 0.02212871052324772, -0.04846842214465141, 0.0029844571836292744, -0.03212537616491318, 0.00046923189074732363, 0.050795890390872955, 0.04567674547433853, -0.026557084172964096, 0.008619941771030426, -0.02316044457256794, -0.0176746416836977, -0.005054037552326918, 0.0584503673017025, 0.0013399992603808641, 0.019703466445207596, -0.027649104595184326, -0.026466989889740944, 0.015692807734012604, -0.029199084267020226, 0.0013532997108995914, 0.015902109444141388, -0.0011581135913729668, -0.004956888500601053, 0.01665179245173931, -0.0262420866638422, 0.03313038870692253, 0.03456244245171547, -0.0619364008307457, 0.0029243153985589743, 0.020824424922466278, 0.008830565959215164, -0.0030087712220847607, -0.04015914723277092, -0.06765685230493546, -0.006114928051829338, -0.07894662767648697, -0.01178278774023056, -0.04046628996729851, -0.0097719831392169, -0.024546807631850243, -0.059958890080451965, 0.029269568622112274, 0.03733660280704498, 0.04681161791086197, -0.0016012117266654968, -0.029699290171265602, 0.025486962869763374, -0.05763882026076317, 0.04584779962897301, 0.025717735290527344, 0.054858509451150894, -0.0424923300743103, -0.015395378693938255, -0.005088426172733307, 0.044561613351106644, -0.020203225314617157, -0.055678319185972214, -0.08457360416650772, 0.03524283319711685, -0.02227172814309597, 0.06005660444498062, -0.03862632438540459, 0.024977711960673332, 0.0011528554605320096, 0.040013786405324936, 0.03613326698541641, 0.0015007469337433577, -0.03388645499944687, -0.04978686571121216, -0.07512064278125763, 0.029109612107276917, 0.030247928574681282, 0.049631357192993164, -0.0494016632437706, 0.018599240109324455 ]
<p>Suppose I have a big online company, and many of my customers churned (i.e. they were paying, and then stopped). My goal is to understand why each of them churned.</p> <p>First I identify the complete set of reasons for churning, $H_1,\ldots,H_n$. E.g. "the website is confusing", "the customer lost interest", etc. Then by observation I identify a set of customer behaviors which are correlated with the churn rate, $O_1,\ldots,O_m$. Each of them is directly measurable, e.g. the number of days he logged in, or the amount of time he spent at my website the day he signed up. Assume that computing $\Pr[O_j=\cdot]$ is easy, and that all of my customers are mutually independent.</p> <p>I know that each $H_i$ is related to a subset of the $O_j$'s. E.g. if a churned customer logged in $d$ days, then the probability that he lost interest is $f(d)$, with $f$ a decreasing function. (One of my problems is accurately computing this function $f$.)</p> <p>My goal is to compute, for each churned customer, and for each $i$, the probability that he churned because of $H_i$, i.e. $$ \Pr[H_i] = \sum_j \Pr[H_i\ |\ O_j=x_j] \Pr[O_j=x_j] $$ where $x_j$ is the value of $O_j$ for the given customer.</p> <p>Now, suppose I send a survey to all churned customers, asking for their reasons, but certainly only a few of them answer it. I want then to update all the functions $f_{ij}(\cdot) = \Pr[H_i\ |\ O_j=\cdot]$ based on the new evidence, so that I can compute more accurately $\Pr[H_i]$ for all the churned customers which haven't answered the survey.</p> <p>My question is how can I do this exactly? and how can I get "good" estimates for the original $f_{ij}$'s? Is my approach correct?</p> <p>EDIT: Now I realize that the formula I gave for $\Pr[H_i]$ is obviously wrong. The $O_j$'s don't form a partition. I think I should compute $\Pr[H_i\ |\ (O_1,\ldots,O_m)=(x_1,\ldots,x_m)]$ directly, since the $O_j$'s are not even pairwise independent.</p>
g74063
[ -0.04344358295202255, -0.010911385528743267, -0.016661066561937332, -0.03921361267566681, -0.04674489423632622, -0.06930152326822281, 0.04485547915101051, 0.044229134917259216, -0.0280334260314703, -0.014565655030310154, -0.049541112035512924, 0.04155365750193596, 0.08331137150526047, 0.05269930511713028, -0.030409542843699455, 0.02559407241642475, 0.005285926628857851, -0.046933118253946304, -0.015062103979289532, 0.0027079428546130657, 0.018795322626829147, 0.0024591879919171333, 0.03005177527666092, -0.007936382666230202, 0.0010757441632449627, -0.07173268496990204, 0.014159572310745716, 0.056167252361774445, -0.02377796173095703, 0.042532578110694885, -0.047422826290130615, 0.009305587038397789, 0.04298461973667145, -0.034873612225055695, -0.05765121802687645, -0.00021574932907242328, 0.09198006242513657, 0.0023700078018009663, 0.025611013174057007, 0.003861978417262435, 0.011540991254150867, 0.016208531334996223, 0.10590843111276627, 0.021906660869717598, 0.010831110179424286, -0.023541633039712906, 0.0028156156186014414, 0.0034953413996845484, 0.04087100178003311, 0.015128727070987225, -0.005012184847146273, 0.002575116464868188, 0.028032155707478523, -0.03413023427128792, -0.03868068754673004, 0.06262167543172836, -0.0462740920484066, 0.03191076219081879, 0.004662785679101944, 0.03475472703576088, -0.001797336502932012, -0.053279656916856766, 0.007115728221833706, 0.0024981917813420296, -0.01190152671188116, 0.0046813031658530235, -0.01279839500784874, -0.002742191543802619, -0.03909427672624588, -0.04997086524963379, 0.001021097181364894, 0.0031695447396486998, 0.03943759202957153, -0.05012531951069832, -0.08186773955821991, -0.006982484366744757, -0.02087888866662979, 0.050933293998241425, 0.0071847084909677505, 0.005386484786868095, 0.05292224884033203, -0.009778103791177273, -0.056008145213127136, -0.01336907222867012, 0.0017039208905771375, -0.0058988966047763824, 0.02861977554857731, -0.0395742692053318, 0.02338285744190216, 0.03142530098557472, 0.0026769298128783703, 0.014588733203709126, 0.0808558464050293, 0.041939906775951385, 0.04207722097635269, 0.015456777065992355, -0.07614702731370926, -0.03487377613782883, 0.03547598421573639, -0.00780203752219677, -0.0014298023888841271, -0.0035443087108433247, -0.03228139132261276, 0.009596031159162521, -0.0031642273534089327, -0.01244252361357212, 0.06109890714287758, 0.04629121720790863, 0.045328132808208466, -0.015044469386339188, 0.011187216266989708, 0.0139534343034029, -0.014893562532961369, -0.019007645547389984, -0.015908250585198402, -0.03270430862903595, 0.010730196721851826, 0.020163776353001595, -0.04258044809103012, 0.019658027216792107, 0.03138050064444542, -0.04681014642119408, 0.03444487974047661, 0.018639180809259415, 0.03824117034673691, -0.011661272495985031, -0.024721836671233177, 0.06201549619436264, -0.00008529824845027179, 0.041891224682331085, -0.02278558909893036, 0.012888860888779163, 0.04989204928278923, 0.036069124937057495, -0.010157900862395763, -0.009608262218534946, -0.03790412098169327, 0.04098616540431976, 0.024008948355913162, 0.03155575692653656, 0.026636483147740364, 0.002531598787754774, -0.011002314276993275, 0.012403144501149654, 0.007042528595775366, 0.015988966450095177, -0.008276542648673058, -0.027294311672449112, 0.012866407632827759, 0.018272800371050835, -0.031515154987573624, 0.07042793184518814, -0.03497295081615448, 0.0028587616980075836, 0.04462406411767006, -0.034360967576503754, 0.010332356207072735, -0.04491984844207764, -0.0034449207596480846, 0.01681153103709221, 0.01744653470814228, -0.038179803639650345, 0.042198192328214645, 0.012666726484894753, -0.011273853480815887, 0.04739304631948471, 0.06472641229629517, -0.04939548671245575, -0.021952496841549873, 0.035596154630184174, -0.026647798717021942, 0.011985108256340027, 0.036766037344932556, -0.04967380687594414, 0.03097173199057579, 0.05656600743532181, 0.05145655944943428, 0.020030701532959938, 0.039621129631996155, 0.03946683555841446, -0.009078949689865112, 0.005322578828781843, 0.06537392735481262, 0.025012444704771042, 0.03271060436964035, -0.026230070739984512, -0.017323831096291542, 0.005100708454847336, -0.0058427536860108376, -0.019736412912607193, 0.013581771403551102, -0.0042884196154773235, 0.012975968420505524, 0.045262791216373444, -0.04101743549108505, -0.008634822443127632, 0.04921434447169304, -0.03299160301685333, -0.006744427140802145, -0.05429643765091896, -0.03578905388712883, 0.015808498486876488, 0.005054808221757412, -0.010015835054218769, -0.02117517963051796, 0.019324423745274544, 0.0309805516153574, -0.02202726900577545, -0.014307349920272827, 0.029708342626690865, 0.013791036792099476, -0.056940801441669464, 0.0034578258637338877, 0.029525505378842354, 0.013767052441835403, 0.008297192864120007, 0.0020292536355555058, 0.0485350526869297, 0.040231749415397644, -0.014004146680235863, -0.04499204829335213, -0.0659603402018547, 0.028072668239474297, 0.008175649680197239, -0.01534163299947977, 0.044433239847421646, 0.046225450932979584, 0.03729280084371567, -0.03409840166568756, 0.06687028706073761, -0.03593156114220619, -0.021344436332583427, -0.022793103009462357, -0.04891492426395416, 0.05656972900032997, 0.000006835242402303265, -0.02378798834979534, 0.026715219020843506, 0.04908806085586548, 0.03784911334514618, -0.013730132952332497, -0.024730201810598373, -0.017296049743890762, 0.012844504788517952, -0.015614820644259453, -0.002271160250529647, 0.00020182415028102696, 0.04855908080935478, -0.03228529542684555, 0.052146654576063156, -0.03856518119573593, 0.016976745799183846, 0.04164774715900421, 0.006035104859620333, 0.010575655847787857, -0.04472066089510918, 0.03593382611870766, 0.01547938957810402, 0.05667993798851967, 0.03771639242768288, -0.005098529160022736, -0.023774528875947, 0.03316803649067879, 0.005104151554405689, 0.044132694602012634, -0.0644805058836937, 0.049092262983322144, -0.07967595756053925, -0.006573108956217766, -0.036851029843091965, -0.045426782220602036, 0.005758050829172134, 0.00700718816369772, 0.0696057602763176, 0.0680689737200737, -0.024757197126746178, -0.015633733943104744, 0.04198971763253212, -0.022313622757792473, 0.0070511396043002605, 0.036104075610637665, -0.0072805434465408325, -0.03258291259407997, -0.002116248942911625, -0.00834276806563139, -0.017832625657320023, 0.016051536425948143, -0.00017679203301668167, -0.00006723034312017262, 0.0815456435084343, 0.03113730624318123, 0.022924786433577538, 0.03526584804058075, 0.04802265763282776, -0.004908728878945112, -0.009120043367147446, 0.06180061027407646, -0.0516248494386673, 0.010809515602886677, -0.043878477066755295, -0.0405542366206646, 0.01743059605360031, 0.01515458058565855, -0.01640014536678791, 0.04630753770470619, -0.030311234295368195, -0.03883865103125572, -0.018884187564253807, 0.03343762829899788, -0.027540676295757294, 0.009170993231236935, 0.017276491969823837, -0.024843016639351845, -0.075507253408432, 0.008522824384272099, 0.004323619417846203, 0.05889492481946945, 0.027594609186053276, 0.0010984339751303196, -0.03670475259423256, -0.08316515386104584, -0.016718782484531403, -0.03234628215432167, -0.038258928805589676, 0.03400222584605217, 0.03176917880773544, -0.09064759314060211, -0.014927946031093597, 0.027755001559853554, 0.02648775838315487, -0.002119898097589612, 0.0022154259495437145, 0.0013721819268539548, -0.05839487910270691, -0.03242839127779007, -0.03202325850725174, 0.010380675084888935, 0.02819639816880226, 0.04430738836526871, 0.03095579892396927, -0.11164755374193192, 0.04411161318421364, -0.011462588794529438, -0.04811142385005951, -0.0715799480676651, 0.04579535871744156, 0.02300674468278885, 0.02311636321246624, 0.058981310576200485, -0.057131215929985046, 0.021463867276906967, -0.03024081140756607, 0.008592233061790466, 0.007077579852193594, 0.02053835615515709, -0.020384248346090317, 0.00024692999431863427, -0.055807191878557205, 0.010211348533630371, 0.02419116534292698, 0.011769561097025871, -0.033851370215415955, -0.030369795858860016, 0.017291536554694176, -0.0387808196246624, -0.036394909024238586, 0.058110617101192474, 0.014992679469287395, -0.03493510186672211, -0.00826393160969019, -0.014251358807086945, -0.05003975331783295, 0.023885125294327736, -0.037747349590063095, 0.05143621563911438, -0.015002595260739326, 0.003471578471362591, -0.020572274923324585, -0.008070521056652069, 0.021998710930347443, 0.03005431964993477, 0.024720516055822372, 0.04268737509846687, 0.03565540164709091, 0.03534572198987007, -0.005065693520009518, 0.02905920334160328, -0.023524951189756393, -0.007702074013650417, 0.010317997075617313, 0.016301564872264862, -0.009402369149029255, -0.04724978655576706, 0.06778882443904877, -0.0007201536791399121, -0.059102416038513184, -0.023625347763299942, -0.04128130152821541, 0.018616914749145508, 0.051309339702129364, -0.01447572186589241, -0.06808415055274963, 0.038555312901735306, -0.019658496603369713, -0.02352183125913143, 0.0014968137256801128, -0.02800813689827919, -0.011238308623433113, 0.04447692632675171, -0.01617644540965557, -0.05431877076625824, -0.06984670460224152, 0.003377564251422882, -0.020651428028941154, 0.028761746361851692, -0.027199318632483482, 0.10021094977855682, -0.06798384338617325, -0.00894442293792963, -0.044965386390686035, -0.015848368406295776, -0.0302361361682415, 0.037255771458148956, 0.010290464386343956, -0.02195347100496292, 0.0053254044614732265, 0.014899146743118763, -0.0161566361784935, 0.010074557736515999, -0.036723870784044266, 0.06260297447443008, 0.06226528063416481, 0.009333666414022446, 0.04114663973450661, -0.002195792505517602, -0.0412612147629261, 0.012353588826954365, 0.02682577259838581, -0.041441936045885086, -0.0022967748809605837, -0.05539582669734955, -0.0058578974567353725, -0.03608982637524605, 0.008296855725347996, 0.07554429024457932, 0.006750793196260929, -0.05408383905887604, 0.03786616772413254, 0.05494559183716774, 0.02617366798222065, -0.013926470652222633, 0.0331418476998806, 0.02524481527507305, 0.08194702863693237, 0.04996844381093979, -0.029304521158337593, 0.015937069430947304, -0.008516754023730755, 0.04587765410542488, 0.05124283581972122, -0.02265567146241665, 0.004930893890559673, -0.03498062863945961, -0.0470990426838398, -0.02498536929488182, 0.008446427062153816, 0.03506847470998764, -0.0010796267306432128, 0.0007972861058078706, 0.017186185345053673, 0.00991499051451683, 0.04626506567001343, 0.060365814715623856, -0.08761104941368103, -0.0707068219780922, 0.04660467058420181, -0.01893633045256138, 0.013723116368055344, -0.003375527448952198, 0.0674387589097023, 0.017364704981446266, -0.0008216799469664693, 0.011848228983581066, 0.0016466497909277678, -0.05649163946509361, -0.010371720418334007, 0.008723841980099678, -0.06608296185731888, 0.0017297847662121058, -0.07174136489629745, -0.00923213642090559, 0.0012928011128678918, 0.02133113145828247, 0.02367212064564228, -0.05670102685689926, -0.031813912093639374, 0.01941809616982937, 0.012946659699082375, 0.02529391460120678, 0.028813781216740608, -0.044537484645843506, 0.05390733852982521, -0.0058439504355192184, -0.016048306599259377, 0.0076090870425105095, -0.014063377864658833, 0.00577128492295742, -0.031146178022027016, -0.007049029693007469, 0.023831726983189583, 0.026115037500858307, 0.08084790408611298, 0.0034119472838938236, 0.03942868858575821, -0.04295250400900841, 0.013583354651927948, -0.002139784162864089, 0.03250579535961151, -0.03573128581047058, 0.02886022999882698, 0.084376260638237, 0.006037093698978424, 0.03157753497362137, 0.043665528297424316, 0.03981778398156166, -0.05346641689538956, -0.07776462286710739, -0.052300769835710526, -0.01921948418021202, -0.06569311767816544, -0.007587021216750145, 0.05522308498620987, -0.06970217823982239, -0.03900967538356781, -0.04205551743507385, 0.03037470579147339, -0.0166368056088686, -0.052786052227020264, -0.04989991709589958, 0.03478392958641052, -0.04526393488049507, 0.06555450707674026, 0.03256381303071976, -0.03864644467830658, -0.030003871768712997, -0.02654045633971691, -0.011684823781251907, -0.028151124715805054, 0.0437229722738266, -0.03221534565091133, -0.022185880690813065, 0.011894087307155132, 0.010699860751628876, -0.031006427481770515, -0.01471035834401846, -0.004487641621381044, -0.0137867396697402, -0.01757218688726425, 0.02164752408862114, 0.03138032183051109, 0.015356362797319889, -0.08152272552251816, -0.03216584399342537, 0.04330157861113548, 0.030825316905975342, 0.059855736792087555, -0.00799502618610859, -0.010604094713926315, -0.0715785101056099, -0.024909887462854385, 0.0037493458949029446, -0.07082583010196686, 0.028819642961025238, -0.009532068856060505, 0.012616968713700771, 0.04670482873916626, -0.010786491446197033, -0.0233931764960289, 0.03632640838623047, -0.030631717294454575, -0.042819783091545105, -0.017835361883044243, 0.06766171008348465, 0.020492879673838615, 0.0014470641035586596, 0.07252438366413116, -0.01323676761239767, 0.009105167351663113, 0.02138390764594078, -0.029820377007126808, -0.02520175650715828, 0.009988978505134583, 0.013225764967501163, -0.04466908797621727, -0.0050053722225129604, 0.0411439910531044, -0.025675371289253235, 0.03522199019789696, -0.048934534192085266, -0.003758104285225272, -0.01900273747742176, -0.0073277298361063, 0.052419111132621765, -0.06076257303357124, 0.004231561440974474, -0.035603124648332596, 0.006044336594641209, -0.023832393810153008, -0.014570824801921844, -0.029125044122338295, -0.0559811033308506, 0.034154705703258514, 0.02762450836598873, 0.08919259160757065, 0.0032823379151523113, -0.0045970166102051735, -0.025869334116578102, 0.0293057132512331, 0.008581005036830902, 0.005321449134498835, 0.024517372250556946, -0.04594389349222183, 0.02036907523870468, -0.06622668355703354, -0.01298523973673582, 0.006224167998880148, -0.04441972076892853, -0.0920913890004158, 0.006338200997561216, -0.011220589280128479, 0.03765125200152397, 0.030917905271053314, -0.03254406154155731, 0.011911138892173767, -0.027121879160404205, 0.045618265867233276, -0.0006195559981279075, 0.08566221594810486, -0.013687067665159702, 0.04332530498504639, 0.005016071256250143, 0.027154840528964996, -0.03318276256322861, 0.010574156418442726, -0.036645032465457916, -0.08742464333772659, 0.03528696671128273, 0.011107995174825191, -0.006229653023183346, 0.02416745014488697, 0.0006050053634680808, -0.011858460493385792, 0.04167855158448219, -0.025559542700648308, -0.011510776355862617, 0.011827067472040653, 0.05449314042925835, 0.02574927546083927, 0.013650980778038502, -0.000593257718719542, -0.02965967357158661, -0.026923425495624542, -0.07258647680282593, -0.04262613132596016, 0.01751868613064289, 0.020176004618406296, -0.04313299059867859, -0.0005354681634344161, -0.02900252491235733, -0.09977956861257553, 0.01824500784277916, 0.0038433775771409273, -0.05330253764986992, 0.011347181163728237, 0.020529262721538544, 0.020717669278383255, -0.011742895469069481, 0.007688452024012804, 0.016003740951418877, -0.006799894850701094, -0.009625711478292942, -0.013639107346534729, -0.019339051097631454, -0.010362721048295498, -0.030296122655272484, 0.08288154006004333, -0.02508806623518467, -0.021938377991318703, 0.03966730087995529, -0.022857649251818657, -0.047604192048311234, -0.058017708361148834, 0.02211781218647957, -0.02016768418252468, -0.04023514315485954, 0.01701582409441471, 0.012467472814023495, -0.036544639617204666, 0.033934492617845535, 0.05800170451402664, 0.014107785187661648, 0.0009503702167421579, 0.011922864243388176, -0.019474072381854057, -0.007106428500264883, -0.01885811798274517, -0.031074298545718193, -0.09885166585445404, 0.0282793790102005, -0.05796390399336815, -0.025353942066431046, -0.014421608299016953, -0.05866650119423866, -0.02425663359463215, 0.010747958905994892, -0.03912502899765968, -0.059282317757606506, -0.018300974741578102, 0.024638047441840172, 0.007630701642483473, -0.004073602147400379, -0.02995326742529869, 0.00433907937258482, 0.034386441111564636, -0.0011838144855573773, -0.05828350409865379, -0.0026393826119601727, 0.06114356964826584, -0.052720438688993454, 0.08029627054929733, -0.005742949899286032, -0.02504560723900795, -0.06915513426065445, 0.04286991059780121, 0.04818813130259514, 0.0029348384123295546, 0.021999474614858627, 0.06456390768289566, 0.030577000230550766, 0.01455710083246231, -0.03708678111433983, -0.06528118997812271, -0.002270397264510393, 0.018658393993973732, 0.03359711542725563, -0.03333545848727226, -0.0051995497196912766, 0.027781331911683083, 0.026183821260929108, -0.008555556647479534, -0.009600997902452946, -0.015000090934336185, -0.017706701532006264, -0.009571629576385021, -0.010984627529978752, 0.005640572402626276, 0.023356949910521507, 0.060883209109306335, -0.003985806368291378, -0.061322253197431564, -0.04441835358738899, -0.03849067911505699, -0.06833148747682571, 0.005070204380899668, 0.004057547077536583, -0.010876703076064587, 0.03240343928337097, 0.03841850161552429 ]
<p>In calculating the pseudoinverse of a matrix $A$, of size (m,n), I need to choose a tolerance threshold for the eigenvalues. I'm trying to understand how I should pick this. Matlab default is to use the $norm(A)*max(m,n)*eps$, where the norm is norm-2 and the eps is the machine epsilon. Any ideas as to why this is the default value?</p> <p>Moreover, there are cases in which $ A $ is only interesting in comparison to other values. For example, I'd like to calculate the eigenvalues of $C + BB^TA^{-0.5}$ where A,B,C are matrices, but B can have a very large second dimension. In this example, how should we choose the tolerance? </p>
g33239
[ 0.0006173732690513134, 0.030541492626070976, -0.0029646828770637512, -0.04648130387067795, -0.014057548716664314, -0.02054458297789097, 0.041964348405599594, 0.06665577739477158, -0.030791953206062317, 0.02245088294148445, -0.040824174880981445, 0.011715510860085487, 0.0431472547352314, 0.02669208124279976, 0.024469368159770966, 0.007667338475584984, 0.039657652378082275, -0.02792944759130478, 0.03114042989909649, -0.0594852939248085, -0.04387206584215164, -0.01389862410724163, -0.043439652770757675, -0.035571251064538956, 0.06598956137895584, 0.01891348697245121, 0.03974015265703201, 0.04428333789110184, 0.03795348107814789, 0.02546839416027069, -0.008328958414494991, 0.025651926174759865, -0.007718081120401621, -0.03688150271773338, 0.03224272280931473, 0.009736926294863224, 0.013104964978992939, 0.0580797903239727, 0.007345505058765411, 0.0005673002451658249, -0.03881838917732239, -0.06522975862026215, 0.0008154966053552926, 0.0024480342399328947, 0.03797384724020958, 0.029393667355179787, -0.001346050063148141, 0.05130157247185707, -0.013206114992499352, 0.01652473956346512, 0.03865685313940048, 0.005612744018435478, 0.0021932092495262623, -0.05205197259783745, 0.019612278789281845, -0.011327819898724556, -0.023246698081493378, 0.038621190935373306, 0.0045165098272264, -0.014453570358455181, 0.05326710641384125, -0.04861302673816681, -0.05262799933552742, 0.002713675843551755, 0.010264934971928596, 0.04115939512848854, 0.009387780912220478, 0.010575525462627411, -0.05622461438179016, 0.006190813146531582, -0.027239494025707245, 0.0035756630823016167, 0.029837245121598244, -0.00592071283608675, -0.01965094543993473, -0.04271174967288971, -0.006598099134862423, 0.030713919550180435, 0.007313985377550125, 0.05139128118753433, 0.00536795798689127, 0.01373662706464529, 0.05611119419336319, -0.01809626631438732, 0.048880141228437424, 0.0647091493010521, -0.0002413828478893265, -0.005887151230126619, -0.059163931757211685, -0.012597346678376198, 0.02145240642130375, -0.03157307207584381, 0.01966859959065914, -0.02003113366663456, 0.009103761985898018, -0.03765849024057388, -0.008812109008431435, -0.015054506249725819, -0.011110377497971058, -0.02810625359416008, 0.08587215840816498, 0.018899906426668167, 0.07003041356801987, -0.04282449558377266, -0.05007304251194, 0.024890083819627762, 0.027674032375216484, -0.009346622042357922, 0.026813460513949394, -0.0358867272734642, -0.03581995144486427, -0.009183662943542004, -0.05511464178562164, -0.08444363623857498, -0.018877888098359108, 0.015316637232899666, 0.07328121364116669, -0.03563089296221733, -0.03193732351064682, 0.007152331992983818, 0.020138215273618698, -0.057849179953336716, 0.02376798912882805, 0.03768698126077652, 0.009404485113918781, 0.03949638083577156, 0.00432489113882184, 0.008653059601783752, 0.05114483833312988, 0.028072595596313477, 0.04188798740506172, -0.00040514551801607013, -0.012434043921530247, 0.024278998374938965, 0.01570367068052292, 0.09424597769975662, -0.001264106947928667, -0.021218949928879738, 0.004148134030401707, -0.01198161207139492, -0.055140189826488495, -0.030144207179546356, -0.005369243677705526, -0.002234846819192171, -0.03538397699594498, -0.012377160601317883, 0.008474349975585938, -0.02907189540565014, -0.017457209527492523, 0.056923579424619675, 0.02089759334921837, 0.09465449303388596, -0.05085739493370056, 0.018146660178899765, -0.04340781271457672, 0.03371687978506088, 0.03487391397356987, -0.07268813252449036, 0.024803752079606056, 0.031641002744436264, 0.016779059544205666, -0.020078588277101517, 0.004820959642529488, 0.017898989841341972, -0.014425771310925484, -0.013290795497596264, -0.054445721209049225, -0.0139299426227808, 0.0007808731170371175, 0.0019905646331608295, -0.018287621438503265, -0.006742321886122227, 0.07099618017673492, 0.008871343918144703, -0.0001393677812302485, 0.07690450549125671, -0.037603992968797684, -0.014656870625913143, 0.03405599296092987, -0.009257539175450802, -0.02840588428080082, 0.006116017699241638, 0.054906826466321945, 0.06825444102287292, 0.010961867868900299, -0.04956577718257904, 0.04288460686802864, 0.00504867872223258, -0.0737418681383133, 0.030263446271419525, 0.0022638263180851936, -0.0015172148123383522, -0.016627877950668335, -0.027942681685090065, -0.03971288353204727, -0.04131290316581726, 0.061684418469667435, 0.023517439141869545, -0.06705136597156525, -0.0697251632809639, 0.027436912059783936, 0.030960921198129654, -0.011222219094634056, 0.022028224542737007, -0.06663141399621964, 0.034951649606227875, 0.016322296112775803, -0.007144344970583916, 0.015856927260756493, -0.019447365775704384, -0.004274171777069569, 0.01184174045920372, -0.011086064390838146, 0.03631480783224106, 0.037428826093673706, 0.002128598280251026, 0.012061121873557568, -0.011558313854038715, 0.011251315474510193, 0.026357928290963173, 0.02216942049562931, -0.03850939869880676, -0.0047137122601270676, 0.019905034452676773, 0.0299212709069252, 0.04619700834155083, 0.0036331554874777794, 0.03778138756752014, 0.06140686571598053, 0.01131216250360012, -0.048802297562360764, -0.015316535718739033, -0.0229782834649086, 0.018993737176060677, 0.008052520453929901, 0.026740897446870804, -0.028004340827465057, 0.013991044834256172, -0.001149396295659244, 0.04538317769765854, 0.07396110892295837, 0.03530732914805412, -0.002050230512395501, 0.03357873111963272, -0.01933077536523342, -0.025992784649133682, 0.030330799520015717, -0.057659395039081573, -0.028612304478883743, 0.044178664684295654, -0.07156846672296524, -0.02272983267903328, -0.017109138891100883, 0.0034012077376246452, -0.04964189976453781, -0.00230690510943532, -0.005048730410635471, -0.029782036319375038, -0.011483044363558292, 0.029100393876433372, -0.0345054566860199, 0.05372054874897003, 0.05907130241394043, 0.013174700550734997, -0.045712243765592575, -0.04206953942775726, -0.027382241562008858, 0.04388007894158363, 0.016606619581580162, 0.021223634481430054, 0.024223100394010544, 0.02801048383116722, 0.0030239589978009462, 0.050074558705091476, 0.020852116867899895, -0.012784765101969242, 0.04353383556008339, -0.03767986595630646, 0.04407908394932747, 0.004291065037250519, -0.07084667682647705, -0.026478532701730728, -0.051676195114851, -0.03424973040819168, 0.09875211864709854, -0.06512728333473206, 0.007407464552670717, 0.04879988357424736, -0.02272983267903328, 0.022497352212667465, -0.03900742158293724, -0.0626923143863678, -0.12339994311332703, 0.01573607139289379, 0.0238096434623003, 0.012251922860741615, -0.02201230265200138, -0.011674865148961544, -0.032297417521476746, 0.03930096700787544, -0.05660935118794441, -0.0067888363264501095, 0.025156838819384575, -0.05948254466056824, -0.0087208803743124, -0.007411309517920017, 0.031134329736232758, 0.03581264615058899, -0.04871382564306259, -0.009375868365168571, -0.03437207266688347, -0.004333463963121176, -0.0028771194629371166, -0.06424971669912338, -0.009785443544387817, 0.03359246253967285, 0.006508073769509792, 0.008748570457100868, -0.033492561429739, -0.09176719933748245, 0.009767977520823479, -0.012098216451704502, 0.025248998776078224, 0.03873883932828903, -0.05118890479207039, 0.004217195324599743, -0.051441438496112823, 0.008311105892062187, 0.003700563218444586, 0.019768616184592247, 0.08478367328643799, 0.027531815692782402, -0.03810683637857437, 0.024930501356720924, -0.01298270933330059, -0.06834618747234344, -0.02556220255792141, 0.007551639340817928, -0.0015812328783795238, 0.03244803845882416, -0.08080054819583893, -0.04417196288704872, -0.018235204741358757, -0.03653186559677124, -0.01856803148984909, -0.027189766988158226, -0.0027991770766675472, 0.03902963176369667, -0.008484735153615475, -0.05322851985692978, 0.018097223713994026, -0.05580942705273628, -0.027744702994823456, 0.028218112885951996, 0.049179885536432266, 0.002504491014406085, 0.009857768192887306, 0.0029202792793512344, -0.004715997260063887, -0.04418133944272995, 0.030856287106871605, -0.04001380130648613, -0.03650273010134697, -0.04047520458698273, 0.026753727346658707, -0.029820574447512627, -0.006253643427044153, 0.03299442678689957, 0.04247990995645523, -0.010534589178860188, 0.04827276989817619, 0.02802335098385811, 0.0012793953064829111, -0.004601924680173397, -0.04694332927465439, 0.00951437372714281, 0.0009241135558113456, 0.005868404638022184, 0.03009711019694805, 0.029192937538027763, -0.02076757326722145, -0.030296852812170982, -0.020718665793538094, -0.05277329310774803, 0.05937383323907852, 0.02466159127652645, 0.0005442947149276733, -0.017653441056609154, 0.007304132450371981, 0.04346565529704094, 0.01700500398874283, -0.006564846262335777, -0.05001717060804367, 0.03460373356938362, 0.08306018263101578, 0.0004886119277216494, -0.014344883151352406, 0.005185767076909542, -0.0325588583946228, 0.01774539425969124, 0.020885339006781578, -0.01172602642327547, 0.024019530043005943, -0.00831909291446209, 0.001766862696968019, -0.013423031195998192, -0.009595627896487713, 0.04658814147114754, 0.037217963486909866, 0.00586608424782753, -0.037287626415491104, -0.001859377953223884, -0.012263664975762367, -0.07052840292453766, 0.023244978860020638, 0.007690928876399994, -0.02690965123474598, -0.024355070665478706, 0.014633680693805218, -0.057484909892082214, 0.014511138200759888, -0.005327343475073576, -0.0952683538198471, -0.031244730576872826, -0.0005080082337372005, 0.030156392604112625, 0.0014418563805520535, 0.03910384327173233, 0.040123969316482544, 0.02006254717707634, 0.004595551174134016, 0.023573609068989754, -0.09047776460647583, 0.0405845046043396, -0.03098243661224842, 0.014998247846961021, -0.060535237193107605, -0.010974780656397343, -0.061478931456804276, -0.00891522690653801, 0.02760137990117073, -0.00011940987315028906, -0.05802985653281212, -0.012272274121642113, -0.01437955442816019, 0.006927521899342537, 0.01590649224817753, -0.020059052854776382, 0.02778608538210392, 0.035624805837869644, 0.023993585258722305, 0.015332958661019802, 0.01232337299734354, 0.012808960862457752, -0.00444093719124794, -0.040711890906095505, 0.008544987067580223, 0.037120796740055084, 0.077130988240242, 0.03098129667341709, -0.015244811773300171, -0.014109790325164795, -0.09306509047746658, -0.003981824964284897, -0.0004906077519990504, 0.013762292452156544, -0.07655871659517288, 0.017957665026187897, -0.003654693951830268, 0.035267457365989685, 0.05200245603919029, -0.006233435124158859, 0.050295211374759674, -0.0024889882188290358, -0.04664367437362671, 0.0027889637276530266, -0.0010868700919672847, 0.017437858507037163, -0.014846518635749817, -0.009216554462909698, -0.024685543030500412, -0.04903300479054451, -0.0014253001427277923, 0.028489794582128525, 0.05861477181315422, 0.025237079709768295, -0.02480994537472725, -0.07604000717401505, 0.03601793572306633, -0.018883472308516502, 0.06918507814407349, 0.09328432381153107, -0.0077667757868766785, 0.03115530125796795, 0.024254651740193367, -0.02248731069266796, 0.04897679015994072, -0.00271421461366117, 0.030082957819104195, -0.031612079590559006, 0.015136933885514736, 0.031821321696043015, -0.043528057634830475, -0.058666255325078964, 0.0016165559645742178, -0.04826165363192558, 0.0728471577167511, -0.034394342452287674, 0.0012616153107956052, 0.025479862466454506, 0.0371820367872715, 0.009837833233177662, 0.08367500454187393, -0.0026176837272942066, 0.03115488402545452, -0.009932136163115501, 0.02314743399620056, 0.012861998751759529, -0.0037915450520813465, -0.033729951828718185, 0.05092784762382507, -0.028462812304496765, 0.026851022616028786, -0.07212866097688675, 0.020901475101709366, -0.0003729493182618171, -0.023799125105142593, -0.0679532065987587, 0.016151269897818565, 0.02323242835700512, 0.04479508474469185, -0.021646367385983467, -0.07026572525501251, -0.006477600894868374, 0.01694135181605816, -0.04130443185567856, -0.03123980201780796, -0.014601684175431728, 0.002715072128921747, -0.036471858620643616, 0.01361222006380558, -0.050992850214242935, 0.025049367919564247, 0.016739532351493835, -0.0026995388325303793, -0.008324172347784042, 0.0373699776828289, 0.015324564650654793, 0.006631169933825731, -0.0031370380893349648, -0.060907140374183655, -0.0036413823254406452, -0.0021397469099611044, -0.0016069088596850634, 0.06480889022350311, 0.08798278123140335, -0.008831475861370564, 0.03378201276063919, 0.03148305043578148, 0.04103875160217285, 0.016988979652523994, -0.028125915676355362, -0.030526071786880493, 0.029543397948145866, -0.037188220769166946, -0.07339674234390259, 0.04490937665104866, 0.013244209811091423, 0.06053059920668602, 0.026796918362379074, -0.013743368908762932, -0.021106544882059097, 0.0897795557975769, 0.016404958441853523, 0.06249250844120979, 0.02757827565073967, 0.006609025411307812, 0.010134147480130196, 0.035475730895996094, -0.04051627591252327, 0.004642669577151537, -0.009751882404088974, 0.03178240731358528, -0.016526786610484123, -0.020458895713090897, 0.02007303386926651, 0.02900012396275997, -0.05583987757563591, 0.024422606453299522, -0.049493223428726196, -0.03747046738862991, -0.05855576694011688, -0.018529988825321198, 0.03916582837700844, 0.03576710820198059, 0.01374602410942316, -0.03938668593764305, -0.025386085733771324, -0.0036029077600687742, 0.005391188897192478, 0.08941280096769333, 0.049594420939683914, 0.01736285537481308, 0.003985722549259663, 0.0068986802361905575, 0.030446330085396767, -0.03571480140089989, -0.005092021077871323, -0.041966330260038376, 0.10305192321538925, 0.03492572903633118, 0.004553146194666624, 0.0028342576697468758, 0.009419589303433895, -0.009609678760170937, -0.02754979394376278, 0.039189595729112625, 0.0314914807677269, -0.006043543573468924, 0.039830148220062256, 0.0096064368262887, -0.041540734469890594, 0.024687351658940315, -0.010793899185955524, 0.010759552009403706, 0.027206450700759888, 0.02205752767622471, -0.04763329029083252, 0.06367011368274689, 0.047030795365571976, -0.012181884609162807, 0.016581527888774872, 0.01391679048538208, 0.03827734664082527, 0.001194173120893538, 0.012165010906755924, -0.10366682708263397, 0.01447339728474617, -0.014608089812099934, 0.05773553252220154, -0.010038705542683601, 0.03705201297998428, -0.018123669549822807, -0.005601251497864723, -0.009494737721979618, 0.00694063538685441, 0.030147789046168327, 0.0661325603723526, -0.0399259552359581, -0.017818646505475044, 0.0862811952829361, 0.013251591473817825, -0.030090371146798134, -0.04588998854160309, -0.041821662336587906, 0.02662881650030613, 0.006710236892104149, -0.04969398304820061, 0.006303646136075258, -0.0292774997651577, 0.0073232571594417095, -0.00651709595695138, 0.028652720153331757, -0.07460526376962662, 0.01876036636531353, -0.03740360587835312, -0.04554310441017151, -0.056308940052986145, -0.026232842355966568, -0.04349406063556671, -0.04255601391196251, -0.015089339576661587, -0.015695828944444656, 0.055357445031404495, -0.0007684455486014485, -0.009731296449899673, -0.02328813634812832, 0.021179743111133575, -0.12258677184581757, -0.013582098297774792, 0.02628936991095543, 0.002538960659876466, 0.011659995652735233, -0.03369676321744919, -0.020477093756198883, 0.05749646946787834, -0.016941450536251068, 0.011703817173838615, -0.019924692809581757, -0.026946404948830605, -0.010045502334833145, -0.03712131828069687, 0.03222166746854782, -0.02528451569378376, 0.021479206159710884, 0.02526080422103405, -0.028305871412158012, 0.06890194863080978, 0.015259825624525547, 0.0038189920596778393, -0.00030398156377486885, -0.04575810581445694, -0.03494584187865257, -0.017789795994758606, -0.04185083508491516, 0.012175165116786957, -0.0004065409011673182, -0.03755596652626991, 0.05576534569263458, -0.0311517845839262, -0.04411274567246437, 0.02218414843082428, -0.006214924622327089, 0.06428953260183334, -0.024595383554697037, -0.008472254499793053, -0.03844452276825905, 0.018233902752399445, 0.03381438925862312, 0.019012903794646263, -0.011015858501195908, 0.005830889567732811, 0.013958195224404335, -0.033683255314826965, -0.04300926253199577, -0.0782419815659523, -0.059748321771621704, -0.03358995169401169, -0.00866688322275877, -0.01980266347527504, -0.03859953582286835, -0.07910308986902237, -0.009707928635179996, 0.02763940952718258, -0.05451873689889908, 0.04617169871926308, -0.040783435106277466, 0.029967864975333214, -0.019256817176938057, -0.00002805444091791287, -0.030970938503742218, -0.01025988906621933, 0.007169995456933975, 0.04931506887078285, 0.03388170525431633, 0.0018691217992454767, 0.005838952027261257, -0.026862649247050285, 0.013634927570819855, -0.031433556228876114, -0.061887383460998535, -0.0031344862654805183, -0.06681164354085922, 0.0723644495010376, 0.013509419746696949, -0.016175933182239532, 0.05226428806781769, 0.0030156264547258615, -0.018514011055231094, -0.030155450105667114, 0.007799688261002302, -0.02139679715037346, -0.04041237756609917, 0.05179242789745331, 0.036743126809597015, -0.02860347554087639, 0.019050437957048416, -0.028783146291971207 ]
<p>I have a dataset that includes variables about customer income levels. The income was collected in binned fashion (<code>Which range describes your income? 0-25k, 25k-50k,...</code>). My question is how best use this for modeling using <code>glmnet</code> and <code>gbm</code> packages in <code>R</code>.</p> <p>I have looked at the <code>grouped</code> packaged in <code>R</code> but it seems to do everything (coursening and regression) for you. Is there a package that converts binned data back to continuous data for use in with other algos?</p> <p>EDIT: The current method I'm using is to convert them to the mid-point of the range (<code>0-25k -&gt; 12500</code>), then using an <code>ifelse()</code> stmt to code a few variables to convey the fact that there is a relationship between the levels.</p> <pre><code>incOver25k &lt;- ifelse(df1$income &gt;= 25000,1,0) incOver50k &lt;- ifelse(df1$income &gt;= 50000,1,0) </code></pre> <p>Then use these flags instead of using <code>model.matrix()</code>. </p> <p>Was curious if there were any better ideas.</p>
g74064
[ 0.02027789130806923, -0.032643526792526245, -0.01794222556054592, -0.02575366571545601, 0.0019943369552493095, -0.018990885466337204, -0.010939612053334713, 0.019080961123108864, -0.07987527549266815, -0.03829880431294441, 0.04154547303915024, 0.04520786926150322, 0.03949042782187462, -0.013941439799964428, 0.001747047295793891, 0.008102331310510635, 0.002052350202575326, -0.0008399526705034077, -0.0422130823135376, -0.030055228620767593, 0.005105327814817429, -0.04693199321627617, 0.061837829649448395, -0.022622443735599518, -0.017034562304615974, -0.0490235909819603, 0.04793691635131836, 0.05545107275247574, -0.061724357306957245, 0.04672268405556679, -0.03494307026267052, -0.01737401820719242, 0.005451110657304525, -0.03220628574490547, -0.03674118220806122, -0.02549675852060318, -0.02105073817074299, -0.0016996668418869376, 0.0002861586690414697, 0.014550041407346725, 0.026455385610461235, -0.01576460711658001, 0.017914894968271255, 0.04774206504225731, -0.03450911492109299, 0.016899511218070984, 0.034764233976602554, 0.008164356462657452, 0.014935484156012535, 0.019990792497992516, 0.010577940382063389, -0.020774152129888535, -0.027341732755303383, 0.05022406950592995, 0.09223233908414841, 0.059401728212833405, -0.005207298789173365, 0.01693454384803772, 0.03611265867948532, -0.02224133536219597, 0.01357945054769516, 0.026657847687602043, -0.044720735400915146, -0.009303842671215534, 0.008331014774739742, 0.03844451904296875, 0.0198611319065094, -0.0403623953461647, -0.00526399863883853, 0.0018855014350265265, 0.011441219598054886, 0.05004499852657318, 0.02818976156413555, -0.014248165301978588, -0.03340864181518555, -0.014053776860237122, -0.04598848894238472, -0.008942222222685814, 0.03641839325428009, 0.08134337514638901, 0.018168006092309952, 0.025454081594944, -0.05238944664597511, -0.03269428387284279, 0.021281158551573753, -0.005978991277515888, 0.03138728067278862, -0.026780135929584503, 0.004190648905932903, 0.0063066319562494755, 0.012807385995984077, -0.013258217833936214, 0.00551542779430747, 0.04977317154407501, -0.04013264179229736, 0.04068513587117195, -0.08809078484773636, 0.013100025244057178, 0.033077530562877655, -0.06411778926849365, 0.006833211984485388, 0.030446218326687813, 0.021243322640657425, -0.07231654971837997, -0.07632014900445938, 0.009915955364704132, 0.04425055906176567, 0.016665946692228317, -0.0023407633416354656, -0.006473885383456945, -0.04725593328475952, -0.007301298901438713, -0.05029706284403801, 0.01965285837650299, -0.0607009194791317, 0.009873655624687672, 0.06108935922384262, 0.005437986925244331, -0.037013377994298935, -0.017981944605708122, 0.029732931405305862, -0.025196995586156845, 0.040860600769519806, -0.018497241660952568, 0.008081459440290928, -0.01607881300151348, -0.0435560904443264, 0.0554049126803875, 0.03657657280564308, 0.020787902176380157, 0.062366195023059845, -0.025457382202148438, -0.07546643167734146, 0.017462419345974922, 0.05581988766789436, 0.006277484819293022, -0.006243403535336256, 0.03790346160531044, 0.013499956578016281, -0.003152627032250166, -0.0077545903623104095, -0.025153813883662224, 0.01184506993740797, 0.0031313674990087748, 0.02671867609024048, 0.026820717379450798, 0.016841262578964233, -0.01657530479133129, -0.010219681076705456, 0.0357016958296299, -0.010271879844367504, 0.059158992022275925, -0.02042158879339695, -0.04328407719731331, 0.012382447719573975, -0.03644124045968056, 0.02766108512878418, -0.06288846582174301, -0.011844044551253319, -0.006421379279345274, 0.027843069285154343, -0.022996636107563972, 0.06117728352546692, -0.009859638288617134, -0.029078278690576553, -0.05225905030965805, -0.007928579114377499, -0.00951254554092884, 0.020036887377500534, -0.0264486912637949, 0.014849130064249039, 0.01148582249879837, -0.02073523961007595, -0.01786203682422638, 0.046728409826755524, 0.033037591725587845, 0.05050596967339516, -0.0014568795450031757, 0.05985970050096512, -0.013170585967600346, 0.056142985820770264, 0.001859620213508606, 0.10732359439134598, -0.01849011890590191, -0.0257162656635046, -0.043673738837242126, 0.014880542643368244, -0.009006793610751629, -0.039782293140888214, -0.04198808968067169, -0.024840526282787323, 0.0168988648802042, -0.016466349363327026, -0.021872418001294136, 0.0002919480612035841, -0.02865993045270443, 0.0672072321176529, -0.05517984554171562, 0.0053447759710252285, 0.05120854079723358, 0.013732298277318478, -0.0031855134293437004, -0.052386123687028885, 0.0544610358774662, -0.015467763878405094, 0.04899626597762108, -0.03364728018641472, -0.048202723264694214, -0.014879865571856499, 0.012615370564162731, 0.014979356899857521, -0.016821011900901794, -0.009019806049764156, 0.042023416608572006, 0.02687167003750801, -0.02059057354927063, -0.04559019207954407, -0.001329595921561122, 0.03655225783586502, 0.048205144703388214, -0.05145677924156189, -0.028397679328918457, 0.052151598036289215, 0.05803792551159859, 0.031855303794145584, -0.0028193059843033552, 0.06218747794628143, 0.04066985845565796, 0.02923482470214367, -0.031509559601545334, 0.0230688638985157, -0.023913370445370674, -0.046648625284433365, -0.056409671902656555, 0.055329326540231705, -0.0013909790432080626, -0.018673790618777275, 0.022584253922104836, -0.011427382938563824, -0.02013433538377285, -0.038089901208877563, -0.0027144483756273985, -0.010554851032793522, 0.04136238992214203, 0.040798839181661606, 0.023198124021291733, 0.048567015677690506, 0.025313373655080795, 0.01724126935005188, 0.0715380311012268, -0.06712710857391357, 0.05946515128016472, -0.03211712837219238, -0.016603857278823853, 0.010370766744017601, -0.03217292204499245, -0.02832455188035965, 0.0359966903924942, 0.03134318068623543, 0.0364471934735775, -0.012260418385267258, -0.016858737915754318, -0.016896940767765045, 0.019899951294064522, 0.02208080142736435, -0.04599855840206146, 0.04807404801249504, -0.04197973012924194, -0.007269131951034069, 0.05880344286561012, -0.024598026648163795, 0.045819275081157684, 0.037724569439888, -0.04764489084482193, 0.01993977278470993, -0.04145166277885437, 0.016362495720386505, 0.00310130906291306, 0.007352802436798811, -0.04834869131445885, 0.001482469728216529, -0.11816395074129105, -0.00488701555877924, -0.05201831832528114, 0.038690242916345596, -0.010675136931240559, 0.011956810019910336, 0.02636057324707508, 0.031940970569849014, 0.030713161453604698, 0.024019688367843628, -0.006130206398665905, 0.005932589992880821, -0.08874805271625519, -0.01843740977346897, -0.024296080693602562, -0.019174937158823013, 0.00930070597678423, 0.07689334452152252, 0.027137942612171173, -0.04691817983984947, -0.01728167198598385, -0.028146347030997276, -0.009065568447113037, -0.02017681859433651, -0.0775667130947113, -0.061076339334249496, 0.019507357850670815, -0.037300873547792435, -0.0067716483026742935, -0.025116048753261566, -0.00908111222088337, -0.011972696520388126, -0.02022544853389263, -0.027543388307094574, -0.03476276248693466, 0.0035005570389330387, -0.0117557467892766, 0.005574277602136135, -0.050567157566547394, -0.002595715457573533, -0.07067696005105972, 0.06923023611307144, -0.04317205399274826, -0.04370326176285744, 0.09991135448217392, -0.04183712601661682, 0.027849799022078514, -0.05316856503486633, -0.004482990130782127, 0.011927507817745209, -0.02895365282893181, 0.02487187832593918, -0.009513145312666893, 0.026845073327422142, 0.020219698548316956, -0.06698468327522278, -0.005913391709327698, 0.04252064973115921, 0.06392249464988708, -0.014896579086780548, 0.0071174632757902145, -0.02345472201704979, -0.01013941876590252, -0.024721156805753708, -0.008747313171625137, -0.01620068959891796, -0.0019128515850752592, -0.06308566778898239, -0.016168298199772835, -0.09128250926733017, 0.03079662285745144, 0.030991287901997566, -0.08051780611276627, -0.04245311766862869, -0.002111304784193635, -0.021325821056962013, 0.005768872331827879, 0.0293282363563776, 0.02899092249572277, 0.030710168182849884, -0.01193250808864832, -0.0009755044593475759, 0.0033355075865983963, -0.00928033608943224, 0.0217435285449028, 0.057866863906383514, 0.041963182389736176, 0.05816294625401497, -0.02857830934226513, 0.033805690705776215, 0.00012658337072934955, 0.05067156255245209, -0.017641019076108932, -0.04374265670776367, -0.05831887200474739, 0.040764182806015015, 0.00549959484487772, 0.0019477049354463816, 0.10489467531442642, -0.002244025468826294, 0.0007147696451283991, 0.049616795033216476, 0.0250107254832983, -0.060254693031311035, -0.08318069577217102, 0.024329790845513344, 0.003757850034162402, 0.01533659640699625, 0.013335231691598892, -0.03291872888803482, -0.05023719742894173, -0.012579850852489471, 0.05590939149260521, 0.002671328838914633, -0.013817498460412025, -0.0017816299805417657, 0.04800936207175255, 0.0066290926188230515, 0.08940690755844116, -0.018635105341672897, -0.002749292878434062, -0.03312799707055092, -0.006347885355353355, -0.01632327027618885, -0.05356815457344055, -0.06367524713277817, -0.05259697139263153, -0.015210404992103577, 0.018209150061011314, -0.019314490258693695, -0.0547671876847744, 0.025133980438113213, -0.011644585058093071, 0.06360004842281342, -0.011168649420142174, 0.05245404317975044, 0.012506231665611267, -0.06078477203845978, -0.027829168364405632, -0.01159747876226902, 0.024944717064499855, -0.03723754733800888, -0.00918195303529501, 0.0343649722635746, -0.00009334723290521652, 0.001431071083061397, 0.017829865217208862, 0.03279081732034683, 0.03936469927430153, 0.026262253522872925, 0.02733520418405533, -0.010540871880948544, -0.0020619293209165335, -0.06017572432756424, -0.01405422855168581, -0.02644113264977932, -0.05216643214225769, 0.00432928092777729, -0.06917677819728851, -0.0058431075885891914, -0.047482531517744064, 0.004754409193992615, -0.059740565717220306, -0.025129390880465508, 0.03138234466314316, -0.05893765762448311, 0.024254415184259415, 0.0024033323861658573, 0.055604223161935806, -0.014876901172101498, 0.00009628391853766516, -0.04515272378921509, -0.012454958632588387, 0.038526490330696106, -0.01827085204422474, 0.0481766015291214, 0.01620546542108059, 0.05671706795692444, 0.0016156493220478296, -0.004328338894993067, 0.0013886310625821352, -0.060755323618650436, -0.056354206055402756, -0.004713034722954035, -0.054497357457876205, -0.020951610058546066, 0.009153478778898716, 0.05000936985015869, 0.009418233297765255, -0.029608678072690964, 0.014577623456716537, 0.03938186541199684, -0.04205179214477539, -0.015315135940909386, 0.05564300715923309, -0.010931040160357952, 0.007552262395620346, 0.061551984399557114, 0.02415071241557598, -0.05296676233410835, 0.019468288868665695, 0.015125954523682594, -0.028118105605244637, -0.013458307832479477, 0.04274604842066765, 0.035058293491601944, -0.07020799070596695, 0.04397060349583626, -0.02669394016265869, 0.020654357969760895, -0.03730979934334755, 0.037413857877254486, 0.014823556877672672, 0.013796278275549412, -0.012221877463161945, 0.006096792407333851, -0.0343271940946579, -0.013785276561975479, -0.031070873141288757, 0.006244890857487917, 0.024603383615612984, -0.030866418033838272, -0.0015989332459867, 0.05166297033429146, 0.02224203199148178, 0.06199187785387039, -0.007070955820381641, 0.029842151328921318, 0.04843217879533768, 0.011633339338004589, -0.02742612361907959, 0.014491027221083641, 0.03950309753417969, -0.00263844127766788, -0.027253692969679832, -0.013585556298494339, 0.012343592941761017, -0.015278703533113003, -0.00639068940654397, 0.0032891526352614164, -0.004129772540181875, 0.05455504357814789, 0.008085781708359718, 0.019835706800222397, 0.022525863721966743, -0.015084800310432911, 0.010493102483451366, 0.09181537479162216, -0.013402634300291538, 0.04161599278450012, -0.0012200851924717426, -0.049532562494277954, -0.04370040446519852, -0.019693776965141296, -0.006645719986408949, -0.04196016490459442, 0.03559901937842369, 0.0634828582406044, -0.016284601762890816, -0.004370458424091339, 0.03573334962129593, 0.00040079368045553565, -0.0008161540026776493, -0.004331888630986214, -0.036824021488428116, 0.0062917619943618774, -0.02021922543644905, -0.004668666049838066, -0.02727944776415825, 0.036931607872247696, 0.020937379449605942, -0.010492381639778614, 0.01415761187672615, 0.001148486160673201, -0.005501098465174437, -0.040438052266836166, -0.04551047831773758, 0.028080176562070847, 0.057296399027109146, -0.006791445426642895, -0.0477306954562664, 0.023795779794454575, 0.04902631789445877, 0.029857808724045753, -0.004864691756665707, -0.020379887893795967, 0.004331763833761215, -0.0029798191972076893, 0.03169846534729004, -0.022281337529420853, -0.07593832910060883, -0.00563994562253356, 0.10260221362113953, -0.017750931903719902, -0.04963985085487366, 0.06670123338699341, -0.016453083604574203, 0.06461146473884583, 0.037815045565366745, -0.03315849229693413, -0.026686616241931915, 0.0323750339448452, 0.04147571325302124, -0.03023228421807289, 0.013519568368792534, -0.05932584032416344, -0.04765699803829193, -0.04076390713453293, 0.013853700831532478, -0.050126902759075165, 0.007247952278703451, 0.04230574518442154, 0.05857221782207489, 0.013934184797108173, 0.024873346090316772, 0.01836341619491577, 0.023880673572421074, 0.022763200104236603, -0.07576613873243332, -0.05581779032945633, 0.015045895241200924, 0.06673271209001541, -0.03242749348282814, 0.019459566101431847, -0.021234039217233658, -0.01692568138241768, -0.024287046864628792, 0.004987174645066261, -0.0011109926272183657, -0.009955791756510735, 0.010144066996872425, 0.04224805533885956, 0.07476043701171875, 0.04486750811338425, 0.025902539491653442, 0.010092031210660934, 0.007502446416765451, -0.009771186858415604, 0.0014756195014342666, -0.04302091896533966, -0.019350040704011917, -0.0221131332218647, -0.027411775663495064, 0.06021461635828018, 0.05795019865036011, -0.006132702808827162, 0.002633812837302685, 0.03712982311844826, -0.001455495716072619, -0.06377986818552017, 0.015217317268252373, -0.011846600100398064, -0.029851777479052544, -0.024377692490816116, 0.047306399792432785, -0.008601156994700432, 0.009310178458690643, 0.026652924716472626, 0.06404702365398407, 0.01920357719063759, 0.020902113988995552, -0.021814297884702682, 0.04463845491409302, 0.03525439649820328, -0.019838299602270126, 0.0431426577270031, 0.02512463927268982, 0.03279951214790344, 0.07419858127832413, 0.05146825686097145, 0.010734166949987411, -0.011339196935296059, -0.008698919788002968, -0.036841388791799545, 0.0006250222213566303, -0.03646647930145264, 0.03046744130551815, 0.03166934475302696, 0.0258437842130661, -0.03325312212109566, -0.034600693732500076, -0.06009215861558914, 0.0030226921662688255, -0.016392100602388382, -0.014828721061348915, 0.00474212784320116, 0.010113733820617199, 0.04390207305550575, -0.0785018652677536, 0.0021777721121907234, -0.021922700107097626, -0.006244199350476265, 0.007259299047291279, 0.01498749852180481, -0.029809540137648582, -0.01359857153147459, -0.035730063915252686, -0.04953192546963692, 0.013323524966835976, -0.01288518588989973, 0.07054058462381363, 0.01720041036605835, 0.0013684360310435295, -0.007115947548300028, 0.023589374497532845, 0.02213321253657341, -0.009050589054822922, 0.07552137225866318, -0.030828353017568588, -0.04735162481665611, -0.008220347575843334, -0.01337463315576315, 0.008134955540299416, -0.015433894470334053, 0.0010742070153355598, -0.08937295526266098, 0.03312201797962189, -0.0073570264503359795, 0.060905780643224716, 0.031845346093177795, 0.02096940577030182, -0.053794361650943756, -0.01579303853213787, 0.014143364503979683, 0.012630094774067402, -0.025082705542445183, -0.009621280245482922, 0.009657382033765316, -0.08270876109600067, -0.059927716851234436, -0.00006790729821659625, 0.019112689420580864, 0.06859166920185089, -0.0028660246171057224, 0.03115689381957054, 0.0019831196404993534, 0.019723284989595413, -0.018249761313199997, -0.020689764991402626, -0.018394237384200096, -0.02328897826373577, 0.049931567162275314, 0.07052987813949585, -0.012360609136521816, -0.03099675662815571, -0.07299932837486267, -0.051526155322790146, -0.01936897449195385, -0.029883746057748795, -0.028468681499361992, -0.07347261160612106, -0.0714053362607956, 0.025715870782732964, 0.059169311076402664, 0.010889236815273762, 0.009531418792903423, 0.014041903428733349, -0.020637892186641693, 0.044216353446245193, -0.02687479928135872, -0.0004498548514675349, -0.0164486076682806, 0.03863496333360672, 0.013603804633021355, 0.037406373769044876, -0.036722201853990555, 0.05505276843905449, -0.025649234652519226, -0.05341275781393051, -0.03382052108645439, -0.010750457644462585, -0.0055391825735569, 0.10344187170267105, -0.03972114250063896, 0.0013343917671591043, 0.022557441145181656, 0.036392148584127426, -0.023578627035021782, 0.0021589966490864754, -0.07506832480430603, -0.01849985122680664, -0.05130486935377121, 0.04698006808757782, 0.0076582725159823895, -0.008515103720128536, 0.008163470774888992, 0.04179297387599945 ]
<p>I am interested in fitting a Poisson/negative binomial distribution to estimate the number of times a phenomenon happens within a period, let's just say 10 years. I can count the events from monthly reports, but unfortunately, there are reports missing. So for one sample, I might have 120 observational slots, but for some others I might have 30. The event can happen if it is not observed. </p> <p>The missing slots pattern is random (ie not correlated between samples), and it can result in anything from a nearly complete observational record to a very decimated one.</p> <p>How can I cope with this?</p>
g74065
[ 0.037610091269016266, 0.012633329257369041, -0.0016245698789134622, -0.03669557347893715, -0.0050360774621367455, 0.00561382994055748, 0.006348768714815378, 0.027625763788819313, 0.013605301268398762, -0.044746074825525284, 0.025889649987220764, -0.05149095505475998, 0.010412304662168026, 0.0011662975884974003, -0.0350230447947979, -0.004356461111456156, 0.027750538662075996, 0.034871239215135574, -0.012763192877173424, 0.03632009029388428, 0.018657559528946877, -0.014722521416842937, 0.0016284743323922157, 0.032888349145650864, -0.043887387961149216, 0.006113061681389809, -0.021842824295163155, 0.018228286877274513, -0.013117440976202488, -0.03448190540075302, 0.0005659166490659118, -0.03323034942150116, -0.05851829797029495, -0.033710576593875885, 0.006096260622143745, 0.0006519245216622949, -0.008350568823516369, -0.014662748202681541, -0.03984583541750908, 0.020874273031949997, 0.016037318855524063, -0.017118100076913834, 0.013343519531190395, 0.020160583779215813, -0.03623676672577858, 0.03678449988365173, -0.019357671961188316, 0.031645189970731735, 0.014872455038130283, -0.046182624995708466, 0.03262721374630928, 0.003558673430234194, 0.01957779936492443, 0.023564258590340614, 0.03619154542684555, 0.0746430978178978, 0.04765307903289795, -0.0593041256070137, 0.047774914652109146, 0.022367900237441063, 0.04201700538396835, -0.04001764580607414, -0.042192649096250534, 0.006513037718832493, 0.005233949515968561, 0.08044598251581192, -0.04534750431776047, 0.03755781427025795, 0.011330311186611652, -0.029352841898798943, 0.02380353957414627, 0.05310971662402153, -0.00009586902888258919, -0.034188445657491684, -0.0299617201089859, 0.03493545949459076, -0.07737332582473755, 0.08405850827693939, 0.020586390048265457, 0.06734856218099594, -0.04201899841427803, 0.02976684831082821, -0.006357821170240641, -0.01976810023188591, 0.05610149726271629, 0.02544873021543026, 0.05911439657211304, -0.05098732188344002, 0.016428086906671524, 0.025210833176970482, 0.03077247366309166, 0.011373819783329964, 0.0538778230547905, -0.02257397212088108, 0.04228982701897621, 0.05220072343945503, -0.03839483484625816, 0.04234608635306358, -0.05210594832897186, 0.03105311281979084, 0.042123500257730484, -0.013846220448613167, -0.009908202104270458, -0.059544023126363754, -0.042827680706977844, -0.021760737523436546, -0.02973002940416336, -0.024631140753626823, 0.06941015273332596, 0.005457218736410141, -0.02960655651986599, 0.04882625490427017, -0.03996480628848076, -0.037296462804079056, 0.04118726775050163, -0.012881927192211151, 0.07673413306474686, -0.02602001093327999, -0.012362027540802956, 0.04764581099152565, -0.06331635266542435, -0.019714321941137314, 0.0070536271668970585, 0.04697861522436142, -0.031072355806827545, -0.022051390260457993, -0.022228211164474487, 0.07579823583364487, 0.041740816086530685, -0.0183570459485054, -0.0058775125071406364, -0.004836634732782841, 0.06558465212583542, 0.06491252034902573, 0.036249496042728424, 0.0122795095667243, 0.030415093526244164, 0.02556692063808441, 0.030957913026213646, 0.07405281066894531, 0.011699819006025791, -0.007851568050682545, 0.015856804326176643, -0.010073733516037464, -0.019062111154198647, 0.01770957186818123, -0.04048522189259529, -0.05151178687810898, -0.01467251405119896, -0.015085450373589993, -0.024259179830551147, 0.010807964019477367, -0.029649602249264717, -0.012806358747184277, 0.019483070820569992, -0.013226659037172794, -0.007867706008255482, -0.04603886604309082, -0.03347437083721161, -0.009807568974792957, 0.04688875749707222, -0.036943525075912476, 0.010649945586919785, 0.06772194057703018, -0.0284747201949358, -0.023146143183112144, 0.020754272118210793, -0.014837086200714111, -0.042880233377218246, -0.008549235761165619, 0.009753645397722721, -0.023173702880740166, 0.046193212270736694, -0.007991830818355083, 0.023343296721577644, 0.06120266020298004, 0.013929703272879124, 0.02278914488852024, 0.02359665557742119, -0.005104848649352789, 0.015239887870848179, -0.014082711189985275, -0.0044488427229225636, -0.036617211997509, 0.024685245007276535, -0.10587061941623688, 0.031411364674568176, 0.060383811593055725, -0.01805560477077961, -0.021647026762366295, 0.05220060423016548, -0.05562600865960121, 0.01359277032315731, -0.03179163485765457, -0.030605284497141838, -0.04551054164767265, 0.04995300620794296, -0.04812684282660484, -0.03381294384598732, -0.03416372463107109, 0.016863033175468445, -0.018062161281704903, -0.040246427059173584, -0.012443293817341328, 0.05912260338664055, -0.05396926775574684, -0.03149442747235298, 0.020658478140830994, -0.03873265162110329, -0.009955612942576408, -0.03934844955801964, -0.06166446954011917, -0.04127483442425728, 0.03213110193610191, -0.033369142562150955, 0.01887599751353264, 0.014961404725909233, -0.005065510049462318, 0.05795447155833244, 0.0014725618530064821, -0.02346162684261799, -0.015533629804849625, -0.01765826903283596, -0.014376976527273655, 0.04866544157266617, 0.019889481365680695, 0.054403480142354965, 0.025248337537050247, 0.0006596565945073962, 0.009446840733289719, -0.051497288048267365, -0.01860700361430645, 0.02355334907770157, -0.06456979364156723, 0.011561131104826927, 0.01934051886200905, -0.002840234898030758, 0.0386774055659771, 0.019567200914025307, -0.022205233573913574, -0.0342780165374279, 0.007092283107340336, -0.12141445279121399, 0.05823173373937607, -0.010646854527294636, -0.006937501020729542, 0.00507956650108099, -0.0189870186150074, 0.03558318316936493, 0.011395419016480446, -0.020308950915932655, -0.01641746051609516, -0.006572304759174585, -0.05567430704832077, 0.034181345254182816, -0.009172149002552032, 0.008479617536067963, 0.014067403972148895, -0.02570868283510208, -0.03763825446367264, 0.0029501388780772686, 0.007204154971987009, 0.05740850046277046, -0.049918144941329956, 0.01093872357159853, -0.08349636942148209, -0.02399522252380848, -0.013586058281362057, -0.04054196551442146, 0.04768762364983559, 0.0299857035279274, -0.008153433911502361, 0.017283301800489426, 0.022182628512382507, 0.04408714175224304, 0.0569276288151741, -0.021152183413505554, 0.01597769744694233, 0.013557038269937038, 0.02753831446170807, -0.006482507102191448, -0.06766905635595322, 0.015398791991174221, 0.00004479967901716009, 0.0014860481023788452, 0.008804063312709332, 0.050618726760149, 0.04727700352668762, -0.008939721621572971, 0.07578147947788239, -0.030718190595507622, -0.041778869926929474, 0.012657351791858673, 0.030458692461252213, -0.021064668893814087, -0.005602128338068724, -0.0025769234634935856, -0.017795609310269356, 0.03289976716041565, -0.013126030564308167, 0.00794057548046112, 0.009942214004695415, 0.021779583767056465, 0.007418260909616947, 0.002208639867603779, -0.05663851276040077, -0.017358530312776566, 0.024600228294730186, 0.03125610575079918, -0.036682069301605225, 0.04103288799524307, -0.013395251706242561, 0.04745687171816826, 0.007367826998233795, 0.0006797899259254336, 0.03854089602828026, -0.027174023911356926, 0.020136607810854912, -0.0227353535592556, 0.012129566632211208, 0.03871626406908035, 0.013598878867924213, 0.026550905779004097, 0.05730464309453964, 0.031820833683013916, -0.013915940187871456, -0.054310694336891174, 0.021456224843859673, -0.04600006341934204, 0.05809643119573593, 0.015613113529980183, -0.07133885473012924, 0.008025753311812878, -0.10260297358036041, -0.01828409731388092, -0.04127280041575432, 0.004030752461403608, -0.05320920795202255, 0.02654418908059597, 0.03933863341808319, 0.015247280709445477, 0.007346301805227995, -0.05355815589427948, -0.047848138958215714, -0.052580174058675766, -0.026532424613833427, -0.0052383290603756905, 0.04960464686155319, 0.05160672962665558, -0.03991691395640373, 0.004139304626733065, 0.0009925474878400564, -0.014006479643285275, -0.04096898436546326, 0.05762623995542526, 0.0026178511325269938, 0.019079163670539856, -0.00581177556887269, 0.05133359506726265, -0.03542475029826164, 0.03750090301036835, -0.04796967655420303, -0.005838985554873943, 0.04282981902360916, -0.0015644457889720798, -0.021475475281476974, 0.01655207760632038, 0.05721290782094002, 0.055825311690568924, -0.028257330879569054, 0.0015051184454932809, 0.07481705397367477, 0.030502671375870705, -0.053968317806720734, -0.009735788218677044, -0.04869956150650978, -0.005013186018913984, 0.035983942449092865, 0.017772063612937927, 0.04801202937960625, 0.005655302200466394, -0.011582744307816029, 0.0061159320175647736, -0.04077659174799919, 0.001956614200025797, -0.054459962993860245, 0.0018815401708707213, -0.010297519154846668, -0.05592194199562073, -0.05688659846782684, 0.023368868976831436, -0.0047203232534229755, -0.008004008792340755, -0.002449818653985858, 0.05974498763680458, -0.10580379515886307, -0.022041887044906616, -0.00014130736235529184, 0.03071642480790615, 0.04000679403543472, 0.03207225352525711, -0.0159736480563879, 0.0603918619453907, 0.02502373792231083, -0.013466477394104004, 0.03377597779035568, -0.016546813771128654, 0.042234454303979874, -0.037557750940322876, 0.03372250869870186, -0.06374833732843399, 0.014326607808470726, -0.0584423802793026, -0.04509618505835533, 0.050529494881629944, -0.00897924043238163, 0.07537046819925308, 0.004400917794555426, 0.04379545897245407, 0.03348339721560478, -0.0047628870233893394, 0.05706728994846344, -0.038100242614746094, 0.007984950207173824, -0.014270494692027569, 0.015929797664284706, 0.0039541637524962425, -0.04152430221438408, 0.02276373654603958, -0.04306609183549881, 0.03771032392978668, 0.06327688694000244, 0.01696093939244747, 0.035524941980838776, -0.0035106746945530176, 0.004252187442034483, 0.02874547801911831, 0.03687036409974098, 0.0323127880692482, 0.009564494714140892, -0.008872532285749912, -0.08134588599205017, -0.041908469051122665, 0.005311636719852686, 0.005863971542567015, 0.04920179396867752, -0.001272499794140458, -0.026999007910490036, 0.02195129543542862, 0.06331165134906769, 0.015937093645334244, -0.01707787811756134, -0.02737080119550228, -0.035335589200258255, 0.009112426079809666, -0.02204347401857376, -0.021470537409186363, 0.04423133283853531, -0.009435529820621014, 0.015295865945518017, -0.039945535361766815, -0.031573496758937836, 0.0008538712281733751, -0.033284254372119904, -0.01646190509200096, -0.06525738537311554, 0.015355145558714867, -0.04326286166906357, -0.001291553839109838, -0.033081550151109695, -0.009815261699259281, -0.04039319232106209, 0.00018050249491352588, -0.025338180363178253, -0.03713606297969818, -0.02787739410996437, -0.05850501358509064, -0.009916088543832302, 0.005134230479598045, 0.06086267530918121, 0.03346410021185875, -0.038802776485681534, 0.004747648257762194, -0.019633766263723373, -0.03972394019365311, 0.0048853615298867226, 0.03909328952431679, -0.08209288120269775, 0.021763509139418602, -0.006201571319252253, 0.026513749733567238, -0.010684661567211151, 0.01774226874113083, 0.06034882739186287, 0.020476235076785088, -0.05668511241674423, 0.032986704260110855, 0.016614152118563652, 0.00565173476934433, 0.0008850411977618933, -0.06077339127659798, 0.03611252084374428, 0.014281916432082653, -0.03167903050780296, 0.018464382737874985, 0.03010742925107479, 0.03452552482485771, 0.01901550590991974, 0.009974160231649876, 0.027448439970612526, 0.010850172489881516, 0.03432023152709007, 0.016249462962150574, -0.01742984540760517, -0.0024581286124885082, -0.011206207796931267, 0.001991638448089361, 0.012956064194440842, -0.036010436713695526, -0.023759925737977028, -0.02859046310186386, 0.03484334051609039, 0.02897258847951889, -0.005705175455659628, 0.010360016487538815, -0.08768253773450851, -0.08904831111431122, -0.005812267307192087, -0.01717323809862137, -0.07626212388277054, 0.050072863698005676, -0.06236565113067627, -0.030675208196043968, 0.021476155146956444, -0.005284862592816353, 0.005922769196331501, -0.01912122406065464, 0.015241320244967937, 0.037636082619428635, 0.0058004953898489475, -0.049662746489048004, 0.0140897948294878, 0.12107274681329727, -0.02162254974246025, -0.002393496222794056, -0.019688311964273453, -0.004206325858831406, -0.01821896620094776, 0.020265908911824226, -0.019066184759140015, 0.011324414983391762, 0.08095651119947433, 0.01412306446582079, 0.03880273923277855, -0.03584398701786995, -0.00495360791683197, 0.04001113772392273, 0.03216155990958214, -0.013826392590999603, 0.02924276888370514, -0.025126859545707703, -0.029952697455883026, 0.019500501453876495, 0.02796691097319126, -0.0219118669629097, 0.04700636863708496, 0.0019998170901089907, -0.023720281198620796, -0.025056488811969757, 0.035902541130781174, 0.013410238549113274, -0.008406024426221848, 0.03198735788464546, 0.016788583248853683, -0.008265725336968899, 0.024859897792339325, 0.03229691460728645, 0.022116858512163162, -0.023318534716963768, 0.00039038658724166453, -0.06388229131698608, 0.01132186222821474, 0.04768269509077072, 0.018438521772623062, -0.040835607796907425, 0.06899389624595642, -0.06391545385122299, 0.036365315318107605, -0.0031749177724123, -0.015840739011764526, -0.01354310940951109, -0.04618397355079651, -0.0034460979513823986, -0.05507078394293785, -0.0335376150906086, -0.036821722984313965, -0.03967330977320671, -0.03433218598365784, -0.035469088703393936, -0.03462320566177368, -0.020252643153071404, -0.055867645889520645, 0.03765701502561569, -0.026698065921664238, 0.029424848034977913, -0.03202996402978897, -0.0212333295494318, 0.01713922619819641, 0.012238794937729836, 0.0225951187312603, 0.0030358920339494944, 0.003422433277592063, 0.05521149933338165, 0.07844800502061844, -0.036204200237989426, -0.05280442163348198, -0.014037003740668297, -0.004778592381626368, -0.051334232091903687, 0.02216111123561859, -0.0034287506714463234, -0.009538833051919937, -0.041062645614147186, -0.044738370925188065, 0.02527671307325363, 0.004073791205883026, -0.0013406418729573488, -0.06887521594762802, 0.06015300378203392, -0.03140467777848244, -0.00019520714704412967, -0.023161785677075386, -0.048469752073287964, 0.05892607569694519, -0.049056101590394974, 0.06958496570587158, -0.0696708932518959, 0.05291364714503288, 0.06915771216154099, -0.02679395116865635, 0.02432517148554325, 0.06143026798963547, 0.055410608649253845, -0.03234276548027992, -0.009368236176669598, -0.018663911148905754, 0.02496601827442646, 0.02848253957927227, 0.017106186598539352, -0.01978818140923977, 0.014302821829915047, 0.003580079646781087, 0.057279039174318314, -0.003962989430874586, 0.008240476250648499, 0.05450936779379845, 0.017130007967352867, -0.005123032256960869, 0.03297065943479538, -0.01963193342089653, -0.058302633464336395, -0.024364277720451355, -0.030699118971824646, -0.03098437935113907, 0.016259226948022842, -0.005943640135228634, -0.013366373255848885, -0.028151394799351692, -0.01887837052345276, -0.03953349217772484, -0.02504456415772438, 0.01710589788854122, -0.0553106963634491, 0.05062175914645195, -0.02186206914484501, -0.03591527044773102, 0.0015014053788036108, 0.05178220197558403, 0.002205797703936696, -0.022725218906998634, -0.02079305425286293, -0.04456355795264244, -0.019398344680666924, 0.005198522005230188, 0.030884405598044395, 0.0773000493645668, -0.018306225538253784, 0.02901303954422474, 0.06139381602406502, 0.008474256843328476, 0.0024860906414687634, -0.017222242429852486, 0.033544450998306274, -0.032349783927202225, -0.010562708601355553, 0.028391866013407707, 0.07545401901006699, -0.08521931618452072, -0.01348997000604868, 0.04430903494358063, 0.018491031602025032, 0.05384524539113045, -0.004481394775211811, -0.05767111852765083, 0.062091223895549774, -0.013210550881922245, -0.030159715563058853, -0.06425657123327255, 0.06948006898164749, 0.02417144551873207, 0.05070071667432785, 0.05328349024057388, -0.061553772538900375, -0.05456986278295517, 0.008845311589539051, -0.031779494136571884, -0.04525558277964592, -0.031169995665550232, 0.009237798862159252, -0.03091351129114628, -0.08038070797920227, -0.0033504648599773645, -0.007292216178029776, 0.0035055791959166527, 0.028866469860076904, 0.010524192824959755, -0.014946967363357544, 0.01150068175047636, 0.002424691105261445, 0.008415314368903637, 0.013580720871686935, -0.023206820711493492, -0.08090855926275253, 0.021936150267720222, -0.0032353054266422987, -0.01253199391067028, -0.011738736182451248, 0.021093007177114487, -0.05535362288355827, -0.007175989914685488, -0.019706066697835922, 0.032981693744659424, -0.013527263887226582, -0.01165859680622816, 0.031220436096191406, -0.057901300489902496, -0.014500340446829796, -0.019781947135925293, 0.02290308102965355, 0.008160044439136982, -0.08968011289834976, 0.010441684164106846, -0.0007656607194803655, 0.04617069289088249, 0.058211009949445724, -0.034279704093933105, 0.053162045776844025, -0.059936780482530594, -0.04021010175347328, -0.033621322363615036, 0.07707773149013519, 0.013248229399323463, -0.026868708431720734, 0.01592903584241867, -0.00498165050521493, -0.0007721516885794699, 0.044545721262693405, 0.029924647882580757 ]
<p>I am using the <code>flexmix</code> package to estimate latent class multinomial logit models in R. In choice theory, there can be variables associated with the alternative (generic) or that vary with the agent (alternative-specific).</p> <p>The <code>nnet</code> package that underlies <code>FLXMRmultinom</code> can't accommodate generic variables. So far, I haven't seen that the <code>FLXMRcondlogit</code> can handle alternative-specific ones.</p> <p>The most flexible package for MNL models is <code>mlogit</code>. Has anyone seen an implementation of this for <code>flexmix</code>?</p>
g36709
[ -0.04088638722896576, -0.01687450148165226, -0.0004667312023229897, 0.002474808366969228, -0.046799108386039734, -0.09984321892261505, -0.09923797845840454, -0.009494432248175144, 0.004716983065009117, 0.01091399509459734, -0.052266925573349, -0.010223970748484135, 0.033474136143922806, 0.023312529549002647, -0.03688124939799309, 0.04603270813822746, 0.03235587850213051, 0.00697149895131588, 0.00009139433677773923, -0.008110103197395802, 0.026379425078630447, 0.024602340534329414, 0.01749512366950512, -0.0028839875012636185, -0.015626467764377594, -0.005333622917532921, 0.01402504462748766, 0.021226253360509872, -0.05677424371242523, 0.004468364641070366, -0.011732639744877815, 0.002706497209146619, 0.018574383109807968, -0.04723428189754486, -0.05333106964826584, 0.019887730479240417, -0.018694421276450157, 0.005080601666122675, -0.023149902001023293, 0.07020873576402664, -0.047705650329589844, 0.07076451182365417, 0.015272671356797218, -0.0020288564264774323, -0.008720804937183857, -0.005665662232786417, 0.007114812266081572, 0.00515787024050951, -0.013105399906635284, 0.000038363697967724875, 0.0028876299038529396, -0.01864785887300968, 0.011137785390019417, 0.02127510868012905, 0.05684903264045715, 0.02674693986773491, -0.06103069707751274, 0.009454488754272461, 0.003767038229852915, -0.025337226688861847, 0.04973311349749565, 0.024602117016911507, -0.01098938100039959, -0.030757922679185867, 0.0073234005831182, 0.0515037439763546, -0.04105525091290474, -0.05348021537065506, 0.027961645275354385, -0.0006969181122258306, -0.010678621008992195, 0.07662246376276016, 0.031496141105890274, 0.03230278939008713, -0.007920115254819393, -0.019379399716854095, -0.05901440605521202, -0.0021124209742993116, -0.01636146940290928, -0.04253462702035904, -0.0034701372496783733, 0.018376296386122704, -0.03220013901591301, 0.01746496930718422, -0.028764093294739723, -0.0312914177775383, 0.005904260091483593, -0.031022366136312485, 0.018345575779676437, -0.02575249969959259, -0.009267481043934822, -0.009604059159755707, -0.012941603548824787, 0.0029408237896859646, -0.0628778338432312, 0.004544712603092194, -0.0476362369954586, 0.013145620934665203, 0.03377380967140198, -0.06830288469791412, 0.02125653810799122, 0.03859320282936096, -0.03051411733031273, -0.011949658393859863, -0.027904406189918518, -0.02440454065799713, -0.018217816948890686, 0.03721430152654648, -0.013338489457964897, 0.003478454193100333, -0.018874267116189003, 0.007668619509786367, -0.0097428597509861, 0.011684594675898552, -0.030399121344089508, -0.06775032728910446, -0.01524076797068119, -0.03074018657207489, -0.0545782707631588, 0.025180989876389503, -0.0016509991837665439, -0.020297471433877945, 0.06696299463510513, 0.022647617384791374, 0.01718135178089142, 0.0192361269146204, -0.004298743791878223, 0.0442928709089756, 0.008352598175406456, 0.009845846332609653, 0.06860137730836868, 0.004221280105412006, 0.052720293402671814, 0.024221576750278473, -0.0030269490089267492, -0.036402467638254166, -0.01753845624625683, 0.04210352152585983, -0.009428268298506737, 0.0040392205119132996, -0.01809212937951088, -0.0030202544294297695, 0.010588409379124641, 0.0033305680844932795, 0.01747557893395424, -0.015975411981344223, 0.049286555498838425, 0.045289453119039536, -0.01947084069252014, 0.006284804083406925, 0.006774221546947956, 0.05271347239613533, -0.0022835503332316875, 0.009092433378100395, -0.018099676817655563, 0.03268423303961754, -0.012725978158414364, -0.032570358365774155, -0.053686853498220444, 0.04661446437239647, 0.00014089394244365394, -0.031743209809064865, 0.01305419858545065, -0.022815130650997162, -0.03136841952800751, -0.036612920463085175, 0.019629444926977158, 0.05401001125574112, -0.021382691338658333, -0.0528922863304615, -0.007971587590873241, -0.008165804669260979, -0.00860808789730072, -0.007784394081681967, 0.05385873094201088, -0.004462306387722492, -0.024918202310800552, 0.0032866967376321554, 0.01236745249480009, -0.025324072688817978, -0.025913594290614128, 0.006029800977557898, -0.009036261588335037, -0.017994044348597527, 0.0005769234849140048, -0.022540554404258728, -0.009296434000134468, 0.053222037851810455, 0.014261453412473202, -0.06596148014068604, 0.017021678388118744, 0.01858425885438919, 0.031326621770858765, -0.005243421997874975, -0.027576476335525513, -0.02690642885863781, 0.004276701714843512, -0.024117382243275642, -0.01209600456058979, 0.024719350039958954, 0.027444856241345406, -0.03324095159769058, 0.0036667250096797943, 0.0022980226203799248, -0.030103296041488647, -0.024060823023319244, 0.00599642563611269, -0.03560679405927658, 0.05997149646282196, -0.007713324390351772, 0.07729412615299225, 0.015160758048295975, -0.04685657098889351, 0.01645418256521225, -0.02180967852473259, -0.024096472188830376, -0.009776774793863297, -0.006227250210940838, 0.045074887573719025, -0.04994761198759079, 0.06984063982963562, -0.053888507187366486, 0.032881349325180054, 0.03751475363969803, -0.030236104503273964, 0.001032102620229125, 0.05920673906803131, 0.007358797825872898, -0.018895640969276428, 0.02943839319050312, -0.03133019059896469, -0.017949016764760017, 0.0018999739550054073, 0.01978820003569126, 0.016784388571977615, -0.002393122995272279, -0.02607094682753086, 0.030351098626852036, 0.011029908433556557, 0.00508209178224206, 0.022051114588975906, -0.031094523146748543, -0.03129972144961357, 0.023812126368284225, 0.006140364333987236, -0.025965671986341476, 0.0314008966088295, 0.011424058116972446, 0.053947631269693375, 0.13466717302799225, -0.019488198682665825, 0.04562566056847572, -0.054509300738573074, -0.006951118353754282, 0.007145282346755266, -0.021428903564810753, -0.0021031475625932217, -0.02272889018058777, -0.040040042251348495, 0.02558700367808342, 0.016961578279733658, 0.07146240770816803, -0.020746126770973206, 0.06115470081567764, 0.016510741785168648, -0.0231541208922863, 0.05375409871339798, -0.05543575435876846, -0.00968634057790041, 0.045806895941495895, -0.02702353708446026, -0.007730281911790371, -0.011996827088296413, -0.03704121336340904, -0.026064828038215637, 0.05069410800933838, -0.03260887786746025, -0.021843835711479187, -0.0011032585753127933, -0.010958018712699413, -0.0026828094851225615, -0.02517431043088436, 0.0005976211396045983, -0.049401115626096725, 0.01109231822192669, 0.015105596743524075, -0.02267591468989849, 0.006157048046588898, 0.0079342657700181, -0.01990669034421444, 0.02394106797873974, 0.0008698117453604937, -0.014149151742458344, -0.033913031220436096, -0.03392084687948227, -0.12088695913553238, -0.0892309620976448, 0.07053414732217789, 0.04678929224610329, 0.03515487164258957, -0.017410406842827797, 0.020003480836749077, -0.01843494363129139, 0.05322502925992012, -0.04429253190755844, -0.07395905256271362, -0.03881493955850601, -0.004039405845105648, 0.06313411146402359, 0.013222035020589828, -0.03554381802678108, 0.024856505915522575, -0.0696786493062973, 0.014943787828087807, -0.04087993502616882, 0.01429025363177061, 0.023374808952212334, 0.04847519099712372, 0.05085619166493416, -0.045363929122686386, 0.053449567407369614, -0.0748017281293869, 0.030373578891158104, 0.05271081253886223, 0.0013642041012644768, 0.030489236116409302, -0.029073918238282204, -0.0035726274363696575, -0.09719018638134003, 0.06375753879547119, 0.03790706396102905, 0.0003611452120821923, 0.006879846565425396, -0.001646508346311748, 0.006049181800335646, -0.030131155624985695, -0.007859745994210243, 0.03926420584321022, 0.0327017642557621, -0.008563940413296223, -0.0021096630953252316, -0.023167770355939865, 0.024858225136995316, -0.0063873473554849625, -0.06487632542848587, -0.007514376658946276, -0.027326107025146484, 0.007899397052824497, 0.04838109388947487, 0.06140517070889473, -0.02463643066585064, 0.007358160335570574, 0.012728575617074966, -0.06492400169372559, 0.028981449082493782, -0.03248969838023186, 0.004602049011737108, -0.021245652809739113, -0.0051112184301018715, 0.05501682311296463, 0.04585804045200348, -0.0323534794151783, 0.009970106184482574, 0.00034944742219522595, -0.03199844807386398, 0.09844309091567993, 0.00949393305927515, 0.07267481833696365, 0.08439551293849945, 0.0007637603557668626, 0.0719224363565445, 0.04939480870962143, -0.010047448799014091, 0.011972748674452305, -0.04335545003414154, 0.018254205584526062, 0.0323423333466053, -0.006457873620092869, -0.06271650642156601, 0.012749763205647469, 0.017970863729715347, 0.027968764305114746, 0.05210369452834129, -0.0014734226278960705, -0.08391789346933365, 0.0016240044496953487, -0.0702284425497055, 0.05648999661207199, -0.03574097156524658, 0.015228357166051865, -0.025136219337582588, -0.0011921783443540335, -0.08172213286161423, 0.021397877484560013, 0.04480127990245819, -0.005968853365629911, 0.034064196050167084, -0.022312216460704803, 0.03612654283642769, 0.04603783041238785, -0.020396949723362923, 0.023978183045983315, 0.005758360028266907, -0.03031476028263569, 0.024778157472610474, -0.08860437572002411, -0.10148683935403824, 0.0018268366111442447, -0.005483755376189947, -0.05381951108574867, -0.039019107818603516, -0.04002320021390915, 0.02228822372853756, 0.0425000824034214, 0.058263327926397324, -0.03927220404148102, 0.06382877379655838, -0.003861811710521579, -0.015457340516149998, -0.04010022059082985, -0.025870060548186302, -0.009209922514855862, -0.07223989069461823, -0.05286824703216553, 0.07442265003919601, -0.003028799779713154, 0.023864159360527992, -0.01091664470732212, 0.02856156788766384, 0.005445928778499365, -0.05525527149438858, 0.008952328935265541, -0.03272022306919098, 0.024646775797009468, -0.011228220537304878, -0.0002036343066720292, -0.015294993296265602, -0.05258134752511978, 0.040331047028303146, -0.03397732600569725, -0.05263930931687355, -0.004933399148285389, -0.02554214373230934, -0.05414200201630592, -0.06888220459222794, 0.009010113775730133, 0.03168170154094696, 0.040563829243183136, -0.01834632083773613, 0.04922020807862282, 0.008263125084340572, -0.0343451127409935, -0.016830481588840485, 0.05402575060725212, 0.06793181598186493, -0.01004957128316164, 0.03930658474564552, 0.0140434755012393, 0.06589564681053162, 0.01812586933374405, -0.01153307594358921, 0.00619922298938036, -0.05891641229391098, -0.001117826090194285, -0.00579058425500989, 0.037415944039821625, -0.013871295377612114, -0.019947191700339317, 0.03227560222148895, 0.03480828180909157, 0.04245477914810181, 0.01270484458655119, 0.026274019852280617, -0.005726258270442486, 0.05353908985853195, -0.0137993935495615, 0.055654216557741165, -0.016937902197241783, 0.02293625846505165, -0.045220572501420975, -0.07017108052968979, 0.01455733459442854, -0.015446444042026997, 0.01697753183543682, 0.03688918426632881, 0.03212449327111244, 0.025486569851636887, -0.01831999607384205, 0.024958131834864616, -0.04816775768995285, 0.06166693940758705, 0.02611275017261505, -0.006279943976551294, 0.05035646632313728, -0.029791437089443207, 0.05517684295773506, 0.04935620725154877, -0.03876074403524399, 0.0043305824510753155, 0.01082516647875309, 0.01798950508236885, 0.03133617714047432, 0.03768108785152435, -0.06587415933609009, -0.048049576580524445, 0.024123497307300568, 0.038399890065193176, 0.040748246014118195, -0.004491494968533516, -0.0014770361594855785, 0.05559095740318298, -0.035994503647089005, -0.008466922678053379, -0.000021983754777465947, 0.0032251416705548763, -0.010410712100565434, -0.03099081665277481, -0.00005652144682244398, 0.007496361620724201, -0.0573945976793766, 0.022204136475920677, -0.03242256119847298, 0.031352698802948, 0.00030443540890701115, -0.007381808012723923, -0.04537264257669449, 0.0004557268403004855, -0.041645996272563934, -0.03387654572725296, 0.004643967375159264, 0.025143643841147423, 0.03962745890021324, -0.012258683331310749, 0.0003987571399193257, -0.008893158286809921, -0.005646744277328253, -0.03762408718466759, -0.0408831462264061, -0.02022009715437889, -0.008662913925945759, -0.011829263530671597, 0.034352317452430725, -0.004061560146510601, -0.03623945266008377, -0.04950740933418274, -0.01633964292705059, -0.020756110548973083, -0.024063456803560257, 0.0032625251915305853, -0.04747983068227768, 0.04028060659766197, -0.004477324429899454, -0.030525632202625275, 0.001703079091385007, 0.01701754331588745, 0.009405471384525299, -0.020641807466745377, -0.04308700188994408, 0.01270721759647131, 0.007091124542057514, -0.01540727261453867, -0.029368095099925995, 0.01806122437119484, -0.020695729181170464, -0.03528003394603729, 0.019028810784220695, -0.03917236998677254, -0.0007011144189164042, -0.03149458393454552, 0.045475054532289505, -0.007188585586845875, 0.031901393085718155, 0.025883663445711136, 0.013889179565012455, 0.02449677139520645, -0.03972140699625015, 0.023161351680755615, -0.010556718334555626, 0.02163355052471161, 0.004148847423493862, 0.014406153932213783, -0.03533441200852394, -0.04604662209749222, 0.021725278347730637, -0.057705242186784744, -0.03426436334848404, -0.020309243351221085, -0.021961648017168045, -0.0786995068192482, -0.01656400039792061, -0.032007962465286255, 0.009730580262839794, 0.056963417679071426, -0.008167870342731476, -0.01743309572339058, 0.06412813067436218, -0.019967615604400635, 0.0035977030638605356, 0.04915749281644821, 0.02353920415043831, 0.006935587618499994, -0.0013905110536143184, 0.04070647060871124, 0.00589583208784461, -0.025531072169542313, -0.006095061544328928, -0.06681253761053085, 0.017231471836566925, -0.008813528344035149, -0.025158748030662537, 0.001511606271378696, 0.07327013462781906, 0.003970865160226822, 0.03684718534350395, 0.027798300608992577, -0.01835346780717373, -0.04695319011807442, 0.0024017563555389643, -0.045106444507837296, 0.015473741106688976, -0.04385606199502945, -0.031678494065999985, -0.004554556682705879, 0.023182369768619537, 0.0038422259967774153, 0.02644815854728222, -0.03297852352261543, -0.05547941103577614, 0.03242451697587967, 0.017419612035155296, 0.0073427362367510796, -0.02052721008658409, -0.0006999198812991381, -0.031249452382326126, -0.021731436252593994, 0.027137380093336105, -0.03947647660970688, -0.033961642533540726, 0.09885725378990173, 0.07297200709581375, 0.007956625893712044, 0.02991863526403904, 0.02494359202682972, -0.021693306043744087, 0.046207182109355927, 0.03040293976664543, 0.01623518392443657, 0.01792421191930771, -0.02442462183535099, 0.024540256708860397, 0.06482584029436111, 0.02845771424472332, 0.00002630804738146253, 0.06197897717356682, -0.010458284057676792, 0.07519584894180298, -0.004411953967064619, -0.014204773120582104, 0.07114052772521973, 0.04454279690980911, -0.06715650111436844, -0.03656862676143646, 0.056173697113990784, -0.002959399251267314, 0.061289794743061066, 0.014351906254887581, -0.007046077866107225, -0.027567271143198013, 0.04285343736410141, -0.03324731066823006, -0.008671276271343231, -0.06303763389587402, 0.00955332349985838, 0.028589921072125435, -0.026532402262091637, -0.07324341684579849, -0.03893355652689934, 0.0654740035533905, -0.011580513790249825, 0.019408848136663437, 0.010071116499602795, 0.04150622710585594, 0.04480718821287155, -0.018867047503590584, -0.009299459867179394, -0.01979990117251873, 0.015004938468337059, 0.03668176010251045, 0.03321155533194542, 0.019171003252267838, -0.016672978177666664, -0.006913374178111553, 0.031480029225349426, -0.0013784081675112247, 0.007359587587416172, 0.006343915592879057, -0.026429567486047745, 0.0413869246840477, 0.07431092113256454, 0.060462258756160736, 0.010888085700571537, 0.0349397286772728, -0.032748449593782425, 0.0023253944236785173, 0.046689946204423904, -0.04871672764420509, -0.047484587877988815, -0.03899962082505226, 0.011850794777274132, -0.08806177228689194, -0.07467318326234818, 0.1249021515250206, -0.015216191299259663, 0.11578298360109329, -0.008549308404326439, -0.009066268801689148, -0.039167243987321854, 0.018866442143917084, 0.0067587560042738914, -0.008535410277545452, -0.018698465079069138, 0.004474559798836708, 0.012177142314612865, 0.014277833513915539, -0.040459584444761276, -0.0725540891289711, -0.04623163491487503, 0.020361484959721565, -0.05698198080062866, 0.011666415259242058, -0.0009358127135783434, -0.07099009305238724, -0.056259941309690475, 0.03002498485147953, 0.06077883020043373, 0.018976353108882904, -0.07175387442111969, 0.0029487768188118935, 0.02924451045691967, 0.05334092676639557, -0.03211633488535881, 0.04046114906668663, 0.03880825266242027, 0.059760358184576035, -0.014744616113603115, 0.05785016715526581, -0.026204712688922882, 0.06923984736204147, -0.03608357161283493, -0.0119430897757411, -0.0449114628136158, -0.026735806837677956, 0.006878474727272987, -0.0355059877038002, -0.008932318538427353, 0.019431453198194504, 0.0026387639809399843, 0.045725297182798386, 0.06308285892009735, -0.051975928246974945, -0.04241432622075081, 0.003484681947156787, 0.040169987827539444, 0.02239489182829857, 0.0028091983404010534, 0.025993814691901207, -0.012197542004287243, 0.006037375424057245 ]
<p>I need to predict with a simple model if a bank customer is still active.</p> <p>I have some information like the date of the last meeting with the customer, but some of them didn't have any meeting with their advisor.</p> <pre><code>Customer_Id | Last_meeting_date (in days from now) | Gender |... A 115 F ... B NA F ... </code></pre> <p>Is it possible to use a special value/flag like 1000 to "indicate" to the tree that we don't have any date ?</p> <p>In my mind, the decision tree isn't linear like regression, so it can make an exception, like if Last_meeting_date=1000 then... but I'm not sure of it.</p>
g36710
[ 0.0028329137712717056, -0.007076413836330175, -0.002774265129119158, -0.030977673828601837, 0.0011894925264641643, -0.06071265786886215, 0.021703436970710754, 0.04061146453022957, -0.05389858037233353, -0.023980051279067993, -0.03371362015604973, 0.0470215268433094, 0.06396419554948807, 0.041100408881902695, -0.002495883032679558, 0.035983629524707794, 0.05775739625096321, -0.05194989964365959, -0.0013431307161226869, 0.024945180863142014, 0.02512706071138382, 0.039205171167850494, 0.03314421325922012, 0.00910890195518732, -0.03228619322180748, -0.017764970660209656, -0.017825724557042122, 0.07050175964832306, -0.041536230593919754, 0.05376094579696655, -0.004411180038005114, 0.04212357476353645, 0.03274090588092804, -0.0025375711265951395, -0.04054936021566391, 0.005959312431514263, 0.04122691601514816, -0.0009552568080835044, 0.03875144571065903, -0.011637191288173199, -0.01378015335649252, 0.07237303256988525, 0.018734179437160492, 0.026718400418758392, 0.007703164592385292, 0.003894345834851265, 0.046195607632398605, -0.03794565051794052, 0.006529300473630428, -0.020680349320173264, -0.004885985981673002, -0.04405047371983528, -0.016659896820783615, -0.00553025770932436, -0.008595513179898262, 0.06851819157600403, -0.010264499112963676, 0.07804407179355621, -0.00920025259256363, 0.016358746215701103, 0.0070463209412992, -0.027905501425266266, 0.020071694627404213, 0.03554423898458481, 0.022154463455080986, 0.032038986682891846, -0.08814457803964615, -0.054278723895549774, 0.0067560928873717785, -0.035702213644981384, 0.03826554864645004, 0.03815750777721405, 0.007251979783177376, -0.016956984996795654, -0.024209272116422653, 0.03324035927653313, -0.07220002263784409, -0.012391283176839352, -0.0024310024455189705, 0.04324408993124962, -0.013595269992947578, -0.0017324681393802166, -0.030807748436927795, -0.01096318755298853, -0.02866426110267639, 0.0289144404232502, 0.03355460613965988, -0.026111764833331108, 0.03793156519532204, -0.013808052986860275, 0.00287937861867249, 0.05060798302292824, 0.053582146763801575, 0.016702979803085327, 0.043550893664360046, 0.03254043310880661, -0.046937379986047745, -0.03337149694561958, -0.0068868896923959255, 0.001523318700492382, -0.0318499356508255, 0.07130160182714462, -0.03205815330147743, 0.0023235243279486895, -0.032505735754966736, -0.07577000558376312, 0.027031375095248222, -0.005298941861838102, -0.005568620283156633, -0.0850440114736557, 0.026517245918512344, 0.02137169800698757, -0.025862952694296837, 0.021434104070067406, -0.04076887294650078, 0.003379636676982045, 0.034154534339904785, -0.08417008817195892, -0.026669297367334366, -0.0335531160235405, -0.012407761067152023, -0.05295922979712486, 0.06435458362102509, 0.06064404174685478, -0.00614948570728302, -0.030973363667726517, 0.016575738787651062, 0.07897356897592545, 0.00916200503706932, -0.021578917279839516, 0.013493492268025875, 0.04264264926314354, 0.00880734808743, 0.0649990662932396, 0.019621247425675392, -0.004476536065340042, 0.0241859033703804, 0.03299066796898842, -0.004082206636667252, 0.018518496304750443, -0.011954388581216335, 0.024295836687088013, -0.050598111003637314, -0.01845177635550499, 0.008687233552336693, 0.007395748980343342, 0.012804713100194931, 0.03898085653781891, 0.007805867586284876, 0.019621968269348145, -0.008007796481251717, 0.002881030086427927, -0.03369298204779625, 0.0334506519138813, 0.006504107266664505, -0.01553706917911768, 0.01660345122218132, -0.017476312816143036, -0.03946344554424286, -0.025124771520495415, 0.08248183131217957, 0.015185865573585033, 0.053792260587215424, -0.028039906173944473, -0.022228088229894638, -0.026146816089749336, -0.029137855395674706, -0.01531969103962183, 0.01611228846013546, -0.014688187278807163, -0.019140684977173805, 0.03903740271925926, 0.03667660802602768, -0.028521021828055382, 0.0658850222826004, -0.002902157371863723, 0.0013518623309209943, 0.029712600633502007, 0.05311260372400284, -0.005566129926592112, 0.010246130637824535, 0.0067649297416210175, 0.028117476031184196, -0.0061555784195661545, -0.07360409945249557, -0.026210440322756767, 0.01403455063700676, 0.037303805351257324, -0.06239154189825058, -0.017231130972504616, -0.034377798438072205, -0.01101632509380579, 0.035462766885757446, 0.009751059114933014, -0.047401562333106995, -0.02225993014872074, 0.019534243270754814, 0.011410681530833244, -0.0363861620426178, 0.027526313439011574, 0.045659419149160385, 0.0272171963006258, -0.046493049710989, 0.06731218844652176, -0.04682597890496254, -0.052045613527297974, 0.01335228979587555, 0.011317657306790352, 0.008750680834054947, 0.014644667506217957, 0.052462417632341385, -0.009278775192797184, -0.03870473802089691, 0.03668491914868355, -0.03106706589460373, -0.0022675448562949896, 0.022556887939572334, 0.055219631642103195, 0.01089702919125557, -0.0007001643534749746, -0.04149450361728668, -0.050417929887771606, 0.02121373638510704, 0.036248426884412766, -0.013466010801494122, 0.061987947672605515, 0.0672105923295021, 0.01822032406926155, 0.004602181259542704, -0.04551044479012489, -0.015863867476582527, -0.03848898038268089, -0.04156772792339325, 0.023637283593416214, 0.057267509400844574, 0.06135124713182449, 0.006267883349210024, -0.016754696145653725, 0.03590370714664459, 0.014074361883103848, -0.000851154385600239, 0.024851983413100243, -0.025386065244674683, 0.04910621419548988, 0.035025060176849365, -0.005805522203445435, 0.001173225580714643, 0.028957532718777657, 0.012859564274549484, 0.047638241201639175, -0.00989591609686613, 0.03142036125063896, -0.02795400843024254, -0.033868465572595596, -0.006547284312546253, -0.04132400080561638, -0.00798700749874115, -0.002237489679828286, 0.019150322303175926, -0.016908781602978706, -0.012567305006086826, -0.009154128842055798, 0.059052400290966034, 0.024086974561214447, 0.036709513515233994, -0.03195706754922867, 0.035015903413295746, -0.04664549604058266, -0.012992681935429573, 0.00871635228395462, -0.0082679633051157, -0.017624493688344955, 0.024360641837120056, 0.054708223789930344, 0.008523056283593178, 0.015277876518666744, -0.048060111701488495, 0.0656304806470871, -0.02235603518784046, 0.03779821842908859, 0.04219366982579231, -0.038438212126493454, -0.02431594207882881, 0.009192348457872868, 0.00714111328125, 0.06868505477905273, 0.04801382124423981, 0.04321878403425217, 0.011936305090785027, -0.006072262767702341, -0.02727094478905201, -0.03765992447733879, -0.010400761850178242, 0.0056929378770291805, -0.01198002602905035, -0.042740598320961, -0.00018803177226800472, 0.03104977309703827, 0.09491314738988876, 0.01013010274618864, -0.039302244782447815, -0.034146249294281006, -0.036031417548656464, -0.02354457601904869, -0.039307449012994766, -0.05120069906115532, -0.04478146508336067, 0.0015361286932602525, 0.04163097217679024, -0.05402214452624321, 0.02179856225848198, 0.010340078733861446, -0.016913028433918953, 0.006915710866451263, -0.05962316319346428, 0.01726929284632206, -0.04503225162625313, 0.030327191576361656, -0.014490640722215176, -0.012297256849706173, -0.0016989358700811863, -0.06645673513412476, -0.01655283384025097, 0.06033607944846153, -0.005577408708631992, 0.034122951328754425, -0.005842261947691441, 0.014621543698012829, -0.03551827371120453, 0.008318022824823856, 0.015212763100862503, 0.01950865052640438, -0.015788910910487175, -0.006556301843374968, 0.013118399307131767, -0.043125219643116, 0.006885778158903122, -0.013244161382317543, 0.004133857786655426, 0.09432241320610046, 0.02954760193824768, -0.0007797044818289578, -0.007469445466995239, 0.02454923838376999, -0.03164971247315407, -0.006766210775822401, -0.030355656519532204, 0.03271941468119621, 0.03520847484469414, -0.021964455023407936, -0.017260026186704636, -0.008090264163911343, -0.00914798304438591, -0.04783083125948906, 0.04316391423344612, 0.04157674312591553, 0.07454724609851837, 0.023041898384690285, -0.02495540678501129, -0.025088941678404808, 0.03791895508766174, 0.012827142141759396, 0.020441601052880287, 0.032888736575841904, 0.021065568551421165, 0.011684524826705456, 0.05151824280619621, 0.03215445950627327, 0.02505888231098652, -0.040111374109983444, 0.050961870700120926, 0.006902433931827545, 0.07313880324363708, 0.0064813862554728985, 0.021329492330551147, -0.01596437208354473, 0.06076660752296448, -0.02562122233211994, -0.016281858086586, 0.08056162297725677, 0.06372998654842377, -0.04009309783577919, -0.03819110244512558, 0.014324095100164413, 0.00945214182138443, -0.06531795859336853, 0.0620233453810215, -0.009444644674658775, 0.03423786535859108, 0.002498326823115349, 0.004358346574008465, 0.011995247565209866, 0.017085811123251915, 0.034463152289390564, -0.007733219303190708, 0.01649077609181404, 0.03906024247407913, 0.014095527119934559, -0.04059452936053276, -0.013205107301473618, -0.03644966706633568, -0.016517773270606995, 0.029887057840824127, 0.03151797130703926, 0.031892839819192886, 0.031054366379976273, 0.02739960141479969, -0.04062943905591965, 0.05205637589097023, -0.062216371297836304, -0.018779482692480087, -0.04563833773136139, -0.07283389568328857, -0.05517597123980522, 0.023422574624419212, -0.050056956708431244, 0.09634276479482651, 0.02434014528989792, -0.024239515885710716, -0.039450857788324356, 0.03802772983908653, 0.04185106232762337, -0.08912529051303864, -0.00606334675103426, 0.020943470299243927, -0.007197362836450338, -0.009368316270411015, -0.02970869280397892, -0.0034908673260360956, -0.02526075206696987, 0.03151887282729149, 0.007679863832890987, 0.004234373569488525, -0.002793021034449339, -0.04056393355131149, 0.007139173336327076, -0.016064561903476715, 0.0026940596289932728, 0.013808785006403923, -0.0324641615152359, -0.08615648746490479, -0.007477303501218557, 0.010093449614942074, 0.049887776374816895, -0.04178880155086517, 0.04737493395805359, 0.003504582215100527, -0.015369798988103867, -0.011408897116780281, 0.08233879506587982, 0.00689653679728508, 0.011975139379501343, -0.03754625469446182, 0.035859365016222, 0.022961871698498726, -0.02864741161465645, 0.009138673543930054, 0.04258463531732559, -0.0030025048181414604, 0.06343095749616623, -0.049428340047597885, -0.04896719008684158, -0.01812831684947014, 0.04783997684717178, -0.051768094301223755, 0.0044174883514642715, -0.02978876419365406, -0.0354250892996788, 0.05899380147457123, -0.006403745152056217, -0.013400757685303688, 0.0741441398859024, 0.058515116572380066, 0.018814070150256157, -0.06803321093320847, 0.03226833790540695, 0.01789128966629505, -0.00432590814307332, 0.06166200339794159, -0.028661563992500305, -0.008053096011281013, -0.002145696897059679, 0.005219344515353441, -0.004175984766334295, 0.03969454765319824, -0.0025775933172553778, 0.010967736132442951, -0.029345372691750526, 0.021054310724139214, 0.03881681337952614, 0.04593036696314812, -0.03515324741601944, 0.040259819477796555, -0.014339295215904713, -0.018668565899133682, -0.047480273991823196, -0.011297947727143764, -0.01523632649332285, -0.03292359411716461, -0.029286930337548256, -0.050951357930898666, 0.016353227198123932, 0.025858744978904724, -0.05843985453248024, -0.007331480737775564, 0.039706867188215256, 0.024528641253709793, -0.07163529098033905, 0.03980604559183121, 0.011280998587608337, -0.06387941539287567, -0.022479860112071037, 0.05306946486234665, 0.009223243221640587, -0.036645784974098206, -0.03010018914937973, 0.00881303008645773, -0.014623931609094143, -0.020690662786364555, 0.0076661366038024426, -0.009540518745779991, -0.024621041491627693, -0.022042740136384964, 0.009642038494348526, 0.05440227687358856, -0.06910588592290878, -0.030072245746850967, -0.052211012691259384, 0.0029353818390518427, 0.007187974639236927, 0.034101452678442, 0.013285612687468529, -0.020764602348208427, -0.0025623615365475416, 0.036025941371917725, -0.040806934237480164, 0.023558203130960464, 0.039145130664110184, -0.009954259730875492, -0.047669973224401474, -0.004053356125950813, 0.003387951524928212, -0.03090566396713257, -0.08330611884593964, 0.001818520831875503, -0.027368659153580666, -0.024640534073114395, 0.03146924078464508, -0.03777827322483063, -0.011317326687276363, 0.03553414344787598, 0.04377521574497223, -0.02721548266708851, -0.04079677537083626, -0.010055080987513065, -0.039138153195381165, -0.011354133486747742, -0.03226540982723236, 0.019970005378127098, 0.013955875299870968, -0.028460467234253883, 0.02605198323726654, 0.00939859263598919, 0.01450427807867527, -0.022998932749032974, 0.02558707632124424, -0.013431782834231853, 0.019526245072484016, 0.008165356703102589, -0.06268908083438873, -0.03156173974275589, -0.0045602996833622456, -0.006544397212564945, 0.02396363578736782, 0.001164441928267479, -0.0635434091091156, -0.007904890924692154, 0.022369517013430595, 0.015552018769085407, 0.05641917884349823, -0.06583812087774277, 0.003031838685274124, 0.013746317476034164, -0.0018348655430600047, -0.007754656486213207, -0.02024819515645504, -0.004794127773493528, -0.059722114354372025, -0.07375454902648926, 0.0358717255294323, -0.011699024587869644, 0.051126107573509216, -0.00914347916841507, 0.05609786510467529, 0.003393761580809951, 0.018908396363258362, -0.08476369082927704, -0.035933803766965866, 0.05834949389100075, 0.0025445364881306887, 0.007328354753553867, 0.014112301170825958, 0.0642070546746254, -0.009290477260947227, -0.007811438292264938, 0.04746614769101143, -0.001235875068232417, 0.05148455500602722, 0.053876426070928574, -0.035975486040115356, -0.044457707554101944, 0.0014263448538258672, 0.030549144372344017, 0.024293987080454826, 0.008331047371029854, -0.05384378507733345, -0.028581254184246063, 0.04502177983522415, -0.07366113364696503, 0.0032548164017498493, 0.0398184172809124, -0.006673447787761688, -0.008035382255911827, -0.08497834950685501, 0.012132576666772366, 0.010759527795016766, -0.05810178443789482, 0.01210147887468338, -0.011431753635406494, 0.013189304620027542, -0.027834616601467133, 0.01420758105814457, -0.04120614379644394, -0.03826074302196503, -0.05709407478570938, 0.011090831831097603, -0.09679305553436279, 0.07051719725131989, -0.004519817419350147, 0.0037641364615410566, 0.03936878964304924, 0.020845625549554825, -0.03390857204794884, 0.03495152294635773, 0.0023519492242485285, -0.008123714476823807, 0.05215703323483467, 0.03539327159523964, -0.004404530394822359, 0.004617147613316774, 0.02311200648546219, -0.011136059649288654, 0.04905802756547928, 0.028664007782936096, -0.004267933778464794, -0.03800206631422043, 0.011274483054876328, 0.010348151437938213, -0.04521936923265457, 0.04912428557872772, -0.017312711104750633, -0.05426234379410744, -0.032325856387615204, -0.03865072876214981, 0.06643151491880417, 0.00810038112103939, 0.022201543673872948, -0.005411696620285511, -0.024711420759558678, -0.05328743904829025, -0.03384305164217949, -0.07594428211450577, 0.008977565914392471, 0.0007347448263317347, 0.04235749691724777, 0.06237047538161278, -0.021008657291531563, 0.031668148934841156, -0.032599564641714096, -0.009651883505284786, 0.02937893010675907, 0.03478659316897392, -0.007737189065665007, -0.0735010877251625, -0.022148890420794487, 0.04671477526426315, 0.03505275025963783, -0.009673581458628178, 0.056780856102705, 0.007187642622739077, -0.07900606840848923, -0.04363580420613289, 0.019615307450294495, -0.07404234260320663, -0.04276648536324501, -0.05470997095108032, -0.08056970685720444, 0.038518138229846954, -0.035856589674949646, 0.05479585751891136, 0.016308702528476715, 0.07217814773321152, -0.006623635068535805, -0.00574433384463191, -0.013618127442896366, -0.04054594412446022, -0.0788903757929802, -0.03681590408086777, -0.08268745988607407, 0.012106429785490036, -0.034655336290597916, 0.060370706021785736, -0.08021243661642075, 0.03803449124097824, -0.011746454983949661, -0.011040061712265015, -0.0060154348611831665, -0.06332720071077347, -0.004536331165581942, -0.02811741642653942, -0.0922621339559555, -0.01799100451171398, -0.011654338799417019, 0.009689811617136002, -0.014991896227002144, 0.007401249837130308, -0.07304500043392181, 0.05900135636329651, 0.003880502888932824, 0.0014003479154780507, -0.01153563428670168, -0.017269069328904152, -0.04799312353134155, 0.015695488080382347, -0.005633479915559292, -0.015102140605449677, -0.019078081473708153, -0.011380334384739399, -0.031189320608973503, 0.058661483228206635, -0.03645392134785652, -0.0036100996658205986, 0.003779815975576639, 0.04549674689769745, 0.033096812665462494, -0.006133748218417168, 0.019081372767686844, -0.03244411572813988, -0.04391291365027428, 0.002508395118638873, -0.08953959494829178, -0.020551545545458794, -0.07502192258834839, 0.03501007705926895, 0.014390252530574799, 0.05127457156777382, -0.011361952871084213, -0.02423364669084549, 0.017681654542684555, -0.03913261368870735, -0.04517188295722008, 0.02180110290646553, -0.028629686683416367, 0.03762829303741455, 0.05074630305171013, -0.010812006890773773, 0.029925070703029633, 0.004628194961696863 ]
<p>I have one categorical dichotomous dependent variable (yes/no - retention of newly learned words) and two independent variables - both are categorical. One independent variable is "delay between exposure and test" and has two levels (short time delay/week time delay). The other IV is "word type" and relates to the types of words children were exposed to - object label, colour label etc. I have run a binary logistic regression on my data (440 participants - 44 per condition of word type and time delay) using the "Enter" Method and defined both IVs as categorical using the categorical tab. The initial outputs - Block 0 "Variables not in the Equation", Block 1 Omnibus Tests of Model Coeffcients and the Hosmer and Lemeshow Test all suggest that the model is significant and the Block 1 Classification Table suggests there's been an 11% improvement in predicting the DV (when compared to the Block 0 classification table). Yet the Block 1 "Variables in the Equation" Table shows no main effect of either of the IVs nor an Interaction effect - and not by a long way (time delay p=0.37; word type p=0.37; Word type*Time Delay p=0.401. I don't know how to interpret this as all the examples I've seen in my book and online show at least one significant main effect when the model is significant. It also seems somewhat illogical for SPSS to report that the model is significant but that neither of the IVs are having a significant effect! Also, my data are quite clear and it seems very likely that there is a main effect of time delay. Retention of all word types except one fall from around 65% in the short delay to around 33% after one week. </p> <p>I have tried changing the indicator from first to last (ie from short delay to the week delay) for the time delay variable and concerningly the results change - I thought when the IV was dichotomous it didn't matter which of the categories was used as the control group (indicator). Even more of a concern, it produces a main effect of word type rather than time delay.</p> <p>I have used dummy coding and effectively treated each of my word type categories as different IVs and this produces completely different results. Again - this is a concern as I would expect very similar results since it should effectively be running the same data.</p> <p>Can anyone help?</p>
g33244
[ -0.023577211424708366, -0.0034786362666636705, 0.0017571577336639166, -0.028097983449697495, 0.008355267345905304, -0.015594284981489182, 0.04374244064092636, 0.037695396691560745, -0.019440295174717903, -0.01115535106509924, -0.021040096879005432, 0.04994456097483635, 0.03035220503807068, 0.05520709976553917, 0.01986839435994625, -0.0036116852425038815, 0.04173419997096062, -0.012188266962766647, -0.025089692324399948, -0.030413562431931496, 0.017116935923695564, 0.06281013786792755, 0.014139384962618351, 0.01527806930243969, -0.07090675085783005, -0.03494406118988991, 0.06151176244020462, -0.007115239277482033, -0.05756054446101189, 0.018194764852523804, -0.009009914472699165, -0.008948447182774544, 0.02235793136060238, 0.00540449284017086, -0.05966668948531151, 0.010532396845519543, 0.05040746554732323, 0.0007050501881167293, -0.008694285526871681, 0.02543770521879196, 0.01162062119692564, 0.029141053557395935, 0.061695728451013565, 0.009213906712830067, -0.06549831479787827, 0.00005770074494648725, -0.022310703992843628, -0.01113079022616148, 0.03122134879231453, 0.016478048637509346, 0.07722961902618408, 0.02177559956908226, 0.009165889583528042, 0.01074129156768322, 0.02852117270231247, -0.017299707978963852, 0.006659823469817638, 0.025449099019169807, -0.01165158860385418, 0.03394700959324837, 0.037770286202430725, -0.011975820176303387, -0.031432364135980606, 0.024744153022766113, 0.026625651866197586, 0.04433609917759895, -0.03204574063420296, 0.007662342861294746, -0.02390313148498535, -0.05042220652103424, -0.013071433641016483, -0.02049882337450981, 0.03440871462225914, -0.03975443169474602, 0.023922912776470184, -0.009432192891836166, 0.014774895273149014, -0.03533123433589935, 0.006206705700606108, 0.028892746195197105, -0.01455068588256836, 0.05497585982084274, 0.00022593657195102423, 0.06884527206420898, 0.014084169641137123, 0.016982270404696465, -0.04885460063815117, -0.021186329424381256, -0.06402193009853363, -0.006442781537771225, -0.010368430987000465, -0.020873652771115303, -0.09963726997375488, 0.04908832162618637, -0.006069948896765709, 0.027296775951981544, -0.009417956694960594, 0.03450605273246765, 0.013818246312439442, 0.027328621596097946, -0.03699452057480812, -0.0023537306115031242, -0.0031797457486391068, -0.03141363337635994, -0.029251860454678535, -0.014164934866130352, -0.047865744680166245, -0.015205087140202522, -0.044402312487363815, -0.025118796154856682, -0.027558593079447746, 0.0301183070987463, -0.08468102663755417, 0.03171037882566452, -0.054888345301151276, -0.05948087200522423, -0.04927569627761841, -0.0026608307380229235, -0.03751758858561516, -0.13014382123947144, -0.010672660544514656, 0.02344687096774578, 0.03279754891991615, 0.06348562240600586, -0.022244475781917572, -0.037406325340270996, -0.048121728003025055, 0.05772092565894127, 0.019567886367440224, -0.04540811479091644, -0.04233191907405853, 0.04423678666353226, -0.01714896596968174, 0.0638265311717987, 0.02713743783533573, -0.040645550936460495, 0.04082038253545761, 0.03964214399456978, -0.019202319905161858, 0.004908457864075899, 0.013172108680009842, 0.047388847917318344, 0.009816080331802368, -0.002159297000616789, -0.019399121403694153, 0.0252926554530859, 0.022439707070589066, -0.051144879311323166, 0.018768146634101868, -0.054740291088819504, 0.006831747479736805, 0.020497091114521027, -0.02349669672548771, 0.0012216659961268306, -0.10316472500562668, 0.0675022304058075, -0.016727427020668983, -0.023797784000635147, -0.022916043177247047, 0.04514821246266365, 0.0778123214840889, -0.04555924981832504, 0.009774677455425262, 0.0022112769074738026, -0.05140195041894913, -0.05290156602859497, 0.013416812755167484, -0.04180222749710083, -0.029680848121643066, -0.06442318856716156, -0.04248426482081413, -0.0053326222114264965, -0.0075014629401266575, 0.012664206326007843, 0.03760429471731186, -0.004059228580445051, 0.03747628256678581, -0.02178754284977913, 0.014085274189710617, 0.023995161056518555, -0.04517771303653717, -0.06266400218009949, -0.018319467082619667, -0.05392370745539665, -0.0017769956029951572, 0.04465606436133385, 0.0006104285130277276, 0.060522373765707016, -0.05678651109337807, 0.021975859999656677, -0.04639599844813347, -0.04297872632741928, 0.010555366985499859, -0.04126787185668945, -0.05039084330201149, -0.044513821601867676, 0.046144191175699234, -0.04104950278997421, -0.027190595865249634, -0.013656224124133587, -0.03253396973013878, 0.015676559880375862, 0.02008076012134552, 0.046140726655721664, -0.024282800033688545, -0.006005328614264727, -0.003953037317842245, 0.005672292783856392, -0.06476010382175446, -0.01648200862109661, 0.05331799015402794, -0.02746889367699623, -0.035569366067647934, 0.04930870980024338, 0.05002687871456146, -0.0868968591094017, -0.00014448404544964433, 0.036826565861701965, -0.017135174944996834, 0.028815900906920433, -0.04271405562758446, -0.03125583380460739, 0.027770262211561203, 0.008863307535648346, -0.011978602968156338, 0.003749158466234803, 0.0818648561835289, -0.02508569322526455, -0.054608192294836044, 0.006884068250656128, 0.013339320197701454, -0.006017506588250399, -0.0028600450605154037, -0.053113099187612534, 0.041971247643232346, -0.016896458342671394, 0.05054416507482529, -0.013985998928546906, -0.008287187665700912, -0.007061258424073458, 0.002657831646502018, -0.0164977815002203, 0.013062792830169201, 0.04335227981209755, 0.010955075733363628, -0.033539485186338425, 0.03562421724200249, -0.031059468165040016, -0.0005157996783964336, 0.04646756500005722, -0.07196033746004105, 0.04663346707820892, -0.02900724671781063, -0.062091629952192307, 0.02343902736902237, -0.001109435805119574, 0.027528725564479828, -0.012707486748695374, -0.04271813854575157, -0.027265150099992752, -0.03993159905076027, -0.011019783094525337, 0.07523460686206818, 0.00444659311324358, -0.013989880681037903, -0.012752526439726353, 0.0002924253058154136, -0.01731852814555168, 0.00036669778637588024, -0.04286514222621918, -0.05963944271206856, 0.0073789446614682674, -0.007564356550574303, -0.013647746294736862, -0.011210341937839985, 0.0748826190829277, -0.06550246477127075, 0.002230477286502719, -0.01390801090747118, -0.003565862076357007, 0.03797877952456474, -0.023310817778110504, -0.012951118871569633, -0.022285759449005127, 0.054528139531612396, 0.05353211611509323, 0.014354544691741467, 0.03031041845679283, -0.026135478168725967, -0.016842612996697426, -0.011277359910309315, 0.06080573424696922, 0.014033319428563118, 0.004181088879704475, 0.04719933867454529, -0.0041626207530498505, -0.044659219682216644, -0.028133640065789223, -0.02544434927403927, 0.002489690203219652, 0.0017936666263267398, -0.030746720731258392, 0.012698153033852577, 0.03430117666721344, 0.05212441831827164, -0.08423188328742981, -0.02501600794494152, 0.016561590135097504, 0.005697404965758324, -0.03662104904651642, -0.03062266856431961, -0.036254316568374634, 0.004338743630796671, -0.019521623849868774, -0.009367257356643677, -0.028365058824419975, 0.021443255245685577, 0.01571115292608738, 0.01651763543486595, -0.011730840429663658, 0.03574096038937569, 0.023717083036899567, -0.004902398679405451, 0.08660478889942169, -0.061602428555488586, 0.008354181423783302, 0.04835476353764534, 0.00003810214911936782, -0.011247998103499413, 0.018802518025040627, 0.031332600861787796, 0.01772483065724373, 0.08241323381662369, -0.054233964532613754, 0.021949423477053642, -0.007825247012078762, 0.0028253423515707254, -0.012206630781292915, -0.04128796234726906, -0.018126778304576874, 0.02073185332119465, 0.008251883089542389, 0.0005575050017796457, 0.029628880321979523, 0.014892805367708206, -0.04974690079689026, -0.007928178645670414, -0.043744418770074844, -0.05695243924856186, 0.03221800923347473, 0.022496363148093224, 0.01812320575118065, -0.011869393289089203, -0.04423157498240471, -0.00438719941303134, -0.013468579389154911, 0.06431296467781067, 0.0043573505245149136, -0.05817354470491409, 0.026868823915719986, -0.01149502582848072, -0.020475490018725395, -0.02960347943007946, -0.008778223767876625, -0.03667351230978966, 0.06218855455517769, 0.05396962910890579, 0.05891820415854454, 0.0195063054561615, -0.013646750710904598, 0.035167645663022995, 0.03322824463248253, -0.03478022292256355, -0.03199150040745735, 0.04563143476843834, -0.000934917014092207, 0.05224708095192909, 0.03573411703109741, -0.052001968026161194, 0.024671992287039757, 0.009679608978331089, -0.054142065346241, 0.01937350630760193, 0.07519935071468353, -0.004017867613583803, -0.04467950388789177, 0.03392167016863823, 0.006948824506253004, 0.010318967513740063, -0.0019692222122102976, 0.026313116773962975, 0.07016067951917648, -0.02963561750948429, 0.07582388818264008, -0.007563312072306871, 0.028965389356017113, 0.013800187036395073, 0.062227632850408554, 0.011488698422908783, 0.0010870374972000718, -0.011566853150725365, 0.002349568996578455, -0.022281521931290627, 0.010346094146370888, 0.0011796212056651711, -0.01682208850979805, 0.049909479916095734, -0.000496156862936914, -0.082461878657341, 0.009014890529215336, 0.017001161351799965, -0.04233664646744728, -0.053133536130189896, -0.002001040382310748, -0.04583233594894409, -0.004767748527228832, 0.048434577882289886, 0.023861905559897423, -0.024358699098229408, 0.04782837629318237, 0.0412011593580246, 0.08544120192527771, -0.05226568505167961, 0.010772386565804482, 0.07191696763038635, -0.02299446240067482, -0.000654429430142045, 0.02343449555337429, -0.0034330354537814856, 0.0023431151639670134, 0.012532818131148815, 0.054913587868213654, -0.017613941803574562, 0.02311030402779579, 0.029343562200665474, 0.0636875107884407, -0.01875949464738369, 0.0446772575378418, 0.023324161767959595, 0.038099564611911774, 0.04059436917304993, -0.007440114393830299, -0.02586752362549305, -0.008848689496517181, 0.06955499202013016, 0.03242019563913345, -0.002808295888826251, -0.041783470660448074, 0.06028679385781288, 0.009473769925534725, -0.04797575995326042, 0.11569221317768097, 0.03547424450516701, -0.03541634976863861, 0.054143186658620834, 0.026033472269773483, 0.03780224174261093, 0.03278041258454323, 0.04044223949313164, 0.05019287392497063, -0.012769930064678192, -0.0005417087231762707, -0.018933633342385292, -0.012561051174998283, -0.03153413161635399, -0.07904805988073349, -0.03804323449730873, -0.005020554177463055, -0.037419795989990234, -0.003702912013977766, 0.017123926430940628, -0.05343763157725334, 0.02299468033015728, 0.02410382404923439, 0.014499948360025883, 0.0852409303188324, -0.02621244266629219, -0.00949911680072546, 0.019723687320947647, 0.003908155951648951, -0.008281141519546509, -0.008804787881672382, 0.03441706672310829, 0.014457933604717255, 0.04906631261110306, 0.01261740829795599, -0.05584140866994858, -0.022558411583304405, 0.023975836113095284, -0.010731073096394539, 0.052955787628889084, 0.011988397687673569, -0.008678168058395386, -0.0030445526354014874, -0.010330474935472012, 0.016681931912899017, 0.0378139391541481, -0.010239611379802227, -0.01272579189389944, -0.02874322235584259, 0.007438666187226772, 0.004083631560206413, 0.06432731449604034, -0.022854352369904518, -0.0408291332423687, 0.007295503281056881, 0.04267044737935066, 0.018702881410717964, -0.0059384978376328945, 0.024100666865706444, -0.012141410261392593, 0.03160766139626503, 0.023029407486319542, 0.026885967701673508, -0.05293845385313034, 0.028320247307419777, 0.017936894670128822, 0.014106987975537777, 0.026200195774435997, -0.007911753840744495, 0.006214728578925133, 0.0009440046269446611, 0.038511645048856735, 0.07954885065555573, 0.045627716928720474, 0.0036910593044012785, 0.0040483055636286736, -0.0562051385641098, 0.01934269815683365, -0.019419321790337563, -0.02141595631837845, 0.0017926606815308332, 0.002512110397219658, 0.03269342705607414, 0.03811532258987427, -0.05838916450738907, -0.015613825991749763, 0.00452775601297617, -0.0070896088145673275, -0.029751645401120186, -0.07582142949104309, -0.01896018721163273, -0.04196283221244812, -0.039334118366241455, 0.06582308560609818, -0.005739796441048384, -0.007946847006678581, -0.06251775473356247, 0.04402565956115723, -0.009449418634176254, 0.008250606246292591, -0.043035175651311874, 0.031033098697662354, 0.02289336547255516, -0.027274448424577713, -0.040287505835294724, 0.031034741550683975, 0.017180053517222404, 0.015543963760137558, -0.03920287638902664, -0.06466633826494217, 0.010174166411161423, -0.0327627994120121, 0.009735282510519028, 0.02197321131825447, -0.012757206335663795, -0.028511887416243553, -0.007297737989574671, 0.0031539644114673138, 0.010884382762014866, 0.09250200539827347, -0.05724901333451271, 0.01605447754263878, 0.004561732988804579, 0.005996750667691231, -0.03503633663058281, 0.029273273423314095, 0.015388110652565956, 0.011206778697669506, 0.051475804299116135, -0.011917874217033386, -0.035326555371284485, 0.0016753390664234757, 0.03178517520427704, -0.009539131075143814, -0.020191306248307228, -0.002372825751081109, -0.027750547975301743, -0.037439022213220596, 0.018372422084212303, -0.024249447509646416, -0.01602628454566002, 0.030434686690568924, -0.012988267466425896, -0.009595921263098717, -0.03270721435546875, -0.04539816826581955, 0.04132571071386337, -0.01868588477373123, -0.026216518133878708, -0.031486667692661285, -0.03800505772233009, 0.03563791885972023, 0.02044885978102684, 0.07679098844528198, -0.04083161801099777, -0.05918741598725319, 0.027138641104102135, 0.017475871369242668, 0.06740348786115646, -0.07404308021068573, 0.011732535436749458, 0.015127078630030155, 0.03406594321131706, 0.0314389206469059, -0.05688394978642464, -0.042019762098789215, 0.004034760408103466, -0.02910734713077545, -0.014486712403595448, 0.012517808005213737, 0.018957410007715225, 0.01608053781092167, -0.045485951006412506, 0.013975460082292557, 0.03432907909154892, -0.03268257528543472, -0.02553846314549446, -0.05537862703204155, 0.06627406179904938, -0.009082586504518986, -0.045177217572927475, -0.04915674030780792, 0.014516767114400864, -0.055222950875759125, 0.020946674048900604, -0.057114098221063614, 0.06548279523849487, -0.004019870422780514, 0.005689122714102268, 0.01845184527337551, 0.03128296881914139, -0.025365740060806274, 0.030453477054834366, 0.03603387251496315, 0.02670607902109623, 0.05278952419757843, 0.026985231786966324, -0.014219556003808975, 0.018868636339902878, -0.0024786898866295815, 0.0642828494310379, 0.009497673250734806, -0.05185868963599205, 0.06904198974370956, -0.0776328444480896, 0.017980732023715973, 0.02611897513270378, 0.011693772859871387, 0.04945551976561546, -0.05350976437330246, -0.07734478265047073, -0.09798842668533325, 0.008037345483899117, -0.004541060887277126, 0.017478588968515396, -0.04065089300274849, -0.025848127901554108, 0.04432271048426628, 0.007659535389393568, -0.011985214427113533, -0.027837516739964485, 0.017056146636605263, 0.0025975811295211315, 0.05866825208067894, 0.00017433050379622728, -0.005663840100169182, -0.03181880712509155, -0.051345452666282654, 0.015425038523972034, -0.030991261824965477, -0.015802940353751183, 0.019581379368901253, 0.05535726249217987, 0.004022587556391954, 0.003304762300103903, -0.025165194645524025, -0.021353181451559067, 0.0018182209460064769, -0.003801449202001095, -0.006400128826498985, -0.03255418315529823, 0.019596487283706665, 0.048555560410022736, -0.006808344274759293, -0.0036686649546027184, 0.02619965560734272, 0.07729879021644592, 0.000616561621427536, 0.04742659628391266, 0.008632977493107319, 0.03422066196799278, -0.007220330648124218, 0.03985369950532913, 0.054477717727422714, 0.023540155962109566, -0.03404008224606514, -0.03994143754243851, -0.010524217039346695, -0.024646267294883728, -0.03076888807117939, 0.009992865845561028, -0.004335350356996059, 0.05212848260998726, -0.03447231650352478, -0.04489943012595177, -0.003735495498403907, -0.037419985979795456, -0.04950171709060669, 0.0865941271185875, -0.04679936543107033, -0.04772970452904701, -0.0031007223296910524, 0.006791483610868454, 0.02698306366801262, -0.04607134684920311, -0.018234850838780403, -0.02476496621966362, 0.0011052407789975405, -0.034515488892793655, -0.07134883850812912, -0.008518152870237827, -0.07054074853658676, 0.03126166760921478, 0.02260095439851284, 0.031559862196445465, 0.07169782370328903, -0.02355429343879223, -0.11265654861927032, 0.0033286765683442354, 0.019917327910661697, -0.013967590406537056, -0.0027005155570805073, 0.021652264520525932, -0.04270920157432556, -0.013152537867426872, 0.025002621114253998, 0.01103422325104475, 0.02625615894794464, -0.03884221240878105, 0.005921273957937956, -0.035047538578510284, -0.039175353944301605, 0.01975816674530506, -0.027882156893610954, 0.04784592241048813, -0.05586305633187294, -0.01628982648253441, 0.00341586209833622, -0.008617596700787544, -0.023838140070438385, 0.005971135105937719, -0.026072850450873375, 0.05360493063926697, 0.024323053658008575, -0.006227409932762384, 0.05551763251423836, -0.005647636950016022 ]
<p>I need help with the following question:</p> <p>Consider $m$ observations $(y_1; n_1); ... ; (y_m; n_m)$, where $y_i \sim Bin(n_i; θ_i)$ are binomial variables. Assume that $θ_i \sim w_1Beta(α_1; β_1) + w_2Beta(α_2; β_2)$ are mixture from two Beta distributions $(w_1 + w_2 = 1)$. </p> <ul> <li>Derive a Laplace approximation of the likelihood and each mixture component of the prior. </li> <li>Derive the empirical Bayes likelihood of the data by integrating out i using the Laplace approximation, and leave the hyper-parameters $(w_j ; α_j ; β_j)$ (j = 1; 2) </li> <li>Derive the EM algorithm to estimate the hyperparameters (you may use also mixture of Gaussian prior to approximate mixture of Beta prior)</li> </ul>
g48384
[ 0.012933444231748581, -0.039625611156225204, 0.003506413195282221, -0.042625028640031815, -0.027262596413493156, 0.005959939211606979, 0.027855603024363518, 0.008417106233537197, -0.058974869549274445, -0.0011971943313255906, -0.015164352022111416, 0.038375988602638245, 0.013032721355557442, 0.037651609629392624, 0.012401776388287544, -0.007551239337772131, 0.03616946190595627, -0.0038860305212438107, 0.0028965137898921967, -0.053378939628601074, -0.048316504806280136, 0.0008891281322576106, 0.001214224030263722, 0.00629187747836113, 0.017216553911566734, -0.01687127724289894, -0.024364283308386803, 0.0232761912047863, -0.04403072968125343, 0.005766612943261862, -0.03396058455109596, -0.021493986248970032, 0.04460146278142929, -0.045946408063173294, 0.020180515944957733, -0.0010264369193464518, 0.02002824656665325, -0.02625664696097374, -0.011212904006242752, -0.014716419391334057, -0.008894179947674274, 0.0452350415289402, 0.062244072556495667, 0.03833862021565437, -0.013109470717608929, 0.013978317379951477, -0.008520223200321198, -0.03113590180873871, 0.020933181047439575, 0.030771801248192787, 0.022370653226971626, 0.02385449968278408, 0.0008398142526857555, -0.0009098000009544194, 0.039809878915548325, 0.042691875249147415, 0.06597164273262024, -0.060109395533800125, 0.04734254628419876, -0.006313937716186047, 0.02580583468079567, -0.0872206762433052, -0.10982156544923782, -0.018994398415088654, -0.006604738999158144, 0.0021405923180282116, -0.0179922915995121, -0.022844327613711357, 0.019628312438726425, -0.0210739616304636, 0.04638933017849922, 0.02518720179796219, 0.0081810113042593, -0.06678567826747894, -0.003196767996996641, -0.048399023711681366, 0.02455584891140461, 0.027737591415643692, -0.00005265781146590598, 0.06752552837133408, 0.02326711267232895, 0.0815844014286995, 0.0623709075152874, 0.01463609654456377, -0.011584488674998283, -0.022197682410478592, 0.03519738093018532, 0.011316034942865372, 0.016570860520005226, -0.05843059718608856, 0.024869440123438835, 0.004757968243211508, 0.011478092521429062, 0.021624142304062843, 0.008090856485068798, -0.013305572792887688, -0.11157830059528351, 0.014148551039397717, 0.013250255957245827, -0.007671566214412451, 0.04633159562945366, 0.008044692687690258, 0.032924942672252655, -0.04748095944523811, -0.03547627478837967, -0.002235088497400284, 0.016187600791454315, -0.02931825816631317, -0.045418333262205124, 0.03116689622402191, -0.0566672682762146, -0.018177013844251633, 0.007391796912997961, -0.07222186774015427, -0.017137838527560234, -0.01688304916024208, -0.008630633354187012, -0.024776730686426163, 0.00941604282706976, 0.03535831719636917, -0.04093227908015251, 0.023059207946062088, -0.040539100766181946, 0.0061431522481143475, -0.039880212396383286, 0.017028195783495903, -0.03951506316661835, 0.018229201436042786, 0.05441221967339516, 0.002909513423219323, 0.006761045660823584, -0.04202151298522949, 0.049875855445861816, -0.01750859245657921, -0.03417675569653511, 0.00646616704761982, 0.016726955771446228, 0.027537070214748383, 0.020175402984023094, 0.07354205846786499, -0.03321034088730812, -0.021241571754217148, 0.0521271675825119, -0.05327152460813522, -0.013665425591170788, 0.08743546903133392, 0.0033023753203451633, -0.03898924961686134, -0.05301353707909584, 0.041770219802856445, -0.037420447915792465, 0.0362233929336071, 0.05302909389138222, 0.1000150814652443, -0.04130716621875763, 0.011295764707028866, -0.009990602731704712, -0.006793438456952572, 0.020876459777355194, -0.05946500599384308, 0.030303003266453743, -0.02795536071062088, 0.014601089991629124, -0.006410189904272556, -0.014127667993307114, 0.019995804876089096, -0.011068176478147507, -0.022415611892938614, 0.013167397119104862, -0.015451956540346146, 0.00591364735737443, 0.004569602198898792, 0.004581112880259752, 0.016853032633662224, 0.0010330788791179657, 0.052636053413152695, -0.02460714988410473, 0.011492796242237091, 0.00028984181699343026, 0.08788995444774628, 0.0333574004471302, 0.050987087190151215, 0.012953397817909718, -0.07913316786289215, 0.003838821081444621, -0.08998488634824753, -0.014306214638054371, 0.044795792549848557, -0.04881787672638893, -0.03677580878138542, 0.01397175807505846, 0.009366790764033794, -0.02360805682837963, -0.06552693247795105, -0.0033067960757762194, 0.03996727615594864, 0.0854157954454422, -0.06065591424703598, 0.03909313306212425, 0.008959654718637466, -0.054288823157548904, 0.025799725204706192, 0.027333395555615425, 0.015402753837406635, -0.00030135782435536385, 0.0010586166754364967, 0.01342818234115839, -0.017390292137861252, -0.033894430845975876, 0.01840839348733425, -0.09977352619171143, -0.023365439847111702, 0.015009282156825066, 0.0010940727079287171, 0.014693288132548332, -0.01646948792040348, 0.015123993158340454, 0.015176070854067802, 0.008855975233018398, -0.02281317114830017, -0.06128702312707901, -0.020308474078774452, 0.07301129400730133, -0.03732657805085182, 0.02704090066254139, 0.02508244477212429, 0.04109324514865875, 0.04335953667759895, -0.005711115896701813, 0.032727427780628204, -0.006690328940749168, -0.017286457121372223, 0.04243602603673935, -0.012633919715881348, 0.03586527332663536, 0.03182167932391167, -0.02965114265680313, 0.035360753536224365, 0.0053490279242396355, 0.028775082901120186, 0.021212507039308548, 0.06063678860664368, 0.012624058872461319, 0.021967701613903046, 0.0019462539348751307, 0.016436902806162834, 0.04520045220851898, -0.02780308574438095, 0.03714849799871445, -0.031424615532159805, -0.07377316802740097, 0.020166520029306412, -0.029430482536554337, -0.01709454506635666, -0.02510334737598896, -0.009451394900679588, 0.0186870489269495, 0.03150002658367157, -0.028220856562256813, 0.0099600525572896, -0.004780071321874857, -0.01576794683933258, 0.012406256049871445, -0.02758566103875637, 0.014495674520730972, 0.013665423728525639, 0.007630830630660057, -0.04815392196178436, 0.0387650690972805, 0.037084516137838364, 0.05254045128822327, -0.012780078686773777, -0.019638042896986008, 0.026878181844949722, -0.0012566789519041777, -0.014769292436540127, -0.022004809230566025, -0.014680705033242702, 0.023234134539961815, 0.0017221252201125026, -0.05195670947432518, -0.12067229300737381, -0.028660612180829048, 0.0007983624236658216, -0.029901783913373947, -0.038751374930143356, 0.06536441296339035, 0.03202103450894356, 0.04177865386009216, 0.024986734613776207, 0.038656312972307205, 0.03190154954791069, 0.017403598874807358, 0.031228119507431984, 0.016265369951725006, 0.006509894505143166, 0.05532042309641838, 0.0029806916136294603, 0.027268361300230026, 0.00005575989416684024, -0.015539723448455334, 0.021092355251312256, -0.011055056005716324, -0.06810346990823746, 0.04690834879875183, -0.02772301807999611, 0.006110224407166243, -0.03569728508591652, 0.00959314126521349, -0.025891974568367004, 0.023555034771561623, -0.06493625789880753, -0.04914276301860809, -0.038634974509477615, 0.031243685632944107, -0.0065279435366392136, 0.0028279139660298824, -0.04246849566698074, -0.007710377220064402, -0.029042817652225494, 0.011633732356131077, -0.016588710248470306, -0.017217274755239487, -0.00950135849416256, 0.01935848966240883, -0.029285775497555733, -0.03123648278415203, 0.024075811728835106, -0.019681865349411964, 0.002838104497641325, 0.06498273462057114, -0.015005015768110752, 0.055256474763154984, 0.000223840688704513, 0.045054350048303604, -0.07147965580224991, -0.012925644405186176, 0.028055932372808456, -0.05896512791514397, 0.012109730392694473, 0.01506033819168806, 0.012708031572401524, -0.01589713804423809, -0.005053992383182049, 0.01581580936908722, -0.07030553370714188, 0.006993473507463932, 0.06233000382781029, -0.0023561925627291203, -0.03971293568611145, 0.015342521481215954, 0.031237147748470306, 0.0503520593047142, -0.01383911818265915, -0.021455176174640656, 0.04269896075129509, 0.015120944939553738, -0.034077465534210205, 0.029643850401043892, 0.0008671905961818993, 0.044027864933013916, -0.08441528677940369, 0.0033425360452383757, 0.026479311287403107, -0.007288811728358269, -0.08137068152427673, 0.04068174585700035, 0.11542651057243347, -0.022611968219280243, 0.02303595468401909, 0.010271783918142319, 0.04278615117073059, 0.04052285477519035, -0.006791914347559214, -0.009407902136445045, -0.05075933411717415, 0.07881306856870651, -0.0002914709330070764, -0.0092058340087533, 0.01497104112058878, 0.0315256230533123, 0.030565336346626282, -0.0060242475010454655, 0.07457727193832397, 0.07881488651037216, -0.04457072913646698, 0.019506528973579407, -0.007386249024420977, 0.04750856012105942, -0.09365812689065933, 0.05556250363588333, -0.07484009116888046, -0.035936757922172546, -0.0067792898043990135, -0.01995428279042244, -0.046493593603372574, 0.0024460647255182266, -0.012734267860651016, 0.008197491057217121, 0.028038769960403442, -0.01630561612546444, 0.05844037979841232, 0.0481727197766304, 0.049942679703235626, 0.014231289736926556, 0.00915609858930111, -0.08249467611312866, 0.0025722957216203213, 0.03238138556480408, 0.045601412653923035, 0.03673649951815605, 0.004009188152849674, 0.03906058147549629, -0.05716167762875557, -0.004354401491582394, -0.0008044421556405723, 0.06186836585402489, -0.041237398982048035, -0.029527563601732254, 0.004888582043349743, -0.07385285198688507, -0.018469614908099174, -0.08775579929351807, -0.06838769465684891, 0.01138973981142044, 0.016428764909505844, 0.05583235248923302, -0.029520440846681595, 0.011517642065882683, -0.04707667976617813, 0.015036816708743572, -0.0050085000693798065, 0.007089248392730951, 0.06493964046239853, -0.015048853121697903, -0.0525667741894722, 0.0014219401637092233, -0.03691396117210388, -0.027910077944397926, -0.034225866198539734, 0.005044606514275074, -0.029405958950519562, -0.03809649497270584, 0.022236164659261703, 0.04044632986187935, 0.050850871950387955, -0.004967928864061832, -0.045601554214954376, 0.06153210252523422, 0.038975805044174194, -0.0021787970326840878, 0.015180951915681362, 0.04318293184041977, -0.0019827894866466522, 0.028211504220962524, 0.0085753807798028, -0.011307398788630962, 0.03054135851562023, -0.020742813125252724, 0.04227406531572342, 0.02924513816833496, 0.016568811610341072, -0.0020121210254728794, 0.02561538852751255, -0.017924031242728233, -0.020129498094320297, -0.06834730505943298, -0.023991873487830162, 0.04195020720362663, 0.028241857886314392, -0.029750822111964226, 0.018008913844823837, 0.05578688904643059, -0.041065894067287445, 0.012022503651678562, 0.009386279620230198, -0.08631822466850281, -0.015115154907107353, 0.014134912751615047, 0.052346788346767426, -0.007729501463472843, 0.0390225313603878, -0.042266845703125, 0.002583978697657585, -0.03987788036465645, -0.009562557563185692, 0.044993720948696136, -0.0635431706905365, 0.06340868026018143, -0.020660443231463432, -0.0029870399739593267, 0.06708289682865143, 0.05521925538778305, -0.0008756538154557347, 0.029690518975257874, -0.07669949531555176, 0.07363665848970413, 0.0289317574352026, -0.018355606123805046, 0.036183394491672516, -0.07847259938716888, 0.007426755037158728, -0.006338748149573803, 0.009188010357320309, 0.04534194618463516, 0.026700057089328766, 0.01751640811562538, 0.015402973629534245, -0.029431357979774475, 0.03570159524679184, 0.0013557134661823511, 0.007849575020372868, 0.026373786851763725, 0.005594287998974323, -0.018914371728897095, -0.012877003289759159, 0.05510111153125763, 0.09213006496429443, -0.0025014691054821014, -0.04428720846772194, 0.06938301026821136, 0.0058632493019104, 0.012794706970453262, 0.013254710473120213, 0.0030185317154973745, -0.07226763665676117, -0.03304870054125786, 0.00010934758756775409, -0.0781727209687233, -0.05742954835295677, -0.042346660047769547, -0.0069170426577329636, -0.05177264288067818, -0.031498655676841736, 0.018494725227355957, -0.019350741058588028, -0.014441902749240398, -0.039293501526117325, 0.00605449452996254, 0.05448932945728302, -0.009859751909971237, -0.024658571928739548, 0.0539456270635128, -0.037270061671733856, -0.015744494274258614, 0.03225496783852577, -0.0038176693487912416, 0.001318079885095358, 0.02288683131337166, -0.000023623664674232714, 0.04253518953919411, -0.000026766954761114903, 0.0236501581966877, -0.028125835582613945, -0.04247395694255829, -0.007175658363848925, -0.0203255582600832, -0.020189765840768814, -0.04763320833444595, 0.01952957920730114, -0.002808595774695277, -0.08008549362421036, 0.026528993621468544, 0.00897734984755516, 0.014704032801091671, -0.024898655712604523, 0.01020118873566389, 0.008735817857086658, -0.021242300048470497, 0.04725387319922447, -0.022298939526081085, -0.020496774464845657, 0.025679798796772957, 0.041374571621418, 0.035947877913713455, 0.006255603861063719, 0.025408541783690453, -0.010546637699007988, 0.01897595450282097, -0.03176364302635193, -0.041237667202949524, -0.021030189469456673, -0.006565254647284746, 0.00850845966488123, -0.00025230503524653614, 0.021647922694683075, -0.05941115692257881, 0.02751140296459198, -0.05385984107851982, -0.08550482243299484, 0.019152410328388214, 0.0026580989360809326, -0.0033165086060762405, -0.03164803609251976, -0.0023004834074527025, 0.04359523206949234, -0.03690739721059799, 0.02781670168042183, -0.009469923563301563, -0.029236145317554474, 0.02358398586511612, -0.057471029460430145, 0.02082247845828533, -0.0043668425641953945, -0.002308106981217861, -0.03070017136633396, -0.017226282507181168, -0.02201901003718376, -0.0035092150792479515, -0.03691571578383446, 0.0008232363616116345, 0.006536790169775486, 0.0019448541570454836, 0.052515994757413864, -0.020859258249402046, -0.020904678851366043, -0.06104099750518799, 0.02009625919163227, -0.03299122303724289, 0.040198586881160736, 0.0356241799890995, -0.01926852948963642, -0.029358603060245514, -0.013942672871053219, -0.026886094361543655, -0.007972847670316696, 0.018174121156334877, -0.03523392975330353, 0.03233780711889267, 0.010238774120807648, 0.12074220180511475, -0.07821229100227356, -0.033373236656188965, 0.0062772189266979694, -0.0263182632625103, 0.05014640465378761, 0.001974717481061816, 0.049911562353372574, -0.007535555865615606, 0.07561580836772919, 0.035142406821250916, 0.02041436731815338, -0.032373540103435516, 0.04819377139210701, -0.006269496399909258, 0.034965891391038895, 0.013682625256478786, -0.010468972846865654, -0.03416620194911957, 0.05731220543384552, 0.024093052372336388, 0.04032159224152565, 0.04727435111999512, -0.011669280007481575, -0.04148947075009346, 0.008482218720018864, 0.013354032300412655, 0.017373135313391685, 0.03436717018485069, -0.022862043231725693, -0.05643787980079651, -0.008468649350106716, -0.045478224754333496, -0.009957000613212585, 0.02833258919417858, 0.02834368497133255, -0.05694244056940079, -0.0031349759083241224, -0.04738873615860939, -0.06271372735500336, -0.021899409592151642, -0.06478486955165863, -0.0169118270277977, 0.03661773353815079, -0.01649000681936741, -0.010449342429637909, 0.036895882338285446, 0.0016881508054211736, -0.03880957141518593, -0.013487571850419044, -0.02942504733800888, 0.01609238050878048, -0.07245880365371704, 0.029580948874354362, -0.021741174161434174, 0.010745846666395664, 0.01030811294913292, -0.0540337860584259, 0.030786002054810524, 0.018296198919415474, -0.035663723945617676, -0.04415789991617203, 0.030939046293497086, -0.02956082485616207, 0.0021887500770390034, 0.03881942853331566, 0.05354909226298332, -0.022553356364369392, -0.006946056615561247, 0.03136635571718216, -0.021628709509968758, -0.0015188574325293303, 0.00010957333142869174, -0.05166642367839813, -0.027763210237026215, -0.011785443872213364, 0.023713842034339905, -0.029033206403255463, 0.02432399056851864, -0.04002125933766365, -0.017715968191623688, 0.040479887276887894, -0.01930384896695614, -0.0037855354603379965, 0.028280219063162804, -0.04224735125899315, -0.05984555184841156, 0.01328861154615879, 0.013108449056744576, 0.0263359397649765, -0.02804218977689743, 0.03325917199254036, -0.005122371483594179, 0.006254737265408039, 0.0197919812053442, -0.08712440729141235, -0.019100448116660118, 0.007109661120921373, -0.004748327191919088, -0.011453816667199135, -0.017055818811058998, -0.04404085874557495, -0.06272290647029877, 0.021957674995064735, 0.017882077023386955, -0.006070038769394159, 0.03948730602860451, -0.007496521808207035, 0.010962393134832382, 0.022121740505099297, -0.03690604120492935, -0.014923907816410065, 0.04554584622383118, -0.04165097326040268, 0.004219591151922941, -0.018464574590325356, -0.030974432826042175, 0.019141171127557755, 0.012733381241559982, 0.016243884339928627, -0.024461951106786728, 0.02640587091445923, -0.040837615728378296, 0.07807333022356033, 0.023120587691664696, 0.011596841737627983, 0.048951681703329086, -0.0002684032660908997, -0.013427921570837498, 0.0009581021149642766, 0.0022089453414082527, -0.07813140749931335, -0.028170617297291756, 0.06507068127393723, -0.006618106737732887, 0.01578284613788128, 0.018739230930805206, 0.04540657997131348 ]
<p>I have a huge dataset (millions of rows, thousands of columns) and <code>glmnet</code> Lasso regularised regression is too slow.</p> <p>I am wondering what other libraries there are that try to implement regularised linear model estimation extremely efficiently? I don't necessarily need a distributed solution (it can estimate on one CPU), and it is fine for me to load all data to RAM (so an <code>R</code> solution may be fine, if one exists that's faster somehow than <code>glmnet</code>). It also does not necessarily need to be Lasso or Elastic Net.</p> <p>I can use java, python or R.</p> <p>My data is pretty messy, some columns are sparse, some have heavy autocorrelation, etc. </p>
g33249
[ 0.08644426614046097, -0.019742321223020554, 0.0035645952448248863, -0.03856280818581581, 0.025123801082372665, -0.0547417551279068, 0.02251439169049263, 0.03003670647740364, -0.032878100872039795, 0.016662349924445152, 0.003153217723593116, 0.026985876262187958, 0.043135929852724075, -0.009878121316432953, -0.04914793744683266, 0.011423877440392971, 0.053348358720541, -0.012703239917755127, -0.0302178543061018, 0.013462022878229618, 0.010658829472959042, 0.030985690653324127, 0.09163541346788406, -0.040892601013183594, -0.0028778910636901855, 0.030327007174491882, -0.023832112550735474, 0.06293082237243652, -0.020299527794122696, 0.06144706532359123, -0.0473845973610878, -0.058236394077539444, -0.03844192624092102, -0.051835428923368454, -0.03081694431602955, -0.016158759593963623, -0.02610287442803383, -0.038187652826309204, 0.024609962478280067, 0.01253337413072586, 0.04163995757699013, -0.05801256373524666, 0.047279760241508484, 0.03608065843582153, 0.005602634511888027, -0.004325223155319691, 0.033593595027923584, 0.014767042361199856, -0.032061684876680374, -0.005700231529772282, 0.0001068021374521777, -0.012577641755342484, 0.034527141600847244, -0.016305452212691307, 0.0009320174576714635, 0.06696809083223343, -0.047468025237321854, 0.02126351371407509, -0.007585764862596989, -0.015212488360702991, 0.0038582489360123873, -0.033835574984550476, -0.05195668339729309, -0.05366426333785057, -0.0916949063539505, 0.022300999611616135, -0.028836866840720177, -0.06532806158065796, 0.06491813063621521, -0.04364165663719177, 0.01696169376373291, 0.03466428071260452, -0.00527066458016634, -0.05256945639848709, -0.04642108082771301, -0.004591268952935934, -0.01448236033320427, 0.01585141196846962, 0.010419106110930443, 0.04932023584842682, 0.0008804853423498571, 0.03417695686221123, -0.08405512571334839, -0.003627748927101493, -0.022925589233636856, -0.01755015179514885, 0.03942732885479927, 0.0031396972481161356, 0.049187496304512024, -0.037515100091695786, 0.012174280360341072, -0.017345836386084557, 0.01670154742896557, 0.03139151260256767, -0.04424198344349861, 0.008396951481699944, -0.045861776918172836, -0.002380939433351159, -0.028637446463108063, -0.025482719764113426, 0.01085761096328497, 0.048922888934612274, -0.018242496997117996, -0.019918210804462433, -0.0380101315677166, -0.0031248268205672503, -0.00331648881547153, -0.008529871702194214, -0.04214249178767204, -0.023432783782482147, 0.008725300431251526, -0.011081094853579998, -0.014522198587656021, -0.0378136970102787, -0.07961808890104294, -0.05064123868942261, 0.07966683804988861, -0.039600078016519547, -0.00480232248082757, 0.017449479550123215, 0.0684344619512558, -0.023769330233335495, 0.006503773853182793, 0.018150735646486282, 0.01079432014375925, -0.0008090311894193292, 0.005651043262332678, 0.09057189524173737, 0.0082292091101408, 0.04863392189145088, 0.008543304167687893, 0.030792776495218277, -0.045857347548007965, 0.017681274563074112, 0.0029763479251414537, 0.020437536761164665, -0.09005896747112274, 0.007584488019347191, -0.014067305251955986, -0.032726582139730453, -0.008048191666603088, 0.015306188724935055, 0.033833954483270645, 0.02054862305521965, 0.05811215937137604, -0.005980216432362795, 0.005268984939903021, 0.03389528766274452, 0.017483334988355637, 0.009980800561606884, 0.01461920328438282, 0.004254519008100033, 0.0006447479245252907, -0.026015060022473335, -0.004124019760638475, 0.04208335652947426, 0.024143826216459274, -0.051600947976112366, 0.026538124307990074, 0.01985703408718109, 0.030465099960565567, -0.031226105988025665, 0.009216913022100925, 0.024414654821157455, 0.04670797660946846, -0.00016710697673261166, -0.0015513827092945576, -0.026780838146805763, -0.030709918588399887, -0.011716572567820549, -0.015998587012290955, 0.004588629584759474, 0.04231962934136391, 0.020410921424627304, -0.013776958920061588, 0.010975964367389679, -0.002376333111897111, 0.02398887276649475, -0.016501763835549355, 0.011143334209918976, 0.04429653286933899, -0.012922589667141438, 0.05881860479712486, 0.004643722902983427, -0.04976029321551323, -0.027115201577544212, -0.02782628871500492, 0.006975082680583, -0.03392096981406212, -0.03722929209470749, -0.017807748168706894, 0.048756156116724014, -0.01936473324894905, -0.00536735774949193, 0.0024565439671278, -0.02027144283056259, 0.031001821160316467, -0.04380996525287628, -0.026455331593751907, 0.047953445464372635, 0.053596969693899155, -0.04103052616119385, 0.0008856378262862563, 0.017327917739748955, -0.014762100763618946, -0.027384543791413307, 0.03505010902881622, -0.06240669637918472, 0.04696502909064293, -0.037205882370471954, 0.03771553933620453, 0.026993269100785255, -0.03956928104162216, 0.057633012533187866, 0.018513934686779976, 0.006899114232510328, -0.06615978479385376, 0.04159554839134216, 0.019009724259376526, 0.016628799960017204, -0.002650831826031208, -0.07941761612892151, 0.006644830107688904, 0.02495543844997883, 0.030370216816663742, -0.013458752073347569, 0.061958763748407364, 0.06329362839460373, 0.059747688472270966, -0.025517374277114868, 0.013805232010781765, -0.009828689508140087, 0.033889323472976685, -0.03513939306139946, 0.06352855265140533, 0.052757587283849716, 0.0023559106048196554, 0.007715786341577768, -0.001953301951289177, 0.0060994126833975315, -0.029582981020212173, 0.04506610706448555, -0.009060217998921871, -0.006272078957408667, 0.019997792318463326, 0.017092913389205933, 0.04975542426109314, -0.004200243391096592, 0.030599528923630714, 0.0176850538700819, -0.013710052706301212, 0.005614354275166988, -0.006390043068677187, -0.04461517930030823, 0.0014755602460354567, -0.03939038887619972, 0.09304077178239822, 0.048078153282403946, 0.010862837545573711, 0.010447541251778603, 0.031153647229075432, 0.05438737943768501, -0.014384950511157513, 0.043034814298152924, -0.05547322705388069, 0.00855833850800991, 0.06692847609519958, -0.03454082831740379, -0.021738287061452866, 0.021950626745820045, -0.010019934736192226, -0.028873076662421227, 0.015632696449756622, -0.07225426286458969, 0.07925773411989212, 0.029432743787765503, -0.007856792770326138, -0.026053184643387794, 0.034981098026037216, -0.007535343989729881, 0.037549786269664764, -0.08351462334394455, 0.008895697072148323, -0.0673704668879509, 0.025517811998724937, -0.015116536058485508, 0.0046569365076720715, -0.01667882315814495, 0.04085931181907654, 0.0003591155109461397, 0.017012963071465492, -0.03256876394152641, -0.027043338865041733, -0.0013372193789109588, -0.04881611838936806, -0.0214233361184597, -0.055500585585832596, -0.05050225183367729, 0.03909488767385483, -0.04797971621155739, 0.007137605920433998, -0.03345590457320213, 0.020316999405622482, 0.03621974214911461, 0.011168550699949265, -0.07197762280702591, -0.0417768731713295, -0.013325463980436325, -0.012401002459228039, -0.005994252394884825, 0.06777596473693848, 0.04116789624094963, -0.016603728756308556, 0.03162799030542374, 0.013930843211710453, -0.009983023628592491, -0.007670996244996786, -0.031778380274772644, 0.01393169816583395, 0.0011008509900420904, 0.0077199130319058895, -0.12714259326457977, -0.008866571821272373, -0.04960932582616806, -0.04906303435564041, 0.047644153237342834, -0.01931612938642502, 0.026395879685878754, -0.029666878283023834, -0.02045609802007675, 0.024128735065460205, 0.02302243933081627, 0.05424374341964722, -0.006015444174408913, -0.04226801171898842, -0.07753478735685349, -0.0030049369670450687, 0.0010363701730966568, 0.040389373898506165, 0.040520232170820236, -0.05753893032670021, 0.0043472349643707275, -0.007625430356711149, -0.026783959940075874, -0.021558310836553574, -0.010233919136226177, -0.04623163864016533, -0.033903252333402634, -0.03074761852622032, -0.04179295152425766, -0.021708395332098007, -0.003674061270430684, 0.027764804661273956, -0.0687217265367508, -0.04308711737394333, -0.04000967741012573, 0.0019525799434632063, -0.027040012180805206, 0.036479875445365906, -0.0036407567095011473, 0.08148425817489624, 0.013745772652328014, 0.035705532878637314, 0.009688738733530045, -0.005570441950112581, 0.013032656162977219, 0.05293260142207146, 0.023719269782304764, -0.0015325528802350163, -0.0016292058862745762, 0.05887111276388168, 0.050692107528448105, 0.040312059223651886, -0.011966802179813385, 0.015780063346028328, -0.055280901491642, -0.00027820569812320173, 0.03320864960551262, -0.002530652331188321, 0.03568009287118912, 0.01094866544008255, 0.017058108001947403, 0.007302749902009964, -0.03368066996335983, -0.03352866321802139, -0.08358830213546753, 0.03716627135872841, 0.019752943888306618, 0.0031833061948418617, -0.0011239534942433238, 0.019553011283278465, -0.07916178554296494, -0.018524497747421265, 0.014417171478271484, -0.02231418713927269, -0.012194089591503143, -0.006978222168982029, 0.0021612877026200294, 0.007514102850109339, 0.029565632343292236, -0.06518087536096573, -0.024530889466404915, 0.016968930140137672, 0.06842221319675446, -0.0063279313035309315, -0.09450798481702805, -0.09626904875040054, -0.010100988671183586, -0.107241690158844, -0.036461908370256424, -0.07763058692216873, 0.030699647963047028, 0.008942065760493279, 0.011562323197722435, 0.06483810395002365, 0.009130909107625484, 0.03570512682199478, -0.01590169593691826, 0.002766083460301161, -0.0218301173299551, -0.014708241447806358, 0.03987583890557289, -0.05489109084010124, -0.01580609194934368, -0.010046575218439102, 0.03623231127858162, 0.03422737494111061, -0.003716429229825735, 0.025110114365816116, -0.01595534384250641, 0.0761716216802597, -0.001694665988907218, -0.03397482633590698, 0.036252621561288834, -0.013000205159187317, -0.009741522371768951, 0.05611412599682808, -0.02341919206082821, 0.021799476817250252, -0.016080113127827644, -0.008738338015973568, -0.010747577995061874, 0.03791501373052597, -0.003750553587451577, -0.0494389608502388, 0.03201401233673096, 0.0161405261605978, -0.0031167748384177685, -0.0545993372797966, 0.03504389151930809, 0.016797566786408424, -0.01368605438619852, -0.03161035478115082, 0.05394142493605614, 0.02397093176841736, 0.017313141375780106, 0.04095763340592384, 0.07387591898441315, 0.09357208758592606, 0.0532180555164814, -0.024078235030174255, 0.030096907168626785, -0.09079280495643616, -0.03540555760264397, -0.016244925558567047, -0.017370792105793953, -0.05844157189130783, 0.0034638133365660906, 0.08707673847675323, -0.0499238446354866, -0.007588554173707962, 0.009466771967709064, 0.021508367732167244, -0.006674456410109997, -0.049386072903871536, 0.02332560159265995, -0.015071864239871502, 0.02454020082950592, 0.041680723428726196, 0.06532640010118484, -0.015167309902608395, -0.008221705444157124, -0.041116539388895035, -0.03658568486571312, 0.018792320042848587, 0.016984814777970314, 0.05634274333715439, -0.049653682857751846, -0.0312490314245224, -0.0484776645898819, -0.039363134652376175, 0.01591765508055687, -0.026595735922455788, 0.04635072872042656, -0.022778447717428207, 0.02111995592713356, -0.03276858851313591, -0.024858897551894188, 0.025247719138860703, 0.013895666226744652, -0.010294918902218342, 0.053763601928949356, -0.01831163838505745, -0.023837901651859283, -0.0039955745451152325, 0.01832660287618637, 0.03337752819061279, 0.044536858797073364, -0.026038777083158493, 0.017143867909908295, -0.02159094251692295, 0.001568929641507566, 0.003785228356719017, 0.026822328567504883, -0.04312567412853241, -0.027556268498301506, 0.036561932414770126, 0.012782428413629532, 0.013760419562458992, -0.033262211829423904, 0.0108897490426898, -0.034368038177490234, 0.06908325850963593, 0.03004077449440956, -0.01850750297307968, -0.021303072571754456, -0.038889504969120026, -0.012967574410140514, 0.02644108049571514, -0.021609682589769363, 0.011594343930482864, -0.04212448373436928, -0.07362152636051178, -0.04272867366671562, -0.01485031470656395, 0.023212412372231483, -0.04301530867815018, -0.0037528080865740776, -0.025979334488511086, -0.056600019335746765, 0.020159341394901276, 0.03564916178584099, 0.04219150170683861, -0.02185671590268612, -0.030678074806928635, -0.046726394444704056, 0.05041138082742691, -0.023789873346686363, 0.02941574715077877, -0.08027737587690353, 0.004635707009583712, -0.01750199869275093, 0.016282763332128525, 0.005777912680059671, -0.020849497988820076, -0.005338778719305992, -0.05868945270776749, -0.032786332070827484, 0.000649907102342695, 0.036464083939790726, -0.001976063707843423, 0.026671381667256355, 0.015164492651820183, -0.04955831915140152, -0.058918360620737076, 0.02616201899945736, -0.05079377070069313, 0.03334999457001686, -0.009016294963657856, 0.005432745907455683, -0.010956627316772938, -0.06186668574810028, -0.0006912812823429704, 0.05757928267121315, 0.030516527593135834, -0.003611502470448613, 0.09545198827981949, -0.04963485524058342, 0.05376894772052765, -0.028225289657711983, -0.008836235851049423, -0.009963121265172958, 0.03907196596264839, -0.0004401855985634029, -0.0076497578993439674, -0.00831633061170578, -0.051890790462493896, 0.009026975370943546, 0.021479293704032898, -0.0017807836411520839, -0.049248140305280685, -0.0029943871777504683, -0.014279584400355816, -0.0641789361834526, -0.008469562977552414, -0.04923589900135994, -0.03299213573336601, 0.05362576246261597, 0.04131592810153961, 0.015590595081448555, -0.03170393407344818, 0.02319273166358471, 0.09058089554309845, -0.02586645819246769, 0.004727639723569155, 0.001051259459927678, -0.00989576242864132, -0.0357244499027729, 0.00024616633891128004, -0.007231212221086025, 0.05577713996171951, 0.04236942529678345, 0.015666959807276726, -0.0009598569013178349, -0.028649255633354187, -0.06159345060586929, -0.02356504648923874, 0.022843198850750923, 0.0007444447837769985, -0.009691394865512848, 0.0003486362111289054, -0.02115391194820404, -0.022562453523278236, 0.03655508533120155, -0.0030377397779375315, 0.010646164417266846, -0.014034315943717957, 0.02326587773859501, 0.06178935617208481, -0.037046726793050766, 0.0020655784755945206, 0.0021054374519735575, 0.02031145989894867, 0.033507656306028366, -0.011325576342642307, 0.023086383938789368, -0.037590425461530685, 0.05057428777217865, 0.049178775399923325, 0.04588927701115608, -0.0011786174727603793, -0.016688382253050804, -0.009352343156933784, -0.02287254109978676, -0.0026083728298544884, 0.04374738782644272, 0.017489513382315636, 0.02904798649251461, 0.011094093322753906, -0.0016484104562550783, -0.013681424781680107, 0.019548218697309494, 0.03314853459596634, -0.019230635836720467, -0.015770569443702698, 0.017079953104257584, 0.02756187878549099, -0.002929836045950651, 0.024422310292720795, 0.011809710413217545, -0.010889647528529167, 0.00032653770176693797, 0.00016158379730768502, -0.06606539338827133, 0.04521800950169563, -0.021937066689133644, -0.061780814081430435, -0.012908072210848331, 0.021868225187063217, -0.048704132437705994, -0.01000146847218275, -0.08110173791646957, 0.005563454236835241, 0.0217194315046072, 0.029483918100595474, -0.027390427887439728, -0.0065584564581513405, -0.055577341467142105, -0.07019439339637756, 0.004631608724594116, -0.005741897039115429, 0.006112344097346067, 0.060237281024456024, 0.018811622634530067, 0.02437489666044712, 0.002112919231876731, 0.03700198978185654, 0.033946599811315536, 0.014514741487801075, -0.023580914363265038, -0.020691771060228348, 0.02320059947669506, 0.002799050882458687, 0.004378695972263813, 0.03137221559882164, 0.028881866484880447, -0.09638183563947678, -0.02342437021434307, 0.06954684108495712, 0.0451519601047039, -0.018974734470248222, 0.026030780747532845, -0.0434517003595829, -0.006945928558707237, 0.05258673056960106, 0.039190854877233505, -0.04274551570415497, 0.02848445437848568, 0.029504917562007904, -0.04389574006199837, -0.03999114781618118, 0.03245367109775543, -0.02951449528336525, 0.02896062657237053, 0.04177091643214226, 0.04422168806195259, -0.04613318666815758, 0.05775268003344536, -0.010227959603071213, -0.028252506628632545, -0.010914428159594536, -0.01383753027766943, 0.009825482964515686, 0.03329484909772873, 0.044234614819288254, -0.009983794763684273, 0.0018357352819293737, -0.004102019127458334, 0.002067223656922579, 0.06022202596068382, 0.06310322880744934, -0.061410631984472275, -0.03096415102481842, 0.02389364503324032, 0.018754543736577034, -0.020904839038848877, -0.002164978999644518, 0.016380852088332176, -0.0050702509470283985, 0.07395393401384354, -0.001871668267995119, -0.027348941192030907, -0.014284476637840271, 0.024823393672704697, 0.031221633777022362, 0.03428180515766144, -0.01742793433368206, 0.015642357990145683, -0.04383840411901474, -0.09049180895090103, -0.01667810045182705, 0.009699707850813866, -0.03859425708651543, 0.039971571415662766, -0.07698038220405579, 0.03730252757668495, 0.040457356721162796, 0.04278445243835449, -0.05164105072617531, -0.004594134166836739, -0.0398615226149559, -0.027418717741966248, 0.026624474674463272, 0.05453231930732727, 0.05509056895971298, 0.027720391750335693, 0.03915771469473839, 0.040925219655036926 ]
<p>I have a data set and I want to examine an hypothesis in there and probably Network Analysis should prove or reject my theory.</p> <p>I have a list of products and a group of people who give the product to each other. Anyone can sell it to another in any price he want (hopefully someone will buy it).</p> <p>So, imagine a chain of products transfers between the people. Except the sell price, one will also take a percentage of the sale only of the next one who will re-sell the product. And also, if I sell for the first time a product, I will take a percentage forever for every sale.</p> <p>Example:</p> <p>A -> B -> C</p> <p>Person A will take the money from sale to Person B. Person B will take the money of the sale to person C and Person A will take a percentage of this sale as the previous owner and the creator of the chain. If person C sell the product to someone else, only person B will take the previous percentage, but person A will take the percentage of the creator.</p> <p>I believe that there are people that try to exploit the system and create small or bigger circles to take advantage of these percentages of next sales to "hide" themselves.</p> <p>Is there any way to identify those people?</p>
g74066
[ -0.00669569568708539, 0.031120646744966507, -0.002745953155681491, -0.00029462011298164725, 0.02024318091571331, -0.06946448981761932, 0.058061182498931885, -0.04181535914540291, -0.014952907338738441, -0.006214735563844442, -0.0005702555645257235, 0.031664613634347916, 0.008937622420489788, 0.010330015793442726, -0.0046988618560135365, 0.027804242447018623, -0.004708046559244394, -0.04492737352848053, 0.010958217084407806, 0.027251046150922775, -0.0149003267288208, -0.016865186393260956, 0.010702130384743214, -0.049190253019332886, -0.07950298488140106, -0.028683362528681755, 0.026785174384713173, 0.01403356809169054, -0.026153819635510445, -0.03451669216156006, -0.036082927137613297, 0.006277791690081358, 0.05313146859407425, -0.056481312960386276, -0.047396380454301834, -0.034730542451143265, 0.015195445157587528, -0.001372113125398755, -0.04040452837944031, 0.06655904650688171, -0.04523618519306183, 0.04334550350904465, -0.02428109012544155, 0.011532613076269627, -0.009967492893338203, 0.003992114681750536, 0.027206702157855034, 0.02881111390888691, 0.04921682924032211, -0.025480838492512703, -0.006248921155929565, 0.008973240852355957, -0.04168578237295151, 0.04098000377416611, -0.04188516363501549, 0.055213093757629395, 0.06247405335307121, 0.015654051676392555, 0.10309524834156036, -0.042476288974285126, -0.040669314563274384, 0.049799952656030655, 0.011144286952912807, 0.024089915677905083, 0.027053214609622955, -0.0014752844581380486, -0.010975150391459465, 0.02154327742755413, -0.005176662467420101, -0.0587526373565197, -0.0038065870758146048, 0.017484184354543686, 0.013540827669203281, -0.013028598390519619, 0.009116945788264275, 0.030988600105047226, -0.03925429657101631, 0.04032722860574722, 0.03647952899336815, 0.035632647573947906, 0.005467436276376247, 0.015513594262301922, -0.052933257073163986, 0.04534639045596123, 0.02476898767054081, 0.004324441775679588, 0.04313037171959877, -0.0423625186085701, 0.01517864316701889, 0.029901837930083275, 0.03967195749282837, -0.010203536599874496, 0.08865375816822052, 0.058939021080732346, -0.005786963272839785, 0.003583413315936923, -0.04593132808804512, -0.00582632003352046, -0.036894701421260834, -0.007956328801810741, -0.00457813311368227, 0.006254250183701515, 0.004984078463166952, -0.011349746957421303, -0.011363793164491653, -0.005241725593805313, 0.050672538578510284, 0.032483361661434174, 0.0031355300452560186, 0.042732346802949905, -0.010812520049512386, -0.05891423299908638, -0.10147296637296677, 0.04598270356655121, 0.0016688432078808546, -0.04593407362699509, 0.03146882355213165, 0.022468604147434235, 0.006519475486129522, -0.009724458679556847, -0.004218518268316984, -0.051467202603816986, -0.03557862341403961, 0.04370276629924774, 0.01588454470038414, -0.004679237026721239, -0.0506402961909771, 0.00834606122225523, 0.004605954047292471, -0.01944739930331707, 0.030052341520786285, 0.02348688244819641, 0.05739505589008331, 0.01631983183324337, 0.017382988706231117, 0.028426138684153557, -0.03616451844573021, 0.014988630078732967, 0.005534755531698465, 0.0025137546472251415, -0.0019092690199613571, 0.05539486184716225, 0.020949838683009148, -0.030315352603793144, 0.007642866112291813, -0.03041081503033638, 0.011939379386603832, -0.01745079830288887, -0.035355567932128906, 0.00023482642427552491, -0.01758488267660141, 0.07984690368175507, -0.04767824336886406, 0.04219040647149086, -0.027658803388476372, -0.02940683253109455, -0.0022933874279260635, -0.040702324360609055, -0.003422970650717616, 0.014264050871133804, -0.013652225024998188, -0.04008188471198082, 0.07961641252040863, -0.019060887396335602, -0.09479755163192749, -0.02192746102809906, 0.037621960043907166, 0.013177288696169853, -0.01665377989411354, -0.017547298222780228, -0.01647256128489971, 0.0539427287876606, -0.08570769429206848, 0.038345832377672195, 0.011336127296090126, 0.0648249089717865, 0.026714473962783813, 0.0008539938135072589, 0.07286901772022247, 0.018521251156926155, 0.004404527600854635, -0.024501226842403412, 0.04531673341989517, 0.020105095580220222, 0.06122554466128349, -0.05611354112625122, -0.007095377426594496, 0.02857965975999832, 0.00911407545208931, -0.056282807141542435, -0.0023154050577431917, 0.005170933902263641, -0.03416531905531883, 0.0030338801443576813, 0.04648787900805473, -0.06710264831781387, 0.006025449372828007, 0.010521874763071537, 0.00784284994006157, -0.04618754982948303, 0.022248264402151108, 0.011301147751510143, -0.02801629900932312, 0.035528507083654404, 0.00237176101654768, -0.01717611774802208, -0.010083160363137722, -0.0316537581384182, -0.044619329273700714, 0.020326755940914154, 0.04142739623785019, -0.08647406101226807, -0.005365221295505762, -0.027473578229546547, -0.02612335793673992, -0.02710357867181301, 0.01714043878018856, 0.01879192516207695, 0.06692398339509964, -0.014950763434171677, 0.01534819882363081, -0.005595801398158073, 0.058306362479925156, -0.022513262927532196, 0.00031996387406252325, 0.005957192741334438, -0.005719802808016539, -0.039383843541145325, -0.03632513806223869, 0.06354944407939911, -0.02845262922346592, -0.016637226566672325, -0.01635415479540825, -0.059597279876470566, 0.03367074579000473, -0.0037004458718001842, 0.0006927982904016972, -0.03532390668988228, 0.025616789236664772, 0.033315207809209824, 0.0029214262031018734, -0.025363441556692123, -0.06562299281358719, 0.023203406482934952, 0.022187378257513046, -0.04164654016494751, -0.006619125604629517, -0.032692473381757736, -0.04153330996632576, 0.037398841232061386, -0.055109474807977676, 0.03149041533470154, -0.027475591748952866, -0.06730496883392334, 0.06462627649307251, -0.013348479755222797, -0.016424763947725296, 0.06094256788492203, 0.0543089285492897, -0.04510242119431496, -0.011924846097826958, 0.014016534201800823, 0.06436268240213394, 0.006117813754826784, 0.030122045427560806, -0.06599737703800201, -0.020633697509765625, -0.05835111811757088, -0.03144294023513794, 0.039561230689287186, -0.09857134521007538, 0.04697626456618309, 0.03162645921111107, 0.06207556277513504, 0.00877691525965929, 0.016382422298192978, -0.006690360140055418, -0.018756702542304993, -0.010428088717162609, 0.058799706399440765, -0.0021357734221965075, 0.053826287388801575, -0.04838692396879196, 0.00037404242902994156, 0.008449806831777096, -0.004852512385696173, 0.0467509925365448, -0.002647344721481204, -0.008357331156730652, 0.021279769018292427, 0.0457848384976387, 0.015455745160579681, 0.04657110199332237, -0.05389868840575218, 0.02786712534725666, 0.041928086429834366, 0.03210674598813057, -0.03248424455523491, 0.0102988351136446, -0.004220511764287949, -0.01381195429712534, -0.0051023769192397594, 0.031692665070295334, 0.021019576117396355, 0.05675584077835083, 0.03739447146654129, -0.010640628635883331, 0.02189396135509014, -0.01743922010064125, -0.0080894585698843, -0.015856627374887466, 0.030508412048220634, -0.01278553158044815, -0.06769260764122009, -0.007534527685493231, 0.05546475201845169, 0.0637630820274353, 0.004740577656775713, 0.037960976362228394, -0.036182109266519547, -0.002229667967185378, -0.02567080408334732, 0.022532159462571144, 0.013019791804254055, 0.0405210480093956, 0.01724265329539776, -0.14179833233356476, -0.013404473662376404, -0.04302626848220825, -0.05309398099780083, 0.01769089326262474, -0.043846894055604935, 0.009176441468298435, -0.0074419318698346615, -0.004246517550200224, -0.02843438647687435, -0.019299764186143875, 0.002434531459584832, 0.013737786561250687, 0.028402669355273247, -0.020061152055859566, 0.028883066028356552, 0.011055601760745049, -0.008471685461699963, 0.015307542867958546, 0.0459718219935894, 0.023886846378445625, 0.03391675278544426, 0.030458886176347733, -0.094762422144413, -0.00401292834430933, -0.04811965674161911, -0.013714056462049484, -0.04410769045352936, -0.027626603841781616, 0.056884825229644775, 0.03282678872346878, -0.03038088232278824, 0.03888748958706856, -0.005537889897823334, -0.028606757521629333, -0.02707630954682827, 0.03385123983025551, 0.031751248985528946, 0.04702082648873329, 0.06698206067085266, 0.052537038922309875, 0.05925951898097992, 0.020511901006102562, -0.014076701365411282, 0.006070990581065416, 0.0263663437217474, 0.038091327995061874, -0.003724448848515749, -0.020881962031126022, -0.019455436617136, -0.012283465825021267, 0.043681081384420395, 0.004622105974704027, 0.07277704030275345, 0.025537913665175438, 0.02043326199054718, -0.050390519201755524, -0.003823094069957733, 0.012558287009596825, 0.00044772206456400454, -0.003794407472014427, -0.03404741734266281, 0.013281851075589657, 0.07482025772333145, -0.010473828762769699, 0.032091815024614334, -0.05734589323401451, -0.013472124934196472, 0.01936997100710869, -0.011019036173820496, -0.07928050309419632, -0.04487818852066994, 0.044805802404880524, 0.02231716364622116, -0.005696106236428022, -0.019427115097641945, -0.04223880544304848, -0.03131665661931038, 0.007171181030571461, 0.03160582482814789, -0.0340879000723362, -0.008667774498462677, 0.03220079839229584, 0.019424065947532654, -0.04635224863886833, -0.04500698298215866, -0.004374068230390549, -0.04229353740811348, 0.044586241245269775, 0.021707525476813316, 0.06924483180046082, -0.008926418609917164, 0.009648377075791359, -0.011049315333366394, -0.01595493033528328, 0.02177729457616806, -0.01601988635957241, -0.0014786762185394764, -0.02084219641983509, 0.02524184063076973, 0.07688020169734955, 0.035417340695858, -0.016436772421002388, -0.06419137865304947, -0.014525191858410835, 0.05435087904334068, -0.037522491067647934, -0.07742458581924438, -0.022701194509863853, -0.055643659085035324, 0.022557692602276802, -0.0023398438934236765, -0.06718722730875015, 0.0014166320906952024, 0.008638580329716206, 0.01241548266261816, -0.01804855652153492, -0.02260025031864643, 0.038689788430929184, 0.04877695441246033, -0.003195576835423708, 0.013944958336651325, -0.0038730395026504993, 0.010035345330834389, -0.008906676433980465, 0.008880899287760258, 0.008703033439815044, -0.01773940585553646, 0.03066343255341053, 0.02005143277347088, 0.014079263433814049, -0.04600755125284195, 0.005847310181707144, -0.006295443512499332, -0.02523096464574337, -0.03267865628004074, -0.027952564880251884, -0.013220928609371185, -0.05747634917497635, 0.005457757972180843, -0.02177048847079277, 0.013627495616674423, 0.049822352826595306, -0.005449047777801752, -0.005177483893930912, 0.039938297122716904, 0.050334397703409195, 0.05944652855396271, -0.017675377428531647, -0.024073831737041473, 0.020914195105433464, 0.0551811121404171, -0.008020482026040554, 0.05201801657676697, -0.020231755450367928, 0.018325969576835632, 0.005902620032429695, -0.007875158451497555, 0.01504063606262207, 0.014458629302680492, 0.013170263729989529, -0.010869847610592842, -0.004088522866368294, 0.0036740656942129135, -0.019554074853658676, 0.008321129716932774, 0.04589905962347984, 0.0327521376311779, -0.0524083711206913, -0.016612280160188675, 0.008433660492300987, -0.03792716935276985, 0.01459204126149416, 0.019900109618902206, -0.03624044731259346, 0.07760332524776459, -0.004244512412697077, -0.018394991755485535, -0.02195073291659355, -0.025625312700867653, 0.004504229407757521, -0.008643741719424725, 0.017018446698784828, 0.06303347647190094, -0.018879644572734833, 0.08090883493423462, 0.0027506283950060606, -0.024030758067965508, -0.04907060042023659, -0.04302148148417473, -0.06230153888463974, -0.02549014240503311, -0.03397883474826813, 0.013172836974263191, -0.003883892670273781, 0.05505020543932915, -0.04385971277952194, 0.08174601197242737, 0.016858043149113655, -0.007506335154175758, -0.03502430021762848, 0.005779247265309095, 0.020663313567638397, -0.00969830621033907, 0.0706300437450409, 0.03988894075155258, -0.023881206288933754, 0.027268605306744576, 0.029789268970489502, -0.01838160865008831, 0.06897668540477753, 0.01935487985610962, 0.02642933465540409, -0.020026545971632004, 0.025360839441418648, -0.02123822085559368, -0.00966156180948019, -0.003916624467819929, -0.0472705103456974, -0.06730373203754425, -0.05074859783053398, -0.013209559954702854, 0.024185722693800926, -0.008871315978467464, 0.00455558393150568, 0.04351511970162392, 0.03161223977804184, -0.032751042395830154, -0.020628415048122406, -0.033398158848285675, -0.06806198507547379, 0.016614364460110664, 0.029924219474196434, 0.06679798662662506, 0.030209360644221306, 0.03251533582806587, -0.00167838332708925, -0.0023495242930948734, -0.022056838497519493, -0.06794259697198868, 0.0007596667855978012, 0.0177005548030138, 0.03624967858195305, 0.0652792677283287, 0.01154660526663065, -0.028511682525277138, -0.015423085540533066, 0.032274577766656876, -0.017580535262823105, -0.014285488985478878, 0.015033229254186153, -0.08146689087152481, 0.0010258173570036888, 0.011784571222960949, -0.012482086196541786, -0.0693504735827446, -0.016067655757069588, -0.007009878754615784, -0.016317689791321754, 0.0395241379737854, -0.012094181962311268, -0.03094944730401039, -0.02106824330985546, -0.012586615979671478, -0.08874477446079254, -0.0005223936168476939, -0.008463606238365173, -0.040372539311647415, 0.007461401168256998, -0.02451211027801037, -0.020446689799427986, -0.009110856801271439, -0.0212862566113472, -0.011901665478944778, -0.02936527319252491, -0.04219495877623558, 0.06828856468200684, -0.026449957862496376, -0.0339667908847332, 0.04300512745976448, 0.021116245537996292, 0.028433633968234062, -0.0007520646322518587, -0.000695564434863627, -0.0065530333667993546, 0.03457266464829445, 0.03392675518989563, 0.0315745547413826, 0.06861329823732376, 0.00846163835376501, 0.022396333515644073, -0.026979070156812668, 0.020391879603266716, -0.027417179197072983, 0.0850667729973793, -0.06683989614248276, -0.05350292846560478, -0.024743909016251564, 0.03318559005856514, 0.09285757690668106, -0.04017136991024017, -0.0689590647816658, -0.01913338713347912, 0.06466859579086304, 0.009749015793204308, 0.018673036247491837, 0.030287830159068108, -0.02146155573427677, -0.09666037559509277, 0.04805983975529671, -0.07356564700603485, 0.034551169723272324, 0.018512461334466934, 0.025554660707712173, 0.01878843642771244, 0.015791019424796104, -0.04973693564534187, 0.03349766135215759, 0.03679564967751503, -0.0007897891919128597, 0.0253297109156847, 0.07438743114471436, 0.029229113832116127, 0.022500185295939445, 0.009419078938663006, 0.023791776970028877, -0.0055862790904939175, 0.003675467101857066, -0.0365302599966526, -0.0008478008676320314, -0.016646619886159897, 0.03119383193552494, 0.0017495136708021164, -0.037601035088300705, -0.07515526562929153, -0.04268696531653404, -0.00624585896730423, -0.0668482705950737, -0.04512738808989525, -0.009525523521006107, 0.03759682923555374, 0.007260124199092388, -0.025345584377646446, -0.015739303082227707, -0.012402569875121117, -0.05566531419754028, 0.016742441803216934, 0.01326703280210495, -0.01571362093091011, -0.04526538774371147, 0.07744596898555756, 0.01348958257585764, -0.03238741680979729, -0.00850951112806797, -0.006303985137492418, 0.05366979539394379, 0.05594862252473831, -0.00519095454365015, 0.015486974269151688, 0.06429391354322433, 0.009268142282962799, 0.04683806747198105, -0.0278707854449749, -0.0465690940618515, -0.06389161944389343, -0.057035308331251144, -0.035901572555303574, 0.002399521181359887, -0.003093675710260868, 0.0655720978975296, -0.01401923131197691, 0.007342210039496422, -0.008197680115699768, 0.07408209890127182, 0.005836482625454664, -0.0032326593063771725, -0.014130746945738792, -0.023436984047293663, 0.03143634274601936, -0.005827630870044231, -0.024609988555312157, 0.04644390568137169, 0.012351981364190578, -0.02624666877090931, -0.025596344843506813, 0.011667552404105663, 0.014534625224769115, 0.03235442563891411, -0.07374225556850433, -0.008990253321826458, -0.05545521154999733, -0.010332648642361164, -0.014635120518505573, 0.008229125291109085, 0.02369394525885582, -0.03135551139712334, -0.019905274733901024, -0.011938579380512238, -0.05451356619596481, -0.06483129411935806, -0.025747502222657204, 0.02877940982580185, -0.03217453137040138, 0.04414249211549759, -0.04507799074053764, 0.03233526274561882, -0.05514015257358551, -0.056551460176706314, 0.018354104831814766, 0.0017176776891574264, -0.04014819487929344, -0.02913837507367134, -0.03120245598256588, -0.01746082678437233, -0.016622362658381462, -0.001503006205894053, 0.024074438959360123, 0.015679731965065002, -0.02944638952612877, -0.031749315559864044, -0.02631848119199276, 0.03330088034272194, -0.02614104002714157, 0.006198122166097164, -0.026708869263529778, -0.013829322531819344, 0.013520712032914162, -0.018904002383351326, 0.030269594863057137, 0.03592010214924812, -0.012740910984575748, 0.043202098459005356, 0.01039031334221363, -0.02071141079068184, -0.0696331262588501, -0.08265024423599243, -0.06170373782515526, 0.06006861478090286, 0.0797336995601654, -0.006469834595918655, 0.028681334108114243, 0.01676837168633938 ]