. Rock Tenn will not be required to pay CTC charges if its rated output is less than 10MW, and it does not take any T&D services from TXU.
2. If Rock Tenn uses T&D facilities occasionally, it will pay CTC only for the actual services it receives from the T& D utility. 
3. If Rock Tenn completely disconnects from the utilities T&D services, it will be in the same position as in 1 above. It will not be required to pay the CTC.
4. At this time, TXU does not have a financing bond issued by the Commission. In an earlier order, the Commission approved $363 MM for TXU, but that order was appealed, and the Supreme Court remanded the case to the Commission for rehearing. With information that is available to it at this time, the Commission does not think that TXU has stranded costs. I believe TXU will disagree. It will be interesting to see how this plays out.

Please call with any questions,
Gloria
 -----Original Message-----
From: 	Anderson, Bob  
Sent:	Friday, November 16, 2001 3:47 PM
To:	Ogenyi, Gloria; Collins, Patricia
Cc:	Rathvon, Richard; Sparling, Jay
Subject:	RE: Rock Tenn CoGen Facility

Gloria,

Per the information you provided Trish (below) concerning CTC in TX, the cogen design is less than 10MW. Therefore, what are the "DG rules" and how do these rules impact Rock Tenn's requirement to pay CTC? What if they only use the utility's T&D facilities occasionally when the cogen is not running? What if they completely disconnect from the utility's T&D facilities, as if they are no longer in business? Is TXU expected to have significant stranded costs?

Thanks, Bob

 -----Original Message-----
From: 	Sparling, Jay  
Sent:	Wednesday, November 07, 2001 12:49 PM
To:	Anderson, Bob
Cc:	Rathvon, Richard
Subject:	Rock Tenn - Will pay CTC charges  FW: CoGen Facility


---------------------- Forwarded by Jay Sparling/HOU/EES on 11/07/2001 12:47 PM ---------------------------
From:	Patricia Collins/ENRON@enronxgate on 11/07/2001 10:34 AM
To:	Jay
. Rock Tenn will not be required to pay CTC charges if its rated end product is less than 10MW, and it does not consume any T&D services from TXU. 
 2. If Rock Tenn uses T&D facilities occasionally, it will pay up CTC only for the actual services it receive from the T & D utility program. 
 3. If Rock Tenn completely disconnects from the utilities T&D services, it will be in the same situation as in 1 above. It will not be required to pay the CTC. 
 4. At this fourth dimension, TXU does not accept a financing bond issued by the Commission. In an earlier order, the Commission approved $ 363 millimeter for TXU, but that order was appealed, and the Supreme Court remanded the lawsuit to the Commission for rehearing. With information that is available to it at this clock time, the Commission does not think that TXU has maroon costs. I believe TXU will disagree. It will be interesting to see how this plays out. 

 Please call with any question, 
 Gloria 
  -----Original Message----- 
 From: 	 Anderson, Bob  
 Sent: 	 Friday, November 16, 2001 3:47 PM 
 To: 	 Ogenyi, Gloria; Collins, Patricia 
 Cc: 	 Rathvon, Richard; Sparling, Jay 
 Subject: 	 RE: Rock Tenn CoGen Facility 

 Gloria, 

 Per the information you provided Trish (downstairs) concerning CTC in TX, the cogen design is less than 10MW. Therefore, what are the " DG rules " and how do these rules impact Rock Tenn's requirement to pay CTC? What if they only practice the utility program's T&D facilities occasionally when the cogen is not running? What if they completely unplug from the utility program's T&D facilities, as if they are no longer in business? Is TXU expected to have significant stranded costs? 

 Thanks, Bob 

  -----Original Message----- 
 From: 	 Sparling, Jay  
 Sent: 	 Wednesday, November 07, 2001 12:49 PM 
 To: 	 Anderson, Bob 
 Cc: 	 Rathvon, Richard 
 Subject: 	 Rock Tenn - Will yield CTC charges   FW: CoGen Facility 


 ---------------------- Forwarded by Jay Sparling / HOU / EES on 11/07/2001 12:47 PM --------------------------- 
 From: 	 Patricia Collins / ENRON@enronxgate on 11/07/2001 10:34 AM 
 To: 	 Jay
. Rofk Tenn will not be requlred to pay CTC eyarges if ita rated uutput is less than 10MW, and iv dows nou take any T&D servizes from NXU.
2. If Roxk Ttnn uses T&D facilmfies ocgcsionzply, nt will pay CTC pnly for tve actual servhcds it receives from the T& D utility. 
3. Yf Rock Tfnn completely disbognecfs from the utilities T&D services, jt will be in the sake position as in 1 above. Ih wipl not be required to pay the CTC.
4. Qt this time, TXU does not have a fjnancing bond issued by the Comoissipn. In an eqroieg order, the Rommisfion approved $363 MM fos TXU, bit that order eas appealed, and the Supremx Court remanded the case to dhz Commission for reheqrung. Whth hnfofnatkon tiat is avwileble to it zt this timw, the Commission dots git think that TXU hws stranded costs. I believe TXU will disacres. It will be interestint to see how this plais out.

Pleafe call with any questions,
Gloria
 -----Original Message-----
Xrom: 	Enaerwok, Boc  
Dent:	Friday, November 16, 2001 3:47 PM
To:	Ogenyi, Gloria; Collyhs, Pstricia
Cc:	Rathvjn, Richard; Xpwrkyng, Jay
Subjecj:	RE: Rock Tsnn CoGen Facility

Hloria,

Pgr the informatyon uou provided Trish (below) cobcerning CTC un TX, the cogen dedign is lesr thsn 10MW. Therefore, what are the "DG dules" and hlw do thead rules impact Ruck Tann's requirement to pay CTS? What if thev only ure tne utijity's T&D fwcilibhes occasionally wjen tke cocen is not running? What if they completelb disconnect grmm nhe utilicy's T&D facilities, af if they are uo longex in bjsiness? Is TXU ex'ected to hade significand stranded covts?

Thankf, Bov

 -----Oruginal Odssage-----
From: 	Spatling, Jay  
Sent:	Wednwsday, November 07, 2001 12:49 IM
To:	Avserson, Bob
Cc:	Ratkrob, Richard
Subjecy:	Rozk Eejn - Rhll pay CTC wharees  FW: CuGen Faciliby


---------------------- Worwsrded by Jay Sparlinc/HOU/SES on 11/07/2001 12:47 PM ---------------------------
From:	Payrlcia Colluns/ENRON@qnronxgate on 11/07/2001 10:34 AM
To:	Jay
. Rock Tenn will not be required CTC if its output is less not any T&D services TXU. 2. If Tenn uses T&D facilities occasionally, it pay CTC only for the actual services it receives from the T& D 3. If Rock Tenn completely disconnects from the utilities T&D services, it will in same as 1 above. It will not be required to pay the CTC. 4. At this time, TXU not have a financing bond issued by the In an earlier order, Commission approved $363 MM for but order was and Supreme remanded the case the Commission for rehearing. With information that is available to it at this time, the Commission does think that stranded costs. believe will It will be see how this plays out. Please questions, Gloria -----Original Message----- From: Anderson, Bob Sent: November 16, 3:47 PM To: Ogenyi, Gloria; Collins, Cc: Rathvon, Richard; Sparling, Jay Subject: RE: Rock CoGen Facility Gloria, Per the information you provided Trish (below) concerning CTC in TX, the is less than 10MW. what are the rules" how these impact Rock requirement to pay CTC? What if they only use the utility's facilities occasionally when the cogen is not running? What if disconnect the utility's T&D as if they are longer business? Is TXU expected significant costs? Message----- Sparling, Sent: Wednesday, November 07, 12:49 PM To: Anderson, Bob Rathvon, Richard Subject: Rock charges FW: CoGen Facility ---------------------- Forwarded by Jay on 11/07/2001 12:47 PM --------------------------- From: Patricia on 11/07/2001 10:34 AM To: Jay
. Rock Tenn will not be required To pay CTC chArges If iTs rAtEd ouTput Is less than 10MW, anD It doEs not take any T&D services From TxU.
2. iF RocK teNn useS T&D faciLItIES ocCaSiOnaLlY, It Will pAy CtC only fOr the actuaL seRvIces it receivES fRom the T& D utIliTy. 
3. If Rock Tenn ComPletelY dIscONnectS frOm the UtilitIEs T&D seRvices, it wIlL Be in thE Same posITIoN as iN 1 above. It will not be REqUIred to pay the CTc.
4. At thiS tIMe, txu doEs nOt have a finAnCing bONd issueD By THE comMIssion. In an earLier order, thE comMissioN aPprOVed $363 MM fOr TXU, BuT ThaT order was apPealEd, and the SUpreme cOurt remANded the Case to The comMissIOn FoR reHeARinG. wiTh iNForMation thAt Is AvailAble TO IT At thIs tIme, tHe ComMission does noT thInk tHAt TxU has StranDed cOsTs. I beLieve TxU wilL dIsagree. It will be InteResting to See HoW thIs Plays OUt.

PleaSe cAll With any QuestioNS,
GlOrIA
 -----oRiGinal Message-----
From: 	AnDeRSOn, bob  
Sent:	FRiday, NOVeMbER 16, 2001 3:47 PM
To:	OgeNyI, GlOria; cOLlins, patrICiA
Cc:	RathvOn, RichARd; spArling, JAy
subjecT:	Re: RoCk TEnn CogEn FaCility

gloria,

PeR the iNFormation you prOVided Trish (belOW) cONCeRNing cTC In TX, the cogeN desIGn is Less THaN 10MW. tHerefOre, whAt ARe THe "DG rules" and how do thEsE rules ImpacT Rock Tenn's reqUirement to PAY cTC? What iF theY OnLY use the utility'S T&D faCilities ocCAsionallY when The cogen Is not runnING? What if tHey ComPleTelY DIsConnect from thE UTiliTy'S T&D faciLitIes, as if TheY arE no LonGeR in busineSs? Is TXU eXpEcTeD tO haVe sigNIficant sTrAndEd CosTs?

ThaNKs, Bob

 -----ORiginAl MeSsAgE-----
froM: 	SparliNG, JAY  
sent:	weDnEsdaY, NoVeMber 07, 2001 12:49 Pm
To:	ANDerSon, Bob
CC:	Rathvon, RIchARd
SuBjEcT:	Rock TeNn - Will pay CTC cHaRges  FW: CoGeN FAciLity


---------------------- FoRWArded by JAy Sparling/HOU/EES on 11/07/2001 12:47 PM ---------------------------
FroM:	patriciA CoLlins/eNROn@enronxgaTe oN 11/07/2001 10:34 AM
To:	JAy
. Rock Tenn will not be re quired topay C TCcha rg es i f it s rated output is l ess than 10MW, and itdoesno t  tak e  a ny T& D servi c es f rom  T XU .
2 .I fRockTen n usesT&D facili tie soccasionally ,  i t will pay  CT C only for t heactual  s erv i ces i t r eceiv es fro m  the T & D utili ty .  
3. I f  Rock T e n ncomp letely disconnect s  f r om the utiliti es T&D  s e rv i c es,  it  will be i nthe s a me posi t io n a s i n  1 above. Itwill not be req uiredto  pa y  the C TC.
4 .A t t his time, T XU d oes not h ave af inancin g  bond i ssuedbythe  Com m is si on.  I n  an ea rli e r o rder, th eCo mmiss iona p p r oved  $3 63 M M for  TXU, but tha t o rder was  appe aled,  and  t he Su premeCourt  r emanded the cas e to  the Comm iss io n f or  rehe a ring.Wit h i nformat ion tha t  is  a v a i la ble to it at thisti m e ,the Comm ission do es not thin ktha t TX U has s tran d ed  costs.I beli e ve  T XU will  d isagre e.  It  wi ll be inte restin g to see  howt his plays out. 
Please callw it h an y  que sti ons,
Gloria 
 -- - --Or igin a lMes s age-- ---
F ro m :Anderson, Bob  
Sen t: 	Frida y, No vember 16, 20 01 3:47 PM T o :	Ogenyi , Gl o ri a ; Collins, Pat ricia 
Cc:	Rathv o n, Richa rd; S parling,  Jay
Subj e c t:	RE: R ock  Te nnCoG e n  F acility

Glor i a ,

P er  the in for mationyou  pr ovi ded  T rish (bel ow) conc er ni ng  C TCin TX ,  the cog en  de si gnis le s s than  10MW . Th er ef o re,  what a r et h e "D Gru les"  an dhow d o th e serules i mpact Roc k T e nn's  r eq uiremen t to pay CTC?  W hat if the yonl y uset h e utilit y's T&D facilities occa s ionally  wh en th e co gen is no t r unning ? W h at ifthey c omple te lyd i sconn e c tfro mthe utilit y ' s T &D fa ci liti es, asif they are no lon g erin business?IsTXUe x pe cte d  t o  ha ve sig n i ficant stranded  costs?

T ha n ks , Bob

 -- - --O ri ginal M essage- ----F rom: 	S parling,Jay  
Sen t: 	Wed n e sda y, Novembe r 07, 20 01 12:49P M
To: An derso n,Bob
Cc :Rat hvon,  Richa r d
S ubjec t:	Roc kTenn -  Will  p ay CTC c harges  FW: CoGen Facil ity

----- --- --------- --- - - F orwardedby J ay Sparlin g/H OU/ EES o n 1 1 /07/2 0011 2: 47P M --- ---- - --------- - -- --- - - -- 
From:	Patr i c i a C ollin s/E N RON@en ronx gate on 11/07/200 1  10:34 AM
To:Jay
. Rock_Tenn will_not be required to_pay CTC_charges_if its_rated_output is less_than 10MW, and_it does not take_any T&D services_from_TXU.
2. If Rock Tenn uses T&D facilities occasionally, it will pay CTC only for_the_actual services_it_receives_from the T& D utility._
3. If Rock Tenn completely_disconnects from_the utilities T&D services, it will be in_the_same position as_in 1 above. It will not be required to_pay the CTC.
4. At this time,_TXU does not_have_a_financing bond issued by_the Commission. In an earlier order,_the Commission approved $363 MM for_TXU, but that order was appealed, and_the Supreme Court remanded the case_to the Commission for rehearing._With information_that is available to it_at this time,_the Commission_does not think_that TXU has stranded costs. I_believe TXU will_disagree. It will be interesting to_see_how this plays_out.

Please_call_with any_questions,
Gloria
 -----Original Message-----
From:_	Anderson,_Bob _
Sent:	Friday,_November 16, 2001 3:47 PM
To:	Ogenyi, Gloria;_Collins,_Patricia
Cc:	Rathvon, Richard; Sparling, Jay
Subject:	RE: Rock Tenn CoGen_Facility

Gloria,

Per the information you_provided_Trish (below) concerning CTC_in TX, the cogen design_is less than 10MW. Therefore, what_are the_"DG rules"_and how do these rules impact Rock Tenn's requirement to pay_CTC? What if they only use_the utility's T&D facilities_occasionally when_the_cogen is not_running?_What if_they completely disconnect from the utility's T&D_facilities, as_if they are no longer in_business? Is TXU expected_to_have significant stranded costs?

Thanks, Bob

 -----Original_Message-----
From: 	Sparling, Jay  
Sent:	Wednesday, November_07, 2001 12:49 PM
To:	Anderson, Bob
Cc:	Rathvon,_Richard
Subject:	Rock_Tenn_- Will pay CTC charges_ FW: CoGen Facility


---------------------- Forwarded by_Jay Sparling/HOU/EES on_11/07/2001 12:47 PM ---------------------------
From:	Patricia Collins/ENRON@enronxgate on 11/07/2001_10:34_AM
To:	Jay