Zoia Profile Blog Joined November 2010 United States 418 Posts Last Edited: 2012-12-28 02:13:22 #2 Despite all the haters Idra does deserve to alteast be in the top 50. Third at WCS NA alone out preforms most of the people in rank 30-50.



Edit: Nvm he is 21 i'm just stupid www.twitch.tv/starcraftsquad - Caster for Playhem.tv

musai Profile Joined May 2010 Canada 552 Posts #3 much more accurate than that other list lol

Cokefreak Profile Joined June 2011 Finland 8068 Posts #4 Top 10:

Most overrated: Snute, seriously he won HSC6 what else? He is good don't get me wrong but he still needs to prove himself.

Most underrated: Kas,well he obviously is.

Top 20:

Most overrated: HuK, when was the last time he won something?

Most underrated: TLO, he showed once again at HSC that he is really a force to watch out for.

Top 30:

Most overrated: MajOr, I believed in him for the longest time.

Most underrated: Socke, he has been consistantly doing well in tournaments for so long now but still doens't get recognization for it.

31-50:

Who deserves Top30 the most? Dimaga, He does, so good.

Who isnt even Top50? JohnnyRecco, haven't even heard of him for a while now when he was supposed to be the next breakout player.

KalWarkov Profile Blog Joined December 2011 Germany 3911 Posts #5 On December 28 2012 10:42 Zoia wrote:

Despite all the haters Idra does deserve to alteast be in the top 50. Third at WCS NA alone out preforms most of the people in rank 30-50.



IdrA is ranked 21. IdrA is ranked 21. DiaBoLuS ** Sc2 - Protoss: 16x GM WoL/HotS/LotV | Dota2 - Offlane/5: peak 5.8k solo | Wc3 - Undead: 2007/2008/2016/2017/2018 ~rank 100 W3A/Bnet, ~60% winrate | Diablo 2 / Grim Dawn / PoE nerd - Melee Classes | Leffen/Ice, MCarlsen, BVB <3 | Agnostic***

coL.hendralisk Profile Joined September 2009 Zimbabwe 1756 Posts #6 On December 28 2012 10:49 Cokefreak wrote:

Top 10:

Most overrated: Snute, seriously he won HSC6 what else? He is good don't get me wrong but he still needs to prove himself.

Most underrated: Kas,well he obviously is.

Top 20:

Most overrated: HuK, when was the last time he won something?

Most underrated: TLO, he showed once again at HSC that he is really a force to watch out for.

Top 30:

Most overrated: MajOr, I believed in him for the longest time.

Most underrated: Socke, he has been consistantly doing well in tournaments for so long now but still doens't get recognization for it.

31-50:

Who deserves Top30 the most? Dimaga, He does, so good.

Who isnt even Top50? JohnnyRecco, haven't even heard of him for a while now when he was supposed to be the next breakout player.



have faith in major! have faith in major!

Cokefreak Profile Joined June 2011 Finland 8068 Posts #7 On December 28 2012 11:06 NMxhendralisk wrote:

Show nested quote +

On December 28 2012 10:49 Cokefreak wrote:

Top 10:

Most overrated: Snute, seriously he won HSC6 what else? He is good don't get me wrong but he still needs to prove himself.

Most underrated: Kas,well he obviously is.

Top 20:

Most overrated: HuK, when was the last time he won something?

Most underrated: TLO, he showed once again at HSC that he is really a force to watch out for.

Top 30:

Most overrated: MajOr, I believed in him for the longest time.

Most underrated: Socke, he has been consistantly doing well in tournaments for so long now but still doens't get recognization for it.

31-50:

Who deserves Top30 the most? Dimaga, He does, so good.

Who isnt even Top50? JohnnyRecco, haven't even heard of him for a while now when he was supposed to be the next breakout player.



have faith in major! have faith in major!

Sorry, no more Like I said I believed in him for the longest time. Sorry, no moreLike I said I believed in him for the longest time.

Zoia Profile Blog Joined November 2010 United States 418 Posts #8 On December 28 2012 10:57 KalWarkov wrote:

Show nested quote +

On December 28 2012 10:42 Zoia wrote:

Despite all the haters Idra does deserve to alteast be in the top 50. Third at WCS NA alone out preforms most of the people in rank 30-50.



IdrA is ranked 21. IdrA is ranked 21.





I don't know why i didn't see him i looked at the list three times. Well i'm just stupid then I don't know why i didn't see him i looked at the list three times. Well i'm just stupid then www.twitch.tv/starcraftsquad - Caster for Playhem.tv

tree.hugger Profile Blog Joined May 2009 Philadelphia, PA 10042 Posts #9



Hey! This looks pretty good to me! On December 28 2012 10:49 Cokefreak wrote:

Top 10:

Most overrated: Snute, seriously he won HSC6 what else? He is good don't get me wrong but he still needs to prove himself.

Most underrated: Kas,well he obviously is.

Top 20:

Most overrated: HuK, when was the last time he won something?

Most underrated: TLO, he showed once again at HSC that he is really a force to watch out for.

Top 30:

Most overrated: MajOr, I believed in him for the longest time.

Most underrated: Socke, he has been consistantly doing well in tournaments for so long now but still doens't get recognization for it.

31-50:

Who deserves Top30 the most? Dimaga, He does, so good.

Who isnt even Top50? JohnnyRecco, haven't even heard of him for a while now when he was supposed to be the next breakout player.

Haha, yes, what Snute done, aside from take HSC6, beat Life at IPL, top 8 at Dreamhack (out to HerO), second at Campus Party (out to SuperNoVa), third at the Battle at Ministry of Win (out to Sage), second in the Acer Challenge (out to Sage), and second in the Thor Open? Must be a noob, because I'm too lazy to look at his Liquipedia page. Haha, yes, what Snute done, aside from take HSC6, beat Life at IPL, top 8 at Dreamhack (out to HerO), second at Campus Party (out to SuperNoVa), third at the Battle at Ministry of Win (out to Sage), second in the Acer Challenge (out to Sage), and second in the Thor Open? Must be a noob, because I'm too lazy to look at his Liquipedia page. Moderator EffOrt, Snow, GuMiho, and Team Liquid

Enel Profile Joined April 2012 Sudan 427 Posts #10 no surprise what race the top5 are. Go Sudan

StarVe Profile Joined June 2011 Germany 12278 Posts Last Edited: 2012-12-28 03:54:22 #11 I'd put VortiX in 2nd place over Scarlett. She didn't look too convincing in RSL against GuMiho and fraer with the US server advantage, while VortiX just comfortably 3-0ed GuMiho, won THOR Open over Snute and others without dropping a map.



And I'd really put Pomi in the Protoss 30-50 lineup over White-Ra or ToD after he beat MMA, Zenio and Nerchio in EG Master's Cup finals this month.

Not that that'd make him incredibly impressive, but it's still way better results than for example those two have produced this month and in the months prior.



HuK should be a bit further down again, sLivko, eh, I don't know why he's still 17th, but I might just be butthurt fraer is lower than slivko again now (fucking WCG -.-).

Luepert Profile Blog Joined June 2011 United States 1853 Posts #12 Zerg 5/5 top 5. Liquid Forever

syntox Profile Joined May 2011 Australia 26 Posts Last Edited: 2012-12-28 03:58:00 #13



Scarlett is so overrated.



User was banned for this post. Scarlett 2nd? Is this a joke? What has he even performed well in recently?Scarlett is so overrated.

TheFish7 Profile Blog Joined February 2012 United States 2814 Posts #14 Stephano overrated? Are there people who would say he is not best foreigner? ~ ~ <°)))><~ ~ ~

cchily13 Profile Joined May 2012 64 Posts #15 10 Terrans in the top 50. It hurts man it hurts. ROOT is reborn!!

sashamunguia Profile Joined February 2011 Mexico 423 Posts #16 huh... so people think Naniwa, TLO and Idra are both, heavily underrated and heavily overrated...huh... "only the need for meaning changes how you feel about what you see" "he who is not courageous enough to take risks will accomplish nothing in life" "being a Rebel is as stupid as to be completely Obedient"

StarVe Profile Joined June 2011 Germany 12278 Posts #17 On December 28 2012 13:31 sashamunguia wrote:

so people think Naniwa, TLO and Idra are both, heavily underrated and heavily overrated... huh... so people think Naniwa, TLO and Idra are both, heavily underrated and heavily overrated...huh...

They've always been controversial players, no surprises there. What surprises me more is people voting for VortiX as overrated. If anything, he might be underrated.

They've always been controversial players, no surprises there. What surprises me more is people voting for VortiX as overrated. If anything, he might be underrated.

Whatson Profile Blog Joined January 2012 United States 5302 Posts #18 On December 28 2012 13:34 StarVe wrote:

Show nested quote +

On December 28 2012 13:31 sashamunguia wrote:

so people think Naniwa, TLO and Idra are both, heavily underrated and heavily overrated... huh... so people think Naniwa, TLO and Idra are both, heavily underrated and heavily overrated...huh...

They've always been controversial players, no surprises there. What surprises me more is people voting for VortiX as overrated. If anything, he might be underrated.

They've always been controversial players, no surprises there. What surprises me more is people voting for VortiX as overrated. If anything, he might be underrated.

He's a Zerg. There's kind of been an over-exposure of them lately. He's a Zerg. There's kind of been an over-exposure of them lately. ¯\_(シ)_/¯

decado90 Profile Blog Joined December 2012 United States 480 Posts #19 No problems with the top 5, but the rest of the list is pretty fucked up.



Most egregious are:



Lucifron #7



Thorzain #10



Demuslim # 20





all way too high.



I think a top 15 list would be better.



When you get past the top 15 the players just get lackluster and aren't very good (compared to Koreans) and aren't very relevant to the scene.



Huk? Slivko? way too high as well.



Also, no Goswser on the list is very silly.





Lastly, I'll reiterate how baffled I am by Lucifron at #7. "Be formless like water"- Bruce Lee

Graphix Profile Blog Joined March 2012 United States 208 Posts #20 i say its more or less accurate.





gogo SortOf ^^ ~Jaedong Forever~

1 2 3 4 Next All