open-llm-leaderboard/ibm-granite__granite-7b-base-details

Dataset Card for Evaluation run of ibm-granite/granite-7b-base

Dataset automatically created during the evaluation run of model ibm-granite/granite-7b-base The dataset is composed of 44 configuration(s), each one corresponding to one of the evaluated task.

The dataset has been created from 2 run(s). Each run can be found as a specific split in each configuration, the split being named using the timestamp of the run.The "train" split is always pointing to the latest results.

An additional configuration "results" store all the aggregated results of the run.

To load the details from a run, you can for instance do the following:

from datasets import load_dataset
data = load_dataset(
    "HuggingFaceEvalInternal/ibm-granite__granite-7b-base-details-private",
    name="ibm-granite__granite-7b-base__leaderboard_arc_challenge",
    split="latest"
)

Latest results

These are the latest results from run 2024-06-21T12-40-44.835422 (note that there might be results for other tasks in the repos if successive evals didn't cover the same tasks. You find each in the results and the "latest" split for each eval):

{
    "all": {
        "leaderboard": {
            "prompt_level_strict_acc,none": 0.1866913123844732,
            "prompt_level_strict_acc_stderr,none": 0.016768448450975755,
            "inst_level_strict_acc,none": 0.2961630695443645,
            "inst_level_strict_acc_stderr,none": "N/A",
            "prompt_level_loose_acc,none": 0.19038817005545286,
            "prompt_level_loose_acc_stderr,none": 0.016895129407634518,
            "inst_level_loose_acc,none": 0.30455635491606714,
            "inst_level_loose_acc_stderr,none": "N/A",
            "acc_norm,none": 0.3517621889426866,
            "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.004765308779338082,
            "acc,none": 0.20766434413813994,
            "acc_stderr,none": 0.0034650335523040234,
            "exact_match,none": 0.006042296072507553,
            "exact_match_stderr,none": 0.0021309570011430875,
            "alias": "leaderboard"
        },
        "leaderboard_arc_challenge": {
            "acc,none": 0.4564846416382253,
            "acc_stderr,none": 0.014555949760496435,
            "acc_norm,none": 0.48976109215017066,
            "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.014608326906285015,
            "alias": " - leaderboard_arc_challenge"
        },
        "leaderboard_bbh": {
            "acc_norm,none": 0.345252560319389,
            "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.0057972256506519625,
            "alias": " - leaderboard_bbh"
        },
        "leaderboard_bbh_boolean_expressions": {
            "acc_norm,none": 0.552,
            "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.031514387611153515,
            "alias": "  - leaderboard_bbh_boolean_expressions"
        },
        "leaderboard_bbh_causal_judgement": {
            "acc_norm,none": 0.5133689839572193,
            "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.03664867131244298,
            "alias": "  - leaderboard_bbh_causal_judgement"
        },
        "leaderboard_bbh_date_understanding": {
            "acc_norm,none": 0.332,
            "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.02984403904746588,
            "alias": "  - leaderboard_bbh_date_understanding"
        },
        "leaderboard_bbh_disambiguation_qa": {
            "acc_norm,none": 0.38,
            "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.030760116042626042,
            "alias": "  - leaderboard_bbh_disambiguation_qa"
        },
        "leaderboard_bbh_formal_fallacies": {
            "acc_norm,none": 0.532,
            "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.031621252575725504,
            "alias": "  - leaderboard_bbh_formal_fallacies"
        },
        "leaderboard_bbh_geometric_shapes": {
            "acc_norm,none": 0.196,
            "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.02515685731325593,
            "alias": "  - leaderboard_bbh_geometric_shapes"
        },
        "leaderboard_bbh_hyperbaton": {
            "acc_norm,none": 0.48,
            "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.03166085340849519,
            "alias": "  - leaderboard_bbh_hyperbaton"
        },
        "leaderboard_bbh_logical_deduction_five_objects": {
            "acc_norm,none": 0.22,
            "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.02625179282460585,
            "alias": "  - leaderboard_bbh_logical_deduction_five_objects"
        },
        "leaderboard_bbh_logical_deduction_seven_objects": {
            "acc_norm,none": 0.136,
            "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.02172334261705207,
            "alias": "  - leaderboard_bbh_logical_deduction_seven_objects"
        },
        "leaderboard_bbh_logical_deduction_three_objects": {
            "acc_norm,none": 0.388,
            "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.030881038748993915,
            "alias": "  - leaderboard_bbh_logical_deduction_three_objects"
        },
        "leaderboard_bbh_movie_recommendation": {
            "acc_norm,none": 0.84,
            "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.02323271478206065,
            "alias": "  - leaderboard_bbh_movie_recommendation"
        },
        "leaderboard_bbh_navigate": {
            "acc_norm,none": 0.42,
            "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.03127799950463661,
            "alias": "  - leaderboard_bbh_navigate"
        },
        "leaderboard_bbh_object_counting": {
            "acc_norm,none": 0.256,
            "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.027657108718204912,
            "alias": "  - leaderboard_bbh_object_counting"
        },
        "leaderboard_bbh_penguins_in_a_table": {
            "acc_norm,none": 0.273972602739726,
            "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.03703787583167248,
            "alias": "  - leaderboard_bbh_penguins_in_a_table"
        },
        "leaderboard_bbh_reasoning_about_colored_objects": {
            "acc_norm,none": 0.196,
            "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.02515685731325593,
            "alias": "  - leaderboard_bbh_reasoning_about_colored_objects"
        },
        "leaderboard_bbh_ruin_names": {
            "acc_norm,none": 0.184,
            "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.02455581299422256,
            "alias": "  - leaderboard_bbh_ruin_names"
        },
        "leaderboard_bbh_salient_translation_error_detection": {
            "acc_norm,none": 0.232,
            "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.02675007037486516,
            "alias": "  - leaderboard_bbh_salient_translation_error_detection"
        },
        "leaderboard_bbh_snarks": {
            "acc_norm,none": 0.5337078651685393,
            "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.03749680060368987,
            "alias": "  - leaderboard_bbh_snarks"
        },
        "leaderboard_bbh_sports_understanding": {
            "acc_norm,none": 0.528,
            "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.0316364895315444,
            "alias": "  - leaderboard_bbh_sports_understanding"
        },
        "leaderboard_bbh_temporal_sequences": {
            "acc_norm,none": 0.08,
            "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.017192507941462973,
            "alias": "  - leaderboard_bbh_temporal_sequences"
        },
        "leaderboard_bbh_tracking_shuffled_objects_five_objects": {
            "acc_norm,none": 0.156,
            "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.022995023034068744,
            "alias": "  - leaderboard_bbh_tracking_shuffled_objects_five_objects"
        },
        "leaderboard_bbh_tracking_shuffled_objects_seven_objects": {
            "acc_norm,none": 0.108,
            "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.019669559381568755,
            "alias": "  - leaderboard_bbh_tracking_shuffled_objects_seven_objects"
        },
        "leaderboard_bbh_tracking_shuffled_objects_three_objects": {
            "acc_norm,none": 0.328,
            "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.029752391824475383,
            "alias": "  - leaderboard_bbh_tracking_shuffled_objects_three_objects"
        },
        "leaderboard_bbh_web_of_lies": {
            "acc_norm,none": 0.488,
            "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.03167708558254709,
            "alias": "  - leaderboard_bbh_web_of_lies"
        },
        "leaderboard_gpqa": {
            "acc_norm,none": 0.24580536912751677,
            "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.01248154213364881,
            "alias": " - leaderboard_gpqa"
        },
        "leaderboard_gpqa_diamond": {
            "acc_norm,none": 0.25252525252525254,
            "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.030954055470365907,
            "alias": "  - leaderboard_gpqa_diamond"
        },
        "leaderboard_gpqa_extended": {
            "acc_norm,none": 0.2326007326007326,
            "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.01809747469809874,
            "alias": "  - leaderboard_gpqa_extended"
        },
        "leaderboard_gpqa_main": {
            "acc_norm,none": 0.25892857142857145,
            "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.02071887932447214,
            "alias": "  - leaderboard_gpqa_main"
        },
        "leaderboard_ifeval": {
            "prompt_level_strict_acc,none": 0.1866913123844732,
            "prompt_level_strict_acc_stderr,none": 0.01676844845097575,
            "inst_level_strict_acc,none": 0.2961630695443645,
            "inst_level_strict_acc_stderr,none": "N/A",
            "prompt_level_loose_acc,none": 0.19038817005545286,
            "prompt_level_loose_acc_stderr,none": 0.01689512940763452,
            "inst_level_loose_acc,none": 0.30455635491606714,
            "inst_level_loose_acc_stderr,none": "N/A",
            "alias": " - leaderboard_ifeval"
        },
        "leaderboard_math_hard": {
            "exact_match,none": 0.006042296072507553,
            "exact_match_stderr,none": 0.0021309570011430875,
            "alias": " - leaderboard_math_hard"
        },
        "leaderboard_math_algebra_hard": {
            "exact_match,none": 0.006514657980456026,
            "exact_match_stderr,none": 0.004599025618546263,
            "alias": "  - leaderboard_math_algebra_hard"
        },
        "leaderboard_math_counting_and_prob_hard": {
            "exact_match,none": 0.008130081300813009,
            "exact_match_stderr,none": 0.008130081300812999,
            "alias": "  - leaderboard_math_counting_and_prob_hard"
        },
        "leaderboard_math_geometry_hard": {
            "exact_match,none": 0.007575757575757576,
            "exact_match_stderr,none": 0.007575757575757568,
            "alias": "  - leaderboard_math_geometry_hard"
        },
        "leaderboard_math_intermediate_algebra_hard": {
            "exact_match,none": 0.0,
            "exact_match_stderr,none": 0.0,
            "alias": "  - leaderboard_math_intermediate_algebra_hard"
        },
        "leaderboard_math_num_theory_hard": {
            "exact_match,none": 0.006493506493506494,
            "exact_match_stderr,none": 0.006493506493506494,
            "alias": "  - leaderboard_math_num_theory_hard"
        },
        "leaderboard_math_prealgebra_hard": {
            "exact_match,none": 0.015544041450777202,
            "exact_match_stderr,none": 0.008927492715084345,
            "alias": "  - leaderboard_math_prealgebra_hard"
        },
        "leaderboard_math_precalculus_hard": {
            "exact_match,none": 0.0,
            "exact_match_stderr,none": 0.0,
            "alias": "  - leaderboard_math_precalculus_hard"
        },
        "leaderboard_mmlu_pro": {
            "acc,none": 0.18342752659574468,
            "acc_stderr,none": 0.0035284076861703917,
            "alias": " - leaderboard_mmlu_pro"
        },
        "leaderboard_musr": {
            "acc_norm,none": 0.3544973544973545,
            "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.016793314199308396,
            "alias": " - leaderboard_musr"
        },
        "leaderboard_musr_murder_mysteries": {
            "acc_norm,none": 0.532,
            "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.031621252575725504,
            "alias": "  - leaderboard_musr_murder_mysteries"
        },
        "leaderboard_musr_object_placements": {
            "acc_norm,none": 0.23046875,
            "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.026372364120563745,
            "alias": "  - leaderboard_musr_object_placements"
        },
        "leaderboard_musr_team_allocation": {
            "acc_norm,none": 0.304,
            "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.029150213374159677,
            "alias": "  - leaderboard_musr_team_allocation"
        }
    },
    "leaderboard": {
        "prompt_level_strict_acc,none": 0.1866913123844732,
        "prompt_level_strict_acc_stderr,none": 0.016768448450975755,
        "inst_level_strict_acc,none": 0.2961630695443645,
        "inst_level_strict_acc_stderr,none": "N/A",
        "prompt_level_loose_acc,none": 0.19038817005545286,
        "prompt_level_loose_acc_stderr,none": 0.016895129407634518,
        "inst_level_loose_acc,none": 0.30455635491606714,
        "inst_level_loose_acc_stderr,none": "N/A",
        "acc_norm,none": 0.3517621889426866,
        "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.004765308779338082,
        "acc,none": 0.20766434413813994,
        "acc_stderr,none": 0.0034650335523040234,
        "exact_match,none": 0.006042296072507553,
        "exact_match_stderr,none": 0.0021309570011430875,
        "alias": "leaderboard"
    },
    "leaderboard_arc_challenge": {
        "acc,none": 0.4564846416382253,
        "acc_stderr,none": 0.014555949760496435,
        "acc_norm,none": 0.48976109215017066,
        "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.014608326906285015,
        "alias": " - leaderboard_arc_challenge"
    },
    "leaderboard_bbh": {
        "acc_norm,none": 0.345252560319389,
        "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.0057972256506519625,
        "alias": " - leaderboard_bbh"
    },
    "leaderboard_bbh_boolean_expressions": {
        "acc_norm,none": 0.552,
        "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.031514387611153515,
        "alias": "  - leaderboard_bbh_boolean_expressions"
    },
    "leaderboard_bbh_causal_judgement": {
        "acc_norm,none": 0.5133689839572193,
        "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.03664867131244298,
        "alias": "  - leaderboard_bbh_causal_judgement"
    },
    "leaderboard_bbh_date_understanding": {
        "acc_norm,none": 0.332,
        "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.02984403904746588,
        "alias": "  - leaderboard_bbh_date_understanding"
    },
    "leaderboard_bbh_disambiguation_qa": {
        "acc_norm,none": 0.38,
        "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.030760116042626042,
        "alias": "  - leaderboard_bbh_disambiguation_qa"
    },
    "leaderboard_bbh_formal_fallacies": {
        "acc_norm,none": 0.532,
        "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.031621252575725504,
        "alias": "  - leaderboard_bbh_formal_fallacies"
    },
    "leaderboard_bbh_geometric_shapes": {
        "acc_norm,none": 0.196,
        "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.02515685731325593,
        "alias": "  - leaderboard_bbh_geometric_shapes"
    },
    "leaderboard_bbh_hyperbaton": {
        "acc_norm,none": 0.48,
        "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.03166085340849519,
        "alias": "  - leaderboard_bbh_hyperbaton"
    },
    "leaderboard_bbh_logical_deduction_five_objects": {
        "acc_norm,none": 0.22,
        "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.02625179282460585,
        "alias": "  - leaderboard_bbh_logical_deduction_five_objects"
    },
    "leaderboard_bbh_logical_deduction_seven_objects": {
        "acc_norm,none": 0.136,
        "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.02172334261705207,
        "alias": "  - leaderboard_bbh_logical_deduction_seven_objects"
    },
    "leaderboard_bbh_logical_deduction_three_objects": {
        "acc_norm,none": 0.388,
        "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.030881038748993915,
        "alias": "  - leaderboard_bbh_logical_deduction_three_objects"
    },
    "leaderboard_bbh_movie_recommendation": {
        "acc_norm,none": 0.84,
        "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.02323271478206065,
        "alias": "  - leaderboard_bbh_movie_recommendation"
    },
    "leaderboard_bbh_navigate": {
        "acc_norm,none": 0.42,
        "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.03127799950463661,
        "alias": "  - leaderboard_bbh_navigate"
    },
    "leaderboard_bbh_object_counting": {
        "acc_norm,none": 0.256,
        "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.027657108718204912,
        "alias": "  - leaderboard_bbh_object_counting"
    },
    "leaderboard_bbh_penguins_in_a_table": {
        "acc_norm,none": 0.273972602739726,
        "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.03703787583167248,
        "alias": "  - leaderboard_bbh_penguins_in_a_table"
    },
    "leaderboard_bbh_reasoning_about_colored_objects": {
        "acc_norm,none": 0.196,
        "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.02515685731325593,
        "alias": "  - leaderboard_bbh_reasoning_about_colored_objects"
    },
    "leaderboard_bbh_ruin_names": {
        "acc_norm,none": 0.184,
        "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.02455581299422256,
        "alias": "  - leaderboard_bbh_ruin_names"
    },
    "leaderboard_bbh_salient_translation_error_detection": {
        "acc_norm,none": 0.232,
        "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.02675007037486516,
        "alias": "  - leaderboard_bbh_salient_translation_error_detection"
    },
    "leaderboard_bbh_snarks": {
        "acc_norm,none": 0.5337078651685393,
        "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.03749680060368987,
        "alias": "  - leaderboard_bbh_snarks"
    },
    "leaderboard_bbh_sports_understanding": {
        "acc_norm,none": 0.528,
        "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.0316364895315444,
        "alias": "  - leaderboard_bbh_sports_understanding"
    },
    "leaderboard_bbh_temporal_sequences": {
        "acc_norm,none": 0.08,
        "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.017192507941462973,
        "alias": "  - leaderboard_bbh_temporal_sequences"
    },
    "leaderboard_bbh_tracking_shuffled_objects_five_objects": {
        "acc_norm,none": 0.156,
        "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.022995023034068744,
        "alias": "  - leaderboard_bbh_tracking_shuffled_objects_five_objects"
    },
    "leaderboard_bbh_tracking_shuffled_objects_seven_objects": {
        "acc_norm,none": 0.108,
        "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.019669559381568755,
        "alias": "  - leaderboard_bbh_tracking_shuffled_objects_seven_objects"
    },
    "leaderboard_bbh_tracking_shuffled_objects_three_objects": {
        "acc_norm,none": 0.328,
        "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.029752391824475383,
        "alias": "  - leaderboard_bbh_tracking_shuffled_objects_three_objects"
    },
    "leaderboard_bbh_web_of_lies": {
        "acc_norm,none": 0.488,
        "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.03167708558254709,
        "alias": "  - leaderboard_bbh_web_of_lies"
    },
    "leaderboard_gpqa": {
        "acc_norm,none": 0.24580536912751677,
        "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.01248154213364881,
        "alias": " - leaderboard_gpqa"
    },
    "leaderboard_gpqa_diamond": {
        "acc_norm,none": 0.25252525252525254,
        "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.030954055470365907,
        "alias": "  - leaderboard_gpqa_diamond"
    },
    "leaderboard_gpqa_extended": {
        "acc_norm,none": 0.2326007326007326,
        "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.01809747469809874,
        "alias": "  - leaderboard_gpqa_extended"
    },
    "leaderboard_gpqa_main": {
        "acc_norm,none": 0.25892857142857145,
        "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.02071887932447214,
        "alias": "  - leaderboard_gpqa_main"
    },
    "leaderboard_ifeval": {
        "prompt_level_strict_acc,none": 0.1866913123844732,
        "prompt_level_strict_acc_stderr,none": 0.01676844845097575,
        "inst_level_strict_acc,none": 0.2961630695443645,
        "inst_level_strict_acc_stderr,none": "N/A",
        "prompt_level_loose_acc,none": 0.19038817005545286,
        "prompt_level_loose_acc_stderr,none": 0.01689512940763452,
        "inst_level_loose_acc,none": 0.30455635491606714,
        "inst_level_loose_acc_stderr,none": "N/A",
        "alias": " - leaderboard_ifeval"
    },
    "leaderboard_math_hard": {
        "exact_match,none": 0.006042296072507553,
        "exact_match_stderr,none": 0.0021309570011430875,
        "alias": " - leaderboard_math_hard"
    },
    "leaderboard_math_algebra_hard": {
        "exact_match,none": 0.006514657980456026,
        "exact_match_stderr,none": 0.004599025618546263,
        "alias": "  - leaderboard_math_algebra_hard"
    },
    "leaderboard_math_counting_and_prob_hard": {
        "exact_match,none": 0.008130081300813009,
        "exact_match_stderr,none": 0.008130081300812999,
        "alias": "  - leaderboard_math_counting_and_prob_hard"
    },
    "leaderboard_math_geometry_hard": {
        "exact_match,none": 0.007575757575757576,
        "exact_match_stderr,none": 0.007575757575757568,
        "alias": "  - leaderboard_math_geometry_hard"
    },
    "leaderboard_math_intermediate_algebra_hard": {
        "exact_match,none": 0.0,
        "exact_match_stderr,none": 0.0,
        "alias": "  - leaderboard_math_intermediate_algebra_hard"
    },
    "leaderboard_math_num_theory_hard": {
        "exact_match,none": 0.006493506493506494,
        "exact_match_stderr,none": 0.006493506493506494,
        "alias": "  - leaderboard_math_num_theory_hard"
    },
    "leaderboard_math_prealgebra_hard": {
        "exact_match,none": 0.015544041450777202,
        "exact_match_stderr,none": 0.008927492715084345,
        "alias": "  - leaderboard_math_prealgebra_hard"
    },
    "leaderboard_math_precalculus_hard": {
        "exact_match,none": 0.0,
        "exact_match_stderr,none": 0.0,
        "alias": "  - leaderboard_math_precalculus_hard"
    },
    "leaderboard_mmlu_pro": {
        "acc,none": 0.18342752659574468,
        "acc_stderr,none": 0.0035284076861703917,
        "alias": " - leaderboard_mmlu_pro"
    },
    "leaderboard_musr": {
        "acc_norm,none": 0.3544973544973545,
        "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.016793314199308396,
        "alias": " - leaderboard_musr"
    },
    "leaderboard_musr_murder_mysteries": {
        "acc_norm,none": 0.532,
        "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.031621252575725504,
        "alias": "  - leaderboard_musr_murder_mysteries"
    },
    "leaderboard_musr_object_placements": {
        "acc_norm,none": 0.23046875,
        "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.026372364120563745,
        "alias": "  - leaderboard_musr_object_placements"
    },
    "leaderboard_musr_team_allocation": {
        "acc_norm,none": 0.304,
        "acc_norm_stderr,none": 0.029150213374159677,
        "alias": "  - leaderboard_musr_team_allocation"
    }
}

Dataset Details

Dataset Description

• Curated by: [More Information Needed]
• Funded by [optional]: [More Information Needed]
• Shared by [optional]: [More Information Needed]
• Language(s) (NLP): [More Information Needed]
• License: [More Information Needed]

Dataset Sources [optional]

• Repository: [More Information Needed]
• Paper [optional]: [More Information Needed]
• Demo [optional]: [More Information Needed]

Uses

Direct Use

[More Information Needed]

Out-of-Scope Use

[More Information Needed]

Dataset Structure

[More Information Needed]

Dataset Creation

Curation Rationale

[More Information Needed]

Source Data

Data Collection and Processing

[More Information Needed]

Who are the source data producers?

[More Information Needed]

Annotations [optional]

Annotation process

[More Information Needed]

Who are the annotators?

[More Information Needed]

Personal and Sensitive Information

[More Information Needed]

Bias, Risks, and Limitations

[More Information Needed]

Recommendations

Users should be made aware of the risks, biases and limitations of the dataset. More information needed for further recommendations.

Citation [optional]

BibTeX:

[More Information Needed]

APA:

[More Information Needed]

Glossary [optional]

[More Information Needed]

More Information [optional]

[More Information Needed]

Dataset Card Authors [optional]

[More Information Needed]

Dataset Card Contact

[More Information Needed]