A new user asked [this question](https://scifi.stackexchange.com/questions/239456/would-it-be-legally-possible-to-release-a-new-lord-of-the-rings-the-hobbit-movie). The question is a valid question but it contains large amount of ranting. Even worse, it had a "if it were me" part, which is almost always unhelpful in this SE.

A user removed ~90% of the content. Even though I agree that the edit was helpful, it is very disrespectful, especially considering that the author is a very new user. Because I find it disrespectful, not because I found the edit unhelpful, I rolled back the edit and explained why I rolled back. (I did the second rollback because it was done without discussion.)

A good new user, would lurk some time before contributing, yet, the lack of many privileges, especially lack of commenting privilege, makes them more eager to post content before necessary amount of lurking.

So, what is the best way to deal with such posts?