So I have this spreadsheet

[![enter image description here](https://i.stack.imgur.com/M7u2x.png)](https://i.stack.imgur.com/M7u2x.png)

And I want to essentially grab the value to the right of the value.

So for example, if I look for `x`, I want to get the values of `E9`, and `E15`. So far this is my query:

```
=LOOKUP(D23 , $D$5:$E$16 , $E$5:$E$16 , FALSE)

```

But all I'm getting is:

```
Error
Formula parse error

```

Any idea what I'm doing wrong?

EDIT:

I thought I might be making a mistake, since I forgot I'd have to `SUM`, but after changing the key to `tax` it still doesn't work

I tried both `LOOKUP` and `VLOOKUP`, same problem in each

I also tried smth I found in a tutorial, but no luck

```
=VLOOKUP(D23 , $D$5:$E$16 , 2 , FALSE)

```

TO FUTURE SEARCHERS:

To figure out which "breaker" you need (`,` of `;`), take a close look at the formula help. It's the blue question mark next to the `fx`