Datasets:
embedding-data
/
coco_captions_quintets

Dataset card Data Studio Files Community
1
set
sequence
[ "a city street with an overpass and building in the distance", "a half dozen stop and go lights all red at the same time", "A street under a traffic light and street sign in city.", "a traffic light and street sign above a city road", "a street sign in a big city out side with cars" ]
[ "Land with trees and animals on the land ", "A herd of animals that are grazing in a field.", "Fenced fields with sheep grazing in the distance.", "Sheep are grazing in a field in the distance.", "A dry grass field with a herd of cattle." ]
[ "two public transit buses on a city street", "Two city buses parked next to the sidewalk.", "Looking down at commuter buses at the curb", "2 large buses at a stop on a street", "two buses sit outside a station awaiting passengers" ]
[ "A fire hydrant in a grassy curb in a parking lot.", "The blue and white fire hydrant is on the corner.", "A blue and white fire hydrant stands by the street.", "A blue and white fire hydrant on a lawn.", "A blue and white fire hydrant in grassy area next to street." ]
[ "A woman wearing a cowboy hat stands on the street.", "A woman leans on a street sign pole on a sidewalk next to a street. ", "A women on the sidewalk in a stylish hat and pink jacket.", "A woman in a red leather jacket is standing on the side walk.", "A man in a cowboy hat is standing next to a sign post." ]
[ "People getting off the bus at the bus stop.", "A green and yellow bus at a bus stop.", "The bus has pulled up to the bus stop.", "Woman at the bus stop after just getting off", "A street scene with a bus stopped at a bus stop." ]
[ "A silver bus approaching a bus stop with woman standing by it.", "a woman on a phone is waiting for a bus", "A young woman is waiting for her bus to arrive.", "A bus pulling into a bus stop in a city with tall buildings.", "A lady is using her phone while waiting for the oncoming bus." ]
[ "A group of goats stand in a field as they graze", "A picture of some goats standing in the grass.", "Several white goats sanding in a dry field", "A goat with horns is standing in a grassy field.", "a close up of an animal on a dirt ground" ]
[ "A sheep dog herding some sheep to another direction.", "A dog is on the field with some white sheep.", "A black and white Border Collie getting ready to do her job of herding sheep.", "A black and white dog eyes three sheep", "A herd of sheep standing next to a black and white dog." ]
[ "A large blue bus is parked in its area near the others. ", "a double Decker bus parked under some kind of roof.", "The double decker bus is parked in the building.", "A double decker bus is parked under some kind of covering.", "A double-decker bus in some bus depot somewhere." ]
[ "A highway with traffic and pedestrians on the edge.", "A yellow bus and various cars on street next to people.", "A busy street with busses, cars and a lot of people on the sidewalk.", "Yellow buses and white vans picking up various passengers on the roadside.", "A long yellow bus driving down a street next to a crowd." ]
[ "A red and yellow bus parked on the side of a brick building.", "A city bus parked in a bus parking spot.", "A yellow and red bus on street next to a building.", "A yellow and red bus driving down a street next to a tall building.", "An empty bus is parked near the curb " ]
[ "A man is standing on a streetlight fixture and is fiddling with it in some way.", "A worker stands on top of a traffic light, repairing it", "A young child climbs to the top of a traffic signal.", "A man repairing a traffic light next to billboards.", "A man hanging off the side of a traffic signal." ]
[ "a parking lot and a large brick building ", "An open court with a basketball goal and soccer goal near with a bench.", "Brick school building behind a blacktop playground with basketball hoop.", "A building sits next to an empty park which has benches and a basketball ball hoop. ", "A parking lot has some benches and a building lot next to it." ]
[ "A pug dog sits with a leash on a bench next to a thermos.", "A small dog sitting on top of a wooden bench next to a thermos.", "A brown and black dog sitting on a wooden bench next to a fence.", "There is a dog sitting on a park bench", "Dog sitting on a bench with a leash on his collar." ]
[ "The people are shaving the sheep's wool in the farm. ", "Two people shaving letters on the side of a goat.", "A group of three people shaving a sheep.", "A woman and a man writing on the side of a sheep.", "A man and woman are marking the goat with white lettering. " ]
[ "Many bicyclists in uniforms stopped at a stoplight", "A group of people on bicycles passing under a traffic light.", "The cyclists are stopped at a red light", "A group of people riding bikes down a street.", "Several bicycle riders are stopped at a red light." ]
[ "A picnic table near a lake and small waterfall", "A bench sitting out in a field next to a tree.", "A bench sits in a field by the water while it is cloudy.", "The empty park table and benches sit beside the grey water.", "There is a bench by the side of a tree on a shore" ]
[ "A car and a truck are going through the intersection.", "A green truck with empty truck bed on road.", "A truck driving down a road next to a car.", "Vehicles at a traffic light stopping during the day.", "A truck drives down the highway alongside a small four-door sedan." ]
[ "Rocks and other debris laying on one side of the bench", "Bench at a beach partly covered with storm-tossed rocks.", "A park bench is covered with rocks and debris with water in the background.", "there is a bench on the sea shore covered in rocks and debris", "A bench by some water that is covered in rocks." ]
[ "Two children sit in a colorful chair near a firepit in an open-air patio area.", "A couple of people and a bus outside.", "A boy sits in a colorful chair by a fire.", "A child sitting in a chair by a fire pit.", "Lawn chairs sit around a fire pit with a VW van in the background" ]
[ "The sheep are standing close together by the rock wall. ", "Two rams in grassy area next to a stone wall.", "Two goats are standing in some grass by a stone wall.", "A sheep that is standing by a wall made of rocks.", "A couple of long horn sheep standing next to each other." ]
[ "Shaded wooden benches line a white sand beach.", "A beach with various shaded benches next to water.", "A row of wooden structures sitting on top of a beach.", "An empty beach with benches running on the shoreline", "Some benches are lined up on the sandy beach." ]
[ "A white dog standing behind a wooden gate.", "golden retriever gazing at sheep in field from behind gate", "A dog stands behind a fence, looking at the sheep in the field.", "Four sheep watching a dog peek through their fence.", "A dog looking through a fence at sheep in a field" ]
[ "a group of black and white baby lambs.", "A herd of lambs playing in a stable of hay.", "A bunch of young goats playing and grazing in their enclosure.", "A group of lambs in hay next to fence.", "A bunch of lamb in a straw filled barn" ]
[ "A little girl putting a blue umbrella over a yellow fire hydrant.", "A girl in pink sweater putting a blue umbrella over a yellow fire hydrant.", "Little girl plays with an opened umbrella on the fire hydrant", "A little girl putting a umbrella on top of a hydrant. ", "A young girl puts an umbrella on a fire hydrant." ]
[ "Two giraffes feed on leaves on either side of a tree. ", "Two giraffes eating dried leaves tied to a dead tree.", "A group of giraffes at a feeding station.", "Two giraffe standing next to a tall tree.", "Two giraffes eating the leaves off a tree." ]
[ "There are some benches on top of a hill", "Two benches and a garbage can sit on a beach.", "A black and white picture of dunes, two benches and a trash can", "Two benches on top of a grass covered hillside.", "Two benches on a hill near grass and dirt. " ]
[ "A wooden bench sits by the fence and some trees.", "wooden bench in front of fenced area enclosing greenery", "a empty swing outside next to a fence.", "A wooden bench siting inside of a forest.", "An old wooden chair and a bird feeder in front of a fence." ]
[ "a young giraffe standing in a green grassy area", "A giraffe is standing in a grassy field.", "a little giraffe standing in front of some trees ", "A giraffe standing on top of a lush green field.", "A giraffe and it's friends watching the onlookers." ]
[ "A white sheep standing in grassy area with trees in background.", "A sheep standing in a shaded area in a clearing in the woods.", "A shaggy haired sheep standing in a small meadow.", "A lamb in a green grassy pasture with trees", "Sheep standing in shade of grassy and tree'd area." ]
[ "A little girl that is sitting on a bench.", "The little girl is sitting on the bench by herself. ", "A little girl sitting on top of a wooden bench near bushes.", "A girl with a hat on fixing her shoe on a bench.", "The child is sitting on the bench in the garden, one shoe off and one shoe on." ]
[ "A lone giraffe standing next to a river.", "Giraffe standing in open area near large tree'd area.", "A giraffe standing in the grass and dirt.", "A giraffe standing in dirt patch with water and bushes in the background.", "a giraffe standing in a green field next to shrubbery." ]
[ "The plane has a ladder hanging from it.", "An airplane flying through the sky above a truck.", "Someone hanging from a rope ladder from a flying airplane.", "Old time stunt man climbs a ladder from a car to a biplane.", "A person climbing a ladder on the wing of a plane in flight." ]
[ "A wooden park bench near a gnarled old tree.", "A pathway with a wooden bench next to trees.", "there is a bench under a very large tree", "A bench is shown on a path next to a tree.", " bench sitting in a park under a large tree." ]
[ "Three giraffes grazing from tree with fence in foreground.", "A couple of giraffes grazing on the little bit of foliage left on the trees.", "A group of giraffe standing next to each other on a field.", "giraffes standing around a tree eating the bark from it ", "Three giraffes eat from a tree that looks to be running out of leaves." ]
[ "A yellow school bus driving down a road.", "A photo taken from a car looking at the back of a school bus.", "School bus traveling down a residential street brakes for passing car. ", "A school bus that is stopped by a turn off.", "A large yellow school bus on a road." ]
[ "A mountain has several rocks with grass on the ground.", "Goats grazing along grassy rocky cliffs with grass growing from them.", "A herd of animals grazing on a rocky grass covered hillside.", "Several goats that are grazing on a rocky hillside. ", "A group of sheep grazing along the side of a mountain." ]
[ "A fire hydrant is sitting next to what appears to be a flooded area. ", "A yellow fire hydrant sitting next to a tree.", "A view of yellow fire hydrant near flooded water.", "A fire hydrant is near a tree in a flooded area.", "Yellow fire hydrant in flooded urban area near bridge." ]
[ "A passenger bus that is pulled up to the side of a street.", "a blue bus going down the road behind a red bus ", "A bus parked on the side of the street.", "Two large city buses are parked on the side of the road.", "A large blue bus on the side of a road." ]
[ "A large window cut into the wood wall in a room with benches along the wall.", "A room with a dirt floor, an open window and a wooden bench.", "A room with benches all along the side of it.", "A plain sauna room, bathed in sunlight, with green trees outside the window.", "Inside a wooden building with benches and an open window" ]
[ "Storm clouds are over two vehicles traveling. ", "A photo taken from a vehicle looking at an intersection.", "Cars at a stoplight with storm clouds gathering in the sky.", "The rear view of a silver car under a very cloudy sky at an intersection.", "Two vehicles stopped at an intersection with both red and green traffic signals." ]
[ "A bus that is on the side of the road.", "A large bus stopped in front of a building, letting passengers on.", "A large bus on the side of a street.", "A large green double decker bus driving down a street.", "A two tier bus stopped at a street while passengers get on." ]
[ "A closeup of a giraffe's face as it licks a young woman's face.", "A close up of a giraffe licking a woman's face.", "A giraffe gives a woman a big kiss.", "A giraffe licking the mouth of a woman", "A young lady is being licked by a giraffe while others look on. " ]
[ "The SUV is stopped in the middle of the crosswalkj.", "The car stops on the crosswalk to allow pedestrians to cross the street safely.", "there are people crossing the street and a car in the cross walk", "An SUV sitting on top of a cross walk.", "An intersection at night and the light is red." ]
[ "A wooden pier with benches over still water.", "A long wooden pier has benches on it.", "The benches are lined up on the walkway.", "A bunch of benches outside during the day.", "A wooden dock with metal railings and benches." ]
[ "A black and white cat walking in grass next to water and duck.", "A cat and a white duck near a muddy body of water", "The goose and the cat are playing by the creek.", "White goose and black and white cat at the edge of a pond.", "A cat and a goose ignore each other near a pond." ]
[ "A stuffed doll made from socks is on a wooden bench.", "There is a stuffed animal sitting on a wooden bench.", "The stuffed animal is left out on the empty bench. ", "A stuffed monkey sitting alone on a bench.", "A stuffed animal sitting on top of a bench." ]
[ "The city has a large packed tour bus driving down the road.", "A double decker sightseeing bus drives down a London street.", "There is a sightseeing bus on the side of the road.", "People sit on the roof of a tour bus.", "A red double decker bus driving through the streets of London." ]
[ "Older people sitting down on benches outside with luggage", "A man sits next to a woman and they both look surprised.", "An old man sitting next to an old woman on a bench. ", "The older couple with their walkers are sitting together on the bench. ", "A man sitting next to a woman on a park bench." ]
[ "Pair of giraffes foraging in natural wildlife area.", "Two tall giraffes eating leaves from a tree.", "Two giraffes in a field of grass with trees behind them.", "A couple of giraffe walking along a dry grass covered field.", "the giraffes are in the field and eating." ]
[ "A large group of people wearing hoods stand near a mountainside with sheep surrounding them", "a group of people standing around a herd of sheep", "A group of men in long robes standing by white sheep.", "Group of Shepherds gather around with their sheep", "A herd of sheep standing next to a group of men." ]
[ "an old black and white photo of four people sitting on a bench", "A group of men sit on a bench outside.", "An old snapshot of four men sitting on a bench.", "Four men are sitting on a bench in an old photo.", "A group of men sitting next to each other on a bench." ]
[ "A tall giraffe standing next to a metal fence. ", "A adult giraffe standing near a gate and trees.", "A giraffe standing next to a lush green forest.", "A captive giraffe looks out longingly over the fence.", "A giraffe walks on the grass near a fence." ]
[ "A woman reading a book while laying on a bench.", "A blonde woman is laying on a bench reading.", "A woman with a book is laying on a bench.", "A girl laying on a bench reading a book.", "a woman laying on a bench reading a book " ]
[ "A bus driving over a puddle of water next to a man on the street.", "The bus splashes a big puddle at the man with the umbrella.", "A person with an umbrella is walking beside a bus.", "a bus splashing through a puddle next to a man carrying an umbrella ", "A transit bus splashing through a puddle as a person walks by with an umbrella." ]
[ "A red fire hydrant is shown in the grass", "A red fire hydrant in a residential grass area.", "A red fire hydrant sitting on top of a stone planter.", "A red fire hydrant sitting in a cement bed.", "A red fire hydrant is on a cement stand." ]
[ "A couple of wooden benches and some trees.", "park benches lined up along the pathway in front of trees", "Unoccupied park benches near very unusual, leafless trees.", "Two benches on a sidewalk under a tree.", "A row of park benches sitting next to ugly trees." ]
[ "Two buses are parked in the parking lot.", "The two city buses are parked together in the lot. ", "Two buses parked next to each other on a parking lot.", "A blue bus and a green bus are parked side by side.", "Two double-decker buses are parked in a lot." ]
[ "A couple of little girls standing next to a yellow fire hydrant.", "A person and some kids standing by a fire hydrant.", "Young children with adult near yellow fire hydrant.", "two young children playing near a fire hydrant", "Two young children playing around a fire hydrant." ]
[ "An intersection that has traffic lights and street signs.", "A traffic light with various stickers encompassing it.", "A street light sitting below a building with lots of windows.", "A traffic light and some street signs on a pole.", "A picture of a street sign and light in a foreign country." ]
[ "A young man is standing next to a traffic light and a man is putting something on a woman 's waist.", "Man in an orange and black jacket walking down a sidewalk.", "A man is staring behind him as he puts his hand in his pocket, next to a traffic light.", "A man leaning against a traffic signal pole. ", "A man walking behind a very sexy fit woman." ]
[ "Two giraffes back to back standing in a savanna ", "A pair of giraffes stand in a field.", "Two giraffes standing in grassy area next to trees.", "Two giraffes stand facing opposite directions in a field of grass", "Two giraffe standing next to each other on a field." ]
[ "A row of cars at street intersection under a traffic light.", "Street intersection on cloudless day in urban setting.", "Looking down the street of a tidy town on a sunny day", "A traffic light sitting on the corner of a street under power lines.", "Cars ride on a suburban street with trees." ]
[ "A giraffe walking across a road and a truck stopped to watch", "A giraffe crossing the road in front of a tour truck.", "A giraffe walking across a street in front of a truck.", "A giraffe is crossing the street in front of a car.", "A truck is waiting for a giraffe to cross the road. " ]
[ "A couple of people that are sitting on a bench.", "Two men and one woman sitting on a low bench.", "Two men and women on park bench next to a tree.", "Two men surrounding a woman on a a bench.", "A group of people sitting next to each other near a tree." ]
[ "A giraffe grazing in the trees next to skyline.", "Tall giraffe stretching up to eat leaves out of the tree", "A giraffe is is reaching up to get leaves off a tree", "A giraffe reaching up to eat leaves from a palm tree.", "A tall giraffe eating food from a palm tree." ]
[ "People are getting on to a pink bus.", "A man getting onto a pink bus at a bus stop.", "A pink bus parked in front of a white bus in a city.", "A pink colored transit bus parked as passengers board it.", "A man getting on a pink bus in a city." ]
[ "A man asleep at the back of a bus with a paper crown on his head.", "A man sitting on a bus seat wearing a crown.", "a man sits on a seat as he rested his legs on other seats ", "Man in a paper crown asleep in a bus seat.", "The boy sitting in the seat is very tired." ]
[ "A giraffe chews on some grass in an exhibit.", "A group of three giraffe standing next to each other.", "A small group of giraffes standing between a fence and a building.", "A group of giraffes on in a fenced off area next to a building.", "A giraffe looking to its left with some hay hanging from its mouth." ]
[ "A park bench on dirt path facing towards mountains.", "A wooden bench sitting in a field with leaves.", "A wooden and metal bench with a mountain view.", "a park bench on a hill overlooking other hills", "A bench on an outlook point over a valley." ]
[ "A man is sitting on a bench in a garden.\n", "An older gentleman with a visible purple sock is sitting on the purple bench.", "A man sitting on a purple bench next to a potter filled with flowers.", "A man sitting on a bench near a variety of flowers. ", "A man sitting on a purple bench in a garden." ]
[ "Four giraffe are standing next to a tall pole.", "Four giraffes are standing next to a bare tree.", "A lot of animals that are standing near each other.", "Four giraffes eating together on an open field.", "Those could possibly be giraffes from one family." ]
[ "Two stop lights in front of the sky", "Two traffic lights sit apart on a horizontal light post.", "A somewhat blurry image of two traffic lights. ", "Two stop lights are shown in an orange sky.", "street lights on a metal pole above a street." ]
[ "A large propeller airplane flying through a blue sky.", "an airplane climbing up toward the clear sky", "A large plane in mid flight in the sky.", "A large military plane flies through the sky.", "Large plane in the air elevating higher up" ]
[ "Several buses wait in line at a bus stop.", "A green bus parked in front of a double deck bus.", "A double decker bus is following a green city bus.", "Regular bus parked at a bus stop in front of a double decker bus", "A green and a pink bus are next to a store." ]
[ "An antique bus beside a storage building full of logs.", "Old orange and yellow bus parked on grass near wood shed.", "A color bus parked on a lush green lawn.", "a colorful bus sitting in a yard next to a barn ", "Odd designed bus sits out on the grass" ]
[ "View of a train with a person in the window.", "Outside view looking into a bus window that shows a girl sitting", "The back of a persons head sitting in a train cart.", "A woman sitting next to a window wearing a white top.", "The back of a child's head pressed against a bus window." ]
[ "A semi wooded park setting with benches for sitting.", "Park with trees, green grass and a white sitting bench.", "A large tree with brown leave sitting on a lush green park.", "A open grass field and a large tree.", "a park filled with paths and some trees " ]
[ "A giraffe standing next to three other giraffe near a lake.", "There are giraffes walking alongside a lake as one is staring straight ahead.", "Three giraffes loiter about a tree and a watering hole.", "two giraffes standing around and one drinking water.", "The giraffes are enjoying the water by the trees." ]
[ "A wooden bench next to a fence and sign.", "A wooden bench sitting in front of a green fence.", "A park bench allocated as a Kodak Picture Spot at Disneyland", "A freshly painted bench sitting in front of a Kodak sign. ", "A sign denotes where a prime picture spot is, next to a bench. " ]
[ "Two giraffes in a grassy field next to trees.", "Two giraffes standing still in the middle of green pasture.", "Two giraffes enjoying themselves in a field while cars drive by.", "Two baby giraffe standing next to each other on a grass field.", "Two baby giraffes are standing in a grassy field. " ]
[ "The lobby features several wooden benches for sitting..", "A deck area containing tables, chairs benches, a tree and a giraffe statue.", "A black giraffe statue next to wooden patio furniture.", "An enclosed patio with wood benches, large potted plants and a large ceramic giraffe in the corner.", "A statue of a giraffe standing next to lots of wood furniture." ]
[ "a large air plane flying in the sky", "A white, blue and red jet airliner flying in blue sky.", "Looking up at a modern jet airplane taking off", "An airplane is flying through the air with it's landing gear down.", "A large jetliner flying through the air in a blue sky." ]
[ "A pole holding bulletins stands next to a stoplight with a smiley face.", "A telephone pole plastered with papers on a city corner.", "Black and white photograph of traffic lights next to a bridge.", "A traffic light sitting on the side of a road.", "A stoplight is on a post littered with flyers, on the side of the road. " ]
[ "Two men sit on a bench and watch as water spurts up near a big tower", "Two men are sitting on the bench watching a water fountain.", "two people sitting at a bench with a view of a fountain", "Two men are sitting outside enjoying the fountain show.", "An array of fountains by a park bench with men sitting on it." ]
[ "A bench near water in a wooded area.", "A bench is kept on the ground surrounded by greenery.", "Wooden bench sitting out along the river in the open", "A park bench is sitting in some woods beside a stream.", "A wooden bench sitting in the middle of a park." ]
[ "A row of different colored wood benches sitting next to each other.", "A park with green, blue, white, yellow and red park benches.", "Several park benches are painted all different colors.", "A row of park benches in park next to trees.", "A row of different colored benches in a park." ]
[ "A series of traffic lights is on the poles over the road.", " A row of traffic lights above a street at night.", "The colorful lights are illuminating the darkened street.", "Traffic lights hang above train tracks at night", "night time at a railroad crossing, yellow, red and green lights shown above" ]
[ "A small group of people are on their bikes riding together. ", "A group of people riding motor bikes on an urban street.", "A woman riding a motor cycle next to a man.", "Some women in scarves are riding on motorcycles.", "The view form a motor cycle in oriental city traffic" ]
[ "Yellow city bus changing lanes on a city street.", "A yellow bus is going down the street.", "The bus appears to be pulling away from the curb.", "A yellow bus travelling on a city street. ", "A yellow bus driving down a street next to tall buildings." ]
[ "A stuffed lamb is sitting next to another stuffed animal", "A group of stuffed animal boys sitting on top of a cushion.", "A toy stuffed sheep next to a teddy bear.", "Two small stuffed animals sit next to one another. ", "Two stuffed animals one sheep one teddy bear." ]
[ "There must have been a bad storm that came through this city.", "A street scene at an intersection with snow everywhere.", "The street and path are covered with snow.", "buildings and streets covered with snow at an intersection", "A street covered in snow surrounded by buildings." ]
[ "A park bench is in the white fluffy snow.", "A snow covered ski slope with lots of trees.", "The snow covered hillside is ready for the sledders.", "A bench with snow around it and trees with no leaves", "a snowy landscape surrounded by lifeless trees and a bench" ]
[ "Two giraffes walking next to each other in a brass and sand enclosure.", "Two giraffes walking away outside side by side.", "two giraffes walking beside each other in a zoo", "two giraffes walk side by side in a enclosed area ", "A pair of giraffe is standing on the ground." ]
[ "A small boy is sitting on a cement bench.", "A young boy sitting on a wooden bench in the sun", "A young boy is sitting on the wooden bench. ", "A boy in green shirt sitting at a concrete bench next to trees.", "A young boy sitting on a stone bench in an arid landscape" ]
[ "People getting on a triple decker bus on display.", "A unique looking purple double-buss has people boarding. ", "An empty tripple decker bus with two people about to get inside.", "The huge bus has three stories on it.", "A picture of a triple decker purple bus. " ]
[ "A city bus at the curb in a parking area.", "Bus with orange and blue stripes in turning corner.", "A bus is currently reading \"55 Transp Center\" ", "A bus is rolling down a street in pursuit of passengers.", "The bus is stopped at the street corner." ]
[ "A city fire hydrant in front of a graffiti building.", "The side of a brick building with graffiti on it. ", "An old fire hydrant is next to a spray painted wall.", "A rusty fire hydrant sits on a street in front of grafitti.", "Graffiti spray painted onto a wall behind an old fire hydrant" ]
[ "A modern ate sculpture on display outdoors with a traffic light visible in the background.", "A traffic light hanging over a city street.", "A black and white view of a sculpture in an urban environment.", "A swirling statue stands next to a street intersection.", "Modern art sculpture displayed outside in metropolitan setting." ]