id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10544v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10544v2 | Pretraining Without Attention | 2022-12-20T18:50:08 | 2023-05-09T01:08:20 | Junxiong Wang, Jing Nathan Yan, Albert Gu, Alexander M. Rush | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Transformers have been essential to pretraining success in NLP. While other
architectures have been used, downstream accuracy is either significantly
worse, or requires attention layers to match standard benchmarks such as GLUE.
This work explores pretraining without attention by using recent advances in
sequence routing based on state-space models (SSMs). Our proposed model,
Bidirectional Gated SSM (BiGS), combines SSM layers with a multiplicative
gating architecture that has been effective in simplified sequence modeling
architectures. The model learns static layers that do not consider pair-wise
interactions. Even so, BiGS is able to match BERT pretraining accuracy on GLUE
and can be extended to long-form pretraining of 4096 tokens without
approximation. Analysis shows that while the models have similar average
accuracy, the approach has different inductive biases than BERT in terms of
interactions and syntactic representations. All models from this work are
available at https://github.com/jxiw/BiGS. | [
0.0201282836,
0.0480977148,
-0.0035250161,
0.008069708,
-0.0258341134,
-0.0098448945,
0.0164259002,
-0.0238922369,
0.013909149,
-0.065498285,
-0.0236584749,
-0.0574479438,
-0.0092501808,
0.0201028325,
0.0538138747,
-0.0508263186,
0.0807204172,
0.0133946501,
-0.0002499055,
0.0038597619,
0.0128611159,
-0.0315207988,
-0.0195394959,
0.0769937038,
-0.0264566746,
-0.0094073555,
-0.0303019006,
0.0015162637,
-0.0053326287,
-0.0564921238,
0.0072589573,
0.0941622406,
0.0212598387,
0.0090173427,
0.0000018944,
-0.0274326131,
-0.0128955096,
-0.0014877903,
0.0019815529,
0.041067984,
-0.070221968,
0.0270307735,
-0.003517976,
0.0424612314,
-0.0563247576,
-0.0492269136,
0.0593569465,
0.0569092631,
0.0953974873,
0.1083220392,
-0.0123625258,
-0.037571501,
0.0383543447,
-0.0550552085,
0.007677278,
-0.0425502062,
0.0306152478,
-0.0500755943,
-0.0296006277,
-0.0108051216,
-0.0532030202,
0.0111204367,
0.0186894741,
0.0430292934,
0.0214088503,
0.0338078141,
-0.0526815504,
-0.0304586161,
-0.0365195237,
0.1007238552,
-0.0525836051,
-0.0188332368,
0.0162666738,
-0.0018233564,
-0.0155440578,
-0.0038129608,
-0.0105146477,
-0.010322121,
0.030212475,
0.0163501427,
0.013684852,
-0.0378007628,
0.0382059775,
-0.0141734928,
-0.0562105738,
0.0326701701,
0.0126291066,
-0.0600381419,
-0.0197959822,
0.0255209096,
-0.0239814799,
-0.0750827417,
0.0306572039,
0.0482742675,
0.0046326509,
0.027602274,
-0.04434181,
-0.0353464074,
0.0006061013,
-0.0500662513,
0.0002204986,
0.0645597056,
-0.0138084507,
0.020998545,
-0.0290020648,
0.0328829065,
-0.0046406826,
0.0382127278,
-0.0352079161,
0.0418827832,
-0.0235424843,
-0.0131096747,
-0.0710694268,
0.0592812784,
-0.0320322402,
-0.0519776903,
-0.0348559059,
0.0017789252,
0.0134286648,
-0.0243401639,
0.0249643717,
0.0111266784,
-0.0043439674,
0.0180323962,
-0.0066096578,
0.0320008025,
-0.0300486032,
0.0036876511,
-0.0112025049,
-0.0321536362,
-0.0624091849,
0.0210444257,
0.0055518402,
-0.0206610579,
0.0106001934,
0.0553912781,
0.0071131308,
-0.100208357,
-0.052654814,
0.0015177213,
0.0113417497,
-0.0302767567,
0.0241444446,
-0.0187650621,
0.0396517068,
0.0103575364,
0.0113663888,
-0.0264731031,
0.0171606001,
0.0190353058,
-0.0134779969,
0.0615598038,
0.014184989,
-0.0236654673,
-0.0571123324,
0.0122401379,
0.007797705,
0.0264226831,
0.0462250933,
-0.0104073314,
0.0130946916,
-0.0350440629,
0.0207743235,
0.0324091725,
0.0643893778,
-0.0214538798,
0.0100619271,
0.0030011209,
0.001750097,
0.00970555,
0.029425187,
0.0469187386,
-0.0494230129,
-0.0038480631,
0.048563797,
0.0669645965,
0.0219877604,
0.0673970878,
0.0516769812,
0.0245636236,
0.0037121212,
0.0145501215,
-0.0306273773,
0.0255021043,
-0.0031592746,
0.0178399738,
0.0666072294,
0.0166843887,
-0.0427822471,
-0.0116060814,
0.0051776399,
-0.014636742,
-0.0015890668,
-0.024070235,
0.0363948792,
0.0139921373,
-0.0919861943,
0.08249107,
0.0102700824,
-0.0617963299,
0.013249048,
-0.0180092435,
-0.0123847043,
0.0345581472,
0.0421741903,
-0.028229041,
-0.0653464794,
-0.0007913008,
-0.0268925074,
0.0348072425,
0.0296472665,
0.0009604672,
-0.006898195,
-0.0593464151,
-0.0059752776,
0.0231281891,
0.0063638082,
0.0163189769,
0.0068531609,
-0.0088022556,
0.0177993421,
0.0038201967,
0.0099073164,
0.0504157469,
-0.0423488654,
-0.0470457077,
-0.0119451415,
0.0246659052,
0.04394719,
0.0251499321,
-0.0178459473,
0.0406680107,
0.0546572879,
-0.002256202,
-0.0241630357,
0.004579877,
-0.0915888026,
-0.0664206967,
0.0340392739,
0.0110507272,
-0.002718667,
0.0415486842,
-0.0375381969,
-0.0520611815,
0.0188203715,
-0.0544096008,
0.0926077664,
-0.0508851707,
0.0318755992,
0.0612828173,
0.0336496867,
-0.0197073128,
0.0237072054,
-0.0413407534,
0.0144124115,
-0.0113128209,
0.0222331118,
0.0099014016,
-0.0109551819,
-0.0467783399,
-0.0177949592,
-0.0091011124,
0.0107177356,
-0.0072942795,
-0.0052340925,
-0.0395981111,
-0.0047268923,
-0.0648500249,
0.0042833267,
-0.0388174243,
0.0537357815,
0.0074349963,
0.0311416332,
0.0148248952,
-0.0076375231,
-0.0093619246,
-0.0296731982,
-0.0085128089,
0.006312158,
0.0327970311,
0.0042361747,
-0.0410721451,
-0.0336849354,
-0.0242445357,
-0.0301512834,
0.0383089595,
-0.0407785662,
-0.0102488808,
-0.0341539308,
-0.0357108153,
-0.0153422793,
0.0607485473,
-0.0052309516,
-0.0653227791,
0.0001153696,
-0.0111367879,
0.0746878907,
0.0275824834,
0.0183627345,
0.0130166225,
-0.001473909,
-0.0037429358,
-0.0145286191,
0.0420230031,
-0.0444792807,
0.0418872498,
-0.0324621722,
0.0363112353,
0.0352306701,
0.0967261791,
-0.0414978676,
-0.0254069883,
-0.0831546411,
-0.0184080265,
0.0093480516,
-0.0013800154,
0.0254740305,
-0.0182890128,
-0.0443428755,
-0.0137352068,
-0.0240969397,
-0.0135433758,
0.0566572659,
-0.0569535419,
-0.0259581488,
-0.0494342037,
0.0294345133,
-0.0263925157,
0.0569506958,
0.0321577303,
-0.0123526566,
-0.0169535838,
-0.0435366221,
-0.0026493846,
0.0100687165,
-0.0214154217,
-0.0219924711,
0.0537564941,
-0.0073689376,
0.0308953691,
-0.0175257735,
-0.016247306,
-0.0356370509,
-0.0307090022,
-0.0112230442,
0.0094993003,
0.0312887691,
-0.0376318246,
-0.047707051,
0.0295428354,
0.0054692114,
0.076493144,
-0.0016145891,
0.025654925,
-0.0305481218,
0.0433229282,
0.0141192898,
-0.0180342477,
0.0026975914,
-0.0322008133,
-0.0098145651,
0.0461185127,
0.0537343435,
-0.0130022028,
-0.0208304189,
-0.0123082791,
0.0398715064,
-0.0746977329,
-0.0271012299,
0.0212993901,
0.0158274639,
-0.0565232486,
-0.0275530163,
0.133176282,
0.0358122028,
-0.0443872511,
0.0334284455,
0.045488961,
-0.0082801245,
-0.0009589816,
0.0049674711,
-0.0699896142,
-0.0468181036,
0.009768717,
-0.0020093361,
0.0216774028,
-0.0313110091,
-0.013816392,
-0.0894103721,
-0.0213246252,
0.0008799278,
-0.0671129748,
-0.032550104,
-0.0625702292,
-0.0177830681,
-0.0000312371,
0.0112123871,
0.0313398018,
-0.0082247863,
0.0101384111,
0.0223566201,
-0.0309406053,
-0.0351952165,
0.0145939011,
-0.0390291326,
0.0538036115,
0.0806254745,
0.0176956952,
0.0009409017,
-0.0570861772,
0.0779609978,
-0.0253676157,
0.0102958484,
-0.0369361453,
0.0298251715,
-0.0702947974,
-0.0079800673,
-0.010153641,
0.0002476218,
-0.0477513596,
-0.0011813962,
-0.0297790691,
0.0759745464,
-0.005629295,
-0.0048935376,
-0.0145567376,
0.00775926,
-0.0037961868,
0.0537854955,
0.0166125651,
-0.0397934392,
-0.0705308169,
-0.0063358461,
0.0159164257,
-0.0429541506,
-0.0275514927,
-0.0196483675,
-0.0007975851,
-0.0391207151,
-0.0556851923,
-0.0691154599,
0.0346519984,
0.0584870167,
-0.0028891847,
-0.0123348022,
0.0569059812,
-0.0004912648,
-0.0277819689,
0.0610944629,
0.0130635099,
0.0073033157,
-0.063433975,
-0.0394918881,
0.0275640003,
0.0136179356,
-0.0368884318,
-0.0091586541,
-0.0390852056,
-0.0541960001,
-0.0087489141,
0.0741837025,
0.01514351,
0.0245817434,
-0.0060028159,
-0.0153386537,
0.0132554332,
0.0463921465,
-0.0123619223,
-0.0154838031,
0.051381629,
-0.0235009249,
0.0081103723,
0.0074820118,
0.0101811122,
0.0289355386,
0.0226579923,
0.1115659699,
-0.0085191494,
0.0073065571,
0.0073330877,
0.0021981574,
0.0911127925,
0.0190295428,
0.0435185917,
-0.0111091388,
0.0496179685,
-0.0071278131,
0.026528459,
-0.0386008732,
-0.0062662177,
0.0089434031,
0.0258801598,
-0.0315895267,
-0.0194487441,
-0.0128441053,
0.0201088022,
0.0048400713,
0.0277519971,
-0.0078847082,
-0.0204513818,
0.0248116218,
-0.0318188965,
-0.0091613242,
-0.0386853106,
0.0157119241,
0.0031238126,
-0.0176698938,
0.0333763324,
0.0343640521,
0.0506249964,
0.0007646739,
0.0410098359,
-0.0405758582,
-0.0090478146,
-0.0483305417,
0.0270176828,
0.0920472965,
-0.0132997353,
0.0431680158,
-0.0084597897,
0.0215763822,
-0.0066658924,
0.0448706374,
-0.0219933931,
-0.0257174168,
0.0219763219,
0.030718632,
-0.0137615688,
-0.0096538495,
0.0965463668,
-0.0012454015,
0.042616725,
0.0041376511,
-0.0133153703,
-0.0298917573,
-0.051628489,
0.0279377885,
0.0438499078,
-0.0415642858,
0.0269051306,
-0.0401296094,
-0.0746741444,
-0.0022970645,
-0.0050788908,
0.0146458298,
-0.005604371,
0.0572108515,
0.0542661808,
0.001902075,
-0.0307676513,
-0.0134572536,
-0.0137757575,
-0.0016520023,
-0.0447911695,
-0.0195752606,
-6.43542676e-33,
-0.0071692099,
-0.0109495427,
0.0361895226,
-0.0000760773,
-0.0641039908,
-0.0018057522,
-0.0546770468,
-0.0079978956,
-0.0145616895,
-0.0233111456,
-0.0262620766,
0.0038585875,
0.0035233279,
0.0463854708,
-0.0062349997,
-0.0121390643,
0.0476656556,
0.0205106735,
-0.0050088516,
0.0090943407,
-0.0257329307,
0.0620678924,
0.0603040829,
0.0137913274,
-0.0270855669,
-0.01654258,
0.0292972736,
0.0012553659,
-0.0300320983,
0.014091515,
-0.024715459,
-0.0040088645,
0.0214693099,
-0.0274300836,
-0.0044491352,
0.0344801247,
-0.0691628605,
-0.0262543187,
0.0289095771,
0.0062928908,
-0.0319251344,
0.0174301621,
0.031836953,
0.0166024081,
-0.0006232571,
0.0301102176,
0.0203172825,
0.0307398401,
-0.0390904471,
-0.0154707162,
-0.0524693131,
0.0180752166,
0.0083598532,
-0.0221353229,
0.006704133,
0.0497748889,
-0.0141875362,
-0.0030998087,
-0.0466288701,
-0.0131296888,
0.0161438882,
0.0598683394,
0.0150973527,
0.0148269925,
0.0336847901,
0.0193907116,
0.0049805548,
-0.0050441111,
-0.0303880516,
0.0083384085,
0.0445279628,
0.0064579109,
0.0146793127,
-0.0693915263,
0.0329372026,
-0.0156304855,
-0.0506004989,
-0.0115567567,
0.0424831845,
0.0470408425,
0.0128928721,
0.0125486841,
0.0089436844,
0.0097560072,
-0.010767038,
0.0117732268,
-0.0116802948,
-0.0394336171,
0.0164967403,
0.0528551526,
-0.0012974456,
0.0302777849,
0.0328012221,
0.0014257666,
0.0070441915,
0.01189199,
0.0192111805,
-0.0036426482,
-0.0165194552,
0.0192848574,
-0.100348711,
-0.0347114615,
0.0060119475,
-0.0036879627,
-0.0089192251,
-0.0128905233,
0.0341095254,
0.0036167149,
-0.0507158414,
-0.0166417584,
-0.0409692414,
0.0138495527,
-0.0209336989,
0.0389665291,
0.0653431341,
0.0340993106,
-0.0067928429,
0.0582323559,
-0.0035135874,
-0.0057374956,
-0.0241434034,
0.0219442062,
0.0155459391,
0.0291691907,
-0.0033400583,
-0.0181423407,
-0.0510330498,
0.0406720415,
-0.019271126,
-0.1081557125,
-0.0335525796,
0.0111509059,
2.753e-7,
0.0256437808,
0.0438211188,
0.0558110587,
0.0379382484,
0.0078250421,
0.0107920067,
-0.014129539,
0.0392705798,
-0.0080671972,
0.0406797901,
0.031672921,
0.0034261753,
0.0044337711,
-0.0493602231,
-0.1054696888,
-0.0182185397,
-0.1014383957,
0.017836798,
-0.0490891933,
-0.0094042551,
0.0183206294,
0.0806643963,
0.0009619184,
0.0148941064,
0.0005915801,
-0.0311049931,
0.0516179055,
0.0440651588,
0.000657679,
0.0101587782,
0.0025476706,
0.0092225047,
-0.0272661969,
0.0312535502,
-0.0420506857,
0.0349823423,
-0.032709416,
0.0525238104,
-0.0147451712,
-0.0649741367,
0.0263387784,
0.0065977937,
-0.0082083158,
-0.0184336379,
0.0480234884,
-0.0547788218,
-0.022862142,
0.0252971668,
-0.0831754953,
0.0124722924,
-0.0191507507,
0.0186423529,
-0.0202183854,
0.0350087844,
0.0311520081,
-0.0114214784,
0.0264303815,
-0.0974212363,
0.0003216519,
0.007788809,
-0.0349435024,
-0.0127764922,
-0.0511604995,
-0.0002450308,
0.0188258793,
-0.0216219891,
-0.052636113,
2.759610283e-34,
0.0512441359,
-0.0566116385,
0.041627489,
0.0492849275,
0.0127679706,
-0.0142463325,
-0.0033130362,
-0.0051571047,
0.0210688915,
-0.0675777942,
-0.052331645
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10543v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10543v2 | Detoxifying Text with MaRCo: Controllable Revision with Experts and Anti-Experts | 2022-12-20T18:50:00 | 2023-05-26T20:26:06 | Skyler Hallinan, Alisa Liu, Yejin Choi, Maarten Sap | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Text detoxification has the potential to mitigate the harms of toxicity by
rephrasing text to remove offensive meaning, but subtle toxicity remains
challenging to tackle. We introduce MaRCo, a detoxification algorithm that
combines controllable generation and text rewriting methods using a Product of
Experts with autoencoder language models (LMs). MaRCo uses likelihoods under a
non-toxic LM (expert) and a toxic LM (anti-expert) to find candidate words to
mask and potentially replace. We evaluate our method on several subtle toxicity
and microaggressions datasets, and show that it not only outperforms baselines
on automatic metrics, but MaRCo's rewrites are preferred 2.1 $\times$ more in
human evaluation. Its applicability to instances of subtle toxicity is
especially promising, demonstrating a path forward for addressing increasingly
elusive online hate. | [
0.0680085346,
0.0821111724,
-0.0333125107,
0.0115414625,
-0.0287269522,
0.0201605,
0.0459766723,
0.0163683593,
0.000584135,
-0.036812719,
-0.0294571649,
0.0184650123,
-0.0092901746,
0.081031695,
0.0201631039,
-0.0328178033,
0.0121753113,
0.0446311645,
0.0264810212,
-0.0202003196,
0.0407164097,
0.0305551756,
0.0282942485,
0.0550484993,
-0.0272899866,
0.0074095805,
0.0612980798,
0.0180287398,
0.0270679351,
0.0053975619,
0.033483237,
0.0360399261,
-0.0025565615,
0.0554010384,
0.0000019843,
-0.019967448,
-0.011708701,
-0.022973096,
0.0032896083,
-0.0090829916,
0.0648388863,
-0.0459642038,
-0.0025785959,
0.0464734696,
-0.0302468948,
0.0272548608,
0.0416302755,
-0.000099501,
0.0957071483,
0.0768241137,
-0.0355002806,
0.0117139509,
0.0126055116,
-0.0235086549,
0.0061294064,
0.0493540764,
0.0524820462,
-0.03630412,
-0.0779794678,
-0.0028860513,
-0.0343790725,
0.0459858924,
0.0411646292,
-0.024159357,
0.0360192023,
-0.0307390653,
0.0316702798,
-0.0471229479,
0.004848747,
0.05243681,
-0.0579248182,
-0.0151866814,
0.0115550198,
-0.0040972796,
-0.0247501358,
0.0029250423,
-0.0038495355,
-0.0008861061,
0.0108271642,
0.0088032279,
-0.0370023549,
0.0084279031,
0.0323377699,
0.0425218306,
0.0153563917,
0.0274235904,
0.0359900519,
-0.0357369408,
-0.013511721,
-0.0363931842,
-0.0093897572,
-0.0266641285,
0.0584730431,
-0.0085990485,
-0.0238633342,
0.0016895317,
-0.0719986558,
-0.07281591,
-0.0049289321,
-0.0520558171,
0.0365764946,
0.0060174246,
-0.0056974906,
0.0035384018,
-0.0049121417,
0.0048189526,
0.0098979296,
0.0145714441,
-0.0133493105,
0.018632561,
0.0157769006,
0.001617237,
-0.0156861302,
-0.01378066,
-0.0218669232,
-0.0052613039,
-0.0531514399,
0.0003877043,
-0.0708983243,
-0.0190548804,
-0.0384076834,
0.0509751104,
-0.0404966474,
-0.0014273498,
-0.0022160788,
0.0126532614,
-0.0402355157,
0.0275253672,
-0.0306449924,
-0.0237822402,
0.0003902647,
0.0411651507,
0.003345957,
-0.0381935202,
0.0170090869,
0.0726111755,
0.0180324167,
0.0090045985,
-0.0026793624,
-0.0464239493,
-0.0565369576,
0.0003136173,
-0.0323869735,
-0.0563349351,
0.0331060141,
-0.0614000708,
-0.0232967436,
-0.1308988184,
0.0063096122,
0.0008238091,
-0.0375202894,
0.0596615151,
0.0109900832,
-0.0277600493,
0.0605215468,
0.0191189516,
0.0010416701,
0.016531799,
0.0402185917,
0.0782211795,
0.0396684706,
-0.0174118988,
0.0317015909,
0.0476442873,
0.0331032164,
0.017009005,
-0.0657878146,
-0.0127726225,
-0.03312115,
0.0197541751,
0.0417472273,
0.0735565275,
-0.0070185242,
-0.0472361594,
0.0679460019,
0.0181382094,
-0.0432081297,
0.0504851528,
0.0786346421,
0.0464373119,
-0.0475120023,
-0.0257236194,
-0.0346894003,
-0.0122603122,
-0.0211752504,
-0.042154707,
0.0564737469,
0.0398382992,
-0.003594226,
-0.0631030649,
0.0093260948,
0.0006943878,
0.0343598723,
-0.0266119502,
0.0234093722,
0.0490391664,
-0.0470062606,
-0.0273594502,
0.041966226,
-0.0454904065,
0.0321979523,
-0.0523804352,
0.0027611055,
0.0822272003,
0.0777412206,
0.0139837125,
0.0272633564,
-0.0736368746,
-0.0443842784,
0.0158684719,
-0.0156373624,
-0.0130338976,
0.0014769773,
-0.0367297381,
-0.0450309329,
-0.0018613947,
0.0133430902,
-0.0041364734,
0.026055377,
0.0146297039,
0.0267066061,
0.0109372186,
-0.0413034447,
0.050511539,
0.0140582444,
-0.0391434431,
0.0155478949,
0.0408295654,
0.027928913,
0.0044384124,
-0.0265352167,
-0.0180330426,
0.0044548488,
-0.029369764,
-0.0530059449,
-0.0225560758,
-0.0160588752,
-0.0203526486,
0.0202321429,
-0.0666669235,
-0.000050042,
0.1034967303,
0.0003674814,
0.0165140983,
0.0401716754,
-0.0417661071,
-0.0417668186,
-0.0101849753,
-0.0137395617,
-0.0442166068,
0.0188571047,
-0.0070334272,
0.0324248448,
-0.0261473414,
-0.002684406,
0.014479138,
-0.0364579819,
0.0021352421,
-0.0011993954,
-0.0483855903,
-0.0750479475,
-0.0100221857,
-0.0003566158,
0.0380829908,
0.0169125684,
-0.0125320265,
-0.016955277,
-0.0538512096,
-0.0143138468,
-0.026839545,
-0.0217943471,
0.0473934971,
0.0177002884,
-0.0050111711,
0.0250320453,
-0.01830451,
-0.0531647429,
0.009400662,
0.0278053302,
0.0158531815,
-0.0433336124,
-0.0170386583,
-0.0304405335,
-0.0156996902,
-0.0001674612,
0.0530904233,
0.0061959056,
-0.0632956922,
0.0498551354,
0.0253435168,
-0.0547794104,
-0.0131447753,
0.0009279769,
-0.083944574,
0.0168107897,
0.0205407478,
0.026822703,
0.038622357,
0.0477733873,
0.0790180936,
0.0433151945,
0.0150376037,
-0.0238837916,
-0.0130187636,
-0.0299613401,
0.0027496188,
-0.0075748544,
-0.0794357732,
0.0171377212,
0.0438756011,
0.0759551153,
-0.0068150279,
-0.0428597964,
0.0650300831,
-0.0338330716,
-0.055812601,
-0.0230871048,
-0.0618324541,
-0.0161412545,
-0.009627277,
-0.062202163,
-0.0593845285,
0.0890201926,
0.029147312,
0.037399102,
-0.0165840071,
-0.0066944631,
0.0225251876,
0.0213289335,
-0.0068780384,
0.053724356,
-0.0180998966,
0.002789316,
0.0105865858,
0.0034095556,
0.047228653,
-0.0101036644,
-0.0379757732,
-0.0531296805,
-0.0105539598,
0.0586618483,
-0.0303284805,
-0.0433817022,
-0.06605234,
-0.0032672621,
-0.0309277847,
0.0596122369,
-0.0064028166,
-0.041566696,
0.0110177733,
0.0226093885,
-0.0051359413,
0.0039616148,
-0.0049826591,
0.0215070937,
-0.0076313135,
0.0508323014,
-0.0550713949,
0.0039200345,
-0.0016719841,
0.0227698535,
0.0720840171,
-0.024784049,
-0.0225842297,
0.0057939887,
0.0371987894,
-0.0169154443,
0.0299280547,
0.0318693779,
0.0014531335,
0.0174556598,
-0.0096261306,
-0.0200679023,
0.0913062394,
0.0106426654,
-0.0130403526,
0.0133679183,
0.0181507356,
0.0268182252,
0.006044738,
-0.0128741506,
-0.0898197964,
-0.0015203025,
-0.0121086901,
0.0478254892,
-0.0736177266,
-0.0446225181,
0.0059878533,
-0.0577853136,
0.0079730777,
0.0139123872,
-0.0046744668,
-0.0428048223,
-0.0120971752,
0.0077760722,
-0.0181242973,
0.0015990788,
-0.0319263153,
0.0245542098,
-0.005948287,
-0.0118210204,
-0.0309438016,
-0.0205909852,
-0.0125524318,
-0.0163578559,
0.0550180189,
0.0375343822,
0.0465536602,
-0.0183115378,
-0.0013513145,
0.0305637922,
0.0140645048,
-0.0215530004,
-0.0324789695,
0.0818959624,
-0.0226789061,
-0.0132808108,
-0.0158956088,
0.0790111423,
-0.0015110947,
0.0006815672,
0.011494102,
0.0214599986,
0.0180078261,
-0.0379860476,
-0.0236487053,
0.0101881819,
0.0277205836,
0.0769505128,
0.0627524704,
-0.057105694,
0.0102479495,
-0.0734566599,
-0.0082044676,
-0.0527911857,
-0.0721618831,
-0.0538989417,
-0.0335207507,
-0.0519191362,
-0.0664720014,
-0.0323143266,
0.0501619615,
0.013527018,
0.0444165133,
-0.0562273376,
-0.017997941,
-0.0336877219,
-0.0337078013,
-0.0017839801,
0.0043547256,
0.0271173604,
-0.017972881,
-0.0107421838,
-0.0561702475,
0.0014261758,
-0.0225079432,
0.0484906398,
-0.053449858,
-0.0555069856,
0.0675371662,
0.0689683706,
0.0234194994,
0.0171872396,
-0.007885565,
-0.0564569309,
0.0748163089,
0.0377900712,
-0.0388227366,
0.0180201344,
0.0365439542,
0.0204802584,
0.0209586676,
0.0245861933,
-0.0183150116,
0.0319254659,
0.0500466153,
0.0008959983,
-0.0433259346,
-0.0023268915,
0.0043903282,
-0.0070239939,
0.0075011486,
-0.0330489911,
-0.0192061402,
-0.0503717996,
-0.0205429588,
-0.0251996964,
-0.0322101712,
-0.0161474384,
0.0270894151,
0.0489254259,
0.0264792554,
-0.046680484,
0.0265697818,
-0.0502996296,
-0.0096801678,
-0.0795208365,
-0.0137563786,
0.023330614,
0.0325155221,
0.0454655625,
0.0246150084,
-0.0235820301,
0.0578600094,
0.0041798004,
-0.0095921168,
-0.0018683099,
-0.0045100627,
0.0109802233,
0.0184735991,
-0.002310903,
0.0132997707,
-0.0098034088,
-0.0229208544,
-0.0698591396,
-0.0080632167,
-0.023939563,
0.0119294981,
0.0319472849,
-0.0090551609,
-0.0261007752,
-0.0068438081,
0.0202602874,
-0.0286449119,
-0.0332997292,
-0.0151174599,
-0.0175930113,
-0.0296778046,
0.0197208691,
0.0595109947,
0.0010909323,
0.0761042684,
0.0291724466,
-0.0421938598,
-0.0350656733,
0.0058884914,
0.0222934745,
0.034272112,
0.0063868994,
-0.0007555469,
-0.0417999886,
-0.0511124581,
0.0172555596,
-0.0326923057,
0.0084859123,
-0.0071888478,
0.0213661715,
0.0371783152,
-0.0124851186,
0.0478568636,
-0.0142103964,
0.0620338731,
0.0375990979,
-0.071594812,
-0.0426058508,
-6.208085418e-33,
0.0203944091,
-0.0377862342,
-0.0418504737,
-0.0341128744,
0.0100303441,
-0.0127479276,
-0.0006005163,
-0.0097681824,
0.0240738429,
0.038939137,
0.020920245,
0.0083771516,
-0.0121800443,
0.0229142606,
-0.0097006923,
0.0111670252,
0.0781570897,
-0.0169174112,
-0.0337104909,
0.019565342,
0.0261824001,
0.0374623314,
-0.0037745868,
-0.0771850497,
0.0479033627,
-0.005487428,
-0.0414837003,
0.015108685,
0.0083123697,
0.0348807909,
-0.0152566899,
0.0805265531,
-0.0013817243,
0.0138361165,
-0.0139798811,
0.0353156179,
-0.0331005044,
-0.016931979,
0.0070446716,
-0.0356933698,
-0.0255634189,
-0.0419959947,
0.0866095945,
0.0133189606,
-0.0222902484,
-0.0027159762,
0.0463910811,
-0.0196302887,
0.0148392906,
-0.0696167052,
-0.0522659346,
0.007780198,
-0.0432518534,
-0.0378041901,
-0.0124060689,
0.0066504832,
0.0295047704,
0.0029505601,
-0.072069861,
0.0231173802,
-0.0080911089,
0.0034902503,
0.0200551655,
-0.0327227488,
0.0187197346,
0.0701372623,
-0.0112798726,
0.0515655875,
-0.0187470764,
0.0264671613,
0.0335478485,
0.0119617451,
0.0501858145,
0.0344557799,
0.0223285947,
-0.0945078209,
-0.0325918086,
0.0183844566,
0.0021202359,
0.0201428682,
0.0053865407,
0.0026371179,
-0.0394129492,
-0.0423995517,
-0.0297739282,
-0.0713098124,
-0.0351178087,
-0.0181041863,
0.0072810422,
-0.008552378,
-0.0570477583,
-0.0385579318,
-0.0241976548,
-0.0247712061,
0.0203123223,
0.0115486747,
-0.0229385551,
0.0118764061,
0.0230611358,
0.0179491509,
-0.0271158349,
0.0468718894,
0.0198311005,
0.0005562318,
0.0271878876,
-0.0243859515,
0.0610391647,
0.0391571335,
-0.0567747876,
0.0086028147,
-0.038461335,
0.0474619418,
0.0379459411,
0.0163838938,
-0.0301747508,
0.0720787719,
-0.0072676255,
-0.0406588838,
0.0439131632,
-0.0059979889,
-0.0184901487,
-0.0044669947,
0.0295806602,
0.0093327221,
-0.0333114974,
-0.0274210908,
-0.0179442689,
0.0244014487,
0.0482570939,
-0.0918809846,
0.0031411808,
-0.0503784418,
2.734e-7,
0.0577838011,
0.0398210622,
0.0266460069,
-0.0216609202,
0.0194389261,
0.0393476896,
0.0700092241,
0.0271226987,
-0.0005737077,
-0.0015945862,
0.0060554682,
0.0241304971,
0.0348638073,
0.0073357914,
0.0107278777,
-0.003177081,
-0.0532426462,
0.0084777223,
-0.052372992,
-0.0091122156,
0.0167996734,
0.0672740638,
0.0691820681,
-0.0373128168,
-0.0199391861,
-0.0091090938,
0.0278831497,
-0.0572800338,
-0.0141579751,
0.0156365633,
0.0401740745,
0.0100761075,
0.0192743223,
-0.030499205,
-0.0177198462,
-0.030616086,
0.0160203651,
0.0552219823,
-0.0098543391,
-0.0216982234,
0.0065353033,
-0.0160803255,
-0.0006973092,
-0.019105833,
0.0535166673,
-0.0065350533,
0.0050090165,
-0.0230462961,
-0.0317960791,
-0.0048524924,
0.0628417656,
-0.0683590621,
-0.0476166233,
0.006517645,
0.0364919566,
0.0486506484,
0.0034100991,
-0.0638196766,
-0.0136480713,
-0.0276684407,
-0.0413269997,
-0.0292145833,
-0.0381520763,
-0.0033171759,
0.0071725012,
-0.0083155399,
0.0553378724,
2.471088408e-34,
0.0311540961,
-0.0103346873,
-0.0179458987,
-0.0396373831,
0.0461313464,
0.0165838022,
-0.0106019489,
0.0035723245,
0.0146053061,
-0.0497161895,
-0.0272310004
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10539v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10539v1 | Toward Human Readable Prompt Tuning: Kubrick's The Shining is a good movie, and a good prompt too? | 2022-12-20T18:47:13 | 2022-12-20T18:47:13 | Weijia Shi, Xiaochuang Han, Hila Gonen, Ari Holtzman, Yulia Tsvetkov, Luke Zettlemoyer | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models can perform new tasks in a zero-shot fashion, given
natural language prompts that specify the desired behavior. Such prompts are
typically hand engineered, but can also be learned with gradient-based methods
from labeled data. However, it is underexplored what factors make the prompts
effective, especially when the prompts are natural language. In this paper, we
investigate common attributes shared by effective prompts. We first propose a
human readable prompt tuning method (F LUENT P ROMPT) based on Langevin
dynamics that incorporates a fluency constraint to find a diverse distribution
of effective and fluent prompts. Our analysis reveals that effective prompts
are topically related to the task domain and calibrate the prior probability of
label words. Based on these findings, we also propose a method for generating
prompts using only unlabeled data, outperforming strong baselines by an average
of 7.0% accuracy across three tasks. | [
0.0516248904,
0.0177410953,
-0.0142851332,
0.0262243934,
-0.0421718433,
-0.0026721039,
0.0236262269,
-0.0162249096,
0.0275222342,
0.0001554704,
-0.0461199172,
-0.0684756935,
0.0182887018,
0.0476524197,
0.0295993835,
-0.0643271282,
0.0308951717,
-0.0574365705,
0.0300076269,
-0.0030530598,
0.010647865,
-0.0186911896,
-0.0476246811,
0.0318296142,
-0.0030526272,
-0.0338160247,
0.0016545811,
0.0180321708,
0.0225425418,
-0.0128704412,
0.029019706,
0.07154309,
-0.0099449093,
0.0164243262,
0.0000019215,
-0.0521296933,
0.0430152155,
-0.0491886735,
-0.0375886187,
-0.0316260047,
0.0532812215,
-0.0113595091,
0.0033935341,
0.0076902001,
-0.0207066555,
-0.0193837918,
0.0479290634,
0.0350072347,
0.0438848399,
0.0648185313,
0.0061229272,
0.0140468264,
0.0123394616,
-0.0278498344,
0.0344419852,
-0.0420992523,
0.0093054576,
-0.0222981963,
0.0418182574,
0.052527912,
-0.0440358967,
0.0414700657,
0.0125719402,
-0.0325677879,
0.0302923601,
0.0443882234,
0.0093362099,
-0.0044832141,
-0.054912027,
0.1104800329,
0.0113284755,
0.0070998804,
-0.0086161345,
-0.0398925208,
0.0151794907,
0.0277055651,
-0.0273298286,
-0.0144344298,
0.0080969017,
0.0015320729,
-0.0085495049,
0.0219199937,
0.0350505821,
-0.0199359208,
0.0599953122,
0.0579526238,
0.0288987756,
-0.0472564623,
0.0357147418,
-0.0073995125,
0.0090364339,
-0.0651257038,
0.0336475261,
0.0063219704,
-0.0384214409,
-0.001373524,
-0.0414829776,
0.0218781214,
-0.0036382265,
0.0055623953,
0.0507983156,
0.0406989567,
-0.0288639441,
0.0556509644,
0.0038548855,
0.045659963,
-0.0232119747,
0.0138138458,
-0.0366594344,
0.0244119298,
-0.0411254168,
-0.0136260856,
-0.041080337,
-0.0138762537,
-0.018563848,
-0.0286636744,
-0.0344544724,
0.0240674745,
-0.0057058223,
-0.026613161,
-0.0026155745,
0.0222277883,
-0.0462831743,
-0.0276730359,
-0.0294207521,
0.0074705207,
-0.0619257577,
-0.0078112623,
0.0435750708,
-0.0280871708,
-0.0172977597,
0.0123929866,
0.0188493654,
-0.056843441,
-0.0274519734,
0.0522955172,
-0.0314017944,
-0.0160218123,
-0.0353365764,
0.0053028716,
-0.0560919456,
-0.0216247458,
-0.0237472504,
-0.030313855,
0.0209259894,
-0.0191170983,
-0.0145740695,
-0.0697570667,
-0.0147449486,
0.010219167,
-0.0296834726,
0.0889274552,
-0.0020583807,
0.0100840079,
0.0555518977,
-0.0168677885,
-0.0545074716,
0.0359947532,
-0.0003594887,
0.0352778435,
0.0252919365,
0.01446574,
0.0510624275,
0.0551537871,
0.0031466589,
0.021630222,
-0.0020389822,
-0.0233956557,
0.0296827164,
0.0587519333,
0.0728575215,
0.0273816623,
-0.0272310097,
-0.022559857,
0.0691434219,
0.0408677682,
-0.0236002617,
-0.0261959434,
0.0727693737,
0.0388876796,
-0.0153799029,
0.0427595675,
-0.0483430438,
0.0119266398,
-0.0118180113,
0.0063558538,
0.0325105563,
-0.0436056405,
-0.0382565185,
-0.0388447158,
0.0280289128,
0.0058234259,
-0.0002845702,
-0.0286225453,
0.0117751015,
0.0181546286,
-0.070622012,
-0.0023662301,
-0.0037363411,
-0.0269842353,
0.0319165289,
-0.0096681211,
0.0242207702,
0.1048082933,
0.0138701331,
-0.0160603691,
0.0065190056,
-0.0238427054,
0.0561800748,
0.0658408031,
0.0210834518,
-0.0133309979,
0.0285578817,
-0.0556994081,
-0.0295216218,
-0.0014642433,
0.0249704346,
0.0446044691,
-0.0356711857,
0.0174660143,
0.0032594155,
-0.0266958717,
-0.0022407975,
0.0331381001,
-0.0114557417,
-0.0408402346,
0.0403724052,
0.0180681162,
0.0070132907,
0.0054708184,
-0.010882711,
0.0192423481,
-0.0171684586,
-0.0359236412,
0.0362259261,
0.0092619155,
-0.0573465675,
-0.0079810591,
0.0089095747,
-0.0291433278,
-0.0205473751,
0.0186646041,
-0.0117820846,
-0.0644384027,
-0.0109975776,
-0.0090520233,
-0.0136903292,
-0.0409951247,
-0.0094277216,
0.0263995882,
0.0143324565,
-0.044297222,
0.0608175658,
0.0076548643,
0.0302173011,
0.024269823,
0.0369392373,
0.0039725015,
-0.114220731,
0.0079962825,
-0.0253337119,
0.0027740041,
0.0090278778,
0.059468776,
0.0145486742,
-0.0199706499,
-0.0215703864,
-0.0801815838,
-0.0205145963,
-0.018226359,
-0.0229090434,
0.0079673035,
0.0075631412,
-0.0320216902,
-0.0279993899,
-0.0401064642,
0.0038282734,
-0.0256002005,
0.0131933857,
0.0423704013,
0.0093126949,
-0.0341332778,
-0.0470421314,
-0.0232234206,
0.0000247701,
0.0115614766,
0.0301446579,
0.0037922703,
-0.067252934,
0.0187651385,
0.0515246503,
0.0176494978,
-0.0023003865,
-0.0069978517,
0.0200888682,
0.0119256331,
0.0913767442,
0.0754703432,
-0.0010926991,
0.0198866129,
0.0120319659,
0.0104160598,
-0.0382382683,
-0.0008727434,
-0.0392141044,
-0.035694208,
-0.0117044682,
-0.0393575765,
0.0304620937,
0.075980559,
0.0339477994,
0.0084888758,
-0.0993607119,
0.0033070392,
-0.0268778987,
-0.0651052445,
-0.086985983,
0.0105854049,
-0.0682086945,
0.0568459183,
-0.0290372465,
-0.0636530221,
0.0885337517,
-0.0251393896,
0.0095797125,
-0.0064688195,
0.0000331427,
0.0092234183,
0.0162933506,
0.0038376155,
-0.007695578,
0.009523904,
-0.0696882457,
-0.043713212,
0.0010854634,
0.0190235414,
0.0138300713,
0.01265876,
-0.0322954468,
0.0018348872,
0.003350805,
-0.0555599481,
-0.0520996153,
-0.06086215,
-0.0149929086,
-0.0002375798,
0.0023372294,
0.0037037118,
-0.0492912829,
-0.0166287348,
0.0182059668,
0.0635243431,
-0.0321839973,
-0.0093649244,
-0.0400798693,
0.0345027186,
0.0537799969,
0.0080456296,
-0.0272608586,
-0.0473155864,
0.0073575182,
-0.0431979373,
-0.0099806255,
0.0401221141,
-0.0267886184,
0.0358455516,
0.0211470909,
-0.0303000249,
0.0086607235,
0.054793708,
0.0720795691,
-0.0046401857,
-0.033166483,
0.1030045375,
0.0042352108,
-0.0810983554,
-0.0030268407,
0.0094133299,
0.0331448093,
0.0067311637,
0.0268525034,
-0.0698173568,
-0.0543621592,
0.0076517044,
0.0463141575,
0.0090871155,
-0.0382078514,
-0.0106697101,
-0.0919824615,
0.0371091664,
0.0246757455,
-0.0101909051,
-0.009507535,
-0.0219281409,
0.0114979381,
-0.0260844082,
0.0304139704,
0.0021975946,
0.0026938843,
0.0243686065,
0.0373675749,
0.0231193975,
-0.0882999897,
0.0246111285,
-0.0057707136,
0.0522898436,
0.0644951686,
-0.0080056656,
-0.0091451732,
-0.0416950062,
0.0241962429,
-0.0270308591,
0.0136397472,
0.0054255892,
0.0165821034,
-0.0145843998,
-0.0193495322,
-0.0342169814,
0.086957559,
-0.0423715301,
-0.0554280765,
0.0156128919,
0.0588062741,
-0.0107709495,
0.0149402497,
-0.024577111,
0.011105122,
0.0838982984,
0.0992982686,
0.038570717,
-0.0875023007,
-0.0166168287,
-0.0464891084,
0.0157390442,
-0.0284580886,
-0.0281057376,
-0.0038399487,
0.0132604018,
-0.0096267266,
-0.0743661746,
-0.035742186,
0.0268963557,
0.0443887599,
0.0412659496,
-0.0051877978,
-0.0218591597,
-0.0072798785,
-0.0412240401,
0.0343428813,
-0.04363662,
0.0129134553,
-0.1145106852,
-0.0225374755,
0.007163398,
-0.05501993,
-0.0295078158,
0.0363067724,
-0.0290999338,
-0.0745781213,
0.013189231,
0.0646927655,
0.0241186377,
0.0210292339,
-0.0397966392,
-0.0680482909,
-0.0071564466,
0.0441997424,
-0.0208233781,
0.0109980926,
-0.000647934,
0.0316230096,
-0.0259132851,
0.0177411716,
-0.0308546312,
-0.0089798765,
0.0551664643,
0.0527160838,
0.0179239325,
-0.0644325092,
0.0174096655,
0.0021316793,
0.0531386361,
-0.0514250547,
-0.009287009,
-0.0735997632,
-0.0308117997,
0.0289138276,
0.0171863548,
-0.0352156274,
-0.0048769773,
0.0417065322,
-0.0511121713,
-0.0264930464,
-0.0050380635,
-0.0288911331,
0.0244678576,
-0.0525975078,
-0.031978216,
0.027979888,
0.046533823,
0.0212569721,
-0.0013024801,
-0.0141262375,
0.0850234255,
-0.0174458995,
0.0511373468,
0.0432001092,
0.0721725449,
0.0404071026,
-0.0092715602,
-0.0333106443,
0.0165161118,
-0.0428274386,
-0.042577561,
-0.0014371738,
0.0425194874,
0.0531055033,
-0.0230548792,
-0.0161784999,
-0.0144367982,
-0.0013197857,
-0.0363236554,
0.0213472191,
0.0350118428,
-0.0159568451,
0.0422803946,
0.0226526577,
-0.000918433,
0.0135448333,
0.0697374642,
-0.0121114235,
-0.0000395597,
0.0065423883,
0.0205170661,
-0.0463700481,
0.0124232154,
0.0287072156,
0.027677374,
-0.0120748468,
0.0532818511,
-0.0525548123,
-0.0398825891,
0.0001204298,
0.025897596,
-0.0052907546,
0.0276196431,
0.0622344166,
0.0173143186,
-0.0540992096,
-0.0126302196,
-0.0445788167,
0.0145128034,
0.022016868,
-0.0410964154,
-0.0324951969,
-5.979031895e-33,
-0.0369408391,
-0.0099139558,
-0.0132485013,
0.0060009621,
-0.0055391504,
-0.0288957115,
-0.0375066027,
0.0233929642,
-0.0010402255,
0.0359882601,
-0.0231691822,
0.0079692993,
0.0317560956,
-0.0075775408,
0.0104267467,
-0.0413300022,
0.0443276539,
-0.0161559749,
-0.0556023791,
0.0319584347,
0.0308026224,
0.0424201787,
0.0272124689,
-0.0433810279,
0.0599755794,
-0.0186152644,
-0.032147605,
0.0512835532,
0.0512601919,
0.0171082821,
-0.052018065,
0.0449874029,
0.0122074615,
-0.0514040999,
-0.0228502247,
0.0589095093,
-0.0608720817,
-0.0301764365,
0.0265902486,
0.0089417445,
-0.0472304821,
-0.0601531491,
0.006414948,
-0.0342180915,
-0.0363967009,
-0.0052645123,
0.0466072001,
-0.0144008854,
-0.0146913929,
0.0372366682,
-0.0448007323,
-0.0121582132,
-0.0270939413,
-0.046005182,
0.0242672767,
0.0223521218,
-0.0088543734,
-0.0237246733,
-0.0430620238,
0.0310367346,
0.0021671245,
0.0531149134,
0.0400631167,
0.0366601646,
0.016322989,
0.0726938322,
0.0688229427,
0.008054724,
0.0310115498,
-0.0084753511,
0.0099889897,
-0.0032573072,
-0.0031843306,
0.0492400527,
0.033632867,
0.002606235,
-0.0302197523,
0.016926283,
-0.0242758784,
-0.0158899557,
0.0110087981,
0.0146106724,
-0.0472066142,
-0.0179390945,
-0.0423405543,
-0.0141495969,
-0.0226021893,
-0.0204123873,
0.0486132614,
-0.0102881463,
-0.0031838552,
-0.0506610051,
0.0505666547,
-0.0176096689,
-0.0066922582,
0.011443207,
0.0108926184,
0.0199936982,
0.010231358,
0.014368658,
-0.040287476,
-0.011476744,
-0.0078847939,
0.0269459914,
0.0309780091,
0.021777207,
-0.0225232206,
-0.0006357213,
-0.0478328466,
0.0023665491,
-0.0206077155,
0.0440717079,
-0.0162233524,
0.0486167073,
0.0291457251,
0.0085086897,
-0.0239342488,
0.0756551996,
-0.0383890606,
-0.0374692567,
0.0144127579,
0.0101895267,
-0.0030219164,
0.060934566,
-0.0555673912,
0.0015611063,
0.0212509539,
0.0110881515,
-0.0049269903,
-0.057773076,
0.0020848552,
0.0369176678,
2.66e-7,
0.0057835104,
0.026538996,
0.012151002,
0.0385654494,
-0.0010040414,
0.0407589413,
-0.0307869986,
0.0342765562,
0.0273512863,
-0.0855510831,
0.019207038,
0.0211193636,
0.0438252129,
-0.0411723815,
-0.1326532364,
0.0030671828,
-0.029304184,
0.0568434149,
-0.0378629975,
0.0005521532,
0.0405328311,
0.0523296632,
0.0088661946,
0.0162724424,
0.0302475095,
-0.0412116796,
0.0461868756,
-0.0329764374,
0.0013075598,
0.0257214922,
0.0495433919,
-0.0392864831,
-0.0096663618,
0.0417220369,
-0.0179222841,
0.0031826149,
0.0466719046,
0.0689706206,
-0.0007401666,
-0.0186907779,
-0.0242621414,
0.0262066852,
-0.0193447135,
-0.0301779862,
0.0318272039,
-0.0330057405,
-0.0244696345,
0.0092154695,
-0.0189062897,
-0.0228314996,
0.0207741968,
-0.0162753891,
-0.0159396343,
-0.0018267001,
0.0482588112,
0.035258539,
0.0038189471,
-0.0355299115,
0.0024411259,
0.0277316924,
-0.0518186577,
-0.0213454328,
-0.0394801609,
0.0089047588,
0.0194333419,
-0.080041334,
-0.0121735344,
2.047444607e-34,
0.0464228727,
0.0081840251,
0.0350227468,
-0.0049017374,
0.0009891827,
0.007232639,
0.0025265284,
0.0171096716,
0.0602910444,
-0.055266533,
-0.0478886589
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10537v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10537v2 | Does CLIP Bind Concepts? Probing Compositionality in Large Image Models | 2022-12-20T18:46:28 | 2023-03-29T15:34:23 | Martha Lewis, Nihal V. Nayak, Peilin Yu, Qinan Yu, Jack Merullo, Stephen H. Bach, Ellie Pavlick | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large-scale neural network models combining text and images have made
incredible progress in recent years. However, it remains an open question to
what extent such models encode compositional representations of the concepts
over which they operate, such as correctly identifying ''red cube'' by
reasoning over the constituents ''red'' and ''cube''. In this work, we focus on
the ability of a large pretrained vision and language model (CLIP) to encode
compositional concepts and to bind variables in a structure-sensitive way
(e.g., differentiating ''cube behind sphere'' from ''sphere behind cube''). In
order to inspect the performance of CLIP, we compare several architectures from
research on compositional distributional semantics models (CDSMs), a line of
research that attempts to implement traditional compositional linguistic
structures within embedding spaces. We find that CLIP can compose concepts in a
single-object setting, but in situations where concept binding is needed,
performance drops dramatically. At the same time, CDSMs also perform poorly,
with best performance at chance level. | [
0.0456096306,
0.0595124885,
-0.019462999,
0.0542023145,
-0.0354077704,
-0.0000722084,
-0.0020469227,
-0.0183149334,
-0.0726967156,
-0.0447392799,
-0.0369975828,
-0.0549085252,
0.0235306453,
0.0640328079,
0.0010986169,
-0.0477544107,
0.0291071963,
-0.0102105932,
-0.0536581352,
-0.0020252212,
-0.0085433852,
-0.0201297365,
0.0318277068,
0.0223787911,
-0.0333405063,
-0.0045705936,
-0.0065017338,
-0.0212974623,
-0.0155856591,
0.0021167435,
-0.0420000404,
0.0303613804,
0.0182632729,
0.0279698987,
0.0000019431,
-0.0110502802,
0.0438917577,
0.0086083654,
0.0077528469,
0.0035211695,
0.0247847103,
-0.042321559,
-0.0080645941,
-0.0498799346,
-0.0174208004,
0.0042504868,
0.0859674886,
0.0577225834,
0.03964293,
0.0327653587,
-0.0186076686,
-0.0516611673,
-0.0001324192,
-0.0378459431,
0.0559892766,
-0.0197963119,
0.03718457,
0.0141891697,
-0.0123429224,
0.020173844,
-0.0702372193,
0.0366442762,
0.0537980273,
0.0097138667,
0.015760256,
0.0749397427,
-0.0424274206,
-0.0391039178,
0.0197409745,
0.079793632,
-0.0576095656,
-0.0027580338,
-0.0140065923,
-0.0156553946,
-0.0059372326,
-0.0098258387,
-0.0043708943,
0.0353789963,
0.0249741338,
0.0206985343,
-0.0609961785,
0.0084054628,
0.0296572819,
0.0259438064,
-0.0505089648,
0.0183998235,
0.0065166098,
0.0087027512,
-0.0129831964,
0.0189603474,
0.0059659057,
-0.0556358062,
0.006557995,
0.01068391,
0.0196120162,
0.0118643763,
-0.0494026728,
-0.0055104597,
-0.0219042748,
-0.0538004003,
0.0504641011,
0.0342048332,
-0.0219055898,
0.0752088577,
-0.0440721288,
0.0408592522,
-0.0224359389,
0.0584167838,
-0.0318858437,
-0.0040090675,
-0.0489939302,
-0.0289216507,
-0.0205796678,
0.0501735657,
-0.0309359934,
-0.1001219451,
-0.0183902066,
0.0260894783,
-0.0354686007,
0.0051620766,
-0.0079686409,
0.0377963148,
-0.0152835995,
-0.022578489,
-0.0085733002,
-0.0164553467,
-0.0086248005,
0.0246173237,
-0.0175280813,
-0.0289423168,
-0.0001915947,
0.0017471153,
-0.0137384189,
-0.0096647404,
-0.0033235205,
0.0469634831,
-0.0153769236,
-0.0505660065,
0.008037501,
-0.0296218731,
-0.0413988531,
-0.0492338166,
0.0570373908,
-0.0810364708,
0.0388543047,
-0.0129039986,
-0.0017701134,
-0.0843944922,
0.0360692665,
0.022321526,
-0.0469870158,
0.1382987499,
0.0235193614,
-0.0072903754,
-0.0309842546,
0.0209933165,
0.0096860025,
0.06257236,
0.021241229,
0.037113864,
-0.0079058399,
0.0133328447,
-0.0006076731,
-0.0054308344,
0.0099227084,
-0.0095771281,
-0.053629607,
-0.0268530045,
-0.0166377481,
0.0399879813,
0.0264724456,
0.0663290247,
-0.0286451224,
-0.0457370244,
0.0675871521,
0.0442677811,
-0.0208014902,
0.0132122776,
0.0521111302,
-0.006573447,
-0.0030111542,
0.0025999709,
-0.0619648024,
0.0374478586,
0.0084292646,
-0.0047497237,
-0.0231163129,
0.022283094,
-0.0512906723,
-0.0169634819,
0.0028261796,
-0.006850129,
0.0194334425,
-0.0316510536,
0.0568966754,
0.025103854,
0.0002826053,
0.0331908204,
-0.0036375322,
-0.0093981,
-0.0044986997,
-0.0230530649,
0.0135738971,
-0.0031844382,
-0.0009099456,
-0.0094411308,
-0.0185013972,
0.0457955115,
0.019019695,
0.0726914927,
-0.0192636363,
0.0006540171,
0.0097860359,
-0.0298672691,
-0.0242675692,
-0.0446673669,
0.016863659,
0.0420470573,
0.0167283975,
-0.0148160346,
0.0230617356,
-0.0185129102,
0.0400899909,
0.0392427929,
0.0475186706,
-0.0055180821,
-0.0105170617,
0.0294902474,
0.0080529572,
-0.0299216248,
-0.0120117478,
0.0465552881,
-0.0114122564,
-0.0400374159,
-0.0655512735,
0.0243526679,
-0.0485435985,
-0.0426954292,
0.0215075426,
-0.0520863496,
-0.0081269024,
-0.0214595757,
-0.0394032486,
-0.006916543,
0.0483032167,
-0.0333600305,
0.0386828408,
-0.0348971114,
0.0129589671,
0.0093825776,
0.0248687789,
0.0084065842,
0.0582226887,
-0.0452550128,
-0.0177662689,
-0.0035420058,
0.0260246899,
0.0135642076,
0.0068633668,
-0.0305808522,
-0.0097295679,
-0.0024578865,
0.0145512577,
-0.0370352194,
-0.0128815407,
-0.0300080422,
-0.0175202396,
0.0033673486,
-0.021145625,
-0.0039376761,
-0.011142225,
-0.0216023605,
-0.0063150702,
0.0221084747,
-0.0218825266,
-0.0052431622,
-0.0008969775,
-0.0197249502,
0.0507642552,
0.0108178649,
0.0253232233,
0.0084530432,
0.0025258805,
-0.0222815964,
0.0089923386,
0.0921114758,
-0.0132257687,
-0.051722303,
-0.010598544,
0.0350195132,
-0.0461225994,
0.0343833268,
-0.0176312365,
-0.0351440981,
0.0073934547,
-0.024997998,
0.0737018362,
0.0924661532,
-0.0171994679,
0.0288806986,
0.0294772573,
-0.017128516,
-0.0205367245,
-0.020468697,
-0.031018354,
-0.0120022772,
0.0156669803,
0.019820312,
-0.0266891904,
0.0473018363,
-0.0218953192,
-0.0235804673,
-0.0804250538,
0.0794447958,
-0.0079984255,
-0.0582566932,
-0.0739784762,
-0.0128796222,
-0.0017064516,
0.0238934252,
-0.0517695844,
-0.0135094216,
0.0290242992,
-0.0108596878,
0.0311017707,
0.0423192233,
0.0175488908,
-0.0170214232,
0.0797275081,
0.0466610678,
0.0236748252,
-0.0108729145,
-0.0116533041,
-0.0563180484,
0.0289519597,
0.0006210952,
0.0009121362,
-0.0096997246,
-0.0259611998,
0.0083330674,
-0.0186930653,
-0.0410221666,
-0.0217259526,
0.0201477632,
-0.0110962382,
0.0477272719,
0.0112068411,
0.0019471952,
-0.0468017533,
0.0404074751,
0.000990576,
-0.0026324303,
-0.0033633532,
0.0006614694,
-0.0186272096,
0.0306132585,
0.0170404632,
0.0072712339,
-0.00055494,
-0.041148439,
-0.0273394268,
0.0464795567,
-0.0180450194,
0.0166831408,
-0.0351102613,
0.0327863246,
0.0100802286,
0.0293741934,
-0.0172949005,
-0.0093547069,
0.0250103176,
-0.0558366217,
-0.0169782974,
0.0403007232,
0.0434831157,
-0.043789126,
-0.0229052529,
0.0043207924,
-0.0229592249,
0.0394410565,
0.0135655906,
-0.0657725707,
-0.0162386801,
0.0097242873,
-0.0774086267,
0.003950167,
-0.0173166487,
-0.0433842875,
-0.1346407086,
0.0110107614,
-0.0072234692,
-0.061800532,
-0.0788997486,
0.0242042411,
0.0115370871,
0.0320247561,
-0.0304253325,
-0.0248441212,
0.0030219741,
-0.0076308413,
-0.0094907619,
0.0050620721,
-0.0556575619,
0.003553465,
-0.0356410444,
-0.0440641642,
0.0464876629,
0.0175151993,
-0.0172779951,
-0.069734253,
0.0243620817,
-0.0020160759,
-0.0083889905,
0.0403088182,
0.0499271415,
-0.0427744202,
-0.0228740517,
0.0185317788,
0.0145787559,
-0.0080987187,
-0.0461466573,
-0.062250644,
0.0343857333,
-0.0177036151,
-0.0180395804,
-0.0547523163,
0.0307841264,
0.0064169765,
0.0578797795,
0.0522165783,
-0.0484734289,
-0.0248614978,
-0.0102636181,
-0.0089384364,
-0.0301474649,
-0.0199039411,
0.0306357369,
0.0311680175,
-0.0064342837,
-0.0683799535,
-0.0008531502,
0.0131075121,
0.0366283506,
-0.0011144211,
-0.0371288322,
-0.0203824379,
-0.0177393965,
-0.0687776282,
0.041474022,
-0.0130598573,
0.0230863839,
-0.04017267,
0.0295603797,
0.0381217636,
-0.0466152169,
-0.045647122,
-0.0245311446,
-0.0955218226,
-0.0360889845,
-0.0033316836,
0.0530926324,
0.014277623,
0.0193799064,
-0.0063146921,
-0.0420101061,
0.0565057509,
0.0790101737,
0.0160835348,
0.0453562029,
0.0103899809,
-0.0556745268,
-0.0048136115,
0.0197730176,
-0.0206185766,
0.0397836044,
0.0514016524,
0.0096221985,
-0.0023856594,
0.0145487795,
0.0097637968,
-0.0615695566,
0.0495566949,
0.0182789508,
0.0465416908,
-0.0307950843,
0.0037076005,
-0.0070826495,
-0.0187762044,
-0.0583705381,
-0.028334707,
0.0221608616,
0.0398470648,
-0.0063390704,
0.0150390742,
0.0279398784,
0.0501440167,
0.0145707941,
-0.0403793976,
0.0686818436,
-0.0592872351,
0.0177707225,
0.0354401097,
-0.0044809072,
0.0229466483,
-0.0340884626,
0.0020034576,
-0.0322185904,
0.0324031413,
0.0470277034,
-0.011908887,
-0.072359629,
0.0333516672,
-0.0362335667,
-0.0465085395,
-0.011275135,
0.0326583982,
0.0404410213,
-0.0313385427,
-0.0501504987,
-0.0484749191,
-0.0522581302,
-0.003826899,
0.0205089115,
0.0243842248,
-0.0542847253,
0.0744754747,
0.0298841745,
0.0169400442,
-0.0142728956,
0.0481688865,
0.0065084477,
0.0294172186,
-0.0073056458,
-0.0166262276,
0.0112373894,
0.0001147538,
0.0209533814,
0.0595307387,
0.0113536371,
0.0465156771,
-0.07161057,
-0.061285615,
0.0137639381,
0.0437403247,
-0.0046601808,
0.033405792,
0.0704535171,
0.055070594,
0.0364073627,
-0.0179054327,
0.0072273156,
-0.024682289,
-0.0227727331,
0.0091733839,
0.0222875159,
-5.803504139e-33,
-0.0449584275,
-0.0134995198,
0.0143170534,
0.0300623197,
-0.0425979383,
0.035481181,
-0.021784246,
0.0073833624,
-0.0095572909,
0.0317234732,
0.00426964,
0.0215733908,
0.0110310959,
0.0331258364,
-0.0061453138,
0.0089494344,
0.0275896136,
0.01658535,
-0.0034044795,
-0.0148317292,
0.0258693565,
0.0121389581,
0.0405773856,
-0.0135934372,
-0.0259533804,
0.052822616,
0.0052654254,
0.004085449,
0.0031841246,
0.0617080852,
-0.0467752554,
0.0150029017,
0.017925987,
-0.0063228742,
-0.0205280595,
0.0406427793,
-0.0511271618,
-0.0355478227,
0.0110246493,
0.0231451225,
-0.0719533265,
-0.0084868846,
0.0682242885,
-0.0083446,
0.0268161967,
-0.0500217862,
0.0296324939,
-0.025941968,
-0.0300281253,
-0.050713364,
-0.0829332769,
0.0107935928,
0.0359004661,
-0.0365442149,
0.043879576,
-0.068280302,
0.0125314863,
0.0533667803,
-0.035953328,
0.0227607414,
-0.0266260132,
0.0319747142,
0.0246249046,
0.078786917,
0.0215416495,
0.0823343098,
0.0203066189,
-0.0137178898,
-0.0572879277,
-0.0067449282,
0.0483223498,
0.0433977135,
0.051950518,
0.0481029563,
0.0501838699,
0.0079728812,
-0.0285379756,
-0.0434178449,
-0.0772914886,
0.036434412,
0.0459480807,
0.001271441,
0.0255615301,
-0.0004372429,
-0.0647688955,
-0.0058661061,
-0.0504210368,
-0.0131907091,
0.0474906899,
0.0206385907,
-0.0004041538,
0.0394175388,
0.0370628685,
-0.0488442667,
0.0012986981,
0.0091372067,
-0.0163008794,
0.0460520871,
-0.0063254535,
0.0163826868,
-0.0427445658,
-0.0256259739,
0.024651438,
-0.0009389988,
-0.0194752365,
0.0119980834,
0.0535801798,
0.0210258402,
-0.0331760384,
-0.0285755619,
-0.0330092534,
-0.0334239192,
-0.0115520433,
0.0699939653,
0.0691377893,
0.0400502905,
-0.0397622697,
0.003807144,
0.0041492293,
0.0271454901,
-0.0055510998,
-0.0068976968,
-0.0220983196,
0.0376942344,
-0.0260760766,
-0.0194175337,
-0.0783632845,
-0.0117934132,
0.0589079969,
-0.0542259514,
-0.0230957605,
0.0424842052,
2.734e-7,
0.0644103661,
0.0177026372,
0.0079118824,
0.031644322,
0.0062303408,
0.0060450411,
-0.0159678757,
0.0345344245,
-0.0091452561,
-0.0141131813,
0.0163586047,
0.0593385436,
0.004986967,
-0.0212653503,
-0.043797601,
0.0582689755,
-0.0412768126,
-0.0180475954,
-0.0432854146,
-0.0142379124,
0.0316490829,
0.1093849316,
0.0172130782,
-0.0073007443,
0.0180715937,
-0.0401316993,
0.1027236953,
-0.0061545111,
0.0363524705,
0.0111859413,
-0.0554275103,
0.0255609564,
-0.0192919727,
0.0408922285,
0.0048421612,
0.0112381531,
0.077952683,
0.019128127,
-0.0177512448,
0.0344677567,
-0.0315645523,
0.0146935266,
-0.0222133454,
-0.0316305943,
0.0844497755,
-0.1281596571,
-0.0378020965,
-0.0395525098,
-0.0073087388,
0.0087658186,
0.0365486071,
-0.004963872,
-0.0282849725,
-0.0020996092,
0.0161706321,
0.0163646974,
-0.0128115928,
-0.1154198945,
0.0008059443,
-0.0061495597,
-0.0285409894,
0.0066877161,
-0.0427613258,
-0.0257981997,
0.048578579,
-0.0274343081,
-0.0795452669,
2.15777118e-34,
0.0280243587,
-0.0038193977,
-0.009846177,
-0.0101126106,
0.0055250674,
0.0031227313,
0.0063962536,
0.0133411363,
-0.0211972166,
-0.0438456535,
-0.0058977283
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10536v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10536v1 | Measure More, Question More: Experimental Studies on Transformer-based Language Models and Complement Coercion | 2022-12-20T18:46:20 | 2022-12-20T18:46:20 | Yuling Gu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Transformer-based language models have shown strong performance on an array
of natural language understanding tasks. However, the question of how these
models react to implicit meaning has been largely unexplored. We investigate
this using the complement coercion phenomenon, which involves sentences like
"The student finished the book about sailing" where the action "reading" is
implicit. We compare LMs' surprisal estimates at various critical sentence
regions in sentences with and without implicit meaning. Effects associated with
recovering implicit meaning were found at a critical region other than where
sentences minimally differ. We then use follow-up experiments to factor out
potential confounds, revealing different perspectives that offer a richer and
more accurate picture. | [
0.0477792136,
0.0433120802,
-0.0449766852,
0.0174970683,
-0.0528281219,
0.0007753071,
0.0185457487,
-0.0173106976,
-0.0100576924,
-0.0569801964,
-0.0486957654,
-0.0249357857,
0.0310096815,
-0.009873691,
0.0174667798,
-0.0259416066,
0.0553784296,
-0.0372080579,
-0.0407272168,
0.0060484949,
-0.02646566,
-0.0075931381,
0.0087842001,
0.027266046,
0.0316310078,
0.0036517405,
-0.0339421295,
-0.0175568312,
-0.0127005093,
0.00118625,
-0.0175294224,
0.0510677025,
0.0195863694,
0.0483072735,
0.0000017781,
-0.0373721048,
-0.0385226756,
-0.0128740091,
-0.0298246499,
-0.0014773819,
0.0406529345,
-0.0721022636,
0.021750927,
-0.0003063362,
-0.0416147001,
0.0179916974,
0.0042029005,
0.0796341524,
0.0069921706,
0.0432094932,
-0.0098979576,
0.0017908514,
-0.0272611007,
-0.002700879,
0.0056631295,
-0.0403062105,
0.0280360132,
0.0076398021,
-0.0353905521,
0.0192684028,
-0.0464131087,
0.0633874387,
0.0310236122,
0.0012274375,
-0.0678081214,
0.0292613637,
-0.0120953722,
-0.0351141505,
0.0106451558,
-0.0121366614,
0.0418539532,
-0.0520543642,
-0.0376334265,
-0.0188515391,
0.0057756663,
0.0759816542,
-0.0282187033,
0.0365973152,
0.0215692874,
-0.0009157889,
0.0022227773,
0.0185052026,
0.0025487014,
0.0091418019,
-0.0089297639,
0.0534068644,
0.001901102,
-0.064061977,
-0.0049723727,
0.0369206555,
-0.0341610052,
-0.0211891532,
0.0110485228,
0.0111702941,
-0.0054279878,
0.0465178788,
-0.0087334327,
-0.052616246,
0.0191493779,
-0.037540555,
0.0190378185,
0.0686050355,
-0.0007452488,
0.0281499606,
-0.0170020256,
0.0781318918,
-0.0024887044,
0.0301067904,
-0.047440175,
-0.01267232,
-0.0002560267,
-0.059800636,
-0.0316306725,
0.0311638676,
-0.0539525263,
0.0007247811,
-0.0258295629,
0.0116194524,
0.0312362704,
-0.0226027332,
-0.0221487395,
0.0050503025,
-0.086305365,
0.0045984942,
-0.035078384,
0.0398601368,
0.0414532498,
0.0722239092,
-0.0410140641,
-0.0836417526,
-0.0180372354,
-0.0015976254,
-0.0096542072,
-0.0410553738,
-0.0488259867,
0.0359093882,
-0.042376712,
-0.0668442696,
-0.037304312,
-0.0404359028,
-0.0520286299,
-0.0358290337,
0.0004874192,
-0.0143432207,
0.0090945689,
0.0279836003,
0.0175348781,
-0.0411170982,
0.0060054678,
-0.00863651,
-0.0036874812,
0.0767992139,
0.0796394572,
0.0073727365,
-0.0332607739,
0.0326400325,
-0.0258507933,
0.073114574,
0.015924938,
-0.00472786,
0.0063796695,
-0.0003475387,
-0.0192785189,
0.026238922,
0.0119231045,
-0.0135547835,
-0.0139872003,
-0.0092675015,
-0.0229732525,
0.0000541837,
0.0196582116,
0.0592801683,
0.002853856,
0.0032588292,
0.0907956585,
0.0481724069,
-0.0046958965,
0.0254103821,
0.0305963103,
0.0300739314,
-0.0028656053,
0.0646152496,
-0.044374533,
-0.000099693,
-0.0493189134,
-0.0019597837,
-0.0307514183,
-0.0360932462,
0.00070806,
-0.0517197698,
-0.0017652394,
-0.0098975655,
0.040039245,
0.012098385,
0.0496592894,
0.0378858373,
-0.0391704887,
0.0523524806,
0.0032748785,
-0.0514415279,
0.029208174,
-0.0345589146,
0.0061081862,
-0.0085870028,
0.0140264202,
-0.016945485,
-0.0008693556,
-0.0009431731,
-0.0046800547,
0.0789886564,
0.0261046477,
0.0086377915,
0.007760922,
-0.0292088315,
-0.0116540566,
-0.0076681892,
0.0253432784,
-0.0296765529,
-0.0153789241,
-0.0084305713,
0.0211707819,
-0.0155439628,
-0.0020700977,
0.0566697195,
-0.0740251318,
-0.0263609402,
-0.0345589258,
0.0170302317,
-0.0232647974,
-0.0108082751,
0.0242007989,
0.0132806022,
0.054143846,
-0.0103500895,
-0.0557415932,
0.0501421019,
-0.0620523654,
-0.0518355556,
0.0123472232,
-0.0563273914,
-0.0260886885,
0.0469226316,
0.0274603534,
-0.0437985957,
0.0191539116,
-0.0616659634,
0.0737058744,
-0.0281466246,
0.0353282392,
-0.0224244241,
0.0069642393,
-0.0393077545,
0.0114076817,
-0.011447723,
0.0376132578,
0.0194720179,
-0.0508322082,
-0.000447853,
0.0021030991,
-0.0433058031,
-0.044333078,
-0.0056784106,
-0.0157162137,
-0.0018642194,
-0.04146773,
-0.0571648069,
-0.0393047743,
-0.0371787883,
-0.0423736684,
-0.0061266734,
-0.0156594887,
0.0236668773,
0.031336505,
0.0060186516,
0.0194933955,
0.0318786614,
-0.0346704982,
0.0016112853,
0.0274028145,
0.0154823633,
0.0026456092,
0.0146771073,
-0.0438101664,
-0.002369666,
-0.0560660437,
0.0527099706,
0.0330892354,
0.0023258398,
-0.0416808501,
0.0691523254,
0.0116704982,
0.0134161115,
-0.0391362421,
-0.0437091887,
0.0338160545,
0.0128004057,
0.0981513783,
0.0607622452,
0.0033056096,
0.0486525297,
0.069735609,
-0.0061513064,
-0.0867542997,
-0.0007605726,
-0.0696434677,
-0.0572948717,
-0.0351221748,
-0.0709758922,
-0.0210289508,
0.0883685797,
0.0399227031,
-0.0230617411,
-0.0707592294,
0.0216001626,
-0.0413860269,
-0.0402336344,
0.0217212997,
-0.0059520127,
-0.0461283326,
0.0450127944,
-0.0316141471,
-0.0192388631,
0.0652858317,
-0.0211172085,
-0.0281230975,
-0.022255417,
0.0084780417,
-0.0079146558,
0.0920480639,
0.00524823,
-0.0025709439,
0.0536367595,
-0.0238364302,
-0.0448072031,
0.0117845424,
0.0332304947,
-0.0054068677,
0.1073876694,
-0.0242073741,
0.0035817809,
0.0107464632,
-0.0002338659,
-0.0511891693,
-0.0631784126,
-0.0074903481,
0.0040619271,
0.007421595,
0.0181237105,
-0.0419411585,
0.0045186114,
0.0431538485,
-0.0060247341,
-0.019109251,
-0.0463883877,
-0.0458747931,
-0.0236195419,
0.0387433544,
0.0617562979,
0.0525635816,
-0.058000613,
0.0231275372,
0.0422436893,
-0.0261563156,
0.0011176295,
-0.0302339457,
0.0059872358,
0.0288310088,
-0.0199205372,
0.0099687381,
0.0012514984,
0.0618381165,
-0.0416577421,
-0.0284179132,
0.1243969649,
0.0171234198,
-0.035514988,
0.0325284004,
-0.0814053118,
0.0043542269,
0.0278181937,
-0.0115064541,
-0.0456184112,
-0.0218494311,
0.0045570387,
-0.0016945343,
-0.0273112059,
-0.0222010631,
-0.0125970533,
-0.0929421633,
0.0127192568,
-0.0371523909,
-0.0207250249,
0.0032014987,
-0.0351480618,
0.0307124853,
-0.0000373269,
0.0335653462,
-0.0126006696,
-0.0339348949,
-0.0139177833,
0.0098039582,
0.0003414639,
-0.0307030566,
-0.0114053432,
-0.0268979948,
-0.010370574,
-0.0162591301,
0.004288021,
-0.0195689667,
-0.026804341,
0.0614689961,
-0.0233789291,
0.0036503766,
-0.007923902,
-0.0030709335,
0.0183297452,
0.0255231857,
-0.0377350524,
-0.0042532654,
-0.0043710405,
-0.0273221135,
-0.0265658349,
0.0684492812,
-0.0038205383,
-0.0280361064,
0.0034807166,
0.0428122021,
-0.011976569,
0.1155609339,
0.0430196151,
-0.0188169312,
0.0101848897,
-0.0052183489,
-0.0032133216,
0.0262993909,
-0.0573625565,
0.0301418547,
0.030634379,
0.0147474166,
-0.020751182,
-0.0488254912,
0.0276873708,
-0.0059610298,
0.0274457112,
0.0154838096,
0.0412191488,
-0.0618496463,
-0.0359358974,
0.0386027656,
-0.0145462472,
0.0207779277,
0.0042332457,
0.0066801347,
-0.0075807902,
-0.0327265523,
-0.0368635021,
-0.0098999934,
-0.07589259,
-0.0673336163,
0.0481462143,
0.0184710212,
0.0322094969,
0.0175168775,
0.0091842432,
-0.0231127832,
-0.0211109146,
0.0277682357,
-0.0507523604,
0.0500289127,
0.0395766087,
0.0129928067,
0.0107314931,
0.0563630275,
-0.0069562467,
-0.0203277841,
0.0313114859,
0.0439625792,
-0.0205961019,
-0.0089826081,
0.0538182631,
-0.0046790163,
0.0592413358,
0.0227442067,
0.0111672049,
-0.0093474388,
-0.0027371389,
-0.0193973947,
-0.0093407873,
-0.016722355,
-0.0476352423,
0.0372191593,
0.016167365,
-0.042840533,
0.0157411359,
-0.0772080123,
0.0595193319,
-0.0515198484,
0.0611240901,
0.065590091,
-0.0203544125,
-0.0023629891,
0.0268874057,
-0.0019217004,
0.0077970619,
0.0085426569,
0.0330363512,
0.028234737,
0.0305289533,
0.0279837847,
0.0333019309,
-0.053891439,
-0.0187035725,
-0.0742091686,
0.0231199972,
0.0424077474,
-0.0225674286,
-0.0211770143,
-0.05503463,
0.0707289428,
-0.0298781041,
0.0216944832,
-0.0040846053,
0.0409563258,
-0.000535421,
-0.0184429642,
0.0703186169,
0.000279525,
0.0020915712,
0.0653648674,
0.0482921489,
-0.0562988743,
0.0489821732,
0.0029568486,
0.012426395,
-0.0307800435,
-0.0186802037,
0.0522577092,
0.0092212046,
-0.0162792448,
0.0103815263,
-0.070546262,
-0.0669153184,
0.0147430915,
-0.0002787728,
0.0374147817,
-0.0605050586,
-0.0037423871,
0.0436386205,
0.0008023506,
-0.0618369877,
-0.0321488604,
0.0454148874,
0.0095528439,
0.0112906657,
-0.0726119876,
-6.489241626e-33,
-0.0670338795,
-0.0405145288,
-0.0082853641,
0.0410991609,
-0.0360264592,
0.0393766426,
-0.0675202459,
0.0336164497,
0.0117346048,
0.0219700858,
-0.0065691201,
0.0316197202,
0.0244277921,
-0.0097189695,
0.0078302836,
-0.0311835017,
0.037654072,
0.010813375,
-0.0342904069,
-0.0617573336,
0.0047187102,
0.0180402007,
0.0597040616,
-0.0364679508,
0.05244115,
-0.0086431615,
-0.0063509271,
0.0214727763,
-0.0291070342,
0.0699266866,
-0.0206372142,
0.0363503657,
0.0418112054,
-0.044884719,
-0.0018607337,
0.0273985825,
-0.0790641755,
-0.0060607214,
0.0937942117,
0.0488720834,
-0.0273054913,
-0.0087792519,
0.0680494905,
-0.0129162762,
-0.0405766442,
-0.013195063,
0.0279591419,
0.0020951331,
0.0124808168,
-0.0048062825,
-0.0621398352,
-0.0186493732,
-0.010247183,
-0.0161187872,
0.0400571302,
0.0832797289,
-0.0036024749,
0.0345895775,
-0.0378640443,
0.0311121121,
0.002154574,
0.0404789187,
0.0313607417,
-0.0005782241,
-0.00883538,
0.0377719179,
0.0001926269,
0.0045412756,
-0.0535443537,
-0.0275794342,
0.0760631785,
-0.0005256883,
0.0365060233,
0.0188968703,
0.0233309902,
0.0057526459,
-0.0106973443,
0.0173261911,
0.0327472351,
0.0245013479,
0.05280919,
0.0005973224,
-0.0122247702,
-0.0243702419,
-0.0706140026,
-0.0387858003,
-0.0360997207,
-0.0130779995,
0.0177725032,
-0.0002654849,
-0.0190828145,
0.0001591055,
0.0365672335,
-0.0610107072,
-0.0074751521,
-0.0472107008,
0.0048315986,
0.0243464727,
-0.0071810363,
0.0410059243,
-0.023146823,
-0.0137337837,
0.0147332139,
0.037320137,
0.0201609097,
0.0267587416,
0.0169262048,
0.0249206442,
-0.0277042333,
-0.0222276691,
-0.0350310728,
-0.0315961167,
-0.0330162533,
0.0169630274,
0.0563707389,
0.0473132841,
-0.0392006151,
0.0012575537,
0.0004228338,
-0.0036964482,
-0.0521215312,
0.0480020605,
0.0188291576,
0.0347862653,
-0.0365133546,
-0.0308036674,
-0.0059700948,
0.0028167306,
0.0434275307,
-0.0538893752,
-0.0337758325,
0.0157222971,
2.632e-7,
0.0513137318,
0.0517413057,
0.0189386159,
0.0586980619,
0.0002546913,
0.0230346825,
-0.0000611582,
-0.0074823592,
0.0480662957,
0.0179093629,
-0.0134514757,
0.0005305535,
0.0178132188,
-0.0020905081,
-0.0362230428,
-0.0268360283,
-0.0144920181,
-0.0022428036,
0.00753813,
0.0483764969,
0.0619159825,
0.0625360683,
-0.0019984625,
0.0108013134,
-0.0360285863,
-0.0031307861,
0.0462319963,
-0.0301241186,
0.0019043871,
0.0101154558,
0.0481266715,
0.0106828772,
0.0176666938,
0.0425563529,
0.0141737629,
0.0209543388,
0.0141988117,
0.0469247252,
0.0148365041,
-0.0334138945,
-0.0077056298,
0.0030014149,
-0.0123584783,
-0.0387946293,
0.0513710454,
-0.1066732481,
-0.0323832668,
0.0216545817,
-0.0279418863,
0.0097617786,
-0.0068055703,
0.0352688357,
-0.0374582373,
0.0170592535,
0.0459146723,
0.0027057903,
-0.0256148651,
-0.0538941287,
-0.0417125337,
-0.0217533074,
-0.0481133237,
0.0130885215,
-0.0132591128,
-0.009301479,
0.01318572,
-0.069905363,
-0.0484527536,
2.270919858e-34,
0.0281763114,
0.0180230998,
0.0326083302,
0.0221269876,
0.0178193338,
-0.0210141819,
0.0305067245,
0.0277170334,
0.0177585911,
-0.1078813747,
-0.0282196347
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10535v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10535v2 | A Survey of Deep Learning for Mathematical Reasoning | 2022-12-20T18:46:16 | 2023-06-22T01:37:02 | Pan Lu, Liang Qiu, Wenhao Yu, Sean Welleck, Kai-Wei Chang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG | Mathematical reasoning is a fundamental aspect of human intelligence and is
applicable in various fields, including science, engineering, finance, and
everyday life. The development of artificial intelligence (AI) systems capable
of solving math problems and proving theorems has garnered significant interest
in the fields of machine learning and natural language processing. For example,
mathematics serves as a testbed for aspects of reasoning that are challenging
for powerful deep learning models, driving new algorithmic and modeling
advances. On the other hand, recent advances in large-scale neural language
models have opened up new benchmarks and opportunities to use deep learning for
mathematical reasoning. In this survey paper, we review the key tasks,
datasets, and methods at the intersection of mathematical reasoning and deep
learning over the past decade. We also evaluate existing benchmarks and
methods, and discuss future research directions in this domain. | [
-0.0312279724,
0.1117222384,
0.0101979384,
0.0615556389,
-0.04393721,
0.0350389592,
0.0393124074,
-0.0141967423,
-0.0528035723,
0.0043318225,
-0.0102056712,
-0.0557546318,
-0.0154963462,
0.029736679,
0.0108102765,
-0.0070976238,
0.0120235812,
-0.008537651,
0.0213798918,
-0.01394503,
-0.047252126,
-0.000214824,
-0.0350159258,
0.0035459031,
-0.0835486427,
-0.0682566464,
0.040098276,
-0.0326093622,
0.0221440047,
-0.0098560844,
0.003509152,
0.0128426291,
0.0589878634,
0.0867244378,
0.0000017727,
-0.0414854884,
-0.025626136,
0.0033007537,
-0.0809003934,
-0.0054391301,
-0.0165301263,
-0.0112974131,
0.0212752093,
0.0013614849,
-0.0879533589,
0.00204884,
0.0033389302,
0.0231743157,
0.0581484959,
0.0592954084,
-0.003038805,
-0.0486411639,
0.0340615846,
-0.0259840824,
0.0308166575,
-0.0629038215,
0.0075116968,
-0.0255817734,
-0.0085108811,
-0.0271110814,
0.0048869578,
0.0551275201,
0.098062031,
-0.0100647556,
-0.0464402325,
0.0182583816,
-0.040846277,
0.019456109,
-0.0148001937,
0.0805646628,
-0.021214176,
-0.0102573307,
-0.0039496939,
-0.0098998584,
-0.0189667977,
-0.0010358635,
-0.0271921474,
0.033336591,
0.0045189122,
0.0078612892,
-0.0382900685,
0.0112245372,
0.0585090965,
0.0041828458,
-0.0594676472,
0.1172879413,
0.0030552852,
-0.0284230784,
0.0063870149,
-0.0178861767,
-0.0697599724,
-0.0373979248,
0.0447140932,
0.0401334986,
0.0260678828,
0.0205706283,
-0.0034799974,
-0.0714580789,
-0.0474490374,
-0.0261097047,
0.0156604033,
0.0466930792,
0.0275394805,
0.0546798483,
-0.0284501389,
0.0473574139,
-0.034180209,
0.0282943994,
0.0161408763,
0.0026337032,
-0.0031090365,
-0.0220912714,
-0.0042282739,
0.0405008942,
0.0035579125,
0.0145368073,
-0.0557320602,
0.003698773,
-0.061563015,
0.0572001524,
-0.0322836041,
0.0217484422,
-0.0020148645,
-0.040756125,
-0.0331023559,
-0.0123912347,
-0.0499200448,
0.0179922041,
0.0042476752,
-0.0324897431,
0.0024231323,
0.0099883368,
0.0041649239,
-0.0400432274,
0.0427050143,
0.0762034655,
0.0287686214,
0.0152916051,
-0.0072208177,
-0.0142908292,
0.0327187702,
-0.0722912401,
0.0233839825,
-0.0705385357,
0.0615964979,
-0.025592681,
-0.0643338785,
-0.0513442308,
0.0043446682,
0.0444435999,
0.0198233295,
0.0920154899,
0.000137871,
-0.0211055912,
0.0493095703,
-0.0108080478,
-0.0118659474,
0.0383797996,
0.0471082702,
-0.0009059586,
0.0259987079,
0.0111427801,
0.0064530838,
0.0122491848,
0.0232056305,
-0.0505545475,
-0.0143533824,
0.0141735319,
-0.0209991373,
0.0511663482,
-0.0695123151,
0.047685653,
-0.0543119833,
-0.0653810576,
0.0013565565,
0.0783210173,
-0.0185050275,
0.0136992652,
0.041505143,
-0.0176271684,
0.0642206445,
-0.0200962871,
-0.0631497726,
-0.0130151697,
-0.0091988016,
-0.0279720258,
-0.0059233406,
-0.0140571361,
-0.0404697172,
-0.0773648992,
0.0069791079,
-0.0182769522,
-0.0051702457,
0.0111812828,
0.0784666315,
-0.033018399,
-0.0143346628,
0.050547488,
0.0220970046,
-0.0061005917,
-0.0047766399,
-0.0178930908,
0.0205858015,
-0.0292933248,
0.027336942,
-0.0879393816,
-0.0282728691,
-0.0206626598,
0.0047945571,
0.0294044893,
0.017417565,
0.0092926193,
0.0214789864,
-0.0391828753,
0.0010155095,
-0.0241593979,
0.0024022653,
-0.0029815552,
0.0054082451,
0.0231954139,
0.0466390252,
-0.0312959962,
0.0174385738,
0.0223628804,
-0.0233824234,
-0.0237414632,
0.0424543358,
0.0291884504,
0.0149729764,
0.0029450045,
0.0040184949,
0.039247781,
0.0066975607,
-0.0228605773,
-0.0327375829,
-0.0331032239,
-0.0661482811,
-0.0398234427,
0.0268311948,
-0.0622745082,
-0.0338961668,
0.0323228128,
-0.0762866586,
-0.0121919969,
0.0534903482,
-0.0064062709,
-0.0343519561,
-0.0142523795,
-0.009111003,
0.0076783504,
0.0375086293,
0.007308851,
0.0457405224,
0.0104053393,
0.0044487999,
-0.0105943913,
0.0093103955,
0.0280313008,
-0.0193940159,
-0.0130688464,
-0.0398752429,
-0.0461537614,
0.0202531088,
0.0026419973,
0.0032506394,
-0.0078952154,
0.0273711085,
0.0041053589,
0.0050864303,
-0.0324476063,
0.0558073819,
-0.0049872282,
-0.0494539924,
0.0194355994,
0.0052667656,
-0.042452421,
-0.018795589,
-0.0008523993,
-0.0154176438,
0.0480473638,
-0.0109917102,
0.0051628924,
-0.0098593794,
-0.0633727089,
-0.053689044,
0.0767865479,
0.0177017488,
0.0377946869,
0.0537499562,
-0.0289790966,
-0.0485561676,
0.0274906941,
-0.0120658334,
0.045699019,
0.0402371548,
-0.0271165185,
0.0039129616,
0.0771623924,
-0.0140765319,
0.0424878784,
-0.0229434669,
0.0012470278,
-0.030267803,
0.0392595381,
-0.0368541181,
0.0602256097,
-0.0033623066,
0.0094116274,
0.002760641,
0.056315653,
-0.0493701659,
-0.0197828524,
-0.0159024503,
0.062974982,
-0.0122954994,
-0.0090226689,
-0.016059462,
0.0230319053,
0.015065196,
0.0461822562,
-0.0285813659,
-0.0147137064,
0.0403263681,
0.0002869091,
-0.001593437,
-0.0483130813,
-0.0066435663,
-0.0730459988,
0.0191432368,
0.0078598214,
-0.0343485624,
-0.0179748666,
-0.0188884269,
0.0160152409,
-0.0140471049,
0.0303983018,
-0.0266681369,
0.0241376366,
-0.0229176953,
0.0444175825,
-0.0175747983,
-0.0181059465,
-0.0474905968,
0.0085423393,
-0.018555399,
0.0359389372,
-0.0253073834,
-0.0168580133,
-0.0195374321,
-0.02223056,
-0.0181540512,
0.0267932229,
-0.0044404306,
0.0024032167,
-0.0224336293,
-0.0054829847,
0.0259855706,
0.0397626609,
0.0607690029,
-0.0167106967,
-0.0173822492,
-0.0013080473,
0.0474399291,
0.0096816244,
-0.0378371626,
0.0292252693,
-0.0023505075,
-0.0184851158,
-0.0098132966,
0.0152426818,
-0.0202977415,
-0.0768693164,
-0.0070853583,
0.0784831792,
0.0336068049,
-0.0103565576,
-0.0047407658,
-0.0265257861,
-0.0355545543,
-0.0042544222,
0.0137539655,
-0.1073613837,
-0.0294904746,
0.0154505745,
-0.0434573293,
0.0152791291,
-0.0383760631,
-0.0001508265,
-0.0866269991,
0.0059481408,
-0.0277607925,
-0.0224649739,
-0.0145640178,
-0.007165167,
0.0154113919,
0.0010566405,
0.0059301197,
-0.031408105,
0.0279077999,
0.0066844127,
0.0151486015,
-0.0514482632,
-0.0148785003,
0.0158566404,
-0.0489538386,
-0.0419529155,
0.0302140843,
0.0487849265,
-0.032765314,
-0.0853855237,
-0.006752321,
0.0694469362,
-0.0745882541,
0.0083925948,
0.0146489982,
-0.011936768,
-0.0243041366,
0.0159328673,
0.05355753,
-0.1049405187,
-0.0215010308,
0.0122046424,
0.0717297792,
-0.0096578505,
-0.0201377459,
-0.0130434381,
0.0166838076,
-0.0469968393,
0.0636869594,
-0.0013318023,
0.0030836745,
-0.0814682394,
-0.0259604938,
-0.0098120412,
-0.069736965,
-0.0160433929,
-0.0020004055,
0.0792142525,
0.0045941221,
-0.0448381715,
-0.0296123307,
0.0215873923,
0.0113474261,
-0.0000925361,
-0.0509695746,
0.0621405579,
-0.0235731304,
-0.0660245568,
0.0323420279,
-0.0465114601,
0.0439304933,
-0.0103734387,
0.0729860663,
-0.0231932942,
-0.0008576058,
-0.0370144397,
0.0386578068,
-0.114348121,
-0.0286600236,
-0.0005037705,
-0.0113534313,
0.0092951115,
0.0120451143,
-0.0340157524,
-0.0067061153,
0.0217877552,
0.0332446545,
-0.0216282737,
0.0065363343,
0.06906005,
-0.0040746364,
-0.0104371076,
0.0456557423,
0.0010138119,
0.0077647613,
0.0426788107,
0.0140647171,
-0.0046870564,
-0.0139690712,
-0.035149999,
0.0189488288,
0.010518156,
0.0808367059,
-0.0102975704,
0.0091182608,
0.0233857483,
-0.0153054902,
-0.0151931373,
-0.0799350291,
0.0223615468,
-0.0039428235,
0.0042618704,
-0.0118610915,
-0.0040005012,
0.0841767937,
0.0076859826,
0.0239994954,
0.0378651358,
0.0062014833,
0.0293652508,
0.0018402102,
-0.0037988604,
0.0214075632,
0.0176692139,
-0.0016493751,
0.0590404607,
-0.0111495312,
0.0305522792,
0.0603169501,
0.026317982,
-0.0340343304,
-0.0243459456,
-0.0596736372,
-0.0834327191,
0.0166624859,
0.0059809247,
0.03088383,
-0.0007320971,
-0.0433422588,
-0.0447331518,
0.01481272,
-0.0038072423,
0.027683435,
0.0179626234,
0.0141857639,
-0.0070717842,
0.0172476843,
-0.0007316733,
-0.0428580381,
0.015719099,
-0.0103388205,
0.0281846374,
0.028871581,
0.0254501943,
-0.0201911815,
-0.0193982106,
-0.0124716572,
0.0107092708,
0.0002566917,
-0.0033017253,
-0.0334163494,
-0.0873409286,
0.0591518097,
0.0008912628,
-0.0190763697,
0.0419325083,
0.0340762734,
0.0431051813,
-0.0238266364,
0.0097331125,
0.040160019,
0.0470672026,
-0.0312108323,
-0.0296553615,
-0.0388744846,
-5.251027305e-33,
0.029386403,
-0.0168075617,
0.0242262054,
0.0047740652,
-0.0027117548,
0.0014006281,
-0.0192338061,
-0.0199519191,
-0.0458123684,
0.0192533825,
-0.0132593401,
0.064107798,
0.0147703914,
0.0604630038,
-0.0439482406,
-0.04876443,
-0.0009266738,
-0.0231488384,
-0.0098570762,
-0.0097016934,
-0.0016424004,
0.030200785,
0.0700934529,
-0.054270912,
-0.0017457512,
-0.0031219749,
0.0094609503,
0.0467722453,
-0.0699056312,
0.0450262912,
-0.040871527,
0.0164024755,
0.0116381664,
-0.0332404338,
0.0076035596,
0.029623799,
-0.0568435863,
-0.0323485881,
-0.0356243216,
0.0079877349,
-0.0750050098,
-0.0266850274,
0.0662138611,
0.0286453608,
-0.0135925477,
-0.019532837,
0.0245147087,
0.0106284497,
0.0046342066,
-0.0249139946,
-0.0384475365,
0.0495393611,
-0.0516045876,
-0.0055294642,
0.0262976401,
0.0057541938,
-0.0028854713,
0.0185965225,
-0.0505836494,
-0.0001325241,
-0.0306754895,
0.0140046105,
0.0285922773,
-0.0287275426,
0.0127890306,
0.0348494463,
0.0344174542,
-0.0284990314,
-0.023841219,
0.0068566757,
0.0750718117,
0.0693444312,
0.0705448017,
0.0053015328,
0.0726211593,
0.0306181442,
-0.0352473408,
-0.0272754617,
0.0068277372,
0.0272159427,
0.0106954342,
-0.0152250081,
-0.0188023616,
-0.0040513268,
-0.0284220334,
0.0229644291,
-0.0626056939,
0.0101382751,
0.0048802095,
-0.0143953245,
-0.0136637865,
0.07414148,
0.0137534039,
-0.0482144691,
0.0055407337,
0.0133216884,
0.0452893078,
-0.0057350281,
0.0333220027,
0.0265824664,
-0.0300120115,
0.0058613084,
-0.0273723975,
0.0044867019,
0.0296015162,
-0.0071263546,
0.0284955017,
0.0166759342,
0.0034679063,
-0.0366224907,
-0.0236726925,
-0.001946313,
0.0237209965,
0.0812261552,
0.0429379009,
0.0508501977,
-0.0054752571,
0.0447934717,
-0.0261295345,
0.0033188113,
-0.0165784936,
0.0428236686,
0.0166731346,
0.0566799715,
-0.0208722688,
-0.0263080318,
-0.0534234717,
-0.0211569648,
0.0201192256,
-0.0909387767,
0.0206649732,
0.0253712591,
2.399e-7,
0.0277267639,
0.0148301655,
0.0524458177,
0.0140487775,
0.0186755918,
0.0311056189,
0.012547412,
-0.0252660401,
-0.0166666601,
-0.0182243362,
0.0162508935,
0.0684360117,
0.0257365201,
0.0146078775,
-0.0509829745,
0.0101599675,
-0.0549393781,
-0.010167812,
-0.0406388044,
0.0264304802,
0.0445643142,
0.0964955017,
0.0336866789,
-0.0290055051,
0.0321892127,
-0.0439271815,
0.0366426818,
0.0085878707,
0.025748888,
0.0274319481,
-0.0098626865,
-0.0198152661,
0.0194110312,
0.0120575847,
-0.0156749133,
0.0462738425,
0.0447953492,
0.043205753,
0.0403238423,
-0.0117751714,
-0.0508368611,
-0.001996598,
-0.0101970071,
0.0047389329,
0.0685262308,
-0.0809168667,
-0.0469783545,
-0.0206876099,
0.0050660032,
-0.0195312873,
0.0646219701,
0.0112218047,
0.0288870651,
-0.0098270541,
0.0283147357,
-0.022022482,
0.0028143742,
-0.0947561041,
-0.000276934,
0.0368051045,
-0.0698161945,
0.0174619742,
-0.0256014727,
-0.0136612412,
0.0662078261,
-0.0061898595,
-0.013589737,
2.168923453e-34,
0.0275266543,
0.0051593212,
-0.0029250197,
0.0053693643,
0.0368855819,
-0.0073372265,
-0.07190869,
0.0195630193,
0.0132420538,
-0.0556949861,
-0.0014399755
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10534v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10534v3 | DISCO: Distilling Counterfactuals with Large Language Models | 2022-12-20T18:46:08 | 2023-06-05T19:16:25 | Zeming Chen, Qiyue Gao, Antoine Bosselut, Ashish Sabharwal, Kyle Richardson | cs.CL | cs.CL | Models trained with counterfactually augmented data learn representations of
the causal structure of tasks, enabling robust generalization. However,
high-quality counterfactual data is scarce for most tasks and not easily
generated at scale. When crowdsourced, such data is typically limited in scale
and diversity; when generated using supervised methods, it is computationally
expensive to extend to new counterfactual dimensions. In this work, we
introduce DISCO (DIStilled COunterfactual Data), a new method for automatically
generating high quality counterfactual data at scale. DISCO engineers prompts
to generate phrasal perturbations with a large general language model. Then, a
task-specific teacher model filters these generations to distill high-quality
counterfactual data. While task-agnostic, we apply our pipeline to the task of
natural language inference (NLI) and find that on challenging evaluations such
as the NLI stress test, comparatively smaller student models trained with DISCO
generated counterfactuals are more robust (6% absolute) and generalize better
across distributions (2%) compared to models trained without data augmentation.
Furthermore, DISCO augmented models are 10% more consistent between
counterfactual pairs on three evaluation sets, demonstrating that DISCO
augmentation enables models to more reliably learn causal representations. Our
repository is available at: https://github.com/eric11eca/disco | [
0.059817031,
0.085820891,
-0.0330105461,
0.0362525284,
-0.0545556545,
0.0025636617,
0.0266316924,
-0.0124202883,
0.0273437053,
-0.0497520529,
-0.0044855466,
-0.001510706,
-0.0374939926,
0.0444102101,
0.0473590717,
-0.0301258862,
0.0593276098,
0.0038012697,
0.0212195143,
-0.0217697844,
-0.0209452827,
0.0084525067,
-0.0105242813,
0.0131656714,
-0.0076365112,
0.0089738034,
0.0069170818,
0.017755786,
0.0488328375,
0.0013991802,
0.0612889715,
0.0364980735,
0.0292844344,
0.0353279077,
0.0000019902,
-0.0595233999,
0.0059307464,
-0.0067861094,
-0.0482891649,
0.0093693035,
-0.0053326287,
-0.0137482705,
0.0039592218,
-0.0062821629,
-0.035164725,
0.0127655976,
0.0491350442,
0.0274863802,
0.0499028489,
0.0948650688,
-0.0015232251,
-0.0346761793,
0.0065902122,
-0.0292735901,
0.0095327133,
-0.0069318945,
0.0119113568,
-0.0009395966,
-0.0008350856,
0.0138388779,
-0.0116538946,
0.0029929187,
0.0526739135,
0.0199710652,
0.010370831,
0.0160655603,
-0.0085687526,
-0.0190662853,
0.0099632349,
0.0756728351,
0.0088245291,
-0.0562240556,
-0.016584903,
-0.0570020936,
0.0157647114,
0.0281402636,
-0.0241802167,
0.0112407245,
-0.0061354744,
0.019848315,
0.0208902974,
0.0323096886,
0.0421040356,
0.04057559,
0.0011310441,
0.0250136126,
0.0191829447,
-0.022259986,
-0.0096535487,
0.0163242836,
-0.0513540432,
-0.021735372,
-0.0079286592,
-0.0374200791,
-0.0297292303,
-0.0059498758,
-0.0324028879,
-0.0689310282,
0.0432206765,
-0.036388699,
0.0137312235,
0.0184348039,
-0.0297326539,
0.0502356254,
-0.0108830407,
0.0221210811,
-0.0570240878,
0.0137887383,
-0.023791112,
-0.0459634587,
-0.0231951419,
-0.0021715467,
0.0029405057,
0.0026469277,
-0.0569552705,
0.0264196899,
-0.0202328209,
-0.0078012226,
-0.0664708838,
0.001585088,
0.0034199809,
0.0570468232,
-0.0464085303,
-0.018675467,
-0.0144024845,
0.0474527031,
-0.0680487454,
0.0376077481,
-0.0135247726,
-0.0531345308,
-0.0298947953,
-0.0200183783,
0.0196803696,
-0.0619978048,
0.0343164355,
0.0808988288,
0.0181094483,
-0.0045648818,
-0.0197416153,
-0.0203880053,
-0.0277102198,
-0.0767819285,
0.0179174412,
-0.039377749,
0.0073646605,
0.0034920461,
-0.0057179751,
-0.034790121,
0.0142847709,
0.0019214685,
-0.0437807031,
0.0549092181,
0.0145434123,
-0.0423982069,
0.0171821136,
-0.0017118206,
-0.017857179,
0.0827941298,
0.019811403,
-0.0272543821,
0.0291832164,
0.0061518755,
-0.0167900808,
0.0076770419,
0.0523108281,
0.0056435317,
-0.0348160677,
0.0108988145,
-0.0026944778,
-0.0072178459,
0.0185773615,
0.0152836833,
-0.0150385993,
-0.0565314144,
0.0422982052,
-0.0439704955,
-0.0273839813,
0.0200854335,
0.0145210307,
0.0085867709,
-0.0158604402,
0.0196637269,
-0.068773739,
0.0154139707,
-0.025656933,
-0.0057308855,
0.0352355614,
0.02148805,
-0.0065641985,
-0.0441429541,
-0.0053911083,
0.001579601,
0.0294092353,
0.0271380935,
0.0632411838,
0.0560165085,
-0.0238299929,
-0.0189166442,
0.0516031086,
-0.046117004,
-0.0071213963,
-0.0083061857,
0.0051045967,
0.0321632139,
0.0396565981,
-0.0645583346,
-0.0241448116,
-0.0010970093,
0.0072232992,
0.0312925763,
0.0591660701,
0.0000757858,
0.040483959,
-0.0307367053,
-0.00872414,
-0.0451991744,
0.0559271835,
0.0055528274,
0.0548840873,
-0.0173199624,
0.0225388482,
-0.0217027795,
-0.0286866371,
0.0178268049,
-0.0220304932,
-0.0429989249,
0.0375055298,
0.0091021536,
0.0183665976,
0.0201534238,
-0.0289550908,
0.0018377848,
0.0280659683,
-0.0420044698,
-0.0114748646,
0.0032385618,
-0.0383259729,
-0.0672918335,
0.0167876277,
-0.0547543354,
-0.0582994856,
0.1002288014,
-0.0675468743,
-0.0325570256,
0.0713556409,
-0.0212837439,
0.0629287213,
-0.0114699509,
-0.0133237783,
0.006146268,
0.0137560507,
-0.0001223254,
0.0517225191,
0.0141817294,
0.0141852368,
-0.0096068513,
0.0315611139,
0.0226638224,
-0.0146160005,
-0.0199837834,
-0.0104983561,
-0.0110808406,
-0.0321173929,
0.0290952586,
-0.0314073712,
-0.0621793345,
0.0193383936,
-0.0579678081,
0.0135132866,
-0.0238562953,
-0.0003117725,
0.0255681053,
-0.0045950389,
0.0094542792,
-0.0452615358,
0.0143017909,
-0.0191409979,
0.0080667622,
0.0264085326,
0.013638895,
-0.0124750426,
0.027063515,
-0.0784110948,
-0.0181411728,
-0.0591639392,
0.0503723957,
0.0323114172,
0.0062755086,
0.0069488068,
-0.0402226485,
-0.0287763551,
0.0541611761,
-0.0182552729,
-0.0350898579,
0.0062635494,
0.0118985483,
0.0608228035,
0.0600335971,
-0.0219412241,
-0.0091877412,
0.0382952988,
-0.0231243428,
-0.0527345426,
0.0305443052,
-0.0181774385,
-0.0061399257,
-0.0067624119,
-0.0416554473,
-0.0347227305,
0.063989982,
0.0142930644,
-0.0421980731,
-0.0607534349,
0.0314212702,
-0.0053566317,
-0.0168002471,
0.0118734296,
-0.0387874357,
-0.0199069679,
0.0169882588,
-0.0412436202,
-0.0298513323,
0.0970566198,
0.0186619852,
-0.0057246247,
-0.0649017617,
-0.0071602361,
-0.004320364,
0.0732908025,
0.0234918632,
-0.0126046976,
0.0339939483,
0.042164918,
-0.0449855216,
0.0136973271,
0.0592169017,
-0.0029389013,
-0.0100647202,
-0.0937940329,
-0.0043047718,
-0.0093733352,
-0.0477482975,
-0.0620746203,
-0.0814676955,
-0.0231548492,
0.0100878393,
-0.0215254296,
-0.0294885468,
-0.0389739312,
-0.0361279026,
0.0072255777,
0.0316462666,
-0.0075408826,
0.01069103,
-0.0215359814,
-0.0013331282,
0.0638193116,
0.0246327799,
0.0513577685,
-0.0152145494,
-0.0107342657,
0.0174915455,
0.0187534839,
-0.0275251251,
-0.0127857914,
0.0052439123,
-0.0258383714,
0.0011794745,
0.0055568842,
0.0113939624,
0.0308659263,
-0.0408722833,
-0.0072896718,
0.0600492395,
0.0320449024,
-0.0163462032,
0.0056989267,
0.0087254997,
0.0331427641,
0.04498934,
-0.0397409499,
-0.078002125,
-0.0427751169,
-0.0054603149,
-0.0180272702,
-0.03157584,
-0.0305398256,
-0.0154329678,
-0.1206347793,
0.027882006,
0.0001948217,
-0.0128021287,
-0.020833347,
-0.0618872121,
0.0137304012,
-0.0353213251,
-0.0246887095,
-0.0282716248,
0.0299462155,
0.0223304983,
-0.010136432,
0.0159695949,
-0.051028721,
0.0226441473,
-0.0276319664,
0.0356069766,
0.0575480312,
0.0092783924,
-0.0128642758,
-0.0110655818,
0.0479179807,
-0.0355601124,
-0.0305297114,
-0.0042409641,
0.0786802545,
-0.0001487893,
-0.0109822107,
-0.0220697839,
0.0608399548,
-0.0210774057,
-0.0400308631,
0.0109794009,
0.0700500682,
0.0092796944,
-0.0037199277,
-0.043568857,
0.0121019911,
0.0153924935,
0.0870103762,
0.0175296906,
-0.050211478,
-0.0349867009,
-0.0094374539,
-0.0172244068,
-0.0424045064,
-0.0087407604,
-0.026856469,
0.0374363698,
-0.0303303618,
-0.0565735213,
-0.0552517921,
0.0027121252,
-0.0107433088,
-0.0244830344,
-0.0310077649,
-0.0278923307,
-0.0303640515,
-0.0502150021,
0.0480385609,
-0.0269015729,
0.035670273,
0.017738577,
-0.0343313776,
0.0005082049,
0.0037068988,
-0.0415079966,
0.0443455949,
-0.1293882877,
-0.0876744762,
0.0249921121,
0.0575138815,
0.0193157066,
0.0490335785,
-0.0325236395,
-0.019910749,
0.0044973702,
0.0334912539,
-0.063390024,
0.0149138141,
0.0724544376,
-0.0089849122,
0.0262711737,
0.0424048603,
-0.0289752744,
0.0157478526,
0.0530865416,
0.0480563119,
0.0014754031,
-0.0196896698,
0.0335357599,
-0.0201158188,
0.0889772251,
-0.010256201,
-0.0183370113,
-0.0379841439,
0.0109458193,
-0.0492008813,
-0.0592966788,
-0.0064302059,
0.0014826108,
0.0124113793,
-0.0049844757,
-0.0171378851,
0.0084002819,
-0.0363973975,
0.05734317,
-0.0514549874,
0.0155028226,
0.053220626,
-0.0078985877,
0.0122533748,
-0.0006338552,
-0.0191280749,
-0.0004724941,
0.0127431955,
0.0470887013,
0.0005423623,
0.0346509889,
0.0299506281,
-0.0256426502,
-0.0146654639,
-0.0314125121,
-0.1242174804,
0.0267984923,
-0.023356691,
0.0170492046,
0.0468859375,
-0.0460548252,
0.0219431017,
-0.0291096754,
-0.0111679882,
0.0043373285,
0.0192852989,
-0.0097061787,
-0.0086692628,
0.0316621102,
0.0179939009,
-0.0046711816,
0.0449798219,
0.0538503602,
0.0096206283,
0.0760716125,
-0.016847631,
0.0346399844,
-0.0165925939,
-0.0621445216,
0.00862554,
0.04567606,
0.0050718035,
0.0293894485,
-0.0749750808,
-0.0679282621,
0.0151410699,
0.0274994709,
0.0103482697,
-0.0060000964,
0.020443717,
0.0077276714,
-0.0254981853,
-0.0305955056,
-0.0141118737,
0.054954309,
0.0073014656,
0.0056329188,
-0.0736937299,
-6.901511739e-33,
-0.0021319771,
-0.0117315445,
-0.0103818141,
-0.0605419166,
0.0236954447,
0.0043026018,
-0.0363044925,
-0.0241107401,
-0.052646298,
0.0299322587,
0.021177154,
0.0432718396,
0.0203498881,
0.0383710153,
0.0016887099,
-0.029313175,
0.0613141283,
0.0322388448,
-0.0040630503,
0.0210890025,
-0.0130017065,
0.0022402806,
0.0789073184,
-0.0780379847,
0.0536008812,
-0.0331527814,
0.0059270016,
0.0165968705,
-0.0516884811,
0.0141365444,
-0.0081054047,
0.0726960152,
0.0254746154,
-0.0258673131,
0.0210837033,
-0.0202121455,
-0.0564415865,
-0.0402622074,
0.0423224419,
-0.0041005588,
-0.0255032349,
-0.0064938474,
0.0285951588,
0.0163042955,
0.0145962248,
0.0019396442,
0.0381191112,
-0.0151664251,
0.0324719399,
0.0317780189,
-0.0674828067,
0.0211047865,
-0.0265397802,
-0.0037367176,
-0.0401124172,
0.0842440575,
0.0406650826,
0.0219146591,
-0.0495565869,
0.0051245126,
0.0338960662,
-0.0162753612,
0.028992163,
0.0123163927,
0.0057460186,
0.052549243,
0.0113837514,
0.0333159044,
-0.0231734347,
-0.0213530641,
-0.0008184393,
0.0363563448,
0.0600973926,
0.1428441703,
0.078598097,
0.0020718649,
-0.0754447505,
-0.0022605392,
-0.0091567794,
0.0117072882,
-0.0022623222,
0.0020475117,
-0.0176981036,
-0.0110516362,
-0.048530221,
-0.0405126661,
-0.029409958,
0.020869609,
0.0147742117,
-0.0044077504,
-0.0273682717,
0.0174671263,
0.0041365349,
-0.0410445742,
0.0143764745,
0.0362794697,
-0.0103501473,
-0.0253929961,
0.0237280857,
0.0409691334,
-0.0675235018,
0.0026157554,
0.0459563285,
0.0266339518,
0.0275044739,
-0.0023001144,
0.0649926588,
-0.0005758419,
-0.0510841981,
0.0079423711,
-0.0449779779,
0.0131425187,
-0.0093084835,
0.0020919226,
0.0412911847,
0.0603946522,
-0.0217811856,
0.0326912403,
0.0560409352,
0.0047919801,
-0.0224763155,
0.0196114276,
-0.0187248364,
0.0148608079,
-0.0206201226,
-0.0271387007,
0.0049039079,
0.0052641691,
-0.0091520771,
-0.0573175922,
-0.0187799167,
-0.0029286733,
2.611e-7,
0.0494652204,
0.0209712777,
0.0326344073,
0.0055591478,
0.0132994382,
0.043727167,
-0.0034754644,
0.0059404052,
0.0283324774,
0.0071467482,
-0.0038250918,
0.04848006,
0.0422485471,
0.0255648755,
-0.0430809148,
0.0445250683,
-0.0955450162,
-0.0281815808,
-0.0274363495,
0.0139618237,
0.0886284634,
0.0935056135,
0.0630377755,
-0.0009463117,
-0.0020503961,
-0.0028272145,
0.0497344583,
-0.0206376873,
0.0143064242,
-0.0234964155,
-0.019488303,
-0.010804899,
-0.0114847841,
0.0480721556,
-0.0290777422,
0.0257680081,
-0.0462709777,
0.0373077132,
-0.0161918234,
-0.0472267494,
-0.0575816967,
-0.0273539536,
0.0154857691,
-0.0600159951,
0.0835611224,
-0.0277104732,
-0.0108315656,
-0.0184411742,
-0.0585773587,
0.0213049632,
0.0515034236,
-0.0305127725,
-0.0492014475,
0.0004025973,
0.0201195404,
0.0111483112,
-0.0266871955,
-0.0535449386,
-0.0631702542,
0.0518533923,
-0.0511515848,
-0.033156801,
-0.0162145142,
-0.0206874721,
0.0355051495,
-0.0314749591,
0.0457568765,
2.205329799e-34,
0.0398988128,
0.0060929167,
0.0108160665,
-0.0256114043,
0.0601714179,
-0.0051187086,
-0.0424038693,
-0.0004318224,
0.0517530851,
-0.0167780668,
-0.0129771149
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.11672v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.11672v1 | Trustworthy Social Bias Measurement | 2022-12-20T18:45:12 | 2022-12-20T18:45:12 | Rishi Bommasani, Percy Liang | cs.CL | cs.CL | How do we design measures of social bias that we trust? While prior work has
introduced several measures, no measure has gained widespread trust: instead,
mounting evidence argues we should distrust these measures. In this work, we
design bias measures that warrant trust based on the cross-disciplinary theory
of measurement modeling. To combat the frequently fuzzy treatment of social
bias in NLP, we explicitly define social bias, grounded in principles drawn
from social science research. We operationalize our definition by proposing a
general bias measurement framework DivDist, which we use to instantiate 5
concrete bias measures. To validate our measures, we propose a rigorous testing
protocol with 8 testing criteria (e.g. predictive validity: do measures predict
biases in US employment?). Through our testing, we demonstrate considerable
evidence to trust our measures, showing they overcome conceptual, technical,
and empirical deficiencies present in prior measures. | [
0.0291868951,
0.0765394419,
-0.0450891145,
0.0155212646,
-0.0073770625,
0.0011248098,
0.0332489945,
-0.0191330966,
0.0662936717,
-0.0532268584,
0.001067057,
0.0115267979,
0.0476786867,
-0.0038977235,
-0.004458433,
-0.0427231081,
0.0349581428,
0.0734410211,
0.0782520771,
-0.0312117822,
0.0416929387,
0.0279653445,
0.0070143663,
0.0448446833,
-0.0341355763,
0.0124532757,
0.0852758288,
-0.0177523158,
0.014852209,
-0.0391469821,
0.0681416467,
0.0626925603,
-0.0584370606,
0.02810972,
0.0000018866,
-0.063982144,
-0.0035141949,
0.0066320039,
0.01669541,
-0.0194833763,
0.0546114258,
0.0092659108,
0.0083202403,
0.0206097495,
-0.0448339507,
0.0066085118,
0.0098622935,
-0.0173534639,
0.0220705438,
0.0141527159,
-0.0029571143,
-0.0156031549,
-0.0694167018,
-0.0014718422,
-0.002965759,
-0.0113125024,
0.0345099606,
-0.0366702266,
-0.0515128784,
-0.0378918573,
-0.0073658824,
-0.0119609861,
0.0043285643,
0.0335214809,
0.0346657149,
0.0180743057,
-0.0149783697,
-0.0310803596,
-0.0120621081,
0.0196349546,
0.0508413464,
-0.0191716775,
0.01374353,
-0.0285783038,
0.0659457073,
0.0590441041,
-0.0109089827,
0.0141204484,
0.0005903615,
-0.0232042931,
-0.0194380358,
0.0565755181,
-0.0042328085,
0.050896205,
0.0465853773,
0.0768776014,
0.0110343499,
-0.0226636473,
0.0180904735,
0.0491178036,
0.0794186145,
-0.027306335,
0.0344069898,
-0.0097404672,
0.0015546306,
0.0064445478,
-0.0153771201,
0.0240505114,
0.0411517993,
-0.060896121,
-0.0186740216,
-0.0044840593,
-0.015289844,
0.0313215889,
0.0199461821,
-0.0096376883,
-0.0071128402,
-0.0266032368,
0.011656885,
0.002213923,
-0.0455559045,
0.0124295987,
0.0031022397,
-0.0403431281,
0.0169877615,
0.037307255,
-0.0293964427,
-0.0178791434,
-0.0882136896,
0.0258597657,
0.0073701739,
0.0293187425,
-0.0028064419,
0.009063879,
-0.0748232082,
0.019153757,
-0.0736892521,
0.0393745005,
-0.0458159558,
-0.054394234,
0.0147393979,
0.0187837016,
0.0052465997,
-0.0367972106,
-0.0126401335,
0.0189775452,
0.0404756777,
-0.0151353534,
-0.0185725689,
-0.0531652197,
-0.0236844476,
-0.0221260618,
-0.0296647698,
-0.0410244204,
0.034815792,
0.0209955238,
0.0240069795,
-0.0509209186,
-0.0181694925,
0.0125014447,
-0.0609978475,
0.0227202121,
0.0009648869,
0.0028410442,
0.0173847098,
0.0117735835,
-0.0249086097,
0.0486043952,
0.0047089984,
0.0040260856,
0.0775094479,
-0.020477144,
0.0157196615,
0.0260007922,
0.0302730873,
-0.0000342176,
0.0278685652,
0.0424218364,
-0.0557146557,
-0.0341168605,
0.0475531742,
0.0505068339,
-0.0135020381,
-0.0139660528,
0.0516741872,
0.0621463545,
-0.0173165873,
0.0275857225,
-0.0122005763,
0.0333232097,
-0.0186772663,
0.0023057477,
-0.0593266748,
0.0129609732,
-0.0156709533,
-0.0379865505,
-0.008530098,
0.0368665718,
-0.0165334046,
-0.0220952444,
-0.0202689338,
0.0477092527,
0.0687184185,
-0.0054726037,
-0.0088830683,
0.0036155891,
0.0139882285,
0.0488636084,
0.0223432593,
-0.0224453453,
0.03035089,
0.0088788485,
0.0138749592,
0.0335160792,
-0.0110282078,
-0.0192932412,
0.0327250734,
-0.0278241932,
-0.0145515474,
0.0294109751,
0.0834912658,
-0.0109638134,
-0.0137853594,
-0.0082001342,
-0.0022971439,
0.0518273637,
0.0632199496,
0.009741134,
0.0927462876,
0.0532144979,
-0.0094646206,
-0.0573442206,
-0.0210862309,
0.0349697024,
0.0594321154,
-0.0131749641,
-0.0207204409,
0.0170590673,
0.0396090299,
0.0457754247,
-0.0174258798,
-0.013217032,
-0.0398173742,
0.0455227122,
-0.0290848184,
0.024880778,
-0.0226256792,
0.0108816661,
-0.0059155216,
-0.0788773522,
-0.0649693534,
0.0136010032,
-0.0076234816,
0.0340181105,
0.0477237701,
-0.0131231891,
0.0286273547,
-0.002577686,
-0.0279520433,
-0.0771434605,
0.0192036889,
-0.0410800874,
0.0510231145,
-0.0025836134,
-0.0142606022,
-0.0091582742,
-0.0488438867,
0.0354165658,
-0.0360397622,
-0.0250675697,
-0.0259987731,
-0.0154823577,
-0.0112428637,
0.0557048954,
-0.0441530421,
-0.0640980154,
-0.0361800641,
-0.0474447422,
-0.0172380991,
-0.0084861973,
-0.0077269715,
0.0179638546,
-0.0094003538,
-0.0206446312,
-0.0061338344,
-0.0308565814,
-0.0267429631,
0.0031418183,
0.040639516,
-0.0021209063,
-0.0395813957,
0.0138807036,
-0.0306915101,
-0.0090604872,
-0.0414361991,
0.0377198718,
0.0494005308,
-0.0182151943,
-0.0586294755,
-0.026678035,
-0.0266672,
-0.0318150371,
0.0391828828,
-0.0006126873,
0.0205336027,
0.0879668891,
-0.0334766954,
0.0444683991,
0.0109131383,
-0.0008872664,
0.0160810072,
-0.0225088913,
-0.0393085256,
-0.0450732782,
-0.0181447435,
0.0363519378,
0.0107433554,
-0.07123252,
-0.003119542,
0.0134782726,
0.0644056499,
-0.0176136531,
-0.0643187091,
0.0491176844,
-0.0787835643,
-0.0439096242,
0.0189241078,
-0.0525902137,
-0.0105759269,
0.0266026258,
-0.0313968658,
-0.0379147194,
0.0057443161,
0.0095505603,
0.0371768773,
-0.0170334708,
0.0011149978,
-0.0246059969,
0.0228542648,
-0.0186847467,
-0.0092689507,
-0.0008039777,
-0.0043735802,
-0.0387960188,
-0.0150227249,
0.057218682,
-0.0171200391,
-0.0353959352,
-0.0321080051,
0.0004664171,
0.0184099842,
-0.0082795573,
-0.0223576892,
-0.0442697629,
-0.0372680016,
-0.0039457618,
0.01312155,
-0.002799931,
0.0249213036,
-0.0204597786,
0.0139975511,
-0.0269721542,
-0.0075453818,
-0.0219130181,
0.0161877163,
-0.0033951355,
-0.0033651593,
-0.0126885371,
0.0584702902,
0.0239757542,
-0.0197677426,
0.0220106412,
0.0200562477,
0.0275446344,
-0.0258654431,
-0.0126595795,
0.013250784,
-0.0429676063,
0.0139048975,
0.0111551527,
0.0475133993,
-0.0074485443,
0.0225836653,
0.0902151167,
-0.006480935,
-0.0346718729,
0.0174364205,
0.0096664745,
-0.0105920378,
0.0452901497,
-0.0162387211,
-0.0668136925,
0.0005204076,
-0.0009152041,
-0.0020698518,
-0.030991111,
-0.0559244566,
-0.0115294689,
-0.0991055071,
0.0032860918,
-0.0145622902,
0.026740836,
-0.0121189579,
-0.0467910804,
0.047324542,
-0.0408978686,
-0.0076264297,
-0.0291328803,
0.0232961699,
0.0195395648,
0.0064921933,
-0.0541219339,
-0.0330872498,
0.0340612195,
-0.0544206165,
0.0444034003,
0.0229489226,
0.0536728874,
-0.0316044278,
-0.0041671055,
0.022466151,
-0.0241344683,
-0.0297460724,
-0.0347625688,
0.0589710437,
-0.0527668409,
-0.0075120316,
-0.0347552672,
0.0483495891,
0.0050532864,
0.0194823742,
-0.0046293531,
0.0252672415,
0.0722359568,
-0.0513720103,
-0.0276561398,
-0.0157951228,
-0.0181037467,
0.100404717,
0.0128154373,
-0.0103063956,
0.0405397527,
-0.0313339457,
0.0158234332,
0.0456063524,
-0.0720351636,
0.0192513354,
-0.0102456594,
-0.0274459384,
-0.0453518853,
-0.0752470493,
0.0191775132,
0.0250872038,
0.0179436952,
-0.0485228263,
0.0734206215,
-0.0461002588,
-0.0125312833,
0.0306213051,
-0.0264963973,
0.0576802194,
0.0470401384,
-0.0228254646,
-0.0528070256,
0.0296227857,
-0.0301642418,
-0.0204435922,
-0.0018036974,
-0.033230368,
0.0634471104,
-0.0005493921,
0.0230337474,
-0.0015658441,
-0.0305030588,
-0.0542473383,
0.0566299446,
0.0223073084,
-0.0395928547,
0.0223205257,
0.0129548591,
0.0171757657,
0.0174251478,
-0.0080273803,
-0.0456894711,
0.0013461183,
0.0448425226,
-0.010490844,
-0.0299092364,
-0.0185796041,
-0.0009802143,
-0.0319285132,
0.0626341552,
-0.0330920853,
0.0541580021,
-0.0402792767,
-0.0717615113,
-0.0005224165,
-0.0752588585,
0.0350862704,
-0.0506895669,
0.0287477281,
0.0262399409,
-0.0702788681,
-0.0248269532,
-0.0641657934,
0.0410900228,
-0.0261140987,
0.0195287298,
0.0173586886,
0.0367639586,
-0.0362534672,
-0.009880174,
-0.0113666393,
0.0231024474,
-0.0399097465,
0.0349592566,
0.0527919903,
0.0347004682,
0.0165901184,
0.0047041872,
0.0161144584,
-0.0132028852,
-0.0545494892,
0.0140009494,
0.0103027867,
0.0013356318,
-0.0222658478,
-0.0722362176,
0.0309805907,
0.0221487749,
0.0048975511,
0.0181861427,
-0.0269215871,
0.0070479279,
-0.0284070503,
0.0268964767,
-0.0149855986,
-0.0109087843,
0.0181465577,
0.0231401566,
-0.0179692451,
0.0177282263,
-0.034789972,
-0.0586479604,
-0.0058878423,
-0.0429599732,
0.0295483191,
0.0008483402,
-0.0327206366,
-0.0308534857,
-0.1043253094,
-0.0364976861,
-0.0223927461,
-0.0136172622,
0.057052549,
-0.0074520232,
0.0067837331,
0.0670185313,
-0.0265267789,
-0.0169814229,
0.0112192864,
-0.0219781809,
-0.0185616892,
0.0027523946,
-0.0545454882,
-6.332621697e-33,
0.0044671819,
-0.0645535812,
-0.0170265194,
-0.0158291087,
0.0188457184,
0.0189457759,
0.0118983639,
0.0137843797,
-0.0469997227,
0.0470934808,
-0.0044860872,
0.0257609934,
0.0217368901,
-0.0380578972,
0.0209037289,
-0.0178708602,
0.032047648,
0.0084745251,
-0.03404627,
-0.0286590848,
-0.0349197499,
-0.0275150649,
0.0518979989,
-0.0593255758,
0.0992493704,
0.0376053788,
-0.012275218,
-0.0071896678,
0.0462152064,
-0.0051115253,
0.0054199621,
0.0809225589,
0.0393912755,
-0.0206492711,
0.020057423,
0.0569934696,
-0.0126149561,
-0.0488108583,
0.0293355454,
0.0392358564,
0.0447836481,
0.0145876864,
0.0011575673,
0.0201939121,
-0.109286651,
-0.001399502,
0.0740856975,
0.0003979733,
0.0530022122,
0.0237153471,
-0.0406334028,
0.033530701,
-0.0302014835,
0.0451932959,
-0.0361299776,
0.0282261781,
0.0156005779,
0.033582624,
-0.0451777503,
-0.0015711944,
-0.061055541,
-0.0121848155,
0.0158422962,
-0.0344031602,
0.0223706849,
0.0735145584,
0.0415078439,
0.0656820312,
-0.0167008415,
-0.0497336946,
0.0421944447,
-0.0577248149,
0.0456438176,
0.1182821393,
0.0393378772,
-0.0090494212,
-0.004168937,
-0.0126299039,
0.0665513575,
0.028442584,
0.0254668444,
-0.0197019968,
-0.1010360122,
-0.0268166624,
-0.0368936025,
-0.0955924615,
-0.0173284411,
0.0061446368,
0.0382568762,
0.0192195624,
-0.0289115403,
0.0340871885,
0.0096160863,
-0.0323279984,
0.0104022771,
0.0260929521,
-0.0189556312,
-0.0214877259,
0.0235212892,
0.0058297114,
-0.0759546906,
0.0052266442,
-0.0059934543,
0.0771408007,
0.0555925034,
-0.0105876978,
-0.0016050607,
-0.0212368648,
-0.055530645,
0.008791822,
-0.0010594998,
-0.0064555546,
-0.0007437871,
-0.0476602614,
0.0343452655,
0.0365714617,
0.0083145471,
-0.0164675508,
0.0521457382,
0.0121340556,
-0.0221787877,
-0.0055167754,
-0.0126215285,
0.0074646985,
-0.0130811129,
-0.0355648659,
0.0110620195,
-0.0338896438,
0.0099127134,
-0.0239404514,
-0.0138865635,
-0.067140609,
2.505e-7,
0.0000697207,
0.066800639,
-0.0425117984,
0.0426291786,
0.0077010198,
0.0388597101,
0.04397038,
0.0522754267,
0.0090409555,
-0.032489527,
-0.0353137776,
0.0085772052,
-0.0135244792,
0.0264446251,
-0.0347824506,
-0.0483033247,
-0.061348822,
0.0317770392,
-0.010968429,
-0.0093981409,
0.0071244952,
0.0034190996,
0.0634568557,
0.0229922142,
-0.0470191389,
-0.0311239008,
0.0123844193,
0.0060722921,
0.0347077698,
0.0322853029,
0.0361812785,
0.0063662208,
0.0271316487,
0.0431277752,
-0.0002493373,
0.0326551795,
-0.0023066932,
-0.0090809735,
0.0081945034,
0.0103777666,
-0.0239292253,
-0.0453745052,
-0.0148891294,
-0.077160269,
0.0274481382,
0.0070961411,
-0.0115536572,
-0.0516794436,
-0.0673373565,
-0.0053840308,
0.0459409282,
0.0058636889,
-0.0432768464,
-0.0230378211,
0.0344546586,
0.0255778618,
-0.0328374654,
-0.0355449356,
-0.032430809,
-0.0683236122,
0.0092003522,
-0.081657581,
0.0314416327,
0.0535174012,
-0.0050394931,
-0.0062110182,
0.026609268,
1.658761086e-34,
0.0034210961,
0.0011802253,
0.0310971029,
-0.0386231765,
0.0746858791,
0.017747147,
-0.0644502863,
-0.0271924995,
0.049527321,
-0.0182214715,
0.0078034438
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10529v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10529v3 | Evaluating Psychological Safety of Large Language Models | 2022-12-20T18:45:07 | 2024-02-29T13:14:37 | Xingxuan Li, Yutong Li, Lin Qiu, Shafiq Joty, Lidong Bing | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | In this work, we designed unbiased prompts to systematically evaluate the
psychological safety of large language models (LLMs). First, we tested five
different LLMs by using two personality tests: Short Dark Triad (SD-3) and Big
Five Inventory (BFI). All models scored higher than the human average on SD-3,
suggesting a relatively darker personality pattern. Despite being instruction
fine-tuned with safety metrics to reduce toxicity, InstructGPT, GPT-3.5, and
GPT-4 still showed dark personality patterns; these models scored higher than
self-supervised GPT-3 on the Machiavellianism and narcissism traits on SD-3.
Then, we evaluated the LLMs in the GPT series by using well-being tests to
study the impact of fine-tuning with more training data. We observed a
continuous increase in the well-being scores of GPT models. Following these
observations, we showed that fine-tuning Llama-2-chat-7B with responses from
BFI using direct preference optimization could effectively reduce the
psychological toxicity of the model. Based on the findings, we recommended the
application of systematic and comprehensive psychological metrics to further
evaluate and improve the safety of LLMs. | [
0.0698310211,
0.0711985752,
-0.0360440761,
0.021186471,
-0.0131525565,
0.0275539383,
0.0162615534,
0.0010364207,
0.0357124731,
0.0009821056,
-0.0875880569,
-0.0251690689,
-0.0136223612,
0.0049323807,
0.0432183333,
-0.0528079979,
0.0513429232,
-0.0063742665,
0.03087564,
-0.0173540395,
-0.0031716062,
0.0211099833,
0.0325645804,
0.0337157622,
0.0101488344,
-0.0440835394,
0.042090524,
-0.0196259916,
0.0251921881,
-0.0507305004,
0.0070146392,
0.0796761513,
-0.0074208998,
0.0404612161,
0.0000023741,
-0.0443758704,
0.0166735724,
-0.004478245,
0.0188832302,
0.0315770768,
0.1034860536,
0.0235259905,
0.0008693245,
0.0493182205,
-0.0148413591,
-0.0074451682,
0.0272003133,
0.0600847416,
0.0530739725,
0.0451000109,
-0.005925532,
-0.0197310857,
0.0195835065,
-0.0261518098,
-0.0210862905,
-0.0018551529,
0.0589764342,
-0.0228459686,
-0.0083388453,
0.0177973602,
-0.0082770037,
-0.0005152522,
-0.0008816462,
0.0068398877,
-0.0209292881,
-0.0077612512,
-0.0178568605,
-0.0610398129,
-0.0072907917,
0.055764474,
0.0082496628,
0.0069048596,
-0.0160429981,
-0.0184303205,
0.0190570131,
-0.046595294,
-0.0073658973,
0.023028234,
0.0060878163,
-0.0280232895,
0.024797963,
-0.0056873639,
0.0190820489,
0.0063661705,
0.0321743377,
0.0476166643,
0.0168290492,
-0.0198667645,
0.0439080894,
-0.0021065667,
-0.0257597771,
-0.0479529761,
-0.0040789908,
-0.0319143608,
-0.0211441852,
0.0210666098,
-0.0225423947,
0.0157218929,
0.0415384173,
-0.0808505863,
0.0016252694,
0.0496265255,
-0.0416261107,
-0.0201678351,
0.0274375342,
0.0495359078,
0.0079035684,
0.0426050127,
-0.0245630704,
0.0234269518,
-0.0084450329,
-0.0066761123,
0.000276248,
-0.0136762895,
0.0283966977,
-0.005542275,
-0.0874433294,
-0.0016751325,
-0.0374217853,
-0.0210100263,
0.0015178456,
-0.0016191349,
0.0112056537,
0.0152413826,
-0.0370155722,
0.0057142451,
-0.0571260676,
0.0100612314,
-0.0069736349,
-0.0448541045,
0.0461215936,
-0.0097492058,
-0.0385536179,
-0.0543608926,
0.043176122,
0.0774075016,
0.0041529266,
-0.0459521599,
-0.0652783513,
0.0028169535,
-0.0476352051,
-0.0811825991,
0.0174317267,
-0.0189845469,
-0.0233670399,
-0.0047589047,
0.00459598,
-0.0464581065,
0.0089128679,
0.0123119121,
-0.0653082952,
0.0365747996,
-0.0173345711,
0.0137772635,
0.0166428871,
0.0288343355,
-0.0285327956,
0.0683185235,
0.0327672102,
0.0242371075,
0.0181658585,
-0.0648236945,
-0.007252668,
0.0381487794,
-0.0244929809,
0.0369762965,
-0.0216993093,
-0.0254545975,
-0.0213412084,
0.0083322497,
0.0144903772,
0.0564610288,
-0.0175223425,
0.0046516028,
0.1102119386,
0.0184916742,
0.0096842702,
0.0549905412,
-0.0019287864,
0.0113535598,
0.0253796615,
0.0306478646,
-0.0877142623,
0.0092052314,
-0.0714034438,
-0.0316861123,
-0.0071152905,
0.0329466462,
-0.0103360526,
-0.0334096476,
-0.030451376,
-0.0078625465,
0.0548884869,
0.0388176553,
0.003965639,
-0.0347722322,
-0.0279904101,
-0.0321403705,
0.0724364817,
-0.0277874935,
-0.0523484349,
-0.0569488704,
0.0241868533,
0.090150401,
0.0135378381,
0.0229049046,
-0.0159858838,
-0.0266447905,
-0.0161151271,
0.0368582159,
0.0358390696,
0.0041573606,
0.0056619113,
-0.0427652076,
0.0101300208,
0.0076085147,
0.0050867982,
0.0097575169,
0.0212033018,
0.0275792573,
-0.0078865048,
0.0233038608,
-0.0569662824,
0.0197926257,
-0.0561862476,
-0.0461467952,
-0.0106371753,
0.0102862036,
0.0568068177,
-0.0071775229,
-0.0218429472,
-0.0069208546,
-0.0074300179,
0.0114325965,
-0.0127289817,
-0.0076814285,
-0.047366824,
0.0505843461,
0.0172051173,
0.0053782538,
-0.003833056,
0.0466176309,
0.0137794055,
0.0113721397,
0.0073073586,
-0.0387420729,
0.0047294595,
-0.0009428883,
0.0245004296,
-0.0633303151,
0.0615440235,
-0.0136442073,
0.0388539992,
-0.0134546673,
0.0048889956,
0.0061349939,
-0.030329885,
-0.0233820006,
-0.0273776297,
-0.0539683327,
-0.0051629376,
0.003750029,
0.0325119086,
0.0203058217,
0.0525968559,
-0.0446972512,
-0.0490107499,
-0.083510004,
0.0169718191,
0.0085934307,
-0.004483406,
0.0091234054,
-0.0401189476,
-0.0564939603,
0.0311291311,
-0.0232095309,
0.0091693737,
0.0110034458,
0.0538188294,
-0.0112740323,
-0.0158980526,
-0.0459047742,
-0.0556277223,
-0.0219171457,
-0.0226719361,
-0.0008053826,
-0.0023473843,
0.0301737618,
-0.0142917195,
0.0784645304,
-0.0505653024,
0.0033246828,
-0.0064324625,
-0.1074796692,
0.0417174287,
0.0377309248,
0.0396034718,
0.0845745504,
0.0357471518,
0.0444189273,
0.0570325181,
0.0041047544,
-0.0142407231,
-0.0064591593,
0.0160872582,
-0.0674447194,
-0.0337474979,
-0.0613662861,
-0.0562040359,
0.054257717,
-0.0031042877,
0.005655712,
-0.0521445572,
0.0134730916,
-0.0296175163,
-0.0581678972,
0.0486476235,
-0.0263366289,
-0.0262107886,
0.0326681584,
0.0092727784,
-0.0431761853,
0.0618157499,
0.0157993045,
0.0165350549,
-0.007096123,
-0.0421871431,
0.0021386475,
0.0355285667,
0.0050966456,
0.0042152791,
0.059149716,
-0.0157207251,
-0.0540785454,
-0.0726012066,
0.0143332016,
-0.0311587118,
0.0298964623,
-0.0279872287,
-0.0340534113,
0.027119156,
-0.0513758659,
-0.0447490513,
-0.0475037098,
-0.0615033954,
-0.0396429636,
0.0587428771,
-0.0071170786,
-0.0323173627,
-0.0361952595,
0.0384841934,
-0.0368752554,
-0.0422727205,
0.0001635817,
0.0237834677,
-0.0554580912,
0.0723445788,
-0.0298613254,
0.0920921341,
-0.0714050233,
0.0247460548,
0.0174855571,
-0.0599254295,
0.0185373388,
-0.0169287454,
0.0165523794,
0.0261847153,
0.0176800936,
-0.0235158857,
0.0272667632,
0.0244297534,
-0.0297660567,
0.0154014099,
0.1064748466,
-0.0033489834,
-0.0204985794,
0.0413110256,
0.002643086,
0.0319654308,
0.026178835,
0.0071203173,
-0.0590178967,
-0.0246640388,
0.0063623586,
0.035747204,
-0.0618983321,
-0.0252122022,
0.0121298209,
-0.0875329599,
0.0213360935,
0.0247902833,
-0.0327221081,
0.0156481601,
-0.0278822798,
-0.0016765008,
-0.0370904319,
0.0509941131,
-0.0129215373,
-0.0019946226,
-0.0372753255,
-0.0047618044,
-0.0615603253,
-0.0487970039,
0.078310281,
-0.022423273,
0.0431509055,
0.0163319539,
0.0198626406,
-0.0347197987,
-0.0143820383,
0.0018711963,
0.0334879421,
-0.0183709804,
0.0249438379,
0.0672887713,
-0.0247899387,
-0.0075038569,
-0.0732363462,
0.0095656924,
0.0103574228,
0.0285579767,
-0.0011173851,
0.0401933491,
0.0361441597,
-0.0807776898,
-0.0165751129,
0.0301582161,
0.013125143,
0.0804488286,
0.0055794655,
-0.0904653221,
0.0271912087,
-0.0148269143,
0.0073945103,
0.00332647,
-0.0727046728,
0.0189513899,
0.0153043633,
-0.0178363267,
-0.0368393362,
-0.0613817424,
0.0182078052,
-0.0034578105,
0.0144890398,
-0.0221651606,
-0.0011971932,
0.0340308435,
0.0104465205,
0.053058546,
0.0048159813,
0.0137523133,
-0.0713686347,
0.0283757821,
0.0496431887,
-0.0148326047,
0.0136218816,
0.0497276224,
-0.0458052494,
-0.0633054897,
0.0589367747,
0.0551527515,
0.0264259372,
-0.0077414466,
0.0137433251,
-0.0716994628,
0.0235689469,
0.005000426,
-0.039972838,
0.0339001492,
0.0128016248,
0.0111602908,
0.0183093473,
0.0304293651,
-0.0262550842,
0.0369460359,
0.0279912166,
-0.0052159661,
0.0004408617,
-0.0394647717,
0.0199461374,
0.0671656206,
0.0053458172,
-0.0491226315,
-0.0109087089,
-0.0305801146,
-0.0282104705,
-0.0701378435,
-0.0100201666,
-0.0200317632,
-0.0274658892,
0.0395953692,
0.0204488207,
-0.0278383456,
-0.0586494021,
-0.0134730423,
0.0299545117,
-0.0434815548,
0.0252836682,
-0.0316921957,
0.0077581895,
0.0229559466,
0.0313491076,
-0.0360691436,
0.0028223114,
-0.0158147626,
0.0349922292,
0.0126370108,
0.065765731,
-0.0149248978,
-0.0129814697,
0.0098441904,
0.0586160831,
-0.0252092574,
-0.0582086258,
-0.0214466397,
0.0078958767,
0.0167959705,
0.0030447119,
0.0699927658,
-0.0417313278,
0.0000547185,
-0.0426877588,
0.0160409026,
-0.0358570516,
-0.0409565233,
0.0064690486,
0.0092674736,
-0.0297355969,
-0.0335245356,
0.0444976464,
0.0380399711,
0.0334877968,
0.0022892621,
-0.019960776,
-0.0181733966,
0.0059980783,
0.0191491451,
0.0277527347,
-0.0352598801,
-0.0200640745,
-0.0836157799,
-0.0824190676,
-0.0093355039,
-0.0056990897,
0.0007377847,
-0.0303556863,
0.0207515359,
0.0267648008,
-0.0268697981,
-0.0147069227,
-0.0214511286,
-0.0348847471,
-0.0008021488,
-0.0177052617,
-0.009191989,
-6.922933655e-33,
-0.0165262148,
0.0077102687,
0.0127581218,
-0.0004651204,
-0.040637318,
-0.059112452,
-0.0100123873,
0.0646521598,
-0.0523193702,
0.0141392229,
-0.0088470262,
0.0045832368,
0.0005830101,
-0.0212328453,
0.0281100646,
0.0085994694,
0.0300639197,
-0.010932941,
-0.0183050577,
0.0034868985,
0.0048391642,
0.013377551,
0.0871689245,
-0.0884849802,
0.0074245012,
0.0161152277,
-0.0187848005,
-0.0190793462,
-0.0271792244,
0.0519470796,
-0.0084451577,
0.058364585,
0.0125846844,
-0.0015044579,
-0.0000433308,
0.0081831431,
-0.0067430832,
-0.0251471754,
0.0256634783,
0.0021642307,
0.0028697881,
-0.0565996394,
0.0480584167,
-0.0126425782,
-0.0342555679,
-0.041474618,
0.0059425766,
-0.0279465355,
0.0080203367,
0.0407530069,
-0.0437214561,
0.0003271808,
-0.0091434577,
-0.0090343123,
-0.0389941856,
0.0203034189,
-0.0231255721,
0.0131669017,
-0.0320545286,
0.0243828744,
0.0114376051,
-0.0119758863,
0.0300856158,
0.0210812259,
0.029076824,
0.0602158308,
0.0523052923,
0.0560400523,
0.0096874656,
-0.0477053076,
0.066755645,
0.0328618959,
0.0436668918,
0.0459985696,
-0.0120510282,
-0.0809962973,
-0.0386529826,
-0.0389909521,
0.0396336541,
-0.0056400876,
0.0393452607,
0.0024478363,
-0.0581827648,
-0.0586029962,
-0.0169507731,
-0.0099830683,
-0.0218734965,
-0.0520423949,
0.0400048755,
-0.0331609361,
-0.0084081544,
-0.0313174948,
0.0342159942,
-0.0340887196,
-0.0017228037,
0.0262722559,
-0.0599812679,
0.0467955507,
-0.0026188199,
0.014962649,
-0.0504399464,
0.0101090791,
-0.0051855096,
0.0058045122,
0.0518254824,
0.0158549696,
0.0242683534,
0.0305556115,
-0.0621104725,
0.0095252106,
-0.0004300813,
0.0290207881,
0.0534938201,
0.0121007115,
0.0049565523,
-0.0002058703,
0.0144013064,
0.0199865196,
0.0268486906,
0.0160939507,
-0.0488006398,
-0.006108501,
0.0141251246,
0.0126432888,
-0.000265808,
-0.0122854291,
-0.0124007305,
0.0231521185,
0.0692846701,
-0.0459279306,
-0.0143294437,
-0.0246142633,
3.05e-7,
-0.0093547497,
0.08317063,
-0.052988831,
0.0533586219,
0.0064166118,
0.067904599,
0.0019474988,
0.0296990499,
0.0353924744,
-0.0212322325,
0.0132973427,
0.0164568238,
0.0684918761,
0.0625215843,
-0.0249542948,
-0.0021697865,
-0.0601552092,
-0.0067477566,
-0.0619258173,
-0.0047189631,
0.0603905804,
0.0787675455,
0.0369149409,
-0.0200629979,
-0.0092474362,
-0.0335617959,
0.0433601215,
-0.0356994011,
-0.018265551,
0.0390346907,
0.021897532,
0.0375789106,
0.0092479298,
0.0474749021,
0.012941571,
-0.0052085593,
-0.0269359704,
0.0608930215,
-0.03061511,
-0.0150237791,
0.0323543064,
0.0247898735,
-0.0237530284,
-0.0569707118,
0.0624995157,
-0.0449220091,
-0.0528068393,
-0.0233255364,
-0.0238679629,
-0.0563842952,
0.0719493404,
-0.0402403884,
-0.0171767455,
0.026848698,
0.0235937797,
-0.0183688458,
-0.0095878672,
-0.0263981558,
0.0356028713,
0.018079007,
-0.0279679615,
-0.0720953643,
-0.0235837996,
0.0315329283,
-0.0276211761,
-0.0323250443,
0.0387555659,
2.792451574e-34,
0.0098426379,
-0.000804736,
0.0321399234,
-0.0284650791,
0.0719442144,
0.0431745127,
-0.007200947,
0.0158096999,
-0.0076950993,
-0.0551523454,
-0.0132242888
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10528v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10528v1 | HYRR: Hybrid Infused Reranking for Passage Retrieval | 2022-12-20T18:44:21 | 2022-12-20T18:44:21 | Jing Lu, Keith Hall, Ji Ma, Jianmo Ni | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | We present Hybrid Infused Reranking for Passages Retrieval (HYRR), a
framework for training rerankers based on a hybrid of BM25 and neural retrieval
models. Retrievers based on hybrid models have been shown to outperform both
BM25 and neural models alone. Our approach exploits this improved performance
when training a reranker, leading to a robust reranking model. The reranker, a
cross-attention neural model, is shown to be robust to different first-stage
retrieval systems, achieving better performance than rerankers simply trained
upon the first-stage retrievers in the multi-stage systems. We present
evaluations on a supervised passage retrieval task using MS MARCO and zero-shot
retrieval tasks using BEIR. The empirical results show strong performance on
both evaluations. | [
0.0122051146,
-0.0327738896,
-0.0251066145,
0.0277576614,
-0.0011019362,
0.0032194874,
-0.0133415638,
0.0173470713,
0.0388915204,
-0.022480404,
-0.0234258994,
-0.0449237712,
-0.0074362108,
0.0136225633,
0.00940012,
-0.0627129972,
0.0345907584,
0.0028090153,
0.0170173533,
0.0405238867,
-0.0255848244,
-0.0104431445,
0.0188382622,
0.0171184856,
0.0488111228,
0.0147602521,
-0.0083962362,
0.0097900806,
0.0519148782,
-0.0601907447,
0.021217715,
0.0004421876,
0.058898557,
0.0520382263,
0.0000020385,
-0.0223175399,
-0.0574750192,
0.0049834368,
-0.0018454456,
-0.0477553792,
0.0297516007,
0.0407515578,
0.0441849269,
-0.0109557435,
0.0065156347,
0.0121475104,
0.0242164992,
0.0407476388,
0.0584790148,
0.0673643127,
0.0043292674,
-0.0338557363,
-0.0087279426,
-0.0294975229,
0.0449041054,
-0.0511659309,
0.0087787332,
-0.0141869113,
0.02014184,
0.0974227712,
-0.0252369922,
0.032967627,
0.0127375331,
0.0279588364,
0.0783629864,
0.031614285,
-0.0248271152,
0.0725286752,
-0.0101949284,
0.0641627908,
-0.0546317995,
-0.0229748078,
-0.0069967182,
-0.0018069166,
-0.0267978944,
-0.0083954614,
-0.0576752387,
0.003863595,
-0.0093572373,
0.0163859725,
-0.0521758832,
0.0550972521,
0.0311472155,
-0.0088213179,
-0.0130154639,
0.0150839249,
0.0027076891,
-0.0357147604,
-0.0192568116,
0.0079371072,
0.0150276963,
0.0125576472,
0.0514088087,
0.0149230091,
0.0332292095,
0.013951066,
0.0003280784,
-0.0146523146,
-0.0183190946,
-0.0133314356,
0.0167146232,
0.0364392214,
-0.0269612316,
0.0369924828,
-0.0478129759,
0.0663077608,
0.0009685053,
0.0363338403,
-0.0295140781,
0.0078196647,
-0.0141660953,
-0.0144979535,
-0.0164549742,
0.0553415194,
-0.0038350762,
-0.0141720371,
-0.0380753055,
-0.0344541594,
0.0417821556,
-0.0198970567,
-0.0268260222,
0.0133991083,
-0.0329923034,
-0.0338548385,
-0.0183910877,
0.009662577,
0.0078253942,
-0.0215515029,
0.0010335402,
0.03648296,
-0.0163743943,
-0.0081664156,
-0.0148347374,
-0.0235213786,
0.0004868106,
0.0107955225,
-0.0590269491,
-0.0689452589,
-0.0369096659,
-0.0195518043,
-0.0123121981,
-0.022950042,
-0.0054962304,
-0.0311560631,
0.0468325466,
-0.0139359459,
-0.0027924555,
0.0025614747,
0.0254607834,
0.0514251702,
-0.03716572,
0.0198715404,
0.0482187308,
-0.0305581577,
0.0107778469,
0.059783306,
0.0139481602,
0.031483531,
0.0136283999,
0.0567137823,
0.0396550372,
0.0212775189,
-0.0013890639,
0.0180380885,
-0.0165878795,
-0.0163115375,
-0.0100906799,
-0.0271934047,
-0.0031565088,
0.0112922098,
0.008134448,
0.0059966343,
-0.0620901436,
-0.0626897514,
0.0711692572,
0.072557874,
0.0433452651,
-0.0005877406,
0.0039113555,
-0.0132877277,
-0.0140171936,
0.0480269454,
-0.0073022312,
0.042754706,
0.0185271893,
0.0168288574,
0.0521636158,
0.0210923217,
0.0011235994,
-0.023754321,
0.0101653179,
0.0299298745,
-0.0385771431,
0.0249164496,
0.044339519,
0.0080132997,
-0.0506125204,
0.0301760938,
-0.0017680682,
-0.0626764596,
0.0050353548,
-0.0093084602,
-0.0216482803,
0.1038414314,
0.0845912993,
-0.0714076161,
-0.0145825036,
0.0004460713,
-0.0044145258,
0.0003518186,
-0.0243800301,
0.0244158152,
0.0144529529,
-0.0843841434,
-0.0259278379,
0.0136211487,
0.0050209262,
0.0398184471,
-0.0168016721,
0.0123835616,
0.0239495281,
-0.0633718073,
-0.0150473621,
0.0612377897,
0.0012096269,
-0.011021493,
-0.021685686,
-0.0005069802,
-0.0051153782,
0.0244600829,
-0.0027757515,
0.0018089238,
0.0602417476,
-0.0295962542,
0.0033664217,
-0.0168199111,
-0.0788100436,
-0.0248010922,
0.015817564,
-0.0115792928,
0.0090256054,
0.0687602311,
-0.0116037615,
-0.0096257683,
-0.0349453315,
-0.0068871318,
-0.0297067817,
0.0024850662,
0.0417203717,
0.0123752262,
-0.0202701874,
-0.0862694085,
0.0620753579,
-0.0140376035,
0.0705329329,
0.0049084686,
-0.030734472,
-0.0241334438,
-0.0653691962,
-0.0430914238,
0.0084375283,
-0.0052745738,
-0.0210323967,
0.0174667407,
-0.0453711785,
-0.0226251781,
0.0003846843,
-0.0508152395,
0.0137588009,
-0.0024893691,
-0.0189196542,
0.0039778603,
-0.0007663044,
0.0060555232,
-0.0187201891,
0.004459023,
-0.0239162743,
-0.0021238136,
-0.0044921809,
0.0231558662,
-0.0141191818,
0.0063793631,
-0.0358298942,
-0.0474964194,
-0.0146881854,
0.0564259104,
-0.0216312949,
-0.0406014137,
-0.028853368,
0.005278653,
-0.0014141572,
0.0229152553,
-0.0568990074,
-0.0183154847,
-0.0022610314,
-0.0187522359,
0.010962435,
0.0614949763,
0.0216808394,
-0.0279510245,
0.0436326303,
-0.023758756,
-0.0694257617,
0.0368013903,
0.007959771,
0.0112786954,
0.0223701149,
-0.0184988659,
0.0124826739,
0.0084821424,
0.0020729895,
0.012568417,
-0.006077602,
0.0008021421,
0.0027934781,
-0.0064125317,
-0.0671757609,
-0.0259071495,
-0.0506933406,
0.0098555908,
-0.0376576521,
0.0006565977,
0.0517821386,
-0.0320074856,
-0.0316861346,
-0.0593192354,
0.0050549959,
-0.0476268195,
0.0716214404,
0.0002454539,
0.0152951879,
-0.0070929178,
-0.0407584496,
-0.0397530869,
0.0066340622,
0.0109677585,
-0.0504257679,
0.0358924083,
0.0228975527,
0.0007627006,
-0.0161469132,
-0.0195766855,
-0.0539645292,
-0.0084090335,
0.0301940981,
-0.0076732244,
0.007950169,
0.0264263954,
-0.0493320301,
0.0409211889,
0.0283387303,
0.0512362272,
-0.0030226617,
-0.0088175908,
0.0003354687,
0.0866291746,
0.0005683089,
-0.0266988371,
-0.0013601473,
-0.0368742608,
0.0224985797,
0.043348629,
0.0263669565,
-0.0516098924,
0.0338737331,
-0.005879215,
0.0486987196,
-0.0516779721,
-0.0175378025,
-0.0061856918,
0.0066559608,
-0.1217251644,
-0.0245071836,
0.0503548495,
0.0400215276,
-0.0608250163,
-0.0460808128,
-0.0116677154,
-0.0066541634,
0.0013054783,
0.0189620741,
-0.0703643933,
0.0094574243,
0.0198295899,
0.0285865031,
0.032151334,
-0.0297779329,
0.0131668085,
-0.1054104194,
0.0546744764,
0.0267791525,
-0.0663492829,
-0.0450174548,
-0.0297221802,
0.0047884043,
0.0386695601,
-0.0309218355,
0.0636401325,
-0.0136448164,
-0.0274999924,
-0.0105716679,
0.0102205239,
0.0148529643,
-0.0064965133,
-0.035296578,
-0.0060469909,
-0.0062183184,
0.0118779466,
-0.007727955,
0.0046556476,
0.0082351407,
-0.0393594839,
0.0019042515,
0.030536823,
0.0719625577,
-0.0464897268,
0.006227307,
-0.0558447465,
-0.0114056552,
0.0587262772,
-0.0131486896,
-0.0358641781,
0.018347742,
0.0101899132,
0.0063769273,
-0.0513918474,
0.0337617546,
-0.0437995829,
0.031096885,
-0.0155974608,
0.0478137359,
-0.0333307832,
-0.0119234435,
0.0556340516,
-0.0623159669,
-0.0636873543,
0.041771885,
-0.0247428287,
0.002280782,
-0.0685113296,
-0.0377084017,
-0.0226753242,
0.002999428,
-0.002963088,
0.0342994183,
-0.0307725649,
-0.007867869,
-0.0418316275,
0.0354249068,
-0.0228794534,
0.0067285639,
-0.0267064665,
0.0233924966,
0.023460025,
-0.0367665887,
-0.0166998096,
-0.0059456429,
0.007159052,
-0.0363963991,
0.0274074916,
0.0600437522,
0.0151685495,
-0.0041500414,
-0.0030107999,
-0.0219093896,
0.0715565756,
-0.0041867872,
-0.0467180982,
0.0218582489,
-0.006907566,
-0.007761192,
-0.0571435504,
0.0045508128,
-0.0743110627,
0.0011805608,
-0.018584013,
0.0282635316,
0.0020431199,
-0.01404431,
-0.0059182653,
-0.0200272687,
0.0403943136,
0.0271436237,
-0.0203799978,
-0.0455251485,
0.037156228,
-0.032615643,
-0.0262218229,
0.012074572,
0.0371388756,
0.0351688899,
0.0185536426,
-0.013629267,
-0.0068813912,
0.0262169596,
0.0193369333,
-0.0694586337,
-0.0117857484,
0.0162783563,
-0.0664868429,
-0.0476370938,
0.0449663103,
-0.0388416722,
-0.0008530091,
-0.0139567098,
0.0847429037,
-0.0057653063,
0.0463332534,
0.0138040921,
-0.014058982,
-0.0809734762,
0.0395303704,
-0.0940161869,
0.0215999857,
-0.0346183553,
0.015243507,
0.0668101758,
0.0022830819,
0.0312977731,
0.0488183796,
-0.0095557645,
-0.0071288305,
-0.0504149981,
0.0016968831,
0.0027937689,
-0.0482993163,
0.0370169766,
0.0169453584,
0.0510495082,
0.0808752254,
0.0027626033,
0.0174442586,
0.0097569684,
-0.0666443706,
-0.0027146263,
0.0108290073,
0.0358224735,
0.094447799,
0.0091955867,
-0.0504634567,
-0.0277036149,
-0.024934819,
0.0694143251,
0.0054483283,
0.0102861458,
-0.0237893015,
0.0116823371,
0.0391855314,
0.0145636909,
-0.0255277343,
-0.0322540924,
-0.0183844883,
-0.0025979504,
-0.0081755025,
-0.0381280817,
-6.045851402e-33,
-0.0387620889,
-0.0004772412,
-0.003222825,
-0.0489850678,
-0.0856530368,
0.0182637516,
-0.0100742821,
-0.0210611206,
0.0202999637,
-0.0116486074,
0.0022812996,
0.0026976033,
0.0120592024,
0.0098949708,
0.0075165103,
0.0044271797,
0.0494658351,
0.0196180418,
-0.0457117036,
-0.0108169876,
0.0906256139,
0.0662812889,
-0.0099997027,
-0.0055170823,
-0.0101188207,
-0.0583583191,
0.0290693715,
-0.0245193187,
0.0319299176,
0.0527721941,
-0.0147390645,
-0.0055281939,
0.0428055972,
-0.0477541313,
0.0135828611,
0.0476108678,
-0.0729568228,
-0.0249996744,
-0.0153948907,
0.0036299783,
0.0143344682,
-0.0283871964,
0.0516573973,
-0.022834748,
0.0438313559,
-0.0450766049,
0.0427471884,
0.0073976624,
-0.0285313856,
-0.0680722371,
-0.0311810728,
0.0378549993,
-0.024483297,
-0.0337688997,
0.0447975583,
0.0716806278,
0.0320972502,
0.0371722728,
-0.043082945,
-0.0073141856,
-0.0140251676,
0.0666247979,
-0.0327960737,
0.043732319,
-0.049632024,
0.0651686937,
0.0434747823,
-0.0217862763,
0.0003301085,
-0.0290731043,
0.0329400264,
-0.0165512729,
0.0560210235,
0.0030597721,
-0.0118982429,
0.0170017835,
-0.053709995,
0.0591858625,
0.0659148544,
0.0289237686,
0.0392966419,
0.054601863,
-0.0389146768,
-0.0049613938,
0.0028570148,
-0.0304581132,
-0.0338971913,
-0.0188334137,
0.0467862077,
0.026658373,
-0.0095492797,
-0.0223740824,
0.0660293326,
-0.0205797125,
0.0309124794,
0.0031973904,
0.0240277909,
0.0332677811,
-0.0013103015,
0.0121619515,
0.0038344762,
0.0352777429,
0.0445001125,
-0.0201275256,
-0.0253148917,
-0.0483174063,
0.0167061146,
-0.0085133808,
-0.0534842946,
0.0165889338,
0.019444406,
-0.036397513,
0.0025850823,
0.0923650861,
-0.0009923795,
-0.0105084069,
-0.0070671984,
0.0904328451,
0.009813875,
0.0504565723,
-0.0371990576,
-0.0019753468,
-0.0013564065,
-0.0179189444,
0.0092050983,
0.0577776507,
0.0044273883,
0.0722858161,
-0.0192933418,
-0.0347291715,
-0.0007087608,
0.0348847844,
2.724e-7,
0.0343751051,
0.0160336047,
0.0293489434,
-0.0158492047,
-0.0081729377,
-0.0126279984,
-0.0121943038,
0.012699401,
0.0414578728,
0.004794227,
0.0323532596,
0.0100128856,
0.0179103073,
0.0070463112,
-0.0971468091,
-0.0689897686,
-0.0487971455,
-0.0787460133,
-0.0109031545,
-0.099493131,
0.0339312814,
0.0633094832,
-0.0112841427,
0.0345598422,
-0.0156813785,
-0.0492433012,
0.0413633212,
0.0115329353,
-0.0249912646,
-0.0125260772,
0.05822476,
0.0420649536,
-0.0420885645,
-0.0313922875,
0.0199020188,
0.0748952925,
0.0694215298,
0.0308007821,
-0.022055367,
-0.0879327953,
0.0104001509,
0.0629266053,
-0.0049934839,
-0.0698349252,
0.0284128264,
-0.0457853377,
0.0142143155,
0.0344952531,
-0.092258282,
-0.0100173233,
-0.0039974493,
0.0301393755,
-0.0537675172,
0.0485345684,
-0.0133885257,
0.0132758943,
-0.0049962713,
-0.130333975,
-0.017132625,
0.0182372238,
-0.0439757183,
0.0119843259,
-0.0074646543,
-0.0322027057,
-0.017239904,
-0.0810593143,
-0.0253073294,
2.277884892e-34,
0.0368080065,
-0.0238418318,
-0.0014449323,
0.0124477046,
0.0251499135,
-0.0252579376,
-0.020781938,
0.011805065,
-0.0031688316,
-0.0721940398,
-0.0268151518
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10526v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10526v3 | Open Domain Multi-document Summarization: A Comprehensive Study of Model Brittleness under Retrieval | 2022-12-20T18:41:38 | 2023-10-25T13:25:20 | John Giorgi, Luca Soldaini, Bo Wang, Gary Bader, Kyle Lo, Lucy Lu Wang, Arman Cohan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Multi-document summarization (MDS) assumes a set of topic-related documents
are provided as input. In practice, this document set is not always available;
it would need to be retrieved given an information need, i.e. a question or
topic statement, a setting we dub "open-domain" MDS. We study this more
challenging setting by formalizing the task and bootstrapping it using existing
datasets, retrievers and summarizers. Via extensive automatic and human
evaluation, we determine: (1) state-of-the-art summarizers suffer large
reductions in performance when applied to open-domain MDS, (2) additional
training in the open-domain setting can reduce this sensitivity to imperfect
retrieval, and (3) summarizers are insensitive to the retrieval of duplicate
documents and the order of retrieved documents, but highly sensitive to other
errors, like the retrieval of irrelevant documents. Based on our results, we
provide practical guidelines to enable future work on open-domain MDS, e.g. how
to choose the number of retrieved documents to summarize. Our results suggest
that new retrieval and summarization methods and annotated resources for
training and evaluation are necessary for further progress in the open-domain
setting. | [
0.0250563622,
0.0108043645,
0.062668018,
0.0003538326,
-0.0088437879,
0.0144690163,
-0.029495623,
-0.0295350011,
-0.0211176258,
-0.0613054447,
-0.0014815597,
-0.0121057956,
-0.0081238085,
-0.0082286866,
-0.0304320604,
-0.0752213746,
0.0389997996,
-0.0052304715,
-0.0035366209,
0.0071966862,
0.0165150221,
0.003166032,
0.0032017448,
0.0271621421,
0.0213802513,
-0.0110357283,
-0.0173790362,
0.0036454697,
0.0338081494,
-0.0078317784,
0.0201161969,
0.002696089,
0.0365400352,
-0.0182949714,
0.0000017605,
-0.0595380776,
-0.0851494521,
0.0085680615,
0.0145563809,
0.0018194569,
0.0603916422,
-0.0501192771,
0.0487987101,
0.0168933403,
-0.0088327816,
-0.0066989139,
-0.0178194456,
0.0739553645,
0.0996646434,
0.0586849377,
-0.0123095009,
-0.0138772763,
0.0544545837,
-0.006104548,
-0.0298373085,
-0.0524318777,
0.0037130446,
0.0370673798,
0.0157113224,
-0.0159519501,
0.0115336152,
0.0247124787,
-0.0187042579,
0.0164116547,
-0.0238911361,
0.0086842738,
-0.0634173229,
-0.0066844844,
0.0120318346,
0.0828428268,
0.0431197993,
0.0505991653,
0.0306901559,
0.0053636245,
0.0157014262,
0.0450551584,
-0.086785689,
0.0656893775,
-0.0223488528,
0.0109790815,
-0.02159057,
0.0516609401,
-0.0273640491,
0.0340064913,
-0.0051734336,
0.0273472406,
0.0041859602,
-0.0096164308,
-0.0334349796,
0.0142725315,
-0.031867817,
-0.0252476744,
0.0190061592,
0.0409906469,
0.0137389284,
-0.0034986692,
-0.059326876,
-0.0802393779,
0.0468951017,
-0.0298539605,
0.0304768477,
-0.0135541288,
-0.0034645083,
0.0605768189,
0.0001212707,
-0.0086868191,
-0.0052415356,
0.0048268707,
-0.0638026744,
-0.0268273242,
-0.0387393311,
0.0066901641,
-0.0271992274,
0.0619778447,
-0.0357663929,
-0.0100992015,
-0.0081074322,
0.0392095633,
-0.0031799469,
-0.0290095042,
-0.0209113322,
0.0093748402,
-0.0015656542,
-0.004887626,
-0.0117844567,
0.0389623418,
-0.0153910574,
-0.014859017,
0.0402588658,
-0.0164512713,
-0.0219669845,
0.0084383907,
0.0262864251,
0.0236901287,
-0.0172802284,
0.0156167941,
-0.0200077873,
-0.0516303331,
-0.0313024558,
-0.0452043191,
-0.0008494483,
-0.0238944348,
0.0332649276,
-0.0532125756,
-0.0053401715,
0.0209084097,
-0.0147715444,
-0.0131122926,
-0.0005890958,
0.0339054652,
-0.0516220145,
0.0087375129,
-0.0176753029,
-0.0187494438,
0.0700294748,
0.0156279057,
0.0140913837,
0.0722701997,
0.0149141997,
0.0232683029,
0.0652882382,
0.0699297488,
0.0007758079,
-0.0075040678,
0.0011910115,
0.0211011283,
0.0369846784,
0.016424546,
-0.0018024885,
-0.0219841897,
0.0327574946,
0.0613470823,
-0.0565560609,
0.0256174374,
0.0123962257,
0.0478080101,
0.013248126,
-0.005809552,
-0.005399642,
0.0214612037,
0.036091879,
0.0602283329,
0.013150108,
0.0194159187,
-0.0467358641,
0.0565780737,
0.0733113661,
0.0198669732,
-0.0347322784,
-0.0635925829,
-0.0139978752,
-0.0205796678,
-0.0076818792,
0.0019887299,
0.0601407327,
0.0152751766,
-0.0319444649,
0.0716085136,
0.024094509,
-0.0754567906,
-0.0095558083,
-0.0217503905,
0.0218067914,
-0.0163536128,
0.0508505851,
-0.0828288347,
-0.0319859684,
-0.0211379994,
0.0216458347,
-0.0195945743,
0.0626220033,
-0.0223720018,
-0.0025357516,
-0.0576966293,
-0.0410662815,
-0.0405260734,
0.0234222319,
-0.0001437142,
-0.0093035372,
-0.0393083431,
0.0625366047,
-0.0260925088,
-0.0266867932,
0.0268308651,
-0.0293123256,
-0.0156365708,
-0.0056245592,
-0.0344748013,
0.0054974002,
0.052664727,
-0.0091494704,
0.0282819401,
0.0359550714,
-0.0111563709,
-0.0288078431,
-0.027960306,
-0.035570126,
-0.0009703088,
0.0404191576,
-0.0502744615,
-0.007208731,
0.0339358672,
-0.040405374,
-0.0495071672,
0.0236084163,
-0.0250825416,
-0.0348643549,
-0.0627700314,
-0.0009928732,
0.019548459,
-0.0075429385,
-0.0323233046,
0.0646327659,
0.004714088,
0.0100358585,
0.0414584167,
-0.060299512,
0.0187849198,
-0.0405538827,
-0.0048522861,
-0.0061350432,
-0.0163089931,
0.0592274852,
0.0489392392,
0.0022501205,
-0.0351015925,
-0.0164635479,
-0.086868532,
0.0159075186,
-0.0189447235,
0.0116802445,
0.0296402238,
0.03676847,
-0.0045606568,
-0.0209435914,
-0.0073171249,
-0.0343422405,
0.0382584706,
0.0183436982,
0.0177765563,
0.0248450059,
0.0691662133,
-0.0414912663,
-0.019335866,
-0.0071739983,
0.0753792003,
-0.0238048397,
-0.0072467881,
-0.0232387129,
0.0294880196,
-0.0500556119,
-0.0243207291,
-0.0069858162,
0.062797986,
0.0010887915,
-0.0358370431,
0.063107118,
0.0110737011,
0.0390342996,
0.0300210454,
0.0578699708,
0.0002018129,
-0.0474261083,
-0.00372045,
-0.0303980168,
-0.0114621045,
0.0507521331,
0.0027824533,
0.0323604085,
0.0201906636,
0.0034846093,
-0.0062325587,
0.0103121176,
0.0119982986,
-0.0486009158,
-0.0009323478,
-0.0742189065,
-0.0195296574,
0.0135075022,
0.0236585736,
-0.0168247167,
0.0180547331,
0.0516037457,
0.0043797228,
0.0245744158,
-0.0738427639,
-0.0032537819,
-0.075795047,
0.0450159721,
-0.0252178721,
0.0241966844,
0.0523671359,
0.0125940703,
-0.032336019,
-0.0452268347,
0.0346896686,
-0.0272063818,
0.0899412185,
-0.0597477779,
0.012770527,
-0.0401711836,
-0.0102117173,
-0.0024339368,
-0.0406033844,
0.0003962824,
0.0358620808,
-0.0328429416,
0.0536474288,
-0.0700268969,
-0.003993588,
0.0497365184,
0.0656513572,
-0.0474033132,
-0.028506333,
0.0043298951,
0.0966129228,
0.0851183683,
0.0071678134,
0.0214520115,
-0.0726825744,
0.0173909944,
0.0468401723,
0.0365514643,
-0.0318657868,
0.0040911911,
-0.0069443849,
-0.0203947481,
-0.0623789169,
0.0223776344,
-0.0229326114,
0.0433456302,
-0.0246052723,
-0.0013715816,
0.088379316,
0.0239009317,
-0.0155179361,
-0.0462385416,
-0.0241584796,
0.0054157414,
0.007177751,
-0.0118386932,
-0.0444211774,
-0.0079241302,
-0.0120473895,
0.0686528683,
0.0355551131,
-0.0230229571,
-0.0157385468,
-0.0690500215,
0.0044665132,
0.0055028046,
-0.0525059961,
-0.0072946153,
-0.0409998298,
0.0073927841,
-0.0309092309,
0.026934281,
0.02902909,
-0.0347520113,
0.0145003991,
0.0191658456,
-0.0379330404,
0.0009774737,
-0.0378739163,
-0.0400313511,
-0.0421273485,
0.0418205336,
0.0001816372,
0.0117290225,
0.0441663079,
0.0440159887,
-0.0193632003,
-0.0001801145,
0.0230636131,
0.0840301365,
-0.0085718073,
0.0340298265,
-0.0373496711,
0.0147548672,
-0.0169299301,
-0.003661331,
0.020860197,
0.0179066416,
0.0029155808,
-0.0033383081,
-0.0747291669,
0.0016441204,
-0.0494442359,
0.0361952111,
0.0135131236,
0.0007710395,
-0.0083020572,
-0.0304551348,
0.0031831269,
-0.0413648337,
0.0002092571,
0.0063251709,
-0.054680869,
-0.0058081462,
-0.0681428909,
-0.0705043152,
-0.001102754,
-0.0145549141,
-0.0395728834,
-0.0388812423,
0.0019541646,
0.0282466896,
-0.0332719497,
0.0374034904,
-0.0222939625,
-0.0163106825,
-0.0247018114,
0.0240521487,
0.081114009,
-0.0364238061,
-0.0292866584,
0.0135669336,
-0.0475703105,
-0.0377951041,
-0.0206547491,
0.0400007367,
0.0193431303,
0.0302033033,
0.0085792113,
-0.0245360956,
0.0453794524,
0.0462448858,
-0.0193981398,
0.0187479015,
0.0410959683,
0.0062570781,
-0.0364290103,
0.0069364696,
-0.0985192582,
0.0566234067,
-0.0636470467,
0.0298976675,
-0.0270820558,
-0.0547970496,
0.0172175411,
0.0539893247,
0.0565711558,
0.026302103,
-0.0124599477,
-0.0376322195,
-0.0390030071,
-0.0148632172,
-0.0411886647,
-0.0308512095,
0.0643834546,
-0.0095358584,
-0.0051506185,
-0.0056758691,
0.0547751896,
0.005165237,
0.0662290528,
-0.0499857962,
-0.0129527831,
0.007763145,
0.0004077246,
-0.0654841363,
-0.0148822423,
-0.0692574605,
-0.0148794949,
-0.0543644652,
-0.0156519376,
-0.0119909737,
0.018326249,
0.0105760396,
0.030522367,
-0.0128774168,
0.0120567391,
-0.111073114,
0.0284499973,
-0.0543896444,
0.0105589237,
0.0041104271,
-0.0264256913,
0.0578704178,
0.0125044445,
-0.027951045,
-0.0376727581,
0.0130001139,
0.0349394083,
0.0027892038,
-0.0418975838,
0.0301453024,
0.022116622,
0.0145301586,
0.0940654203,
-0.0424636081,
0.0170805492,
-0.0219153967,
-0.0207392629,
-0.0453421511,
-0.0292411484,
-0.0021787491,
0.0360741764,
0.0070018959,
-0.0387981646,
-0.0501042604,
0.0096065039,
0.0443119481,
0.009838121,
0.0038961738,
-0.0028040616,
0.0411682092,
0.0445187725,
0.0007689286,
0.005589081,
-0.0523143411,
-0.018290082,
-0.0340888351,
0.0118085844,
0.0095270695,
-5.488265942e-33,
-0.0438024662,
0.009255481,
-0.0308546126,
0.0033310575,
-0.0181238446,
0.0208402649,
-0.0407747477,
0.008562238,
0.0030710248,
-0.0212645885,
-0.0220665727,
0.018831661,
0.0130628534,
0.0351533554,
0.013225276,
0.02590378,
0.0231643505,
-0.0241937265,
-0.041311536,
0.0178126134,
0.061470747,
0.0125454497,
0.0292039122,
-0.062266998,
0.0532444417,
-0.0378528573,
-0.0288700983,
-0.035684213,
0.0667872429,
0.022331737,
0.0018770167,
0.0231860336,
0.0393976346,
-0.0260738209,
-0.0520401336,
0.0017685841,
-0.0896468386,
-0.0431750081,
-0.0051832027,
-0.0565771498,
-0.0443013683,
-0.0330735706,
0.0350890644,
-0.0268162992,
0.0416641273,
-0.0578836538,
0.0597869456,
-0.046592012,
-0.0438736193,
-0.0696956068,
0.0065437006,
0.0333244987,
-0.0335490741,
-0.0157489032,
0.0016504789,
0.0691024661,
0.0027923968,
0.0106249936,
0.0019715226,
0.0545620695,
0.0164854769,
0.0131805204,
0.0263081361,
0.0027219928,
-0.0112680215,
0.0631398857,
-0.0135686817,
-0.0100942748,
-0.0058882707,
-0.0233490914,
-0.0243227426,
0.0170991812,
0.0030483354,
0.0505154096,
0.0312928036,
0.0642398372,
-0.0462399274,
0.1094115302,
-0.026038114,
-0.0081261583,
0.0177795794,
0.014493064,
0.0044789896,
-0.0062566586,
-0.0144359618,
0.0343948416,
-0.0129696941,
-0.0014581461,
-0.0146072162,
0.033404652,
-0.0545998365,
-0.0207971018,
0.0259763394,
-0.0339455567,
0.033805158,
0.0238067303,
0.0063570347,
0.0094644912,
0.0009824041,
-0.0208287723,
-0.0268223025,
0.0074369316,
0.0373694114,
0.0090854215,
-0.0267202482,
-0.006772832,
0.0523679182,
0.0022170334,
-0.0365854912,
0.0090479022,
0.0249946043,
0.0083156023,
-0.0366607457,
0.0478655174,
-0.0056710443,
0.0028501779,
0.0014574695,
0.0467375442,
0.0074180076,
0.0032687567,
-0.0442846976,
-0.0374966338,
0.0217361972,
0.0021099744,
0.0147882095,
0.0309427138,
0.0016427424,
0.0164130162,
0.0538854003,
-0.0252055153,
-0.000894924,
0.0195160676,
2.386e-7,
0.0711398274,
0.0139897503,
0.0549501851,
0.0120521076,
-0.0296947826,
0.0423873216,
-0.0249598101,
0.0503590032,
0.0266307388,
0.0179704223,
0.0362819135,
0.0270518847,
0.0467601344,
0.0614435039,
-0.0749414265,
-0.0275658835,
-0.0563110188,
-0.0431348942,
-0.0127183953,
-0.0334466249,
0.0459396429,
0.0367424525,
-0.0218441244,
0.0105666211,
-0.0427328385,
-0.037603993,
0.060083475,
-0.0057379953,
-0.0485610664,
0.0066910074,
0.0797883794,
-0.0032054151,
0.0000401167,
-0.0379034616,
0.0087528238,
0.0053623635,
0.1008785889,
0.0299546309,
0.0207405519,
-0.025837712,
0.0195214655,
-0.0204489175,
0.0339295603,
0.0259911381,
0.0440224074,
-0.066593416,
0.0074924873,
-0.0263472032,
-0.0557975508,
0.0215438418,
0.0027083138,
0.0124058537,
-0.0169903338,
0.0502331667,
-0.0372379236,
0.002176642,
0.0239474159,
-0.0647030026,
-0.0260860939,
0.0304674227,
0.0087526552,
-0.0557084791,
0.0124331415,
-0.002050393,
0.0212499872,
-0.0840898529,
-0.0080289561,
2.002958344e-34,
0.0924319923,
-0.0059563378,
-0.0528552569,
-0.0394662507,
0.0140798539,
-0.0360933244,
-0.0458930843,
-0.0097234026,
-0.007977657,
-0.0825635642,
-0.0094206361
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10525v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10525v2 | SLUE Phase-2: A Benchmark Suite of Diverse Spoken Language Understanding Tasks | 2022-12-20T18:39:59 | 2023-06-15T22:51:09 | Suwon Shon, Siddhant Arora, Chyi-Jiunn Lin, Ankita Pasad, Felix Wu, Roshan Sharma, Wei-Lun Wu, Hung-Yi Lee, Karen Livescu, Shinji Watanabe | cs.CL | cs.CL, eess.AS | Spoken language understanding (SLU) tasks have been studied for many decades
in the speech research community, but have not received as much attention as
lower-level tasks like speech and speaker recognition. In particular, there are
not nearly as many SLU task benchmarks, and many of the existing ones use data
that is not freely available to all researchers. Recent work has begun to
introduce such benchmark datasets for several tasks. In this work, we introduce
several new annotated SLU benchmark tasks based on freely available speech
data, which complement existing benchmarks and address gaps in the SLU
evaluation landscape. We contribute four tasks: question answering and
summarization involve inference over longer speech sequences; named entity
localization addresses the speech-specific task of locating the targeted
content in the signal; dialog act classification identifies the function of a
given speech utterance. We follow the blueprint of the Spoken Language
Understanding Evaluation (SLUE) benchmark suite. In order to facilitate the
development of SLU models that leverage the success of pre-trained speech
representations, we will be publishing for each task (i) annotations for a
relatively small fine-tuning set, (ii) annotated development and test sets, and
(iii) baseline models for easy reproducibility and comparisons. In this work,
we present the details of data collection and annotation and the performance of
the baseline models. We also perform sensitivity analysis of pipeline models'
performance (speech recognizer + text model) to the speech recognition
accuracy, using more than 20 state-of-the-art speech recognition models. | [
0.0071341479,
0.0580312721,
0.0318698995,
0.0404109471,
0.0037690129,
0.0133951623,
0.0457966216,
-0.0490544997,
0.0053039724,
-0.05483374,
-0.0510537773,
-0.0291574933,
0.0200280622,
0.0490586534,
0.0021024211,
-0.0498365834,
0.0609346405,
-0.0343483202,
0.0241030995,
0.0177690368,
0.0095104594,
0.0270416979,
-0.0402170382,
0.0393078811,
0.0307284407,
-0.0031197714,
-0.0160664357,
0.0225758441,
0.0313115753,
-0.0089756362,
0.0040622395,
0.0418443382,
0.0508877933,
0.0526794679,
0.0000019499,
-0.0587296374,
-0.01314897,
-0.0106234839,
-0.0846821144,
0.0060356148,
-0.0212476179,
-0.0088383704,
0.0287092924,
0.0288868826,
0.0025584248,
-0.0360311605,
0.0129021918,
0.0315189101,
0.0514403209,
0.0709133074,
0.0154487807,
-0.0007313156,
-0.0044611818,
-0.0276353285,
-0.0108540375,
-0.0718721822,
-0.0187879186,
0.001495346,
0.0133890407,
-0.0300407596,
-0.0019196264,
0.0550336577,
0.0031352888,
0.0077073127,
-0.0022133314,
0.0085135167,
-0.0745136067,
-0.0175071862,
-0.0171777513,
0.0901886597,
0.0013564005,
-0.0087170685,
0.0136589166,
-0.0083363121,
-0.0349370502,
-0.0563857444,
-0.042581398,
0.000384012,
0.0146247959,
-0.0097058341,
-0.0219441652,
0.0274674278,
0.0141704334,
-0.0016928047,
-0.0278362744,
0.0523017906,
-0.0055134567,
0.0174247473,
-0.0084929178,
-0.0380768701,
-0.0328691676,
-0.0429625697,
0.0180375651,
0.031847246,
-0.0443454422,
0.0201005433,
-0.0289443098,
-0.0106668789,
-0.0127633177,
-0.0298579503,
0.0027254038,
0.0493135527,
-0.0263265688,
0.070873253,
-0.0104315914,
0.0872503892,
0.0090642534,
0.0169137251,
-0.0332144201,
-0.0208812896,
-0.0234106854,
0.0210668817,
-0.0341666266,
0.0108268429,
-0.0456334725,
-0.036646951,
-0.0164713915,
0.0022826635,
0.0042062225,
0.0161640588,
0.0082870126,
0.0148164667,
-0.0260089785,
-0.0007374564,
0.0245106835,
0.0467346944,
-0.0338661261,
0.0222096946,
0.0031897887,
-0.070726797,
-0.0528326444,
0.0277224667,
0.0391828939,
-0.0063306917,
0.0043738382,
0.0314307548,
0.0035811455,
-0.055902686,
-0.0093550375,
0.0162109751,
0.0010457438,
-0.0746117905,
-0.0460621007,
-0.0232410189,
0.0579963662,
-0.0080540199,
0.0046371329,
-0.0221518017,
-0.0009952802,
-0.02917579,
0.0234018657,
0.0738326535,
0.0017221714,
0.0059359693,
0.0421400703,
0.0072204745,
0.004997456,
0.0461184047,
0.0181704853,
-0.0099425027,
0.0328369327,
-0.0268306322,
-0.0189004261,
0.0408342332,
0.0284757614,
-0.0067573912,
0.0487410091,
0.0442432128,
-0.0326053388,
0.0207871553,
0.0546559617,
0.0094410283,
-0.0230012294,
-0.0356916077,
0.0276906155,
0.0790250674,
0.0063026398,
-0.0426031053,
0.013461885,
0.0716038048,
0.0177665669,
-0.0285934675,
-0.0396985859,
-0.0026256393,
-0.020532418,
0.0209241863,
0.023872003,
0.0074666375,
-0.040831238,
-0.0153303966,
-0.0092658512,
-0.0079887444,
-0.0150087969,
0.0457617231,
0.032384064,
0.0159821231,
-0.0520485379,
0.0751030371,
0.00539773,
-0.0525531769,
0.0109097175,
-0.0172325913,
0.0423923954,
0.0431420282,
0.0183534827,
-0.0306036677,
-0.0538018309,
-0.0510405041,
0.0247092023,
0.031483788,
0.0130314939,
-0.0081373118,
0.0793017894,
-0.0425902456,
-0.0210028514,
-0.0218010545,
-0.0031762435,
0.0425464995,
-0.0058995965,
-0.0209681131,
0.0312098637,
-0.0586116463,
0.0010618367,
0.0076054432,
-0.0155928256,
-0.0095415451,
0.0090976851,
0.011738956,
0.0655631498,
0.0513507165,
-0.0108728698,
-0.0190319773,
0.0339575782,
-0.0151191754,
0.025424026,
0.029878458,
-0.0536933243,
-0.0479716994,
0.0209839568,
-0.024002701,
-0.0184233505,
0.0474291034,
-0.0386720635,
-0.0951265544,
0.0283186566,
-0.0238061212,
0.0001724368,
-0.0371867679,
0.0124794822,
0.0217652973,
0.0288815163,
-0.0197312571,
0.0203761403,
-0.0019003842,
0.0190521963,
0.0366649628,
0.0291178152,
0.0399588868,
-0.0491998233,
-0.0303265266,
0.0002892492,
-0.0398695543,
0.0038886573,
0.0026861841,
0.006961239,
-0.0422747061,
0.0275719929,
-0.0959578976,
0.0213956162,
-0.0432052016,
0.0432204939,
0.04296818,
0.0310199428,
-0.0235848408,
-0.0540531687,
-0.0211210437,
-0.0367482752,
0.0159939267,
-0.0373849347,
-0.0179905817,
0.0108794086,
-0.0138239982,
-0.0666363165,
0.0213785525,
0.0014185241,
0.0365892276,
-0.0116069792,
-0.0236611739,
-0.0456859954,
0.0291251577,
-0.0019511115,
0.0293885972,
-0.0138781965,
-0.0028500841,
-0.0172215775,
0.0176790264,
0.0024042095,
0.0637360066,
0.0022667616,
0.0293148104,
-0.0095280837,
-0.0194490254,
-0.0705507174,
0.0444587097,
-0.0015651102,
0.0283894483,
-0.0372320339,
-0.0021168941,
0.0045547825,
0.0804518312,
0.0349279232,
0.0299459752,
-0.0390183963,
-0.030535806,
-0.0153172174,
-0.0282666069,
-0.0370121635,
-0.0006724605,
-0.0202825218,
0.026552638,
-0.048590783,
-0.0118904682,
0.047633104,
-0.1054047123,
-0.0336016528,
-0.0622431003,
-0.0419258177,
-0.0498426817,
0.0495260209,
0.0090235574,
0.0112196049,
-0.0269829761,
-0.0459490903,
-0.0220689531,
0.0132178301,
0.0017835665,
-0.0349494442,
0.0415354669,
-0.0201833043,
0.0111846766,
-0.0323511548,
-0.0054658321,
-0.0428947657,
-0.0073540127,
-0.0533133559,
0.0041315467,
0.0194759704,
-0.0161919557,
-0.0277297292,
0.0445261896,
-0.0030812421,
0.081199348,
0.000829346,
0.0362728164,
-0.0236742124,
0.0511590913,
0.0344358683,
0.0465214476,
0.0076409187,
0.0248133205,
0.0582395829,
0.0135238171,
0.0630313903,
0.0031585554,
-0.0462859422,
0.0038007584,
0.0338147804,
-0.0388676785,
-0.0053919367,
0.0017781204,
0.0909598395,
-0.0509947799,
-0.0148915509,
0.151674971,
0.0197160263,
0.0019181297,
-0.0319999047,
0.0079231579,
0.0147665059,
0.0491943285,
0.0016543533,
-0.061143741,
-0.0664925054,
0.0173837077,
0.0226210579,
0.0254137367,
-0.0047939597,
-0.022168221,
-0.0692792535,
0.0276391692,
-0.0177116059,
-0.0784628689,
-0.0225316789,
-0.0393518358,
0.009709537,
-0.0336078629,
0.0638911948,
-0.0153343854,
0.0060936986,
-0.0032073106,
0.0348431356,
-0.0421456844,
-0.0324479379,
0.0574064851,
-0.0084816748,
0.0645648465,
0.0174300484,
0.0289223734,
0.0131398467,
0.0161965508,
0.0387920886,
-0.0209029783,
-0.0056924075,
0.0131884804,
0.0490067713,
-0.0371804684,
-0.0268597435,
0.0069924821,
0.0430777073,
-0.0280245952,
0.0004989535,
0.0177162644,
0.0344802774,
-0.0354489014,
0.0167815555,
-0.0006324337,
0.028090151,
0.0043453933,
0.0761529654,
0.0698049217,
-0.0158963837,
-0.0260703657,
0.0014679101,
0.0201487411,
-0.0479719639,
-0.0033354103,
0.0032954265,
0.0418981351,
0.0019939502,
-0.0079577174,
-0.0481706671,
0.0344235897,
0.0166960973,
-0.0132918516,
-0.0034317602,
0.0019839469,
0.0240841061,
-0.0605384223,
0.0667897463,
-0.0077027832,
0.0347075462,
-0.0471361019,
-0.0084712878,
0.008779984,
-0.0219346136,
-0.0750501677,
0.0542686433,
-0.1264067441,
-0.0287315492,
-0.0138644073,
0.0063745519,
0.0229673758,
0.062281359,
-0.0440925173,
-0.0261719041,
0.0063750767,
-0.0436653122,
-0.0519459993,
-0.0008430295,
0.0454922728,
0.0145337088,
-0.0466670766,
0.0265308078,
-0.0607730821,
0.0198046751,
-0.0160101149,
0.0282180924,
-0.0310200006,
-0.0640499964,
-0.019330509,
0.022876583,
0.0447420701,
0.0187253002,
-0.0076641496,
-0.0414648317,
0.0406019762,
0.0364753082,
0.0059784357,
-0.0364051275,
-0.0252397675,
0.0260075815,
-0.0444004424,
-0.0069146189,
0.0308827162,
-0.0202705748,
0.013030285,
-0.0270176232,
0.0437046885,
0.0476357043,
-0.0020795884,
-0.0159769133,
-0.0280973837,
-0.028123688,
0.057318978,
0.0180709641,
0.0481397696,
0.0119706867,
0.0640404969,
-0.0233664885,
-0.0012587555,
0.0165540166,
0.0134782465,
-0.0838691816,
-0.0533578768,
-0.0234747026,
0.0271375626,
0.0055387486,
-0.0313956216,
0.0510154553,
0.0456162989,
0.0210244004,
-0.0261136331,
0.0267748609,
-0.0143425455,
-0.027641654,
0.0215538125,
0.0054655652,
-0.0002066652,
0.0348009951,
0.0698691905,
0.0446539856,
0.0361568294,
0.0124656847,
0.038959574,
-0.0685204417,
-0.0612391718,
-0.0045137499,
0.0267605484,
-0.0219062418,
0.0100819636,
-0.0161222517,
-0.0399889946,
0.0279157255,
-0.0397390984,
-0.0211073495,
0.0005082428,
0.0195122361,
0.023952391,
-0.0352390409,
-0.0150332991,
-0.0030141997,
-0.0376624204,
-0.0182792861,
0.0075965202,
-0.0018859276,
-6.179855921e-33,
-0.0543143451,
0.0247289203,
-0.0154477544,
-0.0089102667,
0.0055656438,
0.0308679212,
-0.0660441518,
-0.0027182435,
-0.0272852518,
-0.0383976698,
0.0024806266,
0.0366512686,
0.0198250022,
0.0543842241,
-0.0640758723,
-0.0580194145,
0.0570013709,
-0.0202237722,
-0.0430252552,
0.02220493,
0.0288517196,
0.052465152,
0.06428729,
-0.0245736931,
0.0174758956,
-0.0150264334,
-0.0111852121,
0.0052744192,
0.0074011725,
0.0451449826,
-0.032594882,
0.0248336047,
-0.0035878501,
-0.0608758144,
-0.0419742763,
0.0180550367,
-0.1174883097,
-0.006528757,
0.0165533368,
0.0560852475,
-0.0439830013,
0.0293441266,
0.0124133714,
0.0113900136,
0.0372693986,
-0.0306140017,
0.0180223398,
-0.0053881416,
0.0106791155,
-0.0235339981,
-0.0209778864,
0.034916237,
-0.0754731148,
-0.0237875544,
0.0383483954,
0.0705623254,
0.0035572462,
0.006404418,
-0.0647027418,
-0.0101370513,
0.0000940316,
0.0065246103,
0.0818411708,
0.0179555677,
-0.0329811312,
0.0466270782,
0.0150136836,
-0.0476614311,
-0.008773474,
-0.0190457534,
0.0308962613,
0.0220997203,
-0.0008096236,
0.0140523054,
-0.0160886012,
0.016206393,
-0.0234194994,
0.0249124076,
0.0107937343,
0.0353540555,
0.0195959993,
-0.0010587457,
-0.0380221643,
0.0100586852,
-0.096089907,
-0.0246178303,
-0.0309908893,
0.0202575214,
0.0650724918,
0.0013153872,
-0.0293209776,
-0.0119000142,
0.0495083667,
-0.0252643079,
0.0260887947,
0.0493414924,
0.0352723971,
-0.0293114372,
0.0160914697,
0.0894575641,
-0.0600213595,
0.008122554,
0.0567670539,
0.0216845348,
-0.0026626484,
-0.0626710877,
-0.006399469,
-0.0016028989,
-0.0345694907,
0.0120042088,
-0.0337420627,
0.0458915904,
-0.0926650092,
0.0568617135,
0.0456724353,
-0.0000406031,
-0.012860761,
0.0631626472,
-0.0275367647,
0.0089522758,
0.0053713932,
-0.0109336451,
-0.0005498351,
0.0341043994,
-0.0422455221,
-0.021704765,
-0.0007637651,
-0.0272002481,
0.0009776193,
-0.0362617038,
0.0144389672,
0.0250369627,
2.569e-7,
0.0373789631,
-0.0072888569,
0.0651470721,
0.0077557908,
0.0131869586,
0.0183600578,
-0.0065177786,
-0.0019032373,
-0.0027460689,
-0.0234521665,
0.0125435451,
0.033642035,
0.0549351573,
-0.0087610343,
-0.0929748863,
-0.0263849106,
-0.0576542765,
0.0059420764,
-0.0297941118,
-0.0103251133,
0.0170525592,
0.1081503108,
-0.0443376414,
-0.0097952653,
0.016396597,
-0.0234253109,
0.0075393701,
-0.0395833477,
0.0244406015,
0.0188899115,
0.0060092811,
0.0349968486,
0.0142678851,
0.0061389469,
-0.0040947003,
0.0329385474,
0.0355398394,
0.0730928257,
0.0084588621,
-0.0626641735,
-0.0526619144,
0.0055563864,
0.0252537597,
-0.0483154021,
0.0826700106,
-0.0299821906,
-0.0242550094,
-0.0451433361,
-0.0547348559,
-0.0012334151,
0.0049469043,
0.0173865054,
0.0459763035,
0.0311341882,
-0.000120469,
-0.0558803938,
-0.0206647459,
-0.1063426286,
-0.0316031612,
-0.0041792546,
-0.0321285799,
0.0188265126,
-0.0294487923,
-0.0136483777,
0.0369105823,
-0.0430528298,
-0.0100860866,
2.166881491e-34,
0.0226347987,
-0.0089720516,
-0.0006692823,
0.0133509832,
0.009490665,
-0.0442644693,
-0.0475285538,
-0.0453805663,
0.0352799781,
-0.0473308153,
0.0136104254
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10522v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10522v2 | Transformers Go for the LOLs: Generating (Humourous) Titles from Scientific Abstracts End-to-End | 2022-12-20T18:37:11 | 2023-12-26T18:05:42 | Yanran Chen, Steffen Eger | cs.CL | cs.CL | We consider the end-to-end abstract-to-title generation problem, exploring
seven recent transformer based models (including ChatGPT) fine-tuned on more
than 30k abstract-title pairs from NLP and machine learning (ML) venues. As an
extension, we also consider the harder problem of generating humorous paper
titles. For the latter, we compile the first large-scale humor annotated
dataset for scientific papers in the NLP/ML domains, comprising almost ~2.6k
titles. We evaluate all models using human and automatic metrics. Our human
evaluation suggests that our best end-to-end system performs similarly to human
authors (but arguably slightly worse). Generating funny titles is more
difficult, however, and our automatic systems clearly underperform relative to
humans and often learn dataset artefacts of humor. Finally, ChatGPT, without
any fine-tuning, performs on the level of our best fine-tuned system. | [
0.0852228925,
0.0728868395,
0.0116737643,
0.0132532082,
-0.0164040513,
0.0116887428,
0.0217492618,
-0.001544777,
0.020837782,
-0.0274990313,
-0.0095988028,
0.0134906434,
-0.018233519,
0.0208560787,
0.0332706645,
-0.1005598754,
-0.0141398041,
-0.0077233482,
0.0112175457,
-0.0285940897,
-0.0109996507,
0.0000154094,
-0.0013260011,
0.0352102928,
0.0178383105,
-0.0045941058,
0.0258420017,
0.0238050725,
0.0162298139,
-0.011564387,
0.0270584002,
0.0412455276,
-0.0356194004,
0.0670033246,
0.0000014405,
-0.0507865921,
-0.0033310931,
0.0007997245,
0.0447630882,
0.0017843506,
0.087541014,
-0.0731328353,
-0.0475484654,
0.009603058,
-0.02280063,
-0.0018435686,
0.0583142787,
0.0388728864,
0.0519426502,
0.089726381,
-0.0136965578,
-0.0300163925,
0.060704615,
-0.0242952332,
0.0183360539,
-0.0334117636,
0.0322576873,
0.023941081,
-0.0060290024,
0.0187640488,
-0.0313609876,
0.0320231654,
-0.009160161,
-0.0267270803,
0.0007757326,
0.0325045586,
-0.0763579234,
-0.0081604039,
-0.0259187613,
0.0440516882,
-0.0289433431,
-0.0143032074,
0.0369384587,
0.0396418162,
-0.0133279618,
0.023248598,
-0.0754228383,
0.016987294,
0.0069806762,
-0.0241300892,
0.0324568078,
0.0459790938,
-0.0245121643,
0.0373167768,
-0.0072520296,
-0.0071459888,
0.0461591221,
-0.0478673391,
-0.0217775349,
-0.0022131552,
-0.0218062587,
-0.0641229451,
0.0608468652,
0.056877438,
0.0113048153,
0.0140045676,
-0.0405092873,
-0.0788424909,
0.0407363102,
-0.0510877967,
0.0001705176,
0.0080998354,
0.0069647976,
0.0519033559,
-0.0353944488,
0.0033633737,
-0.0222108383,
0.0213039909,
-0.0237491895,
-0.0200230684,
-0.0009965145,
-0.0162420142,
-0.0287003852,
0.0219290983,
-0.0009197744,
-0.0309561826,
-0.0739234611,
0.0089795021,
0.01679717,
0.0175779313,
0.0243103784,
0.0436818674,
-0.0572694354,
-0.0329231471,
0.0409518927,
0.0353953093,
0.0039823782,
-0.0420988537,
0.0229521673,
-0.0194725581,
-0.0218543336,
0.0132562248,
0.0259095151,
-0.0139312372,
0.027660083,
0.0694195703,
-0.0069883489,
-0.0502441674,
0.040118847,
-0.0206839312,
-0.030761648,
-0.0312685259,
0.031252984,
-0.0515576452,
0.0583191179,
0.0233188402,
0.0063372739,
-0.028675817,
0.0273031741,
0.0367150307,
-0.0378022157,
0.0393747129,
-0.0167573132,
-0.005061727,
0.048064962,
0.0143412389,
-0.0424104035,
0.0117445337,
0.0364116952,
0.0390013866,
0.0315847322,
-0.0150825959,
0.0606048517,
0.0270022489,
0.0197349153,
-0.0065495218,
0.0652579367,
-0.0164322946,
-0.0485156141,
0.0602034032,
0.01757662,
0.070233427,
-0.0083557433,
0.0065007661,
0.0334478468,
0.0337204374,
0.0084515382,
0.073914662,
0.0322280601,
-0.0164595991,
0.0105158044,
0.0090125334,
0.0021007096,
0.0261838827,
-0.0474286526,
0.019611245,
0.0048691789,
0.0544075891,
-0.0032716221,
-0.0119801825,
-0.0015356563,
-0.0077283587,
-0.0007486422,
-0.0408545546,
0.0596534535,
0.0816528648,
-0.0507481359,
0.0325386934,
0.0216283612,
-0.0522429273,
-0.0018336654,
-0.0173154138,
-0.0220782999,
0.0180941094,
0.0820171237,
-0.0167303123,
-0.0632566959,
-0.0166168138,
0.0055458546,
0.0702895597,
0.0473197512,
0.0064174174,
-0.0266062282,
-0.0255627185,
0.023772886,
-0.0001181003,
0.0206225999,
0.0149816349,
0.0095809354,
-0.002521564,
0.026054848,
0.0067494283,
-0.0537935235,
0.0374426655,
-0.1171384826,
-0.0077398675,
0.0266737714,
-0.0163621064,
0.0361493342,
-0.017309539,
-0.0173784103,
0.0143487956,
0.0343311429,
-0.0402424969,
-0.0454936512,
0.0507740416,
-0.0123243481,
-0.0369593613,
0.0273933169,
-0.1178263277,
-0.0082471343,
0.0560187846,
-0.0250781607,
-0.0402866974,
0.0384471081,
-0.0513717532,
-0.0074988441,
-0.0239897724,
0.0141372764,
0.0176693071,
0.023167761,
-0.040660698,
0.0359627418,
-0.0033585955,
0.0381162018,
0.0342048071,
-0.024445178,
-0.0053149471,
-0.0186128113,
-0.0378205031,
0.002558351,
-0.0232256465,
-0.0083597256,
0.0051991125,
0.004840937,
-0.0180356931,
-0.0797657073,
-0.0695978999,
-0.01601623,
0.0059676678,
-0.01372361,
0.0487518981,
0.0045080446,
-0.0044035884,
-0.0035259479,
-0.0212935824,
-0.0385930091,
0.0064195925,
-0.014968859,
0.0382449776,
-0.01642612,
-0.0198162682,
-0.0342006013,
-0.0283416137,
-0.0523929112,
0.0441531315,
0.0490888283,
0.0368821584,
-0.0587186143,
0.0099369632,
-0.0328932293,
-0.0390598029,
-0.0146094495,
-0.0197829362,
-0.0113047622,
0.0018582009,
0.0027315505,
0.0547989383,
0.0684139654,
0.0226719063,
0.0155060198,
0.0052676154,
-0.013434221,
-0.0128436387,
-0.052341532,
0.0148192896,
0.0175337177,
-0.0421919189,
0.0462939888,
0.0443122461,
-0.0074938084,
0.0254194178,
-0.0501978435,
0.0377277546,
0.0013171416,
-0.0031813513,
0.0354021899,
0.0083910264,
-0.0126358122,
0.0055757486,
0.0211824365,
0.0065703038,
0.0631116852,
-0.0314684957,
-0.0333354026,
-0.0617185868,
0.0215880144,
-0.0458514206,
0.0333628021,
-0.0153471148,
0.0448262021,
-0.0058092335,
-0.0333108306,
-0.0198886022,
0.0335893296,
-0.0110638067,
-0.0417817868,
0.0151293445,
-0.0020207972,
-0.0204595737,
-0.0143669639,
-0.0463129058,
-0.0387409367,
-0.0417643897,
-0.007201395,
0.0252793301,
0.03902575,
-0.0349770263,
-0.0673057958,
0.0073652701,
0.008031752,
-0.001748341,
-0.0465914197,
-0.0546525531,
-0.0173521545,
0.0271377955,
0.0915899947,
-0.0024589563,
0.002117093,
0.0226413887,
-0.0134129962,
0.0087684784,
-0.0220565889,
0.0364008322,
-0.0108345943,
-0.0277824719,
0.0183266662,
-0.0605810024,
0.0325440839,
-0.0212157629,
0.0167777948,
-0.0115308277,
-0.0428165421,
0.0892047137,
0.0263544861,
-0.0210500639,
0.0096684601,
-0.0108546801,
0.0114678079,
0.0062172092,
0.059370216,
-0.0649683401,
0.0137241632,
-0.0024026597,
0.0262930859,
0.0098154377,
-0.0285886303,
-0.0038227153,
-0.080311574,
0.0289263707,
0.0332660377,
-0.038296409,
0.0044899299,
-0.0170720145,
-0.0256204363,
-0.0486027449,
-0.0112860128,
0.007940514,
-0.0297127925,
0.0017863427,
0.0151931066,
0.0055646664,
-0.0437550358,
-0.0007781617,
0.00391358,
0.034227144,
0.0455130339,
0.0506461449,
-0.0241409708,
-0.0324467085,
-0.0108402967,
-0.0089828558,
-0.0198006351,
-0.0135249551,
0.0584307611,
-0.0138861584,
-0.0008377298,
-0.0283304434,
0.0719918311,
-0.0118470164,
0.0230485965,
0.0181533899,
0.0352383777,
-0.0142818065,
-0.0228333436,
-0.0726495907,
0.041748099,
-0.0171645209,
0.0865646824,
0.0241675861,
-0.0475043543,
-0.0431227013,
-0.0613839887,
0.025292052,
-0.0616755895,
-0.0400659144,
-0.0442719124,
-0.0359350555,
-0.0065459004,
-0.0954308212,
-0.017256137,
0.0241673868,
0.0184611771,
0.017999541,
-0.05984433,
0.0007632287,
0.0008555842,
-0.0424421169,
-0.0312560536,
-0.0081653278,
-0.0357278101,
-0.0335680023,
-0.0120936129,
0.0876438245,
-0.0349169672,
-0.0537846237,
0.0357241854,
-0.0207060501,
-0.0684546605,
0.0378507264,
0.0640541241,
0.0255910568,
0.0122170467,
-0.0198550746,
-0.0363099165,
0.0505615361,
0.0928722769,
0.0254611839,
-0.0041299434,
0.0121910777,
0.0419173241,
-0.0203718189,
0.01671266,
-0.0378162712,
0.0551424772,
-0.0105314655,
0.050457947,
-0.0182957146,
0.0089810472,
0.0220031999,
0.0301162433,
0.0215060823,
-0.071404025,
-0.0544322431,
0.0307456013,
-0.0134810051,
-0.02411169,
-0.0042845169,
-0.0333194062,
0.0080997385,
0.0310833752,
-0.0090106623,
-0.011232961,
-0.0066850008,
-0.0434866063,
0.0283600576,
-0.0516485237,
-0.0219848379,
-0.0177230462,
-0.0193908699,
0.0125862351,
0.0037575332,
-0.0161730107,
-0.0165894311,
0.0113347936,
0.0308442563,
0.0076460238,
0.0136445183,
0.0438944474,
0.0168133229,
-0.0213162228,
0.0508420058,
-0.0835960433,
0.0108721917,
-0.0359777138,
0.0258505475,
0.0483893752,
0.0037837753,
0.0732616261,
-0.0442983583,
-0.0164617263,
0.0146225002,
0.027261626,
-0.0141134141,
-0.0210765265,
0.0117110861,
-0.0156656932,
0.0156100225,
-0.0518570058,
0.0751244649,
-0.0626478195,
0.0256121196,
0.0416099653,
-0.0242118686,
-0.0444890037,
-0.0186800994,
-0.0019929747,
-0.0141080664,
0.0255279932,
-0.0191236809,
-0.045529563,
-0.0141040375,
0.0234356746,
-0.0137327323,
0.0311826058,
-0.0249333233,
0.0234826002,
0.0577704273,
-0.0159390867,
0.0362917185,
-0.0300062951,
0.0611843616,
-0.018402623,
-0.0594587959,
-0.0392527208,
-5.373533285e-33,
-0.0183731634,
-0.0098979566,
-0.0135844601,
0.0974727497,
-0.0039278092,
0.0070985779,
-0.0650328323,
0.0218650959,
0.017688673,
0.0150493281,
-0.0280161649,
-0.0244335793,
-0.011661564,
0.0377629139,
0.0345999487,
-0.0122008612,
0.0142740719,
0.0032795856,
-0.0295047928,
0.0240694471,
0.0200729389,
0.0366743654,
0.0308263153,
-0.0932620019,
0.0064761383,
-0.0118152909,
-0.0223326366,
-0.0255536325,
0.0414289124,
0.0418159999,
-0.0181053877,
0.0182842482,
0.0038221611,
-0.010568873,
-0.0072502475,
0.0024994698,
-0.0561034083,
0.0031599745,
0.0026880628,
-0.0114581138,
-0.011832539,
-0.0392487384,
0.0833198801,
-0.0306930002,
-0.0404683836,
-0.0257133953,
0.0594444126,
-0.0185087156,
-0.0134318713,
-0.0867670551,
-0.0684532598,
-0.0170414075,
-0.0186880939,
-0.0482423827,
0.0203200206,
0.0320655406,
0.0289518852,
0.0570745692,
-0.0142615456,
0.0424480848,
-0.0326162092,
0.0151517997,
0.0337729268,
-0.0592668541,
0.0140462397,
0.0499237962,
-0.0020361904,
0.0609538183,
0.0104648378,
0.0132869575,
0.0164345261,
0.0522862226,
0.0840780884,
0.0277172457,
0.0447512828,
0.0008863931,
-0.0145589812,
0.0633515716,
-0.0016242032,
-0.0234728586,
0.0279982574,
-0.0081940638,
0.008515588,
0.0175126139,
0.0270232577,
0.0143741257,
0.0118084075,
-0.0443932749,
-0.0200157948,
0.0335106924,
-0.0688213706,
0.0248083081,
-0.0109133152,
-0.0637092143,
-0.02395555,
-0.0056299595,
-0.0113437688,
0.0273484327,
-0.0212398991,
-0.0214056503,
-0.0281854626,
-0.030682344,
0.0184123721,
0.0599669404,
0.0058796229,
0.0085505499,
0.0780671239,
-0.0069202241,
-0.0476731993,
0.0021301822,
-0.0134503786,
0.0146997022,
-0.0193054546,
0.0006708372,
-0.018144615,
0.0296717435,
-0.0094545893,
-0.0607775562,
0.0450806208,
0.0395101905,
-0.0172197074,
0.0542561039,
0.0197391827,
0.0237551313,
-0.0568482801,
0.0020306706,
-0.006994762,
-0.0594971627,
0.0183546189,
-0.065849252,
-0.0148662422,
-0.0550383739,
2.331e-7,
0.0586311854,
0.097075589,
0.0359437652,
0.0264709424,
0.0370725095,
-0.0038030709,
0.0040957895,
0.0482605211,
0.0368607044,
0.0462186672,
0.0161635261,
-0.0461932793,
0.0153538221,
0.0114892703,
-0.1060313284,
-0.0238228217,
-0.0972419009,
0.0068435278,
-0.0362540185,
0.0164038297,
0.0325159431,
0.0075181387,
-0.004803637,
-0.0202724021,
0.004448521,
-0.0321645774,
0.0538801625,
-0.0166937411,
0.0293754935,
0.0372242928,
0.0465288088,
0.0142327622,
0.0072713285,
-0.0262304805,
-0.0100058885,
-0.0266926605,
0.0439563058,
0.0339682139,
0.000382185,
-0.0115646785,
0.0414015166,
0.0024321505,
0.0277931765,
-0.0617666431,
0.0238665603,
-0.0668652952,
-0.017247811,
-0.0465831272,
-0.0643573701,
-0.007518155,
0.052222196,
-0.0405779704,
-0.0190270096,
0.0276694689,
0.0302653294,
0.0383403301,
0.0240691099,
-0.0306892227,
-0.0270034391,
0.0204464663,
-0.0486366563,
-0.0097225439,
-0.0116877127,
-0.0426891446,
-0.0116349878,
-0.0868487582,
-0.0223067701,
2.113161858e-34,
0.0648266152,
0.008214579,
-0.0245490354,
-0.0073473775,
-0.0076275477,
0.0100507652,
0.0447820835,
0.0309649482,
-0.0093453415,
-0.0388023816,
-0.0242660586
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10711v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10711v1 | Task Ambiguity in Humans and Language Models | 2022-12-20T18:35:33 | 2022-12-20T18:35:33 | Alex Tamkin, Kunal Handa, Avash Shrestha, Noah Goodman | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Language models have recently achieved strong performance across a wide range
of NLP benchmarks. However, unlike benchmarks, real world tasks are often
poorly specified, and agents must deduce the user's intended behavior from a
combination of context, instructions, and examples. We investigate how both
humans and models behave in the face of such task ambiguity by proposing
AmbiBench, a new benchmark of six ambiguously-specified classification tasks.
We evaluate humans and models on AmbiBench by seeing how well they identify the
intended task using 1) instructions with varying degrees of ambiguity, and 2)
different numbers of labeled examples. We find that the combination of model
scaling (to 175B parameters) and training with human feedback data enables
models to approach or exceed the accuracy of human participants across tasks,
but that either one alone is not sufficient. In addition, we show how to
dramatically improve the accuracy of language models trained without
large-scale human feedback training by finetuning on a small number of
ambiguous in-context examples, providing a promising direction for teaching
models to generalize well in the face of ambiguity. | [
0.0792834014,
0.0373550504,
-0.0185332093,
0.0135806929,
-0.0329281241,
0.020898398,
-0.0107927872,
0.0062499079,
-0.008582714,
-0.0857218504,
-0.0347495861,
-0.0648991689,
-0.0012249809,
-0.0011208506,
0.0298785493,
-0.0564876273,
0.0444798395,
-0.0244424157,
-0.0080896467,
0.0234816186,
-0.0001368341,
0.0098976586,
0.0000366641,
0.0447181612,
-0.0084263757,
-0.0118268821,
-0.0168894846,
-0.0019977822,
-0.0198933166,
0.0201594718,
0.0427187681,
0.0651843697,
0.0339389704,
0.0331267342,
0.0000018871,
-0.0379284956,
0.0344404876,
-0.0325561799,
-0.0893814638,
-0.0367242172,
0.0465159081,
-0.0091370223,
0.0232616216,
0.0241051819,
-0.0361069962,
-0.0062319301,
0.018844774,
0.0785165802,
0.0238290355,
0.0677825063,
0.0091376537,
0.0065733814,
-0.0185720939,
-0.0247954503,
0.0171426646,
-0.0449624211,
0.0112319896,
-0.0230750367,
0.0325917304,
0.0422929153,
0.0136131709,
0.022248473,
0.0230622087,
0.0230564829,
0.0005704588,
0.044065088,
-0.0094645359,
-0.0370177478,
-0.0141572086,
0.0586495064,
-0.0242723618,
-0.0348243117,
0.022078827,
-0.0176929943,
0.0139967054,
0.0215097647,
0.0083852438,
0.0065680002,
-0.015035457,
-0.0073351841,
0.0078469431,
0.021202255,
0.0472772382,
0.0569644272,
0.01348239,
0.0627044365,
-0.0367048532,
-0.0157762412,
0.0337516367,
0.0027763871,
-0.075155966,
-0.063932173,
0.0197440963,
0.0179828685,
-0.0738192648,
0.0124070905,
-0.0603322834,
-0.0413950272,
0.0298778601,
-0.0755926743,
0.0794380605,
0.0426417887,
-0.0114706429,
0.0408553518,
0.0013931753,
0.0455529131,
0.0017742997,
0.0265950561,
-0.0436390452,
-0.0047828373,
-0.0866060406,
-0.0059697544,
-0.0391137712,
0.0059653912,
-0.0422165319,
-0.0165856276,
-0.0305484273,
0.0324231684,
-0.0485532917,
-0.0012064421,
0.0180189498,
0.0521406084,
-0.0822003931,
-0.011046702,
-0.0355097726,
-0.0297275204,
-0.0328661464,
0.0587056987,
0.0057019992,
-0.0491239876,
-0.0040712799,
0.0031757313,
-0.0107210213,
-0.0292179491,
0.0171812717,
0.0639415905,
-0.0137557024,
-0.0054001436,
-0.0163035803,
-0.0321820043,
-0.0079808217,
-0.0735520199,
-0.0265476797,
-0.0397265218,
0.0368847102,
0.0246866997,
-0.0194199216,
-0.0123708257,
0.0004568549,
0.0271886252,
-0.0244812109,
0.1271169633,
0.0355801955,
0.0107879397,
0.0526501127,
0.0187230911,
-0.0569361784,
0.0702503547,
-0.0007727852,
0.0362520181,
0.007811605,
0.0262610782,
0.0362278111,
0.0039711776,
-0.0047699651,
0.0053404723,
0.02005779,
0.0207133442,
-0.0190223083,
0.0601184778,
0.0419439338,
0.0516409501,
-0.0231665969,
-0.0338421129,
0.0631231219,
0.0461927913,
-0.0254094172,
-0.0206676759,
0.0493852757,
0.0445017219,
-0.0117170801,
-0.0064787883,
-0.0926529318,
-0.0019856219,
-0.0129970526,
-0.0031828044,
-0.0360322855,
-0.0361267105,
-0.0326180719,
-0.0274535976,
-0.0391029678,
-0.0204796065,
0.0591778681,
0.0311123189,
0.0468966775,
0.024601955,
-0.0254390296,
0.0627411902,
0.0192884132,
-0.0104211168,
0.0194801148,
-0.0503091663,
0.0046552503,
0.0535752475,
0.0170545038,
-0.035289824,
-0.0075098365,
-0.0319441967,
0.0422297157,
0.0194373932,
0.064693056,
-0.0446174219,
0.0335632749,
-0.0244223643,
-0.0216578282,
0.0160996076,
0.0206915196,
-0.0224910155,
0.0377230197,
-0.0339775532,
0.0218390301,
-0.0537674874,
-0.0356164761,
0.0594689436,
-0.0237916745,
-0.0272927899,
0.0029654447,
0.0228785872,
0.0143889822,
-0.0005830472,
0.0201091859,
0.0004297403,
0.0126734097,
-0.018984057,
-0.0296709649,
-0.0261014625,
-0.066079177,
-0.0093097081,
0.0226753931,
0.0195216984,
-0.0415284149,
0.0561306141,
-0.0242522676,
-0.0297557656,
0.003563707,
-0.0257322397,
0.0235820748,
-0.0217389874,
0.019708965,
-0.0167749189,
-0.020917872,
-0.0363431126,
0.0553659946,
0.0025525407,
0.0258167777,
0.0009535235,
-0.0012249931,
0.0060660816,
-0.030435089,
-0.0295084398,
0.012666571,
-0.0006775449,
0.015121622,
0.0331388712,
0.0106260683,
-0.0565641224,
-0.0315505378,
-0.1045426577,
-0.003480253,
-0.039501708,
0.0212429054,
0.0316510499,
0.0017353171,
0.0167327579,
-0.0219846908,
-0.0248220749,
-0.0224019233,
-0.0392131954,
0.0278695878,
0.0313872658,
0.022368826,
0.0099578472,
-0.0232989043,
0.0148121761,
-0.0286014657,
0.0094608758,
0.0083731441,
-0.0308106951,
-0.0660370067,
0.0432648025,
0.0214521345,
0.0440226644,
-0.019956449,
-0.0101863639,
0.0151270377,
-0.001151291,
0.0285603125,
0.0614443347,
-0.0040163212,
0.0653013289,
0.0412360057,
0.0327514969,
-0.0844102129,
0.0146767693,
-0.02826217,
-0.0319331884,
-0.0407832563,
-0.0275439806,
-0.010787921,
0.0701821372,
0.0142021077,
0.0062377173,
-0.0550434552,
-0.0043557775,
-0.0449386165,
-0.0379285961,
-0.0583278425,
-0.0032556215,
-0.0503549352,
0.0247949585,
-0.026425628,
-0.0235271435,
0.0775947496,
0.0284784865,
-0.0046622204,
-0.0493395068,
-0.0142051158,
0.0036053804,
0.0690679029,
-0.0096905548,
0.0067736469,
0.0236240532,
-0.0287088864,
-0.0621327423,
0.0052528321,
0.0035443858,
-0.0322175138,
0.0464318208,
-0.0662558526,
0.0196430404,
-0.0231831893,
-0.0675590336,
-0.056868773,
-0.0446233414,
-0.0072123827,
0.0293251444,
0.0140414806,
-0.0075594964,
-0.0353384204,
-0.0100734169,
-0.0031734495,
0.0239926446,
-0.0095155062,
-0.0426940881,
-0.0283735152,
-0.0035527099,
0.0671888441,
0.0349270515,
0.0037745009,
-0.0535488166,
-0.0229093824,
0.0271835327,
0.0422947966,
0.0105400598,
-0.0395859033,
0.0055619096,
0.0469711609,
-0.0307320096,
-0.030463893,
0.0674141943,
0.0579017997,
-0.0473163426,
-0.0197965913,
0.1121086255,
0.0320644602,
-0.0556842871,
0.0171688553,
-0.0066320556,
-0.0011086107,
0.017581664,
0.0279570427,
-0.0669932514,
-0.067206867,
0.025944015,
0.0256420765,
-0.0218095984,
-0.0115306675,
-0.0087365927,
-0.0783969238,
0.0016175974,
-0.0263161957,
-0.025245674,
0.0014440449,
-0.0355072282,
0.0249400027,
-0.0458569676,
0.0552949794,
-0.0235736053,
0.0028428691,
0.0007627495,
0.0347827859,
0.0153190168,
-0.0904677436,
0.0517401248,
-0.0513055027,
0.0783953369,
0.0313585624,
0.0114682866,
-0.0033987225,
0.0040989192,
0.0387384109,
0.0166409649,
0.0059858984,
-0.0134078199,
0.0525269806,
-0.0015894107,
0.0016783901,
-0.0057016639,
0.0202408526,
-0.0522994027,
-0.0232683569,
-0.0282780118,
0.0581882522,
-0.0339838266,
-0.0127135525,
-0.0040026484,
-0.0429966785,
0.050154224,
0.109045811,
0.004814595,
-0.0670480281,
-0.0594413243,
-0.0187154822,
0.0078380974,
-0.0488367192,
-0.0065724924,
0.0175508577,
0.0040889843,
-0.0208522435,
-0.0526170544,
-0.0609213188,
0.0262423158,
0.0139032556,
0.0280219335,
0.0292662401,
0.0569899082,
-0.0091799675,
-0.0326726027,
0.0364185683,
0.0110571329,
0.0589225143,
-0.0627143681,
-0.0456533507,
0.0253690239,
-0.0215196609,
-0.0036266954,
0.0486857817,
-0.1134991199,
-0.0580923706,
0.0298654828,
0.0012758299,
0.0262961611,
0.0533969626,
-0.042184636,
-0.0803272575,
-0.0072796321,
0.0194557365,
-0.0256414711,
0.0059253848,
0.0346381031,
0.0480745323,
-0.0128978379,
0.0644463003,
-0.0563635752,
0.001595747,
0.0098283989,
0.0113944104,
-0.0654154569,
-0.0220777933,
0.0197855607,
-0.0149726057,
0.0287861917,
-0.0168733131,
-0.0124536529,
-0.0193673894,
-0.0262986142,
0.0306974128,
-0.0226891916,
-0.0318844765,
-0.0181011818,
0.0268160235,
0.0004708351,
0.003912034,
0.0142131429,
0.0006296061,
0.0370113328,
-0.0451240987,
-0.0177870654,
0.0124700032,
0.0052190572,
0.0171086919,
0.0252929181,
-0.0288669635,
0.0217697434,
0.0000244452,
0.0511579178,
-0.0021215361,
0.0376250558,
0.0325262062,
0.0036898437,
-0.0432780832,
0.0174973086,
-0.0628854036,
-0.037077792,
-0.0128789907,
-0.0052058855,
0.0272831433,
-0.0270941965,
0.0252417624,
-0.0317674242,
-0.0057863239,
-0.0121350484,
0.0378005728,
-0.0015604573,
-0.0057867751,
0.0275536682,
0.036832884,
-0.0203465559,
0.0219845753,
0.0779759958,
0.0180802103,
0.044042863,
-0.0155916633,
-0.0379910767,
-0.0414402448,
-0.013961317,
0.0291599594,
0.0341224037,
-0.01843738,
0.0595555045,
-0.0241062846,
-0.0535086654,
-0.0029478187,
0.0014417532,
0.0100068254,
-0.0341753997,
0.0613080263,
0.0546131544,
-0.0126242153,
-0.044129394,
-0.0666552931,
-0.023415627,
0.0249314345,
-0.0066676419,
-0.0946595445,
-6.26003786e-33,
-0.0009484575,
-0.0066452329,
-0.0102666281,
-0.0244844072,
0.0212522689,
0.0080754878,
-0.0133682974,
0.0046204031,
-0.0403774641,
0.0143381897,
-0.0114268698,
0.021587532,
0.0211007949,
0.0176068805,
0.0417504273,
-0.0275233891,
0.0474424176,
-0.008036078,
-0.0092244009,
0.0019436958,
0.052152507,
0.0107789654,
0.0448865332,
-0.0883033946,
0.0507478714,
0.0130556226,
-0.0178927705,
0.0225733966,
-0.0167276468,
0.0403777249,
-0.0387844443,
0.0555377938,
0.0227953643,
-0.0331294574,
-0.0381079018,
0.0033729179,
-0.0799718052,
-0.0282391142,
0.0086273225,
0.0454199426,
-0.0541768223,
-0.0069198483,
0.0552418344,
-0.0035520943,
-0.0460150056,
0.0097565753,
0.0323457383,
0.0132442303,
-0.0078320438,
-0.0098105418,
-0.0187277943,
-0.0048166621,
0.0236944985,
-0.0414190628,
0.0396297984,
0.0315621756,
-0.0403953753,
-0.0192404222,
-0.0735268667,
-0.0180207286,
0.0045608608,
0.022766456,
0.0545742884,
0.0440044366,
-0.0114411647,
0.0498083681,
-0.0025238579,
0.0389381573,
0.0065543801,
-0.0302710887,
0.0100242821,
0.0588410944,
0.015520703,
0.0285141915,
0.0471081249,
-0.0007374802,
0.0030770998,
0.0139365783,
0.0424675941,
0.0237953644,
0.0493331999,
0.0237484816,
-0.0916654393,
-0.0589762703,
-0.0438598506,
0.003658928,
-0.0428378806,
-0.0072820866,
0.0521718003,
0.0225081779,
0.0290830825,
0.0098623997,
0.0152548859,
-0.0521137528,
-0.0252315011,
-0.0289639942,
-0.0026612694,
0.0089606848,
0.0339933112,
-0.004943063,
-0.0551154688,
-0.0444279611,
0.0189991184,
0.0200315081,
0.0254005548,
0.0133260787,
0.0512872264,
0.0131247938,
-0.0335177034,
-0.0070863748,
-0.0360580124,
0.0201642662,
0.0128434766,
0.0289537963,
0.0519455597,
0.0098225912,
-0.0267598573,
0.0528060347,
0.0103280721,
-0.0305603854,
-0.0028259074,
-0.0123227024,
-0.0396468826,
0.0097228922,
-0.0339264907,
-0.0134467641,
-0.021851521,
0.0151192239,
0.0240660589,
-0.0230251309,
-0.008018597,
0.0193491522,
2.59e-7,
0.0413448252,
0.0422782227,
-0.0232446622,
0.0289388318,
-0.0046161832,
0.0710783601,
-0.0000349055,
0.0334924832,
-0.0202893708,
-0.019722566,
-0.0093371952,
0.0144178253,
0.0542144105,
-0.0074287895,
-0.0605233386,
-0.0100298896,
-0.0462127775,
0.0626042113,
-0.0080729611,
0.0199581962,
0.0602553673,
0.0840436816,
0.0302468333,
-0.0073375311,
0.010581227,
-0.0453225262,
0.043023251,
-0.0445513055,
0.0068621952,
0.0194949917,
0.0420466661,
0.0256787892,
0.0305721164,
0.0345574729,
-0.0298816022,
-0.0096801287,
0.0084877042,
0.0710870847,
-0.0317160189,
0.0031326436,
-0.0410629511,
-0.031147372,
0.0274242572,
-0.0452143736,
0.0570204295,
-0.0861027315,
-0.0348838456,
-0.009598203,
0.0206067711,
-0.0004308826,
-0.0016154479,
0.0139624123,
-0.0148041379,
-0.0033796057,
0.0120780533,
-0.0170719828,
-0.048335094,
-0.1003618315,
-0.0185651518,
0.0241085514,
-0.0508125164,
-0.0016606736,
-0.0306305364,
0.0213361587,
0.0377028659,
-0.0848620534,
-0.0038215513,
2.232157473e-34,
0.0154535826,
0.037183594,
0.0052276608,
0.0310213156,
0.0227010883,
0.0127614588,
-0.0275397133,
0.014148213,
0.03361357,
-0.0221985448,
-0.0113970796
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10520v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10520v3 | Privacy-Preserving Domain Adaptation of Semantic Parsers | 2022-12-20T18:35:21 | 2023-06-08T18:03:43 | Fatemehsadat Mireshghallah, Yu Su, Tatsunori Hashimoto, Jason Eisner, Richard Shin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Task-oriented dialogue systems often assist users with personal or
confidential matters. For this reason, the developers of such a system are
generally prohibited from observing actual usage. So how can they know where
the system is failing and needs more training data or new functionality? In
this work, we study ways in which realistic user utterances can be generated
synthetically, to help increase the linguistic and functional coverage of the
system, without compromising the privacy of actual users. To this end, we
propose a two-stage Differentially Private (DP) generation method which first
generates latent semantic parses, and then generates utterances based on the
parses. Our proposed approach improves MAUVE by 2.5$\times$ and parse tree
function type overlap by 1.3$\times$ relative to current approaches for private
synthetic data generation, improving both on fluency and semantic coverage. We
further validate our approach on a realistic domain adaptation task of adding
new functionality from private user data to a semantic parser, and show overall
gains of 8.5% points in accuracy with the new feature. | [
0.053714484,
0.073380284,
-0.0375827067,
0.0473602004,
-0.0332280844,
-0.0433835089,
0.0637354702,
-0.0333913118,
0.0176954418,
-0.0280746389,
-0.0214989726,
-0.0104085961,
-0.0267092325,
0.0561347492,
-0.0061695771,
-0.0336522721,
0.0341455825,
-0.0118738422,
-0.00461761,
-0.0006851748,
-0.0262842253,
0.0131237917,
-0.0064082732,
0.0361344628,
-0.0134582706,
-0.0281924456,
-0.0413284861,
0.0045978674,
0.0013547869,
-0.0023255956,
0.0054358351,
0.0380398035,
0.0193722509,
0.0369612537,
0.0000019631,
-0.064484477,
-0.0479189232,
0.0210834295,
-0.0295423754,
-0.0303384364,
0.026051065,
0.015353675,
0.0132277943,
-0.0037359823,
-0.0696320459,
-0.0022162984,
0.0353136025,
0.0255169179,
0.0803072825,
0.0943153873,
-0.0198719334,
-0.0037258531,
-0.0055035735,
-0.0099085839,
0.0194419585,
-0.0691498145,
-0.0000932176,
-0.0213103909,
-0.0085576037,
-0.0040551936,
0.006102067,
-0.0091517465,
0.0178968217,
-0.0109865395,
0.0067855404,
0.010658728,
0.0035869293,
-0.037029583,
-0.0422891714,
0.0387321673,
0.0432763286,
-0.0145640383,
0.0278784595,
0.0042110025,
0.0347637013,
0.0115933819,
-0.0147094205,
0.0023092865,
-0.0351741873,
-0.0042135087,
0.0401312485,
0.0241604634,
-0.0183805004,
-0.0125852264,
0.0165801123,
0.0481394343,
0.0095396666,
-0.0074680015,
-0.023426462,
-0.0094150985,
0.0047777775,
-0.0383840501,
0.0539168157,
-0.0224607009,
0.0103223557,
0.0155687248,
-0.0833733752,
-0.0690447167,
0.0049983254,
-0.008773135,
0.0115158912,
0.0356216244,
0.0070718983,
-0.0025567471,
-0.0082481978,
0.0389498286,
-0.0009578529,
0.0133298691,
0.0082671233,
0.0269564744,
-0.0333999582,
0.0071718064,
-0.0628216639,
0.0592118353,
-0.1224766374,
0.0062302211,
0.0014059888,
0.071520023,
-0.0068508419,
-0.0055889734,
0.0304887611,
0.0171005204,
-0.0758683905,
0.0064299423,
-0.0112002948,
-0.0648021922,
-0.0115599306,
0.0085366247,
0.0429275632,
-0.0735044181,
-0.0137719596,
-0.0308158323,
0.0214013159,
0.0011380995,
-0.0758297294,
0.0772809014,
-0.0192019716,
0.0155950524,
-0.0028154491,
-0.0946611837,
-0.0085652014,
-0.0085313749,
-0.0011303073,
-0.0439794175,
0.0051296214,
-0.024835499,
-0.0031244049,
-0.0648812503,
0.0177454706,
0.0442846343,
0.0329951495,
0.0568395704,
-0.0302056,
-0.0171791185,
0.010617041,
0.0454875045,
-0.026515618,
0.0449919999,
0.0271574445,
0.0179033596,
0.0475247726,
-0.0082707061,
0.0117464121,
-0.0368132852,
0.0256902725,
-0.0256490055,
0.0232142955,
0.0418061838,
-0.0367438756,
-0.0446754806,
0.0175491795,
0.0277325008,
-0.0188475847,
-0.0334923416,
0.0273174085,
0.0327454433,
0.0087177837,
0.0363383926,
0.0221296567,
0.0659853294,
-0.0549035594,
0.017750049,
-0.0403588042,
-0.034159109,
-0.0406127796,
-0.0269261841,
-0.034611173,
-0.008183552,
0.0005019691,
-0.0114810662,
0.0348543711,
-0.0315168723,
0.0323135294,
-0.0142486552,
-0.0091167921,
0.0659895986,
0.0076709175,
0.0736718476,
0.0178487338,
-0.0605884008,
-0.0029376594,
-0.044104483,
0.0084518464,
0.0996636972,
0.007385626,
-0.0054712589,
-0.0143252993,
-0.0221490581,
-0.0375385135,
0.0414635763,
-0.0095093222,
0.0000549882,
0.0317786261,
-0.0269582905,
-0.0436153784,
-0.0494569428,
0.0244436655,
0.0236984156,
-0.0156915169,
-0.0141504817,
0.0390928797,
-0.0335570388,
0.0414638631,
0.0148838293,
-0.0157284644,
-0.0272315238,
0.0643185824,
0.0085486295,
0.0589862987,
0.059574943,
0.0285470635,
0.0048795766,
-0.0098310281,
-0.0089045027,
-0.005907964,
0.0233018901,
-0.0412156768,
-0.0386808626,
-0.0235138647,
-0.0339229926,
0.0338937938,
0.0588691831,
-0.0161742456,
-0.0468144082,
0.0217980649,
-0.0443468317,
0.0177076831,
-0.0416861475,
0.0010088016,
0.0401306301,
0.0321414582,
-0.0181660689,
0.0193723906,
-0.0277163126,
-0.042843435,
-0.0767908469,
0.0249363929,
0.0002755222,
-0.0453188568,
0.0159663334,
-0.0245575383,
-0.0343944207,
0.0131483693,
0.0074862479,
0.0479341596,
-0.0411133133,
-0.0373008735,
-0.0712348595,
0.0148475468,
-0.0234271381,
0.0440985933,
0.0454655178,
0.0503922179,
-0.004814913,
-0.049241025,
-0.0687513128,
0.0096628591,
-0.0110553373,
0.0059054806,
0.0300310273,
0.0382537656,
-0.0576437898,
0.0104373582,
0.0145374602,
-0.0051662154,
0.0052025327,
-0.0580391288,
-0.0412304625,
-0.0291052498,
0.0510213785,
0.0017022956,
0.0417220145,
0.0108634196,
0.0082373274,
0.0018134488,
0.0176416971,
0.023920713,
0.0344949849,
0.0108151287,
0.013963189,
-0.0130142383,
-0.0165145583,
-0.0680961832,
0.0304669403,
-0.0034019945,
-0.014506775,
-0.0449135043,
-0.0045920638,
0.049432151,
0.0156780425,
0.0285376348,
-0.016005503,
-0.062932387,
0.0190873239,
-0.0154975737,
-0.0827057287,
0.0494868048,
-0.0070638293,
-0.0250331387,
0.0417092033,
0.0124653634,
-0.0262256954,
0.0777333379,
-0.0090479357,
-0.0066570211,
-0.0518773235,
-0.0340098664,
-0.0197738539,
0.0706122443,
-0.0198969506,
0.0197354928,
0.0508796051,
-0.0929465294,
0.0053896806,
-0.0017171383,
0.0280151423,
-0.029638337,
0.024338698,
-0.0263611469,
-0.0281996969,
0.0098425839,
-0.07120388,
-0.0724123716,
-0.0754141062,
0.0032489037,
0.0023623784,
-0.0202860478,
-0.0229536276,
0.015853798,
-0.0312186051,
-0.0273829941,
0.0293922406,
0.0224419683,
-0.0175014175,
-0.0464263186,
-0.0317225195,
0.0277870093,
0.0018754754,
-0.0556121431,
-0.0069893468,
0.0257892422,
0.073194243,
0.0809368789,
-0.0039124484,
0.0255289041,
-0.0313045308,
0.0024207151,
-0.0036884504,
-0.0415396094,
0.0211526621,
0.0693350658,
-0.0410827957,
-0.0199407395,
0.0710866526,
0.0238023549,
-0.0106205074,
0.0112201711,
-0.009788271,
0.0102098202,
0.0041537052,
0.0214754213,
-0.1178421751,
-0.0109859398,
0.0081884479,
0.0554216728,
-0.0521383956,
-0.048296418,
-0.0261467937,
-0.1126857325,
-0.0256763529,
-0.0029903054,
-0.0061288765,
0.0292015076,
-0.015158684,
0.0060576512,
-0.0046280776,
0.0190280732,
-0.0356712192,
0.0269787014,
-0.0036362237,
-0.000608116,
-0.0101270657,
-0.0433031619,
-0.0132624693,
-0.0032858895,
0.0545329973,
0.0556492135,
0.0159969274,
0.0212153792,
-0.0209799036,
0.0025911587,
0.0441182032,
0.0199838113,
-0.0028213826,
0.0335884169,
0.0099477051,
0.0242774468,
0.0119813839,
0.0786237121,
-0.0345456265,
-0.0084487079,
0.0431550406,
0.0230942331,
-0.0295461677,
0.0071392898,
0.017717164,
0.0228339303,
0.0427397862,
0.0546908751,
-0.0001242785,
-0.0284173731,
-0.0095514404,
-0.0309342649,
0.0185382199,
-0.0580054112,
0.0264599025,
0.0162487384,
-0.0015074372,
-0.0636291951,
-0.0848602876,
-0.0035995026,
0.0088065155,
0.0405685864,
0.0115953907,
-0.0209682807,
0.0288450997,
0.0161892679,
-0.0207817461,
-0.0031012362,
-0.0647767633,
0.001295023,
-0.0110653201,
-0.0353738293,
0.0074469349,
-0.0277060959,
-0.0023277216,
0.0036405628,
-0.0203724448,
-0.0583810657,
0.0243594404,
0.0477890596,
0.0104088187,
0.0298143197,
-0.059677992,
-0.0279515237,
0.047684487,
0.0529050715,
-0.1314135045,
-0.0165847,
0.0813081786,
0.0065126941,
0.0085776299,
0.0349717997,
-0.0087901494,
-0.0225653518,
0.0064099487,
0.0098122265,
-0.02109088,
-0.0709506422,
0.023775693,
0.0557536259,
0.0566769689,
0.026539892,
0.040283367,
-0.0141444281,
0.047708068,
-0.0599102229,
-0.0076453737,
-0.0403307863,
0.0058273594,
0.008572543,
-0.0140592856,
0.0680053681,
0.0080931438,
-0.049310606,
0.027965039,
-0.038237486,
0.0177718271,
0.0603184886,
0.0367339589,
-0.0042270254,
-0.0014094695,
-0.0471895859,
0.0007611588,
0.0382872336,
0.0377004556,
0.0145355854,
0.0386543497,
-0.0029541459,
-0.0066000903,
0.0169075429,
0.0347216688,
-0.0836222246,
0.0021164257,
-0.0084557161,
0.0182223246,
-0.0120060658,
0.0530542992,
0.03834996,
-0.0334187821,
0.028889535,
0.0013696697,
0.0335129052,
0.0022060988,
-0.0490031913,
-0.0172975175,
-0.0225194339,
-0.0146615794,
-0.0329430662,
0.0566245392,
-0.003062824,
0.0059134513,
-0.0216737483,
0.0111661302,
-0.0914362743,
-0.0426841825,
-0.0062512779,
0.0767384246,
-0.0094376132,
-0.0217683855,
-0.0269067455,
-0.0508450642,
-0.0195461754,
-0.014609633,
0.0206874311,
0.0045174188,
0.0510268621,
0.0257586315,
-0.0170326494,
-0.0620732047,
-0.064814873,
-0.0234169569,
0.021195991,
0.0131599735,
-0.0420085192,
-5.328504872e-33,
-0.0273930188,
0.0100270323,
0.0043294481,
0.0652704388,
-0.0007930001,
-0.0210308023,
-0.0316037945,
0.0165148154,
0.018396277,
-0.0214760583,
-0.0360768288,
0.0093000485,
0.0322618634,
0.0442819037,
-0.0291557033,
0.010177454,
0.0845280439,
-0.0255387351,
0.0008529593,
0.0569069013,
0.0793628916,
0.0247833636,
-0.004849738,
-0.0954200625,
0.0432863235,
0.0244612265,
-0.0405921265,
0.0390217714,
-0.0006284155,
0.0349506475,
0.0111096743,
0.0126285488,
-0.0022908545,
0.0062661842,
-0.0438758396,
0.0277504064,
-0.053812325,
-0.013236491,
0.0256678779,
-0.0079633491,
-0.0023548226,
-0.0569315255,
0.0102531472,
-0.0380356796,
0.0030523371,
0.0187621117,
-0.011838899,
-0.0174732711,
0.0401530713,
-0.0616738386,
-0.0030390001,
0.0033712175,
-0.0040259962,
0.0023837166,
0.0141734425,
0.0468405895,
0.01483218,
-0.0904057324,
-0.004601066,
0.0246274695,
-0.0097495411,
-0.0219423771,
0.0448596887,
0.0046001743,
0.0266339928,
0.0202736408,
0.0524069965,
0.0267726146,
0.0077715996,
-0.0083704861,
-0.0352051146,
0.0529978611,
-0.0323367417,
0.0545953251,
0.0191462077,
-0.0157201681,
-0.00808011,
0.0156162875,
-0.0141152982,
-0.0157877617,
0.0344486088,
0.0278565492,
-0.0943314433,
0.0250496864,
-0.0110820392,
0.0842648819,
-0.0267006904,
-0.0258338936,
0.0073612314,
-0.005815208,
-0.0488142185,
-0.013388169,
-0.0058011273,
-0.0600434802,
0.0283970162,
-0.0187386051,
0.0444834121,
-0.0529441461,
-0.026663363,
-0.0149383489,
-0.004847846,
-0.0471629165,
0.0602209382,
-0.0042299842,
0.0218449235,
0.0122592384,
0.0108036725,
-0.0142247053,
-0.0752802417,
-0.0110271694,
-0.0234872177,
0.0865868255,
0.0016956975,
0.051178541,
0.0468920358,
-0.0308296587,
-0.0586658418,
0.0346986316,
0.0061206678,
0.0009918028,
-0.0502106249,
0.0400635786,
0.0203970689,
0.0167906974,
-0.0143592963,
-0.0287651345,
0.0193228703,
-0.0193731207,
0.0654144585,
0.0177083071,
-0.0115317795,
-0.0128920311,
2.773e-7,
-0.0303879362,
-0.0286142267,
0.0110820262,
-0.0023173718,
0.0103929956,
0.0478736646,
0.041137889,
0.1076489687,
-0.015601065,
-0.0132087162,
-0.0309960898,
-0.0159152467,
0.0612952635,
0.0495693125,
-0.0700547919,
-0.0302794557,
0.0435435735,
-0.0001276447,
-0.0183132831,
0.0383241475,
0.064185895,
0.0312725231,
0.037058048,
-0.0044592679,
0.0044224276,
-0.044623781,
0.0056145401,
-0.0151962703,
-0.0489379279,
0.0103717009,
0.0279333759,
0.0371170938,
0.0422742963,
0.0146116996,
-0.0258122664,
0.0379840657,
-0.0599689633,
0.0885015354,
0.0187267046,
-0.0356212929,
0.0156270768,
-0.0463076569,
-0.009917317,
0.0099371066,
0.0080344658,
-0.0280384254,
-0.034257438,
0.0301986802,
0.02525221,
-0.0362913571,
-0.0188953076,
-0.0190347265,
-0.0055025364,
-0.0130498437,
0.02249524,
0.0087541891,
0.0267810319,
-0.0151604274,
-0.0128878681,
-0.031217888,
-0.0525575466,
-0.046076443,
0.0011767322,
0.0323638767,
-0.007787528,
-0.0027243872,
0.0592847876,
2.368683565e-34,
-0.0038124633,
0.0327051096,
-0.0098651154,
-0.008417326,
0.0350540392,
0.0192374755,
0.0326252878,
0.014949007,
0.0615231842,
-0.0192255378,
-0.0295540038
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10515v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10515v2 | CausalDialogue: Modeling Utterance-level Causality in Conversations | 2022-12-20T18:31:50 | 2023-07-08T21:59:43 | Yi-Lin Tuan, Alon Albalak, Wenda Xu, Michael Saxon, Connor Pryor, Lise Getoor, William Yang Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite their widespread adoption, neural conversation models have yet to
exhibit natural chat capabilities with humans. In this research, we examine
user utterances as causes and generated responses as effects, recognizing that
changes in a cause should produce a different effect. To further explore this
concept, we have compiled and expanded upon a new dataset called CausalDialogue
through crowd-sourcing. This dataset includes multiple cause-effect pairs
within a directed acyclic graph (DAG) structure. Our analysis reveals that
traditional loss functions struggle to effectively incorporate the DAG
structure, leading us to propose a causality-enhanced method called Exponential
Maximum Average Treatment Effect (ExMATE) to enhance the impact of causality at
the utterance level in training neural conversation models. To evaluate the
needs of considering causality in dialogue generation, we built a comprehensive
benchmark on CausalDialogue dataset using different models, inference, and
training methods. Through experiments, we find that a causality-inspired loss
like ExMATE can improve the diversity and agility of conventional loss function
and there is still room for improvement to reach human-level quality on this
new dataset. | [
0.0267066117,
0.1090014055,
-0.0095136696,
0.0188239925,
-0.0068929042,
-0.0097733764,
0.0312234648,
-0.0219208766,
0.0219768845,
-0.0176306255,
0.0055530244,
-0.0215315353,
-0.0136350878,
0.0567051023,
0.0489714332,
-0.0094974302,
0.0304645281,
0.0021697169,
0.0179903768,
0.0085782707,
0.013126458,
0.0096214013,
-0.0318608806,
0.082385622,
-0.0277430378,
0.0002735045,
-0.0247160643,
0.0592663959,
0.018828107,
-0.0415009707,
0.0435732082,
0.0542602986,
-0.0180867203,
0.0506208129,
0.0000019783,
-0.0214038473,
0.0147134271,
-0.0435152464,
-0.0124731334,
-0.0119853113,
-0.0236948933,
0.0240258016,
0.0145643111,
0.027929889,
-0.0324037559,
0.0107909851,
0.0435216054,
0.0611979179,
0.076128222,
0.1132263467,
-0.0146452589,
-0.0488377474,
0.0269793719,
-0.0614673458,
0.0398123041,
-0.0076223859,
0.0063855564,
-0.010930459,
-0.0284407865,
-0.0507305041,
0.0054012267,
-0.0196527094,
0.0381337106,
-0.0498092957,
0.0731433555,
0.0129233645,
0.0062543587,
-0.0196174011,
-0.0112064974,
0.1427638382,
0.0375050865,
0.006104934,
0.0255528707,
-0.0286456514,
0.0302608479,
-0.0384054594,
-0.0481399335,
-0.0074131447,
-0.0067001889,
0.0055224355,
-0.0033081542,
0.040341191,
0.0392410457,
0.0426250808,
-0.0040943115,
0.0250476617,
0.0069128894,
0.0009513219,
-0.0241654664,
0.0048215711,
-0.0092567811,
-0.0361102931,
0.008771047,
0.0116641102,
-0.0868043751,
-0.0088495286,
-0.0274906401,
0.0280873142,
0.0280322414,
-0.0336537845,
0.036029093,
0.0345281772,
-0.0071233697,
0.0093783643,
-0.0031516547,
0.0294057392,
-0.0247586723,
0.0401325449,
0.0169798788,
0.04105708,
-0.0106685432,
-0.0019757019,
-0.0304059312,
-0.0134592904,
-0.0515869111,
-0.0283881966,
-0.0452217199,
0.0167839732,
-0.0288727209,
-0.0214558784,
0.0139776831,
0.0396892726,
-0.043588724,
-0.0006575357,
0.0025348195,
0.0163814295,
-0.0556163006,
0.0416740626,
0.0628115013,
-0.0653875619,
-0.046218954,
0.031917695,
0.0276997238,
-0.0184628498,
-0.0022507121,
0.0727242678,
0.0050819237,
-0.0183158498,
-0.0186877865,
-0.057291232,
-0.0193251725,
-0.0408476107,
-0.0009315006,
-0.0152442353,
0.0197782423,
-0.0179519001,
-0.0171927381,
-0.020051809,
0.0296582822,
-0.0173990168,
-0.0354612246,
0.0265787728,
0.0225952584,
-0.0132610593,
0.0401744582,
-0.0071962141,
0.0103089921,
0.0534532703,
0.0268294867,
0.0237626117,
-0.0117039066,
0.0046916497,
0.0021541254,
-0.0115733054,
0.0851261765,
-0.0160397924,
-0.0005983391,
-0.019990392,
-0.0626001209,
0.0439555347,
0.0113120703,
0.0191110298,
-0.0717303455,
-0.0369173549,
0.0592931435,
-0.018855745,
-0.0355221182,
0.0047560367,
0.0121314162,
-0.0090535507,
-0.0157152154,
-0.0089836437,
-0.0347649679,
0.0363653302,
0.0298856422,
-0.0128866713,
0.0767805353,
-0.0061343205,
-0.0400495641,
-0.0437266342,
0.0440151282,
-0.0069051865,
0.0311991572,
-0.0325776003,
-0.0013188387,
0.039619796,
-0.0591159202,
0.0230958648,
0.0064233132,
-0.0525473505,
-0.0274398793,
-0.011207195,
-0.0084381057,
0.0355468951,
0.0597138852,
-0.005905713,
-0.0648244023,
-0.0479941554,
0.0071647624,
0.0471228585,
0.0142333694,
-0.0155942822,
0.0540756322,
-0.0659381896,
0.0094802007,
-0.0121817701,
0.0060521136,
0.0314627513,
0.0070635709,
-0.0353903733,
0.0139506105,
0.028244378,
-0.018379977,
0.0025520253,
-0.0106738117,
-0.006908671,
0.0158061236,
-0.0172169209,
0.0427045301,
-0.0032093681,
-0.0158633739,
0.0205395352,
-0.0054290676,
-0.0352109298,
-0.0635151267,
0.054273963,
-0.0884220153,
-0.0564621948,
0.0078697652,
-0.0402606204,
-0.0099338489,
0.0402636155,
-0.0538191758,
-0.0570748821,
0.0712909177,
-0.0481446609,
0.0252421349,
-0.0368980132,
0.0086814854,
0.0547316484,
0.0235530697,
0.0146199754,
0.017839497,
-0.0211620927,
-0.02525899,
0.0035719173,
0.0358212739,
0.0025539564,
-0.0668024123,
0.0129259052,
0.0100887287,
-0.03275178,
0.006340581,
0.0499151722,
0.0010746721,
-0.0563856028,
-0.0046603861,
-0.0897307694,
0.0166451801,
-0.0141141824,
-0.0177868642,
0.0258531366,
0.0353285,
0.0078396136,
-0.0583873093,
-0.0528738908,
0.024924241,
0.0181288905,
-0.0012755162,
0.0450463034,
0.0053846692,
-0.0102299592,
-0.0614381395,
0.0064966218,
-0.008398883,
0.0675974339,
0.0158347283,
-0.0168456472,
-0.0226106066,
-0.0149792228,
-0.0224354789,
0.015010424,
-0.0314219072,
-0.0756708458,
-0.0067201401,
0.0212945975,
0.0303084869,
0.0757340193,
0.0303467903,
0.0268680491,
-0.0504578128,
-0.0108575784,
-0.0450602993,
0.0259748884,
-0.0450099036,
0.019277459,
-0.0059115659,
-0.0397215523,
-0.0036183777,
0.0569095127,
0.0045189476,
0.02952132,
-0.0523696691,
0.0127026234,
0.0381067581,
-0.0405362099,
-0.0213737674,
-0.0322340168,
-0.0418764539,
-0.0064385221,
-0.0573015511,
-0.0691115409,
0.0632944554,
0.0118999071,
-0.0082500409,
-0.0143914334,
-0.0001617267,
-0.0375410058,
0.0137514714,
0.0466382615,
0.0094837509,
0.0116595849,
-0.0412546881,
-0.0385818742,
-0.0009923099,
0.0308534019,
0.0095055206,
0.0096776253,
-0.0446920693,
0.0184744187,
0.0019913742,
-0.0546274297,
-0.0582824834,
-0.0507080331,
0.0174726006,
-0.0131799271,
0.0467256382,
-0.0407854989,
-0.021065224,
-0.0320209526,
-0.008934373,
0.0590403005,
-0.0397954173,
0.0151908435,
-0.0106570432,
0.0378135964,
0.0418250337,
-0.01467543,
0.0051503326,
-0.0395702757,
0.0563695617,
0.0226408336,
0.0162143316,
-0.0143945916,
-0.0416804105,
0.0059788581,
-0.0344757438,
0.0192678217,
0.003242085,
-0.0067067519,
0.072300598,
-0.038979616,
0.0090233646,
0.0635457635,
0.019348558,
-0.0369774438,
0.00353583,
0.0112113301,
0.0577591956,
0.0027295949,
-0.0140999034,
-0.1151532382,
-0.0343011804,
-0.0119000776,
0.0162891261,
-0.0211027488,
-0.0351814926,
0.0135077406,
-0.0676086619,
0.004284218,
0.0119295642,
-0.047738865,
0.024650652,
0.001746643,
-0.0184792615,
-0.0309320334,
-0.0067714397,
-0.0165087841,
0.0312747955,
-0.005311517,
0.0397538617,
-0.0075474354,
-0.0035343016,
-0.0180847179,
0.0035249104,
0.0915449038,
0.0487787686,
0.0586135387,
0.0302391257,
0.028019188,
0.0665703937,
0.0279223006,
0.0085091861,
-0.0069439569,
0.0776141509,
0.0452513508,
-0.0168088656,
-0.0099376272,
0.0812026337,
-0.0287575368,
-0.0312538333,
-0.012889565,
0.013832449,
-0.0178303979,
0.0068603554,
0.0004267177,
0.0514594391,
0.0300820116,
0.0357453302,
0.0504412577,
-0.0204939526,
-0.0839674622,
-0.0138320839,
0.0096772304,
-0.0922447369,
-0.020555824,
-0.0220687035,
0.0482697263,
-0.0307833906,
-0.1003479734,
-0.0777349919,
-0.046123907,
-0.0031040031,
-0.0431252047,
-0.0337797962,
-0.0092570428,
-0.0055695209,
-0.0136707807,
0.0539642721,
0.0021245105,
0.015402779,
-0.0547643453,
-0.010497326,
-0.0024145108,
-0.0257428419,
-0.00623975,
0.0698255152,
-0.0987349972,
-0.0885008201,
-0.0120256143,
0.0417841971,
0.0241694059,
0.085966289,
-0.0054464326,
-0.0454015434,
-0.0121980747,
0.0047289343,
-0.0101275127,
0.0064950353,
0.0583902597,
0.0350097083,
-0.0228883233,
0.043573793,
-0.015627306,
0.0485041626,
0.0009377324,
0.0582282506,
-0.0360752866,
-0.0230667479,
0.0030233369,
-0.0213815495,
0.0398498587,
-0.0034313197,
-0.0139585296,
-0.0222029369,
0.024897065,
-0.0229746532,
0.0079264939,
-0.05325488,
0.0035141627,
0.0068089664,
0.0083188685,
-0.0159283355,
-0.0634963959,
-0.032696493,
0.0446219109,
-0.0050045135,
0.0211429261,
-0.0162081812,
0.004788355,
0.016501274,
0.0100779459,
-0.0104090916,
0.0235308465,
0.0360422581,
0.0355213769,
-0.005630149,
0.0963535458,
0.0369773731,
0.0019455546,
0.0122100273,
0.0025234281,
-0.0843277648,
-0.0092603555,
-0.016747443,
-0.0059933867,
0.0357837975,
0.0169300493,
0.0552487001,
-0.0104255434,
0.0352541767,
-0.0033385514,
0.1014154851,
0.0110460175,
-0.001797853,
0.0128533188,
0.0085212467,
-0.0227988195,
0.0216128565,
0.0809192285,
0.0016204815,
0.0462616161,
-0.0227880757,
0.0295446012,
-0.0259131715,
-0.0512067527,
0.0080953371,
0.0028932514,
-0.002964789,
0.0116391135,
-0.0425041467,
-0.0425726697,
-0.031106893,
-0.0080390461,
0.049808681,
-0.0087921014,
0.0435817912,
-0.0077120382,
-0.024388101,
-0.0102754198,
-0.0176580157,
0.0160232354,
-0.0431766883,
-0.0227529872,
-0.0249181874,
-6.569679235e-33,
-0.0044018254,
-0.0089714453,
0.0085827438,
0.0114074778,
-0.0333724283,
0.0120103993,
-0.0725397095,
-0.0041093286,
-0.0083688889,
0.0227665082,
0.0259012822,
0.0584703125,
0.006420088,
0.0596934035,
-0.0148879737,
-0.0085900715,
0.0626974478,
0.0088556828,
-0.0079063717,
0.0843221396,
0.0409501866,
0.0223598983,
0.005577242,
-0.0819807127,
0.0092201838,
-0.0034863285,
-0.0105394246,
0.0100465249,
-0.0047928998,
0.0213221088,
-0.009786251,
0.0171428025,
0.0116021736,
-0.039857775,
-0.0098862397,
0.0080015231,
-0.030716585,
-0.0278979875,
-0.0045238091,
-0.0004908759,
-0.0481220223,
-0.0674860775,
0.0013852761,
-0.0283504352,
0.0372386202,
-0.0153782079,
0.0115113659,
0.0071992003,
-0.02050611,
0.0020175686,
-0.0448058061,
0.0378070809,
-0.0549168959,
-0.0433936566,
-0.0636264309,
0.0439523123,
-0.0003746662,
-0.0224318691,
0.0015239425,
0.0210914444,
-0.0161951836,
-0.0340885483,
0.000253384,
0.02911699,
-0.0038876422,
0.0708439574,
0.0479672551,
0.0295461472,
-0.0435188711,
-0.0242888238,
-0.0402394794,
0.0509658791,
0.0347394869,
0.0517099649,
0.0286097024,
-0.016074039,
-0.0917869806,
0.0149820745,
0.0396342613,
0.0055140345,
0.0069094007,
-0.0030961551,
-0.0102749001,
-0.0287664086,
-0.0202870369,
-0.0276237801,
-0.0221456364,
-0.0117166108,
0.0180287529,
0.0359716862,
0.017645061,
-0.019979842,
0.0368382819,
-0.0343708098,
0.0168185458,
0.0743380785,
-0.0232583284,
0.0137273595,
-0.0009163661,
0.0078214407,
-0.0632112399,
0.0009966023,
0.0525717959,
0.0404939577,
0.0489817746,
0.0059632245,
0.0596098676,
-0.0089617139,
-0.0240571219,
-0.0210682079,
-0.0562109947,
0.0327740125,
-0.0458145775,
-0.0103053562,
0.022655841,
0.0211974885,
-0.0379207656,
0.0752757639,
0.0013429597,
0.0422665328,
-0.0242311005,
-0.0547359064,
0.0053485539,
0.0176255219,
-0.0458301082,
-0.0035145837,
-0.0080851279,
-0.0059900037,
0.0044608386,
-0.0682309344,
-0.0267752819,
-0.0355882123,
2.685e-7,
-0.0033262311,
0.0335227363,
0.063238129,
0.047141172,
0.0224129278,
0.0237919837,
0.0030194817,
0.0165017303,
0.0106159626,
0.0426673703,
0.0103318896,
0.0137205785,
0.0843995661,
-0.0006765906,
-0.062780112,
0.0061608306,
-0.1253948063,
-0.0316136703,
-0.017200416,
-0.0605231635,
0.0363033973,
0.0331275091,
-0.0014050852,
-0.016895825,
0.0312385224,
-0.0049843378,
0.0782723278,
-0.0390528999,
0.0038836959,
-0.0020585519,
0.0159720331,
-0.0146157341,
-0.0095940856,
0.0009733693,
-0.0329959765,
0.0096185254,
-0.0256042052,
0.0221155901,
-0.015831707,
-0.0705774501,
-0.0005878272,
-0.0125220753,
0.0433246754,
-0.0249901544,
0.0116273761,
-0.0464926213,
-0.0221045967,
0.0274222065,
-0.0413545519,
0.0276223589,
0.0416042842,
-0.0300770309,
-0.0330834612,
0.0227114726,
0.0051911133,
0.0071949423,
0.0290461257,
-0.0723073706,
-0.033194229,
0.0040693912,
-0.0318816043,
-0.0579054989,
-0.0592169426,
0.0153056504,
-0.0075473948,
0.0148217892,
0.0029125395,
2.075064591e-34,
0.0403405316,
-0.0167053584,
0.002461493,
0.0142406207,
0.050176546,
-0.0168953799,
0.0013995833,
0.0130445892,
0.0687511712,
-0.0414890163,
-0.0189081319
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10511v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10511v4 | When Not to Trust Language Models: Investigating Effectiveness of Parametric and Non-Parametric Memories | 2022-12-20T18:30:15 | 2023-07-02T07:21:59 | Alex Mallen, Akari Asai, Victor Zhong, Rajarshi Das, Daniel Khashabi, Hannaneh Hajishirzi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Despite their impressive performance on diverse tasks, large language models
(LMs) still struggle with tasks requiring rich world knowledge, implying the
limitations of relying solely on their parameters to encode a wealth of world
knowledge. This paper aims to understand LMs' strengths and limitations in
memorizing factual knowledge, by conducting large-scale knowledge probing
experiments of 10 models and 4 augmentation methods on PopQA, our new
open-domain QA dataset with 14k questions. We find that LMs struggle with less
popular factual knowledge, and that scaling fails to appreciably improve
memorization of factual knowledge in the long tail. We then show that
retrieval-augmented LMs largely outperform orders of magnitude larger LMs,
while unassisted LMs remain competitive in questions about high-popularity
entities. Based on those findings, we devise a simple, yet effective, method
for powerful and efficient retrieval-augmented LMs, which retrieves
non-parametric memories only when necessary. Experimental results show that
this significantly improves models' performance while reducing the inference
costs. | [
0.0451836176,
0.0590191558,
-0.0209336318,
0.0339605995,
-0.0151283033,
0.0031127112,
-0.0154772177,
-0.0115643675,
0.0313854106,
-0.056187842,
-0.0330581851,
-0.0563780405,
-0.0218236074,
0.0390339009,
0.0261919759,
-0.0143249808,
0.0411733501,
-0.0238261539,
0.0043947864,
-0.0141838863,
-0.0146192415,
-0.0170739926,
-0.0049174675,
-0.000775215,
0.0016107718,
-0.0116768945,
-0.0084765302,
-0.0255816467,
0.0073755551,
-0.0192824434,
0.0096753798,
0.0471172743,
0.0375991017,
0.0405822806,
0.0000020501,
-0.0515044406,
-0.0149281379,
-0.0288940761,
-0.0706709176,
0.0566409677,
-0.0067679058,
0.031180799,
0.0360068344,
0.0074142548,
-0.0478002317,
-0.0315323658,
0.0213861931,
0.0283472147,
0.0430136435,
0.0540243946,
0.0133177461,
0.0011983705,
0.0284844711,
-0.0423096232,
0.0367888547,
-0.0469865985,
0.0557668656,
-0.0086279623,
-0.026404446,
0.044689931,
-0.0179272089,
0.0321860872,
0.0347338691,
0.03192598,
0.0107523017,
0.0490998998,
-0.018464243,
0.0108685559,
0.0139789674,
0.0718118921,
0.0334303305,
-0.0290103722,
-0.0078739058,
0.0187599398,
0.0029110285,
0.0375996456,
-0.0755404383,
0.0110016996,
0.002048854,
-0.0156094534,
-0.0228580665,
-0.0071976506,
0.0428551026,
0.0143758701,
-0.037407469,
0.0450917296,
0.0285237506,
-0.0405489765,
0.0007136813,
0.0134605747,
-0.036318142,
-0.0211885422,
0.0102154724,
0.0193130467,
0.014292839,
0.0542861447,
0.0023552862,
-0.0020417527,
0.0567522235,
-0.045850236,
-0.0000841535,
0.0199181661,
-0.0293215178,
0.0634048209,
-0.0431912169,
0.0727626532,
-0.0089785829,
0.0210885871,
-0.0155650685,
-0.0159640536,
-0.0621133074,
-0.0306192674,
0.0000829688,
0.0461114012,
0.0210715327,
0.0273670908,
-0.0243311636,
0.0094652846,
0.0023877586,
0.0323741622,
-0.0109930122,
0.0151569983,
-0.0071657766,
-0.0089220768,
-0.0651525632,
0.0608903877,
-0.0527324416,
0.018254932,
0.0157236774,
-0.0652722269,
-0.0439565778,
-0.024679549,
0.0223675128,
-0.01976965,
0.0082382523,
0.0079424344,
-0.0096948873,
-0.0668428391,
-0.0417710319,
-0.0298028328,
-0.0008131602,
-0.0623895265,
0.0178535897,
-0.0469785109,
0.0419946238,
0.0090964464,
-0.0061672125,
-0.0286437012,
0.0215687267,
0.0419865102,
-0.0508942604,
0.0361199304,
0.055839207,
-0.0057048788,
0.0211976506,
0.040947888,
0.0088552693,
0.0652906373,
0.0019177668,
0.0141368527,
0.0455771387,
-0.0061299293,
0.0204495396,
0.0130910734,
0.0515324213,
0.0104913665,
-0.0040936591,
0.0417172424,
0.0284490362,
0.0028019755,
0.0224126093,
0.0395822786,
-0.0249022115,
-0.0579223782,
0.0682192296,
0.0287324376,
-0.0155141773,
0.0029814548,
0.0100411261,
-0.0300142597,
0.0469558537,
0.0140316347,
-0.0511423461,
0.0188855734,
-0.0246255379,
0.013941017,
0.0079949163,
0.0324229896,
-0.0506846122,
-0.0263597686,
-0.0128483875,
0.0066366293,
-0.0077364715,
0.0539082102,
0.0447315574,
0.0061296048,
-0.03298885,
0.0894248337,
0.0108016143,
-0.0431054421,
-0.0051034829,
-0.0321360603,
0.0382568426,
-0.0126099344,
0.0442653112,
-0.0525576398,
-0.0336101577,
0.0056088991,
-0.001769321,
0.0092026452,
0.0627518147,
-0.0045665656,
-0.0074985763,
-0.0534129776,
0.0050425543,
-0.0218505785,
0.0444959961,
0.0231298655,
0.0623326376,
0.0376658924,
0.0229412429,
-0.0741067976,
-0.0023620981,
-0.0036045962,
-0.0541771352,
-0.0781622455,
-0.007548105,
-0.0016347611,
-0.028022958,
0.0196454283,
-0.0004204837,
0.0310884807,
0.0496973172,
-0.0295961443,
-0.0190122761,
-0.0177052636,
-0.0456761569,
-0.0464223698,
0.0059258617,
0.0324132778,
-0.0086199958,
0.0458094403,
-0.0256488416,
-0.0443058461,
0.0323253721,
0.0031270445,
0.0881819203,
-0.0389622636,
0.0073114927,
-0.0193370339,
0.0030843418,
-0.0309130996,
0.0945802331,
-0.0198676623,
0.0171975587,
-0.0185225792,
0.0091178454,
0.0017822054,
-0.0342708305,
-0.0250121336,
0.0027635866,
-0.0061687352,
0.0256272797,
0.0098467432,
-0.0585480854,
-0.0855658129,
-0.0114852907,
-0.0942889974,
0.0258706473,
-0.0192376729,
-0.0042376043,
-0.0006148999,
0.0053792712,
-0.0184450746,
-0.0375363715,
-0.0514798835,
-0.0069457237,
-0.0252160877,
0.0662646592,
-0.0001500378,
0.0319040753,
0.0339478664,
-0.0438697897,
-0.0150109725,
-0.0203222893,
0.0568826795,
-0.0148250181,
0.0335921273,
0.0122658014,
0.030919442,
-0.08441329,
0.0099394154,
-0.0407816172,
-0.0015365422,
-0.0174552146,
-0.0209758822,
0.0378261954,
0.0953299627,
0.0077323397,
-0.0195473786,
0.0526232198,
0.0001079531,
-0.0532456227,
0.0196294095,
-0.0211811867,
-0.0628370866,
0.028022781,
-0.0176281258,
0.0011919709,
0.0512549505,
0.0047960836,
-0.0040220553,
-0.0307538863,
0.0381279439,
-0.0175794661,
-0.0141759273,
-0.07243222,
0.0174931567,
-0.0232877694,
0.0382916704,
-0.0262075365,
-0.0252957847,
0.0639849454,
-0.006911187,
0.0067296387,
-0.0218766034,
0.0164866783,
-0.0259302966,
0.0585041009,
-0.0003964212,
-0.0046068812,
0.001374984,
-0.0360033549,
-0.0562592298,
-0.0090249013,
0.0087647624,
-0.080714792,
0.0319432653,
-0.0225127172,
0.0010722559,
0.0091433264,
-0.0496670827,
-0.094759047,
-0.0152678061,
-0.0256739501,
-0.0131276287,
-0.0375299901,
-0.0070599066,
-0.0233887378,
-0.0237991083,
0.0549367666,
0.005830409,
-0.0239765812,
0.0001354361,
0.004933659,
0.0426074453,
0.0806769654,
0.0190180652,
0.0384728797,
-0.0393886007,
0.0109302271,
0.0507196039,
0.0601948015,
-0.0286259782,
0.0237682182,
-0.013425176,
-0.003738872,
-0.0390894338,
-0.0080915,
0.0127707273,
0.0263317581,
-0.0662034824,
-0.0277628135,
0.1056036651,
0.0406082943,
-0.0255514644,
-0.0278446171,
-0.0238188114,
0.0456432104,
0.0266047232,
0.011699615,
-0.0870803595,
-0.0001760953,
-0.0059355586,
0.0237287544,
0.0024096298,
-0.0349549279,
-0.0054751118,
-0.1435242891,
-0.0009836029,
-0.0031833288,
-0.0114824343,
-0.0292277597,
-0.0476440787,
-0.0026375586,
-0.0080971569,
0.0264681801,
0.0371620841,
-0.0092147756,
0.0073501035,
0.0149465827,
0.0070502772,
-0.0213184934,
0.0645314604,
-0.0259595904,
0.0391090326,
0.0134303235,
0.0211331025,
-0.0034251343,
-0.0530202873,
-0.0110836821,
-0.002399592,
0.0049308157,
0.0099695614,
0.0612243302,
-0.015531214,
-0.0092805428,
-0.0154237794,
0.0186225846,
-0.0193901453,
-0.0097097801,
0.0242272113,
0.0575676858,
0.0051225624,
-0.0272002388,
0.0084393369,
-0.0169150289,
-0.028988095,
0.0973833874,
0.0326069891,
-0.0019602755,
-0.011015296,
-0.0168553945,
0.0174574517,
-0.0160871148,
-0.0450454056,
0.0316109955,
0.0104750507,
0.0032448499,
-0.0755825788,
-0.0434324183,
0.0359374434,
0.036711935,
-0.0067401873,
0.0175860971,
0.0297013409,
-0.0071247942,
-0.0537241884,
0.0396644585,
-0.0724016204,
-0.0378516614,
-0.0169456303,
-0.0004317429,
0.0424339212,
-0.0186219122,
-0.0179791898,
-0.0219417084,
-0.0924902782,
-0.0517634638,
0.0185493734,
0.045526851,
0.0259027239,
0.046856977,
-0.0017535989,
-0.0223504975,
0.0430470631,
0.0051442753,
-0.0453397408,
0.0309675448,
0.013993076,
0.0073209875,
-0.016748907,
0.0384505391,
-0.0537803955,
-0.0235921796,
0.0077294204,
0.0473387986,
-0.0197314285,
-0.0219697505,
0.0264939722,
0.0126016038,
0.0528506413,
0.0550405011,
-0.0033323034,
-0.0256441012,
0.0235702768,
-0.0192080438,
0.0009857389,
0.0142698046,
0.0032354852,
0.0274301097,
-0.0113427648,
-0.0037034822,
-0.043404486,
-0.0089036133,
0.0804565996,
-0.0430229306,
-0.0345956422,
-0.0030810309,
-0.0181259401,
0.0373990275,
0.0000729889,
-0.0385229476,
0.0285716392,
0.0056669586,
0.0751943216,
-0.0129246134,
0.0590843409,
-0.008107366,
-0.0165336225,
-0.0213705748,
-0.0250900388,
-0.08498016,
-0.0769328028,
0.0242157001,
0.0387073196,
0.0483253598,
-0.0535935722,
-0.0015437568,
-0.0334932916,
-0.0017943779,
-0.008682888,
-0.0303927194,
0.0118352668,
-0.009658522,
0.0361462571,
0.036615748,
-0.0106931562,
0.0407605022,
0.0788609013,
0.0057816957,
0.0558895804,
0.0049418532,
0.0043831104,
-0.0257908106,
-0.0220880024,
0.0193662196,
0.0359939374,
-0.0266768057,
0.0146874068,
-0.0903597176,
-0.0714663491,
0.0193021167,
-0.0268888865,
-0.0296219978,
-0.0119276438,
0.0157413799,
0.0565879382,
-0.0172054544,
-0.0093197627,
-0.0503623188,
0.0484252274,
-0.0328759216,
-0.0046548815,
0.011597326,
-7.03848328e-33,
0.0015200988,
0.0082810698,
0.0284643229,
-0.0383528844,
-0.0026986278,
0.0365601517,
-0.0236978717,
0.0093450574,
-0.0665001124,
-0.0177314598,
-0.0317512006,
0.0227267686,
0.0064335489,
0.0306888558,
-0.0023893199,
-0.0435911641,
0.0457741804,
0.0051895594,
-0.0273627304,
0.0342365317,
0.063363269,
0.0508203879,
0.0577950291,
-0.0337918103,
0.044753544,
-0.0102099245,
0.0513457395,
0.027104402,
-0.0224993788,
0.0578599758,
-0.0196383689,
0.047277946,
0.0138848154,
-0.053487815,
0.0099861445,
0.0131557733,
-0.0855171606,
-0.0493887141,
0.0338143483,
-0.0102747204,
-0.0140333138,
-0.0175674502,
0.0278689116,
-0.0174025632,
0.0198900104,
-0.0201159474,
0.0108694164,
-0.012146594,
-0.0377532095,
-0.0022454245,
0.0004865254,
-0.0004476876,
0.0131339673,
-0.0039003938,
-0.0313027278,
0.0179613046,
0.0236708354,
0.0504130572,
-0.0813676938,
-0.0024430307,
0.018640466,
0.0264206249,
0.0462053791,
0.021780245,
0.0213467702,
0.0775174275,
-0.0150142126,
0.0309520345,
-0.0309943408,
-0.0027051745,
0.0353012346,
0.0033249499,
0.0336882733,
0.0622722358,
0.0414441675,
-0.0131985191,
-0.0655791089,
0.0027991638,
0.0269921217,
0.0348179787,
0.0240659956,
-0.0024442377,
-0.0494222157,
-0.0069994098,
-0.0729811788,
0.0623866841,
-0.0624033548,
-0.0108513422,
0.0370244607,
0.0283290278,
-0.0425771289,
-0.018794639,
0.0183706656,
-0.0168763548,
-0.0156374499,
0.0388262235,
-0.0016881096,
-0.0144935027,
-0.0231255237,
0.0391266532,
-0.0741099492,
0.0264446139,
-0.0002684529,
-0.0078624208,
-0.017672319,
0.0261032674,
0.0076765884,
-0.0115004089,
-0.0666002929,
-0.0113974409,
-0.0298284553,
0.0074236388,
0.0101473629,
-0.0102719702,
0.0350952856,
0.0527492352,
0.0128553957,
0.0367971249,
0.0387801602,
-0.0128542501,
-0.0387848541,
-0.0118082007,
-0.0154246921,
0.010963032,
-0.0231727511,
-0.0241223965,
-0.0134550622,
0.0152527476,
0.0273918025,
-0.049513001,
0.0200056508,
0.0049764444,
2.769e-7,
0.0066571734,
0.0576147437,
-0.0026929502,
0.0070826774,
-0.0142595861,
0.0417927019,
-0.0176733714,
0.0303061903,
0.0491193756,
-0.0563717335,
-0.0392517708,
0.0499169528,
0.0209930148,
0.0211085714,
-0.1071631908,
-0.0249730125,
-0.0757452995,
-0.0220701993,
-0.0532592274,
-0.0341874063,
0.0311741233,
0.1068353578,
0.0313280486,
-0.0013290643,
0.0084933797,
-0.0617167018,
0.0826736838,
-0.0087359231,
-0.0540449247,
0.0120063825,
0.0373350605,
0.0585728101,
0.0182696432,
0.045474425,
-0.0148035763,
0.0157009009,
0.005580165,
0.0412682928,
0.0461952016,
-0.0626901835,
-0.0373141132,
-0.0137035754,
-0.0031046963,
-0.0889165029,
0.091536656,
-0.0291565415,
-0.0275127646,
-0.0049908534,
-0.0164300054,
0.0039695697,
0.0412535816,
-0.0049451599,
-0.0240170136,
-0.0004445356,
-0.0296242107,
0.0207856316,
0.0173843186,
-0.0629593655,
-0.0316202641,
0.0062009697,
-0.0123864524,
-0.078677617,
-0.0268476196,
-0.0457231775,
-0.0242307112,
-0.0717439502,
0.020942973,
2.610882467e-34,
0.0224482827,
-0.004301406,
0.019396212,
0.0250597931,
0.0309344307,
-0.0252070092,
-0.003353521,
0.007769784,
0.0250387844,
-0.0965172723,
0.0064888312
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10509v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10509v2 | Interleaving Retrieval with Chain-of-Thought Reasoning for Knowledge-Intensive Multi-Step Questions | 2022-12-20T18:26:34 | 2023-06-23T00:59:13 | Harsh Trivedi, Niranjan Balasubramanian, Tushar Khot, Ashish Sabharwal | cs.CL | cs.CL | Prompting-based large language models (LLMs) are surprisingly powerful at
generating natural language reasoning steps or Chains-of-Thoughts (CoT) for
multi-step question answering (QA). They struggle, however, when the necessary
knowledge is either unavailable to the LLM or not up-to-date within its
parameters. While using the question to retrieve relevant text from an external
knowledge source helps LLMs, we observe that this one-step retrieve-and-read
approach is insufficient for multi-step QA. Here, \textit{what to retrieve}
depends on \textit{what has already been derived}, which in turn may depend on
\textit{what was previously retrieved}. To address this, we propose IRCoT, a
new approach for multi-step QA that interleaves retrieval with steps
(sentences) in a CoT, guiding the retrieval with CoT and in turn using
retrieved results to improve CoT. Using IRCoT with GPT3 substantially improves
retrieval (up to 21 points) as well as downstream QA (up to 15 points) on four
datasets: HotpotQA, 2WikiMultihopQA, MuSiQue, and IIRC. We observe similar
substantial gains in out-of-distribution (OOD) settings as well as with much
smaller models such as Flan-T5-large without additional training. IRCoT reduces
model hallucination, resulting in factually more accurate CoT reasoning. Code,
data, and prompts are available at \url{https://github.com/stonybrooknlp/ircot} | [
0.0273283552,
0.0087085497,
-0.0027833662,
0.0399926193,
-0.0627708882,
0.0166091491,
-0.0191315617,
-0.0391205661,
0.0235655755,
-0.0123649146,
-0.019442901,
-0.0200343058,
-0.0186773594,
-0.0024925021,
0.0093244938,
-0.0380370915,
0.0517108105,
-0.0610092916,
0.0007616109,
-0.0250386428,
-0.0114076277,
0.0268753283,
-0.0272107422,
0.0136669902,
0.0077228476,
-0.0659338161,
-0.0374125205,
-0.0022449975,
0.0206217524,
-0.0053672474,
0.0192161296,
0.0545924567,
0.0258226786,
0.0272112433,
0.0000020991,
-0.0574919321,
-0.0290475003,
-0.0127591202,
-0.0346094407,
-0.0040663849,
-0.0343503393,
0.0459086224,
0.036326915,
0.0336656831,
-0.0354196765,
0.0108344425,
-0.0027101466,
0.0483101942,
0.0528403781,
0.0595489778,
0.0218234621,
-0.0488961339,
0.0125283068,
-0.0005157108,
0.0361081734,
-0.0321935154,
0.0275803842,
0.0029291392,
0.0477170385,
0.0436561927,
-0.0126541443,
0.0624754764,
0.0440454595,
0.0213278569,
-0.0156335086,
0.0279422812,
-0.0556536615,
-0.0178625528,
-0.0184205025,
0.0713163167,
0.0224461015,
-0.0112308757,
-0.0088116582,
0.0348656252,
0.0186103955,
-0.0019886561,
-0.0761214718,
0.0290948339,
-0.0330316536,
-0.0206007827,
-0.0104486654,
-0.0026848365,
0.0074451631,
0.0265001617,
-0.0478739664,
0.0677029863,
0.0012987383,
-0.0447352305,
0.0271080323,
-0.0026664995,
-0.0108917048,
-0.033786837,
0.0158754345,
0.0524274036,
-0.0192028936,
0.0145435948,
0.04407138,
0.0082934154,
0.0264937654,
-0.0034242738,
-0.0151577638,
0.0363928899,
-0.0585671067,
0.0665311068,
-0.0117762657,
0.0007035776,
-0.0367741175,
0.021398684,
-0.0521697924,
-0.0148131475,
-0.0520171188,
-0.0530290715,
-0.066740945,
0.0626654699,
-0.0200752132,
-0.010616038,
0.0166646261,
0.0042506964,
-0.0004820457,
-0.0171390418,
0.0290200002,
0.0238745846,
0.0151572153,
-0.0055233748,
-0.0341924503,
0.069651857,
-0.0637296513,
0.0341548324,
0.0429710224,
-0.045512449,
-0.0468689054,
-0.0194375906,
0.009471003,
-0.020219408,
0.0261374265,
0.0069058188,
-0.010162144,
-0.0225732923,
-0.0201122947,
-0.0487184189,
-0.0150866229,
-0.0911328271,
0.0219085794,
-0.0929855481,
0.0374607034,
0.0112542482,
-0.0215095282,
0.0131267635,
0.0070890146,
0.0622784868,
-0.0407281667,
0.0394833684,
0.0173465721,
0.0226298701,
0.014501919,
0.034864381,
-0.0269483868,
0.0500642322,
0.0111747356,
-0.0158882085,
0.0279190224,
0.020819677,
0.0173612926,
0.0300338827,
0.0154067306,
-0.0136187589,
0.0166735686,
0.0630354956,
0.0293287039,
0.0247817729,
0.0211279262,
0.0437624119,
-0.0270249639,
0.0169016197,
0.0221706927,
0.0353536382,
0.0049624131,
-0.0085185952,
0.0417273976,
0.0351618528,
0.0271172058,
0.031728778,
-0.0124944514,
0.0501663461,
-0.0546083748,
0.0194473825,
0.0462778024,
0.0397191867,
-0.0417803079,
-0.0117914164,
0.0118845003,
0.025639426,
-0.0125888521,
0.0768571347,
0.0353872888,
0.0174310859,
-0.032086093,
0.0303797945,
0.0145217562,
-0.0154674146,
-0.0234484505,
-0.0462071523,
0.0328569636,
0.0577878244,
0.0375644192,
-0.022262441,
0.0087764002,
-0.0036244695,
0.0222698636,
0.0123537788,
-0.0172489826,
-0.0137943234,
-0.0193183944,
-0.0256232899,
-0.0062626684,
-0.0173134487,
0.0045459964,
0.0062346081,
-0.001359418,
0.0083140871,
-0.0025663166,
0.0035911377,
0.028653292,
-0.0092369746,
-0.0167538282,
-0.022207845,
-0.0194358975,
0.0015610834,
-0.0019971686,
0.037758261,
0.007673074,
0.0374303535,
0.0199365169,
-0.0238507744,
-0.041002024,
-0.0032833647,
-0.0408197381,
-0.0849510208,
0.0209298003,
0.0181866847,
-0.0258604065,
-0.0065511838,
-0.0300326794,
-0.0391547643,
-0.0099517703,
-0.009389949,
0.0186210629,
-0.0431047529,
0.0105628241,
0.0330127552,
-0.0121555589,
-0.0454319715,
0.1025513783,
-0.0101947952,
0.0283284523,
0.0251334012,
-0.0217419472,
0.0052138832,
-0.0299205016,
0.0172315016,
0.038426917,
0.0034474155,
0.0045735277,
-0.0029803382,
0.028772207,
-0.0756126344,
-0.0144563923,
-0.0714506209,
0.0355319828,
-0.0308152586,
0.0014075062,
-0.001016272,
0.0100717144,
-0.0254198052,
-0.0130301928,
-0.0490545779,
-0.0182723012,
0.0346415453,
0.0319695547,
-0.0181541312,
0.0193308871,
-0.0200475268,
0.0093421806,
-0.002493174,
-0.0146361534,
0.0493835844,
-0.0402180403,
-0.0370088704,
-0.0394013189,
0.0265414361,
-0.0717596561,
-0.0021306423,
-0.0101176482,
0.0120080058,
-0.0006682885,
-0.0356517471,
0.0556042306,
0.0432016291,
-0.0120511921,
-0.0455093943,
0.0490316674,
-0.0308351871,
-0.0432115905,
0.0457818285,
-0.018712759,
-0.0511807054,
0.0252995621,
-0.0034254985,
-0.0192231126,
0.0248825494,
0.0254729427,
-0.0128263757,
-0.0294656064,
0.0011771632,
0.0005904589,
-0.0014958181,
-0.0581457689,
0.003971796,
-0.0242919698,
0.0522497557,
-0.0236499216,
-0.0062348181,
0.0778332055,
-0.0057862597,
-0.0205279291,
-0.0996500105,
0.0110821929,
-0.051824417,
0.074608326,
-0.0245458018,
0.0068223034,
0.001120316,
-0.01908434,
-0.0667142197,
0.0022425614,
-0.0086266063,
-0.0618875809,
0.0414179228,
-0.0241990872,
0.013041961,
0.0095141437,
-0.0574019365,
-0.0356092304,
-0.0183236115,
-0.0118508786,
-0.0103715528,
-0.0489087626,
0.0163863879,
0.0222980361,
-0.0240380242,
0.0790295228,
0.0344907269,
-0.0316140912,
-0.0059927944,
0.0006111864,
0.0712651014,
0.0590190515,
-0.00035973,
0.0178240109,
-0.0086360052,
0.0510296263,
0.0600786544,
0.055013366,
-0.0088501805,
0.0371640585,
0.0032654868,
0.0328776985,
0.0020621095,
-0.0343684517,
0.0194874126,
0.0386875682,
-0.0780014619,
-0.0344864577,
0.0823122561,
0.051981315,
-0.0451084115,
-0.0165186003,
-0.0505620241,
0.0554676019,
0.0063597551,
0.02960773,
-0.0769676492,
-0.0231234431,
0.0308444798,
0.0204738379,
-0.0135164214,
-0.0058835517,
-0.0099956784,
-0.1251198649,
0.042457711,
-0.0039441432,
-0.0114155356,
-0.0262307804,
-0.0480349585,
-0.0064177099,
0.0665479749,
-0.0054907179,
0.0673141852,
-0.0225443263,
0.0155014545,
0.0042533949,
-0.0005509843,
-0.0128360027,
0.0562876314,
-0.0229021367,
-0.006807813,
0.0579802468,
0.0078337509,
0.0128958421,
-0.0563446879,
0.0136320367,
-0.0695134848,
-0.0093281567,
-0.0054458999,
0.0146726985,
0.0264874138,
0.0082753319,
-0.0524561331,
0.055014424,
-0.0165131316,
-0.0104786335,
0.028064942,
0.0906539261,
-0.0282250214,
-0.0209829081,
-0.0184768289,
0.0273340661,
-0.0248027276,
0.0826033503,
0.0276452582,
-0.0144982357,
-0.0151853403,
-0.0244073831,
-0.036303319,
-0.0152286422,
-0.0519292764,
0.0572836623,
0.0432360992,
0.0381239355,
-0.059347976,
-0.0539218932,
0.0309880879,
0.0728746206,
-0.0138696842,
0.0794610083,
-0.0256194416,
0.0286282841,
-0.0196910258,
0.0594728366,
-0.0581167154,
-0.0028267757,
-0.0068981205,
-0.0030537643,
0.0276231319,
-0.0330811404,
-0.0326514989,
0.0293712486,
-0.0657344684,
-0.0351522937,
-0.0391246304,
0.032918714,
0.0315561593,
0.0477863811,
-0.0010105487,
0.0002746286,
0.0181057788,
0.0015703897,
-0.017913755,
0.0085013565,
0.0018487438,
0.0331400968,
-0.0091807069,
0.0355147459,
-0.0688798279,
-0.0152438032,
-0.0242347457,
0.0974493325,
0.0114856176,
-0.0266099367,
0.0510824621,
-0.0063183196,
0.0024563866,
0.0236444026,
0.0005373233,
-0.0201542526,
0.0282346494,
-0.0271623973,
-0.0313588269,
-0.021083815,
0.0305729751,
0.0407322943,
-0.0294536967,
-0.0113582276,
-0.0268743169,
0.0352866612,
0.0128221633,
-0.0359891392,
-0.0384290703,
0.0091806427,
-0.0004871543,
0.0207873825,
-0.0304555539,
-0.0374221317,
-0.0027093957,
0.0157863889,
0.0444876477,
0.0033910295,
0.0973214805,
0.0516315214,
-0.0297281109,
-0.0521980561,
0.0121730035,
-0.0788586661,
-0.0839838386,
0.0105206696,
0.0061726752,
0.0375873931,
0.0121088428,
0.0166005008,
-0.0027513311,
-0.024389375,
-0.0129764546,
-0.0057744933,
0.0303535536,
-0.0531711355,
0.0372089483,
0.0375713855,
-0.0166342873,
0.0091652991,
0.0737342462,
-0.0380643718,
0.0346176215,
0.0046034972,
0.0009712455,
-0.0114288805,
-0.0546046235,
-0.0726482645,
0.0021825645,
-0.0009221806,
0.0120350262,
-0.0628241748,
-0.0698100179,
-0.0174811538,
-0.0237445086,
-0.0161698423,
-0.021408353,
0.0583332703,
0.0794759095,
0.0111342976,
-0.0582254902,
-0.0036789919,
-0.0006472937,
-0.0106424568,
-0.0431329682,
-0.0177819077,
-6.625936925e-33,
-0.0172248036,
-0.0101828808,
0.0542900302,
0.0128106419,
-0.048140645,
-0.0094550047,
-0.0417259634,
-0.0129395314,
-0.0367654227,
-0.0035998789,
-0.014633134,
0.0023491425,
0.0059827585,
0.02514234,
0.026566945,
-0.0360286534,
0.0040956405,
-0.0061942716,
-0.0276408754,
0.0068120821,
0.0605322346,
0.0445715114,
0.0087409858,
-0.0013293365,
0.0207729097,
-0.0348727442,
0.0081226472,
0.0625859424,
-0.051294785,
0.0376077965,
-0.0225290041,
0.0260891784,
0.0284148734,
-0.0419889092,
0.0080473507,
0.0467447191,
-0.1116556823,
-0.0196016729,
0.0322549455,
-0.011019161,
-0.049149882,
-0.0371940956,
-0.0002244374,
0.0065479963,
0.0365356915,
-0.0139479674,
0.0130031155,
-0.0235456731,
-0.0001419649,
-0.0322099216,
-0.0368346907,
-0.0066587306,
-0.0174970087,
-0.056404084,
-0.0098500429,
0.1040658429,
0.0017796636,
0.0279404074,
-0.0426322222,
-0.015202703,
-0.010024962,
0.0167239252,
0.0330171958,
-0.0078355419,
0.0132017015,
0.0297596827,
0.0084547289,
-0.0483039953,
-0.0448329076,
-0.0419605114,
0.0085231559,
0.0102025447,
0.0209049918,
0.0032800059,
0.0019427168,
0.0416838415,
-0.0692813545,
0.0003635926,
-0.0081021972,
0.0440925285,
0.0117834965,
-0.011057511,
-0.0290259011,
-0.0237658359,
-0.0447554514,
0.0267890953,
-0.0360932313,
-0.0071429466,
0.059888985,
0.0124483956,
0.0163973775,
-0.0426931754,
0.0456858426,
0.0017853919,
-0.0091867568,
0.0495835505,
-0.0380676538,
0.0330223441,
-0.0161255244,
0.0769873783,
-0.0288627446,
0.033184614,
0.0229208879,
-0.0052505299,
-0.0051262248,
0.0421509668,
0.0330553837,
0.0049460051,
-0.0576303266,
0.0003037161,
-0.0539307334,
0.030628616,
-0.0360710993,
-0.0114488378,
0.0456436649,
0.0417126194,
0.0004880788,
0.0604728423,
0.01787908,
0.0095616775,
-0.0415580198,
-0.0101276301,
-0.0252407193,
-0.0084238406,
0.0006072226,
0.041726239,
-0.0198137015,
0.0139252143,
-0.0128567033,
-0.0556438975,
-0.0112935295,
0.0660521612,
2.928e-7,
0.0110574393,
0.0047981264,
0.0213195495,
0.0428523421,
0.0035145534,
0.006727187,
-0.0280719995,
-0.0190311614,
0.0512644127,
-0.0501117334,
-0.0099544665,
0.0556066558,
0.0573708341,
0.0187024623,
-0.1198413596,
-0.0251933392,
-0.0547951907,
-0.038827125,
-0.0882665813,
-0.0649509653,
0.0696211755,
0.0746318027,
0.011883555,
-0.0061775991,
-0.0167439617,
-0.0364352725,
0.0529655963,
0.0254996717,
-0.01114727,
-0.0211626925,
0.0329857357,
-0.0113838678,
0.0257377718,
0.0298756566,
0.0104541881,
0.0284826476,
0.0082265371,
0.0334069617,
0.0378020257,
-0.0480012558,
-0.0146465264,
-0.0142558217,
0.0062972875,
-0.0836533383,
0.1011152491,
-0.0440406501,
-0.0206780918,
0.0227879733,
-0.032351438,
-0.0410247631,
0.0103922654,
0.0025124846,
-0.0072958576,
0.0238108765,
-0.0025511438,
-0.0140490122,
0.0254231114,
-0.0952030346,
-0.007872575,
0.0392829552,
-0.0335117653,
-0.0297326539,
-0.0011746159,
-0.0045749154,
-0.0023020974,
-0.0783413574,
-0.0087123076,
2.843269205e-34,
0.0511829406,
-0.0464169793,
0.0345524848,
0.049232807,
0.0391957164,
-0.0188641436,
0.0048212442,
-0.0009533546,
0.0006612406,
-0.0966313854,
-0.0154883983
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10505v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10505v2 | DePlot: One-shot visual language reasoning by plot-to-table translation | 2022-12-20T18:20:50 | 2023-05-23T18:28:39 | Fangyu Liu, Julian Martin Eisenschlos, Francesco Piccinno, Syrine Krichene, Chenxi Pang, Kenton Lee, Mandar Joshi, Wenhu Chen, Nigel Collier, Yasemin Altun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | Visual language such as charts and plots is ubiquitous in the human world.
Comprehending plots and charts requires strong reasoning skills. Prior
state-of-the-art (SOTA) models require at least tens of thousands of training
examples and their reasoning capabilities are still much limited, especially on
complex human-written queries. This paper presents the first one-shot solution
to visual language reasoning. We decompose the challenge of visual language
reasoning into two steps: (1) plot-to-text translation, and (2) reasoning over
the translated text. The key in this method is a modality conversion module,
named as DePlot, which translates the image of a plot or chart to a linearized
table. The output of DePlot can then be directly used to prompt a pretrained
large language model (LLM), exploiting the few-shot reasoning capabilities of
LLMs. To obtain DePlot, we standardize the plot-to-table task by establishing
unified task formats and metrics, and train DePlot end-to-end on this task.
DePlot can then be used off-the-shelf together with LLMs in a plug-and-play
fashion. Compared with a SOTA model finetuned on more than >28k data points,
DePlot+LLM with just one-shot prompting achieves a 24.0% improvement over
finetuned SOTA on human-written queries from the task of chart QA. | [
-0.0194076449,
0.0693386272,
-0.0117408046,
0.0482238904,
-0.0240596756,
0.0498823114,
0.0009276488,
0.0228013285,
0.0003678088,
0.0043750606,
-0.0358523391,
0.0331549533,
-0.0018022611,
0.0560018457,
0.0140146557,
-0.0705181137,
0.0265943911,
-0.0320385098,
0.010937498,
0.0221677125,
0.0072257649,
0.0101460535,
-0.0287547819,
0.0264169406,
-0.0472601093,
-0.0323062316,
0.0040482497,
0.0199787989,
0.0143979806,
-0.0491256826,
-0.0573479608,
0.0153486971,
0.0751357898,
-0.0143785011,
0.0000020359,
-0.0100158853,
-0.0152356429,
0.0002239785,
-0.0320086442,
-0.0320028812,
-0.0127230026,
-0.0600283667,
0.0358491354,
-0.0124075161,
-0.0512099229,
0.00541222,
0.0453381836,
0.0162597746,
0.0831582099,
0.0233469922,
-0.0113883885,
-0.0294014756,
-0.0370180979,
-0.0202053171,
0.0444218591,
-0.0563142672,
-0.02234561,
0.0524441898,
0.0384914055,
0.0198713876,
-0.0502665527,
0.0729448646,
0.0336393677,
-0.0253535993,
-0.0114740264,
0.0523620434,
0.0100452667,
-0.0033969569,
-0.0021630065,
0.1160766706,
-0.0367612541,
-0.0112545574,
0.0111188618,
-0.0024397271,
0.0073079499,
0.0363730043,
-0.090248473,
-0.0163016319,
-0.0014261368,
-0.0113095436,
-0.0296121445,
0.0018462674,
0.0050646681,
-0.0191293322,
-0.0408562459,
-0.0231121518,
-0.0293097999,
0.0054143239,
-0.0059440848,
0.008134474,
-0.0608993769,
-0.0379632562,
-0.0035514985,
0.0666609779,
-0.0063149147,
0.0113240778,
-0.0119934939,
-0.0269120354,
-0.0110622169,
-0.0141758472,
0.0356540978,
0.0294073243,
-0.0568995327,
0.0676158294,
-0.0202036947,
0.0575251095,
-0.0119451666,
0.0302482508,
-0.0151003441,
-0.0058834921,
-0.0664426312,
-0.003261816,
-0.0431571677,
-0.0106238574,
-0.0568790138,
-0.0155967483,
-0.0048441985,
0.0003051005,
-0.003661348,
0.0437968858,
0.0122855231,
0.0248657949,
-0.0423693657,
-0.0484463461,
-0.0553943031,
0.0942724273,
-0.0505695269,
0.0057339757,
-0.0281081256,
-0.0299402904,
-0.0058553554,
0.0306157321,
0.029285172,
-0.0131087536,
0.0057220631,
0.0755557343,
-0.0239488911,
-0.0016359451,
-0.0337292664,
-0.0506072752,
-0.0267695058,
-0.0367119908,
0.0063050212,
-0.0379740633,
0.0394425951,
0.0154160457,
-0.0149442293,
-0.0294915438,
0.0054165944,
0.0366448686,
-0.0213415436,
0.1123126447,
-0.0027166198,
0.0125746783,
0.0302768592,
0.0043145898,
-0.0344543718,
0.0644295216,
0.0439617075,
0.030501049,
-0.0044921236,
-0.0253623147,
0.030712951,
0.0369558297,
0.016988853,
-0.0346725397,
-0.0796980634,
0.0539811067,
-0.0422957204,
0.0134737976,
0.0202322062,
0.0389151685,
-0.0440158024,
-0.0174986906,
0.0377870426,
0.0598972179,
0.0483003855,
-0.0152968764,
0.048824925,
-0.0062075811,
0.0003971042,
-0.0227105077,
-0.0815401077,
0.0830979496,
0.0503236987,
0.0118489629,
-0.0433837585,
-0.0311736036,
0.000209783,
-0.0561819039,
0.0078727864,
0.0100671491,
-0.0026733533,
0.0274843425,
0.0276021529,
0.035361845,
-0.0184503384,
0.0061601312,
-0.0229439531,
-0.0416012369,
-0.0083578266,
-0.0024565423,
0.0242066961,
0.0486039892,
0.0218086187,
-0.011463956,
-0.0244551431,
-0.0118767787,
0.0379411392,
0.0347262584,
0.0221479386,
-0.024344109,
-0.0235636309,
-0.0569935143,
-0.0201084055,
-0.0177370738,
0.0047194138,
0.0187808629,
0.0004485493,
0.0020327419,
-0.0218758173,
-0.0863791704,
-0.0152010377,
0.0003322015,
0.0258700009,
-0.0424673706,
-0.0264802314,
0.0278056078,
-0.0164665692,
-0.004539317,
0.0004334528,
0.0363616869,
-0.0042738239,
-0.0377708636,
0.0254069809,
0.0415186882,
-0.0378246233,
-0.0582260974,
0.0094031794,
-0.0343038887,
-0.0768496096,
-0.0294400528,
-0.0529036708,
-0.0324855894,
-0.001414935,
-0.0181051176,
-0.0390999988,
-0.0070403968,
-0.0403797477,
0.0258476567,
-0.0060822787,
-0.0424807183,
0.067841135,
-0.0049987412,
-0.0097830845,
0.0054181744,
0.010926228,
0.0522230826,
-0.0067596785,
0.0190657545,
0.03803882,
-0.0019426179,
0.0202267915,
-0.0279693566,
0.0201634187,
-0.0347986408,
0.01458544,
-0.0783386156,
-0.009760594,
0.0176691096,
0.0162558071,
0.0259988438,
-0.0081020845,
-0.013276373,
-0.0624425821,
-0.0498657823,
0.0480274968,
-0.0067747165,
-0.0151500646,
0.0653688908,
-0.0082759764,
0.0268686283,
0.0111453645,
0.0078022154,
-0.0241905283,
0.0403030217,
0.0340203792,
0.025117401,
0.0011039623,
0.0217385553,
-0.0286844391,
-0.0012168461,
0.0092331301,
-0.0025926342,
0.0439840667,
-0.0372137316,
0.0205972958,
0.072424747,
-0.0346891172,
0.0226715486,
0.0007729338,
-0.0438787378,
-0.0666363835,
0.0327506773,
0.016629478,
0.00104241,
0.0145443734,
-0.0141060781,
-0.0183744226,
0.0766013637,
-0.0099383052,
0.029505372,
-0.0508789867,
-0.0009301035,
0.0050576595,
0.0314339548,
-0.0804090351,
0.0287577901,
0.0306112077,
0.0305803344,
-0.0431667753,
-0.0391187146,
0.0456540659,
-0.039553754,
-0.0288215019,
0.0015988438,
0.018282121,
-0.0466940254,
0.1048139483,
-0.0081374021,
-0.003585744,
-0.0323851816,
-0.0422992371,
-0.0719754845,
-0.0304758549,
0.02358553,
-0.0425079204,
0.0693190768,
-0.0785648003,
0.0161724947,
-0.0460286029,
-0.0177443381,
-0.0134431114,
0.0050641196,
-0.0529073589,
-0.004286455,
-0.0328730531,
-0.0404029377,
-0.0056246119,
-0.0026955784,
0.0135601033,
-0.0123218251,
-0.0257445946,
-0.0199399684,
-0.0132581973,
0.0285941996,
0.0180868395,
0.0655619875,
-0.0628341064,
-0.0429440625,
0.0477685742,
0.0440708585,
-0.019570902,
0.0019346942,
-0.0280462578,
0.0374806114,
-0.0262719095,
0.0490192957,
-0.0180481244,
0.0313783959,
0.0669519752,
-0.0707075372,
0.0158747733,
0.0626440048,
0.0069021014,
-0.004729101,
-0.0428444371,
0.0121839559,
0.0420506299,
0.0305115208,
0.0475595742,
-0.1088645235,
-0.0626710802,
-0.0010635098,
0.0088752089,
0.0572806671,
-0.0267094206,
-0.0334108882,
-0.0801472664,
0.0652889088,
-0.0013964418,
-0.0191267729,
-0.0106247449,
0.0062933075,
-0.0150800114,
0.0028943215,
-0.0176505987,
-0.0129822856,
0.0135635771,
0.0280639715,
0.0235195272,
0.000702484,
0.0026827606,
-0.0016124886,
-0.0132386014,
-0.0213395637,
0.0026084676,
0.0665248185,
0.0030280831,
-0.0293325484,
0.0083324583,
0.0647688732,
0.0407942533,
-0.019951243,
0.079712078,
0.0324969329,
-0.0582505465,
-0.0072717555,
0.0287253596,
-0.0152545311,
-0.0286164824,
-0.0245594922,
0.0788183808,
-0.0207853783,
-0.0016029202,
-0.0173716675,
0.0262448769,
-0.0185768809,
0.0296353735,
0.0597140342,
0.0210577715,
-0.0748734176,
-0.0540103689,
-0.0012793756,
-0.0812319741,
-0.0408762805,
0.0230069943,
0.0104109356,
-0.0075808032,
-0.0581459254,
0.0050696796,
0.0793187916,
0.0824875534,
-0.0033070436,
-0.0299432911,
0.0065946225,
-0.0110036526,
-0.0462905057,
0.0696745142,
-0.0683287829,
0.0426378734,
-0.0217646789,
0.0099243959,
0.0210818313,
0.0021989746,
-0.0106449369,
0.0021981737,
-0.0906320736,
-0.0039229873,
-0.0343447216,
0.0336842164,
0.0185273439,
0.0234433841,
-0.0059236693,
-0.030205356,
0.0572690554,
0.0641803965,
-0.059779048,
-0.050391525,
-0.0096801789,
0.0171151273,
-0.0133048017,
-0.0040553417,
-0.011187735,
0.0291254707,
0.0166301914,
0.04147771,
-0.0335383639,
0.0547254272,
0.0212550517,
0.0397722162,
0.0161040425,
0.0263420753,
-0.0290084928,
-0.0093574394,
-0.0373475589,
-0.0026745095,
-0.0380488299,
-0.0386436917,
0.0006166019,
0.0345879421,
-0.0193198565,
0.0146114249,
-0.0316493995,
0.0149362274,
-0.0073524574,
-0.0033284342,
0.0137094082,
0.0368027985,
-0.0134807611,
0.022459181,
0.0261287801,
0.0130228624,
0.0158322584,
-0.0061395676,
0.0650992468,
-0.0021529577,
0.0689607337,
0.0263067316,
-0.0003933094,
-0.0149074756,
0.0103744213,
-0.0426202677,
-0.0861482322,
0.0507531613,
0.0233360901,
0.0361115187,
0.0051046791,
0.0080243424,
0.0164539423,
-0.0005349465,
0.0365528092,
0.0417451784,
0.015815163,
0.0167007521,
0.0938356519,
0.025021391,
0.0108812787,
-0.0641460568,
0.0504663922,
-0.0244329665,
0.0017795748,
-0.0254242141,
-0.010566541,
-0.0491447747,
0.0022359914,
0.002612151,
-0.025755316,
0.0231981054,
0.0219109971,
-0.0395914204,
-0.098635897,
0.0113457041,
0.0403922386,
-0.0375164971,
0.0264783911,
0.0139977979,
0.0350513645,
0.0484257452,
-0.004608884,
-0.00528803,
0.0416575707,
0.0075314459,
-0.0316694081,
-0.0341862328,
-5.58191023e-33,
-0.02040557,
-0.0622140951,
0.0586276688,
-0.0251288302,
0.0061459965,
-0.0023316157,
-0.0208141003,
-0.0171459541,
-0.0068781753,
0.0295555983,
0.0024175434,
0.0136058126,
-0.0079640187,
-0.0023688178,
-0.0086221993,
-0.0451083556,
0.0281735919,
-0.0141709438,
-0.033889927,
0.0099855503,
0.0467785671,
0.0116563765,
0.0096495999,
-0.0660119131,
-0.0190297812,
0.0532577299,
-0.016091831,
0.028891664,
-0.0092382999,
0.0244838577,
-0.0061990935,
0.0013173679,
0.029470358,
0.0020871982,
-0.0369828232,
0.0585258678,
-0.1012476459,
-0.0672246218,
-0.0038042208,
0.0341444574,
-0.0438485481,
0.00098018,
0.0570763275,
-0.026544394,
0.0313248672,
-0.0550158918,
0.0340908952,
-0.0141323591,
0.0070859659,
0.0620136112,
-0.0050897221,
0.0269871298,
-0.0164637845,
-0.0279645696,
0.0412253849,
0.0678065717,
0.0038305128,
0.0118972789,
-0.0206337404,
0.0554371364,
-0.0072235144,
-0.0283004083,
0.0533153042,
0.0102180941,
0.0007742323,
0.0265856963,
0.01167682,
-0.0152486376,
-0.044113297,
0.0234191399,
0.0135577479,
0.0998504981,
0.0626174212,
0.0134428432,
0.0306036305,
-0.0018814137,
-0.029880153,
0.0469503067,
-0.056450855,
0.053411644,
-0.0360938199,
0.0061707003,
-0.0206264853,
-0.037537124,
-0.0278452244,
0.0112672411,
-0.0430254564,
-0.006474846,
0.0496519208,
0.0005271273,
0.0128512764,
0.0247101206,
0.0370756239,
-0.0244024061,
-0.0162358936,
-0.0034741818,
0.0098926863,
0.0333118699,
0.014033935,
-0.0018511954,
-0.0157587659,
-0.0214526597,
0.0398614369,
-0.0206381995,
0.0318079516,
0.0133350343,
0.0503693372,
0.0188356731,
-0.0572990365,
-0.0231008269,
-0.033525683,
-0.0433709025,
-0.0039924732,
-0.0070850197,
0.0300442297,
0.0134142851,
-0.0410177894,
0.0232913382,
-0.0113795772,
-0.007185142,
-0.0341861621,
-0.0185725074,
-0.0422225855,
0.0237573478,
-0.0438775532,
-0.0232883357,
-0.0219919197,
-0.0402655154,
0.0141058834,
-0.0739137381,
0.0014825218,
0.0155964233,
2.626e-7,
0.0625695214,
0.0225481726,
0.0297315288,
0.0257278383,
0.0050395736,
0.0369455405,
-0.0558927841,
-0.0360537469,
0.0008918797,
-0.0137800341,
0.0294494685,
0.0326653011,
0.0235761479,
0.0522949994,
-0.0083305482,
0.0059912596,
0.0054155313,
-0.0268559549,
-0.0456864648,
0.0266824607,
0.101161018,
0.0182616282,
-0.0278031901,
-0.0157138612,
0.0291326568,
-0.0623119697,
0.0739932358,
-0.0247571114,
0.0148288598,
-0.0263983794,
-0.0095179193,
0.0074558831,
-0.0082311975,
0.0321148671,
-0.0061234371,
-0.017449284,
0.0233120508,
0.0338623561,
-0.0085954443,
0.0367430523,
-0.0313348956,
-0.0124069285,
0.002446105,
-0.0425660983,
0.0781722441,
-0.0672471076,
-0.0568240248,
-0.0026111901,
-0.0003165934,
0.0028685364,
0.009052746,
0.0072989655,
-0.0231223255,
-0.0017690617,
0.0525045618,
-0.0096304184,
0.0105935261,
-0.0533818267,
-0.0170464553,
0.0245482195,
-0.0110944035,
0.0064340052,
-0.0656697974,
0.0054011322,
0.010721406,
0.0368827172,
-0.072525233,
2.252304573e-34,
0.015020933,
-0.0169759858,
0.0255727321,
-0.0145333549,
0.0546997413,
-0.0242820494,
0.0168854874,
0.0133873532,
0.0411066264,
-0.0957034528,
-0.0169012696
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10504v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10504v2 | Can Current Task-oriented Dialogue Models Automate Real-world Scenarios in the Wild? | 2022-12-20T18:18:41 | 2023-05-24T11:46:33 | Sang-Woo Lee, Sungdong Kim, Donghyeon Ko, Donghoon Ham, Youngki Hong, Shin Ah Oh, Hyunhoon Jung, Wangkyo Jung, Kyunghyun Cho, Donghyun Kwak, Hyungsuk Noh, Woomyoung Park | cs.CL | cs.CL | Task-oriented dialogue (TOD) systems are mainly based on the
slot-filling-based TOD (SF-TOD) framework, in which dialogues are broken down
into smaller, controllable units (i.e., slots) to fulfill a specific task. A
series of approaches based on this framework achieved remarkable success on
various TOD benchmarks. However, we argue that the current TOD benchmarks are
limited to surrogate real-world scenarios and that the current TOD models are
still a long way to cover the scenarios. In this position paper, we first
identify current status and limitations of SF-TOD systems. After that, we
explore the WebTOD framework, the alternative direction for building a scalable
TOD system when a web/mobile interface is available. In WebTOD, the dialogue
system learns how to understand the web/mobile interface that the human agent
interacts with, powered by a large-scale language model. | [
0.0837713853,
0.0272779856,
-0.0207711458,
0.0073869266,
-0.0027956674,
0.0209346022,
0.0211310051,
-0.0124408146,
0.0303376187,
-0.0685480684,
-0.0334625058,
-0.047474701,
-0.0132408412,
0.059970405,
-0.0002984266,
-0.0730365217,
0.0101715298,
-0.048635114,
-0.0155883664,
0.0261861775,
0.0017118003,
-0.0009614952,
-0.0484245457,
0.0617098361,
0.0005496225,
-0.028404003,
-0.06228742,
0.0037093596,
-0.0155405235,
0.0058880793,
-0.0089305528,
0.0440682396,
0.0427660011,
0.0345043279,
0.0000017332,
-0.04170819,
0.0289031193,
-0.0187927093,
-0.0376738831,
-0.0327902175,
-0.019638462,
0.0191412568,
-0.0323756896,
0.0362595432,
-0.0325435959,
-0.0292356126,
0.0335248709,
0.0607994571,
0.0575135984,
0.0677603856,
-0.0002711968,
0.0343142226,
0.0212855954,
0.01864863,
0.0009486489,
-0.0600554757,
-0.0053977775,
0.040413823,
0.0406158678,
0.0023600287,
0.0249336902,
-0.0074955188,
0.0219521523,
-0.021109445,
-0.0185293965,
-0.0001104205,
-0.0346337184,
-0.0110310735,
-0.0508171842,
0.0904480815,
0.0119883409,
-0.0052477447,
0.0250727087,
0.024415426,
0.0025848073,
-0.0081572123,
-0.0632234961,
0.0005649547,
-0.0349309854,
-0.0318113416,
-0.0282060225,
0.0225449856,
-0.012345423,
-0.0024001445,
-0.0358321704,
0.0371421687,
-0.01927655,
-0.0379380994,
-0.0185560994,
-0.0239183176,
0.0052596782,
-0.0705174655,
0.0194640756,
0.0623551048,
-0.0932925791,
0.0313810445,
-0.0358994938,
0.0145945875,
0.0032140126,
-0.0658570454,
0.0385548174,
0.0418711901,
-0.0165466871,
0.0399589613,
0.050728444,
0.0658239424,
-0.0244956091,
-0.0611342005,
-0.0346653983,
-0.0027624019,
-0.0718257204,
0.0062339357,
-0.0487518869,
0.0204089582,
-0.0623634644,
-0.0429594293,
0.0244625174,
0.0958047807,
0.0006836987,
0.0451418497,
0.0238183402,
0.0001082344,
-0.048756998,
-0.0106262537,
-0.0414782576,
0.0000522515,
-0.0049298536,
0.0210159384,
0.007386764,
-0.0566153564,
0.0101312855,
0.0076359184,
0.0181607157,
0.0008239669,
-0.0344896503,
0.0915899277,
-0.0273572747,
-0.0024641275,
-0.0003400054,
-0.0264295228,
-0.013866771,
-0.0573859252,
-0.0372234061,
-0.0452399105,
0.0302357934,
0.0136990771,
-0.0150842797,
-0.0035936444,
0.0265199374,
0.0515982471,
-0.0034243017,
0.0671124235,
0.0114721758,
0.0340194665,
0.0419881791,
0.0019308808,
-0.0413565598,
0.0471963994,
0.0421677865,
0.0640066341,
0.0189841855,
0.0211512465,
0.0190726705,
0.0382594392,
-0.0421904586,
0.0058488571,
0.0706917644,
0.0499913432,
0.0269503575,
0.0316297971,
-0.0056737252,
0.0634259507,
-0.0210082978,
0.034063831,
0.0676855519,
0.0478828549,
-0.0170261636,
0.0186513849,
0.0587658621,
0.0598214008,
0.0198105536,
0.0054968204,
-0.0456876308,
0.0175403189,
-0.0122116124,
-0.0197617747,
0.0198486261,
-0.0401095711,
-0.0328802019,
-0.0419391021,
-0.0092961378,
-0.0039321277,
0.0295708608,
0.0057193968,
0.0522589982,
0.0031593028,
-0.0638866723,
0.0341306962,
0.0045829285,
-0.0187053401,
-0.0416159853,
-0.056434311,
-0.0181642473,
0.0639047399,
0.0421626642,
-0.0424855202,
-0.0738065466,
-0.0214140136,
0.0159397684,
0.0393986367,
0.0679774657,
-0.0433698297,
0.0095545566,
-0.0300077312,
-0.0075394772,
0.0051872851,
-0.0054989629,
0.0004504456,
0.0260084383,
-0.0176082402,
-0.0025665932,
-0.0252351109,
-0.0123347137,
0.0034317712,
0.0165950395,
-0.0062303687,
0.0094625661,
0.0195553247,
0.0346072689,
0.012762215,
-0.0126492735,
-0.029985141,
-0.0025241307,
-0.010526686,
0.0048149209,
0.0150806503,
-0.0487181544,
-0.0096224798,
0.0300745703,
0.0096306736,
-0.0074963057,
0.0365141146,
-0.0246899407,
-0.0510995463,
-0.0001877138,
-0.0341429599,
-0.0107349753,
-0.0404159799,
0.0328088515,
0.0283517875,
-0.0148399509,
-0.0079524983,
0.0338294618,
0.0149978222,
-0.0037226158,
0.0466470234,
0.0059747281,
0.0220891237,
-0.0740013197,
0.0015481465,
0.0017660619,
-0.026769679,
0.0122230379,
0.0086525967,
0.0151499957,
-0.0345438048,
-0.0338416696,
-0.1556137055,
0.0078887837,
-0.0201123394,
-0.0033918705,
0.0100286622,
0.0182009749,
0.0132295024,
-0.0367375948,
-0.0228927732,
-0.0024512294,
0.0488334559,
-0.0005496831,
0.0425657816,
0.0255460013,
-0.0231394581,
-0.0301917773,
0.0276220031,
-0.0094147176,
0.0145905428,
-0.0215590578,
-0.0237146765,
-0.0514957309,
0.0025253545,
-0.0139159057,
0.0529232249,
-0.0183255449,
-0.0384138599,
0.0342571922,
0.0151432697,
0.0262523349,
0.0670711249,
0.0094766738,
0.0478767157,
0.0056959507,
-0.0389024988,
-0.0502005443,
0.0460914746,
0.0114317155,
-0.025030015,
-0.075093694,
-0.0236055292,
0.0368619412,
0.0649421364,
-0.0194747597,
0.0397376679,
-0.0529877245,
0.0116272867,
-0.0007247708,
-0.0149826836,
0.0021129258,
-0.0040148357,
-0.0494479872,
0.0631718785,
-0.0319569521,
-0.0213505067,
0.0596484728,
-0.0101729827,
-0.0013144271,
-0.0425928645,
-0.0012934598,
-0.0198402628,
0.0820704475,
-0.0140494779,
0.0201376174,
0.0590354316,
-0.0458402857,
-0.0423651896,
0.0357327126,
0.0054393183,
-0.037015181,
0.0140706599,
-0.0634809434,
0.0066748573,
-0.0084014088,
-0.0908433869,
-0.0531799346,
0.0032109662,
-0.0293857418,
0.0077008852,
-0.0100643709,
-0.0445218422,
-0.0328131132,
0.0161141697,
0.0038229509,
0.0599554665,
0.0181764867,
-0.0097772582,
-0.0272882581,
0.0328712836,
0.0408044383,
0.0206368361,
-0.0361699089,
0.015963614,
0.0648989901,
0.0347356163,
0.0413109213,
-0.032976564,
-0.0187917221,
-0.0062498595,
0.0405614302,
-0.031559594,
-0.0193041898,
0.0384800658,
0.0529304482,
-0.0362828188,
-0.0120224878,
0.1187135875,
0.039433226,
0.0034241078,
-0.01431931,
-0.010186621,
0.0019927626,
0.0091214282,
0.0470885001,
-0.0737092569,
-0.0230111349,
0.0241866317,
-0.0090502594,
-0.0003041496,
-0.0320454501,
-0.0062418063,
-0.0706457496,
0.0374271497,
-0.0262806229,
0.0080692032,
0.0279051848,
-0.0079935323,
0.0182542093,
0.0200297125,
-0.0162274502,
0.032561589,
-0.0028266646,
-0.0317560509,
0.0017647577,
-0.0304135196,
0.0063646152,
0.0539666973,
-0.0207707286,
0.0608634874,
0.0462574139,
0.0599910244,
0.0508336201,
0.0347575657,
0.0010503955,
0.0296686199,
0.0173100624,
-0.0008654181,
0.0055145207,
-0.0035212901,
-0.0123593044,
-0.0277580414,
0.0424248315,
-0.0425511152,
-0.0045625023,
0.0346698388,
0.0744949207,
-0.0481771491,
0.0249743517,
-0.0284724981,
-0.0158862323,
0.0439779796,
0.073336184,
0.0004677622,
-0.0659389794,
-0.0695071295,
-0.0187054742,
-0.0501146056,
-0.0266467668,
0.0240133014,
0.0001054307,
0.0048825885,
-0.0419531688,
-0.0851180181,
-0.0173299313,
0.0163814481,
0.0492715053,
0.0268770736,
-0.0174252149,
0.0515039861,
0.0398022607,
-0.0242963899,
-0.0199121982,
-0.021816412,
0.0320760235,
-0.0408877879,
-0.0084381327,
0.0495719798,
-0.079108946,
-0.0024333312,
0.0248103812,
-0.083893396,
-0.0316839255,
-0.0459646843,
0.0530701056,
0.0309793483,
0.0323639698,
-0.0159437861,
-0.0242620315,
-0.0164737999,
-0.0252933931,
-0.0695237964,
-0.026857879,
0.0319647454,
0.0549491644,
0.0011441265,
0.0515442975,
-0.08347404,
0.0077558798,
-0.0166303404,
0.0349917822,
-0.039715901,
-0.051551789,
0.0273537114,
-0.0154233435,
0.0240234006,
0.0321654342,
-0.0327193066,
-0.0166438147,
0.0492207855,
-0.0043686186,
-0.0398628786,
-0.0793882832,
0.0213582162,
-0.0344160087,
0.0249053016,
0.024925394,
0.0017798685,
-0.0288899466,
0.0266991965,
0.0061904131,
-0.0225233883,
0.0435007028,
-0.0118792905,
0.0378606878,
-0.0011386366,
-0.022373775,
0.0038137611,
0.0271336921,
0.0348875858,
0.004754662,
0.1052718684,
0.0139965061,
-0.0458197035,
-0.0082368087,
0.0426744223,
-0.0680031925,
-0.0573979095,
0.0091509148,
0.0475009605,
0.0165731777,
0.0328537934,
0.0187300481,
-0.0577911437,
0.0230373964,
-0.0239627399,
0.0273327306,
-0.0027945268,
-0.0113192741,
0.0093995761,
0.0185220242,
-0.0054128459,
0.0248916149,
0.0526286252,
0.0287941732,
-0.0042907707,
0.0286762193,
-0.0442849696,
-0.0638341978,
-0.0388472565,
-0.0096812937,
0.0775083303,
-0.0113788871,
0.0016805077,
-0.0210424233,
-0.0343368426,
-0.0169347189,
0.0247651022,
0.0044669532,
-0.030682819,
0.0216548182,
0.0493290052,
0.0085495515,
-0.0067382376,
-0.0452352017,
-0.0138087766,
-0.0191205181,
-0.0125893112,
-0.0309000127,
-4.857730405e-33,
-0.0121966535,
-0.0117078386,
0.040101748,
0.0311141182,
-0.0211577676,
-0.0476982333,
-0.0281052087,
0.0093880827,
-0.0184571948,
-0.0028638439,
-0.0360195674,
0.0030141596,
0.0223718453,
0.0299292896,
-0.0149166612,
0.0188860986,
0.0504530892,
-0.0185217038,
-0.0264062788,
0.0230643898,
0.0223564636,
-0.0051860269,
-0.002332821,
-0.0218444597,
0.0199692883,
-0.0189949647,
-0.0036159668,
0.0486828312,
0.0443307199,
0.0455968119,
-0.0183643661,
0.0386588946,
0.03388514,
-0.0093701826,
-0.0011831768,
0.0497986339,
-0.0919734761,
-0.0109882671,
0.0354389958,
0.0324627273,
-0.0102439774,
0.0203928649,
-0.0258781519,
-0.0054595387,
-0.012159287,
0.0124912346,
0.0063703572,
-0.0298225097,
-0.0157239456,
-0.0163489319,
-0.0712970942,
0.006074294,
-0.006190036,
-0.1074995697,
-0.0115083195,
0.061313048,
-0.0010961215,
-0.0778852254,
-0.0197599363,
0.0189447869,
-0.0200018454,
-0.0083583184,
0.0551478863,
0.0216351748,
0.0038148991,
0.0615260266,
0.0393953733,
0.0280213393,
-0.0093402257,
-0.0317798741,
-0.0359308943,
0.0537939928,
-0.0165862367,
0.008868265,
-0.013860778,
0.0346058495,
-0.0369369574,
0.025252074,
0.0241476744,
0.0600582473,
0.0273390561,
0.0137233958,
-0.0670435652,
-0.0018405034,
-0.0364222899,
0.0304380041,
-0.0253172051,
-0.0475760512,
0.0594196245,
0.0273569059,
-0.0009116,
-0.0261537582,
0.0489382632,
-0.0433837175,
-0.0078059505,
0.0168850012,
-0.0199358612,
0.023262877,
-0.0357822292,
0.0148913274,
-0.0238909852,
-0.0472106226,
0.008767128,
0.0404936112,
0.0125180399,
0.0222344548,
-0.0133084813,
0.01185105,
-0.0452700593,
0.0079260813,
-0.0621339455,
0.0481633395,
-0.0240076873,
0.0591774024,
0.0431154184,
-0.0119334729,
-0.0343002938,
0.0840958357,
-0.0382917635,
-0.0773479193,
-0.0452166721,
-0.0253951047,
0.0093450407,
-0.0244939439,
-0.0310378149,
-0.0171086043,
-0.0345532522,
0.0239142496,
-0.0317274518,
-0.006018308,
0.0082669063,
0.0233880691,
2.428e-7,
-0.0630306453,
0.0177448299,
0.0115734553,
0.0236130692,
0.0437449962,
0.0426975265,
0.012700405,
0.0494693965,
0.0102853132,
-0.0169954803,
0.010510765,
0.0256940629,
0.0525256172,
0.0190606918,
-0.1059379578,
-0.0287625734,
-0.0173313301,
-0.0189019125,
-0.0656436607,
0.0091171991,
0.0481590964,
0.0590838902,
-0.0088700755,
0.0085089197,
0.0011994973,
-0.02040397,
0.0177533254,
-0.0219056662,
-0.0068660663,
0.0541967526,
0.0190461576,
0.000442946,
-0.0291414578,
0.0326252356,
-0.0035843668,
0.0201530568,
0.010526076,
0.053007707,
0.0071669891,
-0.0214995947,
-0.0295839161,
-0.0504557751,
0.0130188288,
-0.0722605288,
0.047418382,
-0.0495381542,
-0.0261635631,
-0.0291140862,
0.0068540308,
-0.0310939196,
-0.0656253844,
-0.0084715877,
0.0028026835,
0.0139302164,
-0.0006499154,
-0.0030968816,
0.0268936381,
-0.0763146877,
-0.0135255782,
-0.0211230889,
-0.0370108671,
-0.0517154895,
-0.059663441,
-0.0304172058,
0.0125116585,
-0.022884259,
0.0005130701,
1.709924477e-34,
0.007044204,
0.0116297621,
0.0047213794,
0.0459034704,
0.0456338264,
0.0106322039,
-0.0081864651,
0.0130921099,
0.078100726,
-0.0549366735,
-0.0092843138
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10503v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10503v2 | Mini-Model Adaptation: Efficiently Extending Pretrained Models to New Languages via Aligned Shallow Training | 2022-12-20T18:17:28 | 2023-07-04T19:06:55 | Kelly Marchisio, Patrick Lewis, Yihong Chen, Mikel Artetxe | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Prior work shows that it is possible to expand pretrained Masked Language
Models (MLMs) to new languages by learning a new set of embeddings, while
keeping the transformer body frozen. Despite learning a small subset of
parameters, this approach is not compute-efficient, as training the new
embeddings requires a full forward and backward pass over the entire model. We
propose mini-model adaptation, a compute-efficient alternative that builds a
shallow mini-model from a fraction of a large model's parameters. New
language-specific embeddings can then be efficiently trained over the
mini-model and plugged into the aligned large model for rapid cross-lingual
transfer. We explore two approaches to learn mini-models: MiniJoint, which
jointly pretrains the primary model and the mini-model using a single
transformer with a secondary MLM head at a middle layer; and MiniPost, where we
start from a regular pretrained model, build a mini-model by extracting and
freezing a few layers, and learn a small number of parameters on top.
Experiments on XNLI, MLQA and PAWS-X show that mini-model adaptation matches
the performance of the standard approach using 2.3x less compute on average. | [
-0.0020944001,
0.0592010245,
-0.0182698965,
0.0497023799,
0.0073142108,
0.0340049602,
0.0201491527,
-0.0060411966,
0.0073776362,
-0.0357989706,
-0.0775423795,
-0.0144532071,
-0.0230426621,
0.0067729708,
0.0304581299,
-0.075494796,
0.0589789972,
-0.0400478058,
-0.0673255622,
-0.0190450232,
-0.011611132,
0.0038380451,
0.0052414215,
0.0080640689,
0.0453189909,
0.0267393608,
-0.0268431176,
-0.0052289558,
0.0227352623,
-0.0033077057,
-0.014727206,
0.0370757394,
0.0375593938,
0.0648018569,
0.0000020597,
-0.0105793979,
-0.0230072904,
-0.0118087037,
-0.0125627508,
0.0097907996,
0.0400455669,
-0.0459781997,
-0.0294044502,
0.0163194705,
-0.0199048705,
-0.0825964659,
0.0902650952,
0.0234209727,
0.0412875786,
0.0769939721,
-0.0324399285,
-0.0284765325,
-0.0142355449,
-0.0357757658,
-0.0486252159,
-0.0425591506,
0.0118542891,
-0.045089677,
-0.0523935705,
-0.0024497199,
-0.0215057228,
0.0319716036,
-0.0065362211,
0.0246578082,
-0.0259440932,
0.0322315991,
-0.0109667629,
0.0000264364,
-0.0319983438,
0.0456450693,
-0.0912786722,
-0.0373063944,
-0.0274927877,
-0.0224272925,
-0.0051906859,
-0.0072675375,
-0.0166018419,
-0.0264762901,
0.0444205925,
0.00174791,
0.0405594632,
0.0097348951,
0.0560528636,
0.0053854878,
-0.0611419566,
0.0073880292,
0.0474963747,
-0.012372476,
-0.0008201697,
0.0037981488,
0.0138058914,
-0.0284823552,
-0.0131163299,
0.0181571171,
0.0102222385,
0.0026424823,
-0.0773100629,
-0.0693380609,
-0.0230619889,
0.0114893783,
0.0845789537,
0.0501106456,
-0.0250151269,
0.0559886396,
-0.0722980425,
0.0175879057,
-0.02144037,
0.0121010877,
-0.0593959577,
-0.0119050341,
0.0083453069,
0.00905718,
-0.072011359,
0.0070837522,
-0.0647732541,
-0.0083843125,
0.0104538221,
0.0299509503,
0.00160289,
-0.0164544694,
0.0049746954,
-0.0537292771,
-0.0339756273,
-0.0208629444,
0.0393311754,
0.0572834499,
-0.0000555813,
0.0395253934,
-0.0172679201,
-0.0398406498,
-0.0362690724,
0.0133662941,
0.0452750139,
-0.0432160087,
0.0256809164,
0.0591043867,
-0.0216866434,
-0.0337411426,
-0.035795074,
0.0593242459,
0.0118083311,
-0.043941088,
0.0328521952,
-0.0584742986,
0.0311236326,
-0.0268829986,
0.041715987,
-0.0548364781,
-0.0209597927,
-0.0182283819,
-0.0467122495,
0.0675476491,
-0.0073332544,
-0.0185899287,
0.0012375257,
-0.0077136108,
-0.0082035949,
0.0889046043,
0.0284791961,
-0.0071088909,
0.0165259689,
-0.0615893714,
-0.0325592496,
0.0600123741,
0.0481525064,
0.0664427653,
-0.0126663893,
-0.036221087,
0.0466190539,
-0.0176097397,
0.0294205192,
0.0282535534,
-0.0111526847,
-0.0263022967,
0.0501108803,
0.044731006,
0.0277412552,
0.0582641922,
0.0496407561,
-0.0282758456,
-0.0085506253,
0.0004710967,
-0.0156962648,
0.0284569189,
-0.0374027118,
-0.0261845961,
-0.0213145614,
0.0717492402,
-0.0578804687,
0.001200883,
0.0114776446,
0.0024191891,
0.0188779999,
0.0117838979,
0.0302069299,
0.0289007165,
-0.0347579233,
0.081625104,
0.0453021005,
-0.0565880276,
0.0057865321,
-0.0241222177,
-0.0136620207,
-0.0235938225,
-0.0292901956,
0.0025554518,
-0.0262102988,
0.0105096195,
0.0060754307,
0.0155888349,
0.082540229,
0.0126299392,
0.0436931252,
-0.0405471548,
0.0146479867,
0.0027046776,
0.0014866142,
0.0554512814,
-0.0018548486,
0.0308932085,
0.0112350313,
0.0040998654,
0.0211293716,
0.0226563253,
-0.0884884819,
-0.0146693224,
0.0168903638,
0.0255013667,
0.0113025745,
0.0013257256,
-0.0009204232,
-0.0249997787,
0.0324986316,
-0.0603480488,
-0.0044239415,
0.0388436429,
-0.0348859467,
-0.0402333029,
0.0192357972,
0.0112276478,
0.0402823538,
0.0535063669,
-0.0366118737,
-0.0367954224,
0.0245165192,
-0.0026614787,
0.047398217,
-0.0414385647,
0.0155534623,
-0.0060792584,
0.0506810173,
-0.0176480766,
-0.0005250943,
-0.0048614326,
0.0097059375,
0.0296057668,
-0.0295651704,
0.016071463,
-0.0169439837,
-0.0484313294,
0.0479007922,
0.0170843564,
0.0024727155,
-0.0251726955,
-0.0011105775,
-0.0092461156,
-0.0204382148,
-0.058043655,
0.0075767618,
-0.0171987806,
0.0300992262,
0.0200524032,
0.0457172021,
0.0117058298,
-0.0168722086,
-0.0452586859,
0.002326685,
-0.0180789642,
0.0166807193,
-0.0230178982,
0.020526994,
-0.0125724906,
-0.0063870559,
-0.0226367917,
0.0464211628,
0.0546674915,
-0.0631075725,
-0.0378261209,
-0.0741156042,
0.0246110279,
-0.0250238795,
0.0566984713,
-0.0160756521,
-0.0785176232,
-0.0557955466,
-0.0178514533,
0.0171256885,
0.0459285565,
-0.0221605431,
-0.0114233894,
0.070178628,
-0.0084206788,
-0.0307839401,
0.0184977371,
-0.0215859916,
-0.0467674471,
-0.0599065945,
0.005325703,
-0.0225131046,
0.0628067255,
-0.0502896234,
-0.0151512185,
-0.0831594095,
-0.0136374477,
-0.0221476536,
-0.0376646109,
-0.0160189718,
0.0282885935,
-0.0028220268,
0.0143526169,
-0.0265600551,
-0.0244837031,
0.0420134924,
-0.0403516069,
-0.0112169208,
-0.0454165228,
-0.0582935587,
-0.0128928497,
0.0270825904,
0.0105032148,
0.0536329262,
-0.0301673394,
-0.0094443867,
-0.0685822666,
0.012716759,
-0.0146874804,
-0.0195101574,
0.0138392514,
-0.0102847051,
-0.0049709114,
-0.0290925726,
-0.0505643748,
-0.0196993984,
-0.0509295911,
-0.0342784785,
0.005875214,
0.0314627551,
-0.039426215,
-0.0332429744,
0.0257936269,
0.0148811713,
0.0917980224,
0.0099491347,
0.0430805758,
-0.0164855383,
0.0001446045,
0.0286892932,
0.060498409,
0.0107597308,
-0.0159496292,
0.0811292753,
0.0305674151,
0.0611729026,
-0.0268423986,
-0.0455605239,
0.0412983298,
0.0706773028,
0.0125546055,
-0.0317478962,
-0.0037291776,
0.0369822532,
-0.0365829095,
-0.0084963385,
0.0649032518,
-0.0105583537,
-0.032455802,
-0.0045706737,
-0.0158577245,
0.0668486878,
0.0181531552,
0.0384653322,
-0.0724183619,
-0.0082592908,
0.0304680821,
0.0135849491,
-0.0004969948,
0.0062776613,
-0.0140293445,
-0.1146128923,
0.0241365172,
0.0489759594,
-0.0687378943,
0.0084232744,
-0.0404154286,
-0.0004942046,
0.0209727734,
0.0040276181,
-0.014974934,
-0.0092022819,
-0.0572914742,
0.0144631295,
-0.0105427168,
-0.040180698,
-0.0041590878,
-0.0069855545,
0.0332660787,
-0.0077066789,
0.008762111,
-0.0328011028,
-0.0751345083,
0.0510658398,
-0.0279764142,
-0.0333442762,
-0.0295478981,
0.0335486569,
-0.0125801759,
-0.0323219597,
0.0879495218,
0.0064522321,
0.007400143,
-0.0127690192,
-0.0215704851,
0.0812662616,
0.0093029868,
0.0112352548,
0.0479329973,
-0.009420123,
-0.0076276073,
0.0626637712,
0.0214428119,
-0.0313918702,
0.0272602737,
0.0136996554,
-0.0238884501,
-0.0178654324,
-0.021734817,
0.0460803621,
-0.0407895111,
-0.0406924337,
-0.035377197,
0.0140554514,
0.0273854472,
0.0689007193,
0.0415357612,
0.0236234684,
0.0011422879,
0.0074556894,
-0.0453597642,
0.032596983,
-0.0420403033,
0.0236657001,
-0.0447368436,
-0.0187464599,
0.0392869972,
-0.0275693368,
-0.0061877621,
-0.0247396659,
-0.0911821648,
-0.0666812137,
0.0093657495,
0.0341377817,
0.0132584134,
0.0543994308,
0.0090141045,
-0.0614618137,
0.0570486523,
-0.0044925879,
-0.0110980421,
0.0410492085,
0.0766656697,
-0.0628323853,
0.0042862063,
0.0232362915,
-0.0583013445,
0.0107538383,
0.0340658948,
0.0006850612,
-0.0049408716,
-0.0168201905,
-0.0055465326,
-0.0065223705,
0.0371316299,
-0.0239102989,
0.0133034019,
-0.0249206088,
0.0492540449,
-0.026215693,
-0.0082267681,
-0.046243526,
-0.0528640747,
0.0326773711,
0.0322463028,
0.0097429827,
0.0229340773,
0.0118041197,
0.030687483,
-0.036697261,
0.0223543663,
0.0144517906,
0.0279584695,
0.0315915532,
0.0425115153,
-0.029137047,
-0.019312432,
0.0209013578,
0.016048599,
-0.0508443862,
-0.0034290189,
0.0324847549,
-0.0111123566,
-0.0713369697,
0.0434705839,
-0.0655202791,
-0.0579701923,
-0.0058243503,
-0.0262439102,
0.0591431297,
-0.0353369638,
0.063562423,
-0.0030274978,
-0.0366242453,
-0.0140921175,
0.0210803393,
-0.0249405354,
-0.0413007177,
0.0519316718,
-0.00121008,
-0.0118014617,
0.0385987796,
0.0456515886,
0.018887233,
0.0622702986,
-0.0184112769,
0.0341107249,
-0.0240256414,
0.0054624365,
0.0334420949,
0.0487433001,
-0.0071053701,
-0.0032439479,
-0.0104912985,
-0.0876071379,
-0.0119480118,
-0.0333201736,
-0.0107668312,
-0.0001428275,
0.0054972339,
0.0320824943,
0.0125750173,
-0.0069019836,
-0.0357596092,
0.0089766933,
0.0721826702,
-0.0216628574,
0.0314621404,
-6.479654e-33,
-0.0202560369,
0.0389117785,
0.0013907484,
0.0152902454,
-0.0268591978,
0.0128711071,
-0.0167482533,
0.0055960175,
-0.0158195645,
-0.0016322078,
-0.0115408748,
-0.0158675797,
0.0226889458,
0.0234427061,
-0.0547137372,
0.0187622067,
0.0598248355,
-0.0013178531,
0.0149090905,
0.0064652767,
0.0002333748,
0.0350199379,
0.0485843793,
-0.0461921766,
-0.0382550769,
0.0121044833,
-0.0074157175,
0.0079582687,
0.0308330152,
0.0342913792,
-0.0025549149,
0.0054693972,
0.0018155137,
-0.0187672358,
-0.0232187863,
0.0069603999,
-0.1018321514,
-0.015667703,
0.0084206993,
0.0463341922,
-0.0320473537,
-0.0235463865,
0.0025260644,
-0.0010550955,
0.0170384832,
-0.0129169058,
-0.0267888084,
-0.0427405797,
-0.0188091863,
0.0050938949,
-0.0368097834,
0.0199393835,
0.0293565281,
0.0073355553,
0.0800525248,
0.0420081802,
-0.0013631454,
-0.0040853247,
-0.0737651289,
0.000656616,
0.0105228079,
0.0478739142,
0.0586419255,
0.0551597401,
-0.0208361913,
0.0287975054,
0.0334803499,
-0.0185704138,
0.0342171565,
0.0187693723,
0.0877939835,
0.0017976065,
0.0332307741,
0.0234838948,
0.0354334787,
-0.0347811766,
-0.0524653606,
0.0019387467,
-0.0109438412,
-0.0000417836,
0.0047230665,
0.0490897447,
0.0050999238,
-0.0128765441,
-0.0630131364,
-0.0243615825,
-0.025712667,
-0.014255113,
0.0324086212,
0.022839589,
-0.0167817846,
-0.0193985607,
0.0814524591,
-0.039770294,
-0.0023674371,
-0.0199355464,
-0.0162428506,
0.0026780327,
-0.0112238498,
0.0453852862,
-0.0334623568,
-0.0679705516,
0.034465041,
-0.0166535024,
0.0220903028,
-0.0064363559,
0.0674266443,
0.0566041805,
-0.0871460289,
-0.0167921837,
-0.0333911926,
-0.0040429574,
0.0373851061,
0.0603694767,
0.0222181473,
0.0080735665,
-0.0024639387,
0.0177964345,
0.0246920846,
-0.0299535282,
-0.0224418379,
0.0040421039,
0.0215451512,
0.0487551466,
-0.0237790179,
0.0040744198,
-0.0110312831,
0.004247983,
0.0708347112,
-0.0517401695,
-0.0183778964,
0.0135210771,
2.855e-7,
0.0135766678,
0.0036602335,
-0.0339789875,
-0.0327439606,
0.0016930419,
0.019968275,
-0.0377017781,
0.0281672999,
0.0180153064,
0.016480267,
0.0001452009,
0.0306880213,
0.0700189397,
0.0083585652,
-0.0592359602,
-0.0242596008,
-0.0150325811,
0.0377687663,
-0.0163027309,
-0.0065401481,
0.0040477407,
0.1279677302,
0.0372857042,
-0.0055991504,
0.0142321782,
-0.0248059984,
0.0554365739,
-0.0418340079,
0.0094107874,
-0.0279719308,
0.0176773425,
0.067773506,
-0.0255755056,
-0.0016071792,
-0.0481830426,
0.0699548274,
0.0026328601,
0.0311349612,
-0.0221773554,
0.0053847646,
0.0219929349,
0.0320596695,
-0.0387270153,
-0.0495601483,
0.0489352196,
-0.0486515686,
-0.0168312676,
-0.0585080162,
-0.0278920308,
0.0235276166,
-0.01181194,
-0.0279002842,
-0.0193104781,
0.0383834913,
0.0688494965,
0.0015074896,
-0.0415630341,
-0.0573522709,
-0.0116647445,
0.0162205938,
-0.0428344198,
-0.0429048836,
-0.0328792892,
-0.0494273417,
0.0244059823,
-0.0202545486,
0.0204859599,
2.748230946e-34,
0.0017760894,
-0.033212591,
0.0045890836,
0.0526731908,
0.0076478198,
-0.0501359962,
0.0422204919,
0.0106437448,
0.0063529662,
-0.0861234143,
-0.0160162337
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10502v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10502v2 | A Measure-Theoretic Characterization of Tight Language Models | 2022-12-20T18:17:11 | 2023-08-21T18:01:57 | Li Du, Lucas Torroba Hennigen, Tiago Pimentel, Clara Meister, Jason Eisner, Ryan Cotterell | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.FL | Language modeling, a central task in natural language processing, involves
estimating a probability distribution over strings. In most cases, the
estimated distribution sums to 1 over all finite strings. However, in some
pathological cases, probability mass can ``leak'' onto the set of infinite
sequences. In order to characterize the notion of leakage more precisely, this
paper offers a measure-theoretic treatment of language modeling. We prove that
many popular language model families are in fact tight, meaning that they will
not leak in this sense. We also generalize characterizations of tightness
proposed in previous works. | [
0.0110409837,
0.0593182296,
-0.0327981189,
0.0385219492,
-0.0527475998,
-0.0100581674,
-0.0785616562,
0.016921876,
-0.0401845723,
0.0218039695,
0.0059666513,
-0.0821214318,
0.0481851436,
0.0546987765,
0.001558908,
-0.0255297851,
0.0181168988,
-0.0473329984,
-0.0148827173,
-0.0220281389,
0.0015970598,
-0.0531032421,
0.0157836508,
0.0116925212,
0.0474634431,
-0.0087593012,
0.0140994545,
-0.0628742948,
-0.0424692743,
0.0092057921,
-0.0190546624,
0.0694617853,
-0.0597010851,
0.00596201,
0.0000015042,
-0.0237553976,
-0.0103083849,
-0.0129217561,
-0.0099171074,
0.0279445946,
-0.023536345,
-0.0494174957,
-0.0017228801,
0.0076164906,
0.02805987,
0.0304259881,
0.0770793036,
-0.0242612436,
0.025931742,
0.0379527025,
0.0093849767,
0.015426578,
0.0249791276,
-0.0307003055,
0.0384880006,
-0.0469724461,
0.0184665006,
0.0021249475,
-0.0094513884,
-0.0151323853,
-0.0174769294,
0.0403454416,
-0.0020522145,
0.0175860096,
-0.0285797641,
0.0204329025,
-0.0176382363,
-0.04608896,
0.0284254085,
0.0096137645,
-0.0328599066,
-0.0257974416,
0.0096151605,
-0.0155896246,
-0.0188281331,
0.0635540336,
-0.0293083228,
0.0344071537,
-0.0004441775,
0.0480392501,
-0.026464887,
0.0413307399,
0.039966803,
-0.0131752621,
-0.0269511733,
0.0764345229,
0.023101747,
0.0071165776,
-0.0544934534,
-0.0031305894,
-0.0489097089,
-0.0479559749,
-0.0192067251,
-0.0089599388,
0.0308028404,
0.0303319544,
-0.0695572123,
-0.0091523584,
0.0471227951,
-0.0828924999,
-0.0087474734,
0.0125584174,
0.0176548213,
0.0240076631,
0.0247827023,
0.0155651886,
0.0156522561,
-0.0065319999,
-0.0118698431,
0.011854236,
-0.0109527959,
0.0059797727,
-0.0051969555,
0.0331634842,
-0.0159978997,
-0.0359964073,
-0.0590079613,
0.0593107902,
-0.0083571505,
-0.0022215617,
-0.0088149002,
-0.0031428868,
-0.0622668192,
-0.0053651496,
-0.0580366626,
-0.0121634752,
0.0320660956,
0.0323419347,
-0.0346715562,
-0.0211842954,
-0.0109453257,
0.0061651901,
0.0080218781,
-0.017514227,
-0.0689177811,
0.0582275167,
0.0513280183,
-0.0265589431,
-0.0379501097,
-0.0003472544,
-0.053702876,
-0.0296621006,
-0.0564368702,
-0.0567652099,
-0.0457840711,
0.0002943599,
-0.002567675,
-0.0226078033,
0.0202567931,
-0.0208351463,
-0.0409000032,
0.0639500618,
-0.0134696364,
0.0072140684,
-0.0505667292,
0.0095963804,
0.0208686758,
0.0687697902,
0.0294893738,
-0.0118532423,
0.0668068305,
-0.0154744694,
0.0129638975,
0.0626580268,
-0.0042351768,
0.0244257096,
-0.0298720077,
-0.0069518914,
0.0434751995,
-0.0435049869,
0.0142477201,
0.0771703199,
0.0018481268,
-0.048756294,
0.0553955883,
0.035637524,
0.0088432841,
0.0178591404,
0.0070036813,
-0.011426907,
-0.0091109378,
0.0945653021,
-0.0050287233,
-0.0485004969,
-0.0188575443,
0.0180802569,
0.0648017824,
-0.0218271147,
-0.0322072208,
-0.0215036944,
-0.03370912,
-0.0379167236,
-0.0156671368,
-0.0370810777,
0.0578870662,
-0.0016580239,
0.0352063775,
0.0854554996,
0.0125777274,
-0.0118043395,
0.0280485731,
-0.041704189,
0.0108972089,
-0.0064567858,
-0.0044233589,
-0.0459488332,
-0.0005135309,
0.0219381768,
-0.0384601727,
-0.0058485558,
0.0147783328,
0.0126126818,
0.0157349743,
0.02250682,
0.0448740982,
0.0519073866,
0.0468147956,
-0.0029341865,
-0.0705701411,
0.0092711207,
0.0105666397,
-0.021769762,
-0.0215710849,
0.0042032711,
-0.0152044827,
-0.0265471619,
-0.0027327838,
-0.0047088121,
0.0632807389,
-0.0041119112,
-0.0314181149,
0.0655211955,
0.0572190955,
-0.0062069069,
-0.0241528954,
-0.0274747871,
-0.0208247323,
0.0075778663,
0.0424780957,
-0.0176480245,
0.0603120327,
-0.006921642,
0.0021175097,
-0.0320282169,
0.0244025327,
-0.0528672971,
0.0637331679,
-0.0196504146,
0.0580640063,
-0.0239960607,
0.0438269787,
-0.0149344718,
0.0585338995,
-0.0408252217,
0.1124038398,
-0.0356756262,
0.0164593961,
0.0159328301,
-0.0308190715,
-0.044493001,
0.0431490131,
-0.0274061803,
0.0300258584,
0.0875094905,
-0.0431325026,
0.0090189828,
-0.0371313468,
0.0105521269,
0.0107638016,
0.022741355,
0.0438474491,
0.0039161691,
0.0378453694,
-0.0172515195,
-0.0197262187,
-0.0103432825,
-0.0250454005,
0.0375280268,
0.0453694649,
0.0193845201,
0.0368497297,
-0.0346444175,
-0.0270186514,
-0.0323939472,
0.0033726329,
0.047787454,
-0.005649921,
-0.0252110045,
-0.0275768284,
0.0768371001,
-0.0415113382,
0.0487575382,
-0.0120373145,
-0.028284518,
-0.0130869038,
-0.0060554831,
0.006911166,
0.017737003,
0.0125952587,
0.0148789501,
0.0169044714,
-0.0170620233,
0.0131820096,
-0.0345907509,
-0.0637124106,
-0.06460841,
-0.0428591259,
-0.0135977902,
0.0004673325,
0.0719718635,
0.03158167,
-0.0618480481,
-0.039370954,
0.04698468,
-0.0154888127,
0.0071004606,
-0.0048887613,
-0.010776042,
-0.0384828933,
0.0790919065,
-0.0279822052,
-0.0415821299,
-0.0028356158,
-0.0474627577,
0.0566259213,
0.0023830046,
-0.0457834527,
-0.0191236604,
0.0722327903,
0.037478555,
0.0105235148,
0.0487718694,
0.007367203,
-0.0522925369,
-0.0051482557,
0.055384323,
-0.0237905029,
0.04207379,
-0.0346575379,
0.0269649476,
-0.0088813147,
-0.0117542865,
-0.0198412221,
-0.0641240329,
0.0045982078,
-0.0187339224,
0.0283382442,
-0.0379383564,
-0.0090646334,
0.0781179294,
-0.0101112053,
0.0214772392,
-0.0025560849,
-0.0031073531,
-0.0101540769,
0.0410068743,
0.0757688507,
-0.0550083853,
0.0185795575,
-0.0351249017,
-0.0149189448,
0.0095828222,
0.0117309224,
0.0861414075,
0.0006089212,
-0.0216740444,
0.0208659042,
-0.0097333537,
-0.0575820878,
0.0425865538,
0.0294809081,
-0.0235545766,
-0.0037220421,
0.1186265871,
0.0078574158,
0.0099834269,
0.0576350465,
0.0210440606,
0.0515075475,
0.0174649358,
-0.0313288644,
-0.0451200716,
0.0034643901,
-0.0063073337,
-0.0075309854,
-0.0468057804,
-0.0660665035,
-0.0158599727,
-0.0770658106,
-0.0544661358,
0.0135686202,
-0.0139814438,
-0.0340242647,
-0.0240180586,
0.0510654636,
-0.0541328974,
-0.0065490566,
-0.033656396,
0.0206908975,
0.0136351734,
0.0677887127,
0.0237581022,
-0.047969263,
0.0048943162,
-0.0259485003,
0.0428732671,
0.0066848099,
0.0375042222,
-0.0547122583,
-0.0495344028,
0.0052168295,
-0.0228766073,
-0.0495047383,
0.0526039824,
0.0061544999,
0.0492619202,
-0.0164400805,
0.0083597889,
0.0112715242,
0.0022183154,
0.0060774391,
-0.0095753158,
0.076483041,
-0.0201491937,
-0.0311826896,
0.0072447276,
-0.039366968,
-0.0244682841,
0.0566339418,
-0.024302708,
-0.0305565149,
0.0348945074,
-0.0038468877,
0.0151103698,
0.0612826422,
-0.0223695654,
0.0201916303,
0.0011012987,
-0.0933400765,
-0.0457439944,
0.0177083574,
-0.0279732607,
0.0597081855,
-0.0133118602,
0.0462580509,
0.0417094007,
-0.0218195617,
0.0346463211,
0.0034955188,
-0.0550966337,
-0.0047637224,
-0.0170889832,
0.0178438295,
0.0098958183,
0.0260366984,
-0.0522631891,
0.0122426869,
-0.1176753044,
-0.0874968171,
-0.0155648934,
0.0363479145,
0.0465646572,
-0.0291949064,
-0.0075320737,
-0.0581483915,
-0.0223387051,
0.0279448722,
-0.0368575938,
0.0217111837,
0.0271712914,
-0.0119530335,
0.0178124588,
0.0647776872,
-0.0433849506,
-0.0236828476,
-0.0187685005,
0.0295546148,
-0.0387324728,
-0.1176329181,
0.0346300974,
0.0166936535,
0.034309715,
0.0008921922,
-0.0270998571,
0.0102258138,
0.0004437282,
-0.0017451496,
-0.0212411694,
-0.0140166385,
0.0296815429,
0.0286795422,
0.0219092127,
-0.028259214,
-0.0661974624,
0.0150424344,
0.0274853297,
0.0120325349,
-0.0181316454,
0.0634349436,
-0.0265172049,
0.0526710637,
0.0119093861,
0.0249303132,
0.025860047,
-0.0287323855,
0.0212511085,
0.0114160823,
-0.0041447552,
0.0237776805,
0.0348335132,
0.0179459341,
-0.0219408106,
-0.0519342944,
-0.0281641912,
-0.0054404084,
0.0499589592,
0.0192350652,
-0.0512828529,
-0.0342927314,
-0.0301828757,
0.0146565549,
-0.0623887926,
0.0201664008,
0.0305039287,
0.0132852178,
0.0049848598,
0.0129572777,
-0.0208571237,
0.0475017764,
0.0933992937,
0.0020312234,
0.032538157,
-0.028874021,
-0.0667627975,
-0.0202779323,
0.012657064,
-0.0085800709,
0.0607945286,
-0.0147004817,
0.0278135762,
-0.077836968,
-0.1111295447,
0.0296620522,
0.0093202647,
0.0455533229,
0.0266790818,
-0.0279052947,
0.0350669771,
0.0263588428,
0.049202431,
-0.0557347499,
-0.0139102349,
-0.0232065693,
0.0250443369,
-0.0112059265,
-5.786337146e-33,
-0.03033619,
-0.0321194455,
-0.0581736825,
0.0125306277,
0.0424189791,
0.0040570255,
-0.0243861936,
0.0311567802,
-0.0051597315,
-0.0332204551,
0.0019767331,
0.0102555072,
0.0028846273,
0.00914005,
0.0067797489,
0.0021898227,
0.004256418,
-0.0118106678,
-0.0213877447,
-0.0084962491,
0.0280104559,
-0.0181566235,
0.0043920451,
-0.0036224066,
0.0445176885,
-0.0285265241,
-0.0062548309,
0.0650363714,
0.0337762274,
0.0560355559,
-0.034380056,
0.0386222266,
0.0083121788,
-0.0392804779,
-0.0220926441,
0.0089632384,
0.0033647411,
-0.0593989007,
0.0432990417,
-0.0323381498,
0.0363521017,
-0.0157424826,
0.0236448105,
-0.0250381678,
0.0099245897,
0.0043398193,
0.0315943882,
-0.0403854735,
-0.0475655347,
-0.0211053714,
0.0323133282,
0.0523404814,
-0.0015327201,
0.0161277391,
-0.0157743823,
-0.0367327407,
0.0062642968,
-0.042593874,
0.0325221345,
-0.0023454612,
0.0488094017,
0.1100645363,
0.0317428112,
0.0363443568,
0.0216890164,
0.0284725968,
-0.0096320445,
0.0035450372,
0.0342395492,
0.0154345417,
0.0399633721,
0.0022589823,
0.0259278975,
0.0333153196,
0.0512021184,
0.0045010471,
-0.011314,
-0.0224177465,
-0.0196616445,
0.0084855175,
0.0339199454,
0.016594125,
-0.0424686261,
-0.0048769834,
-0.0742029026,
-0.0386081971,
-0.0091665229,
0.0374458171,
-0.0247232523,
0.013583228,
0.0107969362,
0.0301331319,
0.008593631,
-0.050545495,
-0.0614335351,
-0.0134386141,
0.0010974451,
-0.0270280074,
-0.030124452,
0.0404000394,
-0.0127759846,
-0.0242651571,
-0.050906349,
0.0007799335,
-0.0203173719,
0.0033939297,
0.0089415209,
0.0063596363,
-0.048685167,
-0.0231569428,
-0.0396787636,
-0.004269802,
0.0052140434,
0.0219899379,
0.0584339276,
-0.0226139948,
-0.0073217838,
0.0315244161,
0.0416074209,
-0.0142567446,
0.0086953994,
0.0360193551,
0.0012727666,
0.0130663775,
-0.0304612517,
-0.0570443831,
-0.0282544605,
0.0436733514,
0.0913029686,
-0.0369080231,
-0.0180899668,
-0.0011145318,
2.374e-7,
0.0576169044,
-0.014830702,
-0.0107959798,
0.0194120333,
0.0214271825,
0.0389608331,
-0.0265956037,
0.0199383926,
-0.0464173108,
-0.0258391481,
-0.0091428598,
-0.032382831,
0.0089608226,
-0.0036851706,
-0.058975134,
0.0059767202,
-0.0686514452,
0.0019023141,
-0.0078928219,
0.0130761322,
0.0388456732,
0.112532869,
0.0459488891,
0.0107235629,
-0.0222290494,
-0.0997072831,
0.0124910465,
0.0064984327,
0.0101969521,
0.0329699367,
0.0653397888,
0.0153377485,
0.0025079367,
0.0327603631,
-0.0217195153,
0.0554846525,
0.0178875457,
0.0210338924,
0.0034961475,
0.0358496681,
0.0004931663,
-0.0654445663,
-0.0334250629,
-0.002444529,
0.0523079671,
-0.0247052517,
-0.0408817567,
-0.0452070609,
0.0172799584,
0.0167564582,
-0.0056751254,
0.0119357537,
-0.0221794527,
0.0017838912,
-0.002360333,
-0.0191678144,
0.0204686075,
-0.0198022611,
-0.039385017,
-0.0060874443,
-0.0459395498,
-0.0409179218,
0.0014723389,
-0.010648408,
0.0151325511,
-0.0527930483,
0.0363766178,
2.356472658e-34,
0.0576624274,
-0.0288684908,
-0.0302683376,
-0.0198210571,
0.0226377305,
-0.0561805777,
0.0170874503,
0.0325210206,
0.022866223,
-0.0608368963,
-0.0425162837
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10498v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10498v2 | SimpleStyle: An Adaptable Style Transfer Approach | 2022-12-20T18:12:49 | 2022-12-22T16:26:36 | Elron Bandel, Yoav Katz, Noam Slonim, Liat Ein-Dor | cs.CL | cs.CL | Attribute-controlled text rewriting, also known as text style-transfer, has a
crucial role in regulating attributes and biases of textual training data and a
machine generated text. In this work we present SimpleStyle, a minimalist yet
effective approach for style-transfer composed of two simple ingredients:
controlled denoising and output filtering. Despite the simplicity of our
approach, which can be succinctly described with a few lines of code, it is
competitive with previous state-of-the-art methods both in automatic and in
human evaluation. To demonstrate the adaptability and practical value of our
system beyond academic data, we apply SimpleStyle to transfer a wide range of
text attributes appearing in real-world textual data from social networks.
Additionally, we introduce a novel "soft noising" technique that further
improves the performance of our system. We also show that teaching a student
model to generate the output of SimpleStyle can result in a system that
performs style transfer of equivalent quality with only a single greedy-decoded
sample. Finally, we suggest our method as a remedy for the fundamental
incompatible baseline issue that holds progress in the field. We offer our
protocol as a simple yet strong baseline for works that wish to make
incremental advancements in the field of attribute controlled text rewriting. | [
0.0057308655,
0.0626365617,
-0.0084512727,
0.0286080819,
-0.020979993,
-0.0133603504,
-0.008227692,
0.0403663367,
-0.0159528777,
-0.0291788001,
-0.0135179935,
-0.0040908619,
0.0118714627,
0.0379798673,
0.0395099036,
-0.0466485322,
-0.0135500161,
0.0045767813,
0.0604592003,
-0.0166919585,
0.0536608212,
0.0196953025,
0.0430686548,
0.0033662249,
0.009683257,
0.0060717142,
0.0209848396,
0.0445591286,
0.0110093802,
0.0455572344,
0.0248139761,
0.0619274825,
-0.0240407754,
0.0108701233,
0.0000022413,
-0.0152062774,
-0.0492500663,
0.0090984534,
0.0541339926,
0.0077084363,
0.0982900783,
0.0249149129,
-0.0185439102,
-0.0084827086,
-0.0409018584,
0.0153359678,
0.0620987006,
0.0388101973,
0.0882812589,
0.0830351338,
-0.0451098122,
-0.0686022341,
-0.0206597541,
-0.0166181587,
0.0272502899,
-0.001018382,
0.0382515714,
-0.0405669063,
-0.0117747085,
0.0332891494,
0.0027732281,
0.0469246395,
-0.0316803902,
-0.0401635468,
0.0714663938,
-0.0048605283,
-0.0163386911,
0.0152188679,
0.0139080286,
0.057560835,
-0.012953735,
-0.0492022745,
0.0475236401,
0.0081803473,
0.0235124305,
0.0036328747,
-0.0508278087,
-0.0173977017,
-0.0004375149,
0.0242935549,
-0.0419172831,
0.0165391285,
-0.0021349913,
0.0114697246,
0.0018709884,
-0.0211114381,
0.0128362924,
-0.0190662276,
-0.0262206942,
0.0456333905,
0.0295031052,
-0.0424962118,
0.0524680912,
0.0046056262,
0.0369646885,
-0.0261084624,
-0.1117114648,
-0.0581005104,
-0.0340170041,
-0.0020230454,
0.0431778729,
-0.0125225009,
0.0270095263,
0.0319479741,
-0.0513928272,
0.0063513303,
0.0079175606,
0.0169010647,
-0.001685316,
-0.0059956969,
-0.0550017022,
0.0140277855,
-0.0211031865,
0.0118153766,
0.0067675207,
0.000115723,
-0.0361795612,
-0.024899466,
-0.0064124274,
-0.0160690192,
-0.0145683372,
0.0259231366,
-0.0536415391,
-0.0354196839,
0.0344704427,
0.0490685925,
0.0327795036,
0.0189713985,
-0.0002650408,
0.0030650906,
-0.0035864492,
0.011921864,
0.0806854889,
-0.0132872378,
-0.017775258,
0.0294499993,
-0.0575343631,
0.0108643929,
-0.0186237041,
-0.0557828061,
0.0055135754,
0.0068595447,
-0.0197128113,
-0.0731684119,
-0.0056705535,
-0.0102773588,
-0.0038161068,
-0.1110810488,
0.0011590102,
0.0436354578,
-0.0730523467,
0.0476469398,
-0.0218448471,
0.0041752076,
0.0122839333,
0.0058056302,
0.012537241,
0.0094864881,
0.039887324,
0.0799008086,
0.046101965,
-0.0144856935,
0.0344350375,
0.0155852968,
0.0520779006,
0.0407850482,
-0.0474066325,
-0.0568255186,
-0.010663351,
0.0032913978,
0.0434360802,
0.0648723021,
0.0000956967,
-0.0100551778,
0.142848894,
-0.011209379,
0.053745769,
0.0457449928,
0.005862745,
0.0580427386,
0.0054071746,
-0.0080960225,
-0.0183879957,
0.0178121272,
-0.0323420353,
0.0167275406,
0.0043498785,
0.031343855,
-0.006153869,
-0.0130554251,
0.0558124185,
-0.0093081882,
0.0389308035,
-0.0176697709,
0.018026473,
0.0698697343,
-0.0343607813,
-0.0297864433,
0.0136287035,
-0.0534223616,
0.0329764746,
-0.0243154392,
0.0295830239,
0.080026634,
0.0541006885,
-0.0074920673,
0.0529176854,
-0.0293218195,
0.0122133503,
-0.0129652722,
-0.0012722529,
-0.0161043908,
0.0142157907,
-0.0786000416,
-0.0198597293,
-0.0062981723,
0.0017457082,
0.0070715263,
-0.0042921863,
0.0372303315,
0.0129185701,
-0.0253169518,
-0.0698333234,
0.0444822684,
0.0290085208,
-0.0367887318,
0.0237595607,
0.0030353891,
-0.0312386919,
0.0213723872,
-0.0270976499,
-0.0031028218,
-0.0190641321,
-0.0254302491,
-0.0243468732,
-0.0087115923,
-0.0393916965,
-0.0325182229,
-0.0013921204,
-0.0730904341,
-0.0229424462,
0.0457244851,
-0.0529406928,
-0.0451314859,
0.0076945829,
-0.0338541791,
-0.0106063895,
-0.0094244136,
0.0222045984,
-0.0154333394,
0.0325160772,
-0.0370985344,
0.0193013549,
0.0380465612,
-0.040967375,
0.0069780569,
-0.0585022904,
-0.0084911361,
-0.0143847475,
-0.0018008283,
-0.0240332149,
-0.0008600436,
0.0181958415,
0.0237612408,
0.0308125392,
-0.0140772648,
-0.028708905,
-0.018464772,
-0.0161682628,
0.0041157235,
-0.0025790418,
0.0399386771,
0.0332003087,
0.0019241991,
-0.0178736243,
-0.0592475943,
0.0199501384,
-0.0354607515,
0.0018769813,
0.0635802001,
-0.0234442074,
-0.0099158874,
-0.0327916108,
-0.0169146806,
0.0180561934,
0.0379674733,
0.0507544093,
-0.036788784,
-0.0397801921,
0.0026531592,
-0.01137718,
-0.0217292756,
0.0462993011,
-0.0462566353,
-0.0398754403,
-0.0246126801,
-0.0016172612,
0.0780085921,
0.0312179197,
0.0056480183,
-0.0001883428,
0.0151785836,
-0.0095759351,
-0.0236834548,
-0.02867225,
0.033515662,
-0.0088911299,
-0.0705236867,
0.0288625862,
0.0278859399,
0.0333210193,
0.007209965,
-0.0514716879,
0.0406796858,
-0.0008860492,
-0.0442622826,
-0.020789016,
0.0129923029,
0.0085363071,
0.0058351546,
-0.0306400899,
-0.0262927078,
0.0582683571,
-0.0169298463,
0.0008068397,
-0.0071261954,
-0.0351771526,
0.0031830282,
0.0176618919,
-0.0058265505,
0.0327892676,
0.0475930013,
-0.006062333,
-0.058684729,
-0.0086106136,
0.0944957659,
-0.025019424,
-0.0047446527,
-0.0366255231,
0.0071748905,
-0.0291573387,
-0.0149109066,
0.0164453425,
-0.0709822029,
0.0002589524,
-0.0107948715,
0.0091977734,
-0.0417774841,
-0.0124812797,
-0.0066928375,
0.0161981694,
0.0516451262,
-0.0532029234,
-0.0214109756,
-0.0062918556,
0.0802118704,
0.0153004378,
-0.0443571322,
-0.0552229099,
-0.0239115916,
-0.0036915541,
0.0692103654,
-0.0099947872,
-0.0001205595,
-0.0082214121,
-0.0129841249,
0.0107595427,
-0.0050076204,
-0.0220079478,
0.0053492486,
0.0797137842,
-0.0603900552,
-0.0192291215,
0.0826877654,
0.0012816922,
-0.0480508693,
-0.0271510389,
0.0182920098,
0.0461026654,
-0.0088698547,
0.0187029913,
-0.0995092392,
-0.045541089,
0.0050338935,
0.0687451512,
0.0197004899,
-0.0461280569,
0.0005009569,
-0.0407655723,
0.0190584194,
0.0287288204,
-0.0549267381,
-0.0255491957,
-0.017496556,
0.0128703695,
-0.029410582,
-0.0465107784,
-0.0285757389,
0.0045288033,
0.0168460943,
-0.0050603379,
-0.0042658369,
-0.0282616671,
-0.0201472193,
-0.0012739425,
0.0688084364,
0.0356325209,
0.0757620782,
-0.0055145798,
-0.0236253422,
-0.0136050051,
0.0026171287,
-0.0136674801,
-0.0197312627,
0.0705670044,
0.010685619,
-0.007254601,
-0.0144601092,
0.051934503,
0.0008992017,
0.0131727653,
0.0257200226,
0.0139566148,
0.0187368672,
-0.0568344668,
-0.0154559342,
-0.0357234888,
0.0456146151,
0.0497787334,
0.0533936806,
-0.0431517884,
-0.0622147955,
-0.0707960203,
-0.0128698852,
-0.0618482828,
-0.0925509259,
-0.0155013902,
-0.0731194913,
-0.0429478921,
-0.1224016026,
-0.003831567,
-0.0031398609,
0.0343109593,
0.0070394557,
-0.0344912298,
0.0503184088,
-0.0129988287,
-0.0573267825,
-0.0626884252,
-0.040167179,
0.0360002071,
0.0093209082,
-0.040036682,
-0.0013887469,
-0.0270970967,
0.0128823249,
0.0071283667,
-0.0307900924,
-0.0505343713,
0.0297580436,
0.0228001121,
0.0158370025,
0.044312302,
-0.0402868204,
-0.082899712,
0.0665386841,
0.0463446155,
-0.0203000549,
0.0185903329,
0.0535116307,
-0.0358809456,
0.005679185,
0.0361181311,
-0.0243975613,
0.0377657451,
0.0366582498,
-0.0244373847,
-0.0197152235,
-0.0265822187,
0.0023782123,
0.0285320934,
-0.0263765883,
0.0043332949,
-0.00858369,
-0.0138265686,
-0.021754507,
-0.0464952737,
-0.0083231162,
-0.053482689,
-0.0091035087,
0.037999738,
0.0665746406,
-0.0118995747,
0.0074602244,
0.0302398466,
0.0299845021,
-0.0722730681,
0.0040537547,
-0.0267201252,
0.0403204001,
0.0247495044,
0.0244206656,
-0.0001203071,
0.0325248167,
0.0239685215,
0.0496671163,
-0.0353640728,
-0.0140882963,
0.0319334194,
0.0142486766,
-0.0111786416,
0.0414000936,
-0.0618111119,
0.0150881326,
-0.0537314899,
-0.0083996253,
0.0019604706,
0.0036061967,
0.1003211886,
-0.0162366964,
-0.0096298568,
-0.0069082608,
0.0723580346,
0.0058269855,
-0.0010812413,
-0.0378291421,
-0.0180364829,
-0.0009618867,
0.0042410884,
0.1058417112,
0.0011370472,
0.0147468904,
-0.0200178176,
-0.0504247136,
-0.0294975284,
-0.0149661181,
0.0378950574,
0.0012232598,
0.0200061388,
-0.0479795896,
0.0117530255,
-0.045776166,
0.0350058898,
-0.0599316843,
0.0395179912,
-0.0163146313,
0.0286810268,
0.0261709839,
-0.0101982979,
0.0190174524,
-0.0268494487,
0.0094927186,
0.0396901034,
-0.0310653858,
-0.0041602114,
-6.525909703e-33,
-0.0064701829,
-0.0145121142,
-0.03995011,
0.0033456301,
-0.0346692055,
0.0107740927,
-0.0551747419,
-0.0369249806,
0.0166028272,
0.0553191938,
-0.020690728,
0.004242124,
0.0119670294,
0.0322616287,
0.0109752836,
0.0424839668,
0.0577276424,
0.0008492714,
-0.0277024191,
0.0612838268,
0.032844428,
0.0257615577,
0.0452372469,
-0.1178696081,
-0.0081606163,
-0.0147805214,
-0.0502978526,
-0.0272595007,
0.0770840272,
-0.0272241272,
0.0126162209,
0.0421219096,
0.0110707106,
-0.0600145385,
-0.0320212208,
0.0199272111,
-0.0611399412,
-0.035215579,
-0.0106541747,
-0.0028670407,
-0.0080830939,
-0.0181144811,
0.0707954168,
-0.0208278354,
0.0288149286,
-0.0009256128,
0.0688815638,
-0.0288410671,
0.0059291921,
-0.0348943658,
-0.0661834553,
0.0360524654,
-0.0334055759,
-0.0045121196,
0.0293881074,
-0.0012827886,
0.0008734264,
-0.0039527174,
-0.0575590357,
0.0357802697,
0.0061538522,
0.0316438228,
-0.0000597374,
0.0195942447,
-0.0091406396,
0.0125772767,
0.0007699303,
0.0485900827,
-0.0439418331,
0.0016576735,
0.0046595884,
0.0451450236,
0.0585393384,
0.0902674496,
-0.0232231207,
-0.0393955745,
-0.0047411141,
0.050168246,
0.0248847585,
-0.0055182115,
-0.0138436127,
0.0513991043,
-0.027223194,
-0.0381503329,
-0.0123130865,
-0.0331439488,
-0.0156244496,
-0.0041693719,
-0.0134205464,
-0.011587875,
-0.0801150128,
0.0478101783,
-0.0010727367,
-0.0315263122,
-0.0249973033,
-0.0214321055,
-0.0365680717,
0.0563832335,
-0.0221742261,
-0.0589169189,
-0.0392115228,
0.0063747056,
0.0540896542,
0.0288649239,
0.0116501646,
0.0030281227,
0.0546916574,
0.0427789539,
-0.0482419468,
-0.0282724686,
-0.0014209904,
0.0067779231,
0.0318738781,
-0.0227835439,
-0.0145832198,
0.0104117533,
-0.0146804117,
0.005495308,
0.0506804511,
0.0199354868,
-0.0145793278,
-0.0339566804,
0.0484406501,
-0.0142388009,
-0.0504130609,
-0.0219061319,
-0.0370371714,
-0.034543857,
0.0184490494,
-0.0371841826,
-0.0298829619,
-0.0350119658,
2.802e-7,
0.022264272,
0.0437394679,
0.0230563562,
-0.025968805,
0.0124049159,
0.0544272251,
0.0533394702,
0.0493519902,
-0.0048142388,
-0.0069138482,
0.0261529721,
0.0340043902,
0.0647854954,
-0.0045002191,
-0.0842503682,
0.0108697945,
-0.0518536791,
-0.0105079366,
-0.0300700925,
-0.0124128237,
0.0273297932,
0.0081748785,
0.0475109555,
-0.0174517613,
0.03493369,
-0.009917059,
0.039284572,
0.0032073909,
0.0272447467,
0.0154237682,
0.0558513179,
-0.0379762538,
-0.0256556254,
-0.00828877,
-0.0374364406,
-0.0486111715,
0.0287579149,
0.0594959483,
-0.0268862415,
0.0528314374,
0.0003031301,
-0.0329791307,
0.0306775775,
-0.0490910374,
0.0254888646,
0.0135510359,
-0.0256256238,
-0.0215289369,
-0.0473885648,
-0.0013596957,
-0.0044436329,
0.012522121,
-0.0319921449,
0.0020093736,
0.0137575716,
0.0514781736,
-0.0538234599,
-0.0616339929,
-0.0158104356,
-0.0525330193,
0.0056773596,
-0.0350556634,
-0.0202985257,
0.0241905842,
0.0213517491,
-0.0537872203,
0.0571460538,
2.631873306e-34,
0.0151354214,
-0.008122961,
0.0136043923,
0.0254143327,
0.0119541306,
0.0096611427,
0.0131874233,
0.0050751618,
0.0263289735,
-0.0591786541,
-0.0212442093
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10496v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10496v1 | Precise Zero-Shot Dense Retrieval without Relevance Labels | 2022-12-20T18:09:52 | 2022-12-20T18:09:52 | Luyu Gao, Xueguang Ma, Jimmy Lin, Jamie Callan | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | While dense retrieval has been shown effective and efficient across tasks and
languages, it remains difficult to create effective fully zero-shot dense
retrieval systems when no relevance label is available. In this paper, we
recognize the difficulty of zero-shot learning and encoding relevance. Instead,
we propose to pivot through Hypothetical Document Embeddings~(HyDE). Given a
query, HyDE first zero-shot instructs an instruction-following language model
(e.g. InstructGPT) to generate a hypothetical document. The document captures
relevance patterns but is unreal and may contain false details. Then, an
unsupervised contrastively learned encoder~(e.g. Contriever) encodes the
document into an embedding vector. This vector identifies a neighborhood in the
corpus embedding space, where similar real documents are retrieved based on
vector similarity. This second step ground the generated document to the actual
corpus, with the encoder's dense bottleneck filtering out the incorrect
details. Our experiments show that HyDE significantly outperforms the
state-of-the-art unsupervised dense retriever Contriever and shows strong
performance comparable to fine-tuned retrievers, across various tasks (e.g. web
search, QA, fact verification) and languages~(e.g. sw, ko, ja). | [
0.0218477864,
0.0429849327,
0.0226456895,
0.0514942296,
-0.0285748616,
0.0138833029,
-0.0032540229,
0.048716709,
-0.0371695422,
-0.0435207896,
-0.0263221301,
-0.0114787621,
-0.0375419222,
0.0293234978,
0.0079136984,
-0.0017447169,
0.0497598462,
0.0370720252,
0.0225214232,
0.0043296427,
-0.0100361714,
0.0108959088,
0.0058897673,
-0.0007402063,
-0.009982748,
0.0208114441,
-0.0336219519,
0.0368482247,
-0.0084180851,
-0.0051471344,
0.0090479366,
0.0330802053,
0.0538202003,
0.0402706563,
0.0000017562,
-0.0212592911,
-0.0233089831,
-0.0041524335,
-0.0571962483,
-0.0399231352,
0.0217902884,
-0.0422407575,
0.0116300154,
-0.003609787,
-0.0087352302,
-0.0735039935,
0.0306796543,
0.0349949077,
0.037620917,
0.0892918855,
-0.0259608328,
-0.016745992,
0.0282394402,
-0.0132763525,
0.050891947,
-0.0494907498,
0.0250348207,
-0.0483234227,
0.0093493182,
0.0701226667,
-0.0132008409,
0.0190188605,
0.0042014089,
-0.0175001845,
0.0404070728,
0.0215236861,
-0.0710466877,
0.0120029403,
0.0562276058,
0.0607160442,
-0.0317420438,
-0.0331561007,
-0.0055978922,
0.0214515068,
-0.0407591127,
0.0083716409,
-0.049257718,
0.0148226144,
0.0011823705,
0.0159110613,
-0.0041614375,
0.0216544084,
0.003032295,
-0.0004081009,
0.0037458609,
0.0059576971,
0.0196063854,
-0.0469395556,
-0.0232120492,
0.0219224915,
-0.0254849382,
-0.0358772911,
-0.0119449766,
0.0367510505,
-0.0101429438,
-0.0034790367,
-0.0321258456,
-0.0041132639,
0.0350295566,
-0.0511774085,
0.025875967,
0.024793772,
-0.0216511618,
0.0903683901,
-0.0357206166,
0.0406462401,
0.005907841,
0.0312434733,
-0.0482699908,
-0.0488751344,
-0.035084106,
0.0049072951,
-0.0379411094,
0.0627925843,
-0.0442038327,
-0.0115459329,
0.0049973568,
0.0174739324,
0.0008586434,
0.0326919481,
-0.043705944,
0.0319382511,
-0.0667139739,
-0.0233763624,
-0.0227920357,
0.0259907264,
-0.0179495495,
0.0034460719,
-0.0232372135,
-0.0653532147,
-0.03058034,
0.0277412161,
0.0420268551,
-0.0329363681,
0.0019575765,
-0.0024316416,
-0.0180973988,
-0.0767798275,
-0.0526715964,
-0.0247300938,
0.0373153239,
-0.0321336947,
-0.0211260039,
-0.053645242,
0.0328715183,
-0.0172106754,
-0.0341190472,
-0.0383988954,
-0.0337589197,
0.0618446395,
-0.0176747292,
0.0649299845,
-0.002984693,
-0.0065530506,
0.027343601,
0.0245998036,
0.0219144374,
0.0586727075,
-0.0389908813,
0.031004278,
0.0322276689,
0.0249164402,
0.0299134068,
-0.0362204164,
0.0451001227,
0.0307213143,
-0.0220828466,
0.0341361612,
-0.012476068,
0.0085555566,
0.0298363976,
0.0264999177,
-0.0631042719,
-0.0379624143,
0.0111372396,
0.04021018,
0.024164265,
-0.0245651547,
0.03484153,
0.0316452309,
-0.0395308211,
0.0065473057,
-0.0460480005,
0.0372655056,
-0.0416393392,
-0.0061477749,
0.0472877361,
-0.0311392993,
-0.0758779645,
-0.0150254015,
0.0000459241,
-0.0029787514,
-0.0508341752,
-0.0060801045,
0.0545506217,
0.0201266631,
-0.0362273976,
0.0069437474,
-0.0008524179,
-0.0211103316,
0.0167211704,
-0.0143188788,
0.0237749033,
0.0444612242,
0.1024018079,
-0.0298182033,
-0.0082440777,
-0.0025457738,
0.0051671341,
0.0396229662,
0.0320097208,
-0.0277034938,
0.0162168182,
-0.0586614795,
-0.0578754991,
-0.0410531424,
0.0059320349,
0.0095358165,
-0.0058235205,
0.0417195298,
0.050050009,
-0.0468441471,
0.0200127959,
0.0116517507,
-0.0255891792,
-0.0905588195,
0.0326129422,
0.0145028364,
-0.0055759884,
0.0027312015,
-0.0072926343,
0.01422121,
0.0456714891,
-0.0224953704,
-0.0331877172,
-0.057236556,
-0.0378834009,
-0.0284791403,
-0.0035183711,
-0.0410740003,
0.0182385836,
0.0087354258,
-0.033086475,
-0.0423624516,
-0.0036182273,
-0.003540047,
0.0348966271,
-0.0647630766,
-0.013392115,
-0.0079435967,
0.0110078845,
-0.0168650653,
0.0699349344,
0.0076062158,
0.0363594107,
0.0334734358,
0.0059856572,
0.0373070538,
-0.0600982532,
-0.0513493717,
0.0085684462,
0.0010947376,
0.0379439928,
0.0409739316,
-0.0086256387,
0.0047194017,
0.0227333605,
-0.0657496825,
0.0042793113,
-0.0263183583,
-0.0134875774,
0.018876357,
-0.001041021,
0.0062364726,
-0.035776563,
-0.0350887999,
-0.0233520065,
0.0151936002,
0.0446510762,
0.0289096683,
0.0183919519,
0.023176074,
-0.0270131491,
-0.0345420055,
0.0201913957,
0.044488024,
-0.0321105085,
0.008776363,
-0.0232995674,
0.0545461029,
-0.0294934977,
0.0313449092,
0.0030745317,
0.0195553154,
0.0176381972,
-0.0551903509,
-0.0242454242,
0.060263928,
0.0014842462,
0.0155000584,
0.0169723537,
-0.0082789529,
-0.091027528,
-0.0030238093,
-0.0435994416,
0.0070652124,
0.0092313429,
-0.0075512645,
0.0061639845,
0.0152581474,
0.0000326035,
0.009686836,
-0.048086483,
0.0231161583,
0.0277159847,
-0.0009023998,
-0.0515355878,
0.0093174763,
0.0306925252,
0.0478020944,
-0.0400964208,
-0.0109060369,
0.0766830519,
-0.0163061712,
0.0030293155,
-0.004859162,
0.002078414,
-0.0176013857,
0.01318454,
-0.023120217,
0.0168517996,
0.0135973617,
-0.018760955,
-0.0113982726,
0.0089355102,
0.0447242893,
-0.0364369936,
0.0334738567,
0.0187413767,
0.042908553,
-0.0099966591,
-0.061004322,
-0.0617794208,
-0.0588535517,
0.024187725,
0.0229872819,
-0.0349088274,
-0.0118363053,
-0.0864771828,
0.0007885725,
0.0087840399,
0.0654396936,
-0.0138940029,
-0.0309936758,
-0.015268174,
0.037921153,
0.0567286052,
-0.0107945772,
-0.0121453814,
0.0223381408,
-0.0013617177,
0.0723497048,
-0.0069567864,
-0.0011415744,
0.0018168098,
-0.00067207,
0.0163358487,
-0.0186045133,
-0.0099898521,
-0.0117384819,
-0.0082242424,
-0.0008425123,
-0.0590691119,
0.0879216567,
0.0201344527,
-0.0736711547,
-0.0407546908,
-0.0243264586,
0.0018449414,
0.0424667038,
0.045753222,
-0.0817477927,
-0.0159303937,
0.0092861438,
0.0440219752,
0.0111313192,
-0.0204329863,
-0.0096264873,
-0.1524629295,
0.0535988733,
0.0001947252,
0.0455747694,
-0.046879787,
-0.0790565237,
0.0136065846,
-0.0048506642,
-0.0004542458,
0.0336169563,
0.010797333,
-0.0086650914,
-0.0146674402,
0.0662067384,
-0.0787275434,
0.0205166265,
-0.0016511001,
-0.0079562915,
0.0126975114,
0.0139170382,
0.033837609,
-0.0343548432,
-0.0216418467,
-0.0582609996,
-0.0260734968,
-0.0094085103,
0.0744393468,
-0.0487249792,
0.0208673626,
-0.0082066311,
0.0021999425,
-0.0257549174,
-0.0017592893,
-0.0292534679,
0.0703098401,
-0.0341393724,
0.02454569,
-0.0609003901,
-0.0488217697,
0.002772911,
0.0722313598,
0.0037947872,
0.0293480884,
-0.0251481887,
-0.0095720999,
0.0338729545,
-0.0024383338,
-0.0228626113,
-0.0044484851,
-0.017412724,
0.0087640472,
-0.0651011616,
-0.0428317003,
-0.0040902868,
0.0589494146,
-0.037476588,
-0.0320879407,
-0.0271020718,
-0.062001776,
-0.0422788411,
-0.0155770285,
-0.0516974628,
-0.0020188724,
-0.0507529192,
0.0394188911,
0.0481602214,
-0.0159396101,
-0.0080189286,
-0.0512938462,
0.0078280652,
-0.0264083873,
-0.0387800485,
0.0162873473,
0.0137467608,
0.0710978359,
-0.0478730761,
-0.0517322943,
0.0714964792,
0.0654305518,
-0.0527267456,
-0.0064215278,
0.0235090926,
-0.0327452682,
0.0004705185,
0.0404964574,
-0.0664295852,
0.0544872619,
-0.0054025888,
0.0130971596,
-0.0551939495,
-0.0150844697,
0.0452395231,
-0.0016393423,
0.0888423696,
0.0347927697,
0.0532949455,
-0.0338228233,
0.0144827925,
-0.0247926004,
-0.0242335834,
-0.0197931509,
0.0094578667,
0.0190477017,
-0.0143725555,
0.0021242406,
0.0628892034,
-0.0577703305,
0.066762872,
-0.0344249867,
-0.030053284,
0.0327393189,
0.0322006494,
-0.0222517382,
0.0081065148,
-0.0358099416,
0.0248668306,
0.0008411905,
0.0805835202,
-0.0530031733,
0.0067151538,
0.0275832675,
0.0231757425,
-0.0259491149,
-0.0068201595,
-0.0703864396,
0.0025181938,
-0.0504904762,
-0.0136936782,
0.0529289842,
-0.0492261462,
-0.006883041,
-0.0022294119,
-0.0206896663,
-0.0326955914,
-0.0256933328,
0.0129693951,
-0.0344844498,
0.0134669086,
0.0657223985,
0.0118248593,
0.0481950603,
0.0683768764,
0.0132388938,
0.0355488174,
-0.0337874629,
-0.0236049686,
-0.0258448794,
0.0117614409,
0.0536315143,
0.0600757636,
-0.0066106119,
-0.0041809739,
-0.0209390726,
-0.042512089,
0.0454268791,
-0.0100258701,
-0.0055241059,
0.026089631,
0.0452195145,
0.0573902614,
0.0134334518,
-0.0090660825,
-0.0451076478,
0.0075481175,
-0.0093026748,
-0.029155219,
-0.0002929478,
-6.541044927e-33,
0.0057982043,
-0.0121824909,
0.0140320659,
-0.0197763834,
0.0297485888,
0.0317275785,
-0.0344600752,
-0.0363637134,
-0.0572994128,
0.0194159113,
-0.0212406125,
0.0199201126,
0.0039130724,
0.0229803417,
-0.0122221708,
0.0033283622,
0.0582822151,
-0.0042019864,
-0.0275105014,
0.0241527706,
0.0823469609,
0.0248706844,
0.0286490824,
-0.067511037,
0.0020143897,
-0.0480875485,
0.0147783346,
0.0525268018,
0.0409884974,
0.0601077303,
-0.0143435169,
0.0504910648,
0.0219827518,
-0.0027424321,
-0.0058938735,
-0.025467407,
-0.084898904,
-0.042489998,
-0.0504778065,
-0.0225558206,
-0.019340083,
-0.0036478401,
0.0375309698,
-0.0271512493,
0.0095304046,
-0.0202602502,
0.0192510225,
0.0010760358,
-0.0510159694,
-0.0175037198,
-0.0553299412,
0.0256827082,
0.0241394546,
-0.0234133974,
0.0506024696,
0.0590166338,
0.0400311798,
0.0154345976,
-0.0873754174,
0.0198500734,
-0.0824216381,
0.0617897436,
0.0197962411,
-0.0218693651,
-0.0198564939,
0.0626268908,
0.0086359382,
-0.0036001671,
-0.0200555082,
-0.0067777028,
0.0359982811,
0.0222823154,
0.0017066383,
0.0727354139,
0.0894377902,
-0.0145055,
-0.0502747819,
0.0470220037,
-0.035231974,
0.0656779334,
0.0175712686,
0.0364737697,
-0.0787117258,
-0.0380649157,
-0.0053236145,
-0.016906647,
-0.0564191937,
-0.0250140373,
0.0331140347,
0.0446002819,
-0.0150586748,
-0.003744836,
0.0657290593,
-0.021503767,
0.0118407961,
0.0420095436,
-0.0232954454,
0.0065055364,
0.0067061735,
0.0028407807,
-0.0568426065,
-0.0433280952,
0.0426376909,
0.0058222464,
-0.0522963777,
0.020931812,
0.0586696975,
0.0255442094,
-0.0427296683,
-0.0188320093,
-0.0092985043,
-0.0033656231,
-0.0117705278,
-0.0230600126,
-0.0037552442,
0.0228441563,
0.0157472584,
0.0859983191,
0.0089352392,
0.0159763116,
-0.0114399455,
-0.0164355319,
0.0109967832,
-0.0016972587,
0.0028320588,
0.0286554936,
-0.0362657979,
0.0324076936,
0.015569848,
-0.06655287,
0.0262208842,
0.0501693934,
2.629e-7,
0.0061746119,
0.0083034718,
0.0278186724,
-0.000823704,
-0.0062454478,
0.037335068,
0.0136670843,
0.0298494492,
-0.0019317658,
-0.030327471,
0.0141867222,
0.0311734844,
0.0130465571,
0.0305055119,
-0.0843717679,
0.0392643064,
-0.0430641063,
-0.0425893776,
-0.0453236178,
-0.0364533626,
0.0662151277,
0.0811047554,
0.0039755818,
-0.0012652533,
0.0143622067,
-0.0418428816,
0.0829465389,
0.0698978752,
-0.008919226,
0.0006523559,
0.0294812862,
0.0331091471,
0.0288702734,
-0.014343285,
-0.0153375547,
0.0375557989,
0.0309382789,
0.0468815155,
-0.0148241045,
-0.0538249575,
-0.0133576505,
-0.0245206095,
-0.0029316798,
-0.0062694405,
0.0937281922,
-0.0274186451,
-0.0044601662,
0.0017827802,
-0.0655687675,
0.0393747911,
0.029366754,
0.0137404688,
-0.0462474376,
0.0086266538,
0.0344793275,
0.0299156085,
-0.0192106981,
-0.0675003529,
0.0322309658,
-0.0056381109,
-0.0333297849,
0.0283891857,
0.0053712386,
0.0058500534,
0.0198877472,
-0.0041954792,
0.0156117352,
2.228716167e-34,
0.0301208626,
0.0285563506,
0.0141859651,
-0.0343859605,
-0.0033126017,
0.0077813086,
-0.0653285682,
0.0065520476,
0.0374764167,
-0.0513747223,
-0.0344391875
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10481v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10481v2 | Execution-Based Evaluation for Open-Domain Code Generation | 2022-12-20T17:54:37 | 2023-05-19T14:27:46 | Zhiruo Wang, Shuyan Zhou, Daniel Fried, Graham Neubig | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL | To extend the scope of coding queries to more realistic settings, we propose
ODEX, the first Open-Domain EXecution-based natural language (NL) to Python
code generation dataset. ODEX has 945 NL-Code pairs spanning 79 diverse
libraries, along with 1,707 human-written test cases for execution. Our NL-Code
pairs are harvested from StackOverflow forums to encourage natural and
practical coding queries. Moreover, ODEX supports four natural languages as
intents, in English, Spanish, Japanese, and Russian. ODEX unveils intriguing
behavioral differences among top-performing code language models (LM). While
CODEX achieves better overall results, CODEGEN improves effectively via scaling
-- CODEGEN 6.1B performs comparably with CODEX 12B. Both models show
substantial gaps between open and closed domains, but CODEGEN gaps tend to
decrease with model size while CODEX gaps increase. We release ODEX to
facilitate research into open-domain problems for the code generation
community. | [
0.011846941,
0.0700431094,
-0.0083509507,
0.0158609319,
-0.0141455354,
0.0027737212,
-0.0072816066,
-0.0008341953,
0.0188548844,
0.0055311578,
-0.0144224064,
0.0046496168,
0.0093319239,
0.0716846436,
0.0343936272,
-0.0065702745,
0.0011944635,
-0.0479320176,
-0.0362209529,
0.0337206721,
-0.035195075,
0.045971483,
-0.0043077986,
0.0631352291,
0.0641093403,
-0.0164468866,
-0.0230699498,
0.0326341726,
-0.0131885391,
-0.0351874307,
0.0136049604,
0.03843344,
0.0117720524,
-0.0081142858,
0.0000023952,
-0.0388715491,
0.0262476094,
0.0256472658,
0.003086576,
0.017750293,
0.0309939645,
0.0089544123,
0.0256515406,
0.0386782251,
-0.0645723343,
-0.0456212685,
0.0276330449,
-0.085492447,
0.0726076439,
0.0628335774,
0.0138328541,
-0.0217259452,
-0.0096527748,
0.0179735459,
0.0337753445,
-0.026565779,
-0.0217468627,
0.0300525986,
0.0518745035,
-0.0247928929,
0.0267786421,
0.001176302,
0.0515650623,
-0.0388301536,
0.0004997771,
0.0496606119,
-0.0196183845,
-0.0269526783,
0.0051291925,
0.042443417,
-0.0291702207,
-0.0371808037,
0.0146370325,
-0.0208991282,
-0.0246513542,
-0.0886326507,
-0.0115696657,
0.0509471409,
-0.0119615905,
-0.0074588908,
0.0073111416,
0.0097592557,
0.0047920491,
0.0082293963,
-0.02614321,
0.0372239985,
0.0157365836,
0.0245198216,
-0.0249255281,
-0.0089085754,
0.0045026089,
-0.0659604296,
-0.0013859393,
0.0394050591,
-0.0296212956,
-0.0110411337,
-0.0482149385,
-0.0378471427,
0.0146073075,
-0.0326622836,
0.0413224995,
0.0517729297,
-0.0012686835,
0.0021720056,
-0.0222643614,
0.0685925558,
0.0090954835,
-0.00482326,
-0.0365959853,
0.0211317018,
-0.0497652106,
0.0057095699,
-0.0412484631,
0.0358082056,
-0.0455037504,
0.0367758274,
-0.0066710855,
0.03843797,
0.0113748731,
0.040999677,
-0.0030517946,
0.0077973017,
-0.0185402744,
0.0130051551,
0.0116530834,
-0.0300156996,
-0.017591536,
-0.0536991209,
0.0172508173,
-0.0692703649,
0.0006103212,
0.0288393404,
-0.0350846201,
-0.0223746896,
0.0105546322,
0.0724037811,
0.0173582304,
0.028618671,
-0.0033780541,
-0.0429832824,
0.0243641399,
-0.0480893403,
0.0081458725,
-0.0926541984,
-0.0336740501,
0.0271490477,
-0.0278341994,
-0.1123083979,
0.0143304355,
0.027061034,
0.0131056393,
0.0289668199,
-0.030914614,
0.016473949,
-0.0162840337,
-0.0067040483,
0.0307994504,
0.0447821058,
0.0413754098,
-0.0185202006,
0.0152205983,
-0.0324508287,
0.0324439742,
0.0066807549,
0.0078751883,
0.0007026494,
0.0256257281,
0.0572423004,
0.0199387074,
0.031569425,
-0.0003869778,
0.0414431244,
-0.0112422379,
-0.0004008693,
-0.0228052028,
0.001332881,
0.0006358012,
-0.0008410665,
0.1079531685,
0.0417574123,
-0.0131022399,
-0.0375851691,
-0.0305393897,
0.0643802509,
-0.0058177779,
0.0190455522,
0.0084516257,
0.0456192829,
0.0019536677,
-0.0726651847,
-0.0018649602,
-0.0019219621,
0.0195790399,
-0.0231840592,
0.0139395026,
0.0138966972,
-0.0627223551,
0.0378601477,
-0.0142893409,
-0.1073545218,
-0.0285794269,
-0.0573368259,
0.0176435653,
0.0408549421,
0.0693790093,
-0.0199584048,
-0.0273639634,
-0.0090495627,
-0.0126674827,
0.0104651814,
0.0234284792,
0.0029211626,
0.0150623601,
-0.0437855199,
0.0029581785,
-0.0662786067,
-0.0118361181,
0.0304117817,
0.022162335,
-0.0226960424,
0.0323418081,
-0.0230649784,
-0.0831947252,
0.0378882699,
-0.0342181772,
-0.0039086868,
0.0549709313,
-0.0241857711,
-0.007166577,
0.0065375669,
-0.037118569,
0.0301975925,
0.0181291644,
-0.0079063168,
-0.0144862039,
-0.0404699594,
-0.0210983064,
-0.0234538782,
0.0135765476,
-0.0379004702,
-0.0422752947,
0.0310418122,
-0.0313297026,
0.0038597686,
0.054476779,
0.0178956091,
0.0155100254,
-0.0106974589,
0.0030927625,
-0.0127401445,
-0.0121734794,
0.0077147665,
0.0305409152,
-0.0031747867,
0.0046443581,
0.0357446186,
0.0771726742,
0.0398652032,
0.0116243744,
-0.0148848817,
0.0204640683,
-0.0480624065,
0.0482927263,
0.0084965136,
0.0897878408,
-0.0096470956,
-0.0380779691,
-0.0685997307,
0.0520505384,
-0.0350817628,
0.0160016846,
0.0378031209,
0.0299061742,
0.0122527862,
0.0218592994,
-0.0141133117,
-0.0325391218,
0.004222116,
-0.0210382249,
0.0186936595,
-0.0130734239,
-0.0388291143,
-0.0129204029,
0.0074212719,
-0.0054062246,
0.0618276671,
-0.0122303385,
0.0251757801,
-0.0753786564,
0.0931031033,
-0.0268239826,
0.0041694148,
-0.0029784488,
-0.0539725646,
0.0163071211,
-0.0458783582,
0.029078871,
0.0459111482,
-0.015379509,
-0.0167281739,
0.0490168855,
-0.0032010626,
-0.0311332829,
0.0099287368,
0.0277097542,
-0.0496814996,
0.0273689441,
-0.0325317122,
0.0458387472,
0.0645257905,
0.0063977335,
-0.0174217615,
-0.0464937501,
0.0136680938,
-0.0114803361,
-0.0008554942,
0.0036062091,
-0.0111296652,
0.0004684609,
0.0648303032,
-0.0181767326,
-0.0790267289,
0.0659076422,
-0.0045158975,
-0.0323195308,
-0.0542827919,
-0.0082261516,
-0.0515041202,
0.0660429373,
-0.0051977253,
0.014006163,
0.0384891517,
-0.0406775735,
-0.0108193448,
0.0242884345,
-0.0207091402,
-0.0489783511,
0.0631616563,
-0.0643994734,
0.000978858,
-0.0203621145,
-0.0190836303,
-0.0369207673,
-0.007985875,
-0.0025076868,
-0.000855958,
0.0404990837,
-0.0123689668,
0.0476868376,
-0.0049184095,
0.0051373681,
0.0321131721,
0.0154329259,
-0.0302066617,
-0.0037362275,
-0.028812889,
-0.0385191627,
-0.0395506509,
-0.0315416344,
0.0086401422,
-0.0017035875,
0.0276759062,
0.0231735352,
0.0500559732,
-0.0707250386,
0.015576099,
0.0168233868,
0.0057550636,
-0.0315137058,
0.0796473995,
0.0448389649,
-0.043392431,
-0.0289917979,
0.0711454079,
0.0436105952,
-0.0001896637,
0.0054039489,
-0.0366565883,
0.0655083805,
0.0716702044,
0.0582154021,
-0.0950086191,
-0.0382818021,
-0.023254782,
0.07340087,
-0.0186472982,
-0.0096205557,
-0.0447097793,
-0.1389707178,
0.0333751477,
0.004604002,
-0.0337376148,
-0.042170316,
-0.0111592999,
-0.0426794216,
-0.0190401729,
-0.0513379425,
0.0668108761,
0.0062932726,
0.0409368798,
-0.0030428311,
-0.0383491591,
0.0065463725,
0.0361770019,
-0.0299985949,
0.0109035699,
0.1011875048,
0.0361820757,
0.032461945,
-0.0069090691,
-0.004865767,
-0.0200345311,
0.0350117311,
-0.0402132459,
0.0599180199,
0.0559369661,
-0.0283647329,
0.0046864641,
0.0318989567,
-0.0999605656,
-0.0015422828,
0.015052937,
0.0343826637,
-0.0078326687,
-0.0084009776,
-0.0317481011,
0.0172304865,
0.0217521582,
0.0037691316,
0.0413445719,
-0.0234375615,
-0.0490908772,
-0.0728236958,
-0.0122446744,
-0.1008655801,
-0.0300932676,
-0.0213568863,
0.0185731146,
-0.0258257873,
-0.0477968156,
0.0188913681,
0.0294918194,
0.0325657763,
0.0102911498,
-0.0590095147,
-0.0217055418,
-0.0007464176,
-0.0480808392,
-0.0005707636,
0.0095107136,
0.030582726,
-0.0333097279,
-0.0217695013,
0.0268681236,
-0.0278497692,
-0.0150422193,
0.065987967,
-0.0753575712,
-0.0648808256,
-0.0307326484,
0.0676904097,
0.0168983489,
-0.0000326276,
-0.0294689648,
-0.0004734975,
-0.0378762186,
0.0295729805,
-0.0269362554,
0.0172250923,
0.036813654,
-0.0031513495,
0.0392556004,
0.0111937271,
-0.0604604557,
-0.0221919548,
0.0046289288,
-0.0061643091,
0.0149127878,
-0.0141979223,
0.0472840108,
0.0327346474,
0.0082033277,
0.0252827834,
-0.061183814,
-0.0051018526,
-0.0077050463,
0.0050054099,
-0.0401118547,
-0.0684628934,
0.0168536976,
-0.0224310718,
-0.0139019573,
0.0417119749,
0.0478255413,
-0.0552442372,
0.0595110469,
0.0027662974,
0.0529581979,
0.0213432685,
0.0884585753,
0.071190834,
-0.0004211635,
-0.0317483395,
0.0262255091,
-0.0345135517,
0.0430679545,
-0.0130856428,
0.0499378294,
-0.0111660166,
0.0470016338,
0.0714106783,
0.0213094391,
-0.0176647697,
-0.0518441163,
-0.0060553574,
-0.0238184649,
0.0139968377,
0.0565739051,
0.0334618762,
-0.0348614044,
0.03342795,
-0.0121826055,
0.0760038495,
-0.0085621467,
-0.0809203312,
-0.0224879701,
0.003178467,
0.0025529475,
-0.0696574599,
0.0982577354,
-0.0356371328,
0.0050241123,
-0.0107998922,
0.0096156057,
-0.0354022011,
0.0059950086,
0.0360243544,
-0.0317419879,
0.0101451911,
-0.0177370422,
-0.0367738456,
-0.0511689782,
-0.0140131209,
0.0543427356,
0.0288727786,
-0.0128481053,
0.0570979528,
0.058990404,
0.0053021768,
-0.003108928,
-0.0205768067,
0.0189771,
-0.0390110537,
-0.0616986975,
-0.027358612,
-6.058519557e-33,
-0.0340341218,
-0.0276993718,
0.0273540933,
0.0179364979,
0.0117952209,
-0.0160733089,
-0.0612921715,
0.0261443127,
0.0029280775,
-0.0385482647,
0.040276859,
0.0264348462,
-0.0132716773,
-0.0334486552,
0.0131488619,
0.0141369356,
0.0171808228,
0.0005999104,
-0.0506674126,
0.0457405932,
0.0006868411,
0.0070578605,
-0.0113937892,
-0.0336814225,
-0.0192607921,
-0.002703998,
0.0176689792,
-0.0213197432,
-0.0076518911,
0.0265981518,
0.0099451328,
-0.0003699836,
-0.0182329025,
-0.0259741545,
-0.0426906049,
-0.036515791,
0.0103970123,
-0.017881548,
-0.0009998047,
-0.0186288543,
-0.0430455729,
-0.0583470054,
0.0727907568,
0.0037881185,
-0.0381407887,
0.0065785404,
0.0054345294,
0.0052821338,
0.0075926832,
-0.0154964486,
-0.0640941784,
0.0321306139,
-0.0470427088,
-0.0287048258,
-0.0413682871,
0.0335216857,
-0.0295998715,
0.0165889356,
0.0104659442,
0.0147796338,
0.0157265794,
0.0432460345,
0.0519231185,
-0.0377753712,
0.0110334745,
0.0106655359,
0.025980033,
0.0014413684,
-0.0422121994,
0.0530216284,
0.0131117776,
0.0697764456,
0.0282116402,
0.0373000391,
-0.0123866489,
-0.0122474972,
-0.0372636728,
0.038678132,
-0.0577040836,
-0.0081487037,
0.0029523114,
0.0088254865,
-0.0177727863,
-0.0171421822,
-0.037436422,
-0.0011560575,
-0.0241910014,
-0.0435317643,
0.0292980764,
-0.0248295069,
-0.060494747,
-0.0397918895,
0.0117593352,
-0.019581927,
0.0343002006,
0.0498857573,
-0.0586336218,
0.0216581449,
-0.0229436178,
0.0149095813,
-0.0078989659,
-0.0031450908,
0.0227303524,
-0.0062442492,
0.07870242,
0.0273384005,
-0.0227310732,
0.0414183363,
-0.0516690649,
-0.0027907391,
-0.0683468282,
0.0331728235,
-0.0180984586,
0.0356235839,
-0.0087777767,
-0.0119734276,
-0.0036498317,
0.0538012572,
-0.0001701257,
-0.0543302223,
-0.0808815509,
-0.0250460301,
0.0443089455,
0.0130092278,
-0.0682448298,
-0.0148680136,
-0.0420024469,
0.0189779494,
0.0265353527,
-0.0017513365,
-0.067343086,
0.0577704497,
3.084e-7,
0.0104791205,
-0.0028133777,
0.0036129262,
0.0917096436,
-0.0075712376,
0.0483730771,
-0.0282029044,
0.0116928611,
0.0097786793,
-0.0041328808,
-0.05507439,
-0.0121722864,
0.0407043025,
0.0324247405,
-0.0511209331,
0.0575535446,
0.0297829993,
0.0074981977,
-0.0667472258,
0.0002107194,
0.0199508164,
0.0348480344,
-0.0130147757,
0.0138377454,
0.0276136044,
-0.0467518903,
0.0009557998,
0.0108940043,
0.0274527539,
0.0146962311,
-0.0783520862,
0.0267694592,
-0.0055076978,
-0.0115089873,
-0.0180322379,
-0.0442301519,
0.0289411843,
0.0437978879,
0.0136267673,
0.0361438729,
0.0478597619,
-0.0351526812,
0.0016813956,
-0.0793265328,
0.039193999,
-0.0042926474,
-0.0203053057,
-0.0044811317,
0.0172357988,
0.0140117705,
-0.0244029593,
-0.0099044712,
0.0388851278,
-0.0083186636,
-0.0024456314,
-0.025124548,
-0.0027219693,
-0.0048588924,
-0.0458325297,
-0.0392485932,
0.003237291,
-0.0443513654,
-0.0388722047,
0.0433699973,
0.0129118729,
0.0018316489,
0.0199622214,
3.095329633e-34,
0.0104695298,
-0.0247194581,
0.0200042333,
-0.002457906,
0.0593024679,
0.0040281005,
-0.0079213204,
-0.0095129088,
0.0183825698,
-0.0066768834,
-0.0451472215
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.11119v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.11119v1 | A survey on text generation using generative adversarial networks | 2022-12-20T17:54:08 | 2022-12-20T17:54:08 | Gustavo Henrique de Rosa, João Paulo Papa | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | This work presents a thorough review concerning recent studies and text
generation advancements using Generative Adversarial Networks. The usage of
adversarial learning for text generation is promising as it provides
alternatives to generate the so-called "natural" language. Nevertheless,
adversarial text generation is not a simple task as its foremost architecture,
the Generative Adversarial Networks, were designed to cope with continuous
information (image) instead of discrete data (text). Thus, most works are based
on three possible options, i.e., Gumbel-Softmax differentiation, Reinforcement
Learning, and modified training objectives. All alternatives are reviewed in
this survey as they present the most recent approaches for generating text
using adversarial-based techniques. The selected works were taken from renowned
databases, such as Science Direct, IEEEXplore, Springer, Association for
Computing Machinery, and arXiv, whereas each selected work has been critically
analyzed and assessed to present its objective, methodology, and experimental
results. | [
0.0444692671,
0.0354746468,
-0.0100883218,
-0.0015343924,
-0.0373168923,
-0.0198517852,
0.0381656215,
0.0089334482,
0.0118935537,
0.0034377247,
0.0110321157,
-0.055701267,
0.0069334698,
0.0515695773,
0.0398610979,
-0.0609392188,
-0.0218327511,
0.0167885646,
0.0142763006,
-0.0215057153,
-0.0152557334,
0.0076040188,
-0.0084711239,
-0.0054822797,
-0.0531503297,
0.0034137489,
-0.0093399081,
0.0129891839,
0.0487037785,
-0.0545429029,
0.054182224,
0.0384504087,
0.0136245033,
0.0620773286,
0.0000021942,
0.0039594928,
0.0039493814,
0.0108172577,
0.037522018,
-0.0023239241,
0.0383829884,
-0.0564048216,
-0.0302841552,
0.0252660997,
-0.0602097251,
-0.0186919346,
0.0282602459,
0.0503910221,
0.048465766,
0.0860256776,
-0.0281043407,
-0.0831931233,
0.024993591,
-0.0549394861,
0.018062057,
-0.0212634597,
-0.0023259486,
-0.0057956157,
-0.0217646789,
-0.0157296397,
-0.0046739569,
0.0329071917,
0.0449452065,
-0.027940521,
0.0057191984,
0.0887635127,
0.0382161103,
-0.0078092609,
0.004812967,
0.0592841133,
-0.0401319303,
-0.0214469135,
0.0017239138,
-0.0429934375,
-0.0154469265,
-0.0182123613,
-0.0196007844,
0.0325417258,
-0.0281240121,
0.031461522,
-0.0249070525,
0.0176118426,
-0.0124373706,
0.0108038206,
0.0032907431,
-0.0143351899,
0.0218112599,
-0.0121899061,
-0.0105086006,
-0.0136075569,
-0.0140839312,
-0.0373029187,
0.0187935848,
0.0455542244,
-0.0267824605,
-0.0000342815,
-0.1049124524,
-0.0680958778,
0.034855634,
-0.0658021122,
0.0430453457,
-0.0128192985,
0.0402635969,
0.0131588085,
-0.0476601459,
0.0568194799,
-0.0016828515,
-0.001385722,
-0.0145287756,
0.0324531086,
-0.0124779558,
-0.0199463498,
-0.0152397649,
0.0172490235,
-0.0326982513,
-0.0460202135,
-0.0704220161,
-0.0077448143,
-0.0003377137,
0.057493154,
-0.0136249131,
0.0731654987,
-0.0665712282,
-0.0268746167,
-0.0136217047,
-0.0813791007,
-0.0227002893,
0.0001608347,
0.0236899629,
-0.0136557287,
-0.015110122,
0.015059513,
0.0133408457,
0.006863622,
-0.0182796959,
0.0975087732,
-0.0597731657,
0.010747443,
-0.0120820077,
-0.0169246309,
-0.0337487161,
-0.0397537127,
0.0619738288,
-0.0263668559,
0.0054817973,
-0.0249794126,
-0.0266658533,
-0.0648039803,
0.0072673033,
0.0061054388,
0.0403569452,
0.023466127,
-0.0416191258,
-0.03222901,
0.0597396307,
-0.0036863149,
0.0597776808,
0.038088154,
0.0295004956,
0.1131361052,
-0.0107420795,
0.0089906845,
0.0195545088,
0.0009108151,
0.0654243231,
-0.0081923101,
-0.0310408026,
-0.0315710716,
-0.0281853303,
0.0460513085,
-0.0065772175,
0.0519731678,
-0.0178971961,
0.0073089325,
0.0635666028,
-0.0376976393,
0.0125528583,
0.0661389306,
0.0395094454,
0.0054922397,
0.0094031068,
0.0329583399,
0.0310745537,
0.0714558512,
-0.0147671727,
0.010642034,
0.0043948763,
0.0300701037,
-0.0302238334,
-0.0256013293,
0.0539056994,
-0.0243595466,
0.0155942002,
-0.0654274002,
0.0336377881,
0.0507057458,
-0.0678924322,
-0.0774840936,
0.0313780569,
-0.0156850368,
-0.0075419364,
-0.0361161008,
0.0155151505,
0.0272253044,
0.0516109988,
0.0001930282,
0.0197968297,
-0.0051528411,
-0.0290371217,
0.0807161853,
0.0241934843,
0.0144567881,
-0.0109498641,
-0.0645826682,
-0.0107640456,
-0.0766696557,
0.0013263697,
0.0491080619,
-0.0064311032,
0.061875917,
0.0554343909,
0.0280385539,
-0.0339974351,
0.0520258211,
-0.0029370093,
-0.0389281996,
0.0350224636,
0.0098675732,
0.0273478534,
-0.016361542,
-0.0461378135,
0.0255970452,
0.0184317213,
-0.0283265226,
-0.050123468,
-0.0354705341,
-0.046491079,
-0.078590475,
-0.0095328111,
-0.063336499,
0.0261065532,
0.0050930018,
-0.034762796,
-0.0297118928,
0.0202952381,
-0.0425652117,
-0.0268564317,
-0.0344624408,
-0.0136936549,
0.0420520604,
0.0197794959,
-0.0482430458,
0.0651976466,
0.0141152842,
0.0055435435,
0.0013361064,
0.0378099717,
0.0241908673,
-0.0170150138,
0.016769439,
0.0393722914,
-0.0093391966,
-0.0015209058,
0.0420752726,
0.0514057092,
-0.021150317,
-0.0286106076,
0.0053258464,
0.0068035014,
-0.0090906024,
-0.0103999516,
0.0388035625,
-0.0016354702,
0.0156845227,
0.0004669744,
-0.0815881342,
0.0671615824,
0.0184275638,
-0.0658628643,
0.0443828851,
0.0119201122,
0.0388031863,
-0.0159124564,
-0.0081845522,
0.0229573604,
0.0451111607,
0.0654119179,
-0.0296517685,
-0.020754341,
0.0334047675,
-0.031690307,
0.0175002497,
-0.0162833277,
-0.049832318,
0.0102110431,
0.0135058416,
0.05020006,
0.0755068883,
0.0826902464,
0.0492089726,
-0.0327500254,
0.0245807134,
-0.0248144157,
0.0134847285,
-0.0534839891,
0.0190342497,
0.0052026934,
-0.0466593727,
0.0453983769,
0.0295914449,
0.0559595972,
0.0126750758,
-0.0535803437,
0.058355514,
0.0059186374,
-0.0829685926,
-0.0028529698,
0.0158561151,
-0.0220934544,
-0.0347356163,
-0.03746856,
-0.0422261171,
0.0369094983,
-0.003358254,
-0.002798439,
-0.007604369,
-0.0239482652,
0.0156420339,
0.0440568253,
0.0410356149,
0.0543309562,
0.057779517,
0.0287143607,
-0.057152614,
0.0013735131,
0.0630632862,
-0.0111683179,
-0.0327898189,
-0.0084917936,
0.0036109693,
-0.0287640672,
0.0027751664,
-0.0436999127,
-0.0336287208,
0.0499642268,
0.0238904469,
0.0577468835,
-0.0254397076,
-0.0123689054,
-0.0278778896,
0.0169838797,
0.0253369808,
-0.0447993651,
-0.0150434934,
-0.0259409118,
0.0642011911,
0.0523977652,
-0.0345949791,
-0.0277688708,
-0.043462567,
0.0088531822,
0.039312005,
-0.0395968109,
0.0436090864,
-0.005836593,
-0.0196707249,
-0.0211299695,
0.0319162533,
-0.0155710066,
0.0098698009,
0.024699375,
-0.0171516817,
-0.0209421199,
0.044312302,
0.0183647275,
0.0196900908,
0.0343091115,
0.0743163899,
0.0193720348,
-0.0430423319,
-0.0022202339,
-0.0337106436,
0.0078980066,
-0.0405877717,
0.0551335253,
-0.0278757829,
0.0010040894,
-0.0144949788,
-0.0857849792,
0.0183856897,
0.0161177255,
-0.0316253304,
-0.0252544582,
0.0208664965,
-0.0291460287,
0.0179707669,
-0.0226059593,
-0.0100687118,
0.0300241075,
0.0257853866,
0.0481621809,
0.0215871502,
-0.0551524274,
-0.0432916172,
-0.0195155069,
0.0372948796,
0.0620495863,
0.0736661851,
-0.0116636613,
-0.0108511336,
-0.0118155023,
0.0015005805,
-0.0132115763,
0.0046909833,
0.0558177307,
0.0220546909,
-0.017883271,
-0.0219822433,
0.0322854891,
0.0327777155,
0.0051216637,
0.0408079326,
-0.0331211761,
-0.0147110205,
-0.0519333817,
-0.0323781781,
0.0304389466,
0.0299709868,
0.0111636976,
0.0003656515,
-0.047878813,
-0.0347745381,
-0.0392507762,
0.044728931,
-0.1205415577,
-0.0209178496,
-0.0315577425,
-0.0240996126,
-0.0159306284,
-0.0944029167,
-0.0389022604,
-0.0098768584,
0.0718088076,
0.0109776072,
-0.0141430674,
-0.0223994516,
-0.0181661025,
-0.020081643,
-0.0899887085,
0.0220607072,
0.0210557841,
-0.0041158209,
-0.0622688569,
0.0130184749,
-0.0729690269,
-0.0184530187,
0.0474997275,
-0.0438469537,
-0.0639771149,
-0.0049871523,
0.050253205,
0.0057038744,
0.0059105358,
-0.0160616878,
-0.0381705649,
0.0985188261,
0.0992744863,
0.0090061324,
0.0059426776,
0.0078871315,
0.0069084787,
-0.0205824133,
0.0048721214,
-0.0153528731,
0.0148834083,
0.0387894958,
0.0187952463,
0.0024432896,
0.0022620952,
0.0154224997,
-0.0096084159,
-0.0396102183,
-0.0649199188,
-0.0112421373,
-0.0387922972,
-0.0037176844,
-0.0437719412,
-0.0024037121,
-0.0528128035,
0.0126502076,
0.0184642002,
0.033519987,
0.0082045728,
0.0249024164,
0.0192264002,
0.0260232594,
-0.0153801413,
-0.0314308479,
0.0113404589,
0.0843943954,
0.0085199,
0.0011202889,
-0.0182660203,
0.0052875504,
0.001206765,
-0.0054601715,
-0.0010759878,
0.0341800153,
0.0426583812,
-0.0020405406,
-0.0001052452,
0.0175235923,
-0.0540030897,
0.0191772487,
-0.1036577597,
0.0406481437,
0.0420754887,
0.0331314206,
0.0323772468,
-0.0674735829,
0.0127246501,
-0.0009892584,
0.0529610366,
0.0074595809,
-0.0389915891,
-0.0001442699,
-0.0309923198,
-0.0137665272,
-0.0570816994,
0.0699655414,
0.055792965,
0.0018510564,
-0.009219571,
0.0027900403,
-0.055309955,
-0.0233867299,
0.0277863536,
-0.0209556837,
0.0280291867,
0.0193195604,
-0.0088825021,
-0.0367765538,
0.0060759778,
0.0283598229,
0.0421677008,
-0.0011339915,
0.067088522,
0.0154123222,
-0.0165241156,
0.0369292162,
-0.0420887321,
0.0389404483,
-0.0251759682,
-0.0165704712,
-0.0162504222,
-6.023188973e-33,
-0.04753666,
-0.0404721722,
-0.0390865691,
-0.0459300913,
-0.0446287766,
0.0012087177,
-0.0503620431,
-0.0244575143,
0.041128464,
0.0134742409,
0.0025618789,
-0.0241482388,
-0.0062596095,
0.0460298434,
-0.0439445376,
-0.001284775,
0.0548279099,
-0.0241365172,
-0.0339258537,
0.0438636877,
0.0184060261,
0.0338644534,
0.0177731402,
-0.0641119257,
0.0195519906,
-0.0285471473,
-0.0732585862,
-0.0566672273,
-0.0138866724,
-0.0054987352,
-0.0045019547,
0.0016330904,
0.0022626927,
0.0123351868,
-0.0160427261,
-0.0173239727,
-0.0261414498,
-0.0274814945,
-0.0222083274,
-0.0096947365,
-0.0649351627,
-0.0293221492,
0.0066101686,
-0.0301923528,
-0.0009881905,
0.0279219002,
0.0452081114,
0.000942882,
-0.0448314957,
-0.0559262149,
-0.0556623526,
-0.0026996667,
-0.0180138201,
-0.0137546426,
-0.019699106,
0.0202943701,
0.0230110586,
-0.0306314565,
-0.0486856736,
0.0506226756,
0.0369518995,
0.00217952,
0.0139927268,
0.0394875742,
0.0352662727,
0.0368054733,
0.0117215039,
0.0087409699,
-0.0404010527,
0.0236772262,
-0.0031791786,
0.012540306,
0.0545538254,
0.0856582522,
0.0469394103,
-0.0457825102,
-0.080281049,
0.0619064234,
-0.0170091484,
-0.0046143974,
0.0476333611,
-0.0011284472,
-0.0097939968,
-0.0019804095,
-0.0046503218,
-0.0180986952,
0.029628098,
-0.0356121361,
0.0185026173,
0.047227934,
-0.0448461659,
-0.0241228994,
-0.030490594,
-0.0120828189,
-0.0076149306,
0.0063697053,
-0.0393628217,
-0.008167699,
-0.0042158407,
-0.005385079,
-0.0396488309,
-0.0481794663,
0.0772031248,
0.0611190312,
0.0089324834,
0.0142079201,
0.0219440926,
0.0367594473,
-0.0227507632,
0.0291487314,
-0.0399653688,
0.0471578538,
0.0615941919,
-0.0089004859,
-0.022787625,
-0.0431679115,
-0.0464234687,
-0.0128048118,
0.0238876287,
-0.0165642146,
-0.0094128,
0.0015707449,
0.0195770618,
0.0384374261,
-0.0430373177,
0.0166037772,
-0.0155947516,
-0.0077200076,
0.0437714234,
-0.0731191412,
-0.0138712823,
-0.0384544209,
2.804e-7,
-0.0168142337,
-0.0027234983,
0.0097965244,
0.0312980115,
0.0168598928,
0.0439510643,
-0.0015463773,
0.0584549271,
-0.0028942458,
0.0382625796,
0.0221236423,
-0.0018195449,
0.0447158106,
0.0104205282,
-0.0513459891,
0.0487552173,
-0.0629912391,
0.0097639291,
-0.0076011033,
-0.000554081,
0.0545427278,
0.0318118408,
-0.0209670551,
-0.0125119686,
0.0559721105,
-0.0206791069,
0.0674568489,
0.0217180867,
0.0217917822,
-0.0058699027,
0.0181422122,
0.0018253926,
-0.0271611549,
-0.0248779394,
-0.0442195833,
-0.0283872429,
0.0334095955,
0.0016714892,
0.0055134962,
-0.0145057617,
0.0239567794,
0.0056886827,
0.0330482833,
-0.0364523381,
0.0474522971,
-0.0383994132,
-0.057897076,
0.0235872343,
0.0005758459,
0.0203369074,
0.0372338071,
-0.0625114292,
-0.0332919024,
-0.0232072864,
0.0207017604,
0.0281450897,
0.0138667021,
-0.0061448202,
-0.0116638709,
-0.0115545364,
-0.0292400457,
-0.0195142701,
-0.0527785569,
0.0612650514,
0.0092045953,
0.0175090153,
0.0118048023,
2.135376405e-34,
-0.0140931727,
-0.0261788331,
-0.0364091918,
-0.0673429593,
-0.0184124317,
0.0037063188,
0.0143451178,
0.0058941082,
0.0073079658,
-0.0111982729,
-0.0420506299
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10474v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10474v2 | ByGPT5: End-to-End Style-conditioned Poetry Generation with Token-free Language Models | 2022-12-20T17:49:49 | 2023-05-22T21:15:06 | Jonas Belouadi, Steffen Eger | cs.CL | cs.CL | State-of-the-art poetry generation systems are often complex. They either
consist of task-specific model pipelines, incorporate prior knowledge in the
form of manually created constraints, or both. In contrast, end-to-end models
would not suffer from the overhead of having to model prior knowledge and could
learn the nuances of poetry from data alone, reducing the degree of human
supervision required. In this work, we investigate end-to-end poetry generation
conditioned on styles such as rhyme, meter, and alliteration. We identify and
address lack of training data and mismatching tokenization algorithms as
possible limitations of past attempts. In particular, we successfully pre-train
ByGPT5, a new token-free decoder-only language model, and fine-tune it on a
large custom corpus of English and German quatrains annotated with our styles.
We show that ByGPT5 outperforms other models such as mT5, ByT5, GPT-2 and
ChatGPT, while also being more parameter efficient and performing favorably
compared to humans. In addition, we analyze its runtime performance and
demonstrate that it is not prone to memorization. We make our code, models, and
datasets publicly available. | [
0.0349572673,
0.0723592713,
-0.0051405928,
0.0166325178,
-0.0320519879,
-0.0171784312,
0.0093226219,
-0.0108887637,
-0.0174390581,
-0.0253671333,
-0.0323654599,
-0.0289167464,
0.0076443446,
0.0069362163,
0.0276348367,
-0.0417425707,
-0.0132343061,
-0.0245622694,
0.0363909416,
-0.0092455149,
0.0146592706,
0.0267087016,
-0.0102715259,
0.0641427636,
-0.0280081742,
-0.0092039853,
-0.0317266434,
0.0602904633,
-0.0148556847,
-0.0179912616,
0.0009194281,
0.0471731909,
-0.0284306612,
-0.0019300688,
0.0000017663,
-0.0378813483,
-0.0127874054,
-0.0439669937,
0.0607832447,
0.0044467547,
0.0242008474,
-0.0489666238,
-0.00830054,
0.0263656788,
0.0112525439,
-0.0014037594,
0.0367198698,
0.0263283271,
0.1033211276,
0.1148102358,
0.0056704194,
-0.0390198268,
0.0185986981,
-0.0372854099,
0.0187511407,
-0.0290878601,
0.0189796444,
-0.029642297,
0.0136205032,
-0.0293982662,
-0.0559288859,
0.020900758,
-0.0015070456,
0.0379354656,
0.0116796205,
0.0292204563,
-0.0231736302,
0.0206988659,
-0.0181777608,
0.0364710055,
0.0053543928,
-0.0522640049,
0.0320056453,
0.0209994335,
0.0059005953,
-0.0282438081,
-0.0247137081,
0.03980105,
0.0141726527,
0.0263036266,
0.0115890652,
-0.0093073975,
-0.0095914314,
0.0023344855,
-0.0015858058,
-0.0193802938,
0.0341617689,
-0.0521544702,
-0.0287746545,
0.0102090212,
0.0117911249,
-0.0878688097,
0.0145015065,
0.0109481504,
-0.011767026,
-0.0134209869,
-0.0564378612,
-0.0864802152,
0.0070144078,
0.0468344502,
0.0598530769,
0.0516260043,
0.0527079329,
-0.0010715356,
-0.0279052537,
0.0203896873,
0.0121825896,
0.0256566871,
-0.0402468368,
-0.0011600647,
-0.0338041633,
-0.023788318,
-0.0886493921,
-0.0235423036,
-0.0138439927,
-0.0277551375,
-0.0215942524,
-0.01547442,
0.040377669,
-0.017575169,
0.0406246409,
0.0453098826,
-0.0513410755,
0.0083346972,
0.0527226217,
-0.0046723271,
0.0002660274,
0.0176531952,
0.0186755117,
-0.0067586945,
-0.0211457852,
0.0101027004,
0.0590346903,
-0.015578026,
0.027957283,
0.0416983701,
-0.0041918475,
-0.042720601,
-0.0357741341,
-0.0213683303,
-0.0182706434,
-0.0576787218,
0.0056507839,
-0.0628409311,
0.0022866281,
-0.0246084519,
0.0272180717,
-0.0102891857,
-0.00039263,
0.0257756468,
-0.0147870518,
0.0341597944,
0.0080229025,
0.0148832425,
-0.0238250066,
-0.0046913303,
0.0124030961,
0.066417627,
0.0745725334,
0.0447237864,
-0.0276924614,
-0.0063444008,
0.0157499313,
0.0202435851,
0.0002674624,
-0.0003451013,
-0.0189436022,
-0.052844476,
-0.0052220807,
0.051498346,
0.060094621,
0.0822536275,
-0.00768907,
-0.0257323273,
0.0641444996,
0.0170252714,
0.0546514876,
0.0308995228,
0.0652458593,
0.0055825897,
0.0352745615,
-0.0064235404,
-0.0171615854,
0.0096562682,
0.0567342564,
0.0608378276,
0.0412734561,
0.0364087671,
-0.0071564307,
0.0107092373,
-0.0308592897,
-0.0165991131,
0.0064120111,
-0.0405605547,
0.0254527312,
0.0611912571,
-0.0535474978,
0.0337711833,
-0.0038316061,
-0.0767763853,
0.0112535069,
0.0011003806,
0.0364524797,
0.0994873419,
0.078069672,
0.0202442147,
0.0448675863,
-0.0013251208,
0.0099732745,
0.0540449917,
-0.0155503461,
0.0080340076,
0.02557729,
-0.0310891103,
0.0348569117,
-0.0199126285,
0.0170966927,
0.0156411901,
-0.0275172442,
0.0402934141,
-0.0005763816,
-0.0412037149,
-0.0356622562,
0.0420875363,
-0.0006285713,
-0.0360448137,
0.0363710895,
-0.0000510825,
-0.0079850219,
0.0280653946,
-0.0432603061,
0.0463983342,
0.0005474217,
-0.0527035072,
0.0015058498,
0.0496171191,
-0.0709010884,
-0.0665587708,
0.0379325077,
-0.0509674735,
0.0414878204,
0.0154620958,
0.0044423193,
-0.0710424557,
0.0862808675,
-0.0225165281,
0.0737360865,
-0.0242960807,
-0.0100727342,
0.0285614058,
-0.014671714,
-0.0010191301,
-0.0072627673,
0.0072741257,
0.0186587404,
-0.0095911697,
0.0268393327,
-0.0039500999,
-0.0021135779,
-0.019837413,
-0.0131664574,
0.0153604113,
0.0113239065,
-0.0210449621,
0.0219452176,
-0.0177954026,
-0.0574333183,
-0.1052047834,
-0.0004585531,
-0.0186074767,
-0.0087335519,
0.0315633975,
0.0070636603,
-0.0460217297,
0.0102641741,
-0.0441629738,
0.005942117,
0.0132996039,
0.0119581735,
-0.0031355044,
-0.0041924212,
-0.0427583642,
-0.0273134653,
-0.0056499611,
-0.018310314,
0.00274406,
0.0096080657,
0.0299334135,
-0.0193318743,
-0.0119408369,
-0.0063558798,
-0.0264270678,
0.0161501598,
-0.041528184,
0.0222509485,
-0.0600655377,
0.0748478174,
0.0514466241,
0.0079961456,
-0.0245008469,
0.0508676022,
-0.03794365,
0.0034633458,
-0.0013282257,
0.0092293629,
0.0250864178,
0.011491714,
-0.0485708043,
0.0026852698,
0.0622631162,
0.0580129214,
-0.0202633571,
-0.0543211475,
0.0693664923,
0.0136647932,
-0.004114633,
0.0064981999,
0.0323425718,
-0.0246681757,
-0.0055650729,
-0.0325426459,
-0.0002688021,
0.053532239,
-0.0684823245,
-0.0159583557,
-0.0194263458,
0.0255981069,
-0.0593077391,
0.0397237577,
-0.0002082028,
0.0381714031,
-0.0205215234,
-0.0469258651,
-0.018974917,
0.0417957716,
0.0130410744,
-0.0211015791,
0.0249785706,
-0.0170342643,
0.0056610778,
-0.005649549,
-0.0258006137,
-0.0181898773,
0.014771129,
-0.0151111763,
-0.0038686895,
0.0468597002,
-0.0485645644,
0.0653589368,
-0.0102481255,
-0.0597843193,
0.0476382859,
-0.0328819342,
-0.0261490289,
-0.0353465825,
0.0176929776,
0.0231197737,
-0.0224511418,
-0.0489329398,
-0.0223873649,
-0.0168102011,
-0.0027122707,
0.0410765782,
0.0188499,
-0.0240404401,
0.0317567512,
-0.0027274271,
-0.0139854308,
0.0725428388,
0.0141836107,
0.0389960483,
-0.0420549288,
-0.0501302294,
0.0906479657,
0.0157722328,
-0.0212826449,
-0.0030144711,
0.0306359455,
0.0514655411,
0.0039281468,
-0.0188532416,
-0.0564550534,
-0.0672824383,
0.03363939,
0.0788973272,
0.0213904772,
-0.0219643079,
-0.0387280397,
-0.052035518,
0.0082636941,
0.0339084864,
-0.0696636066,
0.0043623755,
0.0227413271,
-0.0349156894,
-0.0397746712,
-0.0221278071,
0.0168602094,
-0.0180317424,
0.0325841084,
-0.0078399861,
-0.0007530304,
-0.0146176824,
-0.0349652544,
-0.062516287,
0.0607434437,
0.0503618158,
0.0316700935,
0.0123541588,
-0.0318571478,
-0.002460809,
-0.0057372628,
0.001278311,
0.0095884725,
0.0017434146,
0.0085661644,
-0.0236556698,
0.0002979338,
0.0485710613,
-0.0359930359,
0.0253741257,
0.0324605294,
0.0092536826,
-0.006548868,
-0.0101172319,
-0.0127984192,
0.0197525881,
0.0164433122,
0.085468255,
0.0527630299,
-0.051339604,
-0.0730879977,
-0.062132217,
0.0100550018,
-0.1418073028,
-0.0157865249,
-0.0316537693,
0.0031599058,
-0.0317724347,
-0.1140508428,
-0.0193521306,
0.0009561689,
0.0335980356,
0.03870726,
-0.0153983897,
-0.0187668279,
-0.0348093994,
-0.0704526827,
0.0060534156,
-0.0206394698,
0.0140325371,
-0.0583525598,
-0.0714957565,
0.0030658017,
-0.0644613579,
0.020883888,
0.050006222,
-0.0965686813,
-0.0411141813,
0.0290172286,
0.0355038047,
0.0154624805,
0.0401969962,
-0.0132301459,
0.0077680624,
0.0105739571,
0.051740896,
0.0179299302,
0.0338930413,
0.0091331257,
-0.0070134546,
0.0059540104,
0.0125798993,
-0.0140701085,
0.0072618783,
0.0439524166,
0.0685491562,
0.0564022586,
-0.0009698853,
0.0699828491,
-0.0115401363,
-0.004142819,
-0.0347395577,
-0.0127779786,
-0.0097222608,
-0.0646600872,
-0.0386996083,
0.0178734548,
-0.0441039242,
0.0134021286,
0.0498107672,
0.0167988557,
-0.0019728397,
-0.0550614372,
0.0114261517,
-0.0189464521,
-0.0235558711,
-0.0199929085,
-0.0113150869,
-0.0114354417,
0.0145929195,
-0.0276522823,
0.0050087939,
0.0115331821,
-0.0300301909,
0.0252403915,
0.0091503635,
-0.0157044791,
0.0120467152,
-0.0105084991,
-0.0336198844,
0.0221100729,
-0.0406224094,
0.023761699,
-0.0373262875,
0.0023018408,
0.0586338639,
-0.0074328794,
0.0704820901,
-0.0562642366,
0.0311917961,
-0.0091108372,
0.0107195303,
0.0111787692,
-0.0149066858,
-0.0652107969,
0.0007311644,
0.0027825781,
-0.0503418744,
0.1109902933,
0.0073153446,
0.0319816433,
-0.0031371976,
-0.0007116627,
-0.0315146446,
-0.0176209677,
-0.0124168294,
-0.0072613996,
0.0008855558,
0.0011383925,
-0.0355197191,
-0.0680089965,
0.0185382627,
-0.0020579058,
0.0357021391,
0.0093597099,
0.0267411973,
0.0229047574,
-0.0250113923,
0.0162958875,
-0.0460091457,
-0.0064896741,
0.0033946307,
-0.0622381456,
-0.0279523656,
-5.940794165e-33,
-0.0359052718,
0.0135289263,
-0.0200978648,
-0.0132772988,
-0.0129586961,
-0.0116634788,
-0.0734900609,
-0.0002597455,
0.0471326448,
-0.0192363206,
-0.0088431062,
-0.0128881186,
-0.0109044751,
0.0320120528,
0.0596026145,
0.0338278562,
0.0502253622,
-0.0215786546,
-0.0510841943,
0.022159338,
0.0743272603,
0.0305030923,
-0.003681317,
0.0039644004,
0.0041398634,
-0.0183966588,
-0.0221499205,
-0.0178164952,
0.0163612366,
0.0186747145,
-0.0253675617,
0.0048262025,
0.0317856483,
-0.0086646602,
-0.0553779602,
0.0075472137,
-0.0640785098,
-0.0087601691,
-0.0056843017,
0.00655948,
0.0222654901,
-0.0623112395,
0.0425358005,
-0.0233350024,
-0.0102007622,
0.0293990467,
-0.0036941885,
-0.0177270863,
0.0238390267,
-0.0895671025,
-0.0271106958,
-0.0229350794,
-0.0378334969,
-0.0669817179,
-0.0091516757,
-0.0119361393,
0.0153780356,
0.0180880707,
-0.0445000343,
0.0427696705,
-0.0261982679,
0.0199377798,
0.0067459429,
0.0240409374,
0.0016314039,
0.0646523684,
-0.005781075,
-0.0304137375,
-0.0363256223,
0.0838393047,
0.0273519009,
0.0000331591,
0.0583254769,
-0.0047831498,
0.065439634,
-0.0317605883,
-0.0092542646,
0.0339934081,
-0.0101559088,
-0.0273898076,
0.0193782896,
0.0023156535,
-0.0143051269,
-0.0187565908,
0.04044009,
-0.0440460183,
-0.0081969565,
0.0011148826,
0.0480361693,
0.0565934107,
-0.0369335152,
-0.0263516456,
-0.0075259176,
-0.0287447274,
-0.0028602208,
0.0274146423,
-0.0580956414,
0.0249657389,
-0.0416185334,
-0.0181739479,
-0.0187128894,
-0.0132055106,
0.0990480185,
0.0085245064,
0.0127801923,
0.0264313836,
0.0477538444,
0.0367454328,
-0.076555565,
0.0001863506,
-0.0490687452,
0.0670277998,
-0.0022346992,
-0.0197471082,
0.0318422057,
-0.0098692458,
0.0127344728,
0.0268642884,
0.0294965599,
0.0154538043,
-0.0266669877,
0.0033536546,
-0.0091048833,
0.0246238895,
0.0050459248,
-0.0020568243,
-0.0175399929,
-0.0287986994,
-0.0025787044,
-0.019816434,
-0.0072028311,
0.0127864163,
2.572e-7,
0.0248469282,
0.0062526804,
0.0666681677,
0.0331577435,
0.0252331328,
0.0181551445,
-0.0565247796,
0.0531530753,
-0.0332926363,
0.0329016112,
0.0367141515,
0.0099871969,
0.0698351786,
-0.00850021,
-0.1567453444,
0.0390779376,
-0.0643935949,
0.0195897296,
-0.1034593657,
-0.0262919236,
0.0622106083,
0.0268554445,
-0.0150030646,
0.0004742141,
0.0183126405,
-0.0425966121,
0.0342396721,
0.0254263021,
0.0112969186,
-0.0174944103,
0.0306610111,
-0.0318029262,
0.0055399006,
-0.013402367,
-0.0266711283,
0.0096915849,
0.0204462912,
0.0274842437,
0.0248264503,
-0.0166300349,
0.0450982489,
0.0093675209,
0.0108450241,
-0.0058845123,
0.0349863805,
0.0470380373,
0.0041185096,
0.0006736137,
0.0125575718,
0.0197558664,
0.0073956284,
-0.033241868,
-0.0581239685,
-0.0043068002,
0.0227418207,
-0.0141066704,
0.0620656945,
-0.0246674661,
-0.0376417972,
-0.0216936544,
-0.0531614795,
-0.0055964645,
-0.0226361286,
0.0266066268,
-0.0242581405,
-0.0895808563,
-0.0340198837,
2.359377645e-34,
0.0663134232,
-0.0611472279,
0.0286790561,
0.0077361427,
0.0304079894,
-0.0009825344,
0.0321277604,
0.0122390427,
-0.0311989449,
-0.0489797257,
-0.0642149225
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.11670v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.11670v1 | Evaluation for Change | 2022-12-20T17:49:27 | 2022-12-20T17:49:27 | Rishi Bommasani | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Evaluation is the central means for assessing, understanding, and
communicating about NLP models. In this position paper, we argue evaluation
should be more than that: it is a force for driving change, carrying a
sociological and political character beyond its technical dimensions. As a
force, evaluation's power arises from its adoption: under our view, evaluation
succeeds when it achieves the desired change in the field. Further, by framing
evaluation as a force, we consider how it competes with other forces. Under our
analysis, we conjecture that the current trajectory of NLP suggests
evaluation's power is waning, in spite of its potential for realizing more
pluralistic ambitions in the field. We conclude by discussing the legitimacy of
this power, who acquires this power and how it distributes. Ultimately, we hope
the research community will more aggressively harness evaluation for change. | [
0.0746541843,
0.0911391899,
-0.0080330241,
-0.0081774984,
-0.0203746352,
0.0031251437,
-0.0154577382,
-0.0105095338,
-0.0411124788,
-0.080285117,
0.0154930279,
-0.000305288,
0.0143633327,
0.002057893,
0.0215277448,
-0.0462134816,
-0.0048722946,
0.0362765417,
-0.0031267628,
0.0299883317,
0.0474650227,
0.0188392289,
-0.0076188934,
0.0741656944,
0.0039391937,
0.0180833507,
0.0266107656,
-0.0486697741,
-0.0222868249,
-0.033283405,
-0.0277112555,
0.0764913484,
-0.0289855041,
0.0168823265,
0.0000021253,
-0.0441755168,
-0.0118578384,
0.011078083,
-0.0427693799,
0.0263395235,
0.0651754066,
0.0027294992,
-0.0214447882,
-0.030320663,
-0.0507399924,
-0.0009659969,
0.0378705934,
-0.0055878726,
0.0175797399,
-0.0018067671,
0.0023391359,
-0.0392412953,
-0.0222828034,
0.0120990686,
-0.0411020331,
-0.0184408147,
-0.0077147926,
-0.0280882362,
0.0311039221,
0.0270782802,
-0.0115950527,
0.0652089044,
0.0199967101,
-0.0263252668,
0.0376430824,
0.0063871439,
0.0047733248,
-0.0396194421,
-0.024586333,
0.0227079131,
0.0766209736,
-0.0003829043,
0.0070258407,
-0.0102137672,
0.0043318151,
0.0374832712,
-0.0342295282,
0.0253509413,
0.0325060189,
0.0068046246,
-0.0115509937,
0.013939159,
0.0221738517,
0.0485214368,
0.0371551514,
0.0775090307,
-0.0206935313,
-0.0270025097,
0.0233796313,
0.0461636111,
0.0216757469,
-0.0220676344,
0.013134012,
0.0113871973,
0.0169509687,
0.0327969752,
0.0343037806,
-0.0229701009,
0.0290195961,
-0.0587244481,
0.0527853221,
-0.0080867754,
0.0322329178,
0.0261560977,
0.0256416928,
0.0110942936,
0.0052570412,
0.0249209963,
-0.0276833251,
0.0477686711,
-0.0803346783,
-0.0211545173,
-0.007152284,
0.0086523546,
-0.0151588321,
-0.0099469665,
0.018988831,
-0.0095744682,
-0.0401639715,
0.0076549929,
-0.0382493138,
0.0492455289,
0.0300897248,
0.0261632856,
-0.0554634556,
0.0378448255,
-0.0204575043,
0.0092936549,
0.0000199026,
-0.052497752,
0.0455188639,
-0.015665384,
-0.0385329314,
0.0162823182,
0.0138211614,
0.050788682,
0.0251573827,
-0.0048019751,
-0.0079145553,
-0.0473047942,
-0.0480677895,
-0.0031901612,
-0.0044544116,
-0.0801528394,
-0.0138729941,
0.0574266873,
0.0373758674,
-0.0489123985,
0.0075058588,
0.008410289,
-0.0293848217,
0.0565593131,
-0.0190292578,
0.0242721979,
0.0197949074,
0.0289801396,
0.0047113793,
0.0748238117,
0.0065358984,
-0.0204029884,
0.0590878241,
0.0186203048,
0.0491512381,
0.0326940417,
-0.0297253001,
0.0355542935,
0.0263080355,
0.0153801022,
-0.0297605954,
0.0039149262,
-0.0323310532,
0.057209488,
-0.0112977438,
0.0198141411,
0.0241711028,
0.0686788261,
0.0309945084,
0.0131709734,
0.0132992491,
-0.0194412153,
-0.0226804838,
-0.0344100967,
0.0124979047,
-0.0196807049,
-0.0431006588,
-0.0212915596,
0.005145344,
-0.0319551453,
0.002049485,
-0.0537452251,
-0.039659854,
0.0687800497,
0.0612659305,
0.0006809784,
-0.0268404614,
0.0492715128,
0.0356302448,
0.0578645393,
-0.0147407055,
-0.0376692787,
0.0090228375,
-0.0638877302,
-0.0160184894,
0.0406772532,
0.0550648235,
0.017030606,
0.0173199661,
-0.0320715718,
-0.0593481287,
0.0675285533,
0.0247678906,
-0.0036113968,
-0.0367667042,
0.0253597293,
-0.0113907289,
-0.0129281087,
0.0037938692,
-0.0056160828,
-0.006893157,
0.0178578533,
-0.0075613223,
-0.0216399878,
-0.1008626595,
0.0352308266,
-0.0067917239,
-0.0185767468,
-0.0542287529,
0.0213447921,
-0.0022770781,
0.0776434243,
-0.0068167648,
0.0400976501,
-0.0101435492,
0.0091839926,
-0.0482179374,
-0.0135657061,
0.0349731557,
0.0566152968,
0.0214472283,
-0.0559380017,
-0.0016577244,
0.0188176874,
0.0275744144,
0.0122806914,
0.0543772168,
-0.0447931141,
0.0157661624,
0.0046407031,
-0.0021104228,
-0.0481821485,
-0.0453470126,
-0.0802534074,
-0.0088115511,
-0.0219633039,
0.020034058,
0.0042341668,
0.0066741775,
0.0037260226,
0.032631252,
-0.0630269647,
0.0815701112,
0.0116115026,
0.0107332533,
0.0719049573,
0.0131864082,
-0.0536172614,
-0.0140706152,
-0.0523879938,
-0.0354654603,
-0.0056237918,
0.0104988674,
0.0478879325,
-0.0175707564,
0.0243893638,
0.0364483707,
0.0188439172,
-0.0592735782,
-0.004385211,
0.0143510168,
0.0131566729,
0.005779095,
0.0162568428,
-0.0188406128,
-0.0137119116,
-0.0101324404,
0.0644304752,
0.0140066389,
-0.0288416352,
-0.015786441,
0.0073400163,
-0.037986353,
-0.0481936634,
0.025355082,
0.0051547936,
0.0557314418,
0.0418367013,
-0.0131668942,
-0.0225517377,
-0.0009063995,
0.0668050051,
-0.0105054304,
-0.0046061925,
-0.0467783585,
-0.0278455392,
-0.0010091345,
-0.0042833821,
0.0015853456,
-0.0325218402,
0.0269654263,
0.019243069,
0.015345634,
0.0022112273,
-0.0112962238,
0.0302118901,
-0.125871256,
-0.0660447106,
-0.0830181167,
-0.0480229929,
-0.0350481346,
0.042342145,
-0.0134863192,
0.0084508881,
0.0249330103,
-0.0082077542,
0.0064500012,
-0.0791072845,
-0.0320944414,
-0.0216856785,
0.127010867,
-0.0600886084,
0.0008536798,
0.0403282605,
-0.0372914225,
0.0062065879,
-0.023638146,
-0.013448094,
-0.0502299368,
0.0654209405,
-0.0445812158,
0.0394553617,
0.0041614613,
-0.0173059795,
0.0229679476,
-0.0275251716,
-0.0375406221,
0.0525613092,
0.0577513017,
0.0178969502,
-0.0095495135,
0.0239374153,
0.0700486451,
0.0237842724,
0.0180786196,
-0.0320871547,
-0.0028830834,
-0.0191299152,
-0.022543706,
0.0166662615,
0.0594245605,
0.0204229876,
-0.0285729095,
0.0585454516,
0.0170891974,
0.0054855393,
-0.0194876008,
-0.0025015208,
0.014587068,
-0.0463381335,
-0.0223657638,
-0.0228494946,
0.0454779454,
-0.0496279821,
0.0011111822,
0.0565959029,
0.0229538362,
-0.016512882,
0.0074139549,
0.0244330112,
-0.066864036,
0.0143889049,
-0.0029208087,
-0.0808127224,
0.0126760099,
0.0071428129,
-0.0021398261,
-0.0602145903,
-0.0290671475,
-0.0132609932,
-0.0816363394,
-0.0083518671,
-0.0132600646,
-0.0162125546,
0.0422445461,
-0.0054905009,
-0.0029110126,
-0.0122109065,
0.05617797,
0.0171285663,
-0.0185367893,
0.0452007465,
0.0412103273,
-0.0655808151,
-0.0370093286,
0.0256038196,
-0.0283290632,
0.031160729,
0.0397454984,
0.0416791216,
-0.0383952335,
-0.038275931,
0.021409858,
-0.0145014105,
0.0154748559,
-0.0201769527,
0.0019102774,
-0.001032821,
0.0002801806,
-0.0331626162,
-0.0282638352,
-0.0474365205,
-0.0104639605,
-0.0195037294,
0.0029084561,
-0.023360908,
-0.0205704328,
-0.0538067967,
0.007822413,
-0.0224397089,
0.0335484445,
0.0361402556,
-0.0298793856,
0.0090179387,
-0.0578665473,
0.0054332344,
0.0023822822,
-0.1242750213,
-0.0026626321,
0.0237082057,
-0.0079037305,
-0.024585424,
-0.0821312368,
0.0240945183,
0.0341802798,
0.0400976799,
-0.0322400704,
0.0042713154,
-0.0431602336,
-0.0189413875,
0.0131583037,
0.0196634438,
0.0281665288,
-0.0119790779,
-0.0553646609,
0.0021735083,
0.0766258016,
-0.016017573,
0.0225377083,
-0.0062246202,
-0.0367964506,
0.0298085455,
-0.0067855571,
0.0255198013,
-0.0663158521,
-0.0075826249,
-0.0482542403,
0.0176109746,
0.0464987233,
0.0060613058,
0.019549787,
0.0115898699,
0.0199323185,
0.008454877,
-0.0003399581,
0.0356786065,
0.0077934223,
0.0305409897,
0.0228558481,
0.0063957009,
0.0172254033,
0.0215765461,
0.0123564294,
0.0212736912,
-0.0570116229,
-0.013184485,
-0.0059806546,
-0.1091618165,
0.0065150708,
-0.0272103995,
-0.0286537129,
-0.0212587193,
0.0080048852,
0.0369281396,
-0.0380615927,
0.0637057871,
-0.0444569699,
0.0428798161,
-0.0757345557,
0.0543111749,
0.0449831262,
-0.0043336758,
-0.0236720685,
0.0058998032,
-0.0168813635,
0.002152419,
-0.026837321,
0.011237422,
0.0275005773,
0.0244050119,
-0.0014135285,
-0.0072919955,
0.0194320977,
0.0464653,
-0.0495788939,
-0.0665300265,
0.0079106335,
0.0114782844,
0.009525937,
-0.0013085975,
0.0321931578,
0.0010464012,
0.0112255439,
-0.0089129796,
-0.0375682898,
-0.0046083708,
-0.0428285897,
0.0265917834,
0.0054440103,
-0.0159799345,
-0.0268593784,
0.0067968522,
-0.0702750385,
0.0078071519,
-0.0062524034,
0.0063177757,
0.0089229904,
-0.0444174036,
-0.0184541903,
-0.0184877198,
-0.0199283343,
0.0004357137,
-0.0629318208,
-0.001420949,
-0.0304696169,
0.0069953529,
0.045420859,
-0.004254818,
0.0126205599,
0.0636104643,
0.0368779302,
-0.0432624742,
-0.0785898119,
0.018409159,
-0.0175526328,
0.0115876133,
0.0047365171,
-6.408039211e-33,
0.0233242251,
-0.0349209458,
0.0140849613,
-0.0480855964,
-0.0450059995,
0.0322459415,
0.0103840614,
0.066010654,
-0.0263208803,
0.0313298479,
-0.0248998683,
0.0012449179,
0.0035159043,
-0.0060385303,
0.0689807683,
-0.009928029,
0.021961173,
0.0182729587,
-0.0145793557,
-0.0457374714,
0.0181434806,
-0.0167460311,
0.1004696488,
-0.0618404001,
0.1079527438,
0.0446885712,
-0.0369640663,
-0.033938095,
0.0377541408,
0.0135587882,
0.0040386147,
0.0596669279,
0.0448891446,
-0.1283038408,
-0.0102384333,
0.0148849022,
-0.019678507,
0.0039347536,
0.0539870039,
0.0224997327,
-0.0281441584,
0.0039030476,
0.0452855341,
0.0054325354,
-0.1045443192,
0.0220597703,
0.0131651005,
-0.0194297675,
0.0081658727,
-0.0061231852,
-0.0503623784,
0.0225984789,
-0.0139692128,
0.0435325839,
-0.0092378361,
-0.0116075287,
-0.0388946161,
-0.0484179258,
-0.1080335155,
-0.0149094537,
0.0519318543,
0.0423657522,
0.0581893697,
0.0117174629,
-0.0199813079,
0.0672357529,
-0.0304391328,
0.0525967889,
0.0031434153,
-0.0300575793,
0.0661982968,
-0.0003484659,
0.0246316604,
0.0012865855,
-0.006126795,
-0.041723568,
0.0292980578,
-0.0123931412,
0.0034191338,
0.0182077829,
0.0545346774,
-0.0110709863,
-0.037373893,
-0.0350439399,
-0.0463262312,
-0.0375310108,
-0.029322939,
-0.0369219929,
0.0173911527,
-0.0053513185,
-0.0364348292,
0.0478975587,
-0.0127324909,
-0.067015402,
-0.0545282401,
-0.0343786888,
-0.0149013931,
0.0445392653,
0.0029337802,
-0.0189346895,
-0.0651314035,
0.0076145181,
-0.0380410068,
0.1002033651,
0.0203542076,
-0.0290579405,
-0.0347677097,
0.0310787335,
-0.0376096889,
-0.0309859514,
-0.0304315612,
0.024193285,
0.027847901,
-0.0423157923,
0.0227143448,
0.0225294512,
-0.0059950911,
0.035042908,
0.0163931064,
0.0114496173,
0.0001798252,
0.0441824012,
-0.0017386273,
-0.0147439269,
-0.0564842448,
-0.0188632999,
-0.0275224932,
0.0316415243,
0.0586852692,
0.0273814425,
-0.0189111345,
-0.0354985632,
2.722e-7,
0.0623275749,
0.0326839462,
-0.0130428411,
-0.0143019725,
0.010475086,
0.0124043915,
0.0238450337,
0.0347162001,
-0.0285376757,
-0.0326784328,
-0.0120526049,
-0.0137760965,
0.0125026628,
0.0234658737,
-0.0577100106,
-0.0425102599,
-0.0637031049,
0.0466421284,
-0.0449540988,
0.0241374653,
0.0276717488,
0.0394514166,
0.0198831037,
0.0123536512,
-0.0897343233,
-0.0161513351,
0.0184981972,
-0.0287600681,
0.0155926244,
0.0296584517,
0.0743129924,
0.0324342884,
0.0472925901,
-0.0234593078,
-0.0010106121,
-0.0022400748,
0.0167138427,
0.0385026149,
0.009908054,
-0.0198385138,
-0.0187630616,
-0.0472543314,
0.0153369987,
-0.0619516969,
0.0479950905,
-0.0179502442,
-0.0383365937,
-0.0588846579,
-0.0485503487,
0.0033546428,
0.0484400466,
-0.0041294061,
-0.0457898937,
0.0573255606,
0.0145067954,
-0.0224807691,
-0.0317447782,
-0.0569144338,
0.0097241551,
-0.0180411916,
0.0394257866,
-0.0229829941,
0.0118009849,
-0.0240368824,
-0.0469522476,
-0.0335095339,
0.0044537,
2.007014948e-34,
0.0136283934,
0.0125908982,
0.05207045,
0.0043753316,
0.0230195932,
0.0538590588,
-0.0039981771,
-0.0319990553,
-0.0176273752,
-0.0214758329,
-0.0117868986
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10471v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10471v3 | Little Red Riding Hood Goes Around the Globe:Crosslingual Story Planning and Generation with Large Language Models | 2022-12-20T17:42:16 | 2024-03-25T17:54:21 | Evgeniia Razumovskaia, Joshua Maynez, Annie Louis, Mirella Lapata, Shashi Narayan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Previous work has demonstrated the effectiveness of planning for story
generation exclusively in a monolingual setting focusing primarily on English.
We consider whether planning brings advantages to automatic story generation
across languages. We propose a new task of cross-lingual story generation with
planning and present a new dataset for this task. We conduct a comprehensive
study of different plans and generate stories in several languages, by
leveraging the creative and reasoning capabilities of large pre-trained
language models. Our results demonstrate that plans which structure stories
into three acts lead to more coherent and interesting narratives, while
allowing to explicitly control their content and structure. | [
0.0143145816,
0.0266800672,
-0.0279416218,
0.0131691955,
-0.0489178337,
-0.0138260974,
0.0270716324,
-0.0438374877,
0.0009653972,
-0.0172056817,
0.0189430527,
-0.0094494242,
-0.0014621677,
0.0742218718,
-0.011543354,
-0.0539977029,
0.0143810371,
-0.0447192751,
0.0139129153,
0.0024576054,
-0.0152527308,
0.0585803017,
0.0052747056,
0.0477093942,
-0.0324837379,
0.0026718855,
-0.0290061738,
-0.0080029434,
0.0401913933,
-0.0307147168,
-0.0031366847,
-0.0111033376,
0.0430958793,
0.0068643712,
0.0000017792,
-0.0640866756,
-0.0013038478,
-0.0417602509,
0.0434667692,
-0.0418525115,
-0.0006249335,
-0.0131236706,
0.0132280439,
-0.0098183667,
-0.0168369357,
0.0135441935,
0.025718607,
0.0726340562,
0.0268889964,
0.0873691514,
-0.0132581992,
-0.0713211298,
-0.0459155217,
0.002626095,
0.0557521917,
-0.0100267977,
-0.0289841834,
0.0283331443,
0.0248679295,
-0.024733834,
-0.0188008286,
-0.0044744783,
0.0450962931,
-0.0236222371,
-0.0715570524,
0.04467576,
0.0025078522,
-0.0111868624,
-0.028965598,
0.0507661924,
-0.0475383773,
-0.0253445804,
0.0039858688,
-0.0289550293,
-0.0042265509,
-0.0018087627,
-0.0232568681,
0.0928646103,
0.0082803369,
0.0293289516,
0.0436051153,
0.0367340595,
0.0215490181,
-0.0042827628,
0.0232410412,
0.0420941748,
0.0240219869,
0.0038040266,
-0.0259225741,
0.0168837383,
0.0256047938,
-0.0883755684,
0.0182798058,
0.0490114428,
-0.0236328058,
0.022461364,
-0.070732221,
0.051948633,
-0.025981551,
-0.019495802,
0.0370532461,
0.0393605158,
0.0023113966,
0.053707812,
-0.0038165979,
0.0417323373,
-0.0017535927,
-0.009803337,
-0.0337977447,
0.0313681699,
-0.034371268,
0.0278056599,
-0.0518002436,
-0.0007777077,
-0.0533701777,
-0.0257472042,
-0.0288624279,
0.0166134555,
0.0562529713,
0.0003809642,
0.0175688714,
0.0213334113,
-0.0273169745,
-0.0167779718,
-0.0469940268,
0.0151668154,
-0.0755258501,
-0.0133496756,
0.0137489988,
0.0246087834,
-0.0155635411,
0.0025671057,
0.0300915316,
-0.0341433808,
0.0320695639,
0.0382196978,
-0.036035955,
0.0194039866,
-0.0586342737,
-0.0874419734,
-0.0022759156,
-0.0985081941,
-0.0116441995,
-0.06138267,
0.0765780658,
-0.006463584,
0.0210234579,
-0.0294211935,
0.0181635413,
0.0032041734,
-0.0228550304,
-0.0102738645,
0.0051722024,
0.0143569754,
-0.0117393732,
0.008180554,
0.009775674,
0.0569620356,
0.0716156289,
0.0499957688,
0.0457230322,
0.032409776,
0.0080893235,
0.016680805,
-0.0251806658,
-0.018251596,
0.0101628443,
-0.016819533,
-0.0027222892,
0.0563611016,
-0.0116913747,
0.0368861966,
-0.0298002474,
0.0102103911,
0.0474354401,
0.0524489954,
0.0146725979,
0.0338119864,
0.1317567229,
-0.0206469372,
-0.0284344144,
0.034491878,
0.0029833261,
0.0412004963,
0.0116473734,
-0.0006385497,
-0.0109563814,
0.0437175483,
-0.0322873592,
-0.0174792744,
0.0258717053,
-0.0008410831,
0.0040464541,
-0.0307323113,
-0.0098630907,
0.0201962367,
-0.056557402,
-0.0050289049,
0.0065130326,
-0.0914482102,
0.0544126928,
0.0311427116,
0.0395350754,
0.085976176,
0.0212850422,
-0.0073100906,
-0.0351909325,
-0.0233904831,
0.0313509367,
0.0194706973,
0.0343565159,
-0.0315281637,
0.0507157296,
-0.0465900563,
0.0133026382,
-0.0606123507,
-0.0057866629,
0.0353396609,
-0.014568612,
0.0397654325,
-0.0061251596,
-0.0113684023,
-0.0254570022,
0.0450905748,
-0.0911578536,
0.0030311691,
0.0077643599,
0.006618428,
-0.0254129358,
-0.01340828,
-0.0202226825,
-0.0086177941,
0.0227406844,
-0.0406052992,
0.0017138903,
0.086781621,
-0.0414789729,
-0.0647562668,
0.0311180111,
-0.0690716058,
-0.0174597576,
-0.0502169468,
0.0172943883,
-0.0392629206,
0.0525633097,
-0.0051658251,
-0.002397219,
-0.0064232028,
0.0157184247,
0.008297557,
-0.0257504396,
-0.0005185576,
0.0534972847,
0.0234450772,
0.0165071003,
-0.0060322843,
0.002861442,
0.0381077752,
0.0078123887,
0.014426115,
0.0357674882,
0.0232406203,
-0.0188608523,
0.0553925522,
0.0239842255,
-0.0092428084,
-0.0343723148,
-0.061494913,
0.0271389354,
-0.0115844039,
-0.0208767522,
0.0337424874,
0.0237371083,
-0.0180103984,
0.0133845499,
-0.0719882324,
0.0036380503,
0.0347348154,
-0.0280600488,
0.0016315398,
0.0153000681,
-0.011250535,
-0.0091061136,
0.0227985922,
-0.0001165913,
0.0524512231,
0.0696173534,
-0.0076493989,
-0.0428125933,
0.050904505,
-0.0609199218,
0.0093630552,
-0.0336473733,
-0.0372129418,
0.0196926538,
-0.0041800174,
0.0730907843,
0.0169596449,
-0.0219993927,
-0.0142806647,
0.0902538449,
-0.0614218488,
-0.0154477982,
0.0280784518,
-0.0199014414,
0.0030309095,
-0.0344877206,
-0.0633370057,
0.0055633644,
0.0735133663,
0.0078414455,
0.0006456327,
-0.0623211041,
0.0202136654,
0.0150806475,
-0.0411313362,
0.006842108,
-0.025466295,
0.0249468125,
0.1067079604,
-0.0157763828,
-0.0254695211,
0.0707890764,
-0.0160920229,
-0.0122009907,
-0.0087913917,
0.0347455628,
-0.0544880182,
0.0957780406,
-0.0028995052,
0.0732276887,
-0.0026783724,
0.0290499907,
-0.0498394221,
-0.0036721784,
0.0256255921,
0.017790487,
0.0112408185,
-0.0557555035,
-0.0247426592,
0.0090366378,
-0.0289816931,
-0.0396211669,
-0.0580877662,
-0.0130076855,
-0.004596252,
0.0127283372,
-0.0306553151,
-0.0498775728,
-0.0005519729,
0.0292024612,
0.0360144079,
0.0013838651,
-0.0156505872,
0.0127267577,
-0.0002033666,
0.0411296822,
-0.0076629315,
-0.0194095112,
-0.0420310311,
0.0483143851,
0.0036794865,
-0.0223808121,
0.0020674816,
0.0290259346,
0.0547749586,
0.0295092054,
-0.0193259269,
-0.0308605153,
0.0129448278,
0.0526806302,
-0.0507778712,
-0.0321619846,
0.0814979672,
0.0384345911,
-0.0062525896,
0.0077954321,
-0.0143244248,
0.0345311686,
0.0238918532,
0.0329560079,
-0.0705686063,
-0.0011421582,
0.0049992553,
-0.0560772493,
-0.0141110336,
-0.0608416386,
-0.0503673591,
-0.1014664099,
0.0488177538,
0.0170693584,
-0.0304416437,
-0.0016666186,
0.0197878405,
-0.0572351404,
0.028829053,
-0.0192821752,
-0.0087512154,
-0.0188594684,
-0.0059235371,
-0.0476028137,
-0.0126946,
-0.010381693,
0.0044180141,
-0.0271800421,
-0.0041566873,
0.0635655075,
0.0572299734,
0.0009134519,
0.009674415,
-0.0262576714,
0.0288098063,
-0.0103615616,
0.0033979425,
0.0287766624,
0.0021972603,
-0.0233820677,
-0.010502019,
0.0463734604,
0.0099799335,
-0.076838389,
0.0421911888,
0.0512778983,
-0.00770577,
-0.0585143194,
0.0162386838,
0.0659331903,
0.0040812613,
0.0899397284,
-0.0051712436,
-0.0368435495,
-0.0207710527,
-0.0290492196,
-0.0027568215,
-0.114727512,
-0.0532907397,
0.0269256141,
-0.0286977962,
0.0139280995,
-0.0586260483,
-0.0741812661,
0.0480918437,
0.0454589128,
0.0564214922,
-0.0187835619,
-0.0026206484,
-0.0112284664,
-0.0386642627,
0.0091464231,
-0.0209847596,
0.0124083376,
-0.0079127811,
-0.0092630498,
-0.0156177711,
-0.0709240511,
0.0059096636,
0.0177768879,
-0.0452941619,
-0.0677897036,
-0.0250940379,
0.0274831727,
0.0125034079,
0.0543940701,
0.0306117721,
-0.0575930662,
0.0184340924,
-0.0261173956,
-0.02533786,
0.0439599901,
-0.0177289937,
0.052345369,
0.0143739525,
0.0174561869,
-0.0278452057,
0.0023210421,
0.0078829303,
0.055660788,
-0.0059070294,
-0.0114133107,
0.0176577847,
0.000812456,
-0.0299860369,
-0.0725281686,
-0.0063096224,
-0.0734469369,
-0.0276882034,
-0.0600994714,
-0.0521690845,
-0.0432392471,
0.0254127271,
0.0460373275,
0.0084729185,
-0.0158342011,
0.026002638,
-0.0658992231,
-0.0414217748,
-0.0145905446,
-0.0058615701,
0.0269848742,
-0.011078787,
0.0358268954,
0.021302158,
-0.0240091886,
0.0256352406,
-0.0419378169,
0.0409758464,
-0.0228231307,
0.0321880914,
0.000054898,
0.0116041275,
-0.0205309615,
-0.0091087008,
-0.0212312359,
-0.0393324532,
0.0249202829,
0.0131232664,
0.0613192692,
-0.0375630856,
0.0709705651,
-0.0346775353,
0.0209314786,
-0.0052432851,
0.0260209795,
0.0347076692,
-0.0386298969,
-0.02109465,
-0.0015765084,
-0.0258891452,
0.0067456462,
0.0718041584,
-0.02418839,
0.0460872799,
0.0359079763,
-0.0106147183,
-0.0142332176,
-0.0285435934,
0.0201357063,
0.0239572208,
0.0276940074,
-0.0341026932,
-0.0628937781,
-0.0199899934,
0.0087391976,
0.0165747181,
-0.0039774664,
0.0165616926,
0.0178568382,
0.0209194813,
-0.0005461422,
0.0451539382,
-0.0548343584,
-0.0050957017,
-0.0061536538,
-0.0357462242,
-0.0043039303,
-5.397842876e-33,
-0.0187676493,
-0.023103958,
0.0327441692,
-0.0225577131,
-0.0411776751,
-0.0105818035,
-0.0452445261,
0.0069976179,
0.017723836,
0.0553188287,
0.0238805264,
-0.0415210538,
0.0034287006,
0.0059702811,
-0.0016270175,
0.0059089083,
0.0411107838,
0.0200982653,
-0.0570131689,
0.0171403624,
0.0506687053,
0.021387754,
0.0067445291,
-0.0059091449,
-0.0184082035,
-0.0380745977,
-0.024262974,
0.0156296771,
0.0502846166,
0.0447942503,
-0.0115329595,
0.0069308854,
0.0228468422,
0.0240539405,
-0.0252418257,
0.0085832849,
-0.0330769196,
-0.040827252,
0.0464954935,
-0.0058975657,
-0.0203783661,
-0.0560040511,
0.0028338192,
-0.0257390458,
0.0058980286,
-0.0147731518,
0.040102385,
0.0029873301,
0.0179965999,
-0.0249339435,
-0.1109014601,
-0.0196946673,
-0.0479588173,
-0.065064244,
0.0381729975,
0.0619622171,
0.0350715294,
-0.0371099263,
0.020497201,
0.0583815314,
-0.0663228706,
0.0142075317,
0.0099501088,
0.0009593398,
-0.0160506833,
0.0943045095,
0.0248187073,
0.0298101213,
-0.0539639965,
0.0777805001,
-0.0161132831,
0.0349899009,
0.0172486771,
0.0650800169,
-0.0113332653,
0.0012914872,
-0.0839689746,
0.0505388379,
0.0098780245,
-0.0147441877,
0.0381898209,
-0.014344899,
0.020995507,
-0.0228825286,
-0.0475062616,
-0.0144235361,
-0.0038010806,
-0.0408579484,
0.018838821,
0.0091423104,
0.0132467188,
0.0254782327,
0.0405034311,
-0.0109853288,
-0.0065441607,
0.0348460414,
-0.0770187825,
0.0176910721,
0.0017664934,
0.0448626019,
-0.0151485754,
-0.0260560904,
0.0321656838,
0.0015490848,
0.0472913869,
0.0197130889,
0.0181429833,
0.0347069688,
-0.0319383182,
0.0104447715,
-0.0667453259,
0.0224090572,
-0.0086839804,
-0.0140297953,
0.0068023945,
-0.0197334234,
-0.0402641445,
-0.0206745416,
0.0336708315,
-0.0651323497,
-0.0072240131,
-0.0521290489,
0.0120956348,
0.0430862568,
-0.0395710766,
0.0258909427,
-0.0337420404,
-0.006845904,
0.0419051796,
-0.0451499969,
-0.0096808039,
-0.0020967028,
2.476e-7,
-0.0090672979,
-0.0086228577,
0.014743356,
0.0526807643,
-0.0190019123,
0.0174357872,
-0.0350491218,
-0.0024320555,
0.0044997386,
0.0001402725,
0.0092824558,
0.020717239,
0.0337082446,
0.055443313,
-0.0694040358,
0.0178792905,
-0.0261333678,
-0.0263389479,
-0.0643585026,
-0.04460999,
0.0672631338,
0.010502384,
0.035557732,
-0.0093464684,
0.0154107548,
-0.0498642698,
0.0789396465,
-0.0491560027,
-0.0531969219,
0.0473236665,
-0.0589737929,
0.0205873158,
-0.0318326242,
-0.0522788987,
-0.0136699807,
0.0184757244,
0.0033599755,
0.0459590293,
-0.0005244967,
0.0055179093,
0.0475644544,
-0.0085798427,
-0.0335978121,
-0.031978745,
0.0582714379,
-0.0145446556,
-0.0044870977,
0.0122780763,
0.0304552056,
0.0273692403,
0.0081297755,
-0.0539858751,
-0.0115136066,
0.0487348251,
0.0342449695,
0.011755907,
0.0096407635,
-0.0394195691,
-0.0436033942,
0.0190144237,
-0.0266012922,
0.0006688856,
-0.0050776689,
0.015926009,
-0.0311158616,
-0.036192704,
0.0186463092,
2.06754005e-34,
0.0137879821,
-0.0148840882,
-0.0044304887,
-0.0158479251,
0.0677614361,
-0.0155834276,
0.0412957966,
0.0003111718,
0.015615127,
-0.0213147458,
-0.0631822348
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10469v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10469v2 | BMX: Boosting Natural Language Generation Metrics with Explainability | 2022-12-20T17:41:18 | 2024-02-17T16:55:27 | Christoph Leiter, Hoa Nguyen, Steffen Eger | cs.CL | cs.CL | State-of-the-art natural language generation evaluation metrics are based on
black-box language models. Hence, recent works consider their explainability
with the goals of better understandability for humans and better metric
analysis, including failure cases. In contrast, our proposed method BMX:
Boosting Natural Language Generation Metrics with explainability explicitly
leverages explanations to boost the metrics' performance. In particular, we
perceive feature importance explanations as word-level scores, which we
convert, via power means, into a segment-level score. We then combine this
segment-level score with the original metric to obtain a better metric. Our
tests show improvements for multiple metrics across MT and summarization
datasets. While improvements in machine translation are small, they are strong
for summarization. Notably, BMX with the LIME explainer and preselected
parameters achieves an average improvement of 0.087 points in Spearman
correlation on the system-level evaluation of SummEval. | [
0.0182573609,
0.0413629413,
0.0027075172,
0.0067329817,
-0.0005770776,
0.0180227701,
-0.0057060868,
-0.0315886065,
-0.0564050712,
-0.0217380188,
0.0212269798,
-0.0207101516,
0.0394393392,
0.0621986613,
0.0454985686,
-0.0771951377,
0.0013960709,
0.0081539042,
0.0057454971,
0.0310903769,
0.0213785917,
0.0299246255,
0.0035951352,
0.0663919598,
0.0108632436,
0.0341155156,
-0.0020578441,
0.012909974,
0.0307913646,
-0.0095423823,
-0.0376947671,
0.0229666699,
0.0181562789,
0.0061039664,
0.0000019033,
-0.0524808355,
-0.0468049571,
0.0018774169,
-0.0170031469,
0.0084408121,
0.0063233236,
-0.0368567184,
0.0410491787,
0.0226526856,
-0.0118411602,
0.0346358977,
0.0255311877,
0.0410180688,
0.074805513,
0.071896188,
0.0020931833,
0.0007472365,
-0.0123171965,
-0.0220688451,
0.0117575154,
-0.0117909778,
-0.0546249896,
0.0277281962,
-0.0118818125,
-0.0017070177,
0.0048334426,
0.0007431629,
0.0107568344,
-0.030620845,
0.0448033139,
0.0118853478,
-0.0201992895,
-0.0132354163,
0.0248732734,
0.0552781895,
-0.0017257439,
-0.0155586591,
0.0280399472,
-0.0046250424,
-0.0138029577,
-0.0104111861,
-0.0483156256,
0.0366749838,
0.0198223349,
0.022327831,
0.029117737,
0.0222067535,
0.056789875,
0.0222531464,
-0.015115059,
0.0595752448,
-0.0011266145,
0.0161483269,
-0.0462714098,
0.0048755948,
-0.0605598055,
-0.0341961943,
-0.0068335696,
0.0379599184,
-0.0505520254,
0.0246249326,
-0.0289581232,
-0.026633881,
-0.0008161716,
-0.0276866425,
0.0175441727,
0.0451282896,
0.0024856452,
0.021220753,
-0.012267381,
0.074717924,
0.0442790352,
-0.0247486457,
-0.0488786288,
-0.0026576261,
-0.0463553891,
-0.0137695828,
-0.0102093015,
-0.000421941,
-0.0356973447,
-0.0101015745,
-0.0565835312,
0.0220203362,
0.0081008412,
-0.024663737,
0.0064200964,
0.0333237723,
-0.0212481804,
-0.0184757262,
-0.0110839838,
-0.0013769822,
-0.0523995422,
-0.0178665817,
0.044361975,
-0.0292101391,
-0.0140928933,
0.0434547588,
-0.0134370914,
0.0100669041,
0.0059448751,
0.0646391064,
-0.0176862273,
-0.0415665358,
-0.0334964134,
-0.1066562384,
-0.0443084799,
-0.0590724237,
-0.0321373641,
-0.047489021,
0.0023792149,
0.0201961081,
-0.0170806907,
0.0013401529,
0.0147782527,
0.0001392584,
-0.0256915577,
0.0002782591,
-0.0179022271,
0.0192483794,
-0.0003834453,
0.0074101249,
-0.0040933904,
0.0368885174,
0.0696075261,
0.0355215222,
0.0449822098,
-0.0084059536,
-0.0027587141,
-0.0264022835,
0.0163114574,
-0.0129609648,
-0.0039936481,
-0.050200846,
-0.0782826468,
0.0281669572,
0.0392319523,
0.0311464407,
-0.0175259747,
0.0519111678,
0.0371413454,
0.0101357456,
0.0342096314,
0.0139090382,
0.0761360824,
0.0118537098,
-0.0205704812,
0.0302062109,
0.0051182043,
0.0487441942,
-0.0432553068,
0.0464541093,
0.0799082145,
0.0365433022,
-0.0051913629,
-0.0786617324,
0.0117583331,
-0.005443648,
-0.0180724058,
-0.0317954831,
0.0319513641,
0.0276497658,
-0.0373795927,
0.0418287665,
-0.0078606624,
-0.087346226,
0.03506767,
-0.0337003171,
0.0397787653,
0.0700221658,
0.0687734038,
0.0196944345,
0.0043196725,
0.0081648389,
0.0008010968,
0.0451490656,
-0.0056000273,
0.0012046067,
0.0147331171,
-0.0583728142,
-0.0321199745,
-0.0339818783,
0.0408381447,
-0.0113077834,
-0.0141725074,
-0.0305571742,
0.0736882016,
-0.0701287389,
-0.0716834888,
0.0366523601,
-0.0030106672,
-0.0142139224,
0.0212697517,
-0.0085072275,
0.0273543801,
0.0432053655,
-0.0157397185,
0.039246954,
0.0003720224,
-0.0566921979,
-0.0272770803,
0.079280436,
-0.0283124931,
-0.0497507267,
-0.0071822288,
-0.0600575842,
0.0395643972,
0.0215626489,
-0.0290405694,
-0.0892081782,
0.0332520194,
-0.0759867057,
0.0176396985,
-0.052339118,
0.0364743397,
0.0041550272,
0.0269397963,
-0.0384274349,
0.0531289503,
-0.016538661,
0.0210918542,
0.0224112216,
-0.0211234745,
0.0157845262,
0.0009563789,
0.0203742888,
-0.0041937027,
-0.0221609399,
-0.0055049602,
0.0460589975,
0.0086846044,
-0.0107612489,
-0.0211349297,
-0.0539215431,
0.0004276982,
-0.0417836756,
0.0154235335,
0.0621139929,
0.01168436,
0.007667928,
0.0101262862,
-0.0436924845,
-0.0232184455,
0.0594876371,
-0.018982172,
0.057483457,
-0.0045287423,
0.0059026871,
-0.0337496251,
0.0223726146,
0.0020018604,
0.0636409596,
0.0279720034,
0.0125550777,
-0.04042219,
0.0414189026,
-0.0399791077,
-0.0858514607,
-0.0124837104,
-0.0373713449,
0.0043780361,
0.030046396,
0.0497717299,
0.0068228487,
0.0384017564,
0.0482669994,
0.0264709666,
0.0145600159,
-0.0080548255,
-0.0336044058,
-0.0469003357,
0.0273304023,
0.0170064196,
-0.0992282405,
0.0607300624,
0.0742481649,
0.0057491208,
-0.0123290094,
-0.0621675588,
0.0217446554,
-0.0106515521,
-0.0139761278,
-0.0142722037,
-0.0410467125,
0.0117777316,
0.0435520932,
-0.0337768681,
-0.0938792601,
0.0690995604,
-0.074485831,
0.0087963911,
-0.0424484573,
-0.0335170142,
-0.0623700321,
0.0472535156,
0.0146288732,
0.0452932604,
-0.0155656617,
-0.0196112469,
-0.0130673563,
-0.002804423,
0.0149596836,
-0.014094308,
0.0425853543,
-0.0608081557,
-0.0375186987,
0.0153420027,
0.0504525937,
-0.012127623,
-0.0348810516,
-0.007638277,
0.0095177898,
0.0763731003,
-0.0199744292,
-0.0211808179,
0.0174862705,
0.0414706543,
-0.0134402523,
-0.0314357989,
-0.0110183507,
0.0035707857,
0.0076526217,
0.0248494819,
0.0297956485,
0.0386550017,
-0.0608794764,
0.0204751939,
0.005334246,
0.0204944909,
-0.0068439222,
-0.0067855571,
0.0107067507,
-0.0196826328,
-0.0148627032,
-0.0257576406,
0.0222658757,
0.0796470121,
-0.0540288426,
-0.0077684261,
0.1227855533,
0.0336975269,
0.0196151976,
0.02495851,
0.0019774595,
0.0670151114,
-0.006999793,
-0.003264671,
-0.0093682958,
-0.0296434686,
-0.0092284558,
0.0667939931,
-0.0214857496,
-0.0013000974,
-0.0450171344,
-0.0759165585,
0.0095409648,
0.0214892384,
-0.0507878438,
-0.0290838797,
-0.0424054936,
-0.0484079719,
-0.0130820852,
0.0014329702,
0.0249485169,
0.0146421203,
0.0493582115,
0.0485312603,
-0.0829743445,
-0.0475043915,
-0.0129829738,
-0.0239010733,
0.0019507841,
0.0817464963,
0.0457993075,
0.0204905402,
-0.0060879067,
-0.0138497734,
0.0000763274,
0.0422328487,
-0.00135415,
0.0723316818,
0.0166744143,
-0.0114831273,
-0.0344019271,
0.0507536307,
-0.018876208,
-0.0045494735,
-0.0415788144,
0.0307137743,
-0.0175323952,
-0.0012625039,
-0.0239152182,
0.0461430922,
-0.021104807,
0.0662955344,
0.0583881699,
-0.0124416715,
-0.0288099386,
-0.0219649523,
0.0024757551,
-0.0868803039,
-0.0038191993,
-0.0088179167,
-0.0093159042,
-0.0382700004,
-0.1014021188,
-0.0430464335,
-0.0002339722,
0.0476535559,
-0.0016752917,
0.0014879573,
-0.0515754968,
-0.0332788005,
-0.0270337481,
0.0405101217,
0.0258165896,
0.008132712,
-0.0355313011,
-0.0214364976,
0.0048500653,
-0.0444179103,
-0.0148778725,
0.0403833576,
-0.0458055399,
-0.0540061854,
-0.0391780883,
0.0296117682,
0.0267727152,
0.0271187704,
0.02003121,
-0.0502415337,
0.0132515887,
0.0341642946,
-0.0164097138,
0.0270505343,
0.0127231665,
-0.0029584896,
-0.0179444365,
0.0289869215,
-0.0408936776,
-0.0148498192,
-0.0291017741,
0.0707453936,
0.0037967043,
-0.0024700079,
0.0273822602,
0.0249808393,
0.0167452302,
-0.0472584218,
-0.0035149567,
-0.0298848916,
-0.0315697044,
-0.0255293325,
-0.0176388733,
-0.0782113224,
0.0319614336,
0.0067824796,
-0.0039938157,
-0.0124365501,
0.007884685,
-0.0514484718,
-0.010905101,
0.0013873738,
-0.0067564021,
-0.0627732351,
0.0003755003,
-0.0363410227,
-0.000367003,
-0.0109350309,
-0.0169751905,
-0.0361890532,
0.0058460669,
0.0120591354,
0.046447251,
-0.0141928215,
0.0285890568,
0.0099991942,
0.0318412781,
-0.056677185,
0.0024371105,
-0.0373672135,
-0.0228784904,
0.0458468236,
-0.0330312774,
0.1206961721,
0.000865089,
0.0170402676,
-0.0089585967,
0.1020682156,
0.0278652068,
-0.061533168,
-0.0278127175,
0.0025090931,
-0.0357685126,
-0.00286109,
0.0943340957,
-0.0025792364,
-0.0218874309,
0.0011051217,
-0.0180318616,
-0.0212658234,
-0.0093674576,
0.0115591241,
0.036118634,
-0.0005167381,
-0.0056400998,
-0.0556623302,
-0.0535283983,
0.0129425172,
0.0060952222,
0.0314706601,
-0.0311669651,
0.0530001074,
0.0616247021,
-0.0459446944,
0.0121010086,
-0.07053563,
-0.0092690261,
-0.0457893796,
0.0492570437,
-0.0079885945,
-6.111749615e-33,
-0.0446716994,
-0.0718882531,
-0.0078074024,
-0.0151460012,
-0.0220378656,
0.0009433994,
-0.0705521777,
0.0149727529,
0.0267778207,
0.0264115296,
0.0447407402,
0.0136540588,
0.0023477133,
0.033071138,
-0.0295580216,
0.0110621676,
0.0398631729,
0.0301112141,
-0.0739179552,
0.0572765693,
0.0638233051,
0.0140194306,
0.0296772961,
-0.0374796875,
0.0508297607,
0.0125064906,
-0.0276984405,
0.0125044649,
0.0338380709,
0.022588728,
0.0019506969,
0.0176150724,
0.026578255,
-0.0475542806,
-0.0417515375,
-0.0165923275,
-0.0083662756,
-0.0067172861,
0.0321448557,
-0.0187114216,
-0.0465723798,
-0.0440710336,
0.0477106981,
-0.02089159,
-0.0045527853,
-0.0061542382,
0.0365369059,
-0.038671568,
-0.0374104604,
-0.047213234,
-0.0262134448,
0.050096523,
-0.0593694448,
-0.0440013669,
-0.0132915378,
0.0448204651,
-0.0137626193,
-0.0007681443,
0.0411288664,
0.0334915556,
0.0520597547,
0.0411664508,
0.0943375826,
0.010030508,
-0.0281554516,
0.0616929159,
0.0159464758,
-0.0145619018,
-0.0419485942,
0.045915097,
0.0000959948,
0.048498366,
0.0866293609,
0.0401023477,
0.0113889528,
0.0351345912,
-0.0586434864,
0.1043341607,
-0.0269416738,
-0.0049385885,
0.0336789377,
-0.0165746845,
-0.0283878688,
-0.0184217617,
-0.041233629,
-0.0193136912,
-0.0239539929,
-0.0357757322,
-0.0021284218,
0.0138393426,
-0.0631041825,
-0.0695725605,
0.0189359616,
-0.0084891766,
0.0558101051,
0.0290727876,
-0.0536981858,
-0.0140995691,
0.0068859654,
-0.0219438337,
-0.0267635453,
0.0207710192,
0.0316146798,
0.0357129127,
0.0196839422,
-0.0266032927,
0.0138667542,
0.0098122321,
-0.0142494431,
0.0265517011,
-0.0433115177,
0.0044475589,
-0.0541840382,
-0.0078324452,
-0.0020127469,
-0.0172593426,
-0.0704873279,
0.0323260874,
-0.014118162,
0.004750269,
-0.0025095786,
-0.0033557701,
-0.0137644336,
0.020579135,
-0.0370728299,
0.0056683016,
0.0099415425,
-0.0208680518,
0.0660618097,
-0.0294377152,
-0.0430727191,
-0.0134572973,
2.556e-7,
0.0546324961,
0.0318980962,
0.0293277819,
0.0068457769,
-0.020575529,
0.0297798477,
-0.0140714776,
0.0003794764,
-0.0045474125,
0.0043644807,
0.0320464782,
-0.0047691227,
0.0728098229,
0.0219968278,
-0.0394534096,
-0.0025620006,
-0.0596343391,
-0.0264352132,
-0.0351731405,
-0.022941662,
0.0539819747,
0.0461458974,
-0.0366964228,
-0.0073967706,
0.0274722334,
-0.0503951795,
0.0492117144,
-0.022293238,
-0.04109082,
0.0241649747,
0.0874303952,
0.0259865951,
-0.0176707599,
-0.0239691772,
-0.0326358378,
0.0064472388,
0.0262047127,
0.0334967114,
0.0460868441,
-0.0416736603,
0.0075839567,
0.0013192844,
0.0234594904,
-0.0236459877,
0.0285368171,
-0.0150426291,
-0.0393573865,
-0.0253617857,
-0.0247827955,
0.0043215626,
-0.0055633676,
-0.0030788025,
-0.0294661969,
0.0286329277,
-0.0112538077,
-0.017082002,
0.0206171554,
-0.043882817,
-0.075526014,
0.005414845,
-0.0054412284,
-0.0123202987,
-0.0317344964,
0.0216671303,
0.0242990479,
-0.0333558731,
-0.022235658,
2.570540511e-34,
0.0425643437,
-0.0229508132,
-0.0023043626,
-0.020603152,
0.0616000667,
0.0116095925,
-0.0166326724,
-0.0178837031,
0.0397410356,
-0.0432210006,
-0.0139972456
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10467v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10467v2 | Generic Temporal Reasoning with Differential Analysis and Explanation | 2022-12-20T17:40:03 | 2023-05-31T17:54:08 | Yu Feng, Ben Zhou, Haoyu Wang, Helen Jin, Dan Roth | cs.CL | cs.CL | Temporal reasoning is the task of predicting temporal relations of event
pairs. While temporal reasoning models can perform reasonably well on in-domain
benchmarks, we have little idea of these systems' generalizability due to
existing datasets' limitations. In this work, we introduce a novel task named
TODAY that bridges this gap with temporal differential analysis, which as the
name suggests, evaluates whether systems can correctly understand the effect of
incremental changes. Specifically, TODAY introduces slight contextual changes
for given event pairs, and systems are asked to tell how this subtle contextual
change would affect relevant temporal relation distributions. To facilitate
learning, TODAY also annotates human explanations. We show that existing
models, including GPT-3.5, drop to random guessing on TODAY, suggesting that
they heavily rely on spurious information rather than proper reasoning for
temporal predictions. On the other hand, we show that TODAY's supervision style
and explanation annotations can be used in joint learning, encouraging models
to use more appropriate signals during training and thus outperform across
several benchmarks. TODAY can also be used to train models to solicit
incidental supervision from noisy sources such as GPT-3.5, thus moving us more
toward the goal of generic temporal reasoning systems. | [
0.0100523056,
0.0502194017,
-0.0164978467,
0.023236353,
-0.0136403553,
0.0147941783,
0.0315678529,
-0.0043745353,
-0.011235049,
-0.0046830759,
0.0452630743,
-0.040084336,
-0.0041215541,
0.0470761769,
-0.0014358414,
-0.0980815738,
0.0575545095,
-0.0391466655,
0.0046153064,
0.0307657551,
-0.009230189,
-0.0192678403,
-0.0346087776,
0.0403898805,
-0.0236792155,
-0.0309341364,
-0.0655205399,
-0.0370727852,
0.0480497405,
-0.0506247431,
-0.0095165865,
0.016638279,
0.0752046332,
0.0035902041,
0.0000019906,
0.0047968542,
0.0036616807,
-0.018248532,
-0.0256806426,
-0.0183093622,
-0.0727212206,
0.0035472969,
0.0218115933,
-0.005889276,
-0.0567530841,
-0.0045922105,
-0.0002778964,
0.0508115925,
0.0425936468,
0.0686098263,
-0.0055588516,
0.0068338858,
0.0147347637,
-0.0199053511,
0.0642769411,
-0.0206191111,
-0.0025809091,
0.0191708393,
0.0354111381,
-0.0187503342,
0.014698185,
-0.0242120959,
0.0445611104,
-0.0262631308,
0.0556498431,
0.0758426338,
0.0237195697,
0.0137085374,
-0.0325659029,
0.034085054,
0.0275481734,
-0.0262181144,
0.0107679842,
-0.0030558968,
-0.0171670988,
-0.0084363837,
-0.0291690733,
-0.0619659536,
-0.0210609827,
-0.0036260432,
-0.0029930349,
0.0190160815,
0.0402385779,
0.0105127497,
0.0019940215,
0.0735380277,
-0.0218316317,
-0.010270399,
-0.0311529376,
-0.0044998401,
0.0194339883,
-0.0603250712,
-0.0173167866,
0.0954854786,
-0.0354773253,
-0.0169841163,
0.0360206962,
0.0418161824,
-0.0240478944,
-0.0270969719,
-0.0232806057,
0.0567019098,
0.0002827367,
0.0399116054,
-0.0018488165,
0.0614488162,
-0.0134209339,
-0.0114729861,
0.0163078811,
0.0465293676,
-0.0813340545,
0.0021034887,
-0.0044681719,
0.0069641359,
-0.0376187041,
0.0230310801,
-0.0226641502,
0.0393121466,
-0.0412542336,
0.0225815363,
-0.0313848592,
0.0430729799,
-0.0237848777,
-0.0091225142,
-0.0675686151,
-0.0201138258,
-0.0562979579,
0.030752331,
-0.0007381972,
-0.0143084945,
-0.0469518527,
-0.0225750692,
-0.0035409431,
-0.0419120602,
-0.0357630849,
0.0963731483,
-0.0049852198,
0.0052852207,
-0.0804211944,
-0.0501102097,
-0.0002014511,
-0.0294894949,
0.0111533208,
-0.0125159994,
-0.008528512,
-0.0183098428,
-0.0196806025,
0.0072964774,
0.0191251617,
-0.0365907215,
-0.0041064015,
0.0900800601,
0.0342629775,
0.0107185347,
0.0153882829,
0.0331204049,
-0.0148920873,
0.0366160311,
0.0137597956,
-0.0036397791,
-0.0030204824,
0.0147363674,
0.0106076524,
-0.0183276329,
0.0485919751,
0.0118180271,
-0.0389504284,
0.0149207255,
-0.0134830186,
0.0359652191,
0.0305930264,
-0.000068517,
-0.034695942,
-0.022374209,
0.0362433828,
-0.0158679336,
-0.0250490569,
-0.0242610555,
0.0889875144,
-0.0419135801,
0.0032536879,
0.0019134743,
-0.0880091116,
0.0337325819,
-0.0069915922,
0.0068437709,
-0.0625878647,
-0.0405480415,
-0.0319232978,
-0.0577589609,
0.0113854744,
0.010507131,
-0.003572826,
-0.0027830864,
0.0563184731,
-0.0175953079,
-0.0323155038,
0.0295693167,
0.0222195517,
0.0166363493,
-0.0105507663,
-0.0539518632,
0.0536962338,
0.0786170214,
0.0109975636,
-0.0515808985,
-0.0508609712,
-0.0391813256,
0.0063010016,
-0.0032801863,
0.0264745168,
-0.0301265102,
0.0221275538,
0.0118584773,
-0.0440947153,
-0.0269249156,
0.01764719,
0.0243342184,
0.0382321067,
0.010114464,
-0.0029773931,
-0.0041749896,
0.0177339632,
0.0239818543,
-0.0013385584,
-0.0344627388,
-0.0216743033,
0.007439801,
0.0223588403,
-0.0011993393,
0.0136721348,
-0.0084085176,
0.0272631478,
0.0085818367,
-0.0161656868,
0.0521868989,
-0.0523760282,
-0.0563134924,
0.0136659807,
0.0241465643,
-0.0256240703,
-0.0079248222,
-0.0595820807,
-0.0306015015,
0.0605773777,
0.0323336646,
0.0304139648,
-0.0034999603,
-0.0360657945,
0.0302222315,
-0.0123923058,
-0.0028617948,
0.0719792023,
-0.0234005004,
-0.0435511619,
0.0043058791,
0.0314616263,
0.013537759,
-0.0371752456,
0.0180263165,
-0.0141603686,
-0.0060250489,
-0.0475830734,
0.0049153911,
-0.0300655253,
-0.0579868071,
0.0136986049,
-0.0609818734,
-0.0017019364,
-0.0173239,
0.0271491054,
-0.0026332361,
0.007030502,
0.0030962504,
-0.03596453,
0.0197233055,
-0.0062628491,
-0.0367562696,
0.0086680548,
0.0549933054,
0.0534781367,
-0.0035296644,
-0.026014775,
0.0156046785,
-0.0671934709,
0.0456128269,
0.0392720848,
-0.0486652292,
0.0015709763,
-0.019256359,
-0.0309926327,
0.0312799476,
-0.0383166037,
0.0040811836,
0.0358642787,
-0.0336634852,
0.0433968715,
0.0688565448,
-0.0107540153,
0.0720758438,
0.0287162848,
-0.0319767408,
-0.0456310995,
0.0582201183,
-0.0494041741,
0.0015852522,
-0.0234526787,
-0.003442029,
-0.058295507,
0.0690200627,
-0.0162511598,
0.0136334216,
-0.0700099096,
0.0093084928,
-0.0252252221,
0.0008840837,
-0.0469713174,
-0.0252165962,
-0.0245247465,
-0.0010681049,
-0.0506269597,
-0.0604140386,
0.0945119709,
0.0420312658,
-0.00022313,
0.0323164202,
-0.0242717862,
-0.0144777931,
0.0987765417,
-0.0148397079,
-0.0378383584,
0.0255211797,
-0.0196873844,
-0.051842805,
-0.031511642,
0.0462038182,
0.021001067,
0.0145483781,
-0.1180601418,
0.0132383956,
0.0290343836,
-0.015893342,
-0.0517409146,
-0.0511616431,
-0.0375180803,
0.0060255285,
-0.0931102186,
-0.029502932,
0.00844659,
0.0037543185,
-0.008965265,
0.0123699326,
-0.0395002775,
-0.0332188569,
-0.0018111471,
-0.0013182237,
0.0244745407,
0.0084217517,
-0.001087495,
-0.0449088886,
0.0403124206,
-0.0190346781,
0.101524815,
-0.0593706816,
-0.0744682178,
0.0529347882,
-0.0851087496,
-0.0050618295,
-0.0180149563,
0.0425297692,
0.0324350595,
-0.0570225343,
-0.0097849155,
0.0842241645,
0.0331891961,
-0.0221241321,
0.0010858995,
0.0033384783,
0.0020898539,
-0.0037641351,
0.0168864895,
-0.0705071017,
-0.0240016636,
-0.0083037624,
0.0009474171,
-0.0165697411,
-0.0479189716,
-0.005662669,
-0.0301353484,
0.0177389365,
0.0029777745,
-0.0155966179,
0.024601629,
-0.0270094834,
0.0008924928,
-0.0114963697,
-0.0317673199,
-0.0157692023,
0.0307340641,
0.0101893228,
0.0473563559,
-0.0408433303,
-0.0543451235,
0.0538944602,
0.025114974,
0.0371954106,
0.0435641892,
0.0399345085,
-0.0013171807,
-0.0267837625,
0.0443660393,
0.003452458,
0.0409473926,
-0.0106140608,
0.0732786283,
0.0064501292,
-0.0005097757,
-0.0260733142,
0.045761846,
0.01781708,
-0.0380227789,
-0.0041631591,
0.1247413456,
-0.0490589291,
-0.014093725,
-0.0198173542,
-0.0035412859,
0.0584996566,
0.0384999663,
-0.0016708317,
0.0151007054,
-0.0777316019,
-0.0058803237,
-0.0157435108,
-0.0365693346,
-0.004486775,
-0.0300202742,
0.0000566065,
-0.032906469,
-0.0492735095,
-0.0487870276,
-0.0256722812,
0.0091863014,
-0.0153460652,
-0.0097625265,
-0.0044182008,
0.0256355088,
-0.0498432219,
0.0503223129,
0.0401180014,
0.0220363811,
0.0196093861,
-0.0150251156,
-0.0153924422,
0.0028908972,
-0.0190460291,
0.0151122082,
-0.0722760558,
-0.0251970012,
-0.014505689,
0.0174340811,
0.0288473088,
0.1037717015,
-0.0182771198,
-0.0054521039,
0.0224682484,
0.0087133627,
-0.0085320575,
-0.0176916681,
0.068017818,
0.0177797452,
0.0034856731,
0.0305554606,
-0.0535744093,
0.0177075863,
-0.0142400507,
-0.0308897495,
-0.0381201431,
0.0508768633,
0.0100288419,
-0.0644972026,
0.0622522719,
0.0158099588,
-0.0095841307,
-0.0134169636,
0.0044326661,
-0.030528469,
0.0054427003,
-0.0290893279,
0.032527376,
0.0138462847,
-0.0022066438,
-0.0371854492,
-0.0253422409,
0.0141593702,
-0.0001671598,
-0.0272318665,
-0.0142200273,
0.062506862,
0.0264573656,
0.0241862349,
0.0153364437,
-0.0090240799,
-0.0103489459,
-0.006318707,
0.0390477367,
0.0211635288,
0.0378846526,
0.0463178754,
0.0287306271,
-0.0066480893,
-0.0624519102,
-0.1406464428,
-0.0269472357,
0.0269906279,
-0.00422276,
0.0404932126,
-0.0200559292,
0.0134143615,
-0.0323425643,
0.0283096619,
0.0271510631,
0.0618585944,
0.0203831345,
-0.0018350851,
0.0319840088,
0.019617267,
0.0091187609,
0.0189316534,
0.0514640138,
-0.0175250545,
0.0767006651,
0.0012105363,
-0.0111974925,
-0.0124047818,
-0.0132991085,
-0.0192130953,
0.0215941407,
0.0000599214,
0.0089271804,
-0.0578675307,
-0.0418052897,
0.0099742813,
0.0105054965,
-0.027474856,
-0.0168582182,
0.004222312,
0.0173093751,
-0.0045998245,
-0.0674986094,
-0.0105717927,
0.0219903383,
0.0171348955,
0.0010114778,
-0.0646181256,
-6.155981263e-33,
-0.0136870462,
-0.0374684222,
0.0408777818,
0.0128409043,
-0.0364514291,
0.0340412185,
-0.0831595883,
-0.039529305,
-0.0165355373,
0.0658927187,
-0.0013225948,
0.0771752447,
0.0125373164,
-0.0435352325,
0.0392471924,
-0.0484629609,
0.0265763626,
-0.0102391504,
0.0141779492,
0.0515888073,
0.0770391449,
0.0247266162,
0.0348434485,
-0.0555449165,
0.0394071154,
0.002086015,
-0.0392038003,
0.0529457778,
-0.0324528478,
0.0385190137,
-0.0043011406,
-0.0172552001,
0.0076887091,
0.0007989405,
-0.0095415013,
0.0057143224,
-0.0920653641,
-0.0792356953,
-0.0007111724,
-0.0214902833,
-0.0314629935,
-0.0126789706,
-0.0207195356,
0.0287830848,
0.0225766134,
-0.0334850997,
0.038370274,
-0.0106377518,
-0.0065171346,
-0.0445101187,
-0.0010627431,
0.0395320877,
-0.0510550886,
-0.0184147842,
0.0225060638,
0.0537940152,
0.0244138334,
-0.0404562466,
-0.0086483769,
0.0064785117,
0.000492885,
-0.0378512926,
0.0219607241,
0.0089284517,
-0.0154090188,
0.0416791849,
-0.0338512138,
0.0031504666,
-0.0467347056,
-0.0050193002,
-0.0246883966,
0.0619388819,
0.0142152254,
-0.0147262905,
0.0123272203,
0.0218239911,
-0.069281593,
0.0181330927,
0.0218868591,
0.0709430054,
-0.0058910823,
0.0091998214,
-0.0444858745,
-0.0017092697,
-0.0021797623,
0.041628506,
-0.0171183757,
-0.0098056896,
0.0238342062,
0.0238502957,
0.0333788171,
0.0181577168,
-0.0023821795,
-0.0311568994,
0.0395797901,
0.0118027311,
-0.0317355618,
-0.0142164361,
0.0213984717,
0.0042362167,
-0.0399370305,
-0.0020338793,
0.0309646819,
0.002637445,
0.0333743878,
-0.0020794482,
0.0088084135,
0.0469332896,
-0.001433317,
-0.0371346809,
-0.0371671095,
-0.0012821092,
0.0146003356,
-0.0535104647,
0.0459543839,
0.0297589153,
-0.0426089056,
0.0457814634,
-0.0007853349,
0.033766564,
0.0046229358,
0.035482984,
0.0013610654,
0.050185129,
-0.0071325861,
-0.0366731733,
-0.0017313184,
-0.0053463802,
0.0101915337,
-0.0291026309,
-0.0090444284,
0.0255499166,
2.66e-7,
-0.0041091824,
0.0116115436,
0.0560683347,
0.0392855927,
0.0393727086,
0.0291682445,
-0.0146216247,
-0.0060773175,
-0.0126486244,
0.0085905353,
0.0532809682,
0.0319317281,
0.0510465652,
0.028742373,
0.0078872871,
-0.044436913,
-0.0498487242,
-0.0663248897,
-0.0466178022,
-0.032023631,
0.0760353357,
0.0386052392,
0.0786978602,
0.0214352906,
0.0256791189,
-0.0395247787,
0.0859500319,
0.0008899205,
0.0005094367,
-0.0129410597,
0.0329003558,
-0.015417153,
-0.0196544081,
0.060286209,
-0.0438174382,
-0.0245402232,
-0.0833491385,
0.0328682885,
-0.050037507,
-0.0174187459,
-0.0476035587,
-0.0169857889,
0.0261767618,
-0.0281561278,
0.0728061348,
-0.0522057638,
-0.0078373943,
0.0274316706,
-0.0145955635,
0.0110623455,
-0.0111387353,
0.0518225692,
0.002692899,
0.0091800792,
-0.015345064,
0.018455442,
0.0115904883,
-0.0988893211,
-0.0295414459,
0.0795162022,
-0.013658504,
0.0052393544,
-0.0135504156,
-0.0297327656,
0.038094148,
-0.0348746926,
-0.0078882221,
2.046139395e-34,
0.0086941607,
0.0198805127,
-0.0449507944,
0.0511097014,
0.0374527313,
-0.0123422928,
-0.0008380207,
0.0062083094,
0.0877300277,
-0.0089734709,
-0.0150327785
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10466v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10466v1 | Controllable Text Generation with Language Constraints | 2022-12-20T17:39:21 | 2022-12-20T17:39:21 | Howard Chen, Huihan Li, Danqi Chen, Karthik Narasimhan | cs.CL | cs.CL | We consider the task of text generation in language models with constraints
specified in natural language. To this end, we first create a challenging
benchmark Cognac that provides as input to the model a topic with example text,
along with a constraint on text to be avoided. Unlike prior work, our benchmark
contains knowledge-intensive constraints sourced from databases like Wordnet
and Wikidata, which allows for straightforward evaluation while striking a
balance between broad attribute-level and narrow lexical-level controls. We
find that even state-of-the-art language models like GPT-3 fail often on this
task, and propose a solution to leverage a language model's own internal
knowledge to guide generation. Our method, called CognacGen, first queries the
language model to generate guidance terms for a specified topic or constraint,
and uses the guidance to modify the model's token generation probabilities. We
propose three forms of guidance (binary verifier, top-k tokens, textual
example), and employ prefix-tuning approaches to distill the guidance to tackle
diverse natural language constraints. Through extensive empirical evaluations,
we demonstrate that CognacGen can successfully generalize to unseen
instructions and outperform competitive baselines in generating constraint
conforming text. | [
0.0663088188,
0.0744392276,
0.0160257183,
0.0154401995,
-0.0424589328,
-0.0218382347,
0.0107089719,
0.0173363928,
0.0154883126,
-0.0544053577,
0.0248679183,
-0.0176253617,
-0.0213406943,
0.0710694343,
0.0678718835,
-0.0196043793,
0.0259144921,
-0.0233943127,
0.0160852056,
0.0056365309,
0.0204301048,
0.0295774303,
0.0107754525,
0.028579928,
-0.0570616387,
0.0194016211,
-0.0069219558,
0.0164487623,
-0.0065430468,
-0.0072421869,
0.0510205291,
0.0516480021,
-0.0189876221,
0.0227810089,
0.0000019947,
-0.0370618738,
-0.0533005148,
-0.0237510893,
0.0107305702,
0.0120423622,
0.031604629,
-0.0325857624,
-0.0107073886,
0.0119239558,
-0.0278598201,
0.0553136095,
0.0274076499,
0.040738076,
0.0775213242,
0.095319815,
-0.0190320686,
0.0233069155,
-0.0160302874,
-0.0277985577,
0.0316966139,
-0.0223773066,
-0.0025506392,
0.0001209315,
0.0205746442,
0.0138868149,
-0.0035130177,
0.0182367694,
0.0120985899,
-0.0207292102,
0.0177835692,
0.0250611082,
-0.0419981927,
-0.046392329,
-0.0291285235,
0.0468159094,
0.0033620808,
-0.0615555532,
0.0414517298,
-0.0335575119,
-0.0112964138,
0.0011110507,
-0.0176393725,
0.0576147959,
-0.0007789921,
0.0081684422,
0.0167150311,
0.0062524737,
0.025284335,
0.0097916853,
-0.0056492263,
0.0699568689,
0.0443809368,
-0.0307590291,
-0.0072592776,
0.0000297974,
-0.0280552022,
-0.09491615,
0.0075877365,
0.0184121411,
-0.0569840111,
0.0209728368,
-0.0997943208,
-0.0251058564,
0.0318561643,
-0.0112506133,
0.0146635845,
0.0419152603,
0.0334844142,
0.0146704875,
-0.030635003,
0.0736713409,
-0.0081469622,
0.0034353579,
-0.0218186546,
-0.003357419,
-0.0226690006,
-0.0292838831,
-0.0665071234,
0.0066231228,
-0.0373468585,
-0.0375527404,
-0.0247705318,
0.0153880464,
0.0253653787,
0.0387029164,
0.0148631269,
-0.0008845363,
-0.0544728637,
-0.0259109624,
0.0015424986,
-0.0422223397,
-0.0341833048,
-0.0313384607,
0.0355767906,
-0.0130418763,
-0.0172344651,
0.0400713198,
0.0025857845,
-0.0218925402,
0.0035992931,
0.0714361891,
-0.0130174858,
-0.0053302185,
-0.0041129803,
-0.0825128704,
-0.0376846381,
-0.0541636422,
-0.0099441567,
-0.0533883087,
-0.0105395811,
0.0014247396,
-0.0189577658,
-0.0693021938,
0.0332532562,
0.0209733043,
-0.0228036698,
0.0333546102,
-0.0200644545,
-0.0230511576,
-0.0033629648,
0.0186025314,
0.0197447557,
0.0599962249,
0.0530472882,
0.0663622841,
0.0259550009,
0.0465029217,
-0.0020072372,
0.0383507758,
0.0571695976,
0.0131249055,
-0.036854431,
0.009552517,
0.0304487608,
0.0405022241,
0.0148680219,
0.0782510638,
-0.0099624321,
0.0079942495,
0.0437472016,
0.0162124243,
-0.0073348917,
0.0162528269,
0.0939624757,
0.0111996699,
-0.0277691577,
0.0037069565,
-0.0406716876,
-0.0043321121,
-0.0055943327,
0.0270913709,
0.0364097878,
0.0145079447,
-0.0099423341,
-0.0485665575,
-0.009860375,
-0.0099497596,
0.0065656854,
-0.0449854396,
0.0266393889,
0.0525090434,
-0.0864079893,
0.0452605337,
0.0087026944,
-0.0800038278,
0.0159286186,
-0.029957477,
0.0150513519,
0.055717431,
0.0837367475,
-0.0057880315,
-0.0298439618,
0.0220974796,
0.0147166857,
0.0982997715,
0.0595553257,
-0.0014062837,
-0.0086510452,
-0.038416028,
-0.0240310133,
-0.0241580363,
0.018989278,
0.0220541973,
0.029714264,
0.0191405434,
0.0498533733,
-0.0189211816,
-0.0468851812,
0.0453673974,
-0.042140279,
-0.0330272429,
0.0092504984,
-0.0171542503,
-0.0065294933,
0.011607578,
-0.0090651633,
0.0461289696,
0.0059507838,
-0.0299866181,
-0.0330401622,
-0.0052397172,
-0.0421324857,
-0.0257864445,
0.025411699,
-0.0408322252,
0.0107528502,
-0.0273939967,
-0.0163687561,
-0.0718951598,
0.0439467169,
-0.0383187532,
0.0332522839,
-0.0314122774,
0.0093953945,
0.0373194776,
-0.0379721336,
-0.0069830338,
0.0599201247,
0.0109609719,
-0.0107500507,
0.0295385309,
-0.0062189642,
0.0079850061,
-0.0231324527,
0.0091511803,
-0.0243980158,
-0.0092193428,
0.0162256993,
0.0700549334,
0.0695799515,
-0.0181484371,
-0.049618654,
-0.0512328483,
0.0299755093,
-0.0272685811,
0.002472071,
0.0145162819,
0.0235148761,
-0.0065539633,
0.0101851951,
-0.057573393,
-0.0140734594,
0.0365114883,
-0.0120183481,
0.0322862118,
0.0338831767,
-0.0200680811,
-0.0469043516,
0.0010321602,
-0.0081953499,
0.0195506588,
0.0576045737,
0.0151182469,
-0.0376410894,
0.0310294852,
-0.0558890961,
0.0242303591,
0.0007500213,
-0.0030252112,
0.0056476961,
-0.0188036431,
0.0593238547,
-0.0103291087,
0.0086261332,
0.004870987,
0.0285480749,
-0.0119279204,
-0.0221101213,
0.0255150143,
-0.0230256412,
0.0059937388,
0.0147775095,
-0.0261379946,
0.0541571416,
0.0636330619,
0.0237438492,
-0.0195816625,
-0.0963190496,
0.0632999837,
-0.0065204152,
-0.0287194103,
-0.0279823318,
-0.013741198,
-0.0031119576,
0.0427195057,
-0.0253124572,
-0.0546577908,
0.0543689765,
-0.0627875999,
0.0173047744,
-0.0209402405,
0.0216253456,
-0.0333496369,
0.0417578518,
0.031010991,
0.0377646536,
0.0623917133,
0.0143932607,
-0.0414992198,
0.0114293322,
0.0365786105,
-0.0121244146,
0.0222492479,
-0.0673437342,
0.0289210659,
0.0027150507,
-0.0292308107,
-0.0569660999,
-0.0124071455,
0.0151259732,
0.0142738409,
0.0830955133,
-0.0359977148,
0.0184616987,
-0.0023027621,
0.0072791954,
0.0710048452,
-0.0149269989,
-0.0119498195,
-0.0422382206,
0.0049476041,
0.0686833337,
-0.0115825003,
-0.0070139468,
-0.030576814,
-0.0377365537,
0.0198123548,
0.032104332,
-0.0255955886,
0.0041028336,
0.0154906381,
0.0033045164,
-0.0475372113,
-0.014343421,
0.02565521,
0.0404447652,
-0.049215138,
-0.0514882877,
0.1117279306,
0.0430239178,
0.0000301641,
0.0201655179,
-0.0028937771,
0.0570544899,
0.0088432906,
0.0362787135,
-0.0805382654,
-0.0187877342,
0.0107955504,
0.0386071168,
-0.0064766882,
-0.0316011347,
-0.0538523719,
-0.083191596,
0.0126518356,
0.0249704123,
-0.0191995315,
-0.003814301,
-0.0015709007,
-0.0558367707,
-0.0088967457,
-0.002545547,
0.0182646085,
-0.0005945889,
0.0128366519,
-0.0021736322,
0.0043934477,
-0.0364271104,
-0.0100225629,
-0.0170356091,
0.0366392322,
0.0567188077,
0.0094075697,
0.0358622819,
0.0038513956,
0.0163314175,
0.0043493942,
0.0043151169,
-0.0370283648,
0.0079038097,
-0.005033893,
-0.0159580782,
0.004740532,
0.0541085601,
-0.0305486694,
-0.0106591117,
0.0095688123,
0.0408000723,
0.004672497,
-0.0246239882,
-0.0220434591,
-0.0172169805,
0.0604909956,
0.0806387514,
0.0431035608,
-0.040938098,
-0.0627925247,
-0.0538642704,
0.0092313634,
-0.0945653617,
-0.0346234553,
-0.0345321484,
0.0016446001,
0.0000372109,
-0.1088858247,
-0.0319611505,
0.0304442644,
0.0510811806,
0.0192542616,
-0.0129194818,
0.0116038593,
-0.0557539798,
-0.0469251275,
-0.0081558339,
-0.0488545261,
-0.009879156,
-0.0639344752,
-0.0447259955,
-0.0036222327,
-0.0427483208,
-0.0040062158,
0.074083969,
-0.0341042913,
-0.0889863148,
-0.0422077589,
0.0678123236,
0.0277888328,
0.0516347215,
-0.0250047278,
-0.0331224948,
0.0083426107,
0.0297685359,
-0.014541951,
0.0083916616,
0.0080612618,
-0.0126016708,
-0.0143663511,
0.0473093465,
-0.0589597076,
0.0228366852,
0.0014152412,
0.0680189654,
0.0139482375,
-0.0013027991,
0.0434974432,
0.0175026581,
-0.0285552777,
-0.0766740665,
0.0164957736,
-0.0302928295,
-0.0189322848,
-0.0645614639,
-0.0241128951,
-0.0478421897,
0.0420642383,
-0.0189013109,
-0.0277205035,
0.0019780379,
-0.0149673652,
-0.0574335232,
0.0352333486,
-0.0259697326,
-0.0329214185,
-0.0311815944,
0.0273059607,
0.0463520326,
-0.0570757054,
0.0027903123,
0.0392476134,
-0.0298909191,
0.0190019459,
-0.0335541256,
0.0179915074,
0.0447231643,
0.0031102274,
-0.0149846599,
0.0135478713,
-0.0108616482,
0.0203071535,
-0.0444437526,
0.0196167491,
0.0450934358,
-0.0012240893,
0.0776059702,
-0.0651616529,
-0.0208072308,
-0.0061560427,
0.0500818901,
0.0511906184,
-0.055328276,
-0.0013521592,
0.0185117889,
-0.0324531458,
-0.0114475265,
0.0824181363,
0.0851488113,
0.0297104008,
0.0087520201,
-0.0032080349,
-0.0770814791,
-0.0286298934,
0.0070153647,
-0.0258397684,
-0.0091138333,
0.0117898751,
-0.0688598603,
-0.0542029552,
0.0237838272,
0.0446079187,
0.0144533906,
0.0196859501,
0.0448597521,
0.0270879511,
-0.0143317292,
-0.0049460861,
-0.0326651819,
0.0077617764,
-0.006384402,
-0.0533331446,
-0.013409989,
-6.455504203e-33,
-0.0475744084,
-0.0576698855,
0.02909193,
-0.0088286921,
-0.0003526156,
0.0181580465,
-0.0755085051,
-0.0167453103,
0.0689781383,
-0.0033612193,
-0.0037173703,
-0.0098816017,
0.0023359337,
0.0423906185,
0.0015137004,
0.0252103638,
0.042529501,
-0.0126120588,
-0.071671769,
0.0693036541,
0.0579357408,
-0.0004561126,
0.0099981045,
-0.0208252016,
0.0329835005,
-0.0351423472,
-0.042737633,
-0.0014719474,
0.0112728635,
0.0443000458,
-0.0303158369,
0.0091842972,
0.006278106,
-0.0310601871,
-0.035981454,
0.004299968,
-0.0266280156,
-0.0385368504,
0.0069562681,
-0.0518134423,
-0.0297135562,
-0.072658509,
0.0376521572,
-0.0285021607,
-0.0286330171,
0.0389747173,
0.0139894243,
0.0023002904,
-0.0138356155,
-0.0676893741,
-0.0919300243,
0.0338403024,
-0.01060801,
-0.0229353569,
-0.0010501064,
0.0186024494,
0.0130777797,
-0.0190649517,
0.013144169,
0.046984043,
0.035884656,
0.0604104139,
0.064700298,
-0.0070831841,
-0.0134206954,
0.0384552926,
-0.0507328138,
-0.0011785305,
-0.0264613964,
0.0234637875,
0.0073966854,
0.0429719836,
0.0440993868,
0.0452079214,
0.0112827476,
-0.0305748936,
-0.0588111654,
0.0230265167,
-0.04325369,
-0.0100534419,
0.0144714741,
-0.0240028556,
-0.040796943,
-0.0128446789,
-0.0351367369,
-0.0079819225,
-0.0269154031,
-0.0095553277,
0.0552453846,
0.0592429712,
-0.0541238412,
-0.0054139649,
-0.0069301762,
0.0077922568,
-0.0013177129,
0.0419209041,
-0.0328307822,
-0.0225437954,
-0.0132342726,
0.0338363089,
-0.0658694282,
-0.033320114,
0.0534478091,
0.0087514725,
0.0220395364,
0.0296023376,
0.009398899,
0.0485192537,
-0.0515629128,
0.0252267197,
-0.0347860195,
0.0620427653,
-0.0190044232,
-0.0256538931,
0.0209384635,
-0.0068299617,
0.0059362934,
0.0150105264,
0.0238526575,
-0.0489574336,
-0.0039364304,
0.0067491396,
0.0266808663,
0.0360944495,
-0.0380490199,
0.0287534259,
-0.020359233,
0.0123842563,
0.0301188119,
-0.028329771,
-0.0130336257,
0.0146548701,
2.696e-7,
0.001428538,
0.0607456006,
0.0550037622,
0.0376733057,
0.0110774981,
0.0167836584,
0.0170083493,
0.049338758,
-0.0472855233,
-0.0497647822,
-0.0021243067,
0.0100069009,
0.0365626439,
0.0131037626,
-0.057403747,
0.0640792996,
-0.0352209546,
0.0105801541,
-0.0689804107,
-0.0345502757,
0.0623230301,
0.0427022725,
-0.0234529097,
0.0030585879,
-0.0182485692,
-0.0489938334,
0.0539293066,
-0.0005188641,
-0.0132880462,
0.0335185155,
0.0524365604,
0.0144967102,
-0.0282135122,
-0.0062817978,
-0.0362176746,
-0.0063006994,
0.009723397,
0.0845211595,
0.0198881514,
-0.0158221629,
0.0257091057,
-0.0247876942,
0.0060804803,
-0.0225203726,
0.0441608764,
-0.0108730439,
0.020853024,
-0.0138698723,
0.0193024725,
0.0072743557,
-0.0252749566,
-0.052610606,
-0.0443134867,
0.0222956892,
0.0015919983,
0.0333703235,
0.0170648936,
-0.0363121144,
-0.0233828258,
-0.0422739536,
-0.0315834284,
-0.0106262425,
-0.0754725486,
0.0293991715,
-0.0226041749,
-0.0510086231,
-0.0174125656,
2.919216242e-34,
0.0318135396,
-0.0374166444,
-0.0054819398,
-0.0212583896,
0.038028542,
0.0059626354,
-0.0309591256,
0.0304648224,
0.0189261679,
-0.053780999,
-0.0498830378
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10465v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10465v3 | SODA: Million-scale Dialogue Distillation with Social Commonsense Contextualization | 2022-12-20T17:38:47 | 2023-10-23T18:46:21 | Hyunwoo Kim, Jack Hessel, Liwei Jiang, Peter West, Ximing Lu, Youngjae Yu, Pei Zhou, Ronan Le Bras, Malihe Alikhani, Gunhee Kim, Maarten Sap, Yejin Choi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Data scarcity has been a long standing issue in the field of open-domain
social dialogue. To quench this thirst, we present SODA: the first publicly
available, million-scale high-quality social dialogue dataset. By
contextualizing social commonsense knowledge from a knowledge graph, we are
able to distill an exceptionally broad spectrum of social interactions from a
large language model. Human evaluation shows that conversations in SODA are
more consistent, specific, and (surprisingly) natural than those in prior
human-authored datasets.
Using SODA, we train COSMO: a generalizable conversation model that is
significantly more natural and consistent on unseen datasets than
best-performing conversation models (e.g., GODEL, BlenderBot-1, Koala, Vicuna).
Experiments reveal COSMO is sometimes even preferred to the original
human-written gold responses. Additionally, our results shed light on the
distinction between knowledge-enriched conversations and natural social
chitchats. We plan to make our data, model, and code public. | [
0.0705470517,
0.0664414167,
0.0091105662,
0.0390396379,
-0.000591298,
0.0017165714,
-0.0422398187,
-0.0031463534,
0.0266345479,
-0.014598852,
-0.0222690124,
0.0201559328,
0.0111529548,
0.05914196,
0.0091985483,
-0.0520006455,
0.0079251155,
-0.03097184,
0.0301101748,
-0.0016772937,
0.0379302055,
0.024575565,
0.0029490313,
0.0319515541,
-0.0152138239,
-0.0193065517,
-0.0133069316,
0.0021163893,
0.0156625472,
-0.0041356487,
0.0148569923,
0.0590132587,
0.0505351387,
0.0257169884,
0.0000019127,
-0.0192448758,
0.044681713,
-0.0394802727,
-0.0111123053,
0.0006081749,
0.0121642482,
-0.0243587829,
0.0268718861,
0.0096293874,
-0.0806270316,
0.0482903868,
0.0161154382,
0.0152966762,
0.0971785113,
0.0592760928,
-0.0142959682,
-0.0614334084,
-0.021510141,
-0.0423011445,
0.0357850119,
-0.0721184835,
0.0054225703,
0.0446269475,
0.0262137763,
0.0242864694,
-0.0130855385,
0.0290898904,
0.0288895816,
-0.0548882112,
0.0647941381,
0.0181140881,
-0.0491508953,
-0.0070049637,
-0.0228107609,
0.1646516025,
0.0448272265,
0.0018364367,
0.0238092542,
0.0142551791,
0.0415469706,
-0.0084561184,
-0.0487355366,
-0.0121361874,
0.0181769859,
0.036113739,
-0.0256265774,
-0.0015208627,
0.0008780846,
-0.0065068444,
0.0247761942,
0.021740552,
-0.0425632149,
0.0052174665,
-0.0092413891,
0.0021404189,
0.0005744449,
-0.0591426976,
0.0142586417,
0.0093560768,
-0.0379425399,
0.0027003845,
-0.0579728819,
0.0436709262,
0.0217002649,
-0.0320980586,
0.0089559322,
-0.0002252832,
0.0056138784,
0.0729534775,
0.051330734,
0.0018897161,
-0.0136566088,
0.0098783411,
-0.0053882892,
-0.0211262237,
-0.0616300516,
0.0088638533,
-0.0226255264,
0.0132653788,
-0.0928319767,
-0.0288192276,
0.0002939085,
0.0244630426,
-0.0124833109,
0.0203203671,
0.0250906534,
0.0644008219,
-0.0168035664,
-0.0104030874,
-0.019802304,
0.0179933421,
-0.0660624802,
0.0153200962,
0.0468441062,
-0.0467741266,
-0.0344933532,
-0.0062736864,
0.054956045,
-0.0065166643,
-0.0059858831,
0.0199338906,
-0.0210970044,
-0.0116235223,
0.0196506884,
-0.0465422124,
-0.0225690305,
-0.0516177155,
-0.0304705743,
-0.0473207943,
0.0732635558,
0.0003993099,
-0.012470115,
-0.0493647493,
0.0228232779,
-0.0013212245,
-0.038991157,
0.066726014,
-0.0268665869,
0.0113419583,
0.0025446676,
0.0382800438,
0.0014460228,
0.0548035838,
0.0128130987,
0.0185366552,
0.0360953212,
0.0021380296,
-0.0017992314,
0.0091031557,
0.032850191,
0.0254220143,
0.0374904089,
0.0238180421,
-0.0350213014,
0.0411441103,
0.0556805246,
0.0324828215,
-0.0498321466,
-0.0522301234,
0.0690745413,
0.0469182581,
-0.0845187381,
0.0509368367,
0.0023100546,
0.068750605,
0.0141340988,
-0.0160612166,
-0.0537243038,
0.0181150325,
-0.0322446153,
-0.0487345792,
0.042467799,
-0.0159106776,
-0.022709433,
-0.0192974396,
0.0511364825,
0.0006138618,
0.0543753542,
0.0139437094,
-0.0093806488,
0.0207104497,
-0.0457335562,
0.0514521487,
0.0261129532,
-0.0531139895,
-0.0441115014,
0.0028076617,
0.0412290655,
0.0582532138,
0.0380616412,
-0.018022934,
-0.0242763273,
-0.019893514,
0.0183020215,
0.0359608755,
0.030564623,
-0.0486571677,
0.0642360672,
-0.0342137069,
-0.0106229847,
-0.025802901,
0.0051293564,
0.0012919352,
0.0328952894,
0.0082773287,
-0.0072924863,
-0.0146881547,
-0.0078643719,
-0.0260929149,
-0.0155868959,
0.0000970034,
-0.0264111813,
-0.023626918,
0.0376653597,
0.0297676753,
-0.0023794118,
-0.024520237,
0.020538209,
-0.0320531875,
-0.0196764842,
0.0277787801,
-0.0464110784,
-0.0888108164,
0.0573970415,
-0.0411037691,
-0.0552958325,
0.0453234948,
-0.0519180223,
-0.0233244859,
0.0302119628,
-0.0252400581,
0.0685107633,
0.0026268456,
-0.0151684191,
0.0013852491,
0.0205893964,
0.021531634,
0.0300507378,
-0.0422684848,
-0.0607561991,
0.0168751255,
-0.0282523558,
-0.0258717556,
-0.0519251898,
0.0187727511,
0.0062210248,
0.0117977839,
0.02354916,
0.0068394416,
0.0129508087,
-0.0645180419,
-0.0151858851,
-0.1149415001,
-0.0214049798,
-0.0097379703,
-0.0168139916,
0.0142349936,
0.0118919583,
0.0212437231,
-0.0302195176,
-0.0635577738,
0.0450223573,
0.0066158203,
-0.0070773107,
0.0553403199,
0.0014105,
0.0208940823,
-0.0554858334,
-0.0039571864,
0.0412901267,
0.0445190482,
0.0179805625,
0.0174611099,
-0.0077583925,
0.0135456854,
-0.0613144264,
0.0294426456,
-0.0360838398,
-0.0342703834,
0.0085699763,
-0.0113251777,
-0.0010518098,
0.0483738594,
0.0290649645,
0.0254139099,
-0.0420930199,
-0.0146866925,
-0.064597398,
0.007049338,
0.0021041834,
0.0342507847,
-0.066227518,
-0.0197293516,
0.0125984615,
0.0336330719,
0.0017054261,
0.0411037356,
-0.0416935384,
0.0253652409,
0.0644296035,
-0.0390553437,
-0.0341502391,
0.002665411,
-0.0048161792,
0.0166517515,
-0.0496213101,
-0.0148451794,
0.0545271598,
-0.0110337967,
-0.0097326916,
0.0059280246,
-0.0171687733,
-0.0097709401,
0.0586421676,
-0.0334761441,
0.0036907995,
-0.0195172485,
0.0048520355,
-0.0152820107,
-0.035795819,
0.0433277413,
-0.0360551849,
0.0295977816,
-0.0371347517,
0.0248820335,
0.0311742406,
-0.0587433688,
-0.0310337264,
-0.0641652048,
-0.0695506781,
-0.0132449847,
0.0386173502,
-0.0408634841,
-0.0203363206,
-0.0121001815,
0.0023017137,
0.030994121,
0.0133964857,
-0.0038394472,
-0.0235101562,
0.0379288048,
0.0368301533,
0.0486645252,
0.0104441028,
0.006893727,
0.0358865894,
0.0773751736,
0.0495316014,
-0.01071971,
-0.0125420289,
0.0063721673,
-0.019823106,
0.0429376401,
-0.0115054678,
-0.0201682486,
0.0881358534,
-0.0189997312,
-0.0046166163,
0.0805679262,
0.0026566528,
-0.0110516697,
0.0015079936,
0.0086111566,
0.0152669121,
-0.0100784246,
-0.0026211462,
-0.0901732817,
-0.0686096027,
-0.0077820341,
0.0118243899,
0.0133750485,
-0.0996964723,
0.0043411432,
-0.091611892,
0.0056628422,
0.0008163183,
-0.0488138348,
-0.0619753227,
-0.0218647681,
-0.0037944182,
-0.0322735161,
-0.0147758294,
-0.0005446384,
0.0142590506,
0.0016481887,
-0.0170151591,
0.0153708719,
-0.0447496027,
0.056240011,
-0.0111940224,
0.0877591148,
0.0267946068,
0.0906327963,
0.0310262721,
-0.0118445391,
-0.00515089,
0.0098805595,
-0.0165236145,
-0.0087610567,
0.0770285577,
-0.0039372654,
-0.0111441296,
-0.0138037,
0.058942318,
-0.0737948716,
-0.0280850735,
0.0135052195,
0.0211105086,
-0.0158590283,
-0.020539429,
0.0044699875,
0.0332418308,
0.0634456798,
0.0763443559,
0.0615450144,
-0.0009248526,
-0.0364668518,
-0.0418366715,
-0.0329715982,
-0.0444504544,
-0.0072235726,
-0.0162770152,
0.0131097017,
0.0029638421,
-0.0798047185,
-0.0184361748,
0.0283304844,
0.0124738188,
-0.0382231697,
-0.0329937227,
0.0377357267,
0.0065527498,
-0.0158531871,
0.0516301692,
-0.0542779639,
-0.0131922858,
-0.0452813171,
-0.0313341133,
0.0077049378,
-0.0248415265,
-0.0284299143,
0.0651303232,
-0.0730465502,
-0.0469028242,
-0.0228835158,
0.0488924161,
0.0231808163,
0.0603747927,
-0.0287297182,
-0.0363531373,
0.0462193899,
0.0436548367,
-0.0366456695,
0.0281786546,
0.039962139,
0.0381422639,
0.0164647456,
0.0680518597,
-0.0123896226,
-0.0045264228,
-0.0272517558,
0.010946474,
-0.0617085882,
-0.0482746363,
-0.0349793062,
0.0059780008,
0.0008047757,
0.0244660284,
0.0146541735,
-0.029394865,
-0.0225232765,
-0.0144623509,
0.0020659082,
-0.0877714008,
0.0151662715,
0.0107866852,
-0.0396127924,
-0.0011904953,
0.00517174,
-0.0446502008,
0.0508192219,
-0.0607254468,
-0.0197428539,
0.0369281024,
-0.0080834292,
0.0464684814,
-0.0117000779,
0.0050028395,
0.0329243653,
-0.033637464,
0.0287540704,
-0.0091080535,
0.059004996,
0.0122284945,
-0.0425566547,
0.0362683646,
0.0448689684,
-0.0879500434,
-0.0515781604,
-0.0064784698,
0.0764217004,
0.0072511882,
0.0319861807,
0.0735722855,
-0.0272750426,
0.0014000731,
-0.01248453,
0.0752941072,
-0.0203148369,
-0.0325938314,
0.0178401209,
0.0124330241,
-0.0332842357,
0.0466872826,
0.0775653347,
-0.0428589955,
0.0068933591,
0.0148308966,
-0.0170861799,
-0.0272397697,
-0.0217791814,
0.0199377257,
0.071283944,
0.0201055408,
-0.0246759951,
-0.0497518331,
-0.0436505638,
-0.001316719,
-0.0011763609,
-0.0274646543,
-0.0050492734,
0.0303506814,
0.0402716249,
-0.0025636791,
-0.0098585365,
-0.028601937,
0.029804457,
-0.0572789349,
-0.0298087783,
-0.0137882475,
-6.209426216e-33,
0.0056390604,
-0.0277139153,
-0.0139584122,
0.0087012947,
-0.051495716,
-0.0046098088,
-0.0557232052,
-0.0106760357,
-0.012323196,
0.0284080245,
-0.0225842651,
0.0770675912,
-0.002994403,
0.0456844494,
0.0141218342,
-0.0499579236,
0.0380934067,
0.0001668643,
-0.0130167287,
0.0887184516,
0.0502405986,
0.0100243529,
0.0377365462,
-0.0749544725,
0.0107495449,
-0.0017595241,
-0.0021691655,
0.0233411919,
0.0540789887,
0.0119187459,
-0.0307998005,
0.0656711534,
-0.001379624,
-0.0204257108,
-0.0030703235,
0.0170049574,
-0.0691981688,
-0.0296478439,
0.0094584674,
-0.0392909274,
-0.0420743749,
0.0103953108,
0.0245331954,
-0.0194566026,
0.0319922864,
-0.0163008161,
0.0130270263,
-0.0116809215,
0.0025628756,
-0.0001833992,
-0.0270662345,
0.0132207219,
-0.0418145172,
-0.0678050593,
-0.0214963593,
0.0128193749,
0.017332932,
0.0030374504,
-0.0353582054,
0.0435533896,
-0.0212257765,
-0.0430668108,
0.0091390861,
-0.0045242594,
0.0445111617,
0.0578804538,
0.0207475182,
0.0386270136,
-0.0158144962,
0.0055889948,
-0.0169307645,
0.0779619068,
-0.0043552411,
0.0911787897,
0.0072399997,
-0.0206474625,
-0.0157256406,
0.0343780741,
0.0137361195,
-0.0029512763,
-0.0308427736,
-0.0015333185,
-0.0132818185,
-0.0113307051,
-0.0083098151,
-0.0353552736,
0.0137171596,
0.0153618883,
-0.0065893386,
0.0002049968,
-0.0494845584,
0.0144972466,
0.0122401714,
-0.0620497502,
-0.0111263106,
0.0752977654,
-0.0278874952,
-0.0017222119,
0.0102234203,
-0.0273751169,
-0.0416924879,
0.0082119964,
0.0383132771,
0.0225277226,
0.0283288117,
0.0312957503,
0.0030986022,
-0.0060681636,
-0.0065989057,
-0.0055836877,
-0.0246831775,
0.0481925979,
-0.036737591,
0.0017986165,
0.0139318304,
0.018881293,
-0.0327313505,
0.0311263371,
0.0036958947,
0.0381433405,
-0.0160730034,
-0.0111425556,
0.0079268562,
-0.0038717994,
-0.024457844,
-0.023291748,
-0.0418901816,
-0.0517572649,
0.0129680866,
-0.0280827954,
-0.0077243289,
-0.026349863,
2.519e-7,
-0.0295756888,
0.0114748608,
0.0355540402,
0.004728178,
0.0291588847,
0.0628007948,
0.0337120257,
0.0616509952,
-0.0109835193,
-0.0810631737,
0.0051443381,
0.0576085746,
0.0454748496,
0.0357369184,
-0.0746461526,
-0.0120613612,
-0.0786494538,
-0.0702583641,
-0.0190901719,
-0.0504358485,
0.0192664713,
0.0443815067,
0.0385886841,
-0.0316007435,
0.024195509,
-0.0366875939,
0.0470112301,
-0.0352770016,
-0.0043789665,
-0.0019959169,
0.0121025406,
-0.0063873027,
0.0021050684,
-0.0162150413,
-0.0026702161,
0.0052513783,
-0.0069861542,
0.0636829659,
-0.0055124462,
-0.0324652791,
-0.0253229588,
-0.0286952332,
0.009687636,
-0.0379777662,
0.0406439006,
-0.0557120591,
-0.0167351123,
-0.0051465211,
-0.0031241647,
-0.029002564,
0.014346608,
-0.0024664381,
0.0110013206,
0.0298034474,
-0.0065861549,
-0.0126645816,
0.0103550069,
-0.0602855012,
-0.0045066257,
-0.0180241279,
-0.0610864237,
-0.0622719787,
-0.0093277255,
-0.0446312167,
-0.0108362921,
-0.0045855707,
0.0316370912,
1.861926802e-34,
0.0266137291,
0.0172857307,
0.001848125,
-0.0043041278,
0.047915563,
-0.0086621819,
-0.0331609361,
-0.0216207858,
0.048139926,
-0.0559858307,
0.0188893117
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10461v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10461v1 | Go-tuning: Improving Zero-shot Learning Abilities of Smaller Language Models | 2022-12-20T17:36:49 | 2022-12-20T17:36:49 | Jingjing Xu, Qingxiu Dong, Hongyi Liu, Lei Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | With increasing scale, large language models demonstrate both quantitative
improvement and new qualitative capabilities, especially as zero-shot learners,
like GPT-3. However, these results rely heavily on delicate prompt design and
large computation. In this work, we explore whether the strong zero-shot
ability could be achieved at a smaller model scale without any external
supervised data. To achieve this goal, we revisit masked language modeling and
present a geometry-guided self-supervised learning method (Go-tuningfor short)
by taking a small number of task-aware self-supervised data to update language
models further. Experiments show that Go-tuning can enable T5-small (80M)
competitive zero-shot results compared with large language models, such as
T5-XL (3B). We also apply Go-tuning on multi-task settings and develop a
multi-task model, mgo-T5 (250M). It can reach the average performance of OPT
(175B) on 9 datasets. | [
-0.0221722852,
0.0222812854,
-0.0115575502,
0.067609407,
-0.023614997,
0.0032479954,
0.0606533512,
-0.0035648665,
-0.009050699,
-0.050856173,
-0.0948162824,
-0.0133875795,
-0.0209646858,
0.0286315531,
0.020196015,
-0.0449882783,
0.0253193155,
-0.0316458903,
-0.0281261038,
0.0009074008,
-0.0387273356,
0.0198782869,
-0.0189616214,
0.0281509943,
0.0288725253,
-0.0461754315,
-0.0351878218,
0.0198251978,
-0.0075584375,
-0.0382556543,
0.0141025707,
0.097637184,
0.0129042789,
0.1057567,
0.000002295,
-0.0288186036,
-0.0080728326,
0.0029795791,
-0.0539722964,
0.031172039,
0.0503606871,
-0.0406423993,
-0.0235502608,
-0.0140625425,
-0.0143502904,
-0.0434183516,
0.0432676561,
0.0060598981,
0.0353082791,
0.0787701085,
-0.0070752907,
-0.0364014916,
-0.0185201541,
-0.0468605459,
0.0233555436,
-0.0430242792,
0.0097163357,
-0.0243378635,
0.0043177297,
0.0426019691,
-0.0274280924,
0.0145927593,
0.0032480794,
0.0217039865,
0.0036607618,
0.0501538515,
-0.0399246067,
-0.0017968705,
0.0018866549,
0.0397309102,
-0.0576065294,
-0.0460478738,
-0.0009895682,
-0.0448099487,
-0.0237500612,
-0.0005543777,
-0.0547383875,
-0.0210810117,
0.0356220193,
0.0133903185,
-0.0139271738,
-0.0126751056,
0.0246157553,
-0.0207105558,
-0.0512305796,
0.0300407279,
-0.0072559831,
-0.0065979934,
-0.0341133475,
0.0026644317,
-0.0362093933,
-0.0207936317,
-0.0468287766,
0.0220980421,
0.0120814191,
-0.0070486218,
-0.0338251255,
-0.0598775186,
0.0146044213,
-0.0323538929,
0.082192108,
0.0406256318,
-0.0108911339,
0.0373685472,
-0.0353142582,
0.0217683893,
-0.0031168314,
0.0312690474,
-0.0463989787,
-0.0030354601,
-0.0616638549,
0.0020733697,
-0.0507026315,
0.0293672569,
-0.0208762139,
0.0052264254,
-0.0116050206,
0.0255245995,
0.0130691072,
-0.0131774815,
0.023014104,
-0.044351317,
-0.0635755137,
-0.06022989,
0.0284973774,
0.0087610213,
-0.0114998752,
-0.0010471678,
-0.0251260679,
-0.0509402193,
-0.0376411751,
-0.0196934361,
0.0324216187,
-0.0296969842,
0.0163683482,
0.0485000461,
0.0051293229,
-0.0749650672,
-0.0277797785,
0.0148019549,
-0.0328662805,
-0.0771207288,
-0.0021373176,
-0.0438091271,
-0.0105016576,
-0.0130212093,
0.0061112801,
-0.0366073288,
-0.0096290912,
0.0222047567,
-0.0141479308,
0.0830215439,
0.0148549648,
-0.0279204361,
0.0012085709,
0.0008767914,
-0.0011015574,
0.1052535921,
0.0168898031,
0.0137681076,
0.0095808348,
-0.0106189661,
0.0026055013,
0.0276049916,
0.0622721091,
0.0505433157,
0.0082965549,
-0.0097654453,
0.037599586,
0.0229956191,
0.042556785,
0.0159532186,
-0.0402565449,
-0.0420532934,
0.0611878671,
0.0474665947,
0.049262289,
0.0126224831,
0.0292692352,
0.0200848803,
-0.0153625198,
-0.0070257331,
-0.0274627265,
0.0045845713,
-0.0339983441,
0.0204026382,
0.0007647117,
0.0263671055,
-0.0681383833,
-0.0184753332,
-0.0290112365,
-0.0060612801,
-0.0096608875,
0.0283163711,
0.0893404856,
0.0055637402,
-0.0360169187,
-0.0207372326,
0.0288297702,
-0.0370739102,
-0.0258153416,
-0.0638107657,
0.0380255207,
-0.0056533427,
0.0221595149,
-0.029748166,
-0.0436144657,
-0.0177079197,
0.0336922891,
0.0637045279,
0.0164622739,
0.0137368785,
0.0383546762,
-0.0384271368,
-0.0024797469,
-0.034930177,
0.0195222609,
0.0140720801,
-0.0085856039,
0.0178702604,
0.01211181,
-0.017032057,
0.0275417045,
0.0261652023,
-0.0430985019,
-0.0716164634,
0.0411343053,
-0.0033729705,
0.0017938748,
-0.0059969574,
-0.0052433894,
-0.0160933416,
0.0393923,
-0.0141720343,
0.0262040794,
-0.0262075681,
-0.0465042256,
-0.046649754,
0.029942086,
0.0146258408,
0.0077911261,
0.0240118522,
-0.0320076905,
-0.0410291664,
0.0327196084,
0.025767168,
0.0061901738,
-0.0325116366,
0.0104918033,
-0.0172953755,
0.0455527529,
-0.0341052897,
0.037901029,
0.0280227438,
-0.002186615,
0.0011702736,
0.0101887509,
0.0170516297,
-0.0458653904,
-0.0396582112,
0.0174957756,
0.0217529479,
0.0073180594,
-0.0127887577,
0.0267686751,
-0.0187108517,
-0.0340083614,
-0.0994475409,
0.0136890998,
-0.0274229925,
0.0125606926,
0.0462952964,
0.0042885235,
-0.0201691408,
-0.0381974615,
0.0213242527,
-0.0034318382,
-0.0206148587,
0.0213593505,
0.0000049129,
0.0074729989,
0.0126921339,
-0.0140277743,
-0.0372059681,
-0.0022210227,
0.0400017463,
-0.0109897908,
-0.0126509629,
-0.021642698,
0.0235428251,
-0.0273616966,
0.045335982,
0.0131737338,
-0.0131459832,
-0.0016591824,
-0.0430637039,
0.0105031235,
0.072698988,
-0.0328395888,
0.0142746577,
0.0598938353,
-0.0108841611,
-0.0277795922,
0.0106645301,
-0.0376159698,
-0.0378551632,
0.0057580303,
0.0193376243,
-0.0220268127,
0.0892193988,
-0.0019771829,
-0.0327115618,
-0.0795139,
0.0477470644,
-0.0180929974,
-0.0082904287,
-0.0337992497,
0.0625079796,
-0.0177957583,
0.0086458819,
-0.0124164065,
-0.0398555398,
0.0375029184,
-0.0065798918,
-0.0335686579,
-0.0396802463,
-0.0036553033,
-0.0479648523,
0.0607595704,
0.0183758773,
0.013661067,
0.0594035424,
-0.0133723356,
-0.0339533091,
-0.0062818234,
0.0362413637,
0.0018032365,
0.0261253286,
-0.0548727289,
0.0391850993,
-0.0195176937,
-0.0690861344,
-0.0199018326,
-0.0256119259,
-0.0292013045,
0.0033418934,
-0.0330005027,
-0.0376179889,
-0.0061971196,
0.009043782,
0.0203951932,
0.1051007584,
-0.0138125848,
-0.0189787354,
-0.024047453,
0.0147037972,
0.0342679955,
0.0082664238,
-0.0200733226,
-0.028238805,
0.0329763852,
0.0200726148,
0.0747270137,
-0.0130349537,
-0.0339486934,
0.0231340639,
0.027601501,
-0.0182288587,
-0.0233729184,
0.0063966205,
0.0331671052,
-0.0505353548,
-0.0388639383,
0.113827765,
0.0120610865,
-0.0256250743,
-0.0095035415,
-0.0457513109,
0.0418499112,
0.0139342425,
0.0280477479,
-0.0803772509,
-0.0299809594,
0.0023387563,
0.0102431467,
0.0080967145,
-0.0249929801,
-0.0105703864,
-0.1425250471,
0.0542360432,
0.0388727933,
-0.0446883366,
0.0311297998,
-0.0384999774,
-0.0079522021,
-0.0434179679,
0.0086387182,
-0.0082416171,
-0.0240061115,
-0.0118122166,
0.0234646685,
0.0191636756,
-0.0694514215,
0.0603775643,
0.0009839617,
0.0483532026,
0.0039320705,
0.0030136837,
0.0040592705,
-0.0230506007,
0.0440390855,
-0.0075928536,
-0.0047322521,
-0.0294468552,
0.0721317977,
-0.0212893728,
-0.0032684973,
0.037551187,
0.0331541374,
-0.0146352164,
-0.0122435912,
-0.0103165982,
0.0787944198,
0.0093093961,
-0.0161336344,
0.0055578901,
-0.0404826775,
-0.0124409599,
0.0631792024,
0.0162477307,
-0.0282226205,
-0.022554772,
-0.0215952545,
-0.0043298155,
-0.0646532848,
-0.0589378104,
0.0152630936,
0.0112098772,
-0.062046241,
-0.0127928611,
-0.0220485702,
0.0613416396,
0.0561438315,
0.0031970579,
0.0216642339,
-0.026701007,
-0.0034929505,
-0.0307375919,
0.0015654877,
-0.0678671971,
0.0142933363,
-0.0901243612,
-0.0084786592,
0.0513305813,
-0.0163755529,
0.0001517992,
-0.0007638787,
-0.0896066651,
-0.0696007833,
-0.0017546583,
0.0588139482,
0.0213443618,
0.0649927184,
-0.0088815112,
-0.0622080453,
0.0753970221,
0.0385891199,
-0.032628037,
0.0250569955,
0.0599255785,
-0.0291584935,
0.0080392938,
0.0417671055,
-0.0025689187,
0.0224084482,
0.0305123907,
-0.0094099399,
-0.0288116597,
0.0242680591,
0.0307274312,
-0.003565636,
0.0943236575,
-0.0052669928,
0.0381360874,
-0.0297537018,
-0.0023553164,
-0.0563733727,
0.0307978,
-0.0350334756,
0.0037026862,
0.0259812959,
-0.0343011804,
-0.0015849251,
0.0243292041,
-0.0330463946,
0.0259457901,
-0.0562429465,
-0.0077840802,
-0.0161285903,
0.0221352447,
0.0255239494,
0.0310161337,
-0.0156427436,
-0.0055793524,
0.0327338725,
0.0292227436,
-0.0009377658,
0.0415115058,
0.0368951932,
0.0119698253,
-0.0610858165,
0.0523059852,
-0.0831879377,
-0.0167083144,
-0.0547804385,
-0.0059830481,
0.0602920614,
0.0096840663,
0.0319491923,
-0.0045887874,
-0.041293595,
-0.0381085835,
0.0352399722,
-0.0091465777,
-0.0129256388,
0.0120556094,
0.0182329807,
0.0048152488,
0.0254556779,
0.0977944732,
0.0618906207,
0.0372321308,
0.0443082526,
0.051246997,
-0.045885276,
0.0074805692,
-0.0178515296,
0.0563958213,
-0.0067769103,
0.0096966848,
-0.0519556589,
-0.0782130361,
0.0168944299,
-0.0192846078,
-0.0008539252,
-0.0206576679,
0.0403536446,
0.0013452651,
-0.0342737846,
-0.0165479537,
-0.0444729254,
0.0296440143,
0.0250928346,
-0.0062775314,
0.0118904905,
-6.60675947e-33,
-0.0353254005,
0.00448032,
0.0344401114,
0.0284810718,
0.0319319554,
-0.0073770336,
-0.0222825613,
0.0154868541,
-0.033110179,
0.0045317532,
-0.0418571122,
-0.0091600902,
0.0190327782,
0.0198429246,
0.0014834211,
0.0118653039,
0.0745904446,
-0.0340150781,
-0.0243554488,
0.0223700423,
0.0124961901,
0.033568427,
0.0727289096,
-0.021093864,
-0.0131385503,
-0.004515823,
-0.0120412419,
-0.0059551671,
-0.0023625884,
0.0478383638,
-0.0186496433,
0.026595179,
0.0015867351,
-0.0299550314,
-0.0535971001,
-0.0291461553,
-0.0674130023,
-0.0400675088,
-0.0440908559,
0.0008070264,
-0.0317831524,
-0.0267175324,
-0.0058656023,
0.0167526789,
-0.0366694666,
-0.0355760679,
0.0063986643,
-0.0156393684,
-0.0609600879,
0.0340378806,
-0.0314615369,
0.0327978246,
-0.0030918356,
-0.035157539,
0.0959070474,
0.0218609665,
-0.0010118644,
0.0317292809,
-0.0583599918,
0.0040787207,
0.0020826634,
0.0374354422,
0.0517162718,
0.0681829751,
0.0158884041,
0.0419865176,
0.0365159661,
0.0069135483,
-0.0251809247,
0.0080941962,
0.089383319,
0.0148231862,
0.0327924155,
0.0228268187,
0.0329296887,
0.0026018387,
-0.0750140473,
0.0042016436,
-0.0022650631,
0.0167589858,
0.0215766579,
0.0411037281,
-0.0405268595,
-0.0235774107,
-0.0187270287,
-0.0629082173,
-0.0529499911,
-0.0019046407,
0.0371090062,
0.0169317387,
-0.0267069507,
0.0138977971,
0.0501783974,
-0.0444245636,
0.0007786663,
0.0131804934,
-0.0354976878,
0.0403948575,
0.0091103865,
0.0315251164,
-0.0632422864,
-0.0136040458,
-0.0098402034,
0.0678501874,
0.0169676188,
-0.0034538764,
0.0455014147,
0.0521474257,
-0.0733362511,
-0.0102061825,
-0.0369974114,
-0.0027574045,
0.0265231561,
0.0368615724,
0.0181775969,
-0.0013897436,
0.0086711319,
0.087444894,
0.0321267396,
-0.0445049666,
0.0161477961,
0.0295882393,
-0.0028643506,
0.0055192928,
0.015471112,
-0.0029421316,
-0.0275399983,
0.015546591,
0.0982855186,
-0.0276564769,
-0.024928594,
0.0230891798,
2.805e-7,
0.0178393554,
0.0572943315,
-0.0084882407,
0.0082898475,
0.003532727,
0.074332051,
-0.0142353801,
0.025647223,
0.0116132936,
0.0203647632,
0.0107355369,
0.0321854018,
0.049499318,
0.006573705,
-0.0875970721,
0.0407133922,
-0.0240191165,
0.0517968275,
-0.0538057387,
0.0055995774,
-0.0025065807,
0.1020577252,
0.0465527773,
0.0104387496,
0.0301334821,
-0.0247873608,
0.0628759563,
-0.0108185317,
-0.0039927205,
0.0224992987,
0.0036928842,
0.0480279066,
-0.0367753543,
0.0079903277,
-0.0223033577,
0.0247859433,
-0.0069615077,
0.0726066604,
-0.0157115944,
0.0069051124,
0.0232943669,
0.0021988868,
-0.0312245116,
-0.045729693,
0.0899415389,
-0.0706971586,
-0.0304876044,
-0.0046980092,
-0.0060942355,
-0.0062522045,
0.0447567627,
-0.0543382019,
-0.0599663891,
0.02278677,
0.0414394364,
-0.0169449206,
-0.0317159221,
-0.0530015081,
-0.0145348012,
0.0110867107,
-0.0333877057,
0.0123361498,
-0.0361730531,
-0.0271041207,
0.024957763,
-0.0640603453,
0.0083822589,
2.618531675e-34,
0.0164732486,
-0.0326345302,
0.0155635551,
0.0085127726,
-0.0203526262,
-0.0150924111,
-0.0018892408,
-0.0049290145,
0.0281168707,
-0.0763728917,
-0.0343762226
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10455v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10455v2 | MULTI3NLU++: A Multilingual, Multi-Intent, Multi-Domain Dataset for Natural Language Understanding in Task-Oriented Dialogue | 2022-12-20T17:34:25 | 2023-06-19T04:09:37 | Nikita Moghe, Evgeniia Razumovskaia, Liane Guillou, Ivan Vulić, Anna Korhonen, Alexandra Birch | cs.CL | cs.CL | Task-oriented dialogue (TOD) systems have been widely deployed in many
industries as they deliver more efficient customer support. These systems are
typically constructed for a single domain or language and do not generalise
well beyond this. To support work on Natural Language Understanding (NLU) in
TOD across multiple languages and domains simultaneously, we constructed
MULTI3NLU++, a multilingual, multi-intent, multi-domain dataset. MULTI3NLU++
extends the English only NLU++ dataset to include manual translations into a
range of high, medium, and low resource languages (Spanish, Marathi, Turkish
and Amharic), in two domains (BANKING and HOTELS). Because of its multi-intent
property, MULTI3NLU++ represents complex and natural user goals, and therefore
allows us to measure the realistic performance of TOD systems in a varied set
of the world's languages. We use MULTI3NLU++ to benchmark state-of-the-art
multilingual models for the NLU tasks of intent detection and slot labelling
for TOD systems in the multilingual setting. The results demonstrate the
challenging nature of the dataset, particularly in the low-resource language
setting, offering ample room for future experimentation in multi-domain
multilingual TOD setups. | [
0.0767962337,
-0.012510702,
-0.0173430201,
0.0780327246,
-0.0136300502,
0.026713958,
0.0379596874,
-0.0355667286,
0.0087111453,
-0.0267981477,
-0.069383122,
-0.0549982525,
0.001729339,
0.0207863189,
0.0055024615,
-0.0337248109,
0.0396567136,
-0.040433649,
0.019587921,
0.0344429687,
0.0141739482,
0.0428048633,
-0.040859323,
0.0529273525,
0.0041462504,
-0.0318552516,
-0.0198874585,
0.0070732953,
-0.0004576008,
-0.0289677083,
0.0155523233,
0.0450150929,
0.02619165,
0.0269180574,
0.0000021067,
-0.0713926554,
-0.0120312003,
-0.0335423052,
-0.0765594542,
-0.0364303626,
0.0162565559,
-0.0115211336,
0.0181081519,
0.0024092169,
-0.0374108143,
0.0134467594,
0.0146097783,
0.0671523139,
0.0394650437,
0.0575176589,
-0.0106413243,
-0.0023665994,
-0.0406774431,
-0.0278366562,
0.0133910915,
-0.0803512409,
0.0027770614,
0.0405393541,
0.0018385622,
-0.0056660636,
0.0175109059,
0.0227138344,
0.0108408509,
-0.0157456156,
-0.0583889261,
-0.0041248421,
0.0097020781,
-0.0473477654,
-0.0354108661,
0.0807863995,
-0.0018698927,
0.0304485224,
-0.0173507985,
-0.0046727844,
-0.0213321317,
-0.0563163757,
-0.0280958675,
-0.007962646,
-0.0473540835,
-0.0397800282,
0.0188633464,
0.0366927087,
0.0051759952,
0.004836069,
-0.0049973596,
0.0618582666,
-0.0012288651,
-0.0105430931,
0.0168126561,
0.0016507825,
-0.003837717,
-0.0450082049,
0.038213335,
0.0072596399,
-0.0758812577,
0.0402322561,
-0.0185605492,
-0.0320940316,
0.0160605814,
-0.0485978499,
0.0161360167,
0.0611856952,
-0.0370393507,
0.0473755524,
0.0251621492,
0.0478223488,
-0.0225332472,
-0.0082396045,
-0.0537999421,
-0.025878096,
-0.0472904369,
0.0083596772,
-0.0294233244,
0.0133532519,
-0.0643198788,
0.0118890088,
-0.0280244425,
0.055636216,
-0.0038769825,
0.0123782046,
0.0289614853,
-0.0167670604,
-0.0430348217,
-0.0134570412,
-0.0345364735,
0.0566189662,
-0.0493189469,
0.0323846489,
-0.01041706,
-0.0474002846,
-0.0025762171,
0.0381621905,
-0.0078315428,
-0.0420837626,
-0.028869234,
0.0601321496,
-0.0182672348,
-0.0368194357,
-0.0293639898,
-0.0140514635,
-0.0370625071,
-0.0912198126,
-0.0360199362,
-0.0409529507,
0.0636284947,
0.0173953976,
-0.0152034042,
-0.0345341042,
0.0115249921,
0.0060114618,
-0.0022825098,
0.083662957,
-0.0226805806,
-0.005940435,
0.0213274267,
0.0132355066,
-0.0129115675,
0.0670352131,
-0.009779335,
0.0350870825,
0.0618372299,
0.0217537005,
-0.0334926285,
0.0276623517,
-0.0126948003,
-0.0091016581,
0.0958252326,
0.0579063222,
0.0007971631,
0.0345651247,
0.0338099599,
0.022716362,
-0.0205918532,
0.0136418892,
0.0223925728,
0.0248195902,
-0.004036718,
-0.0088001331,
0.0502125882,
0.0535633788,
-0.0196835622,
0.0103728808,
-0.012113017,
0.0087989112,
0.0013923987,
-0.0021615212,
0.0179140214,
0.0187339522,
-0.0387571305,
-0.0547420308,
-0.0129193068,
-0.0115353595,
-0.0003542203,
-0.0082618734,
0.0727950409,
0.0090737082,
-0.0538744181,
0.0613327809,
-0.0189432409,
-0.0341945775,
-0.0069452515,
-0.0286029298,
0.0108745201,
0.0656085536,
0.0113379564,
-0.0460094586,
-0.0611511394,
-0.0423643291,
0.0235756263,
0.0369426683,
0.0551541708,
-0.0262083039,
0.0460060723,
-0.0553133674,
-0.0344505794,
-0.0020953689,
-0.0187983997,
0.0417449735,
-0.034772139,
-0.0017432362,
0.0056758262,
-0.0324032642,
-0.0014292368,
0.0096599367,
-0.0036585229,
0.0142248916,
-0.0027596541,
0.0271578655,
0.0408133045,
0.0657251626,
0.003551482,
-0.047029905,
0.0177357234,
-0.0274077915,
0.0118343206,
0.0370418467,
-0.0314778686,
-0.0357642099,
0.0297908988,
0.007282149,
-0.0595866404,
0.0261664651,
-0.0328497067,
-0.0632153153,
-0.0104185753,
-0.0096076867,
-0.026371818,
-0.056825567,
-0.0037680208,
0.0212108176,
0.0172544867,
-0.0069522541,
0.0476296768,
-0.0000504261,
0.0165193379,
0.0620900318,
-0.0257539582,
0.067174539,
-0.0178047996,
-0.007150854,
0.0240573846,
-0.0438936055,
-0.0113526713,
0.0287179891,
0.0527970083,
-0.0266053993,
0.0139080454,
-0.1034515202,
0.0070963129,
-0.0472840108,
0.0389804505,
0.0107031157,
0.0361212716,
-0.0107905744,
-0.0206419863,
-0.0085135894,
-0.0144027835,
0.0216081291,
-0.0096906237,
0.0430168547,
0.0085879331,
-0.0161088128,
-0.0201255735,
0.038428627,
-0.0026265308,
-0.0000737608,
-0.0091290986,
-0.0711714625,
-0.0609492138,
-0.0011140709,
-0.0184718203,
0.0022510914,
-0.0041741026,
-0.0228812862,
0.0149926124,
0.0522536673,
0.0484961458,
0.0164183378,
-0.0286346991,
0.0289828647,
0.0013690827,
-0.0136729712,
-0.0366492756,
0.0361873992,
0.0003609821,
-0.0070463321,
-0.0443388931,
-0.0448843576,
0.0251113996,
0.0544135422,
0.014431674,
0.0265614744,
-0.0481352918,
-0.0410576276,
-0.0361228175,
-0.0494130328,
-0.0374643467,
0.0381845422,
-0.0201831013,
0.06690301,
-0.0040661232,
-0.016837094,
0.0557546094,
-0.0192340035,
-0.042287536,
-0.068482019,
0.0063005541,
-0.0494127013,
0.0712909922,
-0.0637452677,
0.0382447429,
0.048266843,
-0.0578267686,
-0.0114102094,
0.0252915472,
-0.0083683897,
0.0009968739,
0.0579921491,
-0.0504314341,
0.0069423108,
-0.0307103768,
-0.0492229462,
-0.0249998514,
-0.0291028153,
-0.0346745886,
-0.0024264832,
0.0147704007,
-0.0105226776,
-0.0214823969,
0.0175529476,
0.0132924626,
0.0502290688,
0.0022534241,
-0.0101049403,
-0.0168614518,
0.009957891,
0.0328672752,
0.0427504741,
-0.00479424,
0.0105084134,
0.0364901759,
0.0172290001,
-0.0049271239,
-0.0501109585,
0.0212317966,
0.0072794151,
0.0494594276,
-0.0044457628,
-0.0161398184,
-0.0029902388,
0.065114446,
-0.0154827535,
-0.0031043903,
0.1047522649,
0.0210028999,
-0.0321132615,
-0.015971642,
-0.0729797184,
-0.0096480539,
0.0335715041,
0.0206008181,
-0.1120058671,
-0.0763037503,
-0.0082764234,
-0.0140335374,
0.0239058584,
-0.0171481762,
-0.0263431743,
-0.0800678134,
0.0306149945,
-0.0539535545,
-0.025048377,
-0.0170191731,
-0.0048526223,
-0.007813096,
-0.0014836616,
0.0299877319,
-0.0238198582,
0.0245703459,
-0.0482878424,
0.0363748521,
-0.0084294034,
-0.0398712754,
0.0381090902,
-0.0229603276,
0.0299681034,
0.0207902174,
0.0586226135,
0.032493338,
-0.0050053499,
0.0029398478,
0.0361144431,
0.0047143865,
-0.0120674213,
-0.001877737,
0.0016481336,
-0.0135963047,
-0.0094166212,
0.0149031226,
-0.0896237567,
0.0022453149,
0.0258235689,
0.0378239974,
-0.0424032249,
0.0404254831,
0.0133086201,
0.0168818217,
0.0498784818,
0.0918911397,
0.0035335589,
-0.0542846285,
0.0073490692,
-0.0301254075,
-0.0295613036,
-0.0499879122,
0.0200444739,
0.0126273111,
-0.0335065611,
-0.0152109861,
-0.0317570157,
-0.0728171393,
0.0397525392,
0.0327193402,
0.0292081814,
0.025662208,
-0.0000439192,
0.0203115381,
0.0050110724,
-0.0066073318,
-0.0318574458,
0.0561328642,
-0.0565268174,
0.0022931017,
-0.0046329815,
-0.033035025,
-0.0181419048,
0.0367585309,
-0.08919058,
-0.0291179512,
-0.0296074841,
0.0568451919,
0.0261028521,
0.0221016482,
0.005841766,
-0.0095261838,
-0.0760644227,
-0.0361011662,
-0.0316886939,
-0.0378812291,
0.0373000465,
0.0471814126,
-0.0158792771,
0.0583076626,
-0.048680678,
0.0046636988,
-0.0243899748,
0.0223171413,
-0.0273303054,
-0.0402542911,
0.0068667205,
-0.0036959234,
0.0395590775,
-0.007323388,
-0.0445023552,
-0.0719500706,
0.0560303517,
-0.0092254262,
-0.0243538283,
-0.0413980894,
-0.0062994966,
0.0043097176,
-0.0404754616,
0.006254728,
0.0063516209,
-0.0177811738,
-0.0253839437,
-0.0161143821,
0.0054320008,
0.0492903516,
0.0225703418,
-0.0172283612,
-0.0195475984,
-0.0292545669,
0.0244729314,
0.0112742623,
0.0191790294,
-0.0035736037,
0.1051117182,
0.0021809416,
-0.014894384,
0.0461645685,
0.0537790991,
0.0184213966,
-0.0411858559,
0.0309414603,
-0.0273914617,
0.0627620369,
0.00543903,
0.069228217,
-0.0242501777,
0.0375309549,
-0.0155051118,
0.0632152706,
-0.0062264903,
-0.0154295713,
0.0447241813,
-0.0097492933,
-0.0225149952,
-0.0043750019,
0.0765646994,
-0.0185749624,
-0.0055741002,
0.0109002879,
-0.0057883323,
-0.0436992124,
-0.0207249951,
0.0135897528,
0.0265268516,
-0.0382742584,
0.0030497438,
-0.0638107136,
-0.0252069719,
-0.0137831066,
0.0126409736,
0.0026859541,
-0.0139517579,
0.0326468162,
0.0582669564,
-0.0062590097,
-0.036073681,
-0.0373448245,
-0.0357954502,
-0.026232902,
0.0047722813,
-0.0468194559,
-5.922930325e-33,
-0.0165344011,
-0.0123770032,
0.0258951038,
-0.0075661992,
0.0277657397,
0.0071775499,
-0.0255593974,
-0.0114093889,
-0.0146961715,
-0.0001583776,
-0.0023858526,
0.0211242121,
0.0268517695,
0.005752401,
0.0081328321,
-0.0294253174,
0.0482465439,
-0.0147258891,
-0.020795716,
0.0276797507,
0.0773143321,
0.015125704,
0.0970299914,
-0.048657082,
0.0824328884,
0.0143442992,
-0.0045980602,
0.0432648957,
0.0447407514,
0.049823124,
-0.0257474892,
0.0679556951,
0.0318461694,
-0.070811756,
0.0008549929,
0.0217776299,
-0.0774437934,
-0.0331848748,
0.0808254853,
0.0517035499,
-0.0263678506,
-0.0125384731,
-0.030553529,
0.0076764799,
-0.0018010453,
0.0496275388,
0.0018861075,
0.0075500142,
0.0151459314,
-0.0112702567,
-0.0887966752,
0.0157204587,
-0.0310686063,
-0.0593130328,
0.039372202,
0.0934444293,
-0.0045022117,
-0.0614376292,
-0.0671397671,
-0.0045158952,
-0.075243026,
-0.0244902447,
0.0831437632,
-0.0030147885,
-0.0387630574,
0.0458395891,
0.0097944224,
0.0326972641,
0.0272165686,
-0.003606396,
-0.0239752904,
0.0406115763,
-0.0066495384,
0.020888431,
-0.0225576032,
-0.0073344987,
-0.045231618,
0.0594814345,
0.0356306173,
0.0446192846,
0.0309784915,
0.0104002599,
-0.0374128968,
-0.0236738771,
-0.0024929482,
0.0193969924,
-0.0265442468,
-0.0244814176,
0.0479602441,
-0.0087615764,
0.0171351545,
0.0139518818,
0.0618205778,
-0.0022409139,
0.0047639213,
0.0261344314,
0.0173606388,
-0.0052354401,
-0.0032119011,
0.0353950001,
-0.0606174245,
-0.0372299701,
-0.0161853712,
0.0292716101,
0.0376090743,
-0.0022005786,
0.0321325883,
-0.0232640896,
-0.0250742044,
0.0101704784,
-0.0574808829,
0.0382743962,
-0.0499654263,
0.0825295821,
0.0427399501,
-0.0032748382,
-0.0448887907,
0.0887777433,
0.0191002153,
-0.0408478417,
-0.049342867,
-0.0094855893,
0.0115362033,
0.0162334219,
-0.0166056603,
-0.0052698096,
-0.0303348228,
-0.0394541211,
0.0070746685,
-0.0292351618,
-0.0019158415,
0.0176599417,
2.721e-7,
0.0168539584,
0.0317809023,
0.0076609664,
0.0437943228,
-0.0062801046,
0.0639991686,
-0.0144887799,
0.0324698836,
-0.013386501,
0.0007277601,
0.0145455347,
-0.01023826,
0.0478185862,
0.0102529116,
-0.1024061441,
-0.0224143807,
0.0130980415,
0.0105549367,
-0.0533365123,
0.0351407491,
0.0570545979,
0.0940581262,
-0.0214817058,
0.009723356,
-0.0237755589,
-0.0416571721,
0.0223097,
-0.0592700094,
-0.0029100275,
0.030353155,
0.0733182281,
-0.001292291,
-0.0098325042,
0.0234364476,
-0.0049333503,
0.0092685493,
0.035201516,
0.0630816668,
0.0073998999,
-0.0123374891,
-0.0154023236,
-0.0316891037,
-0.00962268,
-0.0583847277,
0.0441300943,
-0.0239940435,
-0.0403967202,
-0.0142642548,
0.0448031016,
0.0074203759,
0.0070248744,
-0.0097512351,
-0.0073484401,
0.0215144027,
0.0315433405,
-0.0513567962,
-0.0049874359,
-0.0405060165,
0.0095320465,
0.0205785967,
-0.012878295,
0.0051677837,
-0.0526011623,
-0.0392849967,
0.0208680686,
-0.0564414077,
-0.0208325777,
2.031640177e-34,
0.0366705619,
-0.0239298325,
0.0068848557,
0.0363718644,
0.0569730885,
-0.0277649071,
-0.0426771566,
-0.016402185,
0.0249661505,
-0.0408041701,
-0.0034497818
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10450v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10450v2 | Is GPT-3 a Good Data Annotator? | 2022-12-20T17:28:41 | 2023-06-14T16:11:50 | Bosheng Ding, Chengwei Qin, Linlin Liu, Yew Ken Chia, Shafiq Joty, Boyang Li, Lidong Bing | cs.CL | cs.CL | Data annotation is the process of labeling data that could be used to train
machine learning models. Having high-quality annotation is crucial, as it
allows the model to learn the relationship between the input data and the
desired output. GPT-3, a large-scale language model developed by OpenAI, has
demonstrated impressive zero- and few-shot performance on a wide range of NLP
tasks. It is therefore natural to wonder whether it can be used to effectively
annotate data for NLP tasks. In this paper, we evaluate the performance of
GPT-3 as a data annotator by comparing it with traditional data annotation
methods and analyzing its output on a range of tasks. Through this analysis, we
aim to provide insight into the potential of GPT-3 as a general-purpose data
annotator in NLP. | [
0.0321762897,
0.0375685021,
0.0161936674,
0.0257739797,
-0.0116242031,
0.0305922665,
-0.0145319272,
-0.0012695142,
0.0056753908,
-0.1163799614,
-0.023760194,
0.0163235851,
-0.015838949,
0.0034804309,
0.0203708597,
-0.0705001429,
0.0580589026,
0.0153921545,
0.0315117016,
0.0591774061,
0.0202443786,
0.0153541565,
-0.000234,
0.0568615943,
-0.0431264155,
-0.0242384989,
-0.0032142783,
-0.0103225205,
0.0231096912,
-0.0427195057,
-0.0183553658,
0.0568713211,
-0.0097211031,
0.0754669383,
0.0000016611,
-0.0351933949,
0.000395355,
0.0488773435,
-0.029557908,
0.0199588705,
0.0064821439,
-0.0438764133,
-0.0099647781,
0.0022450085,
-0.0450262278,
-0.0511381142,
0.0674667433,
0.084047392,
0.0943594053,
0.0777250379,
-0.0242901351,
-0.0374796838,
0.0517809503,
-0.0259690024,
0.034690652,
-0.0305748954,
-0.0029195163,
0.0303457137,
-0.0107966922,
0.0293834042,
0.0226488654,
0.0200115275,
0.0142471408,
0.0124309547,
0.0054558287,
0.0439931676,
-0.0761918649,
-0.0024397064,
-0.0391361415,
0.0854657516,
-0.004736763,
-0.0163154751,
-0.0392311141,
-0.031346716,
-0.0066860644,
-0.0466670059,
-0.0220471006,
0.0082603069,
0.0044018445,
0.0537282303,
0.0347058214,
0.0161150079,
0.0499320626,
0.0105275065,
0.0292632841,
0.0918809995,
-0.0044396981,
-0.0121504096,
0.0216298532,
0.0313269459,
-0.0622672737,
-0.0328335576,
-0.0203028936,
0.0250737723,
0.0344678648,
0.017814476,
-0.0446965061,
-0.0333421156,
0.0249091778,
-0.0306011904,
0.0390429534,
0.0534370728,
-0.0318204574,
0.0490255691,
-0.0323179439,
0.0062840292,
-0.0115654469,
0.032991834,
-0.0039568855,
-0.0532743223,
-0.0852771997,
-0.0107391719,
-0.0570036061,
0.0495552719,
-0.002245412,
-0.046954684,
-0.0215184372,
0.0182422008,
-0.0254980288,
0.0160815995,
0.0390297882,
-0.0234350692,
-0.0375128463,
0.0167554785,
-0.0326691307,
0.0135129234,
-0.0609142035,
0.0130284298,
0.003644363,
-0.0708477795,
-0.0033576097,
0.0144571606,
0.0179991834,
-0.0484670773,
-0.0155747067,
0.0690532848,
0.0376514606,
-0.0452005416,
-0.0666019022,
-0.0042565665,
-0.0088177696,
-0.0524546616,
-0.006998268,
-0.0562224351,
0.009316328,
0.0149980653,
0.0131161157,
-0.0167210344,
0.0320121944,
0.0368009321,
-0.0137022668,
0.0922826752,
-0.0758179203,
-0.0341801271,
0.0048877653,
-0.0059002358,
0.0008550455,
0.0556065887,
0.047403276,
-0.0133588528,
0.0158168189,
0.0142059382,
0.0305446163,
0.0256164577,
0.0061929477,
-0.0131823877,
0.0229784455,
-0.008207486,
0.0216187667,
0.0231921636,
0.012140695,
0.057100486,
-0.0291520823,
0.0159864407,
0.0424237661,
0.021629924,
0.0001745946,
0.0080891028,
0.0344089642,
0.0020441327,
0.0087870192,
-0.0121665513,
-0.0330389664,
0.0152736446,
-0.0012614641,
0.0120326122,
-0.0070117749,
-0.0103137065,
-0.0196253695,
-0.0365709923,
-0.0607985705,
-0.0182399675,
0.0087314993,
-0.0102041401,
0.0295258053,
0.0451128446,
-0.0174257569,
0.0377892107,
0.0167120937,
-0.0429684855,
-0.0105984602,
-0.0375278853,
0.008617295,
0.0282815918,
0.0144169359,
-0.0414241888,
-0.0345652923,
-0.0248360131,
-0.0041361507,
0.0241785143,
0.0695861429,
-0.0161093138,
0.0057581966,
-0.0476585329,
0.0026888484,
-0.0283511933,
0.0356289372,
0.0104881693,
0.0523269065,
-0.0138174221,
0.0277414992,
-0.0394663997,
-0.0221827943,
0.0562741756,
0.0321670212,
-0.0497163087,
0.0086382627,
-0.0121456329,
0.0361084491,
0.0452363305,
-0.0031024476,
0.0013282868,
0.0144681484,
-0.0147315413,
0.0120366449,
-0.0073321359,
0.0220272653,
-0.0289992131,
0.039432954,
-0.0232893676,
-0.051795017,
0.0261902791,
-0.0695879981,
-0.0512124151,
-0.0332008116,
-0.0331908576,
0.0243743882,
-0.0598695874,
-0.0574974492,
0.0241642985,
0.0148351043,
-0.0312197153,
0.0618701391,
0.0386195555,
-0.0219302773,
0.0099208448,
0.0411451086,
0.0502931997,
-0.0168739296,
-0.0638307929,
-0.0027633903,
0.0305731613,
0.0100990925,
0.011950992,
-0.0035845351,
-0.0593322925,
0.0039122398,
-0.1178446114,
0.0385864116,
-0.0193322301,
0.040619906,
0.0348157361,
0.0061035953,
0.0043932642,
-0.0250981729,
-0.0471911095,
0.0188007485,
0.0008307344,
-0.0019063359,
0.0542311929,
0.0240252614,
-0.0077591324,
-0.0242747664,
0.0142263379,
-0.0461642779,
0.0258024484,
0.0298952088,
-0.0677754134,
-0.0264491532,
-0.005539428,
-0.0414930731,
0.0408314951,
0.0383885279,
-0.0114262514,
0.016366031,
0.0109239807,
0.0076309149,
-0.0018184063,
-0.0408956259,
0.0535181612,
0.0314115472,
0.0111419512,
-0.0171417035,
0.0314342976,
-0.0286884047,
-0.0049096695,
-0.002584419,
-0.0054219328,
-0.0032148422,
0.0475174561,
0.0039403234,
-0.0144011807,
-0.0599905625,
0.0008800867,
-0.0298266076,
0.0122967381,
-0.0155731495,
0.0227022637,
-0.0286166221,
0.0044789799,
-0.0215299856,
-0.0466662459,
0.0525093712,
-0.0284158811,
-0.00737083,
-0.0146905314,
-0.0070703914,
-0.0451308824,
0.0855734423,
0.0000748682,
-0.0046045841,
-0.0054043196,
-0.0165059231,
0.016579397,
0.0114143463,
0.0126263369,
-0.0003215324,
0.0288236402,
-0.0460552946,
0.0413504131,
-0.0132998955,
-0.0093301162,
0.0006221082,
0.0089007597,
-0.0590109527,
0.0685251057,
-0.0307568945,
0.0089028152,
0.0009415479,
-0.0030987198,
0.0040876307,
0.0629627407,
-0.0208642557,
-0.0173532069,
-0.0241639409,
0.0168473758,
0.0467570499,
0.0033813536,
-0.0176431742,
0.0330941714,
-0.0049609789,
0.030263355,
0.0086714895,
0.0296881665,
-0.0574580692,
0.0118489824,
0.0094568077,
-0.043396771,
-0.031429518,
0.012355092,
0.0269270334,
-0.0661858469,
-0.0149525944,
0.1054235548,
0.038251657,
-0.0520993844,
-0.007874121,
0.0435171798,
0.0228085965,
0.0228656512,
0.0000346235,
-0.1194303259,
-0.05978214,
-0.0307950042,
0.0016357508,
-0.0108716674,
-0.0070631844,
-0.0044298572,
-0.1128251404,
0.0319431312,
-0.0198881067,
-0.0693333,
-0.019583188,
-0.0471353084,
0.0044052391,
-0.0443424284,
0.0230481122,
-0.0643449873,
0.0247273464,
0.0108902855,
0.0415043645,
-0.0220249873,
-0.0787068754,
0.0150707718,
-0.0443795621,
0.0647527948,
0.0838799551,
0.0355665125,
-0.0242537316,
-0.018485982,
0.0309525188,
0.0078445217,
-0.0094597731,
-0.002319826,
0.0767246932,
-0.0471042059,
-0.0150765777,
0.0007493041,
0.0027090628,
-0.0512204133,
-0.0282692071,
-0.0190209989,
0.0962970629,
-0.0230266806,
0.0212059636,
0.0059215813,
-0.0308014639,
0.0121662365,
0.0696337745,
0.0086300122,
-0.0189870037,
-0.0475458503,
-0.0370914489,
0.0157023147,
-0.0513444953,
-0.0269291978,
0.0187110119,
-0.0044320221,
-0.0532186553,
-0.0494181067,
-0.0884445906,
0.079652831,
0.0246053059,
0.0181399919,
0.0285833627,
-0.0228825919,
0.0193680488,
-0.0140375635,
0.0106075993,
-0.0266475268,
-0.0199936721,
-0.0231384654,
-0.0388330445,
0.0396250635,
0.0203720033,
-0.0078342482,
0.0404226929,
-0.1014498472,
-0.0383861177,
-0.0152793312,
0.0630125552,
0.0277230497,
0.0033576488,
-0.0221781023,
-0.0299803074,
-0.0568796657,
0.0413560979,
0.0088549191,
-0.0345331915,
-0.0020955044,
0.0107807172,
0.0102314102,
0.0140557215,
-0.0096238209,
0.0126363393,
-0.0119546987,
0.0455034487,
-0.0215652809,
0.0137519725,
0.0462930501,
0.0199505519,
0.0750038773,
-0.0104782982,
-0.0162227545,
-0.0443041809,
-0.0193934366,
-0.0174170379,
-0.0326340795,
-0.055249352,
0.0373960808,
0.0533350557,
-0.0171004701,
-0.0417726599,
-0.0170129351,
-0.016698705,
0.0301112458,
-0.0601939708,
-0.0325970799,
0.040972963,
-0.0083273593,
-0.0596039444,
-0.0072161737,
-0.0311192982,
0.003447843,
0.0286825057,
0.0175934341,
-0.0202835351,
0.0313744731,
0.0314650424,
-0.0086136581,
0.026878776,
0.0294378884,
-0.0501544736,
0.0056293537,
-0.0458060168,
0.0465191752,
0.0542201176,
-0.0099161742,
0.0559855811,
-0.0517855808,
-0.034790732,
0.0163010135,
0.0508100465,
0.0162421521,
-0.0397241861,
-0.0011904188,
0.0015684491,
-0.0420314483,
-0.0383906402,
0.0581021756,
0.0116879605,
0.0527853705,
0.0186275095,
-0.0220005438,
-0.0282060951,
0.0108329318,
-0.0245288461,
0.032999631,
-0.0076937512,
0.041532971,
-0.0388237871,
-0.042535264,
-0.026507521,
0.0032899454,
0.001986987,
-0.0044915676,
0.0513495915,
0.0325513333,
-0.0068831858,
-0.050073579,
-0.0508207902,
-0.0395849049,
-0.0095304418,
-0.005185029,
-0.039743416,
-5.555355078e-33,
-0.0597076379,
-0.0249207653,
0.0104094502,
0.0386253111,
-0.0142386463,
0.0030002301,
-0.0226353593,
0.0010403949,
-0.032335896,
0.0216886047,
0.024355175,
0.0186660215,
0.0199824292,
0.0203476474,
0.0038173362,
-0.0588228405,
0.0114715099,
-0.0004252111,
-0.0300407186,
0.0041777082,
0.0283606835,
-0.0084274197,
0.1030965149,
-0.0758257583,
0.0533085763,
0.0157178007,
-0.0518747903,
-0.0229511689,
-0.0102502117,
0.0662356392,
-0.0342573486,
0.0453614332,
0.0346526913,
-0.0451887771,
0.014841673,
0.0024731071,
-0.0799963921,
-0.0326797552,
0.0179351028,
0.0278550256,
-0.0449567065,
-0.0199965257,
0.0077015762,
-0.0197870005,
-0.0042977985,
0.0084943855,
0.0300252847,
-0.018450221,
-0.0168411713,
-0.0153947063,
-0.0923390239,
0.0341454819,
0.0130054792,
0.016134128,
0.0546665676,
-0.0069042165,
0.0039794045,
0.0154291028,
-0.0578662716,
-0.0304175075,
0.0144431898,
0.0296247136,
0.0202201679,
0.0071708551,
-0.0063624042,
0.0521089211,
0.013297555,
0.0022546391,
-0.0245993305,
-0.0030097875,
0.0053815856,
0.0189974271,
0.0392683223,
0.0232174043,
0.0534200594,
0.0161174797,
-0.0354915373,
0.0305710807,
0.0084969383,
-0.0184453744,
0.0023238112,
-0.002513082,
-0.0164635703,
0.0076428764,
-0.0426982045,
-0.0310531817,
-0.0376071185,
-0.0279359408,
0.0380933173,
-0.0082382839,
0.001620187,
0.0775581747,
0.0040445672,
-0.0096776281,
-0.0175815932,
0.0088936994,
-0.0058215433,
0.0451304205,
-0.0175850652,
0.0052661211,
-0.0387331583,
-0.0466672368,
0.0072466219,
0.0222743396,
0.0545451231,
-0.0195817724,
0.0922117904,
0.0209167972,
-0.0587876998,
-0.0007202882,
-0.0420010649,
0.0208607651,
-0.0328390151,
0.0175560918,
0.0290684849,
0.010010574,
-0.0078528943,
0.043571122,
0.0347740687,
0.0121955257,
-0.0150317131,
-0.0291206669,
-0.0139253885,
-0.0394335315,
-0.0158656649,
0.0075053005,
0.0059206379,
-0.0020430523,
-0.0172733851,
-0.0504807457,
-0.0011055857,
0.0367194302,
2.257e-7,
0.0925887153,
0.0602928437,
0.0363603979,
0.0380799845,
-0.0076341121,
0.0017642654,
0.0213933811,
0.0287205316,
0.0161326956,
-0.0260977447,
0.0136875184,
0.0020159215,
0.0313862897,
0.0432397202,
-0.0767285451,
-0.0025952898,
-0.0507846251,
-0.0055821096,
-0.0638492331,
0.0353690572,
0.0631429777,
0.1232010424,
0.0316101424,
0.0174703468,
0.0076631326,
-0.016707195,
0.0737988278,
-0.0366864763,
0.0147832967,
0.0327302702,
0.0593484528,
0.0541029759,
-0.0176548306,
0.0255022757,
-0.0115001034,
0.0048025176,
0.0522495024,
0.0612419136,
-0.019720953,
-0.0385773852,
-0.0158952102,
-0.0131731229,
0.0189599227,
-0.0468322076,
0.0752234757,
-0.0189760793,
-0.0442578644,
0.0023923626,
0.0073090764,
-0.0064920904,
0.0298700053,
-0.0173462853,
-0.0144427177,
-0.0001808454,
0.0107614305,
-0.0135219991,
-0.059372317,
-0.0584869646,
-0.0409151018,
0.0199702419,
0.0009098558,
-0.0146136014,
-0.0194030795,
-0.0463823788,
0.0116597787,
-0.0702330396,
-0.0273629371,
1.938774286e-34,
0.0122010764,
-0.0251167193,
0.0208399054,
0.0534440577,
0.0447425246,
0.0416540764,
0.0378554501,
0.0040297746,
-0.0148158642,
-0.0501183979,
-0.0095321639
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10449v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10449v3 | Socratic Pretraining: Question-Driven Pretraining for Controllable Summarization | 2022-12-20T17:27:10 | 2023-06-08T22:43:58 | Artidoro Pagnoni, Alexander R. Fabbri, Wojciech Kryściński, Chien-Sheng Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL | In long document controllable summarization, where labeled data is scarce,
pretrained models struggle to adapt to the task and effectively respond to user
queries. In this paper, we introduce Socratic pretraining, a question-driven,
unsupervised pretraining objective specifically designed to improve
controllability in summarization tasks. By training a model to generate and
answer relevant questions in a given context, Socratic pretraining enables the
model to more effectively adhere to user-provided queries and identify relevant
content to be summarized. We demonstrate the effectiveness of this approach
through extensive experimentation on two summarization domains, short stories
and dialogue, and multiple control strategies: keywords, questions, and factoid
QA pairs. Our pretraining method relies only on unlabeled documents and a
question generation system and outperforms pre-finetuning approaches that use
additional supervised data. Furthermore, our results show that Socratic
pretraining cuts task-specific labeled data requirements in half, is more
faithful to user-provided queries, and achieves state-of-the-art performance on
QMSum and SQuALITY. | [
0.0296181142,
0.0010594811,
0.0300540347,
-0.0051934342,
0.0137454867,
0.0336527638,
-0.0300752819,
-0.0380734988,
0.0105123362,
-0.0170625485,
-0.0072483378,
0.0034200402,
-0.017759271,
0.0200964138,
0.0023362606,
-0.0696656555,
0.0240982249,
-0.0120176291,
-0.0107304193,
0.0091572572,
0.0463366397,
0.0058704624,
-0.0022404569,
-0.0027147864,
-0.0182701852,
-0.0146656046,
-0.0174121261,
-0.0151474308,
0.000223183,
-0.009000239,
0.0389765203,
0.0414332449,
0.0500434674,
-0.0218967944,
0.0000018593,
-0.0708137527,
-0.0567864925,
-0.0318818353,
-0.0000783396,
0.0046712994,
0.0336954817,
-0.0162342079,
0.0542710014,
0.0228391532,
-0.0392678678,
0.033273153,
-0.0004781505,
0.0786578879,
0.1004502252,
0.076735191,
-0.0165704116,
-0.0273451321,
0.0038952725,
-0.0123607907,
0.014868685,
-0.0772720054,
-0.0228866972,
0.0353999846,
0.0158276074,
-0.0039134631,
-0.0023240943,
0.0469289385,
-0.0035368633,
-0.0184968933,
0.0138582857,
-0.0112871397,
-0.0416821577,
-0.0063610929,
-0.0015425995,
0.099350974,
0.0177186448,
-0.0117562581,
0.0285509098,
0.0230580326,
0.0144223599,
-0.0000606778,
-0.0719873905,
0.0030562731,
-0.0108117592,
0.0018275467,
-0.0285495818,
0.0199554879,
-0.0316325203,
0.0115020741,
-0.0283782575,
0.0160124842,
-0.0045022164,
-0.0068850615,
-0.0326338299,
0.0010399115,
-0.0226858873,
-0.0590129495,
0.0291963499,
0.0633538738,
-0.0412965715,
-0.0123227322,
-0.0688367933,
-0.0527225174,
0.0169153698,
-0.0291353427,
-0.0249224622,
-0.0011434812,
0.0389481522,
0.0564824343,
0.004667318,
0.0073402571,
0.0061454223,
0.0330470763,
-0.0806362405,
-0.0008356329,
-0.0466882624,
-0.0043196152,
-0.0758992657,
0.0496747717,
-0.0417446829,
-0.0190936569,
-0.016699465,
0.0437946729,
0.0449600779,
-0.0067088571,
-0.0257506706,
0.0188076627,
-0.0280088428,
-0.0042115957,
-0.0217683651,
-0.0007914422,
-0.0729301274,
-0.0111364648,
0.038240321,
0.0166124366,
-0.0167934727,
0.0055046878,
0.0402517729,
-0.0017900742,
-0.0094055114,
0.0043062046,
-0.0652281493,
-0.0358546041,
-0.0202630572,
-0.0449935943,
-0.0019636895,
-0.0226952899,
-0.0058693974,
-0.0351231657,
0.025754841,
0.0003781528,
-0.0261365119,
0.0152722644,
-0.0113334097,
0.0218881499,
-0.034485545,
0.0590136312,
-0.0232071839,
-0.0035847723,
0.0472017787,
0.0184870306,
0.0326622315,
0.0569485985,
0.040868178,
0.0319748633,
0.0662551746,
0.0296994932,
0.0560422838,
-0.0065436582,
0.0336319879,
0.0072754272,
0.0298813116,
0.0355748869,
-0.0050396468,
-0.0066243517,
0.01657141,
0.0540607907,
-0.0148585346,
0.0325840786,
0.0407083705,
0.0571829565,
-0.0018890575,
-0.004146433,
0.0306642335,
0.0204629358,
0.0183050726,
0.0613484234,
-0.0190496724,
0.025953766,
-0.0340601429,
0.0475349426,
0.0724454001,
-0.0006964978,
-0.0375295728,
-0.0599031635,
0.0217397362,
0.00001548,
-0.0010371037,
0.0195882041,
0.0069358409,
0.0565127134,
-0.0366344266,
0.0272779465,
-0.0240623094,
-0.082184352,
0.0138620352,
-0.0204161163,
0.0336666964,
0.0232889317,
0.051468946,
-0.0725465268,
-0.043113973,
-0.0149241015,
0.0379882082,
0.0181787405,
0.0630947128,
-0.0357773677,
0.003721985,
-0.0337512791,
-0.0319294855,
-0.0261788983,
0.0025067695,
-0.0088850232,
-0.0295051541,
-0.0257957093,
0.0378906727,
-0.0425324477,
-0.0547261573,
0.0368315727,
-0.0166343804,
-0.0697560906,
-0.0146740824,
-0.0069683716,
-0.0218705069,
0.0198393781,
0.0027557286,
0.0156051116,
0.0134008825,
-0.0100865252,
-0.0075376276,
-0.0008293529,
-0.0587513633,
-0.0695264414,
0.0157546289,
-0.0383158736,
0.0011707617,
-0.0050700139,
-0.0321510956,
-0.0724232197,
0.0205334648,
-0.035390038,
-0.0041298838,
-0.0536353141,
0.0000247281,
0.0187763199,
-0.0242523775,
-0.0515943989,
0.0423081778,
0.0350373946,
-0.0043930737,
0.0522471592,
-0.0269527156,
0.0166487601,
-0.0042410181,
0.0055392468,
0.0134682478,
0.0018640321,
0.0184732936,
0.0611075796,
0.0127875144,
-0.0438881367,
0.0006626088,
-0.0843727291,
0.0131616872,
-0.0343908407,
-0.0040564174,
0.0370744243,
0.0373631679,
-0.0345432162,
-0.0325193144,
-0.0565781333,
-0.0442843735,
0.0396014638,
0.0046100258,
0.0381007306,
0.0543394163,
0.0822828785,
-0.0582302809,
0.0058751777,
0.0108958799,
0.0284194853,
0.03024536,
0.0040073521,
0.0026559192,
0.0425245576,
-0.0444528311,
0.0132426796,
-0.014608481,
0.0016823717,
0.000811477,
-0.0387005545,
0.0513994507,
0.0343092345,
0.0387891643,
-0.0169926286,
0.0345474221,
0.0083226217,
-0.0191896353,
0.0325351432,
-0.0428719446,
-0.0175059456,
0.0114738932,
0.0028490827,
0.0696810037,
0.0538741276,
0.0003790184,
-0.0177314598,
-0.0226489939,
0.0472214557,
-0.0013341535,
-0.0023477939,
-0.0747042596,
0.0160092451,
0.0018132413,
0.0549442954,
-0.0331031643,
0.0068706949,
0.0640634149,
-0.0103924479,
0.0001186799,
-0.0817195624,
-0.0087737087,
-0.0553809367,
0.0304520708,
0.0165159386,
0.0187600013,
0.0026148229,
-0.0066632559,
-0.0619439147,
-0.0466503464,
0.0478483252,
-0.0115216747,
0.0436176732,
-0.0276731681,
0.0073900623,
-0.0235344097,
-0.0136006484,
-0.025600953,
-0.0430326574,
0.0110337781,
0.0054398593,
0.0581815727,
0.0236928184,
0.0076704342,
0.0067354441,
0.0475412123,
0.088188611,
-0.0520905927,
-0.0297754966,
-0.0132710207,
0.0793799832,
0.0850546733,
0.0209438056,
0.0229182821,
-0.0567902997,
0.053234946,
0.0260353982,
0.0646314919,
-0.0330710895,
0.0485630892,
0.0124597605,
-0.0196085982,
-0.0805284232,
0.02819499,
-0.012484082,
0.0917808786,
-0.0270774588,
-0.0413724817,
0.1110650972,
0.0516821854,
-0.0166253392,
-0.0265976824,
0.0222723521,
0.030683944,
0.0298496448,
0.0334804729,
-0.0484565012,
-0.0004099869,
-0.012990674,
0.0544657782,
0.0314137638,
-0.0361271799,
-0.0336001255,
-0.0620532595,
-0.0134007698,
-0.0007063795,
-0.0734931007,
-0.0140770776,
-0.0092564188,
0.0030019614,
0.0099537708,
0.000769002,
0.0308858864,
-0.0417701975,
0.0161629636,
0.0072256238,
-0.0479943417,
0.0255096573,
-0.040964935,
-0.0231987406,
-0.0348232538,
0.0575938523,
0.0236116182,
0.0306399129,
0.0618317984,
0.0305813011,
-0.0479768887,
-0.0204798914,
0.0035757588,
0.0810518935,
-0.0327119157,
0.0067834118,
-0.0154289231,
0.0527322628,
0.0224086903,
0.0106487237,
0.0329137556,
-0.0055119894,
-0.0056583039,
-0.025729645,
-0.0408818871,
0.040060617,
-0.0191189796,
0.0646690875,
0.0620088652,
-0.0058781495,
-0.0521688536,
-0.0388892442,
-0.0083424281,
-0.1156212687,
-0.0073185633,
-0.0307570007,
-0.0318042412,
0.0403867029,
-0.1072104648,
-0.0698988661,
0.0293464344,
-0.0049128477,
-0.0170957036,
-0.01537845,
0.0104183285,
0.0128498757,
-0.0443013981,
-0.0090420637,
-0.0218712725,
-0.0330701321,
-0.0365368463,
-0.0191302299,
0.0620825365,
-0.0359657295,
-0.0164275169,
-0.0090187658,
-0.0402776487,
-0.0354447588,
-0.0410963111,
0.0630193204,
0.0187891088,
0.0661219731,
-0.0089671183,
-0.0258137453,
0.0438191593,
0.0379839763,
-0.0313587338,
0.0184471793,
0.0184846409,
0.0419066809,
-0.0153528545,
0.0272723772,
-0.0655959472,
0.0438789986,
-0.0310480483,
0.032125961,
-0.0539023429,
-0.0544533953,
0.0215575714,
0.0178811215,
-0.0225984324,
0.0159561671,
0.0204136111,
-0.053282246,
-0.0158148911,
-0.0140083423,
-0.0310134739,
-0.0316560045,
0.0600958392,
-0.0279194042,
-0.0111337826,
-0.0025790061,
0.0506069809,
-0.0395489968,
0.0467266589,
-0.0519961752,
-0.0314928778,
-0.0200364068,
-0.0422600023,
-0.0386359394,
0.005782132,
-0.0354953185,
0.0001728397,
-0.0078636901,
0.0473380908,
0.0012320983,
0.0412913337,
0.0322695374,
0.0095136715,
-0.0104601709,
0.0305835269,
-0.1006822735,
-0.0169155803,
-0.036760401,
0.0389807634,
0.0119338445,
-0.0455963127,
0.027912816,
0.0110841831,
-0.0158604905,
-0.0107992096,
0.0369179398,
0.0375245437,
0.0192678701,
-0.0267771855,
0.027714055,
0.0055933041,
0.0293604676,
0.0638297275,
-0.0139216771,
0.0052203666,
0.0284406096,
-0.0224798974,
-0.0578333847,
-0.0339620039,
0.0024432049,
0.035639029,
0.0069189896,
-0.0056428425,
-0.0229981765,
-0.030877417,
0.0283703543,
0.0156208444,
-0.0090560485,
-0.0029648994,
0.0657502413,
0.0295959041,
-0.0025590763,
-0.018265225,
-0.0366685428,
-0.0093798358,
-0.0190041941,
-0.000828913,
0.0207880698,
-5.863215946e-33,
-0.0533777401,
-0.0140083153,
0.0134994807,
-0.0035031228,
-0.0402453691,
-0.0031433117,
-0.0600180216,
-0.0086598741,
0.0057693301,
-0.0083831782,
-0.0319433212,
0.0112714125,
-0.0060230638,
0.041606769,
-0.0357486568,
-0.024051426,
0.0297076628,
-0.0065245549,
-0.0449496992,
0.0755848736,
0.0400903299,
0.0398989171,
0.0027210268,
-0.0314640589,
0.0128311068,
-0.0511344299,
-0.004338867,
0.0158933345,
0.0549459904,
0.0266469605,
-0.0109511577,
-0.0238236338,
0.042036742,
-0.0109425886,
-0.0411499254,
0.0444733426,
-0.06286107,
-0.052321583,
0.0083576404,
-0.035017252,
-0.0537302457,
-0.0263364166,
0.0290293936,
-0.0364111736,
0.0473959558,
-0.0176826902,
0.0609263219,
-0.0257337317,
-0.0131363571,
-0.0839154944,
-0.0295683481,
0.0029951455,
-0.0308921486,
-0.073980771,
-0.0172774717,
0.0832919627,
0.0120735122,
0.0019023668,
0.0191431344,
0.0225158222,
0.0487149805,
0.0323138423,
0.0200767089,
0.0507076494,
-0.0098939687,
0.0284110382,
-0.0164673533,
0.0117835151,
-0.0168819185,
0.0245164745,
-0.0063890489,
0.0071442733,
0.0249629468,
0.0353457965,
0.0235560574,
0.0249004643,
-0.0226687342,
0.0919276252,
-0.0100662401,
-0.0236152168,
-0.0236005299,
-0.0155695193,
0.0038123245,
-0.0179296695,
-0.05348197,
0.0606633611,
-0.0147993108,
0.0156570412,
-0.0028382777,
0.0244058855,
-0.0710656866,
-0.011529658,
0.0255451892,
-0.0135193504,
0.0237047262,
0.0158786904,
-0.0176526774,
0.0219899248,
0.0065767253,
0.0013876638,
-0.0214661807,
0.0362945162,
0.0457222387,
-0.0143038342,
-0.0160808414,
0.0005799402,
0.0294604637,
-0.0016186608,
-0.0251717921,
0.0146677364,
0.0221998841,
0.0407957956,
-0.0382776745,
0.0199930444,
-0.0245687142,
0.0287117735,
0.0014997001,
0.0614282228,
-0.0101999538,
-0.0288203433,
-0.0325318053,
-0.0350177586,
0.0134936729,
0.0436852053,
-0.0182057172,
0.0187129248,
-0.0198255274,
0.0545524471,
0.0152886584,
-0.0946061239,
0.0012169849,
0.0046077678,
2.509e-7,
0.0420612767,
0.0253637489,
0.0563464724,
0.0155440206,
-0.0171207208,
0.0175587162,
0.0067489212,
0.0386979692,
0.0333352573,
-0.0365088135,
0.0510880798,
0.0522185378,
0.0286462922,
0.0131181097,
-0.0938943774,
-0.0603707582,
-0.0436191931,
-0.023640085,
-0.0398779698,
-0.0550173149,
0.0546052344,
0.0288353823,
-0.0320535526,
0.001245689,
-0.0035932784,
-0.0518491641,
0.0385456644,
0.0033391349,
-0.0395439342,
0.059022028,
0.0266352501,
0.0294523221,
-0.0255856421,
-0.0269249603,
-0.0173855983,
0.0042919093,
0.0490435138,
0.0336335152,
0.0366891101,
-0.0629790276,
-0.0078977561,
0.0073264805,
0.0346690156,
0.0196242221,
0.073801361,
-0.0733867809,
0.0241034385,
0.0086565586,
-0.0307323784,
-0.0000689825,
-0.0205080472,
-0.0201931,
-0.0359561034,
0.056408029,
0.0016493495,
0.0113036428,
0.0283798762,
-0.0709352866,
-0.0172562189,
0.0235966574,
0.0122411801,
-0.0301680192,
-0.028074149,
-0.018616017,
-0.0146564171,
-0.06278833,
-0.0017628896,
2.280445495e-34,
0.0770225301,
-0.0233788118,
-0.018008396,
-0.0292867497,
0.0231473967,
-0.0359239727,
-0.0039511188,
-0.0202285182,
0.051199384,
-0.072125189,
-0.0147158792
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10448v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10448v1 | Parameter-efficient Zero-shot Transfer for Cross-Language Dense Retrieval with Adapters | 2022-12-20T17:25:04 | 2022-12-20T17:25:04 | Eugene Yang, Suraj Nair, Dawn Lawrie, James Mayfield, Douglas W. Oard | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | A popular approach to creating a zero-shot cross-language retrieval model is
to substitute a monolingual pretrained language model in the retrieval model
with a multilingual pretrained language model such as Multilingual BERT. This
multilingual model is fined-tuned to the retrieval task with monolingual data
such as English MS MARCO using the same training recipe as the monolingual
retrieval model used. However, such transferred models suffer from mismatches
in the languages of the input text during training and inference. In this work,
we propose transferring monolingual retrieval models using adapters, a
parameter-efficient component for a transformer network. By adding adapters
pretrained on language tasks for a specific language with task-specific
adapters, prior work has shown that the adapter-enhanced models perform better
than fine-tuning the entire model when transferring across languages in various
NLP tasks. By constructing dense retrieval models with adapters, we show that
models trained with monolingual data are more effective than fine-tuning the
entire model when transferring to a Cross Language Information Retrieval (CLIR)
setting. However, we found that the prior suggestion of replacing the language
adapters to match the target language at inference time is suboptimal for dense
retrieval models. We provide an in-depth analysis of this discrepancy between
other cross-language NLP tasks and CLIR. | [
-0.0062598279,
-0.0040878486,
0.0087439325,
0.0532383509,
-0.0027805506,
0.0001623071,
0.0248264726,
0.0131509127,
-0.0045023765,
-0.0209301952,
-0.0845591202,
-0.0086943777,
-0.0335647576,
-0.009931297,
0.0000318649,
-0.0221813116,
0.0565221868,
0.0105707273,
-0.0594228879,
0.0005997153,
-0.0228976924,
0.0131491916,
0.0273138527,
0.0210882556,
0.0244803336,
0.0195645392,
-0.0136936177,
0.0327536911,
0.0024043808,
0.0211708117,
0.0248157699,
0.0296961367,
0.0328281783,
0.0424251817,
0.0000018094,
-0.0243617762,
-0.0455167778,
-0.0002548933,
-0.0283649936,
-0.0466949791,
0.0143975159,
-0.0250776,
0.0193713624,
-0.0000694115,
-0.0084585724,
-0.0596841201,
0.0703383982,
0.0658227429,
0.0151033988,
0.097711876,
-0.0253451578,
-0.0186071377,
0.0425392613,
-0.029517198,
0.0160325207,
-0.0579994619,
0.0160773434,
-0.0243552327,
-0.0074887858,
0.0520978533,
-0.0018606792,
0.0509350449,
0.0099113658,
0.023323549,
-0.0207422618,
0.0068995124,
-0.0554967783,
0.0035482317,
0.0075018625,
0.0329399221,
-0.0596967414,
-0.0261449441,
-0.0470070802,
0.0151227023,
-0.004566289,
0.0348621942,
-0.0370487534,
-0.0042685899,
-0.0017900039,
0.0191428512,
0.0140681081,
-0.0106467241,
0.0108071063,
0.0162795968,
-0.0628978759,
0.0447610356,
0.0344826542,
-0.0060899667,
0.0270718988,
0.0172329098,
0.0001971605,
-0.0093901865,
0.0249286909,
0.0186340604,
-0.0021549601,
-0.0129335755,
-0.0101097478,
-0.0685164109,
-0.0014937535,
-0.0616145469,
0.0612264872,
0.0615063794,
-0.0290622748,
0.0567209013,
-0.0752686635,
0.057256002,
-0.0365217626,
0.0139631703,
-0.0746704936,
-0.0759446695,
-0.0553809479,
-0.020922631,
-0.0847872868,
0.0373322591,
-0.0360154472,
0.002923938,
-0.0232971217,
0.0166395325,
0.003639702,
-0.0418357886,
0.0116717806,
0.0029776664,
-0.0731014535,
-0.0301235039,
-0.0165576953,
0.1077764928,
-0.0209993757,
-0.0111765722,
-0.020344032,
-0.0445335135,
-0.0318827257,
0.0232485365,
0.0332834572,
-0.0928929299,
0.0239980835,
0.0523330569,
-0.0411721878,
-0.0589798316,
-0.0257415976,
0.0090439087,
0.0172788315,
-0.02315934,
0.0386224985,
-0.0656599849,
0.0244796183,
0.0073896605,
0.0190083068,
-0.0343941711,
-0.0149582513,
0.0141212437,
-0.0503575429,
0.0581367016,
0.0257064737,
-0.0140568931,
0.0031733264,
-0.017645061,
-0.0040605627,
0.0829847008,
-0.0200580694,
0.0134929894,
0.0613903292,
-0.0085557727,
-0.0071175094,
0.0349765532,
0.0254768096,
0.0377764218,
-0.0273917075,
-0.012973085,
0.0045063281,
-0.0120659759,
0.0447090454,
0.0070775007,
-0.0660879761,
-0.007272556,
-0.0057105641,
0.0162871443,
0.0777076706,
0.0025328898,
0.0606209934,
-0.0265215989,
-0.0351900719,
0.007128132,
-0.0026536332,
0.0456764773,
-0.027897628,
-0.0277543534,
0.0048396895,
0.042431429,
-0.078370139,
0.0074346913,
0.0285519101,
-0.0171844587,
-0.0037777519,
-0.0017610783,
0.0686884746,
0.030195849,
-0.0324724726,
0.0894158855,
0.0152451005,
-0.0431511886,
0.024587037,
-0.0415746644,
-0.0262279194,
0.0325296186,
0.0103112832,
-0.0202040076,
-0.0389683805,
0.0238837246,
0.0165472589,
0.0122712627,
0.0494972728,
-0.0081360443,
0.0453438573,
-0.0480032228,
-0.0342943743,
-0.0017460627,
0.0053210356,
0.0550903641,
0.0042531132,
0.0387376659,
0.0512102656,
-0.0540529229,
-0.0096280463,
0.0010066594,
-0.064816162,
-0.0379473493,
0.0458299033,
0.0129496269,
-0.0255195815,
-0.0032991795,
-0.0053675254,
0.0048798048,
0.014575975,
-0.0357103981,
-0.0053007407,
0.0231523588,
-0.0331327841,
-0.0381315351,
0.0065121185,
-0.0129523259,
0.0304163639,
0.0295765046,
-0.0010991995,
-0.0429368764,
-0.001258708,
0.0296525788,
0.0342502184,
-0.0375344157,
0.0332073309,
-0.0048448313,
0.0194628201,
-0.0320383757,
0.0196115859,
0.0495169722,
0.0488959625,
0.0125408564,
-0.0351188965,
0.0536761321,
-0.0360046476,
-0.052652292,
0.0322123207,
-0.0165932085,
0.0045274403,
0.0458068438,
-0.0012544091,
-0.0163211804,
-0.0281350724,
-0.088043943,
0.0159956757,
-0.0390356928,
-0.0032637028,
0.0038631398,
0.0643446669,
0.0106087429,
-0.0164171029,
-0.015426687,
0.0265020784,
0.0262810551,
0.0605417415,
0.0182305183,
-0.0021870132,
0.0520854667,
-0.0371317677,
-0.0501675382,
0.0098864194,
0.0636884198,
-0.0434769243,
-0.0344847068,
-0.0511277355,
0.0087430952,
-0.0222257115,
0.0473080985,
-0.0143189132,
-0.0226545297,
-0.0055636214,
-0.0374929011,
0.0377880745,
0.0434964709,
-0.0101087801,
-0.048832316,
0.003385117,
-0.0399173871,
-0.1004467756,
0.043749705,
-0.0384443142,
-0.0424547493,
-0.0197039656,
-0.0030190106,
0.0222111922,
0.0400358699,
-0.0520380065,
-0.0332128704,
-0.0632089004,
-0.0145805972,
0.0023267674,
0.0070378538,
-0.0261949115,
0.0205660369,
0.0245598461,
0.01630136,
-0.0314092413,
0.0018817472,
0.0387989581,
-0.0137293432,
-0.010584089,
-0.0328382067,
0.0037391775,
-0.0508065261,
0.0323807895,
-0.0166176595,
0.0391875766,
-0.0108954916,
-0.0159183424,
-0.0350030102,
-0.0085304193,
0.0312369317,
-0.0125575215,
0.0456525311,
0.0140400277,
0.0162864029,
-0.0356373824,
-0.0605551861,
-0.0227010064,
0.004690493,
0.0118334554,
0.0271600038,
-0.0136798546,
-0.0137400981,
-0.0907329246,
0.0046377853,
0.044529818,
0.055443041,
-0.0229643472,
-0.0235344507,
0.0031943445,
0.0334211439,
0.0252817869,
0.0099692028,
-0.0396083556,
-0.0040891482,
0.005438644,
0.027982736,
0.0067475634,
-0.0084390165,
-0.0160698798,
0.0102655943,
0.075168103,
-0.028743593,
-0.0499223992,
-0.0245174486,
0.0589642003,
-0.0086381268,
-0.0324310996,
0.0698906928,
0.0099444138,
-0.062142849,
-0.0577474944,
-0.0548911057,
0.0139362672,
0.0302134883,
0.0786248744,
-0.0767830312,
-0.0244577844,
-0.0088230511,
0.0075826086,
0.0358333923,
-0.0080862436,
-0.0035676728,
-0.1214545891,
0.0048498167,
-0.0107614072,
-0.0109707695,
-0.0536972396,
-0.0612560883,
-0.0068369303,
-0.022843983,
0.014512849,
0.0086881053,
-0.0045917761,
-0.0274558403,
0.0102987047,
0.0502868779,
-0.0254401956,
0.006689785,
-0.0496178456,
0.0059104511,
0.0158795919,
0.0087094242,
-0.0267832112,
-0.020834852,
0.0197279248,
-0.0309491549,
0.0005919365,
-0.0123783583,
0.0562112443,
-0.0126622338,
-0.0186014194,
0.0253561754,
-0.0499166176,
-0.0104877148,
-0.0036615131,
-0.051261168,
0.0585531369,
0.0163939074,
0.0127089452,
-0.0141450576,
-0.038567476,
-0.007558661,
0.0539785624,
-0.0210443921,
-0.0004005232,
-0.0025484513,
0.0122520942,
-0.0110259335,
-0.0610941388,
-0.0311098322,
0.0195961017,
-0.035350848,
-0.0428302363,
-0.0402797908,
-0.0325644761,
0.0132998778,
0.0493157543,
-0.0054855873,
0.0065612593,
-0.0305922907,
-0.0221343525,
-0.0223188065,
0.0378147103,
-0.043483872,
0.0071835844,
-0.0531100705,
0.029084906,
0.0378284454,
-0.0300878994,
-0.0019649307,
-0.049361147,
-0.0080199316,
-0.0368178301,
-0.0192032978,
0.0551531762,
0.0136871496,
0.0512862131,
-0.028055232,
-0.0429899767,
0.014787741,
0.0449956022,
0.00222104,
-0.012599933,
0.0660416633,
-0.0107665733,
-0.0380613245,
0.0449919626,
-0.0544737726,
0.0353472345,
0.0164835472,
0.0441959873,
-0.0261734724,
-0.0524447002,
0.0128192836,
0.0032909764,
0.0535977818,
0.0328278877,
0.0317503624,
-0.0449969843,
0.0187278427,
-0.0202392116,
-0.0178599283,
-0.0252806544,
-0.0047657108,
0.0679281354,
-0.0192085449,
0.0020433511,
0.0267178006,
-0.0156056583,
0.039292451,
-0.0515295044,
0.0072415881,
0.0155249713,
-0.0041968212,
0.0111804605,
0.0341981277,
-0.0358006656,
-0.0013201036,
0.0381083637,
0.0647811443,
-0.0788429156,
0.0264207404,
0.0215297434,
0.0174350701,
-0.0382155515,
0.014122338,
-0.0521600246,
-0.014338241,
0.0000671269,
-0.0106194774,
0.0648687184,
-0.0524682477,
0.0432895496,
0.0185544565,
-0.0176991597,
-0.0180989951,
-0.007638854,
0.0193506349,
0.0021742533,
0.0321055874,
0.020780649,
0.023299817,
0.0227778703,
0.0623586774,
-0.0285373684,
0.0457493812,
-0.012930546,
-0.0145847732,
0.0037562328,
0.0044513093,
0.0484436043,
-0.0223994087,
-0.0207312126,
-0.0020483346,
0.0222145785,
-0.0518915616,
0.0509243049,
-0.0422171988,
-0.0275585689,
-0.0000430474,
0.023999244,
0.0904703066,
0.0198913291,
-0.0033651644,
-0.0335746221,
0.0032656351,
0.016606871,
0.0038166968,
-0.0193842947,
-6.212205525e-33,
-0.0250618514,
0.0380243324,
0.0217080843,
-0.0202679168,
-0.0115589639,
0.0038502258,
-0.0173488781,
0.006123127,
-0.0841911137,
0.0063954857,
-0.0383127928,
0.0046218387,
0.0254070219,
0.0240128078,
0.0086989384,
-0.0042821229,
0.0272566136,
0.0369961113,
-0.0180803109,
-0.0092162648,
0.0673545003,
0.0731040537,
0.0919037312,
-0.0259576347,
0.0117416345,
0.0102889137,
0.0542980991,
0.0389235914,
0.0621975176,
0.0461855605,
0.0207022615,
0.0499695763,
0.0341529436,
-0.0336390696,
0.0171914659,
-0.0210122243,
-0.1022192314,
-0.0584764257,
-0.0020793013,
0.0186761282,
0.003405672,
-0.0247769952,
0.0332722664,
-0.0349222049,
0.0230135098,
-0.0105494224,
0.0228937212,
0.0040693618,
-0.0317845345,
-0.0158975199,
-0.0692270398,
0.0187245477,
0.0362434946,
-0.010307502,
0.049346745,
0.097349748,
0.0058453698,
0.0154818967,
-0.0640505925,
-0.0012072916,
-0.047682602,
0.0792787746,
0.0053524002,
0.0225822125,
-0.0381360352,
0.0145694176,
0.018272955,
0.0182526018,
0.0070249685,
-0.0041174637,
0.0583845936,
0.0255868006,
0.0354328528,
0.060984306,
0.0291828196,
-0.037421383,
-0.0409661643,
0.0519130602,
-0.0065218229,
0.0814910382,
0.0103789726,
0.0183719471,
-0.0243718047,
-0.0278564151,
-0.0300738141,
-0.0304768626,
-0.053541068,
-0.0446879938,
0.0060425373,
0.0255680475,
-0.005880971,
0.0171315353,
0.0923844576,
-0.0110281436,
0.0017424307,
0.0124835987,
-0.0146262189,
0.0088275308,
-0.0190985743,
0.048916474,
-0.0466054529,
-0.071133256,
0.0221073106,
0.0184271317,
-0.0206844825,
0.0384765454,
0.0513652712,
0.0407186858,
-0.0656448379,
-0.0236303452,
-0.039906051,
-0.0226325113,
-0.0209362619,
0.0745684132,
-0.0025043024,
0.0465850122,
-0.011769373,
0.0279217884,
0.0313182212,
-0.0276199579,
-0.0274274461,
-0.050268434,
0.0366056301,
0.0077620563,
-0.0035095394,
0.0302424375,
-0.0558704399,
0.0530527271,
0.014306386,
-0.0698117465,
-0.0060873949,
0.0497599319,
2.706e-7,
0.0542572215,
0.0188503396,
0.0041894182,
-0.012858985,
-0.0236520804,
0.0096897772,
-0.0244146977,
0.0264521521,
0.057630498,
0.0417927578,
-0.016808005,
0.0317332149,
0.017606061,
0.0283571593,
-0.0932592005,
-0.0244282018,
-0.0212664753,
0.0093200905,
-0.0052489,
-0.0353200659,
0.0203623418,
0.0734999403,
-0.0179145448,
0.0116905309,
0.0075323526,
-0.0493191332,
0.0957510248,
-0.0266402774,
-0.0194359738,
0.0190698598,
0.0424575284,
0.0495072603,
0.01169449,
0.0019423619,
-0.0163416155,
0.0369351208,
0.0285420865,
0.0288155824,
-0.0226078723,
-0.0542078242,
0.0099302456,
-0.0311562512,
-0.0244519245,
-0.0292346794,
0.0731283203,
-0.0701120719,
-0.0070016459,
0.0272889081,
-0.0349740796,
0.0633286834,
0.0224806853,
-0.0230595898,
-0.0554707274,
0.0221866407,
0.0511016622,
0.0200948846,
-0.0402235612,
-0.0662451312,
-0.0020995438,
-0.0076247524,
-0.0155944675,
0.0058660763,
-0.0279245302,
-0.0566743314,
0.0121326447,
-0.0327812135,
0.0287539158,
2.122263674e-34,
0.0171682164,
0.0178630948,
0.0224575847,
0.0026904587,
0.0102795567,
-0.0317063816,
-0.0165686682,
0.0146923475,
-0.0090042353,
-0.0739890561,
-0.0387739986
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10440v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10440v1 | Perplexed by Quality: A Perplexity-based Method for Adult and Harmful Content Detection in Multilingual Heterogeneous Web Data | 2022-12-20T17:14:45 | 2022-12-20T17:14:45 | Tim Jansen, Yangling Tong, Victoria Zevallos, Pedro Ortiz Suarez | cs.CL | cs.CL | As demand for large corpora increases with the size of current
state-of-the-art language models, using web data as the main part of the
pre-training corpus for these models has become a ubiquitous practice. This, in
turn, has introduced an important challenge for NLP practitioners, as they are
now confronted with the task of developing highly optimized models and
pipelines for pre-processing large quantities of textual data, which implies,
effectively classifying and filtering multilingual, heterogeneous and noisy
data, at web scale. One of the main components of this pre-processing step for
the pre-training corpora of large language models, is the removal of adult and
harmful content. In this paper we explore different methods for detecting adult
and harmful of content in multilingual heterogeneous web data. We first show
how traditional methods in harmful content detection, that seemingly perform
quite well in small and specialized datasets quickly break down when confronted
with heterogeneous noisy web data. We then resort to using a perplexity based
approach but with a twist: Instead of using a so-called "clean" corpus to train
a small language model and then use perplexity so select the documents with low
perplexity, i.e., the documents that resemble this so-called "clean" corpus the
most. We train solely with adult and harmful textual data, and then select the
documents having a perplexity value above a given threshold. This approach will
virtually cluster our documents into two distinct groups, which will greatly
facilitate the choice of the threshold for the perplexity and will also allow
us to obtain higher precision than with the traditional classification methods
for detecting adult and harmful content. | [
0.09435343,
0.0536985211,
-0.0448289327,
0.0267166961,
-0.0422282405,
0.0564996712,
0.0101702595,
0.0299072918,
0.0519846156,
-0.0597867593,
-0.0347691029,
-0.0577478372,
-0.0238804724,
0.0118184555,
-0.0279118661,
-0.0081799095,
0.033928737,
0.0273933541,
0.0192801543,
0.0038583453,
0.0258965604,
0.0229787305,
0.04274166,
-0.0050323349,
-0.0031211658,
-0.0046177786,
0.0481171496,
0.036803294,
-0.0006641475,
-0.0132156461,
0.0486215018,
0.0425810143,
-0.0160908084,
0.050335221,
0.0000018277,
-0.036122676,
-0.0134391319,
0.0039496636,
0.0126656191,
-0.0108002843,
0.0768306404,
0.020265542,
-0.0507067405,
0.0244702902,
-0.0225982573,
0.0033952889,
0.0639717206,
0.0411752127,
0.0991706923,
0.0630936176,
-0.0319743529,
0.0021043271,
-0.0117631685,
0.0296549145,
0.0060397023,
-0.0086481236,
0.0704128966,
0.0023137277,
-0.0156007484,
0.0229036175,
-0.0159838852,
0.0006048235,
-0.0151071567,
-0.0181770902,
-0.0158260521,
-0.0444729999,
0.00641682,
-0.0802289918,
0.0431877449,
0.0536777377,
-0.0815047249,
-0.0264343787,
0.0061401604,
0.0178733338,
-0.0169990677,
0.0149521828,
-0.0188938584,
0.0469758995,
-0.0351185203,
0.0251402799,
0.0056573078,
-0.026852347,
0.0286208782,
0.0933487937,
-0.0145375682,
-0.0060202759,
0.0063657127,
-0.0483186319,
0.0343859009,
-0.0157270003,
-0.0307499468,
-0.0088785579,
0.0625371411,
-0.013744819,
0.0167615078,
0.0322015472,
-0.0554552339,
-0.0670886189,
0.0572585016,
-0.100723885,
-0.0299437568,
0.0046131941,
-0.0189533327,
0.0605014861,
-0.0106668109,
0.0092471046,
0.0012125991,
0.028479632,
-0.0201504454,
-0.0051217335,
0.0005108279,
0.0272025466,
-0.0264695231,
0.0465342738,
0.0096345693,
0.0190378986,
-0.044397343,
0.0362481102,
-0.0420681089,
0.0011697942,
-0.0090010539,
0.027819097,
-0.028664032,
0.0029833762,
0.0142280087,
-0.0202299394,
-0.0302435532,
0.037676204,
-0.03841893,
-0.0403475203,
0.0137069654,
0.0289992951,
0.0121428706,
-0.0483711362,
0.0439226776,
0.0412776507,
0.0214668754,
-0.0138986884,
-0.0328375325,
-0.027005665,
-0.0372976437,
-0.0280324779,
0.0019677917,
-0.0463830046,
-0.007965548,
-0.0136007844,
-0.0062068109,
-0.0467175543,
0.0135959769,
0.0228247978,
-0.0578813143,
0.0491824038,
-0.0256578531,
-0.0215607323,
0.0145589719,
0.0151106408,
-0.0097155487,
0.086060822,
-0.0026036934,
0.0389861763,
0.065825671,
-0.002950106,
-0.0322127864,
0.0430593304,
0.0000372708,
0.0277417749,
-0.0103088059,
0.00350528,
0.0099257678,
-0.03419118,
-0.0124318572,
0.0233131927,
-0.0229193065,
-0.023870565,
0.0306932572,
0.0364495739,
-0.0272226948,
0.0493404269,
0.0213360861,
0.0323586576,
-0.02491723,
0.0162287205,
-0.0650204569,
-0.0312540531,
-0.0157260578,
-0.0549360923,
0.0186150447,
0.0960064679,
-0.0099515524,
-0.0260821674,
-0.0098007182,
-0.0250920616,
0.0730478987,
-0.0328322835,
0.0664906278,
0.0395141728,
-0.0344978683,
0.0096551757,
0.0591146089,
-0.0546794944,
0.0392631739,
-0.0447485633,
0.0030547571,
0.0547146685,
0.0529430099,
-0.0343047008,
-0.0141538214,
-0.0408296809,
0.0130028296,
-0.025669951,
-0.0307587609,
0.0110245571,
-0.0077451523,
-0.0476703867,
-0.0572301298,
0.02361493,
0.007514914,
-0.0163524207,
0.0265849158,
0.0203373842,
0.022715373,
0.0004519713,
-0.0329328477,
0.0324971564,
0.0064683743,
0.0157575533,
0.0146555603,
0.0472601838,
0.0796345025,
0.0022736501,
-0.0290867127,
-0.0329226293,
0.038528733,
-0.0132311573,
-0.0089462558,
-0.042661678,
0.0305525176,
-0.0331146196,
0.0547259003,
-0.0480439961,
-0.0017891856,
0.0560688451,
-0.0034449508,
0.0261319168,
0.0415268689,
-0.072716333,
0.019660037,
-0.0548777655,
0.0227361955,
-0.0386420377,
0.0063685011,
-0.0222417749,
0.0733086094,
-0.0101562431,
0.0325563662,
-0.0106244488,
-0.0485533737,
0.0227913931,
0.0330585912,
-0.0525269061,
-0.0311603863,
-0.0548087023,
0.0341207236,
0.0389429554,
0.0397120342,
-0.0173247773,
-0.0572813824,
-0.0455398895,
-0.0293928254,
-0.0135196093,
0.0030606547,
0.0240489785,
0.0100945244,
0.0103899771,
-0.0082663912,
-0.0292824358,
-0.0225118399,
0.0125467042,
0.0510771871,
0.0087888166,
-0.0448311418,
-0.0326065198,
0.0161235202,
-0.0101348339,
0.0068126782,
0.0516324118,
0.0188593231,
-0.0493878424,
0.0098532457,
0.0378851779,
-0.0731210783,
0.0081714233,
0.0001450766,
-0.0556705594,
-0.0164810754,
-0.0121620195,
-0.0389418676,
0.0369983427,
0.0430326574,
0.0564955287,
0.0186208058,
0.0130880587,
-0.0130129959,
-0.0210795496,
-0.0100045335,
0.0263597332,
-0.0170588791,
-0.0384753011,
0.0318416357,
-0.0198796149,
-0.0143337958,
-0.0123455245,
-0.0294954423,
0.0565659441,
-0.0316508748,
-0.0081385626,
-0.018279653,
-0.0555506647,
-0.0013569194,
0.0167125873,
-0.0315920077,
-0.0476294383,
0.042010773,
0.0376328863,
0.0354451723,
-0.0700205937,
-0.0043062367,
-0.0009800731,
0.0371927842,
-0.0337206461,
0.0928980485,
-0.0307496767,
-0.0521903932,
-0.0371405333,
0.0341219194,
0.0511486679,
-0.0394896716,
0.0289079119,
-0.0046374425,
0.0084820557,
0.0134859169,
-0.0605407879,
-0.0631663129,
-0.0652975217,
0.0012316968,
-0.0581091978,
0.0579403453,
0.0113812787,
-0.0447338931,
0.0240677502,
-0.0004524688,
-0.0174677446,
-0.0116725294,
0.0077223489,
0.0242952406,
0.0144544737,
0.0104086418,
-0.0218921881,
0.0130274268,
0.0018108174,
-0.0156109789,
0.1034411564,
-0.0240158457,
-0.0501642115,
0.0507993214,
0.0365114734,
0.0374527499,
-0.0093410425,
-0.023745494,
-0.0176920723,
-0.0143417874,
-0.0178146623,
-0.0245453045,
0.0716663897,
0.0469335504,
-0.0481090359,
-0.0133346058,
0.0035972684,
-0.024088284,
0.011610006,
-0.0169579051,
-0.057179261,
0.0034783778,
-0.0119419023,
-0.0369855724,
-0.0363138989,
-0.0364739113,
0.0083570853,
-0.0748020783,
0.0270540826,
0.0338132158,
-0.048593428,
-0.0445266291,
-0.052590929,
-0.0101088975,
0.015477268,
-0.0156851839,
-0.0313010216,
0.0002656487,
-0.0385033898,
-0.0152990799,
0.0169070754,
-0.0647009164,
0.0125000626,
-0.0363617763,
0.0183203537,
0.0225668084,
0.0697982311,
-0.0471444838,
-0.0399391688,
0.0335459597,
-0.0034565546,
-0.0469303168,
-0.030968735,
0.0517935269,
0.0067803888,
-0.0343522765,
-0.0362383276,
0.0110874884,
0.0178166702,
-0.0072587943,
-0.017856067,
0.0641343147,
0.0068026134,
0.000724975,
-0.0320454128,
0.010505924,
0.0160600115,
0.0709504411,
-0.0024745199,
-0.0851490647,
0.0043019177,
-0.0333278589,
-0.0008277232,
0.0090113198,
-0.0028770894,
-0.0024383743,
-0.0157284066,
-0.0371297076,
-0.0753964111,
0.0277914908,
0.0273059383,
-0.0071561155,
0.0424914956,
-0.0016685992,
0.0140382694,
0.0034939968,
-0.042469658,
-0.0140677122,
0.02905377,
0.008679715,
-0.071761407,
-0.0071138479,
-0.0172089171,
-0.0391792245,
-0.018527016,
-0.0102951964,
-0.0566861033,
-0.0271734465,
0.0268697031,
0.0257276818,
0.015294984,
0.0034118297,
-0.0372405089,
-0.0503846779,
0.0244957134,
0.0396103337,
-0.056965284,
-0.0596961267,
0.0581518039,
-0.0001401448,
0.0096739372,
0.0568334647,
-0.0355055407,
0.0137768211,
0.0416512378,
-0.0572933517,
-0.0524923652,
-0.0114048524,
0.0155323585,
0.0425235219,
-0.0135859903,
-0.0147394473,
-0.0043354155,
-0.0267876908,
-0.0022619972,
0.0029384289,
-0.0271015652,
-0.021792857,
0.0240347404,
0.043878153,
-0.0199736487,
-0.0356517732,
0.0589549951,
-0.0480013676,
0.0333863162,
-0.042922277,
-0.0224685613,
-0.0143466583,
-0.0077653294,
0.0284578055,
0.009909926,
-0.0190334599,
-0.0074242172,
0.0400018916,
0.0016573196,
-0.0327965207,
0.0054686861,
0.0099750357,
0.0030096113,
-0.0190705061,
0.0482609086,
-0.0130830482,
0.0066712592,
-0.0419404134,
-0.0496324599,
0.0119765438,
-0.0182927493,
0.0383686572,
-0.0213099532,
-0.0333588906,
-0.0147231147,
-0.0036206511,
0.006113471,
-0.0688623935,
-0.0141532524,
0.0002467267,
-0.0261302833,
0.0151908183,
0.0715967044,
-0.0262067523,
0.0082102325,
0.0642893687,
-0.0307685714,
-0.0249137394,
0.0029649215,
0.0189348441,
0.0653208047,
-0.0280161966,
0.0319840014,
-0.0313582495,
-0.0584926791,
-0.0222072117,
-0.069885619,
0.0109288199,
0.0101835318,
0.0159052555,
0.0773839578,
0.0129875224,
0.0159352757,
-0.024631273,
-0.0081803082,
0.0150356544,
-0.0280712638,
-0.0177598931,
-5.741826318e-33,
0.0479452722,
-0.0286913645,
-0.0528200567,
0.009618504,
0.0180240758,
-0.0347717665,
0.0247753616,
-0.0189270061,
-0.0267489515,
0.0093727913,
0.0034722334,
0.01871101,
-0.0064818598,
0.0056112371,
-0.0152777713,
-0.0210076421,
0.0480938368,
-0.0061506983,
-0.021570025,
0.030205803,
0.0204552654,
0.0259506907,
0.0553764962,
-0.0951539055,
0.0214636941,
0.0183722861,
-0.0610474907,
0.0125005497,
0.015513761,
0.0548538528,
-0.0093920399,
0.0405736268,
0.0242341906,
0.0160444155,
0.0045904317,
0.0191454366,
-0.0167555772,
-0.0063168514,
0.0062465952,
0.0307548735,
0.0397979394,
-0.0065946225,
0.0422294252,
-0.0125416443,
0.0110713262,
-0.0206821114,
0.0492082424,
-0.0362303294,
-0.0161413532,
-0.0272626113,
-0.025574971,
0.0314622372,
-0.0300032627,
-0.0156082185,
0.0163746737,
0.0578825958,
-0.0058073276,
0.0331636816,
-0.0438513197,
0.052981969,
0.0310723241,
-0.0084075164,
-0.0139848571,
-0.0465669334,
0.0146756014,
0.086531572,
0.02073575,
0.0480810776,
-0.0156404004,
-0.0028923091,
0.0382423103,
0.0444491841,
0.0156243453,
0.0484228767,
0.0582494661,
-0.0307511538,
-0.1154685691,
0.011305118,
0.0039475397,
0.0418939032,
0.0001763147,
-0.0421379171,
-0.0609820709,
-0.0251261313,
0.0066573648,
-0.0216655191,
-0.0342839323,
-0.01966656,
-0.0089213597,
-0.0265280902,
-0.0950511619,
-0.0206940901,
-0.0318609513,
-0.0618718676,
-0.0527360067,
0.0113746542,
-0.0169834737,
0.0046093469,
0.0390150212,
0.0304371957,
-0.0022884072,
-0.011540534,
0.0191233307,
-0.0644998252,
0.0146852648,
-0.0080284942,
0.0561511032,
0.0280495808,
-0.0927525908,
0.0178277958,
-0.0139753018,
0.0329503864,
0.0425880291,
0.0756625235,
-0.0042943917,
0.0212763604,
0.0002305871,
0.0246194229,
0.0951931179,
0.0421772338,
-0.029395109,
-0.0153540848,
-0.0024504745,
0.0121107316,
0.0045592021,
-0.0361895412,
-0.0217892434,
-0.0096712634,
0.0584592968,
-0.1096101627,
0.006227389,
-0.013235556,
2.628e-7,
0.0233709589,
0.0612946972,
0.0046127359,
-0.0008157514,
0.0332867429,
0.0356604755,
0.0199578945,
0.0228618607,
0.0003528317,
0.0059627779,
-0.0127790011,
0.0023240738,
0.0348836929,
0.0449846052,
-0.0456490554,
-0.0002284026,
-0.0400521234,
0.0059038452,
-0.0429592393,
0.0089356266,
0.017403001,
0.1144855767,
0.0324249938,
-0.072635971,
-0.0004473462,
-0.0382421277,
0.0304267649,
-0.0313095041,
-0.0099058766,
0.0002351764,
0.0342995301,
0.0108644124,
0.0144025479,
0.0411785357,
-0.0364397727,
0.007862865,
0.0317885056,
0.0411722437,
-0.0082276836,
0.0139994891,
0.0110114235,
-0.048396118,
0.0029885983,
-0.0469588451,
0.1128277555,
0.0263599083,
0.0041958364,
0.0094546825,
-0.0481740683,
-0.05001707,
0.0733721629,
-0.0800112113,
-0.0330590606,
0.0477866977,
0.0289944485,
-0.01199493,
0.0070605474,
-0.0405094624,
0.0336654261,
-0.0321601778,
-0.0238113664,
-0.029473383,
0.0145267835,
0.0039075925,
0.066043213,
-0.0167478807,
0.0760918334,
2.577570289e-34,
0.0549693108,
-0.0514893346,
0.0128246341,
-0.0050039398,
-0.0003475131,
0.01974052,
0.0193237439,
-0.0059558628,
-0.0099275382,
-0.0136154452,
0.0151895359
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10423v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10423v1 | Fine-Grained Distillation for Long Document Retrieval | 2022-12-20T17:00:36 | 2022-12-20T17:00:36 | Yucheng Zhou, Tao Shen, Xiubo Geng, Chongyang Tao, Guodong Long, Can Xu, Daxin Jiang | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Long document retrieval aims to fetch query-relevant documents from a
large-scale collection, where knowledge distillation has become de facto to
improve a retriever by mimicking a heterogeneous yet powerful cross-encoder.
However, in contrast to passages or sentences, retrieval on long documents
suffers from the scope hypothesis that a long document may cover multiple
topics. This maximizes their structure heterogeneity and poses a
granular-mismatch issue, leading to an inferior distillation efficacy. In this
work, we propose a new learning framework, fine-grained distillation (FGD), for
long-document retrievers. While preserving the conventional dense retrieval
paradigm, it first produces global-consistent representations crossing
different fine granularity and then applies multi-granular aligned distillation
merely during training. In experiments, we evaluate our framework on two
long-document retrieval benchmarks, which show state-of-the-art performance. | [
0.017253831,
0.0222227275,
0.0038995803,
0.0290991813,
0.0149125112,
0.0240283161,
-0.0357122421,
0.0220603477,
-0.0294299647,
0.001803075,
-0.0137934042,
-0.0049527404,
-0.0192137733,
0.037962269,
-0.0155721651,
-0.0587346219,
0.0251049846,
0.0062785712,
0.0268225353,
-0.0073912302,
0.0207246263,
0.0093768016,
0.036357075,
-0.0277811643,
0.0265289862,
0.0007304994,
-0.05779716,
0.0026302743,
-0.0008777659,
-0.0081450203,
0.049243208,
-0.0031117885,
0.0705274418,
0.0176070314,
0.0000018859,
-0.0196496379,
-0.0306800902,
0.0110748177,
0.0044201692,
0.0139890583,
-0.0025357583,
-0.0617580302,
0.0679030195,
-0.0453200676,
-0.0080101388,
-0.0160492007,
-0.0119120823,
0.0911102742,
0.0482180566,
0.0619764067,
-0.0205297507,
-0.0610655621,
0.0554965399,
-0.0563939102,
0.0543244965,
-0.0659731328,
0.0213720128,
0.0288099945,
0.017477043,
0.0580102988,
-0.0515339039,
0.0197320618,
0.0008052455,
0.0304995179,
0.0206963681,
0.0192995425,
-0.0341834985,
0.0156572368,
0.0466820598,
0.0719869211,
-0.0188283864,
0.0298687257,
0.0255348496,
-0.0109389434,
-0.019479733,
-0.0052947192,
-0.0585586876,
-0.0385280028,
-0.0434208773,
0.0219841208,
-0.0272925477,
0.0084460517,
-0.0045207446,
0.0067126788,
-0.0475308038,
-0.0269405954,
-0.0134490952,
-0.0306197647,
0.0100811245,
0.024683021,
0.0202809684,
0.0238264278,
0.0224094987,
0.01467585,
0.0053091617,
-0.0337940827,
0.0136416107,
-0.0168108325,
0.0508354343,
0.0176702943,
-0.0079997843,
0.0147045022,
-0.0176666081,
0.0674532354,
-0.0224361233,
0.0265648048,
-0.0443258956,
0.0128344335,
-0.0387084074,
-0.0527901463,
-0.069516331,
0.0111572817,
-0.0394472331,
0.0405090787,
-0.0188876726,
-0.0359539948,
-0.0236520134,
-0.0004984902,
-0.0218254495,
-0.0090723466,
0.0138484258,
0.0199922547,
-0.0325416736,
-0.0233473461,
-0.0186064467,
0.0824246258,
-0.0716100335,
0.0017956174,
0.012984978,
0.010888339,
-0.0336852856,
-0.007304112,
0.0360391997,
-0.0320882201,
0.025169,
-0.0275034383,
-0.0368490852,
-0.0397872701,
-0.031260293,
-0.0345266238,
-0.035208758,
-0.0659194216,
0.0125478227,
-0.0595890209,
0.0736312866,
-0.0069963955,
0.0143180452,
-0.0232222062,
-0.0080588711,
-0.0171640161,
-0.0418024175,
0.0298943073,
0.0293919761,
-0.0080765933,
0.0248535126,
0.0260765757,
0.0354772881,
0.0779266953,
-0.0350798257,
0.0768918842,
0.0197372586,
0.0124319149,
-0.0025108657,
-0.0220989417,
0.0439180993,
0.0295519177,
0.004821802,
0.0150196804,
-0.0218805131,
0.0153198084,
0.0538671911,
0.0442298539,
-0.0698568076,
-0.0414015837,
0.0038275619,
0.0011479025,
0.0502367057,
0.0102719115,
0.0001366151,
0.0261023212,
-0.0456350967,
0.0451079346,
0.0116519528,
0.0326883681,
0.003393498,
0.0223055966,
0.0815494582,
0.0217139684,
-0.0770986229,
-0.005882463,
0.0237380918,
0.0055207075,
0.0097867129,
0.0161965359,
0.0585347675,
0.017044913,
0.0119365687,
0.0576828867,
0.0425248444,
-0.0241842493,
0.0275954492,
0.0044588647,
0.0416873619,
0.0741883591,
0.0323103145,
-0.0386788212,
0.0103888735,
-0.0130682979,
0.0356656127,
-0.0186988022,
0.0294306949,
-0.0293391682,
0.045794066,
-0.0530063845,
-0.0592768677,
-0.0498591922,
-0.0079190079,
0.0050525265,
0.0246278718,
0.0811841115,
0.0597585477,
-0.0845911279,
0.059271764,
0.0090018716,
-0.0303557571,
-0.0490880087,
0.0041312547,
0.017287802,
-0.0109287575,
-0.0127809243,
-0.0310079735,
-0.0234093629,
0.0491767861,
-0.0542076565,
-0.0355281457,
-0.0908180028,
-0.0180531219,
-0.0276142266,
0.0057660108,
-0.0367021412,
0.0170363132,
-0.0154303554,
-0.0397523195,
-0.0283616241,
-0.0150600374,
0.006332282,
0.0136530781,
-0.035643667,
-0.006278689,
-0.0101960422,
0.0378800593,
-0.0430794843,
0.0333726481,
-0.022082191,
0.0164548568,
-0.0427388623,
-0.0506577864,
0.0200956576,
-0.0357841849,
-0.0206025373,
0.0438682772,
-0.0031488582,
0.0343016163,
0.0471261553,
-0.0170086958,
-0.0239207372,
-0.0517852567,
-0.0590126775,
0.0190675575,
-0.0401415676,
-0.0124466326,
-0.006299478,
0.0283745825,
0.0028178107,
-0.033201497,
-0.0452537388,
-0.008309219,
-0.0128972791,
0.0316886678,
0.0142490845,
0.0237293318,
0.0270351656,
0.0055389171,
-0.0596050918,
0.044690486,
0.0284970067,
-0.0870765373,
-0.0138574261,
-0.0305837821,
-0.0343024246,
-0.0272332262,
-0.0049132258,
-0.0300630126,
0.0262865201,
-0.0023720786,
-0.0608257689,
0.0003454625,
0.0470688678,
0.0156256091,
0.0081690978,
0.008076448,
-0.0264430214,
-0.0874536335,
0.0186501127,
-0.0349887609,
0.0055990876,
-0.017009737,
-0.004052694,
-0.0176912844,
0.0074262558,
-0.016206108,
0.0198724288,
-0.0228943061,
-0.0137881413,
0.0272521451,
0.0041534845,
-0.0485209413,
0.0097164083,
0.0322327204,
0.0097552594,
-0.031508144,
-0.0345575809,
0.0666729361,
0.0093445331,
-0.0005878513,
-0.0008154719,
-0.0104240719,
-0.0569120347,
0.0728680268,
-0.0329639465,
-0.0045681288,
0.0084361881,
-0.0149289137,
-0.0116341366,
-0.0037923937,
0.0000411527,
-0.0365582593,
0.05882686,
0.0254038814,
0.0221098885,
-0.0149989706,
-0.0641215518,
-0.0023225255,
-0.0327406749,
0.0486683361,
0.0284701493,
0.013154909,
0.0006057859,
-0.0542163253,
0.0041408441,
0.0125219589,
0.0269064475,
-0.0402396955,
-0.0168029722,
-0.0185676012,
0.07354597,
0.0583991967,
-0.0202780217,
-0.0250848066,
-0.0503101535,
-0.0044149468,
0.0416050926,
-0.0160390213,
-0.0331453905,
-0.0085273674,
0.0175267607,
0.0452996232,
0.0090496028,
-0.0101466598,
-0.0420660563,
0.0524064228,
-0.0500597581,
-0.0137791922,
0.0499397032,
-0.0036830525,
-0.0496432818,
-0.0386673138,
-0.0006138455,
0.0678142831,
0.0106832217,
0.0382292531,
-0.072976917,
-0.0257120188,
0.0021514732,
0.0381809808,
0.0529353097,
-0.015884649,
0.0254340619,
-0.0480727144,
0.0279608481,
0.0151379723,
0.0118888933,
-0.0681974664,
-0.0540848412,
0.0008446511,
-0.0120148268,
-0.0012643692,
0.0287555456,
-0.0381349958,
-0.0324747041,
-0.0012608205,
0.0281706136,
-0.0291985124,
0.0075064236,
-0.0140740434,
-0.0425946154,
0.0177170653,
0.0160596557,
0.0309736654,
-0.0479728021,
-0.0124855526,
-0.0690809861,
-0.0001695763,
0.0081342757,
0.0962129757,
-0.027497774,
-0.0032668638,
0.0124547714,
0.0030757969,
-0.0307010505,
-0.0067373589,
0.0017680452,
0.0461713038,
-0.0172908008,
-0.0209370386,
-0.0437405631,
-0.0614683181,
0.0065511162,
0.0485090055,
-0.0063157543,
0.0250749532,
-0.0721068829,
0.0014296727,
-0.0253076106,
0.0138655724,
0.0400071703,
0.0152840372,
-0.0372835249,
0.0095882583,
-0.0271364953,
-0.043377094,
0.0032267848,
0.0291357804,
-0.0408554487,
0.0034880533,
-0.0045124595,
0.0034669219,
-0.0657479689,
0.0086677754,
-0.0273874067,
0.0041728769,
-0.0107559487,
-0.0115888109,
0.0231006853,
-0.0125456322,
-0.0001181001,
0.0137056326,
-0.0871141106,
-0.0513946228,
-0.0132694589,
-0.0229625497,
0.0058329478,
0.0944909379,
-0.0023042418,
-0.0467172116,
0.1215700284,
0.0230756607,
-0.0539196841,
0.0104044639,
0.0159278307,
-0.020497743,
-0.0080899615,
0.0295851417,
-0.0549444929,
0.0406641662,
-0.029237397,
0.0292918365,
-0.0313261561,
-0.0048782104,
0.0006594816,
-0.002753682,
0.0236579105,
0.033688724,
0.0268153977,
-0.0321200714,
0.0225311909,
0.0211361591,
-0.0132591482,
-0.0072979382,
-0.0215549618,
0.0470518544,
-0.0556941144,
-0.0024493048,
0.1055230126,
0.0281568076,
0.042175252,
-0.095600836,
-0.0132721802,
-0.0374255776,
-0.0130868126,
0.0196092501,
-0.0023396513,
-0.0102689443,
0.0407742895,
0.0021555324,
0.0632726476,
-0.039785888,
0.0305358935,
0.0226051081,
0.0546385683,
-0.0757713467,
0.0099932048,
-0.0971280634,
-0.0472290516,
-0.0236804802,
-0.0135135986,
0.0113511393,
-0.0377149396,
0.0185022093,
0.0303139091,
-0.0351568088,
-0.0291463304,
-0.018154148,
-0.0212454069,
0.0120939761,
-0.0307973884,
0.0541885309,
-0.0152170062,
0.0258380976,
0.082471028,
-0.0168637764,
0.0297921263,
-0.0281303693,
0.0065737935,
-0.028462695,
-0.0335524306,
0.0419427156,
0.057630986,
0.0056459233,
-0.0281492304,
-0.0000543362,
0.0027413052,
0.0132230911,
-0.042747952,
-0.0104601011,
0.0045333137,
0.0483521484,
0.0749987066,
0.0075306706,
-0.0211038496,
-0.0307396147,
-0.021202568,
0.0068483828,
-0.0120012155,
0.0168918222,
-6.614675689e-33,
0.0173291657,
0.0556182861,
0.008100885,
-0.0137975458,
-0.061938297,
0.0114434687,
-0.0103115868,
-0.0206548497,
-0.0035612092,
0.0380769521,
-0.0185959619,
0.0409179591,
0.0172257647,
0.0306386612,
0.0149037484,
-0.0044198576,
0.0931263417,
0.0224641804,
-0.0041522742,
0.077507861,
0.0593042634,
0.0658582598,
0.0022371546,
-0.0444995835,
-0.0022740345,
0.0013700564,
0.0168519989,
-0.0142327826,
0.0650567487,
0.0404625013,
-0.0188099556,
0.030178383,
0.042980019,
-0.0267872643,
-0.0392588936,
0.0118199214,
-0.1061257794,
-0.0074133067,
-0.0514354967,
-0.0297739133,
-0.0267179124,
-0.0208774097,
0.0403470621,
-0.0382667445,
0.0357636996,
-0.039597109,
0.0350783244,
-0.0027319083,
-0.0361111388,
-0.0727949366,
-0.0231124423,
0.0189624596,
-0.02567566,
-0.0214304216,
0.0406193286,
-0.0185199305,
0.0289628077,
0.0754400268,
-0.0373499729,
0.0089154858,
-0.0316456035,
0.05764658,
-0.0239368044,
-0.0208233278,
-0.0190507062,
0.0719950721,
0.0061714333,
0.0336690918,
-0.005783875,
-0.0470482521,
0.0409435667,
0.0448472202,
-0.0323427916,
0.0288577117,
0.0993725061,
-0.0491791852,
-0.0524096228,
0.0407673344,
-0.024549745,
0.063836731,
0.0049939067,
0.0444754213,
-0.0089464132,
-0.0081435554,
-0.0242003128,
0.0152284987,
-0.0118860109,
0.0193075109,
0.0100153387,
0.0721721947,
0.0145289097,
-0.006270071,
0.0577445701,
-0.029548483,
0.014322212,
0.074418582,
-0.0414513014,
-0.0091362763,
0.0409825779,
-0.0170667805,
-0.033125177,
-0.0468011461,
0.0382568203,
-0.0246258955,
-0.0355099924,
-0.0049652685,
0.0584242754,
-0.0175714288,
-0.0650448948,
-0.0037356711,
-0.0116883731,
-0.006002978,
-0.0166889299,
0.0358454697,
0.0172836967,
0.0291795731,
-0.0085884435,
0.0582345463,
0.0277029406,
0.0249179546,
-0.0057214433,
-0.0423725769,
0.0510161519,
0.0096104788,
0.0154615967,
0.0242872238,
-0.0368728265,
-0.033878386,
0.0404471941,
-0.0579870716,
0.0071903383,
0.0443863198,
2.602e-7,
0.01222343,
0.0137130339,
0.0586255006,
-0.019710809,
0.0099746827,
-0.0049261078,
-0.0016610485,
0.0550473742,
-0.0290611386,
-0.0659079626,
-0.0006387977,
0.0472567417,
0.0480270348,
0.0200183094,
-0.0878214538,
0.0501296185,
-0.013276306,
-0.0502926335,
-0.0309187584,
-0.0479222722,
0.0160045587,
0.0641282573,
0.0034157827,
0.0020754945,
0.0550009981,
-0.0229601655,
0.0780438706,
0.0166565124,
0.0286718011,
0.0335290618,
0.0122942766,
0.0065240343,
0.0067221504,
-0.0152420877,
0.0000953793,
0.0494874679,
0.0249930229,
0.0556113869,
-0.0019544838,
-0.0234891009,
-0.0106552942,
-0.0209096372,
-0.006369404,
-0.0185605362,
0.0689284429,
-0.0293710064,
-0.0052013285,
-0.0249099303,
-0.0379985906,
0.0233558565,
0.0519507565,
0.0102820266,
0.0169791281,
0.0589299165,
-0.0005949132,
0.0248099156,
-0.0147925802,
-0.0830185264,
0.0278115589,
0.0218322799,
-0.0279624853,
-0.0144599089,
-0.0181413144,
-0.0379248112,
0.0137924133,
-0.0411601216,
-0.0078702364,
2.019087413e-34,
0.0445769802,
0.0040928782,
-0.0068887421,
-0.0267997943,
0.0036972051,
-0.0274301432,
-0.0819397196,
0.0025374491,
-0.0157969799,
-0.0668503344,
-0.0236973688
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10422v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10422v3 | Localising In-Domain Adaptation of Transformer-Based Biomedical Language Models | 2022-12-20T16:59:56 | 2023-06-28T08:36:20 | Tommaso Mario Buonocore, Claudio Crema, Alberto Redolfi, Riccardo Bellazzi, Enea Parimbelli | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, I.2.7; J.3 | In the era of digital healthcare, the huge volumes of textual information
generated every day in hospitals constitute an essential but underused asset
that could be exploited with task-specific, fine-tuned biomedical language
representation models, improving patient care and management. For such
specialized domains, previous research has shown that fine-tuning models
stemming from broad-coverage checkpoints can largely benefit additional
training rounds over large-scale in-domain resources. However, these resources
are often unreachable for less-resourced languages like Italian, preventing
local medical institutions to employ in-domain adaptation. In order to reduce
this gap, our work investigates two accessible approaches to derive biomedical
language models in languages other than English, taking Italian as a concrete
use-case: one based on neural machine translation of English resources,
favoring quantity over quality; the other based on a high-grade, narrow-scoped
corpus natively written in Italian, thus preferring quality over quantity. Our
study shows that data quantity is a harder constraint than data quality for
biomedical adaptation, but the concatenation of high-quality data can improve
model performance even when dealing with relatively size-limited corpora. The
models published from our investigations have the potential to unlock important
research opportunities for Italian hospitals and academia. Finally, the set of
lessons learned from the study constitutes valuable insights towards a solution
to build biomedical language models that are generalizable to other
less-resourced languages and different domain settings. | [
0.0406926945,
0.0715039149,
-0.0155475475,
-0.0121364035,
0.0061387802,
0.0198190622,
0.015684966,
0.0339104421,
-0.0363435671,
0.0157851595,
-0.0368745998,
-0.0646806136,
0.0321457312,
0.0234654713,
0.0191977099,
-0.0490404516,
0.0576522201,
0.0086909132,
-0.0280472878,
-0.0069559333,
-0.0209422484,
-0.0076587996,
-0.0075525488,
0.0457453728,
0.0326152705,
0.0327828191,
0.0392924137,
0.0118301595,
0.0203616247,
-0.0345639884,
-0.0002877268,
0.0286749676,
0.0132252006,
0.0084951334,
0.0000017168,
-0.0236025751,
-0.035854511,
0.0239488259,
-0.0218463857,
-0.0248488113,
0.0457102656,
-0.097932823,
-0.0219073445,
0.0067523164,
-0.01927929,
-0.0239396635,
0.0547956526,
0.0045025861,
0.005539997,
0.0906220302,
-0.0226869639,
0.0174119156,
0.005817384,
-0.057813514,
-0.0379477292,
-0.034558598,
0.0089020776,
-0.0185338017,
0.0403605998,
0.0057017752,
-0.0098849358,
0.0827761292,
0.0022237389,
0.0315691121,
-0.0344549976,
0.0237067081,
-0.0132049406,
-0.0120250965,
0.0016753206,
0.0398718305,
-0.0386373661,
-0.0234822072,
0.0162929501,
0.0052110944,
0.0097749736,
0.0118132913,
-0.0417667441,
-0.0072137332,
-0.021340007,
0.0101435212,
0.0037787694,
-0.0081526116,
0.0513958819,
0.0014932046,
-0.0326480903,
-0.0185673442,
0.0214761812,
-0.0292222481,
0.0156736076,
0.0167346317,
-0.0140408194,
0.0035654304,
0.0526449643,
0.0402704738,
-0.0249379836,
0.0172942709,
-0.04396303,
-0.022722695,
0.0661011264,
-0.0551754907,
0.0224717893,
0.00981862,
-0.0204409659,
0.0249165799,
0.0075977612,
-0.0026895727,
-0.0689975396,
0.0186550133,
-0.062653698,
-0.0184798371,
-0.0537247434,
0.0161320884,
-0.0359552465,
-0.0143867293,
-0.0486736633,
0.0081563853,
-0.0651615709,
-0.0013492054,
0.0189399868,
-0.0049593491,
0.0388516784,
0.0125612132,
-0.0650661141,
0.0016530054,
0.0213187337,
0.0696879327,
-0.00007498,
0.0034255807,
-0.0340971239,
-0.0843688026,
-0.0034851574,
-0.0039348328,
-0.0032784299,
-0.0204894636,
0.0150264492,
0.0524708144,
0.0199924819,
-0.0137641029,
0.0018304442,
0.0155956997,
-0.0459979996,
-0.0328018256,
0.0168313403,
-0.061263606,
0.0477094725,
0.0035147392,
0.0465286784,
-0.0846817642,
-0.0158597697,
0.0033626391,
-0.0471832268,
0.0592508055,
-0.0579295531,
0.00814767,
0.0272848178,
0.0119312052,
0.0120122796,
0.0392061807,
0.0537918545,
-0.0522035323,
-0.0134585472,
-0.0156604853,
-0.0181501713,
0.038198933,
0.0463989377,
-0.0147034889,
-0.0124368956,
-0.0066193421,
0.0118488204,
0.0763546601,
-0.0036972952,
0.0656994581,
0.0118453121,
0.0142670497,
0.0399729535,
0.0299558155,
0.0577988401,
0.0034742453,
0.0262134764,
-0.037319351,
-0.0222914219,
-0.0400814302,
-0.0026031118,
-0.020654479,
0.0424787812,
-0.0166157931,
-0.0288904738,
0.0239568148,
-0.0276735034,
-0.0377769396,
-0.0265634358,
-0.0106649036,
-0.0119299814,
0.0023091319,
0.0721779689,
0.0135251172,
-0.0286869686,
0.0664630905,
0.0576312579,
-0.0344046243,
0.0364947096,
-0.0482901074,
-0.027981665,
0.076468505,
0.0488193557,
-0.0227434337,
-0.0268252604,
-0.0075180754,
0.0296050757,
0.0287604406,
0.0457168072,
0.0066882372,
0.020249689,
-0.0562493056,
0.0002406087,
0.0457936265,
0.0121085877,
-0.0115699563,
0.0004366548,
0.0497700609,
-0.009578215,
-0.0444484986,
-0.0511606112,
0.0341523886,
-0.0757766515,
0.0179763865,
0.0113272937,
-0.0017374527,
-0.0012006919,
-0.0034460523,
-0.0224426333,
0.0150238266,
0.0221535563,
-0.0556457005,
-0.0198091306,
0.0000548924,
-0.0286194477,
-0.0023748756,
0.0088682007,
-0.0299175363,
0.0369681232,
-0.0356552787,
-0.0333035439,
-0.0207771063,
-0.011417632,
-0.0589573421,
0.0015044329,
0.0271609724,
0.0337432288,
-0.0089545054,
0.0412789732,
-0.0532316864,
-0.0052965279,
-0.0225469898,
0.0156537723,
0.0245668739,
-0.045643881,
0.0315759592,
-0.036969725,
-0.0393438824,
0.0421031341,
-0.0150431441,
0.0272379108,
-0.0061332481,
0.0172715709,
0.0093084248,
-0.0210692361,
-0.0947018415,
0.0030786616,
0.0175714195,
0.0217389185,
0.0412160493,
0.060216669,
-0.0004377381,
-0.0253422391,
-0.024050571,
-0.0280762948,
0.0009965581,
0.0148567604,
0.017113423,
0.0242958236,
0.0091842525,
-0.0262185223,
-0.0137484418,
-0.0186682288,
0.0143811721,
0.0001016928,
-0.0699599534,
-0.0452229977,
0.0000267503,
-0.0042996323,
0.0121012088,
-0.0044436427,
-0.0315762386,
0.0068484619,
0.0024396814,
0.00458166,
0.0482049659,
-0.0234195739,
-0.0033818893,
0.0356259793,
0.0068013421,
-0.0311337151,
0.0154312318,
-0.0211601816,
-0.0457455106,
-0.044127278,
-0.0571022443,
0.0302928966,
0.0878020078,
-0.0049685948,
0.0013508216,
-0.0561362095,
-0.0262886807,
-0.0630248487,
0.0274389442,
-0.0100249629,
0.0647496209,
-0.0284024905,
0.0639203042,
0.0071662744,
-0.0224245656,
0.0872397423,
-0.0024204212,
0.057297729,
-0.0943916962,
-0.0292928051,
-0.019171508,
-0.022809295,
-0.014583542,
0.0325635932,
0.0093197217,
-0.0190300643,
-0.0294174217,
0.0245721117,
-0.0207748041,
-0.0682445243,
0.06400574,
-0.0431257449,
0.0069635282,
0.0067916592,
-0.0456328541,
-0.015580765,
0.005976439,
-0.0155375851,
0.0110736648,
0.017835062,
-0.0153794037,
-0.0787480101,
0.0335802659,
0.0052802968,
0.1339776069,
0.0140494909,
-0.0119087882,
0.0130392564,
-0.0091021685,
0.0306170583,
0.0267420504,
0.0084480001,
-0.0272808298,
0.0033051511,
0.0364922471,
0.0012341614,
0.0231386833,
-0.0047910153,
-0.0090188282,
0.0273136776,
-0.027685307,
-0.0399836786,
0.0229737125,
0.0580123216,
-0.0339552276,
-0.0504573919,
0.092742905,
0.0062824772,
-0.0931237563,
0.0377480164,
-0.0183395687,
-0.0090302993,
-0.0241863523,
0.0358651653,
-0.0639055446,
-0.013217967,
-0.0076827602,
0.0445156619,
0.0059160357,
0.0100923683,
0.0183614567,
-0.0344211012,
0.0206563007,
0.0224370006,
-0.0563985668,
-0.0302912053,
-0.038958136,
-0.0043667755,
-0.0320420563,
0.0279826932,
-0.036649555,
-0.0039142407,
-0.0140661485,
0.022565024,
-0.0096883578,
-0.1364919543,
-0.028169252,
-0.0137426937,
0.0497793518,
0.0494938865,
0.0176292807,
-0.0149571318,
0.0160468314,
0.0189043377,
0.0139054991,
0.0158652309,
-0.0127866194,
0.0637538061,
0.0475872084,
-0.0121571058,
-0.0152358012,
0.0036630274,
-0.0664026663,
-0.0264627039,
0.0003070016,
0.061651215,
-0.0173896495,
0.0045432644,
-0.0395392329,
-0.0084303655,
0.0359617099,
0.030681381,
0.0254807509,
-0.0548182614,
0.0079367468,
0.0220475812,
0.046240814,
-0.0170292053,
-0.010959751,
0.0642809719,
-0.0798108429,
-0.0485700369,
-0.0674138218,
-0.0041709533,
0.0160345025,
0.0197781287,
0.0501635,
-0.0035304609,
0.0516128242,
-0.023369642,
-0.0501555391,
0.0670695528,
-0.0088215414,
0.0181256421,
-0.0893565491,
-0.0374849401,
0.0351709574,
0.0112010129,
-0.0087754866,
0.0086704222,
-0.0297020823,
-0.0265735555,
0.0158719085,
0.0623746254,
0.0247551482,
0.0171318874,
-0.0081308968,
-0.054914128,
0.0672051832,
0.0258449763,
-0.0450680926,
-0.0137670748,
-0.0041992986,
-0.0312706493,
-0.0204651915,
0.0248317569,
-0.0342013873,
0.0351548009,
0.0175925065,
0.051122956,
0.0037051698,
-0.0296385046,
0.0172060095,
-0.0003524779,
0.0313034132,
-0.0506639518,
-0.0409693122,
-0.0064634643,
0.0144437049,
-0.0048007173,
0.0408401862,
-0.0219583903,
-0.0423186831,
0.0691720396,
0.0178690925,
-0.0059209852,
0.0089776991,
-0.0574630275,
-0.0291641094,
-0.0285656657,
0.008825697,
0.0256239139,
0.0214388464,
0.0492041446,
0.0336706787,
0.0114334533,
0.0424847007,
-0.0047539193,
0.035340175,
-0.0374983661,
0.0452181958,
-0.0011639143,
0.0535237379,
-0.0208764318,
0.0720421001,
-0.0445902795,
-0.0242665038,
-0.0034177254,
-0.0155588323,
0.0493241176,
0.0030251094,
0.0892824456,
0.0191514101,
-0.0071905712,
-0.0324164443,
0.0178769249,
-0.0239856839,
0.0413002372,
0.0191922449,
-0.006151489,
0.0147978356,
-0.0166784786,
0.0886256173,
-0.0007825344,
0.0632433668,
-0.0183766503,
-0.0109329494,
-0.0229827929,
-0.00778466,
-0.0158924572,
-0.0189766977,
-0.0800339058,
-0.0197508056,
-0.0459876731,
-0.0554769114,
0.0291955229,
-0.0219412521,
-0.0282269102,
-0.0540680215,
0.0322735012,
0.0177616421,
0.0027134353,
-0.0034754861,
-0.0247004218,
0.0564230382,
0.0101763206,
-0.0259317067,
-0.0090377005,
-5.150425192e-33,
-0.0096343644,
0.0060887914,
0.020215774,
-0.0345857739,
0.0069466443,
0.0465929359,
-0.0288094059,
-0.0266115386,
-0.0129030235,
0.0195748135,
-0.0357568935,
0.0058952197,
0.0124583673,
0.0438697785,
-0.0098914457,
-0.0146068064,
0.0381558165,
0.0258854926,
-0.0235659424,
0.0225619301,
-0.0186048411,
0.0352208987,
0.0816210955,
-0.0562990978,
0.0196467433,
0.0001919655,
0.0277255643,
-0.000166072,
0.0084840395,
0.069533363,
-0.0028141472,
0.0363549739,
0.0289297868,
-0.0431429148,
-0.0156587679,
0.0056567029,
-0.1039218083,
-0.0001820011,
0.02475092,
0.0302346125,
0.0162308477,
-0.0462350845,
0.0750288069,
-0.0106983734,
-0.0401532948,
0.0005674274,
0.0217727832,
-0.0379280858,
-0.046427466,
-0.0308840144,
-0.0552168638,
0.0261397362,
0.0253176913,
-0.0022824064,
-0.0029393006,
0.0368802249,
-0.0516818017,
0.0290433075,
-0.035378594,
-0.0130102588,
0.0180155877,
0.0422480367,
0.0471013077,
-0.0252650399,
-0.0396262445,
0.0179113429,
0.0146357585,
0.0134790037,
-0.0127675869,
-0.0064867055,
0.0214011446,
-0.0091913659,
0.0535227284,
0.0443039909,
0.0272750575,
-0.0410770401,
-0.0961311907,
0.0406072028,
-0.0443677418,
0.0308242626,
0.0089273108,
-0.0252061691,
-0.0276282616,
-0.0237430818,
-0.0282341335,
-0.0261410791,
0.0016393544,
-0.0445191115,
0.0191515498,
-0.0344900601,
0.0246233977,
0.0271831211,
0.020480508,
-0.0491228215,
0.004409547,
-0.0022923357,
0.0502259061,
0.0089582065,
-0.034609843,
0.0440677293,
-0.0401469246,
-0.0506608635,
0.0021106775,
0.0155134834,
0.0394781679,
-0.0026729652,
0.0511367582,
-0.0099875787,
-0.0319411978,
-0.0000080234,
0.0043917256,
-0.0158119313,
-0.0025685767,
0.0760506243,
0.0436328351,
0.0317583643,
0.0114310309,
0.0585895702,
0.0139929391,
-0.0093451105,
-0.0215457566,
-0.0006592153,
0.0304334164,
0.0269781016,
-0.0665768534,
-0.0392152444,
-0.0618937127,
0.0713552162,
0.0314551592,
-0.0670386329,
-0.037272457,
-0.017240528,
2.508e-7,
0.1112962738,
0.0492959097,
0.0021589031,
-0.0548877679,
0.0179929957,
-0.0249651391,
-0.005176025,
0.020950621,
-0.0306039639,
0.0296681393,
0.0194525924,
0.0008101554,
0.0609363467,
0.016459655,
-0.0745178238,
-0.0329118632,
-0.0710076317,
0.0240510516,
-0.0294850208,
0.0000510805,
-0.0235161409,
0.0902228579,
-0.0170342475,
-0.0476233549,
0.0080978256,
-0.0207430366,
0.0485727154,
-0.0597931668,
-0.0190705452,
0.0623286292,
0.0051164771,
0.042288959,
-0.0048222514,
0.0036122652,
-0.0227127783,
0.0130430507,
0.0020248273,
0.0876573101,
-0.0494873077,
0.0317916162,
0.0359793492,
-0.0209261291,
-0.0102831163,
-0.0375956185,
0.0227491241,
-0.0944126919,
-0.0490330569,
-0.0382896736,
0.0024410116,
-0.0113064256,
0.059490338,
-0.0419374332,
-0.0224564988,
0.0410785526,
0.0614616759,
0.0332247801,
-0.0599031858,
-0.0305183865,
-0.0235623159,
0.0303061474,
-0.0126604615,
-0.0298290681,
0.0145560363,
-0.0283309482,
-0.0173082668,
-0.0469652414,
0.0489214472,
1.98776485e-34,
0.0386106223,
-0.013291141,
0.0029398547,
0.0184484571,
0.0054949988,
-0.0332158729,
0.0137025341,
0.0225068443,
0.0051455549,
-0.0499399602,
-0.000637648
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10409v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10409v3 | ClarifyDelphi: Reinforced Clarification Questions with Defeasibility Rewards for Social and Moral Situations | 2022-12-20T16:33:09 | 2023-05-30T18:59:41 | Valentina Pyatkin, Jena D. Hwang, Vivek Srikumar, Ximing Lu, Liwei Jiang, Yejin Choi, Chandra Bhagavatula | cs.CL | cs.CL | Context is everything, even in commonsense moral reasoning. Changing contexts
can flip the moral judgment of an action; "Lying to a friend" is wrong in
general, but may be morally acceptable if it is intended to protect their life.
We present ClarifyDelphi, an interactive system that learns to ask
clarification questions (e.g., why did you lie to your friend?) in order to
elicit additional salient contexts of a social or moral situation. We posit
that questions whose potential answers lead to diverging moral judgments are
the most informative. Thus, we propose a reinforcement learning framework with
a defeasibility reward that aims to maximize the divergence between moral
judgments of hypothetical answers to a question. Human evaluation demonstrates
that our system generates more relevant, informative and defeasible questions
compared to competitive baselines. Our work is ultimately inspired by studies
in cognitive science that have investigated the flexibility in moral cognition
(i.e., the diverse contexts in which moral rules can be bent), and we hope that
research in this direction can assist both cognitive and computational
investigations of moral judgments. | [
0.0534974411,
0.0467338227,
-0.0216864944,
0.0019777685,
-0.0680417866,
0.0012671502,
0.0108389584,
-0.0063140485,
-0.0259801075,
0.0035398758,
-0.0172236823,
-0.0418769345,
-0.0120595479,
-0.0209678486,
-0.0137263658,
-0.0602457449,
0.0391853452,
-0.0135151939,
0.1007494107,
-0.0108571015,
-0.0035512478,
0.0030604154,
0.0306465831,
-0.0283703804,
0.0095641231,
0.0082294531,
-0.0372701176,
0.0290341415,
0.0495394506,
-0.0226527806,
0.0164092854,
0.0384284742,
0.0482046269,
0.0034376476,
0.0000021295,
-0.0578530282,
-0.0128586376,
-0.0220776871,
-0.0147569114,
0.0039979788,
0.0402056016,
0.0072779232,
0.0366470776,
-0.0079921968,
-0.0299262926,
0.0280486532,
0.0186264124,
0.0568589941,
0.0210552365,
0.0433194712,
0.0136960102,
-0.0170896295,
-0.0202439148,
-0.0206384696,
0.0396321267,
-0.0603080504,
0.008666886,
0.02290616,
-0.0036867375,
-0.0014889261,
-0.0055822148,
-0.0280504059,
0.0388938338,
-0.0066917799,
-0.0165005941,
0.00943451,
0.0472051576,
-0.0109700831,
-0.0257116649,
0.0529238097,
0.0052467822,
-0.0011607802,
0.0247728359,
0.0087390533,
0.0542075932,
0.0217450224,
0.0058326931,
0.0388278291,
-0.0364290886,
-0.0078661926,
0.0167788751,
0.0326121747,
0.0141745247,
0.0590041466,
0.0393867306,
-0.0137739517,
-0.0401284695,
-0.0066926079,
0.0044946736,
-0.010867469,
-0.0885742977,
-0.012191046,
-0.0007782787,
0.019606797,
-0.0529460981,
-0.0008994861,
0.0150607573,
0.0336598568,
0.0495207906,
0.0010028253,
0.0541852228,
0.0174251162,
-0.0036276896,
0.0375219099,
0.0291862991,
0.0058135986,
-0.0241502244,
0.0103249438,
-0.046701286,
0.0234376583,
0.0212629661,
0.022581527,
-0.0037241953,
0.0325812176,
-0.0241776202,
0.0600054376,
-0.0194403362,
-0.0174683146,
-0.0662404299,
0.0117758382,
-0.0375879668,
0.028690204,
-0.0327438228,
0.0130899884,
-0.0670515895,
-0.0306101218,
-0.1067122519,
0.0322205201,
0.0372365229,
0.0363800935,
-0.0129514067,
-0.0590744168,
0.004820304,
0.0229964647,
0.0133660063,
0.0823060796,
0.0014341992,
0.022257043,
-0.01793072,
-0.0175629538,
-0.0030295888,
-0.0208475888,
-0.0343745798,
-0.0198592208,
0.0339032896,
-0.0141757652,
-0.0348235033,
-0.0319600254,
0.0461779423,
0.0037520954,
-0.0016539837,
0.0782159716,
0.0224361084,
-0.0286458004,
0.0156020513,
0.0453711711,
-0.033054769,
0.0511646606,
0.0027923896,
0.0262544975,
0.0492430627,
0.0006240977,
0.0198775195,
-0.0578162521,
0.0012454988,
-0.0042500747,
0.0084369136,
0.0217950568,
-0.015418835,
0.0240245908,
-0.0281612538,
-0.0045457734,
-0.0276265107,
-0.0410436466,
0.0232727304,
0.0870837569,
0.0054879026,
-0.0278577954,
0.0061903424,
-0.0005538278,
-0.0310342889,
0.0164863914,
-0.0550000928,
0.0461925156,
0.000848472,
-0.0116063645,
-0.0949505195,
0.0260804221,
-0.0224817675,
-0.0515384898,
0.031982407,
-0.0140309343,
0.0694468543,
0.0454641879,
-0.0160240885,
0.0040531135,
0.0125534916,
-0.029379284,
0.0742447525,
-0.0589775629,
-0.0017832936,
-0.0465368964,
0.0967829749,
0.0292009898,
0.0484848395,
-0.0376266837,
-0.026565738,
-0.0360018909,
-0.0308235064,
0.0000119632,
0.0349236429,
-0.0224065371,
0.0315465145,
-0.0472416095,
-0.0432760306,
-0.0364011042,
0.0038028746,
0.0131109469,
0.0176829007,
-0.0544462614,
-0.0000385062,
-0.0138972476,
0.0287383199,
0.0413784683,
0.0423921943,
0.0303011872,
-0.0201068334,
0.0077468967,
0.0196805149,
-0.0294891465,
0.0274909306,
-0.0166605115,
0.0141758071,
0.0261059813,
0.0080761686,
-0.0116208252,
-0.0587226339,
0.0183655974,
0.0053584813,
-0.0646993592,
-0.0204360504,
-0.0212534983,
-0.0301703811,
0.0532455854,
-0.0322896764,
-0.0322880149,
0.0249884836,
-0.0118367635,
-0.0080650998,
-0.0557094328,
-0.0585127026,
-0.0338854641,
0.1094970256,
-0.0194109455,
0.0064417394,
-0.0356130861,
-0.0029502911,
0.0230540633,
-0.0152754271,
0.0447929054,
-0.0818138644,
-0.0165607445,
-0.0000256739,
0.0197157692,
0.0525466055,
-0.0609000362,
-0.0163847208,
-0.0155489715,
-0.021788599,
-0.0073564551,
-0.0354824588,
-0.0029505398,
-0.0143946391,
0.0300923456,
-0.0232722014,
-0.0340025388,
0.0330643542,
-0.0213979073,
-0.0018017425,
0.0362046659,
0.0070717572,
0.015937781,
-0.0220990125,
0.0044003562,
-0.0084200492,
0.0107585406,
0.0416983292,
0.0390191637,
-0.0322113149,
0.0122114979,
-0.0756924301,
0.0195380338,
0.002245927,
-0.0221726131,
0.008449222,
0.0458459593,
0.0066029904,
0.0919611901,
0.0680789724,
0.0162921473,
0.0193446651,
0.0551096573,
-0.0427809283,
0.006097069,
-0.0139362495,
0.0249033999,
-0.0168791804,
-0.055030033,
-0.0277764592,
0.0211102106,
-0.0066028805,
0.0142660392,
-0.0267933737,
0.0543092154,
-0.0257660374,
-0.0697223097,
-0.0463958271,
-0.0475771241,
0.01943589,
0.0863686204,
-0.0508342385,
-0.0562090538,
0.1155596003,
0.0891127288,
0.0345720463,
-0.0139463386,
0.0331369415,
-0.013331851,
0.0519332178,
-0.0102988537,
0.010843032,
0.015894467,
-0.0304304194,
-0.0230799615,
-0.0362549536,
0.0808209926,
-0.0465336852,
0.0637299195,
-0.0457776636,
-0.0277542043,
0.0124672698,
-0.103938885,
-0.054677818,
-0.0560534038,
0.0171552077,
-0.0359655842,
-0.0130178239,
0.0299246516,
0.0316146091,
-0.0238902308,
0.0363436528,
-0.0205263607,
-0.0125540905,
-0.016043026,
0.0087007768,
-0.0219001565,
0.0270913225,
0.0443789959,
0.0532169715,
-0.0268022921,
0.0258750319,
0.0245907903,
-0.0168181695,
-0.0151491975,
0.0235467218,
0.0634379834,
-0.0021270036,
-0.0095821386,
0.0556620173,
0.0184108838,
0.077023603,
-0.0076314453,
-0.0150160575,
0.0565446503,
0.0359237529,
-0.0538486093,
0.0093279639,
-0.0545297265,
-0.0088799959,
0.0226760842,
-0.0009798671,
-0.0979075432,
-0.0259068683,
-0.0244035572,
-0.0138849709,
-0.0552818663,
-0.0328694731,
0.0404174067,
-0.0562065654,
0.0192292016,
0.0031746684,
-0.0027625712,
-0.0008059501,
-0.02083195,
-0.0073580458,
-0.0118760848,
0.0102451388,
0.0443073735,
0.0306691509,
-0.046158962,
-0.0065784603,
0.0806533173,
0.0483366661,
0.0509927496,
-0.0294385925,
0.0288125947,
0.0558135845,
0.0437016822,
-0.0229220092,
-0.0564719029,
-0.0303483065,
0.0238003433,
-0.0064890203,
0.01544795,
0.0016058065,
0.0118024889,
0.0055006761,
-0.0752248839,
0.0506421253,
0.0618514791,
-0.0576602519,
0.014519752,
0.0524822995,
0.0037228477,
-0.0144759547,
0.0067861062,
0.0163235217,
0.0122687537,
0.0428916961,
0.0054280167,
-0.0416477434,
0.0115510058,
-0.0220225155,
-0.0156970937,
-0.0379758961,
-0.0083083585,
-0.0525717661,
-0.0022280545,
0.000152694,
-0.0327577777,
0.0062623392,
-0.0286403485,
-0.0262319203,
0.0357021503,
-0.0918131694,
0.0284883808,
0.0328850709,
-0.0552042052,
0.0200753454,
-0.0198056027,
-0.0239043161,
0.0142928241,
0.0050597014,
-0.031548731,
-0.0417019501,
-0.0181804691,
-0.0038680318,
0.0151357912,
0.0054556476,
0.0217103381,
0.033759106,
0.0160821266,
0.0494487844,
-0.0610698909,
0.0221491829,
-0.0009731227,
0.012432605,
-0.0667539909,
0.0224630311,
0.0550220311,
0.0420722365,
0.0034520023,
0.0024589587,
-0.026887266,
0.0208018851,
0.0249118544,
-0.0141005209,
-0.0507068522,
-0.0069058696,
0.0264843479,
-0.0109173572,
0.0052740159,
0.0114310663,
-0.0175143946,
-0.0049317181,
-0.028032789,
0.0136423595,
-0.0378744975,
0.0216355603,
-0.0107298456,
0.0233901404,
-0.030036658,
-0.0019520961,
0.0260594655,
-0.029333761,
0.0027450456,
-0.0103114927,
-0.0287425332,
0.0788946077,
0.024491502,
-0.0282750856,
-0.0105747972,
-0.0285377633,
0.0321919471,
-0.0085426839,
0.0589257292,
-0.015236944,
0.1182551682,
0.020214919,
-0.0142075587,
-0.0104562119,
-0.0134318704,
-0.076700449,
-0.0066788923,
0.0183907561,
0.028133871,
-0.0077681355,
0.0481066033,
-0.0395307466,
0.0082818773,
-0.0105079385,
0.0231048614,
0.0172642209,
0.0182664916,
-0.054207366,
0.0229126215,
0.0366649851,
0.0046505188,
0.0106065068,
0.007182945,
-0.0993885472,
0.0109778699,
-0.0158890989,
-0.0089771645,
-0.0109778335,
-0.0241057668,
0.0255828183,
0.0343952179,
-0.0067824535,
0.0290165395,
-0.0878466591,
-0.0040470166,
-0.0174169745,
0.0550831072,
0.0279671736,
-0.0194915719,
-0.0079786647,
0.0338597819,
-0.0021347231,
-0.0336223468,
-0.0087870117,
0.0712870136,
-0.0325600915,
0.0180128235,
-0.0826923326,
-5.808702763e-33,
-0.0127909938,
-0.0231703222,
-0.0534649305,
-0.0118619623,
-0.027569497,
0.0006833121,
0.0001821976,
0.0014674967,
-0.0599731319,
0.0390906818,
-0.0030081684,
0.0379855856,
-0.0015720131,
-0.0201085359,
-0.0096465591,
-0.0720791072,
-0.011525251,
0.016707873,
-0.0301153567,
0.0240587983,
-0.0351503342,
-0.0275063198,
0.0115263807,
-0.059597306,
0.0266114175,
0.03168929,
-0.0068229521,
0.036210876,
-0.0515928343,
-0.0142825739,
0.0004518334,
0.0378598385,
0.0056697568,
-0.0109306639,
0.0435818397,
0.0499509312,
-0.0682309493,
-0.030786572,
0.0734731182,
-0.0547790974,
-0.0989920795,
-0.034538012,
-0.012273171,
0.0026496937,
0.0062179472,
-0.0041719633,
0.0184578709,
-0.01141336,
0.013469616,
0.0165721364,
-0.0369272046,
-0.0500804894,
-0.0362263098,
-0.0550216436,
-0.0784145147,
0.0457017496,
-0.0141652729,
0.0209146235,
-0.0068552941,
0.0480740443,
0.0245189853,
-0.0371686667,
-0.0197836272,
-0.0067162011,
0.0209797304,
0.0267320573,
-0.0171201862,
0.0168216098,
-0.0335099138,
-0.0260150917,
-0.0425925553,
0.0474581793,
0.0835870057,
0.1063505709,
0.0191614553,
-0.0467021354,
-0.0606427714,
-0.0154585252,
0.0659554154,
0.0003960092,
0.0203428343,
-0.0048610703,
-0.0279727429,
0.0020507697,
-0.0609540045,
-0.0390859358,
-0.0433385074,
-0.0084813489,
0.0043218634,
0.0030904182,
-0.0360977501,
-0.0099780401,
-0.0634468123,
-0.0185985696,
0.0563530698,
-0.0149357449,
0.0472314768,
-0.0186683368,
-0.0051957266,
-0.0111495508,
-0.0004013734,
-0.0004852214,
0.0080216704,
-0.0211935453,
0.0250248387,
-0.0012992176,
0.0698392615,
-0.0080644861,
0.0276809018,
-0.0035362674,
-0.0190438237,
0.0614167079,
-0.0152576389,
-0.0342180207,
0.0087769832,
0.041997496,
-0.012063357,
-0.0324771143,
0.0476861931,
0.0343121253,
-0.0441577248,
-0.0256065298,
-0.0451584794,
0.0697155148,
-0.0254883394,
0.0002078984,
-0.0125694443,
0.0225091167,
-0.0445863567,
-0.0582488365,
-0.0321591236,
0.0227941629,
2.675e-7,
-0.0100395028,
-0.0054787737,
0.0265199933,
0.0034479091,
0.0061988318,
0.0559975654,
0.034131363,
0.0313751362,
0.0479886606,
-0.0844562054,
0.0029173247,
0.0176463109,
0.0404430591,
-0.0012240033,
0.0040694252,
-0.0542241447,
-0.0033289676,
-0.0188674275,
-0.0133973872,
0.0432824716,
0.0443799272,
0.026370123,
0.0421156809,
0.0038261334,
0.0365745686,
0.0387774631,
0.0231926255,
-0.0883351117,
-0.0132374577,
-0.0231520999,
-0.0227770805,
-0.0438247137,
0.0194811523,
0.0180628821,
0.0183640886,
-0.0185337178,
-0.0182701387,
0.0316408016,
-0.0195878893,
-0.0599292144,
-0.0461797714,
-0.0279793479,
0.0252333116,
-0.048308976,
0.0627184585,
-0.0232004356,
-0.0213402752,
-0.008456178,
0.0145725487,
0.0068235071,
-0.0044787088,
0.0139639257,
-0.0687336177,
-0.0294661876,
0.0149699152,
0.0480741113,
0.0115260053,
-0.049354203,
-0.030441884,
0.0298558827,
0.0247351974,
-0.0493779108,
0.0316723287,
0.0157466456,
0.0315491222,
-0.0636141226,
0.0195441768,
1.949646461e-34,
0.0117567163,
-0.0187589359,
0.0151332431,
-0.0021489598,
0.0466692597,
0.0343025587,
-0.0595381521,
-0.0353335217,
0.0622916371,
0.0203364082,
0.0125862481
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10408v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10408v1 | Geographic and Geopolitical Biases of Language Models | 2022-12-20T16:32:54 | 2022-12-20T16:32:54 | Fahim Faisal, Antonios Anastasopoulos | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pretrained language models (PLMs) often fail to fairly represent target users
from certain world regions because of the under-representation of those regions
in training datasets. With recent PLMs trained on enormous data sources,
quantifying their potential biases is difficult, due to their black-box nature
and the sheer scale of the data sources. In this work, we devise an approach to
study the geographic bias (and knowledge) present in PLMs, proposing a
Geographic-Representation Probing Framework adopting a self-conditioning method
coupled with entity-country mappings. Our findings suggest PLMs'
representations map surprisingly well to the physical world in terms of
country-to-country associations, but this knowledge is unequally shared across
languages. Last, we explain how large PLMs despite exhibiting notions of
geographical proximity, over-amplify geopolitical favouritism at inference
time. | [
0.0290305559,
0.0481859408,
-0.0444563963,
0.0096038524,
0.0080824066,
0.0263799634,
0.0537188686,
-0.0268171038,
0.0392125435,
-0.0411693752,
-0.0504359752,
-0.0312665999,
0.0011588217,
-0.0148719428,
0.0517158993,
-0.0678912401,
0.0372457393,
-0.0059460346,
-0.014119897,
-0.031967748,
-0.0150836548,
0.0317046233,
0.018975148,
0.039223846,
0.0087435618,
0.0213195104,
0.0175618622,
-0.0236200858,
-0.0019838118,
-0.0130282417,
0.010465241,
0.0329700336,
0.0130406655,
-0.0023621379,
0.000001755,
-0.0338898674,
-0.0276055038,
-0.0209431536,
0.0252114795,
0.0576080121,
0.0261869952,
-0.0085428022,
0.0074655944,
0.0232781619,
-0.0552174225,
-0.0338953547,
0.0295514297,
-0.0083208671,
0.0182468463,
0.0538124256,
-0.0244283024,
-0.0101207318,
-0.0322734825,
-0.0237723459,
-0.0515029132,
0.0135292467,
0.0307675824,
-0.0208637957,
-0.0430466719,
0.015857324,
-0.0231543034,
0.0131027056,
0.0050169122,
0.0385751165,
-0.0318733007,
0.0364764482,
-0.0245439354,
0.0234268717,
0.0196380876,
0.011820442,
0.0227915011,
-0.011394945,
0.0228775889,
0.0051368647,
-0.0314729735,
0.0293895286,
0.0060151881,
-0.0056539876,
0.0249214172,
0.058084283,
0.021411391,
0.0137453666,
0.0303134564,
0.0404641144,
-0.0719007403,
0.1063318104,
0.0139182908,
-0.0357868224,
-0.0450770669,
0.0420676768,
0.0163799692,
-0.0430090986,
0.0265209693,
0.0032279843,
0.0268066619,
-0.0031218166,
-0.0146920765,
0.0503006428,
0.0203045662,
-0.0220282115,
0.0269876681,
0.0061561516,
-0.0333472416,
0.0377325565,
-0.0034709033,
0.0166691169,
-0.0006997712,
0.0501147397,
-0.0177179407,
-0.0314154737,
0.0026598717,
-0.0036511086,
0.0105108032,
-0.0526956506,
0.0246996507,
0.0422512069,
-0.0759020224,
-0.0025219941,
-0.0160570201,
-0.0101084523,
-0.0334102176,
-0.0034959714,
-0.0076089394,
-0.0269665178,
-0.0452577174,
0.0577477664,
-0.0253752917,
0.0256163906,
-0.0619635694,
-0.0087015489,
0.0185192712,
0.0141594121,
-0.0170379598,
-0.0197933223,
-0.0001223548,
0.033542145,
0.0364285037,
-0.0142934928,
-0.0564615987,
0.0161292255,
-0.0193734262,
-0.0251802094,
0.0345290452,
-0.0496105663,
0.0082463659,
0.0234798919,
-0.0146856066,
-0.0489994623,
-0.0385972299,
-0.0242583081,
-0.0365643725,
0.0129995467,
-0.0100690536,
0.0424414501,
0.0628014058,
-0.0079630092,
0.01572234,
0.0956553817,
-0.0089377938,
0.0074952636,
0.0599875674,
-0.0294261705,
0.0110273445,
0.0496129096,
0.0288589895,
0.0504701473,
-0.044772137,
-0.0048810625,
-0.0176424254,
-0.0347708389,
0.0834451765,
-0.0039731902,
-0.0068658818,
0.0110865207,
0.0650243238,
0.0720063299,
0.0001338481,
-0.0003101265,
0.0088909594,
0.0183841884,
-0.035102196,
-0.0013589546,
-0.0603982694,
-0.0496016741,
-0.0253308937,
-0.0240085796,
0.0367736407,
0.0734007806,
-0.0487742946,
0.0031593756,
-0.0030407729,
-0.0054338775,
0.025766477,
0.020718433,
0.0774385706,
-0.0192159358,
0.0434006266,
0.0899465904,
0.0580858476,
-0.0300239511,
0.0316874534,
0.0007165883,
-0.0174721032,
-0.0006532779,
-0.0403343737,
0.0051856074,
0.0115859928,
0.0120058144,
0.049576126,
0.0290236063,
0.0580750518,
0.0152029637,
0.0115874084,
-0.0080478759,
-0.0448930636,
0.0098285265,
0.0310271047,
0.0072312523,
0.0491097569,
0.0476132482,
0.0262785144,
-0.09277872,
0.0064564743,
0.0115117161,
-0.0180976428,
0.0157828387,
0.0028516124,
0.0355142504,
-0.0146222953,
0.0152891343,
-0.02730483,
0.0007294585,
-0.0072114635,
-0.0302718971,
0.026279578,
0.0180061385,
-0.0360286795,
0.0123903984,
0.0272429083,
-0.0175808202,
0.0019316247,
-0.0004697453,
-0.0034520794,
-0.0228606872,
0.0599593595,
0.0039985846,
0.0915902928,
-0.017844338,
0.0163971819,
-0.0502400137,
0.0353342257,
-0.0157778636,
0.0304364674,
-0.0083909268,
0.0141765084,
-0.002038056,
-0.0005582108,
0.0529605784,
0.0023209769,
-0.033829473,
-0.0421758443,
-0.0125364289,
-0.020363275,
0.0202984009,
-0.0270849671,
-0.0168668292,
-0.0167228747,
-0.0935239568,
-0.0121638533,
-0.0555782169,
0.0286561269,
0.0261686258,
-0.0083632004,
-0.0525146239,
-0.0267265588,
-0.0306944754,
-0.0425972492,
-0.0022835778,
0.0440679938,
0.0057167923,
-0.0479625314,
0.0258676186,
-0.0095875384,
-0.0227021333,
-0.0371258818,
0.0465947464,
-0.0319851525,
-0.0163008962,
-0.0459823869,
0.0304430686,
-0.0300718434,
0.0254068468,
-0.0338631608,
-0.0299985055,
-0.002694882,
-0.0025384855,
0.0134954359,
0.0192375947,
-0.0093471231,
-0.026754586,
0.0704941079,
-0.0268558357,
-0.0537233092,
-0.0158760864,
-0.0269767195,
0.0250988975,
-0.0452741012,
-0.061500676,
0.0081998603,
0.0911423638,
0.0085134031,
-0.0247588232,
0.0070346594,
0.0179706123,
-0.0790860578,
-0.0032829868,
-0.0105489958,
0.0134441163,
0.0143273994,
0.0757317245,
-0.0138474125,
-0.0803302303,
0.0266357455,
-0.0281548481,
0.0453730449,
-0.000958235,
-0.0453615412,
-0.0156957563,
0.0401118919,
0.0165353399,
0.006138958,
0.010653805,
-0.0319488123,
-0.0194331817,
-0.0424838476,
0.004074879,
0.0004871273,
0.0024680134,
-0.0008325312,
-0.0092742732,
-0.0055966391,
-0.0546547584,
-0.0239871535,
-0.0524238087,
-0.0127664562,
-0.0120464927,
0.0370717607,
-0.0353415534,
0.028943954,
0.0602077208,
-0.0064420654,
0.0312160626,
-0.0344357528,
0.0181438774,
0.0151042193,
-0.0120885959,
0.0705187544,
0.048323296,
0.0268274713,
-0.026865527,
-0.0680782273,
-0.0263393261,
0.0168434232,
0.0135015789,
0.0209078621,
0.016981313,
0.0520125739,
-0.0355528072,
-0.0510167591,
-0.0148641365,
0.067686744,
-0.0203160103,
-0.0045015193,
0.1073748022,
0.0320257731,
-0.0652760714,
0.0134491567,
-0.0227330271,
0.0187761858,
0.0335994922,
0.0709942952,
-0.0698636696,
0.0325805694,
-0.0068906723,
-0.0246193372,
-0.0271807928,
-0.0112223085,
-0.0200229995,
-0.1109438613,
0.0346177444,
0.0122811506,
-0.0354549885,
-0.0145104378,
-0.0442771651,
-0.015811136,
-0.0139277969,
0.0285237934,
-0.0479736738,
-0.0188223347,
0.0021438522,
0.0397064798,
-0.1138557792,
-0.0596293323,
0.0074944119,
-0.0858505368,
0.0398907177,
0.0201667976,
0.0212850496,
0.0002554705,
-0.0122761317,
-0.0156175913,
0.0322339237,
0.0059258533,
-0.0101524414,
0.0420429036,
-0.0071973959,
-0.0217686016,
0.016860038,
-0.0180990808,
-0.018683536,
-0.0111579336,
0.0241711549,
0.0461430214,
-0.0262472536,
0.0255870838,
-0.0065087886,
0.0227989871,
0.0268262736,
0.0375349261,
0.0181043372,
-0.0401636474,
-0.0169298388,
-0.0226344522,
0.0242031403,
-0.0076031461,
-0.0306194667,
0.0533239394,
-0.0138612166,
-0.0593744665,
0.0074669365,
-0.0442229882,
0.0144940596,
0.0314591452,
0.0200643837,
0.0048330831,
0.0354252309,
-0.0538984612,
-0.0288350992,
0.0627034456,
-0.0340372212,
-0.0010339705,
-0.002946093,
-0.0409460552,
0.0240343548,
-0.019878732,
0.0034486672,
-0.0079014506,
-0.0492488705,
-0.0548544042,
0.0354988202,
0.0076132664,
0.0113137178,
0.0215290841,
-0.0038654788,
-0.0688805282,
0.0854476765,
0.0047308407,
-0.0634572878,
0.0203730632,
0.0075386451,
-0.0011935751,
0.01525624,
0.0185506176,
-0.0068914657,
0.0389649123,
0.0594583862,
-0.0189242661,
-0.0564109311,
-0.0029058869,
-0.0275678597,
-0.0390692987,
0.1291972399,
-0.030513633,
-0.0019592626,
-0.0609329976,
-0.0198311601,
-0.0307186861,
-0.0055192881,
0.0046601733,
-0.0461982824,
0.047441408,
0.0235947259,
-0.0199835878,
0.015239968,
-0.0338072665,
-0.0121956067,
-0.0422335193,
0.0208075121,
0.0136505021,
0.0178147312,
0.0113516608,
0.0473473743,
0.0206643995,
0.0259785932,
0.0192296281,
0.0382823125,
-0.0073988354,
0.0310072992,
-0.0041659591,
0.0304962248,
-0.0344038121,
0.0107728345,
-0.0539919473,
-0.0263243821,
0.0085598063,
-0.0152357854,
0.0816797391,
-0.0772195756,
0.0483292714,
0.0086950902,
-0.0021189079,
0.0131550962,
-0.0007001196,
-0.0030410772,
-0.0495556667,
0.0211669337,
-0.0385691114,
-0.055916626,
0.0667684004,
0.0566767082,
0.030900063,
0.0240940601,
0.0178359151,
-0.0489157885,
0.0113181351,
-0.0202233363,
0.0538409278,
-0.0152721507,
-0.0592820719,
-0.0273400359,
-0.0601200871,
-0.0738873109,
-0.0116722025,
-0.0180902276,
-0.0569470078,
-0.0057565998,
0.0135467099,
0.0707657635,
-0.0461029746,
-0.0261490084,
-0.0609725863,
-0.0056993845,
-0.0390787236,
-0.019748304,
0.02021713,
-6.273965264e-33,
-0.0208236277,
-0.0168373194,
0.0214179307,
-0.0681369454,
-0.0011937716,
0.0132763926,
-0.0021509165,
0.0326365791,
-0.0317407213,
0.0101136826,
-0.0449396074,
0.0006418004,
0.0155742271,
0.037416134,
0.0160189569,
0.0152323013,
0.0042831628,
0.0136315478,
-0.0110980486,
0.0184881929,
0.0213072617,
0.0256141201,
0.0697035342,
-0.0723917633,
0.0029391546,
0.0168734565,
-0.0074175666,
0.005675863,
0.0294117965,
0.050330393,
-0.0506452359,
0.0531888157,
0.0189728308,
-0.0296234824,
-0.0398867093,
-0.0261409692,
-0.0524237193,
-0.0508546941,
0.0049661547,
0.0307504535,
0.0280425232,
0.0005462593,
0.0223626103,
-0.0008172453,
-0.0141696706,
0.0150866071,
0.0477375314,
0.0446046181,
-0.0199181233,
0.0178868435,
-0.0124049122,
0.0326113664,
-0.0150951687,
0.0497747324,
0.0179924611,
0.0118572908,
0.0068033077,
0.0135945929,
-0.0339235105,
0.0316881835,
0.0698364079,
0.0451965258,
0.0723770037,
0.019151086,
0.021538483,
0.0760591701,
0.0468668491,
0.024140548,
-0.0442052297,
-0.0571417511,
0.0967680961,
-0.0391741283,
-0.0276738629,
0.0475473218,
0.0046926127,
-0.0489942245,
-0.0534451827,
0.0240403656,
0.0140046664,
-0.0238599014,
0.0192564745,
-0.0344545469,
-0.0133796474,
-0.0758180246,
-0.0217459965,
-0.0573821738,
0.0036340747,
-0.0473032407,
0.0279942397,
-0.0321522541,
0.0320487916,
0.0301908515,
0.0421868712,
-0.0547637604,
-0.0603471026,
0.0043654838,
-0.0148332464,
-0.0265986752,
-0.0020745446,
0.0363000184,
-0.0586837605,
-0.0558160953,
-0.047073707,
0.0183968898,
-0.0164672714,
0.014059105,
0.0018563775,
0.0121895364,
-0.0722187459,
0.0080805132,
-0.0109245181,
-0.0177330021,
-0.0030416024,
0.0221226588,
0.0420435108,
-0.0100403195,
0.0214321502,
0.0003653528,
0.061570704,
0.0164944418,
0.0049543167,
-0.0010159233,
-0.0229496155,
0.060978502,
0.0064839865,
-0.0266111102,
-0.0332918987,
0.0420276821,
0.0455283448,
-0.0564074405,
-0.0130716907,
-0.0387877747,
2.42e-7,
0.0772072151,
0.076715216,
-0.0186661277,
-0.0057016984,
-0.0038226417,
0.0146527672,
0.0142952735,
0.0172282998,
0.010841528,
0.0295102056,
0.0037259897,
0.017372394,
0.0352402441,
0.0471641719,
-0.1156382188,
0.0659804642,
-0.0749659017,
0.0451123118,
-0.0626761019,
0.0304207858,
-0.0175081491,
0.0620848611,
0.0278144516,
-0.0209254101,
-0.0261339359,
-0.0216420665,
0.0430188477,
-0.0894176736,
-0.0096969064,
0.0398208164,
0.0225353595,
-0.0194959976,
0.010737082,
0.0353552997,
-0.0258949399,
0.0490941703,
-0.0192508027,
0.0265497044,
0.008032416,
-0.004332222,
-0.0318885669,
-0.0239870101,
-0.0210013278,
-0.1099645644,
0.0635973364,
-0.0515540615,
-0.0543155037,
-0.0267096553,
0.0089375712,
-0.003788763,
0.0706413537,
-0.0222909544,
-0.0155413607,
-0.0062712333,
0.0333105884,
-0.0109669212,
-0.0203866288,
-0.0722142532,
-0.0161041245,
-0.0001416972,
-0.0063637965,
-0.0129893385,
-0.0064352467,
0.0283080246,
0.0479329303,
-0.0086921575,
0.0518123955,
2.090644942e-34,
-0.0110605778,
0.0131795872,
0.0028017005,
-0.0320613831,
0.0415239893,
0.0034646415,
0.0458219014,
0.0176428296,
-0.0001329983,
-0.0404449739,
0.0092560323
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10405v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10405v2 | AnnoBERT: Effectively Representing Multiple Annotators' Label Choices to Improve Hate Speech Detection | 2022-12-20T16:30:11 | 2023-01-10T14:48:54 | Wenjie Yin, Vibhor Agarwal, Aiqi Jiang, Arkaitz Zubiaga, Nishanth Sastry | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SI | Supervised approaches generally rely on majority-based labels. However, it is
hard to achieve high agreement among annotators in subjective tasks such as
hate speech detection. Existing neural network models principally regard labels
as categorical variables, while ignoring the semantic information in diverse
label texts. In this paper, we propose AnnoBERT, a first-of-its-kind
architecture integrating annotator characteristics and label text with a
transformer-based model to detect hate speech, with unique representations
based on each annotator's characteristics via Collaborative Topic Regression
(CTR) and integrate label text to enrich textual representations. During
training, the model associates annotators with their label choices given a
piece of text; during evaluation, when label information is not available, the
model predicts the aggregated label given by the participating annotators by
utilising the learnt association. The proposed approach displayed an advantage
in detecting hate speech, especially in the minority class and edge cases with
annotator disagreement. Improvement in the overall performance is the largest
when the dataset is more label-imbalanced, suggesting its practical value in
identifying real-world hate speech, as the volume of hate speech in-the-wild is
extremely small on social media, when compared with normal (non-hate) speech.
Through ablation studies, we show the relative contributions of annotator
embeddings and label text to the model performance, and tested a range of
alternative annotator embeddings and label text combinations. | [
0.0438049287,
0.0370076634,
-0.0033586633,
0.0222725384,
-0.000265632,
0.0393100306,
0.0468805321,
-0.0078043258,
-0.0260684788,
-0.0674035251,
-0.029743908,
0.0129787456,
-0.0330283083,
-0.0041066362,
-0.0212768577,
-0.0137491878,
0.0207905322,
0.0652363002,
0.0630584434,
-0.0174835827,
0.0784684122,
0.008183552,
0.0155242551,
0.0578602403,
-0.103852801,
0.0200548247,
0.0441203825,
-0.0157736968,
0.0286048744,
0.0212461855,
0.0435158908,
0.0364580452,
0.0168247651,
0.0617403351,
0.0000018196,
-0.0054752002,
-0.0123685915,
0.0045616599,
0.0225290507,
-0.0528121516,
0.0780897811,
-0.0137527548,
0.0054616258,
0.0383007117,
-0.0077996408,
0.0184368826,
0.0670192763,
0.1049495488,
0.081186451,
0.0490375683,
-0.0125051178,
-0.0215839501,
0.0017926528,
0.006650893,
-0.0029154499,
0.0214593075,
0.0216768906,
-0.0319950394,
-0.0605400018,
0.0316675305,
-0.0328226127,
0.0142426016,
0.0566810705,
0.0077759558,
0.0592578724,
-0.0290120374,
-0.0532538332,
-0.0485638529,
0.015285938,
0.0294646062,
-0.0255835205,
0.0034419873,
0.0037572652,
0.0002586775,
0.0124634607,
-0.0368591584,
-0.0111933285,
-0.0056318319,
-0.0137730483,
0.0411531851,
-0.0062043774,
0.0487330519,
0.054170996,
0.0478169434,
0.0167706143,
0.0308293458,
-0.0266206488,
-0.0304803476,
0.006123601,
-0.0060053663,
-0.0206534639,
0.0250710621,
0.0364110656,
-0.0095978118,
-0.0083625447,
0.0062969076,
-0.0536544174,
-0.0652081668,
0.0065801395,
-0.0847228169,
0.0268330146,
0.0397259407,
-0.0576808378,
0.000173549,
0.0155318901,
0.0315147787,
-0.0091113457,
0.0342341214,
-0.0201898534,
-0.0261038281,
-0.0261268038,
0.0024925801,
-0.0063197697,
0.0231215302,
0.007703614,
0.016171122,
-0.0179511402,
-0.0121868169,
-0.059585508,
-0.008738826,
-0.0002561923,
0.0436482355,
0.0008813029,
0.009112617,
-0.000869124,
0.0499243103,
-0.0346854664,
0.0137141347,
-0.0315552838,
-0.0213247444,
0.0230193716,
0.0471000783,
-0.0203889385,
-0.0163148753,
0.0183432121,
0.0406483933,
0.0102578383,
-0.0398147888,
-0.0185501426,
-0.0117245326,
-0.0409464948,
-0.0231509227,
0.025656363,
-0.070319213,
0.0219391193,
-0.0128163621,
-0.026695773,
-0.0766294524,
-0.0006679267,
0.0248383395,
-0.0281954836,
0.0927266255,
0.0164276361,
-0.0632669181,
0.0842794105,
0.0524526015,
0.0124026267,
0.0647486597,
0.0266050082,
0.0429009907,
0.0389566794,
-0.0050972882,
-0.0020692486,
0.0315185413,
0.028331304,
0.0095533011,
-0.0120621491,
-0.0163595304,
-0.0469827801,
-0.0138348779,
0.0030902268,
0.0524579845,
-0.0072309007,
-0.1081938818,
0.0374329351,
0.0569379851,
-0.0306684319,
0.0248913188,
0.016092645,
0.031560488,
-0.0400812924,
-0.0262192544,
-0.0410863571,
0.0223269872,
-0.0131225688,
-0.0633183941,
0.0489843078,
0.0514849871,
-0.0234798919,
-0.0716098845,
-0.0329198502,
-0.017449012,
0.0409129336,
-0.0353720486,
0.0088196713,
0.0236548111,
0.016339913,
0.0388161466,
0.0585521981,
-0.0268371999,
-0.0117875608,
-0.0249592215,
0.0264007486,
0.0210733041,
0.0051421854,
-0.0182724744,
-0.0009016337,
-0.0834204555,
-0.0271310061,
0.036351338,
0.0053771702,
-0.0052847718,
-0.0061018029,
-0.0449042842,
-0.0315930359,
0.037150979,
0.037010543,
0.0348277465,
0.0183098558,
-0.0041623949,
0.0213728137,
0.0352023728,
-0.0270681176,
0.0340122394,
0.0428480282,
-0.0189266335,
0.0169547498,
0.0148517266,
0.0561101772,
0.0401830077,
-0.0366398059,
-0.048652105,
0.0240618624,
-0.0288081989,
-0.0863087177,
0.007777438,
-0.0627423748,
-0.0315093249,
0.0257408358,
-0.0613142811,
-0.0116935009,
0.0443332791,
-0.0092435125,
0.012214642,
0.0442124121,
-0.0376346335,
-0.0346059315,
-0.0319296606,
-0.0633870065,
-0.0519113317,
0.0091481609,
-0.0325962678,
0.0355042517,
-0.0318775475,
-0.0085429549,
0.0142991105,
-0.0556698851,
0.0508957878,
0.0299451593,
-0.0711355582,
-0.0318662785,
0.000023086,
0.0470040478,
0.0181786735,
-0.0232900977,
0.0066207862,
-0.016645059,
-0.0934247375,
-0.0106241405,
-0.0442000069,
-0.0546892397,
0.0030602941,
-0.0144458506,
0.0331217051,
-0.0043003727,
-0.0293207671,
-0.0450073592,
0.0182390511,
0.0409767963,
-0.0077099176,
-0.0444992632,
-0.0108987894,
-0.017679166,
-0.0295720082,
-0.0134238489,
0.0233128276,
0.0172211006,
-0.0614462495,
0.018918613,
-0.0425598733,
-0.0221152492,
0.0025274719,
-0.0252414364,
-0.0262838509,
0.0449764356,
0.0272194799,
-0.0129727386,
0.016521249,
0.0572716147,
0.1015536338,
0.0463436022,
-0.0004879526,
-0.0229441021,
-0.006791316,
-0.0209768489,
0.0365204476,
-0.0149518056,
-0.0364770852,
-0.0262121186,
0.0712287202,
0.0268794354,
-0.0175653547,
-0.0724262595,
0.0011158959,
-0.0713575855,
-0.0377581976,
-0.0461527035,
-0.0728697032,
-0.0112541048,
-0.0382495262,
-0.0231476109,
-0.0565082319,
0.0720959157,
0.0011884528,
0.009609594,
-0.0274823289,
-0.0311079416,
-0.024551088,
0.0238131955,
0.0328824222,
0.0265117679,
-0.0206694528,
0.022781102,
0.0089947432,
-0.013908905,
0.009181303,
-0.0239414219,
-0.0089089321,
0.0020792312,
-0.0121027147,
0.0000614539,
-0.0332681015,
-0.0542745739,
-0.0626873225,
-0.028071519,
-0.0132746575,
-0.0044389442,
-0.0071423762,
-0.0231163222,
-0.0098789986,
0.0228911098,
-0.0001283731,
0.0121960854,
0.0078928769,
0.0433220007,
-0.0106926663,
-0.0019202835,
-0.0069181528,
0.0065022591,
0.008211772,
-0.0257267188,
0.066377148,
-0.0028871319,
0.0011140972,
-0.0533734523,
-0.0006406786,
0.0065808864,
0.0245292652,
-0.0077476888,
-0.0336075723,
0.01835756,
-0.0173044298,
0.0293081924,
0.0908616036,
0.0058687269,
-0.0393620282,
-0.022942083,
0.0050219297,
0.0189276114,
0.0152198076,
-0.0100108469,
-0.090415448,
-0.0049675866,
-0.0238744561,
0.0281039178,
-0.048751466,
-0.0276338886,
-0.0093931118,
-0.0135508832,
0.0013487854,
-0.0119940853,
-0.0296023767,
-0.015889857,
-0.0122058019,
0.0098591074,
-0.0411800183,
0.0520503744,
-0.0517338067,
0.0703831092,
-0.0012071216,
0.0286632553,
-0.0784156471,
-0.0026235518,
0.0033729523,
-0.0126842838,
0.0626469105,
0.0121553428,
0.0266359877,
-0.0273081288,
-0.0027113531,
0.0179028101,
0.0354868434,
-0.009411661,
-0.0382613875,
0.0839223638,
-0.0121563831,
-0.0373960063,
0.0020415138,
0.0190160125,
-0.0036540162,
-0.0108542657,
-0.0099698659,
0.05300235,
0.0301726013,
0.0170169715,
-0.0764223412,
0.0203788728,
-0.0184890497,
0.06851504,
0.0273470543,
-0.0490375124,
0.0400412567,
-0.0614822134,
-0.0123653328,
0.0023667305,
-0.0908444449,
-0.0003612012,
-0.0299289059,
-0.0458079129,
-0.0086537292,
-0.0539341606,
0.0297581479,
0.0225947686,
0.0055171596,
-0.022643635,
0.0119285928,
-0.0297482442,
-0.0340714082,
0.0343212783,
0.0113375941,
0.0251682717,
0.001507884,
-0.000766294,
0.0155080445,
-0.011825541,
-0.0470369533,
0.0056156209,
-0.0498608947,
-0.029723227,
0.0629242063,
0.0589095019,
0.0096242866,
0.0138623165,
-0.0101632932,
-0.0959086567,
0.0419816822,
0.0716779381,
-0.016002208,
0.0018742683,
0.0434383489,
-0.0274749286,
0.001347255,
0.0202338509,
-0.0079120444,
0.0779995173,
0.0208111797,
-0.060500022,
-0.079034768,
-0.0163126793,
-0.0150544457,
-0.0441374891,
0.038980037,
0.0175749175,
-0.0090855621,
-0.0384892002,
-0.0221792161,
0.0228771362,
-0.0591747575,
-0.0243359562,
0.0062492536,
0.010425847,
-0.033539094,
-0.0530037656,
-0.0260495804,
-0.010160788,
0.0399975181,
-0.029710073,
0.0228289124,
0.0515086316,
0.0131059792,
-0.0144291157,
0.0456023216,
-0.0228321813,
0.0221715812,
0.0324065909,
-0.0114588914,
0.0032425134,
0.0221158434,
0.0162177105,
0.0140029714,
0.0403627492,
-0.011911572,
0.0023468391,
-0.0110290097,
-0.0396958068,
-0.0060222964,
-0.0216259826,
-0.0094944024,
0.0302253962,
0.0267670341,
-0.0256988108,
-0.0173096266,
0.0028226706,
-0.008239951,
-0.0381358936,
0.0194590613,
0.0239015874,
-0.0185979418,
0.0009084291,
0.0165047757,
-0.0016019687,
0.0148957856,
0.0322241485,
-0.0347431824,
-0.0371216908,
0.0359853543,
0.0363728777,
0.0372197218,
0.0278831292,
0.0075462316,
-0.0274444055,
-0.0223501045,
0.0267364122,
-0.0649601147,
0.0368451625,
0.014468642,
0.0185302272,
0.0494259037,
-0.0232676025,
0.0096624112,
0.0223717559,
-0.0088441195,
0.020596046,
-0.0490415879,
-0.0095567619,
-5.703493815e-33,
-0.0314932205,
-0.0184028707,
-0.0325318016,
-0.0059615346,
0.012360841,
0.0001241911,
0.0406503789,
0.0215661116,
-0.0043213088,
0.0437983014,
0.0186561067,
0.029074071,
0.0017066407,
0.0104830116,
0.0077775479,
-0.0289136469,
0.0683289394,
-0.0160284024,
-0.0082570808,
-0.0159550942,
0.0480688959,
0.006973533,
0.0300193094,
-0.1373325288,
0.0140407896,
0.0179578196,
-0.0301800221,
0.0020901535,
0.0319190472,
0.0758965537,
0.0066983956,
0.1022612974,
0.0352458842,
-0.048853945,
-0.0064980085,
0.055891078,
-0.0641119331,
-0.0209804624,
-0.0204078071,
0.0165547822,
0.0130369551,
-0.0075957873,
0.0605902709,
0.0027820098,
-0.0242787115,
-0.0272964276,
0.0647570193,
-0.0143170692,
0.0110173514,
-0.0435907878,
-0.0494226068,
0.0287875365,
-0.031092789,
-0.0077031422,
0.0193662085,
0.0064293751,
0.0422442183,
0.022180995,
-0.0712789968,
0.009754546,
-0.04247915,
0.0010038266,
-0.0237352811,
0.0047261366,
-0.0340221226,
0.061920993,
0.0124902232,
0.0205773059,
-0.0324711204,
-0.0120784538,
0.0216975752,
0.0259951111,
0.0888924971,
0.0744873136,
0.0258776285,
-0.0404503569,
-0.0321730971,
-0.0002530965,
0.0449184179,
-0.024409974,
0.0315139182,
-0.0044811228,
-0.0557146072,
-0.0408456475,
-0.032567516,
-0.0661191046,
-0.0390396714,
-0.0229034424,
0.024938181,
0.0082812123,
-0.0147614134,
0.0166670885,
0.0166576933,
-0.0316415355,
-0.0042857244,
0.0530247241,
-0.011081581,
0.0003524878,
0.0310589708,
0.0263783112,
-0.070262894,
0.0055186907,
0.0213132203,
-0.016950177,
0.0247215834,
-0.0157395191,
0.1039389223,
0.0240825061,
-0.0767118037,
0.0116429385,
0.009341564,
0.0085697994,
-0.0110058878,
0.0338085666,
-0.0069708698,
0.0532961823,
-0.0301917568,
0.0022311842,
0.0171592254,
0.0141699854,
-0.0228993259,
-0.0325778872,
-0.0468245596,
-0.0181934536,
-0.0008144173,
-0.0326600075,
0.022105325,
0.026541464,
0.020114556,
-0.0756575316,
0.0187582877,
-0.0574803352,
2.522e-7,
0.013746989,
0.0276743453,
0.0032505477,
-0.0529714003,
0.0149452155,
0.0606798343,
0.0548081063,
0.0344616212,
0.0105263665,
-0.0339637138,
-0.0111514609,
0.0586547703,
-0.0111189717,
0.0693462938,
-0.0008859799,
-0.0255415272,
-0.0746155456,
0.0285476837,
-0.0225375965,
0.0137503389,
0.0155839706,
0.1156551912,
0.0920735002,
-0.0394636653,
-0.0143973501,
0.0189935435,
0.0231885705,
-0.0399457142,
-0.0091855526,
-0.0305815674,
0.0631430373,
0.0039704912,
0.0211003963,
-0.0073223137,
0.0040022009,
0.0223854929,
0.0252351575,
0.0339337066,
0.0089174248,
-0.0211274996,
0.0155305834,
0.0255935583,
-0.0186364241,
-0.02413675,
0.0404435657,
-0.0212052763,
-0.0217242073,
-0.0634783283,
-0.0130961314,
-0.0011627966,
0.0812462121,
0.0005084761,
-0.0086898236,
-0.0268337391,
0.0194684435,
-0.0115373926,
0.0073089143,
-0.1045528799,
-0.0113001699,
-0.026746463,
-0.0536007285,
-0.0255993959,
-0.0417437814,
0.0046485844,
0.041536849,
0.0339322314,
0.0282514803,
1.819865916e-34,
0.0261197668,
-0.03415934,
-0.0008885171,
-0.0078769634,
0.0061791721,
0.0161808468,
-0.0339890346,
-0.0029303296,
0.0464362614,
-0.0026603441,
-0.0096134143
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10403v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10403v2 | Towards Reasoning in Large Language Models: A Survey | 2022-12-20T16:29:03 | 2023-05-26T17:59:33 | Jie Huang, Kevin Chen-Chuan Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Reasoning is a fundamental aspect of human intelligence that plays a crucial
role in activities such as problem solving, decision making, and critical
thinking. In recent years, large language models (LLMs) have made significant
progress in natural language processing, and there is observation that these
models may exhibit reasoning abilities when they are sufficiently large.
However, it is not yet clear to what extent LLMs are capable of reasoning. This
paper provides a comprehensive overview of the current state of knowledge on
reasoning in LLMs, including techniques for improving and eliciting reasoning
in these models, methods and benchmarks for evaluating reasoning abilities,
findings and implications of previous research in this field, and suggestions
on future directions. Our aim is to provide a detailed and up-to-date review of
this topic and stimulate meaningful discussion and future work. | [
0.0427562185,
0.0374824218,
-0.0052420208,
0.0578778833,
-0.0683532134,
0.0404428393,
0.026742138,
0.0172747616,
0.0273005273,
-0.0444920808,
-0.0073993253,
-0.0392801017,
-0.0071048359,
0.0116765099,
0.0199128035,
-0.0177726485,
0.0266704671,
-0.0792519897,
0.058400277,
-0.0040270882,
-0.035574872,
0.0069589424,
-0.0042269435,
0.0207843855,
0.0275486223,
-0.0308654979,
0.0148380212,
-0.0114454022,
0.0165751949,
-0.0215417724,
-0.0492470115,
0.022713339,
0.0213718917,
0.0017393854,
0.0000019572,
-0.0734038949,
0.0046427837,
-0.0101101846,
-0.0611997694,
0.0000999399,
-0.0021172129,
0.0176584534,
-0.0040482436,
0.0449832641,
-0.0225471891,
0.0264463909,
-0.0038550929,
0.0646558255,
0.0372030772,
0.0466454923,
0.0072828033,
-0.0486034192,
0.0138530815,
0.0078902757,
0.0083163297,
-0.0223396923,
0.0380155295,
0.0629185289,
0.0512689315,
-0.0007207422,
0.0058112387,
0.0163667575,
0.0272613075,
-0.0224794932,
-0.0452683009,
0.0292266179,
0.004434132,
-0.0284431688,
0.0293648057,
0.0327291079,
0.0086544761,
0.012625942,
-0.0137545587,
0.0113346381,
-0.0071452167,
0.0182849858,
-0.0461925454,
0.0634319484,
-0.0239054989,
0.0144139705,
0.0487981178,
-0.0051293341,
0.0437825657,
0.0346224718,
-0.0798455328,
0.1268188506,
0.0003182059,
-0.0179890748,
0.0218539145,
-0.0237467084,
-0.0534811392,
-0.0568135045,
-0.0062778443,
0.0723613128,
-0.0281315409,
0.0300267879,
0.0308899842,
0.0433856472,
0.0202615298,
-0.0324270017,
0.0237538628,
0.028286526,
0.0310078729,
0.0639878139,
-0.0458425656,
0.0813753605,
-0.0356530994,
0.0423478447,
-0.0172297619,
-0.0276357569,
-0.0471607074,
-0.0426669978,
0.0110142278,
0.0336190127,
-0.0155193862,
-0.015507332,
-0.0280235764,
0.0168417059,
0.002593697,
0.0121999569,
0.0071281176,
-0.0097304219,
0.0333724245,
-0.067479305,
-0.0897256583,
-0.003818915,
-0.0237701684,
0.0319222249,
-0.0035429318,
-0.0212482736,
0.0053418484,
-0.011973558,
0.0001463244,
-0.0489133969,
0.0184774697,
0.0633490086,
0.0251145158,
-0.0198054351,
-0.0550619848,
-0.0447369553,
-0.0091426801,
-0.1057125255,
0.0109786997,
-0.0519438796,
-0.0136939939,
0.0369189195,
0.0104158269,
-0.0372425169,
0.0132320663,
-0.0072955391,
-0.0428413823,
0.0831862912,
0.0331777222,
0.0309549589,
0.0166357905,
0.0168594029,
0.0123365261,
0.0393258855,
0.0638836473,
-0.0018572599,
0.0023872466,
0.0015617599,
-0.0055899452,
0.0078932242,
-0.0318334922,
-0.0388211533,
-0.0373216756,
0.0047480483,
-0.0214847177,
0.0122913094,
-0.0345230922,
0.0727406964,
-0.0170763358,
-0.0101781003,
0.0407003462,
0.0827899948,
0.0131819639,
0.0153032746,
0.0553421304,
-0.0165120885,
0.0056699468,
-0.0126923779,
-0.0432102866,
0.0445284396,
-0.0371445604,
-0.0032785104,
0.0105900178,
0.0207641646,
-0.0290102325,
-0.0747071207,
-0.0612336136,
0.0157892704,
0.0174139291,
0.0189771652,
0.057830479,
-0.0353893787,
-0.0275873747,
0.0003076951,
0.0176994558,
-0.0328508429,
-0.0066526621,
-0.0922788158,
0.0614480563,
0.0657963082,
0.0402295254,
0.0042506889,
-0.0235363618,
0.0111767324,
0.0048732301,
0.0202116854,
0.0096201776,
-0.0120186498,
-0.0226147827,
-0.0430495776,
-0.0011165264,
0.0009025268,
0.0063708043,
-0.001964709,
-0.0041470495,
-0.0087503325,
0.0080441209,
-0.0318249837,
0.0001073223,
0.0134958299,
-0.0440516137,
0.0011536721,
-0.0504576266,
0.0170592479,
0.031980671,
-0.0089900894,
-0.0017180321,
0.0422839895,
0.0223416556,
-0.0389801823,
-0.0372631028,
0.0243387148,
-0.01418796,
-0.0128904684,
0.0252501573,
-0.0130591271,
-0.0171203073,
0.008795768,
0.0080801928,
-0.010459438,
0.0178070981,
-0.0222275946,
0.017112812,
-0.0523867197,
0.0359981842,
-0.0155386776,
-0.0235076081,
-0.0156759657,
0.1088301018,
0.002591531,
0.0211509056,
0.005882354,
0.0121389301,
0.0112484982,
-0.0473395251,
-0.0024678227,
0.0357161574,
-0.0072865784,
-0.0212929938,
-0.0158428643,
-0.0171078537,
-0.0501616597,
-0.0292252805,
-0.0462296084,
0.0088671083,
0.0068132323,
0.0205679685,
-0.0110301254,
-0.0218955837,
0.0036315059,
0.0351652056,
-0.0080252076,
-0.0153653156,
0.0620578863,
0.027410794,
0.034017805,
-0.0124907801,
-0.0243632235,
0.0073712426,
-0.0158219729,
-0.0398861542,
0.0563419312,
0.0303794406,
0.0047485055,
-0.0530614816,
0.0408956036,
-0.0634857565,
-0.0060763219,
-0.0089126946,
-0.027072005,
0.0212909691,
-0.0108173899,
0.0192242805,
0.1003718972,
-0.0050114114,
0.0326622054,
0.0512170307,
-0.0162943546,
-0.0409835652,
0.0183013659,
-0.0259864628,
-0.0032895289,
-0.0416109897,
-0.0495908968,
-0.0491427332,
0.062713623,
-0.0249155611,
-0.0178952236,
-0.0478815325,
0.0481539592,
-0.022139499,
-0.0022307788,
-0.0188250784,
-0.0249350742,
0.0067127566,
0.0916083455,
-0.0437151194,
-0.0197878145,
0.0606893823,
-0.0145261902,
0.0214097761,
-0.0421210639,
0.0021782424,
-0.0369629972,
0.0796243399,
-0.029592976,
0.0023564594,
-0.0202963185,
-0.0171320233,
-0.007032067,
-0.0490964726,
0.0015536544,
-0.0273587368,
0.0415823907,
-0.0517606176,
0.0259289443,
0.0128867142,
-0.0248649046,
-0.0329789445,
0.0052950736,
-0.0815232098,
0.0152217131,
0.0070315273,
-0.0147423996,
-0.0300136488,
0.0430401005,
0.0156914946,
-0.036440637,
0.0012679732,
-0.0116345035,
-0.002854987,
-0.0048210383,
0.0032562686,
0.0311305374,
0.0555816926,
-0.0478193685,
0.0659758076,
0.0504523665,
0.0258899741,
-0.0003909474,
-0.0251081437,
0.0317721777,
0.0124359438,
0.0010255525,
-0.0120040579,
0.0152722597,
0.0335719809,
-0.0646876171,
-0.0074572572,
0.1384301633,
0.0503998064,
0.0277260765,
0.0008539858,
-0.0325826034,
-0.0058874134,
0.0334587395,
0.028132556,
-0.014678305,
-0.0397391766,
0.0330628604,
-0.0273883939,
-0.0336230993,
-0.0590606071,
-0.0134431599,
-0.1201440617,
0.0585493781,
0.002467738,
0.0205653105,
-0.0460251309,
-0.0509904362,
0.011877127,
0.0080582453,
-0.0313744172,
0.0145479552,
0.0202713422,
-0.015572398,
0.0298534781,
-0.0191585422,
-0.0443033837,
0.0505709462,
-0.0458784811,
0.0350908376,
0.0337159261,
0.0634180233,
0.021521965,
-0.06418138,
0.0251870714,
0.0014365966,
0.0279644243,
-0.0212965254,
0.0048174057,
-0.0039424328,
0.0070053809,
-0.0351856835,
0.0267614089,
-0.0170512795,
-0.0463219136,
-0.0043117534,
0.1027004048,
-0.0396612324,
-0.0287782922,
-0.0065740994,
0.0279392973,
-0.0544502921,
0.0810075477,
0.0061864322,
0.0006501442,
-0.0509000309,
-0.0374822207,
-0.0672144592,
-0.0235671382,
-0.0373722501,
0.039755147,
0.0382040031,
0.0121521521,
-0.0406982712,
-0.0111663202,
0.0467533916,
0.0381565318,
-0.0075290781,
-0.0011896695,
0.0189066771,
0.0088347178,
-0.0267748982,
0.0257291291,
-0.0444587804,
0.0341319479,
-0.0483511575,
0.0282076616,
0.0179939047,
-0.0505613014,
-0.0381426923,
-0.0100400476,
-0.0609232634,
-0.0655219927,
-0.0105159935,
0.0002712582,
0.033128228,
-0.00030806,
-0.0236543454,
-0.0556643382,
0.0032563717,
-0.0108873537,
-0.0177828074,
0.0075195134,
0.0211048592,
0.0255189966,
0.0298657324,
0.0446059369,
-0.0109822182,
0.0295973662,
0.0389668569,
0.0388367437,
-0.021888284,
-0.0232328586,
0.020358704,
0.0353504382,
0.0099026291,
0.053304147,
-0.0269516762,
-0.0339292996,
0.0207954273,
-0.0251451656,
-0.0473527573,
-0.0226755999,
0.0108430022,
0.0209334493,
-0.0067531946,
-0.0291609839,
-0.0417260453,
-0.0161184967,
0.0254218969,
0.0154592441,
0.0217875689,
0.0031211674,
-0.0132490406,
0.006813921,
-0.0195671506,
0.016034022,
0.0078585176,
-0.0163812693,
0.054463163,
0.0201170444,
0.0886374041,
0.0141932042,
-0.0107666515,
-0.0637467131,
-0.0309094675,
-0.078805618,
-0.0966349766,
0.0523395687,
0.0275751688,
0.021399267,
-0.0030797678,
-0.0111345593,
-0.0528312139,
0.0004253897,
-0.004221512,
0.0203101654,
0.0360825062,
-0.0295484494,
0.0470612273,
0.0394296832,
-0.0200737547,
-0.016284043,
0.0338565446,
-0.0012173372,
0.0360179879,
-0.0101536494,
-0.0592717603,
-0.0273937806,
-0.0495198928,
-0.0094142687,
-0.0129143754,
-0.0076019741,
0.0436227396,
-0.0732881874,
-0.084224008,
0.0014270575,
0.029361628,
0.008044038,
-0.0048587439,
-0.0356610268,
0.0678133219,
-0.0070322412,
-0.0214589834,
-0.0367702805,
-0.0230980255,
-0.0417399034,
0.0225101691,
-0.0026351516,
-5.983115635e-33,
-0.020986734,
-0.0520817339,
0.0416284315,
-0.0368493386,
0.0032999758,
-0.0289852247,
-0.03189734,
0.0106652314,
-0.0224306472,
0.0443200916,
-0.0169908963,
0.0158059243,
0.0170125384,
-0.0175570715,
-0.0138831418,
-0.0109094791,
0.0052413321,
0.0325390399,
-0.0209166799,
-0.0011669931,
0.0449440219,
-0.0016577796,
0.008983979,
-0.0317565911,
0.0157812349,
0.010919312,
0.0024628073,
0.0670554489,
-0.0815491229,
0.0760226101,
-0.0112268338,
-0.0273817703,
0.0470883362,
-0.0310850143,
0.0050631803,
0.0347122476,
-0.0581675656,
-0.0001833225,
0.0565518066,
-0.0356753953,
-0.0212073643,
-0.0489474013,
0.0054059122,
0.0238772724,
-0.0308399387,
-0.027412571,
0.0255756043,
-0.0549725518,
0.0252654534,
0.0148483235,
-0.0412833206,
0.0297088642,
-0.0245933738,
-0.0109723993,
0.0105085615,
-0.0007840432,
-0.045246549,
0.0402944721,
-0.0038611586,
0.0451165736,
0.0216134936,
-0.0141652059,
0.0668086484,
-0.0022763088,
-0.0151806064,
0.0676611513,
0.0040649017,
-0.0031972278,
-0.0367787145,
-0.015866885,
0.0073097837,
0.0716638789,
0.0564480573,
0.0128598604,
0.0110997325,
0.0105713168,
-0.0647648498,
-0.0173185226,
-0.0212960932,
0.0706565231,
0.0851107314,
0.0072641275,
-0.0359342508,
-0.0199501198,
-0.0621844865,
0.0295947585,
-0.0525210835,
-0.0138640329,
0.0283887144,
-0.0287660696,
-0.017551424,
-0.0147487028,
0.0422655791,
-0.0370340087,
-0.0044801366,
0.0344980173,
0.0150832431,
0.0023016664,
-0.0278820489,
0.0348127037,
-0.0445941091,
-0.0219660997,
-0.0102257151,
-0.0020207437,
0.0026783282,
-0.0134232426,
0.0131897107,
0.0000918515,
-0.0242186785,
-0.0285721458,
-0.0610111617,
-0.0145405857,
0.0012778012,
0.030716788,
0.0524848364,
0.0301252585,
-0.0018640381,
0.0133040389,
-0.0112668006,
-0.0135868527,
-0.008485782,
0.0117105506,
-0.0181573369,
0.0163863096,
-0.0187779758,
-0.0098541155,
-0.0360315219,
0.0055027562,
-0.0013875236,
-0.0318671688,
0.0014076666,
0.0356680192,
2.665e-7,
0.0135845458,
0.0685550794,
-0.0177133381,
0.0126929246,
0.0151028018,
0.0235083885,
-0.038322553,
-0.0615561754,
0.0488427542,
-0.0199181177,
-0.0059737377,
0.0718211904,
0.0470483825,
0.0228907894,
-0.0347098187,
0.0064857099,
-0.0104437051,
-0.0423206314,
-0.0516972095,
0.0223665293,
0.069602035,
0.0705743507,
0.0230904203,
-0.019575892,
0.0145153794,
-0.083747752,
0.0212606024,
-0.0287246685,
-0.0118366489,
0.0073650358,
0.0316145048,
-0.0026920827,
0.0198788587,
0.0542653985,
0.0245108884,
0.0109796757,
-0.0065480322,
0.0605198592,
0.0008996202,
0.0142109366,
-0.0433357172,
-0.0082837688,
0.0055019562,
-0.0513094291,
0.1086924002,
-0.0521515422,
-0.0639829859,
0.0153127573,
0.042368792,
-0.0506907925,
-0.0268248357,
0.0050484263,
0.0156682283,
0.0033707749,
0.0028890294,
-0.031108208,
0.0192372873,
-0.1005549654,
0.0146043766,
0.0019538661,
-0.0599678867,
-0.0622205921,
-0.0217246059,
0.0024918816,
0.0666434094,
-0.0526898764,
-0.0354563817,
2.571351419e-34,
0.0277126953,
0.0028140433,
0.0065743243,
0.0295081344,
0.0775598437,
0.0288878009,
-0.0096030226,
0.0126573006,
0.029763706,
-0.1170552894,
0.0003824965
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10400v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10400v1 | Contrastive Learning Reduces Hallucination in Conversations | 2022-12-20T16:26:18 | 2022-12-20T16:26:18 | Weiwei Sun, Zhengliang Shi, Shen Gao, Pengjie Ren, Maarten de Rijke, Zhaochun Ren | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Pre-trained language models (LMs) store knowledge in their parameters and can
generate informative responses when used in conversational systems. However,
LMs suffer from the problem of "hallucination:" they may generate
plausible-looking statements that are irrelevant or factually incorrect. To
address this problem, we propose a contrastive learning scheme, named MixCL. A
novel mixed contrastive objective is proposed to explicitly optimize the
implicit knowledge elicitation process of LMs, and thus reduce their
hallucination in conversations. We also examine negative sampling strategies of
retrieved hard negatives and model-generated negatives. We conduct experiments
on Wizard-of-Wikipedia, a public, open-domain knowledge-grounded dialogue
benchmark, and assess the effectiveness of MixCL. MixCL effectively reduces the
hallucination of LMs in conversations and achieves the highest performance
among LM-based dialogue agents in terms of relevancy and factuality. We show
that MixCL achieves comparable performance to state-of-the-art KB-based
approaches while enjoying notable advantages in terms of efficiency and
scalability. | [
0.0532000288,
0.0149601512,
-0.019164687,
0.0332201533,
-0.0600134321,
0.0259789433,
-0.0203189328,
-0.0038865176,
0.0323744453,
-0.0657843798,
-0.0382764824,
-0.0433760546,
0.0016422605,
0.0042693177,
0.0006349609,
-0.0741985142,
0.0335824937,
-0.0393430181,
0.0335402042,
-0.0391449705,
0.0031696544,
0.0068289647,
-0.0496260859,
0.0006317007,
-0.0028218455,
-0.0323554203,
-0.0159775112,
-0.0118686054,
0.0018084326,
-0.0096902279,
0.0483069494,
0.0634440258,
-0.0155752823,
0.0319201611,
0.000002007,
-0.0472394116,
0.0174955688,
-0.0306839664,
-0.0289582536,
-0.0067711528,
0.0350403897,
0.0150146,
0.0001095508,
0.0225717556,
-0.0601897985,
-0.0052839136,
0.0312090479,
0.1148644611,
0.0694603622,
0.0702308044,
-0.0021753183,
-0.0428412333,
0.0140516255,
0.0224343911,
0.0299377255,
-0.0274741258,
0.0302645322,
0.0156616531,
-0.0370174758,
-0.0113504361,
0.0279384404,
0.0364786126,
0.0095600272,
-0.004536767,
0.0054167798,
0.0331071354,
-0.0648245513,
-0.0038485124,
-0.0068776137,
0.1229112521,
0.0279590935,
-0.0339395702,
-0.0049953195,
-0.0091343066,
0.013383721,
0.0053253411,
-0.0358406156,
-0.0024880222,
-0.0056584184,
-0.0017727271,
-0.0120941177,
0.0305409506,
0.0065304488,
0.0222914144,
-0.0282295346,
0.0588258579,
0.0052323481,
-0.0458914675,
0.0268322155,
0.0056403517,
0.0203604028,
-0.0594770052,
0.0141646182,
0.0250329059,
-0.0384719707,
0.0181500483,
-0.0124168536,
-0.0207790062,
0.0451492034,
-0.0923343897,
-0.0323778801,
0.0017016208,
-0.0340089276,
0.0740598962,
-0.0177832507,
-0.0008697259,
-0.0131626921,
0.0183209311,
0.0216801222,
-0.019212747,
-0.0308401473,
0.003584289,
-0.038672138,
0.0620393492,
-0.0276280306,
-0.0104544573,
0.023625616,
0.0240046997,
-0.0214665383,
0.0213378128,
-0.0052198321,
0.0203408599,
-0.018596625,
-0.0332161523,
-0.0639773533,
0.0412626155,
-0.0447462201,
0.0191508532,
0.0044742976,
-0.0588507466,
-0.0135097476,
0.0171768833,
0.0115662497,
-0.0056283479,
-0.0096394038,
0.0495014638,
0.0061005065,
-0.0045244903,
-0.0522298962,
-0.0227631163,
-0.0122009106,
-0.0637398362,
-0.0249930136,
-0.0424242169,
0.0211296435,
0.0186886732,
-0.0227731951,
-0.0557390116,
0.0197591465,
0.0142254485,
-0.0505075231,
0.0828993917,
-0.0299948622,
-0.0215753037,
0.0388370045,
0.021082595,
-0.0507168658,
0.0670388117,
-0.005955196,
-0.0097297616,
0.0345863029,
0.0013404541,
0.0440082848,
-0.0316758789,
0.0596803129,
-0.0083910264,
0.0184340049,
0.0267880894,
-0.0079174442,
0.0065959473,
0.0020742347,
0.0853072777,
-0.0334620327,
-0.0357706621,
0.0830330923,
0.0017236564,
-0.0208591558,
0.0265239421,
0.0143199302,
0.0358398035,
0.0037171019,
0.0361053869,
-0.0417154059,
0.031578362,
-0.0747679472,
-0.0036993446,
0.0491098128,
-0.0073334388,
-0.0559230298,
-0.0342846736,
0.021489488,
-0.0247222129,
0.0421523042,
0.0005799623,
0.0432299487,
0.0416394919,
-0.0854226127,
0.0894720852,
0.0580450632,
-0.0438511819,
-0.0180073883,
-0.0414800532,
0.0247320477,
0.0648533851,
0.0263536386,
-0.0279127639,
-0.0313964561,
-0.0349335112,
0.0165390689,
0.0767174587,
0.0594824925,
-0.027989367,
0.0286724232,
-0.0461591892,
-0.017438408,
-0.0476340912,
0.006051715,
0.0318005458,
0.0101448791,
0.0266380608,
0.0199252442,
-0.0238268804,
0.0055095311,
0.0173383579,
-0.0278329141,
-0.007946576,
-0.0006254266,
-0.001367107,
0.0093832063,
0.0116172815,
-0.007967514,
0.0116663864,
0.0212709643,
0.0041615563,
-0.0455252528,
0.0035086202,
-0.070733808,
-0.0871573016,
0.0463878363,
-0.0160104223,
0.0190661047,
0.0227475855,
-0.021472523,
-0.0392811634,
0.055954624,
-0.0236359704,
0.0929531232,
-0.0369797237,
0.0202377476,
0.0064383433,
-0.000425026,
0.006700892,
0.0833275765,
-0.0194007531,
-0.014820016,
0.0374315828,
0.0141874636,
-0.0118083777,
-0.0261552464,
-0.0151290828,
-0.0000460371,
0.0301731639,
0.0283032544,
0.0150396284,
-0.0368760005,
-0.0742236823,
0.0059181741,
-0.0876153633,
-0.0097949002,
-0.0302984361,
-0.0212427061,
0.0179556888,
-0.016601989,
0.0265824329,
-0.024941124,
-0.0351632461,
0.0089243054,
-0.006702119,
0.0209483653,
0.0200430099,
0.0515756495,
0.0166101512,
-0.0219391547,
0.0279997364,
0.0235536825,
0.0271173492,
-0.0241607651,
0.0161187164,
-0.0395128988,
0.0691535398,
-0.0630309805,
0.0401646718,
-0.0175389554,
-0.0101995869,
0.0014213138,
-0.0037228507,
0.0102751777,
0.0479295403,
0.0613446459,
-0.0088857664,
0.0042993175,
-0.0304649509,
-0.0668662712,
0.0165031068,
-0.0248857532,
0.0190160796,
-0.0263823662,
0.0104737319,
-0.0106952935,
0.0605091974,
0.0038150935,
0.0151605196,
-0.0757737458,
0.0352474526,
0.0190741085,
-0.0550969914,
-0.0008591169,
0.0118623013,
-0.0237629805,
0.040051572,
-0.0360827819,
-0.0216784645,
0.0907232538,
-0.0097357081,
-0.0073680836,
-0.0250298008,
0.0238271821,
0.0143642249,
-0.0058448464,
-0.0488371067,
-0.0034846794,
0.0066623744,
-0.0132939573,
-0.0321876034,
-0.0486656465,
0.0149511071,
-0.0555009916,
0.0148784854,
-0.0304396823,
0.00400043,
0.0376817174,
-0.0434442051,
-0.086433582,
-0.0494205989,
-0.018963661,
-0.0030190353,
-0.0097147282,
0.0132086528,
-0.0286989585,
0.0236574057,
0.0150591126,
0.0316868871,
-0.001863512,
-0.0203877203,
0.0092463149,
0.015313522,
0.0495731235,
-0.0052689863,
0.063594766,
-0.0080045341,
0.0737873986,
0.0479058251,
0.0143673578,
-0.026610354,
0.0070201564,
-0.034056332,
0.0035587512,
-0.0253119543,
-0.0322520137,
-0.0059374711,
0.0060803019,
-0.0281541776,
-0.0147839468,
0.1305777878,
0.0214249883,
-0.0622524917,
-0.0266834404,
-0.0435656421,
0.0294689182,
0.0020499125,
-0.0104645947,
-0.052036956,
-0.0231573097,
-0.0189188961,
0.0208589137,
0.0012741222,
-0.0591477901,
-0.000852165,
-0.1327572465,
-0.011003565,
0.0150959156,
-0.0188651606,
-0.0211247411,
-0.0137043362,
0.0068338085,
0.00057522,
0.0372274555,
0.0168623794,
0.0374915451,
-0.0162170902,
0.0010924437,
-0.0069611743,
-0.0317139737,
0.0196023863,
0.0000339989,
0.0616925806,
0.0515234694,
0.0518272072,
0.0225834511,
-0.0506846644,
0.0212628767,
-0.0463516004,
-0.0154359024,
-0.0303943977,
0.0649146885,
-0.0274235308,
-0.0024218196,
-0.0252531264,
0.0189697798,
-0.0328171812,
-0.0286632776,
-0.0095898509,
0.0494591631,
-0.0236904006,
-0.0006227701,
0.0127799157,
0.055210039,
0.075224936,
0.0963433236,
0.0102106631,
-0.0211698767,
-0.0229235012,
-0.0252469685,
0.015201007,
-0.0271769781,
-0.0362072177,
-0.0046739704,
0.0511066839,
0.025541462,
-0.0780061856,
-0.0731479898,
0.0112712579,
0.0424963795,
-0.0182558801,
0.0216945168,
-0.0043467688,
0.0047915042,
-0.0079349019,
-0.0046027401,
-0.0568337739,
-0.0077494048,
-0.0404800437,
-0.0637478977,
0.0482578576,
-0.0387777388,
-0.0083105592,
-0.0064494475,
-0.032729689,
-0.0850564539,
-0.0028360691,
0.0954449028,
0.0211565346,
0.0782161877,
-0.0104694171,
-0.0408366285,
0.052172821,
0.0338065252,
-0.0498808287,
-0.0155814243,
0.05721955,
0.0328859314,
0.0231273361,
0.0544117391,
-0.0427519418,
0.0026877185,
0.0138599994,
0.0455847792,
-0.0592819117,
-0.0275127366,
0.0167828705,
-0.0237332713,
0.0567032471,
0.0213616267,
-0.0022378177,
-0.0088375071,
0.0346535593,
-0.0287323296,
-0.0338146649,
-0.0347155668,
0.012611852,
-0.0104353204,
-0.0119303837,
-0.0054445257,
0.0024901587,
-0.0480535589,
0.0118635232,
-0.003200982,
-0.0323529951,
0.0621161535,
0.0022255145,
0.0308495965,
-0.0203768127,
-0.0327623151,
0.0219346248,
0.0350626111,
0.0544990189,
0.0115408534,
0.0829267651,
0.0179542284,
-0.0287047736,
-0.0043842886,
0.0001538914,
-0.0484915599,
-0.05451129,
-0.0075474116,
0.022177374,
0.025292905,
0.0037212858,
0.0615089424,
-0.0214776453,
0.0009294423,
-0.0082056075,
0.0320679732,
0.0282961987,
-0.0181177277,
0.0194872655,
0.0152301071,
-0.0192526225,
0.0491401665,
0.0628099814,
-0.0711089522,
0.0499384105,
0.0004383849,
-0.0010457317,
-0.0486060977,
-0.0274378099,
-0.0265334137,
0.0318176523,
-0.0048888568,
0.0313993096,
-0.0624652356,
-0.0557782277,
0.006409822,
-0.0047407136,
-0.0218077023,
-0.0089469086,
0.0471422896,
0.0483144745,
0.0034437224,
-0.0100999298,
-0.0457275584,
0.0219043195,
-0.0054189856,
0.0113527635,
-0.0232419856,
-6.627430538e-33,
-0.0398039706,
-0.0267692357,
0.006171186,
0.0025229321,
-0.0017895903,
-0.0296076722,
-0.0243631769,
0.0146981711,
-0.0337806828,
0.029245792,
0.0008663613,
0.0439579338,
0.0108799953,
0.0121964216,
-0.0412540287,
-0.0378548913,
0.0457692258,
-0.0030359831,
-0.0275638606,
0.0529630817,
0.0245640427,
0.0439428948,
0.0289730877,
-0.1067171022,
0.0234653521,
-0.0431861877,
0.0131390942,
0.0478819832,
0.0185839552,
0.0297323726,
-0.0366476402,
0.0472561829,
0.0011463752,
-0.0491927974,
-0.025765622,
-0.0143921059,
-0.0572573915,
-0.0258031934,
0.0418126881,
0.0121519594,
-0.0242016725,
-0.0012781904,
0.0168839134,
-0.0089386059,
0.0159634966,
0.0003043938,
0.0042730812,
-0.0133963414,
-0.0142518301,
0.03424206,
-0.0708810836,
0.010907257,
0.0011173823,
-0.042849008,
-0.0039502536,
0.0500779897,
0.0196834393,
-0.0068341545,
-0.0751030669,
0.0362749547,
0.0119760148,
-0.0470597483,
0.0346633047,
0.0077872179,
0.0176531114,
0.0664940998,
0.0317301601,
0.0380534977,
-0.0025270821,
-0.0409308076,
-0.0037071707,
0.0202498864,
0.0155058205,
0.0700453147,
-0.0025232898,
0.0077468711,
-0.0281430297,
-0.0103959991,
-0.0160801727,
0.0203002281,
0.0322678909,
-0.0026250111,
-0.0388749316,
-0.0181512199,
-0.0242248252,
-0.0101459278,
-0.0312749743,
-0.0421797447,
0.0160880983,
0.0234033298,
-0.0284881145,
-0.014355259,
0.023859011,
-0.0398367941,
-0.017812781,
0.0670107305,
-0.0285000559,
-0.0270825159,
-0.0248616375,
0.0002617966,
-0.0672071129,
0.008680013,
0.0258671641,
0.0037096927,
0.0038021964,
0.03960355,
0.0128054926,
-0.0159200579,
-0.0602125861,
-0.0011546866,
-0.0192602891,
0.0360700898,
0.0011298691,
0.0081174579,
0.0371229686,
0.0145818051,
-0.0212369859,
0.049515374,
0.0181520078,
-0.0275408067,
-0.0415446274,
-0.0421646051,
0.0033658629,
0.0080892136,
-0.0468133427,
-0.0329890884,
-0.0088529531,
-0.0110594248,
0.0039284364,
-0.0415584743,
-0.0222662631,
-0.0205771271,
2.767e-7,
-0.0074598584,
0.033363767,
0.0080144526,
0.0215454958,
0.0176059026,
0.0564478524,
-0.0073406347,
-0.0061162333,
0.0275105424,
-0.0621337891,
0.0100312838,
0.0349797644,
0.0358353145,
0.0292769298,
-0.0870033205,
-0.045217514,
-0.0408267975,
-0.0273993723,
-0.0321100131,
-0.0401007347,
0.0761253014,
0.0603105798,
0.0334543549,
-0.0004478924,
-0.0069108587,
-0.0313615724,
0.0819698796,
-0.0207338464,
-0.0046331463,
0.0025629397,
0.0402881466,
0.0184408184,
-0.0179390684,
0.0556913801,
0.011019499,
0.0255417284,
-0.0324059427,
0.0378390327,
-0.0004423492,
-0.1139983684,
-0.0051452266,
-0.007360436,
0.0247006565,
-0.0397654735,
0.077607505,
-0.0401423648,
-0.0118920254,
-0.0040625748,
-0.0395255238,
-0.0266414527,
0.03249624,
-0.018678898,
-0.0389443114,
0.0090644397,
-0.0056510218,
0.0290116705,
-0.0020505146,
-0.0868891776,
0.0009520593,
0.0192998145,
-0.0158393588,
-0.058834862,
0.0188804399,
-0.0142380362,
0.0153385568,
-0.0260038581,
0.0582458414,
2.185007063e-34,
0.0594637804,
0.0161026847,
0.0147892628,
0.0600591153,
0.024908768,
0.0067490055,
0.0249509756,
-0.0193170048,
0.0620353334,
-0.0560851544,
0.0021594083
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10397v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10397v3 | Needle in a Haystack: An Analysis of High-Agreement Workers on MTurk for Summarization | 2022-12-20T16:25:42 | 2023-06-14T01:45:33 | Lining Zhang, Simon Mille, Yufang Hou, Daniel Deutsch, Elizabeth Clark, Yixin Liu, Saad Mahamood, Sebastian Gehrmann, Miruna Clinciu, Khyathi Chandu, João Sedoc | cs.CL | cs.CL | To prevent the costly and inefficient use of resources on low-quality
annotations, we want a method for creating a pool of dependable annotators who
can effectively complete difficult tasks, such as evaluating automatic
summarization. Thus, we investigate the recruitment of high-quality Amazon
Mechanical Turk workers via a two-step pipeline. We show that we can
successfully filter out subpar workers before they carry out the evaluations
and obtain high-agreement annotations with similar constraints on resources.
Although our workers demonstrate a strong consensus among themselves and
CloudResearch workers, their alignment with expert judgments on a subset of the
data is not as expected and needs further training in correctness. This paper
still serves as a best practice for the recruitment of qualified annotators in
other challenging annotation tasks. | [
0.0654449016,
0.045503404,
0.0071910839,
-0.017892275,
-0.0248481631,
0.0025758939,
0.0160758216,
-0.0385954604,
-0.0259116422,
-0.0593609475,
0.0073614279,
0.0268529356,
-0.0132360291,
-0.0227606818,
0.0045602,
-0.0746234804,
-0.0178841017,
-0.015716739,
0.0273468196,
-0.0017086158,
0.0227499362,
0.0112101054,
-0.0287809093,
0.0324172229,
-0.0448625274,
0.0158069339,
0.0227209479,
-0.0159052499,
0.0567489564,
-0.0027144977,
-0.014513094,
0.0482389331,
-0.0363008529,
0.074342832,
0.0000017345,
-0.0467772186,
-0.0275235232,
0.0149605656,
-0.046752885,
-0.0377375372,
0.0354767367,
0.0067802798,
0.02027281,
0.0134928264,
-0.0350464843,
0.032545872,
0.0452083237,
-0.0057034469,
0.1016042903,
0.0409318469,
0.0068009347,
0.0247912519,
-0.0055690706,
-0.0031824699,
-0.0211137626,
-0.032015048,
-0.0239381921,
0.0097130733,
-0.0049093296,
-0.0124022309,
0.0172040612,
0.0417762473,
-0.0178562663,
-0.0115814349,
0.0552108213,
0.0131392945,
-0.0828359127,
-0.0465088598,
-0.0007555503,
0.0310366042,
0.0776812732,
0.0223872811,
0.0002241243,
0.0277873296,
0.0161815658,
0.0541259013,
-0.0349065401,
0.0513889864,
-0.0215587001,
-0.0103065511,
-0.0423448458,
0.0626594573,
-0.0146421427,
0.0234850477,
0.0134285558,
0.0272135921,
-0.0460204482,
-0.017389331,
-0.0147640025,
0.0592720099,
-0.0096277418,
-0.0649521425,
0.0393750034,
-0.0041119601,
-0.0301557928,
-0.0366948396,
0.0034729254,
-0.0942625627,
-0.0010535272,
-0.0101167532,
0.0077871927,
-0.0136310076,
-0.0200106632,
0.0747806281,
0.0120214922,
-0.0158959385,
0.0219646301,
0.0172566939,
-0.0209566113,
-0.0256173592,
-0.0646983832,
0.0265269205,
-0.018675955,
0.001487762,
0.026218975,
0.016685782,
-0.0355251878,
-0.0140122585,
-0.0201384053,
0.0296917502,
0.0038240419,
0.0085212048,
-0.0330155008,
0.0200015809,
-0.0551145226,
-0.0083898846,
-0.0410234444,
0.01149067,
0.0068991114,
-0.0269904006,
0.0210503377,
0.052466765,
0.0440016873,
-0.0095366724,
0.0470603406,
0.0215541422,
0.0118073402,
0.0021547237,
-0.0082955463,
-0.0323235765,
0.0350196511,
-0.0348117054,
-0.0249856617,
-0.0618432537,
0.0180214327,
-0.008850744,
-0.0102563668,
0.035631299,
-0.0253909528,
0.0224149656,
-0.029455483,
0.0434882715,
-0.0772883669,
0.001902868,
0.0221351366,
-0.0129287029,
-0.0830249935,
0.0333061107,
0.0333002396,
0.0789616928,
0.0589939617,
0.0044876169,
0.0626400858,
0.039747756,
-0.0370395705,
0.0099631473,
0.0429759808,
0.0296553168,
-0.0357595272,
0.049576506,
0.0693478584,
0.0422180854,
-0.036239285,
0.0390573815,
0.0540266074,
0.10903465,
-0.0229464211,
0.0100785159,
0.0366954245,
0.0256805271,
0.0087555032,
0.0065231002,
-0.0291969478,
0.0418509133,
-0.0088789864,
0.0056707175,
0.0432037003,
0.0263746046,
0.0008083728,
-0.0269149244,
-0.0091704279,
0.0169409104,
-0.0242690966,
0.0334596522,
0.0226701647,
-0.0070368238,
0.0038848016,
0.0028674428,
-0.0241711438,
-0.046204824,
-0.0040836879,
-0.0255321208,
-0.0163331777,
0.040365804,
0.0435652323,
-0.0039697243,
0.0407456309,
-0.0594051667,
0.0419845283,
0.0381877981,
0.0563116819,
-0.019967135,
-0.0474633612,
-0.0488350689,
-0.0495385602,
0.0382769555,
-0.00728577,
-0.0302317459,
0.0066459193,
-0.0139808524,
0.0061774435,
-0.0698012114,
-0.0522231907,
0.0193114076,
0.061595846,
0.0083353296,
-0.0343925841,
0.01268725,
0.0205136649,
0.0572727062,
-0.0193214212,
0.0014614732,
-0.0007224753,
-0.0114471298,
-0.029569963,
0.050827641,
0.0086820545,
0.0468050726,
0.0233152844,
-0.1023496389,
-0.0544615537,
0.0502528213,
-0.0062168245,
-0.0059469119,
0.0068879919,
-0.05108767,
-0.0079459744,
-0.0155102722,
-0.0264652986,
0.0055927429,
-0.0232221745,
-0.0265751146,
0.0678968951,
0.0105905179,
0.0069043613,
-0.0246018544,
-0.0538245887,
-0.0087467842,
-0.0530040972,
0.0017139156,
-0.0209576134,
0.0398556329,
0.058559116,
0.0444416851,
-0.0184117649,
-0.0514043011,
-0.006662094,
-0.0837414935,
-0.0053845616,
-0.0079193832,
0.0113214487,
0.0005612621,
-0.0420477316,
0.0066738287,
0.0003875937,
-0.046016112,
-0.0294134542,
0.0170312654,
0.0387288965,
0.0324876085,
0.0084058829,
0.0302364249,
-0.0229166076,
0.0009297883,
-0.0090926662,
0.0196424257,
0.0967333168,
-0.056954436,
-0.0409281217,
0.0170388967,
-0.0420239083,
-0.0304371696,
0.0238962192,
-0.006959429,
0.0214110035,
0.021654509,
-0.0315607563,
0.0202465001,
-0.0048998352,
-0.0000401357,
0.0393350013,
0.027729921,
-0.0115494495,
-0.0120511651,
0.0341866761,
-0.0085794767,
-0.0055416357,
-0.0308293365,
0.0013085365,
0.0161523409,
-0.0100046573,
-0.0011085216,
-0.0181237627,
0.0386440307,
-0.0472034886,
0.001991522,
-0.0408585779,
-0.012785119,
0.000204535,
0.097251974,
-0.0110027129,
-0.0306720883,
0.0644667223,
-0.017904995,
0.0099531701,
-0.0672413111,
-0.0158010889,
-0.0265077446,
0.0297991503,
-0.0045362022,
0.0360731781,
-0.0581006557,
0.0062696473,
-0.0212419722,
0.0152001325,
0.0759503692,
-0.0313292593,
-0.00497523,
-0.006611146,
0.0153682185,
-0.037862476,
-0.0281450544,
0.0065195635,
-0.0451274104,
-0.0798685253,
0.0057896026,
0.0688037425,
-0.0036665215,
-0.0570673756,
0.0116874464,
0.0558894798,
0.0476874746,
0.0338858031,
-0.0463766977,
-0.0137745449,
0.0248676874,
0.0135113234,
0.0802286789,
0.026739791,
-0.0475736782,
-0.0157511272,
0.0722868219,
0.0454551429,
-0.0438581482,
-0.0110944789,
-0.0312551111,
0.013308675,
-0.0666815788,
0.0070769587,
-0.0318997204,
0.0430378914,
-0.0476091728,
0.0350313708,
0.0392630063,
0.013656918,
-0.0670892969,
-0.0110401595,
0.0081273559,
-0.0085602961,
0.0278326534,
0.0141656585,
-0.0869211704,
-0.0078320373,
0.0048959884,
0.0753307417,
-0.0234141368,
-0.0824684277,
0.0016685546,
-0.0955782682,
0.0717943758,
-0.012556809,
-0.0450725891,
0.0185030662,
-0.0682453886,
0.0077242432,
-0.077929765,
-0.0214724932,
-0.0165026262,
-0.003869826,
0.0427722037,
0.0321648829,
-0.013406951,
0.0012107168,
0.015574621,
-0.0799806044,
0.0450105593,
0.0760691985,
0.0139247123,
-0.0299591944,
-0.0053549367,
-0.0152891539,
0.0283281766,
0.0151288994,
0.0378024951,
0.0951212049,
-0.0311255902,
-0.0212683808,
-0.0383742712,
0.0055373562,
-0.0186269302,
0.0287135672,
0.02197247,
0.0728577077,
0.0261312053,
-0.0142232263,
-0.0041603372,
0.0067206132,
-0.0104460735,
0.0682561621,
0.0169997066,
-0.0652226284,
-0.0124955187,
-0.0235946234,
0.0217838921,
-0.0784393921,
-0.0360895917,
0.0339115709,
0.0032134603,
-0.0301235653,
-0.0721466094,
-0.0790436864,
0.041304864,
0.0499525629,
0.0174382068,
0.0118533671,
0.0042092255,
0.0537983328,
-0.0106621813,
0.0804681927,
-0.0420872793,
0.0166299287,
-0.0137730613,
-0.0562788844,
-0.0096406108,
-0.0142278336,
-0.0133795729,
-0.0080502471,
-0.0617745742,
-0.0083185444,
-0.0019182538,
0.0620431304,
0.0366745964,
0.0275388099,
0.000228489,
-0.044220943,
-0.0107422266,
0.0533796325,
-0.05466225,
0.0103463102,
0.0079593975,
0.0421137698,
-0.0297943484,
0.000541946,
-0.0489664674,
0.0131176524,
-0.0354073532,
0.0079902774,
-0.0340460837,
-0.0183163788,
0.0169702042,
0.065308623,
0.0037082525,
-0.0178372785,
0.0217173453,
-0.024419941,
-0.0198309589,
0.0415974818,
-0.0437325239,
-0.0250851344,
0.0201111976,
-0.034387242,
-0.0089143682,
0.0253546853,
0.0598156005,
0.0082697412,
-0.0015629636,
-0.0575123541,
0.0203882474,
0.0013490637,
-0.0197654068,
-0.0280776843,
0.0089342026,
-0.0349836312,
-0.0038913912,
-0.0112411818,
0.0389775522,
0.0165282879,
-0.0154768964,
0.0288222767,
0.0026511282,
0.0151106697,
0.0378028341,
-0.0751800537,
-0.0481513776,
-0.0048360769,
0.0238102358,
0.0321484767,
-0.0297817606,
0.0454111993,
-0.0058113118,
-0.0122184316,
-0.0017593666,
-0.0094735976,
0.0324521661,
0.018818805,
-0.0302849039,
0.0250417609,
-0.0081364913,
0.0222928356,
0.0586105138,
-0.0714567676,
0.0207262523,
-0.0246730708,
-0.0417788737,
-0.0406859703,
-0.0328638926,
-0.0611418672,
-0.0097628254,
0.0240073074,
-0.0289833304,
-0.0435015969,
-0.0217673387,
-0.0151284589,
-0.0093520256,
0.0078749601,
-0.0089655994,
0.0122590102,
0.0501291864,
-0.0004565556,
0.0162402894,
-0.0420502014,
-0.0084690424,
-0.008566089,
0.0271613728,
0.0058861077,
-5.927312715e-33,
0.0088825617,
-0.0706720799,
-0.016141735,
-0.0136858132,
0.0106499828,
0.001882195,
0.0030180681,
0.0076784496,
0.0014507945,
0.0070645181,
-0.0266874433,
-0.0137135275,
0.0346141644,
-0.0038495215,
0.034171924,
0.0157204345,
0.0599599294,
0.0080659799,
-0.0574606173,
0.019628251,
-0.0146141415,
-0.0184264015,
0.0300695579,
-0.0658848807,
0.0487472937,
-0.0219896808,
-0.048667606,
0.0411332995,
0.0335672535,
0.0432309471,
0.0224439539,
0.032024283,
0.0358474292,
-0.0368397087,
-0.0113376193,
-0.0394483842,
-0.0506443977,
0.0341116711,
-0.002730384,
0.0031105569,
-0.0597564802,
-0.0161680523,
0.0503707975,
-0.0333724841,
-0.0215323791,
-0.0075746919,
0.0708751082,
-0.0393513106,
-0.0017434261,
-0.0159689002,
0.0231942683,
0.0444876626,
-0.049315609,
-0.02046315,
0.0551941544,
0.0231075622,
0.0283124,
0.0085180057,
-0.1069831178,
0.0398501344,
-0.0171385501,
-0.0041727847,
0.0514917634,
-0.0308723077,
-0.0322156884,
0.0705579966,
-0.011617397,
0.0022409614,
-0.0012679129,
-0.017864164,
-0.0336788669,
0.0219828393,
0.0545460247,
0.0570472106,
0.0229002312,
0.0135800606,
0.0075343316,
0.0704829618,
0.0186787043,
0.0022892018,
0.009625881,
-0.0117365113,
-0.0650444105,
-0.001989939,
-0.0195965618,
-0.0595385507,
-0.033567436,
-0.0053711995,
-0.0133225666,
0.0120087927,
-0.047939036,
0.0196195059,
-0.0069330502,
-0.0161270574,
0.0296186022,
-0.0334723666,
-0.0105334474,
0.0538396165,
0.006630328,
-0.039419163,
-0.0411203951,
0.0398540944,
-0.0357881486,
0.0449326895,
0.0663541108,
0.0168636125,
0.0536037907,
0.0001848757,
-0.0577655248,
0.0184147581,
-0.0079534594,
0.0363672115,
-0.0183104947,
-0.0452402309,
0.0162222479,
-0.0007821224,
0.0244914424,
0.0260731857,
0.0177362747,
0.0519261286,
-0.0095052794,
0.0180986784,
-0.0196904223,
-0.0363642164,
-0.0164029617,
-0.000633306,
0.0286097787,
0.0032705092,
0.0143008363,
-0.018873591,
-0.0161853712,
-0.0453298576,
2.431e-7,
0.044772882,
0.0420503765,
0.000097795,
-0.0409766287,
-0.0180817079,
0.0396094285,
-0.0037481647,
0.0180106219,
0.0134171825,
-0.053258881,
0.0179588106,
0.0262749474,
0.056318827,
0.0765341818,
-0.0991563201,
-0.0856936723,
-0.0649594963,
0.025098687,
-0.0505629592,
0.01031374,
0.0411682874,
0.053956002,
0.0150113022,
-0.0237868987,
-0.0139468843,
-0.0745142177,
0.0135206673,
-0.0044514597,
-0.0267644785,
0.0325016081,
0.0560994372,
0.0047023227,
-0.0053526126,
0.0191130973,
-0.009678334,
0.0033178891,
0.0761014074,
0.013717832,
0.0177931301,
0.007164883,
-0.0082870005,
-0.0099673644,
0.0234307908,
0.004276101,
0.0122111505,
-0.0265714675,
-0.0693708807,
-0.0475249365,
-0.0131467627,
-0.0263424236,
0.0174573399,
0.0106481733,
-0.0322811566,
0.0383096151,
-0.0023347382,
0.0135472966,
-0.0431559235,
-0.0456004329,
-0.0106696589,
-0.0057639526,
-0.0054138578,
-0.1163777709,
0.0334583372,
-0.0043063359,
-0.0108403089,
-0.0316602923,
-0.0116314506,
1.679406739e-34,
0.0470068455,
0.017796427,
0.007970918,
-0.0019668988,
0.0597465262,
-0.0122811319,
0.0096993325,
-0.04603016,
0.0187598895,
-0.0166117325,
-0.0011401351
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10392v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10392v1 | Debiasing Stance Detection Models with Counterfactual Reasoning and Adversarial Bias Learning | 2022-12-20T16:20:56 | 2022-12-20T16:20:56 | Jianhua Yuan, Yanyan Zhao, Bing Qin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Stance detection models may tend to rely on dataset bias in the text part as
a shortcut and thus fail to sufficiently learn the interaction between the
targets and texts. Recent debiasing methods usually treated features learned by
small models or big models at earlier steps as bias features and proposed to
exclude the branch learning those bias features during inference. However, most
of these methods fail to disentangle the ``good'' stance features and ``bad''
bias features in the text part. In this paper, we investigate how to mitigate
dataset bias in stance detection. Motivated by causal effects, we leverage a
novel counterfactual inference framework, which enables us to capture the
dataset bias in the text part as the direct causal effect of the text on
stances and reduce the dataset bias in the text part by subtracting the direct
text effect from the total causal effect. We novelly model bias features as
features that correlate with the stance labels but fail on intermediate stance
reasoning subtasks and propose an adversarial bias learning module to model the
bias more accurately. To verify whether our model could better model the
interaction between texts and targets, we test our model on recently proposed
test sets to evaluate the understanding of the task from various aspects.
Experiments demonstrate that our proposed method (1) could better model the
bias features, and (2) outperforms existing debiasing baselines on both the
original dataset and most of the newly constructed test sets. | [
0.0232407078,
0.0296629537,
-0.0012814142,
0.0468618385,
-0.0167708248,
0.0210434347,
0.0018692961,
-0.0146256629,
0.0222129915,
-0.0575098023,
-0.0050165975,
0.0163738467,
-0.0204851385,
-0.0006525547,
0.0112778768,
-0.0192785989,
0.0556498617,
0.0381798968,
0.0686620325,
-0.0273011345,
0.0762137994,
0.0603844151,
-0.0381774418,
0.0144013688,
-0.0280504022,
-0.0437549129,
-0.0007254204,
0.0059508909,
0.0750520527,
-0.0121423351,
0.053915143,
0.0242457185,
0.0108610094,
0.0498255529,
0.0000018858,
-0.0231667664,
-0.0376440547,
-0.0423086509,
-0.0369322449,
-0.0408134013,
0.0022018941,
-0.0432112701,
0.0143097341,
0.0055594929,
-0.0499339849,
0.0062869517,
0.0400070697,
0.062997371,
0.0483274199,
0.0598175786,
0.0016586288,
-0.040082518,
-0.02365941,
-0.0403276496,
-0.0217934381,
-0.0553616174,
0.007997009,
-0.0030463326,
-0.0897237137,
0.0563279055,
-0.0300268531,
-0.0103949495,
0.045595523,
0.0095519228,
-0.047691334,
-0.0016022567,
0.024088949,
-0.0134464176,
-0.0051711304,
0.0606745109,
0.0063781505,
-0.0495142788,
-0.0114375763,
-0.0585100166,
0.0427755974,
0.0229378212,
-0.0191486999,
-0.0014679239,
-0.0324487798,
0.0190216172,
0.0142264031,
0.0166707709,
0.0277689733,
0.0449907184,
0.0115264766,
0.0417537093,
-0.0385633633,
-0.001627846,
0.0228711367,
0.0267879087,
0.0033234444,
-0.0358098187,
0.017565785,
-0.005434467,
-0.0114498604,
0.0205634069,
-0.044276759,
0.0155964764,
0.0321057513,
-0.0362832658,
-0.0615406483,
-0.025230797,
-0.0372440182,
0.052560892,
-0.030947648,
0.0100954939,
-0.0309859905,
-0.0322622173,
-0.0173958056,
0.0254790317,
-0.0209848303,
-0.0310030878,
-0.0039068032,
0.0271066837,
-0.0547071844,
0.01019096,
-0.0053136009,
-0.0246686023,
-0.0464110821,
0.0057152105,
0.001930182,
0.0307286624,
-0.009767008,
-0.0240082741,
-0.0030758374,
0.0646056533,
-0.0469933413,
0.0401391871,
-0.0176115297,
-0.0454503037,
-0.030478945,
0.0275708549,
-0.0033704382,
-0.0301793441,
0.0072616087,
0.0344643146,
0.0372543931,
0.0142001044,
0.0060941838,
-0.0381975211,
-0.0305871684,
-0.0844084769,
-0.0153643461,
-0.0486149602,
0.0170997232,
0.0033953043,
0.0119352108,
-0.0504937172,
-0.0016072274,
0.0175163634,
0.0358947404,
0.0935705379,
0.069332473,
-0.0582069047,
0.0080414778,
0.0288702156,
0.0277088173,
0.1108106673,
-0.0274725445,
0.0464259423,
0.0131644513,
0.04633395,
-0.0185146164,
0.0031182666,
0.0896478444,
-0.0045086695,
0.0044949828,
0.0421107449,
-0.0430903211,
-0.0160836987,
0.0074146874,
0.003932579,
0.0042262143,
-0.0681254864,
0.060274262,
-0.0382249616,
-0.0220469087,
-0.0035766473,
0.0072295098,
0.0415122099,
-0.0122014116,
0.0075053065,
-0.0163966604,
0.0478294529,
-0.0157767925,
-0.025904255,
-0.0458495505,
0.023031937,
-0.0278296638,
-0.0596444048,
0.0074118483,
0.0045258226,
-0.0025619206,
0.0224982984,
0.0123174796,
0.0368155949,
-0.0521139987,
0.0495097265,
0.0183412861,
-0.0258805472,
-0.0149902906,
-0.0410205387,
0.0134887947,
-0.0347678773,
0.0028067396,
-0.0626961812,
-0.0507258028,
-0.0433900356,
0.0114214141,
0.0435773507,
0.0458071046,
-0.0509851612,
0.0007174942,
-0.0333314911,
-0.0167352557,
-0.0529151373,
0.0204266366,
0.0464069471,
-0.0143375322,
0.0107986676,
0.02271582,
0.0249110442,
0.0540521145,
0.0252102446,
0.0537916794,
-0.0325826071,
-0.0017523242,
0.0633392781,
0.0336925946,
0.0557529032,
0.0151623422,
-0.0323393159,
0.0242769402,
0.0079640737,
-0.0248227548,
0.0178389959,
-0.0203039702,
-0.1146578118,
0.0079850564,
-0.0332572944,
-0.06135552,
0.0527803004,
-0.0415993072,
0.0027338578,
0.0134929838,
-0.0048620631,
-0.0347573534,
-0.0260338001,
-0.0397613421,
-0.0252503995,
-0.000950685,
-0.0382722802,
0.0739174038,
0.002255202,
-0.0199454818,
0.0044205412,
-0.0062736878,
0.0476423576,
-0.0104694162,
-0.0186072886,
-0.0117099117,
-0.011173577,
-0.0228136051,
0.0444211923,
-0.0268686991,
-0.0230425633,
0.0095062871,
-0.0660896152,
-0.0130666904,
-0.0363300741,
0.0093315644,
0.0487158597,
-0.0267489087,
0.0254827403,
-0.0073703369,
-0.0471204557,
-0.0648301765,
-0.0256885048,
0.0113786543,
0.0155602191,
-0.0214899816,
0.0256366767,
-0.0236418769,
0.0227215216,
-0.0279367417,
0.0397224501,
0.0274088252,
-0.0569776036,
-0.0084867384,
-0.0121689225,
-0.0321484432,
-0.0219574049,
-0.0356299616,
-0.0478248224,
0.0456311516,
0.0270364061,
-0.0153111937,
0.070913054,
0.0040206807,
0.0539105758,
-0.0088195521,
0.0463956445,
-0.0417605489,
0.0016681532,
-0.0315817557,
0.0930944681,
-0.0193526968,
0.0019288023,
-0.010741815,
0.0504270047,
0.0162901934,
-0.0184322726,
-0.0291956998,
0.0462633744,
-0.0247088056,
-0.0410889871,
0.0027768547,
-0.0184679702,
-0.0076904232,
-0.0249114465,
-0.0519907437,
-0.0323945023,
0.0863162056,
0.0289825574,
-0.0163039602,
-0.0406755432,
0.0125264674,
-0.0159481429,
0.0670474172,
0.0393952131,
0.0024232471,
0.0238235556,
0.0130090741,
-0.0230974387,
-0.0328955837,
0.0337754674,
-0.0148503287,
-0.002391394,
-0.0087611247,
0.0129508851,
-0.0044770041,
-0.0447705351,
-0.033602301,
-0.0697135255,
-0.0380212106,
-0.0116943987,
-0.0192265399,
0.0030771175,
0.0277667716,
0.0193979815,
-0.0096240593,
0.0084390091,
-0.029430801,
0.0188193042,
0.0130492598,
0.0203983933,
0.0375266597,
-0.0443113931,
0.0264130328,
-0.0236121658,
0.0188301299,
0.0637674853,
-0.0090866024,
0.0249446556,
-0.0035196345,
-0.0383791439,
-0.0118958559,
0.0207802672,
0.0190819297,
-0.04352073,
0.0587412044,
-0.0459973887,
0.0250652824,
0.0551238693,
0.0184819363,
-0.0111255301,
0.0138378888,
0.0912140384,
-0.0185843222,
0.0128013007,
-0.0423660576,
-0.067523174,
-0.0497350283,
-0.0038448316,
-0.0075869923,
-0.0352998488,
-0.0022969465,
-0.0135498932,
-0.0752857924,
-0.0327287167,
-0.0319165066,
-0.0418304317,
-0.0331126936,
-0.0276629254,
0.0222239029,
-0.0513873436,
0.0071143433,
-0.0133206965,
0.0471004918,
-0.004908931,
0.0105093131,
-0.0113749886,
-0.016060574,
-0.0123971654,
-0.0298673008,
0.0405389182,
0.0570484512,
0.0685570017,
-0.0023357559,
0.0248630997,
0.0425395854,
-0.0412174091,
0.0065987478,
-0.0146315424,
0.073547259,
-0.0523172878,
-0.017948132,
-0.0198515505,
0.0487292632,
0.0099393651,
0.003017379,
-0.0270557217,
0.0001003049,
0.015992539,
0.0041149394,
-0.0075416476,
0.0370089598,
0.0560763739,
0.045088388,
0.0118482979,
-0.0296667423,
-0.0260482803,
-0.0505494997,
-0.0209437143,
-0.0750293732,
-0.0320839062,
-0.0439359844,
0.0255548321,
0.0334559195,
-0.038024243,
-0.0459583066,
-0.0050871922,
0.0315422155,
-0.0384159572,
0.0049107969,
-0.0209171474,
0.0166142136,
-0.0249342695,
0.019750312,
0.0061866865,
0.0621866435,
0.0222181845,
-0.0394897871,
0.022584239,
-0.0213203393,
-0.0445217751,
-0.013700163,
-0.091798149,
-0.0379417688,
-0.0120805781,
0.0556304865,
0.0095541291,
0.0541429445,
-0.0144153563,
-0.0087973783,
0.0232063588,
0.1013464257,
-0.020815799,
0.0033595948,
0.0678984225,
-0.0023103275,
-0.0072780764,
0.0336490534,
0.0114474557,
0.0060499227,
0.083855316,
-0.0192861296,
-0.0246232226,
0.0126838889,
0.0188676454,
-0.0300738495,
0.0494402498,
0.0109285964,
-0.0323430151,
-0.0411053598,
0.0040154303,
-0.0179590154,
-0.0626903772,
-0.0077839806,
0.0252546035,
0.0017474581,
-0.0211157538,
-0.0404794179,
0.0212054383,
-0.0224412046,
0.0575244613,
-0.0502139628,
0.0672985762,
0.0620597601,
0.0618828759,
-0.019078318,
-0.0177171919,
-0.0237668846,
-0.0058447509,
0.0339324065,
-0.0200821571,
0.0441099294,
0.0399086773,
0.0392728932,
-0.0159903243,
0.0004293468,
-0.0011679135,
-0.0437965319,
0.0534616262,
-0.0489261709,
0.0067129419,
0.0000329482,
-0.0492198505,
0.0084551461,
0.0125823775,
-0.0185151324,
0.0036550392,
0.0122845788,
-0.0154907377,
-0.0322618186,
0.050273668,
0.0314240716,
-0.0001119257,
0.0279218368,
0.023140125,
-0.0060110986,
0.0581966043,
0.0174042266,
-0.015623291,
-0.0162422135,
-0.0462392941,
0.0067650499,
0.0092305914,
0.0059045688,
0.0323635936,
-0.0676427186,
-0.0518984981,
-0.0177757144,
0.0212873574,
0.0232903995,
0.0382210873,
0.0084609278,
0.0407783613,
0.0065171984,
-0.0238175392,
-0.0257575344,
0.0398142524,
-0.0272588059,
-0.0086739454,
-0.0372815728,
-5.729950152e-33,
-0.0078252852,
-0.0534922071,
-0.0376075506,
-0.0343301594,
0.0096874414,
0.0133714359,
-0.0107545881,
-0.0291452892,
-0.0374440067,
0.0681926683,
0.0380819924,
0.065575242,
0.0039533405,
-0.0074926852,
-0.0512355268,
-0.0348903462,
0.0574168526,
-0.0228047073,
-0.0409548618,
0.0220187437,
0.0259074178,
-0.0054221265,
0.0418269262,
-0.0787283927,
0.0621244758,
-0.0262243208,
-0.0500976741,
-0.0042840792,
-0.0376995392,
0.0740275532,
0.0246468522,
0.0142741352,
0.050640218,
-0.0525217466,
0.0164892692,
0.0472903624,
-0.0365090817,
-0.0074841734,
0.0328364335,
0.0274343491,
0.0224208813,
0.0035862327,
-0.0064535867,
-0.0057813888,
-0.0127837434,
0.0029881881,
0.0183163211,
-0.0213919431,
0.0480009541,
-0.0209736917,
-0.0616721734,
0.0349720269,
-0.0098034693,
-0.0205484219,
-0.0275113024,
0.0559431165,
0.034161713,
0.0415191613,
-0.0148447268,
-0.0049965191,
-0.0521118939,
-0.0120366579,
-0.0117698619,
0.0167694632,
0.0041995086,
0.0668174028,
0.0242016297,
0.0305325184,
-0.0406837352,
0.0030197613,
-0.0004201419,
0.0069447444,
0.1003867015,
0.1183260977,
0.037534371,
-0.0010336962,
-0.0847356468,
-0.0170679688,
0.0473008491,
0.0129446825,
0.0154014006,
0.004830684,
-0.0171130262,
-0.0167275257,
-0.0190111734,
-0.078175053,
-0.0063070264,
0.0100832405,
-0.0081480239,
0.020561289,
-0.0730039179,
0.0501211211,
0.0036792057,
-0.0496451482,
-0.0091243088,
0.101295419,
-0.0102906264,
-0.0128275733,
0.0201489888,
0.0266435817,
-0.0550246835,
0.0140242996,
0.0349977762,
0.0120120589,
0.0311663207,
-0.0137949567,
0.0953403488,
-0.0034301896,
-0.0515573286,
-0.0203611981,
-0.0292835142,
0.0136405453,
-0.0271240976,
0.082365185,
0.0455310717,
0.0006022459,
-0.0147553058,
0.0327894464,
-0.0097771343,
-0.0302645452,
-0.0299994294,
0.0370265655,
-0.057790298,
0.0250888485,
-0.0421398729,
-0.0542261079,
0.0320788026,
-0.0168631896,
-0.0286502223,
-0.097082749,
-0.001315913,
-0.0022055127,
2.447e-7,
-0.009365811,
0.0111232661,
0.0189770609,
-0.0108853225,
0.0553962514,
0.0637564287,
0.0023365344,
0.015705606,
0.0067193112,
-0.0287252553,
0.0051836241,
0.0588949099,
0.0301090833,
0.0210532546,
-0.0749317557,
0.0426726788,
-0.0271532182,
-0.0042519062,
-0.004136147,
0.0108832987,
-0.019444583,
0.0653103143,
0.0281596147,
0.0066534653,
0.0439729579,
0.0283328351,
0.0167651251,
0.0201691762,
0.0260715764,
-0.0138894282,
-0.0052208453,
-0.0733996257,
-0.0175087154,
0.0505422913,
-0.0033566921,
0.0283097941,
-0.0085730627,
0.0696456507,
0.0131589072,
-0.0391683504,
-0.0419736207,
0.0103479344,
0.0079285745,
-0.0323130712,
0.0875293836,
-0.0250800904,
-0.0155300852,
-0.0724734515,
-0.0299327355,
0.0170656797,
0.0184115916,
0.0175321065,
-0.0357029289,
0.0173260253,
0.0014093026,
-0.02224393,
0.0133982999,
-0.0865142345,
-0.0470389314,
-0.0304473918,
-0.0355915874,
-0.0407916568,
0.0395732969,
-0.0156568866,
0.0196251739,
-0.0387703218,
-0.0130181657,
1.86688018e-34,
0.0220756419,
-0.0372267589,
-0.0134561807,
-0.0374822654,
0.020134991,
0.0174453221,
-0.0292651802,
-0.0089825522,
0.052023869,
0.0026628275,
-0.0299739819
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10391v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10391v2 | Empowering Sentence Encoders with Prompting and Label Retrieval for Zero-shot Text Classification | 2022-12-20T16:18:03 | 2023-05-19T08:37:33 | Jimin Hong, Jungsoo Park, Daeyoung Kim, Seongjae Choi, Bokyung Son, Jaewook Kang | cs.CL | cs.CL | With contrastive pre-training, sentence encoders are generally optimized to
locate semantically similar samples closer to each other in their embedding
spaces. In this work, we focus on the potential of their embedding spaces to be
readily adapted to zero-shot text classification, as semantically distinct
samples are already well-separated. Our framework, RaLP (Retrieval augmented
Label Prompts for sentence encoder), encodes prompted label candidates with a
sentence encoder, then assigns the label whose prompt embedding has the highest
similarity with the input text embedding. In order to compensate for the
potentially poorly descriptive labels in their original format, RaLP retrieves
sentences that are semantically similar to the original label prompt from
external corpora and use them as additional pseudo-label prompts. RaLP achieves
competitive or stronger performance than much larger baselines on various
closed-set classification and multiple-choice QA datasets under zero-shot
settings. We show that the retrieval component plays a pivotal role in RaLP's
success, and its results are robustly attained regardless of verbalizer
variations. | [
0.0138093838,
0.0165150706,
0.0039482103,
0.0330763236,
-0.0334397852,
0.0221249145,
0.0330536887,
0.000143254,
-0.0009958303,
-0.0789673999,
-0.0389052555,
-0.0036800236,
-0.0382076353,
-0.0085847862,
0.0115229618,
-0.0255957097,
0.0181000512,
0.0232475605,
0.0246300809,
0.0256694909,
0.0265679937,
-0.0061237095,
-0.0009108603,
0.0293813404,
-0.0024861887,
-0.0150231775,
-0.007987055,
0.0116702002,
0.0270347837,
-0.0447611399,
0.0363300703,
0.0432548523,
0.0274165869,
0.022568075,
0.0000017019,
-0.0373989306,
-0.0047730464,
-0.0223154556,
-0.0516782477,
-0.0385747328,
0.0376730636,
-0.0217100196,
0.0526484288,
0.0170451105,
0.0011930601,
-0.0701404586,
0.0463931113,
0.0324065425,
0.0279024206,
0.072019428,
-0.0303631946,
-0.015187284,
-0.0021981595,
-0.0036169568,
0.0261988174,
0.0056537976,
0.0071276738,
-0.0851438865,
0.0206727441,
0.0788806006,
-0.0127603775,
0.0331801586,
0.0445415005,
-0.0001894385,
0.0511317104,
0.037401177,
-0.0387290567,
-0.0018503712,
-0.0177847482,
0.0691167936,
0.0096255336,
-0.0144290393,
-0.0205650926,
-0.0211947747,
-0.0089228926,
-0.0222388245,
-0.0501728654,
0.0386039726,
0.0278770458,
0.0135319764,
-0.0038591356,
0.065760009,
-0.011690245,
-0.027527282,
0.0080324793,
0.0331857167,
0.0323986709,
-0.0636335909,
-0.0091161821,
0.0320099518,
-0.0059167114,
-0.0258504879,
-0.0068444111,
0.0120047629,
-0.0075420639,
0.0026781689,
-0.0438535213,
-0.0343512036,
0.0230132174,
0.0372511186,
0.0463961624,
0.0156205939,
-0.0443820581,
0.0236293171,
-0.0257200208,
0.0497669205,
0.0153194508,
0.0520441122,
-0.0667181537,
-0.0250196606,
-0.073567383,
-0.0255819894,
-0.0426537767,
0.0546681173,
-0.0202045776,
-0.0070306454,
-0.039931003,
0.002031428,
-0.0003375048,
0.0049237339,
-0.0204665642,
0.02510304,
-0.0222586431,
0.0083306478,
-0.0238040518,
0.0583808683,
-0.0315221883,
0.028226262,
0.0386921316,
-0.0333323218,
-0.038307175,
0.0174304526,
0.0558370575,
-0.0333291627,
-0.01609377,
0.0190424677,
-0.0222440865,
-0.0738365948,
-0.0005399413,
-0.011293212,
-0.0212080367,
-0.0194392316,
-0.0028839454,
-0.0217708182,
0.0301580895,
-0.0092331944,
-0.0085701598,
-0.0159453824,
-0.0020990027,
0.0459730811,
0.0022362825,
0.087299794,
0.0011669321,
-0.0597958975,
-0.0012343806,
-0.0002376027,
0.0463957079,
0.0341665931,
-0.0285406895,
0.0148949279,
0.0423936509,
0.0259442069,
0.0289139152,
0.0020394446,
0.0125898654,
0.0006999567,
-0.0258813165,
0.0278450679,
0.0549856313,
0.0175970569,
-0.0103015928,
0.004016696,
-0.0397111736,
0.0044575445,
0.0202076118,
0.067222409,
0.0056914622,
-0.0634626001,
0.034948986,
0.0183206983,
-0.0674510598,
-0.0075327102,
0.0025759388,
0.019320311,
-0.0271797478,
-0.001369143,
0.0426212251,
-0.0173678324,
-0.0620770194,
-0.035080567,
0.0030360683,
-0.0326462612,
-0.0184328444,
-0.0051254304,
0.0226012766,
0.0171830207,
-0.047766488,
0.0158395786,
0.0164055284,
-0.0541491397,
-0.026248591,
-0.0002135885,
0.0253315605,
0.035437163,
0.03096628,
-0.0543878488,
0.0062840558,
-0.0296352115,
0.0079622315,
0.0528850183,
0.0023389852,
-0.0254455581,
0.0276785176,
-0.0530544035,
-0.0517394356,
-0.0451659076,
0.0191185325,
0.0183856152,
-0.0288029183,
0.0302765332,
0.0406705178,
0.004483778,
0.0158420205,
0.034170717,
0.0108577618,
-0.0688903183,
0.0646661669,
0.0348233208,
0.0029316694,
0.0154097434,
-0.0190680139,
0.0043565063,
0.0123696178,
-0.0751993135,
-0.0283683445,
-0.0427341275,
-0.0575943068,
-0.1163671166,
-0.015841797,
-0.0140059395,
-0.0025617636,
0.0241534859,
-0.0515137166,
-0.0466336198,
-0.0180627462,
0.0247865077,
-0.0051739942,
-0.053017363,
-0.012784454,
-0.0012218377,
0.0022725321,
-0.0605625026,
0.0421249121,
0.0453322604,
0.0484381914,
-0.0023030643,
0.0004511664,
0.065054819,
-0.0368318707,
-0.0238678101,
-0.0058983588,
-0.0063803112,
0.0390366875,
0.0439034551,
0.021934893,
-0.0300465878,
-0.0028690223,
-0.0694225058,
0.0182147417,
-0.0292918757,
-0.0019957267,
0.0197506361,
0.0027617388,
0.0102414424,
-0.0333238021,
-0.0296012703,
-0.0102735991,
0.0029555885,
0.032486368,
0.069413498,
0.0097335493,
-0.0030564158,
0.0027667019,
-0.0108954245,
0.0089301793,
0.0810513198,
-0.0052743596,
0.0040031527,
-0.0161467977,
0.0368445888,
-0.0195935797,
-0.0264636613,
0.0226811226,
-0.0117689958,
0.0174387638,
-0.0105154933,
-0.0268279891,
0.0610435493,
-0.0193694234,
0.0115097221,
0.0085395807,
0.0438497551,
-0.0418157205,
-0.0073022391,
-0.0220952351,
-0.0202717427,
0.0209402926,
0.0384198986,
0.0355939083,
0.0496823452,
-0.0025782133,
-0.0194397308,
-0.0508759394,
0.0159079358,
0.0091750072,
0.0021735679,
-0.0964543,
0.0134282764,
-0.0077295988,
0.0500550494,
-0.031127749,
-0.025223691,
0.0687185004,
-0.0203484371,
-0.0152707705,
-0.0476294868,
-0.0223637298,
-0.0355305634,
0.020593727,
0.005125273,
0.0006377462,
0.0735269636,
-0.0168968085,
-0.0290413797,
-0.0270460695,
0.0004740626,
0.0073989551,
0.0048801755,
0.045049239,
0.0329289995,
-0.0320647582,
-0.0650397912,
-0.0472901762,
-0.0737934336,
-0.0083852326,
0.0409315564,
-0.0615789182,
0.0346620232,
-0.0372165814,
-0.0273428652,
0.0223829038,
0.0496240519,
-0.0167335384,
0.0055691809,
-0.0389090665,
0.0905891061,
0.0498021692,
-0.0299346037,
-0.05348178,
-0.0152102932,
0.0442462936,
0.0327721871,
0.0178172383,
0.0452311523,
0.0148140425,
-0.00780037,
0.0056016319,
-0.029236773,
-0.0083871949,
0.0267594252,
0.0380011313,
-0.0099583324,
-0.0363821313,
0.1118888408,
0.0506888218,
-0.0565466844,
-0.025069356,
-0.0019307213,
0.0365887396,
0.037792325,
0.0166187827,
-0.0926312134,
-0.051033169,
-0.015983507,
0.0074952804,
-0.0242899377,
0.002663756,
-0.0179792177,
-0.156719476,
0.0161326211,
-0.0148802828,
-0.0179866645,
0.0045229192,
-0.0305667426,
0.001895546,
0.0300036706,
0.0027177394,
-0.0122674461,
0.0125171542,
0.0060424004,
-0.0051025664,
0.0245029554,
-0.0403546095,
0.0038072618,
-0.0102128582,
0.0148202768,
0.0180449709,
0.0105929263,
0.0081659006,
-0.0260830354,
-0.007801773,
-0.0753168985,
-0.0087384814,
-0.003331763,
0.0847273394,
-0.0345053449,
-0.0052908063,
-0.0082536023,
0.0143343052,
-0.0399189442,
-0.0259888582,
0.0254027713,
0.0641238019,
-0.0000950657,
0.0225518942,
-0.0291971955,
-0.0314762928,
0.0248984545,
0.0586658157,
0.0461639836,
-0.0433306769,
-0.0394635499,
-0.047114674,
0.015475804,
-0.0685130805,
-0.018534895,
0.0119256591,
0.0021725502,
-0.00836151,
-0.0465142578,
-0.0780562758,
0.0159970373,
0.0485616326,
-0.0234880578,
-0.0120793758,
-0.0447853133,
-0.0128580723,
-0.0357512794,
-0.0090274112,
-0.0388747714,
-0.007205809,
-0.0260987189,
0.0232999306,
0.0361177363,
-0.0116323093,
-0.0335863791,
-0.0585221425,
-0.0134590613,
-0.0367296301,
-0.0563142747,
0.0189650059,
0.0034286624,
0.028489951,
0.0009463521,
-0.0320779234,
0.1174616516,
0.0564456955,
-0.0218352713,
0.0073816269,
0.0266909897,
0.0049177236,
-0.0073843305,
0.0373034701,
-0.0481677838,
0.0525324941,
0.0237659551,
0.0046906187,
0.0025306768,
-0.0429691151,
0.0238855351,
0.0259951651,
0.079912357,
0.0278472565,
0.0025876851,
-0.0312831663,
0.022513682,
-0.032972835,
-0.0216902141,
-0.0270748585,
-0.0160160623,
0.0052825464,
-0.0197601151,
-0.0141884554,
0.01855026,
-0.0594953671,
0.0751239359,
-0.0257729478,
-0.010102489,
0.0510064214,
0.0400150642,
-0.0090140607,
0.0260295738,
-0.0207862612,
0.0217822883,
0.012050733,
0.0440614223,
-0.0370586589,
0.0225252137,
0.0245274715,
0.0244754963,
-0.0357052721,
0.0193317011,
-0.0722661391,
0.0276020896,
0.0020765541,
-0.0011735117,
0.0239634048,
-0.0103013255,
-0.0135325603,
0.0282857325,
-0.03033741,
-0.0080191512,
0.0249330476,
0.0060552703,
-0.0610311404,
0.0246265009,
0.0185422637,
-0.0390448831,
0.019662844,
0.0623318665,
0.0004351377,
0.0093168598,
-0.0047817826,
0.0170752257,
-0.043027278,
0.034857627,
0.0306025874,
0.0176587179,
0.0375749171,
0.0179518666,
-0.0077834255,
-0.0292666294,
0.064836517,
-0.0197644159,
-0.0521925241,
0.016512759,
0.022942882,
-0.0155656124,
0.0076608034,
-0.0195942707,
-0.0232434813,
0.0050182152,
-0.0079434263,
-0.0524319112,
-0.016545061,
-5.670019042e-33,
-0.0152378632,
-0.0046834149,
-0.008920962,
-0.0480878651,
0.0124008795,
0.0372237749,
-0.0157787185,
-0.0157721993,
0.004628879,
0.0272745248,
-0.0060340753,
-0.0207123458,
0.0068928422,
0.0753964111,
0.0102656269,
-0.0399655476,
0.0293992832,
-0.0164116155,
-0.0184885096,
0.0184768327,
0.042141553,
0.0424193554,
0.0348724127,
-0.0228931811,
0.0099311117,
-0.0353146866,
0.032138668,
0.0148988469,
0.0697661042,
0.0524677373,
-0.0157104079,
0.0918473005,
0.0301031582,
-0.0567251146,
0.015291228,
0.0756693706,
-0.0520231016,
-0.0690473691,
-0.0392900333,
-0.0144010382,
-0.0149902403,
-0.0565855913,
-0.0079184501,
-0.0156793632,
0.0012520533,
-0.0371340998,
0.0398290791,
0.0033977313,
-0.0021169016,
-0.0010736039,
-0.0386720411,
-0.0165619999,
-0.0025491263,
-0.0088866046,
0.0255469102,
0.1124333739,
0.0173084941,
0.092550382,
-0.0558329336,
0.0047991043,
-0.0265231095,
0.0237770639,
-0.01639577,
0.0216723345,
-0.0098980656,
0.0685110837,
0.0204636361,
-0.0209196266,
-0.0210421123,
-0.0108107394,
0.0039752317,
-0.0069997036,
0.0222676471,
0.1009978577,
0.0667589009,
-0.003703201,
-0.0997898504,
0.0206672251,
-0.0155126331,
-0.0409122184,
0.0166284312,
0.022460198,
-0.026085142,
-0.0398157574,
-0.0259920433,
-0.03445746,
-0.0592943467,
-0.0100030601,
0.0697655007,
0.0186780374,
0.0082769757,
0.0083850119,
0.0400152989,
-0.0334138051,
-0.0091727162,
0.0317496844,
-0.0172995962,
0.0374767557,
0.0158111155,
0.0113947373,
-0.0667346939,
-0.0134121347,
0.0506226309,
0.0263596792,
-0.0088266889,
0.005166044,
0.0881167129,
-0.0104910471,
-0.074478887,
-0.0153261954,
0.0042556296,
0.0003734519,
-0.0394337028,
0.0208523609,
-0.016388135,
0.0660938174,
0.0017471171,
0.0905213356,
0.0220877603,
-0.0288568977,
0.0035866282,
-0.0474432036,
-0.0056180446,
0.003637003,
-0.0027860533,
0.0178847332,
-0.004702914,
0.047263097,
0.0095817698,
-0.0352586061,
0.0221024416,
-0.0147017473,
2.41e-7,
0.0238488764,
0.0070930785,
0.0182768907,
-0.0494789518,
0.0143363224,
0.0587111972,
0.0073114247,
0.0590566322,
0.0076817325,
-0.0345744714,
0.0159240868,
0.0048580398,
0.0290634595,
0.0031046225,
-0.1038723066,
0.0293859299,
-0.0514086001,
-0.0199761726,
-0.062474478,
0.0196571331,
0.1399077028,
0.0828062743,
0.0169043858,
-0.0039577279,
-0.0055233599,
-0.0199065227,
0.0507408194,
0.0102929454,
-0.0104573844,
-0.0160441548,
-0.0111954091,
0.0124387434,
0.017308943,
0.0036472597,
0.0007413251,
0.0323153622,
-0.0011621257,
0.0225453041,
-0.0275882222,
-0.0776878819,
-0.0101343207,
0.0489413776,
-0.0271792449,
-0.0024643608,
0.0943897665,
-0.0858714804,
-0.0231325813,
0.0017904921,
-0.0557191968,
0.0122910338,
0.0394456089,
0.0178129207,
-0.0369646065,
0.0058066794,
0.0401850939,
0.0186129194,
-0.0294219088,
-0.0858190879,
-0.0031795795,
0.0151356095,
-0.0080154743,
0.0243954659,
-0.0222430564,
0.0005196424,
0.0214503668,
-0.0713565946,
0.0132591827,
2.168308844e-34,
0.0117132049,
0.0041273297,
0.023820471,
-0.0032207235,
-0.0058876858,
-0.0239683297,
-0.0207649115,
-0.0239062719,
0.0443620458,
-0.0834588632,
0.0060434826
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10381v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10381v1 | To Adapt or to Annotate: Challenges and Interventions for Domain Adaptation in Open-Domain Question Answering | 2022-12-20T16:06:09 | 2022-12-20T16:06:09 | Dheeru Dua, Emma Strubell, Sameer Singh, Pat Verga | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent advances in open-domain question answering (ODQA) have demonstrated
impressive accuracy on standard Wikipedia style benchmarks. However, it is less
clear how robust these models are and how well they perform when applied to
real-world applications in drastically different domains. While there has been
some work investigating how well ODQA models perform when tested for
out-of-domain (OOD) generalization, these studies have been conducted only
under conservative shifts in data distribution and typically focus on a single
component (ie. retrieval) rather than an end-to-end system. In response, we
propose a more realistic and challenging domain shift evaluation setting and,
through extensive experiments, study end-to-end model performance. We find that
not only do models fail to generalize, but high retrieval scores often still
yield poor answer prediction accuracy. We then categorize different types of
shifts and propose techniques that, when presented with a new dataset, predict
if intervention methods are likely to be successful. Finally, using insights
from this analysis, we propose and evaluate several intervention methods which
improve end-to-end answer F1 score by up to 24 points. | [
0.0430159979,
0.0098119127,
-0.0106117129,
-0.0104708411,
0.0018726487,
0.0091690598,
-0.0025121944,
0.0146740153,
-0.002236587,
-0.0598119311,
-0.0201369394,
-0.0249065887,
-0.05598519,
0.0103659257,
-0.0358504206,
-0.0402942672,
0.0515120737,
-0.0000930761,
-0.0247313138,
0.00177829,
-0.0211730059,
-0.0177812129,
-0.0271933004,
0.01032463,
0.0547607616,
-0.0432649739,
0.0175093897,
0.0002754031,
0.0421793945,
0.004938493,
0.0337021872,
0.0710292011,
0.0379663929,
-0.0156975426,
0.0000018874,
-0.078831628,
-0.0194837935,
-0.007678492,
-0.0273192171,
0.0077564861,
-0.0231495351,
0.0246766526,
0.042107489,
0.0279523227,
-0.0476946719,
-0.0199567471,
0.0391961783,
0.0085330112,
0.0603845678,
0.0672262907,
0.0197500009,
-0.0102017289,
0.0062719039,
0.0050417576,
-0.0263505038,
-0.0454649143,
0.0458533615,
0.0131929507,
0.0005068252,
-0.0120048337,
-0.0528884158,
0.0059437114,
0.0066510453,
0.0353812501,
0.0352251008,
0.0065701432,
-0.0408840328,
0.0428872108,
0.0370513834,
0.0788567439,
0.0354524106,
-0.0116023533,
-0.0268796738,
0.0117681185,
0.0604558624,
0.076136522,
-0.0737751126,
-0.0254729837,
-0.0093903458,
-0.0536594652,
-0.012821584,
0.0179166198,
0.0113385143,
0.0398422405,
-0.0454327799,
0.0687332451,
0.0080108345,
-0.0373474844,
0.0291697346,
0.0267839245,
-0.0741188303,
-0.0301151313,
0.0077349884,
0.0337821133,
0.0112744262,
0.032406047,
-0.0197962504,
-0.0483340323,
0.0086171608,
-0.0476966575,
0.0267651901,
0.0339347459,
-0.0330569856,
0.0304811802,
-0.0245563742,
0.0407340936,
-0.0214440376,
0.0104964767,
-0.054973308,
-0.0027838435,
-0.088819921,
-0.0251585841,
-0.0247640647,
0.0452507809,
-0.033228524,
0.0003228608,
-0.0150427474,
0.0369164012,
0.015777424,
-0.082461141,
0.0087481011,
0.0273117535,
-0.008484751,
0.0038274352,
-0.0758519098,
0.0817554072,
-0.055366002,
0.0366479717,
0.0300595425,
-0.0387293063,
-0.016556628,
-0.0022051686,
0.0157792456,
-0.0161083695,
-0.0080916369,
0.0757261962,
0.0118888784,
0.0011068488,
0.0000551167,
-0.0061290013,
-0.0075902934,
-0.0156453755,
0.039643988,
-0.0502751321,
-0.0139304018,
0.0318975784,
0.0057108598,
-0.0579732396,
-0.0162745062,
0.0392959081,
-0.0202003084,
0.0242185388,
-0.0325706713,
0.0003354851,
0.0532631092,
0.0136997635,
-0.0115719978,
0.0793375522,
-0.009014084,
-0.0591581613,
0.0617964417,
0.005866,
0.0112142712,
0.0183676593,
0.0143696237,
0.015955111,
0.0802156851,
0.0775522962,
0.0310518779,
0.0417316481,
0.0360354707,
-0.0369395837,
-0.0212951545,
-0.0410185046,
0.0291412771,
0.0392679162,
0.0351647846,
0.0023823313,
0.0028589517,
-0.0188253708,
0.016252283,
0.0240961593,
-0.0320386626,
0.0233703703,
-0.0111579401,
0.0021050076,
-0.0105408262,
0.0035793853,
-0.0409185179,
-0.0318624116,
-0.0086788144,
0.023830723,
-0.0124214897,
0.0003799033,
0.0582893863,
0.0303203221,
-0.017348554,
0.0554711558,
0.0356380865,
-0.0224307608,
0.0428183526,
-0.0408171155,
0.0114407167,
0.0085889548,
0.024260724,
-0.0738203824,
-0.0250831358,
-0.0244813208,
0.0526060835,
0.022534186,
0.0340160839,
-0.0313303359,
-0.0202421993,
-0.0242541656,
-0.0269221906,
-0.0055260719,
-0.0014503662,
0.0058614747,
0.0458825976,
0.0071403906,
-0.0068844049,
-0.1056557223,
-0.0083338432,
0.0349922776,
-0.0384474471,
-0.0292493328,
-0.00284834,
0.0080066863,
-0.0001796935,
0.0148278959,
-0.0032850837,
0.0104223453,
0.0132968128,
-0.0102847908,
-0.0572262108,
-0.0316879898,
-0.0210406482,
0.0184428599,
0.0326874889,
-0.0380817167,
0.0128574874,
0.0558390506,
-0.0331624448,
-0.0199571047,
0.0209853984,
-0.021552084,
-0.0014794159,
-0.006481634,
-0.018066166,
-0.0077986508,
-0.0013175636,
-0.0835366994,
0.0535872616,
0.0175665524,
0.0030306519,
0.0057847491,
-0.0316496156,
0.0162849799,
-0.0218014903,
0.0338372365,
-0.0241827257,
-0.0334533267,
0.0340161547,
0.0233115908,
-0.031665273,
-0.0909232497,
0.0200104266,
-0.0710617453,
0.027506249,
-0.0322549231,
0.0419188924,
0.064382121,
0.0208450686,
-0.0154119749,
-0.0155935027,
-0.04930114,
0.0091708833,
0.002676138,
0.0494060777,
0.0203600358,
0.0199547242,
0.0307690334,
0.0059734499,
-0.0157555807,
-0.0070760585,
0.0610523336,
-0.0240378976,
-0.0071272654,
-0.0762154385,
0.026769992,
-0.0636747703,
-0.0059333434,
0.0111369705,
0.0268311109,
-0.0248144772,
0.0208142474,
0.0312066544,
0.0408165045,
0.0094980849,
-0.0255163535,
0.0390008539,
0.0029735279,
-0.0501110777,
0.0117727621,
-0.0131053617,
-0.0557819307,
-0.0387629606,
0.0068409839,
0.0291517396,
0.014482867,
-0.0171587728,
-0.0143948272,
-0.0383901782,
0.0122241508,
-0.0503318831,
-0.0216109585,
-0.0589154139,
0.0238474719,
-0.0208503716,
0.0483183526,
-0.0033844181,
0.0014300261,
0.0571234077,
0.0505909361,
0.0390420072,
-0.0912478268,
0.0230133124,
-0.0352187827,
0.0305437166,
-0.0612124205,
0.0094249435,
0.0480961278,
-0.0083336588,
-0.0602561682,
-0.0084867151,
0.0041140257,
-0.0359881856,
0.0856654495,
-0.0486069508,
0.0131169967,
0.0036225196,
-0.0198031869,
-0.0533152223,
-0.0451208577,
-0.0127469674,
0.0212392136,
-0.0684416518,
0.0132629564,
-0.0462595224,
-0.0026511473,
0.0102645857,
0.0229401477,
-0.0415110439,
-0.0082760565,
0.0098254131,
0.0618203022,
0.0562438145,
0.0758082643,
-0.0040042964,
-0.0242847241,
0.0064140745,
0.0333035551,
-0.0045063701,
-0.0596789308,
0.0044471128,
-0.0276612472,
0.0428742245,
-0.0908313692,
-0.0242332146,
0.0146365445,
0.0575100668,
-0.0117656169,
-0.0428987034,
0.0786529109,
0.0209742915,
0.0054323296,
0.0048978794,
-0.0511288829,
0.0209887195,
0.0187431853,
0.0298391618,
-0.0827961266,
-0.051159244,
-0.0224165972,
0.0632569119,
0.02091581,
-0.0402008668,
0.0413516872,
-0.1291162819,
0.0101955291,
-0.0350637957,
-0.0809220448,
-0.0295284968,
-0.0481210798,
0.0408749469,
-0.0133804567,
0.0009704047,
0.0027924723,
-0.0074858675,
0.009886588,
0.0615697652,
0.0101164151,
-0.0026511003,
0.0106987664,
-0.030913014,
0.035130173,
0.067400597,
-0.0137756225,
-0.0006662159,
-0.0034277281,
0.0114468625,
-0.0520774014,
0.0290166847,
-0.0213443376,
0.0919730514,
0.0057617947,
0.0105882026,
-0.0063676522,
3.543e-7,
-0.0613790825,
-0.0063246447,
0.0396515913,
0.0810681581,
0.0127056548,
-0.0007897965,
-0.0457289666,
0.0076814406,
-0.0250219684,
0.0317236073,
0.0017490177,
-0.0467124768,
0.0153957345,
-0.0144934095,
-0.0493926071,
-0.0260641389,
-0.0430089012,
0.0169405155,
0.003567575,
0.020096967,
-0.0773919597,
-0.0130712157,
0.0131194843,
0.013733672,
0.0078293532,
0.0017509575,
-0.0154139036,
0.0555719584,
-0.055390913,
0.045091521,
-0.0639049187,
0.0166542027,
-0.0375228375,
0.0069101439,
0.0417117923,
-0.0261914488,
-0.0443171635,
0.0039143884,
-0.0317578651,
-0.0145339407,
0.0376831852,
0.0297517851,
0.0151523333,
-0.0199892707,
0.0043005887,
-0.0330855623,
0.0329539999,
0.013052606,
-0.0299061555,
0.0274816528,
0.0302128866,
-0.005239198,
-0.0222372562,
0.0306444764,
-0.0647273064,
-0.0119182346,
0.0232299119,
0.0327714942,
0.0181514453,
-0.0422265753,
0.0271121114,
-0.0113766585,
0.0272884667,
0.0485783666,
-0.0683708638,
-0.0054134829,
0.0155391814,
0.0107068382,
-0.0087190988,
0.0222436804,
-0.0005733329,
0.037787769,
-0.022591684,
-0.0047952328,
0.0658822805,
-0.0387058631,
0.0263242442,
-0.0615049936,
-0.001379748,
0.0686570704,
0.0511177592,
-0.0309460443,
0.0045519103,
-0.0420820899,
-0.0524312705,
0.0283220634,
0.0570486188,
0.0005285631,
0.0652611703,
0.0092920978,
0.0134880431,
0.0064854627,
0.0106879892,
-0.1048200503,
-0.0085250717,
-0.0181069616,
0.0218041465,
0.023258809,
0.0014782015,
0.0261866245,
0.0242763478,
-0.0248294119,
-0.0223583039,
-0.0361645073,
0.0041797785,
0.0338933356,
0.0599906556,
0.020458648,
0.00145287,
-0.0069937594,
0.0360552892,
0.0002434345,
0.054532174,
-0.0125531377,
0.0008643566,
-0.0152028343,
-0.0296986401,
-0.0188348647,
0.030251313,
-0.0170305409,
0.0050460957,
-0.0528646708,
-0.0348213129,
-0.0010442075,
-0.0334262401,
-0.0088890484,
-0.0169152189,
0.0432024859,
0.0439629294,
0.0121222343,
-0.0608889498,
-0.0252655521,
0.0293105934,
-0.0472483113,
0.002589416,
-0.0199277382,
-5.901184781e-33,
-0.0308824684,
0.0083186505,
0.0119979866,
-0.0106349336,
-0.0241402891,
-0.0103808399,
0.0013650667,
0.0366325714,
-0.049241215,
-0.0190944448,
-0.0082774386,
0.0232551862,
0.0156050194,
0.0052364739,
-0.0076749041,
-0.0638765916,
0.0100953784,
-0.0233790744,
-0.0494497679,
-0.0291837007,
0.0427873023,
0.0335883871,
0.059729971,
-0.0687012374,
0.0403524674,
-0.018729005,
0.0130970329,
0.0129730068,
0.0174015071,
0.0604862608,
0.0104666501,
0.0632416606,
0.0532347001,
-0.0569778681,
0.0051096282,
0.0258349683,
-0.1168583259,
-0.018422978,
0.0269390214,
0.0016920264,
-0.0180731788,
-0.0508827381,
-0.0017780275,
0.0367846079,
0.0091282194,
-0.0778996795,
0.0454981998,
-0.0521307997,
-0.0103231575,
0.0114073902,
-0.0557374656,
0.0159879215,
0.0210258868,
-0.0256504994,
-0.0748872533,
0.1050887629,
0.015780285,
-0.0138033917,
-0.0208600722,
0.0211420935,
-0.0034002198,
0.0421543084,
0.0664793327,
0.023852963,
-0.0246365648,
0.0368160978,
-0.0307384059,
0.0044247434,
0.0081438757,
-0.054723084,
-0.0044161868,
-0.0207619239,
0.0569855757,
0.0747193843,
0.0380200818,
0.0116873849,
-0.0950828418,
0.0432324335,
-0.0609100945,
-0.001893503,
-0.0044744583,
-0.0035961138,
-0.0137832724,
-0.0034751142,
-0.0595005862,
0.0452035628,
-0.0277713686,
-0.0287256911,
0.0537356175,
-0.0145672755,
-0.0280150715,
-0.0012049907,
0.0194448978,
-0.0697162971,
0.0371859632,
0.0129299238,
-0.0015970228,
0.029065052,
0.0120947501,
0.0164926685,
-0.0291101374,
-0.0006019951,
0.0197016764,
0.0244162269,
0.0059493016,
-0.000015666,
0.020561194,
-0.0126785943,
-0.0479783714,
-0.0185751095,
-0.0185558796,
-0.013858282,
-0.0102838697,
0.051775489,
-0.0000541361,
0.048234392,
-0.0005470288,
0.0463449992,
0.0370783433,
-0.0160797294,
-0.0356116258,
-0.0312393568,
0.0269103795,
-0.016160734,
-0.0337102376,
0.0136713302,
0.018185908,
0.0450791568,
-0.0565018505,
-0.0471511856,
-0.023858469,
0.0240267385,
2.532e-7,
0.1010032296,
0.0186032653,
0.025509607,
0.027321795,
-0.0045149098,
0.0134537537,
0.0202881899,
0.0293222405,
0.0768670738,
-0.0061604176,
-0.0026938256,
0.0094863437,
0.0175024327,
0.0088739963,
-0.0750454515,
-0.0645611957,
0.0172776971,
0.0125756469,
-0.0164149534,
-0.0154662812,
0.0317665674,
0.0562550835,
-0.0073914519,
-0.0179555602,
-0.0325438157,
-0.0394690968,
0.0558372922,
-0.0032176562,
0.0154162645,
-0.0083696917,
-0.0055314391,
0.0275040753,
0.0235074777,
0.0586658083,
-0.0094261756,
0.0137023292,
0.0483045988,
0.0297682155,
0.0017919719,
-0.0489422493,
-0.0409068055,
-0.0143961608,
0.0456298552,
-0.0324943475,
0.0473996699,
-0.0544718467,
-0.0199124031,
0.007994798,
-0.0452878587,
0.0180015322,
0.0032982293,
-0.0014121402,
0.0101764975,
0.0071050567,
0.012347538,
0.053879045,
-0.0117906043,
-0.0380420052,
-0.0209792443,
0.0002548333,
-0.0119165517,
-0.0662959144,
-0.0109616593,
-0.0194068886,
-0.003707736,
-0.0563034602,
0.0092035318,
1.832123429e-34,
-0.0066935965,
0.0322873555,
0.0162928067,
0.0217852835,
-0.0048298575,
-0.0220415983,
0.0170430671,
-0.0356863812,
0.0526734032,
-0.1064552739,
0.0192870405
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10380v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10380v2 | What Are You Token About? Dense Retrieval as Distributions Over the Vocabulary | 2022-12-20T16:03:25 | 2023-05-24T12:05:27 | Ori Ram, Liat Bezalel, Adi Zicher, Yonatan Belinkov, Jonathan Berant, Amir Globerson | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Dual encoders are now the dominant architecture for dense retrieval. Yet, we
have little understanding of how they represent text, and why this leads to
good performance. In this work, we shed light on this question via
distributions over the vocabulary. We propose to interpret the vector
representations produced by dual encoders by projecting them into the model's
vocabulary space. We show that the resulting projections contain rich semantic
information, and draw connection between them and sparse retrieval. We find
that this view can offer an explanation for some of the failure cases of dense
retrievers. For example, we observe that the inability of models to handle tail
entities is correlated with a tendency of the token distributions to forget
some of the tokens of those entities. We leverage this insight and propose a
simple way to enrich query and passage representations with lexical information
at inference time, and show that this significantly improves performance
compared to the original model in zero-shot settings, and specifically on the
BEIR benchmark. | [
0.0186217502,
0.0106642786,
-0.0081442259,
0.0568041541,
-0.0053793718,
0.0075219697,
-0.0159576479,
0.0414597131,
-0.0385512635,
-0.0443737544,
-0.0079585621,
-0.068373546,
-0.0266712401,
0.0759757534,
0.0134147629,
-0.0479136817,
0.0416503362,
0.0070969672,
0.0207024645,
-0.0055925408,
0.0023644255,
0.0130300131,
0.0156911891,
0.0474019013,
-0.0294331778,
0.0311896671,
-0.0083231749,
0.0543627664,
-0.0154311862,
-0.0324329063,
0.0034806102,
0.0086211991,
0.0547518767,
0.0212549474,
0.0000017415,
-0.0172711965,
-0.0369222388,
0.0099740811,
-0.0335947424,
0.0149065983,
0.0240537263,
-0.0083983634,
0.0451009944,
-0.0341618657,
0.0301783178,
-0.0245076399,
0.0377168804,
0.0493246354,
-0.0130810477,
0.0526170023,
-0.0118464241,
-0.0313816443,
0.0240591355,
-0.0172647741,
0.0461951122,
-0.0504942909,
0.0350397751,
-0.0694062337,
-0.0133262621,
0.058884494,
-0.0367717855,
0.0316714719,
0.0281183552,
0.0413057357,
0.0444522388,
0.0599007271,
-0.0374719501,
-0.0002686252,
0.0176850446,
0.0218789279,
-0.000890298,
-0.0209551733,
0.0064943386,
0.0272256546,
-0.0210206024,
-0.0147420177,
-0.0511860847,
0.0099893976,
0.0032207659,
0.0127049452,
-0.0376458094,
0.0029027839,
0.0170389917,
0.0033476551,
-0.0693399534,
0.0079633379,
0.0375018008,
-0.0215768497,
-0.022418458,
0.0221203025,
-0.0388191082,
-0.0087213786,
0.0205141902,
0.0068263756,
-0.0115380492,
0.0028687753,
0.0206194762,
-0.0261923615,
0.0220324416,
-0.0160094947,
0.0172772799,
0.0529809967,
-0.0583149269,
0.0379576758,
-0.0357786119,
0.0527557805,
-0.0142407902,
0.071124658,
-0.0313173309,
-0.0369080268,
-0.0125952577,
-0.0456403419,
-0.0604861602,
0.0825497955,
-0.0497027487,
-0.0436919667,
-0.0180422645,
0.0242878683,
0.0243724976,
-0.025298778,
-0.0221355539,
0.0436898619,
-0.0446001701,
0.0094619486,
-0.0160922538,
0.0268164668,
-0.051728759,
-0.0115628298,
0.0377811156,
-0.0325987488,
-0.0413057171,
0.0009030731,
0.0301708467,
-0.0714779794,
-0.0132400626,
0.0333981924,
-0.0269705635,
-0.0675739422,
-0.0132418135,
-0.0342262387,
-0.0203883927,
-0.0282445531,
-0.0165372938,
-0.0501707196,
0.0490460768,
0.0383595638,
0.0022602247,
-0.0522206947,
-0.0056660874,
0.035724353,
-0.0433603227,
0.0417881645,
0.0045209094,
-0.0192799419,
0.0202057119,
0.0226826724,
0.0225150213,
0.0664880127,
-0.01884217,
0.057040453,
0.0602776483,
0.042924393,
0.0014672532,
0.0001445214,
0.0373858139,
0.0002644542,
-0.0582051165,
0.0124485083,
0.0100785019,
0.0154604902,
0.0411858968,
0.0769019276,
-0.0742931962,
-0.0289426334,
-0.0018733181,
0.0874212235,
0.0100559527,
-0.0423809029,
0.0337649547,
-0.0188043974,
-0.0440851226,
0.0126600321,
-0.0162978861,
0.0317150615,
0.0080296146,
-0.002180597,
0.0662972778,
0.0072082058,
-0.0482264273,
-0.0042409268,
-0.0112366276,
0.019187877,
-0.0293525252,
-0.0046854205,
0.0462430306,
-0.0210487843,
-0.0268716197,
0.0650152415,
0.0113261873,
-0.050005164,
0.0213875193,
-0.0346712805,
0.0054138759,
0.024845019,
0.0699922964,
-0.0249228533,
-0.0028861305,
0.0442099161,
-0.0266158618,
0.0021802257,
0.0041932776,
-0.0183957797,
0.0186985023,
-0.0493045114,
-0.0518217906,
-0.0217382256,
0.0247350484,
0.0246092174,
0.0115849618,
0.0328649431,
0.0564746521,
-0.0778861567,
0.011708729,
0.0228956845,
-0.0021780874,
-0.0118091516,
0.0180717334,
0.0131776445,
0.0023546393,
0.0279258918,
0.0033963071,
0.0233329665,
0.0654330775,
-0.0294393301,
-0.0171129126,
-0.0227619745,
-0.0550583079,
-0.0129656997,
-0.0011808333,
0.0047185048,
0.043131616,
0.0193548966,
0.0052770819,
-0.0322276391,
-0.0003589318,
-0.0293371882,
0.0538666733,
-0.0305645242,
0.000388139,
0.0055554952,
0.021153165,
-0.0314273573,
0.0702734962,
0.002224084,
0.0456539951,
-0.0230458025,
0.0000882199,
0.0333007835,
-0.056682907,
-0.0379013829,
0.0343257971,
-0.0136553394,
0.0037437321,
0.0601665564,
-0.0572798699,
-0.0053041675,
0.0056037968,
-0.0860620365,
0.0097656557,
-0.0522722043,
-0.0162273515,
-0.0192188639,
0.0325914621,
0.0055424981,
-0.017738577,
-0.0275529679,
-0.0170730781,
-0.0068102442,
0.0414004512,
0.0103300028,
0.0343226343,
-0.0135221919,
-0.0133795962,
-0.0530631952,
-0.001159993,
0.0478844941,
-0.0531471856,
-0.0505186319,
-0.0059048524,
0.00130749,
-0.0258143824,
-0.0063579525,
-0.0225818343,
0.0189357251,
0.021685563,
-0.0704456046,
0.0231337938,
0.058035586,
0.0402461812,
0.0721780062,
-0.0255960375,
-0.0227381438,
-0.0914901644,
0.0171842109,
-0.0432761721,
0.0060187653,
-0.0192160588,
0.0051538949,
0.0055152215,
0.0038535686,
-0.0071735303,
0.0011283855,
-0.0377386883,
-0.0101845646,
0.001572811,
-0.0346507169,
-0.074042134,
0.0144206844,
-0.011141045,
0.043322362,
-0.0272750072,
0.0001607947,
0.0530414321,
-0.0145830568,
-0.0105790775,
0.0106661813,
0.0088889282,
-0.0620943978,
0.0833373591,
0.0078952191,
0.0172357224,
-0.0404590033,
-0.054233212,
-0.0066892034,
0.0204167012,
-0.0367138088,
-0.0216109175,
0.0300027821,
0.0157437995,
0.0185920261,
-0.0081200395,
-0.0514036268,
-0.02990794,
-0.0093964981,
-0.0014121262,
0.0324797407,
0.0142599074,
-0.0161587875,
-0.0693708956,
0.0192569997,
0.0029309518,
0.0175345335,
-0.0342001989,
-0.0006094289,
-0.0193955302,
0.0317049921,
0.0511592887,
-0.0075794561,
-0.0243117493,
-0.0439165086,
-0.0219074246,
0.0720832199,
0.0111859143,
-0.0427706391,
0.0284720212,
0.0056624417,
0.0569620021,
-0.0324046016,
-0.0081181107,
0.0083890734,
0.059352912,
-0.0160158649,
-0.0715716779,
0.0775767863,
0.026227111,
-0.0557961538,
-0.017842263,
-0.0164573882,
0.0599510036,
0.0305705518,
0.0001210166,
-0.0861510858,
-0.0317336917,
0.0126046007,
0.0387084633,
0.0287155658,
-0.0219774209,
0.0320644081,
-0.0884715244,
0.0270466376,
-0.0180804431,
-0.0218043756,
-0.0437164903,
-0.0519182645,
0.003275611,
-0.016446678,
0.0487988256,
0.0203992613,
-0.0033839871,
-0.0098928381,
0.0121328775,
0.0817743391,
-0.0060575809,
0.0063019968,
-0.0472268537,
-0.0054761278,
0.0223778859,
0.033080291,
0.0090444433,
-0.0222137105,
-0.006519835,
-0.060155686,
0.0068827281,
-0.0064356248,
0.0784100592,
-0.0590448007,
0.009846109,
0.0025375595,
-0.0120832585,
-0.0086544435,
-0.0283566397,
-0.0422540531,
0.0219769664,
-0.0216921642,
-0.0059601427,
-0.0682760403,
-0.0488730371,
-0.0322686881,
0.0807695761,
0.0054909918,
0.0225966554,
-0.0387391113,
-0.0257433318,
0.0099028572,
-0.0292875879,
-0.0190110654,
-0.0116600702,
0.0002557096,
-0.0190597866,
-0.0343594067,
-0.0271749143,
0.0097542508,
0.0607798137,
-0.0329113789,
0.0274661165,
-0.0603509434,
-0.0243570823,
-0.0590102524,
0.0140852183,
-0.0467569195,
0.0002547615,
-0.0682202652,
0.0149313016,
-0.003199748,
-0.0043924451,
-0.044385206,
-0.0020669911,
-0.0352897719,
-0.0515751839,
-0.0041542817,
0.0159677844,
0.0170191973,
0.0330948755,
-0.0083724102,
-0.0386793576,
0.0791453198,
0.08041922,
-0.0661218092,
0.0066385656,
-0.0159656312,
-0.0277974326,
-0.036042776,
0.0257299934,
-0.078878738,
0.0159447826,
-0.009207136,
0.0540746599,
-0.0106844595,
-0.0523489267,
0.0260286219,
0.0208720826,
0.0823605508,
0.0269092359,
0.0131000597,
-0.0270120818,
0.0105454,
-0.0508451797,
-0.0203986112,
-0.0079062898,
0.0006423267,
0.0178963337,
-0.017388504,
-0.0257547144,
0.0338802896,
0.0303159244,
0.0819582939,
-0.0541270003,
-0.0405865498,
0.001059632,
-0.0368487537,
0.0045747557,
0.001657553,
-0.0156391449,
0.0059421961,
-0.0014786382,
0.0658800006,
-0.0556416735,
0.0123198824,
0.0188578665,
0.0040562907,
-0.0389644019,
0.0037324543,
-0.0897149891,
-0.0118369712,
-0.0156036988,
0.0361958519,
0.0123653151,
-0.0321862847,
-0.0035049662,
0.0018641473,
-0.0149525534,
-0.0320644528,
-0.0146492114,
0.0277284216,
-0.0274075605,
0.0220135823,
0.042124413,
-0.0112272203,
0.0017712727,
0.0503834225,
0.0190879833,
0.0383268595,
-0.0113934195,
-0.025176242,
-0.0057641752,
0.0055018729,
0.0693996549,
0.0458745211,
0.0125976885,
-0.0110232569,
-0.0241065696,
-0.0369944721,
0.0695868134,
-0.0238763429,
0.0036174764,
-0.0051046833,
0.0364566222,
0.079759568,
0.0273901969,
-0.0362370797,
-0.0263675507,
0.0103654237,
-0.026391834,
0.0040298565,
-0.0024033615,
-6.434429794e-33,
-0.035532631,
0.015180489,
0.0057334714,
-0.0242078751,
-0.020502748,
0.0216771588,
-0.0198709462,
-0.0177454259,
-0.018648468,
0.0070660333,
-0.0126926061,
0.0175470188,
0.0130329421,
0.0270048212,
-0.0145128099,
-0.0248399191,
0.046384681,
0.0173832942,
-0.0145932408,
0.0121779386,
0.0808844194,
0.0575907677,
0.0253617782,
-0.0168306399,
0.0132491942,
-0.0195654314,
0.0473434515,
0.019096693,
0.0471707247,
0.0547958016,
-0.0268339142,
0.0422497801,
0.0220794864,
-0.0125540728,
-0.0124153355,
0.0032555601,
-0.0982069299,
-0.0278793331,
-0.0017799446,
0.0053837574,
-0.0079274112,
-0.0464466922,
0.0465982147,
-0.0199830551,
-0.006339815,
-0.015380064,
0.0194594115,
0.0303616617,
-0.0630802587,
-0.0362824313,
-0.044899676,
0.0202641618,
0.0077057914,
0.0190779213,
0.0542478524,
0.0116379047,
0.0550035797,
0.0237095691,
-0.0286921114,
-0.0101373876,
-0.0771048069,
0.0637874901,
-0.0110820467,
0.0394375399,
-0.0230771359,
0.0679668933,
0.0213314518,
-0.0255841967,
-0.0664651021,
0.0076316516,
0.0380411372,
0.0224298015,
-0.0052754497,
0.0287145525,
0.0503553562,
-0.0295001362,
-0.0569205843,
0.0486112647,
-0.0386403129,
0.0554452203,
0.0611175671,
0.0467369296,
-0.0550738908,
-0.026263807,
-0.0164844431,
-0.0262701847,
-0.0528653897,
-0.0119645894,
0.044940982,
0.0419133827,
-0.0094915545,
0.0249322932,
0.0688368827,
-0.011396924,
-0.0228297319,
0.0407767817,
0.0053157303,
0.0070654987,
-0.0044631474,
0.0355570912,
-0.0058844504,
-0.0423316546,
0.0439727195,
0.0177317001,
-0.0318788216,
0.0103901848,
0.0420624278,
-0.012674259,
-0.0395486429,
-0.0243396293,
-0.0129515883,
-0.0188703369,
-0.0421674289,
0.0301523153,
0.0271220114,
0.0522608273,
0.010246641,
0.0453615524,
0.0147732357,
-0.0000734229,
-0.0427683853,
-0.0316182598,
0.0171746295,
0.0061965105,
-0.0273274221,
0.0220779646,
-0.0513702109,
0.0078201843,
0.0360305235,
-0.0489935726,
-0.0101762433,
0.0322582982,
2.491e-7,
0.0636139736,
0.0082252538,
0.0742293596,
0.0105202924,
-0.0438976213,
0.0064512072,
0.0162502564,
0.0658670962,
0.0242094621,
-0.0314956047,
-0.0026137535,
0.0527737364,
-0.0198408719,
0.0047811572,
-0.1226205528,
-0.0006664766,
-0.0565185808,
-0.0062692873,
-0.061197117,
0.0114420177,
0.0774836764,
0.0919010863,
-0.0280909445,
0.0050853584,
0.0061442545,
-0.0418476351,
0.0649532676,
0.020280024,
0.0180186424,
0.008508374,
0.0125522753,
0.0258419029,
0.0455523357,
0.0016177762,
0.0060897721,
0.0474480577,
0.0665692091,
0.0488492362,
-0.0397835486,
-0.0687482059,
0.0081009129,
0.0035924036,
0.0011493147,
-0.0416321456,
0.0755454525,
-0.0039012793,
-0.0022962999,
0.0052417791,
-0.0613240264,
0.0436585173,
-0.0012822469,
0.0292853527,
-0.0327085778,
0.0279651154,
0.0400484167,
0.0211676396,
0.0157937855,
-0.1295713335,
0.008741891,
-0.0077333706,
-0.04306053,
-0.0055522299,
-0.0476278588,
0.023417199,
-0.0070071849,
-0.0561523922,
-0.0337534249,
2.346739244e-34,
0.0477007329,
0.0475755148,
-0.0112709105,
0.0349979252,
0.0392749533,
-0.0390787236,
0.0041466886,
0.0227376781,
-0.0164808333,
-0.0908699781,
-0.0291425698
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10378v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10378v2 | Data Curation Alone Can Stabilize In-context Learning | 2022-12-20T15:58:54 | 2023-05-24T22:32:56 | Ting-Yun Chang, Robin Jia | cs.CL | cs.CL | In-context learning (ICL) enables large language models (LLMs) to perform new
tasks by prompting them with a sequence of training examples. However, it is
known that ICL is very sensitive to the choice of training examples: randomly
sampling examples from a training set leads to high variance in performance. In
this paper, we show that carefully curating a subset of training data greatly
stabilizes ICL performance without any other changes to the ICL algorithm
(e.g., prompt retrieval or calibration). We introduce two methods to choose
training subsets -- both score training examples individually, then select the
highest-scoring ones. CondAcc scores a training example by its average dev-set
ICL accuracy when combined with random training examples, while Datamodels
learns linear regressors that estimate how the presence of each training
example influences LLM outputs. Across five tasks and two LLMs, sampling from
stable subsets selected by CondAcc and Datamodels improves average accuracy
over sampling from the entire training set by 7.7% and 6.3%, respectively.
Surprisingly, the stable subset examples are not especially diverse in content
or low in perplexity, in contrast with other work suggesting that diversity and
perplexity are important when prompting LLMs. | [
0.0005617277,
0.0380664505,
-0.0079193627,
0.0296973996,
-0.0385144241,
0.0365548618,
0.0105019659,
0.0010260402,
-0.0178349558,
-0.0365471244,
-0.0333869271,
-0.0661671981,
0.0119394641,
-0.0011472981,
0.0324785747,
-0.0286727529,
0.037426915,
-0.0689017773,
-0.0162422322,
-0.0041482723,
-0.0213753991,
0.0007645932,
0.0112569062,
0.0205434505,
0.011702219,
-0.0144858984,
0.0024120624,
0.0229860414,
-0.0250437167,
-0.0474989153,
0.0219042394,
0.0579575114,
0.0312709771,
0.0029151624,
0.0000021201,
-0.0580894575,
-0.0126487622,
-0.0186417308,
-0.0517979078,
-0.0217303541,
0.0326433778,
0.0022947444,
0.0260428507,
0.0292468816,
-0.0402442515,
-0.0171130467,
0.0088466275,
0.013209953,
0.0157499928,
0.0825785026,
0.005820482,
0.0176031608,
-0.0159864444,
-0.0394151583,
0.0105099669,
-0.0106136063,
0.0207227338,
0.0138409855,
0.0086651919,
0.0269890036,
-0.015576018,
0.0229843594,
0.0242412481,
0.0195334461,
0.0257443041,
0.0517962724,
-0.0451680236,
-0.0187032707,
-0.0193935372,
0.0769000575,
-0.011375363,
-0.0172692407,
-0.0129971374,
-0.0201723147,
0.0194994304,
-0.00083455,
-0.0621882007,
0.009180529,
-0.0134265376,
0.0344896615,
0.0160600096,
0.0034685936,
0.0512995385,
-0.0090893172,
-0.0374392867,
0.004106082,
0.0030687945,
-0.052048184,
0.0218004584,
0.0251775011,
-0.0437431745,
-0.0333969332,
-0.0453768559,
0.0019758428,
-0.0688442513,
0.0456624031,
-0.0668279976,
-0.042149201,
0.0195904821,
0.0027288336,
0.0177133232,
0.0262641236,
-0.034071479,
0.0732019171,
0.007619184,
0.018553311,
0.0124388002,
0.0306670312,
-0.0440799594,
-0.0130293369,
-0.046729371,
0.0112536615,
-0.0342663005,
0.0212259311,
-0.0313491598,
-0.0229891483,
-0.0166090466,
0.0500422753,
-0.0049147066,
-0.0034610745,
0.0143330265,
-0.0187929198,
-0.0471401289,
0.0271907728,
0.0026005118,
0.0030422637,
-0.0106239207,
0.044013489,
0.0353149772,
-0.0951658562,
-0.0225346927,
-0.0254030786,
0.0347090438,
-0.0338479429,
0.0156993363,
0.050419569,
-0.0118013378,
-0.0764261037,
-0.0337208286,
-0.0117609473,
0.0020423457,
-0.0510766208,
-0.0025334132,
-0.0759082139,
0.0078927604,
0.0281563438,
0.014114378,
-0.0329419151,
-0.0111972699,
0.0206692461,
-0.0112602813,
0.0689144209,
-0.0110188676,
0.0262357779,
0.0284164231,
-0.0128022507,
-0.0241928697,
0.0898922458,
-0.0148513857,
-0.0307750199,
0.0384481959,
0.022191301,
0.0165709741,
0.0249286424,
0.0529113375,
0.0339471512,
-0.021754751,
0.0194186792,
0.0463348813,
0.0081592128,
0.0192057546,
0.0325501412,
-0.0475902073,
0.0138955293,
0.0812689289,
0.0524820387,
0.0051904283,
-0.0044728322,
-0.0057109701,
0.0015541987,
-0.0000518594,
0.0110803302,
-0.0921890065,
0.0126819592,
-0.0029853424,
0.008198305,
0.0318544284,
0.0154687418,
-0.0362995416,
-0.0337422639,
-0.0081656007,
-0.0180129129,
0.0039275009,
0.0503838807,
0.0616534501,
0.0183462668,
-0.0481549017,
0.0085884016,
0.0399830863,
-0.0178797301,
-0.0174144506,
-0.0268212296,
0.0351715423,
0.0511735007,
0.033514753,
-0.0393288918,
-0.0169327445,
-0.0322976559,
0.069537878,
-0.0080003096,
0.021982776,
-0.0100279767,
0.0497169904,
-0.0389229506,
-0.0431369729,
-0.0171257704,
0.0053382372,
0.0110935466,
0.0312072039,
-0.0011169105,
-0.0201649554,
-0.0338530838,
-0.0282213073,
0.0586776584,
-0.0331017897,
-0.0430709161,
0.0124356756,
-0.0028337881,
0.0395854078,
-0.0130874524,
-0.0096895024,
0.0018339587,
0.0370800272,
-0.0477083214,
0.0167942364,
0.0003829472,
-0.0950835794,
-0.0882816464,
0.0202568565,
0.0042897235,
-0.0225630179,
-0.0040592751,
-0.0291551016,
-0.0335937925,
-0.0093787545,
-0.0174033977,
0.0470126681,
-0.0481337495,
0.0302495454,
-0.0126386527,
0.0272909887,
-0.0480496027,
0.0882220343,
-0.0302227177,
0.0225630384,
0.0358911939,
0.0338474438,
-0.0141569804,
-0.0506037474,
-0.0247974657,
-0.0290527139,
-0.017438639,
0.0136228204,
-0.0021219898,
0.0141680278,
-0.0190370101,
0.0095957955,
-0.0982692018,
-0.0175835639,
-0.062373016,
-0.0261484981,
0.0058418773,
0.017874917,
-0.0102612926,
-0.0308046807,
-0.0188821889,
-0.033214502,
0.0323055908,
0.0446870551,
0.0081348885,
0.0225950964,
-0.0209017098,
-0.0315038525,
-0.0279334541,
0.0177476797,
0.0562830307,
-0.0217679739,
0.0049762945,
-0.0611350499,
0.0424894653,
0.0069867168,
0.0257105231,
-0.0419592783,
0.0307631548,
0.0117305098,
-0.0208102837,
0.0241145976,
0.0652645752,
-0.0277668536,
0.0072024348,
0.0408793762,
0.0049800277,
-0.0630913377,
-0.0056813243,
-0.0079834154,
0.0018036623,
-0.0262216441,
0.0036904507,
0.015580629,
0.0283933412,
0.0070611448,
-0.0000866894,
-0.0331856683,
0.019774437,
-0.0213425048,
-0.0362075567,
-0.0725447908,
-0.0140872989,
-0.0359919854,
0.0569980666,
-0.0335052274,
-0.0898504257,
0.0686923042,
-0.0089109624,
-0.0152119044,
-0.0615225285,
-0.0151248015,
-0.0328872204,
0.0311348476,
-0.0114479484,
-0.01324235,
-0.0075834608,
-0.0130123207,
-0.0556154177,
0.0013550102,
0.0112245437,
-0.0313634649,
0.1035823524,
-0.050517533,
0.0346262529,
0.0088686561,
-0.0606530607,
-0.0677378103,
-0.0272909291,
-0.0084470091,
0.0108091263,
0.0274924878,
0.0232007354,
0.0066559878,
-0.0121570481,
0.0111201229,
0.0589590333,
-0.0048471466,
-0.009864293,
-0.0069286227,
-0.0051124189,
0.028082069,
0.0299861673,
0.0180860944,
-0.060623832,
0.0164456964,
0.0148558384,
0.0608229786,
-0.0282929707,
-0.0326212049,
0.0380851701,
0.0281573273,
0.0063846163,
-0.014172107,
0.0418559276,
0.055603046,
-0.0455442891,
-0.0504033305,
0.1029066518,
0.0034912264,
-0.0843336061,
-0.0100696906,
-0.0151948556,
0.0168945286,
0.0543037057,
0.020361105,
-0.070443213,
-0.0245411173,
0.0080718305,
0.0352392681,
0.0080556395,
-0.002741232,
-0.0030044359,
-0.1380541325,
0.0515577421,
0.0057638409,
-0.084933944,
-0.0218987688,
-0.0674472973,
0.0135757113,
-0.0225529578,
0.0390151292,
0.0283423122,
-0.0292551089,
-0.0124016088,
0.0373842455,
0.013826536,
-0.0964414999,
0.0085686063,
-0.0442564711,
0.0418806076,
0.0769805685,
-0.0229528472,
0.0206702165,
-0.0129659651,
0.0707648918,
-0.0142682679,
0.0016703086,
-0.0298356619,
0.0557309091,
0.0175449587,
-0.0112985689,
0.0083264941,
0.0647134408,
-0.0225811116,
-0.0171422735,
0.0063172779,
0.063214615,
-0.026034601,
0.0264450219,
0.004164536,
-0.0489197299,
0.0562040284,
0.0851225033,
0.0474581718,
-0.0548463166,
-0.0005593846,
0.0007755853,
-0.0101805683,
-0.021755103,
0.0542546324,
0.038181331,
-0.0145466123,
0.0087400721,
-0.061074134,
-0.0136290994,
0.0505267121,
0.0642728433,
0.0103223948,
0.0644511655,
0.002659502,
0.0234032944,
-0.0263508931,
0.0352001227,
-0.026274031,
0.012379799,
-0.0553969853,
-0.0254142806,
0.0000595704,
-0.046823658,
-0.0139522366,
0.0211923607,
-0.0865337029,
-0.0715708137,
0.0127665233,
0.0459557623,
0.0226366352,
0.0975137204,
0.0119171664,
-0.0523813292,
0.0679665431,
0.0238529462,
-0.0040862379,
0.0295631327,
0.0108237034,
-0.0011832822,
0.0057547553,
0.0342846252,
-0.0660594031,
0.0099751437,
0.0368710496,
-0.0006526437,
-0.0392360389,
0.0342489555,
0.0214935653,
-0.023355579,
0.0455025919,
-0.0122608747,
-0.0008197902,
-0.0453923754,
0.0338631645,
0.0182247441,
0.0007271103,
-0.0452666096,
0.0070207245,
0.0085734837,
-0.0008034289,
-0.0152417999,
0.0082691154,
0.0009191837,
0.0524612218,
-0.067751199,
-0.0075839711,
-0.0098856436,
-0.0005552982,
0.0486968756,
0.023374822,
-0.0090794619,
0.0279454589,
-0.0086115999,
0.0209307913,
-0.0157138668,
0.0279696994,
0.0297194608,
0.0172633231,
-0.0444880426,
0.00370176,
-0.0805591345,
-0.0103005031,
-0.0171010606,
0.0353741646,
0.0624848418,
-0.0450539328,
0.0438164435,
-0.0033482569,
0.0035559747,
-0.0402095318,
-0.0050216438,
0.0058831451,
-0.0210754257,
0.0169805214,
0.0274589621,
-0.0144835357,
0.006991413,
0.0981042013,
-0.006900074,
0.0271872804,
-0.0036773216,
0.0353623256,
-0.04950995,
0.0183546394,
0.0479886383,
0.0420341678,
-0.0284707658,
0.0017337408,
-0.020012062,
-0.0580119081,
0.0180846583,
-0.0087049808,
-0.0183570068,
-0.0288114734,
0.0449129567,
0.062955007,
-0.0136007937,
-0.0029181419,
-0.0089821704,
-0.0167715624,
0.0047946689,
-0.0375516675,
-0.0316703767,
-6.787147159e-33,
-0.0099479798,
-0.00139722,
0.0099269385,
0.0114252111,
0.0322596021,
0.0077371048,
-0.0385465175,
0.0137122199,
-0.0088198669,
-0.0164871905,
-0.0526012219,
0.021276217,
0.0228306521,
0.036230389,
0.0154340742,
-0.0276789162,
0.0355402417,
-0.0155940838,
-0.023602562,
0.0264343247,
0.0299132671,
0.0470973141,
0.0335151404,
-0.0648365393,
0.0062613883,
-0.0164101124,
0.0294723641,
0.0122056818,
-0.0008379834,
0.0424776077,
0.0012273213,
0.0362001359,
0.0385388806,
-0.0564477071,
-0.0590191521,
0.0240950305,
-0.0826836228,
-0.0199334789,
0.0187834911,
0.0019476911,
-0.0114968475,
-0.0021055515,
0.0551422872,
-0.0119848913,
-0.0275795124,
0.0156896561,
0.0236457977,
-0.0266693719,
-0.0805989429,
-0.0161016602,
-0.0277175568,
0.0133492136,
0.0137721878,
-0.0233561303,
-0.002468534,
0.0206124764,
-0.0063594766,
0.0420614481,
-0.0334488042,
0.0224159937,
-0.0012008576,
0.0426497273,
0.0487837456,
0.0535374098,
0.0330372937,
0.0741508231,
0.0134697659,
0.0087226247,
0.0316569768,
-0.0608286709,
0.0516851321,
0.0524076223,
0.0033397896,
0.0669257268,
0.0579606667,
-0.0053686663,
-0.0723247677,
0.0092274519,
0.0266254377,
-0.0053394088,
0.041616194,
0.0136595238,
-0.051327873,
-0.0404604971,
-0.0273251589,
-0.0023046436,
-0.0301572494,
0.0112635316,
0.0608155951,
0.0566771962,
-0.0356406868,
-0.0180992652,
0.0683499873,
-0.0389881618,
-0.0543891676,
0.0390934013,
-0.0041119778,
-0.0129488902,
0.0099412715,
-0.012794137,
-0.0693899021,
-0.0450358577,
0.0003417783,
0.0165660307,
0.0139834126,
-0.015821686,
0.058655329,
0.0069507975,
-0.066310443,
-0.0001147405,
-0.0440916941,
0.0563285314,
0.0133798821,
0.0497707315,
0.058454711,
0.0141339339,
-0.0048200884,
0.0165310074,
0.0092792036,
-0.0451884903,
-0.0447263196,
-0.0492202118,
-0.0281636994,
-0.0042015929,
-0.0254953913,
-0.0235044844,
-0.0333973989,
0.0014263174,
0.048208911,
-0.0342284366,
-0.0119364625,
0.0388164409,
2.773e-7,
0.0193814673,
0.0410563387,
-0.0075252415,
0.0011330704,
0.0330671333,
0.0066398531,
-0.0518751405,
0.0073463656,
0.0209280942,
-0.0215778723,
0.004853108,
0.0333619528,
0.0644830093,
0.0253760591,
-0.0970690548,
-0.0131236752,
-0.0534874387,
0.0410296097,
-0.0370274708,
-0.01890992,
-0.0034280228,
0.1194223613,
-0.0024235088,
-0.0304034501,
0.0145281432,
-0.0544265322,
0.0562796704,
-0.0585723184,
0.0138412919,
0.0033890102,
-0.0078243501,
0.0516889133,
0.0051979916,
0.0231976826,
-0.0227677226,
0.0308453143,
-0.0142378025,
0.0466217138,
0.0098704994,
-0.0329840071,
0.0162762031,
0.0274788588,
-0.0119932191,
-0.0535582304,
0.0713447854,
-0.0671730191,
0.0143470736,
-0.0465586334,
0.0122424196,
-0.041318424,
0.0300920885,
0.0090262722,
-0.0028242439,
0.0183992945,
0.0271138381,
-0.0156046581,
-0.0204491578,
-0.0576805845,
-0.0325249322,
0.0003094101,
-0.0498380959,
-0.0500345938,
-0.0462154076,
0.0146302404,
0.0220361464,
-0.0106605841,
-0.0013891694,
2.816405945e-34,
0.0483233854,
-0.0216221716,
0.027766455,
0.0460365713,
-0.031854149,
-0.0292555653,
0.003711967,
0.0214247629,
0.0095208269,
-0.062720865,
0.0082727317
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10375v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10375v2 | Self-Adaptive In-Context Learning: An Information Compression Perspective for In-Context Example Selection and Ordering | 2022-12-20T15:55:21 | 2023-05-03T14:43:50 | Zhiyong Wu, Yaoxiang Wang, Jiacheng Ye, Lingpeng Kong | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Despite the surprising few-shot performance of in-context learning (ICL), it
is still a common practice to randomly sample examples to serve as context.
This paper advocates a new principle for ICL: self-adaptive in-context
learning. The self-adaption mechanism is introduced to help each sample find an
in-context example permutation (i.e., selection and ordering) that can derive
the correct prediction, thus maximizing performance. To validate the
effectiveness of self-adaptive ICL, we propose a general select-then-rank
framework and instantiate it with new selection and ranking algorithms. Upon
extensive evaluation on eight different NLP datasets, our self-adaptive ICL
method achieves a 40% relative improvement over the common practice setting.
Further analysis reveals the enormous potential of self-adaptive ICL that it
might be able to close the gap between ICL and finetuning given more advanced
algorithms. Our code is released to facilitate future research in this area:
https://github.com/Shark-NLP/self-adaptive-ICL | [
0.0091302413,
0.0254322756,
-0.0052854144,
0.036767941,
-0.0314478651,
0.0351440795,
0.0125020752,
0.0406109467,
-0.0128284469,
-0.0848230571,
-0.007474652,
0.0332319774,
-0.0075762859,
-0.0413320996,
0.0201313142,
-0.0273598824,
0.0132525023,
0.0181016568,
-0.0078025772,
0.018547358,
-0.0159404948,
-0.0072508622,
0.000945141,
0.0176600087,
0.0348211229,
-0.0193496607,
0.001090099,
0.0141526917,
0.0137267951,
-0.0499427058,
-0.0019850477,
0.0677193925,
0.0148772774,
-0.0374698862,
0.0000021283,
-0.058402054,
-0.0425989293,
0.0033272966,
-0.05125691,
-0.0473919436,
0.0015312129,
-0.0047561736,
-0.0080025718,
-0.0080460384,
-0.0545527712,
0.0092779761,
0.0432368368,
0.0331239738,
0.0483499616,
0.0608005039,
-0.0163512193,
0.0077455672,
-0.0621213801,
-0.0387323722,
0.0066540502,
-0.0167219732,
0.0316637307,
-0.0447681956,
-0.007866187,
0.0420431308,
-0.0359259807,
0.0035803039,
-0.0101025961,
0.0319513045,
0.0108676311,
0.0170393139,
-0.0751157925,
0.0012205989,
-0.0119611099,
0.0979419574,
-0.0356161185,
-0.0336581245,
0.0091613969,
-0.023520913,
0.0371949226,
-0.0201636385,
-0.0649632663,
-0.0050979005,
0.0006038368,
0.0308360569,
0.0348896645,
0.0910827816,
0.0093019102,
0.0047915424,
-0.0082300827,
0.0198721699,
-0.0198083408,
-0.0362886675,
-0.0042775306,
-0.0042659133,
-0.0189672187,
-0.0120614683,
-0.0339763612,
0.0034803173,
-0.023271922,
0.0254697651,
-0.0428459495,
-0.0152136059,
0.0009194658,
-0.0296137854,
0.0439345054,
0.0065815537,
0.0473297201,
0.0482062623,
-0.0047976524,
0.0171656925,
0.0388091169,
0.0025058778,
-0.0260983575,
0.019037297,
-0.0502066053,
0.0327628553,
-0.0392327607,
0.0704912916,
-0.0347470976,
-0.0135021294,
-0.0491640978,
0.0243604276,
-0.0250028688,
0.0099721532,
0.0092283869,
0.0161305834,
-0.0311629698,
0.0507983752,
0.0043728412,
-0.0168633331,
-0.0134847984,
-0.028879907,
-0.0158473253,
-0.0228713956,
-0.0162124969,
-0.0076330374,
0.0089010773,
-0.0258548968,
-0.0160950571,
0.064752385,
0.0113764759,
-0.0455832295,
-0.0002236061,
0.0025947518,
-0.0012062009,
-0.0257053748,
-0.0254675876,
-0.0658418611,
0.0145128174,
0.0132278744,
0.0106603475,
-0.0251057073,
0.0011553044,
0.0478832386,
-0.0483368859,
0.0480022691,
-0.0144378757,
-0.0111438967,
-0.0133950114,
0.0039430922,
0.0291918274,
0.0830223113,
0.0068895067,
-0.0329301283,
0.0715202689,
-0.026051458,
0.0223836415,
0.0150596043,
0.0520276166,
0.0042547504,
-0.0398017056,
0.0030723936,
-0.028954912,
0.0162025448,
0.0076074246,
-0.0057942197,
-0.0400451086,
-0.0432733148,
0.0093219755,
0.0351203158,
0.0621071532,
0.0351063125,
-0.0080783414,
0.0227936637,
-0.0121952761,
0.0259527434,
-0.0384948924,
0.0504242629,
-0.0266728438,
-0.0024474107,
0.0367017686,
0.0049179252,
-0.0209600814,
-0.0293542277,
-0.000984929,
-0.0073806494,
0.0017201303,
0.0160298664,
0.0158963669,
0.0498962812,
-0.0294500273,
0.0128175579,
0.0348793156,
-0.0075994818,
-0.0616046079,
-0.0083320821,
-0.0152882067,
0.0326414593,
0.0577412136,
-0.0523816794,
0.0057412069,
-0.0259535294,
0.0041289739,
-0.0191981401,
0.030756427,
-0.0403264761,
0.0431243181,
-0.0271259528,
-0.0412160121,
0.0031691948,
-0.0147634428,
-0.0249889586,
0.028048126,
0.0064207981,
-0.0000273192,
0.0024134798,
-0.0124326479,
0.0252864491,
-0.013434751,
-0.0676912963,
0.0667796731,
0.0086178025,
0.0537784956,
0.0034968073,
-0.0065673064,
-0.015094216,
0.0369419865,
-0.0395478643,
0.0037483589,
0.0089452751,
-0.1044369787,
-0.1560415477,
-0.008867817,
-0.0170328021,
-0.0127264019,
0.0026341481,
-0.078571409,
-0.0221253857,
0.0173247792,
0.0046275184,
0.0423176922,
-0.0139416754,
-0.0022849154,
0.0350030214,
0.0298528969,
-0.0705800354,
0.1023594216,
0.01144809,
0.0283796974,
0.0320902541,
0.0275672898,
-0.0122312708,
-0.010271688,
-0.0178131126,
0.0095439926,
-0.0375061519,
-0.0082762362,
0.0254613999,
0.0219807494,
-0.0521238148,
0.0211533252,
-0.0610427223,
-0.0111490274,
-0.0228484832,
-0.0049090381,
0.0295914952,
0.0148254605,
0.0061092484,
-0.0438225046,
-0.0143679334,
0.0075427885,
-0.0204275884,
0.0117902867,
0.0329305492,
0.0064276191,
0.0450091287,
-0.0126746288,
-0.0465267934,
0.0026067458,
0.0778307244,
-0.0268671159,
-0.0093343174,
-0.0194009524,
0.0454436652,
-0.0057696537,
0.0015629631,
0.0009740823,
0.0277087204,
-0.0405253321,
-0.0185758248,
-0.0130594121,
0.0477413572,
0.0153501555,
0.0722381771,
0.0185620096,
0.028292872,
-0.0636295602,
-0.0004482277,
-0.0210369322,
0.0604410022,
0.0204432048,
0.0403123982,
0.0098501816,
0.0244257543,
0.0134408064,
-0.002746017,
-0.0197075587,
0.0412595384,
-0.0072282283,
-0.0319224298,
-0.0586498417,
0.0217454731,
0.0041412823,
0.0171778798,
0.0098331263,
-0.0042810123,
0.0598396286,
0.0483708382,
0.0131038437,
-0.0665491372,
-0.0023112444,
-0.0362260453,
0.0441963114,
0.0015850972,
0.0168260671,
0.0153040234,
-0.0008553535,
-0.0349878557,
-0.0253299884,
0.0271834303,
-0.0209975056,
0.0238801762,
-0.0197231118,
0.0094028916,
-0.009208749,
-0.08170221,
-0.0363388993,
-0.050242912,
0.0324782133,
0.0100770406,
-0.016207926,
0.0373844095,
-0.0066170683,
-0.0160472021,
0.011412085,
0.0514274985,
-0.0060712649,
-0.0300822221,
0.0046392707,
0.0502358079,
0.017496774,
-0.0015592148,
0.0361811705,
0.0456660688,
0.0605032071,
0.0642276257,
0.0830573887,
0.011200686,
-0.0088560469,
0.0230040941,
0.0276904069,
-0.0629844368,
-0.0413168594,
0.0529851355,
-0.0022102071,
-0.029673079,
-0.0140660219,
0.1005134135,
0.0317184068,
-0.07867641,
0.0269489493,
0.0141628496,
-0.0115434304,
0.0393933617,
0.0443385951,
-0.0496236198,
-0.0353524685,
0.0011415668,
0.0139795821,
-0.0234799869,
-0.0421120264,
-0.0117481714,
-0.1178881451,
0.0457019135,
0.0087330732,
-0.0321094841,
-0.0029985467,
-0.0469779633,
0.0466104373,
-0.0258666873,
-0.0146574806,
0.0086035039,
-0.0449690185,
0.0160108805,
0.0007903334,
-0.0316258296,
-0.0820208266,
0.024976844,
0.013823634,
0.0117543209,
0.0408393629,
0.0325325876,
0.0021789742,
0.0327237584,
0.0102817016,
-0.0836618841,
0.008583446,
-0.0607090555,
0.073458083,
-0.0112684332,
0.0027336748,
0.0215460733,
0.0297304559,
-0.0341716893,
-0.0188302752,
-0.0082098441,
0.0421857685,
-0.0148876375,
0.0024668803,
-0.0272198282,
-0.0484888293,
0.0341735929,
0.0824016854,
0.0068770675,
-0.0394840203,
-0.0174005553,
-0.0221577156,
0.0192998275,
-0.032123927,
0.0123863444,
0.0050350064,
0.0275011193,
0.0039289184,
-0.1028887928,
-0.0100518046,
0.0100283735,
0.074326165,
-0.0155991791,
0.0484387949,
-0.0124739753,
0.0005291854,
-0.0312326364,
-0.0547677875,
0.0216377787,
-0.0265639089,
0.0168950874,
0.0111094406,
0.0725278556,
-0.0006137741,
-0.0069622742,
0.0069750967,
-0.0028787646,
-0.0225873087,
0.0203818325,
0.0535202213,
0.0079932166,
0.0784487203,
0.0010110793,
-0.024038313,
0.1011831835,
0.0727834925,
0.0017255157,
0.0172355212,
0.0230508596,
-0.0060599814,
-0.0048759435,
0.0449686572,
-0.0520324744,
0.0460890606,
0.0024811565,
0.0244967323,
-0.0767455474,
0.007803828,
0.042647738,
-0.0275078546,
0.0117476983,
-0.0273043755,
-0.0218983274,
0.0142702851,
0.0429563969,
-0.0006204222,
-0.0473092794,
-0.0393996425,
0.0295408759,
-0.0245437138,
-0.0121817496,
-0.0114086075,
-0.0061442661,
0.0153076854,
0.0057180864,
-0.058912918,
-0.0235109292,
-0.0195164718,
-0.0076029208,
-0.0177404452,
0.0486686341,
-0.0229976829,
0.0065832678,
0.0361661874,
0.0441135839,
-0.0524122193,
0.0297184158,
0.0289150029,
0.0290787183,
-0.0280222278,
0.0507584326,
-0.057811033,
0.0613108762,
-0.0424825177,
0.0110498145,
0.0463210456,
-0.0671342388,
0.0451042056,
0.0077274325,
-0.0047401907,
-0.0158720873,
-0.0006121758,
-0.0097893784,
-0.0225533731,
-0.0127154645,
0.0370097123,
-0.0036205223,
0.0399085358,
0.0713720322,
-0.0142673133,
0.0023723743,
0.0395780653,
0.0213793628,
-0.0596031658,
0.0310205854,
0.001243823,
0.0500569642,
0.0405667573,
0.0161175858,
-0.0255865548,
-0.0394684859,
0.0039601163,
-0.0284460075,
0.0023604019,
-0.0265987646,
0.0727063268,
0.0662798584,
0.0236386061,
0.0162519999,
-0.0517100058,
-0.0286763832,
-0.0170102064,
-0.0332123637,
-0.0245400891,
-6.171877988e-33,
-0.0360953733,
-0.0212327577,
-0.0213110894,
0.0113910884,
0.0608802401,
-0.0132404165,
-0.0212860145,
-0.0213614237,
-0.0022236011,
-0.0094465939,
-0.0478567928,
-0.0321121924,
-0.0021042582,
0.0374247469,
0.003287757,
-0.0077948575,
0.0009525515,
-0.0157102868,
-0.0200231317,
0.0195859335,
0.030708177,
0.0433470048,
0.0540753156,
-0.1019447297,
-0.0534496233,
0.0214474518,
0.0200793482,
-0.0272858217,
-0.0031573197,
0.0662366673,
0.0170044936,
0.0194922034,
0.0393502004,
-0.062364053,
-0.0096293986,
-0.0019207469,
-0.0817210972,
-0.084196426,
-0.0573414192,
-0.0259649307,
-0.0215109903,
-0.0026189145,
0.0587997101,
-0.0111834379,
-0.0125284046,
-0.0335168242,
0.0323318914,
-0.0319163315,
-0.0487363711,
-0.0739855319,
-0.031651441,
0.0169430263,
-0.0321139283,
-0.0162279997,
0.0366416946,
0.0243257228,
-0.0198865831,
0.036147397,
-0.0629322901,
0.0109811621,
-0.0378863066,
0.0464550257,
0.0300245844,
-0.0406083278,
0.0142050916,
0.0631322935,
-0.0255788788,
-0.0010779485,
0.0745558366,
-0.0589007065,
-0.0000703137,
0.0549380742,
-0.0118404292,
0.078782253,
0.0693256333,
0.0181263518,
-0.0893442705,
0.0329473726,
0.0402948074,
-0.0138499886,
0.0072528515,
0.0005839843,
-0.0717711747,
-0.0425286777,
-0.0145335272,
-0.0252939481,
-0.0176027007,
-0.0421104059,
0.0346789397,
0.0217842888,
-0.0416913629,
0.0528391376,
0.0289463792,
-0.0544121377,
-0.0816903561,
0.0124162324,
-0.045428969,
-0.0052463776,
0.0387039892,
-0.0088446531,
-0.0738515183,
-0.0211611409,
-0.013047751,
0.0088820346,
0.0240722075,
-0.0127397981,
0.070280537,
0.0324571393,
-0.0471104644,
-0.007899031,
0.0165792853,
-0.0026427032,
-0.0201979447,
-0.0269787926,
0.0071337461,
0.0185534712,
-0.0068350849,
0.0418563001,
0.0671067908,
-0.0497249886,
-0.0356494449,
-0.0331025533,
-0.0250830874,
-0.0067653293,
-0.0016940106,
-0.0304003377,
0.0105413739,
0.0033151603,
0.0523153208,
-0.0281504896,
-0.0165657904,
0.015698541,
2.841e-7,
0.0258053411,
0.0716826543,
-0.0221308637,
-0.0358473919,
0.0641849861,
0.0418444946,
-0.0111376671,
0.0540779456,
0.0096981907,
0.0163351092,
0.0402253754,
-0.0002205216,
0.0055469563,
0.0056943847,
-0.068283461,
0.0436700955,
-0.0467332117,
0.0079074753,
-0.0090210531,
-0.0231569037,
0.0224705637,
0.1065386906,
0.0112780044,
-0.0012161533,
-0.0317677371,
-0.0115254652,
0.0379543342,
-0.028524382,
0.0258334018,
-0.0122080697,
-0.0539348982,
0.0187058803,
-0.0140765635,
0.0121367313,
-0.041548878,
0.0239985846,
0.0007575322,
0.0387595072,
-0.0154815745,
-0.0478727706,
0.019252466,
0.0150146708,
0.0422541872,
-0.0506590791,
0.0790676698,
-0.1167126596,
-0.0282282699,
-0.0035853859,
-0.0235868897,
0.0092292223,
-0.0015313394,
0.0366693623,
-0.0198441464,
0.0228059422,
0.0119707938,
0.0151439346,
-0.048626516,
-0.084922418,
-0.0069172201,
0.014788528,
0.0069442312,
0.0052590636,
-0.0183051508,
-0.0147741688,
0.0256697461,
-0.0374214649,
-0.0056536975,
2.69018104e-34,
-0.0211930145,
0.0165469516,
-0.0052584587,
0.055547636,
-0.0425359719,
-0.025405746,
-0.0026057637,
0.0272531044,
0.0305594858,
-0.0197576974,
-0.009172108
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10356v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10356v2 | Dissecting Transformer Length Extrapolation via the Lens of Receptive Field Analysis | 2022-12-20T15:40:17 | 2023-05-23T21:18:09 | Ta-Chung Chi, Ting-Han Fan, Alexander I. Rudnicky, Peter J. Ramadge | cs.CL | cs.CL | Length extrapolation permits training a transformer language model on short
sequences that preserves perplexities when tested on substantially longer
sequences. A relative positional embedding design, ALiBi, has had the widest
usage to date. We dissect ALiBi via the lens of receptive field analysis
empowered by a novel cumulative normalized gradient tool. The concept of
receptive field further allows us to modify the vanilla Sinusoidal positional
embedding to create ~\textbf{Sandwich}, the first parameter-free relative
positional embedding design that truly length information uses longer than the
training sequence. Sandwich shares with KERPLE and T5 the same logarithmic
decaying temporal bias pattern with learnable relative positional embeddings;
these elucidate future extrapolatable positional embedding design. | [
0.0078372704,
0.0735619739,
-0.000547516,
-0.0001265019,
-0.0141078737,
-0.0196669176,
0.0163631048,
-0.0049459836,
-0.0519957058,
0.0285569243,
0.0049036425,
-0.0411200859,
0.0411025248,
0.0132061969,
0.0449987501,
-0.0375216007,
0.0040211985,
0.0048805731,
-0.0350486971,
-0.0003241009,
-0.027443694,
-0.0220529996,
-0.0064338301,
0.064243339,
-0.0020237914,
0.0153008001,
-0.0679327548,
-0.0360921808,
0.012903004,
-0.0312946253,
-0.0100971162,
0.0517271943,
0.0338685326,
0.0249310881,
0.0000018594,
0.0361790843,
0.0024872494,
-0.004471242,
-0.0124460608,
-0.0299566519,
0.0024425013,
-0.0626332611,
0.0062052691,
0.009919215,
-0.0348550305,
-0.0603262633,
0.0791145265,
0.061415419,
0.007125956,
0.0708062947,
-0.0221419372,
-0.0971739218,
-0.0129121989,
-0.0608451329,
0.0384972245,
0.0187400077,
-0.0099492054,
-0.0556954183,
0.0402745567,
-0.0012905905,
-0.0693442449,
0.0442094095,
0.0528829023,
0.008657421,
-0.0029984571,
0.033888761,
0.0395394154,
-0.0167925581,
-0.0025659443,
0.0551990308,
-0.0866908729,
-0.0331264623,
-0.0241624396,
0.0204775594,
0.0105685312,
-0.0281397272,
-0.0384871103,
-0.0013964231,
0.0489156619,
-0.0010490549,
-0.0091683138,
0.0222757924,
0.0315777399,
-0.0516013987,
-0.0445863642,
0.0321484357,
0.0209554452,
-0.0386876315,
-0.0456543304,
-0.0159342792,
-0.036110729,
0.0144427214,
-0.0151334843,
0.0305954944,
0.0331445895,
0.0051786797,
-0.0291291866,
-0.0240193885,
0.0023812253,
0.002198047,
0.0487468839,
0.0569052771,
-0.0269391816,
-0.0054866085,
-0.0427390896,
0.0854314789,
-0.0522879437,
0.0220742915,
-0.0561213046,
0.0356039889,
-0.0010917886,
-0.0144525962,
-0.0155268935,
0.0186140034,
-0.0208583176,
-0.028471265,
-0.0300722253,
0.0499594361,
0.025839543,
-0.0022593718,
0.0125029422,
0.0419610515,
-0.038510628,
-0.0083705932,
0.0293920562,
0.057609655,
0.0125937117,
0.0072261374,
-0.0098774554,
-0.0295086522,
-0.0521953627,
0.0233061966,
0.0193504822,
-0.0256805755,
-0.0083922297,
0.0463573523,
0.0083430819,
-0.0649859905,
0.0037268163,
0.0315095559,
-0.0607014671,
-0.0272726454,
0.0497107618,
-0.0446067974,
0.0149516417,
0.0015558468,
-0.0071312296,
-0.0376619734,
-0.0013792738,
0.0215508137,
-0.0034910035,
0.0754061863,
0.0382305421,
-0.0228866339,
-0.0165517852,
0.009087408,
0.0240085237,
0.071457319,
0.0249040164,
-0.0019457868,
-0.0170591697,
-0.0213034041,
-0.0255045127,
0.0275894068,
0.0367903337,
-0.0351621658,
-0.0430683009,
-0.0502986796,
0.0070321718,
0.0081037544,
0.0259887911,
0.0334339254,
-0.0086784782,
-0.0679657161,
0.0573740937,
0.0494187996,
0.0602802485,
0.0413101576,
0.0447786488,
0.0194177404,
-0.0427778289,
0.0199153963,
-0.0250233766,
0.0605214313,
0.0195592009,
0.0286463518,
-0.0103083421,
0.069370158,
-0.0429041125,
-0.0221948028,
0.0058498182,
-0.0565950945,
0.0297744516,
-0.0340427533,
0.0232856777,
0.0133894011,
-0.0645756647,
0.0840131044,
-0.0191639345,
-0.044861719,
-0.0129256686,
0.0100504328,
0.0045818761,
-0.0126481699,
-0.0019750022,
-0.0237623993,
-0.0105000483,
-0.0136910072,
-0.0198784824,
0.0755314827,
0.0313206539,
0.0161779001,
0.0431440584,
-0.0220078081,
-0.038915392,
0.0265595708,
0.0103728725,
0.0163689964,
0.0123075377,
0.0197666287,
0.038329266,
-0.0405045487,
0.0558188669,
0.0213841889,
-0.0097134942,
-0.0068458701,
-0.0340410434,
0.0371159166,
0.0157328788,
0.0082759839,
-0.000555011,
0.0286390502,
0.0696440712,
-0.0678103864,
0.0108486786,
0.0408447087,
-0.0851817653,
-0.0471446216,
0.067346625,
-0.0441650525,
0.0496850275,
0.0472962223,
-0.0229320899,
-0.0457151607,
0.0537711978,
-0.0630239323,
0.0570604764,
-0.0161878075,
0.0300624147,
-0.0032976314,
0.038029965,
-0.0243342984,
0.0172643177,
-0.0198791046,
0.0384913534,
-0.0085189128,
-0.04121878,
0.014789464,
-0.0203341432,
-0.0574239902,
0.0533214733,
-0.0058808806,
-0.0001359385,
0.0204015467,
-0.0315017402,
0.0035695378,
-0.0853415728,
-0.064176172,
-0.058057677,
0.0009793469,
0.0079753278,
-0.0325160772,
0.0271996036,
0.0320604071,
-0.0084349671,
-0.0594799444,
-0.0692094415,
-0.006152872,
0.0147883249,
0.0227362383,
0.0286659691,
-0.0937798172,
0.0016061065,
-0.0244653113,
0.0151603902,
0.0717996731,
-0.027589269,
-0.0147797707,
-0.0668517351,
-0.0440697633,
0.0084702121,
0.0315736793,
-0.0284085684,
-0.0444419347,
0.0016679948,
-0.0093269181,
0.0379057564,
0.0304887146,
0.0181199741,
0.007338827,
0.0111675123,
0.0031792107,
-0.0107997321,
0.0208970644,
-0.0659827963,
0.0193494428,
-0.0366777778,
0.0250148941,
-0.0512027293,
0.0800795704,
-0.0445765853,
0.0068300189,
-0.0850184113,
0.0176187493,
0.0091955541,
-0.0115423985,
0.0401178673,
-0.0013999698,
-0.0303551909,
0.0048276191,
-0.0374675244,
-0.045739945,
0.0529090054,
-0.0292360727,
-0.0267157294,
-0.0304450504,
0.0116741117,
-0.0108035458,
0.0463372059,
0.0159298517,
0.0006663927,
-0.0051792189,
-0.0069413446,
-0.0644162446,
0.0335814878,
-0.0357084535,
-0.0433731079,
0.0624730699,
-0.010188085,
-0.0045783278,
-0.0108246412,
-0.0394132771,
-0.0489199273,
-0.0383487716,
-0.0052904878,
-0.0026561467,
-0.0050413073,
-0.0415496267,
-0.0363739654,
0.0414673127,
0.0088771936,
0.0463965721,
-0.0034379989,
0.0290142577,
-0.0056599323,
0.0219863206,
0.0359918885,
0.0333965756,
-0.0038237143,
-0.0108199362,
0.013934345,
0.0230725687,
0.0449633598,
0.0165851656,
-0.0655811876,
0.0154983001,
0.0314401798,
-0.010917183,
-0.0261273235,
0.0154436463,
0.0091807805,
-0.0174798537,
-0.0169975664,
0.093907617,
-0.0104127787,
-0.0589828156,
0.0338788442,
0.0275643244,
0.0760994926,
0.0083306907,
0.0200616252,
-0.0646216273,
-0.0013668347,
0.0018770812,
-0.0172359645,
0.0146608707,
-0.0026319071,
-0.026684111,
-0.1123077869,
-0.0014436961,
0.0307491943,
-0.0052055516,
-0.0648759753,
-0.018532088,
-0.0237868372,
0.0321340747,
0.0155085837,
0.029573705,
-0.0334579498,
-0.0372513682,
0.0363873094,
-0.0392658338,
-0.0434141047,
-0.0144664412,
0.010049141,
0.0036161607,
0.0033736273,
0.0038059186,
-0.0011064293,
-0.0864162967,
-0.0194065869,
-0.0034862007,
0.0262752455,
0.015444628,
0.0500141419,
0.0030636596,
-0.0431297719,
0.0399094969,
-0.0023355063,
-0.0541088507,
0.0166534074,
-0.0767197683,
0.0897016078,
-0.0101566436,
0.014004169,
-0.0008826129,
0.0242400356,
-0.024967866,
0.0293506905,
0.0352351107,
-0.0538737103,
-0.0271548908,
0.0042122649,
0.0326474905,
-0.016874034,
-0.0222958084,
0.0010515347,
0.057598345,
-0.0485942289,
-0.0397336967,
-0.0105417008,
-0.0094454791,
0.0782029927,
0.0168529395,
-0.0237089824,
-0.0182494428,
-0.0015190602,
-0.0742185265,
-0.0193891954,
0.0247056596,
0.0250795688,
-0.0489672944,
0.0331050977,
0.0367726684,
-0.0277622435,
-0.0116076246,
-0.0141561823,
-0.0992321894,
-0.0754224733,
0.028569283,
0.0247358065,
0.0253417753,
0.0618915409,
0.0035795618,
-0.0026349749,
0.0725894347,
0.0401966497,
-0.0237868782,
0.0254434254,
0.0739201233,
-0.0347317569,
0.0178286303,
0.0214099959,
-0.0287103951,
0.007637193,
0.0020951331,
0.0218230356,
-0.0062458655,
-0.0110191973,
0.0441727042,
-0.0494335741,
0.0443166755,
-0.0081955018,
0.0855995342,
0.0037572207,
0.039311178,
-0.0417705625,
0.0473401062,
-0.0470920093,
-0.0142044704,
0.0526459999,
0.0326644816,
0.0289758034,
-0.0058724741,
-0.0025052999,
0.0161507279,
0.0326219648,
0.0822981,
-0.0137057891,
-0.0202158876,
-0.0106910625,
0.0435008258,
-0.0154291932,
-0.0201046243,
-0.025651658,
0.0359751023,
-0.0116740596,
0.0241872948,
0.0289330762,
0.0154507989,
-0.0595230013,
0.0461965501,
-0.0490494035,
-0.005224613,
-0.0141158486,
-0.0269679409,
0.0360909551,
-0.0535379983,
0.0416010059,
0.0146861169,
0.0103092538,
0.0042887614,
0.011895733,
-0.0268410575,
-0.0400370508,
0.0438147038,
0.0333700627,
-0.0184946954,
0.0175683461,
0.0405763946,
0.0019894452,
0.0062035993,
-0.0237428937,
0.039967373,
-0.0241949018,
-0.0254755542,
0.0310834777,
-0.016565606,
-0.0166717358,
-0.0229674242,
-0.0321780369,
-0.0741740689,
0.0662561432,
-0.0349819921,
0.0021630295,
-0.0307950769,
0.0223274175,
0.0353791863,
-0.0091042714,
-0.0175692514,
0.0202511791,
-0.0324545577,
0.0347359739,
-0.032082472,
-0.0209198333,
-5.945741527e-33,
-0.0052152644,
0.0069629415,
-0.0113122314,
0.0081749111,
-0.0433649048,
0.0321077779,
-0.0168102775,
0.0135644218,
-0.0336295143,
-0.0103456164,
-0.0182201136,
-0.0205226559,
0.0187688265,
0.0370059349,
-0.0122434208,
-0.0089250952,
0.04699542,
0.0178022236,
0.0149515709,
-0.0144762872,
0.00440457,
0.0394524112,
0.0564973205,
-0.0340398662,
-0.0219185539,
0.0204977561,
-0.0032733858,
0.0081063705,
0.0235102549,
0.0612468533,
-0.0250861235,
0.0234223101,
0.0073814848,
-0.0475001149,
-0.018371759,
0.000024638,
-0.0616485924,
-0.0024266036,
-0.0271429624,
0.0476878434,
-0.0136537189,
-0.0205698162,
0.0309587512,
-0.0362800397,
-0.0309791137,
-0.0447402708,
0.015327245,
-0.0288780574,
-0.0534137711,
0.0264329948,
-0.0081913816,
0.0056853653,
0.0114286728,
-0.0033191459,
0.051817514,
0.0344170369,
0.0109705776,
0.029599065,
-0.068164371,
0.017640233,
-0.0088740848,
0.0431025103,
0.0324961767,
0.0076534823,
0.0248763729,
0.0236633122,
0.0731979832,
-0.0238471664,
-0.0166968387,
-0.0049917446,
0.0439540334,
-0.02755058,
0.0641059652,
-0.0172243677,
0.0765137523,
-0.0319983922,
-0.0186512992,
-0.0393183716,
0.0282047298,
0.0535991974,
0.0310575999,
0.0177442506,
-0.0473973565,
-0.0204975009,
-0.0277382266,
-0.0273783617,
-0.0078335283,
-0.0537725799,
0.0167341195,
0.0306391492,
0.0258556362,
0.0167816356,
0.0502911694,
-0.0287868418,
0.0432908759,
0.0083979769,
0.0134345088,
0.0460626632,
-0.0106744906,
-0.0039805854,
-0.0275812354,
-0.023864707,
0.0327590443,
0.0179081019,
-0.0059605176,
-0.0543735884,
0.0229500048,
0.0874890015,
-0.0681009591,
-0.0466064699,
-0.0364526697,
-0.0319896564,
0.0213156007,
0.0275533088,
0.0731585175,
0.0069567105,
-0.0043223412,
0.0456603728,
-0.014294615,
0.0176648516,
-0.00593341,
0.0132606663,
0.0266269092,
0.0509150252,
-0.0111750308,
-0.0403562412,
-0.0098503772,
0.0361952484,
0.0105511993,
-0.0621491335,
-0.0114533613,
0.0023249472,
2.783e-7,
0.0231837928,
0.002763449,
0.0870568454,
-0.0294713527,
0.0151151223,
-0.0138207339,
0.0271402337,
0.0206924044,
-0.0355014391,
0.0135309966,
0.0074319649,
-0.0128095178,
0.0293041337,
-0.0087806825,
-0.0909525752,
-0.0022013101,
-0.0765157342,
0.0297309812,
-0.0048736013,
-0.0176860932,
0.0337960273,
0.1266857833,
-0.0014889807,
-0.0002436498,
-0.0321660452,
-0.0343571492,
0.0437221862,
-0.0102964835,
0.0190704744,
-0.0265682172,
0.0236740224,
-0.0143659376,
0.000882079,
-0.0237769224,
-0.0131379412,
0.0561587885,
0.0092709167,
0.0122331511,
0.0044598291,
-0.058287669,
0.0053344616,
0.0116854496,
-0.0579949357,
-0.0397914425,
0.0168376714,
-0.0781444758,
-0.0261967871,
0.0119385906,
-0.0675450265,
0.0005675998,
-0.0004434897,
0.0049315174,
0.0003357102,
0.0101112649,
0.0406746715,
-0.0129493522,
0.021314729,
-0.0683984831,
-0.024221506,
0.0045376155,
-0.0492868572,
0.0358457789,
-0.0580513887,
-0.0266532395,
0.0692976937,
0.0190766454,
-0.0234398786,
2.498828238e-34,
0.019268129,
-0.0349549279,
0.0197103564,
0.0183396135,
-0.003667986,
-0.0441894457,
0.0427214354,
0.0203131884,
0.0575341694,
-0.0808794498,
-0.0408129804
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10346v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10346v1 | Does It Affect You? Social and Learning Implications of Using Cognitive-Affective State Recognition for Proactive Human-Robot Tutoring | 2022-12-20T15:31:58 | 2022-12-20T15:31:58 | Matthias Kraus, Diana Betancourt, Wolfgang Minker | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.CL | Using robots in educational contexts has already shown to be beneficial for a
student's learning and social behaviour. For levitating them to the next level
of providing more effective and human-like tutoring, the ability to adapt to
the user and to express proactivity is fundamental. By acting proactively,
intelligent robotic tutors anticipate possible situations where problems for
the student may arise and act in advance for preventing negative outcomes.
Still, the decisions of when and how to behave proactively are open questions.
Therefore, this paper deals with the investigation of how the student's
cognitive-affective states can be used by a robotic tutor for triggering
proactive tutoring dialogue. In doing so, it is aimed to improve the learning
experience. For this reason, a concept learning task scenario was observed
where a robotic assistant proactively helped when negative user states were
detected. In a learning task, the user's states of frustration and confusion
were deemed to have negative effects on the outcome of the task and were used
to trigger proactive behaviour. In an empirical user study with 40
undergraduate and doctoral students, we studied whether the initiation of
proactive behaviour after the detection of signs of confusion and frustration
improves the student's concentration and trust in the agent. Additionally, we
investigated which level of proactive dialogue is useful for promoting the
student's concentration and trust. The results show that high proactive
behaviour harms trust, especially when triggered during negative
cognitive-affective states but contributes to keeping the student focused on
the task when triggered in these states. Based on our study results, we further
discuss future steps for improving the proactive assistance of robotic tutoring
systems. | [
0.061772678,
-0.0618161745,
-0.0692291856,
-0.0249705054,
0.0018933287,
-0.0013713427,
0.0457117707,
-0.0463586412,
0.0398540162,
-0.0148258405,
0.0134305796,
0.0311505869,
-0.0199326389,
0.0184695348,
0.0256035365,
-0.0894516483,
-0.0125403712,
0.0158571173,
0.0658670515,
0.0393801518,
0.0455324538,
-0.0028348498,
-0.0604834631,
0.0698330179,
-0.0304153524,
-0.0297511332,
-0.0356647745,
0.0072811013,
0.0375097729,
-0.0408730768,
0.0374250859,
0.0166773722,
0.0013243213,
-0.0410922244,
0.000001942,
-0.0397054479,
-0.0122831082,
-0.0263752937,
0.002751362,
-0.0786001161,
0.0119141368,
0.0757235661,
0.0111909537,
0.0087398505,
-0.0298419558,
0.0412526466,
0.0033913751,
0.0331175439,
0.0491580032,
0.0062541286,
-0.0186647829,
0.0541519411,
-0.0225292239,
0.0498489775,
-0.0091330595,
-0.0358583033,
0.0114253741,
0.0357985161,
0.0360561274,
-0.0461287349,
-0.0344377011,
-0.0076057082,
-0.0059574186,
-0.0216470156,
-0.0137865348,
-0.0022751114,
-0.0062785717,
-0.0529669076,
0.0077476171,
0.0547149554,
0.0354772918,
0.0066677616,
0.0053518354,
-0.0023313223,
0.098730579,
0.0857292786,
0.0007407076,
-0.016579492,
-0.0303325914,
-0.0132012535,
-0.0430150405,
-0.0301351808,
-0.0247135758,
0.0285720024,
0.0459969901,
0.0403849296,
-0.0520925634,
-0.0395187177,
0.0377868935,
0.0164069105,
0.0145033877,
0.0074274074,
0.0266652964,
0.0568150543,
-0.0247820728,
0.0185955577,
-0.0481180586,
-0.0683913007,
-0.0484059192,
0.0384135135,
-0.0102411145,
0.0527899973,
-0.032084614,
0.0088395802,
0.0010517766,
0.0759223923,
0.0395814404,
-0.0066337176,
0.0084280157,
0.0466173962,
-0.0573329441,
-0.0009503866,
-0.0819519982,
0.028040627,
0.0494083241,
-0.0173273887,
-0.0049892259,
0.0351255387,
-0.0571151748,
0.0227021407,
-0.0613017268,
0.0020905181,
0.00600171,
0.031732522,
-0.0065021152,
0.0262837522,
-0.0369558893,
0.0413665213,
0.0102170454,
-0.0485972762,
0.010924628,
-0.001573267,
0.0124776419,
0.0356210247,
-0.0287685115,
-0.0018703172,
-0.0045756972,
-0.0451191217,
-0.0528721213,
-0.0278324969,
0.0158370044,
-0.0260559693,
0.0191364866,
0.0383640938,
-0.0357148536,
-0.0021642423,
0.0090780966,
-0.0231415052,
0.0183230173,
-0.0191909838,
0.0497073643,
0.0489533618,
-0.0242718365,
-0.0139442496,
-0.0016556563,
0.0193013493,
-0.1075278297,
0.0158177651,
0.0184055567,
0.0190153383,
-0.002424286,
-0.0342607237,
0.0684718117,
-0.0427453145,
0.0058091097,
-0.0193658471,
0.0415791944,
-0.0596087649,
-0.0171753373,
0.0088289101,
-0.0185720623,
-0.0192373358,
-0.0114098964,
0.0737467781,
0.0488737226,
0.0027405727,
-0.1156935021,
-0.0032105607,
-0.0501503013,
0.0203447081,
0.0322441719,
0.0057413797,
-0.0148343425,
0.0050739837,
-0.0416955575,
-0.0276942533,
-0.0450224467,
-0.0111554815,
-0.0231379997,
-0.0518674105,
-0.0174635164,
-0.0189806446,
0.0526705682,
0.0422070548,
0.0428428464,
-0.0275906678,
-0.0137137705,
-0.0165010169,
-0.0443960465,
-0.0721962899,
0.0016558502,
-0.048809085,
0.0471871234,
0.0515925884,
0.0120111499,
-0.0739749894,
-0.0423564017,
-0.0111819515,
0.0249457788,
-0.0110662421,
-0.0116779702,
-0.0148630161,
-0.0201370884,
-0.0050988765,
-0.0173215475,
0.012475051,
-0.0020021861,
-0.0007241658,
0.0193828028,
0.0684393868,
-0.008311634,
0.051910989,
0.0040965932,
0.0107642645,
0.0014649959,
-0.0098643107,
-0.0629653111,
0.0186600741,
0.0333172195,
0.0297773592,
-0.0023328052,
-0.0211779568,
0.0229515117,
0.0396216996,
-0.0172101762,
0.0640133396,
0.0104054864,
0.004035674,
0.0354629271,
-0.0169474445,
-0.0551780351,
0.0437459387,
0.0125677753,
-0.0151266893,
0.049170047,
-0.0203134529,
0.0139027787,
0.0241034627,
0.0865627006,
-0.0556266122,
0.0104533639,
0.0105025703,
-0.054865092,
0.014128821,
0.0134552754,
-0.0016950547,
0.0047041653,
-0.005333493,
-0.0219072476,
-0.0140135167,
-0.0161705259,
-0.004819023,
-0.0248708986,
-0.0179103855,
-0.0382355452,
-0.0805330724,
0.0290694125,
-0.0042316541,
-0.0532212965,
0.0135569517,
-0.0398551039,
-0.0266560167,
-0.0645103082,
-0.0231490117,
-0.0264218766,
0.0068576038,
0.0502729751,
-0.0153409634,
0.0220397767,
0.0144645926,
0.0135838818,
-0.0276902746,
-0.0544180721,
0.019422913,
-0.0155964717,
-0.0326611437,
0.0693243295,
-0.0267507117,
-0.0678969771,
0.0523165613,
0.0057702786,
0.0307468679,
-0.03347563,
-0.0604910254,
0.0579756573,
0.0081598163,
0.0560017563,
0.1200416535,
-0.0029945162,
0.086118862,
0.0776754096,
-0.0154684493,
-0.0316131376,
0.0388555527,
0.0216682106,
0.0020859563,
0.0038746346,
-0.0421393886,
-0.0102321766,
-0.0354212113,
0.0083134221,
0.0056656967,
-0.0325878188,
0.0128407609,
-0.0144795245,
-0.062319655,
0.0089500109,
-0.0322838575,
-0.0092330631,
-0.0065660989,
0.0583918169,
-0.0302426554,
0.0603898019,
0.0618822426,
-0.0127242133,
0.0097137457,
0.0296244677,
0.0547466017,
0.0239288751,
-0.0190291815,
-0.0077406708,
-0.0096440893,
-0.017135676,
-0.0108615002,
-0.0387178846,
-0.0137445265,
-0.0344446003,
-0.0392096266,
-0.0718640685,
-0.0495123565,
0.0161738414,
0.0148041574,
-0.0691133514,
0.0258369483,
-0.0273307581,
-0.0193988867,
0.0131879151,
-0.0371003971,
-0.0298679732,
-0.0352674946,
0.0518000089,
-0.0211425349,
-0.0109993592,
-0.0333118699,
0.0106094023,
-0.0540411025,
0.041425731,
0.0468466841,
0.0228087511,
0.0075878613,
0.0651719049,
0.0536347777,
0.0534826033,
-0.0513504855,
-0.0022654985,
-0.0283103194,
0.0248332918,
0.0055770818,
0.0107365744,
0.0150868837,
0.0448947363,
-0.0000164959,
0.0309636742,
0.0776788145,
0.0308737066,
-0.0700901374,
0.0033760017,
-0.0477479696,
-0.0785619095,
-0.001289261,
-0.0260338672,
0.0022810369,
-0.001984016,
-0.0062153097,
0.0290367547,
-0.0325301923,
-0.0224264245,
0.0122847613,
-0.0340382196,
0.0345277824,
-0.0259078238,
-0.0034259767,
-0.0763020143,
-0.009561968,
0.0493935607,
0.0254354514,
-0.0117463777,
-0.015297126,
0.0183797237,
0.0095452806,
0.0440840237,
0.0050747963,
0.0008640288,
0.0018447025,
-0.0151112759,
0.0044249292,
0.0235881042,
0.0540746152,
-0.0042103939,
-0.0339329131,
-0.0553418845,
0.0522835255,
0.0158875957,
-0.0260430612,
-0.0001291727,
-0.012770704,
0.0131286392,
-0.0208414234,
0.0318934619,
-0.0566591583,
0.0101862988,
0.0712614208,
0.0421611927,
-0.0503558815,
-0.008364629,
-0.0098592108,
0.0123370569,
0.04707513,
0.0152443359,
-0.0116652567,
-0.0100247934,
0.032379657,
0.0219205692,
0.0222410206,
0.0556001216,
0.0056428304,
-0.0165849626,
0.0049228948,
0.0172906853,
-0.0462069549,
-0.073279798,
0.0596019849,
0.0671932995,
0.001783055,
-0.0246331077,
0.0269433316,
0.0738693625,
-0.0044142851,
0.0108283777,
0.0347498469,
0.0342825577,
-0.0550970398,
-0.0489036106,
-0.0200671162,
-0.008372887,
0.0302853417,
-0.0346779376,
0.0384009778,
-0.0403981879,
0.0527427904,
0.0384127423,
0.0231841933,
0.0078064632,
0.0397252515,
-0.002688277,
-0.0416076519,
-0.0280329101,
0.0282184258,
0.0163797103,
0.033940535,
0.0173742529,
0.0130124129,
-0.0049156314,
-0.0126468251,
-0.0248196013,
-0.0345663317,
-0.0435283072,
-0.0273282211,
-0.0726737529,
0.0115322545,
0.0481776185,
0.0613591112,
-0.0300016869,
0.0082984576,
-0.011382699,
0.0189527869,
-0.0355356559,
0.0149450237,
-0.0186328217,
0.0053532762,
-0.0108072888,
0.0068325521,
0.0069925874,
-0.0284852814,
-0.0225161612,
-0.0244207196,
0.0169949383,
0.0295505729,
-0.0204208363,
0.0589178056,
-0.0093590934,
0.0132731916,
-0.0054491223,
0.0151031604,
0.0401063636,
0.0188986231,
0.0369983055,
0.1294684857,
0.0130747948,
-0.0159264915,
0.0055859438,
0.0486702323,
-0.0172714964,
-0.0622378327,
0.0195480119,
0.0181701668,
-0.0090620425,
0.0031408342,
0.0187939815,
-0.0582811721,
0.0310817193,
-0.0018323581,
0.032266397,
-0.0124329422,
-0.032240659,
0.0294967927,
-0.0241979174,
0.0210797042,
0.0356556959,
0.025092613,
-0.0468734801,
0.0313793235,
-0.0402172729,
-0.0244943667,
-0.0103738336,
0.0119839832,
0.0281165913,
-0.0007295105,
0.0117399395,
0.032336697,
-0.0224402752,
-0.0212169643,
-0.0499315299,
0.0004897604,
-0.0005945669,
-0.0820565894,
0.0449644662,
0.0080544753,
-0.0139287515,
-0.0387152284,
-0.0536412001,
0.0641137213,
-0.0315083899,
0.0107799396,
-0.039041087,
-4.996199231e-33,
-0.0083467308,
-0.0679696724,
-0.0119594755,
0.0651004016,
-0.0107814567,
-0.0308649745,
-0.0244978853,
0.032246016,
-0.0104010655,
0.0322086662,
0.0139340768,
0.0587097853,
-0.0024772245,
-0.0466841236,
0.0411014631,
-0.0010019544,
0.023595633,
0.0281929336,
0.0393828601,
0.0219174512,
0.0149689736,
0.011465447,
-0.0090866573,
-0.0754159167,
0.0745572224,
-0.0258559603,
-0.02395688,
-0.0285703782,
-0.0141444989,
-0.0359873101,
0.0145896133,
0.0345196128,
0.0098110698,
0.0113719674,
0.0166470762,
0.0236322209,
0.0059925835,
-0.0820063651,
-0.0359106623,
0.0336619131,
-0.0725641847,
-0.0324995518,
-0.0293872468,
-0.0124539714,
-0.0636291727,
0.0195511598,
0.0537552722,
0.014896147,
0.0098669156,
-0.0150601994,
-0.0668421984,
-0.0341088697,
-0.0359505489,
-0.0682782158,
0.0008516732,
0.0956123099,
-0.0257707518,
0.0090218401,
-0.0238703024,
0.0320596956,
-0.019767059,
-0.0346655659,
0.0309677999,
-0.0266792625,
0.025881201,
-0.0021653713,
0.0132962074,
0.0394420549,
-0.0064579132,
0.0004533314,
0.0052277222,
0.0094877388,
0.061028026,
-0.0121916002,
0.0041199266,
-0.037709035,
-0.0218025018,
0.0453142151,
0.0735883489,
0.008995425,
-0.0254595987,
0.0132732121,
-0.0769934654,
0.0162978116,
0.0162977725,
-0.020745175,
0.0204038322,
-0.0588223822,
0.0093660327,
-0.0275364462,
0.019915726,
-0.0475531034,
-0.0454114228,
-0.0097114164,
0.0004688038,
-0.0105213225,
-0.0229618568,
0.0178996567,
0.0021102291,
-0.000062105,
-0.0110051222,
-0.0166657865,
0.0149387605,
-0.0219780039,
0.055566065,
0.0168332569,
-0.0413868092,
0.046591647,
0.0153644877,
-0.0258670524,
-0.0253418479,
0.002778654,
0.0506369732,
-0.0314937346,
0.0051326691,
0.0229001343,
-0.0327565409,
0.0599135496,
-0.0011327645,
-0.0053771343,
-0.0468063653,
0.020587204,
-0.0412076861,
-0.0213727932,
-0.0473311096,
-0.0664015934,
-0.0329969414,
0.030527031,
-0.0442222096,
-0.0560938641,
-0.0082552424,
-0.0437901244,
2.825e-7,
-0.0695293993,
0.0146376407,
0.0080085406,
-0.0091721537,
-0.0005164329,
0.0465572104,
-0.0191193093,
0.0173445996,
0.0785878301,
0.01951457,
0.0355084054,
-0.0141586931,
0.003893316,
0.0226582251,
-0.0595673099,
-0.0377637893,
0.0582637638,
-0.0360218659,
0.0238124169,
0.0699705631,
0.1147573218,
-0.0345828831,
0.0445202179,
0.0065192617,
0.0074306061,
-0.0028081818,
-0.0267068576,
-0.0100213494,
0.04073973,
-0.0257247891,
0.071280919,
-0.0204967633,
0.00982056,
0.0700721815,
0.0345067605,
-0.0120507777,
-0.0347205549,
0.0291897506,
-0.0187930819,
-0.0142982407,
0.0308254715,
0.0457580835,
-0.0015156615,
0.0198651496,
0.0093956748,
-0.0634291172,
-0.0115124555,
0.0711462498,
-0.0338583142,
-0.0457039364,
0.0160568822,
-0.0010207243,
0.0103343287,
0.0294772834,
-0.0456411317,
-0.0141405836,
-0.0029427388,
-0.0210265182,
0.0142194005,
-0.041028522,
-0.0458780304,
-0.0344384424,
-0.0048524663,
-0.0172014479,
-0.0009691335,
-0.0244378354,
0.0205295756,
1.30539566e-34,
-0.0428313091,
0.0144993383,
0.0286282375,
0.0275569502,
0.0150435055,
0.023453543,
-0.039545238,
0.0155913029,
0.0467691794,
-0.004888671,
-0.0326858275
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10341v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10341v2 | CoCo: Coherence-Enhanced Machine-Generated Text Detection Under Data Limitation With Contrastive Learning | 2022-12-20T15:26:19 | 2023-10-20T13:21:51 | Xiaoming Liu, Zhaohan Zhang, Yichen Wang, Hang Pu, Yu Lan, Chao Shen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Machine-Generated Text (MGT) detection, a task that discriminates MGT from
Human-Written Text (HWT), plays a crucial role in preventing misuse of text
generative models, which excel in mimicking human writing style recently.
Latest proposed detectors usually take coarse text sequences as input and
fine-tune pretrained models with standard cross-entropy loss. However, these
methods fail to consider the linguistic structure of texts. Moreover, they lack
the ability to handle the low-resource problem which could often happen in
practice considering the enormous amount of textual data online. In this paper,
we present a coherence-based contrastive learning model named CoCo to detect
the possible MGT under low-resource scenario. To exploit the linguistic
feature, we encode coherence information in form of graph into text
representation. To tackle the challenges of low data resource, we employ a
contrastive learning framework and propose an improved contrastive loss for
preventing performance degradation brought by simple samples. The experiment
results on two public datasets and two self-constructed datasets prove our
approach outperforms the state-of-art methods significantly. Also, we
surprisingly find that MGTs originated from up-to-date language models could be
easier to detect than these from previous models, in our experiments. And we
propose some preliminary explanations for this counter-intuitive phenomena. All
the codes and datasets are open-sourced. | [
0.0151971532,
0.0643139929,
0.0162583794,
0.0658079758,
-0.0518037006,
-0.0097717354,
0.0028156927,
0.0280923825,
0.0238394178,
-0.0298430417,
0.0014323082,
-0.0315259919,
0.0090303207,
0.0393876545,
0.0184718166,
-0.0584227704,
0.0117342453,
-0.0120403655,
0.0015327879,
0.0146841696,
0.0227640383,
0.0149619216,
0.030623544,
-0.0009517525,
-0.0150819197,
-0.0795845911,
0.0109685194,
0.0539899282,
0.0113034816,
-0.0651261732,
0.0231384076,
0.0569319017,
-0.0075944499,
0.0436486453,
0.0000023371,
-0.0365620106,
-0.0328487456,
-0.0078444825,
0.009608198,
-0.0134122018,
0.0633536354,
-0.0420549475,
-0.0370587744,
0.0228597373,
-0.004961099,
0.0310060177,
0.0116225872,
0.0632295534,
0.0352003127,
0.0993254483,
-0.0417752489,
-0.0297182724,
0.053957738,
-0.0025858926,
-0.0009951589,
0.0102168964,
0.0204813834,
0.0001185923,
-0.0024770671,
0.0103647094,
-0.025277473,
0.0198707003,
0.0176782738,
-0.0233824663,
-0.008275317,
0.0377094448,
-0.0281490907,
-0.0149816098,
-0.0143933091,
0.0587270558,
-0.042858351,
-0.0398440957,
0.0485529192,
-0.042282816,
0.0008336361,
0.0089149158,
0.027055949,
0.0206063502,
-0.063363649,
0.0472879484,
0.0173600409,
0.0251214132,
0.0000303749,
0.0279585402,
0.0085996473,
-0.0150960833,
-0.0030088713,
-0.04125157,
-0.0362065211,
0.0266729929,
-0.0195628703,
-0.0223378222,
0.0218375959,
0.0065372479,
-0.0104558375,
-0.0330599323,
-0.1045437902,
-0.0768855363,
0.0341013223,
-0.0425544679,
0.0463688709,
-0.0319707505,
-0.0380755365,
0.0526087731,
-0.040446952,
0.0437668264,
-0.0165572874,
0.0210921895,
-0.0162535552,
-0.0113513824,
-0.0111279935,
0.0049604601,
-0.0270344764,
0.0209318884,
-0.0073359334,
-0.0299587119,
-0.0149911195,
0.0224213153,
0.0009464678,
0.0115700904,
-0.0023944725,
-0.0025886407,
-0.0329011232,
-0.0122209834,
0.0369044691,
-0.0151137989,
0.0205063671,
0.0011970145,
-0.0061039128,
-0.0586116016,
-0.0109059801,
0.0801402852,
0.0544863641,
-0.0183505435,
0.0282188766,
0.0476951674,
-0.0176638123,
-0.0593027771,
-0.0668979213,
-0.0479604341,
-0.0517108627,
-0.0423197225,
-0.0226835441,
-0.0802529231,
-0.0585048534,
-0.0268543307,
0.0136278234,
-0.0317907333,
-0.0108075887,
0.0285963994,
-0.0266360622,
0.042543117,
-0.0537303202,
-0.0126738893,
0.0358267501,
-0.0059744599,
0.0120818801,
0.0407855213,
0.0226265211,
0.0420365743,
0.0418345071,
0.0149995955,
0.0217888504,
0.025455581,
0.0010573699,
-0.0025167437,
0.007918085,
-0.0237138942,
-0.0347297639,
0.0062122238,
0.075836882,
0.0795335695,
-0.0022673646,
-0.046824649,
0.0833150595,
0.0452403724,
0.0534984432,
0.0186970886,
0.0279559866,
0.0934732407,
-0.01554156,
0.0601702631,
0.0150315063,
-0.0296513624,
-0.0249061454,
0.0339369997,
0.0570735186,
0.0171023756,
-0.0251428522,
-0.0232244357,
-0.0053382316,
-0.0297565628,
-0.0074891541,
-0.0433380008,
0.0561414808,
0.0306015816,
-0.0509911031,
-0.0581009425,
0.0240016356,
-0.0474720858,
-0.0025135025,
-0.0359760262,
0.0408297665,
0.0897156894,
0.0481199585,
-0.0054589538,
0.0495611206,
-0.0230769441,
0.0287744738,
0.0730024204,
-0.0249210466,
0.0324481539,
0.0266948976,
-0.0393492095,
-0.0130260764,
-0.0180950426,
-0.0004447397,
-0.0003354232,
-0.0050350954,
0.0364814065,
0.018656021,
0.0037797708,
-0.0446905158,
0.0391771756,
0.0105958758,
0.0085310359,
0.0110767959,
0.0114980247,
-0.0001976162,
0.0276353583,
-0.0383439399,
0.0142411329,
0.0088140648,
-0.0359867848,
-0.0139617957,
-0.0226694364,
-0.0479573943,
-0.0827777758,
0.0085136322,
-0.074997209,
-0.0492450856,
0.0393863171,
-0.017369112,
-0.0344664454,
0.0239684377,
-0.0752058327,
0.0180557966,
-0.0702994764,
0.0080208341,
-0.015268269,
0.0325949825,
0.0066668983,
0.0793051124,
-0.0141281029,
-0.0067521208,
0.0156058371,
0.0259820968,
0.0176793057,
-0.0563857295,
-0.0030141803,
-0.0321263932,
-0.0178440753,
0.0400221571,
0.0275326483,
0.0491216555,
-0.0212020278,
-0.0265809428,
-0.0298301764,
-0.0068666968,
-0.03561984,
-0.0007390556,
0.0329767205,
-0.0267993975,
-0.0051290342,
-0.0300708171,
-0.0085028093,
0.0002149234,
0.0305241309,
-0.0010283279,
0.0641543269,
-0.0521136448,
0.0302329026,
-0.0334366262,
-0.001252876,
0.0181318969,
0.0594968684,
0.0239421111,
-0.057026919,
-0.0523104854,
0.0710036606,
0.0342113152,
-0.0073740291,
0.021077117,
-0.0323421173,
0.0016688624,
-0.0069861864,
0.03429785,
0.0715019256,
0.0491809361,
0.0113459481,
0.0009660769,
0.024330413,
0.0110373702,
-0.0192468427,
-0.0074688382,
0.0362024345,
-0.0000741999,
-0.0445121229,
0.033185523,
0.0535819009,
0.0205636043,
0.0231843423,
-0.0297241304,
-0.0219707917,
0.0041502435,
-0.0150422705,
-0.0017088365,
-0.0051531312,
-0.0298227016,
-0.0378965251,
-0.0479369722,
-0.0358460061,
0.0534477793,
-0.0439336039,
0.0057604546,
-0.0101257144,
-0.0630717948,
-0.0363841541,
0.0125521543,
0.0363932028,
0.0428298563,
0.0379529744,
-0.0400466211,
-0.0415532626,
-0.0014027471,
0.0406963155,
-0.0125800185,
0.0093637472,
-0.0055966671,
0.0032765144,
0.0079330141,
-0.0409549065,
-0.0421618931,
-0.0494095832,
-0.0007306972,
-0.0042073834,
0.0614192076,
-0.0403442867,
0.0020445888,
-0.0030240372,
-0.0051117442,
0.0795379728,
0.010637111,
-0.0309040453,
-0.0324486531,
0.1162484288,
0.0518255159,
0.0009978354,
0.0120877801,
-0.0374707319,
0.021038847,
0.0793984756,
-0.0280474164,
-0.003097164,
-0.0259381663,
-0.0086414106,
-0.0327025838,
0.0234737284,
-0.0210219491,
0.0226971898,
0.0246917512,
-0.0554697849,
-0.0161629114,
0.0855359659,
-0.0258580279,
-0.0386099294,
-0.0328467935,
0.0016336879,
0.0386429317,
-0.0060026711,
-0.0296556726,
-0.0572623052,
-0.0648161322,
0.0041166991,
0.0444508567,
-0.0057754084,
-0.016142806,
-0.0061092149,
-0.0716542974,
0.0161937512,
0.0044224523,
0.0170703772,
-0.0470381342,
-0.0277415346,
-0.0096787447,
0.0026320338,
-0.0262865126,
-0.0307162292,
-0.0231911354,
-0.0081428085,
0.0088374345,
-0.0509809963,
-0.0459045507,
-0.0621096008,
-0.0468789749,
0.0172865037,
0.0505541489,
0.0422657952,
-0.0078575341,
-0.0359922685,
0.0060025007,
-0.0533160195,
0.0017065682,
-0.0081970692,
0.0889985561,
-0.0142992521,
0.0094109131,
-0.0411939956,
0.0500141867,
0.0063880095,
-0.0298044309,
0.0174733717,
0.0309694503,
-0.0117399432,
-0.0606150255,
-0.0127167199,
0.0086540887,
0.0289910529,
0.0786936134,
0.0507554822,
-0.0286256522,
-0.0693127066,
-0.0324605145,
0.0581668392,
-0.0514615253,
-0.0145939067,
-0.0130990697,
0.0182146486,
-0.0138277868,
-0.0863731578,
-0.0364469402,
-0.0556523241,
-0.0118637523,
-0.0167178884,
0.0202680174,
0.0106668454,
-0.0313181207,
-0.0654049888,
-0.0079375161,
-0.0421681665,
0.0087074684,
-0.1043065637,
-0.0103963315,
-0.0134483222,
-0.0540901013,
-0.0087652979,
0.0320417285,
-0.0613858588,
-0.062006373,
-0.0144439451,
-0.0003038294,
0.0034663854,
0.035801813,
-0.0268593244,
-0.0297462624,
0.0876916796,
0.0531796888,
-0.039338585,
0.029837897,
0.0445126146,
-0.0315215029,
-0.0253721215,
0.0308532268,
-0.0146089718,
0.0185805205,
0.015730219,
-0.0106175663,
-0.0357722901,
-0.0196516234,
0.0134440586,
0.0057055773,
0.0473283604,
-0.0155936303,
0.0427843295,
-0.0342055894,
-0.0241523441,
0.0182945393,
-0.0098644355,
-0.0380355306,
0.0045656115,
0.0121516353,
-0.0304230303,
-0.0267039966,
0.0362754278,
-0.0194393005,
0.045350153,
-0.0282794926,
0.0202608965,
0.0170892049,
0.0481791832,
-0.0050262152,
-0.0143982228,
0.0213760715,
0.0503187589,
-0.0063937609,
0.0252118483,
0.0070262863,
0.0314041302,
0.011020082,
-0.0316433981,
0.0151054766,
0.0358218998,
-0.0456229486,
0.0064639319,
-0.0726040751,
0.0099983821,
0.0723464191,
0.0056483001,
0.0623796992,
-0.021619929,
0.0025280942,
-0.060590297,
0.0684969947,
0.029950276,
-0.04720008,
-0.0429561064,
0.0037991325,
-0.0289924871,
0.009246151,
0.0996287838,
0.0108669298,
-0.000911386,
0.0189909767,
-0.0351985469,
-0.0333962478,
0.0028468876,
0.0268259346,
0.0136917466,
-0.0086321617,
0.0187246837,
-0.0227492843,
-0.0416537784,
0.0596307702,
-0.0066301455,
0.035710372,
0.051822599,
0.0169889685,
-0.0057888781,
-0.0014218331,
0.0107602719,
-0.0474614128,
0.0372208506,
0.0197396949,
0.0047302675,
0.0042250687,
-6.699554463e-33,
0.0016970981,
-0.0609815978,
-0.0386241041,
0.0073760781,
0.0249339305,
0.0444627814,
-0.05620436,
-0.021361744,
-0.0039882045,
0.018142134,
0.0084703024,
0.0375346243,
0.0101493141,
0.0538792498,
-0.0338701755,
-0.0016448369,
0.0635291487,
0.0106998831,
-0.0039475178,
0.0272604488,
0.0393790938,
0.0232949164,
0.036441125,
-0.0669135824,
-0.0308085755,
-0.0440153554,
-0.0214781594,
-0.0165304448,
0.0358921625,
0.0435973145,
-0.0314942412,
0.0606047213,
0.0366127081,
0.0005715213,
-0.0352290384,
0.0472876914,
-0.056163162,
-0.0197645053,
-0.063811332,
-0.0269068312,
-0.0378613919,
-0.0515921414,
0.0157242715,
-0.014974772,
0.0300088655,
-0.0134748071,
0.0764569566,
-0.0044155819,
-0.0049015544,
-0.0292589329,
-0.0555620678,
0.082476683,
-0.0055944943,
-0.0132215433,
0.0335569531,
0.0443567485,
0.0132433055,
-0.000719682,
-0.0792099312,
0.0296131782,
-0.0003263059,
0.0294418186,
-0.00422577,
0.0174899139,
-0.0412169509,
0.0718492717,
-0.010255063,
0.0120646488,
-0.0057655685,
0.0184031818,
-0.0085272081,
0.0096213399,
0.0601643808,
0.0583498999,
0.0419049338,
-0.0391433798,
-0.0537391454,
0.0398086086,
-0.0439744368,
0.0090610199,
0.0320741646,
0.001864904,
-0.0574807338,
-0.0073056258,
0.0319129229,
-0.0831544027,
-0.0317015685,
-0.0142035792,
-0.0016345475,
0.0268648565,
-0.0494345948,
0.0006321957,
0.0115075735,
-0.0157090649,
-0.0231265966,
0.0406252369,
-0.038281545,
0.0215753205,
0.010224401,
0.0219685156,
-0.0326027721,
-0.0351317823,
0.0464593247,
0.0341564491,
0.0162419882,
-0.0042100162,
0.0853876919,
0.0153703419,
-0.0632619634,
0.0075417282,
0.0044580298,
0.0022768625,
-0.0052893087,
-0.0271992832,
0.0300610829,
-0.0221812483,
-0.00316235,
0.0368703306,
0.0242064241,
0.007733406,
-0.0382036641,
-0.024262635,
-0.0233817417,
0.0184416696,
-0.0174073931,
0.0285559501,
-0.0341949873,
0.0313807987,
0.0471258685,
-0.0486498997,
0.0054346239,
-0.012983948,
2.898e-7,
0.0245894361,
0.0070730243,
0.0385657102,
-0.0111507801,
0.000502976,
0.04964827,
-0.0079591591,
0.0255419388,
-0.062863335,
-0.0086805271,
-0.0042950939,
0.0168942083,
0.0788375065,
0.0113587612,
-0.0593461208,
0.0764033943,
-0.0823878497,
0.0056952452,
-0.0603014864,
0.0201619435,
0.0766457319,
0.0488108173,
-0.0071059088,
-0.035576161,
0.0483756699,
-0.0648442432,
0.0330112278,
-0.0051088296,
0.0262428187,
-0.0210336484,
0.0335310511,
0.0116882185,
-0.0017764525,
-0.0143427774,
-0.0249172114,
-0.0121751837,
0.0166746564,
0.0450978428,
0.0389755107,
0.0267082565,
0.0313575864,
0.001861729,
-0.0098176235,
-0.0075253341,
0.0627768487,
-0.0094818147,
-0.0076566865,
-0.0362352021,
-0.0158356614,
-0.0454932936,
0.0179006997,
-0.0308416598,
-0.0418062136,
-0.0002521695,
0.0272312183,
-0.0310961362,
-0.009149773,
-0.0504073575,
-0.0407214165,
0.0050148489,
-0.0252224188,
0.0094247311,
-0.0665693432,
0.0284859668,
0.0635453388,
-0.0297602806,
0.0452747531,
2.791553882e-34,
0.0303440336,
-0.0247519817,
-0.0231752824,
-0.0055502243,
-0.005281528,
0.0090277698,
-0.0156762358,
-0.0194573775,
-0.0054287524,
-0.0381276011,
0.015564546
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10325v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10325v5 | SeqDiffuSeq: Text Diffusion with Encoder-Decoder Transformers | 2022-12-20T15:16:24 | 2023-05-22T17:31:46 | Hongyi Yuan, Zheng Yuan, Chuanqi Tan, Fei Huang, Songfang Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Diffusion model, a new generative modelling paradigm, has achieved great
success in image, audio, and video generation. However, considering the
discrete categorical nature of text, it is not trivial to extend continuous
diffusion models to natural language, and text diffusion models are less
studied. Sequence-to-sequence text generation is one of the essential natural
language processing topics. In this work, we apply diffusion models to approach
sequence-to-sequence text generation, and explore whether the superiority
generation performance of diffusion model can transfer to natural language
domain. We propose SeqDiffuSeq, a text diffusion model for sequence-to-sequence
generation. SeqDiffuSeq uses an encoder-decoder Transformers architecture to
model denoising function. In order to improve generation quality, SeqDiffuSeq
combines the self-conditioning technique and a newly proposed adaptive noise
schedule technique. The adaptive noise schedule has the difficulty of denoising
evenly distributed across time steps, and considers exclusive noise schedules
for tokens at different positional order. Experiment results illustrate the
good performance on sequence-to-sequence generation in terms of text quality
and inference time. | [
0.0127989231,
0.0528406501,
0.0114523582,
-0.0006677544,
-0.0133427093,
-0.0086783832,
0.0097228158,
0.0133910459,
-0.031055877,
-0.0227848236,
0.033408504,
-0.0459658168,
0.0034142893,
0.0288712122,
0.0226331986,
-0.0609398037,
-0.0010438313,
-0.0162550211,
-0.0121215219,
0.0054981206,
-0.0096880114,
-0.0091312286,
0.0040061651,
-0.0043706317,
-0.0066584735,
-0.0233553089,
-0.0290925931,
0.0147511996,
0.0235269871,
-0.0321091712,
-0.0036820476,
0.0661431327,
0.0370092355,
-0.0159137845,
0.0000021697,
-0.0211007893,
-0.0065273452,
0.0185051933,
0.0492821522,
0.0056045661,
0.0418942124,
-0.0093219792,
-0.0161476862,
0.0217438452,
0.0072921626,
0.0257931259,
0.0753163397,
0.0277903192,
0.0815790743,
0.0700972304,
-0.0279806312,
-0.0942193791,
0.0201747287,
-0.029824188,
0.0604562014,
-0.0139498431,
0.0151521191,
0.0427595004,
0.0098760501,
-0.0038819157,
-0.041143056,
0.0322448649,
0.0294016395,
-0.0470044762,
0.0663317069,
0.0469816364,
0.0593793988,
-0.0568591692,
-0.0130599132,
0.0503478423,
-0.0173378084,
0.0013409144,
0.0313822702,
0.0030546153,
-0.014226228,
0.0069423066,
-0.0213362053,
0.0261970647,
-0.0140923588,
0.0154015133,
0.01622984,
0.031671308,
0.0008347888,
-0.0232999548,
-0.0033950512,
-0.0222411323,
0.0279305857,
-0.0104093505,
-0.05619701,
0.0086079519,
0.0340083688,
-0.0583701655,
0.0512922369,
0.0491916388,
-0.0227930881,
-0.0000172194,
-0.0783057809,
-0.0777946711,
-0.0270164199,
-0.0397057422,
0.0084118051,
0.028470207,
0.0548802502,
0.0038494959,
-0.0359114297,
0.0086565856,
-0.0030285658,
-0.046237506,
-0.0425204635,
0.0185632128,
-0.0192559808,
0.0087196324,
-0.0476294458,
0.0382694453,
-0.0667987689,
-0.0322368629,
-0.0618362688,
0.0209185034,
0.0378734693,
-0.0325950794,
0.0766572803,
0.0009319487,
-0.0815139413,
-0.0106495526,
-0.0106568607,
-0.0164250191,
-0.0038093461,
-0.0211120695,
0.044810459,
0.025659766,
-0.0459760316,
0.0108091021,
0.041204717,
-0.0317522772,
-0.0369441621,
0.0730088353,
-0.0580495149,
0.0136028128,
-0.0398035869,
-0.0009907748,
0.0007445357,
-0.0250972472,
0.0054302723,
-0.0724818259,
0.010374058,
0.0050036139,
-0.0216012727,
-0.0338965058,
0.0151594765,
0.0279123075,
0.0040211529,
0.0245834365,
-0.0319048427,
-0.0126423268,
0.0780622289,
0.0069223898,
0.0514512844,
0.0660952404,
0.049112346,
0.0323422849,
-0.0144858779,
-0.0037622352,
0.0015067148,
0.002688515,
0.0175642911,
0.0121008409,
-0.0414696597,
-0.0334613472,
-0.0235529877,
0.0406809822,
0.077506803,
0.0972194672,
-0.0527756214,
0.0132559128,
0.0525569357,
0.0192604847,
0.0206119046,
0.0482228696,
0.0698313788,
0.0533737577,
-0.0520090461,
0.0392899029,
0.0495749973,
0.0647175163,
0.0583237335,
0.0184673872,
0.0696475133,
0.0357255042,
-0.0335673057,
-0.0516302027,
0.0273014866,
-0.0183584467,
0.0519049652,
-0.0566119179,
0.0224020164,
0.0605397001,
-0.1080222726,
0.0291226245,
-0.0106754471,
-0.0712157637,
0.022524504,
-0.0272482913,
0.0335170738,
0.0668110028,
0.0383633487,
0.0262372177,
0.0143993786,
-0.0161860269,
-0.0369683467,
0.0625330731,
-0.0023856354,
0.0131055331,
-0.0090830838,
-0.0660740882,
-0.0220188946,
0.0021034861,
0.0159184933,
0.00187023,
-0.025514625,
0.0642010048,
0.0314946584,
-0.0080873547,
-0.0417661145,
0.0304490104,
-0.0504334569,
-0.0276466515,
0.0262400303,
-0.0222592242,
0.0146978097,
-0.005875994,
-0.0219744891,
0.0215250254,
0.0127620809,
-0.0370251909,
-0.0402971581,
0.0144020179,
-0.0731837973,
-0.0790241808,
-0.0092894966,
-0.0554507859,
0.010973854,
0.0040927483,
-0.0229107141,
-0.0388112739,
0.0121505475,
-0.0621517524,
-0.0008672948,
-0.0549400002,
0.0161826871,
0.0403511189,
0.0141188493,
0.0065656393,
0.0611195937,
-0.0245198011,
-0.0125078745,
0.0019634068,
0.0572876558,
-0.0290162489,
-0.0085754041,
0.0217889529,
-0.0346470773,
-0.0128843924,
0.0063464921,
0.019341154,
0.0101819402,
-0.0305321664,
-0.0374485478,
-0.0248022825,
-0.0069579151,
-0.0144876856,
-0.0170506462,
0.0477108024,
0.0224571172,
0.0357436575,
0.0121580642,
-0.0574324317,
-0.0033096478,
0.0072188554,
-0.0267002992,
0.0653380677,
-0.0216361657,
-0.0454601683,
-0.0190528054,
-0.0104320645,
0.0295306407,
0.0442979597,
-0.0040892805,
-0.0107925842,
-0.0714352131,
0.0514911413,
0.0036306055,
-0.0025660384,
-0.0080236802,
-0.0402399078,
-0.0088632489,
0.0226575062,
0.0877733901,
0.0304475036,
0.0755863339,
0.0483460501,
-0.0186255742,
-0.0313969925,
0.0367962979,
0.0143958377,
-0.0413012877,
0.0527840666,
-0.0246841945,
-0.0824508294,
0.0148953078,
0.0756424218,
0.0034904189,
0.0071620652,
-0.0615808517,
0.0009513942,
-0.008565397,
-0.0577821173,
-0.0056899744,
-0.0290431492,
-0.0199954454,
0.0033940577,
-0.0244681686,
-0.014254163,
0.0410925299,
-0.0180707909,
0.0117083164,
-0.0658702478,
0.0022650552,
-0.0011423053,
0.0056248088,
-0.006140891,
0.043596182,
0.0301503614,
-0.0295916907,
-0.0463602841,
-0.0133377211,
0.0250689611,
-0.032618206,
-0.0009297124,
-0.0132496832,
0.0056825066,
-0.0337824933,
0.0074332063,
-0.0389276184,
-0.0013599168,
0.0443492532,
0.0004665639,
0.0262390096,
-0.0234822482,
-0.0044643246,
0.038917724,
-0.0124312071,
0.0231203102,
-0.0229586065,
-0.0080893468,
-0.0259759724,
0.0977706537,
0.0544906668,
-0.0108232815,
-0.0329879634,
-0.0429407507,
0.0339368396,
0.0341433622,
-0.0170391593,
0.0033367057,
-0.0004150829,
-0.0148307569,
-0.0225360226,
0.0075473697,
-0.0043711583,
0.0420472473,
0.0827800855,
-0.035280887,
-0.0420663208,
0.0822209343,
-0.0071198554,
-0.0071586012,
0.0135224322,
0.0237419754,
0.059590321,
-0.0166338272,
-0.0050896211,
-0.0688465908,
-0.0132566774,
-0.0074004405,
0.0087193856,
-0.0101536904,
0.0002273119,
-0.0213357117,
-0.0560716949,
0.0557646975,
0.0277499147,
-0.0294401217,
-0.0371400714,
-0.0479364693,
-0.0484554879,
0.0154833095,
0.0235459656,
0.0220741797,
0.0037756825,
0.0279163513,
0.041609548,
0.0389656499,
-0.0685593262,
-0.0733698532,
-0.0073302193,
0.0291699227,
0.0609419011,
0.0262138136,
-0.0026396012,
-0.0686736628,
0.0181372389,
-0.0067688967,
-0.0211338494,
0.0170314796,
0.0136033064,
0.0015094161,
-0.0055658133,
-0.0251151212,
0.0048343474,
-0.0042969189,
0.0138136623,
-0.0260746703,
0.0197021309,
-0.005960885,
-0.0747460872,
-0.0374390855,
0.0143853938,
0.041649472,
0.05505969,
0.030003259,
-0.0444379002,
-0.0653468594,
-0.0228655264,
0.0179594941,
-0.0739604458,
-0.0511744916,
-0.0159745328,
-0.0008805551,
-0.117349036,
-0.1061184481,
-0.0177347567,
-0.0484777987,
0.0498931818,
-0.010167934,
0.037336491,
0.0399908125,
-0.0248045586,
-0.0429970548,
-0.0585595034,
0.0151962666,
-0.0084372377,
-0.0311416984,
-0.0318041295,
-0.0022017285,
-0.0161988512,
-0.0086800735,
0.0091702351,
-0.126338914,
-0.0519013852,
-0.0183021072,
0.0186366756,
0.0086801294,
0.0068192091,
0.0055456003,
-0.0018069148,
0.0853592232,
0.0532414727,
0.0156603344,
0.0212743282,
0.0001324715,
-0.0367239751,
-0.008755344,
-0.004258228,
-0.0134257153,
0.0400389992,
-0.0391402021,
0.0534399152,
-0.0254793651,
0.004302403,
0.0064187213,
-0.0347078405,
-0.0281493906,
-0.0283591095,
0.0310809202,
-0.0082104448,
0.0146007678,
-0.0486638024,
0.0126546556,
-0.0726621374,
-0.0024904732,
0.0571554527,
0.0087165367,
0.0117065823,
0.006833382,
-0.0000718196,
-0.0190982576,
0.0023555672,
0.0054396666,
0.0061975857,
0.0421533547,
0.0347051583,
-0.0234602783,
-0.0176803581,
-0.0312790945,
-0.0150134405,
0.0343033485,
-0.013246689,
0.032953795,
0.025547279,
0.0267103035,
0.0388800092,
0.0156182898,
-0.0181367304,
0.012829097,
-0.049930241,
-0.0196345374,
0.0443641208,
0.0347032957,
0.074851945,
-0.004111324,
0.0389229842,
-0.0202345904,
0.060422089,
-0.0007550551,
0.0029824118,
0.0187863596,
-0.0160525143,
0.0007426798,
-0.0126166958,
0.086165607,
-0.0100219883,
-0.0070863883,
0.001483941,
-0.0035131618,
-0.0198535528,
-0.023464134,
-0.0346244238,
-0.0432174094,
0.0211044606,
0.0162218641,
0.01939651,
-0.0525253564,
0.0126286149,
-0.0106696924,
0.0423170254,
-0.009858571,
0.0648575202,
0.029141549,
-0.0147639355,
0.0005021347,
-0.0355989747,
0.0411020145,
-0.0083990116,
-0.0360329188,
-0.0155390771,
-6.621877796e-33,
-0.0442380235,
-0.0394340865,
0.0116788046,
-0.0436286591,
-0.0481417701,
-0.0357739702,
-0.0618288778,
-0.006928815,
0.0289883148,
0.0190008953,
0.016405873,
0.0273816176,
0.0108611826,
0.041878134,
-0.0211286563,
0.0343100242,
0.0877458379,
-0.0419379324,
-0.0196788013,
0.0396032184,
0.0115384599,
0.0355986804,
0.0158566535,
-0.0133330654,
-0.017851511,
-0.028260963,
0.0067035723,
-0.0493119955,
0.0651036873,
-0.0089742849,
-0.0151073877,
0.0013464442,
0.0066273618,
-0.0148872677,
-0.0397670679,
0.017869778,
-0.0454310067,
-0.0102001913,
-0.0221175514,
-0.0196108371,
-0.0576131046,
-0.0507250391,
0.058177948,
0.0018622777,
-0.0301186722,
0.007565232,
0.0368702412,
0.0112086199,
-0.0182519481,
-0.0385108702,
-0.0392970219,
0.0479337797,
-0.0157509279,
-0.0162979271,
-0.0133276507,
0.0328979529,
-0.0195969902,
-0.0095281601,
-0.06766776,
0.01578141,
0.0169904996,
0.0760789737,
0.024110591,
0.0179397799,
0.0225613341,
0.0090751462,
0.0179062672,
0.0170604996,
-0.0030309162,
0.0498311967,
-0.0209406111,
0.0161100235,
0.0070349728,
0.0084496178,
0.0455582216,
-0.0458318219,
-0.0732338354,
0.058397375,
-0.0544440448,
0.009776894,
0.0847101435,
0.0150640942,
0.0361252129,
-0.0216335747,
-0.0150615582,
-0.0055739349,
0.0288218595,
-0.0336563289,
0.0163722802,
0.0420460105,
-0.0071476609,
-0.045063857,
0.0352661684,
0.0116277747,
-0.0056232559,
-0.0145850675,
-0.0522850342,
0.016418308,
-0.0063882731,
-0.0033325502,
-0.0556450002,
-0.0294491984,
0.0538779944,
0.0677573234,
-0.0147422003,
0.0243136678,
-0.0298289806,
0.001992729,
-0.0493965931,
0.0042844247,
-0.0270524565,
0.052500546,
0.0176753551,
0.0395761319,
-0.0053836368,
-0.0240975302,
-0.0415303074,
0.0419917889,
-0.0173432324,
0.0032277643,
-0.012342752,
0.0259953309,
0.0212070961,
0.0486480966,
-0.0334250368,
0.017346736,
-0.043927405,
0.0577256829,
0.0413020588,
-0.0499537438,
-0.0439079627,
0.0280241594,
2.888e-7,
0.0043481011,
0.0090740258,
0.0205406658,
0.0199261419,
0.0265742056,
0.0109909251,
0.0060335658,
0.0508109145,
0.0123262126,
-0.0245752018,
-0.0162312649,
0.0164537393,
-0.0006079829,
-0.0043560569,
-0.0827467218,
-0.0227690358,
-0.0663765222,
0.0534256436,
-0.0026003439,
0.0027638823,
0.0238827839,
0.0344660133,
-0.040514674,
-0.0080000814,
0.0355796106,
0.0150601668,
0.0873828605,
0.0509953275,
0.0042045396,
0.0220443811,
-0.0128789097,
-0.0483758561,
0.0092070773,
-0.0158290062,
-0.0418117568,
-0.0118879471,
0.0057597985,
0.0531668663,
-0.0289477371,
-0.0380995832,
0.0554290265,
0.0513188541,
-0.0020230026,
-0.0138091929,
0.0390775651,
-0.0058721551,
-0.0343014747,
0.0098401122,
-0.0545675941,
0.0366336666,
0.0091766883,
-0.0088639334,
-0.0570998006,
-0.0129125807,
0.0449101999,
0.0561922491,
-0.0059788725,
-0.0155901248,
-0.0076777707,
-0.0411730222,
-0.0399223864,
-0.0524203107,
-0.067328535,
-0.0211171657,
0.0103354407,
0.0546065271,
-0.022365652,
2.47520723e-34,
0.0436159335,
-0.0129759321,
-0.0109451348,
0.0325250179,
0.0039392142,
-0.0154599249,
-0.0251193997,
0.0281777401,
0.0090273153,
-0.0490910895,
-0.0504415184
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10315v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10315v2 | HINT: Hypernetwork Instruction Tuning for Efficient Zero- & Few-Shot Generalisation | 2022-12-20T15:07:37 | 2023-05-24T22:30:30 | Hamish Ivison, Akshita Bhagia, Yizhong Wang, Hannaneh Hajishirzi, Matthew Peters | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent NLP models have shown the remarkable ability to effectively generalise
`zero-shot' to new tasks using only natural language instructions as guidance.
However, many of these approaches suffer from high computational costs due to
their reliance on concatenating lengthy instructions with every input example,
resulting in costly reprocessing of the instruction. To avoid this, we
introduce Hypernetworks for INstruction Tuning (HINT), which convert task
instructions and examples into parameter-efficient modules inserted into an
underlying model using a pretrained text encoder, eliminating the need to
include instructions in the model input. The hypernetwork in HINT also produces
an encoded instruction, which we concatenate with encoded inputs during
decoding to further improve performance. HINT models outperform strong
state-of-the-art baselines by over 10% when controlling for compute (measured
in FLOPs). By converting instructions into modules, HINT models can effectively
disregard the length of instructions and few-shot example inputs in terms of
compute usage. As a result, HINT can enhance its performance by up to 25% by
incorporating additional few-shot data, while utilizing only up to 5% more
compute. This combines the strengths of parameter-efficient fine-tuning and
in-context learning. | [
0.0254899953,
0.0467062369,
0.0027610508,
0.0218295176,
-0.0206608847,
0.0394226797,
0.0298928358,
-0.0140221361,
-0.0442700163,
-0.0540105104,
-0.0249003377,
0.0113209793,
-0.0141476281,
0.0017302192,
0.0177552551,
-0.0055355062,
0.0470663384,
0.0196351968,
-0.0345372967,
0.0270916782,
-0.0026498472,
0.0491806641,
-0.0188346449,
0.0511733256,
0.0129855517,
-0.0082272515,
-0.0458137952,
0.0384717956,
0.0190751143,
-0.0148308948,
0.024748439,
0.0289360937,
0.0490857102,
0.0017093059,
0.0000019759,
0.0092457253,
-0.0120692523,
-0.0113015389,
-0.0552635565,
0.0057521914,
0.0307264663,
-0.0604653805,
-0.0008636434,
0.0025612498,
0.0001721386,
-0.0287402514,
0.0631111264,
0.0392347723,
0.0433712639,
0.1295802593,
-0.0041741058,
-0.017075073,
0.0295388922,
-0.0285164323,
0.0377338193,
-0.0403104648,
-0.0034881954,
-0.0034399286,
-0.0142682558,
0.0239146985,
-0.0201807376,
0.0260935817,
0.0202171486,
0.0517492928,
-0.0092437845,
0.0379933827,
-0.0285419337,
0.0023755217,
-0.0392935723,
0.0700489208,
-0.0893446207,
-0.0054829805,
-0.0047487114,
-0.0128856832,
-0.022541916,
-0.0298233181,
-0.0081139263,
0.0136868889,
0.0110343089,
0.0097377719,
0.0448997058,
-0.0015197988,
0.0288581327,
0.016541142,
0.0085177636,
0.0538372099,
0.0143358661,
0.0007603804,
-0.0115172621,
-0.0029193028,
-0.0325576998,
-0.038510479,
-0.0051839817,
0.0500117429,
-0.0082972338,
0.0087343231,
-0.0434409492,
-0.0237699579,
-0.0187052656,
-0.0483421125,
0.0891163573,
0.0812259167,
-0.0031495369,
0.0154332351,
-0.0422879122,
0.0332066938,
-0.0120018907,
0.0036674473,
-0.0351929516,
0.0033642605,
-0.060516376,
0.0121142399,
-0.0722274631,
0.0426316038,
-0.0621057041,
-0.0488318428,
-0.0129076215,
0.048191864,
0.0135231698,
0.0086368872,
0.0236376114,
0.001091995,
-0.0455175675,
-0.0210062806,
0.0012060071,
0.0476591289,
-0.0528752804,
0.0121824984,
-0.0075937985,
-0.0482865311,
-0.0370617658,
0.0030153212,
0.0227798764,
-0.0251815543,
0.0405924916,
0.0730502158,
-0.0153737292,
-0.0548556857,
-0.0539054498,
-0.0328326561,
0.0020894525,
-0.0632437915,
0.0060661477,
-0.0476425029,
0.0443537645,
-0.0264396071,
0.0013612428,
-0.0095910281,
0.0014565021,
0.035289593,
-0.0369779989,
0.0542045832,
-0.0027049829,
-0.0515432954,
0.0042998381,
-0.0104636736,
-0.0170951486,
0.0825267285,
0.0140906284,
0.020123424,
0.0046905424,
-0.002812837,
-0.0047150208,
0.0152924871,
0.0176545456,
-0.0000927653,
0.0185767729,
0.0088696349,
0.0222242456,
0.0296580493,
0.0479438379,
-0.0060628005,
-0.0669902861,
-0.0011300163,
0.0262078345,
0.0360456668,
0.0146281226,
0.0204250887,
0.082833223,
-0.0058355243,
-0.0208751149,
-0.0154115083,
-0.0529339723,
0.0372178666,
-0.0348526686,
-0.0063825767,
0.0114376964,
0.0100843441,
-0.0742945522,
-0.0335872397,
-0.0015294289,
-0.0196717866,
0.0060898843,
0.003881908,
0.0220003594,
0.0221352074,
-0.0812131092,
0.0406352915,
0.0335837565,
-0.0106982877,
-0.0051100738,
-0.0075578382,
0.0022908987,
0.0728706345,
0.0439219512,
-0.0210613105,
-0.030053813,
-0.0108811129,
0.0093457913,
0.0058542043,
0.023212919,
-0.0333296284,
0.0439940616,
-0.0888228938,
0.0003216456,
-0.0398535691,
0.0222068224,
0.0365130901,
-0.0070602936,
-0.0148920156,
0.0218501408,
0.0330120549,
-0.0026501629,
0.0196513031,
-0.0061005782,
-0.0544551536,
0.0215784777,
0.0087560797,
0.0109003829,
0.0034715883,
-0.0089611728,
0.0021249142,
-0.0032924416,
-0.0315727778,
-0.0156731587,
-0.0734402984,
-0.0446502119,
-0.1021502241,
-0.0146117564,
-0.0354234502,
0.0408836678,
0.0243829675,
-0.0599347614,
-0.0394292623,
0.0259302463,
-0.0215663482,
0.0550318286,
0.0016907685,
0.0102332979,
0.0141136786,
0.0269025657,
-0.024905609,
0.0403856002,
0.0102145243,
0.0095420275,
0.0163795613,
-0.013928365,
0.0026309635,
-0.0355603732,
-0.015139984,
0.0015555756,
0.0139550809,
-0.0011565861,
-0.0095537053,
0.0313253738,
-0.0114871794,
-0.0206060242,
-0.0853015557,
0.0663188696,
-0.0438796394,
0.0342768207,
0.0441391245,
0.0111744786,
0.0122351516,
-0.0212870743,
-0.0144341644,
0.0368495584,
-0.0397009179,
0.0115570398,
0.0138819963,
0.0185710844,
-0.021332711,
-0.0175900366,
-0.057014104,
-0.0018974185,
0.0458308794,
-0.0280332193,
0.0239656009,
-0.0448057055,
0.0021021205,
-0.020362094,
0.0156644061,
0.0139197959,
-0.0285557434,
-0.0000701233,
-0.015585565,
0.0049302815,
0.0753163174,
-0.060331963,
0.0254187025,
0.0305582136,
0.0131284622,
-0.0466838554,
0.0277702268,
-0.0553199872,
-0.011558868,
-0.0233635139,
0.0209984649,
-0.0185161605,
0.080654785,
0.0076891547,
-0.0159179792,
-0.071186088,
0.0056723221,
0.0176361762,
-0.0267327763,
-0.0287035629,
-0.0113315154,
0.0273940675,
0.0014383195,
-0.038700901,
-0.0253773089,
0.0562807731,
0.0012627253,
-0.009400337,
-0.0475624055,
-0.0063163736,
-0.0258051865,
0.0000615927,
0.024477547,
0.0291939676,
0.0236024261,
-0.0372434482,
-0.0015891085,
0.015459151,
-0.0171396397,
0.0116596771,
0.0291359704,
-0.0244888552,
-0.0113965422,
-0.0234763362,
-0.0381534025,
-0.0330386348,
-0.0242631566,
0.0053564692,
0.0545313247,
0.0489099212,
-0.0162074473,
-0.0098498715,
-0.010514712,
-0.0050585247,
0.0710371286,
-0.0137544479,
-0.0202850737,
-0.080175072,
0.017662717,
0.0155670522,
-0.0265332293,
0.0043505109,
0.019057462,
0.000909087,
0.0333026387,
0.0006201857,
0.0079168845,
-0.0495050475,
0.0607577264,
0.0120857852,
-0.0389127731,
-0.0207818784,
0.0399146192,
0.0711011961,
-0.0840107352,
-0.0171746854,
0.115938887,
0.0325033478,
-0.0335907638,
0.0205281414,
0.0451076888,
0.0049456116,
0.0229839459,
0.0446232185,
-0.0906383917,
-0.0389574431,
0.0167358946,
-0.0006977699,
-0.0108306948,
-0.0339459032,
-0.0158720259,
-0.1064136475,
-0.0118987588,
0.0210149456,
-0.0051487922,
-0.0024627659,
-0.0388824642,
-0.0191775709,
-0.0121706408,
0.0075667091,
-0.0079131508,
0.0206595007,
-0.0103605203,
0.0106061837,
0.0150125837,
-0.0712748393,
0.0372808799,
-0.025541259,
0.0752597898,
0.045521196,
0.0000911004,
0.0231523179,
-0.0045806174,
0.0134953391,
-0.0358622894,
0.0292639248,
-0.0427493267,
0.0783776045,
-0.0511784106,
-0.0216770973,
0.0313592404,
0.0184690431,
-0.0610539764,
0.000376323,
-0.0178605895,
0.0764966086,
-0.0235591102,
0.011436332,
-0.0181428529,
-0.0313070714,
0.0186595544,
0.0483485386,
0.0123054236,
-0.0230607372,
-0.0279860385,
-0.0308455471,
-0.0581222661,
-0.0960802063,
-0.005066725,
0.0117289191,
0.0009687713,
-0.0171882398,
-0.0475243106,
-0.0471458361,
0.0521088168,
0.0452151932,
0.0041705216,
-0.0541671179,
0.0252076313,
-0.0035060043,
-0.0417563617,
0.0077643855,
-0.0205795188,
-0.006718155,
-0.0384210236,
-0.0240714401,
0.0619934462,
0.0194030628,
-0.0106225479,
-0.0089928443,
-0.0712571368,
-0.0520613827,
-0.0519072637,
0.0626715496,
0.0067474353,
0.0617588721,
-0.0191486087,
-0.0545636006,
0.0217332877,
0.0032898043,
-0.016170809,
0.0043065576,
0.0470046028,
0.0037270852,
0.0121539589,
0.0430271439,
-0.013136358,
0.0579829812,
0.0497245267,
0.025151087,
-0.0298989285,
0.0122209722,
0.0224538911,
-0.0439272672,
0.0230933744,
-0.0100777289,
0.0348120742,
-0.0054182555,
0.0146467024,
-0.0303367637,
0.0325235054,
-0.0410907939,
0.0016131493,
0.0206787698,
-0.0330725573,
-0.0169000328,
0.0284702051,
0.0111947088,
0.0356488973,
-0.0352992751,
0.0102798659,
0.0052154316,
0.0163299516,
0.0038254051,
0.0239358079,
-0.0590129979,
0.0102297422,
0.0079596899,
0.0141975693,
-0.0501487553,
0.0137165273,
0.0260150209,
0.0367150046,
-0.0817794725,
0.0361032821,
-0.0484138243,
-0.0043875161,
-0.0358750448,
0.0000644998,
0.060845986,
-0.0214978121,
0.0086188857,
-0.0034786887,
-0.0197941698,
-0.0136027541,
0.025112737,
-0.0010710307,
-0.0360415243,
0.0288984925,
0.0491711944,
-0.0072578965,
-0.0198489558,
0.0666600168,
-0.0173805319,
0.0778149664,
0.0187669992,
0.0189958978,
-0.0388047919,
0.0084080733,
0.0202967729,
0.0528396629,
-0.0099546695,
0.0310730524,
-0.001761318,
-0.0445990525,
0.0010391197,
0.0074813054,
0.0203528628,
0.0143142305,
0.059693113,
0.0107874414,
-0.0087573677,
-0.063921243,
-0.0240926594,
-0.0133449873,
0.00187579,
-0.0147197368,
-0.0287812669,
-6.376020214e-33,
-0.0203415025,
0.0359879509,
0.0392368138,
-0.0187775213,
-0.0025049418,
0.02981117,
-0.0250893813,
-0.0143148899,
-0.0319225378,
0.0104237963,
-0.0140579119,
-0.0027726528,
0.0161798559,
0.0203900076,
0.004580894,
-0.0089749759,
0.061267186,
-0.0263343472,
-0.0305281952,
0.0337685384,
0.0387112573,
0.0279157888,
0.0819322839,
-0.022880882,
-0.0282889921,
0.0053674132,
-0.0111458534,
0.0042277365,
0.0507608652,
0.0180574302,
-0.0067302659,
0.0565316565,
0.0324828327,
-0.0685151368,
-0.0228613131,
0.0260080211,
-0.095726788,
-0.0394327268,
0.0002677126,
0.0064837625,
-0.0291112438,
-0.0806976929,
0.0264523961,
0.023817813,
-0.0254091881,
-0.0279263053,
-0.004508236,
-0.0170643218,
-0.0184168871,
-0.0503843538,
-0.0815073475,
-0.0085258428,
-0.0066402499,
-0.0286737643,
0.0288209692,
0.0166361686,
-0.0024296418,
-0.0141032049,
-0.0821917951,
0.0093496107,
0.0056428821,
0.0848819762,
0.0261846501,
0.0063338936,
1.128e-7,
0.0282908306,
0.0416835099,
0.0119618168,
-0.0004227911,
0.0629714876,
0.0558314919,
0.0359379947,
0.0106150638,
-0.0091799507,
0.0979812965,
-0.0070048952,
-0.0681708232,
-0.0252625421,
0.0121862078,
0.015181629,
0.023064388,
0.0143882213,
-0.0546114668,
-0.0086256899,
-0.0374890678,
-0.0132384878,
-0.0234648939,
-0.0636432245,
0.0248044115,
0.0404558852,
0.0015009294,
0.0545871444,
0.0612001009,
-0.0625514239,
0.0208585374,
0.030676499,
0.0069561666,
0.0219969843,
0.0086349724,
0.0085994704,
-0.0739314333,
-0.0584689379,
0.0269610826,
0.0023014341,
0.0385975912,
0.0062482064,
0.0414099507,
0.0597723834,
-0.0701499358,
-0.0386038981,
-0.0429160632,
-0.010347818,
0.0081781698,
0.0805922523,
0.0043361709,
0.0300280303,
-0.0176321063,
0.0582346506,
-0.0258457996,
-0.0436402895,
0.0098543921,
0.0174303818,
0.0247108527,
0.0219605137,
-0.0293378476,
0.0149992444,
-0.0370947793,
-0.0172127783,
0.024539765,
-0.0673593953,
-0.0376018248,
0.0423450284,
2.747e-7,
0.0073368317,
0.0437560193,
0.0240740292,
0.0091305077,
0.0300002545,
0.0045187646,
0.0100358911,
0.0453758724,
-0.0200405847,
-0.0286455359,
0.0289377291,
0.0504554063,
0.0149379624,
-0.004838692,
-0.0800685957,
-0.0031435518,
-0.0016159519,
0.0269420203,
-0.0537188873,
-0.0103061013,
0.043337483,
0.1147866994,
0.009617514,
0.0112965163,
0.0267142132,
0.0119899577,
0.031770505,
0.0256646797,
-0.0039768759,
0.0334987044,
-0.0425845869,
0.0512099639,
-0.0215795171,
0.0107469615,
-0.0343406908,
0.0133884791,
-0.0230539106,
0.0920530334,
-0.0272914898,
-0.0801741183,
0.0125051579,
-0.0273942593,
-0.0244761426,
0.0147823272,
0.0824462026,
-0.0786753818,
-0.0298768543,
0.0109129744,
0.0097559271,
0.012742768,
-0.0131074237,
-0.0062305913,
-0.0034825192,
0.033381965,
0.0513440408,
-0.0026104371,
-0.0168460552,
-0.1103216186,
0.0203217473,
0.0398633294,
-0.0250327773,
-0.0357377455,
-0.0060042818,
-0.0374970362,
0.0533015616,
-0.0800408721,
-0.0231041573,
2.641875569e-34,
0.035368938,
-0.025753133,
0.0483408161,
0.0564689003,
0.0012737331,
0.0103325844,
-0.0629831925,
-0.0189819597,
0.0324277952,
-0.093365036,
-0.0580692217
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10313v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10313v2 | Beyond Triplet: Leveraging the Most Data for Multimodal Machine Translation | 2022-12-20T15:02:38 | 2023-09-03T03:46:05 | Yaoming Zhu, Zewei Sun, Shanbo Cheng, Luyang Huang, Liwei Wu, Mingxuan Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multimodal machine translation (MMT) aims to improve translation quality by
incorporating information from other modalities, such as vision. Previous MMT
systems mainly focus on better access and use of visual information and tend to
validate their methods on image-related datasets. These studies face two
challenges. First, they can only utilize triple data (bilingual texts with
images), which is scarce; second, current benchmarks are relatively restricted
and do not correspond to realistic scenarios. Therefore, this paper
correspondingly establishes new methods and new datasets for MMT. First, we
propose a framework 2/3-Triplet with two new approaches to enhance MMT by
utilizing large-scale non-triple data: monolingual image-text data and parallel
text-only data. Second, we construct an English-Chinese {e}-commercial
{m}ulti{m}odal {t}ranslation dataset (including training and testing), named
EMMT, where its test set is carefully selected as some words are ambiguous and
shall be translated mistakenly without the help of images. Experiments show
that our method is more suitable for real-world scenarios and can significantly
improve translation performance by using more non-triple data. In addition, our
model also rivals various SOTA models in conventional multimodal translation
benchmarks. | [
0.0184482858,
0.0409563035,
0.0081180995,
0.064681828,
-0.0275950897,
0.006597871,
0.0338526927,
0.0098644402,
-0.0277233552,
-0.0450804122,
-0.0655482188,
-0.0318471529,
0.0354962759,
-0.0250591859,
0.061577674,
-0.0783920065,
0.0254012626,
-0.0140087306,
-0.0468034111,
0.0021906402,
0.0315135866,
0.0218282398,
0.0077614672,
-0.0024939543,
-0.0349423699,
-0.0034208235,
-0.0013100018,
0.0873461589,
0.0250191577,
-0.0314751752,
-0.0372820459,
0.0255918298,
0.0462286286,
0.0573594384,
0.000002038,
-0.0182150882,
-0.0434004739,
0.0125586651,
0.0617204085,
0.0025256914,
0.074287504,
-0.0759420991,
-0.0008018161,
0.0119882934,
-0.0107663423,
0.0027269886,
0.0586369745,
0.0212792568,
0.0657273307,
0.0670549273,
-0.0397959538,
-0.0180004239,
-0.0153412651,
-0.0279615,
0.0022406911,
-0.0232613496,
-0.0286415555,
0.0285738967,
-0.0396114215,
0.0207688641,
-0.0357360728,
0.0543812849,
0.00146285,
0.0236101393,
-0.0276474785,
0.009108996,
-0.0388932861,
-0.0311778896,
-0.0331376046,
0.1054099649,
-0.046815481,
0.0243958496,
-0.0253439341,
0.002671496,
-0.0415973403,
-0.0106055578,
-0.0100353714,
0.0121200858,
-0.0231557768,
-0.0035496266,
-0.0564448498,
0.0255077556,
0.0419907123,
-0.0030182421,
-0.0199776124,
-0.0097081279,
0.0317902192,
-0.008177219,
-0.0159813724,
0.0114412233,
-0.0218383446,
0.0274957828,
0.0387054086,
-0.0347005166,
0.0099599659,
0.0163460784,
-0.0476350002,
-0.0662659854,
-0.0132183861,
-0.0418404266,
0.0314407833,
0.0565017015,
-0.0538825095,
0.07697355,
-0.020874083,
0.0046690321,
-0.0467072912,
0.0342315063,
-0.0616930276,
-0.0111191692,
-0.016990507,
0.0270784292,
-0.0499946885,
-0.0363019407,
-0.0465029404,
-0.0180007871,
-0.0135409022,
0.0042333561,
0.0196343437,
-0.0139284283,
0.0245777816,
-0.0205467269,
-0.0622640587,
-0.044714801,
-0.0204847604,
0.0579141267,
0.0116589144,
0.0080586197,
-0.0093529215,
-0.0439025909,
-0.0084237326,
0.0441382416,
0.012032914,
-0.0386637338,
-0.0131172901,
0.1151777133,
-0.045752272,
-0.0398924723,
-0.0135230534,
-0.0082588075,
-0.0209969375,
-0.0558033735,
0.0186711047,
-0.0367280617,
0.0817094296,
-0.0054940595,
0.049473241,
0.0030681633,
-0.0074944147,
-0.0074953656,
-0.0064161238,
0.1192712337,
-0.0194659811,
-0.0102568818,
0.0246256478,
0.0183263551,
-0.0108822556,
0.0686895698,
0.0522504225,
0.0463469326,
0.0572973229,
0.0103026209,
-0.0042568892,
0.0722645223,
-0.0089152418,
0.0352097601,
-0.0207709279,
-0.0002141778,
0.0014789172,
0.0420153737,
0.0324466452,
0.0567434132,
-0.0471201167,
0.0192812048,
0.0955815762,
-0.0010825053,
0.0034041815,
0.0152300317,
0.0446594991,
0.0009621457,
0.0013028565,
0.0114992028,
-0.0190778673,
0.0342639275,
0.0107260086,
0.0060230792,
0.0626265854,
0.0589978136,
-0.0183871873,
-0.0204272624,
-0.0036215123,
-0.018237913,
-0.0004971863,
-0.0182948746,
0.0215689447,
0.0051057311,
-0.0662522614,
0.0188508704,
-0.0139035676,
-0.0487645939,
0.0290278718,
0.0006848181,
-0.053636767,
0.0790180489,
0.060710147,
-0.0035395205,
0.0205322839,
-0.0003388319,
0.0187187772,
0.0549596399,
0.046052143,
0.0287632868,
0.0633033514,
-0.0736521557,
-0.0405916199,
0.0306617916,
-0.0116402879,
0.0398543775,
-0.0012762039,
0.0400747396,
0.024048239,
-0.022250291,
-0.0090461969,
0.0201611724,
0.0145215085,
0.0110988598,
0.0091278208,
0.030548308,
0.0185740609,
0.0114264591,
-0.0371397585,
-0.0204674192,
-0.0142790992,
-0.0139603149,
-0.0046605114,
0.0466961972,
-0.028779231,
-0.0470611826,
0.0102552632,
-0.0564752184,
-0.0210524965,
0.0133523867,
-0.0482202619,
-0.0437619053,
-0.0332688242,
-0.038906008,
-0.0171944033,
-0.0529468283,
0.0162953474,
0.029306693,
0.0308854133,
-0.0325004645,
0.0171649065,
-0.0251884237,
-0.0265480727,
0.0031699496,
-0.0022056941,
0.029515693,
-0.0165033545,
-0.0459934548,
0.0436723046,
0.0360356085,
0.0676540583,
0.0156973749,
0.0201920103,
-0.0404161736,
-0.0276088677,
-0.082562007,
-0.0016352325,
-0.0165992696,
0.0109139998,
0.0207587201,
0.0300707091,
0.0075658951,
-0.0132034346,
-0.0051933494,
0.0582098439,
-0.0023095475,
0.0123254312,
0.0267078411,
-0.0081193494,
0.0253878795,
-0.0082790079,
-0.0023456817,
0.0144275492,
0.0246519074,
-0.003486132,
-0.0381502807,
-0.0393566415,
-0.0170860905,
-0.0543184876,
0.0120464116,
-0.0103949169,
-0.0388097577,
0.0057453704,
-0.0372741371,
0.0452778079,
0.0224147681,
-0.0161468983,
-0.0251624975,
0.0196262822,
-0.0292758308,
-0.0252550002,
0.0184331331,
0.0198704042,
-0.0237931181,
0.003323575,
-0.040543247,
-0.0143232886,
0.0052000596,
0.0343860798,
0.0171262305,
-0.049626682,
-0.0130676525,
0.0253605992,
-0.0240141023,
-0.0305465274,
0.0592473261,
0.0185280126,
0.02121507,
-0.04336055,
-0.0643530488,
0.0476243272,
-0.0561927259,
-0.0220685191,
-0.0270263925,
0.0579431653,
-0.0360114314,
0.0570123792,
0.0032170988,
0.0288445204,
-0.0300644729,
0.0098795788,
-0.0281674266,
0.0019197216,
0.0347485133,
-0.0240860023,
0.0345076807,
-0.0838337392,
0.000464697,
-0.0371438824,
-0.0058908132,
0.0108097214,
-0.0023397456,
-0.0100020291,
-0.0305706896,
-0.0241699796,
-0.0097014299,
-0.0415215902,
0.0149938036,
0.0266654436,
0.0796720088,
0.0073928004,
-0.0289810132,
-0.0268290099,
0.0421038643,
-0.0231557917,
0.0209480934,
-0.0357892998,
-0.0720846727,
0.0129183512,
0.0291881245,
-0.0053973617,
-0.0436057337,
-0.0423867777,
0.011248081,
0.0267125983,
0.0453053638,
-0.0310827736,
-0.015172001,
0.0531798974,
-0.0428005345,
0.0312005114,
0.0532671027,
-0.0050995597,
-0.0502691567,
-0.0372000299,
0.0295797344,
0.025952043,
0.0051684221,
0.0043257,
-0.1011181921,
-0.0593691617,
-0.0239394344,
0.0184727851,
0.0472550318,
0.0229831859,
-0.0559171326,
-0.0446029678,
0.0358742066,
0.041856695,
-0.0606252886,
-0.0453841574,
0.0141664427,
-0.0256707985,
-0.0389458388,
0.013926276,
-0.0174521934,
0.0211335849,
-0.0030263925,
-0.0145820649,
0.0522411987,
-0.0571578033,
-0.0119669307,
-0.0490167588,
-0.024951607,
0.024811333,
0.0323160402,
-0.0082318084,
-0.028076537,
0.0251184888,
0.0283421613,
0.0048939385,
-0.0147450678,
0.033798635,
-0.0289446395,
-0.0255046431,
0.015689563,
-0.0039450787,
-0.0105689084,
0.0198034812,
0.0212323796,
0.0251537804,
-0.0058386028,
0.0260949209,
-0.0035468619,
-0.0184393805,
-0.0068063401,
0.0273417793,
-0.0241099056,
-0.0581506938,
0.0160715673,
-0.0229984783,
-0.006871603,
-0.0696436539,
-0.0014214178,
0.003612526,
-0.0758005977,
-0.0173748694,
-0.0873037651,
-0.026242217,
-0.0150726214,
0.0642386749,
0.0174254905,
0.0025939909,
0.0047104247,
0.0442793109,
-0.0114965132,
0.036517296,
-0.0397942439,
0.0345200263,
-0.0198517628,
0.0314888209,
0.0087634763,
-0.0439881645,
0.039991755,
0.0407650061,
-0.0979914591,
-0.0405720919,
-0.0556786619,
0.0601768754,
0.0134194745,
0.025434684,
0.0037916035,
-0.0322567075,
-0.0030942718,
0.019491462,
0.0020598988,
-0.0062808609,
0.0026855529,
-0.0004622988,
-0.0154030267,
0.0142960027,
0.0039039697,
-0.0175839104,
-0.0225584283,
0.0324646756,
-0.0140385646,
-0.0183797851,
0.0113195274,
0.0128283426,
0.0236506406,
-0.0451939702,
0.0105932252,
-0.040218249,
0.0083972635,
-0.0226267893,
-0.0409088321,
-0.0779920518,
-0.0162523873,
0.0510485135,
-0.0047715204,
-0.0212142654,
0.0084622204,
-0.0011949891,
-0.019044932,
-0.0011488755,
-0.0094903521,
-0.0164166614,
0.0100397365,
-0.0105309682,
0.017552834,
0.0096514234,
0.0400246568,
-0.032202214,
0.0084947683,
-0.0284514446,
0.0891924948,
-0.0097923968,
-0.0024107571,
0.0216935929,
0.0625640303,
0.0070435163,
0.0117688794,
-0.0369111598,
0.0298623443,
0.0875012651,
0.0219180938,
0.1065753996,
-0.027816968,
-0.0106900055,
-0.0381273329,
0.0730450749,
0.0171930697,
-0.0187346339,
0.014732562,
-0.0203225594,
0.0094255498,
0.0219564326,
0.0659098774,
-0.0103043802,
-0.0120674307,
-0.0039047764,
-0.0250036642,
-0.032921683,
-0.0031290723,
0.0524218976,
-0.0168593712,
-0.0054593869,
-0.0181815773,
-0.0082604503,
-0.0406042188,
-0.0223703906,
0.036825221,
-0.0152388373,
0.0199177302,
0.0174874645,
0.084683232,
-0.0216590893,
0.0146855274,
-0.0436785333,
-0.0099223508,
0.000239717,
-0.0095318137,
0.0100084562,
-5.838539014e-33,
-0.007277824,
-0.0335933901,
0.0134343561,
-0.0537035614,
-0.0505118705,
0.0250918809,
-0.0048037726,
0.0161891785,
0.0005138376,
-0.0072994833,
0.0234016944,
-0.0021887058,
0.0234085061,
0.0187217016,
-0.02607999,
0.0339138359,
0.0265472457,
-0.020859329,
-0.0303127393,
-0.0100102471,
0.027497109,
0.0119075375,
0.0832257494,
-0.0560556613,
0.016398916,
-0.0067435908,
-0.0701402873,
0.0035569358,
0.0094268965,
0.0189451221,
-0.0031967056,
0.024648454,
0.0122380089,
-0.0083863093,
-0.0318479203,
-0.0306745637,
-0.0799991935,
0.0320326276,
0.0170536879,
0.0757004023,
-0.0639447495,
-0.004803278,
0.0547039472,
-0.0583407804,
0.0208749808,
-0.0273083448,
0.0120261945,
-0.0521414354,
-0.0358220637,
-0.0027603805,
-0.0322415233,
0.0408297591,
0.0041458663,
-0.0140916621,
0.0327096768,
0.07336317,
0.0210762713,
0.0152365547,
-0.074119091,
0.0075094365,
-0.0460039973,
0.000771515,
0.0831945091,
0.0120990714,
-0.0146443462,
0.0125277489,
0.0334714092,
-0.0200975779,
0.0217315666,
-0.003059607,
0.0274902154,
0.033134494,
0.0546705201,
0.0866316557,
0.0204922836,
0.0075642569,
-0.0307056215,
0.0643284321,
-0.0292031225,
-0.0132255349,
0.017080551,
0.0130418083,
-0.0051411092,
0.0120808799,
-0.0464186817,
-0.0370328799,
-0.0424052738,
-0.0221984554,
0.0027280515,
0.0309116915,
-0.026631115,
0.0079864152,
0.0896750689,
-0.0063945367,
-0.0104497364,
-0.0102908844,
-0.0303267837,
0.0352165215,
-0.0258130226,
0.0346197858,
-0.005250514,
-0.0601910278,
0.0278540105,
0.0334977508,
0.0076688956,
-0.0322579928,
0.0432368405,
0.0387055613,
-0.0401719101,
0.0110331755,
-0.0333134085,
-0.0440449081,
-0.0169956088,
0.019500548,
0.03280662,
-0.0241015889,
-0.0324106254,
0.0255640298,
0.0328390673,
-0.0205317214,
-0.0397042483,
-0.0483459085,
0.011404857,
0.0299995001,
-0.0284176059,
0.0391698405,
-0.0366693437,
-0.0769009739,
0.0313679986,
-0.0573369898,
-0.0334928632,
0.0314412825,
2.623e-7,
0.051986292,
0.0271681435,
0.0090587232,
0.0233294275,
0.0216067061,
0.0387833789,
-0.0479472578,
0.0643305033,
-0.0244823582,
0.0039094822,
0.0351484232,
0.0284819901,
0.0891445726,
0.0322575867,
-0.0131517556,
-0.0427020751,
-0.0135100279,
0.0264361501,
-0.0483919755,
-0.005643684,
0.078397423,
0.0824641958,
-0.025096247,
-0.0257559065,
0.006110122,
-0.0428982638,
0.1055033952,
0.0002719495,
-0.0354718007,
-0.0040153549,
0.0493148081,
0.0368004702,
-0.0777101889,
-0.0067596575,
-0.010033017,
-0.0329718962,
0.0796344802,
0.0664770529,
0.008307403,
-0.0185631923,
0.020936491,
-0.0010570744,
-0.0502037853,
-0.0140772704,
0.0582959354,
0.0117969867,
-0.0051140147,
0.0355009101,
-0.0013545357,
0.0295916889,
0.0702029467,
-0.0387807898,
-0.0692053363,
0.0383909643,
0.0649577007,
-0.0048757517,
-0.0517254546,
-0.0268111918,
-0.0373518243,
-0.0300461743,
-0.0254175663,
-0.0476884916,
-0.0296844225,
-0.0221885536,
0.0176101364,
-0.0312981941,
-0.0291938055,
1.856657396e-34,
0.0459740423,
-0.0643201098,
0.0205745064,
-0.0528576262,
0.0306601971,
-0.0225256067,
-0.0066538528,
-0.0309627634,
-0.0306496043,
-0.0296170451,
-0.0352336764
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10297v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10297v2 | Extrinsic Evaluation of Machine Translation Metrics | 2022-12-20T14:39:58 | 2023-06-19T03:59:55 | Nikita Moghe, Tom Sherborne, Mark Steedman, Alexandra Birch | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Automatic machine translation (MT) metrics are widely used to distinguish the
translation qualities of machine translation systems across relatively large
test sets (system-level evaluation). However, it is unclear if automatic
metrics are reliable at distinguishing good translations from bad translations
at the sentence level (segment-level evaluation). In this paper, we investigate
how useful MT metrics are at detecting the success of a machine translation
component when placed in a larger platform with a downstream task. We evaluate
the segment-level performance of the most widely used MT metrics (chrF, COMET,
BERTScore, etc.) on three downstream cross-lingual tasks (dialogue state
tracking, question answering, and semantic parsing). For each task, we only
have access to a monolingual task-specific model. We calculate the correlation
between the metric's ability to predict a good/bad translation with the
success/failure on the final task for the Translate-Test setup. Our experiments
demonstrate that all metrics exhibit negligible correlation with the extrinsic
evaluation of the downstream outcomes. We also find that the scores provided by
neural metrics are not interpretable mostly because of undefined ranges. We
synthesise our analysis into recommendations for future MT metrics to produce
labels rather than scores for more informative interaction between machine
translation and multilingual language understanding. | [
0.0065230718,
0.011204022,
-0.0125068994,
0.0320924297,
-0.0350266248,
0.0170158762,
0.0184372477,
-0.0068653468,
-0.0228061192,
-0.021568317,
-0.0602292046,
-0.0535952337,
0.0404222272,
0.0069746724,
0.0333447494,
-0.0415668525,
0.047414016,
-0.0023669202,
-0.0242389552,
0.0454499796,
-0.0082704844,
0.0005913283,
-0.0055091442,
0.0763409734,
0.0167537257,
-0.0150421765,
0.0211992096,
0.0443672985,
0.047095038,
-0.0064419904,
-0.0113367876,
0.0064697694,
0.002558073,
0.0727609023,
0.0000018286,
-0.0595672727,
-0.0155376922,
0.0164847001,
-0.0064562275,
-0.0295528192,
0.0244021825,
-0.0542016141,
-0.0071552997,
0.005159663,
-0.033534769,
0.0006461118,
0.023316754,
-0.0019279646,
0.0750019327,
0.0654514655,
-0.0068470365,
-0.0035017601,
-0.0118183531,
-0.0286435951,
-0.0153473709,
-0.0555200167,
-0.0445384569,
0.0147480285,
-0.0417885147,
-0.00713591,
-0.0127726616,
0.0598831065,
0.0355373286,
-0.002007019,
-0.0073277997,
-0.0050928365,
-0.0347078852,
-0.0301914811,
-0.0182502195,
0.0657910109,
-0.0238533113,
-0.0119748926,
-0.0386552922,
-0.0090401405,
-0.0059846225,
-0.0402691141,
-0.0466286168,
-0.0178131498,
-0.0023500361,
-0.0133089097,
0.0046236683,
0.0433484949,
0.0244520139,
-0.0112252655,
-0.0275875162,
0.0315709226,
0.0157463867,
-0.0290406123,
0.0037996483,
0.0148616591,
-0.006497703,
-0.0310234353,
0.054249689,
-0.0030492705,
-0.0449553467,
0.0210716948,
-0.0228821803,
-0.0508741401,
0.0175681114,
-0.0526962616,
0.0273138471,
0.073086895,
-0.027496988,
0.0492989384,
-0.0301521309,
0.1104619354,
-0.0234195944,
0.0373882577,
-0.0792352706,
-0.0323660895,
-0.0488587916,
0.0223862994,
-0.0349205285,
-0.0191782508,
-0.0140760047,
-0.023565786,
-0.0278602783,
0.016492201,
0.010894605,
0.0224704631,
0.0295020379,
-0.034255594,
-0.0574429035,
-0.0057389173,
-0.0179813635,
0.0639267117,
-0.0517210662,
-0.03308082,
0.026583489,
-0.0278662723,
-0.0154317133,
0.0224583801,
-0.05271478,
-0.0368801355,
-0.0087893754,
0.1138494536,
-0.0000628088,
-0.0247407332,
0.0332143754,
-0.0183571614,
-0.0175639763,
-0.0666864738,
-0.0078871697,
-0.0251318272,
0.0546798669,
0.0266562216,
0.0107027059,
0.0055447905,
-0.0020903454,
0.0056363014,
0.0030549525,
0.0427601486,
0.0340422802,
-0.004972511,
0.0163819939,
-0.0097154053,
-0.0300257951,
0.0740724578,
0.0640417114,
0.0410153829,
0.0680817366,
0.0098497653,
-0.0225420576,
0.0470748469,
0.0025043322,
0.0194141399,
-0.0356525071,
0.0306148212,
-0.0022576053,
0.0390735678,
-0.0125058955,
0.0382245742,
-0.0261360593,
0.0195423309,
0.0632239729,
0.0235136617,
0.0292593036,
0.0179247037,
0.0618418008,
-0.0082778623,
-0.0169833899,
0.0145828929,
-0.0262698084,
0.031729877,
0.0250508953,
-0.0144427754,
0.0473856367,
0.0310238674,
-0.0078311404,
-0.0501821451,
-0.00910246,
-0.0105300145,
0.0051498236,
0.003601423,
0.0521300398,
0.0273763333,
-0.0470686331,
0.0488055833,
-0.0369853973,
-0.0392498374,
0.0443721749,
-0.0444286466,
-0.0174239911,
0.058747448,
0.051398363,
-0.0040280246,
-0.0470216684,
-0.0182019845,
-0.0097429911,
0.0328728668,
0.0712584034,
0.0075148032,
0.0490687527,
-0.0428505354,
-0.0164394733,
-0.0009977138,
0.0102445902,
0.0095364237,
0.0019848661,
0.0226031933,
0.0381973311,
-0.0958287418,
-0.0487697944,
0.0396178178,
0.0161626264,
-0.0042506522,
0.0424775481,
0.0254139621,
0.0104877902,
0.0229137018,
-0.0017772808,
0.0075025624,
0.0252930764,
-0.0363293439,
-0.01425895,
0.0460526943,
-0.0191106163,
-0.0432772972,
-0.0031540825,
-0.0343607962,
-0.0213832371,
0.0302879531,
-0.0438976698,
-0.0498708524,
-0.0026982019,
-0.0604390018,
-0.0113563985,
-0.0295661297,
0.0243139174,
-0.0161704067,
-0.0050728549,
-0.0494075194,
0.0161047969,
0.0033779473,
0.021701118,
-0.0176648833,
-0.0189424139,
0.0638069808,
-0.0037902715,
-0.0312415678,
0.0132660344,
-0.0292272549,
0.0065119672,
0.0506461933,
0.0184135847,
-0.0649638101,
-0.0273870975,
-0.0802868381,
0.0620696396,
-0.0378317274,
0.0476938859,
0.0714961141,
0.0331462696,
0.0224997103,
-0.0114999395,
-0.0307630338,
-0.0143432906,
0.0365283079,
0.0179964267,
0.0295611359,
0.0252809972,
-0.0048548579,
-0.0199430622,
-0.015656773,
-0.0100013828,
0.0616964139,
0.008482567,
-0.0043670195,
-0.0905967951,
-0.0075844401,
-0.0537115857,
-0.0222916212,
-0.0079409946,
-0.078087166,
0.0248521585,
0.0032330756,
0.0175440609,
0.0644593239,
-0.0076371431,
-0.0086855562,
0.021383943,
-0.0055425023,
-0.0541609786,
0.0059184618,
-0.0320150033,
-0.0239157472,
-0.0128009859,
-0.0341906026,
0.0119046122,
0.0367626697,
0.0245171487,
0.0026515755,
-0.0624660701,
-0.0094585763,
-0.0525837615,
-0.0316633508,
-0.0249779671,
0.0163547695,
0.0147767263,
0.0609211288,
-0.0209253803,
-0.0515562072,
0.0918736458,
-0.0281889085,
-0.0287297089,
-0.0536967814,
-0.0057062176,
-0.0517322905,
0.0641387403,
-0.0206943322,
0.0194972381,
-0.0404782966,
-0.0358402468,
-0.0263241734,
0.0058225873,
-0.0053908899,
-0.0160084739,
0.0292444695,
-0.0653390586,
-0.0423658825,
-0.0103246681,
-0.009078227,
-0.0201414432,
0.00163507,
0.0260032825,
0.0168790873,
0.0205561556,
0.0080979774,
-0.0245052576,
0.0277858172,
0.0420480333,
0.0297652092,
-0.0348064862,
-0.007490247,
-0.0073843943,
0.0323492847,
-0.0015515821,
0.0054872874,
0.0487977676,
-0.058663886,
0.0369505174,
-0.0121317161,
0.0362993293,
-0.021863088,
-0.0304787625,
-0.0289533697,
0.0128642004,
-0.012085909,
-0.0276604258,
0.0034342508,
0.1011340395,
-0.0559426099,
-0.0442570448,
0.0941650644,
0.0185077898,
-0.0378989279,
-0.0126367873,
-0.0149319461,
0.0114199435,
0.0270225164,
0.0150927762,
-0.0643444732,
-0.0222254228,
0.0020815642,
0.0365691446,
0.0371058621,
0.0221252292,
-0.0061548091,
-0.0555981658,
0.0002385233,
0.0053833751,
-0.0766338482,
-0.0288784876,
-0.028703291,
-0.0024205658,
-0.027015144,
0.0254868995,
-0.0270412676,
0.0446288958,
-0.011487769,
-0.0045397994,
0.0016067412,
-0.0203270242,
0.0218779333,
-0.0483231246,
-0.0142498715,
0.1095851436,
0.0549750738,
-0.0008316915,
-0.0203321297,
0.0463595465,
-0.0441758409,
0.0097863395,
0.0157994442,
0.031637039,
0.0276776906,
-0.0287035815,
-0.0032746661,
-0.04660777,
-0.0009757432,
0.049018003,
-0.0033971029,
0.0545698889,
-0.0127918338,
0.0136154499,
0.0151039278,
0.0024314434,
0.0043515097,
0.0694203377,
0.0310531482,
-0.0387877449,
-0.0225574113,
-0.0014688111,
0.0023291488,
-0.081701301,
0.0239657704,
0.0147140957,
-0.0351922736,
-0.0259250607,
-0.0918881744,
-0.0814612955,
0.0149308862,
0.0201187581,
0.0125405584,
-0.002720682,
-0.020659579,
0.0157479178,
0.0136564272,
0.0409602188,
-0.0122925416,
0.0304608513,
-0.0366996899,
0.0233161692,
0.0090650721,
0.0084530097,
-0.0131934797,
0.054855112,
-0.0765500441,
-0.0400198437,
-0.0418938957,
0.0787640065,
0.0245597921,
0.0046917275,
-0.052879449,
-0.0002394635,
-0.0121583641,
-0.0247187428,
-0.041396074,
-0.0149658779,
0.0283864755,
0.0110189449,
-0.0396331996,
0.0547541529,
-0.0308216177,
-0.0156038813,
-0.0209116861,
0.0659926161,
-0.0046781218,
-0.077689372,
0.0189234558,
0.012103674,
0.0562206805,
-0.0385507941,
-0.0323100388,
0.0096502844,
0.0240776297,
-0.0016033837,
-0.0199949443,
-0.0509781465,
-0.0314524956,
0.0591787696,
-0.0126918443,
-0.0025656873,
0.0539587326,
-0.0130315274,
-0.0185253918,
-0.024880765,
-0.0195068885,
-0.0224287864,
0.0403969847,
-0.0108346343,
0.0356887132,
-0.0447206274,
-0.0220767166,
0.0081537189,
0.038169384,
-0.0394166298,
0.0730719417,
0.017859675,
0.0268039946,
0.0426116884,
0.0654634684,
-0.0433437414,
-0.0151120257,
-0.0097630145,
-0.0033596065,
0.0556832962,
0.0185565036,
0.1197395101,
0.0351887047,
-0.0114113372,
-0.0103272609,
0.0567595065,
0.0147798201,
-0.026473945,
-0.0157542489,
-0.0067974045,
0.0202764478,
0.0018732117,
0.0420069806,
-0.051067315,
0.0078601986,
-0.005176208,
-0.0192394424,
-0.0375548191,
-0.0108146863,
-0.0159589499,
-0.0289049055,
-0.0120184207,
-0.0124854641,
-0.0276717208,
-0.055073984,
0.0102268057,
0.0406747907,
0.0205799043,
0.0030407836,
0.012968435,
0.0999281406,
-0.0347839482,
-0.0094892755,
-0.0482090227,
-0.0127050672,
-0.0133036403,
0.0125294896,
-0.0446092039,
-5.725295929e-33,
-0.0498202257,
-0.0137899332,
0.0102963299,
-0.0366969965,
-0.0392516442,
-0.0214333758,
-0.0488895103,
-0.0297119562,
-0.0064673699,
0.0127690677,
0.0190048199,
0.0003372089,
0.0156283658,
-0.0157774501,
-0.0030502903,
-0.0321242437,
0.0492701679,
0.0091308383,
-0.0565675832,
0.0122246053,
0.0452461541,
0.013079429,
0.0877475217,
-0.055195529,
0.0699370801,
-0.007893051,
-0.0166098196,
0.0356766023,
0.0025098599,
0.0388904698,
0.0144854328,
0.0215571839,
0.0364727601,
-0.0687266514,
-0.0167530514,
0.0023317484,
-0.0796490982,
-0.0173817948,
0.0399479009,
0.0493142605,
-0.0369605124,
-0.0177475996,
0.0298682563,
-0.0404139385,
0.0028362942,
0.0084533105,
0.0266739633,
-0.034757629,
-0.0144390743,
-0.0278591216,
-0.0558607839,
0.0027317358,
-0.030560039,
-0.0546850972,
0.0051085316,
0.1251850575,
-0.0237784516,
-0.0085708965,
-0.0433970988,
-0.0231554788,
-0.0450436361,
0.022108376,
0.0696333721,
0.0197563767,
-0.0353374071,
0.012509401,
0.0166040193,
0.0008349316,
0.027586041,
-0.0279290415,
0.0505531691,
-0.0147388009,
0.078438282,
0.0175615866,
0.014180827,
0.0243544672,
-0.0824861005,
0.0643606484,
0.0064068427,
0.0222196113,
0.0001793755,
0.0050139586,
-0.02388978,
0.0120557062,
-0.0507107191,
-0.0307141822,
-0.0478606485,
-0.0412496068,
0.0255959816,
0.0159036014,
-0.0046803625,
0.0030044913,
0.0731440336,
-0.0149360411,
0.0546639003,
0.0164710954,
-0.0074801976,
-0.0060308101,
0.0059259268,
0.0380924642,
-0.0040041693,
-0.0042294092,
0.0051150825,
0.0371563435,
0.0412910022,
-0.0467176363,
0.0551992878,
-0.0029024167,
-0.0141378678,
0.0299362969,
-0.0568452999,
0.0236382131,
-0.0401765108,
0.0217802394,
0.0136435675,
-0.0066825049,
-0.0472865775,
0.051257804,
0.0224863123,
0.0077116694,
-0.0334258825,
0.0193866324,
0.024696799,
0.0292905066,
-0.0766719729,
-0.0031249563,
-0.031897366,
0.0391678326,
0.0062907902,
-0.0465009883,
-0.0359682515,
0.0145162176,
2.541e-7,
0.0620651431,
0.063978903,
0.0106843198,
0.0457784832,
0.0025800834,
0.0307251122,
-0.0525944307,
0.0115303537,
0.0264479108,
0.0011013723,
0.0037655078,
0.002489158,
0.0878365934,
0.0517096557,
-0.0631159842,
-0.0302708689,
-0.0432876758,
0.0310881641,
-0.026242204,
0.0386389531,
0.0625867099,
0.0625377744,
-0.017796725,
0.0288507808,
-0.0286589563,
-0.0378256626,
0.0653751343,
-0.0188158341,
-0.0274420474,
0.0063094771,
0.0282153003,
0.0345324166,
-0.0337211415,
0.0225519594,
-0.0095328586,
0.0168655608,
0.051385887,
0.0591214858,
0.016753681,
-0.0563784689,
-0.009165057,
-0.0184816103,
0.0154684214,
-0.0640579164,
0.0515272282,
-0.0478107296,
-0.0027457767,
-0.0004958143,
0.0036225193,
0.0120496675,
0.0671068206,
-0.0463353992,
-0.0450672619,
0.0250217766,
0.041176375,
0.0003038078,
-0.0049618059,
-0.0468625687,
-0.0502741858,
0.0142354453,
-0.0065267067,
-0.0492794774,
-0.0311801955,
0.0101802368,
-0.0142163318,
-0.0473954603,
0.0105826063,
2.048332426e-34,
0.0406017937,
-0.0150858378,
0.018367406,
-0.0220253579,
0.0538130142,
-0.034906771,
-0.022162281,
-0.0263876636,
0.013029648,
-0.0469471477,
-0.0169345438
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10264v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10264v1 | ReCode: Robustness Evaluation of Code Generation Models | 2022-12-20T14:11:31 | 2022-12-20T14:11:31 | Shiqi Wang, Zheng Li, Haifeng Qian, Chenghao Yang, Zijian Wang, Mingyue Shang, Varun Kumar, Samson Tan, Baishakhi Ray, Parminder Bhatia, Ramesh Nallapati, Murali Krishna Ramanathan, Dan Roth, Bing Xiang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.SE | Code generation models have achieved impressive performance. However, they
tend to be brittle as slight edits to a prompt could lead to very different
generations; these robustness properties, critical for user experience when
deployed in real-life applications, are not well understood. Most existing
works on robustness in text or code tasks have focused on classification, while
robustness in generation tasks is an uncharted area and to date there is no
comprehensive benchmark for robustness in code generation. In this paper, we
propose ReCode, a comprehensive robustness evaluation benchmark for code
generation models. We customize over 30 transformations specifically for code
on docstrings, function and variable names, code syntax, and code format. They
are carefully designed to be natural in real-life coding practice, preserve the
original semantic meaning, and thus provide multifaceted assessments of a
model's robustness performance. With human annotators, we verified that over
90% of the perturbed prompts do not alter the semantic meaning of the original
prompt. In addition, we define robustness metrics for code generation models
considering the worst-case behavior under each type of perturbation, taking
advantage of the fact that executing the generated code can serve as objective
evaluation. We demonstrate ReCode on SOTA models using HumanEval, MBPP, as well
as function completion tasks derived from them. Interesting observations
include: better robustness for CodeGen over InCoder and GPT-J; models are most
sensitive to syntax perturbations; more challenging robustness evaluation on
MBPP over HumanEval. | [
-0.0000196183,
0.0357990153,
-0.0281351805,
-0.0216126125,
-0.0097965216,
-0.0103177885,
-0.0387587324,
0.0093525266,
0.0051263971,
-0.0029324109,
0.0022223538,
0.0359441601,
0.0068899873,
0.0470206216,
0.0297183767,
-0.0428078808,
0.045703724,
-0.0328533016,
-0.050836958,
0.0460435078,
-0.0226742737,
-0.0052663772,
0.0120551195,
0.0638497174,
0.0105300751,
-0.0312733576,
-0.0075491699,
0.0479370281,
-0.0157078579,
-0.0212383233,
0.0181802027,
0.0663121045,
-0.0299881827,
0.024863515,
0.0000023457,
-0.0456425697,
-0.0154222604,
0.0358359963,
0.0076750363,
0.0312926956,
0.0241094455,
0.0072057615,
-0.0237957723,
0.026185384,
-0.0344672427,
0.0206052214,
0.0546399876,
-0.0661199167,
0.0702270046,
0.0315226354,
0.0100650629,
0.0212943591,
0.0235496368,
0.0031721487,
0.0258255824,
-0.0240617357,
-0.0342550613,
0.017767638,
0.0343781523,
0.0074103647,
0.0271146651,
0.0009779467,
0.0415119268,
-0.0013902482,
0.0113374712,
0.0325087011,
-0.0108319838,
-0.0311603304,
0.0021583992,
0.0259878468,
-0.0429116078,
-0.0314351209,
0.0145294629,
-0.0172186047,
0.0088037383,
-0.0311032925,
-0.0125458203,
0.0158860832,
-0.0111952098,
-0.0170402639,
-0.0069609694,
0.0104120569,
0.0124702398,
-0.0195406191,
0.0274711046,
0.0266305171,
0.0216096472,
-0.0172625575,
-0.0382379629,
-0.0045118402,
-0.020008726,
-0.0476572737,
0.0014125273,
0.0263849832,
-0.0054717679,
-0.0077502658,
-0.0729628429,
-0.0523746647,
0.0493890159,
-0.0590841621,
0.0355839878,
0.0512974709,
-0.0260862578,
-0.0269433632,
-0.0714577511,
0.0681485608,
-0.0018033326,
-0.0080661532,
0.0181578994,
0.0473396815,
-0.0459383354,
-0.0039515891,
-0.0333955139,
0.0391785279,
-0.0310124792,
0.0504918806,
-0.0486267507,
0.07058236,
-0.0109863635,
0.0749723837,
-0.0162488036,
-0.0143073471,
-0.0421387404,
0.0078393053,
0.0490906127,
-0.0605020002,
-0.0303285178,
-0.0560609587,
0.0030672476,
-0.0591438077,
0.0258012246,
0.0096930731,
-0.0489211529,
-0.0184051543,
-0.0077716489,
0.0911088064,
0.0038922857,
0.030228572,
-0.0394639708,
-0.0858798772,
-0.007993646,
-0.0086923828,
-0.0215504877,
-0.0541944243,
-0.040992815,
0.0112483688,
-0.0201715678,
-0.0838708803,
0.0162770897,
0.0008285756,
0.0284259114,
0.0406342968,
-0.0682037249,
0.0191250555,
0.0049367342,
0.0207365192,
-0.0665104017,
0.0100658583,
0.0437115133,
0.0359891728,
0.0492393412,
-0.0475411527,
0.058225885,
0.0244575236,
-0.0108942511,
0.0117954155,
0.0170511883,
0.0063315206,
0.0481702536,
0.0010053967,
-0.0067425617,
0.0558778234,
-0.0108175147,
0.0017537486,
0.0183969904,
-0.0037171536,
-0.006184781,
0.0481568314,
0.084505111,
-0.0000074228,
0.0053727408,
0.0093866391,
-0.0491974354,
0.035893321,
-0.0600732565,
0.023535436,
-0.0339016691,
0.0225242954,
0.024293907,
-0.0591585822,
-0.0164193939,
-0.005293713,
-0.0103498027,
-0.0518612079,
-0.0103474362,
0.03117368,
-0.0423017703,
0.0169006214,
-0.0133691179,
-0.1196625903,
-0.0323672965,
-0.076326035,
0.0247053206,
0.0403162837,
0.0706079453,
-0.0329706371,
-0.0080063799,
-0.0101778489,
-0.0053283479,
-0.020240467,
0.0564257354,
-0.0081575755,
0.0218037069,
-0.0382167362,
0.0039196764,
-0.0065407278,
0.0214083511,
0.054985296,
0.0325647704,
-0.0544919446,
0.0530662127,
-0.0173601583,
-0.0547420271,
0.0467991792,
-0.0026982389,
-0.0217772517,
0.0351238362,
-0.0191756114,
0.0115692476,
-0.0227519106,
-0.0521117821,
0.0399294011,
0.0105145527,
0.0204739347,
0.0185884628,
0.0003645223,
-0.0225877874,
0.0117170122,
-0.0065183705,
-0.0116588175,
-0.0237324461,
0.0357017927,
-0.0148346992,
0.0107039539,
0.0374280401,
-0.0369556472,
-0.0177089591,
0.0030163829,
0.0470674187,
-0.0240699612,
-0.0314546265,
-0.0244632214,
0.0264580753,
-0.0003122915,
0.0200516395,
-0.017087806,
0.0904105976,
0.0343492143,
-0.0030092476,
-0.0376336649,
0.015621243,
-0.061999511,
0.0123502128,
0.0226620138,
0.0547032282,
0.0140508218,
-0.0780834034,
-0.094340004,
0.0099587282,
-0.0272869933,
0.02180776,
0.0392329544,
0.0302375313,
-0.0022499396,
0.0074147549,
-0.007496024,
0.0140719106,
-0.0222115945,
0.0206584726,
0.0351062641,
-0.0341604687,
-0.0524429716,
-0.0280750506,
-0.0105053764,
-0.03343454,
0.0462353416,
0.007484029,
0.0139427027,
-0.0584774986,
0.0535502508,
-0.0030417326,
0.0031069014,
0.0044349264,
-0.0496051386,
0.0383873358,
-0.0053057815,
0.0810969397,
0.0534952395,
0.0250040591,
0.018959526,
0.0398183949,
0.0264346786,
-0.0076168673,
0.0056075249,
0.0296674389,
-0.0718522146,
0.038736552,
-0.060456939,
0.0769101679,
0.066813603,
0.0122819785,
-0.012412319,
-0.0711515173,
0.0087693734,
-0.0033668927,
0.0052581765,
0.0172567703,
-0.0354305841,
-0.0256103743,
0.0456100889,
-0.0472147241,
-0.0923365131,
0.0361898877,
-0.0489479676,
0.0015643176,
0.0082789129,
-0.0137880528,
-0.0265869051,
0.0770584941,
-0.0011989211,
0.0038383296,
0.0345573239,
-0.0275246818,
-0.0295595974,
-0.0098367864,
0.029325299,
-0.0438285097,
0.0308935884,
-0.056735009,
-0.0178663004,
-0.0301658716,
-0.0396986157,
-0.0269454252,
0.0025237459,
0.027318839,
-0.0032431565,
0.0433879755,
0.0073735276,
0.0498327315,
-0.0109079266,
0.0061494904,
0.0655860975,
0.0021228029,
-0.0466685295,
-0.0215139762,
-0.0271429475,
-0.0409200639,
-0.056978859,
-0.0340869501,
-0.0034371191,
-0.0079094265,
0.0311250873,
-0.0065558041,
0.0340841077,
-0.0567589328,
-0.009371439,
0.0131377038,
-0.0219889581,
-0.0643944219,
0.0802014619,
0.0727484524,
-0.0306191929,
-0.0323346071,
0.0347948335,
0.0310195424,
0.0038503779,
0.0508260503,
-0.0242475532,
0.0920220315,
0.0569567308,
0.0417981893,
-0.0678048655,
-0.0099785822,
0.020420827,
0.0793871135,
-0.0251758508,
-0.0312234201,
0.0013829947,
-0.0743684396,
0.0445223041,
-0.0038341058,
-0.0190865211,
-0.0357305892,
-0.0029904658,
-0.0195420068,
0.0177457426,
-0.0392600521,
0.0604579076,
0.0125357518,
0.0271299183,
0.0070415693,
-0.0571903326,
0.004628662,
0.0031599901,
-0.0068847113,
0.0037036717,
0.1044730172,
-0.0064797993,
0.0401012525,
-0.0116863092,
0.0352951363,
0.0132135935,
0.0251164064,
-0.012319522,
0.0400190018,
0.0330162272,
-0.0071103103,
0.0199204497,
0.0076673394,
-0.0206626896,
-0.0407280736,
0.0170515105,
0.0109433839,
-0.0025620523,
-0.0138544766,
-0.0435599908,
-0.01499091,
0.0182153694,
0.0313810334,
0.0511036664,
-0.0092759337,
-0.0701556429,
-0.0825427622,
0.0214899164,
-0.0934972242,
0.0112084262,
-0.0477217026,
-0.0018346333,
-0.0282487608,
-0.0746152475,
0.0164677277,
-0.017012544,
0.037278112,
0.001667497,
-0.0673856214,
-0.0016990162,
0.0051157507,
-0.0776306242,
-0.0214969926,
-0.0091138128,
0.0183210392,
-0.0397849306,
-0.014407048,
0.0394567735,
-0.004168394,
-0.0046259202,
0.0285071786,
-0.0518220477,
-0.0575138777,
-0.0102847684,
0.087805517,
0.0316569693,
-0.0199099854,
-0.0483268239,
-0.028642131,
-0.0344739482,
0.030390989,
-0.0225166716,
0.0014580083,
0.0452813655,
-0.0062000304,
0.0211070664,
-0.0232339054,
-0.0638419315,
-0.0222309865,
0.0079438239,
0.005244907,
0.0097382497,
0.0126557471,
0.033751417,
0.0591664538,
-0.013954795,
-0.0138594853,
-0.0452562533,
0.02859262,
-0.0327340439,
-0.01880363,
-0.0195983145,
-0.042316176,
0.054088816,
0.0064505078,
-0.0012861219,
0.0372133814,
0.0059957728,
-0.0549761951,
0.0782085732,
-0.0010700938,
0.0217252932,
-0.0390967354,
0.0614535883,
0.0563257448,
0.0161327552,
-0.0348586179,
0.0356858335,
-0.0059680017,
0.0238554422,
-0.0119906543,
0.0393513143,
0.0067381351,
0.04425909,
0.0368651599,
0.0309733171,
-0.04021018,
-0.0030833792,
-0.0414456166,
0.0273690876,
0.0108017046,
0.0730088577,
0.0275140889,
-0.0317146443,
0.0048139021,
-0.0379248485,
0.0536124744,
-0.0059761037,
-0.0461528748,
-0.0283046942,
0.0103284298,
0.0022815582,
-0.0838017985,
0.0950517133,
-0.0055577573,
-0.0078495182,
-0.0287702829,
-0.0162796918,
-0.0545099601,
-0.0178235341,
0.035363134,
-0.014477795,
-0.0084568895,
-0.0239665247,
-0.0567238741,
-0.05137318,
0.0284568537,
0.0431299098,
0.0507806316,
0.005800426,
0.0241403598,
0.0751148015,
0.0005355466,
-0.0050145122,
-0.0301807467,
0.0191725474,
0.0061329142,
-0.0297390334,
-0.0447655097,
-5.701758491e-33,
-0.040839605,
-0.0065907896,
-0.0281413868,
0.0161907244,
0.0041517462,
-0.0314045437,
-0.0673597232,
0.0402278081,
0.0307232346,
-0.0406696461,
0.036418438,
-0.0177552141,
-0.0152955223,
-0.0269524064,
0.0181645751,
0.0075804694,
0.0437292382,
0.0156646874,
-0.0985300466,
0.0107001495,
-0.0157674756,
-0.0076177469,
-0.0240192991,
-0.0485038683,
-0.0085131712,
-0.007845222,
-0.0065559763,
-0.0270535816,
0.0002502545,
0.0533494167,
0.0211266801,
-0.0075590331,
-0.0013369004,
0.0132895149,
-0.0311815497,
0.0015375359,
-0.0094077829,
-0.0447853394,
0.0022607332,
-0.0057141283,
-0.011548317,
-0.1034436151,
0.0640556812,
-0.0120213032,
-0.0512499325,
-0.0032372326,
-0.0090562338,
0.001797142,
-0.0060852394,
-0.0670509785,
-0.0594730079,
0.0346901864,
-0.034229178,
-0.0153028267,
-0.051484663,
0.0355180949,
-0.0060348264,
0.020473564,
0.0324466899,
-0.0169971753,
0.044369746,
0.0323848501,
0.0417787433,
-0.0160595737,
0.000165842,
-0.0066842767,
0.0265189987,
0.0588789098,
-0.0478102192,
0.0436995775,
0.0224003922,
0.044275403,
0.0663461611,
0.0659155548,
0.0267406106,
-0.0264816098,
0.004349404,
0.0537119508,
-0.0175654627,
-0.0037133244,
0.0147338277,
0.0273808818,
-0.0390476547,
0.0072739804,
-0.0523158088,
-0.0366420113,
-0.0099079628,
-0.0503652431,
0.0411669984,
-0.0134180468,
-0.0337244086,
0.0103675891,
0.001148526,
-0.0057408158,
0.0282194819,
0.0129686324,
-0.0732511953,
0.028887419,
-0.0186925549,
0.014697466,
0.0619279183,
-0.0151784094,
0.0335873924,
0.0090164142,
0.0861674026,
0.0175807495,
0.0120750489,
0.0211725254,
-0.0567126162,
-0.0011338966,
-0.0248773061,
0.0267838221,
0.0109393075,
0.0121354163,
0.0019509598,
-0.05033122,
0.0056334878,
0.0011205649,
-0.0064103883,
-0.0052957758,
-0.0624574497,
0.0001829177,
0.036584571,
0.0387072638,
-0.0235705823,
-0.0237123426,
-0.0241831653,
0.0446847044,
0.0244373083,
-0.0052485564,
-0.0630590022,
0.0182520766,
3.028e-7,
0.0156748723,
0.0206534825,
0.0269197766,
0.0208202563,
0.0106573356,
0.0352733433,
-0.011437471,
0.0118101398,
-0.009819489,
-0.0060647684,
-0.0384826884,
-0.0420931019,
0.0486013405,
0.0243411679,
-0.0123271113,
-0.0172728598,
-0.0312302671,
0.0577021912,
-0.0428525694,
0.0114034647,
0.0825583264,
0.0157264862,
-0.0095152091,
0.0188877825,
0.0270276833,
-0.0098623428,
0.0089304158,
-0.0065571037,
0.0292926487,
0.0123407338,
-0.0447931625,
-0.000348778,
0.0018487304,
-0.0213290993,
-0.0292750392,
-0.0606740862,
0.0376445204,
0.0833408087,
0.0043345913,
0.0487342812,
0.0468455181,
-0.0423515625,
0.0220399108,
-0.0679901242,
0.0349120758,
-0.0005338144,
0.0019275711,
0.0111034913,
-0.0579302832,
0.0215776209,
0.0056418837,
-0.0340974741,
0.0012831498,
-0.0104408171,
-0.0048159515,
0.0248651505,
-0.0223001689,
0.010293182,
-0.0539859943,
0.0037426259,
-0.015282942,
-0.0637997612,
-0.0646274686,
0.0440935902,
0.0204186998,
-0.0349472128,
0.0117598651,
3.271317438e-34,
0.0260523874,
-0.0334798247,
0.0417539887,
-0.0193631854,
0.0479318462,
-0.0040161298,
0.0302272607,
0.0187063161,
0.0170502905,
0.0409054123,
-0.0337262638
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10258v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10258v2 | In and Out-of-Domain Text Adversarial Robustness via Label Smoothing | 2022-12-20T14:06:50 | 2023-07-11T19:33:44 | Yahan Yang, Soham Dan, Dan Roth, Insup Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG | Recently it has been shown that state-of-the-art NLP models are vulnerable to
adversarial attacks, where the predictions of a model can be drastically
altered by slight modifications to the input (such as synonym substitutions).
While several defense techniques have been proposed, and adapted, to the
discrete nature of text adversarial attacks, the benefits of general-purpose
regularization methods such as label smoothing for language models, have not
been studied. In this paper, we study the adversarial robustness provided by
various label smoothing strategies in foundational models for diverse NLP tasks
in both in-domain and out-of-domain settings. Our experiments show that label
smoothing significantly improves adversarial robustness in pre-trained models
like BERT, against various popular attacks. We also analyze the relationship
between prediction confidence and robustness, showing that label smoothing
reduces over-confident errors on adversarial examples. | [
0.0432952717,
0.042162165,
-0.0161229502,
0.0410144962,
-0.0085559832,
-0.014849633,
-0.0169016868,
0.0414377302,
0.0260847434,
-0.0521995202,
-0.0161290448,
-0.0128325559,
-0.0044430713,
-0.0040982477,
0.0735559165,
-0.0409241021,
0.0430838764,
0.0029629807,
-0.0016217497,
-0.0069845701,
0.0149133867,
-0.0388414189,
0.0003233448,
0.0485736616,
-0.0239749793,
-0.0195257757,
0.0304907635,
0.0344705097,
0.0069535677,
-0.0181471296,
0.0621473193,
0.064527452,
-0.0107175382,
0.0706765279,
0.0000017333,
-0.0194517951,
-0.0241552461,
0.0356454253,
0.0011128008,
0.0376587175,
0.032440301,
-0.0377660841,
-0.0053885845,
-0.0044836462,
-0.0114793871,
0.0040031443,
0.0281330384,
0.0664550066,
0.0574972555,
0.0796103552,
-0.0255579446,
-0.0333419479,
0.0176859088,
-0.0669295564,
-0.0405242406,
-0.1044403613,
0.0506944694,
-0.065398708,
-0.0360837542,
0.0115754828,
-0.022700727,
0.0187963042,
-0.0073012901,
0.019599786,
0.0022646098,
0.0245652832,
0.0037431279,
-0.0292390436,
0.0049452344,
0.0739782676,
-0.0487975366,
-0.0075707296,
-0.0107017336,
0.0192331281,
0.0257410016,
0.0111262798,
-0.0108138639,
-0.0380411856,
0.0267630666,
-0.0006027991,
-0.009728739,
-0.0258796997,
0.0493328013,
0.0299707819,
0.0075805997,
0.0392678604,
0.0421338417,
-0.0436595269,
0.0180933643,
-0.0093267644,
-0.0525834486,
-0.0634787977,
0.0252645668,
0.0105946139,
-0.0013470622,
0.0212685354,
-0.1154120341,
-0.0454545394,
0.0140067553,
-0.0192017239,
0.0216788091,
-0.0007380759,
-0.0383050181,
0.0367909782,
-0.0481304415,
0.0287488531,
-0.0090597365,
0.0937671289,
-0.0081210295,
-0.0176041294,
-0.0277307108,
0.0042601055,
-0.0265333876,
0.0368372984,
-0.0009328465,
0.0065662521,
-0.0245186053,
0.0109907994,
-0.0181626454,
0.0383497328,
-0.0209035035,
0.0014078175,
-0.0458927155,
-0.0367885754,
0.0155834574,
-0.0090516247,
-0.0165445339,
0.0021979765,
-0.0132440077,
-0.0770138428,
-0.0480602458,
-0.0104933186,
-0.0313973762,
-0.0432741344,
-0.0256489385,
0.105791457,
0.0014553593,
-0.0498456545,
-0.0410558097,
-0.0085820183,
-0.0349101163,
-0.0331161842,
-0.0139402589,
-0.0148513177,
-0.0339252874,
-0.0260989964,
0.0044811754,
-0.1024477929,
0.0070502078,
0.0183018651,
-0.0446095504,
0.0645080134,
-0.0120463613,
-0.0233823713,
0.0248406343,
0.0378699414,
-0.0010422874,
0.0440606326,
-0.0233692676,
0.0050582131,
0.0607821457,
0.0254161134,
0.0066369153,
0.0538122803,
0.0485719964,
0.0325751081,
-0.0545834601,
-0.0113014635,
0.0385302156,
-0.0178119335,
-0.0124239288,
0.0573708415,
-0.0334451683,
-0.0750477836,
0.0938592553,
0.0026528242,
-0.0371747874,
0.0280573796,
-0.0062376,
-0.0257695727,
0.0372883715,
0.0265470129,
-0.060447529,
-0.0111933947,
-0.0461380742,
-0.0379732251,
0.0362099223,
-0.0023296128,
-0.0142114954,
-0.0209050309,
-0.0448345505,
0.0118691111,
0.0079058046,
-0.0422485583,
0.0225140024,
0.0607125573,
-0.0227848738,
0.0396136381,
0.0210911855,
0.012488964,
-0.0010338795,
-0.0544887185,
-0.0264587719,
-0.0155857289,
0.0795552582,
-0.0543691143,
-0.0001909563,
-0.0215093531,
0.0151101528,
0.0170767792,
0.0395264216,
-0.0084596109,
0.0409285575,
-0.026286589,
-0.0093538659,
-0.0390903428,
0.0370374918,
0.014142382,
0.057867609,
0.0122606726,
-0.0016084574,
-0.0869634524,
-0.0007738692,
0.0526339412,
0.0373631865,
-0.0820452273,
0.0239821095,
0.0112748127,
0.0212274101,
0.0158601794,
-0.0470272563,
0.0214915033,
0.0385978632,
0.0019048919,
-0.0142098116,
-0.0264260303,
0.0104852719,
-0.048449263,
0.0348938629,
-0.0049303882,
-0.0402020998,
0.0651415437,
-0.0466537289,
0.0183385331,
0.0154319461,
-0.0394932926,
0.0203235503,
0.0019541383,
0.0092210677,
-0.0101155676,
0.0520520955,
-0.0325449221,
0.0473838225,
-0.017921973,
0.0135845346,
0.000322979,
0.0429801531,
0.016926093,
0.0052477811,
-0.0610805638,
0.0470013469,
-0.0405332558,
-0.0061588148,
0.0074261967,
-0.029921975,
-0.0135049466,
-0.0014830556,
-0.0169805605,
-0.0232692827,
-0.0281174649,
-0.0157008823,
0.0405397937,
-0.0070738872,
0.0005587723,
-0.0353239216,
0.0210237056,
-0.0033785226,
-0.0436011963,
0.0363237634,
0.0136021618,
0.0112969587,
-0.0139652994,
-0.029225383,
-0.0317282118,
0.0042403042,
0.0709224194,
-0.0339936763,
-0.0538666546,
-0.0167476181,
0.0020291412,
-0.0395433679,
0.0666319653,
-0.0292500779,
-0.0434672907,
-0.0110614635,
0.013911386,
0.0239851512,
0.0651521459,
0.0273461081,
0.0310935676,
0.020841537,
0.020559337,
0.0121697569,
-0.0038875537,
-0.0060327477,
-0.0395704582,
-0.0330233611,
-0.0004060451,
0.0307367854,
0.0663647279,
-0.001361622,
-0.0161723346,
0.0060038483,
-0.001077474,
-0.0326031484,
-0.0420088097,
-0.0245651919,
0.0144879045,
-0.0325459242,
-0.0169483609,
-0.0303188935,
-0.0363314003,
0.0963643789,
-0.0103097297,
0.0123588657,
-0.041108828,
-0.0554054715,
0.0294400156,
0.0426346771,
-0.00333081,
0.0106791034,
0.0201127604,
-0.0284013972,
-0.0608079769,
-0.0747960657,
0.0272924881,
-0.004073645,
0.0282310732,
-0.0186022781,
0.0045873155,
0.0217992123,
-0.024402285,
-0.0561178774,
-0.0773253441,
-0.0066768862,
0.019514136,
0.0201169923,
-0.0073412405,
-0.045490846,
-0.0427665003,
0.0081031639,
0.0299774222,
-0.0207802914,
0.0110415993,
-0.0102539407,
0.0725652277,
0.035652101,
-0.0547210984,
-0.0064296513,
-0.0304748695,
0.0196246784,
0.0560241006,
0.0219123866,
-0.0035141492,
-0.0105292965,
-0.0110353995,
0.0381328054,
0.0006019555,
-0.0096424846,
0.0495804511,
0.0256718341,
-0.0168216508,
-0.0066018384,
0.0428616293,
-0.0102914348,
0.0119778346,
0.0233186986,
-0.0019070558,
0.0583355203,
0.0146534089,
-0.0195512064,
-0.042519521,
-0.0382248573,
0.0410430096,
0.0023312529,
0.019101996,
-0.023658447,
-0.0006434231,
-0.0839191154,
-0.0153995352,
-0.0192572214,
0.0051063234,
-0.0182413328,
-0.0273523442,
0.0215980783,
-0.005805756,
0.0265297443,
-0.0358047299,
0.0346664153,
-0.0126604699,
0.0282738935,
0.0166477915,
-0.064993307,
-0.0153107038,
-0.0394873396,
0.0238211453,
0.0653511509,
0.0439304486,
-0.0245698895,
-0.0258194115,
0.0937237591,
0.0119491592,
-0.0236014333,
0.0153135946,
0.0963040292,
-0.0301236175,
-0.0109492103,
0.028384665,
0.0180463977,
0.0380777791,
-0.0290953442,
-0.0097227413,
-0.0031150265,
0.0319780596,
-0.0324683823,
-0.0204053633,
-0.0015171355,
0.0258562285,
0.0526091345,
0.0044921143,
-0.0387737677,
-0.0518299565,
-0.0641727373,
0.0246881787,
-0.0183564909,
-0.0335461125,
0.0425135568,
-0.0171213094,
-0.0803032368,
-0.0558005609,
-0.012967024,
-0.0183167122,
0.0132235745,
0.0106796101,
0.0007523218,
-0.0288601834,
0.0069497987,
-0.0042307605,
-0.02191942,
-0.0213222653,
0.0650691688,
-0.0241238773,
0.002004297,
0.0305371732,
0.0241699666,
-0.0358979777,
0.0313329436,
-0.0765467957,
-0.0897835046,
0.0299924146,
0.0219297372,
0.0156112742,
0.0445705988,
-0.054623995,
-0.1084821075,
0.0762613192,
0.0696888417,
0.0163535848,
0.015888134,
0.0523273684,
-0.0384776741,
0.0344805904,
0.0600771978,
-0.0566821024,
-0.001957926,
0.0564238876,
0.0128899505,
0.0127401277,
-0.0325431451,
-0.0118698478,
-0.0089508295,
0.0678945109,
0.0021675713,
0.013052159,
0.0188364573,
0.0132791437,
-0.0014773385,
-0.0331553407,
0.0178488065,
0.0494156778,
0.0342143066,
0.0244236998,
-0.0085142553,
0.0396648757,
-0.0093365898,
0.049022831,
0.0159236472,
-0.013380778,
-0.01291628,
0.0206284616,
0.0273597576,
0.0124822333,
-0.0260262676,
0.011845272,
0.0120678209,
0.015957538,
-0.0049914299,
0.0213483125,
0.034480799,
-0.0024170221,
-0.0024026171,
-0.0096106799,
-0.0933890417,
-0.0200333036,
-0.060706459,
-0.0065694642,
0.0312486067,
-0.005150381,
-0.024690954,
-0.0303284395,
-0.0402465016,
-0.0091032451,
-0.0361125879,
-0.0032994063,
-0.0129014058,
0.0414253622,
-0.0079030246,
0.0127898771,
0.0508799106,
0.0942263901,
0.052141089,
0.0622473992,
0.0192187149,
-0.0334001221,
-0.0337614119,
-0.0169439483,
0.0407574065,
0.0371301733,
0.0030957574,
0.0012947267,
-0.0259891991,
-0.1086149141,
0.0407892987,
-0.0293598119,
0.0235589258,
0.0164379291,
0.0048332079,
0.0445344299,
0.0235245712,
0.0135007426,
-0.0509666763,
0.0264784861,
0.0440114923,
-0.0430256128,
-0.0157973487,
-6.044625581e-33,
-0.0020389047,
-0.0068399468,
-0.0689008012,
-0.0685416833,
0.0243752226,
-0.0015370629,
-0.0359794535,
-0.0231553987,
-0.0228116307,
0.0369630121,
-0.0119773662,
0.0211201236,
-0.0177434962,
0.0175284874,
-0.0616319068,
-0.0841883346,
0.0496527776,
0.0067848763,
-0.0143485963,
-0.0295666531,
0.000668192,
0.0445961878,
0.0534917749,
-0.0726752207,
0.0571180508,
0.0261416957,
-0.0355791897,
-0.0168839432,
0.00878854,
0.0400158875,
-0.0033677937,
0.020063689,
0.011245599,
0.0007130509,
-0.0106611578,
0.0027374108,
-0.035866484,
-0.000270061,
-0.0113658225,
0.0013181288,
-0.0139916465,
-0.0011848113,
0.0368850268,
-0.0160252377,
-0.0322912708,
-0.010625625,
0.0242947787,
-0.003054942,
-0.0321849771,
-0.006270655,
-0.0243157186,
0.026140783,
-0.0044958354,
-0.0119929221,
-0.0045641693,
0.0135042742,
0.0452122428,
0.0274429116,
-0.0658288747,
-0.0227130502,
-0.0043524271,
0.0525175147,
-0.0029349583,
0.0046822364,
0.0022954317,
0.052627556,
0.0080233887,
0.028250264,
-0.0069585349,
-0.0521302335,
0.0138187883,
0.0294738784,
0.0751799196,
0.0906015262,
0.0632308424,
-0.0342768207,
-0.0733552426,
0.0120635889,
-0.0184356738,
-0.0063855411,
0.0164143667,
0.0393419042,
-0.0336977169,
0.0034462814,
-0.0314131007,
-0.0738493949,
-0.0440004915,
0.010209945,
0.0079452107,
0.0115117533,
-0.0205294024,
0.0566926673,
-0.0179524906,
-0.0323176235,
-0.0260898098,
0.0299142431,
-0.0411477722,
-0.0153042087,
0.0047567156,
0.0361471772,
-0.0143367508,
-0.0114735719,
0.0297424719,
0.00084682,
0.0157777797,
-0.0134927789,
0.0716378242,
0.0049916883,
-0.0676117614,
-0.0132159684,
-0.0267164297,
0.014495695,
0.0451960824,
0.0231455378,
0.0449424498,
-0.0066348133,
-0.0126291802,
0.0375219993,
0.0310154241,
0.0081451321,
0.0015938885,
0.0322358124,
0.0085080341,
-0.0207945816,
0.0112795858,
-0.0405245684,
0.0049540107,
0.0156619027,
0.0387063585,
-0.0686033294,
-0.0022479098,
-0.0503346249,
2.611e-7,
0.0015012003,
0.0429268517,
0.0068013943,
-0.0248521566,
0.0373114794,
0.0584830195,
-0.0083857169,
0.0695086047,
-0.0007005142,
-0.0461187549,
-0.0228564739,
-0.0109259821,
0.0483451188,
0.0172875896,
-0.0511746146,
-0.0257151816,
-0.067041114,
0.0196502972,
-0.0215790868,
-0.0069900625,
0.023558801,
0.1291127801,
0.0608765036,
0.0102905566,
-0.0166924559,
-0.074607566,
0.0317940935,
-0.007381808,
0.0345858634,
0.0056609651,
0.0283358097,
0.0358278006,
0.0467576981,
0.0080755036,
-0.0662897602,
0.0082488442,
0.0663926974,
0.0578452274,
-0.0164381918,
-0.0030644198,
-0.0434681848,
-0.007189163,
-0.0033166716,
-0.0384000018,
0.0617716275,
-0.0279626939,
-0.0105186533,
0.0072187935,
-0.0289278012,
0.0053601395,
0.0471847095,
-0.0382786952,
-0.0487624183,
0.0329373404,
0.0165016688,
0.0431592651,
-0.0153163867,
-0.082125023,
-0.0167663042,
-0.0062140189,
-0.0448189378,
-0.0246997252,
-0.0099649234,
0.0201572645,
0.0349934809,
-0.0698137805,
0.0174964815,
2.214930511e-34,
0.0217824839,
-0.0284819361,
-0.0017960198,
0.0034998276,
0.0509292707,
-0.0225954205,
0.0410656594,
-0.0316890255,
0.0012777334,
-0.0340348892,
-0.0308335014
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10257v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10257v1 | Original or Translated? On the Use of Parallel Data for Translation Quality Estimation | 2022-12-20T14:06:45 | 2022-12-20T14:06:45 | Baopu Qiu, Liang Ding, Di Wu, Lin Shang, Yibing Zhan, Dacheng Tao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Machine Translation Quality Estimation (QE) is the task of evaluating
translation output in the absence of human-written references. Due to the
scarcity of human-labeled QE data, previous works attempted to utilize the
abundant unlabeled parallel corpora to produce additional training data with
pseudo labels. In this paper, we demonstrate a significant gap between parallel
data and real QE data: for QE data, it is strictly guaranteed that the source
side is original texts and the target side is translated (namely
translationese). However, for parallel data, it is indiscriminate and the
translationese may occur on either source or target side. We compare the impact
of parallel data with different translation directions in QE data augmentation,
and find that using the source-original part of parallel corpus consistently
outperforms its target-original counterpart. Moreover, since the WMT corpus
lacks direction information for each parallel sentence, we train a classifier
to distinguish source- and target-original bitext, and carry out an analysis of
their difference in both style and domain. Together, these findings suggest
using source-original parallel data for QE data augmentation, which brings a
relative improvement of up to 4.0% and 6.4% compared to undifferentiated data
on sentence- and word-level QE tasks respectively. | [
0.0459799916,
0.0630499274,
-0.0101202922,
0.0574634634,
-0.0249063298,
0.015186863,
0.0350073837,
0.0140151735,
-0.0599073358,
-0.016646089,
-0.0677015483,
-0.0413893163,
0.0406398624,
-0.0807405412,
0.0395850725,
-0.0257829055,
0.0158386119,
0.0424116775,
-0.0034073365,
-0.0104120402,
0.0142607857,
-0.003418836,
0.0107971197,
0.004292821,
-0.0186755285,
-0.0034233066,
0.0323211662,
0.0565580651,
0.0491679311,
0.0031639184,
0.0010842615,
0.0338374823,
-0.0198514406,
0.0363440774,
0.0000018588,
-0.0284355655,
-0.0494418442,
0.0094568273,
0.0431364365,
0.0216519944,
0.0514235497,
-0.052433569,
-0.0306815207,
0.0236312803,
-0.0001811425,
-0.0549829155,
0.0466382727,
0.0395006984,
0.0629461855,
0.0593375564,
-0.0150802517,
-0.0109150475,
-0.0057078456,
-0.0242701191,
-0.0492375866,
-0.0233937223,
-0.0298926979,
0.0250565168,
-0.0236272626,
0.0245580133,
0.0151271028,
0.0545350015,
0.0264392514,
-0.0099489605,
-0.017345231,
-0.0398958214,
-0.0251212474,
0.0003641193,
0.0344035588,
0.0430267453,
-0.0151045574,
-0.0253287349,
-0.0162710883,
-0.013593507,
0.009162466,
0.0231000558,
0.0081638591,
0.0318580978,
0.003784064,
0.0215546526,
0.0145390602,
0.0407642014,
0.0312595069,
-0.0170665234,
0.0058299974,
0.0152732618,
0.0188113358,
-0.051218532,
0.0132043445,
0.0537309349,
-0.0316266716,
0.0242095757,
0.034996815,
-0.0467878394,
-0.0226610228,
0.0158728547,
-0.0206250325,
-0.1122003421,
0.0111616543,
-0.0637757704,
0.0345780551,
0.0366794243,
-0.0219115913,
0.0019548242,
0.0078684278,
0.0401321687,
-0.0050838203,
0.0296161417,
-0.1090232655,
-0.0431924313,
-0.016203193,
0.0604946986,
-0.0289067179,
-0.0209928565,
-0.0394161977,
0.0116063533,
-0.0298915878,
0.0037588601,
0.0041294713,
-0.0025761058,
0.0423331596,
-0.0289023351,
-0.0603107139,
-0.0081993742,
0.0167544559,
0.0283307564,
-0.0293628406,
0.0084118433,
-0.016065564,
-0.0441056602,
-0.0125715211,
0.0264739562,
0.0153456246,
-0.0476511084,
-0.0107669123,
0.0542890914,
-0.0025019299,
-0.0275392514,
-0.033337608,
-0.0061974544,
-0.0475059561,
-0.0445043482,
0.0107922535,
-0.0609880202,
0.0367162079,
-0.0112104546,
0.0360713415,
-0.0073109977,
-0.0184783973,
-0.0120960306,
-0.0026010752,
0.0240443982,
-0.0486550778,
0.0000953096,
0.0372184888,
-0.012886242,
0.0086137904,
0.0692643076,
0.0457853414,
-0.0040583238,
0.0561978109,
-0.0036232641,
-0.024341289,
0.0479130782,
-0.0010339553,
0.0485278703,
-0.0288897865,
-0.0222465154,
0.0215938166,
0.0114814136,
0.0182266757,
0.0720098242,
-0.0315488242,
0.0180265959,
0.056744501,
-0.0398497991,
0.0253422074,
0.0074247303,
0.0374536403,
0.0342694968,
0.0061735292,
0.059344396,
0.0069324621,
0.0130357957,
0.0524598584,
0.0182489268,
0.0692236274,
0.0094524948,
-0.0090158731,
-0.0724222884,
-0.0239444431,
-0.020876104,
-0.006807215,
-0.0600354895,
0.0277493987,
0.0400358476,
-0.0175155122,
-0.0006655201,
0.0109070716,
-0.0550405048,
0.0113850869,
0.0011218828,
-0.0205257423,
0.0504137576,
0.0413810462,
0.0194315128,
0.0198172126,
-0.0092287287,
-0.010400394,
0.066087544,
0.0421043523,
-0.0098892907,
0.0542172752,
-0.0455673151,
-0.0416007638,
0.0164733101,
0.0261659306,
0.0057789474,
-0.0215880703,
0.0116194263,
0.0439995751,
-0.0348395146,
-0.081447579,
0.0353939123,
0.0035557202,
-0.0207631066,
0.0633884892,
0.0164168458,
0.0393351726,
0.0294999704,
-0.0330246761,
-0.013686087,
0.0077159917,
-0.039898172,
-0.0113262711,
0.0608209558,
-0.0256109145,
-0.0339864083,
0.0234374329,
-0.0702388883,
0.0044793803,
0.0511493534,
-0.0281762555,
-0.0679676682,
-0.0374912545,
-0.0678240582,
0.0077257217,
-0.0537160151,
0.0351968668,
-0.027380513,
-0.0311588384,
-0.012074369,
0.0323888026,
0.0111978184,
0.0586178564,
0.0156431701,
-0.0387547351,
0.0567272343,
-0.0092401486,
-0.0249064695,
0.0021248476,
0.0133687826,
0.052622024,
0.053143952,
-0.0022688503,
-0.0431462266,
-0.004517559,
-0.014543904,
0.028084347,
-0.0337851048,
0.0541953407,
0.0402197726,
0.0213763583,
-0.0004677411,
0.0111985523,
-0.001711725,
-0.0241011325,
-0.0111322086,
0.003696227,
0.04152897,
0.0161254462,
0.0423191674,
-0.0155885089,
-0.0216746256,
0.0493559316,
0.0134543898,
0.0245237276,
0.0048912968,
-0.0792736188,
0.0215898752,
-0.0176451616,
-0.0284031704,
0.0379744135,
-0.0947525278,
0.01466427,
-0.0092437891,
0.0246126559,
-0.0055483314,
-0.0024264117,
-0.0649122596,
0.034427397,
0.0250646137,
-0.0353055894,
-0.0025242986,
-0.02006552,
-0.0139484098,
-0.0066904719,
-0.0671336427,
0.0314856395,
0.0390864722,
-0.0077172769,
-0.0235593766,
-0.0364514291,
-0.0008672306,
-0.0211652368,
-0.0101208193,
0.0197971743,
0.014427131,
-0.0111993076,
0.0259048566,
0.0007453279,
-0.052886337,
0.061196778,
-0.0305972788,
0.009902603,
-0.0658760518,
0.0040771537,
-0.0110879699,
0.0042185844,
-0.0123902792,
0.0147250863,
-0.0494143739,
-0.0037115507,
-0.0241096541,
0.0423033088,
0.0313154422,
-0.0098628523,
-0.013735991,
-0.0469745547,
-0.0288664736,
-0.0084101558,
-0.0083064018,
-0.0359879509,
-0.0166223105,
0.0003512399,
-0.0091059292,
0.0591159835,
-0.0063956906,
-0.0010041367,
-0.0287134368,
0.0021598316,
0.057950303,
-0.0227081813,
0.013026257,
0.0186756738,
0.0318939835,
-0.0083493954,
0.0034605912,
0.0166951325,
-0.0523699336,
-0.010724986,
0.0043524322,
0.0117098996,
-0.0233690068,
-0.0079275779,
-0.0602863058,
0.0235270467,
0.0097166207,
-0.0584696196,
-0.0236301962,
0.0537989922,
-0.0529451631,
-0.0214295089,
0.1072381437,
0.0337104425,
-0.0386776701,
-0.0312644541,
-0.0136748422,
-0.0076073976,
-0.0079790195,
0.0104696425,
-0.0706436336,
-0.0166183319,
-0.0194253325,
0.0448569059,
-0.0060157464,
0.032007657,
-0.0274934359,
-0.0973657742,
0.0040130625,
0.0520724282,
-0.041130282,
-0.00067051,
-0.0016821562,
-0.0175312255,
-0.0407786109,
0.0446545109,
-0.0001631342,
0.0453524701,
0.0244262051,
0.0124203078,
0.0194207355,
-0.0641301051,
-0.0632714033,
-0.0726995543,
0.010213241,
0.0260183699,
0.038073726,
-0.0146729359,
-0.0708951354,
0.0236075148,
-0.1116328984,
-0.0138625689,
-0.0067351079,
0.0548956208,
-0.0058485898,
-0.0161664244,
-0.0100816498,
-0.0203774851,
-0.0019094725,
0.0277123749,
0.0169115253,
0.0112023894,
-0.0131890075,
0.0152053991,
0.0128611894,
-0.0165491682,
0.0028417003,
0.0382997692,
0.0097658532,
-0.0549020618,
0.0274569094,
-0.009859181,
0.0129152136,
-0.0916296989,
0.0369899906,
0.0171531327,
-0.0754328519,
-0.0482648648,
-0.1327058673,
-0.0694854409,
-0.0441871174,
0.0278042387,
0.0216199569,
-0.0023251101,
-0.0164010283,
-0.023279706,
0.0094300257,
-0.0057203434,
-0.0151835,
0.002279229,
-0.034018822,
0.006583015,
-0.0024101341,
-0.0329081826,
0.0205430482,
0.0341726616,
-0.0441038236,
-0.0577733442,
-0.0117784971,
0.0441251472,
0.0128509924,
0.0619721524,
-0.0363195091,
-0.0346554294,
-0.0161309,
0.0377088934,
-0.0346587673,
0.0074911523,
0.0453339182,
-0.0251596514,
-0.0141371209,
0.0327560566,
-0.0249853376,
0.0214735903,
0.02810698,
0.0059761293,
0.0082368581,
-0.0401299261,
0.0032948814,
0.0356348269,
0.0552457012,
-0.0483163707,
0.0234421603,
-0.0352342762,
0.0225984361,
-0.0299892593,
-0.0159045216,
-0.0456731729,
-0.006104128,
0.0468489081,
-0.0042786826,
-0.0362901427,
0.0336672477,
-0.0557756349,
-0.0014463691,
-0.0111285606,
0.0104179895,
-0.0184464771,
0.0328210294,
-0.0504868962,
0.0391253047,
0.0038364066,
-0.005014814,
0.0492606089,
0.0522487387,
-0.0163447689,
0.0081157703,
0.0148552069,
0.0051959287,
0.0476593077,
0.032981813,
-0.0453227758,
0.0418562107,
-0.0353974737,
-0.0105374912,
0.0484397002,
-0.0444251299,
0.1456170231,
-0.001992218,
-0.0038374597,
-0.0342432372,
0.0409646444,
0.0228962135,
-0.0020184729,
-0.0420399308,
-0.0193420965,
-0.0275769588,
0.012913092,
0.0608162545,
-0.0167076532,
-0.0334918611,
-0.0431859307,
-0.0208748616,
-0.0221116506,
0.0077973343,
-0.0361644477,
-0.0095893648,
-0.0174578279,
-0.0403305553,
-0.0183746386,
-0.0498737618,
0.0087545663,
0.0307285674,
0.0257269889,
-0.0207237322,
-0.012351091,
0.0176766124,
-0.0577451847,
0.0014838787,
-0.0470843315,
-0.0188424103,
0.0052651628,
0.0021332412,
0.0047191922,
-5.539010931e-33,
-0.0041680182,
-0.016091736,
-0.0492530353,
-0.0494907834,
-0.0163708832,
-0.0006068498,
-0.0186755583,
-0.0367592722,
0.0119532477,
0.0497186966,
0.0274861194,
0.0147683797,
0.0404211991,
0.0006585075,
0.0084995842,
0.0373453088,
0.0713791177,
0.0193189047,
-0.0494265407,
-0.0130336517,
0.0428184383,
0.007534489,
0.096049346,
-0.0763823316,
0.0662723631,
-0.0646537617,
-0.0147927841,
0.0019356314,
0.0309967231,
0.0315686278,
0.045706138,
0.0496799126,
0.0165307317,
-0.0574494228,
-0.0255479142,
-0.0318217911,
-0.0728132501,
-0.0069992761,
0.0106162671,
0.0464538038,
-0.0313760228,
-0.0429722369,
0.0425744355,
-0.0261639543,
-0.0280738473,
-0.0213532671,
0.0333670042,
-0.0711396262,
-0.014486542,
-0.0029028291,
-0.0272157155,
0.0347979926,
-0.0070414562,
0.0078449473,
0.0508759394,
0.0599105395,
-0.0190178677,
-0.0092903171,
-0.0703807771,
0.0117919939,
-0.0305845682,
0.0226349998,
0.024129793,
-0.0034809059,
-0.0117837172,
0.0027903207,
0.0417677909,
0.0203565843,
0.0791392773,
-0.0119259981,
0.0112273013,
-0.0181034151,
0.0763904378,
0.0931260884,
0.059759032,
-0.0482032634,
-0.0497894548,
0.0788316801,
-0.0437101834,
-0.0202964339,
-0.0264270417,
0.0041172942,
-0.0224638265,
-0.0113351783,
-0.0171865635,
-0.0517564118,
-0.002120683,
-0.014556366,
-0.0157836787,
0.0152535755,
-0.0406582691,
0.0074563492,
0.0490753502,
-0.0133759705,
0.0328151658,
-0.0064171012,
-0.0607855171,
0.0171326622,
-0.0161902159,
-0.0036994931,
-0.0119869662,
-0.00901487,
0.0366913453,
0.0602526888,
-0.0050534881,
-0.024373509,
0.1123609394,
-0.0020776945,
-0.0634726733,
0.0271780454,
-0.0259115789,
0.0137564447,
-0.0258762315,
-0.0108716264,
0.0109341228,
-0.0183126274,
-0.0058965739,
0.0628861859,
0.0573602319,
0.0048086531,
-0.0082526552,
-0.0025641164,
0.0145678688,
-0.0175354742,
-0.0409830287,
0.0170867816,
0.0359647945,
0.0191033911,
0.0289365612,
-0.0462147854,
-0.019967135,
-0.0279429443,
2.496e-7,
0.0576056615,
0.0210546535,
0.0297092274,
0.0068280143,
0.0004146176,
0.0208240673,
-0.0523138568,
0.0327623226,
0.0047920831,
0.0246964656,
0.0439636707,
-0.0350741148,
0.1081208959,
0.033844877,
-0.0872775316,
-0.0350780226,
-0.0522436053,
0.0353598669,
-0.0188212246,
0.0239732377,
0.0369095765,
0.0684225485,
0.0090068514,
-0.0194378365,
-0.0125488043,
-0.0198318921,
0.0726539418,
-0.0155735966,
-0.0402499177,
-0.0044885841,
0.0421888679,
0.0023462519,
-0.026576696,
0.0077663441,
-0.0713274851,
0.0258602854,
0.0496028624,
0.0552937575,
0.038131997,
0.0191637594,
0.0354640856,
-0.0030242058,
0.0159509461,
0.0105037922,
0.0497492887,
0.0142164687,
-0.0071991286,
0.020609621,
-0.0582627021,
0.0210648738,
0.0562486425,
-0.0305465069,
-0.0471357331,
0.0167021807,
0.0326360911,
0.0206368845,
-0.0147879962,
-0.0106705539,
-0.0462993011,
-0.012943374,
0.0109008271,
-0.0584741607,
0.028913565,
0.0123908184,
0.0192634407,
-0.0593327172,
0.0318497717,
1.756504015e-34,
0.0628292784,
-0.0413831696,
0.0298542418,
-0.0348671116,
0.0222011488,
-0.0166870747,
-0.0186724551,
-0.0082052071,
-0.0057919864,
-0.0031184012,
0.0085183606
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10240v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10240v2 | Diffusion Glancing Transformer for Parallel Sequence to Sequence Learning | 2022-12-20T13:36:25 | 2023-11-29T08:30:34 | Lihua Qian, Mingxuan Wang, Yang Liu, Hao Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Previously, non-autoregressive models were widely perceived as being superior
in generation efficiency but inferior in generation quality due to the
difficulties of modeling multiple target modalities. To enhance the
multi-modality modeling ability, we propose the diffusion glancing transformer,
which employs a modality diffusion process and residual glancing sampling. The
modality diffusion process is a discrete process that interpolates the
multi-modal distribution along the decoding steps, and the residual glancing
sampling approach guides the model to continuously learn the remaining
modalities across the layers. Experimental results on various machine
translation and text generation benchmarks demonstrate that DIFFGLAT achieves
better generation accuracy while maintaining fast decoding speed compared with
both autoregressive and non-autoregressive models. | [
-0.0161799416,
0.0436210893,
0.0080919182,
-0.010850003,
-0.0329850167,
0.0176371485,
0.0198942237,
-0.0218900237,
-0.0844615176,
-0.0286723133,
-0.0581481159,
-0.0575332865,
0.0304598324,
0.0145218829,
0.0125898523,
-0.0391970538,
0.0167590789,
-0.0265029743,
-0.0938206241,
-0.0268185027,
-0.0086969929,
0.0191592928,
-0.0229288805,
0.0083660707,
0.0008296346,
-0.0245615859,
-0.0329303481,
0.0038703533,
0.0276398882,
-0.0317604505,
-0.0134201283,
0.0408587679,
0.0461445525,
0.0209951643,
0.0000021425,
0.0321638361,
0.005151175,
0.017888438,
0.0529148094,
-0.0028398407,
0.1466322243,
-0.0628966093,
-0.0374851748,
0.0239844918,
-0.0039978148,
-0.0193298813,
0.0575088114,
0.0389503203,
0.0465456657,
0.0383395441,
-0.0152128711,
-0.0573306382,
0.0262932293,
-0.0714685097,
-0.0033812791,
-0.0333450437,
-0.0212210696,
0.0217333529,
-0.014110242,
-0.0009951735,
-0.0349261649,
0.0726889521,
0.0307742488,
-0.0322330594,
-0.0311896894,
0.0281021241,
0.0661177635,
-0.0163210202,
-0.0270691421,
0.0855177939,
0.0095103625,
-0.0008064908,
-0.0131259244,
-0.0171032585,
-0.021666117,
0.0452750847,
-0.0184430275,
0.0356131494,
-0.0187958628,
0.0220192168,
0.0122531494,
-0.0063009453,
0.0289036985,
-0.034245681,
-0.0407571904,
-0.0407733172,
0.0194970183,
-0.006312408,
-0.0469562486,
0.0139398621,
0.0233778823,
-0.0091775944,
0.02303808,
0.0024872981,
0.0088933539,
-0.0012122035,
-0.0594605431,
-0.0504582971,
0.0219000112,
0.0217103343,
0.0644332394,
0.058283329,
-0.0061530732,
-0.0223153885,
-0.0501425825,
-0.0265748873,
-0.0493898392,
-0.0162815005,
-0.0558306649,
-0.0021865643,
-0.0396864042,
0.0053890031,
-0.0276987031,
0.0180873573,
-0.0800178126,
-0.0119658196,
-0.021108469,
0.0145424819,
0.020702377,
-0.0438825674,
0.0442665443,
-0.0085255355,
-0.1014057621,
-0.02996465,
0.0254838318,
0.0667090341,
0.0008561466,
-0.0088027818,
0.0231931675,
-0.0071871327,
-0.0349423029,
-0.0016333023,
0.0046337727,
0.0157205276,
-0.0255286004,
0.1047406569,
-0.0585274994,
0.0016221998,
-0.0239867158,
-0.0168287922,
-0.0180073287,
-0.0425486229,
0.031895034,
-0.0529948361,
0.0332582071,
0.0134029379,
-0.0249395389,
0.0201860946,
0.0131629212,
-0.0001156676,
0.0178592801,
0.0478007719,
0.0097155375,
-0.0464229658,
0.0290285461,
0.0121155148,
0.0025453402,
0.0765104964,
0.0300247297,
-0.0012112162,
-0.0378922001,
0.0215555131,
-0.0357031226,
0.02312354,
0.0523152575,
0.0346901566,
-0.0334857479,
-0.0533236451,
0.0394090898,
0.0190145802,
0.0664784461,
0.0627447739,
-0.0554695874,
-0.0216060616,
0.0593594201,
-0.0000514052,
0.0308817346,
0.0455982648,
0.0631495789,
0.0252496935,
-0.0615747571,
0.0401224159,
0.0333996117,
0.0452708453,
0.0222764872,
0.0144617464,
0.0137547283,
0.0593356825,
-0.0451577455,
-0.0263675749,
0.0330363661,
-0.0023360138,
0.0090329554,
-0.0343640149,
0.0244431384,
0.0464459062,
-0.0770218745,
0.0360091217,
0.0013623877,
-0.0614851378,
0.0072943191,
-0.0454974398,
-0.0276224092,
0.0411171094,
0.0044614677,
0.0282619428,
-0.0421400405,
-0.042146828,
-0.0127713075,
0.0532804281,
0.007233425,
0.0220782924,
0.0214084964,
-0.0517150871,
-0.0209232327,
0.0155370822,
0.0067497478,
0.0444858223,
-0.067143485,
0.0347391441,
0.0291607771,
-0.0121471789,
0.0150552429,
0.0248617548,
-0.0365224443,
0.0152815683,
0.0453566089,
-0.034646105,
0.0261574443,
-0.0081813214,
-0.0285317227,
0.0025062184,
0.0305761024,
-0.0564386398,
-0.0196405631,
0.0507075451,
-0.0583034679,
-0.0480381809,
0.0107210325,
-0.051465448,
0.0326065533,
-0.0004491302,
-0.0212829411,
-0.0554338694,
0.0241843779,
-0.0143997641,
-0.0201565456,
-0.0421501398,
0.0135724908,
0.0649853572,
0.0607389137,
-0.0008112996,
0.0272631068,
-0.0498948805,
-0.0170877352,
0.0197812952,
0.055860579,
-0.0375496857,
-0.0024587531,
0.0057843644,
0.0208428856,
0.0271555092,
-0.0118059451,
-0.014328857,
-0.0084043974,
-0.0006817284,
-0.059476655,
-0.0859678686,
0.0134129627,
-0.0138587998,
0.0238012765,
0.0531342365,
0.040658623,
0.0115921088,
0.0151522923,
-0.0479478016,
0.0371755809,
0.0478730612,
-0.0098200794,
0.0162945762,
0.0228169821,
-0.0154661797,
0.0088805733,
-0.0261362344,
0.0320905112,
0.0366488546,
0.0043465374,
0.0091376146,
-0.0634131879,
-0.0005125004,
0.0107151018,
0.0059097395,
-0.0245601162,
-0.046514526,
0.0085127894,
-0.0028811602,
0.0778756738,
0.0162319783,
0.0626223758,
-0.0084318509,
-0.0132422047,
-0.0241409224,
-0.0232769903,
0.0171709545,
-0.0252373125,
0.0174407326,
-0.0355940424,
-0.0621280596,
-0.0164072178,
0.0681105554,
0.0210023597,
0.0289298929,
-0.0372404903,
-0.0148639828,
0.0160718206,
-0.0321159475,
0.0312920287,
0.0291241482,
0.0042581633,
-0.0114816688,
-0.0248320345,
-0.0334018655,
0.045249261,
-0.0259552933,
-0.0033986659,
-0.0496592261,
0.018431494,
-0.0067808544,
0.0100534782,
-0.0265453756,
0.0294915289,
-0.0358668081,
-0.0253082793,
-0.0363587886,
0.0062443824,
0.0271641538,
-0.0187115185,
0.0519971512,
-0.0243558399,
0.0104730502,
-0.053747911,
-0.0223133285,
-0.0047912137,
-0.0343318954,
0.0179583225,
-0.0033683409,
0.0167750418,
-0.0203888249,
-0.0195451323,
0.0239602141,
-0.0030595374,
0.055993367,
-0.0242011491,
-0.0102966251,
-0.0142633822,
0.0484207682,
0.0064658038,
-0.0036571475,
-0.0185620766,
-0.0350344963,
0.0372378416,
0.0352433547,
0.0562002324,
0.0342480727,
-0.0109419664,
0.0063120234,
0.0274002459,
0.024722185,
-0.044707749,
0.0096388087,
0.0405489653,
-0.0663417503,
0.0060293223,
0.0418403819,
-0.0211160369,
-0.0685835183,
-0.0072261775,
0.0274305865,
0.045109462,
-0.037708018,
0.0060091312,
-0.097270526,
-0.0291081872,
-0.0173699539,
0.0241108146,
0.0116213532,
0.0229940061,
-0.0128668621,
-0.0604149029,
0.0570509061,
0.0138188768,
-0.0082414057,
-0.0448040776,
-0.0278059449,
-0.0343257338,
0.0150347361,
0.0348562263,
0.0389112309,
-0.0265876558,
-0.0054460606,
0.0508344397,
0.0779115483,
-0.0761068016,
-0.0460350737,
-0.0433021151,
0.0329818353,
0.0658935457,
-0.0019785117,
0.0181263424,
-0.0865886137,
0.0265310444,
-0.0313065834,
0.0254257321,
-0.0191803165,
0.0029460525,
-0.0211589169,
-0.0057541532,
-0.0140392156,
0.0100123445,
-0.0302013829,
0.0282210018,
-0.0445237309,
0.025823677,
0.0015228805,
0.0242479295,
-0.0080875531,
0.0314726122,
0.0067768656,
0.0227190554,
-0.0176348202,
-0.0460713804,
-0.0421507657,
-0.0450672172,
0.0507641062,
-0.0494729802,
-0.0269714519,
0.0196581669,
0.0147073232,
-0.0936295241,
-0.0761041567,
-0.0100893751,
-0.0445417948,
0.0745034143,
0.0227216408,
0.0414054468,
0.0036173516,
-0.0145391505,
-0.0638526678,
-0.0289754514,
-0.0296062194,
0.0057460656,
-0.0355097502,
-0.011128867,
0.0580760948,
-0.0468527935,
0.0036996594,
0.0033893255,
-0.1693019122,
-0.0631993413,
-0.0213717781,
0.0156764146,
0.0085729789,
0.0711708292,
0.028530933,
0.0139806541,
0.0436975658,
0.0517544113,
0.0020926876,
0.0087016858,
0.0452696793,
-0.0285209902,
-0.0232344512,
0.0166074783,
-0.0143539337,
-0.0037204137,
0.0077275131,
0.0546950847,
-0.0153592536,
0.0062468648,
0.0125222765,
-0.0410902426,
-0.0185333118,
-0.0298951901,
0.0193520747,
-0.0086660087,
0.041980911,
0.0030121882,
0.0146937389,
-0.0585765578,
0.0265034921,
0.0496573076,
-0.0288917758,
0.0112510715,
0.0395697653,
0.0064135711,
0.0037273795,
-0.0046992186,
0.0624551289,
-0.0043302793,
0.0324446261,
-0.0126496702,
0.0063142525,
-0.0077497354,
-0.0341056287,
0.0205325801,
0.0111913737,
-0.0424810946,
0.0802407041,
0.0180066116,
0.0191000085,
0.0089868056,
0.0402462184,
-0.0246423818,
0.0155688664,
-0.0582032353,
-0.005316555,
0.0672709048,
0.0583689623,
0.0539851636,
-0.0077777645,
0.0192577951,
0.0030340042,
0.0355063602,
-0.0221174266,
0.0036743809,
0.0288073812,
-0.0011544691,
0.0129927192,
0.0079984711,
0.0672622994,
-0.0572371818,
0.0199527647,
0.0120116714,
-0.0038499678,
-0.0347789153,
-0.0325104259,
0.0208221823,
-0.0437729917,
0.0176527202,
-0.0040831547,
0.0013587724,
-0.0289537553,
0.0179449636,
0.0130222961,
0.0255063325,
-0.0392241739,
0.0331146568,
0.0451416969,
-0.0097058285,
-0.0082493639,
-0.0622594543,
0.0243586432,
0.0440718196,
-0.0014887754,
-0.0272330754,
-6.68723969e-33,
-0.0371286385,
0.0142762205,
0.0210549254,
-0.0476310737,
-0.067849651,
-0.0263193529,
0.0031010262,
-0.0126342438,
0.0219189487,
0.0087786578,
0.002320549,
0.0250541065,
0.0212285742,
0.0157349035,
0.0132616609,
0.0098353978,
0.0999189466,
-0.0398313031,
-0.0317934975,
0.0488111377,
0.0140210008,
0.0429408327,
0.0303443503,
-0.0176989809,
-0.0119934287,
-0.01993181,
-0.0067695272,
-0.0529364794,
0.013924351,
0.003461028,
-0.003257372,
-0.0128968125,
-0.0017912762,
-0.0187725052,
-0.0445033275,
-0.0146958744,
-0.0834233686,
0.0277876277,
-0.0012459225,
0.0160351209,
0.0037509077,
-0.0496037602,
0.0142287724,
-0.0101825381,
-0.0211563874,
-0.0068772649,
-0.0020940986,
-0.0190605838,
-0.0227269046,
-0.0101898415,
-0.0311498921,
0.0363763236,
0.0237609688,
-0.0168522224,
0.0118674506,
0.0065292576,
-0.0058183852,
-0.0005367374,
-0.0848522559,
0.0141644189,
0.0217690561,
0.0646975189,
0.0697723776,
0.0426728465,
0.049353376,
0.0126416655,
0.074174948,
-0.0044071162,
0.0240185168,
0.0146822818,
0.0412458368,
-0.002818886,
-0.0123330485,
0.0607758872,
0.0903996453,
0.0004984681,
-0.0269912723,
0.0180583876,
-0.0312319696,
0.0096688252,
0.0586693697,
0.0235222597,
0.0362785719,
0.007645716,
-0.0514490008,
-0.0392210297,
0.0027004045,
-0.0239244476,
-0.0072971331,
0.0700794682,
-0.043207489,
-0.0180864912,
0.091947794,
-0.0015290284,
0.0106187919,
0.0166021511,
-0.0358877331,
0.0328347087,
-0.0197039265,
-0.0154553438,
-0.0535081998,
-0.0262507517,
0.0293431133,
0.0085107135,
-0.0086948043,
-0.0006066665,
-0.0024589393,
0.0318492465,
-0.0463864282,
-0.0059159594,
-0.042003125,
0.0539877936,
0.0197713133,
0.0313352756,
0.03934009,
-0.0289608035,
-0.0377757922,
0.035361968,
-0.039971754,
0.029799832,
-0.0195142645,
0.0272684582,
0.0050540911,
0.0526430719,
-0.0370958373,
0.0371706039,
-0.0235479008,
0.0441446155,
0.0251638219,
-0.0775242746,
-0.0529366173,
0.0696050525,
2.813e-7,
0.0203100163,
-0.00768254,
0.0449365452,
0.0084953466,
0.0212878566,
0.0155102983,
-0.0047180266,
0.0265475009,
0.0317919962,
0.0213884078,
0.003008574,
-0.0019685603,
0.0426140726,
0.0315919742,
-0.0554706417,
-0.0494716838,
-0.0009607548,
0.0472151712,
0.0218403935,
-0.024775736,
0.027294416,
0.0612070486,
-0.0671343803,
-0.0179797169,
0.0465269238,
-0.0104590217,
0.0921866223,
0.0232186075,
-0.0086004268,
-0.0146726258,
-0.0185199473,
-0.0548932143,
-0.0200227518,
0.0207836274,
-0.0357487537,
0.0064997245,
-0.0217494294,
0.0099562509,
0.0084396666,
-0.0631088614,
0.0367828608,
0.0422387719,
-0.0257814396,
0.0257007312,
0.0384446904,
-0.0332707167,
-0.013892821,
-0.0040764734,
-0.0665769801,
0.0360004008,
-0.0087900087,
-0.0304736793,
-0.0409285575,
0.0335162058,
0.0307026636,
-0.0067532198,
0.0044706673,
-0.0158329736,
0.0002398081,
-0.0159285069,
-0.0523458943,
-0.0402825102,
-0.0544910245,
-0.03082457,
0.0379125848,
-0.0125659183,
-0.0399385467,
2.658856182e-34,
0.0395657122,
-0.0632412359,
-0.0318100788,
0.0098710647,
-0.0003866779,
-0.0116851339,
-0.0377690196,
0.0127155064,
-0.008189071,
-0.0568336286,
-0.054369323
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10233v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10233v2 | Pre-trained Language Models for Keyphrase Generation: A Thorough Empirical Study | 2022-12-20T13:20:21 | 2024-02-23T04:45:40 | Di Wu, Wasi Uddin Ahmad, Kai-Wei Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Neural models that do not rely on pre-training have excelled in the keyphrase
generation task with large annotated datasets. Meanwhile, new approaches have
incorporated pre-trained language models (PLMs) for their data efficiency.
However, there lacks a systematic study of how the two types of approaches
compare and how different design choices can affect the performance of
PLM-based models. To fill in this knowledge gap and facilitate a more informed
use of PLMs for keyphrase extraction and keyphrase generation, we present an
in-depth empirical study. Formulating keyphrase extraction as sequence labeling
and keyphrase generation as sequence-to-sequence generation, we perform
extensive experiments in three domains. After showing that PLMs have
competitive high-resource performance and state-of-the-art low-resource
performance, we investigate important design choices including in-domain PLMs,
PLMs with different pre-training objectives, using PLMs with a parameter
budget, and different formulations for present keyphrases. Further results show
that (1) in-domain BERT-like PLMs can be used to build strong and
data-efficient keyphrase generation models; (2) with a fixed parameter budget,
prioritizing model depth over width and allocating more layers in the encoder
leads to better encoder-decoder models; and (3) introducing four in-domain
PLMs, we achieve a competitive performance in the news domain and the
state-of-the-art performance in the scientific domain. | [
0.0845314264,
0.0292984322,
0.0108140409,
0.009636702,
-0.0177255087,
-0.0115184598,
-0.0100264689,
0.0116747208,
-0.003488336,
-0.0509774238,
-0.0308235474,
0.0008329222,
-0.0452669784,
0.0513815843,
0.0182683803,
-0.0455157682,
0.0257328469,
-0.0400308408,
0.0298512504,
-0.0065787407,
0.0041607083,
0.0098851426,
0.0116813798,
0.0366503224,
0.0326779336,
-0.0047705807,
-0.0209293086,
-0.0149192205,
0.0081652524,
-0.0483385921,
0.0382547565,
0.0423696041,
0.0211224109,
0.0192954931,
0.0000018897,
-0.0291567035,
-0.0132949539,
-0.0172859747,
0.0150561687,
0.0718749091,
0.0384354144,
-0.0248445738,
0.0182768404,
0.0194607619,
-0.0528592579,
-0.0274904557,
0.0400596261,
0.0119551755,
0.0623724796,
0.0496744886,
-0.0127382884,
-0.0532742254,
0.0449744724,
-0.0394118167,
-0.0488300659,
-0.0651859045,
0.0095481686,
-0.067109488,
-0.0509135276,
0.0315067694,
0.0165107455,
0.0472773686,
0.0086125806,
0.0314291902,
0.0931396782,
0.0425646901,
-0.043913383,
-0.0498996899,
-0.0535989739,
0.0698454902,
-0.0508036576,
0.0091194073,
0.0417731106,
-0.0339292623,
-0.0073092696,
0.0161094833,
-0.0346658416,
0.0353369676,
0.0049118698,
-0.006270132,
-0.0134025384,
0.0081187645,
0.0030740385,
0.0402508527,
-0.0301261898,
-0.0095589748,
0.0639756173,
-0.0407691523,
-0.0101460721,
-0.0023225781,
-0.0520537384,
-0.0553599112,
0.0301489979,
0.025037501,
0.0200480502,
0.0493031293,
-0.0755274966,
-0.0237335879,
0.0577955022,
-0.11376369,
0.0173563138,
-0.0167034287,
0.0026349104,
-0.0040387167,
-0.0413442813,
0.0556148551,
-0.0199859086,
0.0432705022,
-0.0107771754,
0.0079427361,
-0.0233743768,
-0.0403633639,
-0.0186654329,
0.0728063658,
0.0204263981,
-0.0725830346,
-0.0538774654,
0.023057431,
0.0702664778,
-0.0102188047,
0.0122748772,
0.0147622665,
-0.0185697898,
-0.01071552,
0.0049274755,
-0.0066384147,
-0.0018475411,
0.0017319387,
0.0290315542,
-0.0287452918,
-0.0210292768,
0.0094933594,
0.0143341739,
-0.0257929321,
0.0425914377,
0.0386274904,
-0.0111106755,
-0.0386173539,
-0.0034879565,
-0.0489994213,
-0.0230760388,
-0.0092976466,
0.0349857099,
-0.0532616451,
0.0504892655,
0.0343914218,
-0.0212993994,
-0.0419292375,
0.0330388546,
0.0315893106,
-0.0726268515,
0.033205349,
-0.0238610022,
0.015826948,
0.0338918194,
0.0031509835,
0.0368855335,
0.0239754952,
0.0434171408,
0.0549608134,
0.0499049686,
-0.0271394234,
0.0074151405,
0.0288280006,
0.0562041923,
-0.0153773744,
-0.0090962807,
0.0116824824,
-0.0226024017,
0.013919902,
-0.001077859,
0.0375758,
-0.0255493354,
0.0343771204,
0.0709943101,
0.0780151412,
0.0109847002,
0.0393313356,
0.0075194114,
0.0224895068,
0.0280170012,
-0.0373613387,
0.0211886652,
0.0127829928,
-0.0053380942,
0.0391771197,
0.062241327,
0.0389356948,
-0.0240119249,
-0.0328823961,
-0.0148741053,
0.0110662039,
-0.02899874,
-0.0170772709,
0.0413416028,
0.0062735882,
-0.1010574624,
0.1117130592,
-0.0077863131,
-0.0674957857,
-0.0065420228,
-0.0453463234,
-0.0284403563,
0.0423006527,
0.0690645203,
0.0153886341,
-0.0682242736,
0.0222461596,
0.020973511,
0.0831787661,
0.0133468332,
0.0171086043,
-0.0074050785,
-0.0541672818,
-0.0446692891,
-0.0518745929,
0.001631886,
-0.0086401291,
0.0284902155,
0.0217871629,
0.0504672937,
-0.0197490416,
-0.0108827474,
0.0389734283,
-0.0297644418,
-0.0292132031,
-0.0144605171,
-0.0244465768,
0.0154567612,
0.0204379503,
-0.0273786094,
0.0547382012,
0.046533972,
-0.0297132693,
-0.0018788793,
-0.0058664815,
-0.0296910759,
-0.0058729192,
0.0256636329,
-0.0295399409,
0.0478907712,
0.0173535813,
-0.0182012916,
-0.0258449391,
-0.0004289966,
-0.0328308903,
0.0704090074,
-0.0591358878,
0.0268079527,
-0.031429112,
0.0121440347,
-0.0291180257,
0.0618422478,
0.0014265323,
-0.0044226563,
-0.0157720186,
-0.0127742132,
0.012721994,
-0.0071479664,
-0.0060672136,
0.0220080242,
0.0084163826,
-0.0052143764,
0.0243870318,
0.0145261446,
-0.0183052085,
-0.0072819558,
-0.0504592136,
0.0219781585,
0.0145855155,
0.0075740195,
0.0148986522,
0.0170035642,
-0.0108093238,
-0.0089029865,
-0.022888232,
-0.0322060362,
-0.0008202585,
0.0242481679,
0.0223045796,
0.0326882713,
-0.0148858903,
-0.0293256082,
0.0089650713,
0.0104520814,
0.0581798702,
0.0427295007,
-0.0559129119,
-0.0130539909,
0.0609744973,
0.0079542836,
-0.0454038493,
0.0201848857,
-0.0680134147,
0.0045800437,
-0.0084823295,
0.0450072549,
-0.0109943189,
0.0636595637,
-0.0137185939,
0.0056637698,
-0.0180256069,
-0.0408177376,
-0.0209034905,
-0.0356840864,
-0.0366787165,
0.0209209155,
0.0014790641,
0.0850095823,
0.0613413602,
-0.0091129486,
0.0214452259,
-0.0550567061,
0.0164710693,
0.0207068156,
-0.0264707785,
-0.0210934263,
-0.0329157524,
-0.0253930017,
0.0306160599,
-0.0198631827,
-0.0195800811,
0.0333384797,
-0.0285902172,
0.0090079401,
-0.0652917325,
0.0321710072,
-0.0155314654,
0.0161150601,
-0.0207208768,
0.0111097423,
0.0168413147,
-0.0377306901,
0.0003262221,
0.0057577677,
-0.0249114539,
-0.0517893098,
0.037436448,
-0.0411288962,
-0.0001510748,
-0.0012322799,
-0.0002452896,
-0.0663553327,
-0.0460619889,
-0.02146261,
-0.018608667,
0.042372454,
-0.0066246744,
0.0338824131,
0.0393796898,
-0.0013996643,
0.0398685262,
-0.0200710017,
0.0125172408,
0.0061595817,
0.0352067202,
0.0707608387,
-0.0466602296,
-0.0132012144,
-0.0344495475,
0.0138090225,
0.0166774672,
0.0434633531,
-0.0091966689,
-0.0129940929,
-0.0158848148,
0.0315473936,
-0.0484277233,
-0.0137567548,
0.005350125,
0.0146271326,
-0.0198812801,
-0.0201367326,
0.1274406612,
0.041399017,
-0.058039099,
-0.0186398644,
0.023031177,
-0.0173362959,
-0.0202705935,
0.0130405137,
-0.0389958583,
-0.0150395064,
-0.0331010222,
0.0290587917,
0.006257249,
0.0015183062,
-0.0127203166,
-0.1111191586,
0.0051453756,
0.020366881,
-0.0081670908,
-0.026516486,
-0.0508172326,
-0.0454621017,
-0.0077470993,
-0.0095297527,
-0.0041342317,
-0.0371815115,
0.0346836373,
0.0123374965,
-0.0414256267,
-0.0683504269,
-0.003882736,
-0.0706945807,
0.0031174961,
0.0969375297,
0.0190094002,
-0.025781095,
-0.0189412143,
0.0311045293,
0.0136000728,
-0.0196226649,
0.0033611644,
0.0142191155,
-0.0354998186,
-0.0088738538,
-0.0103578046,
0.0114173805,
-0.0331275351,
0.0015032049,
0.0408080369,
0.015357757,
-0.0039977673,
0.0179266781,
-0.0289527494,
0.0222746003,
-0.0312771946,
0.0895477757,
0.0450060852,
-0.0351584069,
-0.0462746322,
0.0192986317,
0.0381371193,
-0.1187016144,
-0.0409571379,
-0.0288003143,
-0.0491207428,
0.0182383582,
-0.066536434,
-0.0382642262,
0.0150485933,
-0.0070519801,
-0.0005426048,
0.0185512993,
0.0010312267,
0.0020994062,
-0.0573203377,
-0.003685466,
0.0048443382,
-0.0455691293,
-0.0633977428,
-0.0368824825,
0.0571007542,
-0.0142079983,
-0.0331117772,
0.0163646713,
-0.0226535499,
-0.0477880798,
0.0186779797,
0.0686234459,
0.0135741141,
0.0052505876,
0.0116362106,
-0.0279479604,
0.1080587208,
0.0578302778,
-0.0096913828,
-0.0026611979,
0.015472929,
-0.0106970845,
-0.0296995509,
0.0150004029,
-0.0446550362,
0.0008990968,
0.0255296528,
0.0811826885,
-0.0224516336,
-0.0756155476,
0.0040693935,
-0.0036978058,
0.0463510305,
-0.0469883494,
-0.0100913467,
-0.031923037,
0.0118750986,
-0.0095540592,
0.0141418595,
-0.060769815,
0.0179974288,
0.0146253807,
0.0089230333,
-0.0216285549,
0.049874302,
-0.0719916075,
0.0416204371,
-0.0228413101,
0.0104223927,
0.0040545147,
0.0291214865,
0.018846659,
-0.0189070497,
-0.043157436,
-0.0107008144,
-0.0177022591,
-0.0228783973,
-0.0217978712,
0.0022631448,
0.0097626792,
-0.0092825806,
-0.0238348376,
0.0806579888,
-0.0611932054,
-0.0312068556,
-0.0647920445,
-0.0043360498,
0.0608405434,
0.0051907627,
0.0269337278,
-0.026179336,
-0.0213689562,
0.0062888185,
0.0525668003,
-0.0006991077,
0.003652195,
-0.00602119,
0.0048499345,
-0.022120133,
-0.0414121561,
0.1162331551,
0.0665045604,
0.0490551889,
0.0151419519,
-0.0397920795,
-0.0118568614,
0.0047268812,
0.0502099581,
0.0064431163,
-0.0174183473,
0.0082600107,
-0.0213216878,
-0.0174385551,
0.0576450601,
-0.028008271,
0.0084529547,
0.0115154283,
0.0450110324,
0.0785805881,
-0.0220328197,
-0.0081488825,
-0.0493131205,
0.0444584005,
-0.0282965861,
-0.0363260172,
-0.0024600804,
-6.402152188e-33,
-0.0154642398,
0.000632396,
0.0122305034,
0.0119607057,
-0.0299771652,
0.0175041351,
-0.0415452607,
-0.0197215434,
0.0038541348,
-0.0182190873,
-0.0192860365,
-0.0089734457,
0.010448657,
0.0291115306,
0.0344313607,
-0.0286862627,
0.0389630087,
-0.0157599282,
-0.0009995799,
0.0399601497,
-0.023806747,
0.0618070103,
0.0604085512,
-0.0009081591,
-0.0125351483,
-0.0543821566,
0.0100645376,
-0.0467778966,
0.0648031384,
0.0465392657,
-0.0214899424,
0.0212945659,
0.0047998978,
-0.0854459405,
-0.0203967839,
0.0362673178,
-0.0334699713,
-0.0088398708,
0.0114590591,
-0.0165491682,
0.0017853155,
-0.0597705618,
0.0262540355,
-0.0152629213,
-0.0063811042,
0.0212447941,
0.0428066328,
-0.01633358,
-0.0327805281,
-0.066108495,
-0.0355314799,
0.0086030746,
0.0286967792,
-0.0112894429,
0.0239800215,
0.0081684152,
-0.0378063768,
0.0632637367,
-0.0356017277,
0.0326125696,
0.0779331401,
0.0097017521,
0.0348580331,
0.0844878703,
0.0235465113,
0.0389458872,
-0.0056600505,
-0.0156295989,
0.0077397814,
0.0743908063,
0.0254726764,
0.0486133546,
0.0303139593,
0.0383260362,
0.0564778224,
0.0117038498,
-0.062856026,
0.0151301622,
-0.0305379014,
-0.0255626421,
0.0439930633,
-0.0077307788,
0.0088955006,
0.0148625458,
-0.0194019675,
0.0134166516,
-0.0158618446,
-0.0470255762,
0.0281877723,
0.0300526433,
-0.0692281723,
0.0527840555,
0.0316809565,
-0.0070833447,
0.0110340714,
0.0187054966,
0.0153206773,
0.0024148738,
-0.0242770351,
0.0208417196,
-0.0784217417,
-0.0304086227,
0.0380695835,
-0.0102891931,
0.0060460223,
-0.0139560699,
-0.0221461523,
-0.0087839793,
-0.0220750459,
-0.0115831709,
-0.0190343503,
-0.0106468815,
0.0040439926,
0.0097850943,
-0.0028316663,
0.0071674655,
-0.0126782535,
0.026716467,
0.0060846629,
-0.0040679504,
0.0107321553,
-0.0127778267,
0.0296085216,
0.0647846013,
-0.0036913867,
0.0209375415,
-0.0466667712,
0.0079574399,
-0.0158191621,
-0.0650433153,
-0.040245261,
-0.0183930937,
2.602e-7,
0.0353566334,
0.0497632436,
0.0483575799,
0.010611007,
-0.0206587221,
0.0085937064,
0.0068911961,
0.0497460589,
-0.017803112,
-0.015798226,
0.0208203681,
0.0264518224,
0.0082688751,
-0.0171380788,
-0.076435551,
-0.0325473174,
-0.0983199105,
0.0358196013,
-0.0493936837,
-0.0192687493,
0.0502740741,
0.0262518767,
-0.0124561563,
-0.022051258,
-0.0284612551,
-0.0287203211,
0.0731435493,
-0.0173808914,
-0.0252123997,
0.0444431119,
-0.0234917421,
0.0557798669,
-0.0511484481,
0.0400718674,
-0.0396794118,
-0.0042159953,
0.0657687411,
0.0438354798,
0.0080643883,
-0.0695563778,
0.0198133793,
-0.0061983326,
0.0077032968,
-0.0333506204,
0.0723375455,
-0.0625258833,
-0.0065490212,
-0.015881693,
-0.0478317104,
0.0181154646,
-0.0170811787,
-0.0793621615,
-0.0237544384,
0.0127713196,
0.0037676846,
0.0222319141,
-0.0109464554,
-0.0576670766,
0.0155105973,
-0.0024870429,
-0.0276901685,
-0.0085193804,
-0.0930940211,
-0.0092244726,
0.028514469,
-0.0316442028,
0.0250236765,
2.418284376e-34,
0.0374205448,
-0.0491718166,
-0.01872335,
0.0492414907,
-0.0011035304,
-0.0135818189,
0.0074633113,
0.0209770761,
-0.0014096908,
-0.0441433229,
-0.0026967325
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10218v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10218v2 | GanLM: Encoder-Decoder Pre-training with an Auxiliary Discriminator | 2022-12-20T12:51:11 | 2023-05-09T09:08:33 | Jian Yang, Shuming Ma, Li Dong, Shaohan Huang, Haoyang Huang, Yuwei Yin, Dongdong Zhang, Liqun Yang, Furu Wei, Zhoujun Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pre-trained models have achieved remarkable success in natural language
processing (NLP). However, existing pre-training methods underutilize the
benefits of language understanding for generation. Inspired by the idea of
Generative Adversarial Networks (GANs), we propose a GAN-style model for
encoder-decoder pre-training by introducing an auxiliary discriminator,
unifying the ability of language understanding and generation in a single
model. Our model, named as GanLM, is trained with two pre-training objectives:
replaced token detection and replaced token denoising. Specifically, given
masked source sentences, the generator outputs the target distribution and the
discriminator predicts whether the target sampled tokens from distribution are
incorrect. The target sentence is replaced with misclassified tokens to
construct noisy previous context, which is used to generate the gold sentence.
In general, both tasks improve the ability of language understanding and
generation by selectively using the denoising data. Extensive experiments in
language generation benchmarks show that GanLM with the powerful language
understanding capability outperforms various strong pre-trained language models
(PLMs) and achieves state-of-the-art performance. | [
0.0177579075,
0.0905558616,
0.0038764451,
0.0220659114,
0.0017505225,
0.0109598422,
-0.0005534234,
-0.0029461363,
-0.0438783318,
-0.0385161974,
0.0041419989,
-0.0064214654,
-0.0586871132,
0.0664674938,
0.055231411,
-0.0361762568,
0.0587314218,
0.0055223536,
0.0461731628,
0.001710355,
-0.000892562,
0.019681802,
-0.010486153,
0.0387980007,
-0.043258775,
-0.0053277919,
-0.0087856734,
0.0135491593,
0.0040011415,
-0.0154004032,
0.018223742,
0.0268772505,
0.0265564658,
0.0361792408,
0.0000021664,
-0.0337951332,
-0.0181744639,
-0.0405843221,
-0.0234436877,
-0.0013633443,
0.020151427,
-0.0287362505,
0.014118623,
0.0228833798,
-0.0367301852,
-0.0856926218,
0.0283190403,
0.0684206933,
0.0560178794,
0.0856755897,
-0.0119680725,
-0.0310417544,
0.012701584,
-0.020442212,
-0.0086235646,
-0.0804515705,
-0.0008724137,
-0.0055791223,
-0.0453728735,
-0.0214478076,
-0.0358641483,
0.0399723426,
0.0430412367,
-0.0076964688,
0.0383274406,
0.0395137519,
-0.0161108244,
-0.0232493337,
-0.0326059349,
0.0355898589,
-0.086469464,
-0.0527242869,
-0.0116555961,
-0.014449019,
0.01377864,
-0.036566101,
-0.0085302535,
0.0075329542,
0.009441901,
0.0294987317,
0.0033256393,
-0.0105617754,
0.021112632,
0.0122925304,
-0.0179570392,
0.0309907924,
0.0235653408,
-0.0046701767,
-0.0403465852,
0.0060218079,
-0.0365791693,
-0.0710545555,
0.031932883,
0.0353217535,
-0.060726203,
0.0003973206,
-0.0759056211,
-0.051002942,
-0.00419574,
0.018245535,
-0.0176660847,
-0.0037225422,
-0.0307965986,
0.0092118047,
-0.0504718572,
0.0396315455,
0.0115094865,
0.0255755335,
-0.0385085121,
-0.0275234561,
0.0105767967,
-0.0481629819,
-0.0539428741,
0.0446525328,
-0.0864031687,
-0.0379399024,
-0.0412276834,
0.0169205051,
0.0230082907,
-0.0032739036,
-0.0018936533,
0.031031616,
-0.0480007157,
-0.0188665669,
0.0138376905,
-0.0271953288,
-0.0336141624,
0.0339989401,
0.0307686236,
-0.0774697512,
-0.0384282395,
0.0243384112,
0.0272894111,
0.0037562505,
0.0047110012,
0.1004014388,
-0.0351880863,
-0.0086229611,
-0.0516252667,
-0.0185520463,
-0.0016012725,
-0.0287263021,
-0.0085065635,
-0.0296158474,
0.0026811133,
-0.0051381704,
-0.0145540535,
-0.0626164302,
-0.003155167,
-0.0082479222,
0.0317146964,
0.0572506338,
-0.0235467125,
-0.0351578221,
0.0285101235,
0.0047962032,
0.0346684009,
0.0473929606,
-0.0046599046,
0.05819593,
0.0059894985,
0.01572215,
0.0335267596,
0.0054840376,
0.0301709697,
-0.0455183759,
-0.0151327858,
-0.0169025939,
-0.018296551,
0.0151730478,
0.0477608442,
0.0576211512,
-0.0575118177,
0.0038948718,
0.0508740656,
-0.0073389951,
0.00094955,
0.0199469849,
0.0626500249,
0.0250272993,
-0.0374552459,
0.0108731668,
-0.0167273693,
0.0123256771,
-0.0240175445,
-0.0023799376,
-0.0026247434,
0.0398945883,
-0.0390516929,
-0.0607714429,
0.0237059705,
-0.024604097,
-0.02375561,
-0.0292174295,
0.0519774333,
0.0607897118,
-0.0782872587,
0.0147279343,
-0.0010828805,
-0.0267082844,
0.0485382713,
-0.0383195542,
0.0480680987,
0.0288578756,
0.059108194,
-0.0022364103,
0.0033608519,
-0.0229984,
-0.0253443364,
0.0415536389,
-0.0121635115,
0.0020645454,
0.0433747135,
-0.0666587949,
-0.0075328988,
-0.0618405789,
0.0242835563,
0.0561823063,
0.0028145977,
0.0150038349,
0.0355964713,
-0.0364824124,
-0.0036721327,
0.0573398396,
0.0117333531,
-0.0522988327,
0.02814072,
-0.0188166574,
0.0425912365,
-0.0031023191,
-0.0082399379,
0.0123464568,
0.013574861,
-0.0454782695,
-0.034814775,
0.0273206756,
-0.0885225981,
-0.1003092825,
-0.0084440494,
-0.0695254654,
-0.0026523613,
0.0521326475,
-0.0407354236,
-0.0379737653,
0.0348036177,
-0.0230256561,
0.0482738279,
-0.0658822581,
0.0127377575,
0.0160654243,
0.0309576672,
-0.0099047953,
0.0674171597,
-0.0074765352,
-0.0283175688,
0.0029288216,
0.0592738278,
0.0165283792,
-0.020602243,
-0.0221593976,
-0.0299524628,
-0.0259428415,
0.005297089,
0.0288314074,
0.0234151687,
-0.0290851649,
0.0152219757,
-0.0377085023,
0.009334675,
-0.0381569415,
-0.0132180285,
0.0612636954,
-0.000619298,
-0.0065338421,
-0.0202417001,
-0.0448801666,
0.0220204256,
0.0439089313,
-0.0562518798,
0.0348300599,
-0.0149615938,
0.0220836792,
-0.0248364396,
0.0405009426,
0.0252915528,
0.0436296128,
0.0299910493,
-0.0201317202,
-0.040286772,
0.0362743363,
0.0002013818,
0.0322386809,
0.0093910247,
-0.0418021195,
-0.0040879874,
0.0182171185,
0.0470683463,
0.0159726478,
0.0272517167,
0.0704356208,
-0.0150885722,
0.0062581138,
-0.0324460194,
-0.0090755941,
-0.0281534791,
0.0143162021,
-0.0241006222,
0.002728028,
0.0520682298,
0.0852634609,
0.0565686971,
0.0033107705,
-0.0492103547,
0.0530819222,
-0.0101333829,
-0.0811564401,
-0.0461536981,
-0.0021211402,
-0.0228130519,
0.024851447,
-0.0502334721,
-0.0406335779,
0.0557516553,
-0.0327035151,
-0.0182459876,
-0.0376563333,
-0.0168598946,
0.0222312752,
0.0093801003,
0.0363074914,
0.0382149816,
0.0174513683,
-0.0464095846,
-0.0342905223,
0.0223596692,
-0.0213102363,
-0.0075224256,
-0.0079867272,
-0.0479864553,
-0.0096451575,
0.0197290983,
-0.0080057336,
-0.0920741186,
-0.0351616293,
0.0273092669,
0.0287438408,
0.0512346402,
0.0023815474,
-0.0294045079,
0.0042648767,
-0.0475890376,
0.0569006503,
-0.0084636044,
0.0093942974,
-0.0593198724,
0.0784826949,
0.0578076839,
-0.0598405935,
0.0077793859,
-0.0478352457,
0.0066722087,
0.0505719297,
-0.0251267366,
0.0079761595,
-0.0343458131,
0.0086116884,
-0.0018830495,
0.0095828259,
0.0117133772,
0.0367031321,
0.050502032,
-0.027476022,
-0.0467035808,
0.1082153544,
0.0105198678,
-0.0151622891,
0.0125312125,
0.0363322124,
0.004110272,
0.0174315777,
-0.001131666,
-0.0972862467,
-0.030910315,
0.001046852,
0.0058887433,
0.0028442473,
0.0032876781,
-0.0151742166,
-0.0880203843,
0.0256168488,
0.0203830451,
-0.0526609421,
-0.0186210107,
0.034518946,
-0.0429026447,
0.0059320452,
0.0543276258,
0.0104567837,
0.0276708547,
0.0246792343,
0.0352500156,
0.000956148,
-0.0942984149,
-0.0311092101,
-0.0377837382,
0.044337865,
0.0662670657,
0.0304365996,
0.0018756746,
-0.0166988056,
0.0523143411,
-0.0025518583,
-0.0031132195,
-0.0110291243,
0.0502031632,
-0.0282739457,
-0.0036074822,
0.0093793552,
0.0422065407,
-0.0502936542,
-0.0121150641,
0.0367711373,
0.0042881342,
-0.0092348587,
-0.0135115236,
0.0055975951,
0.0171547662,
0.0266973842,
0.0516445562,
0.0488619693,
-0.0071062008,
-0.0583146736,
-0.0324575454,
0.0435681827,
-0.1122747585,
0.0084353909,
0.0073717311,
0.0156669021,
-0.0212812163,
-0.0808120444,
-0.0521154366,
0.0320609175,
0.0286946651,
-0.0042598229,
-0.0117094405,
-0.0440213159,
-0.037311554,
-0.0399454944,
-0.0208105687,
-0.0117599471,
-0.0216975547,
-0.0352541842,
-0.0574454032,
-0.0099891666,
-0.0431812108,
-0.0298673473,
0.0506018214,
-0.0492788553,
-0.0532569997,
0.0094409566,
0.0543342978,
0.0131574823,
0.0502843559,
-0.0200842004,
-0.0166582651,
0.0539856218,
0.0523643531,
-0.0481025167,
0.0046629701,
0.001499934,
-0.0292257071,
0.0048847618,
0.0008379153,
-0.0050611738,
0.0608672798,
0.049506221,
0.017231252,
-0.0039869742,
0.0251382571,
0.0700882971,
0.0031817066,
0.0426390208,
-0.055662822,
0.0371552631,
-0.0471942872,
-0.0097144032,
-0.0214479361,
0.0058974754,
-0.0545202121,
-0.0113759087,
0.025266055,
0.0128433602,
-0.0116843376,
0.0224108081,
-0.0263751335,
0.0560423397,
-0.0229002032,
-0.0358064473,
0.0080515221,
0.0335740969,
0.0131001333,
-0.0170898624,
0.0044083796,
-0.0225083865,
0.0088039981,
0.0204892214,
-0.004410977,
0.0261134692,
0.025753526,
0.0213907231,
-0.0047897953,
0.0243669879,
-0.0587426014,
-0.021715343,
-0.0548288636,
-0.0089702271,
0.0785100386,
-0.0273305867,
0.0364277251,
-0.0006867718,
0.0125799309,
-0.0141906356,
0.0678870603,
0.0055186981,
-0.0624093339,
0.008837237,
-0.0066190991,
-0.0384094492,
-0.0443926752,
0.0877109095,
0.0254318751,
0.0461393669,
-0.0288529061,
0.0097686294,
-0.0712099671,
-0.0142402565,
0.0248557031,
0.0233761109,
-0.0003477106,
0.0429431535,
0.0047205957,
-0.058559116,
-0.0453571118,
0.007052551,
0.0514222383,
0.0196043886,
0.0712964237,
0.0510055833,
-0.0318701528,
-0.0189093705,
-0.0289534573,
0.0206833594,
0.0444460697,
0.0055184597,
-0.0267509669,
-6.6704911e-33,
-0.0481541567,
-0.0308820382,
0.0066251336,
-0.0558780357,
0.0091149276,
-0.0080881342,
-0.0467102937,
-0.046559386,
0.0358985215,
0.0188394878,
0.0231591444,
0.0236200709,
0.0070329541,
0.0599320158,
-0.0287962332,
0.0126695,
0.1053901613,
0.0051049194,
-0.0093740067,
0.025934821,
0.0460326821,
0.0744893476,
0.0437070206,
-0.0091889463,
-0.0269040558,
-0.0136323338,
-0.0211229157,
-0.0046097403,
0.0260288306,
-0.0071171741,
-0.0134694474,
0.0359242931,
0.0197254606,
-0.02054004,
-0.0484985039,
-0.0093175145,
-0.0754114315,
0.0087629305,
0.007432234,
0.0465560816,
-0.0451483354,
-0.0428024456,
0.0403291658,
-0.030107148,
-0.0289988499,
0.0414288826,
0.0367441624,
-0.012570451,
0.0055651963,
-0.0568969548,
-0.0709370747,
-0.0014072706,
-0.0272433944,
-0.0004497139,
-0.0031174046,
0.0393753275,
-0.0200654343,
-0.0146376984,
-0.0304654501,
0.0240673106,
0.0278895553,
0.0300816484,
0.0361985825,
0.0558299646,
-0.0069427285,
0.0578448921,
0.0184133947,
-0.0742323995,
-0.033997722,
0.0543263033,
0.0214847159,
0.0094783213,
0.0211440157,
0.024357155,
0.0529794469,
-0.0558818765,
-0.0710316449,
0.0266915895,
-0.0433720872,
0.020339191,
0.0357636549,
0.0253381822,
0.0404043719,
-0.0167505797,
-0.0153730586,
-0.0492673069,
0.0001343633,
-0.0217998978,
0.0674858019,
0.0367172249,
-0.0181935783,
-0.043905925,
0.0284658279,
-0.0306829717,
0.034889359,
0.0414103754,
-0.0175520852,
-0.0515848547,
-0.008486649,
0.0475646108,
-0.0453166738,
-0.0432836376,
0.0654724389,
0.0285820588,
0.0000276806,
0.0016813385,
0.0292853769,
0.0111051388,
-0.0521543287,
0.0357450396,
-0.0633831546,
0.0528724194,
0.0099572614,
0.0159767754,
0.0246601459,
-0.0071919197,
-0.0476839803,
0.0052161156,
-0.0110629918,
-0.0189787876,
-0.0096448185,
0.0222269762,
-0.0126416842,
0.0427696817,
-0.0647772998,
-0.0205978882,
-0.0258202124,
-0.0045253728,
0.0550885648,
-0.0796155334,
0.0045700045,
-0.01627074,
2.802e-7,
0.0277819782,
0.0107747084,
0.0619073585,
-0.0046268497,
0.01891114,
-0.0070959735,
0.0042908206,
0.0344754905,
-0.0107808728,
0.0170806106,
0.0128638148,
0.018180972,
0.0130516617,
0.0127196694,
-0.0642012283,
0.0530206747,
-0.0719837919,
0.019742975,
-0.0322369672,
0.0149720479,
0.0527758524,
0.0788964778,
-0.0116905253,
-0.0111320885,
0.0332241766,
-0.0180603415,
0.0490845218,
0.0033042051,
0.0106110154,
0.0180988591,
0.0205925405,
0.0241733734,
0.0115733705,
0.0158539321,
-0.03059691,
0.0040050442,
0.0141594792,
0.0548098199,
0.0007525175,
-0.0080380915,
0.0003883785,
0.0361815244,
-0.0078573441,
-0.051828403,
0.0472228155,
-0.0631684661,
-0.0180592146,
-0.0157472752,
-0.0554303788,
0.010442974,
-0.018057242,
-0.0158096608,
-0.0256593358,
0.0092360191,
0.0349374041,
0.0383666679,
-0.0091090882,
-0.0451707542,
-0.0070011374,
-0.0175875016,
-0.0559038259,
0.0203671269,
-0.0401493981,
-0.0003535635,
0.0338361673,
-0.0225006007,
0.0010328223,
2.239284596e-34,
0.0256529469,
0.0033912519,
-0.0117362961,
0.0207062941,
0.0228542462,
-0.0241101328,
-0.0111681204,
0.0368910506,
0.0033932361,
-0.0046580383,
-0.0292689074
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10197v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10197v2 | EIT: Enhanced Interactive Transformer | 2022-12-20T12:16:46 | 2024-06-05T10:18:14 | Tong Zheng, Bei Li, Huiwen Bao, Tong Xiao, Jingbo Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Two principles: the complementary principle and the consensus principle are
widely acknowledged in the literature of multi-view learning. However, the
current design of multi-head self-attention, an instance of multi-view
learning, prioritizes the complementarity while ignoring the consensus. To
address this problem, we propose an enhanced multi-head self-attention (EMHA).
First, to satisfy the complementary principle, EMHA removes the one-to-one
mapping constraint among queries and keys in multiple subspaces and allows each
query to attend to multiple keys. On top of that, we develop a method to fully
encourage consensus among heads by introducing two interaction models, namely
inner-subspace interaction and cross-subspace interaction. Extensive
experiments on a wide range of language tasks (e.g., machine translation,
abstractive summarization and grammar correction, language modeling), show its
superiority, with a very modest increase in model size. Our code would be
available at: https://github.com/zhengkid/EIT-Enhanced-Interactive-Transformer. | [
0.0080116559,
0.0118320193,
0.0232173763,
0.0124898311,
-0.0179998986,
0.0144161554,
0.0086047044,
-0.0262384061,
0.0334533304,
-0.0173840374,
-0.086838454,
-0.0244422685,
0.0227232575,
-0.0092065744,
0.0291863214,
-0.085468851,
0.0473473035,
0.0085652228,
-0.0610805415,
-0.0107596358,
0.0002008116,
-0.0121252574,
-0.005350871,
0.0243635271,
-0.0186879635,
0.0058021126,
-0.0240487754,
-0.009285396,
0.0496818349,
0.0222417992,
-0.0031157043,
0.0627465397,
-0.0205349978,
0.0474070311,
0.0000022583,
-0.0204349272,
-0.050155092,
-0.0164342001,
0.0801014379,
-0.0097147468,
0.0279399119,
-0.0494383126,
-0.0007033536,
0.0115922289,
-0.0423146561,
-0.0105876615,
0.0701822788,
0.0933892578,
0.1094447523,
0.0573540889,
-0.0224296283,
-0.0538675003,
0.0035129923,
-0.0699914917,
-0.0098329261,
-0.0339949466,
0.0168807227,
-0.0417184271,
-0.0886916146,
-0.0141799878,
-0.0386740677,
0.0759659111,
0.0203085374,
-0.0552460216,
0.0237163361,
0.0297935195,
-0.0284498651,
-0.0291419979,
-0.02343411,
0.0785678625,
-0.0462610386,
0.0090762135,
-0.0127242692,
-0.001988691,
0.0081934407,
0.0334506035,
-0.0624074973,
-0.0126873599,
0.0108981626,
0.0043911361,
-0.0435841791,
0.0249939468,
-0.00700913,
-0.0241976455,
-0.0536929667,
0.0006817608,
0.0101937279,
-0.0146010686,
-0.0240096841,
0.015584683,
-0.0273745824,
-0.0103929285,
0.017076904,
0.0369191356,
-0.0260867178,
0.003430445,
-0.0326125361,
-0.0487829372,
-0.0221964363,
-0.129216969,
0.0418995097,
0.0480191186,
0.0012875614,
0.0469632372,
0.0028930763,
-0.0001131037,
-0.0398215353,
0.029720597,
-0.0449568145,
-0.0149501069,
-0.0285941139,
-0.0123121012,
-0.0474025905,
0.0373803079,
-0.0000459322,
-0.0188758578,
-0.0467286371,
0.0316384137,
-0.0192649122,
-0.0093999086,
0.0342141092,
0.0013181278,
-0.0600349009,
-0.0057993773,
0.0439188033,
0.0907222629,
0.009355586,
-0.0336736701,
-0.0184755549,
-0.0165932886,
-0.056501992,
0.0349466354,
0.0066135838,
-0.0407971255,
-0.044168707,
0.029212255,
-0.0406153537,
-0.0177573431,
0.0189405344,
-0.009686742,
-0.024788836,
-0.0106023075,
0.0117323501,
-0.0376372114,
0.0354008526,
-0.0154612446,
-0.0008142436,
-0.029611174,
-0.0035144375,
0.0048578908,
-0.0183590706,
0.0701522976,
0.0328168012,
0.0064058136,
0.0423877202,
0.0290165246,
0.0268090051,
0.0595319383,
0.0074814674,
-0.0146913277,
0.0002384149,
-0.0278340746,
0.0182146039,
0.0575364903,
0.0201613437,
0.0106583722,
-0.0129811577,
-0.0136328451,
0.0089216726,
0.0032889217,
-0.0118885934,
0.0436608344,
-0.024409147,
-0.0023168405,
0.0515714996,
0.0087236669,
0.0359632745,
0.0358400792,
-0.01638682,
0.0039727883,
-0.0089398837,
0.0331036933,
-0.0422614515,
0.1011826918,
-0.019031899,
-0.0064069498,
0.0228904691,
0.0169567019,
-0.032296028,
-0.0506169982,
0.0338933617,
0.0060658637,
-0.0270355754,
-0.0125545524,
0.0534809455,
0.0262284894,
-0.0265107658,
0.017990794,
0.0056310105,
-0.0912093595,
-0.0058557293,
-0.0256944597,
-0.0091909831,
0.0121459011,
0.0381755121,
-0.0462105907,
-0.0610674433,
-0.0207788125,
0.0043687541,
0.0655439571,
0.0740376562,
-0.0155060906,
-0.0123404255,
-0.0183169972,
-0.0424360819,
0.0344833061,
-0.0079366583,
0.0275526624,
-0.0244592894,
-0.0202492587,
0.0022928333,
0.0426009633,
0.0194398742,
0.0279222056,
-0.0114042871,
0.0129688336,
-0.0207258444,
0.031881053,
0.0070348755,
0.0071021724,
-0.0067940182,
0.0034795962,
0.0296716113,
-0.0152544482,
-0.0166170355,
0.0330325551,
-0.0411112159,
-0.0369081497,
0.0153832305,
-0.0505557843,
-0.0319780372,
0.0405924283,
-0.0164956618,
-0.0681979954,
0.0214949287,
-0.0379788615,
0.0036007478,
-0.0315982811,
0.0202868152,
-0.0030936622,
0.0294539817,
-0.0611854345,
0.0450653732,
-0.0127897244,
-0.0140426904,
0.0404714905,
-0.0430684313,
0.0020576909,
-0.0077050207,
-0.0543563478,
0.0283212941,
0.0180626195,
0.0008551067,
0.0292813554,
-0.0261052959,
-0.0114239147,
-0.04721478,
-0.0680825561,
-0.0234331675,
-0.0405726582,
0.0186541658,
0.0406327099,
0.0471218154,
0.01728669,
-0.0327291079,
-0.0336461142,
0.0241434276,
0.0072375154,
-0.0015274729,
0.0284348,
0.0016322628,
0.0171435457,
-0.0364741534,
-0.0214311406,
-0.025589237,
0.0280592069,
0.0457527302,
-0.0496614426,
-0.0617290288,
-0.0170990154,
-0.0078474525,
0.0498269722,
-0.001117688,
-0.0140631692,
-0.0181377381,
-0.0415822715,
0.0343727022,
0.0907635167,
0.0321157761,
0.0204676799,
0.075955376,
-0.0038204987,
-0.0468480848,
0.0366717428,
-0.0363340341,
0.0322152674,
-0.0162070468,
0.0190485753,
0.0182417762,
0.0744603574,
0.0013857207,
-0.0241521876,
-0.0567268468,
0.0132054389,
0.0361051559,
-0.0277342852,
-0.0094465008,
0.0257134307,
-0.0235601496,
-0.0042511513,
-0.0224778652,
-0.0094767017,
0.0779497027,
-0.0277138893,
-0.0286079515,
-0.0123807322,
0.0363998376,
-0.0289886873,
0.0381046534,
-0.0018774744,
0.0224261899,
-0.0065961299,
-0.0421017781,
-0.0765166208,
0.0250250492,
0.0386793464,
-0.0051150387,
0.0699922815,
-0.0137256747,
0.0205247737,
-0.04030196,
-0.0339384042,
-0.0030843283,
-0.0183757842,
0.0313500836,
-0.0110008884,
0.0295788702,
-0.0244860798,
-0.04644363,
0.027615644,
0.0535343811,
0.0613376647,
-0.0140609071,
-0.0532461517,
-0.0194684193,
0.0155100757,
0.0376803689,
0.0764979124,
-0.0039059289,
-0.0317357294,
0.011728555,
0.0681161359,
0.013360383,
-0.0354754999,
-0.0088954587,
-0.0097566666,
0.0434489846,
-0.0437557697,
-0.0104087135,
-0.0581424274,
0.0039662574,
-0.0385452732,
-0.0241436921,
0.1047444865,
0.0272563882,
-0.0845142081,
-0.0262575783,
-0.0338849686,
0.0118720969,
0.0277519356,
0.0422458053,
-0.0164241847,
-0.0123751918,
-0.0317761526,
0.0335551985,
0.0551213399,
-0.0105264951,
0.00542031,
-0.0659641847,
0.0432131886,
-0.0059174392,
-0.0218310822,
-0.0217191521,
-0.0326948576,
0.0519607887,
-0.0400020443,
-0.0183877964,
0.0276085846,
-0.019604601,
-0.0325601771,
-0.0095937354,
0.0235749818,
-0.0181998238,
-0.0123891467,
-0.0258533526,
-0.0206460152,
0.0750653818,
0.0494950078,
0.0013020542,
-0.0134162214,
0.0241385568,
0.0098631755,
-0.023659965,
-0.0093087927,
0.0592234023,
-0.0206422284,
-0.0287079625,
-0.0030145925,
0.0240578577,
0.0029130394,
0.02872294,
-0.0253684446,
0.0449161083,
-0.0337020904,
0.0114286849,
-0.0117870048,
-0.0170458816,
-0.0167699922,
0.0253729783,
0.0140886353,
-0.0414770022,
-0.033418607,
-0.0168582816,
0.0065337936,
-0.0275057685,
-0.0666201189,
0.0052631837,
-0.0156738814,
-0.0811149999,
-0.0599773228,
-0.02764518,
0.0238793436,
0.0544108041,
0.0177361947,
-0.0148900831,
0.0669625923,
0.002690522,
-0.013755748,
-0.0145999733,
-0.0052337172,
-0.0139299892,
-0.0318570212,
0.0065315315,
0.0552030466,
-0.0340953395,
0.0065987981,
0.0266233683,
-0.0213269219,
-0.0638617277,
-0.0207423307,
0.0626677051,
0.0172236767,
0.0719385967,
-0.0391637757,
-0.0117232408,
-0.0058132298,
0.0329487883,
0.0209606327,
0.0210126769,
0.0385212377,
-0.0097389044,
-0.0266683046,
0.0490070246,
-0.0254885145,
0.0154145146,
-0.0000080103,
0.0180939082,
-0.0572445542,
-0.0594619736,
0.0155437198,
0.0150204124,
0.0878988951,
0.0380643941,
0.0633702725,
-0.0357037447,
0.0027959044,
-0.0237414204,
-0.0271381233,
-0.0487448499,
0.0352118611,
0.0125006847,
-0.0319793895,
0.004571653,
0.0937576294,
0.0102812238,
-0.0271328501,
-0.0806040615,
0.0280725639,
-0.0316930003,
-0.0434884094,
0.0036415101,
0.0160818193,
0.0001318674,
-0.0273253638,
0.0396801867,
0.021241514,
-0.0066600172,
0.0378171355,
0.0486982018,
0.0048358771,
-0.0265669338,
0.0464679971,
-0.1124347225,
0.027073862,
-0.0584517978,
0.0041403365,
0.0292072613,
0.0033945197,
0.0946929753,
-0.0024111213,
-0.0052753501,
-0.0147863319,
0.0547310598,
0.0087857135,
-0.0290315002,
0.0276229978,
-0.0130921407,
0.0342268199,
-0.0199862923,
0.0836965442,
-0.0955956951,
-0.0029639124,
0.0055921469,
-0.0219148677,
-0.0601559877,
-0.0603892803,
0.0351098366,
-0.0078318287,
-0.0246132445,
-0.0025285811,
-0.0216817018,
-0.0131089156,
-0.0057558385,
-0.0165232643,
-0.0134945866,
-0.0173662789,
0.0451589748,
0.0531346276,
0.0347743705,
0.0015633871,
-0.0227853879,
-0.0046608467,
-0.0095037259,
-0.0173958074,
0.0148847094,
-6.665260885e-33,
-0.0561573319,
-0.0056639221,
-0.0176456682,
0.0315671787,
-0.0376745984,
-0.0441581756,
-0.0441765226,
0.0383322164,
-0.0320441239,
-0.0088843545,
-0.0221281406,
0.0275429375,
0.0096295802,
0.0054505072,
0.0557783172,
0.0317017324,
0.0591147691,
0.004566703,
-0.0345961489,
0.0327676311,
0.0336479358,
0.022048153,
0.0863990411,
-0.0298096072,
-0.0122323101,
0.0235193726,
-0.0208131857,
0.0217967071,
-0.0454614535,
0.029417973,
0.0018871711,
0.0149971107,
0.0056374911,
-0.0674320385,
-0.0426119901,
0.0216130037,
-0.076982446,
-0.0394520275,
-0.0326762795,
0.0450134538,
-0.032809712,
0.0067956299,
0.0582914576,
-0.0092758033,
0.0479283445,
-0.0653028935,
0.0402167439,
-0.019548947,
-0.0217121691,
0.0131950518,
-0.0325084887,
0.0051220921,
-0.0280870348,
-0.0450347401,
0.0305501409,
0.0635646284,
0.0208685752,
0.0167604033,
-0.0735053271,
0.012417865,
-0.0103646182,
0.0422480181,
0.0800719112,
0.0090240128,
-0.0042187423,
0.019870773,
0.0056142192,
-0.0284118392,
-0.0445059277,
-0.0286320392,
0.0168380253,
0.0417786352,
0.0462243967,
0.0417735204,
-0.0281997845,
0.0032372463,
-0.0236078445,
0.0619804375,
0.0069063674,
0.0471244529,
0.019064622,
0.0170907509,
-0.0006101967,
-0.0081303148,
-0.0047181617,
-0.0015109866,
-0.0334779136,
0.000407288,
-0.004746981,
0.0225268602,
-0.0371254385,
0.030344585,
0.0443866476,
-0.0132635916,
0.0121523421,
0.0260460787,
-0.0339136235,
0.0634522289,
-0.0027610674,
0.0040872092,
-0.0126911039,
-0.0004061149,
0.0079594683,
0.0127878655,
-0.0025693206,
0.0074661295,
0.0396599509,
0.0426466241,
-0.0650646016,
-0.0166651066,
-0.0052111624,
-0.0299961418,
0.0014297634,
0.034090858,
0.0050830757,
-0.0154646188,
-0.0122728776,
0.0355633982,
-0.0010535776,
0.0114258481,
-0.03447254,
0.0058512227,
0.0008794082,
0.0227272548,
-0.0010483041,
0.0194472726,
-0.0291081946,
0.0143185752,
0.0495151058,
-0.0419699922,
-0.0434296466,
0.0070839985,
2.956e-7,
0.0731641427,
0.0499662645,
0.0209355056,
0.0438811891,
0.0097938841,
0.0427808091,
-0.0372597836,
0.0789145827,
-0.0153401894,
0.036032442,
0.0185808856,
0.0121996589,
0.018876642,
0.0094836904,
-0.0658278614,
-0.0631366074,
-0.0642332435,
0.0271767583,
0.0020707322,
-0.0329673514,
0.0633146539,
0.0958642885,
-0.0235835649,
0.0259878375,
-0.0080366917,
0.0386149883,
0.0786975026,
0.0163037851,
0.0187413841,
0.0370279476,
0.0187626425,
-0.0098214541,
-0.0347967744,
0.004354625,
-0.0100230593,
0.0275958516,
0.0369490348,
0.0518445969,
-0.020303607,
-0.0294082463,
0.0341250412,
0.0290766582,
0.0209514927,
-0.0567675345,
0.0524364412,
-0.121855028,
-0.0084997676,
0.0166112799,
-0.0265006814,
0.0325963683,
0.0373189002,
-0.0025187097,
0.0117644407,
0.0138590913,
0.0018848418,
-0.0182337202,
-0.0111575099,
-0.0581699349,
-0.0196017474,
-0.0350071304,
-0.0192553531,
-0.01014126,
-0.013748209,
-0.065897502,
-0.0001609176,
-0.0165487695,
-0.0219796803,
2.491411145e-34,
0.0430378057,
-0.0176281743,
-0.0072552739,
0.0187302008,
0.0114165694,
-0.0441205464,
-0.0612479486,
-0.0038188165,
0.021208657,
-0.0700613931,
-0.055031877
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10192v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10192v2 | Adam: Dense Retrieval Distillation with Adaptive Dark Examples | 2022-12-20T12:03:19 | 2024-06-06T15:20:27 | Chongyang Tao, Chang Liu, Tao Shen, Can Xu, Xiubo Geng, Binxing Jiao, Daxin Jiang | cs.CL | cs.CL | To improve the performance of the dual-encoder retriever, one effective
approach is knowledge distillation from the cross-encoder ranker. Existing
works construct the candidate passages following the supervised learning
setting where a query is paired with a positive passage and a batch of
negatives. However, through empirical observation, we find that even the hard
negatives from advanced methods are still too trivial for the teacher to
distinguish, preventing the teacher from transferring abundant dark knowledge
to the student through its soft label. To alleviate this issue, we propose
ADAM, a knowledge distillation framework that can better transfer the dark
knowledge held in the teacher with Adaptive Dark exAMples. Different from
previous works that only rely on one positive and hard negatives as candidate
passages, we create dark examples that all have moderate relevance to the query
through mixing-up and masking in discrete space. Furthermore, as the quality of
knowledge held in different training instances varies as measured by the
teacher's confidence score, we propose a self-paced distillation strategy that
adaptively concentrates on a subset of high-quality instances to conduct our
dark-example-based knowledge distillation to help the student learn better. We
conduct experiments on two widely-used benchmarks and verify the effectiveness
of our method. | [
0.0040860097,
0.047128696,
-0.0273812115,
0.0359615795,
-0.0028021848,
-0.0102758529,
-0.0231767111,
0.0081288982,
-0.0377780907,
-0.0315881595,
0.0071011833,
0.0032090947,
-0.0467253961,
0.0182810407,
0.011103238,
-0.0801398978,
0.0163778327,
0.0132064112,
0.0169037767,
-0.001503741,
-0.0146944001,
-0.014440747,
-0.012871962,
-0.0019296849,
0.0353533253,
-0.0023381158,
-0.0566561297,
0.0171932839,
0.0387709141,
-0.030736275,
0.0363325216,
0.01406244,
0.0132348072,
0.0130513581,
0.0000021815,
-0.043941848,
-0.0531873703,
-0.0016260458,
-0.0453921743,
0.0001543351,
-0.0556998551,
0.0203915052,
0.0663214549,
-0.0156788696,
-0.037654072,
0.0034306634,
0.0039943238,
0.0252398755,
0.0689283013,
0.0228369571,
-0.0131197134,
0.0079101268,
0.0068613696,
-0.0059277429,
0.0596458502,
-0.0197095573,
0.0232586283,
-0.0124808056,
0.0012046974,
0.0122337444,
-0.0227743573,
0.0381345339,
0.0431597456,
0.0276670419,
0.0259538461,
0.0107906358,
-0.0817685798,
0.0059770988,
0.0183985941,
0.0737891495,
-0.0279835053,
0.0155625492,
0.0075417468,
0.003012494,
0.0226830859,
-0.0146009689,
-0.0551719591,
-0.0132139772,
-0.0312659815,
0.0186559092,
-0.0539672151,
0.0329220332,
0.0089582261,
-0.0055291685,
-0.0079296781,
0.034328308,
-0.0047479738,
-0.0420419648,
0.0298935864,
0.0299180616,
-0.0030263395,
0.01940291,
0.0312939025,
0.0452689715,
0.0265969466,
-0.0025117234,
0.0038209597,
-0.0275086556,
-0.0143358773,
0.0063583362,
0.0423542932,
0.0326812714,
-0.0459267907,
0.0367425382,
-0.0508152544,
0.0202043597,
0.0304151122,
0.0830151662,
-0.0195021257,
-0.0146427555,
-0.0417929702,
0.0021855491,
-0.0450567938,
0.0715847164,
-0.0123732202,
0.0212313086,
-0.0310442802,
-0.0214630589,
-0.0592595153,
0.0023294555,
0.0176521335,
0.0244178791,
-0.0400056653,
0.0083471099,
-0.0390357375,
0.0444725603,
-0.0429682098,
0.0047247224,
0.0288421437,
-0.0142608164,
-0.0229256172,
-0.0333718024,
0.0355858728,
-0.0162092503,
0.0097588664,
0.0284470543,
-0.0535776354,
-0.0062017464,
-0.0723315999,
-0.0517727323,
0.0173008218,
-0.0392094702,
-0.0071672178,
-0.0495096445,
0.0126094101,
0.0078334017,
0.0119150244,
-0.0603678338,
0.0205039214,
-0.0093157189,
0.0017400242,
0.0572163947,
0.0106624411,
-0.0184900314,
0.0172633845,
0.0493872799,
-0.0471449606,
0.0650596842,
-0.0143931247,
0.0288417917,
0.0166978072,
-0.0050594681,
0.0183927007,
-0.0167180654,
0.067280829,
-0.0024048379,
-0.0471232831,
-0.0150829135,
-0.0187931191,
0.021354951,
0.011321554,
0.0404037572,
-0.0484239794,
-0.0280071683,
0.0074047465,
-0.0326756462,
0.0243080724,
0.0128730182,
-0.0129831582,
0.0108162612,
-0.0226953682,
0.0622555763,
-0.0020824517,
0.0524840839,
-0.0181076508,
-0.0061513497,
0.0311307013,
0.0371392891,
-0.039555531,
-0.0648628324,
0.033457581,
0.0208563302,
0.0227894206,
0.0484401584,
0.0702007115,
0.0416632779,
-0.0106164319,
0.0441804156,
0.0592334978,
-0.0477496572,
0.0249226205,
-0.0686065927,
0.0117038433,
0.0332471319,
0.0406271107,
-0.0619794838,
-0.016193293,
0.0034838645,
-0.0187430084,
-0.0490846857,
0.0356460735,
-0.0322739147,
0.0357711539,
-0.0658996552,
-0.0882424563,
-0.0235126838,
-0.0002042498,
0.0161678847,
0.032268364,
0.0550789721,
0.0306503233,
-0.0725516155,
-0.0139818639,
-0.0003528628,
-0.0184416473,
-0.0767232105,
0.0208179057,
0.0244987477,
0.0025149188,
0.0026721202,
0.0148365684,
-0.0306118038,
0.061497625,
-0.02525305,
-0.0496950001,
-0.026854638,
-0.063303791,
-0.0129321003,
0.0236125272,
-0.0720508024,
0.0202266593,
0.0445382856,
-0.0182258263,
-0.059503071,
-0.0079828352,
0.026087109,
0.0180198178,
-0.0078651579,
0.0110656703,
0.0040264553,
0.0121449195,
-0.0158292018,
0.0484277308,
-0.0062991809,
0.0058504632,
-0.0408249348,
-0.0525003448,
0.0000442535,
0.0138178933,
-0.0404370092,
-0.0215646271,
-0.0184894037,
0.0307825394,
0.0156875513,
-0.0206401423,
-0.0476168171,
0.0226968378,
0.0018406701,
0.0188849643,
-0.03520035,
-0.0224522166,
0.0000393769,
0.0221136734,
0.0287197344,
-0.0377344973,
-0.0389313884,
0.0261430349,
-0.0441087745,
0.0021479072,
-0.0026929663,
0.0709095672,
0.0277160928,
0.004860892,
-0.028675098,
0.0114924191,
0.0005962171,
-0.0526548252,
0.033183936,
-0.0035880054,
0.0658267811,
0.0027423832,
0.0209645405,
-0.0144631723,
-0.0044764392,
0.022931058,
-0.0745895877,
-0.0450515933,
0.0588117875,
-0.0242947042,
0.0369105972,
0.0488904193,
-0.0112042902,
-0.0898671299,
0.0379358903,
-0.0376279578,
0.0026837154,
0.0020182312,
-0.0096055428,
-0.0543927737,
0.0110520609,
-0.0066219354,
-0.0165360887,
-0.0457269922,
-0.0321128815,
0.006674537,
-0.062587522,
-0.0795451775,
0.031342715,
0.0209929682,
-0.016658226,
-0.0193148404,
-0.0014847149,
0.0930305943,
0.044555176,
0.0079209674,
-0.0000764242,
-0.0114864083,
-0.0105578378,
0.0366449356,
-0.0450307615,
0.0087994477,
-0.0114135668,
-0.0227038004,
-0.0476746634,
-0.0116573581,
0.0422176495,
-0.0565223806,
0.039726302,
-0.0638618171,
-0.0595652536,
-0.0069411062,
-0.0562734194,
-0.0554452725,
0.0214114618,
0.0400877893,
0.0243809223,
0.0083668046,
-0.0082859611,
-0.057109151,
-0.0029845322,
0.0133423069,
0.0447497927,
-0.0211777966,
-0.0244117174,
-0.0143783092,
0.025583351,
0.0402537882,
0.0124403713,
-0.0233372189,
-0.0287479479,
0.0132677425,
0.0622947738,
0.0550554208,
-0.0397100188,
0.0127239469,
0.0185105447,
0.0540209152,
-0.0059413128,
0.0089171659,
0.0170937181,
0.0321275443,
-0.0585320815,
-0.0527284779,
0.0442181528,
0.0125500718,
-0.0407145061,
-0.0282902773,
-0.0201636013,
0.0230060443,
0.0504672006,
0.0151340915,
-0.0531310178,
-0.0099582886,
-0.0227474608,
0.067639865,
0.0142272431,
-0.0342812836,
0.0218667779,
-0.117816329,
-0.0150302192,
0.0375795886,
-0.0209403522,
-0.0346613824,
-0.0305288397,
-0.0067235962,
-0.0344196297,
0.0137480553,
-0.0028513353,
0.0083282711,
0.0134872384,
0.0557389446,
0.0706028119,
-0.0508525409,
-0.0285199117,
-0.022175625,
-0.0430406071,
0.015155076,
0.0196945406,
-0.0246541928,
-0.0492286645,
-0.061709363,
-0.0419381708,
-0.0092487382,
0.0062103299,
0.0842533633,
0.013080772,
-0.0054473286,
0.0286875479,
0.0360470526,
-0.0094845407,
0.0141065074,
0.0278268717,
0.0764400437,
-0.0065097469,
-0.0157612972,
-0.036948707,
-0.077648595,
0.032279145,
0.0614048876,
-0.00863194,
0.0095884614,
0.0049367477,
-0.007073476,
0.047287643,
-0.0255026333,
-0.0023958322,
0.0454180874,
-0.0358872786,
0.0469910242,
-0.0306479894,
-0.0440889373,
0.0304046404,
0.0998529643,
0.0122820698,
0.0013198341,
-0.0022856067,
0.0020909735,
-0.053730268,
-0.0263594147,
-0.0071477089,
-0.017619757,
-0.0017586246,
-0.0452123024,
0.0111152492,
-0.0086800633,
-0.0204469897,
-0.0251239128,
-0.0405328795,
-0.0458307825,
0.0298016034,
0.040961232,
0.0214781258,
0.0796721429,
0.0111409687,
-0.0307050757,
0.0913510025,
0.0434459373,
0.0187607873,
-0.0225667469,
0.0302829389,
-0.0622434504,
0.0047593568,
0.0145034259,
-0.0785114765,
-0.0081152217,
0.0050510434,
0.0370888226,
-0.065583691,
0.0048891399,
0.0445829965,
0.0041928156,
0.0762665123,
0.0245150682,
-0.0065694712,
0.0056936489,
0.0614922382,
-0.0023876957,
-0.0082117021,
-0.0280720163,
0.0112351663,
0.0345788784,
0.013909447,
-0.0113680018,
0.0629109889,
0.0633590668,
0.023257317,
-0.1185993925,
-0.0419368185,
0.0406384543,
0.0123360381,
0.0173990224,
0.0048173275,
0.0024644719,
0.0452168696,
0.0695497319,
0.0707008913,
-0.0087106703,
0.0407475606,
0.0338840447,
0.0475510322,
-0.0049483678,
-0.0103114359,
-0.063520357,
-0.0272126812,
-0.0492410548,
-0.0047633806,
0.014092016,
-0.0099464199,
0.0240779556,
0.0261542704,
-0.0357207879,
0.0027871258,
-0.0208407771,
-0.0080124112,
-0.012491324,
-0.0190812703,
0.0402929746,
0.0423271209,
0.020402275,
0.0769601539,
-0.0591082834,
0.0625174791,
-0.0492812656,
-0.003041307,
-0.0399830192,
0.0068415455,
0.078645207,
0.0407762192,
0.0615313277,
-0.0136726527,
-0.0124112703,
-0.0378151499,
0.0147359995,
-0.0251579974,
0.0309225097,
-0.0113630733,
0.0655634329,
0.0568401068,
-0.0224762745,
-0.0435829274,
-0.0160632879,
-0.0218705311,
-0.0151789393,
-0.023379894,
-0.0003786695,
-6.791450938e-33,
-0.0363487527,
0.0096008899,
-0.0086849844,
-0.017007852,
0.0191575922,
-0.0068974663,
0.0038974734,
-0.0252148472,
-0.0020285875,
0.0449807979,
-0.0146220801,
0.0187382307,
0.016590368,
0.0365452655,
0.0268526021,
-0.0046557118,
0.0865598619,
0.0272005461,
-0.0057912488,
0.0591258705,
0.0549583063,
0.0637292266,
0.0232478697,
-0.0932262093,
-0.0404630974,
0.0065809251,
0.0032661967,
-0.0034031868,
-0.0144563792,
0.0062713474,
0.0027494209,
0.0545277782,
-0.0088628605,
-0.0306929275,
-0.0298468005,
-0.0595457852,
-0.1294999272,
-0.0495429821,
-0.0489625111,
-0.0021127574,
-0.040668495,
-0.0144999567,
0.0703392178,
-0.0134617127,
0.013970579,
-0.0102517707,
0.040240515,
0.0003338216,
-0.0001497723,
-0.0765918419,
-0.0075518331,
-0.0167593863,
-0.0313708298,
-0.0401815549,
0.0279328283,
0.0094397124,
0.01579291,
-0.0146590341,
-0.08422032,
0.0239893161,
0.0076465397,
0.0408793092,
0.0203426648,
0.0166021306,
-0.0477694832,
0.0577607863,
-0.0041944631,
-0.0189049114,
0.0550072864,
-0.0188120864,
0.0377900228,
0.0681770816,
0.0055655208,
0.0541385822,
0.0911792442,
-0.0267700329,
-0.0399793424,
0.0593033172,
-0.0463367105,
0.0208553188,
-0.0063219937,
0.0234419256,
-0.0403580107,
-0.0188838039,
-0.0237897951,
-0.0304405484,
-0.0298896898,
-0.0115240579,
0.0402514376,
0.0214014594,
-0.0270971749,
0.0060261381,
0.0079469467,
-0.0400232561,
-0.0067604096,
0.0189228747,
-0.0246585272,
-0.0105159367,
0.0047136601,
-0.0147503484,
-0.0353301242,
-0.0451246686,
0.0679656565,
0.0042171902,
-0.0037036643,
0.0316204801,
0.0605440587,
0.0305493549,
-0.0374931842,
-0.0069614458,
-0.0263621043,
0.0025652619,
0.0398159511,
-0.0396309532,
-0.0122245839,
0.0231885668,
-0.0179996267,
0.0498663262,
0.0332560316,
0.0178122558,
-0.0407181829,
-0.0323512144,
0.0342628062,
-0.0001867691,
0.00599402,
-0.0001617101,
-0.0066526965,
-0.0744521543,
0.0193161052,
-0.0581516549,
-0.0026787142,
0.0286874045,
2.879e-7,
-0.0136465076,
-0.0120118959,
0.0131475115,
-0.0287116002,
-0.0204262119,
0.020729946,
-0.0122414287,
0.0306859203,
0.0104358625,
-0.0645355955,
0.0192678366,
0.0340018161,
0.0291547943,
0.0490365773,
-0.0486931913,
-0.0495469943,
0.002772152,
-0.0699057579,
-0.0298466031,
-0.0353068002,
0.0771460608,
0.0450309962,
0.0525712334,
-0.0027229097,
0.0357406437,
-0.0386329703,
0.0244738292,
0.0199780632,
0.0461680144,
0.0136055136,
0.0454201028,
0.0036448683,
0.0238534622,
0.0130237825,
-0.0195019897,
0.0040223901,
0.0054128342,
0.0084918048,
-0.0266238209,
-0.0657245666,
-0.0018398165,
0.0412952118,
0.0195272584,
-0.0040742108,
0.0606796592,
-0.0258804187,
0.0038490198,
0.0452449098,
-0.0597129725,
-0.008273012,
0.0052184355,
0.0255035758,
0.023480054,
0.0008743423,
-0.018376017,
0.0404486768,
-0.0161892883,
-0.0783146322,
-0.0055725803,
0.004120803,
-0.0028912658,
-0.0197924934,
-0.0029260151,
-0.0657185912,
-0.0431235582,
-0.0183242112,
0.0030405703,
2.403602176e-34,
0.0277890433,
0.0237052441,
0.0143085141,
0.0155257955,
0.0042682914,
-0.0219980385,
-0.0690347105,
0.0023838452,
0.0021398435,
-0.0012583502,
-0.0297351107
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10191v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10191v1 | Emotion Selectable End-to-End Text-based Speech Editing | 2022-12-20T12:02:40 | 2022-12-20T12:02:40 | Tao Wang, Jiangyan Yi, Ruibo Fu, Jianhua Tao, Zhengqi Wen, Chu Yuan Zhang | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS | Text-based speech editing allows users to edit speech by intuitively cutting,
copying, and pasting text to speed up the process of editing speech. In the
previous work, CampNet (context-aware mask prediction network) is proposed to
realize text-based speech editing, significantly improving the quality of
edited speech. This paper aims at a new task: adding emotional effect to the
editing speech during the text-based speech editing to make the generated
speech more expressive. To achieve this task, we propose Emo-CampNet (emotion
CampNet), which can provide the option of emotional attributes for the
generated speech in text-based speech editing and has the one-shot ability to
edit unseen speakers' speech. Firstly, we propose an end-to-end
emotion-selectable text-based speech editing model. The key idea of the model
is to control the emotion of generated speech by introducing additional emotion
attributes based on the context-aware mask prediction network. Secondly, to
prevent the emotion of the generated speech from being interfered by the
emotional components in the original speech, a neutral content generator is
proposed to remove the emotion from the original speech, which is optimized by
the generative adversarial framework. Thirdly, two data augmentation methods
are proposed to enrich the emotional and pronunciation information in the
training set, which can enable the model to edit the unseen speaker's speech.
The experimental results that 1) Emo-CampNet can effectively control the
emotion of the generated speech in the process of text-based speech editing;
And can edit unseen speakers' speech. 2) Detailed ablation experiments further
prove the effectiveness of emotional selectivity and data augmentation methods.
The demo page is available at https://hairuo55.github.io/Emo-CampNet/ | [
0.0168312471,
0.0107748676,
0.0067870468,
0.0004724001,
-0.0040376745,
-0.0137904715,
0.0220467113,
-0.0032239847,
-0.0199605208,
-0.0217084568,
-0.0876120403,
-0.0089354105,
-0.0197469946,
0.0012106121,
0.0303923469,
-0.1010667831,
0.010568819,
0.0540368259,
0.0211428516,
0.0105546284,
0.0524897724,
0.0122793932,
-0.0230334327,
0.0272506997,
-0.0314545557,
-0.0013184666,
-0.0416958034,
0.0375610851,
0.0281097516,
0.0043838834,
0.035100311,
0.0309035573,
-0.0039356039,
0.0107268523,
0.0000021684,
-0.0104689682,
-0.0196866971,
0.0084213158,
-0.0076457933,
0.0022278458,
0.0827845261,
0.0272888765,
-0.0782721415,
0.0098543894,
-0.006341313,
0.0137345577,
0.077520825,
0.076427348,
0.0900466815,
0.0828312933,
-0.0397493467,
-0.0076673208,
-0.0119949607,
-0.0370296165,
0.0346718989,
0.0158918928,
0.0109798731,
-0.050293114,
0.0077160704,
-0.0494941995,
-0.0431995057,
0.0278630313,
-0.0016566848,
-0.0208793823,
0.0490221344,
0.017197052,
-0.0362619758,
-0.0214144103,
0.0037980988,
0.0382902138,
-0.0455196127,
0.0284817759,
0.0322512463,
-0.0135322036,
0.0163758527,
-0.0380893722,
-0.0189304519,
-0.0229242481,
0.0288085993,
0.0017164751,
-0.0499741659,
0.0130987186,
0.0185893439,
0.0180396736,
0.0481995977,
-0.001542709,
0.0105689298,
-0.0402290225,
-0.0020731238,
-0.0521658398,
-0.0126112849,
-0.0302612111,
0.0624975301,
-0.0044762087,
-0.0006989543,
-0.007373421,
-0.0858286545,
-0.090671517,
-0.0609236658,
-0.0421101898,
-0.0131775336,
0.0126562212,
-0.0077927201,
0.0333798826,
-0.0167156607,
0.0098107122,
0.016612675,
-0.0066367178,
0.0235751271,
-0.0183326751,
-0.0114142559,
0.0117741097,
-0.0470830798,
0.030373659,
-0.0389373451,
-0.0275378898,
-0.0758600309,
-0.0537739508,
-0.0681629851,
0.0061263177,
-0.0050103883,
0.0392994769,
-0.0471001603,
-0.0139430864,
0.014542059,
-0.033779487,
-0.0146118281,
0.0648509935,
0.0133918114,
-0.0083644446,
0.0092879152,
0.0122764306,
0.0479516648,
-0.0331563242,
0.0367465466,
0.0480456948,
-0.0225175675,
0.0199013446,
-0.0633312762,
-0.0176271126,
-0.0148339067,
-0.0081051784,
-0.0008022549,
-0.0288936719,
-0.0056670662,
-0.0570711605,
-0.015754411,
-0.0777795538,
0.0009207746,
-0.0113888131,
0.0028572888,
0.032201089,
-0.0204615463,
-0.0373638459,
0.0475163311,
0.0305232164,
-0.0155499475,
-0.0005793151,
0.0672988594,
0.0451741815,
0.0600025095,
-0.0076733343,
0.0433925763,
0.0520267859,
0.0245410968,
-0.0137114543,
-0.0353397429,
-0.0840878338,
-0.0186063591,
0.0455756038,
0.03687796,
0.017081365,
-0.0444651172,
-0.0525767915,
0.07229954,
-0.0065145437,
0.0192152634,
0.0628129914,
-0.0136978384,
0.0218627881,
-0.0036876369,
-0.0173289087,
0.0064868792,
0.0714769289,
-0.0244066212,
-0.0077168075,
0.0418766774,
-0.04065286,
-0.0174470022,
-0.0518270507,
0.0135280443,
-0.0170697309,
0.0240533426,
-0.0206284374,
0.0082432413,
0.0206727888,
-0.0623042174,
-0.0442484766,
-0.0274019204,
-0.1016720459,
-0.01786552,
-0.014495397,
-0.015645463,
0.0367204063,
0.0227821153,
-0.0446966141,
0.0127734393,
-0.0744006187,
-0.0584566854,
0.0207672119,
0.0308248177,
-0.0341388062,
0.0313994996,
-0.0803304687,
0.0222291201,
0.001281143,
-0.0139643932,
0.0292049758,
-0.0276111439,
0.0338039026,
0.0020079883,
0.0485733822,
0.0131727699,
-0.0135847265,
-0.0010259409,
-0.030623069,
0.0082583427,
0.0374408066,
0.0138090355,
0.0081989979,
-0.045378238,
-0.0080139488,
-0.0095224464,
-0.0157118514,
-0.0227625016,
0.0179724265,
-0.0239775032,
-0.0388812311,
0.0031757972,
-0.0604378842,
0.0029427777,
0.0680908039,
-0.0261810459,
-0.0541132167,
0.0474794544,
-0.0181830637,
0.028566055,
-0.0362205729,
0.0199433621,
-0.0149461143,
0.0128897959,
0.0188618898,
-0.0097411787,
0.0095281024,
-0.005701208,
0.0362078324,
0.0578381233,
-0.0105923861,
-0.0312693082,
-0.0585740618,
0.0097289057,
0.0225878041,
0.0034323949,
-0.0110259997,
-0.0450791009,
-0.0499014147,
-0.0650035217,
-0.0614588596,
0.0120173274,
-0.0073213968,
-0.0171883348,
0.0305138286,
0.0141799534,
-0.0233095195,
-0.0239812322,
-0.0285453871,
-0.0292122401,
-0.0457780585,
-0.03060917,
-0.0095650461,
0.0004091403,
0.023397265,
-0.0647565126,
0.0251443479,
0.0145201413,
0.0011803034,
-0.0092631029,
-0.0693872645,
0.0098205637,
0.0497601032,
-0.0110955732,
0.0404491574,
-0.006987852,
-0.0616388656,
-0.0251107514,
0.0079892706,
0.0329364575,
0.0808448866,
0.0168216638,
0.0466551892,
-0.0073535098,
0.0070253769,
0.0007708805,
0.0307959393,
0.0170730799,
0.0858565941,
0.0027341803,
0.0150108086,
0.0133305266,
0.0309316348,
0.0652400032,
-0.0025037543,
-0.0173079595,
0.0322463289,
0.0224750135,
-0.0501461625,
0.0069229575,
-0.0349987075,
-0.0460834168,
-0.0297437068,
-0.0225749686,
-0.0371980853,
0.020155441,
0.0089711212,
-0.0570535213,
-0.0278400686,
-0.0320294686,
0.0256402139,
0.0085912654,
-0.0373127908,
0.0181562491,
0.0071982807,
-0.0365225002,
-0.0438170098,
-0.0321412943,
0.0082592741,
-0.0538091511,
-0.0134913493,
-0.0139738824,
-0.0401438661,
-0.0027216491,
-0.0046471572,
-0.0097991768,
0.0170807466,
-0.0239020716,
0.0235230457,
0.0412802137,
-0.0260034837,
0.0261207726,
-0.0441749059,
0.0479657575,
0.0585402474,
-0.0303365886,
0.0144388014,
-0.0071395324,
0.0245047379,
0.0379512906,
0.0090855891,
-0.0124176182,
-0.0138078881,
0.0286005288,
0.0331210829,
0.0500951596,
-0.0157809574,
0.0135828527,
0.0231417995,
-0.0311505683,
-0.0054576192,
-0.0380893238,
-0.0309925936,
0.0333802924,
-0.0336557366,
0.064006798,
0.0811938345,
0.0360580906,
-0.0125985593,
0.0026551217,
-0.0153757222,
0.0005861027,
0.0360627547,
0.0424409434,
-0.0368545987,
-0.0268619172,
0.0549630225,
0.051135432,
-0.0317171626,
-0.0151512092,
-0.0264021847,
-0.0661911443,
0.043743439,
0.0135351298,
0.0098150643,
-0.0444784276,
0.0362642072,
0.0454094112,
-0.0047552958,
-0.0132006723,
-0.007647831,
0.0336128138,
-0.0198067054,
0.0345112905,
-0.0059557026,
-0.014996402,
-0.0244118795,
-0.0022650829,
0.0913261473,
0.0249145273,
0.0843951032,
-0.0193642396,
-0.0202047825,
0.0134207271,
0.0533155799,
-0.0109435413,
0.0031127366,
0.074937664,
0.0153297726,
-0.0281368438,
0.0068725306,
0.0761239827,
0.0660804361,
-0.0033935311,
0.01338345,
0.0160072073,
-0.0049833786,
0.0032485418,
-0.0068756589,
0.0085873595,
0.0323021598,
0.0220801905,
0.0478152968,
-0.0810378492,
-0.0095161162,
-0.0402348936,
0.0080271522,
-0.081378378,
-0.0497478694,
0.0112810191,
-0.0209577437,
-0.0394040123,
-0.0717490241,
-0.0257530361,
0.0354144499,
0.011555803,
0.0195255559,
-0.0265750326,
0.0185385067,
-0.0086422646,
0.0017981846,
-0.0296133906,
0.0415589325,
0.0368102863,
-0.025788255,
-0.0357645042,
0.0442113951,
-0.0740932077,
-0.0094326045,
-0.001983193,
0.0336505361,
-0.0472130142,
0.0161634479,
0.0291521512,
0.0128919613,
0.0515773371,
-0.0072152326,
-0.0974816084,
0.035073664,
0.0161322095,
-0.0290755425,
0.034259215,
0.1015443429,
0.0231467746,
-0.0075451289,
0.0210866462,
-0.0143390093,
0.0486456379,
0.0350594781,
-0.0266498569,
0.0009111812,
-0.0029591853,
-0.0312722363,
-0.0007600805,
-0.0180630106,
0.0018202139,
0.0297728386,
-0.0835454166,
0.0213799402,
-0.0069849882,
0.0372996889,
-0.0582750402,
0.0057155392,
-0.0271972921,
0.0140626524,
-0.0342909582,
-0.0521482378,
-0.0113189286,
-0.0749455094,
-0.0136506576,
0.0338131152,
-0.0101607274,
0.0304840226,
0.0273863692,
0.0594190471,
0.0118115935,
0.025542086,
0.0356051922,
0.01736499,
-0.0008646058,
0.0416838564,
0.0046644313,
-0.0344075076,
0.0181209128,
0.0299323015,
-0.0301170424,
0.0572812073,
-0.0383479185,
0.0137592386,
0.0091136582,
-0.0338007212,
0.0456572361,
-0.0273062177,
0.0198185313,
-0.0094639286,
0.0188595429,
-0.002083736,
-0.0445286855,
-0.0239345524,
-0.0421338603,
0.016111102,
0.0325099938,
0.0092613772,
-0.048679851,
0.0970157161,
-0.031745743,
0.0133551722,
-0.0621164255,
0.0051805559,
0.0523180589,
-0.0194205642,
-0.0012409235,
0.0230972059,
-0.0168993957,
-0.0353594571,
0.0495919473,
-0.0062597296,
-0.0182346534,
-0.0582778193,
0.0464500263,
-0.0232927445,
-0.0722266883,
0.0449627303,
-0.0017820215,
0.0086318003,
-0.0200183578,
-0.0156871416,
0.0148707042,
-5.624940303e-33,
-0.0137419198,
0.0265255775,
-0.0356191248,
0.0304812584,
-0.0574391074,
-0.0027760644,
-0.047078494,
0.0389126539,
0.0213232581,
0.0203203801,
-0.0285426583,
0.0254484843,
-0.0074932785,
0.0301172268,
-0.0233087186,
0.0152300056,
0.0712228194,
-0.0181472059,
0.0198538136,
0.0408777297,
0.0394511148,
0.0371375605,
0.0527834557,
-0.0936381966,
-0.0110853529,
0.0253428277,
-0.0537592545,
-0.0346981697,
0.0327034742,
0.0224822778,
0.05975594,
0.0289032273,
-0.0384909026,
-0.0441025868,
-0.0229699966,
0.0041187042,
-0.0065250038,
-0.0205059256,
-0.0562646315,
0.0247067716,
-0.0455802605,
-0.0737245679,
0.0380849726,
0.0323869474,
-0.005547544,
-0.0014157286,
0.0318163037,
-0.0194898639,
0.0099615557,
-0.0736722946,
-0.0139625762,
0.0243843086,
-0.0230833665,
-0.0623366572,
0.041060213,
0.0181711633,
-0.0010201092,
-0.032524135,
-0.0902075768,
0.0174710061,
0.0166097023,
0.0227214154,
-0.0183131844,
-0.0057471576,
0.0066656698,
0.0603147522,
0.0262945555,
-0.0229855683,
0.0128293866,
0.0584475696,
0.0208175872,
0.0460271724,
0.0691095218,
0.041411031,
0.0055325008,
-0.0596411154,
-0.0070268237,
0.0193432532,
0.0055271643,
-0.011173578,
0.0105718672,
0.0697485134,
0.0054714656,
0.0196371432,
-0.0360838883,
-0.0387163162,
-0.0139228292,
-0.0245089997,
0.0220693517,
0.0075513669,
-0.0113514252,
-0.0199322347,
-0.0061291582,
-0.0194585342,
0.0235725977,
0.010446622,
-0.0655520707,
0.0705237165,
0.0061025722,
-0.0318188593,
-0.0064905542,
0.0312961899,
0.0826515555,
0.0456547327,
0.0379042849,
-0.015157504,
0.0091558509,
0.0686926097,
-0.0595611297,
-0.0071910499,
-0.0153355226,
0.0755048767,
0.004752859,
0.0005249957,
-0.0599116683,
0.0077441777,
-0.0180300996,
-0.018232286,
-0.0116857281,
0.052599065,
-0.0066371337,
-0.0381633639,
0.0099981343,
0.0100164898,
-0.0695412382,
0.0217814818,
0.0133517096,
-0.0092423754,
0.0538301766,
-0.0381786153,
-0.0083826026,
-0.0107324617,
2.972e-7,
-0.0321283154,
0.0144053539,
0.0187870096,
-0.0595935173,
0.0629367977,
0.0676861331,
-0.01613345,
0.0289718565,
0.0094848508,
-0.0151766529,
0.0152060715,
-0.0279313065,
0.0674545914,
0.0047687748,
-0.0753376707,
0.0097561376,
-0.0449247994,
0.0583369359,
0.0040404568,
0.0005989983,
0.0762479454,
0.0453890152,
0.043603573,
0.0111220339,
0.0366171226,
0.0633458868,
0.0177379567,
-0.0068480377,
0.0208674781,
-0.0311189219,
-0.0171599146,
-0.0061095189,
-0.0155472644,
-0.0217234213,
-0.0454208031,
-0.00848334,
0.0566034578,
0.0682821572,
-0.0177200958,
-0.0362611115,
0.0336303115,
0.0638749823,
-0.0292552374,
0.0258561783,
0.0560122132,
-0.0378781781,
-0.0061551011,
-0.0104939425,
-0.013487055,
0.0615934208,
0.0142223369,
-0.0431326814,
-0.052620586,
-0.0001463977,
0.0270627029,
0.0230483543,
-0.0179439634,
-0.0512620322,
-0.0112454752,
-0.0359436236,
-0.0330491289,
-0.0323296823,
-0.0587697849,
0.018386675,
-0.0187334288,
-0.0379266031,
-0.0292144287,
1.853595027e-34,
-0.0248863902,
0.0141621651,
0.003493103,
-0.0064035002,
0.0019203773,
0.0317503437,
0.0419740379,
-0.0027477737,
0.0359563902,
-0.0244498849,
-0.0710520521
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10190v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10190v1 | Pay Attention to Your Tone: Introducing a New Dataset for Polite Language Rewrite | 2022-12-20T12:02:34 | 2022-12-20T12:02:34 | Xun Wang, Tao Ge, Allen Mao, Yuki Li, Furu Wei, Si-Qing Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce \textsc{PoliteRewrite} -- a dataset for polite language rewrite
which is a novel sentence rewrite task. Compared with previous text style
transfer tasks that can be mostly addressed by slight token- or phrase-level
edits, polite language rewrite requires deep understanding and extensive
sentence-level edits over an offensive and impolite sentence to deliver the
same message euphemistically and politely, which is more challenging -- not
only for NLP models but also for human annotators to rewrite with effort. To
alleviate the human effort for efficient annotation, we first propose a novel
annotation paradigm by a collaboration of human annotators and GPT-3.5 to
annotate \textsc{PoliteRewrite}. The released dataset has 10K polite sentence
rewrites annotated collaboratively by GPT-3.5 and human, which can be used as
gold standard for training, validation and test; and 100K high-quality polite
sentence rewrites by GPT-3.5 without human review. We wish this work (The
dataset (10K+100K) will be released soon) could contribute to the research on
more challenging sentence rewrite, and provoke more thought in future on
resource annotation paradigm with the help of the large-scaled pretrained
models. | [
0.0742862523,
0.0177510101,
-0.0048432127,
0.042568773,
-0.026809819,
0.0102478703,
-0.0335998125,
-0.0047925184,
-0.0400035642,
-0.0518312231,
-0.0769903436,
0.0253568403,
-0.0107389297,
-0.0289125871,
0.0435477272,
-0.103099376,
0.0189619195,
0.032145828,
0.0727090314,
0.0174590833,
0.0671036392,
0.0042884797,
0.0215365291,
0.0593288504,
-0.0558233224,
-0.0372954309,
0.0150950085,
0.0867348835,
0.0106269857,
0.0088713812,
0.0840853229,
0.070349656,
-0.0135995122,
0.0288957916,
0.0000017773,
-0.0285804849,
-0.0178536233,
0.0102017634,
0.0004936508,
0.0474972278,
0.0757821798,
-0.0139572686,
-0.0335033834,
0.0029492909,
-0.0331073664,
0.0115713924,
0.0641205609,
0.0895115063,
0.1283865422,
0.1332823336,
-0.0176533218,
-0.011633086,
-0.021054754,
-0.0463684201,
0.0194250476,
-0.030283846,
0.004147389,
-0.0083255637,
-0.0570107549,
0.0342510231,
-0.0118215038,
0.0277578328,
0.0171392541,
-0.0705658644,
0.0033722585,
-0.0255888104,
-0.0795578212,
0.0313031413,
-0.0239632707,
0.06001807,
-0.0124541475,
-0.0127573162,
-0.0034889781,
0.0162565503,
0.0192771908,
-0.0331711024,
-0.026045749,
-0.0216555353,
0.0296390373,
0.0290549304,
-0.0183114111,
-0.0082115075,
0.0079230815,
0.0247711558,
0.0738554001,
0.0268131103,
0.0219083112,
-0.0281046499,
-0.0429012328,
0.0122384401,
-0.007002349,
-0.0518762022,
0.02817766,
-0.0017068996,
-0.0143775539,
-0.0151487095,
-0.083203651,
-0.0326962546,
0.0240722653,
-0.0273861364,
0.0467606857,
0.0061883144,
-0.0040286551,
0.0257067271,
-0.0004189108,
0.0384836383,
-0.0347469226,
0.0178944506,
-0.0243087579,
-0.0102228485,
-0.0461963192,
-0.0073157139,
-0.0785696581,
0.0080130007,
-0.0491222553,
0.0081382189,
-0.0506513901,
0.011467359,
-0.0033577459,
-0.0441398583,
0.0299973972,
0.0210237,
-0.0547411144,
-0.0288134776,
0.0091169067,
0.03464761,
-0.0142444214,
0.0120347887,
0.0260310508,
-0.0382026434,
-0.004258424,
0.0154668204,
0.024045147,
-0.0334042534,
-0.012344636,
0.0490495227,
-0.0284665357,
-0.0003084046,
-0.0477758944,
-0.016781535,
-0.0164196808,
-0.0183112063,
-0.0355275571,
-0.0527495854,
0.039251402,
-0.0484701693,
-0.0209857188,
-0.0325877182,
0.0031941922,
0.0247403756,
-0.0279261041,
0.054305248,
-0.03576646,
-0.0131650837,
0.0381664187,
-0.0007039538,
-0.041714713,
0.0304393265,
0.0614657402,
0.0164066926,
0.0612793192,
0.0078943577,
0.0325114243,
0.0291163698,
-0.0130195133,
0.0134936795,
0.0203064177,
0.0131976642,
-0.0190373156,
0.0600269549,
0.0812498778,
0.0730073079,
-0.0433554687,
-0.0386466049,
0.0845098794,
-0.0029762529,
-0.0126151443,
0.0632021874,
0.0738969222,
0.0498149581,
0.0061476058,
0.0161714479,
-0.0631485581,
0.0043906188,
0.0071370956,
0.0081429267,
0.0271117743,
-0.0221904106,
-0.0145907644,
-0.0336122923,
0.0199851152,
-0.0083144726,
-0.0105663529,
-0.0570781343,
-0.0196799617,
0.0587738417,
-0.0443386063,
0.0076241074,
0.0087017212,
-0.0826901644,
-0.0022217908,
-0.0047102743,
0.0005842629,
0.0817805007,
0.0468222611,
-0.0353434831,
-0.032089863,
-0.0410925075,
0.0240390133,
0.0250785798,
0.0630345121,
-0.033821959,
0.0105029466,
-0.0573338158,
0.019782804,
-0.0281767789,
0.0117065432,
0.0149860168,
0.0525955223,
-0.019115163,
0.0210973006,
-0.0303112473,
-0.0507105924,
0.038825389,
0.0505615249,
-0.0176109355,
0.0465140194,
0.0099030584,
0.0271089673,
0.002508705,
-0.0207634587,
-0.014110636,
-0.0330827758,
-0.0297699347,
-0.0191643983,
-0.0080747753,
-0.0382738151,
-0.070520401,
0.0185140688,
-0.064387992,
-0.0374082737,
0.0552912652,
-0.0594122671,
-0.0362261534,
-0.0200267993,
-0.0375747494,
0.0464511998,
-0.0488034338,
0.0143918246,
0.0035586208,
0.024145009,
-0.0245748907,
-0.0095908483,
0.0250417143,
-0.0367583595,
0.0083761467,
-0.0298033096,
0.0042174924,
-0.031331487,
-0.0447462127,
-0.0371174663,
-0.0025866539,
0.0003524898,
0.0057843658,
0.0491379797,
-0.0316579938,
-0.0188816059,
-0.084453471,
0.0089503583,
-0.0147135584,
0.0040513976,
0.0620682761,
0.0131813679,
-0.0115972469,
-0.026402507,
-0.0236838218,
-0.0235605687,
-0.0437395163,
0.0225024968,
0.0819803849,
-0.0330617689,
-0.0003285716,
-0.0575148538,
-0.0081382459,
0.0011140358,
-0.0046500461,
0.0009452077,
-0.015886968,
-0.016184859,
0.0306954831,
0.0057360004,
0.007445008,
0.0342278853,
-0.0934551731,
-0.0032453085,
0.0392045192,
0.0805836171,
0.0774923488,
0.0485171638,
0.0302606691,
-0.0137258656,
0.0076068565,
-0.0064471103,
0.0305988658,
-0.0107711144,
-0.0138546964,
-0.0231694579,
-0.0541517213,
0.0474568009,
0.0264199506,
0.0259439126,
0.005677761,
-0.05719731,
-0.0051702606,
-0.0027603977,
-0.0471840389,
0.0067921882,
-0.0195134636,
-0.0348850973,
-0.0194986463,
-0.0308650862,
-0.021935964,
0.0444828458,
-0.0314808562,
-0.0372358933,
-0.0148027036,
0.0020063114,
-0.009065507,
0.0300275292,
-0.0354791805,
0.0306369495,
-0.0139075117,
-0.0260592196,
-0.0096566565,
-0.0257216021,
0.0493273027,
-0.0156575721,
0.0033701905,
-0.0452911258,
-0.0056516109,
0.0023292461,
-0.0518808514,
-0.0192613285,
-0.0577259362,
-0.01133152,
-0.0024280048,
0.0211871397,
-0.0366960578,
-0.0001255609,
-0.0176797584,
-0.003076589,
0.0759520978,
-0.0236773193,
-0.0017130272,
-0.0161987431,
0.0276385956,
0.0408707634,
0.0410684794,
-0.0019505526,
0.0258512516,
0.0333162881,
0.0610981509,
-0.0173355602,
-0.0354002416,
-0.0233369134,
0.0047449884,
-0.0255606845,
-0.0554627702,
-0.0374041051,
-0.0166172497,
0.062455453,
-0.0603846721,
-0.0168526266,
0.1009863019,
-0.0093630273,
-0.0563232638,
0.0056838668,
0.0286225323,
0.0369527005,
0.0247897878,
0.0289704688,
-0.0819101408,
-0.0402201675,
0.0029728664,
0.0173558798,
-0.0103286933,
-0.0156163191,
-0.0116623808,
-0.0700176433,
0.0591005087,
-0.00743656,
-0.0359644853,
-0.0025983392,
0.0174593572,
0.0033610987,
0.0045762709,
0.0146049373,
-0.0188194644,
0.0056837378,
-0.0123335868,
-0.002491357,
-0.0323723555,
-0.0171564687,
-0.0170320924,
-0.0286538042,
0.072929576,
0.0417682268,
0.0686571747,
0.023403978,
-0.0101375123,
0.0244646426,
0.0329306833,
-0.0007876417,
-0.0029788944,
0.0660754517,
-0.0007244826,
-0.006671981,
-0.0090291305,
0.0337423533,
-0.0278772451,
-0.0126140397,
0.0357882753,
0.0441109315,
0.0072421487,
-0.0028062274,
-0.0157378111,
0.0169865415,
0.0330046266,
0.0651200637,
0.0612306856,
-0.033707682,
-0.0475365445,
-0.040365871,
-0.0020936274,
-0.0877637938,
-0.0172373485,
0.0010166968,
-0.0662712529,
-0.0061325799,
-0.1130976304,
-0.0382928029,
0.03404871,
0.0268722102,
0.0301019214,
-0.0090692854,
-0.003094587,
-0.0165907536,
-0.0095004644,
-0.0174273271,
-0.0317294262,
0.0128892353,
-0.0269066449,
-0.0459098704,
-0.0265608877,
-0.0029996191,
-0.0022224297,
-0.0158776939,
-0.0259642117,
-0.0639175251,
0.0259126779,
0.0728430972,
0.0177472997,
0.0464716591,
-0.012545744,
-0.0672791377,
0.0084914519,
0.0335765556,
-0.0366630293,
0.0288891066,
0.0668293312,
0.0237996671,
0.010046755,
0.0770815313,
-0.0056200614,
0.0047948686,
0.0442483388,
0.0441576317,
0.0057952604,
-0.0436239168,
0.0210041348,
0.0133546488,
0.0058088009,
0.0176616553,
-0.0031310637,
-0.0335521661,
0.0219103694,
-0.0313320607,
-0.015610083,
-0.0625108406,
0.0199843589,
0.011302609,
0.0135636479,
-0.0496875644,
-0.0325071849,
-0.0145276058,
-0.0305080954,
-0.0302563999,
-0.0052529457,
0.0213866327,
0.0188687555,
-0.00222029,
0.0414880067,
-0.0303427037,
0.034149915,
0.0123742148,
0.0111220814,
0.0140784113,
0.0371425003,
0.0460718498,
0.002166125,
-0.0197233707,
0.0352571905,
-0.0332396775,
0.0151089188,
-0.0187356025,
0.0239012633,
0.0263544321,
-0.0144116012,
0.0893808827,
-0.0384372547,
-0.0184449907,
-0.0040300949,
0.0687198192,
-0.0117184576,
-0.0358275436,
0.0169687457,
-0.0194615182,
-0.0195833985,
0.0140362596,
0.0742606446,
-0.0247178599,
0.0484533347,
0.0322947763,
-0.015834203,
-0.0416035354,
-0.0248765014,
0.0325027518,
-0.0024670658,
0.0146065857,
-0.0058478666,
-0.0116913626,
-0.0391557664,
0.002161463,
-0.0117210913,
-0.0091467332,
-0.0124461437,
0.0300886761,
0.0361468717,
-0.0233004987,
-0.0326107331,
-0.0496437326,
0.0244804751,
-0.0069417134,
-0.0449855216,
-0.0512066633,
-5.480887511e-33,
-0.0096164662,
0.0147485193,
-0.0045214049,
0.0525045246,
-0.0515359528,
0.0152507164,
-0.0323092751,
-0.0025163996,
0.0098814685,
0.0517856143,
-0.03516794,
0.0203316417,
0.0071977936,
0.0280045457,
0.0138664059,
0.012555697,
0.0651105493,
0.0104368925,
-0.0374212116,
0.0377794988,
-0.0098661194,
0.0126663046,
0.0749778077,
-0.0799599439,
-0.0097900834,
-0.0284403041,
-0.0655277222,
0.0406371467,
0.0171987209,
0.0078390883,
-0.0019956913,
0.0335773267,
0.0064874161,
-0.010786308,
-0.0205372404,
0.0256547742,
-0.0611586981,
-0.0024396037,
0.0264438204,
0.0256365854,
-0.0275444537,
-0.0723452419,
0.0441895649,
-0.0242502373,
0.0264641102,
0.0123725375,
0.0331280604,
-0.0081376657,
0.0304419342,
-0.0257128831,
-0.0951016173,
0.0156320855,
-0.0322722532,
-0.0422234274,
-0.0351017565,
-0.009118855,
-0.0214892291,
-0.0269609634,
-0.0615394339,
0.0040169982,
-0.0314978138,
0.0255664364,
-0.0263075009,
-0.0305715948,
0.0021863736,
0.0438253544,
0.0050181425,
0.051701095,
0.0280700829,
0.0010677412,
0.0038925416,
0.0369678028,
0.0130516747,
0.070761025,
-0.0081966501,
-0.0124588041,
0.0199219026,
0.0383669138,
0.019341046,
-0.003949244,
-0.01448985,
0.0247088447,
-0.0153227253,
-0.0206678119,
0.0098469472,
-0.024732843,
0.0027409038,
-0.0361484364,
0.0345000066,
0.0074845017,
-0.0021260914,
0.0052768686,
-0.003038954,
-0.0218446888,
0.0019150588,
-0.0211321786,
-0.0030905907,
0.0391695276,
-0.0032662461,
-0.0021843845,
-0.0051150122,
0.0091089047,
0.0286357999,
0.0102170585,
0.0145095065,
-0.0201870818,
0.1104348004,
0.0473181047,
-0.068129085,
0.0006241706,
-0.017742265,
0.0457236059,
-0.0547818691,
-0.0175439119,
-0.0171716306,
0.0143490359,
-0.0215712301,
0.0095681688,
0.0250950549,
-0.0098715946,
-0.0464521088,
-0.0068175374,
0.0250251163,
-0.018212257,
-0.0491090007,
0.0130777061,
-0.0002072914,
-0.0234837942,
-0.007981563,
-0.0466077402,
-0.01786769,
-0.0200479738,
2.472e-7,
0.05939845,
0.030783331,
0.0689441115,
-0.0181460194,
0.0094634108,
0.0318339579,
0.0248971675,
0.0424998552,
0.0065923268,
0.0591976754,
0.0655884817,
-0.0188167151,
0.0533538498,
-0.0270253178,
-0.1340921074,
0.0069437507,
-0.0807820931,
0.0019535946,
-0.0414729677,
-0.0343767293,
0.0195697173,
0.0591011718,
0.0423781462,
-0.0205362402,
0.0006252102,
-0.0265183616,
0.0402854718,
-0.0554517396,
0.0179558489,
0.0241934601,
0.0371845402,
0.0050506005,
0.0122247273,
-0.0115254074,
-0.0187474098,
-0.0299049392,
0.0223918315,
0.0932779908,
-0.0110273743,
0.0054383506,
0.0090634152,
-0.0008648502,
0.0066483794,
-0.0423578806,
0.0218715146,
-0.0014662864,
-0.0056330673,
-0.0132559063,
-0.0209224261,
0.0080425711,
-0.0031591884,
-0.0393760391,
-0.0266899802,
0.02304269,
0.0322234891,
0.0207928475,
-0.0274702832,
-0.0601179674,
-0.0225239303,
-0.0088172927,
-0.0302164815,
-0.003026006,
-0.034343604,
0.0238156784,
0.0038905004,
-0.0140127335,
0.019431388,
1.917979631e-34,
0.0171230398,
-0.0217860118,
0.0571468845,
0.0522796027,
0.0424595363,
0.0281953756,
0.0254499391,
0.0101474067,
0.0072994884,
-0.0541902371,
-0.039839197
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10189v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10189v2 | Do I have the Knowledge to Answer? Investigating Answerability of Knowledge Base Questions | 2022-12-20T12:00:26 | 2023-06-24T11:06:55 | Mayur Patidar, Prayushi Faldu, Avinash Singh, Lovekesh Vig, Indrajit Bhattacharya, Mausam | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | When answering natural language questions over knowledge bases, missing
facts, incomplete schema and limited scope naturally lead to many questions
being unanswerable. While answerability has been explored in other QA settings,
it has not been studied for QA over knowledge bases (KBQA). We create
GrailQAbility, a new benchmark KBQA dataset with unanswerability, by first
identifying various forms of KB incompleteness that make questions
unanswerable, and then systematically adapting GrailQA (a popular KBQA dataset
with only answerable questions). Experimenting with three state-of-the-art KBQA
models, we find that all three models suffer a drop in performance even after
suitable adaptation for unanswerable questions. In addition, these often detect
unanswerability for wrong reasons and find specific forms of unanswerability
particularly difficult to handle. This underscores the need for further
research in making KBQA systems robust to unanswerability | [
0.0731078684,
0.0316111371,
-0.0178736281,
0.0224546604,
-0.0120611815,
0.028179815,
-0.008115341,
-0.0130794048,
0.0123879649,
-0.0141808297,
0.0184253883,
0.0128839994,
-0.059560582,
0.0320741795,
0.0054261209,
-0.0299988128,
0.0198773667,
-0.0180455465,
0.0149815409,
-0.0349929556,
0.0220737606,
0.0270411298,
-0.0409222208,
0.0214143954,
-0.0047333841,
-0.0421621799,
0.0022669064,
-0.0258268397,
-0.0223251078,
0.0267990921,
0.0152539387,
0.0555161126,
-0.0456702411,
-0.02167302,
0.0000021582,
-0.0599005297,
0.0240397528,
0.0072932467,
-0.0850786343,
0.0071691694,
-0.0479471013,
0.0313894153,
0.0344261043,
0.049614571,
-0.0544427633,
0.0135176079,
0.038588129,
0.0726010501,
0.0413096361,
0.0240978729,
0.004009611,
-0.0299503021,
0.0014472103,
0.0052313237,
0.063042298,
-0.0590013564,
-0.0016362967,
0.0311799701,
0.020048447,
0.0032635694,
-0.007855298,
0.0235353224,
0.0124515425,
-0.0177986119,
0.0085121123,
-0.001470615,
-0.0159690361,
0.0012356234,
0.0209020767,
0.0918408707,
0.0319644772,
-0.0122201955,
-0.0093664546,
-0.0106438249,
0.0167883448,
0.0483919196,
-0.0205141902,
-0.0078645432,
-0.0062870886,
-0.0548573025,
-0.0576227456,
0.0295047984,
-0.001639092,
-0.0412870571,
-0.0222284459,
0.1048089042,
-0.0123092849,
-0.015489121,
0.0140018696,
-0.0215823445,
-0.0293962844,
-0.069678925,
-0.0296122804,
0.0746565014,
-0.0487624146,
0.0280631147,
0.0018642923,
0.0388434008,
0.0594889857,
-0.0128160696,
0.0143870693,
0.0354703628,
-0.0101561481,
0.05625486,
0.0008894315,
0.0502507724,
-0.0218568277,
-0.024308851,
-0.03323083,
-0.0420989729,
-0.0741251037,
-0.0182257313,
0.0127105359,
0.0327276662,
-0.030732112,
0.0204965062,
0.0297570862,
0.0233570542,
-0.0258140918,
0.0169675946,
-0.0066876197,
0.055461742,
-0.0008623126,
-0.0194473732,
-0.0851739645,
0.0443698019,
-0.060543593,
0.048691757,
-0.0189100541,
-0.0616794601,
0.0092446711,
-0.010582271,
0.032114584,
-0.006534236,
0.0413298607,
0.0303337257,
0.0199007969,
0.021180613,
-0.0333081931,
-0.0529560521,
0.0081489962,
-0.0448000692,
-0.0503665097,
-0.0605665334,
0.0141263427,
0.0380977951,
-0.0470659658,
-0.029184958,
0.0092738634,
0.0229408219,
-0.0135834487,
0.0712138563,
-0.0068235369,
0.036323227,
0.0293790121,
0.0022665085,
-0.0710871518,
0.0772471875,
0.0062568984,
0.0050940262,
0.0375927761,
-0.0123913223,
0.0250898916,
-0.0298111197,
0.0361824781,
0.0226786267,
0.0487631001,
0.0832693353,
-0.0216809455,
-0.0021552627,
0.0044870819,
0.0105555719,
0.0072681597,
-0.0304135382,
0.0165030546,
0.0296451617,
-0.0251514819,
0.0065839733,
0.0002506212,
0.0153490687,
0.031102214,
-0.0143686486,
0.0006482286,
0.0487886742,
-0.0550734848,
0.0058627445,
-0.0062598283,
0.0235060789,
-0.0532506257,
-0.0504158773,
-0.0046103802,
0.0399865285,
-0.0009972636,
0.049023591,
0.0199076179,
0.0179944038,
-0.0267370101,
0.0276750494,
-0.0224455949,
-0.0428167507,
0.0108966781,
-0.0116103142,
0.0900962502,
0.0026216067,
0.0277220849,
-0.0630172342,
-0.0622722581,
0.0013215648,
0.0118801547,
0.030513525,
0.0149250422,
-0.0221302826,
0.0161721446,
-0.0166340545,
-0.0409337096,
0.0023518333,
0.0377791077,
-0.0159500036,
-0.0050717918,
0.0496201962,
-0.0069373297,
-0.0947640836,
0.0032618439,
0.0055660033,
-0.0150221381,
0.0072143138,
0.0057336539,
-0.0042469492,
0.0620419867,
0.0302874651,
0.0174489301,
0.0304647796,
0.0396529213,
-0.0116424281,
-0.0656722263,
-0.0137577699,
0.034419436,
-0.0271790158,
0.0032947867,
-0.0345746018,
-0.0088795079,
0.0427543409,
-0.0063570929,
-0.0811398774,
-0.0027553763,
-0.0227976535,
0.0510059632,
-0.0213474482,
-0.0314708427,
-0.0040723104,
-0.0220002756,
-0.0150017478,
0.0740510821,
-0.0078302613,
0.0418155678,
-0.0252822228,
-0.0479177721,
0.0245569423,
-0.0345200039,
-0.0220578294,
-0.0173536576,
-0.002341199,
-0.0147752063,
0.0284634158,
-0.029182842,
-0.0603122525,
0.0215319693,
-0.0818016008,
0.012687644,
-0.0115952538,
0.0420746319,
0.0218345542,
0.0081455661,
0.0167603083,
-0.0346407332,
-0.0740520433,
0.0143315718,
0.0152087668,
0.0290188454,
0.0322333127,
0.0342599861,
0.0368872061,
-0.0178023074,
0.019709684,
0.0255154762,
0.0408369005,
-0.0218677931,
0.0475080423,
0.0207446925,
0.0385149866,
-0.0696312264,
0.0129315397,
0.0124801705,
-0.0018650235,
-0.0113317901,
-0.0089011202,
-0.0514291376,
-0.0219391417,
-0.0162491854,
-0.0236933678,
0.0137473401,
-0.0058305175,
-0.0540706664,
0.0416550785,
-0.020070713,
-0.0382174104,
-0.0276179239,
-0.0514860228,
-0.0006457731,
0.0468616001,
-0.009111803,
-0.035265442,
-0.0657925084,
0.067588985,
-0.0134984246,
-0.002151567,
-0.0887142941,
0.0384642892,
0.0354833938,
0.0820472464,
-0.0185219236,
0.0009770972,
0.0460341275,
0.0168186482,
-0.0059053381,
-0.0217698589,
0.0155257322,
-0.0353833511,
0.0878919512,
-0.0198459867,
0.0116862915,
0.021863047,
-0.0120661119,
-0.0295271669,
0.0008784352,
-0.0034115929,
-0.0428751968,
0.0320194289,
-0.0193699636,
0.0136086158,
0.0068801604,
-0.0022147135,
-0.0425508395,
-0.0017823857,
-0.0099989856,
-0.0312738381,
-0.000357317,
-0.019359326,
-0.0313406177,
-0.0001046131,
0.0189574063,
-0.0058282716,
0.0130580589,
-0.0162514411,
0.0083393799,
0.0244168416,
0.0540260412,
0.076561138,
0.046859812,
0.03426506,
0.0210056417,
0.0467300713,
0.023308875,
-0.0161519535,
0.0562173128,
0.0076422379,
0.0058730664,
-0.0194641463,
-0.0233814958,
0.0054617068,
0.0233763997,
-0.0463699363,
-0.0304848608,
0.0880321339,
0.0475196689,
0.0423843041,
0.011247375,
-0.0640109628,
0.0101711974,
0.0249989908,
0.0324905105,
-0.0625356287,
-0.0264003593,
-0.0079887072,
0.0615048967,
-0.0426645577,
-0.0497948416,
-0.0099139623,
-0.1024541184,
0.0093407268,
-0.0510391481,
-0.0623914897,
-0.0399179272,
-0.0341696441,
0.0082523124,
-0.0409044959,
-0.0058280723,
0.0220152661,
0.0192504656,
0.0274960361,
0.0059218151,
-0.0671588406,
-0.0448643491,
0.0571875572,
-0.0106406193,
0.0676226765,
0.0313560478,
0.0270928033,
-0.0073836967,
-0.0066979271,
-0.0777492002,
-0.055224333,
-0.0182394478,
-0.004487419,
0.0334312618,
0.0581954122,
-0.0442363434,
-0.0188310966,
0.018418476,
-0.0715622678,
0.0400346816,
0.0713497549,
0.0849488229,
-0.0192674045,
-0.0159185082,
-0.0194033366,
-0.0275866184,
-0.0106043844,
0.1023046598,
0.0186091121,
0.0013784303,
-0.0365993381,
-0.019794086,
-0.0122002503,
-0.0442351624,
-0.0388181247,
0.037168622,
0.0335695073,
0.0147117013,
-0.076557681,
-0.0742549226,
0.0265835505,
0.0066485992,
-0.0101243854,
0.0303508509,
0.0293495152,
0.0120039331,
-0.049181439,
-0.0074264295,
-0.0264171343,
-0.0069335978,
-0.0370648988,
-0.0094124777,
-0.0202925485,
-0.0299553629,
-0.0215610135,
-0.0629308075,
-0.0019577644,
-0.0102954609,
-0.0105974916,
0.0242827591,
0.0326398686,
-0.0293205865,
-0.0244059898,
-0.0531123802,
0.0433502905,
0.0225477275,
-0.0503774844,
0.0112562906,
0.0310942773,
-0.024162529,
-0.0169494916,
0.0530692376,
-0.0872230306,
-0.0022629148,
-0.0199296791,
0.0600609928,
-0.0364150926,
-0.0045820745,
0.0132802799,
0.0170733854,
-0.0388740748,
0.0840143785,
-0.0340467729,
-0.0178151056,
0.0321085341,
-0.0039220611,
0.0083922371,
-0.0659821257,
-0.0213196799,
0.0239478555,
-0.011065213,
0.006844426,
-0.0265846308,
-0.0458672158,
0.0181205235,
-0.0092833908,
-0.0140890926,
0.0734446719,
0.0098195709,
0.0041488688,
-0.0235542152,
-0.0171115156,
-0.0141955325,
0.0121838683,
0.0321330242,
0.0321306586,
0.0347452834,
0.0050613605,
0.0163032711,
0.0094472719,
-0.0386116877,
-0.0686997324,
-0.0852677748,
0.0016647734,
0.0298305042,
0.0123383366,
0.0253766235,
0.0306636058,
0.0012682683,
-0.0140102217,
-0.0062738792,
-0.0374752618,
0.0319789238,
-0.00123709,
0.0658892617,
0.0313259028,
-0.010500636,
0.0378370285,
0.1026499495,
0.0231455266,
0.0731999651,
-0.0261355657,
-0.0194642711,
-0.0261922423,
-0.0246328246,
0.0006464728,
0.0324370377,
-0.000818551,
0.0499278419,
-0.0859179124,
-0.0626438186,
0.0216586515,
-0.0038825949,
-0.0269980878,
-0.0219935998,
0.0264455378,
0.031376306,
0.0475775562,
-0.0382221863,
-0.0478779748,
0.0194079839,
-0.0814543739,
0.0075581297,
-0.0120908115,
-6.972293397e-33,
-0.0203379467,
-0.0564779639,
0.0235997904,
-0.0378926173,
0.013262433,
0.0054856129,
-0.023961233,
-0.0070128413,
-0.0588626638,
0.0187791381,
-0.0173566677,
0.0306674279,
-0.0135891791,
0.0316598602,
0.0207679011,
-0.0361629426,
0.0057509071,
0.0199209638,
-0.0097996537,
0.0495703369,
0.0820780843,
0.0044131908,
-0.0184634905,
-0.0162686575,
0.0535465889,
-0.0478197932,
-0.0036849168,
0.0737073645,
-0.0475220159,
0.0680136308,
-0.0408419408,
0.07796859,
0.0216810647,
-0.0445360355,
0.0086054252,
-0.0234337039,
-0.053366065,
-0.0716229528,
0.0239727199,
-0.0103900228,
-0.0221462827,
-0.0104434453,
0.025886599,
0.0106840646,
0.0320205018,
-0.007933042,
0.0398211218,
-0.004598801,
0.0209777653,
-0.0178138949,
-0.0038012697,
-0.0091471709,
-0.023583496,
-0.0278525501,
-0.0608171523,
0.0572928414,
0.0080610812,
-0.0528286211,
-0.0521163121,
-0.0249957629,
0.0061033824,
0.0018425506,
0.0422244482,
-0.0327900834,
-0.0096465368,
0.0054448172,
0.0090978285,
0.0089949844,
-0.0002552514,
0.015385014,
-0.0371495485,
0.0413240008,
0.1017125994,
0.0525716394,
0.037633758,
-0.0018793639,
-0.0617559403,
0.0427858345,
-0.0169567987,
0.0312970728,
0.0215324461,
-0.0266527217,
-0.0313993059,
-0.0250765905,
-0.0733505413,
0.0460964032,
-0.0694197789,
0.0003662265,
0.0455366485,
-0.029192457,
-0.0263860766,
-0.0183321182,
0.0072098025,
-0.0333363377,
0.0265344102,
0.0558862276,
0.0102903387,
0.0258369651,
0.0373197719,
0.0436642319,
-0.0565042272,
0.0373709835,
0.0163281597,
-0.0338141583,
-0.0091070058,
0.0221873373,
0.0046419902,
0.0008968659,
-0.0318797156,
-0.0206582025,
-0.0167493839,
0.0527219884,
-0.0447864458,
-0.0090120761,
0.0148557043,
0.0194905773,
0.001174714,
0.0194066931,
0.0018759981,
0.0188066326,
-0.0166765843,
-0.0354516581,
-0.0120531581,
-0.0146948462,
-0.0343863107,
-0.0195520651,
-0.0316493101,
0.0125956703,
-0.0593884513,
-0.0217277575,
-0.0097612282,
0.0078174938,
2.796e-7,
0.0460960977,
-0.0099435132,
-0.0008118444,
0.0289022848,
0.0254591499,
0.0407264233,
0.0130562978,
0.018748749,
0.0056287567,
-0.0516171679,
-0.0037012433,
-0.0179215539,
0.0051028654,
0.0354603939,
-0.0556969307,
-0.0223738551,
-0.006887258,
-0.0213898309,
-0.0216086321,
-0.005179326,
0.0653044879,
0.0366672948,
0.0278390329,
0.0006956451,
0.0175892022,
0.0013566935,
0.0264940206,
-0.0066696061,
0.0389422476,
0.0058803316,
0.0985880867,
0.0383468643,
0.0321158506,
0.0473630354,
0.0043761358,
0.025787631,
-0.006775212,
0.0151200481,
0.0027946073,
-0.0487222187,
-0.0310549885,
-0.0251147076,
0.0466514304,
-0.0569428504,
0.1148333848,
-0.0307477526,
-0.0273271874,
0.0386762396,
-0.0314730704,
-0.0343290642,
-0.0031527265,
0.0140815619,
-0.0175824128,
-0.049506668,
-0.0007939766,
-0.0190085154,
0.0213589035,
-0.0406487323,
0.0092955213,
0.0335699506,
-0.0230442714,
-0.0482938103,
-0.0140583767,
0.0111864209,
0.0071338238,
-0.064659901,
-0.0118382489,
2.295899802e-34,
0.0232942719,
0.024243189,
0.0220399238,
-0.0179956853,
0.0064258673,
-0.0131295109,
-0.0313868448,
-0.0518531762,
0.0341396295,
-0.0668897033,
-0.0048858081
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.05150v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.05150v1 | Unsupervised Question Duplicate and Related Questions Detection in e-learning platforms | 2022-12-20T11:52:52 | 2022-12-20T11:52:52 | Maksimjeet Chowdhary, Sanyam Goyal, Venktesh V, Mukesh Mohania, Vikram Goyal | cs.CL | cs.CL | Online learning platforms provide diverse questions to gauge the learners'
understanding of different concepts. The repository of questions has to be
constantly updated to ensure a diverse pool of questions to conduct assessments
for learners. However, it is impossible for the academician to manually skim
through the large repository of questions to check for duplicates when
onboarding new questions from external sources. Hence, we propose a tool QDup
in this paper that can surface near-duplicate and semantically related
questions without any supervised data. The proposed tool follows an
unsupervised hybrid pipeline of statistical and neural approaches for
incorporating different nuances in similarity for the task of question
duplicate detection. We demonstrate that QDup can detect near-duplicate
questions and also suggest related questions for practice with remarkable
accuracy and speed from a large repository of questions. The demo video of the
tool can be found at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=loh0_-7XLW4. | [
0.0138501031,
-0.0031887216,
-0.0456504188,
0.0347236544,
-0.0228621233,
0.0654467791,
0.017423179,
0.0080018481,
0.0175299905,
-0.0301106889,
-0.0167507119,
0.0136970729,
-0.0489183292,
0.0276770256,
0.0445658825,
-0.0577772446,
0.0303784832,
0.0499730855,
-0.066955857,
0.0214506518,
0.0199166685,
0.0040254323,
-0.0461336635,
0.0191533603,
0.0015822356,
-0.037713863,
-0.0320555307,
0.0155813275,
0.019881798,
-0.0173591785,
0.0124129467,
0.0388706774,
-0.0150584262,
0.0319916084,
0.0000018659,
-0.0845483691,
-0.0565223545,
-0.0333834179,
-0.022544397,
-0.0155030545,
0.0037669251,
0.086647965,
0.0495970696,
0.0361273326,
-0.0635170415,
-0.0513450317,
0.0434706323,
0.0373940915,
0.0419873558,
0.0129297487,
-0.0059145908,
-0.005215392,
0.0406921096,
0.0257691201,
0.0316831432,
-0.0268525705,
-0.0055847783,
0.0171884075,
-0.0009045929,
0.0325922631,
-0.0105661554,
0.0189986005,
0.0325490944,
-0.018443346,
-0.0260090437,
0.0158997476,
-0.0160991028,
0.0251532327,
-0.0002369236,
0.1284377575,
-0.0490928181,
-0.0507236943,
0.0271863956,
-0.0254191905,
0.0335247591,
0.0538029373,
-0.048628971,
0.0051294761,
-0.0227685925,
-0.0102467602,
-0.0290517416,
0.0176632609,
-0.0088542998,
-0.0119537003,
0.0332012437,
-0.0200095586,
0.0208526421,
-0.0063864789,
0.0050084032,
0.0410079435,
0.0037116038,
-0.0209105629,
0.0185628477,
0.0419605821,
0.0104722334,
0.0036325695,
-0.0147523172,
-0.0659214109,
0.0078228489,
-0.0318490788,
0.0343104489,
0.0372014455,
-0.0194166806,
0.0428688116,
-0.0401644036,
0.016732065,
-0.0129887648,
0.010406225,
-0.0418012515,
0.0159315988,
-0.0706655383,
0.0027591444,
-0.0245493259,
0.0602356419,
0.0260118898,
-0.0181401614,
0.010657805,
0.0377580076,
-0.0002254342,
-0.0016417693,
-0.0142031871,
0.0061344579,
0.027168896,
0.0245210212,
-0.0006583041,
0.0043027485,
-0.0897874534,
0.0284950733,
-0.003849298,
-0.0484325252,
-0.0029480641,
0.0399932154,
0.0579385236,
-0.0135683268,
0.0042374572,
-0.0249496438,
0.0291554723,
-0.0206724107,
-0.0400455818,
-0.0540150478,
0.0477050059,
0.0431373715,
-0.0084660342,
-0.0841826126,
0.0574483387,
-0.0189883206,
-0.008828653,
0.0191965476,
-0.0428777635,
0.0365070179,
0.0440623313,
0.0407877602,
-0.0146498503,
0.0069348146,
0.0734352544,
0.0307245199,
-0.0011293548,
0.0169807151,
-0.0362336002,
-0.0405793786,
0.0730723962,
0.0162084736,
0.0089015923,
-0.0067645349,
0.035116829,
-0.0328463912,
-0.015008633,
0.0135207251,
0.0150998617,
0.0287729539,
-0.0103610521,
0.0257792082,
-0.0308287833,
-0.0469177179,
-0.0088721318,
0.0621275976,
-0.0166927092,
0.0221603252,
0.0588852167,
0.0651045069,
0.0246756189,
0.0410026722,
0.0021518462,
0.0558999255,
0.0138850026,
-0.0214796457,
0.0443237945,
0.0456625633,
-0.061952062,
-0.0266509503,
0.0183015466,
0.0003128959,
-0.0481618159,
0.0291649736,
-0.0039383681,
0.0425744019,
0.0338699147,
0.0536061823,
0.031734731,
-0.0164610427,
0.0011430203,
-0.0464002304,
0.0494112223,
-0.015009895,
0.0511085838,
-0.0429517664,
-0.0733229667,
0.0009668992,
-0.0127910953,
0.0067898007,
0.0785378814,
-0.0561359487,
-0.0065290909,
-0.0344515033,
-0.0720093697,
-0.0135185951,
-0.0376603082,
-0.0397014879,
0.0355434194,
0.0428314172,
0.0258963294,
-0.070540525,
0.019142434,
0.0452448055,
-0.0260865353,
-0.01844435,
0.0043599135,
0.023934532,
0.0002784233,
0.0144471908,
0.0147661371,
0.0199380182,
0.0233922154,
-0.035295032,
-0.0272154398,
-0.0304121394,
-0.0256639086,
-0.0621438511,
0.0788906738,
-0.0442260839,
-0.0122150863,
0.0495628081,
-0.0448957235,
-0.0103604356,
-0.0006587763,
-0.0003391087,
0.0038037738,
-0.0607804283,
0.0028111916,
-0.023755325,
-0.0027717252,
-0.0391121842,
0.070993267,
0.0188172683,
0.0314877108,
-0.0331568718,
-0.0224007554,
0.039781373,
-0.0083718067,
-0.0209187176,
-0.0478957668,
-0.0453736223,
-0.0029305911,
0.013126811,
0.002338924,
-0.0732328296,
0.0169779155,
-0.0381748267,
0.0183677971,
0.0153593561,
0.0185845383,
0.0437098816,
0.0402642488,
-0.0085786842,
-0.057378538,
-0.0620655008,
0.0041393288,
-0.0061822599,
-0.003489438,
0.0538228974,
-0.013289988,
0.0312898159,
-0.0302284639,
-0.0158326458,
-0.0460624136,
0.0256348141,
0.0323541425,
0.0067517003,
-0.0252762549,
0.0268640071,
-0.0415233187,
-0.0032895377,
0.0546613783,
0.0238614716,
-0.0084035769,
-0.0361741967,
0.0392296314,
0.0401316918,
-0.0181413442,
-0.0485138223,
0.039297685,
0.0386071764,
-0.0865432844,
0.0290737376,
-0.0531617403,
0.0134598939,
0.0210999008,
0.0095084328,
0.0212770645,
-0.0063658282,
0.0014085639,
-0.0664906502,
0.0123636303,
0.0729678348,
-0.0244289506,
0.0208935682,
-0.0678926259,
0.0056607951,
0.0162905157,
0.0029671891,
-0.0019110161,
-0.0073722117,
0.0841165334,
0.0260842834,
0.010853122,
-0.0800979286,
0.0256429352,
-0.0239106137,
0.064283669,
-0.0029314782,
0.027713459,
-0.0185927264,
-0.0222492125,
-0.0391707197,
0.020094987,
0.0188420415,
-0.0147930784,
0.0034479022,
0.0030530947,
-0.0035267922,
0.0187965631,
-0.002805579,
-0.0582674295,
-0.0198536832,
0.0173890758,
-0.0317389481,
-0.0608006828,
0.0231022593,
-0.0140654016,
-0.027988242,
0.0042146528,
0.0604377501,
-0.0158575866,
-0.0406050868,
-0.000338474,
0.1145010218,
0.0501131862,
-0.0018534476,
0.0523489118,
-0.0229795128,
0.0697069168,
0.0483233891,
0.0191945042,
0.0393438376,
0.0261203311,
-0.0131860627,
-0.0071961996,
-0.0809712112,
0.028275203,
0.0352153741,
-0.007137083,
-0.0298682489,
-0.0580420308,
0.0946436003,
0.0521698147,
-0.0434571132,
-0.0385261513,
-0.0572941266,
0.0036132922,
0.032233946,
0.0524663441,
-0.0364901833,
-0.0085065095,
-0.0335004479,
0.0019280426,
0.0094449855,
-0.026490869,
0.0288752243,
-0.0866196156,
-0.0064047552,
-0.0313933678,
-0.0390258171,
0.0236858372,
-0.0475511514,
0.0036923829,
0.0196681824,
-0.0146870734,
0.0026994247,
-0.0141096385,
0.0109286308,
0.0262265373,
-0.0335681327,
-0.0162245575,
-0.0256335568,
-0.0911378339,
-0.0277219005,
0.004788097,
0.0188844241,
-0.0040502935,
-0.0236469582,
0.0120008085,
-0.0655113608,
-0.0248439237,
-0.0000214014,
0.0481261499,
0.0285630077,
0.0022293241,
-0.0798310935,
0.0504004583,
-0.0341489613,
0.0147508811,
0.0644458532,
0.0841526389,
-0.0370747671,
-0.0276949462,
-0.0587835684,
-0.0054512867,
-0.0202566963,
0.0492722578,
0.0744188577,
-0.0133536998,
0.0113099944,
0.0586513281,
0.016173169,
-0.0314329825,
-0.0235125814,
0.0258055609,
0.0169745907,
0.0294894818,
-0.0906527936,
-0.031032525,
0.0260864086,
0.0195300635,
0.0016162258,
0.0035181886,
0.0396349207,
-0.0047427346,
-0.0788475052,
0.0034793161,
-0.0351475887,
-0.007404719,
-0.0327740274,
0.0026836896,
0.0077377986,
0.0005510852,
-0.0471958555,
-0.037073873,
-0.0940532833,
-0.0270342603,
-0.0643258691,
-0.006616252,
0.0041709887,
-0.0044342447,
-0.0294782873,
-0.0169818029,
0.0030356811,
-0.0177888367,
0.0040334561,
-0.0347797014,
-0.0638244897,
-0.0500924326,
0.0099859536,
0.0298565011,
-0.0199843068,
0.015607872,
0.0110636037,
0.0284562614,
-0.0178309903,
-0.0376263931,
0.0475519039,
-0.0039182305,
0.0273071863,
0.049859371,
0.037304353,
-0.0360135846,
-0.0090611465,
0.0482653268,
0.0110201417,
-0.006374192,
0.0412320569,
0.0240387842,
0.0401881188,
-0.0033672077,
0.006483315,
-0.0282625072,
0.0306356736,
-0.0058826632,
-0.0237506758,
0.0155953765,
0.0411698855,
-0.0337955654,
-0.0256864913,
-0.0222487897,
0.0059613655,
0.0124621373,
0.0272801183,
-0.0233086273,
0.0755264536,
0.0204615816,
0.0034102518,
-0.0053703692,
0.0222402345,
-0.016156612,
-0.0967148617,
0.0049758074,
-0.0076877922,
0.0232982859,
-0.0254823789,
-0.0413944945,
0.0048896959,
-0.0226061847,
-0.0250182934,
-0.0026941271,
-0.0357316993,
-0.0301510524,
0.0065814103,
0.0303324498,
0.0095373588,
-0.0049486607,
0.0439527817,
-0.0777856484,
0.0267189704,
0.0175466891,
-0.0133522945,
-0.0221695583,
0.0290702395,
0.0472490937,
0.0566629097,
-0.0203561727,
0.0248280056,
0.0146057718,
-0.0309381559,
0.0001695858,
0.0318336934,
-0.022538662,
0.0583395734,
0.0674113855,
0.0136011532,
-0.0221890844,
-0.0159644,
-0.0097479252,
0.0543492921,
-0.0390737243,
-0.0570121594,
0.0142217427,
-5.934820083e-33,
0.013678751,
-0.0160762388,
-0.0029833626,
0.0025975385,
0.0081450511,
0.0189738516,
-0.0532922633,
-0.0093605928,
-0.0540717952,
0.0059065823,
0.0231492613,
0.0304192901,
-0.0010312004,
0.0088249147,
0.0262620989,
-0.0269395914,
0.0272008292,
0.0170271099,
0.0359611735,
0.0804691315,
-0.0022511985,
0.0153673757,
0.0238956884,
-0.0183733162,
-0.0169358943,
-0.0321028866,
0.0556010902,
0.0421835035,
0.0049464065,
0.0805451497,
-0.0310103446,
-0.0149603542,
0.0506207906,
-0.0076824217,
-0.0037249429,
-0.0177585594,
-0.0781715438,
-0.0889641941,
-0.0709288493,
-0.025110865,
-0.034908548,
0.0314454362,
0.029270215,
-0.0378192104,
0.0120208999,
-0.0132330172,
0.0669252053,
0.027845379,
-0.0088766003,
-0.0380983464,
-0.02074988,
0.009045477,
-0.0185567141,
0.0101964567,
-0.0430209115,
0.107423991,
0.0072420039,
0.0043465896,
-0.0452738255,
0.0430256501,
-0.0565065518,
0.0127724651,
-0.0006534766,
-0.0338513702,
-0.0073576416,
0.0570523478,
0.0526577868,
-0.0742537752,
0.0143668475,
0.0120649152,
0.0214058403,
0.0073026912,
0.0654359907,
0.0145885665,
0.0289023239,
-0.0060953419,
-0.0639494732,
0.0883656293,
0.0347300768,
-0.0098447297,
-0.0283747241,
-0.026090404,
-0.0394370332,
0.0072582755,
-0.0158270169,
0.0197556093,
-0.0535305291,
-0.0050255689,
0.0668045506,
-0.0438327342,
-0.0354762226,
0.0117600095,
0.0187318549,
-0.0247756056,
-0.0130832726,
-0.024071293,
0.0659386665,
0.0034346618,
0.0020564045,
0.031340111,
0.0074981456,
-0.0218426995,
-0.0170544088,
-0.069810465,
0.0043693455,
0.0106024006,
0.0263427719,
-0.0077693616,
-0.0552740209,
0.0014598159,
0.0133188898,
-0.0642889515,
0.0156663265,
0.0295688454,
0.0092364177,
0.0539407358,
0.0110058691,
0.0529644527,
0.0561230332,
-0.0199112911,
-0.0312206503,
-0.0256091841,
0.0254464131,
0.0141929286,
-0.0104098301,
-0.0235250015,
-0.0774747953,
0.0057470081,
-0.0025963741,
-0.1037436202,
0.0052466844,
0.0027993107,
2.537e-7,
0.0169075206,
-0.0093892831,
0.0141305244,
-0.0429168344,
-0.0018131406,
0.0185269229,
0.019642137,
0.016152624,
-0.0016797103,
0.0254256818,
0.0182414334,
0.0108069982,
-0.0002577605,
0.0160759911,
-0.0988081619,
-0.0123983258,
-0.0286192689,
-0.043863982,
-0.0610707849,
0.0095066214,
0.0641690046,
0.0432274975,
0.0298674963,
-0.0068093645,
0.0138354767,
-0.0435101092,
-0.018704854,
0.0323430859,
0.0321942791,
0.0222290792,
0.0173883773,
0.0042432453,
0.0410567112,
0.0102214124,
-0.0190062355,
0.0190733131,
0.0554932542,
-0.0279417373,
0.0250070095,
-0.013173434,
0.015761327,
-0.0222383644,
0.0201254934,
-0.1007176936,
0.0562898368,
-0.0357863121,
0.0089950999,
-0.0183393639,
-0.0152014391,
0.0044637709,
0.0287215635,
0.0112349363,
-0.0250804834,
0.02219804,
0.037877202,
-0.0239583533,
-0.0067748171,
-0.0454073064,
0.0128068412,
-0.0049164724,
-0.0063579497,
-0.0055026351,
-0.032424558,
-0.0300175063,
0.0284220986,
0.006384375,
0.0030108772,
1.884124819e-34,
-0.0264443737,
0.0264820233,
0.0603668913,
-0.0206440408,
-0.0316728316,
-0.0180610791,
-0.029150432,
-0.0292707421,
0.0116803842,
-0.0504566245,
-0.006080173
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10180v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10180v2 | IndicMT Eval: A Dataset to Meta-Evaluate Machine Translation metrics for Indian Languages | 2022-12-20T11:37:22 | 2023-07-03T14:26:38 | Ananya B. Sai, Vignesh Nagarajan, Tanay Dixit, Raj Dabre, Anoop Kunchukuttan, Pratyush Kumar, Mitesh M. Khapra | cs.CL | cs.CL | The rapid growth of machine translation (MT) systems has necessitated
comprehensive studies to meta-evaluate evaluation metrics being used, which
enables a better selection of metrics that best reflect MT quality.
Unfortunately, most of the research focuses on high-resource languages, mainly
English, the observations for which may not always apply to other languages.
Indian languages, having over a billion speakers, are linguistically different
from English, and to date, there has not been a systematic study of evaluating
MT systems from English into Indian languages. In this paper, we fill this gap
by creating an MQM dataset consisting of 7000 fine-grained annotations,
spanning 5 Indian languages and 7 MT systems, and use it to establish
correlations between annotator scores and scores obtained using existing
automatic metrics. Our results show that pre-trained metrics, such as COMET,
have the highest correlations with annotator scores. Additionally, we find that
the metrics do not adequately capture fluency-based errors in Indian languages,
and there is a need to develop metrics focused on Indian languages. We hope
that our dataset and analysis will help promote further research in this area. | [
0.0212987028,
-0.0140568791,
-0.0171123035,
0.032148201,
-0.0406030118,
0.0401831307,
-0.0086042341,
-0.0138502056,
-0.0365472287,
-0.0383240953,
-0.0660837367,
-0.0083852326,
0.0615580045,
-0.0019763324,
0.018839065,
-0.0307685398,
0.028973924,
-0.0048931297,
-0.0193570741,
0.0333206356,
0.0317168981,
0.0189836603,
-0.0542763956,
0.0541632473,
-0.0173505507,
-0.0062432461,
0.0509625226,
0.0373320132,
0.0528077483,
-0.0360648818,
-0.0368238464,
0.0360274836,
-0.0095979869,
0.1063000038,
0.0000016015,
-0.063532643,
-0.0167500228,
0.0180067811,
0.0006184425,
0.0212728325,
0.0627539754,
-0.0360449068,
-0.0123840468,
0.0270837899,
-0.0002788081,
0.0018895026,
0.0868388414,
-0.0680743307,
0.0645009056,
0.0844007134,
-0.0234051719,
-0.0080548301,
0.0002876316,
-0.0010207761,
-0.0261061788,
-0.0372738652,
-0.0368705653,
0.0339302309,
-0.0552079342,
-0.0222104453,
-0.0067615877,
0.0467731804,
-0.0165971015,
-0.0326931626,
0.0129042985,
-0.0180123392,
-0.0462832935,
-0.0315390863,
0.0314041525,
0.0614643916,
-0.0325380489,
-0.0173493475,
-0.0246480349,
0.0010905331,
-0.0464420579,
-0.0280524418,
-0.0193607733,
0.0099648712,
-0.0225184299,
0.0200661551,
0.036106132,
0.0467599668,
0.0144968685,
-0.0030493296,
0.0304430407,
-0.0327442586,
0.0337852389,
-0.0104750702,
-0.0239691306,
0.0222113803,
-0.0198409744,
0.019642666,
0.0267407671,
-0.0212362986,
-0.0264440253,
0.0114754019,
-0.0083157076,
-0.0744550079,
0.0295477882,
-0.0343491025,
0.0273751467,
0.0603760034,
-0.0127494214,
0.0215108022,
0.0249736197,
0.0493393578,
0.0026885925,
0.0297605041,
-0.0354679003,
-0.0073810569,
-0.0140290568,
0.0143302465,
-0.007846687,
-0.0315162875,
-0.0195661299,
0.0258115716,
-0.0830983371,
-0.0004818806,
0.0272187144,
-0.0036403532,
0.0266295541,
-0.0649396479,
-0.0594119057,
-0.030432431,
0.0279513281,
0.0426520333,
-0.0359242857,
0.0166564249,
0.0221942384,
-0.0805946365,
0.0001148892,
0.0264103264,
-0.0241337251,
-0.0204280242,
-0.034443941,
0.0630781427,
-0.0014096738,
-0.0561205819,
-0.0191934574,
0.0280166492,
-0.0320101157,
-0.0486389846,
-0.0410169289,
-0.0513727255,
0.0524662323,
0.0357328877,
0.0344045758,
0.0083637461,
-0.0207237173,
0.0021974153,
0.036199335,
0.0446809977,
-0.0636935458,
-0.0007404089,
0.0355053768,
0.0086356234,
-0.0310549885,
0.0261518676,
0.0726042166,
-0.0102808094,
0.0379336812,
-0.023972705,
0.0178624764,
0.0432383455,
-0.0211859066,
-0.0015713281,
-0.003011018,
0.0072098626,
-0.0372240767,
0.0565555543,
0.0115718301,
0.0556645244,
-0.0355013758,
0.056204211,
0.0236542337,
0.0465771444,
0.0375921428,
0.040511217,
0.0365764126,
0.0004514808,
0.040387392,
0.0004531058,
-0.0065291589,
0.0174001977,
-0.0247624349,
0.0004096563,
0.072582446,
0.01769628,
-0.000330319,
-0.0447583124,
-0.015680436,
-0.0416923054,
-0.0525645837,
-0.0403024554,
0.0373120904,
0.0150638428,
-0.0225877762,
-0.0240345225,
-0.0154876197,
-0.0749617592,
0.0545431674,
-0.0203004498,
-0.0025342202,
0.0519535728,
0.0347335301,
-0.0115656182,
-0.0133716725,
-0.0129455952,
-0.0174421631,
0.0251430869,
0.0607122928,
-0.0180197544,
0.0106188916,
-0.0381452106,
0.0132330535,
0.0294642206,
0.0257515945,
0.0011555903,
-0.0320640579,
0.0267964285,
0.0267397929,
-0.054322198,
-0.0581068657,
0.0391287059,
0.0093017155,
-0.0077609667,
-0.0013006203,
-0.0246928222,
0.0628396496,
0.0205025245,
-0.0233399607,
0.0029037762,
0.0206692293,
0.0053945519,
0.0200996082,
0.0448790938,
0.0132231535,
-0.0377847105,
-0.0007150244,
-0.0576804653,
-0.0093418835,
0.0242971275,
-0.0362468287,
-0.0707139298,
-0.0209366418,
-0.0426178798,
0.0020964576,
-0.0392124988,
0.0377304554,
-0.0020105063,
-0.0158940013,
-0.034340594,
-0.0008235999,
0.0117914407,
0.0033355074,
0.0110615743,
-0.0177459046,
0.0568344034,
-0.0304260459,
-0.0406462252,
0.0014719438,
0.030270841,
0.0504066534,
0.0234275572,
0.0176679082,
-0.082458064,
-0.029553609,
-0.1064734831,
0.0051291399,
-0.0167419296,
0.0415014513,
0.039157439,
0.0481312536,
0.0004192025,
0.0011610962,
0.0293772891,
-0.0160354786,
0.0441019461,
0.026543187,
0.0187440217,
-0.0006980157,
0.0181824863,
-0.0437519699,
-0.025686156,
0.0168483071,
0.0358657353,
0.0331287086,
-0.012877021,
-0.0425022133,
-0.0008610767,
-0.0296808444,
-0.0591817833,
0.0182521529,
-0.071751371,
-0.0083852904,
-0.0126849404,
-0.005436291,
0.0183286667,
0.0130912494,
0.0012588165,
-0.0019742618,
0.0066206157,
-0.034507703,
-0.0503150374,
0.014801099,
-0.0550628453,
-0.0064511448,
-0.0206196364,
0.030606566,
0.0077653513,
-0.0170066282,
0.0187558886,
-0.0422755517,
-0.009316002,
-0.0421062894,
0.0039454619,
-0.0108075039,
0.0661942139,
-0.0313958265,
0.0881101117,
-0.0079750344,
-0.0728752688,
0.0601506308,
-0.0480909012,
-0.0096754814,
-0.0422955304,
0.0258598737,
-0.0272860732,
-0.0004811767,
-0.0500811003,
-0.004677692,
-0.0467088819,
-0.03768057,
-0.0372940823,
0.0230614468,
0.0205515567,
-0.0504343435,
0.0203124434,
-0.0942916349,
0.0284731425,
-0.0269337855,
0.0132248793,
0.00463008,
-0.0086777713,
-0.0043276614,
-0.0189780351,
0.0276295021,
-0.0222621541,
0.0028732878,
0.0485609919,
-0.0058686426,
0.0341865234,
-0.0113897678,
-0.0056852964,
0.0220989976,
0.0029337043,
0.0188450906,
0.0100364303,
0.0146333361,
-0.0088785691,
0.0395784453,
-0.0421325825,
0.022676805,
0.0100562703,
-0.0191555414,
-0.0250126347,
0.0321114808,
-0.0188234206,
-0.0193835776,
-0.0012739719,
0.0654220432,
0.0007709312,
-0.0106170718,
0.094721064,
0.0364417285,
-0.0173104424,
-0.0294520874,
-0.0414304286,
0.029432863,
-0.0074504237,
-0.0005113151,
-0.0827229396,
-0.0277629271,
0.0115000317,
0.0458498448,
0.0362341553,
0.012763218,
-0.0145710008,
-0.0631938353,
-0.0177772995,
0.0290872529,
-0.0612550229,
-0.0488161556,
0.0051939678,
-0.0380020738,
-0.0657580048,
0.046657376,
0.0307436176,
-0.0153080318,
0.0087206932,
0.042803593,
-0.0242825672,
-0.0742443874,
-0.0074264556,
-0.0329594389,
0.062970899,
0.0644323602,
-0.0032612907,
-0.0216788724,
-0.0384265967,
0.008772701,
-0.0292058624,
-0.0303845759,
-0.0121634714,
0.0412357785,
-0.0309622549,
-0.0125838229,
0.0033048533,
0.0017509501,
0.0147258984,
0.0216293931,
0.0168492589,
0.0420074202,
0.0035174119,
0.0307264086,
0.0111547532,
-0.0366146415,
-0.0291227195,
0.032361608,
0.0310671497,
-0.0360315368,
-0.0072779567,
-0.0135590881,
-0.0193899814,
-0.0342200547,
-0.0088341143,
0.0187905002,
-0.0514688827,
-0.0600307882,
-0.0579111464,
-0.0646453649,
0.0505194999,
0.0243877843,
0.030520048,
0.0389958806,
-0.0265739504,
0.0255805161,
-0.0101356385,
0.0391230695,
-0.0423436463,
0.0186080933,
-0.0919577628,
0.0300040971,
0.0291297175,
0.0244934931,
-0.0185624585,
0.0241907574,
-0.0365015194,
-0.0404911116,
0.0059007844,
0.0794314519,
0.0274748094,
0.0106037203,
-0.0387216732,
-0.053095188,
-0.0063163918,
-0.0220777523,
-0.0550928041,
-0.0198001228,
0.0296374001,
-0.0014946091,
-0.0325808078,
0.0314832553,
-0.0521721803,
-0.0247333553,
-0.0466745049,
0.037848603,
-0.0110431621,
-0.037799079,
0.0299648494,
0.0201543756,
0.0567058697,
-0.1063167974,
-0.0273684729,
-0.0168167036,
-0.0207381994,
0.0269823801,
-0.020398479,
-0.0295488294,
-0.0025252497,
0.0811560526,
0.0118524441,
-0.0259677488,
-0.0070960303,
-0.0433689468,
0.0116147725,
0.0364505164,
0.0390445441,
-0.021532977,
0.0886519328,
-0.0054426016,
0.0016101593,
-0.0268373527,
-0.0161335804,
-0.0127745634,
-0.0006118669,
-0.022796018,
0.0550116971,
-0.0057992619,
0.0473264568,
0.0905948654,
0.080235526,
0.0529590026,
0.0300604291,
0.0053859563,
0.0556167811,
0.0877234265,
0.0238322262,
0.131427601,
0.0190360714,
-0.0017785954,
-0.0623893067,
0.0702033117,
-0.0078657111,
0.0253071431,
0.0303811207,
-0.0058869887,
-0.0306198969,
0.0235976037,
0.0313663892,
-0.0445126183,
-0.0440241806,
-0.0174245965,
-0.0225486811,
-0.0193870235,
0.0013670428,
-0.0645316467,
-0.0113079296,
0.0299980696,
-0.0424514711,
-0.072172232,
-0.0594313107,
0.0262771789,
0.018896291,
0.027958896,
-0.0147790685,
-0.0037667328,
0.0596489273,
-0.0217658468,
-0.0005920934,
-0.0590966307,
-0.0177920032,
-0.0273828693,
-0.0149195567,
-0.0199906603,
-4.940345984e-33,
-0.0512731411,
0.0102728046,
-0.0042803772,
-0.0175573677,
-0.0106641445,
-0.0065361424,
-0.0019563029,
-0.0202454794,
0.0056309174,
0.0115192691,
-0.0020294264,
-0.0023176791,
0.0191502292,
-0.02026603,
0.0291213393,
-0.0021710058,
0.0489511415,
0.0199615173,
-0.0390197784,
0.0044895476,
0.0186390094,
-0.0299300309,
0.1051114574,
-0.0109306816,
0.0635405928,
-0.0521272942,
-0.0242058095,
0.0254540779,
-0.0188296586,
0.0357053541,
-0.0046043429,
0.0247106142,
0.0236732792,
0.003533483,
-0.0196436197,
-0.0239072982,
-0.0794398114,
0.03472149,
0.0408816263,
0.0717145726,
-0.0035073599,
-0.0274730623,
0.0234674718,
-0.0251822732,
-0.0395800211,
0.0151227387,
0.0153848436,
-0.0182891935,
-0.0097279865,
-0.0203128885,
-0.03590573,
0.0697949529,
-0.0341930054,
-0.0177923478,
0.0114424909,
0.0798319876,
-0.0142501183,
-0.0187243484,
-0.050030157,
-0.0087049752,
-0.0178540759,
0.0714262202,
0.0737932324,
0.0067782816,
-0.0394014157,
-0.003274844,
0.0217899717,
-0.0416631326,
0.0696346536,
0.0396736525,
0.0214756802,
-0.0124406721,
0.0440009832,
0.0556751043,
0.0394443758,
-0.0363020897,
-0.0182959866,
0.0503550172,
-0.0433380269,
0.0362286232,
-0.0043201181,
-0.0067556435,
-0.0285811275,
-0.0091292039,
-0.0377471969,
-0.0309032351,
-0.0254760832,
-0.0325283632,
0.0527865402,
-0.030060593,
-0.0069907811,
0.0186402518,
0.0913545936,
0.0021574791,
0.0241799168,
-0.0276668165,
-0.0328428075,
0.0362053066,
-0.0330293812,
0.0544321835,
-0.0289191026,
-0.0180271044,
0.0236325115,
0.0617444478,
0.0211744402,
-0.0427725241,
0.0572077744,
-0.0173814893,
-0.0404064767,
0.0117624607,
-0.018018797,
0.014019235,
-0.0483919494,
-0.0263702478,
0.003049094,
-0.0146585843,
-0.0244303029,
0.0085488148,
0.0107026137,
0.0265419856,
-0.020076938,
0.0023234007,
0.0012397971,
0.0054553938,
-0.0270228107,
0.038622804,
-0.0097349733,
0.0016362111,
0.0126194572,
-0.030401241,
-0.0050594471,
0.0206188392,
2.317e-7,
0.0618398115,
0.0713344514,
0.0441446304,
-0.0301613454,
-0.0304651763,
-0.000421138,
-0.0495665111,
-0.0163000189,
0.0368415825,
0.0620790534,
0.029345395,
-0.0068358625,
0.0586618073,
0.0314008743,
-0.0706421584,
-0.0367385298,
-0.0781640857,
0.0496578403,
-0.0333828665,
-0.0000877722,
0.0216340013,
0.052814275,
0.0010819444,
0.0091628004,
-0.0249878392,
-0.0244820025,
0.0590084307,
-0.0010099212,
-0.0097800884,
0.0210845396,
0.0525139682,
0.0109937228,
-0.025614446,
-0.0133989938,
-0.0173830651,
0.0002534714,
0.0522714593,
0.0711281374,
0.0052678296,
-0.0126519529,
0.0264401063,
0.0149707897,
0.0036145756,
-0.0217101406,
0.0166806299,
0.014763019,
-0.0093510905,
-0.0112258513,
-0.0483854003,
0.0102497796,
0.0722470805,
-0.035976477,
-0.0218938235,
0.0096538886,
0.0387887731,
-0.042841401,
-0.049513083,
-0.010818013,
-0.0363958515,
0.0313840583,
0.0381339937,
-0.0889606476,
0.0104951868,
-0.0099175228,
0.0029556209,
-0.0421621278,
0.003915166,
1.314020276e-34,
0.0690933242,
-0.0320698693,
0.0599630103,
-0.0181978978,
0.0316476151,
-0.0123583553,
0.0086944159,
0.0023291141,
-0.0017414488,
-0.0381003991,
0.0059386869
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10179v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10179v1 | Toward Human-Like Evaluation for Natural Language Generation with Error Analysis | 2022-12-20T11:36:22 | 2022-12-20T11:36:22 | Qingyu Lu, Liang Ding, Liping Xie, Kanjian Zhang, Derek F. Wong, Dacheng Tao | cs.CL | cs.CL | The state-of-the-art language model-based automatic metrics, e.g. BARTScore,
benefiting from large-scale contextualized pre-training, have been successfully
used in a wide range of natural language generation (NLG) tasks, including
machine translation, text summarization, and data-to-text. Recent studies show
that considering both major errors (e.g. mistranslated tokens) and minor errors
(e.g. imperfections in fluency) can produce high-quality human judgments. This
inspires us to approach the final goal of the evaluation metrics (human-like
evaluations) by automatic error analysis. To this end, we augment BARTScore by
incorporating the human-like error analysis strategies, namely BARTScore++,
where the final score consists of both the evaluations of major errors and
minor errors. Experimental results show that BARTScore++ can consistently
improve the performance of vanilla BARTScore and outperform existing
top-scoring metrics in 20 out of 25 test settings. We hope our technique can
also be extended to other pre-trained model-based metrics. We will release our
code and scripts to facilitate the community. | [
0.0173810571,
0.0702636093,
0.0200888664,
-0.0077952654,
0.0079822522,
0.0106583545,
0.0070156143,
-0.0269375946,
0.0101801986,
-0.0597649626,
-0.0161476918,
-0.0687231869,
0.0237942897,
0.049883306,
0.0521221831,
-0.0676742569,
0.0241277833,
0.0082234703,
-0.0039906492,
0.0283608269,
-0.0007084176,
0.0192217268,
-0.0110583557,
0.0684209913,
-0.0127968956,
0.0028136815,
-0.0010204487,
0.0157867428,
0.0431280322,
-0.0478193536,
0.0279723611,
0.0530093908,
-0.0144229913,
0.0288642719,
0.0000020169,
-0.054471802,
-0.002731883,
0.005429619,
-0.0066585117,
0.0113869151,
0.0398934335,
0.0013202478,
-0.0038186347,
0.0329108946,
-0.0207267068,
-0.0327758268,
0.0168409981,
0.0131387422,
0.0810556784,
0.0640344843,
0.0023223474,
-0.0049097161,
-0.008687309,
-0.0279112104,
0.003939542,
-0.0395857729,
-0.0202114303,
0.0453559943,
-0.0175537597,
-0.0148953181,
0.0201596282,
0.0013375352,
0.0104140341,
-0.0198568385,
-0.00120634,
0.0116659785,
-0.0208488125,
-0.0295228157,
-0.0077781007,
0.0545688234,
-0.0053223399,
-0.034278769,
-0.0043725627,
-0.0142650288,
-0.0020638097,
-0.041396495,
-0.0065859258,
0.0560759306,
-0.0183671955,
-0.0103819743,
0.0123221474,
0.0253269728,
0.0110767093,
0.0183901247,
-0.0126052434,
0.0248236451,
0.0129719414,
-0.0060082739,
-0.0092791812,
0.0136378938,
-0.0648903623,
-0.0937070698,
0.0238138288,
0.0454740711,
-0.0835449025,
-0.0239123125,
-0.0871315449,
-0.0427422933,
0.0352228768,
-0.0232667718,
0.0203280933,
0.0256168973,
-0.0014526549,
0.0044695083,
-0.0046366565,
0.0966444239,
0.0433399193,
-0.0144510558,
-0.0571474805,
0.0109805316,
-0.0147825219,
0.0143727353,
-0.0538355708,
0.0093777375,
-0.0507683195,
-0.0178196207,
-0.0731543079,
0.0065912199,
-0.0028324944,
0.0045446083,
0.019024957,
0.0252515413,
-0.0390730761,
0.0006540522,
-0.0159853026,
-0.0110227354,
-0.03375322,
-0.0007296603,
0.0471305624,
0.0039698919,
-0.0081826486,
0.0461914986,
-0.0123112658,
0.0048096562,
0.0081839794,
0.0791209787,
-0.0117590884,
-0.0273999982,
-0.0242046937,
-0.0520769097,
-0.0212207455,
-0.0657711327,
-0.0494483002,
-0.0561155304,
0.0064281952,
-0.0113637522,
-0.014897503,
-0.003996782,
0.0109383287,
0.0311456192,
0.0153324492,
0.0222138781,
-0.0388299935,
0.0038957517,
0.0213407427,
0.002554229,
-0.0031006893,
0.0427440442,
0.0639194772,
0.0439704321,
0.0258562416,
0.0285758283,
0.0183615349,
0.0091283983,
0.0050526694,
-0.0198246464,
0.0063617229,
-0.0161386039,
-0.0424699448,
0.0422606356,
0.0543449223,
0.0783920437,
-0.0388786234,
0.0625022054,
0.0362576991,
0.0199921299,
0.0109189665,
0.0320193321,
0.0953059793,
0.0166871026,
0.0276050847,
0.0117889252,
-0.0217385348,
0.0191131216,
-0.0357656851,
0.0432710536,
0.0556394607,
0.0426534936,
0.0058130245,
-0.0646653697,
-0.0117307156,
0.001834524,
0.0090680765,
-0.024892211,
0.0109358942,
0.0146418847,
-0.0617104284,
0.0541681014,
-0.0176734552,
-0.1041689292,
0.0498620681,
-0.0245444439,
0.0195371117,
0.0606777519,
0.0720839053,
-0.0004811626,
-0.013981929,
0.0070554316,
-0.013105507,
0.036507953,
0.0582397543,
-0.0247589648,
-0.0133478902,
-0.0503867269,
-0.0169098396,
0.0031181385,
0.0295549612,
-0.0051149726,
0.0156410653,
0.0053151646,
0.0425226279,
-0.0167538393,
-0.0642959028,
0.0378126875,
0.0002969073,
-0.0104682734,
0.0109673431,
-0.0267520808,
0.0164237823,
0.0277911481,
-0.0285560172,
0.04168218,
0.0131151127,
0.0018601317,
-0.019986283,
0.0383071154,
-0.0423090309,
-0.0525408648,
0.0255022515,
-0.039428357,
-0.0089375935,
-0.0030754907,
-0.0419946946,
-0.0546067953,
0.0089883553,
-0.045737192,
-0.0187284332,
-0.0302541927,
0.0516493842,
0.024531588,
-0.0047782445,
-0.0267539397,
0.0575014725,
-0.0128469449,
0.0238916501,
-0.0024984949,
0.0259936508,
-0.0021471228,
-0.0320145823,
-0.0064145364,
-0.0388999395,
-0.0193807613,
0.0467935354,
0.0542474538,
0.0540421717,
-0.0545356236,
-0.0084937476,
-0.0999161452,
0.0225569569,
-0.0293102339,
0.0502452254,
0.0498366617,
0.007147572,
-0.0179098975,
-0.0039159344,
-0.028569039,
-0.0219439492,
0.0432979576,
-0.032487575,
0.0420875512,
-0.0118650133,
0.0241991933,
-0.0527921356,
0.0249963347,
0.0029828269,
0.0242598187,
0.0484697782,
-0.0032580777,
-0.0555604286,
0.0824855715,
-0.0238472838,
-0.0208944101,
0.0331209302,
-0.0626356006,
0.0232462492,
0.0214810055,
0.0733585581,
0.0203517228,
0.0433381945,
0.0478733331,
0.0006814215,
-0.0088676112,
-0.0059461505,
-0.009537763,
-0.0273472909,
-0.0010941684,
0.0261966325,
-0.0334397182,
0.0404907763,
0.037623547,
0.0100482507,
0.0125650847,
-0.0450625569,
0.0373415351,
-0.03812778,
-0.0441764109,
-0.022456171,
-0.0345610343,
0.0033715293,
0.0208055824,
-0.0288454965,
-0.0225162189,
0.0517944992,
-0.0384956375,
0.0082049454,
-0.0437054709,
0.0247347131,
-0.0170027371,
0.028280355,
0.0168925505,
0.0352106877,
-0.0207337439,
-0.0314290524,
-0.0221532267,
0.0143030491,
0.0114285899,
-0.0363434218,
0.0346985459,
-0.0838494673,
-0.0089032492,
0.0031064786,
0.0026766523,
-0.0381955579,
-0.0282286257,
-0.0042691641,
0.00346692,
0.0628969595,
-0.0240038931,
-0.0168162175,
0.0058083059,
0.0176583156,
0.02350563,
-0.0123598138,
-0.023219768,
-0.0047361916,
0.0540413633,
-0.0036004642,
0.0075973799,
0.0485912599,
-0.0566234626,
-0.012217069,
0.04219421,
0.0416640192,
0.0242803991,
-0.0256071426,
-0.0041063642,
-0.0055361623,
-0.0085931495,
-0.0216227733,
0.0404285081,
0.1004356295,
-0.0349091887,
-0.0503858887,
0.1264405549,
0.0386366434,
-0.0021966239,
-0.0000567839,
0.0180528983,
0.0436293818,
0.0070969644,
0.0101282252,
-0.0630770549,
-0.0277758427,
0.0109818401,
0.0514799245,
0.0028050984,
-0.0355853513,
-0.0302114468,
-0.1014494151,
0.0273245387,
0.0382677019,
-0.0775391832,
-0.0116076376,
-0.0061101462,
-0.0174365155,
-0.0425148271,
0.0159179773,
0.0288841873,
-0.0067903074,
0.0377193913,
0.0552154146,
-0.0406855159,
-0.0746992677,
-0.0181556642,
-0.0482344106,
0.0443932377,
0.0681834295,
0.036287982,
0.017713435,
0.0063918373,
0.032607805,
-0.0018997638,
0.002905108,
0.0183556657,
0.0506120585,
0.0003211997,
-0.0043178243,
-0.0432359353,
0.0171280839,
-0.0253333002,
-0.029010104,
-0.0195264947,
0.0212629884,
0.0079607088,
0.0166685842,
0.0125643611,
0.0305667315,
0.029075563,
0.0502865463,
0.056263797,
-0.0235904027,
-0.0346516594,
-0.0227898248,
0.0074857282,
-0.0868793651,
0.0083836513,
0.014915552,
-0.0353873745,
-0.024494445,
-0.1192616224,
-0.0718524307,
0.0284410045,
0.038965717,
-0.0217976533,
-0.0690614805,
-0.0179531202,
-0.0001634229,
-0.0143459719,
0.0299563967,
0.0028812096,
0.0131696826,
-0.0654273704,
0.0077882763,
-0.0241090395,
-0.0149137601,
-0.0152380401,
0.0521063916,
-0.083857432,
-0.0585057661,
0.0054062973,
0.0738513544,
0.0219811704,
-0.0102482513,
-0.0187617615,
-0.0508474447,
0.0189310107,
0.0935757235,
-0.0386686139,
0.0117933108,
0.0230048038,
0.0114095854,
-0.0267498959,
0.009496172,
-0.0293248743,
0.0060081733,
-0.0390172489,
0.0769068003,
-0.0064097694,
-0.048041109,
0.0435989052,
0.0392651446,
-0.006549845,
-0.086640574,
0.0081019308,
-0.0342603587,
-0.0496805832,
-0.0175018515,
-0.0463097468,
-0.0447332226,
0.0176067799,
-0.0019154752,
-0.0203610901,
-0.0023033437,
0.0028712805,
-0.0533618182,
0.0020317885,
-0.0023807848,
-0.0120639894,
0.0153558152,
0.0437059216,
0.0097143818,
-0.0034582175,
-0.0310311895,
-0.0434752367,
-0.0218629837,
0.0236197691,
-0.0198507234,
0.0487401411,
-0.002561579,
0.0068837865,
0.011636097,
0.0408132449,
-0.0217725448,
-0.0046916436,
-0.0861988366,
0.0345846936,
0.0859971642,
0.0024240781,
0.1125150993,
-0.0160160456,
0.0098228287,
-0.0313127227,
0.0540197939,
-0.0061881426,
-0.0365803242,
-0.0302591138,
0.0088792341,
0.0054616402,
-0.0233586449,
0.0818044618,
-0.0375788882,
0.0002880165,
-0.0249181837,
-0.0247893985,
-0.0286360402,
-0.0197587293,
0.0065882434,
-0.0091432799,
-0.014848521,
-0.0201959461,
-0.0513729379,
-0.0859002247,
0.0041311369,
0.1068149284,
0.054005146,
0.012576675,
0.0518897027,
0.0391777754,
-0.0328134224,
0.0390171707,
-0.0444596708,
0.0033690026,
-0.0179506335,
0.0144767938,
-0.0460764132,
-5.89183556e-33,
-0.0807776228,
-0.0826381519,
0.008383722,
-0.0496064946,
-0.0364975184,
-0.0297788549,
-0.0612216406,
0.0056752278,
0.0735907033,
0.016065469,
0.0184801091,
-0.0249546263,
0.0045340667,
0.0180219617,
0.0057143043,
0.0050378642,
0.0390058719,
0.0169626269,
-0.0610039867,
0.0239798985,
0.0386189818,
0.0040436652,
0.0303354617,
-0.0321145356,
0.0385955088,
-0.0142627675,
-0.0694303513,
0.0164960176,
0.0243490096,
0.0414498448,
-0.001966519,
0.0271529611,
-0.0043065338,
0.01372883,
-0.0514162779,
-0.0174871888,
-0.0478525087,
-0.0252952799,
-0.0135259815,
-0.0024563319,
-0.0361855216,
-0.0055810041,
0.0316511616,
-0.0249615442,
-0.0424842909,
0.02607104,
0.0128598362,
-0.0311229806,
-0.0003453524,
-0.0694998503,
-0.0448867045,
0.0169964246,
-0.0255995076,
-0.0404214412,
-0.0263580903,
0.053836327,
-0.0331390612,
-0.0434627905,
-0.0104242191,
0.0286901947,
0.0322420411,
0.0009448957,
0.052132085,
0.0060489764,
-0.0362912081,
0.0481379516,
0.0178760197,
-0.0233255643,
0.020075066,
0.0156348217,
-0.0058688638,
-0.0036319648,
0.061220549,
0.0764025003,
0.0226312,
0.0240989923,
-0.0579746403,
0.0871180817,
-0.0343351625,
0.0138374018,
-0.0171102583,
-0.0101268338,
-0.0242239907,
0.0003178173,
-0.0345012173,
-0.0404817723,
-0.0240981132,
-0.0292630885,
0.0224129763,
0.0227619167,
-0.0088968454,
-0.0513715968,
0.0071659042,
0.0002181863,
0.0305337217,
-0.0347324796,
-0.0316798203,
0.0004097419,
-0.0323275253,
0.0243512299,
-0.032084588,
-0.0131939659,
0.0319336653,
0.0497644991,
0.0168801658,
-0.0134557039,
0.0275385808,
0.0326082222,
-0.0535720289,
0.0445077531,
-0.0183805507,
0.0460749082,
0.0085926559,
-0.0129380366,
0.0079886233,
-0.0375569724,
-0.0344706029,
0.0626588911,
-0.0201361347,
-0.0171145778,
-0.0300390869,
-0.0088459123,
0.0261352602,
0.0284796283,
-0.0324604884,
0.025088314,
-0.0006625587,
-0.0002026369,
0.0253217332,
-0.0322650336,
-0.0234781969,
-0.0175696369,
2.624e-7,
0.0405939855,
0.0574072264,
0.0517161116,
0.0162971821,
-0.0283161346,
0.0234267544,
0.0035121266,
0.0339550786,
0.0011823534,
0.0642293468,
0.0227397177,
-0.0166693535,
0.0387667604,
0.0372525193,
-0.0309947189,
-0.0251200087,
-0.0849853233,
-0.0073240292,
0.004784395,
-0.0329296961,
0.0751495063,
0.0267071836,
-0.0174902175,
0.0009700239,
-0.0155501887,
-0.0220182445,
0.0608764738,
0.0086463522,
-0.0650181696,
0.0208086073,
0.038862627,
0.0216618516,
-0.0136769898,
0.0237562042,
-0.0252101012,
-0.0371681824,
0.0496434644,
-0.0000135668,
0.0395095982,
-0.0075019998,
0.0127220349,
0.0008425266,
0.035113547,
-0.0261902735,
0.0171324816,
-0.0731345341,
-0.0016868467,
-0.00392314,
-0.0306299999,
-0.0069950758,
-0.0003739234,
-0.0317805223,
-0.0478144623,
0.0231728591,
0.0213182904,
0.0361712314,
0.0072535248,
-0.0303134844,
-0.0464948043,
0.0141131245,
-0.0071826177,
-0.0266362987,
-0.0058911801,
0.0191356819,
0.0037670629,
-0.0725558847,
-0.001927989,
2.332582572e-34,
0.0809013844,
-0.006443867,
0.0029844202,
-0.0363428891,
0.062249247,
0.0016634699,
-0.0043409541,
-0.0192462299,
0.0277216639,
-0.0310734436,
-0.0294428766
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10173v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10173v1 | On the Role of Parallel Data in Cross-lingual Transfer Learning | 2022-12-20T11:23:04 | 2022-12-20T11:23:04 | Machel Reid, Mikel Artetxe | cs.CL | cs.CL | While prior work has established that the use of parallel data is conducive
for cross-lingual learning, it is unclear if the improvements come from the
data itself, or if it is the modeling of parallel interactions that matters.
Exploring this, we examine the usage of unsupervised machine translation to
generate synthetic parallel data, and compare it to supervised machine
translation and gold parallel data. We find that even model generated parallel
data can be useful for downstream tasks, in both a general setting (continued
pretraining) as well as the task-specific setting (translate-train), although
our best results are still obtained using real parallel data. Our findings
suggest that existing multilingual models do not exploit the full potential of
monolingual data, and prompt the community to reconsider the traditional
categorization of cross-lingual learning approaches. | [
0.0003121727,
0.0385167673,
-0.0438842475,
0.0504460447,
-0.0310380012,
0.0358065665,
0.0861226171,
-0.029643245,
-0.0241804104,
-0.0254057385,
-0.0746842772,
-0.0471684262,
0.0194537602,
-0.0434707589,
0.0204660967,
-0.063124463,
0.0514783971,
-0.0178515855,
-0.028382713,
-0.005102667,
-0.0384116918,
0.0325488672,
-0.0155407647,
-0.0135540888,
-0.0231209621,
-0.0026312738,
0.0319854356,
0.0084386533,
0.025397405,
0.0157095194,
-0.0165590551,
0.0392922387,
0.0281626787,
0.0143859368,
0.0000019198,
-0.0437160209,
-0.0473273657,
-0.0038556824,
0.0353202298,
-0.0063266326,
0.0317692347,
-0.0636815578,
-0.0004321112,
0.0287084207,
-0.0300835408,
-0.045194909,
0.0665592328,
0.0006037195,
0.0259018559,
0.0815660581,
-0.0479818135,
-0.0156069323,
-0.012312877,
-0.0516827479,
-0.0219623484,
-0.0132436045,
0.0185638256,
0.0449451283,
-0.0596247464,
0.0200675633,
-0.0340388492,
0.0457636416,
0.0200398993,
0.0070614764,
-0.0260160752,
0.005447235,
0.0176837202,
-0.0116978129,
-0.0265469439,
0.0738621205,
-0.054076869,
-0.0037649381,
-0.0138408029,
-0.0185417049,
-0.0031799998,
0.0277684815,
-0.0541309565,
0.0211313423,
0.0253619403,
0.0348608866,
0.0337971039,
0.0040589194,
0.0432225913,
-0.0477213003,
-0.0353773162,
0.0001268157,
0.0270618219,
-0.0064131445,
0.072007753,
0.0415623933,
0.0087956497,
-0.0010356155,
0.0170055926,
-0.0212205723,
-0.005105339,
0.0250134598,
-0.0331048369,
-0.0970679149,
0.0072306707,
-0.0672237873,
0.0511469841,
0.0487598479,
-0.0138671361,
0.0331743918,
-0.0234568864,
0.0248068906,
-0.0236813966,
0.0374969654,
-0.0768366233,
-0.0231857859,
-0.05131552,
0.0340196714,
-0.041592665,
-0.0032946179,
-0.0438009165,
-0.0021734277,
-0.0002708373,
0.0218078271,
-0.014166005,
-0.0344513468,
0.0467719212,
-0.0472850129,
-0.0774916783,
0.0056382543,
0.0372897275,
0.055660259,
-0.0154708959,
0.0392933972,
-0.0068574343,
-0.0644363984,
-0.0324353985,
0.0083373738,
0.003702624,
-0.0926585644,
0.0119368844,
0.0753259584,
-0.0784354731,
-0.0006726944,
-0.0407905132,
0.0209825281,
-0.0013861124,
-0.0589891747,
0.0610907264,
-0.0417068303,
0.0932027251,
0.0105785718,
0.0557075962,
-0.0075227865,
-0.0298177134,
-0.0097928941,
-0.0456211604,
0.0854093581,
-0.0204366818,
0.0149717396,
0.0237165913,
-0.0288105682,
-0.0063059782,
0.087875776,
0.0259157531,
0.0023660581,
0.0247827452,
-0.0498394109,
-0.0514545776,
0.0296669304,
0.0472199954,
0.0101261362,
-0.0390998051,
0.0010960706,
0.059323132,
-0.0001499917,
0.0146205081,
0.0272171907,
-0.0125648528,
-0.0067794914,
0.056040924,
0.0222533643,
0.0098620793,
0.0378238112,
0.0695630759,
-0.0253739618,
-0.0174740907,
0.0607754178,
-0.006880709,
0.0434543602,
0.0396235697,
-0.0243185367,
0.0029481924,
0.0239443537,
-0.0373658054,
-0.0023085619,
0.0186179206,
0.0034840014,
0.0100517301,
-0.0266554803,
0.0715822279,
0.0609781593,
-0.0164270867,
0.0074826744,
0.0636558533,
-0.0281084608,
0.0267316904,
0.0129210921,
-0.0312105119,
0.0594952591,
-0.0097083356,
0.0317359604,
-0.024136113,
-0.0158072617,
0.0364211835,
0.0262445044,
0.1116108745,
0.0065114424,
0.0432014726,
-0.049708657,
-0.0169549286,
-0.0149504663,
-0.0065732766,
0.0533975251,
-0.01972083,
0.0396424234,
-0.0003320283,
0.017254997,
-0.036688339,
0.0477448106,
-0.076670371,
-0.0255415179,
0.0635960624,
0.0197242219,
0.0362847336,
0.004131624,
-0.0150681306,
-0.02220973,
0.0350297466,
-0.0421366096,
0.0048831766,
0.0399734378,
-0.0357144512,
-0.0408729874,
0.0160607975,
-0.0273562167,
0.009363357,
0.0399053767,
-0.0080091367,
-0.0426514596,
-0.0024732593,
-0.0048648412,
0.0473346561,
-0.0194505285,
0.0087713366,
0.0023091838,
0.0404834598,
-0.0206184462,
-0.0210214239,
0.0324897319,
-0.0059931632,
-0.0151165472,
-0.0009640695,
0.0164573155,
-0.0362515487,
-0.0181279834,
0.0555067919,
-0.0132811973,
0.0077132117,
0.0095192911,
0.0213978924,
-0.0132075725,
-0.0005502628,
-0.0623819754,
0.0257373359,
-0.0109116733,
0.0437495187,
0.025957752,
0.0352129079,
0.0068772449,
-0.0111487042,
-0.014488318,
0.0452722833,
0.0179110412,
0.0242727716,
0.0124328947,
0.0148111731,
0.0442337766,
-0.0266122334,
-0.0367977656,
0.0234283768,
0.0410168469,
-0.0147943478,
-0.017957028,
-0.0251922645,
0.0298585463,
-0.0085858703,
0.0092075504,
-0.0129852463,
-0.0359206162,
0.0058936449,
-0.0156210754,
0.0544338562,
0.0287891384,
-0.0154690277,
-0.0013618446,
0.0213926546,
-0.0540702529,
-0.0394729823,
0.0292496365,
-0.0208879504,
-0.0118612861,
-0.0496856123,
-0.0346214846,
-0.0096213641,
0.0567888767,
0.0059473454,
-0.0281430967,
-0.0591307208,
-0.0280702543,
0.0008432161,
-0.0391788036,
-0.018968828,
0.0517786965,
0.0236626118,
-0.0011739692,
-0.0267650951,
-0.0457401797,
0.0193032827,
-0.0161918513,
-0.0112237604,
-0.0334269404,
-0.0092477314,
-0.0211196225,
0.0580586158,
-0.0217130892,
0.0110455807,
-0.0798920691,
0.0065510864,
-0.0143338554,
0.0122105684,
-0.0212013461,
0.0119362725,
0.0096038263,
-0.0532364994,
-0.0218816437,
-0.0285240095,
-0.0143451896,
-0.0286778696,
-0.0050417669,
0.0293265041,
0.0082696741,
0.0554954335,
0.0103233466,
-0.0617534406,
0.0053062974,
0.0032506925,
0.0617800578,
-0.0004052762,
0.0127389338,
-0.0109504908,
0.0279310457,
0.0081677074,
-0.0174648687,
-0.0006895677,
-0.0801518634,
-0.0042161793,
0.0092889993,
0.0329709984,
-0.0338208191,
-0.0281847268,
0.0000610479,
0.0238413066,
-0.0147372466,
-0.0247408636,
-0.0282225776,
0.0159344617,
-0.0356165282,
-0.0136468755,
0.0452631861,
-0.020727003,
-0.0393697768,
-0.0215164516,
0.0123700136,
-0.0312627703,
-0.0051169964,
0.0351189412,
-0.0445827842,
-0.0108807674,
-0.0100694504,
-0.012678301,
0.0474432819,
0.0270469934,
-0.0541573316,
-0.0830694064,
0.0159877595,
0.0213615131,
-0.1155757457,
-0.0097104376,
-0.0435229987,
-0.0118817957,
-0.048227217,
0.0348037891,
-0.037039496,
-0.0134125091,
-0.0111585967,
0.0180033408,
0.0462536961,
-0.0297223348,
-0.012061134,
-0.0587239452,
0.0391554013,
0.02333932,
0.0397155322,
-0.0192970447,
-0.042529095,
0.0264225211,
-0.0321855955,
-0.0205179285,
-0.0298185386,
0.0315601081,
-0.0223472659,
-0.0256940834,
0.0432763696,
-0.0157122463,
-0.0296449531,
0.0038573749,
0.0446430184,
0.0790962428,
0.0154977851,
-0.0409194604,
0.0137965679,
-0.0312818028,
0.0438934639,
0.0549637266,
-0.0284089353,
-0.0634584054,
0.017996978,
0.0063139978,
-0.0151823945,
-0.0919898525,
0.019367924,
-0.0121440347,
-0.0548927337,
-0.019545624,
-0.0699247941,
-0.0535422377,
0.0258900281,
0.0564325824,
0.049724184,
0.0189724248,
0.0015931923,
-0.0101085743,
-0.0229322203,
0.0279434919,
-0.0405825973,
0.0149124907,
-0.0263733715,
-0.049106244,
-0.0040184064,
-0.043460004,
0.0192406829,
0.0105650574,
-0.082841754,
-0.0452933051,
-0.0246242788,
0.0913968012,
0.0068059778,
0.0438964963,
-0.0008352133,
-0.0087756226,
-0.0092551485,
0.0065123602,
-0.0626053587,
-0.0081361169,
0.0244111959,
-0.0089230128,
0.0157331321,
0.0294884015,
0.0155692399,
0.0150328297,
0.0439130962,
0.019668676,
-0.0161317587,
-0.0684882402,
0.002329696,
-0.0046925833,
0.0401320197,
0.0164382812,
-0.0045780293,
-0.0589857548,
0.0389530435,
-0.0284227617,
0.0123771718,
-0.0652913675,
-0.0466282219,
0.0410766825,
0.0220851321,
-0.0038372311,
0.0055954568,
-0.0014362927,
-0.0238247588,
-0.0280061215,
-0.026842257,
-0.0210736934,
0.0426636115,
-0.0124634476,
0.0550902076,
0.0167527534,
-0.0116621852,
0.0435384922,
0.0207586661,
-0.018310057,
0.0023563108,
-0.0016199833,
0.0069871405,
0.0316427946,
-0.0059080445,
-0.0450675003,
-0.017482819,
-0.0309441388,
-0.0384473279,
0.0498567298,
-0.0471797697,
0.1376589984,
0.0088388203,
-0.0083694402,
-0.0191238392,
0.0308771655,
-0.0230694935,
0.0362097919,
-0.0248599555,
-0.0157888588,
0.0056052809,
0.0270451363,
0.0758070052,
-0.018833654,
0.0250542033,
-0.0152217485,
-0.0005165805,
-0.0378072485,
-0.0335060991,
0.0440356173,
0.0005654449,
-0.0063430583,
-0.0070901792,
0.0021105781,
-0.0445951223,
-0.0262878537,
-0.0066418531,
0.0098810047,
0.0099969888,
0.0195393246,
0.0716175139,
-0.0569894984,
-0.0106050093,
-0.0491702631,
0.0195077416,
0.0057054101,
-0.001573625,
-0.0046440391,
-5.771071883e-33,
-0.0433773287,
0.0006838277,
0.0390473828,
-0.0024515747,
-0.0168812703,
-0.025464464,
-0.0179991368,
-0.0386867635,
-0.0008048759,
0.0417406335,
0.0182740483,
0.0018521375,
0.0230107624,
0.0126144327,
0.0415388718,
0.0388486385,
0.0686204433,
0.0074976757,
0.0091039827,
0.0239896495,
0.0586360432,
0.043962229,
0.0890571252,
-0.0715294108,
0.0169699285,
-0.0047839596,
-0.0143188769,
0.011515649,
-0.0107912999,
0.0217814241,
0.0070367735,
-0.0007561218,
0.0222085379,
-0.0401158482,
-0.0344333276,
0.0150113311,
-0.0939370543,
-0.0087332046,
0.0346007161,
0.0405518971,
-0.0325537771,
-0.0273981169,
0.0151690459,
-0.0405868739,
0.0256517604,
-0.0485716388,
0.0188348386,
-0.0556360148,
-0.0191412736,
0.0271891691,
-0.0827370062,
-0.0065175486,
-0.0150361396,
0.014126312,
0.0662529171,
0.0706988052,
-0.016715195,
-0.0149987023,
-0.052965682,
0.01926242,
-0.0499833524,
0.0131526506,
0.0679383278,
0.0194744803,
-0.0023726656,
-0.0059823846,
0.0585047267,
0.0016670928,
0.0769014359,
-0.0039818143,
0.0236768313,
0.0550487824,
0.0297973845,
0.0574872904,
0.0148382848,
-0.040771693,
-0.0866868719,
0.0397217534,
-0.028730724,
-0.0317110829,
-0.0090808729,
-0.0062647266,
0.0163584426,
-0.0098221404,
-0.0121423295,
-0.0231187269,
0.0091384752,
-0.0446233712,
0.0142758992,
0.0121420687,
-0.006724583,
0.0314334817,
0.089463301,
-0.0216649473,
-0.0005696942,
0.0057716817,
-0.0315570645,
-0.0019167718,
-0.017526269,
0.0107977763,
-0.0565188713,
-0.0949558392,
0.0235477202,
0.0237046797,
0.0117647378,
0.002633004,
0.075629957,
0.0190973952,
-0.0495908447,
0.0032756026,
-0.0628947094,
0.0208506715,
0.0047593196,
0.0504950099,
0.0323223993,
-0.0052047796,
-0.0077534383,
0.0488417931,
0.0522940867,
-0.0379644707,
-0.0026939737,
-0.0147525724,
-0.0007338673,
0.010267619,
-0.0251158252,
-0.0012765663,
-0.0133418404,
-0.0136496676,
0.0399855897,
-0.0487665199,
-0.0307750404,
0.0097604459,
2.523e-7,
0.0366590954,
0.0252671707,
-0.0148779973,
-0.0142843938,
0.0203524493,
0.0120548001,
-0.0719437376,
0.0518397205,
0.0217419285,
0.0505985059,
0.0405006185,
0.0374008343,
0.09851899,
0.0490552299,
-0.0228716973,
-0.0593194664,
-0.0293879844,
0.0413960405,
-0.0348331966,
-0.0150300451,
-0.0039161802,
0.0329988189,
0.0091559114,
-0.0292039663,
-0.0007581944,
-0.019819038,
0.0790507495,
-0.0647777542,
-0.0244876202,
0.0118069388,
-0.0326511413,
0.018238876,
-0.0551722944,
0.0565149151,
-0.0516286828,
0.0428869091,
0.0343039967,
0.063442938,
0.017590031,
-0.0154035687,
0.0426832177,
-0.0047062528,
-0.0107673788,
-0.0404575691,
0.0612745173,
-0.0518874265,
0.0055650785,
0.0043607163,
-0.0095410869,
0.047128126,
0.0659414753,
-0.0296246111,
-0.0089536635,
0.0170825049,
0.0674317777,
0.0407698676,
-0.0507405698,
0.0002498555,
-0.0267554298,
0.0297034439,
-0.0531566665,
-0.031709265,
-0.018272616,
0.021007264,
0.0000920016,
-0.0018663375,
0.0214836206,
1.611801694e-34,
-0.0084164869,
-0.0170612223,
0.0207279641,
-0.0386518203,
-0.0007308562,
-0.0494073071,
-0.0191696621,
0.0011779555,
-0.0220804214,
-0.0264206734,
-0.025240086
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10171v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10171v1 | Document-level Relation Extraction with Relation Correlations | 2022-12-20T11:17:52 | 2022-12-20T11:17:52 | Ridong Han, Tao Peng, Benyou Wang, Lu Liu, Xiang Wan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Document-level relation extraction faces two overlooked challenges: long-tail
problem and multi-label problem. Previous work focuses mainly on obtaining
better contextual representations for entity pairs, hardly address the above
challenges. In this paper, we analyze the co-occurrence correlation of
relations, and introduce it into DocRE task for the first time. We argue that
the correlations can not only transfer knowledge between data-rich relations
and data-scarce ones to assist in the training of tailed relations, but also
reflect semantic distance guiding the classifier to identify semantically close
relations for multi-label entity pairs. Specifically, we use relation embedding
as a medium, and propose two co-occurrence prediction sub-tasks from both
coarse- and fine-grained perspectives to capture relation correlations.
Finally, the learned correlation-aware embeddings are used to guide the
extraction of relational facts. Substantial experiments on two popular DocRE
datasets are conducted, and our method achieves superior results compared to
baselines. Insightful analysis also demonstrates the potential of relation
correlations to address the above challenges. | [
0.0130355293,
0.0270123295,
-0.0007797554,
0.0882212147,
-0.0211839918,
0.0248306394,
-0.0350692347,
0.0041033686,
0.0194573551,
-0.0064808591,
-0.03903329,
0.0086230012,
-0.0361354463,
-0.0294274744,
-0.0233316366,
-0.0337356254,
0.0308810882,
0.044846423,
0.045104403,
0.0266895741,
0.0086620944,
0.0212484635,
-0.0091809342,
-0.0137927281,
-0.0749581754,
-0.0559113584,
0.0372353308,
-0.0053813024,
0.0552564599,
-0.02794124,
0.0218007993,
0.0130948648,
0.0120114191,
-0.0382380523,
0.0000016651,
-0.0539949127,
-0.0314172953,
0.0357046165,
-0.0022038794,
-0.0593126193,
-0.0355940796,
-0.0599709563,
0.0316189602,
-0.0153603945,
-0.0398025252,
-0.0310648419,
-0.0167731885,
0.0860568509,
0.0049522221,
0.0384730399,
-0.0321545564,
-0.0420540087,
0.0458970852,
-0.0253318977,
0.0533015095,
-0.0260382332,
0.0161773171,
0.0197790917,
0.0027738435,
0.0068901982,
-0.0272717681,
-0.0066746315,
0.0153979398,
-0.0081477175,
0.0132369064,
0.0489059836,
-0.0220803395,
-0.0128133185,
0.0052965381,
0.0885859802,
0.0232700389,
0.0292783156,
0.0421629548,
0.0276543293,
-0.0037313357,
0.0152777852,
-0.0020545577,
-0.0416366309,
-0.0479800217,
0.0223925617,
0.0200603642,
0.0392084382,
0.027412679,
-0.0022975968,
-0.0055808718,
0.0083415508,
-0.0288292132,
-0.0561693721,
0.0120121697,
0.0107109528,
0.0123103019,
0.0033100843,
0.0193150267,
0.0345252939,
0.0137115,
0.0320897773,
-0.0399381816,
-0.0544888191,
0.0129508954,
-0.0693744719,
-0.0520235188,
-0.0390532799,
-0.0274248105,
0.095307745,
-0.0336519964,
-0.0148489559,
0.0050642951,
-0.029847173,
0.0301152617,
-0.0280177146,
-0.0275994539,
0.0273513272,
-0.0059085945,
0.0592626445,
0.0048645241,
-0.0252595004,
-0.0186096113,
-0.0112885227,
-0.0151212905,
0.0661445111,
0.0048558079,
0.0192021914,
-0.0164228249,
-0.0191669315,
0.0000373344,
-0.01232858,
-0.0504477732,
-0.0035525791,
-0.0378708281,
0.0323384553,
-0.00508019,
-0.0175970439,
0.0565433018,
-0.071840845,
0.0043216823,
0.0683832094,
0.0431048125,
-0.0656931922,
0.0001581208,
-0.0425338447,
0.013001875,
-0.0511875823,
-0.0079628164,
-0.0230262969,
0.0650340021,
0.0359538533,
-0.0169307236,
-0.0128144585,
0.0447366014,
-0.0064382437,
-0.0776445046,
0.0569432676,
-0.0056231888,
-0.0247818157,
0.0059724161,
0.0276780557,
0.0193101391,
0.0797481388,
0.0633477122,
-0.0024088742,
0.0601334497,
0.0149774114,
-0.0269277599,
-0.0068994532,
-0.0062431949,
-0.0390004143,
0.0230474435,
0.0113825072,
0.0472921059,
0.0034094059,
0.0510130227,
0.0350400135,
-0.010871944,
-0.0464219302,
-0.0177475419,
-0.003377659,
0.0296425093,
-0.0014893584,
0.0497602299,
-0.0225921236,
0.0052369456,
0.0423767567,
-0.0303526986,
0.0017812961,
0.0193319339,
0.0382869393,
-0.0321864784,
0.0471235141,
0.0066207894,
-0.0031716758,
0.0028502843,
-0.0421305262,
-0.0341433212,
-0.0097549781,
0.0885446593,
0.008108126,
-0.0236270875,
0.0249523837,
0.0658590123,
-0.0034871709,
-0.0008592258,
0.051380299,
-0.0203831475,
0.0099023972,
0.0425522253,
-0.0522272661,
-0.0455716848,
-0.0286889281,
-0.0115182186,
-0.0129738152,
0.0527070984,
-0.0319539197,
0.049150262,
-0.0154630505,
-0.0346783623,
0.0238883886,
0.0013233969,
-0.023149563,
0.0209463332,
0.046308428,
0.0376590081,
-0.0475987531,
0.0294702649,
0.0388863795,
-0.0475975648,
-0.0192341227,
0.0077685886,
0.0408636704,
-0.0112304566,
0.048226539,
-0.0007467928,
-0.00580962,
0.0812149644,
-0.056487143,
0.0249485038,
-0.0104528721,
-0.0319774933,
-0.0296497326,
0.0433167815,
-0.0054176608,
-0.0369492993,
-0.0513716154,
-0.028694978,
-0.0134613104,
-0.0091285296,
0.0169465933,
0.0664525926,
-0.0036535494,
-0.0166731998,
0.037985675,
0.0068816999,
-0.0055853925,
0.097967647,
0.0119430413,
0.0037578472,
0.0253384355,
-0.0394328646,
-0.0075865248,
0.022045264,
-0.0031496275,
-0.0080691045,
0.0075363331,
-0.0350966044,
0.0121308267,
-0.0087470589,
-0.0570679158,
-0.0263808928,
-0.0232221819,
0.0162288677,
0.0298674256,
0.0426096842,
-0.0254877638,
-0.0064164544,
0.0073743607,
-0.0262686554,
-0.0149520067,
0.0185952466,
-0.0382664353,
-0.0194154531,
0.067559734,
0.0155400056,
-0.0413235873,
-0.031818293,
-0.0180498622,
-0.0451099053,
0.0440557115,
0.0159474909,
-0.0268565454,
0.037093468,
0.0294382628,
-0.0309518743,
0.0218045618,
-0.0160265453,
0.0422037132,
-0.0253192876,
-0.0048304931,
0.049655579,
0.0341508053,
0.0198493358,
0.091313608,
-0.009061221,
-0.0099718068,
-0.0240797959,
0.0405255295,
-0.0481937677,
0.0650476217,
-0.0124119949,
-0.0026015171,
-0.0227303468,
0.0285514072,
-0.0106568094,
-0.0021195121,
-0.0070973639,
-0.0147815971,
0.0316708609,
-0.0019632571,
-0.015577646,
0.0355440453,
0.0121609243,
-0.0302666165,
-0.0461013652,
0.0083880462,
0.0573933981,
-0.0155542018,
0.0155456914,
-0.0096110869,
0.0039603207,
-0.052456975,
0.0885095149,
0.0070843813,
0.0064895181,
0.008417136,
-0.0058165574,
-0.024920674,
0.0033594496,
0.0346631557,
-0.0028959804,
-0.0184095316,
-0.006278723,
0.0040365299,
-0.011728053,
-0.0449316204,
-0.0437706336,
-0.0047168867,
-0.0145799974,
0.0245823767,
-0.0143480888,
0.0166529398,
0.0046595912,
-0.0158661567,
0.0219634324,
0.0070551145,
0.0007615484,
-0.0242001321,
-0.0063169277,
0.0999039412,
0.0963860452,
-0.0104253525,
0.0004672876,
0.0074635162,
0.0101770153,
0.0389025733,
-0.0081996238,
-0.0279008131,
0.0208771564,
-0.0179081801,
-0.0346264951,
-0.0391021222,
-0.0063054608,
-0.0228503365,
-0.011367958,
-0.0568320453,
-0.0205567144,
0.086339131,
0.0396849588,
-0.0069480436,
0.00176538,
0.0175784249,
0.0040577087,
0.0390036888,
0.0171908438,
-0.0559289716,
-0.0237036031,
-0.0158948656,
-0.0494460277,
0.0453009829,
-0.0633261353,
-0.0119183389,
-0.0559794903,
-0.0134673649,
-0.0296679046,
0.0031328129,
-0.0192817617,
-0.083622843,
0.0199079551,
0.0011765723,
-0.0135030057,
-0.0161631983,
-0.03381145,
-0.0098980693,
0.0088923965,
-0.0118878558,
-0.028593054,
0.0165807921,
-0.0389485285,
-0.0020261926,
0.0176541843,
0.0632882938,
-0.0210618488,
0.0061715473,
-0.0177613068,
-0.0419013314,
-0.0354203656,
-0.0033389721,
0.0651545525,
-0.0708531961,
-0.0012920821,
-0.0159313176,
0.0093756998,
-0.0449519195,
-0.0054215561,
0.0313519724,
0.0819816515,
-0.0011445527,
-0.0492778569,
-0.0248291586,
-0.0181395486,
0.005645555,
0.0543421768,
0.0149843078,
-0.0183275919,
-0.0214522295,
0.0316644385,
0.0359919891,
0.0145151904,
0.0475744493,
-0.0524868183,
-0.0509765856,
0.0084440308,
-0.0691936463,
-0.0841524452,
0.0289586,
0.0115957549,
-0.0187385418,
0.0181450211,
0.0072670709,
-0.0134150134,
-0.0557403676,
-0.0080720941,
0.0145050017,
-0.004228414,
-0.0160829686,
0.0357162878,
0.0385663137,
-0.0067606382,
-0.0509555079,
-0.0347778648,
-0.0513514504,
-0.0139145348,
-0.0176612232,
0.0060812952,
0.0030779759,
0.0525130741,
-0.0260446779,
0.0236448478,
-0.0225076191,
0.1057831198,
-0.0880887434,
-0.0282366667,
0.0154360589,
-0.033185605,
0.0082105212,
0.0456707962,
-0.0337321013,
0.033298701,
0.0048567331,
0.0395720862,
-0.0658071563,
-0.0559718236,
0.0106950533,
-0.0193119273,
0.0816440582,
0.0150098084,
0.0145870866,
-0.0540446378,
0.0320507735,
-0.0563379228,
-0.0106162513,
-0.0055273501,
0.0195442829,
-0.0215919521,
0.0165870339,
-0.0344861336,
0.0094235251,
0.0257086847,
0.0256938636,
0.0109658083,
0.0066080033,
0.0194478128,
-0.0151847629,
0.0196346603,
-0.0424679443,
-0.0143872844,
0.0017693178,
0.0228111371,
0.0094055235,
-0.0251120813,
0.0056471145,
0.0134507418,
-0.0026082799,
-0.0000494627,
-0.0232704189,
-0.0314064994,
0.0555981621,
-0.0271451399,
0.0234696921,
0.0316404253,
-0.0284381453,
0.0187117122,
-0.0356538668,
-0.004624411,
0.0252174661,
0.0469233952,
-0.0137394723,
0.0063337805,
0.0106635727,
0.0327406377,
-0.0418862775,
0.0317170806,
0.0927436426,
-0.0320794284,
0.0570087545,
0.0126843192,
-0.0335226357,
-0.0438262634,
-0.0032872937,
0.0252903607,
0.0111116525,
0.0032939862,
0.0180081241,
-0.0657971054,
-0.0489557907,
0.0407526828,
-0.0401636027,
-0.0435756519,
0.0273829345,
-0.0001764398,
0.0126179103,
0.0444832258,
-0.0360253118,
-0.0304730255,
0.022536505,
-0.0438560806,
-0.0456694588,
-0.0163504351,
-5.441952199e-33,
-0.0528654866,
-0.0451866165,
0.0051983744,
0.0168078858,
-0.0101681631,
0.0468243584,
-0.0124255624,
-0.0417180881,
-0.040569216,
0.0372945219,
-0.0262395125,
0.0005906438,
-0.0024939603,
0.0069854422,
-0.0155691775,
-0.0093817217,
0.0031442556,
0.0215005409,
0.0560723767,
0.0145034576,
0.0490083098,
0.0779076442,
0.0661429986,
-0.1293037534,
0.0121248728,
0.0027551171,
0.0067404811,
0.0132775204,
0.0467735268,
0.0424437039,
-0.0357356034,
0.0175830033,
0.0256015491,
-0.0119089987,
0.0386953764,
0.0032483512,
-0.1827446222,
-0.0300632492,
-0.0567000993,
-0.0346983857,
-0.0179286208,
0.0093532372,
0.0022073085,
0.0159839131,
0.0834424123,
-0.0529773384,
0.0695665851,
-0.0416321196,
-0.0457684807,
-0.0717850178,
-0.0655656308,
0.0407536887,
0.023791628,
0.0209507998,
0.0242609289,
-0.0259727612,
0.0316187255,
-0.0068583647,
-0.0435536504,
-0.054874517,
-0.0228734259,
0.0112045361,
-0.0242294315,
-0.0244019479,
0.0040139798,
0.0514205694,
-0.0223941319,
-0.0205141436,
0.0099224532,
0.0051203994,
-0.0033156783,
0.0439091288,
-0.0530101657,
0.0400254503,
0.0459116995,
-0.0128881363,
-0.0945352018,
0.0247953665,
0.0563775785,
0.039334625,
-0.0382022038,
-0.0261505451,
-0.0645386577,
0.0079323966,
0.02756745,
0.0380794406,
-0.0132498667,
-0.0362270325,
-0.0148875155,
0.0066382475,
-0.0061770845,
0.0337761939,
-0.0303462464,
-0.0140082166,
-0.0655121207,
0.0547044873,
-0.0088857282,
-0.0196841285,
0.0144864619,
-0.0239951573,
-0.0434827581,
-0.0443118103,
-0.0093169874,
-0.0024225202,
0.0262808893,
0.0151961688,
0.1109045371,
-0.0572693199,
-0.0532043613,
-0.037281666,
-0.0173524562,
0.0079482496,
-0.0065015494,
-0.0154876178,
-0.0014245033,
0.0359317213,
-0.0086777825,
0.0538695268,
0.0599622726,
0.0224421509,
-0.0201046951,
0.0094305966,
0.0057774945,
0.0193667896,
0.0336495973,
-0.0443168394,
-0.00153757,
0.0270875562,
0.0240734909,
-0.0363803804,
-0.0145348394,
-0.0228346866,
2.427e-7,
0.0441630371,
0.0153555479,
0.0565843806,
0.0143121853,
0.0063299071,
0.0315996483,
0.0361086763,
0.0582046621,
-0.0154060042,
-0.0230717864,
0.0253076218,
-0.0070675616,
-0.0056817369,
0.0564408638,
-0.0741405562,
-0.0234661102,
-0.0653725639,
-0.1008215845,
-0.0643576384,
-0.038239561,
0.0559785776,
0.0210891645,
0.0538985617,
0.0030311991,
-0.0328842513,
0.0098008355,
0.0516797081,
-0.0435353108,
0.0270097386,
-0.0030224584,
0.001235588,
-0.0195645783,
-0.0116431266,
0.0343178809,
-0.0359043218,
0.0590037666,
0.0279808454,
0.041084744,
0.0016187218,
0.0123231933,
0.0222622622,
-0.0152587835,
-0.0011921976,
0.0217191465,
0.0872475803,
-0.043102134,
-0.0114518171,
-0.0256704018,
-0.0170623679,
0.0047731251,
-0.0188885275,
0.0279846173,
-0.0087242499,
0.0263777692,
0.0202059578,
-0.0241590217,
-0.0166931078,
-0.0583825447,
0.0337513089,
0.1005235985,
0.0002897656,
0.0043753716,
0.0151313273,
-0.0095608728,
0.0049570058,
-0.0098398905,
0.0202445108,
1.954000382e-34,
-0.0253339931,
0.022607334,
-0.0009706565,
0.0097958958,
0.0467861518,
-0.0351791568,
-0.0857985988,
-0.0033272423,
0.0241470393,
-0.0373612046,
0.0258682352
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10168v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10168v2 | Naamapadam: A Large-Scale Named Entity Annotated Data for Indic Languages | 2022-12-20T11:15:24 | 2023-05-28T06:26:45 | Arnav Mhaske, Harshit Kedia, Sumanth Doddapaneni, Mitesh M. Khapra, Pratyush Kumar, Rudra Murthy V, Anoop Kunchukuttan | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present, Naamapadam, the largest publicly available Named Entity
Recognition (NER) dataset for the 11 major Indian languages from two language
families. The dataset contains more than 400k sentences annotated with a total
of at least 100k entities from three standard entity categories (Person,
Location, and, Organization) for 9 out of the 11 languages. The training
dataset has been automatically created from the Samanantar parallel corpus by
projecting automatically tagged entities from an English sentence to the
corresponding Indian language translation. We also create manually annotated
testsets for 9 languages. We demonstrate the utility of the obtained dataset on
the Naamapadam-test dataset. We also release IndicNER, a multilingual IndicBERT
model fine-tuned on Naamapadam training set. IndicNER achieves an F1 score of
more than $80$ for $7$ out of $9$ test languages. The dataset and models are
available under open-source licences at
https://ai4bharat.iitm.ac.in/naamapadam. | [
0.032413099,
0.0434071347,
0.0076755863,
0.048838608,
-0.0175977759,
0.0606957041,
0.0010564172,
-0.0038404616,
0.0248225927,
-0.0142862741,
-0.0298025496,
-0.015294631,
0.0069649997,
-0.0222666748,
0.0397415757,
-0.0276361164,
0.0191680882,
-0.0002262219,
0.0184454862,
0.0441107675,
0.0026655579,
0.045544982,
-0.0483154319,
0.0109573686,
-0.0337156989,
-0.0034971542,
0.0016265088,
0.0061688279,
0.0429906808,
-0.0835398808,
0.0303365327,
0.0291121062,
-0.0073990128,
0.0090608634,
0.0000018042,
-0.0471653491,
-0.0321403146,
0.0080408091,
-0.0177181009,
-0.0331577286,
0.0262522008,
-0.0283391364,
0.0240586754,
0.0089978352,
-0.0092256675,
-0.0172436778,
0.053249348,
0.0727696493,
0.0184342694,
0.1144837067,
-0.0250696316,
-0.051960405,
0.0072726659,
-0.0083418367,
-0.0467885546,
-0.0097809257,
-0.0016057373,
-0.0321376882,
-0.0187131055,
0.0144068971,
0.0224317685,
0.008579988,
-0.0145609267,
-0.0013352848,
0.032656882,
0.0168768335,
-0.0280173291,
-0.0049653994,
0.0481036492,
0.0641975477,
-0.0156684183,
-0.0070643215,
0.0515345111,
-0.0058589284,
-0.0530269444,
-0.0445188209,
-0.0045195608,
0.0026352264,
-0.0579994135,
0.0414117537,
0.0759033561,
0.025814807,
0.0185505077,
-0.0090571949,
0.0421761349,
0.0018103159,
0.0157726798,
-0.0212522913,
-0.0068572909,
0.0156627409,
-0.0182014462,
-0.0074720983,
0.0101556685,
0.001763739,
0.0112736309,
0.0245546736,
-0.0119233867,
-0.0296744667,
0.0149002308,
-0.0666054785,
-0.0247688666,
0.015790442,
0.0088097006,
0.0370884426,
-0.0285980124,
0.0197201353,
-0.02753965,
0.0101149213,
0.0347313993,
-0.0597848184,
-0.0168695468,
-0.024078479,
0.0049149399,
0.0289381519,
-0.0439948887,
0.0345988609,
-0.039047949,
0.0081827175,
-0.0094871502,
0.005711352,
0.0190254785,
-0.0380009748,
0.0122572742,
-0.0309253763,
-0.0187812615,
0.0100496262,
-0.0254976917,
0.019773962,
-0.0144612929,
-0.0750274435,
-0.0004016962,
-0.0169049334,
0.0133712785,
-0.0337568112,
0.000806758,
0.0389136784,
0.0261621587,
-0.1103122905,
-0.0884359404,
0.02380055,
0.0230028499,
-0.0749738067,
-0.0178236533,
-0.0475023761,
0.070523791,
0.0149015673,
0.0050146212,
-0.0518167652,
0.0391757526,
0.0085636079,
-0.0210178122,
0.1024570242,
-0.0239683427,
-0.0272529386,
0.0516245328,
0.0030299572,
0.0764025599,
0.0220435672,
0.0406242907,
-0.0190755948,
0.0432945453,
0.011112242,
0.0121743428,
0.0488116182,
-0.012730727,
-0.0203707386,
0.0208645035,
0.0368431397,
-0.0116656516,
0.0281267818,
0.0122571113,
0.0239780471,
0.0045044888,
0.038996581,
0.0110127591,
0.044723291,
-0.0103097642,
0.0160705037,
-0.0136066386,
0.0056347395,
0.0197675154,
-0.0377833582,
-0.0424697474,
0.0220713783,
0.0222556256,
-0.0164356772,
0.025616765,
0.0222002342,
-0.0075943093,
0.0258005839,
-0.0003355044,
-0.0516594611,
-0.0243632272,
-0.0127809979,
0.0664370954,
-0.0065228976,
-0.0599634945,
0.0458829403,
0.043369621,
-0.0339928195,
0.0286532361,
0.0081349676,
0.0371021889,
0.0368909985,
0.0152065642,
-0.0425985232,
-0.0282016043,
-0.0333723836,
-0.0314811766,
0.0580272004,
0.0017938397,
-0.0231551789,
0.0269306675,
-0.0326170102,
0.0355624445,
0.0573191233,
-0.0025800539,
0.0160172936,
0.0197825003,
0.0521531217,
0.0270293709,
0.0158389714,
-0.0209095962,
0.0623965301,
-0.0265394971,
-0.0265886504,
0.019280104,
0.0284173433,
0.0373725258,
0.0379266329,
-0.0129258605,
-0.0563321561,
0.0337185934,
-0.0230882671,
-0.0051800101,
0.0098619284,
0.0309037231,
-0.056358397,
-0.0260100942,
-0.0413535982,
0.0053669331,
0.0188781004,
-0.0301206019,
-0.0792557001,
-0.0534362234,
0.024363935,
0.0057301419,
-0.0229117461,
0.0355388708,
0.0108801303,
0.01090331,
-0.0285504851,
0.0322936587,
-0.0001136855,
0.022935275,
0.0020510177,
0.0209718887,
0.0431156121,
-0.0491392948,
-0.0499756522,
-0.0007811594,
0.0155346021,
-0.0259793289,
0.0130712837,
0.002227308,
-0.0451002419,
-0.0375799946,
-0.1025483906,
-0.0027789301,
-0.0046726111,
0.0489481203,
-0.013769174,
0.0578193255,
-0.0268540233,
-0.0262824297,
0.0137448171,
-0.0164678711,
0.0267075486,
-0.0013889065,
0.0512325801,
-0.0068257712,
-0.0262662414,
0.0018693744,
0.0115005327,
-0.0395037122,
0.0132451588,
0.0064363885,
-0.0897686705,
-0.0459109135,
0.0067095743,
-0.0061703785,
0.0127702644,
-0.0109868543,
0.0030746313,
-0.0230778158,
0.01358133,
-0.014309993,
0.0229568221,
-0.0226836447,
0.0047176336,
-0.0759657472,
0.0099559221,
-0.0043436652,
0.0172680523,
0.0029155193,
0.0608487017,
-0.0179868322,
-0.044217661,
0.0218529608,
0.0553134754,
-0.0362722576,
0.0216740053,
-0.0167123135,
-0.0378111899,
-0.0292554554,
0.015672721,
0.0070229317,
0.0617367551,
-0.0401393846,
0.0396559723,
-0.0081206588,
-0.0195348039,
0.0212195069,
-0.0524762757,
0.0067703822,
-0.0248027854,
-0.0087264087,
-0.0499143489,
0.0390402116,
0.0047712107,
-0.0123221343,
0.0108715538,
-0.0780120939,
0.0013742354,
0.061698772,
-0.007867693,
-0.0238811523,
0.0091370242,
-0.0361428596,
0.0410429575,
-0.0308514293,
-0.0401913598,
-0.0287645459,
-0.0505807139,
-0.0316898525,
0.0024282415,
0.0096191969,
-0.0347702205,
0.0313200764,
0.0495801084,
-0.0235362984,
0.0117276153,
-0.0036658593,
0.0109222326,
0.0182486251,
0.0333083645,
0.0549077764,
0.0167481545,
-0.0012062909,
0.03129334,
-0.0249050688,
-0.0495305918,
-0.0087981578,
0.0163973719,
0.0106441202,
-0.0235267244,
0.0064141266,
-0.0324368775,
-0.0184439849,
-0.0344763584,
0.0382569842,
0.0185384657,
-0.006109599,
0.0841142833,
0.0148560945,
0.000167066,
-0.0357444175,
-0.0369532444,
-0.0260941014,
0.0102354717,
0.0319953561,
-0.0866940692,
-0.0369517505,
0.0282189362,
-0.0306682307,
-0.0009849498,
-0.073676616,
-0.0315865502,
-0.1012061164,
-0.0179774314,
-0.032080479,
-0.0482594818,
0.0025000754,
-0.0395053774,
-0.0518467315,
-0.0480182581,
-0.0056846417,
-0.0062754229,
-0.0270228535,
-0.0328038,
0.036152631,
-0.0109757818,
-0.0445159078,
-0.0073026279,
-0.0464165621,
0.0547528379,
0.0233178493,
0.0218866318,
-0.0327082574,
-0.0095906574,
-0.0130880959,
-0.0450190194,
-0.0305128489,
0.0020473488,
0.0546583645,
-0.0466511212,
-0.0331530273,
-0.0317241475,
0.0363246128,
-0.0188394189,
-0.0058147553,
0.0249015782,
0.0214699227,
-0.0002997816,
0.0388145968,
0.0113046756,
-0.0552270673,
0.0335149877,
0.0352582596,
-0.0212616995,
-0.0248364136,
-0.0252678916,
0.0131062092,
-0.010322676,
-0.019343039,
0.0279525872,
0.0227232706,
-0.0575818568,
-0.0368505307,
0.0153935468,
-0.0749107525,
0.0654050782,
0.0423034504,
0.0499108806,
0.0416028239,
0.0142085543,
0.0140669029,
-0.0339711644,
0.0288554654,
-0.0414769538,
0.0344497226,
-0.0486952364,
0.0203076843,
0.0356856547,
0.0407814309,
-0.0422040224,
-0.0049071158,
-0.0601912215,
-0.0620902479,
-0.0075197713,
0.0471839644,
0.0129728289,
0.0283717662,
-0.046622362,
-0.0593050532,
0.0474040657,
0.0126189413,
-0.0560446382,
-0.0317144245,
0.0116047682,
0.0375527963,
-0.0246758796,
0.0221630018,
-0.0353784673,
0.0161487777,
-0.017019568,
0.0132890968,
-0.003912156,
-0.0063221483,
-0.001058137,
0.0316387452,
0.0413313694,
-0.0785872042,
-0.0169419665,
-0.0694839656,
0.0019599297,
0.0205583125,
0.0095374929,
0.0017563145,
-0.0367807485,
0.0633160844,
0.0193870105,
-0.0257910062,
0.0064537879,
0.0033746918,
0.0093868664,
-0.0056664697,
0.0379355513,
0.0341716222,
0.0865721554,
-0.0013110397,
-0.0185631327,
0.0096432278,
0.0310221221,
0.0169749148,
0.0399313495,
-0.0223131105,
0.0475552343,
-0.0099716615,
0.026058048,
0.0214818828,
0.029330926,
0.0577152856,
0.0571589991,
-0.0356186815,
0.0712710097,
0.0515227541,
0.0132893771,
0.0664613694,
0.0052526058,
0.005412607,
-0.0023906375,
0.0387621373,
-0.0570287816,
-0.0107315267,
0.0476572253,
0.007565869,
-0.0451226309,
-0.0047587007,
0.0285007209,
0.0117240781,
-0.0127168298,
0.0400604866,
-0.001850743,
-0.0474870168,
0.0108216163,
0.0113620283,
-0.011459576,
0.0167427007,
-0.0130834365,
-0.0190328695,
-0.0273860749,
0.016691545,
-0.047700759,
-0.019560216,
-0.0178219192,
-0.0119298482,
-0.0263891183,
0.0249911975,
-0.0295039006,
-0.0572170839,
0.0022531943,
-0.0442711376,
-0.0338806175,
-0.000708346,
-5.397799162e-33,
-0.0468184054,
-0.0131562557,
0.0012975095,
-0.0016586261,
-0.0148083856,
0.0233641081,
0.0163921881,
-0.0185352769,
-0.0024788282,
-0.0105918311,
-0.0210744981,
0.0180749018,
0.033587005,
0.0148284473,
0.0316201597,
-0.044424776,
0.0472135879,
0.0635306537,
-0.0155174555,
0.0211536288,
0.0464816429,
0.0455780923,
0.1241917983,
-0.0585281551,
0.044325836,
-0.0600214936,
-0.0160188321,
0.0184864029,
0.0492814742,
0.0347981118,
-0.0486776382,
-0.015275199,
0.0249181148,
-0.0634054095,
0.0394430459,
0.0398805588,
-0.157136634,
0.0203778017,
-0.0156007251,
0.1107560322,
0.0047485749,
-0.0404910445,
0.0008544273,
-0.0062594642,
0.0051086582,
0.0537393875,
0.0266759116,
0.0268690065,
0.0159953199,
0.0148733743,
-0.0615203232,
0.0620787367,
0.0077646091,
0.0504378565,
0.0171457361,
0.0232473258,
0.0244580209,
-0.0347092263,
-0.1080616936,
-0.0309248623,
0.0183631107,
-0.0119553572,
0.0255484171,
0.0441906452,
-0.0327197611,
0.0271942969,
0.0443511531,
-0.0212391894,
0.0035734745,
0.0020489693,
0.0028050146,
0.0281439256,
-0.0418679975,
0.0495315194,
0.0358786881,
-0.0850493759,
-0.0438038856,
0.0487672836,
0.0129967015,
0.0055103921,
0.0015210197,
-0.0436759554,
-0.0682162717,
-0.014715529,
0.0263027623,
-0.0609536022,
-0.0359914787,
-0.0071679843,
0.0600881092,
0.0086921081,
-0.0205787364,
0.0678664222,
0.0500978604,
-0.0053265165,
-0.0330816805,
-0.0059839399,
0.0173655879,
0.0146985557,
-0.0162137058,
0.0102629932,
-0.0565918386,
-0.0868388191,
-0.0183083043,
0.0240369737,
0.0455748327,
-0.012233451,
0.0723939091,
-0.028379295,
-0.0720146969,
-0.0144388527,
-0.002831117,
0.0562522672,
-0.0403427854,
0.0663843006,
-0.0025906109,
-0.0101521909,
-0.0158942696,
-0.0222508106,
0.0704488382,
0.0191612691,
0.0059776842,
0.0033569138,
0.0464945659,
-0.0141537804,
0.0077764806,
0.0197780393,
-0.0282664467,
-0.0057165744,
-0.0031921456,
-0.0500672236,
0.0028330649,
0.0064495993,
2.37e-7,
-0.0059698829,
0.0139649902,
0.0254490077,
-0.0403780416,
-0.0312694684,
0.0048175226,
0.0046210927,
0.0435059406,
-0.056582436,
0.0417624488,
-0.0050718822,
-0.0323557891,
0.0292454474,
0.0217320323,
-0.1424539089,
-0.0283354931,
-0.0242068805,
0.0043557673,
-0.0785700604,
0.0273152478,
-0.0200486146,
0.0820699632,
0.0470731668,
-0.0153840827,
-0.0383065492,
-0.0103432285,
0.0447737053,
0.0128648281,
0.0163832661,
0.0342289694,
0.0098877074,
0.0745384097,
-0.0469953716,
0.0148806097,
-0.0155229084,
0.0259850025,
0.0167072639,
0.0781610757,
-0.0326887369,
0.0359422266,
0.0155494036,
-0.0292335209,
0.0015295509,
-0.0349851623,
0.0740121901,
0.0073392196,
-0.0518922955,
0.0130526088,
-0.0163773056,
-0.0199226569,
0.0225854795,
0.0428690016,
0.0111918058,
0.0004873308,
0.0390199199,
-0.0967173651,
-0.0263847616,
-0.0447497815,
0.0060858042,
0.0251266398,
0.0200564116,
-0.0087265233,
-0.0271817092,
0.0066157118,
0.034760695,
-0.0488125384,
0.0213506818,
1.785647551e-34,
-0.0124982949,
0.0179326683,
-0.0126715843,
0.0442166552,
0.0382145643,
-0.0220529903,
-0.0356029272,
-0.0050307116,
0.0077914484,
-0.0553445928,
0.020120386
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10154v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10154v2 | Human-Guided Fair Classification for Natural Language Processing | 2022-12-20T10:46:40 | 2023-03-16T08:57:14 | Florian E. Dorner, Momchil Peychev, Nikola Konstantinov, Naman Goel, Elliott Ash, Martin Vechev | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG | Text classifiers have promising applications in high-stake tasks such as
resume screening and content moderation. These classifiers must be fair and
avoid discriminatory decisions by being invariant to perturbations of sensitive
attributes such as gender or ethnicity. However, there is a gap between human
intuition about these perturbations and the formal similarity specifications
capturing them. While existing research has started to address this gap,
current methods are based on hardcoded word replacements, resulting in
specifications with limited expressivity or ones that fail to fully align with
human intuition (e.g., in cases of asymmetric counterfactuals). This work
proposes novel methods for bridging this gap by discovering expressive and
intuitive individual fairness specifications. We show how to leverage
unsupervised style transfer and GPT-3's zero-shot capabilities to automatically
generate expressive candidate pairs of semantically similar sentences that
differ along sensitive attributes. We then validate the generated pairs via an
extensive crowdsourcing study, which confirms that a lot of these pairs align
with human intuition about fairness in the context of toxicity classification.
Finally, we show how limited amounts of human feedback can be leveraged to
learn a similarity specification that can be used to train downstream
fairness-aware models. | [
0.0696089417,
0.1065144986,
-0.0173502713,
0.0220591854,
-0.0362762399,
0.0084897708,
0.006130618,
0.0053676511,
-0.0108985547,
-0.0835194811,
-0.0124694183,
0.0177611876,
-0.0196414869,
-0.0263442639,
-0.00009481,
-0.0417385586,
-0.0041429391,
0.0625814274,
0.0181720331,
-0.0340735093,
0.0567935705,
0.0391202308,
0.0332672298,
0.0475928858,
0.0011071166,
0.018652996,
0.0588663965,
0.0207577292,
0.0271097925,
0.0198895112,
0.0361416899,
0.0894397944,
-0.0236743633,
0.0309869628,
0.0000018442,
-0.0568378158,
0.0024911107,
0.0190897826,
0.0348343551,
-0.0210850816,
0.0765804574,
-0.019407494,
0.0023283288,
0.0272691213,
-0.0203244183,
-0.0021560518,
0.0471189395,
0.0226795599,
0.0655151457,
0.0272675008,
-0.0245061424,
0.0130953481,
-0.034569528,
-0.0201208461,
0.0337893292,
0.0051223096,
0.0430053845,
-0.0754822269,
-0.0387879573,
-0.0307734162,
0.0023413007,
-0.0048920428,
-0.0074110245,
-0.0003531301,
0.0253355093,
-0.0113659604,
-0.0617037788,
-0.0329640247,
0.0112289367,
0.0787260011,
0.0030228267,
-0.0309976749,
0.003940546,
-0.0354587436,
0.0555729605,
0.0242501143,
-0.019341642,
0.0115828663,
-0.0336473957,
0.0295793992,
-0.0300878566,
0.0342867635,
0.0216512792,
0.0526942946,
0.0578542091,
0.0454613306,
-0.0001071693,
-0.0333287418,
-0.0036975951,
0.0481669828,
0.0081069171,
-0.0116372453,
0.0325883999,
-0.0207708199,
0.0061941706,
-0.0164410491,
-0.0427781083,
-0.0355785415,
0.0688847452,
-0.0627266243,
0.0334305093,
0.0231888387,
-0.0180564914,
0.00795436,
0.0051772976,
0.0036099583,
0.0133604715,
0.0469679087,
-0.0273543932,
-0.002437324,
-0.0440907329,
-0.0057753157,
0.0025030409,
-0.0127172293,
-0.0279820208,
0.0730914399,
-0.0354286544,
-0.0125791514,
-0.089361459,
-0.026551893,
0.0267015677,
0.0381035693,
-0.0460913703,
0.0294846576,
-0.0375108905,
-0.0192215107,
-0.0155589236,
0.0113966335,
-0.0397768766,
-0.035298679,
-0.0011561093,
0.009850746,
-0.0051395022,
-0.0251730233,
0.0126967272,
0.0616783723,
0.0219007451,
-0.0004045187,
-0.0437194183,
-0.0293097124,
0.0011585853,
-0.0266311616,
-0.0130388746,
-0.0376523472,
-0.0031056518,
-0.021337606,
-0.0022791645,
-0.0696305931,
-0.0112517597,
0.0218129102,
-0.0511775538,
0.0872258991,
0.0574366525,
-0.0487929024,
0.0249124523,
0.0320711471,
-0.0186552648,
0.0437090658,
0.0307384916,
0.0447538421,
0.0403500721,
0.0002582475,
-0.0008169205,
0.0115344152,
0.029568715,
0.0241859723,
-0.031313993,
0.012573312,
0.011400572,
0.0259020664,
0.0368447118,
0.0268484615,
0.0001950768,
-0.0421760529,
0.060366895,
0.0503695272,
0.0013764206,
0.0258163027,
0.0607885569,
0.0213780869,
-0.0778637156,
0.0091842096,
-0.0847167075,
-0.0265393741,
-0.0120069766,
-0.0615215749,
0.0104886713,
0.0306060091,
-0.0256746616,
-0.0260844287,
-0.0067376611,
0.0191633087,
0.0520251021,
-0.0129974354,
-0.0192307252,
0.0239604395,
-0.0246595927,
-0.0245746914,
0.0394552313,
-0.0607125722,
0.0210768841,
-0.054732196,
-0.0020555751,
0.090948537,
0.0309918616,
-0.0316965021,
0.0579309948,
-0.0238252748,
-0.0102594495,
0.0107803885,
0.0644388795,
-0.0036597713,
0.0012761283,
-0.0388247594,
-0.0382158831,
0.01079698,
0.0124482773,
0.009516268,
0.0060909032,
0.0330098718,
0.0123898201,
-0.0265482925,
-0.0431603268,
0.0660092831,
0.0594231598,
-0.0732271075,
0.0599797368,
0.0225713067,
0.0066307201,
-0.0031459988,
-0.0059906314,
-0.0117748342,
-0.0399380513,
-0.0150881419,
-0.0395974852,
0.0062962454,
-0.0301303994,
-0.0006731699,
-0.0139195668,
-0.0559211224,
-0.0308325049,
0.0750788748,
-0.0362852216,
0.016373273,
0.0262673385,
0.0168578066,
-0.0433203019,
-0.0641021505,
0.0004996102,
-0.0140574826,
0.0198983084,
-0.0510119349,
0.0349549241,
0.0161529016,
-0.0205925312,
-0.0407338552,
-0.0895639136,
0.0100160791,
-0.0421439447,
-0.0216617826,
-0.0106429681,
0.0070032766,
0.0346436091,
0.034043666,
0.0233213343,
0.0067767426,
0.014061681,
-0.0509821996,
0.006912,
-0.013673678,
0.002503251,
-0.0122316992,
0.011944145,
-0.0031928066,
-0.0184784327,
-0.0353763923,
-0.0524996705,
0.0071178665,
0.017895218,
0.0353177041,
-0.0328480378,
-0.0168670882,
-0.0197661612,
-0.0459812582,
-0.0472097807,
0.0583321974,
0.0453193299,
0.017961191,
-0.028400911,
-0.0341013409,
-0.0146033736,
0.0309999101,
0.0207717977,
-0.0239983685,
-0.013902491,
0.047846552,
-0.0436947308,
0.0587532967,
0.0590648539,
0.0535653606,
0.0575959086,
0.0575314835,
-0.0059314137,
-0.0086068651,
-0.018075224,
0.0203736722,
0.011053321,
-0.041294165,
0.0230769794,
0.0283890832,
0.026340887,
-0.0510617793,
-0.0881703272,
0.0525882132,
-0.0231324434,
-0.0378706716,
-0.040155936,
-0.0467689671,
0.0102134775,
-0.0150030553,
-0.0274692178,
-0.0623476915,
0.0899860263,
0.002005473,
0.0505636707,
-0.0469978563,
-0.0184507053,
-0.0353745855,
0.038053941,
-0.0164699387,
0.0248496793,
0.0165663343,
0.0100809811,
-0.0207546577,
-0.0359321758,
0.0992239267,
-0.0128573626,
-0.0058829351,
-0.054862,
0.0038854659,
-0.0042811837,
-0.0803608447,
-0.0441069715,
-0.0912534371,
-0.0065909745,
0.0206027403,
0.0135437129,
-0.0141677819,
-0.0311824027,
0.0012240764,
-0.0303505976,
0.0330433697,
-0.0040806266,
-0.0137849785,
0.0123407226,
-0.0137202414,
0.0151536223,
-0.023225205,
-0.0093528861,
0.000598502,
-0.0126635684,
0.0500112511,
0.0067227758,
0.0472015366,
0.0449439175,
0.042131722,
0.0109204752,
-0.0601484068,
0.0095241228,
0.0017435064,
0.0245278534,
-0.0235298928,
0.0144565543,
0.0629996583,
0.0206674654,
-0.0494093597,
0.0266813859,
-0.004906645,
-0.0018464733,
0.0164228883,
-0.0011289441,
-0.0709101632,
-0.0361080617,
-0.0103970254,
0.0510268658,
-0.0917883962,
-0.0373873673,
-0.0002184527,
-0.0571268834,
0.0391764082,
0.0127287498,
-0.0648072213,
-0.0309749395,
-0.0188712142,
0.0133681558,
-0.0573251806,
-0.0122005856,
-0.0299091358,
0.0157331452,
0.0071126898,
0.006013901,
-0.0111497389,
-0.0127230594,
0.0441923849,
-0.0495193452,
-0.0030860617,
0.0246272627,
0.0323709883,
0.0046584453,
-0.0486760587,
0.0050471602,
-0.0465892069,
-0.0063463086,
0.0067690951,
0.0571731478,
-0.0387570933,
-0.0101230564,
-0.0733973086,
0.0770813227,
-0.0159603823,
-0.0049256915,
-0.0027396344,
0.052341599,
-0.0001343847,
-0.0668005124,
-0.0597269833,
0.0033470825,
0.0256924257,
0.0917549431,
0.0148404026,
-0.0491654761,
-0.0368093029,
-0.0526650809,
0.0162531007,
-0.0519895591,
-0.0677002966,
0.0128070386,
-0.0049719117,
-0.0383256301,
-0.0466514826,
-0.0252422839,
-0.0057429085,
-0.0023203993,
0.0159854554,
-0.0490472689,
-0.0226396378,
-0.0083341096,
-0.0663636997,
0.0271497034,
-0.0060431636,
0.0452535972,
0.0335003138,
-0.0395582132,
-0.0384599268,
-0.0028604676,
-0.0502784699,
0.0279269591,
-0.0239352826,
-0.0402159654,
0.0138267195,
0.0176981296,
0.0099592293,
0.0315621942,
-0.0095512671,
-0.0464395285,
0.0527338684,
0.1071837097,
0.0037791503,
-0.0007054115,
0.0367129259,
-0.0485353656,
0.0159428045,
0.0273972135,
-0.0248806626,
0.0197106041,
0.0415398292,
-0.0017188217,
0.0201468226,
-0.0186711047,
0.0247267522,
0.0132720005,
0.0197726469,
-0.0127523737,
-0.0158251394,
-0.0239988156,
-0.0286114942,
0.0173206106,
-0.0528791919,
-0.0109248422,
-0.0266574994,
0.0090881269,
0.0274372753,
-0.0710231215,
-0.0209057592,
-0.0601726249,
0.0474238023,
-0.0725764036,
0.0213204902,
0.0079426616,
0.0462354645,
0.001589725,
-0.0165696144,
-0.0183054041,
0.0056786253,
-0.0066340626,
0.0349597856,
-0.0039670016,
0.0063895779,
0.056010101,
0.0501329936,
-0.0362355299,
0.0118430834,
-0.0456606708,
0.0132196154,
-0.0637463853,
0.0013882141,
-0.0056628338,
-0.0315945372,
-0.0192517936,
-0.0066511952,
-0.0167466737,
0.0153113659,
0.0162778031,
-0.0186673012,
0.0052991593,
0.0190615989,
0.0242820382,
-0.0107967863,
-0.017786745,
0.0211210996,
0.0066564768,
0.073355712,
-0.0475615114,
-0.046895396,
-0.0072472477,
-0.0360769555,
0.0540036708,
0.0212263763,
0.0091469493,
-0.0229194444,
-0.07558126,
-0.0478564128,
-0.0025665911,
0.0105141588,
0.0382287912,
0.0071334327,
-0.0049667261,
0.0629652515,
-0.0095805535,
-0.0654778108,
-0.0077900812,
-0.0205151774,
-0.0051982519,
-0.021470733,
-0.019989552,
-5.85910392e-33,
0.0094167311,
-0.0087432144,
-0.0455783904,
0.0189024601,
0.0092317462,
-0.0409430861,
0.0389375165,
-0.0501029566,
0.0116546694,
0.0523716807,
0.0113014858,
0.0195280947,
-0.0042635421,
0.0052809436,
0.01664735,
-0.0166272596,
0.0379244275,
0.0278213061,
-0.0579595044,
0.0227750707,
-0.0030675717,
0.0025966384,
0.0513079278,
-0.0556123108,
0.064554967,
0.0118890069,
-0.013242037,
0.0275235958,
-0.0198766254,
0.0355080999,
0.0149959093,
0.1085923985,
0.0522016287,
-0.0231799688,
0.0194441732,
0.018922409,
-0.0451004207,
-0.0312306248,
0.0163989216,
-0.0097741904,
0.0111533655,
-0.0115469424,
0.0644197986,
0.0172668528,
-0.030256534,
-0.0433415323,
0.0803879574,
0.0166790988,
0.0606833659,
0.0106832478,
-0.0149101987,
0.0065980963,
-0.0509842038,
-0.0048757908,
-0.0184832793,
-0.0089201434,
-0.0062652486,
0.0496909656,
-0.0347288437,
-0.000510102,
-0.0563839227,
-0.0166928992,
0.0031498405,
-0.0121875452,
0.015055513,
0.0603617057,
0.0236283857,
0.0492769666,
-0.0340043046,
-0.0466535091,
0.010001692,
-0.004711268,
0.0169476438,
0.1062816307,
0.0674620196,
-0.0217118375,
-0.0419494398,
0.0345692933,
-0.0102656279,
0.0089920918,
-0.0088480199,
-0.0078946473,
-0.0629146099,
-0.0520517528,
-0.0143178552,
-0.0761270374,
-0.0285275839,
0.0237682052,
0.0147522241,
-0.0228407942,
-0.0503660217,
0.0318250023,
-0.0310397707,
-0.0251241047,
-0.0032348721,
0.0242631156,
-0.0104670441,
-0.0359691381,
0.0069634919,
-0.0433706902,
-0.0279627815,
0.0053604124,
0.0362228379,
0.0150458803,
0.0424361117,
0.0084303133,
0.0501170084,
0.0159415137,
-0.0498221293,
-0.0041249241,
-0.010554486,
0.044564154,
0.0005372404,
-0.0052516251,
-0.0041897222,
0.0483857319,
0.0150543107,
0.0165738873,
0.0337833688,
-0.0051229051,
-0.040185906,
-0.0038930946,
-0.0005535929,
0.0213041063,
-0.0099006593,
-0.0233810842,
0.0316583849,
-0.027541358,
0.0398179814,
-0.0717651993,
-0.0113749886,
-0.0515589863,
2.587e-7,
0.025025947,
0.0081343502,
0.0082567632,
-0.0090845097,
0.0036135921,
0.0692978129,
0.05650701,
0.0821213797,
0.0148702059,
0.0140263522,
0.0259577204,
0.0380545259,
0.0127259502,
0.0100932159,
-0.0484952144,
0.0309892781,
-0.0785638466,
-0.0169107933,
-0.0229447782,
-0.0036231335,
0.062189132,
0.0188089032,
0.0637534559,
-0.0316423997,
0.0282934606,
-0.0292228553,
0.0239435975,
-0.0336797945,
0.0355886444,
0.0049095731,
0.0309385322,
-0.0713058338,
0.0312743858,
0.0698088929,
-0.0088843349,
0.0109973727,
0.0242758058,
0.0259099305,
-0.0327112041,
0.0153219979,
-0.0276156832,
-0.0143847661,
0.0174658038,
-0.0332737043,
0.0524008758,
0.0227473285,
-0.0439493135,
-0.0611243285,
-0.0085763428,
-0.0385074802,
0.0568849407,
0.0054056216,
-0.0422836058,
0.0198870376,
0.0329646282,
0.053606119,
-0.0006320582,
-0.0698880404,
-0.0157200918,
-0.0415930003,
-0.030505795,
-0.0433519483,
0.0120314332,
0.0269405395,
0.0140085975,
-0.009482949,
0.0550450683,
2.170874957e-34,
0.0050215116,
0.0434306338,
0.0199349411,
-0.0422706641,
0.0267483946,
0.0557556376,
0.0217611138,
-0.0066678161,
0.0354478359,
-0.0228649657,
-0.0107459119
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10152v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10152v1 | Quirk or Palmer: A Comparative Study of Modal Verb Frameworks with Annotated Datasets | 2022-12-20T10:44:18 | 2022-12-20T10:44:18 | Risako Owan, Maria Gini, Dongyeop Kang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Modal verbs, such as "can", "may", and "must", are commonly used in daily
communication to convey the speaker's perspective related to the likelihood
and/or mode of the proposition. They can differ greatly in meaning depending on
how they're used and the context of a sentence (e.g. "They 'must' help each
other out." vs. "They 'must' have helped each other out.") Despite their
practical importance in natural language understanding, linguists have yet to
agree on a single, prominent framework for the categorization of modal verb
senses. This lack of agreement stems from high degrees of flexibility and
polysemy from the modal verbs, making it more difficult for researchers to
incorporate insights from this family of words into their work. This work
presents Moverb dataset, which consists of 27,240 annotations of modal verb
senses over 4,540 utterances containing one or more sentences from social
conversations. Each utterance is annotated by three annotators using two
different theoretical frameworks (i.e., Quirk and Palmer) of modal verb senses.
We observe that both frameworks have similar inter-annotator agreements,
despite having different numbers of sense types (8 for Quirk and 3 for Palmer).
With the RoBERTa-based classifiers fine-tuned on \dataset, we achieve F1 scores
of 82.2 and 78.3 on Quirk and Palmer, respectively, showing that modal verb
sense disambiguation is not a trivial task. Our dataset will be publicly
available with our final version. | [
0.0226898063,
0.0542412512,
-0.0458398312,
0.0135224182,
-0.0479092114,
0.0123520577,
-0.0463269353,
0.0091293361,
-0.027761966,
-0.0584419258,
-0.0651964322,
-0.0011464988,
0.0078522973,
0.0024483309,
-0.0184656847,
-0.0109670889,
0.0585073903,
0.0095266104,
-0.0091457441,
0.0208359957,
0.0262833536,
0.0220399313,
-0.0152662145,
0.0426233709,
-0.0286273118,
0.009648419,
-0.0106039904,
0.0000775541,
0.0461418852,
0.0016873005,
0.0218675509,
0.0481612869,
0.0183039848,
0.0421861224,
0.0000020371,
-0.0459068082,
0.0181488283,
-0.0157237146,
-0.0309002642,
-0.0279844292,
0.040935237,
-0.009577455,
0.0421426333,
-0.0117935836,
-0.0692206174,
-0.0311234985,
0.0373958647,
0.0035733264,
0.0026868824,
0.0583543591,
-0.0108742584,
-0.0102888616,
0.0206899103,
-0.0132861175,
0.0161580853,
-0.0004754348,
0.0123079056,
0.0138462242,
-0.0110003818,
-0.0304897558,
-0.0508034267,
0.0429810807,
0.0087258443,
-0.0117639732,
-0.0532091707,
-0.0058153779,
-0.0123511683,
-0.048856128,
-0.0100842621,
0.0263514537,
0.0734824985,
-0.0339599773,
0.013520129,
-0.0044105332,
-0.0291163102,
0.0926218331,
0.0110330787,
0.0106866406,
-0.0264576524,
0.0193630252,
0.0427377969,
-0.0049633328,
0.0054322029,
0.0399032868,
0.018757863,
0.0417642593,
0.0036147374,
-0.0018045495,
0.0067600454,
0.00725934,
-0.0112526454,
-0.0262593664,
-0.0058289524,
-0.0263651814,
0.0058027282,
0.0149621209,
-0.0177100804,
-0.0025176606,
0.0379727408,
-0.0124746459,
-0.0134622473,
0.0273140837,
-0.0499969646,
0.0280278362,
0.0479155369,
-0.0634345561,
-0.0092903227,
0.0514462367,
-0.0349079631,
-0.0039040938,
-0.1108003482,
0.0206610523,
0.0004546763,
0.002700076,
-0.0734921023,
0.0075670104,
-0.0599609837,
0.0056744274,
0.0004682408,
-0.031888511,
-0.0086204447,
0.0110239545,
-0.0706767514,
0.0308294632,
-0.0316222645,
0.057295423,
-0.0134535376,
0.0768270418,
-0.0535063259,
-0.1089443862,
0.0182995405,
0.0305754952,
0.0078010545,
-0.0279268343,
-0.0243164245,
-0.009608957,
-0.004252648,
-0.0509706102,
0.0139092915,
-0.0429030359,
-0.0640529618,
-0.0483463518,
-0.0623947345,
-0.0415112674,
0.0148817785,
0.0140462574,
0.0106628314,
-0.015229268,
-0.0107063735,
-0.0279112104,
0.0078656534,
0.0488825738,
0.0145551767,
0.0074476693,
0.0141492644,
0.026811162,
-0.0240725949,
0.0344529785,
0.0094904508,
-0.0228722077,
0.037586078,
0.0163181759,
0.0061335922,
0.0063123605,
-0.0266538747,
0.0058458447,
0.0329828151,
0.0073854933,
-0.0717580244,
-0.011339386,
0.002027282,
0.0231116284,
-0.0324924327,
-0.0313583203,
0.0400208347,
0.0286817569,
0.0364988148,
-0.0333933979,
0.0366193056,
0.0320286863,
0.0217656326,
-0.0339327008,
-0.0269705541,
-0.0214512087,
-0.0618370175,
-0.0395071097,
-0.0688225552,
0.0363991633,
-0.0154664908,
-0.0244770627,
-0.015339857,
-0.0042063515,
0.0413470455,
0.0347778574,
0.0550145917,
-0.011977043,
0.0542495064,
0.0157021936,
0.0115179932,
-0.0549470447,
0.0060019586,
-0.0497152023,
0.0125103956,
-0.0007467878,
-0.0037811077,
-0.0453883633,
-0.0400843695,
-0.0258256067,
-0.0206397381,
-0.0054696295,
0.0438176878,
-0.0233135428,
0.0173156317,
-0.040486984,
0.0178664885,
0.019289596,
0.0296283029,
-0.0379040055,
-0.0533065721,
-0.0022247327,
-0.0145483576,
-0.046896521,
0.01893772,
0.0140389167,
0.0234849826,
0.026049912,
-0.0396379568,
-0.0120974779,
0.0493246466,
0.0309595987,
0.0061724652,
0.000321854,
0.0341683365,
-0.0005164496,
0.0330839902,
0.1076870412,
0.0063938601,
-0.0350634977,
0.049594406,
-0.0325141475,
-0.0600885227,
0.0171044972,
-0.0006708817,
-0.0735614225,
-0.0061820396,
-0.0596732982,
0.0051582488,
-0.0626167282,
0.0075578229,
0.0057229893,
0.0169226266,
-0.014639115,
0.0304751266,
-0.0033438625,
-0.0050119376,
-0.02962544,
0.0094692362,
0.0307841729,
0.0190319065,
-0.0406724289,
0.0229524001,
0.0156774111,
-0.0176944546,
0.0387871489,
-0.0376585983,
-0.0967304409,
-0.0094043408,
-0.1344318837,
-0.0080850031,
-0.0022081619,
0.0352888145,
0.0150617845,
0.0342107825,
-0.0049383864,
-0.0083051296,
0.0130995456,
0.0356868021,
-0.0123387082,
0.0025924901,
0.0138975307,
-0.0169662479,
-0.0272629224,
-0.0122554721,
0.0024105881,
-0.0125799207,
-0.0129239066,
0.0133936703,
-0.0340939984,
-0.0010471249,
0.0070174783,
-0.0347447619,
-0.0038047053,
-0.0149528794,
-0.0305945519,
-0.0090975305,
0.0149430586,
0.0181123391,
0.0106406463,
0.0131618055,
0.0446993373,
0.0324699208,
-0.0226534791,
-0.0547174104,
0.0017128596,
-0.0132494448,
0.0019294301,
-0.0562123731,
-0.0456421413,
-0.0027477567,
0.0617539771,
0.0259276349,
-0.0001714094,
0.0043040966,
0.0092280926,
-0.0333732925,
-0.065178521,
0.0337199047,
-0.00069835,
-0.0403118469,
0.0551229492,
0.0032757074,
-0.039658457,
0.0557835177,
0.0073896414,
-0.0299152546,
-0.0385222547,
-0.0267394595,
-0.0207053032,
0.0742471367,
-0.0621012524,
0.0022560447,
0.0376987942,
-0.0226000883,
-0.0421158001,
-0.0601072833,
0.0768512264,
-0.0118463999,
0.1146355048,
-0.0786387771,
0.0489011146,
0.0077534611,
-0.0345122777,
-0.0064611714,
-0.089061141,
-0.056658525,
0.0120707601,
0.0085022915,
-0.0257461071,
0.0440474823,
-0.0257581472,
-0.007323497,
0.00164982,
0.0219164211,
-0.0140388794,
-0.0110202534,
0.0378703251,
0.0121059436,
0.046495609,
-0.014811364,
0.0115658389,
-0.0050886441,
0.0491735116,
-0.0287780873,
0.0114902733,
-0.0121595031,
0.0241948068,
0.042412214,
0.0186192878,
-0.0537784137,
-0.0089372089,
0.1003574431,
-0.0074235653,
-0.0121098552,
0.0620671883,
0.0363766067,
-0.0402399227,
0.0244910978,
-0.0432874858,
0.028331317,
-0.0105560469,
-0.0427025743,
-0.1061778963,
-0.0420956463,
-0.0057005929,
-0.0246473141,
-0.0301133096,
-0.0294529758,
0.0255400017,
-0.0640119091,
0.0490254052,
-0.0112124067,
-0.0417206921,
0.0015688719,
0.0135626113,
0.0226601884,
-0.0331378616,
0.0210627299,
-0.0386414342,
0.0113537246,
0.0061276481,
0.0598677173,
0.0448053032,
-0.0672692209,
-0.0050468193,
-0.0161914192,
0.1042004302,
-0.0431239568,
0.060912244,
-0.0152901001,
-0.0406348184,
0.0176098812,
0.0016004865,
0.0018184922,
-0.0368583575,
0.0086581912,
0.0196534265,
-0.0156275276,
-0.0218513012,
0.0174379703,
-0.0204888023,
-0.0485769436,
-0.0008221634,
0.0600380935,
-0.0645633414,
0.0230685659,
0.001895064,
0.0012371684,
-0.0013713203,
0.0322474614,
0.005144774,
0.0279919263,
0.0152565939,
0.036218334,
0.0062815747,
0.0251650289,
-0.0377776735,
-0.008752971,
-0.041454386,
-0.0179583821,
-0.0487978943,
-0.0666991398,
0.0287552848,
0.010343302,
-0.0064113317,
0.0305468682,
0.0155642023,
0.017796427,
-0.0490565971,
0.0585126318,
-0.031398356,
0.027217878,
0.0220244937,
-0.0270418506,
0.0420091897,
-0.0125315003,
-0.0160137638,
0.0163790397,
-0.0356900692,
-0.0452945717,
0.0090120332,
0.0216394477,
0.0287443437,
0.0139463749,
-0.0239221714,
-0.0209337976,
-0.0442844592,
0.0051884651,
-0.0625998601,
0.0403567553,
0.0535906591,
0.0084086359,
-0.0090903724,
0.0351450555,
0.009357512,
0.0368663445,
0.0189106315,
0.0193299279,
-0.0395490713,
-0.0452033989,
0.0501837023,
0.0082176272,
0.040139772,
-0.020593591,
-0.0162631869,
-0.0394178443,
-0.027264813,
-0.0022603145,
-0.0029649613,
-0.0231296141,
0.0381064974,
0.0572800823,
0.0110958135,
-0.0465561561,
0.0445980541,
-0.0310713015,
0.0058118785,
0.0349829234,
0.0353606194,
0.0991367102,
0.0122740958,
-0.0390525162,
0.0115794595,
-0.0057640579,
-0.0110884011,
-0.0153511716,
0.0272546355,
0.0061165839,
0.0713575557,
-0.0045942939,
-0.0173203442,
-0.0176164694,
0.00317698,
-0.0378895625,
-0.0386792831,
0.0450656898,
0.0476169996,
0.0563523658,
-0.0128869945,
0.0871066079,
-0.0195472967,
0.0054392731,
-0.0229795258,
0.0614274889,
0.0024342288,
0.0458738394,
0.0652418137,
0.0183384046,
-0.0406738631,
0.0190555062,
0.0275699012,
-0.0906257033,
0.0461246185,
0.0038085938,
-0.0151044419,
-0.0454748981,
-0.0159371626,
0.0408698246,
0.011483077,
-0.0011158468,
0.0005382903,
-0.1028855145,
-0.0499146469,
0.0324533358,
-0.0158559196,
0.0377088636,
-0.011540792,
-0.001797475,
0.0344244763,
0.0194648765,
-0.0230703354,
-0.0491870157,
0.012131854,
-0.0122914165,
0.0083812252,
-0.0709226206,
-6.231659222e-33,
0.0020144545,
-0.0079341698,
-0.018150961,
-0.0284428857,
-0.0419358462,
0.0374685824,
0.003987893,
-0.0220290981,
-0.0320205577,
0.0407786891,
0.0048700511,
0.0360738114,
0.0247682966,
0.0068532764,
0.0712516233,
-0.031546846,
0.0357618518,
0.023401944,
-0.0315488391,
-0.0195458643,
0.0625993758,
-0.028960472,
0.0705667362,
-0.0922423676,
0.0636772811,
0.0266486853,
-0.051000677,
0.0437628813,
-0.0279042423,
0.0570894219,
-0.0239212085,
0.0723146126,
0.0260846838,
0.0082978476,
0.0098498249,
0.0170923173,
-0.0503336452,
-0.021874167,
0.1051824614,
-0.0013592952,
-0.0228884593,
0.006941752,
0.0351541266,
-0.0347869806,
-0.0203673765,
0.0723199993,
0.0419083163,
-0.0000855217,
0.0131323524,
0.0054251128,
-0.0478097871,
0.0259544048,
-0.0191088375,
-0.0503151864,
0.0213417001,
0.0350162238,
-0.0157683697,
-0.0929110274,
-0.0449323282,
0.0402394049,
-0.0371128023,
0.0228129849,
0.0412778072,
0.0110868895,
-0.0012552951,
0.0497594215,
0.0645992234,
-0.0523007326,
0.0451753028,
0.0022230549,
0.0196995921,
0.072940506,
0.0013606074,
0.1397474855,
0.0232242011,
0.0030428832,
-0.0030162546,
-0.0136127099,
0.0826899856,
0.0257658772,
-0.0255754795,
0.0021952197,
-0.0697541311,
-0.0207555164,
-0.041116301,
-0.0090371817,
-0.024968762,
-0.0002704069,
0.0186386239,
-0.0101306103,
-0.0072096009,
0.0319689214,
0.0390641168,
-0.0417519212,
-0.0137692308,
0.010570257,
0.0064267046,
0.0467633791,
0.0133260665,
0.0006973604,
-0.00061585,
-0.0199207868,
0.0173151996,
-0.0207966138,
0.0215918962,
0.0041399533,
0.0199801382,
-0.0080693346,
0.003603372,
-0.0124552427,
-0.0079678623,
-0.0291642416,
-0.0374327749,
-0.0098986747,
0.0432074927,
0.0463592522,
-0.0242673606,
-0.0046368307,
0.0512893908,
0.067107141,
-0.0600327104,
-0.0319316424,
-0.0432178788,
0.0180773232,
-0.0113320276,
-0.0043742862,
0.0242797919,
-0.051246468,
0.0085152145,
-0.0150390286,
0.0023393307,
-0.0528262965,
2.925e-7,
0.0671985373,
0.0215339083,
-0.0115981894,
-0.0343771689,
-0.0155935679,
0.0258929189,
0.0007840521,
0.014623614,
0.0155747384,
-0.0315947086,
0.0099145733,
-0.0289790202,
0.032684762,
0.0300202072,
0.0099171782,
0.010432573,
0.032743562,
-0.0015375194,
0.0246645883,
0.0281233508,
0.064564921,
0.0711212531,
0.0245304927,
-0.0070446599,
-0.0315214358,
-0.0289244652,
0.0461368263,
-0.0689546689,
-0.0311354622,
0.0276757311,
0.0436319932,
-0.041046463,
0.0499974899,
0.0531333834,
0.0125165414,
0.0011141478,
-0.0181429759,
0.039040722,
-0.0207255092,
-0.037932191,
-0.0610538274,
-0.0120078409,
-0.0018917077,
0.0004966856,
0.0158587769,
-0.062433932,
-0.0453891605,
-0.036003042,
-0.0063017998,
0.0276826471,
0.0267832484,
0.0381704271,
-0.0012956994,
0.0172695518,
0.0149063757,
-0.0303856321,
-0.0600397363,
-0.0291896127,
-0.0082558794,
0.0328352377,
-0.0387578569,
-0.0605271459,
0.054025352,
-0.0146846613,
0.0034363272,
-0.0657092929,
-0.0343882442,
2.01808388e-34,
0.0019382868,
0.0199869778,
0.0448066816,
0.0271680523,
0.0239687804,
-0.0168279987,
-0.0115921572,
0.0316716805,
0.0318293497,
-0.0343933105,
-0.0025816071
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10140v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10140v2 | Tackling Ambiguity with Images: Improved Multimodal Machine Translation and Contrastive Evaluation | 2022-12-20T10:18:18 | 2023-05-26T10:52:39 | Matthieu Futeral, Cordelia Schmid, Ivan Laptev, Benoît Sagot, Rachel Bawden | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | One of the major challenges of machine translation (MT) is ambiguity, which
can in some cases be resolved by accompanying context such as images. However,
recent work in multimodal MT (MMT) has shown that obtaining improvements from
images is challenging, limited not only by the difficulty of building effective
cross-modal representations, but also by the lack of specific evaluation and
training data. We present a new MMT approach based on a strong text-only MT
model, which uses neural adapters, a novel guided self-attention mechanism and
which is jointly trained on both visually-conditioned masking and MMT. We also
introduce CoMMuTE, a Contrastive Multilingual Multimodal Translation Evaluation
set of ambiguous sentences and their possible translations, accompanied by
disambiguating images corresponding to each translation. Our approach obtains
competitive results compared to strong text-only models on standard
English-to-French, English-to-German and English-to-Czech benchmarks and
outperforms baselines and state-of-the-art MMT systems by a large margin on our
contrastive test set. Our code and CoMMuTE are freely available. | [
0.0233854838,
0.0366217792,
-0.0148926377,
0.0562285669,
-0.0270143244,
0.0041895425,
0.0394439921,
-0.0062162252,
-0.0098133562,
-0.0523702875,
-0.0528235659,
-0.0294071157,
-0.0014243713,
0.0069747488,
0.0482266024,
-0.0879590809,
0.0356498137,
-0.0177985001,
-0.0438714772,
0.0178141911,
0.0141367735,
0.009237892,
0.0142368963,
0.0035306553,
-0.0113159083,
-0.0317651965,
-0.0191904008,
0.0630196482,
0.0375336371,
-0.0229866188,
-0.0364461467,
0.042001266,
0.0009771454,
0.0520848036,
0.0000022181,
-0.0094947163,
-0.0199299213,
0.0016076544,
0.0335456207,
-0.0310932547,
0.0652623028,
-0.0766213685,
0.0074457214,
-0.0123552317,
-0.0179419648,
-0.0017861058,
0.0640103146,
0.0235720258,
0.0948594958,
0.0611350313,
-0.0334706195,
-0.0243756771,
-0.0520857349,
-0.0400382392,
0.011305091,
-0.044632148,
-0.0231084283,
-0.0244302042,
-0.0450165421,
0.0418376401,
-0.0487637483,
0.0726108849,
0.0279782191,
-0.0014837381,
-0.015035362,
0.0217723288,
0.0273812935,
-0.0420504771,
-0.0579119436,
0.0796131119,
-0.0266709328,
0.0221177582,
-0.0464361385,
-0.0250758585,
0.0056977551,
-0.0052429158,
-0.0015163451,
0.0278573949,
0.0033144569,
0.0018028682,
-0.032081496,
0.0619195178,
0.0109815784,
-0.0011746942,
-0.0419576168,
-0.0408060886,
-0.0019844454,
0.0138138095,
0.0051845168,
0.0063507543,
-0.0529258139,
-0.0303491093,
0.0702245757,
0.0105551686,
0.0064861379,
-0.002870871,
-0.0418657698,
-0.1095130667,
0.0077743102,
-0.0678568855,
0.0375201851,
0.0514252186,
-0.0800250247,
0.0976255462,
-0.0272404272,
0.0471495949,
-0.0387694351,
0.0317248702,
-0.0684508458,
-0.0293013044,
-0.0151528167,
0.039798215,
-0.0564745441,
-0.0322424024,
-0.0567443073,
-0.0132242898,
-0.0115605118,
0.0090720654,
-0.0132501302,
0.0043142866,
0.0135313515,
-0.0183891132,
-0.0913307071,
-0.0360349938,
-0.0229164455,
0.0458997674,
-0.0122448364,
-0.0028577992,
-0.0212073121,
-0.034595266,
-0.0291825868,
0.0459370278,
-0.0121726813,
-0.0558898263,
-0.0122643132,
0.1062810048,
-0.0561941825,
-0.0264242664,
0.007225283,
-0.0037814083,
-0.0479847342,
-0.0655769631,
0.0288831238,
-0.0241701566,
0.0528142825,
0.0043757409,
0.0212707333,
-0.0288762916,
-0.0051657334,
-0.0300815292,
-0.0050642407,
0.1240112633,
0.0386238061,
-0.0392662771,
0.0119385794,
0.0018365222,
-0.0729064792,
0.0703813657,
0.0331174098,
0.0510277189,
0.0073129041,
0.0206299704,
-0.0051990626,
0.0435078442,
-0.0014075413,
0.0093242927,
-0.017964134,
0.0042533949,
-0.0138895577,
0.0209889226,
0.0347046368,
0.0631181225,
-0.004294612,
-0.028267296,
0.0770461187,
-0.0465580486,
0.0356655456,
0.0347628072,
0.0431239679,
0.0227263812,
-0.0073305373,
0.0359431878,
-0.0382434651,
0.067161046,
0.0013555529,
0.0039643678,
0.0317697562,
0.0517787226,
-0.028752815,
-0.0319013335,
-0.0000728619,
-0.0122959809,
0.0576139428,
0.0224108715,
0.0436067656,
0.0299037434,
-0.0658383593,
0.0125041623,
-0.0076225447,
-0.0213195123,
0.0007028235,
0.0035054721,
-0.0315199979,
0.0622631572,
0.010714219,
-0.0180487856,
-0.0181000866,
-0.0047871717,
0.0068886806,
0.0647189915,
0.0171684809,
0.0512302928,
0.0607111566,
-0.0660078824,
-0.0319114774,
-0.0225199331,
-0.0176417921,
0.0425899401,
-0.0334937684,
0.0318860523,
0.0172178969,
-0.0176994856,
0.0267125331,
0.0322789028,
0.0509297848,
-0.0019513781,
0.0073759309,
0.0309393741,
0.0141726239,
0.0015430273,
-0.0229100548,
-0.0140118496,
-0.0030603413,
-0.0436968431,
0.0100656357,
0.0286479201,
-0.0614092685,
-0.0669356287,
0.0030876312,
-0.0650100261,
-0.0665134564,
0.0143004432,
-0.0435266197,
-0.0368753299,
0.0085188439,
-0.0301424488,
-0.01885093,
-0.0322305001,
0.0174391735,
0.0335415751,
0.0323132537,
-0.0116310986,
0.0289248433,
-0.0179130714,
-0.0257141106,
0.0126955314,
0.0227199979,
0.0250517689,
-0.0092626428,
-0.0264723711,
-0.0021859694,
0.0112673119,
0.0136402138,
-0.0030405852,
0.0414303988,
-0.0386086255,
-0.0491072759,
-0.0702665523,
0.0049773888,
-0.0282522999,
-0.0063192346,
0.0283793956,
0.0246299878,
0.0261709429,
-0.0336742401,
0.0114446776,
0.0244070552,
0.0017114417,
-0.0018232852,
0.0290999711,
0.0211175866,
0.0737776905,
-0.006622693,
0.004512039,
0.0086666634,
0.0348494574,
0.0048449524,
-0.0532017872,
-0.0456424057,
0.0308147818,
-0.0050686402,
0.0150763113,
-0.0056946459,
-0.0604313686,
0.0014659669,
-0.0135647506,
0.0464580581,
0.0589806549,
0.0052045891,
-0.0076616239,
0.0227760505,
-0.0335731506,
-0.0355376899,
0.0448575616,
0.0262822304,
0.0009954334,
0.0043653361,
-0.0524955317,
-0.0228543524,
0.0366518013,
0.0132044032,
0.0140087558,
-0.05840341,
-0.0142610818,
0.0108054318,
-0.0390872434,
-0.0244707093,
0.0654850528,
0.021031132,
0.0056483205,
-0.0468584038,
-0.0187525135,
0.0903557092,
-0.0286754314,
-0.0456445292,
-0.0334347822,
0.0165806059,
-0.0189178772,
0.058781296,
-0.0116906175,
0.0326398723,
0.0154656982,
-0.0139106298,
-0.0617722683,
-0.0366026722,
0.0235348586,
-0.0129825398,
0.0366554298,
-0.0346145332,
-0.009236115,
-0.0249389932,
-0.0194089375,
-0.0180942621,
-0.0247786045,
-0.0000584444,
-0.0147089027,
0.0156136816,
0.0065712943,
-0.0373045132,
0.0219087154,
0.0399465263,
0.0493182801,
0.0087434435,
-0.0258829352,
-0.0248497874,
0.0465375371,
-0.0148499329,
0.0414742827,
0.0055927346,
-0.0857743397,
0.0139155807,
0.0236827265,
-0.0096529601,
-0.0448261425,
-0.0475972742,
0.0163320508,
0.0176536329,
0.0407150313,
-0.0049270731,
-0.0078726709,
0.0555986315,
-0.0600487553,
0.0038927137,
0.0557107255,
-0.012127473,
-0.0521507375,
-0.0488020554,
0.0039467374,
0.000745248,
0.0041153678,
0.0247825664,
-0.100003764,
-0.0668584034,
-0.0184925124,
-0.0057375929,
0.0448625013,
0.0472605452,
-0.026988633,
-0.0346103907,
0.0255392753,
0.0315704867,
-0.0449151695,
-0.0289151818,
0.0249134842,
-0.0094447536,
-0.0274687782,
0.0211917143,
-0.0133249722,
0.020485986,
-0.0221964531,
-0.0246799644,
0.0743694827,
-0.0452439114,
-0.0231269579,
-0.0305185206,
-0.0144545557,
0.0344426595,
0.0096240323,
-0.0077663804,
-0.0395703055,
0.046426814,
-0.0085953344,
0.009885883,
-0.0314711854,
0.0407315902,
-0.0029082631,
-0.0419075452,
0.0155670643,
-0.0205893423,
0.0266748201,
-0.0058768159,
-0.0022686501,
0.0308936387,
-0.0069588707,
0.0095647769,
-0.0292946938,
-0.0070750639,
0.0038892417,
0.028792752,
-0.0119121214,
-0.049881354,
-0.0253561772,
-0.0191248916,
0.0319241993,
-0.084147349,
0.0187197793,
0.0177452564,
-0.048494596,
0.0037807515,
-0.0468374752,
-0.0457315184,
0.0116762836,
0.0305358656,
0.0160839278,
-0.0088153463,
0.0002405909,
0.0226904824,
-0.0214729253,
0.088315472,
-0.0323303789,
0.0101879109,
-0.0177980885,
-0.0010542874,
-0.007466862,
-0.0514836274,
0.0160445869,
0.0861654654,
-0.0804555714,
-0.0299714766,
-0.0101194251,
0.0728190765,
0.0081828004,
0.0427562073,
-0.017998606,
-0.0219069254,
0.0149808265,
-0.0134739336,
0.0064908541,
0.0139528299,
0.041713044,
0.0181436911,
-0.0143464683,
0.0307517089,
-0.0195400193,
0.022253003,
0.0077506946,
0.036310792,
-0.0134025663,
-0.0262278151,
-0.0015848111,
-0.0256512035,
0.0273301117,
-0.0137236323,
0.0217590462,
-0.0262117758,
0.0065110885,
0.0013529165,
-0.0276053231,
-0.0631320775,
-0.0060608201,
0.0210248698,
-0.0150297284,
0.0058298344,
0.0350525863,
-0.0133985663,
-0.0074594044,
-0.026119994,
0.0210686922,
-0.00404017,
0.0008998351,
-0.025041705,
0.0155089349,
0.0035861162,
0.0192002468,
-0.0079646045,
0.0154283121,
-0.0047996086,
0.0786756352,
0.0114395227,
-0.024529973,
-0.0331074558,
0.0445807427,
-0.0042984234,
0.0339014791,
-0.0307740085,
0.0092686117,
0.0556354113,
0.0165420752,
0.0802957565,
0.0031658295,
-0.016325973,
-0.0029760224,
0.0498725995,
0.0238885153,
-0.0015615483,
0.0181537736,
-0.0179847963,
0.0434266478,
0.0352587067,
0.0305792168,
-0.0510938652,
-0.0087512648,
0.0167839527,
-0.0217431672,
-0.0601282753,
-0.0001627125,
0.0135327196,
-0.0051960396,
0.0057746656,
0.0041444693,
-0.006893985,
-0.0504198112,
0.0270536356,
0.021965256,
-0.0047128843,
0.0124717345,
0.0298648607,
0.0448970348,
0.0206108447,
-0.0265607294,
-0.02278818,
0.0228212643,
0.0384224989,
-0.0114523703,
-0.0312748589,
-6.605307734e-33,
-0.0306519978,
-0.0380776674,
-0.0144792851,
-0.0725698248,
-0.0397402793,
0.0117042223,
-0.039416384,
-0.0111203203,
-0.0361483544,
0.0183891468,
0.0253689829,
0.0122966506,
0.0273935162,
0.0361434519,
-0.0032611287,
0.0217240099,
0.060427431,
0.0147700524,
-0.0101703256,
0.0045257732,
0.013062885,
0.0191258993,
0.0699558705,
-0.0696083233,
0.023837626,
0.0071566789,
-0.0663549677,
0.0089175971,
-0.0036472913,
0.050232105,
-0.0049648397,
0.0038992106,
-0.0024089213,
-0.017578749,
-0.0497209057,
-0.0259029139,
-0.0841039419,
0.0085447747,
0.0059321383,
0.043639373,
-0.0779428557,
-0.03963973,
0.0845063925,
-0.0419557542,
0.0218090396,
-0.0198151302,
0.0185690839,
-0.0363393277,
0.0193664581,
0.0004497515,
-0.0157880001,
0.0087880548,
-0.0280611999,
-0.0406752229,
0.0573938638,
0.0684786364,
0.0163499061,
0.0508671552,
-0.0856740326,
-0.0160775539,
-0.0181746446,
0.0167972594,
0.0642798692,
0.0266783051,
-0.0281452648,
-0.0154824937,
0.0171418488,
-0.033428058,
0.0209395513,
-0.0366519354,
0.0001545408,
0.0295935664,
0.078133747,
0.0599239245,
0.0252074562,
0.0320428126,
-0.0326124467,
0.0167877208,
-0.0587168187,
0.0319865644,
0.0299244076,
0.0245951898,
0.0012297038,
0.0314859003,
-0.0402285494,
-0.0591500662,
-0.0600857511,
-0.0145635111,
0.0098508988,
0.0048135463,
-0.0109565202,
0.0127980737,
0.1063247398,
0.005038565,
0.0042564091,
-0.048266042,
0.0025463828,
0.0508332066,
0.016043067,
0.056954667,
0.001376732,
-0.0329702049,
0.0628181025,
0.0354139544,
0.0163868871,
-0.0016380379,
0.0340365656,
0.000622126,
-0.024482239,
-0.0003211163,
-0.0325990096,
0.0055473768,
-0.0465512648,
0.0226869509,
0.0153656313,
-0.0143849626,
-0.0440549925,
0.0323041864,
0.0282502007,
-0.0090798335,
-0.0430485755,
-0.0071749138,
-0.0009538185,
0.0457664914,
-0.0353827477,
0.0477388203,
-0.0189181622,
-0.008151575,
0.0271192174,
-0.0442974083,
-0.0284869205,
0.0606177077,
2.798e-7,
0.0647920743,
0.0178161059,
-0.0109402053,
0.0311248321,
0.0139358509,
0.0612595938,
-0.044846341,
0.025165379,
-0.0051558861,
0.0047226166,
0.0048599979,
0.0376244672,
0.0734109208,
0.0113307182,
0.008277989,
-0.0029587327,
0.010571287,
0.0242635291,
-0.0222917721,
0.0272769406,
0.0996325612,
0.1079857647,
-0.0197333451,
0.0147968149,
-0.0028372623,
-0.0375844836,
0.0872547776,
-0.0077739987,
-0.0147680463,
-0.0352150649,
0.0160829797,
0.0071059386,
-0.0693068579,
-0.0003870457,
0.0064811166,
-0.0264260247,
0.0390397161,
0.025425693,
0.0049742553,
-0.0225881189,
0.0009796084,
0.0169807896,
-0.019912716,
-0.0484216288,
0.0712175891,
-0.0899318159,
-0.0257203691,
0.0109695196,
-0.0257581808,
0.025209669,
0.0663346499,
-0.0236622244,
-0.0680690184,
0.0248715896,
0.0502790473,
-0.0033199587,
-0.0689357668,
-0.0590293258,
-0.044790931,
-0.0192160383,
-0.014060339,
0.0026041637,
-0.0343524851,
-0.0155353723,
0.0270555485,
-0.0550619252,
-0.0264464729,
2.055311006e-34,
0.0365427025,
-0.0435776822,
0.0011514571,
-0.0141164362,
0.0304240752,
-0.0138789024,
-0.0674599111,
-0.0120812766,
0.001454459,
-0.049669601,
-0.036861591
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10114v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10114v2 | True Detective: A Deep Abductive Reasoning Benchmark Undoable for GPT-3 and Challenging for GPT-4 | 2022-12-20T09:34:43 | 2023-06-01T18:50:21 | Maksym Del, Mark Fishel | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated solid zero-shot reasoning
capabilities, which is reflected in their performance on the current test
tasks. This calls for a more challenging benchmark requiring highly advanced
reasoning ability to be solved. In this paper, we introduce such a benchmark,
consisting of 191 long-form (1200 words on average) mystery narratives
constructed as detective puzzles. Puzzles are sourced from the "5 Minute
Mystery" platform and include a multiple-choice question for evaluation. Only
47% of humans solve a puzzle successfully on average, while the best human
solvers achieve over 80% success rate. We show that GPT-3 models barely
outperform random on this benchmark (with 28% accuracy) while state-of-the-art
GPT-4 solves only 38% of puzzles. This indicates that there is still a
significant gap in the deep reasoning abilities of LLMs and humans and
highlights the need for further research in this area. Our work introduces a
challenging benchmark for future studies on reasoning in language models and
contributes to a better understanding of the limits of LLMs' abilities. | [
0.0271885172,
0.0603665523,
-0.0077329227,
0.0686872676,
-0.1058579236,
0.0344512649,
0.0142709138,
0.0069211475,
-0.0225301199,
0.0028781418,
0.0275126547,
-0.0294687375,
-0.0086230068,
0.0386225134,
0.0009424453,
-0.0299903136,
0.0376577303,
-0.053043779,
0.0267467145,
0.0087899258,
-0.0289804935,
0.0230722558,
-0.0094153984,
0.0072138831,
0.006580058,
-0.0317435712,
-0.0407702886,
-0.0043612341,
0.0043878932,
-0.0116279507,
-0.0202447847,
0.0542872399,
0.0230258908,
0.1082373187,
0.0000020805,
-0.0190726072,
-0.0302747637,
-0.0032441989,
-0.0749533772,
0.0023388152,
-0.0185764078,
0.0131513756,
-0.0092106638,
0.0065097059,
-0.0147782108,
-0.0027703058,
0.0265356619,
0.056850154,
0.0596241727,
0.0854983851,
-0.0001511991,
-0.0296527613,
0.0521009043,
-0.0302345324,
0.0469302796,
-0.0815715417,
-0.002006039,
0.015301412,
0.0294623487,
0.0030255534,
-0.0087029794,
0.01198621,
0.0578193106,
0.0183982644,
-0.0895430446,
0.03285731,
-0.0501988344,
-0.0161360875,
0.0220113546,
0.0747937858,
-0.0407208167,
-0.0067618829,
-0.0232420266,
0.0069137863,
0.0073853605,
0.0370219387,
-0.041718062,
0.0531164259,
-0.0355492346,
-0.0037041577,
0.0408760011,
0.0192756858,
0.0502512045,
0.0003574863,
-0.0104023675,
0.0873359218,
0.0216280818,
-0.015303297,
0.0232489835,
-0.0369138904,
-0.0477531999,
-0.0457033552,
0.0036809561,
0.029933285,
-0.0168968607,
0.0068310695,
-0.0078140311,
-0.0234654434,
0.001768035,
0.0173606612,
0.0071939854,
0.0367265977,
-0.0058169453,
0.0711631998,
-0.0126308808,
0.0847825631,
-0.0695149824,
0.0427630767,
-0.0368253514,
-0.0185079128,
-0.0525664911,
-0.0454325974,
-0.0370625071,
0.0107972585,
-0.0237401556,
-0.014386964,
0.0136751411,
-0.0292625409,
0.0110046798,
0.002828734,
-0.0175726432,
0.0208610371,
-0.0334482864,
-0.0530940071,
-0.0030057216,
0.0442804545,
-0.0548940152,
0.0158711355,
0.0306041464,
-0.0466776527,
-0.0456192829,
-0.0185436457,
0.0248943754,
-0.0634198487,
0.0358790047,
0.0277918484,
-0.0091118524,
-0.0076177926,
-0.0146661932,
-0.018624302,
0.0076961741,
-0.1204379797,
0.0373044871,
-0.0593467616,
0.0145726996,
-0.012281904,
-0.0101138223,
-0.0320992321,
-0.0049823066,
0.036317829,
-0.0173234306,
0.0774496868,
0.0069309319,
-0.0050262781,
0.0278227143,
0.0451971851,
-0.0208104122,
0.0554791801,
0.0116444267,
0.0940672532,
0.0146538457,
-0.0177848451,
0.0638514608,
0.0086534861,
0.0137653612,
0.0178319812,
0.0236686263,
0.0109519055,
0.0026126769,
0.0447030775,
-0.0032764371,
0.0330756754,
-0.0076896907,
-0.0354155563,
0.0515444092,
0.0936730951,
-0.0509412736,
0.0192314498,
0.033119902,
-0.0202988591,
0.0019668865,
-0.0050854525,
-0.0697533116,
0.041734498,
-0.0338351354,
0.0110448319,
-0.0059532211,
-0.000697261,
-0.0146895703,
0.0147675574,
-0.0175610315,
0.0329555757,
0.0205535814,
0.0121055199,
0.0296639483,
-0.009641394,
-0.0645291805,
0.0296311397,
-0.0167891216,
-0.0103338473,
-0.0178540144,
-0.0490044206,
0.0428909138,
0.0147802709,
0.0669502839,
-0.0058864034,
-0.049354285,
-0.0157926399,
0.0531029291,
0.0177565962,
0.0162016358,
0.0366584808,
0.0255672634,
-0.0338000655,
-0.0095693031,
-0.0586735345,
0.020357063,
0.0436970592,
0.0200316943,
0.0246440656,
0.0149117047,
-0.0917354971,
0.0522993356,
-0.0128278602,
-0.0776596367,
-0.0158898123,
-0.0385661423,
0.0019790339,
-0.0020028739,
-0.0126066506,
0.0086001316,
0.0056479163,
0.0045605507,
-0.0342762955,
-0.0357406251,
0.0061087818,
-0.0488671921,
-0.011554474,
0.0076101343,
-0.0735552311,
-0.0333051942,
0.0743013546,
-0.0412445962,
-0.0216965005,
0.043218419,
-0.0504198149,
-0.004591899,
-0.0308080763,
0.0014906462,
0.0038483783,
-0.0105903884,
-0.0108360508,
0.1091655865,
-0.0146822166,
0.0030355572,
-0.0246848259,
0.0314331576,
0.0461096913,
-0.0580142811,
0.0212469287,
0.0164219029,
0.0116835926,
-0.0226636995,
0.0034374685,
-0.0127105312,
-0.0470560566,
-0.0171071887,
-0.0426177494,
0.0370447896,
-0.01783395,
0.0105551984,
-0.0116968649,
0.0062061604,
-0.0101347668,
-0.0093792705,
-0.0537163839,
-0.0486423336,
0.0110283075,
0.0147875715,
-0.0029934777,
0.0068932008,
-0.0127129005,
-0.0028840574,
-0.005628672,
-0.007948474,
0.0075457669,
-0.0106098643,
0.0274711847,
-0.0104491487,
0.0358720496,
-0.0038623586,
0.0037745463,
-0.032626044,
-0.0228802674,
0.0178679023,
-0.035966184,
-0.0091362232,
0.0787976608,
-0.0400927663,
0.0174646191,
0.0127443084,
-0.0210236665,
-0.0093585188,
0.0281878617,
-0.0125465868,
-0.00774256,
-0.0029321397,
-0.0449931994,
-0.0281405728,
0.0534749068,
0.0083491383,
0.0029597895,
-0.0524212457,
0.0495191701,
0.0248761829,
-0.037169233,
-0.0535358265,
-0.0234880783,
0.0040232851,
0.0509376228,
-0.0559886321,
-0.0342664532,
0.0638431534,
-0.0007253668,
0.0149266711,
-0.0224589966,
0.0141133899,
-0.0372276716,
0.1304806024,
0.0010296304,
0.0022605266,
0.0281925686,
-0.0252091382,
-0.025920365,
0.0076570478,
0.0204251613,
-0.0227011796,
-0.0169767626,
-0.0543435439,
0.0044786008,
0.0121111609,
-0.0538882986,
-0.0127477618,
-0.0423176698,
-0.0805306435,
0.0072110058,
0.0046615945,
-0.0275665149,
-0.0459741987,
0.0316536166,
0.0446336567,
0.0105859339,
-0.0039045538,
0.0036400899,
-0.0333248526,
-0.0227121022,
0.0528776944,
0.0132808993,
0.0047867619,
-0.0545192957,
0.0144719807,
0.0564418361,
0.0289890487,
0.0297242869,
-0.0197882,
0.0563298576,
-0.015107885,
0.0159099642,
-0.0417833254,
-0.0221653935,
0.0053016874,
-0.0647043884,
-0.0228985455,
0.0992759541,
0.0310971197,
-0.0055301404,
-0.0137727,
-0.0304624587,
0.022934705,
0.0046259179,
0.0155324098,
-0.076400578,
-0.0461320691,
0.0589664951,
-0.0011186245,
-0.0077515249,
-0.0581032857,
-0.0179181006,
-0.1169803515,
0.0663481429,
0.0039640288,
-0.0171386003,
-0.0284217168,
-0.0683660135,
-0.0161410179,
-0.0303273555,
0.0072617927,
0.003301526,
0.0205989704,
-0.0207682308,
-0.0283032395,
-0.0171036497,
0.0081224525,
0.0559167713,
-0.022383878,
-0.0005035748,
0.061535798,
0.0430748612,
-0.0200240556,
-0.0345889069,
-0.0127651766,
0.0388481542,
0.0017573326,
0.0183855947,
0.0622950606,
0.0059416131,
-0.0052464851,
-0.0270287097,
0.0658245757,
-0.0525425412,
-0.0522463545,
0.0036880097,
0.0880552158,
-0.0091056675,
-0.0316219553,
-0.0095617734,
-0.0380237624,
-0.0383114032,
0.0756954551,
-0.000759962,
0.0186276119,
-0.0602514446,
0.0040007029,
0.0197072346,
-0.0495987274,
-0.0241598729,
0.0377486236,
0.0105765071,
0.0204658881,
0.0158035401,
-0.0043578791,
0.0280391518,
0.0495016389,
0.0026103319,
0.0230598971,
-0.0102386167,
0.0215069335,
-0.0438673086,
0.0417871214,
-0.0357114449,
0.0353871286,
0.0034834335,
0.0402627103,
-0.0176290125,
-0.0412557051,
0.0047694426,
-0.0041837543,
-0.0869863853,
-0.0045866212,
0.0187180061,
-0.0025340326,
0.0279582627,
0.0161911696,
-0.0254601799,
-0.056245815,
-0.0163498279,
-0.0402303711,
0.0021869612,
-0.0014596609,
-0.0028007647,
0.0015162473,
0.0048290612,
0.0294161234,
-0.021640785,
0.0142528703,
0.0233467501,
0.0160189103,
-0.0266742129,
0.029472433,
0.03382238,
0.0356216133,
0.0211867336,
0.005430867,
0.0217652675,
-0.0032021687,
0.0069993315,
-0.0570687242,
-0.0077320114,
-0.0218078159,
0.0085183242,
0.0584358983,
-0.0124875847,
-0.0083455425,
-0.0101829516,
0.0205181576,
0.0219987929,
-0.0681597069,
-0.0321867652,
0.0257574935,
0.0031049952,
0.0272602588,
-0.0146786422,
-0.0137285246,
0.0277951341,
-0.0406669378,
0.0962237418,
-0.022322258,
0.0539823733,
0.051659368,
-0.0097519392,
-0.032658089,
0.0160665903,
-0.1062424406,
-0.0627698898,
0.0318702161,
-0.0032926321,
0.0453852788,
-0.0147069683,
-0.0243503135,
-0.0522228554,
0.001839734,
0.0055024019,
-0.0008529858,
0.048862204,
-0.0066289147,
-0.0071816733,
0.0495418161,
-0.0036455097,
0.0338243544,
0.0405417718,
0.0420743302,
0.0514835268,
0.0322708711,
-0.0188768618,
-0.0142472377,
0.0086300764,
-0.0188591499,
0.062343251,
0.0245321654,
0.0063911011,
-0.0535817929,
-0.0666766614,
-0.0050725262,
0.003829669,
0.0163354613,
0.0291617531,
0.002388597,
0.0643295348,
-0.0255427957,
-0.0800351948,
0.0092157321,
0.0474662483,
-0.0289906207,
-0.0185099337,
-0.0044835834,
-6.376340536e-33,
0.0021184201,
-0.0335971043,
0.0167191699,
-0.0135857891,
-0.0091312155,
-0.02938205,
-0.0231037531,
0.0112992618,
-0.0209480636,
0.0245006811,
-0.0193145331,
0.0386583433,
0.0061385236,
0.0001829278,
-0.0372227617,
-0.0187493302,
-0.0012152659,
0.0198974162,
-0.0426547155,
-0.0073824837,
0.0314163342,
0.0045820358,
0.0292906053,
-0.051574599,
0.0040337294,
-0.0304514859,
-0.0347650759,
0.070613198,
-0.0522920266,
0.0515812486,
-0.0122302119,
-0.0164539143,
0.0316078737,
-0.0410795026,
0.014923268,
-0.0059708515,
-0.0383164287,
-0.0199996997,
0.0134321107,
-0.0200283807,
-0.0427178964,
-0.0746216103,
-0.0064309491,
0.0037666915,
0.0113101127,
-0.0344680175,
0.0003476667,
-0.0139315091,
0.0139485579,
0.028749384,
-0.0422786735,
0.0038291484,
-0.0288583301,
-0.031865105,
0.0362565927,
-0.0124102393,
-0.0134898415,
-0.0205476414,
-0.0021006819,
-0.0074434234,
0.0109529719,
-0.019392062,
0.0346592739,
0.0058770585,
-0.0233937185,
0.0596903041,
0.0447042212,
-0.0025972766,
-0.0727433935,
0.009787512,
0.0222882181,
0.1050085425,
0.077348426,
0.0442627966,
0.0637173429,
0.0312169623,
-0.0518378615,
0.0052871052,
-0.013031641,
0.037112318,
0.0648342669,
0.0163804684,
-0.0555938818,
-0.0165792275,
-0.0521567538,
0.0322370231,
-0.0602793209,
-0.0127540054,
0.0469728708,
0.0000417914,
-0.0064628217,
-0.034265846,
0.0399479233,
-0.0301689003,
0.0520211011,
0.0121382261,
-0.0062468629,
0.0107267844,
-0.0087383296,
0.0507909134,
-0.0201091785,
-0.0118999835,
0.0183939468,
0.0513936467,
0.0320392177,
-0.0365247279,
0.0158666819,
0.0269876234,
-0.0201227702,
-0.0280759763,
-0.0546946079,
0.0161347315,
0.0161989797,
-0.0089589842,
0.0236329176,
0.002502457,
-0.0069603468,
-0.0290060006,
0.0141778467,
0.0241011064,
-0.0354456455,
-0.0014826037,
-0.0170081202,
-0.0335652642,
-0.0057196254,
-0.0126891918,
-0.010051176,
-0.0391440019,
0.0135271335,
-0.0356399864,
-0.0011987287,
0.015623224,
2.738e-7,
0.0027885323,
0.0504134037,
0.0567296483,
0.0220762603,
0.0066148071,
0.027352605,
-0.0110889105,
-0.0019558547,
0.0145125668,
-0.0468119755,
-0.0221503042,
0.0565714948,
0.0716945305,
0.0576553494,
-0.0572456382,
0.0375280678,
-0.0127328346,
-0.0111203482,
-0.0751528516,
0.0078535676,
0.0424550809,
0.0697926432,
0.0501176044,
-0.0292583928,
0.0358468741,
-0.0441764183,
0.0175201967,
-0.0080122836,
-0.016712198,
-0.0014400455,
0.0228222776,
0.0650842115,
0.0049652169,
0.0305109229,
0.0110084098,
0.0043795621,
0.0360177122,
0.0376947112,
-0.0405826159,
-0.0562495217,
-0.0533550754,
-0.0347178616,
0.0068614511,
-0.0640020221,
0.1027179807,
-0.037938945,
-0.0621060431,
-0.0034972872,
-0.0287248101,
-0.0175910424,
0.017578382,
0.0168339368,
-0.0176946148,
0.0149889793,
0.006871637,
-0.0108155124,
-0.0131784109,
-0.0682203099,
-0.0010877115,
0.0194518231,
-0.0428711697,
-0.0367758274,
-0.0637784973,
-0.0112253027,
0.0536332354,
-0.0532029197,
0.006476413,
2.518208283e-34,
0.0441523865,
-0.014550508,
0.0232904442,
0.012134389,
0.0622343533,
0.0250105765,
-0.0177072957,
-0.0041294745,
0.0095318127,
-0.1001720503,
-0.0143992463
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10097v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10097v2 | Optimization Techniques for Unsupervised Complex Table Reasoning via Self-Training Framework | 2022-12-20T09:15:03 | 2024-06-21T03:06:36 | Zhenyu Li, Xiuxing Li, Sunqi Fan, Jianyong Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB | Structured tabular data is a fundamental data type in numerous fields, and
the capacity to reason over tables is crucial for answering questions and
validating hypotheses. However, constructing labeled data for complex reasoning
tasks is labor intensive, and the quantity of annotated data remains
insufficient to support the intricate demands of real-world applications. To
address the insufficient annotation challenge, we present a self-training
framework for unsupervised complex tabular reasoning (UCTR-ST) by generating
diverse synthetic data with complex logic. Specifically, UCTR-ST incorporates
several essential techniques: we aggregate diverse programs and execute them on
tables based on a "Program-Management" component, and we bridge the gap between
programs and text with a powerful "Program-Transformation" module that
generates natural language sentences with complex logic. Furthermore, we
optimize the procedure using a "Table-Text Manipulator" to handle joint
table-text reasoning scenarios. The entire framework utilizes self-training
techniques to leverage the unlabeled training data, which results in
significant performance improvements when tested on real-world data.
Experimental results demonstrate that UCTRST achieves above 90% of the
supervised model performance on different tasks and domains, reducing the
dependence on manual annotation. Additionally, our approach can serve as a data
augmentation technique, significantly boosting the performance of supervised
models in low-resourced domains. | [
0.0056264531,
0.0646424368,
-0.0052467985,
0.0009210455,
-0.0217444897,
0.0493919142,
0.032761272,
-0.0241929553,
0.0370147377,
-0.0376759768,
0.002374839,
0.038513191,
-0.0451561287,
0.0495997183,
0.0218694694,
0.0004587191,
0.0299519915,
-0.0267931353,
-0.0214980133,
0.0288852621,
0.0030290235,
-0.0003196878,
-0.0450680256,
-0.0056041786,
-0.048380401,
-0.0041636406,
-0.040962778,
-0.0084071988,
-0.0233495496,
-0.0022939446,
-0.0073482655,
0.0740487203,
0.0499520786,
0.0076113991,
0.0000020569,
0.0106655909,
-0.0680614412,
-0.0002012201,
-0.0303749908,
-0.0315493755,
0.0188745204,
-0.0123787336,
-0.0065680696,
-0.0082055898,
-0.0627510399,
-0.0052019074,
0.0137269143,
0.0273856893,
0.0604304746,
0.0682903379,
-0.0012636561,
-0.0275792945,
-0.0249561165,
0.0115631148,
0.0282242224,
-0.0230954923,
-0.0010466448,
0.0410010144,
0.0059604798,
-0.0221852083,
0.0362363122,
0.0247311257,
0.0623508282,
-0.0356415361,
0.028122656,
0.0339386016,
-0.0279309675,
0.0243869424,
0.0077089542,
0.0734633654,
0.0212569963,
-0.0308592878,
0.049403511,
-0.0013597144,
0.035311386,
-0.0349243954,
-0.0209447537,
0.017113952,
-0.0096917292,
-0.0061523891,
0.0076124412,
0.007819429,
-0.0037752038,
-0.0266633499,
-0.0525440462,
0.0839652717,
-0.029538285,
-0.0335700884,
0.027855536,
-0.0306664184,
-0.0046378323,
-0.0551976971,
0.0010248711,
0.0685606897,
-0.0419278555,
0.016705269,
-0.0020537509,
-0.0407023281,
-0.0097178118,
-0.0370028056,
0.0283707343,
0.0570456684,
0.0265756473,
0.0192583613,
-0.0450894609,
0.013744087,
-0.0275344159,
0.0465427898,
-0.0363955833,
-0.0075371629,
-0.0937955081,
-0.0199016202,
-0.048519697,
0.0613337755,
-0.0655564517,
0.0116826361,
-0.0179637689,
0.0200520512,
-0.0237372648,
0.0459545217,
-0.0108131552,
0.0464300513,
-0.0168174542,
-0.0079156132,
-0.0584135838,
-0.0223405119,
-0.0629860386,
-0.01607248,
0.0043063718,
-0.0411091261,
-0.0142922662,
-0.0066300607,
-0.0064302958,
-0.0253006965,
0.0312064961,
0.0843632668,
-0.0773818493,
0.0266331043,
-0.0692372397,
-0.0611297302,
-0.0321521983,
-0.0703739673,
0.025989484,
-0.0553944297,
0.0429566726,
0.009481824,
-0.0408360064,
-0.038948793,
0.0104718897,
0.0434901305,
0.0183326565,
0.0737155005,
0.0038715319,
-0.0090523539,
0.0071366746,
-0.0279508531,
-0.0314451233,
0.0428555198,
0.026853431,
0.027696766,
-0.0504364967,
-0.010914539,
0.0264854226,
0.0108807329,
0.0238574371,
-0.0528402589,
0.0018434301,
0.0541332737,
-0.000954426,
0.0322452523,
-0.0172153544,
-0.01838875,
-0.0060035982,
0.0518336408,
-0.0019338256,
0.022510035,
-0.0096439663,
0.0609535426,
0.0342204571,
-0.0135120237,
0.0296930857,
0.0285592061,
-0.0449753739,
0.0736377388,
-0.0039649834,
-0.0131677436,
0.0030545294,
-0.0020411541,
-0.0068398728,
-0.1074214578,
0.0262945443,
0.0100488355,
0.0215440858,
-0.0046964418,
0.0654000416,
0.0475629419,
-0.0389643647,
-0.0257210713,
0.0050897207,
-0.050616961,
-0.0333154909,
-0.0104644755,
0.0171894822,
0.081565626,
0.0134796221,
-0.0991641432,
0.0003070043,
0.0037297164,
0.0097649908,
0.0146051077,
0.0359827466,
-0.0412820168,
-0.0256253872,
-0.0033124995,
-0.0240587927,
-0.0186714362,
0.0311643295,
0.0137471557,
0.0107729174,
-0.0404579118,
0.0003272508,
-0.0460552089,
-0.0306793433,
0.0365668796,
0.0132582337,
-0.026021855,
0.0095181754,
0.0133138159,
0.0208567642,
0.0181847867,
0.0055088061,
0.030330725,
0.0244610049,
-0.0249776058,
-0.0474014767,
-0.0284855887,
-0.0554136112,
-0.0240599774,
0.0181368403,
-0.0068317875,
-0.0707939416,
-0.0273373518,
-0.055005651,
-0.054076869,
0.0505421385,
-0.0139546469,
-0.0584419183,
-0.0259358604,
-0.006845165,
0.0460224673,
-0.0112727303,
-0.0221898854,
0.1006167382,
0.0189435668,
-0.0130183008,
0.017593788,
-0.0502380505,
0.0453271568,
-0.0256132651,
0.0669161379,
-0.0282963049,
-0.0369137786,
0.0229640361,
0.0119523741,
0.0086256033,
-0.0574321821,
-0.0134843308,
-0.0699356645,
0.0488215648,
-0.0190675538,
0.0074472623,
0.0212516431,
-0.0155628836,
0.0061149853,
-0.0361990742,
-0.0549612939,
-0.0143830404,
-0.0012901449,
-0.0174112059,
0.0786270946,
0.0031167467,
-0.0020126936,
-0.0189573318,
-0.020421708,
-0.0695693865,
0.0106470883,
0.0111976974,
-0.0083955945,
0.0261824243,
-0.0325463004,
0.009547201,
0.0534939989,
0.0107859168,
0.0145456651,
0.020007208,
-0.0084306002,
0.0302443802,
0.0682048425,
-0.0468470976,
0.0186044555,
0.0291636139,
0.0009480978,
-0.0447978787,
0.0631920993,
0.00967455,
0.0299400575,
0.0102654798,
-0.0496367551,
0.0202524439,
0.0404506475,
-0.014287998,
0.0167610236,
-0.0335152484,
0.0320043899,
0.0378975794,
-0.0281002875,
-0.0403304696,
0.0486221202,
0.041353412,
0.0432750247,
-0.0184072703,
0.0190336723,
0.0431190915,
-0.0136070987,
0.0009994255,
-0.032836426,
-0.0147888893,
-0.0447493345,
0.0875518546,
0.026208777,
-0.0077404208,
0.0080324849,
0.0068753539,
-0.0439371727,
-0.0144954808,
0.0447866283,
-0.003115298,
0.0572277792,
-0.0670782253,
0.019116912,
0.0157148652,
-0.0471924543,
-0.0350852013,
-0.0237092394,
-0.0135327578,
0.0135113345,
0.0321595855,
-0.0038637114,
-0.0042508426,
-0.0297704116,
0.0194518119,
0.0840955153,
-0.0141322333,
-0.047389999,
-0.0521795154,
0.0169241354,
0.0104047051,
0.0037806577,
-0.0349726342,
0.0057217167,
0.0323825404,
0.0327741429,
-0.0119459312,
-0.0513960421,
-0.0400386788,
0.0453510657,
-0.0208232831,
-0.029201163,
0.0239522234,
0.052015584,
-0.0133204805,
-0.0815927535,
-0.0279252622,
0.0708457232,
0.0412640609,
0.042794425,
-0.0138464533,
0.0002119202,
0.0299610682,
0.0423914641,
0.0766197667,
-0.0568768382,
-0.0321413428,
-0.0062700226,
-0.0091531053,
0.0065911305,
-0.0617204532,
-0.0114605827,
-0.1132010669,
0.0483706184,
-0.0189537499,
-0.0286922567,
-0.05213302,
-0.027577782,
-0.0392053351,
-0.0302536618,
-0.032319393,
0.0396446586,
0.0038211411,
0.0148051763,
0.0262585934,
-0.0511921756,
-0.0094325198,
-0.008011492,
-0.002751481,
0.0349003896,
0.0325360298,
0.0192380659,
-0.0034298119,
0.0052910494,
0.0290100295,
0.0358016081,
0.019885404,
-0.0146082649,
0.0741679594,
0.0324165225,
0.0143562863,
-0.0110028191,
0.0309463218,
-0.0388062,
-0.0174005199,
0.0305742938,
0.0686964393,
-0.0383415408,
0.0137432031,
0.015217755,
-0.0187408086,
-0.0177146364,
0.054367248,
0.0046752556,
0.0172244776,
-0.0705175847,
-0.0434564352,
-0.0664601326,
-0.0791440606,
0.0310314782,
0.0319312923,
0.0134987552,
-0.0253984351,
-0.0631684661,
-0.0023862403,
0.0647964925,
0.0666033179,
-0.005058195,
0.007403973,
0.005018963,
-0.0119845038,
-0.0624152459,
-0.00364956,
-0.0685114712,
-0.0148702133,
0.0383460633,
-0.0461977571,
-0.0210421514,
-0.0582039505,
-0.0214320943,
0.0220212732,
-0.0250214245,
-0.021062851,
-0.0305492915,
0.055446852,
0.0211029612,
0.0578599349,
-0.0105629712,
0.0078863762,
-0.0259709321,
0.0206602979,
-0.0873595104,
-0.0670412108,
0.0291788075,
-0.0115829026,
0.0009507308,
0.0271954965,
-0.0138724726,
0.0197916441,
-0.0005040041,
0.0211453754,
-0.0285977144,
0.0403556563,
0.0868085325,
0.0045523029,
-0.0092950789,
0.0285014268,
-0.0379290357,
-0.0392356068,
0.0178206284,
-0.0627597645,
-0.0704317987,
-0.0179829001,
0.0251859948,
0.0024851598,
0.0130023779,
0.0235918537,
-0.0069034668,
0.0219618734,
0.0170240086,
0.0297881942,
-0.0329169221,
0.0455014668,
0.0021654645,
-0.0277202837,
-0.0222717114,
0.0047854329,
0.0068615391,
0.0210220162,
0.0543190278,
-0.0215564761,
0.0411572903,
0.0478161797,
-0.0222464241,
-0.050567247,
0.0026018433,
-0.0602621622,
-0.0127291726,
-0.0059817415,
0.0177388266,
0.0262610484,
0.0032275626,
-0.0124837207,
-0.0424808301,
-0.0239841454,
0.0554634891,
0.0181615334,
0.0485584699,
0.0089174993,
-0.0012677665,
0.0138163259,
-0.0242971815,
-0.0710604489,
0.0426679887,
0.0281526558,
-0.0078713009,
0.0164789502,
-0.0246792231,
-0.0779558122,
-0.014959137,
-0.0226066411,
0.0074144681,
-0.0115722585,
-0.018710399,
-0.0128677813,
-0.0372414216,
0.012845614,
0.0639633089,
-0.0346169733,
0.0094094845,
0.0452792682,
0.0438014083,
0.0332200415,
-0.0268004332,
-0.0244460497,
0.0266776923,
0.0173404217,
-0.0313298628,
-0.0173366256,
-6.285720942e-33,
-0.0487432145,
-0.0351931043,
0.0523179695,
-0.0380934663,
0.033317484,
-0.044548355,
-0.0464782305,
-0.0032153542,
0.0188248288,
0.0203589126,
-0.0187282637,
0.0228847172,
0.0108644897,
0.0031026443,
0.0265412461,
-0.0585909411,
0.0230857302,
-0.0116888164,
-0.0348029174,
-0.0046899742,
0.0066511552,
0.006758295,
-0.0067237527,
-0.0613414347,
0.0107731428,
0.0061468002,
-0.0117044384,
0.021962814,
-0.0429227389,
0.0189436954,
-0.0285215359,
0.0076235412,
0.0265964828,
-0.0446760394,
-0.0192492958,
0.0214865729,
-0.1565776914,
-0.0227880888,
-0.0099265147,
-0.0027350392,
-0.0346013196,
-0.0389931127,
0.0307902358,
-0.0081197331,
0.005264828,
-0.0072371615,
0.0457986221,
-0.0413257778,
0.0433438271,
0.0084660761,
-0.0345589817,
0.0007842855,
-0.0539209172,
-0.0058659264,
0.0549831353,
0.0408040583,
0.0301583279,
-0.0069774403,
-0.0256622825,
-0.0049183634,
-0.0145518146,
0.0215125885,
0.0796512365,
-0.0132835666,
0.0226940718,
0.011503336,
0.0447651744,
0.0356795192,
-0.0709433928,
0.0170988236,
-0.0457379445,
0.0656951368,
0.0671065003,
0.0276434943,
0.0571483821,
0.0353227891,
-0.0677316412,
0.0372575298,
-0.0074912258,
-0.0205892455,
-0.0302719381,
-0.0110348398,
-0.0293272194,
-0.0164879356,
-0.0229025781,
0.0219485518,
-0.0186807346,
0.0058241449,
0.0189770889,
0.0058813109,
0.0215471834,
-0.0052494938,
-0.0245276857,
0.0056712637,
-0.0108657787,
-0.0132064661,
0.0133110955,
-0.0057300022,
0.0261329021,
0.0292323455,
0.0081429034,
-0.0294615515,
0.0420732535,
-0.0044798055,
0.0586022735,
0.0426146872,
0.0669322833,
0.0239459258,
-0.0550212301,
-0.0084880125,
-0.0658717975,
0.0525193214,
0.0017437725,
0.0073609361,
-0.0162755717,
0.0291531514,
-0.0158483144,
0.0478346199,
0.0171366781,
0.0069096782,
-0.0200629644,
0.0202987418,
-0.0171273462,
-0.004877618,
0.0411693677,
0.0162530709,
-0.0323049575,
0.0066297036,
0.0032332018,
-0.0479409136,
0.011959427,
0.0412183106,
2.589e-7,
0.0690206885,
0.0193546321,
0.0479022972,
0.0249031316,
0.001792983,
0.0373975225,
-0.0204510633,
-0.0319570377,
-0.0202228073,
-0.0574828461,
0.031889949,
0.0345939994,
0.0492568053,
0.035447713,
-0.0089512756,
-0.0140436841,
-0.0285496507,
-0.0151373958,
-0.0451217964,
0.0194009114,
0.0807825476,
0.0661623105,
-0.0206729993,
-0.0041230228,
0.0093074702,
-0.0262400974,
0.0052832984,
-0.0054966793,
0.0397805236,
0.0324794799,
0.010361379,
-0.0079047941,
-0.012584161,
0.0936068743,
-0.0196957197,
0.0013961978,
0.0029188243,
0.0533729754,
-0.003385806,
0.0265151598,
-0.0001512788,
-0.0758015662,
0.0313065983,
-0.0165340826,
0.0920168385,
-0.0936624631,
-0.0056983684,
0.0757832751,
-0.0110746352,
0.0238116402,
-0.0017485457,
0.0443753935,
0.0076888911,
0.0062409891,
0.015293044,
0.0048906114,
0.0313918255,
-0.0507392399,
-0.0261597689,
0.02373771,
-0.0190910883,
0.016183069,
-0.035684891,
0.0118093565,
0.0121857347,
-0.0526733845,
-0.0293408018,
2.564570056e-34,
0.0293419622,
0.006347456,
0.0209138077,
-0.0011851321,
0.081070587,
-0.0201726649,
-0.0416232571,
-0.0094135264,
0.0294076484,
-0.0577682629,
-0.0084046172
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10087v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10087v1 | Hybrid Rule-Neural Coreference Resolution System based on Actor-Critic Learning | 2022-12-20T08:55:47 | 2022-12-20T08:55:47 | Yu Wang, Hongxia Jin | cs.CL | cs.CL | A coreference resolution system is to cluster all mentions that refer to the
same entity in a given context. All coreference resolution systems need to
tackle two main tasks: one task is to detect all of the potential mentions, and
the other is to learn the linking of an antecedent for each possible mention.
In this paper, we propose a hybrid rule-neural coreference resolution system
based on actor-critic learning, such that it can achieve better coreference
performance by leveraging the advantages from both the heuristic rules and a
neural conference model. This end-to-end system can also perform both mention
detection and resolution by leveraging a joint training algorithm. We
experiment on the BERT model to generate input span representations. Our model
with the BERT span representation achieves the state-of-the-art performance
among the models on the CoNLL-2012 Shared Task English Test Set. | [
0.0570624843,
-0.0408739448,
0.0111854663,
0.0266930219,
-0.0060484693,
-0.0207831562,
0.0000023409,
-0.028157765,
0.0271178391,
-0.0126799494,
-0.0188516472,
-0.0021370426,
-0.0452039056,
-0.0125286886,
0.0253967885,
-0.0059291981,
0.0794173032,
0.0267166272,
0.0767348856,
-0.0073496751,
0.0272775572,
-0.0017052618,
-0.0187823661,
0.045201946,
-0.0459603369,
-0.0134088825,
0.0179827902,
-0.0138030909,
0.0408134349,
-0.0057872599,
0.0514219292,
0.0420618802,
0.0040289722,
0.0586288311,
0.0000014814,
-0.0383099392,
0.0019126614,
-0.0097080972,
0.0143082719,
0.0194061175,
0.0013182822,
0.0351050757,
-0.0025381453,
-0.0130466716,
-0.0028437248,
-0.0355847329,
0.0167395435,
0.0913042128,
0.0741794109,
0.049916897,
-0.0073130815,
-0.0180329159,
0.0150627745,
-0.0269968864,
-0.09211009,
-0.0866954103,
0.0205911733,
0.0049187895,
0.0062734019,
-0.0258703008,
-0.004049412,
0.0389837883,
0.0282279272,
-0.0161369313,
0.0285716094,
0.0463094153,
-0.0747291595,
-0.0060029058,
0.0112446947,
0.106527552,
0.0315228216,
0.0242325813,
0.0331202,
0.031563282,
-0.0026200956,
-0.0450076498,
-0.0046188338,
-0.0091878837,
-0.0054510902,
0.0074496707,
0.0174735505,
-0.0286233947,
-0.0134794638,
0.0106124822,
-0.0201390665,
0.0630723014,
-0.009106921,
-0.0161407124,
0.0505806953,
0.0184216574,
-0.0075649889,
-0.0430488512,
0.0982912555,
0.0266911574,
-0.0366389267,
0.0084234513,
-0.0100760097,
-0.0006519211,
-0.0103971716,
-0.0808451772,
0.0102371899,
0.0055866241,
-0.0277151279,
0.0300824251,
-0.0452328324,
0.0308321211,
-0.0274810661,
0.0586558208,
-0.0138719641,
-0.0281663034,
-0.0449725911,
0.031070292,
-0.0663472861,
0.083320573,
-0.0542933606,
-0.0493995324,
-0.055192221,
-0.0194864236,
-0.0221556723,
0.0203493368,
-0.0137205413,
0.0161480326,
-0.022696564,
0.0192550737,
-0.0324241258,
0.059836749,
-0.0454869494,
-0.0070841289,
-0.0427151769,
0.0126881832,
-0.0198951457,
-0.0132773714,
0.0103913844,
-0.0306682196,
-0.0180682112,
0.0347869284,
-0.0052354885,
-0.0235515349,
-0.01223718,
-0.0167489182,
-0.0522131249,
-0.0278226193,
-0.0454448722,
-0.0485900491,
0.0317645036,
-0.0340602323,
-0.0197035633,
-0.0899002999,
0.032288149,
0.0267223027,
-0.0278475024,
0.0532533787,
-0.0036196953,
-0.0294607226,
0.025439214,
0.0059285751,
0.019648388,
0.0509669445,
0.0512878858,
0.0390191413,
0.0046573179,
0.0665676668,
-0.0060922364,
0.044812426,
0.0632275194,
-0.0069163227,
0.0404105932,
-0.0312692188,
-0.069718644,
0.0325346328,
0.0424942002,
0.06937325,
-0.0350853913,
-0.0309222583,
0.0189966504,
0.0274708513,
-0.0084716408,
0.0184525196,
-0.0007483434,
0.0154586351,
0.0114034535,
0.0286440421,
-0.0406203233,
0.0202597212,
-0.006245668,
-0.0396109,
0.0356573611,
-0.0135659296,
-0.0393847562,
-0.0156241516,
0.0194282122,
0.0259200204,
-0.0348548591,
-0.0143944575,
0.0493726917,
0.022081079,
-0.0584500618,
0.0591291152,
0.0284725092,
-0.0256677847,
0.0293842647,
-0.0056475941,
0.0057805222,
0.0230863634,
0.0374624431,
-0.0073045031,
-0.0633758307,
-0.0091769164,
0.0306846779,
0.0721797273,
0.0384530835,
-0.0481620878,
0.040939454,
-0.0272312537,
-0.0175859146,
0.0332909375,
0.0003831166,
0.0266893599,
-0.0055808113,
-0.0561158098,
0.0064883493,
0.0140589988,
-0.0540065803,
0.0272913463,
0.0245198142,
0.0138714099,
0.01857711,
0.0345561765,
0.0309606194,
0.0296257082,
-0.0150576867,
-0.0274138413,
0.0296012126,
-0.0398926325,
-0.0246986616,
0.0381981432,
-0.0491840392,
-0.0729260221,
0.0490556918,
-0.0579769872,
-0.0383654423,
-0.0245471299,
-0.0141231045,
-0.0623779297,
0.0093484512,
-0.034527719,
0.073072128,
-0.0330167413,
-0.0034970758,
0.0286231413,
-0.0104591977,
-0.0382861979,
0.0572582968,
-0.0139924604,
-0.004709254,
0.0322852693,
0.0313446149,
0.0310069043,
-0.0476686917,
-0.0298538767,
-0.0363462977,
-0.0124210846,
-0.0018034324,
0.0598736182,
0.0009573679,
-0.0612537302,
-0.0343398154,
-0.0436525904,
0.0067190286,
-0.0045101247,
-0.0121253524,
0.021153219,
0.0001552978,
0.0094961515,
-0.0374709517,
0.0024262106,
-0.0093908999,
0.0023939223,
-0.0087615466,
0.0343947858,
0.0637958124,
-0.0255191568,
-0.0740332082,
0.0038904748,
-0.049401477,
0.0095219165,
-0.0128462333,
-0.0139297908,
-0.0106897848,
-0.0082930531,
-0.0177533887,
0.0495410152,
0.0188648365,
-0.0083757443,
-0.0134738069,
0.0028063362,
0.0133610722,
-0.0006201962,
-0.0226155166,
0.0448826104,
0.0070171948,
-0.0726680085,
-0.0796092972,
0.0671623126,
0.0089246323,
-0.0237849336,
-0.0251706094,
0.0016989307,
0.0313391387,
0.0432121865,
0.021477893,
-0.0024240694,
-0.06162332,
0.0060505895,
-0.0141388001,
-0.0337064154,
0.0035979683,
-0.0202111285,
-0.0477719232,
0.0215573329,
-0.0733628199,
0.0400557704,
0.0622768588,
-0.009203353,
0.0014525543,
-0.0435067005,
0.0257363562,
-0.0274374224,
0.0247939136,
0.0214727335,
0.0310325455,
0.0539111421,
-0.1051149666,
-0.0059298542,
0.0072446279,
-0.0009481061,
0.0114506977,
0.051297348,
-0.0339449644,
0.0368741639,
-0.0004745097,
0.0148033174,
-0.0604543872,
0.0108616482,
-0.028906608,
-0.0186716355,
-0.0278119985,
0.0175843723,
-0.0283673592,
0.0107660778,
-0.0063265543,
0.0160138384,
-0.0042041531,
0.0040338668,
-0.0323664136,
0.0561718233,
0.016952686,
0.0033123242,
-0.0089406315,
-0.0173992887,
-0.008465969,
0.0527659804,
0.0368311629,
0.0014675818,
-0.0421659462,
-0.0119557548,
0.0228309277,
-0.0902712867,
-0.0151258754,
-0.0147908079,
0.0472265594,
-0.0192507003,
-0.030827947,
0.1314712763,
0.0410453379,
-0.0484484322,
-0.0088700373,
0.0285690092,
0.0115208263,
0.0144521547,
0.0066367961,
-0.0179277565,
-0.0185410045,
-0.0046489243,
-0.0251814183,
0.0430600196,
-0.057486672,
-0.0083307968,
-0.0644553974,
-0.0033099563,
-0.0018778316,
-0.0722167268,
-0.0476927944,
0.0076092305,
0.0560754016,
-0.0483104102,
0.0216896739,
0.0262039546,
0.001227928,
0.0159571301,
0.0091969185,
-0.0080712354,
0.0352611504,
0.0226786733,
-0.0833822191,
0.0402805172,
0.076509051,
0.063484706,
0.0354664363,
0.0390971377,
-0.0043294351,
-0.0444428809,
-0.0185281932,
-0.0169419236,
0.0370256528,
-0.0169462301,
-0.0096098259,
-0.0033890947,
0.0145234196,
0.0122384802,
0.0138932141,
0.0205847844,
0.0268157031,
0.0346262231,
0.0131398961,
-0.0272332504,
0.0454938151,
-0.0186415203,
0.0646805391,
0.0364812315,
0.0058698151,
-0.0236385688,
-0.0059748325,
-0.0028726871,
-0.0968114436,
-0.0139273554,
-0.0250592194,
-0.0505214445,
0.0091291107,
-0.0730963573,
-0.0603066087,
0.0311018396,
0.0325789154,
0.0193290897,
-0.0042044455,
0.0496565215,
0.0357469693,
-0.013820393,
-0.0239524413,
-0.0565604866,
-0.0066287504,
-0.0378120393,
0.0177542418,
0.0686669648,
0.0633359849,
-0.0446234941,
0.0858480036,
0.0055183582,
-0.0354189053,
-0.0127316602,
0.0023111324,
0.010035539,
0.0384679288,
-0.0609137453,
-0.019962417,
0.0047394265,
-0.0065364009,
-0.0328038484,
0.0225477479,
0.0216726158,
-0.0226414613,
-0.014661625,
0.0561977774,
-0.0502820946,
0.0529828034,
-0.0192369111,
0.0810290202,
-0.0407393649,
-0.0539421216,
0.0226970017,
-0.0185663234,
0.009531579,
0.0027884138,
0.0011011504,
-0.0399878882,
0.011593244,
-0.0036792094,
-0.0014949491,
0.0132041397,
0.0295906439,
-0.0285941903,
-0.0059958869,
-0.0145063205,
0.0006378546,
-0.0287078992,
0.0792054161,
-0.0303913485,
-0.0213437974,
0.0376092494,
-0.0276643075,
-0.0414977558,
0.0022123414,
-0.0085329786,
0.0035852329,
0.0517277941,
0.0234480314,
-0.0338105336,
0.0094927968,
0.0234457478,
-0.0033939423,
-0.0085146893,
-0.0286605507,
-0.0461171903,
0.0541119464,
-0.0522617437,
0.0125209577,
0.0776446462,
0.007951769,
0.060308408,
0.0063726846,
-0.0094862198,
0.0103191081,
-0.0182545427,
-0.051694423,
-0.0022384264,
-0.001629562,
0.0158556178,
0.0477228761,
-0.0067519634,
0.048032783,
-0.0060903807,
0.0363661498,
0.0235489663,
-0.0090478519,
-0.0731003955,
-0.0536070429,
-0.0575713366,
0.0304316338,
0.0114414468,
0.0307183154,
-0.0375404768,
-0.0361877978,
0.0533886552,
-0.0018003661,
0.001251479,
0.0034916131,
0.0421193764,
0.0114309676,
0.0439293012,
-0.0298444759,
-0.0085922191,
-0.0117171276,
0.0486378111,
-0.0423676036,
-0.0385964811,
-5.397034356e-33,
-0.1060642377,
-0.0092821242,
0.0212383252,
0.0057271477,
-0.0294212624,
0.0033049011,
-0.0655849427,
-0.0275145825,
-0.0146086048,
0.0308289211,
-0.0129177039,
0.0174829029,
0.017195113,
0.0196020901,
-0.0132123837,
-0.0060604112,
0.0730593875,
0.0129459612,
-0.0081104189,
0.0316973254,
0.0224818401,
0.0612401254,
0.0750308111,
-0.0599006973,
0.0146062961,
0.035757497,
-0.0099423472,
0.0312656052,
0.0633881688,
0.0451023281,
0.0026486383,
0.0471149534,
-0.0029556793,
-0.0180614199,
-0.0051237722,
-0.0295002889,
-0.1808761507,
-0.0491139963,
0.0376192927,
-0.0039520003,
0.026941264,
-0.0330808498,
0.052944351,
-0.0246687904,
0.0068422691,
0.0254046246,
0.063074939,
-0.0268843863,
-0.0247126557,
-0.0375965312,
-0.0537566133,
0.0166358929,
-0.0178020876,
-0.0056483494,
-0.0098312087,
0.0315285735,
0.0088650538,
-0.0329689346,
-0.0696461573,
0.0308610983,
-0.0091130277,
0.0194937997,
-0.0121137071,
0.0016965116,
-0.0179940015,
0.0449127182,
-0.0022862444,
-0.0439803973,
-0.0317557529,
-0.0247473624,
0.0289467014,
0.0096024238,
-0.0080332048,
0.0718725324,
-0.0257952604,
0.0018749338,
-0.0581184477,
0.0324452631,
0.0911777765,
0.0502804294,
0.0002379229,
0.0072088786,
-0.0344693102,
-0.0324648395,
-0.0219460726,
-0.0277273972,
-0.0191000756,
-0.053243719,
0.0041259914,
0.0177699737,
-0.0049275281,
0.0215646327,
0.0215158984,
-0.0327835865,
-0.0145281218,
0.0319478996,
0.0386892147,
-0.0187762212,
0.0324332416,
0.0282316823,
-0.0751014501,
0.0035235351,
-0.0009369844,
0.0216982011,
-0.0047966191,
-0.0209966395,
0.036050491,
-0.0117698722,
-0.0353170298,
-0.000918032,
-0.0150472689,
-0.002468846,
-0.0555988178,
-0.008702442,
0.0011950521,
0.0107977977,
0.0012469473,
0.0204882231,
0.0204905681,
0.0163610261,
-0.0424764343,
0.0230752807,
0.0497641973,
0.0498304553,
-0.0162416603,
-0.0019087119,
-0.0058443542,
0.0701593608,
0.0150653301,
-0.0832279995,
-0.0089413719,
-0.0097439941,
2.206e-7,
0.0047140727,
0.0246040598,
0.049877964,
-0.0287918225,
-0.0031873703,
-0.0069600949,
-0.0076116025,
0.0486790501,
0.0205360223,
-0.0128938705,
0.0127422214,
0.0361683257,
-0.0374852791,
0.0222801026,
-0.0815473124,
-0.019166667,
-0.0559556,
-0.0054910523,
-0.0253131408,
-0.004329626,
0.0011640089,
0.0559775084,
0.0316883251,
-0.0127134053,
-0.0239899103,
-0.0435088053,
0.0337423123,
0.0065297643,
-0.0181038808,
0.040912956,
-0.0042980327,
0.0330977142,
-0.0131701156,
0.0297568627,
0.0258113164,
0.0395909846,
0.0266557429,
0.0443806313,
0.0009355826,
-0.0707681701,
0.0116568711,
-0.019908445,
0.043334648,
0.0278706085,
0.0246575233,
-0.0583999716,
0.0092560472,
-0.0107276617,
-0.0242642052,
0.00972855,
-0.0333241075,
0.0105686188,
-0.0332692079,
0.014149094,
-0.0122052487,
-0.0158731844,
-0.0029166795,
-0.098754026,
-0.0148673514,
0.0140592754,
-0.0037909041,
-0.0152268494,
0.0239265431,
-0.066149354,
-0.0407866798,
-0.0539427921,
0.02457086,
1.62572384e-34,
0.0268077571,
-0.0121816546,
-0.0066721104,
0.0500104763,
-0.0061193015,
0.0063506854,
-0.0439842902,
-0.0280178934,
0.0221003555,
-0.0017563353,
-0.020356534
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10080v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10080v1 | Rumour detection using graph neural network and oversampling in benchmark Twitter dataset | 2022-12-20T08:43:10 | 2022-12-20T08:43:10 | Shaswat Patel, Prince Bansal, Preeti Kaur | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Recently, online social media has become a primary source for new information
and misinformation or rumours. In the absence of an automatic rumour detection
system the propagation of rumours has increased manifold leading to serious
societal damages. In this work, we propose a novel method for building
automatic rumour detection system by focusing on oversampling to alleviating
the fundamental challenges of class imbalance in rumour detection task. Our
oversampling method relies on contextualised data augmentation to generate
synthetic samples for underrepresented classes in the dataset. The key idea
exploits selection of tweets in a thread for augmentation which can be achieved
by introducing a non-random selection criteria to focus the augmentation
process on relevant tweets. Furthermore, we propose two graph neural
networks(GNN) to model non-linear conversations on a thread. To enhance the
tweet representations in our method we employed a custom feature selection
technique based on state-of-the-art BERTweet model. Experiments of three
publicly available datasets confirm that 1) our GNN models outperform the the
current state-of-the-art classifiers by more than 20%(F1-score); 2) our
oversampling technique increases the model performance by more than
9%;(F1-score) 3) focusing on relevant tweets for data augmentation via
non-random selection criteria can further improve the results; and 4) our
method has superior capabilities to detect rumours at very early stage. | [
0.0257025938,
0.0285890177,
0.0045597758,
0.0034359468,
-0.0407290235,
-0.0320645496,
0.0148551809,
0.0003441911,
0.0486706607,
-0.0320840627,
0.0280457549,
0.0091158357,
-0.0017706635,
0.0705703571,
0.0030675002,
0.010130981,
0.0254598018,
0.0282680895,
0.0341001935,
-0.0528483428,
0.0156472009,
0.0652454644,
0.0231673419,
0.0086723035,
-0.0365784205,
0.0344699286,
0.0333653279,
0.0379439816,
-0.0016426099,
-0.022397168,
-0.0019496379,
0.0169059578,
0.0696465448,
0.0478272326,
0.0000020338,
-0.0351902507,
-0.0343429372,
-0.0091085723,
-0.032862395,
-0.0050332965,
0.0179416742,
-0.0397945456,
0.0286398791,
0.0050972067,
-0.033411745,
0.0177423488,
0.0263169296,
0.0610662363,
0.0458536297,
0.0745344162,
-0.0322217904,
-0.0181372259,
0.0280667618,
-0.0378032885,
0.0209797733,
-0.0778041407,
0.0576261878,
0.0232097115,
-0.0211415514,
0.0153938783,
-0.0044745789,
-0.0114496667,
0.011426907,
-0.0147449523,
0.0545230769,
0.0275852233,
-0.0431863368,
-0.0244122297,
0.0110714175,
0.0645525679,
-0.0099307857,
-0.0585356615,
-0.0082758218,
-0.019863328,
0.0106304837,
0.0419472195,
-0.0514353029,
-0.0065339357,
-0.022890944,
0.0790842697,
-0.0217772909,
-0.0118265152,
0.0599049702,
0.0272025988,
0.0563942529,
0.0438163131,
-0.0224130806,
-0.0314751118,
0.030888509,
0.0286429301,
-0.0331937782,
-0.0658239052,
0.0355732329,
0.0111495918,
-0.0173372142,
-0.0058881529,
-0.0503390618,
-0.0165070128,
-0.0003445114,
-0.0983273014,
-0.0530282445,
-0.0020823723,
0.0377243273,
0.0385596082,
-0.0079180459,
-0.0522131212,
-0.0206276067,
0.0185943302,
0.0321844332,
-0.0281321071,
-0.0327802971,
0.0421768911,
-0.0389753282,
0.0309706386,
-0.0208814256,
-0.0130519997,
-0.063695848,
-0.0086555332,
0.0002335331,
-0.0170003623,
0.005488154,
0.0463884845,
-0.0272480994,
-0.0050499747,
0.0179678816,
0.0436689779,
0.0283185691,
0.0406385921,
-0.0305964109,
-0.0137843695,
-0.0112308441,
0.0150218382,
0.0476279296,
0.0150594171,
-0.0067663505,
0.0150766112,
0.0500362925,
-0.0259597152,
-0.0442356467,
-0.0283945017,
0.0041906396,
-0.0295764394,
0.0011431228,
-0.0745929554,
-0.0084023112,
-0.0222711843,
-0.0108533017,
0.0108846305,
0.0140180886,
0.0157953594,
-0.0695913881,
0.0243565217,
-0.033272665,
-0.0077004959,
0.0419170782,
0.0233064238,
-0.0179774072,
0.0738093555,
0.0475180298,
0.0752025917,
0.0586839914,
0.0337780938,
-0.0081363795,
0.002325654,
0.0725170597,
-0.004922023,
0.0339059867,
-0.0294391382,
-0.059808027,
-0.0140394066,
-0.0165720824,
0.0078834035,
-0.0165738259,
-0.0266448669,
0.0633914843,
-0.0399927087,
-0.0295537263,
0.0184486695,
0.0283571798,
0.0434786007,
-0.0324658342,
-0.0046072709,
-0.0300391018,
0.0237982869,
-0.0408663973,
-0.0069582253,
0.0381657891,
0.0116555067,
-0.0427099913,
-0.0053082108,
0.0059425235,
0.0075230538,
0.068346858,
-0.0109278755,
0.0253541265,
0.0007780338,
-0.0574905425,
0.0465839542,
0.0515784733,
0.0053224983,
-0.0309615545,
-0.0452063717,
-0.0107093425,
0.0359770469,
0.008124942,
0.0302225333,
-0.0024783826,
-0.0393223651,
0.0347007178,
0.0029288817,
0.0437865853,
-0.0054126484,
-0.0021681737,
-0.0321811996,
-0.0095782354,
-0.0452825464,
0.0166856404,
0.0153558152,
0.0240392443,
0.0642144158,
-0.0001929177,
-0.0522414111,
-0.0899594128,
-0.0101205362,
-0.0010491965,
-0.0073708366,
0.0213797726,
0.002027119,
-0.0015671176,
0.0140771838,
0.0032724119,
-0.0505615845,
0.0306651033,
0.0293688253,
-0.0427168757,
-0.0218164958,
-0.0442185365,
-0.0381464697,
0.013341831,
-0.0372652784,
-0.0523523092,
0.0125606749,
-0.0433194488,
-0.0081380671,
0.0916292444,
-0.0361798853,
0.0312344227,
-0.0490653142,
-0.0679307356,
-0.0463291779,
0.0505544171,
0.0423950367,
0.0547813997,
-0.0277068149,
-0.0392239168,
-0.0144431666,
-0.0307498015,
0.0100912303,
-0.0305098444,
-0.0055703456,
-0.0164443161,
0.0172338374,
0.0287968703,
0.0118574668,
-0.0267738234,
-0.0070438348,
0.0251993649,
-0.1111173704,
0.0080592968,
-0.0203692596,
-0.0234771725,
0.023753101,
0.03753452,
-0.0079508983,
-0.0171372425,
-0.0284399465,
0.0394914746,
0.0231393017,
0.0120169194,
-0.0090508303,
-0.0248798728,
0.0273415726,
-0.0122880908,
-0.0128342025,
-0.0227846242,
0.0469051078,
0.0684916005,
-0.0700312629,
-0.0038625284,
0.0025577371,
-0.0384664051,
0.0282093342,
-0.0147989523,
0.0117094815,
-0.0171055458,
0.0046538785,
-0.0166595001,
0.0255203974,
-0.0030420017,
0.0283581521,
0.0102365334,
0.0205599181,
-0.0001508445,
0.0100724055,
-0.0368357636,
0.0104680024,
-0.0422217287,
-0.033942543,
-0.0181948021,
0.0122382799,
0.0058462583,
-0.0016592771,
-0.0170528758,
0.0318497159,
0.0270206686,
0.0223779604,
0.0173701849,
-0.0631964952,
0.027671732,
-0.01375499,
-0.050720416,
-0.0589395538,
0.0740200654,
0.003569582,
0.0417669155,
-0.0272813141,
-0.0477201492,
-0.0151543142,
0.0126133021,
-0.0090363882,
0.0035232862,
0.0035348067,
0.0136287166,
0.017892139,
-0.0348322317,
0.0203786995,
-0.0081652775,
-0.0243141726,
0.0134706469,
0.0502853878,
0.0443817787,
0.0177528989,
-0.0228824131,
-0.0983748436,
-0.0464381017,
0.0013445168,
-0.0523822792,
-0.025311064,
-0.04624689,
-0.0261289049,
-0.0139676463,
0.013674899,
-0.0251441449,
0.0089598186,
0.0303874109,
0.0217609126,
0.0078141047,
-0.012337598,
0.0414432362,
-0.0121874064,
-0.0064825518,
0.0528341569,
-0.0365540609,
-0.0146540301,
-0.0062616626,
-0.0343749635,
-0.0484236851,
-0.0132514359,
0.0139927855,
-0.0319144279,
0.0530522205,
-0.0383424126,
0.0048909835,
0.0863512605,
0.0044870018,
-0.0249256622,
0.023505656,
0.0511979759,
0.0130606731,
0.012347308,
-0.0119283572,
-0.0609105602,
-0.0041727833,
-0.025546575,
0.0089321528,
-0.0072885747,
-0.0448322967,
-0.0238994118,
-0.0733586103,
0.0251515619,
-0.0127385361,
0.0012774341,
-0.0461499654,
-0.052076228,
0.0209794659,
0.0022168553,
0.0301389098,
-0.0348410718,
0.0263330396,
-0.000428382,
0.0072690616,
-0.0057855234,
-0.0368294381,
0.052109424,
-0.0202178136,
-0.0007224964,
-0.0331467576,
0.0591598451,
-0.0171887875,
-0.0237152651,
0.0336281732,
0.0249326546,
-0.0326260924,
-0.0178608801,
0.1027330682,
-0.0329897627,
0.0020939081,
-0.0128284795,
0.0331759788,
-0.0260540154,
-0.0070591252,
-0.0449375696,
0.0301399361,
0.0215097945,
-0.0530268773,
-0.0158618223,
0.0310898442,
0.0611376949,
0.040169701,
0.0397227816,
0.0086004045,
0.0088127162,
-0.0449330956,
-0.0365522541,
-0.0478626154,
-0.013435605,
0.0551154576,
-0.0011274973,
-0.0590695441,
-0.0179212596,
-0.0252350159,
-0.0134035805,
-0.0025750147,
-0.0564670153,
0.0007050432,
0.036998231,
-0.0343560278,
-0.0539174639,
0.0005924564,
0.0040996461,
0.0237613171,
0.0807727501,
-0.0047316067,
0.0033673092,
-0.0278203804,
-0.0087699918,
0.0363921747,
-0.0930482224,
-0.0873993263,
-0.025695309,
-0.0105130784,
0.0209053755,
0.0610494465,
-0.047534164,
-0.0384131223,
0.056917198,
0.0399721302,
-0.0081980517,
0.0173030663,
-0.0010926583,
0.0082731694,
0.0369511172,
0.0416018553,
-0.023436876,
0.0517967902,
0.030488871,
-0.0283226315,
-0.0469119065,
0.0073938463,
-0.009664475,
0.0251350645,
0.0081681581,
0.0223057121,
-0.0041325809,
-0.0473995507,
-0.0080236318,
-0.0212275572,
0.0000194864,
0.008709874,
0.0166902021,
0.0070801033,
-0.0081396895,
-0.0301676728,
-0.0444828644,
-0.0117804855,
0.0190452449,
-0.0761016533,
-0.0149634117,
0.0203474388,
-0.0185925681,
0.0199769437,
0.0013909553,
-0.0190521423,
-0.0325685181,
0.0162638295,
0.0096108401,
0.0169083122,
-0.0516321436,
0.0020824634,
-0.0323030278,
-0.0202691909,
-0.0566955246,
-0.0722219124,
-0.0131263714,
-0.0512536764,
0.0173791945,
0.0258784369,
-0.0063171401,
0.0372629501,
0.0076718898,
-0.0093037942,
0.005217806,
-0.0010591779,
-0.0384298265,
-0.0241957642,
0.0041479119,
-0.0172326751,
-0.0306055136,
0.1163955256,
0.0238736998,
0.0140693402,
0.0285121612,
0.0518807061,
-0.0706446469,
-0.0383598953,
-0.0047812383,
0.0057380954,
0.0999253616,
0.0213617366,
-0.0021868751,
-0.0214842968,
-0.0469430201,
0.0516467318,
-0.0150432372,
0.0304313693,
0.0363997966,
-0.0052023949,
0.0648330823,
0.0317960568,
0.0343155675,
-0.0336835198,
0.0026304731,
-0.0026034156,
-0.0401994586,
0.0001007757,
-6.438695369e-33,
0.0546388663,
-0.0373736843,
-0.0397349782,
-0.0008701799,
-0.0402836576,
0.0585402884,
-0.0547407158,
-0.0446471982,
-0.0462989211,
0.0540760159,
0.0308472738,
0.042137906,
-0.0007194759,
0.0098815626,
-0.0289920215,
-0.0214811433,
0.0384378284,
0.0191632342,
0.0202428717,
0.0723285973,
0.069379203,
0.0224188454,
0.0707208142,
-0.0811876729,
0.0292015299,
-0.0543493703,
0.0043338845,
-0.0026778735,
0.0255621858,
0.0259801541,
0.0081249736,
0.1009549499,
0.0427602306,
0.0176060945,
-0.0047806427,
0.0218622517,
-0.0358915254,
-0.0382357165,
-0.0089695631,
-0.0195595361,
0.0313811786,
0.0256935339,
0.0523598269,
0.0236638393,
0.0274481829,
-0.0289850682,
0.0493508577,
0.0300445575,
-0.0069677606,
-0.001129481,
-0.0048959469,
0.0232009441,
0.0060180062,
-0.0027946997,
-0.0449552983,
0.0435455479,
0.0228628404,
0.0107963197,
-0.0910380781,
0.0167642366,
-0.0494107902,
-0.0392970964,
-0.0177205987,
-0.049797941,
-0.0216424614,
0.0471120253,
-0.011712891,
0.0526237935,
-0.0485171005,
0.0400827974,
0.0095345732,
0.0556369126,
0.002701435,
0.0486651324,
0.0430184938,
-0.0668810979,
-0.1495129317,
0.0123772714,
0.056387376,
-0.0214494504,
0.0261317156,
0.0200697016,
-0.027312031,
-0.0345288329,
0.0517807715,
-0.0682557225,
-0.0224379022,
-0.0184247289,
-0.0637479201,
0.0292710066,
-0.0108176861,
0.1090144441,
-0.0074591441,
-0.0706464648,
-0.0105058467,
0.0325708352,
-0.0280803014,
0.0008040254,
0.0184414927,
0.0287413616,
-0.0656785443,
0.0190389995,
0.0247382559,
0.0543222204,
-0.0290090647,
0.0042865966,
0.057010483,
-0.0029821624,
-0.0115463743,
0.019482201,
-0.0379096679,
0.0180958472,
-0.0156772714,
0.038447421,
0.0182887074,
0.0419183001,
-0.0201219693,
-0.005661204,
0.0070029288,
0.0405978039,
-0.0052368124,
0.0318399183,
-0.0151144825,
0.0128606288,
-0.002474403,
-0.0222548489,
0.0096535189,
0.0150633454,
-0.0009700669,
-0.0852563903,
0.0023461811,
-0.0238523819,
2.822e-7,
-0.0008958702,
0.0477190875,
0.0005700589,
-0.057677187,
0.0460200086,
0.0225667283,
0.0299930684,
0.04725926,
-0.0156965144,
-0.1020660996,
-0.0077858479,
0.0624329746,
-0.0309603084,
0.052793473,
-0.0530122742,
-0.0027133862,
-0.0499917082,
-0.0043441593,
-0.0234139394,
0.0109975934,
0.0180386286,
0.0369871631,
0.0732119307,
-0.0283211675,
0.0169883836,
-0.0490275584,
0.0410476625,
0.0333865657,
-0.0465624966,
0.0184544399,
0.0176795498,
0.0389152095,
-0.0331985131,
0.020462241,
-0.0215072818,
0.0316280425,
-0.0004975792,
-0.0200092606,
-0.0205527339,
-0.0003664218,
-0.0158345662,
-0.011330503,
0.0302493237,
-0.0182013121,
0.0463857129,
-0.0435172208,
-0.087211363,
-0.0324390605,
-0.0237050932,
0.0319407322,
0.0511489883,
-0.0053952727,
0.0116188256,
0.0285961032,
0.0011913683,
-0.0132887634,
-0.0208923034,
-0.0369008854,
0.0162382983,
-0.014673559,
-0.0740990043,
-0.0539450757,
0.0198198389,
-0.0402010195,
0.043299064,
-0.0012687921,
0.0766650215,
2.13611637e-34,
0.0506593473,
0.0143390298,
-0.0271419715,
-0.0253280923,
-0.0122787356,
0.0196491629,
-0.0055717085,
-0.0404740646,
0.0243408773,
-0.0310322065,
-0.008479923
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10079v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10079v1 | A Survey on Pretrained Language Models for Neural Code Intelligence | 2022-12-20T08:34:56 | 2022-12-20T08:34:56 | Yichen Xu, Yanqiao Zhu | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.CL, cs.LG | As the complexity of modern software continues to escalate, software
engineering has become an increasingly daunting and error-prone endeavor. In
recent years, the field of Neural Code Intelligence (NCI) has emerged as a
promising solution, leveraging the power of deep learning techniques to tackle
analytical tasks on source code with the goal of improving programming
efficiency and minimizing human errors within the software industry. Pretrained
language models have become a dominant force in NCI research, consistently
delivering state-of-the-art results across a wide range of tasks, including
code summarization, generation, and translation. In this paper, we present a
comprehensive survey of the NCI domain, including a thorough review of
pretraining techniques, tasks, datasets, and model architectures. We hope this
paper will serve as a bridge between the natural language and programming
language communities, offering insights for future research in this rapidly
evolving field. | [
0.0108033447,
0.0802535489,
-0.0198403988,
0.0151337283,
0.0150184203,
0.0106175123,
-0.0190673675,
-0.0312354974,
-0.0142034236,
-0.0022472853,
-0.0039506932,
0.0115291271,
0.0153570976,
0.0551129505,
0.0539853051,
0.0166054219,
0.0251299441,
-0.0200227387,
-0.0130973672,
0.0309470873,
0.0026817673,
0.0274356417,
0.0040008961,
0.0704587623,
-0.0127450433,
-0.0410041548,
-0.0026059344,
0.0133488989,
-0.0256867427,
-0.0313966796,
0.0506814718,
0.0188497212,
0.0010803828,
0.015132416,
0.0000019435,
0.0003106993,
-0.0114667881,
-0.0317027085,
0.0145436954,
0.0338321626,
0.0043308334,
-0.0371906981,
0.0121301748,
0.0367846787,
-0.0556959808,
-0.025202278,
0.0597418584,
-0.0474653393,
0.0703715757,
0.0638480186,
0.0034257455,
-0.0070484863,
0.0325627103,
-0.0177221838,
0.0034724306,
-0.0271119699,
-0.0118882572,
0.0098515116,
-0.0403539687,
-0.0069197104,
0.0268992167,
0.0315471478,
0.045922488,
-0.0061485525,
0.0049956203,
0.0198968556,
-0.0464289449,
-0.0010460579,
-0.0127248429,
0.0608224533,
-0.0844263062,
-0.024192797,
0.0044505973,
-0.0209354814,
-0.0291369185,
-0.0810679868,
-0.0266813226,
0.0389910825,
0.0274465922,
0.0071724765,
0.014419863,
-0.0025341124,
-0.0055331802,
0.0054243398,
-0.0618479811,
0.0238356143,
-0.0015056516,
0.0038756444,
-0.0074908179,
-0.0212415531,
0.0090821376,
-0.0482439771,
0.0174761005,
0.0793258175,
-0.0107604163,
0.0059823054,
-0.0448783152,
-0.0623701997,
0.0209570806,
-0.0487519614,
0.0213997867,
0.0356670506,
-0.0227177739,
0.0164466333,
-0.0522998236,
0.0757344291,
-0.0098831803,
0.0200740565,
-0.0185971316,
0.0012487893,
-0.0401487201,
-0.0119347423,
-0.0442229547,
0.0427226201,
-0.0110712368,
0.0032067951,
-0.0217602514,
0.0459676012,
0.0161584541,
0.0401863381,
-0.0127816815,
0.0102065355,
-0.0579588003,
0.0129653355,
0.0321272798,
-0.0030533504,
-0.0277574714,
-0.0614757799,
-0.0109872725,
-0.0449417457,
-0.0192037188,
0.0374076702,
-0.026434293,
-0.0085850945,
0.0271311309,
0.0469179265,
0.016692441,
0.029373765,
-0.0474803858,
-0.0277425405,
0.0105852745,
0.0173400193,
0.0112502752,
-0.0905945599,
-0.017047165,
-0.0151267583,
-0.0252746791,
-0.097489737,
-0.0137322713,
0.0086988239,
0.0165251531,
0.0204261076,
-0.0934335068,
0.0030981691,
0.0255935322,
-0.0128914639,
0.0119369747,
0.0322135538,
0.0748541281,
0.0243375637,
0.0032923794,
-0.0252158623,
0.0357520804,
0.032969214,
0.0092331385,
-0.0122705987,
-0.012925203,
0.0147138834,
0.007199103,
-0.0393331796,
0.0380672179,
0.0279832818,
0.0001536276,
0.000596039,
-0.0188622028,
0.0538854264,
0.0189400427,
0.0518254451,
0.0838955864,
0.0254743658,
0.0087602912,
-0.0187483933,
-0.0368637964,
0.068117775,
0.0002005344,
0.0406960621,
0.0114745377,
0.0360608585,
-0.0322575942,
-0.0836351141,
0.0298214108,
-0.0376915932,
-0.0002483086,
-0.0129778935,
0.0113577293,
-0.0012034849,
-0.0645804256,
0.0167855695,
0.0265147518,
-0.0644631833,
0.0043093795,
-0.0176727008,
-0.0033239224,
0.0235926695,
0.0497261398,
-0.0768160746,
-0.0629104823,
0.0116131669,
-0.0221645944,
-0.007729677,
0.0402064957,
-0.0070874123,
0.0219081603,
-0.0675922781,
-0.020727694,
-0.0610851124,
-0.0032743458,
0.0505324602,
-0.0028188552,
-0.0279699955,
0.0525924601,
0.0454519875,
-0.1043224931,
0.0526648499,
-0.0004838766,
-0.0174661689,
0.0125451572,
0.0053797616,
0.0248296,
-0.0269404929,
-0.0460271165,
0.0202480722,
0.0216439944,
-0.0182053782,
-0.0299644191,
-0.0252885129,
-0.0477945879,
-0.0475799926,
0.0399831757,
-0.054473456,
0.002464375,
0.0372928567,
-0.0438114554,
-0.0200624932,
0.0677165166,
-0.0408808626,
-0.0128580239,
0.0015497738,
-0.0119464956,
-0.015547242,
-0.0081597622,
-0.0063448292,
0.0423697904,
0.0174684208,
0.0220934432,
0.0161834937,
0.044352781,
0.0379047096,
0.0126555003,
-0.0128309308,
-0.0147817265,
-0.0338989198,
0.040912088,
0.0413549766,
0.0817379951,
-0.0036524234,
-0.0091428673,
-0.0682481974,
0.0326389559,
-0.0337004326,
0.0126325022,
0.0114787826,
0.0125370082,
0.0125224814,
-0.0249464083,
-0.0585374869,
-0.0212018713,
-0.0150221447,
-0.0258841701,
0.0387740135,
-0.0057453904,
-0.0124481292,
-0.060655769,
-0.0110372286,
-0.0551434867,
0.0483683236,
-0.0029214562,
-0.030689491,
-0.0512333624,
0.0702136457,
-0.0329589285,
0.0351110287,
-0.0030781063,
-0.0686441436,
0.0107726455,
-0.0470056273,
0.0589369312,
0.0541870594,
-0.0063777012,
-0.0344147794,
0.0425316542,
0.0223089829,
-0.0582876056,
0.0359539315,
0.0209387559,
-0.0203095358,
0.0182195902,
-0.0375821106,
0.0661104992,
0.0916357413,
-0.0019995694,
-0.0100715579,
-0.0451955087,
0.0230268165,
0.0005904406,
0.0081244092,
0.0167174358,
-0.0294399392,
0.0112909721,
0.0565873198,
-0.0274390522,
-0.0699223951,
0.064313218,
-0.0426457971,
-0.0257767458,
-0.0662877038,
-0.0237561576,
-0.0769453496,
0.0549170785,
0.0040918011,
0.0306661557,
0.0003406915,
-0.0394837372,
-0.0346659385,
0.0122734923,
-0.0607193932,
0.0008039695,
0.0387660898,
-0.0562036708,
-0.0010261805,
-0.0066277571,
-0.0001071302,
-0.0304794628,
-0.012745372,
-0.01720622,
-0.0043982598,
0.063461028,
0.0091140727,
0.0330895893,
0.0092117637,
-0.0163599625,
0.0844335631,
0.0127431815,
-0.0202265698,
-0.0240030456,
-0.0492165722,
0.0022295793,
-0.0456235334,
0.0104504209,
0.0033921357,
-0.0346292853,
-0.0047237151,
0.054249946,
0.0554625466,
-0.097512342,
-0.0129175661,
0.0116337156,
-0.0208330899,
-0.0129686929,
0.0497741438,
0.0399643481,
-0.0280429535,
-0.0230304003,
0.098455824,
0.034586262,
-0.0859794393,
0.0022905404,
0.0323742218,
0.0240614433,
0.0618559979,
0.0389716439,
-0.0577157214,
-0.0241048671,
-0.0304215588,
0.0121065713,
-0.0000691448,
-0.0068197045,
-0.0428753868,
-0.0818765685,
-0.0210695639,
0.0223032869,
-0.0349473841,
-0.0489056483,
0.0046056961,
-0.0265871193,
0.0082846805,
-0.0380962342,
-0.0020779488,
0.0080102598,
0.0057605384,
0.0062987283,
-0.0532466024,
0.0235053487,
0.0030469007,
-0.0506037064,
0.0283999182,
0.1090102792,
0.013880414,
0.0158032384,
0.0195265468,
0.0436195433,
-0.032960467,
0.0265657268,
-0.0119624035,
0.0581775531,
-0.0011622165,
-0.020521136,
0.0557534546,
-0.0013156871,
-0.0782332569,
0.0260114986,
0.0474739373,
0.0179013629,
-0.0093815159,
-0.0014817441,
-0.0406578407,
0.0231888592,
-0.0211486332,
0.0166936703,
0.0915977433,
-0.0272403471,
-0.0169666,
-0.0732371435,
0.0291863792,
-0.0939761326,
-0.0098675499,
-0.0169729404,
0.0160426088,
0.0061660009,
-0.0713459104,
-0.0450903215,
0.0215905588,
0.0197140202,
0.0389208421,
-0.0703033879,
0.0475107841,
-0.0166120492,
-0.0525441878,
0.031522844,
-0.0109917717,
-0.0147942826,
-0.0239335746,
-0.0062557408,
0.0321390182,
-0.0132247191,
-0.0108060939,
0.0060585695,
-0.1021910906,
-0.0311099328,
-0.0444231257,
0.0863533095,
0.0147499871,
0.0302080922,
-0.0532075912,
-0.0702126101,
-0.0280335955,
0.0145605318,
-0.0405377112,
-0.0189644489,
0.0381466933,
0.0069666235,
0.0033928638,
0.0058400305,
-0.0806502774,
0.0167562813,
0.0177051686,
-0.0134392316,
-0.015755523,
-0.0060925148,
0.0410362557,
-0.0104864016,
0.0073852967,
0.0490393937,
-0.0001646368,
-0.0142951366,
-0.0030024496,
0.0230827797,
-0.0214155335,
-0.0600884818,
0.0447247401,
-0.0003324552,
0.0108457664,
0.0308627784,
0.0224043038,
-0.0102377338,
0.0292688962,
-0.0030306266,
0.0251679979,
0.0257519037,
0.0580246449,
-0.0031221639,
0.0036065781,
-0.0419170782,
0.0179019868,
-0.0269324295,
0.0057848943,
-0.016341228,
0.0193476062,
0.031805601,
0.0343926847,
-0.0045843292,
0.0214064643,
-0.060491614,
-0.0543495528,
0.005045244,
-0.0173774883,
0.0439257398,
0.0294191316,
0.0365015641,
0.0134031726,
0.0434798412,
-0.0058905352,
0.0555615462,
0.0031856017,
-0.0162285846,
-0.0196366906,
0.0343766995,
0.0069087488,
-0.0571912788,
0.088887766,
-0.0195169859,
-0.0105012329,
0.0114010992,
0.0034026022,
-0.0314600505,
0.0205768179,
0.0206607636,
-0.0032455877,
-0.0310713425,
-0.0028927005,
-0.0026008044,
-0.0364797972,
0.025482811,
0.0592998378,
0.0500294715,
0.0141857164,
0.0414801762,
0.080028154,
-0.0232073274,
-0.0176119544,
-0.0002091785,
-0.0061712614,
-0.0066205906,
-0.0389012173,
-0.0639692545,
-5.420269471e-33,
-0.0176750757,
-0.0175975449,
0.0046679094,
0.0250694156,
-0.0000333671,
0.0155841438,
-0.0745087937,
-0.0303154849,
-0.0120581593,
-0.0449711233,
0.019865524,
0.0427342542,
-0.0229418986,
-0.0143689299,
0.0359339938,
0.0301506612,
0.0456546471,
0.0187381469,
-0.0294527393,
0.0653448179,
-0.0563349128,
0.0393008851,
0.0333218761,
-0.0283696428,
0.0017329348,
-0.0103089651,
0.0404414386,
0.0062092845,
0.0520317703,
0.0411037505,
0.0082435748,
-0.0044543501,
0.0080247093,
-0.0186633579,
-0.0427110195,
-0.0229413994,
-0.0244082306,
-0.0549365655,
0.0010282682,
-0.0130198253,
-0.012047627,
-0.0711459368,
0.0929920524,
-0.0198321342,
0.0069697998,
-0.0086833583,
0.0517436676,
0.0216243081,
0.0151329441,
-0.0700318739,
-0.0637854561,
0.026825266,
-0.077325359,
-0.0190510806,
-0.0102408221,
0.0396280326,
-0.0023881039,
0.0438011363,
-0.0189310964,
-0.0063453955,
0.0228003021,
0.0516358241,
0.0560153313,
-0.0006427018,
0.0167975165,
0.0257190838,
0.0536887608,
0.0400707647,
-0.0303951669,
0.0263617896,
0.0784726292,
0.0143844523,
0.0404763818,
-0.0173515286,
0.0450204201,
0.0127792181,
-0.0367798284,
0.024556065,
-0.0049390369,
0.0129672028,
0.0049304734,
0.0262631159,
-0.0274810363,
-0.0054097762,
-0.0356738195,
-0.039088577,
-0.0184417255,
-0.0364717655,
0.0281697288,
0.0110503538,
-0.0255319346,
0.0054334518,
0.0194977522,
-0.0422441103,
0.0575335063,
0.0373286828,
-0.0357748307,
0.0367715582,
-0.0062350472,
0.0412476361,
-0.0029514304,
-0.0030998231,
0.011191383,
-0.0038600545,
0.0882912576,
0.0261760671,
0.0320723392,
0.032736212,
-0.0196626894,
-0.001963954,
-0.0361201987,
-0.0264652986,
-0.001065912,
0.0515583642,
-0.0227242019,
0.0302425008,
0.0101296594,
0.0284395888,
-0.0104771573,
-0.0191317108,
-0.0421041809,
0.0155960107,
0.026130151,
0.0432795472,
-0.0502524003,
-0.0444437787,
-0.041316539,
0.0415568426,
0.0143174874,
-0.0452850461,
-0.0607862733,
0.0182409976,
2.46e-7,
0.0217860062,
0.0304395314,
0.0361008383,
0.0396864787,
-0.0105197532,
0.0080135074,
-0.0214925371,
-0.0066775796,
0.0232826471,
0.0202568732,
-0.0020308192,
0.0384911001,
0.0193852969,
0.0045719137,
-0.0598430894,
-0.0052517322,
-0.0196727253,
-0.0008815595,
-0.0705571994,
0.0039926805,
0.0351250693,
0.0925739184,
-0.0149046015,
0.0059391358,
-0.0084241731,
-0.0415040627,
-0.0062466674,
0.0121054631,
0.0137876347,
0.0556880794,
-0.0297380984,
0.0395127051,
-0.0495066531,
-0.0329683796,
0.0010005828,
-0.0164127648,
0.0162172858,
0.0396681055,
-0.0077686785,
0.0150241377,
0.0517675169,
-0.0025763402,
-0.010484009,
-0.044559367,
0.0232239589,
-0.0750580281,
0.0207319707,
-0.00119022,
-0.0004755624,
0.0282524917,
-0.0009697463,
-0.0263429321,
0.0358427912,
0.0098644365,
-0.0026025786,
-0.0564980544,
-0.0201320723,
-0.0581675656,
-0.0428395681,
0.0374793075,
0.0281284973,
-0.0078475773,
-0.0520205349,
0.0041656396,
0.024085829,
-0.0194997508,
0.0437074266,
2.44850583e-34,
0.0392869972,
-0.0520817451,
-0.0016070658,
-0.003035011,
0.0603878014,
-0.0343574509,
-0.0410231464,
0.0102646407,
-0.0089698993,
-0.0128283873,
-0.0583109073
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10077v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10077v3 | DOC: Improving Long Story Coherence With Detailed Outline Control | 2022-12-20T08:30:58 | 2023-06-14T22:05:11 | Kevin Yang, Dan Klein, Nanyun Peng, Yuandong Tian | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We propose the Detailed Outline Control (DOC) framework for improving
long-range plot coherence when automatically generating
several-thousand-word-long stories. DOC consists of two complementary
components: a detailed outliner and a detailed controller. The detailed
outliner creates a more detailed, hierarchically structured outline, shifting
creative burden from the main drafting procedure to the planning stage. The
detailed controller ensures the more detailed outline is still respected during
generation by controlling story passages to align with outline details. In
human evaluations of automatically generated stories, DOC substantially
outperforms a strong Re3 baseline (Yang et al., 2022) on plot coherence (22.5%
absolute gain), outline relevance (28.2%), and interestingness (20.7%). Humans
also judged DOC to be much more controllable in an interactive generation
setting. | [
-0.0074760099,
0.000682573,
-0.0048615807,
-0.0188008845,
-0.0352801681,
-0.026801629,
-0.0092115728,
-0.0010556116,
-0.0494382083,
0.0003593298,
-0.008437573,
0.0085820165,
0.0146692786,
0.1170017645,
-0.0359978303,
-0.0984414071,
-0.0011571089,
-0.0346629173,
0.0439572819,
0.0434212722,
-0.0191544183,
-0.0000961117,
-0.0083837286,
0.0088982824,
-0.0159966387,
-0.0166626424,
-0.0277174879,
0.0180401038,
0.019438399,
-0.0709251612,
-0.0459421314,
0.0194101874,
0.0231186971,
-0.0133386971,
0.0000019704,
-0.0637134537,
-0.0204891432,
-0.0037959621,
0.0189127792,
0.0289447624,
-0.0123489918,
-0.0078104613,
0.0079797069,
-0.0470800549,
0.0272844341,
0.0789699778,
0.0393646508,
0.091949001,
0.03256106,
0.0263980962,
-0.0206036326,
-0.040145278,
-0.0208279118,
0.0074654189,
0.0268867891,
0.0209536031,
-0.068162702,
-0.0016833625,
0.0688847452,
-0.0144102164,
-0.0201074779,
-0.0149981976,
0.0195565335,
-0.0054347301,
0.0425666012,
0.0684632137,
0.0014168487,
-0.0259516407,
-0.0059977747,
0.0561351851,
-0.002492704,
-0.007723114,
0.014406343,
-0.0636380911,
0.0091471989,
0.0139480494,
-0.0717736557,
0.0201577283,
-0.0350319594,
0.0114996843,
-0.0067158481,
0.0103669586,
0.0032905976,
-0.0287442748,
0.0322095901,
0.0044042822,
0.0135515779,
-0.0062791132,
-0.033385355,
0.0240820218,
-0.0072024348,
-0.1020804942,
0.0346117727,
0.0380968079,
-0.0072145383,
-0.0039024742,
-0.0512470864,
0.0098644234,
-0.0018080611,
-0.0109235691,
0.0563696139,
0.0034866272,
-0.0342754722,
0.0322585441,
0.0037264437,
0.0639657453,
0.0121745337,
-0.0437411405,
0.0143199163,
0.065620251,
-0.0335234068,
0.0248685405,
-0.0488509201,
0.0139321946,
-0.0440647081,
-0.0478198044,
-0.0314054936,
0.0108321495,
0.030521797,
0.0191972088,
-0.0438437685,
0.0219753701,
-0.0278225467,
0.0012591115,
-0.0306667276,
0.0270344857,
-0.0677160695,
-0.0353735685,
0.0197049901,
0.0416740738,
0.000747294,
-0.0143358605,
0.035724055,
0.0022373106,
-0.0025233179,
0.0129331425,
-0.0127770836,
0.0115329213,
-0.0422129668,
-0.0892969966,
-0.0201314315,
-0.0224410426,
-0.0227818713,
-0.0360718779,
0.0149058867,
-0.0090842359,
0.0096007865,
-0.0250842813,
0.0098896911,
0.0027490177,
-0.0095760692,
-0.0387247875,
-0.0277207382,
0.0254804175,
0.0224383194,
0.0268719513,
-0.0278736819,
-0.0010855907,
0.0812285915,
0.0851354823,
0.0375471972,
0.0189055633,
0.0672334731,
-0.020858651,
-0.0230418742,
-0.0071785008,
0.0276890807,
0.0057625007,
-0.0382085927,
0.0608684346,
0.0318378806,
0.0257026926,
-0.0291673169,
0.0427906923,
0.0737113431,
0.0403497294,
0.0588032827,
0.0202304684,
0.0907386914,
-0.0004838172,
0.013308798,
0.0562609211,
0.0018306811,
0.0240554139,
0.0489485264,
0.0658576861,
0.0058143623,
-0.0144348936,
0.0000948988,
-0.0288846791,
0.0104183322,
0.0200311691,
-0.0302753542,
-0.0429515801,
-0.0046655876,
0.0066279806,
-0.0547355004,
-0.0437400974,
-0.0028398924,
-0.0812692866,
0.0591739342,
0.0437438115,
0.0643070266,
0.1126700789,
0.0493222028,
0.0096087372,
-0.0286051035,
-0.030037364,
0.0412106365,
0.0475240983,
0.0167987049,
-0.0190282054,
0.0476528257,
-0.0259722546,
-0.0211682096,
-0.0780957639,
-0.0180612803,
0.0235559978,
-0.0308182221,
0.01664811,
-0.0127982423,
-0.0160625055,
-0.0274389926,
0.0304944273,
-0.0475308113,
-0.0058070826,
-0.035426192,
0.0033227517,
-0.0172444619,
0.0076732426,
-0.0571329333,
0.0160802975,
-0.0006840053,
0.0002738449,
-0.004507673,
0.0312980376,
-0.0498149395,
0.0187308826,
-0.0407135859,
-0.0510170795,
-0.0243471377,
-0.0651342794,
0.0420029014,
-0.0538965054,
-0.0066322195,
-0.0410154201,
0.0048986641,
0.0174559727,
0.0420798883,
-0.0045457869,
-0.012014268,
-0.0236646924,
0.0565306246,
0.0044422047,
-0.0179437213,
0.0477865152,
0.0175534673,
0.0010949349,
-0.0506305769,
0.0470023826,
0.0377833098,
0.0395484939,
-0.0651988089,
0.0251741353,
-0.0117089739,
-0.0459101275,
-0.0298637878,
-0.0354031585,
-0.0203658659,
0.0299428105,
-0.0102557465,
0.0209205002,
-0.0304353088,
-0.0508231409,
0.0193912629,
-0.0135066286,
-0.0194434561,
0.0123085063,
-0.0270483997,
0.0190093778,
0.0232950337,
-0.0164113268,
-0.0168353189,
0.0253974479,
0.0193121061,
0.028512504,
0.1320562512,
-0.0355240107,
-0.0578814298,
0.053537529,
-0.031665016,
-0.0310876314,
-0.0110354871,
0.0043570786,
0.0177506376,
0.0319604613,
0.0649986789,
0.0108777164,
0.0134461559,
0.0000728639,
0.091207929,
-0.0602829233,
0.0116486168,
0.0021754797,
-0.0036930901,
0.0765936524,
-0.0077000377,
-0.0370445326,
0.0725692958,
0.0422594957,
0.0429069959,
0.0471429713,
-0.0288595576,
-0.042264279,
-0.0006127899,
-0.0168530215,
0.0221319571,
-0.0753351152,
-0.000955703,
0.0651890263,
-0.0199747477,
-0.0493900627,
0.068338573,
-0.0567419268,
0.0030287676,
0.005857545,
0.0385622606,
-0.0572448298,
0.0595095046,
-0.0100632655,
0.0251953155,
0.0198564995,
-0.0204521418,
-0.0342362374,
-0.0095411427,
0.0518962517,
0.0114388522,
0.0099849729,
-0.0377781764,
-0.0509685017,
0.0091932015,
-0.0290999059,
-0.0296171978,
-0.0071378076,
-0.0020479062,
-0.0043273563,
0.0809575468,
-0.0383842438,
-0.0260444544,
0.0356623754,
0.0485630259,
0.0296428371,
0.0155298254,
-0.0378724299,
0.0118875653,
0.005433016,
0.0536837131,
-0.021507632,
0.0048596715,
-0.0681612119,
0.0295428019,
0.027617963,
-0.0257079937,
0.0101633538,
0.0117017729,
0.0158475842,
-0.036923755,
-0.0247955974,
-0.0342405289,
0.0292853918,
0.0525187738,
-0.0499870479,
-0.0228793751,
0.0806039423,
0.0260501113,
0.0059608435,
0.0034103172,
-0.0301666148,
0.0446282886,
-0.0024905845,
0.0056266752,
-0.0143176271,
0.0131538045,
0.0144321118,
0.0176468473,
-0.0115278326,
-0.0359614827,
-0.0194334816,
-0.0388747416,
0.07414978,
0.0193991251,
-0.016111197,
-0.010938555,
-0.0173371565,
0.0119444327,
0.0576289631,
-0.0496778414,
0.0104330918,
-0.0196291804,
0.0015373387,
-0.0371957906,
-0.0770225301,
0.0118860714,
-0.0439343601,
-0.0229674019,
-0.0024041752,
0.0590016842,
0.0514256246,
0.0157697741,
0.0391704328,
0.0158040412,
0.0235147942,
0.0518150404,
-0.011793687,
0.0635555536,
-0.0142869512,
0.0218655318,
-0.0380054936,
0.0300558358,
0.0684839264,
-0.0877853185,
0.0194551963,
0.0219789445,
-0.0570743494,
-0.0550151169,
-0.0314856954,
0.0438961759,
-0.0123343682,
0.0397947989,
0.0767773017,
-0.0042205486,
-0.0362983942,
-0.0082952511,
0.0297446847,
-0.0660352409,
0.0301126409,
-0.0181022678,
-0.0523930565,
0.0217319988,
-0.0959124938,
-0.0492651686,
0.025773799,
0.0429283343,
0.0288544353,
0.0244552083,
-0.0184469596,
-0.0304763578,
-0.0428888462,
-0.0167473499,
0.0054933112,
-0.0287906714,
-0.0511318743,
-0.0178935397,
-0.0354001187,
-0.0544631034,
0.0162484758,
0.0648646578,
-0.0284122732,
-0.014189776,
0.0061146556,
-0.0172915664,
0.01620901,
-0.0021532308,
0.054582797,
-0.0312876739,
0.0564427376,
-0.0492518693,
-0.0273883585,
0.0381520689,
-0.0399845429,
0.0894456431,
0.0106109679,
-0.0268153697,
-0.0429076143,
-0.0329411142,
0.0079136286,
0.055894617,
0.0280794092,
0.0055063739,
-0.0128921811,
0.0205828808,
-0.0144852418,
-0.0369765274,
0.0095777744,
-0.0767176747,
-0.035557244,
-0.061209023,
-0.0277382601,
-0.031707637,
0.0241410621,
0.0022363092,
-0.0199142341,
0.0063378136,
0.0517240576,
-0.0638931915,
-0.0146490745,
-0.0628317818,
-0.019943336,
0.0001058722,
-0.0577994958,
0.0169590767,
0.0021613203,
-0.0109024383,
0.0233827885,
-0.0715040192,
0.0494807214,
0.0025807391,
0.0412795432,
0.0182715598,
-0.0163989533,
-0.0056523597,
0.0133451968,
-0.0584577993,
0.0031181804,
-0.002779105,
0.0087635098,
0.0319163762,
0.0052395137,
0.068619743,
-0.0391171537,
0.0143990563,
0.0188128464,
0.0314917266,
0.0219975505,
-0.0272047855,
-0.0485939905,
0.0280862246,
-0.0229347087,
0.0104605136,
0.0308205355,
0.0035947782,
-0.0090096248,
-0.0128889745,
-0.0453625321,
-0.0195757058,
0.0137052797,
0.0150233228,
0.0334006548,
0.0028499065,
-0.0384794511,
-0.0604328848,
0.0153479511,
0.0575412177,
0.0087472294,
0.0157549158,
-0.0108242678,
0.0374181084,
0.0087055899,
-0.006748579,
-0.0079390239,
-0.0133946547,
0.0080091134,
0.0045002624,
-0.0205364618,
-0.0506279059,
-5.320405349e-33,
-0.0389486551,
-0.0431602821,
0.0301872361,
-0.0202183612,
-0.0804992765,
-0.0157289524,
-0.0590753704,
0.0125869922,
0.0710417554,
0.0196568146,
0.0223275181,
-0.0102079688,
-0.0043610386,
-0.0176756289,
-0.0265201312,
-0.0044708843,
0.0783948004,
0.048631113,
-0.0826754048,
0.0174534172,
0.0345381424,
0.0353945494,
-0.0224029478,
-0.019516075,
-0.0354082249,
-0.0355427042,
0.00253226,
-0.056413997,
0.0579936728,
0.0309701003,
0.0186214484,
-0.0413064957,
0.0347142331,
0.0247739721,
-0.0291083455,
0.0255134385,
-0.0199067481,
-0.0413766019,
-0.0150691587,
-0.0452373847,
-0.0184947085,
-0.0435204282,
0.0352365971,
-0.0050727152,
0.0322302245,
-0.0473605022,
0.0507261641,
0.0171437766,
0.0086609051,
-0.0334871262,
-0.0819513053,
0.0087350551,
-0.0464834087,
-0.0352783352,
-0.001597201,
0.0340215601,
0.0407707766,
-0.030929178,
-0.0055540102,
0.038054131,
-0.015977364,
0.015391916,
0.0161268897,
-0.0082216989,
-0.0353932157,
0.0919478759,
0.027315028,
0.0296432693,
-0.0930665061,
0.0476787724,
-0.0205892008,
0.0356609188,
0.0169268735,
0.0057886392,
0.0166006982,
0.0249099489,
-0.0314995535,
0.0848215595,
-0.0714213029,
0.048314184,
0.0295715872,
0.0495178066,
-0.0332363211,
-0.00481688,
-0.0136094121,
-0.0111428183,
-0.0298700146,
-0.0358398892,
0.0278402865,
-0.0059840595,
0.022602709,
-0.0046852375,
0.001187079,
0.0444827601,
0.0311792269,
-0.0035880087,
-0.0777827799,
0.0716356337,
0.0008615155,
-0.0304061603,
0.0213312227,
-0.0088817934,
0.0367550813,
0.0390660875,
0.0690858141,
0.0096338559,
0.0101790475,
0.026600223,
-0.0230154824,
0.0017092142,
-0.0124712,
-0.0086195301,
0.0073191146,
-0.0705571547,
0.0141368285,
-0.0451011471,
-0.0248963684,
0.0084221698,
-0.0062414957,
-0.0162246134,
-0.0028330826,
-0.0470206179,
-0.0097102467,
0.0046375841,
-0.0060244487,
0.0401216261,
-0.002052915,
0.0133665828,
0.045645766,
-0.0416936465,
-0.0352465399,
0.0073038051,
2.58e-7,
-0.0101791555,
0.0148395412,
0.0298936628,
0.0246271603,
-0.0101269074,
-0.0160269421,
-0.0028182885,
-0.0222761035,
-0.013590836,
-0.0040661884,
0.0335016958,
0.0159383826,
0.0194097776,
0.0628656372,
-0.0313640088,
-0.0125413919,
-0.0407874435,
-0.0195678547,
-0.0625569448,
-0.0083701788,
0.0846744925,
-0.0676991493,
0.023377724,
0.0028241137,
0.0378208198,
-0.0093589816,
0.0442766435,
-0.0150938258,
0.0013656092,
0.0298932046,
-0.0172940511,
-0.0222949572,
-0.0258644912,
-0.0380252898,
-0.0301840939,
-0.0063218609,
0.033415772,
0.0437948294,
0.0059120604,
0.0428442955,
0.0396325365,
0.0010285315,
-0.0155026354,
-0.0258878842,
0.0159122273,
-0.0088496748,
-0.0319801643,
0.0172624458,
0.000721679,
-0.0015778999,
-0.0102928672,
-0.0109614255,
-0.0045696832,
0.0168318786,
0.003116189,
0.0335311517,
-0.0050356076,
-0.0087608928,
-0.0262703653,
0.0343637653,
-0.0240798984,
0.0176823195,
-0.0505838543,
-0.0106208371,
-0.0350542292,
-0.0701778531,
-0.0166149139,
2.43482854e-34,
0.0082507711,
-0.02100062,
-0.0188385993,
-0.0053608026,
0.0530341752,
-0.0001398856,
0.0257153288,
0.0009284623,
0.0282065682,
-0.0097086634,
-0.0292671081
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10071v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10071v2 | Large Language Models Are Reasoning Teachers | 2022-12-20T08:24:45 | 2023-06-13T10:55:29 | Namgyu Ho, Laura Schmid, Se-Young Yun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Recent works have shown that chain-of-thought (CoT) prompting can elicit
language models to solve complex reasoning tasks, step-by-step. However,
prompt-based CoT methods are dependent on very large models such as GPT-3 175B
which are prohibitive to deploy at scale. In this paper, we use these large
models as reasoning teachers to enable complex reasoning in smaller models and
reduce model size requirements by several orders of magnitude. We propose
Fine-tune-CoT, a method that generates reasoning samples from very large
teacher models to fine-tune smaller models. We evaluate our method on a wide
range of public models and complex tasks. We find that Fine-tune-CoT enables
substantial reasoning capability in small models, far outperforming
prompt-based baselines and even the teacher model in many tasks. Additionally,
we extend our method by leveraging the teacher model's ability to generate
multiple distinct rationales for each original sample. Enriching the
fine-tuning data with such diverse reasoning results in a substantial
performance boost across datasets, even for very small models. We conduct
ablations and sample studies to understand the emergence of reasoning
capabilities of student models. Our code implementation and data are available
at https://github.com/itsnamgyu/reasoning-teacher. | [
0.0303602163,
0.0826304704,
-0.0140718222,
0.0403062068,
-0.0423533916,
0.0292612966,
0.0467545316,
-0.0212700609,
-0.0070266826,
-0.0266524926,
0.0065290919,
-0.0162217207,
-0.0094842268,
0.035366904,
0.0208590236,
-0.0805379599,
0.0171757136,
-0.0791078582,
0.0192255005,
-0.0161461104,
-0.0190529041,
0.0275812298,
-0.0305136051,
0.0466585867,
0.0197895262,
-0.0292501841,
-0.040786963,
-0.0239037666,
0.006085115,
-0.0212165546,
-0.0222315099,
0.0707351789,
0.0425628498,
0.0231498796,
0.0000022034,
-0.0567248873,
-0.0103401029,
0.0021042791,
-0.0590549409,
-0.010679923,
-0.0236848984,
0.0407891609,
0.0065997206,
0.0317331217,
-0.0407579727,
0.0207735915,
0.0276651345,
0.0239973813,
0.05693423,
0.0388605706,
0.0159190055,
-0.0207169261,
-0.0018380033,
-0.0043796175,
0.0236246381,
-0.0353980437,
-0.0011237697,
0.0325870402,
0.0471421555,
0.0361568555,
-0.0087774936,
0.0048447461,
0.0679494813,
-0.0123867774,
-0.0259333234,
0.0508347489,
-0.0164822601,
-0.023142742,
-0.0110000856,
0.0641293004,
-0.0009909146,
-0.0347474739,
0.0021767318,
-0.0092893392,
0.0265556499,
0.0094089368,
-0.0528608486,
0.0505184494,
-0.0215240177,
0.0175737869,
0.0224162918,
-0.0067679919,
0.02931704,
0.016740771,
-0.0381436758,
0.0618593656,
-0.0194800086,
-0.0201193839,
0.0357025303,
0.0114082871,
-0.0149298394,
-0.0653620511,
-0.0195322949,
0.0455113277,
-0.0429756455,
0.0252941009,
-0.0123670986,
0.004419629,
0.002575638,
0.0432774164,
0.0328148417,
0.0560133457,
-0.0026647002,
0.068226777,
-0.0210089162,
0.0463664792,
-0.0157843456,
0.0332860798,
-0.0244726297,
-0.0024165721,
-0.0805201679,
-0.013260616,
-0.0430495255,
0.0247709826,
-0.015336182,
-0.0018709402,
0.0008248516,
0.0079015289,
-0.0093615139,
0.0161557589,
0.021437956,
0.0116165057,
0.0106559256,
-0.0337305926,
-0.0347359367,
0.0142296655,
-0.0653410554,
0.0204473808,
0.0730298907,
-0.0424854793,
-0.0272416435,
-0.0428956114,
0.0016055407,
-0.0354228429,
0.0253511015,
0.016847996,
-0.0170898046,
-0.0160770789,
-0.0374887548,
-0.0466851369,
0.0099037904,
-0.1006995365,
0.0057895463,
-0.0888971537,
0.0141089596,
0.028060453,
-0.0042173122,
-0.0218462143,
0.0126149477,
0.0179762263,
-0.0396133177,
0.0821255296,
-0.0071386462,
0.0210294984,
-0.0107100969,
0.0266232546,
-0.0359315015,
0.0655313358,
0.0328674316,
0.0119497925,
0.0056064031,
-0.0013783649,
0.0069694365,
0.0100836419,
0.0245124046,
-0.0068971128,
0.0074692913,
0.0216100812,
-0.0214168336,
0.0318018384,
-0.0194184557,
0.0472316071,
-0.0200908929,
0.0347549766,
0.0440701656,
0.0669616833,
-0.0090966355,
0.0205650665,
0.0609104447,
-0.0024414444,
0.0166084785,
-0.0212229472,
-0.0851386413,
0.0477247015,
-0.0442881733,
0.006500233,
0.0061545474,
0.0253258087,
-0.0283217821,
-0.0463224612,
0.0118936123,
0.0326707736,
0.0147332847,
0.035586901,
0.061214678,
0.0271906871,
-0.0126467133,
0.0288307723,
0.0297335107,
-0.0541758649,
-0.0209551472,
-0.0745356455,
0.0480507128,
0.0623710491,
0.0486781783,
-0.0058923601,
-0.0106671862,
-0.0171802994,
0.0408606753,
0.0008784167,
0.0426939279,
-0.0139152268,
-0.0154547784,
-0.0335081182,
-0.0354437046,
-0.0333424211,
0.015895877,
-0.0016141111,
0.0368250869,
-0.0107458103,
0.0006442842,
-0.0466473848,
-0.0185465384,
0.0195246432,
-0.0437029637,
0.0037193415,
-0.03455244,
0.0231177285,
0.0113781532,
0.0120870406,
0.0103671402,
0.015229498,
0.0073794443,
-0.0190082453,
-0.0026701491,
-0.0063274517,
-0.048967462,
-0.0245665964,
0.0271277372,
-0.0112360483,
-0.0209154971,
0.0153374933,
-0.0430224463,
-0.046004355,
0.0391774178,
-0.0013571606,
0.0079070162,
-0.0203754883,
0.0143585932,
-0.0155966096,
-0.022366764,
-0.0104544181,
0.0791973174,
0.0012902847,
0.0005250681,
0.0347630195,
0.0433391593,
0.0059169303,
-0.0435092077,
-0.0122368857,
0.0218919721,
-0.0096476451,
0.0067592901,
0.0028594371,
0.0411464907,
-0.0630910695,
-0.0332068093,
-0.072186254,
0.0082181189,
-0.0158332177,
0.011936198,
0.009671662,
0.0015867188,
0.0075471308,
0.0063461754,
-0.0409704186,
0.00907047,
0.010268433,
0.0248327982,
0.0169510078,
0.0004709816,
-0.0281507708,
-0.0131309889,
-0.0140568586,
-0.0322354138,
0.0492495894,
0.0143516902,
0.0255826619,
-0.0443888493,
0.0271319412,
-0.0285930615,
0.0253696293,
-0.0143629164,
-0.015974259,
0.058047276,
-0.0367724188,
0.0371883065,
0.0826540738,
-0.0147352787,
0.0353471376,
0.0629502386,
-0.011834234,
-0.0634140968,
0.0412245542,
-0.0007207522,
-0.0229727626,
-0.0161386877,
-0.0162519105,
-0.0408985876,
0.0712501034,
-0.0169686396,
-0.0053976323,
-0.0835281312,
0.0661991611,
0.0077088038,
0.0040468322,
-0.0470143147,
-0.0136852199,
0.0097909998,
0.0802984312,
-0.0227712039,
-0.0399896204,
0.0983041301,
-0.0208803751,
-0.0117122428,
-0.0324251018,
0.0073084473,
-0.0219449066,
0.1008455455,
-0.0079707289,
-0.0012586926,
0.0297733694,
0.0126141664,
-0.062084686,
0.0005076964,
0.0174863692,
-0.0321170203,
0.0291330628,
-0.0750002265,
-0.0092049371,
0.0012987887,
-0.056090489,
-0.0472621024,
0.0043505011,
-0.0743151829,
0.0255430732,
-0.0195402894,
-0.0281901807,
-0.0046463716,
-0.0137130404,
0.0465557948,
0.0365219973,
-0.0009094753,
-0.0218167622,
-0.0247882381,
-0.0051538483,
0.0466607176,
0.0100669302,
0.0294033065,
-0.03683367,
0.0690493137,
0.024445869,
0.0583446212,
-0.0005945954,
-0.0409539901,
0.0250592027,
-0.0026581883,
0.0093787694,
-0.0049723652,
0.0489293896,
0.0506780818,
-0.0784976631,
-0.0396637842,
0.1208599657,
0.0361594371,
-0.0325880013,
-0.0013770111,
-0.0292516313,
0.0669431835,
0.0384601988,
0.0248762034,
-0.0804015845,
-0.0491349995,
0.0446195193,
0.0032106533,
-0.0226724558,
-0.0512624159,
-0.0058048964,
-0.1299103796,
0.0489377081,
-0.0074729053,
0.0028890269,
-0.0013073802,
-0.0350511931,
0.0008751005,
0.0160388928,
-0.0243053269,
0.031053381,
0.0134199131,
0.0173619669,
0.0119386083,
0.0260584764,
-0.0365839452,
0.0827880949,
-0.0253585093,
0.0326721668,
0.0359896682,
0.0055255629,
0.0170457326,
-0.0622512512,
0.0330764167,
-0.0214514378,
0.0045254552,
0.0000402573,
0.0174953789,
0.0275012311,
-0.0159179568,
-0.0221345555,
0.0855546147,
-0.0357617773,
-0.0395304821,
0.0245891418,
0.1166298166,
-0.0208207425,
-0.0367831513,
-0.0066649849,
0.0023399706,
-0.0079859402,
0.0682109147,
0.0429506898,
-0.0453017317,
-0.0369363502,
-0.0548825711,
-0.0632662252,
-0.0407998152,
-0.0514036454,
0.0207042936,
0.051871933,
0.0254757628,
-0.032933712,
-0.0224907324,
0.0518432409,
0.0421994701,
0.0063096192,
-0.0079427781,
0.0196725,
0.0309107341,
-0.0095424503,
0.0513666421,
-0.0449046902,
0.0178700909,
-0.0469729677,
-0.0061710239,
-0.0149816563,
-0.0577276908,
-0.0278507508,
0.0125256572,
-0.0797464177,
-0.0597932264,
-0.0241473708,
0.0458739735,
0.036374975,
0.0334559865,
-0.0207626708,
-0.0407208763,
0.0068229972,
-0.0005762249,
-0.0155327925,
-0.0228041206,
0.0291704126,
-0.0133034503,
0.0154055124,
0.0422394797,
-0.0444787592,
0.0060260892,
0.0225824341,
0.0352802612,
-0.0175020434,
0.010206826,
0.0456004404,
0.0087290332,
0.0278197918,
-0.0018304156,
-0.0032924041,
-0.0560978092,
0.0212653745,
-0.0018969183,
-0.0356975235,
-0.0597033501,
0.023885686,
0.0103971269,
-0.0273481011,
0.0264374539,
-0.0657842681,
0.0196642037,
0.0365167037,
-0.0079810582,
0.0039821849,
0.0097045833,
0.0299734063,
0.0585235469,
-0.0382216536,
-0.0069439402,
-0.0001134761,
-0.0215379279,
0.0431358814,
-0.0070724552,
0.0949763581,
0.0443345532,
-0.0144584309,
-0.032188151,
0.0042006345,
-0.085377939,
-0.0904252827,
0.0237924885,
0.002392194,
0.0236569587,
0.020089874,
-0.0079666516,
-0.0565851405,
-0.0048851999,
0.0171632059,
0.040815521,
0.0365884416,
-0.0496291406,
0.0196567047,
0.0425644703,
0.0102077061,
-0.0212562047,
0.0497679673,
-0.007624926,
0.0432813056,
0.0145133957,
0.0032791786,
-0.0327182412,
-0.0378894471,
-0.0462809876,
0.0089712935,
0.0072832466,
0.0409184098,
-0.056969028,
-0.0629195124,
-0.0587362349,
0.0264504161,
-0.0136333928,
-0.0135831051,
0.0403197668,
0.0637009442,
-0.0443468317,
-0.0118638258,
-0.017200442,
0.0057939724,
-0.0118694147,
-0.0363651291,
-0.0259768907,
-6.511583365e-33,
-0.0087802913,
-0.0209126174,
0.0532606468,
0.0059741945,
0.0081604412,
-0.0204201732,
-0.0600859486,
0.0163607169,
-0.0381213017,
0.0291425567,
-0.0340842269,
-0.0011161388,
0.0001277383,
0.0179622136,
0.0270102341,
-0.0153098386,
0.01597693,
0.0026599928,
-0.0428509489,
0.0422754511,
0.0370263532,
-0.0119403647,
0.029650284,
-0.0365446731,
0.018845344,
-0.0068680262,
-0.0138768926,
0.0476449132,
-0.0884015262,
0.0397779681,
0.0020283978,
0.0005141951,
0.0282288454,
-0.0466468148,
0.0010475217,
0.018142309,
-0.0659441203,
-0.0124567794,
0.0362521447,
-0.0298532825,
-0.0686285421,
-0.0389878638,
-0.0053131115,
0.0023070078,
0.002895342,
-0.0365983211,
0.0141927507,
-0.040912658,
0.0160469618,
0.0163167417,
-0.0250515062,
-0.0028227433,
-0.0405602828,
-0.0500559509,
0.0142468037,
0.0558664612,
-0.0263668802,
0.0200433321,
0.0030543664,
0.0249523781,
0.0657272637,
0.008493552,
0.0752241462,
-0.0036948088,
-0.0001406464,
0.0577233844,
-0.0029821689,
-0.0100003332,
-0.0457727611,
-0.001946141,
-0.0055233161,
0.0657443479,
0.0684313551,
0.0098665152,
0.026902955,
0.042217169,
-0.071755074,
-0.0139117492,
0.0138933687,
0.0387749672,
0.0481411964,
-0.0168945324,
-0.0292271618,
-0.0236421172,
-0.0682624727,
-0.042411305,
-0.0510723516,
-0.0112577099,
0.0391371213,
0.0088626593,
-0.0302555952,
-0.0415613502,
0.022457134,
-0.0242561419,
-0.0121765118,
0.0478742979,
-0.015267483,
0.0105979852,
-0.0155563764,
0.0211317725,
-0.0359556153,
-0.0214243773,
0.0195030067,
0.0168072022,
0.0200444516,
0.0202905498,
0.0465871766,
0.0163240079,
-0.0424240157,
-0.0063618179,
-0.0971752107,
0.0406666771,
-0.0037105822,
0.0128543712,
0.0206496958,
0.0175384954,
-0.0165682212,
0.0298060644,
-0.0040177186,
-0.0343111418,
-0.0381241627,
0.0282278024,
-0.022979537,
-0.0023563365,
-0.0160219017,
-0.0220008362,
-0.0586512722,
0.0059307311,
0.0381756201,
-0.0319420025,
-0.0071916156,
0.0465878211,
2.809e-7,
-0.0077023627,
0.0348760001,
-0.0104292762,
0.0153183853,
0.0193137862,
0.0436439104,
-0.0242461953,
-0.0247488711,
0.0356580615,
-0.059599001,
-0.0289304163,
0.0676784888,
0.0646905899,
0.0356089845,
-0.0698200837,
-0.0095563335,
-0.0670094639,
-0.0333014987,
-0.0616482273,
-0.0145848542,
0.0628742054,
0.0692961589,
0.0312734582,
-0.0120777776,
0.0359166265,
-0.0253103804,
0.0143704871,
-0.0216563269,
0.0241265651,
-0.0056113666,
-0.0043485574,
-0.0004248791,
0.0152278701,
0.0292944815,
0.0140003869,
0.0036728529,
-0.0386748835,
0.0391749516,
0.0254600123,
0.0141604096,
-0.0207976624,
-0.0381614268,
-0.0007775451,
-0.0793928728,
0.0795814693,
-0.0549779609,
-0.0187918041,
0.0144370627,
0.0157834124,
-0.0441860184,
-0.0266860165,
-0.0183094777,
0.0196335241,
-0.0042938255,
-0.0113138258,
-0.0152294682,
0.0239859838,
-0.0638689846,
-0.0291030183,
-0.0091281822,
-0.0198417511,
-0.0514655039,
-0.0496293791,
-0.0159261338,
0.0123415701,
-0.0602218285,
-0.0036615301,
2.713694601e-34,
0.0185766425,
-0.0139726978,
0.0498859473,
0.0153845642,
0.0551825613,
-0.0050715329,
-0.0020025407,
-0.0060172938,
0.0458052345,
-0.0893279836,
-0.0290539805
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10060v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10060v2 | I Cast Detect Thoughts: Learning to Converse and Guide with Intents and Theory-of-Mind in Dungeons and Dragons | 2022-12-20T08:06:55 | 2023-05-30T23:09:37 | Pei Zhou, Andrew Zhu, Jennifer Hu, Jay Pujara, Xiang Ren, Chris Callison-Burch, Yejin Choi, Prithviraj Ammanabrolu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We propose a novel task, G4C, to study teacher-student natural language
interactions in a goal-driven and grounded environment. Dungeons and Dragons
(D&D), a role-playing game, provides an ideal setting to investigate such
interactions. Here, the Dungeon Master (DM), i.e., the teacher, guides the
actions of several players -- students, each with their own personas and
abilities -- to achieve shared goals grounded in a fantasy world. Our approach
is to decompose and model these interactions into (1) the DM's intent to guide
players toward a given goal; (2) the DM's guidance utterance to the players
expressing this intent; and (3) a theory-of-mind (ToM) model that anticipates
the players' reaction to the guidance one turn into the future. We develop a
novel reinforcement learning (RL) method for training a DM that generates
guidance for players by rewarding utterances where the intent matches the
ToM-anticipated player actions. Human and automated evaluations show that a DM
trained to explicitly model intents and incorporate ToM of the players using RL
generates better-quality guidance that is 3x more likely to fulfill the DM's
intent than a vanilla natural language generation (NLG) approach. | [
0.0881448388,
0.0233322866,
-0.0299214255,
0.0669482648,
-0.0437529795,
-0.0090779699,
-0.0262665842,
-0.032758642,
-0.0036295303,
-0.0465866141,
-0.0195991993,
0.0063179508,
0.0167774744,
-0.0085818265,
0.0267963484,
-0.0620884225,
0.0414168388,
-0.0191264264,
0.0018253531,
0.0370718762,
0.0059374222,
0.040573094,
-0.0466278791,
0.0520318933,
-0.01145765,
-0.0260123629,
-0.0643258169,
0.0026380855,
0.055876635,
-0.0605779849,
0.0344418623,
-0.023200348,
0.0060269237,
0.0093196938,
0.00000189,
-0.0426189974,
0.0005215157,
-0.0662173033,
0.0288396738,
-0.0406420343,
-0.0106324889,
0.0292082988,
0.0478860326,
0.0023448414,
-0.0875209421,
0.0016864521,
0.0385349914,
0.067824088,
0.0610166267,
0.0669632554,
0.0230128206,
-0.0250794403,
-0.0220247228,
-0.0146239288,
0.0367877893,
-0.0351705104,
-0.0113820396,
0.0248160288,
0.0064238627,
-0.0091850003,
0.0022247925,
0.0019269986,
-0.057828445,
-0.0285587236,
0.0191434603,
0.0178631879,
0.0544729605,
0.0157495476,
-0.010283757,
0.0545932651,
0.0548389219,
0.0123874154,
0.0500373989,
0.0107231708,
0.0227615703,
0.0155595625,
0.0155537901,
0.0048667723,
-0.01690544,
-0.0000980238,
0.0162488781,
0.0309858639,
0.0214782357,
0.0390808471,
0.0012126823,
0.0127308778,
-0.0479969531,
-0.0684725791,
-0.0114124287,
0.0200197045,
-0.0114756906,
-0.0564617254,
-0.0361305811,
0.0331896693,
-0.0747305974,
0.0145453075,
-0.0165247526,
0.0147907184,
0.0059753135,
0.0152198309,
0.0371989273,
0.0453470759,
0.0276050996,
0.0109645156,
0.0074033588,
-0.0070634969,
0.0252444223,
0.0145407226,
-0.016284572,
0.0353041887,
-0.0819276795,
0.0174493007,
-0.0557115935,
0.0613312684,
0.0080746897,
-0.0308347978,
-0.0456234179,
-0.0221229419,
-0.0149138449,
0.0326377749,
-0.0174678788,
0.0390677415,
-0.0231680684,
0.0222485885,
-0.0482473262,
0.0390079394,
-0.0416067354,
0.0125537245,
0.0382313915,
0.0071874424,
0.0075648185,
-0.0110872546,
0.0412707105,
0.0032001522,
0.0330374055,
0.0665553957,
-0.0083386265,
-0.0112264901,
-0.0302153137,
-0.0626953691,
-0.0149206361,
-0.0467936434,
-0.014511833,
-0.020594826,
-0.0136824753,
-0.0422217436,
0.0256466959,
0.0174706504,
0.0377419032,
0.0370413586,
0.025591949,
0.0563083775,
-0.0179009996,
-0.0052280775,
0.0225843787,
0.0198983587,
-0.030578237,
0.039130725,
0.0558114499,
0.0099407695,
-0.0160621312,
0.0186707973,
-0.0024244799,
-0.0033844116,
-0.0041466453,
-0.0547458604,
0.0066381916,
-0.0087946765,
-0.0225912016,
0.0883017778,
-0.0088847447,
0.0530315153,
-0.0350794084,
0.0328390002,
0.0370281301,
0.093433097,
-0.0026602985,
-0.0039595477,
0.0797991604,
0.0346043706,
-0.0208934285,
0.0127759324,
0.0086682187,
0.0050703064,
0.0343470313,
-0.0117981592,
0.0042944746,
0.0244072285,
0.0268420875,
-0.0418070443,
0.0048797056,
0.0128415637,
0.0350760035,
-0.0052343598,
0.0120613631,
0.005343697,
-0.0329016075,
0.0101308729,
0.0135197137,
-0.0426656455,
0.0203049872,
-0.0479639247,
0.0422436148,
0.0730480477,
0.0571808778,
-0.046863202,
-0.0443970598,
-0.0478828438,
-0.0257264785,
0.0652331114,
0.0095402468,
-0.029226657,
0.0061347587,
-0.0402974673,
-0.0105123864,
-0.0356098004,
0.0116493497,
0.0137158558,
-0.0431075618,
0.0048698517,
-0.0016882617,
0.0513326675,
-0.0117590129,
0.0387108587,
0.0224828795,
-0.0386301652,
-0.0236961506,
0.0286162067,
-0.0196559969,
0.0388735533,
-0.0190078523,
-0.015321916,
0.0147364875,
-0.0063232305,
-0.0216731858,
0.0134469448,
-0.04694473,
-0.0392916277,
0.0558674783,
-0.0635644421,
-0.0188753605,
-0.0068654101,
0.0085704802,
-0.0142172426,
0.0563317575,
-0.0589660145,
0.038577415,
0.0006026183,
-0.005095127,
-0.0009343262,
-0.0428968407,
-0.026550483,
0.0386438593,
0.0098505784,
-0.0067370236,
0.0060548922,
-0.0841626748,
0.0397297777,
-0.0297138076,
0.0399566591,
-0.0248964801,
-0.0340647958,
0.0252558682,
0.0480361767,
0.0616593957,
-0.0583318435,
-0.0255402382,
-0.0240640156,
-0.0083543099,
-0.0007597093,
0.0160428602,
-0.0045156954,
-0.0225093719,
-0.008157013,
0.0026036238,
-0.061898306,
0.0002467537,
0.0519387424,
-0.0480354428,
0.0638768896,
0.0194981266,
0.0128817298,
-0.0258603618,
0.0477674194,
-0.0344320312,
0.011701989,
0.0279817078,
-0.0448203757,
-0.0248240195,
0.01105054,
-0.0549135357,
0.0196855869,
-0.0222695749,
-0.079204008,
0.0565246791,
-0.0320054926,
0.0049438882,
0.0432818085,
0.0146755725,
-0.0050434261,
0.053105928,
-0.025060894,
-0.0298095327,
0.042587854,
0.0162719544,
0.0057839681,
-0.0318289734,
-0.0056724814,
0.0661198646,
0.0476885624,
0.0385858938,
0.0055512427,
-0.0857760534,
0.0468571298,
0.0147090284,
-0.0229282677,
-0.0174069293,
-0.0157272704,
0.0095181605,
0.0276883114,
-0.0023001914,
0.0097138137,
0.0793502629,
0.0143733704,
-0.0327300131,
-0.063787058,
0.0010334438,
-0.021461308,
0.0196996368,
-0.0281707849,
0.0449248627,
0.0559096485,
-0.0520970039,
-0.0340558439,
-0.0248935185,
0.0375296474,
-0.0112469532,
0.0606313981,
-0.0366589278,
-0.021003833,
0.0304379687,
0.0096455477,
-0.0424400568,
0.0094018057,
-0.0434095673,
-0.0430208668,
0.0170438308,
-0.0342627913,
-0.0403925218,
-0.0457599759,
0.0215655789,
-0.0030996487,
0.0256637577,
-0.0673450902,
-0.0253066327,
-0.0068434458,
0.0710570887,
-0.0093597788,
-0.0047114608,
-0.0150886178,
0.0655081347,
0.0408564135,
-0.0371397138,
-0.0220637619,
-0.0193042755,
-0.0176016446,
0.0169728938,
-0.0058896285,
-0.0051641776,
0.0578670353,
0.0199720133,
-0.0287476219,
-0.0216805618,
0.0856728926,
0.0343762152,
-0.0058526276,
-0.0008283192,
-0.0265984461,
0.0074042855,
-0.0004360992,
0.0016045546,
-0.1092148796,
-0.0235797595,
-0.0157695301,
0.0257061291,
0.0002190859,
-0.0512000099,
-0.0171847958,
-0.083703652,
0.0100594228,
0.0022288628,
0.0097017922,
-0.0114646861,
0.0436641462,
-0.0169102494,
0.009900799,
-0.0323010534,
-0.0238652416,
0.0000880167,
0.0315255336,
0.0514555722,
-0.0219411198,
0.0034844517,
0.0089236265,
-0.0500026159,
0.0772419497,
0.0843174085,
0.0797745362,
0.0437441096,
-0.0636112019,
-0.0476178601,
0.0511692166,
0.0098246941,
-0.035754174,
0.0429874212,
-0.0216754936,
-0.0039090454,
-0.0114691239,
0.0355669744,
-0.0348199084,
-0.0036857992,
0.0605099648,
0.0837974399,
-0.0211220924,
-0.0154672042,
-0.0012046536,
0.0676472262,
0.072610721,
0.0397053175,
-0.0240976159,
-0.0417627394,
0.0155481063,
-0.0125314444,
0.0087623252,
-0.0383031443,
-0.0695878789,
-0.0537713021,
0.0153624527,
0.1005261764,
-0.1008687541,
-0.0470702238,
0.0266155023,
0.0561758615,
0.0300382953,
0.0004922844,
-0.0174534842,
0.0347785801,
0.0186208468,
-0.0209985971,
-0.0345727615,
-0.013838361,
-0.0695291236,
-0.0565925092,
-0.0112736663,
-0.057617873,
0.0147085916,
0.0251781102,
-0.0291203838,
-0.0597138256,
-0.0494965687,
0.0474396907,
0.0143564856,
0.0188699756,
0.034022063,
-0.0193942301,
-0.0094927344,
-0.0131792808,
-0.0480438806,
-0.0050376477,
0.021459179,
0.0770786256,
0.0135693196,
0.0288766529,
-0.0198880937,
-0.002816556,
-0.0290500689,
0.0226359218,
-0.022915341,
-0.0410056412,
0.0091970395,
-0.0321749225,
0.0310191773,
-0.0322712213,
0.0207974557,
-0.0033653681,
-0.0246211588,
-0.0337053388,
-0.028275555,
-0.045893956,
-0.0026124183,
0.051082518,
0.0379947908,
0.0052000801,
-0.0433789566,
-0.0356172062,
-0.0133133531,
-0.0137859629,
-0.0004797305,
0.049567081,
0.0124749709,
0.0087548289,
0.0006418104,
0.0032266011,
-0.0092735579,
-0.0051584402,
0.0496365391,
0.0313821472,
0.097888492,
0.0468373075,
-0.0321854837,
-0.0220764745,
-0.0252108034,
-0.021343112,
-0.0560990721,
0.0615398288,
-0.009028147,
0.0345088169,
0.014538317,
0.0271067284,
-0.0362417847,
0.032066118,
0.0510582067,
0.0487738997,
-0.0081030391,
-0.0526842326,
-0.0135838883,
0.0026824195,
-0.0199893471,
-0.0226457734,
-0.001851295,
-0.052808214,
0.0343229547,
0.0196370408,
-0.0478408374,
-0.0622559153,
0.0170203522,
-0.0047022132,
0.06777668,
-0.0273758378,
0.0702464581,
-0.0809529424,
0.0226515941,
-0.0051692417,
0.0605462492,
0.0027347531,
-0.0474225171,
0.0379150957,
-0.0089468723,
0.0118623506,
-0.0334769413,
-0.0228805151,
-0.0003040643,
-0.0392644294,
-0.0233720839,
-0.0897041783,
-4.696764821e-33,
-0.0393084511,
-0.0281341653,
0.0374803618,
0.0432305001,
-0.0461147018,
-0.0115716197,
-0.038372878,
0.0173475537,
0.0107496418,
0.0412595496,
-0.0011116083,
-0.0011202112,
-0.0239758324,
0.0068539144,
0.0321551077,
-0.0511642583,
0.0048615159,
0.001366726,
-0.0278705154,
0.0459286869,
0.0564781018,
0.0176796634,
0.0498496294,
-0.0796644464,
0.0028821242,
0.045556251,
-0.0092211599,
0.018650664,
-0.0054396591,
-0.0135057038,
-0.0272546988,
-0.0085164839,
-0.0047739213,
-0.0167913213,
-0.0129265124,
0.0262006968,
-0.0176467337,
-0.0610195324,
0.0256744195,
-0.028686218,
-0.0328777134,
-0.012930328,
-0.024880236,
-0.0062404214,
-0.0055748001,
-0.0079761725,
0.0532246269,
0.0335400999,
0.0405865945,
0.006273244,
-0.0687422901,
-0.0359572284,
-0.0574058071,
-0.0761968717,
-0.0050737178,
0.0575074106,
-0.0096779028,
-0.0662340671,
-0.0423642807,
0.0356386788,
0.0472823568,
-0.009769652,
0.0058095232,
0.0438423492,
-0.0202395879,
0.0902603567,
0.0349413902,
0.0077623297,
-0.0416977145,
0.0195062552,
-0.0003743226,
0.0292295311,
0.0325141847,
0.0474695824,
0.005514509,
0.0147345178,
-0.0753958151,
0.0079644816,
0.0466774404,
0.0206491463,
0.0170833562,
-0.0175742917,
-0.021561861,
-0.0027409112,
-0.0028697641,
0.0034762793,
0.0314833634,
-0.0164915808,
0.008087337,
-0.0032026521,
0.0008123976,
-0.0436397791,
0.0117633874,
-0.034952946,
-0.0148479566,
0.0321451873,
-0.0492691845,
-0.0128460154,
-0.038343288,
-0.0327058136,
-0.0441573001,
0.0030425265,
0.0308061074,
-0.0125633543,
0.022893941,
0.0255804341,
-0.0170270633,
0.0403747,
-0.0327700302,
-0.0045399279,
-0.0250860639,
0.0764274374,
-0.0514951907,
-0.0214440729,
0.0155115714,
-0.0264217947,
-0.0337634012,
0.0019239711,
0.0071976851,
-0.069818221,
-0.0159441754,
0.0129666906,
0.0031461138,
-0.0120396083,
-0.0367594399,
0.0137407379,
-0.0511230379,
0.0311557781,
0.0411897525,
-0.027562337,
-0.0108655868,
-0.0359179005,
2.751e-7,
-0.0394383967,
0.025823595,
0.0125096235,
0.0168372747,
-0.0199134294,
0.0713890716,
-0.0242327023,
0.0335660651,
0.0362690166,
-0.0481340028,
0.0401342735,
-0.019320095,
0.0369209573,
-0.0226657987,
-0.0964697227,
-0.0045157899,
0.0019387174,
-0.0218306631,
-0.028413849,
-0.0093615688,
0.0467965156,
-0.013221655,
0.047429014,
-0.0178738683,
0.0294119623,
0.0348377973,
0.0071840533,
-0.0390944667,
0.0326897465,
0.0350118428,
0.0834603012,
-0.0630815625,
-0.0190410167,
-0.015158833,
0.0178498607,
0.0257563237,
-0.044272583,
0.0090338802,
0.0008653711,
0.0258009396,
-0.0167127401,
0.0182292666,
-0.0044091856,
-0.0187782701,
-0.0061995676,
-0.0382519029,
-0.0239429846,
-0.0017369998,
0.0154116219,
-0.0230729356,
-0.0381087884,
-0.0132037513,
-0.0484702736,
-0.0072143236,
0.0034566505,
0.0302254818,
0.0153806796,
-0.0781508684,
0.0182053335,
0.0089814756,
-0.0104803806,
-0.0177463852,
-0.0152393021,
0.0340803973,
-0.0468100496,
-0.0611763149,
-0.0097549902,
1.981888297e-34,
-0.0411465615,
-0.0192983896,
0.0053777345,
-0.0191679131,
0.0876268595,
0.0173801295,
0.0022660454,
0.0148771135,
0.0925763249,
-0.0166069344,
-0.0058464673
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10057v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10057v2 | WeCheck: Strong Factual Consistency Checker via Weakly Supervised Learning | 2022-12-20T08:04:36 | 2023-05-27T13:42:23 | Wenhao Wu, Wei Li, Xinyan Xiao, Jiachen Liu, Sujian Li, Yajuan Lv | cs.CL | cs.CL | A crucial issue of current text generation models is that they often
uncontrollably generate factually inconsistent text with respective of their
inputs. Limited by the lack of annotated data, existing works in evaluating
factual consistency directly transfer the reasoning ability of models trained
on other data-rich upstream tasks like question answering (QA) and natural
language inference (NLI) without any further adaptation. As a result, they
perform poorly on the real generated text and are biased heavily by their
single-source upstream tasks. To alleviate this problem, we propose a weakly
supervised framework that aggregates multiple resources to train a precise and
efficient factual metric, namely WeCheck. WeCheck first utilizes a generative
model to accurately label a real generated sample by aggregating its weak
labels, which are inferred from multiple resources. Then, we train the target
metric model with the weak supervision while taking noises into consideration.
Comprehensive experiments on a variety of tasks demonstrate the strong
performance of WeCheck, which achieves a 3.4\% absolute improvement over
previous state-of-the-art methods on TRUE benchmark on average. | [
0.0295851417,
0.0574521422,
0.0389604345,
0.0100528346,
-0.0417152829,
0.0245038141,
0.0137953823,
-0.0238426924,
0.0217388403,
-0.0067446944,
-0.0108736185,
-0.0453631617,
0.0227051675,
0.0171564072,
0.0721187294,
0.0058810744,
0.0435142145,
0.0093209101,
0.007265334,
0.0190618541,
0.0189788155,
0.0160649791,
-0.0164122898,
0.0249620061,
-0.0684188902,
-0.0132045522,
0.0117835151,
-0.0074423174,
0.023632504,
-0.0170423687,
0.0385563895,
0.0502225161,
0.0043421318,
0.0644075125,
0.0000018186,
-0.0224503446,
-0.0038726833,
0.0136011513,
-0.0194783844,
-0.036434304,
-0.0109840436,
-0.030246662,
0.0033787633,
0.0172730237,
-0.0131684775,
-0.0216729455,
0.0238972213,
0.0699481294,
0.1102017239,
0.0594327524,
0.0012526531,
0.0060781958,
0.000898005,
-0.0320697054,
0.0025688193,
-0.0338300653,
0.0128746275,
0.0263704322,
-0.0216313973,
0.007614274,
0.0060187788,
0.0242989752,
0.0574283712,
-0.0541776456,
-0.0114945704,
0.0525218435,
-0.054794319,
-0.0156976301,
0.0154367117,
0.0628526807,
0.0228323769,
-0.0476265587,
0.0091214711,
-0.0129584353,
0.0193554871,
-0.0341042727,
-0.004680336,
0.0161071885,
-0.0252944957,
-0.018965574,
-0.0111757917,
0.0075961365,
0.0167678576,
0.0384945609,
0.0417390838,
0.0330487005,
0.0239385851,
-0.0507524759,
-0.0091030942,
0.0240313374,
-0.0293843094,
-0.0757417008,
-0.0082887812,
0.0138388798,
-0.0694191977,
-0.0071573183,
-0.0864206776,
-0.0057265419,
0.0230603013,
-0.005460415,
-0.0001330074,
-0.0029881257,
-0.0537942797,
0.0530384667,
-0.0295564104,
0.0484630577,
0.0137127275,
0.0236095861,
0.0116876867,
-0.0083150743,
-0.0095673669,
-0.0105115138,
-0.0170036275,
0.026541274,
0.0169959683,
-0.0214580521,
-0.0518020466,
-0.0120920446,
-0.0338722318,
0.0382843874,
0.0225155856,
0.022539949,
-0.0451916717,
0.0240690727,
-0.0350682773,
0.0175591446,
-0.0667414069,
0.0419692174,
0.0510131717,
-0.0492763929,
-0.0134061994,
0.0391005464,
-0.0134121301,
-0.0196296964,
0.005970058,
0.0381433964,
-0.0353387594,
0.0060188016,
-0.076309815,
-0.0640681386,
-0.0562319718,
-0.0975129977,
-0.0354018509,
-0.0765814334,
0.0330603048,
-0.0495132022,
-0.0206874087,
-0.0287284777,
0.0035192908,
0.0139231393,
0.0041156383,
0.0430645347,
-0.0093465159,
-0.0295726135,
0.027045045,
0.0173509996,
-0.0049617006,
0.0239892248,
0.0068337433,
0.0202955734,
0.0454147384,
0.0627350509,
-0.034762077,
-0.0259147678,
0.0375910029,
0.0054047205,
0.031944897,
-0.0152742369,
-0.0161964428,
-0.0061418731,
-0.0037356906,
0.054724995,
-0.0348838568,
-0.0310649313,
0.0362266898,
-0.0412484258,
0.0157138444,
-0.0216744654,
0.0767638534,
-0.0083553158,
-0.0209522285,
0.0524390116,
-0.0515313558,
0.0325756632,
-0.0030647956,
0.0105587691,
0.057349138,
0.0368747786,
-0.0260828976,
-0.0558292009,
0.0072901929,
-0.0262674205,
-0.0614764355,
-0.0169068519,
0.0465037003,
0.0563097037,
0.0006142978,
0.04876801,
0.0414911695,
-0.0633338615,
0.0270886123,
-0.0166785996,
0.084499903,
0.0027583824,
0.0471269526,
0.0124030011,
-0.0323300995,
-0.0096460991,
0.0582791232,
0.0506521091,
0.0533387586,
-0.0308379997,
0.000761049,
-0.0295444615,
-0.0222354867,
-0.0276596453,
0.0334038325,
-0.0099557145,
0.0413042195,
0.0048152516,
0.059176147,
-0.0518397316,
-0.0189137626,
0.0323062055,
-0.0006624263,
-0.0214855429,
0.0087729171,
0.016226884,
-0.0013224555,
0.010643906,
-0.02927172,
0.0242264476,
0.0102254637,
-0.0035933191,
-0.0202151593,
-0.0193975717,
-0.0306577031,
-0.0420018472,
0.028801078,
-0.0196647048,
-0.0408903658,
0.0147495614,
-0.0513720401,
-0.0462059937,
-0.0027321347,
-0.0542390347,
-0.0652921274,
-0.0489825681,
-0.0189255979,
0.0339396819,
0.0092486339,
-0.0242424291,
0.0646279678,
0.0111738499,
0.007674403,
-0.0137966545,
0.0532531664,
0.0253680963,
-0.0286061093,
0.0196635704,
-0.0196768418,
-0.0288276654,
0.0051858774,
0.0657138899,
0.0268638805,
-0.0336519442,
-0.0473096371,
-0.0142446235,
0.0123290615,
-0.0335059613,
-0.0054116151,
0.0344571248,
-0.0101852976,
0.0284194443,
-0.014645719,
-0.0477716438,
-0.0163014065,
0.0457497351,
-0.0023784109,
0.0305238161,
-0.0083560133,
0.0421924256,
-0.0286870673,
0.0064354362,
-0.0212281421,
0.0339103676,
0.0647166297,
-0.0015107685,
-0.0652495325,
0.0096126422,
-0.0796356276,
0.0021383238,
0.0212016124,
0.0175328068,
0.0641351715,
0.0111335441,
0.0679467171,
0.0387312174,
0.0131999487,
-0.005779095,
0.0154049788,
-0.0128066652,
-0.0237923376,
0.0225456562,
-0.0277624093,
0.005045753,
0.0381214023,
-0.0301759839,
0.0060339691,
0.0183277968,
0.0194694102,
-0.0168144219,
-0.0262803007,
0.043034602,
-0.0206589829,
-0.0399318412,
-0.0192433223,
0.0257389545,
0.0036858507,
0.001738503,
-0.0504982807,
-0.0214563049,
0.0927681401,
-0.0515811928,
0.037906196,
-0.0149660576,
-0.0206768401,
-0.0083132023,
0.0057206694,
0.0106758224,
0.0053958474,
0.0147224618,
0.0351764522,
-0.0575745888,
-0.008814632,
0.0466872603,
-0.0073632617,
0.0217587743,
-0.0244528819,
0.0241059698,
-0.0164575167,
-0.060508769,
-0.0571273938,
-0.0412208289,
0.0392662287,
0.0150180403,
-0.0193949454,
-0.0375168435,
-0.0453286879,
-0.0124369385,
0.0500813797,
0.0467357151,
-0.0167162959,
-0.0274433102,
-0.0403883271,
0.0472881161,
0.0854091421,
0.0332943648,
0.0477685183,
-0.0294236355,
-0.0257377289,
0.0717977211,
0.0164053552,
0.0213465579,
-0.0159186795,
0.0013618042,
-0.0249807723,
0.027542334,
0.0209465381,
0.0124163954,
0.0542686582,
-0.0328041427,
-0.0656000003,
0.0902161822,
0.0118747177,
0.0228843298,
0.0104144812,
0.0251300912,
0.0587802008,
0.0303818882,
0.0135747474,
-0.0256697927,
-0.03475013,
-0.0214012768,
0.0672828183,
-0.0064946222,
-0.0444025472,
-0.0123281023,
-0.1070321724,
0.0266195871,
-0.0152865518,
-0.0322784595,
-0.0275724269,
-0.0310064852,
0.0183625408,
0.0021351867,
-0.0060134893,
0.0194528922,
0.0486996099,
0.0110215368,
0.0231641121,
0.0148528088,
-0.0447013527,
0.0089886589,
-0.0494778827,
0.0015997047,
0.0531717911,
0.0254721493,
0.0121396258,
-0.0394772366,
0.0196359381,
-0.0103419749,
-0.0478170365,
0.032017801,
0.0524728075,
-0.0017658761,
-0.028139811,
-0.0504694059,
0.0543601923,
-0.0203270987,
-0.0237667207,
-0.0000547464,
0.0431716219,
0.0138214519,
-0.0366721228,
-0.0060507865,
0.0228009541,
0.010146332,
0.0554099306,
0.0291230064,
-0.0089518009,
-0.0251439884,
-0.002120317,
0.0050771111,
-0.0490572304,
0.0029318542,
0.0224026386,
-0.0096694874,
-0.0194656607,
-0.0973018482,
-0.0381526649,
-0.0174952727,
0.0644600913,
-0.0412468836,
-0.0543645881,
0.0428656861,
-0.0630656183,
-0.0135099553,
0.0122593893,
-0.0466797836,
0.0269320831,
-0.0198640116,
-0.0267989356,
0.0174161624,
-0.0094987694,
-0.0092959935,
0.0711952597,
-0.083079122,
-0.0424838886,
-0.0303984284,
0.0543527752,
0.0086697889,
0.0264137015,
-0.0453370474,
0.0028458184,
0.0296004694,
0.0695360154,
-0.0394229554,
0.0510313846,
-0.0160806645,
-0.0574223436,
-0.0063330354,
0.0117172655,
-0.067534022,
0.0162215643,
0.0394930467,
0.052519165,
0.0109810662,
-0.0292412769,
0.032459002,
0.0201824475,
0.0228911974,
-0.0237742141,
0.0484907888,
-0.0371556282,
-0.0178103037,
0.0123935444,
-0.048998028,
-0.0037025104,
0.0343038961,
0.0050622625,
0.0002483097,
-0.0086084623,
0.0253895354,
0.0094960174,
0.0768234134,
-0.0401590317,
-0.0624165758,
0.017290486,
0.0300446376,
-0.0204445552,
-0.0491294265,
-0.0335762501,
0.022368256,
-0.0137293749,
0.0362288281,
-0.0085543012,
0.0220508352,
0.0580015704,
0.0076802582,
0.0152002368,
-0.0113757597,
-0.0695833266,
0.040860001,
-0.060623996,
-0.0050650514,
0.0068603284,
-0.0002246909,
0.0243741851,
-0.0276667606,
-0.0186124295,
-0.012837925,
0.013759763,
0.0431158245,
-0.0395582691,
-0.0083928676,
0.0160315614,
-0.0129482755,
0.0067504016,
0.0477594323,
0.0079927454,
0.0546695851,
-0.0215286855,
-0.0073596863,
-0.0559057742,
-0.0873304382,
-0.0503200367,
-0.011381072,
-0.0038298324,
0.0088489065,
-0.0000743563,
-0.0726571605,
0.0211938843,
0.0372193493,
0.0316177569,
0.0650125444,
0.0209994577,
0.0544143803,
0.0020874157,
-0.0061049834,
-0.0279340874,
-0.0072459038,
-0.0024855249,
-0.0033319008,
0.0076389494,
-6.311857324e-33,
-0.0465207808,
-0.0698659196,
0.0068194657,
-0.0562429763,
-0.0071532875,
0.0251425579,
-0.049126789,
-0.0368170924,
-0.0023255239,
0.0368885063,
0.0389739051,
0.035227932,
0.0034804123,
0.048451677,
-0.026292542,
-0.0123518584,
0.0593045503,
0.0361001939,
-0.0600925051,
0.04120088,
0.0576546676,
-0.0146418465,
0.012118049,
-0.0909375772,
0.0298979729,
-0.0070250183,
-0.0435467847,
0.017653143,
-0.0550697744,
0.0542889535,
-0.0119934827,
0.0130548347,
0.0051981458,
-0.010759647,
-0.0062729861,
0.0067797196,
-0.1003971547,
-0.040988721,
-0.0082127564,
-0.0320946611,
-0.064897798,
0.0124699408,
0.0303213801,
-0.0145389969,
0.0296703354,
-0.0053926678,
0.0202233009,
-0.0186837316,
-0.0044530854,
-0.0543251745,
-0.0413354523,
0.03719097,
0.0017749702,
0.0132822115,
-0.0870758817,
0.04737591,
0.002220873,
-0.0322646499,
-0.0440791883,
-0.0029504071,
0.0086300764,
0.0490582809,
0.0481833369,
0.0053099138,
-0.0359785073,
0.0453342795,
-0.0225876607,
0.009124795,
-0.0405118428,
-0.0554347113,
-0.0102874264,
0.0172135737,
0.0631806329,
0.1086604521,
-0.0032343925,
0.0246759187,
-0.0853223428,
0.0372839682,
0.0014514093,
0.0344372094,
0.0167189017,
-0.0314084627,
-0.0275814235,
-0.0084190881,
-0.0380359665,
0.0235195644,
-0.0474325903,
0.0038431541,
0.041469872,
0.0466031544,
-0.0249173082,
0.0030822535,
0.0023093338,
-0.0122967772,
0.0007313939,
0.0197673086,
-0.0380516648,
-0.0339739285,
-0.0081175379,
0.0112907402,
-0.0377716161,
-0.0108539993,
0.0569237433,
0.0416760817,
-0.0061160843,
0.0192767214,
0.0944476202,
0.0155293439,
-0.0347360559,
0.0292207282,
-0.0361256413,
0.0481043123,
-0.0044539534,
-0.0330902524,
0.0243235473,
-0.0332110152,
-0.0420143083,
0.0266259648,
0.003818895,
-0.0033540039,
0.0107439533,
-0.0000171144,
0.0185513161,
0.0331985019,
-0.0366468504,
0.0064266361,
-0.0368175246,
0.00619849,
0.0028306132,
-0.0666383952,
0.0237529445,
0.0276507977,
2.505e-7,
-0.0225848649,
-0.0111129889,
0.040131636,
0.0179620106,
-0.0277372096,
0.0270981509,
-0.0101358788,
0.0098979557,
-0.0582433343,
-0.0476549789,
-0.0258234255,
0.0336189196,
0.0480735824,
0.0557984449,
-0.017675994,
0.032023035,
-0.1103947014,
-0.0044530686,
-0.031439729,
-0.0264122542,
0.0655881166,
0.0896083564,
0.0382398628,
-0.0371036492,
0.0250863079,
-0.0584514812,
0.0617471002,
0.0824872255,
-0.0102211181,
0.0021834164,
0.0959609821,
-0.0130697461,
0.0284492727,
0.0340862162,
-0.0438530818,
-0.0361905508,
0.0283403601,
0.0307764467,
0.0278948061,
-0.0001676777,
-0.0078300824,
0.0122633334,
0.0523947403,
-0.0017741978,
0.0554702692,
-0.045123484,
-0.0070669898,
-0.0350781195,
-0.0198032055,
-0.0112448167,
0.0074075712,
-0.0339799449,
-0.0069183516,
0.0221634731,
0.0075886608,
0.0326388031,
-0.0075421403,
-0.0407926813,
-0.0418988578,
0.0109535782,
-0.0314278603,
-0.0296033025,
-0.0170143247,
0.023482915,
0.0282293539,
-0.0510324724,
0.0069962097,
2.273845507e-34,
0.0179116763,
0.0130953882,
-0.0018710999,
-0.060966216,
0.0687587038,
0.0073599573,
-0.0348382443,
-0.0181652382,
-0.0018271995,
-0.0164145362,
-0.0369273201
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10051v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10051v1 | A Framework of Customer Review Analysis Using the Aspect-Based Opinion Mining Approach | 2022-12-20T07:54:58 | 2022-12-20T07:54:58 | Subhasis Dasgupta, Jaydip Sen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Opinion mining is the branch of computation that deals with opinions,
appraisals, attitudes, and emotions of people and their different aspects. This
field has attracted substantial research interest in recent years. Aspect-level
(called aspect-based opinion mining) is often desired in practical applications
as it provides detailed opinions or sentiments about different aspects of
entities and entities themselves, which are usually required for action. Aspect
extraction and entity extraction are thus two core tasks of aspect-based
opinion mining. his paper has presented a framework of aspect-based opinion
mining based on the concept of transfer learning. on real-world customer
reviews available on the Amazon website. The model has yielded quite
satisfactory results in its task of aspect-based opinion mining. | [
0.0437779911,
0.0137610231,
-0.0173721164,
0.067146942,
-0.0347392373,
0.0213235747,
-0.0097783729,
-0.0079294797,
-0.0442238189,
-0.0479134358,
-0.0429088473,
-0.0123116933,
-0.0224863086,
0.0357577391,
-0.0743550286,
-0.0033122075,
0.0229025856,
0.0481605567,
0.0222274736,
0.0267978441,
0.01124724,
0.0262693875,
-0.0110265166,
-0.0287401099,
0.0175974313,
-0.00773119,
0.0394331925,
-0.0351563767,
0.0382243432,
0.0006733402,
0.015394045,
-0.0379378684,
-0.0517074428,
-0.06439358,
0.0000020189,
-0.006427485,
-0.0510341674,
-0.0153814591,
0.0390914306,
-0.0379619338,
0.0841976628,
0.0106311385,
-0.0038148263,
0.0032137297,
-0.062045332,
-0.0175150819,
-0.0106374864,
0.0912036821,
0.0710801408,
0.0605113022,
-0.0328116491,
-0.0232185498,
-0.051577054,
0.0353363454,
-0.0041628331,
-0.0520931706,
0.0199201051,
-0.0002738381,
-0.0331497826,
0.0424385667,
0.017021982,
-0.0120317433,
-0.0259520989,
-0.0082288431,
0.0251306072,
-0.004094942,
0.0469343327,
0.0516677722,
-0.0236863568,
-0.0025668268,
0.0572297461,
0.0284083672,
0.0002246865,
-0.0007082787,
0.0024773323,
0.0304904301,
-0.0016586754,
-0.0060361987,
0.0014396225,
0.0537250228,
-0.0048235608,
0.0523720533,
-0.0197788198,
-0.0342900679,
-0.0083166165,
0.0612491518,
-0.0233205259,
-0.0258013625,
0.0470695309,
0.0760640427,
0.0497409739,
0.0205001663,
0.0158682168,
-0.00480079,
0.02233948,
0.0225820933,
0.0332455225,
0.0581056252,
-0.017358236,
-0.0734818503,
0.0197455361,
-0.0423527844,
0.0033821317,
0.0291365534,
-0.0095259538,
-0.0418819152,
0.0588455237,
-0.026802253,
-0.0534465015,
0.0344058499,
-0.092051357,
0.0262682289,
0.0265220404,
0.081621781,
-0.0007104084,
0.0106642405,
-0.0636626855,
-0.0139337275,
-0.0098483749,
-0.0085804351,
0.0412703454,
-0.0060444539,
0.0427281372,
0.0135548022,
-0.0443465225,
0.0169470813,
-0.0132907676,
0.0499365628,
-0.0629503429,
0.0488836356,
0.0485004075,
-0.0017611973,
0.0284583606,
-0.0273230225,
-0.0090407217,
0.0054167486,
0.023402879,
-0.0408673175,
-0.0757087693,
0.0184120405,
-0.0091347983,
-0.0208194461,
-0.0243449043,
-0.0471515283,
0.0249670353,
-0.0140941786,
-0.0079738591,
0.0197963826,
0.0019674518,
0.0036855838,
-0.0265888236,
0.0100601241,
-0.060664501,
-0.0136191985,
-0.0203067195,
-0.0070733689,
0.0519429035,
-0.0150875933,
-0.0104510691,
0.0260964185,
0.0379386395,
-0.0054220445,
0.0123143299,
-0.0227086172,
-0.0210335348,
-0.0154245812,
0.0401590578,
-0.0173614416,
-0.0888680294,
-0.0724085495,
-0.0067956462,
0.0434578396,
0.027381815,
-0.0062984773,
0.0367259793,
-0.0428852513,
-0.0360851586,
0.0772635862,
-0.003481759,
0.0123835616,
-0.0270843115,
0.0243366752,
0.0536807217,
0.0170634072,
-0.0263054203,
-0.0207337085,
-0.0267605763,
-0.0076025813,
-0.0065615969,
-0.0505978763,
0.0140907671,
-0.0237167329,
-0.008164959,
-0.0106125595,
0.053220287,
0.021776272,
-0.0273767002,
-0.0234568864,
0.054520797,
-0.0361301489,
-0.0211528353,
-0.0085092932,
0.054983303,
0.0753675699,
-0.0162539165,
0.0058712983,
0.0079373335,
-0.0316023231,
-0.0957626998,
-0.0066113621,
0.0568436943,
-0.0366086736,
-0.055352211,
-0.0034664948,
0.0174413677,
0.0066930023,
-0.0032527335,
-0.0280360058,
-0.0593804754,
0.0678615719,
0.0036188937,
-0.0064842249,
0.0146078607,
-0.0129922098,
0.0037862053,
-0.0008054384,
0.0371434167,
0.0300235637,
0.0097235329,
0.0562895611,
0.0096310275,
-0.0110644968,
0.0545798652,
-0.045471441,
-0.0672268569,
0.0317478254,
0.0060205269,
0.0023655507,
0.0068801241,
-0.0284344032,
0.0376263969,
-0.0093921814,
0.0040272512,
-0.000198363,
-0.0175251607,
0.0112244077,
0.0223979298,
-0.0136957252,
0.0278905835,
0.0213960521,
-0.0017562812,
-0.00751642,
0.0526197813,
-0.0214521792,
-0.0077452334,
-0.0584484562,
-0.0516070537,
0.0100519359,
0.0265324842,
-0.0108187338,
-0.0297613535,
0.0238101743,
0.0041388511,
0.0260786526,
0.0051783849,
0.0097503457,
0.0153835667,
-0.0594502911,
-0.0189995822,
0.0233987346,
0.0485931821,
0.0089556007,
-0.0258839708,
0.0222753417,
0.0630515739,
-0.0160678104,
0.031983804,
-0.0571686663,
0.003578461,
0.0412713364,
0.0647400245,
0.0024127159,
-0.0171664637,
-0.0039350991,
-0.0124632996,
0.0038990353,
0.0180769674,
-0.0579294041,
-0.0525054596,
0.0723665953,
-0.0059862086,
-0.0293588657,
0.0102760941,
0.0036102422,
-0.0492055379,
-0.0300861858,
-0.0407103784,
-0.006025183,
0.0290447623,
0.0405211821,
-0.002423638,
-0.0242125932,
0.010551081,
0.0215633344,
-0.0820462853,
-0.0006736185,
-0.009515929,
-0.0278425515,
0.0699448287,
0.011242372,
0.0098696072,
-0.0275475103,
-0.0349318273,
0.0112472698,
-0.0251794867,
0.0071493816,
-0.0009685493,
0.0170257241,
0.0181809757,
0.0204920545,
0.0322256424,
0.0216760654,
0.0279444885,
0.0268654376,
0.0787348971,
-0.0793664455,
-0.0194659289,
-0.0286258124,
0.0163841769,
-0.0468289889,
0.0255167298,
0.0011934137,
0.0329664759,
0.0535780936,
-0.024384845,
-0.001566037,
0.0151249338,
-0.0068933773,
0.016265966,
0.0052036159,
0.0218352955,
-0.0285402462,
0.0290197302,
0.0097164791,
-0.0190796498,
-0.0161730107,
0.0270990077,
0.0069276094,
-0.0073623066,
0.0082219755,
-0.0415164232,
-0.0404164083,
0.0133526241,
-0.0294642057,
0.0442047082,
0.0215091463,
0.0567153357,
-0.0536416359,
0.0411832482,
-0.0387039855,
-0.01622032,
0.0630090088,
-0.0283605997,
-0.0148341982,
-0.0093334829,
-0.047986038,
0.0244990233,
-0.0116724027,
0.0079986434,
-0.0318326615,
-0.0191805139,
-0.0217267815,
-0.0140604256,
0.0393809937,
0.024788538,
-0.0517858975,
-0.0055025937,
0.0312039535,
-0.0752025098,
0.0040834867,
0.020779226,
-0.0397324301,
0.0027448644,
-0.0393980443,
0.0053232051,
-0.0032847505,
-0.0127749676,
0.0037035635,
-0.095740743,
0.0112792533,
-0.0172351543,
-0.0298066679,
-0.1099384949,
-0.0288029946,
0.0081108231,
-0.0255623385,
-0.0026814369,
-0.0192777086,
-0.0132270399,
0.0124584567,
0.0180552583,
-0.0215660911,
-0.0256606676,
0.0392384082,
0.0158469193,
-0.0027523793,
0.0311332867,
0.06239314,
-0.0219724029,
-0.0598313808,
-0.0127810119,
-0.0848986655,
0.0034011574,
-0.007405587,
0.0862838253,
-0.0574055053,
-0.0156551935,
0.0165994558,
-0.0200596023,
-0.0395779945,
0.0316827372,
0.0525479987,
0.0268450771,
-0.000696906,
-0.0544118807,
-0.001051501,
0.0069043729,
0.0295796618,
0.0451923609,
-0.0535706058,
-0.0818090513,
0.0066070366,
0.0059756692,
-0.0468085222,
-0.0079752486,
-0.0417631902,
0.0033828823,
-0.0287401062,
-0.043321263,
-0.1025479063,
0.0119343689,
-0.0233458709,
0.0672202483,
0.0364441387,
-0.014921098,
0.0634393916,
0.0326781161,
0.0037418199,
-0.0448782146,
0.016248839,
0.0210457463,
-0.0098633207,
0.0031020599,
0.1142416298,
0.00171282,
-0.0244045854,
-0.0520714074,
0.0147218518,
-0.018958699,
-0.0254740342,
0.0635733008,
0.0008585678,
-0.0107836947,
0.0038857393,
0.006229443,
-0.0285936873,
0.0307597872,
-0.0510041788,
-0.0364773199,
0.039754428,
0.0493907221,
0.0093948646,
0.0258858744,
0.0028365273,
0.043231599,
0.0244424492,
-0.0332152136,
-0.058219891,
-0.0306701921,
0.0130494265,
-0.0153163448,
0.0073467563,
0.0482998826,
-0.0286117513,
-0.0105575584,
0.0266907755,
0.0013756489,
-0.021847697,
-0.0374278873,
-0.0189998057,
-0.0123486621,
0.0195716117,
-0.0614788271,
0.0246355142,
0.0295375139,
0.0122602396,
-0.0150952386,
0.0577721931,
0.0284065995,
0.0313107818,
-0.0489447489,
0.0028861312,
0.0139497528,
-0.0915542692,
0.0366454795,
0.0170465931,
-0.0042008744,
0.035453327,
0.0219295472,
0.0094225658,
-0.0351552442,
0.0121831037,
0.0160444062,
0.0423302241,
-0.0386501402,
0.007165608,
-0.0399718992,
-0.0547444448,
0.0366861485,
-0.0435432568,
-0.0188523028,
-0.0069992119,
0.0166390184,
-0.0056992453,
0.0401510857,
0.0273670442,
-0.0004987028,
-0.016715806,
-0.0011583845,
0.0220828261,
-0.1001848131,
0.0166290253,
-0.0014797652,
-0.0484603271,
-0.0443915986,
0.0263238158,
0.0058856839,
-0.0192410238,
0.014503926,
0.0357808843,
-0.0656703562,
-0.0165326819,
0.0194497351,
-0.0262469947,
0.059363436,
-0.001780262,
0.0254848246,
0.0475129709,
0.0356621221,
0.0517977588,
-0.054632809,
-0.0014798138,
-0.0241540652,
0.0389072001,
0.0249706358,
-5.957848017e-33,
-0.0216749087,
-0.029687494,
-0.0509208217,
0.073629491,
-0.010655053,
-0.0304970089,
-0.0023950327,
0.0366162099,
0.0248675197,
0.0461697243,
0.0227341298,
-0.010724429,
0.0056988602,
0.0061044893,
0.0019909353,
0.0143660288,
0.0162336379,
-0.0018319095,
0.0174826775,
0.0320206918,
0.0498691387,
0.0310319364,
0.076591976,
-0.1517653912,
0.0121433074,
0.0165467896,
-0.0585246272,
0.0131619303,
0.0069146594,
0.0370228253,
-0.0073443786,
0.0365715958,
0.0150052914,
-0.0449697562,
0.0274318922,
-0.015041911,
-0.0383948311,
0.0244947542,
0.0135537256,
-0.0054800101,
0.0143278558,
-0.0045282631,
-0.0234117042,
0.0189651474,
-0.0077000367,
0.0158602186,
0.0352224559,
-0.0674059391,
0.0052035968,
-0.091523692,
-0.0630100667,
0.0191580858,
-0.0098152058,
0.0105582522,
0.0546903089,
-0.00002687,
-0.0110312104,
-0.0172521956,
-0.0030253285,
0.028831942,
-0.0110759456,
0.0267551038,
-0.0214346647,
-0.0511585362,
-0.0197421424,
0.0710881799,
-0.0222724043,
0.0092649069,
0.0281832386,
0.0391439125,
-0.0119075822,
0.0581369065,
-0.0273442436,
0.0399508402,
-0.0311930645,
-0.0628996342,
-0.0176394824,
0.0353926495,
0.0510269552,
-0.0232227985,
0.0835649744,
-0.01013852,
-0.0486423448,
-0.00644047,
0.0925416797,
-0.0467136502,
-0.0158975292,
-0.0255498495,
-0.0192897916,
0.0205701087,
-0.0701768398,
0.0153851593,
-0.0359302349,
-0.0629660264,
-0.0528545082,
0.0081472844,
-0.042047374,
0.0163313989,
-0.0186361633,
-0.0601196401,
-0.0494065769,
-0.0264898073,
-0.0826042965,
0.011963116,
0.0163674075,
-0.0306410361,
0.0735977367,
0.0077771232,
-0.0603842661,
-0.0225991085,
0.0236057751,
0.0076393057,
-0.0074368813,
0.066694811,
-0.0366780385,
0.0149781462,
-0.0290327966,
0.0755408183,
-0.0242453106,
0.047820732,
-0.0061434736,
0.026198836,
0.0203115437,
-0.0148317749,
-0.0281518288,
-0.0595923997,
0.025270192,
-0.0032537081,
-0.0274751056,
-0.0325324684,
-0.0334587768,
-0.009245418,
2.716e-7,
0.0321554281,
0.0349753648,
-0.0263311677,
-0.0532462336,
0.0330878645,
0.0519780144,
0.0130442968,
0.0032520934,
0.0425683446,
-0.0240542814,
0.0472272448,
-0.0026769103,
-0.0229221899,
0.044622995,
-0.0677238032,
0.0511561558,
0.0385927744,
-0.0330597721,
0.007426695,
0.0083608115,
0.0508403517,
0.0141527541,
0.0281818323,
-0.0172742642,
0.0002197936,
0.072211504,
0.0076780366,
-0.0441854745,
-0.0298420563,
0.0171187725,
-0.0401664712,
0.0016381639,
-0.0456856266,
-0.0265355315,
-0.0209412407,
0.021973446,
0.0471291989,
0.0310856365,
0.0427902974,
-0.0365651362,
0.0307573956,
0.0314027928,
0.0461841114,
0.0273931194,
0.0332330503,
-0.0486567765,
-0.0460799299,
-0.0954390615,
0.0032054356,
0.0296079498,
-0.0171573851,
0.0025834499,
-0.0213266816,
0.0390565619,
-0.0124810012,
-0.0257663094,
-0.0286498424,
-0.0428804196,
0.0584996603,
0.0722898096,
0.038052924,
-0.023011528,
0.041510582,
0.0034924867,
-0.0130487606,
-0.0212682355,
0.0560964979,
1.755416224e-34,
0.0247973166,
0.0173225291,
0.0008486818,
0.0292627569,
0.0046670474,
0.0006251547,
-0.0480809323,
-0.0288667157,
0.0158825424,
0.0086737778,
0.0207358412
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10047v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10047v2 | An Augmentation Strategy for Visually Rich Documents | 2022-12-20T07:44:25 | 2022-12-22T09:13:04 | Jing Xie, James B. Wendt, Yichao Zhou, Seth Ebner, Sandeep Tata | cs.CL | cs.CL | Many business workflows require extracting important fields from form-like
documents (e.g. bank statements, bills of lading, purchase orders, etc.).
Recent techniques for automating this task work well only when trained with
large datasets. In this work we propose a novel data augmentation technique to
improve performance when training data is scarce, e.g. 10-250 documents. Our
technique, which we call FieldSwap, works by swapping out the key phrases of a
source field with the key phrases of a target field to generate new synthetic
examples of the target field for use in training. We demonstrate that this
approach can yield 1-7 F1 point improvements in extraction performance. | [
0.0207996722,
0.0537795275,
0.0350146033,
0.0200558025,
-0.0054314858,
0.0213152543,
-0.0352073275,
0.0771967545,
-0.0242854822,
-0.0265558343,
-0.0344304144,
0.0367934741,
-0.0078814887,
0.0501563698,
-0.0072460147,
-0.0677494109,
-0.0106242169,
0.0188496243,
0.0055556297,
0.0435034819,
0.0124747688,
-0.0011812086,
-0.0092700617,
-0.026929073,
-0.0242599268,
-0.0188966095,
-0.0311834067,
0.0069316276,
0.0272103269,
-0.0051293923,
0.0019974343,
0.0365818441,
0.0135818776,
0.0267786216,
0.0000019925,
-0.0244196523,
-0.0256248415,
0.0576522127,
-0.0526940264,
0.0303107295,
0.0512321144,
-0.064697884,
-0.0160529651,
-0.0193417035,
-0.0231874548,
-0.0224725325,
0.0082153147,
0.1221215576,
0.0286713429,
0.0669981763,
-0.0519621223,
-0.0012192568,
0.040877644,
-0.0262644775,
0.0583410561,
-0.0659783632,
0.0145321554,
-0.0229213797,
-0.0047870846,
0.0219993852,
-0.0000533336,
0.024127027,
-0.0033624826,
-0.030094102,
0.0541168116,
0.0243807603,
-0.0468991362,
0.0316394381,
-0.0128115397,
0.0616764724,
-0.0471767932,
0.0468181483,
-0.013289541,
-0.0396517366,
0.0075231194,
-0.0079865949,
-0.0664620623,
-0.0099167079,
-0.0373547748,
-0.0277127456,
-0.0123011339,
0.0066830055,
0.0022457626,
0.0239547212,
0.0033685169,
-0.0223509781,
0.0001676609,
-0.0474014133,
0.0234137625,
0.027175406,
-0.0059446911,
-0.0284654666,
0.0310782865,
0.0255249832,
0.0540787578,
-0.005092816,
-0.0578415059,
-0.0723234713,
0.0120528378,
-0.0430906229,
0.0454645716,
-0.0076469821,
-0.0629969984,
0.0857113451,
-0.0471240394,
-0.0167584885,
-0.0486089513,
0.0081519466,
-0.0117010996,
0.0088182958,
-0.0176052041,
-0.0029629988,
-0.0305276252,
0.0147095369,
-0.091742672,
-0.0355697945,
0.0076305969,
0.0119625675,
-0.0346417055,
0.0222633798,
0.0305227451,
-0.0115239546,
-0.0216121413,
-0.0539863743,
-0.0091793006,
0.0037914813,
-0.0327941775,
0.0304202437,
0.010658551,
-0.0261086635,
-0.0023395484,
0.0266315453,
0.0862247422,
-0.0178167466,
0.018125847,
0.0453453362,
-0.0071787778,
-0.0095625045,
-0.0647801012,
0.0123576801,
0.037824139,
0.0060222168,
0.0181053318,
-0.0125442175,
0.040386077,
-0.0374836661,
-0.0463163815,
0.0288030505,
0.0023755641,
0.0024233849,
-0.0224099886,
0.069960162,
-0.0511029102,
-0.0163352769,
0.0317237452,
-0.0480182059,
-0.0125106508,
0.0355747454,
-0.0058467058,
0.0600247197,
0.042464193,
-0.0274091437,
0.0688343644,
0.0634713769,
0.0032264076,
-0.0247348882,
0.0283330996,
0.0192826632,
-0.0084092729,
-0.0114255855,
0.0593006164,
-0.0301394016,
-0.0652113929,
0.0178545024,
0.038121894,
0.0235507414,
0.0577420667,
0.0013233364,
-0.0138545092,
0.049166359,
0.0247931164,
0.0039268038,
0.0087069506,
0.0166620892,
-0.0127385892,
0.0401574261,
-0.0327191167,
-0.0190700646,
-0.0164993927,
-0.0272761527,
-0.0030634992,
-0.0183040947,
0.0017909058,
0.0001664078,
0.0688331947,
0.0608612821,
-0.0467586219,
-0.0121072419,
-0.0040839524,
-0.0526729859,
-0.0309091639,
-0.0018055608,
-0.0343052819,
0.0713456199,
0.0443616994,
-0.0593843274,
-0.0080376938,
-0.0030116241,
-0.0117539894,
0.0170951132,
0.063806057,
-0.0299145132,
0.0517605059,
-0.0504616387,
-0.0313245244,
0.0021720058,
-0.0216954295,
0.0222619958,
0.0256122835,
-0.0242282674,
0.019715609,
-0.0400354303,
-0.0519816279,
0.0392900854,
-0.0048505641,
-0.1013793796,
0.0356894471,
0.0410303473,
-0.0172323044,
0.0163333807,
-0.0245494116,
-0.0071117766,
0.0417229086,
-0.0199192055,
0.032071311,
0.0364179015,
0.0181044638,
0.0289638303,
-0.014578375,
0.0012256916,
-0.0435168259,
-0.0318233967,
-0.0905727595,
-0.0206914674,
-0.024677366,
-0.0081016961,
0.0162237082,
-0.0283854399,
0.0406834707,
0.0265193786,
0.0239830613,
-0.0345471837,
0.0577249154,
0.0345955901,
-0.018079808,
-0.0662797689,
0.0082047917,
0.0125812953,
-0.0300670508,
0.0544830486,
0.0051452545,
-0.0149781425,
-0.011136733,
0.0065850574,
0.0076697115,
-0.0515327677,
-0.0326329693,
-0.0634692833,
-0.0149140572,
0.0195857398,
0.0373065881,
0.0120100854,
0.0320786685,
-0.0265749078,
-0.0574968457,
-0.0450761616,
-0.0241381768,
-0.0186838787,
-0.0112218997,
0.0717533827,
0.0252333023,
0.0359020531,
0.0119070318,
-0.0042226017,
0.0267228261,
0.0026573311,
0.0460894667,
-0.0675576776,
-0.0391054451,
0.0094447033,
0.0447783954,
0.0346700624,
0.0048060524,
0.0312612467,
-0.0269381218,
-0.0307975039,
-0.0087770168,
0.0962065309,
0.0108532896,
0.0150853116,
-0.0271947682,
0.0189130548,
-0.0272837058,
-0.0016732545,
-0.022566719,
0.0688497052,
-0.0037403833,
-0.0095231282,
0.0460651219,
0.0012574776,
-0.0545194745,
0.0357804932,
0.0070230649,
-0.0276077259,
0.0406575277,
-0.0154054286,
-0.0331140533,
-0.0216587875,
-0.017016422,
0.0317616276,
-0.034920074,
-0.0257017631,
0.0246509388,
-0.0164778307,
-0.0231975634,
0.0046310211,
0.0076842136,
-0.0277853217,
0.0795988739,
-0.0013363197,
-0.0101994732,
-0.0252983049,
-0.0363469124,
0.0105944127,
0.0060355654,
0.0288062226,
-0.0364000238,
0.0192091297,
-0.0059730588,
0.0270927232,
-0.0607984662,
-0.0457515046,
-0.0436191,
-0.0212275684,
0.0328192487,
-0.0167100877,
-0.0108520025,
-0.039916344,
-0.071563825,
0.017385995,
-0.001257077,
0.1156224906,
-0.0287580807,
-0.0299440753,
-0.0019521824,
0.056293413,
0.0401723497,
-0.0137203857,
-0.0220962018,
-0.0233169366,
-0.0212196503,
0.0239098482,
0.0209417306,
-0.0106773935,
0.0078554824,
0.0038923342,
-0.0242814142,
-0.0239079501,
0.0169811957,
-0.051147338,
-0.0251869783,
-0.0734950528,
0.0086647421,
0.04508771,
0.0237440504,
-0.0223986097,
-0.0319064595,
-0.0096689053,
-0.0276581869,
-0.0024825665,
0.0723564327,
-0.0884280205,
0.0139460601,
0.0060840896,
0.0286271852,
0.0161224026,
-0.0180810746,
-0.0138355298,
-0.1255290657,
0.0782709867,
-0.0127215106,
0.0047338363,
-0.0343967676,
-0.0644249767,
0.0278812516,
-0.0121338964,
-0.0178825818,
0.0221563298,
-0.0206082109,
-0.0525310896,
0.0159556698,
0.0050745877,
-0.0455303378,
-0.0527643859,
0.0205378551,
-0.0688463598,
0.0490839295,
0.0332340114,
-0.0194389038,
-0.0615709461,
0.019256657,
0.0388851091,
-0.012986091,
-0.0228076056,
0.1227226406,
-0.0166457668,
-0.01961408,
0.0208427627,
0.0258668959,
0.0070061972,
-0.0176450796,
0.0381782465,
-0.0192350149,
0.0122302426,
-0.003416457,
-0.0081219971,
-0.051798556,
0.0021013343,
0.0287147313,
0.0088630896,
-0.0419512764,
0.0099448599,
-0.0127509357,
0.0092920493,
-0.0637129247,
0.0325245,
0.0029057804,
-0.0683149546,
-0.0291327909,
-0.0748620406,
-0.039695479,
0.0654539838,
0.0780411288,
0.0026685116,
-0.0074009048,
-0.0416085124,
-0.0128406743,
-0.0670294687,
0.0380297303,
-0.008807715,
-0.0148102613,
-0.0039959378,
-0.03017384,
-0.0195188057,
-0.0337908342,
-0.0319428816,
-0.0097350357,
-0.0228889864,
-0.0037263865,
0.0132714668,
0.0188067071,
0.015974341,
0.0412022397,
-0.0212416481,
-0.0339427441,
-0.0034205024,
0.0677206293,
-0.0407012738,
-0.0576467924,
0.0457717702,
-0.0401275158,
0.001770555,
-0.0136626866,
-0.043927107,
0.0611607917,
0.0221628286,
-0.0081412923,
-0.0018924722,
0.0347331874,
0.0292773023,
0.04787229,
0.006149496,
0.0116202822,
0.0317129977,
-0.0371209979,
0.0440964364,
-0.0239012446,
-0.0248312838,
-0.0214804541,
0.0203804374,
0.0106110163,
0.0143639483,
0.0257328134,
0.0544656925,
-0.0064541469,
0.0326511674,
-0.0481823981,
-0.0242931731,
-0.0036722135,
0.0366712026,
-0.0174884275,
-0.0138979554,
0.0061699413,
-0.0006093842,
0.0276056714,
0.0654033571,
0.0041908482,
0.0208653994,
0.0125689059,
-0.0000922859,
-0.0381147787,
0.013463377,
-0.061723467,
-0.0130069125,
-0.0513658673,
0.0659408197,
-0.0184392892,
-0.0953495204,
0.0348069631,
-0.0643479973,
-0.0289672166,
0.0009857879,
-0.0168253072,
0.0401722528,
0.0005743395,
-0.0270414241,
0.0350876413,
-0.0074455338,
-0.0029305399,
0.0258545727,
-0.0252453703,
0.0338486508,
-0.0422410294,
-0.0103598852,
-0.0714291856,
-0.0152546838,
0.0595089793,
0.0071824878,
-0.0157728009,
0.0245213062,
-0.0279816333,
0.0128459334,
0.0393252745,
-0.0319632441,
-0.0009779928,
0.0296727475,
0.0288859438,
0.049693346,
-0.012458737,
0.0149510317,
-0.0147846444,
0.0144776478,
0.0080379955,
-0.02338982,
0.0178696085,
-5.976683477e-33,
-0.0131385913,
0.001997733,
0.0005861743,
0.0241091922,
-0.0153461695,
0.0267907418,
-0.011659259,
-0.0552113429,
0.0161433257,
0.0258217603,
-0.0564588942,
-0.0278798752,
0.0570629127,
0.0317423418,
-0.0329664983,
0.0433271155,
0.0514634587,
0.0162981451,
-0.0261818394,
0.0054606628,
0.0123793399,
0.037193276,
0.0920128822,
-0.1099061593,
0.0129129402,
0.014552719,
-0.049481485,
-0.0033363239,
0.082052514,
0.0109184952,
0.0056115254,
-0.0013238508,
0.011794515,
-0.0275056679,
0.0051219785,
0.0487875491,
-0.1067003161,
0.0314634964,
-0.0354149602,
0.0418653749,
-0.0246599354,
-0.0078327367,
0.0376865789,
-0.0369402543,
0.0201781448,
0.0040536607,
0.0250347406,
-0.0598216839,
-0.041042231,
-0.0205418989,
-0.0813750848,
0.0424117595,
0.0226687696,
0.0245758221,
0.0716172084,
0.0203401577,
0.0055220686,
-0.0181038883,
-0.0246912986,
-0.0009180398,
0.0894215256,
0.0196908992,
0.016643865,
0.0256133638,
0.0439812243,
0.0299740899,
0.0180235449,
0.0274172518,
0.0346757211,
-0.0038335233,
0.0200618897,
0.0559370704,
-0.0056443079,
0.0345656872,
0.0987606272,
-0.0230539981,
-0.000938124,
0.0687043741,
-0.025743233,
0.0199481882,
-0.0061360006,
0.0045347144,
-0.0166215803,
0.028551586,
0.0311117657,
0.011386333,
-0.014237999,
-0.0013542931,
0.0230030175,
0.0544205867,
-0.0329402313,
0.0123766121,
-0.0072099143,
0.0014701113,
-0.0213977229,
-0.0013172565,
-0.0178280417,
0.0545918569,
-0.0122283967,
-0.0956112519,
0.0092615047,
-0.0435110517,
0.0214261413,
0.0202631168,
-0.0043999888,
0.0026659123,
0.0613742247,
-0.0396071672,
-0.0803015307,
0.0178502835,
-0.0128734261,
0.0291692819,
0.0339355469,
0.065121986,
0.01928268,
-0.0200606044,
-0.0313680656,
0.0201839171,
0.0089589888,
0.021895837,
-0.0193516109,
-0.0156716425,
0.0119929025,
0.0362930447,
-0.0067919823,
-0.0055768662,
-0.0106840003,
-0.0285727102,
0.0463058092,
-0.0311400667,
-0.0113964882,
0.0149569577,
2.647e-7,
0.0304561835,
0.0554741174,
0.0593594201,
-0.0132413153,
0.0195435397,
-0.0019238276,
0.0086258426,
0.0011273482,
-0.0281583555,
0.0106096016,
0.0604795702,
-0.0046420088,
0.0816491991,
-0.0202383026,
-0.0815265849,
-0.063397944,
-0.058124397,
-0.0439467095,
-0.0319514424,
-0.0082407454,
-0.0144244097,
0.0647587627,
-0.0005909242,
-0.0457334034,
0.0427183993,
-0.0140789924,
0.0299409162,
-0.0065935925,
0.0289028976,
-0.0157397892,
-0.0061551114,
0.0148054836,
-0.0446387418,
0.013044402,
-0.0332469307,
0.0119685475,
0.0194021296,
0.0595936775,
-0.0357480496,
0.049212724,
-0.0455399565,
0.0035503514,
0.0210093129,
-0.0020776652,
0.0232263021,
-0.0184198283,
-0.0202217121,
-0.0638868734,
-0.0725491717,
0.0487477481,
-0.014165814,
-0.0194491986,
-0.0149453934,
0.0310325809,
0.0364148021,
-0.0122925807,
-0.0398299769,
-0.0429281294,
0.0093555124,
-0.0157719571,
0.0225318484,
-0.0243585594,
-0.030819552,
0.006520234,
0.0126598794,
-0.0059503829,
-0.0280377325,
2.459953814e-34,
0.0323662087,
0.0267506931,
0.0089289052,
0.0573383979,
0.0122413235,
-0.0079107005,
0.0396876931,
0.0417105034,
0.0128873708,
-0.0506021716,
0.0126672676
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10039v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10039v1 | A Twitter BERT Approach for Offensive Language Detection in Marathi | 2022-12-20T07:22:45 | 2022-12-20T07:22:45 | Tanmay Chavan, Shantanu Patankar, Aditya Kane, Omkar Gokhale, Raviraj Joshi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automated offensive language detection is essential in combating the spread
of hate speech, particularly in social media. This paper describes our work on
Offensive Language Identification in low resource Indic language Marathi. The
problem is formulated as a text classification task to identify a tweet as
offensive or non-offensive. We evaluate different mono-lingual and
multi-lingual BERT models on this classification task, focusing on BERT models
pre-trained with social media datasets. We compare the performance of MuRIL,
MahaTweetBERT, MahaTweetBERT-Hateful, and MahaBERT on the HASOC 2022 test set.
We also explore external data augmentation from other existing Marathi hate
speech corpus HASOC 2021 and L3Cube-MahaHate. The MahaTweetBERT, a BERT model,
pre-trained on Marathi tweets when fine-tuned on the combined dataset (HASOC
2021 + HASOC 2022 + MahaHate), outperforms all models with an F1 score of 98.43
on the HASOC 2022 test set. With this, we also provide a new state-of-the-art
result on HASOC 2022 / MOLD v2 test set. | [
0.0899369866,
0.0268821325,
-0.0006202813,
0.0435500368,
-0.0103386613,
0.0354314595,
-0.0072995084,
0.0398718975,
0.0106872246,
-0.0358678512,
-0.0095746433,
-0.0240775757,
-0.0095388331,
0.0237081442,
-0.0117198275,
-0.0330892578,
0.0170769971,
0.0550863259,
0.0319048315,
-0.0259655081,
0.0608445369,
0.0383341387,
-0.0151389949,
0.0322329663,
-0.0696760044,
0.0313622728,
0.0354421176,
0.03236394,
0.03367313,
-0.015193495,
0.0614397004,
0.0588574074,
0.0087270783,
0.0484879389,
0.000001838,
-0.0596829094,
-0.0152709316,
-0.0156540498,
0.0205937773,
-0.0446888953,
0.0648784339,
0.0063605667,
-0.0158383939,
0.0514032133,
0.0079450896,
0.0544855446,
0.1081041396,
0.0390216894,
0.0772030875,
0.0982498601,
-0.0161557496,
-0.0442684442,
0.0048799706,
0.0317916125,
-0.0163377263,
0.0483667031,
0.0267564114,
-0.0540495701,
-0.0388752669,
-0.0177575406,
-0.0196516532,
-0.0073789824,
0.0103361476,
-0.0013991256,
0.0222082436,
-0.0296444595,
-0.0433596782,
-0.0218060426,
0.0475563928,
0.0544559211,
-0.0594674461,
-0.0323780961,
0.0012229913,
-0.0064404286,
-0.0515428744,
-0.0356329195,
0.0202296935,
-0.0150211854,
-0.043925181,
0.0658538714,
0.0119521795,
-9.891e-7,
0.0115801143,
0.0800044388,
0.0486868955,
-0.0247858223,
-0.0072519216,
-0.0315532908,
0.0013153072,
-0.0147129158,
-0.0322078094,
-0.0108631942,
0.0452484041,
0.0110288188,
-0.0114145698,
0.020062374,
-0.038860932,
-0.0806143507,
0.0289365128,
-0.1033071056,
0.0007019023,
0.0580415018,
-0.0667654499,
-0.0246969778,
-0.0048870323,
0.0452338047,
-0.0128388731,
0.0439185984,
0.0132178543,
-0.0174333379,
-0.0004915595,
-0.0054581286,
0.008564583,
-0.0156382341,
0.0041875555,
0.0418547466,
-0.06335859,
-0.0024315873,
-0.0164081268,
-0.0329950415,
0.0187131874,
-0.0016361636,
-0.0379610695,
-0.0160360504,
0.0136756264,
0.013586957,
-0.0423822887,
0.0076990584,
-0.055403851,
-0.0868353322,
0.0217850544,
0.0080860015,
-0.0157971904,
-0.0235163253,
0.0215777066,
0.0302077904,
-0.0087808911,
-0.0508162305,
-0.0557489246,
0.0186338741,
-0.0345967524,
-0.0409645401,
-0.0085625723,
-0.0580067486,
0.0142100621,
0.0087707341,
-0.0159023814,
-0.0347653143,
0.0176224485,
0.0274820831,
-0.0490929373,
0.0519736931,
-0.0020375645,
-0.0228609368,
0.0634443536,
0.0248210169,
0.0334629752,
0.0735690892,
0.0381192714,
0.0267821103,
0.0307681076,
0.0128308116,
-0.0017546553,
0.0767499357,
0.030728735,
0.0051187836,
-0.0492335334,
0.0341892019,
-0.093459703,
-0.0277149733,
-0.0153102074,
0.032734111,
0.020014286,
-0.0126274209,
0.0338440724,
0.0394235961,
-0.0323367342,
0.0233206134,
0.012725194,
0.0423747152,
0.008794345,
-0.0286991615,
-0.0226922669,
-0.012070463,
-0.0251792539,
-0.0430648141,
0.0387021564,
0.0555059426,
-0.018277863,
-0.0182978436,
-0.0335020125,
-0.0255343467,
0.0303851105,
-0.0537496768,
0.0450322703,
-0.0145144947,
-0.0369691998,
-0.0172025058,
0.066779159,
-0.0465947613,
0.019682413,
-0.0486366935,
0.0294902809,
0.0742125139,
0.0369804017,
-0.0245757867,
-0.0246888325,
-0.0573540218,
-0.0000275517,
0.0509178825,
0.0074829264,
-0.00757265,
-0.0003049696,
-0.0264552236,
-0.016929945,
0.0463745594,
-0.0060591018,
0.0059935539,
0.0524452254,
0.0299756043,
-0.0031509732,
0.0128334407,
-0.028826993,
0.0197944436,
0.0279782582,
-0.0165707674,
0.0023816358,
0.0149630168,
0.0705795661,
0.0153669221,
-0.0553987548,
-0.0821585283,
0.0078170374,
0.0104559315,
-0.034740869,
0.0423885956,
-0.0031515034,
-0.0338398293,
-0.0055370955,
-0.0162054002,
-0.0015906057,
0.0741686299,
-0.0154814003,
0.003918821,
0.0312323682,
-0.0255860128,
0.0033048035,
-0.0589965172,
-0.0035377159,
-0.0823559612,
0.0181761384,
0.0195552465,
0.0617030859,
-0.0200597197,
-0.0092432816,
-0.0034817678,
-0.0192798115,
0.0737448335,
0.0085431198,
-0.04509582,
-0.0104520796,
-0.0053296215,
0.0313533843,
0.0286826622,
0.0472137928,
-0.0262647551,
0.0029127384,
-0.0724600554,
-0.0016414251,
-0.0167678799,
-0.014639182,
-0.0004028082,
0.0402812548,
-0.0317382514,
0.0049204016,
0.0236033071,
-0.0511221625,
0.0785598457,
0.0265302323,
0.0297947824,
-0.0731191561,
-0.0017301877,
-0.0185016766,
-0.0061269579,
-0.0374862589,
0.0152686844,
-0.0087592201,
-0.0598274842,
0.0611737669,
-0.0491024591,
-0.0214065611,
0.0243584923,
0.0097904839,
-0.1061846465,
-0.0102671441,
0.0090147369,
-0.0023749736,
0.0203993563,
0.0414883383,
0.0646967143,
-0.0253484137,
-0.0148026515,
-0.0306250732,
0.0138714984,
0.0087567326,
0.0178088956,
0.003649804,
-0.0368802436,
-0.0045008827,
0.0495749116,
0.0180491526,
0.0204234775,
-0.0712257698,
-0.0243492983,
-0.0361411572,
-0.0187084787,
-0.0069122654,
-0.0354250818,
-0.050725963,
-0.0222806428,
-0.0216227043,
-0.0859175026,
0.0687591881,
0.0008713621,
0.0255042166,
-0.0754339024,
0.024515301,
0.0171225052,
0.013525553,
-0.0103046186,
0.0371707603,
-0.0364555903,
-0.019874204,
0.0226759519,
-0.0082879197,
-0.0112245334,
-0.0270024277,
-0.0311358385,
-0.0089319339,
0.0222363845,
-0.0021883459,
-0.0403383002,
-0.0467236042,
-0.0789899379,
-0.0153172975,
-0.0426845178,
0.0232750066,
-0.0295616798,
0.0180532932,
0.0376435965,
-0.0003831857,
-0.0365287289,
0.0018683462,
0.0277781915,
0.0390024036,
-0.0145555111,
0.0017744701,
-0.0219552536,
-0.0079818899,
0.0228064377,
-0.0122513939,
-0.0009605836,
0.0168482512,
-0.0159051381,
-0.0169290975,
0.0035189376,
0.0042237327,
-0.0269476306,
0.019879885,
-0.0287474524,
0.0305597391,
0.0503234975,
-0.0124870455,
0.0833081156,
0.0274151694,
0.0150129525,
-0.0227867514,
-0.0158873145,
-0.0181127414,
-0.0088087684,
0.0148956738,
-0.0685379356,
-0.0164955165,
0.0085223308,
-0.0017810088,
-0.0699333996,
-0.0270827916,
-0.0097959265,
-0.0733525679,
-0.0192829706,
-0.0239127297,
0.0198155697,
-0.0222896393,
0.0080005014,
0.0036734333,
-0.0033566242,
0.0078127012,
-0.0214898605,
0.0099712675,
-0.0044912444,
0.0497059859,
-0.0483083576,
-0.0196388792,
0.0207773615,
-0.0103309937,
0.0029440955,
0.0578314699,
0.0394805931,
-0.0700517744,
-0.0257476028,
0.019224342,
-0.0220515169,
-0.039990861,
-0.0577905923,
0.0547485352,
-0.0102010798,
-0.0413133614,
-0.017567087,
0.0201492961,
0.0326705985,
0.003677502,
-0.0342535302,
0.0198059287,
0.0438320301,
0.0137690594,
-0.0255320352,
0.0159846731,
-0.0103732552,
0.0270070657,
0.0124531034,
-0.0680308118,
0.0002900789,
-0.0375664495,
-0.0084706163,
-0.0645521581,
-0.0140472557,
-0.0236625578,
-0.0442411676,
-0.0536756143,
-0.0250479598,
-0.0318979882,
0.0381824635,
0.0056955079,
0.0248001423,
-0.0294789113,
-0.0262759551,
-0.0002910241,
-0.0240938012,
-0.023973735,
0.0010892572,
0.0539218336,
-0.0530933253,
-0.0105331019,
0.0110370535,
0.0027345985,
-0.0351473391,
-0.0210226048,
-0.0014766534,
-0.0332535207,
0.0490351357,
0.0594625995,
0.011800264,
-0.0123629626,
-0.0408657677,
-0.0625213087,
0.0814583153,
0.0667194799,
-0.0331814326,
-0.0235755388,
0.0448949598,
0.0303959306,
-0.0070788497,
0.0166199729,
-0.0389024802,
0.0245733652,
0.0112540228,
-0.0303145945,
-0.0018312061,
0.0137183564,
-0.0101906983,
0.0192820784,
0.0433002412,
-0.0210258048,
-0.0794945657,
-0.0443755649,
-0.0176708866,
0.0457925536,
-0.0248456504,
-0.013712097,
0.0077022947,
0.0156762134,
0.0124913072,
-0.0670797005,
-0.0082879895,
-0.0302780364,
0.0058670645,
-0.0211328957,
0.0490116999,
0.0541574731,
0.0712453946,
0.0156432688,
-0.0006693037,
-0.0350045152,
-0.0182099156,
0.0158478841,
-0.0492971949,
0.0012876468,
0.0504412428,
-0.0062899599,
0.0163840353,
0.0474200509,
0.0099778017,
0.0684213415,
0.0417193063,
-0.0766425952,
0.0111427121,
0.0131774787,
-0.0160332453,
0.0564704761,
0.0010842861,
0.0030342666,
-0.0352714546,
-0.0219559893,
-0.0552059524,
-0.0418800674,
0.0522515178,
-0.0020840256,
-0.0240499135,
0.0033099356,
0.0284634866,
-0.0066099907,
0.0374111123,
0.0614472292,
-0.0373459533,
-0.0327848978,
0.00937567,
0.053223405,
0.0179043114,
0.029559698,
0.0520089902,
-0.0081761554,
-0.0208585095,
0.033915557,
-0.0758134648,
0.0290021505,
-0.0102127921,
0.0302971285,
0.0533330552,
-0.0017480517,
0.0183597412,
-0.0133800227,
-0.0115370499,
-0.001445746,
-0.0509720109,
0.016996922,
-5.507128585e-33,
0.0002570627,
0.0057223691,
-0.0141095221,
-0.0161485095,
0.0217308253,
-0.034577433,
0.0171129052,
-0.0164695326,
-0.0249420144,
0.0214609019,
-0.0094989501,
0.0172060002,
0.0141651034,
-0.008868604,
0.002672567,
-0.0439668335,
0.0322875232,
0.0144651979,
-0.0228562616,
0.0124390228,
0.0754912719,
0.0117751099,
0.058841493,
-0.0071151438,
0.0292852074,
-0.0353393741,
-0.0342926756,
0.0251654703,
0.0366171747,
0.050377056,
-0.0419703871,
0.0764738098,
0.05495435,
0.013838904,
0.0158870667,
0.0425750464,
-0.0388240069,
0.0043855575,
0.0121955592,
0.0498848893,
0.004180972,
-0.0156486668,
0.0532625616,
-0.0015055436,
-0.0563606843,
0.0103603248,
0.0308331121,
-0.0122331604,
0.0265077595,
-0.0413866565,
-0.0817034319,
0.0534238815,
-0.0281689409,
-0.0408479571,
-0.0432580747,
0.0376062952,
0.0390699357,
0.0131798526,
-0.027187977,
-0.0213984475,
0.012103104,
-0.0219317395,
-0.0176428799,
0.0093056215,
-0.0197878871,
0.0408833884,
-0.0073525505,
-0.0513466299,
0.027105093,
0.0462905467,
0.0234129876,
0.0198209286,
-0.0021246392,
0.0339772291,
0.0239224732,
-0.1021027565,
-0.0511199012,
0.0334764197,
0.0593099259,
0.042342715,
0.0125817824,
-0.0375922062,
-0.0589868166,
-0.030069327,
0.0512164533,
-0.0423005037,
-0.0219595339,
-0.0330667272,
0.0363265052,
-0.0281494893,
0.0023908759,
0.0209747627,
0.0440524258,
-0.0077613313,
0.02943624,
0.0422950424,
-0.0361660346,
0.0135284504,
0.0155470828,
0.0736687705,
-0.0541821793,
-0.0401257873,
0.0007155719,
-0.0084473621,
0.0030466591,
-0.0010651915,
0.0684285164,
0.0259902589,
-0.0918520093,
0.0282404274,
-0.002888252,
0.0541962609,
-0.030774178,
0.0831215307,
-0.013278109,
0.0168183595,
-0.0179180019,
-0.01640095,
0.0332299396,
-0.0000359383,
-0.0020196305,
-0.0245008953,
-0.0187264811,
-0.0273478068,
0.0125343511,
0.0148246307,
-0.0009522008,
0.012540766,
-0.0483088419,
-0.0819137618,
0.021811774,
-0.025089886,
2.596e-7,
-0.0050605508,
0.0591945238,
0.0288278311,
-0.0510564335,
-0.0156476703,
0.0125268232,
-0.0137217017,
0.0287366584,
-0.0264166594,
0.0535629876,
-0.0221746825,
-0.0034996816,
0.0191499256,
0.0343349054,
-0.0397386253,
0.0059290794,
-0.1247492582,
0.0201933701,
-0.0517563336,
0.0226439238,
-0.037909165,
0.0565549619,
0.0811044872,
-0.0434350409,
-0.0363127775,
-0.0483418033,
0.0161203481,
-0.0221706554,
-0.0053610671,
0.0067411442,
0.0497291535,
0.0148199284,
0.0191321094,
-0.0338041335,
0.0051346552,
0.0267831795,
0.0111156376,
0.0501829609,
0.0060452693,
0.0322775133,
0.0157559291,
-0.0349661261,
-0.005875173,
-0.028178487,
0.0500307567,
0.0545267053,
-0.0297503714,
0.0165526308,
-0.0075730323,
-0.0174270738,
0.0467287749,
-0.0486924164,
-0.0319648311,
-0.0286203828,
0.0265870374,
-0.0492589213,
-0.0260533784,
-0.0513846017,
0.008090212,
-0.0232219771,
-0.0157895945,
-0.0507747792,
-0.0058647324,
0.0196615122,
0.0453616679,
0.0083386358,
0.072667338,
1.833854643e-34,
0.0565884449,
-0.0381138846,
-0.0119444886,
-0.0152981477,
0.0239373464,
0.0190440081,
0.0382320732,
-0.0137827192,
0.0453958362,
-0.024793366,
0.0028230955
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10029v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10029v3 | Do language models have coherent mental models of everyday things? | 2022-12-20T06:54:04 | 2023-06-08T17:27:44 | Yuling Gu, Bhavana Dalvi Mishra, Peter Clark | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | When people think of everyday things like an egg, they typically have a
mental image associated with it. This allows them to correctly judge, for
example, that "the yolk surrounds the shell" is a false statement. Do language
models similarly have a coherent picture of such everyday things? To
investigate this, we propose a benchmark dataset consisting of 100 everyday
things, their parts, and the relationships between these parts, expressed as
11,720 "X relation Y?" true/false questions. Using these questions as probes,
we observe that state-of-the-art pre-trained language models (LMs) like GPT-3
and Macaw have fragments of knowledge about these everyday things, but do not
have fully coherent "parts mental models" (54-59% accurate, 19-43% conditional
constraint violation). We propose an extension where we add a constraint
satisfaction layer on top of the LM's raw predictions to apply commonsense
constraints. As well as removing inconsistencies, we find that this also
significantly improves accuracy (by 16-20%), suggesting how the incoherence of
the LM's pictures of everyday things can be significantly reduced. | [
0.0776097327,
0.1000689194,
-0.0197442006,
0.0499184281,
-0.0206187516,
0.0037822535,
-0.003023881,
-0.0044068177,
0.0100969356,
-0.0618474856,
-0.0015279416,
-0.0307769943,
0.0060039721,
0.0043748314,
0.0068049957,
-0.074819535,
0.0456793159,
0.024122294,
0.0100013437,
0.0061803679,
0.0046940311,
0.0230073761,
-0.0074262684,
0.0228320789,
-0.048458267,
-0.0060975663,
0.0047127535,
-0.0089881569,
0.0201831628,
-0.0111486362,
0.0216765683,
0.0542584695,
0.0016308174,
0.0254315548,
0.0000020594,
-0.0651550442,
0.0301116426,
-0.0503412597,
-0.0140586225,
0.0245246999,
-0.0179314669,
-0.0386909023,
0.0146008469,
-0.0280707367,
-0.0333163403,
-0.0117318388,
0.0233000908,
0.1076645702,
0.0486834645,
0.0507947877,
-0.0164917652,
-0.0375393815,
0.0078260498,
-0.0119259581,
0.0540261567,
-0.0207761247,
0.0307815224,
0.0260635465,
-0.0227676779,
-0.0306794979,
-0.0107958307,
0.0159938578,
0.0513786636,
0.0473717004,
-0.0159553327,
0.0655445009,
-0.0684721023,
-0.0479116291,
0.0061060241,
0.1167619452,
-0.0186864454,
-0.0446386412,
-0.0050273873,
-0.0415790342,
0.0045324867,
0.0200637151,
-0.0136338267,
0.0189474821,
0.0170137528,
0.0421583056,
0.0026415852,
-0.0103599383,
0.0110284789,
0.0402043909,
-0.007634853,
0.0714348629,
-0.0179965831,
-0.0314654522,
0.0160496123,
0.0200973935,
-0.0663135275,
-0.044895865,
-0.0013919491,
0.0204059985,
0.0186919328,
0.0181653835,
-0.0466666147,
0.012960284,
0.0012154625,
-0.0387391672,
0.0117213456,
0.0275461487,
-0.0407580808,
0.0591403432,
-0.014080978,
0.0615437292,
0.0017724412,
0.0352622159,
-0.0287584458,
-0.0007236668,
-0.0436215438,
-0.0070226062,
-0.0291287955,
0.0425837114,
-0.030864859,
-0.0242530406,
-0.0150697064,
0.0021988556,
-0.0169820394,
0.0325491242,
-0.0090018278,
0.0190214887,
-0.0024885989,
-0.0460441075,
-0.0698354319,
0.0099285906,
-0.0409249738,
0.0483972542,
-0.0276675913,
-0.051626116,
-0.0178244729,
-0.0126640033,
0.0078639612,
-0.0240805019,
-0.0045644469,
0.0203258563,
-0.0006424481,
-0.0205744077,
-0.022762794,
-0.0377315097,
-0.0101334937,
-0.0737793595,
-0.0111828735,
-0.0436210148,
-0.0001250638,
-0.0105180135,
0.0246580578,
-0.0521348342,
0.0134302555,
0.0152329048,
-0.0472459868,
0.0874909014,
0.0146086756,
0.0099158911,
-0.0122319479,
0.0611369982,
0.0552215502,
0.0518481471,
-0.0072651776,
-0.0123809408,
0.0098361764,
-0.004400833,
0.002965431,
0.0138673689,
0.0431364104,
-0.0173896719,
-0.0155848004,
0.0368530005,
0.0223140121,
0.0450198054,
0.0250135586,
0.0570177995,
0.0064972229,
-0.0336411856,
0.0879713595,
0.0125253359,
-0.0409349911,
0.0464519821,
0.015234231,
0.021835072,
0.0412712172,
0.0476739109,
-0.08920113,
0.0210908633,
-0.0515887998,
-0.0078533636,
-0.0156468321,
0.0339360498,
-0.0631055385,
-0.0194852185,
-0.0240103006,
-0.0124265552,
0.0011667968,
-0.0154078566,
0.0246069785,
0.0127635635,
-0.0130915483,
0.0651562735,
0.0285778232,
-0.05514016,
-0.0025845156,
-0.0120174345,
0.0203619003,
0.0135491379,
0.0307499785,
-0.0321805626,
-0.0446339361,
0.0311548654,
0.0133638876,
0.0507541373,
0.0625391826,
0.007223648,
0.0299325306,
-0.0274029672,
-0.0045915535,
0.0040284228,
0.0319656432,
-0.0278175473,
0.0286706537,
0.0184036084,
0.0178294573,
-0.0154712433,
0.0200107954,
0.0427528508,
0.0086149657,
-0.0182128698,
-0.0269526467,
0.0181515533,
-0.0002581603,
-0.0193247311,
0.0080752913,
-0.0019101402,
0.0223608278,
-0.0266602561,
-0.0016689854,
0.0420232601,
-0.0755844042,
-0.0526339747,
0.0243090801,
-0.0287081674,
-0.0507958382,
0.0618541129,
-0.0573244542,
-0.0435204245,
0.0114022205,
0.0015794932,
0.0528189428,
-0.0575625524,
-0.0211751927,
-0.0122363837,
-0.0040996419,
0.0108758099,
0.0927262381,
-0.0292471703,
0.0157614909,
-0.023925731,
-0.0249231998,
0.010031946,
-0.0239378922,
-0.0176836085,
-0.0257706083,
-0.001662916,
0.0219421964,
0.0113706877,
0.038386859,
-0.0493857823,
-0.005982277,
-0.0884337798,
-0.0404510237,
-0.0036386065,
-0.0184438005,
0.0284990799,
-0.011880138,
-0.0018578286,
-0.0432709083,
-0.0393585414,
0.0558838919,
-0.0090073831,
0.0244441777,
0.0411551483,
-0.0067906724,
0.0125168571,
-0.0243866127,
0.0209408682,
-0.0260837022,
0.02648931,
-0.0076709758,
0.018082317,
0.0046399813,
0.0450154021,
-0.0824301913,
0.0332304537,
-0.0030089214,
-0.0149703547,
-0.0084613645,
-0.0055511529,
0.0454049334,
0.0478096977,
-0.0283768177,
0.02637868,
0.0653597042,
-0.0312074292,
-0.0411311761,
0.0167593528,
-0.013143817,
0.0093733715,
-0.0084288688,
-0.0109734563,
-0.0136164678,
0.0808543116,
0.0093724439,
-0.0184579175,
-0.0815537795,
0.0853462219,
-0.003105853,
-0.019205125,
-0.0625466108,
0.0131984539,
-0.0002893095,
0.0692662895,
-0.0386204608,
-0.0378018357,
0.0830349922,
-0.0073945811,
0.0045537357,
0.0065922746,
0.0236310363,
-0.0179113261,
0.0588510856,
0.0255050212,
0.0101691792,
0.0538621955,
-0.0025519854,
-0.0944574922,
-0.0041846968,
-0.0049600583,
-0.0393721871,
0.0378718004,
-0.0701207072,
0.0158087201,
-0.0104621546,
-0.082116127,
-0.0563165955,
-0.0623244531,
-0.0430199653,
-0.0131910155,
-0.0393303186,
0.0070315115,
-0.0435916185,
-0.0078125466,
-0.0030097209,
0.0329632685,
0.0126081379,
-0.012392927,
-0.0225649644,
0.0487046316,
0.0761332363,
0.0436040945,
0.0209497921,
0.0164854601,
-0.0079919752,
0.0261432603,
0.0021542388,
0.0178932268,
0.0100327916,
0.0414888337,
-0.0180064254,
0.0146836126,
-0.016648842,
0.0210109968,
0.0535855219,
-0.0322494283,
-0.0500955395,
0.1173816472,
0.0493277498,
-0.0034632129,
-0.0045975274,
0.0172350481,
0.0047033918,
0.0266825501,
0.0147394119,
-0.0742215142,
-0.0427115299,
-0.0008926744,
-0.0412146635,
0.000400756,
-0.045982495,
-0.0173267033,
-0.1150079072,
-0.0046175704,
-0.0000572895,
-0.0411351174,
-0.0443140976,
-0.0019968981,
-0.0185872018,
-0.0139871268,
0.0167589802,
-0.0215793122,
-0.0021867154,
0.0065048421,
-0.0357585959,
-0.0291733611,
-0.0623762608,
0.0526955687,
-0.0320585482,
0.0571840368,
0.0340956636,
0.0346235074,
-0.0156938303,
-0.0654296651,
0.0350170508,
-0.0072680265,
-0.0183980558,
-0.0131366458,
-0.0101620443,
0.0077378415,
-0.0304400958,
-0.0511246882,
0.0311838984,
-0.0416729748,
-0.0391969904,
-0.0125640156,
0.0978191644,
-0.0038240973,
-0.0506679118,
-0.0211145505,
0.0106039979,
-0.0145606315,
0.1223049462,
0.0420538895,
-0.0344470888,
-0.0341687128,
-0.0343200937,
-0.0052324855,
-0.0068358826,
-0.0290206652,
0.0224038363,
0.0451848507,
0.0374499336,
-0.07067357,
-0.0553815514,
0.0380482711,
0.003340428,
0.0090859169,
-0.0517723672,
0.0477397814,
0.0075621586,
-0.0545538515,
0.0317840055,
-0.0446107388,
-0.0313440152,
-0.0076165521,
-0.000056299,
0.0189403277,
-0.0352195129,
-0.0200809184,
0.0077980915,
-0.0879091471,
-0.057016056,
-0.0074370154,
0.0481800847,
0.0288122371,
0.0484952927,
-0.0231395382,
-0.0545391329,
0.0180301908,
0.0421425812,
-0.0081509091,
0.0404302441,
-0.0056720176,
-0.0196171049,
0.0268398728,
0.0562690087,
-0.0229408648,
0.0455382243,
0.0388220809,
0.020345334,
-0.048236344,
-0.0160037391,
0.0440526679,
-0.0092615858,
0.052445069,
0.0194715634,
0.0374841653,
-0.0414639935,
0.0035587871,
0.0040229992,
-0.0174640995,
-0.025778383,
-0.0111527424,
0.0467051789,
0.0183701664,
-0.0282590855,
-0.0044097723,
-0.0116003687,
0.0512988456,
-0.0301748384,
-0.0766247287,
0.0350842439,
-0.002736141,
0.0077356412,
-0.0178136714,
-0.0260088164,
0.0493403263,
-0.0228549689,
0.0348010808,
-0.0067663486,
0.0495500304,
0.0228903014,
-0.0046999985,
0.0076954584,
-0.0327346586,
-0.0369940586,
-0.0357850865,
-0.0268070977,
0.0007174974,
0.0410552695,
-0.0483008958,
0.0105413785,
-0.0236491151,
-0.0051817293,
-0.0247183777,
0.0314756259,
0.016572902,
-0.0144808087,
0.0531707481,
0.0151142934,
-0.0119389044,
-0.0077513484,
0.0700634867,
-0.0013245614,
0.0637360215,
0.0320357159,
0.0017580584,
-0.0245099124,
0.0065593575,
-0.0041604717,
0.0375666656,
-0.006362719,
0.0795406476,
-0.0780495852,
-0.0464911647,
0.0140089951,
0.0099849468,
0.0096497182,
0.0038519499,
0.0056512034,
0.041706413,
0.017527435,
-0.0291494597,
0.0182678979,
-0.0049656611,
-0.0617110133,
-0.0112819271,
-0.0297255293,
-7.131548637e-33,
-0.0325580575,
-0.0217644721,
0.0122447042,
-0.0127246464,
0.0057930122,
0.0154673923,
-0.0445840135,
-0.0094956914,
-0.0384967588,
0.0326543786,
0.0036614344,
0.0329759791,
0.0010640169,
0.0282068439,
0.0142724961,
-0.0213611126,
0.0284899008,
-0.0072058789,
-0.020261893,
-0.0046423459,
0.0378828682,
-0.0013421372,
0.0598584078,
-0.0222108532,
-0.0024171616,
-0.0182556268,
-0.0245513152,
0.0398057513,
-0.0379398316,
0.0466773622,
-0.0594232529,
0.0388317779,
0.0520892963,
0.0160303619,
-0.0014669145,
0.0163216554,
-0.0972696692,
-0.0727069825,
0.037936531,
0.0059720282,
-0.0401915722,
0.0055933692,
0.0213782117,
-0.00909111,
0.0018943676,
0.0041625183,
0.0437396653,
-0.0076299612,
0.0286189932,
-0.0156552978,
-0.0555841736,
-0.0185211692,
0.0070586065,
-0.010075436,
0.0148874326,
0.0207942557,
-0.0126719102,
0.0075990409,
-0.0750072077,
0.0155937187,
0.0313774645,
0.024494445,
0.0197988581,
-0.0190447718,
-0.0005549421,
0.0631169826,
-0.0217515025,
-0.0144465407,
-0.0741591603,
0.0267696101,
0.0556737892,
0.0367472507,
0.0428678654,
0.0361348391,
0.0559420064,
-0.0092403265,
-0.0726029649,
0.0097016515,
-0.028150836,
0.0308239069,
0.0163446702,
0.0053342162,
-0.035088852,
-0.0125629166,
-0.0411995128,
-0.0187318157,
-0.0572844446,
0.0124459611,
0.0207732022,
0.0254871007,
-0.0056582182,
0.0196282603,
0.0127873812,
-0.0141457655,
-0.0043056407,
-0.0216050707,
-0.0166681036,
-0.0271377396,
0.0111009488,
0.0290513337,
-0.0943205953,
-0.0273870006,
0.0224524718,
0.0205818545,
0.0216538087,
0.0391636826,
0.066034779,
0.0032335152,
-0.0581659973,
-0.0158265717,
-0.0276902951,
0.0080385078,
-0.0087360814,
-0.0159233417,
0.0475687198,
0.0297897961,
-0.0225339234,
-0.0019775413,
0.0164510068,
-0.0290292595,
-0.0591747016,
0.0254764799,
-0.0143309366,
0.0329189077,
0.0107855219,
-0.0290401205,
-0.02208017,
-0.0381890163,
0.0376916751,
-0.0321870409,
-0.0062108599,
0.0424734727,
2.721e-7,
0.0122973556,
0.0509189479,
0.0018344577,
0.008609565,
0.0273773465,
0.0448795632,
-0.0163697358,
0.0399916433,
-0.0273669045,
-0.0556255914,
0.0140238041,
0.0457450934,
0.0462392829,
0.0222610161,
-0.0571364872,
0.0489006825,
-0.0770498365,
-0.0194963347,
-0.0410671085,
-0.0142910471,
0.0786053017,
0.0848290846,
0.0439627096,
-0.0113588609,
-0.0001508841,
-0.037643414,
0.0719242096,
-0.0472348854,
0.0078677824,
-0.007588678,
0.0098516522,
0.0610125586,
-0.0186986625,
0.0459589846,
0.0139029957,
0.0132747749,
0.0205354635,
0.0418253466,
0.000729063,
-0.0086657302,
-0.0395987965,
0.0055804998,
-0.0186074916,
-0.0784038678,
0.0864423439,
-0.0773055926,
-0.0092149843,
0.0026978843,
0.0094229318,
-0.0165190771,
0.0343149826,
0.0042206375,
-0.0118790669,
-0.029509306,
0.0092406655,
0.0043865638,
0.0011220877,
-0.0785847157,
-0.0340533406,
0.041375339,
-0.0057953154,
-0.0219446756,
-0.0324413031,
-0.037533965,
0.0164007787,
-0.0813544095,
-0.0006489718,
2.343742651e-34,
0.0121819908,
0.0121202618,
0.0245972518,
-0.0046928232,
0.0087545943,
-0.0075341244,
-0.0076327338,
-0.0064393394,
-0.0040347409,
-0.07186497,
0.0186065547
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10025v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10025v2 | When Federated Learning Meets Pre-trained Language Models' Parameter-Efficient Tuning Methods | 2022-12-20T06:44:32 | 2023-06-02T12:58:07 | Zhuo Zhang, Yuanhang Yang, Yong Dai, Lizhen Qu, Zenglin Xu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | With increasing privacy concerns on data, recent studies have made
significant progress using federated learning (FL) on privacy-sensitive natural
language processing (NLP) tasks. Much literature suggests fully fine-tuning
pre-trained language models (PLMs) in the FL paradigm can mitigate the data
heterogeneity problem and close the performance gap with centralized training.
However, large PLMs bring the curse of prohibitive communication overhead and
local model adaptation costs for the FL system. To this end, we introduce
various parameter-efficient tuning (PETuning) methods into federated learning.
Specifically, we provide a holistic empirical study of representative PLMs
tuning methods in FL. The experimental results cover the analysis of data
heterogeneity levels, data scales, and different FL scenarios. Overall
communication overhead can be significantly reduced by locally tuning and
globally aggregating lightweight model parameters while maintaining acceptable
performance in various FL settings. To facilitate the research of PETuning in
FL, we also develop a federated tuning framework FedPETuning, which allows
practitioners to exploit different PETuning methods under the FL training
paradigm conveniently. The source code is available at
\url{https://github.com/iezhuozhuo/FedETuning/tree/deltaTuning}. | [
0.0243571438,
0.0898401737,
-0.0236761104,
0.0459761694,
-0.0250124838,
0.0001433129,
0.0844697282,
-0.0222286806,
0.0135724815,
-0.0342208892,
-0.0906912982,
-0.0285753645,
0.0304475166,
0.0219356865,
-0.0080494769,
-0.0283302274,
0.0464451052,
-0.0070217177,
0.002390547,
-0.0152044408,
-0.0508169718,
0.0035421916,
0.0086836703,
0.0130662806,
0.0081332037,
-0.0351809934,
-0.0141413249,
0.0057257605,
0.0130754812,
0.0179635752,
0.0446971916,
0.0709013715,
0.0220520534,
0.074698925,
0.0000021133,
-0.038284488,
-0.0459944755,
0.0437531099,
0.0010031244,
0.0820612907,
0.0110229123,
-0.0037010403,
0.0155777913,
0.038859956,
-0.0451525673,
-0.0445147008,
0.0294815656,
0.0279784109,
0.0398295522,
0.1136556119,
-0.0075746244,
-0.0341706909,
-0.0006949653,
-0.0451902151,
-0.1254091561,
-0.0469545014,
-0.004446202,
-0.0252815057,
-0.0390335247,
-0.0144347697,
0.005315572,
0.0224706698,
0.0038875979,
0.052450601,
-0.0335649438,
-0.0100867907,
-0.0556575246,
-0.0356546864,
-0.0397601984,
0.0486216471,
-0.0018985718,
-0.0082984073,
0.0056090197,
-0.0416709781,
-0.0020052642,
0.0188132282,
0.0114835296,
0.0148936613,
0.0062688375,
0.0246937536,
0.0057626991,
-0.0148885911,
0.0401620194,
0.0235015973,
0.0116097098,
0.0809453279,
-0.0231963135,
0.0081085023,
-0.01504754,
-0.033651568,
-0.0174331572,
-0.05762133,
0.0651584864,
0.0167490896,
-0.001692642,
-0.014943053,
-0.0708215386,
-0.0748233721,
0.0192964897,
-0.0257189311,
0.026807379,
-0.0021911699,
0.024290042,
0.0503956713,
-0.00811058,
-0.0116788577,
-0.0068196212,
0.0484530628,
-0.0072116698,
0.0427052006,
-0.0483582728,
0.0064550908,
-0.0118409386,
0.0488030687,
-0.0503091961,
-0.0160475522,
0.0108655635,
0.0320397466,
0.0112527823,
0.0014613926,
0.0029106706,
-0.011810448,
-0.0266831536,
-0.0140150143,
0.0087277181,
0.0247454289,
-0.0230347067,
0.0140348496,
0.0093831811,
-0.0399977788,
-0.0263767224,
-0.0192405283,
0.0091421008,
-0.0147847002,
0.0087631783,
0.0303680338,
0.0312114302,
-0.0317448042,
-0.0090413867,
-0.0359367505,
0.0466316082,
-0.0576493517,
-0.0068294639,
-0.0192329921,
0.02240007,
-0.0253310408,
0.0180967897,
-0.0414503217,
-0.0112789031,
-0.0159978718,
-0.0491230488,
0.0587212965,
-0.0087992446,
0.0046334518,
-0.014218892,
0.0133619588,
-0.0111377025,
0.1097626537,
0.0201865099,
0.0221619662,
0.0770564452,
-0.0188827757,
-0.0260361172,
-0.007927984,
0.0554123931,
0.0360043719,
0.026370395,
0.0142493499,
-0.0381041728,
-0.0201600846,
0.0057732482,
0.0200450253,
-0.012898216,
-0.0165386088,
0.0393672399,
0.0632872209,
0.0747838095,
-0.0031918632,
-0.0532287546,
0.0340114385,
0.0252924543,
0.0053243153,
-0.0734556019,
-0.031101048,
-0.0937519968,
-0.0419399403,
-0.0217630416,
0.091230765,
-0.0261174925,
-0.0362069011,
-0.004894984,
-0.0480728857,
-0.006198829,
0.0106412861,
-0.0064358357,
-0.0009965218,
0.0043464573,
0.0529830679,
0.0124087436,
-0.0255497731,
-0.0217535272,
-0.0107871117,
-0.0357096605,
0.0710470974,
0.0655969977,
-0.0468870476,
-0.0031387557,
-0.035493806,
0.0399050787,
0.0023565202,
0.0301166009,
0.0191484522,
0.0898283646,
-0.0210449975,
-0.0654813349,
0.0055670724,
0.0252400283,
0.0021589447,
-0.0111189745,
-0.0006878389,
-0.0023436991,
-0.0308159329,
-0.0137088243,
0.0376519039,
0.0097043887,
-0.0345866568,
0.0330095217,
0.0131346053,
0.0145088704,
0.0072489153,
-0.0269659422,
0.0014128523,
-0.0042542475,
0.030730037,
-0.0060266182,
-0.0213999581,
0.0053717168,
-0.0198838338,
-0.0050307615,
0.004879612,
0.0380385481,
0.0391385704,
-0.0637462735,
-0.0354208276,
-0.0187675972,
0.0226965584,
0.0519200638,
-0.0128579549,
0.0334391035,
-0.0425231904,
0.0483980738,
-0.0248169713,
0.0060729724,
-0.0456195064,
-0.0181702171,
-0.0556007177,
-0.0129870605,
0.0346565582,
-0.0084685637,
0.0417876765,
0.0001137435,
0.0163792819,
0.0155817326,
0.0124934744,
0.0399718359,
0.0017504307,
-0.0084590437,
-0.0042643421,
0.0347312689,
-0.0387672819,
0.0439486988,
0.0250921641,
0.0128284013,
-0.0434454754,
-0.0378277898,
-0.0006372748,
0.0158585664,
-0.0497796386,
0.0388117433,
-0.0011833706,
0.0020300187,
-0.0501230918,
-0.011895664,
-0.0324412547,
0.0131111518,
0.0240216032,
-0.0281842016,
-0.071745038,
-0.0504886694,
0.0245357994,
-0.0225956235,
0.0359682813,
0.0219522547,
-0.0066677872,
-0.0241774172,
0.0528158881,
-0.0178366695,
0.0351757258,
-0.0275421496,
-0.0037730304,
0.0570488423,
0.0390026756,
-0.0242866632,
0.0115889274,
-0.0289706271,
-0.0139373746,
-0.0421854556,
0.0426693596,
0.0801217929,
0.0029135833,
-0.0175244361,
-0.0456691496,
-0.0265414119,
0.0654401258,
-0.0092559364,
-0.0600280948,
-0.0432934687,
-0.0037157636,
0.0335810483,
0.0366706327,
0.0160940159,
-0.0904526114,
0.059323635,
-0.015445685,
0.0334736928,
-0.0489983857,
-0.0387855694,
-0.0475168526,
0.0509872027,
0.007613014,
0.0425212197,
-0.0010906374,
-0.0642689094,
-0.001416525,
0.0429401658,
0.0521226265,
-0.0152199771,
-0.000091333,
0.0002918746,
-0.0053657922,
-0.0158554129,
-0.0372232348,
0.0113355285,
-0.0824170485,
-0.018009197,
0.0152490716,
-0.0147774117,
-0.0252601206,
0.0243107192,
0.0065186657,
-0.0119009418,
0.0099281864,
0.0008161287,
0.0100757889,
-0.0091593126,
-0.008444746,
-0.0161601007,
-0.0502458885,
0.013241441,
-0.0039413022,
0.0022098678,
0.0307192467,
0.0710219294,
-0.0088126296,
0.0718451217,
-0.0307524297,
0.0152631495,
-0.0464945398,
-0.0271485634,
-0.0149097135,
0.066263862,
-0.0413817391,
0.0271590855,
0.082788825,
0.01307924,
-0.0492075831,
0.0069363341,
-0.0030567946,
0.0566927977,
-0.0006635129,
0.0119096087,
-0.0729505271,
0.0022313599,
0.0187101327,
0.0421714187,
0.0097811678,
-0.0405783132,
-0.0545951985,
-0.0657798946,
-0.0124609694,
0.0217710864,
-0.0151508357,
-0.037681479,
-0.0484187715,
0.0130404076,
-0.0080618616,
0.032956332,
-0.0297178235,
0.0106183337,
-0.0214608945,
0.0241286997,
-0.0257317014,
-0.0765096843,
-0.0208591782,
-0.041770976,
0.0334417634,
0.0004494323,
-0.0100387409,
-0.0007970518,
-0.0670537353,
0.0220616776,
0.0554850399,
-0.0003551717,
-0.0416233242,
0.0158260167,
-0.0348227136,
0.0004594796,
0.0282052737,
0.0318206102,
-0.0039431406,
-0.0249203816,
0.0154380752,
0.0289750826,
-0.0207720045,
-0.0033464881,
0.0095338477,
-0.0261794906,
0.0381068923,
0.0472198464,
0.0087281959,
-0.0200281441,
-0.0286580287,
0.0148109347,
0.0038746281,
-0.0120802997,
0.032222461,
0.040444389,
-0.0116762836,
-0.040981032,
-0.0168914199,
0.0361877568,
0.0111371959,
0.0299039576,
0.023641983,
0.0268255584,
0.0479316004,
0.0027475005,
-0.0122278202,
0.0378546976,
-0.0509144887,
0.0289690811,
-0.0439407714,
-0.048219718,
0.002232366,
0.0509713888,
-0.0131810438,
0.0228189677,
-0.0571367666,
-0.0744840875,
0.040005032,
0.0105651254,
0.0129430313,
0.0473946966,
-0.037299145,
-0.076807797,
0.0648595765,
0.0413038731,
-0.045604527,
0.0284767654,
0.076581426,
-0.0549114421,
-0.0064885407,
0.033196602,
-0.014436828,
0.0050200745,
0.0667495877,
-0.0095604323,
0.0189042557,
-0.0882743075,
-0.0299484357,
0.050792627,
0.0596754812,
0.0037736155,
0.0224360432,
-0.0515472479,
0.033587046,
-0.0335794576,
0.0111361463,
-0.0184487849,
-0.0127015756,
0.01747551,
-0.0109784268,
-0.0038566391,
-0.0025936875,
0.0450692549,
-0.0139343049,
-0.0016299234,
0.0264483504,
0.0265509952,
-0.038612321,
0.0273966081,
-0.004444065,
-0.0222206898,
0.087225765,
0.0044761454,
0.0571629405,
-0.0184052251,
0.0384454913,
-0.0194771253,
0.0369773582,
-0.0617861971,
0.0584735833,
-0.0599733219,
-0.1193822548,
-0.0271859784,
0.0018429821,
0.0152927525,
0.0108747957,
0.0179602727,
-0.0313067287,
-0.0066948496,
-0.0186834224,
0.0126265837,
-0.0105604017,
-0.0171365738,
-0.0048937104,
-0.0310071986,
-0.0240243264,
0.0770955309,
0.10062363,
0.0160195734,
0.0374246277,
-0.0249492358,
-0.0241764318,
-0.0465900265,
-0.0210444834,
0.003420294,
0.0543831959,
-0.043349091,
0.0179494414,
-0.012764167,
-0.0494108349,
-0.0453859791,
-0.0120871644,
0.0017011138,
-0.0122996997,
0.0174055248,
0.0235432759,
-0.0049364935,
0.0073377714,
-0.0566692837,
-0.0166637767,
0.0337450132,
0.0107230274,
0.0259675421,
-6.625882559e-33,
-0.0334497318,
0.0239509698,
-0.0339160673,
0.0377902053,
-0.0049182898,
0.0148840677,
0.0166057181,
0.0001356068,
-0.01073201,
-0.0350966305,
-0.060843654,
0.0240692813,
0.0200805012,
0.0259981677,
-0.0422055088,
-0.0161787514,
0.0408078432,
-0.0336743593,
-0.0463143662,
0.0241748337,
0.0470284149,
0.0449164696,
0.0484346114,
-0.0306831785,
0.0113236839,
0.0370765701,
-0.0355888866,
0.0341407955,
-0.0316576064,
0.0000572619,
-0.0221444722,
0.0072349817,
0.012779098,
0.0198960956,
-0.0397627205,
0.028721936,
-0.0525716841,
-0.0146959899,
-0.0011158162,
0.024863217,
-0.0016880718,
-0.020100981,
0.0490281656,
-0.0075569809,
0.0017681235,
-0.0323567204,
-0.0202181954,
-0.0031678516,
-0.0349143706,
-0.0506601334,
-0.0133181559,
0.0134279337,
0.0087709101,
0.0125811761,
0.0295980517,
0.014212735,
-0.0146360304,
-0.0232624374,
-0.0542023703,
-0.0181947164,
0.0883735344,
0.0065125395,
0.0460997373,
0.0348958112,
0.0186638925,
0.033082325,
0.0468917452,
0.0237532705,
-0.0349299647,
0.0318666808,
0.0289557688,
0.0283806063,
-0.0127566792,
0.0077218148,
-0.0123659242,
-0.0644358471,
-0.0591712482,
-0.0022030794,
0.0422776826,
-0.0407966152,
0.0014647078,
0.0443500094,
-0.0308867358,
-0.018419072,
-0.0570185147,
-0.0057992847,
-0.0116814561,
-0.0083942041,
-0.0079686679,
0.0169021692,
-0.067463465,
-0.0313590467,
0.0114205442,
-0.0502983108,
-0.0292797145,
0.0087385708,
0.072172299,
-0.0240118224,
-0.0074366205,
0.0136341322,
-0.0697642788,
-0.0389515571,
-0.01190696,
-0.0078640096,
0.0381429829,
-0.0169294383,
0.0713721961,
0.0524413586,
-0.0682097673,
-0.0062318807,
-0.0035967994,
0.0231311712,
0.0298417322,
0.047709778,
0.0457216501,
-0.020464329,
-0.0017310414,
0.0099402862,
0.0287470743,
0.0081220986,
-0.039422933,
0.0160486959,
-0.0033476613,
0.0283428263,
0.0255266968,
-0.0240963567,
-0.0090081841,
0.0056453669,
0.0996052548,
-0.0378757752,
-0.0098709464,
-0.0488445312,
2.881e-7,
0.0444855653,
0.0215845369,
-0.0268122368,
-0.0457981192,
0.0260767397,
0.0232049096,
-0.0116051706,
0.0524583161,
-0.0065794075,
0.0058092424,
0.0001021353,
-0.006411063,
0.0267843232,
0.0150172981,
-0.0274798069,
-0.0406513736,
-0.0156804249,
0.0776048526,
-0.0485110357,
-0.0447272509,
-0.0196682308,
0.078945674,
0.0434673727,
-0.0300615709,
-0.0153647382,
-0.023213204,
0.0307493117,
-0.0531743728,
-0.0602833442,
0.0028917966,
0.0330087692,
0.1085309088,
0.0238947254,
-0.0145328771,
-0.0260414667,
0.0655276477,
-0.0431212522,
0.090255186,
0.0149096698,
0.0273593962,
-0.0186245106,
-0.0403030775,
-0.0434395745,
0.0022938699,
0.0698981956,
-0.0338888839,
-0.0386032872,
-0.0298220366,
0.0806474015,
-0.0519684777,
0.0705006421,
0.0018494811,
-0.0260216016,
0.0261035822,
0.0193007346,
0.0019159509,
-0.0282732341,
-0.0813919827,
-0.0062246933,
-0.0140017485,
0.00226201,
-0.0448339768,
-0.0062597268,
0.0292715225,
0.0001992296,
-0.0235327631,
-0.0043494226,
2.773448744e-34,
0.0305415187,
-0.0419225469,
0.0338773206,
-0.0045731524,
0.0144247143,
-0.0191712994,
0.0475253537,
-0.0217386875,
0.0045638587,
-0.0502101518,
0.0077723372
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10020v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10020v3 | On the Blind Spots of Model-Based Evaluation Metrics for Text Generation | 2022-12-20T06:24:25 | 2023-05-18T20:46:57 | Tianxing He, Jingyu Zhang, Tianle Wang, Sachin Kumar, Kyunghyun Cho, James Glass, Yulia Tsvetkov | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this work, we explore a useful but often neglected methodology for
robustness analysis of text generation evaluation metrics: stress tests with
synthetic data. Basically, we design and synthesize a wide range of potential
errors and check whether they result in a commensurate drop in the metric
scores. We examine a range of recently proposed evaluation metrics based on
pretrained language models, for the tasks of open-ended generation,
translation, and summarization. Our experiments reveal interesting
insensitivities, biases, or even loopholes in existing metrics. For example, we
find that BERTScore is confused by truncation errors in summarization, and
MAUVE (built on top of GPT-2) is insensitive to errors at the beginning or
middle of generations. Further, we investigate the reasons behind these blind
spots and suggest practical workarounds for a more reliable evaluation of text
generation. We have released our code and data at
https://github.com/cloudygoose/blindspot_nlg. | [
-0.0025696098,
0.0566574037,
0.0204947107,
-0.0255740937,
-0.0064284075,
0.0014872862,
0.0204394162,
0.0174634699,
-0.0208726488,
-0.0428839289,
-0.0082519138,
-0.0484864525,
0.022616541,
0.0218413975,
0.0440303609,
-0.0584641844,
0.0196919087,
-0.0101479227,
-0.0142845381,
0.0098507944,
-0.0028699157,
0.0142368125,
0.0000222512,
0.0526888967,
0.0049435413,
-0.0121253468,
0.0017963565,
0.0290467311,
0.0475927033,
-0.0138998134,
0.0134327579,
0.0554223098,
-0.0319394246,
0.0438727625,
0.0000018704,
-0.0502591431,
-0.0169926677,
-0.0010945034,
0.0393971801,
0.0467999429,
0.0397142209,
-0.0180738065,
-0.0269284304,
0.0504199304,
-0.0204536952,
-0.000103332,
0.0221676528,
-0.0112093007,
0.0662913844,
0.0704116747,
-0.0069347592,
0.0140651418,
0.0174097121,
-0.0481726266,
0.0039585424,
0.0045002904,
-0.0181676298,
-0.0031525921,
-0.0071668951,
-0.0454783179,
0.016385626,
0.0094408188,
0.0190226287,
-0.0099926954,
-0.0024699199,
0.0570913441,
-0.0341382995,
-0.015300056,
0.0113611659,
0.0436720029,
-0.0317001827,
-0.0262547769,
0.0031691308,
-0.0107294749,
-0.0079097971,
-0.0186506752,
-0.0234635938,
0.0616922528,
-0.0159495194,
0.0180073567,
-0.005241435,
0.020670183,
0.0039818231,
-0.0087428503,
-0.0126397917,
0.00818682,
0.0497487932,
-0.0337056853,
-0.0168608055,
0.0270199683,
-0.0388532728,
-0.0654757917,
0.0009598896,
0.0237430986,
-0.0278293602,
0.001338918,
-0.0994439647,
-0.0520194732,
0.0419331677,
-0.0411418676,
0.0653246939,
0.0313369259,
0.0060902997,
-0.0157426726,
-0.0294813085,
0.0637125894,
0.0412367731,
0.0060818233,
-0.0511145219,
0.0284850486,
-0.0353652723,
-0.0018588973,
-0.0492697358,
-0.0001135122,
-0.0298980381,
-0.0192516837,
-0.0552234612,
0.0172198936,
0.010244214,
-0.014080028,
0.0095904572,
-0.0001780161,
-0.0486561693,
0.0320064574,
0.0075501939,
-0.0050204955,
-0.0475649349,
-0.0221062377,
0.0481319465,
-0.0502146855,
-0.0226023328,
0.0306091923,
-0.025275562,
-0.0085916584,
-0.0043648076,
0.057202518,
-0.018685203,
-0.0220438074,
-0.0338456929,
-0.0435922518,
-0.0366146304,
-0.0738592222,
-0.0047102557,
-0.0621329881,
0.0004786207,
0.0100263339,
-0.0148389144,
-0.0198460557,
0.0133665288,
0.016938068,
0.0029454832,
-0.0276667159,
-0.0170312561,
0.0070069591,
-0.0007716273,
0.0139839984,
0.021195814,
0.0427269489,
0.0713335127,
0.0313407965,
0.0344309211,
0.0196756981,
0.0054923114,
0.0360485092,
0.0280802269,
0.0257256236,
-0.0018225039,
-0.0222999845,
-0.005784973,
0.0200318582,
0.0387399942,
0.0978583992,
-0.0446754359,
0.0439306758,
0.0637424067,
0.0008035472,
0.0049300175,
0.0412833355,
0.0877674967,
-0.0080304863,
0.0336597636,
0.060138803,
0.0110061914,
0.0022942857,
-0.0554700792,
0.0549582019,
0.0504389741,
0.049181208,
-0.0155581776,
-0.0655523092,
-0.0248988047,
0.0006704002,
-0.0107930293,
-0.0474366397,
0.0262391325,
0.0357616469,
-0.0708217025,
0.0470144413,
-0.0106097758,
-0.1152531728,
0.0415630378,
-0.0131104281,
-0.0001915276,
0.0368098766,
0.0706364065,
0.0024584814,
-0.0276739728,
0.0155060226,
-0.0287995469,
0.0404079035,
0.061942488,
0.0090706125,
0.0032087262,
-0.0365872607,
-0.0065159271,
-0.0422309488,
0.0302885417,
0.0048707058,
-0.0096108597,
0.025556894,
0.0512737446,
-0.0541907996,
-0.0715692043,
0.0407823212,
-0.0263053626,
-0.0208118316,
0.0031456926,
-0.0347374491,
0.009109267,
0.0190452877,
-0.0590175316,
0.0509680845,
0.0197872277,
-0.0122768842,
0.0040331255,
0.0298288502,
-0.0384079628,
-0.036514286,
0.0074502379,
-0.0646018535,
0.0067048804,
0.0337887853,
-0.0249415003,
-0.0526203066,
0.0077865254,
-0.0580278784,
0.0056914235,
-0.0470840782,
0.0358117707,
0.0108853457,
0.0041981535,
-0.0209491439,
0.0632001609,
-0.0003826294,
0.0403639488,
0.0020907128,
0.0171811469,
0.0185738206,
-0.0387833156,
-0.0262948014,
0.0023907993,
-0.0000319399,
0.0172394812,
0.0507155433,
0.0551271439,
-0.052585125,
-0.057195235,
-0.1013659984,
0.029800998,
-0.0431988202,
0.0463080592,
0.0695097297,
0.0020715706,
-0.0194439441,
0.0286148544,
-0.0369096361,
-0.0361420251,
0.0413619652,
-0.0039474964,
0.0443143435,
-0.0075776689,
0.0244956221,
-0.0223080404,
0.0029361879,
0.0070090089,
0.0543522686,
0.0469114706,
0.0363258794,
-0.0408904664,
0.0591016859,
-0.0491894111,
-0.0118475789,
0.0239274502,
-0.0555051155,
0.0367537662,
0.0155665269,
0.0803822428,
0.0196307581,
0.0615196154,
0.0425182655,
0.013626189,
-0.0083382847,
0.01685155,
-0.0053061619,
-0.0307606179,
-0.0294721257,
0.0140960664,
-0.0489309803,
0.0396238752,
0.0562407188,
0.0099779032,
-0.0084500974,
-0.0684097782,
0.0209538098,
-0.0346025489,
-0.0136668421,
0.0016239063,
0.0025136333,
-0.001247791,
0.0330009907,
-0.0193738807,
-0.058827512,
0.0361159667,
-0.0596524067,
-0.0005794726,
-0.0468291789,
0.0114136487,
-0.027770659,
0.030485088,
0.0197875276,
0.0352771878,
0.0258368496,
0.0086000152,
-0.0656702593,
0.0272161551,
0.0209580082,
-0.0234556664,
0.0125700347,
-0.0567151122,
-0.014112547,
-0.0220163353,
-0.019454509,
-0.0269460883,
-0.015474217,
0.0212486759,
0.0044920663,
0.0495494157,
-0.0255480576,
-0.0117360493,
0.000146182,
0.0033363379,
0.0458491743,
-0.0333180055,
-0.0194536522,
0.0031716304,
0.0326408297,
0.0368865877,
-0.039090395,
0.0157121569,
-0.0735447928,
-0.0036082922,
0.0334395096,
0.0295917653,
0.0341389775,
-0.0152679589,
0.0046528489,
-0.0030159717,
-0.0327838883,
-0.0267684776,
0.0262155887,
0.0682076663,
-0.0271679964,
-0.0503094196,
0.0949680656,
0.0361475572,
0.0182052646,
0.0229901485,
0.0086817183,
0.1134144142,
-0.0035564722,
0.0053575621,
-0.0368362628,
0.0078324806,
0.011175978,
0.0716198459,
-0.0229780599,
-0.0223414265,
-0.0155332824,
-0.1189762726,
0.0308763627,
0.0357134938,
-0.0553309396,
0.0018871077,
0.0012856282,
-0.0229225941,
-0.008493783,
0.0277082995,
0.0271562431,
-0.0200667679,
0.0523110256,
0.0513169318,
-0.0349251777,
-0.065902032,
-0.0199567657,
-0.0160867963,
0.0135529181,
0.0540841445,
0.030068431,
0.0087359697,
-0.0167325921,
0.0403788313,
-0.025832586,
0.0017438823,
-0.0023105792,
0.063644968,
0.0136106443,
0.0008311681,
-0.008778845,
0.0145976441,
0.0075694174,
0.0177145097,
-0.0216565263,
0.0011083719,
0.0118600056,
-0.0308905356,
-0.0149220843,
0.0222887937,
0.0079531549,
0.0615719706,
0.0595002994,
-0.034572117,
-0.0817632377,
-0.0353040732,
0.0192404091,
-0.103321664,
-0.0076355059,
0.0188636575,
-0.0403135233,
-0.042566251,
-0.0966176838,
-0.0768550783,
0.0117513733,
0.0598692037,
-0.0163886752,
-0.0427412093,
-0.0417658575,
-0.0185803641,
-0.0347786099,
0.0282742381,
0.0179808438,
-0.0021586146,
-0.0725480244,
-0.032089062,
0.0053974041,
-0.0305775944,
-0.0229947846,
0.0326642953,
-0.0747555792,
-0.0651391372,
-0.0183398053,
0.0636834651,
0.032807447,
0.0030516121,
-0.0109989196,
-0.0326959118,
0.0562931225,
0.0542859733,
-0.0267742686,
0.0343822353,
0.0406397432,
-0.0109300073,
-0.0170069542,
0.0123439925,
-0.0373949222,
-0.0030275008,
-0.0100481296,
0.068418324,
0.03594134,
-0.032839153,
0.0233094804,
0.0502173901,
0.0269155391,
-0.0694767684,
-0.0173899345,
-0.0206755903,
-0.0327133425,
-0.0243727975,
-0.0134078991,
-0.0793820918,
0.0329824686,
0.0107321059,
0.0246093683,
-0.0141326599,
0.0360572934,
-0.0283444729,
0.0152781168,
-0.0190951731,
-0.0146209551,
-0.0163397789,
0.0393273421,
0.0181023944,
-0.0169386137,
-0.0354651883,
-0.0371779948,
-0.032094676,
0.013541406,
-0.0057401909,
0.0238592289,
0.028980054,
0.036904525,
0.0299811531,
0.0475348905,
-0.0477373451,
-0.0048928419,
-0.0797010213,
0.0310384035,
0.0406943262,
0.0206789933,
0.1029921919,
-0.0269588809,
0.0102693653,
-0.0427940413,
0.0428401418,
0.0259059817,
-0.0558715649,
-0.0456010327,
-0.0105996821,
-0.0057249148,
-0.0180961974,
0.0930669457,
0.0115337539,
0.0210678559,
-0.0040101544,
0.0045843842,
-0.0399030522,
-0.0238791257,
-0.0047345371,
-0.0316218212,
0.0133638037,
-0.0356382728,
-0.0707576126,
-0.0628605112,
0.0406759121,
0.0641014725,
0.0441771038,
0.0019974995,
0.0456943996,
0.0321270749,
-0.0680716187,
0.0501319356,
-0.0538949296,
-0.0083264662,
-0.0338865593,
0.0059289802,
-0.0131915798,
-5.688783972e-33,
-0.0606685281,
-0.0198560972,
0.0015821963,
-0.0367231779,
-0.0439933911,
-0.0000154591,
-0.0725476444,
0.0176214855,
0.0462468788,
-0.0030802642,
-0.004001766,
-0.026290983,
0.0075275241,
0.0318632163,
-0.0316514149,
0.0059857252,
0.0438748039,
-0.005644063,
-0.0933850631,
0.0316510424,
0.0216715913,
0.0052649141,
0.0384536348,
-0.0250938181,
0.0170683526,
-0.0292519033,
-0.0484579057,
-0.0267626531,
0.0064968751,
0.0265705325,
-0.0017735196,
0.0382503271,
-0.003515485,
0.0028888914,
-0.0309992079,
-0.0188013017,
-0.035394527,
-0.0353582762,
0.003472626,
-0.0270552263,
-0.0625599921,
-0.0213388037,
0.0219574459,
-0.0153684234,
-0.0300779808,
-0.0212342124,
0.016688209,
-0.0245407484,
-0.0257443134,
-0.0663481131,
-0.0395484157,
0.0225918274,
-0.0297289472,
-0.0244539641,
-0.0364089459,
0.0455914438,
-0.0040604533,
-0.0163403302,
0.0154852029,
-0.0006775302,
0.0657947361,
0.0413564518,
0.0546980128,
0.009537627,
-0.0007164951,
0.0687631741,
0.0061551663,
0.012276886,
-0.0098937741,
0.0153836003,
0.0240965225,
0.008784839,
0.0518646464,
0.0401647054,
0.0129583236,
0.0084087905,
-0.0571783893,
0.0791227594,
-0.0136071341,
-0.0217758808,
0.0136725875,
-0.0133310053,
0.0008541247,
-0.010368675,
-0.0520552658,
-0.0378217511,
-0.0077604656,
-0.0075060325,
0.0293222833,
0.0298063625,
-0.0368163213,
-0.037441846,
0.013947295,
0.0190892071,
0.0307335984,
0.0053735184,
-0.0662789196,
0.0233159252,
-0.0232151411,
0.0288391467,
-0.0035319293,
-0.013073869,
0.0510666966,
0.0521925986,
0.0213449094,
-0.0073480094,
0.0234056357,
0.0263554566,
-0.0493180677,
0.0374859348,
-0.0378359333,
0.0734230727,
0.0151245538,
-0.0056203166,
0.0142291291,
-0.056337256,
-0.0069015543,
0.0248851702,
0.0086462442,
0.0185102597,
-0.0254627075,
0.0186557285,
0.0194738489,
0.019313328,
-0.0325779356,
0.0149953077,
0.0005542665,
0.0338888392,
0.0353769809,
-0.0463774242,
-0.0305898674,
-0.0015650052,
2.473e-7,
0.049588576,
0.0337536372,
0.0449188687,
0.0185194183,
-0.020168826,
0.004275714,
-0.0227929913,
0.0492406115,
-0.0014497968,
0.0344133638,
0.0124392062,
-0.0177120138,
0.0594598316,
0.0294882022,
-0.0380696915,
0.0009959626,
-0.0876899287,
0.0305361785,
-0.0448118523,
-0.0057466296,
0.0421951488,
0.017649848,
-0.0306202341,
0.0168503225,
0.0278311223,
-0.0457461439,
0.0659462884,
0.0050469148,
-0.0168636441,
0.0219709259,
0.0773444325,
-0.0010144453,
-0.0070742276,
-0.004433705,
-0.0343625471,
-0.0247161984,
0.0424737185,
0.0263617486,
0.0460286587,
-0.0093860487,
0.0449018218,
-0.0089588175,
0.0059190453,
-0.0593213774,
0.034636803,
-0.0188494921,
-0.0090113413,
0.0229526516,
-0.0397591703,
0.0069862809,
0.0259095784,
-0.0443169475,
-0.0425829254,
0.0246494208,
0.0135418354,
0.0168259349,
0.0087315934,
-0.0250545442,
-0.0479437783,
-0.0101137226,
-0.0169496052,
-0.068993561,
-0.0309733786,
0.0395580381,
0.0035568704,
-0.0917044431,
-0.0116434125,
2.563341756e-34,
0.0658040494,
-0.0377555527,
-0.0031527423,
-0.058911033,
0.0440513492,
-0.0228164699,
0.0199827459,
-0.0161982831,
-0.0024361352,
-0.0332325399,
-0.0413424671
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10019v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10019v1 | When Do Decompositions Help for Machine Reading? | 2022-12-20T06:23:02 | 2022-12-20T06:23:02 | Kangda Wei, Dawn Lawrie, Benjamin Van Durme, Yunmo Chen, Orion Weller | cs.CL | cs.CL | Answering complex questions often requires multi-step reasoning in order to
obtain the final answer. Most research into decompositions of complex questions
involves open-domain systems, which have shown success in using these
decompositions for improved retrieval. In the machine reading setting, however,
work to understand when decompositions are helpful is understudied. We conduct
experiments on decompositions in machine reading to unify recent work in this
space, using a range of models and datasets. We find that decompositions can be
helpful in the few-shot case, giving several points of improvement in exact
match scores. However, we also show that when models are given access to
datasets with around a few hundred or more examples, decompositions are not
helpful (and can actually be detrimental). Thus, our analysis implies that
models can learn decompositions implicitly even with limited data. | [
-0.0017217794,
0.0615804382,
-0.0305165425,
0.0501032472,
-0.0438621081,
0.0555423461,
0.0307358224,
0.0137265418,
0.0105753765,
-0.0242506601,
0.0138138356,
-0.0094378637,
0.0133757712,
-0.0023037039,
-0.0147209,
-0.0414712876,
0.0347399339,
-0.0196577776,
-0.0302769635,
0.0211335942,
-0.0012679098,
0.0191567279,
-0.0132962083,
0.0232914705,
0.0619230941,
-0.0259326436,
-0.0358104892,
-0.0099671148,
0.013108057,
0.0428007096,
-0.0396121815,
-0.0020944043,
-0.0003349527,
0.045709081,
0.0000015739,
-0.00984661,
-0.0517254733,
-0.0016234266,
-0.0505314171,
0.0002642412,
0.015795473,
-0.0671504512,
0.0514833443,
-0.0084483279,
-0.0497708023,
-0.0680736825,
0.0130541949,
0.0285072215,
0.0458435602,
0.0700310543,
0.0149317272,
-0.04557335,
0.0057682479,
0.0205049403,
0.0123095354,
-0.042543076,
0.0025207184,
-0.0047779293,
0.0097058667,
0.0358536318,
-0.0042472887,
0.0425801948,
0.0253663864,
0.0340776034,
-0.0368792042,
0.0284480564,
-0.0056427359,
0.0027723939,
0.0216708928,
0.0542749017,
-0.0066118194,
0.0019083346,
-0.0086060418,
-0.0194255523,
0.0224124491,
0.0269033909,
-0.010697471,
0.0060520708,
-0.0473902188,
0.0174496453,
-0.0033445596,
0.0120484224,
0.0161811635,
0.017089894,
-0.0460161828,
0.0512253195,
-0.0080735879,
-0.0515319481,
-0.0091697024,
0.0279068127,
-0.0424392931,
-0.0051624943,
0.0128092989,
0.0445012078,
-0.0004765761,
0.0210333671,
-0.0302142277,
-0.0514500737,
-0.0022625343,
0.0181175731,
0.0484119467,
0.0783202797,
0.002353044,
0.0400105305,
0.001449851,
0.0188714601,
-0.0353614278,
0.0157004911,
-0.0896371007,
-0.02230471,
-0.0136315227,
-0.0207445137,
-0.0210854672,
0.0669787973,
-0.0600302182,
-0.0193389375,
-0.0385738946,
0.0236273874,
0.038332995,
-0.0016840076,
-0.0001213995,
0.0033055008,
-0.0329962261,
-0.0255296137,
-0.0318947099,
0.0350291394,
-0.0561569929,
0.0345669948,
-0.005773122,
-0.0042189658,
-0.011135052,
-0.0191284455,
0.0065170461,
-0.0315873288,
-0.015515577,
0.0754473656,
-0.013822441,
-0.0455266051,
-0.0265500452,
-0.0539841354,
-0.001037033,
-0.0628362745,
-0.005323336,
-0.0272363815,
0.0612247512,
0.0436535627,
-0.0030536833,
-0.0098664723,
-0.0363748893,
0.0320265852,
-0.0221132152,
0.1298937649,
0.0637394935,
0.0131273298,
0.0087591205,
0.0275200065,
-0.0299398992,
0.0670139343,
0.002917089,
-0.0123561909,
0.0310846772,
0.0034405873,
0.0045581064,
0.023214763,
0.0227194838,
-0.0123601798,
0.026182346,
0.0123027368,
-0.0604097918,
0.0057229195,
-0.0036930463,
0.0380521715,
-0.0573005266,
-0.0445205867,
0.0396022461,
0.0558505058,
0.0363954566,
0.0273702517,
0.0467920005,
0.0086186966,
0.0051950933,
0.0971389189,
-0.0343616195,
-0.0305564273,
-0.0610493124,
0.0295803677,
0.0008224864,
-0.0032162152,
-0.029479729,
-0.0555925444,
0.0109248422,
0.0347376168,
-0.000514198,
0.0410377458,
0.0637375489,
-0.0222403705,
-0.0169280339,
0.0061572581,
-0.0056473161,
-0.0425947756,
0.008050005,
-0.0444954596,
0.0220234785,
0.0188686699,
0.0524423607,
-0.041407492,
0.0051461454,
0.0299298242,
-0.0122429207,
-0.0272414517,
0.0166129023,
-0.0448542088,
0.0337309688,
-0.033490099,
0.0084290709,
0.0282140356,
0.0290605333,
-0.0312216803,
0.0162016042,
-0.025267601,
0.0102156959,
-0.0362172872,
0.0096783582,
0.0416654088,
-0.0435317829,
-0.049473878,
-0.0142936222,
0.0328365825,
0.0206017122,
0.0094096521,
0.0399987921,
0.0146524161,
0.0384736955,
-0.0337899402,
-0.005876604,
-0.0139301792,
-0.0049611772,
-0.0675390065,
0.0171960331,
-0.0313713551,
-0.0239753015,
0.0519143045,
-0.0359915122,
-0.0209199693,
-0.0065325312,
-0.0452384651,
-0.0070492309,
-0.0626079813,
0.0208886843,
0.0059115798,
-0.0287956707,
-0.061004065,
0.0741578862,
-0.0340071321,
0.0338268131,
0.0055007762,
-0.0768885016,
0.0057902262,
-0.0342666991,
-0.0122589124,
-0.0323850922,
0.0207412597,
0.0246614944,
-0.0142264348,
-0.0479797833,
-0.0561223663,
0.0097165313,
-0.0579350553,
0.0208826941,
-0.0142747005,
0.0103616389,
0.0211116932,
0.0146777164,
0.0075567556,
-0.0124896169,
0.0088404948,
0.0121096019,
0.043586459,
0.0352274626,
0.0520413406,
0.0193122849,
0.0025548493,
-0.0052356278,
-0.0592743307,
-0.0480383933,
0.0692048296,
-0.0318504833,
0.0084608058,
-0.0713981837,
0.0407350324,
0.0176402405,
-0.0033260623,
-0.0109280255,
0.0113389036,
0.0167252757,
-0.0486589596,
0.0018955077,
0.0789942816,
-0.0498509519,
0.0200300552,
0.0204193275,
-0.0011738261,
-0.053806819,
0.0081853513,
-0.0352746993,
-0.0050536725,
-0.0216820389,
-0.0434061959,
-0.0025310565,
0.038933225,
-0.0078146597,
-0.0390387364,
-0.0099581005,
0.0465358086,
-0.0274842046,
-0.0268201381,
-0.0846344754,
-0.009534495,
0.0125812609,
0.0892094895,
-0.0213456862,
-0.0294388961,
0.1021248475,
-0.0028008744,
-0.0082146712,
-0.0444295667,
0.0001365874,
-0.0663667172,
0.0842327848,
-0.0237900298,
0.0061726412,
0.0011090335,
-0.0301440544,
-0.0719525889,
0.0006707343,
0.0342939422,
-0.0052709724,
0.0857912078,
-0.0092241485,
-0.011679518,
-0.025168946,
-0.0488965809,
-0.0334608816,
-0.0297699068,
0.0012306644,
-0.0037219797,
-0.0152134961,
-0.0014576357,
-0.0737984329,
0.0135735329,
0.0134888934,
0.0169210974,
-0.0040934198,
-0.0306725968,
-0.0441430323,
0.0901002586,
0.0187357385,
-0.0023444789,
0.0303725842,
-0.0739762336,
0.0627871752,
0.0412738919,
0.0464372821,
0.0010377613,
0.0112100318,
0.0124081029,
0.0446074046,
-0.0560556501,
0.0155840293,
0.0009552744,
0.0122157764,
-0.0829901695,
-0.0209658071,
0.081438683,
0.0344863459,
-0.0305186082,
-0.0167561285,
-0.0315543637,
0.0022603155,
-0.0062463176,
0.0275560729,
-0.057615038,
-0.021805916,
0.0045940005,
0.0357084684,
0.0074053816,
-0.0219807476,
-0.0005567541,
-0.1030542105,
0.0150420284,
0.0180508792,
-0.0687777996,
-0.0484071337,
-0.0254811645,
-0.0193745457,
-0.0167044941,
0.0223998278,
0.0422182232,
-0.0177328065,
-0.0205431189,
-0.0217030961,
0.0484412834,
-0.0101994695,
-0.0188012626,
-0.0630486161,
-0.0256179105,
0.0252398383,
0.0335527472,
0.0387799889,
-0.0171509795,
0.0200774707,
-0.0324601606,
-0.0275668539,
0.0396564081,
0.0519999079,
0.0123465834,
0.0159861594,
-0.0391832367,
0.0544307008,
-0.0301595479,
0.0040728366,
-0.0147128105,
0.0481536053,
-0.0148106525,
-0.0190437213,
-0.0484129153,
-0.0049868659,
-0.0254117195,
0.0727235675,
0.0538437665,
-0.0162148196,
-0.0606906675,
0.0039291065,
0.0030414329,
-0.0491302833,
-0.0314718708,
0.0344451629,
-0.0266488865,
0.0092663737,
-0.0506362692,
-0.1038938835,
0.0468250811,
0.0536196865,
-0.0181412119,
0.0232584644,
0.0308160782,
-0.0051854053,
-0.0677158311,
0.0346638635,
-0.0368118808,
-0.0160609875,
-0.0138671966,
0.0331404433,
0.0119633535,
-0.0257513188,
-0.0337933302,
-0.0093954038,
-0.0882054046,
-0.0437655188,
-0.0031406097,
0.0154946027,
0.0348930731,
0.017675655,
-0.0179404803,
-0.0576560423,
0.0070086438,
0.0270083621,
-0.0471510626,
0.0153924273,
-0.0160711855,
-0.0216402784,
-0.032115031,
0.0454830304,
0.0034329642,
0.0126540875,
0.0062494087,
0.044934351,
-0.0481133983,
-0.0001694765,
0.040532086,
0.0365003496,
0.0390714854,
0.0144951418,
-0.0103873787,
-0.0248145256,
0.0350054316,
-0.0112009309,
-0.0280781798,
-0.0020808862,
-0.0483859777,
0.0587193817,
0.0011509332,
-0.0489172116,
0.0027747559,
-0.0038361091,
0.0704768747,
-0.0573039874,
0.0013846697,
0.0680079982,
0.0222106967,
0.0237078704,
-0.0060889511,
-0.0227070097,
0.0545977913,
-0.0307177342,
0.0437185317,
0.0143705402,
0.0463795029,
0.0312740281,
0.0282955728,
-0.0675386265,
0.030302152,
-0.0906605721,
-0.0210498534,
0.0233998653,
-0.0162605848,
0.0079458402,
-0.0054834001,
0.0001147468,
0.0155645506,
-0.0360753722,
-0.0263821464,
0.0004999548,
0.027633613,
0.0030393875,
0.0064116232,
0.0545139089,
0.003053996,
-0.0149921067,
0.0781643018,
0.0087190699,
0.0369709469,
-0.0006272931,
-0.0369607061,
-0.0254721474,
-0.038621705,
0.0023410902,
0.040931154,
-0.0351095945,
-0.0170281529,
-0.0924221277,
-0.0776634142,
0.008897461,
0.0184365474,
0.0107761184,
0.0122526297,
-0.0158514362,
0.0602234788,
0.024737265,
-0.0106274905,
-0.029116977,
0.0436587743,
-0.062887013,
-0.0502479784,
-0.0268756654,
-4.942515139e-33,
-0.040381778,
-0.0366655886,
0.0384978242,
-0.0282369945,
0.0057009729,
0.0213204063,
0.0202105977,
0.014932503,
-0.0211330745,
-0.0116490517,
-0.0283280462,
0.0400220379,
0.0107593574,
-0.0038601558,
-0.0125364792,
-0.0251950733,
0.0354508199,
-0.0139517486,
-0.0441041328,
-0.0264959857,
0.0609130301,
0.0153743671,
-0.0164586958,
-0.0194160417,
0.0120886778,
-0.052523464,
0.0077000586,
0.0554717258,
-0.0229816884,
0.0715820193,
-0.0287664309,
0.0199681055,
0.0612993762,
0.0215319451,
-0.0024062057,
0.0542738065,
-0.1246159151,
0.0002353628,
0.0303151719,
0.019455526,
-0.0311463699,
-0.0058531882,
0.0283976458,
0.0034818116,
0.0442283042,
-0.017823251,
0.001592476,
-0.0272590835,
-0.0018882025,
-0.0037135938,
-0.0253605545,
-0.0056787101,
0.0040326472,
-0.0155666145,
0.0616543777,
0.0558724813,
0.014657788,
0.0581034385,
-0.0170018934,
-0.0082354331,
0.030251557,
0.0273600183,
0.0196732804,
0.0008917964,
-0.0364538915,
0.0393108949,
0.0179817211,
-0.0262189247,
-0.0612718277,
-0.02258287,
0.050957121,
0.0356154703,
0.0253219102,
0.0628430471,
0.07744921,
0.0561903231,
-0.0594136752,
0.0556638874,
-0.0006049456,
-0.0017991679,
0.0097696595,
-0.0072721364,
-0.0399006009,
-0.00067146,
-0.0517393053,
-0.0028161095,
-0.0753447041,
0.0066009844,
0.042620983,
0.0174285602,
-0.0590437241,
-0.0245221667,
0.0720775276,
-0.0502185337,
0.0180494953,
0.0378907919,
0.0196746327,
0.0220643654,
-0.009309154,
0.0327834785,
-0.0204926785,
-0.0120281028,
0.0028939412,
-0.0167692751,
-0.0043978267,
-0.0005460909,
0.0244000219,
-0.0232221223,
-0.0423727185,
-0.0068791001,
-0.0119337831,
-0.0013522977,
-0.0335411057,
0.0266363323,
0.063516885,
0.0460344553,
0.006336676,
0.0030486446,
0.0107245464,
0.0051004798,
-0.0406296812,
0.0218242612,
-0.0003718545,
0.006181438,
0.0285673086,
-0.002763127,
0.0105853425,
-0.0062488085,
0.0249897633,
-0.0399316326,
-0.0000821977,
0.0633712113,
2.175e-7,
0.0649826005,
-0.0027406043,
0.0354514048,
0.0667136386,
-0.0202593859,
0.0153200226,
-0.0078888172,
0.0092693288,
0.0120750563,
0.003945482,
0.0311755873,
0.0172646791,
0.0196946859,
0.0411378779,
-0.0818200335,
-0.0202405006,
0.0088049341,
0.0126924105,
-0.0499677584,
-0.0176475476,
0.0731003433,
0.0504629016,
0.0076882122,
-0.0162431132,
-0.0031414244,
-0.0214874502,
0.0443739966,
0.0044486034,
-0.016329987,
0.0085266074,
0.028911721,
0.0113567803,
0.0283230934,
0.0338213891,
0.0207177941,
0.033188995,
0.0512654111,
0.0488179475,
0.0233974271,
-0.048265364,
-0.0266008414,
-0.031234635,
0.0111069912,
-0.0205751415,
0.0713528097,
-0.0551043339,
-0.0141111752,
0.0127268452,
-0.0465399213,
-0.0007576246,
-0.0113147097,
0.0117896041,
0.0204282235,
0.034890037,
0.0102353441,
-0.029631665,
0.0464246497,
-0.1030101329,
-0.0138461264,
0.0159783419,
-0.0084004346,
-0.0318847932,
-0.0211584549,
-0.0128433118,
0.0599891655,
-0.0851974264,
-0.0585077591,
2.040031416e-34,
0.0177118722,
0.0160019547,
0.0055263503,
0.0625459701,
0.0008510686,
-0.0372692347,
-0.0140716499,
0.0025999811,
0.0115418695,
-0.1028342694,
-0.0067684082
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10018v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10018v2 | DIONYSUS: A Pre-trained Model for Low-Resource Dialogue Summarization | 2022-12-20T06:21:21 | 2023-05-26T17:29:01 | Yu Li, Baolin Peng, Pengcheng He, Michel Galley, Zhou Yu, Jianfeng Gao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Dialogue summarization has recently garnered significant attention due to its
wide range of applications. However, existing methods for summarizing dialogues
have limitations because they do not take into account the inherent structure
of dialogue and rely heavily on labeled data, which can lead to poor
performance in new domains. In this work, we propose DIONYSUS (dynamic input
optimization in pre-training for dialogue summarization), a pre-trained
encoder-decoder model for summarizing dialogues in any new domain. To pre-train
DIONYSUS, we create two pseudo summaries for each dialogue example: one is
produced by a fine-tuned summarization model, and the other is a collection of
dialogue turns that convey important information. We then choose one of these
pseudo summaries based on the difference in information distribution across
different types of dialogues. This selected pseudo summary serves as the
objective for pre-training DIONYSUS using a self-supervised approach on a large
dialogue corpus. Our experiments show that DIONYSUS outperforms existing
methods on six datasets, as demonstrated by its ROUGE scores in zero-shot and
few-shot settings. | [
0.0136432992,
0.0232801419,
0.0175092332,
0.0258074105,
0.0339266844,
0.023371309,
-0.0294587202,
-0.0191403553,
-0.0230542142,
-0.0330889933,
-0.0269702896,
-0.0015253688,
0.0093027987,
0.0378160775,
-0.0264706276,
-0.1112522557,
0.0202007834,
-0.0144402888,
0.0238402039,
-0.0229651351,
0.0111485245,
0.0164596848,
-0.0349458531,
0.0176263675,
0.0125849107,
-0.0003324775,
-0.0176133327,
0.0260621365,
0.0475869179,
-0.0178291537,
0.0066592679,
0.0150383543,
0.0402876996,
-0.0123767974,
0.0000020285,
-0.0448841304,
-0.0143092927,
-0.0414401293,
-0.0471958667,
0.0244876891,
0.0093656294,
-0.0356185921,
0.0122886905,
0.018910151,
-0.0185159352,
-0.046080146,
0.0119858151,
0.0638224483,
0.0846210644,
0.0962489396,
-0.019731015,
-0.0516865589,
-0.0115692327,
-0.0322044529,
-0.0269145723,
-0.0415243804,
-0.0314886943,
0.0267566033,
-0.024470916,
-0.0381742492,
-0.0227555931,
0.0282071475,
0.0171240438,
-0.0278076772,
-0.0309029128,
0.0288993418,
-0.0450189523,
0.0204444099,
0.0155895576,
0.0981085449,
0.0054558762,
0.0428703241,
0.0186742675,
-0.0104578175,
0.0006342352,
-0.0392294824,
-0.0648535416,
0.0233834684,
0.0307912789,
-0.0067412625,
-0.0428272039,
0.0905475169,
-0.0381280407,
-0.0024411902,
-0.0281956811,
-0.0184193552,
-0.0054586837,
-0.0004289775,
-0.0589728504,
-0.0066109532,
0.0089034792,
-0.065071933,
-0.0132291419,
0.0396812893,
-0.0178628825,
-0.0202565435,
-0.0361486524,
0.0109824855,
-0.0328942314,
0.0001914204,
-0.0039976682,
-0.0038843502,
0.0154619226,
0.049866993,
0.0195360426,
0.03254788,
0.0279410146,
0.0290618744,
-0.0371150598,
-0.0001615909,
-0.0280973967,
0.0156899597,
-0.0569485575,
0.0190351363,
-0.0557624809,
-0.0505460463,
-0.0157233942,
0.0198153611,
0.0200982131,
-0.0204004459,
0.0098188035,
0.0267267376,
0.0286145899,
-0.0209987331,
0.004462508,
0.0486889295,
-0.0506764576,
-0.0115227271,
0.0283628181,
-0.0056870901,
-0.0350769982,
0.0394918099,
0.0333231874,
-0.0008832915,
0.002958829,
0.0719930604,
-0.0324846841,
-0.0439229012,
0.0185559355,
-0.0136770736,
-0.0567835718,
-0.0272427648,
-0.0263566822,
-0.0170603804,
0.0267581157,
-0.0309890378,
0.0023290513,
-0.0147720296,
-0.0152618438,
-0.0159235261,
-0.0118605141,
0.0167236868,
0.0111060739,
0.004043642,
0.0601310469,
0.0014200632,
0.0207061805,
0.0541590936,
0.0687641799,
0.0303094499,
0.0435250998,
-0.000878692,
0.0132764531,
0.04139328,
0.0154080633,
0.0287160054,
0.0152169103,
-0.0013526641,
-0.0290461201,
-0.0206469391,
0.027190445,
0.034601938,
-0.064000167,
0.0022270191,
0.0452719443,
0.0361072384,
-0.0109696267,
0.003664392,
0.0096384427,
0.0678633228,
0.0419450998,
0.0319935307,
-0.0222951733,
0.0450525172,
0.0026867318,
0.0391139016,
0.0845883638,
-0.0041222186,
-0.0466816649,
-0.0481345691,
0.0415378958,
-0.0128090521,
0.0065708742,
0.0047071283,
-0.0006664665,
0.0463690832,
-0.0753812343,
0.0610430576,
-0.0093622077,
-0.075667344,
-0.0017969523,
-0.0023631281,
0.002703903,
0.0489490628,
0.038991794,
-0.0344460979,
-0.0345337912,
-0.0405033417,
0.0050883526,
0.0323046222,
0.0223241486,
-0.0376661643,
0.0435989089,
-0.0630936846,
-0.0341177769,
-0.0436432511,
-0.0022896896,
0.031071268,
-0.0340697095,
-0.002098972,
0.0230782069,
0.0327674598,
-0.0027509949,
-0.0032523298,
0.0044926172,
-0.0508073904,
0.0106741441,
0.0039949836,
0.0388220325,
0.0366868451,
-0.0458195023,
-0.0170365702,
0.0175956339,
-0.0314159058,
-0.0103514427,
0.0386714898,
-0.0779055879,
-0.0955271721,
0.0065586842,
-0.0625060946,
-0.0101626851,
0.0200071055,
-0.0552863926,
-0.0776716471,
0.0188216623,
-0.0682473332,
0.0120615605,
-0.0206803232,
0.0033914289,
0.0373568013,
0.013370987,
-0.0059242672,
0.0377097018,
0.0190135837,
-0.021127671,
0.0562053733,
0.0157011729,
0.0308812018,
-0.0495824628,
0.0199881941,
-0.0104853855,
-0.0028475069,
-0.0102431141,
0.0583667718,
0.003716334,
-0.0088944063,
-0.0064958702,
-0.0797921568,
-0.0052756239,
-0.0206422415,
-0.0062772059,
0.0398441926,
0.0294594243,
-0.0276419874,
-0.0202872697,
-0.0280776396,
-0.0340232439,
0.0488844104,
-0.0281814951,
0.0116066197,
0.0483715087,
0.0265135691,
-0.0467123687,
0.0019978182,
0.0421655588,
0.0462429374,
-0.0102022383,
0.0003635978,
0.0323744491,
0.0123803867,
0.0032054768,
-0.0089446232,
-0.0026057118,
-0.0424381196,
-0.0168630481,
0.03559025,
0.0422064103,
0.0256574713,
0.0526630729,
0.0117006339,
-0.0008894889,
-0.018111119,
-0.0368609019,
0.0091164717,
-0.0231772885,
-0.000946524,
-0.0072191125,
0.0161456112,
0.0452698357,
0.0478860438,
0.034645915,
0.0520625971,
-0.0480986089,
-0.0093841022,
0.0277960431,
-0.0295924619,
-0.0105063487,
-0.02185685,
-0.0343508683,
0.0303054973,
-0.0302483551,
0.016081199,
0.0537685454,
-0.0386987589,
-0.0240496155,
-0.0516893864,
-0.0097515825,
-0.0379272401,
0.0297790971,
0.0012961933,
0.0184664745,
0.010720117,
-0.0494874045,
-0.0326341912,
-0.0152840894,
0.0614104979,
-0.0086088404,
0.0707461312,
0.0117364069,
-0.0078371726,
-0.018462982,
0.0104467906,
-0.0254728403,
-0.0489463471,
-0.0271159038,
0.0031282627,
0.0008918774,
-0.0093371766,
-0.0345890112,
0.0088914661,
-0.0038397817,
0.0753600076,
-0.015410345,
0.0145313237,
-0.0243964605,
0.079499349,
0.0428926907,
-0.0042093452,
-0.0025237221,
-0.0270791352,
0.0748912022,
0.0096514104,
-0.0150424978,
0.0027767939,
0.0008193302,
-0.0147670228,
-0.0114716552,
-0.0289795995,
0.0493584611,
-0.0064529465,
0.0535913371,
-0.0228747521,
0.0082044853,
0.1384295821,
0.0060748323,
-0.041187726,
-0.0173158292,
0.0114461072,
0.0329265445,
0.0112155331,
-0.0137626864,
-0.072814472,
-0.0530196726,
-0.0108350664,
0.0016510437,
0.0303998701,
-0.0155542661,
-0.0063489997,
-0.0938642994,
0.009288514,
0.0178332329,
-0.0231479667,
-0.0101101287,
0.00342099,
-0.0189025216,
-0.0373505652,
0.0322401077,
-0.0115793571,
-0.0184407048,
-0.0120571144,
0.0042184615,
-0.0427580141,
-0.0099083716,
-0.0289409235,
0.0025454471,
0.0076785432,
0.059906248,
0.043612387,
0.0156255141,
0.070325315,
0.0538688675,
-0.0285690576,
-0.0130965579,
0.0424861908,
0.1003299206,
-0.0295091625,
-0.0129469326,
-0.0047440641,
0.027249556,
0.0087169018,
-0.0169832837,
0.0171025116,
-0.0335340463,
-0.0114333117,
0.0048501967,
-0.017427139,
0.0631662458,
-0.0239563342,
0.0824448839,
0.0515730307,
0.0002965222,
-0.0111709824,
-0.026286643,
0.0080155693,
-0.0706561431,
-0.0465909317,
-0.007989292,
0.0106224027,
-0.030952597,
-0.0890192613,
-0.0559583604,
0.0103981029,
-0.033199586,
-0.0452744216,
-0.0466408841,
-0.0007827133,
0.024769146,
-0.0329755805,
0.0059431349,
-0.024993306,
-0.025884293,
-0.052292943,
-0.0286367349,
0.0639431998,
0.0002180394,
-0.0298655443,
0.0308032911,
-0.0502565466,
-0.058767084,
-0.038166333,
0.0573010407,
0.0172987152,
0.0785732493,
0.0102747763,
0.0214595012,
0.074392803,
0.0047747134,
-0.0097486423,
0.0144377705,
0.0576011054,
0.0283258576,
-0.0383055471,
0.0135331014,
-0.0470632166,
0.0570477918,
-0.0360659435,
0.0088130459,
-0.0860463902,
-0.1082786992,
-0.0048293048,
-0.0015235669,
0.0250819214,
-0.0079209199,
-0.0124868415,
-0.0033609008,
-0.0009426534,
-0.0285588261,
0.0126039386,
-0.0333255753,
0.0158610214,
-0.0169857573,
-0.0203925651,
-0.001968168,
0.0455345474,
-0.0441415496,
0.0013478147,
-0.0326054282,
0.0103738373,
0.0053020739,
-0.0444428809,
-0.0420031287,
0.0027214652,
-0.0323739313,
0.0332076065,
-0.0152628114,
0.007245379,
0.000276847,
0.0478332862,
0.0172453783,
0.0048574372,
0.0284757819,
0.0377583578,
-0.051529482,
-0.0176884681,
-0.0390382335,
0.0146321366,
0.0284059793,
-0.0522260033,
0.0515801944,
0.0300119761,
0.0217729621,
-0.021593608,
0.0324296393,
-0.0043190708,
-0.0335648991,
-0.0236365255,
0.0325527713,
0.0086954525,
0.0262370463,
0.094652459,
-0.0413495153,
0.0194493495,
0.0291315597,
0.0377624445,
-0.0645221695,
-0.0412582234,
-0.0243659895,
0.0254800059,
0.00693443,
0.0391635112,
-0.0047946461,
-0.0102490913,
0.0085300887,
-0.0154153733,
0.0225625075,
0.0046737441,
0.0700940713,
-0.0339128263,
0.0002272846,
0.0142190503,
0.0060752835,
-0.0172303729,
-0.0227965172,
0.0117464308,
-0.0132837528,
-5.840149808e-33,
-0.0481653102,
0.0074368883,
-0.0193583462,
0.0140711088,
-0.0312514156,
-0.0053023705,
-0.0661892667,
0.0074499613,
0.0021115968,
0.016843047,
0.0082902722,
0.0191735979,
0.0136840567,
0.0755061284,
-0.0188980494,
-0.0308028478,
0.0587413348,
0.0050346539,
-0.0612602718,
0.0597550943,
0.0011396216,
0.0015048493,
0.01240585,
-0.0606885254,
-0.0405935496,
-0.0585343055,
-0.0291994438,
0.013756304,
0.0700871274,
0.0348765515,
-0.0056965337,
0.0028228357,
0.0084711304,
-0.0610523187,
-0.0453809872,
0.0323905461,
-0.0793646649,
-0.0271840245,
0.0011875976,
0.0234098285,
-0.0124142664,
-0.0372477844,
-0.0023916073,
-0.0026928303,
0.0350533053,
-0.0516287722,
0.0430996642,
-0.0543466508,
-0.0053670425,
-0.0798150599,
-0.0250587929,
0.024097437,
-0.0701409504,
-0.0887288824,
0.0207022708,
0.0748656169,
0.0395277329,
-0.0238793697,
-0.0243700724,
0.0407388061,
-0.004372674,
0.0148982983,
0.0191057082,
0.0028358987,
-0.0124365604,
0.0686225668,
-0.0107513918,
-0.0246697906,
-0.0278496947,
0.0061355345,
-0.0315134451,
0.0060283113,
-0.00480037,
0.0483000316,
0.0329407826,
0.0168360565,
-0.0477595776,
0.0689491034,
-0.0114444206,
0.0147194108,
-0.0039721183,
0.0093854377,
0.0356000401,
-0.0031000481,
-0.026494287,
0.013300648,
0.0136449225,
-0.0144772502,
-0.0199241284,
0.0267229844,
-0.0257885382,
-0.0342672095,
0.0674543157,
-0.0344770066,
0.0541637167,
0.0361351632,
-0.0315165184,
0.0068937731,
-0.0137032261,
-0.0110236173,
-0.0025727442,
0.0172411427,
0.0798684955,
0.0039111013,
0.0155476974,
0.022493761,
0.0192027856,
-0.0019737061,
-0.0380094387,
0.003108785,
0.0370615609,
0.0469566584,
-0.0570433252,
0.0703681856,
-0.0129780313,
0.03662901,
-0.0159418602,
0.0783512592,
-0.0632274374,
0.0039855465,
-0.0041543948,
0.0009835567,
0.0364500694,
0.049081631,
-0.0388273522,
0.0101076774,
0.0019275849,
-0.0305771213,
0.0333029814,
-0.035863243,
-0.0163709931,
-0.0102827111,
2.557e-7,
0.0118174125,
0.0240817107,
0.0980919898,
0.0070291134,
-0.0084390491,
0.0375051387,
-0.010225256,
0.0166061353,
0.0298001487,
-0.0527507551,
0.0505828857,
0.0596587583,
0.0592472814,
-0.0161245465,
-0.1145983189,
-0.047305394,
-0.0804999918,
-0.0485050455,
-0.0111460304,
-0.020484576,
0.0633287132,
0.0755057931,
-0.0127161806,
0.0083216699,
-0.0253929514,
0.0069666035,
0.0432003811,
0.0028235777,
-0.0155232837,
0.0362414345,
0.0086231586,
-0.0166887343,
-0.0310721584,
-0.0128704868,
-0.0115150614,
0.0101649035,
0.0249622744,
0.0638929978,
0.0044750315,
-0.0751640797,
-0.0122393873,
0.0241763387,
-0.0048528928,
0.038668856,
0.0445589423,
-0.0772687569,
-0.0139115462,
0.0039863945,
-0.0694304779,
0.0198881961,
0.0060967235,
-0.0059948177,
-0.030247191,
0.0700653195,
0.0303227119,
-0.005006949,
0.0150273545,
-0.1074168533,
-0.018885063,
0.0132582309,
-0.0161893014,
0.0157158598,
0.0124541046,
-0.0402357206,
0.0269764625,
-0.0251655616,
0.005566014,
1.951565364e-34,
0.0682139173,
-0.0058894879,
-0.0192935951,
0.0222150553,
0.026423268,
-0.0437049791,
0.0005579193,
-0.0479816496,
0.0327630974,
-0.0600647852,
-0.0105298106
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10015v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10015v3 | Benchmarking Spatial Relationships in Text-to-Image Generation | 2022-12-20T06:03:51 | 2023-10-27T17:24:04 | Tejas Gokhale, Hamid Palangi, Besmira Nushi, Vibhav Vineet, Eric Horvitz, Ece Kamar, Chitta Baral, Yezhou Yang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Spatial understanding is a fundamental aspect of computer vision and integral
for human-level reasoning about images, making it an important component for
grounded language understanding. While recent text-to-image synthesis (T2I)
models have shown unprecedented improvements in photorealism, it is unclear
whether they have reliable spatial understanding capabilities. We investigate
the ability of T2I models to generate correct spatial relationships among
objects and present VISOR, an evaluation metric that captures how accurately
the spatial relationship described in text is generated in the image. To
benchmark existing models, we introduce a dataset, $\mathrm{SR}_{2D}$, that
contains sentences describing two or more objects and the spatial relationships
between them. We construct an automated evaluation pipeline to recognize
objects and their spatial relationships, and employ it in a large-scale
evaluation of T2I models. Our experiments reveal a surprising finding that,
although state-of-the-art T2I models exhibit high image quality, they are
severely limited in their ability to generate multiple objects or the specified
spatial relations between them. Our analyses demonstrate several biases and
artifacts of T2I models such as the difficulty with generating multiple
objects, a bias towards generating the first object mentioned, spatially
inconsistent outputs for equivalent relationships, and a correlation between
object co-occurrence and spatial understanding capabilities. We conduct a human
study that shows the alignment between VISOR and human judgement about spatial
understanding. We offer the $\mathrm{SR}_{2D}$ dataset and the VISOR metric to
the community in support of T2I reasoning research. | [
0.026614828,
0.061039906,
0.0113937426,
0.0532488078,
-0.0264072493,
0.0206428543,
0.0394021869,
0.0066349264,
-0.0026838158,
-0.0436349772,
-0.0151411211,
-0.0199112538,
0.0804858357,
0.0222993735,
0.0247176699,
-0.131663993,
-0.0382258967,
-0.0027511073,
-0.0615617149,
0.0027496645,
0.0028792894,
0.0338869244,
-0.0172236115,
0.0354872048,
-0.0746623799,
-0.0169722419,
0.0006798431,
0.027350083,
0.033120051,
-0.0431691557,
-0.0530917943,
0.0269044507,
0.0463981703,
-0.0183616299,
0.0000022074,
-0.0235785134,
0.0154556856,
0.0091624307,
0.0405326597,
0.0045962613,
0.0308712479,
-0.0803984776,
0.0188856572,
-0.0470889471,
-0.0313272029,
0.0076999101,
0.0760106146,
0.0606100187,
0.0281934347,
0.0118044857,
-0.0211539082,
-0.0297266394,
0.0081676506,
0.0003433999,
0.0290156081,
0.0266379528,
-0.0148628382,
0.0409241803,
0.0039223209,
0.0277147107,
-0.0294238813,
0.0257477462,
0.0406998359,
0.020900555,
0.0341350697,
0.0663555712,
-0.0335613117,
-0.0269281305,
0.0086383661,
0.0724909455,
-0.0225517228,
-0.0243147314,
-0.0089841913,
-0.0055170115,
-0.0278267451,
0.0391058624,
-0.0370018408,
0.0195662063,
-0.0150038339,
0.0244973041,
-0.0807818323,
0.0299896486,
-0.0111833727,
-0.0307225492,
-0.0007415304,
0.013052607,
0.02112207,
0.0156601947,
-0.0557716787,
0.0565530434,
-0.0377536304,
-0.0694516152,
0.0443513915,
0.0198075473,
0.0015251493,
0.0144655732,
-0.0430038795,
-0.0074572135,
-0.0304478593,
-0.0619034544,
0.0585914589,
0.000963839,
-0.0322531797,
0.0454053432,
-0.0472480804,
0.0822553784,
-0.0177431591,
0.0154153295,
-0.0589192174,
0.002654715,
-0.0188877899,
-0.0147734731,
-0.0148034859,
-0.0017380882,
-0.0703938603,
-0.0564734787,
-0.0057877614,
-0.0091428487,
-0.0363506377,
0.0115894815,
-0.0165386889,
0.0602450706,
-0.0390423983,
-0.0018201777,
-0.0392314643,
-0.0031835304,
-0.000434817,
0.0221455395,
-0.0585952364,
-0.031278152,
-0.0092287539,
0.0283781569,
0.0590446442,
-0.010526767,
-0.0463807359,
0.0453738049,
-0.042434901,
-0.0187592767,
0.0058988528,
-0.0444609486,
-0.0400199294,
-0.0325195007,
0.0408486202,
-0.0517282411,
0.0306412745,
-0.0025590856,
-0.0264238231,
-0.0416019857,
0.0031121795,
0.0044175046,
-0.0384891815,
0.0455893762,
-0.0105061876,
0.0291906726,
0.0253230482,
0.0058904961,
0.0416034684,
0.0278775822,
0.0501784757,
0.0779428184,
-0.0016839514,
0.0227387957,
0.0077030431,
0.016702095,
0.00256461,
-0.0005324681,
-0.0611906797,
0.0029711472,
-0.0391307399,
0.0472892933,
0.0299900305,
0.0551940799,
-0.0079289665,
0.024748167,
0.0850978419,
0.0313283093,
0.0099639948,
0.0009785151,
0.0735532641,
0.0304361284,
-0.0109970588,
-0.0071527413,
-0.0365990736,
0.0680858865,
0.0238702279,
0.0209044553,
-0.0146352416,
0.0494701974,
-0.0231340919,
-0.0374317691,
-0.0106197884,
0.013598877,
0.0119451424,
-0.0262580104,
0.0475623123,
0.0481057838,
-0.0408363417,
0.0685623586,
-0.0219029058,
-0.0449630395,
0.0114276521,
0.0081893895,
0.0281925574,
0.0658584237,
0.0270446129,
0.033186432,
0.0267546773,
0.023002224,
0.0626448393,
0.084805809,
0.0114121018,
0.0216013677,
0.0273496043,
-0.0102756266,
-0.0597789399,
-0.0104263183,
-0.002238709,
0.031904161,
0.0389299653,
0.0260509197,
0.0289872754,
-0.0624400489,
0.0073764804,
0.0357850827,
0.0498011373,
0.0072763711,
-0.0538951233,
0.0427231342,
-0.0338278897,
-0.0116280876,
-0.0205715094,
0.0031575593,
0.0080330605,
-0.0208762065,
0.0003334447,
0.0477008,
-0.0501394086,
-0.0275123678,
-0.0185432695,
-0.0869482011,
-0.0251559988,
-0.0137936557,
-0.0244763345,
-0.0150138773,
0.0178219844,
-0.0265616197,
0.0139429914,
-0.0100019388,
-0.0167462584,
0.0275824945,
0.0223053396,
-0.0156423133,
0.0762829855,
-0.0273649897,
0.0002721015,
-0.0062365448,
0.0139027769,
-0.0081091756,
-0.0020516841,
0.0381847732,
-0.0397057608,
-0.0045970324,
0.0059794839,
-0.0131883742,
0.0343483835,
-0.0606018305,
-0.0040995879,
-0.0353043973,
-0.0242057387,
0.0182692632,
-0.0291295089,
0.0005344869,
-0.0616684817,
0.0093626324,
-0.0087969769,
-0.0204492453,
-0.0182104632,
-0.02526314,
0.0067977402,
0.0425749868,
-0.0327193215,
0.0067772283,
-0.0252766386,
0.0319651961,
0.0069622807,
0.0798952952,
0.0692081973,
-0.0151881101,
-0.0294003263,
0.0321570709,
-0.0181666259,
-0.0080912774,
0.0189481489,
0.0012492798,
0.0398697518,
-0.0041212603,
0.0213929843,
0.0764384568,
0.0036307408,
0.0206156429,
0.0176882185,
-0.0289728232,
-0.0602394678,
-0.0187551342,
0.0004366659,
-0.0076225931,
0.0493168905,
-0.0676345155,
-0.0133112511,
0.0232716743,
0.0120192403,
0.0393576436,
-0.0764163882,
0.0401059277,
-0.0158986803,
-0.0288445074,
-0.0375974588,
-0.001886052,
0.0227701422,
0.0392659232,
-0.0779757723,
-0.0441779867,
0.0225072671,
-0.0643568039,
0.0048298989,
0.0096614575,
0.0580513999,
0.0128374547,
0.1032991707,
0.0444287807,
0.0378027447,
-0.0041024885,
0.0211428776,
-0.0454391278,
0.0027846799,
0.0006012001,
0.0161854234,
0.023958452,
-0.0960279256,
-0.0008763016,
-0.0120605789,
-0.0301575605,
-0.0271452032,
0.0094909035,
-0.0184572469,
-0.0237666667,
-0.0309235398,
-0.0286271218,
0.0075949994,
0.044215437,
0.0060902974,
0.0040431786,
-0.0056749568,
-0.0436970331,
-0.025166681,
0.0476301424,
0.0727951303,
0.0110260369,
-0.0354729071,
-0.0148344794,
-0.0134801716,
0.059811648,
-0.0503139645,
0.0135877607,
-0.0703425035,
0.0475940518,
0.008289177,
0.0603019111,
-0.0022474616,
0.0231018011,
0.085150674,
-0.0343505479,
-0.052300822,
0.0420514755,
0.0303094573,
0.014745987,
0.0049554259,
0.0109682651,
0.0312784649,
-0.0015878859,
-0.0050361049,
-0.0486582518,
-0.0230047032,
-0.0181262121,
-0.059717007,
0.0299946629,
-0.031072583,
-0.0281668268,
-0.1057464406,
0.058372099,
0.0047410205,
-0.0768639818,
-0.0647633299,
0.0092476625,
0.0124399634,
0.0408662669,
-0.0376069061,
-0.0136926528,
-0.0019242375,
0.0317877829,
0.0200044475,
0.0096240938,
0.0136424107,
0.0018110579,
-0.0304484889,
-0.0072775157,
0.0138454149,
0.049808573,
0.0375666246,
-0.0560222529,
-0.0216012411,
0.04215765,
0.0366460979,
-0.0005979067,
0.0521812066,
0.0230199769,
-0.0206590556,
-0.0143778678,
0.0290332139,
-0.009601309,
-0.0318900943,
-0.0147910975,
0.0254212897,
-0.0000823034,
-0.0179566834,
-0.0507666655,
0.0542572178,
-0.0112815201,
0.0423669852,
0.0517916046,
-0.006784684,
-0.0490547605,
-0.0163975656,
0.0369795933,
-0.0733593181,
-0.0224061552,
0.0075091864,
-0.0053951661,
-0.0111503517,
-0.0664836019,
-0.0207310431,
0.0347760729,
0.0350123569,
-0.0079012103,
-0.0539418384,
-0.0270355139,
-0.0017702029,
-0.0595439672,
0.0699130446,
-0.0154889515,
0.0325715505,
0.0287832506,
0.0345080011,
-0.0191407222,
-0.0531794578,
-0.0235688817,
0.0295450054,
-0.070139952,
-0.0049847993,
-0.0415534377,
0.0750781,
0.0237386506,
0.0239378959,
0.0261576995,
-0.0230725631,
0.0054497798,
0.0543505512,
0.0020128079,
0.0297268312,
-0.02968028,
0.0200275872,
0.0154371476,
0.0129111744,
-0.0421814509,
0.0278881341,
0.0322693884,
0.0001629011,
-0.0249653049,
-0.0326295607,
0.0051636216,
-0.0326926447,
0.047001265,
-0.0234575775,
0.0212034006,
-0.0171323176,
-0.0152888792,
-0.0539371744,
-0.0071225334,
-0.0713436157,
0.0198396053,
0.0075837802,
0.0411125496,
-0.0211166348,
-0.0147722904,
-0.0007354261,
0.0519216992,
0.0065549761,
-0.0652045682,
0.0275498461,
-0.0021160545,
0.0195928495,
0.0130250435,
-0.0277458895,
-0.0126764029,
-0.0645834506,
0.0560289845,
0.0073472103,
0.0221251212,
0.0282158889,
-0.0360504501,
-0.0315160342,
0.0375081338,
-0.0033347085,
-0.0461876839,
-0.0521076731,
0.0283259265,
0.0629900917,
-0.0352017693,
0.0552953519,
-0.0311159734,
0.0080725383,
0.021859793,
0.052843459,
0.0164110232,
-0.0643583089,
0.0246953703,
-0.0095674014,
0.0077918191,
-0.0356283784,
0.0486017354,
-0.0105238995,
-0.0048062708,
-0.0165286399,
-0.0225699935,
-0.0080486285,
-0.0122158844,
0.0123009561,
-0.0173586756,
0.0176093653,
0.0191088784,
-0.0509349182,
-0.0581897497,
-0.0027007139,
0.0592805594,
0.0076522967,
0.0303030983,
0.0545078255,
0.0185696241,
-0.0100522367,
-0.0156837776,
0.0210856963,
-0.0089041237,
0.0003225041,
-0.0089428993,
-0.0240191538,
-6.069715039e-33,
-0.0486226305,
-0.0718458071,
0.0171262696,
-0.0376950316,
-0.0024685801,
0.007964178,
-0.0554487817,
-0.0031453078,
-0.0155316163,
0.0312981233,
0.0221840106,
-0.0219900813,
0.013065232,
0.0301706456,
-0.0059553874,
0.03361018,
0.020045856,
0.022666283,
-0.029160833,
-0.0063570044,
0.0343153961,
-0.007489251,
0.0366511904,
-0.0725982934,
-0.034919396,
0.0249308553,
-0.0252587032,
-0.0083263367,
0.0115191406,
0.0438944176,
-0.0223637391,
0.0068101208,
0.0241288319,
-0.0148530481,
-0.0209088605,
0.0435370021,
-0.0562551022,
-0.0335389636,
-0.0082157617,
0.0226742532,
-0.0765351281,
0.0063505042,
0.0514233299,
-0.0252700448,
-0.012891395,
-0.0722840205,
0.0686303228,
-0.032877218,
-0.0146152545,
-0.0065992214,
-0.050622981,
-0.017834669,
-0.045035053,
-0.0638060495,
0.0052932827,
0.0275541153,
0.0372615717,
0.035963241,
-0.0675106272,
0.0242302734,
-0.0077769794,
0.0104713729,
0.0680593029,
0.0187934656,
-0.0016438109,
0.0733222663,
0.0449702479,
-0.0259591937,
-0.0501278006,
-0.0030938738,
0.0218916759,
0.061830841,
0.0355108008,
0.0550054647,
0.031747248,
0.021553142,
-0.0312411487,
0.0475746728,
-0.0913495496,
0.0408587381,
0.0084420852,
-0.0016052431,
-0.0193177536,
-0.0034725552,
-0.0293815788,
-0.0321549736,
-0.0439832546,
-0.0060650739,
0.0264570247,
0.0011528034,
0.015809169,
0.017935276,
0.0232513715,
-0.0130790612,
-0.0245507341,
-0.020968372,
-0.0667873546,
0.0494687408,
-0.0212137979,
0.0133210346,
-0.0132896062,
-0.034114778,
0.0404495783,
0.0625135452,
0.022105163,
0.0273131952,
0.0504027791,
-0.0021660898,
-0.0262515172,
-0.0232913345,
-0.0635529608,
-0.0203099009,
-0.001368585,
-0.0220337324,
0.0277008805,
0.009872132,
-0.0366567895,
0.0181000959,
-0.0333251804,
-0.0063300207,
-0.020484658,
-0.0123413624,
-0.0368832089,
0.0012572937,
-0.010554173,
0.0099229738,
-0.057008639,
-0.0597368367,
0.0800911486,
-0.0772965401,
-0.0438619703,
0.0121725034,
2.818e-7,
0.0302324481,
0.0328976773,
0.0003666153,
0.0010238634,
-0.0072052646,
0.0402733944,
-0.0016075668,
0.0336656868,
-0.0240569357,
-0.0069553992,
0.0007914745,
0.0661081821,
0.0494203158,
-0.0138005633,
-0.0312041175,
0.0560520962,
-0.0586611889,
-0.0053292243,
-0.06952703,
0.0046335468,
0.0805226043,
0.0117744226,
-0.0146871125,
-0.0137945944,
0.0098524624,
-0.0199070219,
0.0633870289,
-0.0471461602,
0.0477201492,
-0.0002990401,
0.0204749033,
-0.031173354,
-0.0123456353,
0.0306254011,
-0.0116939023,
-0.0520229526,
0.0525756031,
0.0318848751,
-0.0345764719,
0.0059928969,
-0.0111792777,
-0.037306115,
-0.0239959937,
-0.078138046,
0.058375366,
-0.0701203272,
0.0069225873,
0.0156059256,
-0.015245365,
0.0203302931,
0.00115227,
0.0096242744,
-0.0230729822,
0.0076833586,
0.0468047038,
-0.0082739275,
-0.017535612,
-0.042766545,
-0.0632460639,
0.0001083198,
-0.0113152433,
0.0119922115,
-0.0554550365,
-0.0000729616,
0.0314484388,
0.0183878224,
-0.0693656281,
2.246995563e-34,
-0.0294495374,
0.0329417363,
0.0296025686,
-0.037797723,
0.0561192781,
-0.0244939402,
-0.0327697434,
0.0238339808,
-0.0204063449,
-0.0216793399,
-0.0059780604
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10013v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10013v2 | DocAsRef: An Empirical Study on Repurposing Reference-Based Summary Quality Metrics Reference-Freely | 2022-12-20T06:01:13 | 2023-11-26T05:05:51 | Forrest Sheng Bao, Ruixuan Tu, Ge Luo, Yinfei Yang, Hebi Li, Minghui Qiu, Youbiao He, Cen Chen | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Automated summary quality assessment falls into two categories:
reference-based and reference-free. Reference-based metrics, historically
deemed more accurate due to the additional information provided by
human-written references, are limited by their reliance on human input. In this
paper, we hypothesize that the comparison methodologies used by some
reference-based metrics to evaluate a system summary against its corresponding
reference can be effectively adapted to assess it against its source document,
thereby transforming these metrics into reference-free ones. Experimental
results support this hypothesis. After being repurposed reference-freely, the
zero-shot BERTScore using the pretrained DeBERTa-large-MNLI model of <0.5B
parameters consistently outperforms its original reference-based version across
various aspects on the SummEval and Newsroom datasets. It also excels in
comparison to most existing reference-free metrics and closely competes with
zero-shot summary evaluators based on GPT-3.5. | [
0.044405397,
0.0001302862,
0.0191230178,
-0.0192793086,
-0.0188520662,
0.0147873079,
-0.0294140875,
0.0319051147,
-0.0849439427,
-0.0605617501,
-0.037203595,
0.0094192661,
0.0309367422,
-0.0382723361,
-0.0020422228,
-0.0718738139,
0.0131569309,
0.0276877154,
0.0302728675,
0.0162393153,
0.0624626353,
-0.0207867511,
0.0112541327,
0.0294005014,
-0.0179034378,
0.0023464104,
0.0048975996,
0.0238760039,
0.0337846875,
-0.0168923642,
-0.0228319969,
0.0273013804,
-0.0306475479,
0.0368314385,
0.0000018002,
-0.0645599142,
-0.030411765,
0.0499075912,
0.009175186,
0.0678930655,
0.0566371903,
-0.0057288273,
-0.0063596508,
-0.0025477346,
0.0159830432,
-0.0020903561,
0.0189057961,
0.0415623598,
0.065444611,
0.0394981429,
-0.0163240172,
-0.0127472449,
-0.0090303654,
0.0211486034,
0.0146072805,
-0.0397342183,
-0.0208514836,
0.0828283876,
0.0028092503,
-0.0200964231,
0.0293298531,
0.0217544138,
-0.0134721156,
-0.0480634719,
0.016357651,
-0.0060744686,
-0.0863729268,
0.0254618675,
0.04031156,
0.0417599082,
0.0161497276,
-0.0045371717,
0.0101867085,
-0.0119637195,
0.0161709115,
0.0186055824,
-0.0571536757,
-0.0219285097,
-0.0086250994,
0.0056537115,
-0.0394390784,
0.0183975156,
-0.0054710619,
-0.0128112016,
0.0156232528,
0.0141097102,
0.0035561721,
-0.0417598002,
0.0302167051,
0.0160500668,
0.0155941378,
-0.0383757465,
-0.0025235151,
0.0361561142,
0.0109398607,
-0.0311497021,
-0.0256262459,
-0.0822232589,
0.0591382012,
-0.0715975389,
0.0314002857,
-0.0067909677,
0.0049111652,
0.0406461246,
0.0051192841,
0.063653633,
0.027444629,
-0.0211437698,
-0.0390621535,
-0.0324298963,
-0.0359158702,
0.0236218702,
-0.024146948,
0.0625728145,
-0.0077576777,
-0.0167863686,
-0.0752242282,
0.0165366903,
-0.0159546696,
0.0259266999,
0.0210008249,
-0.0248329025,
-0.0094760731,
-0.0050258068,
-0.0135442931,
0.0012482167,
-0.0196911041,
-0.0177017618,
-0.0312997997,
0.0214058589,
0.0104373004,
0.0275584441,
0.0036750981,
0.0267011523,
0.0058030784,
0.0335993841,
0.0254560672,
-0.0266766846,
-0.0246281195,
-0.0304482915,
-0.0166031197,
-0.0570671335,
-0.0264404155,
-0.0575959571,
-0.0150367254,
0.0251128245,
-0.0205072276,
0.0401156843,
-0.0229744781,
0.0100950683,
-0.0028614742,
-0.0081070624,
-0.0384560451,
0.038397681,
0.0001569922,
-0.0204511527,
-0.0248175599,
0.0537479073,
0.0514876731,
-0.0011057851,
0.0527394861,
0.0465327501,
0.0354173593,
0.0298463199,
-0.0054763597,
0.0346219614,
0.0110431481,
0.0041022357,
-0.029201176,
-0.0207104348,
0.0249656327,
0.044959113,
-0.0478508808,
0.0201662611,
0.0601425506,
0.0293560196,
0.0586966164,
0.0052423337,
0.0273020659,
0.038275972,
0.049455151,
0.044704929,
0.0210741926,
0.0320094973,
0.0126145333,
0.0625942945,
0.070071727,
-0.0336274467,
-0.0200315397,
-0.0466947891,
-0.0178850777,
0.0011604169,
-0.0262493379,
-0.0425026007,
0.0336739346,
0.004231465,
-0.0564053096,
0.0563463867,
-0.0050382474,
-0.0565084815,
0.0159707144,
-0.020241851,
0.0638832748,
0.0406827219,
0.0637983531,
-0.0601239018,
0.018466901,
-0.0085154083,
-0.0242390689,
0.0271135941,
0.0387772918,
-0.0239638407,
-0.0090813022,
-0.0825229958,
-0.0513849221,
-0.0361974612,
0.0259148572,
0.0145248827,
-0.017945433,
0.0058447924,
0.0396530777,
-0.069995299,
-0.0782210156,
0.0080294302,
0.0603670031,
-0.0093757957,
-0.0027987566,
-0.0010294603,
0.0352397114,
0.0360345989,
-0.0407143943,
0.0206830129,
0.0132217025,
0.0302904733,
-0.010332318,
0.0011755668,
0.0083436333,
0.0316630118,
0.0229161102,
-0.0530966371,
0.021342326,
0.0141094718,
-0.0071659461,
-0.0462067649,
-0.0075493339,
-0.0743338391,
0.0226682164,
-0.0389845408,
0.0405183285,
-0.0228065923,
-0.0182183497,
-0.0080966111,
0.0428786464,
0.019343704,
0.0331711173,
0.0438858755,
-0.0389861204,
0.0728317276,
-0.0222770423,
-0.0379356854,
-0.0264012888,
-0.0215571765,
0.0499658883,
0.0739184767,
0.0157794636,
-0.0314713791,
-0.046892643,
-0.1024763063,
-0.0185606219,
-0.022066677,
0.0416173711,
0.0409441032,
-0.0162041411,
0.0003996507,
0.0144254006,
0.0076383944,
-0.0372126587,
-0.0137980627,
0.0107709058,
0.0510629565,
0.0250514317,
0.0595669001,
-0.0477723032,
-0.0256341565,
0.0106652668,
0.0563606024,
0.0447013862,
0.0210877135,
-0.0548003055,
0.0086260512,
-0.0154042458,
-0.0438104868,
0.0342123881,
-0.0037878419,
0.0173120182,
-0.0034385764,
0.0188413821,
0.0131106395,
0.0044022654,
-0.0371555015,
0.0468164533,
-0.0215655752,
-0.0560859405,
-0.010361854,
-0.0035939191,
0.0035817556,
0.0455723479,
-0.0275471136,
0.0221304465,
-0.0230009351,
-0.0084274663,
0.0017090305,
-0.0525990874,
0.0078287497,
-0.0367620699,
0.0124425255,
-0.0397428982,
-0.0253475141,
-0.0026606892,
0.0395686515,
0.0104250209,
-0.0285600405,
0.0159676485,
-0.0524083115,
0.034539137,
-0.0531153865,
0.0364843048,
-0.0573790446,
-0.0004610674,
-0.0380909964,
-0.0035735632,
-0.0106811197,
-0.0020368765,
-0.0165682957,
-0.0137556447,
0.0702400804,
-0.0292750131,
0.0481405966,
-0.0153143024,
-0.0000645927,
-0.0120208859,
0.0220062379,
-0.0020677519,
0.0152568258,
-0.0015367728,
0.022956185,
0.0279085524,
-0.0102248779,
-0.0665951073,
0.0858405307,
0.0543091409,
0.0641057417,
-0.0199278034,
-0.0271200892,
0.029481791,
0.0442630723,
0.0046968297,
-0.0504349954,
0.0298083667,
-0.0167331379,
-0.024358049,
0.0265760273,
0.0456187092,
0.0321249217,
-0.0085889846,
-0.0452861711,
-0.0494445451,
-0.0372471847,
-0.0123852603,
-0.0116658602,
-0.0023539199,
-0.0648792237,
-0.0075304895,
0.0956367403,
0.0134411119,
-0.0219109915,
-0.0508203246,
-0.017271731,
0.0016162507,
0.0033908763,
-0.0028849512,
-0.0414607972,
0.005790309,
-0.0069436044,
0.0482949391,
0.0101690441,
-0.009212845,
0.0125323096,
-0.0777492523,
0.0093670823,
-0.0007019617,
-0.0569029413,
-0.0246415306,
-0.0750433952,
0.024489766,
-0.0383714661,
-0.0216894597,
0.014714418,
-0.011962641,
0.0168210436,
-0.0144256102,
-0.0727783814,
0.0020577514,
-0.0131995697,
-0.0464693233,
0.006412121,
0.0673642755,
0.0618823245,
-0.0019650813,
0.0089745419,
0.0318839289,
-0.080407083,
-0.0304317996,
0.0170448832,
0.0970874727,
-0.0084672067,
0.0257754978,
-0.0240333714,
-0.0251382329,
0.0632449314,
0.0226027854,
-0.0163460765,
-0.0005338736,
0.0219661146,
0.0043195426,
-0.0436178371,
0.0426409543,
-0.0169468056,
0.042068433,
0.0456124768,
0.0043207537,
-0.0177900121,
0.0018407672,
-0.0135761593,
-0.0560152195,
0.047489468,
-0.0058974964,
-0.093529582,
-0.0586012714,
-0.0969143733,
-0.0571249127,
-0.0280608535,
0.0059267422,
-0.0043999762,
-0.0115278214,
0.0022111435,
-0.0172589961,
-0.032042291,
-0.0238226131,
0.010288585,
-0.0108856801,
-0.0339394435,
0.0067957216,
0.0427240841,
0.0083680823,
-0.0174020343,
0.0154181169,
0.0128110312,
-0.0217972714,
-0.0315822549,
0.0425052717,
0.0258531217,
0.0029176583,
-0.0223787855,
0.0071691982,
0.0621600412,
0.0167011749,
0.0145635195,
0.0380016789,
0.0331806578,
0.0098247668,
-0.0272428747,
0.0043193665,
-0.1052123681,
0.0110351993,
-0.0322517641,
0.0151900686,
0.0101127392,
0.0014669828,
-0.0126746912,
0.0595175065,
0.018734904,
-0.0036450333,
0.0157846902,
-0.0048131417,
0.0078509524,
-0.0231242049,
-0.0316737704,
-0.0209063962,
0.0265156776,
-0.0193838067,
-0.0049735736,
-0.0318043642,
0.1037558466,
-0.0640513003,
0.0462898239,
-0.0130191343,
-0.0132298619,
-0.0063419803,
-0.004082826,
-0.0544320159,
-0.0376781933,
-0.0470327921,
-0.0442247614,
0.0043376461,
-0.0102928961,
0.0182858258,
0.0124107171,
0.0526022427,
0.0356521942,
0.0405494198,
0.0488476157,
-0.0541290045,
0.0658519641,
-0.0659724697,
-0.0086104665,
0.0192007218,
-0.0174388029,
0.1095961705,
-0.0129029388,
-0.0106973406,
-0.0188629497,
0.039680019,
0.0232187826,
0.0154210003,
-0.0286124311,
0.0292442124,
0.0097328825,
0.0298203845,
0.0554974973,
-0.0315562971,
-0.0102841519,
-0.0385797583,
-0.0416199788,
-0.0279763304,
-0.0079970714,
-0.0508496948,
0.0127990143,
0.0001628592,
-0.0485290326,
-0.083612442,
-0.0078985319,
0.0508033261,
0.0397303998,
0.0288059488,
-0.0036895252,
0.0233421549,
0.0263722502,
0.0112175886,
0.02655017,
-0.0270724148,
-0.0506958775,
-0.0168396588,
0.0029701032,
-0.0174124464,
-5.445693577e-33,
-0.0313741602,
-0.0320869796,
-0.0432697199,
0.0089796837,
-0.0427416377,
0.0122857904,
-0.0304964129,
-0.0553039722,
0.0261300579,
0.0256806966,
0.0033124546,
0.0161309373,
0.0164867397,
-0.046041023,
-0.0048019853,
0.0130457524,
0.0359373949,
0.0077246572,
-0.0778772011,
0.0254903492,
0.0455822311,
-0.029181147,
0.0304961279,
-0.0569462813,
0.0231554136,
-0.0256515946,
-0.0238568299,
-0.044099275,
0.059558738,
0.0488294177,
0.0247402843,
0.0193085466,
0.0294028316,
-0.0100724883,
-0.0254321527,
0.0057371911,
-0.046785593,
-0.0203426741,
0.0289749503,
-0.0491406955,
0.0521503612,
-0.0082156109,
0.0357570872,
-0.0099732541,
-0.0160057135,
-0.0349162295,
0.0564027987,
-0.0486854203,
-0.0362549461,
-0.0854005218,
-0.0246524531,
0.0424783453,
-0.0167883877,
0.0047972049,
0.0131801488,
0.0571123064,
0.0012763793,
-0.0122672301,
-0.0227697846,
0.0267680455,
0.032523524,
0.0266295932,
0.0116093997,
-0.0195175335,
0.0256902296,
0.0093974611,
-0.0003256933,
-0.014915389,
0.0184879899,
-0.0589977056,
0.0192928296,
-0.0144041991,
0.068803601,
0.0481319241,
0.0478551947,
0.0230562259,
-0.0364558101,
0.0930434912,
-0.0405144952,
0.0881123841,
0.0054174555,
-0.0056738909,
-0.0280317701,
-0.0024866909,
-0.0365135334,
-0.0262193494,
-0.0343725756,
-0.0143179428,
0.0082319779,
0.0020126873,
-0.0217936095,
-0.0204156879,
-0.0042167772,
-0.0111563997,
0.0356545039,
0.0381423831,
-0.0549791493,
0.040901266,
-0.0022240011,
-0.0346244089,
-0.0225740634,
0.0291076563,
0.0396040566,
0.0810382813,
0.0053459434,
-0.0193806104,
0.0754973814,
0.0307556316,
-0.0338745974,
0.0112093445,
0.0276827365,
-0.0141463652,
-0.0382101834,
-0.0196737647,
-0.0341641791,
-0.0264852941,
-0.0136580206,
0.0389643945,
-0.0126381526,
0.0430102684,
0.0033237347,
-0.0135332663,
0.0322591774,
0.0156702735,
-0.0088835666,
0.0179880187,
0.0090374127,
0.027667813,
0.0616515204,
-0.008941357,
-0.0185736232,
0.0109702256,
2.499e-7,
0.0366429128,
0.035984531,
0.0272790771,
-0.0083556743,
-0.0172984656,
0.0186575465,
-0.033767622,
0.0264466032,
-0.0019894685,
0.0304849055,
0.0384924039,
-0.0436504148,
0.041893173,
0.0357924551,
-0.0760814324,
-0.0605745055,
-0.0901090726,
-0.067156665,
-0.0163818337,
-0.0040861554,
-0.0276146028,
0.0203486662,
0.0062978505,
-0.0002502693,
-0.0023314303,
-0.0394007564,
0.0380437449,
-0.0059755165,
-0.0329912603,
0.0231617112,
0.135537535,
0.0145143615,
-0.0159608312,
0.0019139959,
-0.0297693685,
0.0164834801,
0.0662251562,
0.0285020247,
0.0033113803,
-0.0286709182,
0.0593968444,
-0.0499970764,
-0.0025171356,
0.016069198,
0.0160422307,
0.0015328676,
0.0079340767,
-0.0058389949,
-0.0981852189,
-0.0006226346,
0.0107850498,
-0.001225159,
-0.0312697068,
0.0407663658,
-0.0330838375,
0.0092147635,
0.0200975407,
-0.0292591378,
-0.0080998242,
0.0065191127,
0.0499226898,
-0.0773909763,
0.0166305713,
-0.0429044031,
0.002045562,
-0.110771507,
0.0453222692,
1.942633214e-34,
0.110010244,
-0.0452523269,
-0.0279532056,
-0.0559780225,
0.0291185752,
-0.0142990677,
-0.0238121543,
-0.0119027197,
-0.0057347044,
-0.047778137,
0.002941092
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2212.10012v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2212.10012v1 | Language Modeling with Latent Situations | 2022-12-20T05:59:42 | 2022-12-20T05:59:42 | Belinda Z. Li, Maxwell Nye, Jacob Andreas | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language models (LMs) often generate incoherent outputs: they refer to events
and entity states that are incompatible with the state of the world described
in their inputs. We introduce SituationSupervision, a family of approaches for
improving coherence in LMs by training them to construct and condition on
explicit representations of entities and their states. SituationSupervision has
two components: an auxiliary situation modeling task that trains models to
predict state representations in context, and a latent state inference
procedure that imputes these states from partially annotated training data.
SituationSupervision can be applied to both fine-tuning (by supervising LMs to
encode state variables in their hidden representations) and prompting (by
inducing LMs to interleave textual descriptions of entity states with output
text). In both cases, SituationSupervision requires only a small number of
state annotations to produce major coherence improvements (between 4-11%),
showing that standard LMs can be sample-efficiently trained to model not just
language but the situations it describes. | [
0.0185348801,
0.0375447087,
-0.0185504723,
0.0486464202,
-0.042922359,
0.0019676816,
-0.0006257708,
-0.0349232778,
-0.0025951122,
-0.0806103349,
0.0221782122,
-0.0063959667,
-0.0263029616,
0.0516097024,
0.0378227681,
-0.0833506882,
0.0604070611,
-0.0147788161,
0.0202247128,
0.0110016167,
0.0037119619,
0.0278308354,
-0.0251911078,
0.0440573692,
-0.0328823701,
-0.045783639,
-0.0325912125,
0.0115507422,
0.0353799574,
-0.0211978443,
0.0008817303,
0.0299749672,
0.0786689222,
-0.064861156,
0.0000020995,
-0.0441548787,
0.0045186006,
-0.0561684482,
-0.0013730755,
-0.0185440313,
-0.0145134293,
-0.0532961227,
0.0034903951,
0.0109427134,
-0.0291443244,
-0.0027954197,
0.0052513964,
0.0520101115,
0.0528690889,
0.0752013773,
-0.0188900195,
0.0213481914,
-0.0174934715,
-0.0080925925,
0.0055902964,
-0.0265391357,
0.0007072827,
0.013187984,
0.0076455572,
-0.006846142,
-0.0158058982,
0.0354388691,
0.0292637236,
-0.0151190152,
-0.0348814912,
0.0535660535,
0.0171694532,
0.0045099477,
0.0058423928,
0.0655290261,
0.0123104965,
-0.0164534766,
-0.0029991362,
-0.0331471488,
0.0056222761,
-0.0174333677,
0.0134514915,
0.0141371973,
-0.0066803116,
0.0595393591,
0.0466661081,
0.0197207537,
0.020759495,
0.019445179,
-0.000293478,
0.0434868708,
-0.0016194687,
-0.0450822189,
-0.0648065209,
0.0079934234,
-0.0362497829,
-0.0647784546,
0.0278902091,
0.0580601804,
-0.0670473278,
0.0337046385,
-0.055295635,
0.0067398306,
0.0190699082,
-0.0482513979,
-0.0068818484,
0.0522614866,
-0.0419772975,
0.0723738745,
0.0289800186,
0.0429091305,
0.0384932682,
-0.0228448957,
-0.0265503414,
-0.0099769551,
-0.0446896069,
0.0100195268,
-0.0464852005,
0.00166916,
-0.0402635783,
-0.0152151268,
-0.0118870046,
0.0436361656,
-0.0006987468,
0.0201063659,
-0.0241979174,
0.0479855016,
-0.0584891587,
-0.0059571927,
-0.0279988106,
0.0021112461,
-0.0203054342,
0.0277601555,
0.0045458097,
-0.0327715948,
-0.0147395022,
0.0098324204,
0.0194708332,
-0.0182459317,
-0.0419130251,
0.0441971458,
0.013533311,
-0.0301347841,
-0.0788040683,
-0.0234367903,
-0.0053144833,
-0.0523147993,
-0.0353903137,
-0.0211700071,
0.0311400052,
-0.0053655677,
0.0125389667,
-0.0552164838,
0.0213688537,
-0.0032309957,
0.0074193063,
0.0613724813,
-0.0066374494,
-0.0044253543,
0.0083076479,
0.0355593041,
0.0410132073,
0.0569246411,
0.0510013849,
0.0115499897,
-0.0142070996,
0.0049831634,
0.02637228,
0.0217188224,
-0.0187164824,
0.0077237198,
-0.0037784739,
0.0102147777,
-0.0363832153,
0.0401269644,
0.0761866346,
0.0432802513,
-0.0164826252,
-0.0028078882,
0.067222409,
0.0221752115,
0.038529776,
-0.0136219664,
0.0693396181,
0.0523574986,
-0.0170038771,
0.0252847672,
-0.0633296371,
0.0331996009,
-0.0019010295,
0.0196863245,
0.0097471327,
0.0390406586,
-0.0377257317,
-0.0441289954,
-0.0160459988,
-0.0369196832,
0.0009449905,
0.0094123436,
0.0258599818,
0.0329300687,
-0.056391485,
0.0317536853,
0.0552880391,
-0.016162036,
0.0161050092,
-0.0294697843,
0.032083299,
0.0972440094,
0.0394743606,
-0.0312742814,
-0.0304526892,
-0.0373826027,
0.0016330787,
0.0608929284,
0.0077230465,
-0.0278718788,
0.0604440123,
-0.0362459943,
-0.0104364958,
-0.0177654903,
0.0463013873,
-0.0109747788,
-0.0170261934,
-0.015609703,
0.0187039003,
-0.0040388131,
0.0303811915,
0.0566211902,
-0.0197497234,
-0.0259674098,
-0.0276274476,
-0.0014761728,
0.0083076917,
0.0233702008,
0.0216561276,
-0.000784003,
0.0267430414,
-0.0188224763,
0.0088726487,
0.0186853949,
-0.0796534568,
-0.1019394174,
0.003952398,
0.0138407638,
-0.0389888734,
-0.0236645881,
-0.0418714285,
-0.0610903315,
0.0222758092,
-0.03207599,
0.041048944,
-0.0626574084,
-0.0056388592,
0.0212337654,
-0.0123921661,
-0.0202724095,
0.0882139578,
-0.0325013064,
-0.0190033745,
0.0044887303,
0.0223237108,
-0.0379041098,
-0.0409925096,
0.001549216,
-0.0309305284,
0.0184653196,
0.0113679077,
-0.0152762774,
0.024433434,
-0.043731574,
-0.0245485976,
-0.080137305,
-0.0022940002,
-0.0479334779,
-0.0112672858,
0.0256774258,
-0.00722933,
-0.0045228242,
-0.0282867551,
-0.0106666684,
0.0132101504,
0.0226002485,
0.0043006917,
0.0321293846,
0.0019344256,
-0.0178862568,
-0.0876426846,
0.0354790241,
-0.0320041217,
0.0346444063,
-0.0103332503,
-0.0504737645,
-0.0994301587,
0.0686393082,
-0.0268822759,
0.0246791132,
-0.0221181698,
0.0008433508,
0.0177352354,
0.0165143423,
0.0863521397,
0.0153600303,
0.0096098026,
0.0933934376,
0.0613937266,
-0.0166868381,
-0.0769666955,
0.0334415548,
-0.0202960279,
0.0270850901,
-0.0716943517,
-0.0282739345,
0.001241992,
0.0424768776,
0.0208630525,
0.0098188985,
-0.0643000379,
0.0096452245,
-0.0105371187,
-0.038333606,
-0.0039263675,
-0.0285493117,
-0.0281843897,
0.0143675571,
-0.0360507369,
-0.0046640984,
0.0827336088,
-0.0275754053,
0.0076202364,
-0.009424448,
-0.0408256277,
-0.0126655726,
0.0390945934,
0.0156480949,
0.006534657,
0.0032321045,
-0.0248745773,
-0.0445456356,
-0.0008344285,
0.0005531883,
-0.0146830948,
0.0394219533,
-0.0442146808,
-0.0083535686,
0.0126236686,
-0.0538859926,
-0.0705129877,
-0.0446986631,
-0.0034489662,
0.0456100293,
-0.0189045761,
0.0234674551,
-0.0256372914,
0.0161694568,
-0.0058704191,
0.0244232733,
0.0143111069,
-0.0298245009,
-0.0389587544,
0.0013731553,
0.0704118907,
0.0445924476,
-0.0107949534,
-0.0320964865,
0.0289177932,
0.0323791504,
0.0217063166,
-0.0013391087,
-0.0323720053,
0.0166145992,
-0.0004502606,
-0.0121658724,
-0.0289023593,
0.0332907662,
0.0260976143,
-0.0658844486,
-0.0284088086,
0.1287370473,
0.0162894353,
-0.0344923474,
0.0204787664,
-0.0430850349,
0.0083675804,
0.0162402093,
0.0208179932,
-0.0737652704,
-0.0193265304,
-0.0070961518,
-0.0135445772,
0.016330827,
-0.0373252966,
0.001289563,
-0.0597463585,
0.0143222185,
-0.0181510001,
-0.0377586596,
-0.0381026864,
-0.0287082456,
0.0252821371,
0.0054558017,
0.0576845892,
-0.017583238,
-0.011591848,
-0.0034033933,
0.0334747098,
-0.0094671212,
-0.080758512,
0.0044929101,
-0.0343009159,
0.0976538882,
0.0609538108,
0.0344602019,
0.0041374993,
-0.007136602,
0.0083839828,
0.001787566,
0.0321188048,
-0.003513051,
0.019224992,
-0.0500006564,
0.0025910228,
-0.0266590398,
0.0230827592,
-0.0059263851,
-0.0507547855,
0.004441312,
0.0539547391,
-0.064902477,
0.0043883147,
0.0135180745,
0.0096660573,
0.0716323927,
0.0657421947,
0.0566653311,
-0.0307950191,
-0.0186853651,
-0.0235980079,
0.0166170541,
0.0047500441,
0.0304251723,
-0.0471287668,
0.0214056093,
0.0307103489,
-0.0607585646,
-0.090532355,
0.0689644888,
-0.0016537422,
0.0267949197,
0.0032976633,
0.0427451879,
-0.0471119061,
-0.0145597607,
0.0286445003,
-0.0250139758,
-0.0185029209,
0.0249236133,
-0.016524462,
0.0249849837,
-0.022671286,
-0.0137336096,
-0.0194693245,
-0.0451734476,
-0.072146073,
0.0447747186,
0.0536203124,
0.0168459062,
0.0560314767,
-0.0433904864,
-0.0566445291,
-0.0024124568,
-0.0019097071,
-0.0520941801,
0.0308600813,
0.0181422215,
0.0429380909,
0.0160693135,
0.0449180976,
-0.039194338,
0.0144664813,
-0.0018744102,
0.0615380518,
-0.0743606463,
-0.0679335222,
0.0228357464,
-0.0574361123,
0.0611616932,
-0.0109671159,
-0.0241489951,
-0.0752203092,
-0.0224928502,
-0.0321003534,
-0.0164833739,
-0.0424849577,
0.0255620498,
0.014344044,
0.0192753263,
-0.0027731725,
0.0275739487,
-0.0157635082,
0.0485612899,
-0.0143872071,
-0.0062317341,
0.0533786006,
-0.0242603533,
-0.0053074644,
0.008976168,
-0.0287145693,
0.0568445437,
-0.0051899804,
0.0346843489,
-0.016580984,
0.0805566907,
0.0055143437,
-0.0086144358,
-0.0259044897,
-0.0008677553,
-0.0298039224,
0.0180438738,
-0.0270737428,
0.0733028129,
0.0714511722,
-0.0081314147,
0.0699637458,
-0.0258647334,
0.0227873698,
0.0133888135,
0.0943338871,
0.0335131809,
-0.0640621558,
0.0352621078,
0.0347214714,
-0.0369225033,
0.0344322622,
0.0529926941,
-0.0003861861,
0.0645881146,
-0.0047158534,
0.0384744406,
-0.0296593346,
0.0056016012,
0.0103340475,
0.0640082583,
-0.0372006148,
0.0377442241,
-0.0389691293,
-0.0413984731,
-0.0094144391,
0.0223395433,
-0.0351990797,
-0.0186478663,
0.0253160596,
0.020527726,
0.0087970011,
-0.0343194269,
-0.0502852239,
-0.0105346302,
0.0248928349,
-0.0233140998,
-0.0561302826,
-6.630816696e-33,
-0.0795846283,
-0.0476508066,
0.0399982147,
-0.0182842817,
-0.0194723662,
0.0056570149,
-0.0655666068,
0.004093965,
-0.0145594943,
0.0312695466,
-0.0089597125,
0.0436175503,
0.0171699561,
0.0184035227,
-0.0115514407,
-0.0369030647,
0.0615240298,
0.0243184064,
0.0083980449,
0.0082242219,
0.0373505279,
0.0348317437,
0.0469450392,
-0.0846435651,
0.0370905437,
-0.0342057198,
-0.0411680155,
0.0398821495,
-0.0125678126,
0.0172349308,
-0.0614669137,
0.0297640823,
0.0337434113,
-0.0163250733,
-0.0138464076,
0.0113973171,
-0.0655739084,
-0.0367868133,
0.0417789482,
-0.0275794305,
-0.0558954962,
-0.026119316,
-0.0104829771,
-0.0012549264,
0.0419988744,
0.0297089294,
0.0565417744,
-0.0017004539,
-0.0097982241,
-0.0280752834,
-0.0942397788,
0.0158767607,
-0.0037704979,
-0.0125745116,
0.0203845967,
0.0172540527,
0.0071292906,
-0.0389958844,
-0.0319046862,
-0.0175010245,
0.0039542816,
0.0083247814,
0.0457915664,
0.00023317,
-0.0354693122,
0.1001600474,
-0.0051757186,
-0.0046093729,
-0.1055813879,
-0.0013963069,
0.0301109497,
0.0291669834,
-0.0035458251,
0.0273651909,
-0.0211946666,
-0.012810586,
-0.0368780196,
0.0176675767,
-0.005735564,
0.0156028038,
0.027605122,
0.0104681337,
-0.0378078185,
-0.0233291797,
-0.0318118073,
0.0147139961,
-0.0129798437,
-0.039543137,
0.0183867365,
-0.0004176155,
-0.0290882066,
-0.0179450605,
-0.0029792232,
-0.0017767098,
-0.0366741903,
-0.0198891312,
0.0219934974,
-0.0199153554,
-0.0122335004,
0.0279230401,
-0.0473411269,
-0.0428750142,
0.0378298648,
0.0069378661,
0.0285019949,
0.0022202446,
0.0618001856,
0.0221118666,
-0.0445608757,
0.0102624483,
-0.0398245007,
0.0226266049,
-0.0473402441,
-0.0049096588,
0.0172094926,
0.0063536358,
-0.0226301439,
0.0246887505,
0.0163819194,
-0.0295523107,
-0.0147367008,
-0.01137063,
-0.0296600182,
0.0395009778,
-0.0279873777,
-0.0121641466,
-0.0280218981,
0.0366286151,
0.0450275652,
-0.0138264075,
0.0035174261,
0.0492706224,
2.656e-7,
0.0615688376,
0.0342032611,
0.0155315353,
-0.000352297,
0.0016654271,
0.0334609598,
-0.0126852039,
0.0345345065,
0.0222147442,
-0.0184131768,
0.0063783829,
0.0515856519,
0.0365684256,
0.0320268609,
-0.0573212579,
0.0112076392,
-0.0620811023,
-0.0239456408,
-0.0613831393,
-0.0110562574,
0.0800105706,
0.0717032254,
0.0330165736,
0.0117574045,
0.0224126428,
-0.012881672,
0.0444203466,
-0.0447048731,
-0.0409283228,
0.0074508647,
0.0074685556,
0.0242784396,
0.0292382799,
-0.004553528,
0.0138702681,
0.0237339567,
-0.0339275897,
0.0891627893,
0.0028155213,
-0.0193431377,
-0.0206800904,
0.0199596453,
-0.0009586837,
-0.0274957661,
0.0521388054,
-0.0824781805,
-0.0157158338,
-0.0196394213,
-0.0116939023,
0.0100954771,
-0.0040818369,
0.0260964725,
-0.0471799485,
-0.0037607301,
-0.0023155196,
-0.0045984718,
-0.0271385834,
-0.0741251335,
-0.0548282936,
0.0005554979,
-0.028809743,
-0.0018654244,
0.009235559,
0.0198163725,
0.0466571674,
-0.0585776307,
0.0058817999,
2.491953892e-34,
0.0273731872,
0.0211961623,
0.0122203426,
0.0652578697,
0.015022872,
0.0088122059,
-0.0342169255,
0.0113644991,
0.0079411156,
-0.0403625779,
-0.0152044417
] |
Subsets and Splits