id
stringlengths
33
34
doc_url
stringlengths
33
34
title
stringlengths
10
211
publication_date
timestamp[s]
update_date
timestamp[s]
authors
stringlengths
5
20.1k
category_primary
stringclasses
78 values
category_all
stringlengths
5
138
abstract
stringlengths
123
3.09k
embeddings
sequencelengths
768
768
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.07067v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.07067v2
Transformers as Algorithms: Generalization and Stability in In-context Learning
2023-01-17T18:31:12
2023-02-06T08:03:15
Yingcong Li, M. Emrullah Ildiz, Dimitris Papailiopoulos, Samet Oymak
cs.LG
cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML
In-context learning (ICL) is a type of prompting where a transformer model operates on a sequence of (input, output) examples and performs inference on-the-fly. In this work, we formalize in-context learning as an algorithm learning problem where a transformer model implicitly constructs a hypothesis function at inference-time. We first explore the statistical aspects of this abstraction through the lens of multitask learning: We obtain generalization bounds for ICL when the input prompt is (1) a sequence of i.i.d. (input, label) pairs or (2) a trajectory arising from a dynamical system. The crux of our analysis is relating the excess risk to the stability of the algorithm implemented by the transformer. We characterize when transformer/attention architecture provably obeys the stability condition and also provide empirical verification. For generalization on unseen tasks, we identify an inductive bias phenomenon in which the transfer learning risk is governed by the task complexity and the number of MTL tasks in a highly predictable manner. Finally, we provide numerical evaluations that (1) demonstrate transformers can indeed implement near-optimal algorithms on classical regression problems with i.i.d. and dynamic data, (2) provide insights on stability, and (3) verify our theoretical predictions.
[ -0.0312308203, 0.042492751, -0.011679667, -0.0137182251, -0.0133170784, 0.02826868, 0.0076026954, -0.0299087651, -0.024709262, 0.0198627971, 0.0025694938, -0.0235043056, -0.0020336655, -0.0266409088, 0.0355698466, -0.0568751171, 0.0366423726, -0.0727271885, -0.0278646611, -0.02106799, -0.0376272537, -0.0599178635, -0.0040258188, 0.0391685329, -0.0347402953, -0.0120287305, -0.0146394335, -0.0223630108, 0.0304155778, -0.0106064668, -0.0150674116, 0.0067792358, 0.0175423007, 0.0445035994, 0.0000021012, -0.0363062695, -0.0253558997, -0.0186671969, -0.0140798474, -0.1059341878, 0.0122525096, -0.0223301835, 0.0179506484, 0.0058711832, -0.0034347055, 0.0104850037, 0.077770263, 0.0453675836, 0.0532169715, 0.0390885547, -0.0071339365, 0.0125281466, 0.0131847998, -0.0213435702, 0.0088368449, -0.0158284698, 0.0131659368, -0.0357948169, -0.0488133617, -0.041524142, -0.0346992761, 0.0539414696, 0.0386875048, 0.0199223217, 0.017338777, 0.0620693155, -0.0059725866, -0.0193415843, -0.0284030195, 0.0251547899, -0.0345714614, -0.008248236, -0.0167073812, 0.0080450559, 0.0435851812, 0.048569344, -0.0546755418, 0.0082473671, -0.0049115526, 0.0077840644, -0.0025236099, 0.003030872, 0.0210739803, -0.0612091199, -0.0296840407, 0.0633843392, -0.0050997492, -0.0312816277, 0.0368168317, 0.0550733097, -0.0050472124, -0.0222203936, -0.013613794, 0.0390229523, -0.0714215487, 0.0050414298, -0.0368535519, -0.0521773435, -0.054390043, 0.0118169887, 0.0558348857, -0.0010259894, -0.0097173303, 0.0148763265, -0.0074236216, 0.0529840887, -0.0664701909, 0.0525344871, -0.0103458399, 0.0112836827, -0.0397160463, 0.0184011962, -0.0424279049, 0.0400590524, 0.0383876674, 0.0214700215, -0.0328883566, 0.0692575723, -0.0116489129, 0.0037019425, -0.0227102302, -0.0076633408, -0.0830620751, 0.0071473368, -0.0308298301, 0.0109637305, 0.0188602339, 0.0322400071, 0.0323983096, -0.0166969839, -0.0328504033, 0.0097702043, 0.0139408112, -0.0286467094, -0.0232709162, 0.1252233833, -0.023618374, -0.0288169198, -0.0281529315, -0.0033161705, -0.0028275969, -0.0139353266, 0.0559284389, -0.0304037631, 0.0017982706, 0.0227858797, 0.0093315979, -0.0140688671, -0.0187385809, 0.0042003668, -0.0096167149, 0.0623377301, 0.0585623272, -0.0069473656, 0.0074431729, -0.0256347656, -0.1000746116, 0.0492238179, 0.0169413425, -0.0118917981, -0.0013000502, -0.0137089677, 0.0600882843, 0.0369425863, 0.0236265659, 0.0431422591, 0.0282922648, -0.0105384635, 0.0117056463, -0.0029023704, -0.0191589966, 0.0473028235, -0.0212676022, 0.0305616446, 0.0644581914, 0.032988824, 0.0367568173, 0.0392980762, 0.0108446768, 0.0039029338, -0.0324714221, 0.0473364517, -0.0924758911, 0.0525159799, -0.0194364171, -0.0167734008, -0.0561869517, 0.005982602, -0.0305618253, -0.0441696346, 0.0516913533, -0.0192898046, -0.0187598318, 0.0094833942, 0.0762292445, 0.0298235826, -0.0672299042, 0.0597584173, 0.0014471082, 0.0001671337, -0.0179239232, -0.0682580993, 0.0061012013, -0.0344067886, 0.0025642889, -0.063131094, 0.0064723436, -0.0791247711, 0.0284154005, -0.0178099461, -0.0470389724, -0.0060200077, 0.0500564687, 0.024458915, -0.0402593128, 0.043721918, 0.0011269829, -0.0162579194, -0.0020675054, -0.0180583596, -0.0127687464, 0.0146098882, -0.0227268841, 0.0319449231, -0.0370104685, -0.0377902575, 0.0164810717, 0.0220921878, 0.052355621, -0.033379823, -0.0093028694, -0.0075516612, 0.015178198, -0.0098316073, -0.0033866141, 0.0484678447, -0.0543013923, 0.0046445793, 0.0067457212, -0.0748137385, -0.0209012814, 0.0492044613, -0.0069535924, -0.0264397413, 0.0133459484, -0.046449326, 0.0194404777, 0.0349874087, 0.007869198, -0.0028001841, 0.0279482901, -0.0082262307, 0.0389075615, -0.0068756873, -0.0089057321, 0.03051956, -0.0251012277, -0.0361415409, -0.0240568742, -0.0368906856, -0.0138826026, -0.0516747124, 0.0072332215, 0.0125420857, -0.0129967546, -0.0049244193, -0.0210316945, -0.0140437586, -0.0378427505, -0.0472141579, 0.0191195346, -0.0248874296, -0.0079169748, 0.0179481823, -0.0162163842, 0.0045805965, 0.0391022004, 0.000118027, 0.0281241294, 0.0465365313, -0.007148067, -0.0307792127, 0.0086262645, -0.0202698857, -0.008157515, 0.0564853065, 0.0363274105, -0.0284598786, -0.0413820408, 0.0077982917, 0.0430271775, 0.0076534715, -0.0180000868, 0.050338462, 0.0115663642, -0.0304692518, 0.0523510911, 0.1081136167, 0.0190135445, 0.0122430874, 0.0117494678, 0.0044379421, 0.0051925881, 0.0162343867, -0.0580382124, -0.0372893028, -0.0350413211, 0.0105892736, 0.0557462424, 0.0601001866, -0.0465661325, -0.0333343521, -0.0315258391, -0.0139258811, -0.0051565147, -0.0232876223, -0.0279208776, 0.0261104871, -0.0384510085, 0.0255464166, 0.0005873247, -0.0619034804, 0.0927414149, 0.0515610799, 0.0043281647, 0.0154084247, -0.0273953602, 0.0108048506, 0.0061959107, -0.0085313488, -0.0106394924, 0.0319712535, -0.0090869442, -0.0846521407, 0.02620464, 0.0147051523, 0.0009101123, 0.0866097063, -0.0194705743, -0.0122445878, -0.0171396602, -0.0401293226, -0.0536784194, -0.0099203615, -0.0036746787, 0.0016657129, -0.0207620114, -0.0133406138, -0.0474794917, -0.0152023137, 0.0381905921, 0.020338472, 0.0056126942, -0.077393204, -0.0041846302, 0.0191568322, 0.0050265328, 0.0333759189, 0.0088069979, -0.0700354651, 0.0390785113, 0.0115807755, 0.0869526938, 0.0031003193, -0.0421926901, 0.0037307926, 0.0155278044, -0.0039239638, 0.0135634039, 0.0623562224, 0.0292876568, -0.0034504675, -0.0526948012, 0.0508275181, -0.0253123026, -0.0691248924, 0.0096859755, -0.00307747, 0.005554019, 0.0151664522, 0.0631850138, -0.062666595, -0.0299896132, 0.0060446276, 0.0450094827, -0.0033344217, -0.0422353297, 0.028631581, -0.0407128893, 0.0114426631, -0.0241035018, -0.0344548933, -0.0125135817, -0.018432403, -0.0030670625, -0.0540797338, -0.0021515223, -0.0264133122, -0.0290079582, -0.0237509385, 0.0370044671, 0.0086290063, -0.0416109376, -0.0159022845, -0.030022148, -0.0116297938, 0.0602882579, -0.0132775754, -0.0541180708, -0.0386817344, 0.0305357948, 0.0137038482, 0.0004517001, 0.0311790779, 0.0558979847, -0.025271818, -0.0082428707, -0.0271229446, 0.0446400158, -0.0128582353, -0.005424073, 0.0317471996, 0.0864077061, 0.0021162911, -0.0432883874, -0.0074723954, -0.0494548902, 0.0556738339, 0.023886608, -0.0086993305, -0.0654053316, -0.0166696962, -0.0323582031, 0.0107002696, -0.000444251, -0.0566749386, 0.0076959361, -0.0015948218, -0.0476628728, -0.04401806, 0.0297920685, -0.0152336592, 0.0706557259, 0.0305789672, -0.0636913031, 0.0420965068, 0.0279433839, -0.0257011671, 0.0116071543, 0.0078799361, 0.0189497322, -0.0481536835, 0.04288394, 0.0285703298, -0.0497472845, -0.038595885, 0.0156817567, -0.1105095372, -0.0444648974, 0.029984748, 0.0612657927, 0.0236385576, 0.0613818578, -0.0083137453, 0.0015758977, 0.0780363679, 0.0480502099, 0.031349007, 0.0042593749, 0.0795917884, -0.0280130412, 0.0118100736, 0.0179346781, -0.0601266026, 0.0169121511, 0.0332479179, -0.0270332117, -0.0443150513, 0.0236112978, 0.0344214104, -0.0174872447, 0.0947151557, 0.0013532707, -0.0000741596, -0.0124608586, 0.0152635062, 0.091881372, -0.012097206, -0.0508959927, -0.0027557705, 0.0264867302, 0.0213656723, 0.0192135107, 0.0114811929, 0.0584301427, -0.0196064617, -0.0334164575, 0.0030580412, 0.0056481832, 0.011110289, 0.0213727541, 0.0328316204, 0.0151225477, -0.0207619816, 0.0468946248, 0.028748272, 0.045232214, 0.0383794121, 0.037511915, 0.0357722789, -0.0271157715, -0.0442501344, -0.1070348248, -0.0416346788, -0.0009428807, -0.0017879799, 0.0091871098, -0.015051851, 0.0005821977, -0.0384535417, 0.0226349011, -0.024933666, 0.0538477264, -0.014726717, 0.0006892906, 0.0131139923, 0.0152747435, 0.0469657443, 0.0081577925, 0.0735105947, -0.0443905219, 0.0192540977, -0.0535365567, 0.0119300354, -0.04674422, -0.0070178625, 0.0111096604, -0.0071697645, 0.0253626425, -0.018809624, -0.0287907571, -0.0578091778, 0.0193228219, -0.0487351865, 0.0518037975, -0.056284178, 0.0102308188, 0.0506052002, 0.0040186252, -0.0041000573, 0.0184076242, -0.0305308737, 0.0294887852, 0.005344322, -0.0446082652, -6.079970125e-33, 0.0006526778, -0.0238951147, -0.0143507579, 0.0525320768, 0.0052342699, -0.0092896931, -0.0288078804, -0.0055777789, 0.0062346077, -0.0040039499, -0.0193386059, 0.0199955385, 0.0155671416, 0.032444723, 0.0376903191, -0.0491321236, 0.0140479663, -0.0167622436, -0.034780357, 0.0228273515, 0.0266226158, 0.0077122627, 0.0364103988, -0.0421872772, 0.0102541056, 0.02034075, -0.0011488165, 0.002606295, -0.0312276948, 0.0256373752, -0.0136735709, 0.0393439829, 0.0026291397, -0.092801705, -0.0103736874, 0.0711932182, -0.0685904399, -0.0120158074, -0.0540500693, 0.0090092374, -0.0381241143, -0.037719246, 0.0696668923, 0.0114391493, -0.0426347442, -0.0458607674, 0.0561587736, -0.0008332396, -0.0241121221, -0.0522650965, -0.0357681997, -0.0181368571, -0.024357697, -0.0213309471, 0.0201095939, 0.1558130383, -0.0006304943, 0.026319772, -0.0307585094, 0.0286000669, -0.0223682616, -0.0328363329, 0.0526597537, 0.0522361137, 0.0164524559, 0.0317832641, 0.0241041314, -0.0019947817, -0.0197951049, -0.0688934475, -0.0133739607, 0.0438844413, 0.0004618594, 0.0016204357, 0.0252624769, 0.0115472488, -0.0568353496, 0.0038944276, -0.0215823837, 0.0383205339, 0.0468905829, -0.0067004268, -0.0283111166, -0.0359171927, -0.0225803647, -0.0038878352, 0.0087794289, 0.0123732565, 0.0278799664, 0.0172107741, -0.0236188378, 0.0311350543, 0.039131701, -0.0465605147, 0.0207878649, -0.0331299491, -0.0001626352, 0.0372032002, 0.0055469577, -0.007873592, -0.0367178619, -0.0379911102, -0.02217458, 0.0274115782, 0.043771673, -0.0025413278, 0.0644757897, 0.0536373742, -0.0407395102, -0.0407139398, -0.0473683476, 0.0315292887, 0.0479321145, 0.0134057673, 0.0736925304, -0.0113390591, -0.0269178115, 0.0261402652, -0.0326055922, -0.0113356113, -0.0074882978, 0.0520667322, -0.0219057966, -0.0020650749, 0.0013750147, -0.0248920787, -0.0400616415, 0.0026287315, -0.0047814534, -0.0736609474, -0.0373756364, 0.0129894856, 2.94e-7, -0.007654801, 0.0338444859, 0.031629622, -0.001563658, 0.048313424, 0.0334488004, -0.0281467438, 0.0321773812, 0.0418228954, -0.0061879097, 0.0188754592, 0.0154602574, 0.0280872993, 0.0147723826, -0.0548004508, -0.1199344322, -0.0378427804, 0.0709254667, 0.0007764287, 0.0277437754, 0.0302484818, 0.0413117409, -0.0070344335, -0.0109255789, 0.0211930554, -0.0203105845, 0.0701638162, -0.0326840244, 0.0627892837, -0.0283159185, -0.0147869559, 0.0061063021, 0.0037915159, 0.0265871733, -0.0121039804, 0.008961861, -0.007955445, 0.0187943522, 0.0153062576, 0.0035621577, 0.0151204281, 0.0310872272, 0.0385925286, -0.0164537076, 0.05122355, -0.1576591283, -0.0126663055, -0.0179384928, -0.0139099313, -0.0019516438, 0.0160246976, 0.018855663, 0.0310164299, -0.0401258767, -0.005707148, 0.0347908661, -0.0017676133, -0.0354223363, -0.0099903373, 0.0245133881, -0.0378383435, -0.0329034366, -0.024183698, -0.0271604303, 0.0273110494, -0.0293910615, -0.0033775938, 2.642313854e-34, 0.0195888057, -0.0067957216, 0.0467219613, 0.0234773774, -0.0039175292, -0.0639627054, 0.0004261472, -0.0148018794, 0.0913019776, -0.0399095155, -0.0185161699 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.07057v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.07057v1
Transformer Based Implementation for Automatic Book Summarization
2023-01-17T18:18:51
2023-01-17T18:18:51
Siddhant Porwal, Laxmi Bewoor, Vivek Deshpande
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
Document Summarization is the procedure of generating a meaningful and concise summary of a given document with the inclusion of relevant and topic-important points. There are two approaches: one is picking up the most relevant statements from the document itself and adding it to the Summary known as Extractive and the other is generating sentences for the Summary known as Abstractive Summarization. Training a machine learning model to perform tasks that are time-consuming or very difficult for humans to evaluate is a major challenge. Book Abstract generation is one of such complex tasks. Traditional machine learning models are getting modified with pre-trained transformers. Transformer based language models trained in a self-supervised fashion are gaining a lot of attention; when fine-tuned for Natural Language Processing(NLP) downstream task like text summarization. This work is an attempt to use Transformer based techniques for Abstract generation.
[ 0.0282875076, 0.0226332135, 0.0034496791, 0.0194368325, -0.0411811098, 0.0092791142, 0.0125941625, -0.0422282666, -0.0271385331, -0.0601330437, 0.0094329165, 0.0208832342, 0.013734119, 0.0290112924, 0.0069711125, -0.0738890395, -0.0044366168, 0.0023525462, -0.022127429, -0.0160251409, 0.0200972464, 0.0181901772, 0.0423816442, 0.0168404523, 0.0292282775, -0.0353635326, -0.0153237991, -0.0297320783, 0.0175753031, 0.0182948466, 0.0030638799, 0.000445707, -0.0044810986, -0.0000293699, 0.000001858, -0.0477377139, -0.0519954376, 0.0044032908, 0.0515286401, -0.0223441441, 0.0491463318, -0.0634761602, 0.0085495813, 0.0252417438, -0.0281097814, -0.0098133394, 0.0028289102, 0.1137725189, 0.0638488531, 0.042593427, -0.0250326116, -0.0829537436, 0.055805631, 0.0499497056, -0.0279434156, 0.0152070131, -0.0297882706, 0.0377157107, -0.0227991827, 0.0261533186, -0.0234456491, 0.0300205816, 0.0157533046, -0.0188763496, 0.011484066, 0.0206286851, -0.0598472878, -0.0029606158, -0.0171791632, 0.009970881, -0.0234885402, -0.0509903505, 0.0100698378, -0.0034804007, -0.0196107253, 0.0296648722, -0.0455159061, 0.0642972142, -0.0185001716, 0.0097222123, 0.0260302648, 0.0474949777, -0.0334236659, 0.0162619073, -0.0744784474, 0.0249895807, 0.0032498527, -0.0181916058, -0.0083398521, 0.0005042942, -0.0335682333, -0.0376924872, 0.0288922247, 0.0674887076, 0.0232726522, -0.0278628767, -0.0635037273, -0.104304418, -0.0115189822, -0.0252685174, 0.0253944825, 0.017502632, 0.0052602529, -0.003553106, -0.0089749238, 0.0292261112, 0.0217267387, 0.003767872, -0.0718522742, 0.0134348404, 0.0095596984, -0.0065540904, -0.0728878304, 0.0578910634, -0.0493038557, -0.02866311, -0.0455096997, 0.0291693248, 0.0518652275, -0.0178385042, 0.0223855656, 0.0047310619, -0.0405210368, -0.0084774988, 0.0295283496, -0.0169785041, 0.0168126263, -0.0342388153, 0.0067613795, -0.0087382719, 0.0193188991, 0.0128342062, 0.0308757666, 0.0139902709, -0.0004310737, 0.0402748026, -0.0192734152, -0.0369339623, -0.0017486684, -0.0096524712, 0.022307938, -0.0482456535, -0.0138912071, -0.0575511009, 0.0027890743, 0.0355135128, 0.0010313075, 0.0372836292, 0.0055899834, 0.0293519814, -0.0077490578, 0.0269232467, -0.0148308147, 0.0276105329, 0.0507743321, -0.0040756115, 0.0040189195, 0.0034365782, 0.040321365, 0.0214810781, 0.0484527349, -0.0213190857, 0.0526769497, 0.030618906, -0.0191739369, -0.0251477044, 0.0491084903, -0.0239546876, -0.0665283203, -0.0272830296, -0.0241986997, 0.0841488689, -0.0138144493, 0.0504171774, 0.0851035342, 0.059764009, 0.022885086, 0.1266808063, 0.0501232333, 0.0546087921, 0.0552403703, 0.0688094646, 0.0225552153, 0.0106094992, -0.0086205713, 0.0559769422, -0.0150396395, 0.0426043943, -0.0186711997, -0.053031452, 0.0231347177, -0.0189082455, 0.022482954, -0.0183481649, 0.0591863021, 0.0617655069, -0.0448912904, 0.0575909726, -0.0081952671, -0.0809205547, 0.0145346802, -0.007147409, 0.0056651472, -0.002991759, 0.0462249815, -0.0352942944, -0.0180099476, -0.0066883289, -0.0304177944, 0.0518827327, 0.0207027569, -0.0121185528, -0.04291467, -0.0583574623, -0.005183001, -0.0119185476, -0.0040990622, -0.034206599, -0.0209125094, -0.0121459914, 0.0654790029, -0.0042831763, -0.1027824879, 0.0652922317, -0.0597940013, -0.0278289281, 0.0150184389, 0.0011310041, -0.0111340154, 0.0172140896, 0.0066913306, 0.0229745097, 0.0429868922, -0.0276580248, -0.0179761462, 0.0442239903, -0.0134308003, 0.0070674266, 0.0322084762, -0.0766839758, 0.0292132031, 0.0710491985, -0.0084619857, -0.050987374, -0.0000987803, -0.0354831293, 0.0327350125, -0.0226898063, 0.0557716563, 0.0072798193, 0.0014005075, -0.0114260502, 0.0451712608, 0.0297924988, 0.0105219325, -0.0092910724, -0.0271975603, 0.0137766898, 0.0152670825, -0.022491524, -0.0262919813, 0.0037473552, -0.0046086181, 0.06497363, 0.0001308592, -0.0034238761, -0.025487585, -0.0750646293, -0.0217782147, -0.0205416568, 0.004277877, 0.0559050925, 0.0438577384, 0.0185584277, 0.0186102893, -0.0244422387, 0.0114248674, 0.0175400171, -0.0331962965, 0.0371868238, 0.0057683974, 0.01373732, -0.0117939916, -0.0104506956, -0.0052169058, 0.0497484133, 0.0568090864, 0.0207201093, -0.0653256848, 0.0200379845, 0.0075579085, 0.0117381215, -0.0033583993, -0.0199114475, -0.0185450539, -0.0106166145, 0.04770834, 0.0092979465, 0.0693907291, -0.0075749527, 0.0413912125, 0.001222058, 0.0005565031, -0.0051676873, -0.0771821067, -0.0011875919, 0.0140504073, -0.0071349642, 0.0439766049, 0.034078639, -0.0106479982, -0.0314705446, 0.0015241378, -0.0078491084, -0.0118931644, 0.0127931861, -0.0149764931, -0.0420491733, -0.0157864075, 0.03555445, 0.0048386729, -0.0117947888, 0.0296944473, -0.0277683493, 0.0088170636, -0.1104840934, 0.009917859, -0.0633303598, 0.0456576981, 0.012397971, 0.0392472222, 0.0122951595, -0.0078777401, -0.0418353193, 0.0072922437, 0.0181032475, -0.0055898074, 0.0656496584, -0.0145664224, -0.0050883484, -0.0318093225, -0.003671068, -0.0463133827, -0.0442968756, -0.0012370831, 0.0082034022, 0.0487807989, -0.011599632, -0.0629957765, 0.0312206671, 0.0290960986, 0.0599626526, -0.014803376, -0.044706203, 0.0033024133, 0.0363994837, 0.0736692101, -0.0067224265, 0.0300730243, -0.0389946699, 0.0319083445, 0.0327826217, -0.0201819353, -0.0337710343, -0.0468517281, -0.0292395502, 0.0047469321, -0.1077837795, 0.0300227944, -0.0091436347, -0.0208440814, -0.0475268885, -0.0298988931, 0.0959471017, 0.021958923, -0.0365078449, -0.0060355584, -0.0063405996, -0.0336656459, -0.0300169364, 0.0292763039, -0.0487808548, 0.0538228005, -0.0147793042, -0.0030607139, 0.0110861659, 0.012461911, 0.0170984454, -0.0804808438, 0.0080930907, 0.0109257307, -0.0588704459, -0.042310629, 0.0225544162, -0.0391271859, -0.0129877953, -0.0101895481, 0.0249409042, -0.063968502, -0.0060953959, -0.0311232861, -0.0431441106, 0.0236569922, -0.0443192944, -0.0209122691, -0.0886538997, 0.0320998952, 0.0475234427, -0.0346128643, 0.0079895006, 0.0322382152, -0.0466936976, -0.0207375828, 0.0072753467, 0.0410302952, -0.0089305853, 0.0070482991, -0.018847771, 0.0653908476, 0.010827383, -0.0326268226, 0.0109207388, -0.0019161692, -0.0098897172, -0.0161367655, -0.0496656187, 0.0397125706, -0.0232880563, 0.0290773511, -0.0057131378, -0.0248200744, -0.0415610969, -0.0080475528, 0.0190268066, -0.0587879233, -0.0469814949, -0.0085856859, -0.0274750404, -0.039515432, -0.078422077, -0.0208648853, -0.0101300646, 0.0109838815, 0.0474536903, -0.0162395351, 0.0763840973, -0.0151106017, -0.0506020896, -0.0208460055, 0.0066974862, -0.0417169407, -0.0229972489, -0.0234820209, 0.0828245059, -0.0474814773, -0.0135056218, -0.0020089711, 0.013387762, -0.043755874, 0.0444047861, 0.0536823682, 0.0171023682, 0.0434192717, 0.0105703669, 0.0204165969, 0.0523509644, 0.0197915491, -0.0380924307, 0.0203852989, 0.0189224761, 0.0354928896, -0.0362944789, -0.0004492113, -0.02506046, 0.0697177351, -0.0248229112, 0.0019901518, -0.0228504594, -0.0490293242, 0.0290761832, 0.0166675411, 0.0272235218, -0.0527477153, 0.0204906315, -0.0105265817, 0.0103060184, -0.0450560339, -0.0219781771, -0.0432135724, 0.0475985967, 0.0098596113, 0.0269576777, -0.0195384156, 0.0588076897, -0.0194650386, 0.008840126, -0.0090766307, 0.0530819148, -0.0331652276, -0.0193888787, -0.0345003232, -0.0083679184, -0.0247610267, -0.0562356934, 0.0015944242, 0.0244747084, 0.0237139538, 0.0202195775, 0.0396782123, 0.0321995802, -0.0460614413, 0.0315723158, -0.0651042983, 0.0303376261, -0.0607802719, -0.0162010659, 0.0182823893, -0.0608642697, 0.0516452156, -0.0272246264, -0.024059087, -0.0149821294, 0.067806229, 0.0158588998, 0.0254789703, -0.0433677435, -0.0028836415, 0.0155745074, 0.0080202576, 0.0491918437, -0.0492801741, -0.025992265, 0.0567136854, -0.0325870067, -0.0553581193, -0.0008695474, 0.0015654023, -0.0280380175, 0.0097025139, -0.0402589068, -0.0363746136, -0.0081577031, 0.0678448305, 0.0504971705, 0.0372233689, -0.0153897889, 0.0459789522, 0.0554827452, 0.0134875625, 0.0073873629, -0.059867382, 0.0342626311, -0.0157297812, 0.0028700666, -0.0294968747, -5.18677662e-33, -0.0215234309, -0.0241841003, -0.0050034579, 0.0891413465, -0.0513349362, -0.0140003944, -0.0383142643, -0.0209530219, 0.032129202, 0.0064940229, -0.0235293377, -0.0197573751, 0.0079705883, 0.0357560292, 0.0044216788, 0.0425609015, 0.0346879065, 0.0122863865, -0.028495634, 0.013550655, 0.0221675169, 0.0293928012, 0.0183004867, -0.0545799211, -0.041450005, -0.0867366269, 0.005980636, -0.0416805781, 0.005715779, 0.019122405, -0.0108545143, -0.0051674074, 0.0195847452, -0.008923647, -0.0284473822, 0.033842966, -0.0777415708, 0.0033771414, 0.0050950395, 0.0210643355, -0.0268950202, -0.0205194931, 0.0379412174, -0.0318946019, -0.0239253752, -0.0354573764, 0.0650041178, -0.0456812009, -0.0157208629, -0.0934846401, -0.0867454261, 0.005597672, -0.0196949206, 0.0015268925, 0.0524193086, 0.0476949587, -0.0018328382, -0.0040641599, -0.0106187863, 0.0349235944, 0.0692641661, 0.0371976644, 0.0072463844, 0.0130484821, 0.0031732148, 0.0152886501, -0.0144846719, -0.02937489, -0.0186707228, 0.0738947764, 0.0276067555, 0.016705649, 0.0192191191, 0.0273327045, 0.0407786518, 0.0185380708, -0.025054941, 0.0930606201, -0.0496394783, 0.0221739262, 0.0276046116, -0.0219141096, 0.0080252169, -0.0070235636, -0.0027835954, 0.0035817421, 0.004548212, -0.0136439186, -0.0265018027, 0.0157455895, -0.0933144391, 0.0256764684, -0.0046461965, -0.0591899678, 0.0154113378, -0.0233336072, -0.0389085859, 0.0432051867, -0.0524917766, -0.0294212382, -0.0188674275, -0.044575166, -0.0089011751, 0.0343953557, -0.0039133462, 0.0113001494, 0.0473074727, 0.0382436439, -0.0298000593, 0.006234786, 0.0007361941, 0.0051890295, -0.0107618412, 0.0739400834, -0.031979952, 0.0163948573, -0.0007612202, 0.0242259447, -0.0269259792, -0.0042004245, -0.0272963848, 0.0687779337, 0.0580668375, 0.0291138887, -0.0148335295, 0.0211652927, -0.0039850054, 0.0487185754, 0.0621078536, -0.033624392, -0.0235473011, 0.0127544524, 2.405e-7, 0.0664439872, 0.0118273031, 0.0659876317, -0.0063595376, -0.0337342396, 0.0030184877, 0.0321445093, 0.0157680437, 0.0459079221, 0.0240991339, 0.0563113019, 0.0052764327, 0.0211976524, -0.001786352, -0.1106221303, -0.0218936857, -0.0733075738, -0.0459278934, -0.0102084922, -0.0145263411, 0.0471559651, 0.0432011224, 0.0026984154, -0.0134838596, -0.0244752318, 0.0089438045, 0.0508791618, -0.0199950561, -0.0320996009, 0.0490916446, 0.0361120328, 0.0284779444, -0.0244468134, -0.0404763669, -0.0288094822, 0.0306468122, 0.0418217592, 0.0185161047, 0.0157421958, -0.000957253, 0.0288801156, 0.0109168785, 0.0082805585, -0.010794105, 0.0309218802, -0.0790829509, -0.005933431, -0.0210372508, -0.0736066103, 0.0299076457, -0.0381111242, -0.0123089701, -0.0249548648, 0.0621839166, 0.0226505473, -0.0283616055, 0.0190153308, -0.0543238036, -0.0124178994, 0.0192589816, -0.0096329181, 0.0146429446, -0.0027067957, -0.0392152369, 0.0112607935, -0.0453375094, 0.0027353158, 2.247429945e-34, 0.0676075071, -0.0104533043, -0.0368046239, 0.0113089699, -0.0165517628, -0.0365316384, 0.0366166607, 0.0173760075, -0.0257289559, -0.0686867833, -0.0097708479 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2302.01749v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2302.01749v1
Command Line Interface Risk Modeling
2023-01-17T17:10:38
2023-01-17T17:10:38
Dr Anthony L. Faulds
cs.CR
cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG
Protecting sensitive data is an essential part of security in cloud computing. However, only specific privileged individuals have access to view or interact with this data; therefore, it is unscalable to depend on these individuals also to maintain the software. A solution to this is to allow non-privileged individuals access to maintain these systems but mask sensitive information from egressing. To this end, we have created a machine-learning model to predict and redact fields with sensitive data. This work concentrates on Azure PowerShell, showing how it applies to other command-line interfaces and APIs. Using the F5-score as a weighted metric, we demonstrate different transformation techniques to map this problem from an unknown field to the well-researched area of natural language processing.
[ 0.0087581361, 0.0344766229, -0.0196572226, 0.0073741074, -0.0261285622, -0.029726848, 0.0335806906, -0.0261124223, 0.0491921902, -0.0119715882, 0.0275707059, 0.0011511612, 0.0194668733, 0.0672197938, 0.0259837247, -0.0398307256, 0.0534392558, -0.0100581227, -0.028721692, 0.0255318284, -0.0144479359, 0.0047029806, 0.0013920175, 0.045607131, 0.0488439351, -0.0257291589, 0.0399544239, 0.0343555324, 0.0123831434, 0.0356236175, -0.0035101247, 0.0194701124, -0.0437066406, 0.0587963983, 0.0000019726, -0.0514616147, -0.0639313683, 0.0315585285, -0.0396562181, 0.0133318752, 0.0150346169, -0.0108414534, -0.0339507461, 0.0294535216, -0.0153753776, 0.0427370146, 0.0403853208, 0.0459215753, 0.0961691141, 0.0407029763, -0.0246870797, 0.023390891, -0.0267086588, 0.0149377128, -0.0322079547, -0.0372992381, 0.0223844647, -0.0189194661, -0.0432125591, -0.0094361883, -0.0028521905, -0.0047111362, 0.002278741, 0.0028159611, 0.0069072586, 0.0287297666, -0.0031350052, 0.0027967945, -0.0206127428, -0.0067945416, -0.0558951274, -0.0011954521, 0.0300890133, -0.0018725897, 0.003471599, -0.0036072882, 0.0027317656, 0.0046996931, -0.0155415228, -0.034186963, -0.031184556, 0.0286975484, 0.0091580618, 0.0217551552, 0.0283912141, 0.0366944931, 0.0049626706, -0.0031394127, 0.0203795601, -0.0596039779, -0.0236372016, -0.0318303965, 0.005966567, 0.0243218392, -0.0226033404, -0.0061530285, -0.074851498, -0.0491594523, 0.0454756469, -0.0097378343, 0.0381396413, -0.0094350511, 0.045262266, 0.0186577328, -0.0115905339, 0.0718431026, 0.0334170125, -0.0061441469, 0.0431513265, 0.009229742, -0.0196117312, -0.0185592454, 0.0117466319, 0.0315877907, 0.0287515596, 0.0158968177, -0.0403831899, 0.0426182933, -0.0008206379, 0.051261019, 0.0173487049, -0.02025369, -0.0305740554, 0.018064091, 0.013690616, -0.0707966164, -0.0143865328, 0.0189311244, -0.0281778239, -0.0248943511, 0.003079775, -0.0231356844, -0.0205265414, -0.0096339183, 0.0005318108, 0.0969317332, 0.0638673007, 0.0117008546, -0.0511739738, -0.0857996345, 0.0095829675, 0.0448981114, -0.0146686938, -0.0284004807, -0.0311480872, -0.0294274464, -0.0041597141, -0.0334589779, -0.0411071144, -0.0061573982, -0.021245677, 0.0540861525, -0.0058353939, -0.0228805076, 0.0183851589, 0.0421412103, -0.0616027266, -0.0244603641, -0.0087502655, 0.0556154363, 0.0456032492, -0.0602088273, 0.0776294619, 0.0024121355, -0.0160798766, -0.0224216841, -0.0056384257, 0.036512889, 0.016894497, -0.04478525, 0.0408211388, 0.0219168626, 0.0495019108, -0.0672244132, 0.0829138607, 0.0388223976, -0.0035101157, 0.000945211, -0.0056311795, 0.073924996, -0.0267575216, -0.0486372672, -0.0098385606, -0.0022835433, -0.0411917977, -0.0308618937, -0.0183611233, -0.0006945265, 0.0097953072, -0.0165290739, 0.0342006236, -0.0521909744, -0.0008185917, -0.0356652029, -0.0051799463, 0.0536563545, 0.0051651476, -0.0189114306, 0.0044255746, -0.0061508217, -0.010420667, -0.0611109957, -0.0228511039, 0.0706271008, 0.0630916283, -0.0288644675, -0.0013406199, -0.0730627477, -0.0073966016, -0.0169511754, 0.0230220612, 0.0221024118, 0.035028886, -0.0308157727, -0.0230153352, 0.0276144687, 0.0297042374, 0.0119629456, -0.0402504504, -0.0455275699, 0.0203560069, -0.012100704, -0.0352142714, 0.0404278785, 0.0704870448, -0.0748564005, 0.0351051763, 0.0119072599, 0.0244776122, -0.0064635244, 0.0243207105, 0.0422530957, 0.0029086177, 0.055879306, -0.0188377406, -0.0582284182, 0.0031688192, 0.0937869698, -0.0383926556, -0.024523899, 0.0449395925, 0.0307300948, -0.0599771887, 0.0051880865, 0.0304687805, -0.052748017, -0.0227918345, 0.0419170856, 0.0023728458, 0.011091589, 0.0281993747, -0.0429434814, 0.0205762275, 0.0098194592, 0.0186395124, -0.0517994836, -0.0429815501, -0.0147517892, -0.0431498848, -0.0143018039, -0.054007709, -0.0571789667, 0.0081748283, 0.0119384266, 0.0102608381, -0.0091026602, 0.0122151524, -0.0549276769, 0.0047362135, 0.0104887215, 0.002582791, 0.0286990646, 0.0297217295, -0.0430413447, -0.0200660154, 0.0345919318, -0.0746094361, -0.0454876907, 0.0319419578, 0.0528072342, 0.0063554235, -0.031485904, -0.0142217521, -0.0287178271, -0.0328084081, 0.0832060874, -0.0147631261, -0.0196558833, 0.0035044099, 0.0668257773, -0.0044228975, 0.0078395111, -0.0096828314, -0.0060765394, -0.0174309313, -0.005387655, -0.0227836724, 0.0703802407, 0.0233001225, -0.0015444653, 0.0134377191, 0.011212281, -0.0050531076, -0.0255836006, -0.0024702798, -0.0363768786, 0.0031615898, 0.0094377836, 0.0588275343, -0.0125436969, 0.044432994, -0.0165455788, -0.0415627249, 0.0645063743, -0.0076411366, -0.0126878768, -0.0286109354, -0.055127766, 0.0005882137, 0.0575972274, -0.0118157547, -0.076124914, 0.0411729813, -0.0295054857, 0.0298163928, -0.0362637639, -0.0690180957, 0.0179748312, 0.0489678159, 0.0096184285, -0.003923316, 0.0531668216, -0.0519006103, -0.0446871482, -0.0290994849, 0.0259974599, -0.0519910194, -0.025582483, -0.060223002, -0.0472532958, 0.0175028276, 0.0193273406, -0.0158305876, -0.0553832389, -0.012156764, -0.0111131435, -0.0320745073, -0.0261968747, 0.0177903548, -0.0292564426, 0.0362821743, 0.0577351563, 0.046696417, -0.0214995667, -0.0063226698, -0.05445363, 0.0111309234, -0.0684732422, -0.0470727347, 0.013658178, 0.0069980356, 0.0264612678, 0.0615317374, -0.0226292927, 0.0023297826, -0.037648119, -0.0461260639, -0.0671142414, -0.0027615561, 0.0553095825, -0.0100337975, -0.0491600186, 0.0020106256, 0.0529292971, 0.0245156214, 0.0030342331, 0.030309068, -0.0087885084, -0.019527033, 0.008514097, 0.0318966508, -0.0400161184, 0.0040614507, 0.0063117519, 0.0652111694, -0.0484352261, -0.0727527291, -0.0148836598, -0.0812434703, 0.0015972767, 0.0004111573, 0.0094640842, -0.0748136416, -0.0915252492, 0.0035001878, -0.017481368, -0.0376121029, -0.041756276, 0.0206495691, 0.0130051328, 0.0231430996, -0.058941219, -0.0096445056, 0.043381352, -0.0339818001, 0.0011728386, 0.0935896039, 0.0171194691, -0.0339665227, -0.0015643744, 0.0144294025, 0.0214452483, -0.0046153748, 0.0021212085, 0.0793568417, 0.0362210944, -0.0004757571, 0.0153768705, 0.0573370047, 0.0125854686, -0.0149698323, 0.0391158499, 0.0557773858, -0.0588410869, 0.0072400132, 0.0033693728, -0.0099992249, 0.0450741202, 0.063834846, 0.0218622889, -0.0496431813, -0.0089378618, -0.0418251157, 0.0432531759, -0.0168758128, -0.0464199409, -0.0298625026, -0.0011313492, -0.0670107827, -0.0655346885, 0.0042459946, 0.012796144, 0.0304772705, 0.0410954878, -0.0175252948, 0.0178250335, 0.0418240279, -0.0190660153, -0.028590994, -0.0455480851, 0.0550199188, -0.0260029715, 0.0253587626, -0.0048796753, 0.0160365682, -0.0675929636, 0.0114178862, 0.0372965224, -0.0487968475, 0.0390914045, 0.0996884108, 0.0287642591, -0.0399144143, -0.027782606, -0.0502474494, 0.0748571977, 0.0325503461, -0.0484006703, -0.0387814976, 0.0653285235, -0.0131618716, 0.0011922842, -0.011695724, -0.0628910586, -0.0294367336, 0.0110679632, -0.0532894321, -0.058017157, -0.0230743717, -0.010188044, 0.0113000125, 0.0251197349, -0.0144395642, 0.0067887716, 0.0165653098, 0.0312974565, -0.007482334, -0.0221917517, 0.0404674634, 0.0336037166, 0.0237391461, 0.0198240597, 0.0435007289, -0.0441554226, -0.0191454422, -0.0124334581, 0.0038545153, 0.0031889922, 0.0594512857, 0.0279125348, 0.0261655115, -0.0205152407, 0.0069219447, 0.0216910914, 0.0448211245, 0.0470917262, 0.013001713, 0.021274142, -0.0276230704, 0.0328405313, -0.0550315157, 0.0466567576, -0.0523234941, -0.0470205136, 0.0051863198, -0.021573497, -0.0475371443, 0.0006917088, 0.0006036055, -0.0301559493, 0.0105422065, -0.0637599006, 0.0263103954, -0.0158762336, 0.0009667578, 0.0075108325, -0.0124765029, -0.0077433167, 0.0160522629, 0.0631717071, -0.0210371371, 0.0515760928, -0.0372772254, -0.077475749, -0.0738874301, -0.0167653617, 0.0075505842, 0.0404234901, -0.040296223, -0.0346583351, -0.0378386937, -0.0178549774, 0.0237869192, -0.0152661717, 0.0445640348, -0.0092315609, 0.0113522261, 0.0690099299, -0.0211140197, 0.0170631707, -0.0927935541, -0.0032496185, -0.0010498966, -0.0507820807, -0.0516496189, -4.899234906e-33, -0.0121841757, -0.0151460981, -0.0399201773, 0.0974391028, 0.0557149574, 0.0306527857, -0.0194165707, 0.010869964, 0.000878715, -0.0278480407, 0.0149702625, -0.0257954504, 0.0244232845, 0.0071739196, -0.0180958752, 0.0181124564, 0.0046137613, -0.006113274, 0.0141813811, 0.059158124, 0.0525805317, 0.029797988, 0.0042800517, -0.1112733409, 0.0394534022, 0.0264693499, -0.0180235133, 0.0148255369, 0.0075170789, 0.0185724888, 0.0317934006, 0.0026055463, 0.0256314315, -0.0129092485, -0.0087880278, 0.0517963283, 0.0013855167, -0.0173697025, -0.023913024, -0.0142167602, 0.0239410847, -0.0622567646, 0.0362273753, -0.0134278024, 0.0206024144, -0.0096336734, 0.0323801413, 0.0052401684, -0.0091829812, -0.0991031453, 0.0048661469, 0.0134381307, -0.0668240786, 0.0131635629, -0.0074077765, 0.0320681185, 0.0399257727, 0.0264286809, -0.03934706, 0.0241273455, 0.0316603594, 0.0438270792, 0.0505987592, 0.022935044, -0.0135946572, 0.0236294921, -0.002498704, -0.0109689916, 0.0175986644, 0.0450869538, 0.0094978232, 0.013783101, 0.0169529896, 0.0096149342, 0.0117432131, -0.0486129336, -0.0033684734, 0.0403247885, -0.0074809217, 0.0696016327, 0.0268457811, 0.0116190007, -0.070172973, 0.0016976309, -0.0193346422, -0.0745458677, -0.0215740316, 0.00618434, -0.0079643307, -0.0398572646, -0.0522715263, -0.0076284483, -0.0068071522, -0.0247556418, 0.044545766, -0.0117974384, 0.0227066465, -0.0149877379, -0.0172046386, -0.0271414593, 0.0148887308, 0.0108237453, 0.0215693768, -0.0400571078, 0.064371258, -0.0528004467, 0.0331842378, 0.0075143548, -0.0819690749, -0.005588003, -0.003552859, 0.0424292088, 0.0011198448, 0.0728057176, 0.0068759681, -0.0134534342, 0.0066352356, 0.0061783209, 0.017810408, -0.0378068872, 0.0033427747, 0.0046254252, -0.0094393734, -0.0286264028, -0.0150058987, -0.0134262359, 0.0148114357, 0.0196373556, 0.0832531154, 0.0144921727, -0.0074704317, -0.0100307167, 2.859e-7, 0.0507603288, 0.0326451808, 0.0087896986, -0.005419835, 0.0098582935, 0.101511389, 0.0380879864, 0.0355078727, -0.0328695737, -0.0165299717, 0.0030365158, -0.0450733975, 0.061057955, 0.0228806213, -0.0152274268, -0.0632182956, -0.067667, -0.0032208539, -0.0643176213, 0.0055855671, 0.0740677714, 0.0995092914, 0.0357424878, -0.0456402041, -0.0188179146, -0.0605637021, -0.0562584512, -0.0272677504, 0.026329767, 0.0021987765, 0.0380688794, 0.0443073958, 0.038015604, 0.0815267265, -0.0758339092, -0.017896967, -0.0194517616, 0.0570715629, 0.0418767072, -0.0137595842, 0.0031004124, -0.07005243, 0.0001234251, -0.0316470042, 0.0381970368, 0.0172033682, -0.0322361514, -0.0013126828, -0.0261633433, -0.0059803929, 0.0425182395, -0.0224507749, -0.0227037817, -0.0157689098, -0.0034450544, -0.002854401, -0.0117943855, -0.0373501107, -0.0521637723, -0.0151929902, -0.0321618691, -0.0159774031, 0.0186773781, 0.0193130169, 0.0217506178, -0.0106000733, 0.0530672595, 2.867578061e-34, -0.0101349866, -0.0358158834, -0.0098023284, -0.0190490782, 0.0098860171, 0.0443476886, -0.0019969605, 0.0374882892, 0.0081104254, 0.005910154, 0.0059819869 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.07006v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.07006v1
Which Model Shall I Choose? Cost/Quality Trade-offs for Text Classification Tasks
2023-01-17T16:51:58
2023-01-17T16:51:58
Shi Zong, Josh Seltzer, Jiahua, Pan, Kathy Cheng, Jimmy Lin
cs.CL
cs.CL
Industry practitioners always face the problem of choosing the appropriate model for deployment under different considerations, such as to maximize a metric that is crucial for production, or to reduce the total cost given financial concerns. In this work, we focus on the text classification task and present a quantitative analysis for this challenge. Using classification accuracy as the main metric, we evaluate the classifiers' performances for a variety of models, including large language models, along with their associated costs, including the annotation cost, training (fine-tuning) cost, and inference cost. We then discuss the model choices for situations like having a large number of samples needed for inference. We hope our work will help people better understand the cost/quality trade-offs for the text classification task.
[ 0.0525490642, 0.0356930122, 0.0061680954, -0.0028782275, -0.0656318069, 0.0155498208, 0.0552227274, 0.0148619562, 0.0390598252, -0.1258386821, 0.0187097285, -0.0095417788, -0.0095862392, 0.0185416546, -0.0244669244, -0.00394437, 0.0453343354, -0.0124071091, 0.0021573147, 0.0135393562, 0.0128878746, 0.0104930289, 0.0230177492, 0.018012967, -0.0086878426, 0.0091434456, 0.0230715349, -0.0169450361, -0.0140732341, -0.0214699451, 0.039133966, 0.0290316902, 0.0090038097, 0.1025716215, 0.0000015493, -0.0630951896, -0.0308465604, 0.0322156958, -0.0329119898, 0.0340828821, 0.0715765506, -0.0121614756, 0.012478834, 0.0565151647, 0.010868852, 0.0061776643, 0.064606972, 0.0595949255, 0.0163816679, 0.0617506616, -0.0073789414, -0.0493759699, 0.0182600003, -0.0453199334, -0.036433842, -0.0688773468, 0.0437349044, -0.0058233966, -0.0128940232, 0.0208246578, 0.0062298025, 0.0322459117, -0.0020660236, 0.0223041922, 0.0265150312, 0.0146374572, -0.0304133464, 0.0019765345, 0.0000666686, 0.0290783215, -0.0022132332, -0.0230807289, -0.0152787697, -0.0095374798, -0.000863036, -0.017726915, 0.0205445997, 0.0174055602, 0.0234461855, 0.0371186361, 0.0237967186, 0.0106931999, 0.0071147131, 0.0546806827, -0.0263776388, -0.0097567346, -0.034461733, -0.0167126134, 0.0342468396, 0.0242984854, -0.0340539366, -0.0570851639, -0.0126026701, -0.0091144945, 0.0105899367, -0.0026265986, -0.0306606814, -0.0310044941, 0.0340307839, -0.0910971314, -0.0121907536, -0.0162607599, 0.0188004263, 0.0694981888, -0.0483728983, 0.0002871036, 0.022913482, 0.0177566782, -0.0020200415, 0.0141782174, -0.0510855988, 0.031619288, -0.0433571562, 0.0403043479, -0.0012156098, -0.033812739, -0.0727424398, 0.0100255404, 0.0133578824, 0.0414250977, 0.020557357, 0.0009720949, -0.0084431777, 0.0395948961, -0.014303199, 0.0216185264, 0.0006257166, 0.0491570421, -0.0219535325, -0.0079183476, 0.0336138941, 0.0356775112, 0.0087773856, -0.0002898288, 0.051873453, 0.0456680842, 0.0078824461, -0.0886586457, -0.0535694622, 0.0233792923, -0.0420381688, -0.0688297525, -0.0764168352, -0.027062811, -0.0208224561, 0.0391265079, 0.0001370298, -0.0333355106, 0.0177343283, -0.0166941304, -0.0147178527, 0.04849758, 0.0187098887, -0.0338412784, 0.0637088493, -0.0080969045, -0.0336356573, 0.0852723047, 0.0201905053, 0.0592801124, 0.0431008153, -0.0237402432, 0.0148256933, 0.0145417685, -0.0486036912, -0.026668556, -0.0042653517, 0.0293123722, -0.0023697864, 0.0159704164, -0.0132767092, 0.0136948265, 0.0057668514, 0.0108752893, 0.0568901077, 0.0342621654, 0.0277628154, -0.0257544834, -0.0048593804, 0.048733864, -0.007405465, -0.0787466392, 0.0132337241, -0.0077629797, -0.0525629111, -0.0273692589, 0.0437031239, -0.0361749157, -0.0295186341, -0.0679376796, -0.0442188233, -0.0301073845, 0.0094472794, 0.0201173946, 0.0971657485, -0.0801521093, -0.028060656, 0.011908534, 0.0055918605, -0.0006396608, -0.0477783047, -0.0503033139, 0.0422282927, 0.0086427107, -0.0024335773, -0.0559694059, 0.0088099027, -0.046369575, 0.0070853517, -0.0186203644, 0.069025524, -0.0058575529, 0.0060357419, -0.021232659, -0.0094682295, -0.0020020711, 0.0401964374, 0.0117559033, 0.0113304621, 0.0134738218, 0.016581621, -0.0178710725, -0.0824611634, 0.0429180935, 0.0243384819, -0.0518164188, 0.0192854702, -0.0108953696, 0.0584361553, -0.0175648928, -0.0210834015, 0.00046631, -0.005833623, -0.0141816065, -0.0167310871, -0.0671939999, 0.0634261519, 0.0041930336, 0.006052406, 0.0274885278, 0.0108605362, 0.0330237597, -0.0473247133, -0.0099336179, -0.0335627683, -0.0417757854, 0.0201080013, -0.0608934835, -0.0019238868, -0.069296442, 0.0073151011, -0.0642548651, 0.0550511964, 0.0270056278, 0.0384644754, -0.0245119836, -0.0475677438, 0.0356973745, -0.0236093476, -0.051755745, 0.0118574286, -0.0234133061, 0.0566632263, 0.0158415735, -0.0225209445, -0.0107764183, -0.0246788599, -0.0729021952, 0.0203577578, -0.0239843838, -0.0048893853, -0.0461819358, -0.0216913018, -0.0055235261, -0.0190654173, -0.0108535327, -0.0113693122, -0.0070987139, 0.048829034, -0.0063136686, -0.003202507, 0.0076573668, -0.0245082714, 0.0031980709, 0.037446674, 0.0785160959, 0.0239228439, -0.0245888121, -0.0827920139, 0.0122048063, -0.0087887505, 0.0058771921, 0.0051707886, -0.0236465521, -0.0400280021, 0.0015392826, -0.0472793803, 0.0548689961, 0.0140476273, 0.0583825037, 0.0243229643, 0.0638936162, -0.046589803, 0.0116952797, -0.006118896, 0.0127607351, -0.0330221094, -0.0148946764, 0.0196993742, 0.0684802756, -0.0302699897, -0.0209533013, -0.0235245954, 0.0275589693, -0.0262935963, 0.0189650357, -0.0030968115, -0.0088643525, 0.0195746552, 0.0406906977, 0.0200333595, -0.0446348488, 0.0314417891, -0.0215932485, 0.0557485372, -0.0801870972, -0.046258036, -0.0220822617, 0.0399431959, -0.0093186945, 0.0159304664, 0.0217161439, 0.0043497724, -0.0026766658, 0.0097020473, 0.0948332548, -0.0163481161, 0.0170412902, -0.0018335492, 0.0729385167, -0.0515184812, -0.0319447108, -0.0158612542, -0.0624675713, -0.0631619692, 0.0157219283, 0.0094945924, 0.006339157, -0.0351675414, 0.0664890334, -0.0159102865, 0.0504823551, -0.0117001561, -0.0070673693, 0.0264145192, 0.0228753351, 0.0061118267, -0.0101403892, 0.0025322312, -0.0255016256, 0.0061947335, 0.0306231324, -0.017295789, 0.0625484213, -0.0519545376, -0.0306768231, 0.0439924151, -0.0839187503, -0.0403536223, -0.0094565395, 0.0430053063, -0.0453004427, -0.0016096989, 0.0992984697, 0.0302874371, -0.0434199981, -0.0151846707, 0.0602403097, 0.022679504, 0.0094490033, 0.0151266949, -0.0357876532, -0.0376997665, 0.0104056029, 0.0313474759, -0.0205016769, -0.0155378394, 0.007677461, -0.0718809143, 0.0568969622, -0.0197471064, -0.0245507825, 0.0065559414, -0.0769030377, -0.0017541082, -0.0608339757, -0.0216900688, -0.0375933386, 0.0099361343, -0.0042597419, 0.0550740696, -0.041107703, -0.0511657447, 0.0305480175, 0.0000747271, 0.0130506465, 0.0207621828, 0.0150950337, -0.0123159718, -0.0195251703, 0.0627063587, -0.0286638103, -0.0038316301, -0.0023269742, 0.0803821385, 0.0034345665, 0.0188414138, 0.0067694806, -0.013366376, 0.0124725588, 0.0105090449, 0.0056431335, 0.0615788139, -0.0041293893, 0.0085945856, 0.0016671255, -0.019586755, -0.0261226986, 0.0748788565, -0.0142457942, -0.1043385267, -0.0647134557, 0.0184091274, -0.0154256383, -0.0356649309, 0.0222312044, 0.0085297087, -0.0439332016, -0.0759452209, -0.0358524509, -0.0112255234, 0.0349175297, 0.0257105064, -0.0325339586, -0.0035815886, -0.0212029926, 0.0314471982, -0.0308044031, 0.0257692803, -0.009930782, 0.0348296501, -0.0590572767, 0.0150041729, 0.0494301766, -0.0212274157, -0.0490669571, -0.0238512512, -0.097325407, -0.0519199297, -0.0232498813, 0.0150471013, 0.0281238183, 0.0158525594, -0.008999031, -0.054930672, 0.0250340588, 0.046571631, -0.0249898359, -0.0195298307, 0.0362372138, 0.0025491726, -0.055599317, 0.0133532686, -0.051297985, 0.0310752504, 0.0228723995, -0.0269843452, -0.0152396699, -0.05033179, -0.0210776217, -0.0001530114, 0.0314233936, -0.0356080569, -0.0461838841, -0.0202213507, 0.0284836479, 0.0404167324, -0.0421349518, -0.0275036599, -0.012437392, 0.0578276142, -0.0025259864, -0.0621740781, 0.015979033, 0.0441627391, 0.0324427485, -0.045098342, 0.0027949219, 0.0182903409, 0.0325307585, 0.0231640842, 0.000769633, -0.0657315478, -0.0411054865, 0.0241739396, 0.0165686458, -0.020800883, 0.0541545302, 0.017292656, 0.0250825752, -0.0261705387, 0.0222160313, -0.0356511511, -0.0137837501, -0.0402726196, 0.0538822562, 0.0402745418, -0.0480975509, 0.0091950512, -0.0277760159, -0.0368910618, -0.0293262564, 0.0541820303, 0.0326551534, -0.0023510093, 0.0045704134, 0.0084744245, -0.0435089916, 0.0541684926, 0.0720054507, 0.0221039578, 0.0024912984, 0.0149871958, -0.0794347152, -0.048701141, 0.022751946, -0.0075254911, 0.0143237123, 0.0044902856, 0.0077358219, -0.0732273981, -0.014146911, 0.0498533286, -0.0560140423, 0.0083040474, -0.0132400999, 0.0117188413, 0.0705814585, 0.0292164031, 0.0201203097, -0.0647096112, -0.0218287222, -0.0220289733, 0.0177217033, -0.0249194764, -5.194783206e-33, 0.0418807007, 0.0194714349, -0.0194702074, 0.0191428158, -0.0173278973, 0.0281215925, 0.0493946634, -0.0228796266, -0.007077862, -0.0231475271, 0.0237355828, -0.0076831668, 0.007413981, 0.0343008749, 0.0029910733, -0.0160173085, 0.0421836413, -0.003000499, -0.0571239814, 0.010808615, 0.0383149423, -0.0006224754, 0.0232829992, -0.0597506873, 0.0322059356, 0.0242108423, 0.0002151446, -0.009933861, 0.0095357578, 0.0421497896, -0.010254804, 0.0577052832, 0.022880502, -0.0337787867, 0.0485518128, -0.012768737, -0.0062318919, -0.0265887063, -0.0280234814, 0.0157237556, 0.0031690586, -0.0111614158, -0.0046707108, 0.0098834755, -0.0106099928, -0.0246052705, 0.053784661, -0.0277242661, -0.0436581261, -0.0564143956, -0.0308292974, 0.0632613674, -0.0121416003, -0.0209505428, 0.0502227992, 0.0321586169, 0.0111232167, 0.032927081, -0.0487456881, -0.0279353932, 0.0298201274, 0.0263549089, -0.0014312059, 0.0171021894, -0.0237324797, 0.0286409277, -0.0025383425, 0.0114977676, -0.0001974617, 0.0031459823, 0.0008537074, 0.0334249251, 0.0690361038, 0.0371826701, 0.0605124086, -0.0220830217, -0.0903855935, 0.0165679734, 0.0305359885, -0.0220587999, 0.0386166088, 0.0323570147, -0.0432232954, -0.0420200638, -0.0565367751, -0.0253427159, -0.0085641304, 0.0004253067, 0.0248046182, 0.0433405265, -0.0091262171, 0.0202958491, 0.0463474542, -0.0356203914, -0.0563659258, -0.0325910412, 0.002697306, 0.0458339415, 0.0017118482, 0.0033630761, -0.0232115407, -0.0110700605, -0.0091274697, -0.0055729998, 0.0141601898, -0.0576586425, 0.0607228428, 0.0130335102, -0.0599986948, 0.0076823598, -0.0053310981, 0.025153283, -0.0196020249, 0.0786665455, -0.0091571352, 0.0040691607, 0.0215885807, 0.0603757128, 0.0205216184, 0.0247414671, -0.0055706678, -0.0274423547, -0.0124939065, -0.024611216, -0.0223784335, -0.0031310904, -0.0042313379, 0.0496018641, -0.0038392732, -0.0659231693, -0.0073587694, -0.0123908808, 2.199e-7, 0.0596137866, 0.0438321456, -0.0302358698, -0.023310978, 0.0067003109, 0.0515872128, 0.0274987947, 0.0129955942, -0.0099015543, 0.049255047, -0.013143328, -0.0236562453, 0.0518087372, 0.0347000323, -0.0601834655, -0.0048721335, -0.0707500055, 0.058005292, -0.0405797809, 0.025148686, 0.064278774, 0.0968969464, 0.0367782824, -0.0041835052, -0.0078678522, -0.0417230092, 0.0664074048, -0.035781309, 0.037427932, 0.0496205091, 0.0476620384, 0.0163667463, 0.006630579, 0.0082877362, -0.0465902463, 0.0072457809, 0.0165189095, 0.0482635237, -0.0254248548, 0.0199428052, 0.0235325322, -0.0077458429, 0.0302762929, -0.0311604943, 0.1060370132, -0.0458918363, -0.041269768, -0.0347820446, -0.0131598953, -0.0512378067, 0.0572025999, 0.0014610586, -0.0013497869, 0.0168217737, -0.0045503662, -0.0382466763, -0.0233367439, -0.0737998337, 0.0019436134, 0.0129340291, -0.0136246989, -0.0347483195, -0.0209138431, 0.0301160384, 0.0890134797, -0.0618276447, 0.0130505208, 1.828238787e-34, 0.0179144666, -0.029995596, -0.0086314594, 0.0195488036, -0.0095598483, 0.0155017441, 0.0227120593, -0.0088704722, 0.0061516962, -0.0795610771, 0.0418141037 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.06985v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.06985v1
Statistical analysis of word flow among five Indo-European languages
2023-01-17T16:12:42
2023-01-17T16:12:42
Josué Ely Molina, Jorge Flores, Carlos Gershenson, Carlos Pineda
cs.CL
cs.CL, physics.soc-ph
A recent increase in data availability has allowed the possibility to perform different statistical linguistic studies. Here we use the Google Books Ngram dataset to analyze word flow among English, French, German, Italian, and Spanish. We study what we define as ``migrant words'', a type of loanwords that do not change their spelling. We quantify migrant words from one language to another for different decades, and notice that most migrant words can be aggregated in semantic fields and associated to historic events. We also study the statistical properties of accumulated migrant words and their rank dynamics. We propose a measure of use of migrant words that could be used as a proxy of cultural influence. Our methodology is not exempt of caveats, but our results are encouraging to promote further studies in this direction.
[ 0.0017753387, 0.0567575879, -0.046581842, 0.0180278551, -0.059934292, -0.0024825539, -0.007366416, 0.0113158813, 0.0048610345, -0.0099984379, 0.0137030873, -0.0579124652, 0.050625924, -0.0112868417, 0.0408335775, -0.0022815783, 0.0547606684, 0.0030176598, -0.0448204093, 0.0225751102, 0.0332979932, 0.0073970691, 0.0217527971, 0.017025914, -0.0058473004, 0.032109227, 0.0292508882, -0.0611798353, 0.0307965614, -0.0404634289, -0.0302539133, 0.0383782648, 0.0139641166, 0.0566909797, 0.0000017214, -0.0608966127, 0.0052428208, -0.0070759063, 0.0048695579, 0.0083067929, 0.0556443781, 0.0493533202, -0.0280357413, -0.0292604938, -0.0081926966, -0.013773649, 0.0476519279, -0.0501698516, -0.0174255874, 0.0255243033, -0.0092191715, -0.0611227117, 0.0102443174, -0.0399969406, 0.0302610099, 0.0072942106, 0.0238175746, -0.0285215806, -0.0171212386, -0.0395023152, -0.0684950352, 0.0229247529, -0.0575617217, -0.0045572729, -0.0086382944, 0.0114991367, -0.0215329528, 0.0001038363, 0.0285892375, 0.0321280621, -0.0111192064, -0.0226411801, 0.0483395196, 0.0138464496, -0.0288998187, 0.0687262416, -0.0277460013, -0.0282785445, 0.015546578, -0.0061010108, 0.1407890171, 0.0310971756, 0.0063054259, 0.0254964177, -0.0513717085, 0.0825139657, 0.0476684906, -0.0185695402, -0.0075128856, -0.04639953, 0.0306841042, -0.0661737248, 0.0040720808, 0.0148923714, 0.0040756566, 0.0460530855, 0.0388564877, -0.0065169153, -0.0140179219, -0.0226675905, 0.0070700091, -0.014443351, 0.000929493, 0.0471648164, 0.0347758792, -0.0065244036, 0.0082377074, -0.0528132506, 0.0087264804, 0.0127111953, -0.0377169177, 0.0148024866, 0.0200181156, -0.0245940033, -0.016151607, 0.0284221862, -0.0432435498, 0.0013806219, 0.0191273987, -0.0526488386, -0.0053067515, -0.0546347387, -0.0171851777, 0.005140848, -0.0389664322, 0.0023479711, -0.051909402, -0.0005446807, -0.0298299231, -0.0462005772, 0.035636045, -0.0008117713, 0.0145849157, -0.0455873273, -0.0048438157, 0.0504275598, 0.0093812197, -0.0209909752, -0.0229336377, -0.0006620752, -0.0318633169, -0.0163719449, 0.0109732496, -0.0763541162, 0.0414561145, 0.0174481887, 0.0318706632, -0.0273764227, -0.0113008777, 0.0136253154, -0.0947214365, -0.0312115345, -0.0095262621, 0.0234314241, -0.0067617423, -0.0220230855, 0.0210587177, -0.0112527432, 0.046164047, -0.0568271354, 0.0601531379, -0.0357150435, -0.0017391993, 0.013979868, -0.0257276483, 0.0330102891, -0.0218567271, -0.013512833, 0.0061168615, -0.0284597725, 0.0108859977, 0.010358749, -0.0093899854, 0.0000153437, 0.0073696594, 0.0991603434, -0.0127248829, 0.0236464571, -0.0185085367, -0.05415117, -0.0270040035, 0.0016920755, 0.0353111476, -0.0313720703, 0.0436078385, -0.0529789664, 0.0339753069, 0.0622396134, 0.0152929295, 0.0185625013, 0.0249153525, 0.0236414485, 0.0387101062, -0.0469512939, 0.0594196767, -0.0205192398, 0.0240106117, 0.0008925584, 0.0422292016, -0.0550800078, 0.0075461352, 0.0220600441, 0.0581162237, 0.0242799073, 0.0383231044, 0.019925179, 0.0583392568, 0.0487926789, 0.0259261187, 0.0065094996, -0.0255307443, 0.0112238172, 0.0254270211, -0.014142259, 0.0212820675, 0.0464427136, 0.0001479152, 0.0380636938, -0.0330017097, 0.0644179359, -0.004848185, -0.0463917144, -0.0383682698, 0.0158885624, -0.0357879028, 0.025436312, -0.0156415422, -0.0392758437, 0.0131020984, 0.0094795506, -0.0341034457, 0.00283303, 0.0190238152, -0.0349467099, 0.0208140463, 0.0590438545, 0.0229848325, 0.0390961878, -0.0040059877, -0.0541533045, 0.0255621616, -0.048963055, 0.0122012403, -0.0246834997, 0.0755396783, -0.0201167706, 0.0629979968, 0.016269248, 0.0596090667, -0.0145061705, 0.0519529246, -0.0258041639, 0.0679473281, -0.0095092664, 0.0877477601, -0.0383330695, -0.0089307018, 0.040158283, 0.019472817, -0.0109233633, 0.0288453363, 0.025521839, -0.02471889, 0.0463118404, -0.0422102213, -0.0285600983, 0.0174261741, -0.0046486966, 0.0014600089, 0.003552658, 0.0533545427, -0.0206302255, 0.037145678, -0.0182081759, 0.0427468643, -0.0088689607, 0.0169553403, 0.0116552841, 0.0083082728, 0.0472564697, -0.0619169436, 0.0096580964, -0.0384828858, 0.0007413316, 0.0109607317, 0.0376841947, 0.0119063882, -0.0603636131, -0.0252475031, -0.029776752, -0.0990032181, 0.0024340774, -0.0459822826, -0.0528216809, -0.017728854, -0.0022895308, 0.0614257269, -0.0082448777, -0.0043392833, -0.0047787447, 0.0139438082, -0.0843758285, -0.0008926589, -0.0694637522, -0.0202121083, 0.0386509076, -0.0175797269, -0.0476075821, 0.0199239366, 0.0678774938, 0.0212758407, -0.0045397431, 0.0191546399, -0.0127282478, -0.0803575665, 0.0182180908, 0.0060519879, 0.0445195884, -0.0570664331, 0.0947804749, -0.0071601616, -0.0405132696, -0.021939164, 0.0105115166, 0.0306066573, -0.0138871307, -0.0470600538, -0.039075058, 0.0229194649, 0.0190553088, 0.0124839405, 0.0040580579, -0.0209286641, -0.0407727212, -0.0150224799, 0.0538143441, -0.0303236302, 0.0296041332, -0.0621460751, -0.0015217819, 0.0081216348, 0.0126432385, 0.0307526737, -0.0752596036, 0.0119959954, -0.0483460166, 0.0647365525, -0.0666615888, 0.0307744276, 0.0085901888, 0.0032650989, 0.0188934561, 0.0306248236, 0.0213131327, 0.0143868886, 0.0480936356, 0.0002803605, 0.023619011, -0.0136532364, 0.0146264704, -0.0167445969, -0.0008228958, 0.0324546397, 0.0037852272, 0.0165598858, 0.0166981295, 0.0251159873, -0.0403924584, -0.0489967428, -0.0060296752, -0.0108025772, -0.016661698, 0.0144223059, 0.021269301, 0.0545952842, 0.0340350717, 0.0486759543, 0.0061283475, 0.0386513509, 0.0256287511, 0.0040661413, -0.0638695806, 0.0485611819, -0.0144596724, -0.0304586515, -0.0241273474, -0.032994058, -0.0400616676, -0.1306018382, 0.0003194553, 0.0000600109, -0.0377391279, 0.0212239921, -0.0115470216, -0.0016297564, -0.0004623962, -0.0831714869, 0.0031296534, 0.0114972377, 0.0118000647, 0.0257453844, -0.0532838814, -0.0117977075, 0.0156678967, -0.0202656016, 0.0381750092, -0.0224920958, 0.0571785234, -0.0935388431, -0.0904281586, 0.0180360526, -0.0209858716, -0.0293042678, 0.0069444063, 0.0440591723, 0.0368758701, -0.0233627148, -0.0142219216, -0.043968752, -0.0050473902, -0.0203256998, 0.0417291932, 0.0626606569, 0.0242305677, -0.04333717, 0.0165713243, -0.0200860295, 0.0039786836, -0.0015327818, -0.0044595175, -0.0116251949, 0.0524960309, -0.0169220399, 0.0172409173, 0.0460932404, -0.0584826693, -0.0136044426, -0.0834909305, -0.0930595919, -0.102992788, -0.0327109993, -0.0118893329, 0.0755424574, 0.0690750629, 0.0683017075, -0.0008376536, -0.0398020707, -0.0278143156, 0.0271325335, -0.0092723425, 0.0209239125, -0.0303403474, -0.0057303221, 0.0364672728, 0.0376845263, -0.0562794134, -0.0218449086, -0.0381596461, -0.0712969378, 0.0223734975, -0.0095110564, 0.0286657866, -0.0325182043, -0.0137765454, -0.0197647512, -0.0001705442, 0.0058095451, 0.0054372177, -0.0061104149, -0.0157587156, -0.0468910411, 0.0084108543, 0.0160857979, -0.0255504418, 0.007567565, -0.0246927906, 0.0088453768, -0.0547311716, 0.0048472085, 0.0182579812, -0.0189039912, 0.03205112, -0.069042407, -0.0201605912, -0.0375867076, -0.0183370896, 0.0123699205, -0.0156934913, 0.0201366674, -0.0081170481, 0.0230984185, 0.0290373154, -0.0302562695, 0.0017147277, 0.0045236982, 0.0026907763, -0.0073637469, -0.0125040887, 0.0131515274, 0.0631386116, -0.0075013754, 0.0519034863, 0.0345640667, 0.0424315408, -0.0510785468, 0.060618192, -0.0327132419, 0.0015378713, -0.0186817143, -0.0015538399, 0.0362699144, 0.033145275, -0.0278015826, -0.0051451731, 0.0532345921, -0.0008632826, 0.0552002825, -0.0480088368, 0.0743874609, 0.0178786013, -0.0069842292, -0.0211356673, 0.0054736915, -0.0323995315, -0.0094695389, -0.027569171, 0.0043753614, -0.0168896262, 0.0607503653, 0.0494730212, -0.0175067447, -0.0130423866, 0.0214094743, -0.0418892018, 0.0095524704, 0.0243224539, 0.009738869, -0.0392023884, 0.0155455368, 0.0030094576, -0.0944929346, -0.0582513027, -0.0280615967, -0.0220009852, 0.0268423371, -0.0276240874, 0.0124249719, 0.0431573465, -0.017606942, 0.0889061168, -0.0792587921, 0.0456712432, -0.0481864884, -0.0170717333, -0.0011667333, -6.008324479e-33, -0.0034739019, -0.0369730704, -0.0016093708, 0.0203208998, -0.0176348872, -0.0187576637, -0.0330510139, 0.0111284312, -0.0275152083, 0.0125740068, 0.00162529, -0.010380147, 0.005911109, -0.028185308, 0.0344133079, 0.0136846155, -0.0646368042, 0.0426313207, -0.0014143002, -0.0278375335, 0.0778860599, -0.0205541737, 0.0946061313, -0.0272388253, 0.0563508682, 0.0138704991, 0.0086111184, -0.0130672408, 0.0155196637, -0.0190993324, -0.0082671707, -0.0042428202, 0.0251941122, -0.0313541032, -0.0022211799, -0.0222695768, -0.002934159, -0.0545626096, 0.0428037979, 0.0149654467, 0.0464526191, -0.0191095248, -0.0066996203, 0.0083866986, -0.0561626293, 0.0656223372, 0.0408558585, 0.0483976044, -0.0524846762, -0.0002798515, -0.0136018964, 0.0388810001, -0.0080716927, 0.0229346938, -0.0146699287, 0.0047899275, 0.0190565884, -0.0179428626, -0.019439552, 0.0597231463, -0.0015149121, 0.0492001548, 0.0003328423, -0.0047935201, -0.0094177369, 0.0507284366, 0.0216955151, -0.0379940346, 0.0888446942, 0.0579114333, 0.0266804583, 0.0166318268, -0.0112078432, 0.0479293019, 0.0714577138, -0.034289822, 0.0040245149, -0.0275154524, 0.0424158312, -0.0202264041, -0.0368792936, -0.0193116833, -0.0106434803, -0.0160196647, 0.0115032298, -0.0454458073, 0.0250077564, 0.006687222, 0.008822768, -0.0439041331, 0.0369434282, -0.0257755015, 0.0379507877, -0.0129369684, -0.0877494216, -0.0173104703, -0.0144401956, 0.0244097449, 0.0116275623, 0.0418728292, -0.0341046453, -0.0134750456, -0.0220568124, 0.0543040819, 0.0393231586, -0.0035755497, -0.0271549709, 0.0168369748, -0.0526845232, -0.02156079, -0.0194002781, -0.0307776444, -0.0152189126, -0.0056305998, 0.0182218179, -0.0114534963, -0.0220322143, -0.0473932177, 0.0981243104, 0.0093598291, 0.003258426, -0.0500129461, -0.0047317971, -0.0088557173, -0.0216306336, -0.0050011426, -0.0147476913, 0.0884515047, 0.0801853314, -0.0055454466, -0.0237455349, -0.0161665995, 2.772e-7, 0.0513023473, 0.0237550326, -0.0217084121, 0.0358508416, 0.0051698685, -0.0267711803, -0.0570608974, 0.0196168162, -0.0025649176, 0.0103833126, -0.0244382657, -0.0426797867, 0.0545044877, 0.0459663831, -0.0574991703, -0.0469790138, -0.0687991381, -0.01690837, -0.0427017473, -0.0209101327, -0.0244593266, 0.0723861754, 0.0390714183, -0.0103059737, -0.0601286255, 0.0053545521, 0.0182784609, -0.028976975, -0.0451525338, -0.0236875881, 0.0124248834, -0.0228626467, -0.0104065677, 0.0133236228, -0.0255026072, 0.0627752393, 0.0508109182, -0.0301058758, -0.0057989033, 0.0559678636, 0.011592593, -0.0650655627, -0.0065860464, -0.0338748656, 0.0206860304, 0.0787655786, -0.0195439439, -0.0301001482, -0.0548698306, 0.045153942, 0.0377880037, 0.0140190683, -0.0251242127, -0.0021526974, 0.020900175, -0.0140610803, -0.034807317, -0.022801362, -0.0463208519, 0.0235364437, 0.007915888, -0.0767869502, 0.0444202311, 0.0067420704, -0.0100427996, 0.0293578319, -0.0266652927, 2.226010005e-34, 0.0445281044, -0.0085429437, 0.0014187752, -0.0056399889, 0.0754767656, -0.0231873672, 0.0238289926, 0.0443064645, 0.0176182371, -0.0213307813, -0.0220827833 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.07491v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.07491v1
The Newsbridge -Telecom SudParis VoxCeleb Speaker Recognition Challenge 2022 System Description
2023-01-17T15:52:39
2023-01-17T15:52:39
Yannis Tevissen, Jérôme Boudy, Frédéric Petitpont
cs.SD
cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS
We describe the system used by our team for the VoxCeleb Speaker Recognition Challenge 2022 (VoxSRC 2022) in the speaker diarization track. Our solution was designed around a new combination of voice activity detection algorithms that uses the strengths of several systems. We introduce a novel multi stream approach with a decision protocol based on classifiers entropy. We called this method a multi-stream voice activity detection and used it with standard baseline diarization embeddings, clustering and resegmentation. With this work, we successfully demonstrated that using a strong baseline and working only on voice activity detection, one can achieved close to state-of-theart results.
[ -0.0598550662, 0.0271469224, 0.0004946279, 0.0058542816, 0.0067714755, -0.0063206516, 0.0119785909, -0.0135550108, -0.0570333228, 0.0054018637, 0.0028821474, -0.0526235253, 0.0324753374, -0.0253893379, -0.0024089094, -0.0897887349, 0.0254825614, 0.0032414526, -0.0058090785, 0.0093271527, -0.0032445265, -0.02936274, -0.0404263772, -0.0007055469, -0.0174985174, 0.0089549562, -0.0296811927, 0.007340529, 0.0456935093, 0.0022176753, -0.0477748103, 0.0500546992, 0.0401941277, 0.0654102638, 0.0000018957, -0.0273779966, -0.0144703574, 0.012702967, -0.0374472626, -0.0200766977, -0.0047806371, 0.0509838238, -0.0387329981, -0.0002782181, 0.0056806328, -0.042165041, 0.0379735418, -0.0028742596, 0.038517952, -0.0081099309, -0.0033782381, -0.0235596169, 0.0740453154, 0.02530385, 0.0422165096, -0.015582351, 0.0133718513, -0.0402304754, 0.0029608191, -0.0555313751, 0.0232015718, 0.02959943, -0.0029030321, 0.003729023, 0.026870735, 0.0081514362, 0.009797086, -0.0014243075, 0.0202254169, 0.0398778841, 0.016538268, 0.0215769112, 0.0157900564, 0.056416776, -0.0327001698, -0.0228766073, -0.0181397833, -0.0220936593, 0.0202107374, -0.0239828769, -0.0293402225, 0.05361652, 0.0114360405, -0.0003542829, 0.0053523607, -0.023774663, -0.0051083979, -0.0291145779, -0.00606417, -0.0267941114, 0.0403770618, -0.0052961558, 0.0089113824, 0.0053132582, -0.0127637656, -0.0208460335, 0.0154143339, -0.0409848392, -0.0406925343, -0.0391063243, -0.0105137061, 0.0179921966, 0.0178393982, 0.0336776525, 0.0279043633, 0.0124422908, 0.0376991294, -0.0099402564, -0.0272007454, -0.0014389725, -0.0341610499, 0.0244085994, -0.0294765178, -0.0039087022, 0.0459427424, -0.0090729222, -0.036163643, 0.0120165125, -0.042123314, 0.0002582873, -0.0202465728, -0.0087556336, 0.010873205, 0.0167868845, 0.0453443415, 0.0421973132, -0.020648066, 0.0091689629, -0.0524634123, -0.0353991538, -0.006689236, 0.021479981, -0.0005129236, 0.0090437029, -0.0194354635, -0.0832071081, 0.0058655627, -0.0527797416, -0.0213151164, 0.0190056823, -0.0147338444, -0.0615629256, -0.0133390445, -0.0424529426, 0.0002214668, -0.0392004028, -0.0035372039, 0.0193698294, -0.0298222564, -0.0509223714, 0.0434904099, 0.0917774588, 0.0031863479, 0.0252217688, 0.0446300656, 0.0170989297, 0.0256567784, 0.0685438961, 0.035936866, -0.0390614979, -0.0019002289, -0.0308632609, -0.0094179744, 0.0625665486, -0.0585134886, -0.0008103378, -0.0310034417, -0.0204951428, 0.0011478317, 0.0204077084, 0.0349604674, -0.0362534449, -0.0268406458, -0.0371317118, 0.0388736762, 0.0762877762, -0.0193753224, -0.0560966618, -0.0164176542, -0.0117801623, 0.0354073495, -0.0003352329, 0.0307049658, -0.0243227985, 0.0278124847, -0.0341334753, 0.0606249422, 0.0526527092, -0.059509784, -0.0153230522, 0.027481135, -0.0615065582, -0.0082510365, 0.0285290126, 0.0190358087, -0.0548964776, 0.0525520742, 0.0501360409, -0.00465531, -0.0380878299, 0.0109109413, -0.0115379458, 0.0063986336, 0.0492638089, 0.0151207065, -0.0624346845, 0.0282003041, -0.0563846789, 0.0188687611, -0.0408453047, -0.0005112471, -0.0008273618, 0.0510835275, -0.0502968654, -0.0543766953, 0.0593877919, 0.0039804657, 0.0033013695, -0.0186976362, -0.0074156062, 0.0135666626, -0.0456576087, 0.0774029419, -0.0014224998, 0.0177347809, 0.0008535166, 0.0448091142, 0.0228917003, 0.0824510902, 0.0539490543, -0.03638855, -0.0238150861, 0.0406358056, -0.0256206747, 0.0344745368, 0.0690304041, -0.0153418491, -0.0433666743, 0.0444310568, 0.0212339386, -0.0070022605, 0.0606206283, 0.0060221818, -0.0907275826, 0.0341361277, -0.0251488406, -0.0266550966, -0.0407071263, 0.0206476729, -0.0188792497, 0.0136661595, -0.020878002, -0.0294806939, 0.0097669493, 0.0243726708, 0.0080681387, 0.0017742413, 0.0316867828, -0.0624143258, -0.0134727303, 0.0291359816, -0.0400418192, 0.0377498008, -0.0304919183, -0.0352104083, 0.0060523325, 0.0176962204, -0.0185052492, -0.0180136524, -0.0271619074, 0.0008005879, -0.0181604996, 0.0530082844, 0.0063552535, -0.0207665097, -0.0101062413, -0.003861424, -0.0040448909, -0.0064222724, -0.0286463927, -0.0410910323, -0.0308620166, 0.013666207, -0.0072527695, 0.0034613141, 0.0327245928, -0.0244781319, -0.0132682323, -0.0009793311, -0.0373843387, 0.0429112539, -0.0014813675, -0.0083865141, 0.0154902767, -0.0190675724, 0.0213837549, 0.0432032198, 0.0337646827, 0.06441807, 0.0091385124, -0.0321011469, 0.0283298194, -0.0139358649, 0.0181984808, 0.0048842072, 0.0751826316, -0.0252247825, 0.0076734433, 0.0062871431, -0.0039451523, -0.0300959032, 0.0453881919, 0.0248818416, -0.0769935697, -0.0212760866, -0.0392310992, -0.0149046993, -0.0285696778, -0.0635169446, -0.0517351292, -0.0121331541, -0.0119262878, 0.005408349, -0.0554123484, -0.0219989549, -0.059879981, -0.0632107258, 0.0076324237, -0.0065287426, 0.0026449498, 0.0331183746, 0.027878195, -0.0379203856, -0.0111863706, -0.0641996115, -0.0047248569, -0.0533262566, -0.003269041, 0.0326549485, -0.0050066663, -0.0295349676, -0.0326666869, -0.029873129, -0.0064207292, 0.0208748262, 0.0273657497, 0.0319697373, -0.0518378764, -0.0528116412, 0.0753814355, 0.0392330587, -0.0117674172, 0.0063462448, 0.0190153625, 0.0040010465, 0.107334204, 0.0170694832, 0.0729120076, -0.0322194993, 0.0140817845, 0.0125969928, 0.0109575698, 0.0642195567, 0.0273548961, -0.0224626102, -0.015094188, 0.0486859679, -0.0182776507, -0.0242574159, 0.012819252, 0.0809386522, 0.0118740434, 0.0099828308, 0.1137348041, 0.0176789351, -0.0608954169, -0.0240064301, 0.0107245119, 0.0075900382, -0.0000846098, -0.0051343404, -0.0159817003, -0.0210702736, 0.04132713, 0.0538545661, 0.0000440186, 0.021387754, -0.0298405048, -0.0117312446, 0.0666034892, 0.0308311917, -0.0494475849, 0.0041725617, -0.0908720046, -0.0059734811, -0.0509443954, 0.0113560185, -0.0322695635, 0.0291591529, -0.0078517059, 0.028089324, -0.1287605762, -0.0181368534, 0.006680008, -0.0358274058, 0.0632978603, 0.0105586722, 0.0345789827, -0.0049410895, -0.0010587662, -0.0524913073, -0.0656699762, -0.0422584228, -0.0064304979, 0.0397330374, 0.0215375554, 0.0223265216, -0.0077359206, -0.0067005763, 0.0199259482, -0.0199709777, 0.0052902596, 0.0594034828, -0.0193984639, 0.0238098688, -0.0348957703, 0.05519085, 0.0479141325, 0.0555923246, 0.0074058585, 0.0147889201, -0.0111416401, 0.0232296195, 0.0717634931, -0.0275216028, 0.021632595, -0.0324077457, 0.0130987614, -0.0860651359, 0.0056928708, 0.0076029804, -0.008058222, 0.0622466728, -0.0367141813, 0.0640770197, -0.0209280141, 0.028032314, -0.0750881508, -0.01509187, -0.0036046435, 0.0736196041, -0.0280894898, -0.0449380539, 0.0401625596, -0.0144011285, -0.006382429, 0.0218425225, -0.0257906746, -0.0130959023, 0.0299797487, -0.0228045639, 0.0202072468, 0.0575825386, -0.0782015249, -0.0087871077, 0.0838063285, -0.0019763769, 0.0038281966, 0.0149867237, 0.0477444641, -0.0291366857, -0.0611967295, 0.0063696154, 0.0041101584, 0.0366232805, 0.00364201, -0.0595631599, -0.09505108, -0.0593103692, -0.0438427553, 0.0122680943, 0.0227810014, 0.0017915085, -0.0463546291, -0.0046953866, -0.0067044026, 0.0285665542, 0.0382579193, -0.0022824833, -0.0233645346, 0.019030394, 0.0114225671, 0.0098344013, 0.0930534676, -0.0078996066, -0.0362465382, -0.0007379503, 0.0405131653, 0.0311733838, 0.0272517949, -0.045155827, -0.0040919557, 0.0252859183, 0.0316836424, 0.0423714966, -0.0175055377, -0.0067150556, -0.0099278633, -0.0381339788, 0.0102077127, 0.0163127817, 0.0677365437, -0.097840406, 0.0253916942, -0.0152162081, -0.0013301709, 0.0306302961, 0.0546577498, 0.025629377, 0.0210068058, 0.0164202377, -0.0332315266, 0.0043166773, -0.0462269448, 0.0091297254, 0.0127884364, 0.0205650385, -0.012798924, 0.0256549511, 0.0427630842, 0.0160042495, 0.0137667796, -0.0268786009, -0.00523496, -0.0408233888, -0.0356044471, 0.0117301755, 0.0567401126, -0.0460658893, -0.0299036261, 0.0088738054, 0.0016125676, 0.0222903099, -0.0807939917, 0.0055802255, 0.0277233645, 0.0197292808, -0.006395374, -0.0386917256, 0.0004548485, 0.0116627524, -0.0449031629, -0.0427166894, -0.0358436108, 0.0338540711, -5.838827745e-33, 0.0061740633, 0.0503246114, -0.0244255848, -0.0485073626, -0.0342133604, 0.0121718617, -0.0003012154, -0.0004578875, -0.0129757617, -0.036999803, -0.0007528512, -0.0075490694, 0.0412864238, 0.0051436001, -0.0321518332, -0.0342110656, 0.1032400206, -0.0370498225, -0.0044174907, 0.0247843396, 0.063510485, 0.0196067076, 0.0256164446, -0.0469660796, -0.0703807175, 0.0402794443, -0.0271161068, 0.0015123138, 0.0147038018, 0.0077703954, -0.0040786886, 0.0160738956, 0.0007160337, -0.0539261252, -0.0144881764, 0.0519653149, -0.0593103841, 0.0029177915, -0.0605247132, 0.0925362185, -0.0092746066, 0.0073862732, 0.0139469765, 0.0138166305, -0.0354505368, -0.0179411769, 0.045484677, -0.0292039458, -0.0273954459, -0.0540453978, 0.0352809615, 0.0387227312, -0.0430760831, -0.045553714, 0.0416714922, -0.0079191308, 0.0140074082, -0.0687101111, -0.0877708569, 0.0796922445, -0.0235935617, 0.0169544015, 0.0071522431, 0.0618011095, 0.0158523545, 0.0193318427, 0.0690821484, -0.0718481243, 0.0167155378, 0.0062073739, 0.0171116795, 0.0566880889, -0.0006170959, 0.022861205, 0.0437647849, -0.0559112467, -0.0398971029, 0.0798723176, 0.0914637074, -0.0203593653, -0.0238718167, 0.0082568033, -0.0449864455, -0.0109827686, -0.0171414074, -0.0373896696, 0.0199565776, -0.0045446823, 0.0067208223, -0.0141192563, -0.0087672826, -0.0320027247, 0.0485964641, -0.0113927629, 0.0215812027, 0.0410241969, 0.0274516866, 0.0152365128, 0.0227647815, -0.0398656428, 0.0285542849, -0.0440134667, 0.0922833383, 0.0593535639, -0.0108589586, -0.0222507529, 0.0175508, 0.038195014, -0.0247556418, -0.0330441184, 0.0616879873, 0.0102449264, 0.002454855, 0.0485613719, 0.0070779989, -0.037949264, 0.0395638943, 0.0250483584, 0.0282077473, 0.0254498087, 0.0121687297, -0.0186008587, -0.0118053555, 0.0221707039, 0.0097209634, 0.0392728932, -0.0048629609, -0.0454674214, 0.0560574122, -0.0031107673, 0.0142820049, -0.0347821675, 2.718e-7, -0.0248758551, -0.0084859701, -0.0202799756, -0.0675331503, 0.0210263729, 0.0260910317, -0.0180971511, -0.0116645684, -0.020725226, 0.0042940085, 0.0259184334, -0.0133814486, 0.0829525739, 0.0583667308, -0.0983979553, -0.0744558349, 0.0153028639, 0.0359061956, -0.0596043877, 0.0517095998, 0.034211684, 0.0774814337, 0.0231348053, -0.0455753468, 0.0432950482, -0.0469982289, -0.0080046058, -0.0101074288, 0.0211052988, -0.003767719, 0.0493566953, -0.0382650979, 0.0289095081, 0.0203955229, -0.0330940485, 0.0364385955, -0.0101576513, 0.0083316378, -0.0070603238, -0.0647790805, -0.0557833575, 0.0490189455, 0.0129874488, 0.0047393613, 0.057587672, 0.0494858585, -0.0718955919, -0.0335454941, -0.0363979265, 0.0098636607, 0.0335083306, 0.0364769846, -0.005281317, -0.0066269226, -0.0201849733, -0.0370274149, -0.0177670307, -0.0549630933, 0.0124914674, -0.0126566961, -0.0645840466, -0.0509978235, 0.0068899989, -0.0099103684, 0.0595249236, 0.0012574049, 0.0133880069, 2.250016262e-34, -0.0270113349, 0.0144720664, 0.0018741073, -0.0152443741, -0.0272465851, -0.0388754569, 0.0028707802, -0.0118733346, 0.0073022428, -0.0364660211, 0.0150839696 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.06862v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.06862v2
Algorithms for Acyclic Weighted Finite-State Automata with Failure Arcs
2023-01-17T13:15:44
2023-07-11T09:08:33
Anej Svete, Benjamin Dayan, Tim Vieira, Ryan Cotterell, Jason Eisner
cs.DS
cs.DS, cs.CL
Weighted finite-state automata (WSFAs) are commonly used in NLP. Failure transitions are a useful extension for compactly representing backoffs or interpolation in $n$-gram models and CRFs, which are special cases of WFSAs. The pathsum in ordinary acyclic WFSAs is efficiently computed by the backward algorithm in time $O(|E|)$, where $E$ is the set of transitions. However, this does not allow failure transitions, and preprocessing the WFSA to eliminate failure transitions could greatly increase $|E|$. We extend the backward algorithm to handle failure transitions directly. Our approach is efficient when the average state has outgoing arcs for only a small fraction $s \ll 1$ of the alphabet $\Sigma$. We propose an algorithm for general acyclic WFSAs which runs in $O{\left(|E| + s |\Sigma| |Q| T_\text{max} \log{|\Sigma|}\right)}$, where $Q$ is the set of states and $T_\text{max}$ is the size of the largest connected component of failure transitions. When the failure transition topology satisfies a condition exemplified by CRFs, the $T_\text{max}$ factor can be dropped, and when the weight semiring is a ring, the $\log{|\Sigma|}$ factor can be dropped. In the latter case (ring-weighted acyclic WFSAs), we also give an alternative algorithm with complexity $\displaystyle O{\left(|E| + |\Sigma| |Q| \min(1,s\pi_\text{max}) \right)}$, where $\pi_\text{max}$ is the size of the longest failure path.
[ -0.0169256534, 0.0498879924, -0.0125936382, 0.0037670778, -0.0466713011, -0.0166252013, -0.057944905, 0.0120190587, -0.0069901799, -0.0032208634, 0.0544263944, -0.0267412085, -0.001161808, 0.0533289947, -0.0217265617, -0.0301592443, 0.0411284901, -0.054862868, -0.0303750783, 0.0031148919, -0.0070185079, -0.0145563558, -0.0399083868, 0.0355604924, -0.0168466996, -0.0214405339, -0.0180246159, -0.0457989238, 0.0449269339, -0.0291455034, -0.0262438208, 0.0180202425, -0.0563268252, -0.01943966, 0.0000020684, -0.0224045776, -0.0320154056, 0.0055021518, -0.0117196981, 0.0203674696, -0.0261972938, -0.0019465815, -0.0306172911, 0.0516993888, 0.0064716823, 0.0176962018, 0.0573138036, 0.0292977858, 0.0532100983, 0.0260087121, -0.015529857, -0.0245253872, 0.0678415671, -0.0054909065, -0.0576443709, -0.0683457628, 0.0681182444, 0.0264269356, 0.0151728615, -0.096900776, -0.0474886112, -0.0362211168, -0.0398635864, -0.0529143959, -0.0598174147, -0.0187137239, 0.0068015931, 0.0131701427, -0.0243589785, 0.0344505683, -0.011051598, -0.0101036411, 0.0106423842, -0.0031594648, -0.025738446, -0.0406975634, -0.0092078429, 0.0721329898, -0.005471725, 0.0235346816, 0.0347901285, 0.0426409878, 0.0049285796, -0.0301410183, -0.0609008409, 0.0877513438, 0.0465028249, -0.0048761806, -0.0300470479, -0.0113239996, -0.0134120509, -0.0424242653, 0.073541753, 0.0120818531, 0.008753865, 0.0085099684, -0.0448720828, 0.0068869046, -0.0006980688, 0.0061551514, 0.0583142862, 0.0330578387, 0.0419198386, -0.0057704076, 0.0147821791, -0.0126146851, 0.0184874162, -0.0416195281, -0.0068957973, 0.0348434187, -0.0089012366, 0.0024685261, -0.0705310777, 0.0114569636, 0.0136829354, -0.0068901018, -0.012359228, 0.0460465066, -0.0248600114, 0.0014397257, 0.0143189905, -0.0228245333, 0.0069772894, 0.0314137042, -0.0031638814, 0.0450403504, -0.0223122071, -0.0358613096, -0.0121852187, 0.0332589112, 0.018886622, 0.0066032005, 0.0325302742, -0.0060767052, -0.021846896, 0.1006292924, 0.0627068132, -0.062664412, -0.0404469967, -0.0098169539, 0.0069179325, -0.0487046763, -0.0020677135, -0.0058170734, 0.0100603634, 0.0048461384, 0.0345657282, 0.0137060191, 0.0197808277, 0.0186074749, 0.0040216981, 0.011512707, -0.0315652527, 0.018512154, -0.0481876433, -0.0224858392, 0.0435985476, -0.0015478252, 0.0096951239, -0.0281594153, 0.017555261, 0.0174621474, -0.0269032065, 0.0205047633, -0.0259429868, 0.0364993326, -0.0260017179, -0.081093967, 0.0314308479, -0.0295814853, 0.0220511034, 0.0733244568, -0.042769935, -0.0450172015, -0.0353701673, 0.0114745237, 0.0271114781, 0.0335929841, 0.0121159973, -0.0034282485, 0.0304067712, 0.0415790975, 0.0061232364, -0.0095091499, -0.0518394709, 0.0079924343, 0.0212243907, 0.0303370785, -0.0102024209, -0.0318247788, -0.0404026657, -0.0449399464, 0.0447507352, -0.0656695142, 0.0342969187, -0.011068562, -0.0401000641, -0.0077045737, 0.0202541854, -0.0096938284, -0.0280606002, -0.0184961762, -0.0180599261, 0.0264525227, 0.0402298495, -0.051551532, -0.0232909098, 0.0483318642, -0.0176466163, -0.0178607199, -0.0310124457, -0.0011904882, -0.0177819841, -0.0254501645, 0.0031841719, 0.1126497313, 0.0435144901, 0.0193286017, -0.0530730784, -0.0064275404, -0.0274350923, 0.0058203097, -0.0735393167, 0.0082552359, 0.009615778, 0.0021518732, -0.012138227, -0.0002426773, 0.0073379693, 0.0402972177, -0.0193990897, 0.0415073745, 0.0433517583, 0.0143774236, -0.0472768322, 0.0141808586, -0.0097519681, -0.0143891731, 0.0669813305, -0.0183693152, -0.0131641496, 0.0015955917, -0.0217925552, -0.0485965461, 0.0558417626, -0.0508441627, 0.0240506586, 0.0158723705, 0.052080512, 0.0616916455, 0.0086370371, 0.0141848773, 0.024045283, 0.0226124153, 0.0529817604, -0.059874855, -0.0221075919, 0.0466035604, -0.0099349879, -0.0415435843, 0.0292402636, -0.07650619, -0.0036922018, 0.008799931, -0.0205511004, 0.0241056047, -0.0183845535, -0.0055742036, -0.0197777431, 0.007087064, 0.0723623186, -0.0277584661, 0.0462265536, -0.0037735668, 0.0286062174, 0.0212360471, 0.0487572886, -0.0019916939, 0.022580117, 0.0076264627, 0.0137275402, -0.0752765536, -0.0295659453, -0.042349387, -0.0259568915, 0.0294511914, -0.0252943765, -0.0371782035, -0.1075611636, -0.0048098126, -0.0149649484, 0.033500243, -0.0211891457, -0.05546657, 0.0096437261, -0.0056453245, 0.0725863278, -0.0189671293, -0.004258269, 0.0060094711, 0.0451922081, 0.0075606466, 0.0460979268, -0.0246426873, -0.0063139941, 0.004528427, -0.0095615108, -0.0090820733, 0.0438321717, 0.0768855736, -0.0004149543, -0.0378312208, -0.0126811005, -0.0870154426, -0.047277052, 0.0459435619, 0.0271604471, -0.0694962963, -0.0168372113, 0.035513185, 0.0318621434, 0.0088387998, 0.0087390942, -0.0436875895, 0.0566993132, -0.0272310227, -0.0378043838, -0.0613495894, 0.0231062751, 0.026715694, 0.036644768, 0.0663325414, -0.0265456662, 0.0312876664, -0.0046813795, -0.0260907747, 0.0073611694, 0.0133155836, -0.0237015914, 0.0649935901, -0.0224175304, -0.0241638869, 0.0249775164, 0.0338809416, -0.0124143027, -0.0113191642, 0.0066516208, -0.0063424069, 0.0118437512, 0.0524246134, -0.032452818, 0.0133614317, -0.0132793179, 0.0300095547, 0.0014150436, 0.0540315546, -0.0345966704, -0.0538400896, 0.0001476312, -0.0331976973, 0.006954615, 0.0262425002, 0.0788536444, 0.0573095009, -0.0298179425, -0.018091565, 0.0422760993, -0.0618606545, -0.0289313029, 0.0188021697, -0.0192786269, -0.0066451938, -0.0271653235, 0.059288498, 0.0544693619, -0.0258988105, 0.0758370981, -0.0082416153, -0.0083482806, 0.0165194757, -0.0157838427, -0.0595509522, 0.0256138854, 0.0215692502, -0.0197638944, -0.0195452217, -0.0019317074, 0.0689320117, -0.0782411173, 0.0352135077, 0.0061030053, 0.003257096, -0.0380466469, -0.032661587, 0.007398718, -0.0232218504, -0.022342667, 0.0221518893, -0.0308525264, -0.0131977815, 0.0612044223, -0.0240301061, 0.0021814203, -0.0207236521, 0.0116386442, 0.0447639525, 0.0003283652, 0.0680968687, -0.0000571558, -0.0459236167, 0.0684975684, -0.0277094804, -0.0170873236, -0.0338660069, -0.0264320038, 0.0629274696, -0.0304218773, 0.0192245468, -0.0068625156, -0.0402905941, -0.0448211096, -0.0500601381, 0.0639769658, 0.006655958, 0.0066482262, -0.0086808521, -0.0345156603, 0.0062264293, 0.0320977122, -0.000145588, -0.0191172939, -0.0624788851, -0.0267916843, -0.0203118902, -0.0316717289, -0.0573684573, -0.0484401323, 0.0202991739, -0.0001010013, -0.0608941354, 0.0071681356, 0.0233426895, 0.0762773082, -0.0358181633, -0.0069679911, 0.0139121162, -0.03689963, -0.0011279734, -0.0609803796, -0.0880073458, 0.0507494919, -0.0509507805, 0.0382372066, 0.0364228487, 0.065134421, -0.0666889623, 0.0009408206, -0.0174572691, -0.0263769943, 0.0736429021, 0.0168020371, 0.0299439915, -0.0864797607, -0.0556860194, -0.0168650821, -0.0008884806, 0.0255750325, 0.0358397774, -0.0008896677, 0.031073248, 0.0015654366, 0.0027428551, 0.0073465309, 0.0361321568, -0.0192100424, -0.0325679183, 0.0969626829, 0.0104904296, -0.0107252412, 0.0231606103, 0.0493504256, -0.0225035306, 0.0189047176, 0.0066624684, 0.0126448749, 0.0152844694, -0.0373856388, -0.0002459799, -0.0188742839, 0.0827753246, 0.007834658, -0.0248758756, -0.009621866, -0.0880414099, 0.0094873644, 0.0197885204, 0.0142312646, 0.0173354708, 0.0292734113, 0.0360257551, 0.004251115, -0.0241370276, 0.031317275, -0.0429066531, 0.0509668998, 0.0276411418, -0.0283901058, -0.020286411, 0.0044418825, 0.0132485116, -0.0468279719, 0.0210834853, -0.0138081899, 0.0403874591, -0.0274593588, 0.0437071398, 0.0539591163, -0.0006668483, 0.0460509546, -0.0680509508, 0.0218835883, -0.0319471993, 0.0009725542, 0.0249325037, -0.0112020569, 0.010312805, 0.0367759392, 0.0054515316, 0.023408195, 0.0707620904, 0.0074177207, 0.0898219645, -0.0000470863, -0.0023972325, -0.0474580899, -0.0216796361, -0.0668097287, 0.0022157144, -0.0222464968, -0.0184091944, -0.069242619, -0.0866518319, 0.0447301306, 0.0344023146, 0.0759715214, -0.0213725045, 0.0180512816, -0.0097009148, 0.0358366705, 0.0809875727, -0.0049608615, -0.0434957184, 0.0269845035, -0.0284299962, -0.0201059263, -6.010984035e-33, -0.0253296178, -0.0316588506, -0.0177472159, -0.025765121, -0.0021388796, -0.0014371709, -0.0354142934, 0.0404146425, 0.0627061874, 0.0173196029, 0.0053669084, -0.0093981633, 0.0093101868, -0.0017511074, -0.0439163893, 0.0334903225, 0.0060998439, 0.0210079867, -0.0173458904, -0.0132149644, 0.0192066804, -0.0338163562, 0.0222024415, -0.018379448, 0.0204021428, 0.0131765949, -0.0560401529, 0.0178082976, 0.0016291967, 0.0519193485, -0.0311663523, 0.0558115654, 0.0040105423, 0.0017491798, 0.0064526144, -0.0405495353, -0.0509730019, -0.0429540873, -0.0047641587, -0.0319503509, -0.0080021704, -0.0017805098, 0.0040489496, 0.0201365817, -0.0479738228, 0.0529130585, -0.0057259249, -0.0194219705, -0.0661296546, -0.0005089605, -0.0245005414, 0.0384865515, 0.0107346009, 0.0144823128, -0.0376895256, -0.0211575814, -0.0172356274, -0.0459487773, 0.0275718644, 0.0020841192, 0.0396770947, 0.0532733276, -0.030400075, -0.0907769948, -0.0383249633, 0.0075338385, 0.022891162, 0.007335878, 0.0626059026, 0.0140155908, -0.0006045734, -0.0103660105, 0.0104669817, -0.0209833961, -0.0020149786, -0.0393600464, -0.056487672, 0.0345437229, -0.0031026585, 0.0457512923, -0.0119813448, 0.0266740564, -0.0826712549, -0.0132443039, -0.0774002671, -0.0593781471, 0.0123673528, 0.0342412405, -0.0237883013, 0.0092839394, -0.0576636419, 0.0613256842, 0.0080852471, -0.0169830937, -0.074008733, -0.0067383442, -0.0077889189, 0.069372803, -0.0143372891, 0.0259541534, 0.0367344432, -0.0209981985, -0.0518745147, -0.053371422, 0.0003649885, -0.0382435471, -0.012180727, 0.0843146518, -0.0611168146, -0.0114045199, -0.0058249761, -0.0002771392, -0.0022127472, 0.0755786374, 0.0634744242, -0.0072016562, -0.0140034901, 0.0338182636, 0.0220822431, -0.0135057932, 0.01554986, 0.0151898907, 0.0040582265, 0.0400332399, -0.0313714705, -0.0338266268, -0.0215481464, 0.0380790941, 0.0437918007, -0.0426893383, -0.0303053483, 0.0022192062, 3.006e-7, 0.0357733332, 0.0331129804, 0.094716914, 0.0756615996, 0.0164309815, -0.0132605927, -0.0083496468, -0.0032429774, -0.0352890454, 0.0682898611, -0.0067348746, -0.0163896289, -0.0053875172, -0.0192396045, -0.0169716105, 0.0700931549, -0.014779212, -0.0210606009, -0.0209416039, -0.0442792885, 0.0003183778, 0.0410032645, -0.0057669124, 0.0061115013, -0.0160358418, -0.036140006, 0.0207311809, 0.0630465746, 0.0157112833, -0.0131611433, -0.0026832756, -0.0327757448, 0.0209390391, -0.0183094293, 0.0231916513, 0.0437592901, -0.0074989181, 0.0173441712, -0.0213470347, -0.0075897309, 0.0450922772, -0.0115148174, 0.037422467, 0.0667436197, 0.0564846881, 0.0415978171, -0.0515761562, -0.0233025961, -0.0309635215, 0.0427549072, -0.0479644723, 0.0518109165, -0.0394399613, 0.068875283, -0.0244642552, 0.0204179939, -0.0054072668, -0.0346853845, 0.002766113, -0.0249068532, -0.0093055824, -0.0041956976, 0.0057355254, 0.0235890672, 0.0035130496, -0.0666145384, -0.0575770885, 3.337198845e-34, 0.0587258227, -0.0462825112, 0.0322054662, 0.0481684729, 0.0272876248, 0.0097383633, 0.0150082428, 0.0038161662, -0.0325543098, -0.0405774154, -0.0390444994 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.06841v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.06841v1
Syntactically Robust Training on Partially-Observed Data for Open Information Extraction
2023-01-17T12:39:13
2023-01-17T12:39:13
Ji Qi, Yuxiang Chen, Lei Hou, Juanzi Li, Bin Xu
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
Open Information Extraction models have shown promising results with sufficient supervision. However, these models face a fundamental challenge that the syntactic distribution of training data is partially observable in comparison to the real world. In this paper, we propose a syntactically robust training framework that enables models to be trained on a syntactic-abundant distribution based on diverse paraphrase generation. To tackle the intrinsic problem of knowledge deformation of paraphrasing, two algorithms based on semantic similarity matching and syntactic tree walking are used to restore the expressionally transformed knowledge. The training framework can be generally applied to other syntactic partial observable domains. Based on the proposed framework, we build a new evaluation set called CaRB-AutoPara, a syntactically diverse dataset consistent with the real-world setting for validating the robustness of the models. Experiments including a thorough analysis show that the performance of the model degrades with the increase of the difference in syntactic distribution, while our framework gives a robust boundary. The source code is publicly available at https://github.com/qijimrc/RobustOIE.
[ 0.0821644589, 0.0646807477, 0.0106844269, 0.0301311594, -0.0712260529, 0.0020741774, -0.0551579073, 0.0448447838, -0.0220457185, -0.0658888072, -0.0103006903, 0.0236921944, -0.050359115, -0.0128171267, -0.0029897974, -0.0652937815, 0.0446381159, -0.0173282698, -0.0321784429, 0.0148173738, -0.0192529019, 0.0230179001, 0.0027450295, 0.0159314796, 0.0280564651, -0.0098741576, 0.0357544273, -0.0129291872, 0.0170737859, 0.0331347883, 0.0150749832, -0.0098968446, 0.0120575121, 0.0148087936, 0.0000017859, -0.0499933213, -0.0446583964, 0.0074876021, -0.0369327664, 0.0044729863, 0.0853940547, -0.0175823662, 0.0311580859, 0.0131877894, -0.026789004, -0.0386151783, 0.0363631546, 0.00783059, 0.0740798786, 0.0429663435, -0.0164357331, -0.0430518948, 0.0169670321, 0.0268341731, -0.0122890398, -0.001033597, 0.0375922024, -0.0110936575, 0.00054719, -0.03222223, 0.0039588702, 0.0217757151, -0.0222639814, 0.0414418131, 0.0046448722, 0.0164373349, -0.0320056826, -0.0215909313, -0.0068784561, 0.1077953056, -0.0343220904, -0.0151929464, 0.0135402912, -0.0305468608, -0.0156413484, 0.062448252, -0.0570661575, 0.0557678044, -0.0188190471, 0.0247340258, 0.0097372551, 0.032370884, -0.0014244373, 0.0338131487, -0.0149460947, 0.0588902794, 0.015703842, -0.0445195474, 0.0263414923, 0.0082079396, -0.0604290813, 0.0272957999, -0.0056484323, -0.0260763597, 0.0360112712, 0.067998074, -0.0628590211, -0.0633028895, 0.033759892, -0.050823722, 0.0390511528, 0.0094072521, -0.0280473474, 0.0408445001, -0.0509075224, 0.0237438288, -0.0526390523, 0.0747597665, -0.021628974, -0.0409965105, -0.0860878676, 0.0253420509, -0.048706349, 0.0649363175, -0.0475400612, 0.0030251942, -0.0252258088, 0.0251207668, 0.0161762238, 0.0070453063, 0.009577129, 0.0347885117, -0.0200940259, 0.0061159944, -0.0137206791, -0.023627542, -0.0064817294, 0.0060137184, -0.0146748358, -0.0494574681, -0.047762204, 0.0379841812, 0.0526592694, -0.0414406471, -0.0019623574, 0.047548417, 0.007023558, -0.0353630111, -0.0487516224, -0.0337957032, -0.0148015488, -0.0312292334, 0.0042295693, -0.0464969426, 0.0222024079, 0.0014294401, -0.0107330512, -0.0516786724, 0.025945643, 0.0573631488, -0.0752237365, 0.0475006402, -0.0265717134, -0.0660274178, -0.0367776789, -0.0070295744, -0.0150707746, 0.0174661502, 0.0387687162, -0.0220130906, 0.0547811501, 0.0577998795, -0.0140412441, 0.0032995329, 0.0255378354, -0.0032347075, -0.00622214, 0.05279544, 0.0525289997, 0.0236458573, -0.0007976765, 0.0714196488, -0.0261004884, -0.0512785241, 0.0311885197, 0.0061444761, -0.0376231261, 0.0316389464, 0.0742157549, 0.0220556874, 0.001888902, 0.0365324542, -0.0106335096, -0.0556870215, -0.0439772978, 0.0776467994, -0.0508473478, 0.0262518283, 0.0145901777, -0.0073273079, -0.0472920015, -0.0491609126, 0.0050539887, -0.0248337947, 0.0348144658, 0.0437349118, -0.072750926, 0.0481779836, 0.0396560617, -0.0534050241, -0.0300324559, -0.0162652414, 0.002619409, 0.0032929224, 0.0711366162, -0.0645931587, 0.0207704511, -0.0312775895, 0.0097052725, 0.0209532939, 0.0022476788, -0.0060679014, 0.0423732214, -0.0458213761, -0.0078291306, -0.021635551, 0.0326484591, -0.0289276578, 0.0225768462, -0.0166297667, 0.0323520824, -0.022290878, -0.0648731813, 0.0633296445, -0.0083750281, -0.031986963, -0.0044715586, 0.0032252318, 0.0090061892, 0.0202819016, -0.0292465854, 0.0158467386, 0.0307957847, -0.0317835249, 0.0000892801, 0.0521770343, -0.0483851135, -0.0296965018, -0.0007701869, -0.016836768, -0.0198834594, 0.0361039042, -0.0357494131, -0.0274156816, -0.0196274705, -0.0208180975, 0.0614432506, -0.0454393364, 0.0458928384, -0.0073010437, 0.0072963396, -0.0332347304, 0.0964806825, 0.0097270394, 0.0328880921, 0.0101997117, -0.0300625004, 0.0588909537, 0.0013329115, 0.0128623024, -0.0149512766, 0.0167299937, -0.0051537161, 0.0008011236, -0.0093555944, -0.0740854889, -0.0404193178, -0.0536363721, 0.0243365988, -0.0201524477, 0.0300510656, 0.0475413427, 0.0341768637, -0.0102881053, -0.0146061322, 0.0385935344, 0.0354911759, -0.0074862312, -0.0017384489, 0.0734433755, 0.0423075445, -0.0037091905, -0.0394648463, 0.0183049832, -0.0286561437, 0.0842752084, 0.0245474726, -0.0237945281, 0.0004648921, 0.0416780934, -0.0122326659, 0.0526835918, 0.0149861509, 0.0016068775, -0.0332429707, -0.000819881, 0.0096744271, 0.0566302501, 0.0089496849, -0.0213519484, 0.0328766257, 0.011698734, -0.0322377421, 0.0013885682, -0.0069924844, -0.0373906419, -0.0391673967, -0.0045284084, 0.0292795449, 0.0262497738, 0.0359302238, -0.0140945408, -0.0414875373, -0.0042737331, 0.0002228327, -0.0168145392, 0.0021562816, 0.0110148462, -0.0386458077, -0.0052804472, -0.0368898325, 0.0020517083, 0.0726827309, -0.0281941034, -0.0011848036, -0.0427840538, -0.011791233, -0.0470042266, 0.0519611053, -0.018252803, 0.0415041298, 0.0574567243, -0.010546484, -0.0457094833, -0.0261431951, 0.0352047533, 0.0110523906, 0.0266867131, -0.0706768557, 0.0067602121, 0.0078418441, -0.0461009219, -0.0403226987, -0.1066301391, -0.0049028355, 0.008884795, 0.0030900647, -0.012446614, -0.0130928224, -0.0293623712, -0.0050096107, 0.0794064999, 0.0010779841, -0.0126801329, -0.0581198074, 0.0252370443, 0.0689866319, 0.0141053842, 0.0053640748, -0.0401403867, -0.00697497, 0.0282135811, 0.0553922579, -0.0066461847, -0.0136340931, -0.0102487002, -0.0319940001, -0.0643617213, -0.0325474851, -0.0092414031, 0.0142793963, -0.0107360575, -0.0267051123, 0.0916915685, 0.0363213643, -0.0044530667, 0.0002633803, -0.0170696974, 0.0607691556, -0.0078108073, 0.0037688019, -0.0711853877, -0.0393112227, -0.0387519486, 0.0279770307, -0.0228954684, -0.046803467, -0.0113982139, -0.0883053914, 0.0089743361, -0.0123666795, -0.0109272199, -0.0626112893, 0.0125263128, 0.0241262577, -0.0260524061, 0.0102955569, 0.0093823709, -0.0602856763, 0.0277987905, -0.0110234739, -0.0074177766, -0.0523951091, -0.0125205405, -0.0738881156, 0.0251732636, 0.0122930184, 0.0095712384, 0.0225001872, 0.0071235937, -0.013024644, -0.0675694495, -0.0056380546, -0.0033613886, 0.0832417384, -0.0141692515, 0.0130843362, 0.0095564025, -0.0008145066, -0.0512801521, 0.0186988134, 0.0210068785, 0.0620827861, 0.0057172272, 0.0124150794, 0.0193262007, -0.0219809227, -0.0040828716, 0.0805536807, -0.0051859519, 0.0008242698, -0.0354097821, 0.0122965369, -0.011805784, -0.0447477289, -0.0022879425, 0.0254861843, -0.0253853668, 0.0111043854, -0.0840721205, -0.008403928, -0.0098926034, 0.0453238115, -0.0036884334, 0.0370257348, 0.0071199983, 0.0038632853, -0.0073610251, 0.0034707233, -0.0495450608, -0.0299799778, 0.018166624, -0.014505012, 0.0617482066, -0.0103453202, -0.0465527102, 0.016837921, -0.0702568144, -0.0459318645, 0.0127083817, 0.0273948181, 0.0188705865, 0.048030179, -0.0277811214, 0.0143311862, 0.0295294803, 0.0277522393, -0.0654322058, 0.0187428445, 0.0723136812, -0.018495718, 0.0033162076, 0.0439053774, -0.038974002, -0.0466575809, 0.0225390904, 0.0157573447, -0.0272550434, -0.0353621766, 0.0658640191, 0.0131957941, 0.0250127893, 0.0189666431, -0.0125098424, -0.0237857103, 0.0300278608, -0.0120734219, -0.0128208017, -0.0383631811, 0.0437545553, 0.0260624196, 0.0090090642, -0.0078768777, 0.0201950613, -0.038569089, 0.0782705098, -0.0411701091, -0.0245766845, 0.0072016995, 0.0108269602, -0.0223677997, -0.0269876029, -0.0210819095, 0.0157154817, -0.0554169379, 0.0048587113, -0.0091563873, 0.0368345156, 0.0106092384, -0.0329815932, -0.0082867658, 0.0081236791, -0.0797256678, 0.023062408, -0.041601032, 0.080670014, 0.0564856268, -0.0141391074, 0.0469170362, -0.0462937579, -0.0272597466, 0.0474518277, 0.0234015305, -0.0233999044, 0.0207261965, 0.0418899506, 0.0013507559, 0.0065776268, 0.0210631713, 0.0530794933, 0.0777653158, 0.0859693438, -0.0373874083, -0.0057068686, -0.0457134433, -0.042001985, 0.0160167217, 0.0168349016, -0.0013234634, 0.0091672428, -0.0222030077, -0.0364842489, 0.0357481577, 0.0049422877, 0.0026053421, -0.0131321093, 0.075181976, 0.0427334644, 0.0128781516, -0.0638054311, -0.046718616, 0.0079302732, 0.046811901, -0.0106793735, -0.0405772775, -5.898451022e-33, -0.0336048603, 0.0432857834, -0.0147970179, -0.0033654233, -0.0139317224, -0.038089063, -0.0049664462, -0.0313712209, -0.0328374766, -0.0045161238, -0.0129606891, 0.0182336811, 0.0224963129, 0.0389069989, -0.0097844657, -0.0473309904, 0.0151542025, -0.0231315233, -0.0048131663, -0.0116354879, 0.024665691, 0.0452818982, 0.0619200505, -0.1030149385, 0.010536585, -0.0252056848, 0.0207707305, -0.0011143835, 0.0406635329, 0.0404082239, 0.0141427619, 0.0549803227, -0.008923878, 0.0259717349, -0.0157446377, -0.0374742001, -0.1056585908, -0.0001665105, 0.0396256596, -0.0100539643, -0.0687450022, -0.0160517935, 0.0239228103, -0.0572895072, 0.0557760186, 0.0205134954, 0.0251510721, -0.0485659502, 0.0275345072, 0.0262768734, -0.0325435139, 0.0176934507, 0.0197316948, 0.0310945362, 0.011111971, 0.0634597614, -0.0024085217, 0.0378587246, 0.004409567, -0.0170814116, 0.0060449946, 0.0295379329, 0.0087573528, 0.0055476055, 0.0241327416, 0.0348587111, -0.0641571879, -0.0298743825, -0.0129147768, -0.0076429057, -0.0210591983, 0.0593774877, 0.0049901083, 0.0827391744, -0.0060681971, 0.0319586135, -0.0659144595, -0.005371152, 0.0493023545, 0.0054916916, -0.011872041, -0.0052654049, -0.0431108028, 0.031528376, -0.0122380257, 0.0114539992, 0.0061656525, -0.0052119582, 0.0153191248, -0.0168788917, -0.0481816009, 0.0286529213, 0.0171969049, -0.0133372014, -0.0138450377, 0.0074484749, -0.0051607676, 0.0273143351, -0.0131800761, 0.0233705267, -0.0571309105, -0.0719836876, 0.0053149299, 0.0307457726, 0.0279453043, 0.0096268319, 0.0215215627, 0.0201027263, -0.056243144, 0.0183606949, -0.0326265059, 0.0017771648, -0.0319472663, -0.0197865851, 0.011987865, 0.0304804258, 0.0111969672, 0.039591603, 0.0448609516, 0.0116976527, -0.0117486287, -0.0451126099, 0.019682074, 0.0093756719, -0.0107425945, -0.0272927545, 0.0275836047, 0.0191750471, -0.0307008345, -0.0455836877, 0.0371915065, 0.0346939564, 2.612e-7, 0.0593383126, 0.0110499049, 0.0265258048, 0.0208344236, -0.0221914239, 0.0048506679, 0.0198739599, 0.0436565764, -0.0482829995, -0.0716424733, 0.0236349199, -0.0191972274, 0.0004527716, -0.0217384715, -0.128946349, 0.0011070218, -0.0631071031, -0.0312271155, -0.0556933917, -0.0449420027, 0.0854006708, 0.1077068076, 0.0047788578, -0.0017306111, -0.0461036451, -0.0522418655, 0.0662881508, -0.0079077845, -0.0252506696, -0.0102354269, 0.0340996757, 0.0105296914, -0.006600732, 0.050502561, 0.005208557, 0.0640209392, 0.0263484046, 0.0313549414, 0.0160401892, 0.007410564, -0.0064057806, -0.0719569996, 0.0084325587, -0.0457617901, 0.0681370646, -0.0648351535, 0.0041836184, 0.0232943352, -0.0434143953, 0.0265375767, -0.0088058114, -0.0164254047, -0.0102177933, -0.0062839063, 0.0160564836, -0.0088551035, -0.021721838, -0.0519328415, -0.0095599582, -0.0105391266, -0.0269246865, -0.0222445801, 0.0083811386, 0.0074129356, 0.0210338701, -0.0901720747, 0.0027808426, 2.575619244e-34, 0.0199418925, 0.0150005072, -0.0079784589, 0.010365854, 0.0317754783, -0.0057131783, 0.0118048294, -0.0029800523, -0.0040307692, -0.0497231744, 0.0045445673 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.06825v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.06825v1
HanoiT: Enhancing Context-aware Translation via Selective Context
2023-01-17T12:07:13
2023-01-17T12:07:13
Jian Yang, Yuwei Yin, Shuming Ma, Liqun Yang, Hongcheng Guo, Haoyang Huang, Dongdong Zhang, Yutao Zeng, Zhoujun Li, Furu Wei
cs.CL
cs.CL
Context-aware neural machine translation aims to use the document-level context to improve translation quality. However, not all words in the context are helpful. The irrelevant or trivial words may bring some noise and distract the model from learning the relationship between the current sentence and the auxiliary context. To mitigate this problem, we propose a novel end-to-end encoder-decoder model with a layer-wise selection mechanism to sift and refine the long document context. To verify the effectiveness of our method, extensive experiments and extra quantitative analysis are conducted on four document-level machine translation benchmarks. The experimental results demonstrate that our model significantly outperforms previous models on all datasets via the soft selection mechanism.
[ 0.0213794559, 0.0449755751, 0.0123207541, 0.0482452996, -0.0059960843, 0.011144748, 0.0191306155, 0.015111086, -0.0530645736, -0.0174978506, -0.0095192576, 0.0027453613, 0.0326895602, -0.0216163825, 0.0291609261, -0.0321327411, 0.0285369642, 0.005462843, -0.019883832, 0.0070448057, -0.0195118226, 0.0072229281, 0.0419481136, 0.0237293802, 0.0271887314, -0.0105823847, 0.001365128, 0.0762934163, 0.0101948734, -0.0292443521, 0.0277915746, 0.0256751142, 0.0174520724, 0.022892572, 0.0000022031, -0.0128433667, -0.0544213876, -0.0117848841, 0.0122164888, -0.0099391462, 0.0578834936, -0.0867939368, -0.015669642, -0.0003729733, -0.0049756826, 0.0131520042, 0.0415492393, 0.0438538641, 0.0329997577, 0.077878803, -0.0332305916, -0.0045246435, -0.0178323407, -0.0615814589, 0.0282627661, -0.0853582919, -0.0108821951, 0.0030161149, -0.0286441538, 0.0247349478, -0.034912996, 0.035858646, 0.0268719923, -0.0043479078, 0.0290732272, 0.0084682358, -0.0216214675, -0.0108043617, 0.0211042482, 0.1058370993, -0.0403659083, -0.0054897792, -0.0136888288, -0.0125390952, -0.0123539129, -0.0537018552, -0.0507266149, -0.0257825181, -0.0004279485, 0.0118472297, 0.0367366336, 0.0757722855, 0.0325201824, 0.0290656928, -0.0278132465, -0.0182241369, 0.0178350545, -0.0236890633, -0.00533986, 0.0283116512, -0.0204065852, 0.0026966929, 0.0704756379, 0.0035672679, -0.0139159169, -0.0083634695, -0.0390532129, -0.0307885408, -0.0089315772, -0.0704813302, -0.0275572967, 0.0497253947, -0.0018426866, 0.060054142, -0.0087778727, 0.0160886366, -0.0286376178, 0.0205907561, -0.032169234, -0.0312153045, 0.0065666968, 0.036187496, -0.049753014, 0.0103973281, -0.0789153501, -0.0574122183, -0.0284102149, -0.0009222889, 0.0067666983, -0.0239953157, 0.0215173867, 0.0012502918, -0.0922790989, -0.0083059417, 0.0214763954, 0.0396181308, -0.0281497575, 0.0025736759, 0.0125169549, -0.0268363412, -0.0517255552, 0.0330327675, 0.0371418633, -0.0589016564, -0.0166377611, 0.0522986166, -0.0271566547, -0.0295619573, -0.0244108457, -0.011742292, -0.0281843916, -0.0242626835, -0.0019395316, -0.0342733935, 0.0456812158, -0.0187596977, 0.0313322619, -0.061620377, -0.0247773621, 0.0043176138, -0.0060765673, 0.0688675269, -0.0029042596, -0.042241849, 0.0229158383, 0.0180914924, 0.026472684, 0.055027239, 0.0343249254, 0.0484559722, 0.0265055634, 0.0208847933, -0.0130794803, 0.0208048001, 0.0161261689, -0.006603898, -0.0276834294, -0.0024993762, -0.0066745053, 0.0254910439, 0.0443702377, 0.0407374464, -0.0610809065, 0.0095074335, 0.0540042631, -0.022470044, 0.0335055776, 0.0223825183, 0.0204692259, 0.0193375852, -0.0253298339, -0.0075897356, -0.0053002289, 0.0411159545, 0.0010103725, -0.007710808, 0.0338122733, 0.0138627384, -0.0295366943, -0.0263615362, 0.0117609557, -0.0188872982, 0.0476721078, -0.0094109746, 0.037304759, 0.0393182971, -0.0911281034, 0.0399302691, -0.0098472424, -0.0461108722, 0.0295464993, 0.0011663614, -0.0092411684, 0.0474468283, 0.0885870904, 0.001636825, -0.0341586582, -0.0382251702, 0.0176108927, 0.0595650002, 0.0562659949, 0.0004231879, 0.0689819753, -0.0843584239, -0.0442217514, -0.019029282, 0.0101149213, -0.0086172651, 0.0242852811, 0.0386611111, 0.0664260238, -0.0354174636, -0.0248280894, 0.0358252861, 0.0041863252, -0.0615807474, 0.0269056298, 0.0311056115, 0.0188143346, 0.016508095, -0.0025417078, -0.0163049828, 0.0261331759, -0.0470038801, 0.0123140188, 0.0195091441, -0.1011260077, -0.0866511241, -0.0311994404, -0.0405973271, -0.0266816691, 0.0227803923, -0.0451818779, -0.0493613034, -0.0237013381, -0.0148509927, -0.002087588, -0.0443148129, 0.0278416127, -0.0036156822, 0.0526188612, -0.0266741291, 0.0359449349, 0.0051097423, -0.0235957056, 0.0583058745, 0.0350892991, -0.0041232426, -0.0519276895, -0.0236597676, 0.0374805816, 0.0126329083, 0.0252394285, 0.045999825, 0.0581334084, -0.0209580958, -0.0363930687, -0.0779996738, -0.0152053619, -0.0285368524, 0.0043900884, 0.0491008684, 0.0649645776, 0.0130888699, -0.0210669078, -0.0082926676, 0.0259083696, -0.0216832068, 0.0039123613, 0.0277859028, -0.0283571035, 0.02432747, -0.0379139595, -0.0029612954, 0.0465372205, 0.0367290191, 0.0248285364, -0.0598223582, -0.0414831266, 0.0304735433, 0.008516049, -0.0197897255, -0.017575169, -0.020149542, -0.0099612381, -0.0396391526, -0.0440173261, 0.0862403512, 0.0003400597, 0.0473731831, -0.0042416304, -0.0022285408, -0.0542168729, 0.0043255123, -0.0285432488, 0.0149476137, -0.0160756335, -0.0133170225, 0.0092012426, 0.0451549664, 0.0026719654, 0.033076711, -0.0563422889, -0.0048039258, -0.0073979888, -0.0159729961, -0.031588234, -0.0059000598, 0.0063050622, 0.0286056325, -0.0462937467, -0.0271221511, 0.059027601, -0.0146529945, -0.0027769655, -0.0553458668, 0.0155198742, -0.0412204042, 0.0181325432, -0.0324437879, 0.0061567584, -0.0264669973, -0.0490372442, -0.0164281093, -0.0039469311, -0.0195280612, -0.0106067099, 0.0426511727, -0.0516116507, 0.0071875928, -0.0127478763, -0.0149388872, -0.0144059416, 0.0205131453, 0.0075824764, 0.0109563787, 0.0180160291, 0.0023888324, -0.0095069371, -0.0030328534, -0.0061727655, 0.1091363356, -0.0317902006, 0.0015252597, -0.0419999734, 0.0583636202, 0.0148978429, -0.0015150571, 0.0293931887, -0.0521100424, 0.0410620011, 0.038937822, -0.0056038182, -0.0229297876, -0.0170199126, 0.0143298972, 0.0331422277, 0.0268862341, -0.0073234108, -0.0121586686, 0.0637580827, -0.0636468828, -0.0442353263, 0.1007261723, -0.0019322801, -0.0996136963, -0.0171911567, 0.003579882, 0.0409200899, -0.0038401384, 0.0156343151, -0.0672214925, -0.0807582736, 0.0173813067, 0.021647485, 0.05432567, 0.0096365875, -0.0034080488, -0.0564819574, 0.025336409, 0.0607379787, -0.0822634995, -0.0331378169, 0.0053433734, -0.0059639891, -0.041431658, 0.0574532822, 0.0103096729, 0.0223250985, -0.037428651, -0.0201469399, 0.050193131, -0.0669418722, -0.0115143219, -0.0259177405, -0.0043712561, 0.0588203259, 0.0347868726, 0.0150376623, 0.0239663385, 0.0876190588, -0.0332850926, 0.0165428743, -0.0165490042, 0.0310983062, -0.0162952356, 0.0125433467, 0.035389699, 0.0151253808, -0.0731573105, 0.0334105603, 0.0180377904, 0.0250686519, -0.0124318171, 0.0136210974, 0.0056268219, -0.0277426485, 0.0086534303, 0.0559269935, 0.0291974824, -0.0313872471, -0.0318368748, -0.0233492181, -0.0288784076, -0.0650768727, 0.0396146774, -0.0239545163, -0.0204903726, -0.0495701507, -0.1054492444, -0.0763768032, 0.0259449109, 0.0257000551, -0.0072470601, 0.028388055, 0.0005657974, -0.0141005488, -0.012824079, 0.0133387567, -0.0304202791, 0.0058898143, -0.0219871178, 0.0534007698, 0.0227310956, -0.0453378111, 0.0171765201, 0.0523550548, -0.0632424951, -0.0477741286, -0.0041173478, 0.0164999384, 0.0208965093, 0.0932625383, -0.0356556624, -0.0351225883, 0.0235963129, 0.0177055262, -0.0277589001, 0.0191631969, 0.0206441414, -0.0225217864, -0.0125054847, 0.0340905525, -0.0321142711, 0.0295639783, 0.0019853392, 0.0516803525, -0.0160374492, -0.0470024049, 0.0131935747, -0.0442542844, -0.0032603692, -0.0218926929, -0.0156734101, -0.0289559551, 0.0339891873, -0.0106697632, 0.006784921, -0.05260868, -0.0156759005, 0.0264089145, 0.0157785527, 0.0059016407, 0.0185311902, -0.0012295516, -0.0016400616, -0.0129607217, -0.0089318026, -0.0247468837, 0.0412718952, 0.0092469659, 0.0125032943, -0.0210676808, 0.0203803685, -0.0105430922, 0.0216533616, -0.0624166355, 0.0517625548, 0.011035963, 0.0186547115, -0.0199328456, 0.0280059744, -0.0584867783, 0.0353958234, -0.0624202713, -0.0038009426, 0.0441577993, -0.0338371545, 0.12454357, 0.0244802777, -0.0149477553, -0.0018707711, 0.0818185508, 0.0176118258, -0.031182766, -0.0188031495, 0.0046064216, 0.0205786135, 0.0303782802, 0.054020904, -0.0245725103, -0.0057776077, -0.0021079557, 0.0082776202, -0.028581934, 0.0188954305, 0.0074194334, 0.0386566557, -0.0163588542, 0.0114432788, 0.0016463239, -0.0405893773, 0.0108396634, -0.0181162674, 0.0146037741, -0.0069721243, 0.0314037949, 0.0566846356, -0.0370021388, -0.0099602407, -0.0163800307, 0.0052250857, -0.0164747629, -0.0184104461, -0.0557491705, -6.853415653e-33, -0.0488277078, -0.0069197635, -0.0160640627, -0.0421602055, -0.0214625075, 0.0120569291, -0.0826849863, -0.0536137521, -0.0076480275, 0.0070187096, -0.0192102082, 0.0322578102, 0.0279320441, 0.049455069, -0.0307182074, 0.0213199686, 0.0713685453, 0.0136125237, -0.0029844914, 0.0425054207, 0.0340458155, 0.0212139618, 0.0549892001, -0.0582488514, 0.031892132, 0.0091727134, -0.0284366552, 0.0059623411, 0.0384184122, 0.0198718421, 0.0047106408, -0.0057990481, 0.0307517573, -0.0113735497, -0.0177883208, -0.0066109854, -0.115681015, -0.0059513743, -0.0333809629, 0.0186232571, -0.0322150663, -0.08072225, 0.070186846, -0.0289154202, 0.0187203903, -0.0158401225, 0.0137206083, -0.047686398, -0.0728244185, -0.0233809948, -0.0777829587, 0.0339787528, -0.0193032604, 0.0110438103, 0.0201724637, 0.0330256112, -0.0309619382, 0.0493774526, -0.1004484817, 0.0022768832, -0.0170572698, 0.024911765, 0.0428471155, -0.002731235, -0.0066186157, 0.0196546037, -0.0038316986, -0.0093978634, 0.01795361, -0.0229030568, 0.0093049351, 0.0300879404, 0.0618792661, 0.0433674343, 0.0853962898, -0.0271520298, -0.0734180361, 0.0454937071, -0.0127178682, 0.0026772488, 0.020561073, 0.0210484527, -0.0175788607, -0.0162841287, -0.0248969775, -0.0393493474, -0.0325934477, -0.0173333287, 0.0151067954, 0.0530000068, -0.0460614301, -0.017839212, 0.0787989721, -0.0434314385, 0.0549056344, 0.0339359008, -0.0515095703, -0.0006151068, 0.0108822538, 0.0093248375, -0.0097835232, -0.0336181112, 0.0149104204, 0.0136354789, 0.004709776, -0.0247840397, 0.0673573017, 0.0159871783, -0.0350508019, -0.0106851077, -0.0593039729, 0.0077400082, -0.0142466612, 0.0288384743, 0.00842591, -0.0138102053, -0.0205196254, 0.075133957, 0.0096222581, 0.0207273141, -0.0154379848, -0.0155174034, 0.0272906348, 0.045621749, -0.048868876, 0.0000864456, -0.0089879772, 0.0061733034, 0.0758639649, -0.0400009193, -0.0271427389, 0.0107773524, 2.793e-7, 0.0304576401, 0.0288299918, 0.0272673108, -0.0194843989, 0.0185811613, 0.0234165061, 0.0110933017, 0.0463218763, -0.010508066, 0.0240755621, 0.0379067287, 0.0214089304, 0.0925863162, -0.012215008, -0.095025599, -0.0149259623, -0.0066530081, 0.0249271616, -0.0102299657, -0.0219688546, 0.0283423662, 0.0884266645, -0.0373593792, -0.0046886355, -0.0066789081, -0.0328843705, 0.0706906989, -0.0190563556, 0.0146656455, 0.0211510286, 0.0092342589, 0.0116022108, -0.0430628546, -0.0288205221, -0.0337417163, 0.013010798, 0.0555108041, 0.1023884192, 0.0025555019, -0.0175498165, 0.0291636232, 0.0046706307, 0.0109394928, -0.0305084586, 0.0696967691, -0.0676061735, -0.0116205504, 0.0076272716, -0.0205326192, 0.0110602472, 0.028186664, -0.0196938738, -0.0435993522, 0.0083843619, 0.0499364994, -0.0051379572, -0.0433154926, -0.0905881599, -0.0365976468, -0.0520546176, -0.0161773898, 0.0031397026, -0.0196170099, -0.0129179657, 0.0183311719, -0.0086793108, 0.015977921, 2.557155947e-34, 0.0502857193, -0.0039127991, -0.0104256663, 0.0023861916, 0.0462354161, -0.0312535167, -0.0094497418, -0.0122181, -0.0066331225, -0.044731278, -0.0290410016 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.06790v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.06790v1
2nd Swiss German Speech to Standard German Text Shared Task at SwissText 2022
2023-01-17T10:31:11
2023-01-17T10:31:11
Michel Plüss, Yanick Schraner, Christian Scheller, Manfred Vogel
cs.CL
cs.CL
We present the results and findings of the 2nd Swiss German speech to Standard German text shared task at SwissText 2022. Participants were asked to build a sentence-level Swiss German speech to Standard German text system specialized on the Grisons dialect. The objective was to maximize the BLEU score on a test set of Grisons speech. 3 teams participated, with the best-performing system achieving a BLEU score of 70.1.
[ 0.000955969, 0.0081578642, 0.023661837, 0.0339511894, -0.058185026, -0.0423894264, 0.0180290323, -0.0266801976, -0.0170817766, -0.0267205518, -0.0207577106, -0.03197781, 0.0338693634, 0.0845717117, 0.0199184902, -0.0725340173, 0.0429541394, -0.0488041453, 0.0116666714, -0.0173506532, 0.0683623999, 0.0051466865, -0.0251785014, 0.0104862181, -0.0049910611, 0.0104497075, 0.0220281612, 0.0265296325, 0.024078548, -0.0292190388, -0.0287508406, -0.0436191298, -0.0048881066, 0.0253209248, 0.0000017859, -0.084495753, -0.0099339802, -0.0171881821, -0.0187779386, 0.0417156629, 0.0148095153, -0.0176887475, -0.0375471599, 0.0460144281, -0.0290210638, 0.0487347916, 0.0328695364, 0.043219313, -0.0116892392, 0.043037124, -0.0348303877, -0.0282250661, -0.0128554478, -0.0172437914, -0.0196935721, -0.0018230694, -0.0530070737, 0.0019530891, 0.0342544131, -0.012816987, -0.0173551776, 0.0672250912, -0.0171503928, -0.0122839417, 0.0014429601, -0.0303918757, -0.0390912443, -0.0003651154, -0.0191070735, 0.0402849317, 0.0719854012, 0.0044327029, -0.0235886537, -0.0096121617, -0.0093335342, -0.0154307121, -0.0471604392, -0.0076119849, 0.0115062511, -0.001496796, 0.0179863852, 0.0417146571, -0.0323238857, -0.031566754, 0.0308223441, 0.0410460532, 0.0289827865, -0.0484970883, 0.0349633247, 0.0103124753, -0.0303968489, -0.0020421576, 0.0056374352, 0.0043019247, -0.0391389765, -0.0190358665, 0.0007899088, -0.0090533318, 0.0088894079, 0.0135494899, 0.0538084134, 0.0253999494, -0.047420647, 0.0037737864, 0.0360304266, 0.0913600698, 0.0208717398, -0.0708669573, -0.0466949455, -0.026517259, -0.0030749463, 0.0286547951, -0.03515305, 0.0390502028, -0.0744485408, -0.0224642344, -0.0536397211, -0.0422772169, 0.0150918271, -0.0019798463, 0.051586438, 0.0339800529, -0.0414102189, 0.0127115427, -0.0292206742, 0.0281612854, -0.0379451551, 0.0267090779, -0.0476774797, -0.0339667909, 0.0070504798, 0.0381259508, 0.0139470175, -0.0290023331, -0.0288987774, -0.0224349964, -0.0231667142, 0.0088633196, -0.0046910346, 0.0015899261, -0.0540401191, -0.0373494998, -0.0412807763, -0.0653872564, -0.0178929288, -0.0067431098, 0.0182382371, -0.01775809, 0.016195897, -0.0383262634, 0.0007501506, 0.0064292629, -0.023117993, -0.0095099658, 0.0003804519, -0.015652243, -0.0006068394, 0.0657162964, 0.0031649328, -0.0232282858, 0.0304658338, -0.0047658836, 0.0415945202, 0.0577108636, 0.0004150617, -0.0197140276, -0.038465187, -0.0148715908, 0.0135938674, 0.0076264525, 0.0395372771, 0.0852114111, 0.0003211704, 0.0088215284, 0.0820062235, 0.0873138234, 0.0265505798, -0.0184616148, 0.0256443564, 0.0119356103, 0.003797187, 0.0029982741, 0.0328356959, -0.0336860456, -0.0414297134, 0.053873539, -0.0456258431, 0.0486737266, -0.0215601027, -0.0060354988, -0.0159098729, -0.0400817432, 0.0416059904, -0.0291687604, 0.0226549804, 0.0392213352, -0.0129639739, 0.021829389, -0.0007852015, -0.0905808806, 0.0067743966, 0.0205355398, -0.0053193592, 0.069810994, 0.0409574807, -0.0044436045, -0.0062808795, -0.0114327082, -0.0187869444, 0.0789772421, 0.041046828, -0.0223168842, 0.0752126649, -0.0586762242, 0.0314112715, -0.0211478192, -0.0165065285, 0.0183231086, -0.0581709445, 0.0140023055, -0.00139795, -0.0191250704, -0.003118726, -0.0047918307, -0.0409404375, 0.0060883816, -0.0095328558, 0.000144502, 0.01176266, 0.0405678116, -0.0282472484, 0.016963372, 0.0278047677, -0.0676949024, 0.0647201613, 0.0690785274, 0.0057526277, -0.0159976594, 0.0286744926, -0.0717488527, 0.0078873476, 0.0373438857, 0.0063737435, -0.0648577064, 0.0307037067, -0.0472592376, 0.0662217736, -0.0113839293, 0.0109073725, 0.0107392594, -0.0001383679, -0.0230580606, 0.0041240565, 0.0195033941, -0.0052108807, -0.0069049834, -0.0581942014, 0.0314959399, -0.0809193552, -0.0217844527, 0.0120101981, -0.0367922857, 0.0134727294, 0.0200529099, 0.0020881658, -0.0097948182, 0.0140974214, -0.0636011735, -0.0140522113, -0.0326781273, 0.0276632421, 0.0371584632, 0.0518100858, -0.0145101314, -0.0346047282, -0.0219192542, -0.0019027453, 0.0558734089, -0.0683716163, -0.0037710399, -0.0171307661, -0.0192915499, -0.050670743, 0.0242940243, 0.0109799644, 0.0249978788, 0.009426008, -0.0441204235, -0.0382715501, 0.0679448694, -0.041325435, 0.0318053961, 0.0438269936, -0.061385937, -0.0049406653, 0.0193683095, 0.0723400563, 0.0430495888, 0.011398647, -0.0079630399, -0.0353015997, -0.017227672, -0.0438979939, -0.0080535933, -0.0173591096, 0.0268889088, -0.0890086889, 0.005275459, 0.0388159901, 0.0014149423, 0.0107446769, 0.0353398956, -0.0143294968, 0.0086085023, -0.0222435538, -0.0365631059, -0.0054598558, -0.0416032709, -0.0446894169, 0.0151793947, -0.0008598605, 0.0066472464, 0.0031094332, -0.0650104806, -0.0188756287, -0.0934413746, -0.0253542792, -0.0058830222, 0.0516015999, -0.0333132558, 0.0206459444, -0.0177730657, -0.0248620007, -0.0344795883, -0.036744535, 0.0193514992, 0.0037387253, 0.0287509821, -0.0541265942, 0.0062085302, -0.0048664603, -0.0591878854, -0.0029602079, 0.0129294032, -0.0549053065, 0.0329433307, 0.038468197, -0.0031395843, -0.0458842367, 0.0258047283, -0.0041902619, 0.0182173885, -0.0038413394, 0.0365378223, -0.0198017638, 0.062590003, 0.0254204609, 0.0372468382, 0.0062009129, 0.0005687225, 0.0439897068, 0.0269970596, 0.0647726879, 0.045859497, -0.0094609624, -0.0407335795, 0.0368445478, -0.0160051491, -0.0416711979, -0.0048238197, 0.085069634, -0.000801214, -0.0324344039, 0.0953362733, 0.0038540263, 0.0203263331, 0.0005805239, -0.023472311, 0.0861439928, 0.0210934971, 0.0198209044, -0.0673256591, 0.002552148, 0.0144042158, 0.0266682915, -0.0348813124, 0.046286393, -0.0118952133, -0.1258914173, 0.0374324694, 0.0549952164, -0.0133056771, 0.0096763857, 0.0200065058, -0.0496497229, -0.0020040062, 0.0321326442, -0.0122624589, -0.0130757317, -0.0168834683, 0.0263226144, -0.0825686902, -0.0498936065, 0.015116089, -0.0371046588, 0.0740727782, 0.0166556649, 0.0283947699, -0.0117353322, -0.0655783713, 0.0433159843, -0.0393978395, 0.0112083498, 0.0123367524, 0.0321229659, -0.021116538, -0.0145696085, -0.012550639, 0.0404932126, 0.0086303251, -0.0461882167, 0.026350975, 0.0355428122, -0.0355987735, 0.0372806452, 0.0175495334, 0.0860849097, 0.0342107601, 0.0363627709, 0.0497195832, -0.0526026189, -0.0071826256, -0.0395170078, 0.0352111831, -0.111361213, -0.0201202035, 0.0407661051, -0.0073025152, -0.0185514372, -0.054858949, -0.0363299027, -0.0004454721, 0.0614759624, 0.034648329, 0.0433102325, 0.0024387147, 0.0122828614, -0.0185795855, 0.0239633434, 0.0277510248, 0.0311892927, -0.0935900658, -0.01818268, 0.0300911553, -0.0324400626, -0.0252809916, 0.012540699, -0.004240639, -0.0688865036, 0.0358133949, 0.0206442811, 0.0388728566, 0.0302624051, -0.0306687262, -0.0182081759, 0.0117119243, -0.0503137447, -0.0605416708, 0.0368777961, 0.0360249542, -0.0591227338, -0.0169857331, 0.005445228, 0.0233411174, 0.0476641133, 0.019506678, 0.0251302235, 0.0054920544, 0.0028262159, 0.0096511561, 0.0805756673, 0.0129889688, 0.0032436044, -0.0175226033, -0.0262452476, 0.0135691976, -0.0080436487, 0.0156082967, -0.0419718213, 0.0222112294, 0.035143923, 0.0369378217, 0.0169289578, -0.0061953207, -0.0726197287, -0.011109774, 0.0148851108, 0.0176980235, 0.0949970782, 0.0441081934, -0.0165347923, 0.0205800477, 0.0145041272, 0.0632282197, -0.0081467349, 0.0623164847, -0.0162819978, 0.0325137787, -0.009391672, 0.0100059342, 0.0114525221, 0.0242569335, -0.0259515885, 0.0213335026, -0.0508751422, -0.025457181, 0.0476937965, 0.0510880165, 0.1395025551, 0.0140393293, 0.0125079704, -0.0332704931, 0.0312480796, -0.0611938834, 0.0185927432, -0.0326444097, -0.0252401158, -0.0632460564, 0.0273431558, 0.0192164592, -0.0178837888, -0.0177955255, 0.0276679583, 0.0199010838, -0.0323616341, -0.0331101418, 0.0412876941, -0.0063651144, -0.034485545, -0.0317898244, -0.0450389497, -0.0119879469, 0.0549480356, 0.0386248827, -0.0060951207, -0.0290482827, 0.0264962334, 0.014612807, -0.0215552375, 0.0345230997, 0.0088109793, -0.0122648524, -0.0271354821, -0.0542124957, 0.0024227668, -6.172666304e-33, -0.0383034162, 0.0198354237, -0.0296061859, -0.0119606862, -0.0357147828, 0.0185374916, -0.0112547623, -0.0066255461, -0.0072909594, 0.0072719795, 0.0151039073, -0.0509407893, 0.03344322, 0.0413474776, 0.0137724997, 0.0161455087, 0.0363561288, 0.0032034717, -0.0395248011, -0.0120677873, 0.0301312078, 0.0280780457, 0.0574624054, -0.053821899, -0.0470311195, 0.010531296, -0.036959514, 0.0090164915, 0.0416438021, 0.0651344955, -0.0348824561, 0.0375936925, -0.0110029941, 0.0179542173, -0.0185171887, 0.0470519885, -0.0562069602, -0.0266841352, 0.0400007591, 0.0558949262, -0.0289800689, 0.0187488552, -0.0302926674, 0.0036811901, -0.0807870775, 0.0334802084, 0.0071008652, -0.0032755542, -0.0010712424, -0.0002089068, -0.1058308855, -0.0061568283, -0.0049590208, 0.0298412126, 0.0261850655, 0.069971852, -0.0372973233, -0.0616717786, -0.0316947959, 0.0481542237, 0.009240224, 0.0047950237, 0.0382773206, -0.0639358461, -0.0391090289, 0.0423598625, 0.0713215843, -0.0332785062, 0.0403425023, -0.0411780812, 0.0229069591, 0.0102899503, 0.0400783867, 0.0516989082, 0.0144594591, -0.0362718143, -0.0088101476, -0.0095742298, 0.0545043349, -0.005446767, -0.0396149829, 0.0205477495, 0.0321885608, -0.0036572623, -0.0345600545, 0.0051815007, 0.0063288603, -0.0211190227, 0.0731711611, -0.0124314046, 0.0203842185, -0.004629333, 0.07688535, -0.0150828082, 0.0317421146, -0.0561609343, 0.0289484933, 0.0352859087, -0.0482655317, 0.0216859989, -0.0641980469, -0.0316400863, 0.0192926526, 0.0565181375, 0.0271322671, -0.026472725, 0.0203944165, -0.0067111505, -0.0602687672, 0.0293312967, -0.0073715528, 0.015020241, -0.0293908753, 0.0018890628, -0.0056555965, -0.0156493783, 0.024279926, 0.0230948087, -0.0129988519, -0.0423719138, 0.006742802, -0.0339160897, 0.0516106524, 0.0666540861, -0.0527488999, 0.0020858338, 0.0091994787, -0.0369970798, 0.0425119251, 0.0270360801, 0.0034604368, -0.008674724, 2.612e-7, 0.0525344834, 0.035088338, 0.0099905627, -0.0412239134, 0.0052079479, -0.024702182, -0.0034692099, 0.0275510866, 0.000544617, 0.0615210272, 0.0105699347, -0.0467958078, 0.0567728318, 0.0131670339, -0.0734141171, -0.0224155392, -0.0533829518, -0.0376927517, -0.0572181195, 0.0190578457, 0.0194458123, 0.0596096218, -0.019045528, 0.0003611128, 0.0141665824, -0.0217771661, 0.0098569822, -0.0191266537, -0.0573858656, -0.0064074602, -0.0026073605, -0.0241744984, -0.0382772833, 0.0312958956, 0.0027361689, -0.0022693602, 0.0194459986, 0.0111593492, -0.0564746298, -0.0700072572, -0.0212151743, 0.0570148863, -0.0558137782, 0.0256465729, 0.0016310548, 0.0302368477, -0.0048160986, -0.0131803313, -0.0164865758, 0.0145617127, 0.0224522706, -0.01790669, 0.014921804, -0.0143249854, 0.0414143093, 0.0304778982, -0.0702212378, -0.0237624366, -0.0142887449, 0.0397873223, 0.0082838601, -0.0517617911, 0.0242075901, 0.0215351805, -0.0239236858, -0.0625492111, -0.0129695991, 2.40157904e-34, 0.0455277637, -0.0274828058, 0.0177655853, 0.0265130941, 0.0394664556, -0.0495420694, -0.0236399807, 0.0012776386, -0.0136106843, 0.0041554607, -0.0118650384 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.06774v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.06774v2
Temporal Dynamics of Coordinated Online Behavior: Stability, Archetypes, and Influence
2023-01-17T09:52:54
2024-05-09T10:15:28
Serena Tardelli, Leonardo Nizzoli, Maurizio Tesconi, Mauro Conti, Preslav Nakov, Giovanni Da San Martino, Stefano Cresci
cs.SI
cs.SI, cs.CL, cs.CY
Large-scale online campaigns, malicious or otherwise, require a significant degree of coordination among participants, which sparked interest in the study of coordinated online behavior. State-of-the-art methods for detecting coordinated behavior perform static analyses, disregarding the temporal dynamics of coordination. Here, we carry out the first dynamic analysis of coordinated behavior. To reach our goal we build a multiplex temporal network and we perform dynamic community detection to identify groups of users that exhibited coordinated behaviors in time. Thanks to our novel approach we find that: (i) coordinated communities feature variable degrees of temporal instability; (ii) dynamic analyses are needed to account for such instability, and results of static analyses can be unreliable and scarcely representative of unstable communities; (iii) some users exhibit distinct archetypal behaviors that have important practical implications; (iv) content and network characteristics contribute to explaining why users leave and join coordinated communities. Our results demonstrate the advantages of dynamic analyses and open up new directions of research on the unfolding of online debates, on the strategies of coordinated communities, and on the patterns of online influence.
[ 0.0140835801, 0.0577363744, -0.0603449307, -0.0336205326, -0.0403316468, -0.0529104844, 0.0113541987, -0.011801973, -0.0057335971, 0.0092640864, 0.0298746154, -0.0539755486, 0.0026708997, 0.0587990433, 0.0151373763, -0.0224208143, -0.0198861491, 0.0454930104, -0.0010172894, 0.0058649485, 0.0649303943, -0.0213814788, 0.00535199, 0.0122576812, 0.0332109928, -0.0265301447, -0.0095035462, -0.0237836652, 0.0788409561, -0.0227907803, 0.0293784123, 0.0153439306, -0.0002224219, 0.032052882, 0.0000019077, -0.0373403989, -0.0475241058, -0.0394715443, 0.028630903, -0.0095300954, 0.0333323777, 0.0336015522, 0.0253438875, 0.0197009612, -0.0534093045, 0.048846405, 0.0024289468, -0.0405934826, 0.0258201864, 0.0116257062, -0.0180047639, 0.0211271718, 0.0193839446, -0.0128385546, -0.0641594529, 0.0260387883, 0.0037531352, -0.0264243223, -0.0214411374, -0.0138324909, 0.0183376912, -0.0172152799, -0.0476969033, -0.0425501689, 0.0052573592, 0.0125296162, 0.0015545409, -0.0204388592, -0.0142473448, 0.0305758826, 0.01394537, 0.0165289734, 0.1033395678, 0.0133242663, -0.0367511883, 0.0905771032, -0.0340755321, 0.0245521292, 0.0028669578, -0.022229353, 0.021463152, 0.0714087337, 0.0540393889, 0.0313705541, 0.0119176134, 0.058010105, -0.009743779, 0.0023526903, -0.0580724217, -0.0333613306, 0.0338618942, -0.0308465455, 0.0307345819, 0.0005641502, -0.0007443859, 0.0078601716, 0.0416917242, 0.0089593371, 0.0314441845, -0.0345902741, 0.0049630562, -0.0399487242, 0.0428287946, 0.0585569367, 0.0427232012, -0.028388219, -0.0518627986, -0.0070599872, 0.0655178577, 0.0513579771, -0.0602019764, 0.0290569887, 0.0442673415, -0.00203493, 0.0401077718, -0.0183438696, -0.0257267095, 0.0519367568, -0.0706022754, -0.0033248055, -0.0565659739, 0.0009575707, 0.0606844425, 0.0107577089, -0.0001596408, 0.0106442133, -0.0675063431, 0.0252022333, -0.0141116185, 0.0288624372, 0.0126136811, 0.0102448845, 0.0449572355, -0.0372521244, -0.0199963339, 0.0501119345, 0.0250453446, 0.0040961676, 0.0066653294, -0.074383907, 0.007134981, -0.0040806597, -0.0201459285, -0.059885107, 0.0302311741, -0.0003863124, 0.0257261395, 0.052884873, -0.0319255739, -0.0256021041, -0.0070624156, 0.0245666411, -0.0075206421, 0.0441257097, 0.003161415, 0.002423374, -0.0047859941, -0.0094806412, -0.0193498973, 0.004494404, 0.0554930829, 0.0165010877, -0.0162981302, 0.0489636399, 0.0074836728, 0.0059741414, 0.0226382092, -0.0147876833, 0.0182819236, -0.0465246998, -0.0349074602, 0.0094101336, -0.0411855839, -0.0186419189, 0.0482137799, 0.027434554, -0.0366230682, 0.0153231109, -0.0184335709, -0.0189041942, -0.0236660186, -0.0180810541, 0.0320025459, -0.02291492, -0.0035091462, -0.0427863486, -0.0008149723, 0.0533976965, -0.0427810736, 0.0411427543, 0.0026983412, 0.0044389283, 0.0554745235, -0.0195624605, -0.0038976152, -0.0121754371, 0.0312371738, 0.0007170027, 0.017110873, 0.0188782718, 0.0301079284, -0.0523332022, 0.0238970928, 0.039322976, 0.0570297576, 0.0152335493, -0.0294084679, -0.0341503359, 0.0588100962, -0.0186901446, -0.0118105309, -0.0128369462, -0.0586754233, -0.0118129402, -0.0036235985, 0.0635650605, -0.0033972193, 0.0179293472, 0.0182800405, 0.024120532, -0.0636124238, 0.0295000691, 0.023371093, -0.0380318798, -0.0140523482, 0.0640694275, -0.0370852016, 0.0122189252, 0.0658786297, 0.0078906938, -0.0163226109, -0.0539761633, 0.0262136441, -0.0013849967, -0.055675678, 0.0418721288, 0.0492134318, 0.0973154977, 0.0265343729, -0.0260765105, -0.0071747988, -0.0027837311, 0.0279512405, 0.0034866519, 0.1381278634, 0.0144557003, 0.0056813415, 0.0167232174, -0.0483750515, -0.0044099274, 0.0314719006, -0.0055745463, 0.0372017138, -0.036331486, -0.0022920112, 0.0051380936, -0.0462313518, 0.002230237, 0.0197680034, 0.0190313663, -0.0300665107, -0.0308283325, -0.0120212156, 0.0361928679, -0.0470537208, -0.022494033, -0.0383057818, -0.0076435716, -0.041560892, -0.0260369945, 0.0183563028, 0.041100651, -0.0174626205, 0.0279847383, 0.0558689609, 0.0035638707, 0.0343683213, 0.0017745595, 0.0221001487, 0.0289457776, 0.0094273789, -0.0725608543, -0.0223486107, -0.0190601256, -0.0302265584, 0.0563526414, 0.0527631938, -0.0918870047, 0.0249844827, -0.0608936176, -0.0922673419, -0.0465527065, -0.0518945828, -0.0180469975, 0.0084449556, -0.0180124082, 0.0316378064, 0.0181318838, 0.0449449122, 0.0788314119, 0.0053599621, 0.0199002605, -0.0386561528, -0.0266893283, -0.0595590509, 0.0327571705, -0.0388128646, -0.0346184783, 0.0222269762, 0.0590347014, 0.0399923399, -0.0063840607, 0.0005320619, -0.0252627917, -0.0338830873, 0.0096741011, -0.0433900245, -0.0458791293, 0.0038440796, -0.0109414384, -0.0058870143, -0.0263718702, 0.0153706977, 0.0502355509, 0.0669440553, 0.0671358854, -0.0600756817, -0.0023339042, 0.0124179889, 0.0340193957, 0.0098609878, 0.018527383, -0.0288194362, 0.0130302263, -0.0477546826, 0.0736340061, -0.023136355, -0.0117617706, 0.0110785635, 0.0359331332, 0.0429110564, 0.0407044291, -0.002375257, -0.0568732992, 0.0035224217, -0.02452874, 0.068750456, -0.0347209312, 0.0219393168, 0.0040133842, -0.0165718235, -0.0590254217, 0.0067009469, -0.0299230292, 0.009964304, 0.0826249942, -0.0366595089, -0.0171069093, 0.0109969154, -0.0658602566, -0.0364210084, 0.0316741355, 0.0403605476, -0.0405746065, -0.0491851494, -0.0298310891, 0.0026249227, -0.0139819765, 0.0109999664, 0.0014717389, 0.0210974012, -0.000491783, 0.0438009351, 0.0292089209, 0.0403492935, -0.0223025922, -0.0131410779, 0.0240116175, 0.0121614989, 0.0120542049, -0.0213130116, -0.0632608458, 0.043439623, -0.0410141572, -0.0039808974, -0.0342736617, -0.0627132356, 0.0040334216, -0.0007511869, -0.0407147259, 0.0008113196, 0.0138033805, 0.1008690149, -0.0435747728, 0.0216542892, -0.0341571793, -0.0330147818, -0.0343784764, 0.0138262175, -0.0137202758, -0.0044701095, -0.0962821096, 0.0251215454, 0.0048181997, -0.0382521264, 0.0914017931, 0.0018962908, 0.0429544635, -0.0392125584, -0.027750155, 0.0817524344, 0.0066793002, 0.0042728721, 0.0011551335, 0.0663245842, 0.0127310669, 0.0148120048, -0.0159114487, 0.0046571139, -0.0069001531, -0.0006010486, 0.0055182893, 0.0533270985, 0.0191032942, -0.0739592761, -0.0085811717, -0.0037016151, 0.0402061455, -0.0211407933, -0.0265819188, -0.0431892127, -0.0102708451, 0.0014918086, 0.0028411129, -0.0342956781, -0.0268086959, -0.0760482177, 0.0498079956, 0.0370835029, -0.0350430757, 0.0319119543, -0.0574638806, -0.0060085482, 0.0216258299, -0.0159438793, 0.0174675584, 0.0048150294, -0.0119691668, -0.0055069695, 0.0266410466, 0.0424853787, -0.026655389, 0.0008411343, -0.0467840694, 0.0165461469, -0.0269902535, 0.03592664, -0.0807229877, -0.066806972, 0.0376010574, -0.0254814979, 0.0260985214, 0.0271715336, -0.0154699478, 0.0182790477, 0.0242781416, -0.0178470276, 0.0516043231, -0.0220792741, 0.0193041377, 0.0125216357, -0.0202534888, 0.019783197, 0.0181648098, -0.0123662259, -0.0006203038, -0.0640725121, -0.1180149093, 0.0342839658, -0.0364537612, -0.0422333889, 0.0196839068, -0.0015578454, 0.0022567455, -0.0041176733, -0.0631457344, 0.0089037623, -0.0128437011, 0.056585405, -0.0209808517, 0.0192590524, -0.0203831661, -0.0195713658, 0.0695829988, 0.0027188379, 0.009747237, -0.055049587, 0.0106034447, -0.0199533105, 0.022506984, 0.0243194178, 0.0158252399, 0.040103849, 0.0431596749, 0.005385234, 0.0446261019, -0.0103961611, -0.0224050004, -0.0120177092, -0.0186623558, 0.0042629158, 0.0216564536, -0.0323959738, -0.0376896188, 0.0420538187, -0.0152373677, 0.0105146905, 0.0292758308, 0.0676238462, 0.0131546659, -0.0147682894, -0.020339191, 0.0366777591, -0.0422205217, -0.0485095009, -0.0450180471, 0.022642158, -0.0182758812, 0.0528142303, 0.0406140983, -0.0566593297, -0.0188777931, -0.0247272179, -0.0427179746, -0.0083656069, 0.0307484623, -0.0308265612, 0.016195491, -0.0408244245, -0.0096691679, -0.0160990898, 0.0185332242, 0.0520088524, -0.0033878465, 0.0311502758, 0.0215522628, -0.0268369671, -0.0143395364, 0.0130938385, 0.0829994082, -0.0246461648, 0.0238652937, -0.0282553341, -0.0221907571, 0.0102276215, -6.393795893e-33, 0.0638496429, -0.0858053267, -0.0504882932, -0.0417860597, -0.0663760379, 0.0317872241, -0.0155122215, 0.0140643008, 0.0078494502, -0.0214975197, 0.0160376895, 0.0311564617, 0.0158525761, -0.0194720048, 0.024394447, -0.0085827038, 0.0035101955, -0.0033372426, 0.0223812014, 0.0425371267, 0.0522778705, -0.031199364, -0.0691964254, -0.033628501, 0.018845832, 0.0211085081, 0.0030869148, 0.017649183, 0.0149049647, 0.0201805886, -0.0100082159, -0.0163766202, 0.0225228406, -0.0005769319, 0.0151640503, 0.0211947206, -0.0397954173, -0.0083783893, -0.0126744257, -0.0339138806, -0.0186395328, -0.0150536075, -0.0073182625, 0.0002733524, 0.0026397626, -0.0104567166, 0.0481783003, 0.0322827101, -0.0116750132, -0.0059585716, 0.0315852687, 0.0165399667, -0.0728766322, 0.0552613623, -0.0621427819, 0.0160562675, 0.028078638, 0.0400064737, -0.0945526063, 0.0595479943, -0.0828483626, -0.0307112094, -0.0095105032, 0.0344165415, 0.0341339447, 0.0395797975, -0.0516082719, 0.0862889364, -0.0026571373, 0.0320611075, -0.0375591144, 0.0085193515, 0.0223906543, 0.0043936558, -0.0180718303, -0.0571822152, -0.0419749804, -0.0036965143, 0.1056890935, -0.0512793399, 0.0346833766, -0.0185780004, -0.0189161319, 0.0153777283, 0.0517434515, -0.0524394922, -0.0130336415, -0.03038726, -0.0052978266, 0.045925606, -0.0213863011, 0.0002876823, 0.0318801627, -0.0480757467, -0.0603357144, 0.0102078021, -0.0114403004, 0.0322276466, 0.0377746187, 0.0006007323, -0.014387955, -0.0124207884, -0.0721594244, -0.0015473381, 0.0130197527, -0.0503888577, -0.0091647711, 0.0251155868, -0.026616523, 0.0112418272, 0.0442856736, 0.0237896852, -0.0512269288, -0.0357702076, 0.0301095601, 0.0125968978, -0.0033173494, -0.0108412793, 0.0544834808, 0.0316884071, 0.0296026077, 0.025931472, -0.0859132782, 0.0047665713, -0.0013779369, 0.0018763333, -0.060176339, 0.050622195, -0.0076113464, -0.0488073602, -0.0156211797, -0.0883583948, 2.66e-7, 0.0028954998, 0.0449862406, 0.0269922018, 0.0232809857, 0.060369283, -0.0295282379, -0.0062012952, 0.0256801434, -0.0411111787, -0.0807530209, -0.0010876921, 0.0034373973, 0.0051008817, 0.0499997661, -0.0082881739, -0.0093389284, -0.0435762182, 0.0085878586, -0.0492839254, -0.0180787947, 0.0142134307, -0.0324001871, 0.0322727896, 0.0191286989, -0.0134309437, -0.0188654289, 0.0549995638, 0.0042339573, -0.0292200353, 0.0180328712, -0.0182809569, -0.0596889108, -0.0692847595, -0.009692614, -0.0203807224, 0.0310279354, -0.0581166819, -0.050918676, 0.0333750024, 0.0043592053, 0.0015498661, -0.0677175075, 0.0113195814, 0.0154667022, 0.046744179, -0.0477173813, 0.0027559297, 0.0062956177, -0.0251555666, -0.0288766399, 0.0564389415, 0.0251272023, 0.0014085207, 0.035197854, -0.033018332, -0.0110397711, 0.031299334, -0.0742155388, 0.0079258867, 0.0267709494, -0.0606983118, -0.0494146161, 0.0182797331, 0.0087700179, 0.0500048846, 0.0439088382, 0.0241111051, 1.940449136e-34, 0.0270020477, -0.0000733722, -0.0107955569, -0.0438562036, 0.0167052113, -0.0169880819, -0.0664064363, -0.0239762142, 0.084051773, -0.0141796982, -0.0020758151 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.06767v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.06767v1
The Recent Advances in Automatic Term Extraction: A survey
2023-01-17T09:02:15
2023-01-17T09:02:15
Hanh Thi Hong Tran, Matej Martinc, Jaya Caporusso, Antoine Doucet, Senja Pollak
cs.CL
cs.CL, A.1
Automatic term extraction (ATE) is a Natural Language Processing (NLP) task that eases the effort of manually identifying terms from domain-specific corpora by providing a list of candidate terms. As units of knowledge in a specific field of expertise, extracted terms are not only beneficial for several terminographical tasks, but also support and improve several complex downstream tasks, e.g., information retrieval, machine translation, topic detection, and sentiment analysis. ATE systems, along with annotated datasets, have been studied and developed widely for decades, but recently we observed a surge in novel neural systems for the task at hand. Despite a large amount of new research on ATE, systematic survey studies covering novel neural approaches are lacking. We present a comprehensive survey of deep learning-based approaches to ATE, with a focus on Transformer-based neural models. The study also offers a comparison between these systems and previous ATE approaches, which were based on feature engineering and non-neural supervised learning algorithms.
[ 0.0369455144, 0.036608953, 0.005915971, 0.0529258922, -0.0387134217, 0.0018308908, 0.0318318903, -0.018066695, -0.0268971063, -0.0518150032, -0.0482735299, -0.031966202, -0.0402923189, 0.0654804781, -0.0207610521, -0.0256375354, 0.0141238207, 0.0104938922, 0.0139834676, 0.0377657972, -0.040310923, 0.0081358748, -0.0031517749, 0.0076136389, -0.0129239559, -0.0025594239, 0.0153672537, -0.0720435455, 0.0204237998, 0.0027770668, 0.051785443, 0.0488942973, -0.0017387798, 0.0469404981, 0.0000020861, -0.0287773237, -0.0758032128, -0.0220995266, -0.0268966127, -0.0161869265, 0.0549893826, -0.0352067091, 0.023304075, -0.0310682766, -0.0491281413, -0.0472167358, 0.0284286868, 0.058237154, 0.010495645, 0.0402108766, -0.0276370458, -0.064142704, 0.038501475, -0.0050579058, -0.0239726026, -0.026331054, 0.0197383948, -0.0708172247, -0.0179107357, 0.0318909362, -0.0036520713, 0.0331871361, -0.001198823, -0.0080092195, 0.0491824858, 0.0144655993, -0.0015642362, -0.0479754098, -0.0594380833, 0.1045382693, -0.0216748063, 0.0478525348, 0.027599534, -0.0102182794, 0.0044661565, 0.0116400318, -0.035536699, 0.0419338532, 0.0045880061, 0.0036912654, 0.0245121121, 0.0054796208, -0.0106068933, 0.0181131084, -0.0406172909, 0.0568290055, 0.0070065996, -0.0413331538, 0.0339318477, 0.0010724653, -0.0256812014, -0.0028000774, 0.061848741, -0.0176501218, 0.0367017798, 0.0316708907, 0.0137479939, -0.0491984263, -0.0013025132, -0.0788211077, -0.0259149279, -0.0136952521, -0.0626916662, 0.058242593, -0.010652693, 0.0100431452, -0.0404730812, 0.0134674851, 0.0148647577, -0.0104732141, -0.0634952039, 0.0045213364, 0.0079324264, 0.0662133247, -0.0286002085, -0.009065452, -0.0452875197, -0.0038641253, -0.036944367, -0.0155070266, 0.0065900148, 0.0429369248, -0.0179850478, -0.0025346018, -0.012940621, 0.0360147469, -0.0020619533, 0.0176694077, 0.0147904772, -0.0369384475, -0.0170909818, 0.022513397, 0.0792256519, -0.0220108796, 0.0289980918, 0.0700095966, 0.0163019355, -0.0606503934, -0.00845013, -0.0183284301, -0.0035341952, 0.0323373452, 0.0544219948, -0.0775902197, 0.0354591496, -0.0365486033, -0.0344445705, -0.0350897796, 0.0190825779, -0.0036892213, -0.0487909243, 0.0428075232, -0.0528073944, -0.0397201143, 0.0531615466, 0.0117003387, 0.0076629752, 0.0200164728, 0.0326043777, 0.0823431611, 0.07134974, -0.0204835944, 0.023982944, 0.0386840589, -0.0331613347, -0.0684631988, 0.0093297865, -0.0522643365, -0.0461003184, -0.021357445, 0.0261501316, 0.0278437268, -0.0252617449, -0.0105606001, 0.0256623793, 0.0697801262, 0.0380923674, 0.0951948836, 0.0408008359, -0.0043095704, 0.0142738372, -0.0054519163, 0.0009301094, -0.0050577153, 0.0104669267, -0.0053259195, -0.0207042433, 0.0038758568, -0.0110376431, -0.0647333413, 0.0043716528, -0.0380489044, 0.0092492783, -0.0184475612, 0.11618568, 0.0149800126, -0.0051009851, 0.0782171711, 0.0491434038, -0.0225445479, -0.008768891, -0.0345547087, -0.0232633632, 0.0072717313, 0.0130394027, -0.0423874669, -0.0485488214, -0.0307327881, 0.0027961703, 0.0718112886, 0.0081013953, 0.0002838448, -0.0020840899, -0.0419718958, -0.0089086071, -0.0067759189, 0.0125679811, 0.0243249014, -0.0174532644, 0.0241346229, 0.0139291463, 0.0138645694, -0.0307709221, 0.0407572612, -0.0130298389, -0.080791682, 0.0525360517, 0.0062056896, 0.0084298849, 0.0239985716, -0.0359737426, -0.0271733776, 0.0398783758, -0.0539413281, -0.0673747957, -0.0149183664, -0.0508127734, 0.0034123911, 0.0220584981, -0.0263134278, 0.005420587, 0.0315612294, -0.039075613, 0.0033150557, -0.0023480759, -0.0004026828, -0.0051466539, -0.0332863927, 0.0273009222, -0.0088691963, 0.0660012364, -0.029541282, 0.0716122389, 0.0123687712, -0.0206581503, -0.0241787173, -0.055274494, -0.0308226887, 0.0198207684, -0.0131673235, 0.0193000808, -0.0193240475, -0.0007573585, 0.040822383, 0.0231138114, -0.0276336763, -0.0024177337, -0.0492502563, 0.0366902798, -0.0215687342, 0.0296428874, -0.0177952647, 0.0161307324, -0.0030099179, 0.0019195079, -0.0149239656, 0.0055645052, -0.0278394781, -0.0344182178, 0.0527568348, 0.0019033445, -0.0191600863, -0.0527049229, -0.0346462056, -0.020738421, 0.0406323969, 0.0586744621, -0.0464188978, 0.0131468717, 0.0270869341, -0.0142059671, 0.0440660119, 0.0046595708, -0.0257544704, -0.0490908585, -0.0237283837, -0.0291963778, 0.0474789217, 0.0546660237, 0.0348054841, 0.0160377081, 0.006289287, -0.0005541295, 0.0319461077, -0.0849717557, 0.0123295551, 0.0365057103, -0.0004140067, 0.0690359697, 0.0924791619, -0.0052849888, 0.0113523975, 0.0279937536, -0.0158355646, 0.0122719957, -0.0103655411, -0.0076702517, 0.0490798689, -0.027726857, 0.0293220636, -0.002902552, 0.0019778432, 0.0533348843, 0.0246924013, -0.0225496646, -0.0705905929, -0.0239055473, -0.0399979055, 0.0336430371, 0.0062964708, 0.000862554, -0.0009323554, -0.0377403609, 0.0390129499, 0.0214544814, -0.0044808146, -0.0580681935, 0.0587251261, -0.0217227805, -0.0166644901, -0.0143150436, 0.0126784146, -0.05959066, -0.0238887463, 0.0131395897, 0.0257034432, 0.0565896966, -0.0132010905, -0.0079920171, -0.0188254248, -0.003838141, 0.0631866455, 0.000443012, -0.0080061359, -0.015782658, 0.0628299788, 0.0823950395, -0.0095395213, 0.0171086024, 0.0330443382, 0.0200447924, 0.0391762964, -0.0133575676, -0.0296045486, -0.0225173961, -0.0132535826, 0.0416671969, -0.083141841, 0.0328111872, -0.0188084319, -0.0217465721, -0.0506156906, -0.033073552, 0.1244193912, 0.0369805954, -0.0674636438, 0.0029361595, 0.0061325389, -0.0420095325, -0.021057101, 0.0172538962, -0.0712211579, -0.0230061337, -0.028056493, -0.0109373024, -0.001007191, -0.0100786937, 0.03144411, -0.0788094625, 0.045866549, -0.0474782586, -0.0073101586, -0.0289629493, -0.0305489376, 0.0244907718, -0.0332866758, -0.0040600309, -0.0506632291, -0.0313802697, -0.0401896536, 0.0299248882, -0.0520441644, -0.0510261692, 0.0458400473, -0.0351061895, -0.0206118952, 0.0323476642, 0.0223527048, -0.0659623444, -0.0459199175, 0.0208464451, 0.0060342699, -0.0168380048, 0.000323928, 0.0450222902, -0.0347196646, -0.0249837469, 0.012276113, 0.0038472346, -0.0424631983, 0.0155889513, 0.0024941559, 0.0541582778, 0.0091847396, -0.0333085954, -0.0009533207, -0.0120164901, -0.0065312437, 0.0495041981, -0.0117845638, -0.0657489896, 0.0069592809, -0.0000041623, 0.0184010677, -0.0567452684, -0.066058293, -0.0162799228, -0.0437356941, -0.053807985, -0.0512665808, -0.0290897749, 0.0204100534, -0.0076762056, 0.0077492557, -0.0057757744, 0.047565762, -0.0023183001, -0.0441357158, 0.026168786, 0.0100759026, -0.0448537767, -0.0442853086, -0.0324214101, 0.0331150368, -0.0164865907, -0.0548937805, 0.0229459256, -0.0223073587, -0.0261007901, 0.0511657186, 0.0004969928, 0.004191916, 0.009503358, -0.0082987687, -0.0244458988, 0.0538458303, 0.0753864795, -0.0239750315, -0.0607530959, 0.027687069, 0.0152089205, -0.0271183215, 0.0156614389, -0.0407461599, 0.0683606341, 0.0058974875, 0.004840875, -0.0171165243, -0.029527694, 0.0311335698, -0.030715473, 0.1128904149, 0.0270510204, -0.029100921, -0.0644076988, -0.0214614123, 0.0130011821, -0.0022528018, -0.0237215795, 0.0208712257, 0.0050239251, 0.0087309172, -0.0112045957, 0.0397962891, 0.0112393349, -0.0058060181, -0.0038018818, 0.0294886548, -0.0015825634, 0.01074751, -0.0694525689, 0.0026882472, -0.0173176974, 0.0012403083, 0.0376091301, 0.0481538102, -0.0249329302, 0.0327133536, -0.001180798, -0.0136205675, -0.0284806862, 0.0472103097, -0.0504197143, 0.008598581, -0.0426681079, 0.0347885638, 0.0517197996, -0.0566906072, 0.0129914973, -0.0274377745, -0.0097826431, -0.0005306099, 0.0084491596, -0.0375140309, 0.0541574769, -0.0349199176, 0.0042437934, -0.0324626751, -0.0372911468, 0.0317423642, 0.0047332109, 0.0043308767, 0.0149297658, -0.0288933404, -0.0426810123, 0.0128152585, 0.0004981151, -0.034928564, -0.0318291597, 0.0136556374, -0.0138900792, -0.0034769562, 0.0617113262, -0.0344406329, 0.017876327, 0.0194687285, 0.0603749081, 0.0735833123, -0.0092465887, -0.0142043959, -0.0595692545, 0.0525268801, 0.0005194134, -0.0144088026, -0.0119727915, -7.188916435e-33, -0.0219421461, -0.0178727899, -0.021428274, 0.0587292388, 0.0001595926, 0.0185102653, -0.0155308628, -0.0085309241, -0.0124159493, 0.0412990563, -0.0029292235, -0.0030903122, 0.017585421, 0.0287555214, 0.0290873498, -0.0300008263, 0.0163772367, 0.0078988224, 0.0277173556, 0.0002897501, 0.0425003916, 0.0739575028, 0.1046879962, -0.0554809831, 0.023420589, -0.0024279426, 0.0540908687, -0.005820435, 0.0789304674, 0.0472757481, -0.0268639028, 0.0349945575, 0.0182267874, -0.0722573623, 0.0447400771, 0.0143120214, -0.0680436641, -0.0037642857, -0.0633900911, -0.0100484397, -0.0271783844, -0.0283293128, 0.0591130629, 0.0096700955, -0.0222406276, -0.0121731069, 0.0797693059, 0.0018000707, 0.000427323, -0.0678863898, -0.0776630342, 0.0150791584, 0.0276551172, -0.0065803556, 0.0503481552, 0.0331070907, -0.0005206536, 0.0380189493, -0.0837896019, -0.0071548247, 0.020367654, 0.0435598642, 0.0425823815, 0.0165507328, -0.0071342974, 0.0529268682, -0.0116163502, -0.0204717312, -0.0224559531, 0.0093848146, 0.0362515412, 0.0667010397, 0.0103710527, 0.0027197881, 0.0764656439, -0.0078435242, -0.041994635, 0.0312429313, 0.0103578046, 0.0431889221, -0.0229845606, -0.0112502035, -0.0303888638, 0.0407717116, 0.036579784, 0.0142357303, -0.021638928, -0.0225726198, -0.0182619635, -0.0006280306, -0.0491079539, 0.0354804248, 0.0091935266, -0.0265254918, 0.033216387, -0.0073359637, 0.0078379344, 0.0395481847, -0.0021009243, 0.0086021721, -0.0547528863, -0.05999301, -0.0504894368, 0.0144678, 0.01413971, 0.0142143499, 0.0153622124, 0.0010907853, -0.0275330171, 0.012594413, -0.024641538, -0.0161559712, -0.0046883482, 0.0555600971, -0.0170047563, 0.0288067888, -0.0286628194, 0.0514578074, 0.0410329439, 0.0473288, -0.0093833748, 0.0298467595, 0.0434601791, 0.017950736, -0.0464073345, -0.0141627351, 0.0022118702, 0.0251801331, -0.0133174788, -0.0540265553, 0.0074713067, -0.0397622883, 2.93e-7, 0.0299813095, 0.0851501301, 0.0096881874, -0.044005692, 0.015851168, 0.0397228114, 0.0517898984, 0.0116305714, -0.0173093975, -0.015367426, 0.0066779098, 0.0098481718, 0.0039348057, 0.0099949939, -0.0871345252, -0.0637909994, -0.0309291594, -0.0154435104, -0.0240271445, -0.0167906377, 0.0513080321, 0.0862622485, 0.0168845933, -0.0195385888, -0.0423786528, -0.0341732651, 0.0168649945, -0.0179147776, -0.0086559681, 0.0479316823, 0.0315622129, 0.0248641074, -0.0417409725, -0.0170055516, -0.0190557223, 0.070945926, 0.0465426035, 0.0496644415, -0.0061586951, -0.0123461438, 0.0078239106, 0.0075400481, 0.0233229809, 0.0112438267, 0.0338615105, -0.0875429511, -0.0262188762, -0.0671565458, 0.001635951, 0.0591636524, 0.0156196496, -0.0450899489, -0.0075992974, 0.020766288, 0.0090090455, -0.0018215962, -0.0708614811, -0.0830027163, 0.0484212451, 0.0454171114, -0.0194809865, 0.0209817812, -0.0016899025, -0.0157735161, -0.0033870498, -0.0058193901, 0.0288234185, 2.429656595e-34, -0.0021691076, 0.0401353762, -0.0434592776, 0.069961451, -0.011234873, 0.0092003029, -0.0367892794, 0.0100069977, -0.0451436192, -0.0397363417, 0.0059839673 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.06758v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.06758v1
Tracing and Manipulating Intermediate Values in Neural Math Problem Solvers
2023-01-17T08:46:50
2023-01-17T08:46:50
Yuta Matsumoto, Benjamin Heinzerling, Masashi Yoshikawa, Kentaro Inui
cs.LG
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
How language models process complex input that requires multiple steps of inference is not well understood. Previous research has shown that information about intermediate values of these inputs can be extracted from the activations of the models, but it is unclear where that information is encoded and whether that information is indeed used during inference. We introduce a method for analyzing how a Transformer model processes these inputs by focusing on simple arithmetic problems and their intermediate values. To trace where information about intermediate values is encoded, we measure the correlation between intermediate values and the activations of the model using principal component analysis (PCA). Then, we perform a causal intervention by manipulating model weights. This intervention shows that the weights identified via tracing are not merely correlated with intermediate values, but causally related to model predictions. Our findings show that the model has a locality to certain intermediate values, and this is useful for enhancing the interpretability of the models.
[ -0.0157582182, 0.0744549707, -0.0273976997, 0.0093472479, -0.0162300579, 0.025695309, 0.0092134457, -0.017107768, -0.0786428973, 0.0038948723, -0.0039669042, 0.007548233, 0.0450893976, 0.0038442216, 0.0250597522, -0.0329604559, 0.01252901, -0.034654703, 0.0019434741, 0.0108306836, -0.0638332143, -0.039047353, -0.0453301892, 0.0428674035, -0.039840661, -0.0442222059, 0.0066738748, -0.0720020533, -0.0096208965, 0.0125386054, -0.0060028303, 0.0484287813, 0.034175545, 0.0129598901, 0.0000021841, -0.0392951034, 0.0176364016, 0.0058947718, -0.0556004904, -0.0101845488, -0.0230091009, -0.0088718729, 0.0159671977, 0.0107048228, -0.0366704166, -0.0178669691, 0.050744839, 0.0282624774, 0.0216803905, 0.0486907288, -0.0122342566, -0.033271715, 0.0039771576, -0.0165265817, 0.0367486291, -0.0400831029, 0.0116051137, 0.0120253256, -0.0176946297, -0.0023340599, -0.0470905937, 0.003747412, 0.0809436589, 0.0101225981, -0.0268192273, 0.0212664846, 0.0523137264, -0.0075774146, 0.0272268783, 0.0239230115, -0.0278458633, -0.0505725779, -0.0143731078, -0.0169260222, 0.041461505, 0.021855846, -0.0669744015, 0.009984863, 0.0373507626, 0.0199970417, 0.0239173006, 0.0081932954, 0.005360628, -0.026552774, -0.0575956553, 0.060130097, -0.0112742083, -0.0202400535, -0.0551016778, 0.0196284782, -0.0249500349, 0.003122974, 0.0484021157, 0.0213217251, 0.0173267666, 0.0021002586, 0.022467643, -0.0374199152, -0.0552948117, -0.0548981614, 0.046996817, 0.1116394326, 0.0034772051, -0.0269413218, -0.033495836, 0.0728019103, -0.0515591949, 0.0629709885, -0.0386444628, 0.0618305951, 0.0001687571, -0.0469776839, -0.0205628499, -0.0029790641, 0.0046412358, 0.0094361594, -0.0421439968, 0.0209057219, -0.017660914, -0.023479728, 0.0066627231, 0.0010885794, 0.0177196898, 0.0028471965, -0.0299545154, 0.0806330442, -0.062214762, 0.0585185327, -0.0481927656, -0.0227711331, -0.0354300551, -0.0105397515, 0.0004070619, -0.0296287052, 0.0089727379, 0.0561730228, -0.0211463347, -0.0078026904, 0.0073265685, -0.0393181928, 0.0518447831, -0.0357448533, 0.0590052083, -0.0375625677, 0.0128825679, 0.0539231524, -0.0013973239, -0.056827642, -0.0135658272, 0.0144342138, -0.0250283498, 0.0649530143, 0.0781918019, 0.0100529483, 0.021487372, -0.0024097869, -0.0310823377, 0.0277650934, 0.0741991699, -0.0259215739, -0.0247137379, -0.0433864705, 0.0536969304, 0.033631932, 0.0162145514, -0.0651304051, -0.0295612141, -0.0541034155, 0.0087767439, 0.0211628731, 0.019849766, -0.0178277493, -0.0431432687, -0.0008171826, 0.030720925, 0.0231246818, 0.0517889112, 0.0410678163, 0.0567585304, -0.0541705601, 0.0057287128, 0.0397783518, -0.1003682762, 0.0402642451, -0.0246468373, 0.0006703794, -0.0497569703, 0.0199654363, 0.0012490916, -0.0772308782, -0.0101474784, 0.0223975945, -0.0118469531, -0.0105257425, 0.0651728734, -0.006125438, 0.002557921, 0.0830911174, -0.0206940081, -0.0390539989, 0.0185249578, -0.0372757316, 0.0263189059, -0.0064776475, 0.0261208452, -0.0287638474, 0.0217175689, 0.0038393685, -0.0157195982, -0.0588645041, 0.0108394502, 0.0096954769, -0.0055211885, -0.0181220751, -0.0246628691, -0.0166136622, 0.0353970937, -0.0115334122, 0.0227407161, -0.0443024263, 0.0087331999, -0.0470456854, 0.0326346233, 0.0276380964, -0.049323447, -0.0259980466, -0.0092619173, 0.0198649038, -0.0128674973, -0.0171961654, 0.0265350249, 0.0605229028, 0.0260650534, -0.0210387409, -0.0092339031, 0.0214612987, -0.0510327891, 0.0214410406, 0.0155761084, -0.0524766557, 0.0078869406, 0.0248762146, 0.0007457767, -0.015730435, 0.0742925629, -0.0590637289, -0.0123636127, 0.0409100428, 0.037451949, -0.020671254, 0.0101158516, -0.0132195065, 0.0673708245, -0.0069599114, 0.0451663807, 0.0046411171, -0.002497206, -0.0043517626, 0.0320576504, 0.026555812, -0.052755665, -0.0182676669, -0.0055836607, 0.0025038174, -0.0295492988, -0.0065691308, -0.0463345982, 0.0139938714, -0.0326806679, 0.0246096384, 0.0486693308, 0.0298344158, -0.023474494, 0.0087681571, -0.0252441708, -0.0034408248, -0.0004432487, -0.0181963611, 0.0327744298, 0.0246698838, 0.0050977329, -0.0087027624, -0.0250939149, -0.0388935469, -0.0646094009, 0.1015383229, 0.0436240546, 0.0022795645, -0.0414092988, 0.0090322755, 0.0123327402, 0.0019900668, -0.0213628113, -0.0129388822, 0.0351935439, -0.0197298378, 0.0369845033, 0.0559050851, -0.0200877804, 0.082556136, 0.0554630384, -0.0123579511, -0.0448246673, -0.0161968283, -0.0690271333, 0.002824638, 0.0037933206, -0.0408765934, -0.0614427514, 0.1373672485, -0.0123374555, -0.0237106904, -0.0348977856, 0.0455492511, -0.0054136794, 0.0088921962, 0.0029363087, -0.0119395778, -0.0257951599, 0.0490342043, -0.002649535, -0.0244929772, 0.046430666, 0.0198445562, 0.0073889829, -0.0339823849, 0.0430189185, -0.0189943891, 0.0388997756, 0.0241302215, -0.0324500874, -0.0458559953, -0.0284772869, -0.0568159483, 0.0203168783, 0.0380507037, -0.0073019797, 0.0554148704, -0.0441343449, -0.0187204126, -0.0046625724, -0.0288301893, -0.0476414375, 0.0363642722, 0.0056316829, 0.0176281203, 0.0215095337, -0.024380926, -0.033944793, -0.0139351487, 0.0677637681, 0.0625456199, -0.0173178688, -0.02048737, -0.0245200079, 0.0095002856, -0.0069154603, 0.058087334, 0.0738362744, -0.0629672408, 0.0114391353, -0.009757922, 0.0174475182, 0.0011432415, -0.0458145589, 0.0494861677, 0.016050199, 0.0041505061, 0.0143483877, 0.0455194078, -0.0103726489, -0.0648114085, -0.0332504325, 0.0540925302, 0.0409642532, -0.0257942677, 0.0402260274, -0.0604450032, -0.0230567493, 0.0486638732, 0.0444705822, -0.0529262386, 0.0137693509, 0.0110159256, -0.020106636, -0.0117404079, -0.0264123697, 0.0249985307, -0.0792499483, 0.0298530962, -0.0110747013, -0.02959482, -0.014759481, -0.0125955679, -0.0022927762, -0.0119803008, 0.0077997432, -0.0102328118, 0.0051112641, 0.0289039016, 0.0033809636, -0.0065169968, -0.012099022, -0.0039493958, 0.0101995803, -0.0139215849, -0.0003122791, -0.0362060405, -0.0391578116, -0.055972483, 0.0457289927, 0.0120973997, 0.0034780693, 0.0098514212, 0.0410113893, 0.0641997308, -0.0339175574, 0.0005688366, 0.0190396011, -0.0346276388, -0.0489828773, -0.0514894985, 0.0973176956, -0.0112665417, -0.0240612868, 0.040322978, 0.0118952356, -0.0593137108, 0.0124469856, 0.059876781, -0.0311995838, -0.0188065767, -0.0235830676, 0.0110832872, -0.0194827598, -0.0434719548, -0.0018853974, 0.0737425908, -0.0297674481, -0.0297665074, -0.0024901526, 0.0546303503, 0.0317961797, 0.0041195122, -0.0619426519, 0.0257915184, -0.0347409621, -0.0343054347, 0.0877709538, -0.0012299158, 0.0116304709, -0.0265206415, 0.0257419981, 0.0298089907, -0.0559466667, -0.0474907905, -0.0157736167, -0.0817909166, -0.015804382, 0.0392490067, 0.0526878573, 0.0218497273, -0.0101307593, 0.0042445683, -0.0536326319, -0.014456626, -0.0079930862, -0.0580957755, 0.0301692933, 0.0138919326, -0.0218651798, 0.0132689914, -0.0059553087, -0.0013466704, 0.0104109701, 0.0197280087, 0.0506239422, -0.0434485562, -0.0173701234, 0.0543841496, -0.0169355515, 0.0553823188, 0.0648435354, 0.018781621, -0.035841994, 0.0404424518, -0.0243150461, 0.0110596167, -0.0404024608, -0.0341592804, 0.0145147452, 0.0731350854, -0.0010378486, -0.0513280258, 0.0270558335, 0.0240841731, 0.001780911, 0.0108973216, -0.0031979659, 0.025509391, -0.0043081501, 0.0114053572, 0.0431370959, 0.0168878101, -0.0046061785, 0.0443458334, 0.0025118524, 0.064962633, 0.0141750323, 0.0484064594, -0.0818945169, -0.0252192412, -0.04745977, -0.0628979504, 0.0148736052, -0.0348728597, -0.0061257104, 0.0208429042, -0.0019136077, -0.016094096, 0.0116902366, 0.0183422249, 0.0016855669, -0.0167655051, -0.0100997761, 0.0401357152, 0.035630744, 0.0428344086, -0.0511856042, 0.0271781981, -0.040052779, 0.0540929362, -0.0575379394, 0.0121747497, 0.006658535, -0.0394980051, -0.0118280649, -0.0139646083, -0.0278793219, 0.0175565928, -0.0548091233, -0.0647369996, -0.0332873985, 0.0074918247, -0.0072410395, -0.0311904699, 0.0193637293, 0.0227317102, -0.0340237617, -0.0264393445, 0.0157966539, -0.0073269224, 0.0185853653, -0.0115388045, -0.0210004114, -6.366340018e-33, -0.0394447446, -0.0766279474, 0.0561080799, 0.0235922616, 0.0129613308, -0.0219879765, -0.0473736934, 0.0412431061, -0.0252592899, 0.0229785573, 0.0049527967, 0.0069643119, 0.011065864, 0.0007734405, 0.0406980962, -0.0332758799, -0.0041976301, -0.0091462741, -0.0314240232, -0.0583482422, 0.0281948112, 0.0178122725, 0.0789885595, -0.0759875178, -0.0059592519, 0.0464862511, -0.0178658552, 0.0295869112, -0.0566211678, 0.0575487725, 0.0027732553, 0.0032893696, 0.0486381091, -0.0593580715, -0.0170168784, 0.0020389936, -0.0507571287, -0.0668132529, 0.0315886252, 0.0546229556, -0.0271340702, -0.0433289893, 0.0633281022, -0.0242280327, -0.0175492652, -0.0365605429, 0.0216613114, -0.0246392675, 0.0254658144, 0.011301158, -0.0721375421, -0.0276205763, -0.0211728644, -0.0069984701, 0.0257491861, 0.0435837209, -0.0459742248, -0.009984049, -0.0610322095, 0.008508279, 0.0255202986, 0.0202225763, 0.0057886927, 0.0234294999, 0.0005022447, -0.0164613836, 0.0492666475, -0.0453109182, -0.038677182, -0.0354515687, 0.0629966483, -0.0065194322, 0.0928863883, -0.0338467918, 0.054558713, 0.0522459038, -0.0244129989, -0.0356940031, 0.0055071786, 0.0599631593, -0.0041345092, -0.0434338897, 0.0023638674, -0.0267137066, -0.0811655149, -0.0151318908, -0.0849424675, -0.0169493258, 0.0288865007, -0.0132103851, 0.0208921917, 0.0100238891, 0.0179521535, -0.0406538844, 0.0173025224, 0.0123831071, 0.0063833715, 0.0699792579, 0.00072154, -0.0065960069, -0.0188037772, -0.02047983, 0.0078706769, 0.0033130967, 0.0493797325, 0.028610887, 0.0069033857, 0.0135865947, -0.0023384173, -0.0349280536, -0.0382320657, -0.0465668514, 0.0388381593, 0.0434836596, 0.0507265814, 0.0082902201, -0.0236891136, -0.0060240505, 0.0163441598, 0.0410491303, -0.0209402014, 0.0329242051, -0.0100841112, 0.0562625863, -0.0211385582, -0.0477958955, -0.0471070968, 0.0497196428, 0.0467607118, -0.0548526049, -0.0363126136, 0.0086845541, 3.035e-7, 0.0725802109, 0.0418064184, 0.02035583, 0.0418530963, 0.0035198135, 0.0059199072, -0.0035452293, -0.0507031307, 0.0473109595, -0.0241298378, 0.0286740959, 0.0018402567, 0.0086473031, 0.0073245377, 0.0125003681, -0.0234066211, 0.0023030268, 0.034302149, 0.0094616832, 0.0303348191, 0.0266885813, 0.0303784795, 0.0044184951, 0.0211525075, -0.0228600893, 0.019182846, 0.0329109617, -0.016159337, 0.0170826539, -0.0201305635, -0.0146626728, -0.0460585095, 0.0258086845, 0.04419991, -0.019304499, 0.0636073947, 0.0031949044, 0.035870079, 0.0164533481, 0.0076193935, -0.0171577558, -0.0191782974, -0.0167796928, -0.0468551666, 0.0251183156, -0.1274412274, -0.0348709859, 0.0226157084, 0.0166934356, -0.0132990489, 0.0223728027, -0.0010938691, 0.0435887612, 0.000071065, 0.0272501856, 0.0182429887, 0.0077717383, -0.0434995592, -0.0335896276, 0.0182392765, -0.0645415485, -0.0020043445, -0.0548655316, -0.0479595028, 0.0530742593, 0.0234091859, -0.0321172662, 2.936792179e-34, -0.0065428535, -0.0243441183, 0.0586949587, 0.0344551094, 0.0279095583, -0.0353016295, -0.0031573831, 0.0551935993, 0.0397801176, -0.0942186639, -0.0217244141 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.06745v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.06745v1
BERT-ERC: Fine-tuning BERT is Enough for Emotion Recognition in Conversation
2023-01-17T08:03:32
2023-01-17T08:03:32
Xiangyu Qin, Zhiyu Wu, Jinshi Cui, Tingting Zhang, Yanran Li, Jian Luan, Bin Wang, Li Wang
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI
Previous works on emotion recognition in conversation (ERC) follow a two-step paradigm, which can be summarized as first producing context-independent features via fine-tuning pretrained language models (PLMs) and then analyzing contextual information and dialogue structure information among the extracted features. However, we discover that this paradigm has several limitations. Accordingly, we propose a novel paradigm, i.e., exploring contextual information and dialogue structure information in the fine-tuning step, and adapting the PLM to the ERC task in terms of input text, classification structure, and training strategy. Furthermore, we develop our model BERT-ERC according to the proposed paradigm, which improves ERC performance in three aspects, namely suggestive text, fine-grained classification module, and two-stage training. Compared to existing methods, BERT-ERC achieves substantial improvement on four datasets, indicating its effectiveness and generalization capability. Besides, we also set up the limited resources scenario and the online prediction scenario to approximate real-world scenarios. Extensive experiments demonstrate that the proposed paradigm significantly outperforms the previous one and can be adapted to various scenes.
[ 0.0659659579, 0.0274289083, -0.0062906314, 0.0579907447, 0.0059531326, 0.040403422, -0.0260783248, -0.0076927873, 0.009920096, -0.0843531713, -0.0627232864, 0.0158354975, -0.0162488762, 0.0139484704, -0.0354651213, -0.0831668749, -0.0031930036, 0.0350061767, 0.0852336511, 0.0067936168, 0.0461466201, 0.0260088593, -0.0154611832, 0.0160206854, -0.0339226089, 0.0209400188, -0.0259862952, 0.0598598011, 0.0420046002, -0.0228325948, 0.0748860016, 0.0702142641, 0.0310326573, -0.0272835232, 0.0000018636, -0.0443686992, -0.0141478237, -0.0275835823, -0.0143877268, -0.0093378946, 0.0202456824, 0.01066144, -0.0012550204, 0.0168967471, -0.0202340074, 0.0234477911, 0.0364317372, 0.1010430455, 0.0607313663, 0.0954519585, -0.047425244, -0.0265131053, -0.0055170977, 0.008787646, -0.0053492421, -0.0134614464, 0.0143965576, -0.0010424798, -0.0096266605, -0.0249122959, -0.0250435136, -0.0107750883, -0.0035142393, 0.0066509899, 0.0114324782, 0.0243471246, -0.0754017383, -0.0290111415, -0.0199273061, 0.0875500888, -0.0151271103, 0.0090983836, -0.0021676763, -0.0068165688, -0.0049233735, -0.0251282007, -0.0093666064, -0.0288200639, -0.0031974341, 0.0167391729, 0.0036018132, 0.0131490501, -0.0191266108, 0.0519228429, -0.0054396894, 0.0177876689, -0.0022556731, -0.0358847119, 0.0059007597, -0.0053599146, -0.0152079966, -0.0178618915, -0.0028956723, 0.0059305048, 0.0084095197, -0.0025643772, -0.0486276932, -0.0209075119, -0.0228920504, -0.0629261136, -0.0188213289, 0.0122921001, -0.0493741296, 0.0422492288, -0.0079442207, 0.0124436645, 0.0251629036, -0.0035087019, -0.027034156, -0.0097018108, -0.0445728637, 0.0186011326, -0.07484705, 0.016497571, -0.0325555205, -0.0537715442, -0.0599179566, 0.0157444235, 0.0189370196, 0.0188908037, 0.0110228118, -0.0124135464, 0.0035202198, 0.002324213, -0.0001150936, 0.0182863027, -0.0445374884, 0.0326065458, -0.0174860023, -0.0591914207, -0.0041129207, 0.0283912998, 0.0393700823, -0.0135459434, 0.03606648, 0.0038510035, 0.0060584317, -0.081081599, -0.0160277635, 0.0038030464, -0.0573530458, -0.0562250726, -0.0019406147, -0.0161273219, 0.0520462617, -0.0048262589, 0.0082660327, 0.0415199772, 0.0185811594, -0.0698075071, -0.0418146774, 0.066967532, -0.0297849886, -0.0028480478, 0.0468384624, -0.0012694441, -0.0044885487, 0.0541338474, 0.0524301156, 0.041965127, 0.050187774, -0.004765783, 0.0335645601, 0.0386814624, -0.0046814205, -0.004462386, -0.0166611709, 0.0037581592, -0.0215385873, 0.0247194767, 0.0106597114, 0.0124161439, -0.061239589, 0.022840891, 0.0544637032, 0.0272393692, -0.0065214559, 0.060285151, -0.0330771543, 0.0660135224, 0.0474103577, -0.0200440641, -0.0268419627, 0.0037273315, -0.0449315682, -0.026759645, 0.0133905094, -0.015058646, -0.0471469164, -0.0168116018, -0.007682546, -0.0261329357, -0.0111842426, -0.0103171468, 0.0389988311, -0.0200046543, -0.0632989854, 0.0641469061, 0.037033163, -0.0546676032, -0.0250426475, -0.0482990332, 0.0047802022, 0.0807583332, 0.0332167223, -0.0554444082, -0.0483131781, -0.0195245668, 0.0104149459, 0.0255669057, 0.0524700619, -0.0055628405, 0.0623116493, -0.0654867887, -0.0192718506, -0.0139118992, -0.005100613, 0.0119524915, 0.0050434927, 0.0049329447, -0.00438469, -0.0063669928, 0.0167242903, 0.0125213685, 0.0100536337, -0.0177191272, 0.0139938919, 0.0267697722, 0.0306825135, 0.01522402, -0.0359521136, -0.0411523506, 0.0157447588, 0.0153963314, 0.0260467418, 0.0316379406, -0.0361981541, -0.0977162346, -0.0043392209, 0.017338166, -0.0070748902, 0.0164856687, -0.0428080931, -0.033009097, -0.0123879984, -0.004437489, 0.1032006443, -0.0624844283, 0.0258903075, -0.0347351208, 0.0282691102, 0.0060961023, 0.0336078443, 0.0226736888, -0.0101817641, 0.0007588067, 0.0062569901, 0.0186765194, -0.009636269, -0.0664842948, -0.009304841, 0.0217293222, -0.0043848502, 0.0267997012, 0.0287294537, -0.0703731403, -0.0799512863, -0.1290021837, -0.0061266264, -0.008535305, -0.001949903, 0.0049150879, -0.0092680613, -0.0460296869, -0.0093330629, -0.0271888115, 0.0023696418, -0.0012847247, -0.0150933685, 0.0199636687, 0.0149500296, -0.0252335817, -0.0566948652, 0.0399374589, 0.0149186933, 0.0349954702, -0.0063941102, -0.0275238473, -0.0096691893, -0.0051705441, -0.0154532539, 0.0500017703, -0.0026556023, -0.0948538929, -0.0261480063, -0.0081963828, 0.0172185507, 0.0397457071, 0.0264225248, 0.0936559588, -0.0299275443, -0.0320690684, -0.0336973816, 0.0500514545, -0.0452153943, 0.0198373944, -0.0278066751, 0.0007234811, -0.008753066, 0.0358877182, -0.0179492272, 0.0433338135, -0.0600836277, -0.0256923977, 0.03477614, -0.0395416245, 0.0121612391, -0.0331275836, -0.0291079395, -0.0146035096, -0.0024444507, -0.0669194311, 0.0581499822, -0.022946462, -0.0316150002, -0.0772218183, -0.0028689122, -0.0128854169, 0.0491380021, -0.0319917053, 0.0160716139, -0.0053266101, -0.0220183302, -0.0010958614, -0.0626955777, -0.0056836428, -0.0489382856, -0.0064620669, -0.0040621515, -0.0113844732, 0.0325372033, -0.0392388292, -0.0164389145, -0.0581202693, -0.0242168996, 0.0044537755, 0.0004784619, -0.0438895635, -0.0257563181, -0.0084363045, -0.0096272249, -0.0022009264, -0.0146222524, -0.0020983634, 0.0091736494, 0.0704371333, 0.0374890231, 0.0121627059, -0.0041890522, -0.0233137775, 0.0553856827, 0.0283243619, 0.0160356872, 0.0220263749, -0.0197384749, 0.0094813621, 0.0134628117, 0.024468448, 0.0032724089, -0.0265203658, 0.031274531, -0.031625066, 0.0053701028, 0.1523188204, 0.0296260398, -0.0207053889, -0.0170791727, -0.0286580361, 0.0324515924, -0.0092396643, 0.0215498079, -0.0177648347, -0.0406442359, -0.0123528531, 0.0270589422, -0.0117254443, -0.018412495, 0.0025294269, -0.0623262338, 0.0355983265, -0.0016053044, -0.0064860894, -0.0355942212, -0.0023139482, 0.0245537423, 0.0025080158, 0.0072497586, -0.0532045811, 0.025612006, -0.0199425705, 0.0195770003, -0.0195356533, -0.05391936, 0.0486923046, -0.0297754295, 0.0280504283, 0.0262579694, 0.0910306126, -0.0106295897, 0.0068813371, 0.059986189, -0.0202884581, -0.0185938645, -0.0263520274, 0.0432864316, -0.0548567213, -0.0347230323, -0.0194731001, 0.0092372699, 0.0184066389, -0.0091744605, -0.02645633, 0.0283123888, -0.050387986, -0.0138035733, 0.0095034307, 0.0191523805, 0.0447893329, 0.0754897892, 0.0320246592, -0.0537151583, -0.0075614704, 0.0196748413, 0.0351339877, -0.0176073164, 0.0434018597, -0.0173209216, -0.002833131, 0.0205600951, -0.0619572699, -0.0572383739, 0.0250632446, 0.0111639434, -0.0124974949, -0.0440265797, -0.0058059967, 0.0166539177, -0.0290476214, 0.0498806164, 0.0397170894, -0.0069111753, -0.0435053147, -0.0387638509, 0.0604557581, -0.0366026498, -0.0162591841, 0.0019036554, -0.0201307386, -0.0453699678, 0.0122588016, 0.0454893932, 0.0063902074, 0.0444612838, 0.0215862989, -0.0599803068, 0.0506490171, 0.0211482476, -0.0245429594, 0.0029182418, 0.048862651, 0.0427158736, -0.0311548263, 0.0244710166, -0.0274269655, 0.0299201049, 0.0184433237, 0.0120690027, -0.0129160192, -0.118705228, -0.0341952592, -0.0169028677, 0.0564137474, 0.0284946207, -0.0225154851, -0.0367368683, 0.0321962871, 0.0291231088, 0.0109520154, -0.0772568882, -0.0315160453, -0.0091676461, 0.0019227929, -0.0593984798, 0.008752387, -0.0174667239, 0.0012657965, -0.0352994651, 0.056074705, 0.0228481703, -0.0081553347, 0.0130365202, 0.0048488844, -0.0207099766, 0.03102489, 0.0032302719, -0.0023551295, -0.0173704624, 0.0974118933, 0.0292506274, -0.0453042574, 0.0241036322, 0.0436142609, -0.001742146, -0.0080023902, -0.056749139, 0.0378097668, 0.011012963, -0.0462382995, 0.037286602, -0.0504846387, 0.009162141, -0.0006829473, 0.0263326541, -0.0294443406, -0.0365215838, 0.0205794182, 0.0108608985, -0.0307904594, 0.032853622, 0.0022997372, -0.0268530045, 0.0526459403, 0.0185454842, -0.0037301518, -0.0560894758, 0.0016659142, 0.1169331744, -0.0310805552, 0.0009073041, 0.0600733235, 0.0032881759, -0.0104353838, 0.027309658, -0.0543393828, -0.0325464606, -0.0015851521, 0.0631122515, 0.0586560778, -0.0373496339, 0.0171240661, -0.0258195233, -0.0000336978, -0.026978692, 0.0036460147, -0.0019876591, -5.741371549e-33, 0.0015199166, -0.0033778029, -0.0445093922, 0.0148306703, -0.0283702519, 0.0373690426, -0.0179692246, -0.0169049334, -0.0206301715, 0.0364767872, -0.0026526456, 0.0372311175, 0.0087760277, 0.0296346974, -0.041421216, -0.0351558886, 0.0289882366, -0.008244128, -0.0229683369, 0.0211949721, 0.018222224, 0.0532491095, 0.079095602, -0.0759224668, -0.0129599283, -0.0159796178, -0.0332727134, 0.0416954421, 0.079578504, 0.0424187854, -0.018703958, 0.0222391039, 0.0048941197, 0.00020041, 0.0093856836, 0.066127643, -0.0506085716, 0.0086025363, -0.0192852523, 0.0043738107, -0.0418285318, 0.0258855671, 0.0045844107, 0.0115553318, 0.0075215711, 0.0136927031, 0.0178264007, -0.0299811177, 0.0054772189, -0.072649233, -0.0508959889, 0.0446614958, -0.0240009669, -0.0562748723, 0.0296625532, 0.0473702587, 0.0179706067, 0.0122607974, -0.0272198487, -0.0080806613, 0.0278255995, -0.0232118145, -0.0408989079, 0.0024321042, -0.0138696218, 0.0845175833, 0.0034043826, 0.007557875, 0.0159905851, -0.0105002057, 0.0258719511, 0.0626486987, -0.0028550245, 0.0051239096, -0.0446397699, 0.0213145204, -0.0408346578, 0.0282050408, 0.0438955463, 0.0319341943, 0.0442980416, -0.0069660344, -0.045625452, 0.0107589643, -0.0106850741, 0.0160841197, -0.0080729565, 0.0027096008, 0.0295961089, 0.0087534422, 0.0071204244, 0.0055753239, 0.0219093822, -0.0234872214, 0.0144103672, 0.0519111045, -0.0280342773, 0.0210958924, -0.0093277702, 0.018411722, -0.0426224321, -0.0555253401, 0.0729465261, -0.0081682876, 0.0145103373, -0.0030069712, 0.0146716731, 0.0325066522, -0.0433116294, 0.0212806612, 0.0027785907, 0.0292937066, -0.0438742228, 0.0775599107, -0.0270049423, 0.0146681583, -0.019782396, 0.0340033695, -0.0041970704, 0.0395979546, -0.0168312304, -0.0062515889, 0.0144450087, 0.0346339047, -0.01818683, 0.0054045953, 0.0112613356, -0.0281107202, -0.0105375443, -0.0238558892, 0.0157436877, -0.0193928946, 2.689e-7, -0.0065749809, 0.0467535853, 0.0229286104, -0.062067017, 0.016811667, 0.0611321405, 0.0017828697, 0.0471202992, 0.0399270765, -0.0161473174, 0.0664385408, 0.0166511294, 0.0656872541, -0.0206597541, -0.1000215039, -0.0432546772, -0.0644733012, -0.0060037975, -0.0235305186, 0.0178641099, 0.0982596129, 0.0966997743, 0.0518342443, 0.0055766609, -0.0053675254, -0.0172122642, 0.0503103063, -0.0645993501, -0.0191778205, 0.0521005131, -0.0140350116, 0.0069203316, -0.0369987041, 0.0168949664, -0.0087040765, 0.0467221513, 0.0056957365, 0.0859752521, -0.0040897829, -0.0538940802, 0.0280669387, 0.0368656404, -0.0238557439, -0.0529796258, 0.0363324769, -0.0546243936, -0.0319945626, 0.0006999788, -0.0052672615, -0.0169975106, 0.0355183817, -0.0545773543, -0.0398772433, 0.0396884792, 0.0157592595, -0.0362975933, -0.028804414, -0.1256342679, 0.0040701209, 0.0130227227, -0.0507314503, -0.0392877348, -0.0168102551, 0.0041449293, 0.0445843972, -0.0538748801, 0.0418132022, 2.096469838e-34, 0.0134679563, -0.0265534502, -0.0199456159, 0.0492457002, 0.0264135599, 0.0241220333, 0.0228296481, -0.0308076981, 0.0223762803, -0.0591639578, 0.0233247895 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.06736v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.06736v1
Syllable Subword Tokens for Open Vocabulary Speech Recognition in Malayalam
2023-01-17T07:29:47
2023-01-17T07:29:47
Kavya Manohar, A. R. Jayan, Rajeev Rajan
cs.CL
cs.CL
In a hybrid automatic speech recognition (ASR) system, a pronunciation lexicon (PL) and a language model (LM) are essential to correctly retrieve spoken word sequences. Being a morphologically complex language, the vocabulary of Malayalam is so huge and it is impossible to build a PL and an LM that cover all diverse word forms. Usage of subword tokens to build PL and LM, and combining them to form words after decoding, enables the recovery of many out of vocabulary words. In this work we investigate the impact of using syllables as subword tokens instead of words in Malayalam ASR, and evaluate the relative improvement in lexicon size, model memory requirement and word error rate.
[ 0.0320696421, -0.0126085747, 0.00950519, 0.0302050449, -0.0610883459, -0.0049174274, -0.0057800794, 0.0471528172, -0.0166809354, -0.0325080976, -0.0348658003, -0.0863719657, 0.0522358678, 0.0003939733, -0.0009372232, -0.0540742129, -0.0029470513, -0.0737027898, 0.0458099321, -0.0070724981, -0.0059265275, 0.0182892792, -0.0374819152, 0.0288404021, -0.0333701856, 0.0247692838, 0.0052174223, -0.0011505382, 0.0040887785, -0.0216517821, -0.0710813627, -0.0321710743, -0.0051580439, 0.0205089264, 0.0000014025, -0.0449071005, -0.0308026969, 0.0053665051, -0.0523759536, 0.0072142235, 0.0842461362, 0.0352712944, 0.0039671934, 0.0512575544, 0.0464770608, -0.0046730158, 0.0682149529, -0.0347190946, -0.0055954428, 0.0483693331, -0.0210820585, -0.0503617302, 0.0174660627, 0.0325057916, -0.0354771912, -0.0101693133, 0.0066634025, -0.0427299291, 0.0392106734, -0.0731818229, 0.0022212958, 0.0166260041, -0.0615080707, 0.0123495515, 0.0335570276, 0.0187496133, 0.0178976189, -0.0482781976, 0.0040031942, 0.0085052494, -0.0455109328, -0.0013796174, -0.0002542451, -0.0274017397, -0.057536535, -0.0133012338, -0.0054378808, 0.0350767598, -0.0461118668, 0.0317900851, 0.0813051239, 0.0077198306, -0.0257268492, -0.0050401581, 0.0041536042, 0.0364244357, 0.0321593545, -0.0429806821, -0.0133607155, -0.0455585681, 0.0018266543, -0.0265816115, 0.0604072399, 0.0109240189, 0.0089787217, 0.0596386679, 0.0371303968, -0.0583145879, 0.0212902557, -0.0319901593, 0.0496772006, 0.0206769891, -0.0232431255, -0.0152857844, -0.0067948359, 0.0397441164, -0.01240105, 0.0015003197, -0.0153668588, -0.0258672759, 0.0410772301, -0.0346147045, -0.0183721967, 0.0250952598, -0.0205780193, -0.0045525325, -0.0052567311, 0.019524008, 0.0389695093, -0.0348896906, 0.0412159711, -0.0450400673, -0.0162025075, -0.0282757748, 0.009337577, -0.0075786165, 0.0181139428, 0.0354963578, -0.0018322086, -0.0821124762, -0.0214320142, 0.009279212, 0.0369452126, 0.0100753587, -0.0250597149, 0.0224534385, 0.0272105541, -0.060448572, -0.0366263911, 0.0168211162, -0.0361670554, -0.0455435961, -0.0357138216, -0.0513297319, 0.0284340493, 0.0240243152, -0.0052459724, -0.020570064, 0.0302581042, 0.0116107333, -0.0104190893, 0.0479541831, -0.0386021696, 0.0029592828, 0.0273344722, 0.0043599331, 0.1105931327, 0.0316704996, 0.0159623623, 0.0137941409, 0.0400721617, -0.040220622, -0.0097924219, 0.0211734734, 0.0000042165, -0.0142557248, -0.028849965, -0.0183617212, 0.0379055701, 0.0454533435, -0.0118646454, 0.0783443898, -0.0044407449, 0.0051063076, -0.0286489427, 0.0806849152, 0.0361823924, 0.0040234379, 0.0062793186, 0.006396981, 0.0232416801, 0.0161133111, 0.052567564, -0.0175376516, 0.0495714173, 0.0381768458, 0.089575924, 0.0108450558, -0.0042300099, 0.0064529628, -0.0962124467, -0.0553967953, -0.0541552827, -0.0102547659, 0.0796764717, 0.0084085455, -0.0789953768, 0.0701462403, 0.0431344099, -0.0718104467, 0.0318632387, -0.0775211677, 0.0404548012, 0.0208875258, 0.0612737723, -0.0521086119, 0.0288174506, 0.0165101923, -0.0411817245, 0.0361894779, -0.0070107002, -0.0023807434, 0.0258566979, -0.0678986907, 0.0291103479, 0.0777593255, -0.0194760002, 0.0470598377, -0.0220352523, 0.0119156269, 0.0110016065, -0.0297276229, 0.0354072489, 0.0031974823, 0.0387030914, -0.0004619672, 0.0244851131, 0.0008896615, 0.0766095594, 0.0657962412, -0.0190989058, 0.0053443522, 0.0492086783, -0.000464163, 0.0103494972, -0.0070651332, -0.0214753672, -0.0102254525, 0.0402738973, 0.0445431881, 0.0493708439, -0.0006570807, 0.0661175475, -0.0543993153, 0.0236008484, -0.0255819187, 0.1291989088, -0.0325776525, 0.0634059161, 0.0217135828, 0.0146039799, -0.0045797946, -0.0213174019, -0.0164605454, 0.0110087898, 0.0015889407, 0.0077011618, -0.0139199514, -0.0642212927, 0.0155155445, 0.0490709208, -0.0010374556, 0.0306750238, -0.0216062926, -0.0579915009, -0.0109123765, -0.0384613015, -0.0832626596, -0.0165678151, -0.0233625993, 0.01218725, -0.0695805624, 0.039161481, -0.022905454, -0.0031339969, 0.0486146063, 0.0269484892, 0.0453129746, -0.0003230851, -0.0515245087, 0.0115372809, -0.0143948356, -0.0176130924, -0.0379446633, 0.0265123583, 0.0434887633, -0.0069758943, -0.0215635113, -0.0301112998, -0.0178963784, 0.0010619655, -0.013178831, 0.0142994225, -0.0108646778, -0.025623519, -0.04975117, 0.0330716334, -0.0220444519, -0.0065272837, -0.0048478069, 0.0151294973, -0.0620805435, -0.0103083057, -0.0282185357, 0.0305446908, 0.0049329293, 0.0284088757, 0.0463850982, -0.018818384, 0.0085025216, 0.0341158807, 0.0195849948, 0.0104398215, -0.0512148328, -0.0428991802, 0.0108198943, 0.0242399815, -0.0041553038, -0.0875174627, 0.0362095647, 0.009656975, -0.0516995601, 0.0045333053, -0.0733106583, -0.0080486331, -0.0567787811, -0.0099817356, -0.0417247936, -0.0153177846, -0.0252263118, -0.0233193431, -0.0477022305, -0.058628615, 0.0407720245, 0.0379369706, -0.0416821428, -0.0491125919, 0.0260330122, -0.0418636464, -0.0045516202, -0.0270957593, 0.0242304709, -0.0206474755, 0.0140856011, -0.0154608162, 0.0347467288, 0.0315645635, 0.0008642141, 0.0435782671, 0.0645615384, -0.0357938968, -0.028739471, 0.0148670841, 0.0331802145, 0.0041832244, 0.0564557798, 0.0199923925, 0.0001160901, -0.0365488343, 0.0193481036, 0.0143474489, -0.043615941, 0.0946955457, -0.0089954948, 0.0184225682, -0.0077574155, 0.0514474809, -0.0107324105, 0.0230083354, 0.0236193109, -0.0117812445, 0.0255479906, -0.0090005239, 0.0718534216, 0.058530543, -0.0044829608, -0.0455108359, -0.0565773621, -0.0010982949, -0.0170840938, -0.0283370893, -0.0035910867, 0.0073806453, 0.0456845015, 0.03512403, 0.0441093072, 0.0187114365, -0.0276391301, -0.0699152723, 0.0136617189, 0.0087125665, -0.0239810124, -0.0069231316, -0.0379425623, 0.0013907166, -0.0203649607, -0.0181523059, 0.0664325356, -0.0385181159, -0.045011472, 0.0417968109, -0.0409303978, 0.008665191, 0.004433162, -0.0487134121, 0.0295435619, 0.0272763949, 0.0063688974, -0.0364563316, -0.0403597765, 0.0257143248, -0.0449916534, 0.0013005766, -0.0248695482, -0.0138202766, -0.0096490839, -0.0086215446, 0.0267291926, -0.0027841036, -0.0221357178, -0.0121972598, -0.0106611047, 0.0258294735, 0.0269914474, 0.0175575987, 0.0131718628, 0.0043915319, -0.0053925831, -0.0207334701, 0.0083751399, -0.0127518317, -0.0062553752, 0.0162561312, 0.0352278501, 0.0023332359, 0.0268548373, -0.0196870398, -0.0091747707, -0.0672538653, 0.0053832717, 0.0119807618, 0.022653522, 0.0636378974, 0.0236896072, 0.0514253601, -0.0140127381, 0.0380834602, -0.0373350196, -0.0415198803, -0.0168844834, 0.0428167582, -0.1050168723, -0.0208835118, -0.000805516, -0.0257822555, -0.0190602187, -0.0236327369, -0.020504307, -0.0465307012, 0.0872536004, 0.0051221219, 0.0237902328, 0.0127514582, 0.0097586643, -0.0470163897, 0.035876818, -0.0021749844, -0.0268586744, -0.0208170582, 0.0106177609, 0.0051795347, -0.0158319324, -0.0018669901, -0.0272900984, -0.0478319861, -0.0093569765, -0.0096806586, 0.0395255685, -0.0474508218, 0.0101203006, 0.0321009383, 0.058196336, -0.0566743575, 0.0093777413, -0.0298936144, -0.0115618436, 0.0359797627, 0.0652831718, 0.0205159262, -0.0250052921, 0.0245676935, -0.007309529, -0.0386699364, -0.0216183495, -0.0455536395, -0.0132792685, 0.0719809458, 0.0883212686, 0.0280762911, 0.037763387, 0.0205865111, -0.0405285768, -0.0301459506, -0.0307243597, -0.0358296223, -0.0211758129, -0.0010449718, 0.0244738646, -0.062261641, 0.0197064746, 0.0419299603, 0.0465875901, 0.0571931042, 0.0191261023, -0.0116119729, 0.0738828331, 0.0089787105, -0.025032524, -0.0160414297, -0.0274682511, 0.0277988967, -0.0550261587, 0.0121855596, -0.0591201968, -0.0071983756, 0.0540354177, 0.0179566294, -0.0287989061, 0.0027737634, 0.0379584916, 0.0279046949, -0.0183016788, 0.0005054472, 0.0064710877, -0.0056601083, -0.0324632749, -0.049476888, 0.0537569635, -0.0134076336, 0.0004842202, -0.0542132817, -0.0648864359, 0.0455101915, 0.0204811208, 0.0563884825, -0.0139205875, -0.0035385899, 0.0177763905, 0.0231302492, 0.0094919465, -0.0121445982, -0.0287657231, 0.0041622543, -0.0183026902, 0.0425109193, -5.150033973e-33, -0.0346697569, 0.0012917545, -0.0153512526, 0.0049877553, -0.0248570889, 0.0201152973, 0.0015801275, 0.0021556139, 0.0276218187, -0.0687943399, -0.0378338546, -0.0022022307, 0.0290146042, -0.0160612296, 0.0277814846, 0.0173209682, 0.0353593118, -0.00308382, 0.0142507711, -0.0297471303, 0.0507314503, 0.029123215, 0.0161867291, 0.0438787751, -0.0019239333, -0.0085750958, 0.0472483672, -0.0269092601, 0.0049465797, 0.0303938687, -0.0464259945, 0.0727158636, -0.0032663904, -0.0138407238, -0.0288466848, 0.0358209573, -0.0554742105, 0.0417536236, 0.0569339953, 0.0479187444, 0.0001047059, -0.0259033963, -0.0116809327, 0.0271065757, -0.0331982225, 0.021816127, -0.0388137139, -0.0135709932, -0.0462175868, -0.0108816046, -0.0282368567, 0.0768375024, 0.0059652231, 0.0033606484, 0.0786411688, -0.0208107345, 0.0006436661, -0.0543298237, -0.0159738753, 0.0236108433, 0.0244500041, 0.0364144258, 0.0186673105, 0.0384831056, -0.0727353171, -0.0567511059, 0.0433807932, -0.1245432124, -0.0094636828, 0.0279782992, 0.0067867264, 0.0221292023, -0.0048860591, -0.0116994791, 0.063725844, -0.1114971787, 0.0245321319, -0.0466984585, -0.0006421931, 0.0267093908, 0.0348227359, 0.0397109464, -0.0404104851, -0.0085374471, 0.0336072594, -0.0185388662, -0.0482610241, -0.010461336, 0.071670115, -0.016167568, -0.0078319833, 0.0156672802, 0.0622971468, 0.0240214299, 0.0510597713, -0.0212264955, 0.0465470925, 0.0013432163, -0.0620476566, 0.0131299086, -0.0571583994, -0.0430926792, 0.0244890191, 0.0252571907, -0.0150679527, -0.0222299639, -0.0467650853, 0.0315227024, -0.0589953363, 0.0065252362, -0.0077438522, 0.012629807, 0.0150092067, 0.0189182386, 0.0318253711, -0.0101488158, 0.0254848413, 0.001709835, 0.0164102167, -0.026750993, -0.0075798584, 0.0177167822, -0.0121504106, -0.0060970727, -0.0184005722, 0.0354254507, -0.0039792014, -0.0135043664, -0.0254802853, 0.0368463397, 0.0090079941, 0.0521937534, 2.269e-7, -0.0442082621, 0.0235084239, 0.0851499885, -0.0490620248, -0.0070886086, -0.0387724042, -0.025702646, -0.0307711102, -0.0164727625, 0.0258012619, 0.0153871188, -0.037616618, 0.0600590482, 0.0140853459, -0.1136599407, 0.0122537594, -0.0378258713, -0.0023179932, -0.0648117736, -0.0171930566, 0.0100122718, 0.0693816394, 0.0092482539, -0.0367768556, -0.0281278361, -0.0054660416, 0.0174028073, 0.0032876516, -0.0013322561, -0.0217807982, 0.027057603, 0.006027245, -0.0013859739, 0.0079907747, -0.0182161089, 0.0452127345, 0.0711940005, 0.0051274747, -0.039936699, -0.0342948437, 0.0536715984, 0.0215804484, -0.0426612161, -0.0274548251, 0.0347986743, 0.094370082, -0.0016559659, -0.0523631424, 0.001745687, 0.0301926509, 0.0144279134, 0.0015920211, -0.0090981945, 0.0142149981, -0.0069702207, -0.0393728577, -0.0279637054, -0.0294869356, 0.0090092383, -0.0177175552, -0.0370567255, -0.0272304937, 0.0048870943, 0.0471090823, 0.0403244533, -0.0293163732, -0.0138715142, 1.558405666e-34, 0.0555124134, -0.0219207983, -0.0094661498, 0.0245749205, 0.032732293, -0.0474099405, 0.03451965, 0.0472431481, -0.0354348347, -0.0675405711, -0.052201461 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.06735v3
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.06735v3
Two Stage Contextual Word Filtering for Context bias in Unified Streaming and Non-streaming Transducer
2023-01-17T07:29:26
2023-06-08T13:29:38
Zhanheng Yang, Sining Sun, Xiong Wang, Yike Zhang, Long Ma, Lei Xie
cs.SD
cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS
It is difficult for an E2E ASR system to recognize words such as entities appearing infrequently in the training data. A widely used method to mitigate this issue is feeding contextual information into the acoustic model. Previous works have proven that a compact and accurate contextual list can boost the performance significantly. In this paper, we propose an efficient approach to obtain a high quality contextual list for a unified streaming/non-streaming based E2E model. Specifically, we make use of the phone-level streaming output to first filter the predefined contextual word list then fuse it into non-casual encoder and decoder to generate the final recognition results. Our approach improve the accuracy of the contextual ASR system and speed up the inference process. Experiments on two datasets demonstrates over 20% CER reduction comparing to the baseline system. Meanwhile, the RTF of our system can be stabilized within 0.15 when the size of the contextual word list grows over 6,000.
[ -0.0216698945, -0.0091230217, 0.0149433417, 0.0340334773, 0.0307334624, -0.0022518891, 0.0382124409, -0.0213223211, -0.0433455929, -0.0582607761, -0.0092534674, -0.0441206619, 0.0372658074, 0.0370348692, 0.0001333303, -0.0388991646, 0.0060257432, -0.0261892155, -0.0096697109, -0.0182622094, 0.024540497, 0.018546531, -0.0249235928, 0.0195006467, -0.0230507664, 0.0469301492, 0.0014224211, 0.035986159, 0.0053404761, -0.0657892898, -0.0388806388, 0.0215426348, 0.0372187793, 0.0041771885, 0.0000020419, -0.0453577675, -0.0739222467, 0.0094672283, -0.0591713414, -0.0379345007, 0.0332214758, 0.0322723351, -0.041199863, 0.0437485017, 0.0253325459, 0.0026483168, 0.0559595749, -0.0075377505, -0.0131721729, 0.0307141189, -0.012647015, -0.034825962, -0.021120498, -0.0124908257, -0.0157131031, -0.0412771553, -0.000843434, -0.0561251864, -0.0101271402, -0.0224626344, -0.0313368849, 0.0339244641, 0.0138141233, 0.0393043198, 0.0460824631, 0.0086122341, -0.0516592264, -0.0465512536, -0.0181226879, 0.0588343143, 0.0047494695, -0.046779573, 0.0316040777, -0.0013216047, -0.0449434184, -0.0510106906, -0.0065227984, -0.00011134, -0.0422470346, 0.0194162857, -0.0369979851, 0.01982636, 0.0042603216, -0.0382252149, -0.0542766899, -0.0053436118, 0.031407658, -0.0363983177, -0.0084188981, 0.0036037771, 0.0025776797, -0.0241558328, 0.0827388018, -0.0247873105, -0.0438114665, 0.0022001439, -0.0142808016, -0.0062642065, -0.041253563, -0.0299669411, -0.0003573212, 0.0415684655, -0.0093367463, -0.0000557488, -0.0004515732, -0.008246189, 0.0337609388, -0.042923674, -0.0451097451, -0.0414138697, 0.0288721249, 0.0232444722, -0.0352494679, 0.0346478038, -0.0245832969, -0.0532063842, -0.0470484383, -0.0177102759, -0.0233275518, -0.0320292115, 0.0257796664, -0.0118619641, -0.0139776114, -0.0028372284, 0.0351772718, 0.0134400651, -0.0054632602, 0.0636104122, -0.0362393074, -0.0878150165, 0.0027999848, -0.0112219388, 0.0889538005, -0.0132794194, 0.007386988, -0.0303208604, 0.0257433411, -0.0616547354, -0.0118532721, 0.0085913176, -0.0316518173, 0.0252316035, -0.0397171415, -0.0472280532, 0.0343673192, -0.0016046923, 0.0176007953, -0.002460018, 0.0184908658, -0.0187634677, 0.0239797737, 0.0792332143, -0.0260244403, 0.0160689689, 0.0245950799, -0.007204683, 0.0160922706, 0.0581796579, 0.0719638541, -0.0501264781, 0.0496470109, -0.031934686, -0.0388903506, 0.0453690961, 0.0096794115, -0.0318377353, -0.0397023447, -0.0332665816, -0.0036847966, -0.0120078428, 0.0324404947, 0.0378201827, -0.0043549547, 0.0105753839, 0.0162782427, 0.0245084502, 0.0344358496, -0.0051556728, 0.022038551, 0.011812319, -0.0586575046, -0.0096036103, 0.0108949514, -0.0000169363, 0.0134954713, 0.0011312774, 0.0573878102, 0.0281202197, -0.025431335, 0.0295950957, 0.0106140962, -0.0023003977, 0.0006645963, 0.032324478, 0.0315906107, 0.0080983937, -0.041067481, 0.0569738895, 0.0062266504, -0.0466904044, 0.0126698324, -0.0210126564, 0.0403337106, 0.0705440193, 0.0424619615, 0.0170398187, -0.0091746738, 0.0056252452, -0.0064972537, 0.0222365335, -0.0204268843, -0.0183402505, 0.0503781699, -0.055476889, -0.0598689876, 0.0592580698, 0.0093222456, 0.0454265215, 0.0026556635, 0.0736052319, 0.0459159166, -0.0250019189, 0.0447094329, -0.0185119174, 0.0193833522, -0.0182033144, 0.0282398947, 0.0282612313, 0.0543842204, 0.0406331085, -0.0006454961, -0.0139271794, 0.0256177541, -0.0456724986, 0.0378479958, 0.0445238389, -0.0785751194, -0.0276582688, 0.0236991812, -0.0256609824, 0.0345726162, 0.0564429425, 0.029895382, -0.0737785324, -0.0292457342, 0.0032458864, 0.0874226913, -0.0119959218, 0.0573789142, 0.0495469533, 0.0399187729, 0.0619513914, 0.0057290667, 0.0371095389, 0.009767456, -0.0052456562, 0.0197216626, -0.0300115272, -0.0815246552, 0.0028252369, 0.0243192799, -0.0159071367, -0.0502900593, 0.0298583955, -0.0140883215, -0.0424903706, 0.0210074186, -0.0743324682, -0.0117161777, -0.0415769555, 0.0142851556, -0.0270005297, 0.0471149236, -0.0007138582, -0.0228180122, 0.0161637869, -0.0214117225, -0.0194825847, 0.0115946205, -0.0720526725, -0.0189976376, -0.061155986, -0.0147340111, -0.0075995508, 0.0046984465, 0.0266006496, -0.0067265849, -0.078882508, -0.0055376687, 0.0121789332, 0.0578204393, 0.0286037847, 0.0310447346, 0.0507789478, 0.0144461766, 0.0382848307, -0.0036127041, 0.0248964373, 0.0249966253, 0.0055252467, -0.0092233177, -0.0409473702, -0.0500557311, -0.0058509195, 0.0142800901, 0.0176696144, 0.011749329, 0.0032232516, -0.0256077666, 0.007197286, -0.0085565019, 0.0513019897, -0.0252077281, -0.023519529, -0.0133830914, -0.0594887771, -0.0444361866, -0.0550881065, -0.057787776, -0.011269941, -0.0344989598, 0.0009583738, -0.008528132, -0.0428062156, -0.0191060733, -0.0595805831, -0.0094492035, 0.0007206904, -0.0115536284, 0.0008393287, 0.0029970675, -0.0150492657, -0.0378373154, 0.0232093595, 0.0353452787, 0.00737361, -0.0684895664, 0.0064869458, -0.0309072863, 0.0081370501, 0.0048317644, -0.0304676183, -0.0432249643, 0.025603028, -0.0229008719, 0.0242250022, 0.0251802411, -0.008600492, 0.0116989277, 0.0678707734, 0.0038971868, 0.065205805, 0.0410684533, 0.0198980905, -0.030754067, 0.0629292727, 0.0363597311, 0.0195776466, -0.0119056962, 0.0024892029, 0.0675982684, 0.0112744803, 0.0952567533, 0.0109110139, -0.0173157044, 0.0195867997, 0.0415014103, -0.0100073358, -0.0286814887, 0.0530662574, 0.0473646224, -0.0183625463, -0.0045836554, 0.1154590994, 0.007174667, -0.0329385474, -0.0147566143, 0.0105320653, -0.0205448736, 0.0150424121, -0.041974403, -0.0442968048, -0.038692981, 0.0578812547, 0.0195400398, 0.0408001356, 0.0237452686, -0.0394959189, -0.0841032416, 0.0284214448, 0.0181577466, -0.0804253891, -0.0193209033, -0.0585248955, -0.0080040302, -0.0163518302, 0.0269993544, -0.0000454012, -0.0272515211, -0.0207149852, 0.0422361717, -0.0747687817, -0.0836718231, 0.0137353176, -0.0587482862, 0.0568854809, 0.0624667034, 0.0366223231, -0.0227733329, 0.015899539, 0.0615658686, -0.0674840361, -0.0297554005, -0.041086074, -0.0136219338, -0.0574892089, 0.0084865019, 0.027890807, 0.022978384, -0.0057882089, -0.0057723513, 0.0284167305, 0.0260829609, 0.0048330138, 0.0148733463, 0.004506608, -0.0122695239, 0.0127667282, 0.0758920088, 0.002124164, -0.021174619, 0.0390254594, 0.0348911695, 0.0235667303, 0.0062652668, 0.0249019917, -0.0075564976, -0.0101510538, -0.075751707, -0.0216052141, -0.0097036855, 0.0200988036, 0.0279141646, 0.0062843133, 0.0727830902, 0.0154622104, 0.026527416, -0.025105603, -0.0259056687, 0.0030788311, 0.054736238, -0.0293389708, 0.0092007546, 0.0122796781, -0.0332274362, -0.0165274609, 0.0460631698, -0.0552786402, -0.0157060586, 0.0138772465, -0.0347066484, 0.0191166047, 0.0634738058, -0.0427779704, -0.0136692235, 0.0318681188, 0.0279218182, -0.0254755337, 0.0339372456, 0.0163616873, 0.0303758048, -0.0004900302, 0.0190012958, -0.0695172921, 0.0430465043, -0.038979806, 0.0363146216, -0.065315105, -0.0411692262, 0.010927625, -0.0036043604, 0.0573878102, -0.0318099558, -0.0172953587, -0.043754179, 0.0622953326, -0.0126236295, 0.0747712925, -0.0322212912, 0.0318278857, -0.0203236155, 0.047717087, -0.0320463367, 0.0171305053, -0.0310800318, -0.0489188768, -0.0270939954, 0.0854164585, 0.0458131023, -0.043684721, 0.0183412228, -0.0203645565, -0.0025508821, 0.0333818384, 0.082070902, 0.0268130787, -0.0328865871, 0.0385609195, -0.0169942901, -0.0139713287, 0.0185471792, 0.0320932493, 0.0079418793, 0.0594763309, -0.0360552073, 0.053530246, 0.0040653213, -0.0436295681, 0.0254613664, 0.0074093514, 0.0297739077, -0.0517268889, 0.0053299796, -0.0368016474, -0.0239042155, 0.0538285226, 0.0016007539, -0.0210827924, 0.0378700644, 0.0201710854, -0.0309500843, 0.0155982142, -0.0160828512, 0.003080257, -0.0320639573, -0.0230169985, -0.0291291028, 0.0139614129, -0.0494703762, -0.001453517, 0.005133688, -0.0659964308, 0.0046632793, -0.0611407571, 0.0160851832, -0.0231703706, 0.0131890578, 0.0024445241, -0.046197243, 0.0179581922, 0.0384741426, -0.0691349804, -0.0091736391, 0.0127972746, 0.0014799174, -6.523020925e-33, -0.035513524, 0.0229513515, -0.0087130824, -0.0364436097, 0.0012496207, 0.0451934598, -0.0121745048, -0.0149720246, -0.0089147305, -0.0613131188, -0.0130838733, 0.0285863113, 0.0509921648, -0.0080307545, -0.0466726348, -0.0013715067, 0.0908805579, 0.0052241529, 0.0169079937, -0.0208985135, 0.027553726, 0.0800444335, 0.0098906038, -0.0539311431, -0.0412349589, 0.0331366807, -0.0142409215, -0.0250767935, 0.0368089862, 0.0600657165, -0.0214840416, 0.0299683418, -0.0166053679, -0.051918298, 0.0083748335, 0.0435179621, -0.1177735478, 0.0086752055, -0.0503747351, 0.0590176731, 0.0282594617, -0.0097972676, 0.0529158115, 0.029486347, -0.0459278785, 0.0211900603, 0.0280559938, -0.0200969782, -0.0547223166, -0.0571012944, 0.0139070088, 0.0473398231, 0.0051478115, 0.012919331, 0.0395239107, 0.0240846258, 0.0027397447, -0.0364097171, -0.0886356682, 0.0238324124, 0.0026238381, 0.0015727659, 0.0193661097, 0.0009153762, 0.0169899836, 0.0118690003, 0.0250092335, -0.0769013092, -0.0033687612, -0.0678465813, 0.0237595253, 0.0322464183, -0.0129911378, 0.007993211, 0.0860758647, -0.0365797952, -0.0368825831, 0.0197645985, -0.0038357375, 0.0327690206, 0.034384232, 0.0205976348, -0.0701104924, 0.0028934788, -0.0440961123, -0.0363361835, -0.0524667427, 0.0027142304, 0.0744712204, 0.0342514068, -0.0274138581, 0.0111885676, 0.0517028421, -0.0022402785, -0.0035771243, -0.0109082423, 0.0169896409, -0.0146169523, 0.0009888604, 0.0360612459, -0.0659632459, -0.0124518136, 0.0765167996, 0.0337531604, -0.0237143226, -0.0357482322, -0.0197900776, 0.0624330044, -0.0649442077, -0.0192673318, -0.0077374433, -0.0063455049, -0.0298773907, -0.0034603677, 0.069749698, -0.0088151917, -0.0130684469, 0.035473261, -0.0174167659, -0.0058563747, 0.0235990807, -0.0380477831, 0.0155679146, 0.0452979878, -0.0338156484, 0.003090346, 0.0257672351, 0.0074600596, 0.0783239529, -0.0067820633, -0.0242376123, 0.0000234099, 2.822e-7, -0.0409124941, -0.0364648513, 0.0028325892, -0.0294136386, 0.0070542139, -0.0054025776, 0.0187591668, 0.0398555435, 0.0015371148, 0.0142624769, 0.0293195862, -0.0137164602, 0.0730025992, 0.0229713619, -0.0872917101, -0.0109515134, -0.0574061796, 0.0552330948, -0.0112275034, 0.0259076785, 0.0100072706, 0.0862511322, -0.0060064085, -0.0598330982, 0.0107794087, -0.0054455507, 0.0237569641, -0.0537720211, 0.0790826306, -0.0401892699, -0.0165021624, -0.0134475529, -0.0092422953, 0.0462857783, -0.043763034, 0.0154414168, 0.0652584806, 0.0058042519, -0.0239794105, -0.0349626392, 0.0025751072, 0.0342466161, -0.0354487784, -0.0436410643, 0.0985683352, 0.0427483469, 0.0111945542, -0.0364768207, -0.077791281, 0.0074087051, -0.0450717956, 0.0319943205, 0.0034497674, -0.0135354986, 0.0058565992, 0.0041271416, -0.0276180636, -0.0679281503, 0.0134959035, -0.0207792316, -0.0133253783, -0.0178957619, -0.0495188497, -0.0054779719, 0.0387872644, -0.0065525323, 0.0213386416, 2.216342482e-34, 0.0126453675, 0.0007769075, 0.0139942328, 0.0029584395, 0.0132231051, -0.0352053568, -0.0013531129, 0.0076546599, -0.0066504078, -0.0367860496, -0.0436303616 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.06660v4
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.06660v4
VaxxHesitancy: A Dataset for Studying Hesitancy towards COVID-19 Vaccination on Twitter
2023-01-17T02:00:31
2023-04-15T15:32:43
Yida Mu, Mali Jin, Charlie Grimshaw, Carolina Scarton, Kalina Bontcheva, Xingyi Song
cs.CL
cs.CL
Vaccine hesitancy has been a common concern, probably since vaccines were created and, with the popularisation of social media, people started to express their concerns about vaccines online alongside those posting pro- and anti-vaccine content. Predictably, since the first mentions of a COVID-19 vaccine, social media users posted about their fears and concerns or about their support and belief into the effectiveness of these rapidly developing vaccines. Identifying and understanding the reasons behind public hesitancy towards COVID-19 vaccines is important for policy markers that need to develop actions to better inform the population with the aim of increasing vaccine take-up. In the case of COVID-19, where the fast development of the vaccines was mirrored closely by growth in anti-vaxx disinformation, automatic means of detecting citizen attitudes towards vaccination became necessary. This is an important computational social sciences task that requires data analysis in order to gain in-depth understanding of the phenomena at hand. Annotated data is also necessary for training data-driven models for more nuanced analysis of attitudes towards vaccination. To this end, we created a new collection of over 3,101 tweets annotated with users' attitudes towards COVID-19 vaccination (stance). Besides, we also develop a domain-specific language model (VaxxBERT) that achieves the best predictive performance (73.0 accuracy and 69.3 F1-score) as compared to a robust set of baselines. To the best of our knowledge, these are the first dataset and model that model vaccine hesitancy as a category distinct from pro- and anti-vaccine stance.
[ 0.0406731628, 0.0674421936, -0.0184941683, -0.0458711982, -0.0125544686, 0.02274088, 0.0152771948, -0.0364028923, 0.0228123516, -0.0255338252, 0.0308870804, -0.0246105138, -0.0219713692, 0.0211362466, -0.0211343579, -0.0455806255, 0.0134580033, 0.0791898668, 0.0811622888, 0.0010266614, 0.0424147993, 0.0312979817, -0.0178266186, 0.0440222062, 0.0312277377, -0.0118660526, 0.0178717133, -0.0041110357, 0.0597138926, -0.1154711619, 0.0796269327, 0.0117972707, 0.0237285327, 0.0318370573, 0.0000019472, -0.0285511576, -0.042119015, -0.0021402296, 0.0100154467, -0.0308674779, 0.0767998844, -0.0339653455, 0.0157159809, 0.0349527188, -0.072603479, -0.0203614868, 0.0503646918, 0.0049662287, 0.017454179, 0.0541913658, -0.0276322197, -0.0344390683, -0.008855368, 0.0060333218, -0.0188915357, 0.0196542405, 0.0453555249, -0.0099467924, -0.0340175033, 0.0538318977, 0.0270975772, 0.0335767828, -0.0562199615, -0.0001835566, -0.0078039728, 0.0070721121, -0.0135115003, -0.0586677529, 0.0004297905, 0.0549892336, 0.042953711, -0.0353523158, 0.0493687503, -0.031086335, 0.007571822, 0.0338660106, -0.0302484483, -0.0137563888, -0.0093795145, 0.0327838771, 0.0175366271, 0.0165579952, 0.0372864567, 0.0197355933, 0.0200570244, 0.0557588935, -0.0310946386, -0.0408999659, -0.002176319, -0.0192896072, 0.0228289068, -0.0445908271, 0.028843265, 0.0020205118, 0.0160337351, 0.0405936204, 0.017375445, -0.0635855347, 0.0357287489, -0.1056862324, -0.0320766121, -0.0097563248, 0.0230818968, -0.0013622564, 0.0492866375, -0.0152596347, 0.0078208428, -0.0136471679, 0.0731007978, 0.0604624972, -0.0617569461, 0.0132846059, -0.0397087447, 0.0055578253, 0.0318994597, 0.0552908592, -0.0874318406, -0.0231517423, -0.0398593545, -0.0285710115, -0.0551299118, -0.0022052184, 0.0322822742, 0.0099955397, -0.0095354626, 0.0774773881, -0.0301649328, 0.0298993085, -0.0269866493, -0.0130191846, 0.0289095473, -0.0264977776, 0.0318347476, -0.0137560759, -0.0131157422, 0.0331859104, 0.0442580059, -0.0085042305, 0.0226285998, 0.0095172077, -0.0454742201, -0.0521648526, -0.0230454132, -0.0583535023, 0.0224668216, 0.0381787978, -0.0010682726, -0.0511164404, -0.012352162, 0.0193689, -0.0541615374, 0.0391920134, -0.0298892483, 0.0146444701, 0.0388975739, 0.0212870594, 0.0498599894, 0.0246814508, 0.0043474473, 0.0463438369, 0.0226004068, 0.0039538424, 0.0169922598, -0.0166609008, 0.0503391102, 0.0288880337, 0.0021847044, 0.0059535452, -0.0185162872, -0.0282075088, -0.0400600731, 0.0387601405, 0.0158764794, -0.0109806145, 0.0542178489, 0.0526051819, -0.064073883, -0.0770658478, -0.0082678013, 0.0871882141, -0.0030210069, -0.0312027596, 0.0052690492, -0.0233055055, -0.0140468935, -0.0305505414, 0.0014391911, -0.0009243006, -0.0174472127, -0.016034456, -0.0452295877, -0.0017129091, 0.0661597848, -0.0176958069, 0.0156346094, -0.0625595748, -0.050697796, 0.0021028626, 0.0305613112, -0.0586897545, 0.0000189631, -0.0643062964, 0.0427588783, 0.016504854, -0.0210028477, 0.0030242738, -0.0656648502, -0.0515388511, 0.0342311561, 0.0045219017, 0.0382439494, -0.0126093188, -0.0543901846, -0.0037829725, -0.0237263311, -0.0014211623, 0.0412392356, -0.0043377322, 0.0140585117, 0.046246253, -0.0190917496, 0.0332385451, 0.0084524052, 0.0260092746, -0.0097977947, -0.00307431, -0.0287622865, 0.0306842607, 0.0761432871, 0.0361566171, 0.0500931069, 0.0023050262, 0.0412998497, -0.0068564494, -0.0096351346, -0.0131315775, 0.0543844923, 0.0334106795, 0.0206312649, -0.0154725593, 0.00062752, 0.0044721738, -0.042563539, 0.0424007848, 0.0505031645, 0.0237817317, 0.0111937523, -0.0023290941, 0.0116743157, -0.0627874434, 0.0201546997, 0.0000634626, 0.0170501135, -0.0300715268, -0.0034000839, -0.0120170247, -0.1036809087, 0.0005493081, -0.0255119931, 0.0235912707, -0.0467308089, -0.0063628638, 0.0182282012, 0.0304682683, -0.0555211194, -0.0293290336, 0.0124495663, -0.0655749664, -0.0211242251, 0.0070338496, 0.022254901, 0.017307952, 0.0099585932, -0.0137562556, 0.0057966691, -0.0267883781, 0.0090231439, 0.0412612334, 0.0475426205, 0.0362459458, -0.0131512312, 0.0011951264, -0.0587645359, -0.0035059757, -0.0602500737, -0.0289428383, 0.0315132216, -0.0584167875, 0.0273476429, -0.0347804315, -0.0480158329, -0.0033930172, -0.0124873687, -0.0424724557, 0.0166072454, -0.0041986722, -0.0227043536, -0.010290822, 0.0192979872, 0.0374557413, 0.0691021606, 0.0310391281, -0.0369848721, 0.0163799953, -0.0636875927, -0.0122345574, 0.00708284, -0.0222371891, 0.008133525, 0.102240406, 0.0271389689, 0.0200647302, -0.0440767705, 0.0468633249, -0.070103094, -0.0143208718, -0.0326805115, 0.0057243826, 0.0117320893, 0.0450112782, -0.0071602222, -0.0340760723, 0.0178850852, 0.056042172, 0.0471847393, -0.0374410748, -0.034171842, -0.0149250375, -0.0223789625, 0.0217234641, -0.0045317397, 0.0381819531, 0.0338545106, 0.0316534936, -0.0698076859, -0.0550138466, -0.0414748378, -0.0423740372, 0.0128894281, -0.0015142768, -0.0076958169, -0.02523374, -0.0168770142, -0.0716635883, -0.0879545584, -0.0352489874, 0.0249405038, -0.0399767123, -0.0209016334, 0.0145892454, -0.021353079, 0.0056012208, 0.0243845545, -0.0404073484, 0.0534199774, -0.0223078299, 0.0227550901, -0.0475848839, 0.0114398291, -0.0073406249, -0.0208233707, 0.0461137369, 0.0121344468, 0.0180711783, -0.0363696218, -0.0143677974, 0.0138358176, -0.0111800376, -0.005524667, 0.0053172982, 0.0610389225, -0.0059605669, 0.0485942736, 0.0631561056, 0.0167057458, 0.031167455, 0.0071082772, -0.0344779231, 0.0179859884, -0.0065796077, 0.0113115087, -0.0705706328, 0.0007077389, -0.0193351582, 0.0043830755, -0.0655492246, -0.0441849306, -0.0120115736, -0.0101363743, 0.0317726396, -0.0102578541, -0.0056779832, 0.005377382, -0.0686312243, 0.0438608304, -0.0299434457, -0.0124960793, -0.0446262509, 0.0144185489, 0.0011187508, -0.0125869401, -0.0817201734, -0.0371074043, 0.0378115028, 0.0155373868, 0.0218257811, 0.0296309181, 0.0908862725, 0.0106283529, -0.0425972715, -0.0057026255, 0.0190262441, -0.0681866705, -0.0035426058, 0.0979051813, -0.0274729338, 0.007324297, -0.0580653101, 0.0329997428, -0.0420131832, -0.0219727606, -0.0086422553, 0.0452563837, 0.0113666886, -0.052294042, -0.0628116056, 0.0707141384, 0.0021981669, 0.0527334549, 0.0172176864, -0.0279377103, 0.002401463, -0.0079781692, 0.042141892, -0.0543558598, -0.0185612142, -0.0230988786, -0.0154694431, -0.0650678426, -0.022299109, 0.003328732, -0.0050535453, -0.0272374451, -0.0089527387, -0.0546087548, 0.0554215349, -0.0060103931, -0.0572401918, 0.0182297509, 0.0257891621, 0.008180052, -0.017654784, -0.0229338948, 0.0166670885, 0.0412343331, -0.016535148, 0.0411588289, -0.0242534243, -0.0613574646, 0.0168545526, -0.0001072006, 0.0216885284, -0.0229426119, 0.0261774007, 0.0407502651, 0.0982453078, 0.068337217, -0.0168123953, -0.0478378758, 0.0307655353, 0.0242569726, 0.012515299, 0.0098262858, 0.0372696221, 0.0042564822, 0.0292255599, -0.0416546427, -0.072280556, 0.0187992919, 0.013875843, -0.0176524092, 0.0641798079, 0.0021632223, -0.03557707, -0.0408515967, -0.0436566733, 0.0006902931, -0.0162806436, -0.0009713955, -0.0485510901, 0.0128672458, -0.0248419084, -0.0831367597, -0.0049506621, -0.0581965521, 0.0161681082, -0.0435017832, 0.0652390569, 0.0126811331, 0.0480306298, 0.0332360491, -0.0416578874, 0.0179740656, 0.0065720049, -0.0245995969, -0.0252709351, 0.0046142428, -0.0019928925, -0.0344221219, 0.01877301, 0.0471622236, 0.0372915193, -0.0149197616, -0.0506462716, -0.0406524464, 0.0029157104, -0.0263077077, -0.0121229421, 0.0470044054, 0.005022801, -0.04054166, -0.0252636392, 0.052257318, -0.0400675088, -0.021854341, 0.049617026, -0.031525977, -0.0537742525, -0.0210203845, 0.0198674928, -0.0013072108, 0.076378271, 0.0525400117, -0.0497151315, -0.0293440316, -0.0093923211, 0.0106881838, 0.033507172, -0.0142463259, 0.0439955071, -0.0563057922, -0.0361967981, 0.0337322317, -0.0483875386, 0.0023680881, 0.0092891473, -0.027871985, 0.028782906, -0.0026921683, 0.0024076798, -0.048845239, 0.0196854342, -0.0235254616, -0.0353926346, -0.0364998057, -5.984029582e-33, 0.0014907089, -0.0134154251, -0.0269044265, -0.0103976, -0.0009522719, 0.0188688319, -0.0129457237, 0.0350604951, -0.0173326731, 0.043065194, -0.0022417875, 0.0205325801, 0.0053663091, 0.0132263191, 0.0151545992, -0.0031594506, 0.0438924059, -0.0393833779, -0.0027408046, 0.019315267, 0.0078354264, 0.0118894, 0.0126556559, -0.1039409116, 0.0752411261, -0.0053376835, 0.0005877254, -0.0089209266, 0.0218992345, 0.0406739227, -0.0128210587, 0.014200123, 0.0471309312, -0.0123912049, 0.0163357574, 0.1022169814, -0.0118739549, -0.0274287816, -0.0127624543, -0.0329714343, -0.0293621588, -0.056187477, 0.0316353105, 0.0182406493, -0.042826131, 0.0179977566, 0.0182098672, -0.0018864038, 0.0414541215, -0.0245625768, -0.0608069859, 0.0226356369, -0.041921448, 0.0142625347, 0.0093538342, 0.0907828808, -0.0298273321, 0.0999269336, -0.0095913447, 0.048422493, 0.0085295998, -0.0056994506, 0.0231887456, -0.0251973532, 0.0225078762, 0.0231722575, 0.0155863594, -0.0016922798, -0.0413271897, 0.019529352, -0.0118268421, 0.0077161151, -0.0028326318, 0.0386460684, 0.0323575102, -0.0095331725, -0.0700145885, 0.0142728565, -0.0628519952, 0.0433974825, 0.0319763646, 0.0117438408, -0.0233668815, -0.0103621697, -0.0244332943, -0.0506832451, -0.0002469354, -0.0105322292, -0.0169213954, -0.0142443944, -0.0524431206, 0.000028146, -0.0181292593, 0.0001038819, -0.0626415089, 0.0368749835, 0.0041626752, 0.0007303206, 0.0085891886, 0.0361586548, -0.0504564531, 0.0185188185, -0.0227975231, 0.0255280286, 0.0465030037, 0.0211703386, 0.0054963483, -0.0024325361, -0.0805664062, -0.0366874076, 0.0301389769, 0.0310424939, -0.0298254509, 0.0711964443, 0.0465481803, 0.0318071581, 0.0244056005, 0.0183337871, 0.020837117, -0.0217541214, 0.0370227136, -0.0162861254, -0.0593535453, 0.0454404801, -0.012538, -0.0320259668, -0.0172078945, 0.0413033739, -0.0077113016, -0.0703723282, 0.0088936295, -0.0709505156, 2.674e-7, 0.0705325976, 0.0660432503, -0.0374858715, -0.0108180521, 0.0171319898, 0.0480833501, -0.0076840231, 0.0156897437, -0.0122145275, -0.0470158756, 0.0218340177, 0.0043695252, 0.0024068556, 0.0091508431, -0.0448976606, -0.0150420358, -0.0399353057, 0.0356907696, -0.0231477749, 0.0186464321, 0.0147875259, 0.0500626899, 0.0413510166, 0.0079846317, -0.0438684449, 0.051856786, 0.052207794, -0.0375798754, -0.022227155, 0.0281095989, 0.0039724512, -0.0019330139, -0.0222431775, 0.0334411934, -0.0475502275, -0.0398638919, -0.0418418907, 0.0792733356, 0.0100874146, 0.0249131192, 0.0347306766, -0.0367281474, -0.0148821613, -0.0138026997, 0.0148897516, -0.0782235563, -0.0600434206, -0.0268337671, -0.0258972235, 0.026023848, 0.0680401921, 0.0061242944, -0.0259265397, 0.0112214657, 0.0136291627, 0.0005200587, -0.01657754, -0.0411628895, 0.0149180163, -0.0215503462, -0.0214751605, -0.0363578051, 0.0181595534, 0.0137296477, 0.0133245904, -0.0170560498, 0.0957930833, 1.688798296e-34, 0.0471229777, 0.008316379, -0.0384259149, -0.0428432077, 0.0229362007, 0.0049977284, 0.0060757212, 0.023931291, 0.0293307472, -0.0090749022, 0.0420375913 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.06627v3
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.06627v3
Dissociating language and thought in large language models
2023-01-16T22:41:19
2024-03-23T19:52:33
Kyle Mahowald, Anna A. Ivanova, Idan A. Blank, Nancy Kanwisher, Joshua B. Tenenbaum, Evelina Fedorenko
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI
Large Language Models (LLMs) have come closest among all models to date to mastering human language, yet opinions about their linguistic and cognitive capabilities remain split. Here, we evaluate LLMs using a distinction between formal linguistic competence -- knowledge of linguistic rules and patterns -- and functional linguistic competence -- understanding and using language in the world. We ground this distinction in human neuroscience, which has shown that formal and functional competence rely on different neural mechanisms. Although LLMs are surprisingly good at formal competence, their performance on functional competence tasks remains spotty and often requires specialized fine-tuning and/or coupling with external modules. We posit that models that use language in human-like ways would need to master both of these competence types, which, in turn, could require the emergence of mechanisms specialized for formal linguistic competence, distinct from functional competence.
[ 0.045372624, 0.0439332873, -0.0482535735, 0.0334965996, -0.0074056666, 0.0339140184, 0.0008487366, 0.0047708903, 0.0032457039, -0.0199985839, -0.0595598929, -0.0372634381, -0.0041572046, 0.0728568733, 0.0759759173, -0.0286813062, 0.0374478549, -0.062216498, 0.0290550347, -0.0202747397, -0.0130148167, -0.0038111671, 0.0167549923, -0.0030099589, 0.0151823424, -0.0020656071, 0.0145699652, -0.0454538129, -0.0295553803, 0.0100163044, -0.0201002862, 0.0228765458, 0.0266866907, 0.0203643236, 0.0000016617, -0.0517176352, 0.0975095332, -0.0134722833, -0.0083695166, 0.0271297377, 0.0338009372, -0.0026867951, -0.0034773757, -0.0243788436, -0.0388992541, -0.0018967199, 0.0435921922, 0.0394584499, -0.0105347158, 0.0288333278, 0.0013404095, -0.017306203, 0.054102432, -0.0415670052, -0.0233434141, -0.0178355873, 0.0439995825, 0.0138573572, 0.0280586462, -0.0082192924, -0.0477794968, 0.0342244878, 0.0578358993, 0.0061833034, -0.0070421305, 0.0350978002, 0.0222982243, -0.0420412682, 0.0267402492, 0.0222031008, 0.0135925766, -0.0364209078, -0.0019289993, 0.0272065438, 0.0169824809, 0.0013821177, -0.0518720038, 0.0309833474, 0.0471434556, 0.0301027689, 0.03561721, -0.0488662384, 0.0569989122, 0.0261075683, -0.0115189785, 0.0631907582, 0.0009619615, -0.0143469237, -0.0134635391, 0.0039095152, -0.0344006233, -0.06591665, -0.0036693602, 0.0307065584, -0.0190436635, 0.0236643255, -0.0097451648, 0.0356583744, 0.0210527591, -0.0517317355, 0.0167847965, 0.018050177, -0.0072619412, 0.0301176235, -0.024383856, 0.0322851427, -0.0447832458, 0.0637890249, -0.0273509603, -0.0016600364, -0.0439687222, -0.0522307903, 0.0127532352, 0.0108230123, -0.062454395, -0.0362394415, 0.0072224671, 0.0119490521, -0.0051690196, -0.0319425762, -0.0173052847, 0.0235881787, -0.0092716757, -0.0170147456, -0.0578123555, 0.0002878715, -0.0065754917, 0.0293732639, 0.0019873844, -0.047734037, -0.0015003459, -0.0032627033, -0.0313339345, -0.0444658995, -0.0043449644, 0.0420343503, -0.0066041113, -0.017376272, 0.0030992469, 0.0276736282, -0.0208086129, -0.0652128085, 0.0149418199, -0.0410779566, -0.0039448468, 0.0211589541, -0.0172098409, -0.0567114316, 0.0042719981, -0.0264402274, -0.0496967584, 0.0163316913, -0.0153970597, 0.0266079251, 0.0471232273, 0.0020695289, 0.0138855483, 0.0292304251, 0.039696034, -0.0318410024, -0.0357668102, 0.0006954168, -0.0330382586, 0.046007067, -0.0115822358, -0.0331457853, -0.0747701973, -0.0078295497, 0.012303195, 0.0403856151, 0.0853341371, 0.0487850681, -0.0288715623, -0.0115134064, 0.0609659292, 0.0586032644, -0.0005016651, 0.0218888782, 0.0748679712, -0.0112243453, 0.0551823787, 0.0188461859, -0.0746918693, 0.0226157159, -0.0206870195, -0.0098859202, -0.0211586468, 0.0100698983, -0.0305658821, -0.0063584172, -0.0012856214, 0.0177551582, 0.0189097524, 0.0320742019, 0.0312364418, 0.0125379572, 0.0165662877, 0.0117809735, 0.0416918173, 0.0187685173, 0.0328754745, -0.0616967268, 0.0281837527, 0.0301559158, 0.0099423379, 0.0032273422, 0.0091082612, 0.0241077375, 0.0013023587, 0.1262019128, 0.0561364777, 0.0119719924, 0.0099799884, -0.0082351994, 0.041075591, -0.0302775148, 0.0041746162, 0.0016514994, -0.0394489355, -0.0257828292, -0.0201723073, 0.0040896283, -0.0570801944, 0.0324804187, -0.0566970892, -0.0021546632, -0.0411360972, -0.0134144071, 0.0261598174, -0.0326258391, -0.0376997292, 0.0340070575, -0.0011731817, -0.0326612778, -0.0044061677, 0.0152702974, -0.0481868573, 0.0044512078, 0.0300371703, 0.0282444768, -0.0284086131, 0.0422185622, 0.0555308722, -0.0285302904, 0.0348762088, -0.0622241944, 0.0800770223, -0.0433878116, 0.009495046, -0.0379121341, 0.0495053157, -0.0169232823, 0.0592030548, 0.0096133016, 0.0073418166, -0.0084201824, -0.0238669962, -0.0291834213, -0.0487328731, -0.0496832095, 0.0292714089, -0.0013820105, 0.0094532045, -0.0129175633, -0.0003563665, -0.0340092927, -0.0193662308, -0.0495212153, -0.0105432384, 0.0405202173, -0.0047803558, 0.0273219161, -0.0455488823, -0.0181092583, 0.0239576008, -0.0153282536, 0.0135290558, 0.0141334878, 0.0320432261, 0.0278415754, -0.002873373, -0.0647620931, -0.0336717851, -0.0191780776, -0.0229092855, 0.0355582125, 0.0185137335, -0.0057218168, -0.0259618796, 0.0545424484, -0.040431764, 0.0119402865, -0.001700719, -0.0554869212, 0.0227391049, -0.001754046, 0.0262873042, 0.0705886111, -0.0093678618, 0.0299590286, 0.0368242078, -0.0244851857, -0.0150348116, -0.0136995269, -0.0124879414, 0.0130014103, -0.0871189162, -0.0009627666, -0.0304080844, 0.0777007267, 0.0214232001, -0.0093373088, -0.0141888661, 0.0228337143, -0.0263410173, -0.074298352, -0.0193924271, -0.0140701281, -0.0476317368, 0.04996261, -0.0666991621, -0.0242832247, 0.0349305421, 0.007886162, -0.0197470039, 0.0064650406, 0.0035101513, 0.0015413605, 0.0663082451, 0.055387035, 0.0162339974, 0.0071337419, -0.0503589958, -0.0440490469, -0.0120675135, -0.0239310842, -0.0225117989, 0.0064556636, -0.0516531132, -0.0078606512, 0.0247035604, -0.0183647033, -0.0192086231, 0.0475726724, -0.0426563025, 0.0685253143, 0.0127018513, -0.0236384328, -0.0398384407, -0.0344574526, 0.0592617616, 0.0106874984, -0.0123497713, -0.0017886513, -0.0305572059, -0.0040828343, 0.0404412411, 0.056510631, 0.0413179658, -0.0441343859, 0.0322951749, 0.0372516178, -0.027503226, 0.0534181744, -0.0214835871, 0.0350963846, 0.0433225296, -0.0026543748, -0.0379677005, 0.0210876297, 0.0497387871, -0.0563380532, -0.0368637368, 0.1063223332, 0.0138740148, -0.0087424526, 0.0261791255, -0.0232848655, -0.0083603123, 0.0498805903, 0.0179719198, -0.0291758664, 0.0127438512, 0.0075058695, -0.054337617, -0.0317712836, -0.0329495706, 0.0017283573, -0.081549257, 0.0100797331, 0.0107038524, -0.050504256, 0.0053184442, 0.005142183, 0.0197952334, 0.0342143551, 0.057659395, 0.0176437553, 0.0170978941, -0.0199139919, -0.0112991175, 0.0096485643, -0.0661463588, 0.0547730066, -0.0413279124, 0.1120119393, 0.0305641964, 0.0222853906, -0.0381691046, -0.0329829864, 0.0544569232, 0.016528707, 0.0175243746, 0.0057857456, 0.0167231765, 0.0456916951, -0.0166883729, -0.0638997629, 0.0154085737, -0.0203069542, -0.0508487821, -0.0603851192, 0.0915700719, -0.0107634906, -0.0383790657, 0.0369008482, 0.0150830774, -0.0560978055, 0.0533077829, 0.0466488525, -0.0816254914, -0.0202591065, -0.0078314086, -0.0395057499, -0.0052804681, -0.0848428607, 0.0154943988, 0.063820824, -0.0244021155, -0.0464816727, -0.0086900024, 0.0448675714, 0.0037682331, 0.0322755389, -0.0099922549, 0.0273047611, -0.080792062, 0.0089862505, 0.0416892841, -0.0341428556, -0.0008928932, -0.060489703, -0.0328771248, 0.0020416894, -0.0587253757, -0.0178941526, 0.0125466688, -0.0303999986, -0.0897593275, 0.0390924215, 0.0045179804, 0.029584894, 0.0002759682, -0.0069707925, -0.0841174498, 0.010896625, 0.0268346295, -0.0645227805, 0.0671728998, -0.0344339013, -0.0040057274, 0.0196468011, 0.0446887687, 0.0043066973, 0.0084307902, 0.043542549, 0.0392016098, 0.0357921273, 0.0223844666, 0.0328087993, 0.0047111278, 0.0304171536, 0.0027095762, -0.0157843847, -0.0598521642, -0.0508915409, -0.0131620178, 0.0037857483, -0.0148223983, -0.0264684334, 0.0636726692, 0.0705077797, 0.0130378641, -0.0558199622, 0.0285119284, 0.0503320545, 0.0024824294, -0.035734769, -0.021763593, -0.0035261568, 0.0025504497, 0.0360212587, 0.017407693, 0.0366853923, -0.079995364, 0.0138735818, 0.0259137563, 0.0454108976, -0.0157224033, -0.0046497416, -0.0310115013, -0.0167455301, -0.0637369454, -0.0869037732, 0.0455811881, 0.0110292099, 0.0533058532, -0.029998092, 0.0371625312, -0.0490175523, 0.0035602262, -0.012407342, -0.0162784122, -0.015557277, -0.0353560783, 0.0350128338, 0.0383094698, -0.0057927845, -0.0341586471, 0.0189209934, 0.013376019, 0.0455093868, -0.0205106363, 0.008790181, 0.0099622868, -0.0471014977, 0.0017396369, -0.0001566333, -0.04668108, 0.0553819761, -0.0417144559, -0.0811335817, -0.0156028252, 0.0385336801, 0.0048082508, -0.038916342, -0.0050095981, 0.0164969005, -0.0095901666, -0.0270399954, -0.0192844328, 0.0005874543, 0.0725780353, -0.0027426202, -0.0312742963, -5.770388627e-33, -0.0198126603, -0.0195752606, 0.0160199627, 0.0200117808, -0.0249437355, -0.0295822173, -0.059122242, 0.0386812054, -0.023133643, 0.0311139077, 0.0028162098, 0.0204656795, -0.0010722134, 0.0180027392, 0.0364157595, 0.008803945, -0.0137122218, -0.0185168125, 0.0231587905, -0.0040138997, 0.0425701328, 0.0093005281, 0.0638349727, -0.0204430185, 0.0257431474, 0.0192751288, 0.0082039582, 0.0344677009, -0.0482630134, 0.0402596481, -0.049648162, 0.0113311773, 0.0540127754, 0.0058706207, -0.0225881021, 0.0052421982, -0.0155696338, -0.0107834721, 0.1026352346, -0.0063407603, -0.029087184, -0.0402720906, 0.0739218891, -0.0551533513, -0.0170431789, 0.0080814017, 0.0067564598, -0.0424903221, 0.010034061, 0.0392875411, -0.0879238024, -0.0171756279, 0.0067920918, -0.0002335914, -0.041052524, -0.0582185462, -0.0514434464, -0.0327627063, -0.0521295816, 0.0008112041, -0.0411121659, 0.0502506196, 0.0526452437, 0.0163657814, 0.0546463169, 0.0652581677, 0.0547515228, 0.0178105086, -0.0260397978, -0.0030303462, 0.0762798041, 0.0365048908, 0.0086990455, -0.0038143122, 0.0351017937, -0.0253705345, -0.0197771434, -0.0820078403, 0.0086076129, 0.0513101183, 0.0347315408, -0.0000657588, 0.0401828066, -0.0160377603, -0.0318068266, 0.0006253404, -0.0224047676, -0.0214008242, 0.0147913732, -0.0274997391, 0.0387679115, -0.0399272107, 0.0209090691, -0.0476246253, -0.0048265266, -0.0042555765, -0.0115674138, 0.0433884636, 0.0166779049, 0.0229692627, -0.0652236119, -0.0657196492, -0.0128805414, 0.0234688278, 0.0005042088, 0.0244476721, 0.0141284941, 0.027439978, -0.0040441528, -0.0016303479, -0.0648594126, -0.0198241435, 0.0473734215, 0.0036658177, 0.0376776047, -0.0057026544, -0.0351078548, -0.0322408825, -0.0203577802, -0.0342036672, -0.0426192395, 0.0611024089, -0.0223335475, 0.0191081204, -0.032251291, -0.016571546, -0.058727771, 0.0119783012, 0.0364372134, -0.0249230769, -0.0077388976, -0.0048963255, 2.535e-7, 0.045457799, 0.0308719724, -0.0026747505, 0.0464655012, 0.0612378828, -0.0215284042, -0.0493186004, 0.0021015911, 0.0300602987, -0.0460977629, -0.0331107527, 0.0647642687, 0.0400877222, 0.0042790305, -0.0415169932, -0.0034530535, -0.0415538624, 0.0019629705, -0.0282634869, -0.0270635504, -0.0070043183, 0.0693426877, 0.0293512512, -0.0476960205, -0.0023508405, -0.0687469169, 0.0746370107, -0.032909967, 0.01457961, 0.0084014731, -0.0178850219, 0.0011048975, 0.0229187962, 0.0455049016, 0.0248472281, 0.0476941392, -0.0154557042, 0.0775179937, 0.0017710895, 0.0419299342, 0.0074164388, -0.0063413619, -0.0112953475, -0.048904974, 0.0441814847, -0.0852859542, -0.0779183283, 0.0246097017, 0.0190096516, -0.0016502236, 0.0111820875, -0.0273283683, -0.0232120063, 0.0056855166, 0.0285477173, -0.0087174317, 0.0068871127, -0.0224874206, -0.0232967995, 0.0146342935, -0.0883880034, -0.0404270254, -0.0332526863, -0.0139949992, 0.0332996324, -0.0421764031, 0.0141853271, 2.076680207e-34, 0.014404241, 0.0190166514, 0.0382103734, 0.0269638598, 0.052245792, -0.004952475, -0.0052651381, 0.0244322233, 0.0031924369, -0.0929821357, -0.0148650957 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.06617v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.06617v1
ClassBases at CASE-2022 Multilingual Protest Event Detection Tasks: Multilingual Protest News Detection and Automatically Replicating Manually Created Event Datasets
2023-01-16T21:41:03
2023-01-16T21:41:03
Peratham Wiriyathammabhum
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG, cs.SI
In this report, we describe our ClassBases submissions to a shared task on multilingual protest event detection. For the multilingual protest news detection, we participated in subtask-1, subtask-2, and subtask-4, which are document classification, sentence classification, and token classification. In subtask-1, we compare XLM-RoBERTa-base, mLUKE-base, and XLM-RoBERTa-large on finetuning in a sequential classification setting. We always use a combination of the training data from every language provided to train our multilingual models. We found that larger models seem to work better and entity knowledge helps but at a non-negligible cost. For subtask-2, we only submitted an mLUKE-base system for sentence classification. For subtask-4, we only submitted an XLM-RoBERTa-base for token classification system for sequence labeling. For automatically replicating manually created event datasets, we participated in COVID-related protest events from the New York Times news corpus. We created a system to process the crawled data into a dataset of protest events.
[ 0.0154364519, 0.056929417, -0.0066573378, 0.051313363, -0.0275770854, 0.0518265739, 0.0166732259, 0.0062667248, 0.0098869568, -0.0501942448, 0.0170572475, -0.0221933629, -0.0614763908, 0.0236755665, -0.0147451004, -0.0692401007, 0.0378479622, -0.0002858986, 0.0268579684, 0.0051478031, 0.0095024817, 0.0421511084, 0.0032129658, 0.0300977118, -0.0413647555, 0.0087867351, -0.0250764284, -0.0104197646, 0.0530850068, -0.0092086662, 0.0507032387, 0.0484889969, 0.0748138279, 0.0689071193, 0.0000018491, -0.0601254627, -0.016823642, -0.0071905837, -0.0241142362, -0.0469885394, 0.0197829064, -0.0775604844, -0.0052181883, 0.013542504, -0.0203096792, -0.0389397778, 0.0010021004, 0.0749492794, 0.0228510723, 0.0949180797, -0.0197374355, -0.0470344685, 0.0270779692, -0.0081794765, -0.0239473265, -0.020726135, 0.0230197478, -0.0084209256, 0.0123689799, -0.0087836282, 0.03119996, 0.0037688308, 0.0016039817, -0.0033366024, -0.0790383294, 0.0060935859, -0.0490671173, -0.0273045469, 0.015570946, 0.0174468551, -0.0216643177, -0.0481521748, 0.0464774966, 0.0315730684, 0.0251205247, -0.0431153327, -0.0341747068, 0.0191551726, -0.0339039341, 0.0409864485, 0.0605027936, -0.0013709522, 0.0166972373, 0.0652199835, 0.0101186223, -0.0092314454, -0.0234037377, -0.020399373, -0.005926379, 0.0266107135, 0.0018601523, -0.0185083095, 0.0432655811, -0.001859445, -0.0444649383, -0.0022109279, -0.0329188854, -0.0361988358, 0.0251651537, -0.0921133906, -0.0229028128, 0.033693336, 0.0059805624, 0.0566760041, 0.0176583771, -0.0122192819, -0.0075209341, 0.0396919176, -0.0172685478, -0.0095475093, -0.0470692068, 0.0450724885, -0.0311601367, 0.033430893, -0.0525366068, 0.0026584002, -0.0377040356, -0.0104902545, 0.0320177302, 0.0053149685, -0.0410868227, -0.0304532498, -0.021975901, 0.0013529151, 0.0032139015, 0.0436120182, -0.0350814648, 0.0291742217, -0.0140463356, -0.0676473826, 0.005183808, 0.0147093106, 0.0073637543, 0.0108619332, -0.0071955626, 0.029371405, -0.0257805474, -0.0212553386, -0.07210242, -0.0107094673, 0.0114535186, -0.0880965739, -0.0167624019, -0.0878779665, 0.0403842069, -0.0089626946, 0.0136100883, 0.002079518, 0.0064467825, -0.001552407, 0.0064028078, 0.0450497083, 0.0025683977, 0.0007407978, 0.0494116172, 0.0065038819, -0.0040053176, 0.1122250482, 0.0179220606, 0.0184711628, 0.0773525015, -0.0186383761, -0.0193280187, 0.0321574099, -0.0023272091, 0.0056020129, 0.01163984, -0.0106310826, -0.0183544103, 0.0213179812, 0.0330941528, -0.0148459664, -0.0195828322, -0.0155987302, 0.0236254595, 0.0333503708, -0.0330315158, -0.0396230146, 0.0210636389, -0.0088311564, -0.0355758853, 0.0161882676, 0.0149498433, -0.0352693945, -0.0097767636, 0.0002214737, -0.0220462587, 0.0568814501, -0.0379430614, -0.0491250306, -0.0134117184, -0.0052643851, -0.0077920635, -0.0072681555, 0.0619995147, -0.0093469201, -0.0083292928, 0.0092572849, 0.030355135, -0.0598098598, 0.0200802255, -0.0563874952, 0.0218447316, 0.043943096, -0.0054610609, -0.0494215339, -0.0618036762, -0.0530480146, 0.0705335662, 0.0688839108, 0.0549388342, -0.0347195566, 0.0057752682, -0.056535922, -0.0236152429, 0.032586582, 0.0096074194, 0.0294412728, -0.0034806782, 0.0301371124, 0.0065067075, -0.0188429076, -0.0765934587, 0.0352701582, -0.0125168543, -0.0188773256, -0.0284684487, 0.024906965, 0.0488672592, 0.0548183359, -0.0017770241, -0.0424277261, 0.0588144921, -0.0552432537, -0.0129133118, 0.0046832976, 0.0363366082, -0.0516785383, 0.037787322, -0.0176709592, -0.0306748431, 0.0468053706, -0.0666368678, -0.0194071382, 0.0480416082, 0.0337732434, 0.0034089847, -0.0497688949, 0.0120963072, -0.0296218228, 0.0193238202, -0.0228616446, 0.0493983328, 0.0028557717, 0.0227106065, -0.0168341566, -0.0499241278, 0.0624331608, -0.0525268875, -0.0414302684, 0.0682377145, 0.0095873652, 0.0144030992, 0.0420950055, -0.0123925461, -0.0507954434, -0.0065959278, -0.0562054962, 0.0106662624, -0.0490211807, 0.051995635, 0.0037435414, 0.0272096042, -0.0371737964, -0.0175622702, -0.008933085, -0.0516520366, 0.0154327182, 0.013899684, 0.0023026138, 0.0001046731, 0.0032488063, -0.0132960044, -0.0091593396, -0.0258617196, 0.0255979095, -0.0120140743, -0.0879010707, -0.0352198966, -0.0233165938, -0.0134984944, 0.0079306876, -0.0234539732, -0.04510694, 0.0157739893, 0.005994739, 0.0488675237, 0.0609410927, 0.0135795362, 0.0577216968, -0.0019466117, 0.0217216201, -0.0388690419, 0.0152003858, -0.0236217063, 0.0210100356, -0.0657741055, -0.0243851952, 0.0058200769, 0.0587441698, -0.0341426097, 0.0041600224, -0.0377117954, -0.0495889038, -0.0240225419, -0.040604353, -0.0302707646, -0.0267701, -0.018493915, 0.0061305766, -0.0074324543, -0.0295674335, 0.0400642864, 0.0135835372, 0.025120236, -0.0786845759, -0.0407753922, -0.0302723777, 0.0612896048, 0.0025226164, 0.0220502932, -0.0463853516, -0.0444691181, 0.0129609574, -0.0177612416, -0.0042584767, -0.0414522998, 0.0030969805, -0.0150072156, 0.0213241521, -0.0177183021, -0.0280729178, -0.0309135336, -0.0074025937, -0.0107299471, 0.0137370126, -0.0231486, 0.0301626567, -0.0655576065, 0.0469401218, -0.0069023133, 0.0529271923, 0.0181305502, 0.0074058189, 0.0171892829, 0.0501315184, -0.0018879421, 0.0212582462, -0.0135284439, -0.0312756114, 0.0000307384, 0.0244183, 0.063316673, 0.000064068, 0.0095571615, -0.0184136797, 0.0481090806, -0.0468851551, -0.0204105489, -0.0419267565, 0.008472221, -0.064468801, 0.0201055091, 0.0781193748, 0.0269227773, -0.0475549214, -0.0045671389, -0.0028891093, 0.0241504498, 0.0318875946, 0.0135530764, -0.0508741885, 0.0065269903, 0.0325519554, 0.0074828691, -0.03240747, -0.0166635253, 0.001717136, -0.0546435602, 0.0179132167, -0.0072341044, -0.08083231, -0.048901435, -0.0644031167, 0.0227989145, -0.0261454824, -0.0186209995, -0.040351484, 0.0169451255, -0.0159581322, 0.051634226, -0.0603628978, -0.109126091, -0.0313690528, -0.0383908041, 0.0083778268, 0.0159866326, 0.0394032225, 0.0024124731, 0.005159732, 0.064725481, -0.0539443493, -0.0169870369, -0.0378772952, 0.0601561926, -0.0311127137, -0.0160739813, 0.013398475, 0.0533744618, -0.0174726043, -0.0100411503, -0.0057668029, 0.084191829, -0.0110877659, -0.0190283209, -0.0221817996, -0.0100121908, 0.0271336772, 0.0204593781, 0.0106976861, 0.0039139232, 0.0017401291, -0.0084134405, 0.0285244975, -0.0802651495, 0.0431718528, 0.0214025192, -0.0708911493, -0.1012282968, -0.0137465522, -0.0499335416, 0.0209503006, 0.0546162985, -0.0321859382, 0.0095129544, 0.0012031021, 0.0104616489, -0.0456562229, 0.0448460951, 0.0183321424, 0.0196661409, -0.0405250192, -0.0493688397, 0.0061670793, 0.0470131598, -0.0292289127, 0.0003880778, -0.0558666736, -0.0537833758, 0.0149307987, -0.0232013743, 0.0187924244, 0.0223636627, -0.0014886607, -0.0115720723, 0.0278611276, 0.0506869555, -0.0131606702, -0.0241318531, 0.0355686434, -0.0217373054, -0.0220414978, 0.0427679159, 0.0035021135, 0.0535850972, 0.0074730348, 0.0499720797, -0.0635092929, 0.0219823383, -0.0136678703, 0.0284777246, 0.0248677153, -0.0145090297, -0.0953023136, -0.0744476616, 0.0005058952, 0.0036968412, -0.0293270797, -0.0031336143, -0.0129242027, 0.0130834375, 0.00032976, -0.0435844697, 0.079916507, -0.0301998761, -0.0090684379, -0.0551674366, 0.0557170138, 0.0537616089, 0.0497402288, -0.0121675748, 0.0012555466, -0.0294106733, 0.0389631279, 0.012560403, -0.0119612217, -0.0416303985, 0.0052286154, 0.0187460482, 0.0466197357, 0.0219122227, -0.0095897801, -0.0091228802, 0.0297321025, -0.0291600712, 0.0229545981, 0.0513477437, -0.0380336232, 0.0485792086, -0.0106831538, -0.0565834194, -0.0015024978, 0.0275066346, -0.0139863566, -0.0213239174, 0.0369416811, 0.0236521121, -0.03920893, 0.0244915579, 0.0627125576, -0.0212248527, 0.0551257618, 0.0518837497, -0.039156016, -0.0353535973, -0.0263096225, 0.0760901123, 0.0081987027, -0.0097062215, -0.0118854642, -0.0271889362, -0.0100649269, 0.0289930329, -0.0327048488, -0.0246834252, 0.0051628686, 0.0152379237, 0.0874688029, 0.010334407, 0.0154322851, -0.038357351, 0.0281200856, -0.0026616261, -0.0465480685, 0.0509781577, -5.87713784e-33, 0.0010024696, -0.0268699769, -0.0154576376, 0.0338105336, -0.0113139497, 0.0248993747, 0.0120685585, -0.0174441542, 0.0079160286, 0.0259910114, 0.0188712068, 0.0137295248, 0.0366841517, 0.0068003954, 0.0265362188, -0.0369479023, 0.056483537, 0.0086104777, -0.0086231045, 0.0295906737, 0.0481832847, 0.0486287028, 0.0838086531, -0.0793416575, 0.0320446491, 0.0094991541, 0.0164792538, -0.0219214447, 0.0402792096, 0.0755362883, -0.0114771398, 0.0750599802, 0.0473582558, -0.0416293591, 0.0099027939, 0.035212405, -0.067058824, -0.0062113986, 0.0065027, 0.0499673039, 0.0176130794, -0.0394035392, -0.0011843188, -0.0053585405, -0.0085449591, 0.0236536395, 0.0326123834, -0.0373203978, 0.0077511026, -0.0364354439, -0.074750118, 0.0402035229, -0.0200745165, 0.0030642436, 0.0269109812, 0.0231533498, 0.0052829459, 0.084321551, -0.0425507985, 0.0282169841, -0.0377300605, 0.0155962808, 0.0270629823, -0.0097001269, -0.0158989225, 0.0342117809, -0.0102454433, 0.0107596321, -0.0035826352, 0.0369032659, 0.0186948571, 0.0301857721, 0.0179795735, 0.1052669659, 0.0293216091, -0.0521789305, -0.0938840881, 0.0408505015, 0.0598598607, 0.0055153389, 0.0338439457, -0.0156377479, -0.0236647129, -0.0048870887, -0.0151165826, -0.0342823118, -0.0058662677, 0.0054336148, 0.0062498678, 0.0154412556, 0.0034866622, 0.0304503869, 0.0229889639, 0.0011733449, -0.0551388301, 0.0330446251, 0.006602433, 0.008156688, 0.0141683389, 0.0442195423, -0.081237413, -0.0628476813, 0.0113986293, -0.0085678613, 0.0355433561, -0.0261580013, 0.0952280387, 0.0148213981, -0.0446413234, 0.038784869, 0.0044708541, 0.0229560491, 0.0147000644, 0.0417517424, 0.0054606125, -0.0163737368, 0.0129034203, 0.0339052193, 0.0535797179, 0.0001128506, 0.0316889957, -0.0287946835, -0.0461109206, 0.0385650694, -0.0235414561, -0.000969033, -0.0149781685, 0.0527562611, 0.0011232785, -0.0512455106, 0.0026423463, -0.007079015, 2.641e-7, 0.0374007784, 0.024810357, 0.0127120167, -0.0301729161, -0.0166991185, 0.0080889929, -0.0256207287, 0.0537368432, -0.0266426541, 0.0038713249, -0.0170535333, 0.0220452417, 0.0605188049, 0.0640563816, -0.1011666954, -0.0302582718, -0.0155261112, 0.0287801046, -0.0956578478, 0.0537900887, 0.0065412736, 0.0882554427, 0.0204820912, -0.0091886548, -0.0146880932, -0.0051580635, 0.0063698832, -0.032202471, -0.0830405951, 0.0105225202, 0.0270433277, -0.0006537731, -0.0246306602, 0.0333981439, -0.0237814225, 0.0180237498, 0.039903786, 0.0119081326, 0.0209227726, 0.0593670607, -0.0158802215, -0.0350870229, -0.0261064786, -0.038199693, 0.0513491631, -0.010542986, -0.0345996022, -0.0030222356, -0.0256949011, -0.022507444, 0.0367471986, -0.0313050821, -0.0424015075, 0.0281617902, 0.0409844927, -0.0209853258, -0.0002290802, -0.0590172745, 0.0427181311, 0.0401614644, -0.0206105541, -0.0464942232, 0.0210535023, -0.0227397047, 0.0223409552, -0.0070045441, 0.0172462557, 2.313784305e-34, 0.0514183789, 0.0261821449, -0.0398457646, -0.0066841706, 0.0034025055, -0.0314865746, -0.049168963, -0.0133161247, -0.0097715538, -0.0462869145, 0.006179559 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.06606v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.06606v1
PromptShots at the FinNLP-2022 ERAI Tasks: Pairwise Comparison and Unsupervised Ranking
2023-01-16T20:54:27
2023-01-16T20:54:27
Peratham Wiriyathammabhum
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG, cs.SI
This report describes our PromptShots submissions to a shared task on Evaluating the Rationales of Amateur Investors (ERAI). We participated in both pairwise comparison and unsupervised ranking tasks. For pairwise comparison, we employed instruction-based models based on T5-small and OpenAI InstructGPT language models. Surprisingly, we observed OpenAI InstructGPT language model few-shot trained on Chinese data works best in our submissions, ranking 3rd on the maximal loss (ML) pairwise accuracy. This model works better than training on the Google translated English data by a large margin, where the English few-shot trained InstructGPT model even performs worse than an instruction-based T5-small model finetuned on the English data. However, all instruction-based submissions do not perform well on the maximal potential profit (MPP) pairwise accuracy where there are more data and learning signals. The Chinese few-shot trained InstructGPT model still performs best in our setting. For unsupervised ranking, we utilized many language models, including many financial-specific ones, and Bayesian lexicons unsupervised-learned on both Chinese and English words using a method-of-moments estimator. All our submissions rank best in the MPP ranking, from 1st to 3rd. However, they all do not perform well for ML scoring. Therefore, both MPP and ML scores need different treatments since we treated MPP and ML using the same formula. Our only difference is the treatment of market sentiment lexicons.
[ -0.0092530223, 0.0844466239, -0.0049513136, 0.0134748649, 0.0149083622, -0.0027458335, 0.0831334889, 0.0268816445, 0.0057150028, -0.0008967426, -0.0359569825, -0.0048339362, 0.0163727347, 0.031321913, 0.028122548, -0.0349725634, 0.0161163993, -0.0135539714, 0.0557828322, -0.028114086, 0.0076780794, -0.0287514515, 0.0121949371, 0.0358595364, 0.0415699929, -0.0088652587, -0.0066642645, -0.012743663, 0.0490611531, -0.0318872146, -0.0136239445, 0.008750705, -0.0126854992, 0.0535998642, 0.0000023811, -0.0499805361, -0.0191972945, -0.0115041332, -0.0013674462, 0.0125024291, 0.0315595828, 0.0336526707, 0.0222005956, -0.0124379126, -0.0625830963, 0.0043114093, 0.0707464144, 0.0646585599, 0.0431815125, 0.0667107403, 0.0022799186, -0.016225541, 0.0067739803, -0.0850514024, 0.0033132036, -0.0633838102, 0.0182457119, -0.0170968641, -0.0502445661, 0.0350910164, -0.0225771666, 0.0129190125, -0.0110736173, 0.0331898816, 0.0439793728, 0.0199713297, 0.0109206345, -0.0001992327, -0.0142396726, 0.0310814437, 0.0375814661, 0.0279574599, -0.0153608965, -0.0305755679, 0.0041599819, 0.0521591827, -0.0342987217, 0.036075104, 0.012636858, 0.0230288543, 0.0317826383, 0.0512742363, -0.0019402539, 0.0230156127, -0.0209914967, 0.0485728942, -0.0342870429, -0.0249262247, 0.0525329784, 0.0159268938, -0.0358340777, -0.0214575417, -0.0073850034, -0.0320967622, 0.0403473675, 0.0018379812, 0.0596003532, -0.0044826283, -0.0169671159, -0.0816498846, 0.004716821, 0.0267562084, 0.0088475784, 0.0239684265, -0.0517573021, 0.0559316538, 0.0572077297, -0.004120369, -0.0285872184, 0.0373101644, -0.0684146807, 0.0076950938, -0.0011697232, 0.0833050311, -0.011856325, -0.0334496945, -0.130074501, -0.0249624494, -0.0476950258, 0.0156832114, 0.0231051687, -0.0298886281, -0.0239863414, 0.0142496089, -0.0472808704, -0.0119300615, -0.0586298518, 0.0206086673, -0.0064600375, -0.0256258938, 0.0239137188, 0.0249625966, -0.032645531, -0.0257946793, 0.0218725, 0.031333629, 0.0367938131, -0.0452362075, -0.0413910709, -0.031103909, -0.0138880471, -0.0070686159, -0.0364503376, -0.0456471182, -0.0085965442, -0.0491871163, 0.0180677902, -0.0173063669, 0.0112768235, -0.0228504669, -0.0329682678, 0.0964227989, 0.026878912, -0.0359658636, 0.0084464569, -0.0199535135, 0.0002209678, 0.0731229037, -0.02976555, 0.0519921444, 0.0638502538, 0.0059609828, -0.0207002163, 0.0354809947, 0.0200594347, -0.0101039996, -0.0466401279, 0.0134462714, 0.0041230493, -0.0051665851, 0.028707847, 0.00768595, -0.0205450561, 0.0230505895, 0.0758728907, 0.0490238816, 0.0599332787, -0.0106868651, -0.0179963578, -0.0083141513, -0.0073671401, -0.0338114277, 0.0189017225, 0.0015483855, -0.043860957, 0.0356199108, 0.0411742292, -0.009510438, -0.0234158095, -0.0422997922, 0.0229951106, -0.0082740327, -0.0431478918, 0.0217308644, 0.0304865278, -0.0644796267, -0.0235882476, -0.00496771, 0.0181415789, -0.0083257202, -0.0190900285, -0.0310771763, 0.0170559753, 0.0543205924, -0.0182482246, 0.0361291729, 0.0451652892, -0.0138898017, -0.0672831759, 0.0223352164, 0.0285586827, -0.0038863127, -0.0318308324, -0.0528026968, -0.0353904702, 0.0048388615, 0.0043664644, 0.0254474338, -0.0383222811, 0.0429478101, -0.0022800863, -0.0325291269, -0.0258993246, 0.00201722, -0.0142511893, -0.0509646013, 0.0329390429, -0.0064691268, 0.0335345492, 0.0407148972, -0.0075853858, -0.0064359321, -0.0069228983, 0.0084251864, -0.0423338711, -0.007522875, -0.0346215665, -0.0306462925, 0.000965182, -0.0440441966, 0.0378070064, 0.0148583241, -0.0286978651, -0.0217802878, -0.0517921597, 0.0132505773, 0.0027620599, -0.0645507127, -0.0393655002, -0.0104113147, 0.0197482053, -0.0360872149, 0.0727307722, -0.0334708691, 0.0232993942, 0.0027883758, -0.0070568393, -0.0067714686, -0.0414736308, 0.0101089673, 0.0345117263, 0.0202048998, 0.0378181413, 0.0487687327, 0.026157558, 0.0213172752, -0.0212452877, -0.0933605954, -0.0152567951, -0.0038784884, 0.0099826129, 0.0071823774, -0.0086396318, 0.0009287344, 0.0141148288, -0.0086200396, -0.011490141, -0.0285526123, 0.0299416184, 0.0254277308, 0.03266396, 0.0082219215, -0.0303700659, -0.0245194454, -0.0111184176, 0.0142128309, 0.0624893866, -0.0367533304, -0.0111739365, 0.0259696338, -0.0470440537, 0.0009292231, -0.0080357157, -0.0081359269, -0.0007378439, -0.0311900731, -0.0023379468, 0.0710353106, 0.0300487503, 0.0646002889, -0.0093010776, 0.0043633585, -0.0450975485, 0.0060130418, 0.0087239789, 0.0045488845, 0.0133301793, -0.0186327212, 0.003724321, 0.0386780649, -0.001391652, -0.0014361853, -0.091380775, 0.053159304, -0.0296750739, 0.0100633921, -0.092956081, 0.0127107948, -0.0123681175, 0.0721583068, 0.0173936691, -0.0461899303, 0.0358355865, 0.0168753471, -0.0045377053, -0.029328879, -0.0180205703, -0.0525576845, 0.0328282714, -0.0049227588, 0.0043147081, -0.029470766, -0.0101575451, -0.0394293778, 0.0071657295, 0.0393214449, -0.0315521471, 0.0227631852, -0.011901658, 0.0141756292, -0.0119877672, -0.000568872, 0.014522098, -0.0692369714, -0.0140785277, 0.0020351089, 0.0499314889, -0.0362950601, -0.0082139485, 0.0320972167, 0.0162456464, -0.0281578042, -0.0331104286, -0.0501385815, 0.0440610684, 0.0155752087, 0.0701546371, -0.0384454541, 0.0237671807, -0.061275471, 0.1025348008, 0.0224580597, 0.07875368, -0.0076119816, 0.0036523549, 0.0106957527, 0.0290230215, -0.0336768404, -0.0071502551, 0.0765457749, 0.013695173, 0.0108295735, 0.0049561369, 0.0825177953, -0.0015156989, -0.0173796564, -0.0035372472, 0.0322935469, 0.0109573966, -0.0270979293, -0.0065810746, -0.0628742948, 0.0008768025, -0.027050497, 0.0580011234, -0.0176771283, -0.0466175415, -0.012365601, -0.1778266728, 0.0602704771, -0.0087469853, -0.0346345231, 0.0045026387, -0.0461803675, -0.0176373087, -0.076405406, 0.0023219676, 0.0150555028, -0.0288075041, 0.0356058292, -0.0043666922, -0.0292580929, -0.0449717268, 0.0247793663, -0.0328291655, 0.0003161414, 0.0370176025, 0.0135393841, -0.0560711734, -0.0365814865, -0.0688498542, -0.0544696636, 0.0309527833, -0.0012313779, 0.0768330395, -0.0495679267, -0.0132260807, -0.0070887203, 0.0330066718, 0.001584042, 0.0638966188, 0.002229677, -0.0165509712, -0.0281689875, -0.025487233, 0.041923672, 0.0389132351, -0.025741687, 0.0429992676, 0.0127134314, -0.0513425283, 0.0083873337, -0.0585404485, 0.0181848165, -0.055693835, -0.0225259848, 0.0148832146, 0.0284497365, -0.0675114468, -0.0887061432, -0.0799241588, 0.008415631, 0.0580681637, -0.0034683833, 0.0216881447, -0.0270831343, 0.0280083716, -0.0078721428, 0.0139504289, 0.0171761066, -0.0134688802, -0.0599852763, 0.0323078148, 0.0483250283, -0.0286168866, -0.038449686, -0.0134740276, -0.0494153425, -0.033686623, 0.0113353785, 0.0887824744, 0.0260220505, -0.0276425257, -0.0083819898, 0.0366064496, 0.0458147749, 0.0572565347, -0.0026042107, -0.0226251632, 0.0497175418, 0.0606368519, -0.0031580694, 0.0146476692, -0.0290769115, 0.023420224, -0.0008452292, 0.0143538928, -0.0257975142, -0.0387606546, 0.014950878, 0.0378831401, 0.1006044224, -0.0189182349, -0.036288254, -0.0160135329, -0.0246446356, 0.0123658832, -0.0000850818, -0.0140873082, -0.0522955023, 0.0571893416, 0.0286552235, -0.0095759556, 0.0715451688, 0.0017829263, -0.0604912378, -0.0724884495, 0.0284557119, 0.0045418888, 0.0430210158, -0.0116351182, 0.0154683637, 0.0010353557, -0.0414216928, 0.0615208559, 0.0137948198, -0.0003137004, 0.0660375059, 0.0097788619, 0.0104093421, 0.0330488682, 0.005606635, -0.0415041558, -0.0474365205, 0.0047429479, 0.046066545, 0.0262431223, -0.0082329763, -0.0001915098, -0.0444642156, 0.0328958407, 0.0017770577, 0.0079728551, 0.0042832079, -0.0317819715, 0.0183908157, 0.0034683126, -0.0303844009, -0.0040430427, 0.0999880508, -0.0099038575, -0.0099561559, -0.022683356, 0.0047562965, -0.0486175716, -0.0032222783, 0.0449541099, 0.0245374087, -0.0233311877, 0.0201553758, -0.0489087515, -0.0095802434, -0.0278757978, -0.0106327143, 0.0067353556, -0.008783658, 0.0146774109, 0.0386522673, -0.0318877846, 0.0673526004, -0.0261669103, -0.0322023034, -0.0393972732, -0.0025784529, -0.0780258924, -7.093766779e-33, -0.021430023, -0.0553571917, -0.0185266044, -0.031964913, 0.0339825526, 0.0026926715, -0.0000794183, 0.0122204339, -0.0100436099, -0.0060550109, 0.018166244, 0.0013587045, 0.007852979, 0.0142797241, 0.0472533479, -0.0065184128, 0.0187309962, 0.0007894462, 0.0015495649, -0.0429871157, 0.0338775627, 0.0470053926, 0.0473113358, -0.0054169381, 0.0514186807, 0.017717557, -0.0753078759, -0.0202000383, 0.0378304087, 0.0552173555, 0.0324631184, 0.0510296933, 0.0225735251, -0.0966263413, 0.0147274956, -0.0488429554, 0.0150104696, -0.0402145684, -0.01310407, 0.0136782331, -0.0045110839, 0.0060747163, 0.0250272229, 0.0019753128, -0.0396543257, -0.0144530376, 0.0566520467, 0.0013534867, -0.0072503942, -0.0068403906, 0.001238407, 0.0222086646, -0.0030417044, 0.0432290733, 0.0417221934, 0.1119867936, -0.0028632681, 0.059498053, -0.0579242595, 0.029703984, 0.0073504685, 0.0183310341, -0.0099915061, 0.033629898, -0.0088956431, 0.0449476689, 0.0300991889, 0.0124866962, 0.0290260203, -0.0303745456, 0.0172943883, 0.0516686663, 0.0319950543, 0.0499938577, 0.0323415361, -0.018004233, -0.0287060719, 0.0559338778, 0.0355609804, -0.0091538066, -0.0108637121, 0.0189456176, -0.0644827187, -0.0455843434, 0.0142752528, -0.057270024, -0.0397561565, -0.0215895791, 0.0392218754, 0.0014435706, -0.0288742352, -0.0113621959, 0.0367003232, -0.0412116684, -0.0602888651, -0.0355851315, -0.02116259, 0.0444393605, -0.0039485237, -0.0114505235, -0.0691796392, -0.0191765353, -0.0227636732, 0.0169406999, -0.0048627867, -0.0249872599, 0.0170117021, 0.0232691783, -0.0398108028, -0.0162241124, 0.0100751892, -0.0376534201, 0.0350341275, -0.020548949, 0.0286067892, -0.0138686709, -0.0105119571, 0.050607536, 0.0043861256, 0.0164907537, -0.0069956682, -0.054805316, -0.0311205238, 0.0019127532, 0.0156220095, 0.0256004464, 0.022082679, 0.0523114689, 0.0149443476, -0.0170077551, -0.0381062739, 0.0358786434, 3.17e-7, 0.0296692923, 0.059582103, -0.0395935997, 0.0066078259, -0.0143391145, 0.0676010549, -0.0395737067, -0.0041109817, 0.0063207536, 0.0096938284, 0.0724316835, -0.0041473415, 0.0537736677, 0.0080143558, -0.045174893, -0.0558349267, -0.0762141421, 0.0419781096, -0.0792531446, 0.0387588851, 0.0241672993, 0.0544069558, 0.0024450284, 0.012303371, 0.000167593, -0.0478842072, 0.0754028484, -0.0760620907, -0.0335735157, -0.0047542276, 0.0041801669, 0.0061555901, -0.0374865755, 0.038702704, -0.0159099363, 0.0036864309, 0.0637223572, 0.0178185292, 0.0105373776, 0.0224767998, -0.0072443937, 0.0389612727, -0.0132805631, -0.0727436244, 0.0325060301, -0.0567690097, -0.0498122945, -0.0132328756, -0.07645417, 0.03085717, 0.0648840293, -0.0097659938, -0.0211518202, 0.0232408717, 0.0023648918, -0.0076653734, 0.0092479791, 0.0020454021, -0.0199337397, 0.0031140915, -0.0192786865, -0.0225612279, -0.0268297791, -0.0041465112, 0.0156256855, -0.0260071121, 0.0046226205, 2.89648535e-34, 0.0393127315, -0.0324529, -0.0438285694, -0.025490677, 0.0534380488, -0.0171940904, -0.0607720576, 0.0146091273, 0.014098485, -0.0306169037, -0.021567272 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.06602v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.06602v1
TEDB System Description to a Shared Task on Euphemism Detection 2022
2023-01-16T20:37:56
2023-01-16T20:37:56
Peratham Wiriyathammabhum
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.LG
In this report, we describe our Transformers for euphemism detection baseline (TEDB) submissions to a shared task on euphemism detection 2022. We cast the task of predicting euphemism as text classification. We considered Transformer-based models which are the current state-of-the-art methods for text classification. We explored different training schemes, pretrained models, and model architectures. Our best result of 0.816 F1-score (0.818 precision and 0.814 recall) consists of a euphemism-detection-finetuned TweetEval/TimeLMs-pretrained RoBERTa model as a feature extractor frontend with a KimCNN classifier backend trained end-to-end using a cosine annealing scheduler. We observed pretrained models on sentiment analysis and offensiveness detection to correlate with more F1-score while pretraining on other tasks, such as sarcasm detection, produces less F1-scores. Also, putting more word vector channels does not improve the performance in our experiments.
[ 0.0920545086, 0.0076050409, -0.0007854432, 0.0422059, -0.0177858099, 0.0142923752, -0.0020286909, 0.0460872836, -0.0256347489, -0.0853600502, -0.0598091446, 0.0283143446, -0.050887607, 0.0537240393, -0.0267289802, -0.0123921726, 0.0487361662, 0.0528914407, -0.0177638344, -0.0334024988, 0.0043971832, 0.0232227836, -0.0077183601, 0.0479958914, -0.0423932634, 0.0204222538, 0.0420992151, 0.0134245902, -0.0046811965, 0.0286878217, 0.0581008792, 0.0397805087, 0.0065864236, 0.0299381446, 0.0000021277, -0.0484703556, -0.0109416014, -0.007051677, -0.0222590137, -0.0341250859, 0.1213905066, -0.0045801317, -0.0092755184, 0.016929483, -0.0388114378, 0.0132667897, 0.0787702575, 0.0575476438, 0.0576672181, 0.0559193343, -0.003522737, -0.0258428864, -0.0079450617, 0.0025171228, -0.0436964184, -0.026845742, 0.0320849717, -0.0584664196, -0.0575629137, -0.0100518297, -0.0411693342, 0.0253644288, 0.001225571, 0.0309822559, 0.0147049529, 0.007975976, -0.0395303667, -0.0183167607, -0.0128461933, 0.0248654839, 0.0087278783, -0.0122276349, -0.0030941842, 0.0229205247, -0.0359298922, -0.0171741731, 0.0012382101, -0.0132775251, 0.0035015463, -0.0033373053, -0.0096046207, -0.0219328217, -0.0230998546, 0.0862603337, 0.000443856, 0.0365008079, 0.0099830078, -0.0366830602, 0.0333084017, -0.0158803407, -0.0051056771, -0.0180653967, 0.0408877842, 0.0023220896, 0.0030409859, 0.0171464887, -0.0201011784, -0.0582981631, 0.0409544222, -0.0748131648, -0.0244935527, 0.0243593715, 0.0045760428, 0.0145448213, -0.0152726173, 0.0641300976, -0.0007995481, 0.0437342897, -0.0086024748, -0.0152132241, -0.0675408766, -0.0068405471, -0.0317092724, 0.0256347768, 0.0143297566, -0.0147619266, -0.0791353583, 0.0170009825, -0.0221593846, -0.0462672487, 0.0365743749, 0.0604609214, -0.04614437, -0.0061526047, -0.0183310732, 0.0087165665, -0.0095332721, 0.0216942281, -0.0645619333, -0.0312906653, 0.0023721564, 0.0025327504, 0.0012094429, -0.0271012895, 0.0510302708, 0.0512162857, 0.0323655307, -0.0642086044, 0.0160935707, 0.0015165438, -0.059279412, -0.0400634222, 0.01233989, -0.0444090888, 0.0207713302, -0.0161133204, -0.0085279448, -0.0022069942, 0.0160217341, 0.0106158219, -0.0656829476, 0.031916678, -0.0213091895, -0.0209313352, 0.0583904833, 0.0210443586, -0.0288558863, 0.0727647766, 0.0255240463, 0.0379760489, 0.0529418588, -0.002321525, -0.0388411619, 0.0438072421, 0.0067999433, -0.0232803263, -0.0330834985, 0.023224473, -0.0679082572, 0.0030271995, 0.0350689292, 0.0396328308, -0.0147910779, -0.0212086607, 0.0272124372, 0.0380648375, -0.0042913863, 0.0474223346, 0.0558979996, 0.035877116, -0.0077877268, -0.0371005461, -0.0321989283, -0.0236006528, -0.0548866652, -0.0331694707, -0.0129726268, 0.0065488927, -0.0269855689, -0.0375761464, 0.0096789077, -0.0453234613, 0.0037135091, -0.0333138742, 0.0579728372, 0.0375157967, -0.0441909209, 0.0738626495, 0.0447620973, -0.0262941066, -0.0219498985, -0.074039638, -0.0304656364, 0.0709816888, 0.035048563, -0.0075093196, -0.0296462178, -0.0413278379, 0.0292850081, 0.0581633039, 0.0026370112, 0.0100715039, 0.0173244216, -0.0270510297, -0.0152969277, -0.0118725253, 0.0219843667, -0.0045027831, 0.0270303972, 0.0510481745, -0.0031008965, 0.0236780327, -0.0081711905, 0.01735433, 0.0009437329, -0.033862453, 0.0054860073, 0.0006595092, 0.0234231148, -0.0111942766, -0.0313315019, -0.0370730795, 0.0103456397, -0.0429029204, -0.0378855616, -0.0011308324, -0.0284478776, -0.0094232168, 0.0136591718, -0.0373167656, -0.012994051, 0.087322928, -0.017980665, 0.0044609252, 0.0367836244, -0.0357400514, 0.0443416983, -0.0512446277, -0.0140413633, -0.0800427273, 0.043787092, 0.02482583, 0.0562679395, -0.0018117529, 0.0122615499, -0.0099083707, -0.0642146915, -0.0193492454, 0.0335227475, -0.0418246016, 0.0088912081, -0.0113337878, -0.0046836413, 0.006823733, 0.0304564964, -0.0453456715, -0.0397178419, -0.1083948389, 0.0191483814, -0.0086519029, -0.0034763599, 0.0195113998, -0.0187444482, -0.0207844693, 0.0020074248, 0.034067899, -0.0069664503, -0.018841736, 0.0183479805, 0.0141460802, -0.0188027192, -0.0242657792, -0.009284135, -0.008426398, -0.0273683742, 0.027476022, -0.0009513709, -0.026605064, 0.0397819877, 0.0453301109, -0.0088670058, -0.0156043014, 0.0198494829, -0.0737744644, -0.0189248733, 0.0399313606, -0.0119528631, 0.0472215675, 0.0984793603, 0.058324825, 0.0225123744, -0.0057679312, -0.0356259346, 0.0032506015, -0.042480275, -0.0266957153, -0.030042395, -0.0177558213, 0.0135281049, 0.0460158028, 0.0150438398, 0.0271130633, -0.0634641126, 0.0432446674, -0.0457587726, -0.0273885597, 0.0174261499, -0.0374517739, -0.0508614816, -0.0534737445, -0.0037697442, 0.0032315606, 0.0572134815, 0.0291423295, -0.0248869471, -0.0492825471, -0.0214329846, 0.0164471287, 0.0215628669, -0.020377066, 0.0589675829, 0.0069823926, -0.0382888466, -0.000679442, -0.0435052589, -0.0142848007, -0.0601304732, 0.0352257043, 0.0290719494, -0.0253270362, 0.0223843828, -0.0518915579, -0.0490127392, -0.0579891168, -0.0564647652, -0.0194447599, -0.0186717976, 0.0218209866, 0.0028037871, 0.0064057661, -0.0409827307, -0.0311523452, -0.0320561826, -0.0182706304, 0.0162766874, -0.0045028846, 0.0419393554, -0.0271608531, 0.0044007134, 0.0278634876, 0.0167165734, 0.0641695559, -0.0094826529, 0.0241754502, -0.006163728, -0.002547659, 0.0102885067, -0.0455115736, 0.0228593871, -0.0310944729, -0.0025936407, -0.0160090774, -0.0334679075, 0.1298286915, 0.0189712886, -0.051539544, 0.0000034005, 0.0375182852, -0.0217114761, 0.0119048459, -0.0051014028, -0.0466646962, -0.0382403769, -0.0066419267, 0.0220587086, -0.0441311449, -0.0063423114, -0.0260420032, -0.0892914459, 0.0002583216, -0.0330380946, -0.0348167196, -0.0089292359, 0.0084793679, 0.0203574691, 0.0052038897, 0.049495738, -0.0429041758, -0.0118390936, -0.013079809, 0.0117106019, -0.0370938405, -0.030491421, 0.0598812252, -0.004183156, 0.0339268111, 0.0169968363, 0.0653788745, -0.043666862, -0.0401882008, 0.0059578842, -0.006407253, -0.0182035808, -0.0327788815, 0.0643982887, -0.0466963425, -0.0043651713, -0.0014010037, -0.0224059932, -0.0014867943, 0.0197041128, -0.0150874183, 0.0218022615, 0.0002614743, -0.0353926383, -0.0332776085, 0.0731612965, -0.0002291537, 0.0679800287, 0.0178096853, -0.0789765343, -0.0055424068, 0.0176003929, 0.0098674782, -0.0549082533, -0.095089376, -0.0361781605, -0.0460029058, -0.0566608533, -0.0401689038, -0.018756764, 0.0122168912, 0.0210145675, 0.005085655, -0.017936483, -0.0449334793, 0.0092129838, -0.0509378165, -0.0009097563, 0.0261432827, -0.0058993767, -0.0504672788, -0.0022414476, 0.0452621616, 0.0154130338, -0.0477508716, 0.0343910567, -0.0101531418, -0.0301584639, 0.0830948949, 0.0635772124, 0.0171522796, 0.0039442745, 0.0007070076, -0.0038779587, 0.0761337802, 0.0741757154, -0.0527977571, 0.018669853, 0.0696203336, 0.00826531, -0.0061663766, 0.0552911013, -0.0448172651, 0.0608590133, 0.0183527526, -0.0030764923, -0.0149193695, -0.008188664, 0.0007504235, -0.0159954727, 0.0651985556, 0.0095693422, -0.070009537, -0.0037951057, -0.0009484767, -0.0092770299, -0.0226278678, -0.0010795562, 0.0157689769, 0.0063072937, -0.0025686324, -0.0450798385, -0.000364619, -0.0285471752, -0.0065043094, 0.0233835168, 0.0172354672, 0.0295829568, 0.0390586518, -0.0057580657, 0.0268478189, -0.0664634109, -0.0385387056, 0.0640949607, -0.031611722, -0.0255985036, 0.0563395545, 0.0070419232, -0.0074160388, -0.0224308856, 0.0419777408, -0.0101363193, -0.0181353856, -0.0146136181, -0.0387292542, 0.0118288938, -0.0223314818, 0.0386220515, -0.0061874711, -0.0160436984, 0.0024936092, -0.0136594316, -0.0476240292, -0.0049551795, 0.0600546412, -0.0090886531, -0.022976784, -0.0300626326, -0.0097194985, -0.032553941, 0.0494463146, 0.0736232921, -0.0235220082, 0.001074744, -0.0022233513, 0.0005851832, -0.0229827855, -0.0003304747, 0.0278843846, -0.0427006744, -0.0342921093, 0.0720314533, -0.0403068252, -0.0153795462, 0.0242686458, 0.0629855618, 0.0813024268, 0.0340406857, 0.0073228558, -0.0309349205, 0.0277607422, 0.0143592069, -0.0117584383, 0.0017910134, -6.814952743e-33, -0.0247358046, 0.0026471065, -0.0155421579, 0.0548363924, -0.0344513804, 0.0110682817, 0.0109262932, 0.0028780364, -0.0087165236, 0.0202390403, 0.0013312979, 0.0370598994, 0.0063246633, 0.0119871618, 0.0124822361, -0.005887446, 0.0259108674, -0.0022428215, -0.0241618622, -0.0057595489, 0.0454197787, 0.0597511716, 0.104365617, -0.0718348697, -0.002205879, 0.0323770344, -0.0142296189, 0.0002702717, 0.0608209893, 0.055505123, -0.0284077134, 0.1197756082, 0.0152620403, -0.0312487725, 0.018354781, 0.0385760963, -0.0647112206, -0.0396265537, 0.0060401578, 0.0344514623, 0.021783838, -0.0374309719, 0.0581542924, 0.0196849853, -0.0613004267, -0.0230758283, 0.0363085121, -0.0044196304, 0.0341175199, -0.0425426438, -0.075266026, 0.0064832317, -0.0042102467, -0.0296823904, 0.0221212339, 0.0165853314, 0.0328618288, -0.0230629686, -0.0442223102, 0.0181714743, -0.0491498932, -0.0184743516, -0.0144826528, 0.00453358, 0.0351543091, 0.0808741972, 0.0012973665, 0.0232650433, 0.0290323012, 0.0060837748, 0.0435142592, 0.0441503823, 0.0233293455, 0.0194255039, 0.0367477536, -0.0857173204, -0.0097079603, -0.0356405266, 0.043243587, 0.0469098091, 0.0271502249, -0.0580549203, -0.0653193146, -0.0121319238, 0.0042594834, 0.0150707858, -0.0220678803, -0.0499096997, 0.0299759228, 0.0106402207, -0.0175745282, 0.0152743282, -0.0151279662, -0.0416612625, 0.014028172, 0.0234289318, -0.0063102348, -0.0112593248, 0.0147447428, 0.0477212556, -0.0267491285, -0.0212906282, -0.0115971686, 0.0014182631, 0.0295576751, -0.0080794077, 0.0346343927, 0.0737503394, -0.0879944041, 0.0020761259, 0.0003789834, 0.007399335, -0.0126624759, 0.007480267, -0.0149394339, 0.0565106086, -0.0231062099, -0.0113939401, 0.0293676089, 0.0099006211, -0.034732502, 0.0170333367, 0.0260194764, 0.0377980545, -0.0203351732, -0.0267262235, 0.0147882421, 0.0107179433, 0.0107238563, -0.0915692821, -0.0140141342, -0.0341904573, 3.019e-7, 0.0580975935, 0.0819201022, -0.0458144844, 0.0077010384, 0.0029110778, 0.0236217193, 0.0040295338, 0.036776673, 0.0285309628, 0.0437212028, 0.0002858888, 0.0200243089, -0.0115910564, 0.0455580838, -0.0597754531, -0.0326005295, -0.0518886819, 0.032676015, -0.0270527434, -0.0223014578, 0.0348170325, 0.0840311572, 0.0621628836, -0.0539392568, -0.0545333326, -0.0677756444, 0.0280935653, -0.0475988761, 0.0337222926, 0.0058208494, 0.0250732563, 0.0348240212, 0.021283228, 0.0329582728, -0.014296582, 0.0264606271, 0.0052569616, 0.0354431123, -0.0331960209, -0.0380046777, 0.0076777842, -0.0151354047, -0.0189884882, -0.0080813877, 0.0658789575, -0.0421606489, -0.0220811646, -0.061375875, -0.0251120981, 0.006170365, 0.0470897667, -0.045702666, -0.0334773622, 0.0007916109, 0.0313088447, 0.014714825, -0.0142616797, -0.1214087754, 0.0439497009, 0.0182299968, -0.0313603394, -0.0106921038, -0.0046649636, 0.0043669958, 0.0280266106, -0.0314732008, 0.0383963548, 2.548308974e-34, 0.0134760914, 0.0069637783, 0.0248504486, 0.0336898416, 0.0100754164, 0.0183918513, 0.0735032782, -0.0196261462, -0.0071322406, -0.0312220585, -0.0004489028 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.06570v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.06570v1
Cross-institution text mining to uncover clinical associations: a case study relating social factors and code status in intensive care medicine
2023-01-16T19:04:59
2023-01-16T19:04:59
Madhumita Sushil, Atul J. Butte, Ewoud Schuit, Maarten van Smeden, Artuur M. Leeuwenberg
cs.CL
cs.CL, stat.ME, 68T50, 68U35, 62-xx, 62P10, 92C60, 92D30, I.2.7; G.3
Objective: Text mining of clinical notes embedded in electronic medical records is increasingly used to extract patient characteristics otherwise not or only partly available, to assess their association with relevant health outcomes. As manual data labeling needed to develop text mining models is resource intensive, we investigated whether off-the-shelf text mining models developed at external institutions, together with limited within-institution labeled data, could be used to reliably extract study variables to conduct association studies. Materials and Methods: We developed multiple text mining models on different combinations of within-institution and external-institution data to extract social factors from discharge reports of intensive care patients. Subsequently, we assessed the associations between social factors and having a do-not-resuscitate/intubate code. Results: Important differences were found between associations based on manually labeled data compared to text-mined social factors in three out of five cases. Adopting external-institution text mining models using manually labeled within-institution data resulted in models with higher F1-scores, but not in meaningfully different associations. Discussion: While text mining facilitated scaling analyses to larger samples leading to discovering a larger number of associations, the estimates may be unreliable. Confirmation is needed with better text mining models, ideally on a larger manually labeled dataset. Conclusion: The currently used text mining models were not sufficiently accurate to be used reliably in an association study. Model adaptation using within-institution data did not improve the estimates. Further research is needed to set conditions for reliable use of text mining in medical research.
[ 0.007803, -0.0046307412, -0.0179445595, -0.0419675596, 0.0089366911, 0.0577139147, 0.0264059305, 0.0454941876, 0.0187602639, -0.0062425933, -0.0122851962, 0.0026114085, 0.0636188611, 0.0394031368, -0.0063564777, 0.0248671491, 0.0129840095, 0.0485165976, 0.0210806802, 0.0532177873, -0.0055103307, 0.0427214131, 0.0206516795, 0.0395886227, 0.0451141223, 0.0092971064, 0.0294583123, -0.0080952067, 0.0443740599, -0.0559916496, 0.0014330798, 0.0031359869, -0.0175862294, -0.0392861664, 0.0000023899, -0.0634386763, -0.0727776885, 0.0484420545, 0.0026624359, -0.0425355993, 0.0185896959, -0.0560659096, 0.0353156626, 0.0327397287, -0.0681845769, -0.0324719995, 0.0433664136, -0.0075478139, -0.0223048963, 0.0061041852, -0.0258615222, 0.0119711636, -0.0271765962, -0.0072611351, -0.006825503, -0.0058411043, 0.0543625541, 0.034682665, 0.0133404285, -0.0384134352, 0.0229945611, 0.0266540423, -0.0252385698, 0.0390350185, -0.0004979291, 0.0582881011, -0.0105444835, -0.0028185197, 0.0600205697, 0.0126699805, 0.0486575328, 0.0102017103, 0.0652301833, -0.0286203101, 0.0063860244, 0.0357416794, -0.0196253266, -0.0167981442, -0.0326086171, 0.0007317004, 0.0217758492, 0.0598195344, -0.0239108335, -0.0337735973, -0.0144239888, -0.0416700579, -0.0325545445, -0.0356774926, 0.0299809817, 0.0076012556, -0.0279514845, -0.0273771659, 0.0494335331, -0.0318557285, 0.0246254764, 0.0147194657, 0.0233128667, -0.0423684157, 0.0819434226, -0.0672999769, -0.0508752875, 0.0028497183, 0.0394692756, -0.0018141149, 0.0125113577, -0.080223605, 0.0349626131, 0.004806261, -0.0139641045, 0.0371939577, -0.0562269613, -0.0067061237, 0.0024441814, 0.0005556218, 0.0409810096, 0.0472525097, -0.0518828072, -0.0261245966, -0.0121339411, 0.0257869996, 0.005644389, 0.008561126, -0.008130691, 0.0149926944, 0.0009386351, -0.0480569825, -0.0036002926, 0.0429792292, -0.0452886932, 0.0378624499, 0.0754954964, -0.024945695, 0.0791524574, 0.0008305096, 0.0232305173, -0.0201016199, 0.0007931397, -0.0214128643, -0.0244744495, -0.0177821442, 0.0060906322, 0.0327015966, 0.0283793695, -0.0216002669, 0.0271654017, 0.0540152788, 0.0005427747, -0.0555922501, -0.0029470993, 0.0198252909, -0.0567113049, -0.0548679233, -0.0917245522, 0.0123995533, 0.0168667976, 0.0283879135, 0.0298205502, -0.0328095779, 0.0194106456, -0.0428571701, 0.0095939059, -0.06144806, 0.0142963259, 0.0177767891, -0.0080200722, -0.0205880366, 0.0018457359, 0.036681477, 0.0158945676, -0.0172066558, -0.0403182209, 0.0348894335, -0.0033563697, -0.0043845382, -0.0067244791, 0.0319565944, 0.043585401, 0.0318194889, -0.0552583337, -0.0033742494, -0.0132887121, -0.0453507975, 0.0363089889, -0.022416003, 0.0235562436, -0.0122285476, 0.0492684282, 0.0112172533, -0.0153272394, -0.0887909159, -0.0406379439, 0.0000578621, 0.0399484113, -0.0240003243, 0.0194574296, -0.0056057479, 0.0024240322, -0.0290434211, 0.0330176204, 0.0065498883, -0.0250286479, -0.0435526781, -0.0030082203, 0.0899804607, 0.03879622, -0.0343981311, 0.0280379709, -0.0513526797, 0.0172781684, -0.0137635237, -0.0393969119, -0.0014207001, -0.0218067504, -0.0115930839, -0.0248440821, 0.0470910631, -0.0074853273, -0.0124848839, -0.0466987118, 0.0004696366, -0.0518983528, -0.0057823048, -0.0829894841, 0.0585463233, -0.0287936088, 0.0141292335, 0.0326227657, -0.0015966685, -0.004465769, 0.0376885049, -0.0051692296, 0.0306525268, 0.0140551925, -0.0072795385, -0.0339518562, -0.0113881929, 0.0093358587, 0.0086546997, -0.0382648222, 0.0084248837, 0.0034024261, -0.028442556, -0.0016620159, 0.0015931793, -0.0085837804, -0.0272208471, 0.1026613489, 0.0506804995, -0.0253456123, 0.0318900794, -0.0054918225, -0.0282264464, -0.0044657197, -0.047283072, 0.0280773193, -0.0438686348, -0.0534900725, 0.0360279642, 0.0403267704, 0.0015799473, -0.0314094573, -0.0924991816, -0.0084764641, 0.0196479913, -0.0043196017, -0.0014850249, -0.006425126, -0.1350778043, -0.015509516, 0.0241127983, -0.0091758789, 0.0149436127, -0.0032301424, -0.016344605, 0.0131511269, -0.0081286095, -0.0347987376, -0.0066712946, 0.056661278, 0.0268008914, 0.0576232597, -0.0197252128, -0.0253812019, -0.0193875115, -0.0539388768, 0.032512065, 0.0570918508, -0.0757971704, -0.0068327584, 0.037653897, -0.0387858413, -0.0389815792, -0.0314466953, -0.0211337619, 0.0112687219, 0.0066446844, 0.0048160623, 0.0205949228, 0.0113371452, -0.0286367126, 0.051291123, -0.0168715362, -0.0286616813, -0.009764812, -0.0402002744, 0.0011297223, 0.0344828032, -0.0922885463, 0.0064726863, 0.0445974767, 0.0289921146, -0.011317323, 0.003854508, -0.0174044184, -0.0165480878, 0.0386353582, -0.0239559785, -0.0229667034, -0.0053061913, 0.0558152162, 0.0306057055, -0.0489516482, 0.0000988443, 0.0010450552, 0.0480634458, -0.099363938, -0.0654648319, -0.0306372587, -0.0035049811, -0.0358379409, -0.0115234451, 0.0602677464, 0.0138992006, 0.0614320077, -0.0242010653, 0.0065044682, -0.0203414038, 0.0247212499, -0.0142024886, 0.0530394614, 0.0166720022, -0.0293499958, -0.0047268793, -0.0018226795, -0.0256010834, -0.0159628335, -0.0023900946, -0.0008272822, -0.0072781858, 0.0316888019, 0.0302059017, 0.0122229187, 0.0273135174, -0.0340957493, 0.0321879275, -0.0506683476, 0.0396943949, -0.0561952479, -0.0092237219, -0.012608923, 0.0048216395, 0.0237473696, -0.0497415252, 0.0058556097, 0.009038588, -0.0379189439, -0.0353673249, -0.0117428098, -0.0151633509, 0.0125958966, -0.021447476, -0.0222233124, 0.0233342089, 0.0549289435, 0.0391099788, -0.0589995943, 0.0111754546, -0.0227910876, -0.0683029518, -0.0202030037, -0.0086399959, -0.0086893467, 0.0016764037, -0.0230633486, 0.0270395316, -0.0421542078, -0.0595550463, -0.0016945875, 0.0138515662, 0.0043946141, -0.0299142841, -0.0448677801, -0.0009220002, -0.0739184096, 0.0441935919, -0.0135685317, -0.0505867489, -0.0740743577, -0.0049177343, -0.0020847011, 0.019166436, -0.1197599247, -0.043690823, 0.0298076887, 0.0280483793, 0.0221470539, 0.0472012125, 0.014774085, -0.0354656391, -0.0197561458, 0.0107244886, 0.0113400836, 0.0192471854, -0.0196587052, 0.0744447112, 0.017389968, 0.0430321023, -0.024837248, 0.0206043702, 0.0007720533, -0.0323339179, 0.0170154572, 0.0495291092, -0.0510010123, -0.0583489388, -0.0171469618, 0.0413767099, -0.0018742323, 0.0039911163, -0.0278080106, -0.0133066662, 0.0360364057, 0.0456992425, 0.0291811302, 0.0480017997, 0.0095545072, -0.0347665772, -0.0487024896, -0.0332447961, -0.0274823885, -0.0237828754, 0.0569649003, -0.0225026701, 0.0052191145, 0.0388536192, 0.0846963674, 0.0068521686, -0.0752786472, 0.0316064507, 0.0342571437, -0.004755117, 0.0222839825, -0.0342306346, 0.0099347401, 0.0389382914, -0.0152689498, -0.0613004528, 0.0501802713, 0.0374661013, 0.0512517765, 0.023726631, 0.0143146375, -0.02729108, 0.0506138317, -0.0174213275, -0.0089315595, 0.0119000506, -0.0370178409, -0.0213183723, -0.0383681729, 0.0145138288, -0.006203224, -0.0647443682, -0.0020396516, 0.0354731455, 0.0205826797, -0.0311506484, -0.0375835374, 0.037113715, -0.024369128, -0.0059174309, 0.0041175741, 0.0032518082, -0.0589422584, -0.0506950468, -0.0015404893, 0.0030499573, 0.0213896949, -0.009596996, 0.0072925482, 0.0045708152, 0.0260571856, -0.0295404792, -0.0159593783, -0.0567247123, -0.055223871, -0.0197328907, 0.0723396838, -0.0063730665, 0.0748082325, 0.021293629, -0.0072877547, -0.0077885934, -0.0327483602, 0.032549385, 0.058706332, 0.0178984161, 0.04186932, -0.0269682687, 0.0275306348, 0.0087716021, 0.0536478311, -0.030603746, -0.0005661194, -0.0564651489, -0.0354549363, -0.0592569783, 0.0101621076, 0.0087027419, -0.0173981413, 0.0353370681, -0.0423705913, 0.005512224, -0.0100115258, 0.0149224959, 0.0136564942, -0.0106021669, -0.0720210373, -0.001211999, 0.0434813835, -0.0054265028, 0.0169215035, -0.0282238834, -0.0298441388, -0.0009847529, 0.0099417847, 0.0859501436, 0.0214351695, -0.0636933967, -0.020710459, -0.0845275298, 0.0077498355, 0.0432792008, -0.0449979939, -0.0254745428, -0.0099904807, 0.0186322387, -0.0056212652, -0.0168701429, 0.026094716, -0.0079903593, 0.0133378636, -0.0304293763, -0.025813451, 0.0196990855, -5.694344428e-33, 0.0090483557, -0.0592840016, 0.0030708294, 0.0070379991, 0.0209435392, 0.0479797088, -0.0178924575, 0.0086733345, 0.0084962612, 0.0033846104, -0.0116780577, 0.0130501362, -0.0038500014, -0.0075315363, 0.0582089424, -0.0244083218, -0.0167975165, 0.029878607, 0.0034456186, -0.0030609267, -0.032071121, 0.0377410389, 0.0180370156, -0.134420529, 0.0399843156, 0.017311316, -0.0011523386, -0.0411844477, 0.0566119961, 0.0369685031, -0.0335926414, -0.0301371831, 0.0539407395, -0.0015497332, -0.0008073146, 0.0535052307, -0.042451784, -0.0450344011, 0.0222565997, -0.0551936068, 0.0234283395, 0.01345238, 0.0343921557, 0.0392958559, -0.0282717217, -0.0000494308, 0.0413934775, -0.025875885, 0.0039886371, -0.0260683242, 0.0176601056, 0.0745464414, 0.0106350705, 0.0486363731, -0.0178735033, 0.008434101, -0.0284770019, 0.0593087822, -0.0018963676, -0.0298167355, -0.0188897159, 0.0134974746, -0.0311110001, -0.056869369, 0.0029942174, 0.0740221217, 0.0004568865, 0.0449391603, -0.0235926136, 0.0259261727, -0.0172563698, 0.024881579, 0.0467248894, 0.0706562623, 0.02007984, -0.0687914267, -0.0594284795, 0.0528157726, -0.0645112246, -0.0527458303, 0.0530114397, -0.0424656607, -0.0567647927, -0.0531927608, -0.0068540573, 0.0559875891, 0.0004106366, -0.0271480381, 0.0108615318, -0.0008393172, 0.0131192887, 0.0215874705, 0.0240426753, -0.0172518492, 0.0163764153, -0.0276609324, 0.0428014994, 0.0322344974, -0.0345848724, -0.0594011657, -0.0443849042, -0.0050498694, 0.0289210659, 0.0123517709, 0.0879181325, -0.0152736213, 0.0276747104, -0.0496648736, -0.034784779, -0.0214966722, 0.070013158, -0.014672515, -0.0325020701, -0.0413193665, 0.0042680078, 0.0626320019, 0.0091805849, 0.0303738639, 0.0194477029, 0.0229728073, -0.0370720811, -0.0647874922, -0.0341554508, -0.0198730417, 0.0139335301, -0.0224846136, 0.0053106141, 0.0242066123, 0.0669222921, -0.0111189662, 0.0216169115, -0.0001478862, 3.057e-7, 0.0996423438, 0.0712939799, -0.0110951401, -0.0904023573, -0.0046365527, 0.0095057636, 0.017729193, -0.0159845483, 0.052992098, 0.0189690031, 0.085928224, -0.0214160774, 0.0188766327, 0.0782531723, -0.0181834903, -0.0642039254, -0.052767206, -0.0543057546, -0.0207357742, -0.0292729512, 0.0357048251, 0.0037333572, -0.0580147207, 0.0105090421, -0.0342995599, -0.014791863, 0.00253444, -0.0535492264, 0.0149568263, 0.0327581801, -0.0403634273, -0.0166769139, 0.0116362264, 0.0383217633, -0.0339716412, 0.0089491848, 0.0198892541, 0.0623987205, -0.0511872433, 0.0817243978, 0.0389973558, -0.023632763, 0.0253782086, -0.0273058601, 0.0529195294, -0.0341023989, 0.0019165766, 0.0246164333, 0.0160151627, 0.0095553715, 0.0551447719, 0.0303505473, -0.0165590625, 0.0641375259, -0.0056393459, 0.0246072244, -0.0015904179, -0.0384815633, 0.0039100219, 0.0415601879, -0.0050954223, -0.0623415373, 0.0489947796, 0.0113409264, 0.0170989037, -0.0129380748, 0.0166403372, 2.699929149e-34, 0.0404528379, -0.019172471, -0.034237653, 0.0106426962, 0.0504599027, -0.0150791518, -0.0291558336, 0.0567589402, 0.0084409248, -0.0587418042, 0.0058594104 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.06568v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.06568v1
Ankh: Optimized Protein Language Model Unlocks General-Purpose Modelling
2023-01-16T19:04:45
2023-01-16T19:04:45
Ahmed Elnaggar, Hazem Essam, Wafaa Salah-Eldin, Walid Moustafa, Mohamed Elkerdawy, Charlotte Rochereau, Burkhard Rost
cs.LG
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.DC, q-bio.QM
As opposed to scaling-up protein language models (PLMs), we seek improving performance via protein-specific optimization. Although the proportionality between the language model size and the richness of its learned representations is validated, we prioritize accessibility and pursue a path of data-efficient, cost-reduced, and knowledge-guided optimization. Through over twenty experiments ranging from masking, architecture, and pre-training data, we derive insights from protein-specific experimentation into building a model that interprets the language of life, optimally. We present Ankh, the first general-purpose PLM trained on Google's TPU-v4 surpassing the state-of-the-art performance with fewer parameters (<10% for pre-training, <7% for inference, and <30% for the embedding dimension). We provide a representative range of structure and function benchmarks where Ankh excels. We further provide a protein variant generation analysis on High-N and One-N input data scales where Ankh succeeds in learning protein evolutionary conservation-mutation trends and introducing functional diversity while retaining key structural-functional characteristics. We dedicate our work to promoting accessibility to research innovation via attainable resources.
[ 0.0305273682, 0.0748327002, 0.0088437311, -0.0141858226, -0.0083965696, -0.0103612561, 0.0396865346, 0.004578413, -0.0192016773, 0.0190745611, 0.0031652844, -0.0442390814, 0.002300296, 0.0926619619, 0.0144553203, 0.0146876471, 0.029119933, -0.0211350992, -0.0136911692, -0.0213665329, -0.0405744612, -0.006297552, 0.0538113564, 0.0081800334, 0.0606074817, 0.024771709, -0.0255641714, -0.0141414786, 0.0501564071, -0.0125342831, -0.021627102, 0.0224936474, 0.019573357, 0.0874823108, 0.0000021009, -0.0428119898, -0.0087019531, 0.0130678611, -0.0291603766, 0.0803339034, 0.022343412, -0.0078321109, -0.0017021926, -0.0147137372, 0.0104773184, 0.0159829147, 0.0762029365, 0.000138529, 0.0037526968, 0.0440940559, 0.0124393506, -0.0642826632, 0.0192160923, -0.0858749598, 0.0243231747, -0.0215056892, 0.040463306, -0.0300281346, 0.0038204221, 0.034619581, -0.0118708201, 0.0596640483, 0.0042328816, -0.0034808007, 0.0252122767, 0.0166353863, 0.0064941756, -0.0622776002, 0.0397961549, 0.0738453642, -0.027067041, -0.0471322425, -0.0355181247, -0.0065282267, -0.0152432742, 0.0096041467, 0.0098389219, 0.0012460279, 0.0214840006, 0.0542905927, 0.0080137113, -0.0171965361, 0.0659583956, -0.0098275272, -0.0074520237, -0.0130936131, 0.0135606332, -0.0176175646, -0.0632114038, -0.0437336341, -0.0404312909, 0.0052363258, 0.024766149, -0.0011615143, 0.045589827, -0.014625066, 0.0264162272, -0.059526246, 0.04228089, -0.0377947316, 0.0522122197, 0.0738718212, -0.0110476846, 0.0286033526, -0.0173159856, 0.0034782893, -0.0327325948, -0.0021727255, -0.0167991407, 0.0169747639, -0.0531234369, 0.0279122293, 0.0338050947, -0.0045575234, -0.031810306, 0.0072978078, -0.0345895737, 0.0274949409, 0.0059817513, -0.0423154049, 0.0169742089, 0.0172533914, -0.0336516313, 0.0173872709, -0.0341955759, 0.0212592054, 0.0207864847, -0.0232522991, -0.0270849727, -0.0633710921, -0.0131901996, -0.0245867949, 0.0016683739, 0.0028340081, 0.0383627675, 0.1070366055, -0.017558286, -0.0603088886, -0.0037073914, 0.0133406976, -0.0384503342, 0.0095553314, -0.0435546637, -0.0111864954, 0.0657860264, -0.0069855573, -0.0070368401, -0.0305505805, 0.0307443775, -0.0560960248, -0.0557363145, 0.0770406052, -0.0535648689, -0.0074721421, 0.0467929021, 0.0240877643, -0.0304848626, 0.009752336, 0.0149655575, -0.0214216858, -0.0393358469, -0.0060710292, -0.0034481487, 0.0066516888, 0.0007935537, -0.0041407831, 0.0160211194, 0.0064279288, 0.007416721, 0.04134655, 0.012688254, 0.0140490504, -0.0187345352, -0.0460894853, 0.0500436351, 0.0340057164, 0.0291843526, 0.0311171524, 0.0059084576, 0.0534003638, -0.013809571, -0.0598670393, -0.0213300921, 0.0021269186, -0.0432584509, 0.027041845, 0.0492958836, 0.0094808536, 0.0003417071, -0.0347534642, -0.0344897471, 0.0116303172, 0.0212164167, -0.0166255087, 0.0258102734, -0.0082822517, -0.0388479196, 0.037948668, 0.0468613878, -0.0623478852, 0.0050657759, -0.050078433, 0.0764137134, 0.0652152449, 0.0517164879, -0.0494152978, -0.0088495566, 0.0117935091, -0.016579818, 0.0721000135, 0.0480356887, 0.0096572023, 0.03504676, -0.0284093749, -0.0120550506, -0.0443485007, 0.0242505707, -0.0067861332, -0.0244697146, -0.0323197097, 0.0556330606, -0.0488572717, -0.0648635104, 0.0038246324, -0.0370102264, -0.0094489735, 0.0095983073, -0.0055393511, 0.0490352213, 0.0065496909, -0.0315670371, 0.0142471781, 0.0265523996, -0.0530595109, 0.0000388082, -0.0122627327, 0.0051970272, -0.0145278359, 0.0809431821, -0.0208795592, 0.0147192767, 0.0034989077, -0.054455474, -0.0256837681, 0.0494743213, -0.0296628606, 0.0709966198, -0.0633189678, 0.0092943506, -0.0530625209, 0.0303797573, -0.0395039022, 0.0529410057, -0.013223459, -0.0238708109, -0.0022502572, 0.0114008216, 0.0282149576, -0.0380668938, 0.0131543633, 0.0010822235, 0.0256832093, 0.0087909354, 0.0244480427, -0.0000925283, 0.0362696834, 0.0203937422, -0.0353729613, -0.0260229576, 0.0086492077, 0.0361284502, 0.0119723268, -0.0150318854, -0.0025085083, 0.0203350037, -0.0265119057, -0.006340059, -0.0502747558, -0.0083312923, 0.0333734192, 0.0196793154, -0.0356464572, -0.0598179698, -0.030653026, -0.0614681765, 0.0717305318, 0.0009993019, -0.0209335312, -0.0023300643, 0.0132819796, -0.0173905082, 0.0103021301, -0.0128986835, -0.0250067301, -0.0107282074, -0.0193825588, -0.0070927474, -0.0320124142, 0.0013238064, -0.0309614651, 0.0797475576, 0.0391103178, -0.0265581682, 0.0162490718, -0.0370324142, 0.0060518081, 0.0205677543, -0.0488586426, -0.0067973151, 0.0789164677, -0.0165720135, -0.0281266421, -0.0756334513, -0.0194502156, 0.0484755412, -0.0214326233, 0.0076011848, 0.0113098491, -0.0183840003, 0.017437797, -0.0072478275, -0.0405517742, 0.0675673708, -0.026721539, 0.0263150968, -0.0453295931, 0.0157238301, -0.0364624821, 0.0396636948, 0.002901182, 0.0496046729, 0.0455115438, 0.0104576992, 0.0213502869, 0.0422740504, 0.0062190495, -0.0360520482, 0.0085456893, -0.0281027108, 0.001055858, 0.0069272476, -0.0418679714, 0.0135721713, 0.0463939831, -0.0409607589, 0.0028166778, 0.0256758463, -0.0364621282, -0.0592948049, 0.0289502274, 0.0080605755, 0.0480632745, -0.0026859231, 0.0169421881, -0.0194523502, -0.0370781645, 0.0049070669, 0.0012839058, 0.0406639688, -0.0184906553, 0.0427097827, 0.0403067023, -0.0290589556, 0.0485865399, -0.011164153, 0.0071012503, 0.0007993747, 0.0141585674, 0.0018254173, 0.009907796, 0.0105945487, -0.0221452806, -0.0118746944, 0.0508681573, -0.0038410481, -0.0629265457, 0.0149361379, -0.0302188061, 0.0307680853, 0.0046977825, 0.0418190695, -0.1034513265, -0.049150575, -0.0085835028, 0.0369522385, 0.0142105464, -0.0315274373, 0.0056826659, -0.0518870316, 0.020789776, 0.0458709858, -0.021248119, -0.0181420818, -0.0575501882, -0.0475121289, -0.0575116277, 0.0184545945, 0.0616613887, 0.016409602, 0.0341958329, 0.0045582429, -0.0170092694, -0.0951063633, 0.0202087741, -0.0213854816, -0.0216588303, 0.0714582577, -0.0088807978, 0.013486797, -0.0525037162, 0.0354650132, 0.0498449132, 0.0397067033, -0.0113698561, 0.0314735845, 0.0555236861, -0.0476797633, -0.0196892582, 0.0291301627, -0.0673960894, -0.0114216143, -0.0225558113, 0.068940565, 0.0090041449, 0.0000136229, -0.0485395603, -0.0556697585, -0.0538581908, 0.0477217697, 0.0504587293, -0.0389957353, -0.0405750051, -0.0198055878, -0.0081535922, -0.0763549507, -0.0188520849, -0.0123175308, -0.0053555276, -0.0416779034, -0.0107547529, 0.0399343558, 0.0229201727, -0.0052183303, 0.0459992774, -0.0170313735, 0.0108820414, -0.0319557339, -0.0629148856, 0.0095628724, -0.0057939142, -0.0129336324, -0.0641243532, -0.0450892784, 0.0491963401, -0.0209638998, -0.0180065706, 0.0731927305, -0.0485637486, -0.098883763, -0.0263225269, 0.0640691891, 0.0189130008, -0.0076803984, 0.0276980475, -0.0256484803, 0.10520906, 0.0486147776, 0.0297665987, -0.0120306853, 0.0138487136, -0.0368603058, -0.0246787388, 0.0099204658, 0.0125115952, -0.0158068165, -0.0024944383, 0.0508179851, 0.012654732, 0.0283319503, 0.0224685688, 0.0099549936, 0.0330203101, -0.0288651176, -0.043923758, -0.0395343527, -0.0166672692, 0.0391709805, 0.0074940342, -0.0199707188, 0.018955322, 0.0309728663, -0.0289643127, 0.0116416486, 0.0019478877, 0.0200303625, 0.0326478928, -0.0459839851, 0.0211680178, 0.0204764884, -0.0323539414, 0.0449869335, -0.0352700725, 0.0037866801, 0.048800461, -0.0573481321, -0.0124323172, 0.01461183, -0.0266923606, 0.0043114661, 0.0439275615, -0.0358267613, 0.0207186714, -0.0358811207, -0.0557096153, -0.0554626584, -0.0136495735, 0.0636190623, 0.0254927948, 0.0433988012, 0.0002707016, -0.0438964851, -0.0405520387, 0.0357798897, -0.0218242295, -0.0157433525, 0.0463013053, 0.0261786208, -0.0757266432, -0.0314202867, 0.0817691609, 0.0460111275, 0.0569724329, -0.0145845786, 0.0001000151, 0.0003833195, -0.0183372665, -0.0385664999, 0.0667104572, -0.0536064617, -0.0279150922, -0.0403301865, -0.0355481058, 0.0180412661, 0.0040838448, 0.0053913351, 0.0290977135, -0.0030298848, 0.0350872017, 0.0240167268, -0.0613719374, -0.0099758459, 0.0270669237, 0.0051665818, -0.0200573802, 0.0405803621, -6.538470595e-33, 0.0080524012, 0.013654924, -0.0575963259, -0.0252155159, 0.0263048559, 0.0280375909, -0.0721993521, -0.0009933853, -0.0168172568, -0.0144379726, 0.0047439435, -0.016405521, -0.0171865579, -0.0427330211, 0.0409072563, 0.0092789531, 0.050372079, 0.0225020889, 0.0014586301, -0.0005782979, 0.0210115965, 0.0367259271, 0.0365995206, -0.0116862739, -0.0174842011, 0.0532292947, -0.0074217697, -0.0324590057, -0.0107778544, 0.0109584108, -0.0440052785, 0.0429160483, -0.0445415378, -0.024054084, -0.0411689244, -0.0858052224, -0.0443884656, 0.0317782462, -0.0129698934, -0.0112473965, -0.040447779, -0.0264334101, 0.027336847, 0.0077048037, -0.0476573221, 0.0005265854, 0.0098770251, -0.052773308, -0.0509598032, 0.0173772611, -0.0470881648, 0.0247165579, 0.043885801, 0.0253900122, 0.0305103622, -0.0267957002, 0.0301490482, 0.0311658606, -0.0433196314, 0.0435946509, 0.0620555431, -0.017882444, 0.0827282667, 0.006193215, 0.0330128409, 0.0203275438, 0.0097948164, -0.0223349277, -0.0082510365, 0.0019354777, 0.0487946644, 0.0478333309, 0.0333953127, -0.0135591617, 0.0346810408, -0.0419442207, -0.1054253727, 0.0290752519, 0.0179908276, -0.0183539968, 0.0144971395, 0.0613169782, 0.007660633, -0.0192987863, -0.0180270653, -0.0175837576, -0.0152028538, -0.0228968784, -0.0131628653, 0.003367522, -0.0576498173, 0.0097028529, 0.0369677693, -0.0393169895, -0.024578074, 0.0691882893, -0.0283421129, -0.019475596, 0.0252065323, 0.0046461555, -0.0519941896, -0.0422106013, -0.0050858269, -0.0335202664, 0.0117209749, -0.033534579, 0.0132155064, 0.0304203387, -0.0078112613, 0.031975463, -0.0554106943, -0.0455978364, 0.0408721566, 0.0837792754, 0.0042852513, -0.0123737091, 0.0115669798, 0.0612072162, 0.0212525204, 0.0390552543, -0.0154144252, 0.0948073268, -0.0025958014, 0.0395065658, -0.057516586, -0.002707354, -0.0065297657, 0.0215958357, 0.039677728, -0.0732619315, -0.0702761635, 0.022807274, 2.866e-7, 0.0797273666, 0.0467615388, 0.028810177, 0.0062484494, -0.0137185594, 0.0579231791, 0.0083284425, 0.0183842666, -0.0435244888, 0.0040071541, 0.0112081273, -0.0180065837, 0.0154098393, 0.0172745194, -0.0076587452, -0.0010233916, -0.0402376354, 0.0298056789, -0.0376438797, 0.0159925763, -0.0258459672, 0.1023541838, 0.0022648531, 0.0007501128, 0.0844019502, -0.056421537, 0.0536160804, -0.0236043893, 0.0366352312, 0.0389907844, -0.0440556258, 0.0190836489, -0.0272973515, -0.067922093, -0.0400810316, -0.017314963, 0.0002161254, 0.0504141338, -0.0130317165, -0.0244582463, 0.0675219074, 0.0044442653, -0.0151666123, -0.0706340894, 0.050009679, -0.0054559088, -0.0264591798, -0.016879769, -0.013715175, -0.003756921, 0.014423877, -0.0263762977, 0.0276724733, 0.0203824267, -0.0239491109, -0.0006653096, -0.0275263991, -0.0244584121, -0.0697905794, -0.0576685257, -0.0616165847, 0.0347985327, -0.0662456527, 0.0230348352, 0.0281213336, 0.0068915575, 0.0262009576, 2.66288225e-34, 0.0748431981, -0.0254525747, 0.0099945748, 0.0080661299, 0.0264729075, 0.0003127758, 0.0224888586, -0.0019716506, -0.0339220949, -0.0648698956, -0.0420574546 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.06544v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.06544v1
Distinguish Sense from Nonsense: Out-of-Scope Detection for Virtual Assistants
2023-01-16T18:10:12
2023-01-16T18:10:12
Cheng Qian, Haode Qi, Gengyu Wang, Ladislav Kunc, Saloni Potdar
cs.CL
cs.CL
Out of Scope (OOS) detection in Conversational AI solutions enables a chatbot to handle a conversation gracefully when it is unable to make sense of the end-user query. Accurately tagging a query as out-of-domain is particularly hard in scenarios when the chatbot is not equipped to handle a topic which has semantic overlap with an existing topic it is trained on. We propose a simple yet effective OOS detection method that outperforms standard OOS detection methods in a real-world deployment of virtual assistants. We discuss the various design and deployment considerations for a cloud platform solution to train virtual assistants and deploy them at scale. Additionally, we propose a collection of datasets that replicates real-world scenarios and show comprehensive results in various settings using both offline and online evaluation metrics.
[ 0.0608308464, 0.0186884981, -0.0121337418, 0.0137600247, -0.0159135889, 0.0241959132, 0.0279506221, -0.0017973642, 0.0629774183, -0.023025535, -0.0061654211, 0.0144777661, -0.0309306104, 0.0446757302, -0.0424311943, -0.0379511639, 0.0478027575, -0.01492118, -0.0055419928, 0.0115895486, -0.007550614, 0.0386288539, -0.0535660982, 0.0348126441, -0.0341094695, -0.0555623472, -0.0248436015, 0.0025742445, 0.0094156256, 0.008075797, -0.011152707, -0.0387936868, 0.0218373872, 0.0468047932, 0.0000016399, -0.0571011864, -0.0645627603, 0.0026481096, -0.053298302, -0.0767785385, 0.0531577989, -0.0039155041, -0.0171085242, 0.0668974146, -0.0377294384, 0.0259582438, 0.0633630604, 0.020127289, 0.0440318659, 0.0685428157, -0.0168024283, 0.0491122529, -0.0066261305, 0.0082266489, 0.0075942506, -0.1161307618, -0.0013173515, -0.0159546603, 0.0133738564, -0.0267101247, 0.0008249636, 0.0106194718, 0.0051372796, 0.0201889854, -0.0106666302, 0.0353753082, -0.0697323531, -0.0060666827, -0.0463867337, 0.0503056534, -0.0047429828, 0.0111387121, 0.0109893866, 0.0159780849, 0.0061226566, 0.0119115356, -0.0374678448, 0.0067257117, -0.0143832183, -0.0341557562, -0.0193566289, 0.0273042824, -0.0037395298, 0.0218223874, -0.0074667935, 0.0431073792, -0.0078616291, -0.0405606702, -0.0089983502, -0.0065545947, -0.002467531, -0.0552710965, 0.013198209, 0.0458761193, -0.075679712, 0.0223267395, -0.0629031658, 0.0249765739, -0.0085846512, -0.0082547804, 0.035157077, 0.0078451866, -0.0161149073, 0.0669114068, 0.0204643551, 0.0440576673, -0.0216109548, -0.010723345, -0.0189019982, -0.0434655026, -0.0820643306, 0.0142880864, -0.0449283943, 0.0332008675, 0.009562837, -0.0448765233, -0.0153677473, 0.0532624014, -0.0277688373, 0.0336454511, -0.0406079181, 0.0369563028, -0.0315847248, 0.008450184, -0.0224381238, 0.0011572576, -0.0324960388, 0.0316472948, -0.0030279052, -0.109217003, -0.013105792, 0.0294489395, 0.0144863725, 0.0165572464, 0.0041281236, 0.0835879669, 0.0358211175, -0.047213614, 0.0565678962, -0.0574398339, 0.0013568026, -0.0625682995, -0.0022221128, -0.0283906758, -0.0005320695, -0.020367194, 0.0149903102, 0.0135795847, 0.0083269281, 0.0322785266, 0.0044487538, 0.0427150913, -0.0439700112, 0.0293104742, 0.0258333609, 0.0220841262, -0.025482513, 0.0795664117, -0.0135112405, 0.0036142804, 0.090263702, 0.0380353443, 0.0670329258, 0.0019320669, -0.0122494521, 0.0058269165, -0.0038070879, 0.0416612476, 0.015864199, 0.043792069, -0.0109698139, 0.0037256563, -0.0177929718, -0.0145262806, 0.031804543, 0.0431553461, -0.0269829147, -0.0165652316, 0.0169525649, 0.0495400615, -0.0086062718, -0.0068993443, -0.0459369645, 0.0273510627, -0.0399044268, -0.0498038456, 0.001637293, 0.0028738519, -0.028511934, -0.033443518, 0.0166678727, -0.0301517062, -0.0331915356, 0.0146540562, 0.0471727364, 0.0185224377, -0.0105960146, -0.0019759706, -0.0110645555, -0.0246831588, -0.0479824729, -0.0272344463, 0.0121572427, 0.0573124401, 0.1033513695, -0.0533447452, -0.0526971519, -0.0258965474, -0.0085520344, 0.031195512, 0.0180463679, -0.0089366501, 0.0235617608, -0.0277313106, -0.0353354514, -0.0042508305, 0.0015285285, -0.0282258056, 0.0255342294, 0.0068284539, 0.0065446063, -0.0516276956, 0.0221926831, 0.0391741954, 0.0053358614, 0.0064633247, -0.0232207011, 0.0231975187, 0.0528099909, 0.0260300692, 0.0196665525, -0.0320382379, 0.0202478617, -0.0020595794, -0.022648992, -0.0109449094, -0.0088351313, 0.0225614738, 0.023363309, -0.058931388, -0.0244504828, 0.0396033339, -0.0300336126, 0.0068293256, 0.0175228957, -0.0609052777, 0.0393889025, -0.0221921708, -0.0213364922, -0.0332672782, 0.0158883985, 0.0383169577, 0.0281636231, 0.0084066158, -0.0077029173, -0.004821083, 0.0164693743, 0.0255010817, 0.0030758739, 0.0220242124, -0.0038994891, -0.0208235402, -0.0053574392, -0.0120287212, -0.0232616123, -0.0748533383, 0.0063096918, -0.148234576, 0.0100354934, -0.0102373958, -0.0123616094, 0.0191559475, 0.02147034, -0.0138783073, -0.0540488325, -0.0089480644, 0.021491671, -0.0159850325, 0.0399240851, 0.0429889299, -0.0240546744, -0.0319763348, 0.0190055221, 0.0300195124, -0.0188156478, 0.0029413523, 0.0044635222, -0.0097797047, -0.0437554345, 0.0243570935, -0.0758957714, 0.037976332, -0.0119665219, -0.0120440517, 0.0148404185, -0.024301013, -0.0031610737, 0.0873960108, 0.0216834471, -0.0127461059, 0.0925740451, 0.0115877455, -0.0213941876, 0.0035010707, -0.0009151022, -0.0306652598, -0.0261525325, 0.0438735671, 0.0134764388, -0.0023853206, -0.0228894223, 0.0320988409, -0.0531763323, 0.0466603227, -0.0327559523, -0.0210292898, -0.0205586702, 0.0357536227, -0.0214839093, 0.08695627, 0.0219318438, -0.0532823242, 0.0604083687, 0.0244553834, -0.0017601604, -0.1004185006, -0.0303938407, -0.0034859865, 0.0392339192, -0.0460948721, 0.0271775052, 0.0260593202, -0.0131249977, -0.0470284112, 0.0179218072, 0.0118379639, -0.0528322794, -0.0074154478, -0.0333183482, -0.0007260067, 0.0247493498, -0.0177209526, -0.0606387705, -0.023321161, -0.0674236193, -0.0059831566, -0.0626233146, -0.0203905664, -0.0485143177, -0.0065688966, -0.0098721208, 0.0558990762, -0.0290946737, -0.0423621759, -0.0182125606, -0.010787366, 0.0363527276, 0.009644785, -0.0269079898, 0.0145733291, 0.0157928858, 0.0439782105, 0.026944181, -0.0702389628, 0.0147597408, -0.0145741412, 0.0180115439, -0.0221002493, -0.0048486521, 0.0346108563, 0.0559034869, -0.0498111844, -0.0558987893, 0.0772314742, 0.0447443537, -0.0456529483, 0.0042993682, -0.0369429812, -0.0319906175, 0.0558127575, 0.0202805419, -0.0880540833, -0.0416929945, 0.0300437845, 0.0698521361, -0.0268397629, -0.0470257737, -0.0091404989, -0.1385824829, 0.0425449908, -0.0383596346, -0.0157662984, -0.074289389, -0.0402575582, 0.0557617582, -0.0199440215, 0.0074741696, -0.0343728699, -0.0093316948, -0.0042858315, -0.0057353545, 0.0035075103, 0.0089368429, 0.0425106101, -0.039883893, 0.0994918942, 0.0854321346, 0.0444203615, 0.0469160788, -0.0143465986, -0.0213090498, 0.0033525063, 0.0136336535, -0.0079530952, 0.0677569807, -0.0172965098, 0.0097667575, 0.0000787502, 0.0066167987, -0.0251953937, 0.0296684243, 0.0557064675, 0.0713468492, -0.0366931111, -0.0037226619, -0.0035245477, 0.0465019308, 0.0411466248, 0.0640482157, 0.0227131806, -0.0261661913, -0.0563720837, -0.0190790072, 0.0166488998, 0.0337146334, 0.0132209081, -0.0185349695, -0.0461659394, -0.059581276, -0.0652799681, -0.0284692105, 0.0209873095, 0.037034221, 0.0082954876, -0.0090569155, 0.0490402766, 0.0565535761, 0.0059452485, -0.0034063947, -0.0621378832, 0.0096102208, -0.0170632806, 0.0304914601, 0.0404981971, -0.0301060062, -0.0120492205, 0.0002478402, 0.0126612028, -0.0054697311, 0.0504070073, 0.0144268265, 0.0290023219, 0.0412734449, -0.0630798414, -0.0264667645, 0.0207204409, 0.0472105779, -0.0907548591, -0.0194890574, 0.0837469473, 0.0432583913, 0.0163866449, 0.0534663461, -0.0772531405, 0.0124958763, -0.0450243093, -0.0361542366, -0.0671511143, -0.0027591337, 0.008773054, 0.0023847613, 0.0300486851, 0.0239571948, -0.0220955294, -0.0016559315, 0.0422049016, -0.0141862193, -0.0135591542, -0.0279005431, 0.0245958511, -0.0098712631, 0.0049975528, 0.0406537876, 0.0313361771, -0.0598950945, -0.0223270971, -0.0179609489, -0.0092896949, 0.0345631465, 0.0272380803, 0.0187091213, -0.0146947028, 0.0060361549, 0.0187318567, 0.0270324778, 0.0316024683, -0.0121119516, 0.06042891, 0.0210950673, 0.0140192602, -0.0170399994, 0.041467607, -0.0635412559, -0.0761011392, 0.042652145, 0.0351881385, -0.0008301479, 0.0094544375, 0.041811917, -0.0232095234, 0.012842292, 0.0030160227, 0.0096654734, -0.0047456087, -0.0425957255, -0.0267626829, 0.0180838611, -0.0131695718, 0.0182490535, 0.0593560152, -0.0514482111, 0.0700419545, -0.001480703, -0.0157814045, -0.0448700488, -0.0007028065, -0.0143314889, 0.0610227808, -0.0118514914, 0.0267802458, -0.0308645032, -0.0357528813, -0.0375082493, -0.0219228547, -0.0274921115, -0.0134221567, 0.051596079, 0.0501870438, 0.0010073463, -0.0148057817, -0.0468445495, -0.03834996, -0.0146598006, -0.0079001179, -0.0004076842, -5.62012298e-33, 0.0003386122, -0.0342613272, 0.0051516872, -0.019135667, 0.0007131086, 0.0172503069, -0.0349451602, -0.003768546, -0.0313636959, -0.0216599386, -0.0136264898, 0.0789872482, 0.0266009476, 0.0088894013, -0.0026521438, -0.0248535536, 0.0345196873, -0.042907197, -0.017274268, 0.0832295418, 0.0667252392, 0.0091567496, -0.0229774285, -0.1009146944, 0.0089547848, -0.004805509, -0.0199945532, 0.0452300981, -0.0000311302, 0.02423645, -0.0166644435, 0.0580475144, 0.0255193338, -0.0091745853, 0.0125211738, 0.017697664, -0.0331618972, -0.0563337021, -0.032043241, -0.0003123391, -0.0175400134, -0.0074693435, 0.0004191013, 0.0152639234, 0.0143132741, 0.0047228993, 0.0504198931, -0.0152810114, -0.0112350527, -0.0033253068, -0.0728854537, 0.008009648, -0.0263046864, -0.0594757944, 0.0585893989, 0.0433676317, 0.0434578881, 0.0138361324, 0.0063661169, 0.037211746, -0.069062382, -0.0288676731, 0.035410475, -0.0285155419, -0.0157051943, 0.0074478076, 0.0183226913, 0.0064732884, -0.0054026949, -0.0248158202, -0.0079674404, 0.051153224, 0.0106737064, 0.0012750437, 0.0240412876, -0.0249987002, -0.0195214041, 0.014096478, 0.0434458368, 0.0281190332, 0.0204532109, -0.0258588362, -0.0834155604, 0.026182102, 0.0119350897, -0.0365138203, -0.0388209485, 0.0040416187, 0.0250001103, 0.0106683448, -0.0147127174, -0.0340531915, -0.0280070603, -0.0692017227, 0.0613770336, 0.0140544726, 0.0042066379, -0.0089686271, 0.0188526027, -0.0044708517, -0.0285879485, -0.052787859, 0.0419455059, -0.0148514984, 0.0374300405, -0.0336593799, 0.0075829416, 0.0115819937, -0.0455100201, -0.0055729677, -0.0218972899, 0.0735983774, -0.0084253727, 0.0443012752, 0.0308493804, -0.0069080396, -0.0096689183, 0.0474647023, 0.0284897145, 0.0389014781, -0.0502493717, -0.0270488858, -0.0465917401, -0.0513257459, -0.0872363076, -0.0224078726, -0.036432635, -0.012912875, 0.0069441949, -0.0297124535, -0.0440623797, -0.0152537236, 2.608e-7, 0.000674368, 0.0668329448, 0.0108559057, 0.0390889011, -0.0009877869, 0.0693634674, 0.0164741687, 0.0463173576, -0.0509754531, -0.0122419223, 0.0237274356, 0.0037782867, 0.0569980852, 0.036428079, -0.0707056969, -0.0175437927, -0.0027936955, -0.0018169035, -0.0684501752, 0.003330786, 0.0293132663, 0.06998685, 0.037350513, -0.0368549041, 0.0233924203, 0.0108121848, -0.0222184621, 0.0096068066, 0.0336323306, -0.0303921904, 0.0241125319, 0.0653406158, 0.0103889555, 0.02401077, -0.0117068505, 0.0448522605, -0.012659465, 0.0457166508, 0.0172174424, -0.0334859043, -0.0103453584, -0.0011089304, 0.0124849817, -0.0574222878, 0.0862056166, -0.0123715671, -0.039964214, -0.0414074995, 0.0107268095, -0.0136582255, 0.0307557881, 0.0204906221, -0.0282400623, 0.0254248157, -0.0118795736, -0.0187815353, -0.0090704588, -0.0667673349, 0.0425169095, -0.0341155604, -0.0353924297, -0.0317767039, -0.0042427508, 0.0115820151, 0.0407084227, -0.0143838199, 0.0261999369, 1.819172558e-34, -0.0058681485, 0.0262981951, -0.0072360318, 0.0145724909, -0.0010627431, 0.0123967417, 0.0343814194, -0.0094683459, 0.0498324744, -0.0132715572, 0.0252679177 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.06527v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.06527v1
XNLI 2.0: Improving XNLI dataset and performance on Cross Lingual Understanding (XLU)
2023-01-16T17:24:57
2023-01-16T17:24:57
Ankit Kumar Upadhyay, Harsit Kumar Upadhya
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.LG
Natural Language Processing systems are heavily dependent on the availability of annotated data to train practical models. Primarily, models are trained on English datasets. In recent times, significant advances have been made in multilingual understanding due to the steeply increasing necessity of working in different languages. One of the points that stands out is that since there are now so many pre-trained multilingual models, we can utilize them for cross-lingual understanding tasks. Using cross-lingual understanding and Natural Language Inference, it is possible to train models whose applications extend beyond the training language. We can leverage the power of machine translation to skip the tiresome part of translating datasets from one language to another. In this work, we focus on improving the original XNLI dataset by re-translating the MNLI dataset in all of the 14 different languages present in XNLI, including the test and dev sets of XNLI using Google Translate. We also perform experiments by training models in all 15 languages and analyzing their performance on the task of natural language inference. We then expand our boundary to investigate if we could improve performance in low-resource languages such as Swahili and Urdu by training models in languages other than English.
[ 0.0155234123, 0.0415797569, -0.0044603734, 0.0817403644, -0.0273070019, 0.0351292863, 0.0432575196, -0.0237337574, 0.0427393056, -0.0058593177, -0.068866238, -0.0383948572, 0.0188133102, -0.0084094657, 0.0008682435, -0.0359073468, 0.0594358519, -0.0346754454, -0.0150524499, -0.0020735667, 0.0059580468, 0.0530285314, -0.0145115396, 0.0203798171, -0.0202349983, -0.0134453792, -0.0006305974, 0.0035199448, 0.0114960922, -0.0212179907, -0.0342432745, 0.0182824004, 0.0419158153, 0.0200334303, 0.0000019246, -0.0658389255, -0.0176183805, -0.0077183936, -0.0425910689, -0.021042265, 0.0146831144, -0.0879513919, 0.0096766921, 0.0004648688, -0.0267178658, -0.0137763554, 0.0561114438, 0.0736328587, 0.0284003988, 0.0776761249, -0.0036430834, -0.0345154703, -0.0066702375, -0.0137899434, -0.0012704185, -0.0454169475, 0.0006498285, 0.0229160693, 0.0105363457, -0.0092397146, -0.0242529102, 0.0420993194, 0.0264860373, 0.0210574195, -0.0679788142, 0.0155369863, -0.019067131, -0.0604322776, -0.0104936883, 0.0797614306, -0.034744963, -0.0265355073, -0.0475185886, 0.0012348152, -0.0256417077, -0.0041856389, -0.0305259693, 0.0416934118, -0.00720745, 0.0303598512, 0.0687178224, 0.0198541619, 0.0467117205, 0.0128961364, -0.0176439285, 0.0638368502, 0.0042583104, -0.009404962, 0.0355888568, 0.0098172054, -0.003120889, -0.0236581285, -0.0159199238, 0.0067917174, -0.027337322, 0.0303734429, -0.0200011302, -0.0371520817, 0.0195060689, -0.045811601, 0.017871473, 0.0505213402, -0.0412139483, 0.0578489266, -0.0299557727, 0.002708931, -0.0043316106, -0.0131628634, -0.0367650762, -0.0648145601, -0.0136241112, 0.0148343304, -0.028725056, 0.0089985682, -0.0759231672, 0.0095823891, -0.0383979939, 0.0073148794, 0.0085027954, -0.0024233102, 0.0387349054, -0.0355998166, -0.0533367805, -0.0057532247, 0.0151353739, 0.0574770346, -0.0474393144, 0.0176998209, -0.0388554484, -0.1076558009, -0.0147195747, 0.0150617016, 0.0119706457, -0.0434390642, 0.0156074762, 0.0980049372, 0.0179118328, -0.052621264, -0.0800920725, -0.0053882813, 0.0057342234, -0.0740075409, -0.0195476767, -0.0569492988, 0.0703596845, 0.0203902386, 0.0051550777, 0.0045441082, 0.0041110441, -0.0152669605, -0.034101408, 0.0946405008, -0.030513972, -0.0199056063, 0.0141322576, -0.0132570965, 0.0212867148, 0.0971822217, -0.0037419912, -0.0232598949, 0.048958119, 0.0274070241, -0.0543547571, 0.0382135399, 0.0103354389, 0.0066634705, 0.0186432023, 0.0231943876, -0.026420882, 0.0310007092, 0.0025122783, -0.0086668367, -0.0114873564, -0.0039955545, 0.0307864789, 0.0545221195, 0.0357889906, 0.0380808376, 0.0438016504, 0.0265735146, -0.0109081585, 0.0056131962, -0.0152721917, 0.0422056429, 0.030590795, -0.0042955894, 0.0068708318, 0.0673784986, -0.0377234407, -0.0579327121, -0.0179615654, -0.0425096862, 0.0119179003, 0.0240881797, 0.0800158456, 0.0348606445, -0.0122648505, 0.0459336154, 0.0959198251, -0.0555572696, 0.0182781667, -0.0400978848, 0.050851211, 0.0412462763, -0.0204366259, -0.0006373592, -0.0143692419, -0.0018865706, 0.0148638673, 0.0348773412, 0.0686770752, -0.01255133, 0.0507724918, -0.0508299395, -0.0100386729, -0.0171274692, -0.0020118421, 0.0582404397, -0.0007585791, 0.0411893465, 0.0077540204, -0.0430375487, -0.0410425514, 0.035518337, -0.0760283098, 0.0020239968, 0.0090703731, 0.0336633585, 0.023921093, 0.0231590606, -0.0076260339, -0.0312433392, -0.0010263548, -0.0403454453, 0.0152340578, 0.0473856069, 0.0105310967, -0.0590566248, 0.0083526857, -0.07110966, -0.0235465672, 0.0268869009, -0.0490153357, -0.0418355763, 0.0503205694, -0.0085665043, 0.0296691917, -0.0709697604, -0.0403895415, 0.0147386268, 0.0377213694, 0.0100468043, 0.0638279617, 0.0294246301, 0.0196034182, 0.0234063249, -0.006114623, 0.0745526925, 0.0029426401, -0.0075781019, 0.0426039621, -0.019062005, -0.0208513718, 0.0218904391, 0.0226068404, -0.0286892559, 0.017932279, -0.083832413, 0.0238872506, -0.0323129557, 0.0160475299, 0.0268739536, 0.0829691887, -0.0087939827, -0.0255790148, -0.0127770975, -0.0169128142, 0.0260067005, -0.0125475433, 0.0147101115, -0.0080876583, 0.0304993615, -0.0244126953, -0.0001419364, -0.0052442923, 0.0366770066, -0.0096121849, -0.0615987033, -0.0358254798, 0.0053134258, -0.0491361469, 0.020380009, -0.0083285933, -0.026932342, 0.0119259227, -0.0047985241, 0.0013298427, 0.0218996909, -0.0400076695, 0.0054176273, 0.0202976391, -0.0180766657, -0.0485960953, 0.0399301425, -0.0045054178, 0.0127630476, -0.0260745659, -0.0240224618, -0.0373470858, 0.0811467245, 0.0080759544, -0.0293149482, -0.0609106161, -0.027352266, -0.0269826055, -0.0272038411, -0.0059658913, 0.0540404581, 0.0396654122, 0.0470902845, -0.0320759863, -0.0076192785, 0.0865075737, -0.0273132846, 0.0057764039, -0.0769854933, -0.0060159322, -0.0546678007, 0.0335571803, -0.0518809482, 0.0338958912, -0.0202576537, -0.014106459, -0.0447092541, -0.0115660755, 0.0140299127, 0.003837988, -0.006835409, -0.0561446175, 0.0132004917, -0.0203832798, -0.0212321226, -0.0343752094, -0.0146767395, -0.0252501797, -0.0261005703, -0.0151720382, -0.0008666866, -0.0194991585, 0.0256418083, 0.0046961638, 0.0017231794, -0.0193424374, 0.0310856886, -0.0144803924, 0.0340713002, 0.0226607732, -0.0114800399, 0.0328090638, -0.0191745758, 0.0096192174, 0.0167762637, -0.0139340116, -0.0051797428, -0.0197716523, 0.0174956545, 0.0276845228, -0.0254348572, -0.0195087772, -0.012154934, 0.0590857789, -0.0390110165, -0.0163892694, 0.073288165, 0.0141951377, 0.002816272, 0.0079271356, -0.0378957391, -0.0032400598, -0.0006704807, 0.0063728117, -0.1001628563, -0.0625682622, -0.0150822178, -0.0270026512, 0.0180547237, -0.0018313621, -0.0158035755, -0.0986023098, 0.0053777797, -0.0094452528, -0.0635068864, -0.0326155461, -0.0615734085, 0.0011435736, -0.0264224391, 0.0444531031, -0.0376880355, 0.0295720622, -0.0099730808, 0.0134033263, 0.0322332345, -0.080943726, 0.0151265068, -0.0291746221, 0.0013902809, 0.0099284174, 0.0413167886, 0.0035120843, -0.0435042791, 0.0117996102, -0.0571657084, -0.0083951596, -0.0400682427, 0.0316129997, 0.0012759294, -0.0287283994, 0.0005893279, 0.0364941731, -0.0248822048, 0.01355433, -0.0349361449, 0.0651166812, -0.0145431822, 0.0028070046, -0.0079835309, 0.0034299109, 0.0075688688, 0.0839499384, 0.0238801017, -0.0247005112, -0.0466832668, -0.0019408248, -0.0356761254, -0.0534091592, -0.0283925571, 0.0337601453, -0.0175755396, -0.0576378666, -0.0102836899, -0.0924824476, 0.0231743269, 0.0035711252, 0.0159405749, 0.014799579, -0.0148681067, 0.0133776795, -0.0192677975, 0.049983982, -0.0178360045, 0.0078319414, 0.0355659872, 0.0161496121, 0.0465360172, -0.0244380757, 0.0049528228, 0.0330181196, -0.0752458647, -0.0576461665, -0.031267371, 0.0454192832, 0.0267721135, 0.0856695771, -0.0320155695, -0.0090155397, -0.0094632385, -0.0242741071, -0.0012239843, -0.0212201402, 0.0218704324, 0.0340918638, 0.0260375701, 0.0791722536, -0.0240418185, 0.011569323, 0.0118762162, 0.0193695389, -0.0549902022, -0.0289888587, 0.0037798774, -0.011167937, 0.0133508518, -0.022239916, -0.0372530445, -0.0585683808, 0.0284356494, -0.024749944, -0.0278064832, -0.0182080865, 0.0080391634, 0.0419123173, -0.0105771832, -0.0190810766, -0.0052740476, -0.0333289877, -0.0084934803, -0.0332714468, 0.0334898457, 0.0636368617, 0.0267361552, -0.0365599096, -0.0186620895, -0.0206260607, 0.0075455182, -0.007134058, 0.0412877277, -0.0260142498, 0.0163781568, -0.0057764524, -0.0097462069, 0.0184314661, 0.0000360404, -0.0147460625, -0.0410745591, -0.0003071318, 0.0146284718, 0.0622749515, -0.0464551523, 0.0778071731, 0.0216642674, 0.0024456768, 0.0200830568, 0.0716235563, -0.0036129209, -0.0097565027, 0.0388665088, -0.0281894021, -0.0207013972, -0.001812138, 0.0620746762, -0.0099010961, 0.0270816553, 0.0042696605, 0.026880566, -0.0368281156, -0.0214708429, 0.0299960468, 0.0049164402, -0.0217522811, 0.0467188247, -0.0369746312, -0.0703963488, 0.0073957965, 0.0140530737, -0.0063597434, 0.034850914, 0.0169632193, 0.0851031914, 0.0330714285, -0.0200599842, -0.0334100574, -0.0238218773, 0.0314503573, -0.0211517252, -0.0179517064, -6.179525313e-33, -0.0040594721, 0.0397269875, -0.0042318907, -0.0134191671, 0.0164351333, -0.0200365093, -0.0416770279, -0.0169163272, -0.0596524477, -0.0033255054, 0.002481909, 0.0359058864, 0.0330255404, 0.0222739466, 0.0020188135, -0.0167240407, 0.0192811359, 0.0107342973, 0.0063868002, 0.0133206183, 0.054365214, 0.063340202, 0.1381011903, -0.0606704541, 0.0687691718, -0.0217007026, 0.0244513135, 0.0104262037, 0.0086876974, 0.0375116691, -0.0235828236, 0.0326557122, 0.0406951532, -0.0447876304, 0.0078062611, -0.0028327352, -0.1028317735, -0.041095674, 0.0620221458, 0.056414824, -0.0470105223, -0.0152489124, 0.0210823882, -0.0208785329, 0.0128676575, -0.0052049565, 0.0216807481, -0.0245171748, 0.0230363999, 0.0240806229, -0.0567725711, 0.0363300703, -0.0306442827, -0.0174583197, 0.0411857478, 0.1108128577, -0.0204667673, 0.0158252884, -0.0618428178, -0.0028149812, -0.0331695639, 0.0244735945, 0.0664090812, -0.0207992084, -0.0335123278, 0.016979415, 0.0225217436, -0.0461101942, 0.0213801377, 0.0153623084, 0.0253304839, 0.0138563365, -0.0042419629, 0.0815730765, 0.0441528335, -0.0251057986, -0.1204651445, 0.0370874591, 0.0146790389, 0.0410447307, -0.0085224817, -0.0249187816, -0.0285461769, -0.0027011593, -0.0116611142, -0.0833424628, -0.0284902267, -0.014330334, 0.0135219106, -0.0268516336, -0.0307167731, 0.0105183655, 0.0522246659, -0.0275831055, -0.0393388085, 0.0222561825, 0.0187400579, -0.0411118083, 0.0113147339, 0.060861513, -0.0405870415, -0.0429532863, -0.0295147635, 0.0055759414, 0.0216853451, -0.0026504064, 0.07667882, -0.0108704632, -0.029447047, 0.008327621, -0.044815246, 0.0011205715, -0.0268316865, 0.0925281048, 0.0370324068, 0.0192243475, -0.0175947063, 0.0178093649, 0.0305437092, 0.0120100072, -0.0116395783, -0.0159592088, -0.0107506197, -0.0001096737, -0.0383891761, -0.0291674491, -0.0353831463, -0.0070510446, -0.0043778997, -0.0767224282, -0.0066843983, 0.0635093227, 2.608e-7, 0.0436024033, -0.0137842922, 0.0301144719, 0.0242407899, -0.0167301167, 0.023599809, -0.0378374606, 0.0144195324, -0.0098511847, -0.015128986, -0.0000396631, 0.0575179569, 0.0588885695, 0.0229951888, -0.0763015226, -0.0052438495, -0.0063068382, 0.0208094511, -0.0655301958, 0.0244524274, 0.0212091096, 0.133724466, -0.0079881856, 0.0033215019, -0.0209591482, -0.0212866459, 0.056940116, -0.0194783118, -0.0362167619, -0.0001166259, 0.0260927025, 0.0393852666, -0.0096066669, -0.019777203, -0.0385044925, 0.0273113586, -0.0025279929, 0.0334485509, 0.0007866188, -0.0237577464, 0.0255244765, -0.0208779871, -0.0203880053, -0.0164332241, 0.0837172717, -0.0046239384, -0.0374334529, -0.014633866, -0.0001890381, 0.0198065545, 0.0426549651, -0.0204414949, -0.0086038131, 0.0302409884, 0.0415006727, -0.0673229396, -0.0328349508, -0.0393677317, -0.0082063787, 0.0220243838, -0.0173022505, 0.0036612425, -0.0009229589, -0.017072279, 0.0503006727, -0.0368323512, -0.0052816463, 1.854827919e-34, 0.0312724784, -0.0140674189, -0.0019796237, 0.0108780852, 0.037639726, -0.0411194675, -0.0357614569, -0.0239799321, -0.001313939, -0.0227170736, -0.0074503394 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.11276v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.11276v1
BayesSpeech: A Bayesian Transformer Network for Automatic Speech Recognition
2023-01-16T16:19:04
2023-01-16T16:19:04
Will Rieger
eess.AS
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD
Recent developments using End-to-End Deep Learning models have been shown to have near or better performance than state of the art Recurrent Neural Networks (RNNs) on Automatic Speech Recognition tasks. These models tend to be lighter weight and require less training time than traditional RNN-based approaches. However, these models take frequentist approach to weight training. In theory, network weights are drawn from a latent, intractable probability distribution. We introduce BayesSpeech for end-to-end Automatic Speech Recognition. BayesSpeech is a Bayesian Transformer Network where these intractable posteriors are learned through variational inference and the local reparameterization trick without recurrence. We show how the introduction of variance in the weights leads to faster training time and near state-of-the-art performance on LibriSpeech-960.
[ -0.0521766655, 0.0939969122, 0.0095758289, 0.0046555311, -0.030301854, -0.0385625884, 0.0037108748, -0.0486527942, -0.0525875948, 0.0305728707, -0.0217935629, -0.050298579, 0.0336774215, 0.0372313336, 0.019725319, -0.0384479985, -0.0006589048, -0.0256148912, -0.019307524, -0.0297881011, -0.0280786548, -0.0288483109, -0.0717676505, 0.0485894382, 0.0004936483, 0.0421295166, -0.0060373824, 0.0024077855, 0.0371072218, -0.0219458696, 0.0045587705, -0.0313245244, -0.0036322337, 0.0231897086, 0.0000020176, -0.0134187592, 0.0022888654, -0.019907549, -0.0185584091, -0.0237773303, 0.0664785802, 0.0043573137, -0.0092318179, 0.0261487737, -0.0222161487, -0.0590526611, 0.0547571108, 0.0656438246, -0.0113125173, 0.08066912, -0.0013537579, -0.0647783652, 0.0548983328, -0.0433690138, 0.0263710264, -0.046193216, -0.0010939135, -0.0010783046, 0.0074027516, -0.0481923223, -0.0098627424, 0.0424034148, 0.0574296489, 0.0024733427, 0.0254718829, 0.0396110788, 0.0589717068, -0.0110075194, -0.0056949947, 0.0617396496, -0.0443872027, -0.0127815809, -0.0161151681, -0.0365089141, -0.008298819, 0.0493906662, -0.00856693, 0.0566692539, 0.009273299, -0.0102943294, -0.0170227196, 0.019709859, 0.0624268167, -0.0271639805, -0.0345574692, 0.0285674445, 0.0237671714, 0.0238367766, -0.007006078, -0.025985634, -0.0227074735, -0.0262545217, 0.0348053873, 0.029643124, 0.0231926516, 0.0009910339, -0.0163728986, -0.0298494529, -0.0136597315, -0.0443892591, -0.0172798689, 0.0502658859, -0.0491442867, -0.0002303983, -0.0289355274, 0.0086365622, -0.0358543135, -0.015954623, -0.0145288706, -0.0163237825, -0.0410640687, 0.0331239142, -0.0374053195, 0.0135245845, 0.0032235561, -0.0441902801, -0.0442309007, 0.0076829703, 0.0040976014, -0.0306571126, 0.0417917483, 0.0493123867, -0.0577921085, -0.03931484, 0.0149756586, 0.088142477, 0.0357195586, 0.0391981043, 0.0154860262, -0.0474327542, -0.0250974521, 0.0263008531, 0.0199803486, 0.0030835352, 0.0137739498, 0.0243145749, -0.0051993369, -0.0207528695, -0.042692747, 0.0536933355, -0.0368434526, -0.0368359312, 0.0147350868, -0.0615459718, -0.0020464102, -0.0301330704, 0.0060067885, -0.034242671, 0.0016241918, -0.0120819006, 0.0020840005, 0.0915498137, 0.0671471357, -0.0218890049, 0.0769356713, -0.0178371221, 0.0018315642, 0.0229412131, 0.0574673079, 0.0344130173, -0.0429457948, -0.0347984247, 0.0100547448, 0.0443272442, -0.0211302228, -0.0201640166, -0.0545349941, -0.0413141772, -0.0047428194, 0.0352711901, 0.0619984455, 0.0071456223, -0.0388516076, -0.0225660522, 0.0734556839, -0.0097645, 0.0292701386, 0.016571803, 0.0396099873, -0.0292375106, 0.002298343, -0.0763628334, -0.0250632744, 0.0359573849, 0.0126411514, -0.0011822546, -0.033378955, 0.0268344022, -0.0352397151, -0.0397645161, 0.0303522144, -0.0564883836, -0.0130081838, 0.0246794373, 0.0901150107, 0.0248298496, -0.0313884355, 0.0721690953, -0.0033159095, -0.029661607, 0.0228415802, -0.0277401153, -0.0114778429, 0.0405874252, 0.0006520526, -0.0338118337, 0.0016713958, -0.0532064065, -0.0205894001, 0.0088391528, -0.0115837315, 0.0280713215, 0.0499694869, -0.0739606693, -0.0291061923, 0.0361597575, -0.019489225, 0.0827916265, -0.0278680548, 0.0200616382, 0.0148171624, -0.0245361533, 0.0244924668, -0.0073979031, -0.033228036, -0.0109170526, 0.0595487431, 0.0059970967, 0.0509165972, -0.0102634393, -0.0045896885, 0.0166567173, 0.0333476327, -0.0373524241, -0.0086700665, 0.0359480157, -0.0374040715, 0.0027651761, 0.0575530864, -0.0879255459, 0.0730069131, 0.0413984247, 0.0155703574, -0.095627293, 0.0870475173, -0.0383619182, 0.0231152084, 0.0071030399, 0.0295901783, 0.0512259789, 0.0319855697, -0.0229468253, -0.0339727886, -0.0346313044, -0.0143398587, -0.0086750798, 0.0371416956, -0.0125553468, -0.0495026596, -0.0329394862, -0.0140406815, -0.0030313337, -0.0182332732, 0.0054565337, -0.0076360344, 0.0366084985, -0.0448180586, -0.1219889, 0.0011183855, -0.0376329347, 0.0063432651, 0.0178654026, 0.0569582842, 0.0187106282, -0.0228515584, -0.0346116461, 0.0236656219, -0.0185441058, -0.018426802, -0.004756595, -0.0100803953, -0.0285868626, -0.0152072776, -0.0222547408, 0.0134867337, 0.0299409572, 0.0084134564, 0.0122203231, -0.0187280439, -0.0160853025, 0.029083075, 0.0338888019, -0.0307428166, -0.0392675027, -0.013423305, -0.0111730779, 0.0894194916, 0.0431141667, 0.0301637482, -0.0359853469, 0.0109364493, -0.0056472532, -0.0378792733, 0.0115511054, -0.0450383835, -0.035843756, -0.0276202969, -0.0422234647, -0.0251808185, 0.0263344757, 0.0051863478, 0.0499819741, -0.0280480906, -0.0041035009, 0.0158014167, 0.0177683793, 0.0253358334, 0.0023243616, -0.0299974978, -0.02772546, -0.0012862157, -0.0142145306, -0.0044477386, -0.057280086, -0.0114047369, -0.0194988176, -0.0285172686, 0.0148599194, -0.0036450583, 0.0576371141, -0.0015881856, -0.0081775002, -0.0147428336, -0.0214648005, 0.0512154438, 0.0195427462, -0.0151683679, 0.0381777063, -0.0048134266, 0.0407120436, -0.0228754487, -0.0073263044, -0.0370444283, 0.0257054456, -0.0069946195, -0.0183423553, 0.0237307213, -0.0640389174, -0.0287375133, 0.0225830413, 0.0547081232, 0.0580892265, 0.0048611942, -0.0124882227, -0.025049787, 0.0500820689, 0.0303380303, 0.0213293582, 0.0493478104, 0.0297114607, -0.0427202545, -0.0096001113, 0.0649193376, 0.006466723, -0.1078367159, 0.0023152516, 0.0126692494, -0.0155301495, 0.0048161549, 0.0318514965, 0.0282960534, -0.0118755819, -0.0020036907, 0.0495814644, -0.0130186295, -0.0780855417, -0.0274388995, 0.0198020879, -0.0101064211, -0.006489025, -0.0063713547, -0.0691576898, -0.0267065186, 0.0331229866, 0.0323349088, 0.0208835267, -0.0073550018, 0.0032482531, -0.0903605893, 0.047252994, -0.0022852097, -0.0146818357, -0.0007533185, -0.0375866257, -0.0502476394, -0.0967858806, 0.033386644, 0.0115069039, -0.0154032819, -0.015452208, 0.0550835989, -0.0481851436, -0.0311103463, 0.0032586819, -0.0488080643, 0.0359425358, 0.0324828401, -0.026473308, -0.030016385, -0.0649874881, 0.02760089, -0.031208029, -0.0185281709, 0.0402041972, 0.014545762, 0.0047712997, -0.034014836, 0.031059932, 0.0399736576, -0.0738351494, 0.004134241, -0.0141212074, 0.0414489135, -0.0320757218, 0.0458262786, 0.0013006938, 0.0050930069, 0.0282132253, 0.0306014307, -0.0087552583, -0.0185618214, -0.015570038, -0.0037548889, 0.0324935541, 0.011864556, 0.0043377555, 0.0196319781, 0.0307071153, -0.1169158369, -0.0377203673, -0.0122702094, -0.0019670094, 0.0514093935, 0.0118888011, -0.0360562578, 0.0146443872, 0.0360861756, -0.0699473172, 0.0435302965, -0.0061086142, 0.0244045835, -0.0651465282, -0.0091067441, 0.0473867729, -0.0525684208, -0.0115916282, -0.0112777604, -0.0971062928, -0.0364201553, 0.0161664076, 0.0635167509, 0.0263535846, 0.0236834008, -0.0281839129, -0.0311990287, 0.0331416577, -0.0275962632, -0.016192412, 0.0143036516, 0.0586257726, -0.0053384556, 0.0000735522, 0.0126506565, -0.0188237168, 0.0577253252, -0.0011550116, 0.0091493474, -0.0347376801, -0.0707350895, -0.0280196629, 0.015569401, 0.0450350381, 0.0050772079, -0.0067311721, -0.0399171673, 0.0145757599, 0.0136992289, 0.0698034018, -0.0439311042, 0.0388082787, 0.0379451178, 0.0442821197, 0.0109057017, -0.0048697218, 0.0389416553, -0.0326096416, 0.0279526152, 0.0468600914, 0.0356777981, 0.0229001157, 0.0334108733, -0.0086639998, 0.0183190051, 0.0086216778, 0.0266668405, 0.0121080922, -0.0055914763, 0.0145952012, 0.0281433668, 0.0132010467, -0.0556172058, -0.015057331, -0.0647393987, -0.0529977866, -0.0434869826, 0.0170016326, 0.048319865, 0.0208605323, 0.0359706283, -0.0158345327, 0.0321044214, -0.009025787, 0.0275143255, 0.0034711561, 0.0452683046, 0.0194040071, -0.0040052319, -0.018659221, 0.0513552316, 0.0594985522, 0.0080348747, 0.0394943096, -0.0168102775, 0.0662260354, -0.0338231139, -0.0437410027, 0.0005876682, 0.0222554542, -0.013609577, -0.0402892977, 0.0455574095, -0.0208364446, 0.0600506216, -0.0065774187, 0.0232893974, -0.0658123866, 0.0324136578, 0.0173515007, -0.0060550505, 0.0258479789, 0.0081407102, -0.0177126005, 0.037631359, -0.0049015838, -0.0225363094, -6.441755328e-33, 0.0194010139, 0.0090990216, 0.0073765609, -0.0183777828, -0.0091301259, 0.0021590714, -0.0377111994, -0.0007233038, -0.015702419, 0.0044636121, -0.0026779401, 0.0252601989, 0.0406885222, 0.0328130387, 0.0301395636, -0.039318949, 0.0791766495, 0.0134739494, 0.0213918034, 0.021346176, 0.0342469476, 0.0464610532, 0.0326527655, -0.0088112401, -0.0530829914, -0.0067687049, -0.0273266193, 0.0107208593, 0.0168352127, -0.0115565965, -0.0111778127, 0.0241816957, -0.0210053138, -0.0499458238, -0.0130054587, -0.0199722424, -0.066343978, -0.0081866551, -0.0442804135, 0.0265760887, 0.0145427436, -0.0166093986, 0.0988531113, 0.0474237837, -0.0148027167, -0.0242443029, 0.0444227345, -0.0458842851, -0.0286300052, -0.0375918038, 0.0227385852, 0.0246208422, 0.0016457718, 0.0037544898, 0.0026023039, -0.0156197129, -0.0366710834, -0.0142785311, -0.0529391952, 0.0059832851, 0.0293351319, 0.0171081424, 0.0438972004, 0.0551327653, 0.0286954232, 0.0101822391, 0.0910761878, -0.0487731285, -0.025266543, -0.0209165458, 0.0272263754, 0.0431436524, 0.0448586047, 0.0063020005, 0.0525185056, -0.0371667221, -0.0715127438, 0.0032473574, 0.0516621098, 0.0457750149, 0.0169659667, 0.0421813726, -0.0530343242, 0.0140250335, -0.0120391669, -0.0520201661, -0.0177230407, -0.0183426719, 0.0065629683, 0.0275333319, 0.0311563816, -0.0118753714, 0.0380586311, -0.0255777333, 0.0385114253, 0.0101567768, 0.0329906717, 0.0234071873, -0.0106988363, 0.0104147904, -0.0560005717, -0.0086949607, -0.0103659006, 0.0489122346, 0.006899049, 0.0221844278, 0.0027992791, 0.0573864244, -0.031780079, -0.0425524302, -0.0325441509, 0.0489640459, -0.0141259963, 0.1122986972, 0.0745740235, -0.0324863195, -0.0052087628, 0.0440754369, -0.0543508753, 0.0050413436, 0.0064682397, 0.0075528165, 0.0563031733, 0.0335705318, -0.0669327602, 0.0049596396, 0.0072703711, 0.0067596608, 0.0376390852, -0.0600422285, -0.0141570205, 0.0126331383, 3.031e-7, -0.0268627144, -0.0165266581, 0.0458535068, -0.0280036945, 0.0133476071, 0.0098712398, 0.0081909122, -0.0205003824, -0.0124657275, 0.008818767, 0.0435850509, 0.0081967916, 0.0635887012, 0.0243426803, -0.0787544176, -0.0999156609, -0.0567546673, 0.019573478, 0.0212000795, -0.0184758641, -0.0319855958, 0.0822794214, -0.001393727, -0.0272663552, 0.0560552031, -0.0343943276, 0.025889203, -0.0244968645, -0.0002676776, -0.0307699163, 0.0395485833, -0.0022422057, -0.0123914778, 0.0030306058, -0.0100230081, 0.0180058964, -0.0040922137, 0.0341976359, -0.024853589, -0.0611237995, -0.0049854307, 0.0181375574, 0.0000109155, 0.01835276, 0.0192073751, -0.073844105, -0.0176038537, -0.0321544819, -0.0794881284, -0.0238013584, 0.0053512291, -0.0068771159, 0.0211345199, -0.0070927795, -0.0081316717, -0.0338145792, -0.0289705452, -0.1067663282, -0.0055242185, 0.0344431214, -0.0636232048, -0.0192248616, -0.048557926, -0.067477867, 0.074527733, -0.0191411376, -0.0305243451, 2.070426669e-34, 0.0574996956, -0.0251056459, 0.0023614089, 0.0050705005, -0.0109972162, -0.0244447719, -0.0055097579, -0.0026878705, 0.0139687546, -0.0555622615, -0.0551186465 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.06494v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.06494v1
CRYPTEXT: Database and Interactive Toolkit of Human-Written Text Perturbations in the Wild
2023-01-16T16:04:09
2023-01-16T16:04:09
Thai Le, Ye Yiran, Yifan Hu, Dongwon Lee
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SI
User-generated textual contents on the Internet are often noisy, erroneous, and not in correct forms in grammar. In fact, some online users choose to express their opinions online through carefully perturbed texts, especially in controversial topics (e.g., politics, vaccine mandate) or abusive contexts (e.g., cyberbullying, hate-speech). However, to the best of our knowledge, there is no framework that explores these online ``human-written" perturbations (as opposed to algorithm-generated perturbations). Therefore, we introduce an interactive system called CRYPTEXT. CRYPTEXT is a data-intensive application that provides the users with a database and several tools to extract and interact with human-written perturbations. Specifically, CRYPTEXT helps look up, perturb, and normalize (i.e., de-perturb) texts. CRYPTEXT also provides an interactive interface to monitor and analyze text perturbations online. A short demo video is available at: https://youtu.be/8WT3G8xjIoI
[ 0.0465541333, 0.0851321518, -0.0405025259, 0.0154876858, -0.0353265032, 0.0127925221, -0.0026461578, 0.035216637, 0.0025754662, -0.0421869494, 0.0373306014, -0.0100738304, -0.0104729217, 0.0154211819, 0.0154917315, -0.0864264295, 0.0508803427, 0.021700481, 0.0091958214, 0.0209415071, 0.0937019587, 0.0051678903, -0.0059562325, 0.0262689013, -0.0420269445, -0.0258849207, -0.005495552, 0.035870675, 0.0389043503, -0.0059366804, 0.0106197065, 0.0695647746, -0.0362396166, 0.0779904127, 0.0000020388, -0.0166559145, -0.032892067, 0.0039535882, 0.0071792877, 0.0380289368, 0.1087294221, -0.0014252042, -0.0659149364, 0.0352041274, -0.0416571833, 0.01457066, 0.0714164451, 0.0134951463, 0.0895264894, 0.0731030777, -0.0202316791, 0.0225239471, -0.0260792673, 0.0424642339, -0.0061930846, 0.037345957, 0.0364861041, -0.0528339036, -0.0194301084, 0.0246517584, 0.0171135794, -0.0013294662, -0.0086938208, -0.0683159083, -0.011765128, -0.0334466361, -0.0386527777, -0.0493506193, -0.0007543316, 0.04711321, -0.0120287528, -0.0435979478, 0.0352801494, 0.013004574, 0.0057753036, 0.0272260644, -0.0193313491, -0.0160787348, -0.0043914896, -0.0034427699, -0.0131199732, -0.0407571793, 0.0047791754, 0.0436664112, -0.0040059583, 0.0138493208, 0.001188142, -0.0482064039, -0.0499721393, -0.0089731989, 0.0060802801, -0.0375472233, 0.0617525429, -0.0075655668, -0.0202907808, -0.0011910726, -0.0788821355, -0.1382348239, 0.0211099032, -0.0839770734, 0.0322426111, 0.0085332561, -0.0183282997, 0.0147642503, 0.0199197847, 0.0261769332, 0.0091663646, 0.0279688444, 0.0330388136, 0.0387990586, -0.0000314359, 0.0083465772, -0.025626434, -0.0021213447, -0.0112729371, 0.0263714455, -0.0412509255, 0.0043412452, -0.0364997685, 0.0125974705, -0.0187714733, 0.0180787332, -0.0090491492, -0.0041966438, 0.0100538358, 0.0063105603, -0.0503080077, 0.0141666643, -0.0206875335, -0.0202645194, -0.0028437849, 0.0266951341, 0.0367111675, -0.0073727793, -0.0119930208, 0.0369374268, 0.0087652225, 0.0218271557, -0.0210874304, -0.0719814748, -0.0450186506, 0.0086651845, -0.0754676238, -0.059624888, 0.0103788944, -0.0041730339, -0.0519539863, -0.0554918088, 0.0196528956, 0.0323435813, -0.0521179065, 0.0586003922, -0.0815913752, -0.0180939827, 0.0219549276, 0.0032698349, 0.0184439756, 0.0057897088, 0.0213668272, 0.0064530247, 0.0443199426, -0.0023791366, 0.0081158318, 0.0486617237, -0.0027865137, -0.017708851, -0.0431093462, -0.0251384042, -0.0207846165, 0.0039263181, 0.0024089164, 0.0724695399, -0.0122609157, -0.0142264729, 0.0906438828, 0.0539784022, -0.0319339782, 0.032350719, -0.0285916477, 0.0339614339, 0.0113383243, 0.0301997177, -0.0287592821, -0.0230934042, -0.0401820429, -0.0420255736, -0.0013795549, 0.0134701226, 0.032011956, -0.0255013984, 0.0075638569, -0.0168436412, 0.0594684817, -0.0437870696, 0.0159505457, 0.0031632283, 0.0012608785, -0.0048451102, 0.0271354578, -0.0742002279, 0.01890059, -0.0132005718, -0.0156947989, 0.1017932445, 0.043279741, -0.0368721448, 0.0075591523, -0.0453521498, -0.0043869563, 0.0565681942, -0.0228425674, 0.0016196801, -0.0422210507, -0.0231648479, 0.0055040922, 0.0546110421, 0.0231383871, -0.0127628995, 0.025580788, 0.0239130892, 0.0123513686, 0.0164401531, -0.0063766246, 0.0149923023, 0.0385168344, 0.0098058702, -0.0197716486, 0.0123359449, 0.0080493614, 0.036184676, -0.0399892777, 0.0138371801, 0.0023105226, -0.0148881599, -0.0351811163, 0.0225992985, 0.0132530434, 0.0229511168, 0.0652905107, -0.0415152647, -0.0052949847, 0.0365533903, 0.0055541252, -0.0027972006, 0.0635749996, -0.0615603887, 0.0425091758, -0.0483044311, 0.0046475707, -0.0426799692, 0.0263467822, -0.0233810991, 0.0177417621, 0.0045048227, -0.00702109, 0.0028535919, -0.0297039635, -0.0013586784, 0.0402497128, -0.0224333704, -0.0269542597, -0.0077213538, 0.0251796898, 0.0338246487, -0.0212630052, -0.0420534164, -0.0149510382, -0.0533403568, -0.0399069563, -0.0069437255, 0.0443390086, 0.0429316014, 0.0438004509, -0.0175181739, -0.0265446845, 0.0174602978, -0.0528253317, 0.0087777311, 0.0143144857, 0.0620840117, -0.0355420075, 0.0185840502, -0.0682620332, 0.0054003196, -0.0388473459, 0.0106836949, 0.0195311811, -0.0940191671, -0.0215092022, 0.0004614507, -0.0182255022, -0.00663582, 0.0316066332, -0.0890020207, 0.0181113463, 0.0102440454, 0.073709406, 0.0600022487, 0.0566868074, 0.0674847141, -0.0082228472, 0.0095096985, -0.0186398719, -0.0381246358, 0.0078710243, 0.0031391033, -0.0059355451, 0.0024202894, 0.0236277897, 0.0408510305, 0.0330707692, 0.0027149587, -0.0334351808, 0.0583747625, -0.0544247665, -0.0064320224, -0.0173321553, -0.0625606924, -0.0568791553, 0.0377424732, -0.0186482612, -0.0199436061, 0.063927792, 0.0305807497, 0.0203182418, -0.0096632261, -0.0283707436, 0.0291255321, 0.0096454015, -0.0110431658, 0.0555530712, 0.0002780395, -0.0454441719, -0.0140582994, -0.0467258617, 0.0768896937, -0.0451221429, -0.0330859348, -0.0379924104, 0.0186250936, 0.0244876817, -0.0568364449, 0.0044805561, -0.0897590593, -0.0081538195, -0.0559222996, 0.0623834617, -0.0571302734, 0.0042324727, -0.0110745523, 0.0184816457, 0.0088605173, 0.0026077852, 0.0117201684, 0.0121627739, 0.0218049251, 0.0055108969, -0.033137694, 0.0099696759, -0.0220879242, -0.019494107, 0.1192711443, -0.0309899505, -0.049003873, -0.0013853805, -0.0085225012, -0.0099440552, -0.0385018066, -0.0135348272, -0.0108532496, 0.0428156145, -0.039557796, 0.0129763186, 0.0784034654, 0.0331425518, -0.0519010313, 0.0211487673, -0.0258588009, 0.0226443782, -0.0078424523, 0.020699745, -0.1139372885, 0.0020755867, 0.0171876382, 0.0330528095, -0.0501858182, -0.0517063923, 0.0075302068, -0.0435521416, 0.0203583576, 0.02514611, 0.0278306548, -0.0034511308, -0.027907256, 0.0256539136, 0.0375748314, 0.009461767, 0.0217749663, 0.0379894227, 0.0059370603, 0.0120623158, -0.0663274303, -0.0157871321, -0.0800172687, -0.0410235971, 0.0325882882, 0.0394801795, 0.0426202118, 0.0109515823, -0.0140966168, 0.038686987, 0.0190241449, -0.0028399618, -0.0220243093, 0.0499714687, 0.0304682311, -0.0345654488, -0.0827081576, 0.0322946683, 0.0026943837, -0.0266372748, -0.0286070015, 0.0215565823, -0.0038250324, 0.014043699, -0.0391830131, -0.0055348608, 0.0534503162, 0.0042668139, 0.0423751511, -0.0636006817, -0.04256659, -0.0698326081, -0.0092932712, -0.0562631898, -0.0545796119, -0.0482400395, 0.0329495445, -0.024814304, -0.0864014253, -0.0166242849, -0.024715947, 0.004394995, 0.0217566304, -0.0389645658, 0.0492874198, -0.0006193689, -0.0413272493, -0.0159736238, 0.0248515587, 0.0406987816, -0.0069277952, -0.0149601791, -0.0318943858, 0.0470794402, 0.0066595944, 0.0132486811, -0.055982776, -0.0654004812, 0.0691099986, 0.0169660319, 0.0220488477, 0.0247675329, -0.0359630696, -0.0622528084, 0.0250591468, 0.0626361519, -0.0620091595, -0.0098593244, 0.0079758465, -0.0117938248, 0.017538093, 0.0046562743, 0.0277177822, -0.0119656557, -0.0010835847, -0.0144792423, -0.089845635, -0.0152567532, 0.018190233, 0.0176804196, 0.0180482026, -0.0170398708, -0.0260515772, -0.0215204041, -0.012666272, -0.0518073216, -0.0374624357, -0.0152038736, 0.0158645418, -0.0049863476, -0.0149011947, -0.0267269574, 0.0067613968, -0.0693423301, -0.0127469385, -0.0045902659, 0.0312377177, -0.0048957537, 0.0319912806, 0.0501455404, 0.0169483032, 0.0229785349, 0.0552292913, -0.0010155629, 0.044476416, -0.0329772197, -0.0178297404, 0.0018068543, -0.0111378441, 0.019380331, 0.0141821997, -0.0475811847, 0.0271740519, -0.0289173629, -0.0107773868, 0.0168255735, 0.0159095153, 0.0752366409, -0.006926571, -0.034827251, -0.0077336044, 0.020955991, -0.0007443873, -0.0185205322, -0.0462920703, -0.0159874037, -0.0280987322, 0.0034964341, 0.0576107986, -0.0633013695, 0.0379514508, 0.0252716299, -0.0429442786, -0.0356303602, 0.0153553691, -0.0233552195, 0.0302964244, -0.020953469, -0.0101238871, -0.0166421328, -0.0383810028, 0.0060148407, 0.0049651237, 0.0057161446, 0.0111618815, 0.0078333225, 0.0276340842, -0.0229797959, 0.0240214616, -0.0178084746, 0.0458647721, -0.0120838992, -0.0647084042, -0.0139977168, -6.284084801e-33, -0.0166680105, -0.0747295767, -0.0727044493, 0.0185986999, -0.0123986164, -0.0481445864, -0.0237173215, 0.0718680099, 0.0239969995, 0.0299248062, -0.0037044045, 0.0247254279, 0.0138813239, 0.0038762046, 0.0088728415, -0.0224395525, 0.0407930315, -0.0171843879, 0.0036627606, 0.0245284364, 0.0389784612, 0.0338007882, 0.0351000801, -0.1297252625, 0.0630300269, 0.0033407502, -0.050429713, -0.003809541, 0.0177397896, 0.0481615625, 0.0225028861, 0.0535144731, -0.0165567733, 0.0389104858, -0.0241149869, 0.0534109436, -0.0192672405, -0.0144513398, 0.0034891963, 0.0564349927, 0.0160152316, -0.0428905562, 0.0504347906, -0.0307161268, -0.0217588507, 0.0303413812, 0.0319863297, -0.0032911256, 0.0290464051, -0.0198459867, -0.0423293635, 0.0430610627, -0.0473225228, 0.0236918461, -0.0009518314, 0.0440416373, 0.0074805208, -0.0091599114, -0.061650455, 0.0181443468, 0.0350865424, 0.028324252, -0.0009763131, -0.0121854171, -0.0037000079, 0.0339932069, 0.0238510109, -0.0017092081, -0.0273756403, 0.0385975167, 0.0161982924, 0.0105833551, 0.0424736924, 0.1108655706, 0.0251808129, -0.0520911925, -0.0269595683, -0.0110318772, 0.02431597, 0.0197033528, -0.0057418444, 0.0159053542, -0.0197413098, -0.0465287864, -0.0102662761, -0.0503463559, -0.0183641985, -0.0440740325, -0.0094417715, -0.0239674691, -0.0312610753, -0.0114717921, -0.0273920055, -0.0531527698, -0.026796896, -0.0309095252, -0.0234108586, 0.0149521343, 0.0121728713, 0.0035590758, 0.0347149633, -0.000889771, -0.0020122784, -0.0069196871, 0.0522116125, -0.0003150356, 0.0349683873, 0.0168450531, -0.0927627161, 0.0043972405, 0.0232369453, 0.0517159589, 0.0087058656, 0.0259185322, 0.0156874061, -0.0017245676, -0.0121003771, 0.004236232, 0.0464837961, 0.0622849949, -0.0186343472, -0.0243393891, 0.0071247113, 0.0053013419, -0.027474951, -0.0129100336, -0.0060622864, 0.0248623956, 0.0231278893, -0.069239907, 0.0005628311, -0.0308555551, 2.707e-7, 0.0673839524, 0.1283906698, 0.0386936963, -0.0316231772, 0.0447566882, 0.0155238174, 0.0136480862, 0.0134768942, -0.0086647263, -0.0108941672, -0.0019892643, -0.0118932836, 0.0643205643, 0.0264693461, -0.0405038148, -0.036601536, -0.0626061037, 0.0037893842, -0.0578571036, 0.0531324893, 0.0658190027, 0.0339455903, 0.0124971122, -0.0087084137, -0.003684087, -0.014394151, 0.027711859, -0.0093139, -0.0189218055, -0.0250518359, 0.0185045004, -0.0344745703, 0.0196831115, 0.002726723, -0.0274617691, -0.0549436808, 0.0050804755, 0.0564393774, -0.0228029341, 0.0115292333, -0.0006026365, -0.0290815029, 0.0210983921, -0.0493494533, 0.0343416035, 0.0424185544, -0.0030138113, -0.0521164574, -0.037923459, -0.0304261111, 0.029840745, -0.0325889699, -0.0327110253, 0.0078658899, 0.048355449, 0.0498065278, -0.0082184514, -0.034213908, -0.0561322309, 0.0014043705, -0.0144885145, -0.0181158334, -0.0249805599, 0.0261208974, 0.0220432971, -0.0060970043, 0.0402345844, 2.481209598e-34, 0.0422263741, 0.0004691649, 0.0297361705, -0.0159932133, 0.0283358004, 0.0408421271, 0.0734031275, 0.0073058982, 0.0322010107, -0.0422064699, -0.0143321715 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.06475v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.06475v1
Using Kaldi for Automatic Speech Recognition of Conversational Austrian German
2023-01-16T15:28:28
2023-01-16T15:28:28
Julian Linke, Saskia Wepner, Gernot Kubin, Barbara Schuppler
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
As dialogue systems are becoming more and more interactional and social, also the accurate automatic speech recognition (ASR) of conversational speech is of increasing importance. This shifts the focus from short, spontaneous, task-oriented dialogues to the much higher complexity of casual face-to-face conversations. However, the collection and annotation of such conversations is a time-consuming process and data is sparse for this specific speaking style. This paper presents ASR experiments with read and conversational Austrian German as target. In order to deal with having only limited resources available for conversational German and, at the same time, with a large variation among speakers with respect to pronunciation characteristics, we improve a Kaldi-based ASR system by incorporating a (large) knowledge-based pronunciation lexicon, while exploring different data-based methods to restrict the number of pronunciation variants for each lexical entry. We achieve best WER of 0.4% on Austrian German read speech and best average WER of 48.5% on conversational speech. We find that by using our best pronunciation lexicon a similarly high performance can be achieved than by increasing the size of the data used for the language model by approx. 360% to 760%. Our findings indicate that for low-resource scenarios -- despite the general trend in speech technology towards using data-based methods only -- knowledge-based approaches are a successful, efficient method.
[ 0.0004526185, 0.0236895178, 0.0152989477, 0.042786099, -0.0576902814, -0.005743484, -0.0034842426, -0.0110839885, 0.010883173, 0.0339362212, -0.0426145978, -0.018687129, 0.0813267082, 0.0064848331, 0.0091630155, -0.0459824577, 0.0199987888, -0.0998470858, 0.0029385313, -0.0450454019, 0.0343243554, -0.0091326162, -0.0698783845, 0.0108482698, -0.0134497853, 0.0431259908, -0.0101701887, -0.0097445706, 0.0015424073, 0.031893149, -0.0339314714, 0.0185259972, -0.0091868322, 0.0234488118, 0.0000017981, -0.0360792316, 0.0103411078, -0.0167148523, -0.064780578, 0.0108133601, 0.0090094432, 0.0108424285, 0.0031165276, 0.0390000679, -0.0017181328, 0.0060232379, 0.0706517324, 0.0143328914, -0.005369457, 0.0143657289, -0.021730585, -0.0762456059, 0.024109317, 0.0126862312, -0.0538403615, -0.0455130003, -0.0098872408, 0.0052579683, -0.0089197047, -0.0335807912, 0.0123440865, 0.0993459299, -0.0330928825, -0.0076268045, 0.0185225997, 0.0155773377, -0.0538201667, -0.0494767539, -0.033455871, 0.0756875277, 0.0379003473, -0.0329142734, 0.0187923275, -0.0099849533, -0.0152131598, 0.0135900946, 0.0211021695, -0.0038794416, -0.0240916666, -0.0453989543, 0.03669158, 0.0440771692, -0.0224754363, -0.0044739242, 0.0169124044, 0.0131052509, 0.0212509949, -0.0303045101, 0.0546283238, -0.0163543392, -0.0095191356, -0.0026590966, 0.023851335, 0.0002453054, -0.0031810564, 0.0289212782, 0.0086903553, 0.0029522944, -0.0039731977, -0.0431656316, 0.0277996026, 0.0466997884, -0.0212692004, -0.0011567251, 0.0397487767, 0.0596098863, 0.0458798297, -0.0660737976, -0.0066353311, -0.0210973099, -0.0329885706, 0.0332856476, -0.0685209259, 0.0103550553, -0.0484318882, -0.0314248763, -0.0498396754, 0.0435240641, 0.0166509748, 0.0214886852, 0.0386935025, -0.0061977445, -0.0123738348, 0.0070242863, 0.0245612208, 0.064914614, -0.0099709779, -0.0086151464, -0.0246517509, -0.070227772, 0.0135943824, 0.0209480524, 0.0574038699, -0.0153498519, -0.023776615, -0.0056349332, -0.0032925343, -0.0403137989, -0.0123558976, 0.0253650006, -0.0375692211, -0.0278509595, -0.0374285989, -0.0631596148, 0.0563778728, 0.0181373991, 0.0275835656, -0.0227467939, -0.0212921482, -0.0787838846, -0.0253387932, 0.086442329, -0.005364012, 0.0134326285, 0.0479981303, -0.0133804278, 0.001703856, 0.0247464869, 0.0147491423, -0.0502676927, 0.0028315897, -0.0281814691, 0.0051427726, 0.0688152164, -0.0055344421, 0.011681525, 0.0107289776, -0.027031716, -0.0304182582, -0.0128224483, 0.0160725322, 0.0514582172, -0.0254152287, 0.0036592581, 0.0788787454, 0.0237967856, 0.0406582728, 0.0034861884, -0.0250032675, 0.0238124188, 0.0286054928, 0.0026314934, 0.0162654016, -0.0480770394, -0.0351059586, 0.0508138686, 0.0062063625, 0.0130719785, -0.0249864403, -0.0017490799, 0.001385398, -0.0479275063, 0.0349422246, 0.0276746396, 0.0358806588, -0.0216381419, -0.0383100808, 0.0408389494, 0.0540882982, -0.0410353653, -0.0226898175, -0.029613331, -0.0112607973, 0.0707564726, 0.0609881878, -0.0343242884, -0.0560466051, 0.0138479518, -0.0345505215, 0.0448186547, 0.0464949422, -0.0279200431, 0.0680174306, -0.0768860281, 0.0207918845, 0.0584170669, -0.010712699, 0.0784945115, -0.0150682358, 0.0321441777, -0.0037065186, 0.0231161602, 0.0364681929, -0.0415703394, -0.0431060977, -0.0209928397, 0.0212059673, 0.0087589463, 0.017984068, 0.0433847681, -0.0514855646, -0.0106076021, 0.0062507237, -0.0163595993, 0.0701533705, 0.0429838262, -0.0166583154, -0.0369637869, 0.0357075483, -0.0212258957, 0.0100582168, 0.0016248239, 0.0423941836, -0.1076165885, 0.0274996776, -0.0624297149, 0.0762354583, -0.0459763445, 0.029496273, 0.030537609, 0.0081643341, -0.0012797752, -0.018176632, 0.006552184, -0.0419185646, -0.0127250953, 0.0051529841, -0.0404246151, -0.0731629804, -0.0385327749, 0.0252723712, -0.015851045, 0.0459766947, 0.0006722094, -0.0182916, 0.0172099881, 0.0131126754, -0.1000443324, -0.0356663801, -0.0088782534, -0.0081621166, -0.037183892, 0.0912972614, -0.0026168928, -0.0188525785, -0.0301453825, 0.0097653903, 0.0360422805, -0.0107727731, -0.0525193922, 0.0349476598, -0.0471605584, -0.0238543134, 0.0244419258, 0.0378240384, -0.0147226872, -0.0012994151, -0.0253741201, -0.063708052, 0.0273584239, -0.0325258262, 0.0205842759, 0.0061052493, -0.012145211, -0.0402239747, 0.0103905927, 0.0307724848, -0.0132959681, -0.0331916697, -0.01197033, -0.0059662685, -0.0430198461, -0.0816184804, -0.0028075613, 0.0046207611, 0.0446385555, -0.0255592745, 0.0165063124, 0.0078278128, 0.0176667124, 0.0154538453, 0.0529231392, -0.0409961939, -0.0228746887, -0.0191304479, -0.0425726064, -0.0105871148, -0.0304593462, -0.0381426141, 0.0001392223, 0.0352395698, 0.0186074823, 0.0231054109, -0.0908646956, -0.0209448468, -0.0525034741, -0.0421524569, 0.0177129861, -0.0105737057, -0.0277705397, 0.0001715652, -0.0048492802, -0.0397752635, 0.0280718803, -0.011506483, 0.0361315198, -0.0338952504, 0.0439468324, -0.0711788759, 0.0300309435, 0.0335636921, -0.0531071797, -0.0148540083, 0.0099577783, -0.041109968, 0.0035457041, 0.038480632, -0.0352195241, 0.0397004001, 0.0601159967, -0.0127924345, 0.0423352756, -0.0046398398, 0.0431839935, -0.0023991682, 0.1001245528, 0.0298766326, 0.0028279759, -0.0143844755, 0.0241641775, 0.0576820709, -0.03172189, 0.0846057534, 0.0215376671, -0.0149170198, -0.0007872194, 0.0374961831, 0.0124999741, -0.0011424442, -0.0150459222, 0.0243219752, 0.02320184, -0.0081822062, 0.1155963168, -0.0068149958, -0.0292952675, -0.0427692086, 0.0109245582, 0.0548849292, -0.0553432293, 0.0364676677, -0.0557945408, -0.0105105778, 0.0485993251, 0.0698249042, -0.0543503501, 0.0067105414, -0.0109248031, -0.0913604349, 0.0088669052, 0.0274393633, -0.037321981, -0.0347328112, -0.0435897075, -0.0331258699, -0.0357302874, 0.0123147909, 0.0080431672, 0.0252477042, -0.0479162075, 0.0283977799, -0.0557660572, -0.074581109, 0.0466078855, -0.0045878468, 0.100899294, 0.0153101431, 0.0388438813, -0.0209902544, -0.0194454174, 0.0128618712, 0.026328871, -0.002649884, -0.0560038351, -0.0107678128, 0.0108097009, -0.0042454018, -0.0118916305, 0.0331818983, 0.0085775899, 0.0074593932, 0.0277565327, 0.0056661563, -0.0650246441, 0.0056275423, 0.0523435026, 0.0144502735, 0.0475821905, 0.041763477, 0.0360939652, -0.0224466082, 0.0127333356, 0.0068060118, 0.0464592278, -0.0269657373, 0.0061094225, 0.0323545039, 0.0290497337, -0.0716909766, -0.0398467258, -0.0257292055, -0.0095663713, 0.0712555274, 0.0428630821, -0.0227200221, 0.0437708199, 0.0823839456, -0.0485609882, -0.0048213722, -0.0236059707, -0.0129784523, -0.052809488, -0.0123745855, 0.0427165888, -0.0359102562, -0.0130127026, 0.0352324732, -0.0421292856, -0.0949832276, 0.0507564396, 0.0261837393, 0.0332802795, 0.1115815192, -0.0717323497, -0.0721020401, 0.042946294, -0.0183542483, -0.0357769541, -0.0007554641, 0.0182002299, -0.0115942517, -0.007932459, 0.0025752829, -0.0175619759, 0.0263952818, -0.0340655446, -0.0030724369, -0.0672242343, -0.0820160732, -0.0372032151, 0.0755562186, 0.0088524278, -0.0086680157, -0.0036198779, 0.0001161206, 0.0205467679, 0.0426686034, 0.0658615306, -0.0318036191, -0.0398093835, 0.0191802904, 0.0247327089, -0.0138921337, -0.0074000801, -0.0222792197, -0.0250284523, -0.0043251133, 0.0314392224, 0.0767089427, 0.0106943324, -0.0013973747, -0.0108978609, -0.0507166684, 0.079317674, 0.0381886177, 0.0279817246, -0.0042229271, 0.01287595, -0.0309830643, -0.0418648906, 0.035036888, 0.0212461054, -0.0428493023, 0.0078576645, -0.0170726534, 0.0451432168, 0.0159812216, -0.0018861721, 0.0608813092, -0.0418882668, 0.0540454611, -0.064979054, 0.0281074196, -0.021385625, 0.0157474931, -0.0051457272, 0.0119698672, -0.0174408667, 0.0298727937, 0.0261633787, 0.0201176722, -0.0078651384, -0.0154390801, 0.0122905541, -0.0522205383, -0.0655105785, -0.0188212097, 0.0015850022, -0.0542960614, -0.0123223653, -0.0426402465, -0.0514498614, 0.0079974234, 0.0021257482, 0.029282799, -0.0474900603, 0.0162330363, 0.0021573154, -0.035740111, 0.0406141654, 0.011549864, -0.0269528124, -0.0240490027, -0.0381483994, 0.0045445492, -5.739292026e-33, -0.0254309941, 0.0082859034, -0.0020411976, -0.0008176132, -0.0016945034, 0.0156895835, -0.0116513148, 0.0082148509, -0.0134284766, -0.0201582815, -0.0324603319, -0.0334246829, 0.0429388359, -0.0052334857, -0.0233826302, 0.0137495715, 0.0478587374, 0.0072283074, 0.0128978724, 0.0161716323, 0.019193422, 0.0641006604, 0.0275938846, -0.031548582, 0.0157018285, 0.0075270548, 0.0144649846, -0.0307570547, 0.0491652302, 0.0203881375, -0.0126307346, 0.0580732822, -0.0199587401, -0.0359054655, 0.0058522387, 0.0308246762, -0.0870638713, 0.0026757431, 0.0206596013, 0.0933945104, 0.0348040424, 0.0278675426, 0.0131422011, 0.0034646217, -0.0489018783, 0.0120898504, 0.0001105613, 0.0087513858, -0.0479502417, 0.0119279129, 0.0331947207, 0.0406722948, -0.0173931681, -0.0623149909, 0.0760953724, 0.0438570417, -0.0209857989, -0.0771709606, -0.0441906266, 0.0654729232, 0.0217988305, -0.0233576782, 0.0238392707, 0.0196147189, -0.0088932477, 0.0054826033, 0.0388834365, -0.0416812412, 0.0239830837, -0.0414357856, 0.0358215012, 0.0361633152, -0.026270913, 0.0259133969, 0.0049933204, -0.0528195351, 0.017623933, -0.0610594861, 0.0757892579, -0.0424472764, -0.0189057328, -0.0039253859, -0.0737892911, -0.0075686206, -0.0258310642, -0.0226208232, -0.0168059207, 0.0163885709, 0.0421557277, -0.0123345274, -0.0136009278, -0.0046119643, 0.0741733909, -0.0060837758, 0.0243227128, 0.0266009402, 0.0466479473, 0.0177005231, -0.0566385053, 0.0187196862, -0.0281384811, -0.0355918929, 0.0063632252, 0.0355454125, 0.0071730041, 0.0032794343, -0.0323089026, 0.0194649287, -0.0128743947, -0.0018351056, -0.0279690865, 0.0156557187, -0.0304588303, 0.0155280679, 0.0185549464, 0.0078700976, 0.0106506608, 0.0280453078, -0.0000195633, 0.0155865951, 0.0019647034, -0.0542956553, 0.0021324479, 0.0169518515, -0.0464707762, -0.0307650957, 0.0535579994, -0.063105911, -0.0480604358, 0.0215715114, 0.0180378389, -0.0196492095, 2.776e-7, -0.0407387093, 0.0256442819, 0.0194553621, 0.0059485417, -0.0042798193, 0.0056220251, 0.0095793894, -0.0082739387, 0.0007685304, 0.0294884313, 0.0398127809, -0.0086889472, 0.0566350371, 0.018796958, -0.0985438749, -0.0568568371, -0.0434547067, 0.0267563201, -0.0305363927, 0.027017979, -0.0062235617, 0.0665068552, 0.0083209919, -0.0267964844, -0.0027736058, -0.0196273848, -0.0097139701, -0.0042024697, -0.0387267731, -0.006631833, 0.0524872057, -0.0293214191, 0.0026403272, 0.0450304262, -0.0231753141, 0.0217737667, -0.011976881, 0.0527569242, -0.0410268418, -0.0929424837, 0.0211211499, 0.0282843318, -0.0320304409, 0.0043715956, 0.0369420834, 0.0476260409, 0.036029987, 0.025948137, -0.0149232307, -0.0242956523, 0.0086910427, 0.0021326491, 0.0256019011, 0.0252435245, 0.0130925234, -0.0546693243, -0.0025214844, -0.0239892211, 0.0176208653, 0.0200348422, -0.033043243, -0.0226131007, -0.0210162159, -0.0376843885, -0.0018710317, -0.0003317191, -0.0049035191, 1.701174851e-34, 0.0151659707, 0.0033950633, 0.0084477346, 0.0448694751, 0.0288613643, -0.0382766277, 0.026874328, 0.0499347486, 0.0288183875, -0.0125479819, -0.0296434816 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.06469v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.06469v1
Towards an Automatic Consolidation of French Law
2023-01-16T15:18:57
2023-01-16T15:18:57
Georges-André Silber
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.PL
We present preliminary results about Legistix, a tool we are developing to automatically consolidate the French and European law. Legistix is based both on regular expressions used in several compound grammars, similar to the successive passes of a compiler, and on a new specialized language of functional type, allowing to describe the changes applied to the texts. Instead of creating manually a full consolidated version of a text at each modification date, Legistix generates automatically programs from legal documents written in natural language to automatically create the consolidated versions.
[ 0.0062527135, 0.0795688108, -0.011053103, -0.0045884252, -0.0691386238, 0.0095894057, -0.0044945194, 0.0310114138, -0.0297359545, -0.0910681188, 0.0350165814, 0.0008258087, -0.0022061556, 0.010577132, 0.0208269991, -0.0482504517, 0.0547511913, 0.0137342755, 0.0094405385, 0.0154359909, 0.0612049811, 0.0432843417, 0.0274816249, 0.0062586097, 0.0152386865, 0.0504919477, -0.0328810811, 0.0013237545, 0.0033874905, 0.0417901501, -0.0297738798, 0.0727105066, 0.010597039, 0.0255176201, 0.0000016187, -0.0687246248, -0.0381662212, 0.0264785942, 0.0093640164, 0.0490787551, 0.0294803623, -0.0668466985, -0.0695844442, -0.0178896729, -0.0232878514, 0.0174143221, 0.0268987976, -0.0574376546, 0.0419499017, 0.0778269023, -0.0225917846, -0.0747057572, 0.0117182592, -0.0006535386, -0.0055264672, 0.0009834622, 0.0121459803, 0.0131675359, 0.0366713703, -0.0332484618, 0.040792536, -0.0118447021, -0.0107441256, -0.1027319506, -0.0324847884, -0.0538245291, -0.0215082932, 0.0058695404, -0.0016930867, 0.0136589687, 0.0070439647, -0.0479015484, 0.0341071226, 0.0115509601, 0.0380615667, 0.0022719596, -0.0570318587, 0.0439218581, 0.0001050722, -0.0051327124, 0.0567397922, -0.0208544414, -0.0151107498, -0.0394325182, -0.0803475305, 0.0099888826, 0.0287585724, -0.0472255647, -0.0135233663, -0.0128453402, -0.0091990074, -0.0867388994, 0.0281940456, 0.0609426014, 0.013578888, 0.0107031511, -0.0489660203, -0.0371887796, 0.0655137822, -0.0183753241, -0.0224777926, 0.0303492565, -0.0013752541, 0.0494068749, -0.0154089127, 0.0114650419, 0.0057746461, -0.0096633071, -0.0071459715, 0.0080958102, -0.0535580441, 0.0294838026, -0.04181844, 0.0257580522, -0.0846971795, 0.0397923999, -0.0072787954, 0.0024398477, -0.0054921322, 0.0422701538, 0.0199592244, -0.060743425, 0.0137347747, -0.0193464532, -0.0187991057, -0.0324837528, -0.0332252532, 0.0003094551, -0.0212653968, -0.0037266819, 0.0354884528, 0.0053177569, 0.0235124268, 0.0216823258, 0.0038594641, 0.0447525345, -0.0262110699, 0.03125377, 0.0168144815, -0.0729706734, 0.0198741313, -0.0503042787, -0.0681637973, -0.0713441595, 0.0184673406, -0.0259331893, -0.0320431069, -0.0452585258, -0.0007589706, -0.0005740126, -0.0023823937, 0.0166884419, -0.0879797861, -0.0162794981, -0.0227663107, -0.043732781, -0.0069688428, -0.0153958322, -0.015223695, -0.0401202068, 0.0086442949, -0.0106582204, 0.0277203005, 0.0359376334, -0.0152450865, 0.0093988078, -0.0286644921, -0.0119346473, -0.0029147041, -0.034671586, 0.0034235404, 0.0820582286, -0.001385087, 0.0040200278, -0.0494269915, 0.0350259207, 0.0518244244, 0.0644989461, 0.009826418, 0.0050165541, 0.0636803582, 0.0390062034, -0.0094096977, -0.0159197543, -0.0341552496, -0.001524528, -0.0999038666, 0.0035891575, 0.018404467, -0.0490108356, -0.0182015281, 0.0146564636, 0.0195125788, -0.0416255184, 0.0247134361, 0.0425949693, -0.0143867871, 0.009796815, 0.0051623015, -0.07014139, -0.0197955146, 0.0088018663, 0.0253284257, 0.044143986, 0.0385357663, -0.0468058996, -0.0272103734, -0.0139623694, -0.0215818696, -0.0049036788, 0.0337159894, -0.0366150141, -0.0132799428, -0.04307862, -0.0336103402, 0.0146575132, 0.0165527016, 0.0310954731, -0.031753242, -0.0190530941, 0.0224900227, -0.020804612, 0.0172797255, 0.0368903242, 0.0034668313, -0.0136951152, -0.0476935506, 0.0017647378, 0.0133392317, 0.0175400432, -0.0200045444, 0.0212814622, 0.0347418375, 0.0112776877, 0.0149760246, 0.0503619537, 0.0196499284, 0.0173534211, 0.0565803237, -0.0219247676, -0.0373036712, -0.0223189518, -0.040245682, 0.0073896013, -0.0016541365, -0.0301686339, 0.0549592525, -0.015244972, 0.0456976891, 0.0127249174, -0.0413611978, -0.019422913, 0.0310442336, 0.0277750026, -0.0113265533, 0.0314044915, -0.0225549545, 0.0286835525, 0.031217292, 0.0204949565, -0.0346065387, -0.0309908949, -0.0364685878, 0.0343744643, 0.0220929123, 0.0102057625, -0.0466808081, -0.0113501791, 0.0171056148, -0.0324573815, 0.0396706946, 0.0414340571, 0.0218268018, 0.0020829937, -0.0324880369, -0.0149815893, 0.0143036004, 0.0208543055, -0.0423236638, 0.049200058, -0.0026829247, -0.0765850767, -0.0524985157, -0.0090233916, -0.0267183147, 0.0052525303, 0.0460616462, -0.0415869392, -0.0613314249, 0.0217396654, -0.0418109335, 0.0456255116, 0.0110412659, -0.0091807749, -0.0227380488, -0.0570527948, -0.0101548079, 0.0248200875, 0.0221809633, 0.0021079308, 0.0316746943, -0.003718687, -0.0009751598, -0.0381377339, 0.0137708373, -0.0039256765, -0.0494416766, -0.0107723735, 0.0669730008, -0.0146462535, -0.0174535867, 0.013359814, 0.0004655658, -0.01245551, 0.0032222136, 0.0276029501, 0.0018561464, -0.0366801955, -0.0173499994, 0.0337662101, 0.0249829423, -0.0286938138, 0.0349404998, 0.0189866927, 0.0189536531, -0.0275843311, 0.0000574308, -0.0659152269, 0.0880213976, 0.0039868006, 0.0213250555, 0.0291593168, -0.0528835095, 0.0086350832, -0.0348768048, 0.0948842317, -0.0054775351, 0.0734312758, -0.0484107062, 0.0472709164, -0.0322321989, -0.0559379794, 0.006000618, 0.0041751824, 0.0166181568, 0.0122112231, 0.0433953516, 0.0236431528, -0.0490522459, 0.0106282188, -0.016367726, 0.0479296185, 0.0638226196, -0.0185702369, -0.0141161475, 0.0133751081, -0.0654128194, -0.0317984335, -0.0526571274, -0.0097990558, -0.0292883627, 0.0499408171, -0.025535427, 0.0138741229, 0.0044051507, -0.0081629613, 0.0118398014, -0.0814314112, -0.0146135399, 0.0216818582, -0.035899803, -0.0358785465, 0.0392562822, 0.0596519336, 0.024364002, -0.0066273767, 0.002681761, -0.011833447, -0.0094141308, 0.0330514163, 0.0122252433, -0.1079217046, 0.0522716306, 0.0045848428, -0.0355133787, 0.0031119103, 0.0221600309, 0.0084194876, -0.0215318501, 0.066142045, 0.044897899, -0.0198246054, 0.0198174138, 0.0036360431, 0.0189514421, -0.0062488923, -0.066989027, 0.0554583631, -0.042982053, -0.0362362824, -0.020392919, -0.0970119536, 0.0178586263, -0.0447767451, -0.044060275, 0.0343061015, 0.0602956936, 0.0379719473, -0.0065025729, -0.036508359, 0.0657766685, 0.0202352572, 0.0227130838, -0.0202242546, -0.0095197409, 0.0618606582, 0.0011435093, -0.0249158833, -0.0025370249, 0.046667058, -0.0192187726, 0.0528292321, 0.0222444441, -0.0121857449, 0.015045234, -0.0059545888, -0.0454159416, -0.0222069882, 0.0013015475, -0.0081969742, 0.0593393855, -0.0442638025, -0.067825079, -0.0508831739, -0.0566684343, -0.0239805803, -0.0112501262, -0.0609481633, -0.0446052365, -0.052200675, 0.0198469125, 0.0140842004, 0.052178327, 0.0441113971, -0.0149121583, 0.0590570271, 0.0050647822, -0.0553952977, -0.038707681, -0.0164860729, -0.0214563981, -0.0225805659, -0.025309762, -0.0418768078, 0.0764832646, -0.0163660347, -0.0277375039, -0.0033420485, -0.0325352736, 0.0051442273, 0.0113797961, 0.0265173279, 0.0114804823, -0.007205551, -0.0267755054, -0.0243199263, 0.0023344478, -0.0019447228, -0.0120825283, 0.0384288058, -0.0710171908, -0.0178347323, -0.0150983324, -0.0185258985, 0.005938306, -0.0191680212, 0.0014721785, -0.0078615565, 0.0134813404, 0.0352309942, 0.0809728801, -0.0278240256, -0.0037494157, -0.0051331073, 0.0148742162, -0.0203115772, -0.0352444164, 0.0146970581, 0.004155688, 0.0570686385, -0.0103313262, -0.0084572118, 0.0310486965, 0.0731440783, -0.0234824717, -0.0067423657, -0.0127918022, 0.0283427797, -0.0182967559, 0.0298590008, 0.0525795631, 0.0008603766, 0.006368706, 0.0361245945, -0.0226262845, 0.0257104579, -0.0632381365, -0.0239233337, 0.0280249584, 0.0319966115, -0.0324840844, 0.002647677, -0.0132764922, -0.0117305554, -0.0188700724, 0.0048112241, 0.0776345953, 0.0373569727, 0.0595288314, -0.0454294272, -0.0212854836, -0.0016215745, 0.0259869508, -0.0215416029, -0.0100050988, -0.0405533686, 0.0035361752, -0.0132450927, -0.0091324979, 0.0242257696, -0.0312324408, 0.0014976532, 0.010030169, -0.0032855652, -0.0400542319, -0.0107519785, -0.023157591, -0.0257002935, -0.0249430258, -0.096755445, -0.0340427905, 0.024155803, 0.0001680775, 0.0583347641, -0.0093509126, 0.0286554284, -0.0039806291, 0.0188001674, 0.0349810906, -0.0292940326, -0.0247001667, 0.0897057205, -0.0321713015, -0.030864384, 0.0197546408, -4.794016774e-33, -0.0066102874, 0.002731995, -0.0306629669, 0.0310757607, -0.0370339639, -0.0520445667, -0.0437132381, -0.0179451145, 0.0308450796, 0.004504642, -0.0054267738, -0.0024164249, 0.0262459423, -0.0576387048, 0.0363679901, 0.0042223628, 0.047381375, 0.0323278867, -0.0071086655, -0.053647913, -0.0026959023, -0.002677219, 0.0328199603, -0.070347324, 0.0287625715, 0.0152969733, -0.026475871, -0.0106715895, -0.0341939926, 0.0710959211, 0.0295548774, 0.0061581894, -0.0203489736, 0.0149864443, -0.0524198338, 0.0418189913, -0.0560777299, -0.0198535658, 0.0231844317, -0.0010784966, 0.0115388297, -0.0090126675, 0.0427306257, -0.0114097977, -0.0634783357, 0.0534965359, 0.0342074372, -0.0262487344, -0.0203320757, -0.059052743, -0.0978703648, 0.0259700324, -0.0060447077, 0.0520802513, 0.0268398672, 0.0130518433, 0.0345396735, -0.0407655574, -0.0113181202, 0.0113610402, -0.0186650045, 0.0274788681, 0.0252564978, -0.1088848934, 0.0063904026, 0.0099345129, -0.0242240764, 0.0084176473, -0.051672779, 0.062295422, -0.0101313489, 0.0740218088, 0.0323562026, 0.0657018051, 0.0503034331, -0.0128487572, -0.0273538753, 0.0384536311, 0.0282453839, 0.0469472781, -0.0428630188, 0.0409833826, 0.0150482394, 0.0044492418, -0.0248521566, 0.0224179663, 0.0289646555, -0.0170292873, 0.0122997202, 0.0168687403, 0.0678224862, -0.0363257118, 0.0035197344, -0.0027475508, -0.0285295434, -0.0066059548, -0.0095344968, 0.0361351259, -0.0304898489, -0.0051642088, -0.0178661402, -0.0228906665, 0.024355134, 0.0296583101, 0.0447099879, 0.0152384806, -0.0031696728, 0.0062552025, -0.0564868711, 0.0314370133, 0.022271445, 0.0265966486, 0.028211616, 0.0032176084, 0.0265644286, 0.0133031989, 0.0684368908, -0.0081551475, -0.0068642246, -0.0617040619, -0.0357967429, 0.0519995056, 0.055182755, 0.0268675722, -0.006345076, 0.0065983739, 0.006553371, 0.0202071965, 0.0793193132, 0.0462361015, -0.0093137631, 0.0435244478, 2.248e-7, 0.0949473828, 0.0256237276, 0.0765871778, -0.00326329, -0.0215472113, -0.0169459525, 0.010258425, 0.0214636419, -0.0384055637, 0.0139466003, 0.0134205213, -0.0686552972, 0.0433483236, 0.0437226333, -0.0424853452, -0.0335277617, 0.0123060616, -0.0695671067, -0.0493901297, 0.0483478531, 0.0425747186, 0.0366099589, 0.0223010313, 0.0100752851, -0.018323034, 0.0120354127, 0.0075589144, 0.0288082361, -0.0314401872, 0.0101301959, 0.0775920227, -0.0346456729, -0.0371035524, 0.0031015282, 0.0009934023, -0.004611453, -0.0817278624, 0.0661962107, -0.0267952941, 0.1079906225, -0.0073452666, -0.1089088842, 0.0169584192, 0.0163852721, 0.0063901115, 0.0494896993, 0.0473730266, -0.0418399572, -0.0602036156, 0.0070606191, 0.0146952579, 0.0217048936, 0.0092583336, 0.0121179502, 0.0205262396, 0.024118904, -0.0030142083, -0.1053782031, -0.0009169569, 0.0521181524, 0.0046917666, 0.022199221, 0.0333600827, 0.0337673314, 0.0281431712, -0.0501436181, 0.0243541878, 2.118873108e-34, 0.0327252112, -0.0313299038, 0.0111047383, 0.0192957614, 0.0370678306, -0.0036257969, -0.0247191153, 0.04721535, -0.0264961887, -0.0430979356, 0.0194369759 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.06400v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.06400v1
Opening up Minds with Argumentative Dialogues
2023-01-16T12:47:16
2023-01-16T12:47:16
Youmna Farag, Charlotte O. Brand, Jacopo Amidei, Paul Piwek, Tom Stafford, Svetlana Stoyanchev, Andreas Vlachos
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
Recent research on argumentative dialogues has focused on persuading people to take some action, changing their stance on the topic of discussion, or winning debates. In this work, we focus on argumentative dialogues that aim to open up (rather than change) people's minds to help them become more understanding to views that are unfamiliar or in opposition to their own convictions. To this end, we present a dataset of 183 argumentative dialogues about 3 controversial topics: veganism, Brexit and COVID-19 vaccination. The dialogues were collected using the Wizard of Oz approach, where wizards leverage a knowledge-base of arguments to converse with participants. Open-mindedness is measured before and after engaging in the dialogue using a questionnaire from the psychology literature, and success of the dialogue is measured as the change in the participant's stance towards those who hold opinions different to theirs. We evaluate two dialogue models: a Wikipedia-based and an argument-based model. We show that while both models perform closely in terms of opening up minds, the argument-based model is significantly better on other dialogue properties such as engagement and clarity.
[ 0.038112238, 0.0739584416, -0.0038577321, 0.0275651254, -0.0257741231, 0.0043243091, 0.0230189543, -0.0247459523, 0.0392187014, -0.0152745293, 0.0133741368, 0.0168205146, 0.0054132654, -0.0009340868, -0.0019069567, -0.0809326395, 0.0068098097, 0.0011414303, 0.0852487609, -0.014206456, 0.0403135456, -0.0040331003, -0.0564339943, 0.0281915907, 0.0171033945, -0.0263652354, -0.0197874531, 0.0060495809, 0.0980403498, -0.0518833101, 0.0150711415, 0.0361292213, 0.0023482221, 0.0290757008, 0.0000019335, -0.0356942639, 0.0150230257, -0.0290357526, -0.0301164128, 0.0248908345, 0.0205181502, 0.0554097891, 0.0167280138, 0.0310632754, -0.0161250848, 0.0038466041, 0.03275197, 0.0889786184, 0.0424177349, 0.027306987, 0.006682212, -0.0358807817, 0.0291875657, -0.0023513709, -0.004015313, 0.0206005666, 0.0227008462, -0.0056884517, -0.0668423325, -0.0031219968, 0.0109140221, 0.0108638229, -0.0332253352, -0.0673269928, -0.0011120276, 0.0108619938, -0.0380351171, -0.0318855494, 0.0215135403, 0.073944211, 0.063935779, 0.014611748, 0.0211725179, -0.0245589484, 0.0085793994, 0.0630182549, -0.0825064778, 0.0222226623, -0.0083816228, 0.0063113607, 0.0113025699, 0.0427272804, 0.0139794154, 0.0368542485, 0.0260838959, 0.0223875251, -0.022411637, -0.0098392405, 0.0372460447, -0.0387248285, 0.0378276892, -0.0666105375, -0.0382567085, -0.0138695231, 0.0257481802, 0.0532675907, 0.0430732369, 0.0259884316, 0.0535329133, -0.0803857371, -0.0083861845, 0.0200073533, 0.0016967442, 0.0496712551, 0.0375501513, -0.0493078344, -0.0410197563, 0.0032766943, 0.0532692261, 0.0245205555, -0.0462321043, 0.0035067054, -0.0250133686, -0.0162181649, 0.0027428973, 0.0171015058, 0.0284994747, -0.0312427357, -0.0378088132, 0.0076904357, -0.0250990503, -0.0038531274, 0.017936755, -0.0145234037, -0.0655732527, 0.0876250938, -0.0736528188, 0.0144849066, 0.0062005133, -0.0185544211, -0.0284173191, 0.0073443512, 0.0385600179, 0.0224022232, 0.0043017929, 0.0215386041, -0.0116095832, 0.0358317904, 0.0023158593, 0.0007172947, -0.003872432, -0.0244935472, 0.0173294563, -0.0207564346, 0.0284750927, -0.0127676474, 0.0359444395, -0.0547295287, 0.0346465297, 0.0193549711, -0.0273910947, 0.0503528714, -0.0320357904, -0.0143395262, 0.0764995739, 0.0598763265, -0.0163974259, 0.0172209069, -0.0019069635, -0.0257181264, 0.0329726115, 0.0175230708, 0.0255307946, -0.0218109284, 0.0172901712, -0.0084669432, 0.0662336722, 0.0196920224, -0.0219588075, 0.0286799222, -0.0504993983, 0.0356521532, -0.0467316844, -0.030286504, 0.0603052899, 0.056997586, -0.0367970988, -0.0070030028, -0.0363714397, 0.029451862, 0.0136237638, -0.0133029846, 0.0268375576, 0.018576134, 0.0244257543, -0.0228346139, 0.043898318, 0.0060636066, -0.0043627401, -0.0143738268, 0.0000633061, 0.0101831034, 0.0675876737, -0.0048530074, -0.0274950098, -0.0001801803, -0.006391495, 0.0135276075, 0.0493255779, -0.0568711795, -0.0418349989, -0.0391498059, 0.0241175778, -0.0043479241, 0.0017278454, 0.0153640881, -0.030491719, -0.0714567825, 0.0827096328, 0.0744394362, 0.0870396346, -0.0318692885, -0.040899951, -0.0317255445, -0.0298637077, -0.0518090092, 0.0214836355, 0.0424889289, -0.0116644604, 0.0299174991, 0.0031660735, 0.0103322892, 0.0196821112, 0.0244242493, 0.0238138214, 0.0158386771, -0.0242546182, 0.0138401836, 0.0446067303, 0.0302821398, -0.0274293944, -0.0094625913, 0.0346967317, 0.0001585576, -0.0065478678, 0.0701425597, -0.0133358622, 0.0457171947, 0.02865614, -0.0631202608, -0.0095538767, -0.0265425742, 0.0030076893, 0.030593602, 0.048278451, -0.0047224239, -0.0161471386, 0.0181590002, -0.0212034006, -0.0361484811, -0.0335993059, -0.0279905815, 0.0216547567, 0.0089220041, 0.008300148, 0.0085490867, -0.0621284284, 0.0384215079, -0.0470923334, 0.0206165705, 0.000654154, 0.0486600958, 0.0124659427, 0.038415812, -0.0645935237, -0.0702687278, 0.0098177046, -0.1283226013, -0.0426362194, 0.0110036386, 0.0132097751, 0.0052908314, -0.0219282284, 0.0203630421, 0.0176832285, -0.0575423799, 0.0344550796, -0.0330040343, -0.0024708144, 0.0273183715, 0.0254680105, 0.0031722544, -0.000880689, 0.0411959812, -0.002294207, 0.0352521725, 0.0326281488, 0.0004564821, 0.0085663358, -0.0677010119, -0.0575371645, -0.027949594, -0.054923784, 0.0055260267, 0.0349589661, 0.0482770391, -0.0085896915, 0.0234744549, 0.0793550536, -0.0008064873, -0.0076409797, 0.0153153315, -0.0632472858, -0.0135150254, 0.0131854536, 0.0486533865, -0.0526297688, -0.0229989886, 0.0282156765, 0.0436496325, 0.0027138458, 0.034812443, -0.0341947153, 0.1113368422, 0.002856632, -0.0341952629, -0.0531136319, -0.0488092303, 0.0086822407, 0.0734284744, -0.0147202881, -0.0031179118, 0.0168590844, -0.015010057, 0.0435895436, -0.0263339337, 0.0313413516, -0.0307449736, 0.0376521312, -0.0264530852, 0.0294381883, 0.0322506614, 0.0266508423, -0.0086129513, -0.0524858087, 0.0386839695, -0.0536931492, 0.0268836357, -0.040400546, -0.0130777126, 0.0130090378, -0.0265471321, -0.0463453606, -0.0322579741, -0.0370018668, -0.0529483743, 0.0225365944, -0.0049161562, -0.0371711142, -0.0244444143, 0.0323782898, -0.0021689932, 0.0554962866, -0.0105433529, 0.0478729866, -0.0275497772, -0.01747551, 0.0073821228, 0.0433842242, -0.0382974222, 0.0608593971, 0.0609724708, -0.0261433125, -0.0350788049, -0.0008480575, -0.0536145307, -0.0289991815, -0.0077649411, 0.016325539, -0.0383849256, 0.0476015694, -0.0354087465, 0.0254289526, 0.0364413969, 0.021554755, 0.0064525059, -0.0282203052, -0.0634210929, -0.0072106486, -0.0081362184, -0.0068297195, -0.0910627767, 0.0141820395, -0.0134360353, 0.0124503886, -0.0699835345, -0.0430573113, -0.0127529353, -0.0383784808, 0.025400985, 0.0192793887, 0.0675168782, -0.0055859867, 0.0095610982, 0.012754973, -0.0162123796, -0.0381585844, 0.0154619776, 0.0481368713, 0.021777723, -0.0017665783, 0.0257318895, 0.0480014905, -0.0002336293, 0.0086132381, 0.0691681206, -0.0014651122, 0.0617505312, 0.0165727977, -0.0472504869, 0.0091358311, 0.0262535363, -0.0592175312, -0.0054973969, 0.0276245922, 0.0097451247, 0.0173623711, -0.0172586516, 0.0431603417, 0.0157355964, -0.0793335736, 0.0322868228, 0.0208096933, 0.0161476489, -0.03308478, 0.0037577136, 0.04338184, 0.0287783854, 0.0340082981, 0.025962906, 0.0039164741, 0.0233410597, -0.0618370362, -0.0058854958, -0.044421576, -0.0638881251, -0.0422243923, 0.0583865866, 0.0035337436, -0.044370912, -0.006273367, -0.0155774839, 0.0036763204, -0.0003925411, -0.0208745841, 0.0302560143, 0.0576841608, 0.004978017, 0.0236729439, -0.0068733748, -0.0074317525, -0.0195990335, -0.0485800654, 0.008347149, -0.0254711583, -0.0588952973, 0.0408135206, 0.0042130603, -0.0511105321, 0.0134486994, 0.0247829035, 0.0204959456, 0.0392046161, 0.0479976758, 0.0177647956, 0.010092942, 0.0268394575, 0.0176285226, -0.0107508916, 0.0010860504, 0.0726072118, 0.0214507822, -0.0161799397, 0.0439051315, -0.0020786331, 0.0095489016, 0.0041527101, -0.0680077076, -0.0233854875, 0.0090580452, -0.0051286365, 0.0181518178, 0.046208147, -0.0249461997, -0.0532185063, 0.0198943689, -0.0121444725, -0.0275266841, 0.0059962347, -0.0555655733, -0.0147497356, -0.0621148013, -0.0001487996, -0.0005321813, -0.0396481864, 0.032666944, -0.0080426335, 0.0107506095, 0.0020258524, 0.0191497188, -0.0229513943, -0.0240756925, -0.0084005492, 0.0545409471, -0.0103537086, 0.0461246371, 0.0005655361, 0.0676446483, -0.0019707605, -0.0413886011, 0.0400853269, -0.0184078161, -0.0414201543, -0.1056966931, 0.0274750758, 0.0161776915, -0.0454653949, 0.0278780647, 0.0170845594, -0.0114517342, -0.0225596409, 0.0136050722, 0.0066228015, 0.0310856961, -0.0069356505, 0.0655526966, -0.0112814223, -0.0368719101, -0.0255861189, 0.002474389, -0.0693257973, 0.0507700145, 0.0156068178, -0.0151989814, -0.0416892059, -0.0475864075, -0.0474424958, 0.0284510069, 0.0196614452, 0.0492013879, -0.0540686324, 0.0353189223, -0.0332615823, 0.0183436554, 0.0292895287, 0.0110736554, -0.0143145565, 0.026938023, 0.0256805085, 0.0232221577, -0.0332645103, 0.059898179, -0.0342158712, -0.023857981, -0.0437942743, -5.881978673e-33, -0.0149633558, -0.0048345635, -0.0235148016, 0.0379330181, -0.0153275225, -0.0555339754, -0.0243076943, 0.0725536197, -0.0459191278, 0.0662368163, 0.013706686, 0.0251181684, 0.0012023897, -0.0130279111, -0.0302269645, -0.0414278172, 0.0169798825, -0.0253556315, -0.0285401456, 0.0133945616, 0.0072207651, -0.0203807913, -0.0232710224, -0.0910461619, 0.0486943759, 0.0140477717, 0.0324051157, -0.0107818693, 0.0091486573, 0.003096184, 0.0036828471, 0.0358857289, 0.0131928027, -0.0329153761, 0.0059068566, 0.057581149, -0.0297541078, -0.0107510658, 0.0505391024, -0.0488344096, -0.0344587676, -0.038524624, -0.0041790432, 0.0279981326, -0.0111677563, -0.0331266113, -0.0118497666, -0.0046397033, 0.0562674478, -0.000842505, -0.0453581959, -0.0066439928, -0.0709468126, -0.0066516344, -0.0396727286, 0.0378177688, 0.0458983034, 0.0304783918, -0.0749417245, 0.0728624761, 0.011923559, -0.018604828, -0.0040199016, -0.0389839076, 0.0250788573, 0.0591942519, -0.0115674483, 0.0181672182, -0.0739660487, 0.0095886104, -0.049977161, 0.0113193933, 0.078416802, 0.0714395493, -0.0005482879, -0.0252567139, -0.068820715, -0.0189070031, 0.0177916642, 0.0231366344, 0.0157163292, 0.0029291329, 0.0053206338, 0.0233873818, -0.0879716948, -0.0646973923, -0.0226998664, -0.0262842067, -0.0199127328, 0.0179632865, -0.0600932352, -0.0212556683, -0.0236141216, 0.0035218953, -0.0091672977, 0.0315232649, 0.0092284158, -0.0026968746, -0.0047634467, -0.0586014129, -0.0321243741, 0.0227081776, -0.0359748229, 0.017788155, 0.0836586282, -0.0301153325, -0.0288321301, -0.0476666763, -0.0621272996, -0.0246185996, -0.0188438818, 0.0591782629, -0.0067905416, 0.0408317074, 0.0007227633, 0.0293365344, 0.0046522268, 0.0037212316, 0.0136692179, -0.0126328832, -0.0194959342, -0.0984484851, -0.0388357565, -0.001895652, -0.0334552452, -0.0025054975, 0.0327510834, -0.0072693513, 0.0023017016, -0.0398815349, -0.0027372593, -0.0426664948, 2.661e-7, 0.0139222853, 0.0446276888, -0.0147927674, -0.0000416975, 0.0303003136, 0.0328778997, -0.0033316561, 0.0359808914, 0.0024444254, -0.1113629118, -0.0482926555, -0.0069437525, 0.0142226061, 0.0195433013, -0.0691150948, -0.1067178473, -0.0405563675, 0.0001658675, -0.0245414395, -0.0049418518, 0.029994037, 0.0007829302, 0.0102681182, 0.0411154218, -0.0091100838, 0.0620421097, 0.0566453747, -0.0642082691, -0.0105463434, 0.0100926198, 0.0459378287, -0.0576587059, 0.0149497669, 0.0295467861, -0.0054052197, 0.0014631794, -0.0458866209, 0.0251802094, 0.0266166497, -0.0089558372, -0.0045888782, 0.0185458474, 0.0163116753, -0.0508434251, 0.0090337796, -0.0577951185, -0.0519597195, 0.0144157335, -0.0333187617, -0.0114498409, 0.0319995359, -0.0141303902, -0.028069336, -0.013407168, 0.0076401485, 0.0134909367, 0.0565303825, -0.0611803941, -0.0432378799, -0.0760403946, -0.0550580174, -0.0670866892, -0.0164379794, -0.0369570144, -0.032885205, 0.0217969902, -0.0044778441, 1.628976768e-34, 0.019356994, 0.0059751733, -0.0089707971, -0.0084893871, 0.050680995, 0.0196600817, 0.0595167205, -0.0290037151, 0.0161785316, -0.0435229316, 0.0215127412 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.06375v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.06375v1
OLKAVS: An Open Large-Scale Korean Audio-Visual Speech Dataset
2023-01-16T11:40:50
2023-01-16T11:40:50
Jeongkyun Park, Jung-Wook Hwang, Kwanghee Choi, Seung-Hyun Lee, Jun Hwan Ahn, Rae-Hong Park, Hyung-Min Park
cs.MM
cs.MM, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG, cs.SD
Inspired by humans comprehending speech in a multi-modal manner, various audio-visual datasets have been constructed. However, most existing datasets focus on English, induce dependencies with various prediction models during dataset preparation, and have only a small number of multi-view videos. To mitigate the limitations, we recently developed the Open Large-scale Korean Audio-Visual Speech (OLKAVS) dataset, which is the largest among publicly available audio-visual speech datasets. The dataset contains 1,150 hours of transcribed audio from 1,107 Korean speakers in a studio setup with nine different viewpoints and various noise situations. We also provide the pre-trained baseline models for two tasks, audio-visual speech recognition and lip reading. We conducted experiments based on the models to verify the effectiveness of multi-modal and multi-view training over uni-modal and frontal-view-only training. We expect the OLKAVS dataset to facilitate multi-modal research in broader areas such as Korean speech recognition, speaker recognition, pronunciation level classification, and mouth motion analysis.
[ -0.0140277836, 0.0665449873, 0.0102520743, 0.0443384685, 0.0020166358, 0.0185793452, 0.0377791077, 0.0110277478, -0.011485449, 0.0113349706, -0.1048767641, -0.0070818164, 0.0505983159, 0.0186660178, 0.0285985395, -0.0976824537, -0.0237817392, -0.0560434274, 0.0256329551, 0.004796192, 0.0158168506, 0.0041188761, -0.0606763959, 0.0255377963, -0.0271804389, -0.0052779987, -0.0280185211, 0.0543870293, 0.0418998562, -0.0383561291, -0.0731275305, 0.0415493511, 0.0282415915, -0.002856846, 0.0000016037, 0.0200613849, 0.0254620276, -0.0031778847, -0.0348871648, -0.0088746725, 0.0350055508, -0.0611529499, 0.0028822399, 0.0056884582, -0.0211932436, -0.0662068799, 0.0333425216, 0.0414160118, 0.0429208875, 0.0427131429, -0.0115966741, -0.0573435463, 0.0159655735, -0.0004451268, 0.0086941132, -0.0087646535, 0.0014365745, 0.0014792191, -0.0423363708, -0.0516804419, -0.0871205553, 0.0428476073, -0.018816052, 0.0112919668, 0.0082042748, 0.0183114633, -0.0245858021, -0.0579954311, 0.0117415069, 0.1119657382, 0.0099754864, 0.0112690255, -0.0095038489, 0.0122659532, -0.0215165168, 0.0074761896, -0.0122289741, 0.0318085104, 0.0044006803, -0.0265022162, -0.0595137551, 0.0065531535, 0.0289239641, -0.0371244252, 0.041793935, -0.0503209271, 0.0371254049, -0.0161594674, 0.0185234901, -0.0510368608, -0.0043163444, -0.0313981473, 0.0034524202, -0.0203456376, 0.0029099379, 0.0157110356, -0.0300831627, -0.0124346018, -0.0127935316, -0.0178132784, 0.0149326669, 0.039855253, -0.0831141248, 0.0147346221, -0.0024922607, 0.0140034538, -0.0225862134, 0.0376499072, -0.0048415721, -0.0000665861, -0.0006341598, -0.000857453, -0.0245203897, -0.0494503304, -0.0409531333, -0.0420262702, -0.0373618901, 0.0081766313, -0.0571993962, 0.0274915602, 0.0380783752, 0.032320369, -0.0402363203, -0.0125454692, 0.0047672158, 0.0468537919, 0.0167458188, 0.0796349645, -0.023695197, -0.0690690354, -0.0099498536, 0.0285001229, 0.0380447432, 0.0155248558, 0.0197124705, 0.0564821288, -0.0117461402, -0.0096567431, 0.0003251842, 0.0095093427, -0.0546450317, -0.0424555987, 0.0178465024, -0.0510754287, 0.0132808574, -0.0013519024, 0.0224928353, 0.0239863843, -0.0201098472, -0.0073843868, 0.0371966362, 0.0837826803, 0.0683482364, 0.0348258279, 0.006643441, 0.0148751456, 0.0454932004, 0.0410085246, 0.0354418494, -0.0489693619, -0.0007124805, 0.0095323455, 0.0119345672, 0.0646507889, -0.0235397108, 0.0277095158, -0.0490889177, -0.0089358427, 0.015393571, 0.0475345887, 0.0182871073, 0.0010397387, -0.0522143692, -0.0440910831, 0.0521108843, 0.0278908201, 0.0237551089, -0.0267800186, 0.0245016888, 0.005936462, 0.0261258893, -0.0332181565, 0.0141976401, 0.0092308531, 0.0068733101, 0.0285546314, 0.0011033907, 0.0187602378, -0.0588275604, 0.0101061678, -0.0108357044, -0.0360906459, -0.0235458948, 0.034078002, 0.0612278283, -0.0156553015, -0.0294521917, 0.0414840877, 0.0027309626, -0.038702976, -0.0286684129, 0.0172254238, -0.005049522, 0.0162309073, -0.0262383241, -0.0226588547, -0.0302848425, 0.0079659764, 0.0091243563, 0.01869951, 0.0015519104, -0.033162348, 0.1005752906, -0.0576875135, -0.0053563546, 0.0452310331, 0.0126769198, 0.0512960441, -0.0390695557, 0.0040735747, -0.0078440811, 0.0133583173, 0.0420137644, 0.0055144927, -0.022814665, 0.0298170429, -0.0276277047, 0.0553433448, 0.047203742, 0.0594846345, -0.0374628529, -0.019879438, 0.0497243218, -0.0028644765, 0.0780930966, 0.0696681738, -0.046621535, -0.0570691563, 0.0307088047, -0.0504670925, 0.0132129462, 0.0564206615, 0.0115618911, -0.0627074167, 0.0443415381, 0.0100645218, 0.0436090976, -0.0410066396, 0.0029499414, -0.0049008392, 0.0119573576, 0.0313315876, -0.0353258029, 0.0081998361, 0.0041554742, 0.0876388624, 0.0051680594, 0.0305912122, -0.060142789, -0.0211979151, 0.0428442359, -0.0214233566, 0.0140668415, -0.0456639975, -0.0249844808, -0.0582749285, -0.0251109619, -0.1295786202, -0.0074694958, -0.0005761789, -0.0419407599, -0.0303324591, -0.0187262911, -0.0354745761, -0.0610557906, -0.0172962453, 0.0344625004, 0.0220791493, -0.0222901572, -0.0545939729, -0.0031619212, -0.0117634488, 0.0149855781, -0.0071496447, 0.0300848186, -0.0085676191, -0.0084921382, -0.0015743083, 0.0018094375, 0.0183414314, 0.0090543991, 0.0056508621, -0.0071097687, -0.0101335039, -0.0046261908, 0.0038514649, 0.0367194563, 0.051988408, -0.019224314, -0.0028344169, 0.0197485685, -0.0442838669, -0.0122336866, -0.010240146, 0.0450568758, 0.0141079398, -0.0658877119, 0.024029417, -0.0992787778, -0.0080920085, 0.0528453551, 0.0540006645, -0.0367642939, -0.0442676879, -0.0189709682, -0.0427373536, 0.0001545516, 0.0018919696, -0.0557233542, 0.0124123422, -0.0064152665, -0.0126070399, 0.021495536, -0.0930875763, -0.0745960623, -0.0067174537, -0.0109988917, -0.0186047666, 0.0355522819, -0.0191277377, -0.0033284903, -0.0222562347, -0.0263562873, -0.0352073982, -0.0069113323, 0.0234377347, -0.0201839581, 0.0285570696, -0.0216736179, -0.0406696647, -0.0525776446, 0.0181084499, -0.0194079671, -0.0297740698, -0.0521901958, -0.0393256061, -0.0522767417, -0.0016510841, -0.0273756795, 0.0000517663, 0.0381918512, 0.0102397157, 0.0015847565, 0.0317051336, -0.0113848308, 0.0406185463, 0.0301720984, 0.0289226733, -0.0802163929, -0.0496780239, 0.0366336517, 0.0101077091, 0.0516370609, -0.0002574056, -0.0572260804, 0.0269289482, 0.0216897316, 0.0612581819, -0.0071728481, 0.0236072037, 0.0522968285, -0.0283212997, 0.0502443612, 0.0632721931, -0.0199488979, -0.0537862778, -0.045586776, 0.0511035472, 0.02254273, 0.034142267, 0.0055679837, -0.0470164828, -0.0462753326, 0.0564571694, 0.0044597527, 0.0312308408, 0.0410607532, -0.0216326248, -0.0648806542, 0.0532916561, -0.0050854431, -0.0266460646, -0.0548204519, -0.0476896055, -0.0032412754, -0.0658657923, 0.0336654149, -0.02359627, 0.0000504893, -0.0205117576, 0.0510292687, -0.0053377803, -0.0433885902, 0.0543337911, -0.0214944184, 0.0440743044, -0.0215767808, 0.0543799065, -0.0140496995, -0.0522401631, -0.0010803894, 0.0248259231, -0.0100656664, 0.015858395, 0.079549633, 0.0050424663, -0.038643159, 0.0327490643, 0.0538111404, -0.0208902564, 0.0011312786, -0.0045620925, 0.0158197042, -0.0017970481, 0.0272047352, 0.0100040557, 0.0370439664, 0.0267990753, 0.0110584302, -0.0151828658, -0.0329290815, 0.001360226, 0.0259247553, 0.0444218777, -0.0346989334, -0.0080343541, -0.007152196, -0.0094567854, -0.0438137613, -0.0170296691, 0.0078638066, 0.0174788404, 0.0820681825, 0.0208836049, -0.0084252032, -0.0053079305, 0.0509002432, -0.0522542074, 0.0566073917, -0.0038510503, 0.0733186007, -0.035431426, -0.038276162, 0.009142221, -0.0473926589, -0.0086013777, -0.0099257454, -0.0615248568, -0.0611670762, -0.0149112213, -0.0032586972, 0.0157600567, 0.1069544703, 0.0071407906, 0.0001062253, 0.0263589602, -0.0238804333, -0.0374535695, 0.0078626173, 0.065122366, -0.0377791561, -0.0279710051, 0.0056146756, -0.0124809584, 0.0028739721, -0.0106846048, -0.0212164838, 0.0051738298, -0.0476236977, -0.036370378, 0.0208150018, 0.0592894778, 0.0126273874, 0.0318614431, -0.0775205866, 0.0101043209, -0.0003643023, 0.0510137603, -0.0429550521, -0.004365942, 0.0666599423, -0.0057335207, -0.0017224463, 0.0391814485, -0.0083520841, -0.0491366982, -0.0116058076, 0.0515334457, 0.0354759395, 0.0195874069, 0.0039205169, 0.017949041, -0.0178503636, 0.0151172746, -0.0165591445, -0.0148600619, 0.0393710509, 0.0199133828, -0.013877484, -0.0349458419, 0.0093864407, 0.0180131476, -0.0057135415, 0.010019959, -0.0108630182, 0.0068820482, 0.0228197258, -0.0303292684, 0.0200248286, -0.015688451, 0.0168694593, -0.0318673737, 0.0509881303, -0.0762481615, -0.0417719744, 0.0335431658, -0.0149556035, -0.0080380421, 0.0187544692, 0.0520107187, 0.0195053052, 0.0098320683, -0.0343003757, 0.0239450578, -0.0472104922, -0.0192213152, 0.0551786795, 0.016946489, -0.0520565063, 0.0043480177, 0.0028308753, -0.0658199713, 0.0050612343, 0.0005065626, 0.019229671, 0.0108203478, 0.007732288, 0.0024582001, 0.0106817437, 0.004068926, -0.0220505074, -0.0528723225, -0.0079217274, 0.0281882063, 0.0461204462, -4.844772049e-33, 0.007461139, 0.02891469, 0.0355617777, -0.0109950937, -0.0410614349, -0.0080845729, -0.0212659743, 0.0507586487, -0.0149837183, 0.0140039464, 0.0057481946, 0.0212910455, 0.0218236633, 0.0425516926, 0.039869152, -0.0016645801, 0.0556300543, -0.0288824346, 0.0253643151, 0.0120862154, 0.0637097135, 0.015255399, 0.0370960869, -0.0496732295, -0.0127860345, 0.0180691425, -0.0016540865, -0.0180535372, -0.0014319497, 0.0643036366, -0.0190704074, 0.0113379238, -0.0048379726, -0.0194251444, -0.0417358465, 0.013999531, -0.0480213054, 0.0340384282, -0.0230907779, 0.1048490629, -0.059485469, 0.0402649939, 0.0192115884, 0.0014428742, 0.0163257737, -0.0518029369, 0.0582896806, -0.063853398, -0.0211145151, 0.0082363915, -0.0023591013, 0.0396713242, -0.0227086172, -0.0497899577, 0.0740262121, 0.0540218204, -0.0116933286, -0.0207826532, -0.001338546, 0.0504369624, -0.0395758897, -0.0027371987, 0.0732604638, 0.0653567389, 0.0195157081, 0.0253800321, 0.0374193527, -0.0919106007, 0.0263714474, -0.0421712212, 0.0185204986, 0.0886077136, -0.0333198532, 0.0539728701, -0.0135087213, -0.059463717, -0.0243887417, -0.0046209395, -0.0206510592, 0.0171156656, 0.009396675, 0.0134639852, 0.0036927836, 0.0199207868, -0.0488702841, -0.0333569087, -0.0283698775, 0.0240746606, 0.0215480104, 0.0350320525, -0.002602919, 0.0100772046, 0.0723526254, -0.0407721065, 0.0386754014, 0.0490106158, -0.0226422418, 0.0140547622, -0.0036989301, 0.0161539651, -0.0693753809, 0.0079075638, 0.0450788513, 0.0212609749, 0.0167249814, -0.0274330601, -0.0051976135, 0.0553832725, -0.0413569622, -0.0103560435, 0.0100434795, -0.0066752792, 0.0118138678, 0.0587839335, 0.0450160727, -0.0110346442, -0.0231440328, 0.0395869203, -0.0111193191, 0.0304560903, -0.0295989364, -0.0206911992, -0.003727169, 0.0033135125, -0.0193137806, 0.0345507264, -0.0131271472, -0.0758704692, 0.0395425148, -0.0223698001, 0.0107845003, 0.0383780599, 2.505e-7, -0.0326610729, -0.0152248843, 0.0429751426, 0.0030626529, 0.0333158411, 0.0412564911, -0.067250289, 0.0118749011, 0.002106345, -0.0093244985, 0.0375775732, -0.0146234529, 0.0610076673, 0.0014183184, -0.0634341538, 0.0051080878, -0.0379193872, 0.036344789, -0.0211526826, -0.0019511333, 0.0104472833, 0.0676437244, -0.0455909893, -0.0134215234, 0.0189058054, 0.0067538251, 0.0720556602, -0.0188031476, -0.0016080656, -0.0605338812, 0.0477356203, -0.0269845668, 0.0016530433, -0.0070548174, -0.0250841696, 0.0033977604, 0.0346482918, 0.0587131642, -0.0117949527, -0.0817399099, -0.0159357581, 0.0860628039, -0.0667645186, 0.0144134788, 0.0618673339, 0.0196824335, -0.0292417724, -0.0314368978, -0.0500993244, 0.018333409, 0.0286567397, 0.01084504, 0.0038502393, 0.0306141004, 0.0306181889, -0.0424975231, -0.0386322476, -0.0462483689, -0.0294988062, -0.0097782724, -0.0892205313, -0.0056884261, -0.0060458644, -0.042017296, 0.0232710615, -0.0097132111, -0.0527199954, 1.110156724e-34, 0.0089949435, -0.0260045007, -0.0087958034, -0.0536161289, -0.0468832627, -0.0592867658, -0.0282800607, 0.0218117479, 0.0049156672, -0.0598365031, -0.0379519127 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.06340v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.06340v2
Deep Learning Models to Study Sentence Comprehension in the Human Brain
2023-01-16T10:31:25
2023-02-16T13:00:22
Sophie Arana, Jacques Pesnot Lerousseau, Peter Hagoort
cs.CL
cs.CL, q-bio.NC
Recent artificial neural networks that process natural language achieve unprecedented performance in tasks requiring sentence-level understanding. As such, they could be interesting models of the integration of linguistic information in the human brain. We review works that compare these artificial language models with human brain activity and we assess the extent to which this approach has improved our understanding of the neural processes involved in natural language comprehension. Two main results emerge. First, the neural representation of word meaning aligns with the context-dependent, dense word vectors used by the artificial neural networks. Second, the processing hierarchy that emerges within artificial neural networks broadly matches the brain, but is surprisingly inconsistent across studies. We discuss current challenges in establishing artificial neural networks as process models of natural language comprehension. We suggest exploiting the highly structured representational geometry of artificial neural networks when mapping representations to brain data.
[ 0.0304211359, 0.0371849164, -0.0409364365, 0.0254780166, -0.0400498062, 0.0501473695, 0.0131064765, -0.0176758133, -0.0050557884, -0.0041102646, -0.0040699714, -0.0477553867, 0.027235724, 0.0496552885, 0.0326376669, -0.03015697, 0.0363435186, -0.0314272009, 0.0253716186, 0.0063688527, -0.0501464121, -0.0058794911, -0.0256914888, 0.035773579, 0.0008836369, -0.0179536697, -0.0144849708, -0.0260647815, -0.0067917807, 0.0011893816, -0.034708187, 0.040603485, 0.0386165641, 0.0543630682, 0.0000017309, -0.0191648807, 0.0317364894, -0.0009815621, -0.0577236041, 0.0237476993, 0.00104218, -0.0287657045, 0.010250845, -0.0434546098, -0.0285961162, 0.0146464827, 0.015406874, 0.0408709422, 0.0198698472, 0.022160694, -0.0094399843, -0.067259565, 0.0553502254, -0.0265656654, 0.01899435, -0.0445825271, 0.046679914, 0.0011542934, -0.0115027986, 0.0148843136, -0.0510531217, 0.0404397063, 0.0515528657, 0.0478257835, 0.0031303568, 0.0585308708, 0.0050510373, -0.0054684943, -0.0056921295, 0.0708846897, -0.0028212401, -0.0359781608, -0.0043331729, 0.0162589457, 0.0005109534, 0.0024183115, -0.0402767882, 0.0469398312, 0.0189584345, 0.0313790217, 0.0215668492, -0.0503335334, 0.0343237258, 0.0072536021, -0.0250705052, 0.0929199755, 0.0076766149, -0.0408390909, 0.0153752249, 0.013290491, -0.055219546, 0.0019049742, 0.0369583368, 0.0129074752, -0.0282101948, 0.0217344109, -0.0012288458, -0.0449382104, 0.0074242018, -0.0486103222, 0.0359675363, 0.0506350584, -0.0129944254, 0.0426731743, -0.0399773382, 0.0622737445, -0.0390214957, 0.0467211455, -0.0548555851, 0.0117467484, -0.0236017238, -0.0464448221, -0.0196217149, 0.0348185524, -0.0503749363, -0.0599465445, -0.0443974137, 0.0042671417, -0.0011975651, -0.0597640835, -0.0144742774, 0.0540721118, -0.0434239954, 0.0233801473, -0.0477116555, -0.003315714, -0.0354261398, 0.0548826531, -0.0087967208, -0.0061265617, -0.0121635729, 0.0447760075, 0.001420457, -0.016020339, -0.0088829733, 0.0327145122, 0.0052727344, -0.0218993612, -0.0227470137, -0.0270441119, -0.0101582445, 0.0045416583, 0.0335870981, -0.0319452547, 0.0380903631, -0.0044751642, -0.0344022177, -0.0461287946, -0.0363126546, 0.0394434333, -0.0411692634, 0.0655696541, 0.0089645591, 0.0208297316, 0.0271852203, 0.0080033261, 0.0023196647, -0.0277796704, 0.0341378003, 0.0201425124, -0.038509246, -0.0006632421, -0.0288312268, -0.008790371, -0.0145072537, -0.0552924685, -0.0485495441, -0.046984069, -0.0488432311, 0.070048511, 0.024767248, 0.0287195779, -0.0367135704, -0.0524389967, 0.0516770445, 0.0744333565, -0.0134673044, 0.0276029985, 0.0632369146, 0.0018925196, -0.0087577356, 0.0251593553, -0.0610374212, 0.0135097085, 0.0043287263, -0.0031662511, -0.0199097898, -0.0458972901, -0.0113473311, -0.0418967083, 0.0310009513, 0.007368844, 0.0165880341, 0.0095207524, 0.0389453433, -0.005593841, -0.0365119092, 0.0261084177, 0.0204961579, 0.0191764459, 0.03653045, -0.0170175098, 0.0226399601, 0.0138169713, -0.0102200257, -0.0009042665, 0.0121568991, 0.0200809278, 0.0057918159, 0.0443823412, 0.0062501756, 0.0207450818, 0.0052806069, -0.0122141913, 0.0011584423, -0.0190281663, 0.0158424769, 0.0125284018, -0.0554211028, -0.0544806458, -0.0056616501, -0.0335621983, -0.0474199317, 0.0541671738, -0.0116154421, -0.0218921341, -0.0113283042, 0.0230641849, 0.0112491297, -0.0037169929, -0.0071123359, 0.0320538953, 0.0247650649, -0.0393234305, -0.0146395881, 0.0026494418, -0.0531651378, -0.0377435982, -0.012829666, -0.0362916924, -0.0477124974, 0.0452959165, 0.0054629017, -0.0337424539, 0.0258288272, -0.0664827079, 0.0030664606, -0.0308919419, -0.0081085535, -0.0010003236, 0.0472364426, -0.059545625, 0.0756565183, -0.0154533079, 0.0090522896, -0.0010837252, -0.020107897, 0.0158907901, -0.01687981, -0.0501780473, -0.0115231955, -0.0349972136, -0.0360784419, -0.0414802134, -0.0110882018, -0.0599497631, 0.0220444426, -0.0577536486, -0.0090226335, 0.0250406396, -0.0001905999, 0.0259410776, -0.0139740054, 0.0221183579, 0.0038821509, 0.0001147691, 0.0226235371, 0.0019387826, 0.0305070467, 0.0411434621, 0.0058483821, -0.0193875879, -0.0274172388, -0.0452959388, -0.0758505017, 0.0517331921, 0.0037874258, -0.0203595348, -0.0250924379, 0.043505989, -0.0171424262, 0.0066707828, 0.0043460089, -0.0359052569, 0.0406993926, 0.0063668112, 0.0208715312, 0.1139154881, -0.0257044286, 0.0554818362, 0.039276816, -0.0007129911, -0.0093254587, 0.014423741, -0.0352379605, 0.0293312147, -0.0075995023, -0.013915943, 0.0261506606, 0.0762745887, 0.0727262124, -0.0102091264, -0.0112699708, 0.0133692631, -0.0407279916, -0.044979874, -0.0605680048, -0.0174454153, -0.0405001603, 0.0690821931, -0.0588557646, 0.0042627407, 0.0779028535, 0.0152705582, 0.0095113358, -0.0324442908, -0.0134630026, -0.0211777929, 0.0172259212, 0.0381964445, 0.0270945225, -0.0353782438, -0.0373130105, -0.0497902073, 0.0063562039, -0.0298361927, -0.0110809756, 0.0086309491, -0.0158856697, -0.0050651305, 0.0225724895, 0.0100586852, -0.0293056648, -0.0205411464, -0.0295527149, 0.0220079776, 0.0128024518, 0.0297288224, -0.0418503322, 0.0010680559, 0.0222361311, 0.01239016, -0.0209086165, -0.0212878324, -0.0528809056, 0.0623023435, 0.0144041032, 0.0343979374, 0.0434387811, 0.0047348309, 0.0017207405, 0.0267698951, -0.0043827193, 0.0705849156, -0.0446973667, 0.0648663417, 0.0126401735, -0.0207187291, 0.0017746569, 0.0345026888, 0.0083329799, -0.0471889116, -0.0357347839, 0.1110500544, 0.038404718, -0.0344053023, 0.0238920543, -0.0017186083, 0.0091221137, 0.0129132746, 0.0089008603, -0.0392102078, -0.0136968456, 0.0044929078, -0.0519979, 0.0135600921, -0.0188196339, 0.0046255686, -0.0407916568, 0.0269733742, -0.029576689, -0.0708025694, -0.0256294645, -0.0232900605, 0.0212831628, 0.0547373369, 0.053055957, -0.0091103744, 0.0234297086, -0.0013965577, 0.0036796704, 0.0187732093, -0.0226751324, 0.015883876, -0.0354943313, 0.0420055464, 0.0579029694, 0.0612999946, -0.0495664626, -0.0279833879, 0.0282164235, 0.0205141455, 0.0077616437, -0.0107966252, 0.0225068852, 0.0359588377, -0.0171780549, -0.0189104695, 0.0120651722, -0.0821414068, -0.0438237637, -0.0454982184, 0.0925670862, 0.0003128244, -0.025819594, -0.0141984746, 0.0544799417, -0.0611695051, 0.082099691, 0.0643069372, -0.073973164, -0.0380815975, -0.0023161781, 0.0149790077, -0.0159836225, -0.0523522682, 0.0475355387, 0.0569521636, 0.0164755732, -0.0098365815, -0.050208386, 0.0278391559, -0.0036099609, 0.0411142968, 0.0240479223, 0.0525683239, -0.076925762, -0.0229434427, 0.0427320227, -0.01992644, 0.00338047, -0.007449544, -0.0086199176, -0.0215930883, -0.0163107049, -0.054155726, 0.0319767557, -0.0397620611, -0.0155415013, 0.0338312946, -0.024669908, 0.0243632887, -0.0165724084, -0.013350009, -0.0770250782, 0.0130997291, -0.0103828367, -0.0244585108, 0.0667259321, -0.0457855947, 0.0297008101, 0.0083130617, 0.0250200648, -0.0203116015, 0.0109234266, 0.0102607049, 0.0230525993, 0.0013888954, -0.0028068039, 0.0494000651, -0.0078412043, 0.0595216863, 0.0366091989, -0.007460027, -0.026404595, -0.0272292029, 0.0240413118, 0.0063400189, -0.0109824426, -0.0464127809, 0.0506505482, 0.0356611982, -0.0440840684, -0.027318012, 0.0354325026, 0.0055097351, -0.0086090351, -0.0480518863, 0.0201624464, -0.0035307349, -0.0450378992, 0.055379834, 0.0013049253, 0.0273373555, -0.0839115679, 0.032507658, 0.0216583107, 0.0091649229, 0.0149260303, 0.0291245487, -0.0430305898, -0.0052094022, -0.0868227333, -0.0641367808, 0.0392784253, 0.0055272756, 0.0197264515, -0.0326392129, -0.0165450945, -0.019767534, 0.0047905259, -0.0093163047, -0.0203415081, -0.0174816102, -0.0035451674, 0.0673437417, 0.011565838, 0.0380228348, -0.0588397644, 0.0313644409, 0.014709902, 0.010105609, 0.0085876668, 0.0196305513, -0.0370723642, 0.0008469593, -0.0149036609, 0.064653255, -0.0403073579, 0.0397536233, -0.0164836179, -0.0822447836, 0.0268543437, 0.0131421778, 0.0624742024, -0.0414596647, -0.0032345371, 0.0341216549, -0.0123843066, -0.034725938, 0.0189094432, 0.0318223573, -0.0366647653, -0.0426558778, -0.0443354622, -5.882364382e-33, -0.0312885493, -0.0318175331, -0.015229349, 0.00348378, -0.0072683324, -0.0038429974, -0.0449058972, -0.0066130329, -0.0103003932, 0.0304478649, -0.0039293957, 0.0445139818, 0.0064373454, 0.0296630878, 0.008619301, -0.0176444016, -0.0122381113, -0.0396278277, 0.0550386496, -0.0061911917, 0.0021749113, 0.0267153699, 0.0342294164, -0.0576640144, 0.0196625385, 0.0076674302, 0.0256175734, 0.0648589581, -0.0321767442, 0.0464113466, -0.0829790235, 0.0723033324, 0.0708170533, -0.0067514153, -0.0020354083, 0.0442196392, -0.0539753623, -0.0367204249, 0.0418621488, 0.0162240341, -0.0774335414, -0.0299205836, 0.1167748123, -0.0340420008, 0.0478164405, -0.0026091433, 0.0413151234, 0.0099257659, -0.0216122288, 0.0137445182, -0.0813035741, -0.0421485491, -0.0307099018, 0.0031529239, 0.020395413, 0.0097594457, -0.0552542359, 0.0482244976, -0.0619114712, -0.0116136912, -0.0505197607, 0.0389515609, -0.0046541924, 0.0154092433, 0.0116669293, 0.0498144552, 0.0788208768, -0.0045690984, -0.0571347326, -0.0005889874, 0.0864164084, 0.0550719835, 0.0138905942, 0.0138145341, 0.0559650771, -0.0019550545, -0.054180488, -0.0110578379, -0.0218105167, 0.021654984, 0.031890519, -0.0236676019, -0.0061812578, -0.0081180697, -0.0686503947, -0.0328934379, -0.0619992279, 0.0200777389, 0.0460855179, -0.0536848195, 0.0098322788, -0.0256933197, 0.0107311541, -0.0681741983, 0.0311126765, 0.0025843217, -0.0014296729, 0.0232274309, 0.0475119166, 0.0603860058, -0.0316145606, -0.0271351542, -0.0466122366, 0.0235782415, 0.0345521048, 0.0081626158, 0.0107409032, -0.0224751737, 0.0325999558, -0.0245681684, -0.0340254419, -0.0672571957, 0.0138603328, 0.0178936031, 0.031713374, 0.0346947052, -0.0260652266, -0.0228305962, 0.0001448516, 0.0060089533, -0.0117124086, 0.0177453347, -0.0351886824, 0.0410713702, -0.0383464321, -0.0354168788, -0.0148178395, -0.0140578784, 0.0459174849, -0.0886780322, -0.0129989851, 0.0062085418, 2.664e-7, 0.0436300188, 0.0700548962, 0.0088294344, 0.0349048451, 0.0310645737, 0.0095456382, 0.0337990224, 0.0176659562, 0.0307726637, -0.0570229217, -0.0093304785, 0.0637068897, -0.0108593898, -0.0583712719, -0.0494486578, -0.0005643358, -0.0249296036, 0.0506036505, -0.0387559831, 0.0229176562, 0.0709395483, 0.0488490351, -0.0163844824, -0.0489278547, -0.0016371005, 0.0051397136, 0.0658044666, -0.0148063386, 0.0316022038, -0.0203121752, -0.008501472, 0.0029291138, 0.014826837, 0.0847007409, 0.0436455123, 0.0367322899, 0.0325297862, 0.0168600604, 0.0140660442, 0.0071849627, -0.0244321804, -0.0253714956, 0.0039107208, -0.0360182114, 0.0316966064, -0.1062076837, -0.0938794687, -0.0080031315, -0.0155841494, 0.0138849299, 0.0471608229, 0.0385903269, 0.0041671111, -0.0341351442, 0.028442435, -0.0270343926, 0.0089943642, -0.0366765372, -0.0047818501, 0.0368387587, -0.0768569186, 0.0463649891, -0.0632145405, -0.0202804524, 0.0660078228, -0.0486178771, -0.0065094433, 1.837641135e-34, -0.0164455324, 0.013092177, 0.0584477857, 0.0132351555, 0.009463246, -0.0122280773, 0.0197886173, -0.0150460163, 0.0111186085, -0.1038898304, -0.0120576127 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.06323v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.06323v2
An Error-Guided Correction Model for Chinese Spelling Error Correction
2023-01-16T09:27:45
2023-03-20T08:37:45
Rui Sun, Xiuyu Wu, Yunfang Wu
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI
Although existing neural network approaches have achieved great success on Chinese spelling correction, there is still room to improve. The model is required to avoid over-correction and to distinguish a correct token from its phonological and visually similar ones. In this paper, we propose an error-guided correction model (EGCM) to improve Chinese spelling correction. By borrowing the powerful ability of BERT, we propose a novel zero-shot error detection method to do a preliminary detection, which guides our model to attend more on the probably wrong tokens in encoding and to avoid modifying the correct tokens in generating. Furthermore, we introduce a new loss function to integrate the error confusion set, which enables our model to distinguish easily misused tokens. Moreover, our model supports highly parallel decoding to meet real application requirements. Experiments are conducted on widely used benchmarks. Our model achieves superior performance against state-of-the-art approaches by a remarkable margin, on both the correction quality and computation speed.
[ 0.0299886502, 0.0060135159, 0.0238724984, 0.0193855669, -0.008573872, 0.0020475741, -0.0176536888, -0.0068656113, -0.0238616187, -0.0215858128, -0.0030081673, -0.0384597443, 0.0587367378, -0.0373140872, 0.0270798691, -0.0262220185, 0.0665797368, 0.014765664, 0.0277462918, -0.0276526213, 0.014633093, -0.0128048798, -0.0277679116, 0.0594193973, -0.0361102074, -0.0434511043, -0.0192201789, 0.0753060356, -0.0040262449, -0.0107186958, 0.0310541913, 0.0396599732, -0.0431068912, 0.0743961036, 0.0000017498, -0.0280622914, -0.042576015, -0.0041982406, -0.0058219647, 0.071401611, -0.0162448771, -0.0055750804, -0.0875247195, 0.0574014112, 0.0571477823, -0.0187316164, 0.1105069593, 0.0508941859, 0.0363667123, 0.0697005093, -0.0087641776, -0.0123562105, 0.0320152976, -0.00666994, -0.0198888984, -0.0116314245, 0.0373142138, -0.0176245142, -0.0522753149, -0.0541133881, -0.0680973604, 0.0129005508, -0.0214221682, -0.0140714739, 0.001277383, -0.0032491866, -0.0112603633, -0.005499688, -0.0519996881, 0.0252896212, -0.034483958, -0.0365078747, -0.0309298169, 0.0230109096, 0.0113220671, -0.015115899, 0.0130382208, -0.0024634686, -0.0118059237, 0.025957197, 0.0310604423, -0.0842281207, 0.0351202153, 0.0239006877, -0.0204001386, 0.0285075605, 0.0542451181, -0.0808620676, -0.064898178, 0.0145778079, 0.0137814423, -0.0266960766, 0.0886008218, 0.0110832388, -0.018667208, 0.0073523596, -0.0430594273, -0.0834240243, -0.0115219848, -0.0431003384, 0.0147353644, 0.0398058519, -0.0385782421, -0.0075853663, -0.0560954735, 0.0673609003, 0.0192229357, 0.0373499095, 0.0014582411, -0.0297485068, -0.0312976651, 0.0045711705, -0.0743257478, 0.044479996, -0.0045753908, -0.0110341562, -0.0724855959, -0.013979841, -0.0213534236, 0.0336242579, 0.0434146784, 0.0073171547, -0.0397896916, -0.0261061192, 0.0228538532, 0.0340907127, 0.0151608018, 0.0130209196, -0.0141733298, -0.0310730636, -0.0185659043, -0.0222966615, 0.0259893686, 0.0053675659, 0.014616305, 0.0352166779, -0.0225412846, -0.0187167935, -0.032390289, 0.0266855098, -0.0341116749, 0.0367341228, -0.0391781144, -0.0556735098, -0.024722131, -0.0357952081, 0.0394966528, -0.0122839706, 0.0212062299, 0.0074333646, -0.0293097775, 0.0710960478, -0.047019098, 0.0056198244, 0.0472964421, -0.0099048624, 0.0148892058, 0.0238930583, 0.0421083048, -0.0292836055, 0.0587050505, 0.0031650846, 0.0360385366, 0.0332216062, -0.0058999765, -0.015933726, -0.0340498723, -0.0774387121, -0.0109039638, 0.0368369706, 0.0474704094, 0.1050761268, -0.0449520983, 0.031597849, 0.0524399206, 0.0115641579, 0.041237507, 0.0138159068, -0.0059248433, -0.0403730832, 0.0035245093, 0.0132196099, -0.0023227613, 0.0041485885, -0.0275943317, 0.0165044684, 0.0640200973, -0.0252587218, -0.0349264443, -0.0255941749, -0.0246258155, 0.0021295624, -0.00752792, -0.058948651, 0.0630954504, 0.0110796588, -0.0705463514, 0.0562457517, -0.0302329827, -0.041230835, 0.0061807195, -0.0529515706, 0.0115325004, 0.1000742316, 0.0958136693, 0.0053742193, -0.0448558815, 0.0128980596, -0.0592706017, 0.0567661263, 0.0361477807, -0.0096778153, -0.0001306703, -0.068873331, 0.0091549503, 0.0609493032, 0.0138032362, 0.0104662767, 0.0356951654, 0.0287534129, -0.0048877792, -0.0135810189, -0.0328581035, 0.0325582288, 0.0355587341, -0.0159675442, 0.0079478715, 0.0173101369, 0.0123056499, 0.0238758344, -0.055620905, 0.027396556, -0.0290295463, -0.0149328718, -0.0413189232, -0.0122048836, -0.0240126625, -0.0578514487, 0.0781302452, -0.0544302575, -0.0252376422, 0.0455259718, -0.0231912453, -0.0562418811, -0.0211510863, -0.059103094, 0.0579012521, -0.0944428146, 0.0714915916, -0.0074786101, -0.0080747567, 0.0161408987, -0.0032302802, -0.0252183303, 0.0273473971, 0.0134573812, 0.0457100682, -0.0130658923, -0.0557301641, -0.0790771618, -0.0081559345, -0.0114004463, 0.036254473, 0.0062217657, 0.0104147093, -0.0030792393, -0.0269787572, -0.0564204678, -0.0043250453, -0.0351050608, -0.0011794708, 0.0297181271, -0.0024210664, 0.004247345, -0.0304295085, -0.0013617002, 0.0125257475, -0.0053439322, -0.0144935856, 0.0453347601, -0.0320437551, -0.0431406163, -0.0392978638, -0.0028226387, -0.0101842182, -0.0200376343, -0.0175284073, -0.0608757176, -0.084962897, -0.0121482173, -0.0025403474, 0.0454531983, 0.0668797195, -0.100929305, -0.0022155368, -0.0294863749, 0.0267396569, -0.0058800182, 0.0041624303, 0.0173750091, -0.0096550239, -0.0297509078, -0.0102931717, 0.0175813008, 0.015831219, -0.0131786391, 0.0169074461, -0.0403456502, -0.0102626123, 0.0398505107, 0.0108128227, -0.0013190572, -0.053364452, -0.0363578051, 0.0061966777, -0.0169855263, -0.0097930273, -0.0228473544, -0.019394543, -0.028813649, -0.0444487035, -0.0155278072, 0.0598792322, -0.0375123769, 0.0145637784, -0.0329104997, 0.0532145128, 0.0069522834, -0.0392288938, -0.0439035073, 0.0298001096, -0.0441053212, -0.0940417573, -0.0135341752, 0.0167140123, 0.0194176249, -0.0335738324, 0.0275356304, -0.0531749129, 0.0194862541, -0.0054665972, -0.0018786706, -0.0220880248, 0.0263187848, -0.0106509607, 0.0186823644, 0.0493902415, -0.0284945462, -0.0086284904, 0.0328151807, -0.0282175429, 0.0603452437, -0.0081268083, 0.0122648692, -0.0083697233, 0.027221879, -0.0174737088, -0.0065794396, 0.0341678672, -0.0315902308, 0.0562634207, 0.043357987, 0.037336193, 0.0134965545, -0.0105333142, -0.0087991897, 0.0370803326, -0.0497472212, 0.0013062549, -0.0045884345, 0.022053672, -0.0376049727, -0.0339185037, 0.1119923666, 0.0251115896, -0.0404895917, -0.0245058537, -0.0071956636, -0.0383690409, -0.0268648304, -0.0115084816, -0.0720470995, -0.0406909138, 0.0681781843, 0.0146841649, -0.0053187381, 0.0025328551, 0.0316698775, -0.1469373405, 0.031334389, 0.0514704771, -0.0084754983, -0.1014833152, 0.0236028824, 0.0019380234, 0.0212692246, 0.0595085956, 0.051710546, 0.0228100661, -0.0404299684, 0.022622684, -0.0045268517, -0.0669187307, -0.0299058165, -0.0663539916, 0.0752263889, 0.0703081638, 0.0121981036, -0.0009116394, -0.0293652415, 0.0055406671, -0.0083853165, -0.0198207088, -0.003794638, 0.0216828939, -0.0013698082, -0.0365825146, 0.0006783183, -0.0026929649, -0.000370359, 0.008531942, -0.0086020501, 0.0154666444, -0.0076065003, 0.031906303, 0.0092484457, -0.0002085203, -0.0074497825, 0.0503931679, 0.0138530973, -0.0402184166, -0.0602957457, -0.0418371968, 0.0130839022, -0.1078132913, 0.08897046, 0.031477198, -0.0527674295, -0.0455747694, -0.0959765017, -0.0148525955, 0.0233595837, 0.0184003431, 0.0235053878, -0.0111882119, 0.0010264805, 0.0462506115, -0.0248017572, -0.0671383142, 0.0122033441, 0.0237618983, -0.114940837, 0.0112770516, -0.0359071642, 0.0072397492, 0.0264409371, 0.0091465572, -0.0118118105, -0.0340758227, 0.0402400009, 0.025220057, 0.0072196661, 0.0330631882, -0.0506969802, -0.0503816903, 0.0264674649, 0.0531182326, 0.024579348, 0.0217797868, 0.0184560046, -0.0275240932, -0.0084713036, 0.0153916394, -0.0288860369, 0.0043957578, -0.0061980062, 0.086249873, -0.0047950037, 0.0023423058, 0.0520934202, 0.0285107885, 0.0493606776, -0.0286991298, 0.0389219262, -0.0485048033, 0.0479317904, 0.0001131868, 0.0081330193, -0.007136018, -0.0025093709, 0.0127602974, -0.0345808417, -0.0278509837, -0.016614534, -0.0064827581, -0.0368904583, -0.0057248869, -0.0256399717, -0.0106002688, 0.0455331691, 0.0147822602, -0.0096648503, -0.0077740825, 0.0001601336, 0.0541146584, -0.012657579, -0.0124952858, 0.0085805533, 0.0125418743, 0.034197852, -0.028314095, 0.0051716645, -0.00385458, 0.0238205381, -0.0392834768, 0.0504216254, 0.1296194941, 0.021076519, 0.0288110804, -0.0436244719, -0.0187528897, -0.040306285, -0.0093465, -0.0070225559, 0.0192207824, -0.0003333028, 0.0040894765, 0.0284795389, -0.0536639653, 0.0444404408, -0.0172859915, 0.0502859689, -0.0361973792, -0.0546589643, -0.0106347213, 0.0019434899, 0.0236533638, -0.0118215457, -0.0442252196, -0.0227329712, -0.0041187126, -0.0681852251, 0.0145685673, 0.060113389, 0.0429985747, 0.0197357275, 0.0102278367, 0.0099681225, 0.0022370387, 0.0122476993, -0.0209264681, -0.007659357, 0.0154477116, -0.0147385597, 0.0149441771, -5.432166943e-33, -0.0397124961, 0.0160155389, -0.0115366066, -0.0440909527, 0.0020252555, 0.0145474765, -0.0211622156, -0.0144419521, -0.0064559914, 0.040840786, -0.0126146395, 0.0416631848, 0.0237077735, 0.0118418019, 0.0386567153, 0.037694905, 0.0912709832, -0.0027367736, 0.0281318296, -0.0476161353, 0.0512003824, 0.0731429383, 0.0612283014, 0.0327800699, 0.0038721019, 0.0209132675, -0.0328714401, 0.0268572364, 0.0115199322, 0.0228680782, 0.0236277636, 0.0434850566, 0.00669081, 0.0151642431, -0.018000856, 0.000161016, -0.1191791967, -0.0087855365, -0.0080980966, 0.078577742, -0.0066594244, -0.0197775364, 0.0507201441, 0.0052196882, -0.0283433348, 0.0356646515, -0.001715809, -0.0499463566, 0.0046249237, -0.0081359297, -0.0158396401, 0.0136987492, 0.0258268528, -0.0184661914, 0.0003037897, -0.0058864728, -0.0282681044, 0.0033507971, -0.0974012241, -0.0067874957, 0.0357972123, 0.0344743729, 0.018469939, 0.0253615174, -0.021601459, 0.0063561411, 0.0428173989, -0.0214225277, 0.0045567886, -0.0003795452, 0.0385635458, -0.0352033824, 0.0664874762, 0.0019650788, 0.0443200506, -0.0793654546, -0.0350893736, 0.0164463911, -0.0022077211, 0.0270700231, 0.0212343931, 0.0194844808, -0.0273680892, -0.0243246034, 0.0123518659, -0.0041057635, -0.0393003114, 0.0041201548, 0.0191894155, 0.022231929, -0.0199047681, -0.0186359826, 0.0139330849, -0.0366976112, 0.008571744, -0.0091428543, 0.0336420648, 0.013952042, -0.0433609895, 0.0131086018, -0.015932763, -0.0380464755, 0.0131012108, 0.0216952767, -0.025587609, 0.0116316443, 0.0229049474, 0.02994252, -0.0675208941, 0.0172585677, -0.0143639343, 0.0020646832, 0.028708918, -0.0095531298, 0.0068908152, -0.0074912622, 0.0279767141, -0.0229793657, 0.0175690521, 0.0267707389, 0.0124758026, -0.0077774408, -0.0166337732, -0.0026797429, -0.022001341, 0.0095745651, -0.0331236757, 0.0078302119, -0.0121620102, -0.0533380322, -0.0203758683, 0.019793069, 2.464e-7, 0.0291233007, 0.0556961372, 0.0889195725, -0.0001443955, 0.0239783861, -0.0016184943, -0.038954109, 0.0339541398, -0.0103250872, 0.0646902844, 0.0553414039, -0.0324560404, 0.0446415767, -0.0129796015, -0.0509699918, -0.0136311492, -0.0333228745, 0.0488145836, 0.0103953322, 0.0236659348, -0.0126618864, 0.0337210521, -0.0049000485, -0.0182018224, -0.0085726855, -0.0234774742, 0.0147587378, 0.0314119272, 0.008707921, 0.0119152311, 0.036918398, 0.0566477664, 0.0101759322, 0.0307021067, -0.0293628629, -0.0024534806, 0.0419851765, 0.015620173, -0.0479346439, 0.0114827566, 0.0031521844, 0.0061051017, -0.018944962, -0.018608734, 0.0076566031, 0.0232137926, 0.053146217, 0.0066367784, -0.0296371635, 0.0285566114, 0.0108922599, -0.0542688556, -0.0390974917, 0.0153292567, 0.0410161912, 0.0475423038, -0.0202485211, -0.0346984267, -0.0109616462, 0.0032258797, -0.0038773052, -0.0233015679, 0.0170789789, -0.0102936393, 0.009316762, -0.0365218334, -0.0127303442, 1.950073956e-34, 0.0385884866, -0.0487954579, 0.0067001893, 0.0342318565, 0.0105083697, -0.0166243687, 0.0059301965, 0.0010127104, -0.0188741311, -0.0123949181, -0.0500839613 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.06270v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.06270v2
Computational Assessment of Hyperpartisanship in News Titles
2023-01-16T05:56:58
2024-04-21T10:55:52
Hanjia Lyu, Jinsheng Pan, Zichen Wang, Jiebo Luo
cs.CL
cs.CL
We first adopt a human-guided machine learning framework to develop a new dataset for hyperpartisan news title detection with 2,200 manually labeled and 1.8 million machine-labeled titles that were posted from 2014 to the present by nine representative media organizations across three media bias groups - Left, Central, and Right in an active learning manner. A fine-tuned transformer-based language model achieves an overall accuracy of 0.84 and an F1 score of 0.78 on an external validation set. Next, we conduct a computational analysis to quantify the extent and dynamics of partisanship in news titles. While some aspects are as expected, our study reveals new or nuanced differences between the three media groups. We find that overall the Right media tends to use proportionally more hyperpartisan titles. Roughly around the 2016 Presidential Election, the proportions of hyperpartisan titles increased across all media bias groups, with the Left media exhibiting the most significant relative increase. We identify three major topics including foreign issues, political systems, and societal issues that are suggestive of hyperpartisanship in news titles using logistic regression models and the Shapley values. Through an analysis of the topic distribution, we find that societal issues gradually gain more attention from all media groups. We further apply a lexicon-based language analysis tool to the titles of each topic and quantify the linguistic distance between any pairs of the three media groups, uncovering three distinct patterns.
[ 0.0499304123, 0.0750393346, -0.0018559698, -0.0024289624, -0.0063851806, 0.0319521278, -0.0211419631, -0.0072851479, -0.0307789911, -0.0821443498, 0.0057548084, 0.0133116664, -0.0071538799, 0.0239535999, -0.0363346301, -0.0728889406, 0.0362607762, 0.0556066521, 0.0829634592, -0.0247523729, 0.0270073377, 0.0250556674, -0.0122455936, 0.050673794, -0.0364017561, 0.005226044, 0.016622562, 0.0146350274, 0.027556546, -0.0035498138, 0.0131032765, 0.0766229033, -0.0240054205, 0.0285377931, 0.0000017159, -0.0413933098, -0.0229720306, -0.0395402536, 0.0601460673, -0.0261708573, 0.1167656332, -0.0570842624, -0.0167863891, 0.0059372382, -0.0357052758, -0.0147426128, 0.0469199829, 0.0155343032, 0.0257966369, 0.0456773974, -0.0102110142, -0.0001075066, 0.0039934735, 0.0119061703, -0.014803783, -0.0383330584, 0.0468204878, -0.007656598, -0.1011491716, -0.036039196, -0.0419757552, 0.0039683231, 0.0144510092, 0.0167178512, -0.0709622577, 0.017943779, -0.0517243966, -0.0196709577, -0.0101489406, 0.0130127268, -0.0227509737, -0.0301781967, 0.0341886431, -0.0005939112, -0.0010432594, 0.0599289015, -0.0272144135, 0.0388423465, -0.0069084871, 0.007359426, 0.0521419421, -0.0219021514, -0.0100058531, 0.0740219429, -0.0194983725, 0.0745844468, -0.0015776937, 0.0003922631, 0.0043261996, 0.0276965816, 0.019441532, -0.0141531425, 0.0581695177, -0.0110394461, 0.0344203785, 0.0190645959, -0.0166920889, -0.0328237973, 0.0186212938, -0.093273975, -0.030994432, -0.0214912556, -0.0098317917, 0.0730598196, 0.031182671, -0.0440170504, 0.0073151258, 0.0145807657, 0.0268758051, -0.0139241414, -0.0164262205, 0.0116932038, 0.0163242742, 0.0006199616, 0.0180188883, 0.0062311809, -0.0255422816, -0.0170009788, -0.0246813111, -0.0102966847, -0.0165274516, 0.0071810633, -0.0098350476, -0.039156165, -0.0189274959, 0.0644360483, -0.0362948105, 0.0211937167, -0.0240452588, 0.0198300816, 0.0263852905, 0.0529233813, -0.0190974828, -0.0081680696, 0.0071470169, 0.0236086529, -0.008514069, 0.00067464, 0.032731887, 0.0344120674, -0.0405847244, 0.013760196, 0.0145411389, -0.0533403605, 0.0226029009, -0.0042854901, 0.0205790829, -0.0036697441, -0.0093046529, 0.0232489053, -0.0425040647, 0.0363374874, 0.0257614143, 0.028915409, 0.0811775774, 0.0058335913, -0.0018315382, 0.0878673792, 0.0177429914, 0.0528758951, 0.0721617267, -0.0066633872, 0.0397855975, 0.0262915511, -0.0255213287, 0.0267631393, -0.0319621116, -0.0098965811, -0.0293937232, -0.0433877595, 0.029239269, 0.012357533, 0.0439804122, -0.0246957503, 0.0786640719, 0.0492720939, -0.0286187939, 0.0252533816, 0.0188837592, 0.0110671492, -0.0204092655, 0.0175920762, -0.0095657939, 0.0161265805, -0.0440730751, -0.0327767208, 0.0072776373, 0.0468839556, -0.0100826658, -0.0387486853, -0.0080183884, 0.0088541955, 0.0146710034, -0.0208613388, 0.0566510744, -0.0059813615, -0.0243425984, 0.0458901189, 0.0383794196, -0.0081914756, 0.0167953148, -0.0161856785, 0.0448059328, -0.0107975947, -0.0031594208, -0.027163703, 0.0061143148, -0.0319756828, 0.052032914, 0.0369636789, 0.0609920025, -0.0112382546, -0.0493936799, -0.0070418422, -0.0191691741, 0.0373096913, 0.0347002856, 0.0542035699, -0.0144235361, 0.0619975515, -0.0092209997, 0.0220773872, -0.0181436371, 0.0383878946, 0.0022223527, 0.0129155694, -0.0062218257, 0.0221433453, 0.0055738534, 0.0094545772, -0.0063425731, -0.0474299937, 0.0084601548, 0.0208163224, -0.0563560724, -0.0116380015, -0.0085081914, 0.0461916551, -0.0093045328, -0.0853793919, -0.0231370013, 0.0430117771, -0.0109227952, 0.0173988473, 0.0307590924, -0.0083021242, -0.0279413778, -0.0303366669, 0.0031858559, -0.0444755554, -0.0022539429, -0.0552649833, 0.0633380041, -0.0073804962, 0.0268831085, -0.0264207013, -0.0794802308, 0.0030909358, 0.0316484198, -0.0052083852, 0.0374091603, -0.0078088245, 0.0238052886, 0.0503068492, -0.0586063564, -0.0315209143, -0.0711609796, -0.0117210299, -0.0022462241, -0.0453535579, 0.0014976307, 0.0438647643, -0.0350449197, -0.0349970721, 0.0411389135, 0.0126989419, -0.0601794161, -0.0351537019, -0.0045273537, 0.0175715294, -0.0183963068, -0.0049424535, -0.0328542516, -0.020931581, -0.0437275246, 0.037785843, 0.0335538909, 0.0182553325, -0.011960892, -0.0165154971, -0.0391663164, -0.0457211137, -0.0282581653, -0.0172717534, -0.0018527259, 0.0119833285, -0.0018853686, 0.0523761399, 0.0800281689, 0.0697325841, 0.0556384511, 0.0318844207, -0.0257075597, -0.0357144251, -0.0592518933, -0.0231943261, -0.0230634101, -0.0202695988, 0.0513245128, 0.0789126754, 0.0103180585, 0.0104874838, -0.0090523465, 0.0457450636, -0.0493259542, -0.0343283564, 0.025809681, 0.0211771913, 0.0018080627, 0.0429362766, 0.0110594379, -0.0259583574, 0.0163435061, 0.0318309143, 0.072749339, -0.0155038405, -0.0174936317, 0.0009556952, 0.0228094049, -0.0270923842, 0.0171096791, -0.0400741287, -0.0503035299, -0.0325657986, -0.0410255231, 0.049915731, -0.0431106798, 0.0701736808, -0.0298907198, -0.0072317198, 0.0112560764, -0.0150295338, -0.0152354129, -0.0698186234, 0.0083860634, -0.0137211969, 0.0329953469, -0.0301459543, -0.046241466, 0.0377823226, 0.023067141, -0.0472798422, -0.0028913193, -0.0102759777, 0.0216014162, 0.0587291569, 0.0391980857, -0.0278576016, -0.0008421679, 0.0213674754, -0.0247709416, -0.0023583418, -0.015920477, 0.0883024782, -0.0099125523, -0.0318373181, 0.0235718768, -0.0522575639, 0.0035291717, -0.0321938097, 0.0031127543, 0.0063659293, 0.0478937663, 0.0956797004, 0.0477185063, -0.0665912479, -0.0196661893, 0.0005522555, -0.0645558387, 0.0487586744, 0.0058665825, -0.0798052624, 0.0523360632, 0.0098616434, -0.0043768045, -0.0176303238, -0.0360626467, -0.0089626294, -0.0585421138, -0.0194641724, -0.0151643539, -0.0081245666, 0.0128714181, -0.0618125349, 0.0084455973, -0.0552286655, -0.0263887309, -0.029006578, 0.0053217653, 0.0190273002, -0.0229026042, -0.0592427216, -0.0396384373, 0.0282007717, -0.0193928163, 0.0001991412, 0.0029162716, 0.0743391961, -0.040377941, -0.0072639524, -0.0087110912, 0.0131574981, -0.0144856004, -0.0356894545, 0.0724511892, -0.0504148193, -0.0003457663, -0.0400584564, 0.0300217103, 0.0402141847, 0.0280904043, 0.0047512669, 0.0048241126, 0.0016978461, -0.0618965961, -0.0285123885, 0.0229530912, 0.0475208946, 0.0544838272, 0.0196070019, -0.034053307, 0.0197215546, -0.0398345478, 0.0219111815, -0.0179568361, -0.0248254649, -0.0148834093, -0.0503411591, -0.0321499854, -0.028629262, -0.0289051775, 0.0043612234, 0.017685717, 0.0190384872, 0.010175975, 0.0499072485, -0.0115045458, -0.0653120577, 0.0095527871, 0.0198147073, -0.0059419256, 0.0083755692, -0.0625113025, 0.0254721064, 0.0404517613, -0.0655272156, 0.0318473168, 0.0074190819, -0.0214885604, 0.0335505903, -0.0059023779, 0.0161027741, -0.0147159137, -0.0103114489, -0.0016560975, 0.0096353572, 0.0835873261, -0.0368900634, -0.0239029881, 0.0019041585, 0.0194720179, 0.025688773, 0.0059244796, -0.0000996814, 0.0544728898, 0.040517915, -0.0615261197, -0.0523938388, 0.0277067162, 0.0054849181, -0.0208199788, 0.1030677333, -0.0018584902, -0.0451216996, -0.0391291827, -0.0564284623, -0.012299764, -0.0245980863, 0.0321414731, 0.007249176, 0.0238411725, -0.0158429816, -0.0841102973, 0.039346911, -0.0428253002, 0.0381129421, -0.0721816942, 0.0439876467, -0.0495398901, 0.0481537096, 0.0112913512, -0.0010141077, -0.014108723, 0.0112653207, 0.0246927049, 0.0312383231, 0.0175928976, 0.0147014689, 0.0147158438, 0.0366999246, 0.0066148592, -0.0106466776, -0.0373418033, -0.0058445404, 0.0048393989, 0.0435635634, 0.0339046754, -0.047647845, -0.0094520207, 0.0247238409, -0.0260084718, 0.0141503327, 0.0043124086, -0.0086275497, -0.0452865176, 0.0460092314, 0.0206587259, -0.040745683, 0.0013551485, 0.0411636941, -0.0263098832, -0.0049702413, 0.0533430167, -0.0521629304, -0.0104055069, -0.0142197227, 0.0902699232, -0.0246378146, -0.0024289074, -0.0207559653, -0.0433194563, -0.0246671811, 0.0266171899, -0.0279318616, 0.0446412414, 0.0123695498, -0.0334040783, 0.0831807777, -0.0258071218, 0.0317845084, -0.0467010252, 0.036496345, -0.0673465356, -0.0394884348, 0.010144663, -6.006231732e-33, -0.0111591453, -0.0367258489, -0.0217286292, 0.0073779435, 0.0096578142, 0.0364891998, -0.0169683006, 0.0468546227, -0.0233976264, 0.0326127484, 0.0118694752, 0.0492546856, 0.0138175422, 0.0021528723, 0.0282236319, -0.0072037615, -0.0090207178, -0.0080640577, -0.0223020986, 0.0013447365, 0.0042250371, 0.0070570908, 0.0468090884, -0.0790600032, 0.0283274148, 0.0187836289, -0.0223043989, -0.0679529086, 0.0396327786, 0.0128418272, 0.0049484004, 0.0124616968, 0.058712285, -0.0937169343, 0.0198238697, 0.0945563316, -0.026994016, -0.0324547477, 0.0289094802, -0.0006967979, 0.0358283557, 0.0078096995, 0.0236943383, 0.0311023649, -0.0807425156, -0.0195565801, 0.0698109716, -0.0278941486, -0.0061781262, -0.0572412275, -0.0394873098, 0.0114260651, -0.0359138995, 0.0338506326, -0.0169965569, 0.0074638589, 0.050108809, 0.0621368214, -0.0644098297, 0.0241993424, -0.0713261738, 0.0212121941, 0.0204978958, -0.0261722803, -0.0009614183, 0.0718270093, 0.016233908, 0.0540886931, -0.0433549806, 0.0335630849, 0.0359865427, -0.0181923136, 0.034410961, 0.0435771532, 0.0474438816, -0.0853447467, -0.0428315587, 0.0148229348, 0.04524922, -0.0472105369, 0.0412630849, -0.039434839, -0.0233772211, 0.0048317057, -0.0349579789, -0.041798126, -0.0275409333, -0.0275806561, -0.0055207419, 0.0218493473, -0.0389681533, 0.0431827307, 0.0074703936, -0.0541740246, -0.0114987027, 0.036716599, -0.0217568129, 0.0040139258, -0.0129848253, 0.0152681423, -0.0245384946, -0.0173968635, -0.0427478999, 0.0330974199, 0.021728307, -0.0379784629, 0.0357346572, -0.012741046, -0.0667349473, -0.0103239324, 0.0273104347, -0.008991546, 0.0080562271, 0.0338196084, 0.0128779206, 0.0208762381, 0.0082501769, -0.0130319446, 0.0346756503, -0.0343278795, 0.0267053656, -0.0036111108, -0.0694756359, 0.0216600168, -0.0584905334, -0.0584854819, -0.0438156165, -0.0259890538, 0.0388405435, -0.0612644181, -0.0251827147, -0.0494162887, 2.474e-7, 0.07181523, 0.1028580666, -0.0251290053, 0.0223862398, 0.0014951953, 0.0024800408, 0.0248323567, 0.0523351319, -0.029451102, -0.0563426465, -0.0117689688, -0.0077724596, 0.0129234921, 0.0119664865, -0.0707512721, -0.0099793579, -0.0457332581, 0.0328559615, -0.0671930537, 0.0464883521, 0.0090299705, 0.0090524806, 0.0400813855, -0.0036863082, -0.0233884472, -0.0186506379, 0.0274661798, -0.0503408238, -0.0193194747, 0.0395822525, 0.0249037724, -0.0096108373, 0.0023112197, 0.0137806302, -0.0140868779, -0.005465982, 0.0299224705, 0.0433366373, -0.0015445512, -0.01697262, -0.0066474606, -0.0204020329, -0.0016186933, -0.061949309, 0.0696759224, -0.0787229091, -0.0335611589, -0.0933041051, -0.0626735762, 0.0021792324, 0.0626823604, -0.0277349241, 0.0122587485, 0.0277419258, -0.0089958077, 0.0460677668, 0.0172306988, -0.0265634302, 0.0070905853, 0.0247858819, -0.0274134986, -0.0094102863, 0.0149520999, 0.0037094562, 0.0357537754, -0.021530496, 0.0215228591, 1.5878487e-34, 0.0282415915, 0.0036489223, -0.0144282514, -0.0625458136, 0.0354427472, 0.0131471194, -0.0364449285, -0.0124256685, -0.0193726812, -0.05394274, 0.0126415975 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.07695v5
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.07695v5
EHRSQL: A Practical Text-to-SQL Benchmark for Electronic Health Records
2023-01-16T05:10:20
2023-12-25T07:12:53
Gyubok Lee, Hyeonji Hwang, Seongsu Bae, Yeonsu Kwon, Woncheol Shin, Seongjun Yang, Minjoon Seo, Jong-Yeup Kim, Edward Choi
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI
We present a new text-to-SQL dataset for electronic health records (EHRs). The utterances were collected from 222 hospital staff members, including physicians, nurses, and insurance review and health records teams. To construct the QA dataset on structured EHR data, we conducted a poll at a university hospital and used the responses to create seed questions. We then manually linked these questions to two open-source EHR databases, MIMIC-III and eICU, and included various time expressions and held-out unanswerable questions in the dataset, which were also collected from the poll. Our dataset poses a unique set of challenges: the model needs to 1) generate SQL queries that reflect a wide range of needs in the hospital, including simple retrieval and complex operations such as calculating survival rate, 2) understand various time expressions to answer time-sensitive questions in healthcare, and 3) distinguish whether a given question is answerable or unanswerable. We believe our dataset, EHRSQL, can serve as a practical benchmark for developing and assessing QA models on structured EHR data and take a step further towards bridging the gap between text-to-SQL research and its real-life deployment in healthcare. EHRSQL is available at https://github.com/glee4810/EHRSQL.
[ 0.0403106883, 0.0855844766, -0.0314802043, -0.0475383736, -0.0217036773, 0.0520178936, -0.0348141827, 0.0209076926, 0.0318333246, 0.0082118185, 0.0485623553, -0.0393372513, -0.0127534783, 0.0707698241, 0.0010062585, -0.0214476231, 0.0073209312, 0.0404539183, 0.0042683487, 0.0300308112, -0.014343054, 0.0303710699, -0.0385796688, 0.0237332899, 0.0348980129, 0.013496547, -0.0312408507, 0.016067788, -0.0112091517, -0.0469255112, -0.0114122294, 0.0086465143, -0.0407716222, -0.037651591, 0.0000020252, -0.05179983, -0.0577278174, 0.0374800786, -0.1020141616, -0.0341254026, 0.0292846281, -0.0422262773, 0.0082828281, 0.047306139, -0.0251447354, -0.0115654971, 0.0292985588, 0.0015033718, 0.0044979658, 0.0386103243, -0.0271136705, 0.0250320826, 0.0045991288, -0.0100482516, 0.0522706993, -0.0527468808, 0.0098651303, 0.0137525769, 0.0677620023, -0.0288411602, 0.0370306335, 0.0312440582, -0.005545787, 0.0310005527, -0.0088977488, 0.0078411913, -0.0280450117, 0.0463338159, -0.0178266037, 0.0448779352, 0.0478025824, 0.0046469569, 0.0477554165, -0.0037859273, -0.041315347, -0.0069344104, -0.0038857975, -0.0242496468, -0.0208076388, -0.0266811363, -0.0528053157, 0.0199743975, -0.0018182714, -0.0342801325, -0.0231684335, -0.0253195986, 0.0139907477, -0.0380794965, 0.026016809, -0.0343817323, 0.042112913, -0.0178697295, 0.0382348746, 0.0597675294, -0.0379864499, 0.0171709266, -0.0124299582, 0.0154168326, 0.0833938941, -0.0133871743, -0.0023586953, 0.0377375446, 0.0438155383, 0.0453560017, 0.0542278923, -0.0005049167, -0.0134117389, -0.0001176324, -0.05703656, -0.0312662609, -0.0663070828, 0.0041414225, -0.0063895625, 0.0208945423, -0.0117843188, 0.0297893975, -0.0531868488, -0.0036897678, 0.0364913382, 0.0391930379, 0.0381951816, 0.0409679413, -0.0305287149, 0.0036859536, -0.0674341246, -0.0115897357, 0.0122854793, 0.0183894392, -0.0049190298, -0.0786355734, 0.024674926, -0.0156597309, 0.0496672913, -0.0043164636, 0.0193848312, 0.031580478, -0.0008599511, 0.0081465757, -0.0408494733, -0.0685372576, 0.0038743063, 0.0120657012, -0.0085729947, -0.0020868862, 0.0548906066, 0.0376230814, -0.0451487899, -0.049435053, 0.0024157995, 0.0505753942, -0.0304863919, 0.0337428488, -0.0593449138, 0.0459652953, 0.0376618989, 0.006737547, 0.0335172154, 0.0289573316, 0.0062472518, -0.0430600159, -0.0062184832, -0.022268245, 0.00360702, 0.0162228495, 0.0309871566, -0.0091662453, -0.023816688, 0.0900532976, -0.0111542502, 0.0482593961, -0.0754212663, 0.0680258274, 0.0163908713, -0.0269857962, 0.0130465329, 0.0428606384, 0.0213116407, -0.019191483, -0.0176035073, -0.0086548906, -0.0099756168, -0.0865597129, 0.0096776886, 0.0180672221, 0.0356947593, 0.0084808702, -0.0106546544, -0.0443311594, -0.0519372411, -0.0512894206, -0.0303705987, 0.0041179322, -0.0375103541, 0.0131736752, 0.0138323354, -0.0053107901, -0.0431489535, 0.0611065738, -0.0100600701, -0.0364404321, -0.0131038725, -0.0602548569, -0.0204468034, 0.0815334246, 0.0423805974, -0.0608188994, -0.0439299867, -0.0342796147, 0.001280566, -0.0249907952, 0.0150545752, -0.0308123659, 0.0082200924, -0.0255192649, -0.0055546053, 0.0551519804, 0.0074377595, -0.0377073362, -0.0184471961, 0.051347699, -0.025051767, -0.0435418263, -0.0388979204, 0.0250949655, -0.0749326423, -0.019606892, -0.010116715, 0.0117694112, 0.0208210349, 0.0567204729, 0.0170531925, 0.0628224537, 0.0272531845, -0.0068431515, -0.0355187356, 0.0086787762, 0.0144443158, 0.0083891479, -0.0097569041, -0.0087123159, -0.0141990632, -0.0256376546, -0.0194467641, -0.0482154973, -0.0295710713, -0.0411490835, -0.0017000471, -0.0066046026, 0.0242483243, 0.0451823436, -0.0374445245, -0.0438521802, 0.0010420386, -0.0293614678, 0.020043822, -0.0083463406, -0.0540845729, 0.0380052365, -0.0681346729, 0.0301838201, -0.0028554129, -0.0097035728, 0.0390102006, -0.0378117263, -0.0117899366, -0.0918928906, 0.0187022444, -0.0907284766, 0.0007850333, 0.0015539373, 0.0508531854, 0.035123948, 0.046963308, 0.0063048583, -0.0346378013, -0.0499882251, -0.0543850288, -0.0078323595, 0.0067350203, 0.0221503191, 0.0513915569, 0.020431187, -0.0287580024, -0.0104544228, -0.055471044, 0.0295082424, -0.0070959716, 0.0118635194, 0.033726573, -0.0291987043, -0.0076214522, -0.014006895, -0.0021100829, 0.0157516021, -0.0007073137, -0.0403067768, 0.0181622151, 0.0385014042, -0.0168789998, -0.0339153036, -0.0143055553, -0.0149580836, -0.0192974508, 0.0171472747, -0.0339865051, 0.012810017, 0.0514917299, -0.0783232823, 0.03865261, 0.0233832728, 0.0216661002, 0.0019478074, -0.0400535278, 0.0297231562, -0.0187545642, 0.0378162824, -0.0979124233, 0.0388552435, -0.0196072143, 0.0623742417, 0.0217891503, 0.0384021029, 0.0166873671, 0.0234027505, 0.0466432609, -0.0650794953, -0.025774261, -0.0610551536, 0.028190393, -0.0341835842, 0.0126417195, -0.0080389427, -0.0370819718, 0.0059744129, -0.0159816183, -0.0297159068, -0.0572976656, 0.0301910825, 0.0049760677, 0.0367705524, -0.0125794364, -0.008733999, -0.0360964313, 0.0007083351, -0.028834017, 0.012394568, 0.0108733848, 0.0417723395, -0.0397114158, 0.0214915276, -0.0417475067, 0.0735884532, 0.0392485224, -0.0308129434, 0.0263921563, 0.0111726765, 0.0369432494, 0.0039641685, -0.0045520682, 0.0047782417, 0.0401337631, 0.0514982603, 0.0766818672, -0.019810766, 0.0150694624, 0.0212631505, -0.0191606134, -0.036645297, 0.0202984177, 0.0338405259, -0.0046964847, -0.0360613093, -0.0058652014, 0.0445298031, 0.0314948559, 0.0022428976, 0.0078801233, -0.0218672287, -0.0484578945, 0.020102812, 0.0336087346, -0.0574610718, -0.003980027, -0.0175869614, 0.0520304032, 0.0076835211, -0.0648437589, 0.0157910008, -0.0468288325, 0.0186876524, -0.0448319614, -0.0385418236, -0.0196965262, 0.0014208923, -0.0005272097, -0.0238188989, -0.0152698187, 0.0314292312, -0.0274753328, -0.0258104894, 0.0169094093, -0.0419630706, -0.0400863737, 0.0540557094, 0.0085028168, 0.0288997758, 0.0641686395, 0.0479153395, 0.0004104819, -0.045247335, -0.0389815569, -0.017224187, -0.0188708492, -0.016862087, 0.0831628665, 0.0283453166, -0.0052419933, -0.0225148369, 0.0418773778, -0.0526399091, 0.0212122183, 0.0280440394, 0.0921203569, -0.0511367433, 0.0314755291, -0.0486460775, -0.0165596623, 0.0249517336, 0.039045956, -0.0048612906, -0.0144459968, -0.0639572889, 0.0435489751, 0.0391102731, -0.0397159941, -0.017806394, 0.061364416, -0.0258386508, -0.0033338021, -0.0437699407, -0.0618761554, 0.0531179346, -0.0119688259, 0.0048551071, 0.0160529055, 0.0699119121, -0.0102930134, -0.0705502555, -0.0208524093, -0.0000222359, 0.0096849697, -0.0422529802, -0.0339350551, 0.0075929505, 0.0181475841, -0.0299588516, -0.0599824451, -0.0101728896, 0.0122805163, 0.0342855193, 0.0186235886, 0.0225862339, -0.0623603724, 0.0244868919, -0.0103689227, -0.014522803, 0.0246105045, -0.0654883534, -0.0592007153, -0.0491822027, 0.022884585, -0.0483576581, 0.0251182597, -0.0294288993, 0.0159468967, -0.0246942174, 0.0180784911, -0.0247038882, -0.0233528521, 0.0079976087, 0.0486863367, -0.009151374, 0.0659157634, -0.0389818065, -0.0135498131, 0.0546627715, -0.0682170987, 0.0123219071, -0.0232054703, -0.0024144505, -0.0097570308, -0.0078190491, 0.0058978666, -0.0211609602, -0.0532502122, -0.0164207425, -0.0616112761, 0.0318667702, 0.0217477158, 0.0364192091, 0.019168118, -0.0210478809, 0.0130957104, 0.044946216, 0.0170896817, 0.070541583, 0.0025581233, 0.0404565819, -0.0136239063, 0.0421047397, -0.0047734953, 0.0100262929, -0.0332341902, -0.0638961419, 0.0033094594, -0.026885584, -0.0254136696, 0.0187812652, 0.0134848971, 0.0053632041, -0.0126999421, -0.0035356015, -0.0054173893, 0.0427278616, 0.0644497201, 0.056174729, 0.0256398227, -0.0319450721, -0.0128225461, 0.0674783885, 0.0230138153, 0.0443923473, -0.0065494846, -0.0277361479, -0.0446070768, -0.013033988, 0.0725461245, -0.0157677699, -0.0409964956, -0.0378516391, -0.0708071813, -0.0211618561, 0.0532401688, 0.0232210103, -0.0496568643, -0.0130364159, 0.0514541976, 0.028152952, 0.045418296, -0.0027491753, -0.0296873357, 0.0559298769, -0.0880433992, -0.0306469612, 0.0366598703, -6.118563441e-33, 0.0132277226, -0.0229721796, 0.0458751321, -0.0344399996, 0.0472463332, 0.0211321097, -0.0198757686, -0.0269886591, -0.0183342174, -0.0153607577, -0.0445720628, 0.0406870097, 0.0239170436, 0.0325356089, 0.0244388692, -0.0500449613, 0.0182342343, -0.0113362046, 0.008618461, 0.0241253544, 0.0217296015, 0.027780937, 0.0074275276, -0.0304892566, 0.0107200518, -0.0058926456, 0.0133220656, 0.0178609937, -0.0043215468, 0.0451043993, -0.0387549214, 0.010367889, 0.0238753352, -0.027985787, 0.0223889276, 0.0050475732, -0.0773109868, -0.0343766101, -0.0048295972, -0.0211370923, -0.0224403441, -0.0226939637, 0.0418017805, -0.015633624, -0.0296484325, -0.0427780449, 0.0066040745, -0.011775123, -0.008351922, -0.0593763217, 0.0166857932, 0.0379653573, -0.0269278493, 0.0209883656, -0.0224208739, 0.0511016548, -0.0362064317, 0.0212773513, -0.0737057552, -0.0212274212, 0.0131475208, 0.0069528194, 0.0011281935, -0.0265319776, -0.019400876, 0.0009604539, 0.0113034453, 0.0137183741, -0.0126435654, 0.0724411905, -0.0410935692, 0.0513055958, 0.0224601366, 0.0448877923, 0.0076107248, -0.02232158, -0.0972033963, 0.0926448479, -0.0714176744, 0.0217707139, 0.0367258452, -0.0167487469, -0.0801475123, -0.005059659, -0.050680384, 0.0737863854, -0.0497296005, -0.0194298588, 0.061425332, 0.0058098421, -0.0095657771, 0.028426839, 0.001574166, -0.0065923193, 0.0017438834, -0.0075458172, 0.0158288442, -0.0274916198, -0.0307068173, 0.0183420386, -0.061835818, 0.0267993659, 0.0304390546, 0.0083607724, 0.0362593941, 0.0195844881, -0.0001837476, -0.0216552522, -0.0692766979, -0.0019857967, 0.0409599505, 0.0360153951, -0.0681512952, 0.0072747893, 0.0055391206, 0.0244916081, 0.0343645215, 0.0615170598, -0.0022890356, -0.0081625842, -0.0413927585, -0.0284550991, 0.0174119994, 0.0023842417, -0.0107609294, 0.0105117904, -0.0405661426, 0.0007691799, 0.0215120297, -0.0011916055, 0.0102972044, 0.0306788497, 2.729e-7, 0.1044569314, 0.0248157382, 0.0333087817, 0.0232992955, 0.016622182, 0.0086022699, 0.0157084875, -0.0147022521, 0.0136820758, 0.0237104408, 0.0716463923, -0.037515223, 0.0365262292, 0.0448071472, -0.0202073958, -0.0501341075, -0.0686909258, -0.0242818817, -0.0309106223, -0.0258881561, 0.0899520144, 0.0417207703, -0.0536947437, -0.0210475828, 0.0017106909, 0.0401237905, 0.008138, -0.0321444497, -0.0137264831, 0.0321269557, 0.0273990221, -0.0042187474, 0.008701643, 0.0399473831, -0.0138987526, -0.0166242048, -0.0043294034, 0.1039544642, -0.048868183, -0.0176214743, 0.0258102268, -0.0597303919, 0.0274459366, -0.0294102449, 0.0928072557, -0.0367486663, -0.0487140678, 0.0598597936, -0.0370288976, -0.000971792, 0.0434557162, 0.022716945, -0.0302471817, -0.0319287032, 0.0298833959, 0.0503469855, -0.0180528611, -0.0311346631, 0.0232298523, 0.0734187514, 0.0069177588, -0.0305629577, 0.0485495441, -0.0019375464, -0.0412679575, -0.0610049814, 0.0032725336, 2.374818176e-34, 0.0169845726, 0.0386984833, -0.0058052251, 0.0021625031, 0.0404020175, -0.0105616506, 0.0510108285, -0.0142776519, 0.0190844703, -0.0772446841, -0.0226481333 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.06237v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.06237v1
A separation logic for sequences in pointer programs and its decidability
2023-01-16T02:52:06
2023-01-16T02:52:06
Tianyue Cao, Bowen Zhang, Zhao Jin, Yongzhi Cao, Hanpin Wang
cs.LO
cs.LO, cs.CL
Separation logic and its variants can describe various properties on pointer programs. However, when it comes to properties on sequences, one may find it hard to formalize. To deal with properties on variable-length sequences and multilevel data structures, we propose sequence-heap separation logic which integrates sequences into logical reasoning on heap-manipulated programs. Quantifiers over sequence variables and singleton heap storing sequence (sequence singleton heap) are new members in our logic. Further, we study the satisfiability problem of two fragments. The propositional fragment of sequence-heap separation logic is decidable, and the fragment with 2 alternations on program variables and 1 alternation on sequence variables is undecidable. In addition, we explore boundaries between decidable and undecidable fragments of the logic with prenex normal form.
[ 0.017931683, 0.1038459167, 0.0044751712, 0.0398420244, -0.0334126428, -0.0024448992, -0.0229705218, -0.0329795405, -0.0337142348, 0.0024119825, 0.0281986147, 0.022869911, -0.0095958672, -0.0109224431, -0.0108654471, -0.0721415728, 0.0501033366, -0.0453565083, 0.0273948237, -0.0202035811, -0.0408237725, -0.0212930683, -0.0326801576, -0.0277568977, 0.0433228724, -0.0653710738, -0.0229288079, 0.0153368758, -0.0067547131, 0.004222007, 0.0035328188, 0.0387711897, -0.0513091013, 0.0208131857, 0.0000018033, 0.0475192666, -0.0359361693, 0.0441346504, -0.0245863441, 0.0189447477, -0.1112112403, 0.0589316636, 0.0042743217, -0.0119953202, 0.0074960804, -0.0284341294, -0.0192807, 0.0028104123, 0.0899712294, 0.0148599828, 0.0072456086, -0.0330675878, 0.0260465853, 0.0342304707, 0.0246950965, -0.0200423058, -0.0108511169, 0.016871633, 0.04599794, 0.0299623869, -0.0069359192, -0.0388559327, -0.0003697124, 0.0487393215, -0.0128882378, -0.0131699853, 0.0019939947, -0.0437814742, -0.0451488197, -0.0102694109, -0.0146447867, 0.0047437963, 0.0267929249, 0.0184071846, -0.0098313596, -0.0906557962, 0.0186819304, 0.0672626793, -0.0279841479, 0.0013391306, -0.0262080524, -0.007218943, 0.0282103084, -0.0691279396, -0.0765505582, 0.0371762812, 0.0278214663, -0.0544130802, -0.0675400347, 0.0209610015, 0.05433717, -0.0035284646, 0.013845914, 0.0211059768, -0.033131782, 0.0352811366, -0.0235186536, 0.0091869496, -0.0060287984, -0.0593842119, -0.0159719605, 0.0294209998, 0.020268498, -0.0046574613, 0.0448364876, 0.0235223956, -0.0088260025, -0.0101935687, -0.0042084395, 0.0535285696, 0.0205441024, -0.0245363899, -0.0048380634, 0.0756485686, 0.0343817808, 0.0607914068, 0.0023927162, 0.0201468226, -0.0159305893, 0.0706432611, -0.0552162714, -0.0288929194, -0.0172231421, 0.0195428301, 0.0155635634, -0.0279636011, -0.041978851, -0.0042937174, 0.0394617468, 0.0103545021, -0.002242903, -0.0112755019, 0.0073602051, -0.0044657951, -0.0164468903, 0.0300458521, 0.0293735955, 0.0036632773, -0.0296585355, -0.0347312465, 0.053339988, -0.0483088829, 0.016576197, -0.0110337734, 0.003844203, -0.0176099408, -0.0068302955, 0.0352469422, -0.0374086648, 0.0206787866, -0.028033616, -0.0059274361, -0.0136575578, -0.032929495, -0.0446171984, 0.0538270734, 0.0243935212, -0.0222665612, 0.0089813108, 0.0554592721, 0.0555003397, -0.0528895259, -0.0335863307, -0.0599207133, -0.0398391522, -0.0745416284, -0.0713426396, 0.0305669066, -0.0077088713, -0.0832632408, -0.0824808255, 0.0462898538, -0.0004525666, -0.0135400845, -0.0724640861, 0.0514393263, 0.0305779427, 0.0326419063, -0.0189977959, 0.0097606853, 0.0028908709, 0.0966623351, 0.0086639579, -0.0192586519, -0.0051134289, -0.008679729, 0.0362582058, 0.0227273013, -0.0047439067, -0.049979236, -0.0231795665, 0.0156433284, -0.0068647303, -0.0220895316, -0.0032936181, -0.0245698933, 0.0005958067, 0.0194416475, 0.0135440212, -0.0761503428, -0.0234718956, -0.0164998267, 0.0452018045, 0.0377799235, -0.0567704774, -0.0661236122, -0.0450322963, 0.0327277444, -0.064250052, -0.0126492586, -0.0226049107, 0.0144624012, -0.0006078815, 0.0030912012, -0.0472708158, 0.0359366685, 0.0245200805, -0.0013938827, -0.0245302618, -0.0051656277, 0.0063723475, 0.0469651259, 0.0115863746, 0.0006701832, 0.0304198507, 0.0171644427, -0.0177487265, 0.0692332983, 0.0309930779, 0.0318422392, -0.0257814992, 0.022153195, 0.0545328483, 0.0607099421, -0.0196536016, -0.0157532655, -0.0527050905, -0.0277294889, -0.0140001094, -0.0736732334, 0.0094753103, -0.0505577698, -0.0655877888, -0.0193661768, 0.073814638, -0.0122806858, -0.006260504, 0.0320226327, 0.0339635722, 0.0247462112, 0.0091608791, 0.0076293703, 0.027330026, -0.0208520945, 0.0192542244, 0.0130501529, 0.0000983777, 0.0000579344, 0.0089493413, -0.0079249991, 0.0361091681, 0.0035902164, -0.0028533209, 0.0273678079, 0.0037564707, -0.0006808972, -0.0143585922, -0.0004160362, 0.0576503798, -0.0128078861, 0.0392174497, 0.0014768459, 0.0569124557, 0.0290578138, 0.0004000403, -0.0177233499, -0.0225387327, 0.0772974119, -0.0195571911, 0.0335274488, -0.011255946, 0.0055388305, 0.0278164614, -0.0524058454, -0.0270833671, -0.0123634767, -0.0678088963, -0.088856414, -0.0217024311, -0.0279531125, -0.0609885827, 0.0116032073, -0.0289453547, 0.0415487438, 0.0481111445, -0.0513229966, -0.0293375552, 0.0351291969, -0.0325931944, 0.0612734891, 0.0023922191, -0.0099638114, 0.0255669765, 0.0259572901, 0.0510449521, 0.0575497001, 0.0324114226, 0.0688303486, 0.0392484665, 0.0679545552, -0.0149685284, -0.0047408808, -0.0470591374, 0.0199217126, -0.0115374168, 0.0286074281, -0.0015044535, -0.0567859262, -0.0336589552, 0.0153569421, -0.0437115021, -0.0022415398, 0.0428255126, 0.0076577603, 0.0054812813, 0.0018905681, -0.0465225466, -0.0373112448, 0.0434930362, -0.0182211697, 0.0043952805, 0.0419062227, -0.018899221, 0.0057892846, -0.0024517286, -0.001104674, -0.0284571182, 0.0655476004, -0.0331946015, -0.0374218002, -0.0293305926, 0.0069565708, -0.055683732, 0.013187971, 0.0544663221, -0.0144687295, -0.0146211786, -0.0170557648, 0.0261354782, 0.0213355366, -0.0195474476, -0.0048773568, 0.0471852869, 0.0266384445, -0.0082455585, -0.0338594466, -0.0418238044, 0.026169816, -0.0592314526, 0.0209610425, 0.0013130681, 0.0234783273, -0.0064915288, -0.0579826348, 0.0182565656, 0.0220690873, 0.0240400936, -0.0086759385, -0.0581578203, 0.0040983604, -0.0050695115, -0.0362614281, -0.0464733914, 0.0414985344, 0.0079561332, 0.030838741, 0.0292292517, 0.0159258321, -0.0004327187, -0.0118235042, 0.0194134749, -0.0715831518, 0.0164520629, -0.0541914515, -0.0000323311, 0.0177314933, 0.0122538479, -0.0382719263, -0.0508292988, -0.0040591983, 0.0081726834, -0.0131960949, -0.0038309339, -0.0173223112, -0.0127029866, 0.0897274688, -0.061018113, 0.0115683684, 0.0176688917, -0.0083951466, 0.0401331373, 0.0216053128, 0.0255277604, 0.0096981879, 0.0520700552, -0.0423190035, 0.022045318, 0.0344469361, -0.0181843527, -0.0355461501, -0.011388272, -0.0132602379, 0.0033297106, -0.0383390263, -0.0796962008, 0.004874594, 0.0144115072, -0.0422591306, -0.0079366108, 0.0194931533, -0.0268776603, 0.0493367277, 0.0764981136, -0.0204819795, -0.0538783148, -0.0332665332, -0.0334386341, -0.0099455249, 0.0467685983, -0.0655381083, 0.0415097177, -0.0181111991, -0.0289369505, -0.047695417, 0.0073324991, 0.0107592717, -0.0229312051, -0.0711369887, -0.0279188752, 0.0047440827, 0.009307188, -0.0527949892, 0.0401643179, -0.030811457, -0.0472478755, 0.0408475175, -0.0171086974, -0.0162693001, -0.0144554004, -0.0320245326, -0.0133360308, -0.0482055172, 0.0037693619, -0.0702359974, 0.0942703858, -0.032344535, -0.0059279939, 0.0140932687, -0.0671999976, 0.0398071185, 0.0803098679, 0.0133034866, -0.0129717039, 0.0188635513, 0.0218617693, -0.0131877828, 0.0014406842, 0.0141886417, -0.016608404, 0.0445722602, -0.0814774409, -0.0124474298, -0.0592829511, -0.0110944575, 0.0158101525, 0.0021916104, -0.0392968357, -0.0505497195, -0.0336199738, -0.0352607258, 0.060991995, 0.0015099949, 0.0517375581, -0.0233978182, 0.0079083126, 0.0797643587, -0.0377540439, -0.0285519268, -0.0484499857, 0.0168346092, -0.0259775985, 0.0162870809, -0.0228703991, -0.0410191678, 0.0125910826, -0.0208199937, 0.0338572748, 0.0116788866, -0.0015203616, 0.0013193768, 0.0027400204, 0.0194623601, -0.0495995581, 0.073158063, 0.0167613141, -0.0001221005, -0.039056465, -0.0241426956, 0.053204637, 0.0477439947, -0.0155946324, 0.0214450546, -0.0336712673, 0.0276326779, 0.0721987039, -0.0173724834, 0.0128311208, 0.0177765191, -0.0537869483, 0.0180153158, 0.043322172, 0.0040712613, 0.0158499498, 0.0392659381, -0.0370637514, -0.0178908594, 0.0463044122, 0.0156812072, -0.0563254692, 0.0373790152, -0.0171747562, -0.0594803877, -0.0364938639, -0.0258234441, -0.0604756027, -0.0546290465, -0.0236472674, 0.0051018996, -0.0168734659, 0.0079570264, -0.0347327068, -0.0479568765, -0.0098298946, 0.0115657561, 0.0921455696, 0.0094651142, -0.0023335018, 0.0329566263, 0.031805329, -0.0502507016, -0.0093913423, -0.0137554286, 0.0122057889, -0.0202699732, 0.041944813, -5.122824217e-33, -0.0124041121, 0.0306589436, -0.0448632352, -0.0113590313, -0.009801236, -0.0232474003, -0.0474197268, 0.0284206942, 0.0551889539, -0.0373050086, 0.0172971562, 0.0560948998, 0.0329248421, -0.0053431368, -0.0273750816, 0.001610797, 0.0486011356, 0.0515229665, -0.0064605372, -0.0200980771, 0.0396417491, 0.0009872698, 0.0335807428, 0.0837735981, 0.0506578982, -0.1001478955, 0.0539609231, 0.0232965667, -0.0475822464, 0.0040549198, 0.0097371424, -0.0401544794, 0.0097466698, -0.0036321229, -0.0081464509, 0.0395000502, -0.0577845462, -0.0745943263, 0.0492296852, 0.0125436839, 0.0052226651, -0.0381458215, 0.0564843118, 0.0146227442, 0.0202815309, -0.0133301513, -0.0182476602, 0.0467109121, 0.0596565418, -0.0144824786, -0.0278263502, 0.0258118659, -0.0432960168, 0.0406129025, 0.028532315, -0.0212117117, 0.0276042949, -0.031571921, 0.0241928846, 0.0072022593, 0.0290096328, 0.0279997941, 0.0012128367, 0.0333054364, -0.0102438331, -0.023618862, 0.0134546449, 0.0094661638, 0.0017517864, 0.0548219532, -0.0237232037, 0.0486640632, -0.0172541663, -0.09554068, 0.1054676473, 0.0220175479, -0.0216955151, 0.014837577, 0.0073990207, 0.045466125, -0.0309188291, 0.002892727, -0.0145032303, -0.0081993844, 0.0170213804, 0.0169308968, -0.031265568, 0.0005509692, 0.0308987051, 0.0016388908, -0.0622871779, 0.0766672939, 0.0391250104, -0.0228224508, -0.0201699641, 0.0285946205, 0.0355550535, -0.0826768875, -0.0151821719, 0.0387545452, 0.0095618395, -0.0337206908, 0.0046980265, -0.0055631883, 0.0452894159, 0.0062522371, -0.0323622338, -0.0178316813, -0.0116567668, 0.0042356732, 0.0052444506, -0.0075746421, -0.0418736786, 0.0565286316, 0.0358365811, 0.0404938459, -0.0028282655, 0.0181687884, -0.0192696452, -0.022599956, 0.0086995894, 0.052685257, 0.0248384476, 0.044456616, 0.0514840819, -0.0497260094, -0.0014836947, 0.0249727089, 0.0267428383, -0.0206003953, -0.0096745649, 0.0353719965, 2.752e-7, -0.0505066551, -0.0221771654, 0.102727659, 0.0381262042, -0.0263758861, -0.0210907534, -0.0253597051, 0.0116000669, -0.0102723204, 0.006219021, 0.0094466889, 0.0230322853, -0.0202929452, 0.0212036408, -0.00364139, 0.0291505083, -0.0151130138, -0.0322818086, -0.0326789878, -0.0084381625, 0.1187798455, -0.0444573201, 0.0291668717, -0.014062617, -0.0372398198, 0.0036009289, -0.0028394626, 0.0943676755, -0.0167948846, 0.0106929522, 0.0776754096, -0.0066592796, 0.0110650351, -0.019906681, 0.0009858424, 0.0060130348, 0.0265509319, 0.048571445, 0.0059569576, -0.004131936, -0.0050394535, -0.0411597565, -0.0084170168, 0.1079505235, 0.0354972184, 0.0498661883, -0.0576080084, 0.0292616058, -0.0406182818, 0.0149835106, -0.0364907458, 0.0540415384, -0.0255756788, -0.0074850712, -0.0015503732, -0.0008285423, 0.0020430377, -0.0593931898, -0.0289254729, 0.0199185777, 0.0040223058, -0.0024727366, 0.0020747655, 0.0173001215, -0.0613173731, 0.0075238384, -0.0445478559, 2.420919825e-34, -0.0101118879, -0.0175746623, 0.0019002724, -0.0515922718, -0.0166402441, -0.0242648683, 0.0198890734, 0.045521047, 0.0353467762, -0.0075237695, -0.0151418503 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.06211v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.06211v1
What artificial intelligence might teach us about the origin of human language
2023-01-15T23:25:29
2023-01-15T23:25:29
Alexander Kilpatrick
cs.SD
cs.SD, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS
This study explores an interesting pattern emerging from research that combines artificial intelligence with sound symbolism. In these studies, supervised machine learning algorithms are trained to classify samples based on the sounds of referent names. Machine learning algorithms are efficient learners of sound symbolism, but they tend to bias one category over the other. The pattern is this: when a category arguably represents greater threat, the algorithms tend to overpredict to that category. A hypothesis, framed by error management theory, is presented that proposes that this may be evidence of an adaptation to preference cautious behaviour. This hypothesis is tested by constructing extreme gradient boosted (XGBoost) models using the sounds that make up the names of Chinese, Japanese and Korean Pokemon and observing classification error distribution.
[ 0.0728256851, 0.04202215, -0.0567570366, 0.0012919983, -0.0005795777, 0.0269882847, -0.0267448463, 0.0183694884, -0.0574097782, 0.0011097254, -0.0232450441, 0.0035094027, 0.0305756964, -0.0177206621, 0.0212179758, -0.0744728595, 0.0333033018, -0.0244883858, 0.0642783716, -0.0227715038, -0.0374018848, -0.0130044296, 0.0054741078, 0.0687607378, -0.0403620452, 0.0137789492, 0.0125777125, -0.007963609, -0.0069799032, -0.0541291535, 0.0005635978, -0.0065773181, -0.0009877477, 0.0439844206, 0.0000016746, -0.0823732913, 0.0633501261, -0.0187256392, -0.0236915424, -0.0398883373, -0.0041780802, 0.0258655827, -0.0169300959, -0.0101431813, -0.0251471009, 0.0085994238, 0.0809376314, -0.0020563952, 0.0121554239, 0.0357743539, 0.0189339537, -0.0862138346, 0.0248109717, -0.003287405, 0.0388122946, -0.012979079, 0.0364724025, -0.0584175289, -0.0314087681, -0.0421096534, -0.0822444782, -0.0061877612, -0.0094050756, 0.0345155858, -0.042727422, 0.018363867, 0.0071245241, -0.0402614139, -0.0054380344, 0.0100975959, -0.0275811087, -0.0112101939, -0.0474019125, 0.0044963942, 0.0042034532, 0.0044636033, 0.0337272473, 0.0020387832, -0.0114090182, -0.0031696067, 0.0734730065, -0.0086802319, 0.025493281, 0.0195657387, -0.0046385764, 0.0755673945, -0.0174553227, -0.0427588113, 0.0131277703, -0.0341799967, 0.0348592624, -0.0337733403, 0.0010334312, 0.022712661, -0.0059353323, 0.0373650081, 0.0236715153, -0.0185833424, -0.0067815138, -0.0536450222, 0.0119721396, 0.0124434428, -0.0373100564, -0.0107439496, -0.0044447365, 0.0281464532, 0.0227097925, -0.0103281038, -0.016116688, 0.0168924239, -0.072550334, -0.0054936074, -0.0210205168, 0.0147583717, 0.0295941029, 0.018361263, -0.0739203691, -0.0078623546, -0.0364362299, -0.0057092109, -0.0213011317, -0.0069701001, 0.0000031589, 0.0349936485, -0.0434251502, -0.0416399613, -0.0533518158, 0.0516604595, -0.0248228144, -0.0233751684, 0.0613174811, -0.0164581351, 0.0030229676, -0.0070363516, 0.0492230244, 0.0852878392, 0.0367325693, -0.028426569, -0.0025414841, 0.0186961181, -0.0520260073, -0.0050429213, -0.0280168317, -0.0054383501, -0.0034911691, -0.0112598781, -0.0070398659, -0.0541420877, -0.0099507263, -0.0003834013, -0.0391111635, 0.0200341288, -0.0118275257, 0.0531045347, 0.0488831811, 0.0060880836, -0.0530860014, 0.0116905496, 0.0715296119, -0.0095115192, 0.0229340456, -0.0551503673, 0.0407916084, 0.0000101505, -0.0302243009, -0.0167075898, -0.0075053689, -0.0409729779, -0.0607643649, 0.0090735992, 0.0274133626, 0.0465745889, -0.0108528081, -0.0460415334, 0.0569136925, 0.0889641419, 0.0071197255, 0.057911288, 0.0239211544, -0.0099950703, 0.0075678574, 0.0159348026, -0.0127992919, -0.0127350241, -0.0714348331, -0.0216115303, -0.0290459897, 0.0011010881, -0.012288128, -0.0257932656, -0.0245140456, -0.0214187168, 0.0012994275, 0.0213002749, 0.0380481482, -0.0016086755, -0.0189898852, -0.0168955624, 0.036663074, 0.0213043187, -0.0367023684, -0.0685900897, 0.0840112641, 0.032164719, -0.0359301269, -0.0129637662, 0.0540085733, 0.0113998568, -0.0578298979, 0.0240520816, 0.0029910302, -0.0163794383, -0.0039555077, 0.013528835, -0.0160426591, 0.0658797845, 0.0077746487, 0.0340053029, -0.0294341668, 0.0671444535, -0.0163566116, 0.019371938, -0.0600178316, 0.0186248645, 0.0144722378, -0.0473473333, -0.0052316729, 0.0055381092, 0.0610233322, 0.013924513, -0.035320092, 0.0205113627, -0.0089755682, 0.0158157367, -0.0044338843, 0.060802836, -0.011112594, 0.0623891614, 0.0379663184, -0.027601786, 0.0022899208, -0.0116639668, 0.0018103707, 0.0022370443, 0.0452484153, -0.0458453856, 0.0550495721, -0.0173355713, 0.0433537886, -0.0723852366, 0.0266404226, 0.0033029872, 0.016545143, 0.0246503372, -0.0092505049, -0.0505329594, -0.006856265, 0.0350007862, -0.0634292886, -0.0276371762, 0.0329869464, -0.0058848951, 0.0183583163, 0.0103859901, -0.0210678596, -0.0255796872, 0.0053540557, -0.0473316908, -0.040328458, 0.0303588416, 0.0001578511, -0.0264566932, -0.0409377329, -0.0450105518, 0.0020616532, 0.0107506504, 0.0119337542, -0.0211769342, 0.0604189634, 0.0003885611, -0.0288992804, -0.0663219243, -0.0023502065, -0.0122713298, -0.0222043935, 0.0226221066, 0.013494174, -0.0429508574, -0.0451691411, -0.053504318, -0.0553706549, -0.022991091, 0.0131733399, -0.0565815233, 0.023460079, 0.0223030355, 0.0242165402, 0.0103471298, 0.0346780866, 0.0111621097, 0.061446242, 0.0289048944, -0.0015133541, -0.0161007997, -0.010493096, -0.0433162712, -0.0077407029, -0.0508444831, -0.0272670705, 0.0827447101, 0.00967767, -0.0022677842, 0.0238427185, 0.0549114905, -0.0180603173, -0.0674631149, -0.0454082899, -0.0901293457, -0.0395480022, 0.0772399157, 0.0014600212, -0.0470361151, 0.0862201303, 0.043744877, -0.0023095123, -0.0221397337, -0.0355872922, 0.0024982819, 0.077665627, -0.0265639778, 0.0259598102, 0.0592141636, -0.0476829931, -0.0343160182, -0.0474263392, 0.0282697678, -0.0580747016, -0.0383023918, -0.0342239588, -0.0101427957, 0.0047099614, -0.017804876, -0.0187668633, -0.0238349102, -0.0683761612, -0.0148703232, 0.0015590757, -0.0241458435, 0.0114485966, 0.0304655675, 0.0024852913, -0.0444551632, 0.0256271735, -0.0177480038, 0.018458223, -0.0345966704, 0.0186324343, 0.0319023654, 0.021187339, -0.0025794737, -0.0064812717, -0.0045406753, 0.0001195584, 0.0081275348, -0.0174504705, 0.0465307459, 0.0249900166, -0.0203889869, -0.0336161032, 0.05083685, -0.0071287393, -0.0261975676, 0.0418752283, 0.0501884557, 0.034222994, 0.0111559574, 0.0547874793, 0.0053927852, -0.0110444408, 0.0049609328, 0.0198985785, -0.0375242978, -0.0053307563, 0.0114215109, 0.0356706642, -0.021606585, -0.0138702365, 0.0240104012, -0.096995391, 0.0095291352, -0.0053586825, -0.0668516681, -0.0100758001, -0.0193095226, 0.0144333197, -0.0058230977, -0.0080062561, 0.0223757401, 0.0099476911, -0.013171141, 0.039670404, -0.062945269, -0.0308330394, 0.0009550359, -0.0567478389, -0.0212085191, 0.0648390725, 0.0560124628, -0.0620391108, -0.0060741594, -0.022521792, 0.0086861616, 0.030278014, -0.0265124571, 0.0290348548, 0.0454862975, -0.0057692179, -0.0051956782, -0.0205770694, 0.0123240966, 0.0325262249, 0.0747230798, 0.0532286428, 0.0235635247, -0.064370282, -0.0284286067, -0.023431858, 0.0088405879, 0.0485400297, 0.0091335783, -0.0803249478, 0.0089514134, -0.0183948781, -0.0196199547, 0.0421523526, -0.0292781238, 0.0103087695, -0.0180038139, -0.0756333992, -0.1004771739, -0.0276943166, -0.0370108075, 0.0539913476, 0.0688414201, -0.0122473706, -0.040842142, 0.0160057377, -0.0354433507, 0.0120242964, 0.0479524732, 0.0141677419, -0.0293796863, -0.0197163951, 0.035983, -0.0525115803, -0.0041161473, -0.0041170502, 0.0715002343, -0.0632101521, 0.0363995433, 0.056322176, 0.02859612, -0.011850222, 0.0141874626, -0.0727226064, 0.0686185956, 0.0663943589, 0.0251353234, 0.0278516952, 0.0331478976, -0.0414789207, -0.0104351649, -0.0059297937, -0.0371303298, 0.0322158597, 0.013029404, -0.0246171895, -0.045900248, -0.0235319771, 0.0180031061, 0.0055820886, 0.0115032438, -0.0746613592, -0.0598243177, -0.0019556794, -0.0031522627, 0.0398637541, 0.0039020632, 0.0164393634, -0.0402578935, 0.0403124206, 0.0283393208, -0.0219192579, -0.0460594036, -0.0010670425, -0.0322099738, -0.0052437983, 0.0611148812, 0.0775691047, 0.097449109, -0.0089791948, 0.0352262668, -0.0046914946, 0.02155279, 0.0061829411, 0.0321540795, 0.0260105804, -0.003631399, -0.0019861106, 0.0143177966, 0.0124541065, -0.0250725858, -0.0357206725, -0.0755133331, 0.0376742706, -0.0362738632, 0.0670514032, -0.0267546885, 0.0005263624, -0.0308147091, -0.0182253532, -0.0300302897, 0.0018691635, -0.0673642159, -0.0092419805, 0.0126905749, 0.0161114596, -0.0246308502, -0.0095000407, 0.0247701388, -0.0308613051, 0.0492678471, -0.0463169478, -0.047111813, 0.0166935734, 0.0058955336, 0.0108483452, 0.0278870538, 0.0002995374, -0.0118394801, -0.0597432703, -0.0739668012, 0.0227991529, -0.0024225027, 0.084388189, -0.0015542493, 0.0229049083, -0.0008689886, 0.0036434594, 0.0213438682, -0.0138366753, -0.0307271164, -0.0481977537, 0.0352519378, -0.0178206731, -5.116751687e-33, -0.0018486679, -0.0319994986, 0.0027189767, -0.0091811251, 0.023277849, 0.0062895776, -0.017114494, 0.0331607834, -0.0359449796, 0.0054597231, 0.0105234375, -0.0454270765, 0.0065872371, -0.0520270355, 0.0497692898, 0.0084863035, -0.0103970375, -0.0059616952, 0.0237832051, -0.061732199, 0.0665168986, 0.041106727, 0.0445488878, -0.1003448889, 0.0002855136, 0.0496012121, -0.0067184572, -0.0236904062, 0.0016554312, 0.0329665802, 0.0019609239, 0.0422673896, 0.0050362204, 0.0299665444, 0.0000192242, -0.0263096318, -0.0398710258, -0.0202797092, -0.0073824502, 0.0030769932, 0.0529773794, 0.021487454, 0.0504715145, 0.005210659, -0.0555863865, 0.0123743918, 0.0509156659, -0.0525735319, -0.0236865878, -0.0549471229, -0.0531548634, 0.0073828213, 0.0008857921, 0.0228337664, 0.0334908105, 0.0256273951, -0.0215362813, 0.0008728793, -0.0012296679, 0.0812198222, -0.0019548538, -0.0281186886, 0.0194916595, 0.0742059499, 0.0095255328, 0.0312577486, 0.1436492503, -0.0334131792, 0.0115351435, -0.0044787079, 0.0485474989, 0.0300028063, 0.0413885526, 0.0188334081, 0.076633893, -0.0784451067, -0.0052727163, -0.017056793, 0.0727014244, -0.0528553687, 0.0146080786, 0.0453931391, -0.0630708337, -0.02861006, 0.0036837498, 0.0175806265, -0.006724067, -0.0326345228, 0.0004536498, -0.0291612055, 0.0229152963, 0.030913936, 0.0086949123, -0.0253616702, -0.0280057192, -0.010462895, 0.0125760501, 0.0042094919, 0.014754856, -0.0358560756, -0.0128157595, -0.0201723203, -0.0094022034, -0.0058879913, 0.0644166842, 0.0232414864, 0.0173717439, 0.0190688521, -0.0274760686, -0.0022894361, 0.0227774233, -0.0609269924, 0.0692102984, -0.0371500701, 0.0479435958, 0.0057933102, 0.0094846748, -0.0348579437, 0.0822462142, 0.0152101116, -0.0595524758, 0.0115013709, -0.0726022124, 0.0285200551, -0.0032687769, -0.0040783775, 0.0297979675, 0.0239834636, -0.0045287404, -0.0469822884, -0.0264592879, -0.005625267, 2.686e-7, 0.0036803372, 0.0351201296, 0.0131066246, 0.0293497294, 0.0162915383, 0.0259911753, -0.0486628637, -0.0370220691, 0.0656780079, 0.0221395697, 0.0437186584, -0.0261828769, 0.0331529155, 0.0548561737, -0.069210805, -0.0124886772, -0.0613246858, 0.0386365391, -0.0327778906, 0.0653496906, -0.0016036211, 0.0480767339, 0.0210154746, -0.0704950541, -0.0116226235, -0.0099188508, -0.0151267881, -0.034765631, 0.0709460005, -0.0323117301, -0.0083218934, 0.0258940738, 0.0158027634, 0.0202545095, -0.008751452, 0.0157759599, 0.0101747923, -0.0497351177, -0.0280235652, 0.0151277166, 0.0253906809, 0.07426624, -0.0160295591, -0.0184406303, 0.0181091409, 0.025697438, -0.0425404683, -0.0105030518, -0.0227154568, -0.013089912, 0.0136396019, -0.0226136446, 0.0332485288, 0.0048852512, -0.0062818862, -0.0006827722, 0.0261164047, -0.0203271881, 0.023824038, 0.0562668554, -0.0050135902, -0.0640816018, 0.0145939998, 0.061693009, 0.0044017364, -0.0243304521, -0.0086228587, 1.547814738e-34, -0.0006692858, -0.0328454264, 0.0077519072, -0.0069993217, 0.0282997582, 0.0448581763, 0.0309197977, 0.0276658759, 0.044325117, 0.0558558442, -0.0370617658 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.06202v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.06202v2
Shades of Iteration: from Elgot to Kleene
2023-01-15T22:14:43
2023-06-02T15:54:31
Sergey Goncharov
cs.LO
cs.LO, cs.CL
Notions of iteration range from the arguably most general Elgot iteration to a very specific Kleene iteration. The fundamental nature of Elgot iteration has been extensively explored by Bloom and Esik in the form of iteration theories, while Kleene iteration became extremely popular as an integral part of (untyped) formalisms, such as automata theory, regular expressions and Kleene algebra. Here, we establish a formal connection between Elgot iteration and Kleene iteration in the form of Elgot monads and Kleene monads, respectively. We also introduce a novel class of while-monads, which like Kleene monads admit a relatively simple description in algebraic terms. Like Elgot monads, while-monads cover a large variety of models that meaningfully support while-loops, but may fail the Kleene algebra laws, or even fail to support a Kleen iteration operator altogether.
[ 0.0118863136, 0.0674187616, -0.0333790258, 0.0067326734, -0.0081032561, 0.0182315968, -0.0203769412, -0.0394409411, -0.0361162201, -0.0018739008, 0.014836112, -0.0044415738, -0.016998468, 0.0262130387, 0.0008403245, -0.0754780471, 0.0483193845, -0.0447485596, -0.0476225764, -0.0090060448, 0.007329789, -0.0435408168, -0.044059746, 0.0155630792, 0.0127267977, -0.0373834893, -0.0526437908, -0.0744673982, -0.0201345067, 0.0482671969, -0.0090098605, -0.0016847126, -0.0400537699, 0.0193250049, 0.0000016273, -0.0182809439, -0.015249623, 0.0145081859, -0.036930766, 0.0506080166, -0.0403143689, 0.0335344672, -0.0184264127, 0.0222510193, 0.0271236375, -0.0162578896, 0.0844412446, -0.0666582361, 0.056759499, 0.0314590782, 0.0105484864, -0.0260035601, 0.0127736395, 0.0011679387, 0.0548286438, -0.0193633307, 0.0318793021, -0.0422259942, 0.042962566, -0.0400752276, 0.0369643606, -0.0188059174, 0.005597672, -0.0455386899, -0.0182274934, 0.0125317313, 0.048498258, -0.0479366295, 0.0017767081, -0.0529894009, 0.0104459189, -0.0230865031, -0.0205640607, 0.0753864273, -0.00551352, 0.0060001607, -0.0321226902, 0.0477464385, -0.003145477, 0.007022839, 0.0198494103, 0.0058743758, 0.0138720963, -0.0200897884, -0.0387599058, 0.0768229291, 0.0429141484, -0.0125914421, -0.0590621941, 0.0073311501, -0.0003960937, -0.0457143672, 0.0348774008, 0.053790763, 0.0056558228, -0.0105545968, 0.0206320807, -0.0098753646, 0.0199946687, 0.0182741247, -0.0006765352, 0.0479802229, -0.003000878, 0.0281102452, 0.0257183816, -0.0300661083, 0.0022410159, -0.0558898635, -0.0028331762, 0.0326535553, -0.0049247383, -0.0451325104, -0.0178996976, 0.013168402, 0.0333165154, 0.0053657298, -0.0192703418, 0.0605902858, -0.0351323411, 0.0560322516, -0.1020146906, -0.0427267067, 0.0018268995, 0.0578442477, 0.0128952181, -0.0176388677, -0.0256349389, -0.038182389, 0.020556977, -0.0187543333, -0.0319365561, -0.0095967231, -0.0094221309, -0.0205545817, -0.0593550615, 0.0346155837, 0.024826834, 0.0181493741, 0.0375395827, -0.0132012228, 0.0740459934, -0.0070979064, -0.0005288185, -0.0254503097, -0.0077275466, 0.0135948304, 0.0263491441, -0.0164558198, -0.0470878035, -0.0209169928, 0.0608793981, 0.0360694565, 0.0033772413, 0.0089994865, -0.0445124656, 0.0089919614, -0.0592786819, -0.0168611147, -0.0394322723, -0.0243162327, -0.0006753575, -0.0267348215, 0.0406378396, 0.0484988429, -0.0174551066, -0.0149979675, 0.0098454803, -0.0093767941, -0.0223364178, -0.0162854474, -0.0426379405, 0.0878966078, -0.0183846932, -0.0027676423, -0.0452170856, 0.0055096042, 0.0521155, 0.0491927713, 0.0505044647, 0.0004365895, 0.0457048267, 0.073660709, -0.0058673057, -0.0213208646, -0.0923092365, 0.0389762223, -0.0299303792, -0.0322335921, -0.0214584097, -0.0432010442, -0.0089156572, 0.0214100871, 0.0142787024, -0.0504729189, 0.0096036103, -0.0194445811, 0.0258621257, 0.0006611448, -0.0165021066, -0.0168650318, -0.0074776816, -0.0569814742, 0.0637402385, 0.0551701337, -0.0095228329, -0.0556488894, -0.0293576289, -0.0517343543, -0.0036623613, -0.0027506971, -0.005361089, -0.0241564829, -0.0120116845, 0.0321832746, -0.0056805615, 0.0170861352, 0.0151426187, 0.0086189955, -0.0408981144, 0.0203742702, 0.0016237672, 0.01644646, 0.0034017421, 0.0048836633, -0.0016533528, -0.016253328, -0.0204376653, 0.0489559434, -0.0191465598, -0.0272367839, -0.0547257587, 0.0547060706, 0.0598637164, 0.0545380488, -0.0269520264, 0.023330098, -0.0096330205, 0.0297495648, 0.0446029045, 0.0397835039, 0.0223322008, -0.001526839, -0.0236050319, 0.0022882423, 0.0895256251, -0.0019327215, 0.0512134396, -0.0072465581, 0.0539375655, 0.0205715708, -0.0138093969, 0.0237486586, -0.0049725156, -0.0127973063, 0.029733317, -0.0217683893, -0.0140234279, -0.0040663313, 0.0072173877, -0.0555404164, 0.0195070878, 0.0115366168, 0.0401199982, 0.0295607504, 0.0442711972, 0.0177824441, -0.0148797045, -0.0041653807, 0.0307425633, -0.0677308589, 0.0695130602, -0.0036659753, 0.0601190478, -0.0144149205, 0.0319120884, 0.0503408685, 0.0143934488, 0.0278847106, 0.0390803218, -0.0001246568, 0.0335845985, -0.1064632684, 0.0163392983, -0.033999458, -0.0248043332, 0.0239208564, -0.0604847334, -0.0229948927, -0.0642651543, -0.0725545436, -0.0001790975, 0.0220871251, -0.0132701313, 0.0681148022, 0.0322081558, -0.0150001114, -0.0123676611, -0.0350427218, 0.0424741469, 0.0508471839, -0.0370388813, -0.0176658947, 0.0218232721, 0.0011953, 0.0278788172, -0.0823446736, 0.0312189627, 0.0408996157, 0.0015286923, 0.0264621247, -0.100906983, -0.0294800829, -0.0262709409, 0.0561134368, 0.0432311408, 0.0279684849, 0.0006174034, -0.0918097571, -0.0086881556, -0.0066634733, -0.0258917902, -0.0119118821, 0.0317756273, -0.0053056306, 0.0253344104, -0.0013155022, 0.0108243618, -0.0361305214, 0.0675338134, 0.0048353658, -0.0098324288, 0.0300357509, -0.024031572, 0.0545538738, 0.0338453278, -0.0014434875, 0.0036163875, 0.0440721586, -0.0085565876, 0.0457464941, 0.0092146294, -0.0151280798, -0.0839337707, 0.0561583862, -0.0101281041, -0.013525309, -0.021404421, 0.0175898876, 0.0096857194, 0.0155690135, 0.0024935929, 0.013687849, 0.0087113883, 0.0036689935, 0.0090328604, -0.0325567573, -0.0853971988, -0.0135047734, -0.0269398261, 0.0089020636, 0.0218793117, 0.0304008927, 0.0341972299, -0.0050010043, 0.0237936806, 0.0002311722, 0.02496331, -0.086735636, -0.036917422, -0.0372451283, -0.0347729884, -0.0603845567, -0.0486096218, 0.0336571373, 0.0094212266, 0.0088959979, 0.0804918334, -0.0539856106, 0.0408019423, 0.0278579518, 0.025236113, -0.1266398728, 0.0297420509, 0.0268620681, 0.0020483073, -0.0172951091, 0.012456608, 0.0073440345, -0.0233445372, -0.000870407, 0.004793826, -0.0824337006, 0.0023236391, -0.0095851282, 0.0389626995, 0.0105476948, -0.0268227551, 0.0741373599, -0.0299056545, 0.0617226586, -0.0029840572, 0.0752532259, -0.0159755088, -0.0068872776, -0.0157866161, -0.0031828228, 0.0215983801, -0.0161167923, -0.0267338511, -0.0043182955, 0.041976776, 0.0361685641, -0.0185473766, -0.0004167377, -0.0567252748, 0.0011837244, -0.04071128, 0.0221122652, 0.043562483, -0.0022302759, 0.0100762835, 0.0525349118, -0.0004308273, 0.0079803439, -0.0464996994, -0.0026365863, -0.0385142416, 0.0424310341, 0.0279724244, -0.0028583147, 0.0106396368, -0.0476154722, -0.0590595864, -0.0538292155, -0.0319849961, -0.0464432985, -0.0376574881, 0.0504749194, -0.0413865335, -0.0206322037, -0.0244077053, 0.0425699651, -0.043316368, -0.0168288574, -0.0279410966, 0.0249496456, -0.0154461097, -0.0853645205, -0.0024604844, 0.0036099337, 0.0560355186, -0.0061464394, -0.0110889599, -0.0304845292, 0.0568072908, -0.0549601875, 0.0205577854, -0.0581094176, -0.0100054536, 0.0327287987, 0.0750179887, 0.0214142986, -0.0333411805, 0.0017230867, 0.0038741382, -0.0327266902, 0.0144591471, -0.0490009934, -0.0124971261, 0.0185112134, -0.034421619, 0.0381593145, 0.0185257643, 0.0291050263, -0.0324698985, -0.0125026191, -0.0007755758, 0.0096204467, 0.0543671027, 0.0277371816, 0.0177592486, -0.0614048541, 0.0343468562, 0.0239138398, 0.0411022305, -0.0326100066, -0.010167025, 0.0241524167, -0.0595987774, 0.0050199246, -0.0788221881, -0.0127709955, -0.0003779359, -0.0280951802, 0.0117183505, 0.0497381091, 0.0088438205, 0.030789772, -0.0003983208, -0.0058557144, 0.052547954, 0.0369004644, 0.0234903041, 0.0657959357, -0.0048933751, 0.0319246463, -0.0208672695, -0.0487058833, 0.0499180406, 0.0309437569, 0.017889658, -0.0030143333, -0.010733231, -0.0837804973, -0.0013422659, 0.018206764, -0.0043899254, -0.0051336107, 0.0077803358, -0.0470958166, 0.0119218687, -0.0497352108, -0.0412892736, -0.0426932201, -0.0131174391, -0.0960494205, 0.051810842, 0.0507668294, 0.0082489084, 0.0450803004, -0.0119638657, 0.0400618054, 0.014591625, 0.0218379106, -0.0836649686, -0.0060869916, -0.0457078367, 0.0516757704, 0.0390580706, -0.0235642176, -0.0377274193, -0.0231265184, 0.0163296908, -0.0217469018, 0.0266052391, -0.0371581167, -0.0188843962, 0.029220406, -0.0007011757, -0.0052177943, -0.0143505959, 0.0385972708, 0.0208741724, -0.0616042614, 0.0561614409, -5.114358821e-33, 0.0027986309, 0.029825924, 0.0254542436, 0.032164637, -0.0264757685, -0.0115937581, -0.0392317921, 0.0603753515, 0.0555588007, -0.0300737694, -0.0044401833, -0.015607575, 0.0050689927, 0.0008436056, 0.0075284597, 0.0276020207, 0.0270484611, -0.0285979137, -0.032582704, -0.0560597777, -0.0329683982, -0.0052502695, 0.0492956154, -0.0029094927, 0.0627182946, -0.0030718034, -0.0307041798, 0.0245625079, -0.0467201285, 0.0307579879, -0.0099528059, 0.013971556, -0.015028148, 0.0003055698, -0.0578550138, 0.0019244663, -0.0269359574, -0.0277176853, 0.0052489946, 0.009651118, -0.0224384759, 0.0009672677, 0.0312885903, 0.0132547459, -0.0276952516, 0.0243819207, -0.0571403131, 0.0191812627, 0.01250955, 0.0683523789, 0.0207568817, 0.015268039, -0.0660067424, -0.0346013904, 0.0038193355, -0.0321769565, -0.0226674639, -0.0336557701, -0.0160507616, 0.01731872, 0.0229651704, -0.0076196655, -0.029768331, -0.0468574725, 0.0472903289, -0.0082100658, 0.0315172598, 0.0331304818, -0.0646872744, 0.0737722665, -0.0308644585, -0.0022719337, -0.0174561217, -0.0712354183, 0.009671459, 0.0130126746, 0.0247122236, 0.0119351437, 0.0386631489, 0.0687026381, -0.0149678569, 0.0074014072, -0.016158035, -0.001775855, -0.0372755714, -0.0267374609, -0.0143452846, 0.0175336041, -0.0056377049, -0.0117847025, -0.0627239794, 0.0580900572, 0.0252258312, -0.0033504234, -0.0617327169, 0.0292728823, -0.0188714508, 0.0159348734, 0.0138483699, 0.0447435379, 0.0416572392, -0.003334488, -0.0419038236, 0.0126896501, 0.0024395508, 0.0096609993, -0.0468529314, 0.0407748595, -0.0519119389, -0.0009668552, -0.0049514268, 0.060108453, -0.0017519203, 0.0296077654, 0.045340132, 0.01032947, 0.054760512, 0.019932488, 0.030224083, -0.0335950442, -0.018250566, 0.0369650088, 0.0201009549, 0.0379279219, -0.0053964835, -0.0502631553, 0.0081164259, -0.0565642565, 0.0251915045, -0.0434190892, 0.0043945396, -0.0394809581, 2.575e-7, 0.0242370814, -0.0414180979, 0.1012025699, 0.0986691788, 0.0026100567, 0.0042008711, 0.0473590642, 0.0003667843, -0.0252811164, -0.0095271682, -0.013670601, 0.0047659362, -0.0617797449, -0.0550911464, 0.0175704882, -0.0245907158, -0.015034223, 0.0285517536, 0.0181123354, -0.022745166, 0.0094987992, -0.0047034496, 0.0409694426, 0.0121208886, -0.0175230782, -0.0253280308, 0.0084018186, 0.0827698708, 0.0183671005, 0.0365119502, -0.0262192823, 0.0463841334, 0.0447429307, -0.0380500555, 0.040794462, 0.0503261238, 0.0254670661, 0.0565525293, -0.0078510214, 0.0556895398, 0.0004634515, -0.0567466915, -0.0096863396, 0.0002728281, 0.0353063419, 0.0414548628, 0.015793778, -0.0384587087, -0.0209138598, -0.0170865003, 0.0267846901, -0.024481032, -0.0610296875, 0.0598208755, -0.00692268, 0.0237637833, -0.0022245499, -0.0270754285, -0.0602267683, -0.0536123775, -0.0422017612, 0.0244860407, -0.0044533019, 0.0286239889, -0.0496585593, 0.0284959543, -0.0591853596, 2.374426268e-34, 0.0547088385, -0.0390124209, 0.0717310533, 0.0657544807, -0.0128915673, -0.0514035225, -0.0349680409, -0.0200032052, 0.0183778387, -0.0144241694, -0.0890712589 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.06178v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.06178v1
Bike Frames: Understanding the Implicit Portrayal of Cyclists in the News
2023-01-15T20:22:03
2023-01-15T20:22:03
Xingmeng Zhao, Xavier Walton, Suhana Shrestha, Anthony Rios
cs.CY
cs.CY, cs.CL
Increasing the number of cyclists, whether for general transport or recreation, can provide health improvements and reduce the environmental impact of vehicular transportation. However, the public's perception of cycling may be driven by the ideologies and reporting standards of news agencies. For instance, people may identify cyclists on the road as "dangerous" if news agencies overly report cycling accidents, limiting the number of people that cycle for transportation. Moreover, if fewer people cycle, there may be less funding from the government to invest in safe infrastructure. In this paper, we explore the perceived perception of cyclists within news headlines. To accomplish this, we introduce a new dataset, "Bike Frames", that can help provide insight into how headlines portray cyclists and help detect accident-related headlines. Next, we introduce a multi-task (MT) regularization approach that increases the detection accuracy of accident-related posts, demonstrating improvements over traditional MT frameworks. Finally, we compare and contrast the perceptions of cyclists with motorcyclist-related headlines to ground the findings with another related activity for both male- and female-related posts. Our findings show that general news websites are more likely to report accidents about cyclists than other events. Moreover, cyclist-specific websites are more likely to report about accidents than motorcycling-specific websites, even though there is more potential danger for motorcyclists. Finally, we show substantial differences in the reporting about male vs. female-related persons, e.g., more male-related cyclists headlines are related to accidents, but more female-related motorcycling headlines about accidents. WARNING: This paper contains descriptions of accidents and death.
[ 0.0038945882, 0.0725309551, -0.0133498451, 0.0181866419, 0.0240749754, 0.0313082635, 0.0197629817, -0.0088667274, 0.0221542511, -0.0503037237, 0.0351192057, 0.0348201543, -0.0430129059, 0.0260016378, 0.0019723419, -0.0786748976, 0.016136121, 0.0353323519, 0.0541951172, 0.0195676871, 0.0708104298, 0.0175893642, 0.031616807, 0.0479488596, -0.0159438681, -0.0148029188, 0.0416844487, 0.0160703156, 0.0764495656, -0.0600316301, 0.0243874472, 0.0141650913, 0.0655348077, -0.003955727, 0.0000017583, 0.0115730241, 0.0170526076, -0.0182950832, 0.038676288, -0.0551859215, 0.0001995207, -0.0500070974, 0.0347965509, 0.0039888057, -0.0160267279, -0.0466208681, 0.0415569991, 0.0444901884, 0.0331983157, 0.0375639312, -0.0275564026, 0.0452770703, -0.0632058308, 0.0067259674, 0.0125861326, 0.0201374553, 0.0421023369, -0.0378824584, -0.0559475496, -0.0213042218, -0.0380947106, -0.0011873124, -0.0026051612, 0.0493004061, -0.0150906434, 0.012383868, -0.0122119896, -0.0237361584, 0.0140690869, 0.0564997531, -0.0089262519, -0.0426437967, 0.031777095, 0.0154721858, 0.0093801143, 0.0630709231, -0.0375096798, 0.0096659446, -0.0368139185, 0.0129645783, -0.0290088691, 0.0037867764, 0.0012042365, 0.0463062115, -0.0032679231, 0.0082295137, -0.0065623536, 0.0023867043, -0.0012407869, 0.0333109163, 0.0121504394, -0.0319299251, 0.0526593663, -0.016832998, 0.0167484973, 0.0012456116, -0.0069456804, -0.0250593107, -0.0054413085, -0.0915394649, 0.018006552, -0.0147537934, -0.0141897378, 0.0184259266, 0.0244572666, -0.0349809676, -0.0096089439, 0.0151152238, -0.0119121466, 0.0339308716, -0.0449697226, 0.023723226, -0.0017372165, -0.0002458024, 0.0173647553, 0.0416004807, -0.0131053766, -0.0044245403, -0.0248509962, -0.0558469146, -0.0392035283, 0.0157998856, -0.0332120657, -0.0303411298, 0.0058891326, 0.0129643371, -0.0649211705, 0.0665272102, -0.0234622713, 0.0281984378, -0.0021656421, 0.0053548599, 0.0441166423, -0.0355438069, -0.0172974952, 0.0263780542, 0.0000210473, -0.0097241635, -0.0408205204, -0.0525187775, -0.0110142156, -0.0115643656, -0.0465292148, -0.0531148352, 0.0161431469, 0.026763333, 0.0075612841, -0.0558482185, -0.0065016709, 0.0023436453, -0.0730408877, 0.0445539542, -0.0100714192, -0.0150126182, 0.0355761871, 0.0534355603, 0.0239147674, 0.098798044, 0.0340665169, 0.0316191465, 0.0083892634, 0.037455257, -0.0283036474, -0.0157733858, 0.013666206, 0.0123627214, -0.0047742669, -0.0028687937, -0.0233328324, 0.0099849617, 0.0595465638, -0.0271226261, -0.0175437946, 0.0338037759, 0.0518091694, 0.0209977049, -0.0249824263, 0.0133398147, 0.0329718515, 0.0057105483, -0.0209480561, 0.0418548062, -0.0070990133, 0.0006794973, -0.0374399833, -0.0263911858, -0.0044216728, 0.0367412716, -0.0574076883, -0.0052904701, 0.0073809177, 0.0089166593, 0.0874037668, -0.0306181274, 0.0419492573, -0.0182392038, -0.0082334336, 0.0795669109, 0.0041406439, 0.026080668, 0.0189374797, -0.0200364497, -0.0189832151, -0.0195989273, -0.0055451919, 0.015170427, -0.0163255092, -0.0448080562, 0.0236141812, -0.0333626792, 0.0306224152, -0.0033714869, -0.023878241, -0.0117667802, -0.0104012946, 0.0223602429, 0.0437885895, -0.0238849204, 0.0080174571, 0.0512620248, 0.0261774063, 0.0087260474, -0.0466333628, 0.0059168795, 0.0199272744, 0.0037517459, -0.0489273518, 0.0068867486, 0.0052742301, 0.0112015745, -0.0173621625, -0.0092529003, 0.0198919531, -0.0189763419, -0.0130890599, 0.0619635023, 0.0346413851, 0.0443090238, -0.0044553149, -0.1197699085, -0.0236358456, 0.0380519219, -0.0288176574, 0.0137619087, -0.0208893828, -0.0180465579, -0.0447123162, 0.0016867139, -0.0358720012, 0.0249663107, -0.0416515581, -0.0060959538, 0.0692145601, 0.0265634954, -0.0005283909, -0.0091030402, -0.0559592023, 0.0053793425, -0.0107856514, -0.0190814752, -0.017933039, -0.011017764, 0.0105514955, 0.035692554, -0.0545716248, -0.0172837414, 0.0518651381, -0.0715547726, 0.0161095224, -0.0421642512, -0.0197467692, 0.0195583757, -0.0015164448, -0.0050735413, -0.025382733, 0.0179360155, 0.0092001231, -0.0264944509, 0.037458878, 0.0138890259, -0.0383623019, 0.0026761363, -0.0058600726, 0.0011908668, -0.0617910363, 0.0666545108, 0.036200244, -0.0611016192, -0.0445681289, 0.0070050168, -0.0562465601, 0.0234905723, -0.0040051318, -0.0101441126, -0.0004361475, 0.0232397243, -0.0017115745, 0.0655636787, 0.0595961921, 0.0469737686, 0.0285077263, 0.0084941937, -0.0101124058, 0.0056624892, -0.0412323475, -0.0216861479, -0.0309595801, -0.0543214455, -0.0029800171, 0.0573829822, 0.0017685759, 0.0039317161, 0.0237157531, 0.0373232141, -0.0373382121, -0.0160854086, -0.0493218638, -0.0060707722, -0.0070694471, 0.0940664634, -0.0084743584, -0.0188167933, 0.0539174788, 0.0783495232, 0.0676498935, 0.0039395466, 0.013240085, -0.0123079196, 0.0474996865, 0.0246348418, 0.0608302243, 0.0564737543, 0.007920038, -0.0027595113, -0.0405301638, 0.0093875611, -0.0042396886, 0.0597917996, -0.0095095513, 0.0270393398, -0.003829571, -0.0637651756, -0.0060372702, -0.0903163403, -0.0171528421, -0.0508250482, -0.0349234343, -0.0142266685, -0.046820458, 0.0473930724, -0.0239997841, 0.0037161901, 0.0076842508, 0.0159463659, 0.0214627124, 0.0526484624, 0.0415910184, -0.0022101002, -0.0187843051, -0.0108176693, -0.0330812559, 0.0615697764, -0.010583492, 0.0610629059, -0.0185897592, -0.0071169138, 0.0062450003, -0.0420120321, -0.0024331745, -0.0086526684, 0.0628127605, -0.0197266005, -0.0151571659, 0.054675784, 0.0121562872, -0.0558247454, 0.0235124379, 0.0548633784, -0.0125467572, 0.0074465051, -0.0164302308, -0.0535501055, 0.0018490556, -0.0105718337, -0.0307805352, -0.0366631262, -0.0234614462, 0.009061642, 0.0010986925, 0.0074249003, 0.0188114177, -0.0138978371, 0.0140537415, -0.0921826512, 0.0249340869, -0.0483039282, -0.0089711482, -0.026267074, -0.0209251288, -0.0084526846, -0.0131286914, -0.0488809645, -0.0400215909, -0.0200111084, -0.0385738537, 0.0223017894, -0.0205993205, 0.0511504188, -0.052196335, 0.0217036307, -0.0453690328, 0.0280650556, -0.0073150243, -0.0288196728, 0.063575089, -0.0549676158, -0.0086814426, -0.0582549796, 0.0336768329, 0.0301679932, -0.0092471046, -0.0053350003, 0.0191829875, -0.0012713341, -0.0277048685, -0.032792192, 0.0063065439, 0.025577426, 0.0432146713, 0.0482159778, -0.0093005709, 0.0163490083, -0.0670360625, -0.0305450968, -0.0416748002, -0.0738337636, -0.0333474912, -0.0208760723, -0.0403886363, 0.0058738962, -0.0450422838, 0.029266106, -0.0045660818, -0.001739001, 0.0004054015, 0.0640411302, -0.0272825807, -0.1478121877, 0.0759760961, 0.0194542296, -0.0012414822, 0.0682246685, 0.0275415778, 0.026036825, 0.0494207852, -0.0599127188, 0.0646926761, -0.0673922002, -0.0295355469, 0.013615028, -0.0412404723, 0.0215195809, 0.0180744231, -0.0049832128, -0.0457364209, 0.0180852059, 0.0720634535, -0.0187533218, -0.0127644772, -0.0140187982, -0.0377244018, 0.0252950657, 0.0255130399, 0.0111341132, 0.0499094576, 0.0207904484, -0.0553697161, -0.0709834844, 0.0436889753, 0.0256987102, -0.0262241103, 0.0806752443, 0.0047679781, 0.01389533, -0.0410365164, -0.0747659132, 0.0071156924, -0.0020147164, -0.0180811808, -0.0132869137, 0.0475993566, 0.0367266163, -0.0998569205, 0.0170025621, -0.0253564976, 0.065662533, -0.0924676657, 0.0149716251, 0.0033940037, 0.0161033124, 0.0114783812, -0.0285010468, -0.007477704, -0.0019760781, -0.0051416676, -0.0200622883, 0.0103299124, 0.0105875321, 0.0289126132, 0.0656138659, -0.0393736586, -0.0237268843, -0.0440024659, 0.0037618687, -0.0316509828, 0.039006114, 0.0282134954, -0.0168511458, 0.0326460041, 0.013492018, -0.0477560796, 0.0135216499, 0.0236556549, -0.0168424714, 0.0043901945, 0.0770530179, 0.0053465255, -0.0072019221, -0.0076186261, 0.097801201, 0.0088295415, 0.0180054139, 0.0216113906, -0.0562234856, -0.0116012795, 0.0112852603, 0.0376847573, 0.0033388725, 0.0131746829, -0.019608343, -0.0425121561, -0.0498900637, 0.0476149917, -0.04233291, 0.0119719217, 0.028904397, -0.0363976024, 0.0133406455, 0.0219190717, -0.0431749709, 0.0092290835, -0.0090789068, -0.0664249659, -0.0475358963, 0.0076816236, -5.854126069e-33, -0.0197586194, -0.0416214317, -0.0624455027, -0.0293075144, -0.0403570384, 0.0542297512, -0.0240112729, -0.0002093357, -0.0142527465, 0.0305652637, 0.0257678162, 0.0367109962, 0.0126285423, -0.0196139645, 0.041236449, -0.029998878, 0.0553160608, 0.0067517036, 0.0032064363, 0.0079434039, 0.0066552628, 0.0317836292, 0.0254566446, -0.070096083, 0.071502842, -0.0218166355, -0.0637395307, -0.0261578355, 0.0358100869, 0.0458222702, 0.0183273461, 0.0565423667, 0.0540425666, -0.0209370516, -0.0095628016, 0.108887881, -0.0523763783, -0.0196188334, 0.0462973043, -0.0007223468, -0.0333110355, -0.0202658046, 0.0575004034, 0.0087082265, -0.030679401, -0.0300381109, 0.0642046332, -0.0258659199, 0.0429791957, 0.021197591, -0.0009513359, -0.0081715211, -0.019553924, 0.05487708, 0.0312368479, 0.0459789075, 0.0142693892, 0.026602542, -0.0843603313, 0.0038881984, -0.0822984204, 0.010736159, -0.0125086838, -0.0097437445, -0.0319159962, 0.0408712402, 0.01234602, 0.0029939984, -0.0531665869, 0.0339978784, 0.0083449101, 0.0304505788, 0.0001664811, 0.0726143718, 0.0427793451, -0.0372940563, -0.1125146523, -0.0087972451, 0.0250436198, -0.0091502406, 0.0178729575, 0.0034812603, -0.0640723184, -0.0226115696, -0.0188718289, -0.0450076684, -0.0468151979, -0.0424737036, -0.0033546293, 0.0436445884, -0.0175349936, 0.0668551326, -0.0268375855, -0.017374428, -0.0270707067, 0.0038113217, 0.0185193699, 0.0029939762, -0.0024095553, 0.0282062441, -0.0633742511, 0.0202183221, -0.0499236509, 0.0590091608, 0.0304826982, -0.0217793416, 0.0632796064, -0.0205773897, -0.0330352746, 0.0022789314, -0.0054697366, -0.0644649565, -0.0013916993, 0.0255471785, 0.0286476482, 0.0182277355, 0.0110972393, -0.0110057006, 0.041211158, -0.0514991768, -0.0186456162, -0.0103814425, -0.0360046513, 0.0421424545, 0.0085618049, -0.0442027263, 0.0010648966, -0.076529108, 0.0396896675, -0.0722737536, -0.0200639684, -0.041654963, 2.495e-7, 0.0086497702, 0.0363039523, -0.0316761956, 0.0424057692, 0.0215577614, 0.0360022485, 0.0263286866, 0.0656070188, 0.020156594, 0.0052341032, -0.0305778924, 0.057624422, -0.0223743152, 0.0242233239, -0.0514576584, 0.0245964415, -0.026711246, 0.0172384009, -0.0560169294, 0.0350625627, 0.0426018685, 0.0219132658, 0.0116563952, 0.0126502858, 0.0192671344, -0.0120651377, 0.0431582965, -0.026843071, -0.0623715073, 0.0249756575, 0.0173718203, 0.0668806136, -0.0224953424, 0.0440664589, -0.0097838948, -0.0419360846, 0.0294964239, 0.0295689702, -0.003024755, 0.007066383, -0.0081472639, 0.0006121491, 0.0092194071, -0.0072969999, 0.0268817451, -0.0512185208, -0.026162155, -0.0527281165, -0.0332872681, 0.0094117727, 0.0230637994, -0.0047330931, 0.0130728977, -0.0100211902, 0.0073978272, 0.0318686701, -0.0290077254, -0.0541051626, -0.0248414632, 0.0104424739, -0.0302662011, -0.0238520689, -0.0126922168, 0.0295585468, 0.0525755659, -0.0804516301, 0.0041084909, 1.827443262e-34, 0.0022112916, 0.0604876392, -0.021765314, -0.0720469952, 0.0084727053, -0.0073059155, -0.0281003118, -0.0573019832, -0.0109185679, -0.0211474877, 0.0111612547 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.06173v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.06173v1
Summative Student Course Review Tool Based on Machine Learning Sentiment Analysis to Enhance Life Science Feedback Efficacy
2023-01-15T19:56:56
2023-01-15T19:56:56
Ben Hoar, Roshini Ramachandran, Marc Levis, Erin Sparck, Ke Wu, Chong Liu
cs.CL
cs.CL, I.2.7
Machine learning enables the development of new, supplemental, and empowering tools that can either expand existing technologies or invent new ones. In education, space exists for a tool that supports generic student course review formats to organize and recapitulate students' views on the pedagogical practices to which they are exposed. Often, student opinions are gathered with a general comment section that solicits their feelings towards their courses without polling specifics about course contents. Herein, we show a novel approach to summarizing and organizing students' opinions via analyzing their sentiment towards a course as a function of the language/vocabulary used to convey their opinions about a class and its contents. This analysis is derived from their responses to a general comment section encountered at the end of post-course review surveys. This analysis, accomplished with Python, LaTeX, and Google's Natural Language API, allows for the conversion of unstructured text data into both general and topic-specific sub-reports that convey students' views in a unique, novel way.
[ 0.0607181825, 0.0246193334, 0.004427237, -0.0247087926, -0.0239721611, 0.0280097127, -0.0358523838, -0.0394668952, 0.0305659883, -0.0683127716, -0.0188621283, -0.0009350576, -0.0235559046, 0.059556134, -0.0105604408, -0.04489531, 0.0004160667, 0.0454576723, 0.0039840946, 0.0392058864, 0.0401513875, 0.0463622026, -0.0205651578, 0.0340018868, 0.0622679815, 0.0002334998, 0.02844413, -0.0251932871, 0.0333855674, -0.0376621448, 0.0222997889, 0.0474714078, -0.0239356346, 0.0265093539, 0.0000019803, -0.039500095, -0.0281673148, -0.0050213551, 0.0130816717, 0.0184152257, 0.1187578589, 0.0206820779, 0.0147414282, 0.0293851122, -0.0534337536, -0.0113527691, 0.0310168751, 0.0253532268, 0.0627842769, 0.0120258266, -0.0053017372, -0.0447835661, -0.0513325669, 0.0229084045, 0.0340896435, 0.0706512854, -0.0139868334, 0.0014256975, 0.0012553493, -0.0008406616, 0.0005959077, -0.0078612994, -0.0489729904, -0.0527913086, 0.0427842624, -0.0009000172, -0.0285548754, -0.007602782, -0.0050948425, 0.0361524262, 0.0225512274, -0.012586615, -0.0103282323, -0.0224209335, 0.0133272847, 0.0281225629, -0.0584267043, 0.0129445288, -0.0134453131, 0.022710951, -0.0308236033, 0.0281302258, -0.0193088222, 0.0565775447, 0.0163512696, -0.0012014393, -0.0201037377, -0.0267526191, 0.0212489292, 0.0681795478, 0.0241129808, 0.0100529334, 0.0182476155, 0.0177783612, 0.0073791118, -0.0209585447, 0.0290724672, -0.0381183773, 0.0372647792, -0.0442889035, 0.0336137824, 0.0066171056, 0.0007626396, 0.0174652673, 0.0266303383, -0.0125710526, 0.0446794257, -0.0136924563, -0.0106224483, 0.0307205617, -0.0810875148, 0.001701132, 0.064111419, 0.0670839399, 0.0108655579, 0.0448043346, -0.0684414059, 0.0127841635, -0.0640955791, 0.0039862581, -0.0284689162, 0.0291718654, 0.0723703355, 0.054436218, -0.0611312799, 0.0660604537, 0.0091072395, 0.0243238751, -0.011734454, 0.0220676009, 0.0428310372, 0.0248996634, 0.0168570876, 0.0525360629, 0.0063642706, 0.0476235263, 0.0398420133, 0.0001282258, -0.0134793371, -0.0320204645, -0.0066091735, -0.0042097424, -0.0099450946, -0.055440411, -0.0014283288, 0.0236720145, -0.0061311913, 0.0353473723, 0.0230495352, 0.0413813479, -0.0012542278, 0.0546286777, -0.0470232777, -0.0316760652, 0.0262314416, 0.0119451443, 0.0193059649, -0.0150436228, -0.0221677311, 0.0261784997, 0.039173346, -0.0331261344, 0.0245526321, -0.0320745967, 0.0076007745, -0.0426260307, 0.0044046007, -0.0143495323, -0.0512992777, -0.020735532, -0.0731502473, 0.0495061614, 0.0351712815, 0.044979617, 0.0117068887, 0.059821032, -0.0467330068, 0.0450682417, -0.0430469885, 0.0532053411, 0.0187114179, -0.0023052504, 0.0040452387, 0.0355043076, -0.019298017, -0.0091171768, 0.054053735, -0.0084536811, 0.0122666052, -0.0920730755, -0.0395235531, 0.000948348, 0.0403342396, 0.0228435248, 0.009644513, -0.0291556902, -0.0064089959, -0.0173996165, 0.0666681081, -0.1151582375, 0.0353325903, -0.030405689, 0.0692940801, 0.0796716437, 0.0085780425, -0.0198577903, -0.0211394709, -0.0294896476, -0.030172348, 0.0132305352, 0.0716714635, -0.0372665301, -0.0507811867, -0.0204307698, -0.0250010155, 0.0061802943, 0.0014446967, -0.0295223128, -0.0246951059, 0.0089846142, 0.0070343148, -0.010872758, -0.0846227929, 0.0160556436, 0.0584254637, -0.0199449919, 0.007997212, -0.0027451355, 0.0394463725, 0.0620627925, 0.0013319171, 0.0277309548, 0.0327961817, 0.003729023, -0.0520067848, -0.0240869205, 0.0207473263, -0.0007078638, 0.0332037844, -0.0566148646, -0.0344330221, 0.0352662541, -0.0301160421, -0.0241719633, 0.0264794715, -0.0266189985, 0.0242425334, 0.0208090693, -0.0141808046, -0.0296939425, -0.0088689569, -0.029860843, -0.0086564263, 0.028985329, 0.0363439359, -0.0231160689, -0.10115733, 0.0122589609, 0.0203271955, -0.0324330628, -0.0043996726, 0.0297327247, 0.0243046843, 0.044408001, -0.0000612883, -0.0640014261, -0.0122776637, -0.082274951, -0.0588371716, 0.0255536847, 0.0196865797, 0.0049249656, -0.0264314879, 0.030632332, -0.0049630231, -0.0573216416, -0.0247562453, -0.0026164234, -0.0125773959, 0.0422891453, -0.0056621889, 0.0613009185, -0.0585904606, -0.0240621027, -0.0413340442, 0.0192845818, 0.1072731093, -0.0232332181, -0.0093064997, 0.007833574, -0.0428867899, -0.0175760239, 0.0258947909, -0.0255801827, 0.011286607, -0.0157351866, 0.0102216005, 0.0013582233, 0.0320949666, 0.0318579823, 0.0592337549, 0.058383476, -0.0074175377, -0.0039785081, -0.0586939603, 0.0230750926, 0.0274349116, -0.0097860368, 0.0211867522, -0.034497261, 0.0149417492, -0.0540059917, -0.0078085368, 0.0157225877, -0.0241483282, 0.044202134, -0.0410816446, -0.000194228, 0.0203050114, 0.0025032894, 0.0351322107, -0.0089003202, 0.0655772686, 0.0265657473, 0.0136150355, -0.1026008874, -0.0277299285, -0.0366901234, 0.0048905597, -0.0022786837, 0.0132641541, -0.0371696018, 0.0529938787, 0.0192517862, -0.0172449388, -0.0185297113, -0.0424924046, 0.0328636505, -0.0403378382, -0.0280902106, 0.0227223858, 0.0219295546, 0.0129930023, 0.007805943, -0.037240956, -0.0047314232, 0.030361386, -0.0389271677, -0.0055833184, -0.0196537152, 0.02440634, -0.0243593846, 0.0095978742, -0.0555628836, 0.0504912324, 0.0024442817, 0.0210410114, -0.0186838731, 0.0323565118, -0.0242342595, -0.009072992, 0.0800789222, 0.0208157524, 0.0165811684, -0.0045583942, -0.042730432, 0.0025201323, -0.0300383605, 0.0515270829, -0.0392828956, 0.0036207398, -0.0390563607, 0.0359406881, 0.0746228397, 0.0221261401, -0.070178777, -0.0146401525, -0.0102213258, -0.0008036149, 0.015707612, 0.0461116768, -0.0355084203, -0.0072493209, -0.0812380686, 0.0579080693, -0.0296617392, -0.0145764397, 0.0147981877, -0.0841445401, 0.0164535064, -0.0149963452, -0.0421361849, -0.0599852987, -0.0640667751, -0.0037021975, -0.0239554625, -0.0176116135, -0.0600133762, 0.0067008743, 0.043251086, 0.0175907928, -0.0735077485, 0.0042258054, 0.0354477204, 0.0131656285, -0.0099780997, 0.0682522282, 0.0660904422, -0.0327870212, -0.0281339157, 0.0469475873, 0.0018633229, -0.026402954, 0.015261461, 0.0865870938, -0.0074527026, -0.0087696798, -0.0398685411, 0.0035860161, -0.0619390532, 0.0041854936, 0.0332271568, 0.0569464117, 0.0027800302, -0.0243118834, -0.1064520851, 0.0664992779, 0.0132950461, 0.0414307117, 0.0058470084, -0.0810031444, 0.0216628276, -0.0558580309, 0.0334136859, 0.0064432723, -0.0395197123, -0.0204913151, -0.0263620745, -0.0148818726, -0.0383999385, -0.0286646672, 0.0377808735, -0.0063989405, 0.0033915588, 0.0238314047, 0.0551587939, 0.0188494194, -0.0614248104, 0.0187595841, 0.0505530387, 0.0157398842, -0.0361207798, -0.0838091075, 0.0461326391, 0.0191431772, -0.0413998216, -0.0161777772, -0.0000850892, -0.0520474538, -0.0247089528, 0.042822022, 0.0167833939, -0.0234832559, 0.0086940592, 0.0055788923, 0.0380585082, 0.0727866665, -0.0069268188, -0.0184561964, -0.0110584935, 0.0681874454, 0.0028432067, -0.0273174699, -0.0203231052, 0.006465889, -0.0115349786, -0.0311777461, -0.0264930166, -0.0236611888, 0.03583958, 0.0350893252, 0.0503706113, 0.020062672, 0.0000040128, -0.0084576635, -0.0192319229, -0.0120523991, -0.0345810056, -0.0288062822, -0.0280105565, 0.0099528953, 0.0068158372, -0.0276256111, 0.0320216753, -0.0341284424, 0.0347124077, -0.0301193576, 0.0814033151, 0.0157667641, -0.0016212219, 0.0159761645, -0.0249865726, -0.0474269763, -0.0311208759, -0.013060295, -0.0215938687, -0.0077609234, 0.0355416201, 0.0161814783, 0.0179318171, 0.0429215953, 0.0238217637, -0.0585025027, -0.0113244625, -0.0578657016, 0.0194659624, -0.0859089568, -0.0032156499, 0.0187333263, -0.0122853545, -0.006124632, -0.0308232922, 0.0288417526, -0.0496656857, -0.0036162084, 0.0152518423, -0.0055654258, 0.0013438291, -0.0427943096, 0.0087467749, -0.0424161367, 0.0020267048, 0.0210877378, -0.0445846878, -0.0269539431, 0.0166571327, 0.0175350141, 0.0116228079, 0.0233858693, 0.0265830513, -0.0513896458, -0.0344682708, 0.0380826071, 0.0223503374, 0.0615959726, -0.0328790061, 0.0280613378, 0.0298453253, -0.0231975727, 0.0213921815, -0.0417404138, 0.0429795794, -0.0379241966, -0.0282166805, -0.0274758227, -5.935833579e-33, -0.0217059627, -0.0578963645, -0.0576837733, 0.0851020515, 0.0383342616, -0.0096773561, -0.0257643834, 0.0481621586, 0.0094118398, 0.038171608, 0.0185516216, 0.03362808, -0.0181742311, 0.054282438, 0.0456598699, 0.0200662632, 0.0352613628, -0.0101137627, 0.0222502295, 0.0416261703, 0.0087679075, -0.0112564601, 0.0460030362, -0.1157066077, 0.057762906, 0.0062006158, -0.024911439, -0.0228570178, -0.0426971167, 0.0220783632, -0.0204793643, 0.0877455324, 0.0079815947, -0.0061416742, -0.0027309903, 0.0258218106, -0.0091471151, -0.0423893668, -0.0250444207, -0.0402890407, -0.0325411409, 0.0081126131, 0.0634682626, 0.002643025, -0.0651551634, -0.0202492438, 0.0672300756, 0.0025008258, 0.0243680775, -0.0683013573, -0.0458530262, 0.0061368993, -0.0285988506, 0.0057869419, -0.0104313046, 0.0401265733, -0.00765655, 0.0257414877, -0.0291613732, 0.0680034757, 0.0076464573, 0.0067314757, 0.0098199192, -0.0285835601, -0.0210740417, 0.0602503493, 0.0080255531, 0.0181430355, -0.0455703996, 0.0142952409, -0.0102974651, -0.0422116742, 0.069624804, 0.0574443154, 0.0267071594, -0.0343648419, -0.0327302366, 0.0631677136, 0.0347450376, -0.0283345059, 0.0164929498, -0.0188931283, -0.0038697368, -0.0036484231, -0.0080408333, -0.0497382134, -0.0179599877, 0.0043879207, -0.0237871576, -0.0524863973, -0.0349565223, -0.0226965584, -0.0587248951, -0.0360972583, -0.0523866937, 0.0101250485, -0.0286785569, 0.0374617241, -0.0110758729, -0.0581973381, -0.0602599084, 0.067077212, -0.0434349813, -0.0132292407, 0.0268137734, -0.0070104203, 0.0262520202, 0.0131987585, -0.0591569059, -0.0242433939, -0.0009740323, -0.0083671138, 0.0227369722, 0.0152078727, 0.0011933245, 0.0218963977, 0.0034708639, 0.042639602, -0.0127119534, 0.0584365614, -0.013463025, -0.0166311283, -0.0114181554, -0.0173894037, -0.0294654053, -0.0610260405, 0.0029838828, -0.0180566665, 0.0124712419, -0.0418996736, 0.0105056362, -0.0314851552, 2.667e-7, 0.0776108876, 0.075297296, -0.0220954027, -0.0703902692, -0.020977648, 0.0433009826, 0.0121029122, -0.0007524505, 0.0385780185, -0.000073004, 0.0046512526, -0.0077691255, 0.0022358198, 0.0319747925, -0.0744328797, -0.0228839256, 0.0040948768, -0.0448782705, -0.0009954058, 0.0454665124, 0.1117931604, 0.0548458174, 0.0405684449, -0.0056482991, -0.0292489268, 0.0083361408, 0.0136678107, -0.0340603516, 0.0037006522, 0.0051580705, 0.0073811775, -0.0491329134, 0.0031473036, -0.0019822221, -0.0228052754, -0.0565785393, 0.0468225405, 0.0053331912, 0.0098757716, -0.0420146622, 0.0345751494, 0.0622257181, 0.0389540419, 0.0094873942, -0.0276479609, -0.0597039796, -0.0200794525, -0.056394238, -0.0208403599, 0.0026407524, 0.0257043764, 0.0077875177, -0.0254505612, 0.0142906178, -0.0231665988, -0.0483402163, -0.0228176937, -0.0508702062, -0.0027665598, 0.0032036745, 0.0187158957, -0.0220511761, 0.0324687026, -0.013741754, 0.0166987088, 0.0000859193, -0.0005596188, 2.173345562e-34, 0.0677338243, -0.0257927869, 0.0168230589, -0.0131029002, 0.029400602, 0.0149936574, -0.0089171818, 0.0051116226, 0.0170012955, -0.0283110738, -0.0062187258 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.06057v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.06057v1
Hawk: An Industrial-strength Multi-label Document Classifier
2023-01-15T09:52:18
2023-01-15T09:52:18
Arshad Javeed
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.LG
There are a plethora of methods and algorithms that solve the classical multi-label document classification. However, when it comes to deployment and usage in an industry setting, most, if not all the contemporary approaches fail to address some of the vital aspects or requirements of an ideal solution: i. ability to operate on variable-length texts and rambling documents. ii. catastrophic forgetting problem. iii. modularity when it comes to online learning and updating the model. iv. ability to spotlight relevant text while producing the prediction, i.e. visualizing the predictions. v. ability to operate on imbalanced or skewed datasets. vi. scalability. The paper describes the significance of these problems in detail and proposes a unique neural network architecture that addresses the above problems. The proposed architecture views documents as a sequence of sentences and leverages sentence-level embeddings for input representation. A hydranet-like architecture is designed to have granular control over and improve the modularity, coupled with a weighted loss driving task-specific heads. In particular, two specific mechanisms are compared: Bi-LSTM and Transformer-based. The architecture is benchmarked on some of the popular benchmarking datasets such as Web of Science - 5763, Web of Science - 11967, BBC Sports, and BBC News datasets. The experimental results reveal that the proposed model outperforms the existing methods by a substantial margin. The ablation study includes comparisons of the impact of the attention mechanism and the application of weighted loss functions to train the task-specific heads in the hydranet.
[ 0.0277133808, -0.0028989646, 0.0198995974, 0.0025201105, -0.0198542476, -0.0023269316, 0.0403428935, 0.0200539101, 0.049641937, -0.0731570423, -0.0539430231, -0.0025470983, -0.0217593201, 0.0003113405, -0.0039686305, -0.0162822828, 0.0256328564, 0.0337744132, 0.0276385006, 0.0118490467, 0.0321897902, 0.0075088814, 0.042800352, 0.0020605382, -0.0083042067, -0.0194501076, -0.0134646287, 0.0392185748, 0.0116781844, 0.0123298792, 0.0339987986, 0.0217911433, 0.0508644618, 0.0414645188, 0.00000212, -0.030516712, -0.0028623214, -0.0113873053, -0.0198416971, 0.0143207712, 0.0361486189, -0.0052135363, 0.0235878415, 0.0056502931, -0.0015190837, 0.0397651345, 0.013937355, 0.0921461061, 0.0586857051, 0.0593327768, -0.0285983775, -0.048147317, 0.0524692163, -0.0256943032, 0.0158420485, -0.06544891, 0.0259026494, -0.0395310149, 0.0005962972, 0.0271649547, -0.0003238668, 0.0596844964, 0.0386498012, 0.0090223337, 0.0503144562, 0.0238319766, -0.0510763153, -0.0026733547, -0.0204953402, 0.0346477889, -0.0696288869, -0.0154609783, -0.0055685025, -0.0218461696, 0.0191192031, -0.038888, -0.0394344777, 0.0088506807, -0.0112193152, -0.0093994169, -0.0010639024, 0.0260667652, -0.000150944, 0.0144917313, 0.0114299478, -0.0083795227, -0.0179593638, -0.0423759185, 0.0044457847, 0.0289493091, -0.0177380722, 0.0045283297, 0.0553984419, 0.0559223332, -0.0093009593, 0.0129077192, -0.0283021685, -0.0986874178, 0.037052881, -0.1125321835, 0.0038112225, -0.0369168893, -0.0089768982, 0.0576286949, -0.0215587504, 0.0130802058, -0.0250849277, 0.0079147834, -0.0215073619, 0.0265035536, -0.048190847, -0.0376954973, -0.0531476736, 0.0513661839, 0.0730644464, -0.0406033583, -0.0286466368, -0.0048412755, 0.0020730463, 0.0163274743, 0.0248793643, 0.0147174448, -0.0411449336, -0.0052371565, 0.0021269377, 0.029355213, -0.0016408225, 0.0214796513, 0.0050333668, -0.0129025336, -0.0058916705, 0.0583923087, -0.003386118, 0.0091638463, 0.0156077277, 0.0336939208, -0.031724643, -0.0591102876, -0.0786243528, -0.0261053964, -0.0299310051, -0.0430753939, 0.0197126623, -0.0209836215, 0.0162295476, -0.0174407214, -0.0111737289, -0.0227064956, 0.0006310459, 0.0325645059, -0.0103672575, 0.0236943047, 0.0090479441, -0.0536207594, 0.0797301754, 0.0258535985, 0.0073301406, 0.0729580894, 0.0114723686, 0.0872944891, 0.0403177515, 0.0132864574, 0.0196117572, 0.0028515428, 0.0007491914, -0.0290221944, 0.018723527, -0.0067060362, -0.0090247914, 0.0534166694, -0.0042196112, -0.0093658809, -0.0016966532, -0.0032256166, 0.0514128357, -0.02579014, 0.059514951, -0.0023045852, 0.0093053877, 0.0080007529, -0.0074318782, -0.006818457, 0.0039595547, 0.0249534529, 0.0219339468, 0.0122883637, -0.0021273391, -0.0186290964, -0.0420425758, -0.0442433283, -0.0218200833, -0.009922496, -0.0219251662, -0.0165597033, 0.0924730673, -0.0010395164, -0.0520974174, 0.0721293241, -0.0093461499, -0.0034641975, -0.0027087345, -0.0057487115, -0.024301691, 0.0198997054, 0.0317012407, -0.0994578078, -0.0320499241, -0.0491112135, 0.0258388873, 0.0342227109, 0.0428757928, 0.0208437014, -0.015602448, -0.0801758468, -0.0075678304, -0.0106724659, -0.003609474, 0.0399543159, -0.0499946959, 0.0420780182, 0.0294402968, -0.0165410694, -0.012388967, 0.0529964119, 0.0020383894, -0.031910684, 0.0088644866, 0.0106666693, 0.0159246195, 0.0109158866, 0.0034405498, -0.0056196894, 0.0658921525, -0.036154829, -0.0469310023, -0.0745967478, -0.0300358683, 0.0092752557, 0.0135917431, 0.00041452, -0.0015057725, 0.0495596714, -0.038434241, -0.0542905666, 0.0004219549, -0.0172767881, -0.0016493602, -0.0292224083, -0.0134501997, 0.0029733439, 0.0403795093, -0.0427266583, 0.047114905, 0.0156039875, 0.036327675, -0.0461197756, -0.0422419198, 0.0311718062, -0.0302163772, -0.0341437832, 0.0327485725, -0.0159749519, 0.0424352363, 0.0479791239, -0.0077634454, -0.0154551454, -0.022961285, -0.0325829573, 0.0102578169, -0.0230715871, 0.0163231902, -0.0321440548, -0.0245400146, 0.0234542731, -0.0569082461, -0.0417888239, 0.0203919187, -0.0377962403, -0.0023651265, 0.0508062616, 0.024568595, 0.0118398741, 0.0370037705, -0.0364710018, -0.0051718708, 0.0731796101, 0.0204666797, -0.0168188922, -0.0778139383, 0.0182823613, -0.0165729467, -0.0039007515, -0.0083788466, 0.0161031038, -0.0120583493, -0.0234224983, 0.0157088079, 0.0850465, 0.0358752273, 0.027018683, 0.0450407341, 0.0467166491, 0.0041236747, 0.0300170202, -0.033965718, 0.0513814539, -0.0298385881, 0.0202903207, 0.0131052416, 0.0361480154, -0.0237232111, -0.0007764912, -0.0309043583, -0.0405762307, 0.0128312856, 0.0025924682, -0.0554502234, -0.0209937934, -0.0005715783, -0.013349222, 0.029180292, -0.0245619845, 0.0303460117, 0.0104090897, 0.0026652592, -0.0630333945, -0.0091102477, -0.0384276845, 0.0564043522, 0.0311038271, 0.0066126627, 0.054228995, -0.0353155099, -0.0391828045, -0.0050111017, 0.0309369732, -0.0124453744, -0.0074389735, 0.0134168714, 0.0060615512, -0.0500236154, -0.0168589856, 0.0055624768, -0.0186303202, -0.0062958021, 0.0166006237, 0.0026917171, 0.0195090435, -0.1114500389, -0.0064625307, 0.0149755366, 0.0822100416, -0.0261861086, -0.0286921319, 0.0263730194, 0.0708918497, 0.0190182477, 0.0000516238, 0.0104413703, -0.0218600575, 0.0242221579, 0.0569087677, 0.0232788827, -0.0013716639, -0.0310295131, -0.0279775243, 0.0019144233, -0.0749551877, 0.0049595842, -0.028658025, 0.0065941922, -0.081973508, 0.0104674893, 0.076256603, 0.0167834014, -0.0682381839, -0.01928626, 0.0267393738, 0.0177419037, 0.0278113615, 0.0185595006, -0.0361822061, -0.0251447819, -0.0067148567, 0.0273648053, 0.0141321868, -0.0045119454, -0.0036308486, -0.0108466586, 0.0321469828, -0.0103718229, -0.0209858399, 0.0216117632, -0.040070232, -0.0456990562, -0.0173186269, -0.0072152112, -0.0174036939, 0.0093428371, -0.0418672673, 0.0352972709, -0.0475503579, -0.0151994424, -0.0014151861, 0.0171564184, -0.0189605318, -0.0114198364, 0.0488216244, -0.0420233831, -0.0002325504, 0.0634820089, -0.0268022269, -0.0063011213, 0.0108084576, 0.0660581663, -0.0545328781, 0.0233259015, -0.0027267563, 0.0126819257, -0.0446583703, -0.0068211127, -0.0104769096, 0.0747519284, -0.0084801037, -0.03162333, -0.069953084, -0.0409415811, -0.0170082636, 0.0288422108, -0.009567637, -0.0829678699, -0.0630085319, -0.0034935728, 0.0105609298, -0.0142434547, -0.0086664325, 0.0199937467, -0.0340227745, -0.0909579396, -0.0449411087, -0.0428924821, -0.021112401, 0.0284510367, -0.0335124731, 0.0004667898, 0.0094987247, 0.0103000402, -0.0471716188, -0.0197370667, 0.0326969586, 0.0210430287, -0.0442884825, 0.0502018519, 0.0728548095, -0.0373343341, -0.0394959226, 0.0194078479, -0.0790316314, -0.0253372043, 0.0100324377, 0.0068354681, 0.011007363, 0.0140395835, -0.0123454127, -0.0486972779, 0.052834712, 0.0733341128, -0.019987816, -0.0055856272, 0.0321879797, -0.0387723446, -0.0294092745, 0.0256803315, -0.0409237929, 0.0660854578, 0.0079440689, -0.0252739657, -0.0099452147, 0.0035663827, -0.0396256819, -0.0157517809, 0.0373475403, -0.0021490522, 0.0065168701, -0.0255893562, 0.0358201228, 0.0396369919, -0.0161336064, -0.0043550488, 0.0069546993, 0.0087012434, -0.0452814586, -0.0339699388, 0.0599492192, 0.0444923975, 0.0060128057, -0.0296599325, 0.0336950719, 0.0118727488, 0.0162091646, -0.0295117367, 0.0275643449, -0.0288522914, -0.0239516478, 0.0014870967, 0.0224542469, 0.0003608327, 0.0318204984, 0.0448617749, 0.0150544085, -0.0198625252, 0.0287937112, -0.1073053405, 0.0429219119, -0.0343160182, -0.0048887171, 0.0104291458, -0.0087403376, -0.0052552014, -0.036839623, -0.0417350903, -0.0243640468, 0.0311922375, 0.0076796627, -0.0098973969, 0.0153805781, 0.0069649392, -0.0299938507, 0.0388140567, 0.0593338795, 0.0462194346, -0.0179229546, 0.0366256461, -0.0530403368, -0.0702384338, -0.0060592773, 0.0222847424, 0.0439124964, 0.0146889919, -0.0367662311, -0.0261378177, 0.0048764921, 0.0713892132, -0.0262348019, 0.0350618809, -0.0167648494, 0.0325115807, 0.0799441114, 0.0349146426, -0.0165019911, -0.0253456142, 0.0243221074, -0.0510254242, -0.0271647573, -0.0135808978, -5.913165273e-33, 0.0137361055, -0.0340114199, -0.0209300276, -0.0061258851, -0.0411435217, 0.0276187006, -0.0113397436, -0.0400622524, -0.02750393, 0.0218344964, -0.0116743147, 0.0028051853, -0.0073717055, 0.0362891965, 0.0527547002, -0.0288769081, 0.0241370928, -0.0232487153, -0.0050032097, 0.0534148812, 0.066578269, 0.0592345335, 0.0768292174, -0.019147981, 0.0026741198, -0.033180289, -0.0412021801, -0.0266868286, -0.0019327363, 0.0423446819, -0.0050295196, 0.0799295977, 0.0417855605, -0.058619976, 0.0011301704, 0.0628929436, -0.0547973663, -0.0377602354, -0.08170221, 0.0330039226, 0.0094716325, -0.0082538268, 0.0589620806, 0.0024502529, 0.0214178655, -0.0519631989, 0.0844155401, 0.0203148779, -0.0489428267, -0.0836436376, -0.0428263135, 0.0124904774, -0.0083341012, -0.015527186, -0.0104939146, 0.0420391113, -0.0050441315, 0.0695846602, -0.0964358523, -0.0167753063, -0.0533041023, 0.0186287817, 0.0099228956, 0.0267007053, -0.0350459628, 0.0277416669, 0.0000733988, 0.0616994426, -0.0201297197, -0.0314121023, 0.0426202752, 0.0172872469, 0.065993771, -0.0219852645, 0.0695321485, -0.0290739778, -0.0836803913, 0.0105776964, 0.0212877803, 0.0548786521, 0.0399538949, 0.0393796526, -0.0134615041, -0.008748346, 0.0347022116, -0.0009406101, -0.001265706, -0.0046645072, -0.0004749055, 0.0283960141, -0.0072188014, 0.0553626493, 0.0077143665, -0.0370240547, -0.0041464805, 0.0344875753, -0.0078308042, 0.061469771, 0.0151946293, -0.0307435635, -0.0563833416, -0.0128604462, 0.0190677866, 0.029178014, -0.0193813592, -0.0437288173, 0.059956193, 0.0472246893, -0.0628059357, -0.0105121005, 0.0142983589, -0.0250849798, 0.0068703722, 0.0490842201, -0.0023940988, -0.0150272893, -0.0000160936, 0.0824784264, 0.0171891153, -0.0114761451, -0.0177763216, 0.0108411191, 0.00704887, 0.019389689, -0.015549955, -0.0021410438, -0.0097526247, 0.0122642647, 0.0189634748, -0.0880862325, -0.0066387877, 0.0199973583, 2.798e-7, 0.0469070077, 0.0428329632, 0.0167887341, -0.039345894, 0.0554640517, 0.0402830429, -0.0003025451, 0.0672072023, -0.0544714704, 0.0047942158, 0.0281510837, -0.0091891913, 0.0300494451, 0.0022121847, -0.11651434, -0.0541524775, -0.0790383443, -0.0166789386, -0.0703356937, 0.0068474547, 0.0505235903, 0.0834196508, 0.0205762684, -0.0327916704, 0.0165681895, -0.0133469254, 0.0409723595, 0.000991105, 0.0444817618, -0.0034644506, 0.0035248653, 0.018266784, -0.0545511954, 0.0104241082, -0.0480127223, -0.0024408659, 0.0321856216, 0.0373625495, -0.0412767194, -0.0238987934, 0.0306624249, 0.0101777939, 0.016745545, -0.026879007, 0.059367869, -0.0190076642, -0.0561259761, -0.0267904531, -0.0144937951, -0.0295764506, 0.0711158067, 0.021102557, 0.0030994213, 0.0138785429, -0.0128931273, -0.0222474281, -0.0005539304, -0.1085180044, 0.0102909515, 0.0461190492, -0.0454967432, 0.0122007784, -0.0504952073, 0.0086705629, 0.0762194842, -0.0793392286, -0.0222738795, 2.327769474e-34, 0.0488417633, -0.0173704512, -0.027714435, 0.0273344498, -0.0328561701, -0.0082739424, -0.0498138815, -0.0046845526, 0.0293251704, -0.0731860921, 0.0098679494 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.06024v3
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.06024v3
A data science and machine learning approach to continuous analysis of Shakespeare's plays
2023-01-15T06:25:50
2023-07-11T14:20:54
Charles Swisher, Lior Shamir
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.LG
The availability of quantitative text analysis methods has provided new ways of analyzing literature in a manner that was not available in the pre-information era. Here we apply comprehensive machine learning analysis to the work of William Shakespeare. The analysis shows clear changes in the style of writing over time, with the most significant changes in the sentence length, frequency of adjectives and adverbs, and the sentiments expressed in the text. Applying machine learning to make a stylometric prediction of the year of the play shows a Pearson correlation of 0.71 between the actual and predicted year, indicating that Shakespeare's writing style as reflected by the quantitative measurements changed over time. Additionally, it shows that the stylometrics of some of the plays is more similar to plays written either before or after the year they were written. For instance, Romeo and Juliet is dated 1596, but is more similar in stylometrics to plays written by Shakespeare after 1600. The source code for the analysis is available for free download.
[ 0.015385339, 0.0627879873, -0.0292366724, 0.0265967883, -0.0693206936, -0.0031526091, 0.0069746347, 0.0411434397, 0.0060222396, -0.0604495853, 0.044722151, -0.0027392949, 0.0297703445, 0.0042660222, 0.017918475, -0.019786479, -0.024148969, 0.0290968046, 0.0290140975, 0.0485469326, -0.0090850014, 0.0108355936, 0.0197849013, 0.0172951315, 0.0252601206, -0.0366400257, -0.0065201339, -0.0095702885, 0.0172595009, -0.0028452047, -0.0007756209, 0.0311257076, -0.0061884243, 0.0213547666, 0.0000016874, -0.0378319025, 0.0249370281, -0.0333041959, 0.070339337, 0.0268829279, 0.0553074963, 0.0668906048, -0.0269145574, -0.0175654646, -0.0196432751, 0.0805119723, 0.0325334631, -0.0224460419, -0.0021471402, 0.0834650621, -0.0136185046, -0.0493718795, 0.0261354335, 0.0059532467, 0.0185074434, 0.056312494, 0.0343660302, -0.0576715134, 0.0347468592, 0.02785125, -0.0392692536, 0.0393300802, -0.0371269397, -0.0024710402, -0.0182905607, 0.0128436117, -0.0463574007, 0.0401612818, -0.0122192064, -0.0240621716, 0.0425036922, 0.0013192522, 0.0425111651, 0.0156745333, -0.0157183595, 0.0012663309, -0.0067595872, -0.0511066876, -0.0135427257, -0.0311623365, 0.017499771, -0.0333977602, -0.003773124, 0.0329177864, -0.0043625664, 0.0177491531, -0.013115339, -0.023537349, 0.0273867846, -0.0402490646, -0.0436651744, -0.0391230471, -0.020123696, 0.0452868417, 0.0450457074, -0.0220883954, 0.0153313959, -0.0672064275, -0.0038354706, -0.0843257084, 0.0443492383, 0.0090445904, -0.0078643588, 0.0162920915, 0.00388912, 0.0172746908, 0.005447825, -0.0020243749, -0.0013063642, 0.0441540405, -0.0395571142, 0.0135028539, -0.0232569762, 0.0030949628, 0.0090960907, 0.0008667529, -0.0384841412, -0.0377955437, 0.015532176, 0.0027781187, -0.0260748416, 0.0283397399, 0.0149413971, 0.024620682, -0.0426347218, 0.0285181999, -0.0409073271, 0.0021792254, -0.0662510544, 0.0127669722, 0.0164525844, 0.0318189263, 0.0396543443, -0.0563504621, 0.0573142171, 0.0511116832, 0.0043753996, 0.0075375782, -0.0333259664, -0.0111762872, -0.0784718692, -0.0272903722, -0.0331575125, -0.0328942239, -0.0027813201, -0.0095223216, 0.0006987327, -0.0366687998, -0.0142959477, 0.0405717045, -0.0358802341, -0.0014571642, -0.0040331003, 0.0130686034, -0.0115885194, -0.0500414744, 0.0276296344, 0.0035081606, 0.1056492925, -0.0044928449, 0.0131473644, -0.0107265301, 0.0146170892, 0.0376768783, -0.03138135, -0.0235073194, -0.0699362755, -0.0426237471, -0.0196000114, 0.0605309568, -0.0500017926, 0.0362145118, 0.0217049327, 0.0074236975, 0.0663569942, 0.0470145009, 0.0597088858, 0.067213051, 0.0290486533, 0.0264357589, 0.0723466128, 0.011912738, -0.0237777885, 0.0017750242, 0.0471648797, 0.021722246, -0.0859376639, 0.0031698842, 0.031816911, -0.0342863388, -0.0079219965, 0.0133592589, -0.024675278, -0.0367122926, 0.0411687605, -0.0286043826, -0.0184214804, -0.0451335497, 0.0167439785, -0.0497791655, 0.029049404, 0.0194637645, 0.0014224793, 0.1045153067, 0.0490878709, -0.0918199643, 0.0743834749, -0.016338028, 0.0053997203, -0.0261627845, 0.0098855952, -0.0088048326, 0.0444559567, -0.0377675034, 0.030180512, -0.01066163, 0.015365731, -0.0291427169, -0.0835544318, 0.0441773087, -0.044033628, 0.0294009876, -0.0301568601, 0.0422202013, -0.0679495558, -0.0700026676, -0.0158496201, -0.0170319378, 0.0082015917, 0.0273446646, -0.0197109897, 0.0014689016, 0.0125952866, -0.0244601853, -0.0133819105, 0.0216482189, -0.0206026156, 0.043977119, 0.0438827351, -0.0717338547, 0.0183402635, 0.0230107214, -0.0073899282, -0.0265805796, 0.0320438966, -0.0543359332, 0.0635393187, 0.0197170284, 0.0073783514, -0.0484431274, -0.0056764251, -0.0441542789, 0.028677268, 0.0342885517, 0.0427679457, -0.0453780703, -0.0326716192, 0.0105378507, 0.0026540118, -0.0338420272, -0.0538400859, 0.0279583018, 0.0315700509, 0.0598713383, -0.0269503556, -0.0297602639, -0.0702239648, -0.0560620427, -0.0045304797, -0.0166450348, -0.0065653748, 0.0255262833, -0.0179674551, -0.0317982994, 0.0241273884, 0.0010486912, -0.0096356431, -0.0114756459, -0.0384329744, 0.0604204722, -0.0039302157, -0.0139925703, -0.0417308211, 0.0035633552, -0.0584751591, 0.0607116818, 0.041984573, 0.001102193, 0.0018490115, 0.0001951997, -0.0081794569, 0.0041951016, -0.0167449024, -0.0461681895, -0.0098448927, -0.0249151774, 0.0303107072, 0.0422611162, 0.0110671353, 0.0390160382, 0.0520767868, -0.0365044586, 0.034778133, -0.0085304063, -0.0194713864, 0.0186839011, -0.0539307334, -0.0530662015, 0.0535659045, 0.0244386811, 0.00574524, -0.0170597527, 0.0199615788, 0.0659161806, 0.0107027199, 0.0170326997, 0.0072483756, -0.0109456144, -0.0269112531, 0.0476694368, 0.0389942788, 0.0272550099, 0.0205833763, 0.0070091169, 0.0258402769, -0.0751209036, -0.0019499791, -0.0238968115, 0.0663809702, -0.0023031998, 0.0253473949, -0.0234895758, -0.0291706119, -0.0281903911, -0.0043470794, 0.0923762396, -0.0358242132, 0.0280186962, -0.0261222888, -0.029960366, 0.0285020843, 0.0087825349, 0.0194193311, -0.057139691, -0.0595653616, -0.0116996206, 0.0354112461, -0.0718492046, -0.0638682172, -0.04089766, -0.0074096597, 0.0273566116, 0.003149281, -0.0105589498, -0.0371496081, 0.0414095968, 0.0093653211, -0.0059940871, -0.0663470998, 0.0149310809, 0.0424441583, -0.0004145959, -0.0892278403, 0.0533818901, -0.049024187, -0.0175243039, -0.0055887103, -0.062126331, -0.0383107737, 0.0094478671, -0.034122467, -0.047905989, 0.0086266436, 0.1005679071, 0.0078855865, -0.0404245071, -0.0183379129, -0.0309394933, 0.0023392849, 0.013377917, 0.0303890724, -0.0407649241, 0.0160229821, 0.0069654379, 0.0483107343, -0.0004444875, -0.0527531393, -0.0113132065, -0.0686733127, 0.0478604063, -0.0136800166, -0.0315619484, -0.0193814635, -0.015291621, -0.0138227465, -0.0401472896, -0.0392555296, -0.0060658599, -0.010875687, 0.0136040924, 0.0207143873, -0.0521913618, -0.0081872754, -0.0117120259, -0.0368010476, -0.0124621578, 0.0029223771, 0.1336473227, -0.0677428767, -0.0285579246, -0.0249416791, -0.0040506362, 0.0007117582, -0.0035727608, 0.1235369667, 0.0304616168, 0.0097625703, -0.0306217801, 0.0218463875, 0.0365035087, -0.023406323, 0.0925933644, 0.0348308161, -0.0016261509, -0.0272731017, -0.0279203355, 0.0367474072, 0.0002299772, -0.0048450972, -0.0048854416, -0.0439190418, -0.0552263111, -0.0431659184, 0.0385714024, -0.03365504, -0.0593517423, -0.0220703725, -0.0151930386, -0.0108537097, -0.0721424222, -0.022742752, -0.0188475773, 0.0764554143, 0.086509034, 0.0017226508, 0.0149504906, -0.0017222724, -0.1006487533, -0.0181533787, 0.0450178869, 0.0177346338, -0.0354537964, -0.0004140309, 0.0190379955, -0.0336446948, 0.0031235239, -0.0250886213, -0.0484864824, -0.0400734656, 0.0327858888, 0.0325836837, 0.0262095481, 0.0469171144, -0.0166287888, -0.0445429459, 0.0115819899, -0.0035151378, 0.0126893334, 0.0185949728, -0.0174648948, -0.0156022776, -0.017163137, -0.0051091341, 0.01832637, 0.0138081657, -0.000561638, -0.0100430707, -0.0106079392, -0.0322913267, -0.0022500628, -0.0007005696, 0.0598940775, -0.0408959612, 0.0002396157, 0.0231320597, -0.0667833388, -0.0098289987, -0.0225650016, 0.0223671179, -0.0295255315, -0.000295886, -0.0139497286, -0.0687256381, 0.0154914903, -0.0016964225, -0.031076394, -0.0161901992, 0.0553405322, 0.0517131537, 0.0321403816, 0.0007205175, 0.0031076723, 0.0011644335, -0.0001132199, -0.0047211014, 0.1008386388, 0.0428615175, -0.0273100063, 0.0293284655, 0.0054809363, -0.0290219914, 0.0152397724, -0.0663451925, -0.0092768213, -0.0220794901, -0.0400020964, -0.0104130208, -0.0443726331, 0.0540368445, -0.0204945188, -0.0076727625, -0.0218350179, 0.0480906852, 0.0432238393, 0.0378090329, -0.0540334098, -0.006577502, -0.008923037, 0.0042299926, 0.0177030768, -0.0065562371, -0.0370823629, 0.0314559527, -0.0958877653, -0.0076076244, -0.0101081049, 0.01950882, -0.0275619552, 0.0387240686, -0.0187593065, -0.0550097823, -0.0419448279, 0.071086809, -0.0031146635, 0.0596206859, -0.0595061146, -0.0030977384, 0.0242444407, -0.0164984744, 0.0442912988, -0.0704118535, 0.0488001145, 0.0046976162, -0.0245745871, -0.0243887361, -4.622172357e-33, -0.0012144243, 0.00724639, 0.0134670017, 0.0555416793, -0.0516364723, -0.0185559187, -0.02389149, -0.0236023571, 0.0216687638, 0.0367844142, -0.0424929, 0.0116541581, -0.00803087, -0.0212501176, 0.0575140379, -0.0106894793, 0.0224025492, -0.0026159196, -0.0390935093, -0.0280583221, 0.0518049449, 0.0214566533, 0.0527599193, -0.0481929481, 0.0333398469, -0.0405528694, 0.0009228121, -0.0109340427, 0.0238722581, -0.0431388095, 0.021286292, -0.0064000026, 0.0290600639, 0.0089155082, -0.0005962594, 0.0429537334, -0.0214924961, -0.0527057797, -0.0008115279, 0.0170472898, 0.0523120724, -0.0151496371, 0.0252721179, -0.003466059, -0.056917198, -0.0378015153, 0.0864383578, -0.011470695, -0.0135594513, -0.0693339705, -0.0214367043, 0.0013208959, -0.0435067751, -0.0172530003, 0.0121660661, 0.0218553562, 0.0100032026, 0.0067843231, -0.023385169, 0.0361960903, -0.0384558477, 0.0003503682, -0.0422996432, 0.0257870443, -0.0108844582, 0.0465601496, 0.0145123946, 0.0129563818, -0.0421685241, 0.0791271329, 0.0397559479, 0.0273670871, 0.0445236601, 0.0617298782, 0.0241527166, -0.001632727, -0.0180323105, 0.0021514599, 0.0417804495, 0.0122001544, 0.0044538854, -0.0375650339, 0.0022858547, -0.046756763, -0.010013896, 0.0017990654, 0.0198253207, 0.0141873211, -0.0351994373, -0.0589432977, 0.0080192909, 0.0029787419, -0.0143405646, -0.053881593, -0.0433179513, 0.0080489228, -0.0565724, 0.0870752782, 0.0083210506, 0.006975878, 0.026795486, 0.0004765153, -0.0180536956, 0.0502010994, 0.0232228432, -0.0077057071, 0.0295050163, 0.0477884226, -0.0460616127, -0.0321868919, 0.0135006635, -0.0039979839, -0.0076777819, -0.0146778822, -0.0154423993, 0.0117078889, 0.0526046827, 0.0050324551, 0.0321468711, 0.0307073332, 0.0099617913, 0.0268537123, 0.0643685311, -0.0227020569, -0.0120807616, -0.0345040858, -0.0144929942, 0.009999997, -0.0107069341, -0.0601284839, 0.0174907371, -0.0706746206, 2.488e-7, 0.068633534, 0.046958942, 0.0365576632, -0.0162782744, 0.0027952252, 0.0263520498, -0.0253607873, 0.0341525041, -0.0052646375, 0.0221513472, 0.0860935524, -0.0176958665, 0.0179261249, 0.0288968589, -0.0666503459, -0.0485826954, -0.0920210704, -0.0185663961, -0.0706021711, 0.0331650823, 0.0273966193, 0.0252827313, 0.0492592119, -0.0252165403, 0.0187780112, -0.0299573094, -0.0067099845, -0.0312785544, 0.0214026049, 0.021992702, 0.0368728526, -0.0355223194, 0.0244068, 0.0507597029, -0.0346082896, 0.0124356942, -0.003271166, 0.0418075249, -0.0080819046, 0.0874277577, 0.0244593117, 0.0049233786, 0.0181200076, 0.0140644424, 0.0064925211, 0.0507620797, -0.0091656186, -0.0304995738, -0.0550288521, 0.0077612246, 0.0343574584, 0.0175315998, -0.0163914617, 0.0330337361, 0.0290517602, -0.0087413294, 0.0397928543, -0.045349218, -0.0055136727, 0.0276873559, -0.0173579212, -0.0234294403, 0.032060273, 0.0242464896, 0.0242232233, -0.0512483753, 0.0089676874, 1.688877733e-34, 0.05245075, -0.0219325069, -0.0302363932, 0.0015991762, -0.0061793593, 0.012079332, 0.0647831559, 0.0240323171, 0.034125369, -0.0025784571, -0.0080314167 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.08146v3
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.08146v3
What's happening in your neighborhood? A Weakly Supervised Approach to Detect Local News
2023-01-15T03:20:18
2024-06-05T22:50:00
Deven Santosh Shah, Shiying He, Gosuddin Kamaruddin Siddiqi, Radhika Bansal
cs.IR
cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.LG
Local news articles are a subset of news that impact users in a geographical area, such as a city, county, or state. Detecting local news (Step 1) and subsequently deciding its geographical location as well as radius of impact (Step 2) are two important steps towards accurate local news recommendation. Naive rule-based methods, such as detecting city names from the news title, tend to give erroneous results due to lack of understanding of the news content. Empowered by the latest development in natural language processing, we develop an integrated pipeline that enables automatic local news detection and content-based local news recommendations. In this paper, we focus on Step 1 of the pipeline, which highlights: (1) a weakly supervised framework incorporated with domain knowledge and auto data processing, and (2) scalability to multi-lingual settings. Compared with Stanford CoreNLP NER model, our pipeline has higher precision and recall evaluated on a real-world and human-labeled dataset. This pipeline has potential to more precise local news to users, helps local businesses get more exposure, and gives people more information about their neighborhood safety.
[ 0.0272032432, 0.0160055719, -0.0060317842, 0.0066323886, -0.0375134759, 0.0072599868, 0.0143373851, -0.0195713844, 0.0756847188, -0.0210976787, -0.0244270489, 0.0397964269, -0.0083361538, 0.067999132, -0.0171684977, -0.0445478782, 0.0413606763, -0.009951259, 0.0409002937, 0.039684128, 0.0246181171, 0.0494719371, 0.0290976446, 0.0154738054, 0.0019495413, 0.0186548941, -0.0004582717, 0.0120060407, 0.0165772066, -0.053974729, 0.041028358, -0.0195553098, 0.0323728062, -0.0263792779, 0.0000018301, -0.0036696626, -0.018418327, -0.007828379, 0.0560950227, -0.0602248609, 0.0227336138, -0.0839978009, 0.0098388866, -0.0019834845, -0.0201482791, -0.0585737191, -0.0026220102, 0.0372985639, 0.0324141085, 0.0719580874, -0.0380030423, -0.0178223103, -0.0347799733, -0.0120563339, 0.0231241956, -0.0224115532, 0.039196115, -0.0714819431, 0.0178470537, 0.0076705008, 0.0024912849, -0.010754264, -0.008040051, -0.0159155019, -0.0194491465, 0.0437378176, -0.0232669432, 0.0111816796, -0.0330877863, 0.0352100246, -0.0416176654, -0.0395147465, 0.0284578186, -0.0081236279, 0.0022894791, 0.0179944225, -0.0447953977, -0.0491432101, -0.0132898623, 0.0379465409, -0.0333444737, -0.0045906473, 0.0071723592, 0.0499359928, 0.0292819291, 0.1095713899, -0.0113011543, -0.0355630107, -0.0201808754, 0.0484896302, 0.0409870967, -0.0475025326, 0.0675998107, 0.0092567643, -0.0081054745, -0.0166169722, -0.0007932492, 0.0682457611, 0.0078137731, -0.099558495, -0.0484543853, -0.0223409031, -0.0028527556, 0.0661747083, 0.0065941848, -0.0739915818, 0.0183397327, 0.0038293048, 0.0214279685, -0.0138578126, -0.0286324266, 0.0371159278, -0.0150523549, 0.0487627052, -0.0306199025, -0.0207538046, -0.0168368779, 0.0065062139, 0.0026137603, -0.0037267688, -0.0187827349, 0.0543752797, -0.029916862, -0.0171845052, 0.0063696979, 0.0548509732, -0.0635740608, 0.0298306495, -0.0237120464, 0.0353253558, 0.0049239472, 0.0144294072, 0.0349166989, -0.0026422045, -0.0094551286, 0.0200303681, 0.0216418337, -0.0600951165, -0.0623020232, 0.0181093905, -0.0522860475, -0.0228376072, -0.0359288529, -0.0604374334, -0.0259654298, 0.0079444433, 0.0206940416, -0.0529319048, -0.0104523301, 0.0078345463, -0.0126678795, 0.0223432817, 0.0081652161, 0.0118866432, 0.0672611073, -0.0265181269, 0.0411235467, 0.0621760674, -0.0089404602, 0.1214144751, 0.0499656945, 0.0279261321, -0.0302503072, -0.0166422743, -0.002891483, -0.0057841432, 0.0110758077, -0.0054642162, -0.0580346175, 0.0031371829, 0.012658664, -0.0267909169, 0.0076182992, 0.0183056742, 0.0525810383, -0.0044139675, 0.0193016436, -0.0130454106, 0.0531577654, 0.0705258027, -0.0668995306, -0.0343018137, -0.0218714345, 0.0071065626, -0.0496316589, -0.0152868349, 0.0085995141, 0.0672072619, -0.0525902733, -0.001786847, 0.0364780612, -0.0139797088, -0.0024860948, 0.0171166882, 0.0541416928, -0.0120386528, 0.0081784818, 0.0232236572, 0.034823183, 0.0545444861, 0.0433118679, -0.0000058323, 0.0700812712, 0.0419972688, -0.0046639903, 0.0161603782, 0.0282083582, -0.0035227891, 0.0390368775, 0.0040131626, 0.0256550722, -0.0217683408, -0.0015834682, -0.0209497269, -0.0300560798, 0.009028215, 0.0389487818, 0.0123796016, 0.0536336675, 0.0712997466, 0.015489446, -0.0108881993, -0.0258400124, -0.0100271339, 0.0296948031, -0.0187619627, 0.0115181785, 0.0212464239, -0.0314544886, 0.0038182652, 0.031869188, -0.0078621991, 0.0035190845, -0.0090190237, -0.0397853963, -0.0013470883, -0.0010070922, -0.0242326651, 0.0021164792, -0.0377829596, -0.00641861, 0.0190482959, -0.019020373, -0.0233028214, 0.0145302238, -0.0186092351, -0.0274452604, -0.0057585067, -0.0104422355, 0.012891558, 0.0004142023, -0.0381237194, 0.0733120218, 0.0128923161, -0.0129201133, -0.0276594814, 0.0010150537, 0.010505083, 0.0250091776, -0.0133977523, -0.0469666496, -0.0202945583, -0.0233603716, 0.0371702276, 0.0012024918, -0.0132671045, -0.0358375385, -0.036194928, 0.0009836287, -0.0325064436, -0.0215986967, -0.0022584507, 0.0408608392, -0.0186760444, -0.0590399243, -0.0368059091, -0.016270835, -0.0039830818, 0.0277114715, -0.0028944344, -0.0197162684, 0.0372842066, -0.0088078054, 0.0015710904, -0.0313134156, 0.0529880151, 0.0085122399, -0.0734101087, -0.0535638854, -0.0206051543, -0.001940319, -0.0014855911, 0.018237317, 0.0382932872, 0.0017009214, -0.0056712809, 0.0105504114, 0.0356794111, -0.0062541151, 0.0122720143, 0.0008913078, 0.014633799, -0.0505965352, 0.0202767476, -0.0921481103, 0.0364910774, -0.0332862958, -0.0174017157, 0.0230512265, 0.0125200972, 0.0071132234, 0.005315905, 0.0008840684, 0.0290135164, -0.0244946554, -0.0036178057, -0.0302505121, -0.0205184463, 0.0228431821, 0.0351779684, -0.027997395, -0.035523098, 0.0543968379, 0.0379969738, 0.0430019088, -0.0336367376, -0.039403595, -0.071637243, 0.0153954942, -0.0182937402, 0.0280025955, -0.0528210588, -0.0868081301, 0.0247482136, -0.0544806905, 0.0021880846, 0.0119044604, 0.0620124079, 0.008379464, 0.0040358133, 0.0469638146, -0.083506152, -0.0312874503, -0.0441078469, -0.030345032, -0.032216914, 0.0264637936, -0.0195415132, -0.0266943444, 0.045020707, -0.0126371244, 0.043432571, -0.0373989716, -0.0322005749, 0.014605917, 0.0417824499, 0.0480786301, -0.0076631932, -0.0492557958, 0.0652094409, -0.0196339227, 0.0413505323, -0.0060735685, 0.0435148068, -0.0315938108, 0.0522290431, 0.0411135145, -0.0297225006, -0.0003120014, 0.0005182046, 0.0323863365, 0.0218344331, -0.0538084731, 0.0842227042, 0.0356626734, -0.0819051117, -0.014304596, -0.0167428907, -0.013901596, 0.0453845002, 0.041568473, 0.001065826, -0.0136720352, 0.0003596313, 0.0033360329, 0.0592160001, -0.0317200497, 0.001074526, -0.0515589938, 0.0239321832, -0.0022312468, -0.0311441813, -0.0510319322, -0.1148233414, 0.010186363, -0.0183049645, -0.0276926421, -0.0443732068, -0.028703073, -0.0268598497, 0.0317876898, -0.0210205317, -0.0628923178, -0.0131931277, -0.032683257, 0.0024608439, 0.0299747717, 0.0524485782, -0.0042889281, 0.0215237532, -0.0258256476, 0.0127647156, 0.0234973989, -0.0311916471, 0.0526880026, -0.0620517693, -0.0028616507, -0.0589814819, 0.0298692826, 0.0172984526, -0.0222886726, 0.0308753829, 0.052474644, -0.0324419178, -0.0284447763, -0.0172966607, 0.0532408804, 0.0719065368, 0.013054979, 0.0289954059, -0.0104851509, 0.0486879423, -0.0072097443, -0.0340017937, 0.0186874233, -0.0530272052, 0.0131145921, -0.0134824272, -0.0617360286, -0.0228469279, -0.0252409186, 0.0565234683, 0.0329704322, 0.0168975331, -0.0058755898, 0.0507914014, -0.0312404688, -0.0397141278, 0.0334237218, -0.0031757131, -0.0052453014, 0.0182618443, 0.0187803451, 0.0312497485, -0.0201380569, -0.0341433994, 0.0791482031, -0.0894693136, -0.0035994831, 0.0073334333, 0.0224991348, 0.0149918254, 0.0259175617, -0.0732696354, -0.0283495467, 0.0527047478, 0.0221504327, -0.0368400775, -0.0424611606, -0.0157247055, -0.0306003261, 0.0249251891, 0.0054328348, -0.0359872617, 0.0725674331, 0.0282029398, -0.0154655827, -0.0028552234, -0.0018629062, 0.0080234194, -0.0185262244, 0.0724367723, -0.0288280919, 0.0094421394, -0.043836277, -0.0352768525, 0.0276200473, -0.0149875386, 0.0189814735, 0.0162828062, 0.0692277178, 0.031637121, -0.0596329682, 0.0427829288, -0.017164655, 0.0335298963, -0.0735713169, -0.0278680045, 0.0258439276, 0.0181500241, -0.0068061873, 0.0278802011, -0.0069015478, 0.0295814648, 0.0031932457, 0.0152430246, -0.0141996406, -0.0109922914, 0.0059926426, 0.0183765553, -0.0284280106, -0.0004687124, -0.0387380607, -0.0065152138, -0.0401765071, 0.0613262653, 0.0215568747, -0.0597097874, 0.0102779483, -0.0200341251, -0.0099320505, 0.0163565222, -0.0016539482, 0.003122129, -0.0694100112, -0.0063189245, 0.0128258327, -0.0239062533, 0.0403878056, 0.0498349033, -0.0325881578, 0.0132732866, 0.064799577, -0.0633270144, -0.0183190703, -0.003818773, 0.0508954637, 0.0666906759, -0.0405066647, -0.0106013436, -0.0249655806, -0.012677826, 0.0261935946, -0.0706105456, -0.0063720597, 0.0104831653, 0.0255186558, 0.0558224954, 0.0187711082, 0.0008270874, -0.0543484539, 0.0175472572, -0.0189824142, -0.036329437, 0.0065207914, -6.041540276e-33, -0.0067593395, -0.0426562428, -0.0165237635, -0.0148257678, 0.0272385404, 0.0148898652, 0.0222849846, -0.0416440554, 0.0119571174, 0.0105982022, 0.0138070025, 0.0394870825, 0.0189539194, 0.0010506518, 0.0170920324, -0.0403568745, 0.0437475853, 0.0208928324, 0.0065259179, 0.0331590287, 0.0035498124, 0.0711501315, 0.0557968318, -0.0859253928, 0.0046006469, 0.0301372577, -0.0397533402, -0.0083113341, 0.0481719449, 0.0448974967, -0.0139722088, 0.0561901927, 0.0199838858, -0.0575072765, -0.0158293117, 0.034273833, -0.0878550857, -0.0318406001, 0.0281024314, -0.0098746568, 0.0131822126, 0.0172729995, 0.0270607118, 0.0090373605, 0.0310933311, 0.036395248, 0.0577844866, -0.0252783392, -0.0544977114, -0.0081712455, -0.0509338379, 0.0249494147, -0.0211922918, 0.0183615778, -0.0247300677, 0.0133665698, 0.0171750784, 0.0418015644, -0.0451200083, 0.0034441371, -0.0103549538, 0.0586756691, -0.0184930786, -0.0668074265, -0.0427090861, 0.054334756, -0.0029250644, 0.015463165, -0.0055296835, 0.0037787645, 0.0375423059, 0.035598442, -0.0075982334, 0.0581769496, 0.0050481479, -0.0416167751, -0.0951205641, 0.0604479872, 0.0316460095, 0.0297432579, 0.0205175001, -0.007380472, -0.0832128525, -0.0251973663, 0.0339200012, -0.0431385115, -0.0413335823, -0.0579628088, 0.0074954126, 0.0611777119, -0.0114731034, 0.072222501, -0.0257613286, -0.0219169781, -0.0544021092, 0.0377921015, -0.0083478689, -0.0088618398, -0.0078056469, 0.0543219037, -0.044261653, -0.0403532386, -0.0370211974, 0.0107328389, -0.0174463466, -0.0098691825, 0.0587275214, 0.0519581661, -0.0763766468, 0.013359488, 0.0017815948, 0.0053120009, -0.0068108137, 0.0288594197, -0.0017070173, -0.0012571675, -0.0274733827, 0.0394936353, 0.0161970071, 0.0133322636, 0.0737775415, -0.0479897708, -0.0200009868, 0.0434020571, 0.007030128, -0.0245630872, -0.0209919084, -0.0247989092, 0.018939821, -0.0849663988, -0.0052988208, -0.0546903163, 2.693e-7, -0.0062977718, 0.0482479595, -0.0173007771, 0.0176696554, -0.0123578431, -0.0123505713, 0.0147360582, 0.0672815889, 0.0007630785, 0.0455034934, 0.0166562442, 0.0093092751, 0.0019653188, 0.02700302, -0.1555207521, 0.0721786916, -0.0697242767, 0.0133296801, -0.083173722, -0.004682241, -0.0064516962, 0.096858941, 0.0618157573, -0.0226856526, 0.0309247617, -0.0325506888, 0.0038370122, -0.0243108235, -0.0425175205, -0.001522128, 0.066014111, -0.0099171055, 0.0021528979, -0.0205810629, -0.0430746078, -0.0075703594, 0.0471866243, 0.0553797223, 0.0035186536, 0.0082688974, 0.0043287161, -0.0122988699, 0.0158125833, -0.0322382599, 0.0799703002, -0.0727320239, -0.0166083612, -0.0236615576, -0.0242725331, -0.0326876864, 0.0043241009, -0.0123149315, -0.0094792573, -0.0046251751, 0.0346377529, -0.0062904651, 0.0158726089, -0.0626247078, 0.0089832693, -0.0069342386, 0.00149356, -0.0080520464, -0.0408592895, 0.0088830572, 0.0132063283, -0.0483221412, 0.017881779, 1.868289625e-34, -0.0016636865, 0.0850987732, -0.0309571289, -0.0386079028, 0.0077258917, -0.0065660821, -0.0605859198, -0.0163850114, 0.028065946, -0.0359486006, 0.0027949226 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.06009v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.06009v1
Rationalizing Predictions by Adversarial Information Calibration
2023-01-15T03:13:09
2023-01-15T03:13:09
Lei Sha, Oana-Maria Camburu, Thomas Lukasiewicz
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI
Explaining the predictions of AI models is paramount in safety-critical applications, such as in legal or medical domains. One form of explanation for a prediction is an extractive rationale, i.e., a subset of features of an instance that lead the model to give its prediction on that instance. For example, the subphrase ``he stole the mobile phone'' can be an extractive rationale for the prediction of ``Theft''. Previous works on generating extractive rationales usually employ a two-phase model: a selector that selects the most important features (i.e., the rationale) followed by a predictor that makes the prediction based exclusively on the selected features. One disadvantage of these works is that the main signal for learning to select features comes from the comparison of the answers given by the predictor to the ground-truth answers. In this work, we propose to squeeze more information from the predictor via an information calibration method. More precisely, we train two models jointly: one is a typical neural model that solves the task at hand in an accurate but black-box manner, and the other is a selector-predictor model that additionally produces a rationale for its prediction. The first model is used as a guide for the second model. We use an adversarial technique to calibrate the information extracted by the two models such that the difference between them is an indicator of the missed or over-selected features. In addition, for natural language tasks, we propose a language-model-based regularizer to encourage the extraction of fluent rationales. Experimental results on a sentiment analysis task, a hate speech recognition task as well as on three tasks from the legal domain show the effectiveness of our approach to rationale extraction.
[ 0.0341483317, 0.1165613532, -0.0202109721, 0.0280219223, -0.0334867127, 0.0146087715, 0.0192547012, 0.0273943469, -0.0083033442, -0.0202438831, 0.0123563986, -0.0181463789, 0.0007401903, 0.0172540769, 0.0221954901, -0.0713598505, 0.0120152831, 0.0038389254, 0.0729727, 0.0039999201, 0.0269301366, 0.0323339328, 0.0242321491, 0.0368227176, -0.0049425149, 0.0014716648, -0.0085433098, -0.0089545259, 0.0265001133, -0.0022226311, 0.0121811023, 0.0136600677, 0.0220023114, 0.0120658129, 0.0000022947, -0.0193948559, -0.0241453163, 0.0033377896, -0.0588304177, -0.0317177474, -0.005105156, -0.0318052806, 0.0208450276, 0.0105300145, -0.056597691, 0.0299512092, 0.0211915094, 0.0865395442, 0.0281676538, 0.06816113, -0.0137628913, -0.033549495, 0.0238023568, -0.0170781445, -0.0298376903, -0.0683321133, -0.0092295064, 0.0172549319, -0.0383425802, -0.0011968156, 0.0148405461, -0.01113699, 0.0392946862, -0.0194486454, 0.0189728495, 0.0153545402, 0.0405988209, -0.0105458358, -0.0094809718, 0.0768208802, -0.0496633835, -0.0361695327, 0.0196792725, -0.0301143508, 0.020817874, 0.0048497063, -0.0556458272, -0.0070935786, -0.0023407459, 0.0270753559, 0.0342622772, 0.0096875159, 0.053129036, 0.0351519845, -0.0246042237, 0.0211736467, -0.0186049994, -0.020000359, 0.029724855, -0.0194472671, -0.0136315012, -0.0638900995, 0.0231901594, 0.0459403023, -0.0218629781, -0.0045234011, -0.0386552736, -0.0348823778, -0.0053368197, -0.0350540988, 0.0260582436, -0.01813256, 0.0026058638, 0.0420453176, -0.0271776188, 0.0386610106, -0.0213768072, 0.0518283285, -0.0265390649, -0.0014141389, -0.0475083478, -0.0305047557, 0.0081471046, 0.0213074703, -0.0330905654, 0.0297789201, -0.020612793, -0.040822532, -0.0640924051, 0.015956182, -0.0349963717, 0.0743199438, -0.0184388123, -0.0368550606, -0.0259836502, -0.0298407245, -0.0785919353, 0.0356357992, 0.0318116546, -0.0333599001, -0.0224876497, 0.0270136837, 0.0061153895, -0.0200058315, -0.0014116622, 0.1097556949, 0.0004717668, 0.0124037173, -0.0407075323, -0.0635400563, -0.0059158178, -0.0719644129, 0.0003044396, -0.0081815301, -0.0134337191, -0.0372615643, -0.0195686501, -0.096195899, -0.0136518963, -0.0199450552, -0.022269994, 0.0991068855, -0.0206546802, -0.056322556, -0.0198670961, 0.0325102843, -0.0179681778, 0.0166736376, 0.0272174887, 0.0628585815, 0.0317441523, -0.0160630681, 0.0213810392, -0.0202094875, 0.0374985635, -0.0290695447, -0.032564763, 0.0041200975, -0.0332069695, 0.0190530885, 0.0074012605, 0.0456137881, -0.0180561244, -0.0195276551, 0.0286463574, 0.0411681905, 0.0006463903, 0.0390370935, 0.0192675106, -0.006254564, -0.00892678, 0.0312608667, -0.0225166176, 0.0284127388, -0.0591767021, -0.0355356112, -0.0308117457, -0.0009436945, -0.0211437941, -0.073568441, 0.0201788116, -0.0356520377, 0.036504183, 0.0080297533, 0.0383758582, 0.0222956873, -0.0302734412, -0.0118417609, 0.0150106568, -0.012223307, -0.0102447271, -0.0698101968, 0.0463390015, 0.0536978766, 0.0179899074, -0.015274575, 0.0035637782, -0.0276961662, -0.0079108207, -0.0191115495, 0.055609677, -0.0372318327, 0.0149868978, -0.0548299775, -0.0403619297, -0.0541956313, 0.0107055753, 0.0265908837, 0.0095147714, -0.022080794, 0.0330948494, -0.0269070361, -0.034803208, 0.0258691851, -0.0192454271, -0.058971636, 0.0066735689, 0.0303873811, 0.0531896316, 0.0245989058, 0.0109214196, 0.018265374, 0.0217456575, -0.0239903908, -0.0476812422, 0.0353985131, -0.0275819171, 0.0130642271, 0.0221919827, -0.0247238055, -0.0140244821, 0.0425265357, -0.0485994853, -0.0192481112, 0.0233013574, -0.0093251225, -0.0382052101, -0.0126680704, -0.0086718705, 0.0010837583, -0.0075670145, -0.0446012914, 0.0840978622, 0.0160276927, -0.0385441259, -0.0083683161, -0.0401401371, 0.0210681781, -0.0122570209, 0.0115743736, 0.0079161394, -0.0181264188, 0.0163852964, 0.0177173484, -0.0422676019, -0.0270480942, 0.0025552276, -0.031378869, 0.0129459314, -0.033610642, -0.0104758861, 0.0096565839, -0.0066663278, 0.0265544672, -0.0243631024, -0.0285317469, 0.0079711881, -0.0146765159, 0.0114154071, 0.0342502929, -0.0023194591, 0.0046902946, -0.0529256836, 0.0002241319, -0.0220887102, 0.0450929292, 0.0338085964, 0.0291071348, -0.0291334577, 0.0042654965, -0.0108567812, 0.0157159884, -0.0405174308, -0.0181748625, 0.0318197012, 0.0019713393, -0.0695010051, 0.0820610672, 0.0287864245, 0.0653412417, 0.0216821432, 0.051343333, -0.0505431667, 0.0035467993, -0.0184623152, 0.0344267301, -0.0385105349, -0.0175538361, 0.009619833, 0.0690060556, 0.0284149759, 0.0195548348, -0.044865068, 0.0645366237, -0.0019271465, -0.0655680746, -0.0177011713, -0.0514552109, -0.0075170617, 0.0566367507, -0.0418133177, -0.0563160777, 0.1180587858, 0.0145879444, 0.0464634746, 0.006398248, -0.0548136048, -0.0076847929, 0.0575178638, -0.0061840662, 0.0065441374, 0.0258490928, 0.0158161856, -0.0270687845, -0.082110323, 0.0261278357, -0.0187510867, 0.0385957435, -0.0491944812, -0.0195801724, 0.0098480703, -0.0651778355, -0.0466611832, -0.0651535913, -0.0441953279, 0.0126318177, -0.0038358192, -0.0225858744, -0.0047537396, -0.0241936669, -0.0057497439, 0.0116302911, -0.0196352955, 0.0206787661, -0.003885506, 0.0112457806, 0.0567428395, 0.0265161861, 0.0090549383, -0.022787733, 0.0514111668, 0.046446871, -0.003317801, 0.0101531735, -0.0552281663, 0.0003985204, -0.0247774571, -0.0134937251, -0.0115854526, 0.0118188625, 0.0589242354, -0.030549245, 0.0205719341, 0.087265037, 0.0111511918, 0.0125238942, 0.0179217849, 0.0036960496, 0.0010735096, -0.0055351784, -0.0214262623, -0.0335365161, -0.0342762507, 0.0091851326, 0.051431518, -0.0116029829, -0.024074072, 0.0216449872, -0.0951300487, 0.0330891386, 0.0035896276, 0.0072345641, -0.0582827181, -0.0186992716, -0.0054122568, -0.0476435088, 0.0106277224, -0.0206831377, 0.0481125526, 0.0070974967, 0.0312865861, -0.0300316755, -0.0061850925, 0.0247820187, -0.0308967978, 0.0086027533, 0.0835763812, 0.067409426, -0.0016461635, -0.0225268528, -0.0299850851, 0.0178246647, 0.0396712534, 0.0133377844, 0.0986506194, 0.03358097, -0.0033226714, -0.0171559826, 0.0680839196, -0.0014587244, -0.0334422961, -0.0013748507, 0.0428262651, -0.0335640907, -0.0295313094, 0.0062229312, -0.0021850562, 0.0227200072, 0.0609669052, 0.0452093743, -0.022961285, -0.0515077487, -0.046173241, -0.0139680691, -0.122237578, -0.0359854139, -0.002422719, 0.0320714898, -0.014254136, -0.0353478193, -0.03555388, 0.0071319202, 0.006739202, 0.0091562662, -0.0121687194, -0.0121882623, -0.0261314772, -0.0347124748, 0.0229470115, 0.0021395055, 0.0057580979, 0.0547995307, -0.0038516466, -0.019897813, -0.0425057448, -0.0274441373, -0.0028855246, -0.0093585104, -0.0255123768, -0.0102221724, 0.0517376103, 0.02165474, 0.0792280287, -0.0507156551, -0.0469869487, 0.0281990264, 0.0329925157, 0.0156091843, -0.0555780344, 0.0869628564, -0.0427955575, 0.0006171387, 0.0292033888, -0.0109390179, 0.0103033418, 0.0709773451, -0.0296457186, -0.0671216249, -0.0062858076, 0.051623717, 0.0231142864, 0.0631027743, -0.0001527928, -0.0160885621, -0.0282263476, -0.0223483648, 0.0242383219, -0.0204296783, -0.0153733213, 0.0167783033, 0.0500857383, -0.0035868401, -0.0085769296, -0.0588137768, -0.0106048305, -0.0028461567, -0.0569658354, 0.0046965452, 0.0201359987, 0.0559976809, 0.0022730289, 0.0077687567, 0.0045592869, 0.0365480296, 0.0074015306, 0.0499528721, -0.0000892824, 0.0323901772, 0.017942125, 0.0160771832, -0.0123923607, -0.0056652338, -0.0816737786, -0.0489400625, -0.0090245334, 0.0000543528, 0.0291433632, -0.0347178094, 0.0088147298, 0.017679261, -0.0014398491, 0.0041948343, 0.0655871034, 0.0276591014, -0.0316720344, 0.0380652919, 0.0094983364, -0.0167821273, -0.0126146767, 0.0531052761, 0.0088454047, 0.0555102117, -0.0190492067, -0.027071964, -0.0298958048, -0.0313600637, 0.0164255369, 0.007073903, -0.0050392319, -0.0022811161, -0.0393450782, -0.0613615699, 0.0103402734, 0.0168008488, 0.004137815, -0.0034748332, 0.0304836687, 0.0580169745, -0.0189492758, -0.0186303798, -0.0411636308, 0.0511305109, -0.0092771314, -0.0228396151, -0.0352930613, -6.503509189e-33, 0.0057535856, -0.0373501256, -0.0385687649, -0.0074736178, 0.011858603, 0.0003974061, -0.0473559909, -0.0317167528, -0.0402355194, 0.0507103875, -0.0178486891, 0.0312092658, -0.0006949425, -0.0117235426, -0.0149735156, -0.0731675997, 0.0427232496, 0.0210139193, -0.0096634757, 0.0164427217, 0.0395130813, 0.0302123316, 0.0489190258, -0.1182753369, 0.0657157004, 0.0267504677, -0.0264032967, -0.0070849787, -0.0366669334, 0.0642922819, 0.0252227262, 0.0370994546, 0.0205764156, -0.0335586704, 0.0089630885, 0.0363287665, -0.0709768534, -0.0140350461, 0.027539812, -0.0202261247, -0.0545044094, -0.0675950423, 0.0350005478, -0.0159689952, -0.0046140323, -0.0137102334, 0.0379217453, -0.0327842012, -0.0119293081, -0.0280340333, -0.0516076311, 0.0170771964, -0.0467300899, -0.0121740596, 0.0132900933, 0.0356889628, 0.0151944896, 0.0289126933, -0.0400159881, -0.0317112207, 0.0141049344, 0.0065808916, 0.0361938365, -0.0016258314, -0.0388997048, 0.1040203124, -0.0201924406, -0.0178932715, -0.0724005252, 0.0250830818, -0.0429353788, 0.0918105692, 0.1065720469, 0.0547835119, 0.0538937226, -0.0473796241, -0.120042339, 0.0100087216, -0.0223343913, 0.0395636894, 0.0200480949, 0.0182546768, -0.0444333218, 0.0066445256, -0.0384648107, -0.0721450746, -0.0174319167, -0.0300925542, -0.0088131204, -0.0026392031, -0.0504970588, 0.0045054574, -0.0302489419, -0.0665750876, 0.0568314679, 0.0491648205, -0.0061339848, -0.0283481348, 0.0135926716, 0.0088298051, -0.0257481728, -0.0100082848, 0.0261913054, 0.0065990365, 0.0605021678, 0.0183525868, 0.0646673068, -0.0048138103, -0.0002636306, 0.0018261531, -0.0493684858, 0.0181824397, 0.0075696679, 0.0479876697, 0.0238987468, 0.0612626225, -0.0291366354, -0.0178525615, -0.0155448588, -0.0005284783, -0.0268727858, -0.02210523, 0.0115096569, -0.0005707155, -0.0166207533, -0.0465562008, -0.0097842477, -0.0366253778, 0.0350103751, -0.0823477805, -0.0060583567, 0.0014199424, 2.962e-7, 0.0091900239, -0.0069802972, 0.0164624099, -0.0212685019, 0.0062052598, 0.0805757195, 0.0213197954, 0.0167890247, -0.0071509737, -0.0609177761, 0.0012352534, 0.0606305785, 0.0784692764, 0.0305848699, -0.0379218571, -0.0095105981, -0.0370866247, -0.0275845956, -0.0015235489, 0.0206635483, 0.0749830753, 0.0804326534, 0.0381803662, -0.0161234159, 0.0180555563, -0.0270613432, 0.0149556696, -0.0221359432, -0.0038989845, 0.0105720283, 0.0961400047, 0.0039608227, 0.0001722918, 0.0311925635, -0.0232527405, -0.0078034843, -0.0265178755, 0.0675194934, -0.0231443644, -0.0314921364, -0.054900948, -0.0346880741, 0.0509694628, -0.0165216625, 0.0780501366, -0.0015425113, -0.0491434522, -0.0654894114, -0.0302935168, -0.0042380351, 0.014488793, 0.0026654215, -0.0011734894, -0.0026749107, 0.0038189569, 0.0043087443, 0.0055084345, -0.0658768192, -0.0303131882, 0.0359533988, -0.0171124674, 0.0116733396, 0.0094032427, 0.0090087466, 0.0717087686, -0.0316918716, 0.0448140427, 2.431025862e-34, 0.0131384786, 0.0300615281, -0.0097279968, 0.0044650524, 0.0670798644, 0.0254705232, -0.0222717728, -0.0101385545, 0.0508713163, -0.018634025, -0.0198436882 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.05948v3
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.05948v3
tasksource: A Dataset Harmonization Framework for Streamlined NLP Multi-Task Learning and Evaluation
2023-01-14T16:38:04
2023-05-16T08:19:44
Damien Sileo
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7
The HuggingFace Datasets Hub hosts thousands of datasets, offering exciting opportunities for language model training and evaluation. However, datasets for a specific task type often have different schemas, making harmonization challenging. Multi-task training or evaluation necessitates manual work to fit data into task templates. Several initiatives independently tackle this issue by releasing harmonized datasets or providing harmonization codes to preprocess datasets into a consistent format. We identify patterns across previous preprocessing efforts, such as column name mapping and extracting specific sub-fields from structured data in a column. We then propose a structured annotation framework that ensures our annotations are fully exposed and not hidden within unstructured code. We release a dataset annotation framework and dataset annotations for more than 500 English tasks\footnote{\url{https://github.com/sileod/tasksource}}. These annotations include metadata, such as the names of columns to be used as input or labels for all datasets, which can save time for future dataset preprocessing, regardless of whether our framework is utilized. We fine-tune a multi-task text encoder on all tasksource tasks, outperforming every publicly available text encoder of comparable size in an external evaluation.
[ 0.0029680829, 0.0198038835, -0.0179024599, 0.0338850543, -0.0130312359, 0.046968352, 0.0007203628, -0.0336124003, -0.0177283622, -0.0325717814, -0.0474675521, 0.0135954386, -0.0031949216, 0.0283387192, 0.0489672609, -0.0330449156, 0.0177364256, -0.0176506452, -0.0229886025, 0.0292033516, 0.033025831, 0.0302290972, -0.0021053124, 0.063159585, -0.0260480661, -0.0191275608, -0.0128419446, 0.0123241255, 0.0184588376, -0.0104223117, 0.0435735993, 0.0674868748, 0.0345771424, 0.0114402771, 0.0000019101, -0.0206241179, -0.0270617381, 0.0012002557, -0.0288452692, -0.0447415486, 0.0573058724, -0.0414445177, 0.0170823466, 0.0065213735, -0.0478922538, -0.0504488498, 0.0637703091, 0.0511730835, 0.0669999048, 0.0655518994, -0.0225185417, 0.0091863666, 0.0022108869, -0.0217955466, -0.0231321529, -0.0032186308, 0.0129427547, 0.0168810375, -0.0133851264, 0.025344776, 0.0312021095, 0.0130184814, 0.0139266513, -0.0197876077, 0.0088087777, 0.0056176982, -0.0616610684, -0.0209623165, -0.023587808, 0.0797283351, -0.0095381811, -0.0232579205, 0.0018425307, 0.0058420305, -0.0205570925, -0.0043475046, -0.0550589748, 0.0036573529, -0.0062482827, 0.0124423988, 0.0537893251, -0.0130477799, 0.0015392628, -0.025248671, 0.0413416214, 0.0564791486, -0.0066631916, -0.0127721708, 0.0159735493, 0.032441169, -0.0183951501, -0.0539406054, 0.0144342361, -0.0060491571, -0.0342999361, 0.0118721174, -0.0626654848, -0.0882313177, 0.0164511651, -0.0181512237, 0.0581655391, 0.0163717531, -0.0330603495, 0.0132325822, -0.0090961521, 0.0269002654, 0.0151902372, 0.0095750019, -0.0373329483, -0.0238217879, -0.0778661966, 0.0150636444, -0.0605775751, 0.0161156878, -0.0394420102, 0.0128339175, -0.0032123767, 0.0016074498, -0.0531131402, 0.0283836611, 0.1059846878, -0.0176763423, -0.0600874163, 0.0173264164, 0.0005030049, 0.045756422, -0.0268106889, 0.0422937088, -0.0063569499, -0.0538608171, -0.0459197573, -0.0011560273, 0.0334427357, -0.0455124117, -0.0026866116, 0.0276516061, -0.0049767639, -0.0215028431, -0.0310332607, -0.0192792118, -0.0035500091, -0.0325723477, 0.0043480392, -0.0780664235, 0.0645165816, -0.0041668597, 0.0096042519, -0.0330694243, -0.0019358941, 0.0261235479, -0.0018116318, 0.0914295614, -0.037454322, -0.012940689, -0.0172678977, -0.0159595795, -0.0364863984, 0.1093289256, 0.0125722317, 0.0101156486, 0.0381988138, -0.0053598066, -0.0214115288, 0.0533553921, 0.0130219674, 0.0169887282, 0.0384911634, 0.0220025256, 0.0452835523, -0.0208620019, 0.0150833772, 0.0048746369, -0.0165579207, 0.0406126343, 0.0309221502, 0.0446387678, -0.0008506872, -0.0269623138, 0.0357635766, 0.0393386185, -0.0031749166, -0.0165752675, -0.0088509219, 0.0099518597, -0.0075896461, -0.0083721876, -0.0239177607, 0.0446732305, -0.0241254866, -0.0228333101, -0.0354325585, -0.0247142054, 0.0196438115, 0.0068311375, 0.0403968692, 0.048879303, -0.0397879295, 0.0200540554, 0.0302885454, -0.0634809583, 0.0027482652, 0.0142710265, -0.0192427319, 0.05637528, 0.0235561375, -0.0479734614, -0.0829280987, -0.0371570699, 0.0539933816, -0.0010539711, 0.0087201856, -0.0678853095, 0.0278662629, -0.0511881374, -0.0191022176, -0.0242714118, 0.0086374562, -0.0130684758, 0.009503155, -0.0293831285, -0.0158830248, -0.0399642587, -0.0315658264, 0.0430458374, -0.0372168832, -0.012545364, 0.0221689101, 0.0088356175, 0.0297145043, 0.0438999981, 0.009753339, -0.0121322414, 0.0555058718, -0.0287741683, 0.005508495, 0.01474417, 0.0206159987, -0.0377235413, 0.0151251312, -0.0316137113, -0.0403774604, 0.0360571109, -0.0539909936, -0.0486360155, -0.0329406448, 0.0084532043, -0.019089669, 0.0141935861, 0.0056265946, 0.000258723, 0.0051479363, -0.0117664393, 0.038895037, 0.0186084975, 0.0169097353, -0.0154467588, -0.032422252, 0.0017684551, -0.0269868094, -0.0228704587, 0.009934484, -0.0076545016, -0.0149670383, 0.017017534, 0.031722486, -0.0537231266, -0.0108648725, -0.1048736572, 0.0376914404, -0.0295136888, 0.0599081144, 0.0497880653, 0.0071527162, -0.0024976549, -0.0096388832, -0.0327135995, -0.0109587787, 0.0006338555, 0.0026510458, 0.0334741175, -0.02690107, 0.0166890733, -0.024562072, -0.0014109955, -0.0074088913, 0.0241148081, -0.022860853, -0.0328831822, -0.0457723439, 0.0373416767, 0.0170887988, 0.0090983547, 0.0145235797, -0.0010237952, -0.0045434469, 0.0069503239, 0.0632135794, 0.0409924984, -0.0550998114, 0.0433424376, 0.0157991573, -0.0191051643, -0.0322446935, 0.013890232, -0.0065634325, 0.0115937395, -0.045309905, -0.0300911553, -0.0098781232, 0.0498998798, -0.0190578289, -0.0217690617, -0.0488501005, -0.0017525275, -0.0228642952, -0.0201030225, -0.0094007952, -0.0112928636, 0.0032554562, 0.0220767166, -0.0440198071, -0.0086919889, 0.0625536293, -0.0220548175, -0.0332645699, -0.0687131807, 0.006396045, -0.0401259437, 0.1070424691, -0.033810921, -0.0184359588, 0.0393661819, -0.017501425, -0.0081226313, 0.0470022187, 0.013675916, -0.0126626873, 0.0560051389, -0.0574172996, 0.004098549, -0.0568289272, -0.0348123163, -0.0087212035, 0.0087053739, -0.0378695987, 0.0319602229, 0.0264660437, -0.0129368966, -0.0180004202, -0.0140133286, -0.0111416392, 0.0603890903, -0.032764785, 0.0051474967, -0.0286241788, 0.0136752119, 0.032414116, 0.0306990389, -0.0512554459, -0.0054441825, -0.0047657005, 0.023093354, 0.0399027839, -0.0100630196, 0.0142363543, 0.0222671106, 0.063586168, -0.027066363, -0.0249345582, -0.0149408523, 0.0491266735, -0.0622659139, -0.0251566023, 0.1067833304, 0.0222055446, -0.0169534553, -0.0017319965, -0.0041059973, 0.0351595171, 0.0335770845, 0.0056834556, -0.1035918817, -0.0431184173, 0.0281769186, 0.0087215826, 0.0273835193, -0.0296591669, -0.0101603968, -0.0855788365, 0.0287453756, -0.0141643379, -0.0300770402, 0.0027807562, -0.075610362, 0.0074804625, -0.0744400248, 0.0179353412, -0.0356475152, 0.0129291927, 0.0219493732, 0.0364802219, 0.0144721242, -0.0671161041, 0.0076300339, -0.0622059144, 0.0751912445, 0.0462086797, 0.0408698879, 0.0046087834, -0.008302683, -0.0219239201, 0.0338373035, -0.0470327064, -0.0104300128, 0.0628725067, -0.0276635271, -0.019169027, 0.0067653195, 0.0344548859, -0.0854833052, -0.0079411315, 0.0371286906, 0.069447659, -0.0035961692, 0.0483467653, 0.0351580642, -0.0431693792, 0.0563999675, 0.0820844248, -0.0008776019, -0.0100526847, 0.0107215876, -0.0287903491, -0.0108231707, -0.070083417, -0.0248914938, 0.0339186639, -0.0347411968, -0.0124122854, -0.0551206768, -0.0594211966, 0.1047967821, 0.0514507741, 0.0450744852, 0.0216131527, 0.0278445724, -0.0077385842, -0.0933660641, 0.0346555822, -0.0115563376, 0.0223235935, -0.0087081157, -0.0644368753, 0.0244935472, 0.0126728127, -0.001669795, 0.0362787619, -0.1025261059, -0.0245761462, -0.0248451754, 0.0210362151, 0.0137937842, 0.027006682, -0.0103495205, -0.0253402777, -0.042744685, -0.0037274552, -0.0598400533, -0.0369380265, 0.0472868942, -0.0415904, 0.0260914098, 0.0433113165, -0.0205768012, -0.0006136464, -0.0174179096, 0.0443310477, 0.0161541477, -0.0101709552, 0.0158443395, 0.0051555121, 0.0483849794, -0.0015184629, -0.0275775492, -0.068553485, 0.0128161302, -0.0463334024, -0.0449813195, -0.04434181, 0.0413118713, 0.0185232107, -0.0048037842, -0.003411924, 0.1117999405, -0.0047684927, 0.0516245142, -0.0777609795, 0.0618070476, 0.0200669058, -0.0011747074, -0.0105981501, 0.0116072819, -0.0169938058, -0.0308809672, 0.0193964913, 0.003205555, -0.0302134901, 0.0036058838, 0.0177121386, 0.0035400453, 0.0198657811, 0.0600164384, -0.0221794453, 0.0058709653, -0.0315914042, -0.024957642, 0.0288943462, -0.0312749408, 0.1067939773, -0.0069764983, -0.0112947905, -0.0014589045, 0.0390742607, -0.0076107089, -0.018658692, 0.0234227665, 0.0054125008, -0.0276309215, -0.0235600695, 0.1087166071, -0.0228675492, 0.0420107022, 0.0284193121, -0.0060992949, -0.0352662094, -0.0436271727, 0.0273121372, 0.0154572083, -0.0106020933, -0.0159661043, -0.0056524514, -0.0502998531, 0.0057658982, -0.0228101071, -0.0187892765, 0.0110200122, 0.0435691997, 0.0308739841, -0.008169123, -0.0063119289, -0.0353827775, -0.0259441491, 0.0056213285, -0.0406339653, -0.0510065146, -5.882745316e-33, -0.0362200253, 0.0121629126, 0.0074114474, -0.0071982616, 0.0002513535, 0.0294762459, -0.0106503265, -0.0260904543, -0.0008277422, 0.0010499447, -0.0069765458, 0.0049646311, 0.0272416659, 0.0344737656, 0.02585751, -0.0277577378, 0.0391208045, -0.0258118268, -0.0067700897, 0.0167154018, 0.0361195281, 0.0148261758, 0.1005131006, -0.0731440634, 0.0763570219, 0.0174754467, -0.025268903, 0.0083209537, 0.049511373, 0.069531925, -0.0133468611, 0.059950985, 0.0234267302, -0.0790327787, -0.030048836, 0.038777031, -0.1178206801, -0.0107265739, 0.0276282951, 0.02026885, -0.0291449483, -0.0228945985, 0.0027751792, -0.0003034356, -0.0034917265, 0.0106388777, 0.0329353213, -0.0386102758, 0.0150044234, -0.0217800029, -0.065901421, -0.0064771445, -0.0063794013, -0.0387472212, 0.071790874, 0.0529882461, 0.0174945183, -0.0337295234, -0.0629156455, 0.0135158096, -0.0380442068, 0.0476333871, 0.0564915799, 0.0059654675, 0.0169546828, 0.0396895744, -0.0014124685, 0.0293165259, -0.0047424566, 0.0116704302, 0.0044837664, 0.0458000377, 0.0147758499, 0.0185720865, -0.0069458587, -0.0044611632, -0.028487619, 0.0389286466, 0.0410108529, 0.0045930273, -0.0060791536, 0.0098865256, -0.0099290293, -0.031702619, -0.0357384533, 0.0046681222, 0.0017672175, -0.0000545327, 0.0237656161, -0.007831512, 0.0035298439, 0.0796408206, 0.0083543491, -0.0261961725, -0.0087819993, 0.0492273644, 0.0058946782, 0.0221322477, 0.00817471, 0.0147630181, -0.0287365485, -0.0307689533, 0.0583929867, 0.0394610018, 0.0342491679, -0.0078947274, 0.0934351012, 0.0218677614, -0.0544760115, 0.0036010346, -0.0521474779, 0.0502962694, -0.0156807527, 0.072500661, 0.0395285748, -0.0027299202, -0.0095211705, 0.0344090201, 0.0513286702, -0.0226724595, -0.0548094213, 0.0168058518, 0.0002282819, -0.0079330439, 0.0097793918, 0.0057736649, -0.0590732992, -0.0419979952, 0.0270196144, -0.0157944728, -0.007692527, 0.0018150626, 2.525e-7, 0.0347813219, 0.0652313828, 0.0277384166, 0.010309861, 0.0173959062, 0.0133786174, -0.0264333393, 0.0565509647, -0.0171405077, -0.0233159754, -0.0040225917, -0.0100479135, 0.0610832497, 0.0345311016, -0.0999975055, -0.0687616542, -0.0316259749, 0.0021865261, -0.043872606, 0.0145061063, 0.0379708484, 0.0889226347, 0.0217484087, 0.0273801312, -0.0103635471, 0.0264528487, 0.0119847441, -0.0334731676, 0.0247004908, 0.0349616036, -0.0268998761, 0.0070232572, -0.0203539692, 0.0396131985, -0.0468545631, 0.0179921575, 0.0223813821, 0.0690706745, -0.0122932373, -0.0215509739, -0.0210493971, -0.0353438817, -0.0063214097, -0.0336825848, 0.0821903273, -0.0354630649, -0.0705835447, -0.0021582514, -0.0166215021, 0.0478849858, -0.0425678752, 0.0086136525, -0.0047966582, 0.0326301195, 0.0523413345, -0.0188710727, -0.0442207754, -0.0622978806, -0.027979061, 0.0358936898, -0.0209857915, -0.0424391776, -0.003798431, -0.019523887, -0.0223610252, -0.088521868, -0.0007295373, 2.70379703e-34, -0.0019379737, -0.0005266335, 0.0207660962, 0.0363393165, 0.0228904095, -0.0497738384, -0.0372999385, -0.011326517, -0.0048820646, -0.0480544977, -0.0318788067 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.05880v3
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.05880v3
TikTalk: A Video-Based Dialogue Dataset for Multi-Modal Chitchat in Real World
2023-01-14T10:18:22
2023-09-08T10:03:16
Hongpeng Lin, Ludan Ruan, Wenke Xia, Peiyu Liu, Jingyuan Wen, Yixin Xu, Di Hu, Ruihua Song, Wayne Xin Zhao, Qin Jin, Zhiwu Lu
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI
To facilitate the research on intelligent and human-like chatbots with multi-modal context, we introduce a new video-based multi-modal dialogue dataset, called TikTalk. We collect 38K videos from a popular video-sharing platform, along with 367K conversations posted by users beneath them. Users engage in spontaneous conversations based on their multi-modal experiences from watching videos, which helps recreate real-world chitchat context. Compared to previous multi-modal dialogue datasets, the richer context types in TikTalk lead to more diverse conversations, but also increase the difficulty in capturing human interests from intricate multi-modal information to generate personalized responses. Moreover, external knowledge is more frequently evoked in our dataset. These facts reveal new challenges for multi-modal dialogue models. We quantitatively demonstrate the characteristics of TikTalk, propose a video-based multi-modal chitchat task, and evaluate several dialogue baselines. Experimental results indicate that the models incorporating large language models (LLM) can generate more diverse responses, while the model utilizing knowledge graphs to introduce external knowledge performs the best overall. Furthermore, no existing model can solve all the above challenges well. There is still a large room for future improvements, even for LLM with visual extensions. Our dataset is available at \url{https://ruc-aimind.github.io/projects/TikTalk/}.
[ 0.0606829561, 0.0212333351, -0.0134314913, 0.0180590395, -0.0136476671, -0.000302726, -0.015085605, 0.0094585838, 0.0177758727, -0.0710131973, -0.0487981737, -0.020274112, -0.0169238709, 0.0880246609, 0.0280870665, -0.0741007701, 0.022724608, -0.0333320014, 0.0354508311, -0.0048316135, 0.0447605141, 0.0194037389, -0.0264319535, 0.056011904, -0.0803242177, -0.014305749, -0.0343381278, 0.026623087, 0.003928496, -0.0210560244, 0.0152048664, 0.0384005979, 0.0557579324, 0.0167526994, 0.0000017777, 0.0005854204, 0.0279826038, -0.0513638854, 0.0063741198, -0.0303737875, 0.0492660925, 0.0039363899, 0.0041063954, 0.026788339, -0.0873580724, 0.0165531561, 0.0545779765, 0.0268658437, 0.0526254289, 0.0569204018, -0.0279210452, -0.014339691, 0.0093941884, -0.0025982871, 0.0519025289, -0.043058496, -0.013005916, 0.0279516876, 0.05108466, 0.0237997472, -0.042411577, 0.0298691355, 0.0186243355, -0.0551961549, 0.0427710526, 0.035804715, -0.0446656086, -0.0463550836, -0.0342466161, 0.1360911131, 0.0291778073, 0.028192563, -0.0107574575, 0.0235111006, 0.0417362675, -0.0154016623, -0.074337244, 0.0034836589, -0.0047656004, -0.0046990467, -0.0545519181, 0.0153654953, -0.0056594196, 0.0009201624, 0.0323635489, -0.0038764253, 0.0029835782, 0.000718859, -0.030850783, -0.0213255491, 0.0249697044, -0.0758108646, -0.0134175047, 0.0322314091, -0.0169357695, 0.0190683864, -0.0486976206, 0.0337312259, -0.002283266, -0.0094395615, -0.0175807793, 0.0360181816, -0.0522844046, 0.0626160502, 0.0292447712, 0.0367510989, -0.0142307514, 0.0153150214, -0.0238074958, -0.0415277407, -0.0645986721, -0.0028757502, -0.0176086184, 0.0164395906, -0.0545320995, -0.0477388725, -0.0095164888, 0.0570619702, -0.0128192948, 0.0024424063, -0.0250730906, 0.0486983024, -0.0149431312, 0.0003315156, -0.049701862, 0.0136415744, -0.0500999875, 0.0360780619, 0.0212366786, -0.0898703262, -0.0115255769, 0.0184746198, 0.0205324739, -0.0255852658, 0.0159231797, 0.0490846559, -0.0214478057, -0.0525431409, 0.0691842809, -0.0047290535, -0.0479681902, -0.0309793316, 0.0095228665, -0.0505790152, 0.0770943537, -0.0037833927, -0.0116192298, -0.0066132601, 0.0060585174, 0.0096771782, -0.051421959, 0.0849374086, -0.0335649811, 0.0403226949, 0.0147427293, 0.0320062824, -0.0255670473, 0.0457285903, 0.0028877391, 0.0193709619, 0.0469798297, 0.0157679934, 0.0204179045, 0.0187716279, -0.0216461625, 0.0122525087, -0.0112774437, 0.0444330461, 0.0088250935, 0.0407295488, 0.0241753031, 0.0296519212, -0.0586129874, -0.036284849, 0.0774238855, 0.0649131164, -0.0503718518, -0.019521866, 0.0122848488, 0.0563833043, 0.0335357301, -0.0133398464, -0.0317364484, 0.0664590225, -0.0313116349, -0.0278687347, 0.0499828942, 0.0296564996, -0.0620579123, -0.005348824, 0.0121769169, -0.0205130447, 0.065873608, 0.0121920649, 0.0447178558, 0.0015693923, -0.0165369865, 0.0203970093, 0.0223562382, -0.0260394644, -0.03328076, -0.0209597927, 0.0220285486, 0.0785222799, 0.0218499694, -0.0284345951, -0.0588191748, -0.0055341227, 0.0011330141, 0.0238763765, 0.0493192747, -0.0348935537, 0.0421649367, -0.0636550337, -0.0217270032, -0.0234137755, -0.0032512171, 0.0271702074, 0.0105695212, -0.0019282274, -0.0157304965, 0.022762021, 0.0384991877, 0.0110855568, 0.0209341664, 0.0317534581, -0.0198070649, -0.0194797534, 0.0279028602, 0.0380903035, 0.0022804381, -0.0144658256, 0.0286493115, -0.0118047083, 0.0097865071, 0.0583360121, -0.0446667075, -0.0575579964, 0.0708770677, -0.0610181466, -0.0360344164, 0.0170937143, -0.0238786656, -0.0407034494, 0.0617401339, -0.0281518064, 0.0181931984, -0.0528807379, -0.0097092474, 0.0245622974, 0.0359462276, 0.0061982903, 0.0470133983, 0.0025222762, -0.0316102318, 0.0528739765, 0.017817352, -0.0169543438, -0.0324675255, -0.0113005741, 0.0191676728, -0.0007713441, 0.0205026586, 0.0112487944, 0.0182062071, -0.0744050816, -0.0499753766, -0.1281421185, -0.0009433557, 0.009939272, -0.0372109115, 0.0077538169, 0.0010227516, -0.0040738238, -0.0444653854, -0.0589321963, 0.0422352664, 0.0341771357, 0.0220203195, 0.0145612685, 0.0135754161, -0.0003578301, -0.0324889906, 0.0086884676, 0.0253213942, 0.0339126512, 0.0045131319, -0.0030845942, 0.0313541964, -0.0238711722, -0.0439707898, 0.0431578755, -0.0563546233, -0.0451406762, 0.037302807, -0.0214289557, 0.0222042743, 0.0177819002, 0.047649771, 0.0272596404, -0.0175457709, -0.0396376066, -0.07235232, 0.0227972902, 0.0048862314, 0.0026681619, -0.0459684543, -0.0359809101, -0.024702182, 0.0003049519, -0.0081127835, 0.0387569331, -0.0886350572, 0.0670301095, 0.0620014854, -0.0485964678, -0.0553754903, -0.0059073679, -0.0162281264, 0.0406740457, -0.0288297888, -0.0452914275, 0.0505564213, -0.0000894382, -0.0246246438, 0.0236376897, -0.0041306634, -0.0212811809, 0.0976500288, -0.0114993174, 0.0148503631, -0.0079913484, 0.0039873556, -0.0592826977, -0.010645506, 0.0052189864, -0.0344464183, 0.0345080979, -0.0274221841, -0.0062203035, 0.0113710715, -0.0404144078, -0.0443051457, -0.0772029534, -0.0252009388, -0.0122303953, -0.0180302914, -0.008340721, -0.0216961727, 0.0145138633, 0.0243004914, -0.0191500448, -0.002345748, 0.0150191579, -0.0067447359, 0.0239691176, 0.0687154308, 0.0381139368, -0.0377868153, -0.0181147214, 0.0538792387, 0.0457924083, 0.0318134613, -0.0110596661, -0.0046728621, 0.0118071288, 0.0112009551, 0.0661202371, -0.0331218913, -0.0051071011, 0.0595475435, 0.0078376578, -0.0022580975, 0.0928775072, -0.0087534869, -0.0464498177, 0.0054781986, -0.017552793, 0.0104402592, 0.0295338854, 0.0312042367, -0.0697124302, -0.0390082449, -0.0052357595, -0.0281561762, -0.0082538752, -0.0431950353, -0.0132679483, -0.1158095077, 0.006352684, 0.0000303868, -0.054165639, -0.0551055297, 0.0276794322, 0.016964715, 0.0044388263, -0.011685133, 0.0009587522, -0.0035679168, -0.0032381013, -0.0075696292, 0.0087129278, -0.061367169, 0.0558035821, -0.0319259912, 0.0934650153, 0.0357834063, 0.042881418, 0.0076958062, 0.0005929526, 0.0001528823, 0.0260292105, -0.0017811412, 0.013692176, 0.0467868187, -0.0311428253, -0.0083209686, -0.0026244947, 0.021773167, 0.0004098161, -0.0102444738, 0.0098752677, 0.0261575337, -0.0413480587, 0.0296748262, -0.028090002, 0.0325892456, 0.0343320966, 0.0663358495, 0.0203894731, -0.0456848741, -0.0100778891, -0.026793493, -0.053839419, -0.0159640163, -0.0235065073, 0.0149011118, 0.005729666, -0.0199184231, -0.0736649483, -0.0434526801, 0.0429493003, 0.0022494362, -0.019306967, 0.0121642258, -0.0188311581, 0.0292412229, -0.0097755734, 0.0575137287, -0.023262037, -0.0178235862, -0.0236737523, -0.0281720757, 0.0240982566, -0.1049051955, 0.0107128881, 0.0147415474, -0.0575225577, -0.0564449281, -0.0368194431, 0.0588111952, 0.0230964497, 0.0653290302, -0.0040068841, -0.0198264178, -0.0121814571, 0.0111776879, -0.0242737923, -0.010745191, 0.0102577843, 0.0182134602, 0.0005284431, 0.0478398912, -0.0512178577, 0.0151533289, -0.0189821608, 0.0138680236, -0.0612331778, -0.0779131651, 0.000079009, -0.0197034497, -0.0006493127, 0.0026816542, -0.0411998667, -0.0151368752, -0.0239018165, -0.0087727569, 0.0047716666, -0.0773732513, 0.0146880513, 0.013900999, -0.0278960671, -0.0016617742, -0.0337261073, -0.0322482884, 0.0043215486, -0.0337184668, -0.0269766971, 0.0354461297, -0.0148020936, 0.0130543429, -0.0006833797, 0.0137944147, 0.0478630699, -0.0307334289, -0.0131290071, 0.005725353, 0.0651570261, -0.0066937315, -0.0752598047, 0.0143167889, 0.0579998679, -0.0537613854, -0.0123575442, 0.0287327748, 0.0500010662, 0.0344635807, 0.0408597291, 0.0141288294, -0.0288361367, 0.0033712904, -0.0135957366, 0.0694445074, 0.0061652823, -0.0551919751, 0.0488806888, 0.0148580447, -0.0271512121, 0.0111912591, 0.0652634054, -0.0210833959, 0.0174807217, 0.0039984221, -0.0047343615, -0.0190645922, 0.0269038789, 0.0230506454, 0.0583713166, 0.0019621118, 0.0485571474, -0.0446650088, -0.0488615856, -0.0059240232, 0.0027885954, -0.0164100733, 0.0140461642, 0.0588424578, 0.0539214686, -0.0002576444, 0.0214531496, -0.0357400142, -0.002143292, -0.0293358862, -0.019273201, -0.0024129266, -5.906194959e-33, -0.0179478005, -0.0294664297, 0.0261273086, -0.0077233454, -0.0441362225, -0.0083188461, -0.0161185376, -0.0002864389, -0.0350271761, -0.0100142593, -0.0206051432, 0.0404359438, -0.0081577273, 0.0260738898, 0.0202449001, -0.0313886814, 0.0213581324, -0.0080684545, 0.0121680973, 0.034291856, 0.0427751206, 0.0159465801, 0.040269576, -0.0752413049, 0.0065133702, -0.009018912, -0.0141967004, 0.0251694825, 0.0289906505, 0.0655760467, -0.0340557508, 0.0415059589, 0.0139683709, 0.0001435972, -0.0300048646, 0.0278263465, -0.0461106971, 0.002625091, 0.012687589, -0.0038367771, -0.0386477113, -0.0222198255, 0.0002355178, -0.0313520245, 0.0004835231, -0.0048714085, 0.0206365157, -0.0366965495, 0.0128741618, 0.0408489667, -0.0260998718, 0.0195640922, -0.0222916827, -0.0887687728, -0.0108347544, 0.0633277372, 0.0350781269, -0.0090842666, -0.0297660567, 0.0790863484, -0.0382578485, -0.0359579735, 0.0622499585, 0.0077932468, 0.0481817499, 0.0859827772, 0.0458572395, 0.0018011321, -0.0109729012, -0.0578743778, -0.0204666015, 0.0922745317, -0.003452321, 0.062846005, -0.0047866451, -0.0315955654, -0.024087552, 0.0304848049, 0.0338099673, -0.0031690099, 0.0236092713, 0.0116202272, -0.0088579506, 0.0129720103, -0.0145395417, 0.0051648216, -0.0403081998, -0.0270599481, 0.0036526094, 0.0232219938, 0.0140456492, -0.0304617211, 0.0621929355, -0.0477682948, 0.0525140539, 0.0275440589, -0.0381022729, 0.021994045, 0.0126502495, 0.0125977369, -0.0117492294, -0.0178451966, 0.0669910088, -0.0176008511, 0.0004200731, 0.0576074459, -0.015391876, 0.0174119249, -0.0073326319, -0.0269662533, -0.0170087311, 0.0481209345, -0.0408985056, 0.0074692266, 0.0377305113, 0.0467074327, -0.0639712065, 0.0387304649, -0.0046367645, 0.021161234, -0.0219977312, -0.072780937, 0.0031131769, -0.0099986931, -0.0156747289, 0.0268387031, -0.0467726886, -0.0696347579, -0.010192153, -0.0086306389, -0.0152007472, 0.0218367614, 2.591e-7, -0.0281191133, 0.0208931305, 0.0045832726, 0.0119378446, 0.0293542705, 0.0640610456, -0.0097663412, 0.0573232993, 0.0015279967, -0.0705545247, 0.01575399, 0.0450085737, 0.0512899831, -0.0073290667, -0.0561662503, -0.0400038846, -0.04918769, -0.0278110933, -0.021830298, 0.0113497917, 0.0546025895, 0.0837307721, 0.0078435875, -0.0095920851, 0.0077238949, -0.0338223912, 0.0677554682, -0.0274241697, -0.0605778061, -0.0039918767, 0.0254076067, -0.0050650556, -0.0043499749, 0.0216058902, 0.0155214621, -0.0038616995, 0.0317520984, 0.0437054411, -0.016790675, -0.0746322498, -0.0077363905, 0.0269378684, -0.0290862508, -0.0188416727, 0.0692464337, -0.0141067784, -0.0277105235, -0.0194885377, 0.0128904879, -0.0017922181, 0.027216522, -0.0330178328, -0.0196843203, 0.0101906545, 0.0048906305, -0.0243212804, 0.0022979798, -0.0925794467, 0.0132825775, -0.0264646467, -0.0886708945, -0.0525404252, -0.0210943315, -0.0145615786, 0.0343173817, 0.0116865663, -0.0143084945, 1.657566765e-34, 0.0177015308, 0.0114698578, -0.011460294, 0.0058345413, 0.0111870561, -0.0010084241, -0.0192092899, -0.0184279196, 0.0445568785, -0.0683612078, -0.0136336843 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.05863v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.05863v1
Detecting Stance of Authorities towards Rumors in Arabic Tweets: A Preliminary Study
2023-01-14T09:28:43
2023-01-14T09:28:43
Fatima Haouari, Tamer Elsayed
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.SI
A myriad of studies addressed the problem of rumor verification in Twitter by either utilizing evidence from the propagation networks or external evidence from the Web. However, none of these studies exploited evidence from trusted authorities. In this paper, we define the task of detecting the stance of authorities towards rumors in tweets, i.e., whether a tweet from an authority agrees, disagrees, or is unrelated to the rumor. We believe the task is useful to augment the sources of evidence utilized by existing rumor verification systems. We construct and release the first Authority STance towards Rumors (AuSTR) dataset, where evidence is retrieved from authority timelines in Arabic Twitter. Due to the relatively limited size of our dataset, we study the usefulness of existing datasets for stance detection in our task. We show that existing datasets are somewhat useful for the task; however, they are clearly insufficient, which motivates the need to augment them with annotated data constituting stance of authorities from Twitter.
[ 0.059475679, 0.0373935215, 0.0183311459, 0.0199679155, -0.0424182527, 0.0015292463, 0.0375815816, -0.0184659865, -0.0306183845, 0.0034286929, 0.0146002937, -0.0459083878, 0.0164259244, 0.0329422355, -0.0171815567, 0.0284492075, 0.0250106491, 0.0129040508, 0.0852058604, -0.0423623212, 0.0830180272, 0.0690766349, -0.0385779887, 0.0303644333, -0.0291271843, 0.0036775747, -0.0011115142, -0.0185745303, 0.0465944968, -0.0034129955, -0.0017376476, 0.0330122113, 0.0352292173, 0.0198488235, 0.0000014321, -0.0202391762, -0.0326529257, -0.0243409891, -0.0229862016, -0.0157689657, -0.0016915438, -0.0528536998, -0.0086209653, 0.0235512033, -0.031397514, -0.010871294, 0.0394713096, 0.0243869871, 0.083834447, 0.0843448862, -0.0073161437, -0.0144840134, -0.0216055904, -0.0280195158, -0.0043233167, -0.048466038, 0.0417329594, -0.0171846654, -0.0808852836, 0.0680877343, 0.0332980715, -0.0100521324, 0.0035923568, -0.0308262836, -0.0414650366, -0.0159616638, -0.0202056449, -0.0455125719, 0.018697029, -0.007767472, 0.0601460822, -0.0745149255, -0.0046989662, 0.0103616426, 0.0031475641, 0.0588115454, 0.0244888067, 0.060509786, -0.0539008975, 0.0386095084, 0.0349891856, 0.0165692288, -0.0051748995, 0.0449051484, 0.0013854213, 0.0565925166, -0.0408199877, -0.0388422348, 0.0265322793, 0.0388423912, -0.0189577099, -0.0567626767, 0.0262464155, -0.0191775281, -0.0316551886, 0.0314254425, -0.0211059377, 0.0181022715, 0.044046659, -0.0953147784, -0.0673788935, 0.0324430987, 0.0024633254, 0.063731052, -0.0249270927, -0.0766911507, -0.0201323889, -0.0157060903, 0.0408918671, -0.0164903793, -0.0212972611, 0.0531171933, 0.0109625785, -0.011794785, -0.0224595889, 0.0631355345, -0.0520248078, -0.0069864942, -0.0163112078, 0.0302604251, -0.0046490026, -0.0249774531, 0.0041323882, -0.0150768878, -0.0324400216, 0.0310263615, -0.0110440133, 0.021764366, -0.0286550056, -0.0193798412, -0.0045971372, -0.0075195259, 0.0309351943, 0.0330681317, -0.0037882242, -0.0162416901, 0.0263346396, 0.0115775401, -0.028966127, -0.018216189, -0.0049620196, -0.0363031924, -0.0226497725, -0.0609229207, 0.0213749707, 0.0069238073, -0.0101795234, 0.0052317083, 0.0213578697, 0.0521988794, 0.0090150489, 0.0521546602, -0.0288864225, -0.0062047215, 0.0390954837, 0.0337611847, 0.0068209348, 0.0870730579, -0.0141974324, 0.0687643215, 0.0317218527, 0.0485454947, -0.0368634127, 0.0126883443, 0.0701870099, 0.0259498805, 0.0280697811, -0.0200485662, -0.0477588624, -0.0301118214, -0.051608365, 0.0071645239, -0.0149559518, -0.0122578312, 0.0315674059, -0.039985206, -0.0671971887, -0.0402839966, -0.0033289252, 0.0217082053, 0.0143154347, -0.0150548238, -0.0128994742, 0.0177498087, -0.0283478089, -0.0250612833, 0.0115593793, 0.0544792414, -0.0024981145, -0.0479889326, -0.0054187966, 0.0319055431, -0.0029487491, -0.0205310993, 0.0164229088, -0.0268835779, -0.0267247166, -0.0071805324, 0.0311430413, -0.0030444909, -0.0239500478, -0.0401857942, -0.0023531425, 0.0017896917, -0.0250320099, 0.0388458259, -0.0158123374, -0.0233028829, 0.0459528193, 0.0476745032, 0.0034712094, -0.024089979, -0.0246789474, -0.0062736403, -0.0154673513, 0.0269729346, 0.0165184624, -0.0148105286, 0.0550324395, 0.0696983114, -0.0526496768, -0.0018355885, -0.0329845473, 0.0011295351, 0.0023175322, 0.0304493997, -0.0005624988, 0.0394796021, 0.0312009826, 0.0378238782, -0.0130738821, -0.0520796068, 0.0340266116, 0.0463759936, -0.0458663888, 0.0149142435, -0.0163488928, 0.0085838875, 0.0607658066, -0.0187002104, -0.0722066537, -0.002510305, -0.0057846047, -0.0138641484, 0.046038162, -0.0062077409, -0.0298183803, -0.0451355428, -0.021577362, -0.0437869914, 0.0222211983, 0.0206010547, 0.0410836339, -0.0396879129, -0.047230918, 0.0239691567, -0.0312167313, 0.0668621957, 0.0593071096, -0.0249165632, -0.0020634907, 0.0348560773, 0.0107864374, 0.0583845191, -0.0425013043, -0.0224187821, -0.0011066011, -0.0443968065, -0.0169995911, -0.0475036874, -0.0008802188, 0.04716428, 0.0285506416, 0.011579399, 0.0270336363, -0.0129974084, -0.0131618185, 0.0167866647, 0.0136385318, 0.0130062765, -0.0317981094, -0.0085875671, -0.0428298935, 0.0232261997, -0.0240390468, -0.0052697859, 0.0316872671, -0.0753499344, 0.0026790765, -0.0382805914, -0.0605436675, 0.0274886787, -0.026935881, -0.0239913147, 0.0642066374, -0.0061061131, -0.0179445278, 0.0209217574, 0.0443877988, 0.033576753, 0.019898558, 0.0421911664, -0.0077509191, 0.0079012113, -0.0288579203, 0.0183175262, -0.0370647572, -0.0652784854, -0.0062711989, -0.0052954517, 0.0005353102, 0.0001398917, -0.0278944187, 0.0406586565, 0.0122213513, -0.0175882112, 0.0307512674, -0.0211211517, 0.0184895545, 0.0735544041, -0.016152231, -0.031640511, 0.0519728623, 0.0001959544, 0.0542812422, 0.0039487686, -0.0460297354, -0.0343146324, 0.0247919783, -0.0172515716, 0.0015873091, 0.0120873433, 0.0482371859, 0.0425436534, -0.0346008465, 0.0492039211, -0.0044346596, -0.0263303779, -0.0223803166, 0.0473240167, 0.0049112104, -0.0075254943, 0.0204677787, -0.0649057329, -0.047592178, -0.0210098084, 0.0191515498, -0.0336521789, -0.0333310291, 0.0207252521, 0.0137848556, -0.0130155645, 0.0224455241, -0.0066757491, 0.0138930622, -0.0466763973, -0.0073276437, -0.0219737068, 0.0279845353, -0.0024253197, -0.0343736671, 0.0829168111, -0.065428637, -0.0301873386, -0.0338936597, -0.0607976578, 0.0160247758, -0.018838549, 0.0159519669, -0.0784983411, 0.0457135029, -0.016338665, 0.022311803, 0.0676983297, 0.0364171229, -0.0045909178, -0.026486272, 0.0574649312, -0.0038809036, -0.000900444, -0.0299356282, -0.108733356, 0.0257536825, -0.000619965, -0.0089100972, -0.0319095477, -0.0297620185, -0.0168445352, -0.0526143722, 0.0107333586, -0.0487729684, -0.0200149361, -0.0406773426, -0.0662038922, 0.0269429628, -0.0234774072, -0.0061815302, -0.0280243773, 0.0472991504, 0.00515683, 0.0437940545, -0.0371597707, -0.0327974036, 0.0346777588, -0.0283817798, 0.0305498522, -0.0241113622, 0.0115766134, 0.0016195273, -0.0355272852, -0.0430974327, 0.0095952842, -0.0529520176, -0.0130714038, 0.0447551012, -0.0525218584, -0.0028498471, -0.0242590625, -0.0081818448, -0.0234445781, 0.0236293785, -0.0141350627, -0.0109603023, 0.033973325, -0.0151469605, -0.0262769368, 0.0641630813, 0.0428815372, 0.0365593061, -0.0176650658, 0.004216901, -0.0042340537, -0.0430952944, -0.0466345213, -0.0534830727, -0.059342213, 0.005689255, 0.0192948096, -0.0384082906, -0.0400949307, -0.001470095, -0.0078666182, 0.0694220439, -0.0440094098, 0.0078087049, 0.0573743284, -0.0038728791, -0.0282503664, -0.0455315262, -0.002111804, 0.0096581895, 0.0288384166, 0.0163194407, 0.0099684624, 0.0046635279, 0.0251517128, 0.0339235254, -0.0773787946, -0.0734539703, -0.0092833592, -0.0362063088, 0.024692297, 0.0071230871, -0.0412214734, -0.033910986, 0.033441186, 0.0083609996, 0.0033838295, 0.0165000055, 0.0261012744, 0.0069322325, 0.0362629071, 0.0285566226, 0.0215434711, 0.0293463059, 0.0309434328, -0.0622327104, -0.0475652032, 0.0110350261, 0.0258162115, 0.0004441269, 0.0162749793, 0.0078841709, -0.0729314759, -0.0453032367, -0.0090021268, -0.0289760847, -0.0279434156, 0.0258800685, 0.0300219301, -0.0083181988, -0.0124953901, -0.02461881, 0.000459128, -0.0062828953, 0.0216675084, -0.035520345, -0.0097782463, 0.024242308, 0.0289131105, -0.0246078931, -0.0297140609, -0.0107585462, -0.0732846558, -0.0003378288, 0.0059925155, 0.0056139412, -0.047236111, 0.0203655846, -0.0071363905, 0.0696659163, -0.0225421116, -0.0438040346, -0.0187581405, -0.0443912596, 0.0136374533, 0.0183142107, -0.0218115542, 0.0493628196, -0.0117700566, 0.0046290806, 0.0105097871, -0.0188729987, -0.0263938028, -0.0117057003, -0.0010962243, -0.0071821734, -0.0280042384, 0.0838888809, 0.0155040072, -0.0000677392, 0.0084788771, 0.0356614701, -0.0823661536, -0.0044060107, -0.016279621, -0.0616685487, 0.0421057306, 0.0160399769, -0.0150260516, -0.0431296043, -0.0552258417, 0.0174968019, 0.0202088784, 0.0329611711, 0.0441427901, -0.0573047139, 0.0948942378, 0.0624494255, 0.0360778011, -0.0481104255, -0.0250113923, 0.0009500351, -0.0410102084, -0.006592935, -5.564159531e-33, 0.042069722, -0.0378254019, -0.0030762886, 0.0027171951, 0.022496108, 0.0174289867, 0.009515008, 0.0127342744, -0.0445997342, 0.062868908, 0.0005316802, 0.0633852705, 0.0183783453, -0.0253944881, -0.0010998067, -0.0004691582, 0.0335465185, -0.0191709902, -0.0426731892, 0.0209021475, 0.0799394324, -0.0434107408, 0.0754024088, -0.1114070117, 0.0806730464, -0.016808765, -0.0727642551, 0.0289825909, -0.0098531824, 0.0417626351, -0.0134684546, 0.0611645132, 0.0389228724, -0.0523885936, 0.0253506228, 0.0065564797, -0.01980987, 0.0248447116, 0.0290065948, -0.022115251, 0.0083480673, 0.0458151959, -0.0255589671, 0.0198985245, -0.0306199659, 0.0595372543, 0.0129078086, 0.0104992064, 0.0502704531, -0.0080833053, -0.0360078327, 0.0461323559, -0.006849023, -0.0072457981, -0.0247272868, 0.0294933431, 0.0369560868, -0.0076276381, -0.0713847652, 0.0315376967, -0.0827993974, 0.0012881021, 0.000128188, -0.0549805798, -0.0709735826, 0.0334656797, 0.0017722213, 0.0664274842, -0.0239382386, 0.0002955512, -0.0286851004, 0.0303412378, 0.0253974572, 0.0890076011, 0.0304902922, -0.0299097858, -0.1319347173, 0.0228344873, 0.0731046274, -0.0054161004, 0.0278958585, -0.029481506, -0.0306551103, -0.011960756, 0.0384506844, -0.0492797755, -0.0255928766, 0.0049184114, -0.0614083447, 0.0346897393, -0.0197064765, 0.1026114374, 0.0051845587, -0.0000399506, 0.0235010758, 0.0493625477, -0.0209389608, 0.0110056428, 0.0253600813, 0.0628291592, -0.0763986036, 0.0278943423, 0.0151976962, 0.0690308958, -0.0096255746, -0.0036301787, 0.0620485991, 0.0219388735, -0.0731152073, 0.0294053331, -0.0319937281, 0.0404898264, -0.0503324792, -0.0100735361, 0.0291676968, 0.0014622754, -0.0078412658, 0.0016168364, 0.0042218547, 0.002462894, -0.0055172932, 0.0033778034, -0.0515768155, -0.0289942529, 0.0241120532, 0.0007304923, 0.0145381084, -0.0031710269, -0.0531003699, -0.0390043594, 0.0219048876, -0.0194895547, 2.35e-7, 0.0002904488, 0.0194818545, 0.0217782948, 0.0166785754, 0.0364417285, 0.0070798225, 0.0385004729, 0.0067501464, -0.0118409349, -0.1011942104, -0.0286928564, 0.0429947972, 0.0136989923, 0.058990702, -0.0677076951, -0.0389757529, -0.0337367728, -0.0099123241, -0.0436344445, 0.0198798701, -0.0007292408, 0.0588835925, 0.0217833873, 0.0185477547, -0.0114573203, -0.0059526959, 0.0565281026, 0.0201262981, -0.0580449849, 0.0354076549, 0.0898805037, -0.0401973948, -0.0133581925, 0.0057017948, -0.0115241008, 0.0248584822, -0.0335392021, 0.0158981699, 0.0459524505, 0.029571835, -0.0031135587, -0.0411827527, 0.0341678038, -0.0007648643, 0.0269981101, 0.0188936424, -0.0596546195, -0.0332675725, -0.0229574088, 0.0349891521, 0.0362805985, 0.0133370701, -0.0289848316, 0.0179123618, -0.0169819482, 0.0098839179, -0.0203186255, -0.0362260975, 0.0260027833, -0.0353204198, -0.0242632423, -0.0425269268, 0.0795866475, -0.0630142987, 0.020866381, 0.0038660085, 0.0379947312, 1.514286516e-34, 0.060535267, -0.0046004318, -0.0093103014, -0.0113140671, 0.0700250864, 0.0088487687, -0.041636508, -0.0533935763, 0.0273952112, 0.0147679001, 0.0054300381 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.05843v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.05843v2
Leveraging Large Language Models to Power Chatbots for Collecting User Self-Reported Data
2023-01-14T07:29:36
2023-09-22T22:33:24
Jing Wei, Sungdong Kim, Hyunhoon Jung, Young-Ho Kim
cs.HC
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, H.5.2; I.2.7
Large language models (LLMs) provide a new way to build chatbots by accepting natural language prompts. Yet, it is unclear how to design prompts to power chatbots to carry on naturalistic conversations while pursuing a given goal, such as collecting self-report data from users. We explore what design factors of prompts can help steer chatbots to talk naturally and collect data reliably. To this aim, we formulated four prompt designs with different structures and personas. Through an online study (N = 48) where participants conversed with chatbots driven by different designs of prompts, we assessed how prompt designs and conversation topics affected the conversation flows and users' perceptions of chatbots. Our chatbots covered 79% of the desired information slots during conversations, and the designs of prompts and topics significantly influenced the conversation flows and the data collection performance. We discuss the opportunities and challenges of building chatbots with LLMs.
[ 0.0793201029, 0.0513532162, -0.042667307, -0.0136998426, -0.0430070944, -0.0292340294, 0.0411118455, -0.0042867251, 0.0703635439, -0.007461899, -0.0065586767, -0.0203286428, 0.006721552, 0.0631551147, -0.0024010658, -0.0587832443, -0.0056120758, -0.0597101115, 0.0301657505, 0.017132964, 0.021028446, 0.0170751456, -0.0285716262, 0.0722073391, -0.0421962962, -0.0394326523, -0.0591067262, 0.0152739892, -0.0355939046, -0.0373420455, 0.0118142301, 0.0370588787, -0.0062714615, 0.0312014222, 0.0000020349, -0.0298495218, 0.029237913, -0.0133323856, -0.0672005117, -0.0337930024, 0.0609393939, 0.0432434231, -0.005956186, 0.0336469971, -0.0266959388, -0.0102776606, 0.046536535, 0.0386650898, 0.0657516047, 0.0465576574, -0.0185806639, 0.0113579361, -0.0125716133, -0.0062009022, 0.027349554, 0.0030490854, -0.0271887016, 0.005209317, 0.062353611, 0.0336678028, 0.010844646, 0.0092035467, 0.0267039966, -0.0378397219, 0.0213620644, 0.0323641934, -0.0134953447, -0.099605307, -0.0146486238, 0.094639346, 0.0653375611, 0.010973963, -0.0109684514, -0.0054528997, 0.0531689413, 0.0094047012, -0.0600370131, 0.0397468694, -0.010775703, -0.0334615335, -0.0465629175, 0.0159335732, 0.0008819094, -0.0109679485, -0.0216182042, 0.0143516734, 0.0073517496, -0.0007521475, -0.0089046918, -0.0020763653, 0.0660829097, -0.0836127922, 0.0069338423, 0.0484718755, -0.0570720844, 0.0303371958, -0.0136952642, 0.0075619183, 0.0077239424, 0.0015143368, -0.0091051264, 0.0382909328, -0.0462277941, 0.0240660738, 0.0357992239, 0.0561169162, 0.0228482056, -0.0008881792, -0.0148313483, -0.0149802417, -0.0096500749, -0.028823752, -0.0280524008, 0.0354434885, -0.0187926646, -0.0264506731, -0.0035229868, 0.0782072395, 0.0110891806, 0.0190640409, -0.0292200837, 0.0030659565, -0.0120856119, 0.0075274101, -0.0500816666, 0.0092179226, -0.0488203093, 0.0082726246, 0.0543438047, -0.1166430116, 0.0235113185, 0.0071426672, 0.0074229455, -0.0166289788, -0.013950726, 0.0687580109, 0.0345322117, -0.0346000232, 0.0068857446, -0.0581438132, -0.0006383338, -0.0516523905, -0.0106757917, -0.0441374108, 0.0613166355, 0.0298924465, -0.0006667007, -0.0205140356, 0.0194725096, 0.0349228829, -0.0341999903, 0.0412194617, -0.0288940053, 0.0308285523, 0.0155838262, 0.0161642786, 0.0040552313, 0.0450758375, 0.0255888347, 0.0496832654, 0.0248036701, -0.0201465841, 0.036596749, 0.0300522037, -0.0275598504, -0.0276450198, -0.0070029465, 0.0073903981, -0.0008650632, 0.0272936393, 0.0043850159, 0.0573409684, -0.0146555481, 0.0454280376, 0.1042784303, 0.0914850309, -0.0039713453, 0.0076843309, -0.0045246622, 0.018934546, 0.0393220671, -0.0077238264, -0.0163567495, 0.0257454533, -0.0245135706, -0.0295034107, 0.0282785911, -0.0091369264, -0.0454737879, -0.0362257399, 0.0146557232, -0.0499597006, 0.0400761291, 0.0449509323, 0.0216042902, 0.0083401678, 0.0088818576, -0.0036232523, -0.003041592, -0.0861021206, -0.0367767289, -0.0430245101, 0.0614928268, 0.0960333198, 0.0397158861, 0.021092996, -0.0299982298, -0.0062634409, 0.0074277385, 0.0432764962, 0.0666268617, 0.0049778465, -0.0188247655, 0.0240474194, -0.0153931342, -0.0161398277, -0.027283797, -0.0168359298, -0.015369135, 0.0124395462, -0.0204841886, 0.0279165022, -0.0301430747, 0.0209438633, -0.0237085577, 0.0098752538, -0.0125060398, 0.0147089753, 0.0233279467, 0.0417179056, 0.0163089372, 0.0215877052, 0.0145117007, -0.005686793, -0.0124362642, 0.0503207147, -0.0244655441, -0.0054259617, 0.0331236497, -0.0208195969, -0.000154111, 0.0216242801, 0.0136585329, -0.02612965, -0.0111177107, -0.0756861344, 0.036452271, -0.0141006429, 0.0147973932, -0.0062309289, 0.0256680194, -0.0257655736, 0.0122509003, 0.0233949441, -0.0096225096, 0.0371661112, 0.0281129889, -0.0211363155, -0.0443745106, -0.0093713487, 0.0575413145, 0.0169090349, 0.0082040699, 0.07668937, -0.0119646089, -0.0782564655, -0.0223770589, -0.123580493, -0.0057846298, 0.0177382417, -0.0369392335, 0.0116068842, 0.0528906174, -0.0146508655, -0.0166469049, -0.078418158, -0.0135847423, 0.0234235507, 0.0474757738, 0.0551447161, -0.0013819741, -0.0302950293, -0.0396054313, 0.0272691548, 0.0021867105, 0.0200660117, 0.0425661355, -0.0109842848, -0.0480141491, 0.0220312905, -0.0569806844, -0.0167449396, 0.0096440762, -0.0488281697, 0.0558819063, -0.0414033793, 0.0636130124, 0.0723785311, 0.0452733263, 0.0598057881, 0.0258328896, -0.0111618619, -0.0578087009, -0.0034183597, 0.0173177961, -0.0041384529, 0.022592824, -0.057469409, 0.0342792757, 0.0100067072, -0.0041738623, 0.0295926984, -0.0397411138, 0.0510612912, 0.0067501427, -0.0242309682, -0.006618178, -0.004043153, -0.0331946537, 0.0655893981, 0.0088153342, -0.0362021476, 0.0473710038, -0.0201138835, -0.0170172956, 0.0118345059, -0.0351049453, -0.0100895744, 0.0772089586, -0.0006314449, 0.0117813498, 0.0258585624, -0.0193126909, -0.0122483028, -0.0019095553, 0.0099766841, -0.0666705444, -0.0184716918, -0.0330839753, -0.0146802505, 0.0114018153, -0.0345134661, -0.0714707598, -0.0826158449, -0.0416176282, -0.0158218127, 0.0171379931, -0.0160827227, -0.0378629565, -0.0072111241, 0.0552602932, 0.0232935734, -0.0234958977, -0.0029365348, -0.0081135202, -0.0163669772, 0.0252575986, 0.0344593413, 0.0249958988, -0.0072703995, 0.0710790828, 0.0275011342, 0.0047127488, 0.0473495089, -0.0161191281, -0.0401929542, 0.0232964847, 0.0068902764, -0.0135167027, 0.0344662853, 0.0849157497, -0.0381210297, -0.0143754259, 0.1199175864, 0.0074748825, -0.0370272063, -0.0023772847, -0.0241830572, 0.0191239584, 0.0010047499, 0.0295176078, -0.0521970131, -0.0234546531, 0.0226018354, 0.0006868125, -0.0727187991, -0.0556205325, -0.0216635671, -0.1122644767, -0.0152564794, -0.0060639805, -0.029815875, -0.0129127502, -0.0473669656, 0.0181819759, 0.0308059845, 0.0392258652, 0.0109999226, -0.0088756224, -0.011418541, -0.007883057, -0.0953688845, -0.0292718671, 0.023875365, -0.0322551765, 0.0859756246, 0.0684724152, 0.0499011688, -0.013262352, -0.0045443708, 0.0065907855, 0.0622655489, 0.0055960151, 0.0254491866, 0.031688787, 0.0135497935, -0.0173619371, -0.0656659752, 0.0232151691, -0.0238109212, -0.0060674963, 0.0087291962, 0.0094926534, -0.0446263999, -0.0144800562, -0.0327306762, 0.032397151, 0.0219577588, 0.0663934499, 0.0128422044, -0.0795381516, -0.0069171297, -0.0381191485, -0.0136043141, 0.0297285952, -0.055888515, 0.0144122308, 0.0129776439, -0.0189956687, -0.0669455305, -0.0784415528, 0.0591035038, -0.0048643644, 0.0286517516, -0.0063718599, 0.0350964628, 0.0289449897, 0.024257835, 0.0263412092, -0.0638231412, 0.0129188625, -0.0565919839, -0.0212657861, 0.0073807966, -0.051354941, 0.0419674851, 0.0327541418, -0.0479821339, -0.0325532779, 0.0075689233, 0.0330637507, 0.0216083098, -0.0227387603, -0.0050714593, -0.0382973477, -0.0446268618, 0.0415849574, -0.0699532554, -0.0415525585, -0.0119729601, 0.0856929868, 0.0048401668, 0.0065702228, -0.0419594198, -0.0318505354, -0.0192662571, -0.0003750194, -0.0122027174, -0.0754832327, 0.0547573939, 0.0774185136, 0.0231750701, -0.0071654581, 0.011636137, -0.0026524144, -0.0184733886, -0.0695666671, -0.0186651368, -0.0445792861, -0.0020524, -0.0313990004, -0.0102294981, 0.0299881976, 0.0035763297, -0.0657552108, 0.0323836319, -0.0242227297, -0.0087450035, -0.0114296731, 0.0193093196, 0.0063332925, -0.0151039157, -0.021068437, 0.0307495911, 0.0020780854, 0.0225035679, 0.0258731078, 0.0592577644, -0.0032792157, -0.0368719697, 0.0144146588, 0.0316725932, -0.0538918711, -0.0949352384, 0.0455966853, 0.0491262488, -0.0119296964, 0.0164437965, -0.0135413436, -0.0399943478, 0.0145962499, -0.0321534462, 0.0351622589, 0.021308912, -0.0184926279, 0.0032969837, 0.0097199427, -0.0318115912, -0.0419147722, 0.0110564698, -0.0153335696, -0.0060833693, -0.0062059052, -0.0225688759, -0.0437281914, 0.0151609015, 0.0246536024, 0.0028185481, -0.0169355255, -0.0293439627, -0.0520693697, -0.0469800159, -0.0325385854, 0.0050603854, -0.025415482, -0.0240157358, 0.0388619676, 0.014168391, -0.0377701446, -0.0205360241, -0.0558856837, 0.035206452, -0.0396386236, 0.0039981385, -0.0110828206, -6.112813805e-33, -0.0087460959, -0.0382893905, 0.0242796279, 0.0070104813, -0.0332759172, -0.0202884134, -0.0445163473, 0.0362734161, -0.023072103, -0.0018577729, -0.0510709472, 0.0067068166, 0.0074118683, 0.0009032362, 0.021074919, -0.0079263533, 0.073287949, -0.0020082754, -0.035079632, 0.0353382528, 0.0107674319, -0.0058493423, -0.009790957, -0.0627357289, 0.0543053336, -0.0371152759, 0.008433315, 0.007608504, 0.0335785262, 0.007645925, -0.0024830964, 0.0242835786, 0.0076727374, 0.0004504933, -0.0264500994, 0.1064158976, -0.0334658325, -0.0520555228, 0.0148742925, 0.0360579118, -0.049596142, -0.0571116693, -0.0027333125, -0.0434928946, 0.0125718424, 0.0142137362, 0.0249198079, -0.0201249234, 0.0059717093, 0.0457842536, -0.008717184, -0.0267424881, -0.0275036618, -0.0581895038, -0.0077617611, 0.0672195107, 0.0001232784, -0.0158846043, 0.0114923259, 0.0701881498, -0.0083640888, -0.0430686697, 0.0385044329, 0.0255464911, 0.0285570007, 0.0521284789, 0.070022136, 0.0415657163, -0.0469309948, -0.0000438102, 0.0224594548, 0.0250748713, 0.022535434, 0.0298681967, -0.0304192249, -0.0331526063, -0.0275612082, 0.0126319658, 0.0663625747, -0.0013877129, 0.0217804089, 0.0120050618, -0.048290547, -0.0012435546, -0.0304793902, 0.001801106, -0.0287599601, -0.0345120281, 0.003765434, -0.0005906561, -0.0165541414, -0.0681352094, 0.0269958284, -0.0340368226, -0.0332688726, 0.0052142479, -0.0362290107, 0.0055159805, -0.0049598049, -0.0099770613, -0.0011852299, 0.01294473, 0.0166084915, 0.0111539122, 0.028413143, 0.0402142368, -0.0224323347, 0.0222968943, -0.0474739634, -0.0388739109, -0.0413268134, 0.0517281927, -0.0135254338, -0.030619042, 0.0414879136, 0.0283846781, -0.0337403826, 0.0317810252, -0.0114781205, -0.0132508734, -0.051094465, 0.0092682354, -0.005668818, -0.0365784429, -0.0149650984, -0.0413409173, -0.0495085306, 0.0416328013, 0.0679171905, -0.0265645385, -0.0079806177, -0.0401638485, 2.76e-7, -0.0412961617, 0.021468306, -0.0197778363, 0.0538816266, 0.0276291221, 0.0354601443, 0.0168178212, 0.0225317534, 0.0126030091, -0.0418112315, -0.0035073515, 0.0372020453, 0.052009549, 0.0306476206, -0.0989667997, -0.028015865, -0.035751421, -0.0159239527, -0.0522399805, 0.005536959, 0.0810781792, 0.0325178839, 0.014687079, -0.0208054408, -0.0077317064, -0.0058394047, 0.0243549012, -0.0531651191, -0.0218915697, 0.0316152014, 0.014250244, 0.0215016268, 0.025276402, 0.0331934541, 0.0517470874, -0.0161736794, 0.0101731196, 0.0537540093, 0.0286999308, -0.0342902914, 0.0079981713, 0.0394246913, -0.0134421559, -0.0239579398, 0.0455899574, -0.0333109051, -0.0446048155, -0.0494250655, 0.0110843098, -0.0386128277, 0.0377939232, -0.047470659, -0.0192888901, 0.0248527098, -0.0038326881, 0.002418732, -0.0055456324, -0.0116019584, 0.0204488225, -0.019231325, -0.0352654271, -0.0889095291, -0.0509016477, 0.0045353631, -0.0190728791, -0.0291674323, 0.0415207222, 1.809065602e-34, -0.0242344458, 0.0220641829, 0.0021859433, 0.0285460185, 0.0507583208, 0.0141431978, 0.0443495698, 0.0227678847, 0.0443892628, -0.0435189754, -0.0073490576 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.08145v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.08145v1
Music Playlist Title Generation Using Artist Information
2023-01-14T00:19:39
2023-01-14T00:19:39
Haven Kim, SeungHeon Doh, Junwon Lee, Juhan Nam
cs.IR
cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS
Automatically generating or captioning music playlist titles given a set of tracks is of significant interest in music streaming services as customized playlists are widely used in personalized music recommendation, and well-composed text titles attract users and help their music discovery. We present an encoder-decoder model that generates a playlist title from a sequence of music tracks. While previous work takes track IDs as tokenized input for playlist title generation, we use artist IDs corresponding to the tracks to mitigate the issue from the long-tail distribution of tracks included in the playlist dataset. Also, we introduce a chronological data split method to deal with newly-released tracks in real-world scenarios. Comparing the track IDs and artist IDs as input sequences, we show that the artist-based approach significantly enhances the performance in terms of word overlap, semantic relevance, and diversity.
[ 0.0289246887, 0.038682498, -0.0235974547, 0.0359611139, 0.0022027504, -0.0023581453, 0.0452703722, -0.0254358109, -0.0171136148, 0.0089175599, 0.0379445627, 0.0233887285, -0.0242057331, 0.0372978784, -0.0002953579, -0.0800556764, 0.028912846, -0.0215953458, 0.0690800175, 0.0129693756, -0.0569494367, 0.0012981226, 0.0190996453, 0.0178581327, -0.0343051739, 0.0264747962, -0.0265205298, 0.0299594402, -0.0383254215, -0.0548725016, -0.0404953733, 0.0778642893, -0.004971303, 0.0356507078, 0.0000014716, -0.0125796599, -0.0455879159, -0.0271425769, 0.052853439, -0.05541379, 0.0028600188, 0.0040531093, -0.0086789234, 0.0404574499, -0.022761846, 0.0120733306, 0.0182606429, -0.0104182735, 0.0491419137, 0.0534364991, -0.0123098129, -0.0247246735, -0.0180055574, -0.0188939665, 0.0479947403, -0.0089004561, 0.0053471043, -0.0094552096, 0.0178655908, 0.0039472231, -0.0310866553, 0.0405500792, 0.0188241825, 0.0149280317, 0.0443864688, 0.0609169602, -0.0441967659, -0.0543000922, -0.010952916, 0.0423421487, 0.0019846433, -0.0277957991, 0.0227046981, 0.0178706441, 0.020587055, -0.0282328762, -0.0777940676, 0.0039439225, 0.0069420352, -0.0000136005, -0.0254458822, 0.0571587905, 0.0422860086, -0.0142390532, 0.0041926787, 0.0284994747, 0.0411821939, -0.0640480742, -0.01943684, -0.0196091812, 0.0432519503, -0.0773038417, 0.0312131401, -0.0070712189, -0.0293503441, 0.0264351014, -0.0584539175, -0.0290168561, -0.0000776849, -0.0230241194, 0.0121761421, -0.0210106224, 0.0256056041, 0.0439633317, 0.0027606564, -0.0454577953, 0.0206865985, -0.0265435483, -0.0303230006, -0.0381330773, -0.0247572288, -0.0410836712, -0.0306268688, 0.0099681187, -0.0012245481, -0.0309144817, -0.014141879, 0.0074992911, -0.0058869538, 0.0319664106, 0.0061513465, -0.0070532858, -0.0113028632, 0.0086811883, 0.0081385979, -0.0027666949, -0.0446879268, -0.0131809423, 0.0434792191, 0.0109149385, -0.0260231104, -0.0297135711, 0.0508543402, -0.0005029028, 0.041310668, -0.0005913583, 0.0291865822, -0.0382116176, 0.018151274, -0.0666835383, -0.019961955, 0.0142934509, -0.0346106999, -0.0737758577, 0.075558126, 0.0045831557, -0.0158398859, -0.0560761727, 0.0024288914, 0.0370371602, -0.0435130075, 0.0620502569, -0.0269947294, 0.0465131551, 0.0248557106, -0.0097692255, 0.003602515, 0.0084455088, 0.0587861873, 0.0651095286, 0.0939124078, -0.0186986439, 0.0486566424, 0.0360163301, 0.0081062354, -0.0330478624, 0.0141170518, -0.0158881117, -0.0242329799, 0.0648090094, -0.006407056, 0.035085883, 0.015152676, -0.0109044639, 0.0338460803, 0.0441713259, -0.0067060548, 0.0398110524, 0.0301791001, 0.0138246706, -0.0229228158, -0.0326671638, 0.0313983411, 0.0602764934, 0.0642945915, 0.0001138504, 0.0533390008, 0.0139443213, -0.0103724245, 0.0017391463, -0.0037699055, -0.0308750477, 0.0258402862, 0.0156661887, -0.015228658, 0.0302831084, -0.044596374, 0.0843223184, -0.00685579, -0.054216899, 0.0234152172, -0.0140242083, 0.0165633243, 0.1010706723, 0.0343726315, -0.0020671315, 0.0262142569, -0.0042575644, 0.0346781649, 0.0299488809, 0.0121856667, -0.0474124849, -0.0062134229, 0.0048674927, -0.0389714241, 0.0070158141, -0.0142143583, 0.0512063764, -0.0384070575, 0.0105925668, 0.0415169485, -0.0233739801, -0.0304908101, -0.0097466856, 0.0104064122, -0.0311892368, 0.0399418473, 0.008782465, -0.0030185613, 0.0457972027, 0.0180582106, 0.0377569459, 0.0488954149, 0.0056758444, 0.02761323, 0.0147505868, -0.0197820868, -0.0320436172, 0.0443114191, -0.0446989648, 0.0234466419, 0.0460883267, -0.0224041846, -0.0860340744, 0.0262124632, 0.010373964, -0.0026525136, 0.0333115384, 0.0223317519, -0.0007156701, 0.0179647412, -0.0017969763, 0.0438637957, 0.0546352863, 0.0052724476, -0.0378102548, -0.0378178991, 0.0237476937, -0.0528724305, -0.0181709304, 0.1089197993, 0.0056598247, -0.0204941332, 0.0237813257, -0.0114209345, -0.0345116965, -0.0582760386, -0.0826198533, 0.0046144784, -0.0029781316, -0.0134843709, -0.0050112279, 0.0281684343, -0.0082650185, -0.0352134481, -0.0033815689, -0.0836986676, -0.0082163047, 0.0094208242, -0.0403328128, 0.0081236931, -0.0894704312, 0.0164283011, -0.0173473954, -0.0007275002, 0.0087994123, 0.0163452812, -0.0055254498, 0.0058289412, -0.1055934429, -0.0534269474, -0.0536380261, 0.0222682413, 0.0350632817, -0.0229978338, 0.0273650642, 0.0095665893, 0.0102451611, 0.0267376918, 0.03342833, 0.0414775349, -0.0222849585, 0.0221815035, 0.0092915529, -0.0131777423, 0.0207233317, 0.005828036, -0.0467066728, 0.0241797268, 0.0256290063, 0.0246212427, 0.0066841701, -0.0203519445, 0.0036278784, -0.0120271733, -0.0133714993, -0.0554555729, -0.0201720018, -0.0578027479, 0.0435908362, -0.004047493, 0.0084228665, 0.0322305039, -0.0174889136, -0.0276825894, -0.0127846738, -0.0305875447, -0.0541761033, 0.0434466116, -0.020397516, 0.0175289642, -0.0132456301, -0.0747112259, 0.0075307884, 0.0657140464, 0.0296800453, -0.0897471309, -0.0135272434, -0.0240434948, -0.0203986298, 0.034338478, -0.0263079591, -0.0242179092, -0.0543070808, 0.0152882515, -0.0026099188, -0.0226107892, 0.0142260715, -0.0122952014, -0.016971672, 0.0114454208, 0.0476906076, -0.002338226, 0.0079338895, -0.0199850593, 0.0227096789, 0.0292123463, -0.0457619838, -0.0262067001, -0.0040694168, 0.0456162542, -0.014700993, 0.0211619101, -0.0247172173, 0.0171974096, 0.0057379911, 0.0356552675, -0.0491627194, 0.0194109436, 0.0832529813, -0.0265135113, 0.0095159458, 0.00998927, 0.1238246411, 0.0702930391, -0.0258874521, -0.0033108683, 0.0426220149, 0.004122253, 0.0383288115, -0.0183752272, -0.0055149491, 0.0119666969, 0.0216527134, 0.0755550936, 0.0514523201, -0.0268569812, -0.0137577364, -0.0427128486, 0.0185000338, -0.0006617749, -0.0422096029, -0.0060853623, -0.0519084781, -0.0605201013, 0.002546937, 0.01568597, 0.0037957144, -0.0221639648, 0.0413072705, 0.006629758, -0.0288332794, -0.0558355004, 0.0114865964, -0.0600136481, 0.032519538, 0.0832012892, 0.0893421173, -0.0267737508, 0.0083151525, -0.0679537058, 0.0192536078, -0.0349424183, -0.0051604104, 0.0385611579, -0.0133875832, 0.0222406853, 0.0034416455, 0.027527241, -0.0423440337, -0.0162488949, 0.0723410547, 0.0369349755, 0.0126574431, -0.0250735283, -0.0249957182, 0.0009025458, 0.0384458117, 0.0988022462, 0.0296606701, 0.0155186122, 0.0325848907, -0.0341580734, 0.0128412051, -0.0754426643, -0.0092243636, -0.0281335432, -0.0139290402, -0.0392909497, -0.0477689952, -0.0434507839, 0.0192824695, -0.007292483, 0.0131158531, 0.0611124299, 0.0155611122, -0.0484262966, -0.0796220526, -0.0386915803, 0.0300590489, 0.0084348116, -0.0387638845, -0.0829625949, 0.0069127241, -0.0117236907, -0.0179377664, 0.0217591282, -0.0649560392, -0.0064713378, -0.0057313475, 0.0246945806, 0.0210972726, 0.0474998392, -0.0193500724, -0.0179841761, -0.0017648003, 0.0194531847, 0.0028483525, -0.0116040977, -0.0165620428, 0.0270533804, -0.0008112637, 0.0284836348, -0.0840845481, 0.0101530114, -0.0259780046, 0.0650274754, 0.0077361427, 0.0293058921, 0.028725788, 0.0174149889, 0.0201325398, -0.0621442311, -0.0320794322, -0.0070390436, -0.0104583995, -0.0797963962, -0.0079421457, -0.0109398495, 0.0291376673, 0.0343414508, 0.0192468893, -0.0397479497, 0.0170973446, -0.0022413542, -0.0572401918, -0.0596937127, 0.009002123, -0.0195036866, -0.0655086562, 0.0293342117, -0.0126816602, 0.0278875437, 0.0093600517, 0.0697759092, -0.0066369819, 0.0037301795, -0.0422692671, 0.0186253376, 0.0085281441, -0.0507753752, 0.0248948708, -0.0386728905, 0.0105819292, -0.0151025057, 0.0558243059, 0.0536370873, -0.0105956746, 0.0044956626, -0.0061667738, -0.0186091829, 0.0187867116, 0.0498970971, -0.0106587661, -0.0874792933, -0.0294615533, 0.0090052905, -0.0154504376, -0.0232924223, 0.0969997719, 0.0011692852, -0.0470060967, -0.010095167, -0.0429245159, -0.0100759398, 0.042952273, -0.0221385881, -0.0064124665, -0.0222926773, 0.0173080582, -0.013661623, -0.0395052359, 0.0422845148, -0.0382236317, 0.068599239, 0.0256115794, 0.024304999, 0.064098388, -0.0054211202, 0.0233052336, 0.014697846, -0.0392246693, -0.0309405308, -0.0517929681, -0.0223409366, -5.362262866e-33, -0.025172675, 0.0021983448, -0.02941164, 0.0300206207, -0.0056928084, -0.015272269, -0.0627637953, -0.0031859837, 0.054436367, -0.0337018706, -0.0047204634, 0.0159152299, 0.0308075752, 0.0469218642, 0.061136391, -0.0408529192, 0.0791919157, 0.0067602238, -0.0159064028, 0.0096970527, 0.0314062722, 0.0515639037, -0.0430546328, -0.0222387332, -0.000006584, -0.0388796963, 0.0167817716, -0.0093968129, 0.0550908484, 0.0282942168, 0.0162371453, 0.0313696973, -0.00443835, -0.0389606915, -0.0157578718, -0.0010132539, -0.0802007914, -0.023134755, -0.0260059834, 0.015841566, 0.0475147106, -0.0149440346, 0.029225152, 0.0218758844, -0.0452391766, 0.034031935, 0.0534489118, -0.0218426604, -0.034554448, -0.0836478472, -0.0040294887, -0.026601037, -0.0311168227, 0.0023412765, 0.0750828087, -0.0147675918, 0.0281884447, 0.0343348682, -0.0273172781, 0.0430584997, -0.0049454127, 0.0165019948, 0.0695628747, 0.0178914052, -0.0072965319, 0.040407043, -0.0148370843, -0.0431806259, -0.0139218979, 0.0807202756, -0.0454064868, 0.0398468077, -0.0056965924, -0.0033634317, 0.0575682819, -0.0377680212, 0.0117419716, 0.0564311743, -0.0242276862, -0.0628908053, 0.0210629031, 0.0236477964, -0.0308950953, 0.0088969851, -0.0119708497, 0.0073775342, -0.0163079575, -0.0506028086, 0.0338901691, 0.0124173649, -0.0277568642, 0.0123447636, -0.0351193883, -0.0239462443, -0.0649442896, 0.007001081, -0.0098660616, 0.0148572186, -0.0116788223, -0.0027509779, 0.0229241606, -0.0087698251, 0.0834374577, -0.0387752093, 0.0008776392, -0.0331152901, 0.024952136, 0.0375321023, -0.0329406373, -0.0089582903, 0.0312098637, 0.0031907037, -0.0181709379, -0.0235148668, 0.0203472879, 0.0555687733, -0.0510529317, 0.0020524298, 0.0173570979, 0.0344400853, -0.0168863088, -0.0738575235, -0.0192723647, 0.0072505618, -0.0097391438, 0.0178210307, -0.0326453708, -0.0435562432, 0.0420273803, -0.0331580788, -0.0439920761, -0.0080796946, 2.412e-7, 0.004684662, 0.0319001228, -0.008904852, 0.0138750356, 0.0172649287, -0.012440376, -0.0723950565, 0.0416945666, 0.003315286, -0.0298482366, 0.0489907153, -0.0516748354, 0.073487483, 0.0500149839, -0.1251364946, -0.0318973921, -0.0692679435, 0.012689095, -0.081322059, -0.0047295894, 0.0603906065, 0.0629747361, 0.072910212, 0.0063041458, -0.0129114361, 0.0172203723, 0.0008399041, -0.0061370074, 0.0168677829, -0.0497936271, 0.0232602675, -0.046280846, -0.0289779212, 0.0003302479, -0.067215398, 0.0259789769, 0.0694279373, -0.0134988613, 0.0019457227, 0.0027157851, -0.0067825541, 0.0325314179, 0.009356387, -0.0289930832, 0.0561162867, 0.0046986062, -0.0267589949, 0.0171000585, -0.078935653, 0.0386807397, -0.0331691019, 0.0042422665, -0.0168889537, -0.0131566487, 0.0240488108, 0.0121294381, 0.0360540077, -0.0644597188, 0.0098879086, -0.0241565499, -0.0261620339, -0.0051028621, -0.0472472496, 0.0146838007, 0.0181143563, -0.0334493257, 0.0222664196, 2.113511751e-34, 0.0482004508, -0.0008484552, -0.0286591649, -0.0076378332, 0.0371698812, -0.0358935595, -0.0046086786, 0.0472502299, -0.0238195769, -0.011023921, -0.049563136 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.05746v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.05746v1
Infusing Commonsense World Models with Graph Knowledge
2023-01-13T19:58:27
2023-01-13T19:58:27
Alexander Gurung, Mojtaba Komeili, Arthur Szlam, Jason Weston, Jack Urbanek
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI
While language models have become more capable of producing compelling language, we find there are still gaps in maintaining consistency, especially when describing events in a dynamically changing world. We study the setting of generating narratives in an open world text adventure game, where a graph representation of the underlying game state can be used to train models that consume and output both grounded graph representations and natural language descriptions and actions. We build a large set of tasks by combining crowdsourced and simulated gameplays with a novel dataset of complex actions in order to to construct such models. We find it is possible to improve the consistency of action narration models by training on graph contexts and targets, even if graphs are not present at test time. This is shown both in automatic metrics and human evaluations. We plan to release our code, the new set of tasks, and best performing models.
[ 0.0315760784, 0.0206868928, -0.0090486156, 0.0418798625, -0.0203507096, -0.0174292102, -0.0484924726, -0.025031982, 0.0432782285, -0.0709760562, 0.0081766909, -0.006193174, 0.0321184844, 0.0783264041, 0.0116725424, -0.049780298, 0.0073587336, -0.0315093361, -0.0072195497, 0.0247998498, -0.0023730593, 0.047270216, -0.0171404257, 0.0709966719, 0.0045139557, -0.0035027694, -0.0247487128, 0.0165683236, 0.0260822009, -0.0457950793, -0.0185905863, -0.0175631307, 0.0589729846, -0.0211376511, 0.0000016958, -0.0242712107, 0.0347869955, -0.0390307792, 0.0213304013, -0.0153575884, -0.0030380699, -0.0019475103, 0.0358594619, -0.0282481182, -0.038662117, -0.0319241993, 0.0447621047, 0.0145661645, 0.069283314, 0.0598025359, -0.0120868981, -0.00553039, -0.0303916223, 0.0172328297, -0.0000712868, -0.0240528081, -0.0079445392, 0.0516763702, 0.0562961623, -0.0301677026, -0.0539566837, -0.011369491, -0.0153506817, -0.0045379177, -0.010970789, 0.0748162344, 0.0123803541, 0.067730546, -0.0086251302, 0.1273167282, 0.0085913325, -0.0419059433, 0.0258946791, -0.0078342985, -0.0157952253, 0.0156646073, -0.0274883099, 0.0349394567, -0.011636002, 0.0296912044, -0.0012455732, -0.0070889378, 0.0402157716, -0.0065038726, 0.034230005, 0.0582709238, -0.0144826304, 0.0216950793, -0.0489629433, 0.0225714482, -0.0271266289, -0.0622280799, -0.0144926114, 0.0428493321, -0.0505005941, 0.0186986569, -0.0519392304, 0.0587940514, -0.0280493405, -0.0320621133, 0.0601748116, 0.0150184259, 0.0031449031, 0.0571716763, 0.0349607505, 0.058279559, 0.0270536169, 0.0308813676, -0.0446610637, 0.0166054349, -0.0728066713, 0.0109016635, -0.0563182645, 0.0241266247, -0.0514338538, -0.0593840815, -0.0125627611, 0.0277349893, -0.0061171455, 0.0141095323, 0.0216242652, 0.0485100932, -0.0213271454, -0.0086113093, -0.0210340898, 0.0244154111, -0.0212173853, 0.0102704326, -0.0039505693, -0.0219400972, -0.0162363686, -0.007543161, 0.0604009815, 0.0001722603, -0.007994948, 0.0530147515, 0.0219458435, -0.0063606165, -0.0337270275, -0.0423107818, -0.0206472538, -0.0396154523, -0.029848529, -0.0694984719, 0.0506048463, -0.0080625936, 0.0200782567, -0.0184174534, 0.0043183002, -0.0003921341, -0.0333549008, 0.0524178967, -0.0088774282, 0.0207562279, -0.0049850936, -0.0182506349, -0.0026934643, 0.0336387046, 0.0753318667, -0.0004210598, 0.0240199678, 0.0430769734, 0.0181355141, 0.0212452412, 0.0030157827, 0.0072651943, 0.0000990187, -0.0105465548, -0.0272875335, 0.0503390394, 0.0334731527, 0.0526563264, -0.0570121855, -0.0340561979, 0.0834120438, 0.0616057552, -0.0169539489, -0.041254729, 0.1009093449, 0.0317552276, -0.0111824973, 0.0288863964, -0.0282418467, 0.002732737, 0.0137465186, 0.0211429335, -0.0523174666, -0.0175999627, -0.0062360698, -0.0127463462, -0.0086086262, -0.0280054472, 0.0794678032, -0.0270975735, 0.0235774573, 0.0168480761, -0.0686533377, 0.0306993965, 0.0277575944, -0.0506438091, 0.0564239472, -0.0081548728, 0.0119216312, 0.0690529197, 0.0562352352, 0.0032818867, -0.0529955253, -0.0384873599, 0.01107815, 0.0108043738, 0.0085044866, -0.0482966676, 0.0441765971, -0.0349793397, -0.0258214027, -0.0484533645, -0.0053978325, 0.0303372368, -0.0037790916, -0.0080262367, -0.0027073182, -0.0834208056, -0.055764202, 0.023512153, -0.0102241971, -0.0243456326, -0.0391108356, -0.001204149, -0.0101323286, 0.0168612767, -0.0176972635, -0.001045416, 0.0151441302, -0.0032918777, -0.0239274111, 0.0877436548, -0.0321573801, -0.0613394976, 0.0450579152, -0.0689598992, -0.0168198273, -0.0081293527, -0.0011627015, -0.0359739028, 0.0288322531, -0.0497769415, 0.0253264345, -0.0029670366, -0.0081034973, 0.0092066294, -0.0488513298, 0.0076406412, 0.0665321127, -0.0035320779, -0.0117254881, -0.0012380336, 0.0001910148, -0.000828542, -0.0496983528, 0.0306211133, 0.0350883305, 0.0241213348, 0.0164583456, 0.05258606, -0.0060240519, -0.0531747714, 0.018004749, -0.0923837125, -0.0025425861, -0.0097840801, 0.0003795662, 0.03206129, -0.0036476403, -0.0112866107, -0.0000464488, -0.053200081, -0.0034573334, 0.0528517216, 0.007375346, 0.0335234217, 0.0440150313, 0.0292419922, -0.0158687364, 0.008866108, -0.0254421365, 0.0734248534, 0.0359876528, -0.0044433405, -0.042194508, 0.0121612288, -0.0525535122, 0.0451128557, -0.0381051339, -0.0353442803, 0.0339929909, -0.0129504548, 0.0330587924, 0.021967236, -0.0304405689, 0.0457333028, 0.0694364086, -0.051712729, -0.022794148, -0.0026510239, -0.0312534794, 0.006703577, -0.0587395504, -0.0124227582, 0.0344324633, 0.0530320853, 0.034759365, 0.0224357992, -0.0681814402, -0.0263878219, -0.0208374597, -0.0094361678, -0.0259061921, -0.0682177916, -0.0292550288, -0.016129354, -0.060277123, 0.0084487349, 0.0734694302, -0.0167512912, 0.0052307392, 0.0018557373, 0.0011701637, -0.0384593531, 0.0934885591, 0.0378286429, 0.0511636287, -0.0059518586, -0.0198299102, -0.038663134, -0.0456907302, 0.0760587752, -0.0079909582, 0.000971197, -0.0648209378, 0.0097236997, 0.026423296, -0.021105241, -0.0081291236, -0.0130731864, -0.0317858011, -0.0088523347, 0.0067812386, -0.0239479523, -0.0155073376, 0.0144042689, 0.0011049537, 0.0208620448, -0.0014120252, -0.0156336632, -0.0260994639, 0.0361929685, 0.0885334611, 0.0061823395, -0.0424851961, -0.0463211536, -0.002231851, 0.04672518, 0.0126470448, -0.020618882, -0.0092208404, 0.0287650153, 0.0084450357, -0.02267747, -0.0384283401, 0.0258264914, 0.0556713529, -0.0437154397, -0.0115877632, 0.082118988, 0.0252704974, 0.0132106254, 0.0213716775, 0.0331631415, -0.0017158416, 0.0096454173, -0.0182817243, -0.0693633333, -0.0192612931, -0.0209104605, 0.0112501374, 0.0178300552, -0.0656027272, -0.0038755252, -0.1040583774, 0.0132991299, 0.0296605024, -0.0352421291, -0.0275063664, -0.0146829132, -0.0044741938, -0.0156707186, -0.0288993213, -0.033867348, -0.0009328783, 0.0240185615, 0.0046092398, -0.017259717, 0.007450447, 0.0229194872, -0.0595073849, 0.0506103896, 0.0105835712, 0.0813862458, 0.0355799869, -0.0158041809, -0.011189525, 0.0465874299, 0.002183856, -0.0071901758, 0.0391124971, -0.0339406617, -0.0152078914, -0.0108740097, 0.0244352445, -0.0235331226, -0.0649093837, -0.0328361988, 0.0673191473, 0.0131167937, -0.033715412, 0.005393445, 0.0210661385, 0.0520642996, 0.0506227612, 0.0107680028, -0.0042652073, -0.0331800245, -0.0287147518, 0.0153378313, -0.0870903432, -0.0579399876, -0.0058988133, 0.0162200443, 0.0463277437, -0.0867589936, -0.0521753989, 0.0253885277, 0.0517498665, 0.0095420321, 0.0030511569, 0.041272141, -0.0058973283, -0.0379076488, 0.0480109714, -0.0740494132, 0.0007566575, -0.0053175823, -0.0235895514, 0.03725449, -0.0245109852, -0.0053535569, 0.0862204731, -0.055293519, -0.0584218428, -0.0254765209, 0.0197844356, 0.0131627256, 0.0469235741, -0.013817233, 0.0063049002, 0.0053359494, 0.0025340889, -0.0264882315, 0.0273097139, 0.0000809006, 0.0173781961, -0.0030310461, 0.0086826626, -0.0581293032, -0.0285947639, -0.006290751, 0.0772009939, -0.0213391222, -0.0593989007, 0.0130741745, -0.0061635473, 0.0348851606, -0.0311863702, -0.0113511058, -0.0580276437, -0.0541476756, -0.0393801965, -0.0207385495, -0.0371490344, 0.0215976108, 0.0287077818, 0.0182545725, -0.0186790526, 0.0080112293, -0.0338227786, 0.0402931981, -0.0566867292, -0.0359528884, 0.0636754707, -0.0308338236, 0.0314421691, 0.0128420712, -0.0132832369, 0.0161685944, -0.0283682235, 0.0178684182, 0.0123098977, 0.0005150401, 0.0399835445, -0.0504108556, -0.0149087077, -0.0017612934, -0.0465409197, 0.0163883436, -0.0142376767, 0.0443292968, 0.0724760816, -0.0001420568, 0.0475551039, -0.0201289728, 0.0092656491, 0.0096267257, 0.0385160521, 0.0345612355, -0.0701581091, 0.0054930151, 0.0501594618, -0.019827174, 0.0553134307, 0.0453255177, 0.0525366589, 0.0703237876, 0.025772376, -0.0532348342, -0.034561988, -0.0359642245, -0.0211934708, 0.0648410544, -0.0073970789, 0.0174994878, -0.074502483, -0.0347414799, 0.0406337976, 0.0737933367, 0.0121237496, 0.0027130761, 0.031124806, -0.00132741, 0.0253692288, -0.0059785671, -0.059590172, 0.0270160362, -0.0391177684, -0.0016267168, -0.031314224, -5.022707731e-33, -0.0391770266, -0.0719583556, 0.0297629647, 0.0062135011, -0.0631905645, 0.00739128, -0.0730608776, -0.0055805524, 0.0089098327, 0.0507202931, 0.0293307975, 0.021565523, -0.0112737436, -0.0116668353, -0.0368263647, -0.0367913209, 0.034092363, 0.0104756486, -0.0558260605, 0.0404856317, 0.0692033619, -0.0113536017, 0.0526423417, -0.0747933015, 0.0197248161, -0.0336016156, -0.025463352, 0.0139531847, 0.0492297895, 0.0387851037, 0.0008239131, 0.0447446965, 0.018582074, -0.0002762392, -0.0100798951, -0.0167320594, -0.0528600179, -0.025159739, 0.0374555811, 0.0031829313, -0.0222323015, -0.0190805402, -0.0015674642, 0.0033378275, 0.0069228923, -0.0215567648, 0.0628956929, 0.0099046733, -0.0202013385, 0.0227284506, -0.0676186681, 0.0040420657, -0.0327227302, -0.046032533, -0.0291350093, 0.0339637473, 0.018461382, -0.0292401742, -0.0377393961, 0.0585485473, -0.03084464, -0.0299461279, 0.0179091394, 0.0422732607, 0.037291158, 0.0906077772, -0.0410966538, 0.0205128677, -0.075036414, 0.0285618212, 0.0171038806, 0.0533938669, 0.0115068564, 0.0701451972, -0.0451937132, 0.0168377757, -0.0584037714, 0.0357056893, -0.0034151131, 0.0342557169, -0.0069776662, 0.020961022, -0.0412899628, -0.0371800847, -0.0312224384, -0.020223055, 0.0168676302, -0.0094233407, 0.0039167586, -0.0272402205, -0.036715772, 0.0088254251, 0.0122469207, -0.0491577908, -0.017513562, 0.0756939873, -0.0272921324, 0.0336981006, -0.0123881716, 0.0075543635, -0.00439722, -0.0201346278, 0.0508702509, 0.0411899015, 0.0339595526, 0.0219129398, -0.0050711157, 0.061908979, 0.0082297279, 0.0063705291, -0.0365129225, -0.0188738573, -0.033883851, -0.0173921883, 0.0563171059, -0.0123591702, -0.0298200063, 0.0253404062, -0.001432828, -0.0185978282, 0.0167993326, -0.0083818641, -0.0249527041, 0.0208544191, -0.0337487236, 0.0128851067, -0.0356096029, 0.033934433, 0.0186568853, -0.0178544242, -0.0192188174, 0.006512423, 2.419e-7, -0.009230786, 0.009877394, 0.0478136912, 0.0209150128, -0.0185897537, 0.0383892059, -0.0295463465, 0.0340557694, 0.019344762, -0.0444535948, 0.0554908179, 0.0617116615, 0.0088860188, 0.0206871275, -0.085163407, 0.0536426641, -0.0729873776, -0.0200048387, -0.0305192322, 0.0071729142, 0.051699087, -0.013249266, 0.054351829, 0.0160950385, 0.0141032077, -0.0740601644, 0.0502725169, -0.0290080849, -0.027843019, -0.0000462118, -0.0138346963, -0.0055514094, -0.0402127914, -0.0555005446, -0.0124678621, 0.0262437724, 0.0451034196, 0.035796918, -0.0259512085, 0.0020052015, -0.0373464674, -0.0573430732, 0.0037191655, -0.0386802852, 0.0521885902, -0.0347584821, -0.0093579646, -0.0389989056, -0.0076680481, -0.0031810093, -0.0200737994, -0.029782936, -0.0421519466, -0.0041676648, 0.0082202135, 0.0131790973, 0.0016154142, -0.0440112427, -0.0257737096, 0.0027607628, 0.0045540757, -0.0417550355, 0.0146126691, 0.0050578448, 0.0042361869, -0.0462819338, 0.0074182414, 2.023388987e-34, -0.0150874592, 0.0059646182, -0.0027464118, -0.0492895544, 0.0593728609, -0.0056230575, -0.0054767942, -0.0033617362, 0.065873459, -0.0474983864, -0.0185434017 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.05663v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.05663v1
Natural Language Processing of Aviation Occurrence Reports for Safety Management
2023-01-13T17:00:09
2023-01-13T17:00:09
Patrick Jonk, Vincent de Vries, Rombout Wever, Georgios Sidiropoulos, Evangelos Kanoulas
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.LG
Occurrence reporting is a commonly used method in safety management systems to obtain insight in the prevalence of hazards and accident scenarios. In support of safety data analysis, reports are often categorized according to a taxonomy. However, the processing of the reports can require significant effort from safety analysts and a common problem is interrater variability in labeling processes. Also, in some cases, reports are not processed according to a taxonomy, or the taxonomy does not fully cover the contents of the documents. This paper explores various Natural Language Processing (NLP) methods to support the analysis of aviation safety occurrence reports. In particular, the problems studied are the automatic labeling of reports using a classification model, extracting the latent topics in a collection of texts using a topic model and the automatic generation of probable cause texts. Experimental results showed that (i) under the right conditions the labeling of occurrence reports can be effectively automated with a transformer-based classifier, (ii) topic modeling can be useful for finding the topics present in a collection of reports, and (iii) using a summarization model can be a promising direction for generating probable cause texts.
[ 0.0403180569, -0.0087451981, -0.0044527738, -0.0026125172, -0.0391650274, 0.0048904554, -0.0150780752, 0.0016489533, -0.0292009097, -0.0999011099, 0.0830695704, 0.0090965824, -0.013345167, 0.0528362878, 0.0133870803, -0.0359512158, 0.0238280725, -0.0108340494, 0.0301414952, 0.0805764422, 0.0218387824, 0.0647353828, -0.029498376, 0.0389082208, -0.0417418964, 0.0267881714, -0.0045662206, -0.0494827665, 0.0443650298, -0.0481702313, 0.0042394614, 0.0200863518, 0.0468021594, -0.0322913192, 0.0000018509, -0.0279111024, -0.0437866524, 0.0108197723, 0.0388505273, -0.0319982804, 0.0427656509, -0.0305127706, -0.0157751366, 0.0603647344, -0.0202344246, -0.005767453, -0.0020741546, 0.0882289931, 0.0748704374, 0.0481316075, -0.039084401, -0.045454368, -0.0017709669, 0.0576588698, 0.0042694258, -0.0188919399, 0.0240449328, 0.0202095434, 0.0214737374, -0.0187072381, 0.0044376473, 0.002202651, -0.00402924, -0.0458198749, 0.02510304, 0.0309273656, -0.0346945301, -0.0171640944, -0.0203043446, -0.004229961, 0.0112617481, -0.0038010448, 0.049130328, -0.0125735933, -0.0030851986, 0.0038035391, -0.0051125726, 0.0277890991, -0.0566901304, -0.0041445522, 0.0648941025, 0.0631939918, -0.0436796695, -0.003049694, -0.0079007698, 0.0292295553, -0.006165748, -0.0437840559, -0.0200715512, -0.0035781695, 0.0374464281, -0.0463187844, 0.0410371907, 0.0307416022, -0.010802893, 0.0288735349, 0.0154236071, -0.062942788, 0.0634106323, -0.1009712666, -0.0469899699, -0.0056442195, 0.0068886778, 0.0208065137, 0.0243584383, -0.0146990092, 0.0493060499, -0.018854633, -0.0354948379, 0.0193994641, -0.0461390801, -0.0242657661, -0.0578272454, 0.0377021022, 0.0186573695, 0.0310873818, -0.0241295267, 0.0069732796, 0.009848306, -0.0158978086, 0.0019406298, 0.0092085116, -0.0594835617, 0.0245668162, -0.0223685578, -0.0258456692, 0.0026889462, 0.0400024578, -0.0055196444, 0.021612661, 0.0281327236, 0.0485327579, 0.0552544929, 0.0465834774, -0.0545281172, 0.0200542677, -0.0261351205, -0.0182214882, -0.0988555774, -0.0457309149, 0.0047665755, 0.0411935858, -0.0297958869, -0.0412975028, -0.0275810473, 0.020807771, -0.0282422528, 0.0313051306, 0.0144367879, 0.026025001, -0.0259940419, 0.0140885562, -0.0458542742, -0.0009028803, 0.052972611, -0.0101799546, 0.0616688728, 0.0030363195, 0.0504989699, 0.0238734093, 0.0223626513, -0.0102369534, 0.0819592923, -0.0223387107, -0.0283306427, -0.0283803679, 0.0208266955, 0.0009131476, -0.0492202863, -0.0292006452, -0.019025825, 0.0108347349, 0.0008398741, 0.0596690103, -0.0092763966, 0.0406868905, -0.0009535092, 0.0443729945, 0.0392072201, 0.0563302673, -0.0247876514, -0.0202554483, 0.0405994393, 0.00111135, -0.0352487452, 0.002586809, 0.0346823595, 0.01657019, -0.0206783712, -0.0788838714, -0.0314488374, 0.0087791597, 0.031388443, -0.0491007082, 0.0358802155, -0.0012959364, -0.0382789783, 0.0255362671, 0.0105782235, 0.0079393033, -0.0163836926, 0.0162705276, -0.0182047766, 0.0545590557, 0.0173971485, -0.059117537, -0.0401734374, -0.0762838945, 0.0057042907, 0.0032259107, -0.0128029305, 0.0067188661, -0.008700666, -0.005153921, -0.0328411609, 0.0281520505, 0.0187478941, -0.0263676066, -0.0252950639, 0.0006771599, -0.0071528987, -0.0142836999, -0.0808331519, 0.0616233945, 0.0189021807, -0.0112995664, -0.0198924113, -0.0134013398, 0.0147774182, 0.0173854697, 0.0182275102, 0.0168881305, 0.0326948278, -0.0069528404, -0.0884199888, 0.0370711237, 0.0125835631, 0.0441950299, -0.0046137907, -0.0598349907, 0.0042186398, -0.0215807054, -0.0310542956, -0.0430477969, -0.0178813729, -0.0545549467, -0.03934367, -0.0108019868, 0.0125585701, 0.0238882154, -0.0592181385, -0.0345478952, 0.0785756484, 0.0232497472, 0.0002841004, -0.0519920662, -0.0661118701, 0.0474140309, -0.0206428841, -0.0021170024, 0.020981906, -0.0574231893, 0.0506259166, 0.0709085315, -0.0137920761, -0.0080943359, 0.0062910323, -0.0504429303, -0.0127477301, -0.0315567851, 0.0022231953, 0.0244533625, 0.0062841368, -0.0371164642, 0.009972441, 0.0022157182, -0.022200305, 0.0153614897, -0.0184120294, 0.0441857614, 0.0170550644, -0.0051276381, -0.0327946506, -0.0047746426, -0.0410717502, 0.0225451067, 0.0855815113, -0.0607233606, -0.1133913398, 0.0944037363, -0.0362819694, -0.0086058145, -0.0009581868, -0.0357658826, 0.0265366919, -0.0083975317, 0.0424066819, -0.008741756, 0.0542186759, 0.0284698736, 0.0340289548, -0.0058191479, -0.0235795807, -0.0136784194, -0.0648784861, 0.0195697434, 0.0291998088, -0.060281761, 0.0443244465, 0.0104641197, -0.0029843014, 0.0126226423, 0.0011827745, -0.0337623619, -0.0417801403, 0.0215220321, -0.027209999, -0.0585347675, 0.00249965, 0.0546534583, 0.0415571183, -0.012460337, 0.0342276543, 0.0238569193, 0.0271912906, -0.1185655072, -0.0332479104, -0.026054468, 0.0362534225, -0.0059078457, 0.0090906005, 0.048514761, -0.0370929912, 0.0395309217, -0.0260249861, 0.0395360887, 0.0122798476, 0.0005290173, -0.0449475944, 0.0400582291, -0.0133293187, 0.0024076365, -0.0529742129, -0.0740587264, 0.0274624527, -0.0062574958, -0.0005676106, 0.020781666, -0.063441135, 0.0719888061, 0.0547637828, 0.0353095978, 0.0144423926, -0.0224998388, -0.015356468, -0.0009189222, 0.0181288309, -0.0451704301, 0.0156064164, 0.0493575372, 0.005651752, 0.0472481772, 0.0260449108, 0.0110589163, -0.0285927635, -0.0150187202, -0.0248751044, -0.0639780685, -0.0068654609, 0.0390020683, -0.0192604307, -0.032656014, 0.028420331, 0.0499244444, 0.0594588891, 0.0032873373, 0.022099968, 0.0040062801, -0.0724388883, 0.0080544669, 0.0454973839, 0.014855626, 0.0655790493, -0.0379554369, -0.0085408762, -0.0092162034, -0.0384586379, 0.0344124548, -0.0247594435, 0.0629868284, -0.0187348854, -0.0359732807, -0.0548707433, -0.0697471425, -0.0166423153, -0.0404625013, -0.0180133134, -0.0169403348, -0.0249198452, -0.0139209833, 0.0509369262, -0.0949991867, -0.094024986, -0.0318561569, -0.0251103677, -0.0091665396, 0.0018935335, 0.0036125805, -0.0717458129, 0.0247877408, -0.0096016116, 0.0026251941, 0.0039972258, -0.0006506277, 0.0288641583, 0.0056034052, 0.0094303228, -0.0341180302, 0.0057169572, -0.0099821771, -0.025525758, 0.023691861, 0.0751741305, -0.0475659594, 0.0032581012, -0.0444852076, 0.0527201705, 0.0287344232, 0.0141804395, -0.0264537279, 0.0056937071, -0.0071413293, -0.0247353949, 0.0234483797, 0.0078210961, -0.0078113521, 0.0113526741, -0.0244152322, -0.1116625369, -0.0752488822, -0.04631605, 0.0516484566, 0.0016560106, -0.0161209032, 0.0197681673, 0.0452448167, -0.0116657298, -0.0177226029, 0.0144443531, 0.0272570159, 0.0178534221, -0.0272069275, 0.0311289635, 0.043557141, 0.0529767796, -0.0407026149, 0.0198077615, -0.0158997755, -0.0343855619, 0.0260034427, -0.0165193714, 0.0168205444, -0.0261986293, -0.0218933076, -0.0381616168, -0.0015238648, 0.0256353691, -0.0413749665, -0.0402178615, -0.0470508859, -0.0394859314, 0.0066875285, -0.0228850879, -0.028340064, 0.0329283848, -0.0479840599, 0.0259952601, -0.0793520585, -0.0250284243, 0.0139469896, 0.0014001715, 0.0176323541, 0.0013955698, -0.0145286713, -0.0377516635, -0.0107881436, -0.0077612852, -0.0235988833, 0.006745663, 0.0731760785, -0.0259302706, -0.0066103716, 0.0011097211, 0.0234140065, -0.0478585362, 0.0059853462, 0.0251791086, 0.0558906347, 0.0059743146, -0.0058858437, -0.018950846, 0.0119498763, 0.0044021728, -0.0625647232, 0.0184126217, 0.0087276157, 0.003649015, 0.005080861, 0.0336105525, 0.0193579663, -0.0320576355, 0.0178326052, -0.0289066955, 0.0203114953, -0.030905826, -0.0070387223, 0.0318042785, -0.0038010157, -0.0197043512, -0.0677629933, 0.0257399622, 0.0013982941, 0.0455217548, 0.0340719372, 0.0000903644, 0.0544123799, 0.013071523, -0.0188717265, -0.0251939055, 0.0653535277, 0.0357108749, -0.0481683724, 0.0227908548, -0.059169963, -0.0451929644, 0.0227662828, 0.0567170084, 0.0101578776, -0.0031775776, -0.0123794777, -0.0594245382, 0.0116180694, 0.0561822914, 0.0068746242, 0.002393384, -0.0518039279, 0.0072827414, 0.0512191616, 0.0581452884, 0.0061439136, -0.0138042262, -0.013232694, -0.0045583402, -0.0025374382, -0.0361036547, -5.606446103e-33, -0.0327147655, -0.0758135766, 0.0162973553, 0.0530685857, 0.040217042, -0.0081650559, 0.0177682713, -0.0176639538, 0.0366265848, 0.0113864029, 0.0006961248, 0.026427038, 0.0167952627, -0.0400197059, 0.0420156345, -0.0266195722, 0.0298153143, 0.015540353, -0.0107590118, 0.0093786567, 0.0244041495, 0.0036945064, 0.0485944524, -0.126009807, 0.025750244, -0.0166752413, -0.0169666279, -0.0160027705, 0.0493056215, 0.0441847593, -0.0097236261, 0.0295642149, 0.0341347829, -0.0532474183, -0.0050901254, 0.025339365, -0.0078112688, -0.0675672293, 0.0276516583, -0.031302467, 0.0395222716, -0.0183044877, 0.0421515815, 0.0011582671, 0.0054491078, 0.0386758074, 0.0738016218, 0.0082193268, -0.0136090759, -0.0458628535, -0.1041357964, 0.0470125005, -0.0215384141, 0.0195371099, 0.0216394067, 0.005729924, 0.0037079363, -0.0239314027, 0.0076253074, 0.0009425217, 0.0194470547, 0.0176207125, 0.0029383393, -0.0409546085, -0.0464778394, 0.0179738849, -0.0717414469, 0.0266646966, -0.0310523417, -0.0054113031, -0.0336221941, 0.0479824282, 0.0329520404, 0.018044183, 0.0252777804, 0.0038394716, -0.0710463449, 0.0881913677, -0.0448112935, 0.0389823988, 0.0206617229, -0.0011963244, -0.0586533248, -0.0289922114, 0.022705039, 0.0592826232, -0.0032132075, 0.0043276842, -0.0003527945, 0.0297762472, -0.0417916141, 0.0532550365, -0.0148905385, 0.0303839575, 0.0018345653, -0.0179313533, 0.0344456546, 0.0254541896, -0.0339237005, 0.0219472591, -0.0686916932, 0.0455211848, 0.0169132315, 0.0075357994, 0.0143559081, -0.0049678483, 0.0053806729, 0.0235793628, -0.0391882546, 0.0318078622, 0.0346742198, -0.0095268432, -0.0134573439, 0.0275145508, 0.0091398694, 0.0187463704, 0.0265733451, -0.0164797287, 0.0254457183, -0.025392659, -0.0077379299, -0.046464555, -0.0346013978, -0.0236802474, 0.0010208535, 0.0082092043, -0.009675866, 0.0108233253, 0.0490927361, -0.0073472341, 0.003274648, 0.0139310369, 2.498e-7, 0.0467033386, 0.0307140127, 0.04543446, 0.0027763909, 0.0331250578, 0.0094741853, 0.0332541205, 0.0011464128, 0.0326975398, 0.0368700325, 0.0208753441, -0.0425920114, -0.0297437273, 0.0897433162, -0.0412853658, -0.0186914708, -0.0036855123, -0.0249898173, -0.0723275244, 0.0184563417, 0.1141301766, 0.0349199995, -0.0177206639, 0.0205506179, -0.0542296544, -0.0467123464, -0.0176770836, -0.0295514893, -0.0391893946, 0.0101116877, 0.0689948946, 0.0962384939, 0.003347391, 0.0496242419, -0.0333827548, -0.0185143892, 0.0118563361, 0.0059655299, -0.0282265656, 0.0601437166, 0.0143654179, -0.0585068725, 0.012282039, 0.002270858, 0.0170042664, -0.0537336618, 0.0025648989, 0.059742216, -0.0263712183, 0.0212772414, -0.027291391, -0.0033338743, -0.0341259204, 0.0255428795, -0.0239760987, -0.0056006513, -0.0011274618, -0.0556364655, 0.0254110061, 0.0175928902, 0.0260769948, -0.0205212217, 0.012250592, 0.016759824, 0.0461777709, -0.0090787802, 0.017391758, 2.131765204e-34, 0.0102081615, 0.0358958878, -0.0687677264, -0.016684996, 0.0419594608, 0.018604653, -0.0598065481, 0.044435069, -0.0219161473, -0.042791035, -0.0107932035 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.05659v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.05659v1
From stage to page: language independent bootstrap measures of distinctiveness in fictional speech
2023-01-13T16:58:43
2023-01-13T16:58:43
Artjoms Šeļa, Ben Nagy, Joanna Byszuk, Laura Hernández-Lorenzo, Botond Szemes, Maciej Eder
cs.CL
cs.CL
Stylometry is mostly applied to authorial style. Recently, researchers have begun investigating the style of characters, finding that the variation remains within authorial bounds. We address the stylistic distinctiveness of characters in drama. Our primary contribution is methodological; we introduce and evaluate two non-parametric methods to produce a summary statistic for character distinctiveness that can be usefully applied and compared across languages and times. Our first method is based on bootstrap distances between 3-gram probability distributions, the second (reminiscent of 'unmasking' techniques) on word keyness curves. Both methods are validated and explored by applying them to a reasonably large corpus (a subset of DraCor): we analyse 3301 characters drawn from 2324 works, covering five centuries and four languages (French, German, Russian, and the works of Shakespeare). Both methods appear useful; the 3-gram method is statistically more powerful but the word keyness method offers rich interpretability. Both methods are able to capture phonological differences such as accent or dialect, as well as broad differences in topic and lexical richness. Based on exploratory analysis, we find that smaller characters tend to be more distinctive, and that women are cross-linguistically more distinctive than men, with this latter finding carefully interrogated using multiple regression. This greater distinctiveness stems from a historical tendency for female characters to be restricted to an 'internal narrative domain' covering mainly direct discourse and family/romantic themes. It is hoped that direct, comparable statistical measures will form a basis for more sophisticated future studies, and advances in theory.
[ 0.0009597033, 0.0636707395, -0.0246547628, -0.0011473844, -0.0365619175, 0.0088024987, 0.0183950383, 0.0109613221, -0.0403812379, 0.0006485953, 0.0020627268, -0.0706281066, 0.0898892954, -0.0187625904, 0.0468922891, -0.0213533249, -0.0310707483, -0.0282987878, 0.038714122, 0.0026318857, 0.0304772723, 0.0415826552, 0.0129878977, 0.0608562455, 0.0272309855, -0.0339126661, 0.0303192027, -0.0077273911, 0.0381402671, 0.0103580561, 0.0055747256, 0.0168721098, -0.0185574088, 0.026693359, 0.0000016394, -0.0538181774, 0.0409418382, -0.0386663638, 0.0307599567, 0.0221997332, 0.0515341759, 0.0737555772, -0.0164658874, -0.023232419, 0.0109621687, -0.0019915137, 0.0548416451, 0.0200058687, -0.0415872596, 0.0313925892, -0.0173825063, -0.0658278391, -0.0361817628, -0.0458795615, 0.0113116391, 0.0268019438, 0.0178481266, -0.038462095, 0.0227361079, -0.0179923438, -0.0563636646, 0.0027813893, -0.0671653673, 0.031089386, -0.0531081185, 0.0076068593, -0.0380962603, 0.0402061082, 0.0012869415, 0.0254959278, 0.0672450885, -0.0258374009, 0.0148570472, 0.0245633386, 0.025624143, 0.0600831769, 0.0182794053, -0.0159628354, -0.0328206196, -0.0208835397, 0.0171779804, 0.0482266657, -0.0176379699, 0.0034935786, -0.0096464371, 0.0318513326, 0.0223898068, -0.0041943626, 0.0375676751, -0.0289479196, -0.026862422, -0.051800143, -0.0167507157, 0.0328226611, 0.0284936, -0.0082885083, 0.0204999875, 0.0041867262, 0.0009477808, -0.0542340204, 0.0261848923, -0.0084654195, -0.0221216399, 0.0072217826, 0.0090136882, 0.0315183811, -0.0075184763, -0.0334819704, -0.0021364191, 0.0143837314, -0.0489077456, -0.0235339571, -0.0192778986, -0.0472258627, 0.0249233339, 0.0231201667, -0.0297744945, -0.0292089432, -0.0114152562, -0.0126651227, -0.036868941, -0.0319255069, 0.0002976292, 0.0202486161, -0.0283743832, 0.0182685759, -0.0696308017, 0.0026333367, -0.0594296679, -0.0275625773, 0.0064819246, 0.021538144, 0.0403421819, -0.0205702353, 0.0593789108, 0.0445515774, 0.008836396, -0.0129334182, 0.031127613, 0.0095020793, -0.0675746575, -0.0468925573, -0.0405454263, -0.0579911508, -0.0147042917, -0.0129537946, 0.0203994457, -0.0634756535, -0.0117667401, -0.0031922348, 0.0048748902, -0.0264936406, 0.046956405, 0.0336982571, 0.0173071474, -0.0395046249, 0.0162695367, -0.0195453502, 0.061904788, -0.0433110036, 0.024885321, -0.023768194, 0.0160487872, 0.0265999008, -0.0371434726, 0.015188803, -0.0332167447, -0.0116892615, 0.0211609062, 0.0250248294, 0.0305273663, 0.0071243038, -0.0203908123, -0.0114013795, 0.0469711162, 0.0852936804, 0.0702356398, -0.0160124972, 0.0251515247, 0.0238903705, 0.0657704175, 0.0344261117, 0.0021907708, -0.0463763475, 0.0659603402, 0.0064128162, -0.0716058984, 0.0238587018, 0.0133984163, 0.0070146294, -0.0203478206, 0.0088914707, -0.0087184841, -0.0016202762, -0.0253728833, 0.0055286628, 0.0033054061, -0.0394830331, 0.0248395037, -0.0508106984, 0.0147500662, 0.00590458, -0.0156480223, 0.034518145, 0.0046636937, -0.024249414, 0.0619461536, -0.0051926514, -0.0136462841, 0.0373988599, -0.0691352189, -0.0083870487, 0.091244027, -0.0486073941, 0.0636629835, -0.0004566279, 0.0187214166, 0.0297661647, -0.0764542818, 0.0320192203, -0.0164493453, -0.045205567, 0.0151926344, 0.0048368974, -0.0567590483, -0.0663646013, -0.0259101074, -0.0090301186, -0.0173962936, -0.0321958177, -0.074600853, 0.0014680775, -0.0379978754, -0.0350892954, 0.0450721793, 0.0727218166, -0.0197020937, 0.0436186604, 0.0275680572, -0.0896043032, 0.0320126005, -0.0160156768, 0.0282394476, -0.0158567429, 0.0598861426, -0.0471368767, 0.039860867, 0.0016253989, 0.0139284749, -0.0281316824, 0.0174312219, -0.0497081056, -0.0077398317, 0.0577280149, 0.0224401932, -0.0307363737, 0.004357622, 0.0264133736, -0.0390292332, -0.0028717362, -0.0069589866, 0.0422970913, 0.0122729288, 0.0371799879, -0.042163942, 0.0031493297, -0.089906849, -0.0255185459, -0.0097258938, 0.0018245665, 0.0136284437, 0.0037389549, 0.0307293031, -0.055885721, 0.0198976472, -0.041468069, -0.0491996855, -0.0276630912, -0.0247657187, 0.0401640497, 0.00242828, -0.0066260416, -0.0115687409, -0.0136860404, -0.0070256554, 0.0428456739, -0.0059349039, 0.0183927678, -0.0100951958, -0.0199072435, -0.0058596432, 0.0020975112, -0.032100305, -0.0516553, -0.0024835505, 0.0123545984, 0.0883733332, -0.0037556591, 0.0060240058, -0.0372898877, 0.0213696752, -0.0877394006, -0.0067020725, -0.0350060351, 0.0165630747, 0.0522137731, -0.0398079865, -0.0650493428, 0.0182941481, 0.0288319588, -0.0196899101, -0.0112516908, -0.0103818849, 0.0439270064, 0.0135044605, -0.0249713603, 0.0269337073, -0.0072163087, -0.029269509, 0.0494018421, -0.0056101545, 0.0289352518, 0.006009026, -0.0609286129, 0.0171117242, -0.0142951105, -0.0282777324, -0.040055573, 0.0373333804, 0.0016601983, 0.0069454168, 0.0482632294, -0.0335991196, -0.0285821594, -0.0239290874, 0.1096818447, -0.025544405, 0.0428402424, 0.0325574204, -0.0311162509, 0.0113743348, 0.0184049029, 0.0205160864, -0.0832367763, -0.0175723117, -0.0260776579, 0.0192879066, -0.0824733004, 0.0282889474, 0.0150662288, -0.0240970831, 0.0144587522, 0.0113112079, 0.0206739884, -0.0151416771, 0.0106617371, -0.0012444525, 0.0393947065, -0.0516451076, -0.0431839228, 0.0266890395, -0.0526477993, -0.0916587561, 0.0583129004, 0.0106505696, 0.0073194127, 0.0204241071, -0.0382587612, -0.023875339, -0.0334561206, 0.0434469357, -0.0400273018, 0.0195278749, 0.0647146851, -0.0257843416, 0.0296841767, 0.0074364045, 0.0144145889, 0.064109385, 0.0172220841, 0.0222133957, 0.0097974446, 0.041492492, 0.0364828445, 0.058574114, -0.0037805946, -0.0485488735, -0.0458044186, -0.0806976631, 0.0179706588, -0.0049078451, -0.0343575515, 0.0153375948, 0.0095182462, 0.0049090888, 0.0151865194, -0.037065506, 0.0187090803, -0.0272141658, -0.0138035323, 0.0121257408, -0.056912683, -0.00437755, -0.0145277744, -0.0736832023, -0.0068941736, -0.0485682413, 0.0624095164, -0.0456446372, -0.033075586, -0.0761904269, -0.0199873727, -0.0143962586, 0.0118447011, 0.052908536, 0.0245868713, -0.0127111627, -0.0853122547, 0.003872588, 0.0723181516, -0.0240368191, 0.0338338017, -0.0195761621, 0.0308789071, -0.0240171328, 0.0012189095, 0.0530811697, -0.0044242442, 0.0427517034, 0.0324170776, -0.0211616326, -0.0318738036, 0.0114450827, 0.0431564003, 0.0115797371, -0.0685399845, 0.0089895427, 0.0096465359, -0.052537635, -0.0674952045, -0.0277234334, -0.0371192209, 0.0978991985, 0.0712925941, -0.0226759035, -0.0291246902, 0.0082744416, -0.0259521492, -0.006524866, 0.0023162742, 0.0119613912, -0.0325728394, 0.0288092215, 0.0135631831, -0.0552694313, 0.0141864782, -0.0160244126, -0.0471532568, -0.0579961948, 0.0297043156, -0.0480386652, 0.0325871706, 0.0290414337, -0.0178444088, -0.0732192472, 0.0563744679, -0.023411015, 0.0456998385, 0.0698686615, -0.0138161406, -0.016871471, -0.0256858692, 0.0037133999, -0.0112478798, 0.0285112988, -0.0150694028, -0.0110176876, 0.0041741598, -0.0434107333, -0.005387458, 0.0205720291, -0.0148029868, -0.0728455111, 0.0491995849, -0.0252812132, -0.0587581508, -0.0127614941, 0.0153287109, 0.032011684, -0.0214733928, 0.0147374123, -0.0148670254, -0.0225060415, -0.0142449746, -0.0303481929, 0.0180518478, -0.0370898508, 0.0273491684, 0.0463251062, 0.0225842949, -0.003795671, 0.0388019495, 0.0030916194, -0.0096394271, -0.0422256328, 0.0829247832, 0.0452487879, -0.0460364223, 0.0142452596, -0.0187358744, -0.0242344309, 0.0212087072, -0.0508733429, 0.0131032085, 0.0240403377, -0.0462687649, -0.025343189, -0.0497332662, 0.0760263875, -0.0191846732, 0.0000344378, -0.0176510997, 0.0277621765, 0.0265301075, 0.0672975332, -0.0496413708, 0.0175484139, -0.016407093, 0.0403369553, 0.0130029554, 0.0220712163, -0.0044590491, -0.001597359, -0.0732993633, -0.0184632987, -0.0295422282, -0.0213535391, -0.0217543952, 0.0351200178, -0.0002756507, -0.0978222936, -0.0577159859, 0.0463409349, -0.0320460908, 0.0488693491, -0.0064997626, -0.0302978009, -0.0110358773, -0.015416041, 0.0613986962, -0.0518553965, 0.0044544726, 0.0146051943, -0.0008043369, 0.004868615, -5.252902953e-33, -0.0084307604, 0.0528802909, -0.0440593846, 0.0631256029, -0.0612723194, -0.0064550578, -0.0132032689, -0.0105614504, -0.0077878539, 0.0287835132, -0.004180511, 0.0040821349, -0.0110287759, -0.049647741, -0.0166954827, 0.0274532307, 0.0402930565, 0.0490024164, -0.0427711718, -0.0504575595, 0.0581020266, 0.0039196699, 0.0638354197, -0.0285185371, 0.0213990286, -0.0765353814, -0.038755022, -0.0173679367, 0.0624273829, -0.0102861179, 0.0117027694, 0.0420159101, 0.0088288803, 0.0045596035, -0.0218427256, 0.0143319415, -0.0025795389, -0.0717197359, 0.0264426824, 0.0137773212, 0.0828016475, -0.0338411294, 0.0037387563, 0.0120995212, -0.0483274385, -0.0528959371, 0.058363881, 0.0263506379, 0.031407848, -0.0082085161, -0.0551512241, 0.0062904013, -0.0298327543, -0.0268032476, 0.0393889137, 0.0117584253, -0.001440544, -0.0207057409, 0.004708902, 0.0126430253, -0.0265045036, 0.012708866, -0.0473070741, 0.0699258447, 0.0057423632, 0.0470273793, 0.0508009009, 0.0234142058, 0.0211790334, 0.0342045091, 0.0412207544, 0.0128801847, -0.0035966353, 0.0942111388, 0.0250503197, 0.0231109951, 0.003320992, -0.054865893, 0.0598420203, -0.0106314961, -0.0008326151, -0.0206466597, -0.0263717193, -0.0404691994, -0.0268528499, -0.0232002754, 0.0525599457, 0.0225079954, -0.0250391979, -0.0786369741, -0.007408482, 0.0227286946, 0.0388745815, -0.0329312943, -0.0349106453, -0.0256897137, -0.0523054712, 0.0586553402, 0.0327470154, 0.010217173, 0.0770810619, 0.0114987064, 0.0323133357, 0.0484650135, 0.0539384633, -0.0048918216, -0.0087699033, 0.0324745066, -0.0703333169, -0.029930789, 0.0147934156, 0.0223596003, -0.01986707, 0.0362479016, 0.0261173733, -0.0238393508, 0.022347929, -0.0029630025, 0.0286036637, -0.0023889593, 0.0360292308, 0.0131072756, 0.026523402, -0.0147431167, -0.0246977601, 0.0018652634, 0.029004056, 0.0002446461, 0.0552220717, -0.0118243443, 0.0060610007, -0.0597329922, 2.696e-7, 0.0228865817, -0.0116219474, 0.0733964667, 0.0040272274, 0.032758113, 0.0304361936, -0.0137732103, 0.023880979, 0.0188321844, -0.0296560936, -0.008847299, -0.002683002, 0.0667666271, 0.0412758924, -0.0489023589, -0.0131180175, -0.0798628032, -0.0236085765, -0.0177361481, -0.0006076348, 0.0050748158, 0.025030829, 0.0266104452, -0.0243262891, 0.0304373112, -0.024759654, -0.0175948665, -0.0565201789, -0.0057665561, 0.037627589, -0.0037361418, -0.0506188869, 0.0341248401, 0.0537964143, 0.0098962113, 0.0358213037, 0.0188181121, -0.0058417167, -0.01160926, 0.0809778497, 0.0111836651, -0.0063297474, -0.0355834998, 0.0079054264, 0.0157679301, 0.089078337, -0.042645812, -0.0479450226, -0.0302826166, 0.0085288258, 0.088248685, 0.0259842705, -0.0274169277, 0.0454613157, 0.0155006731, -0.0039127581, 0.0168849584, -0.0050235097, -0.0307966117, 0.0361450501, -0.0223292764, -0.0393009335, 0.0450232103, -0.0116318623, 0.0209689457, -0.0604013689, 0.0005022751, 2.227108587e-34, 0.0194460023, 0.0072414083, 0.0069182282, 0.0340274908, 0.0096192202, -0.0128293009, 0.0591737218, 0.0609948039, 0.0515881069, -0.0115071209, -0.0031801818 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.05571v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.05571v2
The 2022 n2c2/UW Shared Task on Extracting Social Determinants of Health
2023-01-13T14:20:23
2023-02-13T20:08:09
Kevin Lybarger, Meliha Yetisgen, Özlem Uzuner
cs.CL
cs.CL, I.2.7
Objective: The n2c2/UW SDOH Challenge explores the extraction of social determinant of health (SDOH) information from clinical notes. The objectives include the advancement of natural language processing (NLP) information extraction techniques for SDOH and clinical information more broadly. This paper presents the shared task, data, participating teams, performance results, and considerations for future work. Materials and Methods: The task used the Social History Annotated Corpus (SHAC), which consists of clinical text with detailed event-based annotations for SDOH events such as alcohol, drug, tobacco, employment, and living situation. Each SDOH event is characterized through attributes related to status, extent, and temporality. The task includes three subtasks related to information extraction (Subtask A), generalizability (Subtask B), and learning transfer (Subtask C). In addressing this task, participants utilized a range of techniques, including rules, knowledge bases, n-grams, word embeddings, and pretrained language models (LM). Results: A total of 15 teams participated, and the top teams utilized pretrained deep learning LM. The top team across all subtasks used a sequence-to-sequence approach achieving 0.901 F1 for Subtask A, 0.774 F1 Subtask B, and 0.889 F1 for Subtask C. Conclusions: Similar to many NLP tasks and domains, pretrained LM yielded the best performance, including generalizability and learning transfer. An error analysis indicates extraction performance varies by SDOH, with lower performance achieved for conditions, like substance use and homelessness, that increase health risks (risk factors) and higher performance achieved for conditions, like substance abstinence and living with family, that reduce health risks (protective factors).
[ 0.0393139832, 0.0895535424, 0.013839283, -0.0293178856, -0.0206320938, 0.0542386808, -0.0142201725, 0.0065198489, 0.0344203226, -0.0419620946, 0.0421045758, -0.0336630978, -0.0251768045, 0.0533451028, -0.0037655784, -0.025106037, 0.0256077349, 0.0550094843, 0.031143833, 0.0292574503, -0.0247523375, 0.0186829995, -0.0163115207, 0.0238266587, -0.0365400463, -0.0020114793, 0.032976374, -0.0367597379, 0.0509386212, -0.0926284716, 0.0116905086, 0.0337183587, -0.0086803408, -0.023938911, 0.0000022043, -0.0427214019, -0.0235963874, 0.0012170722, -0.0525312722, -0.0391682424, 0.0401695445, -0.0582092293, -0.0047870451, 0.0010611737, -0.0730498433, -0.0709319115, 0.0266367178, 0.0602663197, 0.0089851888, 0.0715499744, -0.0298095085, -0.0238554794, -0.0163189936, -0.0407700017, -0.0028641562, -0.0237794686, 0.0716468841, 0.0106880348, -0.0060480558, -0.0446900018, 0.0250355937, 0.0193319321, -0.034772519, 0.0405047834, 0.026595233, 0.0164031349, -0.0265050512, 0.0049679922, 0.009604441, 0.1019636095, -0.0094319833, 0.0251317266, 0.0442905203, -0.0178615525, -0.0104156341, 0.0235375687, -0.0222009346, -0.0280136969, -0.005597563, 0.025448652, 0.0376012251, 0.0413203761, 0.0464162752, -0.0002539957, -0.0317559652, 0.0154647641, -0.0047980412, -0.0074060755, 0.0353978425, 0.0153370984, -0.0009181425, -0.0395957641, 0.0521931946, -0.0027808838, -0.0093847467, 0.0423135757, -0.0022044065, -0.0449811704, 0.0473795161, -0.1002877504, -0.0097470637, -0.0003473239, -0.0344134457, 0.0432108045, 0.0053781429, -0.0189399179, -0.0055602556, 0.0165332947, -0.0110194655, 0.0084664617, -0.0407822765, 0.023970522, -0.0180588216, 0.0419943333, -0.0200624745, 0.0213066973, -0.064420335, -0.0090650218, 0.000190756, -0.0207356438, -0.0090279793, 0.0358232632, -0.0347627476, 0.0414237715, 0.0280992165, -0.002129104, -0.0200942885, 0.0001624605, 0.001704372, -0.0238401089, 0.0230855811, -0.0143982423, 0.0660339594, -0.047557544, 0.0385030061, 0.0487432852, 0.0216365177, -0.0411991589, -0.0445136093, -0.0170317981, -0.0136242472, 0.0078246975, -0.0020156431, -0.0366973914, 0.0569726154, -0.0150476685, -0.0109309163, -0.0992642716, 0.0359495394, -0.0068841735, -0.0783123821, 0.0317990519, -0.0375591479, -0.0218476038, 0.0428713001, 0.0374873914, 0.0402844623, 0.024246579, 0.0610990636, 0.0042999038, 0.0280614533, -0.0558201522, -0.0257484447, 0.0117191235, 0.0262861308, -0.0706863329, 0.0410252921, -0.0083639054, 0.0007811852, 0.0341456197, -0.0240809973, 0.0351935774, 0.0001035631, -0.0015709536, 0.0201677475, 0.0881215706, 0.0277695283, 0.0210188199, 0.033650171, 0.0095408531, -0.0215299465, -0.0339837298, -0.0415318906, -0.0467654169, 0.0222961791, -0.0120381238, -0.0400177911, 0.0288417786, 0.0081521403, -0.0384234674, -0.0222571567, -0.0034977321, 0.0291188993, -0.0286737885, 0.032967478, -0.006395556, -0.0523186736, 0.0402435809, 0.0406452157, -0.0252757967, -0.0096885599, -0.0000102881, 0.0049882876, 0.0432161279, 0.0596505143, -0.0432385467, -0.021080438, -0.0374755114, 0.028359497, 0.0172782373, -0.0005804991, -0.0111640599, 0.0648357719, -0.0201958474, -0.0085229091, 0.0561303496, 0.0173900612, -0.0320198834, 0.0471064337, 0.0261672381, 0.013935959, 0.0216937847, -0.0552040339, 0.0688830093, -0.0175784715, -0.0655420721, 0.0031556438, -0.0038499511, 0.0573697127, 0.032479465, -0.000398236, 0.0071151336, 0.0245790705, -0.0630557612, -0.0288741346, -0.0009058052, -0.0539559387, -0.020074714, -0.0003768664, -0.0277916547, 0.0107966941, 0.0465343744, -0.0326399356, -0.0010558548, -0.0015387508, 0.0037110331, 0.0086390954, 0.0061828382, -0.0317672119, 0.0658457726, 0.0356798619, -0.0309086423, 0.0591138788, -0.0355141982, -0.0414908081, -0.0421231352, -0.0758428574, -0.0505291298, -0.002458533, 0.0332983546, 0.0068890392, -0.0323463455, -0.0208950043, -0.0100735426, 0.0303963181, -0.0301066916, 0.0264489893, -0.0729984641, 0.0285693742, -0.0262461957, 0.0210364722, 0.0032110522, 0.0263360608, -0.0255411975, -0.0457896441, -0.014739465, -0.0395786203, 0.0018223356, 0.0033163524, 0.047930669, 0.0473879501, 0.0317542665, -0.0640097558, -0.005927403, -0.0642147884, 0.0309234839, -0.0039279247, -0.0774936751, 0.0153037077, -0.0042273798, -0.0167646036, 0.0034685063, 0.0082057901, 0.0048198639, 0.0035192803, 0.0087989625, 0.047674004, 0.0296110604, 0.010074378, 0.0659995228, -0.0073560108, -0.0083790515, 0.0037988548, 0.0076550338, -0.0533316359, 0.0622022487, -0.0200139079, -0.0549979582, 0.0182141308, 0.0787514523, 0.0227824636, -0.0247266255, -0.0179152526, -0.0117359832, -0.0169466399, 0.0056151594, -0.0492527224, 0.0004447396, -0.0440690927, -0.0208978299, -0.0284550786, -0.0106563549, 0.0340331271, 0.0143993041, 0.0422700383, -0.0411548242, -0.0446946584, -0.0274223723, 0.0322677754, 0.0052079097, -0.0034484987, 0.0045996434, -0.0359816477, 0.055097919, -0.0140198991, -0.0024118433, -0.0564013645, 0.0207505357, -0.0568384528, 0.0076188482, -0.0072943494, -0.0316384286, -0.0209762547, -0.1021872908, -0.0249108225, -0.0019891637, 0.0073087662, 0.0488920771, -0.0113141499, 0.0184172485, -0.0429608636, 0.0705973506, 0.0329019167, 0.001917629, -0.0264505744, 0.0283944923, 0.0660041496, -0.0105335061, -0.0223585349, 0.0202421676, 0.005504285, 0.0450747237, -0.0080966828, 0.0166719109, -0.0050367531, 0.0194229838, -0.0163021553, -0.0418614745, 0.0036834024, 0.0054541649, 0.0460993648, -0.0419112295, -0.0069675162, 0.0737942457, 0.0124180643, 0.01359531, 0.0517037585, 0.0254243575, -0.0575979576, 0.0013965508, 0.0008113961, -0.0906658098, -0.0331462547, -0.0063303239, 0.0146636916, -0.01824582, -0.0775554329, 0.0122119756, -0.0120234564, 0.0070059006, -0.0129429158, -0.0470909588, -0.0294584408, -0.0449555516, -0.0078032264, -0.0597592592, -0.0401890539, -0.0516138636, -0.0115650175, 0.0115052015, 0.0309173539, -0.082847774, -0.0479137711, 0.0372824036, -0.0088361045, 0.035557989, 0.0368647389, 0.0239962228, 0.0032246881, 0.0304368045, 0.0257036984, 0.0101454463, -0.00472133, -0.0060552284, 0.0596447848, -0.050960876, -0.0162488651, -0.0570698902, 0.0526076816, -0.0381770991, -0.025062969, -0.0284834635, 0.0740558878, -0.0193902068, -0.0368550234, 0.0010779994, 0.0323487334, 0.0491586961, 0.0377462022, 0.0081146481, 0.02441727, -0.0002774538, 0.0141618615, 0.0370769911, -0.0353317074, -0.027768787, -0.0111896424, -0.0398144498, -0.0139858499, -0.0463568121, -0.0619939119, 0.0372696035, -0.0307580084, 0.0179590899, -0.0068458961, 0.0421897173, 0.0021377387, -0.0830192491, 0.0745766163, -0.0063084164, -0.0022496877, 0.0109677119, -0.0243165046, 0.0122266924, 0.0358867832, -0.0137882074, 0.0496062376, -0.0346438549, 0.0187646393, 0.0681696907, 0.0016533105, 0.0065000905, 0.0196308531, 0.0051572346, -0.0132037057, 0.0207554139, -0.0079448447, -0.004291954, -0.0452081449, 0.0175263267, 0.0036766427, -0.012842509, 0.0100408057, -0.0010893155, 0.0151461158, 0.0097590853, 0.0342067629, -0.0448607765, 0.0096508469, -0.0365174226, 0.0036992957, 0.0593393743, -0.0080032805, -0.0588434786, -0.0747874007, 0.0023646334, -0.0173260607, 0.0241379403, 0.0011873089, 0.015001501, 0.027193008, 0.0072359517, -0.0577580817, 0.0241123196, -0.0325086266, 0.0010031931, -0.0592340827, 0.0749194622, 0.0418146998, 0.0389063023, 0.0224372838, -0.0228995252, 0.0018696365, 0.0407133065, -0.0154907089, 0.0329200923, -0.0234633479, 0.0185765382, -0.0214309804, 0.0207939986, 0.0023772481, 0.0378044322, -0.0368772596, 0.0465657488, -0.048632361, -0.0047769211, 0.0678116232, -0.02650984, 0.0363214985, -0.0020708486, -0.010455437, 0.0233690832, 0.043889381, -0.0504750349, 0.0070344545, 0.0209844895, -0.0100044273, -0.0364750922, 0.0209283903, 0.0588269085, 0.0199372657, 0.0051971995, 0.0365730934, -0.0362378396, -0.04381226, -0.0140938628, 0.0235878471, 0.0499503985, -0.0735860988, -0.0198625326, -0.0527753457, -0.039867837, 0.0470255464, -0.0312648341, -0.0257554203, 0.0303705037, 0.0192937516, 0.0341130272, 0.0109834531, -0.0615658984, -0.03854331, 0.0410431214, 0.0003374589, -0.0263387207, 0.0096318247, -6.77990391e-33, -0.0176823307, -0.0424285606, 0.0273807105, -0.020805303, -0.0394192487, 0.0203414913, -0.0223268736, -0.0118177338, -0.025402993, 0.0299498029, -0.0223617759, 0.0125120487, 0.0276153926, 0.0121378778, 0.0281780325, -0.0345996693, 0.0073544891, 0.0000059025, -0.0299719442, 0.0015204825, 0.0178006981, 0.1310250312, 0.0801753402, -0.0786158741, 0.0588903353, 0.0392548144, 0.0562113039, -0.0203395747, 0.0409631208, 0.001331831, -0.0625848919, 0.0375830904, 0.0417076759, -0.061893627, 0.0342835523, 0.0282651354, -0.1129525229, -0.0589374751, 0.0138183162, -0.0359651558, -0.035701815, -0.0460569039, 0.033958897, 0.0127224131, 0.0085352901, 0.0004507937, 0.0264145192, -0.017470045, 0.001612799, -0.0259547662, -0.0428521149, 0.0622448027, -0.0045879264, 0.0217396691, -0.0342191719, -0.0121464841, -0.0141807944, 0.0426328592, -0.0414658636, -0.0474115536, -0.0155348293, 0.019854527, -0.0092850132, -0.0318305045, -0.0259416196, 0.0412610248, -0.0211659987, -0.0217103846, -0.0366082415, 0.0081553357, -0.0280333254, 0.0522415563, 0.0211828928, 0.0069536371, 0.0519787446, -0.0115147587, -0.0991551206, 0.0119351819, 0.0103529962, -0.0045666187, -0.0301783364, -0.0228339229, -0.0465126708, 0.0119182421, -0.0141943153, -0.0077134538, 0.0319251716, -0.0142144421, 0.0060448432, 0.0085520027, -0.0033063118, 0.088049151, -0.0076590651, -0.0255909339, 0.0188900903, 0.0046741571, 0.0462494902, -0.0246803928, -0.0400791578, -0.0344640352, -0.0746445432, 0.0129016899, 0.0134985307, 0.0146662211, 0.0653847754, -0.0230439324, 0.0554649383, -0.0311890226, -0.0197462216, -0.0274428148, 0.0367671959, 0.0108758258, 0.005710009, 0.064555265, 0.006155333, 0.0339719579, 0.0153021729, 0.055242978, 0.019025052, 0.0369746983, 0.0062165386, -0.0364916585, 0.0212561861, -0.012536888, 0.0015296196, -0.0163900014, -0.0142622925, 0.0659859255, 0.0443003438, -0.045914501, 0.0275570378, -0.0195138548, 2.868e-7, 0.0986366495, 0.0397364758, 0.0427647121, -0.0410455428, -0.0036411781, -0.027650062, 0.0362630077, 0.0303670149, -0.0380255952, 0.0282779634, 0.0385200977, 0.0333517045, 0.0512392595, 0.0470189154, -0.0454348214, -0.073477149, -0.0643596053, -0.0502663292, -0.0450073704, -0.0038094518, 0.0373466983, 0.0879046023, -0.0153390858, -0.0200423319, -0.0230419841, 0.0053597698, -0.0083132312, -0.0475825928, -0.0172162428, 0.0295285117, 0.0083561847, 0.0061257649, -0.0212916657, 0.0306645762, -0.0517803431, 0.0242611077, -0.0114191901, 0.0937377363, -0.0494832769, -0.0161625724, -0.0152121875, -0.0163960718, -0.0030092164, 0.0227955543, 0.1061253175, -0.043927338, -0.0601143166, -0.0072342842, -0.028168777, -0.0006584833, 0.0185876042, 0.0001623873, -0.0069906227, 0.0021787519, 0.0347672813, -0.0009878628, -0.0315652266, -0.0812648907, -0.0081217578, 0.0399968214, 0.0010152449, 0.0070432862, 0.0368980877, -0.0320411623, -0.0068313815, -0.0505641028, 0.0156846084, 2.564488781e-34, 0.0100632003, 0.0351414643, 0.0071073412, 0.0080903722, 0.0322566442, -0.0135038877, -0.0659120902, -0.0116007421, -0.0190335922, -0.0413163975, 0.0211903956 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.05562v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.05562v1
Multilingual Alzheimer's Dementia Recognition through Spontaneous Speech: a Signal Processing Grand Challenge
2023-01-13T14:09:13
2023-01-13T14:09:13
Saturnino Luz, Fasih Haider, Davida Fromm, Ioulietta Lazarou, Ioannis Kompatsiaris, Brian MacWhinney
eess.AS
eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, 68T10 (Primary) 92C55 (Secondary), J.3; I.2.6; I.5.1
This Signal Processing Grand Challenge (SPGC) targets a difficult automatic prediction problem of societal and medical relevance, namely, the detection of Alzheimer's Dementia (AD). Participants were invited to employ signal processing and machine learning methods to create predictive models based on spontaneous speech data. The Challenge has been designed to assess the extent to which predictive models built based on speech in one language (English) generalise to another language (Greek). To the best of our knowledge no work has investigated acoustic features of the speech signal in multilingual AD detection. Our baseline system used conventional machine learning algorithms with Active Data Representation of acoustic features, achieving accuracy of 73.91% on AD detection, and 4.95 root mean squared error on cognitive score prediction.
[ -0.0279539004, 0.0671093464, -0.0178442951, 0.0220652409, -0.0126877436, 0.0017574875, 0.0408343449, 0.0334343612, 0.0758473426, -0.0160662085, 0.0105186598, -0.0016382524, 0.0493561886, 0.0382809639, -0.0310768336, -0.0320469998, 0.0411393717, -0.0319695547, 0.0540101193, -0.0482884012, -0.0357229635, -0.0156705175, -0.0621252395, 0.0201462898, -0.0354168117, -0.0143099427, 0.0208780747, -0.0547908992, 0.0067574121, 0.0031242506, -0.0710570365, -0.0171322487, -0.0372970924, 0.0410486832, 0.0000016932, -0.0506647862, 0.0269133374, 0.0013725295, 0.0018078873, -0.0529782437, -0.0270231403, 0.049428001, -0.001062398, -0.0226961691, -0.053158775, -0.0161551181, 0.0299670417, 0.0088051287, 0.0143602416, 0.0566261671, -0.0165966731, -0.0287623666, 0.0340891667, -0.0032572292, 0.026865989, -0.0443083569, 0.0430297405, -0.0315523893, -0.0555097796, -0.0838479027, 0.0101037016, 0.0784634501, -0.0388614535, 0.0597451814, -0.0207241252, 0.0228314325, -0.0112759098, -0.0125580002, -0.03393602, 0.0037376115, -0.0214260444, 0.0268964879, -0.0041874647, 0.0051429984, -0.012634581, 0.0297656264, -0.0419697873, -0.0162388682, -0.0138704954, 0.0132762128, 0.0312651545, 0.0141192386, 0.0112531837, -0.0511124246, 0.0201486349, 0.1023345068, -0.0270611327, -0.0173218679, 0.0619627126, -0.0096287765, -0.063312985, 0.0316825807, 0.0124268299, 0.0284711421, -0.049094636, -0.0120281549, 0.0239266064, -0.0863081142, 0.0313134827, -0.0551804453, 0.0025764548, -0.0001199298, -0.0749713928, 0.0335023701, -0.0253614467, 0.0296825692, 0.0038248743, -0.0315003172, -0.0334337689, 0.01297615, -0.0290625729, 0.0355547927, -0.0235805269, -0.0004651331, -0.0081678098, 0.0176282395, -0.0691716224, -0.0474889167, 0.0260659009, -0.0296011046, 0.0441629291, 0.0099805174, 0.0088608861, 0.0529524237, 0.0214939527, 0.0288964491, -0.0136310589, 0.0385707803, -0.0357353128, -0.0550475121, 0.0628577247, 0.0240627471, 0.0155429896, -0.0054473029, 0.066480279, 0.0637071505, -0.0059385379, -0.0081391577, -0.0502084605, 0.0050868466, -0.0424328074, -0.0396524183, -0.0031700011, -0.0211574491, 0.022319667, 0.0333709382, 0.0247183293, -0.0362649597, -0.0129760755, -0.0203765724, -0.0136402231, 0.0254409555, 0.0120502142, 0.0307748858, 0.0789469257, -0.034932673, 0.0128041962, 0.0321785957, 0.0224326961, -0.0661021248, 0.0330238789, -0.0141487978, -0.0011831796, 0.0725537166, 0.005932047, -0.0026143105, -0.0047308346, -0.0183978714, 0.0362009592, 0.0161395334, 0.0030846435, 0.0430927537, 0.0826120451, -0.0253378935, 0.0354473852, 0.0534055494, -0.0396596119, 0.0153391017, 0.0391654186, -0.0373686627, 0.016157655, -0.0207246598, 0.0427858941, -0.0614237748, -0.0396418981, -0.0146967126, -0.0312985331, 0.0375754461, -0.0091334824, -0.0441054739, -0.0015953635, -0.063739039, -0.0014122901, 0.0363635942, 0.0402428024, -0.018526664, 0.0024610148, -0.0227424558, 0.0025702091, -0.0008975533, -0.0364936516, -0.050533995, 0.0388597921, -0.0072613922, -0.0067475233, -0.0778104812, 0.05189595, -0.020628307, -0.0063895686, -0.0043549091, -0.0670479089, 0.0355308764, 0.0807694644, -0.0288628079, -0.0132125895, 0.0791268647, 0.0153831737, 0.0088732345, -0.0471987724, 0.0582936443, -0.0075248759, -0.0231968723, -0.0214941632, 0.0175204538, -0.0195711534, -0.0134993633, 0.0478273444, 0.0089927465, 0.0482241437, 0.0488474332, 0.0114538241, -0.0046074963, 0.0165811591, -0.0763773993, 0.0052305167, 0.046410691, -0.0666791946, -0.0152651742, 0.0199750438, 0.0160933249, 0.0094028246, 0.0009171079, -0.0057394225, -0.0507637337, -0.0031926471, -0.0509454459, -0.0033698683, -0.0180074982, 0.025665449, -0.0033689854, 0.0413042046, 0.0450096913, 0.0587978177, -0.008959136, 0.0102642598, 0.0386877358, -0.0563755147, 0.0434084237, -0.0604854152, -0.0840930045, -0.0278583188, -0.0471411943, -0.0120391455, -0.0057201567, -0.0066111209, 0.0169491526, 0.0578949526, -0.0812142715, -0.0265334081, -0.013736329, -0.0128293671, -0.0350393802, -0.0212512873, -0.0207590032, -0.0178260468, -0.0504050329, 0.0396837518, 0.0515269078, 0.001984359, -0.025234418, -0.0007738691, -0.0195543487, -0.0249330942, -0.0098446049, -0.0101868063, 0.0520063229, 0.0409804508, -0.0758617595, -0.0094262213, 0.0015848641, -0.0013842806, 0.0585446097, 0.0059828367, 0.0074065239, -0.0530294254, -0.0090420078, 0.0444168188, 0.0646414235, -0.0216197614, -0.0059297523, 0.039625477, 0.0243699346, 0.043755129, -0.0046663424, -0.0166188553, 0.0345368236, -0.0637176633, -0.015199095, 0.0284801312, 0.0592409708, 0.06794893, 0.0229372177, 0.0165296793, -0.0096470863, -0.0546421744, -0.0159350671, -0.0534782037, -0.0292137843, -0.0341297314, 0.0261448529, 0.0200903099, -0.0494178645, 0.0235910956, -0.0411168523, -0.0123973209, -0.0457453467, -0.056094259, -0.0259707812, 0.0100761903, -0.0165457334, 0.0313423015, -0.0042251865, -0.0323068127, 0.0005988992, -0.0186676402, 0.0176973511, -0.0478370301, 0.0340851396, -0.0128300628, -0.0034390776, 0.0250029862, 0.0149338851, -0.028591387, 0.0303011741, -0.0143962903, 0.0503220931, -0.0049665403, -0.0084593557, -0.0849779472, 0.0126336347, -0.0113440873, 0.0396041945, 0.0213115085, 0.0180778056, -0.0054100174, 0.0844052136, 0.0247572456, 0.0008733858, -0.0741916373, -0.0080930507, 0.0040001208, -0.0012805568, 0.0068792892, 0.0307614207, -0.0255112536, 0.0188552737, -0.0070541855, -0.0281463191, -0.0494947806, 0.0437907092, -0.0205080695, 0.0301693529, 0.0185153075, 0.0808403492, 0.0422215834, -0.0929487273, -0.0018116775, -0.0369026139, -0.0496597737, 0.0066287317, -0.011585746, -0.0127090607, -0.014439079, -0.022073213, 0.0358151048, -0.0174157824, 0.016651202, 0.0072296062, -0.0044252207, 0.0327794552, -0.0052739168, -0.0568684489, -0.0115724122, -0.0323317386, -0.0113317035, -0.0518810377, 0.023169091, -0.057192754, -0.0171256084, -0.0351383872, 0.025160512, -0.1059052348, -0.0452810526, 0.0568800569, -0.0099031562, 0.0592322797, 0.0644610971, 0.0316996425, -0.0300475638, -0.0609650463, -0.0019795934, -0.021529749, 0.0486314856, -0.0445557795, 0.0367316231, 0.0440930203, -0.0003924581, -0.0075615966, 0.0103763221, -0.0284552332, 0.0153522454, 0.0405051447, 0.1193248779, -0.0386205427, 0.0043473504, -0.0224398654, 0.0055227284, 0.0434433036, 0.0522989444, -0.0027978239, -0.0266319513, -0.0265821926, 0.0183159411, 0.0394114591, 0.0687672123, -0.0101851514, 0.0046071094, 0.0031566033, -0.0790538341, -0.0661585182, 0.0064462298, 0.048214905, 0.021986071, 0.0405900031, 0.0451042317, -0.0284959171, 0.0311881788, -0.0471567549, 0.0093793413, 0.0328869373, 0.037558198, -0.0705210343, -0.0243719909, -0.0047333543, -0.0271518379, -0.050301671, 0.0341778994, 0.0060880203, -0.0346900523, 0.0680505857, 0.0099080717, 0.0176987499, 0.0136501985, -0.0152687104, -0.0353970118, 0.0290058535, 0.0068802498, 0.0038025281, 0.0242119376, 0.0541030429, 0.0100069372, -0.006381134, 0.014007261, 0.0117496047, 0.0484136865, 0.0168693122, -0.0338229388, -0.0286709052, -0.025511995, 0.0062043276, 0.0704005286, 0.0507021472, -0.0192950014, -0.0081816185, -0.0130083133, 0.0119517492, 0.0315767266, 0.0455258079, -0.0192336552, 0.0020343983, 0.0169954002, 0.0088321278, -0.0031811763, -0.0173893198, -0.0609320179, -0.0764091983, -0.0248231832, 0.0541191325, 0.0313075483, 0.0198740344, 0.0321283787, -0.0069831857, 0.0233484469, 0.0283161234, 0.0180505533, -0.0049598021, 0.0364682116, 0.0581695214, -0.0272094589, -0.0044824821, -0.0066018132, -0.0246633627, 0.0175317787, -0.0534773022, -0.0188166853, 0.0315496661, 0.0542989783, -0.0029667362, 0.0344800279, 0.0001839117, 0.0416863933, -0.0307677761, -0.0170804039, 0.0126496218, -0.0022355274, 0.0116263125, -0.0315588675, -0.0218108073, 0.0226153117, 0.048497308, -0.0512447171, -0.028114453, -0.0107667642, -0.0203860234, -0.0284780301, -0.0377243087, 0.0142944343, -0.02025171, -0.0891049355, -0.0161950327, 0.0126966331, -0.0486107245, 0.0444693603, -0.0271170847, 0.0348757207, 0.0129901301, 0.0250226427, 0.0312426873, -0.0172594972, 0.0094306655, -0.0247339997, -0.018296577, -0.0627313405, -0.0090995459, 0.0010738655, -5.162795066e-33, 0.0090139098, 0.0107021946, -0.0032066184, -0.0180274267, 0.0426704288, 0.0289690066, -0.0136222467, 0.0319809206, 0.0185273476, 0.0171480831, 0.0149964187, -0.0206555873, 0.0342091508, 0.0136742797, 0.0112843486, -0.032417655, 0.0397570394, -0.0235782489, 0.0264922101, 0.0048692143, 0.0427386165, 0.0088474164, 0.0705829784, -0.0423699729, 0.0268879868, 0.0255600568, -0.0029953397, 0.0052217697, 0.030263273, -0.008816734, -0.0434975512, 0.078606993, 0.0222488791, 0.016247496, 0.0244204197, 0.0089076748, -0.0390636772, -0.0097932434, 0.0192622747, 0.0406203605, -0.0364767611, 0.0255443081, -0.0185370743, 0.0246222969, -0.0346161723, 0.0370348655, 0.0822718814, -0.0663436204, 0.0111071244, -0.0351880454, 0.0023044723, 0.0023877777, -0.0213533714, 0.0429745018, 0.0509846546, 0.0531912483, -0.0450933129, -0.0327537693, -0.0274088178, 0.0463242866, -0.0443964452, 0.0193442572, 0.0261201356, -0.0566274822, -0.0163467843, 0.0484250039, 0.0855613872, -0.0765224397, 0.0218223631, 0.0128744114, -0.0289548747, 0.0620708838, 0.0747690797, -0.0433947854, 0.0198716, -0.0583913364, -0.0375087522, -0.0006698133, 0.0871634632, -0.0294566359, 0.0019306575, -0.0344453976, -0.0498881191, 0.0045211427, -0.028707549, 0.0089089954, -0.0231905207, -0.0062842327, 0.0141867129, -0.0222151577, 0.0364294499, -0.0107162781, 0.0384866297, -0.032718882, 0.0363562666, -0.0208269265, 0.039654471, -0.001578413, 0.0054568802, -0.0025886677, -0.0182828289, -0.0408755355, 0.0243210904, -0.0227699708, 0.041561272, -0.0154945161, 0.0082682064, 0.0335110575, -0.0444181338, 0.009266641, 0.0381117798, 0.0054124584, -0.007742635, 0.0331867374, 0.0010428773, -0.0117669851, -0.0178955626, 0.055334013, -0.0249599442, 0.0026944976, -0.028043991, -0.0040590796, -0.0237010103, 0.0547049008, -0.0370160826, -0.0332251415, -0.0207401738, -0.024487121, 0.0122866957, -0.0362962373, 0.0051002535, 0.0149221383, 2.399e-7, 0.0044896142, 0.0331225023, -0.0251671448, 0.0262793433, 0.0249942802, -0.0244387481, -0.0264748689, -0.0236374978, -0.002156656, 0.0429616384, 0.0118979225, -0.023631122, 0.0343003608, 0.037750192, -0.0983920619, 0.0169189628, -0.1050049588, 0.0013959162, -0.0622462519, 0.0665402114, -0.0062469002, 0.0428589545, -0.0417402685, -0.0736911297, 0.0180390626, -0.0235221535, 0.0025820127, -0.0216848757, 0.0269842856, -0.0160977114, 0.0506006405, -0.039535623, 0.0554122105, 0.0682104155, -0.0544727668, 0.0116390195, 0.0204682294, 0.0203409363, -0.0389596, -0.0198792852, 0.0381959081, 0.0752293542, -0.0301813595, 0.0382692851, 0.0688945055, 0.015587029, -0.0590194836, -0.0395023227, -0.0317745283, 0.0052163107, 0.0511172526, 0.0057536177, 0.0272151101, -0.0292366594, 0.0167947523, -0.0011387869, -0.0096054748, 0.0254197847, 0.0118139433, 0.0254830196, -0.044988513, -0.0174312666, 0.0016160255, -0.0358201079, 0.01004175, -0.0859280378, 0.0014274262, 1.656471397e-34, 0.0348498151, -0.0004127475, 0.0096720299, 0.0116820447, -0.0549914017, -0.0502536483, 0.0415122584, 0.0188470259, -0.0287126508, -0.0119317695, -0.0068100924 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.05543v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.05543v1
Classification of Cross-cultural News Events
2023-01-13T13:41:18
2023-01-13T13:41:18
Abdul Sittar, Dunja Mladenic
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI
We present a methodology to support the analysis of culture from text such as news events and demonstrate its usefulness on categorizing news events from different categories (society, business, health, recreation, science, shopping, sports, arts, computers, games and home) across different geographical locations (different places in 117 countries). We group countries based on the culture that they follow and then filter the news events based on their content category. The news events are automatically labelled with the help of Hofstedes cultural dimensions. We present combinations of events across different categories and check the performances of different classification methods. We also presents experimental comparison of different number of features in order to find a suitable set to represent the culture.
[ -0.0006339955, 0.0173309855, -0.0270302128, 0.0071328823, -0.0223647356, 0.0422153324, 0.0450152569, 0.0103740944, 0.0751206353, -0.0693930909, 0.012907506, -0.0127376625, -0.0017669098, 0.0589493103, -0.0217336994, -0.0741644278, 0.0491720103, 0.0138325011, 0.0007692197, 0.0044462229, -0.0136395879, 0.0397398137, 0.0099381367, 0.0068917805, -0.0001364168, 0.041277647, 0.0007203848, -0.0373915508, 0.0404247046, -0.0209232867, 0.0103663085, -0.0158066954, 0.0256237369, -0.0092022177, 0.0000018539, -0.0621264055, -0.0381540023, -0.040789213, 0.0814262778, -0.0080249812, 0.0591110513, -0.0141861001, -0.0173680764, -0.0027252662, -0.0160220955, -0.0770347342, 0.000758759, 0.0533154756, 0.012449149, 0.0869174302, -0.0137187904, -0.0366639495, -0.038773112, 0.0186952464, -0.000808042, -0.0123264045, 0.0232480969, 0.0328404233, -0.0105180321, 0.027437279, -0.0013552114, -0.0211575888, -0.0285090785, 0.038061358, -0.0401784405, 0.027504459, -0.0613943301, -0.0117636323, 0.0345621295, -0.0155111905, 0.0148022575, -0.0173446015, 0.0437859744, 0.0159527641, -0.0348511413, 0.0193368476, -0.0247029047, 0.0222816076, -0.0044387761, 0.0139369788, 0.0594385006, 0.0696487427, -0.0272282381, 0.058539439, 0.027382955, 0.0513209105, 0.0018631686, 0.0310871936, -0.067684114, -0.015272907, 0.0226902738, -0.0416544378, 0.0365709998, 0.0071132989, 0.0276855715, -0.0167278331, 0.0205213353, 0.038169302, 0.0303841829, -0.1002267972, -0.0888706669, 0.0266075544, -0.0121091623, 0.0349296555, 0.0207412653, -0.0016650442, 0.0203757323, -0.0179925133, -0.0026327209, -0.0007527078, -0.0973699763, 0.0622847751, 0.0536052361, 0.0125129707, -0.0067834309, -0.0126241837, -0.0871709734, 0.0120078437, 0.0062499214, -0.0091519635, -0.0028101972, 0.0120436931, 0.0290463082, 0.0209569223, -0.0164825842, 0.0163347293, -0.0928910673, 0.0061880746, -0.0788404867, 0.0312686712, 0.0683211461, 0.0244602934, 0.0128514636, 0.011249572, 0.0066429083, -0.000596541, -0.0117030898, 0.001695095, -0.0855120793, 0.0070868903, -0.0024113676, -0.0154308993, 0.0376114026, -0.0545953996, -0.0021119234, -0.0180199668, 0.0175954252, 0.0050357776, -0.01021781, -0.017421687, -0.0406068116, 0.0030541059, 0.0130048869, 0.0214294158, 0.1226188019, 0.0081188967, 0.002977157, 0.0533938706, -0.0119354902, 0.0405115038, 0.0826758742, 0.0261312611, -0.0051321969, -0.0091201747, -0.0408218913, -0.0016199909, -0.0369254276, -0.020929873, 0.002393798, -0.0315767191, 0.0147928996, -0.0409601964, -0.0102708861, 0.0011667173, -0.0050597913, 0.0361696035, 0.0165752638, 0.0385495126, -0.0000028862, 0.0104521774, -0.0269262604, 0.0029157628, 0.0411422886, -0.0054841936, -0.0135461576, -0.008641433, -0.0013588609, 0.0534302481, -0.0587086901, -0.0286208205, 0.0115926098, -0.0084398249, 0.0656848997, 0.0187106617, 0.0491233319, -0.0595283322, 0.0527390912, -0.0129186111, 0.0315997265, -0.0304129142, 0.0062697311, -0.022333106, 0.0482960865, 0.0461517796, -0.0001554889, -0.0215939526, 0.0496137738, 0.0122926533, 0.0623848364, -0.0180140417, 0.0436966158, 0.0010691293, -0.0604311489, -0.0259077903, -0.0270173512, 0.0038195858, 0.0193591844, 0.0149940969, 0.0391379483, 0.0811088756, 0.0089909052, 0.0826831013, -0.0091307992, -0.0225980952, 0.0080591766, -0.0047224173, 0.0131028714, 0.0204838458, -0.0184537135, 0.0481493995, 0.0054730996, -0.0293620452, -0.0080542192, -0.042466756, 0.0011361145, 0.0039808531, 0.0521871746, 0.008681003, 0.0098239472, -0.0663597137, 0.0212387107, 0.0169496499, 0.0291963443, -0.0227828939, 0.0307543874, 0.0253984891, -0.0275125802, -0.0476339981, -0.0179280583, -0.0306501575, -0.0127397198, -0.019396795, 0.0726468191, 0.0081751691, 0.0210518744, -0.0862292722, -0.052873835, 0.0299107265, -0.0192344207, -0.0019785846, 0.0415261835, -0.0158687178, 0.0138281481, 0.0381145738, -0.0228496715, 0.0004183558, -0.0017782714, -0.0768883303, 0.0003444962, -0.0231931452, 0.0246946253, 0.009940112, -0.0097855907, -0.0213648025, 0.0178219173, -0.0522764325, -0.0028156282, 0.0074240156, 0.0255051814, 0.003587804, -0.0124594821, 0.0194962714, 0.0565193743, -0.0029558556, -0.0294239707, 0.049791269, -0.0047281547, -0.0519211143, -0.0299220849, -0.0206149686, -0.0355738699, -0.0269503333, -0.0171966963, -0.0310101695, -0.038699884, 0.0138852065, -0.0223218948, 0.0114088785, 0.0322667323, -0.0019384829, 0.0472131446, -0.0169802569, 0.0186155681, -0.0183605812, -0.0381528139, 0.0599395894, 0.031167252, -0.0910726786, -0.0018386152, -0.0395031348, 0.0012951468, 0.0106484564, -0.0195633471, 0.0257541034, -0.0457889959, 0.0389632732, -0.0374424346, -0.0008165935, 0.0184982568, 0.066402711, 0.0414316654, -0.0136636337, -0.0034439329, 0.0371095315, 0.0633507743, -0.0649245903, -0.0460452288, -0.0791212991, 0.0221474878, -0.0610273369, 0.057777971, -0.005299272, -0.049478773, 0.0318219066, -0.0528273657, 0.058758866, -0.0343767405, 0.0242816266, 0.0053070332, -0.0586416312, -0.0211360026, 0.0083967848, -0.0247786921, -0.007931442, 0.0166151542, 0.0070956955, -0.0102018062, 0.0213884432, -0.0154743027, 0.0665633157, 0.0406995155, -0.0089014983, -0.0106223207, 0.0184793323, 0.0642088577, 0.0610774197, 0.0170817934, -0.0164596997, -0.0913008898, 0.009500674, -0.0364309996, -0.0155700678, 0.0273206066, 0.0156337358, 0.0343101211, 0.0362297967, -0.0031109382, -0.0424590297, -0.0382201336, -0.0189800058, 0.0229772348, -0.0257305857, 0.0518366732, 0.0693922117, 0.0426874794, -0.0538377613, -0.0250514206, -0.0102652824, -0.0647355169, 0.0214479603, 0.0572099127, -0.0264633335, 0.059885852, -0.0024788291, -0.0225803722, -0.0281310435, 0.0031367356, 0.0012982066, -0.0219098832, -0.0209515989, 0.0385117643, -0.0669261441, -0.0800153241, -0.0244502481, -0.0026568368, -0.0301174577, -0.0635197386, -0.0621129386, -0.0023374923, -0.0378885306, -0.0116061158, -0.1021599323, -0.0306335744, 0.0279245898, 0.0115100862, -0.0206867084, -0.0095759621, 0.0196450502, -0.0066267657, -0.0613844842, -0.0598755851, -0.0113350041, 0.0165708568, -0.0176811311, 0.0320106335, 0.0096080275, 0.0062808851, 0.0028399322, 0.0039018421, 0.053976614, -0.0225925706, 0.0293244608, 0.0383124687, 0.0000979242, -0.0167906266, -0.0008169471, 0.0164610315, 0.0296244901, 0.0013808326, -0.0235541482, -0.0186742134, 0.039822679, -0.0274370667, -0.0162758417, 0.0082872454, -0.048348479, 0.0284395665, -0.0553364418, -0.1320219487, -0.0165223796, -0.0240928605, -0.013284089, 0.0400024913, -0.0142041566, -0.0303047709, 0.024941925, 0.0384658128, -0.032022465, 0.0168646295, 0.009080519, 0.0058440142, 0.0441973619, -0.023447929, 0.02465255, 0.0144691644, 0.0025450252, -0.0005915917, 0.0194228515, -0.0011291454, 0.0236216094, -0.0337643586, 0.0033124338, -0.0324136578, 0.0272407942, -0.0032301669, 0.0457649156, 0.0119991191, -0.0321236663, -0.0377659276, 0.0094173998, 0.0147922793, -0.0163719654, 0.0019027917, 0.0079018855, 0.0392955393, -0.00738511, 0.0013733947, -0.1009185165, 0.0128679881, -0.025793381, -0.0304675885, 0.0039390381, -0.0465904847, -0.0452427715, -0.0183570608, -0.048543904, -0.0052748532, -0.0153895076, 0.0212707892, -0.0422634855, 0.0231278446, -0.0044516432, -0.0382254012, 0.0463228971, -0.0164306518, -0.0242412705, -0.0613643043, 0.0341271013, 0.0491926558, 0.0836902112, -0.0734695122, 0.0402647592, -0.038188953, -0.0124340216, -0.0104824789, -0.0289374441, -0.0503154807, 0.0337477066, -0.0125643527, -0.0114200683, -0.0389968567, 0.0005753092, -0.0109513029, 0.0541456752, 0.0077896086, 0.0274283942, 0.0699616671, -0.0522750504, -0.0245484505, 0.0143684605, -0.0406810381, 0.0056403312, 0.043831788, -0.0027432207, -0.0386789218, -0.0214812048, 0.0190232024, -0.0166717973, 0.0019840428, 0.023975186, -0.0040392526, -0.0664606243, 0.0695960447, -0.0693788975, -0.0336498544, 0.0182161517, 0.1200750247, 0.0308456961, -0.0468028858, -0.0044706161, -0.0720604211, 0.0048368545, 0.0368735939, -0.0243686624, 0.0119481916, 0.0262790956, 0.010496011, 0.0589502677, 0.019618025, -0.002716254, -0.0503344946, -0.0121302633, -0.0720537081, 0.0081408238, 0.0371279679, -5.78828663e-33, -0.0049275202, -0.0611098409, -0.0127700595, 0.0432788618, -0.0181873813, -0.0103707518, 0.0053524529, -0.0035757867, -0.0237971973, 0.0057869479, 0.0168988779, -0.0054062745, 0.0228678007, -0.0287487805, 0.0308557469, -0.00296501, -0.0033396769, -0.0077822921, -0.0168821421, 0.0373864956, 0.0290545784, 0.0034694714, 0.0389791057, -0.0987397432, 0.0096830055, 0.0485295877, 0.0054375678, -0.026651755, 0.1309158802, 0.036560379, -0.0402775705, 0.0500668287, 0.0298597533, -0.0517590158, 0.0222944487, 0.0153867574, -0.0366147421, -0.0287919492, 0.0025267331, 0.0190865099, 0.0861100778, -0.0289820991, -0.0355083756, 0.002207841, 0.011361558, -0.0102270758, 0.0769928768, -0.0354842693, -0.0245700795, -0.015583924, -0.0108612506, 0.0329917371, 0.0093862442, 0.0456131734, 0.025631642, 0.0177277029, 0.0025650773, 0.0187627841, -0.0241305344, 0.0406329148, -0.0221957117, 0.0160733741, -0.008874218, -0.0285802446, -0.0085156346, 0.0066417796, -0.012056496, 0.0378928855, -0.0331446156, 0.0038949237, 0.0352867469, 0.0086015249, -0.0297220666, 0.0982834026, -0.0023494146, -0.0477063842, -0.0584054962, 0.0410614125, 0.0803079084, -0.0395094678, -0.0432233289, 0.0090868752, -0.0319284126, -0.0076679317, 0.038378112, 0.0323729329, -0.020503981, -0.0380655825, -0.0067258207, 0.0227369778, -0.025573194, 0.0465184227, -0.0040573622, -0.0292054396, -0.0200314559, 0.0308964048, 0.0247338843, 0.0125121297, 0.0185764898, -0.0092716198, -0.030004872, -0.061961513, -0.0382251628, 0.0407886766, 0.0118980771, -0.0220780838, -0.0172448456, 0.0255470499, -0.0530068204, 0.0160950646, 0.0546542779, -0.0584357716, -0.0134711424, -0.0038338404, -0.0133097665, -0.019529745, 0.0179400481, -0.0307920612, 0.0013591793, 0.016030876, 0.0398582257, -0.0887309611, -0.0494533777, 0.0505777039, -0.0044780774, -0.0050380104, -0.0153937293, 0.0327745155, 0.0160035491, 0.0180345066, -0.0073205098, -0.0351096094, 2.681e-7, -0.0197365973, 0.0214999784, -0.044646766, 0.0683153868, 0.0071408027, -0.0060675079, -0.0128052514, 0.0457899198, -0.0016263408, 0.0207941048, 0.0378599316, 0.00272119, 0.0580975227, 0.0974382311, -0.1032009795, -0.0206657276, 0.0109049091, 0.0273141097, -0.0545132272, 0.0264965501, 0.030887099, 0.0341982916, 0.0314982906, 0.0000512806, -0.0302523635, 0.0054272576, -0.0019124041, -0.0310645681, -0.0983010754, -0.0353527404, -0.0115620662, 0.0008943223, -0.0134805525, 0.0249700733, -0.021734558, -0.0135501651, 0.0555258542, 0.0134960655, -0.0066414741, 0.0136683146, -0.0146881146, -0.0118907234, -0.0067355135, -0.0438151658, 0.0536769256, -0.0138668381, -0.0122555969, -0.0196179468, 0.0122215692, 0.0040107355, 0.0637005493, -0.0008883821, -0.0198324956, 0.0351006202, 0.0331326537, -0.0104006166, 0.0405815877, -0.0436452702, 0.0042651962, 0.0326925106, 0.0045346715, -0.0118546495, -0.0070187016, -0.0072993175, 0.021287743, 0.0194104854, 0.0474880189, 2.155290933e-34, 0.0015547846, 0.0378385521, -0.0585679226, -0.0393843502, 0.0175548103, -0.0155412732, -0.0066051115, -0.0058409902, 0.028124135, 0.0029767547, 0.0192795973 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.05494v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.05494v1
Multilingual Detection of Check-Worthy Claims using World Languages and Adapter Fusion
2023-01-13T11:50:08
2023-01-13T11:50:08
Ipek Baris Schlicht, Lucie Flek, Paolo Rosso
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.IR
Check-worthiness detection is the task of identifying claims, worthy to be investigated by fact-checkers. Resource scarcity for non-world languages and model learning costs remain major challenges for the creation of models supporting multilingual check-worthiness detection. This paper proposes cross-training adapters on a subset of world languages, combined by adapter fusion, to detect claims emerging globally in multiple languages. (1) With a vast number of annotators available for world languages and the storage-efficient adapter models, this approach is more cost efficient. Models can be updated more frequently and thus stay up-to-date. (2) Adapter fusion provides insights and allows for interpretation regarding the influence of each adapter model on a particular language. The proposed solution often outperformed the top multilingual approaches in our benchmark tasks.
[ 0.0259569734, 0.0112704327, 0.0114739435, 0.0570697971, -0.0258287638, 0.01138731, 0.0131360088, -0.0269397423, 0.0670102239, -0.0410278812, 0.007274894, -0.0138459699, 0.0160534773, 0.0297212787, 0.0230082162, 0.0086861644, 0.0485847816, -0.0100538163, 0.0373936743, -0.023708405, -0.0143263778, 0.0375059135, -0.0146160824, 0.0426457599, -0.0470902435, -0.0145620164, 0.0440539718, -0.0345184281, 0.0709505901, -0.0420759805, 0.0086970115, 0.0277332123, -0.0132876197, 0.0866013318, 0.0000018942, -0.0453298204, -0.0295365974, 0.0623190291, -0.0244655684, 0.0126000103, 0.0156094488, -0.0165209584, -0.0248650536, 0.0203852914, -0.0074768602, -0.0156712756, 0.0451896787, 0.0593199208, 0.0560862608, 0.0652311668, -0.0119443657, 0.0076016164, 0.0534426384, -0.0095876539, -0.0348835625, -0.0570211001, 0.027067285, 0.0310241152, -0.0039543076, -0.0151780797, 0.0011226058, 0.0663219169, 0.0182614233, -0.043970868, -0.0611060113, 0.0096840747, -0.0508565269, -0.0008000398, -0.0090223048, -0.0031821253, 0.0085718371, -0.049229268, -0.0409265645, -0.0093100108, 0.0193205681, 0.0335419104, 0.030579824, 0.0580749661, -0.0190100279, -0.0066804001, 0.0591324009, 0.0000882877, 0.0224925559, -0.0054900069, -0.0258134287, 0.070715867, -0.0130358869, -0.0342051871, 0.0484970324, 0.0230912436, 0.0279371031, -0.0928688869, 0.0042736181, -0.0051841871, -0.0057615745, -0.0050219898, -0.0172237139, -0.0343899727, 0.0615243986, -0.1144523993, 0.0321588032, 0.0113937091, -0.0693710893, 0.0613652244, -0.0652752742, 0.0310240705, -0.0036904088, -0.0131875779, 0.0074780625, -0.0550723597, -0.0310296044, 0.002246124, -0.0271859244, 0.0407551788, -0.0395449921, 0.0340737887, -0.0518465042, -0.0065038176, -0.034438014, 0.0297454856, 0.0010504929, -0.0506870896, 0.0146526853, -0.0164327752, -0.0344483554, 0.0446438715, -0.0074820244, -0.0176920146, -0.0324119069, -0.0869774818, 0.0215996597, 0.0297849234, -0.00401968, -0.0225432664, 0.0101711173, -0.0047589201, 0.0092768176, -0.0257283486, -0.0444411524, -0.0209929068, -0.0234141387, -0.057109531, -0.0189407077, -0.0496907793, 0.0032472566, -0.0215827972, 0.0333447978, 0.0091603473, -0.0213846695, 0.0085446285, -0.010211342, 0.0120888036, -0.0069154263, -0.0109470747, -0.0019997158, -0.0397184193, 0.0219916943, 0.0624260753, 0.0263568312, -0.0083781509, 0.0535838529, 0.0180491954, -0.0125639299, 0.0152001856, 0.0226560328, 0.0124780312, 0.0580911338, -0.0064304611, 0.0281318575, -0.0419931673, -0.0260054041, 0.0205351096, -0.011410987, -0.0373747721, 0.0281756669, -0.03196178, 0.0148456963, -0.0384020396, 0.054333549, -0.0042267763, -0.0170257427, 0.0060294233, -0.0150944339, 0.0344047733, -0.0718659088, -0.0347841009, 0.0063925101, 0.0671771839, -0.0130462833, -0.0557784028, -0.0070017911, -0.0197864939, -0.0257894434, 0.0108395526, 0.0127872834, 0.0190233011, -0.0171512496, 0.0234078038, 0.0408448651, -0.0731121004, -0.0178156924, -0.0490043759, 0.0530266054, -0.0126419291, -0.0011393253, 0.0084414156, -0.0167352073, -0.022845434, 0.0200351737, 0.0549910367, 0.0815659091, -0.0157195553, 0.0160804763, -0.0023895858, -0.0372240171, -0.031237023, 0.0198015682, 0.0256617442, 0.0210965723, 0.0484890379, -0.0041708061, -0.0462603308, -0.0887264609, 0.0086619994, -0.0185040608, 0.0297686346, 0.0226245895, 0.0304485299, 0.0172850676, 0.0205529686, -0.0095546152, -0.0129961511, 0.0185873676, -0.0607777871, -0.0245869458, 0.0772423223, 0.0543847941, -0.0146821402, 0.0412502401, -0.0541538075, -0.0276580341, -0.0123173092, 0.0161703117, -0.0233004894, -0.050753206, -0.0132113183, 0.0454941578, -0.0387328789, -0.0143085569, -0.0229366031, 0.0196363516, 0.0377157927, 0.065870896, -0.0079567004, 0.0087354761, -0.027150359, -0.030106131, 0.0615356676, 0.0002155502, -0.0348920897, 0.0258735567, -0.0021406722, -0.0147415847, 0.0439071618, -0.0230595767, 0.0131606543, 0.0037171752, -0.080979757, -0.0287123509, -0.0129884016, 0.0099935336, -0.0173900835, -0.0073603671, 0.0079234382, -0.0063229841, -0.0414171182, -0.0127936201, 0.0420168191, 0.0448739082, 0.0240103398, -0.0081885541, 0.0315657854, 0.0023634697, 0.0219277274, -0.0149602313, 0.054952722, 0.0458341576, -0.0873712227, -0.0677945688, -0.0593045019, -0.0593724363, 0.0264698416, -0.0192243475, 0.0034569409, -0.0093060266, 0.0518776476, -0.0090877134, 0.0076832389, 0.0110723609, -0.0259197261, 0.0458015017, 0.0292131547, -0.0406733006, 0.015781099, 0.0325873904, 0.0102076186, -0.0093442332, -0.03321217, 0.053576652, 0.037836656, -0.0256961416, -0.0370450765, -0.051249329, -0.0297163911, -0.0445923582, -0.0559818521, 0.028752381, 0.0084717115, 0.0064939433, 0.0664464608, 0.0008835842, -0.0272478759, 0.0914191157, -0.042852357, 0.0047292984, -0.0333047248, -0.0156113487, -0.0308658518, -0.0027271088, -0.0184902754, 0.0570731275, 0.0213230196, 0.0097393822, 0.042503316, -0.0261036567, 0.0750693083, 0.0156075628, 0.0195818376, -0.0084979627, 0.0402139649, -0.0114993425, -0.054034546, -0.0321069136, -0.0307433549, -0.0190979429, -0.0041464893, -0.0780469999, -0.0081440713, -0.1045716926, 0.0153502915, 0.0467552505, 0.0608500242, -0.0018299205, 0.0020240059, 0.0254475866, -0.0136479884, -0.0015422574, 0.0180202276, 0.0275418591, -0.019825805, -0.0173299722, 0.0364047326, -0.0536429361, -0.0023275623, -0.0039418638, -0.0478370637, 0.0079668248, -0.0236846041, -0.0023255155, -0.0350080207, 0.0297351424, -0.0656756088, 0.0254977513, 0.0514470041, 0.0058874656, 0.014321412, -0.0057197055, -0.022652125, -0.001908837, 0.0233180895, 0.0373549387, -0.1071050614, 0.0028765944, -0.0338126756, -0.0477182195, -0.0269740932, -0.0025190352, -0.0154733192, -0.0889611915, 0.0604355782, 0.0054134801, -0.0092799691, -0.0444122069, -0.0069749276, -0.0380831249, -0.0112566045, -0.0067853667, -0.0205796324, 0.0157761741, -0.0248364564, -0.0051870556, -0.0531345718, -0.0183120482, 0.0238972809, -0.0124760941, -0.0214727651, 0.0372310504, 0.0224171914, -0.008151236, -0.1008291915, -0.0001396818, 0.0265352633, -0.0192947742, 0.0112380963, 0.0190947838, -0.008552175, -0.0147407558, 0.0199972019, -0.0165137015, 0.0280592479, -0.003104259, 0.0386330038, 0.1059048101, 0.0284236614, -0.0105409641, -0.0087927934, 0.0179167166, 0.0257706232, 0.0621363819, -0.0233222209, 0.0031267826, 0.0012324875, -0.0177734531, -0.0450388156, -0.0383211859, -0.0136988061, 0.0757707581, -0.0184224788, -0.0566952527, -0.0684279203, -0.0102289328, -0.0051340982, 0.0366734527, 0.0008137237, -0.0018064268, 0.0432859845, 0.0063243373, -0.0407634079, 0.0044492944, -0.0798395574, 0.0539603159, -0.0076432298, 0.0200386364, 0.0553809106, -0.0051422734, -0.0153186843, 0.0527762398, 0.0200468246, -0.0636703223, -0.0526213795, 0.03298942, 0.0159478392, 0.0627242029, -0.0306557119, -0.0043041911, -0.0099585811, 0.0457726195, 0.013981577, 0.0139818676, 0.0605177581, -0.0333807282, -0.0168824438, 0.0161112174, -0.0238901526, -0.0056258123, -0.0001284533, 0.0009497464, -0.0289781, -0.0260165129, 0.0393533669, 0.0302788001, 0.0025100035, -0.0165813845, -0.0272889044, -0.0541383661, 0.0218400657, 0.0011545081, -0.0382245965, -0.0203873664, 0.0326067545, -0.0103712194, -0.0429605693, 0.0174569283, 0.029658284, -0.0253084637, 0.0129845776, -0.0334446281, 0.0390372649, 0.0220834576, 0.0521954969, -0.0063815424, -0.0019137432, -0.0431626625, -0.0205272492, 0.0278885998, 0.0425156169, -0.0161399525, 0.0103825256, 0.0113490038, 0.0106913392, 0.0363819785, -0.0171348061, -0.0249080956, 0.0037453494, -0.0233506095, 0.0181448348, 0.0437126085, -0.0020194312, 0.0604438223, -0.0107766595, -0.0130551625, -0.0099656293, 0.0140628843, 0.0127159385, -0.0506119207, 0.0186128113, -0.0026942519, -0.0356920734, 0.0057545183, 0.055084195, -0.0418490954, 0.0552338362, 0.0035838881, -0.0348441638, -0.0612891912, -0.0706590712, -0.0432896949, 0.0215147529, -0.0154182753, 0.021312464, -0.104761079, -0.0532431975, 0.0372515433, 0.0377385207, 0.0074441447, 0.03397521, -0.036119096, 0.0563248955, 0.0442041866, -0.0083075203, -0.0554309115, -0.0252238195, -0.0095568337, 0.0371456183, 0.0425544009, -5.682938827e-33, -0.0210941993, -0.0410335883, -0.002435565, 0.003405602, 0.0200892538, 0.0255476944, -0.0289657637, -0.0321694016, -0.0416206867, 0.0612858944, 0.0240944959, 0.012861114, 0.0319113694, -0.0118629187, 0.0051537589, 0.0244852155, 0.0677176714, 0.0610113591, -0.0429522991, 0.0256664976, 0.0797792226, -0.0187883638, 0.0956217721, -0.082410939, 0.0702590868, 0.0195341744, -0.0203460902, 0.0099497326, -0.0442463383, 0.0588136725, 0.0018216131, 0.0347570218, 0.0212548897, 0.0032500331, 0.0208839271, -0.05982453, -0.0555108674, 0.0034419296, 0.0521846265, 0.0063589476, -0.0072480096, 0.0130462442, 0.0265487954, -0.023043504, -0.00568996, 0.0199581627, 0.03584392, -0.055990532, -0.0015292858, -0.0109485788, -0.1047102064, 0.0436926968, 0.0165502913, 0.0163402911, -0.0161940046, 0.0655888468, 0.0133827059, 0.0067463219, -0.0706814975, 0.0440229438, -0.0191506334, -0.0189352985, 0.0341452584, -0.0576271787, -0.0476942621, 0.0597683564, -0.0297326092, 0.0163105484, 0.0360515453, 0.0397267528, -0.0029291611, 0.0344613232, 0.0692316592, 0.1438261569, -0.0029495968, -0.0127904667, -0.078307502, 0.0255248323, 0.0710273981, -0.0126637602, 0.0083473176, -0.0563928597, -0.0218145624, -0.0043522068, -0.016409073, -0.0172898509, -0.0332688577, 0.0335529856, 0.0065478287, 0.0274710823, -0.013705017, 0.06877698, 0.0192633048, -0.0447186269, 0.0109265763, 0.011545524, 0.0123353684, -0.0204026271, 0.0249160938, 0.0243596639, -0.0234554783, 0.0058717509, -0.0376252756, 0.0075875432, 0.0034877064, 0.0058303573, 0.1007393673, -0.0042739669, -0.0800534859, 0.0255280007, -0.0218928121, 0.0392017774, -0.0244475808, 0.0129259666, 0.0382453576, -0.0097577693, -0.0105331847, 0.0126308585, -0.0256358907, -0.0169653296, -0.0218404494, 0.0126512628, -0.0096283341, 0.0367049165, -0.0133967511, -0.0260132421, -0.0144251436, 0.0425375514, 0.0322308689, -0.0748210475, 0.0190047063, 0.0298933163, 2.52e-7, 0.0050430009, 0.0206005946, 0.0026443382, -0.046112556, 0.0200228468, 0.0415497348, -0.0203414038, -0.002332068, 0.0217742231, -0.016718382, -0.0679240897, -0.0115197599, 0.0293106474, 0.0650491565, -0.0678791478, -0.0067738527, -0.0467386059, -0.0280893613, -0.0393917076, -0.0107922163, -0.0271077882, 0.0259499233, 0.0059027262, -0.0141693586, 0.0025731379, -0.0406797454, 0.0704273805, 0.0128682544, -0.0522721708, -0.0080628665, 0.0419728979, 0.0033071197, 0.0349400528, 0.0435303189, -0.0453269593, 0.0457646959, -0.0128800198, 0.0261649918, 0.0271453299, 0.0195643716, -0.017031841, -0.0110081742, -0.0203156788, -0.0403729416, 0.0485831536, -0.0035331254, -0.0194403864, -0.0671883225, -0.002628589, 0.0119089903, 0.0472830795, -0.0201373361, -0.0091326423, 0.0169567969, 0.0010358039, -0.0085255802, -0.005938204, -0.0097227907, -0.0062831645, -0.0056023519, 0.0112756183, -0.0398381539, 0.0279345997, -0.0354144685, 0.031920094, -0.0943935588, 0.0267553329, 2.059148581e-34, 0.0442040116, -0.0048165489, 0.0310740285, -0.0322817452, 0.0512138531, 0.0164910592, -0.0294119474, -0.0102855666, -0.0059055742, -0.0056994511, -0.0118678361 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.05487v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.05487v2
FUN with Fisher: Improving Generalization of Adapter-Based Cross-lingual Transfer with Scheduled Unfreezing
2023-01-13T11:26:53
2024-04-04T07:43:16
Chen Cecilia Liu, Jonas Pfeiffer, Ivan Vulić, Iryna Gurevych
cs.CL
cs.CL
Standard fine-tuning of language models typically performs well on in-distribution data, but suffers with generalization to distribution shifts. In this work, we aim to improve the generalization of adapter-based cross-lingual task transfer where such cross-language distribution shifts are imminent. We investigate scheduled unfreezing algorithms -- originally proposed to mitigate catastrophic forgetting in transfer learning -- for fine-tuning task adapters. Our experiments show that scheduled unfreezing methods close the gap to full fine-tuning and achieve stronger cross-lingual transfer performance, suggesting that these methods can go beyond just mitigating catastrophic forgetting. Next, aiming to understand these empirical findings, we investigate the learning dynamics of scheduled unfreezing using Fisher Information. Our experiments reveal that scheduled unfreezing induces different learning dynamics compared to standard fine-tuning, and provide evidence that the dynamics of Fisher Information during training correlate with cross-lingual generalization performance. We additionally propose a general scheduled unfreezing algorithm that achieves an average of 2 points improvement over four datasets compared to standard fine-tuning and provides empirical evidence for a theory-based justification of the heuristic unfreezing schedule for adapter training.
[ -0.0285701789, 0.0243175235, -0.0160387047, 0.0183403715, -0.0045555835, 0.0528925061, 0.0023966457, -0.0407927074, -0.0391848832, 0.001310888, -0.0499740317, -0.0090954052, 0.0148327798, -0.0113288695, -0.0012469268, -0.0527261049, 0.0688152239, -0.0246388018, -0.0138973165, -0.0134652304, -0.0343314596, -0.0082554808, -0.0255954005, -0.0019054494, 0.063418597, -0.0181236584, 0.0092020743, 0.0187411197, 0.037330348, 0.0042278753, 0.0080086002, 0.0364395566, 0.0241258349, -0.0085991723, 0.0000020512, -0.0481322967, -0.03205432, -0.0309143811, -0.0007550376, 0.0143526979, 0.0271659363, -0.0461213365, 0.0073406124, 0.0134989526, -0.0115822265, -0.0289186239, 0.0676847994, 0.0400498994, -0.0154967913, 0.0640727803, -0.0210889243, -0.006663491, 0.0107055837, -0.0150459036, 0.0103506763, -0.0787921697, 0.0454477705, 0.0371323265, -0.0485767126, -0.0216262564, -0.0471326075, 0.0345754661, -0.0089835329, 0.0227290094, 0.0091410708, 0.0170554239, -0.0422790162, 0.0056663672, -0.0311023798, 0.0542679504, -0.0697232261, -0.0339521468, -0.0113038737, -0.025809681, 0.0175622031, 0.0144022638, -0.0622994155, 0.0071552531, 0.0119960178, 0.0286524054, 0.0481171086, -0.0418418422, 0.0337313265, -0.0283246897, -0.0550478175, 0.0571358167, 0.0231107455, 0.0097787278, 0.0592540205, 0.0322372206, -0.0181171671, -0.0184301995, -0.0127062686, 0.0100635597, -0.0029739246, -0.0179965179, -0.0428200141, -0.0457819067, -0.0321077444, -0.0165496394, 0.0947037712, 0.0531301089, -0.0252741463, 0.022089852, -0.0320144072, 0.0406483822, 0.0038757527, 0.0628483817, -0.0504143573, -0.0023543399, -0.0891363099, 0.0270257518, -0.0363353193, -0.0046194671, -0.0051613702, 0.0442639627, -0.029670367, 0.0394806564, -0.0101688942, -0.044839099, 0.0140991062, -0.0188915171, -0.0943020135, 0.021952536, -0.0216056053, 0.0811864659, -0.0137138152, 0.0358126275, -0.0140558016, -0.0184970144, -0.0276294183, 0.0159791894, 0.0341065526, -0.0668453798, 0.0203618631, 0.0398816913, -0.0590609014, -0.0160671305, -0.0459704064, 0.046887815, -0.0094241668, -0.0712883323, 0.0397316962, -0.0255099498, 0.0364037529, 0.0002010275, 0.0137150344, -0.0502457805, -0.0427276976, -0.0403666385, -0.0492432788, 0.0589442849, 0.0317754559, 0.0109467069, 0.007621035, -0.043086011, -0.0070233266, 0.1001493186, 0.0090345629, -0.0423204936, 0.0166377965, -0.0526114404, -0.0107488437, 0.0326301754, 0.0187561531, 0.0416604765, -0.0217291079, -0.0179826617, 0.0776484311, 0.0004181162, 0.0529536195, -0.0012427715, -0.0091792624, 0.0074953223, 0.0542399473, -0.0103285043, 0.0112386663, 0.0309561398, 0.0425632261, -0.0211135857, -0.0330301598, 0.0404608063, -0.0570927709, 0.0409776308, -0.0044775433, -0.0310291592, -0.0318375304, 0.0428448692, -0.0495568849, -0.0014070522, 0.0459706523, -0.0170935653, 0.0111058364, -0.0144113312, 0.0614252761, 0.0379048735, -0.0142169185, 0.0439219847, 0.0572509617, -0.0298883095, 0.0530496538, -0.0095202727, -0.0074101877, 0.0440388359, -0.0354450494, 0.0019978709, -0.0659031123, -0.013395003, 0.0585547313, -0.0295086019, 0.0580551177, 0.0142758936, 0.0614962578, -0.0406215601, -0.0386598296, 0.0303213224, 0.0045480616, 0.0248953737, -0.0235304721, 0.0554620251, -0.0111269085, -0.0641602576, -0.0474545285, 0.0242954846, -0.0727861598, -0.0305304509, 0.0627183393, -0.0041472442, 0.0072614229, -0.0290732216, -0.0075209467, -0.0403889567, 0.0177446026, -0.0538355783, 0.0095914127, 0.0813353658, -0.0537571386, 0.0024894872, 0.0166194551, 0.0234759059, 0.0297460277, 0.0348934084, -0.0271648094, -0.053178601, 0.033992786, 0.0686480254, 0.0448784009, 0.010120824, 0.0320147239, -0.015891742, 0.0484288931, -0.0108396392, 0.0188203994, 0.0346037634, -0.0086378334, -0.0350282378, -0.0341640785, -0.0156003712, -0.0639315695, -0.0083408114, 0.0514024049, -0.0219705105, -0.0033687998, -0.0172804929, -0.0186386649, -0.0288509671, 0.0002234012, -0.0505566858, 0.0345643833, -0.0151130455, 0.0449247546, 0.0164329186, 0.0225218572, -0.0013980852, 0.0010727905, -0.0332244709, 0.0529132597, -0.0186664555, 0.0193671174, 0.0125721907, -0.0034587705, -0.0025246395, -0.0086676329, -0.0064352858, 0.009120129, 0.0315006897, -0.0197913125, -0.0133612501, -0.0613176003, 0.0422492288, -0.0179076921, -0.0072758035, -0.0267917104, 0.0039050577, -0.0362780914, 0.0019012936, 0.0336335301, 0.0804175586, 0.0055709686, -0.0471551083, 0.0357199609, -0.028607253, -0.0431652553, 0.0186744109, -0.0297790412, -0.0634686425, -0.0396339372, -0.0108746327, -0.0293136425, 0.0640225336, -0.0206803177, -0.0064732311, -0.0418573767, -0.0134958979, -0.0271219462, 0.0058293017, -0.0363989323, 0.069674924, -0.0228015706, -0.0132821873, -0.0297794379, -0.0290388186, 0.0200500693, 0.0225284547, 0.0015165163, -0.0650984645, -0.0243504997, -0.0057613798, 0.010135795, -0.0026952624, 0.0071409093, 0.0569701791, -0.0196963418, -0.0638348237, -0.0569964759, 0.0256692506, -0.0002737578, 0.0689534545, -0.0158103444, -0.0113266632, -0.0364122875, -0.0128311524, -0.0123202298, -0.0255770888, 0.0040906565, 0.0292001925, 0.0185604971, -0.0531806275, -0.0650201067, -0.0351208672, 0.0486431345, 0.0261518881, -0.0327242017, -0.0103287632, -0.0113722337, 0.0183336921, 0.0274332818, 0.0576752834, -0.0415649898, -0.0305799767, -0.0030840966, -0.0109811453, 0.0734666511, 0.0112725822, -0.0077423118, 0.0170423035, 0.031209914, -0.0021518802, -0.0296694804, 0.0259047057, 0.0798286721, -0.0087657087, -0.0276690442, 0.043289993, -0.0189486556, -0.0478560664, -0.0042044711, -0.0132694775, 0.0541437492, 0.014231056, 0.0303024929, -0.0703962967, -0.0348899253, 0.0128103234, 0.0391200818, 0.0425178036, -0.0310949236, 0.0119877458, -0.0519695505, 0.0078857541, 0.0401814543, -0.1026266664, -0.0087355962, -0.031108072, -0.0014434258, -0.0511001684, 0.0461051576, -0.0134439254, -0.0227378253, 0.0109159201, 0.0481776483, -0.0058732615, -0.0561304353, 0.019312162, -0.0435532592, 0.0399430431, 0.0330857374, 0.016739605, -0.0491910018, -0.0351908728, 0.0412073992, -0.0393068641, -0.0078610918, -0.0115118567, 0.0097405659, 0.0225438885, -0.0313044228, 0.035809882, 0.0115273222, -0.0077841724, -0.0113407997, 0.0292712245, 0.0860634223, 0.0262541622, -0.0269635916, 0.0625768676, -0.0396792181, 0.0538254306, 0.0669101551, -0.0088547226, -0.0518458337, -0.0042880382, 0.0180476476, -0.0106997015, -0.0847003236, 0.0008458353, 0.0205190144, -0.0369703136, -0.0343562476, -0.0621671006, 0.0008541067, 0.0270195622, 0.0421975963, 0.0385590792, 0.0257965121, -0.0319372714, 0.0024825276, -0.0373456962, 0.0096062589, -0.0491579659, 0.0115883807, -0.0193554144, -0.0490133427, 0.0002565517, -0.016944468, 0.0141816549, -0.0006558669, -0.0435561351, -0.0614046529, 0.0208666641, 0.0628419593, 0.0158325844, 0.0693775117, 0.0266197789, 0.004149206, 0.0315400995, 0.0727741942, 0.0267136116, 0.0584259145, 0.0521760285, -0.0040052719, 0.0160274133, 0.0356558412, -0.0414325707, -0.0127169229, 0.0445345417, 0.0235439204, 0.0006719822, -0.013173054, -0.0112323463, -0.0021077597, 0.0076726614, 0.0173359457, -0.0630376562, -0.0178456418, 0.0234318618, 0.0273895711, 0.0089009395, -0.0226140358, -0.0460268334, 0.0654983371, 0.0545812026, 0.0062470194, 0.061848674, 0.0092697265, -0.0116683571, -0.0244899616, 0.0033125135, 0.0096786013, 0.0323603377, 0.0140334554, 0.063604854, -0.0098057147, -0.0095463432, 0.0559780151, 0.0607663468, -0.0381276645, 0.0417001657, 0.0006338893, 0.0329597779, -0.0505727902, -0.0245623551, -0.0412054248, -0.0537501574, -0.0082563432, -0.0349519327, 0.0497188792, -0.0427007712, 0.0709295571, 0.0100208558, 0.0055234795, -0.0470837317, 0.0185221992, -0.027321646, 0.0348111242, -0.0113761574, -0.0048589306, -0.0094195837, 0.0076678395, 0.0598595366, -0.0382061489, 0.0654896945, 0.0046805376, 0.0312844329, -0.0223641172, 0.0030837846, 0.0182740018, -0.0297209993, -0.0072582066, -0.0293138251, 0.0047965599, -0.0553576313, 0.0285968613, -0.0487086773, 0.0107183876, -0.0066102287, -0.0020800175, 0.0297589656, -0.0419540294, -0.0094840936, -0.0303700399, -0.0095617902, 0.0335387774, 0.022424886, -0.019298844, -6.623184064e-33, -0.0334221944, 0.0374231227, 0.0011518208, 0.0101711219, 0.0023053489, -0.0243673213, -0.0276267324, 0.0050488589, -0.0207349416, -0.0086531108, -0.0094543835, -0.0071698055, 0.034396302, 0.0188641455, 0.0138647705, -0.0186913982, 0.0326942168, -0.0168815535, -0.0420672596, 0.0412167758, 0.085765928, 0.0595712811, 0.0899601206, -0.0369358994, 0.0042964593, 0.0394582525, 0.0213198233, 0.0050663059, 0.0177750271, 0.0062856749, 0.0228626858, 0.0558355413, 0.0253698565, -0.0129114594, -0.0263841022, 0.0071014641, -0.1195935383, -0.028200794, 0.0124702137, 0.0149227362, 0.0014120173, -0.0317888409, 0.0522510856, -0.0173321739, 0.0045439615, -0.0487442873, 0.0117980102, -0.0379909948, -0.0499952734, 0.0222280398, -0.0868942663, -0.0156780183, 0.0083700316, -0.0132317487, 0.0131185912, 0.0125064915, -0.0038041424, -0.039514035, -0.0382607803, -0.0148090208, -0.0335197113, 0.0214407053, 0.0424852446, 0.0420321785, -0.0040094773, 0.0246525221, 0.0583489984, 0.0500673428, 0.0458139963, -0.0331295095, 0.0512987748, 0.0145353694, 0.005303055, 0.0386807211, 0.0405670032, -0.053308472, -0.0586589314, 0.0440756157, 0.0061262571, 0.0085157109, 0.0091680707, 0.0326357633, 0.0062407269, -0.033427868, -0.0236061197, -0.0027826806, -0.0172603056, -0.0184741113, 0.02829016, 0.0011127758, -0.0167285148, 0.0105407862, 0.0681573749, -0.0268116612, 0.0144853909, 0.0015623134, -0.015733894, 0.0020570934, -0.0078936797, -0.034211535, -0.081561856, -0.0923652649, -0.0185496882, 0.0049922923, 0.0222690292, 0.007535731, 0.0890635252, 0.0399827026, -0.0481083244, -0.0312370807, -0.0456002653, 0.0135834636, 0.0459659733, 0.0677178353, 0.032983236, 0.0176768154, -0.0158431903, 0.0063606948, 0.0351460576, -0.0409886949, -0.0213363376, -0.0187828727, 0.004716719, 0.0379829966, -0.0079078283, 0.0039485423, -0.0136951488, 0.0083823334, 0.0066115875, -0.0666058511, -0.0216322504, -0.0113651268, 2.777e-7, 0.0310119167, 0.0133603951, -0.0267508198, -0.0627494454, 0.0069020027, 0.0147735858, -0.0476774164, 0.0287817083, 0.0317167938, 0.0177737568, 0.0043375497, 0.0294672232, 0.0596997514, 0.0131322313, -0.0674138293, -0.0338212401, 0.009976347, 0.0569850579, -0.0085580107, -0.0173084214, -0.0144272707, 0.0481938794, 0.0234080087, -0.0213674847, 0.0301726237, -0.0760701895, 0.061055541, -0.0767621547, 0.012259067, 0.0010175675, -0.0005715978, 0.0333585776, -0.0161825102, 0.0538245365, -0.0371919461, 0.0211285241, -0.0111097367, 0.0225619208, 0.0029644242, -0.0294406172, -0.0179859214, 0.0209569018, -0.0181930475, -0.0435224771, 0.0804252848, -0.1224386767, -0.0360590704, 0.0009886, -0.0310800467, 0.0388881005, 0.024072051, 0.0041643018, -0.0103528788, 0.0142964246, 0.0337042958, 0.0431949124, -0.059067931, -0.0311397798, 0.0069743744, 0.0812994167, -0.0298502911, -0.0463999584, -0.0339152813, -0.0498565361, -0.0107219685, -0.0276351497, 0.0427117795, 2.116793493e-34, -0.0076223784, -0.0048098951, 0.0445438139, 0.0030900433, -0.0218103472, -0.0339574292, 0.0034378772, 0.0063785254, -0.0042227833, -0.0436918214, -0.021396935 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.05478v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.05478v1
Structuring ontologies in a context of collaborative system modelling
2023-01-13T11:13:39
2023-01-13T11:13:39
Romy Lynn Chaib, Rallou Thomopoulos, Catherine Macombe
cs.AI
cs.AI, cs.CL
Prospective studies require discussing and collaborating with the stakeholders to create scenarios of the possible evolution of the studied value-chain. However, stakeholders don't always use the same words when referring to one idea. Constructing an ontology and homogenizing vocabularies is thus crucial to identify key variables which serve in the construction of the needed scenarios. Nevertheless, it is a very complex and timeconsuming task. In this paper we present the method we used to manually build ontologies adapted to the needs of two complementary system-analysis models (namely the "Godet" and the "MyChoice" models), starting from interviews of the agri-food system's stakeholders.
[ 0.0080133639, 0.0040803156, -0.0256816819, 0.036251951, -0.0248995312, -0.0206866395, -0.0155260153, -0.0208223574, -0.0136811733, -0.0045552501, 0.0451919846, 0.0481234156, -0.0263530035, 0.0615755878, -0.0160770547, -0.0201437697, 0.0028723939, 0.0375267491, -0.1113299206, 0.0320085511, 0.0427654497, 0.0212470628, 0.014240359, 0.0421599336, -0.0509212986, 0.0051076757, -0.049235329, 0.0253343713, 0.0169846173, -0.0216140132, -0.0393788442, 0.0203439873, -0.0136905154, -0.0098936372, 0.0000020958, -0.0265086163, -0.0839465559, 0.0152307814, -0.0397551581, 0.0262442604, 0.0405625291, 0.0535676628, 0.0164416805, 0.0013420983, 0.0171013791, 0.0036871801, 0.0038558831, -0.0324190781, -0.021829715, -0.0671767518, -0.0078940503, -0.0486642346, 0.0127590727, 0.0018799521, -0.0729223192, -0.0151248537, 0.0275402907, 0.067384772, 0.0449138507, 0.0360251293, 0.0064182095, 0.0287956484, 0.0233320035, -0.0083744861, 0.0192608219, -0.0079270937, 0.0326664038, -0.0271240976, 0.0047262576, 0.0032066819, 0.1079547927, 0.0329161324, -0.0179834981, -0.01500523, 0.0172954742, 0.0153762279, 0.0029086263, -0.0071798689, -0.0018243644, 0.0159205496, 0.021812709, 0.0341805629, -0.0033570954, 0.0055275722, -0.0166739076, 0.1221463308, -0.0469903722, 0.0150641045, -0.0321673416, -0.003234182, 0.0103169223, -0.0010466927, 0.0084797619, 0.0336579084, -0.0011358121, 0.0023179885, 0.080765821, 0.0280203242, 0.0139329052, -0.0316050425, -0.0340473652, -0.0031664313, 0.0066476786, -0.0190198086, 0.0717156529, -0.0089702252, -0.0404704288, -0.0085303523, -0.0312792957, 0.0122256381, -0.1136650741, -0.0004233857, -0.0353027321, 0.016061103, -0.0191566683, -0.0124826962, 0.028739132, 0.0236315411, -0.0153835369, -0.0031138819, 0.0043780701, 0.0589095764, 0.024536591, -0.0078193909, -0.022334354, 0.024860939, -0.0069707716, 0.0528669618, -0.002716874, -0.0243791398, 0.0546849594, -0.0272677615, 0.0124691147, 0.0349655151, -0.0063225841, 0.0829440653, 0.0148712471, 0.0331550762, 0.003623418, -0.0623212457, -0.002596949, 0.0019085539, -0.0328130834, -0.0263969954, -0.0063218703, 0.0158722736, 0.0629979447, 0.0208287798, 0.0098928884, 0.0139053548, -0.0626568645, 0.0149010401, -0.0144117847, 0.025816042, 0.0187176075, 0.0592563786, 0.003849186, -0.0153009649, 0.0140702641, 0.0401958413, 0.0051917676, 0.0285194311, -0.0044116508, 0.0010158963, -0.0497252867, -0.0218556654, -0.0182039347, 0.0358541757, -0.0875207782, 0.01365087, -0.0216802955, -0.0180183239, -0.0082548289, 0.02860667, 0.0588250607, 0.0091861654, 0.0497001484, 0.0260730647, 0.0187825281, 0.0559580065, -0.0125250118, -0.0340656713, 0.0266601928, 0.0074560689, 0.0077420627, 0.0105367461, -0.0556600019, -0.0295040272, -0.0114644216, -0.0443943553, -0.0012406518, 0.0374420993, -0.0196448397, 0.0038068932, 0.044588808, -0.0110182567, 0.0124295838, -0.0259779748, -0.0363786928, 0.0069253491, 0.0333429612, 0.0000082498, 0.0735894889, 0.055393707, 0.0398349985, -0.0242778938, -0.0165061764, 0.0224093646, -0.0771575496, 0.0558836311, 0.0095704598, -0.0569343418, -0.0859053582, 0.0386830904, 0.000436626, 0.0062420587, 0.0028724514, -0.0022436848, -0.0779931694, -0.0062439642, -0.008956477, 0.0479220226, 0.0357801765, 0.01013353, -0.020043917, 0.035248436, -0.0126812402, -0.0092878854, 0.0282030143, 0.0883733556, 0.0414782204, 0.0658746138, 0.0205156989, -0.0280103292, -0.0307265688, 0.0143518634, 0.0556788817, 0.1041097343, -0.013541705, -0.0104092127, 0.044522889, 0.0114706513, 0.0217892509, -0.0095010772, 0.0223098528, 0.055990696, -0.0202931613, -0.0206609126, 0.0185337942, -0.0019232554, 0.0005473741, -0.0112156868, -0.046001479, -0.0367110409, -0.0162359644, -0.0854018405, -0.0608815402, 0.0639241636, 0.0163209308, 0.0350958183, -0.0148883397, -0.0035019726, 0.024864424, 0.0212020036, 0.009114746, -0.0088480571, 0.0283046719, -0.0578221381, 0.0174674187, 0.0159933437, 0.0462289229, 0.0196092781, -0.0267188195, 0.0089615369, 0.0625582263, 0.0481053405, 0.101292409, -0.028712064, -0.0093725463, -0.0166351311, 0.0626133084, -0.0177887958, 0.0153560583, 0.0157622937, -0.0010183444, 0.063739188, -0.0169806574, -0.002888622, -0.0362596028, -0.0694207773, -0.0569624342, -0.0410492048, 0.0100020589, 0.006751121, -0.0125250248, 0.0429173447, -0.0032569955, -0.0759785026, -0.0244974606, 0.0530477315, 0.0286821295, -0.0677201152, 0.0419138446, -0.0046786987, -0.0253504757, 0.0088275317, -0.00984676, -0.039275039, 0.0126488674, 0.0208538901, -0.006027271, 0.0136801358, -0.0127257584, 0.0693371668, -0.0241439324, 0.0331425183, -0.079602696, -0.0195393357, 0.0135643352, 0.0672623515, 0.0010404387, 0.0127299996, -0.0223887619, -0.0037571811, 0.0424526893, -0.0394045599, -0.0244485699, -0.0109680677, 0.0592750497, -0.0137654813, -0.0021827454, 0.0574572235, 0.0340376049, -0.0381663106, 0.0210198294, 0.0226292554, 0.0058487672, -0.0193228349, -0.0439104997, -0.0166599061, 0.0149891796, -0.021078784, -0.0151978144, 0.0747364461, -0.0434960648, 0.1309571862, 0.0514962114, 0.0442220792, 0.0078243976, 0.0418623462, 0.0019222298, -0.0085252514, 0.0280070249, -0.0381679833, -0.004582956, 0.0524581522, -0.0256133433, -0.0395706706, 0.0194575302, 0.0665779859, 0.0090002017, -0.0259254668, 0.0432266332, -0.0423591025, -0.0028928847, -0.0583600774, -0.0037398844, -0.0452833846, 0.0025705614, -0.0067347148, -0.0988365486, 0.0010802094, -0.0065367613, 0.0206326135, 0.0417243242, 0.0386558175, 0.0518580414, 0.0141410856, -0.078415215, -0.0027689312, 0.0309483595, -0.0402444452, 0.0513820425, -0.0346035324, -0.0484229289, -0.0564963855, -0.0241433196, -0.0587846152, 0.0071555213, 0.032523822, -0.0371749364, -0.0208174139, 0.0374369584, 0.0265157223, -0.0128438119, -0.0440017134, -0.0222424176, 0.0155557143, -0.015095016, -0.02534841, 0.0331742465, -0.0251367372, 0.0297061354, 0.0087381396, 0.0022783424, 0.0346108899, 0.0375789478, 0.0209359806, -0.0235191006, 0.0037271767, 0.0194708537, -0.0227987021, 0.0125181461, 0.0008097637, -0.0204883218, 0.0060708183, 0.0125039946, -0.021091383, -0.0326919891, -0.0348355509, -0.0572021939, 0.0305108391, 0.0599677376, 0.0019288437, -0.0147878313, -0.0120717706, -0.0086788461, 0.0170835927, -0.0104151443, 0.0054660952, -0.0050011929, -0.0140566565, 0.0257200785, -0.0733531117, 0.0234860964, -0.0199823044, 0.0374310762, -0.0286122877, -0.0633501485, 0.0291089714, -0.0020377613, -0.0076928786, -0.0048974976, -0.0396328419, 0.0080644256, 0.0775064081, -0.0039758584, -0.0047618044, -0.0066198204, -0.0025849943, 0.0201081336, -0.002746098, -0.0049343677, 0.0790457949, 0.0188819189, -0.031459365, 0.0118131908, 0.0261237975, -0.0351919085, -0.0043149823, 0.0335805267, 0.0295468662, -0.0133127104, 0.0348886997, -0.0256238859, 0.0594858602, -0.0178615749, -0.0505099893, -0.0422066674, -0.0325069837, 0.0451704785, -0.0150733516, 0.0106811784, 0.0302891843, 0.0443275832, -0.0254372228, 0.0081077572, -0.0418122374, -0.0330930948, 0.0108327344, -0.0519833341, 0.0164555404, -0.0382147916, -0.043764703, -0.0064458526, -0.0075273518, -0.0099836867, -0.0356816612, -0.0055750259, -0.0215466097, -0.0139076915, -0.0320650339, 0.019337168, -0.0299222022, -0.0408897512, 0.0536417961, 0.0345108099, -0.0171765834, 0.0139002716, 0.0541867204, 0.0017093053, 0.0102048935, -0.0222267807, -0.0833230913, -0.0285120644, -0.0154639129, 0.0202664603, 0.0422180668, -0.0151087949, -0.0207871348, -0.0405191481, 0.033766076, 0.0578114353, -0.068884261, -0.0195066258, -0.017004976, -0.0417895652, 0.0135763399, 0.0173575617, -0.065967761, -0.0286250524, -0.0350535586, 0.0498387665, -0.022630224, -0.0261100866, 0.0006991824, 0.0059601604, -0.0078622121, -0.04858182, 0.0318240747, 0.0505083799, -0.0641717166, -0.0366633981, -0.0712230653, -0.0304104984, -0.0226102918, 0.0423174202, -0.0283328108, -0.0445809439, 0.0125004137, -0.099615477, -0.0069811139, 0.000341463, 0.0556298569, 0.0211993288, 0.033149913, -0.0205208249, 0.0105208913, 0.0362428986, -0.041127108, -0.0170629006, 0.0014035038, -0.1119808257, -0.0264371149, 0.0575944632, -5.855487438e-33, -0.0019598843, -0.0422192439, 0.0416004024, 0.0514918603, -0.0078505473, 0.0210742615, 0.0628397539, -0.0011942503, -0.0037930009, 0.0460501611, 0.0316056013, -0.0577630252, 0.0042965743, -0.0065841712, 0.032103356, 0.0200304259, 0.0077704792, -0.0174825918, 0.0000866689, -0.0199809447, -0.0066302363, -0.0344481096, 0.0177606195, -0.0611084141, 0.0697284043, -0.0258323904, -0.043996688, 0.0506394096, -0.0133078871, 0.0233694725, -0.0427837484, 0.0769645348, 0.0577947833, -0.0544981621, 0.0318485796, -0.0057717431, -0.0309054889, 0.0062731118, -0.0029368168, -0.0203561429, 0.0004914181, -0.0178478137, -0.0290377159, 0.03793367, 0.0092551475, 0.0212347247, 0.0222032908, -0.0464297719, -0.0396668799, -0.03582488, -0.0159047265, -0.0174966548, 0.0288740993, -0.0258400999, 0.0254368, 0.037093211, 0.0074598757, -0.0671235248, 0.0088935802, 0.0174201094, 0.0041417102, -0.0478678867, 0.0636728406, 0.0349729136, 0.0062919045, -0.0336882323, -0.0656018928, -0.0180084743, 0.0335978121, -0.0214998256, -0.042574212, 0.0632018298, -0.0022052994, -0.0103282221, -0.0727115422, -0.0208240524, -0.0376674496, 0.0141547425, -0.0443759188, -0.0176153667, -0.0239198226, 0.0000072759, 0.0203996077, -0.0281139519, -0.003043652, -0.0058246385, -0.0312661715, -0.0232183021, 0.0042727599, 0.0091225654, -0.0317863263, 0.0468087308, -0.0184360575, -0.0320883319, -0.0362596028, -0.0566047542, 0.0258087851, -0.0235399567, -0.0106474608, -0.00429693, -0.0527836904, 0.0056420439, -0.0209552608, 0.0176162627, -0.0353483595, -0.0059892586, -0.0131415622, 0.0031863349, 0.0097743459, 0.0137171969, 0.0035696269, -0.0138242655, 0.0034390499, -0.0198873114, -0.0319985189, -0.0296533108, 0.0157573782, 0.0094053438, 0.0126520619, -0.0078262389, 0.0237853192, 0.0458108559, -0.0066002556, -0.0424933732, 0.0180694927, 0.0242305659, 0.0148968436, -0.0737422928, 0.023337014, 0.1011685431, -0.0178582221, -0.0334183462, 2.85e-7, 0.0575002693, 0.0076514594, 0.0184761696, -0.0177245419, 0.0162616093, 0.0296115633, 0.0339939967, 0.0386545733, -0.0942259654, -0.0634344071, 0.0457056835, -0.0608965419, 0.0052934326, 0.0547073074, 0.0028908218, -0.0886599347, 0.0446813591, -0.0201104432, -0.0622471943, -0.0358446464, 0.0273072347, -0.073464103, 0.0149540147, 0.0168880913, -0.0528344549, 0.0573382266, -0.027905114, -0.0525136814, 0.0249086469, 0.045080103, 0.0048709689, -0.0198329929, 0.0248722266, -0.0121302158, 0.028095236, -0.0414899625, -0.0165820662, 0.0009361672, -0.0164916143, -0.0240229387, 0.0222744253, -0.0768882781, 0.0505432449, -0.0820864961, -0.0307219401, -0.0824104398, -0.0242122896, 0.0333277062, -0.0274645276, 0.0462368056, -0.0025634584, -0.033914838, 0.0436435454, 0.0325398035, -0.0303878747, 0.0167657156, 0.0516400114, -0.0231261831, 0.0597718507, 0.030407086, -0.0284716301, -0.0380712524, -0.0079541253, -0.0018766813, 0.0148303928, -0.0234674402, 0.0343737528, 1.548236837e-34, -0.0255139377, 0.0331470221, -0.0122210402, 0.0018863027, -0.0070701847, 0.0334251523, -0.0187279414, -0.0246029068, 0.0255768038, -0.013438982, -0.02153337 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.05453v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.05453v2
It's Just a Matter of Time: Detecting Depression with Time-Enriched Multimodal Transformers
2023-01-13T09:40:19
2023-02-06T14:42:24
Ana-Maria Bucur, Adrian Cosma, Paolo Rosso, Liviu P. Dinu
cs.CL
cs.CL
Depression detection from user-generated content on the internet has been a long-lasting topic of interest in the research community, providing valuable screening tools for psychologists. The ubiquitous use of social media platforms lays out the perfect avenue for exploring mental health manifestations in posts and interactions with other users. Current methods for depression detection from social media mainly focus on text processing, and only a few also utilize images posted by users. In this work, we propose a flexible time-enriched multimodal transformer architecture for detecting depression from social media posts, using pretrained models for extracting image and text embeddings. Our model operates directly at the user-level, and we enrich it with the relative time between posts by using time2vec positional embeddings. Moreover, we propose another model variant, which can operate on randomly sampled and unordered sets of posts to be more robust to dataset noise. We show that our method, using EmoBERTa and CLIP embeddings, surpasses other methods on two multimodal datasets, obtaining state-of-the-art results of 0.931 F1 score on a popular multimodal Twitter dataset, and 0.902 F1 score on the only multimodal Reddit dataset.
[ 0.0471499749, 0.0937139615, -0.0177759882, -0.0067550172, -0.002577971, 0.0093618957, 0.0280338973, 0.0308787208, 0.0048359605, -0.0229063313, 0.0258379932, 0.0024906241, -0.0158337113, 0.0076827421, -0.004743204, -0.0871009827, -0.0169177111, 0.065569669, -0.0088933818, 0.0143378749, 0.0286130831, 0.0021604667, -0.004999896, 0.0374758542, -0.049905926, -0.0170252882, 0.0116763096, -0.005402524, 0.0526498593, -0.0452673659, -0.0106729893, 0.0262949597, 0.0139020076, -0.0036389721, 0.0000021776, 0.0506886132, -0.0132361902, -0.0175932795, 0.0227481406, -0.0414179154, 0.0471437313, -0.0668652952, 0.0327343866, -0.0099104494, -0.0634508505, -0.0446972363, 0.0493146293, 0.0608321168, 0.0681936443, 0.0696088821, -0.0485238247, 0.0134818796, 0.0056760521, -0.0004688111, 0.0166520867, 0.0054854355, 0.0157745127, -0.0047985963, 0.0310195033, -0.0038633738, -0.0571631752, 0.0229944922, -0.0348234251, 0.0350055359, 0.0203270167, 0.009085861, -0.0028689273, -0.0424395688, -0.034904778, 0.068439424, -0.0177956168, 0.0334107652, 0.0008622491, 0.0005034214, -0.0169635881, 0.0129137048, -0.0181809571, -0.0480645075, 0.0400036983, 0.055361595, -0.0013281188, 0.0534167476, 0.0135336025, -0.0458937772, 0.0368650444, -0.0059685432, -0.0175189264, -0.0145907933, -0.0207143743, 0.029033944, -0.0105987713, -0.0406612568, 0.0208140165, 0.0030769415, 0.0111234123, -0.0134486761, -0.0420775153, -0.0714255348, -0.0344973579, 0.0050309636, 0.0040216134, 0.003423041, -0.0590781271, 0.0251456313, 0.0429708287, 0.0013598597, -0.0226620398, -0.0234285444, -0.0111619933, -0.0068808328, -0.0298703201, 0.0201948434, -0.0002271296, -0.033688318, 0.0038802142, -0.0717724264, -0.0376415886, 0.0108161168, -0.0044060899, -0.050247781, -0.0119600957, 0.0320791155, -0.0134083852, -0.0042490182, 0.0326848514, 0.0546995178, 0.007630547, 0.0003007778, -0.024070954, -0.0543157868, 0.0046528205, 0.0092269592, 0.0315597504, -0.0549892001, 0.0020768475, 0.0311121531, 0.0052309325, -0.0367627107, -0.0385661833, -0.0068253628, -0.0339331254, -0.008087514, 0.0253846962, -0.0281071719, 0.0173945893, 0.0168838315, 0.0129454425, -0.0208508, 0.0005234889, -0.0232190788, -0.0375771672, 0.0771318972, -0.0173724499, 0.006259528, 0.0272026304, 0.0007234972, 0.0253083073, 0.0456986539, 0.0195676442, 0.0218224023, 0.0478550531, -0.0311466083, 0.0071943668, 0.0159853343, 0.0199469198, -0.0359939784, -0.0097472453, -0.0570887402, -0.0487946533, 0.0257731322, 0.0109289968, 0.0209495518, 0.0026157224, 0.0005376301, 0.0467055477, 0.0509863198, -0.0033412301, 0.0369488485, 0.0259521473, -0.0000581165, -0.0001027682, -0.0326468162, -0.0266320817, 0.0593204275, -0.0465251543, -0.0358280502, 0.0133063821, 0.0443659388, -0.0141349239, -0.0159520395, -0.0091235051, -0.0335706472, 0.0359762423, -0.0147242546, 0.0187895559, -0.0053143962, -0.0195923634, 0.0688120872, 0.0194585286, 0.015103153, -0.0539977551, 0.0090277735, 0.0061340774, 0.0201923586, 0.0026704539, -0.0373116322, 0.0057370723, -0.0107576465, 0.0756885484, 0.0265428144, -0.0021813056, 0.0288993418, 0.039864067, -0.007486566, -0.013161947, -0.0058743763, 0.0218295567, -0.0346416906, -0.0054657059, 0.0671478286, -0.0228368193, -0.0078364993, 0.0392059721, 0.0270343851, 0.0464480035, 0.0169698782, 0.0035859249, 0.0418730453, 0.0118581867, 0.0068726428, -0.0142534673, -0.0141651295, 0.017533619, -0.0501532778, -0.0414714366, 0.0285830311, -0.0166275799, -0.0515381619, 0.0261059888, -0.0699214265, -0.026237959, 0.0884566307, -0.0636054352, 0.0052295602, 0.0751374289, -0.026755657, 0.0502402596, 0.0000685834, -0.0427597016, -0.0056833029, 0.0578894094, 0.0061657191, 0.0212712754, -0.0427947752, -0.0033267105, 0.0064948006, -0.0429772437, -0.0224588215, 0.0026317521, -0.070782885, -0.0205635447, -0.0126847476, -0.0061642854, -0.012649091, -0.000935726, -0.0371844359, -0.0022876223, -0.1361363381, -0.0149118658, -0.0308493674, -0.0155474572, -0.0308891311, -0.0031717815, -0.0074288896, -0.0674057826, -0.0117200669, 0.0421438999, 0.0030306254, 0.033177197, 0.0302949678, -0.0130706048, 0.0363498107, -0.0507436134, -0.0317310765, -0.0071322708, 0.0589697249, -0.0175783057, -0.0678596646, -0.0017364459, -0.0056892992, -0.0351843946, 0.0245552044, 0.0168055575, -0.0256823152, 0.0015444009, -0.0319486819, 0.0761163235, 0.0544269681, 0.0491571352, 0.0963074416, -0.0221963935, 0.0172662605, 0.0182016585, 0.0007703797, -0.021000009, 0.0187106058, -0.0370992757, -0.0149684427, -0.0344665907, 0.0305252951, 0.0149275055, 0.0223777536, -0.0215299036, 0.0048314463, -0.0310967751, -0.0085401619, -0.0129000004, 0.0533872172, 0.0091396589, -0.0206500236, -0.0201557726, -0.0578532666, 0.0157739688, 0.039078787, -0.0416309498, 0.0436848365, -0.0299876705, -0.0056232139, 0.0404853821, 0.0329388827, 0.0075040208, 0.0060495795, -0.0022556668, -0.0110926274, 0.0090399757, -0.0206866674, -0.0278846864, -0.0068237856, 0.0368227996, -0.010254195, 0.0220786016, -0.0390799157, -0.0015769667, -0.1043115333, -0.0636650324, -0.0482327081, -0.0655895472, 0.0031702691, -0.0205844529, -0.0313302316, -0.0194558874, -0.0003495848, -0.0234450977, -0.0342129283, 0.0391281247, 0.063839063, 0.0638804585, 0.0115404809, 0.0216577109, -0.0369280763, -0.0113079017, 0.0413195938, -0.0417430736, 0.0130645279, -0.0615863539, 0.0490934104, -0.0264345556, 0.0503650866, -0.0120016402, -0.015439814, 0.0402308516, 0.0158966742, 0.0143910749, 0.07684239, -0.012041335, -0.0138069363, 0.0229526833, -0.0184516702, -0.0514227338, 0.012113085, 0.0066848733, -0.0326293074, -0.0700935423, -0.056111075, 0.0042766961, -0.0092697944, -0.0049674585, -0.0057211327, -0.0331831947, 0.0362758413, -0.0235823989, 0.0180189274, 0.0135995075, -0.0037313779, 0.0151060913, -0.0337434486, -0.0153479939, -0.039923586, 0.0094837677, -0.0114411116, 0.0197240636, -0.0447731093, -0.0591324382, 0.0288954452, 0.0129722022, 0.0384616069, -0.0150035881, 0.0840869918, 0.0107712569, -0.0454551838, -0.0414755717, 0.0550220944, 0.0074362992, -0.021925753, 0.0741420686, -0.0364748053, -0.0319224447, -0.0264888015, 0.0596683696, -0.0315155238, 0.0140172709, -0.0563583225, 0.0929114595, -0.0029383521, -0.0343768597, -0.0569476634, 0.0167618338, 0.0502695963, 0.0037043034, 0.0307788048, -0.0840565413, -0.0152883669, 0.0382750705, 0.0154534206, -0.0234477613, -0.0503112003, -0.0195923205, 0.0093836328, -0.0179660339, -0.0539704226, -0.0299398229, -0.0161131155, -0.0194396134, -0.0560097843, -0.0690998733, -0.0045039174, 0.0127305444, -0.0958496109, 0.0520050824, 0.0484774634, 0.0252690446, 0.0011493402, -0.002989162, 0.0237434637, 0.0072991787, -0.0078746006, 0.0093513308, -0.102062881, -0.0072857365, 0.0201121047, 0.0382963903, 0.003036832, -0.0119061125, 0.0298646018, -0.0277813636, 0.0593772605, 0.0353711434, 0.0097111035, 0.005334978, 0.0438717753, 0.0002166347, 0.0038639416, 0.0491524525, -0.0195120517, 0.0514434725, -0.0144452024, -0.0505133234, -0.0149112465, 0.009379562, -0.0335964933, -0.0378901288, 0.0763059556, 0.0233576205, -0.0012830868, -0.0079650944, -0.0610523447, 0.0007626733, 0.0028690773, -0.0615708083, -0.0162981693, 0.0286445618, 0.0036215289, -0.0485296138, -0.0173647534, 0.0311779287, -0.0070470404, -0.0730214044, 0.0105566857, -0.0076411692, -0.0233516339, -0.0063371342, 0.0499635786, 0.0082677845, 0.0198430438, -0.0110962624, -0.0191522501, -0.0043249438, 0.0562007688, -0.00656226, 0.0036355446, 0.0226383097, 0.059609931, -0.0330437981, 0.0032429455, -0.0137207648, -0.0178425889, 0.0426792614, -0.0447709896, 0.1168086007, 0.0277503822, -0.0020013102, 0.000163557, 0.0335772298, -0.0320248567, -0.0300398786, 0.0264130291, -0.0419251435, -0.0094740856, 0.0128925676, 0.0548031405, -0.0547314435, 0.0035676404, 0.0286702327, -0.0187987927, -0.0062409225, 0.0530420467, 0.0442707464, 0.000751753, -0.0008123008, 0.0142684123, -0.0019199902, -0.0504677519, 0.0340205692, -0.0215480998, -0.0327594765, 0.0129849333, -0.0002813748, 0.0559730195, 0.0279588215, 0.0000369404, -0.0476708375, 0.0218065288, -0.0062396424, -0.0403206944, -0.0397046655, -6.557116139e-33, 0.0072314893, 0.0026213685, -0.0514544994, 0.0067964043, -0.0276382733, 0.0848098844, -0.0381222628, 0.0357990265, -0.0004392382, 0.0473917611, 0.0206706598, 0.042149581, 0.0002152451, 0.0552775748, 0.0240741931, 0.0369576402, -0.0009836821, -0.0319533497, 0.0100141829, 0.0064988658, 0.0485265851, 0.0607296415, 0.0711833909, -0.036317084, -0.0415578485, 0.0211634561, -0.0206582695, 0.0031381701, 0.1028387696, 0.035713952, -0.0306345299, 0.0401736945, 0.0385458581, -0.010626846, -0.039377626, 0.0292289499, -0.0821513906, -0.0327228792, -0.0434014983, 0.0233185701, -0.0851744041, 0.0177934151, 0.0426646955, -0.0197583809, 0.0226378068, -0.0422369391, 0.0464743972, 0.0260512475, 0.0402235463, -0.0361702666, -0.0164687783, 0.0343606099, -0.0382834822, -0.0221932735, 0.0312779397, 0.0604641698, 0.0252517108, 0.014837442, -0.0528030843, 0.0183370244, -0.0732644796, -0.0232189447, 0.0196119808, -0.0484450273, 0.0048867925, 0.0535348579, -0.0123147564, -0.0232458655, -0.0029888502, 0.0262791384, 0.0046317345, 0.0392943099, 0.0219451804, -0.0097861672, 0.065564774, -0.0483626202, -0.0242108945, 0.0182189625, 0.016152747, -0.0095290784, 0.035979826, 0.0061821239, 0.0311489515, 0.0289927777, 0.0472366698, -0.0260944515, -0.0187173206, -0.0541999303, -0.0012319207, 0.0278258566, -0.0182375293, 0.034690775, 0.0372443423, -0.0394054726, 0.017989397, 0.002546425, -0.0433414951, 0.0639469549, 0.0221129302, -0.0055963448, -0.011574599, -0.001670448, 0.0542589612, 0.0044048778, 0.057823915, -0.0276394952, 0.0158845391, 0.0150565282, -0.0158974845, -0.0302291885, 0.0050299591, 0.0112547744, -0.0399445482, 0.0685862303, -0.0090119801, 0.0234563313, -0.0432207063, 0.0155085521, 0.0066567599, 0.0836968496, -0.0587742366, -0.0363979265, 0.0242233369, -0.0049723857, -0.0032001918, -0.0360553525, -0.0394389965, -0.0179163869, 0.0248588566, -0.0599239431, -0.0079590697, -0.0015000994, 2.929e-7, 0.0373570509, 0.058939971, -0.0020890201, -0.0046533193, 0.0514624342, -0.0000753871, 0.023128923, 0.0614478923, -0.0076432303, -0.0285943337, 0.0305751245, 0.0420738906, 0.0317652747, 0.0370709375, 0.0245238561, -0.037351191, -0.02174397, -0.0342000052, -0.0445502065, -0.0365932062, 0.062356405, 0.0912941024, 0.0281532053, -0.030406056, 0.0037455861, 0.0029491889, 0.0799659416, -0.0015206023, 0.0127122216, -0.016635092, 0.0397317857, 0.0189252533, 0.0011815859, -0.0697319731, -0.0120636756, -0.0070968512, 0.0377222598, 0.004837601, -0.0464344993, -0.0496209152, -0.0075224815, 0.0511774868, -0.0519165769, 0.0184525214, 0.0472050495, -0.0928885564, -0.0525088832, -0.0984298587, -0.0223651659, 0.0002896903, 0.0885440856, -0.0042385315, -0.0464773737, 0.0416872054, 0.038097553, 0.0039302316, -0.0304892957, -0.1140147075, -0.020172311, 0.0320441686, -0.0420099162, 0.0145453615, -0.0313892551, -0.0578005128, 0.0146445232, -0.0267595463, -0.024578372, 1.942617372e-34, -0.0006860956, 0.018544944, 0.0199752729, -0.0193735249, -0.0179032926, 0.0075285626, 0.0002369427, -0.0533155911, -0.024601629, -0.0696128309, -0.0234962404 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.06916v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.06916v2
Automated speech- and text-based classification of neuropsychiatric conditions in a multidiagnostic setting
2023-01-13T08:24:21
2023-01-31T13:33:03
Lasse Hansen, Roberta Rocca, Arndis Simonsen, Alberto Parola, Vibeke Bliksted, Nicolai Ladegaard, Dan Bang, Kristian Tylén, Ethan Weed, Søren Dinesen Østergaard, Riccardo Fusaroli
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, stat.AP
Speech patterns have been identified as potential diagnostic markers for neuropsychiatric conditions. However, most studies only compare a single clinical group to healthy controls, whereas clinical practice often requires differentiating between multiple potential diagnoses (multiclass settings). To address this, we assembled a dataset of repeated recordings from 420 participants (67 with major depressive disorder, 106 with schizophrenia and 46 with autism, as well as matched controls), and tested the performance of a range of conventional machine learning models and advanced Transformer models on both binary and multiclass classification, based on voice and text features. While binary models performed comparably to previous research (F1 scores between 0.54-0.75 for autism spectrum disorder, ASD; 0.67-0.92 for major depressive disorder, MDD; and 0.71-0.83 for schizophrenia); when differentiating between multiple diagnostic groups performance decreased markedly (F1 scores between 0.35-0.44 for ASD, 0.57-0.75 for MDD, 0.15-0.66 for schizophrenia, and 0.38-0.52 macro F1). Combining voice and text-based models yielded increased performance, suggesting that they capture complementary diagnostic information. Our results indicate that models trained on binary classification may learn to rely on markers of generic differences between clinical and non-clinical populations, or markers of clinical features that overlap across conditions, rather than identifying markers specific to individual conditions. We provide recommendations for future research in the field, suggesting increased focus on developing larger transdiagnostic datasets that include more fine-grained clinical features, and that can support the development of models that better capture the complexity of neuropsychiatric conditions and naturalistic diagnostic assessment.
[ -0.0082599418, 0.0374890268, -0.0217864718, -0.0149402423, 0.019710023, -0.0038740144, 0.0418777876, 0.0324813649, -0.0300053991, -0.067505829, 0.007410707, -0.0316832587, 0.0440393649, 0.0076344041, -0.0118554672, -0.053910207, 0.026147604, 0.009303051, 0.0278364588, 0.0136994813, -0.0225067269, 0.0209786911, -0.0529018082, 0.0551814921, -0.0327697992, 0.0023756686, 0.0278005097, -0.0453845188, 0.0157939494, -0.0235407017, -0.0210833121, 0.0645077899, 0.0085747261, 0.0116964038, 0.000001902, -0.0364158079, 0.0002133816, 0.0109978821, 0.0208964944, -0.0646777898, -0.0371398889, 0.0051419614, 0.0390585847, 0.0474077836, -0.0252446439, -0.0578039475, 0.0430658236, 0.0912380442, 0.0369944498, 0.0278152265, -0.0418237709, -0.0236679371, 0.0459148325, 0.0137461647, -0.0155124431, 0.0056939689, 0.055357825, -0.0250611417, -0.02015342, -0.046116855, 0.0057285312, 0.0235392749, -0.0557117611, 0.0330215916, -0.0340666212, 0.0126482053, -0.0295093786, -0.0586831346, 0.0147651592, 0.0594300516, 0.0068260352, 0.0131791588, -0.0025273331, 0.010002357, -0.0012917721, 0.0100113032, -0.0284493063, 0.0078082699, -0.0363577753, 0.019778965, 0.0325680338, 0.0086241178, 0.0214326475, -0.0630731955, -0.0018228064, 0.0131630246, -0.0318595953, -0.0012572356, 0.0243520495, -0.0199500583, -0.011858725, -0.0539194271, 0.0317284167, 0.013977251, -0.0657103956, 0.004882928, -0.0313662067, -0.0628662929, 0.0299937204, 0.0103069879, 0.0025269315, 0.0169208776, -0.0732179582, -0.021463491, -0.0099938596, 0.0313759148, 0.0145439031, 0.0494372994, -0.0223421305, -0.0124445828, -0.0755179152, 0.0013490749, -0.039466273, 0.0166284963, 0.0410429984, -0.0245343857, -0.0618393384, -0.0042816405, 0.0047975215, -0.0228048246, 0.0351922363, 0.0012624142, 0.0437238887, 0.0813725963, 0.0241294932, 0.0497591943, 0.0023793473, 0.0594599955, 0.0288500246, -0.0186221078, 0.0556557626, -0.0080024367, -0.0107406238, -0.0109049501, 0.030890448, 0.0377153419, 0.028081622, 0.0049930918, -0.0476355404, 0.00045001, -0.0439883173, 0.0024540522, -0.0053786449, -0.030613631, 0.0229705349, 0.0638722554, 0.0065583568, -0.0119835837, -0.0033984368, -0.0370425284, 0.0204296447, 0.0503524244, -0.0144031066, 0.0326232761, 0.0660137758, -0.0053758761, -0.0118172215, 0.0265267361, 0.0514942594, -0.0640784353, 0.0150338421, -0.0728678182, 0.0159678645, 0.0432033204, -0.019339459, -0.0516418815, 0.0039613536, -0.03938438, -0.0165297855, 0.0345784798, 0.0202463083, 0.0523350127, 0.0139611792, -0.027618872, 0.0223693382, 0.0902440548, 0.0497344285, 0.0249639973, -0.0025866281, 0.0062539391, -0.0060190414, -0.0192868449, 0.0212845989, -0.0055241692, -0.0328697935, -0.0403170623, 0.0102578476, 0.0210758988, -0.0014581557, -0.0334469825, -0.0446148328, -0.0433827229, 0.0111160921, 0.0450843759, -0.0009323322, -0.0093018608, -0.0054951706, 0.0466603376, 0.0121811423, 0.0284942407, -0.0372155532, -0.0770598352, -0.0353947245, 0.0145622659, -0.0276422221, -0.0344493128, 0.0124257822, -0.0560181625, -0.0433404781, -0.0257407539, -0.0337421782, 0.0016785297, 0.0334401354, -0.0185443405, 0.0186145455, 0.0463170111, 0.0193823427, -0.0126729896, -0.02631226, 0.0150688589, -0.0337680243, -0.0051745428, 0.0133288736, 0.0529361144, 0.0072639785, -0.0496387407, 0.0447558761, -0.0109924916, 0.067868337, 0.0006120164, -0.0043249838, -0.0184281822, -0.0287855696, 0.0016241174, -0.0842575878, -0.0050452831, -0.0075068688, -0.0114587722, -0.0260642748, 0.0235748366, 0.0046751378, 0.0539051592, 0.0012189037, -0.0294598117, -0.0109325945, -0.0762560368, 0.0078391256, -0.003791288, 0.0246022325, -0.0173163041, 0.0374494195, -0.018166963, -0.0215328541, 0.017155312, 0.0058091902, -0.0313962884, -0.0903778449, 0.0320355073, -0.0247978419, -0.0527295955, -0.009214282, -0.068099238, 0.0276943892, -0.0423988514, -0.0514838435, 0.0234600194, 0.0033448562, -0.1354035288, -0.0092480201, 0.0226761289, -0.0239253528, -0.0199178886, -0.0028184368, 0.0107426867, -0.0002630576, -0.0082069077, -0.0047487165, 0.0475074612, 0.0439240374, -0.0086220456, 0.0220739339, -0.0313746706, -0.0130213937, -0.0128653143, -0.0647017732, 0.0554206073, -0.0174367782, -0.0303969402, -0.0417962931, 0.0113586346, -0.0294641741, 0.0112339612, 0.0036130592, 0.0244057514, 0.0108605316, 0.0114952484, -0.0041362136, 0.0481276773, 0.0277035255, 0.0618307367, 0.0438810401, 0.0223799609, -0.006220507, -0.000071343, 0.0004300772, 0.0039804899, -0.0409001559, -0.0407467894, 0.0219875388, 0.0696916953, 0.081603989, 0.0154562863, -0.0079532973, -0.0394404456, -0.0148594845, 0.000812811, -0.0017911191, -0.0401538312, -0.0328216888, 0.0266692527, 0.0161928385, -0.0194166135, 0.0454896204, -0.0267738532, -0.0132174222, -0.0558579899, -0.0780321658, -0.0320454389, 0.0208598003, -0.0061387974, 0.018284345, 0.0220293663, -0.0153557202, -0.0027148519, -0.0178272184, -0.0064799488, -0.0481449664, 0.0640360415, -0.0147307711, 0.0060802172, 0.0166104008, -0.020413192, -0.0370874964, 0.0037421293, -0.0161039084, 0.0289258771, 0.0184415914, -0.0230308697, -0.067614302, 0.0263106208, 0.002113601, 0.0622009076, 0.0129148616, -0.0346499681, 0.0485501103, 0.0548328459, 0.0094455639, 0.0222294945, -0.0252542589, -0.0372836217, -0.0404238775, 0.0120469332, -0.0703795925, 0.0602703914, -0.0198964551, -0.0046418905, -0.0052747871, -0.0253815353, -0.0412887745, 0.0386180654, -0.0001959075, -0.0024730014, 0.0211983491, 0.0999670774, 0.0329071768, -0.0395277068, 0.0109335016, -0.026476251, -0.0267830454, 0.0057902471, 0.0005341468, -0.0295906141, -0.0335793458, -0.0086521795, 0.0468990617, -0.0324661657, -0.0015504808, 0.0209761504, 0.030762421, 0.0026648073, -0.0263875443, -0.0517759137, 0.0463074297, -0.0441538207, 0.0076710819, -0.0253247898, 0.0130850263, -0.0856532156, -0.0207244642, -0.0207913816, 0.0368334875, -0.1061039791, -0.0644481331, 0.0599495806, 0.0153610837, 0.0707402453, 0.0433788709, 0.0007834226, -0.0312156416, -0.033789441, -0.0404328741, 0.0239299126, 0.0204788651, 0.000330437, 0.0525173955, 0.0390452854, 0.0360901877, -0.0400852822, 0.0177255441, -0.032917928, -0.0170734283, -0.0022454911, 0.0852568075, -0.0337127037, -0.0609975755, -0.0339541323, 0.010363644, 0.0444069393, 0.0428112261, -0.0115533238, -0.0763152987, -0.0163708813, 0.0443131663, 0.0352490507, -0.0027241674, -0.0247720294, 0.0264262035, -0.0022733244, -0.0615898445, -0.0370532461, 0.0120634995, 0.0530593544, -0.0065933443, 0.0219720844, -0.0189548973, 0.038788043, 0.0425878651, -0.0658238903, 0.0590241849, 0.1010091901, 0.0467776135, -0.0715326741, -0.0215977188, 0.0338238552, 0.0057091461, -0.0577694364, -0.0223754887, -0.0236328617, -0.0135558518, 0.0703436211, -0.0386416651, 0.0141914822, -0.0314076319, 0.0277651791, -0.0319079682, 0.0513447002, 0.0285230689, 0.0039350498, 0.0135401776, 0.0112118516, -0.0123264901, -0.01826231, 0.0135337077, -0.0124760279, 0.0609498993, -0.0348166414, -0.0423762761, -0.0420242064, -0.0134435585, -0.0041192542, 0.0122659709, 0.0490823165, -0.001689668, -0.0240614563, -0.0167775657, -0.0205896404, 0.0482177362, 0.0436420292, -0.0164309535, -0.0750296339, 0.0470216982, 0.0155983381, -0.0320436023, -0.0162079744, -0.0544313379, -0.0445290431, -0.032234408, 0.045025561, -0.0228188708, 0.0339357704, -0.0026236477, -0.001495238, -0.005750027, 0.0295534786, 0.0505125299, 0.0139543386, 0.0082818968, 0.0707121715, 0.0129675521, 0.0300926212, 0.0139279664, 0.0223577209, -0.0083816275, -0.0432900526, -0.0353874229, -0.0314971246, -0.0308793597, 0.0291788969, 0.0328255072, 0.0167422462, 0.0245646518, -0.0237611048, 0.0151354345, -0.0439286269, 0.0013197702, 0.0514639281, 0.004841391, -0.0040993392, -0.0193095859, 0.0327297747, -0.0194829721, -0.0200951993, -0.0371105559, -0.0465463176, -0.0366936475, -0.0161458664, 0.0148691824, -0.0097856754, -0.0503915921, -0.0218149312, -0.0311021619, -0.0282433853, 0.059423171, -0.064257741, 0.0417408049, -0.0288999174, -0.0147012118, 0.0222067889, 0.0009172874, -0.0264628492, -0.0121612679, -0.0318913795, -0.0146016274, -0.0317545682, -0.0228997823, -5.103118524e-33, -0.034927126, -0.021178741, 0.0161459371, 0.0138739264, 0.0066866581, 0.0286656655, 0.0213427264, 0.0452201776, -0.0027251933, 0.0054784808, 0.022005925, 0.0043566087, 0.0105785755, 0.0424962044, 0.0347004905, -0.0064795455, 0.0479577072, 0.0127607984, -0.0262041315, -0.0102622155, 0.0163729619, 0.004024534, 0.0469476432, -0.0908992961, -0.0270582158, 0.0427965596, -0.0036218816, -0.0171873923, 0.0080418289, 0.0227344818, 0.0006140369, 0.0579465516, 0.0538091101, 0.0251679085, 0.0212561954, 0.0272970777, -0.0554173626, 0.0085055213, -0.0108874692, 0.0324413441, -0.0028833319, 0.0436359011, 0.0488419496, -0.0097942576, 0.0133517031, -0.0349321142, 0.0828347877, -0.0433062203, 0.0303170998, -0.0645006374, -0.0459844731, -0.0056096506, -0.0014183905, 0.0062139118, -0.0095963767, 0.0711749494, -0.0633683577, 0.0079827616, -0.0554061756, 0.0212099236, 0.0150849838, 0.0004503829, 0.0029589531, 0.0024287945, -0.0537958257, 0.0333271734, 0.0470155701, -0.0782941356, -0.0391885266, -0.0463592075, 0.0125775067, 0.0649740249, 0.0367815308, -0.014136428, 0.0203470998, -0.0336641371, -0.0442285202, 0.0161093827, -0.0058590733, -0.0355146043, 0.0482606031, -0.0274170097, -0.013780877, -0.0242491383, -0.0543685555, 0.0568509921, -0.0182850696, 0.0021616642, 0.0296655204, -0.016250018, 0.0299534127, 0.010492973, 0.0538282767, -0.0198442377, -0.0196518637, -0.0385485627, 0.0196023732, 0.0488710441, -0.0040405137, 0.0001772787, 0.0072638951, -0.0544668697, 0.0825244263, 0.0032383443, 0.1007159054, -0.0069901524, 0.0450251438, -0.0036898174, -0.0363135822, -0.015995739, 0.0601779483, 0.005386597, -0.0276063439, 0.0861439705, -0.0321243741, 0.029378077, -0.0226506088, -0.0015643259, -0.0402817018, 0.0065239673, -0.0541638546, -0.021168001, -0.0155028505, 0.0087591968, -0.0145750931, -0.0102849891, -0.0029634268, -0.0342043415, 0.0311552007, -0.0521725602, -0.0034865863, -0.0118033215, 2.687e-7, 0.0594396368, 0.0877514705, -0.03040554, -0.0220807754, 0.0270261038, 0.0256859269, 0.0036020826, 0.0278174859, 0.0511959381, 0.0191733316, 0.0048936722, 0.013922344, 0.0243109427, 0.0818347856, -0.009042114, -0.0779857934, -0.0592277497, 0.0149326427, -0.0564338639, 0.0241928939, 0.0843311995, 0.0612995364, -0.0171943866, -0.0550477393, 0.0500191748, 0.0098419711, 0.0247155502, 0.0031176314, 0.0597620346, 0.0420675874, 0.0091260793, -0.0261384062, 0.0741111115, 0.0644880608, -0.0264181402, 0.0179812014, -0.0208822414, -0.0039366311, -0.0809941962, -0.0340411216, 0.0024361599, 0.0553674772, -0.0113627268, -0.0199616384, 0.0362912081, -0.0675461069, -0.0491152816, -0.0228578262, -0.0421873629, -0.0074026315, 0.0712114796, 0.0063332836, 0.0236919485, 0.0252432041, 0.0142818764, 0.0080258902, -0.0001747965, -0.0461107269, 0.00358836, 0.0745154545, -0.0726287439, 0.014915606, 0.0271223262, -0.0469753891, 0.0051191696, -0.0592921451, 0.0325687304, 2.254457657e-34, 0.0023157855, 0.0488833077, 0.0243317727, -0.0145490682, -0.0039485376, 0.0011401068, -0.0037489515, 0.0120766787, -0.0376930237, -0.0679073259, -0.0189726669 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.05402v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.05402v1
In BLOOM: Creativity and Affinity in Artificial Lyrics and Art
2023-01-13T06:22:22
2023-01-13T06:22:22
Evan Crothers, Herna Viktor, Nathalie Japkowicz
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.LG
We apply a large multilingual language model (BLOOM-176B) in open-ended generation of Chinese song lyrics, and evaluate the resulting lyrics for coherence and creativity using human reviewers. We find that current computational metrics for evaluating large language model outputs (MAUVE) have limitations in evaluation of creative writing. We note that the human concept of creativity requires lyrics to be both comprehensible and distinctive -- and that humans assess certain types of machine-generated lyrics to score more highly than real lyrics by popular artists. Inspired by the inherently multimodal nature of album releases, we leverage a Chinese-language stable diffusion model to produce high-quality lyric-guided album art, demonstrating a creative approach for an artist seeking inspiration for an album or single. Finally, we introduce the MojimLyrics dataset, a Chinese-language dataset of popular song lyrics for future research.
[ 0.0388765968, 0.0206810348, -0.0276096798, -0.0021599841, -0.0320356414, -0.0163682811, 0.0196541753, -0.0263958871, -0.0324275978, 0.0200887974, -0.0352308415, -0.0570995994, 0.0311356988, 0.0509070009, -0.0066075851, -0.0396416336, -0.0285124183, -0.0068399091, 0.0476784669, 0.0056778044, -0.0190380551, -0.0010163962, 0.0237194505, 0.063214533, -0.0199643523, -0.0440941527, -0.0212316792, 0.039823547, 0.0024676353, -0.0259629022, -0.0752959698, 0.0741002411, -0.0212517399, 0.019844735, 0.0000016371, -0.037812829, 0.0141639272, -0.0180069748, 0.069929488, -0.0171377156, 0.0472151041, -0.0126773631, -0.0354523957, -0.0107457396, -0.0211026762, 0.0345024914, 0.0566800982, 0.0525404625, 0.0987934619, 0.0578423217, 0.0118330447, -0.0719877258, 0.0236209035, -0.0363705195, 0.0086621717, 0.0013642447, -0.0018059062, 0.0333719663, 0.0175220296, -0.0328545347, -0.042652335, 0.0439616032, 0.0135743907, -0.0151713379, 0.0244933367, 0.0442599691, -0.0354824364, -0.0422047749, 0.032945659, 0.0340719298, 0.0069885263, -0.0018450989, -0.0167528242, 0.0056552682, 0.0089863213, 0.0110274768, -0.0477227494, 0.0011618437, 0.0340797901, 0.0097109415, -0.0451778956, -0.0371593274, 0.0177629534, -0.0254724398, 0.0248022731, -0.0214081388, 0.0344634578, -0.048957672, 0.0275462437, 0.0062846476, 0.0155540705, -0.0748418421, 0.007670593, -0.0187109858, -0.0315910392, 0.0041315919, -0.0231975149, -0.0359690599, -0.0038658958, -0.0543120839, 0.1030162647, -0.012823185, 0.0000603751, 0.0813505203, -0.017811168, -0.0232180823, -0.0135826441, 0.0094206752, -0.0630292594, -0.0101764454, -0.028704077, -0.0143206045, -0.0425118804, -0.0297201015, 0.023369763, -0.0482038222, -0.0688018575, 0.0171076581, -0.0185883716, -0.0152018741, 0.0007897599, 0.007983868, -0.0151800551, 0.0086675677, 0.004967174, 0.0073396782, -0.0050274646, 0.0231256206, 0.0040768702, 0.0337731466, 0.0028635978, 0.019431809, 0.0225967076, -0.011887813, 0.0391589925, 0.0541034006, 0.0541491359, -0.0185684003, -0.0174200144, -0.0229497161, -0.0178584866, -0.0279558059, 0.0041158716, -0.0664556101, 0.0260998607, -0.0116382027, -0.0065615396, -0.0360777229, -0.0062305229, 0.0050306185, -0.0217558201, -0.0120942425, 0.0223154761, 0.0567005761, -0.0366440564, -0.0088039301, 0.0008850895, -0.0083843153, 0.092925705, 0.0399782471, 0.0229682922, -0.0276203994, 0.0465651713, 0.017065065, -0.0144942729, 0.0118975108, -0.0502793789, -0.03402723, -0.028024165, 0.0651335493, 0.0104701901, 0.0482398085, 0.0245538969, 0.0142001174, 0.0840910003, 0.0267347842, 0.0165658239, 0.0485298671, 0.0387558974, 0.0103599848, -0.0070687388, 0.0029973434, 0.0381286554, 0.0800238028, 0.0602850765, 0.0459342003, 0.0927190185, 0.0020102651, -0.0141445445, -0.0090250159, -0.0215298012, 0.0006929339, 0.0233284365, -0.0174465403, 0.0008200323, 0.0157610402, -0.0157989617, 0.0113371359, -0.0073612146, -0.0567238405, 0.0019044974, -0.0124664269, 0.0608744286, 0.1033451259, 0.0282231085, 0.0283429902, 0.0928865597, -0.0140900407, 0.0166518055, 0.0681339204, -0.0270346794, -0.0027009016, -0.0256765597, 0.0381379128, -0.000529823, -0.0068731136, 0.0053002168, -0.0008952284, -0.073168017, 0.0496695414, -0.0156493057, -0.0121371113, -0.056121666, 0.0015939808, 0.0059883976, -0.0056234091, 0.0136403535, 0.0330172628, 0.0202609189, 0.0605316795, -0.0959765986, 0.0422228426, 0.0051467838, -0.0073495824, -0.0543531477, 0.0709600821, 0.0098075122, 0.0027794414, 0.0419113934, -0.0719478205, 0.0156093063, -0.0219769105, 0.0158871897, -0.0382860005, 0.0858667344, -0.0117302313, 0.0191267189, -0.0202410463, 0.0162727218, -0.025563905, 0.0216087159, 0.035007745, 0.0067088646, 0.0338705964, 0.0222124066, -0.0502399206, -0.01541318, 0.0466344208, 0.023036588, -0.0285508148, 0.0323932022, 0.0409558676, 0.0305461362, -0.0225379057, 0.0104588503, -0.0513649546, -0.0626006722, -0.0712036714, -0.0202614106, -0.0217702556, -0.04862874, 0.0201282278, -0.0199873354, -0.0230442807, 0.0206875093, -0.033926852, -0.02671922, 0.0193955116, 0.0348316804, -0.0119732162, -0.0196189806, -0.0465633571, -0.0015556059, -0.0124610681, 0.0071592494, 0.0026254256, 0.0177992135, 0.0225959998, 0.0048511866, 0.0144599713, -0.0956517532, -0.0805162638, 0.0162727218, -0.0419770777, 0.008502651, -0.0364316218, 0.0654785708, 0.0484899208, 0.0104033863, -0.0125423204, 0.0908154994, -0.0265576504, 0.0457996316, -0.0142897377, 0.0010637118, 0.0176163949, 0.0354654752, -0.0443333015, 0.0008997765, 0.0029535976, 0.0627888367, -0.023562273, 0.0069294958, 0.0370517559, -0.0246229563, 0.0126163196, -0.0288418774, 0.0313289911, -0.019794533, 0.0504000857, -0.0288403817, -0.0283346921, 0.0618016943, -0.0056886249, -0.0057042129, -0.002676372, -0.0278743207, -0.032260593, 0.0418924876, -0.0479685217, 0.0287093073, -0.012412942, 0.0256247781, -0.0392440595, 0.0512754731, 0.0001908722, -0.0396727808, 0.0136060286, -0.0011350571, -0.0224617533, -0.0067291199, -0.0008023099, 0.0046318253, -0.0260367747, 0.0071864142, -0.0094723208, 0.0098435031, -0.0169799738, 0.0414204523, 0.0058956747, 0.0510607101, -0.0101013891, 0.0032621033, -0.0023414162, 0.0052152378, 0.02296222, 0.0635414347, -0.0102941031, -0.0306227449, -0.0559831038, 0.0396689773, -0.008534926, -0.0175050609, 0.0262507107, -0.0203306545, 0.0095572015, -0.0239902269, 0.0499945767, 0.0205396414, 0.0285734981, 0.0353607647, -0.0395247601, 0.0216486398, 0.0745049864, 0.0068980036, 0.0103093237, 0.0023952406, 0.0021352961, 0.0056734225, 0.0163232312, 0.0022604656, -0.0265676584, 0.0085730152, 0.0082083447, 0.0182293467, 0.0290263668, 0.0105128391, -0.0168518424, -0.0662589818, 0.0432145968, 0.0116755841, -0.0224076714, -0.0079115359, -0.0145441284, -0.0287039354, 0.0411905833, -0.0148390001, -0.0095185889, 0.0041618398, 0.0406474024, -0.0188626163, 0.0375456102, -0.0640049949, 0.0057543172, -0.0833552629, 0.0486750565, 0.0900480822, 0.0835365877, -0.0189758334, -0.0407479815, -0.0103200777, 0.0167698506, -0.0025095684, 0.0330046676, 0.0214839298, 0.0617514253, -0.0082047628, -0.0244333204, 0.0089267138, -0.0407825708, 0.0055153482, 0.0247469433, 0.0469292141, -0.0218689553, -0.0479202308, -0.0271631423, 0.042981267, 0.001788157, 0.0884419084, 0.0693826005, -0.0896801427, -0.0264438447, -0.0423340686, 0.0049726753, -0.0701642931, -0.0430297665, -0.0175103862, -0.041919075, -0.0323027857, -0.0790449306, -0.0351815075, -0.0206295718, 0.0249105785, 0.0575164855, 0.0305743124, -0.031812381, -0.0434856489, -0.0453946479, -0.0093062306, 0.016301943, 0.0462330356, -0.0258361828, -0.0580557249, -0.0420821495, -0.0408399366, -0.0148418285, 0.0060875053, -0.092625469, -0.0433364362, 0.006894147, 0.0019531569, 0.0132096549, -0.0194968022, -0.007987014, -0.0396395065, 0.0143993096, 0.0278232042, 0.045707535, 0.031355232, 0.0127987051, 0.0100907618, 0.0127301281, -0.0010063259, -0.0486223511, 0.0460006595, 0.0514520034, 0.0628786981, 0.0470396131, -0.0074968725, 0.0174293555, -0.005275507, -0.0259491, -0.0246060006, -0.0085187089, -0.0394742824, -0.0378262438, -0.0210385472, -0.0284286793, -0.0368208773, -0.018387178, 0.0578200817, 0.0158070233, -0.0218615346, 0.0061548273, 0.0216916613, -0.0307195783, -0.0333340839, -0.0110224225, 0.02171872, -0.009049464, -0.0024682945, -0.0076004136, 0.0256620366, 0.0186489802, -0.0006918071, 0.0178538393, 0.0295761228, 0.0070583858, 0.0095178941, -0.0382770784, 0.0035090037, 0.037497595, -0.0517117716, -0.0426605456, -0.0009121274, 0.0199143346, 0.1012737453, -0.0008245502, 0.0383140072, -0.0079102656, -0.0074297856, -0.0146834832, 0.0756250322, -0.0071092499, -0.0541108549, -0.0482914522, 0.0167905539, -0.0001933905, -0.0041335486, 0.0664636791, -0.0486658812, -0.0384356342, -0.013190506, -0.0284361281, 0.0096366741, 0.0405966751, -0.0480003096, -0.0196572039, 0.0286693759, 0.0623711385, -0.0672728196, -0.0732000768, 0.0549257733, 0.0238301773, 0.0388881452, -0.0051249126, 0.0087460028, 0.0393899381, -0.0151784401, 0.0279260762, -0.0523728915, -0.037076313, -0.0389988124, 0.0133082364, -0.015667228, -5.422326954e-33, -0.0281792786, -0.0206558779, -0.0348817594, -0.0105108386, -0.0338302962, -0.0442803353, -0.1022656411, 0.038899783, -0.0035221586, 0.0008274248, 0.0075861593, 0.0150342947, -0.0210366156, 0.006206498, 0.0562293604, 0.0033817403, 0.0551435947, 0.0019711594, -0.0441375449, 0.0168628898, 0.0530960783, 0.0267737787, -0.0161797069, -0.0622348487, 0.0288340077, -0.028038824, 0.0043119127, -0.0129260663, 0.0396025553, 0.048507899, -0.0147012761, 0.0300055984, 0.0370770358, -0.0029074736, -0.0290631857, -0.0409912281, -0.0026176367, -0.0322635695, -0.021805156, -0.0014055582, 0.0098798219, -0.0025073036, 0.0430774577, -0.0184211768, -0.0283050817, 0.021864878, 0.0565907694, -0.0432880707, -0.0218343809, -0.0400564373, -0.0602639988, -0.0156612117, -0.0383510664, -0.0122473091, -0.0008792888, -0.0190743823, -0.0035618125, 0.0432415269, -0.0587103814, 0.03937684, -0.0484506935, 0.0162980892, 0.0443577841, 0.0032270935, 0.0300749578, 0.0688183904, 0.0245497916, 0.0119718872, -0.0197692253, 0.0574676059, 0.0057520084, 0.0374469832, 0.0135623747, 0.0427585952, 0.0241376217, -0.0248898286, 0.0021836597, 0.0387917124, -0.0447003283, -0.0493595041, 0.0463664085, 0.0327102803, -0.0203525294, -0.0131983925, 0.0187702607, -0.0748637095, -0.0413884223, -0.0444472171, 0.0033064568, -0.020003153, -0.0264521912, -0.0417428203, 0.0077831354, -0.0215610899, -0.0380372405, -0.0043727942, -0.091441527, 0.0443428606, -0.0061204396, -0.0245108195, 0.0023161708, 0.0011529807, 0.041606348, 0.0250536408, 0.0271917637, 0.0028678318, 0.0366606712, 0.0498658195, -0.0698931068, -0.0035890113, -0.0146508031, -0.0237624776, 0.035215009, -0.0381152444, 0.0223719068, 0.0091240359, -0.0129186511, -0.0030616699, 0.0373452045, 0.0459195226, -0.0086675631, -0.0406964011, -0.0403239913, -0.0129555939, 0.0040227245, 0.0209747422, -0.0137830963, -0.0306887124, 0.0371396206, -0.0553757288, -0.0522082821, -0.0101064276, 2.588e-7, 0.0105950478, 0.0094971135, -0.0161822233, 0.0597356223, 0.0370917544, 0.0377081074, -0.1168934777, 0.0089725824, -0.0004248058, 0.0010286074, 0.02104895, -0.00016915, 0.0683243498, 0.0179336239, -0.1030210629, 0.0573671162, -0.077157326, 0.006934423, -0.0836030468, -0.0155358743, 0.0249521639, 0.0431067236, 0.0258250982, -0.018507136, -0.0005714656, -0.040696118, 0.0488587655, -0.0175129399, 0.0266819876, -0.0462114364, 0.0195128098, -0.0296248049, -0.0111210281, -0.0253183693, -0.0351300612, 0.0210897494, 0.0741221383, 0.0205362756, 0.0314499997, 0.0061433767, 0.0210378524, 0.0348056108, 0.0102033624, -0.0253020506, 0.0262302253, 0.0636449382, -0.0517730713, -0.0374511406, 0.0156579372, -0.0226445235, 0.0411618091, -0.0359883271, -0.0412732102, -0.0388051644, 0.0196560491, -0.0199400168, 0.0575925447, -0.0024224424, -0.037221808, -0.0026565816, -0.0265471693, -0.0184122566, -0.0023569483, 0.0113227041, 0.0045120632, -0.0508378558, -0.0114621455, 2.053827403e-34, 0.0938733593, -0.0586922355, 0.0054246928, -0.0028158429, 0.0446275584, 0.0020103247, -0.005054085, -0.0293714069, -0.0343564674, -0.0466412753, -0.048884742 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.05380v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.05380v2
Prompting Neural Machine Translation with Translation Memories
2023-01-13T03:33:26
2023-02-07T08:10:07
Abudurexiti Reheman, Tao Zhou, Yingfeng Luo, Di Yang, Tong Xiao, Jingbo Zhu
cs.CL
cs.CL
Improving machine translation (MT) systems with translation memories (TMs) is of great interest to practitioners in the MT community. However, previous approaches require either a significant update of the model architecture and/or additional training efforts to make the models well-behaved when TMs are taken as additional input. In this paper, we present a simple but effective method to introduce TMs into neural machine translation (NMT) systems. Specifically, we treat TMs as prompts to the NMT model at test time, but leave the training process unchanged. The result is a slight update of an existing NMT system, which can be implemented in a few hours by anyone who is familiar with NMT. Experimental results on several datasets demonstrate that our system significantly outperforms strong baselines.
[ 0.022667842, 0.0504737981, -0.0112857884, 0.0250280667, -0.0175667126, 0.0164476838, 0.0269929748, -0.0054384731, -0.0084517794, -0.0091484869, -0.0293606874, -0.0388259105, 0.0070176455, 0.015266546, 0.0281503964, -0.0249689501, 0.0136239287, -0.0078880657, -0.0381268598, 0.0132854991, -0.0057582511, -0.0044756783, 0.0210903566, 0.0109662823, -0.0101957247, -0.0030035386, -0.030385904, 0.0476854071, 0.0300574023, -0.0452127419, -0.008962607, 0.0237907711, 0.0203494616, 0.0739307106, 0.0000019959, -0.0132649718, -0.0184717383, -0.0032474468, -0.028765548, -0.0023787671, 0.0198727883, -0.0333351418, -0.0144934822, 0.0201714821, -0.0355745964, -0.0230321959, 0.0422543809, -0.0014752722, 0.1042914838, 0.0943546817, -0.0062524294, 0.0133519834, -0.0131881274, -0.0585108176, 0.0308885965, -0.0187351294, -0.0212438833, -0.0438940227, -0.044480592, 0.0276693087, 0.0365630798, 0.0687636733, 0.0369597934, 0.0084942831, -0.0114213238, 0.0400003679, 0.0196730122, -0.030531602, -0.0502418913, 0.0488730259, -0.0181788262, -0.0087484848, -0.0118385078, 0.0061572939, -0.0118933199, -0.0536429361, -0.0462532938, 0.0103291916, 0.0031692588, -0.0010203194, -0.0012263401, 0.0376028717, 0.0260508806, 0.0067137508, -0.0503952689, -0.027169561, 0.0199766066, -0.0417647399, -0.0104732607, -0.001334571, 0.0388007499, -0.0047928719, 0.0407377295, 0.0236829203, -0.0130682206, 0.026519401, -0.0026479154, -0.0522778109, 0.0100523252, -0.0600887313, 0.0311203115, 0.0650371686, -0.0412081331, 0.0434048399, -0.0506099537, 0.0672973543, -0.0150261344, -0.0044439146, -0.0673176795, 0.0222926736, -0.0625980943, 0.0242903046, -0.0522813909, -0.0003964767, 0.0054631718, 0.0137017416, -0.012650759, 0.0391135812, 0.0443517938, 0.0164386723, 0.0244539585, -0.0176617391, -0.0785807893, -0.0036793097, -0.0079864832, 0.0433576256, -0.0073524201, -0.053926453, 0.0394935422, -0.0570770726, -0.0567341335, -0.0120979371, -0.0189676061, -0.0105098933, 0.0152310934, 0.0939785913, -0.0181658342, -0.0500789098, -0.0244592186, -0.0113532282, 0.0177023076, -0.0511879027, 0.0476271212, -0.017344391, 0.0701540112, -0.0083441893, 0.0094251437, 0.0124025699, -0.0009113792, 0.0198067781, 0.0022784413, 0.0773941875, 0.0419867449, -0.0334609374, 0.051228147, 0.0014610391, -0.0065595033, 0.0250956751, 0.0521608889, 0.0411302596, -0.0148977973, 0.023896737, 0.0023247255, 0.0508785881, 0.0302224476, 0.0326948278, -0.032755293, -0.0004452469, 0.0054904353, 0.044642631, -0.0084700119, 0.0508225299, -0.0114993565, 0.0225416906, 0.0633751005, 0.0203149263, -0.0127940951, 0.0504868478, 0.0676028207, -0.0290474631, -0.0349477082, -0.0150054349, -0.0506000705, 0.0392704681, -0.0135945929, 0.0134244822, 0.0094646793, 0.046857141, -0.0501686595, -0.0304714572, -0.0120526478, -0.0294739846, 0.0127578732, -0.0018380687, 0.0216982774, 0.0194217954, -0.0542494543, 0.0336133242, -0.042192772, -0.0512477532, 0.0242663287, -0.0405296832, -0.0169391166, 0.0663478225, 0.0427846126, 0.0013416472, -0.0310014617, -0.0318808965, -0.0093131568, 0.0609500632, 0.0607455745, 0.0186879467, 0.0200223643, -0.071972914, -0.0026444397, 0.02595599, 0.015698066, 0.042267669, 0.0159034152, 0.0329461992, 0.0551151149, 0.0026328431, -0.0661570206, 0.0381968655, 0.0103647625, -0.0559418835, 0.0413258746, 0.0120237013, 0.0389764085, 0.0111187389, -0.0064693922, -0.0128384735, 0.0401392654, -0.0374781527, -0.0434736088, 0.0318269022, -0.0970662832, -0.0574350208, 0.0102118226, 0.019176675, 0.0096980212, -0.0100490507, -0.0619106516, -0.0554089732, -0.0137783512, -0.0374982357, -0.0015036383, -0.0536545254, 0.0365881883, 0.0285548735, -0.028919369, -0.0492924079, 0.0370999239, -0.0207724757, -0.025651535, 0.0079436032, -0.0263834596, 0.0195908099, -0.0429038703, -0.0262423772, 0.0297224186, 0.0212754086, 0.0469469205, 0.0131398737, 0.0628428012, -0.0334542356, -0.0194257312, -0.0689115897, 0.0294500925, -0.0220001396, 0.0199182015, 0.0255454741, 0.0670038313, -0.0031980213, -0.0352437645, -0.0498868264, 0.0288097002, 0.0021632367, 0.0164634679, 0.0215348974, 0.0135550406, 0.0397946313, -0.0132977897, -0.0071253958, -0.0054805875, 0.0460037291, 0.0054686847, -0.0294068605, -0.0948699713, 0.0117001981, -0.0427543111, 0.0086964304, -0.0017126739, -0.0467719138, 0.0223989431, -0.0547505654, 0.0459556989, 0.0653657392, -0.0116237272, -0.0151491547, 0.0307149831, -0.005620861, -0.0826983824, 0.0326964259, -0.0381930545, -0.0295063797, 0.0450681373, -0.0357161686, -0.0040799854, 0.0284572579, 0.0071080262, 0.017732555, -0.0662021339, 0.0280655678, -0.0005868567, 0.0001810737, -0.025726689, 0.0176907424, -0.0205628145, 0.0070734727, -0.0078660408, -0.0809972733, 0.0937875584, -0.0308965296, -0.0218411963, -0.0538595021, 0.0067555131, -0.0334449075, 0.0424016751, -0.0326517969, 0.0153907547, 0.0171974804, -0.0250984281, -0.0331131443, -0.0054476331, -0.0265046358, -0.0459364727, 0.0059583364, -0.0423569269, -0.0073133116, -0.0303248409, -0.0095441267, -0.0454944968, 0.0247380659, -0.0275747254, -0.0026671998, -0.0437243506, -0.0102085564, 0.0060826703, 0.0111549171, 0.0314447917, 0.0996828079, -0.0238492712, -0.0193269756, -0.026641665, 0.0135105345, -0.0191559419, -0.0010691009, -0.0061976998, -0.0463922434, 0.0432895534, 0.0037985786, 0.0381266698, -0.0233219117, -0.0692096651, -0.0144808209, 0.0023455541, -0.0053389315, 0.0278221425, 0.0069643697, 0.0168909524, -0.0783236548, -0.0275470298, 0.0906814039, 0.0431856178, -0.0614074133, -0.0440829843, 0.0118202176, 0.0362525918, 0.0200241227, 0.0375648439, -0.0659074932, -0.0229396988, 0.0094182128, 0.0489219129, 0.0233875886, 0.036593169, -0.0472837985, -0.0551734157, -0.0015813931, 0.0511575714, -0.0487689041, -0.0130182225, -0.0085035339, -0.069462806, -0.0222298075, 0.0252306983, -0.0042798063, 0.0493097939, -0.0182165951, -0.003381246, 0.0478551425, -0.0535672083, 0.0058756801, -0.0437251404, 0.0161106549, 0.0928503051, 0.0058413185, 0.0236033034, -0.0443475842, 0.0405123122, -0.0079420274, 0.041241508, -0.0316621587, 0.0073152371, -0.0043185684, -0.0402345918, 0.0058870772, -0.0027225544, -0.0189725347, 0.0449394397, 0.0271205064, 0.0864063799, -0.0394383781, 0.0062142406, 0.0154173365, -0.036424011, 0.0039878134, 0.0379108153, 0.0225050971, -0.0329762585, 0.0308443233, -0.01516423, -0.0118642636, -0.0486529134, -0.0079819234, -0.0049914401, -0.0447954796, 0.0076616677, -0.1137680709, -0.0634388328, 0.0065147881, 0.0555837043, 0.0414138772, -0.0194632262, 0.0025124436, -0.0043630516, -0.0332158729, 0.0618875027, -0.0360529833, -0.0348659866, -0.0416226201, 0.0053706309, 0.0465189815, -0.0280230418, 0.0282432437, 0.0383245237, -0.0934637189, -0.0633845255, -0.0456458926, 0.0980819389, 0.0252343938, 0.0463781022, -0.0204715971, 0.0077455374, 0.0442593023, 0.0098671811, -0.0342577584, -0.0293133426, 0.0206510294, 0.0084283771, -0.0216395315, 0.0119199948, -0.0157680716, -0.0019083063, -0.0105713662, 0.0403365158, -0.0177951604, -0.0238819849, 0.0441254415, 0.0065499591, 0.0593570992, -0.0079617407, -0.0390844978, -0.0129514337, 0.0510969795, -0.0027296911, -0.0123507557, -0.052568689, 0.0168714076, 0.0181626715, 0.0218967684, -0.0044804984, -0.0418622717, -0.0094412509, 0.003878142, 0.0213172976, -0.0462244488, -0.0456283279, 0.0276447795, 0.0015748645, 0.0064390046, -0.0305007976, 0.0345438011, -0.0208992194, 0.0087631978, -0.0443695597, 0.090073809, 0.0105552021, 0.0076971767, -0.0114357481, 0.0433854945, -0.0401484817, -0.0625732765, -0.0268492848, 0.0096196197, 0.0601928607, 0.0118706916, 0.0716204345, -0.0141317444, 0.0043930411, 0.0092879422, 0.0223401152, 0.0386802442, -0.0203959048, -0.0087540494, 0.0150146801, 0.0279730409, 0.0106879203, 0.0055495743, -0.0541100129, 0.0017838239, 0.0000094667, 0.01610462, -0.0331823491, 0.0232279506, 0.0087036937, -0.0429331474, -0.0188222826, -0.0278156567, -0.0069499076, -0.0271921493, 0.0224571582, 0.0280238762, 0.0148660969, -0.0080338279, 0.0401663966, 0.0612076074, -0.0405377857, 0.000148103, -0.0078355074, 0.0292121861, 0.0176587403, -0.0487618111, -0.0439467058, -6.37107873e-33, -0.0087648174, 0.0339952521, 0.042879954, -0.0388676301, -0.0472462103, -0.0090506906, -0.0387762971, -0.033428397, 0.0038062886, -0.0460585281, -0.0316630602, 0.0074898475, 0.0315674879, -0.0054161916, 0.0345381238, 0.0042956481, 0.0725793317, -0.0301692355, -0.0329722203, 0.0358330905, 0.0183765497, 0.0338739865, 0.0778465196, -0.0212103594, 0.0274026133, -0.0100732353, -0.0089608636, 0.0358776487, -0.0274589639, 0.0066694878, -0.02230593, -0.0121251615, 0.0267854519, -0.0254461356, -0.0147086345, -0.000530245, -0.0786052868, -0.0022986636, -0.0157992821, 0.0263137594, -0.0288998, -0.024110036, 0.0324204788, -0.0688404664, 0.0083404975, 0.0055852416, -0.0176904351, -0.0201656893, -0.0426028855, -0.0085346894, -0.0185560677, -0.0073612509, 0.0234752707, -0.0379044414, 0.0194926169, 0.0637572482, -0.0167856887, -0.0295983255, -0.0908234566, -0.0091907373, -0.0030212435, 0.0398652628, 0.0436465144, 0.038073156, -0.0263538398, 0.0159589462, 0.0204223003, -0.0047021378, 0.0271629039, 0.0301123317, 0.043982815, -0.0498751141, 0.1086292863, -0.0138844019, 0.0491383262, 0.0084863137, -0.0227756985, 0.026162615, 0.008939743, 0.031957224, 0.0245224163, -0.0040642484, -0.0270730201, 0.0053628427, -0.047276251, -0.0296595246, -0.0525254123, -0.0399571471, 0.0226547588, 0.0653897822, -0.0165410787, -0.039328739, 0.0796809196, 0.0254456364, 0.066184096, -0.0024712738, 0.0017236379, -0.0174297299, -0.0264567025, 0.0235644598, 0.0011337154, -0.0381477214, 0.007362884, 0.0306312405, 0.000185489, -0.0049047843, 0.0481077805, 0.049154833, -0.0378882214, 0.0097556077, -0.0380569138, 0.026356509, -0.0100994315, 0.0080160704, 0.0140159838, 0.0148468101, -0.0098949103, 0.0353478119, 0.0257924646, -0.0199488942, -0.0383417532, 0.0358722694, 0.0279815234, 0.0445028841, -0.0433923304, 0.0162293967, -0.0152117815, 0.0409624577, 0.0332554728, -0.0467462949, -0.0019942473, 0.0186735746, 2.716e-7, 0.0085111931, 0.0460267961, 0.0178446881, 0.0288174413, 0.0024384265, 0.0286960118, -0.0592312552, 0.0247124974, 0.034770444, 0.0291554052, 0.0345101953, 0.0185217503, 0.0654863566, 0.0310021956, -0.1183607429, -0.0611849427, -0.0262998305, 0.0151685718, -0.0847194269, -0.0101635614, 0.0623051934, 0.0972538888, -0.004271477, -0.0000403604, 0.0048154513, -0.0454130471, 0.0759904385, -0.007469831, -0.0196538754, -0.0270857029, 0.0545713194, 0.0363181345, -0.0634120032, -0.0103798853, -0.0184474476, -0.0096512008, -0.0107370457, 0.0831892416, 0.0245640818, -0.0398816094, 0.0337914005, 0.0105478428, -0.0072590355, -0.0148768965, 0.0268234592, -0.0726624504, 0.0303914417, 0.0140536977, 0.0015362635, -0.0019500359, 0.0531324297, -0.0392025262, -0.0414054319, 0.0269566048, 0.0283246133, 0.0066044992, -0.001556599, -0.0738299191, -0.0250999723, -0.0109470487, -0.0090150861, -0.0291705281, -0.0486516021, 0.0033371774, -0.0215328485, -0.0479231775, -0.018570587, 2.250130368e-34, 0.0394294746, -0.0299212076, 0.0248980746, 0.0250472631, 0.0135548199, -0.0152393933, -0.0076216199, -0.0076335082, 0.0306982305, -0.0655385405, -0.0558178984 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.05327v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.05327v1
Blind Judgement: Agent-Based Supreme Court Modelling With GPT
2023-01-12T23:07:55
2023-01-12T23:07:55
Sil Hamilton
cs.CL
cs.CL
We present a novel Transformer-based multi-agent system for simulating the judicial rulings of the 2010-2016 Supreme Court of the United States. We train nine separate models with the respective authored opinions of each supreme justice active ca. 2015 and test the resulting system on 96 real-world cases. We find our system predicts the decisions of the real-world Supreme Court with better-than-random accuracy. We further find a correlation between model accuracy with respect to individual justices and their alignment between legal conservatism & liberalism. Our methods and results hold significance for researchers interested in using language models to simulate politically-charged discourse between multiple agents.
[ 0.0252009332, 0.0652182922, -0.0276518874, 0.0090936571, -0.0343373604, 0.0050356197, 0.0035089797, 0.0193013884, 0.0112819169, -0.0650155693, 0.0021318293, -0.0187499784, -0.0360850729, -0.0016862283, -0.0369897, -0.0942193568, 0.03076078, 0.0096805878, 0.0430858992, -0.0337060168, 0.0104662329, 0.0002129919, 0.005665665, 0.0299268141, -0.0390634276, -0.0197109561, -0.0550668649, -0.0039409092, 0.0293799639, 0.0505738705, -0.0098359138, 0.0678313151, 0.0117430566, 0.0402440205, 0.0000016836, -0.0064000115, 0.0013347069, -0.0182581451, 0.0440919884, -0.020710798, 0.0590022951, -0.000764657, -0.0472173132, 0.023282839, -0.0878691897, 0.0102005629, 0.0201573297, 0.0287642777, 0.0825890079, 0.0905188173, 0.0065952921, -0.0018780272, 0.012840014, -0.02874594, -0.0212935787, -0.0516030826, 0.0279774331, 0.0191688873, -0.0292400215, -0.0259766206, 0.0096980343, -0.0170275327, 0.0160119925, -0.0000637264, -0.0598904863, 0.0276809409, -0.0135501074, 0.0309614129, -0.0211745594, 0.0242016353, 0.0613626018, -0.0064669303, 0.0354260355, 0.0095379958, 0.0405825302, 0.0523717217, -0.0047028498, 0.0610374026, -0.0157507844, 0.0296305958, 0.0324672237, 0.0083325244, -0.0144155892, 0.012549961, -0.0182625223, 0.0737844557, 0.0121668568, -0.0516406, -0.0157011431, 0.0353848077, 0.0117985159, -0.0573501922, 0.0125685539, 0.0004535963, -0.0447901264, 0.0455737263, -0.0327645838, -0.0076680835, 0.0150237344, -0.0605090708, 0.0423601307, 0.0219333824, 0.0435029306, 0.080013223, 0.0340362191, 0.0206303447, -0.0275589582, 0.0487503819, 0.0100203268, -0.0311106704, -0.052514866, 0.0091681071, -0.0440974981, 0.0196092911, -0.0716933161, -0.0110709844, -0.0169627108, -0.0075812051, -0.0466367565, 0.0035786144, -0.004643315, 0.0100308033, -0.0252549872, -0.0223163627, -0.0611021072, 0.0210404228, -0.0496058688, 0.0160387196, -0.0160769746, -0.0126679773, 0.0093420409, 0.0130208638, -0.0103988228, -0.0005134923, -0.0286738779, 0.0852288529, -0.0044879196, -0.0018992466, 0.0102902576, -0.0303864218, 0.0016307854, -0.079773888, -0.0214141067, -0.0544423759, 0.0307843778, -0.0430995114, 0.011069579, -0.0760407075, 0.021304043, 0.0062985299, -0.000185224, 0.0781060755, 0.0257050414, -0.0064964406, 0.0114042331, 0.0143826939, -0.0327091999, 0.0494525135, 0.0132068684, 0.0119033409, 0.0037600908, -0.0301341414, 0.0389942974, 0.0239672884, -0.0256291162, 0.074031651, 0.0155702084, 0.0008535438, -0.020101713, 0.0268755648, 0.0034211583, 0.088980943, -0.0042024245, -0.0452982448, 0.0725693032, 0.040888194, -0.0317503698, 0.0651784688, 0.0481663682, 0.0291381534, 0.0183679461, 0.0264732055, -0.0404788293, 0.0206943247, -0.0226153918, -0.0126323011, -0.0244398937, 0.0475523658, -0.0366498046, -0.040083658, 0.0292578898, -0.0233258978, 0.0455775931, -0.030272726, 0.0504203103, 0.0024479686, -0.0576217473, 0.0213861335, 0.0432966352, -0.0566603094, -0.0318544134, -0.0562875383, 0.0026695007, 0.0396994576, 0.0391590856, -0.001212688, -0.0180598181, -0.0523935929, 0.0098960409, 0.0811690018, 0.0667488426, -0.0052811196, -0.0875616893, -0.0510992371, -0.0292551853, 0.066079013, 0.039705053, 0.0680849105, 0.0074482681, 0.0306693595, 0.0125094522, 0.0033973083, 0.0358914807, 0.0259725694, -0.0326310769, -0.0021797123, 0.0015084874, -0.0205219202, 0.0729548484, 0.0227623712, -0.0090641957, -0.033095818, 0.01619903, 0.0405132137, -0.0647815317, 0.0134002771, -0.0132998656, 0.0471305437, 0.0263850018, -0.0496270917, 0.0004526206, 0.0364138298, -0.020447515, -0.0252097342, 0.0347247906, -0.0106685488, 0.000588768, -0.0566648506, -0.0125715584, -0.0170881785, -0.011669904, -0.0265703797, 0.0371556059, 0.0107151158, -0.0224224329, 0.0215789694, -0.0090792356, 0.0126889879, -0.0155223114, -0.0110796578, -0.0041993461, 0.025372142, 0.0467311032, 0.021664558, -0.0281286705, -0.0181526486, -0.0774120688, -0.0462521166, -0.022582436, -0.0260903221, -0.0027134393, 0.0209462382, -0.0151297981, 0.0014385083, 0.0118218604, -0.025718838, 0.000627845, -0.0078830607, -0.0200461429, 0.0111109484, -0.0193067808, -0.031822592, -0.0273458976, 0.0090723513, -0.0560969189, 0.0316774547, 0.0281462502, 0.0072628059, -0.0331718549, 0.0339011773, -0.0268494543, 0.0394768566, -0.0360532515, -0.0426547788, 0.0297926143, -0.0030819918, -0.0032218334, 0.0359819606, 0.0631264672, 0.0644636974, 0.0152495578, -0.0002193339, -0.0542160422, 0.0230743587, -0.0422156006, 0.0291746911, -0.0791456997, -0.0016048953, 0.0133118927, 0.0516740717, 0.0184428189, 0.0022874048, -0.0657829642, 0.0812686458, -0.0029200912, -0.0251174122, 0.0424979068, -0.0111726262, -0.0289417189, 0.0099330619, 0.0154911848, -0.010036367, 0.0598029047, 0.0007896041, 0.0389559679, -0.0442269817, 0.0293863993, -0.0425767601, 0.063890554, 0.0058549028, -0.0139237642, -0.032856755, 0.0049915053, -0.0344273336, -0.0381678417, 0.0507180169, -0.0492609814, 0.1033883169, -0.0472766422, 0.0220181663, -0.0137020815, -0.033108294, -0.0106847528, -0.0507464819, -0.0376531817, 0.01684005, 0.0457301699, -0.0395769179, -0.0668043345, 0.040457949, -0.020079935, -0.0101250568, 0.0146685569, -0.0004567276, -0.0264771078, 0.0167811513, 0.0149818091, 0.0043032155, -0.0195214134, -0.024782287, -0.0033186364, 0.0375589281, 0.0021629792, 0.0158014949, -0.0265614167, -0.0583515316, 0.0096301539, -0.053594999, 0.0212227106, -0.0097306333, -0.0054803179, -0.0454760045, 0.0391062722, 0.1100849509, 0.0209059063, -0.0441429131, -0.0177849606, -0.0067539769, -0.0011886737, 0.0136083066, 0.0288011413, -0.0972675085, 0.0195847973, 0.0127633158, -0.0266708136, -0.0287425127, -0.0529961698, 0.0112488614, -0.1021580696, 0.0413496159, 0.0172374398, 0.0456779599, -0.0043113176, -0.0256234799, 0.0316743366, -0.0571760386, -0.035712678, -0.0150515065, 0.0280315764, 0.003288419, 0.0035916113, -0.032660313, 0.02286282, 0.0448546372, -0.023136165, 0.0753462464, 0.0485172495, 0.0669172034, -0.0175403822, -0.0534496158, -0.0181822348, -0.0111774281, -0.0212231651, 0.0251173973, 0.0200534184, -0.0065049627, -0.0009786848, -0.0016031325, 0.0232228711, 0.0346947275, 0.0223307926, 0.0426011197, 0.0297343992, -0.0604650602, -0.0693869963, -0.0245060269, 0.0194281992, 0.0496356301, 0.0638253987, 0.0094074327, -0.028806299, -0.0735281855, -0.0455834717, 0.0081390217, -0.033723969, -0.0689508021, -0.0281800702, 0.0185103081, -0.0113602197, -0.0218292251, -0.0474297702, 0.0002197604, 0.0157811996, 0.0164479055, 0.0022698443, 0.0783196613, -0.0035213036, 0.0277632438, -0.0218108762, -0.0575418919, 0.012258105, 0.0064045284, -0.0582714528, 0.0149521939, 0.018248938, -0.0249834675, 0.0084835868, -0.0058076736, -0.0407147966, 0.046468813, 0.0260591116, 0.0336668268, 0.0049698683, -0.0318824537, 0.0179132167, 0.0172627214, 0.0293228123, -0.0321289226, 0.0118992478, 0.0462616235, -0.0204755813, 0.0101989936, 0.008567797, 0.024558166, 0.0684568509, 0.0053065005, -0.0066615739, -0.0878100693, -0.0285188816, 0.0089707877, -0.0494308025, 0.0280813705, 0.0407561921, -0.019208163, -0.0076918122, -0.0073110498, -0.0521549471, 0.0195113793, -0.0111521306, -0.053814888, 0.006591795, 0.0040131905, -0.0135671711, 0.0037849678, -0.0320478939, 0.0150187602, -0.0087341554, 0.0349351354, 0.0183060132, -0.0165642723, 0.018513957, -0.0403457806, 0.0101416167, 0.0188066103, 0.0209340118, 0.0406726487, 0.0049107433, 0.0581185706, 0.0108917858, -0.0040837866, 0.0230557062, 0.0058334391, -0.0685392991, -0.0051069632, -0.0131926332, 0.0423952527, 0.0124533335, 0.0348837078, 0.0102459956, -0.034307193, 0.0136493826, 0.0048394171, 0.0280991998, 0.0278329421, -0.0055379006, 0.0400627069, 0.0257478636, -0.020247655, -0.0103484318, 0.0242267195, -0.0039551128, 0.0438377485, 0.0321630575, -0.0222642031, -0.0370077863, -0.0353833362, -0.0564278811, -0.0226941258, 0.0088462234, -0.0606426634, -0.0964322314, 0.003646926, 0.0303278361, 0.0421906412, 0.0171083622, -0.0129791824, 0.0165414717, 0.0486584902, -0.0208150856, 0.0604433678, -0.0723384246, -0.0029629639, -0.0332775675, -0.0351295769, -0.0266949553, -5.482951973e-33, -0.053341575, -0.0317029357, 0.0487944745, 0.0442830212, -0.0414930992, -0.0162365325, -0.0361657776, 0.003034679, -0.024452161, 0.0368513651, -0.0258753635, 0.0362103656, 0.0233146176, -0.0144653153, 0.0116908615, -0.0055975742, 0.0272547044, -0.0206549335, -0.0078700799, 0.0225358456, -0.0278426614, -0.0050366493, 0.0102315564, -0.0818805248, -0.0080952803, 0.0260915924, -0.039343968, -0.0631351471, -0.0674178824, 0.0222186279, -0.0241582263, 0.0330202095, -0.0110893836, -0.0777689442, -0.0092006456, 0.064083755, -0.0249276254, 0.0037549252, -0.0192374103, -0.0305336323, 0.0305025913, -0.0006164733, -0.0013896741, 0.031580925, -0.0409847461, -0.0037052785, 0.040483214, -0.0263229515, -0.0076356456, -0.0233182907, -0.0609655902, 0.0335023031, -0.015787648, 0.0005864874, -0.0196548905, 0.0040726187, 0.0161240995, -0.0081364457, -0.0707289428, 0.0495650843, 0.0069954991, -0.0278957263, -0.0073808576, -0.0444574989, 0.019762231, 0.0629608333, 0.0331253111, 0.0399618037, -0.1239887699, -0.0269048251, 0.0227886084, 0.0442000851, 0.0650852993, 0.0867264047, -0.0208835118, -0.0767475069, -0.0220095273, 0.0094604427, 0.0740945786, 0.0218707025, 0.0520349555, -0.0280605238, -0.0114094652, -0.0133006386, -0.0131728528, -0.0669267699, 0.0083710738, -0.0353944376, -0.0174927525, 0.011414093, 0.0252926592, -0.0056066946, 0.0090537984, -0.0522553399, 0.0212741029, 0.0160794389, -0.0167872868, 0.0210446715, -0.0219526067, -0.0082803741, -0.0308432113, -0.048452165, 0.008289394, 0.0338560902, 0.005744902, -0.0174463857, -0.0136261834, -0.0090524647, -0.0473369695, -0.0126800938, 0.0184388589, 0.0434244648, 0.0411810987, 0.0117810722, -0.0015504868, 0.0151566593, 0.020405557, -0.0090064071, -0.0082969684, -0.0098863449, -0.0148471463, 0.00337078, 0.0002633449, -0.0104664704, -0.0117029101, 0.0058902195, -0.0417872518, 0.0273740757, 0.0002044095, -0.0019637984, 0.0019318217, 0.0186840352, 2.4e-7, 0.0552084818, 0.0513043404, 0.0031236543, 0.0068270406, 0.0131552964, 0.0567444488, 0.0146197183, 0.063461192, 0.0174815785, -0.0520014204, 0.0379511155, 0.0142350821, 0.0214348994, 0.0483359434, -0.1253858656, -0.0482472219, -0.0609237514, -0.0101284618, -0.0607489906, 0.0034075992, 0.006230427, 0.0552283935, 0.0729492754, 0.0254694931, -0.0230907723, 0.0196240973, 0.0633454323, -0.0267215706, -0.0306338537, 0.0281584114, 0.0204416905, -0.0823704302, -0.0089534996, 0.0685043558, 0.0201975927, 0.0192158297, -0.0289577432, 0.0470436774, -0.0095244367, 0.0112539111, 0.0091792261, -0.0191290267, -0.005380095, 0.0179351307, 0.0285554957, -0.0547871515, -0.0271740481, -0.0271551292, -0.0731958449, 0.00431336, 0.0270948298, 0.0244931821, -0.0468939841, 0.0027062208, -0.0059379772, 0.0155186625, 0.0373711884, -0.0562008098, 0.0180451684, -0.0273184869, -0.0563568957, -0.0523752421, 0.0242111497, -0.0257173348, 0.0449684374, -0.0314963423, 0.014341427, 1.793803346e-34, 0.0551107563, 0.0368478559, -0.0079254499, 0.0267610345, 0.0442223847, 0.0218733232, 0.0334278829, -0.0204267632, 0.0067343283, -0.0758859217, 0.0011821869 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.05272v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.05272v1
Inaccessible Neural Language Models Could Reinvigorate Linguistic Nativism
2023-01-12T19:41:47
2023-01-12T19:41:47
Patrick Perrine
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
Large Language Models (LLMs) have been making big waves in the machine learning community within the past few years. The impressive scalability of LLMs due to the advent of deep learning can be seen as a continuation of empiricist lingusitic methods, as opposed to rule-based linguistic methods that are grounded in a nativist perspective. Current LLMs are generally inaccessible to resource-constrained researchers, due to a variety of factors including closed source code. This work argues that this lack of accessibility could instill a nativist bias in researchers new to computational linguistics, given that new researchers may only have rule-based, nativist approaches to study to produce new work. Also, given that there are numerous critics of deep learning claiming that LLMs and related methods may soon lose their relevancy, we speculate that such an event could trigger a new wave of nativism in the language processing community. To prevent such a dramatic shift and placing favor in hybrid methods of rules and deep learning, we call upon researchers to open source their LLM code wherever possible to allow both empircist and hybrid approaches to remain accessible.
[ 0.0164786149, 0.1389654726, -0.0547686294, 0.050172586, -0.0587503053, 0.008658709, 0.0227476526, -0.0218634699, -0.0089164777, 0.0100027202, -0.0191549733, -0.0357475579, -0.0029256677, 0.0272748899, -0.0008717483, -0.0003542304, -0.0036450403, 0.0154022351, 0.0228895228, -0.0536194183, -0.0117235119, 0.0140933562, 0.0369198769, 0.0647306144, 0.0341481492, -0.0118759181, 0.0262705199, -0.0508156531, -0.0392237045, 0.0035560702, 0.0457175151, 0.0361740775, -0.0054522562, 0.0975815952, 0.0000018786, -0.043899022, 0.0094738007, 0.0034910589, 0.0033063218, 0.0164186843, 0.0340220183, -0.0394003056, 0.0006041572, -0.0216773506, -0.0769006088, -0.0363498107, 0.0857802331, 0.0018965724, 0.0093554175, 0.0551526472, 0.0229560062, -0.0650330931, 0.0524451695, -0.0314592458, -0.0071045198, 0.014443039, 0.0086479709, -0.039127741, -0.0073603084, 0.0039359694, -0.0341095589, 0.0793192014, 0.0726841837, 0.0012037309, -0.0182520393, 0.041292239, -0.0578816421, -0.0284776371, -0.0072986414, 0.0451804399, -0.030788634, -0.006236596, 0.0394586213, 0.0148438131, -0.0415725224, -0.0094010187, -0.0514490195, 0.0662011281, -0.0074061579, 0.033648923, 0.0431359932, -0.0263229199, 0.0330962725, 0.0458160974, -0.000725451, 0.0806943327, -0.0095786862, -0.0180748422, 0.0176751353, 0.0239371546, 0.0288191643, -0.0323330089, 0.0409382619, -0.0173973888, 0.0561790802, 0.0273876283, -0.0174655877, 0.0011917385, 0.0296614002, -0.0511569232, 0.0237771701, 0.000683461, -0.0401336551, 0.0173576623, -0.0359010994, -0.0112294666, -0.0380803533, 0.0356969573, 0.0086904466, 0.0175001472, -0.0383056141, -0.0281104669, 0.0027595293, 0.0033479936, -0.0369945019, 0.0145837581, -0.0019564319, -0.014236792, -0.0126398662, -0.0129520129, -0.0061412221, 0.016826218, -0.0056324368, 0.0178170726, -0.0181752015, 0.0086358972, -0.0125782127, 0.0057580587, -0.0415103361, -0.1123803034, 0.002401246, -0.0059718252, -0.044597853, -0.0350448191, 0.0433251783, 0.009716793, 0.0381272435, -0.0378708094, -0.0313231461, -0.0024386751, -0.0368462428, -0.0217956305, 0.0404083207, -0.0701743439, 0.0076366188, 0.0063647223, -0.0017668114, -0.1076939031, -0.0039719203, 0.0103034219, -0.0344426781, 0.0618156791, -0.0007706913, -0.0052278875, 0.0299260113, 0.0132992184, 0.0069920933, 0.031807147, -0.0105181169, -0.0463674068, 0.0405244082, -0.00818107, 0.0205259584, 0.0108941076, 0.0169891156, -0.0046108444, -0.042635031, -0.0063356142, -0.0157280117, -0.0183261205, 0.0378527045, 0.0852035359, 0.0124253826, -0.0753030181, 0.0454859622, 0.0914642736, 0.0057947794, 0.0407884456, 0.0226266235, -0.0025826863, -0.0131156491, -0.0028721676, -0.0150130112, -0.0065259533, -0.0298099667, -0.0217175893, -0.0207469892, 0.0643985271, -0.0023786412, -0.0491211638, 0.02037967, -0.0159655102, 0.0306480676, -0.0141573222, 0.0485491753, -0.0146371666, 0.0262840111, 0.0076654414, 0.0517034568, -0.0205390286, 0.007942494, -0.0446456224, 0.0214083754, 0.015327028, 0.0161354598, -0.0189232267, 0.0268806238, -0.0120363785, -0.0215667747, 0.071581237, 0.0085242521, 0.0195828713, 0.0116062285, -0.051105015, 0.0196413994, -0.0411478728, 0.0278327297, 0.0255214795, -0.0285807885, 0.058563035, 0.0008638607, 0.0224298406, -0.0684074908, 0.0322588906, -0.0393816493, -0.0186245497, -0.0190235209, -0.0222759899, 0.0416197926, 0.0344401076, -0.0347238071, 0.0258256849, 0.0117401034, -0.0564710796, -0.0461266786, -0.0158760585, -0.0293249097, 0.0126909511, 0.0311486218, -0.089116022, 0.0260063671, 0.0184928775, -0.015748743, -0.0118173482, 0.0558327921, -0.0171444472, 0.0412224084, -0.0312473029, -0.0072898846, -0.0255370978, 0.0516489297, -0.0289733838, 0.0234597996, -0.0415833294, 0.0557728633, 0.0273989495, -0.0431106128, 0.0141366161, 0.0006942978, -0.0519790165, 0.0608090013, -0.0011232917, 0.0072231339, 0.0048143496, 0.0147432499, 0.0109095518, 0.0011138085, -0.0326323695, -0.0229462404, -0.019857496, 0.0044773812, -0.0212631971, -0.0101230396, -0.0228560735, 0.0046421071, -0.0073317932, -0.0396702401, -0.0179585814, 0.0124959731, 0.014736576, 0.006655057, -0.0533057638, -0.0102659669, -0.0541054271, 0.0019857557, 0.0449477211, -0.0271837991, 0.0113327177, -0.0022328857, -0.0156711452, -0.044167649, 0.0363653079, -0.0199593063, -0.0129936608, 0.0238392707, 0.0086603081, -0.0233915225, 0.0431084782, -0.0319236033, 0.017055966, 0.0535984375, 0.0074966736, -0.034519054, -0.0093563767, -0.0059656459, -0.038161844, -0.008368141, -0.0290587023, -0.0002019298, 0.0566326752, 0.0133021185, -0.0331305452, -0.0282598585, 0.0803468525, -0.0691840425, -0.0593262054, -0.0006154672, -0.022034483, -0.0286753196, 0.0434379503, -0.0148745188, -0.0501593724, 0.0790094584, -0.0339480713, -0.0156498458, -0.050317809, -0.0572066493, -0.0544736236, 0.0828206167, 0.0041872957, 0.0099430168, 0.0735523999, -0.0248128865, -0.0183398407, 0.0244294722, -0.0156709831, -0.0300133508, 0.0484171957, -0.0230997391, -0.0082494086, -0.0073187784, -0.0363687202, -0.0154006546, -0.0416135341, -0.0179588553, 0.0113568958, 0.0422766134, 0.0006939651, 0.0033146176, 0.0170226023, 0.0406240895, 0.0349736251, 0.0379468203, 0.0146498214, -0.0129499715, -0.0158018414, -0.0059752339, -0.0199588742, 0.0021336111, 0.0158480965, -0.0282603409, 0.0202412326, 0.0320108943, 0.0431514196, -0.0039186641, -0.0008312913, 0.0200772379, -0.0084412238, -0.0666866526, -0.0148273651, 0.0212799795, -0.0686174259, 0.01304211, 0.0757130533, -0.0001794702, -0.0513196811, 0.015531458, -0.0407942981, 0.006425288, 0.0082870144, 0.0083895186, -0.0645268559, 0.0225364976, 0.0050810473, 0.0296802279, -0.0662241727, -0.0566271208, -0.0026795745, -0.0987840667, -0.0023404835, 0.0142554352, -0.0799357817, -0.0098349778, -0.0252259243, -0.0343991816, -0.0262014624, 0.0450898185, -0.0105805118, 0.0163710974, 0.0157931875, 0.0148169687, -0.0263316128, -0.0250823908, 0.006165924, -0.0429171845, 0.0422212221, 0.017880775, 0.0139919864, -0.043511048, -0.06586916, 0.0217343681, -0.0313183926, -0.0075560678, -0.0308488961, 0.0025532257, 0.0257168841, -0.0508717857, -0.0044924589, 0.022953108, -0.0352687426, 0.0041801468, 0.0033552859, 0.073296003, -0.0112891886, -0.0379205905, -0.0312885642, -0.0081313383, -0.0157901496, 0.05424124, 0.0192033648, -0.0491898358, -0.0197718032, -0.0563156903, 0.0085447747, 0.0226058234, -0.1283374876, 0.0354813859, 0.0021848984, -0.0679329038, -0.0338669866, -0.0468032882, -0.0242444538, 0.034164656, 0.0335061736, -0.0250844341, 0.0500987917, -0.0297025517, -0.0540366098, 0.0701761618, -0.0312693566, -0.003433848, -0.0042871218, 0.004161193, 0.0368682146, 0.0318733007, -0.0145189622, 0.0189700406, 0.0410524607, -0.077919364, 0.0225299019, 0.0382168852, 0.0285779089, -0.0087865954, -0.0014134634, -0.0845127255, 0.0280949008, 0.0764700025, 0.0018404034, 0.0316285677, 0.0552227423, -0.0339429602, 0.0173760876, 0.0334395841, -0.0185329299, -0.0027095457, 0.01819361, 0.0240281168, -0.0219878666, 0.0145807136, 0.0110748038, 0.0066084461, 0.0704951286, -0.0199995879, -0.0065573091, -0.019392401, -0.0206237528, 0.0085013779, -0.0053332737, -0.0324572287, -0.0293708518, 0.0578575395, 0.0413133129, -0.0255924501, 0.0198854022, 0.026361011, 0.0404524915, -0.0308307074, 0.0666877106, 0.0676735118, 0.0485399626, 0.0133095505, -0.0031367331, -0.0248992834, 0.0800126791, -0.0449191295, 0.0356763713, -0.0043183193, 0.0128401658, 0.0029945599, 0.0008868996, -0.000887414, -0.0088721132, -0.0298422184, -0.0955404192, 0.0258986782, 0.0227818452, 0.0273549091, -0.0119429482, 0.0517329983, -0.0040097348, 0.0132746538, -0.031568341, -0.0054717734, 0.0322628096, -0.0363403372, 0.0289112702, 0.0042971433, -0.0398122706, -0.010859889, 0.0618104003, -0.0199955124, 0.0436451323, 0.0072325286, 0.0068968609, -0.0007398002, -0.0666609928, 0.0238139089, -0.019234214, -0.0181664582, 0.0096236449, -0.0673063695, -0.0445194282, -0.0136798592, 0.0300376024, -0.0001971966, -0.0255196113, 0.0189930517, 0.0662653148, -0.0080462722, -0.0290577151, -0.0382734612, 0.0561720021, -0.009673981, -0.0352421291, 0.0102561852, -6.166589732e-33, 0.0085929194, -0.0040393872, -0.003561792, 0.0033779969, -0.0062466627, 0.0060397652, -0.0202082451, 0.0346251391, -0.0453400873, -0.0131273307, -0.0162550434, 0.0072225602, 0.0077988901, 0.0370770954, 0.0287450999, -0.007189339, -0.0106500387, -0.0047134305, 0.0220049825, -0.0115618668, 0.0001030497, 0.0377993137, 0.0513008125, -0.0737133697, 0.0775462836, 0.0283408612, 0.0399077088, 0.0336290002, -0.0044496069, 0.021619508, -0.0347728096, 0.0361542143, 0.0086683966, -0.0683484152, -0.0076229312, 0.0091279494, -0.0288727824, -0.0137936492, 0.0376920141, 0.0037271611, 0.0314740092, -0.056024041, 0.1122263521, 0.0037878731, -0.0390388183, 0.0526347794, 0.0224206224, -0.0285439342, -0.0130429277, -0.0154949185, -0.0174229722, 0.0308877137, -0.0151029164, 0.0386054963, 0.014988103, -0.0062017916, -0.0111723877, -0.0052612321, -0.0659177899, -0.0121183563, -0.0262911934, 0.0248273946, 0.0744345188, -0.0024504715, 0.0316199474, 0.0466251001, 0.1077305526, 0.0110116042, -0.034862753, -0.0049289749, 0.0840238482, 0.0247489605, 0.0391965769, 0.0241783373, 0.0144922649, -0.0043203286, -0.0378663391, -0.0547008067, 0.0406154878, 0.0025870109, 0.0497566238, 0.014989757, -0.0574289411, -0.0330455713, -0.0152997905, -0.1005769074, -0.0103799831, 0.0008774839, -0.0134766214, -0.0072377119, -0.0194805562, -0.0021828306, 0.0219780374, -0.0514974818, -0.0075213942, 0.0299918037, 0.0161562525, 0.0179976653, 0.0239515081, 0.0255716983, -0.0790742114, -0.0096079363, -0.0625380725, 0.0046617053, 0.0388563238, 0.011838885, 0.009027238, 0.02840776, -0.0299254116, -0.0199133456, -0.0405480564, -0.0004327364, 0.0276067033, 0.0354992859, 0.0441194475, 0.0153683014, -0.0009873352, -0.0015853484, 0.0591172613, 0.0184623078, -0.0306148585, 0.0034630415, 0.0212369673, 0.0151482997, -0.0445407778, -0.0297758635, -0.0110145826, 0.079979457, 0.0712325871, -0.0559198596, -0.0164532401, -0.0332907811, 2.67e-7, 0.0453404263, 0.0074513042, 0.0045238798, -0.0111611933, 0.0166067425, 0.0243668016, -0.0134114223, 0.0386183523, -0.052934289, -0.0262698177, -0.0223956387, 0.0266420487, 0.0564744622, 0.0202135276, -0.0864491612, -0.0247832127, -0.0834489688, 0.0103735337, -0.0625004247, 0.0236952696, -0.0339289382, 0.0912571624, 0.0470786802, -0.0028680039, -0.0395430773, -0.0829061642, 0.0304896981, -0.0319776833, 0.024245983, -0.0010802725, 0.0602863058, 0.033209607, 0.0053417403, -0.0441214368, 0.0383272879, 0.0396262445, 0.0027840449, 0.076916784, 0.0330787115, -0.0242778119, 0.021605555, -0.0338216871, -0.0539010428, -0.0494909659, 0.0583404787, 0.0017213873, -0.0456690639, 0.0004479466, 0.021198092, -0.0010013791, 0.064652741, -0.0141716301, 0.001757156, -0.0032376186, 0.0228465255, -0.0553336702, -0.0160413068, -0.0713621005, -0.0266252197, 0.0189410057, -0.0230989717, -0.0131265037, 0.0103295678, 0.0256974921, 0.00165623, 0.0304834973, 0.0409184359, 2.40531927e-34, 0.0309222639, -0.0368698984, -0.0008804932, 0.0043449476, 0.0064834468, 0.0108657666, 0.0100467503, -0.0019752674, -0.0184866395, -0.0584942028, -0.0170239042 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.05226v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.05226v1
See, Think, Confirm: Interactive Prompting Between Vision and Language Models for Knowledge-based Visual Reasoning
2023-01-12T18:59:50
2023-01-12T18:59:50
Zhenfang Chen, Qinhong Zhou, Yikang Shen, Yining Hong, Hao Zhang, Chuang Gan
cs.CV
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
Large pre-trained vision and language models have demonstrated remarkable capacities for various tasks. However, solving the knowledge-based visual reasoning tasks remains challenging, which requires a model to comprehensively understand image content, connect the external world knowledge, and perform step-by-step reasoning to answer the questions correctly. To this end, we propose a novel framework named Interactive Prompting Visual Reasoner (IPVR) for few-shot knowledge-based visual reasoning. IPVR contains three stages, see, think and confirm. The see stage scans the image and grounds the visual concept candidates with a visual perception model. The think stage adopts a pre-trained large language model (LLM) to attend to the key concepts from candidates adaptively. It then transforms them into text context for prompting with a visual captioning model and adopts the LLM to generate the answer. The confirm stage further uses the LLM to generate the supporting rationale to the answer, verify the generated rationale with a cross-modality classifier and ensure that the rationale can infer the predicted output consistently. We conduct experiments on a range of knowledge-based visual reasoning datasets. We found our IPVR enjoys several benefits, 1). it achieves better performance than the previous few-shot learning baselines; 2). it enjoys the total transparency and trustworthiness of the whole reasoning process by providing rationales for each reasoning step; 3). it is computation-efficient compared with other fine-tuning baselines.
[ 0.0292490553, 0.0328887329, 0.0133121582, 0.0508971885, -0.0231832154, 0.0362075083, 0.0391570888, 0.0130687999, 0.0201150011, -0.075104937, 0.0076285731, -0.007890447, -0.0141568491, 0.0534905754, 0.0249215756, -0.0643538237, 0.0214713421, -0.0550605357, 0.0438007601, 0.0069707022, 0.0256952737, 0.0284586027, -0.0088135889, 0.04561745, -0.0080951927, -0.0297297779, -0.0261991099, -0.0155291911, 0.0318234712, -0.0195580479, -0.0317006297, 0.0267365184, 0.0684455261, -0.0228790902, 0.0000019925, -0.0334503055, 0.0242181104, 0.0009166073, -0.0251350254, -0.0096894316, -0.0323050953, -0.0047009364, 0.017116271, -0.0088490518, -0.033875525, -0.0075691966, 0.0376868807, 0.0603085309, 0.072794497, 0.0060761929, -0.0255388133, -0.0390104912, -0.0177903771, -0.0051724371, 0.0567019321, -0.0350493267, -0.0031455758, 0.0558740497, -0.0015040042, 0.0084905792, -0.0322782472, 0.0378849171, 0.0238726232, -0.0640796199, 0.0018705331, 0.0468339436, 0.0006994962, -0.0447366163, -0.0246542115, 0.0946127176, 0.0023080809, -0.0044667316, -0.0105064604, -0.0183366667, -0.0037524786, 0.0136065129, -0.0414266884, 0.0392905287, -0.008537706, -0.0009717738, -0.0292644538, 0.0087909382, -0.0092654089, 0.0212018006, -0.0214011632, -0.0179269426, 0.0062834974, 0.0399786495, 0.0049004671, 0.0207977071, -0.0510602593, -0.0749115795, -0.0466492511, 0.0751895085, -0.0162973311, 0.004205185, -0.0091164177, 0.0246181171, -0.0284643378, -0.021790484, 0.0279298313, 0.0357939638, -0.0508048758, 0.1036030501, -0.0414641686, 0.0470094644, -0.008542656, 0.0454556979, -0.0023699179, -0.0228304267, -0.0440403484, -0.0090145627, -0.0268463828, 0.0041134288, -0.0370698497, -0.047970295, -0.0175808389, 0.0171024706, -0.0148527045, 0.0340246409, 0.0209652577, 0.0343747213, 0.0283944197, -0.0409059934, -0.0786128044, 0.0441955514, -0.0464840271, 0.0230943542, -0.0048899539, -0.0072152982, 0.0076653617, 0.0311955959, 0.0273397118, -0.0103361113, 0.003197941, 0.0229655039, -0.0483324118, -0.0021904684, -0.0330869667, -0.0319970325, -0.0112401908, -0.0664072931, 0.0102098882, -0.0342649259, -0.0018622359, -0.0095366938, -0.0177536327, -0.0138366045, 0.0026397253, 0.0147760967, -0.0393471941, 0.1118343174, -0.0223862622, -0.0129250046, 0.0017466019, 0.0244704764, -0.0228502005, 0.0442030914, 0.0069485307, 0.0361229256, 0.0207251366, -0.0177342892, 0.0286614504, -0.0040107593, -0.0017464651, -0.0258961897, -0.0551620908, 0.0229476653, -0.0188059304, 0.0256461836, -0.0061192559, 0.0329309106, -0.0369606428, -0.0012497712, 0.0488773063, 0.0222040042, 0.0231854748, -0.0472420938, 0.0379722193, 0.0175731834, -0.0125171505, -0.0299343262, -0.0735047236, 0.0966357142, -0.0273632985, -0.0169214252, -0.0188021436, -0.0011454793, -0.0516381375, -0.0383502319, 0.0160050094, 0.00502192, 0.007304051, 0.046220731, 0.0548588187, 0.0043971147, -0.0367676988, -0.0008775393, 0.0090180179, -0.0180409811, -0.0211130157, -0.0597334541, 0.0842489973, 0.064252384, 0.0074331281, 0.0277377442, -0.0237776507, 0.0073235212, 0.0489372984, 0.0129258391, 0.0187574923, -0.0001423114, 0.004926085, -0.0467953719, -0.0586196817, -0.0260644779, -0.0208302494, -0.0054246373, -0.003426193, 0.003801971, 0.0141530493, -0.0138834286, 0.0245822836, 0.0258829668, 0.0735419691, -0.0018380188, -0.0217533018, 0.0309915971, -0.0203537215, -0.007118179, 0.0183207709, 0.0039179893, -0.0042639463, -0.0047986163, 0.015001514, 0.0296552088, -0.0446389169, -0.060301397, 0.028871173, -0.0198798552, -0.0047421856, -0.0468458496, -0.0350268111, -0.0292224158, 0.0110778883, 0.0253829118, -0.0149913989, -0.0585547723, -0.0241609309, 0.0173441246, 0.0046044099, -0.0141684469, 0.0787228942, 0.0039152, -0.0289532095, 0.0218784232, 0.0093938364, 0.0218811519, -0.0138750542, 0.0028236711, 0.0021785721, -0.0057488019, -0.0037680259, -0.0085968338, 0.0135386707, -0.061212521, 0.0206050854, -0.0755906552, -0.0391981117, 0.0000171726, -0.0342458487, -0.019257009, -0.019982012, 0.0188230649, -0.0455911048, -0.0381055623, 0.0658486336, 0.0016004265, 0.0048865443, 0.0337053463, 0.0209673345, 0.0121462988, -0.000697589, 0.0161022563, 0.0316436253, 0.0873057395, 0.0591320992, 0.0116781015, -0.0475265868, 0.0185494144, -0.0491957851, 0.0227991436, -0.0126145966, -0.0105060814, 0.036846444, -0.02040953, 0.0072072614, 0.084202081, 0.001487032, -0.0107878288, 0.0172097143, -0.0228538811, -0.0563188568, 0.0103249783, 0.0115194684, -0.0343692601, 0.0086168041, -0.0137680816, -0.0582046881, 0.0247917045, -0.0419622064, -0.014777205, -0.0844399333, 0.0547126643, 0.0314403661, -0.0334021784, -0.0970502794, -0.0189369153, 0.035033647, 0.0644128919, -0.0379062891, -0.0398822315, 0.074089475, -0.0231914278, -0.0046664453, 0.050567776, 0.0045188903, -0.0139587997, 0.082705535, -0.0115121081, -0.0025684445, -0.003043229, 0.0090453615, -0.0363567322, -0.0596017428, 0.0382061116, 0.0106282895, 0.0479643531, -0.091919966, 0.0118628088, -0.014963313, -0.0292229485, -0.0435622446, -0.0182314944, -0.0731246471, -0.001085456, -0.0553547181, -0.0128095048, 0.0210553352, 0.0428321138, 0.0501828417, 0.0187598485, 0.011378495, -0.006822038, 0.0014115557, 0.0442153551, 0.0444493182, 0.0409150608, -0.0217226949, -0.0165788233, 0.0646090209, 0.0417032689, -0.0084837209, -0.0249281134, -0.0536617078, 0.0335015543, -0.0020381005, 0.0516543724, 0.0104908748, 0.0241082218, 0.0812686011, -0.0544238016, 0.0046598711, 0.0775676519, 0.0204560626, -0.0304206945, -0.0407498106, 0.0010558921, 0.0222809892, 0.042943418, 0.0423003547, -0.0800520405, -0.0608033203, -0.0017558654, -0.028777156, 0.0109402509, -0.0104460707, -0.0385488905, -0.0800805911, 0.0762380362, -0.012556985, 0.0099649327, -0.0165068191, 0.0082228305, -0.0124426847, 0.0066521834, -0.045027256, 0.0065196734, 0.005711209, 0.0046326523, -0.0093472162, 0.0512678623, 0.0027899577, 0.0542459376, -0.0655724481, -0.009210702, 0.023165632, 0.0119612692, 0.027578434, -0.0846012831, -0.0107126646, -0.0178586841, 0.0378173925, -0.0072187702, 0.0548531301, 0.0034085612, -0.0579494163, -0.0294612795, 0.0314222276, 0.0025881198, -0.0422714874, -0.0064548012, 0.0509647019, -0.0451586284, -0.0229058731, -0.0160340387, 0.0244152844, -0.0134524629, 0.0494213067, 0.0219986439, 0.0004613078, -0.0369260162, -0.0120015601, -0.0487148128, -0.0600351058, -0.0346278995, 0.0013731918, 0.0253323354, 0.0056199729, -0.0596200489, 0.0071887951, 0.0682388246, 0.0822441801, -0.0266528409, -0.0445413105, -0.0107500963, 0.0352296568, -0.0547267906, 0.0589655004, -0.0293845516, 0.0317430906, -0.0206736699, 0.0214774739, 0.0429656617, -0.0563975088, -0.0201656222, -0.0073683998, -0.0261039957, -0.0233080238, -0.0608433783, 0.0857828781, 0.0127757126, 0.0548991971, 0.0137272719, -0.0494483076, 0.0385804661, 0.0041200127, 0.0216200873, -0.0137011567, -0.0016029601, -0.0312992372, -0.0043395935, -0.0026080946, -0.0234803911, 0.011909212, 0.0316215865, 0.00249189, -0.0331631675, 0.0014231256, 0.0156996604, 0.0103429742, 0.0349289924, -0.0181116145, 0.0057615004, -0.0271475948, 0.0213637222, 0.0000070853, -0.0027447708, -0.0693531856, 0.0331791118, -0.0010276193, -0.0315248221, 0.0139595065, -0.018077489, 0.0006870389, 0.0085024126, 0.0091195684, -0.010252418, 0.0293815471, 0.0176685657, 0.0002099062, 0.0155503554, 0.0032952931, 0.021451287, -0.023452308, 0.0394971669, -0.005059618, 0.1088975668, 0.0454503335, -0.0397377089, -0.0374663621, 0.0175817069, -0.0207920838, -0.0749444291, 0.0156083694, 0.044714123, 0.0271090977, 0.0160708874, -0.0500498898, -0.0107208146, -0.017892966, 0.0170272924, 0.0416979752, 0.0315193273, -0.0572074801, 0.0799785778, 0.0394267589, 0.0093326801, -0.0218138229, 0.0373304747, -0.0278527513, 0.0084729344, -0.0062263669, -0.0247519203, -0.0429961793, 0.0010618033, 0.0207051318, 0.0096415244, -0.0025443083, 0.0511190929, -0.0274882335, -0.0566748194, -0.0284759421, 0.016197199, -0.0364691578, 0.05625128, 0.0299201608, 0.0436407067, 0.0331526436, -0.0375468396, -0.0076224925, -0.0110422978, -0.0368344188, 0.0213943925, 0.0106630633, -6.176700453e-33, -0.0064564259, -0.0617709979, 0.0704548508, -0.038086392, 0.016767256, 0.0010437008, -0.0258043446, -0.0112586915, -0.021616485, 0.0242801849, 0.0039195707, -0.0018841722, 0.0030494013, 0.0306082349, 0.0012496138, -0.0134621514, 0.0143539431, 0.0260747653, -0.0056147948, 0.0106406324, 0.0254276991, -0.0207656678, 0.0261543319, -0.026151659, -0.0091451807, 0.0474079624, -0.0382864662, 0.0531971976, -0.0260163955, 0.0429402441, -0.0314631723, -0.013939904, 0.0114225419, -0.0032039536, 0.0006880175, 0.0314096585, -0.0686924011, -0.0253124405, 0.0485358164, 0.0064031202, -0.097110793, 0.0046549668, -0.0233322661, -0.0267438497, 0.0232671294, -0.0391046815, 0.0331155099, -0.0268322639, 0.004429508, 0.0186956841, -0.0040862602, -0.0026538267, -0.0191777907, -0.0634717569, 0.0345939621, 0.0284319762, 0.0249027554, 0.0413864888, -0.0321180522, 0.0393122472, 0.010907541, -0.0141049298, 0.0877697617, 0.0274589881, -0.0129613373, 0.0663894042, 0.0107853375, -0.0502217077, -0.0623665377, 0.0083007812, -0.0068070684, 0.0777377486, 0.0789648443, 0.0698083937, 0.0179292765, 0.0363422595, -0.0611337759, -0.0001465203, -0.0587543286, 0.0731464624, 0.0038681626, 0.0020643934, 0.000672476, -0.0015586887, -0.0598232821, -0.0002785849, -0.0666080192, -0.0088546369, 0.0499656275, 0.0406088755, -0.0177724287, 0.0431264527, 0.0591208637, -0.0380068868, 0.0140462918, 0.0340373367, -0.0096161859, 0.0142108714, 0.0009998556, 0.0193581842, -0.0190845504, 0.0067985179, 0.0833081603, -0.024252627, -0.0272066854, 0.0188916419, 0.0367498547, -0.001665502, -0.0299789999, -0.0042033433, -0.0563796312, 0.0066435626, -0.0147068463, 0.0057884869, -0.0007567225, 0.0435122736, -0.0677335709, 0.0125120198, -0.0297789089, -0.025638232, 0.0200616866, -0.0265175086, -0.0048524821, 0.036698021, -0.0143268239, -0.0045312261, -0.0326930098, -0.0531853661, 0.0026271224, -0.0513753183, -0.0109282155, 0.0580524839, 2.584e-7, -0.0038180314, 0.0214773249, -0.0180324577, 0.0098789949, 0.0001153911, 0.0675706044, -0.0062028593, -0.0200875439, 0.0239279047, -0.046639841, 0.0123735545, 0.0723429024, 0.0027208787, 0.0066984943, 0.0099232476, 0.0216373969, -0.0024272003, -0.066449523, -0.0628998652, -0.0042971964, 0.0917320848, 0.0540718324, -0.0120782852, -0.0142440163, 0.0624185242, -0.0811404139, 0.0676909015, -0.0355203487, 0.0049988199, -0.0250753537, 0.0285774749, -0.0144263944, -0.0184085444, 0.0668903887, 0.0069274758, -0.0462413169, -0.0023911002, 0.0103233736, -0.0109856455, -0.0087807802, -0.0614615604, 0.0321281701, 0.0052824891, -0.0764702931, 0.1037744731, -0.0751752406, -0.0254069921, -0.0135506159, -0.0418892577, -0.0357270353, 0.0089415209, -0.0079031037, -0.0181096494, 0.0078789713, 0.0244642831, -0.0265717916, -0.0182474386, -0.0943750963, -0.010388759, -0.0126365237, 0.0011455939, 0.0027768197, -0.0478363223, -0.0250568707, 0.0635046139, -0.0164694358, -0.0425778702, 1.633214058e-34, 0.026720427, 0.0104165403, 0.0083956691, 0.0117853116, 0.0391003191, 0.0254788641, -0.0317795873, -0.0224374849, 0.0370782353, -0.0782023594, -0.0117015298 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.05220v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.05220v1
Adversarial Adaptation for French Named Entity Recognition
2023-01-12T18:58:36
2023-01-12T18:58:36
Arjun Choudhry, Inder Khatri, Pankaj Gupta, Aaryan Gupta, Maxime Nicol, Marie-Jean Meurs, Dinesh Kumar Vishwakarma
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
Named Entity Recognition (NER) is the task of identifying and classifying named entities in large-scale texts into predefined classes. NER in French and other relatively limited-resource languages cannot always benefit from approaches proposed for languages like English due to a dearth of large, robust datasets. In this paper, we present our work that aims to mitigate the effects of this dearth of large, labeled datasets. We propose a Transformer-based NER approach for French, using adversarial adaptation to similar domain or general corpora to improve feature extraction and enable better generalization. Our approach allows learning better features using large-scale unlabeled corpora from the same domain or mixed domains to introduce more variations during training and reduce overfitting. Experimental results on three labeled datasets show that our adaptation framework outperforms the corresponding non-adaptive models for various combinations of Transformer models, source datasets, and target corpora. We also show that adversarial adaptation to large-scale unlabeled corpora can help mitigate the performance dip incurred on using Transformer models pre-trained on smaller corpora.
[ 0.022883812, 0.1072763503, 0.0094000725, 0.0369214565, 0.0244920105, 0.0266674794, 0.008260807, -0.0002568433, 0.0051820627, -0.0541186333, -0.0393466353, -0.0131006679, -0.0340522937, 0.0024737343, 0.0409261696, -0.0517452396, 0.0208207835, -0.0144014461, -0.0173722282, 0.0082895979, 0.0022176334, 0.0001874814, 0.0051752618, -0.0125174196, 0.0359009206, 0.0585616939, -0.0083900625, 0.0151264127, 0.0339664891, -0.0105725816, 0.0275589824, 0.040448416, -0.0216843113, 0.0786919892, 0.0000018199, -0.0616578609, -0.0514679812, -0.0034562286, 0.00193931, -0.0265515018, 0.0129595082, -0.0757854581, -0.0384899229, 0.0075872289, 0.003441955, -0.0866608471, 0.0513732545, 0.0715715438, 0.0054268553, 0.1032484099, -0.0272557661, -0.0495942123, 0.0199721977, -0.0471086539, -0.0318197943, -0.0534421876, 0.0257080123, -0.0587166362, -0.0375227034, 0.0105534093, -0.0456632748, 0.0364533402, 0.0039013368, -0.0111776665, 0.0099253934, 0.0184769779, -0.0165574327, 0.0006789406, 0.0000989932, 0.0730138868, -0.0307677016, -0.0075171548, 0.0057856883, -0.0194952637, 0.0026614743, -0.0156520773, -0.0346468762, -0.0334361047, -0.0091114528, 0.0040114666, -0.0088852085, 0.001899429, 0.0303714033, -0.0199032538, -0.0604935996, -0.0338615254, 0.0162857212, -0.0233551022, 0.0427026041, 0.0128967045, -0.0460939258, -0.0206743758, 0.0292804576, 0.0084841987, 0.0061184801, 0.0078277932, -0.0314716026, -0.0457739495, -0.0174992979, -0.0296874698, 0.0109790601, -0.0136048393, -0.0157704093, 0.0238088816, -0.0615478382, 0.0400824919, -0.064554736, 0.0179213397, -0.0180377495, -0.0465681255, -0.0852921903, 0.0191707257, -0.0398516245, -0.0023899951, -0.0345671773, 0.054629378, 0.0021139663, -0.0050153094, 0.0112509513, 0.0213957783, 0.0400849618, 0.0051372657, -0.0322210118, -0.0214137007, -0.0009482918, 0.0520710014, -0.0072354204, -0.0034996239, -0.0294280089, -0.0688423663, -0.0114500076, -0.0175421536, 0.0210804511, -0.0647718534, 0.0343156531, 0.1237778366, -0.0223867744, -0.0570082441, -0.0266465805, 0.0342591256, 0.0122579327, -0.033710368, 0.0233820751, -0.0390649438, 0.0261403136, 0.0028966565, 0.025215257, -0.069412373, 0.0001181142, -0.0324601568, -0.0784043148, 0.079321593, -0.0180327799, -0.0335350074, 0.0402086414, 0.0140012344, 0.0136307916, 0.0392662138, 0.0182874948, -0.0155326994, 0.0174769834, -0.0022571925, 0.0032806941, 0.0627986714, 0.0355447419, 0.0052131293, 0.0139016174, 0.0075894399, 0.0062135532, 0.0040081274, 0.038751211, 0.0355327986, 0.0367664099, -0.0574340485, 0.0470345952, -0.0317139514, 0.0183542855, 0.0600680187, -0.0125620421, 0.0102419434, 0.0172852296, -0.0066936947, -0.0252596866, 0.0206500832, -0.0460536964, -0.0077299085, -0.0248874761, 0.0279506911, -0.0381665267, -0.0317563303, 0.0067832577, 0.001102819, 0.0303039011, -0.0112141902, 0.0583429784, 0.0783931911, -0.0488869846, 0.0305915531, 0.038739156, -0.0177243166, -0.0000855739, 0.0047864178, 0.0122927809, 0.0256270431, 0.0233826209, -0.0649957582, -0.0154552637, -0.0477455594, -0.0011407046, 0.0388018638, -0.0001619308, -0.0219354294, 0.0607580766, -0.0370985717, -0.014426589, 0.0062348992, 0.0074144667, 0.0696885958, -0.0075291395, 0.0432193577, 0.014045028, -0.0272413362, -0.0449503511, 0.0435096323, -0.061314512, -0.0603065863, 0.0102119567, 0.0353070199, 0.0112659773, 0.0129943695, -0.0238029398, -0.0438287929, 0.011242616, -0.0380683318, -0.0099768033, -0.0217678007, 0.0289197788, -0.0190814864, -0.0106602013, -0.037285164, -0.0317037702, 0.0495101772, -0.0453273617, -0.0032796103, -0.0039556194, 0.0206633136, 0.0185829252, 0.0226977523, 0.0154387606, 0.0197361186, 0.0492830575, -0.0152406199, 0.0438298322, 0.0031666763, 0.0095376391, 0.0068491213, -0.0131502552, 0.0008282267, -0.0080084009, -0.0445639268, 0.0681825131, -0.0121212061, -0.0232542176, 0.0290950537, 0.00270076, -0.0086551858, -0.0158357844, -0.0319890492, -0.0050156149, -0.0342140086, 0.0484000854, 0.0142724486, 0.0405522995, -0.0240562819, -0.0551771931, -0.0182000417, 0.0101665193, -0.0380217992, -0.0018989532, 0.0389780626, 0.0183265153, 0.0029119989, -0.0133697744, 0.0196800753, 0.0002447381, 0.0444220342, 0.0211030953, -0.0129722068, -0.0413277633, 0.0642816573, -0.0177983381, 0.0291804299, 0.0009344258, -0.0317571573, -0.0387057886, 0.0166527182, -0.0236719139, 0.0625042841, -0.0005782573, 0.0218360871, -0.0201614667, 0.0172767602, -0.010434485, 0.0237247776, -0.0117996419, -0.011881832, -0.0783700123, -0.0256656148, 0.0383236744, 0.0736264288, -0.0320049077, 0.0062231622, -0.0201247763, 0.0270357337, 0.0030808437, -0.0033084692, -0.0102901943, 0.076544188, 0.0039291405, -0.0127188312, -0.0084403288, -0.0110543836, 0.0676272437, -0.0133980149, -0.0129688624, -0.0343296267, -0.0129494341, -0.0166634582, 0.0659216493, 0.039623484, 0.0078110695, 0.0411466025, -0.0565395392, -0.0550988913, 0.0092425654, 0.0173588004, -0.0038676655, 0.0567957312, 0.0196059663, -0.010333891, -0.0141708162, -0.0211944021, -0.0369543172, -0.0140391886, -0.022594424, 0.0017960996, 0.0264860597, -0.0334633924, -0.0573393889, 0.0008112538, 0.0047258139, 0.089386411, 0.0331937484, -0.0313839279, -0.0096517876, 0.0392372943, 0.0120668691, 0.0367446393, 0.0104343053, -0.0151025513, 0.0099790078, 0.0319502354, -0.0334725045, -0.0255474225, -0.000225189, -0.0342747234, 0.0167762265, -0.0435042381, -0.0056688436, -0.0340598933, 0.029967308, -0.0050530825, -0.0227635298, 0.0877702758, -0.0205485113, 0.0116407685, 0.0060617509, 0.045743119, 0.0208356678, 0.0139179938, 0.019024197, -0.0439919941, -0.0273714624, -0.0080433553, -0.0050063469, 0.0216070246, -0.0215783753, 0.0021570744, -0.0927742496, -0.0167104993, -0.0140905567, -0.0829463303, 0.0056283032, -0.0284982566, 0.0048679761, -0.0932252854, 0.0139421262, -0.0567040108, -0.0074867797, -0.0054951352, 0.010479657, 0.0022326347, -0.0795631483, -0.0375011079, -0.0505279787, 0.0259201881, 0.0478541218, 0.0353606641, -0.0518768504, 0.0128449062, -0.0005634955, -0.0039716712, -0.0157866571, -0.0085099852, 0.0667868406, -0.0078842333, -0.0050847465, 0.0209140424, -0.0044871531, -0.0065629748, -0.0123338904, 0.05986939, 0.0237543676, 0.0130370464, 0.0108707258, 0.0030735435, -0.0519895889, 0.0207596831, 0.047071524, -0.0022754176, -0.0504041165, -0.0041182977, -0.0172717981, -0.041707091, -0.0480243005, -0.045078598, 0.0355203636, -0.0595800057, -0.0573317707, -0.05509229, -0.0355582498, 0.0176604073, 0.0319835879, 0.0205212627, -0.0078938249, 0.0103431717, 0.0065145884, -0.0419363417, 0.0239426494, 0.0025703702, -0.0153262876, -0.0442629009, -0.0419231504, 0.0228299405, -0.0278729964, -0.0322356932, -0.0082881926, -0.0660712123, -0.0498370565, 0.0132702598, 0.010891282, 0.0094996877, 0.0507122912, -0.0110456413, -0.0442438759, 0.0733838975, 0.0669431165, -0.0275759362, -0.0210961103, 0.0532744192, -0.0261964351, -0.0158155058, 0.0439918116, -0.0258487165, 0.0460256524, 0.0739570558, 0.0160436798, -0.0052443389, -0.0201877467, -0.012871962, 0.0165891144, 0.0633829609, -0.0077818297, -0.0062316009, -0.0488412678, 0.0164800324, 0.0279457364, 0.0276646111, 0.0100267865, -0.0134498877, 0.0378736183, 0.0056188903, -0.0239182319, 0.0401661582, 0.0154268425, -0.0125246476, -0.0643016249, 0.0135099143, 0.0299104024, 0.0507114865, 0.0302563719, 0.0257658027, 0.0486157648, 0.0373552218, 0.0892570391, 0.0346001126, -0.0278494041, 0.0142464098, 0.0304573793, 0.0267371405, -0.0256917384, 0.0102762729, -0.0725999698, 0.0222199131, -0.0578168742, 0.0538701266, 0.0324699208, -0.0335256383, 0.044503618, -0.0187314972, -0.0024052521, -0.0263914671, -0.0105437236, -0.0331978314, 0.0002211675, 0.0004453694, -0.003939982, -0.0138586946, -0.0080692787, 0.0425102226, 0.0541030802, 0.0213766266, 0.0295088589, 0.0108918436, -0.0516400896, -0.0033244339, 0.0364177153, -0.0693084598, -0.0340300798, 0.0121857803, 0.0093317972, -0.046337124, 0.0121641466, -0.0428186767, 0.0075784777, 0.0069964151, 0.0101088742, 0.0052459165, 0.0175971147, 0.0021234197, -0.0342705585, 0.0476236753, 0.0146169309, -0.0298830476, 0.0106541151, -5.895776405e-33, -0.0346963331, -0.0072857761, -0.0309941508, -0.0004641213, 0.0010166513, -0.001242417, -0.0315792263, -0.0131541304, -0.010323517, -0.00604941, 0.0067123454, 0.0064465716, 0.0136037664, 0.0434092097, -0.0067184675, -0.0743283033, 0.0844118893, 0.0577589534, -0.0412347056, -0.0090056788, 0.0276335049, 0.0858669803, 0.1011632532, -0.1043601185, 0.0250563044, -0.0270589702, 0.0002828834, -0.0385806002, 0.0645340085, 0.0796515346, 0.0051637623, 0.0480971672, -0.0003343268, -0.0686715543, 0.0124444626, -0.0015656124, -0.1684838086, 0.0185152031, -0.0466415882, 0.10168989, 0.0068500238, -0.0301701091, 0.0270804036, 0.0003472558, -0.0123340497, -0.0030025963, 0.0420099683, -0.0432499535, 0.0230801366, -0.0177979916, -0.0742216632, 0.0164859015, 0.0248080362, 0.0508867502, 0.0241107009, 0.0228115357, 0.0549337901, -0.0124340402, -0.0911958665, -0.0246233046, 0.0128935268, 0.0127328914, 0.0324421749, 0.0311122257, -0.0212430414, 0.0210275985, 0.016394984, -0.0140597988, -0.0281665698, 0.0075430786, 0.0440078564, -0.009689779, 0.0374254659, 0.0893669054, 0.0704622045, -0.0718039125, -0.0844343007, 0.0278665759, -0.0248833708, -0.0039677029, -0.0293784402, 0.0116655938, -0.0138318753, 0.0218471065, -0.0070186662, -0.0265245903, -0.0141921341, -0.012663736, 0.0128638344, -0.0041896547, -0.0391960815, 0.0278327223, 0.008024578, -0.0275573898, -0.0616691448, 0.0067075021, 0.0176229142, -0.0043637031, -0.0119834468, 0.0181643348, -0.0446542874, -0.0482200868, 0.0441419147, 0.0117944097, 0.0318673514, -0.0184316486, 0.0924315825, 0.0068873335, -0.0622277893, -0.0019352043, -0.0235678256, 0.0475966446, 0.0040531685, 0.0822762251, -0.0012989163, -0.0234423876, -0.0010801542, 0.0249519851, 0.0442324951, -0.0417472348, -0.0162451528, 0.0290072579, 0.0341594368, 0.0130578242, -0.0442779213, -0.0373681709, 0.019117292, -0.03689586, 0.0286117755, -0.103518039, -0.0088366875, -0.0281851124, 2.539e-7, 0.018712258, 0.0161664505, 0.0326276906, -0.0502954014, -0.0158900153, 0.02804932, -0.0088048335, 0.0729214028, -0.0421446525, 0.0050734025, -0.0151022393, -0.0239224471, 0.0372023135, 0.0403808765, -0.0841533169, -0.0408243127, -0.0236739498, 0.0281696972, -0.0169851258, 0.0421614051, -0.0047985837, 0.1224226877, 0.0042987294, -0.0061756112, -0.0122960825, -0.0294682812, 0.0349402465, 0.0124078402, 0.0400983058, 0.0133757126, 0.0268646665, 0.0879765898, -0.0189578719, 0.0127773955, -0.0240252428, 0.0008524382, 0.0367128216, 0.0189235508, 0.0110088652, 0.0315434411, -0.0131383827, -0.0484922715, 0.010873572, -0.0091421949, 0.0341116861, -0.0460345969, -0.0111099984, 0.0118573848, -0.0132675627, -0.0006553567, 0.0371192656, -0.0052806791, 0.0096778814, 0.0276110303, 0.0567539148, 0.002329859, -0.0109983915, -0.0546061918, 0.0234628171, 0.0032931357, 0.0138203083, 0.0081837084, 0.0107082129, 0.0105016194, 0.0011688775, -0.0165845305, 0.0202309359, 2.012874512e-34, -0.024976803, 0.0349930637, -0.047945492, -0.0251229275, 0.0244309101, -0.0486942902, -0.0164728947, -0.0213901661, -0.0088463109, -0.0106303133, 0.000006182 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.05036v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.05036v1
Everyone's Voice Matters: Quantifying Annotation Disagreement Using Demographic Information
2023-01-12T14:04:53
2023-01-12T14:04:53
Ruyuan Wan, Jaehyung Kim, Dongyeop Kang
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY
In NLP annotation, it is common to have multiple annotators label the text and then obtain the ground truth labels based on the agreement of major annotators. However, annotators are individuals with different backgrounds, and minors' opinions should not be simply ignored. As annotation tasks become subjective and topics are controversial in modern NLP tasks, we need NLP systems that can represent people's diverse voices on subjective matters and predict the level of diversity. This paper examines whether the text of the task and annotators' demographic background information can be used to estimate the level of disagreement among annotators. Particularly, we extract disagreement labels from the annotators' voting histories in the five subjective datasets, and then fine-tune language models to predict annotators' disagreement. Our results show that knowing annotators' demographic information, like gender, ethnicity, and education level, helps predict disagreements. In order to distinguish the disagreement from the inherent controversy from text content and the disagreement in the annotators' different perspectives, we simulate everyone's voices with different combinations of annotators' artificial demographics and examine its variance of the finetuned disagreement predictor. Our paper aims to improve the annotation process for more efficient and inclusive NLP systems through a novel disagreement prediction mechanism. Our code and dataset are publicly available.
[ 0.0594293475, 0.0393355638, 0.0133967828, 0.0147959171, -0.0178019926, 0.018073976, 0.0260711461, -0.0420731306, -0.0084602647, -0.0950000659, 0.0120127918, -0.0105103115, 0.0022964715, -0.0451300554, -0.0262631718, -0.0457205437, 0.0030363619, 0.0388646051, 0.059669368, -0.0105137881, 0.0511315763, 0.0176578015, -0.0135659622, 0.0696227849, -0.0467795916, -0.0268247835, 0.019857863, -0.0032924137, 0.0296342596, -0.0029401616, 0.0563513115, 0.0831022933, -0.0153483422, 0.0764673799, 0.0000017121, -0.0068461052, -0.0137640014, 0.0341988616, -0.0169412028, -0.0042442023, 0.0562895685, 0.0691095218, -0.0238064975, 0.0199787468, -0.0407719389, 0.0310451463, 0.0383733511, 0.0378349088, 0.0718951821, 0.0078514833, 0.0086223977, 0.0073543373, -0.0742993057, 0.0234906022, 0.0036692615, 0.0046482258, -0.0023047039, 0.0389468856, -0.0452659018, 0.0233186353, 0.0211206488, 0.0061816457, 0.0037091416, -0.0381312631, 0.0250837058, -0.0250292886, -0.0513244346, -0.0382771939, 0.0259462502, 0.0475564897, 0.0416757129, -0.0173885841, 0.0001538577, -0.0094215283, 0.0069381646, 0.0073299408, -0.0384459421, 0.0384676009, -0.0222659409, 0.0188939534, 0.0048781908, 0.0232552476, 0.0073549156, 0.0070783482, 0.0357878171, 0.0714523494, -0.027060831, -0.0148783708, 0.0035931889, 0.0426439084, -0.020517977, -0.0348000638, 0.0312509127, -0.0174854044, -0.0128581095, 0.0193599407, -0.0158505552, -0.0739052147, 0.0322291218, -0.0759602487, -0.0056858743, -0.0264070742, -0.011908628, 0.0468901545, 0.0555831753, -0.0353980474, 0.0118035665, 0.0127732875, 0.0155609259, -0.0394218266, -0.0450828895, 0.0166214909, -0.0051545477, 0.0112722488, -0.0275469869, 0.0336618461, -0.0234624986, -0.0185653828, -0.0694394335, -0.0023558026, 0.0176389161, 0.01402466, -0.0066411677, 0.002935668, -0.0613737442, 0.0482414104, -0.0457955487, 0.0070278225, -0.0038898182, -0.0532966927, 0.0315339752, 0.0360882841, -0.0082920091, -0.0234336369, -0.0119749149, 0.000535759, 0.0281794481, 0.0262396671, -0.0518514141, -0.0304703675, -0.0204002894, -0.0313039236, 0.001071651, -0.0857284144, 0.0150808925, 0.0047099758, 0.0165906455, -0.0300695393, 0.0093587972, 0.0472825505, -0.0034673116, 0.075851731, -0.02354303, -0.033209078, 0.0909839422, 0.0029806516, -0.0224202983, 0.0809991583, 0.0186100453, -0.0406645499, 0.0636691153, 0.0271302219, 0.0037409987, -0.0056607188, -0.014381432, -0.0017546798, 0.0404885858, -0.0096119726, -0.0183319692, -0.0126802241, -0.0058590346, 0.0553296693, -0.0086654648, -0.0640010238, 0.0311511494, 0.0808009058, -0.0477107838, 0.0166168306, -0.006142491, 0.0419900604, 0.0157285742, 0.0085397223, -0.0142420931, 0.0417490862, -0.0273358785, -0.0659212768, 0.0494601279, 0.0141075198, -0.0053916276, -0.0823290572, -0.0560109802, -0.0034092974, 0.0395906977, -0.0084148673, -0.0171709564, 0.0093020499, 0.0225868635, 0.041452378, 0.0368157178, -0.0865343288, -0.0243685078, 0.0088549433, 0.0245658364, 0.0263966862, -0.0152214235, -0.0360576585, -0.0262660459, -0.0516500585, 0.0353785567, 0.0331263319, 0.0599164926, -0.0250354577, -0.0281175058, -0.0665384308, -0.038482625, 0.0185498185, 0.0320747457, 0.0288203023, 0.0583644249, -0.0275239497, -0.010882793, -0.0143007282, -0.0728707984, 0.0313534886, 0.0033126452, 0.004501652, 0.0177736543, 0.0128556788, 0.0660721213, 0.0510468259, -0.0254357886, 0.009145543, -0.0114182392, -0.0045529422, -0.0355302468, -0.0071783015, 0.0114773093, -0.0218709912, 0.0410297178, -0.0683190674, -0.0583903678, -0.0186684188, -0.0121351639, -0.0071989493, 0.0332986079, -0.0379502662, -0.0637862757, -0.0049436265, -0.0139927007, -0.0203079395, -0.034461882, -0.0929928645, 0.0194658544, 0.0123602105, 0.0095508043, -0.002254715, -0.0166786052, 0.0259925518, -0.0290454347, -0.0687495768, -0.0150524732, 0.0451910198, 0.0316666402, 0.0654367507, -0.0349559188, -0.0157014281, -0.0324204825, -0.0841381624, -0.0035084691, -0.0272857789, -0.0055485456, 0.0186787378, -0.050147824, 0.025655143, -0.0079454463, -0.0308525916, -0.010197957, -0.0368280262, 0.0374322534, 0.0419112034, -0.0193905327, 0.0547450781, -0.0348583832, -0.0180970188, -0.0241406299, 0.049443353, 0.0452588126, -0.0401157103, 0.0017489207, -0.0385706946, -0.0454339646, 0.0266089886, 0.0011096222, 0.024878243, 0.0522415452, 0.0451305583, 0.0354475752, 0.0459565036, 0.0156260133, 0.0595030487, 0.0407767445, -0.0220957138, -0.0517632812, -0.0101088239, 0.0010816935, 0.0239373576, 0.0104788104, -0.0512995087, 0.0223493446, 0.0589661188, -0.0039094114, -0.037182305, -0.0747712702, 0.0431918502, -0.0914932787, -0.0069795889, -0.0068468577, -0.0123286787, -0.0160488579, 0.0323233977, -0.0310733169, 0.0037550905, 0.0625865608, 0.0079202568, 0.0282649975, -0.0611585714, 0.0090903658, -0.0604100637, 0.0288121924, -0.044007387, -0.0058730105, 0.0400478654, 0.0154358735, -0.0180765502, -0.0053310324, 0.0718022138, -0.0581398532, 0.0648601428, -0.0598680601, 0.0090091648, -0.0114037646, -0.0251925085, 0.0021851072, -0.0297840666, -0.0266950987, 0.0068021547, 0.0689530447, -0.015468386, -0.0134907262, -0.0164152402, 0.0096203974, 0.0115317591, 0.0097041233, 0.0019841385, 0.0201924741, -0.0009222927, 0.0017483088, 0.0322089009, 0.0459278487, -0.018173255, -0.0275928378, 0.0673330501, -0.0129863387, -0.0215500779, -0.0065542888, -0.0461644158, 0.0175527409, -0.0492979251, -0.0318972692, -0.0282563306, 0.069288142, -0.0667278245, 0.034660697, 0.0713657737, 0.0430739485, -0.0446638279, -0.0296403039, -0.04092611, 0.0222145952, 0.0357006118, -0.0032295522, -0.0810809061, 0.0064012883, -0.0270981994, 0.0115914512, -0.0339612961, -0.0511473939, -0.0041852263, -0.0957805589, 0.0170743093, 0.004918118, -0.0220954046, 0.0138956318, -0.0295203254, 0.0106495107, -0.039062649, 0.0198663026, -0.0342977718, 0.0609766953, 0.0357572138, 0.0412910618, -0.080357857, -0.0078264801, 0.0257197134, -0.0403466485, 0.078365624, 0.0233120173, 0.0548262522, 0.0075292676, -0.0037189743, 0.0556941293, -0.0050587296, -0.0237879641, -0.0099621592, 0.0695484132, -0.0269711614, -0.0019819397, -0.0343430415, -0.004129672, 0.0208581686, -0.0109019959, 0.0123148225, 0.0168714225, 0.0211166907, 0.0194596127, -0.0369252264, 0.0319357291, 0.0103583038, 0.065144442, 0.0298782513, -0.0405928157, -0.0287259333, -0.0695063323, 0.0154240364, -0.0382169783, -0.0550221391, -0.0061868592, 0.0017226742, -0.0370468535, -0.0414530411, -0.0387347601, 0.0247788597, 0.01059666, -0.0023576678, -0.0134462109, 0.0740217492, -0.0032383432, -0.012638716, 0.028682759, -0.0152112748, 0.0170808285, 0.0066857836, -0.0636035725, -0.007801068, 0.0493416637, -0.0275768749, 0.0116153425, -0.0598581098, -0.0534185991, 0.0366990082, 0.0290529411, 0.0196088869, 0.0106142266, -0.0125299832, -0.0635239333, -0.0231780708, 0.0350021571, 0.0398483872, -0.0245837942, 0.00520356, 0.0675920323, 0.0066614882, 0.0223526694, -0.0104772756, 0.0058894274, 0.0233258344, -0.0030864116, -0.0724802315, -0.0454274863, 0.0026514712, -0.0020393096, 0.0093501816, 0.0240164399, -0.0121387988, -0.031709116, -0.0221317615, -0.0193284582, -0.0658678487, -0.0150296884, -0.0136712398, -0.0260817036, -0.0629129037, -0.0285210181, 0.0537696704, 0.0080491025, 0.0607629381, -0.017398946, 0.0417482667, 0.0189796109, 0.0188578311, -0.0311102085, 0.0003128761, -0.0329045095, 0.005030422, 0.0025189151, 0.018965818, 0.0394290574, 0.0194783304, 0.0012021713, -0.0223585702, 0.0231809784, -0.0156009803, -0.049832534, 0.0054234751, -0.0081433468, 0.0391793773, 0.0070217913, -0.0041635274, 0.0474986695, -0.0014489096, -0.0294155777, -0.0224535856, 0.017935209, 0.0321122669, -0.0041726488, 0.0310564023, 0.0045920857, -0.0191067196, -0.0201608073, 0.0476566479, -0.023230616, -0.0074516213, 0.0066139959, -0.0450002775, -0.042451892, 0.0085891886, -0.0285683721, 0.0269095264, 0.0055086464, 0.0148571953, -0.0694265515, 0.007163499, 0.0324408002, -0.0034763673, 0.0326005667, 0.0291781537, 0.0069662705, 0.0499470904, -0.0287999734, -0.004073557, -0.0440661125, 0.0049502742, -0.0256327149, 0.016654091, -0.0434476398, -5.932580766e-33, -0.0357599854, -0.0602911226, -0.0433958843, 0.0153524186, 0.0112959333, -0.0031819784, -0.0125568053, 0.0448955372, -0.0168430135, 0.0351975337, 0.0163375102, 0.0373785719, 0.0226971824, 0.0127822785, 0.0381051451, -0.0411460102, 0.0495926403, 0.0103262477, -0.0181498118, -0.0197807513, 0.0194616653, -0.0447311066, 0.0292398613, -0.105724588, 0.1029163003, 0.0241975319, -0.0042253025, 0.0079749012, -0.0158935785, 0.0550116003, 0.001541135, 0.071032308, 0.014531807, -0.0509530045, -0.0160248801, 0.0222056024, -0.0310534276, -0.0237443075, -0.0086054252, 0.0253540222, -0.0178849082, -0.031527251, 0.0366434678, 0.0308832563, -0.0471589193, -0.0282045882, 0.0669391081, -0.0126038911, 0.0367468446, -0.0328873843, -0.0315187834, 0.0521892384, -0.0222428944, -0.0020735092, 0.0053524948, -0.0022272957, 0.0151239801, 0.0057248878, -0.0870264247, 0.0283638909, -0.0207698438, 0.0083561866, -0.0193531923, -0.035637103, 0.0113452142, 0.0571778566, -0.0004340886, 0.0611523576, -0.0564762503, -0.051531978, -0.0199813098, -0.0045508244, 0.0576403849, 0.0866801739, 0.0359812044, 0.0188406743, -0.0316796079, 0.014821291, 0.0269740392, -0.0021145262, 0.0420181379, -0.0087054148, -0.0502696075, -0.0245330613, -0.0316270329, -0.0634536222, -0.0234543048, 0.0051538749, -0.0106707597, -0.0103651909, -0.0528177842, 0.0386277139, -0.0130463466, -0.044829905, -0.0351030901, 0.0021108293, 0.0162029434, 0.0055242698, 0.0189356338, -0.0095282542, -0.053348612, 0.0464010313, -0.0119755063, 0.0076657096, 0.0319304913, 0.0054899617, 0.0550249368, -0.0061661405, -0.1018349081, -0.0224129818, -0.0049706814, 0.0312808342, -0.0236446038, 0.030709343, 0.0336524285, 0.024410231, -0.0134647051, 0.0344311334, 0.0124597987, 0.0634555295, 0.0057767713, -0.0229617544, -0.0330235139, -0.0315436088, 0.0077767051, -0.0108024478, 0.0287047271, 0.0151354698, -0.0147191593, 0.0247161202, -0.000062829, -0.0447512306, 2.243e-7, 0.0741679892, 0.0683127791, 0.0233372953, -0.0616162829, 0.026566064, 0.0344447419, 0.0238514859, -0.0019171871, 0.0095471181, -0.0616646819, -0.0360443927, 0.0005878338, 0.0384034403, 0.0847136378, -0.0650617704, -0.0499404557, -0.023550503, 0.0211192463, -0.013932717, 0.0130085321, 0.0628714785, 0.0539802089, 0.0468702093, 0.0242719166, -0.0454077125, 0.0406537279, 0.0493753366, -0.0054446692, -0.0287446305, 0.0242475998, 0.0739141256, -0.0689515918, 0.0396497138, 0.0469404832, -0.0123570235, -0.0097194957, 0.0250236075, 0.035946086, 0.0035222485, -0.0309762321, -0.0079061929, 0.023390606, 0.0045797089, -0.0046398472, 0.023643259, -0.0129310237, -0.0626549348, -0.0908057913, -0.0188169833, 0.0033858567, 0.0766421631, 0.0183646977, -0.0328300931, -0.0138216391, 0.0018770323, -0.0043075229, -0.0254771952, -0.0697646588, -0.0620013773, -0.0185331032, -0.0396731049, -0.0491423719, 0.0128172096, 0.0238160919, 0.002594077, -0.0062608384, 0.0293262415, 1.794781968e-34, 0.0325502306, 0.0180478841, 0.0225189514, 0.0029431551, 0.0335943475, 0.0383111089, 0.0030099261, -0.0186740346, 0.0347134359, 0.0370214246, 0.0070313648 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.04962v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.04962v1
A Dataset of Kurdish (Sorani) Named Entities -- An Amendment to Kurdish-BLARK Named Entities
2023-01-12T12:13:44
2023-01-12T12:13:44
Sazan Salar, Hossein Hassani
cs.CL
cs.CL
Named Entity Recognition (NER) is one of the essential applications of Natural Language Processing (NLP). It is also an instrument that plays a significant role in many other NLP applications, such as Machine Translation (MT), Information Retrieval (IR), and Part of Speech Tagging (POST). Kurdish is an under-resourced language from the NLP perspective. Particularly, in all the categories, the lack of NER resources hinders other aspects of Kurdish processing. In this work, we present a data set that covers several categories of NEs in Kurdish (Sorani). The dataset is a significant amendment to a previously developed dataset in the Kurdish BLARK (Basic Language Resource Kit). It covers 11 categories and 33261 entries in total. The dataset is publicly available for non-commercial use under CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 license at https://kurdishblark.github.io/.
[ 0.057523679, 0.008311634, -0.0274588857, 0.010047772, -0.0024775995, 0.0775384083, 0.0309972037, 0.0149166975, 0.0139614772, 0.0106754908, 0.0059763831, -0.0418425016, 0.0740432441, -0.0569505021, 0.0321219526, -0.0499281324, 0.0117643187, -0.0292312, 0.072969988, 0.0350844823, 0.0130782649, 0.0439890698, -0.067831099, 0.0094485758, -0.0463975184, 0.0279456023, 0.0024884578, 0.0007982185, 0.0094705503, -0.0643126667, -0.0024314665, 0.0102531752, -0.0559595339, 0.0147109656, 0.0000017169, -0.0514581241, -0.0221302155, -0.0423037931, -0.0229702536, -0.0673399121, 0.0344241634, -0.050598301, -0.0629697368, -0.0237766337, -0.0102429511, -0.0316324383, 0.0674146935, 0.0278005712, 0.0535860322, 0.0532881282, 0.0065726922, -0.0748371929, 0.0133466348, 0.0341270342, 0.0024120831, 0.0176265594, 0.0148219299, -0.0665473118, -0.0364606977, -0.0183139462, 0.0224646274, 0.0353852324, -0.0314699262, -0.013432608, -0.0365600139, 0.0369576514, -0.0677853003, -0.0677048787, 0.0441174805, 0.0136948461, -0.0007280535, 0.0104897888, 0.0383553877, 0.0132689606, -0.0424638689, -0.0176719315, -0.0274211019, -0.0045316429, -0.0874786079, -0.0038118395, 0.074660182, 0.060177099, 0.0078967707, -0.0234933179, 0.0160739385, 0.0276351497, 0.0484926999, -0.0257428251, 0.0008313227, 0.0052608657, 0.0118438955, -0.0048127738, 0.0374460258, 0.0288426355, -0.004999131, 0.0368853994, 0.0063568288, -0.0145631405, 0.0032669907, -0.0622014143, -0.0066321604, 0.0081268894, 0.0369810313, 0.0059600035, -0.0877528936, -0.0029382242, 0.070711948, -0.0083477963, 0.0138420602, -0.0151681192, -0.0529754795, -0.0188918076, -0.0683093891, 0.0490136221, -0.0296462905, 0.0415110774, -0.0415089391, 0.0117594535, -0.0063037239, 0.0495243073, 0.0687331632, -0.0292360615, 0.0010349802, 0.0241453946, -0.0328882858, -0.0208157599, -0.0264182799, 0.0064985179, -0.0706628188, -0.0711710006, 0.0454588942, -0.018112937, 0.0346964821, -0.0012829927, 0.0070475684, 0.0442612693, 0.0274264254, -0.0797184035, -0.0774182901, 0.0217583869, 0.015436342, -0.0151537126, -0.0110506359, -0.0303671528, 0.0603514835, 0.0047499905, 0.0033757489, -0.0832538903, 0.0131238699, 0.013441599, -0.0081853829, 0.0828236863, -0.0115149403, 0.0330503061, 0.0430617444, -0.0099801933, 0.1112319306, 0.0253054537, 0.0309519377, -0.0292811636, 0.0858669132, -0.0113815172, -0.0109748933, -0.0054497952, 0.0058235074, 0.0285888575, 0.0096399486, 0.0113028148, -0.033694461, 0.037646316, -0.0337435082, 0.0144579224, 0.0367038175, -0.0341710746, 0.027632026, 0.090420939, 0.0084957387, 0.019410314, -0.0103892032, 0.0432348959, 0.0301606879, -0.0310507379, 0.0089876922, 0.0020036227, 0.0061733392, 0.0272203069, 0.0083851824, 0.0457850099, -0.0293980241, -0.030113589, -0.0157802142, -0.0049134796, 0.0057118949, -0.0392177738, 0.0699876547, -0.0098538576, -0.0401994437, 0.051912006, 0.0568495877, -0.0036215752, 0.0135361943, -0.0342310257, 0.0027284133, 0.0114192655, 0.028959455, -0.0584806688, -0.0370165594, -0.002978836, -0.0447543673, 0.0704657659, -0.033847373, -0.0500758141, 0.0293120258, -0.0100261765, 0.0359050743, 0.0470111929, 0.0184430182, 0.0124551328, 0.014427105, 0.0797459111, 0.02005288, 0.004567544, -0.0142870266, 0.0478756689, -0.0220102351, -0.003788759, 0.0062707481, 0.018936405, -0.0109696966, 0.0848240331, -0.0097629176, 0.0025241694, 0.0085551823, -0.0085247941, 0.0394100361, -0.0005014507, 0.0390835926, -0.0107659958, 0.0209120363, -0.0125799114, -0.0203354862, 0.0306956135, 0.0036728615, -0.0447261147, 0.0296046771, 0.036231868, 0.0163492151, 0.0028223984, 0.0539634116, 0.0209877212, 0.0263348036, -0.0231174324, 0.0132601485, -0.0112571158, 0.0339069217, 0.0015836655, -0.0311820768, 0.0292207319, 0.0148517219, -0.0123527534, 0.0575429685, -0.0068194885, -0.033341758, 0.0070024375, -0.0224813577, -0.0011197118, 0.0051667951, -0.0485740192, -0.0125027178, -0.023352012, 0.0859467983, -0.0241729189, 0.0440242551, -0.0498204455, -0.0030481792, 0.0211179126, -0.0163788013, 0.0246053692, -0.0045944867, 0.0051871669, -0.0276810359, -0.0065231421, 0.0039225975, -0.0256968774, 0.0001019658, 0.0146957543, 0.0241016857, -0.1154263318, -0.0222804751, 0.0152473003, -0.0670689121, -0.0031523465, 0.0268925969, -0.0351848304, 0.0325541459, 0.00600533, -0.0071070935, 0.0094800731, -0.0442476124, -0.0034175955, -0.0290029552, -0.0484703518, 0.0036978573, -0.01078643, -0.0330353677, 0.0168517213, -0.0277043674, -0.0246809088, 0.0032184089, 0.0725779533, -0.0267748088, -0.027301468, -0.0254693106, 0.000945119, -0.0748105496, 0.0037344983, -0.0019953563, 0.0584172457, -0.009715274, 0.0721949413, 0.0052096033, 0.0043771314, 0.0236708317, -0.0258866642, 0.0020724966, -0.0118711749, -0.0016267707, -0.0638589561, 0.0398924984, -0.0057936171, -0.0180009957, 0.0019149507, -0.0908650458, -0.0000802367, 0.0495258421, 0.0012451217, -0.0025483058, 0.0032739062, -0.0351372771, 0.016131321, -0.0182694718, 0.0307857785, -0.0166083965, 0.0069306684, -0.0194895435, 0.0055611241, 0.017443791, 0.0049200896, 0.0385160893, 0.0402862616, -0.0214723404, 0.0066611599, 0.038302388, 0.0281677991, -0.0180371255, 0.042717196, -0.0170942154, -0.0301426165, 0.0117189139, 0.0681926385, -0.0032308616, 0.0245295353, -0.0545179844, -0.0064808722, 0.0061510736, -0.0064956485, 0.0375103615, -0.0662860647, -0.0044463426, -0.0495735742, -0.0117806578, -0.0419568494, 0.0083116107, 0.0782394707, 0.029676225, 0.0250715539, 0.0158298034, 0.0015750133, -0.044002153, 0.02937188, -0.0153103434, -0.0482554398, 0.0152940843, 0.0261613969, -0.0081075383, -0.0244326741, -0.0832742602, 0.0326005109, -0.1080156341, -0.049647063, -0.0280819256, -0.0691638663, -0.0164637752, -0.0718423799, -0.0016284866, -0.0286390129, -0.0747954026, -0.0211365856, 0.005551789, 0.0123605467, 0.032339327, -0.0251729731, -0.0957929268, -0.0099092629, -0.0210678112, 0.0494756997, 0.0010096844, 0.0602228194, -0.0403627977, 0.0124271223, -0.0033290132, -0.0693307072, -0.0293582324, 0.0162234139, 0.0002694093, -0.0179483648, -0.0476646572, -0.0633864403, -0.0431934036, -0.0402409695, -0.0028391324, -0.0054445658, 0.015737718, 0.0291050039, 0.0293241329, 0.0398327895, 0.0107478118, 0.0568856224, 0.0126263099, -0.0298574008, 0.0140109994, 0.0031845653, 0.0158766713, -0.0384153724, -0.0305141266, -0.0591952391, 0.0307463109, -0.0257885307, -0.0052112741, -0.0810808837, -0.0586208068, 0.0344335735, 0.0297243595, 0.0141873229, 0.035442695, 0.0279036276, 0.0099519836, -0.041212339, 0.0025803451, 0.0270304568, 0.0031595714, -0.0347659253, -0.0335584246, 0.036361929, 0.0270861126, 0.0008608021, 0.0242759213, -0.0529920757, -0.0440725014, 0.0383284837, 0.022038769, 0.018074261, -0.0080336696, 0.004092372, -0.0319861248, 0.0248829313, 0.0027569323, -0.0351984538, -0.0182703845, -0.0105808694, 0.0340644382, -0.0301542915, 0.0456759781, 0.0332100131, 0.0291880257, 0.0257408917, -0.0363823324, -0.0109982733, -0.0263879076, -0.028441824, -0.0024411976, 0.0204812549, -0.0311665926, -0.0162874535, -0.051591102, 0.0142916273, 0.0025078577, 0.0189774763, 0.0380422771, -0.0073344735, 0.010796749, 0.0027889004, -0.0482040308, 0.0211607479, -0.0002748392, 0.0171899237, -0.0396426469, 0.0092163635, 0.005936265, 0.05488858, -0.0110384421, 0.0068906415, 0.0273534972, 0.0486027487, -0.0431604683, 0.0199057832, -0.0167602915, -0.0168325547, -0.0345059298, 0.0110982023, 0.029175492, 0.0560583659, 0.0287758354, -0.0178594086, -0.0228723027, 0.0420610718, 0.0238431059, -0.0198727269, 0.0473157652, -0.0009078784, 0.0002484181, -0.0033347749, 0.0464006998, -0.0357012376, -0.0314181484, -0.0165671278, -0.0114598898, -0.0053548291, -0.007869388, 0.0295056775, -0.0215433929, 0.0022395661, 0.0488289595, 0.0103418566, 0.014876835, -0.0259911772, -0.0041747689, -0.0015523449, -0.0282648876, 0.0079230871, -0.0480916277, -0.066160433, -0.027496228, -0.0034529285, 0.0168050174, 0.0132811526, 0.0024641128, -0.0167649854, 0.057301823, 0.0163501445, -0.0427255146, -0.0156056006, -0.088237986, -0.0170191284, 0.0096237073, -5.418008849e-33, -0.0429269373, 0.0069700554, 0.0165164061, -0.014039767, -0.0023104351, 0.0001752714, 0.0137001239, 0.0209442135, 0.0034800956, -0.0271983724, -0.044974681, 0.038977772, 0.0395491645, -0.0083666816, 0.0253490042, -0.0306433514, 0.0151146017, 0.0291962493, -0.0082845148, 0.021552898, 0.0715549737, 0.0239985846, 0.1479594111, -0.0817550793, 0.0336942114, 0.0112942671, 0.0227818526, -0.0123496028, 0.0639724731, 0.0624800585, -0.0407829359, 0.0365385301, 0.0080938423, -0.0779624805, -0.010656259, 0.0039872234, -0.1116312221, 0.008467651, -0.0190247521, 0.0848574042, -0.0286636986, -0.0293544959, -0.0306295715, 0.0030462677, -0.0058231596, 0.0603805855, 0.0026407077, -0.0356541276, 0.00126807, -0.0042149536, -0.0906715915, 0.0552397035, -0.00599952, 0.0566540025, 0.0663726553, -0.0147791551, 0.0261142757, -0.0471167713, -0.0903883055, 0.0024250783, -0.0200564861, 0.0058522136, 0.0229690336, -0.0177401118, -0.023112312, 0.0024607005, -0.0012736856, -0.0139514254, 0.011745682, 0.0234274473, -0.013186546, -0.0104796067, -0.0252355896, 0.0318562835, 0.0111803105, -0.0930316672, -0.0310581382, 0.0149999755, -0.0150787178, 0.0517098904, -0.0297708884, -0.0414492562, -0.0639237091, -0.0281334668, 0.0307195615, -0.0771626234, -0.0161501281, -0.0211237166, 0.0038545544, -0.0222407468, -0.0646733791, 0.0728143677, -0.0092626056, 0.0007319064, 0.0088011883, 0.0066220779, 0.0503653139, 0.0374186262, -0.0350808464, 0.0055263652, -0.0302467514, -0.0570351444, 0.0113990167, -0.0157877561, 0.0588021241, 0.0035934651, 0.0051552868, 0.0120616835, -0.0574709363, 0.0104759848, -0.0167340487, 0.0500020906, 0.0004934882, 0.1014491692, 0.0268781502, -0.016947845, 0.0018956915, -0.0178310014, 0.0722409859, -0.0372168384, 0.0095782494, 0.0306421015, 0.0118192909, -0.0539009944, -0.0175646096, 0.0143873235, -0.0435640439, -0.033717487, 0.033895541, 0.0075188549, 0.0060466281, -0.035129793, 2.492e-7, -0.0057998383, 0.0059865662, 0.033437252, 0.0154290888, 0.0068260357, -0.0381733961, 0.0080166142, 0.0575878993, -0.0267060809, 0.0140228448, 0.0140770245, -0.045318637, 0.0302211624, 0.0053282473, -0.1058569029, -0.0625892356, 0.0216341559, -0.0002481784, -0.0587910637, 0.0269804224, 0.0190707184, 0.0742674246, 0.0060400958, -0.0323737524, -0.0592509657, 0.0104589863, 0.0176157709, -0.0120196976, 0.0321880616, 0.02233986, 0.0231702812, 0.0481100865, 0.0106294304, 0.0038437557, -0.0263631456, 0.0120994542, 0.0262004882, 0.0604864806, -0.0209964793, 0.0245746095, 0.0167242847, -0.054288283, 0.0031839588, -0.035648942, 0.086530827, 0.0148679316, -0.0455729291, 0.0256802924, 0.0106138233, 0.0122826481, -0.0306877606, 0.0086976988, -0.0079804678, 0.0419621505, 0.0318193883, -0.0374433286, 0.0020675329, -0.0471620224, 0.0202072896, 0.0146653792, 0.0347026065, -0.019253226, 0.0269520525, 0.0085004373, 0.0243964866, -0.0072021228, -0.0022953704, 1.759110651e-34, -0.0405195691, 0.0530312955, -0.0153006045, 0.0235164315, 0.0055900314, -0.0277924556, -0.0527318679, 0.0224812459, 0.0185281374, 0.0056591965, -0.0057696276 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.04907v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.04907v2
Think Twice: A Human-like Two-stage Conversational Agent for Emotional Response Generation
2023-01-12T10:03:56
2023-06-08T12:44:35
Yushan Qian, Bo Wang, Shangzhao Ma, Wu Bin, Shuo Zhang, Dongming Zhao, Kun Huang, Yuexian Hou
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.HC
Towards human-like dialogue systems, current emotional dialogue approaches jointly model emotion and semantics with a unified neural network. This strategy tends to generate safe responses due to the mutual restriction between emotion and semantics, and requires rare emotion-annotated large-scale dialogue corpus. Inspired by the "think twice" behavior in human dialogue, we propose a two-stage conversational agent for the generation of emotional dialogue. Firstly, a dialogue model trained without the emotion-annotated dialogue corpus generates a prototype response that meets the contextual semantics. Secondly, the first-stage prototype is modified by a controllable emotion refiner with the empathy hypothesis. Experimental results on the DailyDialog and EmpatheticDialogues datasets demonstrate that the proposed conversational outperforms the comparison models in emotion generation and maintains the semantic performance in automatic and human evaluations.
[ 0.0590852536, 0.0386041366, -0.0155498795, 0.0254240464, 0.0067213126, 0.0283538289, 0.0241039004, -0.0446122028, 0.0194058176, -0.0451190509, -0.0454969369, -0.0356451906, -0.052474916, 0.0468556583, -0.0093521876, -0.0836899951, 0.0242894851, 0.0540241003, 0.0664706826, -0.0164940618, 0.024260154, 0.014222879, -0.0224654675, 0.0495607927, -0.073076278, 0.010623306, -0.0431825407, 0.0388535187, 0.0120167313, -0.0259944629, 0.0476108193, 0.0249778982, 0.0201805867, 0.0277473386, 0.0000018477, -0.0300120506, 0.0211711265, -0.0174415279, 0.0150571261, -0.0402109735, 0.1040958166, 0.0054194862, -0.0202125106, 0.0156339705, -0.0475118048, 0.0123046702, 0.0412079953, 0.0776983574, 0.111363776, 0.0852815509, -0.0263683088, -0.0349125527, 0.0055535627, -0.0392023213, -0.0276300646, -0.006029503, -0.0226861183, 0.0013117599, 0.0157421939, -0.0535247102, -0.0197711196, 0.0077713914, 0.0042921766, -0.0282118078, -0.0155354394, 0.0130842905, -0.0404806621, -0.0536099896, -0.0309857409, 0.0848608911, -0.0007033911, 0.0266316775, 0.005947032, -0.0230384339, 0.0185018182, -0.0500162803, -0.0131077478, 0.0316305161, -0.0190063678, 0.0162734222, 0.0043148794, 0.0329706557, -0.0313524567, 0.0294031929, -0.0035844357, 0.0064777392, -0.0304031558, 0.0057968106, 0.0215439405, 0.0174865127, -0.0195112396, -0.0392146744, -0.0043999748, 0.0276506841, -0.0369423889, 0.0009352974, -0.0517037287, 0.0167266186, -0.0086425142, -0.0496933311, 0.0167060532, 0.0299170185, -0.0011144817, -0.0106504392, 0.0124252979, 0.0246685613, -0.0060005216, 0.0227882601, -0.0408164151, -0.0090036327, -0.0108037377, -0.0010291198, -0.0480415598, 0.0257398635, -0.0554900579, -0.021815585, -0.0673680678, 0.0379477963, -0.0364149287, -0.0106210904, -0.0265391283, 0.0260075033, -0.013352219, 0.0146176396, -0.0420685783, -0.0077949082, -0.0457192995, 0.0265745167, 0.0704990402, -0.0777327344, 0.0148300948, 0.0448278338, 0.0051748781, 0.0239643529, 0.0285639055, 0.0452033319, -0.0285989493, -0.0073705357, 0.0010661557, -0.0232512858, -0.0251980126, -0.0567089356, -0.0174048394, -0.0042856205, 0.0574260876, -0.0291907527, -0.0312117208, -0.0078002508, 0.0283990093, -0.0237546973, -0.0190375429, 0.0514225736, -0.0048582945, -0.0208843742, 0.0225274228, 0.0040834965, -0.0137249148, 0.0323537104, 0.0379601121, 0.0294567011, 0.0390535966, 0.0150495907, 0.0498926342, -0.0006639389, 0.0067935027, -0.0384649336, -0.0127005186, -0.0225137714, -0.0501838587, 0.0661746711, 0.0351805948, 0.0482300557, -0.061319951, -0.0139180124, 0.0164488163, 0.0377778411, -0.0095570786, 0.0652336329, 0.0420611389, 0.0493209288, -0.0098798471, 0.0045260708, -0.0257446188, 0.0663729012, 0.0043640565, -0.0021544893, -0.0080950493, -0.0209496822, -0.0536278263, -0.0422204286, 0.0260646734, -0.0118482178, 0.0162456166, -0.001389657, -0.0255664475, 0.011628909, -0.0472466052, 0.0196022037, 0.0001735755, -0.0650744811, -0.0423531495, -0.0424170867, 0.0051956344, 0.0796312541, 0.0265381038, -0.0133821033, -0.0593438633, -0.0155873364, -0.0335562937, 0.075688377, 0.0586553961, -0.0001026036, 0.0408901721, -0.0667586476, 0.033871267, -0.0178824458, -0.0043948339, 0.0252136979, -0.0562654063, 0.0027175166, 0.0055006007, 0.0741363913, 0.03122155, 0.0071567832, 0.0010556668, 0.0250386056, 0.0317766517, -0.0010145468, 0.0425589383, 0.0187391993, -0.0302742794, -0.0054819458, 0.0238409229, 0.0157202166, -0.0347632617, 0.0464015491, -0.0563394018, -0.098253876, 0.0066841892, -0.0110758832, -0.0006037827, 0.0345248245, -0.0223493874, -0.0472779311, 0.0025728829, -0.0362689942, 0.0350908525, -0.0671399683, 0.0244561937, -0.0001964658, 0.0424653515, -0.0023012243, 0.0105356788, -0.0156002147, -0.0217725672, -0.0135594318, 0.0386038795, -0.0149938734, -0.0723424703, -0.0307365246, 0.0026399919, -0.0013229043, 0.0230481159, 0.0010349463, 0.0196378846, -0.0542547479, -0.0871841833, -0.1106669083, 0.0090819728, 0.0082143676, -0.0149686784, 0.0168060232, -0.0042389524, -0.0182163306, 0.0008570406, -0.0663840324, 0.0852306634, 0.069383651, -0.0175208002, 0.0409386344, 0.001489723, -0.0118972808, -0.066838786, 0.0224470235, -0.0048311539, 0.0061284504, -0.0014351931, -0.0192710944, -0.0228318945, 0.0222638603, -0.0518717431, 0.0702375621, 0.0006709651, -0.0828436315, 0.025949169, 0.004423697, -0.0242706239, 0.0588515066, 0.0592757091, 0.0658479631, -0.0084374594, -0.0132026915, -0.0529093109, 0.0761865899, -0.0242796782, 0.0156520121, -0.0211570617, 0.0014638052, -0.0050197663, 0.0540254302, 0.011189389, 0.0279566441, -0.026593117, 0.0301966779, 0.0469621345, -0.0744291767, 0.0073592444, -0.0385275632, -0.028352065, 0.0059880028, -0.0054838057, -0.0041806032, 0.0373350605, 0.0341820903, -0.0516363755, -0.055479005, -0.0022542137, -0.0072546988, 0.0334567986, -0.0560936891, 0.0172772538, -0.0201277193, 0.017755216, -0.0174265429, -0.0524747968, -0.0113036232, -0.0493583381, 0.0205061119, -0.0229029488, -0.0199752022, 0.0123888552, -0.0530625097, -0.0537914224, -0.0433764607, -0.0188874193, -0.0059861555, 0.0092636487, -0.0049453164, -0.0363425836, -0.0257626344, 0.0198847819, 0.0332326777, -0.0114068594, -0.0233075246, -0.0126704322, 0.0507417619, 0.0508937351, 0.0491003469, 0.0412905738, -0.001815886, 0.1241855547, 0.0479907952, 0.0322204083, 0.0209680796, 0.0015595719, 0.0185885169, -0.0052955444, 0.0360244028, 0.0131081939, -0.0117122037, 0.0289164186, 0.0051236632, -0.0119543653, 0.111217618, 0.0161821954, -0.0237465408, 0.0035881912, -0.0434477106, 0.0012429792, 0.0012577781, 0.0160161611, -0.0486313477, -0.012189378, -0.0013263951, 0.0230959598, -0.0214280449, -0.0377851762, 0.0005116404, -0.062691763, 0.0529989749, 0.0012499588, -0.0109931072, 0.0175881665, 0.0403242633, -0.0027495283, 0.0143712563, 0.0101344939, -0.007928174, 0.0326728672, -0.0065919645, 0.0106571773, 0.0337926447, 0.0116560031, 0.0247005764, -0.0310611166, 0.0590371825, 0.031232005, 0.0813283995, 0.0092467852, 0.0206343662, 0.0369030647, 0.0072530876, 0.0189178884, 0.0072121955, 0.0249705147, -0.0058034253, -0.0159214586, -0.0405787379, 0.0572838821, -0.0063821622, 0.0032650155, 0.0135555649, 0.0105105033, -0.049552571, -0.0080040842, -0.033137437, 0.0424512774, 0.018764006, 0.0497308224, 0.0312460512, -0.0719062611, -0.0334929153, 0.006763679, 0.0203367062, -0.0630589873, -0.0240640864, -0.0019153591, 0.0087042516, -0.0270878728, -0.0821392462, -0.1034830287, -0.0243430771, 0.03736981, -0.041938588, -0.0690378547, 0.021606436, -0.0062055481, -0.0226470679, -0.0103345849, 0.0184208788, 0.0055044196, -0.0120962672, 0.0106615853, 0.0392565727, -0.0292356387, -0.0166596789, 0.0297440719, 0.0018292582, -0.0341995358, 0.0095963133, 0.0569127947, 0.018023856, 0.0372998118, 0.015853608, -0.0315086357, 0.0073083509, 0.0222867541, -0.0367081352, 0.0152322901, 0.0421564765, 0.0929855183, -0.0214195084, 0.0308562126, -0.0238945503, 0.075485535, 0.0097214077, 0.0330672301, -0.0068483073, -0.0693169162, -0.0113965385, 0.0095467307, 0.0310403723, 0.0167988054, 0.0125231426, -0.0164792966, -0.0060888845, -0.0297213364, 0.0055065211, -0.0837511346, 0.0082816184, -0.0186497085, -0.0073427903, -0.028821582, -0.0902695209, -0.0431270637, 0.0170168076, 0.0115600601, -0.0001423576, 0.0099156592, 0.008871045, -0.0367488749, 0.0258421898, -0.0207857098, 0.0120208915, 0.0127064725, 0.0045092767, -0.0201175921, 0.1133424044, 0.0209096335, -0.0415912308, 0.0157453511, 0.0483748503, -0.045971375, -0.0038424677, -0.0376114734, 0.0033700403, -0.0095556481, 0.0488936454, 0.0183383953, -0.042134054, 0.0235878695, -0.0119534405, 0.0405760445, -0.0062659634, -0.0748432204, 0.0101579539, -0.0060762782, -0.0278781652, -0.0265590493, 0.0078965416, -0.071273379, 0.0214647055, -0.0144019034, 0.0041507762, -0.0649453029, -0.0114219934, 0.0252661631, -0.0138365673, 0.0246007349, 0.0219341256, -0.0776818842, -0.0336132236, 0.0185532346, 0.0012457652, 0.0026397477, -0.0409527048, 0.0194545873, 0.0331111401, -0.0098669324, 0.0319594704, -0.0396725088, 0.0524434522, -0.0527388938, -0.0272287223, -0.0425872318, -5.604157563e-33, -0.0027139261, 0.0171256773, -0.0169298537, -0.0060793692, -0.0535001867, 0.0019489997, -0.0338955969, 0.0244963989, -0.0152269164, 0.0525689758, -0.0389376841, 0.0391368493, 0.0033768388, 0.0220792182, -0.01639097, -0.0012392475, 0.0100275446, -0.0032201088, -0.0200578813, 0.0700073987, 0.0448113866, 0.0313563272, 0.0068561123, -0.0862830505, -0.0181104578, -0.0031965524, -0.0221257284, 0.0217664763, 0.0521331616, 0.0450682864, -0.0173190329, 0.0623364747, 0.0213787202, -0.0046317265, -0.001518328, 0.0257802773, -0.0221439991, -0.018918423, -0.0202780161, -0.0161028299, -0.0483575091, -0.0221026335, 0.0078292843, 0.0089470139, -0.0184517261, 0.0033270181, -0.0225428846, 0.0030733771, 0.0185814332, -0.0540890023, -0.0495360717, -0.0128236348, -0.0112249507, -0.0562866591, -0.0078259725, 0.0729630589, -0.0055558695, -0.0193752535, -0.020182997, 0.0109139672, -0.0278106872, -0.0477766693, -0.0189882331, -0.0102874469, -0.0310665388, 0.0871244818, 0.0467015654, 0.0445131138, -0.0232468154, 0.0116764903, -0.0062943585, 0.0363632105, 0.0298921783, 0.1004623398, -0.0479305349, -0.0439362787, -0.0162961055, 0.0586422831, 0.0546126179, 0.0170865785, 0.031602703, -0.0118183643, -0.0149524007, 0.019362364, -0.0272814892, -0.0167045165, -0.0295017213, -0.0117804687, 0.0371791311, 0.0083116414, 0.010266454, -0.0298601482, -0.0023115978, -0.0425615497, 0.0480454899, 0.0213494524, -0.0400507711, 0.0281998552, -0.0118070804, -0.0095114671, 0.022291258, -0.0354046598, 0.0696691945, 0.0401121713, 0.0193883833, 0.0240379702, -0.0090071037, 0.0239729397, -0.0184760168, 0.0026018927, -0.0478409082, 0.0733040273, -0.0377540588, -0.0131071275, -0.0608423688, 0.0148214074, -0.0299272407, 0.0115954624, -0.0199759137, 0.0184654929, -0.0153460363, -0.0224278457, 0.0332644321, 0.0575895235, -0.0566786677, 0.0346554443, -0.0021887997, -0.031583529, 0.0100471731, -0.0387668423, -0.0070228735, -0.008394042, 2.571e-7, -0.0408196673, 0.0044889771, 0.0423467197, -0.0248633921, 0.0581393205, 0.0664270371, 0.0063058776, 0.0707654953, 0.0268184356, -0.0159353279, 0.0336905308, -0.0230585225, 0.0499123037, -0.0162995588, -0.0846988037, -0.0137112411, -0.0397207923, -0.0139083536, 0.0002686579, -0.0022941467, 0.0965807065, 0.0675233305, 0.0244966, -0.0184742361, 0.0274473932, 0.0466699675, 0.0318467319, -0.0439437106, -0.0059632207, 0.013162124, -0.0015974548, -0.0189882107, 0.0080510173, 0.0061984598, 0.0132302521, 0.0227928627, 0.0001604112, 0.0592729263, -0.0051737321, -0.0684385076, 0.0624946728, 0.014322022, -0.0037614068, -0.0496482067, 0.0027565374, -0.0749409199, -0.0300527029, -0.0114207231, -0.0152692283, 0.0146544445, -0.0147633143, -0.0383746289, -0.0491056256, 0.0303718075, 0.0154785113, -0.0000205517, 0.0361436494, -0.0752487034, -0.0024575577, -0.0064121559, -0.0657908544, -0.0388539284, -0.0463033617, 0.0318561085, 0.0351195857, -0.0444376208, 0.0086304201, 1.628758085e-34, 0.0310806297, -0.0031238345, -0.0071398644, 0.040300142, 0.0287022777, 0.0339609496, -0.003687585, 0.0053481348, 0.0459272265, -0.0449100062, -0.0220953021 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.04883v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.04883v1
SlideVQA: A Dataset for Document Visual Question Answering on Multiple Images
2023-01-12T09:00:42
2023-01-12T09:00:42
Ryota Tanaka, Kyosuke Nishida, Kosuke Nishida, Taku Hasegawa, Itsumi Saito, Kuniko Saito
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.CV
Visual question answering on document images that contain textual, visual, and layout information, called document VQA, has received much attention recently. Although many datasets have been proposed for developing document VQA systems, most of the existing datasets focus on understanding the content relationships within a single image and not across multiple images. In this study, we propose a new multi-image document VQA dataset, SlideVQA, containing 2.6k+ slide decks composed of 52k+ slide images and 14.5k questions about a slide deck. SlideVQA requires complex reasoning, including single-hop, multi-hop, and numerical reasoning, and also provides annotated arithmetic expressions of numerical answers for enhancing the ability of numerical reasoning. Moreover, we developed a new end-to-end document VQA model that treats evidence selection and question answering in a unified sequence-to-sequence format. Experiments on SlideVQA show that our model outperformed existing state-of-the-art QA models, but that it still has a large gap behind human performance. We believe that our dataset will facilitate research on document VQA.
[ -0.0034741689, 0.0621806867, -0.0039998759, 0.0390589498, -0.0167733822, 0.046842102, 0.0160617344, 0.0021844986, 0.0046492484, -0.0161468629, -0.0275976043, 0.0013480125, -0.0157037266, 0.0248835608, 0.0333797596, -0.0847603157, 0.0398211516, -0.0343426652, 0.0291468445, 0.005234661, 0.0246076081, 0.0040717204, -0.0140261371, 0.0105656702, -0.0306092948, -0.0619089194, -0.0220622271, -0.0145013612, 0.0174669232, -0.0123232342, -0.0154280467, 0.0481938608, 0.0668212771, -0.0209907759, 0.0000017098, 0.0061012199, 0.0084423404, 0.0062168902, -0.0151378633, -0.0018849685, -0.0226373747, 0.0201411396, 0.0385159217, 0.0032500315, -0.0650553927, -0.0198459458, 0.0419121049, 0.0581553541, 0.0867391229, 0.0246063191, -0.0127546256, -0.0284580626, 0.0006159613, -0.0152704213, 0.0812887773, -0.0607364364, 0.0005660609, 0.0734886974, 0.0680741593, -0.0045357877, -0.0102655692, 0.0372595526, 0.0544896759, -0.0397430547, -0.0406422652, 0.0306490995, -0.0159376487, -0.0101942336, -0.010693294, 0.1229979321, 0.022967739, 0.0207460988, -0.003759414, -0.008396537, 0.0291686039, 0.0305820052, -0.0852766782, 0.0236986075, -0.0415852256, -0.0460270792, -0.0304655824, 0.0115052313, -0.0214232523, 0.003133981, 0.0194649473, 0.0148642259, 0.004175833, -0.0092957793, -0.0027411797, 0.0114968643, -0.0731955096, -0.0406576581, -0.0050759665, 0.0689619333, -0.0089809112, 0.0154016949, -0.0244511254, -0.0493137538, 0.0229380615, -0.0509216152, 0.0111907125, 0.0179993529, -0.0408128425, 0.1054133624, -0.0027993955, 0.0403839722, -0.0269101616, 0.0084578749, -0.0379393362, 0.0103721507, -0.0165651776, -0.0100957258, -0.0519110635, 0.0168349128, -0.0570379794, -0.053345371, 0.0235009138, 0.0151021341, -0.0077171093, 0.0332547761, 0.018124979, 0.0575752817, -0.0250624306, -0.0068830079, -0.0363027044, 0.0387806147, -0.0670208335, 0.0238338206, -0.0016900741, -0.0102643184, -0.0149432784, 0.0384265706, 0.0278123077, -0.0233832523, 0.0171398111, 0.039304994, -0.0352843851, 0.0017193627, 0.0131594995, -0.033146929, 0.0013257064, -0.0514661074, 0.0373580083, -0.0445988588, 0.0488034971, 0.0085935025, -0.0517755263, 0.000370511, -0.0091244746, 0.0616089329, -0.0275094658, 0.0776966289, 0.0309316479, -0.0264496524, 0.0538654514, 0.0330450386, -0.0380036198, 0.064030394, 0.0157566313, 0.0384123251, 0.0536321811, -0.0106787588, 0.0180386808, 0.0274685286, -0.0013417549, -0.0169130992, -0.0010152585, 0.0738189071, 0.0088118911, 0.0157157071, -0.0037234647, 0.0203337595, -0.059812244, -0.0470778085, 0.0150410896, 0.0345719866, 0.0069177016, -0.016835738, 0.0103185298, -0.0006955587, 0.054884728, 0.0047200783, -0.0344611891, 0.0773052722, 0.0508762226, 0.0058790408, 0.0164874718, 0.0015829881, -0.0569023229, -0.0396777317, -0.0093974024, 0.0450649746, -0.0074151708, 0.0159761179, 0.01222008, 0.0338785909, -0.0369982384, 0.0109311529, -0.0057279952, -0.0262975227, -0.0392525159, 0.0053727594, 0.0948479325, 0.0348306447, 0.0438350141, -0.0482195206, -0.025560813, -0.0080295736, 0.042075485, 0.0027672781, 0.0283628106, -0.0180048235, -0.0050585372, -0.0673610568, -0.0209023897, -0.0767937005, -0.0129886279, 0.0033249313, 0.0173317324, -0.0053161778, -0.020647591, -0.0346499942, 0.0184862036, 0.0324916653, 0.0160511006, -0.0297773927, -0.0233361013, -0.0000494094, 0.0155172981, 0.0028670211, -0.0021582707, 0.0102765495, 0.0081941271, -0.0093868366, 0.0039772978, 0.0063541816, -0.0585731156, -0.0541779734, 0.0294098649, -0.0619111918, -0.0516969413, -0.0181715824, -0.0714188516, -0.037170589, 0.0092253238, -0.0364756882, -0.0429931544, -0.0395054966, -0.0499572195, 0.0464460887, 0.0275180414, -0.013943892, 0.072026059, -0.0146684591, 0.0019731133, 0.013417583, 0.014160553, 0.0173750874, -0.0266980827, 0.0194249488, -0.0056094103, 0.0044777491, 0.0064462763, 0.0051005818, 0.037001811, -0.0485481769, 0.0029418634, -0.0579690859, 0.0081186499, -0.0232906379, 0.0221168455, 0.0349172503, -0.0024418596, -0.0076350989, -0.0560268089, -0.0597714111, 0.0222055167, 0.0031356008, 0.0101663638, 0.0498607829, 0.0279105529, 0.0468517393, -0.0369210579, -0.024474429, 0.0025470208, 0.067152366, 0.0409574471, 0.0268395748, -0.0089493012, -0.0175712407, -0.0340671465, 0.0200044904, 0.0018549763, 0.0045276373, 0.0322822705, -0.0455303304, 0.0176922716, 0.0761876702, -0.0305849109, 0.0124859046, -0.0044989125, -0.0158672612, -0.046693448, 0.0385332108, -0.0021958654, 0.0371163636, 0.0297958497, -0.0302671455, -0.0363810547, 0.0399984419, -0.0316222012, 0.019075457, -0.0352764986, 0.0473759472, 0.051387351, 0.0091616567, -0.0642325655, -0.0131120225, 0.0429946445, 0.0438392796, -0.045768939, -0.0271282569, 0.061279539, -0.0085581625, -0.0204698537, -0.0231953505, 0.0571864061, -0.0538946278, 0.063777186, 0.0130002191, -0.0077736913, -0.0106445989, -0.0007194689, -0.033469148, -0.037740685, 0.0328776576, -0.0344813839, 0.0237507634, -0.0565931909, 0.007446086, -0.0451649576, -0.0404677726, -0.0130568678, -0.0076704612, -0.0062064994, -0.000488007, -0.0558282658, -0.0101714153, -0.0567632951, 0.0068541979, 0.0478560105, 0.0409512706, -0.0265580062, -0.0095817717, -0.0161354449, 0.0924139395, 0.0741397962, 0.0471824817, 0.0306403264, -0.034154918, 0.0400254726, 0.0631673411, 0.0085971719, 0.0039399308, -0.0070937811, 0.0305338688, -0.0157606229, 0.0021827871, 0.0077114473, 0.0204827413, 0.0403736755, -0.0786918402, -0.0060008452, 0.0432305485, 0.0293909237, -0.0288983732, -0.0494473502, -0.0658139735, 0.0186309572, 0.0286878478, 0.0627663285, -0.0990356132, -0.0444794595, -0.0153382355, 0.0096026901, 0.0343613811, 0.0026796574, 0.0100178914, -0.0571326353, 0.0783261955, -0.0291361548, -0.0050887885, -0.0107820248, -0.0372631848, -0.0055558197, -0.0010046633, 0.0191704854, -0.0026712879, -0.0093221841, 0.0228667706, 0.0067875399, 0.0179578252, 0.0141288107, 0.0466083437, -0.0047462485, -0.0503879674, 0.0358969234, 0.0229089018, -0.0105470708, -0.0867756829, -0.0240220558, -0.0189832337, -0.0102097169, 0.0082232961, 0.0694755837, -0.0071478775, -0.0370327197, -0.0299985502, 0.0577272177, -0.032210581, -0.0267921593, 0.0185446739, 0.0525604859, -0.0180146508, -0.0178434588, -0.0519036055, 0.0103401486, -0.0170881208, 0.0313121006, 0.0507411063, -0.0028050651, -0.0782046244, -0.0217550434, -0.0011088586, -0.0591580756, -0.0010584804, -0.0167297255, 0.0349318087, 0.0198027696, -0.0862455815, -0.0242682863, 0.0764357448, 0.0488123856, -0.0439008363, -0.0344184116, -0.0063755107, 0.0131655009, -0.0457233898, 0.0575104579, 0.0088202944, 0.0282140188, -0.0091493456, 0.0237054434, -0.0063748001, -0.024934046, -0.0434783064, 0.0056664464, -0.0658344626, 0.0004593034, -0.0261381194, 0.0647390634, 0.0146524962, 0.0124751339, 0.0084417881, -0.0394504331, 0.0225343537, 0.0035439555, -0.0346037596, -0.0339818448, 0.0176459495, -0.0262261964, -0.0133546479, -0.0110076284, -0.0355326235, -0.0003065286, -0.0060912101, 0.046842739, -0.0362256952, 0.0002890901, -0.0123484228, -0.0059098145, -0.0191774666, 0.0331912749, -0.0083456757, 0.0046373969, 0.0308190826, -0.007538469, -0.0186673235, -0.0358108319, 0.0201673415, -0.0207842011, -0.0528251901, -0.0108974408, -0.0185618885, -0.008722269, 0.0049503916, -0.0231660344, 0.0132954083, 0.0727382302, 0.007175948, -0.0184713937, -0.0328816138, -0.0052462653, -0.0176951867, -0.0152714988, 0.0790925622, 0.0035367685, 0.0851582512, 0.0320072845, 0.0027073687, 0.0003731006, 0.0230386835, -0.0503585935, -0.0756948665, -0.0067051034, 0.0226836745, 0.039718926, 0.0015898063, -0.0117692361, 0.0189622343, -0.0325224549, 0.0361972526, -0.0089452704, 0.0142017836, -0.020998206, 0.0692915618, 0.0590992086, 0.0173056945, -0.0008279925, 0.0671623349, -0.01528663, 0.0250143055, -0.0200962182, -0.01575578, -0.0290810578, -0.0400016718, 0.0159219857, 0.0124938181, 0.0121950023, 0.0134151364, -0.0334837437, -0.0550797358, -0.0055772527, 0.0494513661, -0.0318313502, 0.0503426492, 0.0369263142, 0.0383432843, 0.0337441489, -0.0485347062, -0.0080576306, 0.0165066198, -0.0520340726, -0.0270435866, -0.0226585642, -5.403838632e-33, -0.0304272063, -0.0269139502, 0.0491797477, 0.0040581319, 0.0335651152, 0.0021039818, -0.0323208272, -0.0233326685, -0.0203277171, 0.0282444786, -0.0071054022, -0.0013532656, 0.0087285088, 0.0288158804, -0.0002398368, -0.0099734226, -0.0022707416, -0.0351899751, -0.0258147232, 0.0468685813, 0.0273335874, -0.0220437776, 0.0296269096, -0.0161025971, -0.0125674354, 0.0208633058, -0.0150670782, 0.0197130907, -0.0235953461, 0.0583777167, -0.0383699425, -0.0355888531, 0.0075954823, -0.0327405483, -0.0216996372, 0.0506144501, -0.1037322432, -0.0494234487, 0.0130186165, 0.0130275814, -0.068297632, -0.0110743828, 0.0090191131, -0.0152634997, 0.0610683225, -0.0602027141, 0.0502269156, -0.0060013486, 0.0066811638, -0.0106152091, 0.0059905029, 0.0010037158, -0.062624447, -0.0199150164, -0.0091890022, 0.0328393951, 0.0115086464, 0.0221334156, -0.0665100664, -0.0193979368, 0.0050581875, -0.0030521788, 0.0654818416, -0.0127366604, 0.0231386553, 0.0178235862, 0.0261285733, -0.0448251963, -0.0436246023, -0.0128524788, -0.0336735323, 0.0742579922, 0.0841058567, 0.0223437417, 0.0653067902, 0.0643893778, -0.0674282759, 0.0481085293, -0.0326923169, 0.117105782, 0.0044055418, -0.0281251781, -0.0018314406, 0.0089294948, -0.0447080173, 0.0249482431, -0.0454861633, -0.0028378358, 0.0289991163, 0.0054787034, 0.011084781, 0.0287871901, 0.0569026209, -0.0122791361, -0.0119431447, 0.0396156609, -0.0173371173, 0.0484199896, 0.0251704063, 0.0428719893, -0.0472018197, 0.0182266627, 0.0591806695, -0.0185650978, -0.00300995, 0.0149020748, 0.0658194497, -0.0125438124, -0.0490124412, -0.0050033666, -0.0229577683, 0.0149966367, -0.0228913277, -0.0013512839, 0.0152702481, 0.0277050324, -0.0524951369, 0.0011030952, -0.0303819701, 0.0114459628, -0.0266831182, -0.0686442778, -0.0251739658, 0.0179784559, -0.0213764627, -0.0065493374, -0.0615582056, -0.0302517619, -0.0291929264, -0.0556992888, 0.0039718328, 0.0896905437, 2.329e-7, 0.043538969, 0.0024930262, 0.0243151803, 0.0449285656, 0.0324857719, 0.0213496797, -0.0248572081, 0.0037366385, 0.0276854355, -0.0416943468, 0.0077668503, 0.0652577505, 0.0211818628, 0.0266648009, -0.0287919771, 0.0043732934, -0.0554805957, -0.022141004, -0.0608216152, -0.0314197764, 0.0601330437, 0.0610644519, -0.0329178795, -0.0223411117, 0.0253186673, -0.0387824252, 0.0731220022, 0.0170172639, 0.0307014529, -0.0155116236, 0.0354208127, -0.0225480366, -0.0053921239, 0.0141784744, 0.0064448719, 0.0072940188, 0.029140953, 0.0358682945, 0.0223121624, -0.0322098024, -0.0444219597, -0.012345925, 0.0165592395, -0.0512679815, 0.100322552, -0.0586896166, -0.0337365791, -0.0089558912, -0.0757268444, -0.0097727887, 0.0172422044, 0.0081260493, 0.0076421471, 0.0158326123, 0.0351120718, -0.0445281267, -0.0115946615, -0.0746919289, -0.0041102315, 0.0045100437, -0.0107267806, 0.0134876678, -0.0477413237, -0.0391194709, -0.0014130836, -0.0176329948, -0.0541577414, 1.697091615e-34, 0.0431409888, -0.0257932656, 0.0169312265, 0.0218711291, 0.0428905003, -0.0381492898, -0.0122866919, -0.023003364, 0.0249684136, -0.1056844965, -0.0003542322 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.04871v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.04871v2
Learning to Memorize Entailment and Discourse Relations for Persona-Consistent Dialogues
2023-01-12T08:37:00
2023-02-25T07:41:41
Ruijun Chen, Jin Wang, Liang-Chih Yu, Xuejie Zhang
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI
Maintaining engagement and consistency is particularly important in dialogue systems. Existing works have improved the performance of dialogue systems by intentionally learning interlocutor personas with sophisticated network structures. One issue with this approach is that it requires more personal corpora with annotations. Additionally, these models typically perform the next utterance prediction to generate a response but neglect the discourse coherence in the entire conversation. To address these issues, this study proposes a method of learning to memorize entailment and discourse relations for persona-consistent dialogue tasks. Entailment text pairs in natural language inference dataset were applied to learn latent entailment relations as external memories by premise-to-hypothesis generation task. Furthermore, an internal memory with a similar architecture was applied to the discourse information in the dialogue. Placing orthogonality restrictions on these two memory spaces ensures that the latent entailment relations remain dialogue-independent. Both memories collaborate to obtain entailment and discourse representation for the generation, allowing a deeper understanding of both consistency and coherence. Experiments on two large public datasets, PersonaChat and DSTC7-AVSD, demonstrated the effectiveness of the proposed method. Both automatic and human evaluations indicate that the proposed model outperforms several strong baselines in terms of both persona consistency and response coherence. Our source code is available at https://github.com/Chenrj233/LMEDR.
[ 0.0445074625, 0.0487181097, -0.0151771214, 0.0403800532, -0.0495121554, -0.0209484212, -0.0286833663, -0.0530014671, 0.0429717712, -0.0250240881, -0.0165491961, -0.0228779335, 0.0100834463, 0.0267633274, 0.0134642133, -0.0503383689, 0.0756860375, -0.0020325074, -0.0002843339, -0.0070362072, 0.0150851402, 0.0105379755, -0.0387098305, 0.0165174343, -0.0282798521, -0.0001191615, -0.0034731517, 0.0201724935, 0.0578461513, -0.0291675478, 0.0163192358, 0.0267997812, 0.022496067, -0.0254552532, 0.0000018264, -0.079385981, -0.0015250386, -0.0521656759, -0.0111525012, -0.0379963145, -0.0288488176, 0.0186735168, 0.0269132219, 0.0105682584, -0.0344462879, -0.0043701846, 0.0012076072, 0.0814961791, 0.0733640417, 0.0596334673, -0.0192569308, -0.0393982567, 0.0043300693, -0.0009952048, -0.0312406681, -0.0420872755, 0.0040589655, 0.0070031364, -0.0287839826, -0.0049478873, 0.009439094, 0.0040185973, 0.0199762452, 0.003199718, 0.0180496462, 0.0463036001, -0.0217425004, -0.0414920636, 0.0147165833, 0.0980729833, 0.0983972847, -0.0075078956, 0.0136078633, 0.0118566072, 0.0006993536, 0.0002307983, -0.0227690395, 0.0110342307, -0.0653486326, -0.0058948109, -0.0060363109, 0.0186904594, -0.0268273205, 0.0051263757, -0.0418241955, 0.022845326, 0.0031739629, -0.0350957513, 0.0108448071, -0.0065486371, -0.0349735655, -0.0412477143, 0.0244434215, 0.0269025881, -0.0537587367, 0.0338686295, -0.0543173812, -0.0019957116, 0.0197191518, -0.0484383889, -0.0090525914, 0.0384747535, -0.0047347946, 0.0336972438, -0.0285070911, 0.0684479102, -0.008933669, -0.024514785, -0.0130580142, -0.036698062, -0.0535234995, -0.0098282304, -0.0407602899, 0.065870285, 0.0330169536, -0.0282979123, -0.0281537436, 0.0234511308, -0.0108950753, 0.0323538855, -0.0147745628, 0.0188788604, -0.040713124, 0.0097548719, -0.0704000369, 0.0371221453, -0.0569415502, -0.0025037515, -0.0159008447, -0.0111629553, -0.0172662754, 0.0231351573, 0.0295426305, -0.0177068748, -0.0056013069, 0.0458654501, -0.0021196287, -0.0116148042, -0.0048011369, -0.045462057, -0.0092216525, -0.0891796798, -0.0121454559, -0.0308408216, 0.0218077991, 0.0094107613, -0.0169569235, -0.0110409698, 0.0249902196, 0.0449779779, -0.0194624122, 0.0577328391, 0.0195989702, 0.0102022737, 0.0390282571, 0.0134091191, -0.0009517745, 0.0291939881, 0.0300436653, -0.0039902399, 0.0164300874, 0.0169069376, -0.0031722207, -0.009114733, 0.0263896454, -0.0353609398, 0.0337994359, 0.0514780283, 0.0166262127, 0.0424787551, 0.0285941418, 0.0802959949, -0.0632841811, -0.0523381792, 0.0554711446, 0.048537869, -0.0143495323, -0.0203670878, 0.0342394225, 0.0260751806, 0.0197777823, 0.0548260286, -0.0314891301, 0.0431776941, 0.0114195514, 0.001071297, 0.0439839698, 0.0135505563, -0.0407871157, -0.038512677, 0.0170236565, -0.0163046457, -0.0005080443, -0.0093983216, 0.0182738025, 0.0311497208, -0.0539629497, 0.0530662611, 0.0371616222, -0.0443687774, -0.0128095858, -0.0128488857, 0.0402795039, 0.0575905256, 0.0079816459, 0.0081804618, -0.0627910346, -0.0235891007, 0.0098406877, 0.0572970025, -0.0160829872, -0.0265496764, 0.0110447481, -0.055908978, -0.0002732035, -0.0013325389, -0.0156081663, 0.0331625119, 0.0353331342, -0.0115942536, 0.0195520315, 0.0383349434, 0.0413645431, 0.013375896, -0.0492746606, 0.0190258417, 0.0199402235, 0.0215326808, 0.0392464586, 0.0253567044, 0.0257894062, -0.0075144162, 0.0398684032, -0.0203902777, -0.0284429993, 0.0465641357, -0.0945165604, -0.0697987154, 0.014610677, -0.0628082827, -0.0238533746, -0.0168139599, -0.0097080143, -0.0756228492, 0.0508912914, -0.0674581006, -0.0047695232, -0.0580562204, -0.0301779509, 0.0286555849, -0.0127401669, -0.0093669137, 0.0678776577, 0.0059149005, 0.0092677549, 0.0165116824, 0.0289102364, 0.025146544, -0.0637496486, 0.0149483485, -0.0259171873, 0.0078349691, -0.0103284782, 0.042147018, -0.0233123656, -0.0651925728, -0.031515643, -0.1549194306, 0.0206047855, -0.0030834931, 0.0050990139, 0.0224722866, 0.0051988568, 0.0055971332, -0.0453384593, -0.0474033952, -0.0000965286, 0.0124678463, 0.0120003037, 0.058922559, -0.0188677516, -0.0133288214, -0.0342298634, 0.030185869, -0.0223123115, 0.0462959558, 0.0091786403, -0.0373550542, -0.0406384021, -0.0212481953, -0.0664591193, 0.0151079334, -0.0284022447, -0.0170937125, 0.0389313735, 0.0542430542, 0.1028388366, 0.0370775089, 0.043665722, 0.0395093188, -0.0145872021, -0.0275483485, -0.0425153859, 0.0450296737, -0.0435511395, 0.0134650776, -0.0048242481, -0.0252391901, -0.001091273, 0.0363758951, 0.0274376832, 0.0184669532, -0.0500053652, 0.0017147498, 0.0249380227, -0.0034073035, 0.0269068275, -0.0224091541, -0.0277160928, 0.0043422459, -0.0395336598, -0.0059607816, 0.0902056396, -0.0190345719, 0.0047173374, -0.0398893543, -0.0147344274, -0.0443385169, 0.060671825, 0.0161806028, 0.0175950397, 0.0342221186, -0.0507784635, -0.039419353, -0.0127694393, 0.0478952825, -0.0253902096, 0.0458643995, -0.0155757554, 0.0149874752, 0.0122177945, -0.042130664, -0.0762328431, -0.0102045368, -0.0084634591, 0.0017482088, -0.0524653792, 0.0058712419, -0.0196497925, -0.0057629398, 0.0362918116, -0.0027301346, -0.0062237037, -0.0118086189, -0.0311932378, 0.0213689581, 0.054508809, 0.0325768963, -0.0103704017, -0.0348920412, 0.0298931412, 0.0285360198, -0.0276795216, -0.0168875344, -0.0277735163, -0.0059604757, -0.0303900167, 0.0020829898, -0.0169447158, 0.0050990423, 0.0398989096, -0.0113227144, -0.0233500525, 0.1015921161, 0.000463681, -0.0085235713, -0.0084994743, -0.0029462415, 0.0448113009, 0.0318281837, -0.0006905146, -0.0529982485, -0.0329639353, -0.0092815999, 0.0025225757, -0.0031728735, -0.0659965426, -0.0146669513, -0.0839188471, 0.0211818982, -0.0266265497, -0.0250296965, -0.0105119431, -0.0698267445, 0.0224637538, -0.0066098329, 0.0400238037, -0.009877244, 0.0072144889, 0.0009139153, 0.0015893023, -0.0218074284, -0.0122793904, 0.0124413185, -0.0369766094, 0.0497528948, 0.0241604168, 0.0655149072, 0.0366110057, -0.0077437637, -0.0170211494, -0.0066175312, -0.0206137802, -0.0013629815, 0.0622668304, -0.0171560105, 0.0027608783, -0.0537531562, 0.0489702374, -0.0274481717, -0.0329396091, 0.0243085213, 0.0363965333, -0.0636788458, -0.0084834183, 0.0064862636, 0.05906545, 0.0053901747, 0.0878937468, 0.0153458538, -0.0101387743, -0.024241481, 0.0143840509, 0.0253229309, -0.0228841826, 0.0186725557, -0.0216881521, -0.0089177275, 0.0169988498, -0.0846274272, -0.0630562305, 0.0063633448, 0.0424882732, -0.0030448188, 0.0081187049, 0.0452985428, -0.003569633, -0.0468203612, 0.010761329, -0.0527533367, -0.0037233725, -0.0041265613, -0.0027377433, 0.0579675511, -0.0253816992, -0.0137054473, 0.0369449817, -0.0501131415, -0.0518877842, -0.0617086664, 0.0334817953, 0.0183887258, 0.0905609876, -0.0022898682, 0.0161667615, -0.0056930478, -0.0000765209, -0.0586510338, 0.0225148238, 0.0122712934, 0.064952381, -0.0165841617, 0.0457376018, -0.0020482405, 0.0068299007, 0.0011802048, 0.0506254919, -0.0269111916, -0.1076517776, 0.0229607783, -0.0028622732, 0.0437718444, 0.02807514, -0.0117692295, -0.0484912433, 0.013063659, -0.0250824206, -0.0351652093, -0.0263232663, 0.0304479599, -0.004984966, 0.0144322924, 0.0028541861, -0.0420983322, -0.0223304592, 0.068598628, 0.0175101906, -0.065734528, 0.0493792556, 0.0189439375, -0.0089708772, -0.0376172103, -0.0525169484, 0.0041192095, 0.0178147629, 0.0466226712, -0.0063419431, 0.0677507296, 0.035181582, -0.0110142818, -0.0009134002, -0.010539203, -0.0542863198, 0.0162681825, -0.0046896804, 0.0233643539, 0.0372116081, 0.0240815859, 0.0242885295, -0.0333732143, 0.0420746207, -0.0054253847, 0.0829879642, -0.0093090562, -0.0219679624, 0.0343672484, 0.0131541835, -0.0218212176, 0.0372301191, 0.0492295735, -0.0354364738, 0.0393032916, 0.0051660417, 0.0122926701, -0.0558236949, -0.0579441115, -0.0080263028, 0.0534760468, -0.0135301165, 0.019629078, -0.0322785527, -0.0243050884, 0.0420664139, -0.0032929415, -0.0213752706, 0.0048019029, 0.0376619585, 0.0223509744, 0.0309824795, -0.0321242251, -0.0241611861, 0.0085288789, -0.0560374223, -0.005008928, -0.0333050303, -6.178454144e-33, -0.0695523471, -0.0485583283, 0.0482216664, 0.0149968844, -0.0513339825, -0.0110001704, -0.0764596909, -0.0274745394, -0.007622187, 0.0040193759, 0.0204104781, 0.0111884102, 0.0045059253, 0.024973331, -0.0333145261, -0.0296235494, 0.0293045621, 0.0296947788, -0.0253275428, 0.0413483493, 0.0798074454, 0.0173348449, 0.0242977962, -0.0569572821, -0.0023245721, -0.0317633152, 0.0095186764, 0.0551559068, -0.0043786238, 0.0519368388, -0.0301230308, 0.0263861138, 0.0229821689, 0.0114208153, 0.0080186455, 0.0547050722, -0.1091620177, -0.0612226501, 0.0469032936, -0.014288214, -0.032445766, -0.0098880315, 0.0157333314, -0.0251994487, 0.0537503399, -0.0188525859, 0.0491302423, 0.0171693731, -0.006695963, -0.0075409547, -0.0734842718, 0.0074352627, -0.0177465696, -0.029197583, -0.0452924408, 0.0376260616, 0.012189663, -0.053158626, -0.059413407, 0.0032922542, -0.0867941529, -0.0251161531, 0.0226540398, 0.04655784, 0.0066673714, 0.0961111113, 0.0087177511, 0.0098474706, -0.0512826368, -0.0033262935, 0.0172158685, 0.0309918988, 0.0032494196, 0.0318970941, -0.0290290844, 0.025955487, -0.088981919, 0.009219652, 0.018780034, 0.0501101948, 0.0122800814, -0.0016977295, -0.0245548934, -0.0152608398, -0.0447632149, 0.0084533906, -0.019086659, -0.0307743177, 0.0142594725, -0.0117728868, -0.0196887162, 0.0031003652, 0.0216295291, -0.0132783195, -0.0116081722, 0.0205624942, -0.0232932847, -0.0126313381, -0.008249321, 0.0511439033, -0.0510485023, -0.0152016506, 0.0309229381, 0.022237286, 0.023866646, 0.0345271714, 0.0336272828, -0.0194598231, -0.0219303928, -0.0197392404, -0.0342509635, 0.024482511, -0.0903796852, 0.0202708486, 0.0362309143, 0.0629635453, -0.0372074954, 0.0602390319, -0.0123968394, -0.0049563632, -0.0547405742, -0.0112028811, 0.0075896969, 0.0353439376, -0.0156984851, 0.0094745606, -0.0218183771, 0.0018120639, -0.0121838124, -0.038830854, 0.007808906, 0.0279945545, 2.578e-7, -0.0237625632, 0.0213166997, 0.0584986247, 0.010229785, 0.0096868202, 0.037203785, 0.0002752587, 0.0425904393, 0.0290544387, -0.06604027, 0.0133144688, 0.0609953068, 0.035867136, 0.0396857411, -0.0999538451, -0.0019638697, -0.0491658375, -0.0586266853, -0.0385261104, 0.02888312, 0.1106753871, 0.0313378014, 0.0403480306, -0.0017272914, -0.0068772915, 0.0124528129, 0.093394421, -0.008296839, -0.0229566172, 0.0147380792, 0.0250310283, -0.0082759568, 0.0062648281, 0.0671414137, 0.0263684671, 0.0276022516, -0.0015492372, 0.0526653342, 0.0113222543, -0.0439810231, -0.0331539512, 0.0150045715, 0.0134171546, -0.0138152093, 0.0450746901, -0.0741748735, -0.0423128121, 0.0055533936, -0.0356349573, -0.0122827543, 0.0256585032, 0.0145795383, -0.0425411649, 0.0264226813, 0.030948313, -0.0102021443, 0.0142782256, -0.0875261948, 0.0209459811, 0.0150009394, -0.0568808317, -0.0198568646, -0.0013920541, 0.0095869889, 0.0341191515, -0.0445064157, 0.03202812, 2.045989932e-34, 0.0099749723, -0.017082449, 0.01252387, 0.0263635665, 0.0478132516, -0.0374801494, -0.0182141326, 0.0275651477, 0.0435177647, -0.079753533, -0.0010535225 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.08130v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.08130v2
A Cohesive Distillation Architecture for Neural Language Models
2023-01-12T08:01:53
2023-01-29T09:39:20
Jan Philip Wahle
cs.CL
cs.CL
A recent trend in Natural Language Processing is the exponential growth in Language Model (LM) size, which prevents research groups without a necessary hardware infrastructure from participating in the development process. This study investigates methods for Knowledge Distillation (KD) to provide efficient alternatives to large-scale models. In this context, KD means extracting information about language encoded in a Neural Network and Lexical Knowledge Databases. We developed two methods to test our hypothesis that efficient architectures can gain knowledge from LMs and extract valuable information from lexical sources. First, we present a technique to learn confident probability distribution for Masked Language Modeling by prediction weighting of multiple teacher networks. Second, we propose a method for Word Sense Disambiguation (WSD) and lexical KD that is general enough to be adapted to many LMs. Our results show that KD with multiple teachers leads to improved training convergence. When using our lexical pre-training method, LM characteristics are not lost, leading to increased performance in Natural Language Understanding (NLU) tasks over the state-of-the-art while adding no parameters. Moreover, the improved semantic understanding of our model increased the task performance beyond WSD and NLU in a real-problem scenario (Plagiarism Detection). This study suggests that sophisticated training methods and network architectures can be superior over scaling trainable parameters. On this basis, we suggest the research area should encourage the development and use of efficient models and rate impacts resulting from growing LM size equally against task performance.
[ 0.0455709025, 0.0468444899, -0.0227140989, 0.0605851151, -0.0558835119, 0.0056591579, 0.0331712067, -0.0111466711, -0.0007135415, -0.0205845274, -0.0167087968, -0.0281215589, -0.0204089489, 0.0272567067, 0.0229566935, -0.0204757471, 0.0327061228, -0.0426215306, -0.0235604998, -0.0199834108, -0.0098308409, 0.0199039783, 0.0188666526, -0.0069298507, 0.0134109892, -0.0149715655, -0.0021606581, -0.002604723, -0.0051919771, 0.0068871183, 0.0155177088, 0.0417155735, 0.0292351414, 0.0598348975, 0.0000024809, -0.0410701521, -0.0165546499, 0.0052789692, -0.0369527712, 0.019369131, 0.0338187031, 0.0002129194, 0.0423464067, -0.0007875673, -0.0477001332, -0.0157421213, 0.0250409525, 0.0021464708, 0.062879622, 0.0434941463, 0.0009469162, -0.0696262419, 0.0029159468, -0.021626953, -0.0354962721, -0.024817111, 0.0390278175, 0.0002478834, -0.0184683576, -0.0177580453, -0.0433112122, 0.0610992126, 0.0209642071, 0.0170330666, 0.0018856705, 0.0171903931, -0.0182273015, -0.0443483032, 0.0041207154, 0.0385646857, -0.0509188659, -0.015543621, 0.0224545542, 0.0019384909, -0.0113965981, 0.0161437839, -0.0011696017, 0.0098472321, -0.0071658501, 0.0378473811, -0.0006159232, 0.0164744016, 0.046812553, 0.0465618856, -0.0229072087, 0.0397538729, 0.0078075901, -0.0136683909, -0.0004070826, -0.0120791532, -0.0287842229, -0.0303551517, 0.0471173413, -0.0048963861, 0.033411447, 0.035526257, -0.0536184311, -0.0788977742, 0.0014020499, -0.0466567241, -0.0009828636, 0.0112939887, 0.0093073156, 0.0474784188, -0.0348276719, 0.0643844754, 0.006629636, 0.0405989774, -0.0541454181, -0.0212736391, -0.0774565637, 0.0090241814, -0.0294389371, 0.0802259892, -0.0396780781, -0.0384796634, -0.0381488726, -0.007311319, -0.0357234478, -0.0325624011, 0.0357751548, 0.0259588398, -0.0262756906, -0.0015887654, -0.0060922117, 0.0344152451, -0.0011079017, 0.0030192677, -0.0212484822, -0.0656001195, -0.0190433655, 0.0060707787, -0.0096688038, -0.016973244, 0.0230211541, 0.0256878901, -0.0124405408, -0.0444207564, -0.0534229092, -0.0426863618, -0.0331731886, -0.0462447144, -0.0078597944, -0.1018251777, 0.0344727747, -0.0280892681, 0.0116010597, -0.0921359658, 0.0078923004, -0.0187873933, -0.0697214827, 0.081193909, -0.0162122231, 0.0012391378, 0.0368407741, 0.0421700813, -0.0084383674, 0.0483724922, 0.0148829892, 0.0298614837, 0.0343289673, 0.0248129573, -0.0259469021, 0.0123054413, 0.0202981457, 0.0100942412, -0.0008970541, -0.0505811535, -0.0277363509, -0.0096567078, 0.0587066077, 0.086714752, -0.063674435, -0.0228684694, 0.0772709697, 0.0330259353, 0.0214663614, -0.0002407423, 0.0367935523, 0.0097706718, -0.0105303675, 0.0132760378, -0.0512183532, -0.0447374657, 0.0030780889, -0.0028861465, 0.0164761823, 0.0577534214, -0.0161280092, -0.0402800813, 0.0169214215, -0.0201032385, 0.0219608191, 0.0295446478, 0.0612407587, 0.0352861136, 0.0074259937, 0.0683981255, 0.0365348756, -0.0202139802, 0.0447780639, -0.0701246485, -0.00896117, 0.057724487, 0.0502325296, -0.011354289, 0.0233843476, -0.0103818532, -0.0049927519, 0.0107831946, -0.0055354093, -0.0103613483, 0.059052512, -0.045716159, -0.0344447047, -0.0075561702, 0.0092622899, 0.0216153376, 0.0322766006, 0.0137567483, 0.0393155776, -0.0665029213, -0.0407130532, 0.043504905, -0.0355752707, -0.0706674084, -0.0110402228, 0.0003867922, 0.0362582542, 0.0112874946, -0.0564993173, -0.0136824204, 0.0155371176, -0.0649626404, -0.0209479332, -0.0479705594, -0.0272895936, -0.0559458211, 0.037762519, -0.0296645332, 0.0384415165, 0.0431100912, -0.0506094024, -0.0449710488, 0.0302369278, -0.0038693002, 0.0253432095, -0.0681903213, 0.039666418, -0.0102045219, 0.0363040641, -0.0419379398, 0.0439289995, -0.0268984232, -0.0207705963, -0.0154389553, -0.0039181756, 0.0204464328, 0.0221265145, -0.0773324668, -0.0162702221, 0.0106556658, 0.0221712608, 0.0034651863, -0.0000392973, 0.0010818511, -0.0291145779, -0.0245481655, 0.0086723408, -0.0311447438, 0.008791469, 0.0037034354, 0.0443766676, 0.0121132182, -0.0209088326, -0.0045125065, -0.0165006332, -0.0169233847, -0.0016297355, -0.0163299721, 0.0107606733, -0.0364373997, -0.0139897075, -0.0384202302, 0.0229062531, 0.0664011389, -0.0224580821, -0.0412356183, -0.0274701864, 0.0439190865, -0.0348158479, 0.0455829129, 0.0017987937, -0.0117814522, -0.0280786417, -0.0199775398, -0.0134172356, 0.0432545841, -0.0162796956, -0.0070229662, 0.0811957493, 0.0003306078, -0.0534940399, 0.0031718849, -0.0177294444, -0.0026400113, -0.022081811, -0.0354525223, -0.0053316853, 0.0538008139, 0.0382266641, -0.0331150405, -0.004872655, -0.0129632773, -0.0088360822, -0.049159959, -0.0317435637, -0.0231308099, -0.006019047, -0.0087784575, -0.0344731957, -0.0688328147, 0.0793743432, -0.0276279673, 0.0368686207, -0.0538527258, -0.0591900349, 0.0075777029, 0.0558447428, 0.0227869079, 0.0566701815, 0.0086120432, -0.0015372704, -0.0586923882, -0.0150388004, 0.0429406166, -0.0316917598, 0.039684739, -0.0877511129, 0.0209336095, 0.0179600734, -0.0186031964, -0.0388571471, -0.0423175246, -0.0207511373, 0.0384770408, 0.0532123186, 0.0059043835, -0.0024840054, 0.0046219644, 0.0091936672, 0.0603890195, 0.0069793565, -0.0000655137, -0.0344035923, 0.0308370236, 0.0461033508, -0.0302462801, 0.0159356892, -0.0143896937, 0.0234082993, 0.023430774, 0.0460942872, 0.0089377528, -0.0485473275, -0.0013619644, 0.0182012841, -0.0345925763, -0.0249137394, 0.0129558826, 0.0002096745, -0.0430967733, 0.00413513, 0.1183712259, 0.0076330272, -0.0267399158, -0.0226537101, 0.0401703343, 0.0217425991, 0.0067442111, 0.0047481991, -0.0729693919, -0.0323312655, -0.0082246168, 0.0318604372, 0.0067821988, -0.031820938, -0.0263416059, -0.0859358385, -0.0057373699, 0.012030202, 0.0039383131, -0.0427740067, -0.0353879184, -0.0248981286, -0.0095431656, 0.0241733119, -0.0096091172, 0.0207043979, -0.0174032561, 0.0085957656, -0.0263697207, -0.0414368361, -0.0002901124, -0.0625505596, 0.0407379679, 0.0530576482, 0.0025983236, -0.0176538378, -0.048811391, -0.0235176608, -0.0336527899, 0.005174201, 0.0023103103, 0.0737425759, 0.0005784314, -0.0130572719, 0.0179994162, 0.0199332219, -0.0485747233, -0.0170868915, -0.0114515088, 0.0383382216, 0.0044151805, -0.0595855862, -0.0156653039, -0.0246304739, 0.0217982288, 0.0834628344, 0.0115711745, -0.0265584048, -0.0322220698, 0.0262612868, -0.0207730588, -0.0027014606, 0.0164025687, 0.0258236732, -0.0749450549, 0.011918094, -0.0351559222, 0.0111787114, -0.0146237602, 0.0033297106, 0.0168920681, 0.0415391922, 0.0555724725, 0.0059187314, -0.0462089218, 0.0008007005, -0.0358349532, 0.0203467049, 0.0056784046, -0.0022865131, 0.0111575453, -0.0043387874, -0.0394985341, 0.0579305775, -0.121170029, -0.0602251031, 0.035846319, 0.0447119214, 0.023685582, 0.0579744615, -0.0170257781, -0.0771076754, 0.1051068902, -0.008764144, 0.0110431239, 0.0263237655, 0.0030471489, -0.0476327837, 0.0048517701, 0.0554823764, -0.019546533, 0.0463861115, 0.0520698056, 0.0071180686, -0.0627294853, -0.0091811707, -0.0140580721, 0.0325802229, 0.0582477264, -0.0203833543, 0.0317890979, -0.0469709411, -0.0131253693, 0.017705299, -0.0234111678, -0.0340442136, 0.0149660734, 0.0590346903, 0.0061130938, -0.0232043955, 0.0604549721, 0.0422307961, -0.0000716793, -0.0027194251, -0.030208962, 0.0113465805, -0.0216571093, 0.0195937119, -0.0070519368, -0.0035717939, 0.0332013331, -0.005047644, 0.0220791418, -0.0153934071, 0.0299612973, 0.0082171876, 0.0028842357, -0.0413605496, 0.011634035, -0.0812379792, -0.060123574, -0.0167722981, 0.0208777785, 0.0485784523, -0.0110126594, 0.0467015952, -0.0096022142, -0.000302869, -0.0172794349, 0.010203192, -0.0063657598, 0.0367261991, 0.0101293465, 0.0217010248, -0.0112476526, 0.0302415267, 0.0954572037, 0.0122282347, 0.0289419647, 0.0036745819, -0.0137158902, -0.0226791427, -0.0142489886, 0.0218317583, 0.0761107504, -0.0023038746, -0.0187925305, -0.0362395085, -0.071655266, 0.0143079478, -0.009493161, 0.0165649652, -0.0183270853, 0.0518179648, 0.0430268385, 0.0131899221, -0.0142614013, -0.0254644193, -0.0072656935, 0.0266426224, -0.0317541957, 0.0145004857, -7.051158048e-33, 0.0100969486, 0.0207457002, -0.0178340897, 0.0171570331, -0.0174071267, 0.0339662507, 0.0120835258, -0.0493662655, -0.0636287555, 0.0309060812, -0.0095292591, 0.0531323999, 0.0247011818, 0.0417791791, -0.0122992704, 0.0066968156, 0.091450952, -0.0152762281, 0.0219854359, 0.0200411081, 0.037748009, 0.0531735308, 0.0306055937, -0.0871070921, 0.0050022556, -0.0111209732, -0.0009091499, 0.0064610448, 0.0235511865, 0.0149792656, -0.0236090235, 0.0851816908, 0.0161043555, -0.0494859293, -0.0358200707, -0.0095429551, -0.0862441137, -0.0376169719, 0.0222982429, -0.0082095098, -0.0077764164, -0.0099809906, 0.0941724479, 0.0039074151, 0.0094255554, 0.0002050358, 0.0408720188, -0.0110421395, -0.0441043526, -0.0450355336, -0.0088857394, 0.011479917, 0.0117469821, -0.0210345723, 0.0450296924, -0.0620167144, -0.0416725725, -0.0066451933, -0.1188204661, -0.0024423869, 0.0210141446, 0.0518543534, 0.0488601401, 0.0729253218, -0.0032787709, 0.0691450611, 0.0313483477, -0.0211179722, 0.0019017351, -0.0194232669, 0.0521804318, 0.0643016547, 0.0334417447, 0.053227827, 0.0957913697, -0.0243123472, -0.0498621836, -0.0187084507, 0.0043476247, 0.0074461745, 0.0334838405, -0.0121057555, -0.0123203211, -0.0651179999, -0.0833166987, -0.0435980447, -0.0259816125, 0.0064897984, 0.0167965405, 0.0170451775, -0.0251740254, 0.0054709511, 0.0019801941, -0.0869203508, 0.0061996225, 0.0104309786, 0.0166094061, 0.0035073184, 0.021393992, 0.0254321843, -0.040890567, -0.0215325002, -0.018788211, 0.0196456984, -0.0007204232, 0.0054256869, 0.0439090095, 0.0028042395, -0.038373936, 0.0011549718, -0.006912543, -0.0128147593, 0.0384098329, 0.034621723, 0.0184987597, 0.0255562346, -0.0056701247, -0.0483748578, 0.0456559844, -0.0021986894, 0.0056931078, 0.0293134749, 0.0302433316, 0.0260404721, -0.0301445108, -0.0023204698, -0.0201681703, 0.009164799, 0.075071983, -0.0507629216, -0.0028191663, 0.0201307964, 3.208e-7, 0.037522275, 0.0025032435, -0.0291376058, -0.0088790031, 0.0094588036, 0.0018743088, 0.048269663, 0.0135072079, -0.0083042877, -0.0803849921, -0.0241132919, 0.0676447675, 0.0264661182, 0.0255862493, -0.0766853839, -0.0133534363, -0.0017108337, -0.0034158791, -0.0355561972, -0.0226068497, 0.0313734524, 0.1084437892, 0.0651904568, -0.040315669, -0.0042259744, -0.0625417531, 0.0081563378, 0.0066670571, 0.0318466425, 0.0398115329, 0.0333030447, 0.0047735162, -0.0008275657, 0.0685633197, -0.0048474111, 0.0316454135, 0.0118861385, 0.060960874, -0.0151950344, 0.0190979987, -0.0199363362, -0.028394483, -0.0153683722, -0.0438440964, 0.0694151893, -0.0357909873, 0.0351163521, -0.0213573184, -0.0106787197, -0.0091482326, 0.0468064956, -0.0122033516, 0.0090694064, 0.0338312425, 0.006202911, -0.0006530451, -0.0347334184, -0.0685413629, -0.0107562998, -0.0054313256, -0.048521284, -0.0514859185, -0.006262823, -0.0741704628, 0.0435709879, -0.0584036335, 0.0340362303, 2.998751751e-34, 0.0303616989, 0.0047125933, 0.010922431, 0.0065723038, 0.0131107038, -0.0131081957, -0.1010598466, -0.000945456, -0.0140200099, -0.092559889, -0.0143419513 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.04856v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.04856v1
Multimodal Deep Learning
2023-01-12T07:42:36
2023-01-12T07:42:36
Cem Akkus, Luyang Chu, Vladana Djakovic, Steffen Jauch-Walser, Philipp Koch, Giacomo Loss, Christopher Marquardt, Marco Moldovan, Nadja Sauter, Maximilian Schneider, Rickmer Schulte, Karol Urbanczyk, Jann Goschenhofer, Christian Heumann, Rasmus Hvingelby, Daniel Schalk, Matthias Aßenmacher
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.LG, stat.ML
This book is the result of a seminar in which we reviewed multimodal approaches and attempted to create a solid overview of the field, starting with the current state-of-the-art approaches in the two subfields of Deep Learning individually. Further, modeling frameworks are discussed where one modality is transformed into the other, as well as models in which one modality is utilized to enhance representation learning for the other. To conclude the second part, architectures with a focus on handling both modalities simultaneously are introduced. Finally, we also cover other modalities as well as general-purpose multi-modal models, which are able to handle different tasks on different modalities within one unified architecture. One interesting application (Generative Art) eventually caps off this booklet.
[ -0.0167751685, 0.102541104, -0.0297295731, 0.0209683403, -0.0452609546, -0.0170847382, 0.0698364452, -0.0490984954, -0.0603374317, -0.049814526, -0.0867507979, -0.0632107034, -0.0252270792, 0.0657802373, 0.0433164537, -0.0884938091, -0.0038160868, 0.0212053489, -0.0427004509, -0.033720009, 0.0172226876, -0.0083567034, -0.0282969642, 0.0380461141, -0.0626729131, -0.0077351229, -0.0871343166, 0.0140788248, 0.0031049293, -0.0015376364, 0.0059628389, 0.0099096773, 0.0326784477, 0.0307143815, 0.0000021671, 0.0008845772, 0.0227865782, -0.0153788989, 0.0886275694, -0.0229483098, 0.0592709482, -0.0136678778, -0.0034567206, -0.0348276049, -0.028515555, -0.0351689756, 0.0739556998, 0.0643994138, 0.0652101338, 0.0207583494, -0.0060819713, -0.05359881, 0.0570637994, -0.0157023165, 0.0216169115, 0.0051115886, 0.0003103225, -0.0271841399, 0.0106675038, -0.0170686673, -0.0666733533, 0.0318077803, 0.0279331319, 0.0250598621, -0.0045563448, 0.0007126028, 0.0579972155, -0.0247141942, -0.0082616676, 0.0454036184, -0.0436456464, 0.0558052771, 0.0154891275, -0.008048852, -0.0176138151, 0.0010089237, -0.0069936169, 0.0581813455, -0.00294809, 0.0071347174, -0.0930305496, -0.0158221144, 0.0240192357, -0.0087618176, -0.0072577852, -0.0550915785, 0.0172384307, 0.0460473076, -0.0197807923, 0.0091045033, -0.0221183654, -0.0077780047, 0.0009160815, 0.0227201059, -0.001199682, -0.0267786589, -0.0377531424, -0.0218899138, -0.0148367053, 0.022665048, 0.0435868613, -0.0232266895, -0.0840468854, 0.0088551678, -0.0015227208, -0.036647521, -0.0759949759, 0.0404240787, -0.0207029004, -0.0196055491, -0.0476330109, -0.0338637158, -0.0306958947, 0.0143091781, -0.0165433306, -0.0283196792, -0.0413651951, -0.0014977398, -0.0309295692, -0.0494776405, -0.0073365849, 0.0608389936, -0.0462900437, -0.0103694303, -0.0243520103, 0.0656350553, 0.0068000038, 0.0954090357, 0.0246503372, -0.0159055218, 0.0306504965, 0.0183313731, 0.0025283997, 0.0105570089, -0.0083116591, 0.0739878565, -0.0293063112, 0.0305170286, -0.0248303991, -0.036120899, 0.0067110821, -0.0523509197, 0.088249281, -0.0153341619, 0.0147612514, -0.0626808256, 0.0428257324, 0.0023167592, -0.0165984575, -0.0359676927, 0.0572098345, 0.0753164589, 0.0434800461, -0.0228707027, 0.0354544744, 0.010296437, -0.023271149, 0.0332263, 0.0581337698, 0.0174610391, -0.0428082719, -0.0197255872, 0.0001857963, 0.0108149173, -0.0039269412, -0.0228059385, 0.0089813937, -0.0982279629, -0.0020165723, 0.0501919314, 0.0176553093, 0.0225787945, -0.0390584432, -0.0342761949, 0.0418258235, -0.0332408957, 0.0509446338, 0.0376341231, 0.0687168539, -0.0240296945, -0.0122589609, 0.0062403805, 0.014922495, 0.0613374002, 0.0179996993, -0.0266701542, -0.014778642, 0.0292822551, -0.070858717, -0.0349601544, 0.0532118194, -0.0508334264, 0.0211334992, -0.0260851514, 0.0557709634, 0.0089951614, -0.012377182, -0.0269564204, -0.0289918426, -0.007926668, 0.0106561212, -0.0408247523, -0.0503481068, -0.010857733, -0.029442586, -0.0212351494, 0.0002921727, -0.0112713985, 0.010223248, 0.0289947726, -0.0118488437, -0.0085740965, 0.0732203126, -0.0189470332, -0.0206695478, -0.0584974401, 0.029754281, 0.0399670303, -0.0694326088, 0.0069130259, -0.0230918061, 0.0116346376, 0.099988915, -0.0014853374, 0.0109125245, 0.0166358333, 0.0246979576, 0.0416249968, 0.0352783278, -0.0099318922, 0.0091797551, -0.0054671774, -0.0048273471, -0.0381174758, -0.0113557642, 0.0328877047, -0.0327680893, 0.028959943, 0.0085885758, -0.0729801431, 0.0366315208, 0.028043652, -0.004178015, -0.021217037, 0.0814440697, 0.0039171288, 0.0238038022, -0.008044919, -0.0290019438, 0.0446410179, 0.0143777877, 0.0100374483, -0.0111645404, -0.0263215862, -0.0310528968, 0.0118709998, -0.0046970844, -0.0075364779, 0.0159889776, -0.0566341095, 0.0224531237, -0.0084182359, 0.0306399465, -0.0031243935, -0.0392544977, -0.0092558293, 0.0047774534, -0.0718344003, -0.0037653709, 0.0083948998, -0.0246456601, -0.0133854216, 0.006358753, 0.0240981746, -0.0071872114, -0.0483493917, 0.0787935406, 0.0176092982, 0.017828986, 0.021990804, 0.0402623378, 0.0453681014, -0.0065978034, -0.0002788668, -0.0029254025, 0.0326076522, -0.006388416, -0.0085177077, -0.0042817723, -0.0122007392, -0.0204112642, 0.0481343903, -0.0042648045, -0.014179009, -0.0000258006, -0.0516220927, 0.0330280028, 0.054097034, -0.0099644596, 0.0486843996, 0.0211041681, -0.0075451937, -0.0314234346, 0.0035264329, 0.0143859778, 0.0096046505, 0.0141546857, 0.0230773427, -0.0152119575, 0.0222955253, 0.033301685, 0.006186659, -0.0234812107, 0.0294150002, 0.0191709045, -0.0801137388, 0.0061196014, 0.0213863663, 0.0131524233, -0.0252834838, -0.0507212244, -0.0191750005, 0.0108332122, 0.0251583271, -0.0107103586, 0.0551200248, 0.015671663, 0.0129024656, 0.0599145703, 0.0091612199, 0.0327561982, -0.0091981534, -0.0263897087, -0.0542746298, 0.0431963094, 0.0445958376, -0.0115832184, 0.0068237996, -0.0301840175, -0.0218436103, -0.0485231355, -0.0287357345, -0.0203055535, -0.0077283825, 0.0006880567, 0.0320226252, -0.0273195151, 0.0111642787, -0.0361590125, -0.0227949824, -0.0065680775, 0.0062120897, -0.0040130685, -0.0118078468, -0.0129270609, 0.0726609603, 0.0012605581, 0.0559461154, -0.0794908032, -0.0243115015, -0.0168292131, 0.0257560108, -0.0133027909, 0.0085114026, -0.1137043983, 0.0481549017, 0.0265518781, 0.0629127622, -0.0570020303, 0.0038983056, 0.0410544425, -0.0533932112, 0.02668803, -0.0300492533, -0.0214675441, -0.0325433277, -0.0184223801, 0.0442436002, -0.0241218954, -0.0118053379, 0.0000493793, -0.0825049058, -0.0499718003, -0.0338861383, -0.0358496048, 0.0333124138, -0.0046052365, 0.0252786092, -0.0237373766, 0.0423905887, 0.0024003533, 0.0011313652, -0.0340824611, 0.0218413863, 0.0131849544, 0.0166757032, -0.0336407498, -0.0178122818, 0.0083215563, -0.027154617, 0.058670029, 0.0590612814, -0.0212041847, -0.0503490902, -0.0354067907, 0.0116872927, 0.0494305752, 0.0179148037, -0.013533853, -0.0760957301, -0.0024701876, 0.0412133895, 0.0110519482, 0.0070671258, 0.0073337294, 0.0106851766, -0.0025926516, -0.0027883258, 0.0333101042, 0.011788873, 0.023880804, -0.0303648636, 0.0516620092, -0.0274055097, 0.0080810469, -0.0622567721, -0.0105904182, 0.0093714772, -0.0187996607, -0.0056043672, -0.0531010441, -0.0724607557, -0.0197740011, 0.0275650043, -0.0527362749, -0.0192692988, -0.0059541562, 0.0210314747, -0.0270379912, -0.023239458, -0.0044495617, -0.031082429, 0.0393835679, 0.0028132424, -0.0359822065, -0.051737763, 0.0148927262, -0.0467052571, 0.006771564, 0.0117533375, 0.0165163185, -6.208e-7, -0.0299389791, 0.0528924242, -0.0677036867, -0.0008214285, -0.0023557781, -0.0742499307, -0.0205801204, -0.0310130417, 0.0448546372, -0.0037884931, 0.0293446518, 0.0213825814, -0.0669286773, 0.0118263178, 0.0360827148, -0.0005296072, -0.0047280164, 0.0747056827, 0.0115083605, -0.0233782642, -0.0177458357, -0.0206288472, 0.0218143798, 0.0041878321, -0.0192863252, 0.0192743167, -0.0170535613, 0.0155144557, -0.0729989037, 0.0320115909, 0.0045341454, 0.0264646299, -0.0487933829, 0.0071503837, 0.0414717905, 0.0112744458, -0.0555809885, 0.0061912732, 0.0301979035, 0.0039092512, 0.0108781466, 0.003565867, 0.1091221943, 0.0322943032, -0.0521215796, 0.0779993385, 0.0631400272, 0.0293905009, -0.0946623906, 0.0566556975, 0.025713468, 0.0492738262, -0.0010310961, 0.0064442903, -0.0132141672, 0.0403597094, -0.0038956143, -0.005384739, -0.0464879945, 0.0752278492, -0.0040280912, -0.0024496017, -0.0234139264, 0.0625676215, 0.0598647334, 0.0200317651, 0.0007720032, 0.0034893933, -0.0176418889, -0.0374293029, 0.0966826528, 0.0205308329, -0.0193395689, 0.0119917858, -0.0167536698, 0.0264345407, -0.0432758778, 0.0301107615, -0.0526832528, 0.0278783273, -0.0551922768, -0.0138784228, -0.0217871573, 0.009873081, 0.0535656437, 0.0233641267, 0.0102025094, 0.0084128575, -0.0015803836, -0.0218819324, -0.0002040942, 0.0280206837, 0.0199398994, -0.0140961567, 0.0473814048, 0.0761036128, 0.0152058974, -0.0303432383, -0.0301751029, 0.021010438, 0.0423026457, 0.0323079973, 0.0024331361, -5.834494579e-33, -0.0200255718, 0.0325685441, 0.0234345589, -0.0492010415, -0.0322302207, 0.0087793469, 0.0083639519, 0.0353279263, 0.0014407129, -0.0179545898, 0.0207483619, -0.0286446251, -0.0160218943, -0.0039224601, 0.0436451249, -0.0008209163, 0.0301895943, -0.0077740117, 0.0085744103, 0.0207707323, 0.015965404, 0.0142367771, 0.0343796909, -0.0568791889, -0.0236913264, 0.0289819632, -0.0393442884, -0.0403223634, -0.0260393824, 0.0440621376, -0.0466862544, 0.0068650162, 0.0210951641, -0.011865193, -0.0284330696, 0.0135938516, -0.0575486794, 0.0065775197, -0.0298722964, 0.0276247635, -0.1162993908, -0.0255713034, 0.056736771, 0.0063045006, -0.0181451552, -0.0028124903, 0.0440558121, -0.0115539776, 0.0171478409, -0.0194284189, -0.0424339995, 0.0013655556, -0.0347616859, -0.0665687621, 0.0452992059, 0.0236530136, 0.0179555174, -0.0026593274, -0.0312198661, 0.0688482672, -0.0175916739, 0.0027170077, 0.0309893917, 0.0362645872, 0.0125804981, 0.0394783802, 0.0398526415, -0.0466389582, -0.0212700963, 0.0111391945, 0.039313063, 0.0625741929, -0.0180415306, 0.0693105087, 0.0263257362, -0.0014469066, -0.0250456408, 0.0556775592, 0.0368086882, 0.0222005639, -0.0288944896, 0.0257593095, 0.0319605395, 0.0363633372, -0.0212111957, -0.0496470481, -0.0028059178, -0.0167237148, 0.0372004695, 0.0224139635, 0.015860239, 0.0100127794, 0.0882191285, -0.0305682197, -0.0081269778, 0.0001336898, -0.0302709881, 0.0694438517, 0.0031450393, -0.0141932797, 0.0312773995, -0.0347010083, 0.0413055345, -0.0084485868, -0.004029185, -0.0025145006, -0.0233856142, 0.0825238004, 0.0211727265, -0.0095382398, -0.0303396042, -0.030047033, 0.0413775966, 0.0436761081, 0.0389852673, -0.0077108205, -0.0186485797, 0.0138591537, -0.0396554507, 0.0230601486, -0.0483801253, -0.0413893647, -0.0238958243, 0.0147779686, -0.0134783173, 0.013058492, -0.0568635985, -0.0846918449, 0.00154571, -0.099545531, -0.0250982624, 0.0058994945, 2.801e-7, 0.0034752896, -0.0418485664, 0.0131940357, -0.0262288954, 0.0303112715, 0.0327332132, -0.0450331829, 0.0669685379, -0.0325183049, -0.0188022591, -0.0022088967, 0.0187876653, -0.0117888134, 0.0106293112, -0.0072558695, 0.0158700198, 0.0252312776, 0.0696787387, -0.0151275061, 0.0092219012, 0.0123211108, 0.0693513304, -0.0357710496, -0.0419668406, 0.0173489954, 0.0462250672, 0.0804789513, 0.0098725213, 0.008526938, -0.0298487898, 0.0301372688, 0.0244917329, -0.0188114569, -0.0097723659, 0.0088669164, -0.0187294092, 0.0603997409, 0.0046672481, -0.0127693471, -0.0611603633, 0.0071978858, 0.0847750083, -0.0211443007, 0.0420461111, 0.0601409748, -0.0075544463, -0.0189269613, -0.0554205403, -0.0176929981, 0.0369459651, 0.0138109364, -0.013956503, -0.0431097411, -0.0309815295, -0.0122745223, -0.0308104511, -0.0082226293, -0.0505329482, 0.0277387276, -0.0180276316, -0.0732253939, -0.0033047232, -0.0225444864, -0.0578832701, 0.0779453292, -0.0543718897, -0.0536715761, 1.660663573e-34, -0.0165265705, -0.0055749584, 0.014710892, 0.0087208794, -0.0315008387, 0.0079849288, -0.0278778262, -0.0131411003, 0.0179977883, -0.0157639273, -0.0591787584 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.04788v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.04788v1
Language Cognition and Language Computation -- Human and Machine Language Understanding
2023-01-12T02:37:00
2023-01-12T02:37:00
Shaonan Wang, Nai Ding, Nan Lin, Jiajun Zhang, Chengqing Zong
cs.CL
cs.CL
Language understanding is a key scientific issue in the fields of cognitive and computer science. However, the two disciplines differ substantially in the specific research questions. Cognitive science focuses on analyzing the specific mechanism of the brain and investigating the brain's response to language; few studies have examined the brain's language system as a whole. By contrast, computer scientists focus on the efficiency of practical applications when choosing research questions but may ignore the most essential laws of language. Given these differences, can a combination of the disciplines offer new insights for building intelligent language models and studying language cognitive mechanisms? In the following text, we first review the research questions, history, and methods of language understanding in cognitive and computer science, focusing on the current progress and challenges. We then compare and contrast the research of language understanding in cognitive and computer sciences. Finally, we review existing work that combines insights from language cognition and language computation and offer prospects for future development trends.
[ 0.0705723539, 0.0252912529, -0.0771779418, 0.0267539658, -0.0457677431, 0.031579487, -0.0226555895, 0.0084021529, 0.0091088824, -0.0422836915, -0.0347042084, -0.0699048713, 0.0610642731, 0.0112510389, 0.038062349, -0.0270402115, 0.0565883666, -0.0140731232, 0.0703155398, 0.011103088, 0.0004908739, 0.0066216053, -0.026281558, 0.0149867088, -0.0197370499, -0.0149248736, -0.007663345, -0.0353658609, -0.0457474478, -0.0001089612, -0.0344460718, 0.0384411439, 0.029143801, 0.0259743538, 0.000001878, -0.0891879052, 0.0037080706, -0.0231551938, -0.0434637107, -0.0067133917, 0.0632095933, -0.0193509031, 0.0062835705, -0.014339692, -0.0275822766, 0.0533734411, 0.0477379374, -0.0075924871, -0.0151215764, 0.0171691459, -0.013138907, -0.0128581729, -0.0162177868, 0.0232818611, 0.01711246, -0.0038334946, 0.0351223126, -0.0123640485, -0.0025770045, -0.0393878222, -0.0446943231, 0.0224291608, -0.0155099472, 0.0227544084, -0.0290211905, 0.0294807386, -0.0274438635, -0.0462378152, -0.0253511555, 0.0242125504, 0.0335789993, -0.0474487804, 0.0239406191, 0.0365961343, -0.0054237358, 0.0169610064, -0.0377194323, 0.0186774507, 0.0350181088, 0.0129919816, 0.019013444, -0.012140247, -0.0089579411, 0.0422767922, -0.0150630632, 0.1216123328, -0.0081513217, -0.0239572134, -0.0085267285, 0.0068254066, -0.0260988753, -0.0425853841, 0.0162077826, 0.048790209, -0.0261347331, 0.0367606729, 0.0199671611, -0.0661292449, 0.0318146534, -0.0449347869, 0.0308526959, 0.0274152458, 0.0126558235, 0.0227621589, 0.0119785862, 0.0648065805, 0.0070464932, -0.0006777678, -0.0081466502, -0.0062811831, -0.0556346476, -0.0611258671, -0.0366732515, 0.0487564839, 0.0191321466, -0.0045963475, -0.0364523493, 0.0071357405, -0.02111491, -0.033675462, -0.0444825739, -0.0007120832, -0.0147468178, 0.0042846687, -0.0638326779, -0.0152730178, -0.0253378637, 0.0339295007, -0.0392740741, -0.0447334908, 0.0008321502, 0.011783259, -0.0278786235, -0.0106974924, -0.0125329969, 0.0444788262, 0.0076557421, 0.0010588211, -0.000991889, -0.0345243774, -0.0358842388, -0.0670981556, -0.0277816635, -0.0462751165, 0.0104304422, 0.0567270629, -0.037991181, -0.0690441877, -0.0114627592, 0.0087931314, -0.0525491089, 0.0697827414, -0.0164097492, 0.0041481471, 0.0694327801, 0.0108191501, 0.0110753309, 0.0454609394, 0.0371136628, -0.0136369923, 0.0002438609, 0.0043922346, 0.0045170076, 0.0144240838, -0.0108650792, -0.0777198449, -0.0591856465, -0.0232643262, 0.0139950188, 0.0095901452, 0.0112650404, 0.0720293522, -0.0086033093, -0.024433203, 0.0256089251, 0.0905891061, -0.0276699644, 0.0472237021, 0.046315603, 0.0110621508, 0.0160264745, 0.0295000821, -0.0177968126, 0.0260886066, -0.0133393919, -0.0002260869, -0.02165653, -0.0118939346, -0.0063196081, -0.0374684371, -0.0395305306, 0.0077572553, 0.0330201946, -0.0054656728, 0.0481185354, -0.0139638344, 0.0088785943, 0.0264276154, 0.032273978, -0.0401640795, 0.0237671286, -0.0415895395, -0.0065459898, 0.0422090068, 0.0178247485, -0.017159, 0.0165765863, 0.0156596173, -0.0085529247, 0.0375591591, 0.0443483405, -0.0143993814, 0.0000862253, -0.018210616, 0.0310338903, 0.0136730988, -0.0114684105, 0.0065713953, -0.0456286035, 0.0053418013, -0.0336500332, 0.0125561766, -0.0113427276, 0.0478813164, -0.0090797171, 0.0175458789, -0.077554509, 0.0187850203, 0.0362713933, -0.0071043805, 0.0162415206, 0.0251969192, 0.0094239479, -0.0126974639, 0.0099879401, 0.0384506471, -0.0443377495, -0.0036361439, 0.0538754873, -0.0187721625, -0.0002172817, 0.001919526, 0.0486856177, -0.0339356326, 0.0916347653, -0.0717408434, 0.0450272337, -0.0499711372, 0.0395938419, -0.0499637239, 0.0313779637, -0.0210207123, 0.0926884413, 0.0145278657, 0.0355239734, 0.0166199207, -0.0178902708, 0.0431225337, -0.025303917, -0.0590272881, -0.0053134379, -0.0195325371, -0.0282338746, 0.0201773122, -0.0627995878, -0.0769340992, 0.0106130196, -0.0576854721, -0.0414051451, 0.0177229028, 0.0086015854, 0.0027957179, -0.0302530192, -0.0046860324, -0.0034874398, 0.0077127763, 0.0475214943, 0.0161662661, 0.0226084236, 0.0211309008, -0.0176692177, -0.0358095802, -0.0428310968, 0.0178410001, -0.0536059365, 0.0439664386, 0.0506503768, -0.0563025177, -0.0562306531, 0.0154562024, -0.0717205405, 0.0326479524, 0.0030664059, -0.0485478528, 0.0581736527, 0.013661691, 0.0461255386, 0.0568473935, 0.0189371053, 0.0611438677, 0.0651511699, -0.0463695303, -0.0380630717, -0.0099336216, -0.0251010358, 0.0187204406, -0.0314679258, -0.0365793034, -0.0386501849, 0.1127724126, 0.0659980625, 0.0006619939, -0.0338906869, 0.0281151328, -0.0572254248, -0.0558275692, -0.056051828, -0.0374528803, -0.0559355728, 0.0842407271, -0.0259385239, -0.0328684375, 0.0933582559, -0.0097722784, 0.0152081037, -0.0384876505, 0.0225602854, 0.0110082403, 0.0661020502, 0.0032650859, 0.0406399593, 0.0054866942, -0.0357521363, -0.0636843443, -0.002591864, -0.0043108519, -0.0679830164, -0.0103389956, -0.0762255862, 0.0233757328, 0.0173550323, -0.004726524, -0.042536974, 0.0313052125, -0.0145906582, 0.0256351065, 0.0430339389, 0.0070364489, -0.0231648535, 0.0288591515, 0.0254804902, -0.0223867632, 0.0339132883, -0.0195119586, -0.0239799581, 0.0084542343, 0.0380062126, 0.0313845798, 0.0339767337, 0.0132089863, 0.0103406822, 0.0267778579, 0.0324910097, 0.0100815026, -0.0053978851, 0.0517252199, 0.0617558211, -0.0390946977, -0.0126261106, 0.0469318256, 0.0220229123, -0.0270468667, -0.026013596, 0.1077083349, 0.0823784322, -0.0639546588, 0.0122063123, -0.0516226143, -0.021652922, 0.0386651307, 0.0082724579, -0.0480182692, 0.009475695, -0.0075262687, -0.0463515222, -0.0380164497, -0.0518733934, -0.0411526151, -0.0496810786, 0.0285653882, -0.0367520526, -0.0548438095, -0.0231656674, -0.0278408919, 0.0344777368, 0.035050258, 0.0020965689, 0.0062928232, 0.0166225769, -0.005194813, 0.0307086706, -0.0048281825, -0.0159711037, 0.0285348985, -0.0132850222, 0.0849749148, 0.0335510969, 0.0690946132, -0.0103446534, -0.0392656364, -0.0044687097, -0.0341113545, 0.0116978139, -0.0362608917, -0.0035398966, 0.0364894494, -0.0007999375, -0.0256691519, -0.0030449892, -0.0036170429, -0.0515861847, -0.0182094816, 0.07376232, -0.0589034669, -0.004928085, 0.0035924003, 0.0434629396, -0.0024344495, 0.0953170359, 0.0458374806, -0.0620285645, -0.0017613566, -0.0087849768, 0.0216559451, 0.0154603198, -0.0500680581, -0.0069899647, 0.0611068234, 0.0008836707, -0.0662698373, -0.0035629258, 0.0329999924, 0.0027030688, 0.0347898863, 0.0445340015, 0.0393833965, -0.0396608189, -0.0710524172, -0.0057128612, -0.0234376267, -0.0065067685, -0.0115361214, -0.049680341, -0.0241619926, -0.059908472, -0.0309508555, 0.0296554975, -0.0325962529, -0.0703740418, 0.0434993841, 0.0013379713, 0.0341662429, 0.0059712147, -0.0118597159, -0.0361617245, -0.0274934191, -0.0044969874, -0.0447072908, 0.0346613601, -0.0404517688, 0.0146404589, 0.0223621707, 0.0344409719, 0.018809393, 0.0281610154, 0.0203975961, 0.0087019876, -0.0204051137, -0.0275215767, 0.0640712902, 0.0266898181, 0.0505305938, -0.0149296103, -0.0078805378, -0.0212764088, -0.0572603159, 0.0065004225, -0.0158094577, 0.0006529415, -0.0658687055, -0.0078332648, 0.0119600026, -0.0335731581, -0.0648635402, -0.0481456555, 0.0182278566, 0.0164478179, 0.0001848789, -0.0070990594, 0.0521352328, -0.0003241622, 0.0221598204, 0.0572154857, 0.0397090726, -0.06154266, 0.0364603251, -0.0019995689, 0.0662599355, 0.0025745775, -0.0208738931, -0.0509695262, -0.0267862733, -0.0112864012, -0.0379346833, 0.0436772555, 0.0160562582, 0.005413603, -0.0318723843, 0.011027622, -0.0455581509, 0.0257477723, 0.0071454891, 0.0034873525, 0.0049358788, -0.0332987569, 0.0394079573, 0.013671346, -0.0087953405, 0.0032110307, 0.0440130755, -0.0308342278, -0.0210668594, -0.0292644557, -0.031917911, -0.0152313588, -0.0100325318, -0.0064563695, 0.0229240637, -0.0240541492, 0.0738975555, -0.072251901, -0.0591256209, 0.0234853998, -0.0104528619, 0.0759591982, -0.0420919172, 0.0654276088, 0.0436019227, -0.0156434793, 0.0016870928, -0.0162114166, 0.0294758659, -0.0162078906, -0.0220425986, -0.0388074853, -6.123427784e-33, -0.038261842, -0.0610471107, 0.0244926885, 0.0215463452, 0.0019335487, -0.0069571384, -0.0516673326, 0.017324958, -0.0298639759, -0.0056557073, -0.001388328, 0.0246210787, 0.0077695595, -0.0118247345, 0.0324626714, 0.0193702988, -0.0178997777, -0.0513098985, -0.0182608049, -0.0418448374, 0.0500831828, -0.0003602447, 0.0575903803, -0.0420352891, 0.0658532456, 0.0020411001, 0.0240728129, 0.0178480186, 0.0000196859, 0.0281057749, -0.0642282292, 0.0476432368, 0.0599284992, -0.0241626594, 0.0061161588, 0.0501635186, -0.0563760027, -0.05830824, 0.0904836506, -0.0026793263, -0.0197831988, -0.0148076918, 0.0626801997, -0.0380382165, -0.0413758382, 0.0525624156, 0.035453029, -0.014907944, 0.0234545935, 0.0405308418, -0.0869516507, -0.0247681402, -0.0422494449, 0.0160366986, 0.0455931202, -0.0110457204, -0.0473255627, 0.0313871726, -0.0806169957, 0.0377626382, -0.0438379496, 0.0244138204, 0.0537834689, 0.0107435826, 0.0225971434, 0.0810651034, 0.0332694985, -0.0033300682, -0.0153317302, 0.0114032747, 0.0630659461, 0.0133020645, 0.0249038376, 0.0080571258, 0.0146199893, -0.045380298, -0.0243552327, -0.0399472453, 0.0479150638, 0.0175028611, 0.0553843193, -0.009007792, -0.0237032063, -0.0296528358, -0.0233917721, -0.0118548749, -0.0520527549, -0.0106500341, 0.0150884315, -0.0611459911, 0.0160281826, -0.0218621157, 0.0131032802, -0.0338364206, -0.0050726933, -0.0328931287, 0.0168948229, 0.0099283578, 0.0566292629, 0.0424282923, -0.0545123145, -0.0174018145, -0.0281934869, 0.0262705497, 0.0193063971, 0.0146747539, -0.0116610443, 0.0110619422, 0.0275286473, -0.0117059685, -0.0375903435, -0.0032173323, 0.001744999, -0.0208477005, 0.0168552157, 0.0309068821, -0.0236362442, -0.0648099855, 0.0192370974, -0.0425007567, 0.0010159407, 0.0484664962, -0.0487113744, 0.0492324345, -0.0583207831, -0.033260569, -0.0185675845, 0.0139323417, 0.0270650908, -0.0123960786, 0.0062339818, 0.0021383192, 2.737e-7, 0.0689329728, 0.0652792528, -0.0196666345, 0.0036871552, 0.0449100472, -0.0176574923, -0.0269144978, -0.004167085, 0.0149521893, -0.0095251324, -0.0004349913, 0.0672589093, 0.0052537089, -0.0173925795, -0.0386824533, -0.0094417715, -0.0015000254, 0.0174776521, -0.0514110178, 0.0612115823, 0.0453701839, 0.0191013142, 0.0060495464, -0.0184371974, -0.0625014007, -0.0026459983, 0.0304389205, -0.054353293, 0.0443881638, 0.0229896475, -0.0088473121, 0.0156366825, 0.0130956853, 0.0642163754, 0.0120903058, 0.0317735672, 0.0260944888, 0.0166574623, -0.0228051096, 0.0322678946, 0.0293726046, -0.0168475844, -0.0277216826, -0.0525198281, 0.0240602233, -0.0464354493, -0.0468596146, -0.0194030963, 0.0273883995, 0.0143446987, 0.003640458, 0.0224725641, -0.0063499836, -0.0111740138, 0.0206258651, -0.018671805, -0.0119826682, -0.0424147323, 0.0026231285, 0.0128192836, -0.0359207243, -0.0174153727, -0.0280558355, -0.025078496, 0.0445531122, -0.0664971098, 0.0241195038, 2.022219233e-34, -0.0165394153, 0.0140684787, -0.00184938, 0.0436711274, 0.0463044569, -0.0208275393, 0.0009448083, 0.0480730049, 0.0256250389, -0.0576865934, 0.0044814637 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.04770v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.04770v1
KAER: A Knowledge Augmented Pre-Trained Language Model for Entity Resolution
2023-01-12T00:15:40
2023-01-12T00:15:40
Liri Fang, Lan Li, Yiren Liu, Vetle I. Torvik, Bertram Ludäscher
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.DB, cs.LG
Entity resolution has been an essential and well-studied task in data cleaning research for decades. Existing work has discussed the feasibility of utilizing pre-trained language models to perform entity resolution and achieved promising results. However, few works have discussed injecting domain knowledge to improve the performance of pre-trained language models on entity resolution tasks. In this study, we propose Knowledge Augmented Entity Resolution (KAER), a novel framework named for augmenting pre-trained language models with external knowledge for entity resolution. We discuss the results of utilizing different knowledge augmentation and prompting methods to improve entity resolution performance. Our model improves on Ditto, the existing state-of-the-art entity resolution method. In particular, 1) KAER performs more robustly and achieves better results on "dirty data", and 2) with more general knowledge injection, KAER outperforms the existing baseline models on the textual dataset and dataset from the online product domain. 3) KAER achieves competitive results on highly domain-specific datasets, such as citation datasets, requiring the injection of expert knowledge in future work.
[ 0.0418704115, 0.0379657112, 0.0132729085, -0.0022725284, 0.000638968, 0.012738389, 0.0134507865, 0.0298107006, 0.0301005263, -0.0404702127, -0.0179164521, 0.0267185364, -0.027109243, 0.0208869614, -0.0069586048, -0.0321772322, 0.0583955199, 0.0178706814, 0.0538322963, -0.0159894899, -0.0031113189, 0.0062096301, 0.0191371609, -0.0229106396, 0.0053852336, -0.0276552457, -0.0060815667, -0.0109908292, 0.0363680124, 0.0107859168, 0.0562251285, 0.0619403049, -0.0053661568, 0.0408440791, 0.0000018667, -0.0472057089, -0.0043034395, 0.0297257639, -0.033260487, 0.0223256238, -0.0081755808, -0.031401109, -0.0046796049, -0.0055597262, -0.0163198728, -0.0564540885, 0.0039962665, 0.0674809739, 0.0799362585, 0.0395986326, -0.019760251, -0.0250783674, 0.0046409415, -0.0176225044, -0.0450818054, -0.0327255242, 0.0785789043, 0.0307510421, -0.011800237, 0.0000917841, 0.0161659326, 0.0737763047, -0.0001170367, -0.0015579356, 0.0097149862, 0.0266957581, 0.0080744522, 0.035549961, 0.0089634955, 0.0539579876, -0.020934971, 0.0071769967, 0.0358043611, 0.0041078236, -0.0088287024, 0.0302548129, 0.0055626058, -0.0199088994, -0.0120356316, -0.0074130907, -0.0387721881, -0.0277493745, 0.015959885, -0.0078237094, -0.0517873392, 0.022154633, 0.0215988886, -0.012056062, 0.0290030278, 0.012402704, 0.0139175691, -0.1012967601, 0.039470423, 0.0505464785, 0.0041169068, 0.0061370186, -0.0282369778, -0.0393997692, -0.0086411461, -0.0146554597, -0.0264244881, -0.0185478088, 0.0092459032, 0.0588059798, -0.0136628905, 0.0169402789, 0.0169880036, 0.0147503475, -0.0023392458, -0.0213426296, -0.0307535306, -0.0115673663, -0.0461357199, 0.032509394, -0.0635934621, 0.0165488459, -0.0274487697, -0.0283827111, -0.0422974937, 0.0173435733, -0.0305312499, -0.0139399888, 0.0115905479, -0.0373081453, -0.0691716, 0.0401130952, -0.0267764442, 0.0043778862, -0.0333005004, -0.0196687989, 0.0002035262, -0.041466184, 0.0557074025, -0.0602862351, 0.0251213796, 0.0106355445, 0.0154488571, -0.0432644747, -0.0673483834, -0.0341247879, 0.0172600523, -0.0522255376, -0.0531396903, -0.0318360813, 0.0593528971, -0.0151609499, -0.0315550454, -0.0725993663, 0.0000426876, 0.0133665605, -0.0680115372, 0.0802026764, -0.094993785, 0.0351855122, 0.042510543, -0.0125454729, 0.0387101844, 0.0003430682, -0.0162083395, -0.0097109051, 0.007158272, -0.0034296433, 0.0238056257, 0.0453643799, 0.0487306118, -0.0298426319, 0.0288295522, 0.009937115, -0.0272732303, 0.0184613876, 0.0365595557, 0.0459410846, -0.0043549971, -0.0128337247, 0.0332440697, -0.0233457237, -0.0077715348, -0.0038918036, -0.0047827847, 0.0109006902, 0.0257018693, 0.0201836787, -0.0494284257, 0.0073497663, -0.0326428041, -0.0032719551, 0.0341979973, 0.0575940274, -0.0456254035, -0.024180606, 0.0229329597, -0.0066604642, -0.0188393295, 0.0419699512, 0.0677391738, 0.047800988, -0.0229934268, 0.0337398201, 0.0241116639, -0.0229443498, 0.0089190733, 0.0017446412, -0.010083721, 0.048400186, 0.0667243972, -0.0389188379, -0.0580600798, -0.0263459124, -0.0166654252, 0.0168407001, 0.0199407376, -0.0223571546, 0.0123919407, -0.0190593712, -0.0608738847, 0.0435064733, 0.0003011356, 0.0211997349, 0.063664034, 0.0187594984, 0.0392115861, -0.0406814329, -0.0549159274, 0.0369364657, -0.048292961, 0.0044223559, -0.0203959607, 0.0417098291, -0.0333039202, 0.0310141724, -0.0384527892, -0.028601272, 0.0447463989, -0.0057675703, 0.0043604318, -0.0220081676, 0.0364272855, -0.030635247, 0.0623473488, -0.019018691, -0.0549226254, 0.0116027044, -0.0119999619, -0.0423579998, -0.0444317758, 0.027738424, 0.0310728755, -0.0364407226, -0.0007053959, 0.0042987387, -0.0029647304, -0.0136280954, 0.0991520062, 0.0172838848, 0.0167681053, 0.0298417229, -0.0313745774, 0.0150131378, -0.0147093898, -0.0377392173, -0.0146626402, -0.0151935769, 0.0058014169, 0.0565784872, -0.0608918965, -0.0607222021, 0.0224662442, -0.049777668, 0.0020757434, -0.0065443316, 0.0201957542, -0.0119011076, 0.0498987101, -0.0212025065, -0.0158305224, -0.0155234281, -0.0494695157, 0.0303469151, 0.0235242266, 0.0613086075, 0.0284945816, -0.012517876, 0.0127102127, 0.0096263317, 0.0027294783, 0.010516786, 0.0317413099, -0.0641490296, -0.0235692821, 0.0756838173, -0.0589901917, 0.0160273518, 0.0157838222, 0.0121851312, -0.0349755175, 0.0158954691, 0.0470441282, -0.0055561787, -0.0132103665, -0.019448895, 0.0120974798, -0.0424886681, -0.055127915, 0.0150018232, 0.0021697865, 0.0210601371, 0.0154003482, -0.0012793927, 0.0468864217, 0.0415387452, -0.0359794907, -0.0445869416, -0.0371286124, 0.0339119211, -0.0037378178, 0.0110191442, -0.0440674759, -0.0168157071, 0.0102613224, 0.0710602328, -0.0511250831, 0.0214363169, 0.073297359, -0.0021114384, 0.0058363443, 0.030006025, 0.0226868354, -0.0051086503, 0.0449218266, 0.0205910169, 0.0220545065, 0.0290074907, -0.0544176176, -0.0054910854, 0.0191828329, 0.0139842266, -0.0242483616, 0.0465209596, -0.0244769324, 0.0621301942, 0.0037172514, 0.0147332735, -0.0461308993, -0.0045182765, -0.0145382173, -0.0176445264, -0.0233858302, 0.0180325713, -0.0417725481, 0.0304323211, 0.0236285105, 0.0370492972, 0.0186907239, -0.0215866044, -0.0085810525, 0.0034824864, 0.0081762969, -0.0054592472, 0.0407428108, 0.0069611412, -0.0160414036, 0.0475457348, 0.0274456758, -0.051981926, 0.0106673809, -0.0292221885, -0.0122265872, -0.0914855376, 0.0172769353, -0.0552323572, 0.0237352438, -0.0365330689, 0.0082496945, 0.1036590189, 0.0190203823, 0.0117944032, -0.0415483378, 0.052254837, -0.0242919941, 0.0246002059, 0.0378961787, -0.1106087416, -0.0058839722, 0.0019702152, -0.0100085521, 0.0310220327, -0.093253836, -0.0051649986, -0.1180936247, 0.0016129481, -0.0233209338, -0.0140378298, -0.0611355938, -0.044568222, 0.0412976444, -0.0167955328, -0.001615654, 0.0033613527, -0.0286604222, 0.0105757629, -0.0228772517, 0.0135781644, -0.0569762699, -0.0095468275, -0.0932483375, 0.0324435122, 0.025616955, 0.0612030514, -0.0015868945, 0.0069427132, -0.0224263594, -0.0341455229, -0.0283707492, 0.0182645731, 0.0855418593, -0.0096155349, -0.0128075127, -0.0060321977, 0.0041830065, -0.0136335809, 0.0000164117, -0.0042774705, 0.033735428, 0.0251527503, -0.006609418, 0.0131599465, -0.0219396092, -0.0040352256, 0.0825838, 0.0127355969, 0.0284959469, 0.0044292882, -0.0184100289, 0.021937469, 0.0072437199, -0.0143426927, 0.0278766509, -0.0861840993, -0.0325268768, -0.076559864, -0.0889157802, 0.1197604835, -0.002958525, 0.0432810821, 0.025122419, 0.0106759481, 0.0056537166, -0.0525512137, 0.0063104839, -0.067685239, 0.0145242838, -0.0169753376, -0.0036164278, -0.0141886659, 0.0078696804, -0.0363274738, 0.0277440827, 0.0031180715, -0.0589227267, 0.0146453315, -0.0134649668, 0.0161889642, 0.0631837621, -0.0540395901, -0.0162741449, 0.0085242921, 0.0527091436, -0.0560333394, -0.0157590117, -0.0165275335, -0.0279849768, -0.0078018275, 0.0392066464, -0.0542976446, 0.0361896195, 0.0018754726, 0.0035816838, -0.0378134735, -0.061660096, 0.0448402762, 0.056099426, 0.0274419934, 0.0244128723, -0.0133592505, -0.0757214129, -0.012867691, -0.0160913765, -0.0314722285, -0.0075187031, 0.0101907989, -0.009497961, 0.0237414725, -0.0049302508, 0.0654359311, -0.0182497986, 0.0185941327, -0.0369812176, -0.0435307547, -0.0198361687, 0.032661777, 0.0561052114, -0.0200082175, 0.0139725227, 0.0345533416, 0.0505603477, 0.0527646653, -0.0351402611, -0.03314621, 0.0437549092, 0.0334080309, -0.0165631864, -0.0476532802, -0.0538542792, -0.0127250049, -0.009396147, 0.036424879, 0.0549528003, -0.0107506467, 0.0476309732, -0.0190207008, -0.0313355289, 0.0074633672, -0.0292475186, 0.0405512825, 0.0192515273, -0.0001561379, 0.0118010892, -0.0094135944, 0.0134082092, 0.0625220165, -0.0210993439, 0.0925500914, -0.0151580116, -0.0308366306, -0.039228864, -0.0444492586, -0.035450764, -0.0148774181, -0.0113718379, -0.0092876749, -0.0442917719, -0.061340373, 0.0048314282, -0.0212248415, -0.0600191168, -0.0026343442, 0.0092433924, 0.0347266905, 0.0603933558, 0.0122109298, -0.0109477285, 0.0139441602, 0.0004392453, -0.061390914, 0.0245751292, -5.584494848e-33, -0.0439709276, -0.0472027436, 0.0188411139, -0.0364810377, -0.0039604087, -0.0105381059, -0.0423696674, -0.0523683503, -0.0214817114, 0.0335127823, -0.0341318771, 0.0417406224, 0.0180801358, -0.0074144527, -0.0135559337, 0.0105521809, 0.0813832209, 0.0253010076, 0.0038784824, 0.0164618604, -0.0054632616, 0.0908689424, 0.0559009016, -0.0532524474, 0.0588631444, 0.0131135406, -0.0127106933, 0.0259120464, 0.0778009742, 0.021079056, -0.0150521025, -0.0086892499, 0.006843809, -0.0492145531, -0.027478883, -0.0155780092, -0.1789968163, 0.0052932231, -0.0115804775, 0.0329205543, 0.0045909341, -0.0276533104, 0.0624761693, -0.0444938689, 0.0389601402, 0.0268227067, 0.0535562895, -0.0427836664, 0.0035291698, -0.0358118303, -0.0436688811, 0.036933735, 0.0085614314, 0.0071249139, 0.0542711318, -0.0052041546, 0.0259099677, 0.003706933, -0.0574653409, 0.0280571152, 0.0684653595, -0.0058826152, 0.0027471997, -0.011494142, 0.0024060961, 0.0355798826, -0.0114765316, -0.0139264055, -0.0065965862, 0.0249191541, 0.0006209271, 0.0260609295, -0.0321975462, 0.0671860799, 0.0201433692, -0.029457964, -0.0476311781, 0.0856961384, -0.0151573187, -0.0010904109, -0.0558994412, -0.0144294705, -0.0076728459, -0.0167105515, -0.0135371471, 0.0113030709, -0.0395523012, -0.0246562026, 0.0052168518, 0.0223239642, -0.0617237575, 0.0437937342, -0.0184674859, -0.0528041311, -0.0700203553, 0.0227688625, 0.0519409291, 0.0051155416, 0.0176562145, 0.0011860917, -0.0201777779, 0.0225226693, 0.0400885306, -0.0010891131, -0.0039878902, 0.0091727236, 0.0152357845, -0.0479172133, -0.0649149939, 0.0198219065, 0.0051004589, 0.0550001524, -0.0126562845, -0.0173775572, -0.0003983314, 0.0351590738, 0.0330112576, 0.0051296516, 0.0949048474, 0.0030371824, -0.0424412414, 0.0551159121, 0.0381367728, 0.0308525339, -0.0026176262, -0.0207507201, -0.0314098187, -0.0182187762, 0.015033246, -0.0360450037, -0.0128924008, -0.0199867636, 2.417e-7, 0.0462135375, 0.0131407296, 0.0560151413, 0.031138273, -0.0283640455, 0.0081818225, 0.0147552341, -0.0030653293, -0.0257573873, 0.0034080413, 0.0164960083, -0.0104829958, -0.0133639798, 0.0156338904, -0.0817329288, -0.0337564126, 0.0121588307, -0.0553253144, -0.0649466515, -0.0245493092, -0.0229544472, 0.0220875647, 0.0121340854, -0.0352008119, -0.0319551788, -0.0471032523, 0.0235394686, -0.0057574743, -0.0153264729, 0.0783492103, 0.0438070521, 0.0313488878, -0.0003648927, 0.0517215356, -0.0003344954, 0.017147338, 0.0339225717, 0.0594804287, 0.0215443242, 0.0462430678, -0.0158774145, -0.0348059572, 0.0098159211, -0.0108302115, 0.089140676, -0.0373083241, 0.023441067, 0.0216173697, -0.0805855244, -0.0292542353, -0.030115623, 0.0109006912, -0.0176320393, 0.0163506661, -0.0086376593, 0.0187287685, -0.0002482377, -0.0638183132, 0.0265224129, 0.0173711609, 0.0041325074, -0.0207702499, 0.0122687723, -0.0763810724, 0.0187907871, -0.0547473244, 0.030076649, 2.103025745e-34, 0.0042082304, 0.0114855664, -0.0308164265, 0.0245583057, 0.0240055844, -0.0315660201, -0.052729059, 0.0112763969, -0.0105102668, -0.0244143382, 0.0108357742 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.04761v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.04761v2
NarrowBERT: Accelerating Masked Language Model Pretraining and Inference
2023-01-11T23:45:50
2023-06-05T23:47:43
Haoxin Li, Phillip Keung, Daniel Cheng, Jungo Kasai, Noah A. Smith
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.LG
Large-scale language model pretraining is a very successful form of self-supervised learning in natural language processing, but it is increasingly expensive to perform as the models and pretraining corpora have become larger over time. We propose NarrowBERT, a modified transformer encoder that increases the throughput for masked language model pretraining by more than $2\times$. NarrowBERT sparsifies the transformer model such that the self-attention queries and feedforward layers only operate on the masked tokens of each sentence during pretraining, rather than all of the tokens as with the usual transformer encoder. We also show that NarrowBERT increases the throughput at inference time by as much as $3.5\times$ with minimal (or no) performance degradation on sentence encoding tasks like MNLI. Finally, we examine the performance of NarrowBERT on the IMDB and Amazon reviews classification and CoNLL NER tasks and show that it is also comparable to standard BERT performance.
[ 0.0110846618, 0.0606471635, 0.0078127086, 0.067205973, -0.0197361875, 0.0091606192, 0.0407086574, 0.0118925832, 0.0046500545, -0.0604758225, -0.0457829684, 0.0044691083, -0.0408483148, 0.0351375155, 0.0083831297, -0.0132286912, 0.0230276417, -0.0207260177, -0.0141938524, -0.0095642423, -0.0078977356, 0.0303631201, -0.0033332547, 0.0170147102, 0.0020354006, -0.024947267, 0.0039091804, 0.0080567552, -0.0093362471, -0.0458698608, 0.0429334342, 0.0413305201, 0.0342124812, 0.0519988351, 0.0000021825, -0.0461931825, -0.0093700113, -0.0310036223, -0.0321656801, 0.0245439503, 0.0290151257, -0.0474007241, 0.0243995059, 0.0212749541, 0.0013958501, -0.0370820872, 0.0411505289, 0.0664321855, 0.0472792462, 0.0825729892, -0.0215081424, -0.0559383146, -0.004880867, -0.0306261238, -0.0340349749, -0.0288321357, 0.0026179268, -0.0750824809, -0.0369302779, 0.0199053865, -0.0204595961, 0.0624473989, 0.0394029133, -0.0042874399, 0.0333030075, 0.0409090817, -0.0391670354, -0.0202107709, -0.017424617, 0.056354735, -0.0438838564, -0.0392008573, -0.0375313088, 0.0162969921, -0.0136174448, 0.0121182427, 0.0072642481, -0.0018435289, 0.0254881382, 0.0024658223, -0.0030284119, 0.0516711622, 0.0201738812, -0.002497362, -0.066036582, 0.0461915545, 0.0310276654, -0.0307210274, 0.0126542076, 0.0151443686, 0.0052283704, -0.0398838483, 0.0398190133, 0.0143466732, 0.0259413533, -0.0146039836, -0.057648249, -0.0678983107, -0.0150991343, -0.0186878331, 0.0136300391, 0.0234735757, -0.0431221724, 0.0558944046, -0.0504282117, 0.0318853781, -0.0323805958, 0.0417717509, -0.0329808667, -0.0246986933, 0.0340894535, -0.0205145255, -0.1019398421, 0.0373073444, -0.0565572754, -0.0352783948, -0.0079914909, 0.0016166931, 0.0124624483, -0.0095179155, 0.0347345658, 0.0081379199, -0.0295592975, -0.0492605157, -0.0039503057, 0.0319657996, -0.0096415887, -0.0127981957, -0.0155173503, -0.0261552334, -0.0381566323, 0.0134872403, 0.0368120149, -0.0623237975, 0.042192027, 0.0486809127, -0.0217935797, -0.0649768189, -0.0034732898, 0.0263813529, -0.0209665317, -0.0243799295, 0.0049527306, -0.0236035157, 0.0405253433, 0.0213514641, 0.0096278246, -0.0097850142, -0.0018448298, 0.0132340305, -0.0084091313, 0.0943386629, -0.0026923839, -0.0375411585, 0.0250849016, 0.0104763107, -0.0024071736, 0.0442646481, 0.0033441123, 0.0494224951, 0.0302698519, -0.0354966633, 0.0215048008, 0.0533728302, 0.0278464388, 0.0022059965, -0.014946809, -0.0016932437, -0.044591289, -0.0097974138, 0.0476557165, 0.0383765511, -0.0118755121, -0.0489487313, 0.0498658568, 0.0460221767, 0.0315650403, 0.0387617759, 0.0177008901, 0.0423358232, 0.0108272173, -0.0110666445, -0.0156183103, 0.055878412, -0.0304103214, -0.0192947965, 0.0025307264, 0.0319523439, -0.055404108, -0.0155495601, 0.013997593, -0.024323605, 0.0122952135, 0.0112684779, 0.064200595, 0.0441934876, -0.0722724646, 0.0953444913, 0.030206183, -0.0352348611, -0.0049173888, -0.0551077425, -0.009571013, 0.0287104007, 0.0368585736, -0.0343109332, -0.0264962707, -0.0185935255, -0.0329235047, 0.0508568585, -0.0146977929, -0.0001368144, 0.0227188151, -0.0362876281, 0.012847784, -0.0372572988, 0.0109931445, 0.0498157702, -0.0043133474, 0.0227257647, 0.019456083, -0.0262217782, 0.037533395, 0.0407929681, -0.0159854237, -0.0729768127, 0.0042169685, 0.0242685545, 0.02606529, -0.0037529012, -0.0300430376, -0.0094973529, 0.0278829671, -0.0668932423, -0.0517197661, -0.0136860199, -0.0433375277, -0.0534111597, -0.0012546078, -0.0476561561, -0.0019898515, 0.129423663, -0.015023198, -0.0172720328, -0.0153971948, -0.0079007139, 0.0427659564, -0.0297430716, 0.0228231885, 0.0143274125, 0.0367907956, -0.0074208369, 0.0399305038, 0.0010481367, 0.009557806, -0.0099649932, -0.0068475166, 0.0198839866, 0.0068180882, -0.0533507578, -0.0101225711, -0.0018207643, 0.0028443597, 0.0466719791, -0.0073968996, 0.003108447, -0.0247269981, -0.0789531693, -0.0225615669, -0.0425683223, -0.0111684063, 0.019601807, 0.0414052457, -0.0104338573, -0.0223561041, 0.0019522093, -0.0432979241, -0.0316543058, 0.0091575878, 0.0111924866, -0.0061989655, -0.0025750976, 0.0028336612, -0.0287058037, 0.0027581819, 0.0593905933, -0.0061271358, -0.0310755651, -0.0427617393, -0.014452857, 0.029789662, 0.0337312557, -0.0076859095, -0.0550315604, -0.0246799085, -0.0088344906, 0.0043672128, 0.0484586805, 0.0358056016, 0.0262578931, 0.0265034158, 0.0200139303, -0.0348001197, 0.0283527952, -0.0260104798, -0.0271171574, -0.0423397906, 0.0079789823, 0.0326222442, 0.0899626762, -0.038136851, -0.0027376944, -0.0490011871, -0.0156473387, 0.0022346212, -0.023794556, -0.0260577668, -0.0039168089, -0.0173374675, 0.0117674954, -0.0018280654, -0.0053747636, 0.0523472577, -0.05173897, -0.0280022062, -0.0670470297, -0.0044868342, -0.0221870393, 0.0440578274, 0.0374537259, 0.036960762, 0.0097442921, -0.0560942404, -0.0030227033, 0.0431900956, 0.0019541807, 0.0045239059, 0.0184502397, 0.0297011882, 0.0166800357, -0.0011810763, -0.0462777801, -0.0410073362, -0.0825800896, -0.0288794432, -0.0199990235, 0.0610470995, -0.0254828967, -0.0330000222, 0.011400898, -0.0175324008, 0.0805002004, 0.0008173127, -0.0080684638, -0.0129421335, 0.0509166829, 0.0412221812, -0.0027420716, 0.0130956024, -0.0193618871, 0.0264553837, 0.0631248504, 0.0146136573, -0.0016443804, -0.0465405136, -0.0173838828, 0.0586868636, -0.0490496755, 0.0387637578, -0.0226632655, 0.0536230356, -0.0518417247, -0.0090476591, 0.1609952301, 0.0069516972, -0.0392285958, -0.0169988647, 0.0099383397, -0.0024936667, 0.0146589763, 0.02279686, -0.0803445801, -0.0362203382, -0.0068445602, 0.0133364154, 0.0261108968, -0.0062960456, 0.0054149805, -0.1184220836, 0.041722998, -0.0177422799, -0.013644333, -0.0223862492, -0.0507188328, -0.0316243693, -0.0191769134, 0.0098403543, -0.0121476315, 0.0071547874, -0.0287661832, -0.006415931, -0.0056192842, -0.0304866061, 0.0396137387, -0.0311785154, -0.0000505107, -0.008846934, -0.000638867, -0.028466532, -0.0627750158, 0.0435471237, -0.0484908484, -0.0190063454, -0.0069960887, 0.0939406753, -0.0592520125, -0.0323599875, -0.0006855287, 0.0253464617, -0.0182251632, -0.0126975738, -0.0308777373, 0.0294296574, 0.0000183827, -0.0119275516, -0.0089645591, 0.001430681, -0.0379262865, 0.080421038, -0.0057431534, -0.0493519679, -0.0139082056, 0.001003179, 0.0002270688, -0.0517608337, -0.045600079, 0.0187633391, -0.0184553955, -0.0394500606, -0.0380109362, -0.0303261373, 0.0097249383, 0.0627748966, -0.0078093577, -0.0433805771, 0.0434688367, 0.008126758, -0.0511193015, 0.0409177318, -0.030847393, -0.0271619074, -0.0400408916, -0.0195641238, 0.0440281704, 0.0189006906, -0.0191027485, -0.0036090286, -0.06010966, -0.0376328193, 0.0075336564, 0.0522409715, 0.015959153, 0.0536125414, -0.0241813473, -0.035365779, 0.0717419162, 0.0106207114, -0.0796401054, 0.0012911268, 0.0480827168, -0.0527795032, -0.0204414483, 0.0387416482, -0.0271138884, 0.0497379042, -0.0017082512, 0.0151048023, -0.0304097757, -0.0345280282, 0.0207567792, 0.0070830504, 0.0892689154, -0.0285252556, 0.060604617, -0.0260952469, 0.0468891151, -0.0360741839, -0.007529038, -0.0415191613, -0.0091834199, 0.0419474468, -0.0151654519, -0.0349457189, 0.0601230189, -0.0067279423, -0.0129911015, -0.0608834401, 0.0134902019, -0.0161233209, 0.0101071484, 0.009740727, 0.0043018488, -0.0164272171, -0.0186471995, 0.0461361445, 0.0289061256, -0.0232321955, 0.0365259089, 0.0420234129, 0.0113603277, -0.0528882965, 0.0473385081, -0.0491744913, -0.0095834518, -0.0258402918, -0.0139828864, 0.0341117121, -0.0645502955, 0.0260013137, -0.015662916, -0.030220367, 0.0035016329, 0.0194199178, -0.0095019564, -0.0060506943, 0.0145467091, -0.0066727721, -0.018725818, 0.0260365196, 0.0707895309, 0.0027044564, 0.0206336211, 0.069602035, -0.0250635743, -0.0439858995, 0.0054071597, 0.0270937253, 0.0284293871, 0.0060039936, 0.0269886479, 0.000704069, -0.0607757494, 0.045568686, -0.0398448631, 0.0095725143, 0.0060903574, 0.0567475855, 0.0381857939, 0.0177009664, -0.0316191651, -0.00987719, 0.0324967839, 0.037154898, -0.0129919676, 0.0212115161, -7.173225789e-33, -0.0175809748, 0.0004701585, -0.0137196342, 0.0056114206, -0.0084451055, 0.0251340531, -0.0049627004, -0.0149308769, 0.0010883496, 0.0227204915, -0.0160392839, 0.0249342192, 0.0174579006, 0.0531275384, -0.0135806389, -0.0296897013, 0.0830725804, -0.0027988318, -0.0385877602, -0.0146970004, -0.0009235304, 0.0676115006, 0.0440436006, -0.0668652505, -0.0539620146, -0.0095789265, 0.001883153, -0.0026133286, 0.0485143214, 0.029514432, -0.0291828942, 0.0372193493, 0.0033798672, -0.086657092, 0.0044677593, 0.0302484464, -0.121538803, -0.0072035985, -0.0209947675, 0.0406632684, -0.023975892, -0.0060583204, 0.0223277565, 0.0229922608, 0.0006217374, -0.0379720218, 0.0239544306, 0.0043261372, 0.0259347316, -0.0551162884, -0.0478833616, 0.0110654626, -0.0100580826, -0.0263348185, 0.064157322, 0.0472352766, 0.01557157, 0.0232949015, -0.0874906257, -0.0308884606, -0.0085541354, 0.0395916738, 0.0390111394, 0.0235530268, -0.0184810143, 0.0349112079, 0.0284034181, -0.0154285096, -0.0209844466, 0.0392450131, 0.0465354398, 0.0278724488, 0.0551435202, -0.0085610058, 0.0571755767, -0.0071112472, -0.0820104778, 0.0239088517, -0.0650832132, 0.0271649491, 0.0371960066, 0.0202598199, -0.0092360042, -0.0081066675, -0.0108440658, -0.0017677093, -0.032185521, 0.0119666988, 0.0166726764, 0.0302298535, -0.0401080512, 0.0395623818, 0.0418637395, -0.0314465538, -0.0091678659, -0.0033936319, -0.0011197001, 0.0086433478, -0.0040909825, 0.053525541, -0.0336871445, 0.0054857889, 0.0112011442, 0.0158800762, 0.0157375708, 0.0151431514, 0.0518429205, 0.0409956425, -0.1002033427, -0.0195733663, -0.0174581874, -0.0009387486, -0.0032788154, 0.0518452302, 0.0081270561, 0.0348288342, -0.0153470216, 0.050788153, -0.0024451311, -0.0006405694, -0.0284062605, 0.0396992303, 0.0468889102, 0.0102864141, -0.0215706471, -0.0067135277, -0.0172951054, 0.0253316239, 0.04130188, -0.1017745137, -0.032912083, -0.0162126459, 2.876e-7, 0.053487163, 0.0472003631, 0.0100161564, 0.009191717, 0.0011611509, 0.0362461321, 0.029396588, 0.0723674744, 0.0263930317, -0.0024112463, 0.0074849753, 0.023444362, 0.0148119172, 0.0092256637, -0.0781879723, -0.0418117195, -0.0446929112, 0.0241766386, -0.0260769408, -0.0058975834, 0.0398986302, 0.1129300073, 0.0155072892, 0.0017322162, 0.0087228389, -0.0692231804, 0.0658742115, 0.000207799, -0.016815085, 0.014597551, 0.061174985, 0.0557123907, -0.0165140238, 0.0027486002, -0.039916832, 0.0415900052, 0.0081961527, 0.047066018, -0.0247916188, -0.0492859408, 0.0158923082, 0.0067037358, -0.031060338, -0.0414904989, 0.0777706876, -0.0708863288, -0.0313466266, -0.022471888, -0.0433417223, 0.0043622949, 0.0107224565, -0.0232333895, -0.0153252194, 0.0270226263, 0.0724804178, -0.0117146187, -0.0233600363, -0.1139343306, -0.0106352614, 0.0140048312, -0.0432352833, -0.0043486874, -0.0387233496, -0.0451087691, 0.0312745385, -0.0484867133, 0.0182181634, 2.808807476e-34, 0.028749736, 0.0064033996, -0.0092483377, 0.0377603211, 0.016659556, -0.0488255359, 0.0253464244, -0.0144839399, 0.00216446, -0.0767702907, -0.0076118214 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.04752v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.04752v1
Semantic Web Enabled Geographic Question Answering Framework: GeoTR
2023-01-11T23:20:43
2023-01-11T23:20:43
Ceren Ocal Tasar, Murat Komesli, Murat Osman Unalir
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI
With the considerable growth of linked data, researchers have focused on how to increase the availability of semantic web technologies to provide practical usages for real life systems. Question answering systems are an example of real-life systems that communicate directly with end users, understand user intention and generate answers. End users do not care about the structural query language or the vocabulary of the knowledge base where the point of a problem arises. In this study, a question answering framework that converts Turkish natural language input into SPARQL queries in the geographical domain is proposed. Additionally, a novel Turkish ontology, which covers a 10th grade geography lesson named Spatial Synthesis Turkey, has been developed to be used as a linked data provider. Moreover, a gap in the literature on Turkish question answering systems, which utilizes linked data in the geographical domain, is addressed. A hybrid system architecture that combines natural language processing techniques with linked data technologies to generate answers is also proposed. Further related research areas are suggested.
[ 0.0643463731, -0.0276103374, -0.0390849598, 0.0027657587, -0.0139529696, 0.0104146153, 0.0253791064, -0.0131567474, 0.0341428109, -0.0529376753, -0.0066096075, 0.0280709043, 0.0077244365, 0.0019997063, -0.021900855, -0.0821466222, 0.0170858018, -0.0556760691, -0.0245030634, 0.0042670267, -0.0140296724, 0.0635172874, -0.0121246958, 0.0167882349, -0.0025135856, 0.0250185467, -0.004339647, -0.0330348276, 0.0008882489, -0.0415070355, 0.0175924655, 0.0140105924, -0.0034185508, -0.0137047032, 0.0000018868, -0.025553884, -0.0236994717, 0.0279235933, 0.0116085168, -0.0453953333, -0.0136541445, 0.0280459914, 0.019418573, 0.0015593447, -0.0361276604, -0.0200878847, 0.0305259041, 0.0248355679, 0.0572071113, 0.0003640993, -0.0001876081, -0.0804063529, -0.0026195939, 0.0658756867, 0.003280346, 0.0261754952, -0.0186989736, 0.0021243992, 0.0483116359, 0.0484160446, 0.0405816957, 0.0153770009, -0.0322736688, 0.0392735153, -0.0516893491, -0.0063974098, -0.0864453539, 0.0140414778, 0.0221919995, 0.0021183614, 0.073898308, -0.0027535628, 0.0305525046, 0.0183706544, -0.0337038487, 0.0636095852, -0.0350721627, -0.0183251314, -0.0522052161, 0.0242030602, -0.0108757894, -0.0035287961, -0.0131744165, 0.0302939154, -0.0102899475, 0.1033929586, 0.0065836287, 0.0002529288, -0.0551626645, -0.011670446, 0.0725622475, -0.0396047197, -0.005396761, 0.0834316313, 0.0004234144, 0.0365395993, -0.0001628524, 0.0395168364, 0.0354791395, -0.0550764203, -0.0173253976, 0.0087918974, 0.0142106945, 0.0388614684, 0.0031273533, -0.0006095879, 0.0167318098, 0.0099934116, 0.0038584222, -0.0819530264, -0.0783548728, -0.0336957127, -0.0482021123, 0.0611383803, -0.0161806997, 0.0514281355, 0.0184081066, 0.0411850587, 0.0082985824, 0.0296842922, -0.007971216, 0.0240118802, 0.013400211, -0.0185960494, -0.0767523721, 0.0086483778, -0.0128385145, -0.0410340577, -0.0409393646, -0.041503422, 0.071452342, 0.0196859576, 0.0434166603, 0.0191062875, -0.0202747993, 0.0278306101, 0.0406593718, -0.0096822698, -0.0822188854, -0.0485990718, 0.0169803407, -0.0030291628, 0.0164068788, -0.0757289976, -0.0168354176, 0.0318450518, -0.0404699594, -0.0233889986, 0.0011411889, 0.0638618842, -0.0607261732, 0.0484699979, -0.0564745478, -0.0134302806, 0.0859491825, -0.0203882884, 0.0793170854, 0.0643830225, -0.003073331, 0.0201905034, 0.0619229078, 0.027695341, -0.0257103462, -0.0484766364, -0.000413724, -0.014701291, -0.0022783384, 0.0771789774, -0.0741048306, 0.0208509285, -0.0754205212, 0.0226585902, 0.00033439, 0.0411699601, 0.0230945796, 0.0634867176, 0.0293161739, 0.010301711, 0.0158608854, 0.0602804795, -0.0140670016, -0.0034459999, -0.0272988621, 0.0219081528, -0.0088335741, 0.0086832158, -0.0084082279, 0.0445304923, -0.0147388866, -0.049185846, -0.0277748033, 0.0313382111, 0.0044392049, 0.0095708501, 0.0664203092, -0.0446155518, 0.0130394148, 0.0886493996, 0.0090840152, 0.0157897696, 0.0400896184, -0.0201982316, 0.0310202446, 0.0260528885, 0.0130845048, -0.0388528928, -0.0317827687, -0.0151626095, 0.0002263208, 0.0453548729, 0.0102165546, 0.0014369587, -0.0493859686, -0.0061238497, -0.0395475328, 0.0191929936, 0.0073705511, -0.0331745706, 0.0199159682, 0.0760926902, 0.0363384709, -0.0487824976, 0.0632509664, -0.0072782305, 0.0518523827, 0.0250435565, -0.0463886075, 0.0482559986, -0.0486736409, 0.0414864048, 0.0198371541, 0.0337777697, -0.0024215286, 0.0067857224, -0.0397793725, -0.0251904596, 0.0170808882, 0.0177404415, 0.0182540622, -0.0501630642, 0.0263668336, 0.0267526135, -0.0147177214, -0.039201241, 0.0061950977, -0.0155904563, 0.0445331223, -0.0075422172, -0.0072192797, 0.0269841086, 0.0044829426, -0.0679215342, 0.0070630061, 0.0096717309, 0.0267973542, -0.0219040364, -0.0317967832, 0.0664105937, -0.0121833347, 0.0278261825, 0.0006138892, -0.0259758532, -0.0008768234, -0.0070539615, 0.0042010173, -0.0243164506, 0.0264297519, -0.0197701287, -0.0100087048, -0.0104748299, 0.0510028116, 0.0206092577, 0.0171845928, -0.0049410565, -0.0398396738, -0.0349591263, 0.0106391786, 0.0131445546, 0.0125217121, 0.0297107454, -0.0146354213, 0.0139014004, 0.0220927168, 0.0143337958, 0.0001423967, 0.0125449961, 0.0183382053, -0.0423345342, -0.0140736587, -0.0255663805, -0.0837098807, 0.0270092357, 0.0436294563, 0.0070313844, 0.0315571278, -0.0204926133, -0.0260733534, -0.0311920717, 0.003739293, -0.0474469885, -0.0046766074, -0.0430838317, -0.0256417282, -0.0033443072, -0.0286852252, 0.0394066237, -0.0192622468, -0.0035528876, 0.0394549035, -0.0127675608, 0.0226119068, -0.0016078354, 0.0221738592, 0.0410746932, -0.053529717, 0.0447721258, -0.0652194396, 0.0398258939, 0.0252678078, 0.1015013382, 0.0177724231, -0.0252562743, 0.0015291543, 0.007823783, 0.0442173705, -0.0258222595, 0.001321141, -0.0581826903, 0.0535198227, -0.0429738984, 0.0296338089, -0.019583635, -0.0343479775, 0.0029480436, -0.0572051108, 0.0109040597, -0.0139919342, -0.0168601852, -0.0371423103, -0.0062668226, -0.0401710793, 0.001567616, -0.0289083943, 0.0432392955, -0.0225788206, 0.0248103924, 0.0103261629, 0.0135808885, 0.0619518682, 0.048430942, -0.009612388, 0.0314732715, 0.0042928634, -0.0148802409, 0.0011198936, 0.0778146163, 0.0449330658, 0.040813297, -0.0399590656, 0.1178709567, -0.0178862344, 0.0517573245, -0.0567678586, -0.0443353131, 0.0233424716, 0.0026902705, 0.0609468445, -0.0752095878, -0.0481309146, -0.0097390348, -0.0308680218, -0.0714416429, -0.0228500962, 0.0397655442, 0.0763022304, 0.0557874702, -0.0347694717, -0.0418697298, -0.0403433815, 0.0095407944, 0.0504827425, -0.0592883341, 0.0095929084, -0.0345302224, -0.032060653, -0.0058276881, -0.0213048272, 0.021634724, -0.0716076866, 0.0557906367, -0.0602978766, -0.1195860952, -0.0291151665, -0.0593610816, -0.0423284844, 0.0355282351, -0.055829037, -0.0213930346, -0.0028982644, 0.0278816652, 0.0289569981, -0.0840549469, 0.0075813262, -0.0220893063, -0.0273957513, 0.0134269865, -0.0148655176, 0.0798677132, 0.0035833376, -0.0560243875, -0.0460737012, 0.018282989, 0.0033165326, -0.0573317073, 0.0228197593, 0.0008579912, -0.0247646719, -0.0555048287, -0.0438429751, -0.0246387981, 0.0347404331, -0.0043120044, 0.0790435299, -0.0222937614, 0.0872870013, -0.0317607746, 0.0183664113, 0.019591324, -0.0076211318, -0.0493459813, 0.0485001355, -0.0534195676, -0.0162392966, -0.051444307, -0.0303897057, -0.0173387881, 0.0776545331, -0.0118190711, -0.0220269915, -0.034294311, -0.0178381819, 0.0345294401, -0.0098396474, -0.0291343629, 0.0142305857, 0.032800898, 0.0144958869, -0.063979879, -0.0264919698, -0.0388241783, 0.0139869517, -0.0295689702, 0.0021646551, 0.0335942842, -0.0444861725, -0.008524741, -0.0058078575, -0.0076058595, 0.0018968725, 0.0140306726, 0.0187417623, 0.0063050995, -0.0517567992, -0.0056039491, -0.0237315409, 0.0575611666, -0.0270001367, -0.0667255744, -0.0510126576, -0.0298769027, 0.0538076498, 0.0045656948, -0.0034908049, -0.0000398667, -0.0018777067, -0.0083051156, -0.0330873281, -0.0244951993, -0.0307438336, 0.0151879564, 0.0199400391, 0.032929346, 0.0090366611, 0.0172706414, 0.0264228266, 0.0307498481, -0.0107959332, -0.0123896264, 0.0038905779, -0.0013430021, -0.0446184389, -0.0032153854, -0.0014738872, -0.0116005084, -0.0399217866, -0.02195655, 0.000461351, 0.0069510904, 0.0364281572, 0.0120900758, -0.0282701347, 0.0429795273, -0.0338946916, -0.0045823208, -0.0375098661, 0.0249232147, -0.0244026836, 0.0306683388, -0.0192072429, -0.0006195706, -0.0055162511, 0.0251167435, -0.0254988521, -0.0996728837, 0.0059486702, 0.0184980184, 0.0097299414, 0.0309226457, -0.0265819412, 0.0062815091, 0.0053594545, 0.0370320752, -0.0162767153, 0.0202058461, -0.0555838011, 0.0473118797, -0.0176038705, -0.0083750496, -0.0014999342, 0.042097412, 0.0065387944, -0.0150354384, 0.0095943213, -0.0891664773, -0.006746646, -0.0022338599, 0.0544899516, 0.0302823931, -0.0328908153, -0.0182985831, -0.0304897036, -0.0642030314, -0.0217806399, 0.0347285643, -0.030423224, 0.0151165277, 0.0687173232, 0.0160761382, 0.0483267978, -0.043060597, -0.0576247685, 0.0330888294, -0.0640981942, 0.0043092947, -0.0023063889, -5.636370149e-33, -0.0311137661, -0.029967336, 0.0697000921, 0.0317078084, -0.000343936, -0.0560249612, 0.0386361778, -0.0081997691, -0.0297044497, -0.0138096148, -0.0156439152, -0.0010124756, 0.0144077064, 0.0315330252, -0.0224651657, -0.0444552414, -0.0143037913, -0.0033197955, 0.0272562783, -0.0044391393, 0.1185234189, -0.0186704118, 0.0620249398, -0.0109913135, -0.0113521954, -0.0113642383, -0.0095815947, 0.0309546366, 0.0166802499, 0.066622518, -0.0185149219, 0.0726135522, 0.0416651554, -0.0300845876, -0.006220073, 0.0210151728, -0.0846029595, -0.0580052286, -0.0024278038, 0.0354944058, -0.0086101517, 0.0163411722, 0.0172876325, 0.0027435462, 0.05820195, 0.041152373, 0.0470967256, 0.0037806507, -0.0495669805, -0.0376057662, -0.0636122078, 0.0432686694, -0.0021648456, 0.027923746, -0.0190749336, 0.0253050793, 0.0198177174, -0.0088135507, -0.017934788, 0.014331189, 0.0150528569, -0.0018546693, 0.0331568383, 0.0277583394, -0.0120362649, -0.0251537543, -0.0043922625, -0.0442675948, -0.0215381533, 0.0314721018, 0.0066587832, 0.0119276606, 0.0031422875, 0.0409363508, -0.0414283164, 0.0083593251, -0.0345982462, 0.0416089818, -0.0576689281, 0.0424659736, -0.0611700118, -0.027829444, -0.0218109265, -0.0300854538, -0.0146894287, 0.0466982536, -0.0264560468, -0.0290147625, 0.0498177595, -0.033160463, -0.0069902092, 0.0388990268, -0.0436477624, -0.0092753423, 0.0044700759, -0.0144949025, 0.0533584766, -0.0365833379, -0.0373887308, 0.0295683462, -0.0052103964, 0.0038590604, -0.0258841217, -0.0240144171, -0.0380296819, 0.0357489474, -0.0528051965, 0.0008434407, -0.0665563345, 0.0275419876, 0.000317051, 0.0022947572, -0.0156207336, -0.0072813556, 0.0152438097, -0.0257445574, -0.0052738884, 0.0105347764, 0.0257159472, -0.0200856272, -0.0145919155, -0.0497507714, -0.0201074388, -0.0086898301, 0.0203649718, 0.0236919317, -0.0140126562, 0.002521029, 0.0090516843, -0.0102585573, 0.0219903346, -0.0071462244, 2.52e-7, 0.0381914712, 0.0056348844, -0.0322515853, 0.0203681625, -0.0088077392, -0.0323870927, 0.0849586874, 0.0136437817, -0.0079760365, 0.0713949651, 0.0171365999, -0.0304784682, -0.0121762576, 0.0596536845, -0.0922006816, 0.0152427545, 0.0328789316, -0.0450598523, -0.0478156134, 0.0294928923, 0.073328875, -0.024555549, 0.0060844356, -0.0202540997, -0.0569505021, 0.0157333892, -0.0193748362, -0.0088431397, -0.0083854543, 0.0245291963, 0.0471299477, -0.0076349117, 0.0373350345, 0.0045684627, -0.0179953445, 0.0045934296, 0.0223173741, -0.0108361971, -0.007673305, 0.009305465, -0.007985807, -0.1214192435, 0.0127050448, -0.0729252249, 0.0676191077, -0.0368762501, 0.0139791248, 0.0555227809, 0.0130337505, -0.013315971, -0.026650114, -0.0144427922, -0.0414051674, -0.0109285312, 0.0216548387, -0.0000432824, 0.0468889326, -0.0304443613, 0.0586343221, 0.002815607, 0.0008584317, -0.0053977487, -0.0246684626, 0.0106600793, 0.0121353343, 0.0241166595, -0.0233358685, 1.592008619e-34, -0.0489927232, 0.0502049848, -0.0156868491, -0.0164641421, 0.0203793012, 0.0240574908, 0.0299805123, -0.0046476433, 0.0470143855, -0.0175144579, 0.0187380258 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.04704v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.04704v1
SensePOLAR: Word sense aware interpretability for pre-trained contextual word embeddings
2023-01-11T20:25:53
2023-01-11T20:25:53
Jan Engler, Sandipan Sikdar, Marlene Lutz, Markus Strohmaier
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.LG
Adding interpretability to word embeddings represents an area of active research in text representation. Recent work has explored thepotential of embedding words via so-called polar dimensions (e.g. good vs. bad, correct vs. wrong). Examples of such recent approaches include SemAxis, POLAR, FrameAxis, and BiImp. Although these approaches provide interpretable dimensions for words, they have not been designed to deal with polysemy, i.e. they can not easily distinguish between different senses of words. To address this limitation, we present SensePOLAR, an extension of the original POLAR framework that enables word-sense aware interpretability for pre-trained contextual word embeddings. The resulting interpretable word embeddings achieve a level of performance that is comparable to original contextual word embeddings across a variety of natural language processing tasks including the GLUE and SQuAD benchmarks. Our work removes a fundamental limitation of existing approaches by offering users sense aware interpretations for contextual word embeddings.
[ -0.0146603864, -0.0105233705, -0.0104337493, 0.0673564449, 0.0121376365, -0.0039770599, -0.0030217413, 0.0005713969, 0.0079883486, -0.0189085659, -0.0263783131, 0.009301506, -0.0048614121, 0.0794871151, -0.007633009, -0.0398995802, 0.0602001995, 0.0355070718, -0.005563247, 0.0310030039, 0.0304573514, 0.0208262932, -0.015529382, 0.0530241989, -0.0181211419, -0.0166285932, -0.0046164333, -0.0146970628, 0.010523688, -0.0454831868, -0.0226635654, 0.0173240043, 0.0610335097, 0.0477024913, 0.0000018887, 0.0041864165, -0.0367251113, -0.0015633673, -0.011139255, -0.0166993216, 0.077980347, -0.0657114089, 0.0310439896, -0.0352853648, -0.0287137292, 0.0074332436, 0.0324806608, 0.0083468063, 0.0542163588, 0.0288329311, -0.0011806528, -0.01861603, -0.0241031367, -0.0027624713, 0.0189450588, -0.0288813841, -0.0394159704, -0.0063217571, -0.0149200987, 0.0260357969, -0.0898261741, 0.0091611044, 0.0318858176, 0.0221992321, 0.005878564, -0.0059743677, 0.0596159175, -0.0067519713, 0.0008136898, 0.0852587372, -0.0289986841, 0.002643333, -0.0382396355, -0.0280854404, -0.0438318476, -0.0137474518, 0.0138750626, -0.0323058888, 0.0156966802, 0.0407546051, 0.0168572925, 0.0947676525, 0.0641207919, 0.0063995854, -0.031534113, 0.0758117884, 0.0037071547, 0.0028503002, -0.0063059391, -0.0034085861, 0.0022525452, 0.0571280085, 0.039219588, -0.0095672458, -0.030446684, 0.0533740856, -0.0346731357, 0.0201307219, 0.0093854042, -0.0618411005, -0.0061248206, 0.0262271594, 0.0040118909, 0.0617920235, -0.0042985794, -0.0167228598, -0.0110835573, 0.0464071706, -0.0338434838, -0.0376733392, -0.0266180634, -0.0065877791, -0.0092577767, 0.0003444176, -0.0518887751, -0.0547765456, -0.0494452938, 0.0196882766, -0.0473338589, -0.0355692767, -0.0037291774, 0.0270692427, -0.0100985905, -0.034843266, -0.0165071543, 0.0392493382, -0.0450360365, 0.0188899003, -0.0524396561, 0.0035497702, 0.0002993126, 0.0257811751, 0.0113267526, -0.0259128958, -0.031654492, 0.0103333853, 0.0405416526, -0.0630757287, -0.0316972658, -0.0541008525, -0.0347368605, -0.0025590374, -0.0564649031, -0.0320253037, 0.0305221844, 0.0030458984, 0.0075459923, -0.0872088894, -0.0294656362, -0.0116620297, -0.0195833258, 0.127372086, -0.0232306328, -0.0240106732, -0.0589748174, 0.0331465751, 0.0291077401, 0.0670956969, 0.0328455046, 0.0214590169, 0.0527710803, -0.0146054784, -0.0267981905, -0.0118968822, 0.0338112153, -0.0049473303, -0.0217195563, -0.0127002737, -0.0291428119, 0.0512762442, 0.031757012, 0.0170129389, -0.0161767993, -0.0380132049, 0.0110638384, 0.0448700674, 0.0431494303, -0.0440871902, 0.0735069141, 0.0134299584, -0.0512152091, -0.033740893, -0.048185721, 0.0200731289, -0.0029776241, -0.0293835383, 0.0115441568, -0.011550216, 0.0008076746, -0.0254231263, -0.0032144233, -0.0251175947, 0.0357806124, -0.0219426081, 0.0381393172, 0.0041044797, -0.0379790328, 0.0193579979, 0.0223411135, -0.0644659847, 0.0435407236, -0.0029884498, 0.0601785816, 0.0850209892, 0.0486579277, -0.041755911, -0.0057102647, 0.0176518671, -0.0055582542, 0.0375227854, 0.0146509185, 0.0024676993, 0.0597823896, -0.0415821411, -0.0321526453, 0.020858977, 0.0155521603, 0.0089749433, -0.025361754, 0.0184847638, 0.0214408319, -0.0465382114, -0.0093513075, 0.044636827, -0.0111596975, -0.0218052324, -0.0256756507, 0.0264299884, 0.0057429899, 0.056144584, 0.0191695616, 0.0143624088, 0.0328672826, -0.0265962612, -0.0196398497, 0.0305292811, -0.0865943804, -0.0485091358, -0.0137751885, -0.0566487387, -0.0073538637, -0.0123994052, -0.0323821492, -0.0104232468, 0.0358138084, -0.0111719426, 0.0410326645, -0.0379612222, -0.0397700816, 0.0048399661, 0.0245447624, -0.0109588299, 0.0284096599, -0.0383189209, 0.0192060955, -0.0208081901, 0.0567758866, 0.0252368394, 0.0182589032, -0.0568315946, 0.012407748, 0.0467528254, -0.0067923265, 0.0059777121, -0.0180792157, -0.0540420115, 0.0025048531, -0.0408583209, -0.0176581331, -0.0178779084, 0.0044155363, 0.034397684, 0.0174602456, 0.0258309953, -0.0301984157, -0.003060027, 0.0172630362, -0.0024222613, 0.0269452631, 0.0338171721, -0.0190781225, -0.0056708697, -0.0242732633, -0.0170967132, -0.0184747763, 0.0594105907, -0.0093622552, 0.0342521854, -0.0141200116, -0.0056284443, 0.0103916368, -0.0126233147, -0.0008082653, -0.0271601733, 0.0088541508, -0.0259612855, 0.004835532, 0.0128548238, 0.0022331423, 0.0993630886, 0.0249143504, 0.013622554, -0.0423209965, -0.0256428216, -0.0472957306, 0.0527291782, -0.0228803605, -0.0289559383, 0.0065595494, 0.0581377894, 0.0074821147, -0.0079000676, -0.0660747886, 0.0271370877, -0.0662653595, -0.0455207154, -0.0279983059, 0.0103956833, -0.0282095857, 0.0275175925, -0.016210366, -0.0339981541, 0.0488235131, -0.0157991499, -0.0229393225, -0.0329537578, -0.0031848182, -0.0442540385, 0.1044510901, -0.0113355266, 0.009612265, -0.0712841228, -0.0146759599, -0.016520232, -0.0139637263, 0.0157123283, -0.0363766402, 0.0295339655, -0.0065409201, -0.0211872887, 0.0125176515, 0.010535853, -0.0275706053, -0.0326803923, -0.0324725658, 0.0116680516, 0.0399519131, -0.0113385385, 0.0010351067, -0.0137025546, 0.0067804256, -0.0229706783, 0.0180082396, -0.0148692448, -0.0112522934, -0.0008568004, 0.026334988, 0.0281433836, 0.024136709, 0.0139608849, -0.0010069668, 0.0457256213, -0.0563512444, -0.0704796463, -0.0518663302, 0.0038479171, 0.0135996882, -0.0190378595, 0.0163672138, -0.0186574832, 0.0590283349, -0.0598876588, 0.0031542196, 0.0936793461, 0.0445548892, -0.0430537723, 0.0405032896, 0.0121692969, -0.016959792, 0.0273587368, -0.019276822, -0.0361850299, -0.0628459901, -0.0329396054, 0.0297357179, 0.0254652929, -0.0401336402, -0.023532236, -0.0535504408, -0.0286014006, -0.0013436017, -0.0327334739, -0.059203133, -0.0046930066, -0.0197516829, -0.0282894615, 0.009368469, 0.0115307439, 0.0061484994, 0.036688108, -0.0066665742, -0.0175228007, 0.0074523948, 0.0099044675, -0.0390193723, 0.0321666673, 0.0267193317, 0.0367832817, 0.006069507, -0.0678200051, -0.0530036464, -0.0582284406, -0.0078514768, -0.0295893345, 0.0313502587, -0.025381403, 0.0014455295, -0.0186582394, -0.0038421212, -0.046708528, -0.0468149558, -0.0236756708, 0.0711746663, -0.016776707, -0.0071390313, -0.052311603, 0.0173816998, 0.0300466102, 0.0862026811, 0.0388261527, -0.0207903031, -0.0279641021, -0.0184558257, 0.0133174313, -0.0525675677, -0.0489303097, -0.0139632439, 0.0058338325, 0.0491416119, -0.0455472022, -0.0722364411, 0.0085809426, 0.0705517456, -0.011348377, 0.0053452225, -0.0226623565, -0.0179609209, -0.0581969991, 0.0115925465, 0.0332961753, 0.0322278626, -0.0127351182, 0.0168840792, 0.0321068168, -0.0069757146, -0.0228063185, 0.0159854554, 0.0200514551, 0.0104415081, 0.0358867459, 0.0397050418, 0.016969258, 0.0084119095, -0.0572190061, -0.0348406136, 0.0051773037, 0.0522246026, -0.0471412912, 0.010082081, 0.0537239574, 0.0729105249, 0.0063537806, 0.0653943196, -0.0223878026, 0.0282843858, -0.0264695734, 0.0338594876, 0.0033842677, -0.0383274965, 0.0019132476, -0.0320984088, 0.0346802548, -0.0046888338, 0.00514135, -0.0312182233, -0.0289763473, -0.047991138, 0.0031795774, -0.0300598517, 0.0203412585, 0.0120950267, -0.0482256897, -0.0520399511, 0.036136657, -0.0116489045, 0.0017970504, 0.0060261334, 0.0478568897, 0.0570824631, 0.0088444958, -0.0184433833, 0.0345045961, -0.036630597, 0.0146548133, -0.0627401471, 0.0202321503, -0.0182380956, 0.0481702015, 0.00144906, -0.0176486503, -0.0702558979, 0.0373258367, -0.0613240562, 0.0104679437, 0.0515995026, 0.0426639952, -0.0201753527, 0.0085723568, 0.0269464068, -0.009135494, 0.0036053013, 0.0085525122, 0.0466581434, 0.0170542598, -0.0082252743, 0.0274439286, 0.0124397138, -0.0187878702, -0.0205840897, 0.0432659015, -0.0516724251, 0.0212909002, -0.0044283057, -0.0323255062, -0.018373182, 0.0101552373, -0.0102264984, 0.1030242369, -0.0410246849, 0.0419819765, -0.1105449721, -0.0589384623, 0.024493536, 0.022344891, -0.0122506535, 0.0274264216, 0.0138587514, 0.0353412032, -0.0049063819, 0.0175338183, -0.0339443833, 0.0471630879, -0.0341299735, -0.0131973224, 0.0145903686, -5.973240381e-33, -0.0187794287, -0.033383593, -0.0143227847, -0.0435977653, -0.0124365389, 0.0246577747, -0.0355234966, -0.001429282, 0.0009172001, 0.0314191543, 0.0215834714, 0.0201392733, -0.0042482354, 0.0312274732, -0.0190495308, -0.0027775711, 0.0611834861, 0.0360827334, 0.0209742747, 0.0183086824, 0.1146372929, 0.0356358252, 0.0513244271, -0.0702741742, 0.0530795231, 0.026801832, -0.0005868667, 0.0243496485, 0.0181452855, 0.0643019155, -0.0332229473, 0.0498800166, 0.0113666691, -0.0092379414, -0.0432495028, -0.0081261368, -0.0560051985, -0.0508286729, 0.0375411138, 0.0225707199, -0.0974904746, -0.002727919, 0.0274500176, -0.0182546601, -0.0033183082, 0.0080118235, 0.0163701009, 0.0002880282, -0.0297146346, 0.0139580304, -0.0694999546, 0.0442380458, 0.0121630393, -0.0004756766, 0.0428223163, -0.0216213055, 0.0275610965, 0.0509906188, -0.0742916167, -0.0153191481, -0.0673741028, -0.0039242883, 0.0345476419, 0.0039889351, -0.0335044935, 0.0882803425, 0.031527143, -0.066330649, -0.0286915023, -0.0214630198, 0.043067351, 0.0386571549, 0.0549814552, 0.1260329485, 0.0373464189, -0.0341290608, -0.0138007626, 0.0083364854, 0.0339711867, -0.0108220726, 0.0397762097, 0.0208268389, -0.0730947703, 0.0139967799, -0.042715352, -0.0367795303, -0.0300167259, -0.0398537256, 0.0261058137, -0.0058512781, -0.0242689643, 0.0537974685, 0.0418242924, -0.0425671823, 0.0299203023, 0.0351326391, 0.0071414937, -0.0311532505, 0.0341816247, 0.0169359297, 0.0426781438, -0.0214634594, 0.0119027356, -0.0078139324, 0.0008765578, -0.0443110652, 0.0560493134, -0.0114256367, -0.0065098712, -0.0023456234, -0.0190837458, -0.0346688367, -0.0451127291, -0.008399345, 0.0481343567, 0.0223433767, -0.0645969808, 0.0537408181, 0.0245757326, 0.0246261656, 0.0102340234, -0.0436550975, 0.0036369343, 0.0318372361, -0.0478692017, -0.0526301712, 0.0049556303, -0.0051380037, 0.0231017172, -0.0785346776, -0.0110574104, 0.0090966187, 2.494e-7, 0.0857836604, 0.0067579783, 0.0077966694, -0.0504793264, 0.0397470407, 0.0250859968, 0.0126871122, 0.0522329323, -0.1022812128, -0.0073887301, 0.0048312843, 0.0294282511, 0.008104519, -0.0057830731, -0.0067494414, 0.0092225252, 0.0037839666, 0.0306018479, -0.0162438117, 0.0093119619, 0.1067960411, 0.0817455053, 0.0320698619, 0.0088064522, 0.0236208737, -0.0124216964, 0.01788068, -0.0397229344, 0.044377394, -0.0642883331, -0.0098442379, -0.0165645164, 0.05027657, -0.02755698, -0.0186438691, 0.0234179199, 0.0337668844, 0.0607752055, -0.0128875664, -0.0410744064, -0.0532078147, -0.0238813646, 0.0083108554, -0.0540228523, 0.0616229735, -0.0480754636, -0.0451046564, -0.0451756865, -0.039155025, 0.0177273806, 0.0315913893, 0.014449127, -0.0231934357, 0.0088701164, 0.0111114997, -0.0387228206, -0.028965231, -0.1015910208, 0.0039540646, -0.012328648, -0.0129680848, 0.0058758087, -0.0341673493, 0.018135516, 0.0797414407, -0.0281617735, -0.0242859721, 1.888994741e-34, 0.0284918826, 0.0132830655, 0.0323594995, -0.0401714854, 0.0247012712, 0.005550337, -0.0117824282, -0.0042894422, 0.0816621929, -0.0353403389, -0.017623974 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.04647v4
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.04647v4
EXIF as Language: Learning Cross-Modal Associations Between Images and Camera Metadata
2023-01-11T18:59:16
2023-06-17T12:46:01
Chenhao Zheng, Ayush Shrivastava, Andrew Owens
cs.CV
cs.CV, cs.CL
We learn a visual representation that captures information about the camera that recorded a given photo. To do this, we train a multimodal embedding between image patches and the EXIF metadata that cameras automatically insert into image files. Our model represents this metadata by simply converting it to text and then processing it with a transformer. The features that we learn significantly outperform other self-supervised and supervised features on downstream image forensics and calibration tasks. In particular, we successfully localize spliced image regions "zero shot" by clustering the visual embeddings for all of the patches within an image.
[ -0.0207733121, 0.0363125429, -0.0012840062, 0.06638439, -0.0389337391, 0.0058013201, -0.0029844553, 0.0071658036, -0.0091688242, -0.07250572, 0.024811931, 0.0491397902, -0.021788517, 0.0285610408, 0.0353595614, -0.0378096029, 0.0261420589, -0.0071734497, 0.0498052463, 0.028634904, 0.0618353263, -0.0313085467, 0.0260088053, 0.0407829322, -0.1097535118, 0.0343777351, -0.0317361541, 0.0301177558, 0.0405342802, 0.0449485481, -0.0600817725, 0.0596492887, 0.0577667728, 0.0381369442, 0.0000016946, -0.034131553, -0.0197027046, -0.0116890538, -0.0160444248, 0.0064380462, -0.0121495631, -0.0605484322, -0.0293094255, -0.0318814926, -0.0229490735, -0.0327182077, 0.0459985398, 0.0055524008, 0.052667737, 0.0410366617, -0.0446422324, -0.0110981949, -0.0316105932, -0.0045556352, 0.036522828, 0.0141704502, -0.025992075, 0.0025229745, -0.0009372387, 0.0139495609, -0.0399579443, 0.043772582, 0.0120688193, -0.0272750352, -0.0100555411, 0.0441600755, -0.0282071996, 0.0281778984, 0.0166325234, 0.0212020483, -0.0450486764, 0.0083415564, -0.0484895296, 0.0057971207, 0.0243997369, 0.0401370972, -0.0087122433, 0.0266462527, 0.0133801792, 0.0317402817, -0.0688330457, 0.0205223821, 0.0077129742, -0.0126467366, 0.011302528, -0.0247171242, 0.0252511296, 0.0343277231, -0.0672082156, -0.0217965376, -0.0399414115, 0.0007660115, -0.0088077569, 0.0271781255, 0.0673045516, -0.0237583295, -0.0450926684, -0.0308829769, 0.0299862437, 0.025343664, 0.0125387935, -0.0459253378, -0.0717392936, 0.0912406072, -0.0343780927, 0.0060955132, -0.0048374543, 0.0549835339, -0.0402436629, -0.0610273071, -0.0543494001, -0.0510401204, 0.0224514697, -0.0325910114, -0.0132471211, -0.0357655734, -0.011734372, -0.0323122591, -0.0215015505, -0.0089427782, -0.0564712659, 0.0342671573, -0.0219791885, -0.023212038, -0.0177539699, 0.0317087248, 0.008354675, 0.045392748, -0.0280642398, 0.0370697156, -0.0062556337, 0.0490506515, 0.0403124318, 0.0023438896, -0.0063178292, 0.0124031277, -0.0084627317, -0.0402397439, -0.0129688401, -0.0443453118, -0.036221344, -0.0216667242, 0.0353650115, -0.0530299284, -0.0019757613, -0.0151258893, -0.0129680987, -0.0264251605, -0.0160779543, -0.0116038397, -0.054116752, 0.1203524247, -0.0132415127, -0.014424745, 0.0312824436, 0.0079581011, 0.0041334238, 0.0258788466, 0.008529448, 0.0722836182, 0.0310323071, 0.0100221178, 0.0434146859, 0.0288387053, 0.0093348883, -0.0011483491, -0.0410794653, -0.0206113253, 0.0569414198, -0.0039821453, 0.0040653516, -0.009904555, -0.0066702962, -0.0350971892, 0.0387131535, 0.0164527521, 0.008741186, -0.0383570641, 0.0048262449, -0.0074463324, -0.036613062, 0.0012397206, -0.0334693715, 0.0540525801, -0.012548957, -0.0134462789, 0.0114485445, 0.0091182385, -0.0517249703, 0.0241123736, -0.0021739083, -0.0462763496, 0.0137640443, -0.0032744303, 0.0318216793, -0.0151977334, 0.0327776596, 0.0349526294, -0.019977456, 0.0117897717, -0.0190802403, -0.0617589839, 0.0203501731, 0.0476589501, -0.0126827983, -0.0152086206, 0.0126144625, -0.0012811346, 0.0532271564, 0.0025480685, -0.0348894373, -0.0241595972, 0.0187154859, -0.0550147332, -0.0242693909, -0.0695707649, 0.0047483286, 0.0020933221, -0.0357515216, -0.0072152298, 0.0449310578, -0.0332771018, 0.0127518708, 0.0008321599, 0.0330041423, -0.0493476316, -0.0107625481, 0.0772658661, -0.0493586697, -0.0242450219, -0.0195613634, -0.0156655125, 0.0506700613, -0.0109107867, 0.0382568389, 0.0045846179, 0.0449872538, -0.0126112876, 0.0473594628, -0.0697230175, -0.0091105876, -0.0202845763, -0.052679915, -0.0519268326, 0.0320542306, -0.034393426, 0.0164995324, -0.0843997076, -0.0239859466, 0.0069146412, 0.0320795439, -0.0070133302, 0.0364362746, 0.0151308719, -0.0591606088, 8.354e-7, -0.0120597612, 0.0740130097, 0.0216450207, -0.0025853785, -0.0510327704, -0.0136368293, 0.037304163, 0.0106216073, 0.0013845748, -0.0432982333, -0.0432774276, -0.1088974699, -0.0225053318, -0.0255767349, -0.0316951796, -0.0184596237, -0.0106813144, 0.0422012471, -0.0400179327, -0.0160311107, -0.0137172779, 0.0207143556, 0.0116618434, 0.007499171, 0.0641727522, -0.0231930595, -0.0051809046, -0.0229341667, 0.0204434786, 0.056861084, -0.0004453145, -0.0160011556, -0.0610706694, -0.062080875, -0.0058583231, 0.0182235502, -0.0249718279, 0.0021449656, 0.0153614199, -0.021464454, -0.0055091148, 0.048804637, 0.0035387867, -0.0277766101, -0.0326064378, -0.017107388, -0.0311083291, -0.0264138766, 0.0279704742, 0.0137256961, -0.0084821694, -0.0128308441, -0.0266555008, -0.0353209227, -0.0503621884, 0.0094385082, -0.0310434531, 0.0077740247, 0.0498312786, -0.0377324969, -0.0277998913, -0.0051610689, 0.0449899137, 0.0009543981, -0.0438200012, -0.0944548175, 0.0481970087, -0.0245141257, 0.0108218854, 0.0580061078, -0.038520176, -0.0299268048, 0.0635602474, 0.0692812651, 0.0476777889, 0.0245992281, -0.027188275, -0.004768949, -0.0300147999, 0.0264558606, 0.0200011712, 0.0133170914, -0.0246794131, 0.0079931784, 0.0062247957, 0.001481001, 0.0249162689, -0.073209241, 0.0232848972, 0.0148209101, -0.0962510481, -0.0020162817, -0.0281932298, -0.0063721901, 0.0245378278, 0.0373726785, 0.0171156116, 0.0122141577, 0.0055184062, 0.0754256994, 0.0584037676, -0.0135005768, -0.0240917299, -0.0285654683, -0.0551400855, 0.0289932396, -0.0208107941, 0.0278271772, -0.0311523434, 0.0328637138, -0.035106279, 0.0484286286, 0.0185921229, 0.0129913194, 0.0241281074, 0.0049639591, 0.0094846776, 0.0365081057, 0.0144919232, -0.0211655609, -0.0095154308, 0.0279947035, -0.0301492903, 0.0288894493, 0.0005113965, -0.048020985, -0.050790567, 0.0005754598, -0.0472237654, 0.0091873324, 0.0346171781, -0.003389043, -0.015926199, 0.0367799252, 0.0218204949, 0.0055102766, -0.034026362, 0.0039963331, -0.0058629801, -0.002525653, -0.0062795896, -0.0411303081, 0.0027555746, 0.003880041, -0.0279098339, 0.0345298015, -0.0127250375, -0.0015665945, -0.0516550727, 0.0072605275, 0.02178213, 0.0061727073, -0.0281262994, -0.0656373352, 0.0077451649, 0.0750797093, 0.0315479003, 0.0132762576, 0.1034520417, -0.0111842714, -0.0179958511, 0.0054491637, 0.0420728102, 0.0146410577, -0.0215844382, -0.0413250178, 0.039857287, 0.0069511775, 0.0468255803, -0.029938329, -0.0560900867, 0.0298056006, -0.0519251749, -0.0004193457, -0.0187681876, -0.0061908886, -0.0241034105, -0.0005291895, 0.0395809449, -0.0161696468, 0.0527241379, -0.0050808657, -0.0515969954, -0.0095285, 0.0098625729, 0.0559785813, 0.0321233571, 0.0023175601, -0.0086799748, -0.0214141626, -0.0157927647, -0.103894271, 0.060112834, -0.0379231833, 0.0587107651, 0.0228129085, 0.0280601718, 0.0595371611, 0.0144183943, 0.0125821438, 0.0244876221, -0.0473747253, -0.0355297662, -0.0312372837, 0.083648704, 0.0084663853, 0.0506458096, 0.0092180539, -0.0319538414, -0.0207638815, 0.0275100917, -0.019465901, -0.0154722435, 0.0172770992, -0.1104077548, -0.0202536117, 0.0189464428, -0.0215467326, 0.0450574383, 0.0338166207, -0.0593201481, -0.0553016886, -0.0048408792, 0.0117828446, 0.0014184114, 0.0876909643, -0.0065054982, 0.0171187706, 0.0028067112, -0.0151597122, -0.0172939189, 0.0100334836, -0.011799138, -0.021621583, -0.0064230808, 0.0253099371, 0.0261489246, 0.0410933569, 0.0120067848, 0.0335335061, -0.0142381117, -0.0118234186, -0.0082581649, 0.0097224098, -0.0329810083, 0.0374932252, 0.0371782742, 0.0397760496, 0.0230552796, 0.0699820817, -0.0358587764, 0.0313996002, 0.0256186873, 0.027003333, -0.0635585189, 0.0188008491, 0.0078792516, 0.0112947393, -0.0430711545, 0.0021016416, 0.0632553399, -0.0532818213, 0.0153845595, -0.0058623916, -0.0331957489, -0.0313870125, 0.0850780755, -0.0136449737, -0.0381442383, 0.0063617281, 0.0189941581, -0.0171707682, 0.0563048422, 0.0195191987, 0.0079838913, -0.0061653908, -0.0291929804, -0.0191538557, -0.0434799232, 0.0170371924, 0.0593499728, -0.0422362313, -0.0421880819, 0.042949792, -0.020097902, -0.0308740158, -0.0177181438, 0.0477662794, -0.0176458266, 0.0900937244, -0.0085232919, 0.0478178896, 0.0312531255, -0.0257216152, 0.0074832668, -0.0125782052, 0.0165742617, -0.0386603102, 0.0303854942, -5.624631735e-33, 0.0022966033, -0.0475467034, 0.0240205154, 0.0177326407, 0.0251497999, 0.0231650192, -0.0026285949, 0.0251694433, -0.012574356, 0.0041659251, 0.0063632815, 0.004676579, -0.0056050159, 0.0222312063, 0.0160938166, 0.0120243803, 0.0092000682, 0.0036878183, 0.0172223337, -0.000878328, 0.0430012159, 0.0093064578, 0.0480881147, -0.1183446273, -0.0353370421, 0.0425543189, -0.0442742594, 0.0077073406, -0.0041079181, 0.0559398495, -0.0042717517, -0.0220449958, 0.0024659622, -0.0280730352, -0.0370793529, 0.0155622, -0.0390496068, 0.0089992555, -0.0302713662, 0.0169461593, -0.0104244426, -0.0399707928, 0.013517404, -0.0545417964, 0.0417821854, -0.0414864831, 0.0541619509, -0.025287699, 0.0057021445, 0.0153599186, -0.0435361899, 0.0139683578, -0.0352638662, -0.0319799781, 0.0720122606, -0.0088435039, 0.0357390419, 0.0138090812, -0.0707653761, 0.0090957731, -0.0257732421, -0.003507812, 0.0282266159, 0.0078404145, -0.0260391776, 0.0790434927, 0.0029596621, -0.0446273498, 0.0060544559, 0.0213486347, 0.0418219715, 0.0744657069, 0.0200989675, 0.0833261758, 0.0562179498, -0.0372392647, -0.0677408725, -0.0037054962, -0.0452435575, 0.0166159999, -0.0214931984, 0.04558786, 0.0268067755, 0.0060569933, -0.0564341955, -0.0038674704, -0.0287437942, -0.034902297, -0.0141013311, 0.0670480877, -0.0278230011, 0.0322861597, 0.0593124926, -0.0199785307, 0.0050950814, -0.0447437838, -0.0058607981, 0.0536466092, -0.0139067713, 0.0353850871, 0.0001726977, -0.0377482027, 0.0558267422, -0.0020562359, 0.0347487926, 0.015637137, 0.1085409895, 0.0652244911, -0.0127677619, 0.0272941701, 0.0011567291, -0.0128423152, -0.0131183295, -0.0055567911, -0.0070642466, 0.034208402, -0.0098659545, -0.0157122742, -0.0356471539, 0.0096543487, -0.0091153244, -0.0384794213, -0.0177824702, 0.0083318325, 0.016684087, 0.0035858918, -0.0345519595, -0.0594254881, 0.0397888571, -0.0276573058, 0.0191583596, 0.0596810393, 2.509e-7, 0.0183964428, 0.0124578532, 0.0354321674, -0.0376646668, -0.0170769542, 0.0840407237, -0.0507478304, 0.0108903442, 0.0195556972, -0.0809219182, 0.0196927749, 0.0133130467, 0.0526085347, 0.0266582612, -0.0288805794, 0.0858450532, 0.0293726567, -0.019817451, -0.0468566008, 0.0077363099, 0.0193706863, 0.117056556, -0.0027022958, -0.0121286744, 0.0507257693, -0.065084368, 0.0795838758, -0.036570549, -0.0191775225, -0.0305496715, -0.0282270405, 0.0043036574, -0.0271320306, 0.0205554236, 0.0216193348, 0.0310838111, 0.0304809771, 0.0239561759, -0.0316420346, -0.0382116511, -0.0395258702, 0.0238504987, -0.0014254621, -0.0245708097, 0.0413452052, -0.0208282229, -0.0116156721, -0.0406733006, -0.0387552269, 0.0415137857, 0.0470730849, -0.0151852239, -0.0054126303, 0.035049729, 0.051020287, -0.0319252498, 0.0061119101, -0.0897006541, -0.0050077699, 0.0275172945, -0.0518085212, 0.0674105063, -0.0290519353, -0.033712998, 0.1071300581, -0.013275696, -0.0050347201, 1.695237686e-34, -0.0048340997, -0.036272198, 0.0251895841, -0.0192337949, 0.010398983, 0.0018398922, -0.0855851248, -0.0325410292, -0.0067864889, -0.0532838069, -0.0367149524 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.04643v3
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.04643v3
tieval: An Evaluation Framework for Temporal Information Extraction Systems
2023-01-11T18:55:22
2023-11-24T16:13:18
Hugo Sousa, Alípio Jorge, Ricardo Campos
cs.CL
cs.CL
Temporal information extraction (TIE) has attracted a great deal of interest over the last two decades, leading to the development of a significant number of datasets. Despite its benefits, having access to a large volume of corpora makes it difficult when it comes to benchmark TIE systems. On the one hand, different datasets have different annotation schemes, thus hindering the comparison between competitors across different corpora. On the other hand, the fact that each corpus is commonly disseminated in a different format requires a considerable engineering effort for a researcher/practitioner to develop parsers for all of them. This constraint forces researchers to select a limited amount of datasets to evaluate their systems which consequently limits the comparability of the systems. Yet another obstacle that hinders the comparability of the TIE systems is the evaluation metric employed. While most research works adopt traditional metrics such as precision, recall, and $F_1$, a few others prefer temporal awareness -- a metric tailored to be more comprehensive on the evaluation of temporal systems. Although the reason for the absence of temporal awareness in the evaluation of most systems is not clear, one of the factors that certainly weights this decision is the necessity to implement the temporal closure algorithm in order to compute temporal awareness, which is not straightforward to implement neither is currently easily available. All in all, these problems have limited the fair comparison between approaches and consequently, the development of temporal extraction systems. To mitigate these problems, we have developed tieval, a Python library that provides a concise interface for importing different corpora and facilitates system evaluation. In this paper, we present the first public release of tieval and highlight its most relevant features.
[ 0.047824841, 0.0448318385, 0.0005004522, 0.0193894692, -0.0564299524, 0.0288769491, 0.01248853, 0.0362560935, 0.0177312829, -0.048480317, 0.0086217057, -0.0069179903, 0.0088406662, 0.0324525461, -0.0604599193, -0.0672839954, 0.056192521, 0.0015907354, 0.0245427582, 0.0626869127, 0.0010764991, -0.0127539122, -0.0584805012, 0.0202856734, -0.016325593, 0.0004793417, -0.0130588422, -0.0430689007, 0.0674053878, -0.0390795767, -0.0022324191, 0.0060739457, -0.0356637686, 0.0603636764, 0.0000016985, -0.0257656481, -0.0368460678, -0.0012559126, -0.0192830879, 0.0120065436, 0.0153985862, -0.0262131952, -0.0127672022, -0.0356138945, -0.0448960364, -0.0392444134, 0.0183723234, -0.0306175072, 0.0286855325, 0.0817610696, -0.0321400389, 0.0031790598, 0.0304388311, 0.0160871428, -0.0261121057, -0.049010504, 0.0086523816, 0.0054050041, 0.0423389152, -0.061304573, 0.042071484, 0.0326689668, -0.0155702922, -0.0141718863, -0.0034492565, 0.0293941442, -0.0647739321, 0.0101737706, -0.0455756485, 0.0127810501, 0.0433498509, -0.0174648147, 0.0233721137, 0.0330680348, -0.0401742123, -0.0004422598, -0.0517119654, 0.0099645955, -0.033097811, 0.0200099181, 0.0390776768, 0.076214768, -0.019647764, 0.0171038397, -0.0219755098, 0.0768998042, -5.92e-8, -0.0146486303, -0.0111884642, 0.0227314886, 0.0543474555, -0.0369847007, 0.0552626997, 0.0435066707, 0.0263014492, -0.0014877411, -0.0044914628, -0.0450578816, 0.003405544, -0.0679790154, -0.0335838906, 0.0226254091, 0.0070006554, 0.0642641112, -0.0037127526, 0.0318586119, -0.0004225539, -0.0063602645, -0.0016439194, 0.001074435, -0.0549883507, 0.0460513718, -0.0016496766, 0.0139581542, -0.0330487154, 0.0194833465, -0.0181771517, 0.033470951, -0.0053625982, 0.032528609, -0.0446715988, -0.0527822301, 0.0022785608, 0.0150684677, -0.0256251525, 0.0195334014, -0.024804363, -0.0166269001, -0.0240371693, -0.0333658159, -0.0056040906, 0.0217914954, 0.0276287533, -0.0535295904, -0.016301129, 0.0560409948, -0.035917379, -0.0150845889, -0.0557370782, -0.0319798887, 0.0003350461, -0.0426880382, -0.0369390137, -0.0576923378, 0.0228906553, 0.0146203348, -0.0001144748, -0.0146053713, -0.008611355, -0.0151871787, -0.0130567309, 0.05100872, -0.0073360549, 0.0002258873, -0.0072881486, -0.0221872572, 0.0397567041, 0.0307455175, 0.0351880863, 0.003955381, 0.0590831675, 0.027477162, -0.0552464686, 0.0362438671, -0.0288308151, -0.0274786986, -0.0318863094, -0.0065978174, 0.0051228241, -0.0197650995, 0.0169062838, 0.0413570739, -0.0097153354, -0.0263346359, -0.0028255668, -0.0073084431, 0.0256770849, -0.0350841135, 0.0806931928, -0.0208708234, 0.0715931281, 0.0292720534, 0.0153851891, -0.0269881692, -0.0143701136, 0.0314351059, -0.0594776981, 0.0204620548, 0.0054996288, -0.0344552733, -0.0331914462, 0.0112768076, 0.0102731278, -0.0348929092, 0.0842986703, -0.0247639082, -0.0113679292, 0.0211890042, 0.0109826606, -0.002590877, 0.0046524503, 0.0181068461, -0.0022100133, 0.0738333538, 0.0338836536, -0.0613075383, -0.0327347405, -0.012536603, -0.0168379974, 0.0165022109, 0.0288166199, -0.0737009495, 0.0050519584, -0.011334545, -0.0341596268, 0.0385906138, 0.0048243264, 0.0041288775, 0.0281271972, 0.0598176792, 0.0029978254, -0.0160016473, 0.0150362197, 0.0479058251, -0.009896093, -0.0082454951, -0.0576188043, 0.0130030913, 0.0294826012, 0.0742052272, -0.0294876527, -0.0116144773, 0.0595356934, -0.0292731822, 0.0474854782, 0.0730061978, -0.0131228967, -0.0396715663, 0.0253435057, 0.0007629877, -0.0355109721, 0.0312205777, -0.0259327032, -0.0257790368, -0.0254293773, 0.0312608406, 0.066022642, -0.0248709526, 0.0276638176, 0.0166503731, -0.0039522089, -0.059072528, 0.0677574202, 0.0034325987, 0.0120719904, 0.0134441182, -0.0144850193, 0.0247197375, -0.0320311897, -0.0383223668, 0.0401540734, 0.005053082, -0.0490785874, 0.0239048675, -0.0100405933, -0.0821689293, -0.0032819738, -0.083567217, 0.0139689753, -0.0283370987, 0.0771401599, 0.0137476977, -0.0060588149, -0.024519939, -0.017235728, 0.0092123095, -0.0271674898, -0.0326471962, 0.0123772686, 0.0570996255, 0.0816152841, -0.0194990002, -0.0334638618, -0.0088586221, -0.0421978422, 0.0524093919, 0.0439315289, -0.114143841, -0.0107434886, 0.0149552487, -0.0021763584, 0.0277938843, 0.018251026, 0.0107788322, 0.0057459138, -0.0165206548, 0.0114075271, 0.0405839868, 0.0038057468, 0.0452098101, 0.0080673592, -0.0355919041, -0.0298590288, 0.0191712286, -0.0137350764, 0.0456558168, -0.0295691825, 0.0097158151, 0.0142450202, 0.0404408127, -0.0261478089, 0.0537828095, -0.0109722046, -0.0138081117, -0.0446775332, -0.0161754508, -0.0053731436, 0.0121842762, -0.032790754, 0.0208378155, -0.0411132127, -0.0126925856, 0.0392004922, -0.0091353245, -0.0267910846, 0.0104896864, -0.020139616, -0.0583837181, 0.1064114273, 0.0041442849, -0.014673233, 0.0314456597, -0.0845269337, 0.0035752184, 0.0329261459, 0.0537330881, -0.0249161236, 0.0255940221, -0.025607422, 0.0371431373, -0.0190944448, -0.0004084341, -0.0410714634, -0.0294884257, -0.0315964818, -0.0184257962, -0.0363057181, 0.0078498349, -0.0173857585, 0.0430244245, -0.0349464193, 0.0460875407, 0.0054940968, -0.0112608969, 0.0100397067, 0.0897372067, -0.0014327981, -0.0146003477, -0.0138609447, 0.0336243659, 0.0214451775, 0.0215905979, 0.0479950234, -0.0222475696, -0.0346507505, -0.0084033459, 0.0022062047, -0.0936952606, -0.0115785049, -0.0306335501, 0.018622674, -0.0687890425, -0.0108822891, 0.102323018, 0.0462131724, -0.0096511794, -0.0217995942, 0.0082547627, 0.0138813891, 0.0074264272, -0.0086282734, -0.0717920586, 0.006121892, -0.0047458448, -0.013986988, -0.0327675901, -0.0518336743, 0.0103173172, -0.0653206781, 0.0090750614, 0.0051758084, -0.0374780819, 0.0275722817, -0.0288444497, 0.0093646292, -0.0601616427, -0.029095782, 0.0310706235, -0.0258486047, 0.0254908483, 0.0385697372, -0.0511425957, -0.045714628, 0.0131460438, 0.0154818529, 0.0499709249, 0.0041275132, 0.0327516012, -0.0326988436, -0.0238310937, 0.02632837, -0.0139145004, -0.0217246655, -0.0493609533, 0.0569854975, -0.0093911197, -0.0156226549, 0.0015065954, -0.0161397867, 0.0342836268, -0.0012100955, -0.0035329526, 0.072465077, -0.0027051582, 0.0492706187, -0.0119086532, -0.043282941, 0.0180541538, 0.0446069278, -0.0240980014, 0.0150458803, -0.0482471399, 0.015620809, -0.0406803191, -0.0816903785, -0.0111574959, 0.006539383, -0.0492215753, -0.0580868796, -0.088507846, -0.0729707479, -0.0065642763, 0.0264789741, -0.0193577167, 0.0217177533, -0.0086523974, 0.0446342006, -0.0726451576, 0.0134063167, 0.015873326, -0.0020748838, -0.0397782736, -0.0195640344, -0.0211004298, 0.0475110076, -0.0329156965, 0.044212196, -0.0566988252, -0.0347368233, 0.0215365514, -0.0067798621, 0.0176045094, 0.0552642792, -0.0173259284, 0.0289533623, 0.0180703644, 0.0045002312, -0.0047987821, -0.0448201336, 0.0313157476, -0.0069136261, -0.0135385953, 0.0025868043, -0.01110732, -0.0075570839, -0.036162708, 0.0335170962, -0.0398033708, 0.0174652487, 0.0170032401, 0.0330300406, 0.0450702161, -0.000480743, -0.0238431599, 0.0024934108, -0.0408740193, -0.0503133759, 0.0066114417, -0.0153965503, 0.022082556, -0.021279281, 0.0130473645, -0.0338658951, 0.0500622541, -0.0014658875, 0.0238008983, -0.0376695655, 0.052976165, 0.0406722464, 0.0582163259, -0.0280456115, -0.0003500602, -0.0236969981, -0.0004384688, 0.0188037101, 0.0225483309, -0.0229433626, -0.0105687818, 0.0130093023, 0.0234311745, 0.0262286346, 0.0211204551, -0.0648624152, 0.0920693427, -0.0159643944, 0.0051715611, 0.0839380473, -0.0484596752, 0.100499332, -0.0027043801, -0.0132347131, 0.006693278, 0.0170933846, 0.0533074886, 0.0087688398, -0.0544483438, 0.0108521935, -0.0158122554, 0.0293805823, 0.0604394376, -0.0476714447, 0.0181511715, 0.0376680717, -0.0745960101, -0.0207417626, -0.0196191333, -0.0659153983, -0.0278634094, -0.0106526222, -0.0369004533, -0.0749260485, -0.0050594793, 0.0800716281, 0.0190825965, 0.0199504849, 0.0291524772, -0.0012802052, 0.0347078145, 0.0502733514, -0.0033717076, -0.0537937917, 0.0425091647, 0.0278859623, -0.0298325457, -0.0532094501, -5.608443709e-33, -0.0414836295, -0.0195314772, -0.0089449892, 0.0249380916, -0.045682691, 0.0311334059, -0.0257348791, 0.007539303, -0.0065987776, 0.0071969172, -0.0134491511, -0.017527882, 0.048339799, -0.0640118048, 0.030845318, 0.0052334601, 0.0198574197, 0.0040473575, -0.0267499872, -0.0154358484, 0.1023620442, 0.031186495, 0.0673053488, -0.0612823144, 0.059933193, 0.0116935326, -0.0081091793, 0.0013657968, 0.0833695605, 0.0538852774, 0.0207233056, 0.0048821392, 0.0385248028, -0.0335850827, -0.0227473453, 0.0128421849, -0.1538391709, -0.0272641405, 0.0116021698, 0.042226579, 0.0216190629, -0.0117042139, -0.0097974362, -0.0396910608, 0.0128259007, 0.0079738367, 0.0254939999, -0.0672508329, -0.0049828896, -0.0880786404, -0.0355578847, 0.0773616731, -0.016466694, 0.0293383244, 0.0931293964, 0.0478639416, 0.0540104657, -0.0350585803, -0.0419545025, 0.0128776012, -0.0311553515, 0.023012232, 0.0263162404, -0.0208593383, -0.0184883401, 0.0393253453, -0.0475260988, -0.021382289, 0.0080043711, 0.0697503015, -0.0095406882, 0.0039802459, -0.0225636866, -0.0078884652, 0.0148305343, -0.0168535598, -0.0584836714, 0.0509541631, 0.0584762767, 0.0272661187, -0.0419891402, -0.0085476963, -0.052573435, 0.0744908676, 0.0221685488, -0.0021525202, 0.0191049445, -0.0172411688, 0.0112511432, -0.0082126614, 0.005456029, 0.0414700881, 0.0330767371, -0.0044724932, 0.0105593987, -0.0093486644, -0.022719318, 0.0406976305, -0.0133463545, -0.0128207793, -0.021451205, -0.0432277396, -0.0148878051, 0.0440561436, 0.0457855426, -0.0526281185, 0.0387099274, 0.0217438266, -0.0198897906, -0.0180888642, -0.012920469, 0.037432231, -0.0324212611, -0.0288846232, 0.0223161634, -0.0188382789, -0.0095034996, 0.0295873154, 0.0283720214, 0.0541510247, -0.0115442481, 0.0354629867, 0.0152745098, 0.0178319234, -0.0128980167, -0.01797699, -0.0060264519, 0.0446044132, -0.0083150873, 0.0281812791, 0.0130647672, 0.0051690205, 2.254e-7, 0.0579040907, 0.0072758319, 0.0813119859, 0.0305725783, -0.0004475186, -0.0363887623, -0.014092288, 0.0096818982, -0.0581002422, 0.0308744851, 0.0232441444, -0.044129055, 0.0258991625, 0.0299429074, -0.0477700904, -0.0831397027, -0.0284799971, -0.0541085415, -0.0600842945, 0.0090432083, 0.0579551496, 0.0275892597, 0.0384505391, 0.0144347008, -0.0396688655, -0.0540306754, 0.0386950448, 0.0112106586, -0.0220905636, 0.0331170298, 0.0544080809, -0.010238043, -0.0214000382, 0.008212884, -0.0264604446, 0.0118738161, -0.0005779841, 0.0486625843, -0.0102641098, 0.0023527914, -0.0058641951, -0.0531132631, 0.006492353, 0.0043480857, 0.0736107007, 0.0038868629, -0.0107884444, -0.0036300756, -0.02807674, 0.0480859093, -0.0289432723, 0.0441087335, -0.0308060162, 0.0434726663, 0.0096756453, -0.0134342564, -0.0372611247, -0.0823934451, -0.0364061408, 0.0403855108, 0.0097456928, -0.0157317519, 0.0316417404, -0.0367178246, -0.0250758864, -0.0530492365, -0.0257984661, 1.869056681e-34, 0.0207659621, 0.0252760779, -0.0328499526, 0.0517065227, -0.0039037974, -0.0116310073, -0.0186152644, 0.0064486121, -0.017558286, -0.0076944171, 0.0253324043 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.04606v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.04606v1
Modelling low-resource accents without accent-specific TTS frontend
2023-01-11T18:00:29
2023-01-11T18:00:29
Georgi Tinchev, Marta Czarnowska, Kamil Deja, Kayoko Yanagisawa, Marius Cotescu
eess.AS
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD
This work focuses on modelling a speaker's accent that does not have a dedicated text-to-speech (TTS) frontend, including a grapheme-to-phoneme (G2P) module. Prior work on modelling accents assumes a phonetic transcription is available for the target accent, which might not be the case for low-resource, regional accents. In our work, we propose an approach whereby we first augment the target accent data to sound like the donor voice via voice conversion, then train a multi-speaker multi-accent TTS model on the combination of recordings and synthetic data, to generate the donor's voice speaking in the target accent. Throughout the procedure, we use a TTS frontend developed for the same language but a different accent. We show qualitative and quantitative analysis where the proposed strategy achieves state-of-the-art results compared to other generative models. Our work demonstrates that low resource accents can be modelled with relatively little data and without developing an accent-specific TTS frontend. Audio samples of our model converting to multiple accents are available on our web page.
[ -0.0168947019, 0.115888603, 0.0129210372, -0.0368764326, -0.0101048425, -0.0379610509, 0.0585213043, -0.0219240673, -0.0520505235, 0.022420926, -0.0298866984, -0.0582337379, 0.0315407142, 0.0357187502, 0.066131562, -0.0813529119, -0.0093865246, -0.0421898775, -0.0172862243, -0.0688660741, 0.0436601862, 0.0330922082, -0.0264180582, 0.0528023019, -0.0397163518, 0.0257701147, -0.0136952903, 0.0292412341, 0.0151439728, 0.0408692285, -0.0332264826, -0.0058211787, 0.0230836868, 0.0053232019, 0.0000019219, -0.0094472133, -0.0486637205, 0.0072826906, -0.0763119087, 0.0294756331, 0.0749730021, 0.0434195735, -0.0529320091, 0.0315907151, 0.0013826319, -0.0250593387, 0.0788459033, -0.048533652, 0.0371237621, 0.0464387499, -0.020250693, -0.0462700278, 0.0101707373, -0.0147961443, 0.0159471519, 0.0110034309, -0.0103600556, -0.0558301993, 0.0141003598, -0.0151143279, -0.022265844, 0.0298170894, -0.023212187, 0.0165011436, 0.0023371689, 0.0153176337, 0.0003441968, -0.0502962694, -0.0046115434, 0.0410842858, -0.0216182433, -0.0115979658, 0.033304818, 0.0353601985, -0.0221728384, -0.0281737745, 0.0179650616, -0.0076177828, 0.0025812634, 0.009837308, -0.0305210445, 0.0449354835, 0.0093696713, -0.0611141175, -0.0256118346, -0.0253489502, 0.0290616415, -0.0284006745, 0.0061615389, 0.0152416127, -0.0249269623, 0.0179296229, 0.0280995276, 0.0252667796, 0.0079042874, 0.0113529991, -0.013170992, -0.0209520906, -0.0095933378, 0.0560920313, 0.0526062846, 0.0201608967, -0.050756596, -0.048335731, 0.0040759346, -0.0106993727, -0.0290718507, -0.0489558801, -0.0253799446, -0.0438712016, -0.0009556141, 0.0055447333, -0.0708010346, -0.0312732942, 0.0002629373, 0.0221635178, -0.0263171475, -0.0205188598, -0.0441115126, 0.0069780494, 0.0672017112, 0.0440609455, -0.0687819123, -0.0351721831, 0.030643478, 0.0560561605, -0.0013314922, 0.0485690311, -0.0371345244, -0.0927250981, 0.0153501257, 0.0092044547, 0.0460084304, 0.0311218686, 0.0238225274, 0.0196728706, 0.0114893345, 0.0146158719, -0.029992139, -0.0365362652, -0.0244823825, -0.0150379036, -0.0141061572, -0.0690310448, 0.0290028751, -0.0385821983, 0.006285545, -0.0267352406, -0.0248954166, -0.008371206, 0.0215929411, 0.0338530391, 0.0023735552, 0.0553591661, 0.060068462, -0.0402739048, -0.0204184689, 0.0255636014, 0.0486143269, -0.0352842584, -0.0033148134, -0.0355402716, -0.0182833485, 0.0970771089, 0.0863663405, 0.03588688, -0.0259197056, -0.0285246633, -0.0468167178, 0.0461797379, 0.0946137905, 0.0303281806, -0.0011417314, -0.046599254, 0.0462162048, 0.0280968696, 0.0509580448, -0.0128690554, 0.0915681124, 0.0242338274, -0.0213930029, -0.0201727375, -0.0035077718, -0.0123483548, 0.0254823714, 0.0259318985, -0.0061770473, 0.0674616322, -0.0480776541, 0.0411282629, 0.02321258, -0.0707528889, 0.0028951014, -0.0077624083, 0.0257054176, 0.0320940167, -0.0043583312, 0.0151570393, -0.0047268015, -0.0587529726, 0.0424296074, -0.0328112505, -0.0331222713, 0.0262404382, -0.013920404, 0.0510264859, -0.0055407067, -0.0493453331, -0.0285493974, 0.0050755292, -0.0032400738, -0.0226102844, 0.053852275, -0.0561049953, 0.0084153181, 0.0304923747, -0.0129413512, 0.0431538373, -0.0392011553, 0.0019286994, 0.0112413662, -0.057981696, 0.0812120587, -0.049010165, -0.0326065235, 0.0026456041, 0.0178740546, 0.0098619843, 0.0064344001, 0.0221671164, -0.032641612, 0.0133049656, -0.0078955246, -0.0328234993, 0.0237022135, 0.0443166718, -0.0223347954, -0.0070744865, 0.0362969264, -0.0534096025, 0.022795869, -0.0001511883, 0.0188553911, -0.1068372652, 0.0405412614, -0.0471073315, 0.0662801117, -0.0314026251, -0.0057865852, 0.0136330072, -0.0099291913, 0.02598764, -0.0182532873, 0.0375571959, -0.0150884707, 0.0225721039, 0.0704062954, -0.0023054765, -0.098501347, 0.013699241, -0.0291948039, 0.0147403823, 0.0453058966, -0.0268623922, -0.0303347204, -0.001479446, -0.0117349308, -0.0632559955, -0.0058427276, 0.0190687235, 0.0099641001, 0.0241020191, 0.0401696749, -0.0086525856, -0.0227306057, -0.0657702163, -0.0346953087, 0.0160158761, -0.017947657, -0.022957705, -0.0446897931, 0.027045738, -0.0235426053, 0.0150834778, -0.0019794675, 0.0095668342, -0.0362735316, 0.0270170178, -0.0243476331, -0.0395837314, 0.0250221323, 0.0381773077, 0.0392724089, -0.0379100926, -0.0280443579, -0.0030697898, 0.0825650394, -0.0189502798, -0.0105656851, -0.0380044691, -0.0066102901, -0.0510352291, -0.063011393, -0.0062160911, 0.0064133387, 0.0230758786, -0.029111838, -0.0493486151, -0.0250868537, 0.0249973815, 0.0351423882, 0.0249838177, -0.0618853606, 0.0122407069, 0.0020575861, -0.0022115975, 0.0126139168, -0.0093444809, -0.0283302516, 0.0007922596, -0.030071307, -0.0087305326, 0.0187271889, -0.0841382593, -0.0656938925, -0.0443317033, -0.030143423, -0.0030731284, -0.0320663601, -0.0088042049, 0.0400329567, 0.0083462726, 0.0002000041, -0.0105822152, 0.0586662106, 0.0093776034, -0.048518233, 0.0107106818, 0.0114051821, -0.0298055038, -0.0073557515, -0.0086788693, 0.0290717296, 0.0034011309, -0.0332065448, 0.0198343974, 0.0632032156, -0.0373853967, 0.0300286189, 0.031179674, 0.0007280473, 0.0453006439, 0.0011573014, 0.0196332876, 0.0037300512, 0.0208756123, 0.0430210605, 0.0507720783, -0.0883344039, -0.0307396185, 0.0266765673, -0.0228770338, 0.0554604977, 0.0359754078, -0.0552932508, -0.0149154672, 0.0257854648, 0.0477107354, -0.0274458267, -0.0005420069, 0.025447024, 0.018612897, -0.0131644057, 0.0707987323, -0.028990902, -0.017851362, 0.0066047912, -0.0186270475, 0.0620796233, -0.0187773015, -0.0099428892, -0.0686804056, -0.005261784, 0.0533502139, 0.0694690794, -0.027181888, 0.0048660389, -0.0323654003, -0.1105602831, 0.045898933, 0.0382967032, -0.035851717, 0.0298661198, -0.0194876641, -0.0137506966, -0.0223481469, -0.0099140499, 0.0054806974, 0.0048073037, -0.0008971805, 0.0514765903, -0.0763305053, -0.0416469462, -0.0081471689, -0.037952181, 0.1195957586, 0.0212421156, -0.00015075, 0.001816303, -0.0439095832, -0.0372486264, -0.0103296125, 0.0014430047, -0.0077362983, 0.0271137413, 0.0540917739, -0.018376492, 0.0045218053, 0.0625343025, -0.003914691, 0.0229633544, 0.0066784769, 0.0307892207, -0.0263921972, 0.0430739596, -0.003031218, 0.0298793092, 0.0430754535, 0.0492146872, 0.0310557112, -0.0934278294, 0.003210129, -0.003766625, 0.0348975845, -0.0717028677, -0.0554136038, 0.042600628, 0.0418922566, -0.035909567, -0.0230256133, 0.0127076609, -0.0160854273, 0.054020822, 0.0079168258, -0.0255746935, -0.0130369263, -0.0145107973, 0.0019461828, -0.0191136803, -0.0435710438, 0.0601351149, -0.0205681846, -0.0156511404, 0.030757457, -0.0741880536, 0.00387668, -0.0217092782, -0.0171754081, -0.042434115, 0.0369324461, 0.0332240649, 0.0241228286, 0.0497107431, -0.0348941684, -0.0298086237, 0.060585767, -0.011211127, -0.002706141, 0.0189709961, 0.0821936801, 0.0116797434, 0.0064832601, 0.007991815, -0.0210293513, 0.07244201, -0.0222247541, -0.0012727688, -0.0273792613, -0.0629921257, -0.0091540748, 0.0302174538, 0.0242097043, -0.0261590723, 0.0715078861, -0.0389382131, 0.005138271, -0.00192014, 0.0716309175, -0.0450941287, -0.0288301781, 0.0668904781, 0.0510671996, 0.0125386668, -0.0672423318, -0.0146612609, 0.0206356794, -0.010277424, 0.0442973524, 0.0432099737, 0.0358819328, 0.0345374048, 0.026412271, 0.0146259451, 0.0388489403, -0.0160883702, -0.0034323446, -0.0096974168, -0.0381132886, 0.0068323803, -0.0278286804, 0.0135000953, 0.0093632471, -0.0057490123, 0.0136528183, -0.0287397578, -0.0215559285, 0.0319676995, 0.0226842873, 0.0949087068, 0.0323118605, 0.0508224964, -0.021592034, 0.0185313877, -0.0504847877, -0.0144429142, 0.0003877888, -0.0194385163, -0.0030448269, 0.0152098509, 0.0374002568, 0.0042207083, 0.0537457466, -0.0882354826, 0.0334192589, -0.0092880558, -0.0228006579, -0.0364833847, -0.0362756401, -0.0233314447, -0.0443393178, -0.0223057754, -0.07363002, 0.0108945072, 0.0124654192, 0.0019661924, -0.0382377766, 0.0375754312, -0.0290810876, -0.0446463376, 0.0520993024, -0.0002612836, -0.0067274477, -0.0003568917, -0.0186939668, 0.0468347743, -5.745873692e-33, -0.0200028308, 0.038522277, 0.0056884354, 0.0460394882, -0.0397417806, 0.0140077127, -0.0309970472, -0.0268239882, -0.0179193132, -0.030166693, -0.0072282613, -0.0280483738, 0.0083313603, 0.0336135179, -0.0060329991, 0.0635357276, 0.0895730704, -0.0205698609, 0.002707273, 0.0309442263, 0.0335434712, 0.0421808362, 0.004326981, -0.057318788, -0.0238145832, -0.0320051759, -0.0347907767, -0.0097957589, 0.0209539849, 0.0353497118, 0.0161192678, 0.0864917487, -0.0245441012, -0.0423429795, -0.0238550808, 0.0208533108, -0.059457209, -0.0049318229, -0.0215322357, 0.0221255571, 0.0156672988, -0.0143059948, -0.0006944776, 0.0015877044, -0.0269497931, -0.008111937, 0.0109158754, -0.0381205976, 0.0217720121, -0.0177932158, -0.0184187721, 0.027636217, 0.010756419, -0.0016527948, 0.0508772619, 0.0854069665, -0.039418228, -0.0403582342, -0.0501804389, 0.013899412, 0.0044922177, -0.0171543453, 0.0211346336, 0.013650652, -0.0085567161, -0.0079430752, 0.0475442745, -0.0754672438, -0.0011116207, 0.0228536017, 0.0587538779, 0.0455960855, 0.0340418555, 0.0439519025, 0.0135580599, -0.0570639409, -0.0248165429, 0.0332596451, 0.0688518509, -0.0252003614, -0.0342147388, 0.0352168344, 0.0292566884, 0.0115539776, -0.0531119928, -0.0564253479, 0.0048844586, -0.0404086225, 0.0195555184, -0.0188099481, -0.0141418837, 0.0417520888, 0.0683740675, -0.0050713206, 0.0166521706, -0.029185975, -0.0198332202, 0.0106315902, -0.0107731, 0.0177211817, -0.0220813751, -0.0382621475, 0.0678440705, 0.0486623198, 0.0313880965, 0.0135215539, -0.0096151317, 0.0629259422, -0.0628745705, -0.0038849779, -0.0239520054, 0.0339110605, -0.0130391782, 0.0109746, 0.0359695032, -0.015265015, 0.011765413, -0.0180246774, 0.0150259286, 0.0227107313, 0.0193178374, -0.02797403, 0.0277190525, 0.026667282, -0.0530926026, 0.0074696015, 0.0342334658, -0.036234621, 0.0329366587, -0.0066870954, -0.0305268429, -0.0201424863, 2.706e-7, 0.0131591018, -0.0374546051, 0.032017529, -0.0298120975, 0.0455862656, 0.0002694634, -0.0419108383, 0.0101025207, 0.0085673928, -0.0030777634, 0.0040179826, -0.0309033412, 0.0869556218, 0.0459696427, -0.0594539195, 0.0053627845, -0.0648240522, 0.0108059486, -0.0216959994, 0.034000542, 0.0254489575, 0.0324102975, -0.0059307432, -0.069881998, 0.0296597611, -0.0081945006, 0.0241697151, -0.0265680198, 0.0125516606, -0.0337143652, 0.063920714, -0.0136901494, -0.0192785282, 0.0175525062, -0.0166993961, 0.0466024242, -0.0042125825, 0.0276640728, -0.0192381963, -0.0336808488, 0.0171259884, -0.0037303255, -0.0687402636, -0.0143064717, 0.0250146445, 0.0172711909, 0.0040095211, -0.0412181094, -0.0381402709, 0.0397232696, -0.0312972479, -0.0278869886, 0.0004874012, -0.023098886, 0.0156085286, -0.0103933616, -0.0245260838, -0.0038557868, -0.0073347869, 0.0400836281, -0.0587690584, -0.045952145, -0.0192132909, 0.0192569066, -0.0103121223, -0.0319512747, -0.0050229756, 2.083129355e-34, -0.0121922689, -0.0404695868, 0.0353072435, 0.0075922934, -0.0270514172, -0.0295370277, 0.054646071, 0.0228671227, 0.0069605373, -0.0246019717, -0.0726917163 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.04571v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.04571v2
Analyzing And Improving Neural Speaker Embeddings for ASR
2023-01-11T16:56:03
2023-09-20T07:43:13
Christoph Lüscher, Jingjing Xu, Mohammad Zeineldeen, Ralf Schlüter, Hermann Ney
cs.CL
cs.CL, eess.AS, stat.ML
Neural speaker embeddings encode the speaker's speech characteristics through a DNN model and are prevalent for speaker verification tasks. However, few studies have investigated the usage of neural speaker embeddings for an ASR system. In this work, we present our efforts w.r.t integrating neural speaker embeddings into a conformer based hybrid HMM ASR system. For ASR, our improved embedding extraction pipeline in combination with the Weighted-Simple-Add integration method results in x-vector and c-vector reaching on par performance with i-vectors. We further compare and analyze different speaker embeddings. We present our acoustic model improvements obtained by switching from newbob learning rate schedule to one cycle learning schedule resulting in a ~3% relative WER reduction on Switchboard, additionally reducing the overall training time by 17%. By further adding neural speaker embeddings, we gain additional ~3% relative WER improvement on Hub5'00. Our best Conformer-based hybrid ASR system with speaker embeddings achieves 9.0% WER on Hub5'00 and Hub5'01 with training on SWB 300h.
[ -0.0510219373, 0.0141416462, 0.0297089219, 0.0355888493, 0.0146784475, -0.0139953401, 0.0262512285, -0.0439925827, 0.0215837508, 0.0209853742, -0.0038500053, -0.0142774088, 0.0146851465, -0.0063043381, 0.0280714966, -0.015309833, -0.0066387975, -0.0149861602, 0.0012234706, -0.0363803841, 0.0174190532, -0.0233248416, -0.0451787561, 0.0429898798, -0.0230420511, 0.0355817899, -0.0072518913, -0.0085453298, 0.0642340332, 0.0007290745, -0.0158881396, -0.0153564876, 0.0997607261, 0.0483497903, 0.0000018257, 0.0364073664, 0.0052404599, 0.0148037653, -0.0942551866, -0.0165901538, -0.0102458857, 0.0149096576, -0.0240124781, 0.0509287231, 0.0058830227, -0.0361654684, 0.0137785142, 0.0595297851, 0.0190161988, 0.02699022, 0.0136848446, -0.0574570037, 0.0112532703, -0.0007589642, -0.030578794, -0.0088927988, -0.0155750485, -0.0455842577, -0.0129116625, -0.0178445801, -0.0037905809, 0.0625979155, 0.0379040651, -0.004288733, 0.0523712896, 0.0084324656, -0.0063148947, 0.0207218174, 0.0000269901, 0.0693708584, 0.0050608316, -0.0240954403, 0.0216101501, 0.0290093701, -0.0486155488, -0.0270452779, -0.0187606458, 0.0021034533, 0.0299551878, 0.005894884, -0.0163477939, 0.0259083584, 0.038582135, -0.0503941737, -0.0247614477, 0.0143976528, -0.0152566005, -0.0630385056, 0.0071788398, -0.0348160379, 0.0562866144, 0.0021743088, 0.0400805995, -0.0228566956, -0.0023438463, -0.0245692544, -0.0042581116, -0.0100754676, -0.0052897027, -0.0589369461, 0.0255238283, 0.0754659027, -0.0477603599, -0.005387031, -0.0396041498, 0.093873702, -0.0101471795, -0.0082262838, -0.0085616987, 0.0183620173, -0.0309840403, 0.0065109991, -0.0335022025, 0.0125503708, 0.0266064461, -0.0601176433, -0.0461117364, 0.0386335365, -0.0187216923, 0.0333520211, 0.0347151384, 0.0102236513, 0.0024953994, 0.0028744703, 0.0213842317, 0.0469733924, -0.0078605944, -0.0099993832, -0.0383537225, -0.0255657844, -0.0471842475, 0.0368009657, 0.0380555987, 0.0038511825, -0.0133904247, 0.0157379918, 0.0178293027, -0.0209635757, 0.0116464151, 0.0323089659, -0.0334398188, -0.017422853, 0.0154447081, -0.030242661, 0.0557087623, -0.0285708141, -0.0186978597, -0.0192877539, 0.012164535, 0.0094695585, 0.0451454744, 0.054260999, 0.0173742343, -0.0235510971, 0.0300732926, -0.0168555453, 0.0057283333, 0.0140344435, 0.0415241495, -0.018560918, -0.0143955145, -0.0644563586, -0.038415011, 0.0247257408, -0.0017971814, -0.0496270247, -0.001480236, -0.0165662654, 0.0291566644, 0.0587512963, 0.0445169993, 0.0159092378, -0.0365861803, -0.0736294612, 0.0300555993, 0.0622000806, 0.049286969, -0.0177716911, 0.0496872365, 0.0117098382, -0.0195169896, 0.0023261853, -0.0212380961, -0.0014926917, 0.0070647015, -0.0071719447, 0.0256254133, 0.0478741974, -0.020432381, 0.0041832947, 0.0019143188, -0.0469625928, 0.0018891925, 0.0430967584, 0.0065451823, -0.0287898947, -0.0200013779, 0.0684191734, -0.0082622226, -0.0487241559, -0.0102175968, -0.0178986192, -0.009329766, -0.001367489, -0.0005300213, -0.0105906548, 0.0267458912, -0.051827006, -0.0093423864, 0.0107862866, 0.0026920545, 0.0073609953, 0.0499778874, -0.0797190517, -0.0328923091, 0.028746387, -0.0208059493, 0.0519455411, -0.0139967352, -0.0025600547, 0.0467587598, -0.007889796, 0.0252639577, -0.0177988391, -0.026027726, -0.0349003002, 0.0068564531, 0.044092074, 0.0590071604, 0.0485670343, -0.028631717, -0.0444531105, 0.0668678731, -0.0590558425, -0.024203686, 0.0240723658, -0.091735445, -0.0290994514, 0.0748967081, -0.037219312, 0.022143878, 0.0348044969, 0.0096110376, -0.056186527, 0.0424034707, -0.0493893735, 0.0456672646, -0.0507307798, 0.0123449098, 0.037508823, 0.0353010185, 0.009068517, 0.001040009, 0.0364525914, 0.0007809261, -0.0078318845, -0.0369283557, 0.0051601822, -0.0953488499, -0.035838265, 0.0247122813, 0.0036199575, 0.0078051123, -0.0234259553, -0.0511870906, 0.0105014658, -0.0298664682, -0.0482092351, -0.0368522443, -0.0099535398, 0.0006789106, -0.0430680849, -0.0052624657, 0.028504651, -0.0133155836, -0.0184444115, -0.0406240933, -0.0299563129, -0.0120297112, -0.0491321422, 0.0031594015, -0.0828582719, 0.0021678135, 0.0082978206, -0.0140487198, 0.0206977762, -0.019477481, -0.0119188083, -0.0160830561, -0.0418236814, 0.0390723236, 0.0241002478, -0.0102901161, -0.0296626817, -0.0013675393, 0.0179218296, 0.0401488617, 0.0406861939, -0.013773961, 0.0085605411, -0.010682134, -0.0095023653, -0.0508462265, 0.0203491505, 0.0377511159, 0.0954731032, 0.0022674103, 0.0204189252, -0.0225389227, 0.0005377974, 0.0001812822, 0.051033143, -0.0218919367, -0.0097337849, 0.0126763163, -0.0406675935, 0.0202828832, -0.0290670488, -0.0400670096, -0.0480282716, -0.0072095315, 0.0106083769, 0.0396397635, -0.0871965364, -0.0441965722, -0.0264314376, -0.0896167085, -0.0186803769, -0.0604663305, 0.031992808, 0.0419956669, -0.0316861086, -0.0280747302, 0.0208786521, 0.0201511011, -0.0117052142, -0.0427672975, 0.0445039272, 0.0737689584, 0.0019014708, -0.0320500098, -0.0416271389, -0.0342580192, -0.025025364, -0.0361373797, 0.0419744365, 0.0056842514, -0.05672675, -0.0095509309, 0.0477279574, 0.0371614881, 0.0079752775, 0.0150902327, 0.0441764928, -0.0379365347, 0.0309670437, 0.0181880035, 0.0758339241, -0.0179110244, 0.0220975056, 0.0197516084, -0.0219652634, 0.0577516109, 0.0077421102, -0.0801602975, -0.0370666757, 0.0198489092, 0.004162671, 0.0062814513, 0.0134535478, 0.0010217819, -0.0094506228, 0.0448565744, 0.111954473, 0.0088400096, -0.013657039, -0.0244267341, -0.0290620904, 0.0168840643, -0.0145170903, 0.0054252534, -0.0558895729, -0.02085522, 0.0738838315, 0.01882983, 0.0335999131, 0.0080787344, -0.0118377646, -0.0490386672, 0.0142144756, 0.0170463212, -0.0493419766, -0.0575267076, -0.0485144109, -0.0483218022, -0.0222238619, 0.0857076272, -0.0108430628, -0.0176029671, -0.0342922248, 0.0387202762, -0.0984338075, -0.0650740936, -0.0054104803, -0.0494447239, 0.0821442306, 0.0237532258, 0.0090245446, -0.0056055603, -0.0861367136, -0.0296130404, 0.020182902, 0.0054082759, -0.0055516479, 0.0340724587, -0.0074427747, -0.0145367309, 0.0166166686, -0.0105781248, 0.0009198033, -0.010191109, -0.0197958779, 0.0834718794, -0.0172848441, -0.0111774961, 0.0250915624, 0.0616968498, -0.0067480393, 0.0791989788, 0.0260822549, -0.0010515333, 0.004222922, 0.0234957095, 0.0920872167, 0.0142889069, 0.0052382317, 0.0074270675, 0.0178743657, -0.0543314256, -0.0017523719, -0.0129931672, -0.0170919318, 0.0328729898, 0.0232735965, -0.013747083, -0.0218297634, 0.0118367216, -0.0335973389, 0.0216519497, -0.0549018607, 0.0361841768, -0.0490867198, 0.0455954783, 0.0499324948, -0.0301660281, -0.0002868083, 0.0061081089, -0.0227994453, -0.0525082126, 0.0252262261, -0.0363382697, 0.0060016965, 0.043607913, -0.0381712839, -0.0624841079, 0.0582441986, -0.0119448118, 0.0010890699, 0.0100004058, 0.0791217685, -0.0218171086, 0.0050604679, 0.0183791984, -0.0218068641, -0.0038586839, -0.0350667164, -0.0096157268, -0.036239896, -0.0385727249, 0.0035473914, 0.0394796431, 0.0173256453, 0.0194646977, 0.0327658094, -0.0279904697, 0.05616441, -0.0229384024, 0.0669849515, -0.0172851756, -0.0393079706, 0.0119921025, 0.0373238288, 0.0183900464, 0.0485200845, -0.0235472359, -0.0002237751, 0.0201038998, 0.0605863295, 0.0320353173, -0.0105665931, -0.0106545798, 0.0331243649, -0.0316505618, 0.0069340472, 0.039190039, 0.0173308942, -0.0230401848, -0.003719565, -0.0257637035, -0.0079549458, -0.0118244486, 0.0385344066, -0.029760696, -0.0117823789, 0.0035745148, 0.0050438405, 0.0296250302, 0.0108509539, 0.0119241774, 0.0431203693, 0.0121383751, -0.0083859125, -0.0077503463, -0.059281908, 0.0204534177, 0.0775277689, 0.0243753027, -0.018355269, 0.0203581341, 0.0183709841, -0.0232739262, 0.0335100479, -0.0449307673, 0.0461188257, -0.0527078472, -0.030156333, 0.0034671982, 0.0256277788, -0.0212045759, -0.0591437072, 0.022899976, -0.0670701042, 0.0451910831, -0.0263900775, -0.0172412489, 0.0109048476, -0.0288003348, -0.0547935329, -0.0157316104, -0.0036471239, 0.0614226051, -0.0472093336, 0.0157052297, -0.0536602885, 0.0295950677, -6.128013314e-33, -0.0197074134, 0.0643760934, -0.0005160297, -0.0423291102, -0.0297825411, -0.0083551686, 0.0198368859, -0.0076316907, -0.0232627299, -0.0334591977, -0.0204587188, -0.0194569286, 0.0327961333, 0.0135881305, -0.0493505038, -0.0034257581, 0.1148741469, 0.004094739, 0.0159196798, -0.0491322502, 0.0380830318, 0.0171470623, -0.0128723439, -0.0407170914, -0.086381793, 0.0171812046, 0.016141681, -0.0154056856, 0.0020456249, 0.0316896476, -0.0153261395, 0.0288724732, -0.0220562425, 0.0116960527, -0.0121885268, 0.0618526936, -0.0621004924, 0.0011492296, -0.0810952857, 0.0677178577, 0.0314215384, -0.0426483005, 0.0322795361, -0.0081302254, -0.0314527489, -0.0218556784, 0.0208385419, 0.0126005979, -0.0282264687, 0.0057691224, 0.037669681, 0.0280654822, 0.0196107384, -0.0107866172, 0.0773518011, 0.0398369357, 0.0160284769, -0.0009250173, -0.116507709, 0.0290253013, -0.008552881, -0.0061262655, 0.0176603701, 0.0287859961, 0.0061054192, 0.0127234263, 0.0811049864, -0.0736004561, 0.0024227195, -0.0686780289, 0.0389942229, 0.0031244992, 0.0239479337, 0.0045149438, 0.0379940383, -0.0140818674, -0.0427580364, -0.0056612906, 0.053710036, 0.0377097167, -0.0040412755, 0.0473601744, -0.0533355884, -0.0091265617, -0.0218353029, -0.0580676943, -0.0015425564, -0.0500266738, 0.0505093075, 0.003858842, 0.0061524967, -0.031591706, 0.0330345407, -0.0539442562, 0.0524947494, 0.0176858976, 0.0055377455, -0.0060866103, 0.0176892262, -0.0039214524, -0.0489332043, -0.0137806777, 0.0725304261, 0.0167548023, 0.0056477785, -0.0513146482, 0.0290935151, 0.0842578113, -0.0438735262, -0.0170693435, 0.0073188809, -0.0195426084, 0.0314817093, 0.0166489687, 0.0445700958, -0.0233571772, 0.0323933773, 0.0215591379, 0.0307661109, 0.0422148965, 0.0225429162, 0.0353030115, 0.0696812645, 0.0174172688, -0.0206671283, 0.020453034, 0.0247526728, 0.0248842146, 0.0199109633, -0.0641370714, 0.0079286722, -0.0233070012, 2.749e-7, -0.0896383375, -0.0029225349, 0.0488376841, -0.0645617396, 0.0156178987, 0.0046337787, 0.0196322426, 0.0029874898, 0.0004639398, 0.0264540911, 0.0080057792, -0.0050399196, 0.0522691309, 0.0170227867, -0.107246317, -0.0437982939, -0.0976907834, 0.0048176832, 0.0078715011, 0.0068651442, 0.0216532275, 0.0812802687, 0.01604563, -0.0296450052, 0.0050989585, -0.0450278111, 0.0310961064, 0.0031879675, 0.0163281765, -0.0485697053, 0.0036858369, -0.0290738214, -0.0201908331, 0.0109104794, -0.0046130526, 0.0978931561, 0.0070227422, 0.0050854157, -0.0102549894, -0.0618854947, -0.0263774153, 0.0601137094, -0.0336609297, 0.0131610502, 0.0529714376, -0.0303850602, -0.0488555916, -0.048319988, -0.0690982789, -0.010316412, 0.0197653491, -0.0045771329, 0.015557956, -0.0089979526, 0.0034239863, -0.0368368253, -0.0116994968, -0.0452014469, 0.0320355184, 0.0449647233, -0.0847789496, 0.0158374887, 0.0044164145, -0.0297598448, 0.0515920185, 0.0313113704, 0.0003078618, 1.881168061e-34, -0.0072165458, 0.0192024875, 0.0451393314, 0.0086112302, 0.0034577867, -0.0461195372, -0.0111091221, -0.0070492271, 0.027066119, -0.0866833478, -0.0315862447 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.04558v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.04558v2
Learning to Exploit Temporal Structure for Biomedical Vision-Language Processing
2023-01-11T16:35:33
2023-03-16T17:12:03
Shruthi Bannur, Stephanie Hyland, Qianchu Liu, Fernando Pérez-García, Maximilian Ilse, Daniel C. Castro, Benedikt Boecking, Harshita Sharma, Kenza Bouzid, Anja Thieme, Anton Schwaighofer, Maria Wetscherek, Matthew P. Lungren, Aditya Nori, Javier Alvarez-Valle, Ozan Oktay
cs.CV
cs.CV, cs.CL
Self-supervised learning in vision-language processing exploits semantic alignment between imaging and text modalities. Prior work in biomedical VLP has mostly relied on the alignment of single image and report pairs even though clinical notes commonly refer to prior images. This does not only introduce poor alignment between the modalities but also a missed opportunity to exploit rich self-supervision through existing temporal content in the data. In this work, we explicitly account for prior images and reports when available during both training and fine-tuning. Our approach, named BioViL-T, uses a CNN-Transformer hybrid multi-image encoder trained jointly with a text model. It is designed to be versatile to arising challenges such as pose variations and missing input images across time. The resulting model excels on downstream tasks both in single- and multi-image setups, achieving state-of-the-art performance on (I) progression classification, (II) phrase grounding, and (III) report generation, whilst offering consistent improvements on disease classification and sentence-similarity tasks. We release a novel multi-modal temporal benchmark dataset, MS-CXR-T, to quantify the quality of vision-language representations in terms of temporal semantics. Our experimental results show the advantages of incorporating prior images and reports to make most use of the data.
[ 0.018467024, 0.0924216285, 0.0318487845, -0.0008788883, -0.0212901719, 0.0105707906, 0.0152303008, 0.0334333889, 0.0082557946, -0.0182523113, -0.018141266, -0.0289371815, 0.034463875, 0.0576507561, 0.0159737803, -0.0514720231, 0.0392090939, 0.0370328277, -0.0199552346, 0.0073398482, 0.0068344255, -0.0054674316, -0.0053039226, 0.0436110385, -0.025971109, -0.0309300274, 0.0054401355, 0.0149099352, 0.0463328585, -0.0546910353, -0.0198305417, 0.0690425262, 0.0478908122, -0.011530743, 0.0000019335, 0.0116155809, -0.0140619054, 0.0115031563, 0.0093299756, -0.0241558757, 0.0265635625, -0.0667472929, 0.0141912457, -0.0374299735, -0.0389479585, -0.0517635718, 0.0450572222, 0.0475033708, 0.0582567491, 0.0540379435, -0.0330674425, 0.0116908923, 0.0264573693, -0.0273641329, 0.0284759272, -0.0308238901, 0.0051684109, -0.0001034096, 0.0171993263, -0.0054199104, -0.0357052237, 0.0617390797, 0.0294565, 0.0055398163, 0.0299874153, 0.0821016282, 0.0168246031, -0.0069085336, -0.0330165401, 0.0542726852, -0.0259245504, -0.0241155867, -0.0185973458, -0.0212191325, -0.039069999, -0.0129949758, -0.0051721628, 0.0054698451, 0.0195494462, 0.0258153882, -0.0296083577, 0.0345389061, 0.0093377857, 0.0196119808, 0.0123148123, -0.0185282044, 0.0236761589, 0.0287462361, -0.0421549007, 0.0193166081, 0.0226954836, -0.0134287169, 0.0031263195, 0.0443481244, -0.0070990711, -0.0147295287, -0.04737534, -0.030184526, 0.0439750552, -0.0513629057, 0.0056032436, 0.0111979609, -0.0888259038, 0.0611847639, -0.0256901346, 0.0347432941, -0.0587981939, 0.0438144952, -0.0288915783, 0.0200066995, -0.0358535163, -0.0136586037, -0.003716433, -0.0063573546, -0.014664053, -0.0219568666, -0.0423405468, 0.0016056129, 0.003586137, -0.0287874192, 0.0184144285, 0.0886924267, -0.0776599646, -0.0191633794, -0.0243111327, 0.0422279276, 0.0577685386, 0.0008139125, -0.0385802947, -0.0313386172, -0.0165971126, 0.0343083069, 0.0187020451, -0.0300787129, 0.0047796303, 0.0362154059, -0.0541848317, -0.0346633904, -0.0060197162, -0.0189636666, -0.0595646054, -0.0225897618, 0.0240092706, -0.0678039789, 0.0488318726, 0.018768521, -0.0024027948, -0.0182724223, 0.0055689439, -0.0177166313, -0.0149183022, 0.1130751073, -0.0060322531, -0.0393366888, 0.0344101898, 0.0041826768, 0.0771099702, 0.0279052146, 0.0364371352, -0.0161451306, -0.039489314, 0.0183192827, -0.0077492604, 0.0083854664, 0.0084184986, -0.0256040636, -0.0825095177, -0.0137005942, 0.0076981271, 0.064633958, -0.0018028023, 0.0242237132, 0.0085316682, -0.0389252044, 0.0385806449, 0.029411735, 0.0179348439, -0.0056545744, 0.0347336195, -0.0329530612, -0.0006735629, -0.027012147, -0.0085493037, 0.0427652337, 0.0567755401, 0.0144947162, -0.0586780198, 0.0349095464, -0.026835639, -0.0201180708, -0.0017321095, -0.0176057275, -0.0057405019, -0.0108010676, 0.03305443, 0.0052233082, -0.0501950346, 0.0511439294, 0.036769364, 0.003791204, -0.0091039194, -0.0272874124, -0.0245975126, 0.0631945729, 0.0341921039, -0.0148202563, -0.0400041938, 0.0026129566, 0.0357325673, 0.0554056726, 0.0078856051, 0.0250513535, 0.0578695275, -0.0465381145, -0.061435733, 0.0183327254, -0.0065658698, -0.0453620031, -0.0126112271, 0.0035302415, 0.0005058883, -0.0226674918, -0.0030796656, 0.0646605343, 0.0013831161, 0.0048545944, -0.0127579607, 0.0240151081, -0.0002732766, -0.0247880481, -0.0302218441, 0.000778339, 0.040440537, -0.0506315567, -0.0225345343, 0.0416188315, -0.0863619223, -0.0708793327, 0.0300588645, -0.045769807, -0.0232276414, -0.002362963, -0.0311114825, -0.0274054743, -0.0291810092, -0.0253415536, -0.0033710259, -0.0373675078, 0.0168389175, 0.0307506472, 0.032471478, -0.0389250852, 0.0468927845, -0.0138259297, -0.0338215567, -0.0119938264, -0.0147788515, 0.0278698988, -0.0073964112, -0.0191794485, 0.0093446597, 0.0187778492, -0.0064973431, 0.0206148904, 0.0182846934, -0.0250170883, -0.0136761572, -0.1039266512, -0.0382471606, 0.006375819, -0.0343028419, 0.021252837, 0.0079232631, 0.0314909443, -0.0560778566, -0.0488675348, 0.0097208442, 0.0327498503, 0.0100685051, 0.0870742202, 0.0215952229, 0.0331649892, -0.0200425442, -0.010979278, -0.040588364, 0.0608393811, 0.0161322504, -0.0643135905, 0.0107189473, -0.0228654891, -0.0431504212, 0.0339298174, -0.0086352983, -0.0201881342, 0.013739517, -0.0110543016, 0.0284589473, 0.0493643098, 0.0338586234, 0.0585597232, 0.0408750176, 0.0218300056, -0.0217243638, -0.0203695595, -0.0460483655, -0.00598998, -0.0230114534, -0.0024016956, -0.044225093, 0.0472001769, 0.0111075705, 0.0224589426, -0.0617449619, -0.0218897164, -0.0201612338, -0.0087886285, -0.0265329853, 0.0349019282, -0.0381492227, -0.0046665017, -0.0516657978, -0.0767076388, 0.0869095623, 0.0165700447, -0.0031099133, -0.0047676209, -0.0121012665, -0.0429828987, 0.0727036446, 0.0563633218, 0.0420830287, 0.0285200179, 0.0043133614, -0.035581436, 0.0125631951, 0.0150010213, -0.026303323, 0.0554761067, -0.0288248118, 0.0529100671, 0.0005110533, -0.0343167558, -0.035150364, -0.0442569852, 0.0050286674, -0.0262699444, -0.0801121369, 0.0152014196, -0.0601426139, 0.0057433108, -0.0309486426, 0.0723277107, -0.009628213, -0.0166654028, -0.014772472, 0.051833827, 0.0274293125, 0.0312029067, -0.0176698845, -0.0320861116, 0.007866147, 0.0596552901, 0.0285400059, 0.0173899587, -0.0547629297, 0.0431807898, -0.0095515801, 0.0350708142, 0.0289581586, 0.0443406738, 0.0357538834, -0.07598342, -0.0187667422, 0.0534823984, 0.0151364664, -0.0735840723, -0.0121459272, 0.0366896503, -0.0120741697, -0.0039275778, -0.0055167964, -0.051789403, -0.032647837, -0.0475836582, -0.0287000779, 0.0009170044, -0.0019021302, -0.0216526352, -0.0012423355, 0.0414416157, 0.007997565, -0.0040793126, -0.0055455132, -0.0060048196, -0.0257261321, -0.0323812738, -0.0168027971, -0.0448454432, -0.002042854, -0.0201558266, 0.0105213253, -0.0130260559, -0.0831559598, 0.0082939574, 0.002650921, -0.002466979, 0.0470404737, 0.0260812249, -0.0254816785, -0.0577255934, 0.0297304988, 0.0203636605, 0.0273066796, 0.013017904, 0.0914070383, -0.0190712456, -0.0461739451, -0.0120202452, 0.024570059, -0.0109445071, -0.0349883959, -0.0510588139, 0.0521635115, -0.0247233752, -0.0154084656, -0.0513941571, -0.0010195579, 0.0031849097, 0.0074991938, -0.0324930847, -0.0090409527, -0.0373510383, 0.0276189074, 0.0769426674, -0.0306966733, -0.0360047892, 0.0131656425, -0.0204048026, -0.0070896032, -0.0431828983, -0.0242242962, 0.0073294956, 0.0264631175, -0.0096997656, -0.0153542925, 0.0113153299, -0.0275956076, -0.1151351407, 0.0856313556, 0.0292333122, 0.0111959819, -0.0440041572, -0.0267318357, 0.0574419387, 0.0042780624, -0.010742465, 0.0351594053, -0.1041040272, -0.0225212481, -0.0064436276, 0.0386183225, 0.0021333564, 0.0447942987, 0.0228307843, 0.0055035637, 0.0833875239, 0.0682634041, -0.0204233956, 0.0052364552, -0.0190983899, -0.0629196912, -0.0425098203, 0.0176738985, -0.0099924654, 0.0077256658, -0.0040622395, 0.0045940843, 0.0088973781, -0.0203045085, 0.0506403185, -0.0359131619, 0.0679938942, -0.0432760864, 0.0167592447, -0.0138854599, -0.016084468, -0.0221585855, 0.0196648091, -0.0508334264, -0.0014491807, 0.0249395724, 0.0124768279, -0.0063671991, 0.0515419431, -0.0309645776, -0.0253943205, -0.0247986019, 0.0148364231, -0.0057391101, -0.0291030407, 0.0009739492, 0.0141277164, 0.0095235771, 0.0154952081, -0.0094672013, -0.0187596399, -0.0109429397, 0.0251585748, 0.0490767807, 0.0594528317, -0.0408596992, 0.0448815189, -0.0380129702, 0.0230820533, -0.0458741859, -0.0074059367, 0.0407972001, -0.0312963687, 0.0465808511, 0.0075622313, -0.0171016697, -0.015961187, 0.052985657, -0.0178601462, -0.0052479394, 0.0790712759, -0.0158364717, 0.0123953549, -0.0109429108, 0.0763258785, 0.0361279547, 0.0366395563, 0.0199595541, -0.0136972396, -0.0384895243, -0.0210886355, -0.0151540181, -0.0632792637, -0.0333781093, 0.0299150385, -0.0150637524, -0.0385585986, 0.0612477362, -0.0122327218, -0.0326714218, 0.0136023508, 0.0512589961, 0.0333610363, 0.0328984186, -0.042127613, -0.0006449801, 0.0209865514, 0.0581288375, -0.0219735708, -0.0101590399, -5.938422973e-33, 0.0001671127, -0.0523796864, 0.0338699333, -0.037186116, -0.0066413851, 0.0650280789, -0.0436434932, 0.0041840919, -0.0041386117, 0.0522134304, 0.0148675153, 0.0028636879, 0.0178983882, 0.0587345362, 0.0025019771, -0.003648896, 0.0204825606, -0.042590104, -0.0071915057, 0.0065412777, 0.0016008583, 0.0487879887, 0.0700888112, -0.0583071895, -0.0238439292, 0.0407694951, -0.0051949732, 0.0004303465, 0.0406015329, 0.0484427139, -0.04337712, 0.0063826572, 0.0339007117, -0.0122158015, -0.0283685997, -0.0236109737, -0.0835339427, -0.024686832, -0.0198428147, 0.0054708589, -0.0998051912, 0.010252933, 0.0363684818, -0.0473002866, -0.0051091113, -0.0488906875, 0.0565188453, -0.0064756772, -0.0044947588, -0.0353985839, -0.0389381871, 0.0404988825, -0.0148724001, -0.0194342602, 0.0440092087, -0.0072571356, 0.0076987268, 0.0486832708, -0.0291267559, 0.0181395579, -0.032351315, 0.0249275882, 0.0598923117, 0.00616547, -0.0094004925, 0.0651815683, 0.0160125457, -0.0322529003, -0.0330974907, 0.0202650242, -0.0023913644, 0.030547373, 0.0411305241, 0.0204758439, 0.0172796696, 0.0001130008, -0.0684807077, 0.0205798857, -0.0758842453, 0.044684086, -0.023736814, 0.000464455, 0.021131156, 0.0110919951, -0.0036097304, 0.0122453282, -0.0168945976, 0.0063881488, 0.0312887914, 0.028788846, 0.0197742097, 0.0689400509, 0.0296603478, -0.0110912425, -0.0344224982, -0.0084819812, 0.0128420694, 0.0309320074, 0.0069342526, 0.0355733819, -0.0278548021, -0.0035983401, 0.0655101538, 0.0254298188, 0.0285875723, -0.0217282027, 0.0364600047, 0.016045507, -0.045399908, -0.0126258628, -0.0194334369, -0.0385630764, -0.0028494203, 0.026737174, 0.0334706344, 0.0169707481, -0.0493950956, 0.0558011532, -0.0165523123, -0.0071266056, -0.033376012, -0.0096806688, 0.0202579312, 0.0580223016, 0.0005234926, -0.0134108765, -0.0678856671, 0.0197886024, 0.0630319044, -0.0397047773, -0.0175372865, 0.0339441262, 2.652e-7, 0.0935776681, 0.0226270035, 0.0480961278, -0.0216909908, 0.0084048947, 0.0143188685, -0.0419861488, 0.0367375799, -0.05224666, -0.0163190681, 0.0295646898, 0.0537842251, 0.0180272013, -0.0055891355, 0.0346356779, 0.0281736236, -0.075090833, -0.0347669944, -0.0320579223, -0.043009948, 0.0532968789, 0.0787176564, -0.0433070101, -0.0355942585, 0.0405876152, -0.0294024181, 0.1076810881, -0.01399046, -0.0106241861, 0.0228077415, -0.0216311309, 0.0118604163, -0.0211338028, 0.0197603498, -0.021342203, -0.0384848602, 0.0079883803, 0.0296353661, -0.0617100261, -0.0379306711, 0.0045344587, 0.0618666336, -0.012480434, -0.0182502307, 0.0495542213, -0.0888149887, -0.0217487123, -0.040169701, -0.0064005922, 0.0698938817, 0.0959572941, -0.0078784768, -0.0575465709, 0.0387925468, 0.0431166291, 0.0084843216, -0.0627783909, -0.0904231742, -0.0496745482, 0.0132548241, -0.0361188278, 0.0317582563, -0.0370031856, -0.0328936242, 0.0540181957, -0.0534537658, -0.0362727791, 2.113087701e-34, -0.0057495483, -0.0190989021, -0.0118319746, 0.0024931636, -0.0196505133, -0.0149685508, 0.0235556439, -0.0061269412, -0.0226005502, -0.0197451804, -0.0120652951 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.04535v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.04535v2
Few-shot Learning for Cross-Target Stance Detection by Aggregating Multimodal Embeddings
2023-01-11T15:52:55
2023-03-31T12:39:09
Parisa Jamadi Khiabani, Arkaitz Zubiaga
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.SI
Despite the increasing popularity of the stance detection task, existing approaches are predominantly limited to using the textual content of social media posts for the classification, overlooking the social nature of the task. The stance detection task becomes particularly challenging in cross-target classification scenarios, where even in few-shot training settings the model needs to predict the stance towards new targets for which the model has only seen few relevant samples during training. To address the cross-target stance detection in social media by leveraging the social nature of the task, we introduce CT-TN, a novel model that aggregates multimodal embeddings derived from both textual and network features of the data. We conduct experiments in a few-shot cross-target scenario on six different combinations of source-destination target pairs. By comparing CT-TN with state-of-the-art cross-target stance detection models, we demonstrate the effectiveness of our model by achieving average performance improvements ranging from 11% to 21% across different baseline models. Experiments with different numbers of shots show that CT-TN can outperform other models after seeing 300 instances of the destination target. Further, ablation experiments demonstrate the positive contribution of each of the components of CT-TN towards the final performance. We further analyse the network interactions between social media users, which reveal the potential of using social features for cross-target stance detection.
[ 0.0024319629, 0.0216026884, 0.0229651928, 0.0143816471, -0.0048424583, 0.0207627993, 0.0027931589, -0.0043243836, -0.0427042544, -0.0773580298, -0.0304842647, -0.0355178416, -0.0116263488, -0.0253572483, 0.0447236858, -0.011035094, 0.0712574795, 0.0300111845, 0.0013547631, 0.0119790472, 0.0712497681, 0.0572517663, -0.0375422873, 0.0471744053, -0.0452943891, -0.0158349853, -0.014567107, -0.0023499476, 0.0922544152, -0.0272620115, 0.010231792, 0.0371063761, 0.0710881948, 0.0387297235, 0.0000018203, -0.0064829472, -0.0352390967, -0.0094419792, -0.0195417535, -0.0230340026, 0.0004772994, -0.0889810473, 0.0208857078, 0.0058649303, -0.0470740646, -0.0010983269, 0.0159744229, 0.0529213101, 0.0478963442, 0.059380319, -0.0096560596, -0.0429309346, 0.0111292154, -0.0329214334, -0.0124925543, -0.0691427663, -0.024012316, -0.0233897939, -0.0502992049, 0.0743789896, -0.0432428196, 0.0023815858, -0.0036151432, 0.0035999503, -0.0190108176, 0.038618125, 0.0064113908, 0.0097388783, -0.0054450477, 0.0775492713, -0.0200767554, -0.0073917685, -0.0034283081, -0.0382470377, 0.0123105934, 0.0015973684, -0.0298200194, -0.0228479132, 0.0146446545, 0.0469428487, -0.0387284383, 0.0197680965, 0.0068890774, 0.0207661521, 0.0230120961, -0.0300456248, -0.0517577492, -0.0037284158, 0.0304798298, 0.019196311, -0.0134048443, -0.0416907184, -0.0313335881, 0.0334430374, -0.0265985597, -0.0030312806, -0.0645299777, 0.0158093274, 0.0310080349, -0.0011347556, 0.0339305326, 0.0081458194, -0.0115069542, 0.0765002444, -0.0126583502, 0.0131954104, -0.0505054817, -0.0175465476, -0.0031832231, 0.0249429122, -0.07691966, -0.0047013406, 0.0003525626, 0.011473651, 0.0105583146, -0.0640957952, -0.0501725636, -0.0178364441, -0.0207519736, -0.0121555254, -0.0126114003, 0.0341149494, 0.001620722, 0.0030867709, 0.0336575285, 0.0547532886, -0.0002571158, 0.021345159, -0.0101379398, -0.0096574081, -0.0233014505, 0.0099915983, 0.0152011691, -0.0337116383, 0.0140199717, 0.030615529, 0.0062786969, -0.044872418, 0.0374438241, -0.0219779555, -0.038768921, -0.0610795319, 0.0109947426, -0.0467809588, 0.0774250403, -0.0120178973, -0.002368984, -0.0128023745, 0.0006005032, 0.0376792029, 0.0156427193, 0.0935126469, 0.0486191139, -0.0247364305, -0.0008264728, 0.0067346902, 0.0245004762, 0.109307453, -0.0128514878, 0.0323615894, 0.0024362262, 0.0148383314, -0.0067755682, 0.0130104674, 0.0479044802, 0.0019548894, 0.0173905492, 0.0083237719, -0.0475060865, 0.0023650879, 0.0216202829, 0.0177692361, -0.0263789948, -0.0633783937, 0.0518733412, 0.0222586859, 0.0050443197, -0.0274712071, 0.0344868489, 0.0487545021, -0.0082762418, -0.0312622823, -0.0251580421, 0.076723069, -0.0294638462, -0.0280024372, 0.0169058535, 0.0450843684, -0.0331304148, -0.0077920994, 0.0041182046, -0.0058891149, 0.0134565756, -0.0082157776, 0.0310780015, -0.0042119934, -0.0621727258, 0.0394934975, 0.0388171002, 0.0077736336, -0.0267082024, -0.0043516741, -0.0250282306, -0.0171225406, 0.0017792099, -0.0269362144, -0.0503639989, -0.0532485954, 0.0214077737, 0.0256348196, 0.0356429443, -0.032512933, 0.0176432617, -0.0248409417, -0.0405789167, -0.0525493808, -0.0006278747, 0.0345124975, 0.0020462093, 0.0332410224, 0.0142740291, 0.0274943672, 0.0966528058, 0.0273443907, 0.0506411344, 0.0128767826, -0.0116443839, 0.0458159968, 0.0346860848, 0.0589134172, -0.0093653928, -0.0291695371, 0.0112559265, -0.0207431167, -0.0349312387, -0.0093679391, 0.0030485094, -0.0501112863, 0.040324185, -0.0007287672, -0.0286731403, 0.0351142436, -0.0464788042, 0.0198766235, 0.0327156149, -0.0572148748, -0.0256658308, -0.0359722078, -0.0579063594, -0.0226704571, 0.0236874372, 0.0060184817, 0.0416370332, -0.0239579976, -0.0373502597, -0.0133449584, -0.0339218453, 0.0352695137, -0.0174845159, -0.02743439, -0.0384462513, -0.0135407727, 0.0027390767, 0.0007311484, -0.0204263721, -0.0230251756, 0.0046634474, -0.0844535008, -0.0078475531, -0.0309321936, -0.0154121602, -0.0121735847, -0.0223056879, 0.0306592174, -0.0106904814, -0.0317953229, 0.0047150296, 0.0048340699, 0.0354241058, 0.0171949565, -0.0058159409, -0.0006961906, -0.041616369, 0.0245355517, -0.0095060645, 0.0579737499, -0.0309398975, -0.0802555904, 0.0016454743, 0.0042977426, -0.0351888314, 0.0140077062, -0.0128456354, -0.0393824056, 0.0622356087, -0.0087115755, -0.0078184502, 0.0354395807, 0.0157241151, 0.0603251755, -0.0150439823, 0.0211820304, -0.0516343452, 0.0046407944, -0.0063374797, 0.0445331596, -0.0384047665, 0.0295260064, -0.0071953298, 0.0488527045, -0.0019175457, 0.0133565776, -0.0540505126, 0.030021565, -0.0094369045, -0.0274944957, -0.0385644585, 0.0084367357, 0.0164775699, -0.0255044792, -0.0277532134, -0.0172412694, 0.0623131096, 0.0082618911, 0.0018203217, 0.0418818519, -0.0169028137, -0.0215768516, 0.0614580326, 0.0244775452, 0.0107955961, 0.029780874, 0.0180482361, -0.000782953, -0.0439571664, -0.0006632645, -0.0131316949, 0.0011684747, 0.0663689598, 0.0285873879, -0.0061116354, -0.0296188593, 0.001774717, -0.0906206742, -0.0644142702, -0.0137300203, -0.0483929552, -0.0080545321, 0.0174074527, 0.0145581942, 0.0240632016, -0.0291228946, -0.0158155486, -0.0123998942, 0.0219481513, 0.0166222565, 0.0449370854, -0.0484297648, -0.0237961989, -0.0294914301, 0.0045261499, 0.0799259692, 0.0077855587, 0.0189654585, -0.0450959094, -0.0438564643, 0.0052868836, 0.0444273874, -0.0316080377, -0.0372910015, 0.0872417018, -0.0177015271, 0.0478521846, 0.0712921992, 0.0202171095, -0.0081603881, 0.0127858389, 0.0993036851, -0.0310299285, 0.0130174635, 0.0033429509, -0.0792228207, -0.0624404661, -0.0300279614, -0.0168200824, 0.0144732539, -0.0057847695, -0.0146408929, -0.0941998065, -0.0082550673, -0.0260884333, -0.0605713874, -0.0143897347, -0.0299479757, 0.0286805276, -0.0381930172, 0.0264163222, -0.0152821755, 0.0175081883, -0.0290765222, 0.0113104666, -0.0253210738, -0.0214665476, 0.0102849817, -0.0380361937, 0.0343541466, 0.015937753, 0.0472895652, -0.0144503079, -0.0333696194, 0.0106166871, -0.0037600938, 0.0279314648, -0.0028094498, 0.0622687116, -0.0440073982, -0.0316665694, -0.0073894532, 0.0295587834, 0.0088496096, -0.0316402242, -0.0806927979, 0.0312968604, -0.0033792988, 0.0085211182, -0.040364746, 0.050143633, 0.0407812782, 0.0189009719, 0.0214220155, -0.0624436811, -0.0397002921, -0.0174042247, -0.0355530754, -0.0819115862, -0.0549493395, -0.0193339735, -0.0121315755, 0.0012631089, -0.0306392778, -0.0318919942, 0.017777767, 0.0443180501, -0.0563589372, 0.0034526652, -0.0236676801, 0.0213526599, -0.0203906558, 0.0160656217, -0.0001542275, 0.0907486454, 0.0276692547, 0.0086339843, 0.0539067201, 0.0117281573, -0.0202514697, -0.0215300154, -0.0841978639, -0.0442412011, -0.0569875576, 0.0345498025, 0.0024829663, 0.0269998387, 0.0100495825, -0.0295243245, 0.0590414517, 0.083306618, 0.0097799497, 0.0328920335, 0.0447869338, 0.0120253647, -0.013876236, 0.0337447934, -0.017140042, -0.0080179656, 0.0437825806, -0.0402013622, -0.0643219054, 0.033843141, -0.0087627182, -0.0690129474, 0.0514069274, -0.016636733, -0.0509926192, -0.0114215948, -0.0351172611, -0.0069909701, -0.0263194144, -0.036071606, -0.0152710993, 0.0107838791, -0.0552790537, -0.0191198085, -0.0064995647, -0.0061363084, 0.0981469378, -0.0793649256, 0.0346965268, 0.0491340384, 0.0041611362, -0.0128888926, 0.0245541111, -0.0216717198, -0.023936715, 0.0135311745, -0.0335212387, 0.0058341334, 0.0428008363, 0.0025178243, -0.0115824062, -0.0123770181, 0.0406912491, -0.0151548078, 0.045401454, -0.0333255306, -0.0072280969, 0.0320465975, -0.0091628581, 0.0207174104, 0.0338448808, -0.0243044514, 0.0045728921, 0.0326256081, -0.0759210438, -0.0345658101, 0.0504635908, 0.0543086082, 0.0073910635, 0.009767809, 0.0531687252, -0.0268162638, 0.0089158844, 0.0396535322, -0.0100124618, -0.0209292714, 0.0097384686, 0.0333144814, 0.0575534031, 0.0161612798, 0.0189295076, -0.0433938578, -0.0538727753, 0.0224794094, 0.026408853, -0.0099615613, 0.0718417913, -0.0045650327, 0.0397469252, 0.0275143739, 0.0267114975, -0.0498035736, 0.0061939736, 0.0051750159, -0.0267888121, 0.0152429724, -5.915720136e-33, 0.0027388036, -0.024817124, -0.0106415255, -0.0037915013, -0.0397764109, 0.031370718, -0.0056356695, -0.0037217352, -0.0036943008, 0.0489947237, 0.0101114046, 0.0280558579, -0.0111090494, -0.0025709637, -0.0023725925, 0.0063013765, 0.0043893927, -0.0286506917, -0.0110950023, 0.0144596519, 0.0508916192, -0.0226222444, 0.0297417864, -0.0702532008, 0.025762666, 0.0328526385, -0.0453596152, -0.0078820903, 0.0205784962, 0.0958769098, -0.0076773595, 0.0112580396, 0.0379861444, -0.0473663472, 0.0031461709, 0.0780688375, -0.0298846625, 0.020901978, -0.0217067786, 0.0179958828, -0.0108225765, 0.0171530154, -0.0193669833, -0.0294926837, 0.0043971888, -0.0368981846, -0.015082865, 0.002952402, 0.0414808914, -0.0484663509, -0.0565274134, 0.0388669409, -0.0274173245, -0.0504821017, -0.0068236068, 0.0358131193, 0.0584888458, 0.0246919468, -0.0508580729, 0.0112144174, -0.0965229869, -0.0192213543, 0.0249315426, 0.0169398747, -0.0106595196, 0.083941333, 0.0070332722, 0.0163080133, -0.0143382847, 0.0247200076, 0.0233799312, 0.0430645309, 0.0728776157, 0.0876266584, 0.0256360751, -0.0144169983, -0.0982800052, 0.0078963479, 0.0536445267, 0.0090088267, -0.0034588228, 0.0514571443, 0.0077167307, -0.0116124926, 0.004962082, -0.0512942038, -0.0137393083, -0.0277547687, -0.0192134175, 0.0513015129, -0.0500264131, 0.0677521005, 0.073316291, -0.0403736494, -0.0138462782, 0.0680961609, -0.0151853664, 0.0393597707, 0.0134824822, -0.0122821964, -0.0127329305, -0.0266248174, 0.0378142707, -0.0197765026, 0.0287047606, -0.0146061452, 0.0926105529, 0.0129191522, -0.0592759624, -0.0450640954, -0.015979778, 0.0035600082, -0.0428012721, 0.025441708, 0.0241177864, 0.0226535406, -0.0303771682, 0.0555123761, -0.006892323, -0.0232306477, 0.0060817557, 0.0247957874, -0.0360837281, 0.0052995062, 0.0018965637, -0.0200106166, -0.0023540298, -0.0091875969, -0.0048062308, -0.0756115094, -0.002740629, 0.0167074986, 2.497e-7, 0.0172760505, 0.0328312218, 0.0133332666, -0.0034210361, 0.0585113391, 0.0708923563, -0.0212797187, 0.0611520782, 0.0119943321, -0.07081718, -0.0132105798, 0.0781305656, 0.01838989, 0.0543104336, -0.0519802496, 0.0278456528, -0.0298412219, -0.0219232496, -0.0471454747, 0.0120822359, -0.0383217111, 0.0691444576, 0.032984674, -0.0219958909, 0.0066410662, 0.0223730952, 0.0543494038, 0.0051903715, -0.0336219333, -0.0487267897, 0.0000939464, -0.070574075, -0.020426495, 0.0111935697, -0.0382523388, 0.0238008127, 0.022809688, 0.031864997, -0.0051093977, -0.043964576, -0.0158078317, 0.0145760309, -0.0222591218, -0.0011776136, 0.0949190333, -0.0900427774, -0.0299541969, -0.0716842338, -0.0251755826, 0.0338730104, 0.0524237752, 0.0109947314, -0.0266330019, 0.0066028186, 0.0174137633, -0.0316493995, -0.0038780842, -0.0960014835, 0.0031609195, 0.0101615945, -0.0447665378, -0.0093844356, 0.0356179848, -0.0553453974, 0.0504020676, -0.0135337338, -0.0548768155, 1.570979668e-34, 0.0165945794, -0.0274989121, 0.0401245542, -0.0366435163, 0.0026291977, 0.025790045, -0.0511318035, -0.0318795443, 0.0568142571, -0.0430874117, 0.0022630428 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.04528v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.04528v1
The Role of Interactive Visualization in Explaining (Large) NLP Models: from Data to Inference
2023-01-11T15:46:52
2023-01-11T15:46:52
Richard Brath, Daniel Keim, Johannes Knittel, Shimei Pan, Pia Sommerauer, Hendrik Strobelt
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.HC
With a constant increase of learned parameters, modern neural language models become increasingly more powerful. Yet, explaining these complex model's behavior remains a widely unsolved problem. In this paper, we discuss the role interactive visualization can play in explaining NLP models (XNLP). We motivate the use of visualization in relation to target users and common NLP pipelines. We also present several use cases to provide concrete examples on XNLP with visualization. Finally, we point out an extensive list of research opportunities in this field.
[ -0.0079165651, 0.0536984056, -0.0415391028, 0.0356031172, -0.0045261532, -0.0053055962, 0.0021722063, 0.0096918633, -0.0083685284, -0.0106507512, 0.021335274, 0.0221267194, 0.0254543535, 0.0316235498, 0.0419643931, -0.103793107, 0.0027818421, -0.0197594203, -0.000537342, 0.0407268777, 0.0047192737, 0.025571622, -0.0340232253, 0.101264447, -0.0180683527, -0.059980303, -0.0343757123, -0.0045053754, -0.0297407284, -0.0451670326, -0.065355964, 0.0216045044, 0.0457785986, 0.0187922083, 0.0000020501, -0.0112543097, -0.0010898103, 0.0162703022, -0.0898637697, 0.0524171181, 0.0132546974, -0.0353530422, 0.0270986035, 0.0086433496, -0.0238202438, -0.0014459005, 0.065268293, 0.0511222966, 0.0666538924, -0.0145414928, 0.003261633, -0.0100464737, -0.020155983, -0.0029984524, -0.0095933676, -0.0114358058, -0.0256563127, -0.0107354159, 0.0213417318, 0.0279027075, -0.0166799761, 0.0152954608, 0.0194937326, -0.0413591526, 0.0380466655, 0.0171354637, 0.0097134812, -0.0502703041, -0.0185903125, 0.0589758791, -0.0301943179, -0.0268155448, -0.0151496045, -0.0253266506, 0.0132481819, 0.0484086946, -0.0847823992, -0.0105242701, 0.021662036, 0.025583392, -0.0083856657, 0.0011420094, 0.0596052259, 0.0115875835, -0.0096164588, 0.0417859256, -0.0037601294, 0.0188025851, -0.0235542171, -0.0143019687, -0.0280437581, -0.0299727954, 0.0203381814, 0.0644557327, -0.0245659109, 0.0385743976, 0.0358225405, -0.0308458116, 0.0125984726, -0.0412207022, 0.0942845568, 0.0036043571, -0.021544626, 0.0244680755, -0.0041269092, 0.0439437516, -0.0035068642, -0.0120616211, 0.0168470275, 0.0124368854, -0.06046113, -0.0561563969, -0.0333782025, -0.0484529175, -0.0340690315, -0.0190832764, -0.0136482846, 0.0116223805, -0.0337443314, -0.0019748751, 0.0220142212, 0.0419776365, -0.0097265625, 0.0108549967, -0.0764194578, 0.0169496816, -0.0652482137, -0.014501377, -0.0049115294, -0.0484905988, -0.0142764114, 0.0060512163, -0.0008500153, 0.0048510456, -0.0385421962, 0.0715782568, 0.0334355235, 0.0055795419, -0.0238509607, -0.0209526047, -0.0153884981, -0.003316534, -0.0057683643, -0.0285883043, 0.0056331716, 0.0126907658, 0.0039348342, -0.030902518, 0.0003586227, 0.0229966175, -0.0415027551, 0.1047339812, -0.0396305807, 0.0191010293, -0.0202362277, -0.0262041222, -0.0043799216, 0.0511035137, 0.0289670732, -0.0369120091, 0.0196352024, -0.0463280566, 0.0365316607, -0.0186223369, -0.0054864325, -0.0013271908, -0.0332976952, -0.0457319058, -0.0423103832, 0.0522281826, 0.007274088, -0.0084420322, -0.0347259641, 0.0034700108, 0.0344006605, 0.0763480365, 0.0674106777, -0.0042755408, 0.025095772, 0.0205718074, 0.0027348259, 0.0289339237, -0.0320111178, 0.0345968902, -0.005722627, 0.0030850382, -0.0209583789, 0.0227931682, 0.0164440274, -0.0646770149, -0.0638130307, 0.0374264903, 0.0214214344, -0.0000974261, 0.0345912986, 0.0605836138, 0.0158807263, 0.0452105813, 0.0630529672, -0.0483870544, -0.0092312573, -0.0416567251, 0.0165067501, 0.0814637318, 0.0432183743, -0.0225911364, 0.0153437452, 0.0228521302, -0.0184552111, 0.0481785983, 0.0342371874, 0.0105882091, -0.0086066229, -0.0080736624, -0.038805306, -0.0494380295, 0.0278297421, 0.0017234745, 0.0276223961, -0.0512943231, 0.0081968466, -0.0688676909, -0.054070726, 0.0337723233, -0.0276957005, -0.0033850232, -0.0054253782, 0.0184030309, -0.0142041445, 0.0691079423, 0.0355226807, 0.0463117138, 0.0202253237, -0.0049444181, 0.0111006442, 0.0172759555, 0.013632508, 0.0032474999, 0.0132035278, -0.0436547473, 0.0124956081, -0.0038112726, -0.0111983391, -0.0327527374, 0.0233506095, -0.0540205315, 0.0634391233, 0.0071938261, -0.0129727628, 0.0005775841, 0.031202713, -0.0416431427, 0.0596812479, 0.0321156904, 0.0085846437, 0.026979642, 0.0345472842, 0.0052038035, 0.004601181, 0.0128561566, 0.0152576994, -0.003641417, -0.0133934272, 0.004441381, -0.0333778895, -0.0202926993, 0.0389854349, -0.0240707956, -0.0331715047, 0.0010871053, -0.0038429175, 0.0366748758, -0.0107634701, 0.0071533397, -0.0357508473, -0.006146933, 0.0143232727, -0.01068216, 0.0075695338, 0.0735226646, -0.0121619003, -0.0174327902, -0.0447646566, -0.0240673386, -0.0396013595, 0.0911882967, 0.0405876413, -0.0196216926, -0.074196741, -0.0172439497, 0.0224735569, 0.0006638757, 0.0081067076, 0.0133651905, 0.0657862648, -0.0075010718, -0.002974557, 0.0352374651, -0.0216984134, 0.1261050701, 0.0500649102, 0.0023886634, -0.065169856, -0.0082609933, -0.0378479809, 0.0301566906, -0.0115380865, -0.0339571238, 0.008417258, 0.0651404038, -0.0014653094, -0.0016815749, -0.0442588851, 0.0403221585, -0.0230888389, 0.0310965199, -0.0457702726, -0.0474888198, 0.0019120502, 0.0650777817, -0.004482409, -0.055152975, 0.0570280589, -0.0726681054, 0.0340061113, -0.0264507327, -0.0416899137, -0.0485278107, 0.1164166257, -0.021796301, -0.0106190313, 0.0373621024, -0.0308180209, 0.0138466069, -0.0107811149, 0.0240326636, -0.0137336552, 0.0237820018, -0.0393556431, -0.0354137868, 0.0200306196, 0.0109452121, -0.0170443822, -0.0264224485, -0.028785985, 0.0048901835, 0.0560030192, -0.0463785045, -0.0011792026, 0.0260485671, 0.0343459621, -0.0181252081, -0.0097496137, -0.0121758441, -0.0229977835, -0.0030377787, 0.0185115598, 0.0447208434, 0.0499909408, -0.0445136987, 0.0020480682, 0.0209377818, 0.0115301069, 0.031672582, -0.0855403244, 0.0017896852, 0.0062888162, -0.0198819991, -0.0120045412, 0.0067758705, 0.0557878688, -0.0584413409, 0.0254558101, 0.0905200839, 0.0457580276, -0.0484052747, 0.0564195886, 0.0036207794, 0.0423689038, 0.0345269777, 0.0194704998, -0.0355046764, -0.0201139357, 0.0031388816, -0.0003910259, 0.0107787447, -0.004505306, -0.0156689025, -0.0961404741, 0.0248020887, -0.0152573735, 0.0013169893, -0.0088258749, -0.0977255479, -0.0008868971, -0.019776199, 0.0390480869, -0.0303306375, -0.0041125994, 0.0249876622, 0.0203254055, -0.027861679, -0.0318796225, -0.0065965005, -0.0378395766, 0.010517179, 0.0200251844, 0.0442754813, -0.0018012783, -0.0303202104, 0.0290626232, 0.0142504973, 0.0855834559, -0.0085092504, 0.104541719, 0.0321635604, -0.0185587239, -0.0555995815, 0.0013131268, -0.0036058903, -0.0399544649, -0.0570982471, 0.044744581, -0.0214593858, 0.001699727, -0.0222876612, 0.0067153787, -0.0342963263, 0.0487105511, 0.0845335349, -0.0278579537, -0.0466080382, -0.056495782, 0.0204737205, -0.0195637587, -0.0695971847, 0.0183916148, 0.0293403771, -0.038904842, -0.0265968312, -0.0120132873, 0.0417257845, 0.0318851396, 0.0319549516, 0.0033258742, -0.0109233707, -0.0333196558, -0.0000496897, 0.0821135789, 0.0117827272, 0.022826517, 0.0299086981, -0.0318494178, 0.0183751062, -0.0108713768, -0.0013202165, 0.0308270883, -0.0462075621, -0.0413688719, -0.0260474738, -0.015256132, 0.0246208031, 0.0340442993, -0.0241333302, -0.1143271849, 0.0053891167, 0.0079050623, -0.0075551118, -0.0661083087, -0.0220262595, 0.0133740138, 0.0201065317, 0.0263490994, 0.0028200045, -0.0117227407, -0.0394140445, 0.0373510905, -0.0590679459, -0.0118644405, 0.0425917245, -0.0151220495, 0.0501812808, -0.0067092045, -0.0519632064, -0.0170827974, -0.0237769783, -0.0289231595, -0.0320415013, -0.0245138891, 0.0204896387, 0.0258852914, -0.051041536, 0.0261276364, -0.0246337485, -0.0092802076, 0.0149299372, -0.0553155541, 0.0472138412, 0.0287743136, -0.05337492, -0.0269679502, 0.0313632935, 0.0116348499, 0.0102843409, -0.0696315914, 0.0116331065, 0.0240395069, 0.0482918769, 0.0005124878, -0.0090849074, -0.0350602008, 0.0075880061, -0.0737788528, -0.0619283728, 0.0350237489, 0.0048140264, 0.0218697246, -0.0299265198, 0.072308287, -0.009212058, -0.012473315, 0.0438221805, 0.0541808233, 0.0155659718, -0.015513178, 0.0118835894, 0.032651674, -0.0377014279, -0.050152, 0.058974497, 0.0166339148, -0.0041158823, -0.0034686746, -0.0156514924, 0.0024073077, 0.0046442603, 0.0234253034, 0.035733521, -0.0087266024, 0.0226752032, -0.0691300556, -0.0735738128, -0.0246586185, -0.0129178502, -0.0256549828, -0.0154532744, 0.0153777227, 0.0551857725, -0.0077654896, -0.0268544909, -0.0389482975, 0.0165567026, 0.0022978433, -0.011187206, -0.0184779689, -6.275166472e-33, -0.0076063769, -0.0928898901, -0.0111630578, -0.0293249954, 0.0168722328, -0.007657886, -0.042794507, 0.0137162283, -0.0450893231, 0.0274148267, -0.0036272553, 0.0230516065, -0.0036870295, 0.0273071527, -0.0161783621, -0.0156399328, 0.0442241877, 0.0364944041, -0.0162477102, -0.0029215706, 0.0348083787, 0.0162542388, 0.0411127359, -0.0668981746, 0.071955815, 0.05396742, -0.0126676904, 0.0106812157, -0.0297345985, 0.0672067627, -0.0423974134, 0.0405400954, 0.0199016519, -0.0729193464, -0.0259858463, 0.0171273462, -0.0417384654, -0.0082970234, 0.0352112912, 0.0275853183, -0.0430611372, -0.0275343973, 0.05130006, -0.0070091453, -0.0049689524, -0.020578308, 0.0508867726, -0.0022215862, -0.0399739444, 0.0365444422, -0.0196767393, 0.0322559997, -0.0575905032, -0.001863698, 0.0387231, -0.0013578747, -0.0153908711, 0.0223848801, -0.0239803493, 0.0049453042, 0.0529819168, 0.0202409364, 0.0656141937, 0.0138578769, 0.0123974457, 0.0493788123, 0.012997455, -0.0006534809, -0.060204614, -0.0016726322, 0.020655103, 0.0776287615, 0.0930408388, -0.0330418497, 0.015628323, 0.0182367843, 0.0032814126, -0.0109135071, -0.008981538, 0.0120386528, 0.0469634607, 0.0160945728, -0.0323853344, -0.0246237088, -0.0639092401, -0.080506593, -0.0441290475, -0.0172788929, 0.0034721808, -0.0315581039, -0.0326671787, 0.0041842568, -0.0499929041, -0.0358562991, -0.0442844629, 0.0247852057, 0.0095614484, 0.0198882706, 0.0023929465, -0.024469329, 0.0280145891, -0.0095734252, -0.0214934312, 0.0196518749, 0.0305915661, 0.0168814212, 0.0435997583, -0.0251780469, -0.0223819744, -0.0085208612, -0.0607866906, -0.0574244373, -0.0053021275, 0.001100225, 0.0582596548, 0.0127649773, -0.0529227816, 0.0411593057, 0.0149148507, 0.0378642455, 0.01598607, 0.0035508554, -0.0395571403, -0.0082337372, 0.0072878608, -0.0480226204, -0.0384388193, -0.0003785998, 0.0800239593, -0.0643778145, -0.0421963856, -0.0065242257, 2.43e-7, 0.0781401396, 0.0685173497, 0.0454290621, 0.031768661, 0.0182643682, 0.0014352436, -0.0004113587, -0.0401251093, -0.0307118595, -0.0383130163, -0.0544020571, 0.0360413529, 0.0571646169, 0.0273556449, -0.0278093591, -0.0338845775, -0.0657440796, -0.0192554481, -0.066008158, 0.0274342168, 0.0721021444, 0.0707752928, -0.0050263135, 0.005644239, -0.0073172273, -0.028773101, 0.0104418471, -0.0389129221, 0.0218568612, -0.0215671752, 0.0326115116, -0.0051604658, 0.0403883755, 0.0026726627, -0.0261751134, -0.0049978429, -0.0214703176, 0.0263726581, -0.0123264836, -0.0206885859, -0.0275137872, -0.0298597105, -0.0082467953, -0.061377909, 0.0672726259, -0.0203257781, -0.0430141576, -0.0262609981, 0.0305641871, -0.0199312959, 0.0355068222, -0.0220453739, 0.0113867112, 0.0349054188, -0.0224013552, -0.0366487429, -0.0268835127, -0.0530156456, -0.0614660569, 0.0006985418, -0.0214366857, 0.0470918901, -0.0366245359, -0.0339372158, 0.0426901914, -0.018290136, -0.0126195019, 2.310710801e-34, 0.031023128, 0.0268124454, 0.0382212475, 0.0304441992, 0.0653904825, 0.0157963429, 0.0246482324, 0.0060768267, 0.0554053932, -0.0637334138, -0.013098388 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.04521v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.04521v1
Deteksi Depresi dan Kecemasan Pengguna Twitter Menggunakan Bidirectional LSTM
2023-01-11T15:37:48
2023-01-11T15:37:48
Kuncahyo Setyo Nugroho, Ismail Akbar, Affi Nizar Suksmawati, Istiadi
cs.CL
cs.CL
The most common mental disorders experienced by a person in daily life are depression and anxiety. Social stigma makes people with depression and anxiety neglected by their surroundings. Therefore, they turn to social media like Twitter for support. Detecting users with potential depression and anxiety disorders through textual data is not easy because they do not explicitly discuss their mental state. It takes a model that can identify potential users who experience depression and anxiety on textual data to get treatment earlier. Text classification techniques can achieve this. One approach that can be used is LSTM as an RNN architecture development in dealing with vanishing gradient problems. Standard LSTM does not capture enough information because it can only read sentences from one direction. Meanwhile, Bidirectional LSTM (BiLSTM) is a two-way LSTM that can capture information without ignoring the context and meaning of a sentence. The proposed BiLSTM model is higher than all traditional machine learning models and standard LSTMs. Based on the test results, the highest accuracy obtained by BiLSTM reached 94.12%. This study has succeeded in developing a model for the detection of depression and anxiety in Twitter users.
[ 0.0465371758, 0.0182291716, -0.0059769051, 0.0267753098, -0.0170536358, 0.0305722393, 0.0198073518, 0.0301267914, 0.0581505932, -0.0422802456, 0.009940289, -0.0518681221, -0.0405857041, 0.003885106, -0.0300491676, -0.0587165058, 0.0023276571, 0.0578870624, 0.0362334326, -0.0220505968, 0.0261296071, 0.0328424722, -0.0057651945, -0.0159488115, 0.0032468201, -0.0184988454, 0.0234295279, 0.0300660767, 0.0311699547, -0.0685744584, 0.0207587834, 0.0009883457, -0.0220465232, 0.0479899384, 0.0000024397, 0.0064607738, -0.0173290279, -0.0392346382, 0.0146999471, -0.059222661, 0.0583148263, -0.0089397784, 0.0293052569, 0.0302101802, -0.0679529682, -0.0184379686, 0.0063296556, 0.1348249912, 0.0866543874, 0.0775079057, -0.020639278, -0.0290016923, -0.0131252948, -0.0266325679, 0.0278883688, -0.049243968, 0.0674963668, -0.0798772648, -0.0046978202, -0.0165634062, -0.0100986268, 0.0508215353, -0.01380233, 0.037181057, 0.0053411457, -0.0068533928, 0.036615409, -0.035774257, 0.0293899979, 0.059067551, -0.0140299229, 0.0190495886, 0.0403530709, -0.0145277781, -0.0112513732, -0.0020022211, -0.00013882, -0.0044557299, -0.0296221673, 0.0564579479, 0.0107383691, 0.0088008847, 0.0249736551, 0.0225091763, 0.0111623229, 0.0416742489, -0.026133474, -0.0460659713, -0.020356888, -0.0150631042, -0.0457382463, -0.062869519, 0.0578857623, 0.0443646498, -0.0221497975, 0.0075389314, -0.0038861262, -0.094654426, -0.0177394878, -0.0292094201, -0.0286972746, 0.020477647, -0.0498361923, -0.0119516272, 0.0006699531, -0.0087389769, -0.0058542662, -0.0325921327, -0.0051313583, -0.0079920404, -0.0358276069, 0.0191149674, -0.014625241, 0.0423936434, -0.0078746928, -0.0180978067, -0.0798736513, 0.0062427679, -0.0114487223, -0.0330942459, 0.0116014257, 0.0223748013, -0.0060969149, 0.003898035, 0.0304471776, 0.0311981961, -0.002478234, -0.0045827557, -0.0272023212, -0.0264710132, 0.0483340509, 0.005574388, 0.0606451482, -0.0394213609, -0.0066145808, 0.0018179516, 0.0513701327, -0.0434258282, -0.1156289726, -0.0144748241, -0.0126761794, -0.0376122221, -0.018834535, -0.0128307566, -0.0168852936, -0.0051222155, 0.0012140332, -0.0504221022, 0.0301466975, 0.0216636993, -0.0055020731, 0.0536631197, -0.0505895689, -0.0003083815, 0.0338915288, 0.0275017265, 0.0597588047, 0.049335517, 0.0382454135, 0.0765160397, 0.0311769303, -0.012764967, 0.0181237459, -0.0187613573, 0.036889445, -0.0357034467, 0.0236860085, -0.0484875627, -0.0610032715, 0.0193612762, -0.0279195327, 0.0316371806, 0.018886812, 0.0471400879, 0.0619314052, 0.0627436489, 0.0674376711, 0.0332182832, 0.0097523853, 0.0443360247, -0.0383749269, -0.0333090685, 0.0098528909, 0.0090010678, -0.0380931161, -0.0067058732, -0.0013408195, -0.0148798916, -0.045809187, -0.0410953984, -0.0299894176, -0.0486152135, 0.0137597686, -0.0148469256, 0.0261039361, -0.0362065732, -0.0558296181, 0.0359455571, -0.0027994867, -0.0222029015, -0.027509544, -0.0392620303, 0.0167260058, 0.0381672718, -0.0175630134, -0.03153795, 0.0154340491, -0.015219057, 0.0330631174, 0.0497242734, 0.0114634577, 0.0457345843, -0.0015773888, -0.0459297411, 0.0173063725, 0.0356786996, -0.0010078807, 0.0185147021, -0.0352540985, 0.0830363929, -0.0027086088, 0.0216079745, -0.0048096152, 0.0232429542, -0.0220057536, -0.0357018299, 0.0391401909, 0.0170506537, 0.0342735276, 0.0342022255, 0.0124359475, -0.0101119848, 0.0147630861, -0.0416958556, -0.0963946506, -0.0059885909, -0.0264728684, -0.030038422, 0.0168329477, 0.0099770091, 0.0043179221, 0.102543816, -0.0300718807, -0.0494284518, 0.0824163035, -0.0288285352, 0.0123170754, -0.0169784874, -0.0080809202, -0.0059304009, 0.0544543341, 0.009811555, 0.037072733, -0.0126231797, 0.0178076122, -0.0332410857, -0.0427056439, -0.0127812624, -0.0226561483, -0.076760225, -0.0523794852, -0.0101120928, 0.0081032673, -0.0168343745, 0.0082840733, -0.0156166581, 0.0060555334, -0.0678131133, 0.0225134064, -0.0198314302, 0.0274043363, -0.0094314143, 0.0309234783, -0.0196504761, -0.0065735173, 0.0069666984, 0.0305267479, 0.0398679674, -0.0012168899, 0.0578079224, 0.0172787923, 0.0082712518, -0.0289926063, -0.0036524739, -0.0348802395, -0.0004760938, 0.0135776419, -0.0921284556, 0.0028116386, 0.0234771539, -0.0069677178, 0.0242217202, 0.0289060101, -0.0524828285, -0.0388295278, -0.0224534348, 0.0234828722, 0.0256197881, 0.0328469425, 0.0288761649, -0.0174568798, 0.0082854358, 0.0090563977, 0.0423401706, -0.0055597988, 0.0016271733, 0.0081959609, -0.0165177267, -0.0055940663, 0.0546116307, 0.0311887469, 0.0060977316, -0.0219928641, -0.0248707309, -0.028205594, 0.0421272293, -0.0124978498, 0.0204292163, -0.0223654192, 0.0146051561, 0.0001385112, -0.0065684854, 0.0150088295, 0.0393107906, -0.0100098327, -0.0351357162, -0.0298473444, -0.0286987424, -0.0028738156, 0.0033804681, 0.0165255312, 0.049761232, -0.0304081105, 0.0443692952, -0.0676951781, -0.0424557626, -0.0434465818, -0.0279224906, 0.0081877224, 0.0035716281, -0.016821038, -0.0044543552, -0.041063752, -0.0538933985, -0.0545183793, -0.0377792642, -0.022204265, -0.011375959, 0.0071351943, -0.02443479, 0.0174556654, 0.0075679529, -0.015505055, -0.0270120297, 0.0147765633, 0.0378565006, 0.0511260517, -0.0508408211, -0.0017367082, -0.0064057433, 0.0462299027, 0.0304924678, -0.0198464897, 0.0541891865, -0.0222379006, -0.008276769, -0.0095647732, -0.0314717442, -0.0042576739, 0.0178409852, 0.0102843056, -0.0023819583, 0.0141434595, 0.1313497573, 0.0029784576, -0.023651801, -0.0172225963, -0.0159665588, -0.0619498529, -0.0074678143, -0.0091601713, -0.0636111945, -0.0276870206, -0.0700785518, 0.03319332, -0.0099328971, -0.0193716791, -0.0025128156, 0.0047750301, -0.0015457991, -0.0189509615, 0.0243108273, 0.0026228228, -0.0229368843, 0.0015108738, 0.0024768377, 0.0016072365, -0.0204226393, -0.0176162701, -0.0026040194, 0.0266456567, -0.118988052, -0.0214009415, 0.0450759865, -0.0213618372, -0.0023613838, -0.0059884614, 0.1046736166, -0.0234959666, -0.018140113, 0.0058829808, -0.0401506312, 0.0198749956, -0.0347650796, 0.0656109154, -0.0036098608, -0.0129509596, -0.0551418215, 0.0280917604, -0.1119647399, 0.0292579047, -0.0291165709, 0.0750747547, -0.0002201071, -0.0598357804, -0.0205954928, 0.0267473869, 0.0340870246, 0.0319824778, 0.0387497954, -0.0535315834, -0.0536974445, 0.0307315886, -0.0295715127, -0.054387439, -0.0365647115, -0.0127476733, -0.0166770723, -0.0654964149, -0.0521983132, -0.0394255891, -0.015324465, 0.0036595436, -0.0353069268, 0.0174651854, 0.0280325022, -0.0118014785, -0.0280488823, -0.0093877232, 0.0191933513, 0.0240108483, -0.0095628249, 0.0267275199, 0.046976082, -0.0203965437, 0.0136065753, -0.0320827067, -0.0759146661, -0.0246586408, 0.0402153172, -0.0451263003, 0.013651398, -0.0278632194, -0.0028103907, -0.0405558199, 0.038416151, 0.03506561, -0.0144718783, 0.0023058117, 0.0413988382, 0.0599061958, -0.0003496795, 0.0448679514, 0.0156767499, 0.0582292527, 0.037521854, -0.0593417361, -0.0477297679, 0.0456398912, -0.0279172957, 0.0333258659, 0.0436334647, 0.0402868874, -0.0954695642, -0.0325572155, -0.0501543805, -0.0021222774, -0.0204994902, -0.0163652766, -0.0126890531, 0.0465412736, -0.0209863819, -0.0686324611, -0.0593277924, -0.0109505802, -0.063188307, -0.0697111636, 0.0324110426, 0.0049628192, 0.0454697348, -0.031604372, 0.0126995975, -0.0151238078, -0.0155177321, 0.0182385799, 0.0033838332, 0.0077041886, 0.0776364207, -0.0262551289, 0.0097078662, 0.025273582, 0.0346854925, -0.0222230107, -0.0350700803, -0.0235425178, -0.0516172759, 0.0735220164, -0.0129984785, 0.0650101751, 0.0075825383, 0.0332068205, -0.0050443592, 0.0602895617, -0.0500711128, -0.012562654, 0.0279562864, -0.0147031182, -0.0124056451, -0.0005897962, 0.0242262557, -0.0176157057, 0.0071942331, 0.0606902875, -0.013867368, -0.0255456269, 0.0789791644, 0.0213176794, 0.038596224, -0.0060404907, 0.0294494182, -0.005123477, -0.0694006383, 0.0817813352, -0.0466206856, 0.0201131031, -0.0268762335, 0.0262488928, 0.0125113865, 0.0576208383, 0.021012662, -0.0559457429, 0.024741279, 0.0077919625, -0.0273160432, -0.0842575729, -7.048214169e-33, 0.006191602, -0.018676497, -0.0188299306, 0.0143198008, -0.013406653, 0.0056000319, -0.0410611928, 0.0196101833, -0.0308767408, 0.0065718428, 0.0015435437, 0.0834339783, -0.0060222531, 0.0390013605, 0.0093724821, -0.0277349558, 0.0095390696, 0.0021729532, 0.0417125151, 0.0470271781, 0.0411356278, 0.0802139714, 0.0643377602, -0.0969028249, 0.0038923454, -0.0352042392, -0.0065480177, -0.008267601, 0.0625102222, 0.0021757053, -0.0467037596, 0.0908555686, 0.060993094, -0.0044027437, 0.0144142723, 0.0395117551, -0.0150622688, -0.06870801, -0.0351904444, 0.0103490194, -0.0504610352, 0.0013981641, 0.0500913486, 0.0098130088, 0.0096464027, 0.014015398, 0.0472573452, 0.01703934, 0.0436895341, -0.0067044008, -0.0137130907, 0.0363073573, 0.0052592885, -0.0013110983, 0.0131896213, 0.0116713643, -0.0152446944, 0.0144074969, -0.0700111166, -0.0241433121, -0.0459758677, -0.0017759918, -0.007364885, -0.055468902, -0.0464863554, 0.0133508574, 0.0251070261, 0.0045524295, 0.0163598936, 0.0215788595, -0.0253006108, 0.0053059645, 0.0520291552, 0.003056274, 0.0757674202, -0.0422116891, -0.0609964468, 0.0116986567, 0.0486321934, 0.0356284454, 0.0323991701, 0.0154339205, -0.0101506729, -0.0144333867, 0.0617519543, -0.042244412, -0.0482876226, -0.0228059236, -0.0084797945, 0.0078042774, -0.003131811, 0.0059446115, -0.0081562465, -0.0274966452, 0.0091196466, -0.0047278441, 0.0046977568, 0.0326067284, 0.0192436185, -0.0027859805, -0.0176340137, -0.0292187203, -0.0164761823, 0.0705462173, 0.0191679057, 0.0015377143, 0.0019266339, -0.0006182684, -0.0194287095, -0.0245847795, 0.0174414236, 0.0070789228, -0.0284622218, 0.0559399016, -0.0546426848, 0.0105149783, -0.0033528628, 0.0763936788, 0.0134116625, -0.0155707113, -0.0802365169, -0.0228287037, 0.0089754649, -0.0342806317, -0.0219304021, -0.0388006419, -0.0064983098, 0.0600992702, 0.025616819, -0.075944908, -0.0230719, -0.012308713, 3.203e-7, 0.0494858548, 0.0367383547, -0.0002000165, 0.0061493292, 0.0335681997, 0.0209932998, 0.0279423185, 0.0315103456, 0.0254263729, 0.0132945357, 0.0012076956, 0.0083475262, 0.017654568, 0.0326795988, -0.0546425954, -0.0266109724, -0.028232649, 0.0064049982, -0.0415996686, 0.0334871002, 0.084295772, 0.0402947553, 0.0337576978, -0.023457367, 0.0150515651, 0.0070292139, 0.0262122694, -0.0083666705, 0.044567056, 0.0186327621, 0.0483461842, 0.0011109684, 0.0172029976, -0.0301733464, -0.0153696211, 0.0066563091, -0.0136543578, -0.0008113298, -0.0529071093, -0.014162764, 0.0287666991, 0.0248696115, 0.0064098854, 0.0057918271, 0.0661192536, -0.0438920297, -0.073560372, -0.011281536, -0.0020598271, -0.0350413769, 0.0423992611, 0.0177692212, -0.0316251852, 0.0072071906, 0.0109628728, -0.0155911855, -0.0201964695, -0.1004076749, 0.0074320342, -0.005935437, -0.0571329705, 0.0158304702, -0.0224852301, 0.0277375635, 0.0405778475, -0.0576109625, 0.0266045462, 2.665396936e-34, 0.0200273935, 0.0224411022, -0.0157767124, 0.02186298, -0.0035191136, 0.0357405059, -0.0566513799, -0.0106650395, 0.0188369397, -0.0777289048, -0.0295996349 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.04449v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.04449v1
Diving Deep into Modes of Fact Hallucinations in Dialogue Systems
2023-01-11T13:08:57
2023-01-11T13:08:57
Souvik Das, Sougata Saha, Rohini K. Srihari
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI
Knowledge Graph(KG) grounded conversations often use large pre-trained models and usually suffer from fact hallucination. Frequently entities with no references in knowledge sources and conversation history are introduced into responses, thus hindering the flow of the conversation -- existing work attempt to overcome this issue by tweaking the training procedure or using a multi-step refining method. However, minimal effort is put into constructing an entity-level hallucination detection system, which would provide fine-grained signals that control fallacious content while generating responses. As a first step to address this issue, we dive deep to identify various modes of hallucination in KG-grounded chatbots through human feedback analysis. Secondly, we propose a series of perturbation strategies to create a synthetic dataset named FADE (FActual Dialogue Hallucination DEtection Dataset). Finally, we conduct comprehensive data analyses and create multiple baseline models for hallucination detection to compare against human-verified data and already established benchmarks.
[ 0.0564990118, 0.0192849748, -0.0063433894, 0.0149671715, -0.0366040953, 0.0216378346, -0.005350926, 0.0219233837, 0.0477945469, -0.0239146687, 0.0022764904, -0.0181661788, 0.0063480437, 0.0357958414, -0.0004646168, -0.0594363548, 0.0477747731, -0.0092675686, 0.0074155708, -0.0186161064, 0.0199942831, 0.018215416, -0.0437492356, 0.023928497, -0.0637470409, -0.0416704156, -0.0163429193, 0.0188457333, 0.0138110109, 0.0022094639, 0.0255695079, 0.0590113737, -0.0217898451, 0.0645126626, 0.0000018595, -0.028692225, 0.0074012512, -0.0200908687, -0.0596897118, -0.0177857373, -0.0155957062, 0.0347971246, -0.0173212476, 0.004446317, -0.0487430468, 0.0073741418, 0.0343817659, 0.1251936555, 0.0867596939, 0.1139374003, -0.0076398188, -0.0126403812, 0.0373469703, 0.0425669178, 0.0379093178, -0.0026827967, 0.0323806815, 0.0521565042, -0.0216240622, -0.0119136507, -0.0051629161, -0.010625354, 0.0273608211, -0.0147456024, 0.0467509031, 0.021252133, -0.0812901631, -0.0275816042, 0.0039267638, 0.1057944223, 0.0046790955, -0.0537811145, 0.0141410055, 0.0096836146, 0.046499338, -0.0148511482, -0.0120557789, -0.0280870665, -0.0565827526, -0.0146682234, -0.0406300724, -0.0290408712, 0.0112994798, 0.0102623934, -0.0244852807, 0.0585807078, -0.0054795709, -0.0375265069, 0.0267052911, 0.0091649573, 0.0033822649, -0.0644599423, 0.035686858, 0.0250877142, -0.0577055849, -0.0131154619, -0.0575870574, 0.0255644191, 0.0135356979, -0.0840241686, -0.0447156951, -0.0173249505, -0.0567032211, 0.0594894961, -0.0112249097, 0.0375850387, -0.0132284164, 0.0318555944, 0.0089137647, 0.0029636202, -0.0325253382, 0.0013531024, -0.0520134717, 0.0168340281, -0.0125916302, -0.0242491327, 0.0001049021, 0.0144963637, -0.0429798774, 0.0356589481, -0.0133315763, 0.0587395839, 0.0002512877, -0.0154085914, -0.0352996029, 0.0401255414, -0.0281803738, 0.0021042079, 0.0394419096, -0.09065523, -0.0424596667, 0.0201369841, 0.0045911772, 0.0050356928, 0.0123859579, -0.0035640025, 0.0430484116, -0.0011978219, -0.0213334728, -0.0480620004, -0.0295550637, -0.0771546364, 0.0106503982, -0.0436088182, 0.0242093075, -0.0275538433, -0.0300206169, -0.0228663981, 0.0128920423, 0.0148561448, -0.0427113175, 0.0584067851, -0.0632059127, -0.017779693, 0.0405615158, 0.0352153741, -0.0458516963, 0.0640001446, -0.0052336389, 0.0214790478, 0.0324674919, -0.0120775038, 0.0481838435, -0.0238080695, 0.0266779829, -0.0113357045, 0.0253644995, 0.0042920252, -0.0253221188, 0.0401730798, 0.017624395, 0.0190175623, -0.0495807454, -0.0470122695, 0.056419909, 0.001536848, -0.0349830538, 0.0250907056, 0.0087513281, 0.0225704163, 0.043709673, 0.0539243817, -0.0609804094, 0.013609468, -0.024650706, -0.0169125367, 0.0291726924, -0.0077092163, -0.0358889252, -0.0283074267, 0.0296571255, -0.0116267279, 0.0539709628, -0.0172729976, 0.009134138, 0.0486876033, -0.076800026, 0.0621950515, 0.0226828121, -0.0345263295, -0.0223902278, -0.0239648428, -0.0242078379, 0.074203603, 0.0579051822, -0.0198030267, -0.0398163572, -0.035073135, 0.0408743359, 0.0679571405, 0.0286909044, -0.0157796443, 0.0120920343, -0.0453477353, -0.0006521424, -0.0127584096, 0.031868007, 0.0124182506, 0.0042218682, 0.0154189058, -0.0008312206, -0.0059918053, 0.008358757, 0.0186840352, 0.0046732659, 0.0412805639, -0.0257153809, -0.0194381271, 0.0241673328, 0.0264138859, 0.0014324412, 0.0047110757, 0.0222966112, 0.0210442413, -0.0521730296, 0.0248751733, -0.0378249064, -0.0708760098, 0.0517271198, 0.0010046057, -0.0207751766, -0.0015150541, -0.020471124, -0.032639645, 0.0237659272, -0.0455823839, 0.0640484169, -0.0206552912, 0.03215928, 0.006961525, 0.0588081665, 0.0418806635, 0.0733132437, -0.0246224571, 0.0000591841, -0.0039851931, 0.0155895986, -0.002333256, -0.0197782088, 0.0216448065, 0.017656453, 0.0067170281, -0.0021806324, -0.0042515746, -0.0603832528, -0.0907770768, 0.0160272848, -0.1250325143, -0.0199411847, -0.0192134958, -0.022340592, -0.0011120229, -0.0197465084, -0.0078423452, -0.0291652437, -0.0211664606, 0.0190518033, 0.0016200941, 0.0331569575, 0.0118194129, -0.001484773, -0.0277904738, -0.0024321431, 0.0484251603, 0.0074891117, 0.0266958755, 0.0022658512, -0.0312127154, -0.0748634264, 0.0493068285, -0.0678416118, 0.0390303023, -0.0124051385, -0.020153787, 0.0250060111, 0.029563671, 0.0573791824, 0.0887710154, 0.0475059152, 0.0683706179, 0.0100760134, -0.0427840091, -0.031802699, 0.0162239689, 0.0013612874, 0.0519208945, -0.0211742278, -0.0005668448, -0.002526772, 0.0182338953, 0.0096250707, 0.0239139311, -0.0623262338, 0.0259821098, 0.0016740652, -0.0623695813, 0.0453556031, -0.0085269148, -0.0413216054, 0.0059285411, -0.0454042293, -0.0135536622, 0.0955441743, -0.0085508237, 0.0060393908, 0.0134199439, -0.0026683721, 0.0221002735, -0.002718193, 0.0026375584, -0.0093905888, -0.0121251466, -0.0126280356, -0.0315646715, -0.0051567829, -0.0157338288, -0.0571538508, -0.0208902005, -0.0112046851, -0.008650871, 0.050753139, -0.0084155882, -0.0654804632, -0.0149548911, -0.0105211567, -0.037539985, -0.0214696527, -0.0191087909, -0.0367591828, -0.0199229419, -0.0154694365, 0.0242197178, -0.0241237711, 0.0006092555, 0.0279473513, 0.006456675, 0.0584215708, 0.0197253134, 0.0573700443, -0.0047563021, 0.0536922663, 0.0920648128, 0.0344015211, 0.0147180576, -0.0171946641, -0.0324142911, -0.0368483327, 0.0097031398, -0.0149520971, -0.0360158794, 0.0496424437, -0.0377920382, -0.0195053574, 0.1001944691, 0.0148516614, -0.0306863859, 0.0119782267, -0.0269410536, 0.0515273884, -0.0008207539, -0.0166880134, -0.0896333829, -0.0102416361, -0.0092567839, -0.0051328433, -0.0426508337, -0.0643144175, -0.0138849597, -0.0764221326, 0.0064105312, 0.005933587, -0.0101099322, -0.0745092556, -0.024585221, 0.0134979552, 0.0192111209, 0.0303986948, -0.0195535086, 0.0693844333, -0.0222687889, -0.0014133702, -0.0171209238, -0.0092906989, 0.0192810278, -0.0074727018, 0.0947097018, 0.0400818437, 0.0889235362, 0.0308388192, -0.0201892983, 0.0189888328, -0.0015989025, -0.0183243621, 0.0035699683, 0.0814891532, 0.0013052443, 0.0125172427, -0.0167137235, 0.0127161704, -0.0122287823, -0.0136912297, 0.0044408655, 0.0431780033, -0.0577664264, -0.0355088562, 0.0097452141, 0.0564943142, 0.0394721478, 0.0523618981, 0.0319992267, -0.0117873, -0.0348117761, -0.0304908697, 0.0506620333, -0.0309379771, -0.0281472337, 0.0277288519, 0.0391045399, -0.0050393334, -0.0978346393, -0.06202114, -0.0155506274, 0.0251408871, -0.0463384762, 0.030273404, -0.0134576466, 0.0056531262, 0.0186524801, 0.0339740291, -0.0333872624, -0.007841574, -0.0182313379, -0.0229825042, 0.003928314, -0.0131797586, 0.0178632196, 0.018443333, -0.0743741095, -0.0655679703, 0.0299463943, 0.0430165492, 0.0200632028, 0.0848557055, -0.0316439122, -0.0067112236, 0.0307556763, 0.0366292819, -0.0455392227, 0.0156371817, 0.0560402088, 0.0147153866, 0.0034231697, 0.0352969952, -0.0283440575, 0.0051415567, -0.0105863167, 0.0164979678, -0.0525356345, -0.024507463, 0.0262881331, -0.0178925563, 0.0189191997, 0.0154079506, 0.0199613534, -0.0109017491, 0.0036163335, -0.0356867984, -0.0135323191, -0.030760698, 0.0079408363, 0.0090944106, -0.0180147607, 0.007309298, -0.0186732132, -0.0429406017, 0.0156743303, -0.0094137769, -0.0733927935, 0.0373219065, -0.0106074344, 0.0325004756, -0.0263232086, -0.0223243944, 0.0172546692, 0.0139805637, 0.0265499856, 0.0269041918, 0.072045356, 0.0143137686, -0.0583666302, 0.0159216728, -0.0013750837, -0.0546006486, -0.0431210957, -0.0205451865, 0.06020974, 0.0249992572, 0.0217795745, 0.0505455025, -0.0124425618, 0.0082012955, -0.0038564552, 0.026697943, 0.0172110479, -0.044053752, -0.0372722857, 0.0318910852, -0.0291550197, 0.0406426452, 0.0448552705, -0.0195159856, 0.067058973, 0.0085668089, -0.0204338115, -0.040200606, -0.0547201037, -0.0603163429, 0.0042058341, 0.0081698857, 0.0066716629, -0.0519429334, -0.0633065328, -0.0081472965, -0.0042659151, 0.0071803252, 0.0064218477, 0.0273735113, 0.0496904142, -0.0224748217, -0.0115225064, -0.0188353341, 0.0061107674, 0.0119953407, -0.0097480984, 0.0030664492, -6.142727565e-33, -0.0154159116, -0.0539410003, 0.0018020509, 0.0105868112, -0.0463274457, -0.0328531452, -0.0264684502, -0.0061765658, -0.0139914276, 0.0433954671, 0.0031144118, 0.083348088, 0.0027679626, 0.0081666186, -0.0521723218, -0.0417091362, 0.0459421426, -0.0004050596, -0.0261849687, 0.0681486204, 0.0427048095, 0.010591724, 0.0402324684, -0.0902111605, 0.0274530612, -0.027426064, -0.0294740461, 0.0306598488, -0.0082729151, 0.0257927794, -0.0098878788, 0.0506627373, 0.0043067103, -0.0392794833, -0.0225935075, -0.0077027292, -0.0441989154, -0.0278802849, -0.0202925727, 0.0530166067, -0.0068528033, -0.0077493186, 0.0284947399, -0.0303324368, 0.0421618149, -0.0134154586, 0.0231812876, -0.0402693152, -0.0196340438, 0.0272802822, -0.0454341546, 0.0023178121, -0.0096222516, -0.0347110145, -0.0391604416, 0.0727213249, 0.0181770343, -0.0723471195, -0.0634863675, 0.0169354603, -0.0261141006, -0.0486495346, 0.0171922706, -0.010254655, 0.041661337, 0.0713879615, 0.0471513271, 0.0495235622, -0.0529688783, -0.0147117851, -0.0013046587, 0.0494027548, 0.0417729542, 0.0223288797, 0.025760809, -0.0340556279, -0.0393572003, -0.0198095888, -0.030421732, 0.0274144057, -0.0032615247, -0.0108694481, -0.0600660183, -0.0235873424, 0.0266656857, -0.0001488042, -0.0093713077, -0.0487294458, 0.0017479007, 0.0085363137, -0.0234271865, -0.0156224966, 0.0202088933, -0.0459929928, 0.030070642, 0.0586149767, -0.0214477275, -0.0107833184, 0.0055795535, 0.0010770966, -0.0120568676, -0.0024219698, 0.073100172, -0.0213579461, 0.0396001302, 0.0090927053, 0.0230028313, -0.0147908758, -0.0271319598, 0.0012594264, -0.0214148108, 0.0434365682, -0.0013376733, 0.0126921246, 0.0419647247, 0.0111785801, -0.0404363982, 0.015360645, 0.0430962928, 0.0458552241, -0.0374209881, 0.0396875441, -0.0273709204, 0.0037460874, -0.0384569839, -0.0357585773, -0.0256718937, -0.0541049205, -0.0203017537, -0.090393059, -0.0220551472, -0.0332153998, 2.66e-7, -0.0533188507, 0.0512948036, 0.0369384177, -0.0067820558, 0.0282519683, 0.0330675766, 0.0335864499, 0.0026812137, 0.0175684039, -0.104359515, 0.0066016801, 0.040026065, 0.0608512089, 0.0379812643, -0.1095305756, -0.0506659187, -0.0429540612, -0.0327656008, -0.0472248979, -0.0549306348, 0.0336419456, 0.0367351882, 0.0493933856, -0.026300082, 0.0168478321, -0.0214812122, 0.041853305, 0.0213604644, 0.0112659261, 0.009103382, 0.0580778606, -0.001010961, -0.0090148924, 0.0667632073, 0.0065352824, -0.0117832879, 0.0051806089, 0.0099531906, -0.0009064723, -0.0692371577, -0.0137827573, -0.0006552815, 0.0138431685, -0.0404029451, 0.0568227805, -0.0168828312, -0.019775806, -0.0021050854, -0.0494030677, -0.0436471812, 0.0582162924, -0.0039526559, -0.0118324403, 0.0067435247, 0.0014589333, 0.0200119019, 0.0256099645, -0.0473253652, 0.0089372508, 0.0030817464, -0.0511287227, -0.0508790016, 0.0183556508, -0.0258523487, 0.0190371368, -0.024880901, 0.0338550396, 2.165215595e-34, 0.0212482847, -0.0020222007, 0.0384675935, 0.0378094688, 0.0274080262, 0.0022899513, 0.0423357598, -0.0112698944, 0.0304492507, -0.0149540324, 0.0001169551 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.04434v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.04434v1
Multilingual Entity and Relation Extraction from Unified to Language-specific Training
2023-01-11T12:26:53
2023-01-11T12:26:53
Zixiang Wang, Jian Yang, Tongliang Li, Jiaheng Liu, Ying Mo, Jiaqi Bai, Longtao He, Zhoujun Li
cs.CL
cs.CL
Entity and relation extraction is a key task in information extraction, where the output can be used for downstream NLP tasks. Existing approaches for entity and relation extraction tasks mainly focus on the English corpora and ignore other languages. Thus, it is critical to improving performance in a multilingual setting. Meanwhile, multilingual training is usually used to boost cross-lingual performance by transferring knowledge from languages (e.g., high-resource) to other (e.g., low-resource) languages. However, language interference usually exists in multilingual tasks as the model parameters are shared among all languages. In this paper, we propose a two-stage multilingual training method and a joint model called Multilingual Entity and Relation Extraction framework (mERE) to mitigate language interference across languages. Specifically, we randomly concatenate sentences in different languages to train a Language-universal Aggregator (LA), which narrows the distance of embedding representations by obtaining the unified language representation. Then, we separate parameters to mitigate interference via tuning a Language-specific Switcher (LS), which includes several independent sub-modules to refine the language-specific feature representation. After that, to enhance the relational triple extraction, the sentence representations concatenated with the relation feature are used to recognize the entities. Extensive experimental results show that our method outperforms both the monolingual and multilingual baseline methods. Besides, we also perform detailed analysis to show that mERE is lightweight but effective on relational triple extraction and mERE{} is easy to transfer to other backbone models of multi-field tasks, which further demonstrates the effectiveness of our method.
[ 0.0496131815, 0.054515563, 0.0225681588, 0.0879062489, -0.0299759954, 0.0386163853, 0.0046377527, -0.0237384811, 0.0013208709, -0.0400795564, -0.0347076915, -0.0134750446, -0.0481423959, -0.0281330831, 0.0112421904, -0.0491559394, 0.0490175597, 0.0035132975, 0.0021044426, -0.0074991081, -0.001905199, 0.025084354, -0.0062264497, -0.0375733227, -0.0352195092, 0.0011408135, 0.0365826823, -0.0135563845, 0.049785465, -0.0245109517, 0.0218501016, 0.027731983, -0.0136178685, 0.0114180325, 0.0000018515, -0.0524336323, -0.0488955826, 0.0087211505, -0.0141352527, -0.0379900411, -0.0017553606, -0.0423103794, 0.0005073645, -0.0077792369, -0.0343237706, -0.0316309743, 0.0298099499, 0.0889228955, -0.0000699758, 0.0664979666, -0.034522865, -0.028763257, 0.0115925325, -0.031833794, -0.0272130985, -0.0259686969, 0.0142849442, 0.0104401233, -0.0280210637, 0.0209910907, -0.0170759503, 0.0234431736, 0.0356609114, 0.0248993393, 0.0084730713, 0.0255033076, -0.0549328104, -0.0289379545, -0.0217825212, 0.0798672661, -0.0548145361, 0.028206367, 0.0103607466, 0.0232025199, -0.0056946748, -0.0081149563, 0.002017451, 0.0046959333, -0.0210469961, 0.0096453223, 0.0386171788, -0.0045544924, 0.0426238924, 0.0286845025, -0.0358703472, 0.0206865333, 0.0136198932, -0.0424797125, 0.0627270862, 0.0594361797, 0.0202805791, -0.0240430813, 0.0252195727, -0.0095346002, -0.0130575141, 0.0234483946, -0.0039402125, -0.0498230308, 0.0003592651, -0.074165836, -0.0421303026, 0.0233755093, -0.0388210043, 0.0676121935, -0.0569727793, 0.0121046565, -0.0262507834, -0.0041200658, 0.0040829629, -0.0210415348, -0.0266354084, 0.0130878147, -0.0154027361, 0.0616411641, -0.0528462641, -0.0016470911, -0.0325596035, 0.0012486471, -0.0055678617, 0.0169388503, 0.0142730689, -0.0108345849, -0.0081232805, 0.0054449751, 0.0090723215, 0.052198071, -0.0634861588, -0.0147911282, -0.0211020038, -0.0632519946, -0.0321238339, -0.0044036801, 0.0441472977, -0.0596943758, 0.0299168341, 0.0947850347, -0.0198102221, -0.0512239598, -0.0188175216, 0.0033644477, 0.0292685051, -0.0900991336, 0.0248741936, -0.0560482144, 0.0996554792, 0.0335029811, 0.0218522567, -0.0246642567, 0.0445003659, -0.047468029, -0.0592359304, 0.0426779836, 0.0008799846, -0.0330942385, -0.0343461707, 0.007657425, -0.0028263894, 0.1036146954, 0.0208903383, 0.0059469556, 0.0880738646, 0.0117786266, -0.0384049565, 0.0516685359, -0.0028161502, -0.0128382379, 0.029179113, 0.0036543203, 0.008602689, -0.0188125297, 0.0567641482, 0.0337243602, -0.0425104052, 0.0030244133, -0.0047459253, -0.0078042634, 0.0117050214, 0.0424436778, 0.0628328621, -0.0088770213, -0.000878225, 0.0322628729, -0.0416515358, -0.0001738164, 0.0133166406, 0.0292526633, -0.0237464216, 0.087547645, -0.0050165043, 0.0100595923, 0.0298056714, -0.0545737483, -0.0058434196, 0.0240795612, 0.0764493346, 0.0037870642, -0.0292531848, 0.0935388729, 0.0701848865, -0.0416959897, 0.0132641532, 0.0520627946, -0.0408369601, 0.0247367695, -0.01281018, -0.0147609059, -0.0209620539, -0.0061073969, -0.0426600762, 0.042899549, 0.0401198156, -0.0252877958, 0.0781050995, -0.0251997896, -0.0445772745, 0.0083063729, -0.0116435187, 0.0335260667, 0.0392256752, 0.0477758162, 0.0116485106, -0.0062664538, 0.0008927876, 0.0131381303, -0.0656909198, -0.0205682963, 0.0081173368, 0.0389894657, 0.0082193194, 0.0606573708, -0.0148691246, -0.0339952521, 0.0467086807, -0.0640145615, 0.0022256002, 0.0297579262, -0.0255771615, -0.0673017129, 0.0150010465, 0.0274840277, -0.0499746501, -0.0241430495, -0.0266290959, -0.0095308805, -0.0271738805, 0.0338268839, 0.0439136773, -0.0109572494, -0.0034129999, 0.0163843874, 0.044906076, -0.0015935695, 0.0824219435, -0.0062435605, 0.002967308, 0.0001251541, -0.06760934, 0.0158274528, -0.007299596, -0.0236407481, 0.0505527481, 0.0087168831, -0.0245699547, 0.030166598, 0.0262759198, -0.0432268307, -0.0267502852, -0.0689965263, 0.0226278156, -0.006038982, 0.0783767477, -0.0018065085, 0.0411201678, -0.0127362292, -0.0303905141, -0.0139397187, 0.0006306733, -0.0128906937, 0.0081107402, 0.0220474582, 0.0190929938, 0.0126263946, -0.0177257955, 0.0006108126, -0.006499771, 0.0657503903, -0.0245737322, -0.0716206878, -0.0071483678, 0.0118271355, -0.023530839, 0.0363797396, 0.013976383, -0.0012820688, -0.0521782711, 0.0171322823, 0.0463236347, 0.0437302403, -0.0395322703, 0.0383983999, 0.0051496918, -0.0017233134, -0.0377848037, 0.0560287796, -0.0131877204, 0.0450797118, -0.0517453216, -0.0030548316, -0.0004316767, 0.0278118327, -0.0218663625, 0.0040617846, -0.0035238625, -0.0172366649, 0.0144745866, -0.0247781426, -0.0225045718, 0.0529279225, 0.0064818868, 0.0138691701, -0.059175238, 0.0267142095, 0.0647360459, -0.0084114354, -0.0224092659, -0.0500764959, -0.0014193063, -0.058679942, 0.039930217, -0.0250618216, 0.040562164, -0.0237793811, -0.0333118886, -0.0261216927, -0.0033634792, 0.0144777745, -0.0104153594, 0.0117978202, -0.0043209335, -0.0132205896, -0.0269688908, -0.0483457707, -0.0316611528, 0.0004375614, -0.0259193107, 0.0171756949, -0.0282302909, -0.0061771893, -0.0161338672, -0.0171226989, 0.0462503545, 0.0173341911, -0.030452814, 0.0014948193, 0.0019772782, 0.0723271593, 0.0502746105, 0.0093571134, 0.0145167643, -0.0096852835, 0.0140291788, 0.0332380682, -0.0034920652, -0.0240771696, 0.0246247239, 0.0272883084, 0.0272856448, -0.0445854254, -0.0145427464, -0.0531987436, 0.020679092, -0.051852636, 0.0111014759, 0.080289863, -0.0029750511, -0.0258876793, -0.0035863055, 0.008639928, 0.0277516525, 0.0255985111, 0.0388605148, -0.0919659212, -0.0104931369, -0.0168481562, -0.0489105508, 0.0388180465, -0.0170235448, -0.0033662845, -0.1005838737, -0.0430487394, -0.0104875155, -0.058320377, -0.041975189, -0.0481619202, -0.002727645, -0.027436344, 0.0125391912, -0.0328279175, -0.0260478836, -0.0139030935, -0.0116185481, 0.0327518322, -0.0672238916, 0.0002575135, -0.0438482948, -0.0271178484, 0.0253071245, 0.0251032393, -0.0365031101, 0.0256665796, 0.0094648786, -0.003928076, -0.0363713242, -0.0253288336, 0.0556052066, -0.047528021, -0.0259788651, 0.0011051218, -0.0397086293, -0.0260778815, 0.0032238399, -0.0006456727, 0.0764201656, 0.0435924195, -0.0034282987, 0.0338684954, -0.0494528897, 0.0208668802, 0.0654041395, -0.0216173474, -0.037992496, -0.0159995761, 0.0140452841, -0.0045745866, -0.0618183538, 0.0149341822, 0.0139233368, -0.0674968362, -0.0401293375, -0.0317581557, -0.0993965715, 0.03103677, 0.0113932043, 0.0212683119, 0.0372631773, 0.0168605912, 0.0109489374, -0.0379967988, 0.0171105638, 0.0008225556, -0.0206068233, 0.028279487, 0.0084213689, -0.0211070608, -0.0072278092, -0.031535361, -0.0566413216, -0.0315272361, -0.04689385, -0.0219536498, 0.0322337188, 0.0009433259, 0.0663322806, -0.0041761375, 0.0002362266, -0.0149188824, 0.0425074957, -0.0621567778, -0.0151019329, 0.0513252951, -0.0004772229, -0.0116094453, 0.0355720073, -0.0471841693, 0.0181771647, 0.0229566656, 0.0668669045, -0.0259518828, -0.0354743414, 0.0026686287, 0.000314007, 0.0267883725, -0.0287485346, 0.0120733529, -0.0580354445, 0.0309262648, -0.0292794053, -0.0161357857, -0.0286941361, 0.006230168, 0.0070816795, -0.0051074009, 0.0086952662, 0.0412603244, 0.0385780223, 0.0029031439, 0.0011857757, 0.0038554932, 0.0097329291, -0.0028401141, 0.0052255411, 0.0119852601, -0.0004149412, 0.0089123612, 0.0322664045, -0.0080320919, -0.0683048069, 0.0103770783, 0.0057783024, -0.0443815067, 0.0090434058, 0.010973569, -0.0010417704, 0.0479802303, -0.011550826, 0.0152774351, 0.1033164188, -0.0492435582, 0.0657082722, -0.0085521806, -0.0139029399, 0.0191983506, 0.0231634323, -0.0103247277, -0.0029296228, 0.0240233149, 0.0052339304, -0.0317554884, 0.006443195, 0.0564340763, -0.032750573, 0.0354590453, 0.022088537, -0.0027067354, -0.0456606634, -0.0291559603, 0.0016399929, -0.0132189067, -0.03128694, 0.0141765876, -0.0375614576, -0.0419640951, -0.0048560309, -0.0364806466, -0.0468791425, 0.0068940176, 0.0166306123, 0.0576911271, 0.0318520181, -0.0366093405, -0.0484537743, 0.0068014408, -0.0117296092, -0.0148991263, 0.0084295291, -6.033901032e-33, -0.0353969447, -0.0028518836, 0.0032231521, -0.0059448583, -0.0349719562, 0.0310451072, -0.0259078126, -0.0092717428, -0.0527136438, 0.0219860952, -0.0115642585, -0.0268929899, 0.0324303173, 0.0175110213, 0.002519469, -0.0006082654, 0.0195478946, 0.033348348, 0.0149889104, 0.0089420388, 0.0462193117, 0.0844935998, 0.1291004419, -0.0902857259, 0.0252778232, -0.009017068, 0.0169838127, 0.0145952264, 0.0634135753, 0.0509949885, -0.0188585594, 0.0126285618, 0.0263309609, -0.0418127179, 0.0332888924, -0.0023417531, -0.1727089435, -0.0288022514, -0.0016696012, 0.0304051153, -0.0431928299, -0.0480522774, 0.0099446503, -0.0160617791, 0.0626076385, -0.0338247828, 0.0245465394, -0.0228444431, -0.0082720118, -0.0559090823, -0.089333348, 0.0155563951, 0.0402676091, 0.0558656156, 0.0653445795, 0.0514491051, 0.0264253169, -0.0228201468, -0.0255936738, -0.0361013785, -0.0432068706, 0.0079363147, 0.030337343, 0.0039605, -0.0175918192, 0.0572729707, -0.009964915, -0.0296046101, 0.006351457, -0.0165133681, 0.0026986108, 0.0485812798, -0.0242591687, 0.0635476857, 0.0163421724, -0.0079691708, -0.0927497745, -0.0009376471, 0.0450228602, 0.0505045727, -0.0217158385, -0.0255352836, -0.0259438064, 0.010262344, 0.006854082, 0.002542827, -0.0105813351, -0.0733609274, 0.0210460573, 0.0098491181, -0.020561073, 0.0586747937, 0.0177719612, -0.0306234229, -0.0577824749, 0.0587460957, 0.0031238645, 0.0133049218, 0.0156789459, 0.0144224204, -0.0498482361, -0.0520959646, -0.0375024639, -0.0197975747, 0.0295491051, 0.0239901841, 0.0785350055, -0.026502911, -0.0518695228, 0.0051364894, -0.0536603332, 0.0160721056, -0.0251180641, 0.0619942695, -0.0019185656, 0.0137000503, -0.0378555134, 0.0336086601, 0.07562235, 0.0187417604, -0.0264799371, 0.0447268449, 0.0152558479, 0.0578795187, 0.0137903541, -0.0189463571, -0.0359275714, 0.0237101559, 0.0027081696, -0.0535573736, -0.0096579315, -0.0133277019, 2.6e-7, 0.0357666276, 0.009104806, 0.0154782701, 0.0250521097, -0.007131096, 0.0230046138, 0.0023884827, 0.0345610641, -0.0152805438, 0.0197413247, -0.0232077315, 0.0151155535, 0.01257715, 0.0552608706, -0.0924750641, -0.0180413872, -0.0405777209, -0.0486567058, -0.0595796593, 0.0054106708, 0.0457465835, 0.0770354345, 0.0291245896, 0.0113364998, -0.0697264075, -0.0064901221, 0.0560448058, -0.0311071835, -0.0256630294, 0.0373646654, -0.0167934857, 0.0297440421, -0.0110855093, 0.0323192067, -0.0460774116, 0.0476732105, 0.0207598973, 0.0565583296, -0.0073064831, -0.0155581404, 0.0363429114, -0.0184446219, -0.0148013085, -0.0266268235, 0.0685010627, -0.0084462641, -0.0014010202, -0.0039274921, -0.0143963248, 0.0428781919, 0.0123422286, 0.0015737675, -0.0387607887, 0.0246886406, 0.0519120246, -0.0182898417, -0.0596465804, -0.0364875682, -0.0250283293, 0.0587186739, 0.0272331666, -0.0109584285, 0.0021726566, -0.037295904, -0.0113067264, -0.0436270609, -0.0022634328, 2.322294471e-34, -0.0224999357, 0.0158588197, 0.00286108, 0.0692977458, 0.0250976514, -0.0544457808, -0.054565005, 0.000540875, -0.0238579288, -0.0017565162, 0.0307447668 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.04408v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.04408v1
GPT as Knowledge Worker: A Zero-Shot Evaluation of (AI)CPA Capabilities
2023-01-11T11:30:42
2023-01-11T11:30:42
Jillian Bommarito, Michael Bommarito, Daniel Martin Katz, Jessica Katz
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY
The global economy is increasingly dependent on knowledge workers to meet the needs of public and private organizations. While there is no single definition of knowledge work, organizations and industry groups still attempt to measure individuals' capability to engage in it. The most comprehensive assessment of capability readiness for professional knowledge workers is the Uniform CPA Examination developed by the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants (AICPA). In this paper, we experimentally evaluate OpenAI's `text-davinci-003` and prior versions of GPT on both a sample Regulation (REG) exam and an assessment of over 200 multiple-choice questions based on the AICPA Blueprints for legal, financial, accounting, technology, and ethical tasks. First, we find that `text-davinci-003` achieves a correct rate of 14.4% on a sample REG exam section, significantly underperforming human capabilities on quantitative reasoning in zero-shot prompts. Second, `text-davinci-003` appears to be approaching human-level performance on the Remembering & Understanding and Application skill levels in the Exam absent calculation. For best prompt and parameters, the model answers 57.6% of questions correctly, significantly better than the 25% guessing rate, and its top two answers are correct 82.1% of the time, indicating strong non-entailment. Finally, we find that recent generations of GPT-3 demonstrate material improvements on this assessment, rising from 30% for `text-davinci-001` to 57% for `text-davinci-003`. These findings strongly suggest that large language models have the potential to transform the quality and efficiency of future knowledge work.
[ 0.0015521533, 0.0527232662, -0.0369088612, 0.0068517509, -0.0518921725, 0.016263878, 0.014359639, 0.0436435975, -0.0037980899, -0.0216282941, 0.0087685976, 0.0030398564, 0.0045465007, -0.0060204579, 0.0506527834, -0.0370757282, 0.0253339838, -0.0037700138, 0.0493961647, -0.0045903646, -0.0092067644, -0.0103773084, -0.0237252172, 0.0492541045, 0.0075495304, -0.0407051519, 0.0012409063, -0.0583274812, 0.0118677942, -0.0072384179, -0.0219563432, 0.0675622448, 0.0071410332, 0.0237155594, 0.0000023026, -0.0666797459, -0.0105368504, 0.0065943198, -0.0615291372, 0.0254129376, 0.0184435826, 0.0479580387, 0.023749873, 0.0323670544, -0.0680521727, 0.039295394, 0.0145362951, 0.0099256337, 0.0135871423, 0.0344090462, 0.0090024406, 0.0020301535, 0.0342610106, -0.04647943, -0.017352175, -0.1026760414, 0.0118403547, 0.0202768724, 0.0060369205, -0.0160441957, -0.0092661809, 0.0071056015, 0.029150309, 0.0010377537, -0.0138748046, 0.0345406272, -0.0419256091, 0.0242324527, -0.0069452347, 0.0093307262, 0.0483986065, 0.0176630151, -0.0142344348, -0.0235195793, 0.0561181344, 0.0100882147, -0.0227034427, 0.0171022527, -0.0121439146, -0.0197404008, 0.0122805014, 0.0100099333, 0.0013672251, 0.0030703892, 0.0176604856, 0.0308872759, -0.0235155299, -0.0575431287, 0.0661588982, 0.0399389826, -0.0402504764, -0.0273532625, -0.0168085955, 0.0466287993, 0.0215108842, 0.024200445, 0.0063603157, -0.0036180639, 0.01157864, -0.0162059925, 0.0363099761, 0.0573300011, 0.0084834266, 0.0346639752, -0.0270249043, 0.1139418781, -0.0044965325, 0.0487112813, -0.0230020806, 0.0167823583, -0.0779599473, -0.030664565, -0.0230509005, 0.0373379551, -0.0053925682, 0.0237258226, -0.0582585186, 0.0006028993, -0.0451806523, 0.0557991304, 0.0058388398, -0.0053186133, -0.0000391216, -0.0117497472, -0.1038616821, 0.030330345, -0.0394043252, -0.0078582941, -0.017258374, -0.0118947458, 0.0209635273, 0.0137329819, -0.0110690808, 0.0083767092, 0.0200099368, 0.0286360141, -0.0034224025, -0.0017285437, -0.0352152102, -0.0429199748, 0.0034851306, -0.071148634, 0.0092686154, -0.0288899336, 0.0140788173, -0.001617277, -0.0381657593, -0.0468131788, 0.0083205085, 0.0273417067, -0.0107048955, 0.0421110876, -0.0047466466, -0.0086426875, 0.0068079149, 0.0198541749, -0.0418459289, 0.0366414227, 0.0298533384, -0.0150022889, 0.0010617914, -0.0208080877, 0.0460855141, 0.0467271507, -0.0105010904, -0.0200887267, 0.0204245411, 0.0631106347, 0.0143185668, -0.0123773739, -0.0055755223, 0.0155504197, -0.0257602315, 0.0365269743, 0.0240618084, 0.0414618142, 0.0254122373, 0.0459516682, 0.0317928344, 0.0145940697, 0.0640125126, -0.0153981196, -0.0328857452, 0.0100623043, -0.0484987646, 0.0372910053, -0.0428282171, -0.0180134084, -0.0264688563, -0.0621943884, 0.0067978143, 0.0310668405, -0.0451308265, 0.0324686877, 0.0066599231, -0.0479491949, -0.0650711805, -0.0136121185, -0.0262191165, -0.0135084782, -0.0361124538, -0.0592311323, 0.056692712, 0.0565365031, 0.0425872356, -0.024746595, 0.0032436757, -0.0355973355, -0.0192944426, 0.058027003, 0.0648215786, -0.0057034274, -0.0558032505, -0.0577131733, -0.0161228906, -0.0053221928, 0.0006408027, 0.0461132713, 0.001982681, 0.0243875589, 0.0181286987, -0.0171769001, 0.0422958732, 0.0078478213, -0.03250001, -0.0742083117, -0.0441116132, 0.0334185846, 0.0114405286, 0.0335778482, 0.0083534392, 0.0120470421, 0.0011884081, 0.0189340953, -0.0166677441, -0.0229095798, -0.0224938113, 0.0541206151, 0.0129246712, -0.0181780942, -0.0301771574, 0.0227459893, 0.0059231049, -0.0314493179, -0.007285885, 0.0184438433, 0.0482883453, -0.0481640697, -0.0204434078, -0.0452720001, -0.0172980856, 0.0014566248, 0.0973493531, 0.0251790117, 0.0327519737, 0.0130628478, 0.0014585617, 0.0351049453, -0.0569903962, -0.0062565366, -0.0059832591, -0.0062072328, 0.0330371745, 0.0241756737, 0.0443203785, -0.0407339782, -0.002540359, -0.109951295, 0.0072651692, 0.0025331595, 0.0404890701, 0.0093606254, -0.0658022687, -0.044696521, 0.0220171064, -0.0600526333, -0.0076688277, -0.0035563677, 0.0147228278, 0.0187938586, 0.0136776138, -0.0071531856, -0.0151622863, 0.0147648631, -0.0302911662, -0.0243230127, 0.0854810476, 0.0375833511, -0.0007769321, 0.0619446002, -0.0277822707, -0.0159525201, 0.0131667955, 0.0150636155, 0.0327004343, 0.0071883225, -0.0206096079, 0.0168623812, -0.0612430051, 0.0369626842, -0.0289592296, -0.0128361387, -0.0299626589, 0.0388155766, 0.0459912419, -0.0155823734, 0.0137651023, 0.001132471, -0.0156754665, 0.0277009029, 0.0066738841, 0.0096676396, -0.0622109622, 0.049136728, -0.0553854518, -0.0165487863, -0.0550409295, -0.014977403, -0.0177068189, 0.0477484316, -0.0056201471, -0.0031073992, -0.0091749905, -0.0027591833, 0.0019003425, -0.0567913055, 0.0332796946, -0.0122504625, 0.0852088109, -0.0120986784, -0.0238883663, 0.0080422396, -0.0048006508, -0.0697169229, -0.0173494853, 0.0267167725, -0.0297418069, 0.0222300384, -0.0470536426, 0.0048231147, -0.0167480912, -0.0236624014, -0.0312686861, -0.0128949247, -0.0172995757, 0.0540768765, -0.0023672096, -0.0172232892, -0.0262880884, -0.0132035799, 0.0360954665, 0.0024347987, -0.0145820379, -0.039500393, -0.007812121, 0.0148633691, 0.0330960937, 0.025744075, 0.0206507389, -0.0401587263, 0.0179673266, 0.0158544034, 0.0707175955, -0.0007457394, 0.028550474, -0.0037711256, -0.0240089223, -0.0526079014, -0.0324523337, 0.0669356883, -0.0378356837, -0.0574206412, -0.0029082112, 0.1101916805, 0.0268853623, -0.0267976932, -0.0368178412, -0.0259088129, -0.0437211543, 0.036174763, 0.0760181248, -0.0949953571, -0.0021744035, -0.0086425841, 0.0314292125, -0.0555067174, -0.0757882893, 0.0138030322, -0.1026104838, 0.0889822766, -0.0143347597, -0.0255694687, -0.0077223764, 0.018991895, -0.0042119171, -0.0122692818, 0.0186730176, 0.0114895329, 0.032637082, 0.0019937707, 0.0376332551, -0.0449726693, 0.0184905697, 0.0711851269, 0.0070621134, -0.0123783937, 0.1009619161, 0.0170131829, -0.045523271, -0.0506758355, -0.0216923784, -0.0290211551, 0.0027956404, 0.0390591696, 0.0131037012, -0.0138374306, 0.0042967545, -0.0040682103, 0.0007661757, -0.0628216267, 0.0398928486, 0.0843062177, 0.1047023311, 0.0165358391, -0.0230071582, 0.0214888137, -0.0347299725, -0.049373433, 0.0580863133, -0.0157946423, -0.0170390904, -0.0248217434, -0.0540744811, -0.0083707627, -0.0580678657, 0.002737846, -0.0094915116, 0.0198318474, 0.0057824268, -0.0582982525, -0.1053625643, 0.0843244642, 0.0364492498, -0.00395494, -0.0362807438, 0.0423814468, 0.0001938223, -0.0047298525, -0.036043752, -0.0899722949, 0.0513293818, -0.0508023277, -0.0003778438, -0.0328484848, 0.0077889753, -0.0432025641, 0.0016083835, -0.0587965772, -0.0017326577, -0.0019346648, 0.0253161136, 0.0385366343, -0.0581863597, -0.0252683256, 0.0281908885, 0.0311053041, -0.0034125408, -0.0552814603, 0.0283964612, -0.0001633779, -0.0030810698, -0.0136207221, -0.0027963738, -0.0316175967, -0.0228375234, -0.0000254795, 0.0421719812, 0.0045103938, -0.0115605555, 0.0357329585, 0.0595492311, -0.0358072855, 0.0416941941, 0.0096673444, -0.0068222312, -0.0044702319, -0.0254052319, -0.0097844228, -0.0093436018, -0.0565778874, 0.046391312, -0.0084215086, 0.0133487862, 0.0160569828, -0.029207563, -0.0038931328, -0.0531166606, 0.0161230639, 0.0300252996, 0.0708926544, -0.0189366192, -0.0493714735, -0.0056048725, -0.0358265713, 0.0038699151, 0.0383517332, 0.0318246596, 0.1166975871, -0.0207601693, 0.0273711476, 0.0116446028, -0.0171751827, -0.0428819917, -0.0581383184, 0.027543446, 0.0679405183, 0.031901978, -0.0036179328, -0.0583522432, -0.0635975748, 0.0271209162, 0.0313134566, -0.0425318517, 0.0477473848, -0.0518156253, 0.0467824601, 0.0277309567, 0.0069361371, -0.0440907627, 0.0851751193, -0.0180680472, 0.0496906042, -0.0660234243, -0.019153811, -0.037990462, -0.0444667749, 0.0188068915, 0.0264346283, 0.0079993773, 0.023795085, -0.1124011725, -0.0465030521, -0.0033783913, 0.0158159491, -0.0187859945, -0.0229763277, -0.0055977711, 0.0593392476, -0.016225474, -0.0362224095, -0.0219779033, 0.0326351412, -0.0385413654, 0.0159025304, -0.0412357002, -6.063524959e-33, -0.0233272836, -0.0331759118, 0.0568301231, 0.0004605245, 0.0223258547, -0.0234563537, -0.0081532383, 0.0273780078, -0.0420595855, 0.007872005, -0.0527370162, 0.0030085177, 0.00524486, -0.0229545478, 0.0206210595, -0.0218847226, -0.0081354054, -0.0432974696, -0.0041925218, -0.0282345153, -0.040475484, -0.0074943891, 0.0363772027, -0.0085898321, 0.0828736201, -0.0210118387, -0.0157765839, -0.0132196816, -0.0223462041, 0.0494538024, -0.0009029952, 0.0417550988, 0.0220120046, -0.0564985164, 0.0162103027, -0.009303838, -0.0133476928, -0.0625335649, 0.050920818, -0.0050458838, 0.023671655, -0.0374201834, 0.0162264295, -0.0032554804, -0.0471740291, -0.0091218892, 0.0219196454, -0.0390600897, 0.0181103628, -0.0191331264, -0.059314508, -0.0023898827, -0.0315599516, 0.0280503519, -0.0382973365, 0.0593916699, -0.0122385342, -0.0216210764, -0.0718534365, -0.0065676863, 0.0400985926, -0.0079161506, 0.0327275842, -0.0208641551, -0.0010360411, 0.0077268207, 0.0215359125, 0.012390418, -0.0232488923, -0.0536743179, 0.0414574072, 0.0215500463, 0.0471784808, 0.0509322882, 0.0057921638, -0.0177806467, -0.0290965941, 0.0465334281, 0.0489450581, 0.0252127592, 0.0182360094, -0.02597275, -0.0922489762, -0.0302003026, -0.0112456018, -0.0105248531, -0.0454221703, -0.010699613, 0.0585939288, -0.0233109538, 0.0263669454, 0.0296227913, 0.0198967047, -0.026791865, 0.0407066867, -0.0192346592, -0.0094244033, 0.0552356094, 0.020796394, 0.0440430306, -0.1037168577, 0.020811338, -0.024556201, 0.0274560563, 0.0279549435, 0.0056556882, -0.0108888978, 0.0074380403, -0.0508615077, -0.0142140873, -0.0440121368, 0.0405210257, 0.0410625935, -0.0094718793, 0.0027718595, 0.0331504159, 0.0309946444, -0.0410287008, -0.0180453621, -0.0577158853, -0.0262269974, 0.0175987873, -0.0101031149, -0.0251873787, -0.0161081757, -0.0130722914, 0.020255385, 0.0146484971, -0.0012146104, -0.0186979752, -0.0038427638, 0.0333948694, 2.971e-7, 0.0442864336, 0.0216126349, -0.0296884142, 0.0010608394, -0.0102766724, 0.0384313799, -0.0073167682, -0.018022079, 0.0475339405, 0.006181845, 0.045152925, -0.0046588844, 0.0234845411, 0.0102431718, -0.0690908432, -0.0152325481, 0.0261647757, 0.0048451643, -0.0530952364, 0.0452063568, 0.0589934625, 0.0229602568, 0.027204264, -0.0149760647, -0.0145315723, -0.0576099567, 0.0564018525, -0.0078960089, -0.0059129824, -0.0244934354, 0.0575028174, 0.0253910087, -0.0066941692, 0.1079510748, 0.0205947459, 0.0346642397, 0.0318652876, 0.0850027427, 0.0040913117, 0.0389432572, -0.0042704702, -0.0485785231, 0.0140847955, -0.069954969, 0.0599691495, -0.0035090856, -0.0155426105, 0.0481411144, -0.0460758023, -0.0121783074, 0.0033176802, 0.0190861914, -0.0127956085, -0.0049633598, 0.0038937523, -0.0327358618, 0.0076610339, 0.0242890436, 0.0436954498, 0.0176767129, -0.0128051052, -0.0306010731, -0.0403892137, -0.0279676877, 0.0484527759, -0.0788735598, 0.0112208948, 2.680695122e-34, -0.0024157397, -0.0121747525, 0.0257959198, -0.0167026203, 0.0630357787, 0.0490667485, 0.0243656617, 0.0265395138, 0.0064310525, -0.0380053446, -0.0134614464 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.04388v3
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.04388v3
Perceive and predict: self-supervised speech representation based loss functions for speech enhancement
2023-01-11T10:20:56
2023-06-26T09:31:53
George Close, William Ravenscroft, Thomas Hain, Stefan Goetze
cs.SD
cs.SD, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS
Recent work in the domain of speech enhancement has explored the use of self-supervised speech representations to aid in the training of neural speech enhancement models. However, much of this work focuses on using the deepest or final outputs of self supervised speech representation models, rather than the earlier feature encodings. The use of self supervised representations in such a way is often not fully motivated. In this work it is shown that the distance between the feature encodings of clean and noisy speech correlate strongly with psychoacoustically motivated measures of speech quality and intelligibility, as well as with human Mean Opinion Score (MOS) ratings. Experiments using this distance as a loss function are performed and improved performance over the use of STFT spectrogram distance based loss as well as other common loss functions from speech enhancement literature is demonstrated using objective measures such as perceptual evaluation of speech quality (PESQ) and short-time objective intelligibility (STOI).
[ -0.0132275987, 0.0420704596, 0.0281251632, 0.0044355453, 0.0011364585, -0.0553028397, 0.0705235377, 0.0054881144, -0.0162192006, 0.0092505356, -0.1157479137, -0.0002099295, 0.0163627043, 0.0360654518, 0.0421072803, -0.0328960419, 0.0060880515, -0.0374399759, 0.03663693, -0.0483148396, 0.0017946525, -0.0252101794, -0.0418046117, 0.0177519321, -0.0275281873, -0.0202979092, 0.0173447914, -0.0040977048, -0.0335506797, 0.0030197841, -0.0089176111, 0.026784854, 0.0106026763, -0.0298005026, 0.0000019628, -0.0279874336, -0.0112774866, 0.0084818974, -0.0472969376, 0.0242731571, 0.0490000099, 0.060535945, -0.0473005325, 0.0116056474, 0.0050666644, 0.0001095123, 0.026092412, 0.0196039341, 0.0341834128, 0.0424310118, -0.0038790579, -0.0310185309, -0.0197773501, 0.0023640464, -0.0032968665, 0.0724497288, -0.0283014104, -0.035112448, -0.0836434588, -0.0014140217, -0.011353869, 0.0458646119, -0.0132756447, -0.0298437383, 0.1043916345, -0.015409247, -0.0144825308, -0.0131770382, -0.0138298832, 0.0105211642, 0.0206424929, 0.0097833024, -0.0320088156, 0.0421848111, 0.0086569767, -0.0521638021, 0.0174011551, -0.0452745594, 0.0734480768, 0.0105216084, -0.0584495701, 0.0445791781, 0.0241851602, -0.0085482188, 0.0030805522, 0.0150446631, -0.0141883269, -0.0609012246, 0.0247681066, -0.0347871445, -0.043990504, 0.0639661551, 0.0546863973, 0.0029426198, 0.0196659341, -0.028545646, 0.0129656708, -0.0609696917, -0.0387251936, -0.0241710693, 0.0033104792, 0.031105658, -0.0665348023, -0.0549662188, -0.0488628894, 0.0397779904, 0.0305221286, 0.0310167167, -0.0383807905, 0.0160837285, 0.0158635471, -0.0002523114, -0.0226582512, 0.0739018098, -0.0239146352, 0.0215822943, -0.0630831644, -0.0299715046, -0.0981810614, 0.0125182411, 0.0221744906, 0.0215620287, -0.0610865951, -0.0080966027, -0.0234137345, 0.0524709336, 0.0084828008, 0.0322154798, 0.0041352552, -0.0078520933, 0.0076703145, 0.0250189714, 0.0283180028, 0.0351671241, 0.0435272641, 0.0932805613, 0.0329251774, -0.001800579, -0.0434162319, -0.0316905566, -0.0405644216, 0.003683839, -0.0238287356, -0.0445464402, -0.0193636212, -0.0224600658, -0.0243533403, -0.0515509248, -0.0345077328, -0.0460667163, 0.0583869517, -0.0142492112, -0.0667309836, 0.0132183498, 0.1018674746, -0.0124338083, -0.0101727135, -0.0184846949, 0.0512589924, -0.0280974638, 0.0071962001, -0.0719157457, -0.0348038636, 0.0265063364, 0.0253823269, -0.0089278352, -0.0283451099, -0.0466182753, -0.0561474822, 0.0306964647, 0.0730961859, -0.0016849535, -0.0220405087, -0.0418605693, 0.0580239482, 0.0539776795, 0.0978432596, 0.0422359481, -0.0213690475, 0.0243042465, -0.0063046846, -0.0005868218, 0.005026117, 0.0058075488, -0.0125960987, 0.0108178956, 0.0564960316, 0.0174279958, -0.0312824883, -0.0704326034, 0.0485950448, -0.0518739335, 0.0138401277, 0.0006517599, 0.0646687523, 0.0089148553, 0.0127890278, 0.0227197204, -0.0087103685, -0.0497485287, 0.0355060734, -0.0416138731, 0.0189280938, 0.0169365387, -0.0349372663, -0.0381023735, 0.0125315543, -0.0284443796, -0.0728935078, 0.000258505, -0.0163607951, 0.0098934891, 0.0674771741, -0.0378151573, -0.0165095106, -0.011971727, -0.0214439239, 0.0094616814, -0.053055916, -0.0098649245, 0.0232986547, -0.0217636395, -0.0099547328, -0.0266974289, 0.0361778624, -0.0350195058, 0.0371726193, 0.0081953937, 0.056622684, 0.0619684607, -0.0230792332, 0.0506095402, 0.0188750606, -0.0165437534, 0.0115641784, -0.0054850928, -0.055071447, 0.0058651171, 0.0414295979, -0.0107309734, 0.0496662483, 0.0386555865, 0.0292380676, -0.0582356118, 0.0840583071, -0.0544728301, 0.0096518127, -0.0571971275, 0.0223124605, 0.0103423242, -0.0158667173, 0.0351205654, -0.0328025781, 0.0282877777, -0.0330802388, 0.0077121998, 0.028161807, 0.0366140157, -0.0479436666, -0.0064296001, -0.0075647691, -0.0495258197, 0.0339600556, 0.0157495253, -0.0256238561, -0.0382002182, 0.001008297, -0.0574694164, 0.0006409549, -0.0087581584, -0.0128774391, 0.0054640197, -0.0050001978, 0.0263626147, -0.0290389694, -0.0238947105, -0.038535852, -0.0064566992, -0.0093028117, -0.0264979564, 0.0034773466, 0.0013716909, -0.0066253729, -0.0274744425, 0.0262720957, -0.0014320216, -0.0560024641, -0.0367939174, -0.0338981226, 0.0135397138, -0.0114966277, 0.0389370844, 0.0371809751, -0.0624738, 0.0004674284, 0.0005655001, 0.0404100753, 0.0655641556, 0.0125344498, -0.0273713637, 0.0693415031, 0.021643782, -0.0314165056, -0.0073131891, -0.0252766274, 0.0742459372, -0.0013616502, 0.0239841901, -0.0143913822, -0.0186724607, 0.0636043996, 0.0260501001, -0.0419142134, -0.0067999167, 0.0103028538, -0.0699046105, -0.0196361504, -0.0165732168, -0.0179540049, 0.0120366113, 0.0078536496, -0.0153723331, -0.0019772123, -0.0411530621, -0.0094202468, -0.0295800809, -0.0562838987, 0.0328977741, -0.0450979359, -0.0191656966, 0.0298051275, -0.0576103628, -0.025157446, -0.0335779041, -0.0183409601, 0.0381725989, -0.0539673306, -0.0389143042, -0.0188258011, -0.0537171476, 0.0254555438, 0.0332047269, -0.0163631719, -0.0036218574, 0.0321638212, -0.0009500508, 0.0255728289, 0.0334890708, 0.0660909489, 0.0329271071, 0.0145002492, 0.046800334, 0.0042970981, 0.0115378108, 0.0267930254, 0.0218681507, -0.0065873307, 0.0533497967, 0.0138087217, 0.004956448, 0.0158946738, -0.0139675569, 0.0237152912, -0.0224429816, -0.0552506484, 0.0156983063, -0.0071406052, 0.0219127294, -0.0265412387, 0.0108318217, 0.0769198686, -0.0630014166, 0.0188951492, 0.0814176798, -0.0021887459, -0.0068451832, 0.0086301276, -0.0148241501, -0.023465829, -0.0024964304, -0.0396308899, 0.0290925708, 0.0252356902, 0.0189184975, 0.0290722456, -0.0321260281, 0.0634416565, -0.0100818817, -0.0448189639, 0.0349465013, 0.0658071116, 0.0222392455, -0.0426536575, -0.0193056278, -0.02135613, 0.0045825411, 0.0430542566, -0.0038181706, 0.0109513747, -0.0131907742, 0.068814069, -0.0914984569, 0.0079777585, -0.0674170703, -0.0231843181, 0.0927847922, 0.0540751107, -0.0357249677, -0.0251122434, -0.0451995879, -0.0008951994, 0.0246010665, 0.0166504905, -0.023216404, 0.0920963138, 0.0344660878, -0.0073148157, 0.012771043, 0.0484728478, 0.0080196336, 0.00770996, -0.0040133726, 0.0043793586, -0.028995879, -0.0020479034, -0.0120961666, 0.0606344901, -0.011960513, 0.0399047844, 0.0267798137, -0.0465364493, 0.029478291, 0.0170408543, 0.0601850003, 0.0090505509, -0.0243522171, 0.0247006696, 0.0130952522, -0.0667890981, -0.0293201525, -0.0282007642, -0.0307962243, 0.005169414, 0.0106506208, 0.0188915841, -0.0087412978, -0.0088670021, 0.0100511378, 0.0062451363, 0.0280583147, -0.0028815584, -0.027113203, 0.0059331148, 0.0233204234, -0.0270564463, -0.0203663036, -0.0412322581, 0.0139454659, -0.0163702592, 0.023069609, 0.0007736155, 0.0087174335, 0.0288779065, -0.0121767893, -0.0475199595, 0.0999333784, -0.0101485113, -0.099984616, 0.0228910688, 0.1087262779, -0.0073521677, -0.0078028329, 0.0340936296, -0.0193426553, 0.0785690248, -0.0486566424, -0.0275387503, 0.0142531795, -0.0415705852, 0.0025511445, 0.0103928139, 0.0597893894, 0.0230287164, 0.0367008299, -0.018817801, 0.0303791426, -0.0278286412, 0.045446828, -0.0218452401, -0.0120449532, 0.0354795083, 0.045597896, -0.0042482675, -0.0051477738, -0.0479386337, -0.0017581421, 0.0315921754, 0.0454371795, -0.0442193709, -0.0190473106, -0.0340797529, 0.0608627796, -0.0186136011, 0.0044185705, 0.05556117, -0.0223463736, 0.0146058593, 0.0107770842, 0.0105861146, -0.0428216681, 0.0081712417, 0.0482222438, -0.0115947267, 0.0069702943, -0.0231190473, 0.0045032529, -0.0505499281, -0.0076293582, 0.01343391, -0.0039558671, 0.0143289417, -0.024757009, 0.0040468648, 0.0040900903, 0.0760511979, 0.033856906, -0.0297873095, -0.0123191224, -0.0253510736, 0.0153801516, -0.0262854118, -0.0003608146, -0.0302436613, 0.0199914016, -0.0302374475, -0.0387258418, -0.0922662541, 0.0606230982, -0.022695655, -0.0060337083, 0.0324625038, -0.0435431972, 0.0060374914, -0.0291215014, 0.018384397, -0.0407575555, 0.0232913177, -0.0280860942, -0.0486781076, 0.0124607589, 0.0547922626, -0.0486295, 0.0308678914, -0.0107528483, 0.0215188731, -5.704637718e-33, -0.0258302856, 0.027483236, 0.0032030137, 0.0474503897, -0.0217351709, -0.0177331623, -0.0319009013, 0.0428922176, -0.0067691482, 0.0221002996, 0.023139352, 0.0003647391, 0.0305555575, 0.0074294414, -0.0247781184, 0.0350202546, 0.0859764293, -0.0366051421, 0.0342740305, -0.0169376507, 0.0376718827, 0.0143269496, 0.0396207087, -0.1120336428, -0.0289899465, 0.0484302901, -0.0212712847, -0.0371826552, 0.0605851896, 0.0359032378, -0.0023292275, 0.093498446, -0.0317781903, -0.034014158, 0.0121330069, 0.0003433797, -0.0187245347, -0.0117679713, -0.0470835119, -0.0011496887, -0.0693386793, -0.04363418, 0.0679709688, 0.0248023011, -0.0651189014, -0.0235697627, 0.0202805828, -0.0476250984, 0.0117580248, -0.0230449457, -0.0061179805, 0.0176447667, -0.0173062477, -0.026463706, 0.1019435897, 0.0513659827, -0.0416051894, -0.0446598455, -0.0178641602, 0.0399911404, 0.0104237339, 0.0657093152, 0.0112537313, -0.0182097647, 0.0191524327, -0.007154536, 0.0875300467, -0.0380842984, 0.0831775665, -0.0556069873, 0.0474439152, 0.0218602698, 0.0771052241, 0.0067806654, 0.0294727758, -0.0578156076, -0.0146936337, 0.008436583, -0.0022272482, -0.0033570239, -0.0020310991, 0.0401693881, -0.0013720245, -0.0155957052, -0.050398346, -0.0392254703, -0.0361056589, -0.0439690016, 0.0245776605, -0.0446226113, 0.0247690789, 0.0068427059, 0.0281623844, -0.0301730298, 0.0400239713, -0.0234301407, -0.0504018292, -0.0021207936, 0.0292089451, -0.0219076611, -0.0174495261, -0.0049073882, 0.055123657, 0.0551253818, -0.0006583067, -0.0427154563, -0.0204078704, 0.0228753947, -0.0352185369, -0.0139449239, -0.0069497954, -0.0227451157, 0.0396976881, -0.0323899202, -0.0168596487, 0.0044191531, -0.0154842166, 0.0367667973, -0.0169423353, 0.0308898408, 0.0008958585, 0.0017193776, 0.0403548516, 0.0076125413, -0.0350989141, 0.0056916489, 0.0157198757, -0.0473862663, 0.041392304, -0.0104663791, -0.0217697285, -0.036820706, 2.778e-7, -0.0469178781, 0.0092963465, 0.008009023, -0.0287016593, 0.0356447175, 0.0344994925, 0.0011490193, -0.044591561, 0.010577824, -0.0297364686, -0.0005140533, -0.0194063392, 0.0250249971, 0.0247334149, 0.0134824598, -0.0258977804, -0.0461454913, 0.0270512719, 0.0224548802, 0.0554044954, 0.0141587351, 0.0227601156, -0.0326127335, -0.0655080155, 0.0077738729, 0.0192737468, 0.0297229309, -0.0495423116, 0.0132721607, -0.0183003712, 0.0555303656, 0.0151895182, 0.0290848203, 0.023366699, -0.0413407423, 0.0100689083, 0.0101641966, 0.0166382436, -0.0182132702, -0.0863154531, 0.0331988819, 0.1022846773, 0.0035076239, 0.0677877739, 0.0329693891, -0.0062941541, -0.0231728964, -0.0101537723, -0.0673101544, -0.0043215533, -0.0070068892, -0.038093701, -0.0162871052, -0.0682239011, -0.0071646697, 0.0302256271, -0.0230283663, -0.0080950763, -0.0137389293, 0.0518852212, -0.0256272685, -0.0236678924, -0.0363445319, 0.0006492307, 0.0018395711, 0.002062845, -0.0064620422, 1.677167789e-34, 0.0079519311, -0.0242493898, 0.052530203, -0.0259383544, -0.0407004245, -0.0363575742, -0.0089620734, -0.013765607, 0.0472702086, 0.0025517335, -0.0335510112 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.04366v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.04366v1
Multimodal Inverse Cloze Task for Knowledge-based Visual Question Answering
2023-01-11T09:16:34
2023-01-11T09:16:34
Paul Lerner, Olivier Ferret, Camille Guinaudeau
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG, cs.MM
We present a new pre-training method, Multimodal Inverse Cloze Task, for Knowledge-based Visual Question Answering about named Entities (KVQAE). KVQAE is a recently introduced task that consists in answering questions about named entities grounded in a visual context using a Knowledge Base. Therefore, the interaction between the modalities is paramount to retrieve information and must be captured with complex fusion models. As these models require a lot of training data, we design this pre-training task from existing work in textual Question Answering. It consists in considering a sentence as a pseudo-question and its context as a pseudo-relevant passage and is extended by considering images near texts in multimodal documents. Our method is applicable to different neural network architectures and leads to a 9% relative-MRR and 15% relative-F1 gain for retrieval and reading comprehension, respectively, over a no-pre-training baseline.
[ 0.0596791767, 0.0174751896, -0.0044478211, 0.0336344168, 0.0041134139, -0.0057024476, -0.0084368037, 0.0049540275, 0.0360086299, -0.0503326282, -0.041349493, -0.0259438567, -0.0235710777, 0.0395809039, 0.0479842946, -0.0495603457, 0.0314159952, 0.0165962558, -0.0039422628, -0.0018635676, 0.0437481478, 0.002784445, 0.0006749312, 0.0204838123, -0.0363564342, -0.035326831, -0.0117259808, 0.0240812339, 0.0429757647, -0.0119213248, 0.0016565259, 0.0138065936, 0.0761212036, -0.0329297036, 0.0000019053, -0.0223728232, -0.0061458671, -0.0084833102, -0.0026760995, -0.0382436477, -0.0337441042, -0.0095298477, 0.0404905975, -0.0015694231, -0.0401848294, -0.0173686743, 0.0530696288, 0.0562380292, 0.0673613697, 0.0561205111, -0.0209280625, 0.003798312, 0.0246127322, -0.0017914266, 0.0191376507, -0.0402662121, -0.0025814197, 0.0419125371, 0.0122889765, 0.0229783356, -0.0320383646, 0.0553235002, 0.0405186303, 0.0015302477, 0.0333684199, 0.0455762893, 0.0253038891, 0.0016641518, -0.0278119761, 0.098286517, 0.00948055, 0.0047932966, -0.0339711644, 0.0211622454, -0.0134127587, 0.028191518, -0.0396185666, 0.0288806017, -0.0325638205, -0.0101569323, -0.0688994005, 0.0043443702, 0.0189933106, 0.0273445398, -0.008647101, -0.0103796888, 0.0145994592, -0.0153818177, 0.0267746672, 0.0194097813, -0.0820749402, -0.015736118, -0.0095243286, 0.0614790767, -0.0040214397, 0.0081900358, -0.0230884403, -0.0448201075, 0.0041377773, -0.0509255975, 0.0299372487, 0.0384585746, -0.0358673371, 0.0675690696, -0.0357357487, 0.0490020625, -0.0327123962, 0.0168950185, -0.0224335026, -0.0383889675, -0.0412126891, -0.0179507211, -0.0502931625, 0.039184384, -0.0785460919, -0.0643857047, -0.0058395392, 0.0281270687, 0.0228189677, -0.0159186572, 0.0007547003, 0.0605611466, 0.0009888697, -0.0033934568, -0.0516809784, 0.0549668483, -0.0604790524, 0.0161541589, -0.0073750676, -0.0081569785, -0.0347669423, 0.0071393936, -0.0156577099, -0.0497261733, 0.0142238336, 0.0661446899, -0.075271681, -0.0640530512, -0.0293843877, -0.0346388966, -0.0076355971, -0.0365708955, 0.0505478121, -0.0235322379, 0.0536821149, -0.0092031294, -0.0097472779, 0.0030928403, 0.0023817609, 0.0045186253, -0.0137912249, 0.0856584534, -0.0290771648, -0.0301394947, 0.0312949866, 0.0180106368, -0.0048079086, 0.0679385811, -0.0173161495, 0.0134240761, 0.0189493764, -0.0096262507, -0.0087827332, 0.0259566419, 0.0236053169, -0.0195288509, -0.0140959183, 0.0325522646, -0.0231592506, 0.0132310512, 0.0523113646, -0.0010202482, -0.0339431576, -0.0620289743, 0.0541018881, 0.0366978012, -0.0041272873, -0.0058951518, 0.0041749128, 0.0002772395, 0.0103478767, 0.0301241167, -0.0358506367, 0.0783748627, -0.0317585915, 0.0108332112, -0.0026272465, 0.0527713224, -0.0494501442, 0.0028658251, 0.0156492423, 0.0159746893, -0.0202948935, 0.0384544134, 0.0441062711, 0.0287407115, -0.0502954461, 0.0369951501, 0.0104030073, -0.0273850728, -0.0134230163, -0.012023746, 0.0464395806, 0.0388592705, 0.034263134, -0.048086457, -0.0249580983, 0.0300093479, 0.004201645, 0.0377308838, -0.0240180921, -0.0092757177, 0.0575069487, -0.0433653407, -0.0327705443, -0.0285456087, -0.0070332671, 0.0152179068, 0.0221886318, -0.0145703861, 0.0169337764, -0.0229375362, 0.0337516405, 0.0246603172, 0.0327417217, 0.0287982095, -0.0270658154, 0.0385725386, -0.010323232, -0.0021770915, -0.028141303, -0.005741647, 0.0254165623, -0.0554464534, -0.0154728433, 0.0347616151, -0.0371852703, -0.0666664764, 0.0247442238, -0.0525198355, -0.0256919116, 0.0179769788, -0.0176029652, -0.0264833942, 0.0002783378, -0.0273871794, 0.0641160086, -0.0477586277, -0.0149726132, 0.058121793, 0.0044537862, -0.0225787479, 0.0610844977, -0.0389601775, 0.011813689, -0.0012356929, -0.0144689986, -0.0020493784, -0.0296085961, 0.0166331921, -0.0266612489, 0.0075364453, 0.0019420458, -0.0095424401, -0.0057038083, -0.063744992, 0.0056221546, -0.0881853998, -0.0063236868, -0.0072848783, -0.045239836, 0.0151517754, 0.0358769335, 0.0124572115, -0.0446434021, -0.0313847959, 0.0388399996, -0.0089203948, 0.0238874871, 0.0449498184, 0.0225479547, 0.0469361022, -0.0496848561, -0.0158956628, 0.0030223636, 0.0888065472, 0.0061836736, -0.0120718135, 0.0068978462, 0.0063705649, -0.0474937372, 0.0483015589, -0.0344741009, -0.0380020626, 0.0099826101, -0.040951129, 0.0457965881, 0.062296968, -0.0084768627, 0.0013154667, -0.0169695523, -0.0354792289, -0.0437071212, 0.0358713754, 0.0011498772, -0.0063823657, 0.0177038945, -0.0122941379, -0.0225509834, 0.0208534636, -0.0275630131, -0.0211357083, -0.0406656116, 0.0203190688, 0.0391492061, -0.0234454218, -0.0796713978, 0.0264333822, 0.039206136, 0.0232127681, -0.0868355781, -0.0176290534, 0.0673313513, -0.0142167071, -0.0215072762, -0.0097045796, -0.0141447252, -0.02521649, 0.0493281409, 0.0310416948, 0.0302233417, -0.0309298113, -0.0084240241, -0.0462768227, -0.0030586629, 0.0055481261, 0.0244470853, 0.0613990352, -0.015179853, 0.0223323982, -0.0136052854, -0.021092359, -0.0316023529, -0.0433574244, 0.0143295685, -0.0139048807, -0.0225783493, -0.0068502561, -0.0276633799, 0.0276129078, 0.0316386297, 0.0136551093, -0.0049479338, -0.0122820456, -0.0174630005, 0.1117122397, 0.0586560778, 0.0970987678, -0.0272680931, -0.0105233537, 0.019433029, 0.0576063953, 0.0357848071, -0.0407673009, -0.0357017815, 0.0384300388, -0.0020624436, 0.0161727928, 0.0077855415, 0.0003757834, 0.0585970953, -0.059173096, -0.0014664055, 0.0483715385, 0.01692947, -0.0012658647, -0.0614624955, -0.0027486812, 0.0219212696, 0.0441615097, 0.0254755896, -0.0439874157, -0.0402649678, -0.0355846398, -0.0200890899, 0.0129656419, -0.0026659986, -0.0223825928, -0.0848614275, 0.0073716971, -0.0089744795, -0.0512621514, -0.0125488443, -0.0151765337, -0.0122194355, 0.0370649993, -0.0217407029, -0.0062425765, 0.0080241645, -0.01557393, -0.0111958897, 0.0641526207, -0.0070594405, 0.006434849, -0.0614834689, -0.0098180212, 0.0454871096, 0.0124656996, -0.0286674313, -0.0327356905, -0.0017069204, -0.033580061, 0.0267677009, -0.0099019511, 0.0675873905, -0.0248412974, -0.0471392311, -0.0234313663, -0.0101772677, -0.002936135, -0.0250121057, -0.0120210769, 0.0373069383, -0.0054200459, -0.0038367889, -0.0328061059, 0.0320410058, -0.0036136678, 0.0574063957, 0.0257251598, -0.0341836549, -0.0193068646, 0.0282274634, 0.028590044, -0.0415846221, 0.0220769737, 0.0096948827, 0.0074931993, 0.0037068864, -0.0731872469, -0.0262965914, 0.0330174342, 0.0936925858, 0.002767721, -0.0252180863, 0.0031861837, 0.006634085, -0.0875732228, 0.094659254, 0.0062911096, 0.0177385267, -0.0504137576, 0.0084774019, 0.0207352974, -0.0472067297, -0.0284467861, 0.0462561846, -0.0607196391, -0.0288982149, -0.072167106, 0.0740701333, 0.014538045, 0.0364475138, 0.0095158499, -0.0261850767, 0.0313074738, 0.0204884224, -0.063697271, 0.0274358932, 0.0038140547, -0.0392463207, -0.0201789085, -0.0143298125, -0.0479386412, 0.002897376, 0.0116094667, 0.0245833863, -0.062853083, -0.0308518186, 0.0115414867, 0.0018177397, 0.0313994437, 0.0096339174, 0.0206127167, -0.0568427928, 0.0131742246, 0.0257105175, -0.0104832873, -0.0597390719, -0.0038788228, -0.0006373405, 0.0232733563, -0.0069222134, 0.004577138, -0.0006832927, 0.0426817909, -0.0050729625, -0.0484115444, 0.0751016662, 0.0074727465, -0.0000562415, 0.0118287401, -0.0206570085, 0.0338717364, 0.0029994703, 0.0255937129, -0.0041938163, 0.0894065872, 0.0401435569, -0.0396260135, -0.0374409296, 0.0279125292, -0.0284793861, 0.0058521456, -0.0331593677, 0.0712716132, 0.0422623828, -0.001854673, -0.0112796221, 0.0187634546, -0.0187959075, 0.0022761473, 0.0139352065, -0.0001196472, -0.0220463164, 0.0720524192, 0.0268297307, 0.0250804164, -0.0151125249, 0.0512340702, -0.0286891777, 0.0329338945, -0.0020254892, -0.0035315109, -0.0415460393, -0.0291179121, 0.0421685874, 0.0399123617, 0.0168910716, 0.046708785, -0.028330721, -0.0606743097, 0.0646154508, 0.0224999636, -0.0455480441, 0.0458583012, 0.0305966735, 0.0264578033, 0.0563827194, -0.054457739, -0.0180332102, 0.0175564755, -0.0048259269, 0.0101708965, 0.0232741628, -6.522215712e-33, -0.0672749728, -0.041481629, 0.0377186723, -0.0242406055, -0.0356005877, 0.0317477398, -0.0302034821, -0.000980495, -0.0310956892, -0.0104269497, 0.0102134068, 0.0063045723, -0.0068248725, 0.0406456999, -0.0509375371, 0.0136278942, 0.0194784869, 0.0059900363, 0.0296017937, -0.0055073062, 0.0243649799, 0.046184402, 0.0426715873, -0.0345451981, -0.0143395439, 0.0075525497, -0.0119455233, 0.0483039916, -0.0155296614, 0.0470356867, -0.0584297888, 0.0231050495, 0.0261473358, -0.0111720264, -0.0030955335, 0.0201010555, -0.1348843277, -0.0397329926, 0.0299591832, 0.022312345, -0.0732550398, 0.0294922944, 0.0498302095, -0.0285597537, 0.0884429887, -0.0232630242, 0.0575605258, -0.0050984682, 0.0019837285, -0.0049580652, -0.0306903459, -0.003815972, -0.0133766076, -0.0163749494, -0.0240545105, 0.0275360234, 0.0469670147, 0.0165665429, -0.0667248443, -0.0197297558, -0.0307290964, 0.0025696449, 0.0188208316, 0.0697408244, -0.0004559145, 0.0658584908, -0.0025829943, -0.0659138337, -0.0796863958, 0.0160501506, 0.031390857, 0.0363054499, 0.0411305614, 0.1004840657, 0.0366751701, 0.0178841725, -0.0523620918, 0.0315855742, -0.0423198193, 0.0525053553, -0.0481043942, -0.0224604104, 0.0193540957, 0.003365597, -0.0142832873, -0.0194839258, -0.0605353788, 0.0023499043, 0.040935535, 0.014250665, -0.0126785152, 0.0360782966, 0.0347666778, -0.0312765874, 0.030894829, 0.0163758676, -0.0128126945, 0.0403674692, 0.0101369536, 0.0326347426, -0.0253066514, 0.0024411441, 0.0689590052, -0.0419269018, -0.0111676613, 0.0284635387, 0.0404374786, 0.0099867005, -0.0386133455, -0.0276666023, -0.0394533463, 0.0235591959, -0.0068680821, 0.0333611779, 0.0023874447, 0.0214649271, -0.067071557, 0.0116862515, -0.0033314431, -0.001538079, -0.0164153259, -0.0265896153, 0.0196004417, 0.0439843386, 0.0020538836, 0.0129177989, -0.0119245015, -0.0602780022, -0.0172810499, -0.0827749893, -0.009989311, 0.0551534109, 2.592e-7, 0.0537594073, -0.0270098653, 0.0312474612, 0.0073506311, -0.0175426267, 0.0257471129, -0.0459794253, 0.0433468074, 0.0134091275, -0.0787925944, -0.0038100251, 0.0472255982, -0.0095506748, 0.0194075014, -0.0484565608, -0.0230255891, -0.0227109343, -0.0403530598, -0.0378356762, 0.0119323879, 0.0503952578, 0.0738707632, 0.0125885867, -0.0508494563, 0.0167694837, -0.0790870711, 0.1008679643, -0.0037586505, 0.0012015442, -0.014340044, 0.0223897304, 0.0347111225, -0.0225791112, 0.0675171092, 0.018965276, -0.0152371395, 0.0618793406, 0.0035730156, -0.0120250722, -0.071446687, -0.0312838666, 0.0252177343, 0.0007529226, -0.0084838467, 0.0771447867, -0.0270396788, -0.0050921733, -0.0016772592, -0.0654239282, -0.0124069806, 0.0210541263, -0.0179666821, 0.0012363732, 0.0262004659, 0.0337689072, -0.0203840658, -0.0102050975, -0.1297674626, -0.013760319, -0.0053072805, -0.051522702, -0.0002716938, -0.0359323993, -0.0464876927, 0.0299519692, -0.0463144816, -0.0525071509, 1.911461836e-34, 0.0022991162, -0.0128304036, 0.0136641068, 0.0217521023, 0.0137066683, -0.0315866768, -0.0779523775, -0.0622300357, 0.0069279177, -0.0708112642, -0.0006111031 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.04347v3
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.04347v3
Counteracts: Testing Stereotypical Representation in Pre-trained Language Models
2023-01-11T07:52:59
2023-04-07T17:12:23
Damin Zhang, Julia Rayz, Romila Pradhan
cs.CL
cs.CL
Recently, language models have demonstrated strong performance on various natural language understanding tasks. Language models trained on large human-generated corpus encode not only a significant amount of human knowledge, but also the human stereotype. As more and more downstream tasks have integrated language models as part of the pipeline, it is necessary to understand the internal stereotypical representation in order to design the methods for mitigating the negative effects. In this paper, we use counterexamples to examine the internal stereotypical knowledge in pre-trained language models (PLMs) that can lead to stereotypical preference. We mainly focus on gender stereotypes, but the method can be extended to other types of stereotype. We evaluate 7 PLMs on 9 types of cloze-style prompt with different information and base knowledge. The results indicate that PLMs show a certain amount of robustness against unrelated information and preference of shallow linguistic cues, such as word position and syntactic structure, but a lack of interpreting information by meaning. Such findings shed light on how to interact with PLMs in a neutral approach for both finetuning and evaluation.
[ 0.074556917, 0.0475416481, -0.0294969231, 0.0213381946, 0.0065567279, 0.0184909534, 0.02507741, -0.0298943073, 0.030145945, -0.1044256464, -0.0596033074, -0.0549418665, 0.0093067652, 0.0564376339, 0.0179832596, -0.0546804816, 0.0452220626, 0.0124446796, 0.0040510362, -0.040915329, 0.0096146259, 0.0185929779, 0.0301076565, 0.0177281648, 0.0249482933, -0.0348838456, 0.0434561893, -0.0237827245, -0.044957988, 0.0006891894, 0.0585598275, 0.0728842467, 0.0395000279, -0.0097679906, 0.0000021593, -0.0896551162, 0.0320933722, -0.025856683, -0.0177077726, 0.0151838288, 0.0198552441, -0.0026148844, -0.0088455882, 0.0161420889, -0.0317279249, -0.0350451916, 0.0230729748, 0.0416461788, 0.0318635814, 0.0138784982, -0.0020055447, -0.0241472684, -0.080170542, -0.0180414058, -0.0171326026, 0.0161973443, 0.0406602733, -0.0492094755, -0.0300856475, -0.0194066092, -0.0148205347, -0.0158818234, -0.0137187978, 0.0382061377, -0.0042606383, 0.0247138832, -0.0384009853, -0.0562070608, -0.0109783309, 0.0745023936, -0.0128656821, -0.0282827746, -0.022708185, -0.0097058685, 0.0074988962, 0.0042940881, 0.0072670551, 0.0351880863, -0.0092840148, -0.0195092764, -0.0316422097, 0.032144893, 0.0134496009, 0.0342193656, -0.0329672992, 0.0657582432, 0.0164079797, -0.0250107553, 0.0082944194, 0.0074799163, -0.0254221614, -0.0312454887, -0.0024950067, -0.0283630006, 0.0050363932, 0.0290788412, -0.0232797712, 0.0128077241, 0.0136589725, -0.0721256956, 0.0039093778, 0.0634058416, -0.0140827671, 0.0147918761, -0.0164753534, 0.030703323, 0.0166227221, 0.0144290728, -0.0029877489, -0.0107797869, -0.0124006644, -0.0296050236, -0.020369444, 0.0285047516, 0.0400074534, 0.0392700657, -0.0315330513, -0.007923645, -0.0189766791, 0.0000883592, -0.0090508237, 0.0328541994, -0.0335778631, -0.0239665955, -0.090200901, 0.0114975255, -0.0470722616, 0.0169361029, -0.0786914751, -0.094383955, 0.0179349333, 0.0134904459, -0.0132582551, -0.048545476, 0.0028806035, 0.0649517477, 0.0085923141, -0.0446747765, -0.020268511, -0.0100436788, -0.0380952507, -0.0541387498, 0.0018755813, -0.0254570339, 0.0084824637, 0.0253219269, 0.0248100385, -0.0642923862, -0.0111278631, 0.0012790762, -0.0401855148, 0.0925056189, 0.0570942163, -0.0030076199, 0.0173695572, 0.0257541444, -0.0260361247, 0.0791367143, -0.0125983898, -0.0032456124, 0.0206820276, -0.0416118465, -0.0255040247, 0.043480508, 0.0357947126, -0.0186991449, -0.0404235646, 0.0559231639, 0.0185148381, 0.0032778338, 0.0786653161, 0.0093488181, 0.0089599453, -0.0457112566, 0.0625533089, 0.0702447593, -0.0105094695, -0.004322798, 0.053040579, 0.0142948646, 0.0058241282, 0.0504581705, -0.0825891346, -0.0326329805, -0.0108447764, -0.0186667759, -0.0375287831, 0.0629335791, -0.0280323531, -0.0138524873, -0.0125946496, -0.0199317802, 0.0077764727, -0.0040746941, 0.0259465668, 0.0355552174, 0.0091312863, 0.0902961567, 0.0225346144, -0.0164720099, -0.0126167396, -0.0335848592, 0.0207771547, 0.0456977151, 0.0221400578, -0.0169794839, -0.0094753709, -0.01585963, -0.0753619373, 0.0387433432, 0.0787924975, 0.0088028545, 0.0342073105, -0.0147871487, 0.0008082398, 0.0199877582, 0.0247936249, 0.029105233, 0.0320664495, 0.0399673507, 0.0382203385, -0.0334107168, -0.0304107592, 0.0249815639, -0.0149219539, -0.0299298968, 0.0011100181, 0.0202668719, 0.0309086833, 0.0081437994, -0.0146598015, 0.0024002821, -0.0069158026, 0.0117768236, 0.0246543884, 0.0638434961, -0.1105594337, -0.0335857235, -0.001441448, -0.0499716103, -0.0636818781, 0.0226989649, -0.0013325699, -0.0244786423, 0.0540025085, -0.0015425888, 0.0611023046, -0.0487432145, 0.0171152744, -0.0217297673, 0.0334958546, -0.0043113944, 0.0391548276, 0.0015323656, -0.0176599137, 0.0140228234, -0.0314796939, 0.016721772, -0.0384503491, -0.0437958501, 0.0231549181, 0.0011214379, -0.0167193599, 0.0066269371, -0.0257258434, -0.0376615189, 0.014448191, -0.0460151993, -0.0323476717, 0.0170630813, -0.0264442004, 0.023592215, 0.0234157313, -0.0368953571, -0.042251721, -0.0249141045, -0.0289879795, -0.0073687085, 0.0377588086, 0.0314201862, -0.0085548917, 0.0326688327, -0.0333289616, 0.0055323816, -0.0426225998, 0.0517783202, -0.0093480349, 0.0054325075, -0.0390646905, 0.0371981673, -0.0211624596, 0.0399665125, 0.0112134106, -0.0558501817, 0.0147074647, 0.0150501309, 0.0427025445, 0.0617618337, 0.0132201742, 0.0040793559, 0.0664531216, 0.0033303578, -0.0600615181, -0.0152188279, -0.0025603708, 0.0281176325, 0.0259653796, -0.0420369208, -0.0266186874, 0.0819310769, 0.0241966471, -0.0328061469, -0.0478026196, 0.0637040809, -0.0257497095, -0.0336307995, -0.0248460323, -0.042395547, 0.0065400354, 0.043688979, -0.0457504913, -0.0498408452, 0.0743502229, -0.0457558483, -0.0133147277, -0.0195236802, 0.0158317257, -0.0472070314, 0.0428582579, 0.0255173706, 0.014477862, 0.0575343296, -0.0284362119, -0.0823423937, -0.0397273079, 0.0167370774, -0.0073652165, 0.0078727826, -0.0295829549, 0.006837192, 0.0120749585, -0.0405727588, -0.0715205744, -0.0639618635, -0.0350051932, -0.0296623278, 0.0075353025, 0.0053491862, 0.0207462143, 0.0424143784, -0.0194285363, 0.0323476084, -0.005987193, 0.0133572407, 0.0040106303, -0.0148225287, 0.0283645969, 0.0412293226, 0.0079475585, 0.0085491445, 0.0397436842, -0.0202029459, -0.0565873869, -0.0055824188, -0.0204489809, 0.0411253013, 0.0326129161, -0.0461852103, -0.028174242, -0.015089809, 0.0491233468, -0.0335808024, -0.0163783338, 0.119112283, 0.0399591587, -0.0521868356, 0.0249139685, 0.0193924401, 0.0034881916, 0.0499020703, 0.009798754, -0.0453624241, -0.0376723073, 0.0008303322, -0.0072965259, -0.0336813442, -0.0469115153, -0.0436382368, -0.1366815716, -0.0110398764, 0.0070695891, -0.0715746582, -0.0135159604, -0.0119361989, 0.0051512779, -0.0023406462, 0.0207561776, -0.0112162307, -0.0187924914, 0.0133770742, -0.0171910767, -0.0624109805, -0.0607283041, 0.052661512, -0.0391958579, 0.0448317155, 0.0323830955, -0.0063414094, -0.0122125261, 0.0258477796, 0.0353166759, -0.0373409986, 0.0225865003, -0.0377952233, 0.035286013, -0.0340698138, -0.0119924527, -0.0167384949, 0.0066303145, -0.0047206925, 0.0264859479, -0.0253501274, 0.0345472917, -0.0031364586, -0.0439486019, -0.0374904014, 0.018219538, -0.005115422, 0.112220861, 0.0354029164, -0.0334260128, -0.025785977, -0.0435841084, -0.0134785092, 0.0189873353, -0.0605090931, 0.0244122129, 0.0281978715, -0.0188489351, -0.0266680829, -0.0888151005, 0.025752455, 0.0037615371, 0.0134151354, -0.0503241718, -0.0010124134, 0.0006153994, -0.0645465553, 0.0580697283, -0.0072729862, 0.000817715, -0.0170678422, -0.0158891249, 0.0463652238, -0.0684285387, -0.0260004848, 0.022153046, 0.0114588747, -0.0553791523, 0.0261477362, 0.0458994359, 0.0295225065, 0.0688971877, -0.0238843709, -0.0545235015, 0.069242619, 0.0199627131, -0.0154088717, -0.0143286763, 0.0285782926, 0.019802127, 0.0133106839, 0.0324250795, -0.0183885694, 0.075251624, -0.0009777363, -0.0320181996, -0.0037603073, -0.0601086356, 0.0289845895, 0.0204264112, 0.0447827242, -0.0331033245, 0.0497719161, -0.0427430794, -0.0058056223, -0.0297220647, -0.0621622615, 0.0193979815, -0.0350378938, 0.0207474101, 0.0083553288, -0.0262449309, -0.0316960998, -0.0803238228, 0.0540129393, 0.0162309371, -0.0012348661, 0.0872171968, 0.0378269255, 0.0105017051, 0.0107691083, -0.0076029915, 0.0401409008, -0.0290110502, 0.038751293, 0.0177692939, 0.0439268127, -0.012116136, 0.0228086449, -0.0164726861, 0.0124629475, -0.0299939755, -0.0228059851, -0.0139835365, 0.0057878662, -0.0006387747, -0.0712843612, 0.0193379372, -0.0052588037, 0.0157636162, 0.0051790033, 0.0141362129, 0.0114179412, 0.0005934164, 0.0599394403, 0.0081283012, -0.0251977351, -0.018217003, 0.0703340545, 0.0271364395, 0.0556862243, -0.023057228, -0.0231480096, -0.0316582918, 0.0119953277, 0.0262672305, 0.0075836335, -0.0188389532, 0.011315098, -0.0874942765, -0.0808154196, -0.0108321505, -0.0168469809, 0.01492137, 0.0177951828, 0.0202791039, 0.0580801219, 0.0059323739, -0.0151522486, -0.0059482404, 0.017998701, -0.0186440833, 0.024763776, -0.0148684895, -7.126009855e-33, -0.0511598215, -0.0404679328, -0.0289737731, -0.0324016549, 0.0157737099, -0.0132488534, -0.0343826786, 0.0013791139, -0.0277385525, -0.0074318177, -0.0083077606, 0.0293770526, 0.014532201, -0.0245624408, 0.0027069759, 0.0327041075, 0.0695163831, -0.0131866662, -0.0414525345, -0.0638370216, 0.0283732023, 0.0377734378, 0.0616403557, -0.0191511121, 0.0731194988, -0.0072628101, 0.0004694444, -0.0045426749, -0.0089407824, 0.0477338471, -0.0433021896, 0.0694643259, 0.033948604, -0.0143013149, -0.0233373959, 0.0812549293, -0.0719837397, -0.0576061159, 0.0486873612, 0.0546541139, 0.0401778482, -0.0182288624, 0.0339989997, -0.0214449316, -0.0408361778, 0.0271023102, 0.0378725417, -0.015757544, 0.0529405475, 0.0442842692, -0.0256162398, 0.010011605, -0.0159252919, 0.011765698, -0.0019384457, 0.0384667516, 0.0013236358, 0.0485230759, -0.0556945167, 0.0505286939, -0.0116968015, -0.028770525, 0.0653729737, 0.0199781805, 0.0261369199, 0.0310256071, 0.0227899794, 0.0360894427, -0.0061464342, -0.0230136774, 0.05185524, -0.036845535, -0.0105455006, 0.0538768917, 0.050417956, -0.0098869922, -0.0183781218, -0.0000207466, 0.0589019544, -0.0081581874, 0.0211005025, -0.0241328869, -0.0748295411, -0.059879642, -0.0473168194, -0.0719904602, -0.0165549237, -0.0269899685, 0.0262968484, -0.0279808547, -0.0317904651, 0.0117300823, 0.0145634962, -0.0494212732, -0.0187914427, -0.0147337066, -0.0161244553, -0.0314770341, 0.0342533514, 0.0347541757, -0.0586882383, 0.0068362709, 0.0316418, 0.0448765308, 0.0129680503, 0.0454565771, -0.0114626493, 0.0101056686, -0.0478337109, 0.0028942472, -0.0203288887, -0.0136041818, -0.0056206128, 0.0135222878, 0.0426870435, 0.0444429144, -0.033484824, 0.0267302208, 0.0240319949, -0.01405372, -0.0395842344, 0.0110872658, 0.0219865013, 0.0723092854, -0.0201396979, -0.0316355899, 0.0143688321, -0.0153965261, 0.0456856415, -0.0255453102, 0.0008609317, -0.0295702554, 2.799e-7, 0.0228261817, 0.0400201678, 0.0069777812, 0.0480493493, 0.0505719557, 0.0495392866, 0.0025420273, 0.0274802092, 0.0003232571, -0.0257735495, -0.005625315, 0.0257039536, -0.0149129266, 0.0253559016, -0.0650418848, 0.0213478748, -0.0423498638, 0.0142854685, -0.0146950511, 0.0064056586, 0.0504766367, 0.0872377455, -0.0058436743, -0.0113577908, -0.0332384631, -0.0365625694, 0.0248299744, -0.0315752104, 0.026674388, 0.0081470944, 0.0231940672, 0.0402068309, -0.0053017531, 0.0571590289, 0.0121301161, 0.0156556629, 0.0051903934, 0.0083997976, -0.032038454, -0.0174413063, -0.0261747614, 0.0118410597, -0.016606275, -0.0667513311, 0.0801386237, -0.0484316461, -0.0550446473, -0.026427405, -0.0249638986, -0.0120457942, 0.0469742902, -0.0100256531, -0.0088619115, 0.0061083008, 0.0200289395, -0.0236668512, -0.0127180154, -0.0602416173, -0.0325936899, 0.0089595411, -0.0205345787, -0.0536301956, -0.0157259945, -0.0310805943, 0.0547874756, -0.0467061885, 0.0267813243, 2.3185547e-34, 0.0325446874, 0.028632639, 0.0244240426, -0.0102657536, 0.0221686307, -0.0270705111, 0.0149099492, -0.0055200807, 0.0651722699, -0.0220397264, -0.0053924369 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.04339v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.04339v1
Topics in Contextualised Attention Embeddings
2023-01-11T07:26:19
2023-01-11T07:26:19
Mozhgan Talebpour, Alba Garcia Seco de Herrera, Shoaib Jameel
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.IR
Contextualised word vectors obtained via pre-trained language models encode a variety of knowledge that has already been exploited in applications. Complementary to these language models are probabilistic topic models that learn thematic patterns from the text. Recent work has demonstrated that conducting clustering on the word-level contextual representations from a language model emulates word clusters that are discovered in latent topics of words from Latent Dirichlet Allocation. The important question is how such topical word clusters are automatically formed, through clustering, in the language model when it has not been explicitly designed to model latent topics. To address this question, we design different probe experiments. Using BERT and DistilBERT, we find that the attention framework plays a key role in modelling such word topic clusters. We strongly believe that our work paves way for further research into the relationships between probabilistic topic models and pre-trained language models.
[ 0.0146292606, 0.0102302665, -0.02065566, 0.0363757461, -0.0086702388, 0.0108242258, 0.0134623488, -0.0156152472, -0.0565083511, -0.0538053848, -0.0230581742, -0.0213629548, -0.0111344391, 0.0481085777, 0.0639885888, -0.0634972081, 0.0429762974, -0.0231568515, 0.0112661934, 0.0347079486, 0.0186472367, -0.0184896365, -0.0061564907, 0.0256205834, -0.018870566, -0.0246264581, -0.0220493302, -0.0482689478, 0.0083623715, -0.000582444, 0.0021090449, 0.0793076158, 0.054195255, -0.0215862729, 0.0000017589, -0.0158006456, -0.0075860592, -0.0445116907, 0.0445134714, 0.0513667576, 0.0738974661, -0.008707243, 0.0359180421, 0.0013145298, 0.0049409876, -0.0067207562, 0.0264386665, 0.0583363585, 0.0214784816, 0.0324489996, -0.0249198377, -0.0099842539, 0.01749897, -0.0502311178, 0.0323153697, -0.0337933861, 0.0029176802, 0.0122182732, -0.0085710045, 0.0488272421, -0.0201270487, 0.0085252607, -0.0135269398, 0.0192739498, 0.0782409385, 0.0641994923, -0.0206356775, -0.0213452335, 0.005719074, 0.0632805005, -0.0288840774, -0.020826377, -0.0034892142, 0.006892249, -0.0329514891, 0.0334264375, -0.0328269862, 0.0463196188, 0.013510921, 0.0328015238, 0.1017913222, 0.0213799253, 0.0256952904, -0.0404199362, -0.0308395997, 0.0557508692, 0.0566670336, -0.0239467658, -0.0333346426, 0.013903914, -0.0268288851, -0.0572527945, 0.0121573554, -0.0036331841, 0.0601550527, 0.0294561628, -0.0181284659, 0.0060477438, 0.0170096587, -0.0262646917, -0.009508742, 0.0214088019, -0.0324587785, 0.0601497218, 0.0155556407, 0.0114925578, -0.0404029749, -0.0199440587, -0.0624517351, -0.0036638398, 0.0100494474, 0.004629497, -0.0177710764, 0.0143047143, -0.0015694422, -0.0425210856, 0.033768557, 0.0758289844, 0.0152508235, -0.0385271423, -0.0618190095, -0.0172004383, -0.0262430329, 0.0044323904, 0.0095374119, -0.0013948531, -0.0820744261, 0.0500708632, -0.0290394705, 0.0164708477, -0.0147517296, 0.0627494603, 0.0137882642, -0.0271745902, -0.0595905408, 0.0104271034, -0.0118499417, -0.0582342036, -0.0582321882, -0.0241151713, -0.0220651515, 0.0233928952, 0.0248771869, -0.0608194359, 0.0149689978, 0.0438968129, -0.0111552011, 0.0061929058, 0.0005592871, 0.0328712501, -0.0474742651, 0.0575101636, 0.0228795204, 0.0198923722, 0.0339080505, 0.0165793449, 0.0122987833, 0.0427794531, -0.0109468652, 0.0284321997, 0.0238996819, -0.023114698, -0.0037334883, -0.0099857422, 0.0269645154, 0.0340305269, -0.0244695041, 0.0135982931, 0.0007102379, -0.0025085257, 0.0688207522, 0.0358911455, -0.0497221276, 0.0057863509, 0.0430874564, 0.1262378842, -0.0001200163, 0.0460057557, -0.0079822987, -0.0030300436, -0.0176819321, 0.0177998617, -0.0327652059, 0.0129725058, -0.0337686017, -0.0159832034, 0.0971684381, -0.0216232017, -0.0477575697, 0.0097691929, -0.0095121162, 0.0091185858, 0.012789377, -0.0537642278, 0.0737254024, 0.004812717, 0.0059367339, 0.0403860584, 0.0467873663, -0.0046969084, 0.0193152558, -0.0088940188, 0.0536599532, 0.0122271935, 0.0390868634, -0.0597545542, -0.0296874344, -0.0087170443, 0.0024485879, 0.0133454958, -0.0134671666, -0.0120584061, -0.0515591092, 0.0004417733, -0.0040110401, -0.0504014902, 0.0101920748, 0.0137638981, -0.0185587462, -0.0051803547, -0.0103221498, -0.0554414801, 0.03730461, 0.0547651984, 0.0145772407, -0.0163834672, -0.0179956295, 0.0034246857, 0.0275025293, 0.002421706, -0.0044300468, 0.0498690903, 0.0664155036, -0.0411927402, 0.019002663, -0.0009206767, -0.0080608362, -0.0430098325, -0.0027079475, -0.0619988441, 0.0134390388, -0.031535361, 0.0146896522, -0.0080050025, 0.063996464, -0.0424464308, 0.0638498664, -0.0353168808, 0.0040503554, -0.0234480202, 0.0106953355, -0.0305317435, 0.078684479, -0.0384933501, 0.0505850613, 0.0261873305, 0.031928163, -0.0123775424, -0.0033055313, -0.0019827052, -0.0325604118, 0.0304037835, -0.0020440717, 0.0402787067, -0.032063175, -0.0086021628, -0.0055835731, -0.0890237987, 0.0128550744, -0.0514152125, -0.0090584308, 0.052425392, -0.0068068891, 0.009166168, -0.012685542, -0.0200902577, -0.0344581716, -0.0362240039, 0.0218473952, 0.0320112072, -0.040190272, 0.0416883603, -0.0669281185, -0.0260856356, -0.0355202742, 0.079545781, 0.0043450501, 0.0008785267, -0.0581681728, 0.0147962086, 0.0092705255, -0.0176612642, -0.0205443539, 0.0080383727, 0.0282734372, -0.0463398993, 0.1178652942, 0.0447415225, 0.0338783376, 0.0762775242, 0.0722537786, 0.0015539494, -0.0141618783, -0.0079225935, -0.0463682152, 0.0333158113, -0.0110176206, -0.02589426, 0.0523703247, 0.0654953867, 0.0133926757, 0.0060329065, -0.0466019548, 0.0097973477, -0.0177456141, 0.0026687246, -0.067388691, 0.0104125198, -0.0231297947, 0.0300730802, -0.0352048576, -0.0482897758, 0.0488567278, 0.0121747721, 0.008068921, -0.0657159686, 0.006683745, 0.0020636218, 0.0208070315, 0.031264402, 0.0079518631, -0.0695047081, -0.0102411052, -0.0120191006, 0.0400599875, -0.0293761753, 0.0170090999, 0.0645211115, -0.0085835923, -0.0132944919, 0.0216161646, 0.046042975, -0.0460341126, -0.0589445233, 0.0123696662, 0.0149771646, 0.034636762, 0.0122148367, -0.0582681, 0.0325192697, 0.0288244206, 0.023327535, 0.007410693, -0.0082528712, -0.0258261114, 0.0684523433, 0.0378430635, -0.063393563, 0.0033315627, -0.0272013117, -0.026026845, 0.0422758162, 0.0519680455, -0.009866247, -0.0180541743, 0.014508931, 0.0182629842, -0.0496616662, -0.0019919185, 0.0014733118, 0.0128266206, 0.0005906216, -0.0470894612, 0.0991913825, 0.0484859645, -0.0810855255, -0.0000028035, -0.011992638, -0.0084588453, 0.018275056, 0.0172762629, -0.0148260901, 0.0052022473, -0.0361512303, 0.0051361257, 0.0514696948, -0.0114353644, -0.0091669578, -0.062732771, 0.0127093354, -0.010611847, -0.052153796, -0.0434799679, -0.0901059583, 0.0333547965, 0.0160369743, -0.0018169653, 0.0126229031, -0.0012923804, 0.0124078626, 0.0143611971, -0.0122601474, -0.0190756749, 0.0045253579, -0.0494750962, 0.0556616969, 0.0469798297, 0.0113150524, -0.007221981, -0.0310529303, -0.0339249037, -0.0539852269, -0.0123346644, 0.0171698108, -0.0093239257, -0.0339245722, 0.0215511061, 0.0067302929, 0.0316480845, -0.0698579699, -0.0520048216, 0.0146149229, 0.0925087556, -0.0255929772, -0.0240372662, -0.0339219645, 0.0043154717, 0.0116459019, 0.0671906173, 0.0633050501, -0.0512882695, 0.0278885011, 0.0013030685, 0.0415814705, 0.0669355243, -0.0114659155, -0.0119370529, -0.0184363425, -0.0398763157, -0.0743158087, -0.05061955, 0.0532141998, -0.0042458968, -0.010218027, -0.0045999754, 0.0096269408, -0.0493016131, -0.0515392646, 0.0757834166, 0.0149939088, -0.0223283693, -0.0601999201, -0.0403983593, 0.020001309, -0.0402466618, -0.0137363831, -0.0407500751, -0.0590694025, -0.0336720683, 0.0180662032, -0.011345746, -0.0009865719, 0.0213745274, -0.0669355169, -0.0671558082, -0.008992712, -0.037799105, -0.0477074459, 0.0082986606, -0.0331747755, 0.0168140922, 0.0119329123, 0.003989181, -0.0427187234, 0.0595326088, 0.0003643821, 0.0016421602, -0.0560913347, -0.0653143376, -0.0131750079, -0.0386850089, 0.1243794411, 0.012177703, -0.0272540357, -0.0513644032, -0.0512618981, 0.0118850721, 0.0138552319, -0.0004601477, -0.0052074487, -0.0018790545, -0.0071792859, -0.02328231, 0.0176120996, -0.0577973351, 0.0020294592, -0.0298163332, 0.0274472982, 0.0278739296, 0.0256417971, -0.0301776715, 0.0239062272, -0.0114220995, -0.0045145112, -0.0668975189, 0.0253482908, -0.0184215121, 0.0448069945, -0.0028644379, -0.0216770917, -0.0251238365, 0.0209712852, -0.0880140737, -0.0157740116, -0.0142906094, 0.0207719989, -0.0076063802, -0.0517822132, -0.0046863197, -0.0376539193, -0.0058119432, -0.0180768222, 0.0121476622, -0.0076814033, 0.0015922268, 0.0187119413, 0.0297804177, -0.0087589743, 0.0088273715, 0.0591207221, 0.006613906, -0.0107369749, 0.0256630592, -0.0339524299, -0.0305058714, 0.0508057326, 0.05327731, 0.0676372796, -0.0420169272, 0.0537670366, -0.0147130657, -0.0207819026, 0.0169447847, -0.0161922667, -0.0369767472, -0.015014112, 0.0556044541, 0.0812895223, -0.0294967685, 0.0254286025, -0.0555075034, 0.0737741962, -0.0258403141, -0.0334333144, -0.0335207768, -6.661465507e-33, -0.0174933523, -0.0503067113, -0.0193742439, -0.0209637079, -0.0026150392, 0.0249772985, -0.0554776564, 0.0054737534, 0.0075268536, 0.0070202104, -0.0147714047, 0.0501233228, -0.0121781025, -0.0088428846, 0.0107620321, -0.0117519582, 0.0191529058, -0.0064759157, -0.0251781642, 0.055841621, 0.0447890982, 0.0011120958, 0.039415285, -0.0152197788, 0.0229970794, -0.0300014783, 0.0593354441, 0.0193821583, 0.071227774, 0.0444852896, -0.0612200014, 0.0050498592, 0.0389043987, -0.0238961428, -0.0143772336, 0.070151031, -0.0430297181, -0.0834978595, 0.008802616, -0.0364030935, -0.041972287, -0.049611032, 0.0317301936, 0.0141648827, 0.0326141976, 0.0127934776, 0.0623837337, 0.0369929224, -0.0749210119, -0.009501121, -0.0602389649, 0.0192654878, -0.0216593388, 0.0096032899, 0.0130120115, -0.0255076475, 0.0109884907, 0.0412563458, -0.0221456047, 0.0395585895, 0.0106812073, 0.0167885497, 0.025130501, 0.0383634083, 0.0029713833, 0.0527858138, -0.0157833435, 0.0146217952, -0.0370841064, -0.0048735505, 0.0388536006, 0.0632113218, 0.0061782445, -0.0319060311, -0.0210395865, 0.0326034352, -0.0164598189, 0.0271238424, 0.0244030468, -0.0203953758, 0.0628752708, 0.0018124132, -0.0228295308, -0.020266436, -0.0406248681, -0.034493912, -0.0426016636, -0.0015233301, 0.01306991, 0.0020847586, -0.0217679553, -0.0095715802, 0.0214270633, 0.0024862504, 0.0404021665, 0.0151540553, 0.0165859163, 0.0142936716, 0.0109364418, 0.0389397666, -0.0788322389, -0.0121514881, 0.0200514048, -0.0295200441, -0.0223614238, 0.0129234577, -0.030522164, -0.0196313169, -0.0171157531, -0.0378079899, 0.0037437347, -0.0635665432, -0.0095667476, 0.0319463275, 0.0353067555, 0.0122883543, -0.0071651195, 0.036057137, 0.0620309263, 0.0004762275, -0.0066188807, -0.0247657839, -0.0131826634, 0.030230185, -0.02537168, -0.0187561158, -0.0292583518, 0.064368397, 0.0615941398, -0.0467281006, -0.029985087, 0.0103443433, 2.483e-7, 0.0873653516, 0.0618531853, -0.0141647197, -0.0211549066, 0.0448214822, 0.0177287105, -0.0090092588, 0.0500134714, 0.0132902302, -0.0033943213, 0.0126363114, 0.046727512, -0.0227081515, 0.0309250746, -0.0159569774, 0.0097903702, -0.0038827413, 0.0546510667, -0.0222386681, -0.0315376818, -0.0191352777, 0.0992709994, 0.0074398052, 0.0224428605, -0.0115221133, -0.0257765781, 0.0425254926, -0.0329372026, -0.0378577262, 0.0090678418, 0.0122750914, 0.033028096, 0.0000524121, -0.0076074209, -0.0078116069, 0.0251897499, 0.0308690816, 0.0244563669, -0.0274504349, -0.0429203101, -0.0261086039, -0.0407709703, -0.0004986239, -0.0571417399, 0.0440380462, -0.0560015701, -0.0105295377, -0.0160503257, -0.0100298747, 0.0314937793, 0.0005296411, 0.0216191765, -0.0469884016, -0.0061398936, -0.0018544085, 0.0005076356, 0.0109868916, -0.0739490017, -0.0145257413, 0.0417223051, -0.0651349425, -0.0368944816, -0.0346182585, -0.0463817343, 0.0472978838, -0.0251418594, 0.0204966031, 2.087426797e-34, 0.0247298162, 0.0115828188, -0.0423767865, 0.0068236091, 0.0031149238, -0.0618008301, -0.0405736268, -0.0089349048, 0.0431160554, -0.1048684791, -0.0034309309 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.04327v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.04327v1
Dual Learning for Large Vocabulary On-Device ASR
2023-01-11T06:32:28
2023-01-11T06:32:28
Cal Peyser, Ronny Huang, Tara Sainath, Rohit Prabhavalkar, Michael Picheny, Kyunghyun Cho
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI
Dual learning is a paradigm for semi-supervised machine learning that seeks to leverage unsupervised data by solving two opposite tasks at once. In this scheme, each model is used to generate pseudo-labels for unlabeled examples that are used to train the other model. Dual learning has seen some use in speech processing by pairing ASR and TTS as dual tasks. However, these results mostly address only the case of using unpaired examples to compensate for very small supervised datasets, and mostly on large, non-streaming models. Dual learning has not yet been proven effective for using unsupervised data to improve realistic on-device streaming models that are already trained on large supervised corpora. We provide this missing piece though an analysis of an on-device-sized streaming conformer trained on the entirety of Librispeech, showing relative WER improvements of 10.7%/5.2% without an LM and 11.7%/16.4% with an LM.
[ -0.0242513958, 0.004158318, -0.0098755406, 0.006579536, 0.0024215528, 0.0191300232, 0.0682929084, -0.0257057678, -0.0068962723, -0.0472292453, -0.0628956333, -0.0725204945, -0.0012859072, 0.0357749201, 0.0483562686, -0.0040640905, 0.0260241143, -0.0520336367, -0.01542388, -0.0314068049, 0.0314088911, 0.0167471692, -0.0266792793, -0.000021876, 0.0073556155, 0.0274352524, 0.0083604427, 0.0218937788, -0.0324270464, 0.0041885138, 0.0061008278, 0.0070523252, 0.0526206419, 0.0562629551, 0.0000018862, -0.0192760043, -0.0136563629, 0.0085424483, -0.0441432148, -0.0056623346, 0.0292364266, 0.0323286764, -0.0214022938, 0.0413176417, -0.0230557211, -0.0419148318, 0.0291573796, 0.0031107606, -0.0272872578, 0.041324012, -0.0145708183, -0.0428798161, -0.0065392619, -0.0164560229, -0.0489159226, 0.0001292533, -0.048611708, -0.0437315889, -0.0215942636, 0.0011197423, -0.0151819056, 0.0503687412, 0.0238199607, 0.0003786143, 0.0561473928, -0.0018348752, -0.052063752, -0.0168633051, -0.0054127467, 0.0478466824, 0.0212463196, -0.0536806509, 0.0374969207, 0.0170568582, -0.0506857932, -0.0270915385, 0.0084150396, 0.0121043576, -0.0144184502, 0.0150974402, -0.0349243321, -0.0639112666, 0.0502630584, -0.0525337569, -0.0442218408, 0.0359396413, 0.0175847281, -0.0386994369, 0.0249505546, 0.0350968502, 0.0079035591, -0.0419571139, 0.057070747, -0.0159248803, -0.0420643315, -0.0227535106, -0.0357615352, -0.0369030423, -0.0464019962, -0.031416785, 0.099369958, 0.0079565328, -0.0430918373, 0.0108972201, -0.0276507307, -0.0004921774, 0.0139599433, 0.0560191646, -0.0312568359, 0.0248440765, -0.0397813953, -0.013340245, 0.0006757414, 0.0560085885, -0.0385542624, -0.0688131973, -0.011867105, -0.0090365587, -0.0059510381, -0.0244736522, 0.030898219, -0.0234375317, -0.0275008176, -0.0029808795, 0.0547177978, 0.0723242462, 0.017618807, 0.0685842559, -0.0004361048, -0.0791964382, 0.0316221863, 0.0232168157, 0.0165207665, -0.0182065479, 0.0076481299, 0.0434217751, -0.029413728, -0.013436486, -0.0424154103, 0.0139471283, -0.0112532116, -0.0035027047, -0.0121820262, -0.0407288112, 0.0359051414, -0.0046270844, 0.0185973104, -0.0458628349, 0.0279068686, -0.0210782308, 0.0526624843, 0.0872244164, -0.0579349101, 0.0004622453, 0.0148155885, -0.0170805976, -0.0176062267, 0.056606397, 0.0724899769, -0.0350118019, 0.0282541085, -0.0554127507, -0.0448189527, 0.0564864278, 0.0105472747, -0.0288223363, -0.0213249326, -0.0595358945, 0.0325116366, 0.0324834101, 0.0526563488, 0.0472598933, -0.0023672644, -0.0018003158, 0.0694501325, 0.0301104933, 0.073651664, 0.0230819806, 0.0183174908, 0.0111101354, -0.0133118071, 0.0123095484, 0.0135676153, -0.005752231, 0.0205699634, 0.0265480801, 0.041772414, 0.0372110419, -0.0433772504, -0.0312771499, -0.0287082177, -0.0420438871, -0.008913991, 0.0586370043, 0.0656528696, 0.0119985426, 0.0045642699, 0.0372459888, 0.0085061342, -0.0548977181, 0.0215222519, -0.0579064749, -0.0100042941, 0.0298144426, 0.0020632085, -0.0501715392, -0.0588322915, -0.0410064422, 0.0127248242, 0.03341664, 0.0063775112, -0.0004617943, 0.0596155673, -0.05698606, -0.0159176327, -0.0057879561, -0.002811311, 0.0808600485, -0.040678218, 0.0195597801, -0.0016887883, -0.0093496684, 0.0131222699, -0.0194582175, -0.0335971154, -0.0093772653, 0.0605451204, 0.0151947653, 0.0449021794, 0.0028907976, -0.0513269901, -0.0117723029, 0.0331135727, -0.0568274297, 0.0099491654, 0.0136769842, -0.0642593354, 0.0053102821, 0.0349428244, 0.001441988, 0.0272634886, 0.0906563252, 0.049639076, -0.0512993783, 0.0009755052, -0.0162651744, 0.0702337474, -0.0205438156, 0.0265999548, 0.056503389, 0.0294023454, 0.0315567441, -0.0062110154, 0.0524268672, 0.0356714353, -0.0634388924, -0.0178583506, -0.0036793873, -0.0552889258, -0.0027744065, 0.0276616979, -0.0170274042, -0.0207718424, 0.0054469197, -0.0429265834, -0.0167829599, -0.0129824085, -0.0357653461, -0.0059790234, -0.0696795881, 0.0216264501, -0.0090467483, 0.0317068323, 0.0094381338, -0.0194556024, -0.0076419162, -0.0249614622, -0.0100541059, 0.0200681854, -0.0483005345, 0.0142792398, -0.0000093615, 0.0089853322, -0.0143758617, 0.01446814, -0.0209604781, -0.0083973156, -0.0270481836, -0.0663792342, -0.0247905869, 0.0245870929, 0.0010005519, 0.0183457248, 0.0163339227, 0.0183149558, -0.0010241164, 0.0215603895, 0.0408187509, -0.0066074557, 0.0096521014, 0.048130136, -0.0050469977, -0.0532908477, -0.00945793, 0.0529764928, -0.0059998673, -0.0432668813, 0.0381826907, -0.0166244693, 0.0396930054, -0.0060458006, 0.0104024895, -0.0056025903, -0.0469648018, -0.0183276888, -0.072732076, -0.0120766656, -0.0120724626, -0.0439576656, -0.0011034247, -0.0157215316, -0.0467124358, 0.0103116184, -0.0223017856, -0.0485333204, -0.0440544263, -0.0712210834, -0.0072865356, 0.0333080664, 0.0230548568, 0.0053265542, -0.0353385508, -0.0376198925, 0.0302776657, 0.0494341291, -0.0036025937, -0.0395993106, 0.0364031345, -0.0658117607, 0.0248664916, -0.0159709584, -0.0310738664, 0.0077274879, 0.0054314239, 0.0087641925, -0.0096721798, 0.0469206385, 0.0042947, -0.0305058435, 0.0487341918, 0.0158147495, 0.0830977932, 0.0552978367, 0.0107855229, -0.031850189, 0.0219295304, 0.0075451075, 0.0049334564, -0.0293665752, -0.0199681073, 0.0177444536, 0.0099830013, 0.1162116528, -0.0399220958, -0.0434210114, 0.0321519747, 0.0798718706, -0.014049245, -0.0461394154, 0.0371805876, 0.0520514883, -0.0378142446, -0.0163930804, 0.1115096733, 0.0142588913, -0.0356457122, -0.0108140623, 0.0043175346, 0.0177801009, 0.0101850247, -0.0079432465, -0.0547290184, -0.0222038906, 0.0468256623, 0.0311826281, 0.0409403369, 0.0198506191, -0.0279965792, -0.0872716308, -0.0038605775, 0.0233389698, -0.0073874998, 0.0090337666, -0.0227001663, -0.0424969755, -0.0340771191, 0.022139864, -0.0241863988, -0.0292111225, -0.0096569294, 0.0452041999, -0.1050903276, -0.0615203232, -0.0111031132, -0.0585995801, 0.0593069382, 0.0413397923, -0.016794458, -0.003702228, -0.0346378051, 0.0310800709, -0.0218393728, 0.019924162, -0.0343193598, 0.0117263794, -0.0010918166, -0.0028591075, 0.0179119315, 0.0573174953, -0.0179318246, 0.0083856303, 0.0064872494, 0.0187302027, 0.0019531953, -0.0014345336, 0.0318966061, -0.0270819124, 0.0075918543, 0.0331154987, -0.0131832743, -0.0258997791, -0.0033045807, 0.0345892049, 0.0129840104, -0.0062831845, -0.0193579365, -0.0080786152, -0.0149100311, -0.0505323485, -0.0153768798, 0.0206682123, 0.0163419191, 0.0588154122, 0.0476328842, 0.0605827272, 0.0003286913, 0.0017615308, -0.0241792575, -0.0191860963, -0.0141690392, 0.0575158447, -0.066353254, -0.0807325318, 0.0320224315, -0.0334172957, 0.0063109542, 0.0402601063, -0.041751232, -0.0918181837, 0.0302994177, -0.0031681682, 0.0239039306, 0.0650815219, -0.018691197, -0.0376182348, 0.0217128489, 0.0771809891, -0.0671341345, 0.0321139134, 0.0343598723, -0.0144273508, -0.0043813162, 0.0248028953, -0.034551397, 0.0221358277, -0.0240515135, 0.0317413174, -0.0315965563, 0.0052762693, 0.002281558, 0.0420668125, 0.0849386975, -0.0164831672, 0.0263096076, -0.0459351204, 0.0388227329, 0.0104884254, 0.0676940084, -0.0406003259, -0.0241766758, 0.0171134043, 0.0023612482, -0.0424956977, 0.0715322345, 0.0046431953, -0.0319225751, -0.0361760966, 0.0521818325, 0.0334656537, -0.0218807105, -0.0200272873, 0.0281647444, 0.0261368062, 0.0336599089, 0.083623983, 0.040396791, -0.0184381772, -0.009392431, -0.0071800379, 0.0223117433, -0.0040216101, 0.0339703374, -0.0473442003, 0.0044702515, -0.0176266301, 0.0803796798, 0.0281301979, -0.0550423153, 0.0406810567, 0.0206599701, -0.0036823135, -0.0633214787, 0.0227446128, -0.0381266288, 0.0129137207, 0.0187742896, -0.0099866521, -0.0371868648, 0.0404498652, 0.0506287441, -0.0049221092, 0.0340325832, -0.0125344703, 0.0212035589, -0.0550232902, -0.039361354, 0.0184069611, 0.0116727632, -0.0138209173, -0.0231692549, 0.0208781026, -0.0777763799, 0.0320291333, -0.0288634095, 0.0491304398, -0.0464418083, -0.0104094902, 0.0058799712, -0.027179582, 0.0378582217, -0.0064315209, -0.0534869395, 0.0104641598, 0.000996397, 0.0507516079, -5.987172193e-33, -0.0398087613, 0.0699288324, -0.0161653012, -0.002870043, -0.0127012366, 0.0096767386, 0.02723746, 0.004188749, -0.0002669296, -0.0287546068, -0.0259549152, -0.0048157703, 0.0390236005, 0.0239987243, -0.0043666265, -0.0204148274, 0.0843673199, -0.0176900085, 0.0058266209, -0.0190866254, 0.0481943898, 0.0694520548, 0.0080000963, -0.0293173529, -0.0316412039, 0.0140827354, 0.0413428694, -0.0702978894, -0.0120584015, 0.042027209, 0.0105255805, 0.0345768519, -0.0151430974, 0.0077835787, -0.0218213741, 0.0218002498, -0.07374309, 0.031204069, -0.0331983455, 0.0579513013, -0.0060779359, -0.0265458878, 0.0618352219, 0.0262470301, -0.0935600922, -0.0108819781, 0.0333996713, -0.0042112749, -0.0421049744, -0.0600175075, 0.0207005814, 0.0003178852, 0.0085030999, -0.0048809703, 0.0574420653, 0.0254953057, -0.0296444707, -0.0289716069, -0.0939440206, 0.0370407179, -0.0194343068, 0.041403994, 0.0561669506, -0.0159355085, 0.0123588964, 0.0382137261, 0.0393163785, -0.0706518441, -0.0012956804, -0.0277637746, -0.0019795056, 0.023117397, -0.0058368566, 0.0325845815, 0.0790992528, -0.0379877277, -0.0482639223, 0.0168926474, -0.0134927593, 0.0060075126, 0.0011075406, 0.0604504943, -0.0193840396, 0.0112072164, -0.0465624072, -0.0046443911, -0.031662181, -0.01484193, 0.0736723617, 0.0086353831, -0.0115847318, 0.0049832794, 0.0442436375, -0.0430183485, -0.006793079, -0.0553898513, 0.0384090021, 0.0155256297, 0.0116363531, 0.0072144256, -0.06469246, -0.0347229987, 0.0281151589, 0.0687872097, -0.0117891775, -0.026947571, 0.0238828249, 0.0481473468, -0.0701731443, 0.0114356494, -0.0124404309, 0.0124594001, 0.0128942821, -0.0090624392, 0.0799471885, -0.0308060516, -0.0191151593, 0.0722756088, -0.0596282929, -0.0148248924, 0.0058874055, -0.0376700163, -0.0039383322, 0.0168654434, -0.0233289544, 0.0316387117, -0.015665032, -0.0241039693, 0.0270548481, -0.0321325585, -0.0226609036, -0.0022442918, 2.723e-7, -0.0358685292, 0.0126706101, -0.0015453795, -0.0511700027, 0.0063267085, -0.0166429896, -0.0315818861, 0.024179915, -0.0170161687, -0.011218884, -0.0202358551, 0.0180249605, 0.0784514323, -0.0115759289, -0.0488286354, -0.0264022388, -0.0503924228, 0.1048718914, 0.0053769224, 0.0082751457, 0.0159793869, 0.0767877549, -0.0112056211, -0.0522319116, 0.0420489684, -0.0200407989, 0.0269566718, -0.0159249846, 0.0262531824, -0.0232106149, 0.0065310257, -0.0281842314, -0.0526062846, 0.0258174296, -0.0380998105, -0.0083867274, 0.0492779464, 0.0102047101, -0.0051265988, -0.0082860636, -0.0114259655, 0.0462558344, -0.0278877057, 0.0171883591, 0.0596282408, 0.0115550812, -0.0385560989, -0.0016078474, -0.0810739845, -0.0393576771, -0.0027798382, -0.0048510716, 0.0315372646, 0.0124851437, -0.0138287125, -0.0020581351, -0.0344312266, -0.0440836959, 0.0297184549, 0.0223655514, -0.0290904138, 0.007801516, -0.0679752156, 0.0466168784, 0.0408474095, -0.0511652604, -0.0057210308, 2.038960155e-34, 0.0195160788, -0.0185040757, 0.0359333009, -0.0106353443, -0.0129725682, -0.053070195, 0.0257436242, 0.0152048478, -0.0231383592, -0.0500008576, -0.0284587834 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.04312v6
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.04312v6
Word-Graph2vec: An efficient word embedding approach on word co-occurrence graph using random walk technique
2023-01-11T05:21:00
2023-12-20T02:38:55
Wenting Li, Jiahong Xue, Xi Zhang, Huacan Chen, Zeyu Chen, Feijuan Huang, Yuanzhe Cai
cs.CL
cs.CL
Word embedding has become ubiquitous and is widely used in various natural language processing (NLP) tasks, such as web retrieval, web semantic analysis, and machine translation, and so on. Unfortunately, training the word embedding in a relatively large corpus is prohibitively expensive. We propose a graph-based word embedding algorithm, called Word-Graph2vec, which converts the large corpus into a word co-occurrence graph, then takes the word sequence samples from this graph by randomly traveling and trains the word embedding on this sampling corpus in the end. We posit that because of the limited vocabulary, huge idioms, and fixed expressions in English, the size and density of the word co-occurrence graph change slightly with the increase in the training corpus. So that Word-Graph2vec has stable runtime on the large-scale data set, and its performance advantage becomes more and more obvious with the growth of the training corpus. Extensive experiments conducted on real-world datasets show that the proposed algorithm outperforms traditional Word2vec four to five times in terms of efficiency and two to three times than FastText, while the error generated by the random walk technique is small.
[ 0.0242517088, -0.008835067, 0.0134349931, 0.0385934003, -0.058248315, 0.0060999068, -0.0464080647, 0.027688643, 0.085759826, -0.0576752163, 0.0474917889, -0.0164310485, 0.0204185136, 0.042471163, 0.0112083135, -0.0062923883, 0.0596345402, 0.017447412, 0.0103840306, -0.003963619, -0.0128086498, -0.0062524481, 0.0219436344, 0.0135678863, -0.0318313614, -0.0139590455, -0.0024241507, 0.0188992117, 0.0039111497, -0.0631072745, -0.0210801847, 0.0033590074, 0.0506412536, 0.0148546156, 0.0000018185, -0.0185437351, -0.0234300233, 0.0147227813, 0.0215028655, 0.0271102376, 0.0369716957, 0.0067744814, 0.0138536729, 0.046370402, -0.0193627607, -0.0147216944, 0.0278459247, 0.0613636523, 0.0209884681, 0.0811078474, -0.0221833196, -0.0494911745, -0.0108917328, -0.0169586353, -0.0138406558, -0.0411937125, 0.0230614059, -0.0032296663, 0.0062936242, -0.0022748429, -0.0871209502, 0.0050669448, -0.0300409868, 0.0087277181, 0.0524160117, 0.0407663211, -0.0475409925, 0.0014186105, 0.0092901299, 0.083141759, -0.0298405848, -0.0054884148, 0.0008918876, 0.002813136, -0.008319173, 0.0477676839, -0.0297943, -0.0389926024, 0.0073147099, 0.0542448089, 0.0017328917, -0.0215755943, 0.0229032971, -0.0103853997, -0.0210268963, 0.0321902595, 0.0252357945, -0.0259323455, 0.0223224945, 0.0156911369, -0.0018353763, 0.0109369447, 0.0076370775, -0.0025968826, 0.001613728, 0.0376569815, -0.0309026521, -0.0055479808, 0.0244279671, -0.0963226035, 0.0011375141, -0.0190741606, 0.0228234045, 0.0583900064, -0.0381865948, -0.0177266635, 0.0135927284, 0.0347426422, -0.027660219, -0.0098936185, -0.0383772999, 0.0224484615, -0.043493472, 0.0363575816, 0.0303249918, -0.1036160812, -0.0475494377, 0.0182831343, 0.007733562, -0.0007690949, 0.0166533682, 0.0215153694, 0.0268167071, 0.0267158076, 0.0290250182, -0.0279463436, -0.0324801989, -0.003568114, -0.0413970016, 0.0091781933, -0.0148987323, 0.006840182, 0.0859118775, -0.0145019358, 0.002698805, 0.040079806, 0.0389416069, -0.1015439779, -0.0282115098, -0.0066020628, -0.007518996, 0.0000864601, -0.0251388792, -0.091059342, 0.0408277549, 0.0192183182, 0.0226740036, -0.0036020272, 0.0364058428, 0.0329770483, -0.1115628481, 0.0572082959, -0.0204734411, 0.0034467883, -0.004845771, -0.0116889719, 0.0589459129, 0.0239029955, 0.0428089164, -0.0140860565, 0.0728883818, -0.010930297, -0.0346259214, 0.0061406451, 0.0041994471, -0.0156879406, 0.0473303534, -0.0082385847, 0.0158273894, 0.036751695, 0.0036927236, 0.0679509789, -0.028865343, -0.0324997418, -0.0117726931, 0.0665082335, 0.0246969368, -0.0155492695, 0.0417252593, 0.0497074276, -0.0197459068, -0.001934813, 0.005534716, -0.0459485687, -0.0130544435, 0.0124532273, 0.0530868284, 0.0078572631, -0.0214374699, 0.0147132855, -0.0242400654, -0.0424616411, 0.1105539426, -0.0561950319, 0.0311226137, 0.0092258537, -0.0597523525, -0.0065259999, 0.045878578, -0.0169560201, -0.0316313542, 0.0206650086, -0.0314671062, 0.0483366288, 0.0796384588, 0.0186345372, 0.0112274596, 0.0005660043, -0.0034775909, 0.005558271, 0.0364752151, -0.0067990613, -0.0222162958, -0.0557341166, -0.0455052294, 0.0145523474, -0.0331742428, 0.0075172475, 0.0160821769, 0.0763424858, 0.0267650206, -0.0504774302, -0.0398107059, 0.0248502735, -0.0026316808, -0.009150533, 0.0246334299, -0.0067961318, 0.0047455286, 0.0308660064, -0.0092039714, 0.0268337782, 0.033595752, -0.0374561585, -0.0605567098, -0.0052112089, -0.0172264669, -0.0666062906, 0.0433406346, -0.0770807713, -0.0000961428, 0.0255063288, -0.0186299793, -0.0311706625, -0.0026965998, -0.0675051138, 0.0786518753, -0.0136893149, 0.0285653714, -0.0148333842, 0.0534513742, 0.0017880606, 0.0670223013, -0.0030464667, 0.038976945, -0.0205080044, 0.0303047262, 0.0086526154, -0.0198557582, -0.042515602, 0.0114429016, 0.0193817653, -0.0017870283, 0.0369117782, -0.015489772, -0.0344654433, 0.0053265751, -0.0753808692, 0.0011365837, 0.0144024538, -0.0008138942, -0.0397706255, -0.0017509806, 0.0063398909, -0.0115192207, -0.041251637, 0.0537983254, 0.0004223416, 0.0307256915, 0.0160088763, -0.0608913898, -0.0399612188, -0.0208141562, -0.016495008, -0.0062358812, 0.0324321985, 0.0134567358, -0.048695121, -0.0011848757, 0.0550736301, -0.0206985492, 0.0046196347, 0.023327345, -0.0039956686, -0.0248442013, 0.0148604186, 0.0427809879, 0.0036411346, 0.0390334837, 0.0222317595, 0.0187406167, -0.0204331726, -0.0110700056, -0.031846527, -0.0464460887, 0.0417756364, -0.0259118881, -0.0104966853, -0.0178822558, 0.0180364735, 0.0294243228, 0.0112908129, -0.0410771109, -0.0589329153, -0.0292750858, 0.0425211117, -0.0090811402, 0.0018525429, -0.029121181, -0.0716526136, -0.0040876358, 0.0099603748, 0.0404379815, -0.0011021185, 0.0375270583, -0.0490337834, -0.0356869549, -0.0326097533, 0.0517940633, 0.0247117206, 0.0328397751, -0.0138992602, -0.0248222519, 0.0050254674, 0.0044148322, 0.053171441, -0.0534602962, -0.0134073086, 0.0464131236, 0.0461288504, 0.0013630603, -0.0209628623, -0.0040042032, -0.078462705, -0.0258422773, -0.0129299024, 0.0269470122, -0.050202772, 0.0266409405, 0.0080172336, -0.0153857404, -0.0117837386, 0.0071263309, -0.0216122121, -0.0179733839, 0.0539753847, 0.0663479343, -0.0058332877, -0.0105262706, 0.0367503762, 0.0059915073, 0.0520143807, 0.0219353791, -0.0062669516, -0.0264995433, -0.0331876427, -0.0155143179, -0.0502992868, -0.0408611484, -0.0006334304, -0.0081059737, -0.0108577395, -0.0137919178, 0.078671962, 0.0452531427, -0.0302090999, 0.0008095333, -0.0082239071, 0.0084027136, 0.033753816, 0.0004192517, -0.0626708716, -0.0380091593, -0.0024042754, 0.0305590648, 0.021249989, -0.0508257709, 0.0097690523, -0.1211753711, 0.0168487038, 0.0292538349, 0.0599620305, -0.0575510487, -0.0859216899, -0.0143956272, 0.0186031945, -0.0453367196, -0.0290265623, -0.0214000307, -0.0165590309, 0.0093278103, -0.0677641258, -0.0334305428, 0.0146771045, -0.0287948139, 0.0014643357, -0.0150325112, 0.0852049142, -0.0178312641, -0.032381054, 0.0216552783, -0.023595104, -0.0313766934, -0.0399397723, 0.0497992299, -0.0240252428, 0.0047478788, -0.0224736147, -0.0130411079, -0.0316987373, -0.0254113097, -0.0060087326, 0.1313455403, -0.0249934364, -0.0339456536, -0.0181340277, -0.016772924, 0.0357905701, 0.0481705889, 0.0271585695, -0.0226133987, -0.0290421844, -0.0061257295, 0.041596245, 0.0146128004, -0.0478770547, 0.0024170331, -0.0244571809, 0.0166560318, -0.0779235661, -0.0377579182, 0.0118794991, 0.0567556731, 0.0069419886, 0.0543439128, 0.0175866298, -0.0360198356, -0.0684246123, -0.0421054475, -0.0215342119, 0.046376545, -0.0336454399, -0.0113862455, 0.0155999381, 0.0297887381, -0.0143162347, 0.0240158346, -0.0062555009, -0.0743996054, -0.0322476327, -0.0217381511, -0.0046563316, 0.0436686985, -0.0397151895, 0.0146654481, 0.0654462725, -0.0066670189, -0.009024268, -0.0232440978, 0.0139397569, -0.0041414048, -0.019209113, 0.0267042015, -0.029228786, -0.0224209856, -0.044601392, 0.0878163278, -0.017390931, -0.0740999505, -0.002401877, 0.009574255, 0.0481425039, -0.0103488863, 0.0380761251, -0.0463564284, -0.0153565509, -0.0184242204, -0.0019731487, -0.0030666944, 0.0079985205, 0.0227196794, -0.0423546322, -0.0396756232, 0.0005924724, -0.0261398423, 0.0009615808, 0.0089213746, 0.0350028314, 0.0219672341, -0.0143629741, 0.0038815211, 0.0009384976, 0.0026812581, -0.0106164915, 0.0031114165, -0.0080358936, -0.0260203518, 0.0226386841, -0.0025867338, 0.0032257501, -0.0245540682, 0.0038481026, -0.0363064781, 0.0087484308, 0.0082685323, 0.0274004713, 0.0503328815, -0.0332451351, 0.0406956114, -0.0302391835, -0.0248517282, -0.0095039774, 0.0576080829, -0.0243325271, -0.0504039787, 0.037150979, 0.0163097363, -0.0391511321, 0.0430815555, 0.059291698, 0.0130866729, 0.0128745669, 0.0019167294, -0.0610131659, -0.0309232697, 0.0108460616, 0.067729041, 0.0476994179, -0.0203294605, 0.024670206, -0.0405758321, -0.0681689829, 0.0347545706, -0.02489057, -0.0200365521, 0.0118940063, 0.0540954806, 0.0267172102, 0.0421425588, 0.0319562592, -0.0823733807, 0.0440058485, 0.0000717149, -0.043093957, 0.0179345794, -6.256926473e-33, 0.0039429879, -0.0231498629, -0.0169702154, 0.0491686389, -0.0381710269, 0.015670605, -0.0311845969, 0.0133286873, -0.0453161635, 0.0415459201, -0.0274353921, 0.010997666, 0.0051391893, 0.0071902224, 0.0115784053, 0.0181969032, 0.0132643599, 0.0127826305, 0.0089060627, 0.0083180908, 0.0744626224, 0.0550149903, 0.0546298474, -0.0719348937, -0.0031168375, -0.0079942662, 0.049443692, -0.0186151974, 0.0778938234, 0.0099981306, -0.0239098594, 0.0502244756, 0.0300294049, -0.0049949721, 0.0176493526, 0.0441563167, -0.0645558164, -0.0559088066, -0.0329242982, 0.0010467533, -0.0477301963, 0.0197204426, 0.0058052, -0.0049938909, 0.0256557409, 0.0198224001, 0.0546892546, 0.015184503, -0.0775482282, 0.0056385989, -0.0730321631, 0.067770198, -0.0075381361, -0.0021567494, 0.003598213, -0.0467803329, 0.0220805686, -0.0354299396, -0.0470290184, 0.0025436098, -0.06243724, -0.0076179048, -0.0395491458, -0.0076236404, 0.0089461869, 0.0628505722, -0.0424928814, -0.0388771184, 0.0421229564, 0.0430562645, 0.0028796161, 0.0239557121, -0.0125201503, 0.0403260849, 0.03617654, -0.0501611307, -0.0494158566, 0.0149598848, 0.0304628983, 0.0551213287, 0.0127461702, 0.0077041448, -0.0738334209, -0.0339453854, 0.0134733291, 0.0080783237, -0.0096143652, -0.0630353615, 0.0029905443, 0.0252834316, -0.0327392444, -0.0004300323, 0.0084655359, -0.0203018785, -0.0839594081, 0.0727353096, -0.0056021125, -0.0094427392, -0.0335607603, 0.0190671347, -0.0282706767, -0.0738246217, -0.0461271554, -0.0123506496, 0.0045559458, -0.0326824114, 0.0309098586, 0.017614115, -0.0606572591, -0.0127045261, 0.007337722, -0.0582828186, -0.0272006691, -0.0209469981, 0.0317241512, 0.0173314568, 0.0016409517, 0.0494598337, 0.0414894521, 0.0443022847, 0.0088736461, -0.0400026999, 0.0147521766, 0.0110156089, -0.0157444328, 0.0132226041, -0.0406346843, 0.0803278983, 0.0308294781, -0.0667833686, -0.0104501685, -0.0106915692, 2.743e-7, 0.0552092977, 0.0471441112, 0.0149265267, 0.0059340219, -0.0153912595, 0.013572365, 0.0049199541, 0.0481963381, -0.0598007366, -0.0015673944, 0.0299086068, 0.0233095251, -0.0058008162, 0.0100270445, -0.0687919781, 0.0665283799, -0.0680152774, 0.0175973494, -0.0409712419, -0.0134622231, 0.0352843106, 0.10562253, 0.0385882482, 0.0039875973, -0.0324769616, -0.0657568574, 0.0489835031, 0.0111553008, -0.0304595064, -0.0415685065, -0.0185770988, 0.0472709946, 0.0031579665, -0.0170884859, -0.0541170016, 0.0628749281, 0.0681404173, -0.0040086196, -0.0217452031, 0.0525704324, 0.0062603662, -0.0480843782, -0.0180772766, 0.0232201554, 0.079944931, -0.0152667947, -0.0571258925, -0.0675772429, 0.0025469265, 0.0031533842, 0.06719096, -0.0107536046, -0.0247429255, -0.0021813239, 0.0280557591, -0.0182276554, 0.0174366832, -0.0729657859, 0.037335936, 0.0119417589, 0.002900593, 0.0310024563, -0.0078653917, 0.0326559581, 0.0298453122, 0.0316535942, 0.0229444895, 2.242917379e-34, 0.0304315221, 0.0035701436, 0.0147406701, -0.0360798761, 0.0133636715, -0.0168476645, 0.0110695697, 0.0065858508, 0.0248177517, -0.0726078749, -0.025903279 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.04283v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.04283v2
MGeo: Multi-Modal Geographic Pre-Training Method
2023-01-11T03:05:12
2023-05-24T04:20:27
Ruixue Ding, Boli Chen, Pengjun Xie, Fei Huang, Xin Li, Qiang Zhang, Yao Xu
cs.CL
cs.CL
As a core task in location-based services (LBS) (e.g., navigation maps), query and point of interest (POI) matching connects users' intent with real-world geographic information. Recently, pre-trained models (PTMs) have made advancements in many natural language processing (NLP) tasks. Generic text-based PTMs do not have enough geographic knowledge for query-POI matching. To overcome this limitation, related literature attempts to employ domain-adaptive pre-training based on geo-related corpus. However, a query generally contains mentions of multiple geographic objects, such as nearby roads and regions of interest (ROIs). The geographic context (GC), i.e., these diverse geographic objects and their relationships, is therefore pivotal to retrieving the most relevant POI. Single-modal PTMs can barely make use of the important GC and therefore have limited performance. In this work, we propose a novel query-POI matching method Multi-modal Geographic language model (MGeo), which comprises a geographic encoder and a multi-modal interaction module. MGeo represents GC as a new modality and is able to fully extract multi-modal correlations for accurate query-POI matching. Besides, there is no publicly available benchmark for this topic. In order to facilitate further research, we build a new open-source large-scale benchmark Geographic TExtual Similarity (GeoTES). The POIs come from an open-source geographic information system (GIS). The queries are manually generated by annotators to prevent privacy issues. Compared with several strong baselines, the extensive experiment results and detailed ablation analyses on GeoTES demonstrate that our proposed multi-modal pre-training method can significantly improve the query-POI matching capability of generic PTMs, even when the queries' GC is not provided. Our code and dataset are publicly available at https://github.com/PhantomGrapes/MGeo.
[ 0.0423336662, 0.0360089578, 0.0042362167, -0.0011694157, -0.0275592115, 0.0128219379, 0.0115810102, -0.0307819527, 0.0404613316, -0.0695428625, -0.0508950502, -0.0081680287, 0.0090358565, 0.0000555212, 0.0256258119, -0.057959117, 0.0482564308, -0.0150815928, -0.0177045725, 0.0171544123, -0.0031921526, 0.0567315668, -0.0123637561, 0.0361567363, 0.0150081879, 0.0225769021, -0.0028196194, 0.0240351632, 0.0044608726, -0.0687443465, 0.0181114357, 0.0134656681, 0.0333216675, -0.0345631763, 0.0000019531, -0.0199230257, -0.0404451974, 0.0371598005, 0.0675425157, -0.0094492063, 0.029144343, 0.0250845011, 0.0589966178, 0.0188183505, -0.0088097807, -0.0225784704, 0.0493360311, 0.0351321436, 0.0503509827, 0.0496626608, -0.0309489518, -0.0424523279, -0.010397302, 0.0084688151, -0.0092109693, 0.0130120916, 0.0080432734, -0.0079240333, 0.0165208057, 0.0378094055, -0.0041250484, -0.0104915397, -0.0404802337, 0.0560695268, -0.0365479402, 0.0287165493, -0.0291071683, 0.0468798243, -0.0014415247, 0.0586733073, -0.0032364328, -0.0350901559, 0.0377350971, 0.0350969695, -0.0365157761, 0.022581134, -0.0332831219, -0.0693586245, 0.0196746606, 0.0679014102, -0.0336904489, 0.0475688949, 0.0203710776, 0.037690632, 0.0030063221, 0.0645710379, 0.0214541722, -0.0575355217, -0.0577231869, 0.0336377546, -0.0173816066, -0.0426573195, 0.0069243605, 0.0052166586, 0.0025245538, -0.0122172246, -0.026902426, 0.0435042158, 0.0141413994, -0.0439136922, 0.001374574, 0.0194895491, -0.0493205115, 0.0518685281, 0.0067519499, 0.0372736901, 0.0009065804, 0.0598468967, -0.0273837298, -0.0575897656, -0.0493309684, 0.0292600878, -0.0326001719, 0.0355684794, -0.018718943, 0.0184314959, 0.0002775371, -0.0025181081, -0.0136476951, -0.0185776334, -0.0466097444, 0.0285533872, 0.0010576224, -0.0565373972, -0.0149364583, 0.0199599266, -0.0096601266, 0.0213514529, -0.0535340831, 0.0021554946, 0.0141201215, 0.0371781737, 0.0663147643, -0.0039959685, -0.020206878, 0.0103389388, 0.0181079451, -0.0453819968, -0.0570049658, -0.0094272383, 0.0119049801, 0.0135974018, -0.0138444277, -0.0569430701, 0.0259637646, 0.0023616625, -0.0249883682, -0.0260428786, -0.019629769, 0.0251881965, -0.0553735979, 0.037333753, 0.0127990367, 0.0309339203, 0.0373350568, -0.0134672476, 0.0640540868, 0.0679048821, -0.0043980465, 0.0473407917, 0.0588068999, 0.0293185636, -0.0192567725, 0.025326049, 0.0120183127, 0.0383954011, 0.0080507947, 0.0415380932, -0.0270845722, 0.030648211, 0.0307429601, 0.0466763861, -0.0377407968, 0.0322790705, 0.0515571535, 0.0578022972, 0.0123795532, -0.0011911702, 0.0436048582, 0.0640816763, -0.0649157986, -0.0303948838, -0.0612491034, -0.0487054214, -0.062650606, 0.0096788863, 0.0658916458, 0.0604114719, -0.0518958569, 0.030153919, 0.0081066256, -0.0190657303, 0.0110322004, 0.0303657837, 0.0575762466, -0.0511820503, -0.0162696298, 0.0573340468, 0.0287479665, -0.0054123248, 0.0512000024, 0.0119853001, -0.0197753031, 0.0064794845, 0.0324103944, 0.0206268914, 0.0035727827, -0.0141151138, 0.0121926228, -0.0069111665, 0.0493567549, 0.0055684894, 0.0106602116, -0.0651157051, -0.0813663751, 0.0388235971, 0.0039553382, -0.02810614, 0.0644205287, 0.0531804822, 0.0563814342, -0.0881875381, 0.0563911535, 0.004939069, 0.0384861119, -0.0124682914, -0.0306125078, 0.0412485562, -0.0194469392, 0.0041221143, -0.0003516708, 0.0126212053, 0.0233212747, -0.0096067488, 0.0348159932, 0.0545224622, -0.0398336686, -0.0062686568, 0.0261793733, -0.0128136259, 0.0228831507, 0.0392893627, -0.0152362706, -0.031300012, -0.0344265811, -0.0082406383, 0.0629094914, -0.0203387849, 0.026586825, -0.0028301363, 0.0110041322, -0.0502960496, 0.0229844283, -0.0038372325, 0.0179806072, 0.010107466, 0.0188171361, 0.0560091361, 0.0327864066, -0.0225494653, -0.0503917672, -0.0078631015, 0.0084748995, -0.004841839, -0.0094607137, -0.0243235286, -0.0323935896, -0.1357634366, 0.0013584709, -0.0042976579, 0.0292651225, 0.0263773203, 0.0115843723, -0.0371935517, -0.0454653837, -0.0386294574, -0.0193229467, 0.0198876839, 0.0244872626, 0.0068484894, -0.0528531671, 0.0183262359, -0.0060700444, 0.0089460947, -0.0204433296, 0.0408986956, -0.0300085507, -0.0265969653, -0.0298528466, 0.0078802556, -0.0369968824, 0.036581479, 0.0112201516, -0.014786059, -0.0057755033, -0.0162424352, 0.0167468209, -0.0393234864, 0.0207101721, -0.0773367882, 0.0173473153, -0.0639182404, -0.086620003, -0.0032608323, -0.0611963272, 0.0123988464, -0.0417552516, -0.0307090655, 0.0353997685, 0.0062644966, -0.0014319238, -0.0025223289, -0.0091813914, -0.0406949632, -0.0086483434, -0.0062463931, -0.0436973087, 0.0269345418, 0.0257423539, 0.0399266705, -0.0368965529, -0.0373950191, 0.0353356451, -0.0607378483, 0.0064158645, -0.0441322252, 0.0244901516, -0.0357379727, 0.0817858204, -0.0115552358, 0.0280193817, 0.0237015244, -0.0331532955, 0.0356243402, -0.0223330092, -0.0193176791, 0.0112341372, 0.0144888228, -0.0205739122, 0.0154427225, 0.0126895625, -0.0696595982, -0.0121579012, -0.0623201653, -0.0195513666, -0.0054972512, 0.0013117854, -0.0385703705, 0.0117908344, 0.0741652995, -0.008813208, 0.0544854924, -0.0208173543, -0.0153714838, -0.016293399, 0.0174282603, 0.0841221511, 0.0819084123, -0.0621083863, 0.0640845448, -0.0950194821, -0.0007186369, 0.004698846, -0.0285093356, 0.0121596511, 0.0244385973, 0.0696205795, -0.0302567445, -0.0223997645, 0.0299425181, 0.0539771728, 0.0150015345, -0.0634660572, 0.0792867914, 0.0444980115, -0.0721775368, -0.0166232381, -0.020742977, 0.0352823474, 0.0055644428, 0.0573410541, -0.0446819775, -0.0239861496, -0.0041021546, -0.0122458041, 0.0107798632, -0.0203023124, -0.0207619257, -0.1094532907, 0.0245320275, -0.0199439824, -0.0140144425, -0.0405404717, -0.0550939776, -0.0204272699, 0.014846622, -0.0430551209, -0.0548562445, -0.0069693634, -0.0019117109, 0.0346087031, -0.0445695631, -0.0519687198, -0.0167076103, -0.0885115638, 0.0070393281, 0.0231807977, 0.0559060834, 0.0185341723, -0.0442302898, -0.0276079066, 0.0471860133, 0.0249996725, -0.0223164093, 0.0252530519, -0.0409139097, -0.0001242216, -0.0055082007, -0.0207900405, -0.0377067961, -0.0337448791, -0.0124949683, 0.0434680395, -0.0394202508, 0.0943062976, -0.0371952914, 0.039823126, 0.0245609116, 0.0232015643, -0.0114988862, 0.0066697528, -0.0160873234, -0.0294028129, 0.0212667417, -0.0260194205, -0.0039315103, 0.0110774124, -0.0004099219, 0.0014642192, -0.0511477217, -0.0359365493, -0.0244765487, 0.0212012585, 0.0102010677, 0.0122964671, 0.0335795246, -0.0465402976, -0.0373349302, 0.0540438667, -0.0630397573, -0.003189574, -0.0325190388, 0.0384405181, 0.0321172923, -0.040456634, -0.026521001, -0.0111578945, -0.0765042454, -0.0518950261, -0.0226244703, 0.0325885862, -0.0007024873, 0.0275793523, -0.0758035854, -0.0332823284, 0.0043430482, 0.0014174833, -0.0162845943, -0.0215357151, -0.0197523944, 0.0148550067, 0.0204443485, -0.0043179244, -0.0262240972, 0.0128280073, 0.0114910547, -0.0078880973, -0.0303897467, -0.0336953327, 0.0082164546, 0.0094513027, 0.1236696094, -0.0094360383, 0.0339322984, -0.0570512973, -0.0186066758, -0.0125419823, 0.0205862671, -0.0156699121, 0.0131882383, 0.0301147159, 0.0159261357, -0.0025930747, 0.0291342773, -0.0091987094, -0.0296537858, -0.0395172611, -0.0229705907, -0.0004754419, 0.0085931467, -0.0285046864, 0.0264976565, -0.0314284191, -0.0013079885, -0.0231218953, 0.0298945569, -0.0876956433, 0.0191534963, 0.006611763, 0.0043456606, -0.0489457883, 0.0552935041, -0.0289222673, -0.0234372076, -0.036255043, -0.0300364476, 0.0778787136, -0.0506438166, 0.0145828864, 0.020336749, 0.0128221493, 0.0150975492, 0.0331475027, -0.0072417618, -0.0258159973, 0.016294362, -0.0203331001, -0.0172833391, 0.0478054583, 0.055561766, -0.0025066461, 0.0351348221, 0.0098818289, -0.0553583093, -0.0121832248, 0.0021790178, 0.0370455459, 0.0506426506, -0.0409045219, -0.0192804039, 0.0050051101, -0.0051799743, 0.0253883824, -0.0364587232, -0.0303088576, 0.0090566101, 0.0668843165, 0.0478237607, -0.0218296479, -0.0289754253, -0.050729122, -0.0310752373, -0.0325152352, -0.018460637, -0.0309119895, -6.063280677e-33, -0.0078495797, -0.0279542208, 0.0658078864, -0.0502282679, -0.0289455168, -0.0000262606, 0.0086995782, -0.034657903, -0.0476370156, -0.0401691683, -0.0140111391, -0.0335973203, 0.0187384207, 0.0398992747, -0.0090100551, 0.0014225554, 0.0397696607, 0.0315413922, 0.0146781122, 0.0035711464, 0.0510934703, 0.0186857525, 0.0423113219, -0.1113948226, -0.0006231835, -0.0219323114, -0.0415919498, 0.0243918374, 0.0392601714, 0.05858225, -0.0172427185, 0.0185734443, 0.0291020554, 0.0218728613, -0.0210421495, 0.0029896954, -0.0256235618, -0.0195140559, -0.0004782109, -0.0000345776, 0.0238974188, 0.0120451925, 0.0254644286, -0.0087266201, 0.0175261963, 0.0304398797, 0.0401075296, 0.0212479364, -0.070578374, 0.014822959, -0.0412304662, 0.025100844, 0.019400917, -0.0120925829, 0.033475671, 0.0587041229, 0.0262615606, 0.0443464257, -0.0174393225, 0.0458314829, 0.0185596533, 0.0459878631, 0.0185689498, 0.0037973137, 0.0237644818, 0.0790791586, -0.0233473796, -0.0334654823, -0.0309643913, 0.0143961571, 0.063127555, 0.0202254616, -0.0344797559, 0.0680901334, -0.0094201444, -0.0266588833, -0.0393382385, 0.0614811443, -0.0460938253, -0.0175161064, -0.0198441856, 0.0023454092, -0.053378623, -0.0412925743, -0.0366247296, -0.0357867926, -0.0188399628, -0.0370687619, 0.0560150482, 0.0369497091, 0.0229688957, 0.0944405943, 0.030855244, -0.0154022528, -0.036344029, 0.0005150263, 0.0214742813, 0.0009746206, -0.0302750506, 0.0302738529, -0.0706917346, -0.0712314025, -0.0208364837, -0.0257923231, -0.0193939451, 0.0214767568, 0.0009966909, 0.0251104012, -0.0567593724, 0.0066474318, -0.007203524, -0.0663713887, -0.0420364179, 0.0014367686, 0.0280273445, -0.0121036414, 0.0102614025, 0.0521312281, 0.0502704158, 0.0244287532, -0.0055147237, -0.0634657666, 0.0047833989, 0.066211924, 0.0428681672, 0.0183537398, -0.0223463606, -0.0223225448, 0.019247232, -0.0088383583, -0.0123638287, 0.009794184, 2.679e-7, 0.0295304023, 0.0508319139, -0.0066457507, -0.0227005854, -0.0333602428, 0.0331502222, 0.048461467, 0.0256643575, -0.0024535514, 0.0757260621, 0.0350162275, -0.0093570128, 0.0096215112, 0.0412117429, -0.1015736535, 0.0585069694, -0.0468357243, -0.0110856546, -0.0683246478, 0.0125015881, 0.0487043411, 0.0605208203, 0.0256766379, -0.0028925198, -0.0072292462, -0.0372110866, 0.0292143896, -0.0590190291, -0.0473261662, 0.0240526795, 0.0196668282, 0.0087080412, 0.0193230845, -0.0340398885, -0.0432672463, 0.0137686757, 0.0322740898, 0.041863054, -0.0287586506, -0.0434259512, -0.0154898893, -0.0425253063, -0.0446514152, -0.0836160406, 0.05787028, -0.0147661157, 0.0067587374, -0.0026686296, 0.0024354465, 0.0379654281, -0.0005117375, 0.0032865342, -0.030556526, -0.0361772142, 0.0498971678, 0.008365823, -0.0201653298, -0.0809470639, 0.0031347487, -0.0028317666, 0.0023275726, 0.027203951, -0.0364603847, -0.0027855625, 0.0276450105, -0.008033176, 0.0071302401, 2.184300618e-34, -0.0295461398, 0.0053484049, -0.0093633495, 0.0007290565, 0.067536898, -0.0016400815, -0.0054501696, 0.0158397257, -0.0176037326, -0.0283337347, 0.0001149332 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.04253v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.04253v2
Towards Answering Climate Questionnaires from Unstructured Climate Reports
2023-01-11T00:22:56
2023-07-27T18:13:40
Daniel Spokoyny, Tanmay Laud, Tom Corringham, Taylor Berg-Kirkpatrick
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG
The topic of Climate Change (CC) has received limited attention in NLP despite its urgency. Activists and policymakers need NLP tools to effectively process the vast and rapidly growing unstructured textual climate reports into structured form. To tackle this challenge we introduce two new large-scale climate questionnaire datasets and use their existing structure to train self-supervised models. We conduct experiments to show that these models can learn to generalize to climate disclosures of different organizations types than seen during training. We then use these models to help align texts from unstructured climate documents to the semi-structured questionnaires in a human pilot study. Finally, to support further NLP research in the climate domain we introduce a benchmark of existing climate text classification datasets to better evaluate and compare existing models.
[ 0.0201282352, 0.0855278671, 0.0315146819, 0.0243025292, -0.0248369705, 0.0139152715, 0.0223123208, 0.0082302187, 0.0467249714, -0.0664520487, 0.0121526858, 0.0206829533, -0.0200163666, 0.0437183827, -0.0213394575, -0.0556654222, 0.0357016921, 0.0020544359, 0.0140602337, -0.0102324141, 0.0298146587, 0.0113748861, 0.0075652893, 0.0070546749, 0.0080417069, -0.035066966, -0.019791374, 0.0185347646, 0.0326293372, -0.0299434513, 0.0363941193, 0.0487012342, 0.0355441533, 0.0257506743, 0.000001565, -0.0403385647, -0.0443876609, -0.0037138886, 0.0232332665, 0.0318604894, 0.0820466056, -0.0443010218, 0.0332343839, 0.0295590516, -0.0439790897, -0.0169251077, 0.0754065588, 0.0544775948, 0.0903899148, 0.0220814385, -0.0049640578, -0.0270962324, -0.0026132416, -0.0011602971, -0.0301843937, 0.0447033644, 0.0495399944, -0.0222003665, -0.0488911495, 0.0051925578, 0.026505027, 0.0377545841, -0.0028841584, 0.0059780832, 0.0160507131, 0.0198765751, -0.0724985525, -0.0169003997, -0.0247421153, 0.0661525503, 0.040315114, -0.0191533808, 0.0021183242, -0.0196490195, 0.0234058164, 0.0103553347, -0.0148419589, -0.0113117946, -0.0093123484, 0.0110030547, 0.0103402464, 0.0344401225, -0.0247684736, 0.0556570366, -0.0234157629, 0.0908302814, -0.0406447835, -0.0518939905, 0.0050952644, -0.0123447496, 0.0372489952, -0.0353422016, 0.0118390592, -0.0291377753, 0.0057906648, 0.0261143632, -0.0347005315, -0.0005566622, 0.0324066915, -0.0700276718, 0.0255679153, -0.0266148467, -0.006915133, 0.045264557, 0.0475060567, 0.0353976004, 0.0266838204, 0.0398006625, -0.0219107531, 0.0123176258, -0.0733226389, -0.0412284173, -0.0337372571, 0.0214057732, -0.0431108102, 0.0353113711, -0.0066550565, -0.0173724405, -0.0153151155, 0.013736506, 0.014971233, 0.0190861542, -0.0024568373, -0.0081385709, -0.0413996466, 0.060920801, -0.0341643095, 0.0217976086, 0.0189343169, -0.0132264271, 0.0101747587, 0.0011784285, 0.0294719543, -0.0093961656, 0.0037217035, 0.0391828194, 0.0163333435, -0.0041701193, -0.008453506, -0.0133028161, -0.0192494672, -0.0317423381, -0.0179718491, -0.0192430895, 0.0100381318, -0.0095415656, -0.0125800623, -0.0514019541, -0.0153065026, -0.0138152959, -0.0332787149, 0.0949321613, -0.0151588758, -0.0292275548, 0.0592926927, -0.0283646062, 0.0486267246, 0.0538752154, 0.0440120064, 0.0171106309, 0.0355027169, -0.0421125293, 0.0175675824, -0.0118135447, 0.0191209577, 0.0258966554, 0.0175969582, 0.0523377247, -0.0379742905, 0.0486922637, 0.0161671229, 0.0068790605, 0.0062666242, -0.0231744666, 0.0646326989, 0.0307548288, 0.0073936102, 0.0007430538, -0.0373161174, 0.0671694353, -0.0184739307, 0.0381047763, 0.0056043132, 0.0050033103, -0.0279796235, 0.0057424121, 0.0216084812, -0.013403235, -0.0387069061, -0.0696129501, -0.0598213896, 0.0398151204, 0.0038214179, -0.0093025845, 0.0066198697, -0.0076266825, -0.0388623402, 0.0106018707, 0.0046847309, -0.0675055385, -0.0013817998, -0.0008445221, 0.0174503997, 0.0075531402, -0.0303450841, -0.0228004307, -0.0000212438, -0.0567662306, 0.0167061854, 0.0124672754, 0.0823101029, -0.0018254895, -0.020018084, -0.013376887, -0.0420407876, -0.0263846926, -0.0076191807, 0.0025431453, -0.0105653852, -0.0179710351, 0.004125467, -0.0463492945, -0.0309327915, 0.054355789, 0.0015351, -0.0715493411, 0.0253383406, 0.0354619361, 0.0570760742, 0.0086353943, -0.0140338168, -0.0008576224, 0.0597547852, -0.0095204627, -0.0918405727, 0.02144791, -0.0025095674, -0.0041687763, 0.0219440386, -0.009057261, -0.0134090567, 0.0390814878, -0.0507977717, -0.0226574149, 0.0045659095, 0.0306499656, -0.0013145679, -0.0224090852, -0.0354344882, 0.0169152133, 0.0344125293, -0.044373773, 0.0566404611, 0.0146761844, 0.0249816906, -0.0505757928, -0.0322840735, 0.033038415, -0.0439302363, 0.0172502026, -0.024627313, -0.050873436, -0.0024033813, 0.0277913064, -0.0147979753, -0.0624335259, -0.0053280569, -0.0424091071, 0.0304865949, -0.0069151595, 0.0383223258, 0.0228497889, -0.0334246606, -0.0256791189, 0.0269614719, -0.0203628689, -0.0643973276, -0.006062997, 0.030839093, 0.0611438118, -0.0108484142, 0.0430819429, -0.0469997339, -0.0065398593, -0.0301514212, 0.0595817901, 0.0344003439, -0.0813432112, -0.0316713192, 0.0427600071, -0.0161615554, 0.0037600279, 0.0069526639, -0.0260546729, -0.0183977205, -0.0116101336, -0.0304169226, 0.0532624796, 0.0534468256, 0.0311231352, 0.0239143278, 0.0329048224, -0.0765182376, 0.032045342, -0.0148519985, 0.0170460008, 0.0213143993, -0.0038391198, 0.054269582, 0.0429985113, -0.0032107153, -0.0132756103, 0.0322474241, 0.0548989773, -0.036590036, -0.0188902691, -0.0375803933, -0.045907937, -0.0087547302, 0.044388853, -0.0105299698, -0.0721070319, 0.0414892212, -0.0285279043, 0.0095471675, -0.0961704701, -0.0209329389, -0.0156898852, 0.0887031481, -0.0044424497, 0.013441517, 0.0811793357, -0.0072185262, 0.0050304243, -0.0606770217, 0.0189554859, 0.0199704245, -0.016458299, -0.0437188968, 0.0610511862, -0.029116964, -0.049842041, -0.0303018168, -0.0533635579, -0.0014107733, 0.0131558217, -0.0005193035, -0.0243404061, -0.0953915343, 0.037555486, 0.0244983267, 0.0298204869, -0.0018372561, -0.0298340432, 0.0077288165, 0.0355565771, 0.0345542431, 0.0343519337, 0.024967866, 0.0079131657, -0.0111960843, 0.0171707403, 0.0276569854, 0.0402883254, -0.0259036664, -0.0290480629, -0.0058480548, -0.0587367751, 0.0253910534, -0.0257935319, 0.0195018165, -0.0471728519, 0.0046507404, 0.0848714337, 0.0321591534, -0.0005779064, -0.0013678621, 0.0150850583, 0.0166914072, 0.0321961865, 0.0175076183, -0.0655570328, 0.0078396555, -0.0049517797, -0.0087911198, -0.0125163654, -0.040642947, -0.0160897058, -0.0604201667, 0.0371476002, -0.0019744954, -0.0430754498, -0.0142012704, -0.0956918374, -0.0127054993, -0.0348947905, -0.0492487364, -0.0657486841, -0.0377036408, 0.0028768159, 0.0347293913, -0.1036579087, -0.0057551223, 0.0026146818, 0.0147495167, 0.0025842688, 0.0687890574, 0.0480692945, -0.0288618281, -0.0215642937, 0.0544173457, -0.0363218449, -0.0219779965, -0.0023967375, 0.043509528, 0.0124141052, -0.0098013636, 0.0166866165, 0.0654574335, -0.0552370362, 0.0296600144, 0.0330239125, 0.0356615894, 0.0050595677, -0.0107105896, -0.0102576073, 0.0295948908, 0.0213878863, 0.0696801692, -0.0120797064, -0.0086200628, -0.0615191273, -0.0713145509, 0.0098362919, -0.0477997661, -0.0359132178, 0.0200830847, -0.0379322954, 0.0172128156, -0.0412175804, -0.039487645, 0.0561150908, 0.0220623873, -0.0204774477, -0.0017383972, 0.0547778942, -0.0062971949, -0.0409667604, 0.0572536215, -0.0199925564, 0.0209287535, -0.0149304615, -0.0642847642, 0.0229800772, 0.0656526536, -0.0332959071, 0.0139751211, -0.0711796805, -0.0657858774, 0.0061254869, -0.006497859, 0.0170995034, 0.0004307728, 0.0230035279, -0.0074603418, 0.0462003201, 0.1020157933, -0.0638205111, -0.0213151779, 0.0148953907, 0.0315492824, -0.0085109081, -0.0056841965, 0.0087565603, 0.0178718772, -0.0115871066, 0.0339783393, -0.0496061929, -0.0023242671, 0.0354282595, 0.018947795, 0.0557717569, 0.0079683298, -0.0270650871, -0.0554047264, -0.0132483961, 0.0186549257, -0.0447968952, -0.0243396331, 0.0183900818, 0.0188488737, -0.003172288, -0.0496649295, 0.0876670629, -0.0640029311, 0.0343836062, -0.07012593, 0.0326018333, 0.054158248, 0.0401841663, -0.0194642767, -0.0014110546, -0.0328258127, -0.0391164348, 0.0399939157, -0.0042201886, 0.0482028835, -0.0180814434, -0.0001930843, 0.0800567791, -0.0290797967, 0.0014335859, -0.0617664121, -0.0261553358, -0.048616536, 0.0113957096, -0.0250579547, 0.0154449297, -0.0198172927, -0.0175838284, -0.0431597456, -0.0019782702, 0.0303903986, 0.0255223811, -0.0110974452, 0.0904143602, -0.0006653537, -0.0792470202, -0.0006761694, 0.0192823503, 0.0423345529, 0.0481531844, 0.0398778394, -0.03270467, -0.057949882, -0.0351996571, -0.0263650585, -0.0227061454, 0.0159606952, -0.0131422654, -0.0376272984, -0.0172570925, 0.0523381121, -0.0067752302, 0.0106119458, 0.0122739598, -0.0058314884, 0.0476042107, -0.0007909233, -0.0419415757, -0.0257388316, 0.0246784221, -0.0472151265, -0.0354651809, -0.0372671746, -5.653299839e-33, -0.0154194767, -0.0283817351, 0.0076912199, 0.0012512141, 0.0232475791, 0.0423161648, 0.0261772703, 0.0145406295, -0.0466114543, 0.0196987335, -0.0085770376, -0.0097280676, 0.0276571475, 0.0108730998, 0.0265516955, 0.014696083, 0.0529152602, -0.0336750112, -0.0125602167, -0.0297696982, 0.0455156676, 0.0120059401, 0.0558373034, -0.1224833503, 0.0369245708, 0.0047947946, -0.0401002392, -0.02338445, -0.0083294464, 0.0373439603, -0.022939153, 0.0576688573, 0.0364298709, -0.0303520747, -0.0223551281, 0.0624702014, -0.0898567587, -0.0101330904, -0.0120690176, -0.02300849, -0.032244835, 0.0104357814, 0.0210066829, 0.0238869395, 0.0129146418, -0.0269745439, 0.0632539466, -0.0078709098, -0.0392774567, -0.0650566593, -0.0335404761, 0.0257376824, -0.0362555571, 0.0473323949, -0.0466124564, 0.0682565644, -0.0138992919, 0.0708078295, -0.0803105906, -0.0080227805, 0.0495466515, 0.0301789008, 0.0293335058, -0.0110748559, 0.0131113296, 0.0565294065, 0.0001414731, 0.0394350961, -0.0350457206, -0.0219229534, 0.0204106588, -0.000657588, 0.0062014032, 0.089304626, 0.0540892184, -0.0264055654, -0.0653670132, 0.04696339, 0.0280652139, 0.0044388934, -0.0052706292, 0.0048164073, 0.0358374789, -0.0076293889, -0.0685357451, -0.0029212488, -0.0404540189, 0.0214995425, 0.0389794298, 0.0117431153, -0.003409117, 0.023408765, 0.0087918285, -0.0423178412, -0.0430854633, 0.0065603224, -0.0045401044, 0.0217361785, 0.0313046686, 0.0251022596, -0.0705860555, -0.0048755091, -0.0312789194, 0.0566515438, 0.014320557, -0.018207347, 0.0810203403, -0.0174261071, -0.0760781616, 0.0035933335, -0.0041691107, 0.0045444733, -0.0176882129, 0.0234664343, -0.0167047232, 0.0050949613, 0.0218601394, 0.0444598645, -0.0143256569, -0.00427905, 0.0093220612, -0.0098988945, -0.0413771532, 0.0322589539, 0.0065754266, -0.0090853656, -0.0250138063, 0.0023256706, 0.0228172168, -0.0215870589, 0.019717684, 0.0208907221, 2.193e-7, 0.0746819153, 0.025799118, -0.0011773752, -0.0477658175, -0.0067013851, 0.0355825387, 0.0137641681, 0.0480484068, -0.0389845259, 0.0073860176, -0.0179491192, -0.0534703508, 0.0400118493, 0.011137398, -0.0745801032, -0.0175921116, -0.0595504567, 0.0012403284, -0.0807826817, -0.000718569, 0.0480451174, 0.0579313785, 0.016306797, 0.0197131801, 0.0008460707, -0.0047290274, 0.0697347894, -0.0478388853, -0.0125630135, 0.0199844595, -0.0042502885, -0.0414041542, 0.0078332853, 0.0205776021, -0.0514197275, -0.0186078977, -0.0189664587, 0.046970956, 0.0397073254, -0.0669190139, 0.0076843724, 0.0043331627, 0.006865981, -0.0277457684, 0.0395044349, -0.0659385175, -0.0236236714, -0.015387346, -0.0391291194, 0.0359152704, 0.0279555749, -0.0070927343, 0.0058870981, 0.0438613929, -0.0004520305, -0.0383294113, -0.0122596985, -0.0449306406, 0.0037633018, -0.0043218471, -0.0114750499, 0.0278763026, -0.0014641258, 0.0111698713, 0.0574064292, -0.0043729865, 0.0078538619, 1.895465814e-34, 0.0113051375, 0.0104135778, -0.0417654403, -0.0553020015, 0.0433696546, 0.0046771802, 0.0170379411, 0.0203495976, -0.0118721193, -0.0650558472, 0.0231130775 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.04248v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.04248v1
Predicting Hateful Discussions on Reddit using Graph Transformer Networks and Communal Context
2023-01-10T23:47:13
2023-01-10T23:47:13
Liam Hebert, Lukasz Golab, Robin Cohen
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SI
We propose a system to predict harmful discussions on social media platforms. Our solution uses contextual deep language models and proposes the novel idea of integrating state-of-the-art Graph Transformer Networks to analyze all conversations that follow an initial post. This framework also supports adapting to future comments as the conversation unfolds. In addition, we study whether a community-specific analysis of hate speech leads to more effective detection of hateful discussions. We evaluate our approach on 333,487 Reddit discussions from various communities. We find that community-specific modeling improves performance two-fold and that models which capture wider-discussion context improve accuracy by 28\% (35\% for the most hateful content) compared to limited context models.
[ 0.0572906025, 0.0961510241, 0.0091069927, 0.0334621109, -0.0116302082, 0.0169507209, 0.0344514549, 0.003263779, -0.0031751187, -0.0388867892, -0.0116324434, -0.0228743404, 0.0004951134, 0.0392604619, -0.0219626222, -0.0221325457, -0.020881379, 0.0329268016, -0.0041282079, -0.0128446892, 0.0477717258, 0.0141461613, 0.0267595872, 0.0396534055, -0.057640478, 0.0029449908, 0.0418732166, 0.0282760169, 0.0137861744, -0.008117782, 0.0439778231, 0.0295583326, 0.0038773797, 0.0634908602, 0.00000175, -0.0072851027, 0.0090910047, -0.0206740219, -0.0061301608, -0.0438025966, 0.0812402368, -0.0703313202, 0.0106181093, 0.045922529, -0.0583581217, -0.0115475664, 0.0440890864, 0.0461664684, 0.0596477315, 0.0739217401, -0.0339908302, -0.065187186, 0.0263618939, -0.0024798801, -0.0094418414, -0.0165786929, 0.0231559295, -0.0028805863, -0.0350864194, -0.0002167257, -0.044911813, 0.0051123481, 0.0344488285, -0.0260119215, 0.0562887006, -0.0218125265, -0.0088582356, -0.0366208255, 0.0074282624, 0.0839119405, -0.0429773033, -0.0280370004, 0.0166574251, -0.0031879998, -0.0096097477, 0.0108958548, -0.0596719086, 0.0011283981, -0.0067127226, 0.0418419801, -0.0065986798, 0.0144343069, 0.0894585624, 0.0333554484, 0.0062174737, 0.0465997458, -0.0203779917, -0.0057146396, -0.0185109023, 0.0095591675, -0.02811631, 0.0174189564, 0.037312571, 0.0031928495, -0.0255337059, 0.0173951965, -0.0414986126, -0.0305080153, -0.0210757386, -0.0693988651, 0.0218430404, -0.016330678, 0.0100281918, 0.026774304, 0.0102596292, -0.0004436477, -0.0319314525, 0.0225076396, -0.0181525946, -0.0345607325, -0.0295389052, 0.0117239365, -0.0274588615, -0.0017645358, -0.002632662, -0.0196498968, -0.033728119, 0.0220854357, -0.0511977598, -0.0533671007, 0.0244991109, 0.0544036329, 0.0050454503, -0.0195128191, 0.0312238019, 0.0391959734, -0.020771211, 0.0114631467, -0.0074203834, -0.0329830833, 0.0087182904, 0.03015575, 0.0210046116, -0.0015288447, 0.0052052261, 0.0674831793, 0.0592193343, -0.0076732561, 0.0028683709, -0.0165774599, -0.0292881913, -0.005621288, 0.0224533211, -0.0723105744, 0.0323601812, 0.0005790374, -0.0288026407, -0.0490339249, 0.0143759884, 0.0167715643, -0.0540754199, 0.0694434047, 0.0123474114, -0.009223789, 0.0465332009, 0.0217019077, 0.0011796011, 0.0347478501, 0.0153216813, 0.0126121417, 0.0561913699, -0.0110753514, -0.0115461554, 0.0542793088, 0.0513132103, -0.0191697273, -0.0227017589, -0.0016143494, -0.0512306467, -0.0152794169, -0.016170064, 0.0562596619, -0.0121035874, -0.083571218, 0.0261184629, 0.0634668991, -0.0509223193, 0.0365181528, 0.0409228206, 0.0265849847, -0.0607430264, -0.0330339335, -0.0563347898, -0.0063417549, -0.0167363342, -0.0586223938, 0.0251383912, 0.0260890629, -0.0089220414, -0.0019473224, 0.0039538234, -0.0242608935, 0.07932733, -0.0465700552, 0.0194841642, 0.0218932852, -0.0302440301, 0.0360913202, 0.0431044511, -0.0145335309, -0.0099399742, -0.0090837749, -0.01424387, 0.0519191734, 0.0098839784, 0.0110659078, -0.0268081408, -0.0509248674, 0.0153143425, 0.0102851503, 0.0272664595, 0.0019502976, -0.0235213526, -0.0499987639, -0.0123197474, 0.032097064, 0.0058046468, 0.0023938678, 0.0412126966, 0.0090788808, 0.0199433975, 0.033902511, -0.0179742444, -0.0127770407, 0.0303545445, 0.033967983, 0.0222253334, 0.0027222028, 0.0382172465, 0.0104801208, -0.0003376535, -0.0329625942, 0.0158442464, -0.0153891239, -0.0627777055, 0.0032594961, -0.0665824488, -0.0260720104, 0.0129080676, -0.0750545934, 0.0017927221, 0.0713353381, -0.0038485515, 0.0027436886, 0.1014800519, -0.0541276634, 0.0220611468, 0.0479790978, -0.0448720269, -0.0386256613, 0.0404246636, 0.0000076123, 0.0409834161, -0.0343717746, -0.0099937962, 0.0311901066, -0.0244931225, 0.0068671689, 0.0241274741, -0.0241964739, -0.0389856659, -0.0186633766, 0.0149078127, 0.0398144759, -0.0201009605, -0.0209713783, 0.0110327564, -0.1122118533, -0.0132586425, -0.0321671329, -0.0094332909, 0.0468790755, 0.0239919592, 0.0203806181, 0.0106742391, -0.0405549482, 0.0172602497, 0.0417685509, 0.0171368867, 0.0142254094, -0.0487088375, -0.0018794973, -0.0463635251, -0.0632930249, 0.0005145716, 0.0908593982, 0.033203423, -0.0621609241, 0.0363278426, 0.0215196814, -0.0359745845, 0.0217243023, -0.0277642924, -0.023258714, 0.0084659178, -0.0025883322, 0.0031831758, 0.0384986848, 0.0473640747, 0.0815151483, -0.0200138092, 0.0207002815, -0.0375395454, -0.0350605734, -0.0595845245, 0.0107430406, -0.0435559899, -0.0283393785, -0.011373681, 0.0662753955, 0.0365942158, -0.0113434037, -0.0520746298, 0.0264129788, -0.0570774414, -0.0025622479, -0.0000663587, -0.0674934015, 0.026564138, -0.0370506719, -0.0500965528, -0.0517692976, 0.0586436763, 0.0280834083, 0.0191032626, 0.0395448692, -0.0414700061, -0.0305773839, 0.033042077, 0.0504054166, 0.0234116372, -0.0436661951, -0.0033514528, -0.0090620397, -0.0159642007, 0.0302871168, -0.0233963914, 0.0057463357, 0.0013987493, 0.0213501416, 0.01676796, -0.0365312733, -0.0374619216, -0.050251469, -0.0289858133, -0.0251745991, 0.0548782162, -0.029650256, -0.0030921965, -0.0000785492, -0.0192740299, -0.0125549352, 0.0046050306, -0.0139685553, 0.0339066535, 0.0135736652, 0.0217337832, -0.0216540359, 0.0143101532, -0.0067549534, -0.0200676695, 0.059099976, -0.0011569425, -0.0088195493, -0.0489552356, -0.0182482023, -0.0154472096, 0.0508713946, -0.019801937, -0.0491613001, 0.0370660871, -0.0192962941, -0.0045140865, 0.0949713141, 0.0022584747, -0.0456418917, -0.0064455322, 0.0045471694, -0.0052577741, 0.0162945632, -0.0297798682, -0.128211543, -0.0260758065, -0.0627237558, 0.0087672081, -0.0004635151, -0.0659447759, 0.0128974244, -0.0464037322, -0.010352347, 0.0035643314, -0.0132351611, -0.0358366407, -0.0128697855, 0.0236451607, -0.0303177796, 0.0181082729, -0.0560862869, 0.0160434637, -0.0121047636, 0.0069531137, -0.0788456574, 0.006959918, 0.013225046, -0.0278192051, 0.048887454, -0.0010792365, 0.0294492804, -0.014177232, 0.0071840473, 0.0607500225, 0.0320962518, -0.0195262842, -0.0253617465, 0.0588599332, 0.0101076355, -0.028256163, -0.0314024128, 0.0263518803, -0.0447251648, -0.0258525591, -0.0384076536, 0.0572627708, 0.0118830632, -0.060735371, -0.040811073, 0.0330062062, 0.006244848, 0.0390874669, 0.0293030962, -0.0450194664, 0.0018739996, -0.0633003041, 0.0007569335, -0.0489491932, -0.0709957331, -0.0325692706, 0.0087024868, -0.0027614546, -0.0423726961, -0.0138693769, 0.0010478894, -0.0120234871, 0.0029803424, -0.025231082, 0.041903235, -0.0415547527, -0.0526074171, 0.0198925473, -0.018297255, 0.0260686576, -0.0063631833, 0.0009874647, 0.0182252936, 0.0035765923, -0.021621488, 0.0330824703, -0.0987631008, -0.0524603911, 0.0194550492, 0.0281318482, 0.0175788887, 0.037941508, -0.0195822101, -0.0149726691, 0.0370365717, 0.036166545, -0.0021283883, -0.0209682304, 0.0370589346, -0.0034336692, 0.030168239, 0.0461754352, -0.0214979798, 0.0529048853, 0.0023422127, -0.0440388359, -0.0857583284, -0.054995168, -0.0493207127, -0.0275748465, 0.0545701124, 0.0523106009, -0.0118657472, -0.0457525216, -0.0340845399, -0.0116998497, -0.003478549, 0.0009154438, -0.0006487861, 0.0371050276, -0.0151584558, -0.0369877927, -0.0305559039, -0.0150626516, 0.0182467308, -0.0553616919, 0.0176699348, 0.0547910519, -0.0128120808, 0.0780470222, 0.0322664268, -0.0086369468, 0.036237292, 0.018455755, -0.0167235695, -0.0089432923, 0.01633217, -0.008844194, -0.0036045439, 0.0252207704, -0.0167903733, -0.0313801281, -0.0228970181, -0.0265703462, -0.0100869834, -0.0003009392, -0.0090569137, 0.0366210043, 0.0300726425, 0.0008779499, -0.0119919097, 0.0421628654, -0.0144485254, -0.056964308, -0.0046424055, 0.0190354846, -0.0164370313, 0.0466663092, 0.0508279875, -0.0168430414, 0.0181492213, 0.0477959812, -0.0462146103, -0.0218288861, 0.0172070768, 0.0095731337, 0.0305050947, 0.0224246364, 0.0298935212, -0.0125524411, -0.0664575845, 0.0084112231, -0.0504215509, 0.0319926441, 0.0234411228, 0.0116670989, 0.0452315882, 0.0071168323, 0.0517995656, -0.0045992564, 0.0510512739, -0.0071207322, -0.0684951022, -0.016653413, -5.857233415e-33, 0.0132057499, -0.0584366173, -0.057050813, 0.0371467806, -0.0362028256, -0.0000978684, 0.0001196169, 0.0222423822, -0.0216804333, 0.0315438323, 0.0299003404, 0.0460098721, -0.0180696081, 0.0408012122, -0.0146960886, -0.0550994202, 0.0182836913, 0.0036895098, 0.0271907803, 0.0351151191, 0.0530573316, 0.0175611675, 0.0197459087, -0.0610948056, 0.0213191379, -0.046758119, 0.0229679607, 0.016072765, 0.0466073044, 0.0474411473, 0.0044724243, 0.0858623534, 0.0558033362, -0.008597808, -0.0150246089, 0.0606296472, -0.0476699546, 0.007475405, -0.0022121759, -0.0015381878, -0.0171393026, -0.0040153638, 0.0826708153, 0.0081364848, 0.0138110528, -0.0604347102, 0.0405798443, 0.0248964112, 0.0147414692, -0.0335924514, -0.0570609309, 0.0245699957, -0.0558359921, -0.004259795, -0.0180172604, 0.0276733954, 0.0444333553, 0.0013125007, -0.051876355, 0.0111292712, -0.0774761066, -0.017596703, -0.006230568, 0.0004076649, 0.0009118792, 0.0485437736, -0.016773032, 0.0303424634, -0.0494357347, -0.0049629924, 0.0014971945, 0.067636326, 0.042560067, 0.041639708, -0.0011260778, -0.0719138011, -0.0973941833, -0.01070417, 0.0261576809, -0.0142471828, 0.0358698331, 0.0002670721, -0.0256113, -0.0280701071, 0.0171865895, -0.0544352978, -0.0234061498, -0.01471595, -0.0275408756, -0.0138915814, -0.0308054034, 0.0255454462, 0.0142656993, -0.0954251811, -0.0081346473, 0.1116288975, -0.01394023, -0.0008012283, 0.0130225262, 0.0466527827, -0.0385348164, 0.0088753728, -0.0119265914, -0.0006770597, 0.036935702, 0.0016745876, 0.0575994924, 0.02755595, -0.0471880212, -0.0197094064, -0.0442488343, 0.0373255983, -0.0625974759, 0.0605807379, 0.0211551841, 0.0666397214, -0.0338799134, 0.0078765843, 0.0210765544, 0.0417968258, 0.0023829706, 0.0305697192, -0.0009266468, 0.0024118237, -0.0452377461, -0.0335675664, -0.0120813902, 0.0395929702, 0.04782857, -0.0838156864, -0.0004370544, -0.0601904318, 2.432e-7, 0.0506492667, 0.0610668883, 0.0279397964, -0.0049624084, 0.0468158685, 0.0297567341, 0.0595110469, 0.0494930446, 0.0008916393, -0.0174640585, -0.0033283976, 0.0617909171, -0.027019402, 0.0628825501, -0.0258418787, -0.0365929157, -0.1081645265, -0.0087971725, -0.0158514958, 0.0061593656, 0.0024300243, 0.0856795534, 0.0514502078, -0.0547648445, -0.0154952975, -0.0043050726, 0.0501027256, -0.0554847382, -0.0172134135, -0.0172005147, 0.027150359, 0.0087623689, -0.0014255377, -0.0151397148, -0.0132362321, 0.014961727, 0.0281977262, 0.0152941812, 0.0010695765, -0.0304132402, 0.0247737281, -0.0306898635, 0.0068295877, -0.0261307471, 0.0355789289, -0.0536260419, -0.0114890952, -0.0873322189, -0.0147168087, -0.000453664, 0.0396047644, 0.0022045292, 0.0362927541, 0.0172257684, 0.0286101587, -0.021811191, 0.0036839438, -0.0757073015, 0.0026379982, 0.0144687174, -0.0464556515, -0.032100223, -0.0028321296, -0.0384023339, 0.0558967516, 0.0648696348, 0.0526896566, 1.429457495e-34, 0.0228854883, 0.0039381208, 0.0013327172, -0.0550100319, 0.0214657951, -0.0060982471, -0.0400924906, -0.0015811594, 0.0420496054, -0.0539151505, -0.002998061 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.04230v1
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.04230v1
User-Centered Security in Natural Language Processing
2023-01-10T22:34:19
2023-01-10T22:34:19
Chris Emmery
cs.CL
cs.CL, cs.CY
This dissertation proposes a framework of user-centered security in Natural Language Processing (NLP), and demonstrates how it can improve the accessibility of related research. Accordingly, it focuses on two security domains within NLP with great public interest. First, that of author profiling, which can be employed to compromise online privacy through invasive inferences. Without access and detailed insight into these models' predictions, there is no reasonable heuristic by which Internet users might defend themselves from such inferences. Secondly, that of cyberbullying detection, which by default presupposes a centralized implementation; i.e., content moderation across social platforms. As access to appropriate data is restricted, and the nature of the task rapidly evolves (both through lexical variation, and cultural shifts), the effectiveness of its classifiers is greatly diminished and thereby often misrepresented. Under the proposed framework, we predominantly investigate the use of adversarial attacks on language; i.e., changing a given input (generating adversarial samples) such that a given model does not function as intended. These attacks form a common thread between our user-centered security problems; they are highly relevant for privacy-preserving obfuscation methods against author profiling, and adversarial samples might also prove useful to assess the influence of lexical variation and augmentation on cyberbullying detection.
[ 0.0876542181, 0.0789001212, -0.0338173807, 0.0215788241, -0.0540115237, -0.0210839305, 0.0647466704, 0.0135980565, 0.0478158407, -0.0550327636, 0.0016697769, -0.0129695833, 0.0019601951, 0.0036443849, 0.0410008617, -0.0322964229, 0.0209568329, 0.0194003824, 0.025735734, -0.0199756343, 0.0219923221, 0.0160980504, -0.0011265322, 0.0178980697, 0.0131473122, -0.0147894938, 0.0474109948, -0.0324860811, 0.0213408247, 0.0147336079, 0.0008006045, 0.0376150012, -0.005419699, 0.0799750164, 0.0000017537, -0.0590121076, -0.0106792254, 0.0410212912, 0.0056240661, 0.0026774372, 0.0855623633, -0.0261032935, -0.0023071745, 0.0189258438, -0.0558376014, 0.0170277506, 0.0239832699, 0.0311151687, 0.0688394681, 0.1022172049, -0.027143687, -0.0381345972, 0.0123374863, -0.0157028791, -0.0188291259, -0.0147192618, 0.0300237872, -0.0708772168, -0.0251308884, 0.0316041745, 0.0217831507, 0.0622398108, 0.0060020592, 0.0163303092, 0.0167721175, -0.0140459072, -0.0312433075, -0.017105775, 0.024085246, 0.0313095748, 0.0118439728, -0.0254229121, 0.0250399299, 0.0324366428, 0.0349478722, 0.0494519398, -0.0017667675, 0.0297024287, -0.0640548691, -0.0272517335, -0.0001540131, -0.0073739835, 0.0666044801, 0.0670062676, 0.0202881787, 0.035625238, 0.0013670393, -0.0075120591, -0.0249189213, -0.0530987941, 0.0085800746, -0.0152774379, 0.0656700432, -0.0076348502, 0.0056602932, 0.0038005104, -0.0907011554, -0.0649276376, 0.0038360278, -0.0504536778, -0.0050246143, 0.0000329602, 0.019071551, 0.0057587344, 0.0219843108, 0.0106065227, -0.0180713311, 0.0240033455, 0.0355226696, -0.0016072517, -0.0149859954, -0.0114674261, 0.0017385691, 0.0065098484, -0.006838629, 0.0258911904, -0.0529565439, 0.0261983871, -0.0366239063, 0.0097421957, -0.0354280435, 0.0090102367, -0.0246564243, 0.0171400346, 0.0113237752, -0.0428561941, -0.0062424946, -0.0002388648, -0.0346269719, -0.0470417179, -0.0003347505, -0.0100688767, -0.0171786901, -0.0169021077, -0.0093357451, 0.0924349949, 0.0520639606, -0.0471735522, -0.032688003, -0.084653087, -0.0275612418, -0.0083113834, -0.0024113613, -0.0341013186, -0.0081849173, -0.0017213566, -0.0254127439, -0.0964746624, -0.0184481628, -0.0000508102, -0.0448962152, 0.068178378, -0.0048479876, -0.0236488059, 0.0327724703, 0.0538994297, 0.0116956485, 0.0043789865, 0.0173471458, 0.0521110334, 0.0726273134, 0.0127675552, 0.0296757761, 0.0080651194, 0.0303401295, -0.0208059791, 0.0197403543, 0.0072420854, -0.0320970155, -0.0605160408, -0.0254725013, 0.0479511656, -0.0063352324, -0.0621088073, 0.0921157673, 0.0720332935, -0.0326546691, 0.041538123, 0.0043059499, 0.0179994609, 0.0058132624, -0.0109518049, -0.0567009337, -0.0289389361, -0.0881901383, -0.0807606801, 0.003409402, 0.0227554794, -0.0009991057, -0.0177447107, -0.0050057927, -0.014863614, 0.0850807428, 0.0044341506, -0.0112291565, 0.0551455952, 0.0113250362, 0.0032314372, -0.0095222779, -0.0171464831, 0.0197315719, -0.0434727781, -0.0276684146, 0.0397126935, 0.0343121141, -0.0015078965, 0.0687342063, -0.0578687936, -0.003053457, -0.0033453016, 0.0217107199, 0.0078349747, 0.0292206202, -0.0009090505, -0.0146865668, -0.0240016133, -0.0101845721, 0.0188302584, 0.0662638545, 0.0051931501, 0.0100433538, 0.0191008504, -0.0354460962, 0.002897355, -0.0025898886, -0.0554482862, -0.0170914624, 0.0195550229, 0.0250926148, 0.0370841846, -0.0087838881, -0.0011252591, 0.0213459525, 0.0140057355, -0.0337475315, -0.0459728353, 0.0203911047, 0.0142257623, 0.0082410378, -0.0336673968, -0.0064344658, 0.0233398378, -0.0129740406, 0.0307669323, 0.0898347497, -0.0194399003, 0.0021138734, -0.0035799139, -0.0257809274, -0.0327529944, 0.0432559401, -0.0442736894, 0.0675065517, -0.0411945097, 0.0160810556, -0.0178569537, -0.0131551009, 0.0127812847, -0.0047917292, -0.06635198, -0.0141243115, -0.0338190794, 0.0153590534, 0.0354090817, -0.0267003346, -0.0107977474, -0.0064101629, -0.0140509875, -0.0139751192, -0.0246295836, 0.0242923163, 0.0076600621, 0.0218134075, -0.0116967857, -0.0151935834, -0.0022029197, -0.0797026828, -0.0334129296, 0.0317354128, 0.0309137274, -0.0073871221, -0.0330832601, 0.0030981817, -0.0106746182, -0.0196218248, 0.0237628948, 0.0098998649, -0.0554621667, 0.0156723317, 0.017164439, -0.037528418, 0.0358395278, -0.0316312015, -0.0085621634, 0.0311267525, 0.0313869715, -0.0352700539, 0.0406081267, 0.0436754003, 0.0781252608, 0.0277162753, 0.0463452116, 0.0155072296, -0.023474304, 0.0100811077, -0.0101180021, -0.0245563202, -0.0225833599, 0.0408076048, 0.0051232027, 0.0741116628, -0.0433836915, -0.03780213, 0.0645364597, -0.055571083, -0.0481391177, 0.011957489, -0.0426553674, 0.0052486337, -0.0156071559, -0.0158856865, -0.0485234596, 0.0912984461, -0.0165704004, 0.0336603969, -0.0284623504, -0.0748178735, 0.0228822306, 0.053995207, 0.0208706539, 0.0502443723, 0.0400650539, -0.0265934709, -0.0066553932, -0.0172538348, 0.0683719665, -0.0265270155, -0.0146463132, 0.0054880786, -0.0021434946, 0.0282259118, -0.0470123142, -0.0497770496, -0.0912686586, -0.0337045565, 0.0010002586, 0.0249432158, -0.0621107407, -0.0182465333, -0.0402624756, 0.0385273322, -0.0282642543, 0.000217173, -0.0324789435, -0.0096422499, 0.000649986, -0.0225832798, -0.0616072565, -0.0090859635, 0.0211814456, -0.0159483217, 0.0758046135, 0.0085860472, -0.0009769759, 0.0258747004, -0.0159174688, 0.0010029587, -0.010973664, -0.0287693292, 0.0170890391, 0.0457335375, -0.0180441048, 0.0113538131, 0.0438359939, 0.0220066868, 0.0110591762, 0.0113005433, 0.0277309101, -0.0139856059, 0.0153072355, -0.0164791141, -0.0566562377, 0.0125766313, -0.0075825951, 0.0629358888, -0.0636834949, -0.0344412625, -0.0391138084, -0.0500174612, -0.0152951367, -0.0088321092, -0.0336729661, -0.0086784633, -0.0575214997, -0.0466625579, 0.0175746977, -0.0007621535, -0.0483999178, 0.008206144, 0.0125870556, -0.0003761921, -0.0359895825, -0.0240358785, -0.0249284934, -0.0537213832, 0.0331265591, 0.0349823944, 0.0517699495, -0.0314908363, -0.0091585973, -0.0158170555, 0.0219816994, -0.0084663825, -0.0247661863, 0.0822336525, -0.0018547975, -0.0104212919, -0.0281521399, 0.0619151704, 0.0241579339, -0.0243456475, -0.0082634306, -0.0054216078, -0.0074303644, -0.012393699, -0.0235926919, 0.01097445, 0.0240354426, 0.049476929, -0.0099462448, -0.0330653638, 0.0033781854, -0.0915337503, 0.0214416571, -0.0300042275, -0.065225862, 0.0043064994, -0.0126454318, -0.0485669822, -0.0389467329, 0.0058995523, -0.0222895592, 0.0043504057, 0.043505799, 0.0091088004, 0.0235308465, -0.0024559645, -0.0387016311, -0.0051358412, -0.0142046306, 0.0530225039, 0.004803048, -0.005249327, 0.0064932192, 0.0115871355, 0.0011132788, 0.0639132187, -0.0495196171, -0.0866841152, 0.0388857163, 0.0153209046, 0.0146229537, 0.0441873707, -0.063918516, -0.1075141355, 0.0728324279, 0.065237917, -0.0164210629, -0.0021080095, 0.0757459626, -0.015474814, 0.0101240752, 0.0180509854, -0.009642981, -0.0209881589, 0.0564269163, -0.0754751787, -0.0509892106, -0.0270744078, -0.027831357, 0.0290898159, 0.0441925265, 0.001810052, 0.0212206226, 0.0152779054, -0.0473103002, 0.0063942289, -0.0406905413, 0.0260711629, 0.0161824115, 0.0334259272, 0.0072212717, -0.0012412322, 0.0446871258, -0.0057658902, 0.0166284386, -0.0393480994, 0.0094218086, 0.0331841148, 0.0485361256, 0.0030376338, 0.0156063046, -0.0082878834, 0.064610526, 0.0104353903, 0.0250753127, 0.0016422283, 0.0012516668, -0.0072473022, 0.0228208918, -0.0247305017, -0.0023037985, -0.086626716, -0.0159096811, 0.0012334848, 0.0183053184, -0.0277054086, 0.0041120728, 0.0147460923, 0.0107823359, -0.0072723161, -0.0085408101, -0.0006985039, -0.0165137257, -0.034852121, -0.0089371102, -0.0022204095, -0.0308452267, 0.0500363223, 0.0424321182, 0.006842698, 0.0330152102, 0.0184114445, -0.0810542405, -0.020863561, -0.0298094265, 0.0217195936, 0.0590269528, -0.0002618706, -0.0116055626, -0.0500546917, -0.0653977692, 0.0162937902, -0.0057054269, 0.0424079634, -0.0120601673, -0.0197873097, 0.0444049686, 0.0155204665, -0.0065246643, -0.0931627303, 0.0441864356, 0.0264000632, -0.0760399699, 0.0209383816, -5.164026029e-33, 0.0310543515, -0.0429941304, -0.0483715199, 0.0088122291, 0.0361399651, -0.0035803863, 0.0234765746, 0.001518808, -0.0475598574, -0.0247611571, -0.022759404, 0.0288332403, -0.0228409693, 0.0143484632, -0.0505951755, -0.0215415303, 0.045547232, -0.0118926577, 0.00046737, 0.0099290796, 0.080443196, 0.0032631923, 0.0170698501, -0.1054598764, 0.1131822094, 0.0193051584, -0.049507957, -0.0095926737, -0.0071559665, 0.0366000496, -0.0033989048, 0.0449260287, -0.0077314791, 0.0133106075, 0.0013996033, 0.0291846525, -0.0597760268, -0.0215783771, 0.028532872, 0.0115213981, 0.0206601415, -0.0544903651, 0.0433326215, -0.0461594239, -0.0242767949, 0.011474682, 0.0208533406, 0.020472683, -0.0072938236, -0.0559468195, -0.0053508766, 0.0029678666, -0.0410029702, 0.0176283773, 0.000217221, 0.0354933701, 0.041242037, -0.0313718654, -0.0692891851, 0.0263493601, 0.0070624389, -0.0136578064, 0.0216362514, -0.0113597671, 0.0045780223, 0.0455289409, 0.028912032, 0.0161277018, -0.0010520656, 0.0026750399, 0.0158789512, 0.0221321024, 0.0173144322, 0.0948954001, 0.0137942415, -0.0647499785, -0.0480371974, -0.0045478484, 0.0319098048, -0.0157397594, 0.0472052023, -0.0045532039, -0.0804461464, -0.0477900393, -0.0324022099, -0.0870906711, -0.0371948667, -0.0093669947, -0.0261711646, -0.0026613132, -0.0645832494, -0.0181902591, -0.015878411, -0.0832556784, -0.0169233344, 0.0502418987, -0.0010639863, -0.0300717428, 0.0134468777, 0.0102057001, 0.0144296009, -0.0000039999, 0.0185918957, -0.0315522142, 0.0401936099, -0.0305329524, 0.0688721016, 0.0316622928, -0.0401465259, -0.0382678956, 0.0195808914, 0.0586824454, 0.0184470434, 0.0609565116, 0.0327493958, 0.0286559705, -0.0276276059, -0.0143782431, 0.0514375605, 0.0200412218, -0.0237870254, 0.0397864804, -0.0216206927, -0.024458101, 0.0312009491, -0.0275273249, 0.0030756653, 0.0464257747, 0.069539018, -0.0671252087, -0.0076451311, -0.0616953783, 2.706e-7, 0.0160609707, 0.0069588316, -0.0101603735, -0.0064601558, 0.0384404808, 0.0548841581, 0.072450757, 0.0767920017, -0.025290234, -0.013292212, -0.038087815, 0.0059138066, 0.0301584657, 0.0211569965, -0.0359238312, -0.0009341813, -0.0374383926, 0.0259986334, -0.0404390283, 0.0315310359, 0.0148455976, 0.0625960529, 0.0764697343, -0.018108001, -0.0473217256, -0.0729865208, -0.0111290989, -0.0104321325, -0.0174269211, -0.0158855803, 0.0635129288, 0.0669273436, 0.0392456055, -0.0146442056, -0.0301313605, 0.0141432425, -0.016241936, 0.0529359989, 0.0403500982, 0.0222128574, -0.003434666, -0.0452061668, -0.0016747559, -0.0135319363, 0.0658390447, 0.0293114707, -0.0438683182, -0.0355602056, 0.0160180721, -0.0498143584, 0.0471968576, -0.0314155556, -0.0185451545, 0.0142869055, 0.0143485479, -0.0055310517, -0.0065424894, -0.0731245056, -0.0171521958, 0.0018067803, 0.0117589515, -0.0125929331, 0.0281383768, 0.0328759216, 0.0446407646, 0.0122589124, 0.0439633504, 2.306986183e-34, 0.0008252981, 0.0133893713, -0.0116395624, -0.0511713959, 0.0321013071, 0.0277956724, 0.0012595311, -0.0102343941, 0.027636461, -0.0297814645, -0.0234962888 ]
http://arxiv.org/abs/2301.04213v2
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2301.04213v2
Does Localization Inform Editing? Surprising Differences in Causality-Based Localization vs. Knowledge Editing in Language Models
2023-01-10T21:26:08
2023-10-16T17:42:58
Peter Hase, Mohit Bansal, Been Kim, Asma Ghandeharioun
cs.LG
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
Language models learn a great quantity of factual information during pretraining, and recent work localizes this information to specific model weights like mid-layer MLP weights. In this paper, we find that we can change how a fact is stored in a model by editing weights that are in a different location than where existing methods suggest that the fact is stored. This is surprising because we would expect that localizing facts to specific model parameters would tell us where to manipulate knowledge in models, and this assumption has motivated past work on model editing methods. Specifically, we show that localization conclusions from representation denoising (also known as Causal Tracing) do not provide any insight into which model MLP layer would be best to edit in order to override an existing stored fact with a new one. This finding raises questions about how past work relies on Causal Tracing to select which model layers to edit. Next, we consider several variants of the editing problem, including erasing and amplifying facts. For one of our editing problems, editing performance does relate to localization results from representation denoising, but we find that which layer we edit is a far better predictor of performance. Our results suggest, counterintuitively, that better mechanistic understanding of how pretrained language models work may not always translate to insights about how to best change their behavior. Our code is available at https://github.com/google/belief-localization
[ 0.024144223, 0.0605409481, -0.0066410797, 0.0427215844, -0.0210626107, 0.0078966646, 0.0339413881, -0.0207439028, -0.0447103083, -0.0380282253, -0.0193796866, -0.0181341041, 0.026363967, 0.0025197642, 0.0449846834, -0.0497094989, 0.047206495, -0.0054776454, 0.0045256256, -0.0273311902, -0.0165221244, -0.0325930007, 0.0331019945, 0.0597048886, 0.003133927, -0.0011326195, -0.0162182935, 0.0165938679, 0.0023907821, 0.037407469, -0.0228655096, 0.0475615077, 0.0184899904, 0.0470260978, 0.0000019763, -0.0168628786, -0.0282817557, 0.0085951518, -0.0514733382, 0.0476158634, -0.0202735849, -0.0183650199, -0.0200261325, -0.0090839146, -0.0071246261, -0.0336534008, 0.044464495, 0.0365228988, 0.0182118472, 0.1093759239, -0.0212967061, -0.0299659166, -0.0253404286, -0.0237753037, 0.0328646861, 0.0085668303, 0.0163226034, 0.0243931767, -0.0744185299, -0.029228624, -0.0402481891, 0.0366503373, 0.0179235209, -0.0024102845, 0.0124928746, 0.0177273862, 0.0210752618, -0.038967818, 0.0330412686, 0.005275141, -0.0117716659, -0.0477621667, -0.0128571242, 0.0073210667, 0.0393200405, 0.0105820652, -0.0119871441, 0.0300931856, 0.0352541097, 0.0224144459, 0.0244310368, -0.0404906087, 0.0620935299, 0.0058557787, -0.0378614403, 0.0719230324, 0.0292305499, -0.0289718956, -0.0551375151, 0.0384520218, 0.0035073417, -0.0741944835, 0.0212199464, 0.0109169111, 0.0227361545, 0.0117533254, -0.0434263982, 0.0423351638, -0.0344957113, -0.0591797382, 0.0364945494, 0.0523114949, -0.0141519727, 0.0390413441, -0.0498497821, 0.0183116775, -0.0112741264, 0.0366942994, -0.0452094972, 0.027671149, -0.0068406384, -0.0181342606, -0.0208351389, -0.0017516853, -0.024378974, 0.0289776009, -0.0507725738, 0.0055916766, -0.0237733461, -0.0084505184, -0.0471819937, 0.0019053153, -0.040100459, 0.0004222293, 0.0042711119, 0.0449185409, -0.0343952812, 0.0475080535, -0.009574404, -0.0203114711, -0.0439623632, 0.0101951836, 0.0120086707, -0.0210350268, 0.0169150066, 0.0389506817, 0.0096588619, -0.0328170396, -0.0408384055, -0.0201298855, 0.00741908, -0.0629958361, 0.0063841268, -0.0430777073, -0.0090085426, 0.0219434965, -0.0031625372, -0.0932326093, -0.0238644909, -0.0257923249, -0.0235331543, 0.0678008869, 0.0037176819, 0.0186696481, 0.0313514993, -0.0075877849, 0.0047075548, 0.0485683195, 0.0285405051, 0.0276471078, 0.0343863815, -0.011277575, 0.0165018402, 0.018434789, 0.0579398498, 0.0155745577, -0.0699764714, -0.0353603773, 0.027516434, -0.0038686986, 0.0534444265, -0.0211443342, -0.054074645, 0.0136697907, 0.0777792037, -0.0023461133, 0.0242198072, 0.0044976608, 0.044615645, -0.0472322255, -0.0148279751, 0.043636702, -0.0710116774, -0.0013796539, -0.0537959449, -0.0065977718, 0.0032475472, 0.0262269434, -0.022958966, -0.023985913, -0.0295256078, 0.0268460065, 0.0133044599, 0.005219534, 0.0336722285, 0.0387739502, 0.0070011248, 0.0546988957, 0.026067121, -0.0221077595, 0.0003307686, -0.0528496653, -0.0078156739, 0.0129684275, 0.0195854455, -0.030170856, -0.050075449, 0.0058650193, -0.0265551172, -0.0000415833, 0.0528576225, -0.0064929812, 0.0407313183, -0.008120859, -0.0147056701, -0.048089534, 0.05095708, 0.0170718357, 0.0334819108, -0.0157953668, 0.0065342076, -0.0419277735, -0.0393845886, 0.0241499003, 0.0161841381, -0.0030071756, -0.0112400828, 0.023927873, -0.0053154868, 0.0007760998, -0.0305816773, -0.0043675746, 0.0003332014, 0.0002158273, 0.0010437623, 0.0454369821, -0.0293251667, -0.0503652357, 0.0640973598, -0.0130684571, -0.0191166271, 0.0117971357, -0.0124021638, -0.0453287251, 0.0339647941, -0.0241963491, 0.0587369464, -0.0110678943, 0.0436201058, -0.012389591, -0.0239950158, -0.0129899345, 0.0306394044, -0.0029092538, -0.000291138, 0.0227712654, -0.0075974865, 0.0165469963, -0.0366236903, -0.0215263907, 0.0017806712, -0.0110758301, -0.0166642163, 0.0277744774, -0.0133704068, -0.0074264724, 0.0005584592, -0.061436478, -0.0152266435, -0.0249610655, -0.0192227159, 0.0605119914, 0.0145870363, -0.0142022567, -0.0401934199, -0.0313983336, -0.0388618186, -0.0197888911, 0.0466717407, 0.0236751307, 0.0083764009, -0.0001614511, -0.0374110378, -0.0135642728, 0.0093287341, 0.0365249813, -0.0205385443, -0.0567692742, -0.072267361, 0.0327574871, -0.0547167696, 0.0295211729, -0.0006511514, -0.0528098755, 0.0032567088, -0.0133555075, 0.0416331403, 0.0803508982, -0.076934956, 0.066011034, 0.105349116, -0.0074732876, -0.0274735987, 0.0066359704, -0.0285585839, 0.0356952734, -0.045148883, -0.0349104591, -0.0469544604, 0.0897938237, -0.0084632384, -0.0441386178, -0.0391055495, 0.0183254872, -0.0452568009, -0.0518720411, -0.0452856086, 0.0054401215, -0.0164055452, 0.0808777362, -0.0455656089, -0.0771446377, 0.0654387996, -0.0073164129, 0.019116478, -0.0159099121, -0.03026006, 0.0148683749, 0.0466055945, 0.0433774889, 0.0406386778, -0.0407441743, -0.0140725691, -0.0761623457, -0.0066302349, 0.0610784814, 0.0090347631, -0.0107289841, -0.0780453309, -0.0141519886, -0.0181259476, -0.0375618674, -0.016310012, -0.0046540014, 0.0160805862, -0.0078192092, -0.0020588096, -0.0345143303, -0.0269547272, -0.0097562578, 0.048386611, 0.0923545212, -0.0210171118, 0.0150453104, -0.0027461895, -0.0320915841, 0.0309207849, 0.0241192952, 0.0396754555, -0.0401823744, 0.0134228151, 0.0281785261, 0.0226342678, -0.0167717841, -0.0298443213, 0.0194524303, 0.0181764755, -0.0484400168, -0.0313051268, -0.0013452803, 0.1265939921, -0.0382730253, -0.0405920669, 0.0879805386, 0.0436541028, -0.055639483, 0.0036969709, 0.0019068003, 0.0071103056, 0.0567419901, 0.018580988, -0.0530989878, -0.0065879733, 0.0588771403, -0.0077485847, -0.0229149237, 0.0075277491, -0.0045879758, -0.0423320644, 0.0250076037, -0.001990776, -0.0230855756, -0.0253965352, -0.0292625781, -0.0143433157, -0.0247461889, 0.0220227167, -0.000450692, -0.0008491905, 0.0360317007, 0.0032155565, 0.0137005625, -0.0387115143, -0.0314801745, -0.0150282187, 0.0590079688, 0.0313056782, -0.0033794953, -0.0041430774, -0.0011260427, 0.0189004634, 0.0820474774, 0.0220763814, -0.0199882165, 0.0397179499, 0.0338821486, -0.012978808, 0.0002277897, 0.0190076586, 0.0239523388, -0.0495638885, -0.0302358698, 0.0281031374, -0.0323758274, 0.00450313, 0.0283970088, -0.0099992473, -0.0375723951, 0.0504892766, 0.0730266124, -0.0230789334, -0.0201022867, -0.0678267777, -0.0013808941, -0.0059057209, -0.0357204974, -0.0015898086, -0.0057915794, -0.0197951328, -0.0459321961, -0.0377693884, 0.0414589569, 0.0544077754, 0.0415932462, -0.0287522338, 0.0040547876, -0.0457970202, -0.0237057433, 0.052563224, -0.0527580082, -0.0115089901, -0.0264347736, -0.0267831963, 0.0135018965, -0.0481245033, -0.0250732992, -0.0377410315, -0.0464093871, -0.078412056, 0.0416631885, 0.0525050312, 0.0316644534, 0.0661027357, -0.0269857571, -0.0897991732, 0.0317575149, -0.0385011658, -0.0334974043, 0.0540660024, 0.0548604168, -0.0535149388, 0.003509237, 0.0382859893, -0.0167353544, 0.0239905845, 0.0779405609, 0.0103972023, -0.0253349934, -0.0190790445, 0.0394995585, 0.0064672087, 0.0676886514, -0.0052412087, -0.0073930994, -0.0554670244, 0.0285849273, -0.0306191389, -0.0145797394, -0.0404069126, 0.0123425527, 0.0562016293, 0.0561224781, 0.0039976044, 0.0001016995, -0.0030369801, 0.0083736135, -0.0421347357, -0.015537654, 0.0137088196, 0.004483548, 0.0492699854, 0.0590725131, -0.0125767831, 0.0989894345, -0.0080044214, 0.018957166, 0.0028423232, 0.0267758649, 0.0364761613, 0.0202734061, -0.0803350732, 0.0091071678, -0.1159143969, -0.0495261662, -0.0045124805, 0.0051252181, 0.098752372, -0.024377903, 0.0506442152, -0.025289299, -0.0334934965, 0.0011657552, 0.0404469483, 0.0538764745, -0.040881291, -0.015949836, -0.0198306423, -0.038397193, 0.0190206096, 0.077697821, 0.0116157457, 0.1094767526, -0.0396234803, -0.0243151803, -0.0164914243, -0.0667976066, 0.014950295, 0.0282716453, -0.0546929725, 0.0065665715, -0.0546879284, -0.0942401737, -0.0496165864, -0.0142561989, -0.0143720964, -0.0410754196, -0.011738847, 0.0243380647, -0.0206476673, -0.0134617323, -0.020489892, 0.0066469088, 0.0499021597, 0.0043113106, -0.0017219572, -6.450167459e-33, -0.029307358, -0.0004622608, 0.0048249802, -0.0073935916, 0.0268777609, 0.0205996763, -0.0299642198, 0.0486019216, -0.0197993591, 0.0658873245, -0.0257184729, 0.0450744331, 0.0178991631, 0.0026593243, -0.029097883, 0.0188516583, 0.0611087047, 0.0077788201, -0.0363337733, -0.023200145, 0.0173492823, 0.0410988294, 0.1091247648, -0.0262309201, 0.0292239115, 0.0373832732, -0.0397745594, 0.0241195075, -0.0656985417, 0.021166645, -0.0186631605, 0.0108257085, -0.0008354602, -0.087096855, -0.038197238, -0.0894853845, -0.0140020158, -0.040514905, 0.0163743533, 0.0507915169, -0.0369095765, -0.033613719, 0.0598769076, 0.0059804735, -0.0337142497, 0.0203668438, 0.0242906567, -0.002642425, -0.0338835903, 0.0095444685, -0.0856508538, 0.0109842205, -0.0003383612, -0.0121257305, 0.0381242298, -0.0320552625, -0.0007824093, -0.0508564189, -0.058652848, -0.0201932807, 0.0497560613, 0.0456292927, 0.025304107, 0.017727159, 0.0082161399, 0.0462589972, 0.0251479968, 0.0296089277, -0.0040646084, 0.0088937813, 0.0534044616, -0.0113378903, 0.0377441831, 0.0336016156, 0.0047598784, 0.0041801482, -0.0573609807, -0.0161319934, -0.0167741515, 0.0053017666, -0.003238579, 0.0314811021, 0.0317919366, -0.0219195411, -0.0655578524, -0.0300395712, -0.0288686547, 0.0080146426, -0.0029123079, 0.031210918, -0.0168567915, -0.0220160019, 0.0312529914, -0.0274408516, 0.0130625702, 0.0146764731, -0.0201228224, 0.0276313089, 0.0108914301, -0.0048608626, -0.0508080199, 0.0109432423, -0.0046462147, -0.0009948575, -0.0023143755, 0.0226662513, 0.0650433376, 0.0334616974, -0.0145612042, 0.0275292583, -0.0458271876, -0.0119911432, 0.0257870164, 0.0307665803, 0.0530930534, -0.0001900324, -0.0220888406, 0.009056502, 0.0663334727, 0.0728617609, -0.0116546396, -0.00400001, 0.0177187715, 0.0443051197, -0.0444632955, -0.0304361004, -0.0387413315, 0.0328630917, 0.0365443677, -0.0468988977, -0.0375992693, -0.0146342767, 2.727e-7, 0.0637881532, 0.0182669051, 0.0301688239, 0.0187319983, 0.0305221174, 0.0444538407, -0.019319078, -0.0090205111, 0.0217215735, 0.0103852982, 0.0057375939, 0.028703589, 0.0153144272, 0.0006653127, -0.0534043051, 0.0154748661, -0.0273423232, 0.0342455953, -0.0080309445, -0.0038559996, -0.0578445941, 0.0701748058, 0.0347868055, 0.0088638924, 0.0330916643, -0.0177805666, 0.0543725602, -0.0524775684, -0.0022908316, -0.0007295503, 0.0549330264, 0.0097079603, 0.0007630212, -0.0255168751, -0.0158457272, 0.0158577431, -0.0113802897, 0.0434787832, -0.0408737138, 0.0202495549, -0.0489519127, 0.0207640789, -0.0115448767, -0.0677063093, 0.0570808686, -0.0220811497, -0.0383486003, -0.0118128331, 0.0088919625, 0.0149066392, 0.0230289903, 0.0019076366, 0.0082775755, 0.0104371114, 0.0098393131, 0.043015752, -0.0439977609, -0.0774397403, -0.0734719634, -0.0159271043, -0.0009046554, -0.0348118991, -0.0185717512, -0.0463370904, 0.0475951694, -0.0566671677, -0.0255355258, 2.741410554e-34, 0.0191530026, 0.0178185105, 0.0347459204, 0.0149683338, 0.0307710171, -0.0300789233, -0.0176362675, -0.0063555734, 0.0120399408, -0.0486694537, -0.0333097987 ]