id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.10395v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.10395v1 | A Graph-Guided Reasoning Approach for Open-ended Commonsense Question Answering | 2023-03-18T11:15:33 | 2023-03-18T11:15:33 | Zhen Han, Yue Feng, Mingming Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Recently, end-to-end trained models for multiple-choice commonsense question
answering (QA) have delivered promising results. However, such
question-answering systems cannot be directly applied in real-world scenarios
where answer candidates are not provided. Hence, a new benchmark challenge set
for open-ended commonsense reasoning (OpenCSR) has been recently released,
which contains natural science questions without any predefined choices. On the
OpenCSR challenge set, many questions require implicit multi-hop reasoning and
have a large decision space, reflecting the difficult nature of this task.
Existing work on OpenCSR sorely focuses on improving the retrieval process,
which extracts relevant factual sentences from a textual knowledge base,
leaving the important and non-trivial reasoning task outside the scope. In this
work, we extend the scope to include a reasoner that constructs a
question-dependent open knowledge graph based on retrieved supporting facts and
employs a sequential subgraph reasoning process to predict the answer. The
subgraph can be seen as a concise and compact graphical explanation of the
prediction. Experiments on two OpenCSR datasets show that the proposed model
achieves great performance on benchmark OpenCSR datasets. | [
0.0220045503,
0.0079944199,
0.0374264047,
0.0037796849,
-0.0352307372,
0.0103427796,
-0.0110364845,
0.0197659377,
0.0845764875,
-0.0116213914,
0.0533300005,
0.0475331768,
-0.0307844412,
0.0016569413,
-0.0061023948,
-0.0183922891,
0.022790214,
-0.0132101076,
0.0072194943,
-0.0285582338,
-0.0216899961,
0.0499911755,
-0.0169899575,
0.0149991233,
-0.0046425611,
-0.0605184324,
-0.0097594671,
-0.0026020771,
0.0109380465,
-0.0088099297,
-0.0130592445,
-0.0043338169,
0.0394014791,
-0.0409691222,
0.0000020105,
-0.0364569426,
-0.0224571284,
0.0119726174,
-0.0552646816,
-0.0371836722,
-0.0323891565,
0.0301031861,
0.0610637777,
0.0239899047,
-0.0158753917,
0.0240500271,
0.0352728143,
0.034493424,
0.0560943633,
0.0171805639,
0.0067002228,
-0.0710722432,
-0.0271429382,
0.0410395786,
0.0154114179,
-0.0453827903,
0.041015517,
0.0399833284,
0.0219734795,
-0.0331088901,
-0.0426266268,
-0.0032215817,
0.0170435645,
-0.0037782253,
0.0225451197,
0.0289724227,
-0.0297210831,
0.0198574997,
0.0173954237,
0.1470014155,
0.0230273381,
-0.0353666022,
0.0020270832,
-0.0091580981,
-0.0170447566,
0.0637266487,
-0.0525510386,
0.024794424,
-0.0280291699,
-0.0116587039,
-0.0133303544,
-0.0250315946,
0.0105827944,
0.0249449238,
-0.0078218002,
0.0773605332,
-0.0067294231,
-0.0044205734,
0.045016285,
0.0018409292,
-0.0373601727,
-0.0267248135,
0.0045807124,
0.0820872933,
-0.0363124274,
0.0193463042,
0.028611118,
0.0205261856,
-0.0186134744,
-0.022686284,
0.0225807913,
0.0226121936,
-0.0108010806,
0.0482023507,
0.0039868997,
0.0122779962,
-0.0233082697,
0.0618416555,
-0.0365352705,
-0.0255829133,
-0.0495762229,
0.0174586177,
-0.0513862073,
0.0353698209,
-0.0447802953,
-0.0215098653,
-0.0116193835,
0.0099655008,
0.0003058961,
0.0059770946,
0.0643443465,
0.0874646455,
0.0070820963,
-0.0316491574,
-0.0554122813,
0.0636641383,
-0.0434433818,
0.0201815516,
0.0014792092,
0.0244023763,
-0.0356846079,
0.0135059459,
0.0662111565,
-0.0171756893,
0.00900668,
0.0381600559,
0.0068616206,
0.0143192401,
-0.0391414165,
-0.04038902,
0.0152047258,
-0.0272979159,
-0.0015277321,
-0.0456729531,
-0.018108815,
0.0435211957,
-0.0288853794,
0.0048117479,
0.0192543212,
0.0148511203,
-0.0419036262,
0.0562228151,
-0.0209581945,
-0.0283279903,
-0.0113070589,
0.0059345243,
0.0150646465,
0.0370011553,
-0.0155438483,
-0.0061611719,
0.0503130406,
0.0137872407,
-0.0130870705,
-0.033810731,
0.0363320708,
-0.015156785,
0.0418866612,
0.0636230186,
-0.0159861166,
0.0438472144,
0.005597204,
0.0008828068,
-0.0277489461,
-0.0620339587,
-0.0018506461,
0.0366906822,
0.0020515176,
-0.0108666755,
0.0130733727,
0.0350765102,
0.0035801092,
0.0138239963,
-0.0114775179,
0.0477922224,
-0.0225290209,
0.0289869905,
-0.0157864019,
-0.0209229924,
-0.0211504884,
0.0006184299,
-0.0274198782,
0.0063569807,
0.0400473028,
0.0272944532,
0.0763490349,
-0.0073900176,
-0.0519323684,
0.0550146177,
0.0319662802,
-0.0151016694,
-0.0172096044,
-0.0071104686,
0.0449864194,
0.03865695,
0.0616351627,
-0.0114365695,
-0.0487698205,
-0.0055323266,
0.0248860233,
0.000338114,
0.0226517636,
-0.0466872491,
0.0060660252,
-0.0574605875,
-0.019133646,
-0.0221472234,
-0.0453112796,
0.0172977671,
0.0106299706,
0.0055287392,
-0.0198027231,
-0.0690364167,
0.0041093957,
-0.0083763944,
-0.0001016789,
-0.0146590071,
-0.0024355135,
-0.0115201427,
-0.016364323,
0.0095554898,
0.0100121284,
0.0149871847,
0.0156410746,
0.020948546,
-0.0386407636,
0.0045341509,
-0.009905613,
-0.091334857,
0.036158897,
-0.0357722603,
-0.0584531352,
0.0206746329,
-0.0355979688,
-0.0539367832,
0.0269596949,
-0.0092279268,
0.0464021713,
-0.0182620771,
-0.0631128922,
0.0324537978,
-0.0519439094,
-0.0057512699,
0.080898881,
-0.0064783343,
0.0148441168,
0.000662246,
0.0033425426,
0.0353759825,
-0.0565656945,
0.0429617763,
-0.0006278971,
0.0027416779,
0.0008844363,
-0.0015979095,
0.0032485821,
-0.0758223906,
0.0507219434,
-0.0709094405,
0.0042576506,
0.0109344348,
0.0028954404,
-0.024509728,
0.0007357094,
0.0398180299,
-0.0436320789,
-0.0431670025,
0.0611602962,
0.0110131931,
-0.0025087462,
0.0452465117,
-0.0038931638,
0.0288612302,
0.021335816,
-0.0184402466,
-0.0313877426,
0.0699327588,
0.0165058244,
0.0903855041,
0.0061823144,
0.0004524645,
-0.0638979077,
0.0308362003,
-0.0040170825,
0.0168372728,
0.02130403,
-0.0354634225,
-0.037880484,
0.0702552572,
-0.0179290082,
-0.0039368933,
0.0216222927,
-0.021022113,
-0.029752912,
0.0201150607,
-0.0505234003,
0.0016771244,
-0.0107402056,
0.0180464238,
-0.0548595339,
0.0214397088,
0.0169901215,
-0.0264450349,
-0.0482632667,
-0.0001912316,
0.034625683,
0.0469775721,
-0.0757308304,
0.0166683551,
0.0037300624,
0.0272723883,
-0.0215849467,
-0.0017966528,
0.0984585509,
0.0362695381,
0.021180952,
-0.0420722701,
-0.0028951503,
-0.0568210967,
0.0470897704,
-0.0202802494,
-0.0019891285,
0.0104728192,
0.0016505144,
-0.02786953,
-0.0425065793,
0.048885908,
-0.0167734977,
0.001029579,
-0.0348366424,
0.0295563377,
0.0161288157,
-0.0286024325,
-0.0130165434,
-0.0391117409,
-0.0254518222,
0.0195286013,
-0.0183665063,
-0.0381922051,
-0.0147567391,
-0.0139005519,
-0.0052881632,
-0.0023880526,
-0.0118689993,
-0.0073845861,
-0.003346567,
0.0671838596,
0.0467377827,
0.0430362299,
0.0084051806,
0.0002462674,
0.0044266135,
0.0473202132,
0.0147456303,
-0.050994467,
0.009355152,
0.0284690764,
-0.0158064906,
-0.0048673376,
0.0141261611,
-0.008220125,
0.0751705766,
-0.0474308133,
-0.0145278396,
0.0497448966,
0.0388378017,
0.0332747214,
-0.0160047952,
-0.0300777778,
0.0038319079,
0.0184339918,
0.0324858166,
-0.0803610608,
-0.0549682714,
-0.0161581114,
0.0511901006,
0.0060932417,
-0.0634557158,
0.0013303431,
-0.0827319697,
0.0161079951,
-0.0187995993,
-0.0644536987,
-0.0363549665,
-0.0634064227,
-0.0093590869,
-0.0266315192,
-0.0692541376,
-0.0009947008,
0.0034310005,
0.0081165675,
0.0208868831,
-0.0031758046,
0.0030475932,
0.0672981143,
0.0005007997,
-0.0068312399,
-0.037049491,
0.0559677668,
0.0345292054,
-0.0600428209,
-0.0156927221,
-0.057442572,
0.0099357571,
-0.0353549011,
0.0234166849,
0.0329662077,
-0.0067083277,
-0.067005381,
0.0413547792,
-0.0510408692,
-0.0376565345,
-0.0101170475,
0.108990632,
-0.0182299931,
-0.0375034362,
-0.0117908539,
0.0200217552,
-0.0131125469,
0.0470386483,
0.0197538584,
0.0456921048,
-0.0724520311,
-0.0723949,
-0.0006547472,
-0.0664735213,
-0.0165959708,
0.0172354244,
-0.0118356748,
0.0274657719,
-0.0449295267,
-0.0012945582,
0.0446306057,
0.0416825488,
-0.0479996093,
-0.0216148384,
0.020389853,
0.0203023423,
-0.0451642275,
0.0565264858,
-0.0294699017,
0.0042622071,
-0.0024633859,
-0.0054241298,
0.0109411879,
-0.021799285,
-0.0274404809,
0.0368638039,
-0.0268642977,
-0.0513304099,
-0.0518433414,
0.0126566468,
0.0170493349,
0.046966292,
-0.0089562265,
-0.0028541139,
0.0508629978,
-0.0013804627,
-0.0214893799,
-0.0318759307,
0.0297538284,
-0.0006218588,
-0.0080882991,
0.0175893418,
-0.0440404266,
-0.0381453857,
0.0109499581,
0.0488777943,
-0.0337519422,
-0.0278860964,
0.0198461562,
0.0280036237,
0.0163285621,
0.0566616952,
0.0166562535,
-0.0404400527,
-0.006470223,
-0.025726065,
-0.0199184939,
0.0150556639,
0.0300485138,
0.016568495,
-0.0503814593,
-0.0109951543,
-0.0129752103,
-0.0367253907,
0.025853958,
-0.025739016,
-0.0032459716,
0.0812056214,
-0.0038065922,
0.034005411,
-0.0308928676,
-0.0225132313,
-0.0186586324,
0.0044268845,
0.0396950357,
0.0143730855,
0.084722653,
0.0392843448,
-0.0083323661,
-0.0279720351,
-0.0562734567,
-0.0931636617,
-0.0148947258,
0.026046278,
0.0421312228,
-0.0032815773,
0.0144576197,
-0.018904943,
0.0107901441,
-0.0295490995,
0.0144798448,
0.0551515482,
0.009460167,
-0.0302104186,
0.0721260831,
0.0271893088,
-0.0048915264,
0.0215985384,
0.03354913,
-0.0132180974,
0.0251342244,
-0.0155656133,
-0.0545706451,
-0.0202040225,
-0.0284058768,
-0.0263460986,
0.0645309314,
0.0463889912,
0.0282567404,
-0.075331375,
-0.054617431,
0.0097420961,
0.026245866,
0.0028755225,
-0.0046893558,
0.0346691273,
0.0137033826,
0.0687171891,
-0.0840689167,
-0.031813655,
0.0611699261,
-0.0923226327,
-0.0087375985,
0.0104946215,
-6.624200867e-33,
-0.0011825819,
-0.0807722658,
0.0244969223,
-0.0252307709,
-0.0225524791,
-0.0000983301,
-0.0504055731,
-0.0470909774,
-0.0411375389,
0.0232292674,
-0.0209572706,
0.0293170903,
-0.0055024158,
0.0246041231,
-0.0231697094,
-0.0240188967,
-0.0197013672,
-0.0036716703,
-0.0135926567,
0.0211280677,
0.1109460294,
0.0185411125,
0.0239659734,
-0.0123582212,
0.0315945931,
-0.0299985595,
0.024784768,
0.0317106098,
-0.0344794244,
0.0415073335,
-0.0045073517,
0.0620086379,
0.0173885673,
-0.030749118,
0.0359890722,
0.0233429782,
-0.1100722551,
-0.071019955,
0.0238752235,
-0.0137342587,
-0.0793027431,
0.0041993926,
-0.0029878234,
0.0156901106,
0.0623315312,
-0.0552053489,
0.0410468876,
-0.0006852857,
-0.0169065669,
0.0088859322,
0.028055897,
0.0187044404,
-0.0614233613,
-0.0342754126,
-0.0561586581,
0.0266198255,
-0.0099060545,
-0.0065883487,
-0.0273623597,
0.0356134176,
-0.0037581827,
-0.0547956564,
0.0147685744,
-0.0050191907,
0.0225936025,
0.0248993561,
-0.0479560234,
-0.043609865,
-0.0661709905,
0.0350134671,
-0.0521348938,
0.0644326359,
0.0471522324,
0.0387547277,
0.0087071704,
0.0151027329,
-0.1023510396,
0.0372702256,
-0.0096063111,
0.0351265743,
-0.0219873935,
0.00438635,
-0.0019325364,
-0.055917386,
-0.0168135166,
-0.0110827563,
-0.0224589389,
-0.0022211948,
0.0019772991,
-0.0302657112,
-0.0388453938,
0.0154926488,
-0.0081322286,
-0.031408824,
0.0265270211,
0.0906262621,
0.0041725272,
-0.0010274359,
-0.0074627572,
0.0368490629,
-0.0514217466,
0.0359628797,
0.0440414697,
-0.0249135979,
-0.004450398,
0.0410113111,
0.0052676885,
-0.0031633063,
-0.0001283357,
-0.023631772,
-0.0435805917,
-0.0230173357,
-0.0362808034,
-0.0088149905,
0.0367358476,
0.065221332,
0.0105454968,
0.0838308483,
-0.0072923326,
0.0665227249,
0.0077541084,
0.0122272884,
0.0043929084,
0.0083311358,
-0.0251736566,
0.0266712289,
-0.0133529184,
-0.0071546771,
-0.0327548869,
-0.049025178,
-0.0191997495,
0.0689691976,
2.619e-7,
0.0321575478,
0.0141907474,
0.0296326298,
0.046261128,
-0.0187534485,
0.0272947997,
0.0235972144,
-0.0023024431,
0.0057398365,
-0.0464491807,
0.0112781469,
0.0486318357,
0.0029838053,
0.0417976491,
-0.0360492729,
0.0432160646,
-0.0215491764,
-0.0688037798,
-0.0325549617,
-0.0066338112,
0.0744622648,
0.0106764557,
0.0330041163,
-0.0320582315,
-0.011593136,
-0.0256807506,
0.0302472357,
0.0334930718,
-0.010107819,
-0.0556136481,
0.0231071133,
-0.0228033867,
-0.0134231849,
0.0668991953,
0.0016413706,
-0.0093032187,
0.0103913965,
0.0124999853,
-0.0031002371,
-0.052559942,
0.0125533948,
-0.057073433,
0.017943183,
-0.0221137721,
0.1165466607,
-0.0469667353,
-0.0427051634,
0.0063253841,
-0.0075907605,
-0.0141492868,
0.0040526697,
-0.0166985001,
0.0160158444,
-0.0130915679,
-0.0191333666,
-0.0347900093,
0.051376313,
-0.0670420229,
0.0254077241,
0.0264505818,
0.0208221599,
-0.0452951901,
0.0365809165,
-0.0042184927,
0.0482003391,
-0.0242926776,
-0.0148103237,
2.007438539e-34,
0.0202670712,
0.0162165053,
-0.022997655,
-0.0500739515,
0.0312113725,
-0.0358538218,
-0.0180632994,
-0.0297767632,
0.0673611462,
-0.0944107547,
-0.0164859369
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.10384v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.10384v1 | Powerful and Extensible WFST Framework for RNN-Transducer Losses | 2023-03-18T10:36:33 | 2023-03-18T10:36:33 | Aleksandr Laptev, Vladimir Bataev, Igor Gitman, Boris Ginsburg | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD | This paper presents a framework based on Weighted Finite-State Transducers
(WFST) to simplify the development of modifications for RNN-Transducer (RNN-T)
loss. Existing implementations of RNN-T use CUDA-related code, which is hard to
extend and debug. WFSTs are easy to construct and extend, and allow debugging
through visualization. We introduce two WFST-powered RNN-T implementations: (1)
"Compose-Transducer", based on a composition of the WFST graphs from acoustic
and textual schema -- computationally competitive and easy to modify; (2)
"Grid-Transducer", which constructs the lattice directly for further
computations -- most compact, and computationally efficient. We illustrate the
ease of extensibility through introduction of a new W-Transducer loss -- the
adaptation of the Connectionist Temporal Classification with Wild Cards.
W-Transducer (W-RNNT) consistently outperforms the standard RNN-T in a
weakly-supervised data setup with missing parts of transcriptions at the
beginning and end of utterances. All RNN-T losses are implemented with the k2
framework and are available in the NeMo toolkit. | [
-0.02480218,
0.1032851338,
-0.0020148309,
0.0409634896,
-0.0022150895,
-0.0203877129,
0.0139738228,
-0.0098930979,
-0.0574842654,
0.0230948217,
-0.0348141454,
-0.0335439555,
0.0570573471,
-0.0047179936,
0.0289775897,
-0.0448688567,
0.0259890649,
-0.02028591,
-0.0207370538,
0.0245476048,
0.0221870653,
0.0065686298,
-0.0536973327,
0.0476826243,
-0.027363427,
0.0273717716,
-0.0234061778,
0.0100912573,
0.0562005453,
-0.0506125279,
-0.0008951211,
0.0001288903,
0.0161494985,
0.0571802184,
0.0000020809,
-0.0051303683,
0.0050501893,
0.0013296341,
-0.0222203303,
-0.0033980419,
-0.0063456492,
0.0157070737,
-0.0313643366,
0.0355421267,
-0.000575111,
-0.0572923124,
0.0731169581,
0.0534150861,
0.0361257158,
0.0609487072,
0.0185816567,
-0.002085268,
0.0541844331,
-0.0267672166,
0.0493873581,
-0.0573691726,
0.0182505623,
-0.050695423,
-0.0042071971,
-0.0743466616,
-0.0377088338,
0.0347626358,
0.0165719874,
-0.0293806829,
0.0219435599,
0.0206810143,
-0.0120903067,
-0.0253967606,
-0.0366790928,
0.0728372186,
-0.0032953077,
-0.0226541702,
0.0350805037,
0.0399192795,
-0.0464734733,
-0.0702582896,
-0.0091505358,
0.0209797341,
0.0225338191,
0.0157851689,
-0.0581596382,
0.0455974005,
0.0466473848,
-0.0304085724,
-0.0277395472,
0.0162734613,
0.0339833349,
-0.0013999919,
0.0012449471,
-0.0030865485,
0.0272979941,
-0.0043945047,
0.0558652878,
0.0022592186,
-0.0145916343,
0.0015778303,
-0.0292209405,
-0.065825507,
-0.0190226752,
0.0042163371,
0.0364040397,
0.0455738492,
-0.0151761947,
-0.0035020059,
-0.0229403712,
0.0447357111,
-0.0214720462,
-0.033290837,
-0.0405661725,
-0.0320201851,
-0.0443064049,
-0.0380608626,
-0.001951238,
0.0163988993,
0.0005818381,
-0.0259829164,
-0.0471094325,
0.0082235327,
-0.0484314039,
-0.0159636717,
0.0353623666,
0.0371103436,
-0.0821161196,
0.004254444,
0.0226715505,
0.0785373002,
0.027872514,
0.0350033008,
0.0078961905,
-0.0377941094,
-0.0210707728,
0.0186844599,
0.0321200192,
-0.0110246222,
0.0142652709,
0.0697613582,
0.0277327336,
-0.0230162889,
-0.0024237426,
-0.0083062099,
-0.0372040123,
-0.0280268583,
0.0099662635,
-0.0503623225,
0.0485093519,
-0.0437174849,
0.0189375803,
-0.0363914706,
0.029346101,
0.0073793512,
0.0508548506,
0.0565972626,
-0.0027450884,
-0.0258220825,
0.0394024625,
0.0079713352,
0.053525053,
0.0374707989,
0.053774137,
-0.0143158566,
-0.0256226566,
-0.0168333203,
-0.0360756032,
0.0304224845,
0.0399936438,
-0.0053769499,
-0.0808519945,
-0.0284371823,
0.0134715671,
0.0722417086,
0.0846748725,
0.0513888001,
-0.0445133187,
-0.0394295529,
0.0399493687,
0.0483918637,
0.0602176487,
0.0362157002,
0.0189940892,
-0.016073022,
0.0013449255,
-0.0280086193,
-0.0054017166,
0.0344825983,
-0.0050232029,
0.0041781268,
0.0285704434,
0.0190590378,
-0.0105417157,
0.0049198535,
0.0219801217,
-0.0394451544,
-0.00594615,
-0.0202137381,
0.0264191367,
0.0138860578,
-0.0646730363,
0.0408285372,
-0.01143522,
-0.0696331263,
-0.0068936101,
-0.0054959757,
0.0246601887,
0.0280357972,
0.0040176124,
-0.0351406001,
-0.0192217659,
-0.0015162681,
-0.050653059,
0.0306944847,
-0.0087580895,
0.0037261341,
0.0620195381,
-0.0610800087,
-0.0153569384,
0.0550182648,
0.0172990654,
0.0667880028,
-0.0214275811,
0.0176234096,
0.0181456301,
-0.0841910616,
-0.016660871,
-0.0035082523,
0.0219458975,
-0.0346526206,
0.0198120549,
0.0015671826,
0.0475713909,
0.0223870836,
-0.0102460887,
0.032246761,
0.041797217,
-0.0408292934,
-0.0137474546,
-0.0014340284,
-0.0830688179,
-0.0479472317,
0.0181631912,
-0.0376552865,
0.0110428585,
0.0825423002,
-0.0256131589,
-0.0734607205,
0.0545189418,
-0.0548479967,
0.0760149211,
-0.0305321589,
-0.0259114243,
0.056956891,
0.0028512995,
0.016788885,
0.001989359,
0.0024051205,
0.0010186645,
0.0045565129,
-0.0635327399,
-0.028526498,
-0.0742034093,
-0.007619374,
0.028031325,
-0.0424530953,
0.0106626479,
-0.0012498241,
-0.0400439687,
-0.0159267243,
-0.0114852404,
-0.0550375767,
0.0247471891,
0.0020907051,
0.0465844162,
0.0032965618,
0.0526966676,
0.0140117798,
-0.0079460433,
-0.0019864775,
-0.0080327075,
-0.0349050537,
-0.0034922406,
-0.0003364695,
0.0024493821,
-0.0271432195,
-0.0087122694,
-0.0266384743,
-0.0195980463,
0.0356492177,
-0.0496920981,
-0.0243563168,
-0.0280766021,
-0.0029635197,
0.0178119987,
0.0045218444,
0.0134433918,
-0.0165566597,
-0.0017538021,
0.0011656795,
0.0431423523,
0.0289683267,
-0.0344762169,
0.0300982632,
0.0254950449,
-0.0267005712,
-0.0318476297,
0.0320109054,
-0.0062221629,
0.0107086869,
-0.0193780642,
-0.0102198329,
-0.0459497981,
0.0581148751,
0.033510264,
0.0146963745,
-0.0400976688,
-0.0188533179,
-0.0117090372,
-0.0146861561,
-0.0074774101,
-0.0304465797,
-0.0479964167,
-0.016501883,
0.0067359591,
-0.0097595574,
0.0139916204,
-0.0750840008,
-0.0228978507,
-0.0329932831,
-0.0407585651,
-0.0371536613,
0.0515787937,
-0.0073643303,
-0.0160607826,
-0.0223720297,
-0.0386319011,
-0.008030992,
-0.0254201032,
0.005994821,
-0.0067486786,
-0.0137282303,
-0.0159797631,
-0.0142286941,
-0.037244603,
-0.0121264718,
0.0102783749,
0.0658077523,
-0.0275749434,
-0.0164837427,
0.0205537882,
-0.0498327464,
0.004847493,
-0.0181950945,
0.0021327478,
0.070018068,
-0.0066006025,
-0.0015151965,
0.0085629197,
0.0665077716,
-0.0018377361,
0.0407748967,
0.0152279222,
-0.0106149912,
0.00821946,
0.0358052813,
0.0948856398,
0.0053400313,
-0.0711858422,
-0.0052338876,
0.0072407364,
0.0081060529,
0.0171352457,
0.0348042697,
0.065125227,
-0.077291429,
0.0106568178,
0.0361514837,
0.0104152719,
-0.0232744589,
0.0004944091,
0.0242857374,
0.0459379815,
0.0184811745,
-0.0139898937,
-0.0409094058,
-0.0428711884,
0.0566682741,
0.0735402182,
0.0008909866,
-0.0087793479,
0.0014726999,
-0.0496139526,
0.0030238368,
0.0221216884,
-0.0477720983,
-0.0205689017,
-0.0478480123,
-0.0108009744,
-0.0361526385,
-0.0035670418,
0.0077527636,
0.0100779589,
0.0017634963,
0.0517820567,
-0.0730642825,
-0.0000608225,
-0.0067921784,
-0.0008980573,
0.0507569239,
0.0681480244,
0.0417077467,
-0.0040854299,
-0.0409510806,
0.0317250676,
-0.0143486299,
-0.0030161415,
-0.0310897473,
0.031835936,
0.0431659594,
-0.0225338209,
-0.025849212,
0.0448740087,
-0.0270641092,
0.0076533365,
-0.0076210308,
0.1016855687,
0.0032249142,
-0.001193177,
-0.0225334298,
-0.0123742828,
0.0412697159,
0.0628544465,
0.0368812419,
-0.0037062964,
-0.0643540323,
-0.0049764961,
0.0095594451,
-0.1034120768,
-0.0491310395,
-0.0476952009,
0.0470531471,
-0.0628004074,
-0.0461466834,
-0.0052379919,
-0.0112101892,
0.0238725375,
0.0088899108,
-0.0054351068,
0.0000912506,
-0.0020685287,
-0.0522428006,
0.0070736436,
-0.0264649652,
0.0535275117,
-0.0159961823,
0.0256864168,
0.0407940708,
-0.0170342289,
-0.0059166891,
0.0620365851,
-0.0879303366,
-0.0349383429,
-0.0023381263,
-0.0052945106,
0.0193163604,
0.0376729593,
0.0077749696,
0.020816762,
0.0454306602,
0.0411124341,
-0.034342315,
0.0194877237,
0.0902816877,
-0.0492734574,
0.001144703,
0.0291663613,
-0.0511370711,
0.00177866,
-0.0220479891,
0.050598342,
0.051419355,
-0.043155469,
0.0149856331,
-0.0307768285,
0.0593189672,
0.0410915054,
0.0201401226,
-0.0255003683,
0.0456571616,
0.0076394896,
0.0576420426,
-0.0475332551,
0.0075086602,
0.062694028,
0.0349067897,
-0.0141109079,
0.0017027187,
0.0581485517,
-0.0077840523,
0.0087312693,
0.0788339898,
0.0365849473,
-0.0205612462,
-0.0005939567,
0.0142138209,
-0.013992616,
0.0077700699,
0.0058689769,
0.0467441976,
-0.0039009892,
-0.0203152876,
-0.0124677401,
-0.0173609406,
0.0107362811,
-0.0166125018,
-0.0385628641,
-0.0137834521,
-0.0069636428,
0.0040060263,
0.0280707795,
0.0025533161,
0.0329326764,
-0.0346355923,
0.0069066612,
-0.0273814425,
0.0218243934,
-0.0547241531,
0.0328418203,
0.0568281151,
-0.00279614,
0.0093146367,
0.0086223874,
0.0370271355,
0.04495956,
0.0827451646,
0.0002221236,
0.0181626808,
-0.0281759128,
-0.0507510528,
-0.0052068112,
-0.0213256124,
-0.0433628112,
-0.0312986113,
0.0092096804,
-0.0599202923,
0.0762607828,
-0.024159817,
0.0020910634,
-0.0286657345,
0.016480457,
-0.0450974107,
-0.0158315562,
0.0084525524,
0.0367492326,
0.0038962057,
0.0259237047,
-0.0267724823,
0.0147293648,
-6.309244053e-33,
-0.0133261783,
-0.0160126798,
0.0151693635,
-0.0149378758,
-0.0508544296,
0.0148922503,
-0.0506226458,
0.003959937,
0.0209036376,
-0.020204505,
0.0038244689,
0.0137583986,
0.0352769792,
0.0352322683,
-0.0004094065,
0.0049733394,
0.0866706744,
-0.0027940508,
0.0280457512,
0.0183776096,
0.0247495081,
0.0590801574,
0.0585859157,
-0.0534487292,
-0.0359914303,
0.0265905205,
-0.0065615601,
0.010618058,
-0.002180181,
0.0133357197,
-0.0256844964,
0.0543713421,
-0.0424491838,
-0.0661499724,
-0.0410984196,
0.0141489254,
-0.1043737456,
-0.0480219498,
0.0043407744,
0.0301868208,
-0.0488244556,
-0.0452424176,
0.0362498909,
0.0137820896,
0.001748091,
-0.0453967601,
-0.0012879061,
-0.0219672471,
-0.0487768315,
-0.0578649975,
-0.003123068,
0.0486055762,
-0.0353880152,
-0.0255115684,
0.023109246,
0.0072801528,
-0.016581405,
-0.0721627921,
-0.1127597392,
-0.0114173749,
-0.027266087,
0.0616362058,
0.0233052224,
0.0208650865,
-0.0189645458,
0.0031498556,
0.0753469542,
-0.0481435545,
0.0198102668,
0.0051411721,
-0.0080216257,
0.0010771087,
0.0542561077,
-0.0018820766,
0.0373381786,
-0.052071508,
-0.0444893241,
0.0077903629,
-0.0314681716,
0.0480646566,
0.0039251326,
0.0596822165,
-0.0193007272,
0.0194956809,
-0.0087462096,
-0.0177509654,
-0.0089138923,
0.0388897583,
0.0408551618,
0.0184803661,
-0.019960681,
0.0085743247,
0.0122280652,
-0.0071827807,
0.0115642501,
0.0257801507,
0.0189696979,
-0.0013817924,
-0.0160919074,
-0.0119143762,
-0.0225652307,
-0.007918993,
0.0476438366,
0.0223685429,
0.0546486862,
-0.0488934442,
0.0444832072,
0.0844885111,
-0.0665633082,
-0.0284139551,
-0.0292249508,
0.0229300577,
-0.0145677505,
0.037330471,
0.0386594459,
-0.019914262,
0.0112863965,
-0.0128638949,
-0.0068063089,
0.0336892717,
-0.0403975248,
0.0016120255,
0.0111651458,
0.0117036207,
-0.0477518961,
-0.0234718509,
-0.0184682701,
0.0098281857,
0.0423238799,
-0.0480697416,
-0.0211908277,
0.0119634522,
2.95e-7,
-0.0006474052,
0.0045510978,
0.0726431459,
-0.0448047593,
0.0179052483,
-0.0008416033,
-0.0448990911,
0.0236026682,
-0.0255331248,
0.0287817139,
0.0389433838,
-0.0221363679,
0.0940345153,
0.0212973151,
-0.1087280959,
-0.0165055711,
-0.0744366944,
0.0278070401,
-0.0395449549,
-0.0260561816,
-0.0074095298,
0.1029274687,
-0.0000816573,
-0.0377225988,
0.0290801357,
-0.009852577,
0.027294077,
0.005667048,
0.0762058869,
-0.0578049906,
0.0346993729,
-0.0233881939,
-0.0245031063,
-0.026841877,
-0.0278943423,
0.006630206,
0.0103088515,
0.0472062603,
-0.0116773602,
-0.106688492,
0.0089204265,
0.028891813,
-0.0075794091,
0.0181276463,
0.0274919514,
0.0020609759,
-0.014847558,
-0.0144495508,
-0.005650348,
0.014273515,
0.0367106274,
-0.006666318,
0.0548358969,
-0.0358174816,
-0.0148218349,
-0.0017210324,
-0.0519579947,
-0.040990565,
-0.0171806924,
0.005896206,
-0.0682678893,
-0.0250731595,
-0.1090590656,
0.0014232568,
-0.0003966317,
-0.0461949185,
-0.033971861,
2.600455006e-34,
-0.0008944594,
-0.0339296535,
0.0174777936,
-0.0181477126,
0.0180873033,
-0.0285943002,
0.0122319153,
0.0209043231,
-0.0036715423,
-0.0725840926,
-0.0618209168
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.10368v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.10368v1 | An Empirical Study of Pre-trained Language Models in Simple Knowledge Graph Question Answering | 2023-03-18T08:57:09 | 2023-03-18T08:57:09 | Nan Hu, Yike Wu, Guilin Qi, Dehai Min, Jiaoyan Chen, Jeff Z. Pan, Zafar Ali | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large-scale pre-trained language models (PLMs) such as BERT have recently
achieved great success and become a milestone in natural language processing
(NLP). It is now the consensus of the NLP community to adopt PLMs as the
backbone for downstream tasks. In recent works on knowledge graph question
answering (KGQA), BERT or its variants have become necessary in their KGQA
models. However, there is still a lack of comprehensive research and comparison
of the performance of different PLMs in KGQA. To this end, we summarize two
basic KGQA frameworks based on PLMs without additional neural network modules
to compare the performance of nine PLMs in terms of accuracy and efficiency. In
addition, we present three benchmarks for larger-scale KGs based on the popular
SimpleQuestions benchmark to investigate the scalability of PLMs. We carefully
analyze the results of all PLMs-based KGQA basic frameworks on these benchmarks
and two other popular datasets, WebQuestionSP and FreebaseQA, and find that
knowledge distillation techniques and knowledge enhancement methods in PLMs are
promising for KGQA. Furthermore, we test ChatGPT, which has drawn a great deal
of attention in the NLP community, demonstrating its impressive capabilities
and limitations in zero-shot KGQA. We have released the code and benchmarks to
promote the use of PLMs on KGQA. | [
0.0529667661,
0.0197319221,
0.0089076236,
0.0397618674,
-0.0287696254,
0.0016098479,
-0.0194200743,
0.009916869,
0.0545025915,
-0.0558783226,
-0.0281850249,
0.0148563357,
-0.0365216918,
0.0269067511,
0.0181815326,
-0.0119090509,
0.0354683325,
0.0030334748,
0.0138276536,
-0.0223194212,
0.0325965658,
0.0156972762,
-0.0061960388,
0.0043856013,
0.0137335574,
-0.0245491471,
-0.01421359,
0.0164867565,
-0.0176294502,
-0.0019239746,
0.0253363121,
0.041403953,
0.0118538598,
-0.0045723096,
0.0000018705,
-0.0371563174,
0.0066198539,
-0.0015139206,
-0.045910161,
0.0374336727,
-0.0608009957,
0.0381377265,
0.058663059,
0.0211628191,
-0.059179578,
-0.0288566314,
0.012945707,
0.036312338,
0.0845864639,
0.0628352761,
0.00683928,
-0.024292795,
0.0171774533,
-0.007113832,
-0.0088845911,
-0.0604779273,
0.0400992371,
0.0144949518,
0.0228117164,
-0.0124244373,
-0.030977672,
0.0201870576,
0.0283751655,
0.0335065797,
0.0104550077,
0.0333176889,
-0.0805730969,
0.0166419968,
-0.0070293825,
0.1391069591,
-0.0086599011,
-0.0052799955,
0.0077452492,
-0.0049779187,
-0.0150000881,
0.0074502649,
-0.0356497504,
-0.0269394517,
0.0079527274,
0.0041241664,
-0.0519770011,
-0.0148052238,
0.0251589008,
0.0112592988,
-0.0412419923,
0.0651467964,
0.0190681182,
-0.0190459769,
0.0376096927,
0.0235254355,
-0.060043335,
-0.0637374595,
0.0217579473,
0.0741128996,
0.0133523215,
0.0327152386,
-0.0324244536,
-0.0026747731,
0.0139324171,
-0.0546333045,
0.0083661005,
0.021982763,
-0.0080171246,
0.0701426268,
-0.0344395041,
0.0613400675,
-0.0051035429,
0.0414595865,
-0.0610085279,
-0.0338019319,
-0.0431502871,
-0.0151535515,
-0.0730133429,
0.074930422,
-0.0213056114,
-0.069139488,
-0.0174102075,
0.0330896229,
0.0184276812,
-0.030322738,
0.0525288209,
0.0451657996,
0.0333797596,
-0.0011213697,
-0.0313844085,
0.0699531138,
-0.0681605935,
0.0105467103,
-0.0268269163,
-0.0551569387,
-0.0346595943,
-0.0104607474,
0.0549741462,
-0.0203636251,
0.0255832672,
0.0411352515,
0.0203589778,
-0.0444814079,
-0.0299180802,
-0.0259812959,
-0.011987621,
-0.0344879441,
-0.0057072639,
-0.0576188117,
0.0721562356,
0.0033099363,
-0.0105231907,
-0.000167064,
0.0231318362,
-0.0043467819,
-0.054044608,
0.0598492883,
-0.022500772,
0.0216086153,
-0.0060368273,
0.0050327545,
-0.0388130285,
0.053027615,
0.0089411791,
-0.0013536663,
0.0486394577,
-0.0075439336,
-0.006307038,
0.0476182401,
0.0570213869,
0.0091416966,
0.040484,
0.0526545085,
-0.0451336876,
-0.0026399984,
-0.0032911901,
0.0503696501,
-0.0503890961,
-0.0051973229,
0.0332376473,
0.0442594737,
0.0104792509,
0.0097904615,
0.0151132299,
0.0272064116,
0.0486646518,
-0.0028520613,
-0.0194946676,
-0.0193667598,
-0.0503445007,
0.0076165027,
0.0307845417,
0.0014654272,
-0.052533485,
-0.0119088739,
0.0181379672,
-0.0105081256,
0.029737087,
0.0290923864,
0.0258926265,
0.0278478973,
-0.0291327294,
0.0635442659,
0.033783447,
-0.0028825502,
0.0015284691,
-0.0241320692,
0.0106368177,
0.0414676256,
0.0491520464,
-0.0268881023,
-0.0762162954,
0.0317303762,
-0.0106952731,
-0.016058255,
0.0251122303,
-0.0122092748,
0.0268259104,
-0.0377435572,
-0.0283963997,
-0.0303710215,
-0.0200333279,
-0.0074490374,
0.0743378773,
0.0269174948,
0.0111085372,
-0.0856832936,
0.0127567388,
0.0031786803,
-0.0200538132,
-0.0235700179,
0.0026558684,
0.0024927526,
0.0069893915,
0.0160736181,
-0.0045702192,
0.0295286663,
0.0302751064,
-0.0061770054,
-0.0196234416,
-0.015057466,
-0.0413976572,
-0.1258659959,
0.0486226939,
0.0100573367,
0.0081120282,
0.0345938392,
-0.067832917,
-0.0375319868,
-0.0022092159,
-0.0174622294,
0.06512665,
-0.0325841829,
-0.0047956412,
0.0333536454,
-0.0045064637,
-0.0136171039,
0.0390383564,
-0.0157719646,
0.013341262,
-0.0293061342,
0.0084837927,
-0.0021825589,
-0.0111074075,
-0.0286858194,
-0.0143473689,
-0.0011035861,
0.0119501501,
0.0122441724,
0.0115708383,
-0.0652107447,
0.0314213894,
-0.1250594556,
0.0234580357,
-0.0144150229,
0.0321858451,
0.0372824445,
0.04210601,
-0.0000029023,
-0.0380192809,
-0.0624421611,
0.0262221582,
0.0123685496,
0.0263253488,
0.0405008793,
0.0052123698,
0.030842755,
-0.0372520685,
-0.0322175659,
0.0136698885,
0.0758557841,
-0.0142156864,
-0.0055413903,
0.0230892915,
0.0041507059,
-0.0788215846,
0.0477037393,
0.0109339841,
-0.0215224419,
-0.0101779988,
-0.0335887596,
0.0408550873,
-0.010322405,
-0.0308433417,
-0.0057298015,
-0.0067781433,
-0.0022266698,
-0.0504479706,
0.0236155428,
-0.0461349413,
-0.0036943408,
-0.0056209923,
0.0168720298,
0.0163490456,
0.0401207507,
-0.0114907036,
-0.0396420993,
-0.0450617075,
0.005204075,
0.0145396562,
0.0066252071,
-0.0432950668,
0.0014942883,
-0.0095043862,
-0.0204249211,
-0.0392410941,
-0.0006698727,
0.066136688,
-0.0166260507,
-0.0003067326,
-0.0288356375,
0.0100531457,
-0.0493868217,
0.0603111535,
0.0175922364,
0.0007173028,
-0.0222424883,
-0.0113563566,
-0.0262648799,
-0.01661296,
-0.0185008831,
-0.0471642874,
0.0013739655,
-0.0082796616,
0.0322722532,
0.0186186396,
-0.0087505532,
-0.0359402485,
-0.0247283429,
-0.0390432663,
0.0357435085,
0.0142446375,
0.0059332722,
0.0440094844,
0.0176932514,
-0.0099330582,
0.0158605594,
-0.0141269192,
0.0234549232,
-0.0284890365,
0.0966963246,
0.0525866374,
0.013449885,
0.0284225028,
-0.0009749818,
0.0091347741,
0.0667607337,
0.0317038,
-0.0224990733,
-0.0161585659,
-0.0009870199,
-0.0102241207,
-0.0582928285,
-0.0084841112,
-0.0278802756,
0.0613281205,
-0.024447795,
-0.0018430375,
0.1205092892,
0.0273986254,
0.0210175719,
-0.0027964332,
0.034107361,
0.0150942784,
-0.0017647011,
0.0191529244,
-0.0955860689,
-0.0499497391,
-0.0326514542,
0.0242887009,
0.0401128493,
-0.054410886,
-0.002263108,
-0.1100068241,
-0.0271576103,
-0.0216765366,
-0.0202380288,
-0.0368999131,
-0.0289073177,
-0.0004931362,
0.0108272554,
-0.0080990801,
0.0092595955,
-0.009796463,
0.0403619036,
0.0199023653,
-0.0406831913,
-0.0213799942,
0.0548690706,
-0.0603906512,
0.0270529855,
0.0148861706,
0.024844287,
0.0002921335,
0.0135482224,
0.028902676,
-0.0313888304,
-0.0119626187,
-0.0138349598,
0.0299702585,
-0.0098442202,
-0.0252543334,
-0.0274822731,
-0.0223721508,
-0.0503814667,
0.0011384073,
0.0080039846,
0.0635005087,
-0.0064882585,
-0.0583716407,
0.0106429216,
0.0038840612,
-0.0306011103,
0.0691963956,
0.059765812,
0.0084722908,
-0.0746776164,
0.0109851966,
-0.0150711779,
-0.05172728,
-0.0096323844,
0.0199034102,
-0.0119927498,
0.0506492779,
-0.080939889,
-0.0630164444,
0.0792504102,
0.004452738,
-0.0360972323,
-0.0090468116,
0.0264769904,
0.0303297322,
-0.0453077666,
0.0272750035,
-0.0317348465,
-0.0130369151,
-0.0311263949,
-0.0249176975,
0.0128089329,
0.0046969359,
-0.0304975044,
-0.008824721,
-0.0747608468,
-0.0587002523,
-0.0169998314,
0.0420749113,
0.0118042175,
0.0317451619,
-0.0505889803,
-0.0294940174,
0.0527219884,
0.0073285759,
-0.0320128277,
0.0140693542,
0.0197666623,
-0.0044096401,
-0.0038537306,
0.0332833491,
-0.0624376275,
-0.009395605,
0.0178170111,
0.0946249142,
-0.0261866953,
-0.0541179106,
0.0030921258,
0.0618138835,
0.0198092945,
0.0451479703,
0.0217280127,
-0.0333936103,
-0.0026265301,
-0.0104556838,
-0.0016939214,
-0.0571715198,
-0.0185409784,
0.0142114032,
-0.0049478575,
-0.030103201,
-0.0166793987,
-0.0237065032,
0.0376825333,
-0.0191418901,
-0.0259238984,
0.0527631119,
-0.0379923508,
0.05450207,
-0.0302347839,
-0.0288116913,
0.0430110581,
0.007706291,
0.0100870263,
-0.0363440737,
0.022388,
0.0130908359,
-0.0137977824,
-0.0342036486,
0.0239239261,
-0.058984261,
-0.0873208717,
-0.0076297834,
0.0527494475,
0.0485923178,
0.0198116656,
0.014578877,
0.003817847,
-0.0199185815,
-0.0310471281,
0.0049113692,
0.0038006657,
0.0050908346,
0.058897201,
0.0253358316,
-0.0055474052,
0.0278453901,
0.0830517262,
0.0249092728,
0.063249208,
0.0232331119,
-0.0082469564,
-0.0253381561,
-0.0290486384,
0.0020108726,
0.0341442302,
-0.0159173775,
0.0325555131,
-0.0225321148,
-0.0668812096,
0.0020969675,
-0.0371770002,
-0.0470951125,
0.0111174164,
0.0568475686,
0.0322279073,
0.0432268083,
-0.0265655946,
-0.0192480385,
0.0456617922,
-0.040781796,
-0.0128321331,
0.0447139926,
-6.435037377e-33,
-0.0057005142,
-0.0025386433,
0.0227427464,
-0.0236974265,
-0.0465996526,
0.0153652532,
-0.0384089164,
-0.022407515,
-0.0523419492,
-0.0002228768,
-0.0130819874,
0.0029192585,
-0.0102054011,
0.0376599431,
-0.0586467944,
-0.0593002662,
0.0033217527,
-0.0124985976,
0.0136660077,
0.0285081044,
0.0060595241,
0.0754573494,
0.0566373244,
0.0168445446,
-0.0221126638,
-0.0507049896,
0.0265239011,
0.0274746269,
0.0120150913,
0.0425465256,
-0.0321377553,
0.0332200192,
0.0308278706,
0.0029952938,
0.0072998186,
0.0365048237,
-0.1152929291,
-0.0651864707,
0.0297795106,
0.0101712383,
-0.0701005235,
0.0304495394,
0.0478643142,
-0.0013910112,
0.0661860257,
0.006065446,
0.006600088,
0.0114201438,
-0.0190276187,
-0.0408700444,
-0.0175658651,
0.0209622774,
-0.0113911238,
-0.0288904496,
-0.0113793099,
0.0156365205,
-0.0284759123,
-0.0029639502,
-0.0479213148,
-0.0093446756,
0.0517394841,
0.0009169822,
-0.0071007819,
0.030540606,
0.014902343,
0.0268635359,
-0.0130829765,
-0.0242091659,
-0.0362439491,
0.0165748671,
0.0260462407,
0.0516608506,
0.0126758255,
-0.0177779756,
0.0019059087,
0.0337908305,
-0.0829283893,
0.003019888,
0.019516794,
0.0164916944,
-0.0342159308,
-0.0216753017,
-0.0074911779,
-0.0377160832,
-0.0350098535,
0.0228263997,
-0.0273682047,
-0.0210087579,
0.0287141092,
-0.0009937841,
-0.0308541004,
0.0159532838,
0.0043406361,
-0.0722493604,
0.0066652694,
0.065080598,
-0.0045392714,
-0.0003830269,
0.0015073383,
0.0585720204,
-0.0786348432,
0.0238204375,
0.0260389615,
-0.0430738181,
-0.0332520641,
0.0283112265,
-0.0119867446,
-0.0056943162,
-0.0265107136,
-0.0167855639,
-0.0471003018,
0.0073064109,
-0.0220933761,
0.0300237704,
0.0306351706,
0.0664501041,
-0.013856235,
0.0223719273,
0.0432535224,
0.0199323017,
-0.0198530387,
0.0231943652,
0.0293339901,
0.0292393435,
-0.0229278766,
0.0073354677,
-0.038809482,
0.0313465372,
-0.0408862531,
-0.0589616187,
-0.020853091,
0.0077924049,
2.608e-7,
0.1005782932,
0.0294769742,
0.0445647277,
0.0313010514,
0.0054649543,
-0.0058975872,
0.012230237,
0.0372329019,
0.0101141287,
-0.015898928,
0.0288864318,
0.0698196441,
-0.0190239269,
0.0194419157,
-0.0628101751,
-0.0138791082,
-0.0715151057,
-0.04647981,
-0.0315907672,
-0.0318528377,
0.0634324774,
0.0447475798,
0.0428855978,
-0.0069964994,
-0.0339820758,
-0.0554333217,
0.0614134371,
0.0258355923,
0.0022949777,
0.0259773526,
0.0112733208,
0.0232608262,
-0.0057863784,
0.0373683758,
0.0031735764,
0.0233915895,
0.0343401991,
0.0559632368,
-0.0228288155,
-0.0503727347,
-0.0139004737,
-0.0384705327,
0.0327546671,
-0.0589044243,
0.1252115518,
-0.058020357,
-0.0082299588,
0.0102750035,
-0.0692463964,
-0.0333938487,
0.0212344825,
-0.0073750089,
-0.0128497947,
0.0177811738,
0.0226435307,
-0.0094525963,
-0.0303521995,
-0.0970071405,
-0.0038758807,
0.0004630461,
-0.0200760998,
-0.042544324,
-0.0083512086,
-0.0349798426,
0.0004986597,
-0.0310390107,
0.0280520059,
2.296131457e-34,
0.0239218865,
0.0008478316,
0.0273043048,
0.0113627333,
0.0101448977,
-0.0149243213,
-0.0059974059,
-0.0269462597,
0.016007578,
-0.1099304557,
0.0036873384
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.10330v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.10330v3 | Exploring Partial Knowledge Base Inference in Biomedical Entity Linking | 2023-03-18T04:31:07 | 2023-06-03T07:57:51 | Hongyi Yuan, Keming Lu, Zheng Yuan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Biomedical entity linking (EL) consists of named entity recognition (NER) and
named entity disambiguation (NED). EL models are trained on corpora labeled by
a predefined KB. However, it is a common scenario that only entities within a
subset of the KB are precious to stakeholders. We name this scenario partial
knowledge base inference: training an EL model with one KB and inferring on the
part of it without further training. In this work, we give a detailed
definition and evaluation procedures for this practically valuable but
significantly understudied scenario and evaluate methods from three
representative EL paradigms. We construct partial KB inference benchmarks and
witness a catastrophic degradation in EL performance due to dramatically
precision drop. Our findings reveal these EL paradigms can not correctly handle
unlinkable mentions (NIL), so they are not robust to partial KB inference. We
also propose two simple-and-effective redemption methods to combat the NIL
issue with little computational overhead. Codes are released at
https://github.com/Yuanhy1997/PartialKB-EL. | [
0.0716448203,
0.0228264257,
0.0230461713,
-0.0187967867,
0.0102693411,
0.0478758365,
-0.0242771469,
0.0338548347,
0.0372831672,
-0.0084542166,
-0.0182023793,
0.0360630676,
-0.0156983919,
-0.0092494264,
0.0338706374,
-0.0270953793,
0.0382479653,
0.0313768759,
0.0117550828,
-0.0171322413,
-0.0231870189,
-0.0002088513,
-0.0277299564,
-0.008380346,
0.0289626494,
0.0264109764,
0.0204583909,
0.0150731327,
0.0454015061,
-0.0469431393,
-0.0060046013,
0.013687118,
-0.0422886498,
0.0211444087,
0.0000019775,
-0.0656873956,
-0.0405815616,
0.0387405045,
-0.0859980211,
-0.0059442972,
0.012586779,
-0.02685,
0.0211127587,
-0.0228627808,
0.0019197878,
-0.0410143808,
0.0457060523,
0.0665532947,
-0.0056920405,
0.036831256,
0.0082944119,
0.0053393315,
0.0094428044,
-0.0280887149,
-0.0053845788,
-0.022929322,
0.0416693874,
-0.0283281635,
0.0216073357,
-0.0132357329,
0.0092498884,
0.0641189516,
-0.009615127,
0.0644514263,
0.0233638454,
0.0509840958,
-0.0721376911,
-0.0158483163,
0.0336185619,
0.0879411921,
0.0169220455,
-0.0131336059,
0.0663740337,
0.0129098156,
-0.0191617422,
0.0048823333,
-0.021804342,
-0.0009017086,
-0.0478765182,
-0.0044123973,
-0.0288497992,
0.0202020183,
0.059192609,
0.0118595548,
-0.001621503,
0.0010873482,
-0.0089657586,
-0.0310159102,
0.0159463082,
0.0168625843,
-0.0030847676,
-0.0477593057,
0.0365072973,
-0.0135201989,
0.0212055556,
0.0390342772,
-0.0228740219,
0.0321499705,
0.0636812449,
-0.0484739803,
-0.0571843833,
-0.019096138,
-0.015247927,
0.0411823578,
-0.0665423274,
-0.0401105098,
-0.032303907,
-0.0023048657,
0.0433719791,
-0.0337992758,
-0.0216869563,
0.0153762661,
0.0016458778,
0.0504828878,
-0.036331892,
0.0047353813,
-0.0675303712,
-0.036382582,
-0.0184023585,
0.0679255724,
0.0069291168,
0.0121453051,
-0.009392187,
-0.0002240856,
-0.0308592189,
0.0205168519,
0.0013210175,
-0.0203740411,
-0.0485128239,
-0.0483130626,
-0.0048522209,
-0.0183205772,
-0.0061966903,
-0.0689601749,
0.0293141007,
0.0759883597,
0.0642981306,
-0.0447398759,
-0.0330375358,
-0.0433044471,
0.0226610433,
-0.0480998121,
-0.0056080455,
-0.0384867229,
0.0346321017,
0.0159755554,
-0.0090098763,
-0.0655975193,
0.0009579094,
-0.0293947682,
-0.0812792704,
0.0994084775,
-0.0795514211,
-0.067444317,
-0.0194440782,
0.023792021,
0.0109751737,
0.0393185839,
0.0177540518,
-0.021731874,
0.0107903825,
0.0323996842,
-0.0632976517,
-0.0190196857,
0.0825031549,
-0.0520800464,
0.0603779294,
0.0058574933,
-0.0053295656,
0.0439093225,
0.0072584273,
0.0627828017,
-0.0353887863,
-0.0330533087,
-0.0097599551,
0.0200363137,
0.0083972951,
-0.0104231639,
0.03615769,
0.0101405159,
0.0176621135,
-0.0432762615,
-0.0633458495,
0.0138039384,
-0.0228947122,
0.0188572835,
0.021687299,
0.0556591265,
0.0008328139,
0.0115107913,
-0.0105168056,
-0.0074958373,
-0.0162287112,
0.0297966059,
0.0718287677,
0.005999899,
-0.0223787539,
0.1158760488,
0.0684335232,
-0.0211154502,
0.0092189154,
-0.0172093064,
-0.0273670815,
0.0285353977,
0.0487589203,
-0.0190397166,
-0.0542845279,
-0.0194702968,
-0.0379875302,
0.0278064422,
-0.0118148113,
-0.0449904688,
0.0353327654,
-0.0210372861,
-0.0102865035,
0.0291652977,
0.0253762249,
-0.0015451789,
0.0286060274,
0.0603778288,
0.0252929479,
-0.0922950953,
0.034284886,
0.0172812454,
-0.044407919,
-0.0000118284,
-0.0264328793,
0.0342996828,
0.0147298854,
0.0387211703,
-0.0046540219,
-0.0069295513,
0.0505238548,
-0.0061503146,
-0.0218412057,
-0.0023727894,
0.0529813468,
-0.0753991306,
0.0091529535,
-0.0042181513,
0.0038531495,
-0.0374091081,
-0.0254310779,
-0.049750343,
0.0058154017,
0.0429898687,
0.0564433821,
0.0014573038,
0.0092599774,
0.0208711494,
-0.0163239725,
-0.0155093139,
0.0406777076,
-0.0273895003,
0.0541036166,
0.0160822291,
-0.0528947785,
0.0255860928,
-0.0369118489,
-0.0599591359,
-0.0001634806,
0.0170382578,
-0.0358115137,
-0.0003036922,
-0.0488518439,
-0.0640707687,
0.0033210428,
-0.0657448396,
0.0394658074,
0.0326697901,
0.0525482856,
0.0013019133,
0.0415096544,
-0.0039217235,
-0.0509555489,
0.0432930514,
-0.028037414,
-0.0264083929,
0.0018032097,
-0.0090793865,
0.034290839,
0.005230715,
-0.0141749298,
0.0049472828,
-0.0223053619,
0.0364412144,
0.0047188816,
-0.0738515928,
-0.0241499078,
0.0173636228,
-0.053874217,
-0.0000279773,
-0.0077683763,
0.0444403887,
-0.0155128222,
0.0380959138,
-0.0405838564,
0.0307902098,
-0.0499745198,
0.0106828082,
0.0169632174,
-0.0046715066,
-0.0667572021,
0.0250930339,
0.0047823736,
0.0179878883,
-0.0139764799,
-0.0391030498,
-0.0220206007,
0.0534797907,
-0.0308359582,
-0.0154122142,
-0.0267810486,
-0.0011835583,
0.0106342882,
0.0101087233,
-0.0095919054,
0.0705927983,
0.0083320113,
0.0023072904,
-0.0041536558,
-0.0242726281,
0.0596530065,
-0.0252147671,
0.0383188352,
-0.0221469756,
0.0179616567,
0.0126609923,
0.0139586432,
0.0296100844,
0.0061489232,
0.0586351268,
-0.0258587413,
0.0118009318,
0.0752159357,
-0.0062755905,
-0.016212957,
0.04060008,
-0.0097486069,
0.0763439238,
0.0061143483,
-0.020989053,
-0.0353231691,
-0.0020467099,
-0.0533939004,
0.0056501194,
-0.0107959341,
-0.0149454325,
-0.0095550418,
0.0325968973,
0.0262954142,
0.0265060998,
0.046498891,
-0.008107529,
-0.0121247312,
-0.008299889,
0.0540491529,
-0.0603304543,
0.0624292381,
0.0037800749,
-0.0196451284,
0.0683748275,
0.027933415,
0.0019626913,
0.0144387772,
-0.0143308137,
-0.0057444926,
-0.0716031268,
-0.0338999778,
0.0068835695,
0.036934454,
-0.0369741507,
0.0132821957,
0.1061206907,
0.0184602831,
-0.051055029,
0.0028131616,
0.0353434421,
-0.0059806481,
-0.021586664,
0.0365274064,
-0.1051033139,
-0.0387660787,
-0.007472083,
0.0130521934,
-0.0199969038,
-0.101623863,
0.0037681193,
-0.0591674522,
-0.000059204,
-0.0396597162,
-0.0581677631,
-0.0132601419,
-0.0711225867,
0.0288450439,
-0.0559287257,
-0.0387301408,
0.0038576745,
0.0000711666,
0.0294412374,
-0.0018536785,
-0.0118091684,
-0.0821934491,
0.0179696735,
-0.0879997462,
0.077645503,
0.0042046122,
0.0284202117,
0.0102838548,
0.0326557271,
-0.0330348574,
-0.0407328755,
-0.0467391983,
-0.0099776443,
0.0982624069,
-0.0243172925,
0.0009312696,
-0.0109719988,
-0.0016354428,
-0.0211811289,
-0.0065199928,
-0.0122499913,
0.0359219089,
0.0040979325,
0.0124287643,
-0.0115178879,
-0.0479771979,
0.0103271818,
0.0758349374,
-0.0099915043,
0.0023609474,
-0.0213975683,
0.0300537609,
0.015371209,
0.0010186438,
0.036270678,
0.0132247601,
-0.1004323438,
-0.0200554598,
-0.0637361705,
-0.027126817,
0.0261781756,
0.0490306169,
-0.0145112006,
0.0282833539,
0.0395995192,
-0.0098353708,
-0.0687752813,
0.0599964298,
-0.012825002,
0.0021677616,
-0.022120662,
-0.0332650542,
0.0434369929,
0.0112857018,
-0.036166545,
0.0116090253,
-0.0406110473,
-0.0359818004,
-0.0164161958,
0.0336680077,
0.0202390514,
0.0527343713,
-0.0013735736,
-0.0125589808,
0.025589101,
0.057146538,
-0.0167767555,
0.0136765419,
-0.0172296297,
0.008307769,
-0.0234620497,
0.0297592469,
-0.0496645421,
-0.0043979948,
0.0345662273,
0.0379626527,
-0.0357721373,
0.0098133152,
-0.0115456963,
0.0267831534,
0.0370504409,
-0.0147732571,
-0.0026393153,
-0.0237851776,
0.0199289005,
0.0347216427,
0.0184349064,
-0.0290503837,
-0.0177955125,
0.0068862494,
0.0468487404,
-0.0192621667,
0.0128814792,
-0.0096048228,
0.021813862,
-0.0420776494,
-0.0253781322,
0.0487474911,
0.0111171333,
0.0522322543,
-0.0650857463,
0.0104541732,
0.001718264,
0.0526788794,
0.0526427738,
-0.0396248996,
-0.0170428287,
0.0104592517,
0.0142813027,
-0.0341105349,
0.026874233,
-0.019499179,
0.024500275,
0.0026571695,
0.0446918644,
0.0334722809,
0.0258416254,
0.0640852451,
-0.0035363785,
-0.0173908751,
0.0200746693,
0.0232833792,
-0.0275169499,
0.0061843954,
0.0493429974,
0.0032881764,
-0.0155691076,
0.033486601,
0.054268077,
0.0344345123,
0.101429686,
-0.0511287078,
-0.0353554897,
-0.0265272427,
-0.0292908661,
-0.0184287261,
-0.0160520673,
-0.0206265748,
0.0089336308,
-0.0461167917,
-0.0884132236,
0.0574453101,
-0.0213506892,
-0.0400093012,
0.0041270698,
0.0482848324,
0.0111859655,
0.0552453101,
-0.0535817742,
-0.0024507409,
-0.0135161104,
-0.00532836,
-0.0499179624,
-0.0069122589,
-6.290187821e-33,
-0.0251325388,
-0.0039888867,
0.0119123533,
-0.0327317975,
-0.0230737031,
0.0267487373,
-0.0268474892,
-0.0466004387,
-0.0254754312,
-0.0163313709,
-0.0107041849,
0.0188427586,
0.0028609009,
0.0006762542,
-0.0272770748,
-0.0267025717,
0.0374281555,
0.0409980118,
-0.018337287,
0.0031100293,
0.0557017475,
0.0655392632,
0.0607417561,
-0.0542483069,
0.0499004014,
0.0138058402,
0.0184745919,
-0.006052528,
0.008047414,
0.0434720404,
-0.0217838325,
0.0068861577,
-0.0002521684,
-0.0174220148,
0.0023772756,
-0.0450421646,
-0.1563698351,
0.0082641244,
0.0054484601,
0.0067654564,
0.0066278009,
-0.0103406599,
0.0515411422,
-0.0066316854,
0.0201836284,
-0.0090539176,
0.008480778,
0.0020302362,
-0.0414670855,
-0.0538229682,
-0.0073844194,
0.054187756,
0.0256640427,
0.0649284273,
0.0239079986,
-0.0341107808,
-0.0391156152,
0.0027913575,
-0.0564365573,
-0.0311025046,
0.0527360626,
-0.0067074294,
0.0178846493,
-0.0206434131,
0.0230872054,
0.0378560685,
0.0439043045,
-0.0204992238,
-0.0234612953,
0.0334756114,
-0.0286056045,
-0.0011474645,
0.0011573513,
0.0474997424,
0.0506169759,
0.0085242828,
-0.1025186703,
0.0269339159,
-0.0006164035,
0.0552219152,
-0.0393481478,
-0.0037961381,
-0.0349198915,
-0.0296721552,
-0.0510079823,
-0.0154245682,
-0.0075866221,
-0.044010967,
0.0092506716,
-0.0025491116,
-0.0454305373,
0.0573381446,
-0.0120407185,
-0.0321239568,
-0.0312744379,
0.0080096275,
0.0777392685,
0.0169451199,
0.0090319663,
-0.002884194,
-0.069244884,
-0.0125247659,
0.0260265041,
-0.0181508064,
0.0353932492,
0.0018313944,
0.0281905886,
-0.0326548778,
-0.0332975611,
0.0082198856,
0.0055198548,
-0.000353518,
-0.0222135615,
-0.0024067194,
0.0327354148,
0.0277338009,
0.0236900914,
-0.0184006039,
0.0550416335,
0.0011498748,
-0.0059490232,
0.0456790924,
0.024420118,
0.0146122854,
-0.0184625182,
-0.0010837817,
0.0002306139,
0.042089358,
-0.0578813553,
-0.0886401087,
0.011576931,
0.020232318,
2.84e-7,
0.0543271266,
-0.0115931015,
-0.0047196094,
-0.0305996053,
-0.0049844207,
-0.0226361454,
0.0572085641,
0.0100216968,
-0.0301464275,
-0.0242990497,
0.0067540072,
-0.0293791108,
0.0047802282,
0.0105844419,
-0.1024486497,
-0.048331961,
-0.0046349573,
-0.027594503,
-0.0137676913,
-0.035932932,
-0.0336649232,
0.0170341153,
-0.000891017,
-0.0034511969,
0.0168422256,
-0.014891671,
0.0398585275,
-0.0087053739,
0.0155727044,
0.0163638294,
0.030048158,
0.0234433822,
-0.0080032293,
0.056391608,
-0.0216349848,
0.0217803512,
-0.0049130805,
0.052772928,
-0.0050271205,
0.0040876744,
0.0143136568,
-0.0603600889,
0.0290674809,
0.0076571531,
0.0872393921,
-0.0460456721,
-0.0073476965,
0.0639888197,
-0.0190487355,
-0.0222432818,
-0.0096246703,
0.0032204634,
-0.0142752137,
0.0274072234,
0.0041552065,
-0.0141115896,
-0.0118140103,
-0.0905422866,
0.0166451186,
0.0517766513,
-0.0181001499,
-0.046393808,
0.0296397414,
-0.0315821543,
-0.0094334064,
-0.0830520242,
-0.0059380266,
2.301372049e-34,
-0.0001879978,
-0.0116179409,
-0.0133137368,
0.0304145701,
0.0065021231,
-0.0356539786,
-0.0466423407,
-0.0193771329,
-0.0051963781,
-0.0628987774,
0.0060656047
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.10328v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.10328v1 | Revisiting Automatic Question Summarization Evaluation in the Biomedical Domain | 2023-03-18T04:28:01 | 2023-03-18T04:28:01 | Hongyi Yuan, Yaoyun Zhang, Fei Huang, Songfang Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automatic evaluation metrics have been facilitating the rapid development of
automatic summarization methods by providing instant and fair assessments of
the quality of summaries. Most metrics have been developed for the general
domain, especially news and meeting notes, or other language-generation tasks.
However, these metrics are applied to evaluate summarization systems in
different domains, such as biomedical question summarization. To better
understand whether commonly used evaluation metrics are capable of evaluating
automatic summarization in the biomedical domain, we conduct human evaluations
of summarization quality from four different aspects of a biomedical question
summarization task. Based on human judgments, we identify different noteworthy
features for current automatic metrics and summarization systems as well. We
also release a dataset of our human annotations to aid the research of
summarization evaluation metrics in the biomedical domain. | [
0.0428807847,
-0.0107246898,
0.0363990441,
-0.0465853922,
-0.0086161857,
0.0328685865,
-0.0141957263,
-0.0099095795,
-0.0076664481,
-0.0143293785,
0.0057388041,
-0.0427566133,
0.0413203761,
-0.0074380012,
0.0292861648,
-0.0937020183,
0.01319448,
0.0207097456,
0.0164957847,
0.0316227339,
0.0260715578,
-0.0187791009,
-0.0217010211,
0.0579785481,
0.0332162231,
0.0023484421,
0.0456364714,
-0.0032778524,
0.0599415526,
-0.0449631773,
-0.0040744981,
0.0102982027,
-0.0369140469,
-0.0301051978,
0.0000015069,
-0.0655599013,
-0.0085064825,
0.0133671891,
0.0125747304,
0.0380305424,
0.0343644358,
-0.0359861068,
0.0148787424,
0.0271245968,
-0.0317633338,
-0.0212207064,
0.0052935714,
0.0105731292,
0.0682928711,
0.0353676826,
-0.0109369894,
0.0064250263,
0.0186870396,
-0.007927903,
-0.0232372768,
-0.0038032972,
-0.0148622785,
0.0220457632,
0.0332713462,
-0.0162096079,
0.0521526188,
0.0369037017,
-0.0063454034,
0.0086951237,
0.0306784827,
0.024949858,
-0.0576706119,
-0.0256601498,
0.0171796493,
0.0508407429,
0.0394374579,
0.0115530631,
0.0310675502,
0.0209875423,
0.0131837782,
0.0187577773,
-0.0766183436,
0.0356399007,
-0.0306966696,
-0.024683686,
-0.0286152381,
0.0415777341,
-0.0259049702,
0.024508534,
0.0046777884,
0.0052889292,
0.0030054022,
-0.0195131283,
-0.0320060663,
-0.0010890735,
-0.0291446038,
-0.0640233755,
0.0442126058,
0.0395765938,
-0.0074485387,
-0.0372267924,
-0.0146788433,
-0.0641390607,
0.0727361366,
-0.047563795,
-0.0073613641,
-0.0039204755,
-0.0030246694,
0.0168456305,
-0.0173386037,
0.0218587741,
0.0219807308,
0.0311057568,
-0.0600850731,
0.034813799,
-0.0129536474,
-0.0031544606,
-0.0103153577,
0.0371507071,
-0.0158518013,
-0.0131088709,
-0.0858768523,
-0.0133964987,
0.0178723987,
-0.0100226654,
-0.021343844,
0.0334852412,
-0.0024871705,
0.0084468126,
-0.0113491863,
0.0025402065,
-0.0630802065,
-0.0320135504,
0.0519216917,
0.0065709255,
-0.0064496254,
0.0219145138,
0.0231506694,
0.0347490348,
0.0029395784,
0.04356068,
-0.0143882986,
-0.0081182132,
0.0397841148,
-0.0501250774,
-0.013270908,
-0.0103386473,
-0.0232173726,
-0.055899065,
0.0069719153,
0.0311651509,
-0.0220867675,
0.0092318216,
0.0048301658,
0.0277515016,
-0.0323645957,
0.0107990364,
-0.0401577428,
0.0311190411,
0.0568240732,
0.0093709072,
0.0016130462,
-0.0061893826,
0.0507661402,
0.019196922,
0.0304092765,
0.0250185449,
0.0214099139,
-0.0174447894,
0.005941994,
-0.0346312746,
0.0348030478,
0.0194503386,
-0.0264779758,
0.0588529296,
-0.0181875192,
0.0900793746,
-0.0298831854,
0.0453845151,
0.035795562,
0.0911509991,
0.0171213727,
-0.006861221,
0.0230642352,
-0.00056174,
0.0420012847,
0.0715676174,
-0.0107039288,
0.0237354003,
-0.018222414,
0.0669156238,
0.0698013902,
0.0181181487,
0.0063828724,
-0.066965729,
-0.0250803549,
0.0159096587,
-0.0020822654,
-0.0131894415,
-0.0092078149,
0.0106215449,
-0.0221426636,
0.0176290441,
-0.0006502275,
-0.073176235,
0.0254026651,
-0.0324391313,
-0.0048428392,
0.0200664885,
0.0412516743,
-0.0335893258,
-0.0306048077,
-0.0042865393,
0.0028027627,
0.0211984869,
0.0227568317,
-0.0244194493,
-0.0112545434,
-0.03716572,
-0.0023359975,
0.0193701908,
-0.0006270344,
-0.044139199,
-0.029415803,
-0.020701699,
0.0390420072,
-0.0341674685,
-0.065672785,
0.0518336557,
-0.0079451287,
-0.0189960897,
-0.0185171831,
-0.0096519087,
0.0021190268,
0.0446328931,
0.0006756336,
0.0624075793,
0.0106367571,
-0.0315038823,
-0.0156551991,
0.0082773315,
-0.0291185435,
-0.0334008411,
0.0030761403,
-0.0843802765,
0.0047396421,
-0.0024469183,
0.0018061954,
-0.047901392,
-0.0177425258,
-0.0807416588,
-0.0324326716,
-0.0239552576,
0.0115808696,
0.0260948334,
-0.0363924168,
-0.0513523705,
0.0345276743,
0.0003920335,
0.0117489565,
0.0486418568,
-0.0761672258,
0.0336954258,
-0.0291161519,
-0.0173204783,
-0.0157121588,
-0.0005643491,
0.0066493629,
0.0545974858,
-0.0069861324,
-0.041598089,
-0.0205380637,
-0.1131674424,
0.0078407666,
-0.0114668459,
0.020228548,
0.0616069697,
0.0246227942,
0.0002660139,
-0.0123988548,
-0.0572876185,
-0.0643290654,
0.0201902892,
0.0343035758,
0.056344375,
0.0396927372,
0.0609191507,
-0.0805112869,
-0.026608238,
-0.0270328056,
0.0476519391,
0.0588585325,
-0.0182979144,
-0.0360262692,
0.0047501926,
-0.0355090499,
-0.0655157119,
0.0525512546,
-0.0281040501,
0.0395890176,
0.0266893636,
0.0467877313,
0.078886874,
0.0619609617,
-0.0147353997,
0.0458211191,
0.0351878926,
-0.0114807412,
-0.036944367,
-0.0434641093,
0.0201775748,
0.0544762239,
-0.0485105105,
0.0349941179,
0.0279222224,
0.0426105335,
0.014269446,
-0.0219301023,
0.0272305273,
-0.05751656,
-0.0054912558,
-0.0764375478,
-0.0141145987,
-0.0336934589,
0.0620718934,
-0.012431113,
0.0031811106,
0.0980367661,
0.0016645658,
0.0232374761,
-0.060985297,
0.0194751453,
-0.0515717454,
0.0103096161,
0.0037613665,
0.0286871027,
0.0014753318,
-0.0240421183,
-0.0320700966,
0.0081847059,
0.0440558307,
-0.0338335745,
0.0641511157,
-0.051989045,
-0.0029521072,
-0.0191606991,
-0.0241463315,
-0.0120608825,
-0.0025634945,
-0.0137531003,
0.0150483809,
0.0295529235,
0.0041812779,
-0.0227515176,
0.0329719447,
0.0543636531,
0.0562821515,
-0.0482514501,
-0.0058362824,
-0.0095830765,
0.0520316809,
0.0636832118,
0.0198442042,
0.0520370305,
-0.0384163186,
0.0295836814,
0.0463756397,
0.0082172519,
0.0106163612,
0.0384944938,
-0.01902752,
-0.0020806263,
-0.0709628463,
-0.0002106643,
0.0098430011,
0.0845933631,
-0.0452311374,
0.0095763979,
0.0796270594,
0.0320842005,
-0.013141864,
0.0003978054,
0.0125294952,
-0.0002411017,
-0.0175701082,
0.0112966709,
-0.0548434481,
-0.0054885042,
-0.0166258533,
0.0598651171,
-0.0036238951,
-0.0382438228,
0.0144546591,
-0.0321671441,
0.0031795222,
0.015550104,
-0.0877973884,
-0.0318609737,
-0.0525748543,
0.0070889457,
-0.0037413463,
0.006316307,
0.0259068068,
-0.0294077098,
0.0197033398,
0.0260577761,
-0.0923368111,
-0.011223889,
-0.052593492,
-0.0396336615,
-0.0009836432,
0.0785998851,
0.0329140499,
0.012780726,
0.0185109582,
0.0102347173,
-0.0313839205,
-0.0172727611,
0.0343113542,
0.0781382471,
0.01025178,
0.0152038718,
-0.0626037642,
0.0420532823,
0.0169867855,
0.0091674421,
0.0210621636,
0.0054617631,
0.000425185,
-0.0193069205,
-0.0707413927,
0.0510377921,
-0.0417034887,
0.0603415035,
0.0797344372,
-0.0157985669,
-0.0135064591,
-0.0014382887,
0.0373858176,
-0.0866058096,
-0.0258451141,
-0.0009850962,
-0.0415153466,
-0.0063287364,
-0.1165452451,
-0.0730784833,
0.0364144966,
-0.0572691262,
0.0057503236,
-0.0079407049,
0.0078818062,
0.0297473874,
-0.0474397987,
0.0245989617,
0.0585428365,
0.0010553871,
-0.0473800413,
-0.0274376385,
0.0552591421,
0.0102200918,
-0.021830285,
0.0340085998,
-0.0186068043,
-0.0058147167,
-0.0249239393,
0.0488357395,
0.0199750792,
-0.0191881508,
0.02542587,
-0.0242966879,
0.0295939092,
0.0149050783,
0.0144432271,
0.0120887505,
-0.0122068683,
0.0232571159,
-0.0248807911,
-0.0037985246,
-0.0457900651,
0.0323902555,
-0.0447798371,
0.038719207,
-0.0271725021,
-0.0508118831,
0.029562531,
0.0631180778,
0.0108171655,
-0.0473675802,
-0.0083875032,
-0.003190632,
-0.0403341241,
-0.0304588303,
-0.0008264686,
-0.0301284865,
0.0334142447,
-0.0084580444,
0.0413709022,
-0.0249747485,
0.0420881808,
-0.0509779081,
-0.0076964716,
-0.0390048884,
0.0324220955,
-0.0187961049,
0.0027510878,
-0.0312289167,
-0.009373554,
-0.0590305664,
-0.0418747999,
-0.0361277536,
0.0110257789,
0.0026514484,
-0.0014954992,
0.0220040958,
0.0267603435,
0.0224193633,
0.0653800219,
-0.0838327333,
0.0206001736,
-0.034205541,
0.0161826164,
0.0031491206,
-0.0187009238,
0.0681678578,
0.0285966564,
-0.0176788922,
-0.0208347365,
0.0428035818,
0.006352176,
0.0264501553,
-0.0328607857,
0.0205631983,
0.0278720502,
-0.0338659734,
0.0798738301,
-0.0445745401,
-0.0056857802,
-0.0066507002,
-0.0583260693,
-0.0480613969,
-0.015399171,
-0.0488477647,
0.014989757,
-0.0150214182,
-0.0217529237,
-0.0947630182,
0.0066939681,
0.0307758711,
0.0407585427,
0.030686656,
-0.0268282145,
0.0415678732,
0.004988221,
-0.0193213336,
-0.0244641583,
-0.0426348597,
0.0163917039,
-0.0471779443,
0.0247352086,
-0.012061853,
-4.983799603e-33,
-0.0260467436,
-0.0283123348,
-0.0295847636,
-0.0004431611,
-0.0309464801,
0.0244654398,
-0.070849143,
0.0193464924,
0.0143521624,
0.0254966691,
-0.0204570387,
-0.0296244472,
0.006841681,
0.0121323168,
0.0111436155,
-0.0097945025,
0.0195057653,
-0.0163259208,
-0.0509517454,
0.0297731534,
-0.0145160798,
0.0052020033,
0.0065615247,
-0.0311703105,
0.0498464257,
-0.0310986359,
-0.0069198692,
-0.0179521125,
0.0511562936,
0.0382896885,
-0.0071603744,
-0.0027286874,
0.0470847301,
-0.0148489047,
-0.0544060022,
0.0350943729,
-0.0515320897,
-0.0156044075,
0.0291177891,
-0.0552192703,
-0.0810879469,
-0.0312817208,
0.0475974791,
-0.026184082,
-0.0122080101,
-0.0215072725,
0.064074643,
-0.0424897969,
-0.017261032,
-0.0766589344,
-0.0116058877,
0.0377039015,
-0.0154806133,
-0.0371042117,
-0.0046897396,
0.0480891578,
-0.041354835,
0.0104150139,
0.0267186537,
0.0348081067,
0.0417601652,
0.0329935886,
-0.0001519061,
0.0119080748,
-0.0132657625,
0.0318725668,
0.0179833528,
0.0090786498,
-0.0216969214,
0.0296256095,
-0.0387646854,
0.0011281546,
0.0684344769,
0.0344611518,
0.0332459062,
0.0432991907,
-0.0549711175,
0.0978194624,
-0.068296954,
-0.0036395986,
-0.0058774371,
-0.0412749946,
-0.016085634,
0.0069074505,
-0.0256104283,
0.0171913411,
-0.0143555561,
-0.0212163404,
-0.0026996417,
-0.0168426782,
-0.0594219975,
-0.0088043204,
-0.014561791,
-0.0044832923,
0.0582224205,
-0.0431648158,
0.0066624582,
0.0258730259,
-0.0077627427,
-0.040857669,
-0.0368231907,
0.0597714931,
0.0109137045,
0.0421927273,
0.0488811359,
-0.0026240468,
0.0306952726,
-0.0365982838,
-0.0115927337,
0.0061411266,
0.027189726,
0.0124202361,
-0.0370765403,
-0.0061750235,
-0.0179033969,
0.0269441009,
0.0206099655,
0.030117007,
-0.0302303042,
0.017554922,
-0.0230813734,
0.0049806568,
0.0315303355,
0.0382808074,
-0.030015409,
0.0265442859,
-0.0150183281,
0.0540686585,
0.0066584866,
-0.0285931434,
-0.0078141224,
-0.0286161564,
2.148e-7,
0.0912558511,
0.0543517843,
0.0679461136,
-0.0153477713,
-0.0231253561,
0.0037112162,
0.0211248174,
0.0132281985,
0.0182012934,
-0.0020328898,
0.0474842489,
0.0096320165,
0.020735357,
0.0069465907,
-0.0997297317,
-0.0568681024,
-0.0840916336,
-0.0228710845,
0.0024164745,
-0.0253813509,
0.0735346079,
-0.0184741449,
-0.0792370737,
0.003058715,
-0.0158246215,
-0.0142895952,
0.0215273239,
-0.0033654154,
-0.0275416821,
0.0543529019,
0.0455674678,
0.0111157577,
0.0171946399,
0.0107435668,
-0.0114899781,
-0.0567003749,
0.1033693999,
0.0336271711,
0.013191211,
-0.0368738025,
0.0179798678,
0.0138030015,
0.0553833544,
-0.0023683643,
0.0240759607,
-0.0739213526,
-0.013526326,
-0.0174085852,
-0.0290067531,
-0.0052233529,
0.0383001082,
-0.0307984073,
-0.0501660854,
0.0628131106,
0.0055699339,
-0.0056493506,
0.0134589775,
-0.0442954898,
-0.0653708577,
0.0351382531,
0.011610142,
-0.0321634673,
-0.0017114349,
-0.0382229574,
-0.0439837091,
-0.070150122,
-0.0364480279,
1.488142099e-34,
0.072330609,
0.000102424,
-0.0038909577,
-0.0057682423,
0.0143762687,
-0.0293808281,
-0.0151019869,
-0.0105978167,
0.0261940863,
-0.0373659618,
0.0001665304
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.10311v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.10311v1 | On the rise of fear speech in online social media | 2023-03-18T02:46:49 | 2023-03-18T02:46:49 | Punyajoy Saha, Kiran Garimella, Narla Komal Kalyan, Saurabh Kumar Pandey, Pauras Mangesh Meher, Binny Mathew, Animesh Mukherjee | cs.SI | cs.SI, cs.CL, cs.CY | Recently, social media platforms are heavily moderated to prevent the spread
of online hate speech, which is usually fertile in toxic words and is directed
toward an individual or a community. Owing to such heavy moderation, newer and
more subtle techniques are being deployed. One of the most striking among these
is fear speech. Fear speech, as the name suggests, attempts to incite fear
about a target community. Although subtle, it might be highly effective, often
pushing communities toward a physical conflict. Therefore, understanding their
prevalence in social media is of paramount importance. This article presents a
large-scale study to understand the prevalence of 400K fear speech and over
700K hate speech posts collected from Gab.com. Remarkably, users posting a
large number of fear speech accrue more followers and occupy more central
positions in social networks than users posting a large number of hate speech.
They can also reach out to benign users more effectively than hate speech users
through replies, reposts, and mentions. This connects to the fact that, unlike
hate speech, fear speech has almost zero toxic content, making it look
plausible. Moreover, while fear speech topics mostly portray a community as a
perpetrator using a (fake) chain of argumentation, hate speech topics hurl
direct multitarget insults, thus pointing to why general users could be more
gullible to fear speech. Our findings transcend even to other platforms
(Twitter and Facebook) and thus necessitate using sophisticated moderation
policies and mass awareness to combat fear speech. | [
0.0882464722,
0.0152612785,
-0.033774022,
-0.0002456679,
-0.0341929011,
0.0115616471,
-0.0001025662,
-0.0147191724,
0.0156674869,
-0.0141601451,
0.0113942958,
-0.0028675462,
-0.0014010812,
0.0142662395,
0.0103943581,
-0.0421340317,
0.0031347719,
0.0425714031,
0.0276103299,
-0.0119597036,
0.0839586034,
0.0179249421,
-0.0250294171,
0.0294492189,
-0.0276109818,
-0.0027995212,
0.0587371811,
-0.0020073715,
0.0548640527,
-0.0389611199,
0.0238280315,
0.0123633081,
0.0266190898,
0.0576309711,
0.0000018727,
-0.0411096178,
0.0170854926,
-0.0194387473,
-0.0192444175,
-0.0310231373,
0.081948407,
-0.0208101347,
0.0125874495,
0.0505984426,
-0.0234418064,
0.0096901525,
0.0438468046,
0.0335953496,
0.0467225015,
0.0390839018,
-0.0213397536,
-0.0585108139,
-0.0001362865,
0.046590291,
-0.0114870584,
0.0779169276,
0.0100691393,
-0.0660742149,
0.0014136245,
-0.0089197662,
0.0393404104,
0.0254081767,
0.0180666037,
0.0011911136,
0.0187502299,
-0.0343338475,
-0.0276125986,
-0.0721946433,
0.0253307894,
0.0331571549,
-0.0151305106,
-0.0297768395,
0.0384486318,
0.0129639534,
-0.0073743276,
0.0576493815,
-0.038586095,
0.0332564637,
-0.0327189155,
-0.0025242462,
-0.0296540894,
0.0466934964,
0.0456171036,
0.0549113415,
0.0528872274,
0.0257619359,
-0.0264652185,
0.0128463581,
-0.012695889,
-0.0629924759,
-0.0217685793,
0.0037670648,
0.0504126474,
0.0069713839,
-0.0007248853,
0.0251888651,
-0.0347622596,
-0.0662285686,
0.0336548127,
-0.0848397091,
-0.0415509231,
0.0313076898,
0.0211795736,
0.0151860202,
0.0296014175,
-0.0212488025,
-0.0062759076,
-0.0102004921,
0.0421704128,
0.0363812447,
-0.0141842589,
0.0386440344,
0.0057653929,
-0.0285900086,
0.0626291409,
0.0041056494,
-0.0411010794,
-0.0222360045,
-0.071681805,
-0.0062649436,
-0.0496603921,
0.0133270575,
0.0158278737,
0.0228602588,
0.009059147,
-0.0020819781,
-0.0332078673,
0.0001185414,
-0.016951846,
-0.0875842944,
0.0303092897,
0.002292359,
0.0306253713,
-0.0100920349,
-0.0145862522,
0.0360629894,
0.0259414613,
0.0010274213,
-0.0094330646,
-0.0464396328,
-0.0135907233,
-0.0051296502,
0.0070196711,
-0.059658207,
0.0224805232,
0.0113476506,
-0.0340021625,
-0.0213921182,
0.0225122757,
0.0378243215,
-0.0464572757,
0.0543765537,
0.0048624482,
0.0149121871,
0.0627628788,
0.0568892099,
0.0017330358,
0.0141253155,
-0.010289575,
0.0495275594,
0.0451930165,
0.0144383181,
0.029193392,
0.0279713515,
0.0480232984,
0.0180583484,
0.0351369232,
-0.0035611163,
-0.0411111861,
-0.0716938972,
-0.0223310981,
-0.0024526101,
0.0114105465,
-0.0216062609,
0.0504766032,
0.0392442793,
-0.0570736937,
-0.0105228256,
0.0419779718,
0.0523882061,
-0.0024204729,
-0.0641734451,
-0.0349651612,
-0.0526601784,
-0.0586414486,
-0.0633615255,
0.034250088,
0.0637410358,
-0.0121512972,
0.0245277267,
-0.0422679149,
0.0015337048,
0.0731761605,
-0.0270006023,
-0.0121875415,
0.0041884072,
0.0017879498,
0.0125769833,
0.0559160709,
0.0049825781,
0.0077206613,
-0.0124862893,
-0.0075847036,
-0.0098723974,
-0.0242578462,
0.0320489854,
0.0081982631,
-0.0496120192,
0.0383832343,
0.0467389748,
0.0209749322,
0.0197713356,
-0.0384728387,
-0.0057442025,
0.0051203961,
0.0412888788,
0.0055108354,
-0.0076158699,
0.0612163022,
0.0119778486,
0.0024978158,
0.0482040867,
-0.052359309,
-0.0157154985,
0.0372287855,
0.0107117696,
-0.054106649,
0.0216957815,
0.0687106103,
0.015203435,
0.0024455574,
-0.0309744906,
0.020054793,
0.0246545039,
-0.0558472201,
0.0053804261,
-0.0314999036,
0.0776766613,
0.0277110301,
-0.0301342495,
-0.0026312633,
0.027398577,
0.0136543754,
0.0651025474,
0.1072433069,
-0.0195056964,
-0.0015650968,
0.0257339235,
-0.0534410216,
-0.0558069609,
-0.0091952439,
0.0075118132,
0.0682544708,
-0.0344356857,
0.0059353369,
0.0160656273,
-0.0997624695,
0.021594001,
0.0643882453,
-0.0085405577,
-0.0623807646,
-0.0382652469,
0.0190798528,
0.0143996496,
-0.0815773457,
-0.0444762781,
0.024391273,
-0.0191552173,
-0.0278704856,
-0.0301589575,
-0.0052061314,
0.0608982556,
0.0008565156,
-0.0062924791,
0.0265209991,
-0.0140894903,
-0.0089495815,
0.0278566368,
0.0438024625,
-0.0170906372,
-0.0252845641,
-0.0282472167,
-0.0200049877,
0.02424022,
-0.0378294736,
0.0257273335,
0.0495115072,
-0.0828530937,
0.0757806152,
0.0259630252,
-0.0664460212,
-0.0061026555,
-0.020803269,
-0.0376027301,
0.0398691073,
-0.0045298361,
-0.0007314887,
-0.0512001216,
0.0732594803,
0.0836647153,
0.0053293672,
0.070420593,
-0.0073283571,
-0.0517193452,
-0.0432526544,
-0.0054366086,
-0.0429222845,
-0.0366072357,
-0.0265061855,
0.0399002247,
0.0840443,
-0.0056283041,
-0.0315894596,
0.0367912836,
-0.0841419026,
-0.0392577648,
-0.0455686711,
-0.0576634966,
0.0001530866,
0.0014651124,
-0.0560211278,
-0.0347061977,
-0.002553161,
0.0243146103,
0.043517638,
0.0412226282,
-0.0418199748,
0.0295593105,
0.0157310832,
0.045504842,
0.0428759642,
-0.016568372,
-0.0025305334,
0.0401995406,
-0.055633273,
0.0605666898,
-0.0302130766,
-0.0500934273,
-0.0068793506,
0.0266386699,
0.022710152,
-0.0172068365,
-0.0413950905,
-0.0734639466,
-0.0623900853,
-0.0282542873,
0.0185708031,
-0.0186768025,
-0.0426371023,
-0.0316658877,
0.06219019,
-0.048126556,
0.0187425576,
-0.0308031943,
0.0538928546,
-0.0079892064,
-0.0129361404,
-0.0103553925,
0.0719087869,
-0.0077419113,
-0.05215149,
0.0760728046,
-0.0124811875,
0.0184756052,
-0.0126536023,
-0.0115249362,
-0.0112696858,
0.024041893,
0.0244921353,
0.0107403742,
0.0297528822,
0.0166158117,
0.0283715855,
0.0330481306,
0.0207550321,
0.0334959589,
-0.000657185,
-0.0213134419,
0.0477470942,
0.0169384778,
-0.0218429398,
-0.0589287914,
0.0331141166,
-0.0392656922,
0.0263280366,
-0.0624510944,
-0.0172388759,
-0.0181167591,
-0.0260818657,
0.0120451245,
-0.02335619,
-0.0112275658,
0.0025103579,
0.0028355513,
0.0246770605,
0.0149919949,
0.0029280083,
-0.0290342923,
-0.003059984,
0.0111557916,
-0.0134850284,
-0.104664959,
0.0324377976,
-0.001330064,
-0.0465395153,
0.0194756482,
0.0041474332,
0.0549040437,
-0.0155694038,
0.0080522634,
0.0378695242,
0.0054835845,
-0.0258611143,
-0.0286835879,
0.071349591,
0.0200420991,
-0.0299843717,
-0.0583050512,
0.0740883946,
0.0100737009,
-0.0203560721,
0.0136051644,
0.015067975,
0.027944386,
-0.0152435508,
-0.0479270406,
0.0547518805,
0.011078544,
0.0051345984,
0.0339208618,
-0.0270544309,
0.0647338033,
-0.0719286948,
0.0091406517,
-0.0158265457,
-0.099413231,
-0.0208735634,
0.0069681224,
-0.0231647976,
-0.0069573368,
-0.013977482,
0.0198861901,
0.0021555054,
0.033428181,
-0.0375787653,
0.0315060169,
-0.0385033749,
-0.0343028791,
-0.0024954116,
0.0045981864,
0.0359790362,
0.0081955362,
0.0025672039,
-0.0441788696,
-0.0054763411,
-0.0397855975,
0.0391124263,
-0.0430531055,
-0.0210291184,
0.0931392461,
0.003396522,
0.0123408521,
0.0120921079,
-0.0003684931,
-0.0081746113,
0.0868645087,
0.0103798378,
-0.0326975062,
0.0051604286,
0.0187501833,
0.0045445529,
0.0487717614,
-0.0185654387,
0.0469455235,
-0.0117434915,
0.0601274371,
-0.0793134198,
-0.0486290902,
0.0313521214,
-0.0332642533,
-0.0115469964,
0.0161741227,
0.0150266914,
-0.0182643626,
-0.0030459478,
-0.0540994257,
0.0051685539,
-0.0340765975,
0.0260587987,
-0.0084156487,
0.019323051,
-0.0015918377,
-0.0453260317,
-0.0345270969,
-0.0544198416,
0.0235705245,
-0.0478083529,
0.0150577035,
0.0247834064,
0.0073596193,
0.0505381003,
-0.0173453949,
0.019202603,
0.0666012391,
-0.0243737269,
-0.0131104589,
-0.0045747324,
-0.0130376723,
-0.0126263797,
-0.0175745059,
0.0456101298,
-0.0199350584,
-0.0022134848,
-0.0606192015,
-0.0052426071,
-0.0276077818,
-0.0385377705,
-0.0216745343,
0.0676401705,
0.0215360634,
-0.0148168607,
0.0004891643,
0.0029547892,
-0.0387112945,
-0.061827708,
-0.0223801155,
0.0323388875,
-0.0263717882,
0.0429809913,
-0.0053027701,
-0.0273892246,
0.0464710072,
0.0764198378,
-0.0558644868,
0.0089584133,
0.0214171391,
0.000755731,
0.0602822676,
0.0222719982,
0.0079065468,
-0.0319901966,
-0.0362689048,
0.0420618951,
-0.0410382226,
0.0015721682,
-0.0117847826,
-0.0022131882,
0.0036140701,
-0.0025130934,
0.0486933924,
-0.0173998401,
-0.0081845829,
-0.002280951,
-0.0636861101,
0.0315684192,
-5.65780088e-33,
0.0363348611,
-0.0563164838,
-0.0307882763,
-0.0117985504,
0.0055194469,
-0.01846903,
0.031104818,
-0.0035425245,
-0.0034479129,
0.0366054773,
-0.0213520341,
0.0381445177,
-0.0040948214,
0.0055807657,
-0.0177132394,
-0.0446846224,
0.0166186094,
-0.0309712868,
-0.0103335399,
-0.0057605174,
0.053671632,
-0.0161359366,
-0.0294539183,
-0.0820997134,
0.0250839628,
0.0048468783,
-0.0270397309,
-0.0075237988,
0.0383159257,
0.0352795981,
-0.0183598567,
0.0383965857,
0.0115918638,
-0.014513216,
0.0003838886,
0.0803688839,
-0.0304281339,
-0.0086306129,
0.041902069,
-0.0390210152,
0.0124698365,
0.0311753508,
0.0135251405,
-0.033521641,
-0.0031029207,
0.0002147609,
0.0207164492,
0.0042860517,
0.042882096,
-0.0344931781,
-0.0395771116,
-0.0045701968,
-0.0280447919,
0.0175489746,
-0.0319804735,
0.0573571585,
0.0313223451,
0.0164553095,
-0.0805103406,
0.0601565801,
-0.0220062342,
-0.0272145234,
-0.0059360871,
-0.0199286379,
-0.0071066734,
0.045254983,
-0.0100113153,
0.019056743,
-0.0188911185,
0.0465838388,
-0.0072833351,
0.0395339765,
0.0274070539,
0.0735749751,
-0.0002201341,
-0.0806784928,
-0.040111158,
-0.0148397563,
0.0312481709,
0.0073231249,
0.0062439558,
-0.0384832919,
-0.063945882,
-0.0381515846,
-0.0291804839,
-0.0466867462,
-0.0462795421,
-0.0092001809,
-0.0015629763,
-0.0108155645,
-0.0485562272,
-0.0249204747,
0.012487066,
-0.0009283292,
-0.0348403826,
0.0407707356,
0.000541268,
0.0089572091,
0.0238060821,
0.0391727984,
-0.0149591994,
0.018715281,
-0.0094630755,
-0.0058643501,
0.0409425572,
-0.0073897005,
0.029607093,
0.0401549749,
-0.0554092899,
0.019425841,
0.0076243198,
0.044285953,
-0.0343271121,
0.0283231158,
0.0124890115,
0.0611979924,
-0.0242768209,
-0.064404048,
0.0516990386,
-0.025203621,
0.0206269044,
0.0196414553,
-0.0783293992,
0.0011320215,
-0.0229224432,
-0.0290967859,
-0.047254853,
0.0319502167,
0.0470506921,
-0.0919412598,
0.0377692319,
-0.0944325775,
2.503e-7,
0.0175022315,
0.0489496291,
-0.0447858125,
0.0230540615,
0.0413660146,
0.0263302345,
0.0944906324,
-0.0046620853,
0.003444565,
-0.0502098128,
-0.0150525318,
0.0400984511,
-0.0213164724,
0.0327754207,
0.0053180861,
-0.0451130308,
-0.0489591993,
-0.0104037626,
-0.0408081859,
-0.005340524,
-0.0287151057,
0.0271445327,
0.0648520365,
-0.0132653844,
-0.0580464453,
0.0021942132,
-0.0022455943,
-0.0295642726,
-0.0305716749,
-0.027753925,
0.0147781987,
0.0245515425,
-0.017435668,
-0.0324211381,
-0.0131866029,
-0.0121573303,
-0.0081340279,
0.0047105099,
0.0395422652,
0.0185767338,
0.0170387756,
-0.0054887258,
-0.0078063239,
-0.0283625573,
0.0160392001,
-0.0614762641,
-0.0399841703,
-0.0528251119,
-0.0473415628,
-0.0270754974,
0.0165531375,
0.0050981618,
-0.0344693549,
-0.0091642672,
0.0174959656,
0.0151251815,
0.0062797191,
-0.0510555916,
0.0233168826,
-0.0143751912,
-0.028093094,
-0.0553833358,
-0.0331132449,
-0.0018165344,
0.0293401014,
0.0642155632,
0.0390351228,
1.874204749e-34,
0.0084188804,
0.0032859233,
-0.0081038708,
-0.0888464823,
0.0316272639,
0.0142732272,
-0.0176137555,
-0.0175496694,
0.0480363779,
-0.0137686301,
-0.0046364148
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.10255v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.10255v2 | Feedback Effect in User Interaction with Intelligent Assistants: Delayed Engagement, Adaption and Drop-out | 2023-03-17T21:39:33 | 2023-04-18T15:26:44 | Zidi Xiu, Kai-Chen Cheng, David Q. Sun, Jiannan Lu, Hadas Kotek, Yuhan Zhang, Paul McCarthy, Christopher Klein, Stephen Pulman, Jason D. Williams | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.CL | With the growing popularity of intelligent assistants (IAs), evaluating IA
quality becomes an increasingly active field of research. This paper identifies
and quantifies the feedback effect, a novel component in IA-user interactions:
how the capabilities and limitations of the IA influence user behavior over
time. First, we demonstrate that unhelpful responses from the IA cause users to
delay or reduce subsequent interactions in the short term via an observational
study. Next, we expand the time horizon to examine behavior changes and show
that as users discover the limitations of the IA's understanding and functional
capabilities, they learn to adjust the scope and wording of their requests to
increase the likelihood of receiving a helpful response from the IA. Our
findings highlight the impact of the feedback effect at both the micro and meso
levels. We further discuss its macro-level consequences: unsatisfactory
interactions continuously reduce the likelihood and diversity of future user
engagements in a feedback loop. | [
0.0625413731,
0.0041862573,
-0.0565509796,
-0.0423927531,
-0.0015591445,
-0.0162111055,
0.0371377394,
-0.0266540516,
0.0409948528,
-0.0018590284,
-0.0068829446,
0.0141338753,
0.0329617448,
0.0168061499,
-0.0427592807,
-0.0561842509,
0.01752216,
-0.018741833,
0.0002149093,
-0.001195442,
0.0053531253,
-0.0060274513,
-0.0358772911,
0.0788447186,
-0.029868979,
0.0012735957,
-0.0240156967,
-0.0273155533,
-0.0069497726,
-0.0270945728,
0.0116566913,
0.0279564839,
-0.0148303537,
0.0429974869,
0.0000021539,
-0.0681295395,
0.0127429767,
-0.0101484703,
-0.0806019232,
-0.0165903512,
0.0249603484,
0.067151688,
0.031219162,
0.0424879342,
-0.0282478146,
0.0492772982,
0.0166695938,
-0.0149263525,
0.0091792941,
-0.0339432955,
-0.00992826,
0.0517779402,
0.0067951111,
-0.008205927,
0.02896614,
-0.0905618444,
-0.01225104,
-0.0470993146,
0.0114534944,
-0.0534094907,
0.009028337,
0.0146114742,
0.0058059772,
-0.0165217165,
0.0175598022,
0.0463495478,
0.0046116221,
-0.0502958149,
-0.0045640939,
0.031060677,
0.0835634843,
0.0377290808,
-0.0430717245,
-0.00140922,
0.0605142415,
0.0757523105,
-0.0428250097,
-0.0572226793,
-0.0375307202,
-0.0603127703,
-0.0304462444,
0.0287624486,
0.0020519258,
0.0101268552,
0.0032724515,
0.0063136378,
-0.0109706977,
-0.0577536933,
0.008221711,
0.0114420298,
0.0366422758,
-0.0275962781,
0.0229598805,
0.0179439802,
-0.0849195719,
-0.0096959341,
0.0117777707,
0.0125467256,
-0.0013521134,
-0.0042311586,
0.0525429584,
0.0298996344,
-0.0372645184,
0.0292999502,
0.0628778115,
0.0174124874,
-0.0014584695,
-0.0427500196,
-0.011435505,
0.0332246199,
-0.0584541857,
-0.0071325302,
0.0134911733,
0.0209459905,
0.023891747,
-0.0333904065,
0.0314730927,
0.0727343857,
-0.0071285432,
0.0394290872,
-0.0700085387,
0.0340901017,
-0.0498334393,
0.0181028731,
-0.0972664207,
0.0231475234,
-0.0648762435,
0.0471748523,
0.0232064631,
-0.0113246404,
-0.0125139821,
-0.0118162427,
0.0406581797,
0.0126587162,
0.001137394,
0.0257657189,
0.0197175667,
-0.0464160554,
-0.0102771781,
-0.0312007703,
0.0303158872,
-0.0357994251,
-0.0459368676,
0.0264995769,
0.0152642066,
0.0504958145,
-0.0431406125,
0.0074377018,
-0.024474632,
0.0135036912,
-0.0320597477,
0.0703562126,
-0.0403457507,
0.0485541672,
0.0491774343,
0.0110675124,
-0.0253158305,
-0.0101331491,
0.0032017569,
0.036043372,
0.0552450716,
0.0019575474,
0.0662065074,
0.0196884852,
-0.0591960736,
0.044905968,
0.0595664009,
0.0282012057,
-0.0713118911,
0.0103619136,
0.0175118241,
0.0045151687,
-0.0258306917,
0.058879111,
0.0818690956,
0.0820600539,
-0.0283920728,
0.0128894355,
0.0095034922,
0.0139178699,
-0.0211519767,
0.0041305711,
-0.031455718,
0.013534734,
-0.0081332577,
0.0150443912,
0.0141191939,
0.0046729944,
-0.0526635572,
-0.045398552,
0.0402432159,
-0.0150356926,
0.0274531916,
0.045751784,
0.0241641141,
0.0009150968,
0.0096859122,
-0.0359806605,
-0.028630536,
-0.0304210857,
-0.0043391846,
-0.0685654283,
0.0619096011,
0.1211888343,
0.0433622673,
-0.0151151754,
-0.016665712,
-0.0066637634,
-0.0177612547,
0.0277644191,
0.0332646221,
0.0040617883,
-0.0265738964,
0.0343520343,
-0.0588001125,
0.0110623362,
-0.0187620409,
0.0359719209,
-0.0523225628,
0.020819718,
0.0077459454,
0.0091592325,
-0.0166672077,
0.0026221692,
-0.0089167403,
-0.0073855943,
-0.0461069606,
0.0568068512,
0.031298656,
0.0435376838,
0.0339323841,
0.0014162081,
0.0178340636,
0.0326450653,
-0.0117332954,
0.0637716651,
-0.0125494776,
0.0807223544,
0.0175956972,
0.0378048085,
-0.0166641921,
0.0156901032,
0.0386388302,
-0.0247632861,
0.0405623317,
-0.0299743582,
0.0796354711,
0.0304321814,
0.0467379577,
-0.0117086098,
-0.0264053456,
-0.0162990838,
-0.0049083438,
-0.0535971597,
-0.0272871777,
-0.0254231784,
0.0112473108,
0.0106204012,
-0.0068837479,
0.018702548,
-0.004022419,
0.002441009,
0.0005135798,
0.0241453554,
-0.0230732206,
-0.0400224179,
0.0134332534,
-0.0903021768,
-0.0249111969,
-0.0166053306,
-0.018182328,
0.0025285706,
0.0570778176,
-0.0180205908,
-0.0258377027,
0.0104929125,
-0.0291278325,
0.0022546162,
0.0482423268,
0.0199155323,
0.0618740171,
-0.0426277779,
-0.072315827,
0.0108959712,
0.0127188461,
-0.0376995206,
0.0477251336,
-0.0344958343,
-0.0328394584,
-0.0700479522,
-0.0265070647,
0.0039354679,
-0.0221538115,
-0.0187668949,
0.0644787923,
0.0085314624,
0.0309824571,
0.0543990247,
0.0131166214,
0.0709204227,
0.0424804464,
0.0237138718,
-0.0560452081,
0.0262039378,
-0.0077039436,
-0.0345369801,
-0.0130394697,
-0.0009376087,
0.0577730574,
-0.0097241467,
0.0139674982,
0.0452463292,
-0.0268876404,
0.0215090066,
-0.0133127635,
-0.0662002712,
0.0203043669,
-0.0012324093,
-0.0364373736,
0.0523719527,
0.0000439812,
-0.0668583512,
0.0180023629,
0.0203519668,
0.0040345197,
0.0123240016,
-0.0092130415,
0.0068384646,
0.0507659689,
-0.0194192827,
0.006032133,
0.0228119437,
-0.0170891955,
-0.0036690934,
-0.0006656888,
0.0098299701,
-0.0249034055,
0.0194559153,
-0.020166209,
-0.0192709323,
0.0307000708,
-0.0158769544,
-0.0131536778,
-0.0282790121,
-0.0142997047,
-0.0392516069,
0.0205409229,
-0.058392901,
-0.0178252831,
-0.0325872116,
0.0553897619,
0.0290617794,
-0.0216913112,
-0.0665771738,
-0.0059325406,
-0.0271681007,
0.029376125,
0.0821611062,
-0.021478612,
-0.019228017,
0.0364950299,
-0.019593887,
0.04505812,
-0.05921188,
-0.0116385631,
-0.0300241075,
0.0412192158,
-0.0068099177,
-0.0170279685,
0.0423501134,
0.0269719698,
-0.0033386948,
0.0106840096,
0.0637517869,
0.029248666,
-0.0860838071,
0.023100948,
-0.0638925433,
0.0030228898,
0.0178228728,
0.0131051932,
-0.0232848004,
0.0012186252,
0.0312994607,
0.0735404193,
-0.0323916785,
-0.0119292671,
0.014089982,
-0.1055384353,
0.0228500292,
-0.0620549694,
0.0240466911,
-0.0224650428,
-0.0310525373,
0.030506663,
0.0075238412,
0.0392059274,
0.0103533203,
-0.0316481926,
-0.0064922334,
0.0255224742,
-0.0473764837,
-0.0026431149,
0.0011857924,
-0.0408891588,
0.0348951519,
0.0852300152,
0.0178057812,
-0.0027787937,
-0.0038017386,
-0.0378895849,
0.0532745086,
0.0444733948,
-0.002830209,
0.0662439987,
-0.001006486,
0.0447665043,
-0.0112931412,
0.0248033665,
-0.0113762636,
0.0361300521,
0.0676999316,
-0.0241862703,
-0.0143704927,
-0.0043621911,
-0.0406822376,
-0.0146380644,
0.0234607141,
0.0151569303,
0.0188497528,
-0.07835944,
0.0248138886,
-0.0124345366,
-0.0095906826,
-0.010550932,
-0.0036281978,
-0.0098869782,
-0.035407912,
-0.0040026559,
-0.0262228977,
-0.0547768399,
-0.0299482178,
0.0021185854,
0.0259042457,
0.0365581773,
-0.0231456235,
0.0346594751,
0.0629282221,
0.0207968578,
0.0332855619,
0.0127074756,
-0.0384833254,
-0.0064569837,
-0.0319456719,
-0.0415968634,
0.0178483296,
-0.035043709,
0.0466131307,
-0.0350983404,
0.035301853,
0.0909968987,
0.0345640816,
0.0351894423,
0.0194061399,
-0.030591445,
-0.0292444956,
-0.0228851549,
-0.023844976,
-0.0088251205,
0.03182818,
0.054747995,
-0.0300680399,
0.0110498201,
-0.0330372602,
-0.0348526761,
-0.0514363535,
-0.0219226573,
-0.0711863264,
-0.0479133241,
-0.0004272802,
0.0240239389,
0.0149417883,
-0.0442355573,
0.0346078984,
0.0130553544,
-0.005192325,
-0.0064172279,
-0.0045311847,
-0.0077702552,
-0.0195305366,
-0.0278440844,
-0.0074554561,
0.0245673358,
-0.024967242,
-0.0268728193,
-0.0274802689,
-0.0817047954,
0.0008948669,
-0.0259587895,
0.0538145788,
0.0002291732,
0.0146387899,
-0.013514298,
-0.0134109082,
0.023338031,
-0.0077035376,
0.0119898748,
0.060007222,
-0.0069278916,
0.0049296278,
-0.0084675355,
0.0746012181,
-0.0132669229,
-0.0962459967,
0.0299981497,
0.0177932847,
-0.0361895524,
-0.0082641859,
0.013229006,
0.0148986122,
0.0463322327,
-0.0219912771,
0.0062130899,
0.0150152873,
0.0083654104,
-0.0244173147,
0.0248968098,
-0.036620155,
0.0113111679,
0.0398297533,
-0.0669078678,
0.0415877998,
-0.0757813975,
-0.0171128362,
-0.053812243,
-0.0311569907,
0.0140597019,
0.0226934999,
-0.0329900123,
-0.0298203863,
-0.0493988656,
-0.0017329165,
-0.0452766642,
-0.0276856851,
0.0235225353,
-0.0489074178,
0.0234482177,
0.0295830611,
-0.0024503702,
-0.0304591767,
-0.0179385636,
-0.0398036391,
-0.095386833,
0.028172778,
-0.0120472424,
-6.031665022e-33,
0.0137727931,
-0.0378559977,
0.0009358483,
0.01846499,
0.0028079681,
-0.0203641057,
-0.0088623473,
0.0543023683,
0.0059165265,
-0.0563546829,
-0.030374689,
-0.0285964701,
0.008736901,
-0.0409169085,
0.0697143376,
0.0403042659,
0.0652071834,
0.002408064,
-0.0350168645,
0.033598505,
0.0009107232,
0.0051597981,
-0.0561174676,
-0.0883012637,
0.0471676067,
-0.0218594428,
-0.0001084314,
-0.0012119288,
-0.0094841057,
-0.0000690342,
0.0011940257,
0.0704707652,
0.029669214,
0.0151581047,
0.0373884961,
0.0411523134,
-0.0370513499,
-0.0271505881,
0.0012621644,
-0.007021917,
-0.0280110221,
-0.0171744656,
-0.0195197742,
0.0147340773,
-0.0409715548,
0.058574412,
0.0425678119,
0.0134494686,
-0.0328816101,
0.0515216812,
-0.0628387034,
-0.0162171833,
-0.0288372934,
-0.07084582,
-0.043621473,
0.101408869,
0.0207500234,
-0.0312893316,
-0.0560100153,
0.0050276574,
-0.0139636667,
-0.0107988361,
0.0198459104,
0.0004631043,
0.0282985326,
-0.0030802477,
-0.000809686,
0.0350024179,
0.0096010407,
-0.0508274846,
0.0053959121,
0.0309739877,
-0.0412148573,
-0.0208977424,
0.0020938178,
-0.1089346558,
0.0533276461,
0.0488900617,
0.048193492,
0.0917389095,
0.0124216583,
0.0163085219,
-0.0858641714,
0.0178232193,
0.0000364687,
-0.00700576,
-0.0315983631,
-0.0541727692,
0.0467264913,
0.0474802516,
-0.007323497,
-0.0362345167,
-0.0170344971,
0.0211031344,
0.0067696795,
-0.0702502131,
-0.0191818625,
0.0090701319,
0.0119832326,
-0.0446833633,
-0.0675957128,
-0.0304835048,
-0.0625189021,
0.0315894522,
0.0250204615,
-0.0065757418,
-0.0031685017,
0.0302998852,
0.0031546145,
-0.0257367622,
0.0209509097,
0.0552786589,
0.0449197367,
-0.0457122587,
0.0590825453,
-0.0122028869,
-0.0344900638,
0.041656699,
0.0058091762,
0.0156877749,
-0.0780024827,
-0.0364281386,
-0.0260626264,
-0.0415530726,
-0.0494674556,
-0.0388347842,
-0.0459915288,
0.0118507333,
0.0032759607,
-0.0326460078,
-0.0426044948,
-0.0667084903,
2.941e-7,
-0.0649035648,
0.0435664505,
-0.0143013941,
0.0024595936,
0.0004613072,
0.053333018,
-0.0085874135,
0.0193015803,
0.022288017,
0.0702318102,
0.0493017547,
-0.0232529659,
0.0088105947,
0.0084635308,
-0.0229844134,
-0.045011431,
-0.0095882053,
0.058024399,
-0.0404798873,
0.0198680069,
0.0174340364,
-0.0331482068,
-0.0030272501,
-0.0075663631,
-0.0059013125,
-0.0477404855,
0.0133858174,
-0.0278285164,
0.0115232402,
-0.0470684618,
0.0431191474,
0.0307193846,
0.0176098775,
-0.0018557337,
-0.0133995097,
0.0147443749,
-0.0331306756,
-0.0040369905,
-0.0082205618,
-0.0370657854,
0.0448703952,
0.0174117927,
0.0412768312,
-0.023689786,
0.0434190072,
-0.0526599921,
-0.0231909622,
-0.0140348691,
-0.001171244,
-0.008057043,
0.0187418852,
-0.0001377756,
-0.0342768021,
-0.0122590605,
-0.0108670499,
-0.0151861766,
-0.015148202,
-0.0347543024,
0.0356909446,
0.0107234083,
-0.0190588813,
-0.0438876078,
-0.0398624949,
0.0080011077,
-0.0333397277,
-0.0040733302,
0.017630117,
1.57809359e-34,
0.0081486637,
-0.0070032701,
0.0523162335,
0.0459772684,
0.0197234005,
0.024712503,
0.0353857949,
0.0395760834,
0.0703613982,
0.0176321249,
-0.0192710795
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.10227v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.10227v1 | Conversational Tree Search: A New Hybrid Dialog Task | 2023-03-17T19:50:51 | 2023-03-17T19:50:51 | Dirk Väth, Lindsey Vanderlyn, Ngoc Thang Vu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Conversational interfaces provide a flexible and easy way for users to seek
information that may otherwise be difficult or inconvenient to obtain. However,
existing interfaces generally fall into one of two categories: FAQs, where
users must have a concrete question in order to retrieve a general answer, or
dialogs, where users must follow a predefined path but may receive a
personalized answer. In this paper, we introduce Conversational Tree Search
(CTS) as a new task that bridges the gap between FAQ-style information
retrieval and task-oriented dialog, allowing domain-experts to define dialog
trees which can then be converted to an efficient dialog policy that learns
only to ask the questions necessary to navigate a user to their goal. We
collect a dataset for the travel reimbursement domain and demonstrate a
baseline as well as a novel deep Reinforcement Learning architecture for this
task. Our results show that the new architecture combines the positive aspects
of both the FAQ and dialog system used in the baseline and achieves higher goal
completion while skipping unnecessary questions. | [
0.0550399236,
0.0617673062,
-0.0210372768,
0.0169707388,
0.0072427904,
-0.0047499663,
0.0009631293,
0.0035690917,
-0.0129097467,
0.0044012428,
-0.0352435224,
-0.0275660064,
-0.0366583727,
0.0731496364,
-0.0334652737,
-0.0784189254,
0.0316807106,
-0.0232896414,
0.0603040941,
0.009757285,
0.0248268377,
-0.0005956202,
-0.0328889526,
0.061027471,
-0.020514138,
-0.0252420809,
-0.0577625521,
0.0211251769,
0.0069188746,
-0.0518042222,
0.0835523531,
0.0449491814,
0.0341946669,
0.0359314606,
0.0000020995,
-0.0333071165,
-0.0106952414,
-0.0359923914,
-0.0746639445,
-0.0676889941,
0.0141059272,
0.0831560493,
0.0468374081,
0.0368967503,
-0.0399001613,
-0.0182447862,
0.0391981639,
0.1029247344,
0.0567334853,
0.0694566742,
-0.001380267,
-0.0438964106,
-0.0102080014,
-0.030344246,
0.0616889112,
-0.0938713998,
0.0023922483,
0.0116485674,
0.0099989949,
-0.0024393026,
-0.0057001868,
-0.0104707936,
0.0150974849,
-0.0545950271,
-0.0120779295,
0.0204566438,
-0.0040363888,
-0.0254560355,
-0.0083935959,
0.1080417559,
0.0034142879,
0.0259074327,
0.0033539995,
-0.0003667643,
0.0131899044,
-0.0270303264,
-0.0328423604,
0.0036710731,
-0.0291423779,
-0.0319317952,
-0.0178311989,
0.0293885097,
0.0152415922,
-0.0074356035,
-0.04464975,
0.039396856,
-0.0314887427,
-0.03768811,
0.0312809087,
-0.013544891,
0.0218331553,
-0.0647707283,
0.00581457,
0.0172550324,
-0.0944944397,
0.0019200541,
0.0141794365,
0.0360095054,
0.0046329824,
0.0082944771,
0.0065349969,
0.0176667403,
-0.019438656,
0.0536316782,
0.0451429524,
0.0187392551,
-0.0448853672,
-0.0241988506,
-0.0430816673,
-0.0145369926,
-0.0466778837,
-0.0009591911,
-0.067343168,
0.0673302785,
-0.0721346512,
-0.0202947073,
0.0010583489,
0.0317238942,
0.0049848901,
0.0063034557,
0.019121917,
0.0647664145,
-0.0426507182,
0.0056827147,
-0.0763470903,
0.0088680517,
-0.0626684427,
0.0180850308,
0.0276686214,
0.0188105814,
0.0147656361,
0.0232612733,
0.0142310038,
-0.0054493616,
-0.026335258,
0.0617121756,
0.0203511789,
-0.0262126662,
-0.01872712,
-0.0160773564,
0.0107662957,
-0.0394104607,
0.0010097078,
-0.0325552411,
0.0044460855,
-0.0500527211,
-0.0422500111,
-0.0004366633,
0.0329226628,
0.0556584112,
0.0111145815,
0.0569671132,
0.0063301809,
-0.0132828439,
0.0596791767,
0.0085540991,
-0.0399534218,
0.0447869226,
0.0108271511,
0.0629266798,
0.0345696844,
0.0264901631,
0.0449913405,
-0.0217474345,
0.0086059934,
-0.0296534672,
0.0654769018,
0.0515000597,
-0.0505572893,
0.0327002741,
-0.0133454092,
0.0251087099,
-0.0613923296,
0.0027039277,
-0.0071156058,
0.0604793094,
0.0190260429,
-0.0275126044,
0.0028273386,
0.0387361906,
-0.0184690319,
-0.0265899245,
-0.0282307081,
0.0183940884,
0.008494718,
-0.0149759445,
0.0088681197,
-0.0075204601,
-0.0310900379,
-0.0409157537,
0.0366257839,
0.0075412346,
0.0014185343,
0.0395542756,
0.0140841249,
0.0005571054,
-0.055976674,
-0.0094112884,
0.0043796473,
-0.0096392976,
-0.0484181941,
-0.049315311,
0.0334670469,
0.0611251071,
0.0394115746,
-0.0099197403,
-0.0267790649,
-0.0281732343,
0.0227043442,
0.0400332324,
0.0568765961,
-0.0257894378,
0.0399856493,
-0.036307916,
-0.0483634844,
0.0054854536,
0.0063013351,
0.0225350745,
0.0184651203,
-0.0163669288,
0.0245154649,
-0.0031443161,
0.0038285153,
-0.0103103677,
0.0246517286,
-0.0218310114,
0.0461589694,
0.0220554695,
0.0318524279,
0.0278322734,
0.0078403438,
-0.0062593739,
0.0039545493,
0.0262904167,
-0.0162202418,
-0.0023740535,
-0.0485148467,
-0.0171428509,
-0.0126889134,
-0.0554160178,
-0.0299803354,
0.022274062,
-0.0029743903,
-0.0535708442,
-0.0289948937,
-0.0517997853,
0.0340054445,
-0.0310576782,
0.0176338553,
0.0400116555,
-0.0374754779,
-0.0465473756,
0.086423628,
0.0257375576,
-0.0024585929,
0.0197863523,
-0.0053719617,
0.0463488325,
-0.0681358203,
-0.0001512485,
-0.013421502,
-0.0317984223,
0.0000482347,
0.0446429402,
0.049302008,
-0.0433217511,
0.0224455968,
-0.0756415501,
0.0155883906,
-0.0140036903,
0.0086564729,
-0.0103949346,
0.0533344075,
-0.0087511521,
-0.0549085662,
-0.0613463037,
0.0200559609,
0.0234529283,
-0.01597712,
0.0665653944,
0.030331973,
-0.0155413132,
-0.0794101804,
0.0181755051,
0.0140939755,
-0.0109524,
0.0122668892,
-0.0195072256,
-0.0132315122,
-0.0304549653,
-0.0317828022,
0.0423720516,
-0.0002178339,
-0.0060156202,
0.0291165691,
-0.0186739434,
-0.0029358983,
0.039064277,
0.0330896936,
0.0404580906,
-0.0320547149,
0.0067385542,
-0.0682905689,
0.0707377121,
-0.041040387,
-0.0061891833,
-0.0188574772,
-0.0129608968,
0.0547135882,
0.0411785357,
-0.0230481476,
0.0555728972,
-0.0545560978,
0.02906367,
0.0441792123,
0.0012798497,
-0.0278778337,
0.0448988974,
-0.0172021594,
0.0771751851,
-0.0275806226,
-0.0093338434,
0.0865594968,
0.0451284237,
-0.0255633891,
-0.0730648786,
-0.035690438,
-0.0432480015,
0.0692746565,
0.001170597,
0.0214021318,
0.0510233194,
-0.0547646694,
-0.0173216406,
0.0063573667,
0.0285038836,
-0.0114233857,
0.0478002653,
-0.0073193088,
0.0168745201,
0.0042701699,
-0.0848190859,
-0.0393945463,
-0.0343737043,
0.0040385751,
-0.0242716148,
0.0287572313,
-0.0566773117,
-0.0623555705,
-0.0300704651,
0.0144397272,
0.0928341448,
-0.0171695817,
-0.0379448906,
0.0067380634,
0.040124841,
0.0590884909,
0.0457250625,
-0.0220237579,
-0.0114712995,
0.0469679087,
0.0251946189,
0.022209892,
-0.0179688148,
0.0067855525,
-0.0305156652,
0.0182051379,
-0.0294096228,
0.0164614692,
0.017470073,
0.0170815419,
-0.0493039601,
-0.0291486587,
0.0821958333,
0.0598691292,
-0.0571841672,
-0.0204634834,
-0.0547560528,
0.0465971455,
0.0059167664,
0.042896539,
-0.084477514,
-0.0444952659,
0.0041780723,
0.0139962351,
0.0188645516,
-0.0159878228,
0.0177865252,
-0.06233209,
0.0223529283,
-0.0506434217,
0.0097636124,
-0.0124229724,
-0.0076813833,
-0.0033695435,
0.0181054734,
-0.0070526097,
0.0282359421,
-0.01192021,
-0.0317063332,
0.0036531764,
-0.0224309098,
-0.0090515958,
0.0164705589,
-0.0417322926,
0.0142531134,
0.0817488879,
0.030929802,
0.0337141491,
0.0176764335,
-0.0127688274,
0.0170006379,
-0.0126301153,
-0.0198127888,
0.0508413278,
-0.0169422794,
-0.0152337933,
-0.0398629233,
0.0258120466,
-0.0305747502,
0.0121720862,
0.0457774624,
0.0384058766,
-0.0628609657,
0.0080171889,
-0.0435987525,
-0.0024186603,
0.0040699383,
0.0516781509,
-0.0131618464,
-0.0205254424,
-0.0613031313,
-0.0678857341,
-0.0036702456,
-0.0524957106,
0.0047455807,
-0.0164174046,
0.0149176754,
0.0492167175,
-0.0612840131,
-0.0577014014,
0.0117804408,
-0.001352641,
-0.0281098764,
-0.0636425391,
-0.0128708053,
0.0411834978,
-0.0177045409,
-0.0120399361,
-0.0421288572,
0.0063371584,
-0.0501394346,
0.0226614606,
0.0112067107,
-0.0168285277,
-0.0346425585,
-0.0041396031,
-0.0153300669,
-0.0140841529,
-0.0650278404,
0.0225159936,
0.0196512602,
0.0416022837,
-0.02174972,
0.0052970508,
-0.0157362353,
0.0041354476,
-0.0485340878,
-0.0738876909,
0.0464079939,
0.0251726191,
-0.0158341862,
0.0320402682,
-0.0846529156,
0.0084469542,
-0.0544749163,
0.0374440588,
-0.0465964079,
-0.0607146397,
0.0284760594,
-0.0170076787,
0.0147667285,
0.0615742169,
0.0048219133,
-0.0419863388,
0.0661963597,
0.007197089,
-0.0225060955,
-0.0388918705,
-0.0015274237,
0.0103105865,
-0.0202575307,
0.0528043658,
-0.016228741,
-0.0189728457,
0.0370032452,
-0.0006767135,
0.0133848879,
0.0446259193,
0.0203717891,
-0.0015521437,
-0.0141037991,
0.010599805,
0.0301647037,
0.0551215373,
0.0346612036,
0.0077773533,
0.0755199865,
0.0296121575,
-0.0081002237,
0.0020911957,
-0.0103102913,
-0.0487495624,
-0.0975553766,
-0.0046736742,
0.0224057809,
0.0093598245,
0.0190969035,
-0.053556826,
-0.0425065756,
0.0198501796,
0.0085062301,
-0.0137779908,
0.0008072022,
-0.0190330595,
0.0583903231,
0.0298885666,
0.0023897863,
-0.0080384603,
0.0532123223,
0.0343512297,
0.0105788168,
-0.0284250621,
-0.0297620278,
-0.0514341481,
-0.0403590612,
0.0048796386,
0.0523563102,
-0.0125289289,
0.0013548831,
-0.0249504652,
-0.0207718592,
-0.0414388925,
0.004774747,
-0.0167986359,
-0.0047416347,
0.0885413289,
0.0440039225,
0.0126518542,
-0.0624393523,
-0.0137653509,
0.0133658946,
-0.0546596386,
0.0007006808,
-0.0563611463,
-5.818694833e-33,
-0.0186410416,
-0.0310453251,
0.0490974672,
0.0332515538,
-0.013593806,
-0.0099423509,
-0.0447536334,
-0.0012418703,
-0.0211110804,
0.0197366979,
0.002727546,
0.0157561172,
0.0055282889,
0.0532601178,
-0.0316350088,
-0.0158142503,
0.0647785664,
-0.0048836162,
-0.0116331149,
0.0617395751,
0.0139771756,
0.0334695354,
-0.0016894604,
-0.0354191624,
0.0358043946,
0.004027253,
0.0120684113,
0.089219816,
0.0033512313,
0.0653173849,
-0.00007176,
0.0321998559,
0.0071191275,
-0.0377505235,
0.0308945067,
0.0361051373,
-0.0980397686,
-0.0774964169,
0.0208278168,
-0.0300838239,
-0.0598757528,
-0.0021184925,
-0.0015647667,
-0.0005851886,
0.0383579731,
0.0250187479,
0.0310447887,
0.0162221864,
0.0093121761,
-0.0002207821,
-0.0386532769,
0.0060161161,
-0.0202322993,
-0.0420003496,
-0.0193826947,
0.0889280736,
0.0132950097,
0.0046903705,
0.016779203,
0.0150170261,
-0.0062041925,
0.0315786302,
-0.0082532475,
0.0115602231,
-0.0252910554,
0.0341290161,
0.0264463238,
0.0186495055,
-0.0384420231,
-0.043766737,
-0.0201395378,
0.0450013392,
0.0083514182,
0.0427254178,
0.0237281062,
-0.012193324,
-0.0420561098,
0.0359787382,
0.0254630055,
0.0866222158,
-0.0008128728,
0.0067566196,
-0.0406434648,
0.0002399246,
-0.0488371439,
0.0427542292,
-0.0291005801,
-0.0343287215,
0.0584983453,
0.03038463,
0.0381872579,
-0.0259776432,
-0.0086262627,
0.003236352,
0.0010616784,
0.0270771869,
0.0170254074,
-0.0103330445,
0.0111801932,
0.0195016991,
-0.045999065,
-0.0002090941,
-0.0104893073,
-0.0052904752,
-0.0167032089,
0.0175697878,
-0.0217179116,
-0.0249927957,
-0.059998624,
0.0079486826,
-0.0137166055,
0.0162528101,
-0.0836725906,
0.0636231974,
0.0054656127,
0.0086246338,
-0.0121896081,
0.0523810834,
-0.0133993495,
0.0019580983,
-0.0974542722,
-0.0721398816,
0.0049534189,
0.0084270583,
-0.0178058278,
-0.0006525431,
-0.0263255015,
0.0224294439,
0.0118730133,
-0.0831828639,
0.0103538083,
0.0144875394,
2.597e-7,
-0.0306025483,
0.044895865,
0.0112295765,
0.0416149609,
0.0088007562,
0.0416642018,
0.0301951468,
-0.0277599599,
0.0146476682,
-0.0357106254,
0.0343383178,
0.0037885003,
0.0120191649,
0.0098554408,
-0.1285567731,
-0.0275581144,
-0.0600685664,
-0.0439822897,
-0.0469501428,
-0.0383144729,
0.0222520977,
0.0783632249,
-0.0189657081,
-0.0106604891,
0.0125189628,
-0.0046238299,
0.0196200144,
-0.028013574,
-0.0177846216,
-0.0027499055,
0.0386985056,
0.0109895179,
-0.0014955943,
0.0014083531,
-0.0086238747,
0.0272486135,
0.0037620829,
0.0641987771,
0.0099107325,
-0.0451501757,
-0.0157905743,
-0.0097775972,
0.0198717229,
-0.0331418365,
0.0140868658,
-0.0480260253,
0.0222852845,
-0.0174060725,
-0.0021874001,
0.0004324453,
0.0030276664,
-0.0050857235,
-0.0305963121,
-0.0272157677,
0.0215628929,
0.0124352323,
0.0401173197,
-0.0689989105,
0.0054478543,
0.0184105448,
-0.0131480359,
-0.0046437089,
-0.0580996946,
-0.003615825,
-0.0137793012,
-0.0059678024,
0.0111598941,
2.05917705e-34,
0.0313262083,
-0.0246468335,
-0.0144751305,
0.0258385036,
0.0284996647,
0.0181821808,
0.0017909011,
-0.0073800348,
0.068817243,
-0.0523105375,
-0.0081750629
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.13379v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.13379v2 | Practical and Ethical Challenges of Large Language Models in Education: A Systematic Scoping Review | 2023-03-17T18:14:46 | 2023-07-22T15:26:28 | Lixiang Yan, Lele Sha, Linxuan Zhao, Yuheng Li, Roberto Martinez-Maldonado, Guanliang Chen, Xinyu Li, Yueqiao Jin, Dragan Gašević | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | Educational technology innovations leveraging large language models (LLMs)
have shown the potential to automate the laborious process of generating and
analysing textual content. While various innovations have been developed to
automate a range of educational tasks (e.g., question generation, feedback
provision, and essay grading), there are concerns regarding the practicality
and ethicality of these innovations. Such concerns may hinder future research
and the adoption of LLMs-based innovations in authentic educational contexts.
To address this, we conducted a systematic scoping review of 118 peer-reviewed
papers published since 2017 to pinpoint the current state of research on using
LLMs to automate and support educational tasks. The findings revealed 53 use
cases for LLMs in automating education tasks, categorised into nine main
categories: profiling/labelling, detection, grading, teaching support,
prediction, knowledge representation, feedback, content generation, and
recommendation. Additionally, we also identified several practical and ethical
challenges, including low technological readiness, lack of replicability and
transparency, and insufficient privacy and beneficence considerations. The
findings were summarised into three recommendations for future studies,
including updating existing innovations with state-of-the-art models (e.g.,
GPT-3/4), embracing the initiative of open-sourcing models/systems, and
adopting a human-centred approach throughout the developmental process. As the
intersection of AI and education is continuously evolving, the findings of this
study can serve as an essential reference point for researchers, allowing them
to leverage the strengths, learn from the limitations, and uncover potential
research opportunities enabled by ChatGPT and other generative AI models. | [
0.0754369199,
0.0105333338,
-0.0479140878,
0.0178259201,
-0.075157322,
0.0054340023,
0.0523860268,
-0.0226518959,
0.0441897437,
-0.0922987983,
0.0024426358,
0.0002037932,
-0.0250486545,
0.0435338728,
0.0113453437,
-0.0370040089,
-0.0041636988,
-0.0099386089,
0.0014710374,
0.0240618438,
-0.002392858,
0.0458862819,
-0.0089507541,
0.0522424728,
-0.0024478002,
-0.0254224073,
-0.0237593483,
-0.0448598377,
-0.0121512543,
-0.0005297349,
0.0150913065,
0.0771898925,
0.0117237736,
0.0583628044,
0.0000024309,
-0.0655473098,
-0.0339155942,
0.000893206,
-0.0045710099,
0.0294933598,
0.0713040829,
0.0735531822,
-0.0189523529,
0.0213215631,
-0.0676315576,
0.0210345462,
0.0462244712,
-0.028313823,
0.0190315619,
0.0173673872,
0.0076909959,
-0.0010419134,
0.0735108331,
0.0378607959,
0.0167642031,
0.0293622985,
0.0293835737,
0.0317863598,
0.0439190604,
0.0415549688,
-0.0055497326,
0.0479711778,
0.0127567705,
-0.0712054595,
0.0152869979,
-0.0047072428,
-0.0325570181,
-0.0456938148,
0.0132997939,
0.0398815051,
0.0355572999,
-0.0158218741,
0.0255309921,
-0.0096684955,
0.0189626459,
0.0209561754,
-0.0621998683,
0.0711042807,
-0.0229475107,
0.0204602722,
0.0417548716,
-0.0423640311,
-0.0132123278,
0.0397413336,
0.0339101441,
-0.0169753376,
0.0039954972,
-0.0202237815,
-0.0340832807,
0.0518209673,
-0.0008001651,
-0.0476112217,
0.0204975139,
0.0709885135,
0.0106605859,
0.0408528261,
-0.0243456867,
-0.0479958244,
0.0460119918,
-0.0249389708,
0.0234492086,
0.0405092239,
0.0086788442,
-0.0053823604,
0.0049675778,
0.0586864799,
0.005395819,
0.0586106181,
-0.035910245,
0.0441694558,
-0.0557277724,
-0.0325537547,
-0.0239593424,
0.0688867867,
-0.0110595683,
0.0060565788,
-0.02915808,
0.0385151878,
-0.0365218781,
0.040392898,
-0.0075971512,
-0.0105021317,
-0.0040012128,
0.0071293507,
-0.0103684403,
0.0188189857,
0.0126071395,
-0.0005984665,
0.0025852036,
-0.048243098,
0.0422483943,
0.0246192515,
-0.0077229915,
0.033465445,
0.0154064456,
0.0554024428,
-0.0063081668,
-0.0262213983,
-0.0269801915,
-0.0678475872,
0.0002067361,
-0.048813913,
0.0039400919,
-0.0825348869,
-0.0134937176,
0.012428985,
-0.0174180418,
-0.0160711277,
0.015607493,
0.0397545286,
0.0144616878,
-0.0025926905,
0.000406088,
0.0132547254,
0.0516080856,
0.011901265,
0.0290410239,
0.0288765244,
0.0407065339,
0.0093254121,
0.0283017606,
-0.0227206312,
0.0238479842,
0.0328469574,
-0.0094990078,
-0.0089293849,
-0.0076508783,
-0.007029085,
0.0007126671,
0.0325647555,
-0.0529475659,
0.0645220131,
0.0001947866,
0.0201809518,
0.050199762,
0.0825573429,
-0.0282988138,
0.03754922,
0.0458647572,
0.0316202268,
0.0598527826,
0.0238776729,
-0.0244702715,
0.0027845281,
-0.0059210481,
-0.0186827518,
0.0048646233,
0.0482757613,
0.0164800063,
-0.0915653706,
-0.0185652412,
-0.0399511382,
-0.0162566788,
0.0498181768,
0.0491809733,
-0.0230004862,
-0.001439264,
-0.0327890925,
0.0353142917,
-0.0457222648,
0.0399875641,
-0.1270834357,
0.0828271583,
0.0960923806,
0.0711582303,
-0.0443179794,
-0.0389350913,
-0.0302441958,
-0.0148839476,
0.052881442,
0.0118149221,
-0.0416052341,
-0.0663493648,
-0.0177552681,
-0.0149511928,
-0.0206177514,
-0.0225725789,
0.0086185569,
0.0082228137,
-0.0001306653,
-0.002565833,
-0.01174594,
-0.0771814957,
0.0375657007,
-0.0750282332,
-0.0465921536,
-0.0383278728,
0.0140714254,
0.0024271365,
0.0436595455,
-0.003639261,
0.0124106165,
0.0136797028,
0.0131534794,
-0.023317283,
-0.0397425443,
-0.043029353,
0.0520798713,
0.0465277769,
-0.0460951328,
0.0059421062,
0.017414093,
-0.019677829,
-0.0238698814,
-0.0025381092,
-0.0116486475,
0.0276338253,
-0.034513358,
0.0139928125,
-0.061451409,
-0.0507536605,
-0.0539516732,
0.0152635258,
0.0174325444,
0.0067664934,
0.0008205381,
0.0131287398,
0.0296471342,
0.0339892879,
-0.0429002643,
0.043379683,
0.0048054811,
0.0531095788,
0.0277835242,
0.0255559683,
-0.0398440622,
-0.0410205834,
-0.0905568749,
-0.0164748449,
0.0119346753,
0.0090732127,
0.024660062,
-0.0165323317,
-0.0137808723,
0.0157904699,
-0.0657608286,
-0.0166900028,
0.0191369392,
-0.0073518651,
0.0051392713,
-0.0156683791,
0.0128695844,
-0.0317183323,
-0.0063669481,
-0.0263411608,
0.0079693189,
0.096039027,
0.014826824,
-0.0675445125,
0.0446229763,
-0.0284043923,
0.0090885842,
0.036214482,
-0.0188235957,
0.0125306807,
-0.0227809008,
0.0366673358,
0.0682899058,
0.0066729747,
0.0297148004,
0.0666178316,
-0.0047963476,
-0.0566713661,
-0.0168304052,
-0.0003525611,
-0.011125599,
-0.0100599499,
-0.0449374504,
-0.0247077718,
0.0079908762,
0.0311796255,
-0.0373927467,
-0.029881008,
0.0527078733,
-0.0689136013,
0.0094743976,
-0.038392067,
-0.064033635,
-0.0287435465,
0.0192289315,
0.0101759182,
-0.051462803,
0.0930224732,
-0.0035887179,
0.0202449691,
-0.0556678064,
0.0063739466,
-0.0345272981,
0.0427905768,
0.0007800229,
0.0305974614,
0.0124525614,
0.0027808629,
-0.0425512269,
0.031135058,
0.054441385,
-0.0641594753,
0.0244947486,
-0.0598024502,
-0.0197641477,
-0.0214219261,
-0.0029198984,
-0.0342560783,
-0.0009605004,
0.0049476358,
-0.001339142,
0.0181966182,
-0.0046973275,
0.0092136674,
-0.0169580225,
0.0413235612,
0.0276281089,
-0.0447381511,
-0.0112354923,
-0.0146013126,
0.0242963675,
0.022695763,
-0.0521782786,
-0.0043714326,
0.0138636287,
0.0638088658,
0.0616303533,
0.000924033,
0.0080089662,
0.0304011591,
0.0021401348,
0.0478520319,
-0.0248254146,
-0.0199257191,
0.0252602734,
0.0305941813,
-0.0779919773,
-0.0073528863,
0.0922046676,
0.0352580957,
-0.0738529637,
-0.0319177024,
-0.038748797,
-0.0439444892,
-0.0105950013,
0.0213940088,
-0.088269271,
0.0293931738,
-0.025997309,
0.053097792,
-0.064300172,
-0.0474294536,
0.0051402519,
-0.0882168561,
0.0552107468,
-0.0035310348,
-0.006176617,
0.0177630559,
-0.0275358669,
-0.0131343361,
0.0212648641,
-0.0159901883,
-0.0321326926,
-0.02100401,
0.0121072717,
0.0494507253,
-0.0200925842,
-0.0192483887,
0.033921916,
0.0059049395,
0.0599918105,
0.0556209907,
0.0365270749,
-0.028653333,
-0.045554664,
0.0043399776,
0.02412064,
-0.03305877,
0.011252082,
0.0158874579,
0.0084339548,
0.0093324156,
-0.0736832917,
0.0506557897,
-0.0028408859,
-0.0026228577,
0.0486730561,
0.1205461845,
0.0007234772,
-0.0157516655,
-0.0323015973,
-0.0171804577,
0.0150600243,
0.0659504086,
0.0206288006,
-0.0851596817,
0.0063935569,
-0.0253585242,
0.0051184851,
-0.0190679654,
-0.0432417206,
0.0160118416,
0.0003824237,
-0.0000870968,
-0.0601970255,
-0.0538276657,
0.043564897,
-0.0174207799,
0.025632523,
0.0080798995,
0.0597826913,
-0.0223982111,
-0.0220738109,
-0.0064003384,
-0.0216870084,
-0.0199279729,
-0.0746357143,
-0.0467139781,
0.0005695647,
-0.0485822372,
0.0209959485,
0.0037637968,
-0.0441344008,
-0.0655565336,
0.021360429,
0.0363882594,
0.0155181475,
0.0064249113,
0.0305126086,
-0.0243560914,
0.0287376326,
-0.0192821492,
0.0001010671,
-0.0020304087,
-0.0208191276,
0.0196778663,
-0.0076879356,
-0.0161027964,
-0.0214390717,
0.0267249737,
0.0112442328,
-0.025731964,
-0.0072196238,
-0.0294946972,
0.0396066718,
0.0599270612,
-0.0023661698,
-0.0565218888,
0.003260582,
-0.0629346594,
-0.0352302231,
-0.0405483879,
-0.0254431069,
-0.033294972,
0.0063232812,
0.0258903801,
-0.0143424626,
0.0036907967,
0.0086102253,
-0.0448661745,
0.0291260276,
-0.025251139,
0.0696502179,
-0.0371455923,
0.0614646822,
0.0303848647,
0.0028359024,
-0.0506805144,
0.0168526936,
-0.0328242332,
0.033579383,
0.000017491,
0.0684456378,
-0.0044806623,
0.0013567901,
0.0611220077,
0.0384100787,
-0.0106063206,
-0.0586337447,
-0.0428403653,
0.0369386077,
-0.0060093855,
0.033239238,
0.0156788882,
-0.0507571958,
-0.0071456041,
-0.0070187622,
0.0184018947,
0.0079211257,
-0.0459906496,
-0.0169892162,
0.0047604661,
0.0062894477,
-0.0275449697,
0.0191898886,
-0.007886189,
0.0249332301,
0.012856584,
-0.0286682285,
-0.0152970497,
-0.0392645262,
0.0151927434,
-0.0225605518,
0.0066238921,
0.0049414928,
-0.0454612784,
-0.0378164761,
-0.0355325863,
0.0335521214,
-0.0098448163,
-0.0506709218,
0.0236378126,
0.0434305258,
-0.0138765816,
0.0091834422,
-0.0606551655,
0.0293256454,
-0.0250300076,
-0.0437842309,
0.01651817,
-6.481100593e-33,
-0.014155074,
-0.0630121455,
0.0431947894,
0.0439151265,
-0.012121954,
0.0062689567,
-0.021701958,
0.0251415037,
-0.012664644,
0.0153756747,
0.0143216234,
-0.0196833666,
-0.0163227394,
0.0231441986,
0.0484747961,
0.0142051121,
0.0284284689,
-0.0428821146,
0.0090792207,
0.0652799606,
0.0318965875,
-0.0354894772,
0.0537870228,
-0.0425402746,
0.0753153116,
-0.0315513723,
0.0053898948,
-0.010531635,
-0.0682419389,
0.0345574766,
-0.0209582932,
0.0737300143,
0.0292861443,
-0.0102937352,
0.0066094678,
0.0546553805,
-0.034706343,
-0.0451211408,
0.00858266,
-0.0105523998,
-0.0077605201,
-0.0665054545,
0.0367604457,
-0.0303661693,
-0.0373920873,
0.0156893283,
0.0578794181,
-0.0119223008,
0.0057840836,
-0.0374288596,
-0.0877947733,
-0.0002281005,
-0.0291883666,
-0.009946622,
0.0078705344,
0.0673105121,
0.0125874691,
-0.0151480939,
-0.0268587992,
0.0421179608,
0.04974401,
-0.0063349856,
0.0500030965,
-0.0032606029,
0.0017124247,
0.04001268,
0.0039441101,
0.0114015089,
-0.0288154315,
-0.0041648513,
0.0298448708,
-0.0135204261,
0.0800359175,
0.0378255323,
-0.0454226248,
-0.0223092809,
-0.0361953713,
0.0225602835,
0.0223854054,
-0.0098283496,
0.030806791,
-0.0702632666,
-0.0540986285,
-0.0282427669,
-0.0080234138,
-0.0271963105,
-0.0159048904,
-0.0114102075,
0.0365411416,
-0.0596817769,
-0.026070144,
-0.0271431655,
-0.000194942,
-0.0356449932,
0.0040343581,
0.0062208893,
-0.0027383405,
0.0394087024,
-0.0210967753,
0.0217976235,
-0.034482576,
-0.0099078706,
0.0115531897,
-0.0307180621,
0.0119512994,
0.033564683,
0.0054962132,
0.0285300352,
-0.0298558213,
0.0232159384,
-0.0418894738,
0.0431652442,
0.061047174,
-0.0375781618,
0.0082589546,
-0.0013511647,
0.015093389,
0.0218951795,
0.0468532927,
-0.0013293298,
-0.0433865748,
-0.0232401453,
-0.0019343755,
-0.0283972044,
-0.0378917195,
0.0168582387,
-0.0658177733,
0.0512882136,
0.0475978963,
-0.038845364,
0.0055606351,
0.0010362979,
3.114e-7,
0.0282248333,
0.0367151685,
-0.0067806966,
-0.0296837091,
-0.0078037875,
0.0219026525,
0.0301186573,
-0.0111017488,
0.0655262247,
0.0231297929,
0.016342951,
0.0103784725,
0.0389483944,
0.0419253893,
-0.0676849186,
-0.0206650738,
0.0009081317,
-0.0050900108,
-0.0749146044,
0.0584851764,
0.0769174024,
-0.0026826635,
0.0350652263,
-0.0205617193,
-0.047714442,
-0.0089978054,
-0.0049466067,
-0.0235943012,
-0.0024485681,
0.0266301744,
0.0211844593,
0.0248001441,
0.0157695059,
-0.0005303229,
-0.0091043552,
-0.0092436206,
-0.0162413586,
0.0423093401,
0.0165183339,
0.0205195807,
0.0215232763,
-0.0643101037,
0.0044055115,
-0.0853138492,
0.0605474636,
-0.0076578916,
0.0056492873,
-0.0258629993,
0.0091738394,
-0.0613602288,
-0.0139683317,
-0.055558484,
0.0193220954,
0.0324090868,
-0.0255162567,
-0.0467788018,
0.0557248443,
-0.0212117136,
0.0042209015,
-0.0290570185,
-0.0213529132,
-0.0542825572,
-0.0195425451,
-0.0175206624,
-0.0225001629,
-0.0469681211,
0.0555950552,
2.906365701e-34,
-0.0069427071,
-0.029116787,
0.0343040638,
-0.0095271822,
-0.0021734182,
0.0527142994,
-0.0029937616,
-0.0005714686,
0.0187593214,
-0.0647298023,
-0.0415432751
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.11156v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.11156v3 | Can AI-Generated Text be Reliably Detected? | 2023-03-17T17:53:19 | 2024-02-19T16:34:24 | Vinu Sankar Sadasivan, Aounon Kumar, Sriram Balasubramanian, Wenxiao Wang, Soheil Feizi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The unregulated use of LLMs can potentially lead to malicious consequences
such as plagiarism, generating fake news, spamming, etc. Therefore, reliable
detection of AI-generated text can be critical to ensure the responsible use of
LLMs. Recent works attempt to tackle this problem either using certain model
signatures present in the generated text outputs or by applying watermarking
techniques that imprint specific patterns onto them. In this paper, we show
that these detectors are not reliable in practical scenarios. In particular, we
develop a recursive paraphrasing attack to apply on AI text, which can break a
whole range of detectors, including the ones using the watermarking schemes as
well as neural network-based detectors, zero-shot classifiers, and
retrieval-based detectors. Our experiments include passages around 300 tokens
in length, showing the sensitivity of the detectors even in the case of
relatively long passages. We also observe that our recursive paraphrasing only
degrades text quality slightly, measured via human studies, and metrics such as
perplexity scores and accuracy on text benchmarks. Additionally, we show that
even LLMs protected by watermarking schemes can be vulnerable against spoofing
attacks aimed to mislead detectors to classify human-written text as
AI-generated, potentially causing reputational damages to the developers. In
particular, we show that an adversary can infer hidden AI text signatures of
the LLM outputs without having white-box access to the detection method.
Finally, we provide a theoretical connection between the AUROC of the best
possible detector and the Total Variation distance between human and AI text
distributions that can be used to study the fundamental hardness of the
reliable detection problem for advanced language models. Our code is publicly
available at https://github.com/vinusankars/Reliability-of-AI-text-detectors. | [
0.0441325009,
0.035170801,
-0.0288899504,
0.0814603344,
-0.0398900732,
-0.0226434022,
0.0128388181,
0.0575427264,
0.0319187492,
-0.0478025451,
-0.0024321179,
0.0205941312,
0.0175871309,
0.0184120238,
0.0673391148,
0.0463698022,
0.0082693538,
-0.0165347941,
0.0299564917,
0.0062357159,
-0.0019923577,
0.017149128,
0.0393647179,
0.0540480241,
-0.0107241552,
-0.0235867202,
0.0137383165,
0.0117671583,
-0.0036533938,
-0.0136781335,
-0.0358242951,
-0.0052013537,
-0.0261043496,
0.0921039656,
0.0000019104,
-0.0358669497,
-0.0258797146,
0.0120728621,
-0.0398082361,
0.041347906,
0.0407521613,
0.0092297606,
-0.018473031,
0.023777876,
-0.0489074402,
0.0616481267,
0.0055381251,
0.0359659828,
0.0702135637,
0.0907649845,
-0.0229390897,
0.0077974242,
0.0811939165,
-0.0062240181,
0.0243058894,
-0.0375889726,
0.0129444292,
-0.0199111104,
0.0032205083,
0.0352935046,
0.0244601555,
0.0386560783,
0.0026080224,
-0.0058016265,
-0.0240435004,
0.0111837322,
-0.0133974496,
0.0043173595,
-0.0121608209,
0.03386271,
-0.0535236746,
-0.0592393875,
0.040119078,
-0.0166797545,
0.0304538887,
0.0265105926,
0.0058522434,
0.0638615191,
-0.0164196305,
-0.0014959045,
0.0338271298,
-0.0189471114,
0.0496179089,
0.008777773,
0.0061509665,
0.0264251903,
0.0108624725,
-0.0342022069,
-0.0524928495,
-0.033249937,
0.0133961923,
-0.0683096871,
0.0436338373,
0.0235420149,
0.0404962637,
0.0085759871,
-0.1107882559,
-0.0667591244,
0.0192396007,
-0.0406414904,
0.054699257,
0.0072626113,
-0.0089471322,
0.0341184922,
-0.0541329496,
0.0765414909,
-0.0530987419,
0.0695695505,
0.017008692,
0.0193983838,
-0.0086718379,
-0.0409915335,
-0.0243751481,
0.0563816279,
0.0191616099,
0.0036833016,
-0.0316238701,
0.0313174948,
0.0032916861,
0.0456726216,
-0.0588296875,
-0.0138201611,
-0.0040003727,
0.010099086,
0.0262562819,
-0.0475083329,
0.0154266888,
0.0292311031,
0.0000771207,
-0.0736856833,
-0.0334375873,
0.0555830933,
-0.0175870582,
0.0114795668,
0.0050395099,
0.1025195494,
0.0368492343,
-0.053034462,
-0.0423211865,
-0.0732138157,
-0.0144112678,
-0.0083752908,
-0.0082625784,
-0.0662704632,
-0.0394043736,
-0.0280818995,
-0.0079873931,
-0.0857265815,
0.0009557152,
0.0229187068,
-0.0284757931,
0.0304230079,
-0.0237296913,
-0.0218661819,
0.0096420553,
0.0081515107,
-0.0363985747,
0.0188983288,
0.0729654059,
0.0821799561,
0.0863003358,
0.0196094345,
0.0700086281,
0.0366025344,
0.0201318171,
0.011612935,
0.0007584805,
-0.0215317607,
-0.024190804,
-0.0200455002,
-0.0141137857,
0.0528934672,
-0.0185561236,
-0.0611626916,
0.0832461566,
0.084874332,
-0.0340834782,
0.0259518977,
0.0395063981,
0.0083927251,
0.0313009247,
0.0170174055,
-0.0134202437,
-0.0237610564,
-0.0673170611,
-0.0253212359,
-0.0095018623,
0.0048059733,
0.0118848355,
-0.0454191528,
-0.0078207264,
-0.0443590358,
-0.0195405893,
-0.033066228,
0.0096886223,
0.0210924763,
-0.0324102491,
0.0020946728,
-0.0468109213,
-0.0363198593,
0.0047856905,
-0.1022902653,
0.0389959998,
0.0284638423,
0.0819203556,
-0.0222031903,
0.0646966249,
-0.0243353788,
-0.0297532026,
0.0157127213,
-0.0333094597,
0.012846116,
0.0141693084,
-0.0014048365,
-0.0106246937,
-0.0504994728,
0.0055895061,
0.0066596502,
0.0221192073,
0.0316663571,
0.024378635,
-0.0454716235,
-0.0426527299,
0.0338285528,
-0.0232114941,
-0.0495126322,
0.0130781448,
-0.0067895642,
0.0366004333,
0.0254329499,
-0.0352497511,
0.0528223142,
0.0456955805,
-0.054643672,
-0.0448649786,
-0.0165423658,
0.0203852281,
0.0283164885,
0.0306866169,
-0.060281273,
0.0077797691,
0.0608328767,
-0.0189501643,
-0.0013598343,
0.0388842747,
-0.0612268709,
0.0186509993,
-0.0341645926,
0.0496910624,
-0.034940701,
0.0435745828,
-0.0446476564,
0.0440519117,
-0.0180499442,
0.0034800021,
-0.0126782106,
-0.0035792927,
0.0321770273,
-0.0114648798,
-0.034323696,
0.0017670728,
-0.0225948039,
0.0167101659,
0.0007667691,
0.0090627354,
0.0012836298,
-0.0361889042,
-0.0249145534,
-0.0056314589,
0.0002095093,
0.0182762332,
0.022362005,
-0.0209365673,
-0.0108319465,
-0.0043631648,
-0.0121764429,
-0.0421183892,
-0.0007764207,
-0.0066885892,
0.0612991676,
-0.030070398,
-0.0190547463,
-0.0135307312,
0.0087954849,
-0.0227413625,
0.0555204861,
0.0265436321,
-0.0405337848,
-0.0801619142,
0.0402328968,
-0.0075342525,
0.0077647311,
-0.0148326652,
-0.0290517528,
0.0012335884,
-0.007897093,
-0.033359848,
0.0940436795,
0.0279059261,
0.0094980486,
0.0129848123,
0.0583924279,
-0.0382817946,
-0.0350441299,
0.0380283371,
0.0145607051,
-0.0387507156,
-0.0398094282,
0.072894685,
0.0335314833,
0.0358472802,
-0.0154049844,
0.0026501729,
0.0351753086,
0.0060279593,
-0.0313815735,
0.0414952599,
-0.0398220494,
-0.040438462,
0.0071809813,
-0.0156531669,
-0.0844546258,
0.0407089181,
-0.0726038218,
0.020776296,
-0.0236913804,
-0.0168392323,
-0.0091041513,
-0.0029798388,
-0.0014270903,
0.0146845831,
0.0036066007,
-0.0111873997,
-0.0245476048,
-0.0228732917,
0.0469052345,
-0.0417535268,
0.0063055488,
-0.0217512548,
0.0141447503,
0.0105297454,
0.0008658289,
-0.0386684835,
-0.0691647232,
-0.0238884408,
-0.0227420703,
0.0122108432,
-0.0258387588,
-0.0128132701,
-0.0354560167,
0.0606708601,
0.0238469187,
-0.0093944622,
-0.0125952382,
-0.0523831174,
0.0573308095,
0.0191307217,
-0.0527590178,
0.024087755,
-0.0278041959,
-0.0032959972,
0.0725905374,
0.0070457268,
0.0508029424,
-0.0064989412,
-0.0190763976,
0.0171037745,
-0.0071938266,
-0.0301418081,
0.0368088521,
0.0147053478,
-0.0265871342,
0.0185582805,
0.0527863652,
0.0077933604,
-0.028849259,
0.0091370642,
0.0093586612,
-0.0076961243,
0.0129552474,
-0.0315978192,
-0.0817642957,
-0.0171015635,
0.0277379658,
0.0197219737,
-0.0266757999,
-0.0082756421,
-0.0118411873,
-0.0696937963,
0.0118631171,
0.0200753435,
-0.0139014963,
-0.0127277281,
-0.0204138681,
-0.0280980989,
0.0451435447,
-0.0383051187,
-0.0540389717,
0.010773682,
0.0052633011,
-0.0086496901,
-0.0209302288,
-0.0092497813,
-0.0159267355,
-0.0510164574,
0.032873068,
0.0826760307,
0.0438208058,
-0.0059644124,
-0.0358584672,
0.0084599862,
0.0092891566,
-0.0078119943,
0.0137951663,
0.0399190597,
-0.0146535458,
-0.0069977054,
0.0370497443,
0.0252540782,
-0.0141931828,
0.0015352094,
0.0437599309,
0.031174276,
-0.0015813626,
-0.0368506387,
-0.0122939628,
-0.0351061746,
0.0180780832,
0.0492940135,
0.0296979137,
-0.0069489558,
-0.0707254261,
-0.0411161743,
0.0275394376,
-0.0598475039,
-0.0531160198,
0.0158796702,
-0.0140225813,
-0.0314808413,
-0.0823941231,
0.0150600718,
-0.0798646882,
0.0228483807,
0.028162431,
0.0370018408,
0.0128845554,
-0.0082340837,
-0.0180032719,
-0.0465578586,
-0.0700383037,
0.0561346486,
-0.0511772446,
0.0364705436,
-0.0008116156,
-0.0345458835,
0.0004336833,
0.0256558005,
-0.0898395255,
-0.0362762995,
-0.01241819,
0.0255465843,
0.021954434,
0.0153491637,
-0.0306284744,
-0.0601523779,
0.0868655592,
0.0252164584,
-0.016567193,
0.0353026502,
0.0507177822,
-0.0156478193,
0.0162836965,
0.0248285402,
-0.047483895,
-0.0030365025,
0.0549834259,
-0.034602657,
-0.0488115922,
-0.0045570936,
0.0119699184,
0.0675364211,
0.0059245448,
-0.0171132032,
0.0176440813,
0.0330289379,
0.0196711347,
-0.0139866918,
-0.0073023066,
-0.0394577421,
0.0330958515,
0.0267570205,
-0.0147797074,
0.0135550126,
0.0182181299,
-0.0151847601,
0.0318603031,
-0.0010080955,
0.0058634449,
-0.0195942484,
0.064957954,
0.0089687966,
0.0024623848,
0.0157070011,
0.04430319,
-0.0241363384,
0.0405066721,
0.0235371422,
-0.0025606949,
0.0102708284,
-0.0044867564,
-0.0161339771,
0.0616665371,
-0.0884949714,
-0.0143143628,
0.0039142217,
0.0467762686,
0.0385081917,
0.0230589211,
0.0116254697,
-0.0116555532,
0.0039570332,
-0.0165501833,
0.0137700513,
-0.0205422882,
-0.0310742613,
-0.0248745047,
-0.005536695,
-0.0243805554,
0.0319269672,
0.0826968849,
0.0211873408,
0.0376551487,
-0.0027236971,
-0.0286298227,
-0.0346070416,
-0.0214502625,
0.0420856811,
0.0106073506,
-0.0069407187,
-0.0301737823,
-0.0362393223,
-0.0708499551,
0.046953883,
-0.0007004179,
0.0413952433,
-0.0142018218,
-0.0478382632,
0.0766213834,
0.0005302976,
0.0301846173,
-0.065272361,
0.0138908522,
0.0165440068,
-0.0567005835,
-0.036090292,
-5.069277511e-33,
0.0195314735,
-0.0681314468,
-0.043978896,
0.0138199301,
0.0199088566,
0.0486693345,
-0.0182001963,
-0.0253218003,
-0.0155131463,
-0.0215006787,
-0.0286940224,
0.0242842212,
-0.0038973375,
-0.0062388154,
-0.0412188023,
-0.014053205,
0.0024286131,
-0.0131557947,
-0.0556860603,
0.0061305533,
0.0214682296,
-0.0283485018,
0.0067622554,
-0.0758021027,
0.022131253,
-0.0380719751,
-0.0439422615,
-0.0294803679,
-0.0404965617,
0.0564943962,
0.0004496554,
0.017556427,
0.017978156,
0.0195357706,
-0.0320990533,
0.0059428266,
0.0135884332,
-0.0308054127,
0.0011697732,
-0.0003339663,
-0.0034250978,
-0.0867912918,
0.065173775,
-0.021641925,
-0.0149049601,
0.031515684,
0.0412965901,
-0.0160633903,
-0.0290130302,
-0.0246782135,
-0.0240389612,
0.0118465638,
-0.0221439023,
0.018322628,
0.0259754583,
0.0298512373,
0.0360804163,
0.0649300665,
-0.0887939706,
0.0243236925,
-0.0141906682,
0.0018484261,
0.0320947021,
-0.0089267362,
-0.0030073307,
0.0329212137,
0.0251217987,
0.0004578357,
-0.0222706757,
-0.0186914131,
0.0043958533,
0.0068835123,
0.0759508237,
0.069572404,
0.048285123,
-0.0316757783,
0.0000664067,
0.028945988,
0.0024468212,
0.0027922136,
0.0378008038,
0.0036584297,
-0.0882095546,
-0.0075106202,
-0.010961052,
-0.0572484881,
-0.0270521939,
-0.0134319188,
0.0163706727,
0.0207753573,
-0.0243428331,
-0.0333818756,
-0.007222109,
-0.0892467573,
0.0051386962,
-0.0035690933,
-0.0140611362,
0.0082570864,
0.0183224697,
0.0172805544,
0.0050611114,
0.0018872959,
0.0075657824,
-0.0046517993,
0.0747421086,
-0.0156683065,
0.0347236656,
0.0225332305,
-0.0547329858,
-0.0043839402,
-0.0015779168,
-0.0024954434,
0.0459306128,
-0.004941449,
0.0094093205,
-0.0360029601,
0.0014144832,
-0.009225077,
0.0038728488,
-0.0024492035,
-0.0153813763,
0.01917856,
-0.034955021,
0.0142919477,
-0.034023881,
-0.0115345754,
-0.0356002152,
0.0684373304,
0.0390447043,
-0.0643821955,
-0.0130409999,
-0.0415354185,
2.645e-7,
-0.0064199911,
0.009506437,
0.047142148,
0.015218717,
0.0276530925,
0.0770363659,
0.0181572009,
0.0292517599,
-0.0499752425,
-0.0047507868,
-0.0328693762,
-0.0054720868,
0.0698293,
-0.0094832629,
-0.0708726346,
0.0418540724,
-0.0639275536,
0.0361259319,
-0.0612112805,
-0.0033608822,
0.0597428977,
0.0726506561,
0.03985456,
-0.0422883518,
-0.021404909,
-0.1039274633,
0.0163626019,
0.011771651,
0.029883286,
0.0057868059,
0.0588491671,
0.0143234665,
0.0177270975,
0.0033824332,
-0.0223957524,
-0.0044266237,
0.0008685885,
0.0416338369,
0.0067777503,
0.0244411808,
-0.0261787977,
-0.0612824745,
0.0159262195,
-0.0300578028,
0.062117476,
0.0609398745,
-0.0057056909,
-0.041697219,
-0.0147165032,
-0.0586370714,
0.0365108438,
-0.0157875307,
-0.0052260594,
0.0015333924,
-0.0053717233,
0.0168490615,
0.0147270765,
-0.0515224673,
-0.0211788975,
-0.0692115724,
-0.0238970164,
0.0058769844,
-0.0448847599,
0.0224761274,
0.0608713292,
-0.0455880947,
0.0277876463,
2.532054551e-34,
0.0024232187,
-0.0671261773,
0.0027733909,
0.0683754161,
0.0494766794,
0.0080148596,
-0.0162747428,
0.0131805176,
0.0000104728,
-0.0042446819,
0.0051252679
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.10128v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.10128v2 | Direct and indirect evidence of compression of word lengths. Zipf's law of abbreviation revisited | 2023-03-17T17:12:18 | 2023-05-27T08:36:57 | Sonia Petrini, Antoni Casas-i-Muñoz, Jordi Cluet-i-Martinell, Mengxue Wang, Chris Bentz, Ramon Ferrer-i-Cancho | cs.CL | cs.CL, physics.soc-ph | Zipf's law of abbreviation, the tendency of more frequent words to be
shorter, is one of the most solid candidates for a linguistic universal, in the
sense that it has the potential for being exceptionless or with a number of
exceptions that is vanishingly small compared to the number of languages on
Earth. Since Zipf's pioneering research, this law has been viewed as a
manifestation of a universal principle of communication, i.e. the minimization
of word lengths, to reduce the effort of communication. Here we revisit the
concordance of written language with the law of abbreviation. Crucially, we
provide wider evidence that the law holds also in speech (when word length is
measured in time), in particular in 46 languages from 14 linguistic families.
Agreement with the law of abbreviation provides indirect evidence of
compression of languages via the theoretical argument that the law of
abbreviation is a prediction of optimal coding. Motivated by the need of direct
evidence of compression, we derive a simple formula for a random baseline
indicating that word lengths are systematically below chance, across linguistic
families and writing systems, and independently of the unit of measurement
(length in characters or duration in time). Our work paves the way to measure
and compare the degree of optimality of word lengths in languages. | [
0.0081682978,
0.0386333056,
-0.0467339084,
-0.0224797353,
-0.0582267791,
0.0032935829,
-0.025826443,
0.1020216942,
-0.0910188258,
0.0345278084,
0.0333630517,
-0.0657991171,
0.0965516418,
-0.0328052379,
0.0627905577,
-0.0397021733,
0.0228941757,
-0.0034547546,
0.0266751889,
0.0156381987,
0.0292572174,
-0.0336648077,
0.0234722402,
0.009581117,
0.0027990113,
0.0323600657,
-0.0241346508,
-0.0399944484,
-0.0316044316,
0.0115505923,
-0.0477154292,
0.0684109554,
-0.0197482482,
0.0317664146,
0.000001671,
-0.0503797717,
0.035577666,
-0.0009971494,
-0.0350417383,
0.0265564024,
0.0604428686,
-0.0424605832,
-0.0246879868,
0.001912722,
-0.0011609558,
0.0151496595,
0.0853584781,
-0.0051021841,
-0.0763803869,
0.0126505876,
-0.0074090948,
-0.0157452524,
0.0194441937,
-0.0777515769,
-0.0057099145,
0.0319223367,
0.0042024162,
-0.0257446114,
0.0205468219,
-0.0090984367,
-0.0949860439,
0.0268850923,
-0.0029931273,
0.034147609,
-0.0159513894,
-0.0036573692,
-0.025049476,
-0.036798276,
0.016254643,
0.0432214327,
0.0338227749,
-0.0453944393,
0.0081048571,
0.0139636826,
-0.0014528921,
-0.0372223444,
-0.0405572094,
0.0093296245,
0.0158107188,
0.0270102657,
0.0235353094,
0.0395927839,
0.0172463953,
-0.0058646407,
-0.0378729068,
0.0722621903,
0.0263688024,
-0.0512099378,
-0.0043941825,
-0.018146392,
0.0276021883,
-0.0602168329,
-0.0258995406,
-0.0229453202,
0.0377268903,
0.0208807718,
-0.0267740302,
-0.036666926,
0.0250466187,
-0.0190440752,
0.0086406535,
-0.0028579445,
0.0356087349,
-0.0211925581,
0.0009459518,
0.0612832196,
0.027672343,
-0.0074671591,
-0.0218373276,
0.0413497165,
-0.0048399074,
-0.0102874162,
0.0030691102,
0.0128022451,
-0.0029822255,
-0.021903716,
-0.0404055454,
-0.0039036402,
0.0307039563,
-0.0264299475,
-0.0265706051,
-0.0199843235,
-0.0217709597,
0.0041896193,
-0.0025046805,
0.0134640625,
-0.0776271373,
0.023820132,
-0.026100995,
-0.0366053618,
0.0122176204,
0.0284944903,
0.0058337655,
-0.0153084351,
-0.0047268039,
0.0300218239,
-0.010088902,
-0.012709707,
0.071198903,
0.0009219099,
-0.0678930059,
-0.0092869308,
-0.021246532,
-0.064807035,
0.0342679508,
0.0118300207,
0.0088434806,
-0.0318388678,
-0.0219830479,
-0.0155969253,
-0.0620074011,
0.0238857828,
-0.0415866151,
0.0435127839,
0.0077009182,
-0.0066966992,
0.0733219162,
0.0086933766,
0.0677161068,
-0.0257556904,
0.0866336226,
-0.0419279411,
-0.0106698312,
0.0538091138,
0.0171455238,
0.0271763001,
-0.0183575526,
-0.055249773,
-0.0198041927,
0.0135218939,
0.0354869403,
0.0913086906,
-0.0248911791,
-0.067972526,
0.0314419083,
0.0956175625,
0.0416481011,
0.0162322763,
-0.0107334713,
0.0348618068,
0.0022103335,
0.0538004451,
0.0462481566,
-0.0189839192,
0.0000698131,
0.0064425776,
0.0728862882,
-0.0155197168,
-0.010347317,
-0.013886149,
-0.0478474014,
-0.0116681987,
0.0460371412,
-0.0517941341,
-0.0025747321,
-0.0030609993,
-0.0040383465,
0.0065460601,
0.0267732833,
-0.0443958193,
-0.0113397315,
-0.02951557,
-0.0186060909,
0.0094268341,
0.0201607104,
0.0606577806,
0.0633817017,
0.0083720749,
0.0201218668,
0.0498949066,
-0.0187331438,
0.0025947993,
0.0363535881,
-0.0189173035,
0.0431198329,
0.0124298008,
0.0119432388,
-0.0112678818,
0.0112798791,
0.0638797879,
0.0127640702,
-0.0544695221,
-0.0214608517,
0.0277874656,
-0.0121218255,
-0.0295237936,
-0.0439485945,
0.0051320489,
0.0259537268,
-0.0269112401,
-0.0480430089,
0.054523129,
-0.0280033052,
-0.0234859046,
0.0150575982,
0.0021124231,
0.029482821,
0.0211798567,
0.0331915356,
-0.0400706865,
0.0662622824,
0.0008121269,
0.0423913561,
-0.0300681312,
0.0002339734,
-0.0767532438,
0.0846809521,
-0.0057449583,
0.0279943477,
-0.0262640398,
0.0159179233,
-0.016959291,
-0.0039863484,
0.0168736763,
0.0643740818,
0.0173648354,
-0.0116299726,
0.0726761892,
-0.01982636,
-0.0097983517,
0.0522478707,
-0.0157910194,
-0.0251943618,
0.0759476125,
0.0090215355,
-0.0131113678,
-0.0481401123,
-0.0524013713,
-0.0373448357,
0.0265765451,
0.0298050139,
-0.0255991574,
0.0024257633,
-0.0085025448,
0.0362778492,
-0.0263975039,
-0.0126363728,
0.0015516473,
0.0283946265,
0.0699251294,
0.0050071855,
-0.0670755282,
-0.0557400286,
-0.026887238,
0.0148162013,
0.0292890184,
0.0045744008,
-0.0876392275,
-0.0431865677,
0.0415711589,
-0.0601685829,
-0.0403659381,
-0.0135201998,
-0.0999458805,
0.0102889016,
-0.0019500465,
0.0851033255,
0.0191601105,
0.032142926,
-0.0066934228,
0.0189735163,
-0.0184853114,
-0.0195683762,
-0.0455166884,
-0.0492664762,
0.0201791748,
-0.0443922766,
-0.0565881357,
0.0179966167,
0.0690544322,
0.0030131505,
-0.0033044657,
-0.0655989125,
-0.023006171,
-0.0390371792,
-0.0565797687,
-0.0071436763,
-0.0183914807,
-0.0451778583,
0.0656055883,
-0.0080293817,
-0.0731553286,
0.0313052125,
-0.0342364945,
-0.0165796913,
0.0166080836,
-0.0175134409,
-0.0201619137,
0.0774133578,
0.007054931,
0.0135154836,
0.0239786245,
-0.0408139415,
-0.0634627044,
0.0013471293,
0.0375328921,
-0.0237235986,
-0.0330080576,
-0.040396098,
-0.0032831584,
-0.0011382352,
-0.0510866567,
0.0329074226,
-0.0427045748,
-0.0096022766,
-0.0161927883,
0.0561671555,
-0.0593429916,
0.0474739522,
0.034652181,
0.0301437005,
0.0100698387,
-0.0093377149,
0.0333640873,
0.0157508682,
0.0141942194,
-0.0030503988,
-0.0463717058,
0.0345977806,
-0.0483539812,
-0.0502122231,
0.0182961635,
0.0088164043,
0.0785181373,
0.0520462953,
-0.01269696,
0.0181369074,
0.0064475727,
-0.0676221624,
0.0260816161,
0.0200768467,
0.01004293,
0.0164401792,
0.0800570473,
0.0076002753,
0.0096322447,
0.0532153584,
-0.0196027476,
0.0690321401,
-0.0052377889,
-0.00853414,
-0.0644805133,
-0.0025210946,
0.0254056565,
0.0037784202,
-0.0215399358,
0.0001223947,
-0.0209590513,
-0.0930226371,
-0.0475509763,
0.03413314,
-0.0139845433,
-0.0055420413,
-0.0188774858,
-0.0040780175,
0.0359834284,
-0.0244292002,
0.0338356718,
-0.026442267,
0.0386680849,
0.0310344826,
-0.0806674883,
-0.0199488569,
-0.0507774241,
-0.0148538509,
0.0448000357,
-0.007394711,
0.0416315757,
-0.0402869731,
-0.039079573,
-0.0179000776,
0.0158048645,
-0.0186341982,
0.006733031,
0.030966945,
0.0505324863,
-0.003157571,
-0.0467502922,
-0.0090843476,
0.021003047,
0.0131176086,
0.0022127414,
0.0055084913,
-0.0008879937,
-0.0605811924,
0.0238418449,
0.0171579253,
-0.0180842001,
0.0601940937,
0.0320549421,
-0.014491641,
-0.0155588882,
0.0198913012,
0.0207056478,
-0.0029131714,
-0.0492073819,
-0.054105904,
-0.0072617596,
-0.0861284733,
-0.0859356597,
-0.041575484,
-0.0138293859,
0.0711865053,
0.0387869962,
0.0027359149,
-0.0360006951,
0.014036811,
-0.0379579067,
-0.0812741071,
-0.0139004467,
-0.0037365886,
-0.0899274573,
0.015303907,
-0.0316949487,
0.0300962925,
-0.0068240138,
0.0538114607,
-0.0798441917,
-0.050704509,
0.0118916268,
0.0025383662,
0.0329328142,
-0.0164948329,
0.0379199758,
-0.0512541868,
-0.0370619632,
0.0055313259,
-0.004785243,
0.0989964381,
0.0282470714,
-0.0946259797,
0.0385194905,
0.0292354785,
0.0125073036,
-0.0202052593,
-0.0373802185,
0.0424388051,
-0.0216461532,
-0.0650817007,
0.0064922501,
0.0228443276,
-0.051478222,
-0.0582555272,
-0.0278268885,
-0.0090653468,
-0.0006725939,
-0.0194752924,
0.0220549125,
-0.0058540064,
0.0061440505,
-0.0001717669,
0.0421020985,
-0.0334784351,
0.0192558821,
-0.0336173736,
-0.0126973726,
0.0673532933,
0.0108341174,
-0.0289086979,
0.0199741218,
0.0403901525,
0.0495914295,
0.0309761725,
0.0324875452,
-0.0274131056,
0.0476153903,
-0.0319181606,
-0.0349783339,
0.0247086938,
0.0147103183,
-0.008208828,
0.0048209261,
-0.0215347838,
-0.0107067646,
0.0538851805,
0.0027915705,
0.0016328975,
-0.0063419677,
0.0590135604,
-0.0679479912,
0.0074168351,
-0.0306504909,
0.0111769028,
-0.0355752669,
0.0164605509,
-0.0389077216,
0.0071447073,
-0.0481843129,
0.0375081897,
0.0679506883,
0.0051059849,
-0.0260965321,
-0.0111144595,
-0.0244621504,
0.0140620526,
0.0142018953,
-0.0179997738,
0.0171284918,
0.0194935687,
-0.0175600499,
-0.0782664865,
-0.0364947394,
0.0055205938,
-0.0056849262,
0.0243798848,
0.0076056048,
0.0064714467,
0.0633329302,
-0.0284311883,
0.0218688138,
-0.02066903,
0.0106920665,
0.0145802284,
-0.0067851278,
-0.0043858844,
-5.341831305e-33,
0.0119726257,
0.0063462313,
-0.0301447846,
-0.0023771867,
-0.0391818322,
0.040543329,
-0.0328325778,
0.0334301442,
0.0049073705,
0.0121000484,
-0.0264423098,
0.0056161536,
0.0150929028,
-0.0087042535,
0.0377864018,
0.031995818,
0.0061143832,
0.0029944549,
-0.0218198337,
-0.0371444821,
0.0293537434,
-0.0238118414,
0.0586581491,
0.0419062153,
0.0500727296,
-0.0010509357,
-0.0116366176,
0.0054318081,
0.0598039925,
0.0285672136,
-0.0070169726,
0.0050168112,
0.0130316168,
-0.0245474335,
-0.0054744473,
0.0328977443,
-0.0193093531,
-0.0605808794,
0.063667655,
-0.0245346781,
-0.0273699593,
-0.0099475654,
0.0029688051,
-0.0298919603,
-0.0549219176,
0.012679847,
-0.0037653572,
0.0031224291,
-0.026008416,
-0.0233907551,
-0.0334004611,
0.0212314669,
-0.0077101253,
0.0075477138,
0.0422118455,
-0.0283581149,
-0.0040014475,
-0.0436569713,
0.0076753441,
0.0740974396,
0.0330365598,
0.0875326395,
-0.0156987533,
-0.0436121523,
0.0065368623,
0.0252544563,
0.0600214377,
0.017095726,
0.0336333103,
0.0240460541,
0.0557663031,
-0.0201476533,
0.0301078316,
0.0720642135,
0.0786582902,
-0.0273942407,
-0.0027142842,
-0.0347064249,
0.0521736145,
-0.0111748008,
-0.0350532793,
0.000396066,
-0.0896129608,
-0.0521269031,
-0.0213254988,
0.0133505715,
0.0279170424,
-0.0461290367,
0.0046090232,
-0.0053049191,
0.047739353,
-0.0057219164,
0.0404470079,
-0.0238307361,
-0.0618034266,
0.0079121077,
-0.0195378251,
0.0512216277,
0.0014194512,
0.0015039736,
-0.0396040082,
0.0013789407,
-0.0258010663,
0.0329538919,
0.0398953445,
-0.0288164765,
0.0311327409,
0.0145237371,
-0.0492719896,
-0.0130381016,
0.0315120593,
-0.0489912815,
0.041756127,
-0.0839235261,
0.0346430168,
0.0416786335,
0.0142120328,
-0.0012818419,
0.0261274688,
-0.0208885316,
-0.0072225477,
-0.0204880852,
-0.0161489882,
0.0044503789,
-0.0245771222,
-0.0169970989,
-0.0444753729,
0.073778905,
0.0555580854,
-0.0157842543,
-0.019046016,
-0.0211847033,
2.578e-7,
0.0315824151,
0.0461042225,
0.0875449032,
-0.0176080056,
-0.0015488002,
-0.0341141261,
-0.0122927232,
0.0210101604,
-0.0814974979,
-0.0045471475,
0.0176766589,
-0.003693548,
0.0240717493,
0.0053199101,
-0.038311556,
0.0251831356,
-0.0445850939,
-0.0020195702,
-0.022011565,
-0.0030363158,
0.0099281697,
0.0533288158,
0.0362110063,
-0.0113647217,
-0.0366022326,
-0.0307263024,
0.010745788,
-0.0522167534,
0.0373105071,
0.0216282532,
-0.0118887369,
-0.0282761622,
0.0233478025,
-0.0132387858,
-0.035233736,
0.0124786347,
0.0161165986,
0.0250592493,
0.0054952567,
0.0517705679,
0.0270246416,
-0.0404999368,
-0.0595855527,
-0.0210259985,
0.0374103971,
0.0493310094,
-0.0284988303,
0.0279881563,
0.0326862298,
0.021049099,
0.0047928165,
-0.0000179958,
-0.0065433169,
0.0045668739,
0.0176664703,
0.0090623591,
0.0094597116,
-0.0303774085,
-0.0223730914,
0.0492404699,
0.0154107558,
-0.0508158095,
-0.0384096839,
0.0186093021,
0.0259235874,
-0.0403354168,
-0.0142180873,
2.276913731e-34,
0.0258736834,
-0.0135569656,
0.0168219674,
-0.0092982836,
0.0106090773,
-0.0378201269,
0.0237313136,
0.0314922072,
0.03435174,
-0.0368345417,
-0.0233496893
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.10093v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.10093v2 | Investigating the Role of Attribute Context in Vision-Language Models for Object Recognition and Detection | 2023-03-17T16:14:37 | 2023-11-06T20:58:11 | Kyle Buettner, Adriana Kovashka | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Vision-language alignment learned from image-caption pairs has been shown to
benefit tasks like object recognition and detection. Methods are mostly
evaluated in terms of how well object class names are learned, but captions
also contain rich attribute context that should be considered when learning
object alignment. It is unclear how methods use this context in learning, as
well as whether models succeed when tasks require attribute and object
understanding. To address this gap, we conduct extensive analysis of the role
of attributes in vision-language models. We specifically measure model
sensitivity to the presence and meaning of attribute context, gauging influence
on object embeddings through unsupervised phrase grounding and classification
via description methods. We further evaluate the utility of attribute context
in training for open-vocabulary object detection, fine-grained text-region
retrieval, and attribution tasks. Our results show that attribute context can
be wasted when learning alignment for detection, attribute meaning is not
adequately considered in embeddings, and describing classes by only their
attributes is ineffective. A viable strategy that we find to increase benefits
from attributes is contrastive training with adjective-based negative captions. | [
0.0167693943,
0.0523025729,
0.0101890769,
0.0722060055,
-0.0062121083,
0.0284048896,
0.0103925364,
-0.0056258217,
-0.0485037491,
-0.0949006975,
-0.0549258925,
-0.0000897025,
0.0129852993,
0.0256593116,
-0.0005745405,
-0.0120292641,
0.0119990492,
0.0030768076,
-0.0305529144,
0.0402958728,
0.0301683899,
-0.0055531757,
0.0223686025,
0.0082888585,
-0.0131016169,
0.0207497682,
-0.0003830035,
0.0120949345,
0.0364217125,
-0.0294405054,
-0.0201577432,
0.0679875016,
0.0390822105,
-0.0093922839,
0.0000016015,
-0.0415932387,
0.0298336502,
0.0294767972,
-0.005396842,
-0.0117620053,
0.0665401816,
-0.0159701034,
0.0381667763,
-0.0338842049,
-0.012336784,
-0.0549137853,
0.0974837914,
0.0639677942,
0.0057676872,
0.0190213006,
-0.0239055101,
-0.0576935746,
0.0093101328,
-0.027417805,
0.0277739242,
-0.0440815464,
0.0317905918,
-0.0110081034,
-0.0373147577,
0.0563305356,
-0.0390693136,
0.0224091876,
-0.0209565368,
0.0294188466,
0.0514193214,
0.0580759533,
-0.0397412367,
-0.0351178423,
0.0087109925,
0.064868629,
0.0280626994,
-0.0183849037,
-0.0283560529,
0.0058714156,
0.0108242417,
-0.013364031,
-0.0173277445,
0.0386153832,
-0.0051942053,
0.0121344337,
-0.023030512,
0.0217642821,
-0.0005458756,
0.0262034964,
0.0148320375,
-0.0186143965,
-0.0089718476,
0.0123205287,
-0.0187024232,
0.0304167531,
-0.0668342113,
-0.0413988605,
-0.0259180665,
-0.0131137343,
0.0355364233,
0.0078793261,
-0.0515913256,
-0.0129040955,
-0.0080297301,
-0.0235360749,
0.0123591879,
0.0029693174,
-0.0888939351,
0.080853872,
-0.0590518266,
0.0771808624,
-0.0241738744,
0.0425746255,
-0.025594864,
-0.0065909717,
-0.0392656401,
0.0013222615,
-0.0361425057,
0.0079432949,
0.0090038478,
-0.0247351006,
-0.0009072557,
-0.0204024538,
-0.0128208632,
0.0162449572,
-0.0252676252,
0.0126822684,
-0.0580324829,
0.0131111201,
-0.0205326509,
0.0228747111,
-0.0153006315,
0.0301028434,
-0.0328689367,
-0.0210980605,
-0.00961845,
0.0376446322,
0.0249723773,
-0.0497788489,
-0.0099844728,
0.0619768016,
-0.0077428785,
-0.0820388943,
-0.0227054786,
-0.0115787312,
-0.037087623,
-0.0277736578,
0.0152299404,
-0.0318992883,
-0.0070561999,
0.0156432483,
0.0083956281,
-0.0484547988,
0.0204348397,
-0.0093361763,
-0.0124230534,
0.1026462317,
-0.0249977317,
-0.0249148123,
-0.0116632497,
-0.0052051684,
0.0148846414,
0.0474975668,
-0.0193317756,
0.035637401,
-0.0077276863,
-0.0096505536,
0.023643434,
-0.0167402923,
0.0127390791,
0.0398617759,
-0.0664784163,
0.0143724242,
0.0315842107,
0.0169957858,
0.0265529621,
-0.0073635466,
0.0028495393,
-0.0327631123,
0.0781232044,
0.0213573948,
-0.0465755053,
-0.0065995925,
0.0221596863,
-0.003777775,
-0.0365027674,
-0.004250362,
-0.0735474974,
0.0591170825,
-0.0251872092,
0.0231484547,
-0.0490587503,
0.0202099327,
-0.0367352143,
-0.0375834778,
-0.0422894359,
-0.0220142249,
0.031202171,
0.0035738673,
0.0620728619,
-0.0012011701,
0.0008055249,
-0.0104361475,
0.027327925,
-0.0187664796,
-0.0184156727,
-0.0488924943,
0.0076087872,
0.0328163318,
-0.0047128173,
-0.0099027995,
-0.0150839295,
-0.0052014771,
0.088851735,
0.0341048837,
0.0136169903,
0.0158327408,
0.0107250689,
-0.0356406532,
-0.072289139,
-0.0319118127,
0.0006776578,
-0.0001350681,
0.0155917592,
-0.0038230668,
0.0335873254,
-0.041162286,
-0.0526093021,
0.0616809726,
0.0696277693,
-0.0305249859,
-0.0375386775,
0.0556587689,
-0.0141463941,
-0.0248267632,
-0.0165214762,
-0.010082243,
-0.0052738101,
-0.0148672294,
0.0015845284,
0.0463802628,
-0.021755971,
-0.0066515245,
0.0062133255,
-0.0168739781,
-0.0185479317,
-0.0290343743,
-0.011543096,
-0.0076992433,
0.0217799321,
-0.0310686529,
-0.0099621918,
-0.0294918157,
0.0377825014,
-0.0346650518,
0.0133630978,
-0.0333938189,
0.0654798299,
0.0029825389,
0.0261344463,
-0.0055077015,
0.0067958659,
0.0473190509,
-0.0285627525,
-0.0197435766,
-0.0254288837,
0.0029288793,
0.0153736798,
0.0376749448,
0.0069386349,
-0.0236751195,
0.0134584997,
-0.0301458444,
-0.0160577614,
-0.0133838449,
0.0013885195,
-0.0114292204,
-0.0305929426,
0.0282241311,
-0.0355012976,
-0.0317400694,
0.0199992657,
-0.0611605905,
0.0172344595,
0.0499020927,
0.0311695486,
-0.0545383543,
-0.0251346137,
0.0144831631,
0.0026381707,
0.0631582215,
0.0332504399,
-0.0232503377,
-0.0307301506,
0.0356292203,
-0.0162357017,
0.0331703536,
0.0038809236,
-0.0467786305,
0.0190649517,
0.0035405662,
-0.014386721,
0.1195009574,
-0.0063262489,
0.0363051966,
0.032755468,
0.0218717959,
-0.0263014864,
-0.0249927994,
-0.0008250575,
-0.0530440882,
-0.0003160559,
-0.0252981987,
-0.0086022094,
0.0943785161,
-0.0421478823,
-0.0048684678,
-0.0929559171,
0.0256021358,
-0.0309982542,
-0.0353354029,
-0.0421602726,
0.0258178711,
0.0287233181,
0.0432409309,
-0.0689858422,
-0.0673680827,
0.0398379862,
-0.0570331551,
-0.0101094525,
0.016120825,
-0.022644382,
-0.0157164056,
0.0659727901,
0.0297465362,
0.044476565,
0.0300394837,
0.0002896583,
-0.0287808031,
-0.0113238515,
0.0417009071,
0.0095148589,
0.032029558,
-0.0226337574,
0.0266223345,
-0.0428376347,
-0.0053771697,
-0.0074862,
-0.0175574627,
-0.0269361157,
0.0107253678,
-0.1020333171,
-0.005385288,
-0.0447430499,
0.0443881974,
0.0139824031,
0.0222015399,
-0.008918657,
-0.0170620084,
0.001969794,
0.0057623652,
0.0456090532,
-0.0167616121,
-0.0511756949,
-0.0047094235,
-0.0041069686,
0.0240830928,
0.0050762794,
0.0254790317,
-0.0454364233,
0.0115176803,
0.0237390697,
0.0227234084,
-0.0260212366,
0.0130953779,
0.0390346311,
-0.030669488,
-0.0579888672,
0.051776465,
0.0206390042,
-0.0196977258,
-0.0373221375,
0.016662566,
0.0177010037,
0.0651364848,
-0.0141174756,
-0.0723558143,
-0.0520998389,
-0.023290256,
-0.0355637223,
0.044429455,
0.027231494,
-0.0141962208,
-0.0669874251,
0.0280972105,
0.0059781675,
-0.0910857916,
-0.07645946,
0.0120408665,
0.0332919694,
-0.0514988452,
-0.0199371446,
-0.0426613316,
0.0004495642,
0.0079251723,
0.0237784032,
0.0780005977,
-0.0038458181,
0.0218287837,
-0.0766057149,
0.0063757552,
0.0628184676,
0.0056301309,
-0.0165561996,
-0.0453442112,
-0.0163849052,
-0.032332968,
0.0059277508,
0.0147383697,
0.0480849333,
-0.0460563004,
-0.0509391129,
0.042171672,
0.0128404545,
-0.013248357,
-0.0292484201,
-0.0389867462,
0.0084321816,
0.0042591216,
0.0166341364,
-0.036795076,
-0.0230593644,
0.0061234008,
0.056999892,
0.0145935081,
-0.0248363446,
-0.0100120408,
0.0217854492,
-0.0129361684,
0.0013838415,
-0.0308452919,
0.0296741929,
-0.0383640751,
-0.0139716128,
-0.0574936904,
-0.0046984563,
0.0396756195,
0.0189462211,
0.0189989191,
-0.029682586,
-0.047989402,
0.0081910202,
-0.0923593789,
0.0875686482,
-0.0290212147,
0.0320421644,
-0.0196064021,
-0.0337800048,
0.0614273176,
-0.0553327836,
-0.0264642406,
0.0139508341,
-0.0433380865,
-0.0195350684,
-0.00289132,
0.0315140337,
0.0093349116,
0.0465628766,
0.0007475506,
-0.0391814299,
-0.0215899087,
0.0311617143,
0.0080118151,
0.0205674861,
0.0068398379,
-0.0235058311,
-0.0135311913,
0.013804514,
-0.0378495976,
0.0306293555,
0.0462923124,
-0.0267388355,
-0.0077712848,
-0.0475645028,
0.017128326,
-0.0085962806,
0.0585427433,
-0.0141454451,
0.014868143,
-0.0191990361,
0.0001350152,
0.0326721482,
-0.0187650416,
-0.0364668071,
-0.0267844126,
0.0025253217,
0.0335796848,
0.0316273905,
0.0199707448,
0.0048560109,
0.0565888323,
-0.0397975482,
-0.013159371,
0.0033187771,
-0.0252721962,
-0.0253161322,
0.04835812,
-0.0124554839,
0.00022462,
-0.0082685761,
0.0484342501,
-0.0074257967,
0.0720558763,
0.022954857,
0.0160000231,
-0.0441052355,
0.0436869264,
0.0106848981,
0.0727863237,
-0.0539720021,
0.0596897788,
-0.006794496,
-0.0783870742,
-0.0151178828,
-0.0370118879,
-0.0165543724,
0.0089141959,
0.0429627523,
0.0159387477,
-0.0188949052,
0.0728998259,
0.0519987307,
-0.0146803875,
-0.0309806503,
0.0475852489,
0.0783157796,
0.03959224,
-0.0163964685,
-0.0159391295,
-0.0057472698,
0.0116775893,
0.0415510722,
-0.0138847707,
-0.0044072489,
0.0482009202,
-0.020987412,
-0.0473387167,
-0.0433425829,
0.0078544831,
-0.0070290966,
0.0169313662,
0.0550514013,
0.0367994718,
0.0160996653,
-0.018301934,
0.002026967,
-0.0595310703,
0.001926753,
0.0484931655,
-0.0064912187,
-5.16275723e-33,
-0.0682197511,
-0.0387077741,
0.0163233578,
0.0359706394,
-0.0190309417,
0.023458397,
-0.0117426533,
0.0185203906,
-0.0370832123,
0.0392187908,
0.0417584814,
-0.0159202125,
0.0077826246,
0.0258566011,
0.0098476205,
-0.0240938477,
0.0321489535,
0.0084017916,
-0.0110633383,
-0.0114821615,
0.0282922909,
-0.0271775424,
0.0799600258,
-0.0854475424,
-0.0026190311,
0.0159485005,
-0.0163866989,
0.0308989771,
0.0394091457,
0.0506973825,
-0.0024572231,
0.0156364869,
0.0108021079,
-0.0456809886,
-0.0022115926,
-0.0009667506,
-0.0821462199,
0.0050396025,
0.0527787507,
0.0639146566,
-0.0225942191,
-0.0120095164,
0.0417491868,
-0.0374680422,
0.0125509948,
-0.0123220868,
0.0569159389,
-0.0473875217,
-0.0011816247,
0.0024756775,
-0.0894653052,
0.0019754067,
-0.0150062824,
-0.0305004846,
0.0916098505,
-0.0636978596,
0.0415762737,
0.0540307276,
0.0086710462,
0.03199213,
0.0007317274,
0.0344831198,
0.0608752966,
0.0871349126,
-0.0035695168,
0.073598139,
0.0461793393,
0.0023562615,
-0.0078370394,
0.0002982722,
0.0297855623,
0.0501024574,
0.0496569015,
0.0749816447,
0.0140355071,
0.0258211326,
-0.0230209995,
0.0088686803,
-0.0782333389,
0.0508415587,
0.0180583224,
0.0202017091,
-0.0511975251,
0.0083036711,
-0.0538370945,
-0.0164271761,
-0.0799652115,
0.0128687415,
0.0484777205,
0.0200134907,
-0.053962253,
0.0628377944,
0.0554503612,
0.0008823309,
0.0037598312,
-0.0053267614,
-0.0004994114,
0.0482096225,
-0.0396863297,
-0.0312775038,
-0.0259834807,
-0.057195507,
0.0581111237,
0.0240241811,
0.0269112103,
0.0122425444,
0.0883386731,
-0.0224177223,
-0.0336257108,
-0.0058215414,
-0.0495413467,
-0.0240487102,
-0.0194117744,
0.0251110103,
0.024558261,
0.0332303382,
-0.059075214,
0.0659170896,
0.0283072721,
-0.04535795,
-0.0435796902,
-0.0245053545,
0.0058267405,
0.0017859414,
-0.0258520376,
-0.0113056488,
-0.0162883289,
-0.0643216074,
0.0270726178,
-0.0433754325,
-0.0080866776,
0.0241054855,
2.278e-7,
0.0235639531,
0.0040541012,
0.0374235287,
0.0155309848,
-0.0190234333,
0.0807370394,
-0.0299159139,
-0.0001181274,
-0.0029355753,
-0.0428492203,
0.0133501664,
0.0426582918,
0.0105830366,
-0.0161222797,
-0.0142601868,
0.0838451087,
-0.0074425084,
0.0109405778,
-0.05731811,
-0.0193401687,
0.0343671851,
0.1070672497,
-0.0308721345,
0.0042351908,
0.030994704,
-0.0622377582,
0.0682752952,
-0.0433728211,
0.0320147201,
-0.0124558061,
-0.0136255966,
0.0514344499,
-0.0373391993,
0.0633836091,
-0.0010726439,
-0.002194189,
0.0698051229,
0.0214068145,
-0.0465342924,
0.0206178837,
-0.0351788811,
0.0043886309,
-0.0047296407,
-0.0497786142,
0.0604091436,
-0.0652439296,
-0.0024334616,
-0.0394584127,
-0.0122313481,
-0.0084564583,
0.0090461485,
0.0054982575,
-0.0050072582,
0.0078250123,
0.0134041831,
0.0090898871,
-0.062728934,
-0.0777876675,
-0.0485390238,
-0.0083287191,
-0.003831055,
-0.0217762683,
-0.0273731221,
0.0201396234,
0.0397711918,
-0.0334079228,
-0.0582117736,
1.502449839e-34,
-0.0044086189,
0.0236779582,
0.0018674152,
0.0361742564,
0.0096008014,
-0.0113292858,
-0.0263048057,
0.0003688653,
-0.0148423314,
-0.0305572599,
0.0082068285
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.09905v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09905v1 | More Robust Schema-Guided Dialogue State Tracking via Tree-Based Paraphrase Ranking | 2023-03-17T11:43:08 | 2023-03-17T11:43:08 | A. Coca, B. H. Tseng, W. Lin, B. Byrne | cs.CL | cs.CL | The schema-guided paradigm overcomes scalability issues inherent in building
task-oriented dialogue (TOD) agents with static ontologies. Instead of
operating on dialogue context alone, agents have access to hierarchical schemas
containing task-relevant natural language descriptions. Fine-tuned language
models excel at schema-guided dialogue state tracking (DST) but are sensitive
to the writing style of the schemas. We explore methods for improving the
robustness of DST models. We propose a framework for generating synthetic
schemas which uses tree-based ranking to jointly optimise lexical diversity and
semantic faithfulness. The generalisation of strong baselines is improved when
augmenting their training data with prompts generated by our framework, as
demonstrated by marked improvements in average joint goal accuracy (JGA) and
schema sensitivity (SS) on the SGD-X benchmark. | [
0.0711085647,
0.0270111263,
-0.0117852325,
0.0374304913,
-0.0270890929,
-0.0256091114,
-0.0415226705,
-0.0002305648,
0.0136904903,
-0.0934467241,
-0.018000342,
-0.0322783254,
-0.0231988579,
0.030364804,
-0.0340902843,
-0.0799132735,
0.0713604316,
-0.0269745849,
-0.0146994321,
0.0068881391,
0.0087927133,
0.0219535995,
0.004565448,
0.0426772572,
0.01573129,
0.0055366894,
-0.0016605451,
0.0134018362,
0.0230260789,
-0.0209996104,
0.0136303157,
0.0180133488,
0.0174286757,
0.0146911154,
0.0000018823,
-0.0575092509,
-0.0349943601,
-0.0154837063,
-0.0405338295,
-0.0384733938,
0.0322850645,
0.0192133505,
0.0057390369,
0.0162199195,
-0.056957379,
0.0194480531,
0.020272227,
0.0388518646,
0.1046530753,
0.067142874,
-0.009502708,
-0.0341241099,
0.0244731642,
0.0024921454,
-0.0031914134,
-0.0825928003,
-0.022102965,
0.0259570386,
-0.0032488534,
0.0562307015,
0.0146863917,
-0.0002925623,
-0.0275370907,
-0.0061931671,
0.0329749882,
-0.0286223684,
-0.0365786478,
-0.0086823348,
-0.0288938619,
0.0842843726,
0.0176563077,
0.0041830516,
0.008161746,
-0.0275510103,
-0.0177073777,
-0.0191812683,
-0.0314642973,
0.0054059541,
-0.0442916714,
0.0129679367,
0.010324602,
0.0114578269,
-0.022136068,
-0.001089589,
-0.0218118913,
0.0598333254,
0.0014203788,
-0.0334297046,
-0.0466732569,
-0.0208674874,
0.0036976491,
-0.0582616478,
0.0005430331,
-0.0054619047,
-0.0796582028,
0.0536805987,
-0.0771892816,
-0.0279453155,
0.01290006,
-0.0430843495,
0.0547428876,
0.0441059247,
0.0023961859,
0.0074176933,
0.0220088474,
0.0844562426,
-0.0193654597,
0.0328387469,
-0.0349227376,
-0.0315576568,
-0.0931991264,
0.0211873017,
-0.0610824414,
0.0544239767,
-0.0507941991,
-0.0394972824,
-0.0460890122,
0.0397808328,
0.0402710252,
0.008822537,
0.0197676718,
0.0315563753,
-0.0559474155,
0.0058084908,
-0.0265674442,
-0.0039571556,
-0.005841604,
0.0028594721,
0.0084101213,
-0.0327728763,
-0.0003091804,
0.027264677,
0.0376487114,
-0.0189350862,
-0.0071172668,
0.0694540665,
-0.0033796371,
-0.0588319525,
-0.0152035244,
-0.0375579782,
-0.0469195992,
-0.021386493,
-0.0346602276,
-0.012434951,
0.0377396159,
-0.0142264357,
0.0067509473,
-0.0459990092,
0.0268869363,
0.0518577918,
-0.0342423245,
0.0602478422,
-0.027288964,
-0.037471056,
-0.0536332726,
-0.0024663485,
-0.0587377325,
0.0165808704,
0.0398555286,
0.0389457978,
0.0587456264,
0.0441154093,
-0.0307321344,
-0.0284614824,
-0.0129105253,
0.024357127,
0.0095694652,
0.0589640662,
-0.0004624373,
0.007572127,
0.0004440857,
0.0373858027,
-0.0142210135,
0.0147458231,
0.0866763741,
0.0456314422,
-0.0087499414,
-0.0257364418,
0.0459049903,
0.0504548773,
-0.0174870621,
0.0193616785,
-0.0222333446,
-0.0098957894,
-0.0145005509,
0.0291581377,
-0.016244866,
0.0161898192,
0.0082698315,
-0.0612263903,
-0.0292458795,
0.0100541897,
-0.0078044981,
-0.0037160316,
-0.003856241,
0.0298873913,
-0.0699796081,
0.0514420532,
-0.0080483714,
-0.061995402,
-0.0506104007,
-0.0228655878,
-0.0049815532,
0.1091359481,
0.0625348389,
-0.0274718162,
-0.0690641925,
-0.0095923478,
0.0131330332,
0.0791871101,
0.0037010538,
-0.0331825912,
0.0700899512,
-0.0457856767,
-0.0312106088,
-0.0185151119,
0.0150775863,
0.0007518883,
0.0358490124,
-0.0376738161,
0.0289660506,
-0.0222481787,
-0.0274962969,
0.0403115898,
0.0120515777,
0.0005759025,
0.020328356,
-0.0187643245,
0.0409188792,
0.0432413891,
-0.0266539343,
0.0221969392,
-0.0054735146,
-0.0071054846,
-0.0257090144,
0.0293385815,
-0.0555841811,
-0.0322627798,
0.0033146893,
0.0419268273,
-0.0138402265,
0.0345493406,
-0.0184037425,
-0.0553600788,
-0.0417629406,
-0.0452894568,
0.0121518588,
-0.0582000166,
0.0309521947,
0.0014368733,
-0.0173482597,
-0.0451929085,
0.0736818165,
0.0180760901,
-0.0089647351,
0.0405886285,
-0.0134194279,
0.042499885,
-0.0172648262,
0.0163621586,
0.0177786574,
0.0202475786,
0.0229974687,
0.0424660631,
0.0162778124,
-0.0473575816,
-0.0138626229,
-0.0637305975,
0.0155938789,
-0.0270179436,
0.0072205663,
0.0168774147,
0.0131263165,
0.0221154038,
-0.0317885801,
-0.0206008386,
-0.002256792,
0.0341243185,
-0.0206402838,
0.0440856479,
0.0313723981,
-0.0446157269,
-0.0659785867,
0.0354677513,
-0.0067405812,
-0.0072477171,
-0.0059760311,
0.0074401316,
-0.0626822188,
0.0441514663,
-0.0425573364,
0.0453491062,
-0.0069160932,
0.0016566423,
0.0242731944,
0.0196807478,
0.0017273442,
0.0602240078,
0.0465450287,
-0.0018182092,
0.0303660631,
-0.0022646417,
-0.0458566397,
0.0129226185,
0.0152417235,
0.0398362279,
-0.0461782664,
-0.0198557936,
0.0496510044,
0.0335207842,
0.0504081696,
-0.0042309719,
-0.0716339946,
-0.0180620588,
-0.0087860422,
-0.0056978641,
0.0031213085,
-0.0257718228,
-0.042852547,
0.02859056,
-0.0278421659,
-0.0503341369,
0.0713350028,
-0.0598201863,
-0.0001064439,
-0.0812407061,
-0.016178241,
-0.0571997017,
0.0731011927,
-0.014750571,
0.0408745296,
0.0214899667,
-0.0135098277,
-0.0330936387,
-0.0551883578,
0.0657220259,
-0.0107177831,
0.043042358,
-0.058812011,
0.0421298444,
0.0081655653,
-0.032329265,
-0.066323176,
-0.0363043286,
-0.0145643977,
0.0229124799,
0.0277898796,
-0.017609736,
0.0051562628,
0.0016330193,
0.0050535286,
0.0800463334,
0.0189740807,
-0.0246001109,
-0.048050914,
0.0381292962,
0.0422017649,
0.0048245685,
-0.0071990383,
-0.0057881055,
0.0669470578,
0.0125522418,
0.081658341,
-0.0129316133,
0.00321437,
-0.0361133218,
-0.0047376142,
-0.0445598438,
-0.0463858768,
0.0187778156,
0.0381585918,
-0.0175367929,
-0.0249547996,
0.1094478518,
0.0437218361,
0.0170130488,
0.0071047479,
-0.0213545822,
0.0352318101,
0.0250548888,
0.0153921964,
-0.0705996007,
-0.0439280905,
-0.0016388824,
0.0180519521,
-0.0101004699,
-0.0385244302,
-0.0427054726,
-0.0706884935,
0.0162758902,
-0.0110785533,
-0.0498113334,
-0.0040451763,
0.007757917,
0.0240952224,
0.0063634468,
0.012129386,
-0.0021379297,
-0.020083556,
-0.0110268835,
-0.0084096882,
-0.0165787674,
-0.017417524,
0.027723683,
-0.0491556302,
0.0295226481,
0.0786354467,
0.0571591109,
0.0526988134,
0.0445419326,
0.0026509138,
-0.009920192,
0.0232157819,
0.0134946341,
0.037119925,
-0.0516869649,
0.0081731342,
0.0039290455,
-0.0057995999,
-0.0288036801,
0.0227047708,
0.0104473382,
0.0174669027,
-0.0458871387,
0.0318165608,
0.0062249945,
-0.0143983532,
0.0139275817,
0.0460886247,
0.0046355999,
-0.0099141132,
-0.0253786203,
-0.0041409386,
-0.0061006602,
-0.043538373,
-0.0151758064,
0.0349773429,
-0.0299958754,
0.0303125922,
-0.0899748132,
-0.0635058284,
-0.0082845613,
0.0240761768,
-0.015440884,
0.076750569,
0.0008448494,
0.024208894,
0.018604761,
-0.0257583484,
-0.0531087331,
0.0120241074,
-0.0125035951,
-0.0221302714,
0.0691795647,
-0.0083228415,
-0.0157937948,
0.0322161019,
-0.0651375428,
-0.0402239785,
-0.0145756761,
0.0450030193,
0.021214962,
0.0302235316,
0.0097972136,
0.0291599557,
-0.0320002139,
0.0049836524,
-0.0278342776,
0.004176626,
0.05515505,
0.0095845778,
-0.0157702304,
0.0719504207,
-0.0514185354,
0.0278003924,
-0.0289502405,
0.0794147328,
-0.0096955393,
-0.0708607286,
0.0424149446,
0.006167498,
-0.0300848465,
-0.0057915496,
-0.0153693389,
-0.0098734647,
0.0807448849,
-0.0343764648,
-0.0417311415,
-0.0629091114,
0.0236814357,
-0.0258602705,
-0.0301992018,
0.0013916512,
0.0115861623,
-0.0667861775,
0.0555138737,
-0.0338767581,
-0.0347233377,
-0.0014494555,
-0.0084747663,
0.0069232951,
-0.0252148118,
-0.0302479565,
0.0292610582,
0.0033553073,
0.030431902,
0.0115254223,
0.0469451286,
0.0155264512,
-0.0579350404,
-0.0264948197,
0.0485384986,
-0.0928767025,
-0.078534171,
-0.0266482215,
0.0347905755,
0.0589268953,
0.0250257589,
0.0832391828,
-0.0390659459,
0.015046563,
0.0254029501,
0.0496984608,
0.0399707593,
-0.014162383,
0.0017859221,
0.0131819062,
-0.0012449441,
0.047347486,
0.079631187,
0.0544842072,
0.0303923395,
0.0088125672,
-0.02638999,
-0.0712658018,
-0.0413384363,
0.0156841706,
0.0502218306,
0.0104179187,
-0.0066488869,
-0.0465725362,
-0.033767473,
0.0484389253,
-0.0171871595,
-0.001181635,
-0.055896759,
0.06534601,
0.0365039669,
0.00368096,
-0.0342668667,
-0.0311229359,
-0.0357981883,
0.0013764364,
0.0215059016,
-0.0464976169,
-5.362104174e-33,
-0.0559736714,
-0.0216875132,
0.0141155906,
-0.0053411471,
-0.010212847,
-0.0152720008,
-0.0401254185,
-0.0335236974,
-0.0187418722,
-0.0281785019,
-0.0205195118,
0.0499485545,
0.024698453,
0.0398301929,
-0.0116537772,
-0.0330999829,
0.0420960709,
0.0029784276,
-0.018165525,
0.0039894367,
0.0432310328,
-0.0018278759,
0.0454778783,
-0.0607162416,
0.0394054838,
0.0134224994,
0.0010505473,
0.0137896687,
0.0267278999,
0.0404450968,
-0.002081705,
0.0522798672,
0.0134758074,
-0.040198829,
-0.032674171,
-0.0099070519,
-0.0155457854,
-0.0199763402,
0.0452752709,
-0.0275103711,
-0.0229529552,
0.0077291243,
-0.0114407632,
-0.0481490977,
0.0017074527,
0.0443494581,
0.0091085136,
-0.0297646746,
-0.0162917618,
-0.0185645837,
-0.0848788768,
0.0249139909,
0.0444759391,
-0.0516762435,
-0.0563269854,
0.0590462014,
0.0126321968,
0.0232977532,
0.0035942725,
0.0273322724,
-0.0245146155,
0.0016587009,
-0.0080884835,
0.0163353942,
-0.0053585139,
0.0816880837,
0.0085030515,
0.0406669453,
0.0247081295,
-0.0512132905,
-0.0351373926,
0.0271109585,
0.0198071431,
0.0454384238,
-0.0123746442,
0.0555846542,
-0.0463681035,
0.0224997308,
0.0402977653,
0.0182509832,
0.0200842507,
0.0257687699,
-0.062474031,
0.0015758221,
-0.0432141051,
0.0379478112,
-0.0044284775,
-0.0336394832,
0.0526743047,
0.0127596566,
-0.0339985602,
-0.0119959777,
0.0462384783,
-0.0170330051,
3.589e-7,
0.0389073975,
-0.0341052674,
0.0098320302,
-0.0068131392,
0.0369931795,
-0.0330044106,
-0.0225305576,
0.0459571034,
0.0106195211,
0.0114346417,
-0.0062298286,
-0.0198783167,
-0.0045526931,
-0.052437406,
0.0137936221,
-0.0115390597,
0.0121814255,
-0.0834403038,
0.0169895403,
0.0295005571,
0.0213526599,
-0.0112911304,
0.0915122703,
0.0059640394,
-0.0122388909,
-0.0297799502,
0.0046949023,
0.0058003049,
0.0193014592,
0.0168373417,
0.0004077875,
-0.0203122497,
-0.0359121226,
-0.0462488271,
-0.0280604251,
0.0059230211,
-0.0299516898,
2.683e-7,
-0.0091487793,
0.0305521414,
0.0276721492,
0.0494083911,
-0.002958254,
0.0376988277,
0.0359355584,
0.058660727,
-0.0240770318,
-0.0743714571,
0.0230451375,
-0.0085766073,
0.0135252355,
0.015368754,
-0.1227665693,
-0.0283199381,
-0.0337884724,
-0.0214523189,
-0.042574849,
0.0030804926,
0.0506195761,
0.0843853727,
-0.027854519,
0.0103594689,
-0.0112269027,
-0.0110265203,
0.0456603207,
0.0028797681,
-0.0119325006,
0.0122020813,
-0.0016444788,
-0.0152420877,
-0.0346193425,
0.0415234566,
0.0195132587,
0.0499413908,
0.0039312425,
0.0501714572,
-0.0279189833,
-0.0341540799,
-0.0446567014,
-0.0234842207,
-0.0036889408,
-0.0300804246,
0.0255437978,
-0.0231530257,
-0.0063217129,
-0.0092067961,
-0.011314054,
0.0255923066,
-0.0280937199,
0.0103863291,
-0.026632363,
-0.0084302723,
0.0015486906,
0.0159238745,
0.0026691353,
-0.0675479174,
-0.0141206207,
-0.0051285513,
-0.0245328974,
-0.0540226139,
-0.0113098063,
0.0061399075,
0.0121882996,
-0.0477274172,
-0.0036703707,
2.672376893e-34,
0.0418389812,
0.0093231341,
0.0176179409,
0.0492155813,
0.0357614122,
0.0119971028,
-0.0051840572,
-0.0177133996,
0.0638307855,
-0.0476712584,
-0.0180696379
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.09901v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09901v3 | mCPT at SemEval-2023 Task 3: Multilingual Label-Aware Contrastive Pre-Training of Transformers for Few- and Zero-shot Framing Detection | 2023-03-17T11:33:06 | 2023-08-01T15:16:52 | Markus Reiter-Haas, Alexander Ertl, Kevin Innerebner, Elisabeth Lex | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, I.2.7; I.7; J.7 | This paper presents the winning system for the zero-shot Spanish framing
detection task, which also achieves competitive places in eight additional
languages. The challenge of the framing detection task lies in identifying a
set of 14 frames when only a few or zero samples are available, i.e., a
multilingual multi-label few- or zero-shot setting. Our developed solution
employs a pre-training procedure based on multilingual Transformers using a
label-aware contrastive loss function. In addition to describing the system, we
perform an embedding space analysis and ablation study to demonstrate how our
pre-training procedure supports framing detection to advance computational
framing analysis. | [
-0.0595092736,
-0.0011508546,
0.0075272596,
0.0485739186,
-0.000636738,
-0.0017147311,
0.0242507122,
0.0429451428,
-0.057947062,
-0.0326416865,
-0.0437736474,
-0.0247697569,
0.0091242995,
-0.0035102668,
0.0026994636,
-0.0626913533,
0.0313227028,
0.003106501,
-0.014753663,
-0.016354233,
0.0158894565,
-0.0121156741,
-0.0318098627,
-0.0136996582,
-0.0618629046,
-0.0100225685,
0.0069104792,
-0.0306606349,
0.0711930469,
-0.057232134,
0.0126924859,
0.0478375629,
0.0230055582,
0.0351264514,
0.0000019715,
-0.0275710709,
-0.0108619835,
0.010957743,
-0.0159673933,
-0.0240645651,
0.0581761189,
-0.0537401326,
-0.0225163754,
0.0013879931,
-0.0326905102,
-0.0584904179,
0.0589120798,
0.0215101521,
0.0211391803,
0.0419191569,
-0.04554056,
-0.0571303852,
-0.0630559474,
-0.0313019678,
-0.0092362855,
-0.0057940092,
0.0220539942,
-0.0469537526,
-0.0380615927,
0.018915046,
-0.0503428839,
0.0060782749,
0.0029300463,
-0.0078961505,
-0.0925711319,
0.0157305244,
-0.0432320945,
-0.0045686904,
-0.0137883816,
0.0487417281,
0.0414450206,
-0.0015576292,
-0.0223628208,
-0.0251845159,
-0.0155133568,
-0.0566331632,
-0.0327899642,
0.0304267704,
0.0257048886,
0.026852252,
0.0005874189,
0.0618790686,
-0.0205158833,
-0.0164055731,
-0.0032512802,
-0.0272758398,
0.0378516316,
-0.0048561529,
0.0102614872,
0.0132383602,
0.0271857399,
-0.0315466337,
0.0284837447,
-0.0156886391,
0.0200026743,
-0.0011360887,
-0.0221087765,
-0.0676207542,
0.0084997527,
-0.0182738192,
-0.0438540168,
0.021617176,
-0.0405481271,
0.0423777066,
-0.0480375811,
0.0634811148,
-0.050484743,
0.0501021072,
-0.0332221054,
0.0062949508,
-0.0321842618,
0.0035765108,
-0.035932824,
0.0186647028,
-0.054529421,
0.0097703673,
-0.0325218923,
-0.0214703884,
-0.0287414938,
0.0040479326,
-0.05367928,
0.0161488503,
-0.0115919095,
-0.0210744124,
0.003171616,
0.0923083723,
-0.0258752964,
-0.0147640184,
-0.0312677398,
-0.0695952103,
-0.0434882455,
0.075774543,
-0.0055085248,
-0.0452768691,
0.0262920149,
0.024045581,
-0.0381592065,
-0.0423634164,
0.0092201047,
-0.0134794014,
-0.0658410937,
-0.0355850756,
0.0115727773,
-0.0833033696,
0.023906894,
0.0099773891,
0.0168502964,
-0.0217988938,
-0.0083356006,
-0.0120027829,
0.0379378162,
0.07076253,
0.016620202,
-0.0435985103,
0.012312456,
0.0122750867,
0.0012486991,
0.1082474738,
-0.0304061733,
-0.0022894619,
0.0427612215,
0.0223522559,
0.0007299213,
0.0723170489,
-0.0047181193,
0.0422087796,
0.0084404079,
-0.0375715643,
0.0437659882,
-0.0015741804,
0.0553351566,
-0.0205283891,
-0.0165666156,
-0.0377269872,
0.0255639311,
0.0067814072,
0.005411583,
-0.0348334871,
0.0442389809,
0.0131754493,
-0.0271477345,
0.0670509785,
0.0173715763,
0.022152748,
0.0247155111,
-0.0273901783,
-0.0281259399,
0.0108606182,
-0.0439712964,
-0.0011048537,
0.0292884745,
0.0015314838,
-0.0303818956,
-0.0351389199,
0.084502995,
0.02536311,
-0.0673416927,
0.1354741901,
0.001895783,
-0.0269567389,
0.0280396566,
-0.0038953493,
-0.0301192962,
-0.0403765552,
-0.0087147336,
-0.0620003827,
-0.0071197236,
-0.0286897346,
0.0282753929,
0.06927111,
-0.0112649743,
0.0104935765,
0.0601007938,
-0.0292322934,
-0.0292606782,
-0.0351255648,
0.0103522819,
0.0517824292,
-0.0521605872,
0.0367563888,
-0.0224573314,
0.028913362,
0.0295399837,
0.0181912873,
0.0341867432,
-0.0380697437,
-0.0326242894,
0.0284228846,
0.0225987397,
0.0247183274,
-0.0299043972,
-0.0350262299,
0.0309271868,
-0.0460895598,
0.0189603791,
0.037432842,
-0.0780906677,
-0.0597880594,
0.0467637256,
-0.0885836929,
-0.0051186928,
0.0000263221,
-0.0503289849,
-0.0342452414,
0.0197974276,
0.0115614263,
-0.0093930773,
-0.0348566025,
-0.0078444444,
-0.0373784788,
0.0210339967,
0.0020108493,
0.0380230807,
0.0165408216,
0.0294984672,
0.0387563072,
-0.0062077222,
0.0627835989,
-0.0663601384,
-0.0094918059,
0.0212782919,
-0.0425994098,
-0.0187260173,
0.0414841622,
0.0132617373,
-0.0191026032,
0.0164192058,
-0.0626627356,
0.0018851168,
-0.0244390499,
0.0273741689,
0.0308953673,
-0.0232778043,
-0.0067672557,
-0.0376226753,
-0.0080227666,
-0.0422179922,
-0.0035708763,
0.0059262263,
0.0140084289,
0.0171265043,
-0.0094310334,
0.0184422471,
0.0117325233,
-0.0062276996,
0.0575875677,
-0.0171362571,
-0.0635126531,
-0.0440305956,
0.0156871472,
0.0526460744,
-0.0137199471,
-0.0037424425,
-0.0288687572,
-0.0056939721,
0.0386368781,
0.0161658172,
0.0564749725,
-0.0198178161,
0.0276631247,
0.021121297,
-0.0123686241,
0.0205964595,
0.000550136,
-0.0002041462,
-0.0105337994,
-0.0577336736,
-0.0395624638,
0.0027250077,
0.0563211404,
0.0023548489,
0.0501485355,
-0.055217661,
-0.0283137634,
-0.0297572538,
-0.0236093067,
-0.0095418775,
0.0281843636,
-0.0252922829,
0.0428483747,
-0.0098909438,
-0.0031477055,
0.0299630985,
-0.020711327,
-0.0520846359,
-0.0313030966,
0.0084807565,
-0.0246347301,
-0.0102918586,
0.0214367229,
0.0304565039,
0.0150139416,
-0.0455203354,
-0.075572066,
-0.045314867,
0.0512285158,
0.0024360842,
0.0479476526,
0.011522376,
-0.009848644,
-0.0431609899,
-0.0413692556,
-0.0275905859,
-0.018388778,
-0.0427688472,
-0.0026693447,
-0.0297163576,
0.0186095946,
-0.0663314536,
-0.0012221565,
-0.0003265,
0.0479662642,
-0.0040894588,
0.0173556916,
-0.0016833922,
0.1199428216,
-0.0252284873,
-0.0504051149,
0.0054087071,
-0.0608154461,
0.0369562507,
0.0533088334,
-0.0062502711,
0.038113229,
-0.034539137,
0.0242009163,
0.0213858448,
0.0262921564,
-0.018757537,
-0.0358503535,
0.0235722978,
-0.0179086942,
0.0150100738,
0.0719070882,
0.0106939422,
-0.0486185737,
-0.0505236126,
-0.0202566292,
0.0029249762,
0.0196872503,
0.013179726,
-0.1017179564,
-0.0519243404,
-0.0106153116,
-0.0239334423,
0.0023435429,
0.0051713027,
-0.0117411036,
-0.0936300308,
0.0411835387,
0.0157780778,
-0.0062389737,
0.0092139291,
-0.0404815413,
0.0085434234,
-0.0386733487,
0.0030481874,
-0.0383809619,
0.0246881973,
-0.0286721587,
0.0122597292,
0.0377582014,
-0.0397489332,
-0.0187307578,
-0.0288073253,
-0.0068460931,
-0.0220506396,
0.0358354636,
-0.0495896861,
-0.050925307,
-0.0292842854,
-0.0639369041,
-0.010826597,
-0.0159432292,
0.0944978148,
-0.0027554156,
-0.0281674433,
0.0180731844,
0.0005092202,
0.0020858636,
-0.0470842384,
0.0075882403,
0.0449725464,
0.0239503197,
0.0012875588,
0.0048667253,
0.0308131222,
0.0067800926,
0.0284909848,
0.0151785724,
-0.0194536876,
0.004315868,
0.0063299933,
0.042266041,
-0.0389092341,
0.0307827294,
-0.0116125494,
-0.018309176,
-0.0361082666,
-0.020960737,
0.0254654177,
0.0154445805,
0.0395890027,
-0.0063145715,
-0.0384832509,
-0.0221240297,
0.0108871786,
-0.0652173311,
0.0277553294,
-0.0203046463,
0.0258426275,
-0.0749063268,
0.027149545,
0.0573616512,
-0.0098445173,
-0.0257399511,
0.0293137021,
-0.0514323153,
-0.0502232425,
-0.0161132459,
0.0370844007,
0.0137061048,
0.0715265796,
0.0167971943,
0.0174649972,
0.0651380196,
0.0154872769,
0.0119941989,
0.0546784028,
0.0785576403,
-0.0642931685,
-0.047534626,
-0.001597425,
-0.014589658,
0.043467354,
0.0252359156,
-0.0003831651,
-0.006857981,
0.0386157446,
0.0211782046,
-0.0274767596,
0.0433477685,
-0.0622450411,
0.033323098,
-0.0286828186,
-0.001087434,
0.0130046727,
-0.011104947,
0.0008983502,
-0.0131525779,
0.001599042,
-0.0082420427,
0.0113651194,
0.0759875178,
-0.0509983264,
-0.0079153581,
0.0323637202,
0.0581131577,
0.0154544916,
0.0136626344,
-0.0037439433,
0.0559036955,
0.0312170517,
0.0160520971,
0.0192019213,
0.0416268371,
-0.029761197,
0.0678068697,
0.042088192,
-0.000521447,
0.0047499235,
0.0488705039,
0.0763822049,
0.0726552755,
-0.0290584862,
-0.0162153412,
0.0515017547,
-0.061902985,
0.0187293235,
0.0092615588,
-0.0407931507,
-0.0060007344,
0.0054861605,
-0.0163008459,
-0.0096953576,
0.0344815589,
0.01251416,
0.0099569159,
0.0301355924,
0.0599599965,
-0.047057353,
-0.0004210405,
0.0496035554,
-0.0013004532,
-0.0180972014,
0.0342470258,
0.0154244807,
-0.0147765456,
-0.0147861708,
0.0009264916,
-0.0591417067,
-0.0488116965,
0.0586509295,
-0.0496170111,
-0.0192022193,
0.0356470495,
0.0251341872,
0.0121306628,
0.0133023774,
0.0057791737,
0.0277373251,
-0.0261811595,
0.0074462527,
0.0077666212,
0.0073912297,
-5.727508797e-33,
-0.0308809225,
-0.0514594652,
-0.0322340727,
-0.0035584657,
-0.0078691598,
0.0535008311,
-0.0147796944,
-0.0013186812,
-0.0058522089,
0.0341857597,
0.0429738723,
0.012161484,
0.0327678733,
0.0229152162,
-0.012715254,
-0.0301008988,
0.0646043494,
-0.0115267932,
-0.0284421537,
-0.02331407,
0.0011363836,
0.0089979656,
0.0801114589,
-0.0497042388,
-0.0507163182,
0.0305888895,
-0.041787751,
0.0118978042,
0.059238378,
0.0693392158,
0.0038585514,
0.040346615,
0.0100285131,
-0.0595678352,
-0.0044902149,
0.0462357067,
-0.054747086,
-0.0303163473,
0.0082215853,
0.0632029027,
0.0046557635,
-0.0161024556,
-0.032688003,
-0.0021820688,
-0.0218323283,
-0.0207342375,
0.0469434969,
-0.0347147062,
0.0313537493,
0.0578935929,
-0.0325558186,
0.0163832288,
-0.0088514602,
-0.0093236277,
0.0693737417,
0.0294746775,
0.0266115181,
0.0596686676,
-0.0862598047,
0.0311412867,
-0.0409711264,
0.0238248464,
0.0545532927,
0.0334864147,
0.0032682936,
0.040524859,
0.0433582962,
-0.0175061058,
0.0428421311,
-0.0477713943,
0.0388163105,
-0.0077789361,
0.0570578501,
0.0873593539,
0.052758947,
0.0148614971,
-0.0519115143,
-0.0022261138,
-0.066576533,
0.0487740897,
-0.0050710961,
0.0330549702,
0.0439314209,
-0.0123554757,
-0.0498182066,
-0.0885339752,
-0.0198182594,
-0.0043444578,
-0.0050010029,
0.0203738976,
-0.012623542,
-0.0121022789,
0.0755792186,
0.0050492752,
0.0350050442,
0.0035279077,
-0.0198902469,
0.0496234521,
-0.0070502111,
0.0357485153,
-0.0064304941,
-0.0143678775,
0.0386376455,
0.0271071922,
0.033111643,
-0.0494602025,
0.0616630763,
0.0395569503,
-0.0462845862,
0.002004341,
0.0010112912,
0.0165668335,
0.0169750005,
0.052680634,
0.0065717674,
0.0415974967,
-0.0235618036,
0.0706148371,
0.0235466305,
-0.0157532543,
-0.0006334215,
-0.0092065828,
-0.0074512744,
0.0721066222,
-0.0592911318,
0.0259974953,
0.0113571221,
-0.0075772982,
0.0790334418,
-0.0625228435,
-0.0384149402,
-0.0371401682,
2.568e-7,
0.0193930026,
0.0126861492,
0.0263640471,
-0.035810709,
0.0310273822,
0.068908073,
-0.0323492587,
0.0288957413,
-0.0199639611,
-0.0209503751,
0.0087722074,
0.0059938263,
0.019165067,
0.0075778575,
-0.0701423511,
0.0641403049,
-0.0001374377,
-0.0008335391,
-0.0193684157,
0.0135393236,
0.0116698686,
0.0774624273,
-0.0052787084,
-0.0051493593,
0.002787143,
-0.0437911451,
0.064642258,
0.0185928792,
0.0107576558,
-0.0144581012,
-0.0665161833,
0.0165390242,
-0.0277382359,
0.0088798804,
-0.0086516431,
0.0111799268,
0.0239468478,
0.0165890437,
-0.0000708486,
-0.0086554429,
0.0068063601,
0.0341524892,
-0.0700949654,
-0.0055808439,
0.0327206142,
-0.0838646963,
-0.0272137485,
-0.0436043739,
-0.0778268799,
-0.0172909312,
0.0290719736,
-0.0054275929,
-0.0323283151,
0.0371087268,
0.0188873522,
0.0303934384,
-0.0547721796,
-0.0467752889,
0.0267501418,
0.0126322843,
-0.0214687064,
0.0119434567,
-0.0201608557,
-0.0281629525,
0.0112663498,
-0.0215029716,
0.004295792,
2.082554006e-34,
0.0118723484,
-0.006447854,
-0.0039774016,
-0.0071453722,
-0.0132042812,
-0.0209575444,
-0.0632324517,
-0.0033424413,
0.0185853802,
-0.0067758379,
0.0205569994
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.09892v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09892v3 | Memotion 3: Dataset on Sentiment and Emotion Analysis of Codemixed Hindi-English Memes | 2023-03-17T11:13:30 | 2023-10-02T14:28:03 | Shreyash Mishra, S Suryavardan, Parth Patwa, Megha Chakraborty, Anku Rani, Aishwarya Reganti, Aman Chadha, Amitava Das, Amit Sheth, Manoj Chinnakotla, Asif Ekbal, Srijan Kumar | cs.CL | cs.CL | Memes are the new-age conveyance mechanism for humor on social media sites.
Memes often include an image and some text. Memes can be used to promote
disinformation or hatred, thus it is crucial to investigate in details. We
introduce Memotion 3, a new dataset with 10,000 annotated memes. Unlike other
prevalent datasets in the domain, including prior iterations of Memotion,
Memotion 3 introduces Hindi-English Codemixed memes while prior works in the
area were limited to only the English memes. We describe the Memotion task, the
data collection and the dataset creation methodologies. We also provide a
baseline for the task. The baseline code and dataset will be made available at
https://github.com/Shreyashm16/Memotion-3.0 | [
0.0490064733,
0.0645872876,
-0.03390963,
0.0343179442,
0.0048196167,
0.079165034,
-0.0288055968,
0.0246856101,
0.0512506366,
-0.0084078526,
-0.0063318573,
-0.0110531123,
-0.0334943943,
0.0499305911,
-0.005304527,
-0.0811043754,
-0.0025238679,
0.0779457092,
0.0505698584,
-0.0380196124,
0.0586732253,
0.0475361347,
-0.0512459874,
0.0096301818,
-0.0776589215,
-0.0086828433,
0.0399122387,
0.0439796336,
0.007615447,
-0.0667410791,
0.0095358016,
0.0210836027,
0.0238148738,
-0.007295385,
0.0000018868,
-0.0333668441,
0.0061053112,
-0.045733761,
0.0028586464,
-0.0254527926,
0.0890306756,
-0.0162317958,
0.0032347529,
0.018143177,
-0.0143550122,
0.0054522026,
0.11513336,
0.0145207364,
0.0838770792,
0.1008356065,
-0.0408628844,
-0.0330343358,
-0.0290201362,
-0.0027985901,
0.0222204346,
0.0105890417,
0.0024236494,
0.015549575,
-0.0497185215,
-0.0353154689,
-0.0292738751,
0.0135113178,
-0.0132801449,
0.0368859321,
-0.0315006636,
-0.0123614324,
-0.0226252433,
-0.0217181835,
0.0276610423,
0.0335431062,
0.0110143246,
-0.0006414867,
0.0419504866,
0.0163936857,
-0.0330636129,
-0.0405713618,
-0.0540933907,
0.0287914146,
-0.0205584075,
0.0459702648,
0.0060721217,
0.039565023,
-0.0003084492,
0.0194204487,
0.0468279496,
-0.0282180496,
-0.018704189,
0.014529638,
-0.0294084847,
0.0038240426,
-0.0292215347,
0.0004863623,
0.0481807142,
0.0084067658,
0.026368361,
0.0562327355,
-0.0336662084,
-0.0941687375,
0.0161675848,
-0.0932535902,
-0.0325983763,
0.0076330355,
-0.010977569,
0.0282492358,
0.0048910896,
0.0081563005,
0.0075266622,
0.0192609001,
0.0088675041,
-0.0065983613,
-0.0071231942,
0.0054866117,
0.0275427774,
0.057401713,
0.0343357958,
0.0147384237,
-0.1197747812,
0.01489277,
-0.0425251983,
-0.0075307451,
0.0111382483,
-0.0138906194,
0.0115330499,
0.0074056946,
-0.0061804876,
-0.0012148286,
-0.0726224333,
0.0120033855,
-0.0215960164,
-0.0707350671,
0.0290193576,
0.008278125,
0.0199859198,
-0.0208427254,
0.0228356551,
0.0669384897,
0.0311220363,
-0.0225104652,
-0.0488043986,
-0.0188622344,
-0.028720513,
-0.0314375348,
0.020410154,
-0.0952679962,
0.0625352561,
0.0364536941,
0.0150470035,
-0.0340303816,
0.0105883265,
0.0061673312,
-0.0106104938,
0.0755798742,
0.0057098707,
-0.0200606585,
0.0107332636,
0.0465433709,
-0.0054887864,
0.0209829826,
-0.0210632607,
0.0519297421,
0.0676075965,
-0.016689023,
0.0111071067,
0.011600229,
0.0112873474,
0.0010731242,
-0.028948281,
0.0208438206,
-0.0408347696,
-0.0110039571,
-0.0154307839,
0.0053487401,
-0.021733325,
-0.0104756271,
0.0028842958,
0.0365149081,
-0.0181795415,
0.0357194133,
-0.0238775071,
0.0081213163,
0.0389583856,
-0.0359955467,
0.0112009943,
0.0312770233,
-0.0249010231,
-0.0306601282,
0.0399710201,
0.0148297297,
-0.0425555855,
-0.0235545263,
-0.0225607604,
-0.0603901632,
0.0274568815,
-0.0326581486,
0.039536301,
-0.0075309495,
-0.0191930439,
0.0136081353,
0.0455460027,
-0.0961447656,
-0.0289007816,
-0.0093819797,
0.029669797,
0.0217382461,
0.0085317194,
-0.0362480618,
-0.0060945381,
0.0037840002,
0.0084097236,
0.0049335319,
-0.0214759726,
0.0063214405,
-0.0216156002,
-0.0440838709,
0.0499167368,
0.0009870405,
-0.0048625353,
0.0163313448,
0.0465604477,
0.0644899309,
-0.006832445,
0.0593171865,
-0.0010854377,
-0.0191439651,
-0.0086249076,
0.0243574195,
-0.0187471211,
0.0087691946,
0.0931956396,
0.0171581656,
-0.033129625,
-0.047294233,
0.0379632898,
-0.0050188582,
-0.023247797,
0.058384642,
-0.0282604303,
-0.078512989,
0.0272392854,
-0.0763500854,
0.0116126416,
0.0711813271,
-0.0212156679,
-0.022134196,
0.0829010978,
-0.0117025496,
0.0565291978,
-0.0291623436,
-0.0092800055,
-0.0245842971,
0.0164010655,
0.0343623012,
0.0295953453,
-0.0206789821,
0.0056695552,
-0.0144512588,
0.0089156814,
0.0484899096,
0.0628499165,
-0.0432604775,
0.0431015119,
0.0045846696,
0.0427237786,
-0.0118606836,
-0.0053907991,
-0.0600331314,
-0.0250731874,
-0.1025786847,
-0.0257040653,
0.010169548,
0.0025641758,
0.0163725186,
0.0157357994,
-0.0262615401,
-0.0358941257,
-0.0377683081,
0.0551265851,
0.021850748,
0.022235997,
0.0120110111,
-0.0105405953,
0.0374080501,
-0.0336980782,
-0.0124629959,
-0.0148354424,
0.0196766648,
-0.0052896743,
-0.028462233,
0.0359116085,
0.0231813025,
-0.0616572909,
-0.0091217924,
-0.0157242585,
-0.0795570761,
-0.0106731253,
-0.0175920967,
0.0515293628,
0.0176176392,
0.0143139651,
0.0715696886,
-0.0316001624,
-0.0151192704,
-0.0205641314,
-0.0127033051,
-0.0091590425,
0.0266577993,
0.0282854512,
-0.0619877912,
-0.0137597332,
0.0169763919,
0.0183073487,
0.0392666645,
-0.0533855855,
0.0221566912,
-0.0137571478,
0.0170184653,
0.0174496267,
0.009368957,
-0.0323144682,
0.0028698125,
-0.0032179267,
-0.0595766865,
0.048399657,
0.0011240107,
-0.0120433681,
-0.0431880206,
0.0191615038,
-0.022625545,
0.0811435655,
-0.0297026727,
0.0337068476,
-0.041671019,
-0.0115889413,
0.021756934,
-0.0382747948,
-0.0113859503,
-0.0590375327,
-0.0206663217,
0.0208100751,
-0.0056485431,
-0.0135137858,
-0.0085573243,
0.0073795617,
-0.033422377,
-0.0319327489,
-0.0584479757,
0.0324704759,
-0.036241509,
0.0250423755,
0.0050078416,
-0.0082401037,
-0.0768122151,
0.0165727548,
-0.0035542236,
0.0480590947,
0.0058918176,
0.0299752709,
-0.0444760919,
0.008614108,
0.0208766386,
-0.009454214,
0.0302198306,
-0.0034256952,
-0.0306188557,
-0.0118496045,
-0.0053036637,
0.0011290116,
0.0375262797,
0.0286424439,
-0.0641332418,
0.055888664,
0.0038417089,
0.0180690922,
0.0660745874,
0.0325130448,
-0.0605478808,
-0.0098048551,
-0.0111588901,
-0.0116231581,
0.0312950611,
0.0056072641,
-0.0372175984,
-0.0259624664,
-0.033334095,
0.0076028947,
-0.0185245071,
-0.0101468302,
0.0098879393,
-0.1002818793,
-0.017759338,
0.0034386972,
0.0060636932,
-0.0256922487,
0.0066674091,
-0.0233409423,
0.0028012872,
-0.0376494713,
-0.0538443625,
0.0074929125,
-0.0054501477,
0.0272117462,
-0.0111531839,
-0.0038781501,
0.004232605,
-0.0025682284,
0.081405513,
0.0085066836,
0.0500670709,
-0.0278759394,
-0.0600038022,
-0.0060764863,
-0.0364209339,
-0.0377122015,
-0.036670696,
0.0782803446,
-0.0049802093,
-0.0617551431,
-0.0360921025,
-0.011298229,
-0.038638927,
-0.0085138176,
-0.0192106497,
0.0253132135,
-0.0102895349,
-0.0161397289,
-0.0442781895,
0.0376459248,
0.0052889991,
0.0468401872,
0.0416788682,
-0.0529207028,
0.0190761108,
-0.0411835983,
0.0347961225,
-0.0587226152,
-0.0148934387,
-0.0563565977,
-0.0507914536,
-0.0239600353,
-0.058471702,
-0.0284437202,
0.002684528,
0.0536573082,
-0.0072839647,
-0.0216695406,
-0.0461662114,
-0.0124311596,
-0.048818063,
-0.0125608267,
-0.0233102627,
0.0178652443,
-0.0205558352,
-0.0295069739,
0.0077770343,
-0.0208917912,
0.0119781094,
-0.0085351774,
-0.0700586811,
-0.020812653,
0.0125526311,
0.0635392368,
0.0157210007,
0.0305843297,
0.0008674553,
-0.0278446525,
0.0527328886,
0.0399945118,
-0.0289904047,
-0.0082190167,
0.0498921275,
0.0498052128,
-0.0027874301,
0.0076712975,
-0.0062418729,
0.0366007723,
0.0142179206,
-0.046350494,
-0.0152469631,
0.0251651555,
-0.0101024415,
0.0092218611,
0.014662344,
-0.0207684711,
-0.055557318,
-0.0096660126,
-0.0109332949,
-0.0035587493,
-0.0303224921,
-0.0207703542,
-0.0135167046,
0.023203481,
0.0231660903,
-0.0582183413,
-0.0527701415,
-0.0020455213,
-0.0059385546,
0.0261043217,
0.065626137,
0.0839060843,
0.0535799824,
0.0070141694,
0.0268959887,
-0.0026589523,
0.0355937853,
-0.0063324133,
-0.0160548389,
-0.0292019136,
0.0369451456,
-0.0124360397,
-0.0252231695,
0.0562034883,
0.0341382585,
0.0929018334,
0.0162260476,
0.0148637928,
-0.0096935937,
0.0597180463,
-0.0505361147,
0.071883224,
-0.0235235058,
0.0299979933,
-0.0204492155,
-0.0018813496,
-0.0565458871,
-0.0277112387,
0.0103417085,
-0.0118908547,
-0.0093807383,
-0.0149995172,
0.0540969111,
-0.1073154137,
0.0476786382,
0.0510671362,
-0.0283156801,
-0.0217438601,
0.036270801,
0.0590830371,
0.0134286853,
0.0445510037,
-0.0071500139,
-0.0392448679,
-0.0692428797,
0.0353420377,
-0.0660592169,
0.0196842682,
0.0250975545,
0.0155876623,
0.0408822447,
0.0339736566,
0.082605496,
-0.0507573225,
0.0412808135,
-0.0797396824,
-0.031216044,
0.0420561433,
-6.120623863e-33,
0.0199589431,
-0.0101737324,
-0.0615649484,
0.0464503914,
-0.0105513036,
0.0156626403,
-0.0236516632,
0.0131992251,
0.0121875564,
0.0157057773,
-0.0114236316,
0.0223769154,
0.0000332965,
-0.0165000968,
0.0283168349,
-0.0274545252,
-0.0171694066,
0.0205341503,
-0.0183249135,
0.035245344,
0.0595244169,
0.0153055768,
0.057576444,
-0.093805477,
0.0115436716,
-0.0202890784,
-0.0442315042,
0.0048173349,
0.0679404661,
0.0510024428,
-0.0031836345,
0.0813507736,
0.0328318775,
0.0226750188,
-0.015406006,
0.0191281959,
-0.0362368077,
-0.0047877128,
0.0223948881,
0.0423035286,
-0.0204671994,
-0.0503355749,
0.0312820598,
-0.0260979496,
-0.0190354455,
0.0399478301,
0.017433228,
-0.0172938425,
0.0399903655,
-0.0578596964,
-0.0155582307,
0.0378161334,
-0.0140384845,
-0.0074864072,
0.0095627373,
0.0196517073,
0.0398434922,
0.0367606618,
-0.0704161003,
0.0456186086,
-0.0510742664,
-0.0215770639,
-0.0051832884,
-0.0138062527,
0.0109838815,
0.0740789473,
0.0119141908,
0.0094158612,
0.0361200981,
0.0613883026,
-0.0126477871,
0.0306730401,
0.0366914757,
0.0452386476,
0.0579419509,
-0.065746665,
-0.0076279924,
0.0118859187,
0.0077831903,
0.00979973,
0.0416323505,
0.0236530676,
-0.0529514104,
0.0043909075,
0.0612107255,
-0.0104948711,
-0.0257829987,
-0.0902424455,
-0.0138797872,
-0.0350993238,
-0.0425232835,
0.0048898277,
0.0210853834,
-0.0282685459,
0.0151146846,
0.020766018,
-0.0254152957,
0.0449535958,
-0.0012383243,
0.0312746242,
-0.0281070322,
0.0080203218,
0.0263354667,
0.0376624316,
0.0314493589,
0.0114860469,
0.0697509348,
0.02731416,
-0.0866983682,
-0.0292487536,
-0.0143987183,
0.0407994352,
-0.0417528637,
0.0174469147,
-0.0000509402,
0.0262596756,
-0.0267198849,
-0.0358004868,
0.0306972619,
0.0179028139,
-0.0197408684,
-0.0167909004,
-0.0190202035,
0.0155402515,
-0.0172047261,
-0.0326605104,
-0.0477757044,
-0.0420983061,
-0.0157895349,
-0.0487521589,
0.003947672,
-0.0346777141,
2.686e-7,
0.001074929,
0.0522389896,
0.0155490544,
-0.0154115334,
0.0165992286,
0.0350911766,
-0.0385783613,
-0.0169225782,
-0.018261876,
0.0072035915,
0.0173508003,
0.0290348716,
0.0267928131,
0.0192800574,
-0.0904825926,
-0.0086205881,
-0.0606512986,
0.0028229519,
-0.02485919,
0.0567039661,
0.0693944693,
0.0607925877,
0.0699540973,
-0.0220823251,
-0.0312517546,
0.0117202448,
0.0368011408,
-0.0491665043,
0.0179317724,
-0.0337155983,
-0.0366445184,
0.0211671274,
-0.0107468208,
-0.0529844724,
0.0176264141,
-0.0688230917,
0.0252851304,
0.027293114,
0.018392073,
-0.0193970706,
0.0258618779,
0.0330928862,
-0.000352663,
-0.0162954628,
0.0203150753,
0.0382732712,
-0.0530619696,
-0.048050113,
-0.0207820386,
-0.0119196195,
0.0481713265,
-0.0143480143,
-0.0260819383,
-0.0071789394,
0.0185097866,
-0.0231683888,
-0.0265844725,
-0.0504164323,
-0.0112427548,
0.0186388511,
-0.0166694839,
-0.0209816433,
-0.0172501598,
0.0246827248,
0.0201564804,
-0.0261826403,
0.0342747495,
1.983716512e-34,
0.0301194545,
-0.0504347384,
-0.0046982211,
-0.0251144655,
0.0310945436,
-0.0134497937,
0.0055843061,
-0.0238583963,
0.0355321504,
-0.030892415,
0.0048655118
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.09859v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09859v3 | Trained on 100 million words and still in shape: BERT meets British National Corpus | 2023-03-17T09:53:33 | 2023-05-05T23:59:35 | David Samuel, Andrey Kutuzov, Lilja Øvrelid, Erik Velldal | cs.CL | cs.CL | While modern masked language models (LMs) are trained on ever larger corpora,
we here explore the effects of down-scaling training to a modestly-sized but
representative, well-balanced, and publicly available English text source --
the British National Corpus. We show that pre-training on this carefully
curated corpus can reach better performance than the original BERT model. We
argue that this type of corpora has great potential as a language modeling
benchmark. To showcase this potential, we present fair, reproducible and
data-efficient comparative studies of LMs, in which we evaluate several
training objectives and model architectures and replicate previous empirical
results in a systematic way. We propose an optimized LM architecture called
LTG-BERT. | [
0.0295107942,
0.0496444814,
-0.0014134714,
0.0346181802,
-0.0177396778,
0.0010337209,
0.0428435355,
0.0311891455,
0.0116805369,
-0.0578889064,
-0.0277086236,
-0.0348830968,
-0.0272827242,
0.0282779057,
0.0352501459,
-0.0580013245,
0.0299842544,
-0.0317705125,
-0.028716661,
-0.0074455692,
0.0299647469,
-0.0023863777,
0.0213904306,
0.0364810899,
-0.0118885348,
0.006077853,
0.0170869119,
0.0254598577,
0.0122727184,
-0.0254570078,
0.0455724411,
0.0354667678,
0.0232937187,
0.0901304856,
0.0000017488,
-0.0421007872,
0.0011059203,
0.006504212,
-0.0211144537,
0.0779967606,
0.0124336453,
-0.0172017291,
-0.001324327,
0.0665116236,
-0.0135557679,
-0.0218434799,
0.0460468046,
0.024617346,
0.0754122585,
0.0781547204,
-0.0068794778,
-0.045206435,
0.009979181,
-0.051734563,
-0.0569909178,
-0.0251845438,
0.0361659415,
-0.0442594178,
-0.0181621481,
-0.0300621614,
0.0055828234,
0.0348560847,
-0.0122427475,
0.0126668224,
0.0063295108,
0.0553451106,
-0.0652450994,
-0.00523016,
-0.0000592464,
0.0522471964,
-0.039111305,
-0.0143786687,
0.022093093,
0.0050288141,
-0.0324755274,
-0.0050982158,
0.0066593224,
0.0146568315,
0.0219082292,
0.0223250054,
-0.012255176,
-0.0061990805,
0.0401473418,
0.0286379214,
-0.0531138666,
-0.0011294583,
0.0348760523,
-0.0446016639,
-0.0250878353,
-0.0101049636,
-0.0550880469,
-0.0417173468,
0.0331296399,
0.0036077038,
0.0220665541,
0.0073450305,
-0.0445641279,
-0.0732127503,
0.0211161561,
-0.0342080966,
0.0155467968,
0.0096301576,
-0.0410398878,
0.0294137895,
-0.0378307514,
0.0554885231,
-0.002116967,
0.0409886949,
-0.0294881575,
-0.0315891355,
-0.0332656577,
-0.0108712371,
-0.0650502443,
0.0366534479,
-0.0590517521,
-0.0149165327,
-0.0119832074,
-0.0274552815,
-0.0039849272,
0.0155597655,
0.0302659776,
-0.0176503602,
-0.0256365892,
-0.0085304752,
0.018074017,
-0.0153275644,
-0.0134581961,
-0.0009442478,
-0.0255614687,
-0.0542842112,
-0.017466668,
0.0099466331,
-0.0024746219,
-0.0390768945,
0.043431595,
0.0518184267,
-0.0048750839,
-0.0460330583,
-0.0199021306,
0.0452678166,
-0.0060089566,
-0.0154651925,
-0.0012799378,
-0.0393732302,
-0.0041331998,
-0.0270073693,
0.0287029203,
0.0054835971,
0.0222576689,
0.0154419355,
-0.0312264226,
0.0801245347,
-0.0211730041,
-0.006467436,
0.034464322,
0.0080418205,
0.0062235021,
0.0490171351,
0.0625578985,
-0.0077976929,
0.0363204293,
-0.0187624283,
-0.0018218793,
0.0678395405,
0.0301377736,
0.0272564515,
0.0082900831,
-0.0202556439,
-0.0085413279,
0.0229170322,
0.0362625681,
0.0665704608,
-0.025512984,
-0.0472759381,
0.0595236532,
0.0307523329,
-0.0089823157,
0.0405481011,
-0.0057936325,
0.0381606705,
0.0309146792,
-0.0141926501,
-0.0248748474,
-0.0537840277,
-0.0276474375,
0.0048569394,
0.0022958079,
0.0264497418,
-0.0395781212,
0.0093374094,
-0.0489858277,
-0.0044650673,
0.0164796095,
-0.015763266,
0.0240559746,
0.0029955287,
-0.03331168,
0.0712309331,
0.0137702301,
-0.0339719169,
0.0125354314,
-0.0587813221,
-0.0130688548,
0.0040296358,
0.0485524945,
-0.0468027741,
-0.0238173623,
-0.0106833661,
-0.0230943002,
0.0725939795,
0.0009734649,
-0.0143755926,
0.0613376833,
-0.0523334369,
0.0242989231,
0.0003479008,
0.0085308934,
0.0326695815,
0.0052301544,
-0.0089365123,
0.0018012115,
-0.0510941111,
0.0050577256,
0.0632691383,
-0.0414129235,
-0.0619229563,
0.0189649537,
-0.0069061583,
0.0376492925,
-0.0089367535,
-0.073635079,
0.0164695233,
0.0150276674,
-0.0633054897,
-0.0004973341,
-0.0185889099,
-0.0162456036,
-0.0524632894,
0.0392241366,
-0.0618406348,
0.0168350674,
0.1396069974,
-0.049470868,
-0.0368931592,
-0.0116131511,
-0.0505681746,
0.0588748381,
-0.0683335513,
0.0227390695,
-0.0061482638,
0.0168071035,
-0.0380474962,
0.0169901289,
-0.0196659286,
0.0213817731,
-0.0009528822,
-0.0142486645,
0.0369629711,
-0.0402991101,
-0.0384667814,
-0.0102892602,
0.0066047511,
0.0288531892,
0.0047841696,
0.0132809756,
-0.0198841598,
-0.0291053765,
-0.1108860895,
0.0073275482,
-0.0266412254,
0.0241905879,
0.0328894928,
-0.0087558385,
-0.0357796997,
-0.0129266009,
-0.0253347568,
-0.0719918385,
-0.021339247,
0.011441865,
0.0231119152,
0.009955381,
-0.0233238041,
-0.041227255,
-0.0231374446,
0.0031211837,
0.0415319093,
-0.0344331563,
-0.0542747527,
-0.0303243119,
0.0016064487,
0.005853672,
0.0611405559,
-0.0101058166,
-0.0563605726,
-0.0299492739,
-0.00220815,
0.0377967991,
0.0080029527,
0.0235543326,
-0.0207306631,
0.0400108285,
0.0109974621,
-0.044523757,
0.010422037,
0.0027537264,
-0.0273708515,
-0.0136213796,
-0.0582875609,
0.0269268174,
0.0856285617,
-0.0005067595,
-0.0159877408,
-0.0542732105,
-0.0310981832,
-0.012111526,
-0.0172971822,
-0.0696907416,
-0.0125814155,
-0.0367764607,
-0.0049422467,
-0.0246647988,
-0.0429512523,
0.036877837,
-0.0674315095,
0.0011271155,
-0.055677589,
0.0124250604,
-0.0219818465,
0.0266578235,
0.0214948244,
0.0296705477,
0.0285119601,
-0.04790264,
-0.0130132502,
-0.0010941209,
0.0096500376,
-0.0328656957,
-0.0196309071,
-0.0617639162,
0.0289896559,
0.000502855,
-0.0570682287,
-0.0386392623,
-0.1163150296,
-0.0329439193,
0.0294166151,
0.0405847132,
-0.0281255506,
-0.0270844754,
0.0030348478,
0.0095862783,
0.0796334743,
0.0345287248,
0.0003312865,
-0.0080847973,
0.0517398752,
0.0443895832,
0.0015913047,
0.0325718634,
-0.034439303,
0.00333717,
0.0109353215,
0.092828624,
0.0384195969,
-0.0155656245,
0.0001703368,
0.026310809,
-0.050004825,
-0.0339581408,
0.0026729847,
0.0261194669,
-0.0141853066,
-0.0143548623,
0.1258287877,
0.0208557714,
-0.0000266713,
-0.0029985262,
-0.001130275,
0.0693324357,
0.0038352597,
0.0107811727,
-0.0896798894,
-0.0206913389,
0.0234912243,
0.0447801165,
-0.0117626553,
-0.0291521344,
0.0073662396,
-0.1161579937,
0.0201558135,
-0.0001153436,
0.0113228774,
0.0018034744,
-0.0579862967,
-0.0171648134,
-0.021267388,
0.0093341433,
-0.0107185198,
-0.0038282429,
-0.0167209916,
0.0637325048,
-0.0498626269,
-0.0299681872,
0.0385974012,
-0.0595920794,
0.0338307396,
0.0510238931,
0.0314410888,
-0.0349813923,
-0.0543499216,
0.0244863555,
-0.018924417,
-0.0210621208,
-0.0171350371,
0.0820291564,
-0.0308251921,
-0.0346940048,
-0.0071495818,
0.0229390655,
-0.0021799603,
0.0021069075,
0.0166290607,
0.0249014311,
0.0325945951,
0.0012734818,
0.0051552989,
-0.0072998405,
0.0090420237,
0.0812801495,
0.0236382708,
-0.0395317636,
-0.02421383,
0.0029446469,
0.0182124618,
-0.0388901904,
-0.0030337845,
0.0444544367,
-0.0550150946,
-0.0004357045,
-0.062016122,
-0.0079002157,
0.0233266056,
0.0428823344,
0.0248237047,
-0.026525287,
0.0012433385,
-0.0005739028,
-0.0359950401,
0.0552858673,
-0.0327254757,
0.0294959191,
-0.0779931247,
-0.0219592508,
0.028817514,
0.0058926065,
-0.027328711,
-0.0032567151,
-0.0558739379,
-0.0524778254,
0.0403564498,
0.0633074939,
0.0273928978,
0.0356122218,
-0.0222185906,
-0.0856316686,
0.0970394835,
0.0032029592,
-0.0057868757,
0.0117464652,
0.0454719141,
-0.0274817441,
-0.0077386177,
0.037782263,
-0.0301135909,
0.0255809668,
0.0276866071,
0.0327908359,
-0.0319097899,
0.0356756896,
-0.0125633068,
0.0491692536,
0.0720090047,
-0.052146744,
0.0082893297,
-0.041074913,
0.0169705078,
-0.0164885055,
-0.0125971576,
-0.0264799986,
0.0065191765,
0.0480796136,
-0.0022640796,
-0.0578597113,
0.0785198808,
-0.0297356248,
0.0320271179,
-0.0515475124,
0.0327776037,
-0.0062754233,
0.0296918247,
0.0146074994,
-0.0128335478,
-0.0244900212,
-0.0081196139,
0.0109650325,
0.0281116758,
0.0149703315,
0.0181063693,
0.009288257,
0.0148026757,
-0.007712632,
0.0317678489,
-0.0586508214,
-0.0258998983,
-0.0213925764,
0.0008167863,
0.0490877219,
-0.0303614736,
0.0492497198,
-0.0092242602,
-0.0225265976,
-0.0166624412,
0.0007527814,
0.006265474,
-0.0130997067,
0.030445613,
-0.0070771133,
-0.032915812,
0.0202170592,
0.0947741792,
0.0412350222,
0.0702466816,
0.0341696292,
0.0040685246,
-0.0483279377,
0.0118764546,
0.0486199856,
0.0517887473,
0.0004102762,
0.0068608257,
-0.0401286632,
-0.057642445,
0.0246076938,
-0.0158623792,
0.0306373741,
-0.0057946616,
0.0337446854,
0.0201889221,
0.0163027346,
-0.0132090617,
-0.0300532561,
0.0214049537,
0.0304192323,
-0.0206358954,
-0.0133046024,
-6.151735892e-33,
-0.0201532692,
0.0492865331,
-0.0141876945,
-0.0208471194,
-0.0120058116,
0.0363180824,
-0.0122397412,
-0.0106510641,
-0.0300242603,
0.0092469817,
-0.0382142067,
0.0081274165,
0.0209748521,
0.0487268344,
-0.047548376,
0.0008915003,
0.0590978153,
-0.0358075947,
-0.016107576,
-0.0161953233,
0.0138630578,
0.0581364185,
0.0304050185,
-0.043394994,
-0.0176776331,
-0.0072748815,
-0.0220454764,
0.024855148,
0.0147138275,
0.0298670083,
-0.0580765232,
0.0311140176,
0.0170242451,
-0.0072722188,
-0.0158044137,
0.0339230672,
-0.0767453611,
0.0063391849,
0.0143419048,
0.0045487918,
0.0059652398,
-0.0100636799,
0.0257046018,
-0.0002878658,
-0.0270337965,
0.0096295364,
0.0178124961,
-0.0240117684,
-0.0291218925,
-0.0447114892,
-0.0214897431,
0.0415475741,
-0.0110072382,
-0.0317076296,
0.0359147117,
0.0027195872,
-0.0099624759,
0.0038577521,
-0.0630563945,
-0.0280832704,
0.0496584587,
0.0396205448,
0.0278048031,
0.0427052379,
0.0225214884,
0.0574097484,
0.0219281763,
0.0046583172,
-0.0273473728,
0.0240944233,
0.0553583391,
0.0343663543,
0.0687579289,
0.0104356529,
0.051849708,
-0.0156183448,
-0.0896602198,
0.0319762826,
-0.0006184027,
0.0057177832,
0.0187366456,
0.0240488723,
-0.0255374461,
-0.0185987391,
-0.0511769317,
-0.0156482887,
-0.024393063,
0.031384185,
0.0298234839,
0.022460822,
-0.026518032,
0.0264509656,
0.0095633445,
-0.0266146306,
-0.0151982857,
-0.0271204114,
0.0380944908,
-0.0056364918,
0.0049678548,
0.0578730218,
-0.0845005512,
-0.0263517704,
0.0198861863,
0.0286023244,
0.0134494407,
-0.0266563017,
0.0284529049,
0.0242621731,
-0.0979740322,
0.0010290527,
-0.0324755535,
0.0266750939,
0.0015732666,
0.0475912876,
0.0097105298,
-0.0138755124,
0.0194877386,
0.001111722,
0.0104044499,
-0.0096586216,
-0.0067769173,
0.0317418873,
-0.0104842028,
0.0374860838,
0.0035248457,
0.007991178,
-0.0180050936,
0.0204442777,
0.0786934197,
-0.04053827,
-0.0067236908,
-0.0198889766,
2.357e-7,
0.0443234034,
0.0410375334,
0.0281375721,
-0.0094321538,
0.000783759,
0.0326220542,
-0.0006281243,
0.0713981166,
0.0026802698,
0.0185748599,
-0.0277152844,
-0.0285531599,
0.0644141212,
-0.0005426581,
-0.0571002923,
-0.041797366,
-0.0729697272,
0.0226756893,
-0.0410509221,
0.0168184564,
-0.0079738768,
0.1226000711,
0.0348443873,
-0.021151159,
0.01756531,
-0.0598621517,
0.060661491,
-0.0538084581,
-0.0170712303,
0.023321474,
0.0375431105,
0.0473633111,
0.0045360723,
0.0061282683,
-0.0304064639,
0.0543647595,
0.0130106546,
0.070917964,
-0.0215638652,
0.010766034,
0.0034092225,
-0.0009964758,
-0.0369972959,
-0.0395399146,
0.058176931,
0.0027426213,
-0.0051063681,
0.0025387728,
-0.0493367985,
-0.0080389753,
0.0305527654,
-0.0517997853,
-0.0469952673,
0.0365032293,
0.0406344309,
-0.0383449532,
-0.0066131689,
-0.0954377279,
-0.0391016565,
-0.0134426355,
-0.0535122789,
-0.0312063731,
-0.0258254502,
-0.0085745314,
-0.0043947212,
-0.0953681767,
0.0258037988,
2.189085018e-34,
0.0324570648,
-0.0351284556,
-0.0191219635,
0.0506160185,
0.0263315085,
-0.0037605234,
0.0477592908,
-0.0172468759,
0.0016409787,
-0.0938211605,
0.0202280264
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.09827v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09827v1 | DORIC : Domain Robust Fine-Tuning for Open Intent Clustering through Dependency Parsing | 2023-03-17T08:12:36 | 2023-03-17T08:12:36 | Jihyun Lee, Seungyeon Seo, Yunsu Kim, Gary Geunbae Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We present our work on Track 2 in the Dialog System Technology Challenges 11
(DSTC11). DSTC11-Track2 aims to provide a benchmark for zero-shot,
cross-domain, intent-set induction. In the absence of in-domain training
dataset, robust utterance representation that can be used across domains is
necessary to induce users' intentions. To achieve this, we leveraged a
multi-domain dialogue dataset to fine-tune the language model and proposed
extracting Verb-Object pairs to remove the artifacts of unnecessary
information. Furthermore, we devised the method that generates each cluster's
name for the explainability of clustered results. Our approach achieved 3rd
place in the precision score and showed superior accuracy and normalized mutual
information (NMI) score than the baseline model on various domain datasets. | [
0.0329509638,
0.0126587609,
-0.0163405016,
0.0393284522,
-0.0244415067,
0.0105744461,
0.0067096129,
-0.016940048,
0.0424949825,
-0.0571082532,
-0.0291358456,
-0.0135209737,
-0.0251244195,
0.0577774532,
-0.017458031,
-0.0780837163,
0.0574383698,
-0.0210968815,
-0.0141711337,
0.0173842143,
-0.0084334761,
0.0296046194,
-0.034418121,
0.0598815456,
-0.0010351796,
-0.0416255444,
-0.015284582,
0.0169523414,
-0.0088703819,
-0.0205859859,
0.0060080485,
0.044311408,
0.0232493319,
0.0481349304,
0.0000021652,
-0.0959411636,
-0.0505305566,
-0.0002253552,
-0.0612690672,
-0.0172952544,
0.0138655826,
-0.0030055966,
0.0265314635,
0.0148039171,
-0.0139722554,
-0.0033702904,
0.0156798922,
0.0549833253,
0.0383956656,
0.060586784,
-0.0282086339,
-0.0223874412,
0.0167483613,
-0.018868275,
-0.0299510583,
-0.0367776304,
-0.0136816809,
0.029069012,
-0.0205987021,
0.0162858516,
0.0043295752,
-0.0001170547,
-0.0072150426,
-0.0095294435,
-0.0018367757,
0.0024059578,
0.00250066,
-0.0378276296,
0.0031596238,
0.0964539722,
0.0603944138,
0.0577833876,
0.017942261,
-0.0258863438,
-0.0160015486,
-0.0185310394,
-0.0384580009,
-0.000138537,
0.0019104653,
0.0010921987,
0.0131320022,
0.044489529,
0.0079372237,
-0.008433423,
-0.0357501544,
0.0620827153,
-0.0087865507,
-0.0137036238,
0.0005284384,
0.0046844701,
-0.0358398035,
-0.0339587219,
-0.0064131538,
-0.0350067616,
-0.0426314585,
0.0397210941,
-0.0429068878,
0.0162039883,
0.0088692587,
0.02264826,
-0.0252356008,
0.0376123823,
-0.0306925122,
0.0540555343,
0.0268071257,
0.0050283447,
0.0107630724,
-0.0283911619,
-0.0426574089,
-0.0127542559,
-0.0735699981,
0.0082873181,
-0.0221230779,
0.0307968128,
-0.1130685732,
-0.0022209887,
-0.0249441769,
0.031872876,
0.0036543033,
-0.0118046738,
0.0253448524,
-0.0066725332,
-0.030242702,
-0.0197309814,
-0.030787345,
0.0401445068,
-0.0544299707,
0.0568438023,
0.0100147715,
-0.0605618469,
-0.0234456584,
0.0374827497,
0.0053455499,
-0.0180044025,
-0.0438679792,
0.0513198487,
-0.0131404484,
-0.0545856506,
-0.0419526845,
-0.0959315896,
-0.0402619094,
-0.0392819978,
-0.0403535068,
-0.0291226916,
0.0117400838,
0.008909516,
0.0050064377,
-0.0691648498,
0.0015845757,
-0.0147640333,
-0.0174850579,
0.0551243573,
-0.0566318259,
-0.017189607,
0.0032734426,
0.02095096,
-0.0375101939,
0.090272516,
0.0045061256,
0.008284823,
0.043781884,
0.0108939055,
-0.0354571156,
-0.0039817072,
0.0238518976,
0.0122539075,
0.0548309125,
0.0446173474,
-0.0013224856,
0.0299132559,
0.0190727729,
0.0297007877,
-0.0410779715,
-0.0046618278,
0.02404253,
0.0519260764,
-0.0035582834,
-0.012170922,
0.0151960021,
0.0423571765,
-0.03551789,
-0.0056711817,
-0.0267941374,
-0.0250458717,
-0.0234751888,
0.0005540745,
0.0289359055,
0.0325625837,
-0.0209757797,
-0.0382033922,
0.0103535531,
-0.0279399678,
0.0194440112,
-0.0141052026,
0.0608560555,
0.0366337709,
-0.0573009886,
0.0586796738,
0.0234552231,
-0.0266219433,
-0.020872632,
-0.0438608713,
0.028813893,
-0.0003546367,
0.0476865061,
-0.0398646779,
-0.0559453331,
-0.0583223253,
0.0233353358,
0.0054724975,
-0.0070953271,
-0.0278273895,
0.041473303,
-0.0531671494,
-0.0424576774,
-0.0021414864,
0.0088150566,
0.0016317228,
-0.0226601288,
-0.044140853,
0.016506793,
0.0085835326,
0.0323717892,
0.0020638972,
0.0079896431,
0.0152797913,
0.0405339599,
0.0212310888,
0.0769553035,
0.072170347,
0.0140326442,
-0.0211293306,
-0.0013917802,
-0.0004282287,
0.0121469907,
0.0415373966,
-0.028227197,
-0.0353536904,
0.0066930274,
-0.0259571429,
-0.0451550521,
-0.0124965431,
-0.0219897293,
-0.0626623854,
0.0197586082,
0.0115391985,
0.0294772033,
-0.0465594828,
-0.0162786692,
0.0498200841,
0.0031882541,
-0.018998893,
0.0773879364,
0.0114983153,
-0.0144569231,
0.0240084156,
0.0263235793,
0.0443201326,
-0.0331066921,
0.0046152747,
-0.0205957051,
-0.0465869568,
0.0001989644,
-0.018229872,
0.000373322,
-0.066591084,
-0.0273677781,
-0.0979819298,
-0.0208987314,
-0.0124897053,
-0.002507824,
0.0129498392,
0.0450417511,
0.0134549811,
-0.0115551893,
0.0124459052,
0.0202788692,
0.0108623849,
-0.0068207001,
0.0294944718,
0.0060729752,
-0.0503212698,
-0.0057588778,
0.0395991765,
-0.016161222,
0.011941676,
-0.0014977233,
0.0547919199,
-0.0484434925,
0.066239737,
-0.0060657714,
0.0053537097,
-0.0226900112,
-0.0286846608,
0.0244128015,
0.008120901,
-0.0012690591,
0.0602937937,
-0.0103708617,
0.0140144527,
-0.0166085977,
-0.0199497808,
-0.0505766831,
0.0215980373,
0.000806832,
0.0209311172,
-0.0360616259,
-0.0072175451,
0.0430526547,
0.0566214137,
0.0402107313,
0.0144565608,
-0.064225547,
-0.0522193983,
-0.0160494093,
-0.0460706912,
-0.0182979945,
-0.0098092621,
-0.006212153,
0.0603812337,
-0.0009924279,
-0.0467786379,
0.070556581,
-0.0301846471,
-0.0272165947,
-0.0622648746,
-0.0123574547,
-0.021710217,
0.0466097891,
-0.0518051833,
0.0108627146,
0.094315052,
-0.0460999049,
-0.016899595,
-0.0116310623,
0.0069967904,
0.0027436735,
0.0993664116,
-0.0456655025,
-0.0158861261,
0.0130984522,
-0.0436240472,
-0.0287451874,
-0.061056979,
-0.0237394795,
-0.0198250543,
0.0354449898,
-0.0141267758,
-0.0121373935,
0.012117343,
-0.0025744811,
0.0188259296,
0.0191214941,
-0.0110170674,
-0.0148291169,
0.0246268604,
0.0363788381,
0.0172020551,
-0.042016089,
-0.0030457936,
0.0502041355,
0.0469244793,
0.0340256654,
-0.0352850966,
-0.0176390372,
0.017899869,
0.0061433688,
0.0198400822,
-0.0214625206,
0.0070873648,
0.1081030294,
0.0244788174,
-0.0183209367,
0.1238900945,
0.0332379714,
-0.0201555379,
-0.0143399006,
-0.0175023749,
0.0625409707,
0.0187804084,
-0.0181561355,
-0.0642892048,
-0.0760744065,
-0.0045228181,
0.0628617108,
-0.0021898355,
-0.0350395776,
0.0337924585,
-0.0939535499,
0.0372103192,
-0.0052223625,
-0.0308362078,
-0.0465917662,
-0.0365294069,
-0.0031101666,
-0.0592257269,
0.0154188313,
-0.0316310935,
0.0377488695,
-0.0218149927,
0.010207017,
-0.0170339942,
-0.0320673287,
0.0371792912,
-0.0283530429,
0.0836240873,
0.0458906889,
0.0194790345,
0.0614151694,
0.0212402008,
-0.0225389786,
-0.0458084382,
0.0102927359,
-0.0188712589,
0.0665291697,
-0.0019314209,
0.0053141871,
-0.0039551142,
0.0569479652,
-0.0611931235,
-0.0325856619,
0.015729947,
0.0653619245,
-0.0218181442,
0.0809860155,
0.0221906807,
0.006358176,
0.0470011458,
0.088705264,
0.0067653838,
-0.003576525,
0.0291728582,
-0.0458090305,
0.0226046145,
-0.0006624138,
0.0022025818,
-0.0276588947,
0.013507314,
0.0148688359,
-0.0456718095,
-0.0649078637,
0.0571390651,
0.0357417688,
-0.0180844255,
-0.002861094,
0.0194591917,
0.0283707306,
0.0102217402,
0.0533588268,
-0.0172711071,
-0.0022041255,
-0.0820367113,
-0.0067354278,
0.0702777728,
-0.0369991735,
-0.0271800924,
0.0528618023,
-0.0330793187,
-0.0574198477,
-0.0068200878,
0.0313964598,
0.0167283304,
0.0648038611,
-0.0493235961,
-0.0058788592,
-0.051560916,
-0.0089567304,
-0.0540471599,
-0.0285591539,
0.0676606819,
0.0251560565,
-0.008117212,
0.0362821408,
-0.036908485,
0.0238658972,
-0.0197753664,
-0.0046958365,
-0.0743111745,
-0.086756736,
0.0257027838,
0.0224190298,
0.0832324177,
0.0104742637,
-0.0254366659,
-0.0478619821,
0.0371901877,
-0.0258326344,
-0.0036974999,
-0.0573914945,
0.0189759675,
0.0371496379,
-0.0389808677,
0.008010543,
0.0266238078,
-0.0526930615,
0.0253121369,
-0.0340993255,
0.0251461193,
0.0208588429,
0.0548076071,
-0.0058126687,
-0.0299160089,
0.0036859575,
0.0159384906,
-0.012076389,
0.0304116197,
-0.01381764,
0.1110079139,
0.0182169061,
0.0229604132,
0.0180754419,
0.0318729244,
-0.0167320147,
0.0021753889,
0.0002317757,
-0.0126406141,
0.0127461003,
-0.0243898183,
0.0943953469,
-0.0152451284,
0.0189317707,
0.0086248815,
0.0912981629,
-0.0151889594,
-0.0060413051,
0.0277808532,
0.0290564913,
-0.0329905599,
0.0152218016,
0.0663481653,
-0.08417698,
0.0334259421,
0.0098478487,
0.0079527749,
-0.0681028813,
-0.0305842832,
0.0447129421,
0.0421508364,
-0.0255138986,
-0.0025306614,
-0.0409532897,
-0.0274530929,
0.0054596402,
-0.040636465,
-0.012339104,
0.0059121293,
0.0799753964,
0.0553790517,
0.0041288389,
-0.0329056904,
-0.0162691828,
-0.0420848429,
0.0059456453,
-0.0150875458,
-0.0104035996,
-6.550994018e-33,
-0.0237173568,
0.0144694103,
-0.0131435459,
-0.0221189242,
-0.0079559097,
-0.0243502762,
-0.0313162208,
0.0030567639,
-0.0254106354,
0.0023552161,
0.0119000636,
0.021323761,
0.0183676146,
0.0299450718,
-0.0310124084,
-0.0019497874,
0.0377307162,
-0.038858749,
-0.0034205494,
0.0380064324,
0.0669802353,
0.0026834889,
-0.0004437627,
-0.0921220332,
0.0216913279,
0.0368901007,
-0.0122644296,
0.0351313874,
0.0047448189,
0.0595890582,
-0.0075067286,
-0.0060960012,
-0.0048199389,
-0.0648650303,
-0.0149235046,
-0.0049698777,
-0.0683345348,
-0.0214869436,
0.0276224352,
-0.0246199183,
-0.0147333927,
-0.0270074382,
0.0094268247,
-0.0026096641,
0.0129048247,
-0.010805984,
-0.0154632051,
-0.0132865664,
-0.0068637202,
0.0397722982,
-0.0473317727,
0.0512580164,
-0.0386910476,
-0.0418561734,
-0.0043056998,
0.0479769595,
0.0402158797,
-0.0058026933,
-0.0200256351,
0.0353085846,
-0.0568867289,
0.014677112,
0.0270985924,
-0.0037074317,
-0.0133918235,
0.0663918629,
0.0173722617,
-0.0186894406,
-0.0169363748,
0.0174678657,
-0.0193739235,
0.0638285056,
-0.0011915753,
0.0645780414,
-0.0277007446,
-0.0010534429,
-0.0604454353,
0.0336084291,
0.0023303637,
-0.0253774263,
-0.009361309,
0.0189606119,
-0.0758608356,
0.0050866758,
0.0030559243,
-0.0218023006,
-0.0123401927,
-0.0313364677,
0.0300719813,
-0.018761484,
-0.0378943942,
-0.0077506346,
0.0469661094,
-0.008633988,
0.0657825693,
-0.0004067718,
0.026849702,
0.0221646316,
-0.0102620069,
-0.0041335109,
-0.043411579,
-0.0333925635,
0.0617895499,
0.0262710266,
0.0260621402,
0.0087728789,
-0.00866892,
-0.0246931426,
-0.0181150474,
0.0052746767,
-0.0152890598,
0.0172909889,
-0.0630294159,
0.0310340431,
0.0354944952,
0.0062012281,
-0.0204071123,
0.0764805004,
-0.0025555505,
-0.004149863,
-0.048273135,
-0.0486433655,
0.0132778492,
0.0059027355,
-0.0116082067,
-0.0394341536,
0.0192182362,
-0.0814618915,
0.0294368546,
-0.0214236304,
-0.0273266621,
-0.0041169198,
2.981e-7,
0.023742374,
0.0316933207,
0.0133977486,
0.0335863605,
-0.0095817419,
0.0756315887,
0.0130192759,
0.0141580198,
0.0208061803,
-0.0417506546,
0.0358805954,
-0.0252132919,
0.0314933471,
0.0101730898,
-0.1096781194,
-0.0025061774,
0.0414876565,
-0.0295971353,
-0.0364185981,
0.0187097751,
0.0746455416,
0.1252333224,
0.0017787709,
0.0269128345,
0.0008761207,
-0.0110993152,
-0.0044078208,
-0.0309024043,
-0.0203208234,
0.0262082163,
0.0204608552,
-0.045507174,
-0.0219867099,
0.0292326063,
-0.0086894054,
0.0401952974,
-0.0084426831,
0.0444729142,
0.0061053606,
-0.0535719469,
-0.0122248409,
0.0011444259,
0.0074992636,
-0.0263066981,
0.0491324142,
-0.0284696538,
-0.0327120125,
0.0404736102,
-0.028806325,
-0.0058293133,
-0.0227252916,
0.0197237972,
0.009865704,
0.0020608047,
-0.0064278268,
-0.0102454945,
0.0128709059,
-0.0671203136,
0.0035004227,
-0.0130251981,
-0.0354108438,
-0.0501823574,
0.0038447378,
-0.0084164916,
0.0498606153,
-0.022253165,
-0.0025436606,
2.897018685e-34,
0.0144728394,
-0.0001932978,
0.0032238802,
0.0284345485,
0.054067567,
-0.0275306236,
-0.0271677282,
-0.0094833216,
0.0553195067,
-0.088385351,
0.0069335359
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.09823v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09823v1 | Transformers and Ensemble methods: A solution for Hate Speech Detection in Arabic languages | 2023-03-17T08:02:54 | 2023-03-17T08:02:54 | Angel Felipe Magnossão de Paula, Imene Bensalem, Paolo Rosso, Wajdi Zaghouani | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | This paper describes our participation in the shared task of hate speech
detection, which is one of the subtasks of the CERIST NLP Challenge 2022. Our
experiments evaluate the performance of six transformer models and their
combination using 2 ensemble approaches. The best results on the training set,
in a five-fold cross validation scenario, were obtained by using the ensemble
approach based on the majority vote. The evaluation of this approach on the
test set resulted in an F1-score of 0.60 and an Accuracy of 0.86. | [
0.0481029637,
0.065076232,
-0.0200613383,
0.0281968061,
-0.0253092833,
0.0392148457,
0.0325106792,
0.0085449573,
-0.0137127973,
-0.0673438236,
0.0001619672,
-0.0536841266,
0.0272304304,
-0.0210314728,
-0.050390508,
-0.0319467299,
0.0050814981,
0.0089196637,
-0.0312791169,
-0.0224880893,
0.0479863659,
0.003312354,
-0.0086245369,
0.0414087288,
-0.0707237497,
0.0362900719,
0.0270763971,
-0.032515496,
0.0258760564,
0.0214873888,
0.0427660011,
0.0702513307,
-0.0301304627,
0.0581437461,
0.0000019439,
-0.03008263,
-0.0371594504,
0.0024686684,
0.0053228191,
-0.0867343843,
0.0486986004,
-0.0209595188,
-0.0316593312,
0.0440292284,
-0.0266386643,
0.0051476313,
0.065751031,
0.0979983956,
0.0761997402,
0.0683196336,
0.0006635829,
-0.0607738197,
0.0057256557,
0.0464187972,
-0.0475829616,
0.0478195101,
0.0354144722,
-0.0786505714,
-0.0613714829,
-0.0431993604,
-0.0172636081,
0.0062328554,
0.0000237807,
0.0198173821,
0.0119909188,
-0.0377413034,
-0.0569948442,
-0.0242393557,
-0.0166042652,
-0.0007327885,
-0.0542789027,
-0.0080233691,
-0.0320242606,
0.0183770601,
-0.0440121852,
0.0142070139,
0.0012237466,
0.0208657812,
-0.0476583391,
0.0194861274,
0.0004755414,
0.0380072072,
0.007695531,
0.0386219397,
-0.0521279052,
0.0775156319,
-0.0029412436,
-0.0549846217,
0.0249868371,
0.0214146804,
-0.0134247737,
0.034195248,
0.0358309187,
-0.0049657542,
-0.0064915861,
0.0013849129,
-0.0027185499,
-0.0944709182,
-0.001789713,
-0.0465065278,
0.0421452783,
0.0492994525,
0.0049077678,
-0.0058108801,
-0.039647799,
0.0644832104,
0.0120738838,
0.0119328368,
-0.0372898243,
0.0016241384,
-0.0395065919,
0.0400112197,
-0.0231795609,
0.0263399091,
-0.0390708148,
0.04851266,
-0.0644572601,
-0.0157424584,
-0.0287376568,
-0.0363948643,
0.0447911173,
0.0135982977,
-0.0101590278,
0.0061980854,
0.0088380277,
0.0393640511,
0.0056611649,
0.0030137131,
-0.0723957121,
-0.0839567408,
0.0146383168,
0.054529313,
-0.02490394,
-0.0102976095,
0.0241212416,
0.0460215397,
0.0272600781,
-0.0562324971,
-0.0061658463,
0.0173977073,
-0.0557285659,
-0.0349068642,
-0.0132429739,
-0.0576779842,
0.0063838875,
-0.0012486731,
0.0070764059,
-0.037833523,
-0.0002918052,
0.0118112583,
-0.0003955344,
0.0751550123,
0.0212860536,
-0.0196864158,
0.0568956211,
0.0192644242,
0.0109213851,
0.0563508794,
0.0133928834,
0.0206168685,
0.0215619989,
0.0078806235,
0.0381326303,
0.0689338893,
-0.0009216049,
-0.0097114071,
-0.0091223279,
-0.0215291977,
-0.0372107811,
-0.0371845849,
-0.0396384709,
0.0578518324,
0.0005693355,
-0.0452234857,
0.0370450951,
0.041110687,
-0.0165757071,
0.0035836212,
-0.0007803174,
0.0107660135,
0.0047392994,
-0.0046315645,
-0.0176740475,
-0.0385922603,
-0.0418773815,
-0.0458206534,
-0.0036642749,
0.0938442275,
-0.0135235749,
-0.0655030608,
-0.035808824,
-0.015392499,
0.0163336936,
-0.0405263491,
0.0709667131,
0.0211115349,
-0.0359861217,
0.0369442552,
0.041418992,
-0.026579177,
-0.0012472789,
-0.0461186506,
-0.0141880009,
0.0240678471,
0.0313766934,
0.0033026559,
0.0022335427,
-0.0750456229,
-0.051560048,
0.0472332537,
-0.0368961468,
0.0022350706,
-0.0014787799,
-0.0341633894,
-0.0380087458,
0.0863926411,
0.0261136536,
0.0024513053,
0.0545207411,
0.0096847676,
-0.0064952467,
0.0280033387,
-0.0189038962,
0.0363989398,
0.0399604701,
-0.0054377089,
0.0110717984,
0.0264209677,
0.0543652587,
0.0302616321,
-0.0426804125,
-0.0499857999,
0.0334140696,
-0.0351056159,
-0.0914189368,
0.0432478897,
-0.0388438441,
-0.0149291484,
0.0141235646,
-0.0646612123,
0.0151258428,
0.0790283605,
0.0190189928,
-0.0020801043,
0.0508581661,
-0.0517681614,
-0.0218254961,
-0.015005447,
0.0326688401,
-0.0474212654,
0.056611985,
-0.0352184363,
0.0605486259,
-0.0192686841,
-0.010227575,
0.0012511399,
-0.0694288388,
0.0490118191,
0.020737322,
-0.0886416212,
-0.0020458887,
-0.0090814624,
0.0265976451,
0.0205172915,
-0.0274954569,
0.0062354747,
-0.0357954912,
-0.0621926337,
-0.0105242347,
-0.0456511192,
-0.0082312236,
-0.0149022639,
0.0035377501,
-0.0036481924,
0.0315856934,
0.0092236716,
-0.0757061541,
0.0723100379,
0.0040339804,
-0.0240157451,
-0.0660529286,
-0.0496138036,
0.0013479401,
-0.0101682665,
0.0000032374,
0.0563564338,
0.0240057781,
-0.0574506037,
0.0151796322,
-0.0623761155,
0.0104614552,
0.031537842,
0.0066446508,
-0.049659282,
0.0155355437,
0.032529138,
0.0110373702,
0.0387144201,
0.0634084493,
0.0689044297,
0.0082503222,
-0.0009189896,
-0.013818277,
-0.0074014058,
-0.0384507328,
0.0254224315,
-0.0327976681,
-0.0342650898,
0.0113131488,
0.0835693553,
0.0394588113,
-0.0167240594,
-0.0544191264,
0.0056614042,
-0.0497548059,
-0.0298120193,
0.0111592123,
-0.077923052,
0.0008512864,
-0.0022946352,
0.002958393,
-0.0446390882,
0.0509481058,
-0.0227471069,
0.0237592384,
-0.0558254197,
-0.0298308507,
-0.0138205122,
0.0243092068,
0.011183585,
0.0428919196,
0.0084394831,
0.0093292808,
0.0169018731,
-0.0191204753,
0.0160814319,
-0.0334587805,
0.0180683285,
-0.0157585163,
0.0058574113,
0.0012954049,
-0.027092414,
-0.0848962441,
-0.0315915719,
-0.0476277992,
-0.0228599794,
0.0548618399,
-0.0216030199,
-0.0778598934,
0.0683827773,
0.0031323638,
-0.0093247546,
-0.0072246869,
0.0033676496,
0.0427469499,
-0.0051306379,
-0.0178605672,
-0.000695686,
0.032848306,
-0.0076059313,
0.007602355,
0.061291948,
0.0170456879,
0.0328550749,
-0.0577007085,
-0.0233748779,
0.0323235989,
-0.0301560964,
0.0082036546,
-0.0724017546,
-0.011376394,
-0.0068326658,
0.0114972489,
0.1114615351,
-0.0002639491,
-0.0202543754,
-0.0143888192,
0.0149956681,
-0.006497121,
-0.0146206077,
-0.0171510018,
-0.0663513467,
0.0124146082,
0.0130280145,
0.0148021085,
-0.0649783313,
-0.0248318408,
0.0386828706,
-0.0529867932,
-0.0009890145,
-0.0218530204,
-0.0389099196,
-0.0313882902,
-0.020020362,
0.0321757719,
-0.056458801,
0.0213071704,
-0.0331569947,
0.0235092044,
-0.0057116169,
0.0320128985,
-0.0538418517,
-0.0145984534,
0.0009223928,
-0.044088643,
0.019965753,
0.0500606373,
0.0081592882,
-0.030415982,
-0.0232521873,
-0.0289709922,
-0.0456951,
-0.0041503138,
-0.0558973104,
0.0356604569,
0.0011989123,
-0.0343639366,
-0.0032849349,
-0.0181017183,
-0.0326740034,
0.0257938057,
0.0043436456,
0.0441420078,
0.0080681546,
0.0046389573,
-0.0199373048,
0.0388721898,
-0.0279814173,
0.0737955123,
-0.0278006736,
-0.0596769266,
0.0117946845,
-0.0259843189,
-0.0126554826,
-0.0420331694,
-0.0858685747,
0.0142775066,
0.0258302484,
-0.0076433439,
-0.0524700135,
-0.0192873087,
0.0282799769,
0.0324469618,
0.031605918,
-0.002894389,
-0.0042693266,
0.0277710669,
-0.0339301787,
-0.0144998524,
0.0227497071,
0.0418209024,
-0.0375804715,
0.0122196348,
-0.0048489897,
-0.0241995975,
-0.0248172712,
-0.009604048,
-0.0654672086,
-0.0174159929,
0.1013587713,
0.0380266123,
0.0197614506,
0.006267596,
-0.005845279,
-0.0384860262,
0.0540313348,
0.055498451,
0.0158584658,
-0.0012844381,
0.0414047278,
-0.0585777611,
-0.0247623045,
0.0117827896,
0.0336221494,
0.0857688785,
0.0336908288,
-0.0480070226,
-0.0642214492,
-0.0270641651,
0.0119454628,
-0.0313946828,
0.0448029749,
-0.0242572334,
-0.0680150613,
-0.0225250553,
0.0134938071,
0.0235150643,
-0.0225839205,
-0.0075037084,
0.0009019481,
0.0013665518,
0.0203117188,
-0.0326845869,
-0.010142942,
-0.0290026292,
-0.0162368007,
-0.011753099,
0.0757369101,
0.0537354872,
0.0010589588,
0.0153578389,
0.0377703011,
-0.0094882706,
-0.0096609425,
0.0434647016,
-0.0078912415,
0.0107885683,
0.0138049526,
-0.0059543001,
0.0031148801,
0.0362694487,
0.0117305666,
0.0032375182,
0.032503657,
-0.0708823875,
-0.0151939848,
-0.0133173903,
-0.029270662,
0.0366164669,
0.0113151902,
0.017213814,
-0.0233703256,
-0.0077422149,
-0.0035020544,
0.0226010717,
0.0085870614,
0.014164811,
-0.0121913301,
0.0100240763,
0.0370566249,
-0.0382448733,
0.0343613029,
0.0621093288,
-0.0174006727,
-0.0502084419,
0.0005876134,
-0.0054978309,
-0.040417444,
-0.0135751218,
0.0251792837,
-0.0458708182,
-0.0115454197,
0.0608753674,
-0.0475672893,
0.059665028,
-0.0014029965,
0.0180567577,
0.0553697273,
-0.0027092348,
0.0335054807,
-0.0068957093,
-0.0173234232,
-0.0033003308,
-0.0210950281,
-0.0040544998,
-5.710590127e-33,
-0.0253120344,
-0.0383942202,
-0.027708577,
-0.0021365308,
0.0032382063,
-0.0211151335,
0.0508961901,
0.0205122512,
-0.0129231093,
0.021011617,
-0.0153352451,
0.0078808954,
0.0251381826,
0.0075177979,
-0.011315247,
-0.0131667787,
0.0559928752,
0.0047771931,
-0.0131276548,
-0.0254749637,
0.048402518,
0.0326803327,
0.0606779903,
-0.0447032601,
0.0098423911,
-0.010315177,
-0.0516113006,
0.0182151143,
-0.0161959678,
0.0949942917,
-0.0036676687,
0.0804683343,
0.0430427305,
-0.0646823123,
0.0210913941,
-0.0060452512,
-0.0277804229,
0.0210566856,
-0.0012418395,
0.0672395006,
0.0570708811,
0.0142635172,
0.0314156041,
0.0012587107,
-0.086560227,
-0.0158722084,
0.0360522233,
-0.0494156033,
0.0189781021,
-0.0436332114,
-0.0821325183,
0.044033058,
-0.0143775633,
-0.0082041696,
0.0211652741,
0.0552817918,
0.0293809529,
0.0073321243,
-0.0598571114,
0.0126493881,
0.0333893634,
0.0091413083,
0.0095036989,
-0.0009840699,
-0.0243326165,
0.0549867004,
-0.0053527448,
-0.0196849722,
-0.0336501971,
-0.0209153742,
0.035871949,
0.009330539,
0.072352916,
0.0342931896,
-0.0082693575,
-0.0323496647,
-0.0233632438,
0.0354334004,
0.0446500853,
0.0282716826,
0.0403821692,
-0.0406509079,
-0.0781970397,
-0.0212628283,
0.0032290414,
-0.0472425632,
0.000357753,
-0.0125061823,
0.0020595083,
0.0129374666,
-0.0654074103,
0.0112646259,
0.0129343392,
-0.0254884977,
0.0483945645,
0.0285901744,
-0.0085585145,
0.0062091583,
0.0037372415,
0.0295130853,
-0.0188574046,
-0.0194955971,
0.0221362375,
0.038040176,
0.0165754091,
-0.0186988246,
0.0563673787,
0.0549491569,
-0.1017011032,
0.0238246564,
-0.0055917273,
0.065892525,
-0.0041560037,
0.0919777304,
-0.0020911517,
0.0408822224,
-0.031971667,
-0.0396535099,
-0.0140460096,
-0.0263002887,
-0.0172085837,
0.0461313464,
-0.00963422,
-0.0190385152,
0.0038563642,
-0.001679067,
0.0070914482,
-0.0336091928,
-0.0011051771,
-0.075020045,
0.0126045896,
-0.0299294032,
2.551e-7,
0.0040081339,
0.0399295948,
-0.0069876625,
-0.0453041941,
-0.0032305797,
0.0201586876,
0.0152419638,
-0.0168437585,
0.0114662619,
0.0525395609,
-0.0258710943,
0.0311670061,
0.0209419448,
0.0421154872,
-0.0537854321,
-0.0363102593,
-0.0512525924,
0.0112507651,
-0.0106871696,
0.0234425087,
0.0090857856,
0.1151369736,
0.0231530555,
-0.0446688607,
-0.0570939854,
0.0273851845,
0.0124644879,
-0.0161695313,
0.0036456294,
0.0060404646,
0.0725644752,
-0.0167733729,
0.028307952,
0.0239424352,
-0.0073895203,
0.0354545079,
0.0206053704,
0.0251379572,
0.0116649345,
0.0294686239,
0.0258891657,
0.0023965815,
-0.0236628894,
-0.0393285416,
0.0214134492,
-0.0038580224,
-0.0057025556,
-0.0473120734,
-0.0353453457,
0.0130875763,
0.0334773883,
-0.0120115848,
0.01586904,
0.0101783425,
0.0295940619,
-0.0085221343,
0.0040401462,
-0.0558564626,
0.0073784054,
-0.0210989434,
-0.0176888667,
-0.0195008516,
0.0081719654,
-0.0279478412,
0.0303020515,
0.0451891758,
-0.0021908341,
1.808719267e-34,
0.0313144736,
0.0062110978,
-0.0288705323,
0.0237776674,
0.0203981847,
-0.0120661706,
0.0114037069,
-0.008005634,
-0.0007126786,
-0.0485336669,
-0.0009039085
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.09752v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09752v3 | CoLT5: Faster Long-Range Transformers with Conditional Computation | 2023-03-17T03:28:17 | 2023-10-24T00:51:49 | Joshua Ainslie, Tao Lei, Michiel de Jong, Santiago Ontañón, Siddhartha Brahma, Yury Zemlyanskiy, David Uthus, Mandy Guo, James Lee-Thorp, Yi Tay, Yun-Hsuan Sung, Sumit Sanghai | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Many natural language processing tasks benefit from long inputs, but
processing long documents with Transformers is expensive -- not only due to
quadratic attention complexity but also from applying feedforward and
projection layers to every token. However, not all tokens are equally
important, especially for longer documents. We propose CoLT5, a long-input
Transformer model that builds on this intuition by employing conditional
computation, devoting more resources to important tokens in both feedforward
and attention layers. We show that CoLT5 achieves stronger performance than
LongT5 with much faster training and inference, achieving SOTA on the
long-input SCROLLS benchmark. Moreover, CoLT5 can effectively and tractably
make use of extremely long inputs, showing strong gains up to 64k input length. | [
0.0359199904,
0.0529921874,
0.0125192702,
0.0426097326,
-0.016917225,
-0.0113048172,
0.0283968635,
-0.016772639,
-0.0351445787,
-0.0179856736,
-0.0408294089,
-0.0224060081,
0.0056061018,
0.0278573427,
0.0070180329,
-0.0479719341,
0.0374061167,
-0.0270408187,
-0.0303809606,
0.0303391479,
-0.0057899752,
-0.0124458512,
0.0129146874,
0.0193274636,
-0.0277014542,
-0.0039006069,
-0.0040757093,
-0.0097732265,
-0.0087329643,
-0.0105787823,
-0.0080054831,
0.0213450249,
0.0081691071,
0.0212458614,
0.0000018105,
-0.0007496894,
-0.0135699576,
0.0184345637,
-0.0234607179,
0.0056102844,
0.0370073766,
-0.0578203835,
-0.0083486792,
0.0030976019,
-0.011177511,
-0.0477707684,
0.029178638,
0.0987160131,
0.0375638716,
0.0943748578,
-0.0179433078,
-0.0729232579,
0.0577454641,
-0.0598256625,
0.0058918493,
-0.0440882295,
0.0001548136,
-0.0853822604,
0.0082701333,
0.0338046104,
-0.0290704891,
0.0403222889,
0.0654721409,
-0.000969005,
0.0179373026,
0.0546080917,
-0.024249617,
-0.0149512701,
0.0050850287,
0.0604596622,
-0.0418090187,
-0.0071450607,
-0.0023224489,
0.0036115551,
0.008832166,
-0.0497341231,
-0.0231123902,
0.0051251599,
-0.0002503666,
-0.0040027918,
0.0157591756,
0.0223535039,
0.0097504631,
0.0008347109,
-0.0629092306,
0.0538620129,
0.0023042047,
-0.0233163033,
-0.0222572554,
-0.0124943294,
-0.0216012262,
-0.0193410981,
0.039715264,
0.0189998969,
-0.0188361257,
-0.0111082867,
-0.0425997674,
-0.0474585891,
-0.007291554,
-0.025952911,
0.0139698992,
0.0321653113,
-0.0379598811,
0.0466627032,
-0.0519644804,
0.0378039442,
-0.071588397,
0.0247359686,
-0.0169076398,
-0.0323627517,
-0.0063059386,
-0.0140882051,
-0.0612845868,
-0.0007498208,
-0.0431038253,
-0.0485800803,
-0.0077864979,
0.0054827537,
0.0156040266,
-0.0098251039,
0.0361768343,
-0.0061436524,
-0.0498454981,
-0.0280309934,
0.0045528389,
0.072991237,
-0.0562887639,
0.0251022782,
0.0020605181,
-0.0336034521,
-0.0378963947,
0.0204785299,
0.0256280657,
-0.0535588749,
0.0181342755,
0.0757080764,
-0.0060802083,
-0.0501847342,
-0.0348534398,
0.0099908877,
-0.0309790857,
-0.0622362345,
0.0407595038,
-0.048693113,
0.0361633264,
0.0113105057,
-0.0085516255,
0.0058036554,
-0.0119518712,
0.0586204007,
-0.0062951511,
0.0657528713,
0.0517415404,
-0.0367651023,
0.0103242146,
-0.0069020102,
-0.0307468772,
0.0506941602,
0.02438033,
0.0483420119,
0.0026338364,
-0.0173140746,
0.0269901268,
0.0446085893,
0.0143649494,
-0.0369438045,
0.0005087338,
0.0011308852,
-0.0263912883,
0.017646376,
0.045034565,
0.0511432551,
-0.0294476245,
-0.0403631814,
0.0326322243,
0.0487627238,
0.059775997,
0.0259581655,
0.0297295526,
0.0064504389,
-0.0332740434,
0.0041697156,
-0.0634374842,
0.0606670603,
0.0224019196,
0.0094679054,
-0.0002879831,
0.0214286633,
-0.0225954987,
0.0013555911,
0.0035729997,
-0.003180838,
0.0109210638,
-0.0246528368,
0.0402304232,
0.0360180661,
-0.0372625701,
0.0965004265,
0.002221012,
-0.0607032925,
-0.0154444417,
-0.0226243269,
0.0216281693,
0.0175514426,
0.0160083883,
-0.0152273467,
-0.0132902656,
-0.0118443882,
0.0031429259,
0.0645907894,
0.0371822007,
0.0171656385,
0.0068460442,
-0.032458961,
0.0222629998,
0.0035320362,
0.0069558634,
-0.0106994398,
0.045762457,
0.0388596691,
0.0356409103,
-0.0369266644,
0.0086239381,
0.0257582795,
-0.0169324037,
-0.0320068933,
0.012935196,
0.0240928065,
0.039402701,
0.0015637783,
0.0174758136,
0.042747397,
0.0221136473,
-0.0523296408,
-0.0339837633,
-0.0128394887,
-0.0702858269,
-0.0428131409,
0.0242951624,
-0.0634021759,
-0.0007728225,
0.0326143727,
-0.0329592898,
-0.0212120228,
0.0264723208,
-0.0699195489,
0.0261593647,
-0.00217499,
0.0104543483,
0.0381220691,
0.054470323,
-0.016805714,
0.0393232778,
0.0124000832,
0.0130006131,
-0.0036639383,
-0.0136595098,
-0.0011638299,
0.0040451195,
-0.0142841479,
0.0062687495,
-0.0313341133,
-0.0412052087,
0.0033985472,
-0.0311825369,
-0.0279457718,
-0.0636193305,
-0.0703219771,
-0.0061266022,
-0.0344379954,
0.0373217799,
-0.0025667537,
0.0503901951,
0.0032474909,
-0.0188156646,
-0.0358401462,
-0.0196706597,
-0.0052483832,
0.0321384743,
0.0213337019,
-0.0031786887,
-0.0257581193,
-0.0267182682,
-0.0413289964,
0.0005041897,
0.0550487675,
-0.0101000872,
-0.03477237,
-0.0355795994,
-0.0293668229,
0.0229068231,
0.0451230966,
-0.0315177888,
-0.0426747315,
-0.0166139845,
-0.039268814,
0.0654044971,
0.0464603007,
0.0264153145,
-0.0146289803,
-0.0123316273,
-0.0025175957,
-0.0081539582,
0.0374561064,
-0.0166300591,
0.0341614559,
-0.0502491184,
0.0228929296,
0.0006498302,
0.0577390566,
-0.0310518965,
-0.0068652942,
-0.0271954164,
-0.0091864867,
0.008008495,
0.0002203462,
0.0398849547,
-0.0153402938,
-0.0216256268,
0.0148621742,
-0.0142451897,
0.0046741134,
0.0545652509,
-0.0523834489,
-0.0268497299,
-0.0354500152,
0.0182787124,
-0.0675374344,
0.0622091293,
0.0462169386,
-0.0377887897,
-0.0281995963,
-0.0451351702,
-0.0133935083,
0.0377430804,
0.0040964247,
-0.0100779478,
0.069419831,
0.0091474568,
0.0372045711,
-0.0485912375,
-0.0448433161,
-0.0257127825,
-0.0397042707,
-0.0174944755,
0.0046029389,
0.0408911742,
-0.0448907129,
-0.0397717431,
0.0182920862,
0.0273798332,
0.1060653999,
-0.0130746504,
0.0051423726,
-0.0264092404,
0.0427079387,
0.0147194583,
0.0212498568,
0.0294246599,
-0.0228980314,
0.0059046275,
0.0466686822,
0.0296388865,
0.0004768664,
-0.0393485986,
-0.0241290685,
0.0159645751,
-0.0380107798,
-0.0011300644,
-0.010597771,
0.0214759558,
-0.0961267799,
-0.0004538158,
0.0911319554,
-0.0007118115,
-0.0473256968,
-0.0018256179,
-0.0027383629,
0.025402125,
0.0058688554,
0.0260887947,
-0.0868495479,
-0.0596332252,
0.0171101037,
0.0033783058,
0.0218211282,
-0.0233680587,
0.0003145857,
-0.0892480314,
0.0465000272,
-0.0164453816,
-0.0462838821,
-0.0466003716,
-0.0489541404,
0.0019170825,
-0.0172434263,
-0.0011066707,
0.0191716608,
-0.0239522681,
-0.0357895195,
-0.0167528205,
-0.0172190387,
-0.0065526702,
0.0474741459,
-0.0280556493,
-0.0177523643,
0.0183531698,
0.0055899331,
0.0033395917,
-0.0421044342,
0.0461847447,
-0.0017285144,
-0.0057003503,
0.0216451604,
0.0832485408,
-0.0312714837,
-0.0070107048,
-0.0132887783,
0.0346589051,
-0.0153180351,
0.0130778346,
-0.0225200634,
0.0693064332,
0.0034632322,
-0.033888299,
-0.0232193675,
-0.0144184474,
-0.0327781737,
0.0573032945,
0.0301782712,
-0.0216245279,
-0.0739087686,
0.0136829996,
-0.0278133415,
-0.0429615602,
-0.0266818777,
0.0004342222,
0.0145181585,
-0.0882959664,
-0.0594489984,
-0.0560345463,
-0.0023847446,
0.0356809609,
-0.016449023,
-0.036006704,
0.0582962446,
-0.0057206554,
-0.0412860587,
0.0585928448,
-0.0228221193,
0.0185613055,
-0.0610408448,
0.058151558,
0.0679844469,
-0.0060461289,
-0.0101368399,
0.0414565913,
-0.1384379715,
-0.0321591161,
0.0180387441,
-0.0104134511,
0.0112510463,
0.0499116033,
-0.0328476951,
0.0088561792,
0.038173452,
0.044966463,
-0.0717590079,
0.0094075417,
0.0296025556,
-0.0617307462,
0.0171167012,
0.0405211486,
-0.0042853872,
0.026274858,
-0.0001178714,
0.0172664691,
0.0149878021,
-0.0041650697,
-0.0085952375,
-0.0077460492,
0.0438305028,
0.0219936855,
0.0413420834,
-0.0082922047,
0.0497744717,
-0.0270994026,
-0.0021656028,
-0.0271195862,
-0.0081313709,
0.009343585,
0.0061091771,
-0.0009764086,
0.0344781838,
0.0246926453,
0.0019765992,
-0.0216491446,
0.0345906951,
0.0178973861,
-0.047728356,
0.022612229,
-0.017769374,
-0.0107925171,
-0.0174181461,
0.0166346543,
0.0353048593,
-0.0491734482,
0.0453212038,
0.0331881419,
0.009429412,
-0.0495894887,
0.0178764798,
-0.0789538026,
-0.0382841155,
-0.0161645208,
0.0309296492,
0.0113714114,
-0.0365708433,
0.0284666959,
-0.0263365246,
-0.0142011996,
0.0032416454,
0.0153625766,
-0.0127644055,
-0.0334082879,
0.0117715821,
0.0137787946,
0.0049527092,
-0.0187611729,
0.0632386059,
-0.0212226063,
0.0213885419,
0.0138786128,
0.0001579163,
-0.0449988469,
-0.0375704654,
-0.0178502593,
-0.0217774827,
0.0002364681,
0.0217218064,
-0.0017431024,
-0.0452025756,
0.0386075266,
-0.0561227947,
-0.0057385927,
-0.0233325381,
0.0321264081,
0.0679901689,
0.0182894114,
-0.0461568497,
0.0026767659,
0.0380163342,
0.0436726473,
-0.0397121273,
-0.0415320992,
-6.091786782e-33,
-0.0052417698,
0.0070747058,
0.0320903361,
0.0177091062,
-0.0753668323,
0.0150358444,
-0.0123607889,
-0.0256178658,
-0.0158721581,
0.0218162015,
-0.0487412959,
0.0322074257,
0.0183781255,
0.0698126033,
0.0105928024,
-0.042027805,
0.0615751222,
0.0043001762,
-0.031830892,
0.0074829347,
0.0357066952,
0.0337902457,
0.0629676133,
-0.0014053605,
-0.0256164931,
0.0355182402,
-0.0008500449,
0.0069063096,
-0.0165626928,
0.0410513543,
-0.0131774405,
-0.0107189715,
0.039348565,
-0.0885274187,
-0.0210089497,
0.0628672242,
-0.1285494864,
0.006754742,
-0.0180700868,
0.0556548126,
-0.0341939852,
-0.0221405681,
0.0669957921,
0.0049547241,
0.0380064659,
-0.0659212098,
0.0183159951,
-0.0090293223,
-0.004598178,
-0.0184955075,
-0.0610443614,
0.0380648524,
0.0081961704,
-0.0143803321,
0.032740932,
0.0593651794,
-0.0037383998,
0.0428532921,
-0.0722909942,
-0.0216045734,
-0.0117322085,
0.0721990317,
0.0220738556,
-0.0097679272,
-0.0133355912,
0.0095537696,
0.0308626015,
-0.0126080364,
-0.0591006726,
-0.0390082635,
0.0279582664,
0.0155793671,
0.0482317731,
-0.0135605503,
0.0839984864,
0.0012703472,
-0.0516403131,
-0.0481134579,
-0.0025563037,
0.089458257,
0.0356088392,
0.0107694166,
-0.0113544296,
0.0031579142,
0.0017518045,
0.0114596989,
-0.0361967348,
0.0177326165,
0.0141409282,
0.0478151105,
0.0083317822,
0.0033263345,
0.0663316473,
-0.0099673187,
0.0073531978,
0.0602170266,
0.0040670885,
0.0273841675,
-0.0032090349,
0.0013582304,
-0.0274016447,
0.0230436977,
0.0232527386,
0.016431734,
-0.0070620375,
-0.0085275285,
0.0573412515,
0.0290944055,
-0.0725524276,
-0.0357429981,
-0.0396823362,
0.0367507152,
-0.0232161228,
0.0667850077,
0.0656440035,
0.0193727445,
-0.0121139763,
0.060945604,
-0.0249615852,
0.0387515537,
-0.016930813,
0.0115227876,
0.0353378654,
0.0365810357,
-0.0397873633,
0.0083668185,
-0.0445682928,
0.0279066879,
-0.0046494561,
-0.0698370785,
-0.0038742137,
0.0443034954,
2.607e-7,
0.0305878166,
0.025789896,
0.0902341455,
0.0371857025,
0.0176394712,
0.0109357256,
0.042953752,
0.0453053005,
-0.0100856936,
0.0291765518,
-0.0051751761,
-0.0120055983,
0.0433427431,
0.0224009845,
-0.103528738,
-0.0368201137,
-0.0968640596,
-0.0105855772,
-0.0334722959,
-0.0542611182,
0.0494758822,
0.1357963532,
-0.0164598264,
-0.0124690132,
0.0116808079,
-0.0228952039,
0.0375622064,
0.0173561815,
0.0097140037,
0.0098865628,
0.0280894265,
-0.0102707436,
0.0140367188,
-0.0009120411,
-0.0140692443,
0.0382191017,
0.0106930854,
0.067731604,
0.0205252673,
-0.0220835637,
0.022886876,
-0.0148618147,
-0.0244546086,
-0.0217362624,
0.0601200834,
-0.0791963711,
-0.0001126153,
-0.0304581411,
-0.0404741615,
0.0027140782,
-0.0187161192,
0.005999445,
0.0052932962,
0.0411153324,
0.0510657281,
-0.0278094057,
-0.0059188609,
-0.1019119844,
-0.0401697643,
-0.0114889797,
-0.0624555796,
0.0109424824,
-0.0619006231,
-0.010166605,
0.0592580363,
-0.0355862603,
-0.0348045155,
2.340882894e-34,
0.0334190503,
-0.0111894701,
-0.0020833977,
0.0019098092,
0.0178019181,
-0.0039321054,
0.0116226804,
-0.0009551774,
0.0092419283,
-0.0714400187,
-0.0384524912
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.09719v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09719v1 | Learning towards Selective Data Augmentation for Dialogue Generation | 2023-03-17T01:26:39 | 2023-03-17T01:26:39 | Xiuying Chen, Mingzhe Li, Jiayi Zhang, Xiaoqiang Xia, Chen Wei, Jianwei Cui, Xin Gao, Xiangliang Zhang, Rui Yan | cs.CL | cs.CL | As it is cumbersome and expensive to acquire a huge amount of data for
training neural dialog models, data augmentation is proposed to effectively
utilize existing training samples. However, current data augmentation
techniques on the dialog generation task mostly augment all cases in the
training dataset without considering the intrinsic attributes between different
cases. We argue that not all cases are beneficial for augmentation task, and
the cases suitable for augmentation should obey the following two attributes:
(1) low-quality (the dialog model cannot generate a high-quality response for
the case), (2) representative (the case should represent the property of the
whole dataset). Herein, we explore this idea by proposing a Selective Data
Augmentation framework (SDA) for the response generation task. SDA employs a
dual adversarial network to select the lowest quality and most representative
data points for augmentation in one stage. Extensive experiments conducted on
two publicly available datasets, i.e., DailyDialog and OpenSubtitles, show that
our framework can improve the response generation performance with respect to
various metrics. | [
0.0422270261,
0.1158202589,
-0.0050004348,
0.0271147247,
0.0058973539,
-0.0214982573,
0.0139844595,
-0.0144073293,
0.027281031,
-0.0437352136,
-0.0297845602,
-0.0499389209,
-0.0259499457,
0.0623940602,
0.0455751084,
-0.0736535266,
0.0403998196,
0.0120511083,
0.028720187,
0.0021526306,
0.0142382253,
0.0129208947,
-0.0360513218,
0.0365607068,
-0.0103491852,
0.0059968592,
-0.0279484652,
0.02761879,
0.026165653,
-0.0222201347,
0.0567297973,
0.0429859981,
0.0145178847,
0.0680225268,
0.0000018767,
-0.0001675046,
0.0326361358,
-0.0196653865,
-0.0272690989,
0.0121669807,
0.0186760705,
-0.0266068745,
0.0052446355,
0.0338073298,
-0.0491574965,
-0.0336606465,
0.048805438,
0.065685302,
0.0784742534,
0.094326131,
-0.0167510472,
-0.0136920707,
0.0419936217,
-0.061537005,
0.0025818527,
-0.0141415531,
-0.0215035304,
0.0230141412,
0.0024366376,
0.0289814528,
0.0041822009,
0.0226699915,
0.0462570414,
-0.0432507806,
-0.0005005,
0.0301458836,
-0.0296696685,
-0.0037884277,
-0.0028866322,
0.1061938629,
0.0335120931,
0.0204640869,
-0.0158102922,
-0.023134904,
0.0373068191,
-0.0635458007,
-0.0759847164,
0.0013375171,
0.019445451,
0.0203191843,
-0.0456316322,
0.028637059,
0.0033443512,
0.033646252,
-0.0134414472,
0.0019779208,
-0.0005776654,
-0.0068042064,
-0.0387500152,
0.0030322757,
-0.024721453,
-0.0611023717,
0.0171607491,
0.0237698909,
-0.0526230559,
-0.0022366401,
-0.0869075656,
-0.0398986749,
0.0322058946,
-0.0034120514,
0.0281926151,
0.0222314186,
-0.0246309806,
0.0123264259,
-0.0210239943,
0.0337012634,
-0.0295647252,
0.0208379589,
-0.0327560343,
-0.0146182794,
-0.0279990043,
-0.0295913257,
-0.0225521065,
0.0287037082,
-0.0807806998,
-0.0366218127,
-0.0479473136,
0.0128360437,
-0.0140230805,
0.0148411235,
-0.0041716904,
0.0568271801,
-0.0626340583,
-0.0062979059,
-0.0154319871,
-0.0017416289,
-0.0704998747,
0.0394285917,
0.0757782236,
-0.0672365576,
-0.0164955836,
0.0467157625,
0.0205464605,
-0.011923016,
-0.0232352316,
0.0676285326,
-0.0404114947,
0.0228374805,
-0.0329505168,
-0.0453217104,
-0.0285396036,
-0.0372458771,
-0.0144248586,
-0.0249996167,
0.0350899249,
-0.0404577479,
-0.0404800996,
-0.0398829356,
-0.0022834814,
-0.0010741557,
0.0081664864,
0.0316354707,
-0.0232530292,
-0.0392173864,
0.045860555,
0.0066220006,
-0.0124033438,
0.0516314581,
0.0367277302,
0.0446544625,
0.0013100494,
0.0102060763,
0.0132013522,
0.0134382369,
0.0665677711,
0.0195959341,
-0.0097180968,
0.0213178024,
-0.0607817918,
0.0384084359,
0.0300865639,
0.0338260904,
-0.0618170761,
-0.0341959745,
0.0706032813,
-0.0410342813,
0.0097400947,
0.0277033392,
-0.0012095314,
0.0526294038,
-0.009619371,
-0.0025305089,
-0.0119070103,
0.0599638969,
0.027766984,
0.0131636513,
0.0514168143,
0.0004347014,
-0.0472244583,
-0.0625489429,
0.0574231632,
-0.0102628302,
0.0377398022,
0.0131831057,
0.0005508517,
0.0408040471,
-0.0377418064,
0.0069715842,
-0.0173608847,
-0.0492702313,
-0.0110284621,
-0.0298975296,
0.0044496004,
0.019714402,
0.058341343,
-0.0235287342,
-0.0687292516,
-0.0410498977,
0.0023450411,
0.0558433309,
0.0561356023,
-0.0009412525,
0.0356446132,
-0.0905672833,
-0.0056887544,
-0.0632618666,
0.0025418096,
0.0615986846,
-0.0080442075,
-0.001007881,
0.0592819378,
0.023365641,
-0.0231300909,
0.0040196721,
0.0042146049,
-0.0087478245,
0.0595569685,
0.0011461242,
0.0494877696,
0.0336990841,
0.0113630323,
0.0091362922,
0.0130502889,
-0.0278666187,
-0.0211874899,
0.0062443018,
-0.0404776074,
-0.0649068877,
0.0090894019,
-0.0269325711,
0.0055958722,
0.0376191325,
-0.0542701855,
-0.0716555417,
0.0327335522,
-0.0516553186,
-0.0272769425,
-0.0598688088,
-0.0296425801,
0.0508603007,
0.0557383336,
-0.0230868198,
0.0411900543,
0.0021272521,
-0.0133061009,
0.0531457476,
0.0756174475,
0.0300719347,
-0.0767527446,
-0.0035714239,
0.0002149837,
-0.0347144119,
0.0258033033,
0.021594381,
-0.0075017512,
-0.0388203673,
-0.0157404989,
-0.0617096312,
0.0212349035,
-0.0035945647,
0.0025642775,
0.0325064622,
0.0256157517,
-0.0048262663,
-0.0253531467,
-0.0848701894,
-0.0092996871,
0.0407302119,
-0.0142403245,
0.047418721,
0.0252158791,
0.0144291427,
-0.060857933,
0.0212526005,
0.050487902,
0.0137421107,
-0.0088666314,
0.0014244892,
-0.0266194921,
-0.0093197552,
-0.0326684006,
0.0510463938,
-0.0195111874,
-0.0793623477,
0.0115684755,
0.0223731827,
-0.0169026908,
0.0399370231,
0.0431883931,
0.0123191262,
-0.0280375723,
0.0221639629,
-0.0551692881,
0.0406308249,
-0.018517239,
0.0373443365,
-0.0022411358,
-0.0295128766,
0.019979408,
0.0268061906,
0.0282128975,
0.0222872421,
-0.0237199869,
0.0470431633,
0.0564816482,
-0.0598498546,
0.0139002232,
-0.0237867404,
-0.035433054,
0.0276281107,
-0.0399638377,
-0.0399729684,
0.071245946,
-0.0296046901,
-0.0345417224,
-0.0250406042,
-0.0149821881,
-0.0144838737,
0.0133220945,
0.0154276099,
0.0230125487,
-0.0140913539,
-0.0350027271,
-0.0365310311,
-0.0154231153,
0.012685664,
-0.02924514,
0.0471357889,
-0.0033092324,
-0.0112332208,
-0.0208319761,
-0.0389293805,
-0.066801697,
-0.0346272215,
0.0197985582,
-0.0000020291,
0.0173382908,
-0.0302617084,
-0.034280438,
-0.0193921067,
-0.012532562,
0.0546435602,
-0.0503385141,
0.0261021331,
-0.0299446546,
0.0567654707,
0.0492928363,
0.0637001321,
-0.0102578076,
-0.031541504,
0.0473663732,
0.0204368122,
0.0232942645,
0.0091048805,
-0.031236792,
-0.0272753593,
-0.0010051427,
0.0273949057,
0.0096137719,
-0.0176555272,
0.0606372245,
-0.0348417945,
-0.0153426882,
0.0748194754,
0.0117741283,
0.0104585579,
0.0061555989,
0.0096331257,
0.0421532579,
-0.0018376003,
0.0138968825,
-0.0726025254,
-0.0254359543,
-0.033774823,
0.0372377597,
-0.0124145709,
0.0038209618,
-0.013898286,
-0.1050373763,
0.0445615239,
0.0124564804,
-0.0483270027,
-0.046448905,
0.0627833232,
-0.0121450592,
-0.0147337541,
0.0475114062,
-0.014242393,
0.0390755273,
0.0090602767,
0.0365651101,
0.0216165502,
-0.0452109873,
-0.0483249202,
-0.0108176144,
0.0517171994,
0.0428929515,
0.0443590395,
0.0173954833,
0.0169800334,
0.0206601676,
-0.005306656,
-0.0012756698,
0.0158522464,
0.0891230553,
0.0228525773,
-0.0297862533,
-0.0095571196,
0.0509158261,
0.0130664008,
-0.0069787111,
0.0272482615,
-0.0148848211,
-0.0402098373,
0.0126192104,
-0.0178536382,
0.0330413207,
0.0391051285,
0.0591079518,
0.0411803648,
-0.0196097996,
-0.0157581028,
-0.0197265632,
0.0106203835,
-0.1288965344,
0.0521155372,
0.0248728301,
0.0230698735,
0.0132396203,
-0.0989704728,
-0.0788263157,
-0.0059693353,
0.0076259081,
-0.0280810595,
-0.0185236316,
-0.0336049013,
-0.0366937183,
0.0047322814,
0.0086731743,
0.0029531217,
-0.0027444619,
-0.0196220186,
-0.0377623774,
0.0271821674,
-0.0688008144,
-0.0050369906,
0.0248126499,
-0.0530674569,
-0.0506811775,
-0.0357608348,
0.0441163965,
0.0214520711,
0.0925112888,
-0.0186293386,
-0.0364657119,
0.0182146486,
0.0497508273,
-0.0362780951,
-0.0302915592,
0.054465469,
0.0098413359,
-0.0256417505,
0.0120164687,
-0.0229517668,
0.0450135991,
0.0058438238,
0.0277498644,
-0.0333227254,
-0.0302227065,
0.0022233818,
0.0138291223,
-0.0052808565,
-0.0104350615,
0.0080969557,
-0.0432862453,
0.0368787348,
-0.0098205218,
-0.0067901784,
-0.0720813796,
0.0124542648,
0.019031642,
-0.0173808746,
0.0036954628,
-0.0243726391,
-0.0301654246,
0.0553870276,
-0.0648801476,
-0.0041333698,
0.0114792027,
0.0121653816,
-0.0049236007,
-0.0041326005,
-0.0262129009,
0.0359008163,
0.0062686428,
0.0275189914,
0.0041795732,
0.0668457001,
0.0094230063,
-0.0069129551,
0.0094850864,
0.032397218,
-0.0601750091,
0.0066435207,
-0.0398233049,
0.0264914092,
0.0091330092,
-0.011159678,
0.0408810638,
-0.0166373588,
0.0188608542,
-0.0210333765,
0.0611862652,
0.0093383938,
-0.0483314209,
0.0200253278,
0.0035567661,
-0.009964712,
0.0065999846,
0.0560146347,
-0.0073390398,
0.0280882455,
-0.0128094908,
0.0225227531,
-0.0638231561,
-0.0522447973,
0.0348605365,
0.0100180786,
-0.0124573484,
0.0220854077,
-0.0024479907,
-0.0392045863,
-0.0422196463,
0.0086205686,
0.0041027577,
0.002121855,
0.0506605692,
0.0159034263,
-0.020461401,
0.0191161297,
-0.04360459,
0.0254209302,
-0.0070159989,
-0.0242526401,
-0.0003569077,
-5.698770899e-33,
-0.0296709053,
-0.0005522889,
0.0097213201,
-0.0443696901,
-0.0352276228,
-0.0144587448,
-0.0427363589,
-0.0216342006,
-0.0234120209,
-0.0028257258,
0.0134861777,
0.001336873,
0.0031159462,
0.0753839538,
-0.0358918495,
-0.025968641,
0.0772721618,
0.0108356746,
-0.0218147002,
0.0470747799,
0.0202920884,
0.0180851668,
0.01393825,
-0.0617201254,
0.0105251083,
-0.0273837186,
-0.0240135789,
-0.0102913575,
0.0103583084,
0.0602853671,
0.0052115838,
0.0382212587,
0.0074754562,
-0.0369013585,
-0.0414932705,
0.0308461897,
-0.058708936,
-0.0231582299,
0.0039329519,
0.0194828119,
-0.0452487059,
-0.0275360569,
0.020043755,
-0.0288012438,
0.054484915,
0.0081322957,
-0.0034644951,
-0.0441892929,
-0.0287780259,
0.0084305415,
-0.044662796,
0.0315458775,
-0.0309127104,
-0.0416412875,
-0.0141812637,
0.0937222764,
0.0216305982,
0.0018483048,
-0.039026849,
-0.0071397303,
0.039328061,
0.0097399112,
0.0446385033,
0.0248019639,
-0.0288477335,
0.0641190782,
0.0071550016,
-0.011900303,
-0.0258511938,
0.0158083346,
-0.0281420816,
0.053320121,
0.04081624,
0.1001027077,
0.0292145964,
-0.0327393226,
-0.0536901988,
0.0446791016,
0.0198110528,
-0.0036322824,
0.0164567251,
0.0021845992,
0.0107924892,
-0.0041602571,
-0.0099005885,
-0.0187584665,
-0.0170514956,
-0.0439732559,
0.0366357528,
0.041658584,
-0.03178804,
-0.033958137,
0.0227490868,
-0.0437983647,
0.0136371888,
0.0268329475,
-0.0472773723,
-0.0282706451,
-0.0092540169,
0.001003522,
-0.0058855764,
-0.0344543718,
0.1029945463,
0.0287048854,
-0.0181785412,
0.0270578787,
0.0567850024,
-0.0153921265,
-0.0308498964,
0.0271017794,
-0.0314294659,
0.0870400518,
-0.0433892943,
0.041928567,
-0.0048088329,
-0.0189359281,
-0.035498593,
0.0568437092,
-0.0335745327,
0.0087775048,
-0.0331318118,
-0.0495554544,
0.0044486104,
0.015935069,
-0.0597396493,
0.0029766851,
0.0106095402,
-0.056266956,
0.0084867515,
-0.060675934,
-0.0074906386,
-0.00359824,
2.429e-7,
-0.0170343556,
0.0029090885,
0.047184933,
0.0168327522,
0.0302739572,
0.0385946035,
-0.006513766,
0.0386456884,
0.0089342706,
-0.0171522889,
0.0181182176,
0.0008521457,
0.0659463927,
0.0129932929,
-0.0657311454,
-0.0026305318,
-0.1058894098,
-0.0089904517,
-0.0168460924,
-0.0144530265,
0.051044181,
0.1002269536,
-0.0218569189,
-0.0147343744,
0.0356963277,
-0.0154163651,
0.0408978835,
-0.0023549853,
-0.0338414609,
0.0419774838,
0.0602248684,
0.0364420302,
0.0045445636,
0.0054853992,
-0.0382583477,
0.0100569213,
0.0160112362,
0.0426584482,
0.0294386763,
-0.0495611951,
-0.0110154012,
0.0005156815,
0.0352298766,
-0.0389563479,
0.0471956469,
-0.0480657704,
-0.0355927423,
-0.0164011996,
-0.0526473373,
0.009707286,
0.0188861974,
-0.0556177124,
-0.0173800346,
0.0065535833,
0.0338037647,
-0.0078581935,
0.0149098784,
-0.0576370619,
-0.0301608462,
-0.0347017758,
-0.0691104755,
-0.026503142,
-0.0530315973,
0.0001830273,
0.0113993259,
0.004917311,
-0.0034702346,
1.743821418e-34,
0.0308427438,
-0.0145025812,
-0.0043707332,
-0.0047386163,
-0.0091954824,
-0.0038928937,
0.0249961019,
-0.0002068106,
0.0359087177,
-0.0362034775,
-0.0430839621
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.09713v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09713v2 | CHAMPAGNE: Learning Real-world Conversation from Large-Scale Web Videos | 2023-03-17T01:10:33 | 2023-08-16T08:17:02 | Seungju Han, Jack Hessel, Nouha Dziri, Yejin Choi, Youngjae Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Visual information is central to conversation: body gestures and physical
behaviour, for example, contribute to meaning that transcends words alone. To
date, however, most neural conversational models are limited to just text. We
introduce CHAMPAGNE, a generative model of conversations that can account for
visual contexts. To train CHAMPAGNE, we collect and release YTD-18M, a
large-scale corpus of 18M video-based dialogues. YTD-18M is constructed from
web videos: crucial to our data collection pipeline is a pretrained language
model that converts error-prone automatic transcripts to a cleaner dialogue
format while maintaining meaning. Human evaluation reveals that YTD-18M is more
sensible and specific than prior resources (MMDialog, 1M dialogues), while
maintaining visual-groundedness. Experiments demonstrate that 1) CHAMPAGNE
learns to conduct conversation from YTD-18M; and 2) when fine-tuned, it
achieves state-of-the-art results on four vision-language tasks focused on
real-world conversations. We release data, models, and code. | [
0.050994046,
0.0990048796,
0.0024986882,
0.0273661092,
-0.0078822477,
0.0187456179,
-0.0170116629,
-0.0119768772,
0.0028974728,
-0.0694224387,
-0.0159992483,
-0.0406691395,
0.0157445092,
0.0729064122,
0.0355914459,
-0.0821862519,
0.0178406816,
-0.0220526513,
0.0353357419,
0.0284780711,
0.0524594784,
0.0133077893,
-0.0220499001,
0.0306957848,
-0.0565034859,
0.0138274012,
-0.0166302975,
0.0112992572,
0.0318446681,
-0.0111555113,
0.0076820455,
0.027985245,
0.0768374205,
-0.0102884537,
0.0000018133,
-0.0005173397,
0.0428418517,
-0.0412305705,
0.0120780207,
-0.011212362,
0.0202039983,
-0.0412653014,
-0.0010561411,
0.0462151505,
-0.0678722411,
0.0017876715,
0.0252823383,
0.0268110577,
0.0767448321,
0.0765704885,
-0.0358225517,
-0.0252778064,
0.0170381162,
-0.0391753241,
0.0474523529,
-0.0619296394,
-0.0199068431,
0.0260803383,
0.0060444279,
0.0180512816,
-0.0389155895,
0.0213107336,
0.0081351306,
-0.063053064,
0.0414056741,
0.0386729836,
-0.0551268347,
-0.0382494852,
-0.0023121578,
0.1182767302,
0.0217468757,
0.0240462217,
0.0176864509,
-0.0057066618,
0.020810619,
-0.0599831529,
-0.0782502592,
0.0483770929,
0.0436971709,
0.0195319317,
-0.0663005933,
0.0169134866,
-0.0038435215,
-0.0044911997,
0.0261324178,
-0.0217429902,
0.0056194952,
0.0385400429,
-0.0295803715,
0.0173366647,
0.0062973453,
-0.0762501806,
-0.014174914,
0.012372057,
-0.0165538788,
0.0096313283,
-0.0364700854,
0.0390448943,
-0.0289848,
-0.0583991781,
0.0175550897,
0.0219634622,
-0.0158896372,
0.0284165535,
0.0161149837,
0.0329213627,
-0.0204496477,
-0.010725826,
-0.0120200431,
-0.0180567075,
-0.0324552469,
0.0150037818,
-0.0287565254,
-0.0104854209,
-0.088171564,
-0.0634903759,
-0.0127080325,
0.0448300615,
-0.011052628,
0.0095232064,
-0.0093023609,
0.0424630381,
-0.0196411479,
-0.0072530983,
-0.0085068271,
0.0245882887,
-0.023503786,
0.0467343219,
0.0191973038,
-0.0840041935,
-0.0344993994,
0.0453667939,
0.0282983948,
0.0000937766,
-0.0150275631,
0.0528837256,
-0.0377687439,
-0.0240292903,
0.0175138786,
0.0140427779,
-0.0416565835,
-0.0295086168,
0.0197263714,
-0.0341545455,
0.0502760336,
-0.0466871038,
-0.0046945349,
-0.0438016616,
0.039663095,
-0.0064153112,
-0.0269240346,
0.0662907809,
0.0006349367,
0.0055343187,
0.0330217481,
0.0288781282,
0.0172570888,
0.0583423376,
0.0494899601,
0.0315798521,
0.0099249175,
0.0097062821,
0.0677175298,
0.0154542373,
-0.0034293677,
0.0057697799,
-0.0454210266,
0.0200524591,
-0.0085116439,
0.0857371762,
0.0292641949,
0.0573960692,
-0.0526516475,
-0.0326500498,
0.080882892,
0.0198606979,
-0.0682969093,
-0.0099135563,
0.0213462003,
0.0232208855,
0.0105279339,
-0.0380403511,
-0.0584125966,
0.0570196249,
0.0099975951,
-0.0229036529,
0.0047412589,
-0.0114596514,
-0.0733738244,
-0.0409544595,
0.0118129272,
-0.0180608425,
0.0233522616,
0.013335553,
0.0171093363,
0.0358723104,
-0.047628548,
0.0223946925,
0.0074908142,
-0.0504322834,
0.0041014613,
-0.0100836363,
0.0103171859,
0.0595040433,
0.016331045,
0.0035709832,
-0.0489359163,
-0.0230880212,
0.0539309829,
0.0459930152,
0.0165145285,
-0.0273224469,
0.0791631714,
-0.0728317425,
-0.0325364545,
-0.0304030012,
0.0182593372,
-0.0068352856,
-0.0097559039,
-0.0156257972,
0.0244004335,
0.0026002557,
-0.0058102808,
0.0391124226,
-0.0096298326,
-0.0044660885,
0.013666545,
-0.0070834854,
0.0098792706,
-0.0041070534,
-0.0304595623,
-0.0182362739,
0.0168992542,
-0.0329510123,
0.0189137589,
0.0340640806,
-0.0570231117,
-0.0426209569,
0.0270947963,
-0.047067035,
-0.031769298,
0.0268532,
-0.052483879,
-0.0395335183,
0.0551720522,
-0.0221193135,
0.0243698265,
-0.0527489521,
-0.0096879816,
0.057279136,
0.0222490728,
0.0013489595,
0.0088596409,
-0.0034865832,
-0.0621439032,
-0.0018966282,
0.02849737,
-0.0089336978,
-0.0533846281,
0.0096258549,
-0.0145396367,
-0.0125045013,
0.009199217,
0.0234932732,
0.0242628194,
-0.0708092451,
-0.0310365353,
-0.0945615768,
-0.0094860522,
-0.0053643575,
-0.0183696002,
0.0055925413,
0.0047145286,
0.0078901108,
-0.0419875309,
-0.0494118892,
0.0449286327,
0.0137598626,
-0.0128160976,
0.0541713238,
0.005215744,
0.0024051967,
-0.062440332,
0.0263885725,
0.0487965047,
0.0406169146,
0.0229355246,
0.0050418782,
0.0128456801,
-0.0063780705,
-0.038563475,
0.0638741478,
-0.0532523356,
-0.0410599224,
-0.0002493887,
-0.0208325367,
0.020871982,
0.0718142465,
0.0425297953,
0.0404245518,
-0.0311957225,
-0.0301237684,
-0.0366635211,
0.0020151602,
-0.0026825124,
-0.0150950039,
-0.0517027825,
-0.0021837414,
0.0011951545,
0.0127525516,
-0.0222573858,
0.0452094674,
-0.060453508,
0.0259761009,
0.0554262809,
-0.0373559184,
-0.0141456723,
0.0030738646,
-0.0286611151,
0.0292712077,
-0.0341471694,
-0.0622605123,
0.000780498,
-0.0293945838,
-0.0460283756,
0.0189109594,
-0.0120989876,
0.0033223082,
0.0708855614,
0.0101186149,
0.014164676,
-0.0005407077,
-0.0307850894,
-0.0659451038,
-0.0267651919,
0.0027582201,
-0.0022254554,
0.0429050736,
-0.0828074738,
0.0076577091,
-0.0066868039,
-0.0225868039,
-0.0518594645,
-0.0189604145,
-0.0351564437,
-0.024190519,
-0.0397103094,
-0.0143300463,
-0.050286293,
-0.0292080492,
-0.0064388523,
0.046451617,
0.0065854383,
0.0068016183,
-0.012536509,
0.048455175,
0.066646874,
0.0139376074,
-0.0183311403,
-0.0201198664,
0.0474876501,
0.0638129637,
0.0097885085,
0.0082301749,
-0.0519558489,
0.0041560414,
-0.002422781,
0.0427337401,
-0.0159587804,
0.010163581,
0.0556690916,
-0.0125032961,
-0.0485704355,
0.101255849,
0.0055160439,
-0.0334901586,
-0.0169605091,
0.0442349948,
0.0127436407,
0.0093345968,
0.0145808123,
-0.0841556862,
-0.027551325,
0.024067115,
-0.0107574668,
0.0194032807,
-0.0040076314,
-0.038620349,
-0.0861923099,
0.0525435284,
0.0176203754,
-0.004836149,
-0.0213384014,
0.0246309973,
0.0061741685,
-0.0408584885,
0.0138589377,
-0.0069463514,
0.0142004546,
0.0190328583,
-0.0091910595,
-0.0082439529,
-0.0682953,
0.0256433375,
-0.0275472887,
0.0753893405,
0.0131069049,
0.0494103245,
0.0134114092,
-0.0250105672,
0.0405552685,
0.0152583281,
-0.0213163309,
-0.0072939075,
0.0621804632,
-0.0280969702,
-0.0332638174,
0.0148405312,
0.0654860958,
-0.0105038667,
-0.0254854262,
0.0066927928,
-0.0049402546,
-0.0545699932,
0.0084050409,
-0.0148014789,
0.0269962847,
0.0388346948,
0.0499639995,
0.0186325964,
-0.0262808539,
-0.0119692916,
-0.0148233995,
-0.0364701748,
-0.0293367151,
-0.0272877943,
-0.037686903,
0.0492404737,
-0.002781952,
-0.090087682,
-0.0182279926,
0.0447489321,
0.0255072359,
-0.0356358774,
-0.0667299703,
0.0056630769,
0.0241536442,
-0.0348771475,
0.0525058918,
-0.023643706,
0.0026797219,
-0.0595998727,
-0.0238544494,
0.04721836,
-0.0483751558,
-0.0072032451,
0.0274419431,
-0.0669549853,
-0.0466465428,
-0.0407416895,
0.0922866166,
0.0166665241,
0.0849420652,
-0.0080050016,
-0.0115144094,
-0.0075782426,
0.0139586292,
-0.0013974662,
0.0186369568,
0.0278041735,
-0.0014345702,
-0.0077182115,
0.0483470708,
-0.0137063749,
0.042998936,
-0.0076458701,
0.0130371721,
-0.0449018888,
-0.0509419814,
-0.005726655,
-0.0483859479,
0.0361551605,
0.0038046453,
-0.0144139705,
-0.037584126,
-0.0265127514,
-0.0269414838,
0.0204821769,
-0.1195833534,
0.0264962614,
0.0317863338,
0.0151558779,
-0.0083270166,
-0.0074321623,
-0.0395238996,
0.0138514573,
-0.0107267508,
-0.0534945689,
0.0157558843,
-0.0144391404,
-0.0054516778,
0.0083042858,
0.023944864,
0.0354323871,
-0.046805881,
0.0182550903,
-0.0031740563,
0.043130409,
0.0233384613,
-0.0400157012,
0.0233904868,
0.0212819334,
-0.0533205755,
-0.0282575991,
-0.040007323,
0.0891852081,
0.0216460098,
-0.0079129869,
0.0143989613,
-0.0157189276,
-0.0016897039,
-0.0101020727,
0.0957579389,
-0.0302496906,
-0.0701320693,
0.0307725444,
0.0035318702,
-0.0344216488,
0.0036679916,
0.0701363981,
0.0181170534,
0.0210556313,
0.0193002727,
0.0295031574,
-0.0312797651,
-0.0145637887,
0.0476845503,
0.0116224652,
-0.0043282383,
0.0524517708,
-0.0060841599,
-0.0449466407,
-0.0253748409,
0.0303458627,
-0.0184133612,
0.02417586,
0.0512475446,
0.020709632,
-0.0051685539,
0.0188881606,
-0.0244506113,
-0.0072680279,
-0.0079823332,
-0.0405442417,
-0.0224752668,
-5.462792245e-33,
-0.0153933736,
-0.0116533507,
0.0213631541,
0.0072048507,
-0.0655978471,
-0.0033701838,
-0.0511680394,
0.0149588427,
-0.0109893531,
0.0255993046,
0.0217135604,
0.061125461,
-0.001735621,
0.0670653656,
0.0264899582,
-0.0149544552,
0.0344095565,
-0.0240075961,
-0.0039100689,
0.0479113087,
0.0109216971,
0.0157926269,
0.0462303609,
-0.0780865699,
-0.0306717921,
-0.011201459,
-0.0503098592,
0.0463885255,
0.0551202446,
0.0225289669,
-0.0213382151,
-0.0327925421,
-0.0123700881,
0.0094685275,
-0.0364912115,
0.0255562421,
-0.0646112859,
-0.006142329,
0.0058191828,
0.0254921615,
-0.0622552074,
0.0232695136,
0.0088937115,
-0.030616302,
0.022431666,
-0.0366870314,
0.0289892387,
-0.0384990498,
-0.0083281016,
0.0134575376,
-0.0331054293,
0.0022360517,
-0.0217829403,
-0.077677384,
0.0161223952,
0.0280406736,
0.0339680575,
-0.0056021772,
-0.0086401254,
0.0380341262,
-0.0538684204,
-0.0024914131,
0.0496509969,
0.0078196088,
0.0176948812,
0.0693366006,
0.0207676291,
-0.0420831814,
-0.0227271877,
-0.017652493,
0.0156509113,
0.0705247968,
0.02019112,
0.0604193658,
-0.0151250381,
-0.0087909084,
-0.0439924747,
0.0206533819,
-0.0306012686,
0.0448390953,
-0.0431540608,
0.0131811956,
0.0255185571,
0.0168374255,
-0.0163731258,
0.007244342,
-0.0080774175,
0.0113498196,
0.0221535619,
0.0383287519,
0.0078872778,
-0.0023212181,
0.0596958213,
-0.0600399747,
0.0108216312,
0.0564581826,
-0.0111484127,
0.0170226451,
0.0097702509,
0.0159038361,
-0.0208040532,
-0.0135320527,
0.0809426755,
0.0441617444,
-0.0025723991,
0.0101934737,
0.0226150732,
0.0347710289,
-0.017712405,
-0.0059154434,
-0.0331169292,
0.0435164422,
-0.0131074945,
0.0687524378,
0.0043688822,
0.0294769146,
-0.0700090528,
0.0506416932,
-0.0436369218,
-0.001493476,
-0.0106010772,
-0.0352658108,
0.0131928017,
0.0264323466,
-0.054082945,
0.0141350068,
-0.036744114,
-0.0386788547,
0.0510937274,
-0.0384600498,
-0.0089243585,
0.0114780562,
2.511e-7,
-0.0292770937,
0.0095786089,
0.0355841815,
0.0076720128,
0.0296131801,
0.0520085804,
-0.0222584233,
0.0602953173,
-0.0075755902,
-0.0458487719,
0.0397360697,
0.0514175147,
0.0546710566,
-0.0105990069,
-0.0199541915,
-0.0033194888,
-0.0651609674,
-0.056855157,
-0.0128774075,
-0.035804823,
0.0410357192,
0.1035064831,
0.0029264225,
-0.0049786582,
0.0564495325,
-0.0348482691,
0.0806469545,
-0.0345619433,
-0.0168277342,
0.001803522,
-0.0040235436,
0.010357473,
-0.0144183207,
-0.027069496,
-0.0308098719,
-0.0258944295,
0.0151908109,
0.0868219957,
-0.0385421105,
-0.0280230176,
-0.0335618407,
0.0339950137,
0.0109601133,
-0.0214977879,
0.0309215114,
-0.0658228099,
-0.0083809886,
-0.0420376956,
-0.0374899544,
-0.0078956643,
0.0241402276,
-0.000749576,
-0.0112061854,
0.0384809598,
0.0395415574,
-0.0241820961,
0.0101018865,
-0.1094889864,
-0.0023060488,
-0.0400816016,
-0.0509720445,
0.0198689085,
-0.009718718,
-0.0149518177,
0.0181148145,
0.0124852424,
-0.03032827,
1.488398779e-34,
0.0306928512,
-0.0058117979,
-0.0188513044,
0.0125906076,
0.0045130495,
0.0182413086,
0.001878718,
-0.0006866571,
0.0235563256,
-0.0295448154,
-0.007340115
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.09639v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09639v2 | Neural Architecture Search for Effective Teacher-Student Knowledge Transfer in Language Models | 2023-03-16T20:39:44 | 2023-10-13T21:34:39 | Aashka Trivedi, Takuma Udagawa, Michele Merler, Rameswar Panda, Yousef El-Kurdi, Bishwaranjan Bhattacharjee | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large pretrained language models have achieved state-of-the-art results on a
variety of downstream tasks. Knowledge Distillation (KD) into a smaller student
model addresses their inefficiency, allowing for deployment in
resource-constrained environments. However, KD can be ineffective when the
student is manually selected from a set of existing options, since it can be a
sub-optimal choice within the space of all possible student architectures. We
develop multilingual KD-NAS, the use of Neural Architecture Search (NAS) guided
by KD to find the optimal student architecture for task agnostic distillation
from a multilingual teacher. In each episode of the search process, a NAS
controller predicts a reward based on the distillation loss and latency of
inference. The top candidate architectures are then distilled from the teacher
on a small proxy set. Finally the architecture(s) with the highest reward is
selected, and distilled on the full training corpus. KD-NAS can automatically
trade off efficiency and effectiveness, and recommends architectures suitable
to various latency budgets. Using our multi-layer hidden state distillation
process, our KD-NAS student model achieves a 7x speedup on CPU inference (2x on
GPU) compared to a XLM-Roberta Base Teacher, while maintaining 90% performance,
and has been deployed in 3 software offerings requiring large throughput, low
latency and deployment on CPU. | [
0.0337784886,
0.0874470845,
-0.0309981685,
0.0574825108,
-0.0271570589,
-0.0059459461,
0.0257751551,
-0.0349560417,
-0.0285449065,
0.0085545769,
-0.0327637978,
-0.0200629719,
-0.0281118099,
0.0164366178,
0.0130306613,
-0.0505880117,
0.0365258344,
-0.0497979037,
0.0053320508,
-0.0051249312,
-0.012246456,
0.0038513946,
-0.0135749336,
0.0312755816,
0.0189992227,
0.0104227047,
-0.0380482562,
0.0282658879,
0.0197520219,
-0.0053356877,
0.0247758608,
0.017623391,
0.0259562042,
0.0146609154,
0.0000024845,
-0.0017743561,
-0.0296491459,
-0.031188935,
-0.0533775464,
0.0204445459,
0.0487729497,
0.0376316123,
0.0032773798,
-0.0046018809,
-0.0372556075,
-0.0206086114,
0.0672951192,
0.0048126946,
0.0809259489,
0.05869947,
-0.0057442132,
-0.0316967331,
0.0004839847,
-0.0310229864,
-0.061942786,
-0.0622340515,
0.0241493583,
-0.0454826578,
0.0018807225,
-0.0097199827,
-0.040425539,
0.0641855299,
0.033080373,
-0.0211492516,
-0.0218024105,
0.0138155287,
-0.0210530218,
-0.0281905048,
-0.013214183,
0.0714091286,
-0.0444345959,
0.0191418212,
0.0385650359,
-0.0056769098,
0.0055135735,
-0.0306167752,
-0.0161177665,
0.0070019304,
0.0107230628,
0.0272309128,
0.0273853503,
-0.0077728522,
0.035594482,
0.0308926478,
0.0014478485,
0.0154868653,
0.0317631736,
-0.0038374686,
0.0243632253,
0.0351959839,
-0.0315773673,
-0.0530762635,
0.0448641255,
0.0321702659,
-0.0121174604,
0.0352875702,
-0.0698907524,
-0.0508012064,
-0.0398018174,
0.0088671967,
0.064927496,
0.0462974831,
-0.0013337838,
0.0203543771,
-0.0361135304,
0.0548193492,
-0.0235772878,
0.0200435985,
-0.0481504761,
-0.0014820808,
-0.0574458912,
0.0149199124,
-0.0355709083,
0.0224002283,
-0.0355890989,
-0.0233118478,
-0.0280388407,
0.0125296796,
-0.0594909936,
-0.0367231742,
0.050320033,
0.0372188464,
-0.0174870621,
0.0272855852,
-0.0409628823,
0.1166986302,
-0.0286636706,
0.0059719584,
0.0239387043,
-0.0423835628,
-0.0143395141,
0.0168788508,
-0.0081394464,
-0.0265343655,
0.0123784989,
0.0351518504,
-0.0311055444,
-0.0370886847,
-0.0569969155,
-0.0080072926,
-0.0007043644,
-0.0651935562,
0.0520307347,
-0.0481259078,
0.086112909,
-0.0383442417,
0.0061763343,
-0.0753046051,
0.0116299205,
-0.007328942,
-0.0007865306,
0.0314192809,
0.0078594368,
-0.0029265285,
0.0351069234,
0.0266787428,
-0.0244811401,
0.0815577134,
0.016243929,
0.0461427905,
0.0209468659,
-0.0087308316,
-0.0391274244,
0.0175000522,
0.0535708964,
0.0289084557,
-0.0172823854,
-0.0194277465,
-0.0153331859,
0.0466385297,
0.0649419501,
0.0466002561,
-0.0558016524,
0.0002781333,
0.0677862018,
0.030698495,
0.0278579518,
0.0050533051,
0.0304406937,
-0.0005737968,
0.0034523983,
-0.0191081464,
-0.0255379546,
0.0324710272,
0.0153983599,
-0.0430661663,
0.0343420468,
0.0808252171,
-0.0328353271,
-0.0460219681,
0.0336704664,
-0.0242340285,
-0.0155059351,
0.0301975999,
0.0591602512,
0.015445482,
-0.0265867598,
0.0709269643,
0.0453998037,
-0.03191109,
0.050290484,
-0.0834332183,
-0.0030617819,
0.0761178955,
0.0229607616,
-0.0036186487,
-0.0118046049,
0.0176343601,
-0.0021844765,
0.0232820027,
0.0304417107,
-0.0259191766,
0.0513190329,
-0.0588581301,
-0.0255458467,
-0.0016296962,
0.0200665891,
0.0171914939,
0.0189352911,
0.0430797487,
0.0033529825,
-0.0008205826,
-0.0395197868,
0.0355645083,
-0.0429002233,
-0.035628356,
-0.012392465,
0.0136790406,
0.0183468815,
-0.0170063637,
-0.0111029046,
-0.0323912241,
0.0141175753,
-0.0446035378,
0.0042352863,
-0.0343422182,
-0.0828833282,
-0.0596502498,
0.0133290216,
-0.0203741807,
0.0412780941,
0.0419751965,
-0.0504699126,
-0.0535466932,
0.0792123377,
-0.0110961599,
0.0390027016,
-0.0096192649,
0.0353868492,
0.0007008055,
-0.0153614832,
-0.0217828285,
0.0402438715,
-0.0084269792,
-0.0384959243,
-0.0062486734,
-0.030780986,
-0.0078966431,
-0.0036508739,
-0.042627193,
0.0003662081,
-0.0206152592,
0.0170294531,
-0.0035766256,
-0.00342002,
-0.0073179542,
-0.0305246823,
-0.0380102843,
0.0147910928,
-0.0141478041,
0.0192706175,
0.016462693,
0.0242859684,
0.0250110198,
-0.0194397848,
-0.0214708447,
0.0178703684,
-0.0455579534,
0.0047553256,
-0.0021295405,
0.0142842168,
0.002812756,
-0.0405082926,
-0.0478625298,
0.0271204039,
0.0431809984,
-0.0287099127,
0.0144769326,
-0.0335918367,
-0.0011437335,
-0.0146779669,
0.0513111465,
0.0008931718,
-0.041782625,
0.0019746695,
-0.0151962424,
-0.0062020007,
0.0715617761,
-0.0463646278,
0.0101443976,
0.0740781352,
-0.0225040261,
-0.0635275319,
0.0523479916,
-0.0061035124,
0.0185502637,
-0.01872609,
0.004225044,
-0.0104145482,
0.0723216683,
-0.0183191858,
-0.0284787565,
-0.0522448197,
-0.0247651432,
-0.0180662721,
-0.0176806841,
-0.0204263907,
-0.0169972982,
0.0180743076,
0.0087233437,
-0.0292906128,
-0.0207407549,
0.0501295924,
-0.0045788977,
0.0007748354,
-0.0638083965,
0.0027012047,
-0.0017209201,
0.0183193702,
-0.0028926015,
0.0150383618,
-0.0449680127,
0.01269075,
-0.0557541996,
0.0269401614,
0.0215106998,
-0.0273438301,
0.0475262925,
-0.0691710263,
-0.0187554155,
-0.015032514,
-0.0430094041,
-0.0150499931,
0.061124552,
-0.0157001149,
0.0226614028,
0.0397727005,
-0.0207421891,
-0.0286662821,
-0.0321860015,
-0.0044243811,
0.0769829452,
-0.0193823855,
0.0077268188,
-0.0328917652,
0.0165755432,
0.0453028306,
-0.0068841791,
-0.0085563036,
-0.044352524,
-0.0016750903,
0.0523752086,
0.0434483439,
-0.0147105344,
-0.0378716812,
0.0030189718,
0.0689151958,
-0.0165606681,
-0.0224617422,
0.0173368324,
0.0347602852,
-0.1013441235,
-0.0139789479,
0.064207904,
-0.0176925212,
-0.0545585491,
-0.0130143743,
0.0267806426,
0.0429316796,
0.0023392427,
0.052265577,
-0.0575689152,
-0.0438809618,
0.0060883625,
0.0087053329,
0.0158384666,
-0.0092429258,
-0.0196760017,
-0.0742276683,
-0.0091235377,
0.0002281433,
-0.0200013891,
-0.0077933902,
-0.0302380435,
-0.0043376507,
-0.0150505118,
0.0012645193,
-0.0109686535,
0.0101245567,
0.0099170292,
0.0265466943,
-0.0015496764,
-0.0595918521,
-0.0105692428,
-0.0277398396,
0.0195238143,
0.0788108483,
0.0386624672,
-0.0029932647,
-0.0829832926,
-0.0182988085,
-0.0119291432,
-0.0048657642,
0.0095542753,
0.072274588,
0.0089355279,
-0.0262751542,
-0.0153359221,
0.0077926368,
-0.0361737609,
0.0238672756,
0.0201271325,
0.1027175188,
0.0175825153,
-0.0292217229,
-0.0085582798,
-0.0408575051,
0.0468397737,
0.0580237843,
0.0189565625,
-0.0562016517,
-0.042517852,
0.0186763052,
-0.0225520935,
-0.0834319293,
0.0071011293,
0.0133671341,
-0.0333728194,
-0.0210698992,
-0.0559752658,
0.0042291195,
0.0295647625,
0.0539097004,
0.0309726223,
0.0029707868,
0.0455470718,
0.0066553089,
-0.034513697,
0.0006809669,
-0.0064161271,
0.022214327,
-0.043004401,
-0.0354459547,
-0.0297746155,
-0.012938017,
-0.0182987843,
-0.002039884,
-0.1101827845,
-0.0638976321,
0.0240884144,
0.0775256082,
0.0121193696,
0.0465163551,
-0.0025533473,
-0.0548117757,
0.0819335803,
-0.0126083661,
-0.0136852255,
-0.0084345872,
0.0426540375,
-0.0554232523,
0.00926142,
0.0459760092,
-0.0113452859,
0.0216005519,
0.0469131842,
0.0383994728,
0.0182364844,
0.0240024291,
-0.0170687549,
0.0023526784,
0.010744324,
0.0097586885,
-0.008226851,
-0.0492797717,
0.0274511185,
0.0156247113,
0.0141974958,
-0.0700717345,
-0.0118783424,
0.0615692511,
0.0314676911,
0.0130279027,
-0.0137506491,
0.0994085297,
-0.0122952936,
-0.0187783204,
0.0155532612,
0.0285505876,
0.0283640642,
0.0344770476,
0.0381939709,
0.0009679606,
0.0108684879,
0.0180259068,
0.0504176617,
-0.069808118,
0.0554208532,
0.0533060133,
0.0076491921,
0.0208354071,
0.0325285718,
-0.0306458659,
-0.0665655136,
-0.0292453654,
-0.0160328802,
0.0428812467,
-0.003974129,
0.0688810274,
-0.0057940464,
-0.0050479933,
-0.0043352419,
0.0211962536,
-0.0374757424,
-0.00699447,
0.0177127831,
0.0203696638,
0.0388171896,
-0.0034500647,
0.0547444597,
-0.0320766456,
0.0534224398,
-0.0232974235,
0.0461680442,
-0.0060563819,
-0.0153549481,
0.0047470354,
0.0361915343,
-0.0028756694,
0.0041632461,
0.0026004743,
-0.0552575625,
-0.0585287921,
-0.016705472,
-0.0333384238,
-0.0233313646,
0.0459613688,
0.0366805345,
-0.0173999462,
-0.0484570637,
-0.020288799,
-0.034656819,
0.0039447434,
-0.0114898589,
0.0018293317,
-7.024300941e-33,
-0.0029054729,
0.0367323495,
0.0349324606,
-0.0244535506,
-0.0311883744,
0.0074631241,
-0.0354294144,
-0.0380537324,
-0.0627047941,
0.0103925103,
-0.0243953466,
0.0243652388,
0.0220447686,
0.0525511727,
0.0223096162,
0.0149697373,
0.069009617,
-0.0010037716,
-0.0071347384,
0.0687131956,
0.0285026506,
0.0543308109,
0.0655073673,
-0.0086779771,
-0.0397324897,
0.0182884093,
0.0440718792,
0.0204570442,
-0.011140015,
0.0089707356,
-0.0232899636,
0.058424376,
-0.0020963938,
-0.0405672044,
-0.0244633518,
-0.0294271167,
-0.0740597099,
-0.0854558349,
0.0115598813,
0.0080006151,
-0.056953229,
-0.0373852253,
0.0398278609,
0.0285915565,
0.0347272567,
-0.0186412316,
0.0200087726,
0.0142348818,
-0.0182509385,
-0.0064600203,
-0.0573501736,
-0.0107036578,
0.0146141089,
-0.0264759474,
0.0560231246,
0.0328987166,
-0.0326923616,
-0.0299198627,
-0.0882250667,
0.0215410553,
0.0168922953,
0.071383886,
0.0508573763,
0.0586381108,
-0.0212461278,
0.0545334369,
0.0440902151,
0.0012044306,
-0.0037925586,
-0.0366229266,
0.0847369209,
0.0724237114,
0.0306547806,
-0.0385668091,
0.0743131414,
-0.0227202829,
-0.0406886153,
-0.0582958572,
0.0560347214,
0.0243892111,
0.0105186282,
-0.0058275219,
0.001534664,
-0.0569868013,
-0.0470549092,
-0.0539285094,
-0.0210915003,
-0.0195376258,
0.0476968549,
0.0309293959,
0.0049208323,
-0.0209554881,
0.023070721,
-0.0620165393,
0.0079518473,
-0.0114369076,
0.0002566851,
-0.0221064892,
0.0258772671,
0.0177109353,
-0.0881990343,
-0.045644749,
-0.0034873495,
-0.0211491287,
0.0030382485,
0.0141296722,
0.0227288324,
0.0371206962,
-0.0360416584,
-0.0054151886,
-0.0727157146,
0.0060616652,
0.0482123196,
0.0158890504,
0.0133432997,
0.0242894534,
-0.0319925062,
0.014232683,
0.0305372979,
-0.0025200788,
-0.02507817,
-0.0022839627,
0.0114915939,
0.0250827949,
-0.0398417525,
-0.023813501,
-0.068120189,
0.0055403691,
0.0000668897,
-0.1016375273,
-0.0240037944,
0.0145195583,
3.181e-7,
0.0019235597,
0.0227837265,
-0.0253696516,
-0.0454969145,
-0.0038221565,
-0.0053791259,
-0.0140316682,
0.0068294578,
-0.0054163355,
0.0025688049,
-0.02543143,
0.0428567082,
0.0624150373,
0.0340007097,
-0.0941738859,
-0.0163124017,
-0.0293511041,
0.013833235,
-0.0164155401,
-0.0614254922,
0.0128505332,
0.0501213893,
0.0609281361,
-0.0350455046,
0.0021923864,
0.0100851161,
-0.0039063967,
0.0081386883,
0.0526005775,
0.0343466215,
0.0336802416,
-0.0424073748,
-0.0333660915,
0.0470021814,
-0.0082660979,
0.0280796085,
-0.00540786,
0.0684922263,
-0.0070365653,
-0.0328633748,
-0.0054283971,
0.0156166116,
-0.0279858429,
-0.0463743918,
0.0738932937,
-0.0587774329,
0.0079011805,
0.0040745605,
-0.0309654102,
-0.0128229586,
0.0119332196,
0.0057622846,
0.0278864596,
0.0322067924,
-0.004876452,
-0.0068320371,
-0.0380203053,
-0.0690819472,
0.0257720761,
-0.009250693,
-0.0242482312,
-0.0556507446,
-0.0721503645,
-0.0319842882,
0.0121673299,
-0.0101368483,
0.017228175,
2.698848704e-34,
-0.0031753089,
-0.0165397301,
0.034594249,
0.0256926361,
-0.0050927545,
-0.0144697474,
-0.0617615581,
0.0154197952,
-0.0117286639,
-0.055033356,
-0.0364468694
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.13355v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.13355v1 | Revealing Weaknesses of Vietnamese Language Models Through Unanswerable Questions in Machine Reading Comprehension | 2023-03-16T20:32:58 | 2023-03-16T20:32:58 | Son Quoc Tran, Phong Nguyen-Thuan Do, Kiet Van Nguyen, Ngan Luu-Thuy Nguyen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Although the curse of multilinguality significantly restricts the language
abilities of multilingual models in monolingual settings, researchers now still
have to rely on multilingual models to develop state-of-the-art systems in
Vietnamese Machine Reading Comprehension. This difficulty in researching is
because of the limited number of high-quality works in developing Vietnamese
language models. In order to encourage more work in this research field, we
present a comprehensive analysis of language weaknesses and strengths of
current Vietnamese monolingual models using the downstream task of Machine
Reading Comprehension. From the analysis results, we suggest new directions for
developing Vietnamese language models. Besides this main contribution, we also
successfully reveal the existence of artifacts in Vietnamese Machine Reading
Comprehension benchmarks and suggest an urgent need for new high-quality
benchmarks to track the progress of Vietnamese Machine Reading Comprehension.
Moreover, we also introduced a minor but valuable modification to the process
of annotating unanswerable questions for Machine Reading Comprehension from
previous work. Our proposed modification helps improve the quality of
unanswerable questions to a higher level of difficulty for Machine Reading
Comprehension systems to solve. | [
0.0361586511,
0.0168619547,
-0.0259569883,
0.056429971,
-0.0592947789,
0.0318673551,
0.0118105263,
-0.0215462204,
0.0198900662,
-0.0091223093,
-0.0092501948,
-0.0421829112,
0.0006891152,
0.0068920259,
-0.0019252733,
-0.0328795761,
0.0506721362,
-0.0415264443,
-0.0315821804,
-0.0082657309,
-0.0079981228,
-0.0123659782,
0.0183346272,
0.009819326,
0.063345097,
-0.0544209108,
-0.0174922384,
0.0215235613,
-0.0044799312,
-0.0288461857,
-0.0258830711,
0.0234808698,
-0.0437092073,
0.0422257371,
0.0000020103,
-0.0154099623,
-0.0399218425,
-0.0078815389,
-0.0053192885,
0.0136314873,
0.0619698688,
-0.0784107223,
0.0188798737,
-0.0078269588,
0.0028281822,
-0.0180344991,
0.014550373,
-0.004989245,
0.0624369793,
0.0046200021,
-0.0060757585,
-0.0011326973,
0.0058670822,
-0.0143008148,
0.0249378756,
-0.0519505665,
0.0229762327,
0.0666092709,
0.048522044,
-0.0336072929,
-0.0621604249,
0.0789664388,
0.0324779414,
0.0214516278,
-0.014158532,
0.0097665945,
0.039571587,
-0.0119392034,
-0.0212766416,
0.0486194007,
0.0050182478,
-0.0151980855,
-0.045739878,
0.0102060679,
-0.0158984121,
0.0396789573,
-0.0330270045,
-0.0206507538,
-0.0263247676,
0.0081366999,
0.0610671863,
-0.0282359254,
0.0292175096,
0.0232839193,
0.0024647429,
0.024198072,
0.0033074522,
-0.0623770803,
-0.0009165091,
0.0130005851,
-0.0537446402,
0.0143327434,
0.0340036415,
0.0738226697,
-0.0080264276,
0.0421207361,
0.0001773581,
-0.0238059908,
0.0372193605,
-0.0444649011,
0.0338950343,
0.0696361065,
-0.0441972762,
0.0661283657,
0.0139627811,
0.0473228954,
-0.0402138829,
0.0362568051,
-0.091356203,
-0.0156772248,
0.0152566088,
-0.0377530828,
-0.058530733,
0.0184014495,
-0.0139285475,
-0.022441471,
-0.0020249984,
0.0144312112,
0.0222938713,
-0.0277731605,
-0.0202714335,
-0.0177542232,
-0.0742694587,
-0.0362854488,
0.0004067129,
0.0377952345,
-0.05009792,
0.0248730816,
0.003919756,
-0.0486236326,
0.0074464092,
0.0236836579,
-0.0458265319,
-0.0378110334,
0.0020111222,
0.0638315678,
-0.0208086539,
-0.0004763843,
-0.0232934095,
0.0202471558,
0.0123087866,
-0.0427635349,
0.015138356,
-0.0457744375,
0.0150953969,
0.0424681008,
0.0525899567,
0.0034867553,
-0.0012829551,
-0.0026525692,
-0.0330355391,
0.0980869308,
-0.0015482102,
0.010224673,
0.0307821222,
0.0179584138,
-0.0430029891,
0.0570379272,
0.018246768,
-0.0336216278,
0.0742656887,
-0.0230384544,
-0.0247539915,
0.0353398249,
-0.017298406,
-0.0101899682,
0.0073932367,
0.0420711339,
-0.0363915265,
0.0091982391,
-0.0178960972,
0.0668258518,
-0.0071323188,
-0.0330723301,
0.0230527781,
0.0195945036,
0.003469151,
-0.0005246314,
0.0584021993,
-0.0171690099,
0.0364796817,
0.0881256312,
-0.0152881555,
-0.0086840009,
-0.0489223339,
0.0484700426,
0.0033280174,
-0.0112158917,
-0.0182707123,
-0.0776910484,
0.0071379426,
0.0012889389,
0.010824413,
0.0312583335,
0.0711252019,
0.0305242296,
-0.0536447838,
-0.032527864,
0.0092415344,
0.0168698356,
0.0344462506,
-0.0275866967,
0.0296299029,
0.024066912,
0.0599720404,
-0.0081210574,
-0.0076351552,
0.030787291,
0.0098835938,
0.0238493383,
0.0514072105,
-0.0312913805,
0.0300699472,
-0.0258910619,
0.0478855185,
0.0434972234,
0.0144143496,
0.0498357192,
0.0012656463,
0.0089904135,
-0.0143095907,
-0.0680370107,
-0.0290467236,
0.0367010832,
-0.0491814502,
-0.0026831543,
-0.01967532,
0.0079059973,
0.0261185449,
0.0256638154,
0.0185324065,
0.0140548237,
0.0460890681,
-0.0438662507,
0.0392992683,
0.004592672,
-0.0281736068,
-0.0144683439,
0.0110622412,
-0.0469133593,
-0.0254993457,
0.060549818,
0.015258316,
-0.0461943783,
-0.0041178484,
-0.009899037,
-0.0306327306,
-0.0685940385,
0.04477733,
-0.0214493498,
0.0294664558,
-0.057565663,
0.0372689925,
-0.0231506806,
0.0557855964,
0.0378116518,
0.0230754428,
0.0038966672,
-0.0285855159,
-0.0655286908,
0.0513797328,
0.0037865164,
0.0058535412,
-0.0241651759,
-0.000890379,
-0.0413544886,
-0.0328737423,
-0.066057384,
0.0395973101,
-0.0216431431,
-0.000401022,
0.0038507271,
-0.0282665957,
-0.0232219417,
-0.0389611013,
0.0427941903,
0.0076822108,
0.0454645045,
0.025847951,
0.0087096654,
0.0337830223,
0.0218005814,
-0.0343248397,
-0.0592604391,
0.0195324067,
0.016339194,
-0.0029303932,
-0.0417756289,
-0.0421532802,
-0.0145526445,
-0.013226511,
-0.048712872,
-0.0218177531,
-0.0160661526,
0.0001828892,
-0.0108233392,
0.020000862,
0.0482309349,
-0.0181035064,
0.0490163602,
0.0138062006,
-0.0298273508,
-0.0149911763,
0.0203677136,
-0.0162951779,
-0.0132424347,
-0.0432111435,
-0.0349307694,
-0.0621584989,
0.0899148732,
0.0055533685,
-0.0148723628,
-0.0116684372,
-0.0067684585,
-0.0721674338,
-0.0270379689,
-0.0572331324,
0.0065084114,
-0.0137470858,
0.0463533141,
-0.0391973071,
-0.0400441661,
0.0950965062,
-0.0087056421,
-0.0337667391,
-0.0559248477,
0.0317147598,
-0.0372350477,
0.0584668517,
0.0158709735,
-0.00181366,
-0.0188872442,
-0.034329474,
-0.0353071764,
0.0232589524,
0.0108074788,
-0.0227113385,
0.0708111003,
-0.0329493545,
-0.0165827889,
-0.0090081757,
-0.0040429244,
-0.0415924191,
0.0345672816,
-0.0337944552,
-0.0340995863,
-0.006455651,
0.053792581,
-0.0224692971,
0.0557550378,
0.0121330163,
-0.0274035092,
-0.0151505498,
-0.0029066741,
-0.0303014219,
0.0820227414,
0.0300844628,
-0.0265020076,
0.0163968857,
-0.0652705431,
0.0751483738,
0.0007914965,
0.0187272802,
-0.0020882718,
0.0319568478,
0.059895087,
0.0443831831,
-0.0199952498,
0.0064904913,
-0.0171279144,
0.0191366822,
-0.0754362345,
-0.0122413374,
0.0622492395,
0.0529136918,
-0.0071247034,
-0.0137903979,
-0.0610982664,
0.0187132489,
0.0045516351,
0.0254842136,
-0.0484324396,
-0.0141867502,
0.0070825862,
0.0154919801,
0.0055272188,
-0.0064261751,
-0.0278123859,
-0.0863466114,
0.0094464431,
-0.0020619498,
-0.0392789766,
-0.0446703061,
-0.0184419714,
-0.0273508765,
-0.024159478,
0.0517838001,
0.0369957015,
0.0123644238,
-0.0063024121,
0.0001519411,
0.0092674196,
0.0114734182,
0.023622388,
0.0051006535,
-0.0161198862,
0.0306193326,
0.0248656031,
-0.0050187581,
0.0273207929,
0.046689745,
-0.0315312333,
-0.0009754425,
-0.0010378869,
0.0095601575,
0.0105421925,
-0.0156112118,
-0.0408780985,
0.0167507902,
-0.0095410096,
0.0072703194,
0.024330372,
0.0463382676,
0.0145300245,
-0.0343095288,
-0.0442167968,
0.0302886274,
-0.0172822494,
0.0631083921,
0.0215590782,
-0.0661311522,
-0.0526496805,
-0.0227245968,
-0.0086986003,
-0.0547497533,
0.0070196684,
0.0454774015,
0.004610552,
-0.0229040217,
-0.0383141153,
-0.113277562,
-0.0041144053,
0.0169579368,
0.0392591655,
0.061765641,
0.0170891471,
-0.0049277013,
-0.0212289151,
-0.0041110339,
-0.0225510597,
-0.0028419651,
-0.0356281251,
0.004365799,
-0.0035887382,
-0.0465561189,
0.0011145568,
0.0341277011,
-0.0599428825,
-0.0219453536,
0.015367561,
0.0319410525,
0.028207507,
0.0342690423,
-0.0314056389,
-0.0355820246,
-0.0407815278,
-0.0137697002,
-0.0012507834,
-0.0138998283,
0.0021970531,
-0.0247445572,
-0.025101766,
0.0506680049,
0.0058823577,
0.0135747381,
-0.0340796709,
0.057257358,
-0.0397141092,
-0.0080441618,
0.0275689494,
0.018565787,
-0.0001227066,
-0.0264330842,
-0.0020778337,
-0.0355506539,
0.014439432,
-0.0285965279,
-0.0281663295,
-0.0227799006,
-0.0294276513,
0.0458063781,
-0.0496503487,
-0.0444709063,
-0.0230201818,
-0.0034493215,
0.0322715826,
0.034865357,
0.0432744883,
0.0083874874,
0.0635154396,
-0.0059533832,
-0.0002405227,
-0.0003477169,
-0.0078878179,
-0.0291760676,
0.0697774366,
0.0383415818,
0.1020344049,
-0.0055972985,
-0.0017653216,
0.0231889188,
-0.0104973987,
-0.0404941663,
0.0059312857,
0.000565127,
0.0462022237,
0.0197962318,
-0.0055211135,
0.0275364332,
-0.024750283,
-0.0313908495,
-0.0475534499,
0.0077645951,
0.0489012897,
-0.0373526923,
0.0337402485,
0.0325747058,
0.0370691605,
0.0284375474,
0.0670728013,
0.0038388004,
0.0176748056,
0.0405630432,
0.0013781707,
-0.0393617488,
-0.0185986739,
0.0039710635,
0.0470078364,
-0.0346800461,
0.0078972774,
-0.0795161277,
-0.088720873,
0.025366487,
0.033859387,
0.0401676521,
0.0055035264,
-0.0631579906,
0.0920998529,
0.0105716586,
0.0137867182,
-0.0871025026,
0.024211796,
-0.091006048,
0.0121619543,
0.0356733054,
-5.896184522e-33,
-0.0692156851,
-0.0337035805,
0.0153964041,
-0.0579426102,
0.0301034618,
0.0114141898,
-0.0408537909,
0.0130953453,
-0.0553395376,
-0.0016583712,
-0.037210498,
0.0038422714,
0.0225775633,
0.0168881323,
-0.0028189612,
-0.0013216315,
-0.0102684703,
0.0318415426,
-0.0082848528,
-0.0243669488,
-0.007740994,
0.0390500352,
0.0173068549,
-0.0040801745,
0.0797329992,
-0.0653197989,
-0.0054698074,
0.0255019404,
-0.0012588038,
0.0455198176,
-0.0646860823,
0.0528079197,
0.0390557796,
0.0076082218,
-0.0131121641,
-0.0165368319,
-0.1204428896,
-0.0219774935,
0.0655968934,
0.0521626249,
-0.0504935943,
-0.0233971644,
-0.0144030983,
-0.0082587823,
0.0479762107,
-0.0057375254,
0.0160653833,
-0.0625277683,
-0.0149258841,
0.0958420709,
-0.0705291852,
0.0219055992,
-0.0163553115,
-0.0358267426,
0.036320284,
0.0855386555,
-0.0128930034,
0.0349105671,
-0.0672127828,
-0.0049129925,
0.0247648768,
-0.0137347542,
0.0400131084,
0.0306780059,
0.0072233207,
-0.0120303724,
0.0172957107,
-0.0239586402,
0.0202408656,
0.0071327793,
0.0298259221,
0.0079321349,
0.0325118303,
0.058741916,
0.0888354629,
0.0177964512,
-0.0318231173,
0.0007567852,
-0.0102584893,
-0.0084975762,
0.0160575081,
-0.0341994166,
-0.0588246733,
-0.006980502,
-0.0466901474,
-0.0591989681,
-0.039480269,
-0.0498528592,
0.0497896634,
-0.0024315941,
-0.0561848022,
0.022178553,
0.0766082779,
-0.0693829134,
-0.0075779147,
0.0034725484,
-0.0097201271,
0.0369134806,
-0.0326088667,
0.0876553878,
-0.0324355327,
0.0127365412,
-0.0243904646,
-0.0081231473,
-0.0288976673,
-0.0023967458,
0.0088922819,
-0.0217847098,
-0.0216402095,
0.0063629756,
-0.0256181061,
0.0126196211,
-0.0215104148,
0.0349480174,
0.0302743968,
0.0240706205,
-0.0111367153,
0.0537051335,
0.0230425745,
0.008600329,
-0.0554043725,
0.0098533109,
-0.0492678992,
-0.0015302226,
-0.0258715563,
0.0047074435,
-0.0250858385,
0.0361224674,
-0.0042153192,
-0.0262008179,
0.0315421186,
0.0561619513,
2.499e-7,
0.0695313439,
-0.0105565405,
0.0789555162,
0.0228361227,
-0.0074238838,
-0.0056728832,
-0.0503630191,
-0.0144855808,
0.0456913486,
-0.0105185257,
0.0276202932,
0.0552339181,
0.0598808043,
0.012295736,
-0.0470243581,
-0.0093824742,
-0.0090292133,
0.0364381075,
-0.0401757583,
-0.01325347,
0.0202367045,
0.0573150255,
-0.0617986023,
-0.0073236269,
-0.0113407979,
-0.045242846,
0.0461395346,
0.0008983311,
-0.0231602807,
0.0523909256,
0.0535420999,
0.0119278878,
0.0166645125,
0.0009808833,
-0.0010824573,
-0.0134581616,
0.0775449648,
0.0389194116,
0.041868113,
-0.0310664363,
-0.0181864984,
-0.0004858392,
-0.0162826926,
-0.0684469491,
0.0666931793,
-0.0108885393,
-0.0309588015,
0.0076971599,
-0.0254734419,
0.0283773411,
0.0255858377,
-0.0134093547,
-0.0581502058,
0.0306430254,
0.0193999428,
-0.0376424491,
-0.0104319407,
0.0133696375,
-0.0479643792,
-0.0384837985,
-0.0157849528,
-0.0097082192,
-0.0277808178,
-0.0338215418,
0.0228459314,
-0.0795140117,
-0.0208418742,
1.691426513e-34,
0.048065152,
-0.021057345,
0.0172009021,
0.0170797184,
0.0182460882,
-0.0546321385,
-0.0375429429,
0.0152686946,
-0.017096471,
-0.0572999306,
-0.0104048345
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.09618v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09618v2 | HIVE: Harnessing Human Feedback for Instructional Visual Editing | 2023-03-16T19:47:41 | 2024-03-26T22:59:52 | Shu Zhang, Xinyi Yang, Yihao Feng, Can Qin, Chia-Chih Chen, Ning Yu, Zeyuan Chen, Huan Wang, Silvio Savarese, Stefano Ermon, Caiming Xiong, Ran Xu | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.LG | Incorporating human feedback has been shown to be crucial to align text
generated by large language models to human preferences. We hypothesize that
state-of-the-art instructional image editing models, where outputs are
generated based on an input image and an editing instruction, could similarly
benefit from human feedback, as their outputs may not adhere to the correct
instructions and preferences of users. In this paper, we present a novel
framework to harness human feedback for instructional visual editing (HIVE).
Specifically, we collect human feedback on the edited images and learn a reward
function to capture the underlying user preferences. We then introduce scalable
diffusion model fine-tuning methods that can incorporate human preferences
based on the estimated reward. Besides, to mitigate the bias brought by the
limitation of data, we contribute a new 1M training dataset, a 3.6K reward
dataset for rewards learning, and a 1K evaluation dataset to boost the
performance of instructional image editing. We conduct extensive empirical
experiments quantitatively and qualitatively, showing that HIVE is favored over
previous state-of-the-art instructional image editing approaches by a large
margin. | [
0.0556318909,
0.0276145581,
0.00141474,
0.008416824,
-0.0057729715,
0.0058630784,
0.0124950791,
0.0159723125,
0.0014786989,
-0.0648754686,
-0.0661325157,
-0.0136191407,
0.0094667254,
0.0034613395,
0.0203849208,
-0.1203335971,
-0.0154344039,
-0.0219638254,
-0.0401678346,
0.0100471824,
0.0211983044,
-0.0254908912,
-0.0017207509,
0.032823272,
-0.0228975974,
-0.0285091586,
-0.0268748645,
0.0534380339,
0.0245089661,
0.0078990953,
0.001205947,
0.0760285258,
0.0317747667,
-0.0001586663,
0.0000019824,
-0.011778634,
0.0013708922,
-0.011836648,
0.0211797822,
0.03497269,
0.0649921224,
0.0045346422,
-0.0436769538,
-0.0457191356,
-0.0062235831,
0.0448608734,
0.0804717913,
0.040672563,
0.1043420434,
0.0342732742,
-0.0060010236,
-0.0264378805,
-0.0388712958,
-0.0326564126,
0.0583932549,
0.0241648331,
0.020754965,
0.027636718,
0.0305566508,
-0.0078269821,
-0.0547241084,
0.0381590836,
0.0047093946,
-0.0563541725,
0.0762960613,
0.048243057,
-0.0115748877,
-0.0022919476,
-0.0201127473,
0.0714255199,
-0.0247630905,
0.0373996459,
-0.0086464919,
-0.0312390551,
0.0240582842,
0.0362690985,
-0.0658360422,
-0.0331618339,
-0.0083720488,
-0.0093451906,
-0.0613677949,
-0.0345054753,
-0.0151205668,
0.0084242094,
0.0433314964,
-0.0186385121,
0.0102011086,
-0.0265905894,
-0.0344643742,
0.0321605429,
-0.0442249328,
-0.061644379,
0.0377864353,
0.0129697705,
-0.0183912087,
-0.0178569574,
-0.03941245,
-0.0206422247,
-0.0148300808,
-0.0532697178,
0.0628481358,
0.0041994131,
-0.0052410313,
0.0681754425,
-0.0167870969,
0.0516428463,
-0.0178905521,
0.0359127074,
-0.0106784478,
0.0601347834,
-0.0447908193,
0.0080692451,
-0.0281002987,
0.0277152192,
-0.0236606821,
-0.0080993026,
-0.0608122349,
0.0085758874,
-0.0619707406,
0.0771709159,
0.0332767703,
0.049995508,
-0.0796810985,
0.0062609394,
-0.0447446071,
0.0189842843,
-0.0110845799,
0.024322398,
0.0331869386,
0.0330558792,
0.0050644698,
-0.0033260651,
0.0366720557,
-0.0062082484,
0.008252264,
0.0425993167,
-0.0368519388,
0.0435606651,
-0.0251090117,
-0.0137895839,
0.0175026767,
0.0009936985,
0.0111684939,
-0.0506358184,
-0.0004706107,
-0.0231973305,
-0.0086951042,
-0.0488407649,
-0.0095475717,
0.0236082505,
-0.0411343053,
0.0618651472,
0.0097713014,
-0.0012468301,
0.0723534003,
0.0223046523,
-0.0548262,
0.0354173519,
0.0454710573,
0.0873256475,
0.0670162514,
-0.0260251593,
0.0260566734,
0.0593582466,
0.007099214,
-0.0107002165,
-0.025341535,
0.0012763266,
-0.0129786329,
0.0405829959,
0.0246684998,
0.035424985,
-0.0544969253,
0.0137824733,
0.0817450359,
0.050398536,
-0.0049409945,
-0.0198008753,
0.0192685667,
0.0154426927,
0.0030577385,
0.0378125608,
-0.0383469984,
0.0782777518,
0.0479847789,
0.0287543405,
0.0286864173,
-0.029415369,
-0.0251342822,
-0.0707592443,
0.0062396503,
-0.0076598465,
0.0246934537,
-0.0065419041,
0.0362684093,
0.0186095964,
-0.0701471418,
-0.0319795534,
-0.0019343417,
-0.0523026846,
0.0312048346,
-0.0406748541,
0.0231663752,
0.1158743128,
0.0421462581,
-0.0069914162,
0.0203980692,
-0.0638265908,
0.0417593494,
0.009327149,
0.0299913045,
-0.0378539935,
-0.0251189545,
-0.0389913134,
-0.0488858111,
-0.0335709937,
0.0135765746,
0.006574316,
0.0064466968,
-0.0352358446,
-0.0055801864,
0.0297726449,
-0.0854332298,
0.0279571377,
0.0161398333,
-0.0468701944,
-0.001865943,
0.047789216,
-0.0001639659,
-0.0155397467,
-0.0329561308,
0.0103887022,
-0.0130206281,
0.0213137213,
-0.007696412,
-0.0024560681,
-0.0085895108,
-0.0074972045,
0.0118648773,
-0.0451703407,
-0.0290939864,
0.0019738837,
-0.0330767035,
0.0037284018,
0.0111926189,
0.0065073268,
0.0027499569,
-0.0294589773,
0.0138141969,
0.0039627948,
-0.0356370807,
-0.0434410349,
0.0251192693,
0.0044124564,
-0.0021300556,
0.0041760025,
0.0082843993,
-0.0226458162,
-0.0426098406,
-0.018045282,
-0.0405517109,
0.0260465574,
0.0169384908,
-0.0081178593,
0.0315174796,
-0.0682805702,
-0.0235910993,
-0.05151999,
-0.0232999083,
-0.0098240245,
-0.0008174191,
0.0104748327,
0.0175006557,
-0.0134282419,
-0.0565342903,
-0.0097068259,
-0.0050051408,
-0.0379329063,
0.0225226022,
0.0309224352,
0.016013328,
0.0523192696,
-0.0727348551,
-0.0163382813,
0.0115038613,
0.002233214,
0.069877997,
0.0279500857,
-0.0292090774,
0.0420895293,
0.0082648182,
0.0115042375,
0.007548864,
-0.0086434148,
-0.0010826712,
-0.013522014,
0.0539189689,
0.1383128464,
0.0039010018,
0.0414176621,
0.0123028923,
-0.0155623555,
-0.0705431104,
0.0138430921,
-0.0093956897,
-0.0143298302,
0.0264942702,
-0.0188896507,
0.0029491445,
0.0303166639,
0.0008075628,
0.0128930155,
-0.0612548739,
0.0397230498,
0.006964731,
0.0095857512,
-0.0771702453,
-0.0090208342,
-0.0006360149,
-0.01198602,
-0.0538700745,
-0.0770518705,
0.0923601314,
0.0017358183,
0.0005201988,
0.0152397417,
0.0085234018,
-0.0001026573,
-0.004359703,
-0.0124851912,
0.0067887008,
-0.0402792245,
0.0212563258,
-0.0760679692,
0.0025666098,
0.0859071091,
-0.0190231763,
0.0179623533,
-0.0548328348,
-0.0223681014,
-0.0532339923,
-0.0208013076,
-0.0208975226,
-0.024599012,
0.0180893522,
-0.0257026441,
0.0108187459,
-0.0119568035,
-0.0089838048,
0.0102172717,
0.0265259035,
0.0318903401,
-0.0169920139,
-0.0357372686,
0.0089585632,
0.0169009659,
0.0677145422,
-0.0141986748,
-0.0864230245,
-0.0848189667,
0.0084686615,
0.0295384862,
0.051657211,
-0.0385523699,
-0.0159225855,
0.0209608506,
-0.0072890869,
-0.0344930254,
0.021055758,
0.0163879655,
0.0654088333,
-0.0427237675,
0.0091054849,
0.0728990734,
0.0398273803,
-0.0664073229,
-0.0258770771,
-0.0092022531,
0.0372482911,
0.0322808921,
0.0529312231,
-0.065820545,
-0.0222996771,
-0.020358,
0.0194515809,
0.0248024333,
-0.0102221314,
0.0091435276,
-0.0629217029,
0.0846797228,
0.0281805936,
0.0286010951,
-0.0186236203,
-0.0191748403,
0.0259438325,
-0.0221736822,
-0.0516657755,
-0.0024697646,
-0.0121185388,
0.0074356678,
-0.0011746744,
0.0683467835,
-0.0369881466,
-0.0146795288,
-0.0432417169,
-0.0288342759,
0.0931970552,
-0.007968951,
0.0069719763,
-0.0832661763,
0.0074909297,
0.089922443,
-0.0029863589,
-0.0159493256,
0.0777785257,
-0.0182835646,
0.0017459387,
-0.0187795162,
0.0472666584,
0.0573756769,
0.0011033651,
0.046467714,
0.0654418916,
-0.0177790206,
0.0231119711,
-0.0337259099,
-0.0423778929,
0.0334650204,
0.0110239694,
0.0330329873,
-0.0658778772,
-0.0271692406,
-0.066891931,
-0.0075649172,
-0.0620100163,
-0.0337946787,
-0.0265533291,
-0.0335037373,
-0.0040505826,
-0.0858759433,
-0.0141266529,
0.0720381886,
0.0124006569,
0.0177146327,
-0.0142001109,
0.0025375199,
-0.0182930697,
-0.0585748479,
0.0334793031,
0.0107442439,
0.0254630242,
-0.0784544945,
-0.0303841736,
-0.0009171619,
-0.0282876398,
-0.0294741299,
-0.0105702849,
-0.0480525009,
-0.0463146754,
-0.0512941033,
0.0923711285,
0.0066652498,
0.0522159599,
0.033183638,
-0.0654824078,
0.0203350261,
0.0257754885,
0.035128843,
-0.0201179069,
-0.0023703282,
-0.0151194837,
-0.0211872235,
0.0023713969,
-0.0564178787,
-0.0145978164,
0.0248075016,
0.0032988903,
0.0087250378,
0.0098110344,
-0.0138337743,
-0.0192015413,
0.0220227242,
-0.0285571907,
-0.0121621462,
-0.0329081863,
0.0180641282,
-0.0098343296,
-0.0259802081,
-0.0571330413,
0.0019133008,
0.0124013824,
-0.0119074807,
-0.014981241,
0.0059475997,
0.0171725024,
0.0150880162,
-0.0741182268,
0.0088974535,
-0.0158810392,
0.0168951061,
0.037133947,
0.0408448502,
0.0231277235,
0.010493529,
0.0312636085,
0.0542482026,
0.0235259272,
0.0817344338,
0.0119882906,
0.0271514431,
0.0092423018,
0.0387345441,
-0.0281519443,
-0.0156627595,
-0.0582827702,
0.0162656065,
0.0550229512,
-0.0199067835,
0.0016572641,
0.0132677499,
-0.031690862,
-0.0060107345,
0.0487348139,
0.00190859,
-0.0186683927,
0.0263816584,
0.0007581431,
0.0356172584,
0.0195586793,
0.0616195612,
-0.0443684906,
0.0176515412,
-0.0446500853,
-0.0434161834,
-0.0496220253,
0.0209973194,
0.0155783789,
-0.0028078838,
-0.0121704955,
0.0339305922,
-0.0207816456,
-0.0396440551,
-0.0552608296,
0.0586427264,
-0.0210430995,
0.0179761201,
0.0758886486,
0.0164991859,
-0.0457645655,
0.0053932844,
-0.0205501188,
0.0144084888,
-0.0509258769,
-0.010239833,
-0.0366037749,
-5.306891572e-33,
-0.0355119556,
-0.0257584788,
0.0076481863,
0.064135775,
0.0020352802,
-0.0400477014,
-0.02643512,
0.0092290621,
0.0303122364,
0.0089531308,
-0.0067189396,
-0.0401745774,
0.000902176,
0.0159902088,
0.0341120623,
0.0376951471,
0.070099473,
-0.013707743,
-0.0497950725,
0.0136786159,
-0.0146766827,
0.0168190934,
0.0460306816,
-0.0356710516,
0.006018314,
0.0197485331,
-0.0139825819,
-0.0046957941,
-0.0132202199,
0.0593151487,
-0.0010558319,
-0.0022615783,
-0.0302501824,
-0.0238217618,
-0.0133059267,
-0.0004532802,
-0.0498903915,
-0.0108935116,
-0.0232731216,
0.017355362,
-0.0674226508,
-0.046268858,
0.0567511432,
-0.0052505829,
-0.0386516154,
-0.0181196574,
0.0734993666,
0.0015258534,
0.025793165,
0.0319112316,
-0.0283766016,
-0.0005448207,
-0.0256966017,
-0.0512419529,
0.0312293377,
0.0101940017,
0.034048669,
0.003602996,
-0.0894368738,
0.0450864136,
0.064421162,
0.0359654203,
0.0929359794,
0.0098260809,
0.0315008052,
0.017902704,
0.017386701,
0.0237294119,
0.0118295411,
-0.0236641392,
0.0117403725,
0.045567885,
0.0295020901,
0.0117850658,
0.0213913843,
0.0024234282,
0.0059625688,
0.0635797903,
-0.0886232778,
0.0441155359,
-0.00885092,
0.0264237579,
0.0017168147,
0.0237550847,
-0.0233710203,
-0.0105153397,
-0.0261847228,
-0.050997939,
0.0235302281,
0.0057430784,
0.0060052034,
0.0153952911,
0.0300625861,
0.0059758858,
-0.0250109117,
-0.0285860188,
-0.0410052352,
0.0647196993,
-0.0078927223,
-0.0738010705,
-0.0340221673,
0.0131397182,
0.0282360353,
0.0073695127,
-0.0117529444,
0.0307516232,
0.028789632,
0.0188716147,
-0.0235831514,
0.009531931,
-0.0251585972,
-0.0016406463,
-0.0084135029,
-0.0112751052,
0.0006488471,
-0.0095887715,
-0.0649218708,
0.0257307272,
-0.0111920144,
-0.0054190611,
-0.0344065651,
-0.0235459469,
-0.0013982272,
0.0025428084,
-0.0285693742,
0.0028054228,
-0.0223559868,
0.0238160249,
0.0175099391,
-0.0349489823,
-0.0202859901,
-0.0005624096,
2.474e-7,
-0.000206827,
0.0545813031,
0.0091952533,
-0.0136630982,
-0.0003960402,
0.0660397559,
-0.0551065356,
-0.0226868,
0.0529317446,
0.0057033901,
0.0167188123,
0.0232785512,
0.0350611545,
-0.0208351184,
-0.0522415601,
-0.0392313339,
-0.0136979008,
0.0251555704,
-0.0121723581,
-0.0371527076,
0.0354379937,
0.0095337043,
0.0270089097,
-0.005055517,
0.0424840786,
0.0103561869,
0.0957675129,
-0.0318995491,
0.0007434226,
-0.0169662107,
-0.0229424909,
0.0043807211,
-0.0166132115,
0.016958097,
-0.0473547131,
-0.0111445189,
0.0145281227,
0.0492791757,
-0.0453909971,
0.0324669145,
-0.0059697349,
0.0421222746,
0.0086563472,
-0.0538846739,
0.0204606,
-0.0698819011,
0.0084736738,
0.0002341752,
-0.0178652909,
0.0120319445,
0.038984891,
-0.0435437746,
-0.0369570516,
-0.0115475329,
0.0237896666,
0.0272930544,
-0.0532593951,
-0.0277354885,
-0.0261368956,
-0.0084944954,
-0.0057583596,
-0.0090702688,
-0.0654650852,
0.0154504878,
-0.0389940888,
0.0100153871,
-0.0338903479,
1.894033181e-34,
0.0403727628,
0.003040445,
0.0442068428,
0.0143658053,
0.0454715379,
0.0307813715,
-0.0242613312,
-0.0206019767,
0.0443165787,
-0.0379586741,
-0.0447311923
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.09601v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09601v1 | Psychotherapy AI Companion with Reinforcement Learning Recommendations and Interpretable Policy Dynamics | 2023-03-16T19:01:29 | 2023-03-16T19:01:29 | Baihan Lin, Guillermo Cecchi, Djallel Bouneffouf | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, q-bio.NC | We introduce a Reinforcement Learning Psychotherapy AI Companion that
generates topic recommendations for therapists based on patient responses. The
system uses Deep Reinforcement Learning (DRL) to generate multi-objective
policies for four different psychiatric conditions: anxiety, depression,
schizophrenia, and suicidal cases. We present our experimental results on the
accuracy of recommended topics using three different scales of working alliance
ratings: task, bond, and goal. We show that the system is able to capture the
real data (historical topics discussed by the therapists) relatively well, and
that the best performing models vary by disorder and rating scale. To gain
interpretable insights into the learned policies, we visualize policy
trajectories in a 2D principal component analysis space and transition
matrices. These visualizations reveal distinct patterns in the policies trained
with different reward signals and trained on different clinical diagnoses. Our
system's success in generating DIsorder-Specific Multi-Objective Policies
(DISMOP) and interpretable policy dynamics demonstrates the potential of DRL in
providing personalized and efficient therapeutic recommendations. | [
0.0491125733,
0.032009732,
-0.0172398388,
-0.0461403504,
-0.0004306468,
0.0093045542,
0.0125022912,
-0.0145964567,
0.0205224901,
0.0570190996,
-0.0311250165,
-0.02163128,
-0.0031456905,
0.0718907788,
-0.0518056862,
-0.1027576476,
0.0194693524,
0.0112982541,
0.0451350734,
0.0137494784,
0.0031475108,
-0.00391417,
-0.0578342862,
0.0635772943,
-0.0096830018,
-0.0080503272,
0.0093410313,
-0.0211739913,
0.0300022494,
-0.0859107375,
-0.0171863027,
-0.0259524882,
0.0313417092,
-0.0368958935,
0.0000021714,
-0.014693033,
-0.0352014266,
-0.0321358033,
0.0569508299,
-0.0901682228,
0.0470055565,
-0.0367350578,
0.0302499179,
0.0232842937,
-0.0149125643,
0.0213181842,
0.049419608,
0.1015998274,
0.0586389974,
0.0544085652,
-0.0255282596,
0.0024613682,
0.0259102471,
-0.0531468056,
-0.001515455,
-0.0174941048,
0.0257729255,
-0.0164984409,
0.0343670957,
-0.0141198002,
-0.0339492559,
-0.0408977345,
-0.0032799158,
0.0068789204,
0.0189981312,
0.0237488449,
0.0485180542,
-0.0524644889,
-0.0236032233,
0.0871881023,
0.0101728784,
0.0692014694,
0.0490797348,
-0.0410414897,
-0.002812132,
-0.0296972934,
-0.0026788106,
-0.0118536456,
-0.010351209,
0.0289979912,
0.0702195242,
0.0249826834,
0.00511934,
-0.0634848922,
0.0014569612,
0.054591544,
-0.0164074954,
-0.0066139479,
0.0287453718,
0.0104881199,
0.0253008232,
-0.0423572548,
0.0274375416,
0.0327741988,
-0.1028101444,
0.0014652736,
-0.0112509634,
0.0199951679,
-0.0113378624,
0.032363601,
0.0569948256,
0.0292178877,
-0.0366011038,
0.006516465,
0.0560946874,
0.030639641,
-0.0394782349,
0.0025847869,
-0.0358348824,
0.0220588353,
-0.0877801627,
0.038918145,
-0.00293641,
0.0519144982,
0.0301128589,
-0.0445296243,
-0.0786474645,
0.0216579381,
-0.0778217763,
0.0190812349,
0.013329125,
0.0385137945,
0.0080055827,
0.0238027405,
-0.0690402761,
0.0313201733,
-0.082666032,
0.0014582119,
0.0163186211,
0.0439449325,
0.0246190652,
-0.0133408988,
-0.0082802139,
-0.0266077276,
0.0276772361,
0.062712267,
0.0150800096,
-0.0034575262,
-0.0097052557,
-0.0448444001,
-0.0269116703,
0.0089920256,
0.031394247,
-0.0317766666,
0.0210277587,
-0.0341833942,
0.0184940528,
-0.0476099923,
0.0107249878,
-0.0295959488,
-0.0445862375,
0.0662886873,
0.0089596193,
-0.0096971309,
0.0034528887,
0.0256303772,
-0.0016145245,
0.0201453473,
-0.005724933,
0.0375185572,
-0.0046783364,
-0.0176927783,
0.0391036868,
-0.0434173942,
0.0120724179,
-0.008647169,
0.007427,
-0.0407990851,
-0.0309903864,
0.0769923627,
-0.022457324,
-0.0075982739,
-0.0251004659,
0.0257698875,
-0.0110478243,
0.0569053255,
0.0659044683,
0.055928342,
0.009958514,
-0.0118642077,
-0.0514890254,
-0.0122814905,
-0.0290300772,
0.0809916183,
0.0407166891,
-0.0312849656,
0.0034759189,
-0.0433375016,
-0.0305430442,
-0.0621255077,
0.0372361988,
-0.0296463836,
-0.0433334559,
-0.002150604,
0.0108488491,
-0.026846217,
-0.0044739558,
-0.0156476349,
0.0401442349,
0.0658472925,
-0.0393167473,
-0.0460201651,
0.0290951412,
0.1195316985,
0.0291238334,
-0.0584827438,
-0.0151777882,
-0.0300704818,
0.0168251637,
-0.0372977331,
0.0222573318,
0.0036881946,
0.0237458292,
-0.0034788228,
-0.0514998585,
-0.0197974127,
0.0044806846,
0.0454892106,
-0.0158733949,
0.014860387,
-0.0622751415,
0.0195595287,
0.0161297247,
0.0424638987,
-0.0390621796,
0.0006737097,
0.0498384722,
-0.0192088652,
0.0596797504,
-0.0037419836,
0.0185897555,
0.0019491039,
0.0192982517,
-0.0297206417,
-0.0277249571,
-0.0089121098,
-0.0717181563,
0.0653328821,
-0.0223060809,
-0.0469201319,
0.0398845263,
0.0157080423,
0.0074247536,
-0.0419625156,
0.0165208876,
-0.0162575692,
-0.0265520569,
0.0328514241,
-0.0373339579,
0.0166609026,
0.0295844562,
-0.0178130884,
-0.0024080866,
-0.021361772,
-0.0106946398,
0.0099960212,
-0.0394684635,
-0.019721657,
-0.0089690695,
0.0084704757,
-0.0095421374,
-0.0385995694,
-0.025715407,
0.0068723527,
0.0115855262,
-0.0018135372,
-0.0238805991,
-0.047932405,
0.0395112373,
-0.0095599098,
-0.0492974408,
-0.0025859205,
-0.0138012031,
0.0001978339,
-0.0264272541,
-0.0346982256,
0.028743064,
0.0266523845,
0.0086740386,
0.016603075,
0.0607352629,
-0.0168562159,
-0.0638865009,
-0.0068966509,
-0.0233980622,
-0.0101333857,
-0.002541583,
0.0635629296,
-0.011565526,
-0.0258512311,
-0.0110077132,
0.01627676,
-0.028969964,
-0.0042027808,
0.0310685374,
-0.0564195253,
0.0197223835,
0.0236463938,
-0.0259620883,
0.0996182114,
0.0666140467,
0.0183860417,
-0.0594220348,
0.0195612777,
-0.0634662658,
-0.0259097535,
-0.0429956615,
-0.0348974653,
-0.0081775989,
0.0684243143,
0.0252158884,
0.0525313132,
-0.0769580379,
-0.0544356443,
0.0170003548,
0.0121212397,
-0.0158449076,
0.0276053175,
-0.0087868953,
0.0020125869,
0.0104369596,
-0.0418393761,
0.0942643955,
0.0684656277,
0.0159366317,
-0.0579628423,
-0.03942848,
-0.0198936984,
0.0099048251,
0.001812622,
-0.0013652242,
-0.0302171819,
-0.0194506831,
0.007597697,
-0.0438051932,
-0.0046482813,
-0.0049208393,
-0.0065826885,
-0.0528689809,
-0.010417561,
0.0297352001,
0.021470096,
-0.0552746691,
0.0028939908,
-0.0192654375,
-0.0099928752,
-0.0074678762,
-0.0074771312,
-0.0072649261,
-0.0762715712,
0.0520169735,
0.018993251,
-0.0010987403,
-0.0474718809,
-0.0136893317,
-0.0109193418,
0.081942983,
-0.0408104546,
-0.0125851631,
-0.0383338891,
0.0345991254,
-0.0020214927,
-0.0001530321,
0.0205040853,
-0.0526065715,
0.0374247506,
-0.0322583281,
0.0021842357,
0.0027079531,
0.056741558,
0.0053669671,
-0.0109005282,
-0.0215711407,
0.06261722,
0.0267396513,
-0.0723140612,
0.0291838832,
-0.0116470717,
-0.0114667481,
0.005310867,
0.0253109969,
-0.0146495607,
-0.0030362001,
-0.0430769771,
0.0650453642,
-0.0081739919,
-0.0316015296,
0.0142714586,
0.0060047456,
0.0107714003,
-0.0557831116,
0.0177721288,
-0.0009221091,
-0.0432000719,
-0.0037685626,
-0.044814758,
-0.070742324,
-0.0482323058,
0.0044816467,
-0.0024547405,
0.0213121269,
-0.0140266484,
-0.0148537094,
0.0401394926,
0.0036341967,
0.0718471557,
0.0770143569,
0.0122860689,
-0.0387736,
-0.0176610406,
-0.0697568059,
0.0833602473,
0.0078551816,
-0.00456294,
0.0348631032,
0.0174172632,
0.0195460338,
-0.0339414477,
0.0896640942,
-0.0334313512,
-0.009299513,
0.0033894109,
0.084330909,
-0.0635643229,
-0.0321467705,
-0.0365290418,
0.0269426946,
0.0556511432,
0.012841858,
-0.0219706241,
-0.0722361654,
-0.0301105939,
0.0133893713,
0.0260949247,
-0.0348474234,
0.0023469646,
-0.0308757946,
-0.0231419094,
0.0215454064,
-0.0559957698,
-0.0313923806,
0.01030479,
-0.0104243504,
-0.0136876721,
-0.0623560026,
-0.0213797726,
0.0067672906,
-0.0114139132,
0.0211569276,
0.0556393899,
0.0122613842,
-0.0387727357,
-0.0021043748,
0.0227099806,
-0.0143743642,
-0.0247403104,
-0.0192098133,
-0.0040976661,
0.0263767838,
0.0326350592,
0.0508137383,
0.0088034449,
0.0182146691,
0.0228203647,
-0.0340093337,
0.0219130591,
0.0325020626,
-0.0089849429,
-0.029782841,
0.0246398598,
0.0288628656,
-0.0091009447,
0.0208841935,
-0.0309420172,
0.0664165989,
-0.0084784012,
-0.0093747834,
-0.0130012436,
-0.0006017941,
0.0007870874,
-0.0410802439,
0.0264420155,
0.0048588449,
-0.0294928532,
-0.0111665167,
-0.0354865119,
0.0204336159,
0.039095249,
-0.0389474295,
0.0031291423,
0.0514492579,
-0.0383987017,
0.009481404,
-0.0213448852,
-0.021941958,
-0.0345156789,
-0.0419099368,
-0.0038924136,
0.0225212947,
0.0264735408,
-0.0132025881,
0.0342392512,
0.0288219266,
0.038952563,
0.001036605,
0.0176670812,
-0.0112426002,
0.0615584105,
0.0458407663,
0.022837365,
0.0290467087,
0.030860018,
-0.0340668857,
-0.1193256527,
0.0399300158,
0.0099374829,
0.0245878212,
0.0583945662,
0.0051142671,
-0.0506674163,
0.0496246144,
-0.0002660607,
0.0384988971,
-0.0644987524,
0.0047597429,
0.0162777323,
0.0125200041,
0.0280527119,
-0.0261827856,
0.0626309663,
-0.0096055837,
0.0154254138,
-0.0212484598,
0.0128862653,
-0.0528727621,
0.0313331708,
-0.0029870777,
0.0803285465,
-0.0408651046,
-0.0079589775,
0.0134467101,
0.0020074344,
0.0038749124,
-0.0310133938,
-0.0322421044,
-0.0399627239,
0.0530834161,
0.0060094306,
-0.0298047457,
0.0166926589,
-0.0401178412,
-0.0024279922,
-0.0199421179,
-0.0310411397,
-0.0713933408,
-5.449793114e-33,
0.0403123647,
-0.000426459,
0.0347335599,
-0.0017714767,
-0.0143438606,
-0.0162181631,
-0.0338373445,
0.0174373407,
0.0211150311,
0.0295708682,
0.029721003,
0.0554257557,
0.0043830508,
0.0103078317,
0.0392785147,
-0.010301304,
0.027711032,
-0.0092975553,
-0.0013280078,
0.0384888574,
0.0188681427,
0.0465572998,
0.0085880924,
-0.1060164869,
0.017939385,
0.0654505938,
-0.0257637091,
-0.0164049286,
-0.002491978,
0.0412225202,
-0.0310143176,
0.0195864867,
0.0223038662,
-0.0431979038,
0.0018847561,
0.0038221804,
-0.0559557341,
-0.0898242891,
-0.03498419,
-0.071448788,
-0.0990202799,
0.0063184118,
0.015320722,
0.0125030559,
-0.0005416602,
-0.0296971202,
0.0544843413,
-0.0190692674,
0.0035448074,
0.0199776646,
0.0177201778,
-0.0088249315,
-0.0227433834,
-0.0210644696,
-0.0162226949,
0.0299066361,
-0.0428987518,
0.0571847931,
-0.0041950773,
0.017091291,
0.0095163397,
-0.0057590418,
-0.0079037677,
-0.0245219283,
-0.0281272437,
0.0199906994,
0.0075410153,
0.006164473,
-0.0056642634,
-0.0196851175,
0.0054530627,
0.0766939521,
0.0212314967,
0.0049461755,
-0.0316385441,
0.0098651443,
-0.0407065786,
0.0229352172,
-0.0043861577,
0.0301040374,
0.0092341667,
0.0064370609,
-0.0392450653,
-0.0007485005,
-0.0294540357,
0.0045235124,
-0.0282681212,
-0.0500601232,
0.047192134,
0.0294717457,
-0.0026391237,
0.0283102449,
-0.0110592525,
-0.0470901243,
0.0174125731,
0.0078829424,
-0.0082829082,
0.0424987525,
0.0327577293,
-0.0259251986,
-0.0681063309,
-0.0295943692,
0.0058263629,
-0.0452911034,
0.0621059202,
0.0253243167,
0.0049712318,
-0.0289407,
-0.023030499,
-0.0251648091,
0.0184907764,
0.0346904434,
0.0060636159,
0.0177855212,
-0.0301050972,
0.0198374707,
-0.0312733017,
0.0715528652,
0.0195288975,
0.0405090675,
-0.0710371509,
-0.0566574559,
-0.0145375794,
0.0326686837,
-0.034984868,
-0.0364669338,
-0.0725108311,
-0.0306935031,
0.0236242879,
-0.0430029929,
-0.0162600912,
-0.0291681364,
2.895e-7,
-0.0309119709,
0.0673740953,
0.0230709948,
0.0058810031,
0.0408479981,
0.0417836346,
0.0093662087,
0.0536103658,
-0.010526048,
-0.0347620808,
0.0504297651,
0.0068855914,
0.0025431975,
0.0325562395,
0.0266915318,
0.0096645579,
-0.036456883,
0.0105790952,
-0.0659471899,
-0.016461283,
0.0308695119,
0.0329899602,
0.0531916991,
-0.0168291721,
0.0662657842,
0.069132857,
0.064238444,
-0.0368657522,
0.0222006869,
0.0069041513,
0.0118406862,
0.0058701113,
0.0133431777,
-0.0116851553,
-0.0195613075,
-0.0074657942,
-0.0627756938,
0.0563416705,
-0.0399105586,
-0.0447539985,
0.0033747989,
0.0569119453,
0.0093482621,
-0.0148640294,
0.0328142568,
-0.0630770102,
-0.0315612033,
-0.015219532,
-0.0188784245,
-0.0194752626,
0.0386788882,
-0.0128962966,
0.002487621,
0.0013351802,
-0.0009224843,
0.028064115,
0.0256606694,
-0.0255571939,
0.0413541086,
0.0503859073,
-0.0265996344,
0.0392708033,
-0.0496977568,
-0.0118396683,
-0.0024285708,
-0.0660995468,
-0.0074944892,
2.341933722e-34,
-0.006088912,
0.0226465836,
0.0159007553,
-0.0424329787,
-0.0098181525,
0.0301602613,
-0.0631930456,
0.0581004955,
0.0559293926,
-0.0280684922,
-0.0447982997
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.09522v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09522v3 | P+: Extended Textual Conditioning in Text-to-Image Generation | 2023-03-16T17:38:15 | 2023-07-15T15:48:48 | Andrey Voynov, Qinghao Chu, Daniel Cohen-Or, Kfir Aberman | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.GR, cs.LG | We introduce an Extended Textual Conditioning space in text-to-image models,
referred to as $P+$. This space consists of multiple textual conditions,
derived from per-layer prompts, each corresponding to a layer of the denoising
U-net of the diffusion model.
We show that the extended space provides greater disentangling and control
over image synthesis. We further introduce Extended Textual Inversion (XTI),
where the images are inverted into $P+$, and represented by per-layer tokens.
We show that XTI is more expressive and precise, and converges faster than
the original Textual Inversion (TI) space. The extended inversion method does
not involve any noticeable trade-off between reconstruction and editability and
induces more regular inversions.
We conduct a series of extensive experiments to analyze and understand the
properties of the new space, and to showcase the effectiveness of our method
for personalizing text-to-image models. Furthermore, we utilize the unique
properties of this space to achieve previously unattainable results in
object-style mixing using text-to-image models. Project page:
https://prompt-plus.github.io | [
0.0203046221,
0.0462388061,
0.032638628,
0.011390442,
-0.0251137316,
-0.0204648785,
0.0125556579,
0.0353308879,
-0.0093022427,
0.0097665284,
-0.0030714376,
-0.0220369846,
0.0088395737,
0.0579341128,
0.0231957939,
-0.1177941933,
-0.040121194,
-0.0328188837,
-0.0532037243,
-0.0385746248,
0.0232323334,
0.0084095225,
-0.010671963,
-0.0229782593,
-0.0011530875,
-0.02828818,
-0.0182747561,
0.0552113764,
0.0326639228,
-0.000124519,
-0.057977058,
0.0476846397,
0.0439507701,
-0.0204710774,
0.0000024667,
-0.0095572323,
-0.0098597128,
0.0395903476,
0.0232911706,
0.0044976305,
0.0685187206,
-0.0025031893,
-0.0204792041,
-0.062781401,
-0.013194412,
0.0487615503,
0.0861141533,
0.0676699877,
0.1046568155,
0.0638306364,
-0.0290184431,
-0.0448706746,
0.0102869514,
-0.0153476782,
0.052581124,
0.0212918799,
0.0115442816,
-0.0334838554,
0.0273306984,
0.031661123,
0.004882222,
0.0351765603,
0.0592885278,
-0.0044422033,
0.0351299569,
0.0555277504,
0.0698678344,
-0.0411635302,
-0.0452034622,
0.0447605066,
-0.0385430753,
0.0024466042,
-0.007424444,
-0.0084932772,
-0.0204550698,
0.0312834382,
-0.0200172793,
-0.0232493244,
0.0162464492,
0.0226870459,
-0.0723951012,
0.0488093272,
0.0014572256,
-0.0172810685,
-0.0186397303,
-0.0206707995,
0.0467156433,
-0.0146701057,
-0.0377272554,
0.0301704779,
-0.0290641077,
-0.0559953973,
0.087615177,
0.0152968848,
0.0202727728,
-0.0339286141,
-0.0787815154,
-0.0666110516,
-0.0247735828,
0.0139225321,
0.0569431782,
0.006807074,
-0.0138777858,
0.0348897688,
-0.0465763249,
0.016470151,
-0.0479538776,
0.0066553345,
-0.0590415746,
0.0000429455,
0.0151936356,
-0.0122779049,
-0.037197452,
-0.0041357311,
-0.0884562433,
-0.0369176641,
-0.0085335886,
-0.0014766534,
0.0107825398,
-0.0069382512,
0.0033785962,
0.0284491125,
-0.0764497519,
-0.0351083167,
-0.0151853655,
-0.0648721233,
0.0177380182,
0.0193185192,
0.0202703532,
0.0191782694,
-0.0319749638,
0.0179380607,
0.0546517111,
-0.0096983099,
-0.0117600933,
0.0661324263,
-0.0748753697,
0.0441071503,
0.0077994848,
0.0071503147,
-0.027538294,
-0.0164234582,
0.0457333438,
-0.0570708215,
0.0293242969,
-0.0321435593,
-0.0076238853,
-0.0724271461,
0.0115363821,
0.0182849262,
0.011648736,
0.0414392017,
-0.0103836302,
-0.0199769344,
0.0461535938,
0.0036621534,
-0.0183948167,
0.0286104456,
0.017970534,
0.077371709,
-0.0198633187,
-0.0028615398,
0.0036610835,
0.0356456302,
0.055733785,
0.0409907177,
-0.07109721,
-0.0257303119,
-0.0233879257,
0.0040903571,
0.0494870618,
0.0873509496,
-0.0466091819,
-0.0254551731,
0.0799450576,
0.0102236187,
0.0040509505,
0.01756805,
0.0589714423,
0.0411497429,
-0.0148666697,
0.0472419821,
0.0162926838,
0.0421505123,
-0.0031780798,
0.0381443314,
0.0092986431,
0.0392740816,
-0.0510282516,
-0.0489680804,
0.0434377119,
-0.0023712979,
0.0356980935,
-0.0377813838,
0.0406909958,
0.092089422,
-0.0768034086,
-0.0241757613,
-0.0110515179,
-0.075092189,
-0.0241820067,
-0.0503827557,
0.0349450968,
0.076218687,
0.0071280035,
0.0013062381,
0.0710828975,
0.0354883112,
0.0032658514,
0.0880466551,
-0.0317083187,
0.0434420705,
0.0404766835,
-0.0272380244,
0.0074898466,
0.0142091764,
-0.0040960601,
0.0249030273,
-0.0180520732,
0.0072286567,
-0.0154666929,
0.0083694458,
0.0027228929,
0.0504048616,
-0.008442685,
-0.0092085069,
-0.00221057,
0.0176873766,
-0.0114269154,
0.003852203,
-0.0340827703,
0.0084019629,
0.0288125444,
-0.0370431729,
-0.0534263104,
-0.0101877917,
-0.0445535742,
-0.0631427392,
-0.0189651884,
-0.0559906885,
-0.0209738351,
0.0029347776,
0.0062825917,
-0.0390649401,
0.0058408524,
-0.0182054676,
0.0618641488,
-0.0441475883,
-0.0186014865,
0.0178086907,
-0.0014857358,
-0.0192194674,
0.0469054393,
-0.0480537266,
-0.0246535297,
0.030333193,
0.0540391468,
-0.0602172576,
-0.0125788897,
-0.0239288565,
-0.0595442913,
-0.0030999493,
-0.0036021827,
-0.0038698292,
0.0374982916,
-0.0351971649,
-0.0449997894,
-0.0245265178,
-0.0002000616,
-0.005780811,
-0.026592534,
0.0235967562,
0.0287427548,
0.0035649945,
0.0141515257,
-0.049069941,
-0.0121012777,
-0.0092119211,
-0.0026243427,
0.0383551456,
-0.0147074759,
0.006397495,
-0.0451263785,
-0.0138835302,
0.0442616791,
0.044218339,
-0.0023747201,
-0.0499109067,
-0.0331251733,
0.0522282943,
0.0180504639,
0.0179163162,
-0.0082414579,
-0.0362210572,
0.002233413,
-0.0280585308,
0.0817486197,
0.0797914714,
-0.0099782497,
0.0039312746,
-0.027677374,
-0.0160076283,
-0.0119359465,
0.0078643681,
-0.0426833071,
0.0216857996,
0.0467832685,
-0.0352157019,
0.0099150212,
0.0459338725,
0.0183257051,
0.0272419322,
-0.0697316676,
0.0449052267,
-0.0020896266,
-0.0656989813,
0.010554757,
-0.0187520999,
-0.0131752631,
0.0086023975,
-0.0670828968,
-0.0389030278,
0.0416254103,
-0.0552334227,
-0.0182704125,
0.0045405412,
0.0025791684,
0.0370372273,
0.030589303,
0.0235724449,
0.0551176667,
0.0319087207,
0.056378264,
-0.0609096698,
-0.0031337508,
-0.0001660853,
-0.0119964611,
-0.0151307229,
-0.0207481552,
-0.0000892856,
-0.0035196391,
-0.0085967649,
-0.0019797643,
-0.0635797009,
0.0530416816,
-0.0084884064,
-0.0188926663,
-0.0176045019,
-0.0197913311,
0.0327137858,
-0.0145003805,
0.0236299075,
-0.0244782437,
-0.031279847,
-0.0331146792,
0.0649773628,
0.0411715433,
-0.027983984,
-0.0498358831,
-0.0465414524,
0.0338553339,
0.055447679,
-0.0031765176,
-0.0248770341,
-0.0264018159,
0.0020527516,
0.000349871,
0.0737648308,
-0.0022520281,
0.0214393064,
0.073514618,
-0.0473132953,
-0.0218908917,
0.0235506743,
0.0128932865,
-0.018958725,
-0.0107031455,
0.0218846183,
0.0966947302,
0.0026172914,
-0.0086929221,
-0.0696832091,
-0.0277977809,
0.0037451836,
-0.01371371,
-0.0074564158,
0.0105386376,
-0.0265669171,
-0.0466760844,
0.0513245165,
0.0122966822,
-0.0054730154,
-0.0249976851,
-0.0079389755,
0.0182097126,
0.0288712159,
-0.0311085638,
-0.000768591,
0.0292716362,
0.0242261291,
0.0234998595,
0.0750948265,
-0.0359923095,
-0.0470104143,
-0.0058662207,
-0.0055352673,
0.0771701708,
0.006638255,
-0.0081402808,
-0.0693942308,
-0.0127448076,
0.029721437,
0.016679503,
-0.0032871645,
0.0492811128,
0.0401877202,
0.0125790797,
-0.0462121852,
0.0647770017,
0.0139023084,
-0.0188331977,
-0.0095619699,
0.0200735833,
0.0107813692,
-0.0073843324,
-0.071176149,
0.012076823,
0.0432705693,
0.0177310165,
0.0064707664,
-0.0963788778,
-0.0382061303,
-0.0571548492,
0.0476934649,
-0.0649563,
-0.0493056588,
-0.0127697457,
-0.0263660476,
-0.0617095567,
-0.0695697293,
0.0255284812,
-0.0210376605,
0.0781171247,
-0.0093027176,
-0.0237697046,
-0.0332346894,
-0.0138306199,
-0.0273920596,
-0.0042789932,
-0.0075781564,
0.0202359445,
-0.0026074497,
-0.0159872957,
0.0061314432,
-0.0466160476,
-0.0372157246,
0.035696134,
-0.0769201815,
-0.0495635048,
0.0172972605,
0.0391404517,
0.0181274097,
0.0299205035,
-0.0044726999,
-0.0345086455,
0.0607187338,
0.0570097193,
-0.0016434733,
0.0112418719,
0.0187112428,
-0.0055100094,
0.0191048458,
-0.0036331881,
-0.0587051958,
0.0508277379,
0.0327479355,
0.0021096161,
-0.0123672737,
-0.0127104567,
0.0482825488,
-0.0322138034,
0.0091839572,
-0.019401608,
0.0265290197,
-0.0318162777,
0.0077767815,
-0.0302339178,
-0.0283229928,
-0.0749971494,
-0.0106734717,
0.015978476,
0.0027434858,
-0.0023083077,
-0.0095120426,
0.0350773968,
0.0455465056,
-0.0509397686,
-0.0129808662,
0.0581872985,
0.0138806142,
0.0331019461,
0.0241332371,
0.0021817849,
0.048424609,
-0.0427803509,
0.0070211203,
0.0109770214,
0.0360965431,
0.0173313059,
-0.0435581282,
-0.033774171,
0.0413142219,
-0.0607594885,
0.0013011661,
-0.0474591032,
0.0169079881,
0.0248640999,
0.0281545296,
0.0579923727,
-0.0118557494,
0.0042319293,
-0.0085940892,
0.0162082165,
0.0415712707,
-0.0431461483,
0.0209311862,
-0.039048709,
0.0294842422,
-0.0311003812,
0.0523002595,
-0.0241431631,
0.0075509669,
-0.0211153999,
0.0130082509,
-0.0066778008,
-0.0230935607,
0.0112619605,
0.0113771893,
0.0405953825,
0.0118547045,
-0.0264407061,
-0.0380055681,
-0.0013370316,
0.0374562591,
0.0026572789,
-0.0012482373,
0.046822615,
0.0215601865,
-0.023952473,
-0.0084765982,
0.0232832637,
0.0394768976,
0.0165409576,
-0.0514367484,
-0.014564693,
-6.690665522e-33,
-0.0574528836,
-0.0187450517,
-0.0243487507,
-0.040862903,
-0.004832577,
-0.0339087024,
-0.0206455607,
-0.0050934833,
0.0305845626,
0.0189284943,
-0.0214611273,
0.002429652,
0.0088835414,
0.0538215339,
-0.0717935935,
0.0734052733,
0.0507639199,
0.0022934258,
-0.0204114504,
0.0284919012,
0.0185742695,
0.0013635048,
0.0224156901,
-0.0501469672,
-0.0038991424,
-0.0452305488,
-0.0419965237,
-0.0383369364,
0.0219545141,
0.026829442,
-0.0170586593,
-0.0202833135,
-0.0163554829,
-0.01529059,
-0.031444829,
0.0515571274,
-0.0240943395,
-0.0339408517,
0.010796397,
-0.019380739,
-0.0901395082,
-0.0434346087,
0.0523262732,
-0.0240577124,
-0.0203450676,
-0.0266920775,
0.0367576778,
-0.0175503287,
0.015972212,
-0.0022365488,
-0.0631904304,
0.0127165271,
-0.0432117209,
-0.0504303426,
0.0180920176,
0.021297913,
0.0152358646,
0.0081107374,
-0.0822024196,
0.0288153198,
0.0257919822,
0.0035487495,
0.0285823289,
0.0377555974,
0.0096309194,
0.0249269847,
0.0187517069,
0.0003320674,
-0.0259321909,
0.0092927711,
-0.0021235056,
0.0547418408,
0.0599378794,
0.0426817462,
0.0325765051,
-0.0100415256,
-0.0404075757,
0.0541366525,
-0.0749753714,
-0.0275636613,
0.0487289838,
0.0612020232,
0.0234811064,
0.0004933374,
-0.0627747551,
-0.0591228269,
-0.0131227942,
-0.0262728166,
0.0109094484,
0.0177366976,
-0.0220118687,
-0.0496455133,
0.0305333138,
0.0159719512,
-0.0058016246,
-0.0261373445,
-0.0581692643,
0.0544913076,
-0.0236778576,
-0.0023074206,
-0.0043825787,
-0.0159072559,
0.0918018073,
0.0549954586,
-0.0147304842,
0.0363952667,
0.0212464556,
0.0258454103,
-0.033835534,
-0.0073961732,
-0.0238653477,
0.0417152569,
0.0382359289,
0.0397476628,
0.0114519717,
-0.0240571406,
-0.0393981375,
0.0152978357,
-0.0042948369,
0.0216888972,
-0.0194764491,
-0.0030740821,
-0.0093864277,
-0.0109334877,
-0.0280997083,
0.0242219623,
-0.0255848262,
0.0128130652,
0.0500174351,
-0.0338948146,
-0.0277603455,
0.0417277664,
2.947e-7,
0.0175731331,
0.0073381611,
0.0119167846,
0.0186472032,
0.0129953101,
0.0332358107,
-0.0307693481,
0.0089412127,
-0.0085081086,
-0.0353426151,
0.01434978,
0.0302361827,
0.0314997733,
-0.0145272845,
-0.0375665836,
0.0005817807,
-0.0584454909,
0.0222075917,
0.002671598,
0.0061076609,
0.0635252222,
0.037617214,
-0.0053066714,
-0.0318027288,
0.0302103441,
0.0249469187,
0.0817941055,
-0.0435482785,
0.0361189805,
-0.0152350934,
0.0072803721,
-0.053238187,
0.0090657566,
-0.0139087187,
-0.0095200129,
-0.0005375638,
0.0726600438,
0.0514778942,
-0.0689143538,
-0.0056432518,
0.0199171752,
0.0121943904,
-0.0184062496,
-0.0592942536,
0.0610133074,
-0.0024205309,
-0.0199199244,
-0.0494795628,
-0.04035585,
0.036208827,
0.0157640371,
-0.0346071087,
-0.0571459532,
0.0055007441,
0.0409017131,
0.038290374,
-0.0289614126,
-0.0188624449,
-0.0644540489,
-0.0267134886,
-0.012214249,
-0.027467778,
-0.0901427642,
0.0245981589,
-0.0049342723,
-0.0276727676,
-0.0458993129,
2.898487823e-34,
-0.0024581046,
0.0199105889,
0.0072488836,
-0.0084793651,
0.0125477975,
0.0271974672,
0.0286382288,
0.021574825,
0.012159273,
-0.0621413663,
-0.0410721153
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.12734v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.12734v1 | MultiModal Bias: Introducing a Framework for Stereotypical Bias Assessment beyond Gender and Race in Vision Language Models | 2023-03-16T17:36:37 | 2023-03-16T17:36:37 | Sepehr Janghorbani, Gerard de Melo | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent breakthroughs in self supervised training have led to a new class of
pretrained vision language models. While there have been investigations of bias
in multimodal models, they have mostly focused on gender and racial bias,
giving much less attention to other relevant groups, such as minorities with
regard to religion, nationality, sexual orientation, or disabilities. This is
mainly due to lack of suitable benchmarks for such groups. We seek to address
this gap by providing a visual and textual bias benchmark called MMBias,
consisting of around 3,800 images and phrases covering 14 population subgroups.
We utilize this dataset to assess bias in several prominent self supervised
multimodal models, including CLIP, ALBEF, and ViLT. Our results show that these
models demonstrate meaningful bias favoring certain groups. Finally, we
introduce a debiasing method designed specifically for such large pre-trained
models that can be applied as a post-processing step to mitigate bias, while
preserving the remaining accuracy of the model. | [
0.014822077,
0.0848503858,
-0.0236971527,
0.0267269164,
0.0045521073,
0.0308302753,
0.0495561585,
-0.0222235378,
0.0025281385,
-0.1102729291,
-0.048828654,
-0.033231359,
0.0316039249,
0.0159709901,
0.0204372685,
-0.080727078,
0.0365586206,
0.026391007,
0.0339296833,
-0.034355823,
0.0388936475,
0.0481484458,
-0.0106902048,
0.0398261435,
-0.0584560335,
-0.0191145521,
0.0654095337,
0.0111910235,
0.0038390851,
-0.012188687,
0.0220512766,
0.0666427389,
-0.0019090218,
-0.0199639201,
0.0000020651,
-0.0607746877,
0.0432564653,
-0.0111860642,
0.0277501326,
-0.0023281544,
0.073802799,
-0.02853439,
0.0050221351,
0.0039088666,
-0.0240616817,
-0.020218702,
0.068476513,
0.016221324,
0.0420324616,
-0.0021947317,
-0.0144711658,
-0.0206518322,
-0.0807909295,
-0.0147550972,
0.0075665275,
0.0098407473,
0.034648627,
-0.0087760566,
-0.0864811763,
-0.0576830246,
-0.0477233045,
0.0085748453,
0.0050216615,
0.046742674,
0.0163578372,
0.0155295106,
-0.0552031882,
-0.0641954541,
-0.0127853081,
0.0881553292,
-0.0258443691,
0.0009611374,
-0.0110629685,
-0.0076099494,
0.0127197979,
0.0379603952,
0.0009270073,
0.0451574363,
0.0051022195,
-0.0008000973,
-0.0772039667,
0.0339233503,
0.0181247741,
0.0205178242,
-0.0075649624,
0.0142607922,
0.0387527421,
0.0330962017,
0.0039939699,
0.0163663439,
0.0219304245,
-0.0226006005,
-0.0089305881,
-0.0374527611,
0.0291489232,
-0.0154064791,
-0.0605851486,
0.0053133336,
-0.0050129462,
-0.0469145216,
0.0274932142,
0.0381741188,
-0.0652432889,
0.0136254095,
-0.0023197152,
0.0078010764,
0.0104000224,
0.0301152114,
-0.0014490128,
-0.0029081816,
0.0074845687,
0.0081768604,
-0.0066800541,
-0.0477709472,
-0.0055866865,
0.0285021737,
-0.0640084296,
-0.0351908952,
-0.0646668449,
-0.032945767,
-0.0033738362,
0.0405543409,
-0.0417691171,
-0.0270127542,
-0.0387581438,
0.0190357249,
-0.0042048213,
0.0079589207,
-0.0643752366,
-0.131493926,
0.0337335728,
0.0303855296,
-0.0154546453,
-0.0447099954,
0.0003072664,
0.0645046011,
-0.0010847501,
-0.038382858,
-0.0308339074,
-0.0181520898,
-0.0683166832,
-0.038616281,
0.0183403697,
-0.0485267416,
0.0257561747,
-0.0025631131,
0.0398770832,
-0.0454972163,
-0.0177253578,
0.0014373169,
-0.0275271796,
0.084432669,
0.0336857513,
0.0007137122,
0.0508006476,
0.009351166,
0.0085617984,
0.0902443454,
-0.0020410882,
0.0179875847,
0.0452042483,
-0.01897588,
0.0146401459,
0.0529309511,
0.0248417184,
0.0050690384,
-0.0759692192,
0.0015005884,
-0.0062349853,
-0.0127959745,
0.0849229991,
0.0366049409,
0.0036420173,
-0.0543444902,
0.0710353106,
0.0528925397,
-0.0207034294,
-0.0055743232,
0.0298615377,
-0.0011781657,
-0.0008390003,
-0.0008904444,
-0.0732970312,
0.0175747238,
0.0024412358,
-0.0257604271,
0.005166213,
0.096236445,
-0.0327416547,
0.0003992304,
0.0058910898,
-0.0090226512,
0.0059394161,
0.0006638169,
0.0286617987,
0.0302398745,
0.0243183374,
0.0436822213,
0.0348999016,
-0.0187912788,
0.0102646453,
-0.0338659585,
-0.0184446517,
0.0057898932,
-0.0006640069,
0.0175484605,
0.0162637457,
-0.0102347936,
-0.0145043256,
0.0467197821,
0.0461732335,
0.0254051145,
0.0448876359,
-0.0542661063,
-0.0336127244,
0.0234360565,
0.0367763601,
0.0309703704,
0.0336362422,
0.0441059507,
0.0398642421,
-0.0432420559,
-0.0103700003,
0.0348099172,
0.0278810468,
-0.0184197389,
-0.0164508298,
0.0188250281,
0.0192537345,
0.0026137924,
-0.0611950047,
-0.0182419512,
-0.0391549133,
0.0086705862,
0.0400762223,
0.0486136451,
-0.0913805664,
-0.0269150566,
0.0152130956,
-0.104748562,
-0.0283645093,
0.0288714636,
-0.0063531427,
0.017417023,
0.048615817,
0.0001014055,
-0.0128025468,
-0.0360815749,
-0.0073616095,
-0.0084318388,
0.0345560983,
-0.0086098732,
0.0265110824,
-0.0184748378,
-0.0367234126,
0.0003766861,
-0.0646814108,
0.03180518,
-0.028633181,
-0.0440697297,
0.0091874842,
-0.018398378,
0.0034786188,
0.0104950052,
-0.0340946019,
-0.0267343782,
0.03586483,
-0.0764031038,
-0.0323296115,
-0.0374920219,
-0.0471059382,
-0.028611185,
-0.0129511654,
-0.0352797844,
-0.0858111233,
-0.0030204647,
-0.0214853045,
0.010943599,
0.0472832136,
-0.0173681471,
-0.0341350026,
0.0243724734,
-0.0255141128,
-0.0434433445,
-0.0120447436,
0.0869290009,
0.0158115178,
-0.0362903625,
0.0031489132,
-0.0453332365,
-0.0307785813,
0.0381612256,
-0.0046110139,
-0.0274778064,
0.042914398,
0.0253946614,
0.0454536937,
0.0436894707,
0.0566899255,
0.0024097257,
0.0648706555,
-0.0088505996,
-0.0145142861,
-0.0384257846,
-0.0079345359,
0.0094633335,
0.0188907795,
-0.0676488206,
-0.0259578209,
0.0503873751,
0.0493405908,
0.0019613807,
-0.0601235852,
0.048063539,
-0.0250349902,
-0.0858017802,
-0.0542476475,
-0.0114391949,
-0.0117528671,
0.023636302,
-0.0515815355,
-0.0890171975,
0.0304867309,
-0.0048046787,
0.0018608929,
0.0316616409,
0.0372082554,
-0.0093782963,
0.0652650669,
0.0344809629,
0.036184568,
0.0205620956,
0.0148404995,
-0.0581551865,
-0.0411660261,
0.0369744711,
-0.0184814688,
0.0238812696,
-0.0317803137,
0.0018913123,
-0.0059000752,
-0.0265312307,
-0.0483149923,
-0.024593953,
-0.0342109352,
-0.0447843187,
-0.0063358252,
0.0076726782,
-0.0145843327,
0.0099489251,
-0.0030392564,
0.022044722,
-0.0117701394,
0.002711681,
0.0321249403,
-0.0062680971,
0.0285384003,
-0.0105548138,
-0.0244832188,
-0.0384194031,
-0.0141390245,
0.0261230785,
0.0084577156,
0.0200132765,
-0.0614702217,
0.0254442003,
0.0258936286,
0.0160878301,
0.0112373643,
0.0140033709,
0.0568676144,
-0.0033687921,
0.0572323874,
0.0900810808,
0.0000968417,
-0.0734090656,
-0.0073957667,
0.0241098031,
-0.0018025581,
0.0354437642,
-0.023582723,
-0.1093082726,
-0.0351066664,
-0.0182556156,
-0.0136880279,
-0.0122832395,
-0.0271816645,
-0.0136777759,
-0.093141526,
0.0370347872,
0.0151469419,
-0.0204802714,
-0.0208570529,
0.028457921,
0.0168187134,
-0.0543668978,
0.0029635523,
-0.0176348519,
-0.018872451,
0.0199182071,
0.0065486832,
-0.0608514249,
-0.0633279458,
0.0131917354,
-0.048319336,
0.0190525651,
0.0217206739,
0.0002443097,
-0.0076371082,
-0.0129784904,
0.0406293049,
-0.0256948434,
0.0226714071,
-0.0344519764,
0.0881774873,
-0.0726673976,
-0.0521488041,
-0.0027477937,
0.0176932085,
0.035523098,
0.0059861732,
-0.0128507093,
-0.031648811,
-0.0075862524,
-0.0120856632,
-0.0729143992,
0.0044945008,
-0.0052883443,
0.0497057475,
0.0151302405,
-0.0299658123,
-0.0039561563,
-0.0360997431,
0.0092032338,
0.0017618284,
-0.0783937573,
0.0159736276,
0.0114100343,
-0.0173372738,
-0.0187607165,
-0.0255100094,
0.0085031893,
0.0311210118,
0.0002663116,
-0.0599707663,
0.0089199068,
0.0246379282,
-0.0807898119,
0.0882284343,
-0.0296109747,
0.0400292017,
-0.003784345,
-0.0170367733,
-0.0070431614,
-0.0416138433,
-0.0091045126,
0.024013577,
-0.0347431563,
-0.0275822263,
0.0478985272,
0.0669477731,
0.0156335328,
0.0344750434,
0.0264652204,
-0.0597285181,
0.0697303936,
0.0547744185,
0.0174620394,
0.0254827663,
0.0041986825,
-0.0257704612,
-0.0033691875,
0.0067139361,
0.0017313363,
0.066452913,
0.0059841638,
-0.0397684835,
-0.0229223929,
-0.0372278057,
-0.015029816,
-0.0088387774,
0.0552900359,
-0.0525402129,
0.0631961003,
-0.0463912226,
-0.0433558151,
0.0082336068,
-0.0227713119,
-0.0365584828,
-0.0078736925,
0.0321674757,
0.0367871448,
-0.0203043949,
-0.0195076335,
-0.0451974943,
-0.0120805269,
-0.0228078254,
0.0212098286,
0.0350165181,
0.0183844324,
-0.0171863046,
0.0265212916,
0.0118213063,
0.042418059,
-0.0329505615,
0.0211518854,
0.0211721603,
0.0519915074,
0.0269176252,
0.014085901,
-0.0178923197,
0.0188147686,
0.0160589088,
0.0205969941,
-0.017111307,
0.0229835697,
0.0393745527,
-0.0434386246,
0.0262269657,
0.0014904767,
-0.0029000458,
-0.0055819172,
0.0145432279,
0.0187137816,
0.0070975889,
0.0562699512,
-0.0135801546,
-0.013011965,
-0.0006325467,
0.0604553632,
0.0302986279,
0.0448196717,
-0.0057631908,
-0.0396100879,
-0.0279463232,
-0.0202327427,
0.0491942428,
-0.0145018082,
-0.0058005848,
0.0090883039,
-0.049631983,
-0.0640753061,
-0.0187696759,
0.0108016077,
0.0336108282,
0.0418679416,
0.0514040887,
0.0455070995,
-0.0121024204,
-0.03382672,
0.0164374728,
-0.0254711322,
-0.0391562916,
0.0093688117,
0.021746777,
-6.201008942e-33,
-0.0468146987,
-0.0226868298,
-0.013783223,
-0.0493590906,
-0.0072014979,
-0.0000192908,
0.0107411575,
0.019524809,
-0.0344508626,
0.035575103,
0.0376714319,
0.0136084156,
0.0318304598,
0.0089047449,
0.0029951583,
0.0297071598,
0.0576414093,
-0.0025840446,
-0.0172701515,
-0.0416639745,
-0.0356744491,
0.0219957102,
0.0430746228,
-0.0498504303,
0.0195122939,
0.0294254888,
-0.0397277065,
-0.0161230862,
0.0108267469,
0.0532600135,
-0.0448000617,
0.0641693994,
0.0299809296,
0.0270271804,
-0.0172204543,
0.0529407077,
-0.0448790863,
-0.0238404274,
0.0086252242,
0.0502980649,
-0.0378779471,
0.0223649032,
0.0101085547,
-0.0099241622,
-0.0604592338,
-0.0065480471,
0.0651701838,
-0.0323521495,
0.0163296275,
0.0425949506,
-0.0246477425,
0.0359196737,
-0.0120494161,
0.0102024041,
0.0232994743,
0.0143060163,
0.0143404761,
0.0241333079,
-0.0135121737,
0.0454527661,
-0.01312894,
-0.0197691768,
0.0744407773,
0.0711474866,
0.0260921996,
0.070226267,
0.0839849189,
-0.0057031703,
-0.0166532919,
-0.0693968311,
0.06461256,
-0.0203751475,
0.0116752395,
0.1033156589,
0.0484307297,
0.001630989,
0.0014981542,
0.001623067,
0.0000713452,
0.0200651176,
0.0439687036,
-0.018129291,
-0.0524305962,
-0.0195021275,
-0.0474578552,
-0.0632124245,
-0.0142400125,
-0.0135529647,
0.0459770449,
0.0115907099,
-0.0087068593,
0.0763583928,
0.054548379,
-0.0347214453,
-0.0079173194,
0.0015674807,
-0.0264457725,
-0.0127783744,
0.0086921081,
0.0159187708,
-0.055240918,
0.0331300832,
0.0459358171,
0.024372099,
0.0181732532,
0.001545261,
-0.0030866805,
0.000953615,
-0.0813630894,
0.000444462,
-0.002465117,
-0.0218172092,
0.0074199988,
0.0459262021,
0.0480688885,
0.0261426829,
-0.0539088324,
0.0138149587,
-0.0014313799,
-0.033764638,
-0.0307530519,
-0.0389382653,
-0.0090970611,
0.0520213395,
-0.0131218787,
-0.0009294021,
-0.0292140637,
-0.0439360924,
0.0283025745,
-0.0413514934,
-0.0040625455,
-0.0226465948,
2.497e-7,
0.0122439703,
0.028575711,
-0.0021224869,
0.0207587015,
0.0280306637,
0.0373678394,
0.0379922986,
0.0288977604,
0.0148759615,
-0.0340213664,
-0.0313576646,
0.0687333643,
0.0272550937,
0.0091315117,
0.0122291781,
0.0344256461,
-0.0389739424,
0.0278328341,
-0.0275328085,
-0.012302978,
-0.0055232849,
0.0490688048,
-0.004940575,
-0.0281031728,
-0.0047632912,
-0.0172709227,
0.0306047276,
-0.028089866,
-0.0031050669,
-0.0040243026,
0.0191520993,
0.0457471274,
-0.0082434062,
0.0370497815,
0.001005228,
-0.0047913515,
0.0232296698,
0.0000030454,
-0.0363281108,
0.0208193623,
-0.0108103026,
0.0648288503,
-0.0649879947,
-0.0389559343,
0.0570568927,
-0.0046280152,
-0.01525799,
-0.0735730007,
-0.0415740646,
-0.0039437222,
0.0722980052,
-0.0103843175,
-0.0389555097,
0.0053256718,
0.0507227592,
-0.0213224161,
-0.0517967045,
-0.0877795219,
-0.0207659267,
-0.0266143456,
-0.0235854927,
-0.0233483687,
-0.0138072949,
-0.0088713896,
0.0235425252,
-0.0011335867,
0.0002359877,
1.588685781e-34,
0.0338074416,
0.0081150159,
0.0191175025,
-0.0727475509,
0.002383722,
-0.0190918297,
-0.0243862569,
-0.0384311825,
0.0189820416,
-0.0052988529,
-0.0012816079
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.09438v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09438v1 | Trustera: A Live Conversation Redaction System | 2023-03-16T16:13:36 | 2023-03-16T16:13:36 | Evandro Gouvêa, Ali Dadgar, Shahab Jalalvand, Rathi Chengalvarayan, Badrinath Jayakumar, Ryan Price, Nicholas Ruiz, Jennifer McGovern, Srinivas Bangalore, Ben Stern | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Trustera, the first functional system that redacts personally identifiable
information (PII) in real-time spoken conversations to remove agents' need to
hear sensitive information while preserving the naturalness of live
customer-agent conversations. As opposed to post-call redaction, audio masking
starts as soon as the customer begins speaking to a PII entity. This
significantly reduces the risk of PII being intercepted or stored in insecure
data storage. Trustera's architecture consists of a pipeline of automatic
speech recognition, natural language understanding, and a live audio redactor
module. The system's goal is three-fold: redact entities that are PII, mask the
audio that goes to the agent, and at the same time capture the entity, so that
the captured PII can be used for a payment transaction or caller
identification. Trustera is currently being used by thousands of agents to
secure customers' sensitive information. | [
0.0385586955,
0.0369087644,
-0.0236597434,
0.0009999656,
-0.0249799881,
0.000812316,
0.0832283646,
0.0145012895,
0.0145800402,
-0.0281718839,
-0.0240502805,
0.01648462,
0.034709435,
0.0898125991,
0.0208139531,
-0.0415765271,
0.0126650967,
0.0041398765,
0.037740808,
0.0430083536,
0.0300212409,
-0.0027838056,
-0.0138698807,
0.0451079533,
-0.0076594348,
-0.0552241057,
0.0076462114,
-0.0066500506,
0.0058062091,
0.045387283,
0.0096943136,
0.0214408431,
-0.0051937304,
0.0708861426,
0.0000021011,
-0.0182390455,
-0.0445596389,
0.0321255885,
-0.0975409821,
0.035914816,
-0.0451752916,
0.0205321964,
-0.0459057502,
0.0471418463,
-0.0295346901,
0.0330859236,
0.0270804986,
0.0492563657,
0.0716889501,
0.0354781747,
-0.03518093,
0.0080027059,
0.0320598409,
0.0059443759,
-0.0123018501,
-0.0074266661,
0.0254966766,
-0.0669470578,
-0.0001340873,
-0.0174470264,
0.0484332852,
0.0560541563,
0.0001794883,
-0.0527925752,
-0.0011362407,
0.006421173,
-0.0528418459,
-0.0344210677,
-0.0485050082,
0.0141433934,
-0.0084653785,
-0.0043266495,
0.009203204,
0.0240874514,
-0.0224891938,
-0.0273022354,
-0.0072967382,
0.0029349693,
-0.0349968709,
-0.0279416293,
-0.0868180618,
0.0233423989,
0.0287609491,
-0.0095781637,
0.0036256325,
-0.004869754,
0.030979773,
-0.010890713,
-0.0193258021,
-0.0358522795,
0.041466374,
-0.0499552265,
0.0773864165,
-0.017782094,
0.0122612016,
-0.0250564255,
-0.0487821475,
-0.0451149084,
-0.0191226769,
-0.020203298,
-0.022018522,
-0.0132389953,
-0.0291040763,
0.006022654,
0.0220326148,
0.0144806094,
0.0211290326,
-0.0246087648,
0.0163968448,
-0.010144732,
0.0483774319,
-0.0096297245,
-0.044513993,
0.0784436017,
-0.0431686044,
0.009416163,
-0.0493570417,
0.0181191172,
-0.0571872629,
0.0547101907,
0.0159502346,
-0.0130466856,
-0.0123020792,
-0.0208388176,
0.024111446,
-0.0140424911,
0.0064613419,
0.0484961197,
0.0013477957,
-0.063649334,
0.0185783301,
-0.0085076885,
0.030594008,
0.0091757569,
-0.0339924507,
0.0613271147,
0.0016080658,
-0.0448726639,
-0.0387016647,
-0.0263792966,
0.0194778703,
0.0024894306,
-0.0251301695,
-0.0112761213,
0.0013090682,
-0.0372610651,
-0.0459009781,
-0.0266043637,
-0.007136859,
0.0007498199,
0.001334639,
0.0758921951,
-0.0102420831,
-0.0281788874,
0.0394935161,
0.0068981294,
-0.0132570118,
-0.0262452625,
0.0276574064,
-0.0179728046,
0.0624313354,
-0.0034825094,
0.0489207543,
0.0354088433,
-0.0151191009,
-0.0421609953,
0.0445644855,
0.0057191146,
0.0022660724,
-0.0452472605,
0.0153248087,
0.0256713033,
0.0177223962,
-0.0437992699,
0.1093839332,
0.0583234206,
-0.0127177881,
-0.0314063542,
-0.0324978232,
0.0658117756,
0.0042811371,
-0.0039824718,
-0.004098292,
0.0031037631,
-0.0192621816,
-0.0474143215,
-0.0245147608,
-0.0090445951,
-0.0488872714,
-0.0060901395,
0.0070583029,
-0.072145611,
0.0172223412,
0.032458473,
-0.0148259327,
0.0333712772,
-0.0317963138,
-0.0064160172,
-0.0343437754,
-0.0422831476,
-0.0193648897,
-0.0590545423,
0.032433778,
0.1020141616,
0.0250378177,
-0.0071150688,
0.0003319987,
-0.0629301071,
-0.0227236878,
0.0140300663,
-0.0570835359,
-0.0158284865,
0.0214112904,
-0.0555191413,
-0.0427556857,
0.0292863417,
0.0073160888,
0.0404923633,
-0.0248966068,
-0.0033071009,
0.0102154464,
0.052113153,
0.0649516657,
-0.0227777734,
0.0197734721,
-0.0507322885,
0.0165297706,
0.0130143771,
0.0134631712,
0.03440395,
-0.0041901083,
0.0072446503,
0.0310093202,
0.0327811874,
0.0195136648,
0.043554578,
0.0144849457,
0.0373522714,
-0.0053181751,
-0.079345122,
-0.0188340731,
0.0982639715,
-0.0159472022,
0.0031065289,
-0.0134152286,
-0.044258032,
-0.0010925704,
-0.0347571634,
0.0283165425,
0.0057180445,
0.0386614352,
-0.0009480103,
-0.056353692,
0.0108998958,
-0.0559911318,
-0.0651464984,
0.0154499551,
-0.0144135812,
-0.0415760577,
0.0130904419,
0.0003755647,
-0.0012534112,
0.0361624472,
0.0045487741,
-0.0051331343,
-0.0189148393,
0.0029464932,
-0.0267877076,
-0.0013877939,
-0.0036079208,
-0.0202148315,
0.0232576542,
0.0544031896,
0.003924157,
-0.0237432159,
-0.018247107,
-0.0390267372,
0.0132662151,
-0.0044386331,
0.0307057928,
-0.0170405917,
-0.0870429054,
-0.0029523829,
0.0092612999,
0.012852476,
0.0065339226,
-0.0165886451,
-0.0911704227,
-0.0259489212,
-0.0230862722,
0.018757632,
-0.0052698269,
-0.008139547,
-0.0099257622,
-0.0095250932,
0.051031854,
-0.026066076,
0.0499707013,
0.0185084902,
0.0403145961,
-0.0327449068,
-0.0042176307,
0.0207429007,
-0.032695055,
-0.0058581298,
0.0075706509,
-0.0202635061,
0.0111237811,
0.0157554839,
0.0238458905,
0.0345161483,
0.0128071178,
-0.0282038283,
-0.0008189458,
0.0020413392,
-0.0304541234,
0.0047471165,
-0.0545733646,
-0.0488404185,
0.013266528,
-0.0122203138,
-0.0241351146,
0.0323748961,
-0.0172742624,
0.0013458534,
-0.0103486199,
-0.0439923666,
-0.0090111578,
0.0293257497,
-0.0534775034,
0.0047751386,
0.0434757397,
-0.0822406486,
0.0092641003,
-0.0434755869,
0.0147437872,
-0.0582473613,
-0.0300633032,
-0.0647476017,
-0.0479773842,
0.0183156468,
-0.0355972238,
-0.0221209507,
-0.0218434948,
-0.0333479829,
0.0043492299,
0.0224527642,
-0.0316169113,
-0.0471450128,
-0.003884421,
0.0498125814,
0.0677272081,
0.0233524106,
0.0118744783,
-0.0060137603,
-0.0184630938,
-0.0434495173,
-0.0173504911,
-0.0143040111,
0.032508336,
0.03271088,
0.0684661046,
0.0411493853,
-0.0375703387,
-0.0130579984,
-0.0332104713,
-0.0001959858,
-0.0179440882,
-0.0177516751,
-0.0331020243,
0.0181496982,
-0.0257693548,
0.0196150467,
0.047776673,
-0.0003188356,
-0.0237662029,
-0.0049954499,
0.0050750608,
-0.0233524665,
-0.0070219478,
-0.0266475044,
-0.0734128207,
0.0180709772,
0.0223155934,
0.0561840422,
-0.0150083406,
0.0024372102,
-0.0317669511,
-0.0407953076,
0.0586046614,
0.0236072149,
0.0125960736,
-0.0343354531,
-0.0060981414,
0.020811975,
0.026709564,
0.0525938198,
-0.0423784889,
0.0138897272,
-0.0149197448,
0.0142801367,
-0.0577744953,
0.0072855325,
0.0014767781,
-0.0348776355,
0.0272980481,
0.0560205914,
0.0523678176,
-0.0015256983,
-0.0422696956,
-0.042969048,
0.010082107,
-0.049499616,
0.0222378056,
0.0807778165,
0.0265355092,
0.0209031831,
0.0123447282,
0.0877406001,
0.0526818857,
-0.0345298424,
0.0493257269,
0.0030796744,
-0.0222210977,
0.0161013808,
-0.0018115768,
0.0142671671,
0.0345684066,
0.0505295098,
0.0250129029,
-0.0262159631,
-0.0148475766,
-0.0164069254,
0.0199226718,
-0.0200348198,
0.0148412948,
0.0283638202,
-0.023651531,
-0.0951191857,
-0.036559701,
-0.0257284623,
-0.0006406119,
0.0409083776,
0.0519061424,
0.0056466474,
0.0827102289,
0.0093501722,
-0.0396077372,
-0.0667024776,
-0.0445061885,
0.0596738681,
-0.0179131646,
0.0404615961,
-0.016231196,
-0.0304545723,
0.002213541,
0.0479628257,
-0.0204927288,
-0.0219376143,
0.0425533205,
0.0347178653,
0.0393159017,
0.0293035805,
-0.0187150873,
-0.0703790411,
0.0282160584,
-0.03392547,
-0.0898366645,
0.0159081165,
0.0765969455,
-0.0074390694,
-0.0161083248,
-0.0024130407,
-0.0297478568,
0.0075917603,
-0.0032274786,
-0.0663663447,
-0.04711264,
-0.0180007592,
-0.011221977,
0.0343179293,
0.03354799,
0.013437937,
0.0567559451,
-0.0157957729,
0.0724402964,
-0.0493364148,
0.0441475399,
-0.0195705444,
0.0299453586,
-0.0130566871,
0.0201957896,
0.0388314463,
-0.0135608651,
-0.0399772748,
-0.0250097513,
0.0104523152,
-0.0019430766,
0.0224217828,
0.0073299296,
0.012677935,
-0.0036922842,
0.0139314486,
0.086199671,
0.0398717858,
0.038108144,
0.0196151324,
-0.0148846172,
-0.0093358988,
-0.000641548,
-0.0039175204,
0.0337100513,
-0.058233209,
-0.0277224407,
0.0350084938,
0.0825155154,
-0.0248522721,
0.0132579701,
0.003821834,
-0.0216313545,
0.0011631259,
-0.0116776349,
0.0491320044,
-0.0272330865,
-0.0164342485,
-0.0576788522,
-0.0094007198,
-0.0186387021,
0.0335716084,
0.0213055275,
-0.0460838117,
0.053364262,
-0.0720812231,
-0.0433159396,
-0.0763502046,
-0.0242076572,
-0.0152986925,
0.046326749,
-0.0114065707,
-0.0726152062,
-0.0340740532,
-0.0020157169,
0.0309942607,
-0.020507589,
0.021907771,
-0.0250336416,
0.0271766726,
0.0028563868,
-0.0195427444,
0.0007717166,
-0.0187748075,
0.0068330388,
-0.0285660047,
-0.0349132158,
0.0041500735,
-5.766451455e-33,
-0.0028364314,
-0.0163543615,
0.016585255,
0.0828539208,
0.0085013751,
0.0886977613,
-0.0040090224,
-0.0239247531,
0.0230971854,
-0.0024925349,
-0.0360294916,
0.0134154866,
0.0181981716,
0.0178188868,
-0.0587710291,
0.0181916133,
0.0742944703,
-0.0070934063,
0.0158783775,
0.0120448926,
0.0408628099,
0.0240990948,
0.026749311,
-0.1175500229,
0.0146618653,
0.0148052024,
-0.0937497318,
0.0107665891,
-0.0115366364,
0.0234375447,
0.0071939216,
-0.011396586,
-0.0439000763,
-0.0201398917,
0.0031642197,
0.1225894392,
-0.0669100583,
-0.0213215016,
0.012142471,
0.0699889138,
-0.0096395956,
-0.0405444168,
0.0152960373,
-0.0201974064,
-0.0510210581,
0.0260425042,
-0.000715401,
-0.0146659045,
-0.0088027446,
-0.0324389711,
-0.0345177837,
0.010069727,
-0.0362052396,
0.0049052406,
0.0388277732,
0.0514328368,
0.0211517364,
-0.0620312952,
-0.1024587452,
0.0316601135,
0.0380458497,
-0.0423791483,
0.0004692615,
0.0120946197,
-0.0243179742,
0.0385800041,
0.0392961986,
-0.0421074815,
0.0005432746,
0.018627312,
-0.0285701603,
0.0357537977,
0.0455959812,
0.0540407375,
-0.0409749188,
-0.0386808887,
-0.0323139168,
0.0610868372,
0.0139344633,
0.0053096134,
0.0272671878,
0.0349321626,
-0.0735257044,
0.0143320374,
-0.0443428047,
-0.0103931082,
-0.0013066846,
-0.0227558911,
-0.0055541862,
-0.012691278,
-0.0442424603,
0.079042159,
0.0106916213,
-0.0343523026,
0.0067862971,
-0.0056092958,
0.0236214288,
-0.0175739992,
-0.0165622588,
-0.0011602838,
0.0254930649,
0.0235052947,
0.0656658784,
0.0182855427,
0.0346064717,
-0.028572144,
0.0530935191,
0.0308085382,
-0.0690858588,
-0.0028804145,
0.0180006772,
0.0660434067,
0.0257009007,
0.0215540975,
-0.0129719758,
0.0153126474,
-0.0061112754,
-0.0017849575,
0.0104653724,
-0.0209409017,
-0.0166477729,
0.0547181815,
-0.0313799083,
0.0378428735,
-0.0118050836,
0.0127432225,
0.0073581696,
-0.0140169412,
0.0861469358,
-0.0144325998,
0.001964618,
-0.0521246456,
2.818e-7,
-0.0211323835,
-0.0073334067,
0.0349206589,
-0.0081299013,
0.013729631,
0.0671296567,
0.0608340502,
0.033636678,
-0.0004689302,
-0.0278124642,
0.0005410709,
-0.0410688035,
0.0714243427,
0.0474603958,
-0.0565896258,
-0.1009459049,
-0.0113515453,
-0.0204430539,
-0.0401938185,
0.0385687985,
0.0112413745,
0.0743941665,
0.0914175063,
-0.0688841343,
0.0113591626,
-0.0173319187,
-0.0133989956,
-0.0199698973,
-0.0062612304,
-0.0599895753,
0.0188902859,
-0.0023748437,
0.0124432985,
0.0576232821,
-0.0543674752,
-0.0287279524,
0.0048570693,
0.0946337134,
0.0101337545,
0.0095072687,
-0.0044950065,
-0.0386565961,
-0.0246935431,
-0.038879253,
0.0246177092,
0.0388834439,
-0.0455060415,
-0.0136915762,
-0.0284405965,
-0.0398456044,
0.0110422457,
-0.0214249808,
0.0218677912,
0.01038008,
0.002143865,
-0.0057209614,
-0.0116835926,
-0.0290991459,
0.0099066421,
-0.0436429419,
-0.0045680073,
-0.0082939342,
-0.0012320958,
-0.0146830669,
0.0012818361,
-0.0447596274,
0.0532725118,
2.507020883e-34,
-0.0248586144,
-0.030672444,
-0.033830896,
0.0601666421,
0.0617245436,
0.0027500554,
0.0709802285,
0.0448432453,
0.0315042362,
-0.0095410617,
-0.0154472506
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.09435v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09435v2 | Jump to Conclusions: Short-Cutting Transformers With Linear Transformations | 2023-03-16T16:10:16 | 2024-06-18T19:58:27 | Alexander Yom Din, Taelin Karidi, Leshem Choshen, Mor Geva | cs.CL | cs.CL | Transformer-based language models create hidden representations of their
inputs at every layer, but only use final-layer representations for prediction.
This obscures the internal decision-making process of the model and the utility
of its intermediate representations. One way to elucidate this is to cast the
hidden representations as final representations, bypassing the transformer
computation in-between. In this work, we suggest a simple method for such
casting, using linear transformations. This approximation far exceeds the
prevailing practice of inspecting hidden representations from all layers, in
the space of the final layer. Moreover, in the context of language modeling,
our method produces more accurate predictions from hidden layers, across
various model scales, architectures, and data distributions. This allows
"peeking" into intermediate representations, showing that GPT-2 and BERT often
predict the final output already in early layers. We then demonstrate the
practicality of our method to recent early exit strategies, showing that when
aiming, for example, at retention of 95% accuracy, our approach saves
additional 7.9% layers for GPT-2 and 5.4% layers for BERT. Last, we extend our
method to linearly approximate sub-modules, finding that attention is most
tolerant to this change. Our code and learned mappings are publicly available
at https://github.com/sashayd/mat. | [
0.0044638733,
0.0563006327,
-0.0103848903,
0.0614605695,
-0.0086235106,
0.012055926,
-0.0034525755,
-0.0008551915,
-0.0092300335,
-0.0255361255,
-0.0546964481,
-0.0110530406,
0.0216744468,
0.0193579011,
0.0431117341,
-0.0496915877,
0.0171329714,
-0.0474236868,
-0.0468839332,
-0.0106141577,
-0.000413587,
0.0024507986,
0.0318682268,
0.070711866,
-0.0004239868,
-0.0153952986,
-0.0052690068,
-0.0198080204,
0.0076604444,
0.0260204747,
0.0063808961,
0.0161236394,
0.0298407413,
0.0580568723,
0.0000020503,
0.0134448903,
-0.015743779,
-0.0030309572,
0.0033410145,
0.0199457556,
-0.0210772697,
-0.0483075455,
-0.0208047926,
0.0089156907,
-0.0424577333,
-0.0112740602,
0.0786936805,
0.0219033062,
0.0460920893,
0.061682526,
-0.012892494,
-0.0373408832,
0.0329282135,
-0.0223532338,
-0.0127904844,
-0.0270800963,
0.003421647,
-0.0655415878,
-0.0453488901,
-0.0065971012,
-0.0461846925,
0.0374733396,
0.0105776032,
0.0015963947,
-0.0209671166,
0.0694856569,
-0.01009632,
-0.0218719486,
-0.0183930155,
0.0487622283,
-0.054882966,
-0.0299967136,
0.0048490781,
-0.0053262999,
-0.0088252956,
-0.0095959408,
-0.0272156317,
0.0222239867,
0.0322861969,
0.0288253389,
-0.008775562,
-0.0078069251,
0.0320313647,
-0.0406727903,
-0.0408699363,
0.0664512813,
0.0381812975,
-0.0188577026,
-0.0276361722,
-0.0043388964,
0.0060441969,
-0.0222086255,
0.014465617,
0.0160482656,
0.0461737812,
0.0163435955,
-0.031833481,
-0.0206800681,
-0.0321873277,
-0.0524398796,
0.0788548887,
0.0673931539,
-0.0303343851,
0.0153972106,
-0.0586652532,
0.0556956418,
-0.0523646697,
0.0567969047,
-0.0271212272,
-0.0106746191,
-0.0200687051,
-0.0214269757,
-0.0623752847,
0.0267670099,
-0.024286693,
-0.0302154236,
-0.0283434633,
0.0287984889,
-0.0145504391,
-0.0279630478,
0.0310609769,
0.0141736735,
-0.0339433998,
-0.0067458511,
-0.000551027,
0.0551873259,
0.0095646456,
-0.012512072,
-0.0202175323,
-0.0490030013,
-0.0380310155,
0.021258248,
-0.002377758,
-0.0344910286,
-0.0049884934,
0.1119003221,
-0.0204007365,
-0.0431861058,
-0.0199764762,
0.0358155891,
-0.0381801464,
-0.0421693698,
0.0502897017,
-0.0519883372,
0.0136773,
0.0096784011,
0.0144420909,
-0.0219275001,
0.0040148501,
0.0151614975,
-0.0408237204,
0.0779609084,
0.0427430794,
-0.0069097383,
-0.000219375,
0.0067725787,
-0.0289619453,
0.0280016549,
0.0593390577,
0.0454846434,
0.0109760258,
-0.0348192751,
0.0197557323,
0.0660868511,
0.033092089,
-0.0117216399,
-0.0363268666,
-0.0073195156,
-0.0037692478,
-0.0240281019,
0.0207728241,
0.0565194935,
-0.026797127,
-0.0192334019,
0.0587318316,
0.0464756414,
0.0208551288,
0.0751098543,
0.0292908307,
-0.0174259357,
-0.0066145863,
0.0278065298,
-0.0516424067,
0.0647626817,
-0.0090250773,
-0.0095241219,
-0.0052089668,
0.0250513889,
-0.0227721073,
0.0122747365,
-0.0147028994,
-0.0237838905,
0.0349916071,
-0.0053579016,
0.0193139706,
0.0167772584,
-0.0700596571,
0.1589450985,
0.0061951284,
-0.0456998348,
-0.0076870914,
-0.0830817297,
-0.0072861202,
0.015071339,
0.0060169562,
-0.0087027848,
0.0078947758,
0.0179644953,
-0.0123770656,
0.0325763859,
0.0009061478,
0.0135109955,
0.0319049284,
-0.038649153,
-0.0054206247,
0.0170938782,
0.0210450254,
0.0005939716,
0.0080808615,
-0.0000022626,
0.0192635693,
-0.0716392919,
0.0057848361,
0.0229336135,
-0.0323818736,
-0.0165736526,
-0.0011540832,
0.0083127255,
0.0257009603,
-0.0365865752,
-0.0009232725,
0.0252411366,
0.03651217,
-0.030673502,
-0.0169530697,
0.016304411,
-0.0505847335,
-0.0314968117,
0.0245381035,
-0.0747969374,
0.0105424775,
0.0914975926,
-0.0318118855,
-0.0262627043,
0.0437401161,
-0.0812439248,
0.052904889,
-0.0357504375,
0.0131432693,
-0.0196327195,
0.0169999786,
-0.0099962968,
0.0233363826,
-0.0250302348,
0.003567945,
0.0169478171,
-0.0269119758,
0.010055813,
0.0023448735,
-0.0337327756,
0.0419686995,
-0.0010919305,
0.0017762571,
0.0061857989,
-0.0150189959,
-0.0088793347,
-0.061359778,
-0.0746758059,
-0.0197310504,
-0.0131234163,
0.0301189162,
0.0331875533,
0.0120371617,
0.0259094127,
-0.0069604409,
-0.0198224168,
0.0024250795,
-0.0309518334,
0.0116791883,
0.0272314996,
-0.0113783665,
-0.0054097651,
-0.0336607248,
-0.0401748233,
-0.0245410241,
0.0836474821,
-0.0594460927,
-0.0074390401,
-0.0517549329,
-0.0494065657,
0.0042102053,
0.0503984988,
-0.0266455486,
-0.0771127641,
0.0137115363,
-0.0342257135,
0.0208907947,
0.0381072015,
0.0266453736,
0.0596350804,
0.0623813681,
-0.0013069499,
-0.0287957639,
0.0231387578,
-0.040559914,
0.0014392553,
-0.0471156202,
-0.0246021207,
-0.0021399276,
0.1021563709,
0.0016725068,
0.0005985803,
-0.0825282037,
-0.0175126437,
0.0115732038,
0.0194268711,
0.0431833565,
-0.0166776609,
-0.0537384152,
0.0168216042,
-0.0166187435,
-0.0342379659,
0.0819052458,
-0.0444293395,
-0.0304772854,
-0.0213724915,
0.0148535939,
-0.0318428501,
0.0496838093,
0.0241271332,
0.0122628938,
-0.0411291383,
-0.0217823125,
-0.0716424286,
0.0151577657,
0.0075196922,
-0.030430425,
0.0691875219,
-0.0013360328,
0.0082498323,
-0.0182422698,
-0.0291920714,
-0.0323873796,
-0.0060252994,
-0.0213273726,
0.0310716424,
0.0249768328,
-0.0548006147,
-0.0723893121,
0.0086481683,
0.0009661997,
0.076004751,
-0.0038041801,
0.009529436,
-0.022005301,
0.019849373,
0.0293339919,
0.0047206669,
0.0420686118,
-0.0492637604,
0.0269008968,
0.064004302,
0.0383260176,
0.0351989195,
-0.0524029061,
-0.0049134139,
0.0540447384,
-0.0167400856,
-0.019412145,
-0.0033503615,
0.018579565,
-0.0437707566,
-0.0077095726,
0.1033839285,
0.0026573194,
-0.0596580096,
0.0169522054,
-0.0089368308,
0.0441820584,
0.0147132892,
0.0353576131,
-0.0828032345,
-0.0316058919,
0.005100918,
0.0451283716,
0.027626045,
-0.0233405847,
0.0128847491,
-0.0972434729,
0.0344492868,
0.0127503779,
-0.0121708717,
-0.0308159385,
-0.0199171063,
0.0231565982,
0.0131060723,
-0.0020219847,
-0.0016707636,
-0.0340100043,
-0.021637233,
0.0165846925,
-0.0317015089,
-0.0124231474,
0.0342706181,
0.0103599718,
0.014364182,
0.050092835,
0.0473711491,
-0.0003184185,
-0.0641599372,
0.0320904925,
-0.0062454771,
-0.0194207449,
0.0109314583,
0.050488513,
0.0114350375,
-0.0134177711,
0.022856513,
0.0153137399,
-0.0156774092,
-0.0144552821,
-0.0401489772,
0.090583235,
-0.0046790987,
-0.0877492577,
0.0012060859,
0.0054790438,
-0.0242573954,
0.0605379231,
0.048239395,
-0.039052356,
-0.0416518189,
-0.0108203851,
0.0374216698,
-0.0117948661,
-0.0664650053,
0.0159830265,
0.0113130556,
-0.0435071439,
-0.0318440422,
-0.0013565439,
0.0380342267,
0.0231915452,
0.0122688999,
-0.0554339848,
0.0252224095,
0.0001005142,
-0.0557320863,
0.0099584768,
-0.0124432901,
0.0211328063,
-0.0414742902,
-0.0090820966,
0.0397710428,
-0.0262912977,
-0.0454382375,
0.0031240294,
-0.1154977232,
-0.0690704733,
0.0084825167,
0.0405298434,
0.0209887214,
0.0285007358,
0.008993254,
-0.0272679068,
0.0643789768,
0.0155912284,
-0.0046191653,
0.0135042267,
0.0542446114,
-0.0429498069,
-0.0099188136,
0.0500979163,
-0.0345612094,
0.0044850507,
0.0334704183,
0.0336282365,
-0.0148180258,
-0.011319235,
0.016384935,
-0.0255529117,
0.0765996575,
-0.0003435531,
0.0223959312,
-0.0341770835,
0.0350913033,
0.0187725239,
0.0002647743,
-0.0763442293,
-0.017252259,
0.026741391,
0.0188145693,
0.0010546577,
0.0189744215,
0.004364369,
0.0125103677,
-0.0299789347,
0.0321019664,
0.0307727754,
0.0032903617,
0.0438643582,
0.02268859,
-0.0237009674,
-0.005981131,
0.0098402891,
0.0140208909,
-0.0151257971,
0.0069368002,
0.0274503864,
0.0076396428,
-0.0413778014,
0.0164647438,
-0.0703969523,
-0.0787280872,
-0.0416769721,
0.0313141458,
0.0008295182,
0.0030717847,
0.0481844731,
-0.0304271895,
-0.0107562924,
-0.007617956,
0.0251579322,
-0.0104451012,
-0.0343386717,
0.031642776,
0.0072164703,
-0.0006335907,
-0.028084984,
0.0837088674,
0.0158517621,
0.055551935,
-0.0318850465,
-0.0135009829,
-0.0296381358,
-0.0423282981,
-0.0056204819,
0.0182514489,
-0.0100740641,
-0.0061776158,
-0.0311069079,
-0.0838638395,
-0.0055396343,
-0.0104169818,
0.0004024786,
-0.0460529402,
0.0246598274,
0.035403695,
0.0350999124,
-0.0134523539,
-0.0121407993,
-0.0075767841,
0.0502933413,
-0.0371023379,
-0.0333673805,
-6.35808364e-33,
-0.0192207471,
0.0128886877,
-0.0146145141,
0.0353486314,
-0.0274934694,
0.0108993808,
-0.0538324527,
0.0030722134,
-0.018191969,
0.012862483,
-0.0077453167,
0.0106034745,
0.0053511225,
0.031267561,
0.0010679717,
-0.0079051666,
0.0550425462,
-0.0072694104,
-0.0295094885,
0.0215915851,
-0.0008383439,
0.0493330918,
0.098646313,
-0.0113034211,
-0.0321790613,
0.0009481372,
-0.0241920315,
0.0108285043,
-0.0060343849,
0.0584533624,
-0.0187881198,
-0.0026858067,
0.0145553881,
-0.0316856131,
-0.0294521712,
0.0162601657,
-0.0712912232,
-0.0029136832,
0.0156564359,
0.027888922,
-0.0409692712,
-0.0178323798,
0.0394640341,
0.0025646673,
-0.0122957826,
-0.0659659058,
0.0251377337,
-0.001151731,
-0.0167142078,
-0.0018438806,
-0.0473901704,
0.0011243552,
-0.0120625496,
-0.0198977143,
0.0399836674,
0.0575198457,
0.0037212886,
0.0493511669,
-0.0882663652,
-0.0015334931,
0.0029233994,
0.0367345475,
0.056665767,
0.0330028273,
-0.014877853,
0.0520075522,
0.0425474793,
-0.0138034597,
-0.0364313498,
-0.0682944953,
0.0521330908,
0.0566652454,
0.0162499622,
-0.0501495451,
0.0467991717,
-0.0136858625,
-0.0279083904,
-0.0235408582,
0.0037021809,
0.0514166839,
0.0519260764,
0.0208627824,
0.0175627191,
-0.0206086431,
-0.0311166029,
-0.0088434834,
-0.0417431816,
-0.0049668294,
0.0031183092,
0.0140191056,
-0.0304820053,
0.0044954419,
0.0482847877,
-0.0555965677,
0.0124493865,
0.0272569321,
-0.028715441,
0.0394365378,
0.0040978119,
0.0523346514,
-0.0261995625,
-0.0268167127,
0.0095110983,
-0.0174310673,
0.0158339534,
0.0133093521,
0.0262911357,
0.0770999566,
-0.0572128445,
-0.0210709088,
-0.0759956315,
-0.0101729846,
-0.0007358472,
0.0644652471,
0.0236604661,
0.0140585313,
-0.0061081927,
-0.0161209852,
-0.0079847835,
0.0457552224,
-0.0124553703,
0.0389511995,
0.027347371,
0.0411378555,
-0.0568077154,
-0.0408727899,
-0.0478257462,
0.0372056998,
0.0370447338,
-0.0693650171,
-0.030086996,
0.0381014012,
2.782e-7,
0.0652836561,
0.0228114128,
0.0162260849,
0.0279471986,
0.040001899,
0.0269210637,
0.0013104837,
0.0582346879,
0.0278145578,
0.0193330422,
-0.0070527978,
-0.0035158014,
0.0581589118,
0.0282177236,
-0.0756625906,
-0.011307206,
-0.0914354026,
0.0066141835,
-0.0127416523,
-0.0270796753,
-0.0025395153,
0.1101981923,
0.0196591206,
-0.0195627045,
-0.0140469931,
-0.0013841509,
0.0872077122,
-0.0082303397,
0.0457620285,
-0.0095000705,
0.0163715798,
0.0231287889,
-0.0191836189,
-0.0205679052,
-0.0124503365,
0.0262659229,
0.0062830625,
0.0496694185,
-0.020075839,
-0.0549918711,
0.0218632258,
0.0178791359,
-0.0174985882,
-0.0489874817,
0.029470047,
-0.0721035078,
-0.0125659555,
-0.0157001186,
-0.0152311753,
-0.0072019743,
-0.020698294,
-0.0240805503,
-0.0223537795,
0.0346511938,
0.0212645419,
-0.0317223221,
0.0121742031,
-0.0782379732,
-0.0348532051,
-0.0235090908,
-0.072579883,
-0.0385827981,
-0.0519369468,
-0.0405921899,
0.0519402064,
-0.0395018049,
-0.0012132376,
2.621365718e-34,
0.017605098,
0.0040823221,
-0.0102487719,
0.0640241057,
0.0165192001,
-0.0372653976,
0.0767263845,
0.0069600148,
0.0040758112,
-0.0728146583,
-0.06231023
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.09421v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09421v2 | SheffieldVeraAI at SemEval-2023 Task 3: Mono and multilingual approaches for news genre, topic and persuasion technique classification | 2023-03-16T15:54:23 | 2023-05-09T09:33:33 | Ben Wu, Olesya Razuvayevskaya, Freddy Heppell, João A. Leite, Carolina Scarton, Kalina Bontcheva, Xingyi Song | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper describes our approach for SemEval-2023 Task 3: Detecting the
category, the framing, and the persuasion techniques in online news in a
multi-lingual setup. For Subtask 1 (News Genre), we propose an ensemble of
fully trained and adapter mBERT models which was ranked joint-first for German,
and had the highest mean rank of multi-language teams. For Subtask 2 (Framing),
we achieved first place in 3 languages, and the best average rank across all
the languages, by using two separate ensembles: a monolingual
RoBERTa-MUPPETLARGE and an ensemble of XLM-RoBERTaLARGE with adapters and task
adaptive pretraining. For Subtask 3 (Persuasion Techniques), we train a
monolingual RoBERTa-Base model for English and a multilingual mBERT model for
the remaining languages, which achieved top 10 for all languages, including 2nd
for English. For each subtask, we compared monolingual and multilingual
approaches, and considered class imbalance techniques. | [
0.046095062,
0.0114381267,
-0.0020119555,
0.0154414047,
-0.0188237485,
0.0413676165,
0.0199990291,
-0.0018208681,
-0.0268628728,
-0.0805242658,
-0.0664603338,
-0.0271681137,
0.0012005264,
0.0226878617,
0.0086567597,
-0.0447466299,
0.0169092994,
-0.0136070801,
0.0192622934,
-0.0090248538,
0.0369536094,
0.035864003,
-0.0059640724,
0.0291238949,
0.0215058029,
-0.0385737196,
-0.0069790855,
-0.0028982549,
0.0294466019,
-0.0449794196,
0.0634344071,
0.0766397938,
0.0346377157,
0.0292079262,
0.0000019537,
-0.0410800911,
-0.02174774,
-0.0368619002,
0.0178604126,
-0.039375212,
0.0697500333,
-0.0131990956,
0.0021112564,
0.0503763445,
-0.0104405005,
0.0026351027,
0.0401190743,
0.0937462524,
0.0492244661,
0.0653436705,
-0.0257710945,
-0.0156602953,
0.000455822,
-0.0241791345,
-0.0203804318,
-0.0280429348,
0.0322946049,
-0.038483832,
-0.0494330861,
0.0595245212,
0.0110792341,
-0.0157039072,
-0.0245451964,
-0.0016927266,
-0.0597449094,
-0.0048881099,
-0.0096130744,
0.0027801346,
-0.0114403758,
0.0266250689,
0.0193312969,
-0.05079519,
-0.015136864,
0.0290834326,
0.019731855,
0.0417106412,
-0.0427475721,
0.0147765735,
-0.028485816,
0.0105920229,
0.0594412237,
0.0264691468,
0.0068683955,
0.0450044908,
0.0161167402,
0.0489321463,
-0.003021688,
-0.0305926055,
0.0880924314,
0.0261968412,
0.0238423347,
-0.0599764325,
0.0155763803,
-0.0213605501,
-0.0244853757,
0.0071603069,
0.0111063682,
-0.0400322974,
0.0191953424,
-0.1361021698,
-0.0192520097,
0.0222498216,
0.0188660659,
0.0490315817,
-0.0043562958,
-0.0349086374,
-0.0237399619,
-0.0096325241,
-0.0074085556,
0.0083263805,
-0.0800492913,
0.0264888033,
-0.0267184582,
0.036347311,
-0.0095690126,
-0.0001117674,
-0.0793974772,
0.0201946814,
-0.012578032,
-0.0220087823,
-0.0336642042,
-0.0122564118,
-0.0293805245,
0.0144645888,
-0.0249431487,
0.0603859313,
-0.0215852875,
0.0132375928,
-0.0016915619,
-0.0089365672,
0.0293605831,
0.0585100688,
-0.0360463075,
-0.0571508594,
0.0322822183,
-0.0142362295,
-0.0434084609,
-0.0386361293,
-0.0396771543,
-0.0001752889,
-0.0266815629,
-0.0723867193,
0.0207882859,
-0.0685360208,
0.0004977949,
0.0037434781,
0.0294275153,
0.0018166419,
-0.0148344422,
-0.0010652583,
-0.0177303609,
0.0478850044,
0.057092458,
-0.0162547324,
0.0672940835,
0.0459976457,
-0.0327993594,
0.0948723182,
-0.0293218158,
0.0732628852,
0.056007646,
-0.0256466158,
0.038337566,
0.0104997037,
-0.0178740565,
0.0180238951,
0.036377307,
-0.0031817115,
-0.0402134731,
-0.009744009,
0.0275213663,
0.0027319624,
-0.0192007981,
-0.0000319699,
0.058091037,
-0.0113361748,
0.0227586273,
0.0361933447,
0.0255173016,
-0.0259270668,
0.0095885154,
0.0411077067,
0.0199270248,
-0.0017926141,
-0.0475404449,
-0.0241958685,
0.0221625417,
0.036100287,
-0.0646137074,
-0.0374907814,
-0.0006920091,
-0.0145675121,
0.0083253896,
0.0013482831,
0.0590812936,
-0.0072925184,
-0.0261228736,
0.0213163607,
0.0408254862,
-0.0093979146,
-0.0056102318,
-0.053508956,
0.0108119352,
-0.0191417951,
0.0040114038,
-0.0421365313,
-0.0168600716,
-0.0583139695,
0.0361353159,
0.0415657423,
0.0685023218,
-0.0285072625,
-0.0251859259,
-0.0220966488,
-0.042439241,
-0.0197498724,
0.0119699035,
0.0628661811,
-0.0449469648,
0.0524964854,
-0.0288755912,
-0.0073939217,
-0.0296859127,
0.0050357739,
0.0327850208,
-0.0122864898,
-0.000925518,
0.0199028756,
0.0734412,
0.0542309321,
-0.0086195935,
-0.0450674854,
0.0432860442,
-0.023476664,
-0.0259661768,
0.031034762,
-0.0244848542,
-0.0353525765,
-0.0018743445,
-0.0232834592,
-0.0084868874,
0.0206420049,
0.0138757508,
-0.0209136773,
0.0277992934,
0.0026156607,
0.0272420589,
-0.0389372297,
-0.0010745857,
-0.0237760656,
-0.0137784649,
-0.0001052845,
0.0550135337,
0.0121130962,
0.0121448282,
-0.0259165615,
-0.1050086543,
0.015217511,
-0.0139975138,
0.0061714808,
0.0323977992,
0.0214556959,
0.0152383912,
0.0452082306,
-0.031622123,
-0.0150464997,
-0.0352136753,
-0.1021821946,
-0.0098903375,
-0.0503755584,
0.0380461402,
0.0125302132,
-0.0154236769,
0.0014425869,
0.0164933112,
-0.0662396178,
-0.0325365514,
-0.0073292912,
0.061025355,
-0.0084410803,
0.0064462502,
0.042272009,
0.0224249531,
0.0038164407,
-0.0178247746,
0.0590776168,
0.0037059109,
-0.0520036779,
-0.0436220728,
-0.0268083885,
-0.0146258418,
-0.0232902188,
-0.0548216291,
-0.0180739276,
-0.0187809225,
0.0182992257,
0.0300231334,
0.0329086334,
0.0243153833,
0.0506701805,
0.0256276075,
0.0565537773,
-0.0216457266,
-0.0018097075,
-0.0292845424,
0.0178454462,
-0.0661660284,
-0.0319610797,
0.0539686345,
0.0416753069,
-0.0020409774,
0.0164523106,
-0.0026548847,
0.0065983399,
0.020427091,
-0.0053063058,
-0.0351064503,
-0.0515347421,
0.000996581,
0.017054351,
-0.0024469185,
-0.0082269032,
0.0525320433,
-0.0105182491,
-0.0012676694,
-0.0955315232,
-0.0678293332,
-0.0222917814,
-0.0054971599,
-0.0247871168,
0.0577590652,
0.0033079206,
-0.0445970669,
-0.0246731937,
-0.0728510842,
0.0664139017,
-0.0163879469,
0.0338249728,
0.0533442907,
-0.0012161534,
0.0271939002,
-0.0365522727,
-0.0391439497,
-0.0354415663,
0.0054958565,
-0.0120289987,
-0.0090347165,
0.0074749049,
-0.0758001804,
0.0123716071,
0.0146919861,
-0.0038403044,
-0.0362336747,
-0.0250176266,
0.0583685301,
0.0729578957,
0.0340247303,
-0.0065206955,
-0.0068520075,
-0.0649312288,
0.0307123065,
0.0436379053,
-0.0247665606,
-0.0265506096,
0.0023927698,
-0.0123858228,
0.0388574339,
-0.0493726879,
0.0097858338,
-0.0474522933,
0.037375316,
-0.0250001717,
0.0424282216,
0.0729616433,
0.0323911831,
-0.0876722634,
-0.0405277424,
0.0013647455,
0.0173846055,
0.0167621002,
0.0371871069,
-0.0321818627,
0.0036856704,
0.0089001516,
0.0148559641,
-0.03749476,
0.0115529904,
-0.0223884042,
-0.0616283901,
0.0194534026,
0.0152510321,
-0.0332646519,
0.0157804936,
-0.0694338158,
-0.0166051146,
-0.0316185877,
-0.0140093705,
-0.0397957042,
-0.0073282309,
0.0158179831,
0.0199650526,
-0.0223537385,
-0.0465333164,
-0.0007634058,
-0.0138228303,
0.0089851161,
0.0098138312,
0.0380582847,
-0.0561559536,
-0.024278285,
0.0846510753,
-0.0318794399,
-0.0052809427,
-0.0387193933,
0.0571812466,
-0.0631040409,
0.0392270274,
-0.0246733464,
0.0135836964,
0.016185876,
-0.0208058506,
0.0306350105,
0.0594673976,
0.0003289255,
-0.0528237,
-0.0033143109,
-0.0083914883,
0.03779779,
0.077444993,
0.0091085816,
-0.0296448469,
0.0301988125,
-0.0380311161,
0.0182139017,
0.0074951993,
0.0309649576,
-0.0174507443,
-0.0093113352,
-0.0469914451,
-0.031473469,
-0.0423230156,
0.0132571235,
0.05049932,
-0.0030305211,
0.0401928276,
-0.0228609592,
0.0329563059,
-0.0386333205,
0.0261235274,
0.0165225621,
0.0010302736,
-0.0401362106,
-0.0456146449,
0.0205602963,
-0.0531537607,
-0.0160768423,
-0.0466286652,
-0.0035824126,
-0.0636695698,
-0.0490375422,
0.0338760428,
0.0203344338,
0.0349455178,
0.0174728259,
-0.037301302,
0.0766822025,
0.01853857,
-0.0022314561,
-0.006429866,
0.0679408982,
0.0117678149,
-0.0276708845,
0.0118424036,
-0.0059117349,
0.0627343208,
0.036356084,
-0.0180052165,
-0.0296137761,
0.0303399153,
0.0206931811,
-0.026455909,
0.0208078679,
-0.0163491908,
-0.0441057757,
-0.0602839962,
-0.0301138349,
0.0355045795,
-0.0184997041,
-0.0029784173,
-0.0184278321,
0.055964902,
-0.0100165894,
-0.0205189772,
0.0411498994,
-0.0387712903,
-0.009046806,
-0.0312494636,
0.0643479005,
0.0331211314,
0.063959673,
-0.0299311671,
0.0310915112,
-0.0229080971,
0.0129495123,
0.0554782785,
0.0100603551,
0.0012064551,
0.071118407,
0.0162112024,
-0.0069837538,
0.0450551026,
0.0506155714,
-0.0255181771,
0.0381075069,
-0.0196672063,
0.0407095701,
0.0557274781,
-0.0053909784,
0.0324892066,
-0.0032201123,
-0.0285012368,
-0.0324352123,
0.0383712016,
-0.0084578348,
-0.0014491401,
0.0357876308,
0.0150656169,
-0.0310903136,
0.0282065049,
0.034499988,
-0.0625967756,
-0.0109781418,
0.0696879923,
-0.0712208971,
-0.0284421034,
0.0148493117,
0.0343179442,
0.0418251343,
-0.0171674918,
0.0130413743,
-0.029081637,
-0.0270030815,
0.0393352397,
-0.0339763314,
-0.0089402348,
0.0073871831,
0.0083764801,
0.0827386901,
0.0100927046,
0.0451758467,
-0.0783437043,
-0.0251749381,
-0.0273443311,
-0.0108960783,
0.0152673973,
-6.588435717e-33,
0.0108854258,
-0.0236055739,
-0.0477897674,
0.0236838758,
-0.0005994362,
0.0024108172,
-0.0044793077,
0.0009960564,
-0.0118513359,
0.0403556563,
0.0237180758,
0.0128892278,
-0.0024356509,
-0.0200726315,
-0.0306735225,
-0.0086441189,
0.0543374009,
0.0213733781,
-0.0580298863,
0.0334060602,
0.0331682488,
0.0204921365,
0.0794198513,
-0.0810877681,
0.0214476436,
0.0031288983,
-0.0374502018,
-0.0154467635,
0.042921301,
0.0829004794,
0.0059459489,
0.0725442171,
0.0612812415,
-0.0299839079,
0.045898594,
0.0641964674,
-0.0500213206,
-0.0536889471,
0.0212447457,
-0.0059089777,
0.0170146655,
-0.0068453299,
0.0300802663,
0.0021593824,
-0.0071191448,
-0.0096836109,
0.0498661846,
-0.002492771,
0.0368009545,
-0.0037494332,
-0.0344082154,
-0.0044909101,
-0.0033603087,
0.0048571522,
0.0040000877,
0.0518218577,
0.0096570598,
0.0183866322,
-0.0808792263,
0.0336158201,
-0.0509070605,
0.0002957092,
0.003830493,
-0.0257101841,
-0.0497451909,
0.045061186,
0.0132337203,
0.0498550348,
0.0041144271,
-0.0007091187,
-0.01343513,
0.0158137474,
0.0398779958,
0.0648872405,
0.0197743066,
-0.0112456065,
-0.0704101026,
0.0527081303,
0.1303372532,
-0.0150766838,
-0.0061757197,
-0.021480415,
-0.0491168648,
-0.0301139094,
-0.0120700942,
-0.0519478619,
-0.0350737087,
-0.0498859957,
0.0236543063,
0.0140614491,
0.0037462034,
0.0245979428,
0.0116781509,
-0.0173419099,
-0.0704892948,
0.0108435992,
-0.0048257262,
0.0165502951,
0.0022975747,
-0.0005226982,
-0.0370797552,
-0.016305482,
-0.0025655348,
-0.0010587146,
0.0212622248,
-0.0188776422,
0.0775013119,
0.012174949,
-0.0655423626,
-0.0023678464,
-0.002111858,
0.0186978672,
0.0179298576,
0.0765874162,
0.0137116928,
0.0103198234,
0.0096150143,
0.0435070731,
0.0239596777,
-0.0201312173,
-0.0213727411,
-0.0528439656,
-0.0138138998,
0.042433925,
-0.0176335666,
-0.0344582498,
0.0266704988,
-0.0172026549,
0.0192369204,
-0.0722513199,
-0.0319470391,
-0.063669838,
2.846e-7,
0.0323599428,
0.0446092188,
-0.0696580634,
-0.0422411039,
0.0235739909,
0.054262571,
-0.0522601902,
0.0320424885,
0.0168701615,
-0.0137022296,
0.0043857251,
0.0002570133,
0.0284697991,
0.0472268872,
-0.0903085768,
-0.0169313233,
-0.0229026917,
0.018479893,
-0.0459318757,
0.0444249175,
0.0348768085,
0.0714157671,
0.0197963007,
-0.0167296734,
-0.0199771244,
-0.0274253655,
0.0638228133,
-0.014189912,
-0.0461501628,
0.0155986985,
0.010156597,
-0.0141039034,
-0.0250528362,
0.0248175543,
-0.0331723429,
-0.0125268539,
0.0026346177,
0.0202780515,
-0.0140066352,
-0.0156802461,
0.0212134644,
0.0539053828,
-0.0137041872,
-0.0332304463,
0.038744323,
-0.0208706912,
-0.0618876554,
-0.0619039387,
-0.0461722389,
-0.0185818337,
0.0661995411,
-0.0098222448,
-0.0216642767,
-0.0039548846,
0.0103631886,
0.0072273258,
0.0121475244,
-0.0583699122,
0.0367129408,
0.0212365203,
-0.0112061854,
-0.0560506843,
0.0016218488,
-0.0013976911,
0.0336199403,
-0.066903688,
0.025624251,
2.649747708e-34,
0.0590057448,
0.0126370899,
-0.0015321639,
-0.0169275291,
-0.0024270928,
-0.0147111472,
-0.0273895543,
-0.0132222865,
0.0252413787,
-0.0490391441,
-0.0143618435
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.13360v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.13360v1 | Towards the Scalable Evaluation of Cooperativeness in Language Models | 2023-03-16T15:34:23 | 2023-03-16T15:34:23 | Alan Chan, Maxime Riché, Jesse Clifton | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | It is likely that AI systems driven by pre-trained language models (PLMs)
will increasingly be used to assist humans in high-stakes interactions with
other agents, such as negotiation or conflict resolution. Consistent with the
goals of Cooperative AI \citep{dafoe_open_2020}, we wish to understand and
shape the multi-agent behaviors of PLMs in a pro-social manner. An important
first step is the evaluation of model behaviour across diverse cooperation
problems. Since desired behaviour in an interaction depends upon precise
game-theoretic structure, we focus on generating scenarios with particular
structures with both crowdworkers and a language model. Our work proceeds as
follows. First, we discuss key methodological issues in the generation of
scenarios corresponding to particular game-theoretic structures. Second, we
employ both crowdworkers and a language model to generate such scenarios. We
find that the quality of generations tends to be mediocre in both cases. We
additionally get both crowdworkers and a language model to judge whether given
scenarios align with their intended game-theoretic structure, finding mixed
results depending on the game. Third, we provide a dataset of scenario based on
our data generated. We provide both quantitative and qualitative evaluations of
UnifiedQA and GPT-3 on this dataset. We find that instruct-tuned models tend to
act in a way that could be perceived as cooperative when scaled up, while other
models seemed to have flat scaling trends. | [
0.0571647361,
0.0792704299,
-0.0560227074,
0.0406855717,
-0.0751559734,
0.0016723928,
0.0236855224,
-0.0058044223,
-0.0288848951,
-0.0247225501,
-0.0100610657,
-0.0578297675,
-0.0042959591,
0.0482644737,
-0.0146548375,
-0.0223204326,
0.031246284,
-0.0454194769,
0.032438986,
-0.0288319197,
-0.0208167695,
-0.0229478385,
0.0036792397,
0.0583627187,
-0.0412649922,
0.0332158953,
-0.0487343185,
-0.021276651,
0.0142867547,
0.0189325754,
-0.0002980476,
0.0628930405,
0.0546384454,
0.0037523583,
0.0000021832,
-0.0695521757,
0.0018389706,
-0.0315165669,
0.0027961012,
-0.0186334942,
0.0132959066,
-0.0145160984,
0.0043106312,
0.0243874658,
-0.0823574886,
0.0148130646,
0.011463521,
0.0060251681,
0.0587651581,
0.0606079884,
0.0057541728,
-0.0047878865,
0.0173972733,
-0.0158699956,
-0.0516413338,
-0.0639070719,
0.0245185476,
-0.0032111276,
0.015613989,
-0.003066919,
0.0239216015,
0.028401535,
0.0463981815,
0.0046858806,
-0.0323130637,
0.0433680564,
-0.060759943,
-0.0479263552,
-0.0248057321,
0.0581763349,
-0.004914158,
-0.0348386578,
-0.005034789,
-0.0230197161,
0.0092665041,
0.0257803723,
0.0126402592,
0.0164094456,
0.0236123987,
0.0291746631,
0.0185023211,
0.0371832624,
0.0202015173,
-0.0041797832,
0.0125380978,
0.088153176,
-0.0311585255,
-0.0019662105,
-0.021692235,
0.0108117182,
-0.0255618393,
-0.0643258467,
0.0055481945,
0.0398410037,
-0.0544912256,
0.0045692492,
-0.0464642197,
0.0000521685,
0.0094004776,
-0.045535177,
0.0609748997,
0.0013264639,
0.0135830287,
0.0572316647,
0.0344075933,
0.0323056094,
0.0261725411,
0.0030843252,
-0.0158587527,
-0.0115697905,
-0.0541248694,
0.0079434449,
-0.0863517597,
0.0072792964,
0.0033382152,
0.0030962816,
0.0163251255,
0.0015973973,
-0.0414687619,
0.0435840562,
0.0206194203,
-0.0025143235,
-0.0173231978,
-0.017272884,
-0.0207383446,
-0.0251508914,
-0.0708418638,
0.0116635272,
-0.0041053267,
-0.1002610549,
-0.0015202027,
-0.0227192286,
-0.0087037468,
-0.0214213897,
0.0016258572,
0.0505525321,
0.0212534126,
-0.021306375,
0.0023213641,
-0.0317746922,
0.0269932747,
-0.0888128579,
-0.0330678597,
-0.075397037,
0.0844674706,
-0.0038195474,
-0.016779393,
-0.0494819693,
-0.0063533806,
-0.031832546,
-0.0355590023,
0.087133579,
0.0038177127,
0.0656649619,
0.0178848132,
0.0201632883,
-0.0299375076,
0.0602401271,
0.0777846351,
-0.0032811211,
0.0604848489,
-0.0058236956,
0.0630832836,
0.0704574212,
-0.0021102582,
0.0193322133,
0.0287701525,
0.0109067596,
0.0149730099,
0.0344065018,
-0.0223548859,
0.0798144713,
-0.0213114731,
-0.0561500527,
0.0756281689,
0.0774409696,
-0.001512915,
0.020810036,
0.0324979164,
0.0297770519,
0.0018501546,
-0.0019414395,
-0.0560043566,
0.004290808,
-0.0534412675,
-0.0240282714,
-0.0292204935,
0.059477523,
-0.0288382396,
-0.0538240448,
-0.0051047103,
-0.0250084624,
0.0379281342,
0.0082439845,
0.0418874212,
-0.0192748271,
-0.0473541357,
-0.0452182852,
0.008177815,
-0.0697303116,
0.016837636,
-0.0856315866,
0.0256052762,
0.0236518588,
0.0482784733,
-0.0210837685,
-0.0066874647,
-0.0001145612,
-0.0267917849,
0.0333988629,
0.0514221713,
-0.0265738387,
0.0136436811,
-0.0496540442,
-0.0269061774,
0.0137182744,
-0.0006623181,
0.008505133,
0.0194920935,
0.000317653,
-0.0149808051,
-0.0007245856,
-0.0317245871,
0.0221520625,
-0.0219571162,
0.0155560784,
-0.0422740132,
-0.0072549777,
0.055226095,
0.0115334513,
-0.0251903255,
0.0053898748,
0.0396126062,
-0.016884014,
-0.013418979,
0.0601310097,
-0.0194381401,
-0.0046692598,
0.0140777864,
0.0122571345,
0.0048872093,
0.0307033211,
-0.0106615853,
-0.0109126903,
0.024368925,
0.0055432627,
0.0295265168,
-0.0292354301,
0.0342764296,
-0.0479869992,
-0.0166680496,
-0.0120913927,
0.0386743955,
-0.0270578135,
-0.0374818631,
-0.0205210038,
0.0008858757,
0.0273404494,
-0.0322576687,
-0.02856794,
0.0344503149,
0.010601759,
0.0213940758,
0.0652745143,
0.0069596069,
-0.0174286347,
-0.0438087173,
-0.0641113669,
-0.0204989165,
-0.0433478355,
0.0034772442,
0.0075301137,
-0.0149687594,
-0.0166347772,
0.033917103,
-0.0179370362,
0.0634473637,
0.0408856608,
0.0281061977,
0.016004296,
0.015985148,
-0.0413181521,
-0.0454916954,
0.0105508668,
-0.0087823654,
0.017221706,
0.0199141633,
-0.0129623283,
-0.0549215265,
0.03771808,
-0.0384344533,
0.0578703061,
-0.041981671,
-0.0689059272,
0.0537565872,
0.0076979497,
0.0450371392,
0.0683517903,
-0.001049838,
0.0754171684,
0.069496803,
-0.0066594505,
-0.0666417554,
0.0337642729,
-0.0186155643,
-0.0414693095,
-0.0589053854,
-0.0667334497,
0.0218638387,
0.0899478123,
-0.017593706,
-0.0219152886,
-0.0862980336,
0.0193315558,
-0.0119280368,
-0.0591501482,
-0.0202193372,
-0.0504519306,
-0.0238418821,
0.0507835969,
-0.0023713601,
-0.0439227261,
0.0746813565,
-0.0192721169,
0.0052836328,
-0.0052326345,
-0.0078702522,
-0.0261197872,
0.1067905575,
0.0301421154,
-0.0055727977,
0.0017334472,
0.0328134,
-0.0380618311,
-0.0107650822,
0.0106767332,
-0.0238848832,
-0.033679761,
-0.0635600314,
-0.0052324426,
-0.0059026256,
-0.0263171624,
-0.0176738612,
-0.0249232464,
-0.0357894339,
0.0420890562,
0.0381058492,
-0.0048975879,
-0.0097761527,
0.0315131694,
0.0055351621,
0.0316304043,
0.0129957423,
0.0059044133,
-0.0405920893,
-0.0198260453,
0.0421054512,
0.0667057633,
0.0038690399,
-0.0344261453,
-0.0014986342,
0.0218148585,
0.0461318418,
-0.0272588264,
-0.0005409298,
-0.0011029482,
0.0273026451,
-0.0064104549,
-0.0309632663,
0.0360336974,
0.0377425253,
-0.0243431404,
-0.0061255451,
0.0958409086,
0.0387210883,
-0.0238993112,
0.0422139764,
-0.0318380445,
0.0304001216,
0.0032089667,
-0.0033585259,
-0.0740052164,
-0.0055505554,
0.0114423372,
-0.0113652097,
-0.0085348664,
-0.048284471,
0.0062227915,
-0.1061664075,
0.0386133082,
-0.0038901302,
-0.0279852618,
0.0107547753,
-0.0298711136,
0.0018307336,
-0.0254477076,
0.0088299196,
-0.0035175253,
0.0561205223,
-0.0045984527,
-0.0061796,
0.0203027371,
-0.0086492654,
0.0172015727,
-0.089066565,
0.1031336337,
0.0760019049,
0.05440237,
-0.0134237902,
-0.0359524935,
0.0083980691,
0.0459729657,
0.0111193936,
0.0171283726,
-0.0119891772,
-0.029970726,
0.0101692593,
0.0289719701,
0.0269907843,
-0.0433518887,
-0.0219904929,
0.0537234768,
0.0563591383,
-0.0113820983,
-0.072815761,
0.0192057714,
-0.0033937609,
0.0351510197,
0.079735741,
0.0221952442,
-0.046860382,
-0.0473829731,
0.0039872103,
-0.0026116986,
-0.0359951816,
-0.0509163179,
-0.0031451152,
0.0479765944,
-0.0137522267,
-0.0357600376,
-0.0966563076,
0.0277349353,
-0.0071182316,
0.0107556824,
-0.007482368,
0.0505906604,
0.0286031738,
0.0150075601,
0.025239367,
-0.010496065,
0.0200472977,
-0.0639656857,
-0.0263348743,
0.0068954551,
-0.0438707136,
-0.0148341767,
0.0074787163,
-0.0628597215,
-0.0868641585,
0.0255103819,
0.0636313856,
0.0263311043,
0.0156161813,
-0.0091977473,
-0.050358884,
-0.0131041789,
0.0141681852,
-0.0148459077,
0.0390421711,
0.0199001692,
-0.0096529471,
0.0129772238,
0.0515761524,
-0.008456259,
0.0252439585,
-0.0047826613,
0.0475110561,
-0.0574971661,
-0.0799609274,
0.0128876809,
-0.0119637027,
0.0149067659,
-0.0085931951,
-0.0314100832,
-0.0151260523,
-0.0012334004,
-0.0263428539,
-0.0268062074,
-0.0729615688,
-0.0186898522,
0.0035044162,
0.0288261268,
0.0165228676,
0.0062564858,
-0.0233382285,
0.0014362941,
0.0038932529,
0.0256179832,
0.0170726031,
0.0275384672,
0.0230493713,
0.0048137289,
0.0207001101,
0.0415633917,
-0.0229078028,
0.0190398544,
0.0208102986,
0.0355363339,
0.0254938826,
-0.0029517123,
0.0325985849,
0.0566747859,
-0.0464786999,
-0.0999134108,
0.030644998,
0.0295154639,
0.0437476821,
0.0124384863,
0.0465909876,
-0.0506873019,
0.0212738495,
-0.0196080022,
0.0204237346,
0.023345435,
-0.0630789325,
0.0150812697,
0.0157882161,
-0.0265468583,
0.0539890379,
0.0788782462,
-0.0030029907,
0.0413079448,
0.004944412,
0.0163823459,
-0.0115896352,
-0.0297531169,
0.0069514071,
-0.004082324,
-0.0499198623,
0.0344712213,
-0.0553716086,
-0.0406444594,
-0.0509087741,
0.0530414991,
0.0165826008,
-0.0169998668,
0.0230813287,
0.046772927,
-0.0389252193,
-0.0048275543,
-0.0426201448,
0.0122555653,
-0.0295826085,
-0.0056158369,
-0.0137217175,
-6.596765564e-33,
-0.025838552,
-0.0433025807,
0.0374477021,
-0.0084337322,
-0.0039336383,
-0.0349704586,
-0.0231743194,
-0.0000682084,
-0.050600715,
0.0025369006,
-0.021838218,
0.007943403,
0.0158963762,
-0.0305765253,
0.0021346933,
-0.0193495266,
0.0166964568,
-0.0522332564,
-0.0454164222,
0.0153571321,
-0.0152884405,
-0.0316979699,
0.0220370777,
-0.072540082,
0.0359397754,
-0.0427915156,
-0.0415437706,
0.0441664606,
-0.0362058505,
0.0231132116,
-0.0175840426,
-0.0106215635,
0.025612345,
0.0027136349,
0.0136141768,
0.0021889557,
-0.0317188017,
-0.0017437963,
0.0132422997,
-0.0018027049,
-0.0827128217,
-0.0123101026,
0.0088674817,
-0.0159910321,
-0.0821265057,
0.0258251894,
0.0169415511,
-0.0044458802,
0.0135532143,
0.019687824,
-0.0630320981,
0.001581821,
-0.0251428969,
-0.038296964,
0.0022353786,
0.0150386626,
-0.0020299489,
0.0101698097,
-0.0435388722,
0.040380694,
0.0161495917,
-0.0234174281,
0.064323552,
-0.022187598,
0.0451870672,
0.0400268324,
0.0024910308,
0.0392743722,
-0.0303053316,
-0.0773547143,
0.0283176694,
0.0751421452,
0.0593880489,
0.0520282239,
-0.0196340624,
-0.0201199632,
-0.014619071,
0.0324602239,
0.0394670703,
0.0223563537,
0.0155000491,
0.0011102279,
-0.0401523076,
-0.0267672706,
-0.0328321271,
-0.0580202267,
-0.0040973765,
-0.0362487026,
0.0189652108,
0.0051641082,
-0.0112420674,
-0.028023826,
0.0520642288,
-0.0521843322,
-0.0096937763,
0.0252368506,
-0.0016924958,
0.0345300101,
0.0127275176,
0.0195979811,
-0.065671809,
-0.0275027994,
-0.0248110518,
-0.0133229615,
0.0340723172,
0.0240226649,
-0.0013809286,
0.0354938135,
-0.0035271279,
0.0092432983,
-0.0179934725,
0.0326438658,
0.0135172587,
-0.0272246022,
0.037821386,
-0.0106351785,
-0.0108900731,
-0.0019209142,
0.0179637969,
-0.0450261608,
-0.051096119,
0.0487019606,
-0.0176930893,
0.0009080142,
-0.0129242623,
-0.004402162,
-0.0526245721,
0.0396185331,
0.0510285795,
0.0181518234,
-0.0400628448,
-0.0397096947,
2.879e-7,
-0.0016400533,
0.0491764508,
0.0129822101,
0.0444247574,
-0.0130702769,
0.0687552541,
-0.0555052459,
0.0562956706,
0.0035931757,
0.0109731462,
0.0458602197,
0.0655789599,
0.0342801213,
0.0354909077,
-0.0316305272,
0.0168544557,
-0.0641936138,
-0.0291522034,
-0.037903484,
-0.0151828779,
0.0343415029,
0.0156114539,
0.0384610891,
0.0236009341,
-0.0191684924,
-0.0308515802,
0.0240166374,
-0.0906284302,
-0.0136134923,
0.0623681583,
-0.0233056396,
-0.015856931,
-0.0101059927,
0.0042644073,
0.0250019748,
0.0427147523,
-0.010112646,
0.0584997833,
-0.0116698965,
-0.0086049726,
-0.0207763333,
-0.029822031,
-0.0077650221,
-0.0775291696,
0.051165916,
-0.0347862393,
-0.036184676,
0.0004257493,
0.0455683768,
-0.0158107951,
0.0059384522,
-0.006181824,
-0.0126150548,
0.0045949384,
0.0261611342,
0.0050351573,
0.0127403727,
-0.0281559266,
-0.0112338075,
-0.0291982684,
-0.0242902599,
-0.0719401389,
-0.0051426399,
0.0335190557,
-0.0163602363,
-0.0153773576,
0.0194778983,
2.37030515e-34,
0.0285971668,
0.006139461,
0.0288534239,
0.0309834853,
0.0696315244,
0.0120430719,
-0.0500387028,
0.0239540748,
0.0397238359,
-0.023606332,
-0.0172573309
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.09366v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09366v2 | The Scope of In-Context Learning for the Extraction of Medical Temporal Constraints | 2023-03-16T14:51:44 | 2023-10-16T14:22:41 | Parker Seegmiller, Joseph Gatto, Madhusudan Basak, Diane Cook, Hassan Ghasemzadeh, John Stankovic, Sarah Preum | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Medications often impose temporal constraints on everyday patient activity.
Violations of such medical temporal constraints (MTCs) lead to a lack of
treatment adherence, in addition to poor health outcomes and increased
healthcare expenses. These MTCs are found in drug usage guidelines (DUGs) in
both patient education materials and clinical texts. Computationally
representing MTCs in DUGs will advance patient-centric healthcare applications
by helping to define safe patient activity patterns. We define a novel taxonomy
of MTCs found in DUGs and develop a novel context-free grammar (CFG) based
model to computationally represent MTCs from unstructured DUGs. Additionally,
we release three new datasets with a combined total of N = 836 DUGs labeled
with normalized MTCs. We develop an in-context learning (ICL) solution for
automatically extracting and normalizing MTCs found in DUGs, achieving an
average F1 score of 0.62 across all datasets. Finally, we rigorously
investigate ICL model performance against a baseline model, across datasets and
MTC types, and through in-depth error analysis. | [
0.0288323909,
0.0449046902,
-0.0029335339,
-0.0527629033,
-0.023500504,
0.0255094059,
0.0068803472,
0.0107852314,
-0.0110966871,
-0.0398073494,
0.0562873408,
-0.0394132584,
-0.0292623919,
0.0174478814,
-0.0204283223,
-0.0283355359,
0.0306782853,
0.0421729162,
0.0178377051,
0.0613853335,
0.0081455735,
0.0066385032,
-0.0389924049,
0.0411984175,
-0.0372632928,
-0.0345648117,
0.0355615504,
-0.0216014739,
0.0500582233,
-0.0903324261,
0.0284715295,
0.015820777,
-0.0009595561,
-0.0325276591,
0.0000019517,
-0.0566333942,
-0.0281969644,
0.0154713923,
-0.041885823,
-0.0337887816,
0.0324235521,
-0.0795034766,
-0.0185420457,
-0.0191144794,
-0.0704030991,
-0.006954913,
0.0159948636,
0.0247299336,
0.0119904801,
0.0882678479,
-0.0308990013,
0.0384707861,
-0.0138352355,
0.0032197523,
0.0046828203,
-0.0266191661,
0.0526446924,
0.023742415,
0.032352861,
-0.0361506194,
0.0255803075,
0.0119712967,
-0.0105204768,
0.0117191598,
0.0419356413,
0.017250685,
-0.0230839942,
0.0252406858,
-0.0186237115,
0.0525616333,
0.0146971103,
-0.0204576757,
0.0520579293,
-0.0132395634,
-0.0139276534,
0.0084497351,
-0.0467808954,
-0.0144863827,
-0.0233000033,
0.0402116254,
0.0325701162,
0.0234003384,
0.0289515667,
-0.0389069356,
0.0129261995,
-0.0066432236,
-0.00946326,
-0.0214341991,
-0.0161705464,
-0.0281228423,
-0.020970121,
-0.0176202524,
0.0287667681,
0.0114069162,
-0.0468457006,
0.0117116151,
-0.0261773504,
0.0121472962,
0.0712025985,
-0.032446973,
0.0109949987,
-0.009573793,
0.0455467924,
0.0383829772,
0.0359190479,
-0.0186801292,
-0.0017443774,
0.0199148562,
-0.0480504185,
0.0566888601,
-0.0604071468,
-0.0002856715,
-0.0071062096,
0.0004600038,
0.0033162127,
-0.00117919,
-0.0862946212,
0.0042145555,
-0.0393149406,
0.0043915403,
0.0137477601,
0.018355811,
-0.0150232483,
0.0196706336,
0.0217568967,
-0.0313398577,
0.0054325568,
0.0100181885,
-0.0047504758,
0.0126221376,
0.0116836959,
0.0055505703,
0.0322337635,
-0.0043650116,
-0.0095936898,
0.0262526851,
0.0040873163,
0.0017223773,
-0.0538717881,
-0.0481982753,
-0.0210406259,
0.0180777647,
-0.0013678318,
-0.0493143722,
-0.0044423407,
-0.0344217308,
0.0079227127,
-0.0243638791,
-0.00067492,
0.0056982287,
-0.0001774016,
0.0453935005,
0.0003951356,
-0.0148843108,
0.0152995912,
0.0072151627,
0.0595132597,
0.0089990795,
0.0171747282,
-0.0355685689,
0.0284438282,
-0.0092465067,
-0.0004294562,
0.0274265334,
0.0115350308,
-0.0541506894,
-0.011540208,
-0.0062411213,
0.0433216095,
0.0095747607,
-0.061290063,
0.0506626144,
-0.0102864876,
0.0125214178,
-0.0044030203,
0.0246839337,
0.0384090394,
-0.0273343883,
0.0439838246,
-0.0519359931,
-0.0140738338,
-0.0465426408,
-0.0404884405,
-0.0405750424,
0.0022531375,
0.007883749,
-0.063166827,
-0.0197921358,
-0.0011277656,
-0.0482800342,
-0.0367791541,
-0.0367923416,
0.000631635,
-0.0273497403,
0.044768516,
-0.0091213416,
-0.0360683762,
0.0736652836,
0.0316339917,
0.0107767442,
-0.0557387285,
0.0220465623,
-0.0041225483,
0.0686667264,
0.0525297783,
-0.0704183802,
-0.04162772,
-0.0444715098,
0.065105781,
-0.0106840748,
-0.006532365,
-0.0697273239,
-0.0001639617,
-0.0311678983,
0.0058697551,
0.0469795018,
0.0166392848,
-0.0504929721,
-0.0084540276,
0.0226166155,
-0.0101636089,
-0.0072330954,
-0.030796295,
0.0632377639,
-0.0124154827,
-0.066665329,
-0.0051233754,
0.0165443178,
0.0189493801,
0.0440564528,
0.0272533875,
0.014087881,
0.0685676634,
-0.0632462576,
0.0304670576,
0.0132846646,
-0.0678306073,
-0.0338496789,
0.019840816,
-0.0172626711,
-0.0002747632,
-0.053172987,
-0.036935214,
0.0015419978,
-0.0086514559,
0.0012302971,
0.0675807148,
0.0057136947,
-0.0004373291,
0.062742874,
-0.0187597945,
-0.0825754628,
0.0320385024,
-0.0250703115,
0.0138856526,
0.0250815153,
-0.0471277125,
-0.0039138435,
0.0140058687,
0.0541178398,
-0.0085724778,
-0.0313034616,
-0.0086011803,
-0.0009369771,
0.0534036309,
-0.0127936834,
0.0219795518,
-0.0610910058,
-0.0286347568,
-0.015753353,
0.0190809071,
0.0218950417,
-0.0005554648,
-0.0139002707,
-0.0460125357,
-0.0094949435,
-0.0170750748,
-0.0154695967,
-0.0302133411,
0.0521586388,
0.0706228539,
-0.0374456272,
-0.0158270095,
-0.0114146285,
-0.0659714863,
0.0182601586,
-0.0214964133,
-0.0515941791,
0.0113672335,
-0.0088626267,
0.0332360789,
0.0004813212,
-0.0103980815,
0.0264532119,
0.0337575488,
-0.010189442,
0.018190911,
0.0337656513,
-0.0316455141,
0.0251088254,
0.0245307665,
-0.0178124644,
-0.0194835216,
0.0011311092,
-0.0474431887,
0.0042362507,
-0.0004022793,
-0.0562145784,
0.0210726745,
0.0839406401,
0.0146540394,
0.0177855715,
-0.0247204807,
0.0061244275,
-0.0471651405,
0.0316389725,
-0.0644994751,
0.0372692682,
-0.0493731722,
0.0206889473,
0.0129658394,
-0.0446571819,
0.0540016815,
0.0385176875,
0.0322646908,
-0.0366034433,
-0.0390874967,
-0.0464993566,
-0.0490336791,
0.019953955,
0.0022911939,
0.0768473595,
-0.0222977661,
0.0245331898,
0.0045555849,
0.0346152186,
-0.0159114338,
0.0778834447,
-0.0484454483,
0.0397165418,
0.0150117315,
-0.0450593531,
-0.0330154859,
-0.0404846407,
0.0032632386,
-0.0052976403,
-0.0187038314,
0.03545947,
-0.0538172945,
0.0238596071,
-0.0972708464,
0.0543931201,
0.0386903137,
-0.0374076739,
0.0044107018,
0.0227668323,
0.0655742511,
-0.0423740409,
-0.0428890362,
0.0164105874,
0.0208588932,
0.0587009862,
0.0150676668,
0.0105215274,
-0.0026455277,
0.052330073,
-0.0311420355,
-0.0206316784,
0.002511313,
0.0608705021,
-0.0127603905,
-0.0159094706,
-0.015955722,
0.0868935362,
0.0689158589,
-0.0190709233,
0.0524779111,
-0.0087738344,
-0.0401262753,
-0.0068576206,
-0.018948134,
-0.086091809,
-0.0284365397,
-0.0166156236,
0.0387232676,
-0.0320143662,
-0.0271050893,
0.0011679996,
-0.0059360159,
-0.0037260354,
0.0428552777,
-0.0436387993,
0.0175988898,
-0.0312928818,
-0.0136118159,
-0.068188183,
-0.016617991,
0.008952735,
-0.0418678597,
-0.0066626845,
0.0379459821,
-0.093687728,
-0.0889398754,
0.032811515,
0.0218609087,
0.0531820022,
0.0188484732,
-0.0172802005,
0.0105498983,
-0.0115083409,
0.0272640716,
-0.0071276678,
-0.0035479374,
-0.0281857327,
0.0093803536,
0.00535713,
-0.0016058586,
-0.0554102138,
0.0769349337,
-0.0751453266,
-0.0863456428,
-0.0020196724,
0.1241891757,
-0.0082919579,
-0.0077405777,
-0.0563542545,
0.0217044521,
0.078963317,
0.0259436928,
-0.0086059496,
0.0143047441,
-0.0162667725,
-0.0050850152,
0.0101966904,
-0.036032252,
0.0229713898,
-0.0097391848,
-0.0572590157,
0.0059758215,
-0.0634643883,
-0.0187786352,
0.0123853637,
-0.0162827708,
-0.0097871525,
-0.0161905419,
0.018929515,
-0.0019474023,
-0.0475030653,
0.0277015045,
0.0275830142,
0.0069898102,
-0.055734966,
-0.0391772725,
-0.0106735816,
0.0435878448,
-0.0313364789,
0.0525331534,
-0.0000481791,
-0.0251804087,
0.0281015839,
0.0169197712,
0.0123072816,
0.0103788171,
0.0117134182,
0.0760402828,
0.0252032746,
0.0657340139,
0.0216815621,
-0.0508109443,
0.0022396126,
-0.0094230035,
-0.0058008949,
-0.0151729137,
-0.0315715708,
0.029703185,
-0.0400184877,
0.0581327938,
-0.0944165662,
0.0252195112,
0.0509387963,
-0.001623885,
0.0156942848,
0.0142534031,
-0.0196773261,
-0.0283417068,
0.0069101281,
-0.0187838711,
-0.0079852501,
0.0020116719,
0.0258579627,
0.0156136751,
-0.0209209844,
-0.0233233329,
0.0395733342,
-0.058011122,
-0.047672037,
-0.0239501949,
0.037740998,
0.0303786378,
0.0130008971,
0.016656341,
-0.0160926133,
0.0233418178,
0.0194926318,
-0.0086320117,
0.0408542193,
-0.017475009,
0.0464952253,
-0.001001299,
0.0667993128,
-0.0438511893,
0.0297655985,
-0.0226876158,
0.0845743492,
-0.0344472788,
-0.0272229295,
0.0517624021,
-0.0517260395,
0.0516659692,
-0.044004716,
-0.0008105986,
-0.0311816093,
0.0715476871,
0.0128972027,
0.0295416787,
0.0426137745,
0.0159350876,
-0.0160494372,
-0.0402518995,
0.0995507613,
0.010875904,
0.0139204254,
0.0174334347,
-0.0446892641,
-0.0594161376,
0.0181134362,
0.0017234422,
-0.0000991742,
-0.0455849282,
-0.0025555438,
-0.0638315082,
-0.0228268057,
0.031832654,
0.0044897399,
-0.0174162555,
0.0124462359,
0.0184859894,
0.0029672519,
0.0203524828,
-0.0663810596,
-0.0323443487,
0.044135306,
0.005095894,
-0.0103516215,
-0.0245434269,
-5.01529881e-33,
-0.007229588,
-0.0332331695,
0.0094411261,
0.0115261218,
0.0280003063,
0.0153377159,
-0.0198391303,
-0.0095415041,
0.040537443,
0.0313200764,
0.0136162685,
-0.0070062107,
0.0115126371,
-0.0037098648,
0.0504414178,
-0.0165924449,
-0.0157947615,
-0.0109000541,
0.0078196805,
0.0117200492,
0.0477624498,
0.0705072135,
0.0625695512,
-0.0665342286,
0.0358361229,
0.0184968654,
0.0220487509,
-0.0008235485,
-0.0093504163,
0.0827283263,
-0.0205555093,
0.0335901529,
0.0304145291,
-0.0126047051,
-0.0167592969,
0.0052628596,
-0.0762597993,
-0.053874176,
0.0037593148,
-0.0358028449,
-0.0191121213,
-0.0457131453,
0.0133343935,
-0.0246558152,
-0.04388972,
0.0260809343,
0.0258421972,
-0.0422628857,
-0.0340682939,
-0.0425520986,
-0.0513419248,
0.0604051203,
-0.0540504865,
0.0063818297,
0.007693463,
0.019738676,
-0.0262135658,
0.0115503222,
-0.0275857896,
0.0145680141,
0.0083061345,
0.0391511023,
0.0234952196,
-0.0132302213,
-0.0021860828,
0.0150824832,
-0.0644884557,
-0.0206383057,
0.0044890381,
0.0248831213,
-0.0375541188,
0.0509232767,
-0.0275153257,
0.0142745022,
0.067860648,
-0.0114417113,
-0.1027689874,
0.0367470048,
-0.0552516766,
0.0516785793,
0.0002847308,
0.0033420033,
-0.0546712428,
-0.0360217802,
0.0330605879,
0.0510224812,
0.0138167851,
0.0090307277,
0.0331479199,
0.0104281045,
-0.015599288,
0.0444370769,
-0.0368353091,
-0.0162336566,
-0.0081447698,
-0.0164126214,
0.0663159341,
-0.0225498527,
-0.0190479178,
-0.0471587144,
-0.0950906128,
-0.0342429206,
0.0197588485,
-0.0208289083,
0.0635584816,
0.0094183413,
0.0598751642,
-0.016018685,
-0.0083759166,
-0.0254508425,
0.0458319485,
0.023767611,
0.0139917759,
0.0135165202,
0.0491530858,
0.003376914,
-0.0044855936,
0.0736648366,
-0.0014802238,
-0.0247622281,
-0.0188708492,
-0.0099535706,
0.01828002,
0.0110444967,
-0.0253195781,
-0.0330793448,
-0.0255781151,
0.0766465217,
0.0785842016,
-0.0095717181,
0.0193808749,
-0.0209911391,
2.599e-7,
0.101764299,
0.0619294085,
0.0254680477,
0.0121117262,
0.0326161869,
-0.0102139004,
-0.0256628301,
0.0049866033,
-0.0660550818,
0.0041845399,
0.0980466157,
-0.0571167581,
0.010890903,
0.0336348861,
0.0090005901,
-0.0176172182,
-0.0506396927,
-0.0704195276,
-0.0207707975,
-0.0017732042,
0.0397569947,
0.0454721935,
-0.0104827741,
-0.0159513187,
0.0099002421,
-0.0387381315,
0.0172415674,
-0.0566044562,
0.0040069148,
0.0346943624,
0.0253131799,
-0.046171017,
-0.0097343661,
0.0297009386,
-0.0119821159,
-0.0158660877,
-0.0205971468,
0.1071061045,
-0.048641026,
0.0188066103,
-0.0030667153,
-0.0383871384,
0.0115735652,
0.0022898843,
0.0409849063,
-0.0364736542,
-0.0378261246,
-0.0169574022,
-0.015107899,
0.0073540783,
0.0498991348,
0.0171161387,
-0.0291013792,
0.0238536391,
0.0326715931,
0.0456992909,
-0.025446672,
-0.0493293516,
-0.0181728043,
0.0836279616,
-0.0057603605,
-0.0009630527,
0.0555856377,
0.0244939495,
-0.026684748,
-0.0489430018,
0.004267111,
2.430346279e-34,
0.0370306,
0.0184636153,
0.0239375532,
0.0067130732,
-0.001831828,
-0.0076842485,
-0.0076604458,
0.0154801952,
0.0233393591,
-0.0793806911,
-0.0022727347
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.09364v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09364v1 | Tollywood Emotions: Annotation of Valence-Arousal in Telugu Song Lyrics | 2023-03-16T14:47:52 | 2023-03-16T14:47:52 | R Guru Ravi Shanker, B Manikanta Gupta, BV Koushik, Vinoo Alluri | cs.CL | cs.CL | Emotion recognition from a given music track has heavily relied on acoustic
features, social tags, and metadata but is seldom focused on lyrics. There are
no datasets of Indian language songs that contain both valence and arousal
manual ratings of lyrics. We present a new manually annotated dataset of Telugu
songs' lyrics collected from Spotify with valence and arousal annotated on a
discrete scale. A fairly high inter-annotator agreement was observed for both
valence and arousal. Subsequently, we create two music emotion recognition
models by using two classification techniques to identify valence, arousal and
respective emotion quadrant from lyrics. Support vector machine (SVM) with term
frequency-inverse document frequency (TF-IDF) features and fine-tuning the
pre-trained XLMRoBERTa (XLM-R) model were used for valence, arousal and
quadrant classification tasks. Fine-tuned XLMRoBERTa performs better than the
SVM by improving macro-averaged F1-scores of 54.69%, 67.61%, 34.13% to 77.90%,
80.71% and 58.33% for valence, arousal and quadrant classifications,
respectively, on 10-fold cross-validation. In addition, we compare our lyrics
annotations with Spotify's annotations of valence and energy (same as arousal),
which are based on entire music tracks. The implications of our findings are
discussed. Finally, we make the dataset publicly available with lyrics,
annotations and Spotify IDs. | [
0.0347645767,
0.008165122,
-0.0123054972,
0.0114734154,
-0.0082699722,
0.0230337027,
-0.0104078697,
-0.0356756188,
0.0134906545,
0.015211368,
-0.0562786274,
-0.0230148192,
0.0226771217,
0.0145973982,
-0.0337269232,
-0.0342887118,
-0.0288056638,
0.0632310063,
0.1002375335,
0.0221053064,
-0.0165960286,
0.0343546942,
-0.0369010717,
0.0310021453,
-0.0706661195,
-0.004961269,
-0.0219005421,
0.0580622554,
0.0069767921,
-0.067449525,
-0.0033608379,
0.075384289,
0.0015009842,
-0.0049855933,
0.0000017163,
-0.0124415532,
-0.0123935826,
0.0099424152,
0.0366323665,
-0.041979067,
0.0375080891,
0.0228724908,
0.0068255374,
0.0181795303,
0.0034511525,
-0.0140012633,
0.0611942261,
0.0376874134,
0.0475215912,
0.0791006237,
-0.022443125,
-0.0120440014,
0.002411217,
-0.0150919529,
0.002155877,
0.0032589622,
-0.0037193557,
0.0420266017,
0.0290753245,
-0.0424468182,
-0.0286343116,
0.0333905853,
-0.0405522883,
0.0375766233,
0.0483757183,
0.0017286382,
-0.0624372512,
-0.0589554012,
0.0501068458,
0.0105809672,
0.0065798401,
-0.0308072828,
0.0212653745,
0.0124810655,
-0.0258665532,
-0.0419356897,
-0.0229932945,
-0.0269799139,
0.013259138,
0.0516098551,
0.0047562486,
0.0448976867,
-0.0167165622,
0.001043131,
0.0581403635,
0.0047762906,
-0.0252973158,
-0.0602152869,
0.0717039928,
-0.0196859967,
-0.0319249555,
-0.0046283007,
0.0218994338,
-0.0230685044,
-0.0058445316,
0.0181420911,
-0.0472320803,
-0.1166290939,
0.0013339651,
-0.0711499453,
0.001071244,
-0.002574306,
-0.0395314656,
0.0343422033,
0.0032893934,
-0.0093694506,
0.0375595056,
-0.0170399211,
-0.0319990814,
-0.0103274304,
0.0066187573,
0.00024707,
0.0101030217,
-0.0072744307,
0.0313730463,
-0.0146886967,
-0.0959313512,
-0.0029377055,
-0.0205364954,
0.0119915614,
-0.0246018842,
-0.0288006254,
0.0327551626,
0.0122342138,
0.060365092,
0.0018886788,
-0.0296311062,
0.0459385663,
-0.031326279,
-0.0302265435,
0.052097749,
0.0236168914,
0.0005128798,
0.0204437915,
0.0661094785,
-0.0064480007,
0.0479127057,
-0.0432932079,
-0.0425027311,
-0.0338837057,
-0.015929278,
-0.0581029616,
-0.0493136831,
-0.0363483727,
0.0811106339,
0.0377486758,
-0.0206750389,
-0.012290284,
0.0221527498,
-0.0139078377,
-0.0091245249,
0.0487437546,
0.0046601621,
0.0013940816,
-0.0041490723,
0.0139811598,
0.0071824486,
-0.0196263082,
0.0424209237,
0.0588592887,
0.0593103878,
-0.0480778404,
0.0483446717,
0.0079617519,
-0.0210658628,
-0.0234292261,
-0.047471419,
-0.0489482135,
-0.0250142012,
0.0504770614,
-0.0009188869,
-0.0049087014,
0.0425032116,
0.0123521769,
0.0210032891,
0.0502779111,
0.004564452,
0.0707663223,
-0.0644856691,
0.0513002127,
0.0637097806,
-0.0205131695,
-0.0048081311,
0.0551263168,
0.015006518,
0.0130092585,
0.0896421894,
-0.0290096384,
0.0036742531,
-0.0093160896,
-0.0750632286,
-0.004627631,
-0.0136860171,
-0.0072243898,
0.0562415905,
-0.0215751156,
-0.0325699449,
-0.0216331165,
0.0432645679,
-0.0839878097,
-0.0126351072,
-0.0020017752,
0.060068436,
0.0181608796,
0.0111443875,
-0.0681061074,
0.0432240553,
-0.0165558625,
-0.0402432084,
0.0238039903,
-0.0269593336,
-0.0015562586,
-0.0240245834,
-0.0334939286,
0.0422154032,
0.0075913509,
-0.002299408,
-0.009720142,
-0.0578230843,
0.0419856943,
-0.0085901851,
-0.0087707005,
-0.0176512655,
0.0091362325,
0.0608966015,
-0.0205835961,
0.0079078898,
0.0327146761,
0.0498758331,
0.0384160653,
-0.026666414,
-0.0166753605,
0.0466359295,
0.0127739972,
0.0190468058,
0.0131884385,
0.0292207915,
-0.0004346519,
0.0393228233,
0.0204490386,
0.0453310795,
0.0312731713,
-0.0077637536,
-0.056928277,
0.0619686246,
0.0468441658,
0.0157515891,
0.0097954795,
0.0433352105,
-0.0215558428,
0.0471232124,
0.0560655743,
-0.0164937805,
0.0336607322,
0.0171312429,
-0.0561892912,
-0.0373872593,
0.0439708047,
0.0153956031,
-0.0405715331,
0.0409556068,
0.0110546378,
0.0379923657,
-0.0433465354,
-0.0541375764,
-0.0408764444,
-0.0721629858,
-0.0976516232,
0.0088744294,
-0.0193346515,
-0.0504213646,
-0.0184145235,
-0.0197843779,
-0.0390391275,
-0.0528391562,
-0.0282234047,
0.0187897738,
0.014246868,
0.0158248972,
-0.0407401212,
-0.0318033025,
0.003396275,
-0.0294007789,
0.0038835711,
-0.0316296294,
-0.0059708846,
-0.0301057994,
-0.0331066698,
0.0190344751,
0.0072029107,
-0.0466293991,
-0.0329117291,
0.0182713605,
-0.0475900955,
-0.0259807594,
-0.0193028338,
0.0038497571,
0.0138381133,
-0.00844453,
0.0400061011,
0.032296367,
-0.0027262378,
0.018957261,
0.0201507658,
0.01225881,
0.0230128877,
0.0005031629,
-0.0414787494,
0.009305995,
0.0125702927,
0.0231006257,
0.0021677963,
0.0345929302,
-0.0178738814,
-0.0304319561,
0.0360026993,
0.0009018552,
0.0354290605,
-0.0017095356,
0.0376497842,
0.0333921239,
-0.0417833962,
0.0226860456,
-0.0102427984,
-0.01749577,
-0.0711707696,
-0.0592927672,
-0.0164073128,
0.0279866513,
-0.0826450586,
-0.0002753867,
0.0025152368,
0.0065251114,
0.0344081223,
-0.0154270278,
-0.0387268439,
-0.0759731308,
-0.008685722,
-0.0096766995,
-0.0158716831,
-0.00008277,
-0.0004053365,
0.0169058591,
-0.0773525983,
-0.0130016897,
-0.0137411226,
-0.0208574701,
-0.0172945336,
0.050309103,
0.0153980795,
-0.0088272458,
-0.040942587,
-0.0020936448,
-0.0005856982,
0.0562847517,
0.0394685492,
0.0737401396,
-0.0174956005,
-0.0131488666,
0.0155972838,
0.0345601328,
-0.0019477381,
0.0206073653,
-0.0092444625,
-0.0065638339,
-0.0002479316,
0.0146854362,
0.0088169556,
0.0077066538,
-0.039767582,
-0.026156133,
-0.0258906893,
0.0440651961,
0.0774883553,
0.0120127965,
-0.0144105693,
-0.0154054724,
-0.034883488,
-0.0336633474,
0.0194179565,
0.0246982388,
0.0165883824,
0.0248446018,
0.0400769673,
0.0475421436,
0.0250189304,
0.0215919577,
-0.015881259,
-0.0105720349,
0.0148607064,
-0.009391739,
-0.0319588147,
0.0095393695,
-0.0054234709,
-0.0091329394,
-0.0008785037,
-0.0235690419,
-0.0429885089,
-0.0060512926,
0.019000778,
0.0384605564,
-0.0065190275,
0.0037741612,
0.0069421134,
-0.0575632788,
0.055807285,
0.0099803442,
0.0945349783,
-0.0315223038,
-0.0334925763,
-0.0243583601,
-0.020691501,
-0.0110050552,
0.0043333662,
0.0292514078,
0.0179952811,
-0.0316470861,
-0.0025670959,
0.0298881251,
-0.0471929945,
-0.0054490147,
0.0178009681,
0.0409896933,
-0.0040396871,
-0.0350359194,
-0.032355614,
0.0368288904,
-0.0012032421,
0.0398580991,
0.0192076061,
-0.0547238886,
0.0218785405,
0.0082860906,
0.0346193574,
0.0050455197,
-0.0187442265,
-0.0317489803,
-0.0031628397,
-0.0595212877,
0.0164879132,
-0.0497146174,
0.0093859965,
0.0047854162,
0.005713894,
0.0360693261,
-0.0415160283,
-0.0256275777,
-0.0435985513,
0.0038005381,
0.0367357656,
0.0426220819,
-0.0010926052,
-0.0483028665,
0.0162980109,
-0.0235826988,
-0.0221579019,
-0.076684922,
-0.0048217243,
-0.026847532,
0.0324298404,
0.0118368762,
0.008341833,
-0.0076186834,
-0.0171619263,
-0.0424199663,
0.0146766985,
0.015358489,
-0.0087276679,
-0.0049677338,
0.054482419,
0.0400828123,
-0.0298744012,
-0.0007183001,
-0.0481202044,
0.0386809781,
0.0230508838,
-0.0102432147,
0.0340211727,
-0.0519538559,
0.0102801239,
0.0045517338,
0.0439412184,
-0.0186186712,
-0.0771842971,
-0.0192431733,
-0.0357857347,
0.0420755073,
-0.0095325066,
0.0051415344,
-0.028077282,
0.0553322248,
0.0470711477,
-0.0860338956,
-0.0535359494,
0.0195250995,
-0.0386665612,
-0.0095513966,
0.0574035272,
0.0226575155,
-0.0209952667,
-0.0048723174,
0.0122607397,
-0.0060892496,
-0.0416459516,
0.0575758442,
-0.0057556094,
0.0500554889,
0.0194367617,
-0.0081472211,
-0.023098221,
0.0085226577,
0.060235735,
0.034114331,
0.0041998806,
-0.017531842,
-0.0085663032,
0.0362953171,
-0.0351539329,
0.0356628634,
-0.0357012711,
0.0100653004,
-0.0073372857,
0.0244729407,
-0.0408735648,
-0.0332975797,
0.0280230641,
-0.0059279976,
-0.0321472026,
0.0256085433,
0.0258548502,
-0.0344295576,
0.0022984706,
0.0456336923,
-0.0341165699,
-0.0127590476,
0.0494370535,
-0.0019844472,
-0.0164776016,
0.0288099628,
0.0420020483,
-0.0474961735,
-0.0520799682,
0.0731131807,
-0.0556320585,
0.0291797332,
-0.0292822402,
-0.0257557277,
0.0331464186,
-0.010669197,
0.0407308936,
-0.0393411741,
-0.0336855352,
-0.062973544,
0.0052592633,
-0.0101668276,
-5.313271935e-33,
0.0232293122,
0.0094127227,
-0.0867193267,
0.0607449226,
-0.0609966293,
-0.0013129568,
-0.0305304453,
0.034116108,
-0.0067115496,
0.0288038049,
-0.0298528727,
0.019431565,
-0.0007600489,
-0.0288717058,
0.053943634,
-0.028193105,
0.029025659,
0.0000677464,
-0.0314427204,
0.021585362,
0.0561766513,
0.057113938,
0.0647517666,
-0.1347763687,
0.0186045151,
-0.0232796315,
-0.0023695459,
0.0032832304,
0.0420089774,
0.0259761047,
-0.0301419236,
0.057619568,
0.0127844932,
0.0151366964,
0.0044847354,
0.005619159,
-0.0258083977,
0.0137489848,
-0.0201944262,
0.0959126055,
0.0002806157,
0.0004543103,
0.0401712097,
0.01083529,
-0.0369098037,
-0.0087605966,
0.0280498359,
-0.0259171445,
-0.0084136389,
-0.1142363101,
-0.0275907051,
0.0017954366,
-0.0230377279,
-0.0558277145,
0.0599381067,
0.0587000884,
0.0183862634,
0.0425696932,
-0.0407020561,
-0.0231107175,
-0.0311066993,
0.003108649,
0.0129001858,
0.0028026607,
-0.0190800652,
0.0389994904,
0.0311920345,
-0.0730478987,
-0.0001160856,
0.042493362,
0.0106277857,
0.0379414409,
-0.0066614691,
-0.0500325635,
0.0658353716,
-0.0534504503,
0.0249054823,
0.0494426191,
0.0368272327,
-0.0009827557,
0.0604896173,
0.0490093529,
-0.0552865677,
-0.0047164503,
0.0364914946,
-0.0602419786,
-0.0492654145,
-0.0425812565,
0.0287457295,
-0.0515868887,
-0.0052278787,
0.026884703,
-0.0183169581,
-0.0279654246,
-0.0124547575,
0.0051647034,
-0.0439142995,
0.0718199611,
0.0015994284,
-0.0251280628,
0.0187812019,
-0.0018339482,
0.0295042247,
0.0247092564,
0.0578193814,
-0.0315229744,
0.015017136,
0.0583566613,
-0.0738380775,
-0.0107945409,
0.0141174132,
0.0021632779,
0.0246951655,
0.0335740782,
0.0022942401,
0.0140515864,
-0.0063846735,
-0.0059765559,
0.0124415839,
0.0907131955,
0.0040231072,
-0.0296138283,
-0.0332290381,
0.0016791793,
0.0239109322,
0.002077481,
0.0002977206,
-0.0527280681,
-0.0334200747,
-0.0084486119,
0.0064146365,
-0.0086251404,
2.692e-7,
-0.0305783655,
0.0186218489,
-0.0070389044,
-0.0928539336,
0.0103188688,
0.072383441,
-0.1230089143,
-0.0321908221,
0.0135079147,
-0.0048050093,
0.0458153263,
-0.0396518447,
0.0989678353,
0.0406968407,
-0.1144246683,
0.0002441488,
-0.0430765152,
-0.0133875348,
-0.0564874932,
-0.0042626536,
0.0303559992,
0.0675366819,
0.0600423887,
-0.0116193201,
-0.0002488222,
0.0432637855,
-0.0064304508,
-0.0432572998,
0.0270901397,
-0.016312331,
-0.0119059393,
-0.0146499146,
-0.0175176356,
-0.0225458574,
-0.0257485844,
0.0272285733,
0.0534021109,
0.0061887191,
0.0291445479,
-0.0057712947,
0.0155595252,
0.0668863803,
0.0055789053,
0.0049885088,
-0.0111495825,
0.0371293463,
-0.0854373127,
-0.0413106717,
-0.0269075315,
-0.0099927094,
0.0594680533,
-0.0146273319,
-0.0234418157,
-0.0331892781,
-0.0061543332,
-0.0649381727,
-0.0159426164,
-0.028572049,
0.0161636341,
0.0454725362,
0.0100684175,
-0.0118632792,
-0.0157823469,
0.0893275663,
0.025366785,
-0.01746599,
0.0125923585,
1.938859464e-34,
0.0468355939,
-0.0621576011,
-0.0124934744,
0.036335256,
0.0138937244,
0.0082996311,
-0.0154662719,
0.0015102251,
0.0129606891,
-0.0511684828,
0.014769977
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.09325v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09325v1 | Can Generative Pre-trained Transformers (GPT) Pass Assessments in Higher Education Programming Courses? | 2023-03-16T13:58:45 | 2023-03-16T13:58:45 | Jaromir Savelka, Arav Agarwal, Christopher Bogart, Yifan Song, Majd Sakr | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | We evaluated the capability of generative pre-trained transformers (GPT), to
pass assessments in introductory and intermediate Python programming courses at
the postsecondary level. Discussions of potential uses (e.g., exercise
generation, code explanation) and misuses (e.g., cheating) of this emerging
technology in programming education have intensified, but to date there has not
been a rigorous analysis of the models' capabilities in the realistic context
of a full-fledged programming course with diverse set of assessment
instruments. We evaluated GPT on three Python courses that employ assessments
ranging from simple multiple-choice questions (no code involved) to complex
programming projects with code bases distributed into multiple files (599
exercises overall). Further, we studied if and how successfully GPT models
leverage feedback provided by an auto-grader. We found that the current models
are not capable of passing the full spectrum of assessments typically involved
in a Python programming course (<70% on even entry-level modules). Yet, it is
clear that a straightforward application of these easily accessible models
could enable a learner to obtain a non-trivial portion of the overall available
score (>55%) in introductory and intermediate courses alike. While the models
exhibit remarkable capabilities, including correcting solutions based on
auto-grader's feedback, some limitations exist (e.g., poor handling of
exercises requiring complex chains of reasoning steps). These findings can be
leveraged by instructors wishing to adapt their assessments so that GPT becomes
a valuable assistant for a learner as opposed to an end-to-end solution. | [
0.0070799543,
0.0274660867,
-0.0534737185,
-0.013494974,
-0.0111333923,
0.0133738387,
0.0256280079,
-0.0391559042,
0.0107515091,
-0.0420987532,
0.0096268393,
0.0566508137,
-0.0466011912,
0.0222265124,
0.0252480116,
-0.0713422969,
0.0163805299,
-0.0306437649,
-0.0417471826,
0.0222046562,
-0.0047626914,
0.0107717458,
-0.0448157564,
0.0670408085,
-0.0048586177,
-0.0352539383,
-0.0158374384,
-0.0371643528,
-0.0074729649,
-0.0198850054,
0.0113169281,
0.0484604836,
0.0279500205,
0.0217043199,
0.0000021736,
-0.0283461921,
-0.0176449679,
-0.0031931675,
-0.0344552435,
0.0379938297,
0.0069984929,
0.0833904073,
0.0105433827,
0.0267246701,
-0.0692998692,
-0.028015906,
0.0251283627,
-0.0274229236,
0.0998529345,
0.0352561548,
0.0235854089,
-0.0051123961,
0.016109651,
0.0210300907,
0.0280169267,
-0.0198114775,
0.0117137292,
0.0555338226,
0.0102281542,
0.0060943258,
-0.0503162928,
-0.0231192484,
0.0419151299,
-0.0077419458,
0.0373968817,
0.0261505116,
-0.0444847345,
-0.006542787,
-0.0095854672,
0.0226390902,
-0.0435647592,
-0.045983877,
-0.0294077061,
-0.0380413905,
0.0144947516,
0.0223180633,
-0.0452680476,
0.0217046421,
-0.0250970479,
-0.0188267641,
-0.0133410227,
-0.0349668264,
-0.0317130946,
-0.0219707321,
-0.0147864344,
0.015156514,
0.0185558163,
-0.0222518425,
-0.0225891192,
0.070314914,
0.0045587569,
-0.0189335328,
0.0317293927,
0.0825540349,
-0.0167252421,
-0.0028067841,
-0.0241826531,
-0.028181348,
-0.0065158065,
0.046158623,
0.0338327102,
0.0469384342,
-0.007696677,
0.0047924789,
-0.0193879362,
0.1121884808,
-0.005734555,
0.0561599806,
-0.0202067327,
0.0334791504,
-0.0694139823,
-0.0167803764,
-0.0357473642,
0.0518308952,
0.0429648943,
0.0791765228,
-0.0504457466,
0.0343135633,
-0.0416866057,
0.009843844,
-0.0220186785,
0.0173291508,
-0.0156161459,
0.0394658968,
-0.0387804359,
0.0337548032,
0.0045705568,
-0.0284875054,
0.0026434343,
-0.0282639489,
-0.0026102664,
0.0057415841,
-0.0005954442,
-0.0167135764,
0.0315949582,
0.0608439371,
-0.0094580725,
0.0035439462,
-0.0024882022,
-0.0343808904,
0.0300915614,
-0.0121200848,
0.0037581178,
-0.0743630081,
-0.0490803085,
0.0296335816,
-0.0011940108,
-0.0009579107,
-0.0053306501,
0.0313586891,
0.03306197,
0.0378423035,
0.0297548193,
0.0109696165,
0.0091714971,
0.004998792,
-0.0346651636,
-0.0300525427,
0.0202206839,
-0.0035851959,
-0.0219886974,
-0.1033400372,
0.1046116501,
-0.0140402913,
-0.0146504082,
-0.0284713786,
0.0825407356,
0.0134579167,
0.0120431725,
-0.0198646784,
-0.0297977123,
0.011291055,
0.0100651756,
0.0566069148,
0.016292328,
0.0187115781,
0.0203692913,
0.0641830191,
0.0691912994,
0.0165017862,
0.0385318622,
0.0514977872,
-0.0491715483,
0.043384131,
-0.012521158,
0.0012592585,
-0.0252976492,
0.0661692843,
0.0137858763,
-0.1024988219,
0.0161073282,
0.0076774103,
-0.0202193614,
0.0411392823,
0.0609049238,
0.0027485597,
-0.0386980623,
0.0025165088,
-0.0005814888,
-0.0865532458,
0.0370162837,
-0.1050390974,
0.0153799793,
0.0410024561,
0.0760372281,
-0.0818720609,
-0.0533854887,
-0.0367848538,
-0.0228732247,
-0.0455730893,
0.0357464328,
-0.0273059178,
-0.0463037454,
-0.0275129434,
-0.0316867568,
-0.0252214652,
0.0051244791,
0.025002338,
0.0114907892,
-0.0234853029,
0.0202196259,
-0.0123076718,
-0.0273158643,
0.0320669115,
-0.0258325301,
-0.0743356049,
-0.0332847722,
0.0022647523,
0.0173654649,
0.0031515036,
-0.0065644099,
0.0019439007,
0.0283143781,
0.0267748386,
-0.0085151345,
-0.0534317717,
-0.0779256746,
0.0245950706,
0.0223430526,
-0.0718738213,
-0.0469837412,
0.0513448045,
-0.0141382217,
-0.0222970713,
0.0344049521,
-0.0228248332,
0.0141316252,
-0.0147988731,
0.038729962,
-0.0283801928,
-0.0088716829,
-0.0137984101,
0.0086954031,
0.0921531096,
0.0453447476,
0.0150737949,
0.0191805605,
0.0476730764,
0.0150150182,
-0.0486655869,
-0.0006982334,
-0.0322881639,
0.026025515,
0.0335061625,
0.0321082734,
-0.0535477772,
-0.0070988964,
-0.0195032246,
0.0033032384,
-0.000096585,
0.02528359,
0.027562758,
-0.0486685112,
-0.0104420986,
0.0051283818,
-0.0339344889,
-0.046501983,
-0.001421561,
-0.0157861132,
-0.0196625609,
-0.0038060301,
-0.0084694037,
-0.0284068398,
-0.0116049657,
-0.0678778887,
0.0173859913,
0.070413895,
0.0518888831,
-0.0298091657,
0.0482790619,
0.0160199124,
0.0041787992,
0.0050338525,
-0.0525725409,
0.0153557053,
-0.0289046913,
0.0876711234,
0.0502681732,
-0.0086217178,
0.0028183479,
0.0371757708,
-0.0257363692,
-0.0566535741,
0.0348554254,
-0.0188132692,
-0.0558217615,
-0.0026869948,
-0.0268863104,
-0.0108847441,
0.0302202161,
0.0414772294,
-0.0614495426,
-0.0349797904,
0.0539467111,
-0.0215541348,
0.0216885787,
-0.0080142533,
-0.0303356834,
0.0224400759,
-0.0030420106,
0.0170855895,
-0.0354069211,
0.1165174916,
-0.0033750208,
-0.0155880451,
-0.0212735943,
0.0177621767,
-0.0204420052,
0.0303859022,
0.0439571477,
-0.0298475139,
-0.0097084027,
-0.0145754116,
-0.0574410073,
0.0544444248,
0.0397834964,
-0.0392656624,
0.0237495657,
-0.0443379469,
-0.0472719744,
-0.0019186187,
-0.0200004838,
-0.0585444495,
0.0350458995,
0.0240917932,
-0.0119755017,
0.0138838049,
-0.0071205162,
0.0245505814,
-0.0122716418,
0.0247872099,
0.0019549537,
-0.0054784562,
-0.0354034901,
0.0065216469,
0.0048451847,
-0.0423185453,
-0.0284134392,
-0.0140512157,
-0.0359999835,
-0.0124327,
0.0188282933,
0.0563340262,
-0.0000821671,
-0.0191899259,
0.0235984791,
0.0155305974,
-0.0554547012,
0.0226312727,
0.0253908243,
0.0022057614,
-0.0784531161,
-0.0179754887,
0.0505713336,
0.0350393243,
-0.0119953929,
-0.0268070176,
-0.0002007639,
-0.02921593,
0.0355420113,
0.0504209958,
-0.0712016895,
0.0063838838,
-0.0298164543,
0.0413337015,
-0.0303065777,
-0.0342595354,
0.0194013081,
-0.0927700475,
0.0265503824,
0.0340822525,
0.0043684882,
-0.000930377,
-0.0061853644,
-0.0206995495,
-0.0437991135,
-0.0271640308,
-0.0001057879,
0.0038435694,
0.0626918599,
0.0592557304,
-0.0241243392,
0.0297329277,
0.0655721799,
0.0284683071,
-0.0009149482,
0.0798361227,
-0.0103715267,
-0.0174073391,
-0.0408231951,
0.0197005924,
-0.0524373092,
0.0216951706,
0.0117596164,
0.0473490693,
-0.0070355507,
-0.0096187089,
-0.0079322038,
0.0125211794,
-0.0200662501,
-0.0114118578,
0.0511121489,
0.0982345343,
-0.0088706333,
-0.0327572599,
-0.0391257964,
-0.0402603336,
0.0054191626,
0.0104824724,
0.0400745086,
-0.0199998859,
-0.0152096618,
-0.0745042413,
0.0123610189,
-0.0427999534,
-0.0710348114,
0.0126468213,
0.0247469563,
0.0028380719,
0.0081928726,
-0.0460069254,
0.0790556371,
0.0011734208,
0.019865701,
-0.0486183837,
0.0370585322,
0.0304447003,
-0.0593079738,
0.0067305407,
0.0039080256,
-0.0120413275,
-0.0550478771,
-0.0729132295,
0.0191543773,
-0.0528831892,
-0.0496336594,
0.0022409288,
-0.0550062843,
-0.0270718317,
0.0392093435,
0.0943432897,
0.0185856279,
-0.0136960372,
0.0054421197,
0.0016279208,
0.0128072612,
-0.0055574775,
-0.0087558059,
0.0060216924,
-0.0017783818,
-0.0196999814,
-0.0048186234,
-0.0548041314,
-0.0186659638,
0.0264032651,
0.008501986,
0.0187505502,
-0.0075208726,
-0.013226009,
0.0513106287,
0.0636675805,
0.0453468226,
0.0325549766,
-0.0026203112,
-0.0292110723,
0.0188486353,
0.0195311513,
-0.0050505027,
-0.0193636883,
-0.0333712772,
0.0227774177,
-0.0010932523,
0.0119471308,
0.0373102725,
-0.0469276719,
0.0524281338,
-0.007355825,
0.050193768,
0.0291840099,
0.0202776566,
0.0411223806,
-0.0176804401,
-0.0054315324,
-0.0485180281,
0.0447731242,
0.0564670712,
0.0084853433,
0.0852281153,
-0.0222955626,
0.0625482276,
0.0536295399,
0.0078277085,
-0.0622871108,
-0.0274588782,
-0.0286368653,
0.0287148282,
0.0008459325,
0.0512196943,
-0.0161882453,
-0.0285831932,
0.0224674996,
0.0055255764,
0.0510447584,
-0.0048284503,
-0.0363338441,
-0.0045205783,
0.0333976969,
0.0438206792,
-0.0132942321,
0.0396441109,
-0.0488602221,
0.030396048,
-0.0126792202,
-0.020130109,
-0.0379584655,
-0.0053854277,
-0.0150285903,
-0.024332568,
0.0298179723,
-0.0007874467,
-0.0342931449,
-0.0730298683,
-0.0237391237,
0.0589153692,
0.0369664542,
-0.0478529334,
0.018479811,
0.0643156022,
-0.0621299706,
-0.0177801251,
0.014153339,
0.0362721421,
0.003256656,
-0.0263333991,
-0.0103186555,
-5.423937014e-33,
-0.0360253155,
-0.041992344,
0.0614825711,
0.0539713725,
0.0193073433,
-0.0059390534,
-0.0196108203,
0.0233409964,
-0.0234842524,
-0.0274196137,
0.0028562041,
0.0151038868,
-0.0100993728,
0.0015029516,
0.0443180539,
0.0179904699,
0.0442525186,
0.0196854752,
-0.0188576505,
0.0713865608,
-0.0278552547,
-0.0001104539,
0.0706353188,
-0.0527909398,
-0.0095262425,
-0.0347332582,
0.0092032701,
-0.046862945,
-0.0792177394,
0.0316119529,
0.000105048,
0.0308257993,
0.0028919675,
-0.0416812077,
-0.0225500241,
-0.0161035694,
-0.043269027,
-0.0646786168,
-0.0479275212,
0.0186838992,
0.0141349351,
-0.0474878885,
0.0442700163,
-0.0054764552,
-0.0435746126,
-0.0102896895,
0.0727526546,
0.0172436927,
0.0553699285,
-0.0201351102,
-0.0512295552,
-0.0205314923,
-0.0652127042,
-0.0350640938,
-0.0375810266,
0.0379543453,
0.002773325,
0.0206669681,
0.0021226902,
0.0631743744,
0.0872365907,
0.0272129644,
0.0803583786,
-0.0243651848,
-0.0236857478,
-0.0083642574,
0.045741003,
-0.0120249847,
-0.0113692209,
-0.0283305552,
0.0279633999,
0.0064458996,
0.0670899972,
0.0458267219,
0.0535883717,
0.0131476028,
-0.0417750031,
0.0495742038,
-0.0071555506,
-0.0003527583,
-0.0206939187,
-0.0393512957,
-0.0415033773,
0.0003116814,
-0.0292075779,
-0.0072069988,
-0.0129519245,
-0.0442209356,
0.0504936762,
-0.0348574817,
0.0053363587,
0.024107933,
0.0018547548,
-0.0434316844,
-0.0012142491,
-0.0311556272,
-0.0451878607,
0.0508983508,
-0.03797343,
0.0194102656,
0.0037735584,
-0.0001925561,
0.033229351,
-0.0197292957,
0.0687238127,
-0.0009028741,
0.0025312824,
0.0387120135,
-0.03663994,
-0.0193689764,
-0.0636335984,
-0.0033792374,
0.0277384464,
0.0161310285,
0.0040253992,
0.0459204838,
-0.0223835148,
0.0060806326,
-0.0216714293,
-0.0375250019,
-0.0683698207,
0.0145673882,
-0.0069250483,
-0.0135573177,
-0.0191815365,
-0.0420745946,
-0.0494039841,
-0.0013949551,
-0.0264351871,
-0.0471391529,
-0.0238841511,
0.0242278911,
2.723e-7,
0.0303876083,
0.0249059089,
0.0344649032,
-0.0000523564,
-0.0369671211,
0.0171696618,
-0.0264785811,
-0.0132451979,
0.0775981992,
0.026296353,
0.0024284453,
0.0170996077,
-0.0042934096,
0.0360889547,
-0.0205355175,
-0.0277314968,
0.0344556905,
-0.0265635476,
-0.0497822538,
0.0393967032,
0.1052784175,
0.0165302027,
0.0337856188,
0.003794085,
0.0204658397,
-0.0303897671,
-0.0021126345,
0.0418717377,
0.0140657406,
0.0391701125,
-0.0462051891,
-0.0023658078,
0.001540051,
0.048449561,
-0.0026019441,
-0.0447904728,
-0.0047134478,
0.011639243,
0.0000051826,
-0.0262344629,
0.0073894924,
-0.0016413557,
0.0081111742,
-0.0385125428,
0.0018094234,
-0.0540659912,
0.0233583879,
0.0585410409,
-0.0674516037,
-0.029746158,
-0.0133658256,
-0.0115077617,
0.0175819304,
0.0038225024,
-0.0192042328,
-0.0033407561,
0.0001190511,
-0.0178378914,
-0.0075713154,
-0.0216709059,
-0.0230772477,
-0.0405786969,
-0.0287182312,
-0.0548523404,
0.0256347097,
-0.0246887021,
0.0011116371,
2.427977612e-34,
0.0111708194,
-0.0251731277,
0.0695971921,
-0.0101732565,
-0.0002514941,
0.0224749465,
0.0280305631,
-0.0034434616,
0.0147637324,
0.0047007818,
-0.0665963888
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.09306v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09306v2 | BanglaCoNER: Towards Robust Bangla Complex Named Entity Recognition | 2023-03-16T13:31:31 | 2023-03-17T15:13:01 | HAZ Sameen Shahgir, Ramisa Alam, Md. Zarif Ul Alam | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Named Entity Recognition (NER) is a fundamental task in natural language
processing that involves identifying and classifying named entities in text.
But much work hasn't been done for complex named entity recognition in Bangla,
despite being the seventh most spoken language globally. CNER is a more
challenging task than traditional NER as it involves identifying and
classifying complex and compound entities, which are not common in Bangla
language. In this paper, we present the winning solution of Bangla Complex
Named Entity Recognition Challenge - addressing the CNER task on BanglaCoNER
dataset using two different approaches, namely Conditional Random Fields (CRF)
and finetuning transformer based Deep Learning models such as BanglaBERT.
The dataset consisted of 15300 sentences for training and 800 sentences for
validation, in the .conll format. Exploratory Data Analysis (EDA) on the
dataset revealed that the dataset had 7 different NER tags, with notable
presence of English words, suggesting that the dataset is synthetic and likely
a product of translation.
We experimented with a variety of feature combinations including Part of
Speech (POS) tags, word suffixes, Gazetteers, and cluster information from
embeddings, while also finetuning the BanglaBERT (large) model for NER. We
found that not all linguistic patterns are immediately apparent or even
intuitive to humans, which is why Deep Learning based models has proved to be
the more effective model in NLP, including CNER task. Our fine tuned BanglaBERT
(large) model achieves an F1 Score of 0.79 on the validation set. Overall, our
study highlights the importance of Bangla Complex Named Entity Recognition,
particularly in the context of synthetic datasets. Our findings also
demonstrate the efficacy of Deep Learning models such as BanglaBERT for NER in
Bangla language. | [
0.0307306163,
-0.0010851638,
0.0202657953,
0.0332823582,
-0.0144800823,
0.0449670851,
-0.0020603011,
-0.0046447082,
0.0286381096,
-0.0094738519,
-0.0038114244,
-0.0664551482,
0.0097010061,
0.0126873301,
-0.0003876991,
-0.0741776451,
0.0243059751,
-0.0071509057,
0.0590478964,
0.0286233276,
-0.0078772092,
0.015328723,
-0.010729963,
-0.0191269629,
-0.0340591669,
0.0060557947,
-0.0016643697,
-0.0150026968,
0.0421784222,
-0.0516501963,
-0.00896875,
0.0631948337,
-0.0379429311,
0.0300890021,
0.0000019163,
-0.0814944357,
-0.0591618754,
0.0079454202,
-0.0416897982,
-0.0329064876,
0.0091186976,
0.0029948363,
-0.0512055121,
-0.0068789781,
-0.0166516136,
-0.0347904935,
0.0569409877,
0.1155629605,
-0.0227396861,
0.096816197,
-0.0026855632,
-0.0741333142,
0.0517487228,
0.0112658357,
-0.0075561544,
-0.0435758382,
0.0131159471,
-0.021669548,
0.0069516329,
0.0110994419,
-0.0100675076,
0.0027083303,
0.0131361745,
-0.0003277881,
0.0172084607,
0.0060958513,
-0.0261181425,
-0.023846956,
0.0275687203,
0.0759802088,
-0.0665710792,
-0.0102320397,
0.0310226474,
-0.0222637486,
-0.0154892057,
-0.0646221787,
-0.0237874798,
0.0327423923,
-0.0489647351,
0.0155177955,
0.0278581902,
0.0255346764,
0.0442469381,
-0.0028802576,
-0.0193452928,
0.0055290954,
0.0003768985,
-0.0341804139,
0.0046561607,
-0.0048549883,
-0.0061275596,
-0.0080343653,
0.0083265342,
-0.0049229856,
0.0109696593,
0.0185802206,
-0.0231335126,
-0.0398376435,
0.0056948322,
-0.0191033538,
-0.0268421117,
-0.0017184849,
-0.0200939327,
0.0393806025,
-0.0672544613,
-0.0008247484,
-0.0231794007,
0.0268003102,
0.0499502383,
-0.0387480035,
-0.0632682666,
-0.0174301844,
-0.0035263554,
0.0507498197,
-0.0369611867,
0.0141517688,
-0.0632406771,
-0.0046038786,
-0.0419537388,
0.0172133017,
0.0089927539,
0.0174076613,
0.0172367189,
-0.0270893462,
-0.0053122416,
0.0123102041,
-0.028966371,
0.0032848984,
0.006516431,
-0.1014342234,
0.0295133889,
-0.0118236374,
0.0367463045,
-0.0327094011,
0.0166034568,
0.0427596495,
0.0205992665,
-0.1008534506,
-0.1007748544,
0.0084902523,
-0.0074593504,
-0.0518077649,
-0.0061837365,
-0.060470324,
0.0416325592,
-0.0110681606,
0.02545527,
-0.0274605099,
0.0199996848,
-0.0002746852,
0.0003253899,
0.1121799275,
-0.025481496,
-0.0323141441,
0.0395797454,
0.0176998209,
0.0715846717,
0.0326723866,
0.0140309259,
0.0162367839,
0.0454596765,
-0.0137619385,
0.0184055697,
0.0335829444,
-0.0353898741,
-0.04356011,
0.0189389102,
-0.0100323474,
0.0004729589,
9.759e-7,
0.0020020232,
0.023422258,
0.0316084288,
0.0121081593,
0.0247095861,
0.0288665369,
0.0283032898,
0.0364090465,
-0.0063567953,
0.0076121958,
0.0157892033,
-0.00431555,
-0.0294313096,
-0.0003694949,
-0.0364727005,
-0.0026379679,
0.0194072314,
0.0528607629,
-0.0147400517,
0.0167828351,
-0.0119120628,
-0.0278471112,
-0.0121747488,
-0.0216240156,
0.0845972672,
0.015991684,
-0.0430588871,
0.0263436791,
0.0484188311,
-0.016772734,
0.0060382104,
-0.0078558875,
0.0159891937,
0.0248754732,
0.024330914,
-0.0292429104,
-0.0153984455,
-0.0272939652,
-0.0158018824,
0.0389607996,
0.0216539148,
-0.0001423893,
0.0373594053,
-0.0321251713,
0.0275385249,
0.0611515827,
-0.006987249,
0.0136514995,
0.0162777361,
0.0435942449,
0.0022017525,
-0.0004662368,
-0.0307799336,
0.0434379429,
-0.0010349391,
-0.0238639135,
0.0307410322,
0.0417169519,
0.034394823,
0.051072754,
0.008934007,
-0.0359959267,
0.0184817426,
-0.0139841121,
-0.0238997694,
-0.0117215198,
0.0015814275,
-0.0436589532,
-0.0095848665,
-0.0472498611,
-0.0068982299,
-0.0035033533,
-0.0172732249,
-0.0612257831,
-0.0171275567,
0.0156018091,
0.017580837,
-0.0257660709,
0.0485367961,
-0.0113783795,
0.0517719798,
-0.0247763004,
0.0533316061,
-0.0106457062,
0.0067298752,
0.0346532837,
0.0053959908,
0.019682534,
-0.0532803386,
-0.0330630243,
0.0455695502,
-0.0267835166,
-0.0277632289,
-0.0210462771,
0.0211550258,
-0.0545648485,
-0.0088812551,
-0.0825790763,
-0.0102746533,
-0.0156995635,
0.0180673022,
0.0011496734,
0.0586212873,
-0.0293405242,
-0.0028145236,
0.0056447866,
-0.0086687868,
0.0306130666,
-0.0209287498,
0.0272514429,
-0.0206350368,
-0.028066542,
-0.0008366712,
-0.0004859858,
-0.0354421623,
0.0241772141,
0.0423449539,
-0.0492327847,
-0.0129504539,
-0.0198560655,
0.0327428579,
0.0074399873,
0.0091897454,
0.0248213168,
-0.0265240874,
-0.0105756335,
-0.0123859849,
0.0592410974,
-0.0010919695,
0.0034902967,
-0.0479206406,
-0.0003691927,
-0.0166910589,
0.0195420608,
-0.0351940207,
0.0650795624,
-0.0181883611,
-0.0298063941,
0.0064989962,
0.0617368035,
-0.0226791948,
0.0524342321,
-0.0300270375,
-0.0239175111,
0.0059351763,
-0.0504081361,
-0.0193777177,
0.0530882142,
-0.0493091606,
0.0374057144,
-0.0114687663,
-0.0154750096,
0.0495526865,
-0.0459447913,
-0.0129927741,
-0.0289299265,
0.0247041751,
-0.0080688465,
0.0165790245,
0.0124739343,
-0.0013054436,
0.031804841,
-0.0690718517,
-0.0088250684,
0.0632043034,
-0.0063444492,
-0.0202715266,
-0.0346048325,
-0.0115203224,
-0.0022428562,
-0.0245340075,
-0.0029153004,
-0.0330840461,
-0.0244731512,
-0.0128509123,
0.0281518605,
0.0440222882,
-0.0197544601,
0.011625329,
0.0643002912,
-0.0147465682,
0.0025208315,
0.0014223817,
0.00820293,
-0.0154048046,
0.0691451132,
0.0295476876,
0.0140368249,
0.0799209028,
-0.0029407598,
-0.0346599519,
-0.0329189673,
0.0176312346,
-0.012933325,
-0.0119253127,
-0.0370727926,
-0.0094120651,
-0.0683146268,
0.0116969803,
-0.0101802293,
0.0035976511,
-0.0271058381,
-0.013826861,
0.1050187722,
0.0056232894,
-0.0013497263,
-0.0300335698,
-0.0265351254,
-0.0046327715,
-0.0281800553,
0.0064953961,
-0.0739329085,
-0.0429936349,
0.0317128152,
-0.0361911729,
0.0234090816,
-0.0574026331,
0.0238498505,
-0.1321630627,
0.004558478,
-0.0460313372,
-0.0286564846,
-0.0327949002,
-0.047863733,
-0.0187065005,
-0.0289246421,
0.0243698973,
-0.0202955846,
-0.051926747,
-0.0299829058,
0.0305231512,
-0.0265747756,
-0.0555372946,
0.0261892658,
-0.079091996,
0.0531328321,
0.0367917977,
-0.005312433,
-0.0532385856,
0.0408572778,
-0.0199648179,
-0.0150694866,
-0.0418573469,
-0.004935896,
0.0045206537,
-0.01709182,
-0.0307692215,
-0.0008428279,
0.0056797997,
-0.0162265133,
0.008910805,
-0.0136932116,
0.0720298365,
0.0021711772,
-0.0108860834,
-0.0246474296,
-0.0281713419,
0.0088550085,
0.0465469174,
0.0183304902,
-0.0304721314,
-0.0336049832,
0.024466835,
-0.001426802,
-0.0348650813,
-0.004114246,
0.0489966124,
-0.0480155237,
-0.0515330806,
-0.0184449833,
-0.0865389332,
0.0492870212,
0.0373342969,
0.0073214276,
0.0040345495,
0.0361881927,
0.0147023825,
-0.0502511598,
0.0393166207,
-0.0488824919,
0.0290801525,
-0.0886717364,
0.0311035831,
0.0013935438,
0.002723028,
-0.0342851803,
-0.0176143404,
-0.0603454597,
-0.0353631228,
0.0245001763,
0.0038630352,
0.0124133667,
0.0205314122,
-0.0443692058,
-0.048316054,
0.0198083427,
0.0266537853,
-0.0521044061,
-0.0267332867,
0.0190763623,
-0.0030208554,
-0.0026526209,
0.022037752,
-0.0073799207,
0.0125543391,
0.0047310097,
0.0195585638,
-0.0046018795,
-0.0190594755,
-0.0268434901,
0.0072776829,
0.0625425354,
-0.0362485908,
-0.0631848872,
-0.0574626923,
0.0116751464,
0.0595028363,
0.0019200942,
0.0157668348,
-0.0432723016,
0.0355551057,
0.0499155037,
0.0079987422,
0.0554009452,
0.0039926665,
-0.0026704029,
0.0229382291,
0.056856256,
0.0383101106,
0.0361421295,
-0.0099139987,
-0.0111266254,
0.0424624197,
0.0436636433,
0.0481100492,
0.0510442406,
-0.0227250252,
0.0000268954,
-0.0163786393,
0.0176506974,
-0.0264159441,
0.0346921235,
0.0362599343,
0.0424177647,
-0.042241998,
0.0343335122,
0.0715109408,
-0.0431526788,
0.0339916907,
-0.0034707985,
0.0147351781,
-0.0400235504,
-0.0039821309,
-0.0557993688,
0.0197815746,
0.0406279452,
0.0106852688,
-0.0237772539,
0.0194698218,
0.0199272707,
0.0170920957,
-0.0163567811,
0.0351164006,
0.0013964076,
-0.0434898064,
-0.0261268318,
0.0295161046,
0.0266250987,
-0.0158837624,
0.0099848332,
-0.0391743407,
-0.0393735841,
0.0475681834,
-0.0410748497,
-0.0080112237,
0.0350213349,
0.0255294181,
0.0113897687,
0.0252796896,
0.0251343437,
-0.0223889966,
-0.0006296441,
0.0418507308,
-0.0173842907,
-0.000885369,
-5.868939502e-33,
-0.0085839648,
-0.0322353616,
-0.0013340957,
-0.0521757007,
0.000666733,
0.0130450474,
-0.0225637443,
0.0159337316,
-0.0424625538,
-0.016075803,
-0.0482681282,
-0.0197856929,
0.0536890104,
0.0459601618,
0.0261575561,
-0.0576240532,
0.0268469341,
0.0535676628,
-0.0055908817,
-0.0013544778,
0.0441098809,
0.0827549472,
0.0878566206,
-0.0483004414,
0.0288423486,
-0.0106288139,
-0.0125040077,
-0.0113011887,
0.0514932089,
0.0730408803,
-0.0459946059,
-0.0025687618,
0.0256056227,
-0.0551859774,
0.0089338114,
0.0545537733,
-0.1527650952,
0.0276305862,
-0.0092602298,
0.0816307366,
-0.0224620812,
-0.0287633613,
0.0563060082,
0.002252507,
0.0024498347,
0.0318833031,
0.0394260623,
-0.0065520289,
0.0007351552,
0.0057026916,
-0.0925594419,
0.0668242574,
0.0075970362,
0.0679352358,
0.0418679751,
-0.0181546379,
-0.0071265139,
0.0137856631,
-0.0683048517,
-0.0227209572,
0.0505958982,
0.0070050792,
0.0582299866,
0.0456386283,
-0.03821126,
0.0145171601,
0.0659412518,
-0.0567971468,
-0.0098785851,
0.008908825,
0.0461111553,
0.0315773301,
0.0061344523,
0.0995877087,
0.0603770018,
-0.0499325208,
-0.0520686358,
0.0290445443,
0.0229454804,
0.0308004338,
-0.0186842531,
-0.0349258967,
-0.0952264816,
0.0063785752,
0.0134786433,
-0.0038371305,
-0.0426077992,
0.0029782194,
0.0497641601,
-0.0117379548,
-0.0500106178,
0.0505917668,
0.0363554209,
-0.0382544808,
-0.0077952673,
-0.0143830404,
0.0316486917,
0.0569567829,
0.0044662552,
0.0267608259,
-0.0639824197,
-0.0603512339,
-0.002571577,
0.0009214986,
-0.0099087814,
0.005506915,
0.0673119649,
-0.0328280628,
-0.0695611313,
0.0163422711,
-0.0022838903,
0.0191278886,
-0.021093199,
0.080210045,
0.0040021376,
-0.024842903,
-0.0055008121,
-0.0020170952,
0.0586815812,
0.0483120084,
0.0111931553,
-0.0105179818,
-0.002085055,
-0.0106158368,
-0.0037549681,
-0.0120376367,
-0.0182816517,
-0.0098384256,
0.0117296288,
-0.0513414517,
0.0242057666,
-0.0070138522,
2.599e-7,
0.0085358238,
0.0238490887,
0.0547223948,
-0.0436064713,
-0.0327099375,
0.0286486112,
0.0270054135,
0.0224764682,
-0.0803159326,
0.0218117945,
0.0220457055,
-0.0357539207,
0.0116668595,
0.0140696913,
-0.1305368841,
-0.0040517859,
-0.0445634313,
-0.016202908,
-0.0583803728,
-0.0143946428,
-0.0273594763,
0.1262031049,
0.0211152863,
-0.0566934943,
-0.016315667,
0.0064580683,
0.0169995427,
0.0000382119,
0.0351972617,
0.0188842826,
0.0117478538,
0.0966308713,
-0.0146943284,
0.0160414409,
-0.003625602,
0.030626798,
0.0171979647,
0.0508751497,
-0.0071935412,
0.0211910401,
0.0233370233,
-0.0393600352,
0.007455898,
-0.0364733003,
0.0873193294,
-0.0127382036,
-0.0332465135,
0.0101359095,
-0.0497439615,
-0.0135111893,
0.0187927149,
0.0065559782,
-0.0107114436,
0.0164438207,
0.0375353023,
-0.056691993,
-0.0408515632,
-0.0501936302,
0.0350645967,
0.0156379472,
-0.0211804211,
0.0267230868,
-0.0148923127,
-0.0059939022,
0.047372669,
-0.0403482057,
0.0265729632,
2.424069553e-34,
0.0083831949,
0.0371070467,
-0.0133814169,
0.0160085186,
0.0000396709,
0.0031526913,
-0.0253132042,
-0.0071565192,
-0.0073001711,
-0.0596385263,
0.0115093384
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.09266v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09266v2 | SmartBERT: A Promotion of Dynamic Early Exiting Mechanism for Accelerating BERT Inference | 2023-03-16T12:44:16 | 2023-05-08T13:05:00 | Boren Hu, Yun Zhu, Jiacheng Li, Siliang Tang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Dynamic early exiting has been proven to improve the inference speed of the
pre-trained language model like BERT. However, all samples must go through all
consecutive layers before early exiting and more complex samples usually go
through more layers, which still exists redundant computation. In this paper,
we propose a novel dynamic early exiting combined with layer skipping for BERT
inference named SmartBERT, which adds a skipping gate and an exiting operator
into each layer of BERT. SmartBERT can adaptively skip some layers and
adaptively choose whether to exit. Besides, we propose cross-layer contrastive
learning and combine it into our training phases to boost the intermediate
layers and classifiers which would be beneficial for early exiting. To keep the
consistent usage of skipping gates between training and inference phases, we
propose a hard weight mechanism during training phase. We conduct experiments
on eight classification datasets of the GLUE benchmark. Experimental results
show that SmartBERT achieves 2-3x computation reduction with minimal accuracy
drops compared with BERT and our method outperforms previous methods in both
efficiency and accuracy. Moreover, in some complex datasets like RTE and WNLI,
we prove that the early exiting based on entropy hardly works, and the skipping
mechanism is essential for reducing computation. | [
0.0111205643,
0.0563328974,
0.0090439646,
0.0122818192,
-0.0268936157,
0.0252980292,
0.0145446854,
-0.0130404802,
0.0093788132,
-0.0091553451,
-0.0242038704,
-0.0240668617,
0.0108796926,
-0.016544966,
0.0332846232,
-0.0613610707,
0.037652351,
-0.0111997854,
0.0141745694,
-0.0318761989,
-0.0031516277,
0.0076128631,
-0.0110916533,
0.0330180489,
0.0377061069,
0.0191815551,
-0.0193574317,
0.0299286898,
0.0229730681,
-0.0296669416,
0.0373527929,
0.0621488355,
0.0026679258,
0.0420442298,
0.000002121,
-0.0403382406,
-0.019753864,
0.0166408774,
-0.0122026177,
0.0434866473,
-0.0295364447,
0.0203249622,
-0.0181180537,
0.0483345762,
0.0001683859,
-0.0487979352,
0.0697874725,
0.0262414459,
0.0154706892,
0.0539170466,
-0.0143893529,
-0.0441080518,
0.0171310417,
-0.0157036539,
-0.0125524867,
-0.0240323655,
0.0331173949,
-0.0831927955,
-0.0005759745,
-0.0903348625,
-0.0087837577,
0.0265019983,
0.0513600856,
0.0421834029,
-0.0467327014,
0.0753665417,
-0.0330947228,
-0.0105109941,
-0.0223356318,
0.0819185376,
-0.0482954383,
-0.0200745668,
0.0315944962,
-0.020554876,
-0.0185645036,
-0.0190700125,
0.00046177,
-0.003200151,
-0.0108796423,
0.0424638279,
0.0308088977,
0.0060968148,
0.0124908471,
0.0177384578,
-0.0327171907,
0.0043506408,
0.0480922051,
-0.0132269105,
0.0063340128,
0.0176297501,
-0.0280579086,
-0.0313651301,
0.0097969994,
-0.004631428,
0.0181471184,
0.0070908652,
-0.0491404906,
-0.0324114263,
-0.0143454662,
-0.0763956681,
0.0093051866,
0.0591824651,
-0.0384870768,
0.0375760458,
-0.0435346365,
-0.0178234447,
-0.0314436406,
0.0220825542,
-0.0188072361,
-0.017234344,
0.0190796833,
0.0199504979,
-0.0619332828,
0.0442164578,
0.0041103694,
-0.0307815634,
-0.056056045,
0.0044682999,
0.0144528681,
-0.0353967436,
0.0224142335,
0.0021115982,
-0.0057667764,
0.0074666743,
0.0093063954,
0.0253320578,
-0.050477609,
0.0196673125,
-0.0443800762,
-0.0365064666,
-0.0102434671,
0.0323699266,
0.0431837253,
-0.0298137516,
0.0517406128,
0.0312196314,
0.0114835817,
-0.0500385053,
-0.1110235527,
0.0393509082,
0.0119536407,
-0.0537359715,
0.0114483852,
-0.0528918952,
0.0243350156,
-0.0056799594,
-0.0293956306,
0.0096737202,
-0.013958266,
0.0112975808,
-0.0168076418,
0.0481167659,
-0.0724166706,
-0.028992733,
0.0084474888,
-0.0152397193,
-0.0161168836,
0.0616847277,
0.0240756366,
-0.0071796165,
0.0065217596,
-0.0063996501,
-0.0327966101,
0.0726019666,
0.0502821021,
-0.0209750626,
-0.0754377544,
-0.026675975,
-0.0245105028,
-0.0240642801,
0.0292400662,
0.0473984629,
-0.0486539677,
-0.0096397456,
0.027805388,
0.0332070813,
0.0228898432,
0.0488430485,
0.0155462716,
0.0138675487,
0.0214566123,
0.0253128372,
-0.0400867239,
0.0167275649,
-0.0346461795,
-0.0022446455,
0.0519607216,
0.0326659828,
-0.0501989461,
-0.0037475245,
0.003684324,
-0.0192139819,
0.0286247265,
0.011741126,
0.0703174025,
0.0057589314,
-0.0428802557,
0.075721845,
0.0625967309,
-0.0395204909,
-0.0444418713,
-0.0878154486,
0.0044617369,
0.0672082007,
0.0163501482,
-0.0322278179,
-0.0506776832,
0.0478471406,
0.0158068035,
0.0249704365,
0.0231139921,
0.0197837502,
0.0525254123,
-0.0681229383,
-0.0418283083,
0.0424055643,
-0.0000725536,
0.0234982073,
0.0308975186,
0.0179392565,
-0.0101916827,
-0.042136047,
0.006163564,
0.0280750096,
-0.0068606958,
-0.013156252,
0.0335268825,
0.0371430144,
0.0146566834,
-0.0026349477,
-0.0363779105,
-0.0162683576,
0.0200560093,
-0.0192409027,
-0.0180808231,
0.0134569844,
-0.0367750339,
-0.0959594175,
0.0137829715,
-0.0271008853,
-0.0067762905,
0.0594839565,
-0.032046847,
-0.0273170508,
0.0224647131,
-0.0524701811,
0.1106285006,
-0.051104527,
0.0138357654,
-0.0095077259,
0.0079895677,
0.0170005728,
0.0980804563,
-0.0308357403,
0.0324122496,
0.0245501697,
0.0208797883,
0.0125485351,
0.0021786937,
-0.0540446602,
-0.0237552058,
-0.0169497281,
0.0027939458,
0.0214236546,
0.0108836442,
-0.0157778915,
-0.0087963603,
-0.05379612,
-0.0055836523,
-0.0225408357,
0.0455012731,
0.0142062707,
0.0239945352,
-0.0045287046,
-0.0387204811,
0.0080546457,
-0.0070790653,
-0.0611328073,
-0.0002600611,
-0.0066526406,
0.0267297383,
-0.0546974987,
-0.0016511014,
-0.0357599743,
-0.0045143329,
0.0570593067,
-0.0299716908,
-0.0239735208,
-0.001033462,
-0.0485562943,
-0.0043930081,
0.068279922,
0.0202705115,
-0.057702031,
-0.0020683538,
-0.0336441733,
0.005712165,
0.013970498,
0.0133844782,
0.0264463965,
-0.012760058,
-0.0019571218,
-0.0360847227,
0.026678931,
-0.0135048097,
0.0621636137,
0.0020198929,
-0.0204127654,
-0.0444443859,
0.0950579867,
-0.0040526143,
0.0290008374,
-0.0572086684,
-0.039030578,
0.0371530876,
-0.0111337481,
0.0535863265,
0.0115791317,
-0.0264845341,
-0.0205527265,
-0.0278449934,
-0.0090706525,
0.0886669382,
-0.0268034376,
-0.0164863057,
-0.0428768694,
0.0104195643,
-0.0050807949,
0.0314381942,
-0.0362807587,
0.017329555,
0.0392000824,
-0.0509252697,
-0.0251861699,
-0.007281485,
0.0093339868,
-0.0158782247,
-0.0081422431,
-0.0341321193,
0.0222921167,
-0.0107599748,
-0.0450731628,
-0.0103678433,
-0.0223631095,
-0.0286037736,
-0.0093117198,
0.0094352029,
-0.0495235398,
-0.0348616056,
0.0043123397,
-0.0170987863,
0.0880662501,
-0.0044493587,
0.0215045828,
-0.0039393692,
0.0709605888,
0.0164695177,
-0.0118935229,
0.0137488497,
-0.0336749405,
0.0443929322,
0.0335433856,
0.0557214133,
0.0293972362,
-0.0528607033,
-0.0113456743,
0.0717040002,
-0.0241118111,
-0.0371302404,
0.0222629961,
-0.0069645005,
-0.0632863194,
0.0055445288,
0.1238987595,
0.0077036116,
-0.0314590186,
-0.0182680767,
0.0174447279,
0.040320415,
-0.0249115713,
0.0032472631,
-0.0448027886,
-0.0654572323,
0.0010009554,
0.0443036482,
0.0168839283,
-0.0196091458,
0.0143847428,
-0.1087192595,
0.0237770993,
-0.0318341702,
-0.0318584964,
-0.0080692284,
-0.0404400118,
0.0150007494,
0.013559876,
-0.0146455327,
0.0038337829,
0.0208996367,
-0.0227972828,
0.0476097129,
-0.0112510938,
-0.0271615069,
0.0299466439,
-0.0574467257,
0.0097526731,
0.0610421859,
0.0100211389,
-0.0247690883,
-0.0618835054,
0.0618107952,
-0.0865563154,
-0.0331158787,
-0.0410512835,
0.0583902374,
-0.0133856609,
-0.0302099772,
-0.0467883535,
0.0198340192,
0.0211564098,
0.0031690022,
-0.0289511085,
0.0587627068,
0.0059989612,
-0.0371618345,
-0.0090085203,
0.0188595653,
-0.0361212865,
0.0616429336,
0.0282294434,
-0.0943013281,
-0.0398966484,
0.0062654992,
-0.0205229726,
-0.0771590471,
0.0289864037,
0.0109747294,
-0.0325740576,
-0.0685723722,
-0.0140380114,
-0.0146032255,
0.0297813844,
0.085081324,
-0.0310812164,
-0.0084447479,
0.0241726246,
0.0126979891,
-0.0481717773,
0.0088754157,
0.0258431453,
0.0159820784,
-0.0454958007,
-0.0349587984,
0.0449684784,
-0.0062425071,
-0.0238418709,
-0.0066414224,
-0.0038966236,
-0.0671260878,
0.0058564218,
0.0178557411,
0.0148373721,
0.0495200269,
-0.0304170959,
-0.0528644621,
0.0617616437,
0.0312998109,
0.0091604264,
-0.0136333257,
0.0500866584,
-0.0528763309,
0.0199986231,
0.0305543784,
-0.0435191393,
0.0027051899,
0.040878132,
0.0554124936,
-0.0461814478,
0.0011938227,
0.0032027808,
-0.0168581214,
0.064145498,
-0.0353871696,
0.0024639054,
-0.0273934063,
0.0439984053,
0.0135787968,
0.0052579129,
-0.0609454773,
0.0506675094,
0.0054779048,
0.0460890196,
-0.0320086814,
0.0378815979,
0.0408621579,
-0.0261622667,
-0.0448698066,
0.0426319428,
0.012359906,
0.0468077287,
0.0114477109,
-0.0452262796,
-0.027530726,
-0.0016734466,
0.0281615723,
0.0063324757,
-0.0507383794,
0.0298970919,
0.0686998591,
0.0122581925,
-0.0205824524,
0.0176185481,
-0.035622526,
-0.0176153425,
-0.087331526,
0.0456441827,
0.0294201858,
0.0265801344,
0.0142400479,
0.0121015571,
-0.0109213004,
0.009336927,
0.0119567178,
-0.0298610199,
-0.0432327278,
0.0173441172,
0.0215335991,
0.0037977092,
-0.0189556889,
0.0475746728,
0.0038317963,
0.0510469824,
0.0032792161,
0.000906523,
-0.0215620194,
-0.029528426,
0.053442806,
0.0080560418,
-0.0293819085,
0.0288601071,
0.0001860578,
-0.0722769052,
-0.0012872984,
0.0126701724,
0.0186224189,
0.0245646816,
0.0690001324,
0.0404024087,
0.0104691423,
-0.0517902039,
0.0099564269,
-0.0224154517,
0.0456478558,
-0.014290968,
0.0223471504,
-6.941297815e-33,
-0.0078701628,
0.0307090115,
0.0092278197,
-0.0168149918,
0.0100456653,
0.0131169911,
-0.0309805088,
-0.0291656274,
-0.0174139105,
-0.0062210085,
0.0092275739,
0.0230767522,
0.0318361335,
0.0443840064,
-0.0170221459,
-0.0114156296,
0.0602380298,
0.005085547,
-0.0079858191,
0.012510458,
-0.0270687267,
0.0594456047,
0.0790351629,
-0.0009009481,
-0.0379889905,
0.0133180991,
-0.0208409429,
0.002764805,
0.0362833813,
0.0094216196,
-0.025427185,
0.0058485596,
-0.0149916494,
-0.0348647684,
-0.0038606443,
0.034347903,
-0.1261089742,
-0.0400819294,
0.0018751799,
0.0502551422,
-0.0572485738,
0.0357987918,
0.033615429,
0.0186406542,
0.0069472063,
0.00313115,
0.0269825272,
-0.0016762817,
-0.0095820241,
-0.0605781116,
-0.0384120122,
0.0645998865,
0.0007833139,
-0.0322833247,
-0.0040273811,
0.018697964,
-0.0208045784,
-0.0001132995,
-0.0567588843,
-0.0218421388,
0.0374792479,
-0.0180398338,
0.0039923596,
0.0307204798,
0.0229376815,
0.0206100028,
0.0641416088,
-0.0236606896,
0.033001855,
-0.025206076,
0.0840522647,
0.0290535074,
0.0211592373,
-0.0326523744,
0.0835868195,
-0.01676853,
-0.0705551803,
0.0210988149,
0.0539509989,
0.0045511927,
0.0198648684,
-0.016433062,
-0.0299490858,
-0.0266510602,
0.0022069812,
-0.0181346145,
-0.0322040692,
-0.0156519283,
-0.0075289472,
0.0237087104,
-0.029940594,
-0.0013559137,
0.0276635457,
-0.0227360874,
0.0085006794,
-0.0077177123,
0.0021896493,
0.0022569913,
0.0129139964,
0.0262762476,
-0.0511690639,
-0.0558856018,
-0.0032210492,
-0.0121830776,
0.007536232,
0.0048391712,
0.0380821005,
0.0545624569,
-0.067515865,
-0.0032117555,
-0.0312741809,
-0.0054302751,
0.0106531996,
0.0270028431,
0.0445564836,
-0.0002288206,
0.0248913281,
0.0104530444,
0.0113193095,
0.069692269,
-0.0324324258,
-0.0036437777,
0.0303970911,
0.0580789335,
-0.0081968224,
-0.0232484844,
-0.0384322517,
0.0017295643,
-0.0300099514,
-0.0862866789,
-0.0319986641,
0.0455628447,
2.943e-7,
0.0235446356,
-0.0061532678,
0.0309402812,
0.0212202482,
-0.0298072249,
0.0150508704,
0.0123049207,
0.0170509629,
-0.0064374367,
0.0697176829,
0.0519828387,
-0.0057723876,
0.0273065995,
0.010697986,
-0.091142334,
-0.0194371082,
-0.0845185891,
0.0078474004,
-0.0256136414,
-0.0086801006,
0.0346361436,
0.0930336788,
0.0166602358,
-0.0232977793,
0.0169281512,
-0.0540039167,
0.0260638967,
0.0216907095,
0.044684004,
-0.017887136,
0.0265972614,
0.0210846215,
-0.0205575898,
-0.0081637707,
-0.0102193831,
0.0677699447,
-0.022269126,
0.0212176777,
-0.0138744842,
-0.044819884,
0.0574966744,
-0.03735267,
-0.001782238,
-0.0152724311,
0.0737413764,
-0.0464878194,
-0.0228495989,
0.0240097214,
-0.0402629115,
-0.0198460426,
-0.0038069943,
-0.0356221981,
-0.0046101878,
0.0120652393,
0.0307793804,
-0.0825261623,
-0.0420805104,
-0.1006678641,
-0.0126909632,
0.020618014,
-0.025590878,
-0.0324990973,
-0.0305210333,
-0.0067701028,
0.0327218026,
-0.065290384,
0.0206562132,
2.731484973e-34,
0.0546460859,
-0.0380922444,
-0.023639001,
0.0515533574,
0.0079336995,
-0.0107638715,
0.0007682476,
-0.0097176135,
0.0175752901,
-0.0472410731,
-0.0390576757
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.09184v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09184v2 | Block-wise Bit-Compression of Transformer-based Models | 2023-03-16T09:53:57 | 2023-04-01T12:50:29 | Gaochen Dong, Wei Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | With the popularity of the recent Transformer-based models represented by
BERT, GPT-3 and ChatGPT, there has been state-of-the-art performance in a range
of natural language processing tasks. However, the massive computations, huge
memory footprint, and thus high latency of Transformer-based models is an
inevitable challenge for the cloud with high real-time requirement. To tackle
the issue, we propose BBCT, a method of block-wise bit-compression for
transformer without retraining. Our method achieves more fine-grained
compression of the whole transformer, including embedding, matrix
multiplication, GELU, softmax, layer normalization, and all the intermediate
results. As a case, we compress an efficient BERT with the method of BBCT. Our
benchmark test results on General Language Understanding Evaluation (GLUE) show
that BBCT can achieve less than 1% accuracy drop in most tasks. | [
0.0089175012,
0.0331180356,
0.0016726131,
0.0472418629,
-0.0208271556,
0.0290307552,
0.0079185991,
-0.0118107256,
-0.0287344325,
-0.0214633588,
-0.0033566444,
-0.0468486138,
0.011709189,
0.0261675324,
0.0053663072,
-0.0516509376,
0.0463899374,
0.014858813,
-0.0326451249,
-0.0046235109,
0.0059621064,
0.0139300972,
-0.0018518458,
0.0551334843,
0.0165128205,
0.0017328743,
-0.0393886231,
-0.0059305565,
0.0178507064,
0.0253594592,
-0.0063291779,
0.0369835943,
0.0478823557,
0.0409130678,
0.0000018562,
-0.0037790148,
-0.0458648428,
0.0225951299,
-0.0689109862,
0.0173959415,
-0.0017326312,
-0.0203994233,
-0.0296620838,
0.0399939157,
-0.0230006445,
-0.0292648468,
0.059449777,
0.0687519833,
0.0760857314,
0.0705503151,
-0.01968343,
-0.04978697,
0.0203193147,
-0.0029190488,
-0.0289358869,
-0.0254928917,
-0.0105108321,
-0.0097716302,
-0.0169493593,
-0.0026719738,
-0.0358831957,
0.0279501602,
0.0428647175,
0.0295826588,
-0.0033522921,
0.0348765552,
-0.0697823539,
-0.0203932114,
-0.0154549787,
0.0563599057,
-0.0406687669,
-0.020124279,
-0.0228453875,
0.0401265249,
0.000561104,
-0.0082233092,
-0.0367395133,
0.0390304327,
0.0196554121,
0.0274843108,
-0.0413439684,
0.0042985315,
0.0397311561,
-0.0027504098,
-0.0215035472,
0.0492253341,
0.0224567726,
-0.0182383191,
-0.0539266504,
-0.0074152765,
-0.0226942487,
-0.0113038579,
0.0139044849,
0.0335431285,
0.0045295767,
-0.0096562337,
-0.0599309281,
-0.0181291588,
-0.0143243242,
-0.0103843315,
0.0347558819,
0.077816084,
0.0102495635,
0.0450170711,
-0.0367916934,
0.0630132034,
-0.0129512167,
-0.0015634379,
-0.0098742899,
-0.0292870961,
-0.0385649502,
-0.0114036696,
-0.0995351896,
0.0375661179,
-0.040506158,
-0.0363231041,
-0.0146742808,
0.0293992162,
0.0139721064,
0.0090937847,
0.0598113947,
0.0137505513,
-0.0372576378,
0.0025053166,
0.013881227,
0.0361382775,
-0.0254180133,
-0.000820474,
-0.0132213421,
-0.0644733608,
-0.0294240788,
0.0080965208,
0.0225357749,
-0.0169332754,
0.0239403434,
-0.0078873802,
-0.0155181447,
-0.0482294969,
-0.0125147942,
0.0084887734,
0.0272153765,
-0.0458979011,
-0.0058720079,
-0.0395091251,
0.0225681234,
-0.0075187888,
0.0304278005,
0.0258086938,
0.0023908562,
0.0170234982,
-0.0124214953,
0.0575299487,
-0.0345868133,
-0.0124317752,
-0.0029894565,
0.0406686515,
0.0205093995,
0.0649713948,
0.0458569638,
-0.0051713306,
-0.0009094175,
-0.056213133,
-0.0196303092,
0.0330509841,
0.0292285867,
0.0044007208,
-0.0238461178,
-0.0027094262,
-0.0078741657,
0.0330737047,
0.0198243298,
0.0782493725,
-0.0525672287,
-0.0528524145,
0.0558742136,
0.0173546337,
0.028639067,
0.116317831,
0.0085631544,
0.042695336,
0.0058942195,
0.0069339187,
-0.0286690108,
0.0437869094,
-0.0177439861,
0.0102738189,
0.0001211259,
0.0871571153,
-0.0481259786,
0.0148609439,
-0.0139051238,
-0.0244177114,
0.0196479186,
-0.0239846632,
0.0172808487,
0.0200164132,
-0.0527011976,
0.1381835341,
-0.0210919585,
-0.074705638,
-0.0299474113,
-0.0607459769,
-0.0183870215,
0.0165919196,
0.0649135783,
0.0178367589,
-0.0364921205,
-0.0285697188,
-0.0333688818,
0.0179546811,
-0.002635085,
0.0118596014,
0.0195068121,
-0.0844269991,
-0.0200380553,
0.0213947222,
-0.0107720662,
-0.0033000184,
0.041278936,
0.0064775306,
0.0259466134,
-0.0425935909,
0.0343952589,
0.0281848032,
0.0170156639,
-0.0044819745,
0.024060877,
0.0038457746,
0.03536129,
-0.0068556545,
-0.0205045864,
-0.0285682715,
0.0386677161,
-0.0409734026,
-0.0369455814,
0.0223367792,
-0.0624176599,
-0.0589542165,
0.0223550051,
-0.0170100518,
0.0103344917,
0.1083843559,
-0.0570428483,
-0.0573672578,
0.003440036,
-0.0697351843,
0.0418294892,
-0.0515979044,
-0.0046649035,
-0.0185465831,
0.0363622978,
0.0059901956,
0.0195654109,
-0.0207603145,
0.0015208423,
0.0091177328,
-0.0038041603,
0.0392068997,
0.0094623314,
-0.0640462786,
0.0253311694,
-0.0433406457,
0.0182673018,
0.0040528076,
-0.0396583229,
-0.0288042184,
-0.0096534528,
-0.1211532876,
0.007533004,
-0.0242335536,
0.031234676,
0.0141642271,
0.0715643913,
0.0210618228,
-0.0086261043,
-0.0316511169,
-0.004396318,
-0.0212851167,
0.0219423398,
0.0036898989,
-0.0188230928,
-0.0390731506,
0.0099169565,
-0.0271781329,
0.0071420916,
0.0591329299,
-0.0490848646,
-0.0105018876,
-0.0439642444,
-0.0129612293,
-0.0021121684,
0.0549461991,
-0.0084354132,
-0.068994157,
-0.0132959979,
-0.0090958066,
0.0603300221,
0.0498417132,
0.029496707,
0.0329143927,
0.0364437327,
0.0067551737,
-0.0379208997,
0.0466539003,
-0.0404744521,
-0.0139072938,
-0.0397724621,
-0.0154835219,
-0.029013332,
0.0724392757,
-0.0207204167,
-0.0125924312,
-0.0808577687,
-0.03598525,
0.0019926073,
0.0343502648,
-0.0125308344,
-0.0164228622,
-0.0337090567,
-0.0212986656,
-0.0105530135,
-0.039699655,
0.0624969862,
-0.0807439089,
-0.0385633111,
-0.04580025,
-0.0153797856,
-0.0358360931,
0.0575170666,
0.001370198,
0.0380425677,
-0.0533183254,
-0.0234655533,
-0.0326448418,
0.0234403647,
0.0008729068,
-0.0375119969,
-0.0019555974,
0.0125155784,
0.0118513061,
-0.0345479883,
-0.037823204,
-0.0230992027,
-0.0270683169,
-0.0252890605,
0.0542423502,
0.0563456267,
-0.0510927103,
-0.0595976003,
0.0457064658,
0.0110291326,
0.0535156131,
-0.0058238097,
-0.0004734746,
-0.0090819951,
0.0219057854,
0.0332920179,
0.0509338006,
0.0402104482,
0.0359355137,
0.0101417266,
0.0632118136,
0.0521788448,
0.0142206969,
-0.0958615765,
-0.0112351663,
0.0261138566,
-0.0208233763,
-0.0154059269,
-0.0032823675,
0.0360558927,
-0.0594727732,
-0.0158633962,
0.1175851449,
0.013549882,
-0.0262262225,
0.0013225205,
0.0060241073,
0.0363357253,
-0.0030366392,
0.0232586749,
-0.0805205628,
-0.0595303029,
0.0227513481,
-0.0094304588,
0.0132938223,
-0.0100078294,
-0.0142066618,
-0.0918260738,
0.0122617185,
-0.000579105,
0.0625433624,
-0.0400902517,
-0.0533070527,
-0.0187630095,
-0.0055041495,
0.0009322618,
0.00423506,
0.0058055851,
-0.0082727186,
0.0264443271,
-0.0178582985,
-0.0581267662,
0.0250587314,
-0.0166561492,
0.0338413119,
0.0492009595,
0.0068354872,
-0.0069495584,
-0.056936536,
0.000495753,
0.0107259108,
-0.0272296984,
-0.0077221324,
0.0184245724,
-0.0004160868,
-0.0128648868,
-0.0057832021,
-0.006236875,
-0.0169877,
-0.010169494,
-0.0553776585,
0.1132887453,
-0.0118603418,
-0.0174863301,
-0.0136428624,
-0.0174217317,
-0.0100167654,
0.0721518695,
0.0158358384,
-0.0026157745,
-0.0270802639,
0.0140608037,
0.0050443904,
-0.0117217982,
-0.0180687197,
0.0235977247,
0.0255059246,
-0.0453002267,
-0.0190286282,
0.0039538951,
0.0200405009,
0.0340982862,
-0.0080027068,
-0.0342769399,
0.0462621897,
0.042728506,
-0.0869667977,
0.0196433961,
-0.0057227858,
0.0224644952,
-0.0463509485,
0.0090419631,
0.0360840559,
0.0105136111,
-0.0302197579,
-0.0007858835,
-0.068854779,
-0.0162722208,
0.0142261898,
0.0201265272,
0.0228498094,
0.01812106,
-0.002530871,
-0.0398219265,
0.0284529366,
0.0472068712,
-0.0470801927,
0.0095614158,
0.0243232399,
-0.0658670142,
0.0073186131,
0.0456586629,
-0.0230676681,
0.0008977635,
-0.0618278235,
0.0315291621,
-0.043900419,
0.0066226409,
0.0085594719,
-0.0018561591,
0.0507477447,
0.0162077658,
0.0374152884,
0.0198661741,
0.0603662916,
0.0282627605,
0.0247183573,
-0.0639062971,
-0.0002174635,
0.0217804387,
-0.0315965116,
0.0180073697,
0.039407935,
0.0265626349,
-0.0368523151,
0.0098061524,
0.002361078,
-0.0109298592,
-0.0455998965,
0.0546793491,
0.0040738848,
-0.0193400476,
-0.0334454849,
0.0504470989,
0.0098965075,
-0.0299865603,
0.0493253805,
0.029960854,
0.0251758993,
-0.0175388511,
0.0465344191,
-0.036504481,
-0.0448817573,
-0.0261422843,
-0.0132480254,
0.009018111,
-0.0072002276,
0.0396736749,
-0.0193900466,
-0.0094827833,
-0.0116085596,
0.0161922574,
-0.0373281837,
-0.0332926102,
0.0695832372,
0.0050674053,
-0.0207582824,
0.0114667863,
0.068278268,
-0.0028986684,
0.0643361583,
-0.0332585834,
-0.0136107914,
-0.0430005342,
-0.0355893448,
-0.0035132591,
0.0116582066,
-0.0027568031,
0.0095204068,
-0.0133450571,
-0.0408537276,
-0.0057223532,
-0.0088438923,
0.0182298813,
-0.0536048561,
0.0448402315,
0.0539351478,
0.0155513892,
-0.0348938555,
-0.0096063018,
-0.0003645431,
-0.014287821,
-0.0084445942,
0.0061149406,
-6.304617749e-33,
-0.0271039382,
0.0035132968,
0.0257140845,
-0.0422415063,
-0.0141978068,
0.0277176928,
-0.0170469042,
-0.0129420226,
-0.0404545851,
-0.0023295479,
-0.0201917291,
0.0241211075,
0.0151306409,
0.0522925332,
-0.0455804244,
-0.0244443566,
0.0825457126,
-0.0099529438,
-0.0290889703,
0.0364383422,
0.0092444317,
0.0373790786,
0.0493537001,
0.0019034405,
-0.065790683,
-0.0087261852,
-0.0281440783,
-0.003499679,
0.0085470406,
0.0439172052,
-0.0383870378,
0.0054874793,
0.0076393783,
-0.0754952431,
-0.0057051554,
0.0162275061,
-0.0932295471,
0.0110708,
0.0126645751,
0.0553584285,
-0.0535536557,
0.0142474817,
0.0258027688,
0.0197592117,
0.0034129459,
-0.043157015,
-0.0213871039,
-0.0118477801,
-0.0278109293,
-0.0741707236,
-0.0225900672,
0.0240420867,
-0.0078053433,
-0.0486732759,
0.060475044,
0.0305147897,
-0.0270369202,
0.0149751818,
-0.0722592175,
-0.0143023599,
0.016652178,
0.0648528263,
0.0431827009,
-0.0340817347,
-0.0059922128,
0.014116426,
-0.0072335135,
-0.0504261069,
-0.0585046336,
0.0005343573,
0.0345314704,
0.0473642237,
0.0405578203,
-0.0081273001,
0.0401352234,
0.0038711936,
-0.0493136011,
0.015531118,
0.0513351038,
0.0577683859,
0.0163975209,
0.0115049342,
-0.0160392709,
-0.0105031282,
-0.0307563674,
0.0012202389,
-0.0199186523,
0.0088665374,
0.015418509,
0.0259173457,
-0.0300920513,
0.0155752096,
0.0589981414,
-0.049944222,
0.0338250436,
0.0245476067,
-0.004488246,
0.0056532733,
0.017926719,
0.0408747979,
-0.0288736075,
-0.0305667911,
0.0196863264,
-0.0126001779,
0.0083982516,
0.0122766774,
0.047171738,
0.0675831884,
-0.0755615458,
0.0047450666,
-0.037735492,
0.0040891077,
-0.0311973393,
0.0402617976,
0.0247490127,
0.0263489429,
0.0078098522,
0.0497062877,
-0.0209608339,
0.0391468517,
-0.0291541256,
0.0015840315,
0.0197679326,
0.0300999284,
-0.0300920568,
-0.0074498435,
-0.0535163507,
0.0115174698,
0.0296602678,
-0.0585068241,
-0.0260497797,
0.0324457809,
2.662e-7,
0.0190445781,
0.0444667116,
0.0279350188,
-0.0108903814,
0.0178154465,
0.0534404144,
0.0278253332,
0.0353893414,
0.0075200684,
0.026335068,
0.016150156,
-0.0000877842,
0.0397542156,
0.0048643947,
-0.0805599317,
-0.0204486325,
-0.0957145393,
-0.0058787148,
-0.0456332304,
0.0089338329,
0.0167737082,
0.1457078606,
0.0020616062,
-0.0213430244,
0.0315646268,
-0.0070837759,
0.0427122004,
-0.0027339181,
0.0174189266,
0.0038156295,
0.0370216258,
0.0528535023,
-0.0139368335,
-0.0196251757,
-0.0059803124,
0.0463747755,
-0.0302426163,
0.074612841,
-0.0135749569,
0.0021673671,
0.0216044132,
-0.0443588495,
-0.0302780215,
-0.0439838171,
0.0700504482,
-0.0178622659,
-0.0351940244,
-0.0067029265,
-0.0253540538,
-0.0187738296,
0.0076392055,
-0.0074191308,
0.0022473985,
0.0031109403,
0.0219710842,
-0.0543153957,
-0.0108111864,
-0.0958436877,
0.0148497699,
-0.0172477532,
-0.0582369007,
-0.0065865004,
-0.0455139801,
-0.0449654236,
0.0638927743,
-0.0153040085,
0.0068725809,
2.569678176e-34,
0.0296706315,
0.0091620749,
0.0372476429,
0.0554119051,
0.0182675719,
-0.0284504071,
0.0680404902,
-0.0043367534,
-0.0309513137,
-0.0972028673,
-0.0443252772
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2304.02015v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2304.02015v1 | How well do Large Language Models perform in Arithmetic tasks? | 2023-03-16T09:28:15 | 2023-03-16T09:28:15 | Zheng Yuan, Hongyi Yuan, Chuanqi Tan, Wei Wang, Songfang Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models have emerged abilities including chain-of-thought to
answer math word problems step by step. Solving math word problems not only
requires abilities to disassemble problems via chain-of-thought but also needs
to calculate arithmetic expressions correctly for each step. To the best of our
knowledge, there is no work to focus on evaluating the arithmetic ability of
large language models. In this work, we propose an arithmetic dataset MATH 401
to test the latest large language models including GPT-4, ChatGPT, InstrctGPT,
Galactica, and LLaMA with various arithmetic expressions and provide a detailed
analysis of the ability of large language models. MATH 401 and evaluation codes
are released at \url{https://github.com/GanjinZero/math401-llm}. | [
-0.0406161994,
0.1284905523,
-0.0150106335,
0.0561626405,
-0.0632906705,
0.0189321656,
0.0135667911,
0.0227764174,
-0.0671824515,
-0.0201615617,
-0.0516379401,
-0.0440553054,
0.01937031,
0.0094910609,
0.0299781226,
-0.0236916766,
0.0229300018,
-0.0708862245,
-0.0135382991,
0.0002022175,
-0.032839071,
-0.022187341,
-0.0129961818,
-0.0061041387,
-0.0007307923,
-0.0593954511,
0.0143770948,
-0.075831145,
0.005353203,
-0.0137386695,
-0.0183077157,
0.0254776925,
0.0135435713,
0.1038640141,
0.000001889,
-0.03998252,
0.0063330452,
0.0427197739,
-0.0482489541,
0.0797722638,
-0.0023572261,
0.0068821902,
-0.0124112731,
0.0314143486,
-0.0420846455,
-0.0086968103,
0.0220079925,
0.0080678891,
0.0666111112,
0.0608808026,
-0.0019643207,
-0.0576013438,
0.0362093598,
-0.0384338088,
0.0443933122,
-0.06075041,
0.0135923624,
0.0562419519,
0.0301408973,
0.0054360856,
-0.0171294231,
0.0004806141,
0.0559613742,
0.0082379505,
-0.0782970786,
0.0051707234,
-0.0425540693,
0.0115749473,
0.0010311903,
0.0417657122,
0.0043763542,
-0.0009044036,
-0.0293472223,
-0.0018097955,
-0.0173064899,
-0.0027178891,
-0.0802731216,
0.0337487087,
0.0072292038,
0.0115975225,
0.0148181617,
-0.0147311231,
0.0224072021,
-0.0034871821,
-0.0350884832,
0.1033559442,
0.0488153212,
-0.0088576423,
-0.0191521738,
-0.0110877408,
-0.0838095322,
-0.0467428043,
-0.0004568474,
0.0436682887,
0.0092409672,
0.0222428124,
-0.0368952267,
-0.0057633263,
-0.0010903788,
-0.035724923,
0.0395166092,
0.0719544888,
0.0120654013,
0.0470796824,
-0.0091821318,
0.0683055148,
-0.0430966578,
-0.003703858,
-0.0105603058,
0.0519128107,
0.0029650347,
-0.0177943036,
-0.0409626178,
0.0306304321,
-0.0154166464,
0.0263488498,
-0.0421539396,
0.0129761016,
-0.0132151395,
0.0120251821,
0.0261690952,
-0.0471742228,
0.007116891,
-0.0305183157,
-0.0230406635,
0.0144392122,
-0.0479142666,
0.0138726551,
0.00410811,
-0.0763914213,
-0.0136692235,
-0.0042018821,
-0.0285647959,
-0.0341492631,
0.0364802293,
0.0825675279,
0.0107824774,
-0.0237405878,
0.0028228716,
0.0111121135,
0.0137836654,
-0.107547015,
0.0187833421,
-0.0941288322,
0.0368969142,
0.0296588335,
-0.0104287779,
0.0089918571,
0.0088938884,
0.0048840842,
0.0339162238,
0.0424637832,
0.0274010077,
-0.0078915693,
0.0071520708,
0.0040070349,
-0.0150617054,
0.0602922589,
0.0491219535,
-0.0235213768,
0.0124389017,
-0.0148690399,
-0.00568246,
0.0848645195,
-0.0013991534,
0.0167451482,
-0.051641468,
0.0225031506,
0.0233588424,
0.026123967,
-0.0122380508,
0.075381279,
-0.0574278682,
-0.0179671925,
0.0059160911,
0.0603362769,
0.0179653727,
0.0422521606,
0.0181738306,
-0.0260991286,
0.0663113669,
0.0002770011,
-0.0635072291,
0.0166786052,
-0.0413975902,
0.0159817524,
0.0153068816,
0.0421231575,
-0.0284253415,
-0.054271657,
-0.0126625914,
0.0117305163,
-0.0192519166,
-0.0014722374,
0.0666375533,
-0.0306899827,
0.003857546,
0.0375270322,
0.0185032785,
-0.0592730902,
-0.0388143584,
-0.075132452,
0.0352706127,
-0.0301943161,
0.078310743,
-0.0499890782,
-0.0254653431,
0.002929854,
-0.0023754176,
-0.0038778502,
0.0352316909,
0.0130055295,
-0.0161640234,
-0.0196895991,
0.0115060378,
-0.027300993,
0.0447344743,
-0.0027999068,
0.0309829786,
-0.0039044726,
0.0077428427,
-0.0485920794,
0.030173922,
0.0002866478,
-0.0393028855,
-0.0412681885,
-0.017739078,
-0.0033321078,
0.0209288429,
0.0057416228,
-0.0060372427,
0.0492325015,
0.012710101,
-0.0257549435,
-0.0076705627,
-0.0208377745,
-0.0343686678,
-0.0349574536,
0.0736304298,
-0.0331307165,
-0.0227501243,
0.0197140779,
-0.0271337368,
-0.0194678362,
0.0665498376,
-0.0657784194,
0.0246463623,
-0.0180868506,
0.0468562804,
-0.0041640401,
-0.0169337131,
0.007455423,
0.090855293,
-0.019594362,
0.0661338344,
-0.0102999872,
0.0251553878,
0.0258901063,
0.0044687376,
-0.0149581032,
0.0074593117,
-0.0120336749,
0.0135791041,
-0.0293417405,
0.0176199861,
-0.0246727634,
-0.0380755216,
-0.0235564243,
-0.0181481764,
-0.0363770537,
0.0863322243,
0.0138745215,
-0.0015269478,
-0.0092185633,
0.0105982665,
-0.0381136797,
0.0144421533,
0.0177174937,
0.0205373,
0.0185479801,
-0.0101904925,
-0.0363291465,
-0.0397073217,
-0.0529113561,
-0.022960797,
0.0516209528,
-0.0083542746,
0.0149015477,
-0.0281842258,
0.0448862873,
-0.0356424078,
0.0286695939,
-0.0250432622,
-0.0292986315,
0.0278089941,
-0.0274600442,
0.0512499474,
0.0277870316,
-0.0418713987,
0.0309907123,
0.0259428564,
-0.0189037751,
-0.0115148071,
0.0021202443,
0.0132925399,
-0.0315808505,
-0.0073809642,
-0.0186867267,
-0.0375035293,
0.1167029887,
-0.0342260227,
-0.0373743102,
-0.0087314555,
0.0131735886,
-0.0244909097,
0.0151947886,
-0.0079974318,
0.0300959349,
-0.0225602575,
0.0391432904,
0.0010929038,
-0.051757317,
0.0061678495,
-0.0306113046,
-0.0338010304,
-0.052474048,
0.0052099507,
-0.0758530647,
0.066918388,
0.0285602324,
-0.022443451,
-0.0351140797,
-0.0207971167,
-0.0183678158,
0.0077612386,
0.0141358869,
-0.039023336,
0.0903772563,
-0.0300468951,
0.0324258171,
-0.0214263573,
-0.0552100204,
-0.0084863082,
0.0233463291,
-0.0325482264,
0.0421218015,
0.0007642818,
-0.0512743816,
-0.0211088471,
0.0030999638,
0.0525610186,
0.0478212237,
-0.0393873528,
0.0041867956,
-0.0230773501,
0.0382601805,
0.046765171,
0.0146341827,
0.0402437449,
-0.0580229647,
0.0185087267,
0.0215677284,
0.0902135,
0.0179833863,
-0.0177247804,
0.0224148408,
0.025119869,
-0.0230544396,
-0.0321950987,
0.0457887277,
0.0257083159,
-0.0332373716,
-0.0335550383,
0.0850933343,
0.0394013077,
-0.0476484448,
0.0168333519,
-0.0657131597,
0.0113483192,
0.0311116092,
0.0073389737,
-0.1046831086,
-0.0131475041,
0.0141810188,
-0.0572827384,
0.0007671505,
-0.0255510341,
0.001760843,
-0.1173420995,
0.0233015791,
0.0209344421,
-0.0434857458,
-0.0152684841,
-0.0460514948,
0.0077582113,
-0.0140906172,
-0.0006527501,
0.0385970585,
-0.0223931428,
0.0214692131,
-0.0147834159,
-0.0046509625,
-0.0105433455,
0.0672054663,
0.0229069069,
-0.0035670779,
0.0373116508,
0.0017123574,
-0.0436036214,
-0.0723167509,
0.0733165741,
-0.0035783276,
-0.0468379594,
0.0232660957,
-0.0141780367,
0.0354127772,
-0.0116817122,
-0.0026216062,
0.0524747893,
-0.040656615,
0.0120143006,
0.0160704441,
0.0996375307,
-0.0157375298,
-0.0021101886,
0.0190489348,
-0.0105272215,
-0.0203553475,
0.0343666486,
0.043838799,
-0.0119374283,
-0.0456342436,
-0.0370102413,
-0.0239885598,
-0.0179993138,
-0.0090778787,
0.013149838,
0.0561352223,
-0.012434612,
-0.0081822854,
-0.0142005933,
0.038297344,
0.0534896255,
-0.0197206046,
-0.0166753847,
0.0313627869,
-0.0064719557,
-0.0138948513,
0.0155385798,
-0.0384617411,
0.0531207658,
-0.0715934113,
0.0277839601,
0.0265560597,
0.0018537299,
-0.0405165553,
0.03380806,
-0.142983824,
-0.0403101258,
0.0030129096,
0.0402134992,
0.0390675887,
-0.0426992774,
-0.0084819412,
-0.0071269954,
-0.0091761444,
0.0040362612,
-0.0607649647,
0.0380260535,
0.0100969337,
0.0319899693,
0.0124085071,
0.0246180557,
0.0030312915,
0.0122010345,
0.0166012384,
0.0470829159,
-0.0286590066,
-0.0066251704,
0.016099792,
0.0525621697,
-0.0211719163,
0.0382682346,
0.042577114,
0.0135860229,
0.023985805,
-0.0528838299,
0.0153171448,
-0.0662078559,
-0.0189091116,
0.0228802525,
-0.0165970977,
0.0026117759,
-0.0377427787,
0.029779654,
0.0309567191,
-0.0026967174,
0.0497199036,
0.0190306343,
0.0469648615,
0.0496722944,
-0.0477959178,
0.0172130335,
-0.0351720676,
-0.0182705484,
0.0329313911,
0.0069040353,
0.0607376397,
-0.0062849931,
0.0169182196,
-0.0349182524,
0.0164155737,
-0.0224642828,
-0.0864514336,
-0.0155370524,
0.0367575623,
0.0381469727,
0.0180304963,
0.002169044,
-0.0497702919,
-0.0124698933,
-0.0311403666,
0.0083909696,
0.016372228,
-0.0124575542,
0.0213641673,
0.0453669205,
0.0128608271,
-0.0428586043,
0.0584262758,
0.0116912778,
0.0279646609,
0.0440674536,
0.0431505516,
-0.023821665,
-0.0607726201,
-0.0423737615,
-0.0246500056,
-0.0089548063,
0.0124592138,
-0.0716867819,
-0.0872497931,
-0.0408249833,
0.0123274,
-0.0117276106,
0.0013114031,
0.0397738703,
0.0855890736,
-0.0292601921,
0.005024645,
0.0022841378,
0.0177140627,
-0.0188645758,
-0.0421626158,
-0.0206266493,
-5.458620709e-33,
-0.0290068593,
-0.0132724158,
0.0566924214,
0.005906913,
0.0024258746,
-0.0039152657,
-0.0256131608,
0.028609572,
-0.0148406876,
-0.0007589164,
-0.0273709726,
0.0287192296,
0.0029801656,
0.0210442021,
-0.01338806,
-0.0152759096,
0.006693657,
-0.0321679413,
-0.0488874726,
-0.006755861,
-0.0117421262,
-0.0224524811,
0.0833079442,
0.004532076,
0.002165026,
-0.0028324311,
-0.0037831303,
0.01745902,
-0.0526349582,
0.0587208569,
-0.0285159368,
0.0208764859,
0.0136375707,
-0.0256470516,
-0.0084661832,
-0.0111282738,
-0.0246780645,
-0.0468951873,
0.0453752317,
-0.005701608,
-0.0411896594,
-0.0274572335,
0.0116114374,
0.0136501649,
-0.0531032532,
-0.024041649,
-0.0307226498,
-0.0308516435,
-0.0097365687,
0.0400437936,
-0.0264108721,
0.0368697941,
-0.0010865959,
-0.0042636907,
0.0145319905,
-0.017820254,
-0.0358476229,
-0.0214912016,
0.0029367437,
0.01968286,
0.0699160621,
0.0562268272,
0.0316895582,
-0.0303313006,
0.0116211427,
0.0210807305,
0.0329855271,
-0.0303058885,
-0.0096418029,
-0.02083846,
0.0081488974,
0.0394745283,
0.0465453379,
-0.000369288,
0.0519086272,
0.0441334918,
-0.0531617925,
-0.0094799288,
0.0424516015,
0.0360323228,
0.0039954204,
-0.0178790074,
-0.0260983575,
0.005110166,
-0.0282058418,
0.0067123678,
-0.0662645474,
-0.010291839,
-0.0022332084,
-0.0353211835,
0.0355456509,
-0.0102391215,
0.0197907537,
-0.0320151895,
-0.0289337803,
0.0528991781,
0.0086740488,
0.0628346056,
0.011395744,
0.0462161899,
-0.0351479761,
-0.0071913572,
-0.0404400192,
0.0170137137,
0.0049035209,
-0.0218808558,
-0.0027608115,
0.030699186,
-0.0692590997,
-0.0074585644,
-0.0622173846,
0.0024541654,
0.0220299568,
0.0440599769,
0.0347993001,
-0.0076099215,
0.010264107,
0.0245371182,
-0.0321956836,
-0.0311371312,
-0.0128988596,
0.0288129598,
-0.0123784179,
0.0340494476,
-0.0111757964,
-0.038755998,
-0.0333782956,
0.0231372137,
0.0417680033,
-0.0322234146,
0.0006007675,
-0.0057721385,
2.628e-7,
0.0406309962,
0.0283381324,
0.0358082838,
0.0362374745,
0.0428782776,
0.0118873185,
-0.0482168384,
0.0005281896,
-0.0101994239,
-0.0049854876,
-0.0047354205,
0.0144579401,
0.0358553566,
0.0203948338,
0.0064515076,
0.0391627662,
-0.0448467284,
-0.005644375,
-0.0487678498,
-0.0146710537,
0.0051252167,
0.09702003,
0.0105005233,
0.0060845148,
-0.0135067208,
-0.0406861566,
0.0284424517,
-0.0124037527,
-0.0468195714,
0.009823421,
-0.0225714855,
0.0036405518,
0.0176978707,
-0.0291205235,
0.0030827615,
0.038242057,
0.038185738,
0.0851044357,
0.022837935,
0.03718419,
-0.0096455757,
-0.0307697114,
-0.0207172427,
-0.0286718383,
0.0753617734,
-0.0236917809,
-0.0510343201,
-0.0074907816,
-0.0090201627,
-0.0369159579,
0.0204594489,
-0.0254650619,
0.0457044393,
0.0048906668,
0.0129197463,
-0.02514432,
-0.0108317388,
-0.0361023732,
-0.0365316011,
0.0311936494,
-0.0694819465,
-0.0683893412,
-0.0529646352,
0.0233769398,
0.0280145742,
-0.0286802258,
-0.0105048837,
2.648818333e-34,
0.0674737468,
-0.0321632139,
0.0401969254,
0.0530840829,
0.0272033643,
-0.0218823235,
-0.0132001638,
0.0322216861,
-0.00349776,
-0.0832125172,
-0.0060822568
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.09136v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09136v1 | A Short Survey of Viewing Large Language Models in Legal Aspect | 2023-03-16T08:01:22 | 2023-03-16T08:01:22 | Zhongxiang Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have transformed many fields, including natural
language processing, computer vision, and reinforcement learning. These models
have also made a significant impact in the field of law, where they are being
increasingly utilized to automate various legal tasks, such as legal judgement
prediction, legal document analysis, and legal document writing. However, the
integration of LLMs into the legal field has also raised several legal
problems, including privacy concerns, bias, and explainability. In this survey,
we explore the integration of LLMs into the field of law. We discuss the
various applications of LLMs in legal tasks, examine the legal challenges that
arise from their use, and explore the data resources that can be used to
specialize LLMs in the legal domain. Finally, we discuss several promising
directions and conclude this paper. By doing so, we hope to provide an overview
of the current state of LLMs in law and highlight the potential benefits and
challenges of their integration. | [
0.059316393,
0.0766199902,
-0.0267777108,
0.0247637145,
-0.0848683268,
0.0209964849,
0.0659440532,
0.0349698178,
0.0212877449,
-0.0704483762,
-0.0014435708,
-0.0409540944,
-0.0006313041,
0.0144431535,
-0.0044553843,
-0.0299900249,
-0.0018538947,
-0.0296607669,
0.0778553113,
-0.0027416777,
0.0082075093,
0.0160766877,
0.0409285426,
0.0384688415,
-0.029067127,
0.0025030649,
0.0040691034,
-0.0236895531,
-0.0291176643,
0.0053347549,
-0.0401973203,
0.0751419663,
0.0452801473,
0.0510924421,
0.0000019066,
-0.0928450599,
0.005606764,
0.0111097451,
-0.0087093357,
0.0489044078,
0.0395179614,
-0.0586892553,
-0.0270760003,
0.0054550786,
-0.0302049518,
0.0291428696,
0.019232614,
0.0177153852,
0.0255673286,
0.0814568922,
-0.0097487718,
-0.0535169989,
0.0390402079,
-0.0471875109,
0.0024905817,
-0.0175356306,
0.0625067577,
0.0149342511,
0.0312080737,
-0.0372798219,
0.0087955045,
0.014185518,
0.0143502075,
-0.0498985127,
-0.0284723621,
-0.0069924337,
-0.0162846148,
0.0018897246,
-0.0118214572,
0.0271058623,
0.0340848155,
-0.0119575337,
0.022553781,
-0.0086375335,
0.0433682725,
0.0276352633,
-0.0341769457,
0.1161717474,
-0.0062545063,
0.0361712053,
0.0194841754,
0.0019597651,
0.0307385065,
0.0530412756,
-0.0227155387,
0.0594097227,
0.0049330997,
-0.0256932583,
-0.0180385858,
-0.0037448197,
0.0195016861,
-0.0643207058,
0.0488099232,
0.0304417554,
-0.0131349387,
0.0444053411,
-0.0584371239,
-0.0158749092,
0.0646900237,
-0.0750682801,
0.0486434363,
-0.019667197,
-0.0054338262,
0.0751135647,
-0.0210670289,
0.027454026,
-0.0182820838,
0.0079775108,
0.0161193814,
-0.0369446911,
-0.0010805997,
-0.0164806545,
0.0008371735,
0.0452829748,
-0.0913818404,
0.0063786265,
-0.0296845101,
0.0359019004,
-0.0282976553,
0.0312807001,
0.0061896625,
-0.0055068219,
0.0147714065,
-0.0574254692,
-0.0811890364,
-0.0633311793,
0.0102431234,
0.046155896,
-0.0090615116,
-0.0151987746,
0.0318525992,
0.0004594032,
-0.0046019405,
-0.0124329356,
-0.0027888173,
0.1134549677,
0.0004702649,
-0.0380694754,
-0.0208285451,
-0.0621020421,
-0.0391291082,
-0.0727220923,
-0.0585352667,
-0.0655013546,
-0.0107139517,
-0.0183374938,
-0.0290395468,
-0.0591475964,
0.0182869714,
0.055086948,
-0.0372559726,
0.079539597,
-0.0160409641,
0.0082385931,
-0.0270048454,
-0.005836051,
0.0381673127,
-0.0018199313,
0.0185773801,
0.0134988576,
0.0159524269,
-0.0155315287,
0.0164044444,
0.0390419401,
-0.0030620063,
0.0228702128,
-0.0399244688,
0.0091079213,
0.0013575138,
0.0214533173,
0.0021860185,
0.062569648,
0.0163646955,
-0.0100938035,
0.066182375,
0.1014907509,
0.0099981306,
0.0406520739,
-0.0045573148,
-0.0030892999,
0.0003412095,
-0.0190610867,
-0.0755417272,
0.0071657333,
-0.0364675187,
-0.0202717837,
-0.042212043,
0.0351397023,
-0.0165772457,
-0.057783857,
-0.0061144573,
-0.0182811394,
0.0153514426,
0.0144962063,
0.0471594632,
-0.0207233243,
-0.0095455218,
-0.0006469315,
0.0329708718,
-0.0124702444,
-0.0174203459,
-0.0430172049,
0.0238756631,
0.0740673393,
0.0525718667,
-0.0170224924,
0.0223655552,
-0.0367813297,
-0.0142517285,
0.0342018642,
0.0194428135,
0.0119714523,
-0.0233915485,
-0.026552178,
-0.0289385188,
0.0169067103,
0.0293989368,
0.0289854296,
0.0077027343,
-0.0054188287,
0.031829752,
-0.0349337608,
-0.026650805,
0.0301839504,
-0.0180445425,
-0.0396765061,
0.028001545,
-0.0051414259,
0.0250931811,
0.0167309362,
0.0054877466,
-0.0073592435,
0.0273266174,
0.006878919,
-0.0088222176,
-0.0057039275,
0.0003785391,
0.0291509479,
0.0378755406,
-0.0235120077,
0.0110849086,
-0.0125519671,
-0.0380060524,
-0.0079541104,
-0.0427776352,
-0.0394418463,
0.0237016082,
-0.0503114313,
0.0118407924,
-0.0069466946,
-0.0166881606,
-0.0353989005,
0.0478473343,
-0.0139161423,
-0.0180004481,
0.001061467,
-0.0131693007,
0.0320658721,
-0.0248644296,
-0.0166323036,
-0.0184409991,
-0.0120252296,
0.0254651364,
0.0235684477,
0.0021726601,
-0.0109966919,
-0.0455260873,
-0.0456320979,
0.004171642,
-0.0141703356,
-0.0019451524,
-0.0225267746,
-0.0245748926,
-0.0164772607,
-0.0261070114,
-0.0233485587,
-0.0190744735,
0.0331564471,
-0.0013096362,
0.0318637602,
-0.0199267138,
-0.0528308749,
-0.0053236904,
-0.0385931693,
-0.0204280615,
0.0442882627,
0.0480773896,
-0.0310503189,
-0.0630625263,
0.0663962662,
-0.006271671,
0.0131875668,
-0.0221270826,
0.0116775176,
-0.029930532,
0.0150347333,
-0.0178304315,
0.0429106131,
0.0477571897,
0.0322391503,
0.0426288657,
0.0125034731,
-0.0469751135,
-0.0274320692,
-0.0092524532,
0.0064527891,
-0.0672877133,
-0.0409695059,
0.0125727523,
0.0219657496,
-0.0074721873,
0.0029883548,
-0.0197643302,
0.0232518986,
-0.0021196578,
-0.0049834121,
-0.0019377484,
-0.0353854522,
-0.0225157887,
0.0550239757,
0.012751,
-0.0961064771,
0.0687737688,
-0.0078057968,
0.0801128969,
-0.0058062417,
-0.0332683399,
-0.0482495315,
0.0924311355,
0.0087683611,
0.0114731956,
-0.0070239273,
-0.0417401753,
0.018316485,
-0.0365926735,
0.0595097654,
-0.041782558,
0.0910763294,
-0.0454350486,
0.0357142277,
-0.007765091,
-0.0348678902,
-0.0315922275,
-0.0654065758,
-0.0364346802,
0.0210845489,
0.0174137913,
0.0070133298,
-0.0242977962,
-0.0006904636,
0.0121105416,
-0.009489214,
0.0229403917,
0.0090081925,
-0.0376418866,
-0.0024296872,
0.009114203,
-0.0237741508,
0.0026623397,
-0.0246224813,
-0.0139118079,
0.0051649781,
-0.0135997152,
0.0175516736,
0.0155391274,
0.0018052157,
-0.0044440883,
-0.0471427701,
-0.0159337744,
0.0614582412,
0.0034937023,
-0.0533856563,
0.046095904,
0.1054961458,
0.0174798127,
-0.0228100978,
-0.0066816784,
0.0208717026,
-0.0118909711,
0.0304602273,
0.0169052761,
-0.1017740518,
0.0161302686,
-0.002329574,
-0.0200846363,
-0.0442615822,
-0.0468876734,
-0.0161624998,
-0.1150695384,
0.0918141827,
0.0253005102,
0.014313777,
-0.0445070155,
-0.0204306561,
-0.014087854,
-0.0038647808,
0.0118932063,
-0.0209117159,
-0.0194927845,
-0.0444055051,
0.0203449093,
-0.0358400121,
-0.001874631,
0.0113234324,
-0.0585423373,
0.0665612891,
0.0383703075,
0.0325843617,
-0.0322193429,
-0.0207836945,
-0.0115607148,
0.0276717003,
0.0109719113,
0.0177347269,
0.0251860078,
0.029799439,
0.0029450131,
-0.0774128065,
0.0503727607,
0.014003682,
-0.02953583,
0.0156561043,
0.0624814928,
-0.0541088134,
-0.01746759,
-0.0195640381,
-0.0322309807,
-0.0071731014,
0.0635851026,
-0.0019266781,
-0.0296826977,
-0.0483682975,
-0.0432640016,
-0.0329387411,
0.0074485797,
-0.0175618064,
-0.0146472752,
-0.0125973355,
-0.0060935831,
-0.0209017899,
0.0078054881,
0.0140085537,
0.0320500992,
0.0250325762,
0.0338950045,
0.0540443696,
-0.0225096121,
-0.026523795,
0.0238255262,
-0.0531163141,
0.0141252717,
-0.0348770544,
0.0306842178,
-0.003926571,
-0.0226841159,
-0.0066980561,
-0.0080112685,
-0.0199735574,
-0.0324989967,
-0.0044916063,
0.001568569,
0.0185741521,
0.0190114584,
-0.0169798117,
-0.0901945457,
0.0636818185,
0.0360104293,
-0.0149325915,
-0.0098807029,
0.0314812399,
-0.0000137963,
-0.0186568946,
0.0046895919,
-0.0171862822,
0.0068541425,
0.0290289093,
-0.0256511811,
-0.0329866521,
-0.0202462599,
0.0357397199,
0.0523081943,
0.0109534459,
-0.0011438804,
-0.0012045347,
-0.0258028768,
-0.0008327494,
-0.0323018581,
-0.007482064,
-0.0259421747,
-0.0183504727,
0.0317922346,
-0.0122931385,
-0.0347232148,
0.0493848622,
-0.0140948659,
0.0048670783,
-0.0439674146,
0.0513769314,
0.0103331916,
-0.0168169905,
0.0394320488,
-0.0211998429,
0.0227118265,
0.0567424558,
-0.0200143289,
0.0496261492,
0.0076854788,
0.0486790836,
0.0032965185,
-0.0046564471,
-0.0223817453,
-0.0030584501,
-0.0215027072,
-0.0549659617,
0.0052816547,
0.0612851605,
0.0479536057,
-0.003934748,
0.0058380966,
-0.0692181513,
-0.0091407038,
-0.0068241581,
0.0255890936,
0.0131472526,
-0.0499781705,
0.0459179729,
0.0101028141,
-0.0308662504,
0.0350907743,
0.0428498797,
0.0269383043,
0.0201558396,
-0.0302542057,
-0.0323619805,
-0.0129333884,
-0.0415608957,
0.0069585871,
0.0078247599,
-0.0308638737,
-0.0393681489,
-0.0748375207,
-0.043049559,
-0.0115577504,
-0.013276414,
-0.016061822,
-0.0216061361,
-0.0012610793,
0.0423115455,
0.0194912683,
-0.009020173,
-0.0505473129,
0.0363330059,
0.0032832304,
-0.0252655186,
-0.0043431283,
-5.597366144e-33,
-0.0152525473,
-0.0624721684,
0.0139386589,
0.007110754,
0.0069487724,
-0.0144952778,
0.0039141285,
-0.0119196931,
0.0116148265,
0.0170271806,
-0.0140030766,
0.0157286581,
0.0148213161,
0.0146716917,
0.0113132801,
-0.016374357,
0.0073224753,
-0.0034673046,
0.0160382316,
0.0089594871,
-0.0095018484,
0.0008972022,
0.005479706,
-0.0992093608,
0.0485991798,
0.0543688349,
-0.0385551266,
-0.0096310088,
-0.0874012113,
0.0501090884,
-0.0279034115,
0.0411820412,
0.0161748193,
-0.0444267057,
-0.0123590622,
0.076606907,
-0.0329765901,
0.0293795783,
0.0288403705,
-0.0121131046,
0.0243920796,
-0.0394680202,
0.0518059842,
-0.0058514411,
-0.0473229922,
0.0140389698,
0.0386753082,
-0.0551094674,
-0.042670548,
-0.0354065374,
-0.0672945604,
0.0500898995,
-0.0195650496,
0.0224740691,
0.0563139208,
-0.0133430837,
-0.0076751676,
0.0407475121,
-0.0367354155,
0.0252072047,
0.0125223594,
-0.0275402162,
0.0568006001,
-0.0427823514,
0.0031104658,
0.0820385814,
0.0163702685,
0.0119852405,
-0.0555578731,
-0.0310865007,
0.0184364002,
0.0899937153,
0.04286623,
0.0531605668,
-0.0050822143,
-0.0241055042,
-0.0687908903,
-0.03774276,
-0.001588281,
0.0108671347,
0.0634587854,
-0.0360816009,
-0.0543802604,
-0.0274006035,
-0.053547591,
-0.0298902579,
-0.0039824517,
0.0229873843,
0.0115834558,
0.0145994499,
0.0297913067,
-0.0043832147,
-0.0018652047,
-0.06326662,
-0.0201535504,
0.029956013,
0.0120962467,
0.0193442162,
-0.0183776878,
0.0151884295,
-0.0627040491,
-0.0403088965,
-0.0057576927,
-0.0430215411,
0.0022109021,
0.0009547033,
0.035390649,
-0.0116294054,
-0.0676419139,
0.0077928342,
0.0010584987,
0.0306458231,
0.0590388514,
0.0061928695,
0.0289440732,
0.0116565535,
0.0278120376,
0.0246444568,
0.0194092765,
-0.0251945443,
0.0056029451,
-0.015973771,
-0.0260190703,
0.003070425,
0.005086829,
0.0121227168,
-0.0070832595,
0.035646908,
0.06153965,
0.0066678133,
0.0172996931,
0.0278888866,
2.521e-7,
0.066256389,
0.0668192953,
-0.0170683712,
0.0174628701,
0.0032045019,
0.0483076386,
0.0161073115,
0.0411754996,
0.0194438435,
-0.025927376,
0.0195809789,
0.0027439438,
0.0545022674,
0.0171662625,
-0.0477170534,
0.0065975743,
-0.0530802608,
-0.0474767685,
-0.0939683467,
0.0408502482,
0.0357565507,
0.0932807326,
0.0373223349,
-0.0271094702,
-0.0046368428,
-0.0424007736,
0.0526329689,
-0.0612641647,
-0.0324271582,
-0.0169841498,
0.0686771348,
-0.0239944607,
-0.0167285092,
0.0399988368,
0.0140549364,
0.0699509829,
-0.0498336665,
0.0783532634,
0.0034483632,
0.0562056154,
-0.0205060486,
-0.0571501106,
-0.0077342023,
-0.0375890918,
0.0592262261,
-0.0101052625,
-0.0271985158,
-0.0429052673,
0.013459418,
-0.0690581575,
0.0086470963,
0.0179374479,
0.0183934569,
-0.0299349055,
0.0269832015,
-0.0252397396,
0.0195806921,
-0.0914851129,
-0.0065466031,
0.0264415666,
-0.0311597325,
0.025783537,
-0.024589099,
0.0156970136,
0.0679492429,
-0.0842172131,
0.0494637899,
2.140347461e-34,
0.0193202831,
-0.0081536751,
-0.0113052186,
0.0157961156,
0.0381206237,
0.0631719157,
-0.0210076198,
0.0294334684,
0.0019730681,
-0.1015037224,
0.0319956727
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.09128v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09128v2 | Exploring Distributional Shifts in Large Language Models for Code Analysis | 2023-03-16T07:45:46 | 2023-12-05T19:25:52 | Shushan Arakelyan, Rocktim Jyoti Das, Yi Mao, Xiang Ren | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SE | We systematically study how three large language models with code
capabilities - CodeT5, Codex, and ChatGPT - generalize to out-of-domain data.
We consider two fundamental applications - code summarization, and code
generation. We split data into domains following its natural boundaries - by an
organization, by a project, and by a module within the software project. We
establish that samples from each new domain present all the models with a
significant challenge of distribution shift. We study how established methods
adapt models to better generalize to new domains. Our experiments show that
while multitask learning alone is a reasonable baseline, combining it with
few-shot finetuning on examples retrieved from training data can achieve very
strong performance. Moreover, this solution can outperform direct finetuning
for very low-data scenarios. Finally, we consider variations of this approach
to create a more broadly applicable method to adapt to multiple domains at
once. We find that for code generation, a model adapted to multiple domains
simultaneously performs on par with those adapted to a single domain | [
0.0143157439,
0.0680441186,
-0.0204753149,
-0.0011751632,
-0.0072159912,
0.0165698174,
-0.0290813129,
-0.0152083645,
-0.0344570503,
-0.0260735154,
-0.0184715092,
-0.0203407221,
0.0068647084,
0.0440195017,
0.0502037741,
-0.0166231319,
0.0083677666,
-0.0426080823,
-0.044711493,
0.0032107709,
-0.0038301253,
0.0267187003,
0.0331857838,
0.0603098199,
0.0212376676,
-0.0300482456,
-0.0027037386,
0.0189594552,
0.0023770989,
0.0006620123,
0.0342402048,
0.0340739302,
0.015873719,
0.0156082204,
0.0000021523,
-0.0195942689,
-0.0439211614,
0.0083358185,
0.0489415154,
0.0500114486,
0.0379905887,
-0.0334763229,
0.0054657846,
0.0278594811,
-0.0368812643,
-0.0179290567,
0.0819712356,
-0.0462584049,
0.0471413247,
0.0451513492,
-0.0054636789,
-0.027363576,
-0.0161515102,
-0.0324771143,
-0.0375036709,
-0.0473606773,
0.0207711272,
0.055962868,
0.0246151332,
-0.0198669825,
-0.0249603055,
0.0377424732,
0.0149053028,
0.0164274238,
0.0016638187,
0.0615702532,
-0.044312302,
0.0066206446,
0.0159638338,
0.0408033654,
-0.0827476084,
-0.0407650657,
0.0281244162,
-0.0275849625,
-0.0256077386,
-0.0098980013,
-0.0197754074,
0.0229386054,
-0.0105265183,
0.0019171884,
0.0167832021,
-0.0359050333,
0.0206951443,
-0.0130711952,
-0.06397558,
0.0155385192,
-0.0020759238,
0.0083189998,
-0.032417275,
-0.0005868862,
-0.0278529786,
-0.0443749242,
-0.0366847366,
0.039802663,
-0.0191932376,
0.005199308,
-0.0361724645,
-0.0304948334,
0.0184660163,
-0.0146207558,
0.0435011946,
0.0218471419,
-0.0381307378,
-0.0034353288,
-0.029241275,
0.0367828123,
-0.0125090312,
-0.004341878,
-0.0409004092,
0.0042605116,
-0.0793497041,
0.0067104711,
-0.0540199876,
0.0535551868,
-0.0221245233,
0.0246705282,
-0.0288426224,
0.0524415448,
0.0091033485,
0.019469481,
-0.0004797251,
-0.0340388753,
-0.0483654737,
0.0146843176,
0.0725797936,
0.01357505,
-0.0242963471,
-0.0201685745,
-0.0159953255,
-0.0298709925,
-0.0092426697,
0.0031340229,
-0.0320564434,
-0.0205519032,
0.0076921084,
0.0602690876,
0.0087505309,
0.0214578062,
-0.0216649529,
-0.023171775,
-0.029515069,
-0.0342370793,
-0.0265907571,
-0.1143317521,
-0.0632198974,
0.0365355983,
0.0003171039,
-0.0568548478,
-0.0234743301,
-0.0281039514,
-0.0302881058,
0.0167388301,
-0.0273442082,
0.0311985333,
0.0214121379,
-0.0060204007,
-0.0071728928,
0.0821561739,
0.0346764289,
0.0029410948,
0.0009877747,
-0.0233289544,
0.0283131674,
0.0660834312,
-0.0004396408,
0.025986243,
0.0062266239,
0.0258617233,
0.0291682538,
-0.0463575497,
0.0355960652,
0.0051073451,
-0.0201044139,
0.0489373207,
0.0017502725,
0.0215091929,
0.0453185961,
-0.0013504949,
0.0644824058,
0.0122606866,
-0.0279352218,
0.0175575688,
-0.0402363874,
0.0246800371,
0.0331554525,
0.0393681861,
0.0044679684,
0.0456183329,
-0.0245153289,
-0.0303226206,
0.009466459,
-0.0131785655,
-0.0140924295,
-0.0100000817,
0.0560343191,
0.00130688,
-0.0333377831,
0.0208934303,
0.0444396175,
-0.0338490643,
-0.0240949113,
-0.0489415489,
-0.0050612995,
0.0069027636,
0.0355768353,
-0.0824341103,
-0.0297003444,
-0.0177878309,
0.0314503498,
-0.0207192507,
0.0373660289,
-0.0212534908,
0.0191773456,
-0.038891755,
-0.0307858698,
-0.0376640894,
0.0125254439,
0.0577766746,
-0.0082255369,
-0.0217935517,
0.0226370431,
-0.0273085758,
-0.0532257333,
0.0284635201,
-0.044112727,
0.0273527876,
0.0309890974,
0.0047338293,
0.0106000686,
-0.041942697,
-0.0696115717,
-0.0041597141,
0.0041381726,
-0.0222648196,
-0.0092572393,
-0.0356498845,
-0.0139328642,
-0.0140259769,
0.0160923433,
-0.0460933633,
0.0053566149,
0.0083464663,
-0.0374912471,
-0.028574517,
0.046260085,
0.0013702684,
0.0302660279,
0.0200955961,
0.0204181187,
-0.0374715813,
0.010107425,
-0.0376939438,
0.0420342311,
0.0210862067,
0.0271613523,
0.0015512037,
0.0314242095,
0.0386739075,
0.0458813533,
-0.0153317899,
0.004389205,
-0.0357191004,
0.0665250495,
0.0227770694,
0.037844345,
-0.0197662823,
-0.0649670959,
-0.0777924508,
0.0228195582,
-0.0333486125,
0.0336475894,
0.0291074701,
0.0479988419,
-0.0017333688,
-0.0056060031,
-0.0211939327,
-0.0358715877,
-0.0288908333,
0.0213429835,
0.0212395806,
0.0040872386,
-0.0435857549,
-0.0456964709,
-0.007139524,
-0.0238700304,
0.0479447693,
-0.0440107286,
-0.0271125045,
-0.0874683559,
0.0966187045,
-0.0089481119,
0.0213282816,
-0.0311733466,
-0.0538492873,
0.0046600592,
-0.0251964778,
0.0954475775,
0.0224032123,
-0.0170337241,
0.0061061876,
0.066702567,
0.008769528,
-0.0437894352,
0.005971462,
0.0262635052,
-0.0538746603,
-0.0141151631,
-0.0067339828,
0.025083974,
0.0808025599,
0.0125143947,
-0.0282392539,
-0.0554983132,
0.0073357676,
-0.0225037541,
0.0182653442,
0.015301832,
-0.0005978015,
-0.0043335827,
0.0514603108,
-0.0032858413,
-0.0817087069,
0.0441017225,
-0.0109756682,
-0.0085762776,
-0.0432449058,
-0.0439399071,
-0.0673892424,
0.0479377508,
-0.0010898784,
0.020864889,
0.0375704207,
-0.0442226566,
-0.0658161119,
-0.0032544248,
0.0016484626,
-0.0111672599,
0.0932699069,
-0.0542563796,
0.020554956,
-0.0256412476,
-0.0222674478,
-0.0030532214,
-0.0350321382,
-0.0087423995,
0.0255658645,
0.0377721749,
0.0039228862,
0.0114030307,
0.0460825823,
0.0044154553,
0.0631751642,
0.0111222994,
-0.0485832766,
-0.0241301637,
-0.0170271415,
0.0178537238,
-0.044970382,
-0.05011677,
-0.0392058082,
-0.0323700458,
-0.0254343878,
0.0454796366,
0.0411723815,
-0.0386711508,
-0.0210256986,
0.0171205085,
-0.0155078936,
-0.0365364663,
0.044504147,
0.0708389655,
-0.0221648999,
-0.0292652268,
0.0821639523,
0.0330673307,
-0.0496310629,
0.0190310013,
0.0108202277,
0.0563575923,
0.0661169887,
0.0488392413,
-0.0714092553,
-0.0209532995,
-0.0238387398,
0.0305690132,
-0.006737954,
-0.0058463374,
-0.0247153863,
-0.1045787036,
0.0168457627,
0.0110290693,
-0.0725322217,
-0.0384368636,
-0.0146216694,
0.008070427,
-0.0089967968,
-0.0389866121,
0.0157950334,
-0.0170065444,
0.0184842162,
0.0249150358,
-0.035475947,
-0.0309793111,
0.0340079553,
-0.0364301577,
0.0289692841,
0.1037743911,
0.0171476994,
-0.0003956,
0.0382768884,
0.0351751857,
-0.0543081164,
0.0158592109,
-0.0064112474,
0.0700447485,
0.0180815142,
-0.02879804,
0.0807596222,
0.0169508401,
-0.0501591563,
0.011295869,
0.0460035577,
0.034931317,
-0.0043055648,
-0.0239522681,
0.0108827958,
-0.0020172861,
0.0112819104,
0.010885003,
0.0411616974,
-0.0389168896,
-0.018902434,
-0.0552901439,
-0.02060402,
-0.0302753318,
0.0136037869,
0.0009924666,
-0.0185190421,
-0.0236989819,
-0.059160661,
0.0153329633,
0.0193601865,
0.0656738356,
0.0374191441,
0.0108522335,
0.0082630403,
-0.0011774474,
-0.048009444,
-0.0207543056,
-0.0298071392,
0.0292141065,
-0.0167484973,
-0.0277185179,
0.046831321,
-0.0433512479,
-0.0317659192,
-0.002272625,
-0.1276207119,
-0.0704837516,
-0.0344067663,
0.0318282656,
0.0236449242,
0.0441348888,
-0.0360585526,
-0.0347732641,
-0.0071251253,
0.0491438136,
-0.0595225431,
0.0233254544,
0.0332228281,
-0.0224930476,
-0.0082972739,
0.0051531275,
-0.0952742621,
0.0240455214,
0.0073500117,
-0.0269962251,
-0.0311259571,
0.0044412608,
0.0083522061,
-0.0100070434,
0.0163596179,
0.0230869558,
-0.0560990237,
-0.0217955969,
-0.0119296499,
0.0369514041,
-0.0274182707,
-0.041738838,
0.0132663725,
0.0149274413,
-0.0151966223,
0.0199924,
0.0483004861,
0.0136612309,
0.0485903658,
-0.0282336026,
0.03566771,
0.0214119051,
0.0389262289,
0.0740375817,
-0.0068745562,
-0.0228309724,
-0.0045839604,
0.0022653006,
0.0227721129,
-0.0125629809,
0.0405569337,
0.0294014178,
0.0537681282,
0.0226689614,
0.0093875108,
-0.0674860775,
-0.0510482192,
-0.0184015539,
-0.0041446327,
0.0484552979,
0.0248369891,
0.0659740716,
-0.0019495941,
0.0293715876,
-0.0268725101,
0.081384182,
-0.0006252264,
-0.0097104181,
-0.0029718087,
0.009938621,
-0.0309142694,
-0.0204419643,
0.1280476451,
0.0217408389,
0.0180996004,
-0.0201253779,
-0.0152192768,
-0.0341371261,
0.0224430803,
0.0507968962,
-0.0059115258,
-0.0029023832,
0.0063163564,
-0.0419068672,
-0.0297330339,
-0.0139262406,
0.011334396,
0.0301822796,
-0.0144898212,
0.0255299117,
0.1059472859,
0.0052717454,
0.0132322479,
-0.0433386788,
-0.0111906193,
0.0438277498,
-0.0173025187,
-0.0073543224,
-6.163575324e-33,
-0.0107440967,
-0.0134968087,
0.0125143304,
0.0232191626,
-0.0051321005,
0.0034213667,
-0.039562352,
-0.003864818,
-0.0162448585,
-0.0496144928,
0.0263871737,
0.0261374656,
-0.0034075717,
-0.0299689472,
0.0571099371,
0.0236902013,
0.0531647541,
0.0267929919,
-0.0363630392,
0.065194115,
-0.0247387569,
0.0370415784,
0.0319748968,
-0.0421395674,
-0.0149065126,
0.0035844636,
0.0317446329,
-0.0196804777,
0.0549021699,
0.0179573447,
0.0117594358,
0.0049861809,
-0.000458902,
-0.048079174,
-0.0393235944,
-0.0530485176,
-0.0202781875,
0.002763385,
0.0265764855,
-0.0195049513,
0.0320919752,
-0.0565218031,
0.0594356433,
-0.0005770693,
0.021820534,
-0.0435219668,
0.0451776609,
-0.014370162,
-0.0158031024,
-0.058719296,
-0.0958063006,
0.0478550121,
-0.0324091315,
-0.0262615476,
-0.011940998,
0.022641724,
0.0113921594,
0.0502102077,
0.0317871198,
0.0005198178,
0.0141445836,
0.056492269,
0.0770687833,
0.0257349517,
-0.0138768423,
0.0124163544,
-0.011138658,
0.0519042686,
0.0147182569,
-0.0286604986,
0.0550661683,
0.0467872322,
-0.0238751546,
0.0180331748,
0.0214245673,
-0.007125773,
-0.0514598116,
-0.0027393892,
-0.0171225145,
-0.0212118682,
0.0377512164,
0.0403655246,
-0.0350744836,
-0.0132387457,
-0.0311776716,
-0.0099373199,
-0.0089710224,
-0.0245059803,
0.0354528204,
0.000933509,
-0.0179587211,
0.0130874822,
0.0298222564,
-0.0671399683,
-0.0004468614,
0.0430788174,
-0.0751337633,
0.0339978412,
-0.0204464197,
0.014188529,
-0.0168791711,
-0.0222704764,
0.0106077371,
0.0357508287,
0.0756917149,
0.0144280298,
0.0521352254,
0.0214652177,
-0.0782585666,
-0.012764209,
-0.0462491103,
0.0058116815,
-0.0235679168,
0.0680655167,
0.008053639,
-0.0140228216,
0.0122420006,
0.0215667151,
0.0101660434,
-0.0583582446,
-0.0378777236,
0.028820781,
0.0053258999,
0.0196632668,
-0.0503203347,
-0.0207951926,
-0.0274394397,
0.0377952605,
0.0612243749,
-0.0191712603,
-0.0693980604,
0.0110453246,
2.825e-7,
0.0419509634,
0.0396455415,
-0.0029001508,
0.0376534238,
0.0040331134,
0.0353798755,
-0.0471101403,
0.012475118,
0.022080211,
0.0034132551,
-0.0192782432,
0.0032365655,
0.049416665,
0.0351442546,
-0.0649715364,
-0.0001065971,
-0.0006530714,
0.0012390142,
-0.0605153106,
-0.0055447486,
0.0162097551,
0.0950357467,
0.0106487041,
0.0011971307,
0.0267158467,
-0.0641658232,
0.0113844126,
0.0107410913,
0.0141555909,
0.0540142171,
-0.0871631503,
0.0241280738,
-0.0264931675,
0.0029556861,
-0.010102245,
-0.0148236454,
0.0384874754,
0.0526826233,
-0.0021871654,
0.0910250023,
0.0465974882,
-0.0148069756,
-0.0116096614,
-0.0689883605,
0.0395232923,
-0.0830800459,
0.0002345057,
-0.0291574113,
0.0108684301,
0.0210950337,
-0.0274268556,
0.0003305645,
0.042599339,
0.0357658155,
-0.005572076,
-0.0345785022,
-0.019960301,
-0.0392073542,
-0.0504859984,
0.0617242903,
0.0028506466,
-0.0576771498,
-0.0330549181,
-0.0066945264,
0.02322766,
-0.0597199015,
0.0505554378,
2.839485583e-34,
0.051208809,
-0.0501384623,
-0.0055665472,
0.0049504605,
0.0223280676,
-0.0344587155,
-0.0321424156,
0.0043157199,
-0.0066774031,
-0.0230998676,
-0.02331057
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.09100v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09100v2 | Patch-Prompt Aligned Bayesian Prompt Tuning for Vision-Language Models | 2023-03-16T06:09:15 | 2024-07-01T15:29:45 | Xinyang Liu, Dongsheng Wang, Bowei Fang, Miaoge Li, Zhibin Duan, Yishi Xu, Bo Chen, Mingyuan Zhou | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | For downstream applications of vision-language pre-trained models, there has
been significant interest in constructing effective prompts. Existing works on
prompt engineering, which either require laborious manual designs or optimize
the prompt tuning as a point estimation problem, may fail to describe diverse
characteristics of categories and limit their applications. We introduce a
Bayesian probabilistic resolution to prompt tuning, where the label-specific
stochastic prompts are generated hierarchically by first sampling a latent
vector from an underlying distribution and then employing a lightweight
generative model. Importantly, we semantically regularize the tuning process by
minimizing the statistical distance between the visual patches and linguistic
prompts, which pushes the stochastic label representations to faithfully
capture diverse visual concepts, instead of overfitting the training
categories. We evaluate the effectiveness of our approach on four tasks:
few-shot image recognition, base-to-new generalization, dataset transfer
learning, and domain shifts. Extensive results over 15 datasets show promising
transferability and generalization performance of our proposed model, both
quantitatively and qualitatively. | [
0.0241216589,
0.052517157,
0.0111973258,
0.0205886904,
-0.0164469462,
0.004572385,
0.0398161784,
-0.015914686,
-0.008873363,
-0.0595590286,
-0.0415102094,
-0.0436173901,
0.0149984201,
0.0526113547,
0.0156672262,
-0.0784529299,
0.0159036741,
-0.0611173473,
0.0290983934,
0.0023930811,
0.0013945894,
-0.00276035,
-0.0155973136,
0.0269315001,
-0.0253017116,
-0.0148089882,
0.0002347306,
0.0487794578,
0.0255416147,
-0.0141294654,
0.0008867197,
0.0570732243,
0.0217051413,
-0.0152805839,
0.0000020194,
-0.0654244497,
0.0309345126,
-0.008030693,
-0.0080381921,
-0.0295886956,
0.0282214005,
-0.0601723939,
-0.005726845,
-0.0222911816,
0.0060674357,
-0.0429628566,
0.0806203559,
-0.0000494832,
0.0199550577,
0.045930773,
-0.0309092086,
-0.0037442804,
-0.0185799189,
-0.0295822192,
0.0615976639,
-0.0622692332,
0.0187817588,
-0.0086681731,
-0.0000809644,
0.0057624057,
-0.0719717145,
0.0244023893,
-0.0119342012,
-0.0144233648,
0.0373496264,
0.0328435265,
0.0332422629,
-0.0340861939,
-0.0553637147,
0.0561892539,
-0.0245706122,
-0.0021241312,
-0.0261478387,
-0.044717636,
0.0171408132,
0.0423610583,
-0.0382756293,
0.0308154635,
-0.0114255482,
0.0195555966,
-0.0187324006,
-0.0166039467,
0.0132011697,
-0.0296828616,
-0.0057270308,
0.0266023818,
0.038097091,
0.0196489822,
0.0012156637,
0.0139902998,
-0.0305548273,
-0.0650693774,
-0.0242263433,
0.0063247127,
-0.0329116769,
0.0141137866,
-0.0871246457,
0.0173288435,
-0.0142783811,
0.0264490787,
0.0583794937,
0.0316661634,
-0.1039164364,
0.0729785636,
-0.0021560802,
0.0469748825,
0.0041451114,
0.0565528721,
-0.0417741947,
-0.0195508655,
-0.0134105487,
0.0256107114,
-0.0557732023,
-0.0399378203,
-0.0082483236,
-0.0223312918,
-0.0288392939,
0.0311401356,
0.0044053928,
-0.0304081179,
0.0338389315,
-0.003508576,
-0.0719133168,
-0.0251432266,
-0.014469211,
0.0259637181,
-0.0417520255,
0.0129623469,
0.0354627781,
-0.0527337119,
-0.0209637918,
0.038008526,
0.0298563968,
-0.0297768693,
-0.0197614897,
0.0506057404,
-0.0369401909,
-0.03860965,
-0.0343851559,
0.016238628,
-0.0465720184,
-0.0096595725,
0.0272908546,
-0.0394837968,
0.0182347354,
-0.0105205374,
0.0292727556,
-0.0693578795,
-0.014458484,
-0.0285317693,
-0.0300712548,
0.0883580148,
-0.018404346,
0.0161192715,
0.0208522733,
-0.0187319051,
-0.0161039773,
0.0552637726,
-0.0000699232,
0.0335907936,
0.0407658666,
0.0023302387,
0.0278501511,
0.0544337295,
-0.024378987,
0.022334693,
-0.0391436145,
-0.022755824,
0.0526080094,
0.0061927503,
0.055933658,
0.0074025113,
-0.0109927803,
-0.0280769132,
0.0431168713,
0.0270519797,
-0.0283799134,
-0.0528711341,
0.0791872516,
0.0015472306,
-0.0232855361,
-0.0139601929,
-0.0512670502,
0.0188400913,
-0.017446164,
-0.0011957509,
-0.0159486886,
0.0175591018,
-0.0472758301,
-0.0087673683,
0.0077178739,
0.0063544116,
-0.0371715501,
0.0151941804,
0.0506138876,
0.0263817739,
-0.0189580284,
0.0162254367,
0.0194632448,
-0.0106739178,
0.0238465741,
-0.0409917645,
0.016060723,
0.0484841317,
-0.0015637632,
-0.0171997007,
0.0191088524,
-0.0007933944,
0.0648357272,
0.0525023602,
0.030519966,
-0.0054469989,
0.0288505983,
-0.0425141826,
-0.0783332884,
0.0222572908,
0.0215508379,
0.0474167019,
-0.0314550065,
-0.0073143779,
0.0133725703,
-0.0211367216,
0.0121917874,
0.0479609333,
0.0303888004,
-0.0246250425,
0.0163086392,
0.0236887597,
0.0053066541,
-0.043287158,
-0.0102510015,
-0.0003160803,
0.0023238172,
-0.0298029575,
0.0470139422,
-0.0011744399,
-0.0142965876,
-0.0119863516,
0.0247567482,
-0.0186422858,
0.0095681371,
-0.0239229016,
-0.0572308078,
-0.0448823273,
-0.0091620162,
0.0102568632,
-0.0365565345,
-0.0265629273,
0.0152490065,
0.0161883701,
0.0196894463,
-0.0549426936,
0.0367042348,
0.0040446152,
-0.0239596143,
0.0335825421,
0.0330209509,
0.0122678801,
-0.0476253778,
-0.0041429563,
-0.0020683233,
-0.0137506397,
0.0099479277,
0.0373146646,
0.0257646963,
-0.0192460753,
-0.0118506169,
-0.0666395798,
-0.0271196943,
-0.0436874032,
-0.0288241711,
0.0132318335,
0.0010076535,
-0.0277748164,
-0.0433093272,
-0.0256114192,
0.0215675049,
0.0007890019,
0.023204511,
0.0077943481,
0.025691187,
-0.0167294517,
-0.0236264523,
-0.0087162461,
0.02850914,
0.0524481647,
0.0297201201,
-0.0493328981,
-0.0652688444,
0.0183165297,
-0.0033184378,
0.0451887809,
-0.019923294,
0.019310629,
0.0114919143,
-0.0470846146,
0.0524364784,
0.0635919496,
-0.0111608151,
0.0163681991,
0.0052926983,
-0.0074249199,
-0.0166555736,
-0.0081143156,
-0.0505411513,
-0.0880059972,
-0.0317825787,
-0.0182033498,
-0.0104950666,
0.0638488606,
0.0019786889,
-0.0073439041,
-0.1034066156,
0.0383707546,
-0.0018590587,
-0.0382550396,
-0.1078321412,
0.0325436443,
0.0027356923,
0.0590886809,
-0.0327713788,
-0.0891239569,
0.0386438854,
-0.0304160845,
0.0103151305,
0.008426385,
0.0148396362,
0.012821096,
0.0578190945,
0.0328746401,
0.0054863272,
0.0392080881,
-0.0002076114,
-0.1017026678,
0.0105685899,
0.0119232852,
0.0157989711,
0.0118546961,
-0.0779163018,
0.0378014334,
-0.0177379008,
0.0075985747,
-0.0428872257,
-0.0395179428,
-0.0174089596,
9.366e-7,
-0.0325945243,
-0.0033675858,
0.0081357276,
0.0179013405,
-0.0098874392,
0.0589259006,
-0.0042883498,
-0.0071761929,
-0.0151290288,
0.0311959293,
0.0693258941,
0.0166658685,
-0.0330569968,
-0.0166576542,
-0.0250036325,
-0.0085611604,
0.034858536,
-0.0163137522,
-0.0225453563,
0.0277636666,
0.052910123,
0.0296809543,
0.006192592,
0.0697661191,
0.0665872246,
-0.0198206734,
-0.0289487746,
0.0608063675,
0.0205464717,
-0.0477593765,
-0.0263238512,
0.0346276462,
0.0380589403,
0.0304146595,
0.0140771559,
-0.0939284787,
-0.0432614759,
-0.0110888183,
0.0095181195,
0.0263250247,
0.0021637592,
-0.0370683521,
-0.0881728455,
0.04830084,
0.0113186585,
-0.0262499526,
-0.0135818571,
0.0216189977,
0.0122824023,
-0.0005296117,
-0.031602636,
-0.0065075923,
-0.0111492584,
0.0146504706,
0.0116636083,
0.042307537,
-0.0451268181,
0.0304850843,
-0.0181934405,
0.0360996798,
0.0562980548,
-0.0472226962,
0.0107757021,
-0.0695246384,
0.0412181318,
-0.0210578125,
0.0003292322,
0.0046170629,
0.0103744362,
-0.0275461841,
-0.0372612067,
0.0690409914,
0.0429988727,
-0.0157765113,
-0.0492837019,
-0.008585508,
0.0367991999,
-0.0159770697,
-0.0037920768,
-0.0281027388,
-0.0196065251,
0.0535678938,
0.0457905605,
0.0243444555,
-0.0582402684,
-0.0003156452,
-0.0339873992,
-0.0095638577,
-0.036531698,
-0.0166369006,
0.0283598509,
-0.0064882706,
-0.0612381436,
-0.0623497106,
-0.0076040132,
0.0447198153,
0.0285672694,
0.014274477,
-0.0343647152,
-0.0347821601,
0.0254636426,
-0.0406045541,
0.0901613012,
-0.0482749902,
0.017694911,
-0.0969409272,
-0.041871205,
0.0149765201,
-0.0571419485,
-0.0314983688,
0.0063255262,
-0.0538768806,
-0.0415556841,
-0.0052826516,
0.0848338604,
0.0088165868,
0.039598491,
-0.0287039317,
-0.0753032938,
0.0310674123,
0.0481875762,
0.038598422,
0.0237467941,
0.0043695862,
-0.0251589976,
-0.0342998803,
0.0238922071,
-0.0618998744,
0.0541916005,
0.0528623834,
0.019616954,
0.0197464079,
-0.0617764927,
0.0147065371,
-0.0080925589,
0.1092262343,
-0.0613905862,
-0.0017668802,
-0.0489750169,
-0.0005942489,
0.0243360624,
-0.0041700448,
-0.0685695037,
-0.0035439027,
0.0263526272,
-0.0047268854,
0.0245274026,
0.0093949735,
-0.0323249437,
0.0632637367,
-0.033295799,
-0.0455429405,
0.0288136937,
0.0270001385,
0.0120165572,
0.0412030369,
0.018628398,
0.0406059027,
0.0024866946,
0.0182461999,
0.0146984002,
0.0712405443,
0.039196942,
-0.0021580791,
-0.0107278321,
0.0151713761,
-0.0309325829,
-0.0564319268,
-0.0454046018,
0.0514425524,
0.0281414166,
0.0155144352,
-0.0021351189,
0.0121121919,
-0.0216513816,
-0.0415415727,
0.0628843606,
0.0731830671,
-0.0415183306,
0.084390983,
0.0154225053,
-0.0152468774,
-0.0240670852,
0.0581059158,
0.0381106101,
0.0242475048,
-0.021425372,
0.0311796833,
-0.0316842273,
-0.0117582539,
0.0101395007,
-0.0137631455,
-0.00604069,
0.0482583381,
-0.0407725014,
-0.031541571,
-0.009265299,
0.0206270032,
-0.0119613344,
0.0562826172,
0.0698092654,
0.047004059,
-0.0421529599,
0.008390788,
-0.029687332,
-0.0267973077,
0.0190281998,
-0.003116695,
0.0189664233,
-6.064508701e-33,
-0.0511272587,
0.0022764329,
0.0232745111,
-0.0206546709,
0.0385850444,
-0.0343411304,
-0.0244468283,
0.0170719903,
-0.0094496226,
0.0213831328,
-0.0046744859,
-0.0292358063,
0.0374323241,
0.0462501012,
-0.0127368253,
-0.0028223365,
0.0590315163,
0.0006899314,
-0.0244630203,
0.0115887439,
0.0121427746,
0.0272250175,
0.0378187373,
-0.0257682465,
0.0153354835,
0.0078257192,
-0.0356245153,
0.028399583,
0.0609891526,
0.0443769656,
-0.00594217,
0.0298547857,
0.0009324695,
-0.0113757839,
-0.0285629407,
0.0505001508,
-0.0493962131,
-0.0236044563,
0.0103618065,
0.022715224,
-0.0655935109,
-0.0230278298,
-0.0322209001,
-0.0146949869,
-0.0031605961,
-0.0298279282,
0.0487470888,
-0.052181989,
-0.0408164635,
-0.0160657428,
-0.0453298092,
-0.0042140177,
0.0244581327,
-0.0314318687,
0.0160232056,
0.0373682752,
0.006864659,
0.0480620973,
0.0112909535,
0.0188645925,
0.0418173969,
0.0328725092,
0.0685924441,
0.1202700958,
0.0015732038,
0.0311465785,
0.0280623678,
-0.0380715132,
0.0289381389,
-0.0114233801,
0.0218497198,
0.0179865826,
0.0144053139,
0.0631433427,
0.0317153558,
0.0260328036,
-0.0597844571,
0.0208039042,
-0.0402483456,
0.0011864788,
-0.0160603877,
0.024806086,
0.0189855639,
-0.0108864531,
-0.063445501,
-0.0432211384,
-0.023723403,
0.0064171441,
0.0618442744,
0.0314132422,
-0.0361227468,
0.0186534431,
0.0834759995,
-0.0219309255,
-0.019126758,
-0.0259516612,
-0.006863914,
0.0296031144,
-0.0031627535,
0.0221178923,
-0.0532424711,
-0.0228946209,
0.0559904575,
-0.0007864418,
-0.0042474177,
0.0261384808,
0.0298777241,
0.035414435,
-0.0498793796,
0.0243492555,
-0.0321116559,
0.0182207227,
-0.0127242031,
0.0691845939,
0.0056814463,
0.0117746908,
-0.0395373218,
0.0812200978,
-0.0088089043,
-0.0584206358,
0.0319144912,
-0.0011553045,
0.0084821787,
0.0450203642,
-0.0248015989,
0.0126412977,
-0.001196694,
0.0045712972,
0.053737998,
-0.0275678691,
-0.0131190903,
0.0266742781,
2.725e-7,
0.0395387784,
-0.0138590811,
-0.0172484759,
-0.0032821044,
0.0024423939,
0.0325006023,
-0.0153584033,
0.0385330543,
0.0177806262,
-0.0803222954,
0.0042238515,
0.0373103209,
0.0332759321,
-0.0327436179,
-0.0650291815,
0.0087037282,
-0.0040081507,
0.0288852341,
-0.0532153547,
-0.0121261301,
0.0385012068,
0.1070596948,
-0.0303628258,
-0.0155793186,
0.057394743,
-0.042063117,
0.0661004633,
-0.0543516688,
0.0111293579,
0.0190724432,
-0.0261094086,
0.0071372841,
-0.0148502374,
0.0552013963,
-0.0146223241,
-0.0243924372,
0.0381626338,
0.0441189632,
-0.022033453,
-0.0049211853,
-0.0413178876,
0.0341647863,
-0.0194446202,
-0.0341921039,
0.0660186112,
-0.0891704708,
0.0090306792,
-0.0238577779,
-0.0276023205,
-0.0089320876,
0.0184163097,
-0.0481954627,
-0.0310922209,
0.011484446,
0.0578632094,
0.0298357643,
-0.0311863292,
-0.0616500266,
0.0012464582,
-0.017220391,
-0.024814954,
-0.0344232619,
-0.0271947514,
-0.0366789177,
0.0123736886,
-0.0474041328,
-0.0289157201,
2.085307234e-34,
0.051587373,
-0.0010157868,
0.0015607836,
-0.0361347236,
-0.0151598109,
-0.0301092062,
-0.0268967561,
0.0076650223,
0.0219798144,
-0.0694310293,
-0.0261251125
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.09093v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09093v3 | GLEN: General-Purpose Event Detection for Thousands of Types | 2023-03-16T05:36:38 | 2023-10-31T17:21:45 | Qiusi Zhan, Sha Li, Kathryn Conger, Martha Palmer, Heng Ji, Jiawei Han | cs.CL | cs.CL | The progress of event extraction research has been hindered by the absence of
wide-coverage, large-scale datasets. To make event extraction systems more
accessible, we build a general-purpose event detection dataset GLEN, which
covers 205K event mentions with 3,465 different types, making it more than 20x
larger in ontology than today's largest event dataset. GLEN is created by
utilizing the DWD Overlay, which provides a mapping between Wikidata Qnodes and
PropBank rolesets. This enables us to use the abundant existing annotation for
PropBank as distant supervision. In addition, we also propose a new multi-stage
event detection model CEDAR specifically designed to handle the large ontology
size in GLEN. We show that our model exhibits superior performance compared to
a range of baselines including InstructGPT. Finally, we perform error analysis
and show that label noise is still the largest challenge for improving
performance for this new dataset. Our dataset, code, and models are released at
\url{https://github.com/ZQS1943/GLEN}.} | [
0.0250542145,
0.0301010627,
0.0249311067,
0.0804995224,
-0.007357568,
0.0203908645,
-0.0277417507,
0.0300414637,
0.0622555874,
-0.0483625382,
0.0031271812,
0.0156348478,
-0.0660599321,
0.0634689257,
-0.009644432,
-0.0243806932,
0.0642278343,
0.0101865297,
0.0243824236,
0.0508770086,
0.016006805,
0.0336586349,
-0.0597113259,
0.0515622459,
-0.0682458207,
-0.0230888054,
-0.0101679368,
-0.0192043055,
0.0350105986,
-0.0611421429,
0.0380732492,
0.012597003,
0.0445362926,
0.038138818,
0.0000018517,
-0.0306985285,
0.0203741714,
-0.0143466434,
-0.0238598678,
0.0263308156,
-0.0415494666,
-0.0013030395,
0.0070661916,
-0.0237412769,
-0.0177502763,
-0.0593364537,
0.0251050461,
0.0731219873,
-0.0214097947,
0.0720547959,
-0.0261718407,
0.0210953504,
0.0727149546,
-0.010265802,
0.0548212938,
-0.0459208563,
0.0329361036,
-0.0307979137,
0.0075060041,
0.0057401559,
0.0203745048,
-0.0011913845,
-0.0116246538,
-0.0075302445,
0.0024785148,
0.0327115059,
-0.0460743308,
-0.0019091041,
-0.0361749008,
0.0541469604,
0.0446349978,
-0.0020887922,
0.0522296838,
0.0074604666,
-0.0053132181,
0.0182734951,
-0.0143731404,
-0.008542805,
-0.0255240537,
0.008636944,
0.0381807722,
0.022636693,
0.0062158024,
0.0006574311,
0.0432021134,
0.0759923756,
0.0088778893,
0.0015260836,
-0.0254688654,
0.0177686308,
-0.0122845517,
-0.078224048,
0.0174954478,
-0.0058827987,
-0.0232379083,
0.0141625432,
-0.0322065204,
0.0820487291,
0.0110764978,
-0.0567984954,
-0.0443108901,
0.0325203873,
-0.0315839462,
0.0555156656,
0.0222991724,
0.0069847647,
-0.0226767622,
0.0064746416,
0.0175101981,
-0.0121080242,
-0.0728297234,
0.0453432463,
-0.0449441299,
0.030049324,
-0.0294206049,
-0.031333141,
-0.0171844624,
0.007773567,
0.0292166583,
0.0188682713,
0.0061851293,
-0.0248575062,
-0.0442518182,
-0.0003283352,
0.0030499937,
0.0146267908,
-0.030700434,
0.0053898585,
-0.0344407484,
-0.0314505398,
-0.0017440185,
0.0164020229,
0.0465480387,
-0.0148511063,
-0.0434968248,
0.0501297638,
0.0217455886,
-0.0646716356,
-0.0508055724,
-0.0592214093,
-0.0113761295,
0.0172570106,
-0.0237651505,
-0.0474909618,
0.0160829723,
-0.0284161661,
0.0178355258,
-0.0411377996,
0.0417937189,
-0.0190558732,
-0.0273866355,
0.0476785004,
-0.0860471427,
-0.008018964,
-0.0101383645,
-0.0030879935,
-0.0417082012,
0.0560971648,
0.0470883809,
0.0176293161,
0.0865230039,
0.0338294283,
-0.0147947269,
0.0343917646,
-0.0045267818,
0.0059091323,
0.0409349985,
-0.006018701,
0.0100080697,
-0.0106165474,
0.051778473,
-0.0392820984,
-0.0364437327,
-0.0110678012,
0.0311573781,
0.0106832441,
-0.0433882847,
-0.038305968,
0.0267626327,
0.0048684268,
-0.0087712714,
-0.0062798327,
-0.0083729057,
-0.0170112215,
0.0181027353,
-0.0177155975,
-0.0054626572,
-0.033609502,
-0.0185725726,
-0.0112591852,
-0.0101284618,
-0.0181939974,
-0.0693606511,
-0.0131448423,
0.0383316875,
-0.0036211677,
-0.0093261059,
0.0696273893,
0.0777575225,
-0.0343760699,
0.0080715679,
-0.0035438244,
0.0581263825,
0.0322929136,
0.0464243554,
-0.0814737305,
-0.064801082,
0.0048378077,
0.00667493,
0.0510488041,
0.0537033789,
-0.0594465137,
0.0282812119,
-0.0308834817,
-0.0165380146,
0.0162864104,
0.0424917638,
0.0076701245,
0.0488338508,
0.0109779462,
-0.0186759066,
-0.0196082648,
-0.0147994729,
0.0430731066,
0.0213647019,
-0.0620246418,
-0.0439747758,
-0.0223341659,
0.0211408008,
0.0102235191,
-0.0027936383,
-0.0189735889,
0.0447879806,
-0.0635903701,
-0.0138753513,
0.0290334914,
0.0176312067,
-0.0708011612,
0.0616249368,
0.0103529412,
-0.0265342556,
0.0073255673,
-0.0430910587,
-0.0448109582,
-0.0224402528,
0.0139922155,
0.0426754579,
0.0053779557,
-0.0262653679,
0.0255543813,
-0.0179203302,
0.0053390251,
0.0650840029,
-0.0013080803,
-0.0119791571,
-0.0244303532,
-0.0015716109,
0.0294104889,
0.013618364,
-0.0295339022,
0.0221435986,
-0.0264484137,
-0.0145072499,
0.0397172943,
-0.0414812788,
-0.057154581,
0.0300540235,
-0.0792004392,
0.0480161048,
-0.0277245045,
0.0656105354,
0.0298317596,
0.0294155087,
-0.0158065036,
-0.0140961874,
0.0003290914,
-0.0362517536,
-0.0556255057,
0.015960427,
0.0305468962,
0.0336208344,
-0.0047084247,
-0.0547484681,
0.0049526119,
-0.0565692745,
0.0517189167,
0.0060155871,
-0.0695596486,
-0.0132376095,
-0.0151248025,
-0.0066680275,
0.0148554211,
0.0003272766,
0.0007047407,
0.0022245417,
0.0002257618,
0.0152520621,
-0.018306531,
-0.0237802491,
0.0553116538,
-0.023140654,
-0.042608276,
-0.0400275365,
0.0323781595,
-0.0235644598,
-0.0132715665,
-0.0164799094,
0.0075043463,
0.0210574158,
0.0550926104,
-0.0036199952,
0.0000257445,
-0.0570354909,
-0.0590697043,
-0.0400968343,
0.0026351209,
-0.0253311135,
-0.0418258905,
-0.0395282805,
0.0262422822,
-0.0373361185,
0.0007590486,
0.0220631566,
-0.0017422549,
-0.0127098747,
-0.0157300476,
-0.005296058,
-0.0523560122,
0.089572683,
-0.0154133271,
0.0033347271,
-0.0049701496,
-0.0731577352,
0.0219376776,
-0.0103563378,
-0.0039536823,
0.0066186134,
-0.0022312542,
-0.0171071123,
0.0433007553,
-0.0175592005,
0.0018976976,
-0.0278670043,
-0.0394481495,
-0.0175020751,
-0.0020659294,
-0.0131335612,
-0.0048730928,
0.0120766787,
0.0198381655,
-0.0363566205,
0.0732952058,
0.0029069099,
-0.0006403393,
-0.0283316411,
0.0899237245,
0.0447945707,
-0.0218101386,
-0.0239763688,
0.0444734655,
-0.0137310736,
0.0529291406,
0.0138107622,
0.0058843889,
-0.0030507471,
0.003734244,
0.0055640512,
-0.0816114545,
-0.0016999443,
0.0066128187,
0.0660783648,
-0.0986613408,
-0.0055972049,
0.1004607305,
0.0517567657,
-0.0481503159,
0.0216526631,
0.022794893,
0.0002933645,
0.0009838969,
-0.0358657464,
-0.0899184123,
-0.0571875311,
-0.0127784973,
-0.0195075646,
-0.0025153104,
-0.0506419316,
0.0257435199,
-0.0402868874,
0.0063527976,
0.0021507568,
-0.0218533445,
-0.0367893577,
-0.0352831669,
0.0418615416,
-0.0369773917,
-0.0621995404,
-0.0000930825,
0.0117286174,
-0.0073918523,
0.0077537009,
-0.0439508259,
-0.049261447,
0.0402507856,
-0.0628551319,
0.0386813357,
0.0140211619,
0.0539330579,
0.0112191187,
0.0221643914,
-0.0013516468,
-0.0368103236,
-0.0280875824,
0.0145063018,
0.0703774616,
-0.0176920127,
-0.0138536124,
-0.0164185781,
0.0438118428,
-0.0663213208,
-0.0289833341,
0.0148284314,
0.0853831992,
0.0168038514,
0.0104093552,
-0.0076590595,
-0.0241854098,
0.047899358,
0.0476498418,
0.0005664594,
0.0257843789,
-0.0041411384,
-0.0051399767,
0.0055539943,
-0.0435647592,
0.0117142042,
-0.0098361624,
-0.0453156605,
-0.0693468079,
-0.0917843059,
-0.0518968217,
0.0356817953,
-0.0083938558,
-0.0428987071,
0.0158752948,
0.0299212597,
0.014181911,
-0.0412224755,
0.0703560337,
-0.0629420206,
-0.0058811614,
0.0125199296,
-0.0237023532,
0.0290478654,
0.0701134652,
-0.0237222798,
0.0705210194,
-0.0025381413,
-0.0393673368,
-0.0002530015,
-0.0472619236,
0.016551137,
0.0264585353,
-0.0223718099,
0.0180184543,
-0.0177490022,
0.0480850227,
-0.0254436005,
-0.0252954811,
0.0269475989,
0.0140387453,
-0.0140053304,
0.0559417494,
-0.0278789327,
0.0091461297,
-0.0684363544,
0.0543256961,
-0.081740804,
-0.0132294483,
-0.001174767,
-0.0192375518,
0.0539835542,
-0.0017241207,
-0.0177645721,
-0.0664100274,
-0.0077071474,
-0.0096183494,
0.0150586441,
-0.0213008597,
0.0360124297,
-0.0073695774,
-0.0243588276,
-0.0347267725,
0.0368625447,
-0.0202548429,
0.0408642702,
-0.0700928196,
0.0189259928,
0.0594339035,
0.0379680507,
-0.0038751138,
-0.0181883313,
-0.0329093412,
-0.0010139903,
-0.0098578231,
-0.0196327399,
-0.0394116789,
-0.0169557296,
0.0128147714,
-0.0236910954,
0.0247532278,
-0.0272382349,
-0.0511615537,
0.0215953887,
-0.012134037,
0.0381309651,
0.0920672268,
-0.0239769667,
0.0685688779,
-0.02507006,
-0.028558325,
0.0192561187,
0.0303246584,
-0.0222089235,
0.0241025519,
0.0156108169,
0.0226484928,
-0.0497391261,
0.0006427216,
0.0633287132,
-0.0034896282,
0.0953558013,
0.0523069948,
-0.0346630961,
-0.02030278,
-0.0142448535,
0.0541083179,
0.06531737,
-0.0110396901,
0.0312501118,
-0.0547471456,
-0.0001800334,
0.0409018844,
-0.016425183,
-0.042308718,
0.0127765341,
0.0330972932,
-0.0148816956,
0.0495139807,
-0.0350632183,
-0.0237193834,
-0.0113703199,
-0.0208674725,
-0.0231152121,
-0.0353599563,
-5.822845062e-33,
-0.0496563762,
-0.0299486239,
0.0113720559,
0.0368469507,
-0.0262573566,
0.0389055163,
-0.0065802699,
-0.0279908106,
0.0198059995,
0.0468742512,
0.0080579128,
0.017953001,
0.0151543701,
-0.0107500209,
0.0382466763,
-0.0232322756,
0.0540682599,
0.0024962148,
0.0230419878,
0.059183538,
0.0714954212,
0.0233693346,
0.0773532391,
-0.0761900917,
0.0487473719,
0.0126243746,
0.016804127,
-0.0192191303,
0.0609917603,
0.0513670407,
-0.0324246809,
0.0436897054,
0.0158489905,
-0.0045965617,
0.0043457551,
0.0191309731,
-0.0813550949,
-0.0333291367,
0.0186188277,
0.0004538707,
0.0300990175,
-0.0513113327,
-0.0121875815,
0.0150403455,
0.0224468578,
-0.0156884138,
0.0185977183,
-0.0006482443,
-0.0254834015,
-0.0497643501,
-0.0627784654,
0.0674387887,
0.0226919651,
-0.0148549499,
-0.0014478754,
-0.017594872,
0.0527793318,
-0.0127599668,
-0.0696357414,
-0.00387826,
-0.061887864,
0.0260388944,
-0.0356799662,
-0.0319672264,
-0.0182995666,
0.0388927795,
-0.0303792953,
-0.0080365501,
0.0092645073,
0.0532873459,
-0.0398226976,
0.0855250955,
0.0190916713,
0.0199143793,
0.0487305671,
0.0005452468,
-0.0745723024,
0.0386229083,
0.0340425633,
-0.0066507212,
-0.0078104832,
0.0293871611,
-0.054261338,
0.0152489794,
0.002475508,
0.0191448536,
0.0009906767,
0.0127215786,
0.018436918,
-0.0013445502,
0.0201482065,
0.1034007818,
-0.0034771666,
-0.0254161563,
-0.0150392512,
0.0314181671,
0.0150560709,
0.0338737816,
-0.0021233477,
0.0062167472,
-0.0519941635,
-0.0399970263,
0.0094548082,
-0.029688267,
0.0174656752,
0.0031348076,
0.0287790392,
0.0212910753,
-0.0375374705,
0.0106581496,
-0.0112292049,
-0.019564895,
-0.0289057996,
0.0066702422,
0.0306252632,
-0.0063480115,
0.0025466378,
0.022968825,
0.0424865559,
0.0394103192,
0.003356969,
-0.0231126994,
-0.0303718783,
0.0206147917,
0.0184424557,
-0.0033736483,
-0.039218884,
0.0306850728,
-0.0126716625,
-0.0008443227,
-0.0080491109,
-0.0096919881,
2.445e-7,
0.0252404884,
0.0210956186,
0.0405960977,
0.0549607873,
0.0162605029,
0.0013795688,
0.0254242383,
0.061949145,
-0.028935425,
-0.0193975475,
-0.0136814658,
0.0004781057,
-0.0110725826,
0.0603529103,
-0.0840388685,
-0.0874340236,
-0.0450676642,
-0.0317157842,
-0.1052717939,
-0.0156274345,
0.0672262236,
0.0516895652,
0.0472476594,
-0.0037135419,
0.0183356591,
-0.0346494205,
0.0316584632,
-0.0090884026,
-0.0302330386,
0.0502376184,
0.0304455105,
0.0450849235,
-0.0249555316,
0.0444436297,
-0.0124061117,
0.0145713948,
-0.004100211,
0.0380070582,
-0.0328733511,
-0.0106383394,
-0.0178081132,
-0.0275334921,
-0.0034158621,
0.005028123,
0.0631426722,
-0.0063095652,
-0.0017313138,
-0.005930589,
-0.0176038351,
0.0384738557,
-0.0472648218,
-0.0025134028,
-0.0086482298,
0.02047964,
0.0061008045,
-0.000437998,
-0.0339238048,
-0.073685199,
-0.0062756408,
0.0504948832,
-0.0209337845,
-0.0550480559,
-0.0052763233,
-0.0426944233,
-0.0397268459,
-0.0745126382,
-0.0006803386,
2.28735382e-34,
-0.0235172622,
0.0366466269,
-0.0323976353,
0.0554263964,
0.0307037979,
-0.0364735574,
-0.0272006579,
-0.0172839724,
0.0144928042,
-0.0102369627,
0.0240858905
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.09092v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09092v2 | Challenges to Evaluating the Generalization of Coreference Resolution Models: A Measurement Modeling Perspective | 2023-03-16T05:32:02 | 2024-06-18T16:19:36 | Ian Porada, Alexandra Olteanu, Kaheer Suleman, Adam Trischler, Jackie Chi Kit Cheung | cs.CL | cs.CL | It is increasingly common to evaluate the same coreference resolution (CR)
model on multiple datasets. Do these multi-dataset evaluations allow us to draw
meaningful conclusions about model generalization? Or, do they rather reflect
the idiosyncrasies of a particular experimental setup (e.g., the specific
datasets used)? To study this, we view evaluation through the lens of
measurement modeling, a framework commonly used in the social sciences for
analyzing the validity of measurements. By taking this perspective, we show how
multi-dataset evaluations risk conflating different factors concerning what,
precisely, is being measured. This in turn makes it difficult to draw more
generalizable conclusions from these evaluations. For instance, we show that
across seven datasets, measurements intended to reflect CR model generalization
are often correlated with differences in both how coreference is defined and
how it is operationalized; this limits our ability to draw conclusions
regarding the ability of CR models to generalize across any singular dimension.
We believe the measurement modeling framework provides the needed vocabulary
for discussing challenges surrounding what is actually being measured by CR
evaluations. | [
0.0174203012,
0.0560490787,
-0.0286240913,
-0.0365278833,
-0.0434756391,
0.0159530248,
0.0213576686,
-0.018192336,
0.0036896728,
0.0103266453,
-0.0195695311,
0.0017870571,
0.0526410416,
-0.0447231494,
-0.0284749735,
-0.0320658498,
0.0171835367,
0.0279109217,
0.0423677266,
0.0253441706,
-0.0097287344,
-0.0045730858,
0.0352149159,
0.036266923,
-0.0319728255,
0.0187561586,
0.0433722474,
-0.0030749438,
0.0331754275,
-0.0129287988,
0.0070494968,
0.0506438762,
-0.000697431,
0.0136573855,
0.0000020756,
-0.0718700439,
0.005722919,
0.0178228598,
-0.0139730293,
0.0183920413,
0.0133693535,
0.0243676584,
0.0682793111,
-0.0022890554,
-0.0137330871,
0.0107964538,
0.010353039,
-0.0079639778,
-0.0280688535,
-0.0475798063,
0.0040006079,
-0.0015671668,
-0.040929839,
-0.0363151357,
-0.0733712092,
-0.0108927237,
0.0302562732,
0.0737592205,
-0.0198077075,
-0.0147910053,
-0.0232854299,
0.0137078036,
0.0400030985,
0.0781861916,
-0.007509884,
0.0070602614,
-0.0471815653,
-0.029764425,
0.0524165295,
0.0521595702,
0.095507957,
0.0411355123,
0.0093000485,
0.0107315788,
0.0234404504,
0.0277000275,
-0.0479949042,
-0.027206894,
-0.0062277815,
-0.0245484728,
-0.0394911766,
0.0749326572,
-0.0171265136,
-0.0145299258,
-0.0180455446,
0.0977096483,
-0.0245291218,
-0.0069884844,
0.0355958417,
0.0047397115,
-0.0185391773,
-0.0392088033,
0.0225715805,
-0.0325490832,
0.0040879492,
0.0092896996,
0.0303402804,
0.0553686619,
0.0521241687,
-0.0506036244,
0.0256665219,
0.0102130529,
-0.0083012646,
0.0087597147,
0.042540364,
0.0726884007,
0.0199245196,
0.0609836467,
-0.0172289088,
0.0119247083,
-0.092325747,
0.0402982421,
0.0279941987,
-0.0028918204,
-0.0091712922,
0.0041936464,
-0.0790222138,
-0.0294562858,
-0.012440253,
-0.0019038934,
-0.0524268188,
-0.020705238,
-0.0145711005,
0.0076994016,
-0.0470483266,
0.0470885858,
-0.0479889475,
0.0537265725,
-0.0232514869,
-0.0280103236,
0.0557276309,
-0.0068182549,
-0.0134793408,
-0.0322128721,
0.0381607935,
0.0335886329,
0.0402186811,
-0.0081182998,
0.0393909998,
-0.0494896434,
-0.0630075112,
-0.0459029227,
-0.000662089,
-0.0688295439,
0.0286976211,
0.0546344072,
-0.0078974487,
-0.0998326093,
0.0055416427,
-0.0083712433,
-0.0481193848,
0.0141791292,
0.0247808993,
0.0430568606,
-0.0102248183,
0.032938756,
0.0460494645,
0.0426797792,
0.0137847429,
-0.0096553285,
0.0242657233,
-0.0105448319,
-0.0499080569,
0.0125219468,
0.0257098656,
0.0366983861,
0.0024944877,
0.020960303,
-0.0527332686,
-0.0333247967,
0.0104453173,
0.0199578665,
-0.0229551438,
0.0046928762,
0.0461711138,
0.0831055641,
0.0055528996,
-0.0354043469,
-0.0333366208,
-0.0266555231,
-0.0089492174,
0.0486855879,
-0.06441053,
-0.0009341287,
0.0133924689,
-0.0006332865,
0.0634734556,
0.004587498,
-0.0196245015,
-0.046827551,
-0.0502058305,
0.0481259376,
-0.0007942002,
0.026406819,
0.0367711149,
-0.0097859306,
0.0202748068,
-0.0150625296,
-0.0127673419,
-0.0292954203,
0.0019975964,
-0.0177447163,
-0.0098159304,
-0.0257542003,
-0.0109152319,
0.0189629719,
-0.0142334169,
0.0183140635,
0.0548219271,
0.0073245782,
0.0238784775,
0.0217777938,
-0.0092140818,
0.0159644987,
-0.0321763754,
0.0111687947,
0.0094458098,
0.0227345861,
0.0063916631,
0.0031154326,
0.0159110911,
-0.0438042283,
-0.0280558877,
0.0186050609,
-0.0007596563,
0.0281516574,
-0.0454773456,
0.0058557163,
0.0522012897,
0.0212015193,
-0.0170012079,
0.0297052227,
0.0020805215,
0.0194254294,
-0.0018290734,
0.0311330277,
0.0228734296,
0.0876911134,
-0.0195966363,
-0.0613274463,
0.0242338162,
-0.0467354693,
0.0129245734,
-0.0103390384,
0.0147057809,
0.0091286898,
0.0561391748,
0.024943484,
0.0190396886,
-0.0581523478,
-0.0277863704,
-0.0226995759,
0.0201992691,
-0.039296817,
0.024672443,
0.0123995123,
-0.0171038304,
0.0430291146,
-0.0107670166,
-0.0003763654,
-0.0354503319,
-0.0282846782,
-0.0110160382,
0.0548994616,
-0.0129209375,
-0.0582965687,
-0.01174735,
-0.0314207524,
0.0196964331,
-0.0001248493,
0.0147861214,
0.038241975,
-0.0064211143,
-0.0161243733,
0.0104400329,
0.0079161953,
-0.0528573282,
0.0382620543,
0.0819620788,
-0.0417503603,
-0.0101616103,
-0.0373672619,
-0.0568941645,
-0.0282327849,
-0.0223427359,
0.0394922532,
0.0180984754,
0.0090426067,
0.0109260399,
0.0275737923,
-0.0765012205,
-0.0278835148,
-0.0064262087,
0.0036718566,
0.0604572706,
0.0638120994,
-0.0076761888,
-0.0084161498,
-0.0605000518,
0.0138378274,
0.0304416921,
-0.0531141236,
-0.0738435015,
-0.029999245,
-0.0218829233,
-0.0566172823,
-0.012504139,
-0.1007677689,
-0.0223949961,
0.0431978256,
0.0244658515,
0.0062968391,
-0.0201013777,
0.075623177,
-0.0618854873,
-0.0331285708,
-0.0541552603,
-0.000121287,
-0.0169736128,
0.0993875787,
-0.0469722934,
-0.034043435,
-0.0450202525,
0.0012744984,
0.0287496224,
0.0186122674,
0.0002980827,
-0.0098140221,
0.0826386809,
0.0163402352,
-0.0284043401,
0.0590194911,
-0.0154301859,
-0.0253914781,
-0.0238804389,
0.0227466784,
-0.0153121082,
0.0421841182,
-0.0563376322,
0.0245767087,
0.007698576,
-0.0066952463,
-0.0284619015,
0.0977371782,
0.0060248529,
0.007487345,
-0.0128219556,
0.0250240453,
-0.0142239211,
0.0065131597,
0.0621258989,
-0.014550887,
0.0153468987,
-0.0127943372,
-0.0238172878,
-0.0254798029,
-0.0086874217,
0.0041990341,
0.0441867411,
-0.0511209927,
-0.0451043099,
-0.0074728448,
-0.0056935879,
0.0198699925,
-0.0177524965,
-0.0046743178,
-0.0001583113,
-0.0060041756,
-0.0069737798,
0.0327151753,
0.0708610043,
-0.0114929667,
-0.0214786176,
0.0550316684,
0.0157273803,
0.0369100273,
0.0078290226,
-0.0039886297,
-0.0309861638,
0.0382457562,
-0.0588061847,
0.006494767,
0.0362722352,
0.0034615172,
-0.013301759,
-0.0435520224,
-0.0376126692,
0.0022523743,
-0.047035154,
0.0005076941,
-0.0017698953,
-0.0771420598,
-0.0323532261,
-0.0239124037,
0.0874195099,
-0.0360658355,
0.0053274711,
0.0121272542,
0.0024263992,
0.0145090222,
0.0034369526,
-0.0551187694,
-0.0292609017,
0.012511191,
-0.0603798367,
0.0117294639,
0.0173791703,
0.0356524773,
-0.0030768209,
-0.0175078884,
-0.0364244431,
-0.003983398,
-0.0480598286,
0.0353322513,
0.0189664736,
0.0453760885,
-0.0037141601,
-0.0118952133,
0.0002905391,
0.0035794242,
0.004956767,
-0.0036610712,
-0.0122350948,
0.0345234014,
-0.0114956768,
0.0046714582,
0.0092733176,
-0.042165406,
0.0404982492,
0.0360953026,
0.0194228254,
0.0320464894,
-0.018567577,
0.0003181996,
-0.0083338721,
-0.05050686,
0.0311575625,
-0.0463597178,
0.0015536669,
-0.0077313399,
-0.040458627,
0.0154528413,
0.0156894438,
0.016748881,
-0.0394414999,
0.0197649822,
-0.039949894,
-0.0163440537,
0.0109505188,
-0.0169525277,
-0.0005875794,
-0.0459467731,
0.0147808865,
0.029779071,
0.1041234434,
-0.0548999012,
0.0583239011,
-0.016559856,
0.0255504474,
0.0265077185,
-0.0154849086,
0.0303250905,
-0.0559111685,
0.0355263278,
0.0535023026,
-0.0016049383,
-0.0033137596,
-0.0116132796,
0.0208661519,
0.0198952015,
0.0211847853,
-0.004137238,
0.0007042639,
-0.0104186293,
0.0378132313,
0.0356565192,
-0.0122748856,
-0.0318637714,
-0.0709972382,
0.0049927845,
-0.0103833163,
0.0385847427,
0.0118501177,
0.0052803676,
0.007339159,
-0.0623433776,
-0.0119828815,
-0.0142441597,
0.0033516018,
-0.0539432056,
0.0102806576,
0.0670361221,
-0.0319289677,
0.0304844491,
-0.0545574278,
0.063109003,
-0.0592088141,
-0.0114288712,
-0.0067459447,
0.0197846796,
-0.0271911696,
0.0011624639,
-0.0091418726,
-0.010636677,
-0.01375347,
0.0355363786,
0.019235108,
0.0034811217,
0.0008380832,
0.0412221737,
0.0304680821,
0.0128686782,
-0.0307458825,
0.0061636637,
-0.0593367815,
-0.0401800908,
-0.0152436299,
0.0115880668,
0.0423429534,
0.01726982,
-0.010107737,
-0.0638343617,
-0.0214324594,
-0.0019897902,
-0.0077313213,
0.0022053691,
-0.0283016767,
0.0060514379,
0.028805133,
0.0303911995,
-0.0114367763,
-0.0112191886,
-0.0760015473,
-0.0457178243,
0.0075250212,
-0.0457687601,
0.0079583405,
-0.0113220932,
-0.0015456181,
0.0094771096,
-0.0929376408,
-0.0447829887,
0.0333686508,
-0.0078044734,
0.0271521341,
0.0273882691,
-0.0170391779,
0.0171646681,
-0.01338124,
-0.0446247421,
0.0283902716,
-0.0164200477,
-0.0203780364,
-0.0181332864,
-0.0462979786,
-5.866365537e-33,
-0.0579667613,
-0.0275761876,
-0.020197276,
-0.0438742489,
-0.0061903014,
0.0068513956,
-0.0090232417,
0.0400363542,
-0.0178705323,
-0.0243170187,
0.0248907749,
-0.0308324657,
0.0007040721,
-0.0318515375,
0.0517414697,
-0.0116498796,
0.0148878274,
0.0028874844,
-0.0373030975,
-0.0313257501,
0.0321034119,
-0.0308842976,
0.0998554081,
-0.0993748307,
0.0820185095,
0.0584570952,
0.0016926604,
-0.0521784313,
0.0285156555,
0.0240063425,
0.0101303924,
0.0291246101,
0.0341813453,
-0.0695962235,
-0.0054905722,
0.0053769178,
-0.0666820928,
-0.0581448264,
0.0813166946,
0.0097385859,
-0.0004583086,
-0.0251719262,
0.0101076458,
0.0179775059,
-0.0399475284,
-0.0466191582,
0.0454642437,
-0.0381152704,
-0.0017412143,
-0.001314124,
-0.0418272279,
-0.0048429924,
-0.0201431885,
0.02150077,
-0.0565660559,
0.1026625335,
-0.058336433,
0.0356273688,
-0.0515218042,
0.0336256847,
0.0163334087,
-0.0101096127,
0.0079834349,
0.0099412063,
0.0588913932,
0.0526773483,
0.0030290294,
-0.0197043847,
0.0076114372,
-0.04869904,
0.0587326847,
0.0260938965,
0.0390144549,
0.1321829706,
-0.0088887261,
-0.0113372747,
-0.0400594398,
-0.0081950231,
-0.0110910824,
-0.004018215,
0.0048458613,
0.0105072055,
-0.0169647913,
-0.034873426,
-0.0611023791,
-0.0728561133,
-0.0282389577,
-0.0449584872,
0.0340695977,
0.0003212604,
-0.0183292385,
0.0294131152,
0.0722367838,
-0.0303724334,
-0.0437726788,
-0.0218251124,
-0.0016410468,
0.0404310375,
0.0370661356,
-0.0262302235,
-0.044191841,
0.0256544817,
-0.0000055912,
0.0918578729,
0.0780391321,
-0.0138783492,
0.036045827,
-0.0591762252,
-0.0419592261,
-0.0362821408,
-0.0037213906,
-0.0076107127,
0.0164041165,
-0.1105868146,
0.0436080545,
0.000995516,
0.0181969292,
0.0120323608,
0.0133027546,
0.0072903172,
-0.0710590035,
-0.0189595595,
-0.0107867541,
0.0168218296,
0.0074297888,
-0.0275967661,
-0.0045783836,
-0.0149321025,
0.0312879272,
0.0419729538,
-0.0154880676,
-0.0083333189,
2.684e-7,
0.0116917938,
0.0203630868,
-0.0033449179,
-0.0184684433,
-0.0033712746,
-0.0111295627,
-0.0186776221,
0.0186358634,
0.0406741947,
-0.0820749104,
0.0215236358,
-0.0132666249,
0.0159801841,
0.0151254777,
0.0126282759,
-0.0438341312,
-0.0393259227,
0.0118063157,
-0.0353925787,
0.054158967,
-0.0289973933,
0.0102031613,
0.0307810847,
0.0263830554,
-0.0685558319,
0.0072330907,
0.0190918259,
-0.0516513214,
0.0056786961,
0.0337731615,
-0.0008517181,
0.0400296524,
0.0235376637,
0.0745828375,
0.040430326,
0.0078536728,
0.0535165519,
0.0226113591,
0.0451898612,
0.0064575952,
-0.0211944263,
-0.014140619,
0.0132467067,
-0.0467504598,
0.0743488222,
-0.1068466827,
-0.0251783505,
-0.0271795318,
-0.0207599662,
0.0406915955,
0.0718260333,
0.0314875543,
0.0103271361,
0.0387266763,
0.0089083835,
0.0510993637,
-0.012176821,
0.0159357693,
0.0192586035,
0.00793037,
-0.0126095004,
-0.0878481194,
0.0013932349,
-0.0410805754,
-0.0687156841,
-0.0063147647,
-0.0126050645,
2.287451166e-34,
0.0493588224,
0.023100676,
0.0407827683,
-0.0791567937,
0.027517695,
-0.0429508127,
-0.0552799404,
-0.0195181351,
-0.0047399476,
-0.0109965373,
0.0347419269
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.09075v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09075v3 | Enhancing Text Generation with Cooperative Training | 2023-03-16T04:21:19 | 2023-09-23T13:24:28 | Tong Wu, Hao Wang, Zhongshen Zeng, Wei Wang, Hai-Tao Zheng, Jiaxing Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recently, there has been a surge in the use of generated data to enhance the
performance of downstream models, largely due to the advancements in
pre-trained language models. However, most prevailing methods trained
generative and discriminative models in isolation, which left them unable to
adapt to changes in each other. These approaches lead to generative models that
are prone to deviating from the true data distribution and providing limited
benefits to discriminative models. While some works have proposed jointly
training generative and discriminative language models, their methods remain
challenging due to the non-differentiable nature of discrete data. To overcome
these issues, we introduce a \textit{self-consistent learning} framework in the
text field that involves training a discriminator and generator cooperatively
in a closed-loop manner until a scoring consensus is reached. By learning
directly from selected samples, our framework are able to mitigate training
instabilities such as mode collapse and non-convergence. Extensive experiments
on four downstream benchmarks, including AFQMC, CHIP-STS, QQP, and MRPC,
demonstrate the efficacy of the proposed framework. | [
0.007659683,
0.109822683,
0.0162885878,
-0.0064716358,
-0.0252334382,
0.0063642492,
0.0469348915,
0.0052791741,
-0.0258800685,
-0.0342997909,
-0.0270282049,
-0.0483676717,
-0.0194630474,
0.0335104428,
0.031286031,
0.0137481391,
0.0144957742,
0.0056233075,
-0.0028049652,
-0.0068539595,
0.0168392323,
0.0208801255,
-0.0078976518,
-0.0083586425,
-0.0496499017,
-0.0301092267,
0.0110722305,
-0.00422099,
-0.0055522891,
-0.0153027214,
0.0286290515,
0.0899293795,
0.0216798428,
0.0243145823,
0.0000019289,
-0.0109787695,
-0.0189292636,
-0.006657972,
0.0086957635,
0.0253384858,
0.019388495,
-0.0004622818,
-0.0247743521,
0.0235798862,
-0.0281969942,
-0.0137448786,
0.0409628041,
0.0326823555,
0.0619358458,
0.0691311136,
-0.0130895479,
-0.0325435251,
0.0069972072,
-0.0622468181,
-0.0152449077,
0.0138170002,
0.0129608968,
0.0155537073,
-0.0345290974,
0.0007528387,
-0.0149797974,
0.0366831832,
0.016724553,
-0.0307638831,
0.0243204068,
0.0839976817,
0.012070464,
-0.0252078082,
0.0299214758,
0.047210753,
0.00402189,
-0.055993475,
0.0370736346,
-0.0252149962,
-0.0231550578,
0.0157187823,
0.0064300094,
0.0268902034,
-0.0323650502,
0.0531022586,
0.0040549557,
-0.0046259989,
0.0173533857,
0.0090254238,
-0.0048302338,
-0.00985434,
0.0261008702,
-0.0348023809,
-0.0235115401,
0.0319203846,
-0.0238639507,
-0.0267244335,
0.0386610813,
0.0044628945,
-0.0102315927,
0.0100545008,
-0.0687615275,
-0.0411100946,
0.0201266464,
-0.0303074233,
0.0561756566,
0.0249591935,
0.0048095579,
-0.0049573318,
-0.0614101291,
0.0273674261,
0.0246316846,
0.0017523669,
-0.0299093351,
0.0446092039,
-0.047459498,
-0.0251763221,
-0.053895615,
0.0212668516,
-0.0332207084,
-0.0316630043,
-0.0613624528,
0.0450706668,
0.0310295224,
-0.0104844915,
0.049453035,
0.0079561826,
-0.0754823089,
0.0138915023,
0.0509274043,
0.0059312824,
-0.0190493874,
0.0215106513,
0.0374445617,
-0.0418440178,
-0.0310546737,
0.0060458467,
0.024620438,
-0.0103650549,
-0.0055330396,
0.0306254644,
-0.0526850037,
-0.0129555119,
-0.0275301468,
-0.0156308096,
-0.0349992029,
-0.0797947496,
0.0047722198,
-0.0550419502,
0.018318221,
-0.0026697256,
-0.0224968102,
-0.0559535436,
0.0173357539,
-0.0131582208,
0.0251243338,
0.0496132821,
-0.0455104783,
0.0015049189,
0.0612771213,
0.0072732917,
0.0459369868,
0.0927971303,
0.0430143811,
0.0132784741,
0.0114954403,
0.0055524255,
0.0181702729,
0.0261891205,
0.0485438667,
-0.0017934937,
-0.009663769,
-0.0358203724,
0.0035983205,
0.0569302291,
0.0472017117,
0.0582058839,
-0.0436618179,
0.0164017659,
0.0689049438,
-0.0120861223,
0.0817538798,
0.0500497296,
0.0714652687,
0.0137634045,
-0.0188095216,
0.0500019118,
0.0101638967,
0.001903163,
0.014327826,
0.0419242196,
0.0465085842,
0.0273353029,
-0.0570368133,
-0.0445391424,
0.0089255497,
-0.0141010033,
-0.0186695196,
-0.0175562594,
0.046085123,
0.0451339111,
-0.0310948137,
-0.0105533898,
0.0203497279,
-0.0881448388,
0.065658465,
-0.0273295697,
0.0392926037,
0.0475029051,
0.0427021571,
0.0114646601,
-0.0187140591,
-0.0055622859,
-0.0103312368,
0.0595397614,
0.0219095796,
-0.0174047314,
0.0135119231,
-0.0450541601,
-0.0214291904,
-0.0108949067,
0.0076323552,
0.0126880324,
-0.0034745906,
0.0036989676,
0.0406177193,
0.0068279165,
-0.0119827092,
0.0601174384,
-0.0391354524,
-0.0411513001,
0.0445927419,
-0.0105378442,
0.018924959,
0.0034981226,
-0.0286217071,
0.0233154539,
0.020296542,
-0.0176639929,
-0.0291153993,
0.0139142731,
-0.0781370103,
-0.0788692981,
0.0144659653,
0.0138356602,
0.0135782333,
-0.0142800976,
-0.0242604502,
-0.0599318258,
0.0335572697,
-0.0726742819,
-0.0533575937,
-0.0840181783,
0.0208741091,
0.054686293,
0.0284128711,
-0.0288867,
0.0636620745,
0.019646788,
0.0113972481,
-0.0305201709,
0.0512756892,
0.0071930694,
-0.0512123741,
0.0355159454,
-0.0081647858,
0.0081622256,
0.0124385236,
0.0381536633,
0.010545929,
-0.0380902961,
-0.0408609584,
-0.0589640029,
0.0131297121,
-0.0457386523,
0.0205722526,
0.03685214,
-0.003925262,
-0.0227012876,
0.0022408757,
-0.0299011767,
0.0007470509,
0.0628664717,
0.008676392,
0.0407905355,
0.016239889,
0.0156379212,
-0.0155121414,
-0.0047883727,
0.0173498169,
0.0510682985,
0.0253415443,
-0.006460431,
-0.0744291916,
0.0283493921,
-0.0382782556,
0.0143424086,
0.015846638,
-0.0040819659,
-0.0051826425,
-0.0059380913,
0.0924665779,
0.030386297,
0.0522570871,
0.0177879818,
-0.0004336772,
-0.0163761582,
-0.0426336639,
0.0019578962,
-0.0711688325,
0.0114531526,
0.0103610484,
-0.0342418551,
0.0335169099,
0.0943163857,
-0.000484363,
-0.0101571027,
-0.0533148944,
0.0140280733,
0.0024407257,
-0.0474851355,
0.001503433,
-0.0074807117,
0.0028497677,
-0.0233884715,
-0.0140246125,
-0.0640551522,
0.0596693084,
-0.0619594157,
-0.0047003189,
-0.0348144434,
-0.0080877971,
-0.0208054334,
0.0267253313,
0.0054864525,
0.0253059193,
0.0338304676,
-0.0010124618,
-0.0333775543,
0.0272503812,
0.0313818008,
-0.0162143856,
0.0172596686,
-0.0503658913,
0.0463421531,
-0.0202308502,
-0.0392381288,
-0.0423788801,
-0.0460503362,
0.0553308576,
0.026129432,
0.0321390107,
-0.0022452539,
0.0440876931,
0.0299621597,
-0.0270146243,
0.0626360923,
-0.0337419324,
-0.0233808681,
-0.0085050398,
0.05245094,
0.0242273118,
-0.039923761,
-0.025257621,
-0.0559158288,
-0.0040404955,
0.0436797328,
0.0211561974,
0.0176365767,
-0.0153886154,
-0.0009767853,
-0.0017834258,
-0.0203571543,
-0.0162703935,
-0.0094632832,
0.0508080609,
-0.0123280194,
-0.0840101093,
0.0999845117,
0.0072916397,
-0.0139260637,
-0.0001452867,
0.0463415757,
0.0537365898,
0.0058295168,
0.0014856729,
-0.0294231847,
0.0076022018,
-0.0216638073,
0.0485304855,
0.0071655968,
-0.0163756292,
-0.0524985194,
-0.0784680545,
0.0389627106,
0.0240618754,
-0.0248780493,
-0.0025844085,
-0.0359421857,
-0.0324013121,
-0.0052054492,
-0.0179910883,
0.0163523722,
-0.0239037219,
0.0294004008,
0.0504905879,
0.0141002769,
-0.0820762888,
-0.0817855969,
-0.0462151431,
0.0530320033,
0.0801555365,
0.0426464304,
0.0307717323,
0.0018030654,
0.0215988215,
-0.054096397,
-0.0015575474,
-0.046128042,
0.0331862345,
-0.0353163816,
0.001182616,
0.0168229844,
0.0302119385,
-0.0088866167,
0.0015168721,
-0.0019329569,
-0.0114285043,
-0.0044888421,
-0.0389494486,
0.0071606208,
0.0313294791,
0.0277056638,
0.0445707627,
0.0232252385,
-0.0231853221,
-0.0512063317,
-0.0092932284,
0.0421573296,
-0.0882219896,
0.0039320015,
-0.0303708743,
-0.0018396587,
-0.0148388539,
-0.0980463102,
-0.0585947111,
0.0007328077,
0.0647346154,
-0.0121675292,
0.0133684855,
-0.0484246761,
-0.0312631503,
-0.0413925722,
-0.0104930103,
-0.0353254229,
-0.0232810341,
-0.0482128151,
-0.050716456,
0.0315677598,
-0.0570992306,
0.010449145,
0.0129561946,
-0.1084798574,
-0.0709418356,
-0.0085611725,
0.0407489166,
0.0119467871,
0.0487218499,
0.0041292482,
-0.0567907132,
0.0536075942,
0.0814438015,
-0.0721620396,
0.019276252,
0.0032001541,
-0.0056971926,
-0.0315532424,
0.0040416857,
-0.0047994819,
0.0587824211,
0.0332859457,
0.0568909161,
-0.0005019191,
-0.0338710286,
0.0401389897,
-0.0171535295,
0.0374875963,
-0.0689251348,
0.0462276042,
-0.0697811544,
-0.0036943057,
-0.0286865886,
0.008516877,
-0.0682414696,
0.0248266663,
0.0389055833,
-0.0090298792,
-0.0247742664,
0.0544369891,
0.0069883824,
0.071404472,
-0.0702378154,
-0.0246293936,
-0.0224573817,
0.014508253,
-0.0162331499,
-0.0119984122,
0.0006431451,
0.0083847363,
0.0223221537,
0.0230901148,
-0.0267847367,
0.0654185042,
0.0193616338,
0.0363043174,
0.019514706,
0.0191516895,
-0.0580131412,
0.0137677062,
-0.0830348805,
0.0424441323,
0.0511839762,
0.0229115151,
0.0487405173,
-0.0520483889,
0.0077361977,
-0.0322319418,
0.0238101613,
-0.0125308223,
-0.0224520452,
0.0071987356,
-0.0108491592,
-0.0393945202,
-0.0234488044,
0.0855308771,
0.0374153443,
0.0085651232,
-0.0180069916,
0.0096726976,
-0.0651406199,
-0.0537364259,
0.0118009886,
-0.0301011149,
-0.0122646326,
0.0004659677,
0.0002105718,
-0.0398377404,
0.0152412709,
-0.0051583247,
0.0228697136,
0.0119972182,
0.0445236564,
0.0582804121,
-0.0493092537,
0.0121162608,
-0.073629126,
0.0238159914,
-0.0041090492,
0.0059858616,
-0.0246158913,
-6.25472536e-33,
-0.0638394952,
-0.0163658038,
0.0316965431,
-0.0292638596,
-0.0396539234,
0.0048748604,
-0.0320692323,
-0.01470003,
0.0601794571,
-0.0059348494,
-0.0322705135,
0.0035136461,
0.0160817001,
0.044555109,
-0.03349033,
0.0165958703,
0.1022427827,
-0.0308046509,
-0.0594890676,
0.0531256534,
0.0181406494,
0.0375992246,
0.0208100174,
-0.0426366515,
-0.009225633,
-0.0375887528,
-0.0534935184,
-0.0051290919,
0.002970672,
0.0313910097,
-0.0267793387,
-0.0068081045,
0.0102923177,
-0.0073630419,
-0.0505436584,
0.0015619933,
-0.0855028927,
0.0184312705,
-0.0207287334,
-0.0100783873,
-0.0583418086,
-0.0120880343,
0.0242831297,
-0.0316045694,
-0.0317363255,
0.0018073815,
0.0121821091,
-0.0160858091,
-0.0252267234,
-0.084691748,
-0.0446356349,
0.0242562443,
0.0015282867,
-0.0149793141,
0.0123771839,
0.0107703786,
0.0197437648,
-0.0096607944,
-0.0451878794,
0.0447762311,
0.0270920806,
0.0783380792,
0.0533370525,
0.033592537,
0.037435513,
0.0194672942,
0.0333216116,
-0.0037900407,
-0.0154277328,
-0.0072207516,
0.0132055106,
0.020403916,
0.0384248085,
0.0475845933,
-0.0021730918,
-0.0132724941,
-0.0536465906,
0.0525630303,
-0.0185321029,
-0.049228061,
0.0388592668,
0.013993592,
-0.0078270715,
-0.0247387998,
-0.0359076709,
-0.0195433702,
0.0040954263,
-0.017991079,
0.0285117943,
0.0884523541,
-0.0519801378,
-0.0032212781,
0.0278580654,
-0.0121414522,
-0.0318302251,
-0.0050951215,
-0.0266001839,
-0.0013496137,
-0.0042446661,
0.0047587422,
-0.0719488785,
-0.0435081646,
0.043792069,
0.0297136623,
-0.0199586209,
0.000227162,
0.0244260412,
0.0383372717,
-0.0620895922,
0.0343974121,
-0.046357438,
0.0557960495,
0.0075813457,
0.0094738677,
0.0213627908,
-0.0360027477,
-0.0256754719,
0.0405214503,
0.0436637141,
-0.0011106662,
-0.0285007805,
0.0029014279,
-0.0057625757,
0.0546818003,
-0.0140252141,
0.0376575626,
-0.0182256326,
0.0144209629,
0.0320246294,
-0.0492174104,
-0.0079946639,
0.0031856196,
2.472e-7,
0.0186731648,
0.0139883179,
0.0540555753,
-0.0184634775,
0.0179037023,
0.0097496975,
-0.0269536152,
0.0356699899,
0.0171477646,
0.0306225289,
0.039841067,
0.0163576324,
0.0352455229,
0.021538645,
-0.0291051995,
0.0456447937,
-0.0631829202,
0.0396979377,
-0.0383715481,
-0.0498275161,
0.0182104018,
0.036031574,
-0.0294576194,
-0.0144094173,
0.030847786,
-0.038608171,
0.1078507081,
0.0181099586,
-0.0078227753,
0.0645216927,
0.0150445383,
-0.0240195245,
-0.0170693621,
-0.0017436809,
-0.0551304668,
0.0057047955,
-0.0170198381,
0.0457150713,
0.0300088804,
-0.0125806229,
0.0340321697,
0.0142614087,
0.0201618094,
-0.0166890733,
0.0355426557,
-0.068977654,
0.0095349019,
0.0073606009,
-0.0269686077,
0.0020334097,
0.0188053194,
-0.0269346796,
-0.0241184663,
0.034696959,
0.0162635073,
0.0183959045,
-0.0108919106,
-0.0510387644,
-0.042790655,
-0.0456068292,
-0.0718733743,
-0.0212715268,
-0.055529207,
0.0395284668,
0.0180545654,
-0.0376491658,
-0.0083704041,
2.318907349e-34,
0.0097304871,
-0.0079999864,
-0.0114556551,
-0.001264734,
-0.0114653884,
-0.0169776231,
0.0198514201,
0.0246263929,
0.0133299399,
-0.0172170885,
-0.020125825
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.09067v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09067v1 | Secret-Keeping in Question Answering | 2023-03-16T03:56:17 | 2023-03-16T03:56:17 | Nathaniel W. Rollings, Kent O'Sullivan, Sakshum Kulshrestha | cs.CL | cs.CL | Existing question-answering research focuses on unanswerable questions in the
context of always providing an answer when a system can\dots but what about
cases where a system {\bf should not} answer a question. This can either be to
protect sensitive users or sensitive information. Many models expose sensitive
information under interrogation by an adversarial user. We seek to determine if
it is possible to teach a question-answering system to keep a specific fact
secret. We design and implement a proof-of-concept architecture and through our
evaluation determine that while possible, there are numerous directions for
future research to reduce system paranoia (false positives), information
leakage (false negatives) and extend the implementation of the work to more
complex problems with preserving secrecy in the presence of information
aggregation. | [
0.0652068555,
0.0534103997,
-0.0177632365,
0.0557488091,
-0.041805774,
-0.0274590906,
0.0238089263,
-0.0059659984,
-0.0002704269,
-0.0064753075,
-0.0150280073,
-0.0193757657,
-0.0145595493,
0.0032368668,
0.0239945985,
-0.0060041742,
0.0437001884,
-0.0146133834,
0.0140825901,
-0.0526212491,
0.0096030608,
-0.0058396999,
-0.0092144581,
-0.0111479787,
0.0027292327,
-0.0566415302,
-0.0278265532,
-0.031931825,
0.0073775183,
0.0022076522,
-0.0160178654,
-0.0025372417,
-0.0280603506,
0.0961207002,
0.0000019786,
-0.0543541014,
-0.0640581697,
0.0442260392,
-0.0832432136,
0.0043702722,
-0.077958636,
-0.0067043183,
0.0191598628,
0.0233738944,
-0.065986827,
-0.0267170761,
0.0382659025,
0.0412440933,
0.1025258228,
0.0527146123,
0.0160882473,
-0.0043585473,
0.0406276099,
-0.0321782343,
0.0092988545,
-0.0797054321,
0.0117136054,
-0.054968901,
-0.0297830235,
0.006189446,
-0.0014130245,
0.043898318,
0.0355150439,
0.0308058709,
-0.0316242017,
0.0340709873,
-0.0129765943,
-0.0102479327,
-0.0228129234,
0.0205726363,
0.0126001444,
-0.022783339,
0.0032087371,
0.0373047441,
0.0285973083,
0.0335639268,
-0.0282537695,
-0.0055916146,
-0.0417765006,
-0.0480030067,
-0.0196480919,
-0.002048404,
0.0024171963,
0.014545287,
0.0492720157,
0.0366610289,
-0.0019290366,
-0.0097902156,
-0.0340120345,
-0.0298935231,
-0.0158404354,
-0.0875842497,
0.0492668711,
0.0729658529,
0.0213122163,
-0.0065283012,
-0.0437442996,
-0.0522420369,
0.0260891672,
-0.0498382337,
-0.0224860888,
-0.007536768,
0.0246720668,
0.064665392,
-0.0228451267,
0.0568626709,
-0.024699565,
0.0428250097,
-0.000139765,
-0.0257091355,
-0.0100484192,
-0.030651791,
-0.043452166,
0.0911629871,
0.0020298304,
0.0321119428,
-0.0055587841,
0.027786281,
-0.0277077984,
0.0643872544,
-0.0655234754,
0.0394243374,
-0.0005373929,
-0.0204043873,
-0.0091052046,
-0.0281059425,
-0.0436321907,
0.0103988387,
-0.0162129682,
-0.0339391753,
-0.0329556018,
-0.0254888777,
-0.0268420074,
0.0294467788,
-0.000140565,
0.0910850242,
0.0080925003,
0.0075804312,
-0.0128151467,
-0.0654651225,
0.02532392,
-0.0286732465,
-0.0184667241,
-0.0473794155,
0.0141046187,
-0.0035664076,
-0.025981443,
-0.0218254849,
-0.0098746652,
0.0216084849,
0.001896977,
0.0653484166,
0.021294862,
-0.0405562185,
0.0345885865,
0.0470853597,
-0.0206314009,
0.0317749865,
0.0198606867,
0.0405800715,
0.0753907114,
0.0233115815,
0.0617890321,
-0.0327502452,
0.0717934147,
0.0010931431,
0.0480902717,
0.0672862753,
0.0027606289,
-0.0452656746,
-0.0660670474,
0.0324924178,
0.0106514487,
-0.0967824534,
0.0450109281,
0.014980739,
-0.0417120121,
0.0258463174,
-0.0395812728,
-0.0056102886,
0.0098770577,
0.0144743985,
-0.0159160998,
0.0536554493,
-0.126315698,
-0.0227107201,
-0.0438944921,
-0.0040008021,
-0.0361312963,
-0.0231843162,
0.0042601894,
-0.0205381066,
0.014742773,
0.0382168479,
-0.0004605489,
0.0345967561,
-0.0371931344,
-0.0065801847,
-0.0103796897,
-0.0125091877,
0.0194262285,
-0.0688973889,
0.049244158,
0.0245116819,
0.07362587,
-0.0371242873,
0.0367426351,
-0.032364931,
0.029189501,
0.0020103985,
0.0323035941,
0.0071090907,
0.0647944212,
-0.0157974027,
-0.0146345636,
-0.0154287312,
-0.0122858891,
0.0057482738,
-0.0126861995,
0.0089980206,
-0.0153221106,
0.0049269893,
0.0467344411,
0.0107800923,
0.0000777553,
-0.0630648211,
0.0104086138,
0.0155035704,
0.0396928191,
0.0161434896,
-0.0155472597,
0.06041326,
0.0419521444,
0.0032231177,
-0.0246521682,
-0.0682033971,
0.0027798784,
0.0175981987,
-0.0270308275,
-0.0454185456,
-0.0071826479,
0.0679457411,
-0.0166265592,
-0.0010836996,
0.001269578,
-0.0567545965,
0.020128496,
-0.0285606254,
-0.0175555162,
0.0065737534,
0.0047672014,
-0.0466867238,
0.0462561287,
-0.027502561,
-0.011916128,
-0.0627162904,
-0.0329893045,
0.014762938,
-0.0248823036,
-0.002524087,
0.0013483869,
-0.0056189313,
0.0233246498,
0.0083927643,
-0.0206401721,
-0.0023289211,
0.0019578291,
-0.0163881443,
0.0312626213,
-0.0028017459,
0.0419236012,
0.0072680656,
-0.0038970162,
0.0226508565,
-0.0479397029,
-0.0404721461,
0.0247051902,
0.0001525173,
0.0251421034,
0.026539661,
0.0382752568,
-0.005355949,
-0.0100072427,
-0.0026765922,
-0.0143999457,
0.0314513296,
-0.0460798517,
0.0257052016,
0.0132789584,
-0.0123218363,
-0.0389398895,
0.0646529645,
0.0116579542,
-0.015500363,
0.0166879687,
-0.0095387809,
-0.0520800985,
0.0567949079,
0.0510708615,
-0.0134146595,
0.0249271952,
0.014631764,
-0.0192304514,
0.0175639819,
-0.0231567696,
-0.0207678638,
-0.0128809949,
0.020647306,
-0.0057456172,
-0.0032215547,
0.0406072363,
-0.0422262475,
-0.0402669907,
0.0891492665,
-0.019662613,
-0.035862688,
-0.0528169423,
-0.0431633107,
0.0387590043,
0.0467535444,
-0.0267415959,
-0.0335046239,
0.1061326712,
0.0049781683,
-0.0014675068,
-0.0280621238,
-0.0315072499,
-0.0186913051,
0.0695909858,
-0.0173708964,
0.0245054979,
0.0408392251,
0.0130387237,
-0.0567077659,
-0.0603290163,
0.0273190197,
-0.0577041321,
-0.0471955203,
0.0041992916,
-0.0442905165,
0.015961932,
-0.0328756608,
-0.0933875889,
-0.0490522124,
-0.0246090572,
-0.0065674288,
-0.0519076996,
-0.0134523548,
-0.0380072109,
-0.0289899372,
0.048068434,
-0.0092306137,
-0.0057579307,
-0.0391648598,
-0.0266773142,
0.0156992003,
0.0243214332,
-0.0046600886,
0.0228373241,
-0.0147625189,
0.0203400105,
0.1125492528,
0.0269275904,
0.0178313926,
0.0535718203,
-0.0533534698,
0.0253265891,
-0.0031268694,
-0.030746121,
0.0032837265,
-0.0004643837,
-0.0352007039,
-0.0121344822,
0.0381317586,
0.0539892241,
0.050514888,
0.0016267819,
-0.0116457278,
0.0087826699,
-0.0293740965,
0.0259505957,
-0.071186766,
0.0095127504,
-0.0131802317,
0.0531730913,
-0.0307911132,
-0.0234683417,
-0.0552689284,
-0.0653811172,
-0.0499580316,
-0.001887764,
-0.0263761617,
-0.0274619907,
-0.0727513283,
-0.042828463,
0.0137740821,
-0.018447293,
-0.0032797444,
0.0481822714,
0.0086284699,
0.0043803412,
-0.0306057557,
0.0445846841,
0.0089900205,
-0.0199096333,
-0.0210779291,
0.0631817505,
0.0302492604,
0.00659825,
-0.0608757511,
-0.0466256738,
-0.0123778069,
-0.0238123722,
-0.0066550532,
0.0598393492,
-0.0260290932,
-0.0236694943,
-0.0211678129,
0.0347030871,
-0.0042106267,
0.0107857957,
0.0675672069,
0.0444479994,
-0.0181202013,
0.0026588945,
-0.0428760648,
0.0044933828,
0.0041231415,
0.0464968085,
-0.0371025987,
-0.0301990025,
-0.0114981811,
-0.0313551463,
0.0319032446,
-0.046888411,
-0.0085297944,
0.0048476127,
0.0323441476,
-0.015036786,
-0.0508312918,
-0.0451265983,
-0.0251497924,
0.0249644425,
-0.0130679784,
-0.0136844916,
-0.0079169823,
0.0489055105,
-0.0151160387,
-0.0520695671,
-0.0379196666,
0.0231747702,
0.0008872437,
-0.0284311995,
0.0253967009,
-0.0237127822,
-0.0147405807,
0.0370992459,
-0.033867918,
-0.029027652,
0.0175394509,
0.0725645795,
0.0239478666,
-0.0305734687,
-0.0428470485,
-0.0433395654,
0.0808672234,
0.0188011862,
-0.0480152145,
-0.0142885083,
0.0662597567,
-0.0383116826,
0.0207491405,
0.0206829514,
-0.0376808792,
-0.016940292,
0.0596636124,
-0.0490219891,
-0.0963049158,
-0.0033486567,
-0.0087855784,
0.021310471,
-0.0015085845,
0.0505869761,
0.005159962,
0.0214415975,
0.0635705516,
-0.0266952794,
0.0020835211,
0.0003632045,
0.0027825127,
0.0261743963,
-0.006953991,
0.0590968058,
-0.0030627481,
0.047088068,
0.000001665,
-0.0060466998,
-0.0035887738,
0.0748153031,
0.0323353298,
-0.0054884101,
0.0059019588,
-0.0141833108,
0.0389454141,
0.0163933374,
0.0323154479,
-0.0026382387,
0.0298270117,
0.0127595793,
-0.0325703695,
0.0002501182,
0.0285327099,
-0.1120977178,
-0.0732248127,
0.0246830247,
0.0643742234,
0.0210458841,
0.0371630006,
-0.0367974676,
-0.0074913637,
0.0107066389,
-0.0140148597,
-0.0233440585,
0.0085776513,
-0.0318791345,
0.0094551081,
0.0375379659,
0.015143998,
0.0345919393,
0.0532186367,
0.0041392362,
0.0331168957,
-0.0231367499,
-0.0287323464,
-0.0575346351,
0.0096947085,
-0.0026859464,
0.0719679669,
-0.0040033157,
0.0312327873,
-0.0622854345,
-0.0262993965,
0.0126860347,
0.0229763985,
0.0319084339,
0.0120541379,
0.0186321139,
0.016436927,
0.0552744344,
-0.0569927208,
-0.0590660051,
0.0298364926,
-0.0031728332,
-0.0400769711,
0.0022232991,
-5.485473408e-33,
-0.0147860423,
-0.0306744669,
-0.0210583881,
0.0267349649,
0.0683580413,
0.0364845023,
0.0120957894,
-0.0069455798,
-0.0575028807,
-0.0244233124,
-0.0400422886,
0.0144678606,
-0.0064704609,
0.0149657913,
-0.0575562529,
-0.043441806,
0.0381126702,
-0.0183863956,
-0.0305624176,
0.016891323,
0.0738201365,
0.0052972035,
0.0054518031,
-0.0535041653,
0.0461015478,
-0.0213767439,
-0.0399241559,
0.0454408377,
-0.0670605451,
0.0427071005,
-0.0166626144,
0.0194839351,
-0.0031235937,
-0.0094280159,
0.0158635825,
0.0277862586,
-0.0445244685,
-0.0600996539,
0.0412383005,
0.006372069,
-0.0353025645,
-0.0107628396,
0.0203839168,
-0.0306301713,
0.0392570011,
0.0085250111,
0.0077990089,
0.021430891,
0.0103982706,
-0.0434173644,
0.0442751981,
-0.0112212645,
-0.0113474503,
-0.0553256534,
0.0161449276,
0.0233721845,
0.0040920302,
-0.0660450459,
-0.0667505488,
0.0112911733,
0.028690191,
0.0052458798,
0.0355734713,
-0.0064388183,
-0.0133077651,
0.0346894749,
0.0481841341,
-0.0099184969,
-0.0123719228,
0.0043046605,
-0.0300016981,
-0.0047504413,
0.1197677478,
0.0436100513,
0.0213584788,
-0.014888538,
-0.0738617033,
0.0062289508,
0.0144669162,
0.0334255472,
0.0516022369,
0.022857273,
-0.0595851131,
0.0330376253,
-0.0323579945,
0.0404014811,
-0.03343134,
0.0051575536,
-0.0108555052,
0.0392084233,
-0.0639097542,
-0.0056248768,
-0.0052067954,
-0.0702433139,
0.0211830325,
0.0478682742,
0.0704654381,
-0.0209864564,
0.0185619462,
0.012414583,
-0.0286232587,
0.0500425063,
0.03729764,
-0.0433150195,
0.0067085922,
0.015116021,
0.0219784994,
0.0082522621,
-0.0587876402,
0.0090928655,
0.0116832079,
0.0573028103,
0.0297383834,
-0.0452478975,
0.0136023778,
0.0042581069,
-0.0061476957,
-0.0071570966,
0.0056492374,
0.0031708053,
-0.0566150956,
0.0659515858,
-0.0329423435,
0.0213210322,
0.0099002756,
-0.0248404201,
0.0154856965,
0.0079809707,
0.0073336018,
-0.0336580388,
0.0075023631,
-0.0205410775,
2.591e-7,
-0.0291067343,
-0.0418573879,
0.0267189723,
-0.0055327713,
0.0385778509,
0.0556678846,
0.0252462812,
0.0565777048,
0.0022700713,
-0.0452278554,
-0.0416815691,
0.0251095574,
0.0163582638,
0.0585437678,
-0.0313835777,
-0.0303339176,
-0.0085480735,
-0.01264155,
-0.0304333791,
0.010171935,
0.0529002547,
0.0665914938,
0.0702897161,
0.0134988837,
-0.0341094658,
-0.0652744398,
0.0150370523,
0.0293387529,
-0.007071896,
-0.0180489346,
0.0701739937,
0.040375866,
0.0077393311,
0.0312946439,
-0.0131162656,
-0.0105537707,
-0.031963855,
0.0319770351,
-0.0079031456,
-0.089751035,
-0.0187224876,
-0.026993081,
-0.0190409794,
-0.017647,
0.0837691128,
0.0188604649,
-0.0347291045,
0.0077571799,
0.0168691371,
-0.0054972684,
0.0194141679,
0.0156743396,
-0.04892442,
-0.0154566765,
-0.0037565934,
0.0222174693,
0.0588395894,
-0.0119046951,
-0.011839808,
-0.0059683979,
0.0102065345,
-0.0383112058,
0.0395852737,
-0.0057412162,
-0.0140921799,
-0.0033768297,
-0.0012678392,
1.932787071e-34,
-0.0207609069,
-0.020273244,
0.0003246985,
0.0150827561,
0.0147369867,
-0.0209571831,
-0.0036284775,
-0.0264116097,
0.0912542045,
0.0097988164,
-0.0403150283
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.09038v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09038v3 | Translating Radiology Reports into Plain Language using ChatGPT and GPT-4 with Prompt Learning: Promising Results, Limitations, and Potential | 2023-03-16T02:21:39 | 2023-03-29T03:22:52 | Qing Lyu, Josh Tan, Michael E. Zapadka, Janardhana Ponnatapura, Chuang Niu, Kyle J. Myers, Ge Wang, Christopher T. Whitlow | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, physics.med-ph | The large language model called ChatGPT has drawn extensively attention
because of its human-like expression and reasoning abilities. In this study, we
investigate the feasibility of using ChatGPT in experiments on using ChatGPT to
translate radiology reports into plain language for patients and healthcare
providers so that they are educated for improved healthcare. Radiology reports
from 62 low-dose chest CT lung cancer screening scans and 76 brain MRI
metastases screening scans were collected in the first half of February for
this study. According to the evaluation by radiologists, ChatGPT can
successfully translate radiology reports into plain language with an average
score of 4.27 in the five-point system with 0.08 places of information missing
and 0.07 places of misinformation. In terms of the suggestions provided by
ChatGPT, they are general relevant such as keeping following-up with doctors
and closely monitoring any symptoms, and for about 37% of 138 cases in total
ChatGPT offers specific suggestions based on findings in the report. ChatGPT
also presents some randomness in its responses with occasionally
over-simplified or neglected information, which can be mitigated using a more
detailed prompt. Furthermore, ChatGPT results are compared with a newly
released large model GPT-4, showing that GPT-4 can significantly improve the
quality of translated reports. Our results show that it is feasible to utilize
large language models in clinical education, and further efforts are needed to
address limitations and maximize their potential. | [
0.0589717887,
-0.0068287868,
-0.0171300732,
-0.0089467978,
-0.0346599929,
0.0284032002,
0.0038819683,
0.0601266026,
0.01294138,
-0.0120132072,
-0.0024293626,
-0.0339078419,
0.0256952904,
0.0098151658,
-0.0030184425,
-0.1319304854,
0.0288604237,
-0.0042025307,
0.0347177386,
-0.0047512488,
0.021314485,
0.0076127173,
-0.0294219684,
0.0409581624,
0.0182244685,
-0.0108497599,
0.0113049746,
-0.018519504,
0.0152502172,
-0.0398209244,
-0.0411101356,
0.0396061279,
-0.0115476968,
0.045528952,
0.0000021699,
-0.0331576392,
-0.0392158292,
0.031848304,
-0.0235647503,
-0.0292386636,
0.0938689187,
-0.0379430354,
-0.0256401151,
-0.0001417101,
-0.0308622811,
-0.0397841074,
0.0468653031,
0.045468498,
0.0736500174,
0.0684717,
-0.0065980856,
0.0119612543,
0.0024952518,
-0.0034616538,
0.0449334048,
-0.0500522703,
-0.0066484273,
0.0658516511,
0.0295670256,
0.0526629314,
0.0015933926,
0.0449847281,
-0.0089965966,
0.0019600338,
-0.0401450321,
0.0636128634,
-0.0243485253,
-0.0301978141,
0.0007825747,
0.0322427824,
0.0040560993,
0.0078213308,
-0.0036332279,
-0.0058229216,
0.0167057458,
0.0058767102,
-0.0660513788,
0.0062370002,
-0.0157506596,
-0.0174455922,
0.0054268935,
-0.0051366263,
-0.014807798,
-0.0142997568,
-0.0029035835,
-0.0363025852,
0.0072423341,
-0.0250262395,
0.0316298902,
0.0258957259,
-0.0301889908,
-0.0321660787,
0.0324083753,
0.0376408473,
-0.0457096472,
0.0330370441,
0.0078516761,
-0.0080632875,
0.0781771913,
-0.0661031976,
-0.0641353205,
0.0436996818,
-0.0229006801,
0.0506633222,
-0.0162021499,
0.0452982448,
-0.0070159542,
0.0588028952,
-0.0590585209,
0.0404967889,
-0.0628084242,
-0.0351493284,
-0.0603122078,
0.0249225367,
0.0114407344,
-0.0037682024,
-0.0791097507,
-0.0228466019,
0.0277993772,
0.0347409695,
0.0425903685,
0.0068695564,
-0.0760016665,
0.0285361595,
-0.0261657368,
0.0596492216,
-0.0016378436,
-0.0264553353,
0.0002006169,
-0.013461886,
0.0360510498,
0.0273163952,
-0.0107781375,
0.016009165,
-0.0196511727,
0.0311544295,
-0.0273050964,
0.0036202043,
0.0250284448,
-0.0523655638,
-0.0231350325,
-0.0319721177,
0.0135564655,
-0.0648587048,
0.0048089684,
0.0393842384,
0.0338334441,
0.0109654479,
0.0207816307,
0.0138579179,
-0.0456333645,
0.053647913,
-0.0203654934,
0.010505884,
0.0411491469,
0.0414213017,
-0.0053247018,
0.0148363281,
0.0041462048,
-0.0069651408,
-0.0165083855,
-0.0282439012,
0.0043543857,
0.0090235556,
-0.0127890632,
-0.0229100212,
0.0242440272,
0.0020251821,
0.0194037985,
0.068591319,
-0.039844539,
0.0807927325,
-0.0258896034,
0.0289717205,
0.0320501924,
0.0618512258,
0.0298016611,
0.0252912231,
0.0120031033,
-0.0069695669,
-0.0023456779,
0.018870566,
-0.0127979387,
0.0210451707,
-0.0173101556,
-0.0020467823,
-0.0283040944,
-0.0213232525,
-0.0306193214,
-0.0180199686,
-0.0402924605,
0.0139733404,
0.0138706686,
-0.008378868,
0.0357353874,
-0.0134346271,
-0.0471497364,
0.0290930569,
0.0400873795,
-0.0277525149,
-0.0120459953,
-0.0704743341,
-0.0163028371,
0.0970308259,
0.0491739288,
-0.0039155618,
-0.0150750987,
-0.0230903197,
0.050297197,
0.0387291871,
0.0599116273,
0.008580789,
-0.0328073949,
-0.039250616,
-0.0291979183,
0.061557319,
0.0103756627,
-0.0060650934,
0.0000061702,
0.0587731935,
-0.0303991362,
-0.0279208925,
-0.0462781303,
0.0245711692,
-0.0057742642,
-0.0159081407,
-0.0400435179,
0.0112935826,
0.0175072197,
0.0194064751,
-0.0027101275,
0.0112012858,
0.0008084736,
0.0389511734,
-0.0390028991,
0.0258474983,
-0.0625574291,
-0.0416560285,
0.0137957595,
-0.0627332181,
-0.0079009077,
-0.0282962658,
-0.0211603884,
-0.0003390962,
-0.0547332056,
-0.0621845424,
0.0440620147,
-0.0035139336,
0.0327073261,
0.0478675514,
-0.0275479797,
-0.0241492912,
0.0319862925,
-0.0031469651,
0.0134683745,
0.0183513779,
-0.0331541151,
0.0116058365,
-0.078790307,
-0.0369436629,
0.0551980101,
0.0151379947,
0.0097663533,
0.0051561161,
0.0720993727,
-0.0288583431,
-0.0298243891,
-0.0970112011,
-0.0279031098,
0.0122735435,
-0.0124200825,
0.0721978694,
0.0071478966,
0.0031898385,
-0.023486916,
-0.055515077,
-0.0006784719,
0.0627671704,
0.021596171,
0.0319921821,
0.0443535112,
0.0010439112,
-0.0270634349,
-0.0183869414,
-0.0340654701,
-0.011281305,
0.0743324757,
-0.057768587,
-0.0331648178,
0.0396409892,
-0.017098112,
-0.0252580866,
0.0142938308,
-0.0703652725,
0.0246640947,
-0.0553211607,
-0.0185715985,
0.0313907601,
0.006417932,
0.0294911396,
0.0249376316,
-0.0153597333,
-0.0427241139,
0.0005975071,
-0.0483730584,
-0.0667433292,
0.0370465517,
-0.0994704142,
-0.0291939229,
0.0365733169,
0.0255044494,
0.0354430079,
-0.0698513314,
-0.0062847701,
-0.0566936657,
0.0191367287,
-0.0721536055,
0.0048247525,
-0.0022585916,
0.0299091861,
0.0037813478,
-0.0155414045,
0.0979232118,
0.0001841385,
0.0092710424,
-0.1168528199,
0.0204902906,
-0.013725251,
0.0242954735,
-0.0425328203,
0.0436226837,
0.0345122404,
-0.0420422778,
-0.0170308501,
-0.0161167718,
0.0493321344,
-0.0534617193,
0.0007238935,
-0.0297197588,
0.0047968817,
-0.0212550722,
-0.0063630636,
-0.0282953214,
-0.0273920484,
0.0203904249,
-0.0161231942,
0.02969734,
0.0003913549,
-0.0787122995,
0.052520752,
0.0334987454,
0.0443524048,
0.0067039807,
-0.0249810424,
0.0106317941,
-0.0120691489,
0.0142297717,
-0.0011134376,
-0.0179134179,
-0.0305110328,
0.0458680578,
0.0898523033,
-0.0392087288,
0.0112095568,
0.0061498997,
-0.0131699853,
-0.0061798128,
0.0070218318,
-0.0254843161,
0.004233039,
0.015385842,
-0.0322204866,
-0.0105803721,
0.0968404561,
0.0385969616,
-0.048924271,
-0.0339752063,
-0.0194133278,
-0.0177667718,
-0.0330702737,
0.02155062,
-0.0454029702,
0.0041726637,
-0.0144360289,
0.0520574562,
-0.0044987928,
-0.0115539776,
0.0196129642,
-0.0239212383,
0.0442664847,
0.0127157317,
-0.0582915731,
-0.0291776359,
-0.0176710598,
-0.0158275422,
0.0094210915,
-0.0142711848,
-0.0085225701,
-0.0004090183,
-0.0069836061,
0.0113210604,
-0.0793550313,
-0.0443137921,
0.0371790752,
0.0017611709,
0.0026159384,
0.0682869554,
0.0385378189,
-0.0319660865,
-0.0289589558,
-0.0246607028,
0.0583770834,
0.0165747292,
-0.0192357618,
0.0859616399,
0.0285227168,
0.0104172137,
-0.0534700528,
0.0131803676,
-0.0092936233,
0.0186998267,
0.0151854483,
0.0706468299,
-0.0214121919,
-0.0217133965,
-0.0118950792,
0.0636101291,
0.0419403724,
0.0429157168,
-0.0259586293,
0.0242706314,
0.0024890755,
-0.0183949657,
0.0532241613,
0.0267042331,
-0.0444679931,
0.0262800977,
-0.0399088115,
-0.0576483496,
-0.0893028378,
-0.0404159911,
0.0425170995,
0.0157831386,
0.0150874481,
0.0312966853,
0.0141329933,
0.0235787984,
0.0103923688,
0.0294965748,
0.0093855336,
-0.0086297952,
-0.0727392584,
-0.0607253909,
0.0128107006,
-0.0197749622,
0.0043066144,
0.017901253,
-0.0351362005,
0.0041093891,
0.0088692401,
0.035875503,
0.0343978219,
-0.0270110462,
-0.0121092955,
0.0022747372,
0.0349446647,
0.0355026349,
-0.0358806588,
-0.0092442585,
-0.0172730461,
0.0059717502,
-0.0023219725,
-0.0066338568,
0.006233654,
-0.0013082146,
-0.01651177,
0.0297154933,
-0.0413796194,
-0.0318290256,
0.0579284541,
0.0704824775,
0.0282479469,
-0.0085679675,
-0.01776856,
-0.0129533494,
-0.0087826513,
-0.0420214795,
0.0110326149,
-0.0105331708,
-0.0052410406,
0.035503041,
-0.0269640181,
0.0074982429,
-0.0170959216,
-0.0674163997,
-0.0590549186,
-0.0188304968,
0.036138583,
0.0113004493,
-0.0062442892,
0.0638238937,
-0.0036188776,
-0.0292235296,
-0.0570337735,
0.0069701886,
0.0281132739,
-0.0062246835,
0.0983936116,
0.0206259936,
0.0113695478,
0.0335012414,
0.0236701649,
-0.0175757613,
-0.085875988,
-0.0207522213,
0.0521845408,
0.0301108472,
0.0431342423,
0.0132442331,
-0.067534484,
0.0047384738,
-0.0162843224,
0.0278283749,
0.0196426529,
0.0005922054,
0.0445594527,
-0.0171326865,
0.0464138538,
-0.0289115254,
0.0689586103,
-0.0666388273,
0.0042390195,
-0.0144293029,
-0.0656737238,
-0.0583550632,
-0.007893078,
0.0041820803,
-0.0005743225,
-0.0377682224,
-0.0034802526,
-0.0418854468,
-0.0376276299,
-0.0510695092,
0.0078174928,
-0.0198320989,
-0.0412555151,
0.0599939302,
0.0619837418,
-0.013685707,
-0.0304373559,
-0.0255286675,
0.0757320002,
-0.0104607791,
-0.0047191982,
-0.0080620823,
-6.019733019e-33,
-0.0184698217,
-0.0319860354,
0.047905121,
0.0103852544,
0.0350135081,
0.0026152139,
-0.0341442786,
0.0218063612,
0.0029429691,
0.0246655717,
-0.0153159192,
-0.0254289843,
0.0233903434,
-0.0036140746,
0.0026878701,
-0.0148827657,
0.032001745,
-0.0116511816,
-0.0239475686,
0.0151489777,
-0.0027557672,
0.0002858403,
0.0628914833,
-0.0853532925,
0.0134524899,
-0.0040562605,
-0.0208690166,
-0.0156717822,
-0.0175551064,
0.0445788726,
-0.009104427,
0.0191172119,
0.0289000589,
-0.0221691504,
-0.0059280172,
0.0217263848,
-0.0709165037,
-0.0365473516,
0.0258962791,
0.0177174117,
-0.027279878,
0.0115129929,
0.0093902694,
-0.0595321693,
0.0095354971,
0.0047215903,
0.0261404533,
-0.0037783331,
-0.0069949795,
0.0397685878,
-0.0492131338,
0.0397711024,
0.012859744,
-0.0070608635,
-0.0259573348,
0.0406405479,
-0.0530252941,
-0.0018309209,
-0.0214299783,
0.0319399461,
0.0887280181,
0.0268621296,
0.0211047474,
-0.0543200076,
-0.0361697562,
0.0111368001,
0.0422291458,
-0.0153919766,
-0.0077580512,
0.0013756602,
-0.0114001958,
-0.0164798591,
0.0479332097,
0.033511769,
0.0146624269,
-0.0290712863,
-0.0529457219,
0.0477271192,
-0.0081726406,
0.0616057776,
0.0282307584,
0.0051233089,
-0.0887600109,
-0.0253981873,
0.0145898648,
0.0179061592,
-0.0168635938,
-0.08656881,
0.0370926373,
0.0159491226,
0.0100273192,
-0.0085287215,
0.0276211854,
0.0185624417,
0.0164745301,
-0.0590321906,
0.0087185921,
0.0295533147,
-0.0678943172,
-0.001306347,
-0.0517597608,
-0.0111163249,
0.0318947732,
0.009620768,
0.0184145775,
0.0254957937,
0.0386887901,
0.0023869567,
-0.0501160659,
0.0259549264,
0.011272423,
0.0052147647,
-0.0165551472,
-0.0241216943,
0.0278604012,
-0.0059633432,
-0.004999646,
0.0272852387,
-0.0082234815,
-0.0229487345,
-0.0731649995,
-0.0640768558,
-0.013855489,
-0.0155072585,
-0.0557470992,
0.0007226694,
-0.028032491,
0.0123478426,
0.0678305104,
-0.0203584731,
-0.0105597312,
0.010864797,
2.876e-7,
0.0713541433,
0.0454024933,
0.0168075357,
-0.0032172543,
0.010037642,
-0.0126469526,
-0.0183466449,
-0.0009700738,
0.0500717089,
0.005949677,
0.035616979,
-0.00380753,
-0.0014078123,
0.0586343333,
-0.0896929875,
-0.0599101223,
-0.0332648233,
-0.0229451861,
-0.0240734965,
-0.0011163555,
0.1191151217,
0.0361526906,
-0.0403387323,
-0.0168384612,
-0.026278777,
-0.0171315614,
0.0471472517,
-0.0470871031,
0.0047241813,
0.0037893963,
0.0250657722,
0.0101747597,
0.0081701884,
0.0730453432,
0.0113843288,
-0.0706681758,
0.0292456374,
0.0718682408,
-0.0216380525,
0.0170653574,
0.0270078946,
-0.0171946492,
0.0140682478,
-0.0641980171,
0.0202119742,
-0.0723154023,
-0.0096938247,
0.0508355834,
-0.0179800224,
-0.029220866,
0.0475091934,
-0.0387012661,
-0.0712020546,
0.0232323129,
0.0083685881,
0.0444361977,
-0.025421964,
-0.0391609594,
0.0246113744,
-0.0120445266,
-0.0040498897,
-0.0740598664,
0.0303335674,
-0.0045855162,
-0.0318395793,
-0.0438255556,
0.0015840129,
2.518827484e-34,
0.0290805791,
0.0109394817,
0.0230302922,
-0.0338779725,
0.0237636436,
0.0117167775,
0.0496092439,
0.0243927203,
0.0440231822,
-0.0314205736,
-0.0354256034
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.09031v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09031v1 | A Picture is Worth a Thousand Words: Language Models Plan from Pixels | 2023-03-16T02:02:18 | 2023-03-16T02:02:18 | Anthony Z. Liu, Lajanugen Logeswaran, Sungryull Sohn, Honglak Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Planning is an important capability of artificial agents that perform
long-horizon tasks in real-world environments. In this work, we explore the use
of pre-trained language models (PLMs) to reason about plan sequences from text
instructions in embodied visual environments. Prior PLM based approaches for
planning either assume observations are available in the form of text (e.g.,
provided by a captioning model), reason about plans from the instruction alone,
or incorporate information about the visual environment in limited ways (such
as a pre-trained affordance function). In contrast, we show that PLMs can
accurately plan even when observations are directly encoded as input prompts
for the PLM. We show that this simple approach outperforms prior approaches in
experiments on the ALFWorld and VirtualHome benchmarks. | [
0.0404599942,
0.0443783477,
-0.0086375698,
0.0244608074,
-0.0158774219,
0.0083422856,
0.0086620916,
0.003102591,
0.0061229253,
-0.0388782956,
0.0012182923,
-0.0171900541,
0.0252030604,
0.0708616301,
-0.0051754927,
-0.0657091513,
-0.0002274853,
-0.0561148673,
-0.0243624877,
0.0004923928,
-0.0016273645,
-0.0182184596,
-0.0100627569,
0.0423265323,
-0.020650534,
0.0130408742,
-0.0731787682,
-0.0062562879,
0.0092440359,
-0.0399849564,
-0.0503482185,
0.0238664076,
0.05704825,
-0.014266748,
0.0000018443,
-0.0244019795,
0.0049651568,
-0.0419948734,
0.0071254545,
-0.0090330988,
0.009579693,
-0.0433632135,
0.0083222389,
-0.024630921,
-0.0479227789,
-0.0235630944,
0.0754072815,
0.0108141238,
0.0514722504,
0.0643574968,
-0.0256433543,
-0.008795945,
0.0143617913,
-0.0037709768,
0.0226993244,
-0.0121678896,
0.0196662582,
-0.0107918344,
0.0256965086,
-0.0001680987,
-0.0384323671,
0.0251861606,
0.0326801613,
-0.0063087507,
-0.0203490332,
0.078724131,
0.0043233652,
-0.0714304522,
-0.0464612171,
0.0642685443,
-0.020082606,
-0.015307175,
0.0492968522,
-0.0178451166,
-0.0263543967,
0.0002373875,
-0.0281453952,
0.0664016157,
0.0241551604,
0.0407733396,
-0.0197107811,
0.0138250776,
-0.0056516835,
0.0005707004,
-0.0409317389,
0.0541050918,
0.0041045621,
0.0041230037,
-0.0080139264,
0.0076255831,
0.0042594378,
-0.092951566,
0.020307878,
0.0641285926,
-0.0107534975,
0.039888788,
-0.0440901741,
0.0053931572,
-0.0326587893,
-0.0196609441,
0.0623444133,
0.0523728319,
-0.027063597,
0.0421367176,
-0.0238770228,
0.0811688974,
0.0194757301,
0.0288525987,
-0.0174485147,
0.0554352365,
-0.0228764378,
0.0090220589,
-0.0557542555,
0.0215983186,
-0.0877573341,
-0.05807117,
0.0398809873,
0.0214284714,
-0.005753689,
0.0373492725,
0.0089992341,
0.0267477948,
-0.0007102849,
-0.0413716249,
-0.072128959,
-0.0555864125,
-0.0265661161,
0.0150071485,
-0.0101024928,
-0.046985019,
0.0167961679,
0.0207969565,
0.0291212406,
0.0143046938,
-0.0316441618,
0.0680987686,
-0.0085773291,
-0.0295154732,
-0.0115240514,
-0.0172441341,
-0.0145269101,
-0.0292513501,
0.036345344,
-0.0446203016,
0.0208416786,
-0.0331786685,
0.0013120029,
-0.042302642,
0.0312894545,
0.0048803799,
-0.0018781612,
0.0808355361,
-0.0069642393,
0.043982029,
0.0244167503,
0.0115106544,
0.040542338,
0.0588947795,
0.0466036797,
0.0761238262,
-0.0064263102,
0.0405651703,
0.0526473634,
0.0507376045,
-0.0025566665,
0.0008366609,
-0.0173015371,
-0.0052799219,
0.0084299464,
0.029219253,
-0.0091892267,
0.0473169759,
-0.0239547193,
-0.0227449425,
0.0575904027,
0.0688215494,
-0.0421190448,
-0.0277547743,
0.0763811469,
-0.0009881142,
-0.020793207,
-0.0304945875,
-0.0607495867,
0.0506278686,
0.029400479,
-0.0141495317,
-0.002483337,
-0.0202048533,
-0.0296807773,
-0.0684753507,
0.0080074975,
-0.008487694,
0.0151906935,
-0.0242090486,
0.0193802249,
0.0167148504,
-0.0624327846,
-0.0381033458,
-0.0262644533,
-0.0341655537,
0.0037218702,
-0.0257305223,
0.045011919,
0.0782700703,
-0.0029863704,
-0.013737605,
0.0003933538,
0.0322176814,
0.0554687753,
0.0783369169,
0.0165657606,
-0.0093524996,
0.0434092507,
-0.0274162702,
-0.021995699,
-0.0126837613,
-0.007742025,
0.0443907529,
0.004234449,
0.0062915278,
-0.0046214238,
0.004530842,
-0.036371164,
0.0616034977,
-0.0094169183,
-0.008054221,
-0.0359666124,
0.0147199007,
-0.0077626477,
-0.0343133211,
-0.0205661189,
0.0171681419,
0.0134696066,
-0.0209668782,
0.0053516761,
0.0118944002,
-0.0539160594,
-0.0595271029,
0.0308502875,
-0.0531744771,
0.0142300669,
-0.0069292947,
-0.0177849028,
-0.0394638814,
-0.0011390318,
-0.001058055,
0.0450671278,
-0.0144306421,
0.022271242,
0.0283754449,
-0.0329491757,
-0.0151039846,
0.0353140496,
-0.0421103425,
-0.0204755962,
0.0021214199,
0.0252278466,
-0.0030747068,
-0.0514154285,
-0.0030788889,
-0.0053182971,
0.0247614104,
-0.0111511163,
0.015822798,
0.0275120735,
-0.0454282425,
-0.0040908935,
-0.0936043933,
-0.0498446412,
-0.0147166876,
-0.0291068293,
0.0153097576,
-0.0476046503,
-0.0086861802,
-0.0266922656,
-0.012688051,
0.0691004619,
-0.0126924869,
0.0128849614,
0.0330443345,
0.0189044699,
-0.0205922574,
-0.0526052713,
-0.0041679065,
-0.0032378805,
0.0131535083,
0.0335426182,
-0.042882029,
-0.0388973877,
0.0425524563,
-0.0215389896,
0.0342728719,
-0.0268547982,
-0.042681843,
0.0252542496,
-0.0551400594,
0.0228313487,
0.0548867919,
-0.0003903063,
0.0435319766,
0.0544179529,
-0.0361793973,
-0.0344971716,
0.0119179981,
-0.0553578623,
-0.0026904491,
-0.0207036901,
-0.0052122311,
0.0191998892,
0.0696191862,
-0.0286731552,
0.0359943584,
-0.0860605538,
0.0390947536,
0.0038697228,
-0.067076087,
0.0078825019,
0.0183525681,
-0.0238027684,
0.0711494908,
-0.0604939982,
-0.0733332485,
0.0367623009,
-0.0505907163,
-0.0378243327,
0.045429185,
0.0270217303,
0.0132034328,
0.0717983991,
0.0515804738,
0.0252011921,
-0.0136254299,
0.0091558984,
-0.030441232,
0.0018518082,
-0.0270891413,
0.0180282611,
0.0349478237,
-0.1023722887,
0.0109824603,
-0.0014434181,
-0.0212525651,
-0.037975397,
-0.0064480109,
-0.0487581417,
-0.0078419568,
-0.0568580106,
-0.0120053478,
-0.0204012003,
0.029285701,
0.0180631764,
0.0351996347,
0.011530621,
-0.0257662497,
-0.0390573256,
-0.0277418066,
0.0715403929,
0.0419911183,
-0.0551081076,
-0.0315198004,
0.0365152881,
0.0204831082,
-0.0153698614,
-0.01336342,
-0.0608492568,
0.0631931573,
0.008298154,
0.017227754,
-0.0058538392,
0.0645885691,
0.0554301403,
-0.0191485435,
-0.0239791032,
0.0642212182,
0.0248763058,
0.0087396614,
-0.0025089227,
-0.0161248446,
0.043697726,
0.0360780694,
0.0319369771,
-0.0372023843,
-0.0299041793,
-0.0117979096,
-0.0399493761,
0.0148365796,
-0.0486864448,
-0.0245822184,
-0.1082783043,
0.0432942659,
0.0028505796,
-0.0449591391,
0.0105433604,
0.0127169872,
0.0053781522,
0.0077815559,
-0.0735379308,
-0.0024791486,
0.0228209347,
0.0180447455,
0.0065336572,
-0.009391591,
0.0382029265,
0.002545963,
-0.0210886635,
0.0453697592,
0.0659861416,
0.0220012292,
0.0056862808,
-0.0700949579,
-0.0064129615,
0.0153311072,
0.0231743883,
-0.0235635396,
0.0257789828,
-0.0220845416,
-0.0098324902,
0.0506137721,
0.0444251187,
-0.0537692718,
-0.0522399284,
0.0138421692,
0.0473076589,
-0.0344945677,
-0.0300473664,
-0.0144415479,
0.0185324773,
0.0207514223,
0.0456071235,
0.0214851592,
-0.0144302417,
-0.083731398,
-0.0426995941,
-0.0222307574,
-0.0544935726,
-0.0395881385,
-0.0160754751,
0.0052572517,
-0.0171719305,
-0.0836949795,
-0.0382225923,
0.0727386475,
0.0707081705,
0.0359065123,
-0.0676665306,
0.0361006707,
0.0175569374,
-0.0267300922,
0.0130001297,
-0.0310671479,
0.005407711,
-0.0441008285,
-0.0305718519,
0.0255090445,
-0.0836437047,
0.0051724291,
0.0124301463,
-0.0121296998,
-0.0421348363,
-0.0140467929,
0.1086639464,
0.0188309234,
0.0272243619,
0.0080027087,
-0.0262380652,
0.0633810014,
0.0265139733,
-0.001275257,
0.0301050693,
0.0385312922,
0.0260923337,
0.0029071916,
0.0217686892,
-0.0270302072,
0.0348770246,
0.025925409,
0.0509671532,
-0.0193615723,
-0.0160452332,
0.0149485534,
-0.025417326,
0.0457806215,
-0.0366116613,
-0.0098969918,
-0.0354370512,
-0.00730818,
-0.0051002046,
0.0018630148,
-0.0768132657,
0.0243701264,
0.0055401516,
0.0677685142,
0.0387931727,
0.0025830872,
-0.0337426141,
0.003824106,
0.049208466,
-0.0079643112,
0.0386329181,
0.0071780281,
0.01983371,
0.0359258987,
0.0107693244,
0.0334857106,
-0.0589929149,
0.0473975874,
0.0186131857,
0.0427199677,
0.0448989123,
-0.0127585735,
-0.0394909084,
0.0312892906,
-0.0258434638,
-0.0494335666,
0.0151770655,
0.0546604991,
0.033142779,
-0.0133700576,
0.0134353666,
-0.0508945771,
0.0231256485,
0.0007191067,
0.0209542029,
0.0517524779,
-0.0719381496,
0.0595286191,
0.0302547365,
-0.0249190889,
-0.0232611857,
0.0288376007,
-0.0098872688,
0.05014221,
0.0253280699,
0.0010500783,
-0.0285719149,
-0.0121094109,
0.0032605804,
0.0084094815,
-0.0029089395,
0.0104981223,
-0.0098644849,
-0.035390839,
-0.0237367433,
0.0692332759,
-0.032367602,
-0.0007645208,
0.0519816503,
0.0082864584,
0.0115732169,
-0.0027077682,
-0.0272223055,
-0.0199340805,
-0.0272921529,
0.0008546811,
-0.0056061074,
-5.012176403e-33,
-0.0375439972,
-0.0428329632,
0.0739281848,
0.0009058233,
0.0228335466,
-0.0030607569,
-0.064104706,
0.0107820593,
0.0041698446,
0.0092529971,
-0.0030115354,
-0.0197001733,
0.0156115759,
0.026372822,
-0.0089981817,
-0.0052095065,
-0.0074271145,
-0.0221876334,
-0.0452586636,
-0.0265975855,
0.0004526096,
0.0040341737,
0.007060166,
-0.0069538001,
-0.0254208017,
0.0168041531,
-0.0052513732,
0.029165294,
0.016203966,
0.052489385,
-0.0642676726,
-0.0392814763,
0.0098996917,
-0.0110143367,
-0.0415763855,
0.0663174763,
-0.0673555732,
-0.0412401222,
0.0254113916,
0.0047223703,
-0.0963703915,
0.0032534208,
-0.0131216412,
-0.0025960053,
-0.033427123,
0.0274992827,
0.0339277536,
-0.0284395218,
-0.0011518608,
0.0459055677,
-0.044410646,
0.005153629,
-0.0045427931,
-0.0413190909,
0.0943547562,
-0.0086834356,
0.018144317,
0.0203709118,
-0.0114184804,
0.0496907271,
-0.0039641787,
0.0107881436,
0.0640245527,
0.0424120538,
0.0462773331,
0.08268518,
0.0400899649,
-0.0128709599,
-0.0625803545,
0.0434882976,
0.0236749481,
0.0570108928,
-0.0004989622,
0.0169120971,
0.0006388737,
0.0304090865,
-0.0145755494,
0.0381260403,
-0.071608305,
0.0248969831,
0.0244672298,
0.0170221999,
0.0084654605,
0.0056411834,
-0.0458447598,
-0.0119136078,
-0.0180061087,
-0.0115531124,
0.0562065691,
0.0508042872,
-0.0050925263,
0.0078140125,
0.0575680919,
-0.0189396143,
0.0016458026,
-0.0098086894,
-0.0459717475,
0.032915812,
0.0044270623,
0.0410083011,
-0.0434610322,
-0.0461991131,
0.0609281398,
0.0201796759,
0.0181509387,
0.0193784684,
-0.0268220827,
0.0613678135,
-0.0145418383,
-0.0210507065,
-0.0427997336,
-0.0379905924,
0.0129605634,
0.007239054,
0.0377663262,
-0.0208756793,
-0.0520283803,
0.0087016821,
-0.0358046405,
-0.0635233372,
-0.0205031335,
-0.0361176506,
-0.0144425947,
0.0239354763,
-0.047699932,
-0.0169385113,
-0.0474581644,
-0.0032171304,
0.0327772237,
-0.0445519537,
0.0041468586,
0.0449258275,
2.517e-7,
-0.0084529268,
0.003334139,
0.0448001437,
-0.0060645044,
0.001666254,
0.0252073295,
-0.0258372407,
0.0151193449,
-0.0435112044,
-0.0846488178,
0.0420260541,
0.0516326912,
0.0270509068,
-0.0378430262,
-0.0427071862,
0.0142011913,
0.0050293677,
-0.0395411365,
-0.0748260692,
-0.0235570055,
0.0612170435,
0.0707350597,
-0.0070437687,
0.0144279283,
0.0219420083,
-0.0512794368,
0.0458337851,
-0.0599177815,
0.0516772717,
-0.0004845372,
-0.0143233687,
-0.0050214799,
-0.0426825657,
0.001288131,
-0.0100050364,
-0.0041829818,
0.0216297302,
0.0721257031,
-0.0225945134,
-0.0177811924,
-0.0219873693,
-0.0059697619,
-0.01127881,
-0.0475276113,
0.0681205615,
-0.034135364,
0.0014297812,
0.0233963411,
0.0125325182,
-0.0094629517,
-0.0526714809,
-0.0093779666,
-0.0147023061,
-0.0041857562,
0.015959125,
-0.0045767776,
0.003478985,
-0.1041185558,
-0.005769942,
-0.0060512167,
-0.0259792414,
-0.0043735486,
-0.0841738507,
0.0281938035,
0.0257822387,
-0.0327169597,
-0.0517073385,
1.773841638e-34,
-0.0327978469,
0.0112644341,
-0.0307838377,
0.0134424232,
0.0319001824,
0.0021502776,
0.0133760907,
0.02273909,
0.0244277306,
-0.0746203735,
-0.0348920338
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.09014v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09014v1 | ART: Automatic multi-step reasoning and tool-use for large language models | 2023-03-16T01:04:45 | 2023-03-16T01:04:45 | Bhargavi Paranjape, Scott Lundberg, Sameer Singh, Hannaneh Hajishirzi, Luke Zettlemoyer, Marco Tulio Ribeiro | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) can perform complex reasoning in few- and
zero-shot settings by generating intermediate chain of thought (CoT) reasoning
steps. Further, each reasoning step can rely on external tools to support
computation beyond the core LLM capabilities (e.g. search/running code). Prior
work on CoT prompting and tool use typically requires hand-crafting
task-specific demonstrations and carefully scripted interleaving of model
generations with tool use. We introduce Automatic Reasoning and Tool-use (ART),
a framework that uses frozen LLMs to automatically generate intermediate
reasoning steps as a program. Given a new task to solve, ART selects
demonstrations of multi-step reasoning and tool use from a task library. At
test time, ART seamlessly pauses generation whenever external tools are called,
and integrates their output before resuming generation. ART achieves a
substantial improvement over few-shot prompting and automatic CoT on unseen
tasks in the BigBench and MMLU benchmarks, and matches performance of
hand-crafted CoT prompts on a majority of these tasks. ART is also extensible,
and makes it easy for humans to improve performance by correcting errors in
task-specific programs or incorporating new tools, which we demonstrate by
drastically improving performance on select tasks with minimal human
intervention. | [
-0.0113661857,
0.0348860174,
-0.0212458931,
0.0370891355,
-0.0583129823,
0.0246632192,
0.0373913534,
-0.0259130057,
0.0123308375,
-0.0338892937,
0.0193854347,
-0.0035878473,
-0.0155832637,
0.0179740619,
0.0165824126,
-0.0584729165,
0.0404285379,
-0.0746521503,
0.0056657791,
0.0011162744,
-0.0156569518,
0.0184269436,
-0.0419825763,
0.040245533,
0.001924475,
-0.0402034782,
-0.0462405197,
-0.0004663697,
0.0104952455,
-0.0319030806,
-0.0302013401,
0.0590994805,
0.0263853483,
0.0300374981,
0.0000023256,
-0.062139079,
-0.0085522793,
0.0076115238,
-0.0662039891,
-0.0055441055,
-0.0011809469,
0.0489575639,
-0.0093539413,
0.0404008292,
-0.0371377915,
0.0259530898,
0.0209164862,
-0.0045885062,
0.0681403205,
0.0379154868,
0.0088386154,
-0.0102323536,
-0.0184738357,
0.004306233,
0.0011750959,
-0.045539692,
-0.0050438424,
0.0375831798,
0.0755118877,
-0.0145658776,
0.0078941602,
0.0445672125,
0.0777939186,
-0.0236731991,
-0.0326012671,
0.0512521341,
-0.0177697036,
-0.0503185801,
-0.0014917036,
0.0354937278,
-0.0434545614,
-0.0414340347,
0.009986667,
-0.0047998559,
0.0004453545,
0.000485771,
-0.0530748814,
0.0525996201,
-0.0225842986,
-0.0070394124,
0.0013567848,
-0.0381414443,
0.020085549,
0.0154482266,
-0.0371972807,
0.0828956068,
0.0050934618,
-0.0079832515,
0.0011352728,
0.0071288417,
-0.0024088838,
-0.1002607718,
0.0009843021,
0.0695463941,
-0.0616753362,
0.0222474802,
-0.0182618573,
-0.0237951931,
0.0044306768,
-0.0030271567,
0.0464138389,
0.0629385784,
-0.0282569118,
0.0493260287,
-0.0477850288,
0.0348359235,
-0.0091879936,
0.0059393952,
-0.0281207021,
0.0093523674,
-0.050721813,
-0.0010885043,
-0.0532780364,
0.0073428047,
-0.038577646,
-0.0047417018,
0.0003965265,
0.0358710475,
-0.0021618435,
0.0394531041,
0.0025346521,
-0.005332293,
0.0177352671,
-0.0405517109,
-0.019304283,
0.0221001133,
-0.0575658605,
-0.0004735543,
0.0377570912,
-0.0495243929,
-0.0239241235,
0.0088625401,
-0.019587718,
-0.0231005587,
0.0353366472,
0.0604556836,
-0.030939104,
0.0104082962,
-0.049689468,
-0.0573953241,
0.0275006872,
-0.1159119681,
0.0270921625,
-0.1017162874,
0.0041290252,
0.0299628545,
-0.036620561,
-0.0158092137,
0.0120208133,
0.0253935158,
-0.0071265036,
0.0670813471,
-0.0024410407,
-0.0011214137,
0.0035948781,
0.0232397001,
-0.0378574207,
0.071981743,
0.0248282477,
0.0349999368,
0.0024033324,
0.0215332508,
0.0168198198,
0.0482155308,
0.0094294176,
-0.0099983085,
-0.0323248431,
0.0259633865,
-0.0033398457,
0.0505605489,
-0.0074217496,
0.0186458435,
-0.0116053838,
0.0486784242,
0.0102876807,
0.0605355017,
-0.015174048,
0.0064298082,
0.0577134192,
0.0008671665,
0.0056518023,
-0.0130748339,
-0.0710704774,
0.0774508864,
-0.0321122594,
0.0143107967,
-0.0055136331,
0.0507903323,
-0.0113204271,
-0.033432655,
-0.0144002968,
0.031683322,
-0.0038681156,
0.0345616825,
0.049132213,
0.0137327136,
-0.0293165892,
0.0468490832,
-0.0054899515,
-0.0466909818,
-0.0505056977,
-0.0723381862,
0.0382262059,
0.0804976672,
0.0411092527,
0.0042851958,
-0.0554558896,
0.0023194528,
0.0559103042,
0.0223507006,
0.0155473426,
-0.0032647417,
-0.0267426074,
-0.0423929617,
-0.0274800621,
-0.012057472,
-0.003038218,
0.0148035986,
0.054078538,
-0.0154093821,
0.0084497146,
-0.0369704627,
0.0137976315,
0.0222928077,
-0.0438555256,
-0.005589243,
-0.0153951533,
0.0208554938,
0.0072715161,
-0.0018266335,
-0.0133979814,
0.016859524,
0.0221772324,
-0.0148088681,
-0.0318322815,
0.0215442814,
-0.0341381766,
-0.017945854,
0.0391685516,
0.0138925249,
-0.0362977013,
-0.0028802152,
-0.0244632997,
-0.0350256376,
0.0295323469,
0.0053560487,
0.018022716,
-0.0206528716,
0.0318625905,
-0.0003859412,
-0.0305726416,
-0.0187727697,
0.0635053366,
-0.013115271,
0.000215835,
0.0457317419,
0.0217313804,
-0.0013086301,
-0.0237534549,
0.0125368014,
0.0458896235,
-0.0055077658,
-0.0004684131,
-0.0258081965,
0.0645529777,
-0.040218994,
-0.008823785,
-0.0977092311,
0.026800612,
-0.0289261248,
0.0201206617,
-0.0057502612,
-0.004313441,
-0.0129141258,
-0.0075186454,
-0.0116219735,
0.0186651647,
0.0244704783,
0.0131291794,
-0.0033714329,
0.0054218005,
-0.0363784395,
-0.004017856,
-0.0124152834,
-0.0261051282,
0.0349048264,
0.0047207465,
-0.0058374186,
-0.0390901864,
0.0492539369,
-0.0289367195,
0.0393799953,
0.003300529,
-0.0056391545,
0.0526918061,
-0.0367582552,
0.026982991,
0.0789763257,
-0.0325192474,
0.0271071028,
0.0754238591,
-0.0404639319,
-0.062077973,
0.0432889834,
0.0415593125,
-0.0070104259,
0.0092763957,
-0.0092940051,
-0.0507298149,
0.0615709648,
-0.0120292641,
0.0058292323,
-0.0212116558,
0.0266872607,
0.0101468284,
-0.0158909932,
-0.0147596281,
-0.0274367072,
-0.0194237493,
0.0496343672,
-0.0287407991,
-0.0427614562,
0.0835762098,
-0.0478643812,
-0.0265284497,
-0.0262133349,
0.0062174019,
-0.0078470716,
0.1124469787,
-0.0110306162,
0.0047855251,
-0.0012121857,
0.0043947143,
-0.0295290835,
-0.005150117,
0.0151947271,
-0.0365457274,
0.0384311415,
-0.0777715743,
0.0039499155,
-0.0152469929,
-0.0298804548,
-0.0616104975,
0.0362643227,
-0.0709223226,
0.0089853611,
-0.0030780106,
-0.0486432351,
0.0120754763,
-0.0136602623,
0.0517799817,
0.0497122854,
-0.0019341926,
-0.0142546482,
-0.0218629446,
0.0078322394,
0.0293917134,
0.014260293,
0.0148146115,
-0.018330371,
0.0601671934,
0.0529443398,
0.0774428174,
-0.0225050468,
-0.047010906,
0.0036408778,
0.0125734396,
-0.0109148212,
-0.0081575215,
0.0526181497,
0.0446601249,
-0.1034501418,
-0.0203757919,
0.103747718,
0.0438241698,
-0.019369904,
-0.0025328565,
-0.0299447738,
0.028404275,
0.0454062596,
0.0642196536,
-0.1175083295,
-0.0536460839,
0.045438081,
-0.0105474489,
-0.0063008186,
-0.039988216,
-0.0227010865,
-0.1315768808,
0.0532721952,
-0.0055265371,
-0.0028930034,
0.0411391929,
-0.0253658574,
0.0016548015,
0.0501898527,
-0.0252587534,
0.0472832806,
0.013362214,
0.0059633506,
-0.0021208518,
0.0089626983,
-0.0262642,
0.0856780335,
-0.0156504083,
0.0321278982,
0.0520178787,
0.0033370638,
0.0186512861,
-0.0347130001,
0.0944402739,
0.021387767,
0.0170414019,
-0.0377416797,
-0.0030036343,
0.0237236563,
-0.007781703,
-0.0202364158,
0.0305094551,
-0.0200152341,
-0.0426276661,
0.0181180742,
0.1143083572,
-0.0360771306,
-0.035503611,
-0.0049603079,
-0.0122636845,
-0.0080770878,
0.0428302661,
0.017023297,
-0.0214339849,
-0.0537427552,
-0.0424129069,
-0.0721609816,
-0.0583777688,
-0.0354304388,
-0.0054992116,
0.0199828874,
0.0213135742,
-0.0239677541,
-0.0133659774,
0.0748491883,
0.0634774491,
-0.0047324295,
-0.0302160326,
0.0024035233,
0.0278477781,
-0.0579603761,
0.0339339487,
-0.0351429507,
0.0486793295,
-0.0309869945,
0.0085529983,
-0.0065193875,
-0.0305084288,
-0.0159355365,
0.0574361309,
-0.0689863712,
-0.0645476356,
-0.0332254544,
0.0515438132,
0.0316027179,
0.0336878784,
-0.0234520901,
-0.0379975177,
0.0024916502,
0.0134495487,
-0.0317309313,
-0.003953231,
0.0110880407,
-0.008678698,
0.0095329704,
0.023685893,
-0.0360315219,
0.0040463572,
-0.0130454283,
0.0416309237,
-0.0059456588,
-0.0384702496,
0.0207264367,
0.0366269611,
-0.0169705097,
-0.0153626464,
0.008894383,
-0.0247540027,
0.0366226882,
-0.0052647702,
-0.0366292335,
-0.0429714769,
0.0297234617,
-0.0314646475,
-0.0219511222,
0.046844054,
-0.0227422956,
0.0109203588,
0.0178249106,
-0.0014835772,
0.0291305706,
-0.0078227827,
0.0338632092,
0.0673051253,
-0.0149940168,
-0.0135260439,
0.0245939195,
0.0028666698,
0.0427884459,
-0.0378400944,
0.0952787995,
0.024899397,
-0.0102827409,
-0.0576963276,
0.0136797903,
-0.0444310904,
-0.1011410952,
0.006395896,
0.0226053111,
0.063682124,
0.0091812871,
0.0156654101,
-0.0648197755,
-0.0122859655,
0.0064924397,
0.0282206368,
0.0177870858,
-0.0587049164,
-0.0106532285,
0.0428479537,
0.0109447185,
-0.0288817324,
0.0359768718,
-0.0258447677,
0.0403720923,
0.0148471212,
-0.0139596313,
-0.041735962,
-0.0690911189,
-0.0333430432,
-0.0219196826,
0.0036172995,
0.0015844358,
-0.0580152646,
-0.0799474865,
-0.037353456,
0.0332708098,
-0.0330565348,
-0.0158615727,
0.0457896292,
0.0702935085,
0.0164993927,
-0.0275162701,
0.0020575139,
0.0247997884,
0.0197847281,
-0.0359311812,
-0.022249965,
-6.3775175e-33,
-0.0236712992,
-0.0427446142,
0.0808873922,
-0.0229706336,
0.0119665172,
-0.0389581434,
-0.0723160058,
0.0268782061,
-0.0037477026,
0.0120028388,
-0.0180089939,
-0.001824653,
0.0159635786,
-0.0141208638,
0.0370150954,
0.00086079,
0.0214425866,
0.0086727021,
-0.0283156727,
0.0136699984,
0.027389057,
0.0005800668,
0.0099901324,
-0.0269203782,
0.0037091717,
0.0036171547,
-0.0126824901,
0.040573746,
-0.0668426231,
0.0251759924,
0.0028327988,
0.0003382886,
0.0125555843,
-0.0508749112,
-0.0109012043,
0.0164088551,
-0.0564515144,
-0.0129176835,
0.0354066156,
-0.0110277543,
-0.0678635836,
-0.0389962159,
0.0123175438,
0.0228250492,
-0.0240916833,
-0.0012187078,
0.0024454514,
-0.0114134811,
0.0220560003,
-0.0057062237,
-0.0466310792,
0.0065461351,
-0.0125290817,
-0.0734408572,
0.0128879538,
0.0282388739,
-0.0226425622,
-0.0295761898,
-0.0072179721,
0.0078553846,
0.0303786434,
0.0018684081,
0.0951803103,
-0.0058292407,
-0.0103041166,
0.0304393955,
0.0008564088,
-0.012678463,
-0.0453828387,
0.0180035494,
0.0304216836,
0.0726683065,
0.0385492519,
-0.0178925768,
-0.0052255285,
0.0305842962,
-0.0325275697,
-0.0072299484,
0.0401538834,
0.0805415809,
0.0491844192,
0.0093316277,
-0.0197332744,
-0.0195253175,
-0.0245224889,
0.0057810815,
-0.0472485125,
-0.031100003,
0.0420770496,
-0.0013841547,
-0.0117477449,
-0.0456845053,
0.0398372523,
0.0052000694,
0.0100918785,
0.0377098657,
-0.0204752702,
0.0215030871,
-0.0007442795,
0.0467285141,
-0.0172568634,
0.0017214954,
0.0031033161,
-0.0049158731,
0.0292407088,
0.0164816938,
0.0073395814,
0.0306654777,
-0.0563902035,
0.0027139559,
-0.0985715315,
0.0337161012,
0.0205035023,
0.0099808509,
0.0183349065,
0.0073025348,
-0.0125314416,
0.0358993337,
-0.0146946823,
-0.0567241348,
-0.0429489613,
0.0447426178,
-0.003581018,
-0.0012763873,
-0.0192348659,
0.0065215421,
-0.0612515584,
0.0103359083,
0.0157004837,
-0.0549535789,
-0.0046581682,
0.0308253486,
3.037e-7,
-0.0024159153,
0.0398488119,
0.0011778022,
0.0606205352,
0.0040138052,
0.0294460654,
-0.032817401,
-0.0318243317,
0.0307883434,
-0.0335305221,
-0.025150001,
0.0641478077,
0.0391687639,
0.0573670454,
-0.0595455281,
-0.0229713432,
-0.0146671394,
-0.0131917698,
-0.0689048991,
-0.0025631415,
0.0423076376,
0.0348295197,
0.0118137067,
-0.0143171744,
0.0320378132,
-0.0421446636,
0.0075529218,
0.0041019404,
0.0120772393,
-0.015403254,
-0.0309170429,
0.0104024895,
0.012720949,
0.0303354487,
0.0067754872,
-0.0241605081,
-0.0176302548,
0.0698012039,
0.0153457588,
0.0096181268,
-0.009176434,
-0.053869646,
0.0016723827,
-0.0384960659,
0.0848069787,
-0.0384741127,
0.0074275131,
-0.0118169952,
0.0370227769,
-0.0422006436,
-0.0365479812,
-0.0078528402,
0.0247455221,
0.0270299949,
0.0038544745,
-0.0294861812,
-0.0098502766,
-0.0751635134,
-0.0635591224,
0.0404927731,
-0.0481488705,
-0.0349508449,
-0.0413605124,
-0.0106410878,
0.0012248231,
-0.0507261194,
-0.024333328,
3.27835043e-34,
0.0255641956,
0.0033754376,
0.0356316231,
0.0526504144,
0.0357561447,
0.0084978519,
-0.0343941599,
0.0140221063,
0.0265291128,
-0.0716836303,
-0.0437240154
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.08991v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.08991v5 | DeltaScore: Fine-Grained Story Evaluation with Perturbations | 2023-03-15T23:45:54 | 2023-11-02T06:08:44 | Zhuohan Xie, Miao Li, Trevor Cohn, Jey Han Lau | cs.CL | cs.CL | Numerous evaluation metrics have been developed for natural language
generation tasks, but their effectiveness in evaluating stories is limited as
they are not specifically tailored to assess intricate aspects of storytelling,
such as fluency and interestingness. In this paper, we introduce DELTASCORE, a
novel methodology that employs perturbation techniques for the evaluation of
nuanced story aspects. Our central proposition posits that the extent to which
a story excels in a specific aspect (e.g., fluency) correlates with the
magnitude of its susceptibility to particular perturbations (e.g., the
introduction of typos). Given this, we measure the quality of an aspect by
calculating the likelihood difference between pre- and post-perturbation states
using pre-trained language models. We compare DELTASCORE with existing metrics
on storytelling datasets from two domains in five fine-grained story aspects:
fluency, coherence, relatedness, logicality, and interestingness. DELTASCORE
demonstrates remarkable performance, revealing a surprising finding that a
specific perturbation proves highly effective in capturing multiple aspects. | [
0.0257215798,
0.0426783599,
-0.0319821276,
-0.0131846834,
-0.0572297275,
0.0070571257,
-0.0033765081,
-0.030361509,
-0.0318968184,
-0.0454093069,
0.0015005373,
-0.0156575013,
0.0439580753,
0.1154052317,
0.0192604344,
-0.0499869063,
0.0143235167,
0.0160714928,
0.0443111435,
0.0383355916,
0.0246608444,
0.0384595878,
-0.0191812385,
0.0626877695,
-0.0011605042,
0.0084614847,
0.0076781269,
0.0181891304,
0.0624167211,
-0.018923847,
0.0034324504,
0.0345507897,
0.0135212047,
-0.0180532169,
0.0000019934,
-0.0603030138,
-0.0107465191,
-0.004741306,
0.0344549827,
0.0090936068,
0.054655157,
-0.0047196411,
-0.0068394919,
0.0059717679,
-0.0319205001,
0.0138872815,
0.0324914381,
0.0429207161,
0.0191140231,
0.0932791606,
-0.0102612562,
-0.0278614573,
-0.0181337893,
-0.0029533464,
0.0149684316,
-0.0080406135,
-0.0310917255,
0.0135976505,
-0.0001558242,
-0.0362533629,
-0.0068405513,
-0.0193754248,
0.0108863739,
-0.0076475954,
0.0087015433,
0.059560746,
-0.0027528589,
0.03250755,
-0.0076216534,
0.0525693037,
-0.0075989454,
-0.0345656388,
0.0095653106,
-0.0375695713,
0.0180242751,
-0.010645573,
-0.0256711878,
0.0052293725,
0.0127714453,
0.0198888294,
0.0470239781,
0.0158517696,
0.0045186928,
0.0211570412,
0.0334876068,
0.0099343462,
0.0288869049,
-0.0142655931,
-0.075089477,
-0.0044210036,
0.0033566488,
-0.0793435052,
0.0245613959,
0.0384837762,
-0.0102210818,
-0.0066395304,
-0.0808265805,
0.0222526491,
0.0073856362,
-0.0470637344,
0.0303803552,
0.0195926931,
-0.0170997828,
0.007789663,
0.0025864365,
0.0590745173,
0.0520171113,
-0.0441511124,
-0.0179815777,
0.0589926355,
-0.0447442532,
0.0293706376,
-0.0428822339,
0.0205193348,
-0.0286127143,
-0.0427656397,
-0.0214257985,
-0.0007353263,
0.0333145596,
-0.0254176147,
-0.0192439165,
0.0296754576,
-0.0206946209,
0.0029042638,
-0.0171850771,
0.0150906844,
-0.0658048317,
0.0124966307,
0.0611374378,
0.0093648015,
-0.0300384015,
0.0103145419,
0.0460663773,
-0.0100242365,
0.0213433802,
0.0060040415,
-0.0139445215,
-0.0416201837,
-0.062019214,
-0.0906465799,
-0.0175950211,
-0.0733974278,
-0.0912782624,
-0.034677919,
0.009966827,
0.0071988613,
0.0177650135,
-0.0577012561,
-0.0029090452,
0.0034807955,
-0.024255503,
-0.0152059132,
-0.02086832,
-0.0030047058,
-0.0051247906,
0.0074497368,
0.0058931285,
0.0227404181,
0.1044191644,
0.0466563813,
0.0496521667,
0.0101021454,
0.0180151407,
-0.0260307845,
-0.0396058857,
-0.0274377968,
0.0072971946,
-0.0100394767,
-0.0440827943,
0.0488385744,
0.0264829434,
0.0381331854,
-0.0448264815,
0.0313590243,
0.095058158,
0.022982778,
0.0265657809,
0.0313022621,
0.0964319333,
0.0185890626,
-0.0117830923,
0.0803998858,
-0.0118496921,
0.0137549294,
-0.0177718457,
0.0202096589,
0.0528732911,
0.0198926721,
-0.0093573984,
-0.0413301177,
0.0009536204,
-0.0114862062,
-0.000432604,
-0.031791348,
-0.0234663412,
0.0249544084,
-0.0637056381,
-0.0177686494,
0.018695401,
-0.0938547254,
0.0677765608,
0.0086350469,
0.0295844469,
0.1007376537,
0.0776782408,
0.0298497081,
-0.0188700333,
-0.0230212789,
-0.012904874,
0.0078182202,
0.0416533984,
-0.0090511972,
0.0450981893,
-0.0243837498,
0.0140727805,
-0.0689674169,
0.0372726172,
-0.0292764474,
-0.0196415167,
0.025299279,
0.0238919444,
-0.0415061042,
-0.033301603,
0.0386608504,
-0.0218025669,
-0.0006675252,
0.0143121565,
-0.0141427312,
-0.0306151696,
0.0064348313,
-0.0307786055,
0.025459066,
-0.0008918808,
-0.0283226576,
-0.0024920639,
0.0631557927,
-0.0252147838,
-0.0596926026,
-0.0052257152,
-0.0405389443,
0.0264962707,
-0.0130058434,
-0.010220821,
-0.0524686426,
0.0515419915,
-0.0582841188,
0.0068926527,
-0.0299781058,
0.0363923237,
0.0027709515,
0.016950909,
-0.0227752011,
0.0737022832,
0.0037743635,
0.0288260169,
-0.0423776656,
0.0096946955,
0.0068915058,
-0.0208991561,
0.0109802112,
-0.029983582,
0.0060349023,
0.0011753268,
0.049301669,
-0.0105218366,
-0.0128640784,
-0.0631234944,
-0.0512596481,
0.0276644919,
-0.0190441385,
0.0292932726,
0.0507789366,
0.001610134,
-0.0274119563,
0.0355100706,
-0.0490373522,
-0.0332253613,
0.0280759558,
-0.0082177622,
0.0370366797,
0.0530493781,
-0.0122904321,
-0.0589810461,
0.0309173223,
0.0089935157,
0.0517860353,
0.0715664625,
0.0260275733,
-0.0653401241,
0.0585975163,
-0.0372955836,
-0.0357953757,
0.0182424709,
-0.0618688837,
0.013570236,
0.0447462127,
0.0842080265,
0.029307887,
0.0253506284,
0.0267149322,
0.0462224931,
-0.0514778234,
0.0068610138,
-0.0227938034,
-0.0327339321,
0.0602802709,
-0.020364916,
-0.0476089083,
0.0362387486,
0.0313677341,
0.0408926494,
0.0106781069,
-0.0531365536,
0.0583518259,
-0.024047507,
-0.021382235,
0.0766138211,
-0.0131604644,
-0.0026717575,
0.0545782037,
-0.0117661431,
-0.0415148586,
0.0974899605,
-0.0515800118,
0.0056361943,
-0.012849669,
-0.0169299729,
-0.0600549951,
0.0424405523,
-0.0288463198,
0.0403157696,
-0.0073799002,
-0.0176136978,
-0.0187290758,
0.005361638,
0.0306734927,
-0.0222765747,
0.0197841264,
-0.0314401314,
-0.0230544899,
0.0304308385,
-0.0325086974,
-0.0194282178,
-0.075731203,
0.001805827,
-0.0026597974,
0.053634923,
-0.0380377211,
-0.0329544693,
0.0220903568,
0.0010747737,
0.0211105198,
-0.0337396376,
-0.0061255833,
0.0006675512,
0.039068114,
0.0730004236,
-0.0053896536,
0.0120310327,
-0.0298289955,
0.0215231217,
0.0138671072,
-0.0185860675,
0.0371491276,
0.0121769458,
0.0036518569,
-0.0005299412,
-0.054701373,
-0.0283738486,
0.032045763,
0.0721222609,
-0.0648657307,
-0.0645543113,
0.1221765131,
0.0330344699,
-0.0008235442,
0.0455724411,
0.033620704,
0.0503692925,
-0.0115329428,
0.0158496927,
-0.0420084484,
-0.0261448957,
-0.0012618783,
0.0045373905,
-0.0271675531,
-0.054045625,
-0.0380758978,
-0.0602051876,
0.0248210188,
0.0207418595,
-0.0257663168,
-0.0763246417,
-0.0041301423,
-0.0132251382,
0.0096959705,
-0.012079671,
0.0117185023,
-0.0389725938,
0.0282528643,
-0.0205408372,
-0.0154906847,
-0.071536541,
-0.0189330634,
-0.0331376716,
0.0200657696,
0.0754497424,
0.0299398396,
0.0122448094,
-0.0236433763,
-0.0360306054,
0.0005396851,
0.0223904233,
0.0052080397,
0.0433590375,
-0.0169481207,
0.0077644419,
-0.029257115,
0.0416161865,
0.0248527937,
-0.0548836291,
-0.0368427634,
-0.0028632034,
-0.024759531,
-0.0401408076,
0.0212112218,
0.0569585487,
0.0281457864,
0.0864773318,
0.0707966909,
-0.0533170104,
-0.0390537158,
-0.0146861766,
0.0280603748,
-0.0652077273,
0.009484265,
-0.0092741754,
0.0393868722,
-0.0014830471,
-0.1123509929,
-0.0679482147,
-0.0088805584,
0.0237478185,
0.0102186827,
0.0090043889,
-0.0331543908,
-0.0183306318,
-0.0155083565,
0.020629162,
0.0007244266,
0.0035140081,
-0.0474794172,
-0.0151528176,
0.0050904327,
-0.0366283581,
-0.0206920095,
0.0233213864,
-0.0803444758,
-0.0562363975,
-0.0165528134,
0.0010858278,
0.0126475133,
0.0143823614,
0.0045477068,
-0.0697868317,
0.0166962408,
0.0069480874,
-0.0578214861,
0.0638359785,
-0.0038884468,
-0.0140989237,
-0.0019593772,
0.0028233221,
-0.0125566218,
-0.0143270483,
-0.0194501001,
0.0745122731,
0.0182150137,
-0.0466300733,
0.0110302782,
-0.0309362169,
0.0082275635,
-0.0714298487,
0.0124775758,
-0.0669226125,
-0.0263059046,
-0.0052770567,
-0.0050567971,
-0.0640790612,
-0.0012465027,
0.0237410292,
-0.0051368019,
-0.0275109448,
0.0057586418,
-0.0928795487,
0.0301546529,
-0.0642838627,
-0.0159488153,
0.0005446955,
-0.0180353094,
-0.002991071,
0.0016247319,
-0.0344150364,
0.0019627055,
-0.0499757938,
0.0265375767,
-0.0239786878,
0.0233942941,
0.0084078424,
0.0138531523,
0.0331118442,
0.0480716191,
-0.0266301706,
0.033826258,
-0.0321738906,
-0.0206228998,
0.050967712,
0.0093090171,
0.0951820314,
0.0059885508,
0.0396418832,
-0.0227521583,
0.0494820029,
0.0092156166,
-0.0502348766,
-0.0384707525,
-0.0002324777,
-0.0160442423,
0.0298390444,
0.0719117373,
-0.0425506197,
0.0332953483,
0.0052201017,
-0.0133321099,
-0.006916523,
-0.0271381699,
-0.0042531663,
0.0492351279,
0.023003526,
-0.0052286093,
-0.0883920193,
-0.0163433962,
0.0150784077,
0.0184897222,
0.0402297936,
-0.0083664004,
0.0299615078,
0.0273817778,
-0.0356211513,
0.0220854543,
-0.0599299222,
-0.0539112724,
0.019065788,
0.0138512077,
-0.0211940166,
-6.342454708e-33,
-0.0159065947,
-0.0231999289,
-0.01291457,
0.0108212149,
-0.0486462787,
-0.0168749932,
-0.0546681099,
0.0140462834,
0.0357599035,
0.0350664333,
0.0380351841,
-0.0244325977,
-0.0066623916,
0.0105296858,
-0.0378212333,
-0.007602626,
0.0542952269,
0.0426551886,
-0.0931891724,
0.0499948896,
0.0181453358,
0.0127716763,
0.047262352,
-0.02617185,
0.010642468,
-0.0293023959,
-0.055268988,
-0.025348682,
0.0584368855,
0.0342239365,
0.0170170814,
0.0265244823,
0.0187497213,
-0.0049167811,
-0.0336820222,
-0.0233938079,
-0.0017351342,
-0.0331244059,
0.039382536,
-0.0228099879,
0.0160145592,
-0.0299716052,
0.0135157155,
-0.0215264447,
-0.0006993207,
-0.0159671362,
0.0355995782,
-0.0040764124,
0.0197134353,
-0.0443320535,
-0.0750686675,
0.0430786237,
-0.0189584419,
-0.0698053241,
-0.0357853323,
0.0547419973,
0.0105449073,
-0.0303313285,
0.0045760828,
0.0474250652,
0.0282312818,
0.058032427,
0.0011464597,
-0.04707307,
-0.0416655019,
0.0777840465,
0.001370258,
0.0087659257,
-0.0138340006,
0.0429663323,
0.0075106705,
0.0134337228,
0.018944798,
0.0509542078,
0.0350730047,
-0.0067627593,
-0.0667230338,
0.0638604537,
-0.0203977358,
-0.0180874262,
0.0171289705,
-0.0080260821,
-0.0310967918,
-0.0228794646,
-0.0440968648,
-0.0319156535,
-0.0292790122,
-0.046243988,
0.0135274623,
0.0145172942,
-0.0132456934,
0.0203018505,
0.0123845981,
-0.004919732,
0.0152332783,
0.0170506705,
-0.088431716,
0.0264104623,
-0.0070418157,
0.0051008342,
-0.0109492317,
-0.0026256619,
0.0632388294,
0.0293452404,
0.0396217331,
-0.0156983025,
0.0270450264,
0.0644529983,
-0.0461269766,
0.0260843132,
-0.0134711638,
0.0346520506,
-0.0141863395,
-0.0410273299,
0.005188778,
-0.0187996104,
-0.0403446369,
0.0322659425,
0.01026705,
0.0102851354,
-0.0337501355,
-0.0069459355,
-0.0018944968,
0.0491406024,
-0.0333252586,
0.0094365738,
0.0248130057,
-0.0059043663,
-0.0021544306,
-0.019884795,
-0.0075572571,
0.0226392988,
2.737e-7,
-0.0039814375,
0.0326482952,
0.0112793865,
0.0200496875,
-0.0079767667,
0.0233015139,
0.0003183514,
0.0257513635,
0.0002954686,
0.0117739495,
0.0058938772,
0.0008869283,
0.0462608002,
0.0117208101,
-0.0698298141,
0.0193043835,
-0.0485454351,
0.0036011566,
-0.0532063618,
-0.0549637675,
0.0795290992,
0.0044257357,
0.0290350951,
-0.0066822069,
0.0053208689,
-0.0626572371,
0.0635703057,
-0.0083458144,
-0.0460563116,
0.0434981249,
-0.0141146556,
-0.001615111,
-0.0354952402,
-0.0258995034,
-0.0394836776,
0.0326869376,
0.0044242707,
0.0545289516,
-0.0004730875,
-0.041472327,
0.0296799261,
-0.0044650859,
-0.0222823042,
-0.0418011285,
0.0494846739,
-0.013863774,
-0.0281107258,
-0.0099140378,
-0.0050688125,
0.019123394,
0.0136952512,
-0.0391657837,
-0.0548657179,
0.0413483679,
0.0226701461,
0.0244710855,
-0.0123038283,
-0.0263878405,
-0.0580624603,
0.0185963567,
-0.0144147156,
-0.0099942815,
-0.0013865428,
-0.0330794044,
-0.0302434117,
-0.058371447,
0.0242681876,
2.682819737e-34,
0.0536278449,
-0.0028042719,
-0.0060191676,
0.0174851362,
0.0528581664,
0.0397403203,
0.0384147502,
-0.0303500947,
0.0330314077,
-0.0234144107,
-0.0108456798
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.08985v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.08985v1 | Cross-domain Sentiment Classification in Spanish | 2023-03-15T23:11:30 | 2023-03-15T23:11:30 | Lautaro Estienne, Matias Vera, Leonardo Rey Vega | cs.CL | cs.CL | Sentiment Classification is a fundamental task in the field of Natural
Language Processing, and has very important academic and commercial
applications. It aims to automatically predict the degree of sentiment present
in a text that contains opinions and subjectivity at some level, like product
and movie reviews, or tweets. This can be really difficult to accomplish, in
part, because different domains of text contains different words and
expressions. In addition, this difficulty increases when text is written in a
non-English language due to the lack of databases and resources. As a
consequence, several cross-domain and cross-language techniques are often
applied to this task in order to improve the results. In this work we perform a
study on the ability of a classification system trained with a large database
of product reviews to generalize to different Spanish domains. Reviews were
collected from the MercadoLibre website from seven Latin American countries,
allowing the creation of a large and balanced dataset. Results suggest that
generalization across domains is feasible though very challenging when trained
with these product reviews, and can be improved by pre-training and fine-tuning
the classification model. | [
0.0094392803,
0.0330235176,
-0.0071502677,
0.0337733589,
-0.0184194725,
0.0108869551,
-0.0091609536,
-0.009720521,
0.025676148,
-0.0729669258,
-0.0723655075,
-0.035280332,
-0.0022839843,
0.001829136,
-0.0491380878,
-0.0121591771,
0.0096618216,
0.0271144304,
0.0134395231,
-0.0345922261,
-0.0053338516,
0.0058529386,
0.0062144515,
-0.0043230043,
0.0115858242,
0.0114643127,
0.0452066883,
-0.0423449725,
0.019823296,
-0.0007242885,
0.0576509349,
0.034430895,
-0.0438008234,
0.0149144782,
0.0000016682,
-0.0374973789,
-0.0336776562,
-0.0266345292,
0.0823836252,
-0.0413840264,
0.077688016,
-0.0623524636,
0.0048578773,
0.0316875391,
-0.0607188977,
-0.0654554293,
0.0348944515,
0.0594964176,
0.0400955714,
0.0444803424,
-0.0284570437,
-0.0559079684,
-0.0293843802,
-0.0036030347,
-0.0149519145,
-0.0093784323,
0.019562874,
0.0044604498,
0.0071268706,
0.000627926,
-0.0000685132,
-0.0066994154,
-0.0036822211,
-0.000749864,
-0.0226890519,
-0.0459136479,
-0.0137813725,
-0.0046486314,
0.0056059156,
0.011911097,
0.0222347751,
-0.0456548147,
-0.013224531,
0.021207314,
-0.0003564009,
-0.0053325733,
0.002226298,
-0.0103604393,
0.0057745976,
0.0524471514,
0.0112088416,
0.0607463308,
0.0104272459,
0.0295272544,
-0.0076990002,
0.0631281361,
-0.0302494653,
-0.0325914808,
0.0584025234,
0.1094595194,
0.026391428,
-0.0072880257,
0.0309794024,
-0.0149823567,
0.0162661038,
-0.0090084597,
0.0081323199,
-0.0154567966,
0.0195906106,
-0.1131796315,
-0.022143852,
-0.0228206404,
-0.0227078479,
0.0166827422,
-0.0120838042,
-0.0154072428,
0.0019247533,
-0.0173667632,
-0.032638628,
-0.0112930154,
-0.0818530545,
0.0346200764,
0.0040216204,
0.0286274049,
-0.013009076,
0.0338819623,
-0.08227624,
-0.0166732147,
-0.0174136236,
-0.0615822002,
0.0306649394,
-0.0130352033,
0.0508027822,
0.0114399744,
-0.0362123735,
0.0369835496,
-0.0300238803,
0.0415518433,
-0.0623439141,
-0.0305976048,
0.0453577936,
0.0073471274,
-0.0063577038,
-0.0219241884,
0.0339863934,
0.0767889991,
0.0311356932,
-0.0469327495,
-0.0449494645,
-0.0181776229,
-0.0311799515,
-0.0895767286,
-0.0044404562,
-0.0621885769,
0.0106041087,
0.0127083845,
-0.0040268535,
0.0196225587,
-0.0089243557,
-0.020554129,
-0.0019584515,
0.0535728075,
-0.0316921361,
-0.0476997308,
-0.0130294729,
-0.0127512449,
0.0144119086,
0.0551401302,
-0.0375666134,
0.025542954,
0.03423604,
0.022172749,
0.0010552178,
-0.0153702889,
-0.0117743379,
-0.0271712411,
0.0072859274,
0.0099499514,
-0.028617559,
-0.0175960865,
0.0269548651,
-0.0093713906,
0.0082043344,
0.0289306082,
0.0284812562,
-0.0187093988,
-0.001955267,
0.0470263734,
0.0324144848,
0.0048467419,
0.0109201018,
-0.0183898248,
-0.0122117084,
-0.0276330393,
-0.0028553968,
-0.0049903761,
-0.0120941773,
-0.0039328882,
-0.0470538475,
-0.0732093528,
0.0188919064,
-0.0385284908,
0.0134695536,
-0.0076817474,
0.080922544,
0.0061544548,
0.0034196172,
-0.0026059386,
0.0356829911,
-0.0610710867,
-0.0076945471,
-0.0219227094,
0.0484439805,
0.0317249373,
-0.0347755365,
-0.0095572406,
-0.002187083,
-0.0142726041,
0.0101232175,
0.0192198884,
0.029774772,
-0.0031387424,
-0.012615284,
-0.0271085687,
-0.0187128335,
-0.0011502157,
0.0286151357,
0.0318580493,
-0.0226672012,
0.0876141638,
-0.0019672802,
-0.0161493327,
0.0210942533,
-0.0249583758,
0.0319015831,
-0.018865088,
0.0355141275,
0.0318120867,
0.0123169273,
0.0766890943,
-0.0290041175,
-0.0489027798,
0.0341268107,
-0.0341515318,
-0.0747724324,
0.0144429123,
0.0140562821,
-0.0188085493,
0.0232987553,
-0.0524411574,
0.0025169167,
0.0151908286,
-0.0030497937,
-0.0049563339,
0.0289316699,
0.0052307979,
0.0524656214,
-0.0332459472,
0.0172143709,
-0.0669741109,
0.0119291609,
-0.0023163995,
0.030565137,
0.0131088793,
0.0219077673,
-0.0538818724,
-0.086654231,
0.0485362858,
0.0075557134,
-0.0195380375,
0.0276728868,
0.0081125963,
0.025183836,
0.0415334366,
0.0246352926,
0.0262281019,
-0.0056750397,
-0.0670449138,
-0.0135167455,
-0.0050257407,
0.0436321609,
0.0164799578,
-0.001639293,
0.0146808457,
0.0240407027,
-0.0250332654,
-0.0012765471,
0.0013436571,
0.0159271322,
0.0245311409,
0.0198689085,
0.0272050668,
-0.0103043895,
0.0097733559,
-0.0068106968,
0.0206072833,
0.0081933886,
-0.0478959568,
-0.0671328753,
0.0433096662,
-0.0384923182,
0.0198363103,
0.0224216077,
-0.067960076,
-0.0411102064,
0.0347893909,
-0.0264495909,
0.0028057527,
-0.0240106601,
-0.0236323718,
0.047581736,
0.0480662249,
0.0037072911,
0.0053140977,
-0.0239416547,
-0.0025274705,
-0.0297913533,
-0.0105251381,
0.0160552599,
0.0741390139,
0.0077241403,
-0.0272101946,
-0.0251097437,
-0.0115393326,
-0.0297436677,
-0.0209914111,
0.0268207211,
0.0234866235,
0.0306307636,
0.0247075856,
0.0301284641,
-0.0324823521,
0.0302605554,
-0.0013351351,
0.04025447,
-0.1210621744,
-0.0321616642,
-0.0396976136,
0.0100478446,
-0.0213215407,
0.0259523969,
0.0146478098,
0.0201302376,
0.0222729463,
-0.0465680175,
-0.0185315404,
0.003520705,
0.0494252332,
-0.0022918177,
-0.0018755207,
0.0001773244,
-0.0542110279,
0.0037301681,
0.0105333561,
-0.0556095466,
-0.023465354,
0.0335760526,
0.009324614,
-0.0041677337,
0.0092006726,
-0.0278307647,
-0.0091979085,
-0.0146757187,
-0.0226511043,
0.0337846801,
0.0059743407,
0.0014185779,
-0.0472530313,
-0.0066891187,
-0.0263376124,
-0.0356371775,
0.0082650641,
-0.0461649932,
-0.0012137088,
-0.0286747105,
-0.0339213051,
0.0300359279,
-0.0038263153,
-0.0158846658,
-0.0588147566,
0.0038089303,
-0.0155693162,
0.0329754353,
0.0813895985,
0.0216032546,
-0.0756203309,
-0.0334732942,
0.0110400561,
-0.0419721082,
0.0307417624,
0.0332283229,
-0.0177444778,
-0.0194834787,
-0.025996685,
-0.0128266774,
-0.0137284258,
0.0161575135,
-0.0137567148,
-0.1290513575,
-0.0070866672,
-0.0124708954,
-0.0336388126,
-0.0851252526,
-0.017926516,
-0.0236965157,
-0.0447863378,
-0.0166693255,
-0.0773367062,
-0.0043356284,
0.0018946381,
0.0305560455,
-0.0337790772,
-0.0396435186,
0.0253741276,
-0.0130567681,
-0.0352301784,
0.053100884,
0.0464826636,
0.0006761207,
-0.0204500277,
0.0388903171,
-0.0261370577,
-0.0027771543,
-0.0509745963,
0.0590270832,
0.0096881827,
-0.0119424434,
0.01017184,
-0.0433259122,
-0.0705473125,
0.0530256815,
0.019466443,
0.0795267001,
-0.0007107668,
-0.0282303207,
-0.0353075489,
0.0259456802,
0.0065739569,
0.0222677924,
-0.0304572675,
-0.0803789645,
-0.0097307852,
0.0093330331,
-0.0417466685,
-0.040098656,
-0.0189595111,
-0.0187036674,
-0.0490892045,
-0.0592928156,
-0.0401769094,
-0.0367573872,
-0.0124415206,
0.0321649872,
0.0158389341,
0.0118562197,
0.038562566,
0.0165799037,
-0.0124304472,
0.0072571929,
0.0101744737,
0.0213114303,
-0.0129935211,
-0.0246925652,
0.0832365379,
-0.0053908168,
-0.0100794863,
-0.0459023416,
-0.0184247885,
-0.03786809,
-0.0371249579,
0.0450059064,
0.0168466549,
0.0126370396,
-0.0244285204,
-0.0125899035,
0.0464635193,
0.0568884723,
-0.0298642442,
-0.0178871136,
0.0732636005,
0.0448865891,
0.0105441129,
0.0329502225,
-0.01469965,
0.034956038,
0.029796619,
-0.0326371156,
-0.0048336778,
-0.001654271,
-0.0055252188,
-0.0440064557,
0.0809661895,
-0.0026287411,
-0.0207915194,
-0.0167512763,
0.0004753037,
-0.005928006,
0.0009663597,
-0.0150794657,
0.0058584251,
0.0337060429,
0.0257315729,
-0.0579891689,
0.0136915827,
-0.042285718,
-0.0011227833,
-0.0051763486,
0.0708760023,
0.0621679686,
0.0413443111,
-0.0120278383,
0.0315573737,
0.0091604153,
-0.0059519699,
0.0338881575,
-0.0283118412,
-0.0265828222,
0.0106602358,
-0.0237684976,
0.0392785519,
-0.022617884,
0.0423972085,
0.0075143697,
0.0370798744,
-0.0405308753,
-0.0053737033,
0.0338778049,
-0.0540548488,
0.0179005601,
-0.0002484891,
-0.0066184751,
0.0019156721,
0.044732403,
-0.0091532236,
0.0196871459,
0.0337789841,
-0.0270527676,
-0.0356758684,
-0.0089934571,
0.0562402979,
-0.0571446456,
0.0118997963,
0.0316358432,
-0.0135080386,
-0.0240350403,
-0.0008085915,
0.0536482707,
-0.0521121435,
-0.0106620686,
0.0005307139,
-0.0363277718,
-0.0719441324,
0.0522851534,
-0.0548516251,
0.0172575619,
0.0129593974,
0.0405693129,
0.0875702202,
0.0335102528,
0.055431135,
-0.0547825396,
-0.0243357085,
-0.0225150641,
-0.0004232861,
-0.0267662499,
-4.900718601e-33,
0.0348155238,
-0.0037359921,
-0.0453322381,
0.0403931998,
0.0176822972,
-0.0055146427,
0.0095534679,
0.0247060135,
0.0274710692,
0.0416498259,
0.0298780203,
0.0201436616,
0.012863148,
-0.0036809687,
0.0249995645,
-0.0083544133,
0.0260404348,
-0.0016680505,
0.0163182095,
-0.0064628306,
0.0042256531,
0.043400716,
0.0900684521,
-0.1210381463,
0.054755196,
0.0160639286,
-0.0262123309,
0.0154873114,
0.0739967152,
0.0531973839,
-0.0139255896,
0.1044065878,
0.036740154,
-0.0457192212,
0.0222070254,
0.034672033,
-0.0026788791,
-0.0221868139,
0.0197399985,
0.0344746262,
0.0476821177,
-0.0385780744,
-0.0090053389,
0.0089370059,
-0.0539834388,
0.018439224,
0.0511571914,
-0.0375828706,
0.0196490157,
-0.0753217936,
-0.0582638495,
0.0103268689,
0.0334144607,
-0.0059441323,
0.0475644059,
0.0887364522,
-0.0093055358,
0.0091394894,
-0.0034977433,
0.0461569391,
-0.0361433662,
0.0125820702,
0.003438829,
-0.0277952887,
0.001230976,
0.048534479,
-0.0018596955,
0.0122251837,
0.0305199847,
0.0620490797,
-0.0063649556,
-0.0093521038,
-0.001844636,
0.1137722135,
0.0260897577,
-0.0491674766,
-0.0607508831,
0.0206331518,
0.0128835635,
-0.0407308266,
0.040362563,
-0.0297663044,
-0.014520986,
0.0170248374,
0.0350803211,
-0.0475352369,
-0.0119000189,
-0.0187765155,
-0.0345422812,
-0.0035291743,
-0.0116103683,
-0.0242187567,
-0.0191604439,
-0.080294922,
-0.0416075848,
0.0489211679,
-0.0494193323,
0.0023270042,
0.0274686106,
-0.0186288096,
-0.0281384662,
-0.0492014773,
-0.0733496919,
0.0639026687,
0.0200536754,
-0.0112053417,
0.0856797174,
0.0226219986,
-0.0684891343,
-0.0018427881,
0.0022130895,
0.04668108,
0.0244428348,
0.1122097373,
-0.0295413099,
0.030718619,
-0.0069958949,
0.0779575706,
-0.0138011677,
0.0404710695,
0.0129213408,
0.0091260485,
-0.0007052664,
0.0132551463,
-0.0370671041,
-0.0629946142,
0.0003937916,
-0.0090558901,
-0.0327294357,
-0.0690722466,
-0.0236977413,
-0.05586344,
2.427e-7,
0.0396168381,
0.0277573094,
-0.0415506959,
0.009761448,
0.0190426726,
0.063131243,
-0.0003358258,
0.0410629287,
-0.0025991716,
0.0148100555,
-0.0069516911,
-0.0217166226,
0.0279665496,
0.0466793478,
-0.1238476336,
0.0047944104,
0.0282462873,
-0.0093869427,
0.0169647299,
0.0413899198,
0.0435658246,
0.1037976667,
0.0019404094,
-0.0208668448,
-0.0176004618,
-0.0286038201,
0.0595134757,
-0.0335844047,
-0.0221563466,
0.0085393665,
-0.0174624138,
0.0023860612,
-0.0373043939,
-0.0351740792,
-0.0220458191,
0.0300239511,
0.0069899932,
0.0278376695,
0.0355042554,
0.0230037179,
0.0568754934,
-0.0345408581,
0.0089110006,
0.0376049243,
0.011993357,
-0.0535388254,
-0.027059814,
-0.0636617467,
0.0431228168,
-0.0150467474,
0.0708738267,
-0.0246439967,
-0.0173470881,
0.0255711433,
0.0154639911,
-0.0567018725,
-0.0343089513,
-0.0394803993,
0.0076059494,
0.0558156073,
-0.0001765539,
-0.0189816114,
0.0405149162,
0.0365728624,
0.0463189557,
-0.0120187448,
0.0890443325,
1.389898781e-34,
0.0394040383,
-0.0408477709,
-0.0028600818,
-0.04115545,
0.0218364112,
-0.0109945918,
-0.0199364759,
-0.0364133008,
0.0235499535,
0.0149082821,
0.0284083374
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.08954v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.08954v2 | PRESTO: A Multilingual Dataset for Parsing Realistic Task-Oriented Dialogs | 2023-03-15T21:51:13 | 2023-03-17T02:26:52 | Rahul Goel, Waleed Ammar, Aditya Gupta, Siddharth Vashishtha, Motoki Sano, Faiz Surani, Max Chang, HyunJeong Choe, David Greene, Kyle He, Rattima Nitisaroj, Anna Trukhina, Shachi Paul, Pararth Shah, Rushin Shah, Zhou Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Research interest in task-oriented dialogs has increased as systems such as
Google Assistant, Alexa and Siri have become ubiquitous in everyday life.
However, the impact of academic research in this area has been limited by the
lack of datasets that realistically capture the wide array of user pain points.
To enable research on some of the more challenging aspects of parsing realistic
conversations, we introduce PRESTO, a public dataset of over 550K contextual
multilingual conversations between humans and virtual assistants. PRESTO
contains a diverse array of challenges that occur in real-world NLU tasks such
as disfluencies, code-switching, and revisions. It is the only large scale
human generated conversational parsing dataset that provides structured context
such as a user's contacts and lists for each example. Our mT5 model based
baselines demonstrate that the conversational phenomenon present in PRESTO are
challenging to model, which is further pronounced in a low-resource setup. | [
0.0538668633,
0.044516325,
-0.0346524157,
0.0300110336,
-0.0125245405,
0.0095215524,
0.0263511539,
-0.0225758348,
0.0027238973,
-0.0278573446,
-0.0404021554,
-0.031774722,
0.0048935772,
0.0381375961,
0.0258129612,
-0.0635058433,
0.0415416583,
-0.0353386253,
0.0214989055,
0.0326628424,
0.0242572483,
0.0216619,
-0.0224384815,
0.0582354553,
-0.0188924,
-0.0559217222,
-0.0302659422,
0.0243435428,
-0.0007260184,
-0.027939463,
0.0170970596,
0.0660509989,
-0.0045138504,
0.0182600338,
0.0000016352,
-0.02288015,
-0.0128838914,
-0.0357357897,
-0.0781323984,
-0.0447284058,
0.0167764742,
-0.0218898933,
-0.0353890322,
0.0267057531,
-0.0370896496,
-0.0061619324,
0.0256796032,
0.0508615114,
0.0687873587,
0.0778146163,
-0.029618023,
0.0170378312,
-0.0142268967,
-0.0098984502,
-0.0019501648,
-0.0618253723,
-0.0131317666,
-0.0152052138,
0.0000640164,
-0.0065816287,
0.0284298062,
0.0143964058,
0.0407223478,
-0.0349552818,
-0.0712788105,
0.019378854,
-0.0462673828,
-0.0303073693,
-0.0292852521,
0.1081216782,
0.0000257573,
0.0144744217,
0.0187446475,
0.0147712352,
0.0119737182,
-0.0411695875,
-0.0536893904,
0.006948851,
-0.0354807414,
-0.0081174886,
0.0030453159,
0.0136386994,
0.0095415069,
-0.0184429977,
-0.0069586798,
0.0140255215,
-0.0037352154,
-0.038647715,
0.0113532748,
0.0068753455,
-0.0091680177,
-0.0471094586,
0.03656023,
-0.0357139036,
-0.0799698606,
0.019002879,
-0.0546564795,
-0.0263568144,
0.0195183698,
-0.0230612904,
0.045799572,
0.0333654955,
-0.0522580966,
0.0438267812,
0.0501543619,
0.02980165,
-0.011295395,
-0.0162866749,
-0.0173008982,
-0.0281337816,
-0.0405340455,
0.0122975884,
-0.0418629088,
0.0046784123,
-0.0528366007,
-0.0080757421,
0.0130611518,
0.0470333174,
-0.0285238307,
0.0491492338,
-0.00218351,
0.0156167485,
-0.0510743111,
0.0252279807,
0.008010326,
0.0268793162,
-0.0298071206,
0.0268804636,
0.0147714755,
-0.0953066647,
-0.0242696032,
0.0242259204,
0.0105044832,
-0.058178544,
-0.0347308069,
0.0264080968,
0.0060054814,
-0.012170176,
0.0312756598,
-0.0268008355,
-0.0312622637,
-0.0402586311,
-0.0108309146,
-0.0254431628,
0.059530396,
-0.013118864,
0.0057620727,
-0.0269989762,
0.0097610867,
0.0305624269,
-0.0133121051,
0.0961183086,
-0.0041232556,
0.0126854833,
0.0109485155,
0.0014149197,
-0.0241050459,
0.0642768592,
0.0151946023,
0.0103598796,
0.0571314171,
0.0078524118,
0.0130420513,
0.0508087017,
0.0020677978,
-0.0097383298,
0.0108357519,
0.0430393815,
-0.016446596,
0.0356394015,
0.0433096141,
0.0477957428,
-0.0398969837,
-0.0373918489,
0.046198789,
0.0556370839,
-0.0277360938,
0.0410390608,
0.0256523248,
0.0149804959,
0.010689267,
-0.0010822631,
-0.0640730709,
-0.0058980747,
-0.0136966649,
-0.0084353304,
-0.0103378156,
0.0039473185,
-0.0349073149,
-0.0034835518,
0.0186521988,
-0.0138409371,
-0.0162716303,
-0.0188264623,
0.012419207,
-0.0000427037,
-0.0254014302,
0.0518918149,
-0.0238181185,
-0.0754087493,
-0.0399905518,
-0.0158511307,
0.0018888954,
0.0740624964,
0.0694076121,
-0.0418960229,
-0.0604165457,
-0.0391635299,
0.0144457249,
0.0396213122,
0.0277345181,
-0.0306739062,
0.0466252714,
-0.0328972526,
0.0041208048,
-0.017681716,
-0.0078883981,
-0.0122248391,
-0.0210074447,
-0.0281848479,
0.0022584158,
-0.0111674732,
0.0120602082,
0.0035953936,
-0.0243365411,
0.0222298633,
-0.0017700383,
0.0144020719,
0.031081045,
0.0635002479,
-0.01207319,
-0.0123278638,
0.0178085174,
-0.0254364572,
0.0491126813,
0.0772970691,
-0.0546832532,
-0.0512609184,
0.0458562039,
-0.0205951668,
-0.0428562164,
0.052641727,
-0.0364776514,
-0.0627280027,
-0.0098737655,
-0.0064951475,
0.0270454101,
-0.0142295286,
0.0118150683,
0.0504902713,
0.0154892849,
0.0230997466,
0.009495954,
-0.0260531958,
0.0113077844,
0.0284255352,
0.0421111099,
0.0047721639,
-0.0567104369,
-0.0098568406,
0.0411191471,
0.0040504471,
-0.0339255817,
-0.0005748853,
-0.0021809079,
-0.0576566048,
-0.0227668658,
-0.1460152417,
-0.0220025871,
-0.0340751223,
0.0198116023,
0.0406325608,
0.0334918685,
-0.0163430069,
-0.0561769754,
-0.0250329375,
-0.0131014781,
0.0168616977,
0.0124232881,
0.0310425088,
0.0140424054,
-0.0056012953,
-0.0860013738,
0.0143082337,
-0.0179586243,
0.0037356329,
-0.02868676,
-0.0316379368,
-0.0454333872,
0.0216410812,
0.0005683815,
0.0542615913,
-0.0223365203,
-0.0388829596,
0.0222985018,
0.0056830081,
0.0823233128,
0.068224512,
-0.0264045913,
0.0433688983,
0.0074793333,
-0.0519673489,
-0.0412218235,
0.0306173973,
0.0240674131,
0.0033882614,
-0.0561257079,
-0.012693014,
0.0347929336,
0.0602953881,
-0.0015959218,
0.0529618487,
-0.0193292797,
-0.0018430066,
0.0094437245,
-0.0299588405,
0.0256900489,
0.0018798866,
-0.0460954979,
0.0745272636,
-0.0394077525,
-0.0261206869,
0.0533389263,
-0.0524017513,
-0.0499043502,
-0.0487103947,
-0.0081241839,
-0.010665115,
0.0681922734,
-0.0164713282,
-0.0173867773,
0.0240496136,
-0.0497261994,
-0.0176610351,
0.0449131764,
-0.0110614477,
-0.009286507,
0.0491765253,
-0.0805436224,
-0.0070210043,
-0.0186856631,
-0.0654394254,
-0.0351270474,
-0.0268887803,
-0.03441168,
0.005366263,
0.0181781054,
-0.0302948467,
-0.0233739745,
-0.0325487666,
-0.0195232313,
0.0927158743,
-0.010023498,
-0.00373341,
-0.0331655033,
0.0150903063,
0.0578740165,
0.041999124,
-0.0259299912,
0.0000594489,
0.0458744094,
0.0367384367,
0.0791677609,
-0.0215399023,
0.0005147168,
-0.0106787821,
0.028161969,
-0.0015979009,
-0.0310188066,
-0.0008021812,
0.0367379934,
-0.036451146,
-0.034542717,
0.1248440146,
0.0224657841,
-0.0735234916,
-0.0089354673,
-0.073490724,
0.0030107724,
0.0093447603,
0.0236723889,
-0.1142095849,
-0.0472004376,
0.025982311,
0.0119826179,
0.0043173358,
-0.048180934,
0.0184559226,
-0.1020323932,
0.0392937101,
-0.0241340138,
-0.0199750252,
-0.0037881888,
0.0061193951,
0.0271535832,
-0.0450746715,
0.0558664203,
-0.0426916629,
0.0137033304,
0.0036463914,
0.0012730579,
-0.0249891859,
-0.0320323855,
0.0524031259,
-0.0321789533,
0.0559007265,
0.0822402686,
0.0475263931,
0.0276305713,
0.0165338833,
-0.0006023552,
0.0004339799,
0.0053002615,
-0.0048884633,
0.0501025803,
-0.0131453192,
-0.0148113873,
-0.0020728805,
0.0390030146,
-0.0557885207,
-0.0179930683,
0.0365382433,
0.0414010324,
-0.0553440154,
0.0454157293,
0.0196924955,
-0.0058740028,
0.0515825637,
0.0658243075,
0.0521455519,
-0.0296414923,
-0.0479726158,
-0.0351985134,
0.0196328089,
-0.0460487008,
0.0129392669,
-0.0048525189,
0.0177542418,
-0.0066237603,
-0.0684728622,
-0.1015663743,
0.0508523919,
0.0131645994,
-0.0043246732,
-0.0254223738,
0.0642905235,
0.0020090817,
-0.0114229871,
0.0255392287,
0.0008684557,
0.0164327864,
-0.0460574552,
-0.0113686202,
0.0175815448,
0.0000114035,
0.0049543637,
0.0224036835,
-0.0625060201,
-0.0359370783,
0.0217807684,
0.0588911995,
0.0194462445,
0.0505677424,
-0.0325644277,
-0.0408263914,
-0.0556207411,
-0.0018536219,
-0.06442561,
-0.0285071954,
0.070562914,
0.037273746,
0.0135619668,
0.0538587086,
-0.0191468447,
-0.0005872402,
-0.0408558995,
0.0168843064,
-0.0566078871,
-0.0735620037,
0.0105732204,
-0.0103086093,
0.0531838685,
0.0286612399,
0.0100044385,
-0.0312859602,
0.0362351201,
-0.0440700836,
0.0024565482,
-0.0561663918,
0.003418864,
-0.0085623888,
-0.0446216688,
0.0305077098,
0.0278755222,
-0.0633407757,
0.0267078876,
-0.0576104596,
0.0188621692,
0.0327071398,
0.0209252536,
0.0054792245,
-0.0020217437,
-0.0042164512,
0.0066684084,
0.0029255089,
0.043704614,
-0.0073008058,
0.05973747,
0.0156997871,
-0.0325744413,
0.0305515509,
0.0688916445,
-0.0447901934,
-0.0418998413,
0.0203471091,
-0.0118843438,
0.0487495139,
-0.0221766606,
0.119103916,
-0.010701295,
0.0285851378,
0.0013739503,
0.0588774234,
-0.0023950618,
-0.0198823679,
0.0111400299,
0.0123826433,
-0.0209543668,
0.008846961,
0.0908394083,
-0.0525296666,
0.0505086221,
0.0069480967,
0.0066942191,
-0.0543792807,
-0.0409515463,
0.0035231404,
0.0229534023,
-0.0121786511,
-0.0235178024,
-0.0331387036,
-0.0241135284,
0.0150283435,
-0.0081827343,
-0.0116407331,
-0.0213153455,
0.0239622705,
0.059969902,
0.0042552133,
-0.008936082,
-0.018756276,
-0.0084234318,
-0.0069788736,
-0.0340652093,
-0.0424220152,
-5.085803125e-33,
-0.0221439563,
-0.0082386453,
0.0267540459,
-0.0078337919,
-0.0284659509,
0.0030086476,
-0.0545989797,
-0.0112329582,
-0.0197733808,
-0.0240053032,
-0.0402504168,
0.040356975,
0.0371460393,
0.01939358,
0.0339952335,
-0.0107237091,
0.0797035545,
-0.0266412366,
-0.0004658925,
0.0510398336,
0.0393763185,
0.0241443664,
0.0395856984,
-0.065925397,
0.0455799177,
0.0022889946,
0.006141746,
0.0430015177,
0.0297692996,
0.0400851853,
-0.0154380435,
0.0162261762,
0.0183862373,
-0.0174836293,
-0.0424743555,
0.0178821534,
-0.0692867637,
-0.0119498624,
0.0357870683,
0.035921745,
-0.0220312215,
-0.0083315745,
-0.0111299679,
0.001295021,
0.0533576161,
0.0398731828,
0.0063732467,
-0.0266730078,
0.0116705103,
0.0109886443,
-0.0592514649,
0.0189937688,
-0.0337557904,
-0.0393639505,
0.0433358364,
0.0794101954,
0.0101911966,
-0.0173409246,
-0.0738121793,
0.000696937,
-0.043359831,
-0.0036169398,
0.0670449212,
-0.0288336948,
0.0073302547,
0.0446807556,
0.0514947474,
0.0319131278,
-0.02499073,
0.0063768108,
-0.0268438105,
0.062575087,
-0.029615378,
0.0369484052,
0.0042514233,
-0.0005368171,
-0.0048184083,
0.0020978043,
0.0341972969,
0.0503903106,
-0.016414538,
0.0250263717,
-0.0406831168,
-0.0005215756,
0.0109804291,
-0.026460737,
-0.0057484489,
-0.0347217061,
0.044784233,
-0.0141063789,
0.0371895619,
-0.0008616298,
0.0405435115,
-0.0064893742,
0.0176692642,
0.0091177309,
-0.0147522818,
0.0266608689,
-0.0109533668,
0.0037667644,
-0.0547373928,
-0.030452596,
0.0387034714,
0.0262334738,
0.0550984927,
0.0237875916,
0.0249742828,
0.0036536171,
-0.0301400609,
0.0031452726,
-0.0409922451,
0.0522377938,
-0.0378788635,
0.0454067476,
0.0317071341,
-0.0120121036,
-0.0301392302,
0.0709224418,
0.0006244908,
-0.0024211016,
-0.0577697977,
-0.0146834822,
0.0101954816,
-0.0064025307,
-0.0357735604,
-0.0377907343,
-0.0416418463,
0.0088494746,
0.0329161435,
0.0027729829,
-0.0050943112,
-0.0336658396,
2.38e-7,
0.0054232324,
0.0254569594,
0.0540488735,
0.0103423046,
0.0338871293,
0.0465443768,
-0.0084138466,
0.0272774957,
-0.0183519162,
-0.0074476083,
-0.0055914279,
-0.013712828,
0.0727779269,
0.0533926152,
-0.0847507492,
-0.0210716873,
-0.0664398074,
-0.0359804258,
-0.0550143458,
-0.0007437925,
0.0665286332,
0.0746127889,
-0.0219497345,
0.0048075691,
-0.0022895643,
-0.0018937945,
0.0104702543,
-0.0475739278,
-0.0168245547,
-0.0150326462,
0.0276890155,
-0.025919605,
-0.0071913921,
-0.0047258236,
0.0066422815,
0.0142781669,
0.0009118326,
0.0599013306,
-0.0045364527,
-0.0289146788,
-0.0032233964,
-0.025516307,
-0.0149535201,
-0.0383663215,
0.0396064073,
-0.0271455422,
-0.0319561921,
-0.015316057,
0.0258032344,
0.0050509954,
-0.0055623692,
-0.0156939402,
0.0101039223,
0.0371234566,
0.0029181819,
-0.0259289145,
-0.0115193725,
-0.0547628626,
-0.0325546749,
0.0203503855,
-0.0450100154,
-0.0133668669,
-0.0478007458,
-0.0431216769,
0.0016607773,
-0.0117376382,
0.0220726673,
1.707493821e-34,
0.0188723523,
0.0208691582,
0.0275938492,
0.0765036643,
0.0307429489,
-0.026328275,
0.0116136,
0.0205927305,
0.0065573892,
-0.0541157871,
-0.0277729053
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.08928v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.08928v1 | Applying unsupervised keyphrase methods on concepts extracted from discharge sheets | 2023-03-15T20:55:25 | 2023-03-15T20:55:25 | Hoda Memarzadeh, Nasser Ghadiri, Matthias Samwald, Maryam Lotfi Shahreza | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, 68P20, H.1; J.3 | Clinical notes containing valuable patient information are written by
different health care providers with various scientific levels and writing
styles. It might be helpful for clinicians and researchers to understand what
information is essential when dealing with extensive electronic medical
records. Entities recognizing and mapping them to standard terminologies is
crucial in reducing ambiguity in processing clinical notes. Although named
entity recognition and entity linking are critical steps in clinical natural
language processing, they can also result in the production of repetitive and
low-value concepts. In other hand, all parts of a clinical text do not share
the same importance or content in predicting the patient's condition. As a
result, it is necessary to identify the section in which each content is
recorded and also to identify key concepts to extract meaning from clinical
texts. In this study, these challenges have been addressed by using clinical
natural language processing techniques. In addition, in order to identify key
concepts, a set of popular unsupervised key phrase extraction methods has been
verified and evaluated. Considering that most of the clinical concepts are in
the form of multi-word expressions and their accurate identification requires
the user to specify n-gram range, we have proposed a shortcut method to
preserve the structure of the expression based on TF-IDF. In order to evaluate
the pre-processing method and select the concepts, we have designed two types
of downstream tasks (multiple and binary classification) using the capabilities
of transformer-based models. The obtained results show the superiority of
proposed method in combination with SciBERT model, also offer an insight into
the efficacy of general extracting essential phrase methods for clinical notes. | [
0.0696937963,
-0.0005008256,
0.0268140025,
-0.0311607625,
-0.0674156696,
0.0344117135,
-0.0081346156,
0.0507674851,
0.0195792913,
-0.0674871728,
-0.021134913,
-0.0234628078,
0.0003533812,
0.0322506763,
-0.0174003243,
-0.0449487828,
0.0178152546,
0.0195675809,
0.0175321214,
0.041293446,
-0.0274299812,
0.0084299305,
-0.0308197681,
0.0440207906,
0.0369175375,
0.0209764764,
0.0296356771,
-0.025657326,
0.0405095294,
-0.0479983203,
-0.0268065128,
0.0337913297,
-0.0538642779,
-0.0596924052,
0.0000019935,
-0.0689445883,
-0.082761474,
0.019820679,
-0.0120152282,
-0.0580920205,
0.0568274371,
-0.0612592511,
-0.0148668559,
-0.0126475822,
-0.0254936144,
-0.0386747345,
0.0140831098,
0.1061476842,
0.0555444248,
0.0493591391,
-0.034165144,
-0.0354284458,
0.0225081015,
0.0360351168,
0.011378523,
-0.055680804,
0.0577848665,
-0.0237910412,
0.0194343254,
-0.0254424307,
0.0061516738,
0.0102667883,
-0.0577098317,
0.0036140529,
0.0713136196,
0.0334562883,
-0.0686338097,
-0.0039797481,
0.017898459,
0.0328731388,
-0.0015177097,
0.0074552568,
0.072499074,
-0.0260611046,
-0.0275394786,
0.0135260159,
-0.0416966043,
-0.00640035,
-0.0697926655,
-0.0264135879,
0.0304092653,
0.007693694,
-0.0279188752,
0.0026731414,
-0.0491526276,
-0.0258056633,
0.0149761941,
-0.0231349077,
0.0424198695,
-0.018437745,
-0.0386660397,
-0.027397152,
0.0494144,
0.0238659866,
0.0219993554,
0.0237906016,
-0.0159944985,
-0.0814680457,
0.0593924262,
-0.1059236526,
-0.0018993246,
-0.0230585057,
0.0253795441,
0.0335597806,
-0.0264656171,
0.0053951456,
-0.016804263,
0.0094758207,
-0.0306833964,
0.006717104,
-0.0565611459,
-0.0239925496,
-0.0284539219,
0.0732412189,
0.0435007513,
-0.0141764525,
-0.0633985996,
-0.0286425911,
0.0181960016,
0.011269344,
0.0347766988,
0.0047007147,
-0.0255432501,
-0.0080319354,
0.029499745,
-0.018622525,
-0.0119103566,
-0.0135405594,
-0.0425147973,
-0.0333998576,
0.0357954614,
0.0233668126,
0.0644497275,
0.0010826332,
0.0263190065,
-0.0061298143,
0.013908294,
-0.0446424074,
-0.0524528511,
-0.0429732576,
-0.0143472049,
0.027552871,
-0.0070622363,
-0.0457754582,
0.0059978934,
0.0325066969,
-0.0077181505,
-0.0284769069,
0.0199336912,
0.0171647742,
-0.067632392,
0.0356400125,
-0.0476018935,
-0.0123441778,
0.0331127308,
0.0366336331,
0.0237055533,
-0.0391623005,
0.0140721099,
-0.0219739936,
0.0124280164,
-0.0437659509,
0.0338402726,
0.0016803654,
-0.0290761366,
-0.0888819471,
-0.0133688562,
0.0253240317,
-0.0142063238,
0.0082080904,
-0.0519516692,
0.0483535007,
0.0178492181,
0.0328396745,
-0.0239083227,
0.0993937477,
0.0188715402,
0.0241605751,
-0.0270451326,
0.0065702009,
0.0272815321,
0.0084734531,
0.0403700806,
-0.027637152,
0.0483346581,
0.0084103011,
-0.0226334855,
0.008669083,
-0.0000925184,
-0.0348382816,
-0.0363182724,
-0.0092591308,
-0.0212717671,
-0.0481606163,
0.088608779,
0.0243515987,
-0.0610133335,
0.0848722905,
0.0244980082,
-0.0357665345,
-0.0276057534,
-0.038281098,
-0.0645169541,
0.0444617234,
0.0729148686,
-0.0362888984,
-0.0508052148,
-0.0278629083,
-0.0065557137,
0.0191867277,
-0.0078863306,
0.0049708099,
-0.0285685547,
-0.0547799878,
-0.0185763463,
0.0513660014,
0.006938715,
-0.0553079508,
-0.0158359408,
0.0322740935,
0.000364901,
-0.0142006828,
-0.0100882342,
0.0463721268,
-0.0000298691,
-0.0414923914,
0.0046488834,
-0.0203165747,
0.0063809557,
0.0374483205,
-0.0064153899,
0.0289439186,
0.037633352,
-0.0228092223,
-0.0154743735,
-0.0004294514,
-0.0045897118,
0.0291293915,
-0.0308954399,
-0.0141970571,
0.0247940477,
-0.042946294,
0.0170167778,
-0.0222695582,
-0.0486389324,
-0.015785303,
0.0403533764,
0.0035627997,
0.038721852,
0.0418359227,
-0.0158680212,
-0.0446911789,
0.0562113784,
0.0005162464,
0.0168202762,
-0.0590351075,
-0.0793774799,
0.006411294,
0.0244653895,
0.0154460333,
0.0437371321,
-0.0399843901,
-0.0213483125,
0.008289434,
-0.0054535936,
0.0140788807,
-0.028327778,
-0.1072358415,
-0.0084338253,
0.0093491394,
0.0289754663,
0.0310414564,
0.0417974964,
-0.0129780313,
-0.0142980283,
-0.0015165519,
-0.0321624875,
0.0320899561,
-0.0286154673,
0.0308423173,
0.0502323359,
0.0011295902,
0.0030675691,
0.0232046936,
-0.0475737676,
0.0341407508,
0.0283933356,
-0.0942494497,
0.0199414175,
0.0542249121,
0.0102759534,
-0.0323020704,
-0.0066149593,
-0.0101348329,
0.0057141166,
-0.0194070712,
0.0466862284,
0.0409885645,
0.040534474,
0.0190614574,
0.008754855,
-0.0176963583,
0.0014742931,
-0.0161631256,
-0.023042446,
-0.0013924744,
-0.0055183852,
-0.0287240297,
0.0756847709,
0.0572166294,
0.0372028872,
-0.0009068458,
0.0006646325,
-0.0345783494,
-0.0265813805,
0.0495539233,
-0.0193657912,
0.0005626536,
-0.0421516784,
0.010778497,
0.0356495678,
0.0080067692,
0.0462215319,
-0.0154970093,
0.0310397763,
-0.096610181,
-0.0154779274,
-0.0351952054,
0.0212180857,
-0.0339130983,
0.024765756,
0.0524243526,
-0.0385826752,
0.0521288253,
0.0016262092,
0.0022540109,
-0.0423630476,
0.0688842908,
-0.0119125312,
0.0109488415,
-0.0100937113,
0.0169805232,
-0.037371736,
-0.0086139739,
-0.0091334209,
-0.0205273181,
0.0265823957,
0.0145787131,
-0.0228151344,
0.0665890798,
0.0082988013,
0.0671041757,
0.0101692323,
-0.0084646177,
-0.0021980351,
0.035395693,
0.0526984856,
-0.0533071235,
-0.0019200699,
0.0209592134,
0.0008717391,
0.0651639849,
0.0064328108,
0.0102330018,
0.0513795838,
-0.0239032488,
-0.0223296415,
-0.1065865979,
-0.0264677145,
0.0001078597,
-0.0188807715,
-0.0397160277,
0.0061876127,
0.1015600786,
0.061212156,
-0.045576591,
0.0038366609,
-0.0114703923,
-0.1158633307,
-0.0361978337,
0.010984052,
-0.0016348577,
0.0058858846,
0.0068195886,
0.0280133542,
-0.0199910291,
-0.0558081418,
0.0171461906,
-0.017911667,
0.0336127691,
-0.0175443813,
-0.0089778518,
-0.0359019972,
-0.0575108603,
-0.0089357421,
-0.0105729131,
-0.0893632472,
-0.0196266323,
-0.0445268899,
-0.0100188665,
-0.0054420279,
-0.0665455088,
-0.0728213713,
0.0160623696,
-0.0417535342,
-0.0139324516,
0.0492372811,
0.0350111127,
-0.0453823656,
-0.0079834415,
-0.0257257279,
-0.0252531692,
-0.0130000478,
-0.0100299567,
0.020601254,
-0.0016797514,
0.0034539287,
-0.0272950213,
0.0181311257,
-0.0405581519,
-0.0328693427,
0.0116671463,
0.0115552265,
-0.0621014126,
-0.0227976069,
-0.0122761521,
0.0143108629,
0.0013075387,
0.0476808846,
-0.0369201005,
0.008984874,
-0.0171176959,
0.0323063172,
0.0726537779,
-0.0082771825,
-0.0523276888,
-0.0014138112,
-0.0544925109,
-0.0201656781,
-0.0680984333,
-0.0088381367,
0.0419220738,
0.0343881883,
0.0011866126,
0.0449326783,
0.0182877798,
0.0119327931,
-0.0677806288,
0.017901361,
0.0220884401,
-0.0358106196,
-0.0602274165,
-0.0494752377,
0.0607506745,
0.0292998496,
-0.0362669304,
-0.0221100338,
0.0242375247,
0.0231617987,
0.0445427038,
-0.0140867271,
0.0112994155,
-0.047136452,
0.0287292916,
0.0169126466,
0.030062208,
0.0350120552,
-0.0203846041,
-0.0431615636,
-0.021365894,
-0.025695093,
-0.033022169,
-0.0033372093,
-0.0073517058,
0.0307716895,
0.0112788733,
0.047034204,
-0.023369126,
-0.0323055759,
-0.0079810806,
0.0211865939,
0.0577055775,
-0.0192275345,
-0.023654338,
-0.0338565595,
0.0148744835,
0.0317890793,
0.0133418152,
-0.0042082439,
0.0050933706,
0.0128557207,
0.0146139674,
-0.0198478568,
0.065483287,
-0.060248971,
-0.0467454083,
0.0154742589,
0.0469913781,
0.0441613346,
-0.0027674153,
0.0041913679,
-0.0366523676,
0.0022297227,
-0.0182529856,
0.0365771353,
0.0055750045,
-0.0038124102,
0.0353114754,
-0.0142633095,
0.0067668636,
-0.009782875,
0.0739736632,
-0.0177825503,
0.0143028721,
-0.0693691075,
0.0095656849,
0.0260278527,
-0.0248041116,
-0.025187796,
-0.0483790562,
-0.0044770027,
-0.0147697804,
0.0398274772,
-0.0037525573,
0.0465537831,
-0.0023548095,
0.0182685871,
-0.0088807596,
-0.0259413403,
0.0564797185,
0.0285634659,
0.0352806821,
0.0207162425,
-0.0567582399,
-0.0407738462,
0.0081977881,
0.043291714,
-0.0144014154,
-0.0384348184,
-0.0081080925,
-0.0503422655,
0.0264288727,
0.1108579859,
-0.0242956821,
0.0009456881,
-0.0137379356,
0.0576492064,
0.0334117152,
0.022083275,
0.0102286283,
-0.0500038937,
0.0332673006,
-0.0210058037,
0.0096780518,
0.0178277604,
-5.924595119e-33,
-0.0062248511,
-0.0622576363,
-0.00604271,
0.0519109182,
0.0324779451,
0.0304596517,
-0.0004579503,
-0.0232274812,
0.0247043297,
-0.0074204528,
-0.0282911044,
-0.0167282075,
0.0388643295,
-0.0031874187,
0.0183824711,
-0.0092748143,
0.0116361352,
0.0258814581,
-0.0297732353,
0.0165590849,
-0.0113436244,
0.0785124376,
0.1107374951,
-0.0689368472,
0.016616514,
-0.0232691746,
0.0390381105,
-0.0358539186,
0.0495297313,
0.0439649783,
-0.0207207259,
-0.020008456,
0.0338954888,
-0.0414680429,
0.00648202,
0.0020181499,
-0.0755665153,
-0.012792754,
-0.0130694453,
0.0014676539,
0.0230856929,
-0.0244497452,
0.0206396095,
-0.0327626802,
-0.0145745818,
0.0209643841,
0.0438001864,
-0.006218194,
-0.0208184477,
-0.0662229881,
-0.0385597125,
0.0636513159,
0.0361770242,
0.0228060056,
0.021533167,
-0.0307611451,
-0.038100969,
0.0315689482,
-0.0344803855,
-0.0097939754,
0.068002373,
0.0398140252,
-0.0119987689,
-0.0285164546,
-0.0055105495,
0.0270647537,
-0.001010629,
-0.044212997,
-0.0130604375,
0.0118853226,
-0.0180868804,
0.0389226414,
0.0162811428,
0.0215797462,
0.0695790127,
-0.0016301874,
-0.0318000726,
0.0640382916,
-0.0523394644,
0.0513013341,
0.0032119856,
-0.0335596539,
-0.0506439433,
0.022416275,
0.0285338387,
0.0065921764,
0.001726132,
-0.0071000694,
0.0148976268,
0.001567031,
-0.0613657646,
0.0445227511,
0.0133421663,
0.0177274849,
0.0201506987,
-0.0315716676,
0.0796420053,
0.0629468709,
-0.039857354,
-0.0198499635,
-0.0523640327,
-0.0257046614,
0.048053503,
-0.0028735839,
0.0331081115,
0.0099920062,
-0.0255260076,
-0.0336789787,
-0.0477923416,
-0.0012496852,
0.0798546448,
-0.0256373547,
-0.0201627389,
0.0571922585,
0.0162297301,
-0.0021825028,
0.0189844687,
0.0560974069,
0.0129496045,
-0.0103713078,
-0.0194325242,
-0.0102331191,
0.0295258071,
-0.0119167073,
0.0072208359,
-0.0011813021,
-0.0149038471,
0.0360695086,
0.0055822576,
0.0081168851,
0.0259177461,
0.0178607386,
2.856e-7,
0.0763268918,
0.0560499057,
0.0192290694,
-0.0292337537,
-0.0012732939,
0.0117205158,
0.0283024032,
-0.000072305,
-0.0432044342,
-0.0073084417,
0.0746043473,
-0.0157753844,
-0.0026440171,
0.0374467857,
-0.0882451981,
-0.0295533817,
-0.0574793518,
-0.0340876319,
-0.0385376438,
-0.0239626318,
0.0610962138,
0.0359224677,
-0.069866173,
-0.0122901127,
-0.0237160753,
-0.0249855313,
0.0165052116,
-0.0098525751,
0.0264919661,
0.0589997508,
0.0361080207,
0.0096196933,
-0.0073451861,
0.0655820146,
-0.0112369293,
-0.0073844884,
0.0302968137,
0.0754753575,
-0.0387573466,
0.0289060324,
0.003993582,
0.0023340422,
0.0366767496,
-0.008270842,
0.069220677,
-0.0329279937,
-0.0249816217,
-0.017309323,
-0.0335238092,
-0.0020908073,
0.0197521355,
-0.0079052961,
-0.0239425357,
0.0453360379,
0.0209537838,
0.0010543085,
-0.0447999723,
-0.075853996,
0.0312124286,
0.0323867649,
0.0171920564,
0.0268119778,
0.0227037538,
-0.0453206338,
-0.0058641019,
-0.0310751349,
0.0097089121,
2.663694535e-34,
-0.0148963043,
0.0105750179,
-0.0280185379,
0.0325046442,
0.0081834355,
-0.0117046814,
-0.0110672163,
0.0344225243,
-0.0383863971,
-0.0334642678,
0.0243252032
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.08896v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.08896v3 | SelfCheckGPT: Zero-Resource Black-Box Hallucination Detection for Generative Large Language Models | 2023-03-15T19:31:21 | 2023-10-11T17:43:28 | Potsawee Manakul, Adian Liusie, Mark J. F. Gales | cs.CL | cs.CL | Generative Large Language Models (LLMs) such as GPT-3 are capable of
generating highly fluent responses to a wide variety of user prompts. However,
LLMs are known to hallucinate facts and make non-factual statements which can
undermine trust in their output. Existing fact-checking approaches either
require access to the output probability distribution (which may not be
available for systems such as ChatGPT) or external databases that are
interfaced via separate, often complex, modules. In this work, we propose
"SelfCheckGPT", a simple sampling-based approach that can be used to fact-check
the responses of black-box models in a zero-resource fashion, i.e. without an
external database. SelfCheckGPT leverages the simple idea that if an LLM has
knowledge of a given concept, sampled responses are likely to be similar and
contain consistent facts. However, for hallucinated facts, stochastically
sampled responses are likely to diverge and contradict one another. We
investigate this approach by using GPT-3 to generate passages about individuals
from the WikiBio dataset, and manually annotate the factuality of the generated
passages. We demonstrate that SelfCheckGPT can: i) detect non-factual and
factual sentences; and ii) rank passages in terms of factuality. We compare our
approach to several baselines and show that our approach has considerably
higher AUC-PR scores in sentence-level hallucination detection and higher
correlation scores in passage-level factuality assessment compared to grey-box
methods. | [
0.0277875774,
0.0373075791,
-0.0159109347,
0.0405636616,
-0.0566857196,
0.0392037295,
0.0166068263,
-0.0108080693,
0.0529312082,
-0.0402117111,
0.0185515527,
-0.0436306112,
0.0111641064,
0.0082265101,
0.0287644602,
-0.0065691983,
0.0641063228,
-0.035538137,
0.0185880102,
-0.0314110294,
-0.0119600343,
0.0290867295,
-0.0160296168,
0.0244078226,
-0.0157125033,
-0.0543362871,
-0.0049444367,
-0.0091003431,
0.0293052252,
0.0060834009,
-0.0060271979,
0.0745288655,
-0.0396788828,
0.0950408727,
0.0000019231,
-0.0568982102,
-0.0139282634,
0.0022358163,
-0.0420102514,
0.0133340769,
0.0103333183,
0.0651322305,
-0.0300771743,
0.022930596,
-0.0481819101,
-0.0054900059,
0.0155701535,
0.0737422779,
0.0660373867,
0.0751930624,
0.0058676046,
-0.0032328174,
0.060667295,
0.0139386021,
0.0667165369,
0.0275377408,
0.0339606144,
0.0326668732,
-0.0402015969,
0.0003363093,
0.0041349782,
0.0250908434,
0.0199391041,
-0.0196902752,
0.0086568324,
0.0381506458,
-0.0694406107,
-0.0284853969,
0.0241753031,
0.0554111637,
-0.0057990691,
-0.0465190671,
0.0164686851,
0.0152900675,
0.0245308634,
0.0289253984,
-0.0236676,
0.0438283049,
-0.0490562767,
0.0041934075,
0.0212858506,
-0.0135249142,
0.0343523733,
-0.0058642882,
-0.0060658171,
0.0887951031,
0.0302428454,
-0.0417393707,
0.0046971836,
0.0160095096,
0.0090489397,
-0.0646313429,
0.0011288016,
0.0007030905,
-0.0202979371,
0.0019820514,
-0.0467377156,
0.0240520053,
0.0623794086,
-0.0459494516,
-0.0179162417,
-0.0081040701,
-0.0471783839,
0.0714587495,
-0.0261974055,
0.0388931483,
-0.0075072576,
0.0474682711,
0.0149202272,
0.0040406659,
-0.0345240422,
-0.0087058619,
-0.0202247016,
0.0260224231,
0.0124715511,
-0.0025444203,
-0.0433726497,
-0.0016483427,
-0.02270885,
0.0408687107,
0.0124530476,
0.0001528938,
-0.0212980676,
-0.015635604,
-0.0485607423,
0.0192442685,
-0.0098273233,
-0.013908321,
-0.0130098443,
-0.0930214524,
-0.0136701157,
0.0029472897,
0.0001161039,
-0.0098253516,
0.0030604969,
0.0170309581,
0.0284601431,
-0.0209076051,
-0.0422936305,
-0.0504858643,
-0.0423625298,
-0.0925361738,
-0.0163107459,
-0.0811215937,
0.0101594124,
0.012157077,
0.0029129046,
-0.0165140461,
0.0164519381,
0.0366917029,
-0.0078028259,
0.0606792234,
-0.0007053007,
-0.0046249204,
0.0229231119,
0.0065371422,
0.0151457768,
0.0477970503,
0.0270201154,
0.028832905,
0.0358478539,
0.0236703437,
0.0381022282,
0.0173443314,
0.0043295934,
-0.0022911914,
0.0306837708,
-0.0105922585,
0.0450153798,
0.0251757279,
0.0215271451,
0.07338918,
-0.0269718971,
-0.0354626961,
0.0993397385,
0.0181413647,
-0.0110982088,
-0.0022648668,
0.0465826392,
-0.0017196437,
0.0264687315,
0.0598928332,
-0.0435940474,
0.0068760919,
-0.0265090037,
0.0081816018,
0.0468909852,
0.0507215708,
0.0028804531,
-0.0361724123,
-0.0014130216,
-0.0076441364,
-0.0079225767,
0.0082233064,
0.0374678336,
0.0297614299,
-0.0403936394,
0.0388127081,
0.0439455435,
-0.0742645636,
0.0206678621,
-0.0721390024,
0.0370208137,
0.0800300539,
0.068265304,
0.0012450084,
0.0257015247,
-0.0495449752,
0.004925272,
0.0666766912,
0.0362150446,
-0.0131079704,
-0.0168787483,
-0.0334245563,
-0.0029590176,
0.0122905681,
0.0314865485,
0.0260776356,
0.026636485,
0.0128909918,
0.0020591051,
-0.040006239,
-0.0373391323,
0.0242131315,
-0.0297720097,
-0.0247768629,
-0.020230975,
-0.0191430952,
0.0185406357,
0.0205512345,
-0.0310433842,
0.0071396711,
0.0068285624,
-0.0260948334,
-0.0485089496,
-0.0084037147,
-0.0367538333,
-0.0465999357,
0.0486497693,
-0.0285426173,
-0.0281560253,
0.0241021197,
-0.0156047614,
-0.0341159813,
-0.0143794334,
-0.0561755411,
0.038355004,
-0.0663171411,
0.022218354,
0.0089023812,
0.0444730297,
-0.0060626883,
0.0925872102,
-0.0122426208,
0.014128902,
-0.0167768132,
0.0120694637,
0.0033845853,
-0.0497779027,
-0.0500788428,
-0.0038552538,
0.0174825564,
0.0148089835,
0.0125310905,
-0.0326456949,
-0.0498866178,
-0.0093278233,
-0.092245467,
0.0183603019,
-0.0244958177,
0.001263437,
0.0182390921,
-0.0036720515,
-0.0082518682,
-0.009610422,
-0.028997235,
-0.0178724919,
0.0136175929,
0.0198753029,
0.0278350879,
-0.0216587838,
0.0021548469,
0.003503392,
0.011949826,
-0.0182935633,
0.0318273827,
0.0281953719,
0.0142503008,
-0.0590050817,
0.0314405262,
-0.0503974669,
0.0082485741,
0.0075447168,
-0.0221769325,
0.0284157209,
-0.0027946869,
0.0536128171,
0.0629434958,
0.037212722,
0.0102703013,
0.0392523445,
-0.0096117137,
-0.02624771,
-0.0020202256,
-0.0030321344,
-0.0130271483,
0.0051141563,
-0.0527525581,
0.0024523623,
0.0340404548,
0.0516017005,
-0.0117124338,
-0.0550264269,
0.023448512,
-0.0288336575,
-0.032121785,
-0.0043532737,
-0.0120578669,
-0.042149853,
0.0220341422,
-0.0252501089,
-0.0428499244,
0.0802359805,
-0.0562195443,
0.0132323448,
-0.0042161215,
0.0006062275,
0.0178444441,
0.0417591743,
0.0430057049,
0.0168996528,
0.0123224007,
-0.0028648048,
-0.0221780129,
0.003785969,
0.0451084189,
-0.0647454336,
0.006059743,
-0.0323145613,
0.0005473826,
0.0167011637,
-0.0312706232,
-0.0602586158,
-0.0364151709,
-0.0138039691,
-0.0337876603,
-0.0231179241,
-0.0324744508,
-0.0182753447,
-0.0138816871,
0.0392265134,
0.0440669954,
-0.038316384,
-0.0180110503,
-0.0069849505,
0.0256650839,
0.0793287903,
-0.011345841,
0.0531705804,
-0.0187850334,
0.0011450337,
0.0728373677,
-0.0056895437,
0.0440043025,
0.0036509088,
-0.0543983653,
-0.0097961929,
-0.0310020912,
-0.0104027167,
0.0031719825,
0.0158379897,
-0.0465835594,
-0.030482851,
0.127802074,
0.0212605465,
-0.0215683058,
-0.0176074151,
-0.0263439007,
0.0406218469,
-0.0017197555,
-0.0008872321,
-0.1004661322,
-0.0069283196,
-0.0134337181,
0.0129804024,
-0.0599028282,
-0.0496700928,
-0.0136300111,
-0.1411631107,
0.038513273,
0.0065663247,
-0.0098518655,
-0.019938942,
-0.0353652351,
0.0049129738,
-0.0072795399,
0.0138866911,
0.0011575286,
0.0199447498,
-0.0025365348,
-0.0045570116,
-0.0371936783,
-0.0301224496,
0.0494567193,
-0.0186273251,
0.0681470335,
0.0573621131,
0.0478233136,
-0.0042460146,
-0.0524102896,
-0.0132328114,
-0.014124346,
-0.0391162187,
0.0258666351,
0.0709761679,
0.0038018906,
0.000707855,
-0.0371027179,
0.036518082,
0.000999985,
-0.0114859408,
-0.0083855567,
0.0802531615,
-0.0225575212,
-0.0447283424,
-0.0156366415,
0.0153444912,
0.0313518979,
0.1142094582,
0.0130889621,
-0.0192688275,
-0.0524149239,
-0.0451828986,
0.0277184416,
-0.038443014,
-0.0677959323,
0.0406867042,
0.0284356512,
-0.0410967544,
-0.084266074,
-0.0425046086,
-0.0086559728,
0.0261551496,
-0.0190642476,
0.0404746979,
0.0363778211,
-0.0035209267,
-0.0132818418,
-0.0064138458,
-0.0775948465,
0.0051193177,
-0.020371573,
-0.0112373438,
0.0355341062,
-0.0321920887,
-0.000275821,
0.0138464291,
-0.0769443214,
-0.0658535361,
0.0570059717,
0.0280123968,
0.0265938453,
0.0341680199,
-0.036868751,
-0.033172328,
0.0688059926,
0.0555741899,
-0.0370470919,
0.0190045573,
-0.0096955476,
0.0149215441,
-0.0044234865,
0.0265186951,
-0.017984014,
-0.0000763102,
-0.0247952472,
0.0138586042,
-0.0384943523,
-0.0259962063,
0.0241981689,
0.0232484937,
0.0360772498,
-0.0234083552,
0.0173890758,
-0.0405716114,
0.0048487871,
-0.0323654898,
-0.0201375037,
0.0019128445,
0.0215859711,
0.0362665243,
-0.0268067438,
-0.0081673535,
-0.0333081409,
-0.0623780675,
0.0190977845,
-0.0394809991,
-0.0548321828,
0.0304929372,
0.0054266648,
0.0381828658,
-0.0643187463,
-0.0261872783,
0.0107810404,
0.0125150215,
0.0533028208,
0.014046357,
0.0574104823,
0.0071338615,
-0.0282961316,
0.0196677577,
-0.0026986406,
-0.0695451051,
-0.011601611,
-0.029929433,
0.0606667213,
0.0227247719,
0.0319933519,
0.0742449611,
-0.0462413058,
-0.0210670065,
-0.0163021088,
0.0054858797,
0.0548415966,
-0.0201985296,
-0.0099818399,
0.023867663,
-0.0381903462,
0.0240207855,
0.0554296784,
-0.0074919625,
0.0540224239,
0.0084124459,
-0.0459184945,
-0.05041942,
-0.0784556046,
-0.0722570717,
-0.0204464383,
-0.0126992995,
-0.016697688,
-0.0858379602,
-0.0631467775,
-0.0013779735,
0.0604292527,
0.0148891648,
-0.0183448009,
0.0021272721,
0.0456051342,
-0.0269781053,
-0.025225278,
-0.0571824275,
0.0327188931,
0.0167246107,
-0.0200825594,
-0.0104012331,
-6.469119367e-33,
-0.0354370624,
-0.0713242143,
-0.003087501,
-0.0116435327,
-0.0022719956,
-0.0136988461,
0.0050576511,
0.0073220474,
-0.0070992517,
0.0473925844,
-0.0036364275,
0.0361725874,
0.0264275391,
0.0232337527,
-0.0141557753,
-0.0041781617,
0.0589147136,
0.0068449038,
-0.0529229641,
0.0651383027,
0.0649502352,
-0.0198554806,
0.0347331129,
-0.0684387609,
0.0659735575,
-0.0493143313,
-0.0147624882,
0.0143364742,
-0.0438871086,
0.0477013513,
-0.027273532,
0.0611023903,
0.0081388997,
-0.0390375666,
0.0079684891,
-0.0038167499,
-0.0627185479,
-0.0200119279,
0.0107407384,
-0.0053593908,
-0.0018003598,
-0.0056513171,
0.018460013,
-0.0153949363,
0.000231543,
-0.0159055404,
0.0429099649,
-0.0213886071,
-0.0040553198,
-0.0025617345,
-0.0494272299,
0.0237984192,
0.0207870379,
0.0016939141,
-0.0647642538,
0.0266952589,
0.010115915,
-0.0400527753,
-0.0810708329,
0.0285490509,
0.034396071,
-0.0074350387,
0.0397575945,
-0.0152939968,
0.0057957284,
0.0676627979,
0.0132050896,
0.0052699614,
-0.0327781811,
-0.0089645563,
-0.0000701089,
-0.0129114343,
0.0319386385,
0.1020096317,
0.0164174084,
-0.0010639348,
-0.0517484024,
0.0171491131,
0.0120516242,
0.0137807019,
0.0602017082,
-0.0450053401,
-0.0575331785,
-0.024432309,
-0.0100914566,
0.0113867139,
-0.0232751705,
-0.0115058478,
0.0212480538,
-0.0007233644,
-0.0297569148,
-0.0267364644,
0.0213007163,
-0.0232845377,
-0.0206022635,
0.0408366211,
-0.0312489867,
-0.0025638286,
-0.005919517,
0.0301625933,
0.0070036403,
0.0255914386,
0.0165975466,
0.0203515217,
0.020565277,
0.0264676511,
0.0312934518,
0.0006629197,
-0.0679443702,
0.0228505749,
-0.0289772842,
0.036385294,
-0.002986317,
-0.01395093,
0.0367729925,
-0.017796997,
-0.0178932846,
0.0135163749,
0.0247927215,
0.0210113507,
-0.0390700474,
0.0032148862,
-0.0192027856,
-0.0180123467,
-0.0337684564,
0.0123942457,
-0.0224422161,
0.015198146,
0.0108765913,
-0.0575018525,
0.0209165011,
0.0137420353,
2.665e-7,
-0.0001187351,
0.0294312295,
0.0081410669,
0.0043034302,
0.0325292274,
0.033706367,
0.0287017133,
0.0183981527,
0.0156867933,
-0.0624221675,
-0.0386748724,
0.0389458723,
0.0611663386,
0.0492646322,
-0.0888769105,
-0.0211809836,
-0.0523891523,
-0.0135335568,
-0.0854492262,
-0.0149045074,
0.0454354994,
0.0649334192,
0.043400649,
-0.029622389,
0.0353500396,
-0.0446433648,
0.0522503816,
0.0291302782,
-0.0338092484,
0.0197859053,
0.0752988309,
0.0022062631,
0.019198278,
0.0367800482,
0.0024004935,
-0.0399740227,
-0.0066638724,
0.041140426,
0.0116330665,
-0.0329136588,
-0.021830108,
-0.02349592,
0.0017117955,
-0.0709874853,
0.0782480687,
0.0044985237,
-0.0050434419,
-0.0232479908,
-0.0052281697,
-0.03239071,
0.0576529726,
-0.0235181265,
-0.0396817029,
0.0215199757,
0.0091297189,
0.0110810678,
-0.0081004072,
-0.0282779913,
-0.0202696454,
-0.008370664,
-0.0447070934,
-0.090425536,
0.011864949,
-0.0176184494,
-0.0048912582,
-0.0859782398,
0.0467966944,
2.644807188e-34,
0.0236875303,
0.0167528093,
0.0305268168,
-0.0340371877,
0.0524724796,
0.0074369735,
0.0426169932,
0.0026257238,
0.0088517079,
-0.0589755401,
-0.0194622409
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.08894v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.08894v1 | A Formalization of Operads in Coq | 2023-03-15T19:29:40 | 2023-03-15T19:29:40 | Zachary Flores, Angelo Taranto, Eric Bond, Yakir Forman | math.CT | math.CT, cs.CL, cs.PL | What provides the highest level of assurance for correctness of execution
within a programming language? One answer, and our solution in particular, to
this problem is to provide a formalization for, if it exists, the denotational
semantics of a programming language. Achieving such a formalization provides a
gold standard for ensuring a programming language is correct-by-construction.
In our effort on the DARPA V-SPELLS program, we worked to provide a foundation
for the denotational semantics of a meta-language using a mathematical object
known as an operad. This object has compositional properties which are vital to
building languages from smaller pieces. In this paper, we discuss our
formalization of an operad in the proof assistant Coq. Moreover, our definition
within Coq is capable of providing proofs that objects specified within Coq are
operads. This work within Coq provides a formal mathematical basis for our
meta-language development within V-SPELLS. Our work also provides, to our
knowledge, the first known formalization of operads within a proof assistant
that has significant automation, as well as a model that can be replicated
without knowledge of Homotopy Type Theory. | [
-0.0193527099,
0.0689364001,
0.0035249691,
-0.0013541561,
0.0139220748,
0.00204146,
-0.0112389317,
-0.0611140318,
-0.0013017247,
-0.0058513703,
0.0189612303,
0.0322030559,
0.012812756,
0.0948096737,
0.0385482386,
-0.0427278541,
0.0666046813,
-0.0339805856,
-0.0255320109,
0.0232306086,
-0.0210242681,
-0.0272151995,
-0.0377253033,
-0.0005163109,
-0.0007164761,
-0.0640169084,
-0.0195489172,
-0.0365792178,
-0.003427228,
0.0019390112,
-0.0123819513,
0.0262272283,
-0.0612635911,
0.029720623,
0.0000016954,
-0.0139489081,
0.0170723274,
0.0794787183,
-0.0231026933,
0.0201312564,
-0.0451696441,
-0.0040364717,
-0.0041097631,
0.003802387,
0.0045616394,
-0.0111327711,
0.0496543199,
-0.0389514826,
0.0360392705,
0.0229813866,
0.0145969773,
-0.034012679,
0.0693120137,
0.0287492014,
0.0459540263,
-0.0266930889,
0.0016328406,
0.0017598954,
0.0722244531,
0.0019215982,
0.0591403954,
0.0103668394,
-0.006634986,
-0.0294008367,
-0.0121384189,
0.0081782332,
0.0562050194,
-0.0072483276,
0.0018162223,
-0.0251635388,
0.1050529107,
-0.0317653716,
-0.015417831,
0.0342920944,
-0.0246451218,
-0.0305220708,
-0.0151166404,
0.0528610796,
0.0170124229,
-0.0175557639,
0.0510547124,
-0.0059227888,
0.0266899187,
-0.0162947718,
-0.0063429535,
0.0717576444,
0.0310288556,
-0.0065789837,
-0.0512105413,
-0.0002606228,
0.015005298,
-0.0158051886,
0.0184265934,
0.0240072031,
-0.0125031816,
-0.0316916592,
0.0132293738,
0.0015819202,
0.0362645723,
-0.0581751242,
-0.0133950049,
0.0152108483,
0.0082106926,
0.0284202322,
0.0252168924,
0.0388030782,
-0.0028098335,
-0.006466053,
0.0094991922,
0.0044043246,
0.02520038,
-0.0366878994,
-0.0153708784,
0.0195143782,
0.0635013655,
0.0414065793,
-0.0238890965,
0.034688592,
-0.0501563773,
0.0889461637,
-0.0748784393,
-0.0699119791,
-0.0305553786,
0.0387886129,
0.0150130466,
-0.0532152131,
0.0174011979,
-0.0290464219,
-0.0220982712,
-0.0040068524,
-0.0182541609,
0.0145044141,
-0.0539229326,
-0.0048517874,
-0.0261828862,
0.0656854734,
0.0151572973,
0.024624873,
0.0550739057,
-0.0435148552,
0.0231362991,
0.0149549693,
-0.0135569395,
-0.0543422326,
0.0053182701,
0.0060993759,
0.0248199943,
-0.0302104484,
-0.0556774735,
-0.00831002,
0.0343822762,
0.0068458943,
-0.0309665222,
0.0016551389,
-0.0406969823,
-0.0069340225,
-0.051386077,
-0.0299792867,
0.002527524,
-0.0072732191,
-0.009834894,
0.0011833266,
0.0594404675,
-0.0092067588,
-0.0421090908,
-0.0423972271,
-0.0077520525,
0.0115306163,
0.0222468935,
-0.0122646596,
-0.0568878315,
0.0679509342,
-0.0261679254,
0.0155118508,
-0.0270805378,
-0.0108030103,
0.0236062706,
0.005925341,
0.037643604,
0.0126370545,
0.0402070209,
0.0228941794,
-0.0733469278,
0.0244155433,
-0.0551230498,
0.0344556831,
-0.0604582354,
-0.0064664418,
0.0215452909,
-0.072201483,
-0.0708990023,
0.0293902624,
-0.0277480632,
-0.0515810773,
-0.0009070679,
-0.0127268257,
0.0356735326,
-0.0413695797,
-0.0354975127,
-0.0170814712,
-0.0260496195,
-0.0522414595,
0.053034775,
0.014417544,
-0.0143363178,
-0.0625863746,
-0.0146064628,
-0.0575086772,
-0.015604943,
0.0667024106,
0.0390471816,
-0.0561571307,
-0.0340628885,
0.0334480703,
0.0394166894,
-0.0116546834,
0.048679322,
-0.0054744203,
0.0050038756,
-0.0213397611,
0.0009038778,
0.0128272418,
-0.0008042019,
0.0217406172,
-0.0058651394,
-0.0704306364,
-0.026623236,
0.0354841165,
-0.0185649861,
0.0067959325,
-0.0446498841,
0.0476575196,
0.0194467381,
0.064722158,
-0.0187331568,
-0.0141103193,
0.0055649374,
0.0617835969,
0.0107284077,
-0.0628034472,
-0.016076548,
0.0045007956,
-0.0563639067,
0.0344463438,
0.0689820573,
0.0119029712,
-0.0431514978,
-0.0319121815,
0.01036584,
0.028324334,
-0.0703282654,
0.0338494778,
-0.0215019677,
0.0161784049,
-0.0134808216,
-0.0169495046,
-0.0012655029,
-0.0049016918,
0.0420619138,
-0.0629249215,
0.0628209338,
-0.0069958824,
0.093001917,
0.025838105,
0.0464076959,
0.0211848393,
-0.0304210447,
-0.0131857125,
0.0466787666,
-0.0283715148,
0.0090251286,
-0.0063463934,
0.0145598194,
0.0183445271,
0.0179242715,
0.0458459817,
-0.0165960453,
0.0129766781,
0.0166539736,
0.035196349,
0.0069319373,
-0.0728332698,
0.0081629492,
-0.0218833741,
-0.0589844808,
0.0039749122,
-0.05604228,
-0.009982436,
-0.0069118114,
-0.0458449423,
-0.0246861149,
-0.0109760091,
-0.0160547346,
0.0547115542,
0.042909354,
0.0043084021,
-0.0248509441,
-0.0110309711,
-0.0080855759,
0.0174350645,
0.0365454704,
0.0328824744,
0.0243624691,
0.0018441651,
0.0155660575,
-0.0728984997,
0.0284284372,
0.0307612978,
0.0024799977,
0.05623639,
-0.0993310437,
0.0069798627,
-0.0342238285,
0.0230867174,
0.0207781717,
0.0536284149,
-0.0146926297,
-0.0425361879,
-0.035345193,
0.0106241656,
0.0029347613,
-0.0416991599,
0.039167691,
-0.0288067516,
-0.0079466328,
-0.0021411311,
-0.0466164835,
-0.0689342618,
0.0657563955,
-0.0400047153,
-0.0100107659,
0.0132631529,
0.0087269992,
0.0206573773,
-0.0261180922,
0.0228195842,
-0.010120214,
0.0029947639,
-0.0115090273,
0.0203727018,
-0.0113622062,
-0.016196847,
-0.0755408555,
0.1220435202,
-0.045010522,
0.0235847104,
-0.0779083073,
0.029449081,
0.0441838093,
-0.0048050643,
-0.0198934227,
-0.012357289,
0.0108979298,
0.0065996726,
-0.0281883422,
-0.0836111382,
-0.065866001,
0.007841764,
-0.0247231051,
0.0041314671,
-0.0038389494,
0.0100805173,
-0.0583577827,
-0.0209268332,
-0.0096604042,
-0.0126608536,
0.0490636341,
-0.0639091879,
-0.0318913646,
0.0074050361,
-0.0467677526,
-0.0476280153,
-0.0224084575,
-0.012530799,
0.0097265681,
0.0108142467,
0.0430466458,
-0.0201280471,
0.0131496843,
0.0420895442,
0.0646033734,
-0.1619418114,
0.0276046619,
-0.0207679905,
-0.0155948028,
0.0284700971,
0.0398721658,
-0.0144617129,
-0.0079782717,
0.0296186116,
0.0333077461,
-0.0290449336,
-0.0475764386,
-0.0115224877,
0.0187214725,
0.0077947639,
-0.0351019055,
0.0160111785,
-0.0051524723,
0.0321702324,
0.0388789438,
0.0656888708,
-0.0065727183,
-0.039352566,
-0.012469843,
-0.0104819583,
0.0189304873,
0.0163349714,
-0.0226700958,
-0.0539028198,
-0.0253985785,
0.0641532317,
-0.0495827161,
-0.009242096,
-0.0626199692,
-0.0364448912,
-0.0017283683,
0.0112397652,
0.0296301059,
0.0285860226,
-0.0565430187,
0.047661528,
0.0661429167,
-0.0165833794,
-0.0428784601,
-0.0348233879,
-0.0358712934,
0.0211755373,
0.0267094113,
-0.0067732884,
0.0523392782,
-0.0372632593,
-0.065778248,
-0.066127032,
-0.0220690835,
-0.0510273948,
-0.0099338749,
0.0511559919,
-0.0474815257,
-0.012084241,
-0.0030004627,
0.0667975247,
-0.0337458551,
0.0003612986,
-0.0110486532,
-0.0005900899,
-0.0045339502,
-0.0816820562,
-0.0049554803,
-0.0392428041,
0.0549814738,
-0.0225098487,
-0.0017767145,
-0.035667859,
0.011721788,
-0.0561939478,
0.0133661777,
0.0198206306,
-0.0219754446,
0.0566968732,
0.0658797324,
0.0171626005,
-0.0510143638,
-0.025381187,
-0.0012716065,
0.000977587,
0.021544531,
-0.0259332135,
-0.0143207544,
0.0740031227,
-0.0365573876,
0.0016323002,
0.0216975845,
-0.0026386764,
-0.0094710933,
-0.0542123839,
0.0063191392,
0.0017028028,
-0.0005765728,
-0.0055214195,
0.0171610136,
-0.009985636,
0.0058342391,
-0.0056616394,
-0.0001675216,
-0.0349508524,
0.0215659812,
-0.0083891097,
-0.0460719056,
0.0195861608,
-0.0927842706,
-0.0039455327,
0.0190183651,
0.0103827827,
-0.0146651873,
0.0440830849,
0.050354749,
0.0508546494,
-0.008872726,
-0.0000351419,
0.0582996234,
0.0335210301,
0.016894538,
0.0522673577,
-0.0143284379,
0.0489482135,
-0.0381487608,
-0.058261577,
0.055975344,
0.022375023,
0.0001832455,
-0.009217266,
0.0088776341,
-0.0615956001,
0.0071684984,
0.0327330492,
-0.0088745821,
0.0518244952,
-0.0085119558,
-0.0601307116,
-0.0012440176,
-0.0266289152,
0.0415841229,
-0.0066675167,
-0.0074949064,
-0.0262227133,
0.0412866212,
0.0452248156,
-0.0413274504,
0.0181632936,
-0.0313681476,
-0.0062921555,
-0.0042926283,
-0.0031132011,
-0.0388663523,
-0.0491242111,
-0.0122175785,
0.039433822,
-0.0289862119,
-0.044060301,
-0.0956191719,
-0.0415322855,
-0.0061105732,
0.0367208682,
0.0278865099,
-0.0236682817,
-0.0282895118,
0.0063330834,
0.0324258134,
-0.0292080529,
-0.0119541083,
-0.0096138883,
0.0557383634,
-0.0511731543,
0.0386603065,
-4.654205313e-33,
-0.0304984283,
0.0419446453,
0.0731790289,
0.0628001317,
0.0037776341,
0.0044948566,
-0.0427351259,
0.018426951,
0.0371117778,
0.0117789116,
0.0496144518,
-0.0061235544,
0.0087785767,
-0.0313517638,
-0.0252310541,
0.0285255108,
0.0752283931,
-0.0070719449,
-0.0344321653,
-0.022991132,
-0.0143409539,
-0.0715665072,
0.0473657288,
-0.0167192649,
0.0870944411,
-0.0268152785,
-0.0141362147,
0.0368186533,
-0.0618013144,
0.040415965,
0.0122257583,
-0.0098722167,
-0.0496293902,
0.024306491,
-0.0353958458,
0.0340798721,
-0.0097788824,
-0.0439047739,
0.0473099314,
-0.033440575,
-0.0408290066,
-0.0334599204,
-0.0308715589,
0.0317120589,
-0.0176583193,
-0.0267643481,
-0.0241667815,
0.0488175862,
0.022770077,
0.0344809219,
-0.0207009818,
0.023524018,
-0.0361813307,
0.0164913684,
0.0504614152,
-0.0392689034,
-0.0100067239,
0.0011279354,
-0.0017673504,
0.0355699845,
0.0362733826,
-0.0255123284,
0.0385092311,
-0.0209717471,
-0.0181351397,
-0.0049802652,
0.0223559178,
0.0485912524,
-0.0018000765,
0.1022114232,
-0.0166420639,
0.0378963239,
0.0079287924,
-0.0106047951,
0.0228336118,
0.0298362337,
0.0332286395,
0.040162731,
-0.0348583274,
0.0264622644,
-0.0241822414,
-0.0192529745,
-0.0457485504,
-0.0027139313,
-0.0669167563,
0.0224428251,
-0.0058195968,
-0.0085622733,
-0.009878627,
0.0075983452,
-0.0904696286,
0.0763184801,
0.0275931973,
-0.0259615537,
-0.0259499494,
0.0250835959,
-0.0239019133,
-0.0015402392,
0.0129260197,
0.0343224183,
0.0396132544,
0.010015511,
-0.0365924463,
0.0142537719,
0.0572751351,
0.0079514505,
0.0347725749,
0.0406206623,
-0.0169771481,
0.0323947743,
-0.0297597367,
-0.0228666235,
-0.0083244834,
-0.0023429976,
-0.0073082009,
0.0205530748,
0.0298228208,
0.0430585593,
-0.0387457572,
-0.033378467,
-0.0375365056,
0.0276089069,
0.0339235775,
0.0194104891,
0.0224795751,
-0.0264838971,
-0.0009098328,
0.0162764136,
0.0764822662,
0.0036217284,
0.0173142198,
-0.0107887965,
2.649e-7,
0.0136207007,
-0.0287554767,
0.0679647774,
0.1133974418,
-0.0422609895,
0.0412551798,
0.0295243394,
0.0042608725,
-0.0041258242,
-0.0070854654,
-0.0250929184,
0.0469784625,
-0.0354615115,
-0.0039183944,
0.017136151,
-0.0301071052,
0.0148344534,
0.00105208,
0.0055582686,
-0.0236438755,
0.0488520041,
-0.0491785444,
0.0454671159,
-0.0048475536,
-0.0435074233,
0.0256363507,
0.0017689951,
0.0598170869,
0.0051928051,
0.0299925543,
-0.0602962561,
0.0156825334,
0.0496945083,
-0.024834048,
0.0076494375,
-0.004048008,
0.0039904509,
0.0569040701,
-0.0048179203,
0.0732844621,
-0.044266317,
-0.0349803306,
0.0065252357,
0.0339394771,
0.0427062064,
0.0153713888,
-0.0053545483,
-0.0625687912,
-0.0359863378,
-0.0090744309,
0.003413934,
-0.0083778407,
-0.0152223296,
0.007716503,
-0.0115606384,
0.0202054586,
-0.0025458834,
0.0010590689,
-0.0492942445,
0.0464916937,
0.03529175,
-0.0219287314,
0.026478352,
0.039361231,
-0.0363777727,
-0.0021125881,
0.0024305272,
2.664595671e-34,
0.0225914493,
-0.017715672,
0.0716927722,
0.022585433,
0.0239599925,
-0.0346543267,
-0.0350509286,
-0.0075158351,
0.0493078232,
0.0247876756,
-0.0342484415
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.08877v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.08877v1 | ROSE: A Neurocomputational Architecture for Syntax | 2023-03-15T18:44:37 | 2023-03-15T18:44:37 | Elliot Murphy | cs.CL | cs.CL, q-bio.NC | A comprehensive model of natural language processing in the brain must
accommodate four components: representations, operations, structures and
encoding. It further requires a principled account of how these components
mechanistically, and causally, relate to each another. While previous models
have isolated regions of interest for structure-building and lexical access,
many gaps remain with respect to bridging distinct scales of neural complexity.
By expanding existing accounts of how neural oscillations can index various
linguistic processes, this article proposes a neurocomputational architecture
for syntax, termed the ROSE model (Representation, Operation, Structure,
Encoding). Under ROSE, the basic data structures of syntax are atomic features,
types of mental representations (R), and are coded at the single-unit and
ensemble level. Elementary computations (O) that transform these units into
manipulable objects accessible to subsequent structure-building levels are
coded via high frequency gamma activity. Low frequency synchronization and
cross-frequency coupling code for recursive categorial inferences (S). Distinct
forms of low frequency coupling and phase-amplitude coupling (delta-theta
coupling via pSTS-IFG; theta-gamma coupling via IFG to conceptual hubs) then
encode these structures onto distinct workspaces (E). Causally connecting R to
O is spike-phase/LFP coupling; connecting O to S is phase-amplitude coupling;
connecting S to E is a system of frontotemporal traveling oscillations;
connecting E to lower levels is low-frequency phase resetting of spike-LFP
coupling. ROSE is reliant on neurophysiologically plausible mechanisms, is
supported at all four levels by a range of recent empirical research, and
provides an anatomically precise and falsifiable grounding for the basic
property of natural language syntax: hierarchical, recursive
structure-building. | [
0.0108921425,
0.0393326133,
-0.0525755584,
-0.0014842016,
-0.0320538282,
0.0419289768,
-0.0338286832,
0.0288044289,
-0.0132525479,
-0.0035269754,
-0.0492518023,
-0.0271648951,
0.0505209602,
0.0461353026,
0.0437528118,
-0.034165144,
0.050294023,
-0.0007954716,
0.0272953995,
-0.0034145298,
0.01054879,
-0.0197052471,
-0.0431745313,
0.0229618233,
0.0037479529,
-0.0187659618,
-0.0418551825,
-0.0334847346,
-0.0363096185,
-0.0120085059,
-0.0611499064,
0.0350015834,
0.0009897377,
0.0294760372,
0.000001806,
-0.0307223406,
0.0422550589,
-0.0040200348,
-0.0248758458,
-0.0311969388,
-0.0031471986,
-0.0029494532,
-0.0124143371,
-0.0279106945,
-0.0139311105,
-0.0273008756,
0.0819534808,
0.0234830845,
-0.0250871722,
0.042843245,
-0.0133420071,
-0.0531766377,
0.0533772111,
-0.0093274442,
-0.012755448,
0.0494229533,
0.039905671,
-0.0223047212,
0.0212333053,
0.0274650976,
-0.0501492769,
-0.0103724618,
0.0218529031,
0.0211376175,
0.0097340718,
0.0466993973,
-0.0166399181,
-0.0265755244,
-0.0038059535,
0.0040976717,
0.0457174256,
-0.0424954928,
-0.0152203916,
0.0394203998,
0.0037355849,
-0.0260874629,
-0.0413721465,
0.0121296654,
-0.0128288791,
0.0484340414,
0.0574076325,
-0.0649045408,
0.0189795028,
-0.0323296078,
0.0459266156,
0.0468231887,
0.0154147884,
-0.0307576824,
0.0227847993,
-0.0083604958,
0.004176619,
-0.084668614,
0.0000112828,
0.0038661486,
-0.0113214999,
-0.0086705843,
-0.0034400583,
0.0022166632,
0.0096352603,
-0.068694368,
-0.0072866054,
0.0168035123,
0.0011128541,
0.0006602606,
-0.0025352747,
0.040679846,
-0.0511803515,
0.0200900957,
-0.0243177935,
0.0528311431,
-0.0602019243,
-0.0483297631,
0.0220123138,
0.03818262,
-0.0235244446,
-0.0350537039,
-0.0418924801,
-0.004439224,
0.0081009306,
-0.0387753882,
-0.0603908859,
-0.0007120164,
0.0271727946,
0.0572044216,
-0.0281010326,
0.0096762208,
-0.0219156034,
0.0358952694,
0.0185628068,
-0.0323714837,
-0.035698954,
0.0041038012,
-0.0193117671,
0.0050410819,
-0.0266022887,
0.0209068973,
0.0081475908,
0.0028768727,
0.0022398159,
-0.0133204609,
-0.0099346368,
0.001133378,
0.0358649567,
-0.0674157813,
-0.014992075,
0.0545037352,
-0.0395015627,
-0.0101561127,
0.0188508909,
0.0107851345,
-0.0204880163,
0.0325357318,
-0.0533128642,
0.009440423,
0.0305302385,
-0.0056903837,
-0.0085500292,
0.0103536872,
0.033868257,
-0.019259287,
-0.0405194126,
-0.0015608475,
-0.0169929937,
-0.0106291734,
-0.0069013364,
-0.0597754568,
-0.0752460957,
-0.0628891587,
-0.0136941541,
0.0202901661,
0.030062519,
0.021158861,
-0.0180883333,
-0.0156716593,
0.0069938535,
0.0333465487,
0.0118515147,
0.0632463768,
0.0267917402,
-0.069711335,
0.0605499633,
0.0143392282,
-0.035746485,
0.0333281048,
-0.0332744159,
-0.0048830048,
-0.0473716445,
-0.0039812815,
-0.0190145858,
-0.0142278764,
-0.0026679381,
0.0233214535,
-0.0033751433,
-0.0069601177,
0.021174917,
0.0004136894,
-0.0100361621,
-0.0207290165,
0.0228935443,
0.0020209693,
0.0042789774,
-0.0266626067,
-0.0204416644,
0.0530262254,
0.0080641611,
-0.0026730744,
0.0297299679,
0.0051333979,
-0.0079051293,
0.0924044475,
-0.0288213193,
0.0436143205,
0.011337298,
0.0013840429,
0.0022709514,
0.011294432,
-0.002169549,
0.0058906879,
-0.0684224814,
-0.0142713161,
-0.0579847023,
0.0139132189,
-0.0216616224,
0.0035352353,
0.0105999112,
-0.0164176784,
-0.0610330626,
0.000177012,
0.0068714707,
-0.0217598453,
-0.0136972992,
0.0628551841,
0.0043057953,
-0.0184589513,
0.0153365145,
0.0245327596,
-0.032853432,
0.0093406709,
0.0216688085,
0.05643747,
0.0101109482,
-0.0045953235,
0.0685146153,
-0.03151628,
0.0706889629,
-0.0708713233,
0.0652540252,
-0.0190930292,
0.0179530215,
-0.0228891037,
0.0594197102,
-0.0294672213,
0.0611563697,
0.0070750401,
0.0408220179,
-0.0098085506,
-0.0437842458,
0.0105505651,
-0.0304908417,
-0.0200376194,
0.01450059,
-0.0181569383,
-0.0046462161,
-0.006473457,
-0.0352207161,
-0.0686547235,
-0.0228333045,
-0.0841543749,
-0.011406674,
0.0591738001,
0.0257091597,
-0.0011801086,
-0.0323753394,
0.0012572501,
0.0139188264,
0.0275372099,
0.0559817441,
0.0108750109,
0.062836349,
0.016602179,
-0.0185417216,
-0.0686192587,
-0.0317835957,
-0.0412065983,
-0.0696693137,
0.0715288222,
-0.0009795539,
-0.0511898249,
-0.0403534509,
0.0545329563,
-0.013934792,
-0.0078599257,
0.0166512895,
-0.0338945203,
0.0694026649,
0.0267428923,
0.0479448065,
0.0488240272,
-0.0179453176,
0.0180810411,
0.0432619452,
-0.0536234193,
0.02482903,
-0.0376377292,
-0.0255702827,
0.0263759792,
-0.0260294192,
0.0010022811,
-0.0497159213,
0.095900014,
0.0579130314,
0.000009776,
-0.0201476198,
0.0091474699,
0.001864289,
-0.0327727832,
0.0074510719,
-0.0591432527,
-0.0372565314,
0.0390602015,
-0.0481934249,
-0.039375253,
0.0578280687,
0.0113759087,
0.0075742104,
-0.0033346117,
0.0135192601,
-0.0052175489,
0.052688688,
0.0362537503,
-0.0058477251,
0.0120072784,
-0.0547054037,
-0.0395465642,
-0.053689044,
-0.0340417325,
-0.016390875,
0.0175304338,
-0.0468551703,
-0.0184077714,
-0.0017644262,
0.0125353485,
-0.0398992226,
0.0377219766,
-0.031651102,
0.0386574753,
-0.0095629925,
0.0179436188,
0.0047242828,
-0.0255794674,
0.068173945,
-0.0016851192,
-0.0293816756,
-0.0380344056,
-0.0213657226,
0.0126174409,
-0.0251558274,
0.0207900405,
0.0347242057,
0.0049692076,
-0.0030865988,
0.0118391775,
0.0246607941,
0.0743611529,
-0.0519921519,
0.0443584546,
0.0192499794,
-0.0015891594,
-0.0649670511,
0.0049695838,
0.0128058279,
-0.0280657373,
-0.027013028,
0.0796814486,
0.0172586981,
-0.0440674499,
0.0109169735,
-0.0131294671,
-0.0140655423,
0.0291402563,
0.0240767878,
0.0080668833,
0.0519425347,
0.008048797,
-0.0484346226,
-0.0057248315,
-0.0036293757,
-0.0211497881,
-0.0182266589,
0.0114288414,
0.0051500872,
-0.0527529716,
-0.0134908054,
-0.0191581883,
0.0363968946,
0.0744701326,
-0.0187136885,
0.052865088,
-0.0212740283,
0.0350022018,
0.0352404751,
0.0343261324,
0.0445883684,
-0.028721977,
-0.0372443274,
0.0682436898,
0.0298274681,
0.0328063481,
-0.0397783853,
-0.0158567522,
0.0091238143,
-0.0002842557,
0.0201422777,
-0.0219618808,
-0.021829458,
0.1011184603,
-0.0225701295,
-0.0663425475,
-0.0027630054,
-0.0256877225,
-0.0648952946,
-0.0429800227,
0.0643230379,
-0.0541339144,
0.0178527646,
0.0277296696,
0.0596189015,
-0.0533850454,
0.0055745058,
0.0702248663,
-0.0262610298,
-0.0159225259,
-0.0100339223,
0.051187817,
0.0004093788,
-0.0459889621,
-0.0028189705,
0.0416470245,
-0.0377550945,
-0.0559885018,
0.0017686764,
-0.0178757645,
0.0076254769,
0.0099915806,
0.0262388811,
0.0504376069,
-0.0824365392,
-0.012110034,
0.009731316,
0.0282322727,
-0.0153292371,
-0.0383178107,
-0.0347520411,
-0.0211343654,
-0.0674246699,
-0.0437680259,
-0.0135493204,
0.0177111775,
-0.038755063,
0.0839056969,
0.0073441016,
0.0138637694,
-0.0349972881,
0.042164553,
-0.0263187718,
-0.0094578722,
0.0627092719,
0.0284040906,
0.11548765,
-0.0367295183,
0.0213984419,
0.0220041331,
0.0171221849,
-0.0030412788,
0.0009551676,
0.0235624425,
0.0132934554,
-0.0026866449,
0.0015453016,
0.0399321429,
0.0048121531,
0.0796459988,
0.040107701,
0.0132291075,
-0.023297552,
-0.0171313137,
-0.0201679245,
0.0294507165,
-0.0176475253,
-0.0673381016,
0.0430748351,
0.0460649468,
-0.0311088152,
-0.0689073056,
0.0320616439,
-0.001682118,
0.0663795099,
-0.0165692028,
-0.0154044563,
0.0161695704,
-0.0385965817,
0.0479203239,
0.0115049602,
0.0410403125,
-0.0415995978,
0.0132948654,
-0.0073489179,
0.0353567824,
0.0249034818,
-0.0148401763,
-0.0583110303,
0.0100618405,
-0.0449195877,
-0.0584407635,
0.0767714679,
-0.063265413,
0.0071342564,
-0.008914249,
0.0223890264,
-0.0363236852,
0.0121048857,
-0.015021625,
0.0095234718,
-0.0183404535,
-0.0023616212,
0.0185070988,
0.0307290219,
0.0104981102,
-0.0671009943,
0.0222325716,
-0.0195613299,
0.0040518749,
0.0295195375,
-0.0160710216,
0.004738634,
-0.0295445938,
-0.0520362034,
-0.005999981,
-0.0131922867,
0.0317131206,
-0.0544753037,
-0.0238714255,
0.0534975044,
-0.0029509289,
0.0275258776,
-0.0279950537,
0.0602137186,
0.0254487544,
0.010973054,
-0.0561607927,
0.0312625282,
0.0180748664,
0.0152138378,
-0.0296688881,
-0.0296515096,
-5.712985932e-33,
-0.0550131835,
-0.0271342862,
0.0277422573,
0.0672080368,
-0.0617738403,
0.0309545733,
-0.0222356562,
0.0673151612,
-0.006540746,
0.0091735786,
-0.0202904139,
0.0363558382,
0.0023492875,
0.0104459096,
0.0768046603,
0.0063209538,
-0.0376243219,
-0.0371290147,
0.0185615625,
-0.0395138077,
0.0722315311,
0.0085148755,
0.078325741,
-0.0551972836,
-0.0129933823,
0.0764001161,
0.0171869621,
0.0090648122,
-0.0310068615,
0.0079073235,
-0.0422710292,
0.0485057011,
0.0317097008,
0.0383402035,
0.0081651071,
0.0276819486,
-0.008719394,
-0.0947849005,
0.064340502,
-0.0236098245,
-0.0262177419,
-0.0273733791,
0.0943450555,
-0.0556868017,
0.0051803193,
0.023843918,
0.0071876636,
-0.0561647788,
0.0139828287,
0.08804629,
-0.0641427562,
-0.0399689525,
0.0216719266,
0.0099945869,
0.0115782144,
-0.0295038484,
-0.0624099188,
0.0009836447,
-0.0597101822,
0.0091291787,
-0.0568949655,
0.092907086,
-0.0009064079,
0.03115681,
0.0716557726,
0.0530099198,
0.1436335742,
0.0002999453,
-0.0238127802,
0.0301325768,
0.0497214086,
0.0367749631,
0.018166231,
-0.0268113539,
0.0201415922,
-0.00556998,
-0.0471374877,
-0.0656381696,
0.041588705,
0.0399928279,
0.0009833169,
-0.000960638,
-0.0153200021,
-0.0274081528,
-0.0023115929,
-0.0264922176,
-0.0331729539,
-0.0345599353,
-0.0152091552,
-0.0339737907,
0.0869439095,
-0.0060489941,
-0.0148419775,
-0.0004951524,
-0.0111295115,
-0.0361074656,
0.0101999668,
0.0230527464,
0.0581658073,
-0.0193760805,
-0.0279692225,
-0.0246497747,
-0.004059345,
0.0112668211,
0.0579252578,
0.0128254564,
-0.0238591135,
0.0169250406,
-0.0288370848,
-0.0142747331,
-0.0225109775,
-0.0571268983,
0.0345012657,
-0.0493655838,
0.0110941092,
0.0085104536,
-0.0019152602,
-0.0252304412,
0.0223297533,
0.0149554182,
-0.0334114544,
-0.0034547553,
-0.0517061539,
0.0569308624,
0.0101888506,
-0.0044970037,
-0.0325810201,
0.0407365859,
0.0107013937,
-0.065179579,
-0.0439865068,
0.0367189609,
2.871e-7,
0.0368387178,
0.049743697,
0.0506317541,
0.0990046188,
0.057696864,
-0.0004499409,
-0.0023268792,
-0.0128741814,
0.0348165743,
-0.0594899245,
-0.0517457202,
0.0341479629,
-0.0125513664,
0.0286853835,
0.0079358919,
-0.006136714,
0.0067993803,
0.0065997439,
-0.018079998,
-0.0047124987,
0.0214488823,
0.0027194768,
0.0103816828,
-0.0284509342,
-0.0039681364,
-0.0009427617,
0.0617140681,
0.0051464518,
0.0176640227,
-0.017771313,
-0.0674925074,
-0.0303670149,
0.0219316743,
0.059942089,
0.0136941038,
0.0172913913,
-0.0318011828,
-0.0283604003,
-0.0464957394,
0.0020309612,
0.0461776555,
-0.0146254851,
-0.0424331017,
-0.0156128444,
0.0050958931,
-0.0416324548,
-0.0422983281,
0.0125021059,
0.0005410277,
-0.0006122236,
0.0468653813,
0.0086490642,
-0.031384863,
-0.0305662882,
0.0039898856,
0.0078580864,
-0.0014443297,
0.0152429594,
-0.0057807248,
0.0667105466,
-0.0421486087,
-0.0193820056,
-0.0387878679,
0.0029241242,
0.0378724635,
-0.0179663282,
-0.0388228148,
2.670920382e-34,
-0.0189833399,
-0.0504139103,
0.0571469851,
0.0375573933,
-0.0223664604,
-0.0148174157,
-0.0041722269,
0.006473579,
0.0130235329,
-0.0593240447,
-0.0370169543
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.08809v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.08809v2 | Cascading and Direct Approaches to Unsupervised Constituency Parsing on Spoken Sentences | 2023-03-15T17:57:22 | 2023-05-09T10:36:55 | Yuan Tseng, Cheng-I Lai, Hung-yi Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, eess.AS | Past work on unsupervised parsing is constrained to written form. In this
paper, we present the first study on unsupervised spoken constituency parsing
given unlabeled spoken sentences and unpaired textual data. The goal is to
determine the spoken sentences' hierarchical syntactic structure in the form of
constituency parse trees, such that each node is a span of audio that
corresponds to a constituent. We compare two approaches: (1) cascading an
unsupervised automatic speech recognition (ASR) model and an unsupervised
parser to obtain parse trees on ASR transcripts, and (2) direct training an
unsupervised parser on continuous word-level speech representations. This is
done by first splitting utterances into sequences of word-level segments, and
aggregating self-supervised speech representations within segments to obtain
segment embeddings. We find that separately training a parser on the unpaired
text and directly applying it on ASR transcripts for inference produces better
results for unsupervised parsing. Additionally, our results suggest that
accurate segmentation alone may be sufficient to parse spoken sentences
accurately. Finally, we show the direct approach may learn head-directionality
correctly for both head-initial and head-final languages without any explicit
inductive bias. | [
-0.0300108083,
0.0583261326,
0.0046831365,
0.0408521593,
-0.0386204422,
0.0342757702,
0.0162007585,
-0.0394230857,
-0.0103766499,
-0.0464931354,
-0.0205335692,
-0.0045183972,
0.0208543912,
-0.0122868046,
0.0320723839,
-0.0712995976,
0.0552103184,
-0.054689128,
0.005049482,
0.0184099134,
0.0177800097,
0.0144840796,
-0.0352800265,
0.0148909204,
-0.0574838407,
-0.0329410918,
-0.0172934309,
-0.0030880496,
-0.0013697457,
0.0027653477,
-0.0152403032,
-0.0005916631,
0.0348290652,
0.0030418464,
0.0000017921,
-0.024799021,
-0.0523316413,
-0.0097456863,
-0.0613704361,
-0.0167310685,
0.0495968498,
-0.0121453255,
-0.0317333601,
0.0203035623,
0.0085549513,
-0.0123450737,
-0.0067894952,
0.0055833911,
0.0331781246,
0.0489978343,
-0.0208174866,
-0.0806975141,
0.0167443473,
0.0233004466,
-0.0310603008,
0.0088523189,
-0.0086604673,
-0.0023043293,
-0.0356283411,
-0.0312434491,
-0.0170627404,
0.0123383934,
0.0009747247,
-0.0124900285,
0.0292109791,
0.0330228098,
-0.0595969222,
-0.0197657254,
-0.0054969369,
0.040034689,
-0.0050696796,
-0.0322357863,
0.0545718595,
-0.015641436,
-0.0614143424,
-0.0453765094,
0.0030117221,
0.0747136772,
-0.0078305975,
0.0238169394,
0.0613943562,
0.0173388571,
0.0107795736,
-0.0313188061,
-0.0093966005,
0.0898326561,
-0.0044540004,
-0.0498412326,
0.0251551699,
-0.0012702752,
0.0165764298,
0.007069129,
0.0240806434,
-0.0556554049,
0.0224048588,
0.0238658078,
0.0147471726,
-0.0216773562,
-0.0353940651,
-0.0352657847,
-0.0167965442,
0.0218032878,
-0.0433792658,
0.0358437635,
0.033339221,
0.0055492441,
-0.0294105951,
0.0214012358,
-0.070182845,
0.0372339785,
-0.0471662506,
0.0139929364,
-0.0601368994,
0.0133707589,
-0.0345198363,
-0.0057893824,
0.0008336168,
-0.0099188313,
0.0090691792,
0.0073243235,
0.0138980579,
-0.000576676,
-0.0366653539,
0.0108606033,
0.0359300449,
0.0368699953,
-0.0226830039,
0.0119346837,
-0.0040912651,
-0.006143616,
-0.0230189189,
0.0938600078,
0.0508119836,
0.0010711121,
-0.0231270995,
-0.0035642155,
-0.0136590395,
-0.017452253,
-0.0268972833,
-0.0353945419,
-0.0392847173,
-0.0144330375,
0.010304857,
-0.0465482473,
0.0422579385,
-0.0090033272,
0.0008920952,
0.0277045388,
-0.0282364972,
-0.0119687626,
0.0419224799,
0.0490102619,
-0.0082204565,
0.0004666717,
0.0302001238,
-0.0215069335,
0.0380427316,
0.0514347553,
0.0388184339,
0.0187408775,
0.0265436526,
-0.0074576661,
-0.0150622241,
0.0199957043,
-0.031159617,
-0.0234528165,
-0.0606905855,
0.0199515074,
-0.0043123486,
-0.004664246,
0.0239906479,
0.030734973,
-0.0303538181,
0.0040035467,
-0.0306186881,
0.0712286234,
-0.0297911111,
0.0091914609,
0.050757546,
0.0085230218,
0.0021941925,
0.0767174959,
-0.0097814677,
-0.0597196519,
0.030061515,
0.0097974725,
-0.0008295528,
-0.025051333,
-0.0150251491,
0.0117067974,
-0.0117450468,
-0.0435447618,
-0.0114617031,
-0.0070527,
0.0484570302,
0.0156869926,
-0.0027456216,
0.0349778645,
-0.0071797045,
-0.0864365399,
0.0176135693,
0.0080646593,
-0.0204979852,
0.0195682179,
0.0070856106,
-0.0584590994,
0.0006177962,
-0.0282350779,
-0.0055090147,
0.0491967387,
-0.0180213768,
-0.0268172137,
0.0610790066,
-0.0462413579,
0.0093054259,
0.0537498295,
0.0277163219,
0.0114219068,
-0.082682915,
-0.0318988897,
0.0024124286,
-0.0461798944,
0.0497122929,
0.0281044003,
0.0040398617,
-0.0039157788,
0.0221220125,
0.0145874722,
0.0514633656,
0.0451955236,
-0.0340084359,
-0.012963797,
0.0315420665,
-0.0335222073,
0.0342899747,
0.0270374529,
-0.1150487363,
-0.0719117448,
-0.0322210863,
-0.0470029227,
-0.0354280882,
0.0086148707,
0.007116219,
-0.0648527369,
0.00771672,
-0.0442299731,
0.0506304651,
-0.0453109071,
0.041850172,
0.0173562132,
-0.0223450642,
-0.0092464164,
0.0678387582,
-0.0044208406,
-0.0222052801,
-0.0256765056,
0.0037789647,
0.0289215911,
-0.0556181818,
-0.0089015337,
-0.0034917605,
-0.027152162,
-0.0456117876,
0.0019063096,
-0.0592122003,
-0.0463134311,
0.0129239876,
-0.0827430859,
-0.0191868134,
-0.043535959,
0.0606599487,
0.0188906342,
0.0123205464,
0.0201094188,
-0.0251831673,
0.0064975694,
-0.0000794888,
0.008714431,
-0.0103213945,
0.0009658307,
-0.0210138019,
-0.0516008772,
-0.0424667373,
-0.0062529612,
-0.0684285089,
0.000324187,
-0.0003402879,
-0.0662044138,
-0.0356652364,
0.0185794737,
0.0459669828,
0.0364916511,
0.0120247547,
-0.0404401496,
0.0176692475,
-0.0364657752,
0.0563681908,
0.0847324654,
-0.0091663133,
-0.0262329616,
0.0111031774,
-0.0280816257,
-0.014131505,
-0.0075895418,
0.015267795,
0.079443939,
-0.0388300456,
0.0368129462,
0.0162215568,
0.0904243216,
0.0600716136,
0.0332023725,
0.0186371952,
-0.053128507,
-0.0449453928,
-0.0111559257,
0.0088792387,
-0.0691404045,
-0.0343334489,
0.0370589681,
0.0018895324,
-0.0201844182,
0.0166281685,
-0.0841764882,
-0.0760153383,
-0.0520966724,
-0.040063452,
-0.0151993278,
0.0593590364,
0.0628331006,
-0.0017454256,
0.019290084,
-0.0972710773,
-0.0029745696,
0.0266879387,
0.0261566341,
0.0036014921,
0.0290204044,
-0.0151058612,
0.021705376,
-0.0206116457,
-0.0349771269,
-0.0277545135,
-0.0345241986,
-0.0099245319,
0.0379982628,
0.026559839,
0.026420407,
0.0137950247,
0.0438778661,
0.0150850108,
0.0698941574,
0.0125308596,
0.0436598957,
-0.0371269137,
0.0524630509,
0.0024554611,
0.0151618635,
-0.0301654562,
-0.0033617127,
0.0593950674,
0.0087560415,
0.0938635543,
0.0315713547,
-0.0556717291,
0.0195919909,
-0.0286502168,
-0.0253597368,
-0.0357994139,
-0.0110087795,
0.0130853355,
-0.0504990742,
-0.0230484959,
0.0945208222,
0.023561744,
-0.0322078615,
-0.0217249356,
0.0094660893,
-0.0264966115,
0.0016910136,
-0.0067000785,
-0.058505103,
-0.0179485399,
0.0421030819,
0.0156287495,
0.0247798525,
-0.018406475,
0.0296406467,
-0.0887522548,
0.0457435139,
0.0113302805,
-0.0207621101,
0.0210514069,
-0.0255439188,
-0.027033288,
-0.0644177422,
-0.0237722639,
0.0341458879,
-0.0280541275,
-0.0344854295,
0.0170808677,
-0.1315090358,
-0.0064751804,
0.0059380317,
-0.024769241,
0.0108464677,
0.0848784968,
0.0063089365,
-0.0160035398,
0.0013453074,
0.0712385476,
-0.0855342224,
0.0136529896,
0.0069611399,
-0.00523178,
-0.0168564059,
0.007892645,
0.0159471687,
0.0280020759,
0.0062919031,
-0.0046642744,
0.0294340067,
0.0771734864,
-0.0516463742,
0.0362211578,
0.0441609733,
0.0312048476,
0.0050408896,
0.0610541627,
0.0092391809,
0.0117611866,
-0.0299050491,
-0.016832063,
0.064285934,
-0.013385715,
0.0147633068,
0.0282737594,
0.0183613803,
-0.001148903,
-0.0543064512,
-0.013832734,
0.0360502787,
0.0261898302,
-0.0083530946,
0.0083287116,
0.0533520393,
-0.0031859868,
0.0189103838,
0.0007695576,
-0.0150797749,
-0.0015416489,
-0.0419102944,
-0.0494607314,
0.0123465313,
0.0038260671,
-0.0322695896,
-0.0319581628,
-0.0136635089,
-0.0328695662,
0.0506393351,
-0.004221139,
0.011042634,
0.0461445004,
-0.05326882,
0.0012115618,
0.0142857144,
0.0312659256,
-0.0857329965,
0.0006770066,
0.0119816195,
0.03558027,
-0.0141176106,
-0.0010709277,
-0.0063453582,
0.047553435,
-0.0316924229,
0.0007736341,
-0.0689576045,
-0.0129854288,
0.0244583152,
0.0116841933,
0.1343993694,
0.0055650012,
0.0439895652,
-0.0233480111,
0.0372682065,
-0.0285610426,
0.0124087697,
-0.0199581292,
0.0069679543,
0.0007072741,
0.0212337878,
0.0137588615,
0.0329951644,
-0.043003276,
0.0125843091,
-0.0052558631,
0.0869649276,
0.0546004996,
0.0252278335,
-0.0451226756,
0.0193028878,
-0.011639649,
0.0120278411,
-0.0028843896,
0.0420410037,
0.0026674431,
0.0242542792,
-0.0160710402,
-0.0027688369,
-0.0030682338,
-0.0077374228,
-0.0712423325,
0.0620222837,
-0.0165150873,
0.0042770645,
0.0305428896,
-0.0553595573,
0.0379967578,
0.0056438488,
0.0495881252,
-0.017024057,
0.0322753824,
-0.0030730744,
-0.0374211706,
0.0212988667,
0.0152036212,
-0.0399792269,
-0.0075385249,
0.0277580731,
0.0293092579,
-0.0083747711,
0.0090444088,
0.046722658,
-0.0406090245,
-0.0511029214,
-0.0291822031,
0.0020785409,
-0.0461993106,
0.0031846601,
0.0245184004,
-0.002997407,
-0.0104450081,
0.0072586061,
0.0554193892,
-0.011904316,
0.0416928455,
-0.0007898427,
-0.0358408578,
-0.0257639661,
0.0249302201,
-0.0067577194,
-0.0280953869,
0.0078620836,
-0.0020295919,
-5.82742398e-33,
-0.0489462093,
0.0081952093,
-0.0126835378,
0.000088806,
-0.0261820629,
-0.0019014839,
-0.0170938782,
0.0060189986,
0.0577938668,
-0.0293084178,
-0.0097970795,
-0.0033675756,
0.0284725856,
0.038007874,
0.0413244069,
-0.0068211644,
0.066381678,
-0.0512402728,
-0.0016664615,
0.0026289881,
0.0337523073,
0.0545809455,
0.0119835725,
-0.0373639576,
-0.0529232956,
-0.0349381939,
-0.0092656901,
0.0321340375,
0.012982836,
0.0380704403,
0.0084612155,
-0.0393252522,
0.002448447,
0.0002178259,
-0.0321861692,
0.0629831702,
-0.0882438943,
0.034927886,
-0.0289577842,
0.0511278883,
-0.0181748625,
0.0061301515,
0.0221744925,
-0.0116327284,
0.0197593477,
0.0095330188,
0.02907761,
-0.0016455607,
0.0104106823,
0.0255021229,
-0.0447814204,
0.0325314216,
-0.0217729732,
0.0354413949,
0.0795575604,
0.0558447875,
0.0167961624,
-0.0121131698,
-0.0456000492,
0.0085569043,
-0.0254507922,
0.0610019341,
0.0166999456,
0.0092555135,
-0.0059674392,
0.0436456129,
0.0738311037,
-0.0733074024,
-0.0384443738,
-0.0395114385,
-0.0085418634,
0.0423278585,
-0.0251494925,
-0.0239434987,
0.0256441422,
0.0087095452,
-0.0415289178,
-0.024064647,
0.0627055988,
0.0008923304,
-0.0315001123,
0.0360728018,
-0.0451828055,
-0.0059399558,
0.0163225457,
-0.0647235438,
0.0035902092,
0.0069959341,
0.0295897946,
0.0007213418,
0.0067911725,
0.0328630358,
0.0826591104,
0.0026121037,
0.0307961144,
-0.0336158946,
0.0254370645,
0.0142394789,
-0.0051120338,
0.034681797,
-0.0528643355,
-0.0731692463,
0.0130547034,
0.0535492487,
0.0384291038,
-0.0048124692,
0.0155379269,
0.0255371984,
-0.0451007262,
0.0096765086,
0.0001309607,
-0.0217753723,
-0.0583935007,
0.073268123,
0.0501113385,
0.0115929917,
0.0023090269,
0.0841351524,
-0.0290674213,
0.0220305156,
-0.0130394818,
-0.0256784949,
-0.0475297309,
0.0366722643,
-0.0228626542,
-0.0409178324,
0.0484003127,
-0.0234452449,
0.0364732966,
-0.0106713874,
0.0149395308,
0.017241573,
2.529e-7,
-0.0173648,
0.0307952259,
0.0842457265,
-0.0427993536,
0.0564076751,
0.0199606512,
-0.020958513,
-0.0037919283,
-0.0473702848,
-0.0195273161,
-0.0058859522,
-0.0591477379,
0.0645781755,
0.019599136,
-0.1420953274,
0.0468841158,
-0.0492328778,
0.0030742805,
-0.0414749533,
-0.0134720076,
0.0322474279,
0.0797949359,
-0.0529460274,
-0.0026015474,
-0.0258168299,
0.0115875909,
-0.006761807,
0.0112076588,
-0.0059057465,
-0.0355032533,
-0.069944106,
0.0002196946,
-0.0546132028,
0.0332424939,
-0.0177465677,
0.0449076816,
-0.0003870923,
0.0696914047,
0.0012492596,
0.0148206735,
0.0360754207,
0.0411727726,
-0.0157771241,
0.0168263223,
0.0450144485,
-0.0221125204,
0.0139780082,
-0.0170142762,
-0.0439421199,
0.0308199637,
-0.038706854,
0.0482319333,
0.0174956527,
0.0181745403,
0.0156657603,
-0.0442362465,
-0.0224663354,
-0.0229731817,
0.0003909862,
0.0333590657,
-0.0572690964,
-0.0167717822,
-0.0015200975,
0.0700666159,
0.0366920605,
-0.022194352,
-0.0433289036,
2.009949321e-34,
-0.0061154719,
-0.0138786063,
0.0184521694,
-0.024704935,
0.0168519411,
-0.0315962471,
-0.018861277,
0.01488348,
0.0164248142,
-0.0511959754,
-0.0196462553
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.08806v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.08806v1 | Understanding Post-hoc Explainers: The Case of Anchors | 2023-03-15T17:56:34 | 2023-03-15T17:56:34 | Gianluigi Lopardo, Frederic Precioso, Damien Garreau | stat.ML | stat.ML, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | In many scenarios, the interpretability of machine learning models is a
highly required but difficult task. To explain the individual predictions of
such models, local model-agnostic approaches have been proposed. However, the
process generating the explanations can be, for a user, as mysterious as the
prediction to be explained. Furthermore, interpretability methods frequently
lack theoretical guarantees, and their behavior on simple models is frequently
unknown. While it is difficult, if not impossible, to ensure that an explainer
behaves as expected on a cutting-edge model, we can at least ensure that
everything works on simple, already interpretable models. In this paper, we
present a theoretical analysis of Anchors (Ribeiro et al., 2018): a popular
rule-based interpretability method that highlights a small set of words to
explain a text classifier's decision. After formalizing its algorithm and
providing useful insights, we demonstrate mathematically that Anchors produces
meaningful results when used with linear text classifiers on top of a TF-IDF
vectorization. We believe that our analysis framework can aid in the
development of new explainability methods based on solid theoretical
foundations. | [
0.0224512983,
0.0438060984,
-0.0124552427,
0.0226752684,
0.0035879705,
0.0193934254,
0.0329216048,
0.0162567347,
-0.0247071125,
-0.005309897,
0.0663928464,
0.0163298473,
-0.0043668943,
0.0281056315,
0.0000653286,
-0.0487416461,
-0.0044238456,
-0.0275565553,
0.000636077,
0.0109874001,
-0.0002401187,
0.0091299312,
0.013308824,
0.0700534433,
0.0251290929,
0.0054963869,
-0.0366041176,
-0.0096751899,
-0.0206254497,
0.0344449952,
-0.0374448299,
0.017904697,
0.0086964266,
0.0323410816,
0.000002107,
-0.0099483486,
-0.068140097,
0.0192182939,
-0.0675707832,
0.0041397875,
-0.0280020032,
-0.0484262556,
0.0239468049,
-0.0090445187,
0.016390821,
0.014274504,
0.0655720234,
0.0661000162,
0.0231231637,
0.039620094,
-0.0037099575,
-0.0439646505,
0.0133174835,
0.0113514103,
0.0474136285,
-0.0339058414,
-0.0053816033,
-0.0001752045,
-0.0645178929,
-0.011250806,
-0.0219333041,
-0.0097359819,
0.0372233912,
0.0015874864,
0.0648090988,
-0.0013919614,
0.0045877527,
-0.0122195957,
0.0148571609,
0.0297076274,
0.011129071,
-0.044999741,
0.01021598,
-0.0119113019,
0.0161090698,
0.078875795,
-0.0241163056,
-0.0394776016,
0.0085276589,
0.0271118451,
0.0174361672,
0.0347338729,
0.0712793916,
0.0165390167,
-0.0464615971,
0.0654095188,
-0.0526719652,
0.0112262797,
-0.0311889984,
0.0192319732,
0.0052947188,
-0.024496913,
0.0200553201,
0.0463601798,
-0.0259652566,
0.0232797656,
0.0279239696,
0.0095295813,
0.0081039974,
-0.0395674929,
0.0680504963,
0.0028508992,
-0.0242720451,
0.0186892729,
-0.0126271117,
0.021585498,
-0.0171531662,
0.019335296,
-0.0150896106,
-0.0037902482,
-0.09713047,
-0.042798847,
-0.0034885837,
0.0051401854,
-0.0257389117,
0.0149847949,
0.0002973137,
-0.0002219888,
-0.0324589498,
-0.0033324696,
-0.0291199367,
-0.0013315782,
-0.022166552,
-0.0148407826,
-0.0099411914,
0.0049809804,
-0.0483176112,
0.0095250253,
0.0027019777,
-0.0440064147,
-0.0059089572,
0.0087502608,
0.0040502581,
-0.0049901903,
-0.0133796362,
0.0354378335,
0.0324652381,
-0.0001090777,
-0.0262633972,
-0.0927899927,
-0.0286256932,
-0.0519713573,
-0.0406380408,
-0.023662081,
-0.03488205,
0.0283222459,
0.0153375668,
-0.0672516972,
-0.0369411111,
-0.0157480277,
-0.0501627699,
0.0783180445,
-0.0293281805,
-0.0037896219,
-0.037598215,
0.0147673786,
-0.0061271023,
0.0330918059,
-0.0161258224,
0.0441469364,
0.058254756,
-0.0656076819,
0.0434913337,
-0.0442074016,
0.038629584,
-0.0137089984,
-0.0320590958,
-0.0138622001,
-0.0400030538,
0.00225011,
-0.0062353653,
-0.002003988,
-0.0083531961,
-0.0135829439,
0.0095307641,
0.0335674286,
0.0448385142,
0.0493588783,
0.0435009636,
0.0205038991,
-0.0204766598,
0.0491401777,
-0.0309998542,
0.0063008773,
-0.068016082,
-0.0186743885,
-0.0392144285,
-0.0321674347,
-0.0161200389,
-0.1055107713,
-0.0212968029,
0.0059983474,
-0.0183167234,
-0.0042943647,
0.0818387866,
0.0124611659,
0.0203380175,
0.0394987427,
0.018734822,
-0.0384976007,
0.0073229289,
-0.0705365017,
0.0415440947,
0.0537845306,
0.0183361862,
-0.0407507271,
0.0163120832,
-0.0033064212,
0.0485085063,
-0.0214517023,
0.0074604852,
0.0059884223,
0.0007069202,
-0.0272559635,
-0.0366093069,
-0.0234991275,
0.0485059433,
-0.0009180985,
-0.0352733396,
-0.0429284088,
-0.0011888648,
-0.0502142347,
-0.0656449795,
0.030147722,
0.0214855634,
-0.0128413476,
-0.0029141596,
0.0029078277,
0.0064855558,
0.0486278869,
0.0112737315,
0.0025384712,
0.0296880808,
0.0114625171,
-0.0105138412,
0.0236340575,
0.0148617486,
0.0321347304,
-0.0219918806,
-0.0253798924,
-0.0056963996,
0.0137261273,
-0.0349330083,
-0.0383623466,
0.0238565691,
-0.0352146737,
0.0489205085,
-0.0155349644,
-0.0274719596,
-0.0264764614,
0.0172629524,
-0.0131317154,
0.0530710854,
-0.0068290825,
0.0184274446,
-0.013059902,
-0.0177134667,
0.0258725993,
-0.0114988619,
0.0169047192,
0.0093306741,
-0.0242727436,
-0.0062942109,
0.0238000229,
-0.0287810098,
-0.0113057131,
0.0079816319,
-0.0207942091,
-0.0293353647,
-0.0207491331,
-0.0154725956,
0.0001606315,
-0.0242238585,
0.0229781587,
-0.0171277225,
-0.0148605974,
-0.0085887946,
-0.0181866772,
0.0021554357,
0.0497641452,
-0.0070859184,
-0.0564460605,
-0.0098026693,
-0.0212997645,
-0.0254599918,
0.1170414388,
0.0350291319,
0.003773758,
-0.0666543469,
-0.0395926349,
0.0035450773,
-0.0378871225,
-0.0172294546,
-0.0287374463,
0.003302753,
-0.0151793268,
-0.0715158284,
0.0355913937,
-0.0078949928,
0.132588625,
0.0142917605,
0.0357214063,
-0.0461587533,
-0.0419074595,
-0.0296951812,
0.0178983584,
-0.045959264,
-0.0441853032,
-0.0006676962,
0.0721725076,
-0.0149070984,
-0.0152307982,
-0.0623911843,
0.051176738,
-0.0017473965,
-0.0280640423,
-0.0566321053,
-0.0380471312,
0.0141070504,
0.0815311521,
0.0014375008,
-0.0995483026,
0.0656517223,
-0.0243479311,
-0.0014975137,
-0.014628428,
-0.0449692085,
-0.0501027107,
0.0621080101,
-0.0102750314,
0.0142359911,
0.0309481695,
0.0018633368,
0.0201070327,
-0.030241739,
0.0038971833,
-0.0013819154,
0.0224793311,
-0.0400720164,
-0.0235017091,
0.0325199626,
-0.0015511293,
-0.0114384918,
-0.0491179451,
-0.0400097333,
-0.0102105327,
0.0250202622,
-0.0393897146,
-0.0168575849,
0.0156603754,
0.0280338749,
-0.0254881363,
-0.0171899516,
-0.0360057652,
-0.0040533147,
-0.0033596188,
-0.0031568881,
0.0161717962,
0.0224777013,
-0.0207834877,
0.0045096958,
0.0393733568,
0.0194203239,
-0.0422501862,
-0.0525189787,
0.0387131646,
-0.0014018316,
-0.0309369862,
-0.0368478745,
-0.0086051794,
0.0233748667,
-0.0690372288,
0.0110116173,
0.0613762066,
0.0434241369,
-0.0242542066,
0.0416734666,
-0.0178337097,
0.0195051078,
-0.0197609048,
0.0004271104,
-0.0185889173,
-0.022570461,
0.0111575508,
0.0468108989,
-0.0275549944,
-0.0067793927,
0.01545294,
-0.0298818722,
0.0616749264,
-0.0116676325,
-0.0452192873,
-0.0323980786,
-0.0581152439,
-0.04740135,
-0.0430603102,
-0.0285484809,
-0.0024014588,
0.0291596316,
0.055362951,
0.0548513457,
-0.0362322442,
-0.0114717511,
-0.0041413521,
-0.0125152189,
0.0415495709,
0.0442299359,
0.0260296091,
-0.0133616142,
-0.0462879874,
-0.0265115295,
-0.0042706728,
0.0515542887,
-0.0266648866,
0.0916476101,
0.0228590574,
-0.0125163011,
-0.0453128479,
0.0492109545,
-0.0254996009,
-0.0214091558,
-0.0375624523,
0.0589422174,
-0.0134129087,
-0.0229825582,
0.0021361019,
-0.006663023,
-0.0158059038,
0.081374988,
0.040800944,
-0.0167484786,
-0.0528197773,
-0.0606208965,
0.0144678289,
-0.0403776579,
-0.0710679218,
0.0027332467,
0.028163109,
-0.0454960056,
-0.0084153619,
-0.0315692052,
-0.0290255845,
0.0618395321,
-0.0219693575,
0.0332418829,
-0.0651457682,
-0.0055410168,
-0.0284716841,
0.0624164641,
0.0287745837,
-0.0028114615,
0.0251084492,
-0.0423697419,
0.0324882604,
-0.0639747679,
-0.0337137021,
-0.0196898784,
0.0637942925,
0.0079268711,
0.0254097208,
0.0157680474,
0.0422251746,
0.0525458343,
-0.0096500143,
-0.0769831836,
-0.0004816041,
0.0334922448,
-0.0143880937,
-0.0071343281,
0.0806745216,
-0.0417196117,
0.0177787803,
0.0430270694,
-0.0171025824,
0.0150428768,
0.0131790619,
-0.0263096951,
-0.066447489,
0.0341547094,
0.0248810127,
0.0134247439,
0.0737154782,
0.0112308599,
-0.0688301325,
0.0211002044,
0.0142508149,
0.0065620132,
-0.0110194078,
-0.0450115204,
0.0285917502,
0.0275276396,
-0.0041001928,
-0.0046792049,
-0.0213219374,
-0.0162578281,
-0.0187703799,
-0.0246035345,
0.0498272963,
0.02370077,
0.0303433258,
-0.0089294231,
0.0300139878,
-0.0168369114,
0.0016943521,
-0.0113638993,
0.0463052765,
0.0170696266,
0.0272708889,
0.0375086293,
0.0149600133,
-0.0291281976,
-0.0083519705,
-0.098800987,
-0.0081034359,
0.0122485561,
0.0047770543,
-0.019399222,
-0.018771477,
0.0409892276,
0.0189318731,
-0.0037040396,
0.0193736125,
0.0709963217,
0.0446227156,
-0.0298990514,
-0.0169150922,
0.0075176978,
-0.0507941917,
-0.0027965044,
0.0747853741,
0.0370952301,
0.006426448,
-0.022435829,
-0.0488533005,
-0.0181739777,
-0.002822025,
0.0268381592,
0.0590828918,
-0.0017887458,
-0.0092784017,
-0.091797851,
-0.0502624363,
-0.0019199594,
-0.0122170579,
0.0307618622,
-0.0209545754,
-0.0228849053,
0.0955506563,
-0.0025505212,
-0.0295885708,
-0.0521842726,
-0.0034895123,
-0.0373791195,
0.0192131978,
0.0252542272,
-6.249340127e-33,
0.0053861174,
-0.0730707347,
-0.0213539191,
0.011751743,
0.0490019396,
0.0287628453,
-0.0222826842,
-0.0277926326,
0.0026474462,
0.0457113758,
0.0120059755,
0.033793699,
0.0206015464,
0.0156242307,
0.0083574262,
-0.0224912595,
0.0240052156,
0.0467756502,
0.001898078,
0.0235796887,
0.0674357116,
0.0211521741,
0.0334805474,
-0.0749723241,
0.0947133526,
0.0135292318,
-0.0266242959,
0.0091003934,
-0.0337106511,
0.075125657,
-0.0030660494,
0.0089036822,
0.0276904311,
-0.0511646345,
-0.0043217819,
-0.0105375871,
-0.0535992384,
-0.0026031411,
0.047655575,
0.0305897277,
-0.0350552052,
-0.0447029583,
0.0518455692,
-0.0046814159,
-0.0046915566,
-0.0155523354,
0.0450640954,
-0.0310126208,
-0.0240815952,
0.0095428014,
-0.0321761444,
0.0474326424,
-0.0640119463,
0.0008577994,
0.0540665649,
0.039446488,
0.0084943166,
0.0115120811,
-0.0240574963,
-0.0124710761,
0.0376228094,
-0.01413,
0.0613603145,
-0.006772921,
-0.0307945143,
0.0669462159,
0.0718960315,
-0.0349881016,
-0.0723428503,
0.0267135557,
-0.0126177212,
0.0622813217,
0.1015045345,
0.0408480801,
0.0563505553,
0.0280280821,
-0.0717004463,
0.0332143195,
-0.0376533642,
-0.0006336621,
0.063165091,
0.0179512799,
-0.0781651363,
-0.0076013962,
-0.0238069464,
-0.0721518546,
-0.0277017951,
-0.0370511077,
0.0033263662,
-0.0283898599,
-0.1058611646,
0.0570533462,
0.0004804389,
-0.0659412369,
0.0303986873,
0.0220487155,
0.0102663878,
0.0159663223,
0.0161979254,
-0.0469441675,
0.0152977295,
-0.0202208832,
-0.0124716721,
0.0153119816,
0.0627255663,
0.0123199001,
0.04910345,
0.0027036362,
-0.0078227064,
-0.0217782333,
-0.0313767865,
-0.0392713994,
-0.026107017,
0.0012941549,
0.042300351,
0.0198332053,
-0.0508687496,
0.0287457388,
0.0122655099,
0.076136142,
0.0158688091,
0.0072796661,
-0.0510042682,
0.000195799,
0.0012632713,
-0.0740568265,
0.0193708669,
-0.0140117267,
0.0665431693,
-0.0283634793,
-0.0228493419,
-0.0132644167,
2.667e-7,
0.0697619617,
0.025166668,
0.0222778227,
-0.0408079773,
0.0166718327,
0.035439793,
0.0032069751,
-0.0204444267,
-0.0095918467,
-0.0169109814,
0.0207670387,
0.022824306,
0.0485529155,
0.0219609719,
0.0057197092,
-0.0331585445,
-0.051266823,
-0.0092204651,
-0.0090564741,
0.0442520082,
0.0454772227,
0.0504899509,
0.0226734262,
-0.0190122686,
0.0472957492,
-0.0312724151,
0.0053267307,
-0.0583320372,
0.0541179962,
0.0113617247,
0.0766398907,
-0.0338325575,
0.0314640142,
0.0163140148,
-0.0183087979,
0.0077176937,
-0.0147913117,
0.0575252548,
-0.0199876502,
0.0317638591,
-0.0449569561,
-0.0587586537,
0.0415281765,
-0.0660958588,
0.0815102383,
-0.0202693529,
-0.0685352311,
0.0302583482,
-0.0104849888,
-0.0367523357,
0.0043104626,
0.0154031068,
0.0180866141,
0.0243498329,
-0.029516302,
-0.0497241095,
0.0056246072,
-0.0605714768,
-0.0432224944,
0.0067072511,
-0.0089954268,
0.0178743303,
-0.029228149,
-0.0312452186,
0.0739433244,
-0.0422809087,
-0.0292890873,
2.678410026e-34,
0.0205418002,
0.0304350834,
-0.0016823858,
0.0241119191,
0.0516658761,
0.0044099777,
0.0157253835,
0.0121308491,
0.0621978864,
-0.0418269075,
0.010958923
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.08774v6 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.08774v6 | GPT-4 Technical Report | 2023-03-15T17:15:04 | 2024-03-04T06:01:33 | OpenAI, Josh Achiam, Steven Adler, Sandhini Agarwal, Lama Ahmad, Ilge Akkaya, Florencia Leoni Aleman, Diogo Almeida, Janko Altenschmidt, Sam Altman, Shyamal Anadkat, Red Avila, Igor Babuschkin, Suchir Balaji, Valerie Balcom, Paul Baltescu, Haiming Bao, Mohammad Bavarian, Jeff Belgum, Irwan Bello, Jake Berdine, Gabriel Bernadett-Shapiro, Christopher Berner, Lenny Bogdonoff, Oleg Boiko, Madelaine Boyd, Anna-Luisa Brakman, Greg Brockman, Tim Brooks, Miles Brundage, Kevin Button, Trevor Cai, Rosie Campbell, Andrew Cann, Brittany Carey, Chelsea Carlson, Rory Carmichael, Brooke Chan, Che Chang, Fotis Chantzis, Derek Chen, Sully Chen, Ruby Chen, Jason Chen, Mark Chen, Ben Chess, Chester Cho, Casey Chu, Hyung Won Chung, Dave Cummings, Jeremiah Currier, Yunxing Dai, Cory Decareaux, Thomas Degry, Noah Deutsch, Damien Deville, Arka Dhar, David Dohan, Steve Dowling, Sheila Dunning, Adrien Ecoffet, Atty Eleti, Tyna Eloundou, David Farhi, Liam Fedus, Niko Felix, Simón Posada Fishman, Juston Forte, Isabella Fulford, Leo Gao, Elie Georges, Christian Gibson, Vik Goel, Tarun Gogineni, Gabriel Goh, Rapha Gontijo-Lopes, Jonathan Gordon, Morgan Grafstein, Scott Gray, Ryan Greene, Joshua Gross, Shixiang Shane Gu, Yufei Guo, Chris Hallacy, Jesse Han, Jeff Harris, Yuchen He, Mike Heaton, Johannes Heidecke, Chris Hesse, Alan Hickey, Wade Hickey, Peter Hoeschele, Brandon Houghton, Kenny Hsu, Shengli Hu, Xin Hu, Joost Huizinga, Shantanu Jain, Shawn Jain, Joanne Jang, Angela Jiang, Roger Jiang, Haozhun Jin, Denny Jin, Shino Jomoto, Billie Jonn, Heewoo Jun, Tomer Kaftan, Łukasz Kaiser, Ali Kamali, Ingmar Kanitscheider, Nitish Shirish Keskar, Tabarak Khan, Logan Kilpatrick, Jong Wook Kim, Christina Kim, Yongjik Kim, Jan Hendrik Kirchner, Jamie Kiros, Matt Knight, Daniel Kokotajlo, Łukasz Kondraciuk, Andrew Kondrich, Aris Konstantinidis, Kyle Kosic, Gretchen Krueger, Vishal Kuo, Michael Lampe, Ikai Lan, Teddy Lee, Jan Leike, Jade Leung, Daniel Levy, Chak Ming Li, Rachel Lim, Molly Lin, Stephanie Lin, Mateusz Litwin, Theresa Lopez, Ryan Lowe, Patricia Lue, Anna Makanju, Kim Malfacini, Sam Manning, Todor Markov, Yaniv Markovski, Bianca Martin, Katie Mayer, Andrew Mayne, Bob McGrew, Scott Mayer McKinney, Christine McLeavey, Paul McMillan, Jake McNeil, David Medina, Aalok Mehta, Jacob Menick, Luke Metz, Andrey Mishchenko, Pamela Mishkin, Vinnie Monaco, Evan Morikawa, Daniel Mossing, Tong Mu, Mira Murati, Oleg Murk, David Mély, Ashvin Nair, Reiichiro Nakano, Rajeev Nayak, Arvind Neelakantan, Richard Ngo, Hyeonwoo Noh, Long Ouyang, Cullen O'Keefe, Jakub Pachocki, Alex Paino, Joe Palermo, Ashley Pantuliano, Giambattista Parascandolo, Joel Parish, Emy Parparita, Alex Passos, Mikhail Pavlov, Andrew Peng, Adam Perelman, Filipe de Avila Belbute Peres, Michael Petrov, Henrique Ponde de Oliveira Pinto, Michael, Pokorny, Michelle Pokrass, Vitchyr H. Pong, Tolly Powell, Alethea Power, Boris Power, Elizabeth Proehl, Raul Puri, Alec Radford, Jack Rae, Aditya Ramesh, Cameron Raymond, Francis Real, Kendra Rimbach, Carl Ross, Bob Rotsted, Henri Roussez, Nick Ryder, Mario Saltarelli, Ted Sanders, Shibani Santurkar, Girish Sastry, Heather Schmidt, David Schnurr, John Schulman, Daniel Selsam, Kyla Sheppard, Toki Sherbakov, Jessica Shieh, Sarah Shoker, Pranav Shyam, Szymon Sidor, Eric Sigler, Maddie Simens, Jordan Sitkin, Katarina Slama, Ian Sohl, Benjamin Sokolowsky, Yang Song, Natalie Staudacher, Felipe Petroski Such, Natalie Summers, Ilya Sutskever, Jie Tang, Nikolas Tezak, Madeleine B. Thompson, Phil Tillet, Amin Tootoonchian, Elizabeth Tseng, Preston Tuggle, Nick Turley, Jerry Tworek, Juan Felipe Cerón Uribe, Andrea Vallone, Arun Vijayvergiya, Chelsea Voss, Carroll Wainwright, Justin Jay Wang, Alvin Wang, Ben Wang, Jonathan Ward, Jason Wei, CJ Weinmann, Akila Welihinda, Peter Welinder, Jiayi Weng, Lilian Weng, Matt Wiethoff, Dave Willner, Clemens Winter, Samuel Wolrich, Hannah Wong, Lauren Workman, Sherwin Wu, Jeff Wu, Michael Wu, Kai Xiao, Tao Xu, Sarah Yoo, Kevin Yu, Qiming Yuan, Wojciech Zaremba, Rowan Zellers, Chong Zhang, Marvin Zhang, Shengjia Zhao, Tianhao Zheng, Juntang Zhuang, William Zhuk, Barret Zoph | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We report the development of GPT-4, a large-scale, multimodal model which can
accept image and text inputs and produce text outputs. While less capable than
humans in many real-world scenarios, GPT-4 exhibits human-level performance on
various professional and academic benchmarks, including passing a simulated bar
exam with a score around the top 10% of test takers. GPT-4 is a
Transformer-based model pre-trained to predict the next token in a document.
The post-training alignment process results in improved performance on measures
of factuality and adherence to desired behavior. A core component of this
project was developing infrastructure and optimization methods that behave
predictably across a wide range of scales. This allowed us to accurately
predict some aspects of GPT-4's performance based on models trained with no
more than 1/1,000th the compute of GPT-4. | [
0.0417910106,
0.0717919022,
0.0084958943,
0.0311921723,
-0.039996516,
-0.0091311662,
0.0088160345,
0.0107945511,
-0.0209251978,
-0.0401976705,
-0.0111813191,
-0.0073773623,
-0.0207853373,
0.0632276163,
0.037533056,
-0.0914402977,
0.0433151647,
-0.0107273599,
-0.0143265547,
0.0255481265,
0.032093849,
0.0069335909,
0.0126549797,
0.0311046895,
-0.0920447707,
-0.0273403469,
-0.0475882143,
0.0324603319,
0.0006875948,
0.0078813983,
-0.0150567424,
0.0484899804,
0.0201588012,
0.1004579961,
0.0000019076,
-0.0182878692,
-0.0130072786,
0.0217371844,
0.0143559976,
-0.0065242564,
0.0490461104,
-0.053044036,
-0.0259900913,
-0.0087975953,
-0.0337990075,
-0.021991061,
0.0638715923,
0.0941848308,
0.078292951,
0.0786050186,
-0.0337633789,
-0.0394341052,
0.0622912385,
-0.0166576952,
0.0025771654,
-0.0358003341,
0.0081728213,
-0.0137971137,
-0.0161542445,
0.0218685847,
-0.0264654309,
0.0238167718,
0.0272782221,
-0.0191593692,
0.0081779109,
0.0633650571,
-0.0232579261,
-0.034947522,
-0.0459173173,
0.0440209582,
-0.0228779968,
-0.0257463939,
-0.0106809083,
-0.0151083758,
-0.0079305861,
0.0207760539,
-0.0613630936,
-0.0015807803,
-0.0189443659,
-0.0074063605,
-0.058887627,
-0.0031722577,
-0.0007449479,
0.0153467292,
-0.0045486554,
0.0268297754,
0.0287375338,
-0.031126963,
-0.0188000072,
0.0267050024,
-0.0086174058,
-0.0521105044,
0.0378864184,
0.0218283702,
0.0185904,
0.0138072921,
-0.0606050715,
-0.0272611734,
0.0168387461,
-0.0063603031,
0.0046535395,
0.028309809,
-0.0145506952,
0.0654768646,
-0.0337440632,
0.0668981746,
-0.0679250434,
0.0256722141,
-0.0166016929,
-0.0160182286,
-0.043866396,
-0.0349024907,
-0.0423768647,
0.0153151751,
-0.0278429314,
-0.0641240925,
-0.0354636423,
0.028807858,
0.0234077647,
0.0275911111,
0.0355765522,
0.0200120211,
-0.0569833033,
-0.0347206332,
-0.0501031019,
0.0594214462,
-0.0127062341,
-0.0035755439,
0.0111853573,
-0.0069905482,
0.0174576472,
0.0381967425,
0.002752265,
-0.0154761914,
-0.0008925851,
0.0881744176,
-0.0490592718,
-0.0079035601,
-0.0118127782,
-0.0299054794,
-0.0166594684,
-0.0660070404,
0.025363002,
-0.0368867256,
0.0353529304,
0.0078572994,
-0.0151441107,
-0.0095910653,
-0.01118406,
0.0399411283,
-0.0089035099,
0.0929355323,
0.0021687762,
-0.0179866366,
0.0484905578,
0.0000800616,
-0.0232086759,
0.0320817903,
0.0191398598,
0.0931969658,
0.0302784648,
-0.0213613901,
0.0098981149,
0.0670599937,
-0.0116246119,
-0.028320672,
0.0303948447,
0.0075661484,
0.0305664744,
0.0646769032,
0.0492940433,
0.0614486858,
-0.0327795371,
-0.0197349694,
0.1188493222,
0.0578679368,
-0.0022216677,
0.0252804141,
0.0247403253,
-0.0173322521,
0.0045969146,
0.0186948907,
-0.0849573463,
0.0611348636,
0.0066909157,
0.0419080071,
0.0070478399,
0.0392890871,
-0.0075903768,
-0.0221465528,
0.0067809774,
-0.0042901156,
-0.0234841201,
-0.0517087802,
0.0456935987,
-0.0099277133,
-0.0979417935,
0.0268734079,
-0.049179133,
-0.0498113297,
-0.0208587646,
-0.0299531389,
0.0185774453,
0.0475242138,
0.0706833303,
-0.0099342093,
-0.0230743475,
-0.0139477374,
0.015440885,
0.0708133653,
0.0414063074,
0.0001468203,
-0.0320586041,
-0.0696036071,
-0.0361101292,
0.0134066287,
-0.0292610656,
0.0238921437,
0.0282584857,
0.0164889768,
0.0057750931,
-0.0138206985,
-0.0037283925,
0.0537988432,
0.0312193483,
-0.0402404144,
-0.0403615758,
0.0206749067,
0.0379742905,
-0.0023441282,
-0.0006083685,
-0.0032049951,
0.0364717618,
0.0180305485,
-0.0114294877,
0.0102757206,
-0.0360164568,
0.0117393117,
0.0493125468,
-0.065921858,
-0.0212562494,
0.0502873026,
-0.0500528999,
-0.0434015915,
-0.0076916758,
-0.0329250842,
0.0328866206,
-0.061729718,
-0.0003435702,
0.0367975421,
-0.0128464913,
-0.0129222712,
0.0366700366,
0.0165779535,
-0.0018520007,
-0.0275906213,
0.0121282153,
0.0346029773,
-0.0181892775,
-0.0140119782,
0.004912904,
0.00361295,
0.0195904598,
0.0445547253,
0.0119310031,
-0.0288369395,
-0.0285553094,
-0.11200241,
0.0055551473,
0.000359374,
0.0245426446,
0.0047526616,
0.0007693599,
-0.002137077,
-0.028144829,
-0.0281122513,
-0.0058424301,
0.0010978577,
-0.0090544289,
0.0620281585,
0.0214345772,
0.0197958425,
-0.0212544296,
-0.0191858504,
-0.0266445223,
0.0223255884,
0.0330244787,
-0.0056827031,
-0.0376604758,
-0.0256820787,
0.0013705693,
0.0429987572,
0.0012518587,
-0.0222517028,
0.0314726271,
-0.0119452439,
0.0530797169,
0.0697272718,
0.0364885218,
0.0069865449,
-0.030562425,
0.021625746,
-0.0412709862,
0.0227792934,
-0.0288715009,
-0.0092041465,
-0.0059146602,
-0.0076473909,
0.0118773216,
0.0463545546,
0.0024889321,
0.0328993015,
-0.0756474063,
0.0349360816,
0.0098960176,
-0.0196427554,
-0.0196983982,
0.0066835647,
-0.041466672,
0.0216168184,
-0.0280622449,
-0.0753842667,
0.0494398326,
-0.0473455526,
-0.0163759924,
-0.0042755669,
0.0346883833,
0.0005145011,
0.0640123934,
0.0447623394,
0.0143516473,
0.0022148597,
-0.021303758,
-0.0780781582,
0.0187047776,
0.0328764953,
-0.0058733211,
0.0348973908,
-0.0236031469,
0.0363113619,
-0.0408868864,
-0.0462743342,
-0.0174038298,
-0.0256741457,
0.0034009232,
-0.0043638558,
-0.000279852,
-0.035239175,
-0.0728605911,
0.0263171326,
0.0017468465,
0.0672316402,
-0.0382907055,
-0.0386248045,
-0.0361201428,
0.05494247,
0.0571690127,
-0.0076201009,
-0.0239486545,
-0.0366290063,
-0.0510823056,
0.0696913302,
0.0181757975,
-0.0326138139,
-0.0663785487,
-0.0209083799,
0.001025517,
-0.0395760983,
-0.0086490791,
0.0060507338,
0.0233507566,
-0.057121288,
0.0193849578,
0.088391766,
0.0175957344,
-0.0372124836,
-0.0498574413,
0.0120044919,
0.008592613,
0.0048084524,
0.0262075234,
-0.0837599039,
-0.04127701,
0.003229178,
0.0121663511,
0.0200238414,
0.0124199465,
0.001802408,
-0.0790537074,
0.0801481828,
0.007813273,
-0.0239985287,
-0.0350084938,
-0.0119139487,
0.0035030255,
-0.0350362472,
-0.0091955476,
0.0136834523,
-0.0012858349,
-0.0108770132,
0.0043831086,
-0.0267640892,
0.0153381126,
-0.0078703174,
-0.0147176748,
-0.0314190648,
0.0632080063,
0.0298678298,
-0.0128159784,
-0.0517812707,
0.0177689251,
0.0193169974,
0.0211326387,
0.003585045,
0.070074603,
-0.0550408177,
0.0192348845,
-0.0508528985,
0.0224251784,
-0.0014720967,
-0.0179975703,
0.0107536912,
0.1045090705,
0.0042712735,
-0.0163073,
-0.0581190027,
-0.021594435,
-0.0269303825,
0.0463718772,
-0.0039635822,
-0.0273942612,
-0.094079338,
-0.0324983895,
0.0422290526,
-0.0493267551,
-0.0076496727,
-0.0470438041,
-0.0065169227,
-0.0122592486,
-0.0708284825,
-0.0286712237,
0.0008779361,
0.0619422272,
-0.0009740006,
-0.0233239066,
0.0055916375,
0.0030968066,
-0.061059162,
0.0230905283,
-0.0063239071,
0.0145696551,
-0.0801414549,
0.0173750892,
0.0299701672,
-0.0239183865,
-0.0232396852,
0.0469826758,
-0.0481793024,
-0.0495561585,
-0.016517859,
0.07120727,
0.0301139355,
0.0369013697,
0.010797116,
-0.0105461376,
0.0409315117,
0.0330309607,
-0.0536014438,
-0.023405036,
0.0248757806,
-0.0386231057,
-0.0351661034,
-0.0090551944,
-0.0109018628,
0.0100500546,
-0.005153947,
-0.0214667805,
-0.0155896731,
-0.033023145,
0.0160504542,
0.0043809051,
0.0448259227,
-0.0354319885,
0.012767693,
-0.0218234155,
0.0066370852,
-0.0116728507,
-0.0045450092,
-0.0254539102,
-0.0017294919,
0.038932953,
0.0298116039,
-0.0103178089,
-0.0064203148,
-0.014405624,
0.0267241932,
-0.0487775691,
-0.0310358442,
0.0138990786,
0.01186225,
0.013431659,
-0.0178386997,
-0.0033328526,
-0.0229612831,
-0.0112111326,
0.0423849076,
-0.0355438367,
0.0784328058,
0.0385016464,
0.0178179368,
0.0159602631,
0.0394870006,
-0.0683954731,
-0.0120489039,
-0.0700660944,
0.029337056,
0.0258295201,
-0.0055214702,
0.024931021,
-0.0665905476,
-0.0271688607,
-0.0019945605,
0.0454112887,
0.0232064072,
-0.000828472,
0.0163824297,
0.0172847919,
0.0046430654,
-0.0207918119,
0.0602008104,
-0.0160103422,
0.0202145074,
-0.0082520423,
-0.0284645502,
-0.0541040413,
-0.0211039875,
0.033042796,
0.0009833216,
0.0010977741,
-0.0242739152,
-0.0236196462,
-0.034770228,
0.0275524687,
0.0418818444,
-0.0245593879,
-0.0195317063,
0.0580534786,
0.0694754347,
-0.0024152675,
-0.0331606455,
-0.0099121444,
0.0153897433,
0.01107038,
-0.0071652299,
-0.0146937165,
-5.908412235e-33,
-0.0236830972,
-0.0338788778,
0.037154071,
0.0260997526,
-0.0293083061,
-0.0059981439,
0.0003249777,
-0.0281372033,
0.0269990303,
-0.0020812466,
-0.0159592461,
-0.010283675,
0.0238226578,
0.015884513,
0.0182632208,
0.0240539704,
0.0379745513,
-0.047990758,
-0.0395699516,
0.0252042338,
0.0174714979,
0.0246307757,
0.0461250693,
-0.0455040224,
-0.014098621,
0.0224621017,
-0.0442278273,
-0.027964076,
-0.0106719285,
0.0543321855,
-0.0322949365,
0.0107987113,
0.012445868,
-0.0601963066,
-0.0033287597,
0.0641464591,
-0.0641852543,
-0.0028742824,
0.0092798052,
0.0599216856,
-0.0572421141,
-0.0202503521,
0.0454542488,
-0.0590807721,
-0.0233712234,
-0.0414150096,
0.0549302101,
0.0108004063,
0.0028247358,
-0.0204148442,
-0.091148816,
0.0260885973,
-0.0041715819,
0.0084995124,
0.0341767743,
0.026911309,
0.0497100987,
0.016890252,
-0.0725450888,
0.004969113,
-0.0227665082,
0.023087861,
0.0747296512,
0.0047690198,
-0.0028773828,
0.0378919244,
0.0153729254,
-0.0389927104,
-0.0174312908,
0.0008595018,
0.0172342099,
0.0459028259,
0.0771827698,
0.0604656227,
0.0293517988,
0.0028379068,
-0.0289543811,
0.0531297065,
-0.0018099695,
0.0467459187,
0.0214192271,
0.0125744976,
-0.0184466764,
0.0286886077,
0.0140056126,
-0.0257885251,
-0.0141612412,
-0.0293095857,
0.0287301056,
0.0318020321,
0.0196800008,
0.0521389581,
0.0603604801,
-0.0256269146,
0.0098446673,
-0.011305375,
-0.0292520523,
0.0499683283,
-0.0117044561,
0.027294416,
-0.0465243161,
-0.0330378115,
0.0264737178,
0.027913373,
0.0131878396,
0.0066479929,
0.032047011,
0.0355623513,
-0.0807836354,
0.0049156868,
-0.0161942039,
0.0167309828,
0.0067177187,
0.0050092153,
0.0378318243,
-0.0136141852,
-0.015356373,
-0.0077651646,
-0.0201471113,
0.0083609596,
-0.050114166,
-0.0266849864,
0.0077038868,
0.0146053433,
-0.0248123724,
0.0205337033,
-0.0287530534,
-0.0251636095,
0.0067745983,
-0.0604671091,
-0.0121211,
0.0803183019,
2.489e-7,
0.0619639382,
0.0477178954,
0.0635617375,
-0.0041613705,
0.0123795448,
0.0315244906,
-0.0141494311,
0.0361358561,
0.0033976084,
-0.0328115933,
0.0433768369,
-0.004567923,
0.0391200334,
0.0101945624,
-0.0868428424,
-0.0182641372,
-0.0541489758,
-0.0144120082,
-0.0672666579,
0.0224617012,
0.0384561457,
0.0884140059,
-0.0213365164,
-0.0326975174,
0.0182496272,
-0.0242773648,
0.0866699964,
0.0093819881,
0.0046787127,
-0.0111772381,
0.0267205127,
-0.0153614525,
-0.0393027365,
0.0327158384,
-0.0077776704,
-0.0181091595,
0.0497519188,
0.0649663582,
-0.0296232421,
-0.0015916493,
0.0006509613,
-0.0068560285,
-0.0095543033,
-0.0808645114,
0.0651695803,
-0.0152775375,
-0.0050024129,
-0.0154984277,
-0.0752600655,
-0.0108989077,
0.0018718471,
-0.0160806924,
-0.0332041755,
0.042097006,
0.0398647636,
-0.0036471398,
-0.0096706236,
-0.064805761,
0.000029969,
-0.0045807739,
-0.0539246909,
-0.0181005448,
-0.0770300776,
-0.0213852804,
0.0544140823,
-0.0626110286,
-0.0691905469,
2.263721792e-34,
0.0350520052,
-0.0158766974,
0.0368968435,
-0.0069122049,
0.0233949553,
0.0007164563,
0.0079542948,
0.019657895,
-0.0064627007,
-0.0648127273,
-0.0323976353
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.08721v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.08721v1 | Artificial Influence: An Analysis Of AI-Driven Persuasion | 2023-03-15T16:05:11 | 2023-03-15T16:05:11 | Matthew Burtell, Thomas Woodside | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Persuasion is a key aspect of what it means to be human, and is central to
business, politics, and other endeavors. Advancements in artificial
intelligence (AI) have produced AI systems that are capable of persuading
humans to buy products, watch videos, click on search results, and more. Even
systems that are not explicitly designed to persuade may do so in practice. In
the future, increasingly anthropomorphic AI systems may form ongoing
relationships with users, increasing their persuasive power. This paper
investigates the uncertain future of persuasive AI systems. We examine ways
that AI could qualitatively alter our relationship to and views regarding
persuasion by shifting the balance of persuasive power, allowing personalized
persuasion to be deployed at scale, powering misinformation campaigns, and
changing the way humans can shape their own discourse. We consider ways
AI-driven persuasion could differ from human-driven persuasion. We warn that
ubiquitous highlypersuasive AI systems could alter our information environment
so significantly so as to contribute to a loss of human control of our own
future. In response, we examine several potential responses to AI-driven
persuasion: prohibition, identification of AI agents, truthful AI, and legal
remedies. We conclude that none of these solutions will be airtight, and that
individuals and governments will need to take active steps to guard against the
most pernicious effects of persuasive AI. | [
0.066321373,
0.0977913737,
-0.0125457132,
-0.0409733504,
-0.0314431638,
-0.0307901874,
0.0378849097,
-0.0196107272,
0.0464981608,
-0.0063692518,
-0.0196188875,
-0.0014860108,
0.0115246931,
0.0165325049,
0.0340642594,
-0.0401041172,
-0.0029481216,
0.0167148728,
0.0603353642,
-0.0051011806,
0.019003801,
0.0144464765,
0.0282998886,
0.0431075469,
-0.0345298424,
-0.069961004,
0.0436901264,
-0.010810093,
-0.0106173474,
-0.0510196239,
0.003879877,
0.024880873,
0.0287574176,
0.0227866396,
0.0000019443,
-0.0470248237,
0.0418786556,
0.0081271976,
-0.0582887307,
0.0244269595,
0.0677403286,
0.0135662025,
-0.0020288553,
0.0151066156,
-0.0473085195,
0.0542869307,
0.0100299018,
0.0461333543,
0.0031523213,
0.0458030328,
-0.0206660926,
0.0130367484,
0.0398691967,
0.0039974554,
-0.0063519212,
-0.0000630857,
0.0040971804,
-0.0532813966,
-0.005469616,
0.0025021373,
0.0638337955,
0.0356633104,
-0.0241983235,
-0.0050346632,
-0.0270915031,
0.0066953441,
0.0006252822,
-0.0362365432,
-0.0230296534,
0.0400739573,
0.0242490098,
-0.0149405198,
0.0287558995,
0.0393596552,
0.0603593178,
0.0381191075,
-0.01279693,
0.0474928655,
-0.0119421231,
-0.0132719642,
0.0185728036,
-0.0009677372,
0.033847034,
0.0614854991,
0.0094304476,
0.0155565068,
-0.0091697611,
-0.0310797133,
0.0588259734,
-0.0221298058,
0.0596610159,
-0.049906224,
0.0117638428,
-0.0016336326,
-0.0358797349,
0.0006835234,
-0.0437127054,
0.010187502,
0.005461982,
-0.0869737044,
0.0175031126,
-0.0040577785,
-0.0041317125,
-0.0008226537,
0.0543720163,
-0.0209957957,
-0.0443473198,
0.0288058985,
-0.0000444428,
0.0441280231,
0.0078995479,
0.0038361663,
-0.0086595621,
-0.0004367907,
0.0088915378,
-0.0075431205,
0.0100026708,
0.024387395,
-0.0923484489,
0.0416151658,
-0.0840851218,
0.0536956862,
-0.0012795338,
-0.0306177475,
-0.0187688153,
0.0121198827,
-0.0487324856,
0.0253436882,
-0.0095664319,
-0.0150025589,
0.005859036,
0.027628297,
0.0069119623,
0.003121885,
0.0188962519,
0.0547983833,
0.0116190258,
-0.0210050251,
-0.0144774318,
-0.0212084688,
-0.0014357979,
-0.0501843542,
-0.0048278198,
0.0042680507,
-0.0136152646,
-0.0141160879,
-0.0133319031,
-0.0851595625,
-0.0021200967,
-0.0068176254,
-0.0212468579,
0.0582992211,
0.0023503508,
0.01517272,
0.0368507281,
0.0469771363,
-0.0392974056,
-0.0134915775,
0.0073427637,
0.0960595459,
0.0407225229,
0.0184416808,
0.0914134085,
0.0090975296,
-0.0076816198,
0.0189463757,
0.0479676127,
0.0188553911,
-0.0742353797,
-0.0238068551,
-0.0574346818,
0.0363487191,
-0.0075408015,
0.0303345025,
0.0851955339,
0.0394111276,
-0.0742283389,
0.0086441403,
-0.0000111479,
0.0037424872,
-0.0015396287,
-0.0098780813,
-0.0307141952,
-0.0428461209,
-0.0387315527,
-0.0552838035,
-0.0239581428,
0.0188874416,
-0.0559779741,
-0.024581423,
0.0199946761,
-0.0457008108,
0.0497261435,
0.0435295366,
-0.0091366945,
-0.0087327575,
0.0069666672,
-0.0479617678,
0.0008849729,
0.0063479017,
-0.0225634798,
-0.0623854436,
0.0003050097,
0.0367003158,
0.0206638593,
0.0004246635,
0.0342614986,
-0.0491065308,
0.0026538966,
0.0648726672,
0.0157308038,
-0.0366504043,
-0.0557062663,
0.0371082835,
0.0045762807,
-0.004455335,
0.0055553094,
0.0473496392,
-0.0202855989,
0.0225851554,
-0.0145033915,
0.0215443261,
-0.0147246663,
-0.0044265999,
0.0351904035,
-0.0471795462,
-0.0558441244,
0.044318825,
0.0202390123,
0.039910607,
-0.0092048291,
0.0095997173,
0.0612615198,
-0.0031583186,
-0.0292751696,
-0.0155380564,
0.0356415808,
0.1325720549,
0.0027502624,
-0.0479873605,
-0.0504130423,
0.0193481911,
0.0285426378,
0.0452986658,
0.0593366213,
-0.0393747911,
0.0325083211,
-0.0037319416,
-0.0034520493,
-0.0258879121,
-0.0142727569,
0.0055494336,
0.0134539753,
0.0037426839,
-0.0853908509,
0.0102798333,
-0.0339305364,
0.0238074698,
0.0206841677,
-0.0132821258,
-0.0278695039,
-0.0132774115,
0.0144564668,
0.0744216144,
-0.0687619671,
-0.0226428714,
0.0088323969,
-0.015747318,
-0.0689406469,
0.0094636641,
0.0072739199,
-0.0217694286,
0.0040747533,
0.0092987968,
0.0138950441,
-0.0379402936,
-0.0525008664,
-0.028614454,
0.0320554487,
0.0118040694,
0.0093371458,
-0.030902924,
-0.003515657,
0.0413395241,
-0.031700965,
-0.0139383469,
0.0594685897,
-0.0500820242,
-0.028892966,
-0.0213776138,
-0.0539015979,
0.0184681453,
-0.0176619757,
0.0033425181,
0.0208151489,
0.0179854594,
0.0073632742,
0.0534443147,
0.0426879153,
0.0690695941,
0.0448347516,
0.0852050483,
-0.0347596593,
-0.0180178154,
-0.0141273448,
0.0534817874,
-0.0353367105,
0.0053964197,
0.0108015742,
-0.0390903801,
0.0338722132,
0.0343700685,
0.0135943554,
0.1115712076,
-0.0060095601,
-0.0640848279,
0.0077556344,
-0.0670099705,
-0.0258108694,
0.0428186096,
-0.0103895795,
-0.063914746,
0.043402411,
0.0041047176,
0.0464153178,
0.0324727558,
-0.0206516124,
0.0434430279,
0.0225764289,
0.0076940162,
0.0321447812,
0.0316306762,
-0.0004449532,
-0.001870683,
-0.0365272574,
0.0145717012,
-0.0576071441,
0.0146200117,
-0.0198384207,
0.002265021,
0.0473528095,
-0.0519256964,
-0.0446490534,
-0.0639745146,
-0.0213184878,
-0.0380741879,
0.0231183451,
-0.0053507327,
-0.0223720707,
-0.0559025295,
0.0525663793,
0.0042242864,
0.0215299502,
-0.0272064079,
0.0115750693,
-0.0417607874,
0.0008359019,
0.0128186019,
0.0316276141,
0.0131900162,
-0.0072936625,
0.0090868948,
-0.0111324601,
-0.0442190766,
-0.0207374953,
-0.0255578011,
-0.0041357884,
0.0140186753,
0.0401498526,
-0.0027380129,
-0.0018372826,
0.0045718406,
0.039248459,
0.0285646394,
0.0011558111,
-0.0526084751,
0.0432323627,
0.0259005856,
-0.0349978618,
-0.0073189433,
0.0099298907,
-0.0826421902,
0.0201122947,
0.0072483118,
0.0235635079,
-0.0744852424,
0.0049974192,
-0.0010649363,
-0.0460503995,
0.0303822551,
0.0123163108,
0.0919632316,
-0.0330829956,
-0.0116583453,
-0.0411419198,
-0.0066303522,
0.0088063553,
-0.0567075461,
0.016417712,
0.0012934755,
-0.019278083,
-0.013716653,
0.0413813032,
-0.0068163932,
-0.0388962887,
0.0244141817,
0.1092910618,
0.0690470263,
-0.0301653035,
-0.0579705201,
0.0153646916,
0.0479022004,
-0.0125162741,
0.0156067098,
0.0611534715,
-0.0198392496,
0.0141071985,
-0.0392656513,
0.0181229189,
0.018492924,
0.0032329166,
0.0330693312,
0.0474560037,
-0.0277137328,
-0.0615868643,
-0.0088071441,
-0.0403596312,
0.0553081781,
0.025105428,
-0.0338659808,
-0.0366478078,
-0.00060654,
-0.0509326346,
0.0330750234,
0.0272319652,
-0.0320197307,
-0.0417832211,
0.0016871518,
-0.0316213332,
-0.0472248495,
-0.0568334721,
-0.0348007381,
-0.0076032248,
0.0609488487,
-0.0273466092,
0.0192939173,
0.0363293886,
0.0439110734,
0.0255703386,
-0.0222138464,
0.025088992,
-0.0165632162,
-0.0311551467,
-0.0415452272,
-0.0027500386,
0.029902881,
-0.0176603552,
0.0511925071,
-0.0212672129,
0.0307602249,
0.033335343,
0.0247078724,
0.0590515397,
0.0019939188,
0.0087429537,
0.047814399,
0.0314116403,
-0.0271484423,
-0.0016822281,
0.0679233521,
0.0019115165,
-0.017214926,
-0.0052367109,
-0.0036469228,
0.0352063403,
0.0093847159,
-0.0674871728,
-0.066873692,
0.0104530985,
0.0490985811,
0.0536176041,
0.0076794717,
-0.0335843377,
0.0290141907,
0.0156449955,
-0.0384553559,
0.0093910638,
-0.0158457942,
0.0158951338,
-0.0295529384,
0.0160482973,
0.0232991222,
0.003834181,
0.0214903094,
-0.0323343575,
-0.026713457,
-0.0336450338,
0.0318217836,
-0.0257682689,
0.0905576572,
-0.0074859555,
-0.0064004003,
0.0060544494,
0.1147141606,
-0.0166014973,
0.0403284132,
0.0051095807,
0.0164169166,
-0.0197510011,
-0.0067609875,
-0.0110940225,
0.060315799,
-0.0466071628,
-0.0687618479,
0.0371603929,
0.0192696191,
-0.02255968,
0.0444921814,
-0.0072779153,
0.0216584299,
0.0028851756,
-0.001899023,
-0.004337416,
0.0084183533,
0.0008653151,
-0.0517448075,
-0.0024747164,
-0.0559625439,
0.0525845177,
0.0047614747,
-0.104488939,
0.0750414878,
0.0008808897,
-0.0267383121,
-0.0026597935,
-0.0559805408,
-0.0254636295,
0.0079092402,
0.0121433195,
-0.0213141087,
-0.0555622019,
-0.0097974017,
-0.027369434,
0.0072462778,
-0.015100061,
-0.0564272813,
-0.0152835213,
-0.00947526,
-0.0265160874,
0.0018996221,
-0.0210427307,
0.0317867436,
-0.0463248231,
-0.0033353956,
-0.0145975742,
-5.440144509e-33,
0.0357333608,
-0.0257620532,
-0.0218248516,
0.033426214,
-0.0300842319,
-0.0150134498,
0.0190938693,
0.0335795246,
-0.034821827,
0.044233799,
-0.0292765833,
-0.0054237954,
-0.0041965004,
-0.0440407544,
-0.0205988865,
-0.0352155715,
0.0213944782,
-0.0284745339,
0.0050518434,
0.0534507483,
0.0211459491,
-0.0101891691,
-0.0530150384,
-0.1198918447,
0.0696159974,
0.0004367972,
-0.0657850057,
-0.0411277898,
-0.0289375708,
-0.0210632998,
0.0073517296,
0.0481196269,
0.0031391513,
-0.0296292547,
0.0177756324,
0.1139628589,
0.0131558655,
-0.0223131925,
0.0130314631,
-0.0411180481,
0.0013100988,
-0.0516484305,
-0.0283203945,
-0.0316934958,
-0.0661534145,
0.0514487736,
0.0036262278,
-0.006666854,
0.0099363727,
-0.0007633704,
-0.0637776256,
-0.0333520994,
-0.0345869921,
-0.0031775478,
-0.0219817162,
0.0830231979,
-0.0139660491,
0.0171295889,
-0.0619669296,
0.0504651032,
0.0182173327,
-0.0508865304,
0.0138274422,
-0.0351132639,
0.0277165193,
0.0480575636,
0.057011798,
0.0004401735,
-0.07409174,
-0.0177968275,
-0.0069279303,
0.0398132764,
0.0306493044,
0.0295964144,
-0.0016484843,
-0.0796074793,
-0.0130450064,
0.0107589643,
0.0632953867,
-0.0089412974,
0.0223741625,
-0.0397291444,
-0.0656160116,
-0.0229472555,
-0.0028372859,
-0.0947585404,
-0.0324765369,
-0.0386857614,
0.000693616,
0.0133755747,
-0.045029711,
0.0297106635,
-0.0286675319,
-0.0622312017,
0.0070725172,
-0.0032065229,
0.0242976714,
-0.0219928976,
0.0136558143,
-0.0348521732,
-0.0125188017,
0.0006150767,
-0.0230368059,
-0.0140061351,
0.0723295212,
0.0192980599,
0.0280399863,
0.0006311126,
0.0015652466,
-0.0244695581,
-0.0094141224,
0.0345342793,
0.0262333918,
-0.0208353922,
0.0257348195,
0.0283427294,
0.0187474471,
-0.0304525606,
-0.0042201653,
0.0333288833,
-0.0096464027,
0.012219891,
-0.0291259941,
0.010455016,
-0.0437739268,
-0.0206670724,
-0.069472827,
0.0233232919,
0.0202543158,
-0.0822580308,
-0.017601572,
-0.097961843,
2.622e-7,
-0.0265253633,
0.0427611023,
0.0001690231,
0.0208079293,
0.0000192252,
0.07665544,
0.030529052,
0.0283026155,
-0.0048560239,
-0.0603739992,
0.0051832297,
-0.026073087,
0.0081659108,
0.005345799,
-0.0405635722,
-0.01243582,
-0.008031534,
0.0097284419,
-0.0480166003,
0.0476918072,
0.0395338722,
0.0317344069,
0.0402098298,
-0.0304245949,
-0.0161879547,
0.0005061041,
0.0150226997,
-0.035983786,
0.0296516642,
-0.0246232878,
-0.0190635752,
0.0172975808,
-0.0149517525,
0.0164254755,
-0.0182149522,
0.0019063661,
-0.0608897842,
0.0604226068,
-0.01853274,
-0.0233026017,
-0.0109707657,
0.0033974857,
0.0265188813,
0.0273038372,
0.0473622642,
0.0005670661,
-0.0532389022,
-0.0343176723,
0.0094882185,
-0.0041124253,
-0.0040892153,
0.0158201344,
-0.0272484403,
-0.0388690941,
0.0127748204,
0.0170153808,
0.0428344384,
-0.0545667708,
0.0568453483,
-0.003486108,
0.0243769512,
-0.0435437039,
0.0108344639,
0.0383425131,
-0.0137804104,
-0.0084641036,
0.0220860243,
1.962344096e-34,
0.0165753849,
-0.0380395539,
0.0212759171,
-0.0132745448,
0.0298326593,
0.0437027402,
0.0004781453,
-0.0446726978,
0.0438150018,
-0.0624090582,
-0.0079674935
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.08697v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.08697v1 | Mirror: A Natural Language Interface for Data Querying, Summarization, and Visualization | 2023-03-15T15:31:51 | 2023-03-15T15:31:51 | Canwen Xu, Julian McAuley, Penghan Wang | cs.DB | cs.DB, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SE | We present Mirror, an open-source platform for data exploration and analysis
powered by large language models. Mirror offers an intuitive natural language
interface for querying databases, and automatically generates executable SQL
commands to retrieve relevant data and summarize it in natural language. In
addition, users can preview and manually edit the generated SQL commands to
ensure the accuracy of their queries. Mirror also generates visualizations to
facilitate understanding of the data. Designed with flexibility and human input
in mind, Mirror is suitable for both experienced data analysts and
non-technical professionals looking to gain insights from their data. | [
-0.0168381613,
0.0849070027,
-0.0370578319,
0.0068759178,
-0.0475646108,
0.0066032079,
-0.0054733064,
-0.0150215169,
0.0068861288,
0.0028695466,
0.0226166565,
0.0277922377,
-0.0062696435,
0.0985435098,
0.0188933816,
-0.0893285722,
0.0422831066,
0.0032299359,
0.0006306469,
0.0485980995,
-0.0134437727,
0.03104995,
-0.0015783702,
0.0161561612,
0.0225993916,
-0.005140021,
-0.0354201309,
-0.0102263652,
-0.0223335773,
-0.0496131666,
-0.0300407894,
0.0321603678,
0.0191496741,
0.0190952476,
0.0000022829,
-0.0755990744,
-0.0255767051,
0.0193999875,
-0.0277537927,
0.0274472237,
0.0852789208,
-0.0168683846,
0.0386458486,
0.0375950038,
-0.0368745327,
-0.0417070873,
0.0416431092,
0.0215104632,
0.0741341859,
0.0036822457,
-0.0158466417,
-0.0462246314,
-0.0464485995,
-0.0052112816,
-0.0033797999,
0.0101194866,
-0.0017842054,
0.0364386141,
0.0599606335,
0.0308319312,
0.0090194764,
0.0065945685,
-0.0193236526,
-0.039421685,
0.0095401388,
0.0165693071,
0.0015281807,
-0.0186851677,
-0.0090840012,
0.0059464541,
0.0379224941,
-0.00585117,
0.0144953616,
0.0006576786,
0.0111691132,
0.0233325809,
-0.0726695284,
0.0314818844,
0.0178593379,
-0.0022942896,
-0.0400092453,
-0.0139116496,
0.0002458327,
-0.0215141661,
-0.0713169277,
-0.0092705898,
-0.0096159903,
-0.005196135,
0.0278844275,
-0.0408088341,
-0.0006991366,
-0.0308875069,
0.0008364943,
0.0350764915,
-0.0529028699,
0.0109080868,
0.0132704014,
-0.0780170709,
0.0492551811,
-0.0109787323,
0.009469226,
0.0101588257,
-0.0281800088,
0.0527145937,
0.0246929508,
-0.0003080784,
0.0320511162,
0.0060725813,
-0.0078098229,
-0.0438596196,
-0.0215820987,
-0.0104045225,
-0.0493273996,
-0.0074510546,
-0.0763742402,
0.009809955,
-0.0413420312,
0.0158694368,
-0.0298453532,
-0.0039376151,
0.0201997831,
0.0351256654,
0.0141640985,
0.0399008952,
-0.0527237616,
-0.0068971254,
-0.026167497,
0.0071099978,
-0.0057036588,
-0.0811898708,
-0.0040522506,
-0.0263357721,
0.026490001,
-0.0027186919,
0.0061445595,
0.0690263733,
0.0456843227,
0.026069738,
-0.040912196,
-0.0279187541,
-0.0000207243,
-0.007306668,
-0.0438164547,
-0.0535883196,
0.0384720489,
0.015329456,
-0.0267645307,
-0.0034310785,
0.0072487406,
0.0432919748,
-0.0198532213,
0.0395310931,
-0.0954470932,
0.0180737283,
-0.0016805446,
-0.0327564962,
0.0432208069,
0.032052502,
-0.0065638712,
-0.0132004805,
0.0137844579,
-0.0405349694,
-0.0071991258,
0.0104944203,
-0.0067905984,
-0.005986291,
-0.0772185624,
0.0375136137,
-0.0096366033,
0.0039381906,
-0.0211902522,
0.0321463682,
0.0168973655,
0.0151815955,
0.03576722,
0.0750486925,
0.0501258932,
0.0657574087,
0.0013688552,
0.0731790364,
-0.0123410095,
-0.0779855326,
-0.013629877,
0.0494601242,
0.0570167974,
0.0224859938,
-0.0212968979,
0.0207237881,
0.0183435902,
-0.0534796789,
-0.0206109397,
0.016304953,
0.0062082135,
0.0014711282,
0.0356372893,
-0.0035416817,
0.0289838277,
0.0240432229,
0.0258291848,
-0.0576997735,
-0.019039588,
-0.0058372114,
-0.0000239789,
0.083592698,
-0.0044035441,
-0.0600298606,
0.0114068026,
-0.0280148722,
0.0165581685,
0.0108173182,
0.0376362652,
0.0152805969,
-0.0255676508,
-0.004655594,
-0.0102751805,
0.0387982838,
0.0426261127,
-0.0137607614,
-0.0235554334,
0.0126960212,
-0.0145265246,
0.018080378,
-0.0683886483,
0.0168298874,
0.0220737141,
-0.0037188663,
0.0171524752,
-0.0017171655,
-0.0142787807,
0.0421089865,
-0.0039019403,
0.0499228574,
0.0565918088,
0.0165963601,
-0.029900495,
0.0559303164,
0.0870991722,
0.0389566906,
-0.0028544278,
-0.0503390729,
-0.0094103552,
-0.0157651398,
-0.0425732061,
-0.0251598228,
0.0379646569,
-0.067906931,
0.0217803959,
-0.0133119337,
-0.0240035523,
-0.0188339371,
0.0040948046,
-0.0301391091,
0.0310721789,
0.0172714666,
0.0116862468,
0.0118068121,
-0.0691277385,
0.0412348546,
-0.0411231592,
0.0444251001,
-0.0284547918,
-0.0188967343,
0.0166803841,
0.0169448443,
0.0008065367,
-0.0282510612,
0.020531375,
-0.0733631924,
0.0141709466,
0.009622233,
0.0213658437,
0.0338452496,
0.0565936975,
-0.0536790192,
-0.0230189674,
-0.0254994966,
-0.0340456218,
0.0386981294,
-0.0210098643,
0.0551639348,
0.0205678586,
-0.0025773498,
-0.0324163288,
-0.0183239058,
-0.0490538925,
0.035767898,
0.0511142835,
-0.0376420878,
-0.0040866784,
-0.0094986996,
-0.0066578882,
-0.0062686186,
0.0076515679,
0.0155619765,
0.0067279432,
-0.039885968,
-0.0065088789,
-0.004037057,
0.0060947714,
0.0308701042,
0.0446983203,
-0.0332562812,
-0.0285638738,
0.0106948437,
-0.0181798078,
0.0219982434,
0.0360973477,
-0.0535825491,
0.0524920374,
-0.0086230673,
0.0438761041,
-0.005181245,
-0.0002339363,
0.0263123251,
0.0093784984,
0.0389985926,
-0.0645838752,
0.0211854018,
-0.0089151058,
0.0367278755,
0.0133288372,
-0.047101289,
0.026054183,
-0.0000652178,
0.017827427,
-0.0538173914,
-0.0530298539,
-0.0687553212,
0.0790958181,
-0.0190517921,
0.0179886147,
-0.0203122627,
-0.038573049,
0.0290829651,
-0.0310877785,
0.0078895437,
-0.0338955931,
0.0654113591,
-0.0722181201,
-0.0184378363,
0.0073666535,
0.0327483192,
-0.0081685577,
-0.0354728289,
-0.0473346375,
-0.016724309,
0.0872689113,
-0.0241794512,
-0.0287722964,
0.0055706692,
0.0438017286,
0.0079781488,
0.0136808325,
-0.0268908553,
0.0166721623,
-0.0700703934,
0.0233662687,
0.0308137108,
0.004617454,
-0.0044205091,
0.0097188577,
0.005708768,
-0.0018374401,
-0.0108823646,
-0.0584402457,
-0.0025685285,
-0.0339939147,
-0.0378306806,
0.0175062139,
0.0300856959,
-0.0499971546,
-0.0480729453,
0.0434880294,
0.0810410529,
0.0257442798,
-0.0258273333,
0.0136130117,
-0.0282679722,
-0.0058339634,
0.0431241691,
0.0392367318,
-0.1312433481,
-0.016351996,
-0.0453195423,
0.0183430146,
0.0454922989,
-0.0413426794,
-0.0298152007,
-0.0927623436,
0.0649054796,
-0.0357678607,
-0.0449391566,
-0.0432657227,
-0.0768620893,
-0.0076650293,
-0.0691869929,
-0.0288366526,
0.0308986548,
-0.0431524552,
0.0172468256,
0.0011818612,
-0.0575658791,
-0.0336555727,
-0.0072837267,
-0.0854945853,
-0.0075794775,
0.036363177,
0.058809977,
-0.031776879,
0.0033271767,
-0.0038068616,
0.0296986625,
0.002941397,
-0.0368711054,
0.1011292562,
0.0410183482,
-0.0359710641,
-0.0622874573,
0.0195874572,
-0.0066525768,
0.0216139462,
0.005739247,
0.0704973489,
-0.0349025652,
0.0175768957,
-0.0332849436,
-0.0133960992,
0.0270124935,
0.0371341482,
0.0181269087,
-0.0070299222,
-0.0340862945,
-0.0340587795,
-0.0127690593,
-0.0241442136,
-0.046299573,
0.0456187315,
-0.0130865611,
-0.0447764695,
-0.0111430585,
-0.0084668063,
0.0640550628,
-0.0132399146,
0.0418309309,
0.0356293879,
0.0408135355,
-0.0247650594,
-0.0326834992,
0.0035972658,
-0.0035371014,
0.0451558046,
0.0199842136,
-0.0165833402,
0.0160236843,
0.0141233923,
-0.0268617608,
-0.006450884,
-0.0411903039,
-0.0116139408,
0.00722889,
0.0025435889,
0.0232150126,
-0.0494623967,
0.0091801919,
-0.0144974412,
-0.0419796184,
0.0430786908,
-0.0788844675,
-0.0751761571,
-0.0661988631,
-0.0032788506,
0.0141017241,
-0.0035269933,
-0.0195086673,
-0.0359382927,
-0.08207082,
-0.0180386305,
-0.0161794052,
-0.0158145521,
0.0465009175,
0.02555223,
0.0589238927,
0.0448718369,
-0.0233712327,
-0.0214775596,
-0.0003520343,
-0.0673426762,
-0.043132782,
-0.0183252674,
0.0219218694,
-0.0070507801,
-0.0098209735,
0.022699248,
0.0189694352,
-0.0132317459,
-0.0333052687,
-0.0561176986,
0.0617008843,
-0.0229957774,
-0.0374982022,
0.0012841906,
0.0092314295,
-0.0051126471,
-0.0087114796,
-0.0127689382,
0.0460029654,
0.0085178353,
0.008732209,
0.0057683745,
-0.0247076433,
0.0092191705,
0.0001976755,
-0.017594032,
-0.0532939583,
0.0532438457,
-0.0204935949,
0.0265692808,
-0.0321823992,
0.0216170624,
-0.0381210297,
0.0162825976,
-0.0189017393,
0.0318004973,
-0.0019593351,
0.0038049149,
0.0319007076,
-0.0119715557,
-0.0351564437,
-0.0809708461,
0.0627660677,
0.0085541857,
0.0096233115,
-0.0236045867,
-0.0468690842,
-0.0263440106,
-0.0088127712,
0.0289823525,
-0.0161353406,
-0.0405672528,
-0.0370546766,
-0.058277227,
-0.0147734825,
-0.0065989187,
0.0416735485,
-0.0141806845,
-0.0334929414,
0.0306041017,
0.0330951102,
0.0455525145,
-0.0329987966,
-0.0094106626,
0.0601186678,
-0.076390706,
-0.0407657735,
-0.0276904404,
-6.127053817e-33,
-0.0251426511,
-0.0653151199,
0.0267781578,
-0.0006048146,
0.0137312571,
-0.065519236,
-0.0404947288,
0.0053831907,
-0.0163297057,
0.0170925129,
0.0090871435,
0.0464811176,
0.0064720619,
0.0060331435,
0.0488350093,
-0.0067604738,
0.0403346494,
0.024407398,
0.017493194,
-0.0171325337,
0.033072263,
0.0266839061,
0.0260155518,
-0.0588211343,
0.0503409058,
0.0308166053,
0.008190698,
0.0168519933,
-0.0045011402,
0.0084578982,
0.0207183305,
0.033675272,
-0.0028760489,
-0.027534144,
-0.052773837,
0.0091052875,
-0.0326271839,
-0.0261304304,
0.0099140247,
0.0118506802,
-0.0139096519,
-0.0040864786,
0.0505436659,
0.0088823754,
-0.0417170189,
0.017676862,
0.0557274297,
-0.0283598378,
-0.0052849231,
0.0437198728,
-0.0049902499,
0.0357807316,
-0.0604420453,
0.0536195748,
0.00048673,
0.0278615337,
-0.0147844534,
0.0052676643,
0.0072627268,
0.0592242852,
0.0779189989,
0.0131503437,
0.044362478,
0.0159590691,
0.0678061247,
0.0260961577,
-0.0079819895,
-0.0504176989,
0.0115859956,
0.0751004964,
0.000665744,
0.0970077217,
0.0571946949,
0.0370684117,
0.0122739347,
-0.0107282298,
-0.0931999311,
0.0580503903,
-0.0556230918,
0.0378455333,
-0.0160306208,
0.027976444,
0.0037052089,
-0.0242292769,
-0.0226631351,
0.0216016825,
-0.0382281505,
-0.0066701211,
0.0140087735,
-0.0266212448,
-0.0192949641,
0.0426656306,
-0.0058204262,
-0.0039751977,
-0.0861729532,
0.012246063,
0.0051273187,
-0.0270537529,
-0.0111043807,
-0.0287684817,
-0.0209437124,
0.039549917,
-0.0238249004,
0.0301493332,
0.0297172442,
0.0406112261,
0.0059822351,
-0.0063866396,
-0.0784392133,
0.0123702763,
0.0045156344,
0.0158529151,
-0.0369907953,
-0.0115465475,
0.0227709953,
0.0023494409,
0.0228735674,
0.0742276087,
0.0302167367,
-0.0168727338,
-0.0450616442,
-0.0061736153,
-0.0119004585,
-0.0379987732,
0.0248677116,
-0.0066692103,
-0.0255524386,
-0.0256847814,
0.060307499,
-0.0226871986,
-0.00927414,
0.0242556557,
2.817e-7,
0.0880682394,
0.0758755654,
0.0586905964,
0.076996088,
0.0027123794,
0.0147963753,
-0.0065618134,
0.0054260273,
0.0204782821,
0.0197102726,
-0.005585358,
0.0057122596,
0.0245071556,
0.0661538616,
-0.0397562645,
-0.0020325079,
-0.0530038103,
-0.0390136242,
-0.1119040623,
0.0253584031,
0.1004848629,
0.0547446311,
0.000530553,
0.0367851704,
0.0001829671,
-0.0589906238,
0.009255561,
-0.0488232747,
0.0090174237,
0.0244415775,
0.0306364056,
0.0061281584,
-0.0015511033,
0.014633988,
-0.0254001971,
0.0047240928,
-0.0468274653,
0.0354933403,
-0.007028026,
0.0456264094,
0.0387668274,
-0.0742499754,
-0.001332597,
-0.0479348227,
0.0577222891,
-0.0659203157,
-0.0011030333,
-0.0051442059,
0.0005844297,
-0.0244868416,
0.0525531918,
-0.0355030596,
-0.0190189406,
-0.012797921,
0.007557604,
-0.0143707199,
-0.0021393329,
0.0017927082,
-0.0216064174,
0.0334561728,
-0.0027017386,
0.0108785182,
-0.0195966586,
0.0296973735,
0.0155989854,
0.0148000652,
0.0357790515,
2.9026482e-34,
0.0417346247,
0.0600265265,
0.0066047926,
-0.0135857482,
0.0832034945,
-0.0203707274,
0.0000054102,
0.0330794454,
-0.0047877817,
-0.0888324082,
-0.0273877345
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.08652v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.08652v1 | Automated Query Generation for Evidence Collection from Web Search Engines | 2023-03-15T14:32:00 | 2023-03-15T14:32:00 | Nestor Prieto-Chavana, Julie Weeds, David Weir | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | It is widely accepted that so-called facts can be checked by searching for
information on the Internet. This process requires a fact-checker to formulate
a search query based on the fact and to present it to a search engine. Then,
relevant and believable passages need to be identified in the search results
before a decision is made. This process is carried out by sub-editors at many
news and media organisations on a daily basis. Here, we ask the question as to
whether it is possible to automate the first step, that of query generation.
Can we automatically formulate search queries based on factual statements which
are similar to those formulated by human experts? Here, we consider similarity
both in terms of textual similarity and with respect to relevant documents
being returned by a search engine. First, we introduce a moderate-sized
evidence collection dataset which includes 390 factual statements together with
associated human-generated search queries and search results. Then, we
investigate generating queries using a number of rule-based and automatic text
generation methods based on pre-trained large language models (LLMs). We show
that these methods have different merits and propose a hybrid approach which
has superior performance in practice. | [
0.0656747669,
0.0169752408,
-0.0097522149,
-0.0140575031,
-0.0852303058,
-0.0023547623,
0.0305677354,
0.0190935545,
0.0072404915,
-0.0758816674,
0.0433303304,
-0.0320663042,
-0.0471453778,
0.0102355732,
0.0040932498,
-0.0048014722,
0.0133867227,
0.0029676547,
0.0540632904,
0.0177859161,
0.0381233692,
0.0381265581,
0.020532487,
0.0229273997,
-0.0055807796,
0.0099891964,
-0.0267852824,
0.002554731,
0.0033962613,
-0.0163489189,
-0.0128676835,
0.0381203666,
0.0272785667,
0.035141807,
0.0000014641,
-0.0507744849,
-0.0045858412,
-0.0178524051,
-0.0233978108,
0.0214002933,
0.0462221578,
0.0354747325,
0.0137722427,
0.0332952887,
-0.0248813648,
-0.026840955,
-0.0100955768,
0.0363265276,
0.0782932341,
0.0925757289,
-0.011612542,
-0.0398542099,
-0.0080066416,
0.0370095782,
0.041355744,
0.0037658371,
0.0451338924,
0.0117478948,
0.0223141629,
0.0286959969,
0.0680434853,
0.017872164,
-0.0135637522,
-0.0554974303,
-0.0310217664,
0.0209826007,
-0.0528461151,
-0.0101148244,
0.0159378648,
0.029693488,
-0.0164305083,
-0.0758229494,
0.0342868455,
-0.0029863375,
0.0074458728,
0.0817043558,
-0.0181642827,
0.0912619382,
-0.0523460917,
0.0001227269,
0.0422003344,
-0.0139619811,
0.0080211367,
0.0337806642,
-0.0220494177,
0.0588885248,
0.029112123,
-0.0572450943,
0.0213553309,
-0.0088555459,
0.0323914476,
-0.0679176226,
0.0201167949,
0.0287300162,
-0.014953834,
0.0062745772,
-0.0666052401,
-0.0184914898,
0.0531595983,
-0.0887449086,
-0.0161777176,
-0.0187917016,
-0.0247438829,
0.0665662214,
-0.0260084681,
-0.0079610134,
-0.0092341732,
-0.0148689924,
-0.0355692878,
-0.0121703018,
-0.0236550961,
-0.0084537771,
-0.0100533627,
0.0154077262,
-0.0313283466,
-0.0174112152,
-0.0036333597,
0.0204245076,
0.0325507149,
0.0129775163,
-0.0163017847,
-0.0156866927,
-0.027014859,
-0.0140059208,
-0.0473550037,
-0.0226733051,
-0.0026196556,
0.0460943617,
-0.016245367,
-0.0144040249,
0.0217008777,
0.0488692261,
0.0489073806,
0.012731622,
0.0163774826,
-0.0070912936,
-0.0173247904,
-0.0284372214,
-0.0527235009,
-0.0491292812,
0.0050931163,
-0.0282360762,
0.0009667421,
-0.055880256,
0.0128947357,
-0.0246053543,
-0.0323153362,
0.0052950275,
0.0029738818,
0.0772565231,
-0.0110923555,
0.0272912383,
-0.0168890264,
0.0195748881,
0.0446115844,
-0.008790167,
0.0393710956,
0.0567436442,
0.0093967523,
0.0801109076,
0.0614741519,
0.0372967348,
0.0238010138,
-0.0094134975,
0.0113144973,
0.0244501773,
0.0167642273,
0.027323788,
-0.0165743567,
0.0499300696,
-0.0303042065,
0.0599165559,
-0.0153987231,
-0.0033397882,
0.0478924997,
0.0276896507,
0.0405442044,
0.0003479471,
0.0641141608,
0.0063363961,
0.0368671939,
0.00641402,
-0.0174222048,
-0.0258225519,
-0.0075286967,
-0.0005828981,
0.0152267059,
0.0507713184,
-0.0326209553,
-0.0155379791,
-0.034217719,
0.0244106669,
-0.0253366623,
-0.0028205293,
0.0258917995,
0.0045157112,
-0.0178477503,
-0.0343111828,
0.0090018678,
-0.0437232368,
0.0278826542,
-0.0365779772,
0.0480795987,
0.0406971313,
0.0529444069,
-0.0236361567,
0.0176049918,
0.0013310113,
0.0335117802,
0.0273027029,
0.03064478,
-0.0134864273,
-0.0465540625,
-0.0275129993,
-0.0375846922,
-0.001578918,
0.0074424264,
-0.0184615999,
0.007665961,
0.0082993228,
0.0532236025,
-0.0366942994,
-0.0713987723,
0.0552328303,
-0.0041984175,
-0.0024065876,
0.0202210452,
-0.0000764645,
-0.0014604761,
0.0282429084,
-0.0225373302,
0.0185682923,
0.042689234,
-0.0008560725,
-0.0614735745,
-0.0032703714,
0.0453671403,
-0.0022403335,
0.0160441883,
-0.0749877915,
0.0179994814,
-0.0328897126,
-0.0021635157,
-0.026817048,
-0.0817250311,
-0.0491825715,
0.0358991325,
-0.0489653796,
0.0261712745,
-0.0074438015,
-0.0393641479,
-0.0437582619,
0.0675357282,
0.034977939,
-0.0143720349,
-0.0116869323,
-0.028967686,
-0.0083468501,
-0.047559917,
-0.029208865,
-0.0222196393,
0.0339642353,
0.0402009748,
0.0628808662,
-0.0081273485,
-0.0358915515,
0.0120882364,
-0.0821268186,
0.023925567,
-0.0123773273,
-0.0140405456,
0.020846488,
0.0100160707,
-0.0306984633,
0.0203383099,
-0.0486114807,
-0.0419854783,
0.0286159907,
0.0295180399,
0.0342161879,
0.0284716617,
-0.0011958411,
-0.0210877657,
-0.0147959748,
-0.0220810659,
0.045683533,
0.0643360764,
0.00857234,
-0.047595568,
0.0691637844,
-0.0274304207,
-0.0126484344,
-0.0142976893,
-0.0206711814,
0.003222008,
-0.0383929163,
-0.003234152,
0.0701228306,
0.0769538209,
-0.0006385833,
0.0602071695,
0.0025772355,
-0.0419729799,
-0.0074270428,
-0.0667701662,
0.0327060446,
0.0187140722,
-0.0552772768,
0.0739167705,
-0.0545128807,
0.0257998127,
-0.0013290173,
-0.0189645495,
0.0282332767,
0.0149095105,
-0.0105688181,
-0.0231727771,
-0.035955891,
0.0215922538,
0.0676589459,
0.0052379128,
-0.0475553349,
0.0726212785,
-0.0248795357,
0.068803519,
-0.0633984432,
-0.009885083,
-0.0094886646,
0.0426801369,
0.0032377462,
0.038802065,
0.0010544439,
0.0232760087,
-0.0018047494,
0.0000850992,
0.0749792159,
-0.036314927,
0.0331614166,
-0.0497948788,
0.0366734043,
0.0404755063,
-0.0346858725,
-0.0406337939,
-0.0846044198,
-0.0039220746,
-0.0398073867,
0.0312819816,
-0.0345075391,
-0.0864693075,
0.0352020785,
0.0547236614,
0.0264671855,
-0.0159246586,
-0.0146852862,
0.021345241,
-0.0190949924,
0.0275216084,
-0.028688468,
0.0119429529,
0.0210452527,
0.0015910638,
0.0130952625,
0.0223396681,
0.0046995729,
0.0002244454,
-0.0349983759,
-0.02628945,
-0.0670763478,
-0.0053839483,
-0.0035791798,
-0.0235744156,
-0.0286503229,
0.005006982,
0.0837913826,
0.049719926,
-0.0436104387,
-0.0596880578,
-0.0096564172,
-0.0584193952,
-0.0003312107,
0.0347497053,
-0.0826870129,
0.0162284095,
0.0081572412,
0.0209697448,
-0.0570219308,
-0.0227610935,
-0.0179482661,
-0.1013298184,
0.0467213541,
-0.0105514107,
0.0423273183,
-0.0245392472,
-0.10040012,
0.0079230256,
-0.0120571963,
-0.0576181449,
0.0379497968,
-0.0287256092,
-0.0002276136,
0.0220219214,
-0.0001158775,
-0.0535078049,
-0.0065865726,
-0.0512378551,
0.0001775004,
0.0331868008,
0.0436628982,
-0.0020238336,
-0.025290383,
-0.0118530858,
-0.0099677136,
0.0005954779,
-0.001030548,
0.046482414,
-0.0264605191,
0.0216556098,
-0.0558824092,
0.0273231454,
0.0132870423,
0.0058133551,
0.043189209,
0.0489287265,
-0.0476249345,
-0.0309904739,
-0.0405113921,
-0.003098981,
0.0000243923,
0.0880725458,
0.0053949873,
0.0157898087,
0.0008221313,
0.0152368452,
0.0013045671,
0.0070773531,
-0.0431241244,
0.0284143947,
-0.0573483482,
0.0206386279,
-0.0701065958,
0.001145387,
0.0125635238,
0.0748670697,
0.0328850262,
-0.0028858166,
0.0348939635,
-0.0041198526,
-0.0332335941,
-0.0128635634,
-0.0162593499,
0.0238575246,
-0.037453834,
0.0164556149,
0.0524189398,
-0.0218518488,
-0.0182907935,
-0.0139995459,
-0.006293281,
-0.0534776486,
-0.0001451955,
-0.0210355446,
0.0183751751,
0.0191682372,
-0.0150180776,
-0.0275908727,
0.0448349975,
0.0555335283,
-0.0234155506,
-0.0471598357,
0.0006819488,
-0.0526621602,
0.003831614,
-0.0055249063,
-0.0391612686,
0.0306359921,
-0.0263778586,
0.0053055747,
-0.0383159444,
-0.0660518184,
0.0865163803,
0.0626104027,
0.0429177098,
-0.0275878664,
-0.0123681817,
-0.0327203423,
-0.0125619778,
-0.0500043593,
-0.0366776176,
0.0097073354,
0.0563628897,
-0.0127362013,
0.0181117523,
-0.00153009,
0.0330295302,
-0.0686223134,
0.0390786007,
-0.038404651,
-0.0002553904,
-0.0055819247,
0.0312079433,
0.0072141136,
-0.0478273518,
-0.0274256468,
0.0046831788,
-0.0000769598,
0.0218819063,
-0.0228752699,
0.0147452774,
0.0492858589,
-0.012162962,
-0.0196955763,
-0.005829291,
-0.0945695564,
-0.0327430405,
-0.0517500602,
-0.0117752049,
0.0443161838,
-0.0288106874,
-0.0222266819,
-0.0495621338,
-0.0218441542,
-0.0013276607,
0.0210496336,
0.0285253767,
0.018746851,
0.0207688212,
0.0089648953,
-0.0410132743,
0.0117726503,
0.0530358776,
0.0203438494,
0.041092094,
0.0079287905,
-0.1043892801,
-0.005256997,
-0.0570551269,
-0.0027669936,
0.0319012031,
-0.0240852199,
-0.0513592884,
-0.0354432538,
0.0046543297,
-0.0110758869,
0.0305206571,
0.0317886658,
0.0147765595,
0.0222783424,
0.1134204641,
0.0306284316,
-0.0009600176,
-0.0398994349,
0.0329139307,
-0.0324820541,
-0.0055695502,
-0.0045370148,
-5.589222172e-33,
0.0127946362,
-0.041760236,
0.0081483843,
-0.0004950355,
-0.0054221996,
0.0124153653,
-0.0066828262,
-0.0507636666,
-0.040369641,
0.0282768849,
-0.0052544512,
0.0325258933,
0.015633272,
-0.0295212585,
0.0018720818,
0.000095556,
0.0459381565,
-0.0064706947,
-0.0493039191,
0.0136489756,
0.063628301,
-0.0187993553,
-0.0169921406,
-0.0627841726,
0.0106134936,
-0.0169603601,
-0.0230597742,
0.0473874062,
-0.0047667967,
0.0424621254,
0.0069156061,
0.0293800067,
0.0256772134,
-0.0272412188,
0.0243345052,
0.0257767662,
-0.0271974411,
-0.020721864,
0.0562395528,
-0.0649136901,
0.044333946,
0.020203542,
0.0228165556,
-0.0088285832,
-0.0167017337,
0.0605843998,
0.057203535,
-0.0114853131,
-0.0215129498,
-0.0840281993,
-0.0411156379,
0.023833571,
0.001006796,
0.0078308824,
-0.0317605659,
0.0375670493,
-0.0063509559,
0.0005807627,
-0.0371189192,
0.0771550313,
-0.0089575406,
0.0171030425,
0.0207065772,
-0.0172077902,
0.003442877,
0.0582798719,
-0.0002392092,
-0.0006724778,
-0.0395266972,
0.0117762797,
0.0009940447,
0.0197756328,
0.0039232266,
0.094010219,
-0.0000558279,
-0.0112222396,
-0.0494834408,
0.0535731912,
0.0288086813,
0.0495181754,
0.0367004089,
-0.0172427502,
-0.0563534647,
-0.0088585261,
-0.0192232113,
0.0219237227,
-0.0219812226,
-0.0020201514,
0.0125766313,
0.029300943,
-0.0259107035,
-0.0033797808,
-0.0017279579,
0.0053550499,
0.0165523253,
0.0254357737,
-0.0307266042,
-0.0243630651,
-0.0436758772,
0.007640583,
-0.0409129821,
-0.0240588542,
0.0111127868,
0.0120181851,
-0.0294150226,
0.0067516938,
-0.0132145472,
0.0014408979,
-0.0378862545,
-0.0054493793,
0.0125887422,
-0.0116484463,
-0.0021453863,
-0.062312264,
0.0261037312,
0.057944674,
0.0297059081,
0.0008042508,
0.0280206818,
0.0058528921,
-0.0287457034,
-0.0679786503,
0.0214164965,
0.0016682819,
-0.0039982172,
0.0108628487,
-0.0352890119,
0.0112139545,
0.0072909673,
-0.0609540716,
0.0203333218,
0.0335386246,
2.376e-7,
0.0292754639,
0.0398188867,
-0.0275219865,
0.0430927128,
-0.0216180794,
0.0280437917,
0.0375178531,
-0.0146648651,
0.0185353886,
-0.0231968891,
0.0285563339,
-0.0039840876,
-0.003058925,
0.0538697168,
-0.0550606512,
-0.0359504595,
-0.0430014245,
-0.0938440487,
-0.082406871,
-0.0153767401,
0.0676275417,
0.0501413792,
0.030653514,
-0.0232435875,
-0.0349376462,
-0.0705995709,
0.0360464491,
0.0099328086,
-0.0469978079,
0.037398506,
0.1041809916,
-0.0030135012,
-0.0161686763,
0.0673343912,
-0.0184269771,
0.0200564396,
-0.0040536541,
0.00397615,
0.0353673361,
0.0509230457,
-0.0018911634,
-0.0628128424,
0.032071501,
-0.0567383394,
0.0653102696,
-0.0223041512,
0.0320697911,
-0.0332538858,
-0.0253064968,
-0.0412172228,
0.0112942345,
-0.0501301214,
-0.026739886,
0.0013978117,
-0.0190782435,
0.0168207791,
0.0150632439,
-0.0442718156,
0.0376541317,
0.0171585977,
-0.0498635806,
-0.0534523018,
-0.0006942518,
0.0057980316,
0.0009131886,
-0.0571243055,
0.0698477924,
1.888609835e-34,
0.0430197865,
0.0375724658,
-0.0421194769,
-0.0171809737,
0.0409207307,
0.0536908656,
-0.0377708115,
-0.0074814861,
0.0130603528,
-0.104598105,
-0.012008707
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.08606v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.08606v1 | On the Calibration and Uncertainty with Pólya-Gamma Augmentation for Dialog Retrieval Models | 2023-03-15T13:26:25 | 2023-03-15T13:26:25 | Tong Ye, Shijing Si, Jianzong Wang, Ning Cheng, Zhitao Li, Jing Xiao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Deep neural retrieval models have amply demonstrated their power but
estimating the reliability of their predictions remains challenging. Most
dialog response retrieval models output a single score for a response on how
relevant it is to a given question. However, the bad calibration of deep neural
network results in various uncertainty for the single score such that the
unreliable predictions always misinform user decisions. To investigate these
issues, we present an efficient calibration and uncertainty estimation
framework PG-DRR for dialog response retrieval models which adds a Gaussian
Process layer to a deterministic deep neural network and recovers conjugacy for
tractable posterior inference by P\'{o}lya-Gamma augmentation. Finally, PG-DRR
achieves the lowest empirical calibration error (ECE) in the in-domain datasets
and the distributional shift task while keeping $R_{10}@1$ and MAP performance. | [
0.0469707474,
0.110833317,
0.0021079667,
0.0230377,
0.0272545293,
0.0035929824,
0.0027158167,
-0.0330827534,
0.0112115685,
0.0060219113,
-0.0536611602,
-0.081096366,
-0.0091958251,
0.0795004666,
-0.0219129622,
-0.0358686633,
0.0220965296,
0.0107616894,
0.0812796801,
0.0010666752,
0.0100312876,
-0.0355386883,
-0.0393399857,
0.0389800966,
-0.0406551585,
-0.0081325807,
-0.013627761,
0.0406140946,
0.0174368508,
-0.0221976694,
0.0330421552,
0.0185304377,
-0.0137221403,
0.0479754768,
0.000001883,
-0.0121340072,
0.0027645791,
-0.005932881,
-0.0918881521,
-0.0270176418,
0.0405028127,
0.0573924519,
0.0292264614,
0.0154272541,
-0.0138586545,
-0.0297131483,
0.0584254451,
0.0676126778,
0.0315255001,
0.0666660592,
-0.0047266316,
-0.0245096404,
0.0777591988,
-0.0425508209,
0.0142538622,
-0.0748802722,
-0.005199288,
0.0146733345,
-0.0260479245,
0.061506018,
0.0372679606,
0.0242236387,
0.0332269184,
-0.0370449871,
-0.0396372452,
-0.0097223539,
0.0314871334,
-0.0150061268,
-0.016737124,
0.0527897142,
0.0480621569,
0.0184061583,
-0.049327556,
-0.0233231746,
0.0193053018,
-0.0027578129,
-0.0709990934,
-0.011062311,
0.0113758324,
-0.0097625656,
-0.061473541,
0.011074882,
0.0258321092,
-0.019049963,
-0.0073069809,
0.0921459571,
0.0095448876,
-0.0235320851,
-0.0037677716,
0.0145308645,
-0.007518189,
-0.011813934,
0.03709599,
-0.0039073392,
-0.0299477,
0.020895442,
-0.0039944793,
-0.0124719627,
0.0089180702,
-0.0243177433,
-0.0071456297,
0.0484133214,
-0.0347674415,
0.0333388261,
0.0174110215,
0.0752005205,
-0.0248131864,
-0.0125473356,
-0.0467021279,
-0.0533983745,
-0.0212420169,
-0.0191522427,
-0.0185656827,
0.0275611319,
-0.0449674875,
-0.0233141538,
-0.0674792379,
0.043054387,
-0.004538408,
-0.0097391242,
-0.0113607021,
0.0682817921,
-0.0709794238,
-0.0107244067,
-0.071934998,
0.0703682229,
-0.0439554118,
0.0311593693,
0.0575600825,
-0.0693993047,
-0.0123002864,
0.0034727645,
0.0247291885,
-0.0228967946,
-0.007280732,
0.0286680348,
-0.0179608259,
-0.0197002999,
0.0203453973,
-0.0031025675,
-0.017271705,
-0.0439023189,
0.0114339981,
-0.0003545447,
0.0256420486,
-0.0291058067,
-0.0135096721,
-0.048499126,
0.0030637363,
0.0245258659,
0.006906664,
0.0675440952,
0.0452976711,
-0.022947954,
0.0530811213,
-0.0114635238,
-0.0368856378,
0.0758077949,
0.006066429,
0.0037120418,
0.0332655385,
-0.0016866613,
0.0620077178,
-0.0248584487,
0.0124920635,
-0.0077482816,
0.0206938013,
0.0260578152,
-0.0372687317,
0.0092224497,
0.0365696438,
0.037119966,
-0.04447449,
-0.0335380062,
0.0507449172,
0.0245144535,
0.0040607387,
-0.0156678427,
-0.0179989804,
0.0004410776,
-0.0056055854,
-0.0016391579,
-0.0477285124,
0.0168673657,
-0.0150542213,
-0.0013234183,
0.0137448478,
-0.0284920298,
-0.0310292691,
-0.07052017,
0.0266766101,
0.033561781,
0.0019960837,
0.0526036583,
0.0254412405,
-0.0471192412,
-0.0462904386,
0.0423964374,
-0.0095447041,
-0.0447201729,
-0.0229577608,
-0.0611729063,
0.0112138167,
0.0055271299,
0.0079532322,
-0.0522792637,
-0.0554532669,
-0.0114600165,
-0.0280892961,
0.0155304885,
0.0230069831,
-0.0035933619,
0.0262402855,
-0.0328328833,
-0.0217403024,
-0.0127434926,
0.0099692,
0.0296475366,
-0.0002978233,
-0.0081384731,
0.0705845878,
-0.0046601011,
0.0142285805,
-0.0044249045,
0.0151047856,
-0.0438786224,
0.0216246191,
-0.0000146272,
0.0518794097,
0.0158434939,
-0.0016847625,
0.0181325749,
0.0213170853,
-0.0084954938,
-0.000308881,
-0.0191128999,
-0.0375198722,
-0.0049645198,
0.0466711,
-0.0120408358,
0.0205900725,
0.0406472906,
-0.0207359511,
-0.070094645,
0.0303446203,
-0.0292217918,
-0.0422589555,
-0.0585182756,
-0.0007498456,
0.0162244625,
0.0291494858,
-0.0484922677,
0.0041466923,
-0.014121606,
0.0146741997,
0.0330263488,
0.042951975,
0.0464194119,
-0.0800101459,
-0.0353472978,
-0.0310614649,
-0.0278963707,
0.0047763553,
0.0473401621,
-0.0500642881,
-0.0542397648,
-0.0229052939,
-0.0872501284,
0.0240311027,
-0.0319187976,
0.0196489356,
0.0192902368,
0.0345895179,
-0.0050063869,
-0.01434498,
-0.0408359766,
0.0095043546,
0.0252230354,
0.0374603979,
0.0137543166,
0.0232450236,
0.0116197523,
-0.0817886218,
-0.0271449164,
0.0113897743,
0.0139689604,
0.009586635,
-0.009581076,
-0.0293619204,
-0.0283254795,
-0.029124368,
0.0390542746,
-0.035698913,
-0.0575364977,
0.0136821838,
0.0038748779,
-0.0017531426,
0.0605195798,
-0.0175661799,
-0.045552779,
-0.0335175954,
-0.0047573671,
-0.0453905053,
0.0579720363,
-0.0499270856,
-0.0591878667,
0.0053656092,
0.000769113,
0.0055013127,
0.0214238483,
-0.0076611815,
0.008616956,
-0.0194030497,
-0.011934178,
0.0161731988,
-0.0073597198,
-0.0093781026,
-0.0305772629,
-0.019791482,
0.0449938402,
-0.0246475078,
-0.0204422232,
0.0657578781,
-0.0252980608,
-0.0214321427,
-0.0500390083,
-0.0146623328,
0.0143365972,
0.0209543351,
0.0097428486,
-0.0043475968,
-0.0414607748,
-0.0431205183,
-0.0692115799,
-0.0095286639,
0.0202304274,
-0.059081912,
0.0645938516,
-0.0011270655,
0.0211655796,
-0.0208241977,
-0.0422588848,
-0.0768482909,
-0.0273945183,
-0.0198717229,
0.0035727313,
0.0137074236,
-0.0125708804,
-0.0394390151,
-0.0029743693,
-0.0047594858,
0.023970075,
-0.0260903202,
-0.0002458911,
-0.0111784404,
0.0410438403,
0.0543157868,
0.0448235236,
0.0232413672,
0.0030586114,
-0.0182697847,
0.01664651,
0.0089260591,
-0.0137743615,
-0.0119076045,
-0.0577481501,
0.0292541441,
0.0131799532,
-0.0046310807,
0.0267499872,
0.0638969168,
-0.0280996673,
-0.0232384615,
0.0729419962,
0.0038565132,
-0.072703436,
-0.0728114247,
-0.0435712859,
0.0320103876,
0.0157630667,
0.0345113277,
-0.0695991889,
-0.038935896,
0.0254581515,
0.0162298102,
-0.0140640521,
0.0045165173,
0.0228304602,
-0.0957550928,
0.0336902775,
-0.028598452,
0.0140807154,
-0.0472439378,
-0.0129652629,
0.0153690921,
0.0046830918,
0.0770979375,
0.0257599521,
0.0365602374,
0.0010865021,
0.045670744,
-0.0033780027,
-0.0154540362,
-0.0180441849,
-0.0158251394,
0.0321529508,
0.0693627447,
0.006370951,
-0.0063289064,
-0.0145550119,
0.0698438063,
-0.0374601856,
-0.0415882133,
0.0426632203,
0.0731670707,
0.0156422071,
-0.0039112512,
-0.0102594821,
0.0282522719,
-0.0329163708,
-0.001194085,
-0.0349650346,
0.0270080827,
-0.0298030861,
0.0644437075,
-0.0343961827,
0.0085729109,
0.040295437,
0.0219319072,
0.008949752,
-0.0129724192,
-0.0432229824,
-0.0430900902,
0.0503944829,
0.0018301414,
0.0493794717,
0.0078264773,
0.0504471287,
-0.0165361855,
-0.0402166992,
-0.0348832533,
-0.0430770405,
0.0155241601,
-0.0215454213,
-0.0188351572,
-0.0019662564,
-0.0021449632,
-0.0142484168,
0.0455356315,
-0.0274812784,
0.0003495845,
-0.0608281009,
0.0395500883,
0.0340698026,
-0.0043149451,
-0.0176385604,
0.0597777516,
-0.0938892365,
-0.0267167185,
-0.0072776554,
0.0459912457,
0.0190211423,
0.0042425673,
-0.0134682972,
-0.0384001546,
0.0122751659,
0.0100015877,
-0.0208443627,
-0.0138408812,
0.0350193307,
0.0525592677,
-0.0442442968,
0.0227594264,
-0.05535651,
0.0261762012,
-0.0175899807,
0.0329079852,
-0.0381363109,
-0.1148345619,
0.0118896198,
0.0111986483,
0.0986728445,
0.0674390122,
-0.0162266158,
-0.0589003339,
0.0462644622,
-0.0100696106,
-0.0028429211,
-0.0368644372,
-0.0202664454,
0.054042168,
-0.044672545,
0.0169613063,
-0.0462296754,
-0.0103096636,
0.0384362377,
-0.0308569726,
-0.0346285067,
0.0809203908,
-0.0255480371,
-0.0031032905,
-0.0082799746,
-0.0297589153,
0.0232860669,
0.0335503779,
0.0440518297,
0.0193032548,
0.0629149824,
0.0088782497,
-0.0444523618,
-0.0076028882,
-0.0162918903,
-0.0832397789,
-0.054837618,
-0.0296472199,
0.0053256704,
0.0208925027,
0.0310969763,
-0.0050514201,
0.0156876799,
-0.0121688703,
-0.0240218621,
0.0143808285,
0.0209974442,
0.0086806593,
0.0663010329,
0.0163955931,
0.001885146,
0.0107936775,
0.0274921786,
-0.0023951484,
0.0247581284,
-0.0328167267,
-0.0108964555,
-0.0252423305,
-0.0541746132,
-0.0309237335,
0.0733223185,
-0.0098675564,
0.0043397113,
0.0245460588,
-0.0392893776,
0.0101236133,
0.00849362,
-0.0156591907,
-0.0359054022,
0.0341290049,
0.058394663,
-0.0198605713,
-0.0294455383,
-0.0338861644,
0.0167349335,
-0.0011970372,
0.0293319672,
-0.0353394374,
-6.316282326e-33,
-0.0247179829,
-0.0044408678,
0.0047399933,
-0.0211202316,
-0.0382464454,
-0.0010193404,
-0.0135837821,
0.0285297502,
-0.0443001054,
0.0191743542,
-0.0045814761,
0.0339669921,
0.0323871858,
0.0426720195,
-0.0231621899,
-0.0468957648,
0.0641458109,
0.0075426949,
0.0094470466,
0.0021346351,
0.0503785014,
0.0445370078,
0.0277343579,
-0.0790635496,
0.0068111643,
0.0029917932,
0.0093173748,
0.0336676016,
0.0086836079,
0.0487948023,
-0.0200707652,
0.0404082686,
-0.0049035978,
-0.013233494,
0.0187896807,
0.0281177405,
-0.0508644171,
-0.0543667525,
0.0035247067,
0.0401562788,
-0.0060770861,
0.0150274495,
0.0486090071,
0.0117095383,
0.0150875691,
-0.0199049413,
-0.0019289139,
-0.017475592,
-0.028730046,
0.0478122085,
-0.0008100762,
-0.0006522477,
0.0061960481,
-0.0169385262,
0.0002329418,
0.0664616004,
0.0229536872,
0.0107970247,
-0.0722122416,
-0.049018804,
-0.0139892399,
0.0349078067,
0.0331202298,
0.0798437893,
-0.0071109436,
0.0409667753,
0.0290101152,
-0.0012301719,
-0.0610696599,
-0.0841082335,
-0.0145813217,
-0.0023287598,
0.0252735261,
0.0686991289,
0.0409193523,
-0.0185282342,
-0.0694181174,
0.0260840598,
0.0273286477,
0.0514132194,
0.026388796,
0.0274079274,
-0.0527628884,
-0.0193668008,
-0.0668917149,
0.000249854,
-0.0537459217,
0.004267375,
0.0388293415,
0.0217998531,
0.0209541209,
0.0008408908,
0.0472083837,
-0.0271665026,
0.0200228691,
0.0334361792,
-0.0102657359,
-0.0005428816,
0.0033055427,
0.0415881239,
-0.0210957583,
-0.0138489977,
-0.0057181525,
0.0169890597,
-0.0223928243,
-0.0019244719,
-0.0308189057,
-0.0257784519,
-0.0548997745,
-0.0048064673,
-0.038669467,
0.033832632,
-0.0116883535,
0.066157043,
0.0034444295,
-0.0121845882,
-0.0025168671,
0.0731755272,
-0.0134020904,
0.0588745661,
0.0004457252,
-0.0247413609,
0.0294575598,
-0.0262362063,
-0.056775149,
0.0011360634,
0.0218154043,
-0.030346483,
-0.0406967551,
-0.057036791,
-0.001536335,
0.014229686,
2.694e-7,
0.0399474017,
0.0053378749,
0.043638926,
0.014728507,
0.0134982588,
0.0425493084,
0.0087096486,
-0.0057119136,
0.0708767399,
-0.035983704,
0.0274065342,
-0.0084533459,
0.0140965162,
0.02689467,
-0.0694504231,
-0.0600163229,
-0.0249731969,
0.0248607285,
0.0329328775,
-0.0070329346,
0.0538376421,
0.1223556176,
-0.0152652562,
-0.017873656,
0.0161265153,
-0.0475000367,
0.070546031,
-0.007980342,
-0.0132578835,
0.0525879934,
0.099782981,
0.0420395546,
0.0066974326,
0.031640552,
0.0229930282,
0.0378872566,
0.0157764275,
0.0450061858,
0.0076028523,
-0.0821482092,
-0.0295852069,
0.0021424312,
0.034195669,
-0.0488989055,
0.0505727045,
-0.0410097688,
-0.0347702168,
-0.0476416759,
-0.061501909,
-0.007531411,
0.0738622025,
-0.0037719046,
0.0018804057,
-0.0173006169,
0.0077963048,
0.0129530355,
-0.0160217471,
-0.0769226328,
-0.0087303221,
0.0035889479,
-0.057710398,
-0.012330832,
-0.0266572144,
-0.0585984588,
0.0300267804,
-0.0077009541,
0.0470013656,
1.96061162e-34,
0.0389482938,
-0.0048779878,
-0.000304736,
0.0092721283,
0.0337286778,
-0.0018023454,
0.0239350256,
-0.0183894876,
0.052024316,
-0.0882367119,
-0.0012692852
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.08601v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.08601v2 | GCRE-GPT: A Generative Model for Comparative Relation Extraction | 2023-03-15T13:15:22 | 2024-06-27T06:34:11 | Yequan Wang, Hengran Zhang, Aixin Sun, Xuying Meng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Given comparative text, comparative relation extraction aims to extract two
targets (\eg two cameras) in comparison and the aspect they are compared for
(\eg image quality). The extracted comparative relations form the basis of
further opinion analysis.Existing solutions formulate this task as a sequence
labeling task, to extract targets and aspects. However, they cannot directly
extract comparative relation(s) from text. In this paper, we show that
comparative relations can be directly extracted with high accuracy, by
generative model. Based on GPT-2, we propose a Generation-based Comparative
Relation Extractor (GCRE-GPT). Experiment results show that \modelname achieves
state-of-the-art accuracy on two datasets. | [
0.0327013358,
0.0880934,
0.0254044496,
0.0614738278,
-0.0397942103,
0.0359556042,
-0.0044983351,
0.0131041678,
-0.0310990717,
-0.0513382033,
-0.0255210083,
-0.019918656,
-0.0379205495,
0.0197361223,
-0.0020533018,
-0.0739441067,
0.0065066097,
0.0412121564,
0.0467556454,
0.0213425308,
0.020849837,
0.0046644979,
-0.0148768919,
-0.0295710806,
-0.0154322935,
0.0037147799,
0.0388249569,
-0.0192422867,
0.0757015496,
-0.0604631938,
-0.0113838343,
0.0425038598,
0.0030777529,
-0.0134584988,
0.0000019612,
-0.0210631564,
-0.019399697,
0.0161467977,
0.0502199903,
0.0028934884,
0.054050535,
0.0058046631,
0.006321271,
-0.0218200013,
-0.0761140361,
-0.0614629649,
0.0371644162,
0.0568162017,
-0.0055495491,
0.0428917371,
-0.0550377704,
-0.0814154893,
0.0042117643,
-0.0486774854,
-0.0123420898,
-0.0316960476,
-0.0210103784,
0.0205870084,
-0.0160960108,
0.0347536877,
0.0171908066,
0.0330367535,
0.0130571164,
-0.002851292,
0.020045897,
0.0711963624,
0.0174986273,
0.0053170896,
-0.0198986344,
0.052793961,
0.0166590158,
-0.0036823507,
0.0256839804,
-0.0157931373,
-0.0116726914,
-0.0006683655,
-0.0084516546,
0.0276913606,
-0.0460799076,
0.0559718013,
-0.0104194293,
0.0542532466,
-0.0116536496,
-0.0384065136,
0.0014342637,
0.0131227002,
0.0185638871,
-0.0276667271,
0.0132429646,
0.0501449741,
-0.0019971514,
-0.0262558423,
0.0016705228,
-0.0082894498,
0.022507187,
-0.0050149807,
-0.0007059684,
-0.0316160619,
-0.0182948019,
-0.0505523533,
0.009562036,
-0.0519574694,
-0.0240897313,
0.0476023592,
-0.0062429816,
0.0581777915,
0.023976462,
-0.0155885993,
-0.0320797339,
0.0207272731,
-0.0896061063,
-0.0060075871,
0.0034855416,
0.0357381776,
-0.0441250317,
-0.0074259122,
-0.0338181965,
-0.022343656,
-0.023670163,
-0.0128899151,
0.0336291678,
0.0134198079,
-0.0057777846,
0.0125123411,
-0.0347722284,
-0.0085742055,
-0.0569536164,
-0.0079134358,
-0.0193588492,
-0.0115352208,
0.012964353,
0.0151955811,
0.0637796968,
-0.0244767778,
-0.0169252362,
0.0770215169,
-0.0143591668,
-0.0307534803,
0.012862443,
0.0063618035,
0.0206577517,
-0.0381941497,
0.0046518138,
-0.0504788086,
0.0658932775,
0.0064532412,
-0.0498045087,
-0.0155779282,
0.0123512195,
-0.0015448573,
-0.0241917595,
0.053690806,
-0.031183999,
-0.0248525739,
0.0037363772,
0.0131594473,
0.0363834687,
0.0304859038,
0.0059461212,
0.0092208618,
0.0535894856,
0.0033778159,
0.0172905345,
-0.0030837008,
-0.0371178277,
-0.0459190719,
-0.0107607367,
0.0261418726,
-0.0282641333,
0.0015911103,
0.0209776759,
0.082263127,
-0.0214175154,
-0.0243964307,
0.0376537703,
-0.0011920122,
-0.0161702223,
0.0257914104,
0.0301894248,
0.0181855299,
-0.0230169967,
0.0492496341,
-0.0153826745,
0.050225094,
0.0210507084,
0.0388866365,
-0.0243508387,
0.0280408319,
0.0019381262,
-0.0523646325,
-0.0069108531,
-0.0116541684,
-0.0135168303,
-0.0277875457,
0.0630235448,
0.0265440345,
-0.0658381954,
-0.0077001033,
0.0342782922,
-0.0611040667,
-0.0356677696,
-0.0406655408,
0.021895485,
0.0257862527,
0.0107747531,
-0.0077341264,
-0.0449093245,
0.0213771053,
-0.0744848847,
0.0305502582,
0.0134098707,
-0.0072175902,
-0.0059597306,
-0.0373753235,
-0.0275509208,
-0.021108957,
-0.0015892624,
0.0209299307,
0.026297234,
0.0318515785,
0.0465606935,
0.0145434914,
-0.0105439685,
0.0146814939,
0.0486421473,
-0.0219665095,
0.0147818178,
0.0167749878,
0.0050884588,
0.0351849496,
-0.0568544418,
-0.0015327289,
0.0308305435,
-0.0350792669,
-0.0328459069,
0.0544143058,
-0.0507661179,
-0.0729126707,
-0.0029278367,
-0.0735471398,
-0.0224364623,
-0.0086110011,
-0.080373399,
-0.0037949341,
-0.0253800992,
-0.0062106019,
0.0723318905,
-0.0551260673,
0.0033120937,
0.04425551,
-0.0415153168,
-0.0340707861,
0.101156868,
-0.0157115627,
-0.0359041058,
-0.0044985623,
-0.0402706303,
-0.0162161887,
0.0188686382,
-0.0068781306,
0.0338599905,
0.020878505,
-0.0150000546,
0.0082643516,
0.0260782633,
-0.0336951353,
-0.0166463237,
-0.051414486,
0.0056137629,
0.0284455717,
0.0573661253,
0.0463511646,
-0.0203889254,
-0.0018004522,
0.0141364466,
-0.0457912087,
0.0221766662,
-0.0075511583,
0.0099335192,
0.0771151185,
0.031397175,
0.0324063338,
-0.072942473,
-0.0073148794,
0.0057194564,
0.045175951,
0.0502001904,
0.0063247834,
-0.0067021814,
0.0615972206,
-0.0485305525,
0.0319946855,
-0.0092515741,
-0.0449257642,
0.0020476622,
-0.0282452498,
0.0178662259,
-0.0013549004,
0.0329897478,
0.0560801253,
0.0234643761,
-0.0193767287,
0.0076281605,
0.0075255153,
-0.0387490764,
0.0006638919,
0.0276375245,
-0.0084595392,
0.0066019958,
0.0434209555,
0.0031435201,
0.0222798549,
-0.0381534174,
0.0168594196,
-0.0061284145,
0.0186034217,
-0.0093513196,
0.0412285253,
0.0275502466,
0.0024971096,
-0.0417716615,
-0.0103093339,
0.0759230703,
0.0013903636,
0.0174431,
-0.0175765678,
0.0070364331,
-0.0300045442,
0.092256926,
0.0659818128,
0.0327553116,
0.017425552,
-0.0025736373,
-0.0143127078,
-0.0199628267,
0.0575847849,
0.0002147224,
0.0074594994,
-0.0506367385,
0.0055078557,
-0.0188750681,
-0.0595888123,
0.0100809131,
0.0176474899,
-0.014323012,
-0.0337109938,
0.0168759227,
-0.0239926819,
0.0475439653,
0.0616642982,
-0.0401845574,
0.0330164544,
0.0144080715,
0.0073223533,
0.0092338044,
0.0776607096,
0.0705097392,
-0.0510337502,
-0.0391367525,
0.0198800061,
0.0045136907,
0.0584589466,
-0.0215274449,
-0.0159023963,
-0.0266320817,
-0.0203733109,
-0.0230400246,
-0.0169362742,
-0.0229067784,
-0.0532615408,
0.0188389048,
-0.0523899496,
0.0077500935,
0.1100994125,
0.0181789827,
-0.0152377645,
-0.0131325098,
0.0586020872,
-0.0011417547,
0.0145055456,
0.0003337148,
-0.0552286431,
0.005267032,
-0.051510714,
-0.0132622421,
-0.0302463826,
-0.0010349726,
-0.0129134264,
-0.1221830249,
0.0132120606,
-0.0257990025,
-0.0376345105,
-0.0393751822,
-0.0099704051,
-0.0067318222,
-0.0224430785,
-0.0783349872,
0.0247004051,
-0.0120249409,
0.0466076434,
-0.0243773293,
-0.0014852193,
-0.0589238703,
0.0129705239,
-0.0347051919,
-0.0084280977,
0.0654263049,
0.0292095281,
-0.0089675961,
-0.0286718234,
0.0294678453,
-0.0320829786,
0.0078637497,
-0.0337301418,
0.0781392753,
-0.0222133752,
-0.0111081535,
-0.0286556091,
-0.0082755778,
0.0180507749,
0.0187110454,
0.0052315076,
-0.0216394644,
0.0387253501,
-0.0408552885,
-0.0159688145,
0.0151917497,
0.0026164344,
0.0297844876,
0.0306937825,
0.0055934838,
-0.0520801209,
0.0118090753,
-0.0076086014,
-0.0719016939,
-0.0013217129,
-0.0335419178,
-0.0139922891,
-0.0359474458,
-0.1138415113,
-0.0410759933,
-0.0114948265,
-0.0050882366,
-0.0275724679,
-0.0380329229,
0.0114229023,
-0.0028663415,
-0.0652198568,
-0.0406955369,
0.0470516384,
-0.0474822856,
-0.0188276153,
-0.0207946356,
0.1023311093,
0.0380678065,
-0.0416188352,
-0.0132266833,
-0.0459172726,
-0.027033912,
-0.0678318143,
0.0824281573,
0.0094697922,
0.0194731634,
0.0129038161,
0.0194814503,
-0.0221630279,
0.0892351046,
0.0052139773,
-0.02479464,
0.0070148944,
-0.0027669705,
-0.0083903866,
0.0051024659,
0.0132204909,
0.0589470007,
-0.0042293002,
0.0051384033,
-0.0396221951,
0.0116741545,
0.021658862,
-0.0097024441,
0.1006927118,
-0.0104605276,
-0.0032422165,
-0.0639059395,
0.0050679245,
-0.0785567313,
-0.0046237847,
-0.050586544,
0.0171118248,
-0.0469381437,
0.0327949822,
-0.0547722727,
-0.0088172276,
-0.0207989719,
0.0385187455,
-0.0448897369,
0.0293732602,
0.0267892908,
-0.0154636092,
-0.0103966538,
-0.0231641568,
-0.0236770976,
-0.0171951167,
0.0252767969,
0.0225789696,
-0.0245265514,
0.0501395911,
0.0266366582,
-0.0049037728,
0.0447179787,
0.0577220693,
-0.0160162877,
0.040638838,
-0.0720062256,
0.0397838056,
0.0329195745,
-0.020847071,
0.0298767127,
0.003361956,
-0.0118316524,
0.0254822131,
0.0422254018,
-0.0224364027,
-0.0270627812,
0.0260548647,
0.0011409891,
0.0077594439,
0.01763702,
0.0711814761,
-0.0217103604,
0.0098872054,
0.0371243618,
-0.0274869595,
-0.0450580604,
-0.0034930939,
-0.037943799,
-0.0543762743,
0.0454070531,
0.0341274254,
-0.0373073816,
-0.0336177535,
-0.0366971791,
0.0174275972,
0.0329377279,
0.0260755196,
0.0731126219,
0.0299486835,
-0.0000090048,
-0.0247432161,
-0.0272045564,
0.0089417035,
-0.0528770536,
-0.0412034355,
-0.0236360077,
-6.426030887e-33,
-0.0491534062,
-0.0461231582,
-0.0103354026,
0.0117821451,
-0.0481631905,
0.0085805245,
-0.029498456,
-0.0195002537,
0.0185040049,
0.0343622379,
0.0261710193,
-0.0168777443,
0.0150907384,
0.033465296,
-0.0056068054,
0.0010770781,
0.0366513878,
-0.0001919136,
0.020794848,
0.0354415327,
0.0181851536,
0.016351467,
0.0884464979,
-0.0941484347,
-0.0366861448,
-0.0081726266,
0.009193263,
-0.0301130209,
0.0266391188,
0.0319113843,
0.0095386785,
0.0064325295,
0.0332003012,
-0.03197328,
0.0361235142,
-0.0160107985,
-0.0716244951,
0.0013644544,
0.0007522624,
-0.0434790291,
-0.0073303762,
-0.0143350931,
-0.0130470293,
-0.0308229234,
0.0126529019,
-0.0367135368,
0.0567312427,
-0.0358585492,
0.0148309283,
-0.0868111923,
-0.0763673931,
0.0420766063,
0.0131335007,
0.0297401138,
0.0237334818,
0.031027833,
0.0021160948,
0.0361753553,
-0.0175185464,
0.0101740435,
0.0743867606,
0.0633834004,
0.038832467,
-0.0178704895,
0.01740532,
0.0349028818,
-0.0285525117,
-0.0596284904,
-0.0205138158,
0.0131560927,
-0.0661690757,
0.085650824,
-0.0088762548,
0.0286316406,
0.0608667806,
-0.044125393,
-0.0376593471,
0.0096441451,
-0.0117156245,
0.0306618214,
-0.020638898,
0.0235898476,
0.0011710527,
0.017568605,
0.0272679161,
-0.0718066469,
-0.0305429455,
-0.0521955267,
0.0311701875,
-0.0118869804,
-0.0175207108,
0.0343415551,
0.0061667431,
-0.0125909075,
0.0020939114,
-0.0146786179,
-0.0488369241,
0.0407444276,
-0.0242046751,
-0.0042163925,
-0.0271162242,
-0.0372639783,
-0.0028377797,
0.0778284892,
0.0234195609,
0.0002693457,
0.0424117111,
-0.0333736651,
-0.0538855679,
0.0056479606,
-0.0322089121,
0.0137603525,
-0.0595396645,
0.0006595238,
-0.0289344545,
0.0304892939,
-0.0340582021,
0.0638773963,
0.0094895475,
0.002122327,
-0.035198085,
0.0487083383,
0.0061718309,
0.0253289025,
0.0354215913,
0.0247669443,
0.0110624991,
0.0080148606,
-0.0078109014,
-0.0130088842,
-0.0328568034,
0.0267182775,
2.692e-7,
0.0185033046,
0.0335200541,
0.0504467562,
0.0001947425,
0.0151634654,
0.0284410436,
0.0418619551,
0.0340210609,
-0.0047212671,
0.0117282728,
0.0276554469,
0.0117227286,
-0.0052338596,
0.0520983748,
-0.0255890135,
0.0138452249,
-0.0952929035,
-0.1101044267,
-0.0410637148,
-0.0113262767,
0.1410329789,
0.0321601033,
-0.0098986533,
0.0308487713,
-0.0253228098,
0.0013363172,
0.0585689098,
-0.0460482314,
-0.0066231065,
0.0071084732,
0.0036265715,
0.0044113039,
-0.0453119352,
0.0469858758,
-0.0061809435,
-0.0224779285,
0.0426192656,
0.0340976156,
0.0059790574,
-0.0337377749,
0.0406293087,
0.0407538339,
0.0040619643,
-0.050887607,
0.0623837151,
-0.0494401529,
0.0054517654,
-0.0334986523,
-0.0591855571,
0.0281285085,
-0.0073633729,
-0.0305851549,
-0.0348827019,
0.0348971859,
0.0177251771,
-0.027926458,
-0.0614331588,
-0.0691993982,
0.0189907085,
0.0596679524,
0.0234998018,
-0.0033232374,
0.0013646672,
-0.0053969556,
-0.0362543873,
0.0029224365,
-0.0164445322,
1.779425466e-34,
0.0372180119,
0.0201166309,
0.0007371978,
-0.01885961,
0.0491969027,
0.0212496724,
-0.0910694376,
0.0041608308,
-0.0255410783,
-0.0060557593,
0.0213549938
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.08599v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.08599v1 | Efficient Uncertainty Estimation with Gaussian Process for Reliable Dialog Response Retrieval | 2023-03-15T13:12:16 | 2023-03-15T13:12:16 | Tong Ye, Zhitao Li, Jianzong Wang, Ning Cheng, Jing Xiao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Deep neural networks have achieved remarkable performance in retrieval-based
dialogue systems, but they are shown to be ill calibrated. Though basic
calibration methods like Monte Carlo Dropout and Ensemble can calibrate well,
these methods are time-consuming in the training or inference stages. To tackle
these challenges, we propose an efficient uncertainty calibration framework
GPF-BERT for BERT-based conversational search, which employs a Gaussian Process
layer and the focal loss on top of the BERT architecture to achieve a
high-quality neural ranker. Extensive experiments are conducted to verify the
effectiveness of our method. In comparison with basic calibration methods,
GPF-BERT achieves the lowest empirical calibration error (ECE) in three
in-domain datasets and the distributional shift tasks, while yielding the
highest $R_{10}@1$ and MAP performance on most cases. In terms of time
consumption, our GPF-BERT has an 8$\times$ speedup. | [
0.0418320969,
0.1183339059,
0.0255095512,
0.0318804793,
0.0329800509,
-0.018093802,
-0.0079857521,
-0.009622152,
-0.0268992297,
-0.0025634186,
-0.0386133268,
-0.0770287365,
0.0101736132,
0.0212492757,
-0.0160497818,
-0.0300842803,
0.0063672308,
0.0076645734,
0.0848331153,
-0.0040133954,
-0.0028508515,
-0.0227607861,
-0.0600648969,
0.0413161628,
-0.051691927,
0.0066415924,
-0.0128297806,
0.0647977069,
0.0575923733,
-0.0254601501,
0.0629815161,
0.0199589543,
0.0009304667,
0.0655552372,
0.0000019718,
-0.0206538048,
0.0117025385,
0.0005858444,
-0.0621670187,
0.0050894381,
-0.0170054063,
0.0749099031,
-0.0155325914,
0.044437442,
-0.0012952749,
0.0127279526,
0.0585568324,
0.0548175238,
0.0512748063,
0.0713443682,
-0.0058207004,
-0.0494551733,
0.0327325836,
-0.0291536674,
0.0096623972,
-0.0811251104,
-0.0199743602,
-0.0203200821,
-0.0256677158,
0.0554392003,
0.0358484723,
0.0238238424,
0.0196397379,
-0.0421144813,
-0.0122641018,
0.0171541888,
-0.0595331825,
-0.0083424514,
-0.0319746397,
0.0689000487,
0.01126754,
0.0229133721,
-0.0237475354,
-0.0227048006,
0.0124698943,
-0.0488100275,
-0.034804143,
0.0206386354,
-0.0012539519,
-0.0090497285,
-0.0647197589,
0.0223400239,
0.0232715942,
0.0138464905,
-0.0492411479,
0.0584784076,
0.0162903834,
-0.0386563241,
0.0034653745,
-0.0215265341,
-0.0374420844,
-0.0088616544,
0.0536897369,
0.0086418325,
-0.0711708814,
0.0021962228,
-0.0223235041,
-0.0060146675,
-0.0164611619,
-0.035445489,
-0.0105613982,
0.0560209192,
-0.0194121432,
0.0274383705,
0.0095224772,
0.0668777674,
-0.0172287207,
-0.0369424969,
-0.0308183134,
-0.0599071048,
-0.0294412412,
-0.0144271785,
-0.0581163839,
0.0229984038,
-0.0450496003,
-0.0565158613,
-0.050135795,
0.0419940464,
-0.0051985062,
0.026325712,
0.0015010748,
0.058797542,
-0.0605001971,
0.005794005,
-0.0401702635,
0.0647123754,
-0.0390400998,
0.0085120909,
0.0481891744,
-0.0289249104,
-0.0210084934,
0.0177300815,
0.0247088019,
-0.0214460194,
0.0265907329,
0.0113374954,
-0.0208168812,
-0.0326211341,
0.0168926641,
0.045849584,
-0.0273782611,
-0.026725078,
0.0083377864,
-0.0013341266,
0.0042134007,
-0.0199772101,
-0.0097798584,
0.0026360562,
0.0234023873,
0.0215567239,
-0.0014041279,
0.0458829887,
0.0505764671,
-0.0148900999,
0.0667883754,
-0.0113989161,
-0.0276735853,
0.0587354749,
0.0241221916,
0.0094334651,
0.0176887307,
-0.000297267,
0.0350842997,
0.0143739376,
0.0123294657,
-0.0193628743,
-0.0056308596,
0.0247331131,
-0.0527923033,
0.0547127202,
0.0395603143,
0.0559629314,
-0.0425297357,
0.000263428,
0.0578782186,
0.0489740223,
-0.0106531112,
-0.0030785552,
-0.0217692852,
0.0218190551,
0.0003271988,
-0.0348471142,
-0.0382974558,
0.0249245707,
0.0019433784,
-0.0213460159,
0.0296661183,
-0.0058773733,
-0.0266406219,
-0.0329361372,
0.0064218794,
0.0244974904,
-0.0263561122,
0.0390358455,
-0.004205869,
-0.0421578139,
-0.0589643605,
0.0878574476,
-0.0387946367,
-0.0430670641,
-0.0461074822,
-0.0286889728,
-0.0193354674,
0.0334207565,
0.0225352645,
-0.0392639749,
-0.0608562827,
-0.0121174017,
-0.01158763,
0.02530393,
0.0065616718,
-0.0071495008,
0.0628110841,
-0.0474624895,
-0.0284491796,
-0.0175906271,
-0.0022679381,
0.0090933125,
0.0136576919,
-0.0020326646,
0.0445427708,
-0.0366667323,
0.0209337119,
-0.0046329196,
0.0564348474,
-0.0381285995,
0.0436657183,
-0.0029619804,
0.0327976868,
0.025797708,
-0.0385408774,
0.0173920635,
0.011509438,
0.002702638,
-0.0052122483,
-0.0140443742,
-0.0306988619,
-0.028747227,
0.0289473869,
-0.017112432,
-0.0087061627,
0.021834543,
-0.0361532159,
-0.059461154,
0.0153741809,
-0.059134759,
-0.0012615813,
-0.0467276089,
0.0245007593,
0.0190222636,
0.0030734064,
-0.0455848686,
0.0319648311,
-0.0079116765,
0.0204642173,
0.0639484748,
0.0632637963,
0.049124781,
-0.0900869519,
-0.0250850655,
0.0065582143,
-0.0414691977,
0.0045205075,
0.0380108245,
-0.0115474463,
-0.0358634405,
-0.0310620014,
-0.1201260835,
0.0376591496,
-0.0335018821,
0.0133703295,
0.0048752665,
0.0338826999,
-0.0031389333,
-0.0220314022,
-0.0433694497,
0.0046175593,
0.0132625801,
0.0049148365,
0.0146592315,
0.0110221617,
-0.0144802034,
-0.0522130243,
0.0036591727,
0.0178364553,
0.0258838665,
-0.0250538867,
0.0178680215,
-0.0346746668,
-0.0021008642,
-0.0446005948,
0.053896483,
-0.0052540279,
-0.0680238381,
0.0272253063,
0.0053924406,
-0.0016949563,
0.0413959958,
0.0232335534,
0.0059144283,
-0.0383992493,
0.0058786841,
-0.0689297542,
0.0711302683,
-0.022299638,
-0.0092061032,
-0.0055329986,
0.0053272336,
0.0075551663,
0.0281756576,
-0.0144267483,
0.0308942664,
-0.0295099448,
0.0045198211,
0.0271535553,
-0.0158567652,
-0.0305130817,
0.004207693,
-0.0261100661,
-0.0076804892,
-0.0240054838,
-0.011887664,
0.0652278364,
-0.0470338538,
-0.0364596844,
-0.0654164702,
-0.0054026213,
0.0473513119,
-0.0179556925,
-0.019694142,
0.0037583518,
-0.0415024348,
-0.0473843887,
-0.0561041571,
-0.0071638497,
0.0442019328,
-0.0410370119,
-0.0047399187,
-0.0202644337,
0.0130197937,
-0.024000138,
-0.0593208112,
-0.0671888962,
-0.0167314503,
0.0079145618,
0.0385336764,
0.0235280078,
-0.0565544181,
-0.0392164513,
-0.0251231287,
0.0030452418,
0.0517167225,
-0.0131441616,
-0.0113759721,
-0.0161499381,
0.0522411428,
0.0399643257,
0.0271794666,
0.0242615137,
0.0120251626,
-0.0088426583,
0.024207212,
0.0620348044,
-0.0035458885,
-0.0261394307,
-0.0439231023,
0.038654305,
-0.0092531564,
0.0077108433,
0.0284790117,
0.0693727508,
-0.0209033638,
-0.0312498678,
0.1089553386,
0.0218045544,
-0.0199396927,
-0.048620332,
-0.0249906704,
0.0373474322,
0.0166269839,
0.0225947369,
-0.043284703,
-0.0170192253,
0.0341207832,
0.0430543981,
0.0018235631,
0.0036864881,
0.0374913588,
-0.1079081893,
0.0371025614,
-0.0391882285,
-0.0112432716,
-0.0496089235,
-0.0413123854,
0.0020984202,
0.0068721729,
0.0535533652,
0.0226074141,
0.0455817692,
-0.0088819927,
0.0370882377,
-0.0027513888,
-0.0458415821,
-0.0102135055,
-0.0437696986,
0.0387218744,
0.0732180998,
0.03556161,
-0.0008207629,
-0.0241392609,
0.0488632731,
-0.0597133599,
-0.0491210036,
0.021152202,
0.0345748253,
-0.0074771321,
-0.0200791731,
-0.0239040162,
0.0120580792,
0.0077884719,
-0.0043107723,
-0.0506233163,
0.0182880405,
-0.0611832403,
0.052948691,
-0.015692018,
-0.0072058085,
0.0476502441,
0.0508204848,
0.0116600236,
-0.0161457639,
-0.0279726069,
-0.0318314023,
0.0581569597,
-0.0385281257,
0.0531693995,
0.0403987691,
0.0374917164,
0.005711155,
-0.0475388058,
-0.0436092615,
-0.0306390245,
0.0527116731,
-0.0226821732,
-0.0586390831,
-0.0061754747,
0.0154545652,
-0.0411944278,
0.0321131982,
0.0379384607,
0.0055034398,
-0.0458402373,
0.0218980853,
0.0206716564,
0.016563721,
-0.017216254,
0.0346070565,
-0.0591399632,
-0.0361065716,
-0.0220445078,
0.0730181187,
0.0122660594,
-0.0085945698,
-0.0191142131,
-0.053781379,
0.0238245614,
-0.0044352999,
-0.0043687234,
-0.0249648746,
0.0440781079,
0.0394554697,
-0.0307178013,
0.0311408509,
-0.0622966625,
0.0046162638,
-0.0155423023,
0.0548426434,
-0.0201790929,
-0.0987078846,
-0.0066016638,
0.0089020496,
0.0756936222,
0.0164220631,
-0.0330210403,
-0.0418158285,
0.0672002509,
-0.022167461,
-0.0113641256,
-0.038888514,
-0.00534083,
0.0534625202,
-0.0180812608,
0.0034382206,
-0.0044195075,
0.0192345306,
0.0169346333,
-0.0374476351,
-0.0100188339,
0.0424621068,
-0.0341149569,
0.010933863,
-0.0099378144,
-0.0305988342,
0.0346049517,
0.0444215164,
0.0501242206,
0.0067950222,
0.0729861483,
0.040110901,
-0.0609455556,
0.0090845972,
0.0130097652,
-0.0759698227,
-0.0694237053,
-0.0445737243,
0.0291957427,
0.038945619,
0.0128089106,
0.0342028253,
-0.0041606207,
0.0008284908,
-0.0068896548,
0.0102684731,
0.0279173888,
-0.0046237968,
0.0303978659,
0.0282566678,
0.0115193455,
0.0092307637,
0.0276170988,
0.0141209774,
0.0329217575,
-0.025948409,
-0.0155357746,
-0.0378389433,
-0.0372201018,
-0.0087640313,
0.0310369991,
-0.0251805782,
0.0095951511,
0.0410362408,
-0.0277697872,
-0.0026848188,
-0.0017295912,
-0.0123014906,
-0.030741794,
0.0498645343,
0.0725020841,
-0.0231819525,
-0.0262901708,
-0.0048483619,
-0.0120178591,
0.0040642438,
-0.007291141,
-0.0622652173,
-6.055018054e-33,
-0.0212943461,
-0.0126614152,
-0.0029333765,
-0.0399626009,
-0.02437873,
0.0013595858,
-0.0270483382,
0.0081334328,
-0.0198656935,
0.0263202805,
-0.0166823901,
0.0389788002,
0.0373100154,
0.0564176552,
-0.0226587355,
-0.0276511796,
0.0682482645,
0.0053482475,
-0.0312962309,
-0.0239741262,
0.0366259851,
0.06994389,
0.055182673,
-0.0548235513,
-0.0337204412,
0.0152476551,
-0.0060993847,
0.0723645538,
0.0287599638,
0.024350768,
-0.0067210365,
0.0282993596,
-0.016824469,
-0.0190633554,
0.0106625911,
-0.0185178928,
-0.071024932,
-0.0427692272,
-0.020679459,
0.0420180112,
0.0121263703,
0.0439284407,
0.0473489501,
-0.0115332529,
-0.0054119467,
0.0159949176,
-0.0087730931,
-0.0156390984,
-0.0253804512,
-0.0273457505,
-0.0013711025,
0.0158751886,
-0.0111849569,
-0.0510834381,
0.0173372775,
0.0312523246,
0.0242609866,
-0.0372977592,
-0.0577395521,
-0.0464667566,
-0.0454536192,
0.029764358,
0.0128655033,
0.0703966767,
-0.0288770385,
0.0340783596,
0.0442738421,
0.0115636215,
-0.0210085344,
-0.1050767675,
-0.0033523832,
0.0167266931,
0.0162048209,
0.0328555554,
0.0006242411,
0.007998772,
-0.0555869117,
0.0448108874,
0.0228352286,
0.0520280451,
-0.0067907711,
0.0503125489,
-0.0521391705,
-0.0104130236,
-0.0312560834,
-0.0072323876,
-0.0377745442,
0.0394626111,
0.0211071037,
0.0213714447,
0.0247456469,
0.0042113317,
0.0492174365,
-0.0117611801,
0.0141549502,
0.0421389975,
0.0046589654,
-0.0077602263,
-0.0010966379,
0.037295755,
-0.032662116,
-0.0221838709,
0.0322112441,
0.0522293039,
-0.0134792086,
0.0150802815,
-0.0330513157,
-0.0047527091,
-0.0455799364,
0.0214368217,
-0.0428300872,
0.0148155438,
-0.0569348894,
0.0855980217,
-0.0133317374,
-0.035839621,
0.0208808072,
0.0489007011,
-0.0203436259,
0.0611047298,
-0.008074264,
-0.0233789049,
0.0331998095,
-0.0121194897,
-0.0328464098,
0.0188654624,
0.0160797797,
0.0055517522,
-0.0481616147,
-0.0605763644,
0.0022347709,
-0.0134055391,
2.761e-7,
0.0179435778,
0.0123764435,
0.0351066962,
0.036507979,
0.020706838,
0.0328891017,
0.005444366,
0.0149027742,
0.0187160913,
-0.0161843505,
0.0368777774,
-0.0159399286,
0.0266692787,
0.0239031147,
-0.0845309123,
-0.1018925831,
-0.0731904209,
-0.0073669935,
0.0033665572,
-0.035208445,
0.0186579321,
0.0956890211,
-0.0344903097,
-0.001621347,
0.0317073688,
-0.027204657,
0.0499363057,
-0.0178461038,
0.0076178489,
0.0346476622,
0.0835890099,
0.0139776561,
-0.0033242183,
0.018071834,
-0.0084411586,
0.0431633182,
0.0143430308,
0.0543572009,
-0.009104494,
-0.0916601866,
-0.0332431123,
0.0043101967,
0.0327793211,
-0.0706612095,
0.0065367469,
-0.0263039675,
-0.0082732718,
0.0117469849,
-0.0435723066,
-0.0116139557,
0.0642145127,
-0.0237072185,
-0.0212556403,
-0.0167602096,
0.0029175889,
0.0071866335,
0.0043729064,
-0.1089819297,
-0.0134699177,
0.0108515983,
-0.0575646423,
-0.0249175169,
-0.0186499823,
-0.0883526504,
0.0368444249,
-0.0032622523,
0.0114836264,
2.159429729e-34,
0.0634670034,
-0.015080112,
-0.0058238511,
0.0426779352,
0.0359791145,
0.0142778829,
0.0205569118,
-0.0202936903,
0.0239011236,
-0.0502128564,
-0.0149019472
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.08559v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.08559v2 | Large Language Model Is Not a Good Few-shot Information Extractor, but a Good Reranker for Hard Samples! | 2023-03-15T12:20:13 | 2023-10-21T14:44:11 | Yubo Ma, Yixin Cao, YongChing Hong, Aixin Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) have made remarkable strides in various tasks.
Whether LLMs are competitive few-shot solvers for information extraction (IE)
tasks, however, remains an open problem. In this work, we aim to provide a
thorough answer to this question. Through extensive experiments on nine
datasets across four IE tasks, we demonstrate that current advanced LLMs
consistently exhibit inferior performance, higher latency, and increased budget
requirements compared to fine-tuned SLMs under most settings. Therefore, we
conclude that LLMs are not effective few-shot information extractors in
general. Nonetheless, we illustrate that with appropriate prompting strategies,
LLMs can effectively complement SLMs and tackle challenging samples that SLMs
struggle with. And moreover, we propose an adaptive filter-then-rerank paradigm
to combine the strengths of LLMs and SLMs. In this paradigm, SLMs serve as
filters and LLMs serve as rerankers. By prompting LLMs to rerank a small
portion of difficult samples identified by SLMs, our preliminary system
consistently achieves promising improvements (2.4% F1-gain on average) on
various IE tasks, with an acceptable time and cost investment. | [
0.0381058119,
0.0698733181,
0.005777353,
0.0528367087,
-0.0373217389,
0.0296085328,
0.0180065781,
0.0386482477,
0.0097216032,
-0.073995918,
-0.0259673223,
-0.0201878864,
-0.0174636208,
-0.022172831,
0.0020889321,
-0.0047206297,
0.0080713024,
-0.0299769528,
0.037684083,
0.0088598235,
-0.022640001,
0.0227916446,
0.0130181173,
-0.008565885,
0.0481723733,
0.0265877284,
0.0196649022,
0.0014813042,
0.0347812586,
-0.0152618671,
-0.0184159987,
0.0225154832,
0.0111794723,
0.0497791432,
0.0000020064,
-0.0424126722,
-0.0235968474,
0.0053620883,
-0.0670611709,
0.0090740612,
0.0136756273,
-0.0272548962,
-0.0077739833,
0.0037672559,
-0.0253347959,
-0.0396074057,
0.0150335068,
0.0018193623,
0.0386170931,
0.0757684186,
-0.0124747837,
-0.0460363999,
-0.0093241893,
-0.0487454496,
-0.0000175795,
-0.0651140437,
0.067951344,
-0.0325198025,
0.016044572,
0.011272762,
0.0116958302,
0.063607581,
-0.0234970506,
0.0208584853,
0.0130118653,
0.0313504674,
-0.0520543084,
0.0145366583,
-0.0068684039,
0.0751185268,
-0.0896514654,
0.0181768052,
0.026658278,
-0.0164640974,
-0.0201364588,
0.0145978471,
-0.0566937663,
0.0145757273,
-0.0087504843,
0.0516158566,
0.0088335564,
-0.0031797218,
0.0355475396,
0.0427983217,
-0.0539450534,
0.0500229411,
0.002659776,
-0.0348599739,
0.0055030328,
0.0153644243,
-0.0104195839,
-0.0328854173,
0.0056094676,
0.0205652714,
0.0015997706,
0.0291630439,
-0.0324578322,
-0.0223004445,
-0.007934737,
-0.0262076836,
0.0366981849,
0.0066612959,
0.0176905356,
0.0971653089,
-0.0334728546,
0.0499501415,
0.0129410774,
0.0156241013,
-0.0339222848,
-0.0174815077,
-0.0343457535,
-0.0114283795,
0.0037982122,
0.056089364,
-0.0249216966,
-0.0084543657,
-0.022405168,
-0.0062228534,
0.0117992051,
0.0113993641,
-0.0059498437,
-0.0437638275,
-0.0002765365,
-0.0118184797,
-0.0000627959,
0.028498875,
0.0252908114,
0.0157687608,
-0.0270734783,
-0.0220928174,
-0.0241967291,
0.0010891639,
0.0457202159,
-0.0301014259,
0.0446085706,
0.0472363196,
-0.0081773819,
-0.0618620105,
-0.0155448541,
0.0085343467,
-0.0060012112,
-0.0628840178,
-0.0157955308,
-0.0465959013,
0.0897451192,
0.0092490437,
-0.0005465107,
-0.0392892919,
0.025384644,
-0.0081480183,
-0.084521614,
0.0717118308,
0.0144270482,
0.0305502843,
0.021861596,
-0.0069401618,
0.033192113,
0.0733521432,
0.0265176371,
0.0331924707,
0.0468937233,
-0.0011429819,
0.0142804505,
0.0671568736,
-0.0055267201,
-0.0157526396,
-0.01827389,
-0.0151556851,
-0.0339395776,
-0.0290390067,
0.0282348488,
0.0504024662,
-0.0339149684,
-0.0099783782,
0.0771592706,
0.0401487201,
0.0613252707,
-0.0168634057,
-0.0067187324,
0.010217539,
-0.0088574328,
0.010635836,
-0.0252855849,
-0.0006187122,
-0.0321263038,
0.0205468554,
0.038393043,
0.0612864047,
-0.0136131076,
-0.0303614717,
-0.0239044204,
0.0005989192,
-0.042030964,
0.0700988024,
0.0810931772,
-0.0203196071,
-0.005952586,
0.0393454954,
0.0404220596,
-0.0212975107,
0.0039128964,
-0.0446541496,
0.0203686338,
0.092170909,
0.0578344427,
-0.0643720329,
-0.0115336971,
-0.0009549474,
0.0060075531,
0.0138718784,
0.0151531463,
-0.0190779865,
0.0548452176,
-0.0372782052,
-0.0240716115,
0.0322187953,
0.0040798704,
0.0188791733,
0.0255456436,
-0.0116524417,
0.0114073856,
0.0169220194,
-0.0238446444,
0.0340366811,
-0.0049348529,
-0.0525432639,
0.0296132304,
-0.0141176954,
0.0365118608,
-0.0010975738,
-0.0326027572,
-0.0094045298,
0.0409324504,
-0.0714462847,
-0.0001495255,
-0.0546237193,
0.0037258621,
-0.0869216248,
0.0281271674,
0.0244140718,
0.014030925,
0.023235498,
-0.0669950172,
0.0016284839,
-0.0102601089,
0.0153826242,
-0.0016922666,
-0.0245500915,
0.0435198881,
0.0325196683,
0.0219852105,
-0.0806840584,
0.0606770255,
0.0006323087,
-0.0044331211,
0.0194117241,
-0.0323586091,
-0.0515653826,
-0.0301251784,
-0.0428162254,
0.0470887236,
-0.0273898598,
-0.0028608963,
-0.0098487893,
0.0093025798,
-0.0078875124,
-0.0485788547,
-0.0414561704,
0.0228707734,
-0.0154656293,
0.0180112068,
-0.0010301614,
0.0065551847,
-0.0092152888,
-0.0130932406,
-0.0176367424,
-0.0137456227,
-0.0015997895,
0.0110756652,
0.0191364549,
0.0380730331,
-0.0021584248,
-0.0569694564,
-0.0311898217,
0.011515717,
0.0614874996,
-0.0323687345,
-0.0689588413,
-0.0225955267,
0.0402919278,
-0.0428660884,
0.01840958,
-0.0088790441,
-0.0043215477,
-0.0615824386,
-0.0314588584,
0.0036706587,
0.0475795791,
-0.0040169344,
0.0432952903,
0.0319254734,
-0.031614352,
-0.0612400584,
0.0076466748,
-0.0412222371,
0.0129000554,
-0.0067736246,
-0.0260037631,
0.0105775418,
0.0612279661,
-0.0177280512,
0.0290646106,
0.0043871342,
0.0599677153,
-0.012017956,
-0.0155995032,
-0.0611965917,
0.018476123,
0.0036751016,
0.0032387737,
-0.0408257209,
-0.0237830356,
0.0659558475,
-0.0428663269,
-0.0080614006,
-0.005682542,
-0.0332279578,
-0.0482627675,
0.0209746696,
-0.0106954621,
0.0073531279,
-0.0086549893,
-0.0031275114,
-0.0224014912,
-0.0191327762,
0.0269608516,
-0.0694503188,
0.0579973236,
-0.041182518,
0.0295069572,
-0.0286670607,
-0.0516322963,
-0.0238730013,
-0.0684053674,
-0.0146635855,
0.0111093502,
0.0066233543,
0.0222094022,
-0.0427700765,
0.0722957551,
0.0310680382,
0.0444948114,
-0.0204927623,
0.0060012471,
-0.0177181792,
0.0511527658,
0.0658062249,
-0.0057459548,
-0.0067179431,
-0.0103601785,
0.0748299286,
0.0480259508,
0.0553422049,
-0.0012495669,
0.0093746409,
-0.0088342251,
0.028047476,
-0.0280550439,
-0.0029203261,
-0.0264110118,
0.0105757127,
-0.0589915812,
0.0015721202,
0.1197166741,
0.0230631921,
-0.0212693233,
-0.0226858016,
0.0412231945,
0.0019658469,
0.0181484669,
0.0291658174,
-0.0586706772,
-0.0277578104,
0.0207152441,
0.0180760622,
-0.028639663,
-0.0383570194,
-0.0121532409,
-0.1298037767,
0.0508841872,
0.026099585,
-0.0367865302,
-0.0009819872,
-0.0247971434,
0.0268104095,
-0.0174769834,
-0.0040552095,
0.02565993,
-0.0373335928,
-0.0105311675,
0.0062505887,
-0.0179593079,
-0.0628939718,
-0.0002962979,
-0.0231327415,
0.01049654,
0.0353136621,
0.0194004327,
0.0000727191,
0.0374750718,
0.0054155756,
-0.0282478593,
-0.0268405806,
-0.0398919433,
0.0433002189,
-0.041485332,
-0.0216861963,
0.0071607465,
-0.0019135235,
0.0075775837,
-0.0015185266,
0.0068063117,
0.0537815578,
-0.0078047547,
-0.0010401633,
0.0231173467,
-0.0235289764,
-0.0303694848,
0.0832237154,
0.02650523,
-0.0316035077,
0.0106258718,
0.0000042174,
-0.0306929089,
-0.0351903476,
-0.0367757604,
0.0198395737,
-0.0428733863,
-0.0118254591,
-0.0780189931,
-0.0317082033,
0.0703433007,
0.0210502092,
-0.0233439039,
0.0398731418,
-0.0079885907,
0.0218591355,
-0.0428563543,
-0.0028758131,
-0.0406026356,
-0.0104418406,
-0.0374955274,
0.004724138,
0.0373603962,
-0.0178986508,
-0.0321699418,
0.0148507161,
-0.0753342286,
-0.0603193305,
-0.0152630368,
0.0267046262,
0.0259342287,
0.0093659628,
-0.0043611932,
-0.0614238493,
0.0561546721,
0.0400246456,
-0.0206300598,
0.013891479,
0.0064376513,
-0.0147733362,
-0.008059646,
0.0371032394,
-0.0832376108,
0.0314563252,
0.0300812107,
0.0194856524,
-0.0609006248,
-0.0140731735,
0.0155935893,
0.0519931167,
0.0855030566,
-0.003884542,
-0.0404998623,
-0.038893003,
0.0392223485,
-0.029344894,
-0.034821447,
-0.0466424264,
-0.0040936754,
0.0330672897,
0.0007860935,
-0.0321047045,
0.0056704311,
0.0197191089,
0.0321004279,
-0.0760825202,
0.0099103432,
-0.0403856784,
-0.0456118807,
0.0338233449,
-0.0071068839,
-0.0014889791,
0.041616302,
0.0536252037,
-0.0013503821,
-0.0439025238,
0.0136861261,
-0.0008554782,
-0.011185199,
-0.0245340113,
0.0371786319,
-0.0552759953,
-0.0180942435,
-0.0520539582,
0.0248464532,
0.0613667443,
-0.0335934833,
0.0671565682,
0.0275810435,
-0.0113602914,
-0.0377828255,
-0.0251753852,
0.0193239786,
-0.0014659928,
0.0447689444,
0.0531065315,
-0.0360651948,
0.0526699647,
0.0963263959,
0.0280594695,
0.0196573474,
0.0137738595,
-0.015499928,
-0.0428869091,
-0.0212931242,
-0.006933263,
-0.0006002245,
-0.0421626717,
-0.0049566273,
-0.0458350815,
-0.0320004113,
0.0271868128,
-0.0445707217,
-0.0330867469,
-0.0239822213,
-0.0025025222,
0.0605558008,
0.0114364009,
-0.0007363665,
-0.0624980778,
-0.027311312,
-0.0086885113,
-0.0423186719,
0.0380784906,
-6.864726848e-33,
-0.048465088,
0.0058085797,
-0.0027152961,
-0.0021328158,
0.0022039979,
0.0215943512,
-0.0115047768,
0.0081472825,
-0.0123648122,
-0.0143933957,
-0.0222056322,
-0.0220523532,
0.040506091,
0.0196850747,
-0.0152134439,
-0.0112443203,
0.0406521,
0.0004520907,
-0.0169659369,
-0.0102579817,
0.0247093216,
0.0652360544,
0.0330535918,
-0.0371274725,
-0.0464826785,
0.0017002308,
0.0002083277,
0.0173839126,
0.0343221836,
0.0597420521,
-0.0181466956,
0.0342554264,
0.0388216339,
-0.0529496148,
-0.003973593,
0.0033401849,
-0.0637193099,
0.0155795347,
0.0000626893,
-0.0201370437,
0.0284086987,
-0.0228049699,
0.0431466848,
0.0017896381,
0.0226149857,
-0.0269247666,
0.0067668394,
-0.0544016249,
-0.0490398593,
-0.053346213,
-0.0095316824,
0.0563103408,
0.0086974232,
-0.0221330356,
0.1032163054,
0.0265769195,
-0.011056805,
0.0724740177,
-0.0116617102,
-0.0047028409,
0.0133078359,
0.085178107,
0.047706794,
0.0308550596,
-0.0166160315,
0.0641205907,
0.0108246645,
-0.0280221943,
0.0306397323,
-0.0325668007,
0.0115781901,
0.0534338914,
0.0318535864,
0.0194427166,
0.0092261471,
0.0107396338,
-0.0947357118,
0.0169604216,
0.0461263657,
0.020156581,
0.0262632612,
0.0299201272,
-0.038073536,
-0.0204742644,
0.0015822557,
-0.0099528339,
-0.0464750305,
0.0025784178,
0.0361393057,
0.0462034829,
-0.0353187807,
0.0375924781,
0.0528411865,
-0.0276208259,
-0.0209772475,
-0.0046517779,
0.0047979676,
0.0149234571,
-0.0163565762,
-0.0034684993,
-0.0865463763,
-0.031522844,
0.0022585629,
0.0022534165,
-0.0035268613,
-0.0211777631,
0.0365524665,
0.0106708799,
-0.0675666556,
-0.0154557824,
-0.0324547738,
0.0211097524,
-0.0105149457,
0.05328032,
-0.003449569,
-0.0037298987,
0.0081485277,
0.0363390259,
0.0345696062,
-0.0226404183,
0.0148234498,
0.0008584894,
0.0086472835,
-0.0004371218,
-0.0032462694,
0.0180118755,
-0.0069083464,
-0.0012455961,
0.0174489766,
-0.0290565528,
-0.0057326527,
0.0096600251,
2.772e-7,
0.0264201481,
0.0694219321,
-0.014801519,
0.0068670744,
0.0211028084,
-0.0015242165,
-0.0402239189,
-0.0126992064,
0.0141207445,
0.0211444702,
0.028236717,
0.0212051831,
0.0648041517,
0.0336314775,
-0.0815414637,
0.0002515368,
-0.0708695054,
-0.0475065671,
-0.0550447181,
-0.0645706728,
0.0129590826,
0.1129353866,
0.0016405075,
0.0014437835,
-0.0451313332,
-0.0765156075,
0.042155426,
-0.0312261768,
-0.0191218294,
0.0123428972,
0.0601009801,
0.0153435385,
-0.030261904,
0.0112647694,
-0.0195598081,
0.0537990704,
0.0387075879,
0.1003174409,
-0.0131854294,
-0.0264382102,
0.0002348238,
-0.0002319161,
0.0055431831,
-0.0347317494,
0.1109723225,
-0.0703845471,
0.0015553256,
-0.0155517189,
-0.0239209626,
-0.0148826437,
-0.0229939017,
-0.0272010081,
-0.0225577634,
0.0482936017,
0.0273758601,
-0.0239878856,
-0.045213785,
-0.1013026834,
-0.0076649594,
0.0259521436,
-0.0250544213,
-0.0211047512,
-0.012582114,
-0.0292593576,
-0.0121895103,
-0.0444123261,
0.0008331757,
2.591629614e-34,
0.0213632658,
0.0093712984,
-0.0373529717,
0.0647091046,
0.0124644069,
-0.0033389495,
-0.0891641602,
0.0381940342,
-0.0427546725,
-0.1177406609,
0.0182886254
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.08553v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.08553v2 | The Image of the Process Interpretation of Regular Expressions is Not Closed under Bisimulation Collapse | 2023-03-15T12:13:30 | 2023-11-12T12:52:31 | Clemens Grabmayer | cs.LO | cs.LO, cs.CL, F.4.1 | Axiomatization and expressibility problems for Milner's process semantics
(1984) of regular expressions modulo bisimilarity have turned out to be
difficult for the full class of expressions with deadlock 0 and empty step~1.
We report on a phenomenon that arises from the added presence of 1 when 0 is
available, and that brings a crucial reason for this difficulty into focus. To
wit, while interpretations of 1-free regular expressions are closed under
bisimulation collapse, this is not the case for the interpretations of
arbitrary regular expressions.
Process graph interpretations of 1-free regular expressions satisfy the loop
existence and elimination property LEE, which is preserved under bisimulation
collapse. These features of LEE were applied for showing that an equational
proof system for 1-free regular expressions modulo bisimilarity is complete,
and that it is decidable in polynomial time whether a process graph is
bisimilar to the interpretation of a 1-free regular expression.
While interpretations of regular expressions do not satisfy the property LEE
in general, we show that LEE can be recovered by refined interpretations as
graphs with 1-transitions refined interpretations with 1-transitions (which are
similar to silent steps for automata). This suggests that LEE can be expedient
also for the general axiomatization and expressibility problems. But a new
phenomenon emerges that needs to be addressed: the property of a process graph
`to can be refined into a process graph with 1-transitions and with LEE' is not
preserved under bisimulation collapse. We provide a 10-vertex graph with two
1-transitions that satisfies LEE, and in which a pair of bisimilar vertices
cannot be collapsed on to each other while preserving the refinement property.
This implies that the image of the process interpretation of regular
expressions is not closed under bisimulation collapse. | [
-0.0290687978,
0.0760320798,
-0.0073740454,
0.0169617571,
-0.032553371,
-0.0307408292,
-0.0175405852,
0.0001084977,
-0.035922911,
-0.0026606189,
0.0255688746,
0.012301838,
0.0044755763,
0.0474292003,
0.001004413,
-0.0164052453,
0.053138826,
-0.0280846525,
0.0577775948,
0.0167501383,
0.0165866707,
0.006064604,
-0.0232891496,
0.0198474098,
-0.0107730664,
0.0094433725,
-0.0143408366,
-0.0064894636,
-0.0088807102,
-0.0300297253,
-0.0947054997,
-0.0047233836,
-0.0557152219,
0.0229424331,
0.0000018361,
-0.0268187877,
-0.0380822867,
0.0583506487,
-0.0852977931,
0.0592817552,
-0.0716725141,
0.0113854175,
-0.0084258588,
0.0261224266,
0.0137951327,
-0.0706674829,
0.069889605,
0.0332402103,
0.022596024,
0.0175150111,
-0.0280161519,
-0.0329774208,
0.038945403,
-0.0039163418,
0.0233866032,
-0.0738941655,
0.0582619868,
-0.0436914749,
0.0364975482,
-0.0455025844,
-0.0122799966,
-0.0355085284,
-0.0001950914,
-0.0403560661,
-0.0869204476,
-0.0113682514,
0.0802391544,
-0.0001925096,
0.0429602265,
0.000758725,
-0.0378687717,
0.0170993134,
-0.0320965834,
0.0178449098,
-0.0189412404,
-0.0208159983,
-0.017922787,
0.0474576652,
-0.0069103241,
0.0533493124,
-0.0207500458,
-0.0236967299,
0.064256534,
-0.0579477884,
-0.0107412478,
0.073448956,
0.0396288149,
-0.0026517224,
-0.0578138381,
0.0001744535,
0.020128103,
-0.028459793,
0.0097325612,
0.0296612587,
-0.0022308712,
0.0324379019,
-0.0191605333,
0.0946576819,
-0.0078972783,
0.074128978,
0.0246898066,
0.0422900096,
0.0498057231,
0.0129714552,
-0.0093768369,
-0.0407471322,
0.00607567,
0.0441430882,
-0.0131552229,
0.0301184151,
-0.0256290007,
-0.0237791836,
-0.0846982077,
0.0289565213,
0.0449442081,
0.0141693475,
-0.033185713,
0.0335896611,
-0.0453432016,
0.0375067033,
-0.0422894508,
-0.0711948127,
-0.0112761967,
0.0306361187,
-0.0234593749,
0.0494888425,
0.0323761143,
-0.013756684,
-0.0141122146,
-0.0507445224,
-0.0302464608,
-0.00108239,
0.0260071047,
-0.0106296679,
-0.0058622118,
0.0315852314,
0.0265881196,
0.0162506793,
-0.0288753882,
-0.0314886905,
0.0782618448,
0.0067944294,
0.0218896195,
0.010658999,
0.0018319574,
0.0221921932,
0.0263217594,
-0.0147710461,
-0.030888401,
-0.0130662899,
-0.0035299866,
0.0426973701,
-0.0253550112,
-0.002974594,
-0.0809914023,
-0.0153903197,
0.0270573311,
0.0036042333,
-0.0141381314,
-0.0249512792,
0.0203117616,
-0.0424510911,
0.0537201948,
0.0260852817,
-0.0255265702,
-0.0239840634,
0.0036865172,
-0.0365216918,
0.0128358835,
-0.0764529407,
-0.0102510266,
0.0716776252,
-0.0274584517,
-0.0061319829,
-0.0768505409,
-0.0006541855,
-0.0158710107,
0.023702858,
0.03114032,
0.0364712998,
0.0406233855,
0.0583059825,
-0.0091293715,
-0.0549138561,
-0.0165828355,
0.0195275825,
-0.0162842628,
-0.062535271,
-0.0194971804,
-0.0502078459,
-0.0175650883,
0.0110681755,
0.0374626368,
-0.042148266,
0.0385391936,
-0.0263754241,
-0.043475464,
-0.0059576989,
-0.0292565059,
-0.0106588677,
0.0208005272,
-0.0521125682,
-0.0031534776,
0.0438122228,
0.0371100642,
-0.0503617227,
-0.0197839886,
-0.0090550771,
-0.0601295456,
-0.0260670856,
-0.0011439377,
-0.0150628947,
0.0376386717,
-0.0036034556,
-0.0300260223,
0.0269987117,
0.028679166,
-0.019843353,
-0.0794559717,
-0.0182778351,
-0.006501032,
0.0086005805,
-0.0258978158,
0.0047010984,
0.0583028495,
-0.0599319078,
-0.0090174126,
0.0160725955,
0.0199862514,
-0.0127589311,
-0.0391195714,
0.0715137422,
0.0353425369,
-0.0028489714,
0.0262029972,
0.0654592142,
0.0106442999,
0.0321149305,
0.0330033638,
-0.0273211375,
-0.0329074971,
0.0330227502,
-0.0387786143,
-0.0351425745,
0.0858087465,
-0.0401379727,
0.0100158406,
0.0235066917,
0.0515093282,
-0.013659223,
0.0135056879,
0.0098573882,
-0.0008699489,
0.012268926,
0.017456891,
-0.049261719,
-0.0529769249,
0.0681938082,
0.0081544947,
-0.0867829397,
0.0258899331,
-0.014529041,
-0.021162523,
0.0382590629,
-0.0075535239,
0.0131101888,
0.0132483086,
-0.0084572388,
0.0213488825,
0.0057554836,
0.091143921,
0.0173568018,
0.0541631691,
0.0101198945,
-0.0053278254,
0.0159873422,
-0.0001571754,
0.0894868672,
0.0214642007,
0.024681177,
0.0395105965,
-0.1118228734,
0.0118835522,
-0.0644494519,
-0.0433537923,
0.0093460903,
-0.0412091725,
0.017760817,
-0.0308282282,
-0.0375654623,
0.000889823,
0.0416202359,
0.000252054,
0.0398554727,
0.0702443197,
-0.0297303759,
-0.0387072191,
-0.0082865059,
-0.0034541199,
0.0519738682,
-0.0018348062,
-0.0138534326,
0.0558394194,
-0.0181399714,
0.0141998334,
-0.0301531199,
-0.0368915759,
-0.0094551984,
0.0222638436,
0.0529706441,
-0.0377738625,
-0.02476486,
-0.0231151953,
-0.0219008084,
0.0159868337,
0.0529557131,
0.0037759345,
-0.0923548043,
-0.0073527312,
0.0155563327,
-0.0375226997,
-0.0056484235,
0.0143109867,
-0.0267506354,
0.0134698814,
-0.0171338841,
0.02465613,
-0.0260291528,
0.0456995964,
-0.0314337835,
-0.0055597229,
0.0293992683,
-0.0126435114,
0.0190273765,
-0.0666996986,
0.0380792134,
-0.0116214249,
-0.014669368,
0.0010391246,
0.0412538424,
-0.0350932255,
-0.0068289191,
-0.0369524285,
0.0372157358,
-0.0064269174,
0.0433254763,
0.0616768561,
0.0224446431,
-0.0110816257,
0.0474388897,
-0.0210255068,
-0.0257574804,
0.0223554205,
0.0118790967,
-0.0142008523,
-0.0461049341,
-0.0298160706,
0.0002281801,
-0.0402460918,
-0.0086370418,
-0.0291742273,
-0.0075545982,
0.0255946834,
0.023442449,
-0.0095657939,
-0.0149938008,
0.0197467823,
-0.0803697705,
-0.0170478467,
-0.0215236545,
-0.0238770489,
-0.0428958535,
-0.0100001497,
0.0133937132,
0.0004614688,
-0.004587817,
0.0484814271,
-0.0316826887,
-0.0213989727,
0.0024826853,
0.0163370054,
-0.0995722562,
0.0399285294,
-0.0084444396,
-0.0100581562,
-0.002478119,
0.0008380753,
0.0154884486,
-0.0113030495,
-0.0154198557,
0.0130013376,
-0.0378327072,
0.0001746216,
-0.0233777706,
0.0429178923,
0.026341401,
-0.0415956862,
0.0237023626,
0.0018416726,
0.0119062709,
0.0152026657,
0.0216240939,
-0.0138905235,
-0.0209366381,
0.0382400677,
-0.0350754149,
-0.0195100233,
0.0398530625,
-0.016624907,
-0.0716879442,
0.0813255534,
0.030650299,
-0.0137070408,
-0.0268675908,
-0.0599459,
0.0564822964,
-0.0159600023,
-0.0150691718,
-0.0223242585,
0.0088781081,
-0.0163723901,
0.0117353639,
0.0658127069,
0.0164889023,
-0.0363690034,
-0.0034297786,
-0.0543253012,
-0.0043112002,
0.0126473932,
-0.011293551,
0.0377119966,
-0.069297336,
-0.0300389379,
-0.0091113197,
0.0144705269,
-0.0299705304,
-0.0332182385,
-0.016894903,
-0.0375694558,
0.0261227507,
0.0207118057,
0.0419395529,
0.0757724643,
-0.0469185933,
-0.0080637168,
0.0364030637,
0.0049777185,
-0.0501029566,
0.0321692266,
-0.075848192,
0.0313579999,
-0.0156544913,
0.0111338049,
-0.0761479363,
0.0559245124,
-0.0270877201,
0.0061558178,
0.0298509374,
-0.0008089357,
0.0233744774,
0.0031037214,
0.0299660042,
-0.0223175455,
-0.0175249726,
0.0098341815,
-0.0291571002,
-0.0494514517,
0.0143939434,
-0.0206800736,
0.0699417442,
-0.0343147144,
0.0207761265,
-0.0169367883,
0.0237020664,
0.0145833567,
-0.0101942774,
0.0160997231,
-0.0006500934,
-0.0528753027,
0.0125501696,
0.1320213228,
-0.018038867,
0.0596858039,
0.0238744058,
0.0184490401,
0.0052546784,
-0.0189905614,
0.011591753,
-0.0516904891,
0.0111241192,
-0.0218962077,
-0.002338975,
-0.0076549193,
-0.0361553244,
0.0010646305,
-0.0078638652,
0.0525933802,
0.0080133509,
0.0151828323,
0.0323002711,
0.0280513205,
0.0037276335,
0.0181766525,
0.0427753963,
0.0132681066,
-0.0039087324,
-0.0017747392,
-0.0308832172,
0.0436773486,
0.0537786558,
-0.044514101,
-0.0009689064,
0.002481068,
-0.0364451073,
0.0391372032,
-0.0288064461,
0.0471494347,
0.0154558886,
0.0175060667,
-0.0061620064,
0.0220003352,
-0.0327137932,
-0.0053614439,
-0.0021489537,
-0.0371053703,
0.001096303,
0.0583849549,
0.0154782077,
0.0110180862,
0.0238185562,
-0.017724419,
0.0376373008,
-0.0236452464,
-0.019877689,
-0.082907699,
-0.0460618958,
-0.043501839,
0.0985298231,
0.0336251035,
0.0074636796,
-0.0477121435,
-0.0733386055,
0.0052720131,
0.0088168243,
0.0372238196,
0.0006300462,
-0.0019164685,
0.0271710772,
0.041282624,
-0.0328841098,
-0.0045893295,
0.0261127464,
0.0324078314,
-0.0192393698,
0.0056220377,
-5.285866753e-33,
0.0027180244,
0.0031120011,
-0.0047458713,
0.0028497765,
-0.0408633575,
-0.0216628425,
-0.0872221515,
0.0432529449,
0.0017431754,
0.0151054766,
-0.0357899666,
-0.0126597108,
0.0239389353,
0.0086607523,
-0.0662296191,
-0.0139092747,
0.0768176392,
0.0070412601,
-0.0549308024,
-0.016828116,
0.0517609492,
-0.0462532267,
0.0312443376,
-0.0369459614,
0.0626108944,
-0.0475130528,
-0.0616919063,
0.0129819922,
-0.0309975222,
0.0361666158,
-0.0106977317,
0.0393368751,
0.0121551212,
0.0226015486,
-0.0434009098,
-0.0233960003,
-0.0490756743,
-0.0188125949,
0.051975362,
-0.0190362148,
-0.0478244238,
-0.0218766537,
0.0737488717,
-0.0063379621,
-0.0235032924,
0.0678205788,
-0.0403309353,
0.0032357348,
0.0157937407,
0.0607512482,
-0.0313459188,
0.0127352867,
-0.0270368177,
0.0158201195,
0.0145778907,
-0.0546015389,
-0.0260131601,
-0.0896772593,
0.0507024936,
0.021969445,
0.0030524579,
0.0067171706,
-0.0054604122,
-0.0504651144,
-0.0002132277,
-0.0303946529,
-0.0038595777,
0.0318775587,
0.0494934767,
0.0166210365,
0.0182910413,
0.0514006875,
-0.0157899372,
-0.0528309606,
0.0489591621,
-0.0019327345,
-0.019545408,
0.0467480384,
0.0031121001,
0.0733945072,
-0.0114296842,
0.0089366669,
-0.0222269408,
-0.0339957513,
-0.0356654637,
0.0334685631,
-0.0271665119,
0.0078509934,
-0.0056392387,
-0.0043769907,
-0.0184962656,
0.0882181227,
0.042354811,
-0.0312669948,
-0.041657459,
0.0362193175,
0.0185611155,
0.0021439097,
-0.0124211647,
-0.0391563177,
0.0326857902,
-0.0281787217,
-0.0091317054,
-0.0209663268,
0.0043682936,
0.0220373701,
-0.0182716548,
0.0117361145,
-0.0503801331,
-0.0070680669,
-0.0155972522,
0.0259775203,
0.0046523577,
0.0234233383,
0.0477463119,
-0.0079683075,
0.0150398714,
-0.0497629382,
0.0074262596,
-0.0003601426,
0.0035580061,
0.092079781,
0.0155889532,
0.0422266684,
-0.0030887031,
-0.0625216439,
0.0138078183,
-0.0138586424,
0.0430282094,
-0.0442145579,
-0.0064978469,
-0.0288100969,
2.772e-7,
0.064145416,
-0.0408612937,
0.1063459814,
0.0300511066,
0.0286625773,
-0.020940626,
0.0349170007,
-0.0231402311,
-0.0386843607,
0.0537098423,
0.008757703,
0.0051426911,
-0.0665830746,
-0.027858058,
0.0503586642,
0.0068791048,
0.0163697861,
0.0204596203,
0.0269415714,
0.0270065051,
0.0261406526,
-0.0197842922,
0.0101065282,
0.01883219,
-0.0105183674,
0.0011375984,
-0.0241651367,
0.0571414828,
0.0203168094,
0.03240503,
0.048538696,
-0.0284215882,
0.0388167799,
-0.0039689769,
0.0148255881,
0.0598017499,
-0.0213446692,
0.0476619713,
-0.0214234106,
0.0327746458,
-0.0136827119,
-0.0604527555,
0.014242298,
0.0477556996,
0.0502031818,
0.0325478278,
-0.0976914838,
-0.0377798378,
-0.0547772013,
0.0009653762,
-0.0154030742,
0.0740403906,
-0.0488362983,
0.0296395253,
-0.0176508091,
-0.0207652356,
0.0111210532,
-0.0097142393,
-0.0021421118,
-0.0512999892,
-0.0280689634,
-0.0053660343,
-0.0127832228,
0.0409473106,
0.0064995852,
0.0144223375,
-0.0083315549,
2.789028636e-34,
0.0612856522,
-0.0663902014,
0.0506347157,
-0.0196708031,
-0.0059202253,
-0.011020151,
-0.0421217643,
0.0241652615,
0.0270692464,
-0.0597300045,
-0.0398062356
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.08518v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.08518v4 | UPRISE: Universal Prompt Retrieval for Improving Zero-Shot Evaluation | 2023-03-15T10:53:49 | 2023-12-16T06:50:09 | Daixuan Cheng, Shaohan Huang, Junyu Bi, Yuefeng Zhan, Jianfeng Liu, Yujing Wang, Hao Sun, Furu Wei, Denvy Deng, Qi Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) are popular for their impressive abilities, but
the need for model-specific fine-tuning or task-specific prompt engineering can
hinder their generalization. We propose UPRISE (Universal Prompt Retrieval for
Improving zero-Shot Evaluation), which tunes a lightweight and versatile
retriever that automatically retrieves prompts for a given zero-shot task
input. Specifically, we demonstrate universality in a cross-task and
cross-model scenario: the retriever is tuned on a diverse set of tasks, but
tested on unseen task types; we use a small frozen LLM, GPT-Neo-2.7B, for
tuning the retriever, but test the retriever on different LLMs of much larger
scales, such as BLOOM-7.1B, OPT-66B and GPT3-175B. Additionally, we show that
UPRISE mitigates the hallucination problem in our experiments with ChatGPT,
suggesting its potential to improve even the strongest LLMs. Our model and code
are available at https://github.com/microsoft/LMOps. | [
-0.0144151673,
-0.000723728,
0.0041261762,
0.0451137647,
-0.0378817208,
-0.0081526265,
0.0120210843,
0.025945859,
0.0142763807,
-0.0372400992,
-0.0566160418,
-0.0376804098,
-0.0181942452,
0.0460551791,
0.0249216165,
-0.0409113765,
0.0680008084,
-0.0492327698,
0.0048361691,
0.0086103259,
-0.0011926116,
-0.0061984281,
-0.0276904199,
0.0718189776,
0.0280889142,
-0.0437006019,
-0.0346193388,
0.0318019651,
-0.0122313639,
-0.0215392634,
-0.0151147572,
0.0752355829,
0.0044601206,
0.0349527635,
0.0000020686,
-0.0332412422,
-0.0270537212,
-0.0228379667,
-0.0489698797,
0.0066807498,
0.0312319472,
0.0182606317,
-0.0240903534,
0.034836676,
-0.0015651615,
-0.0190788656,
0.0421391316,
0.0089798607,
0.0285608601,
0.0673099309,
0.0146991964,
0.0307150744,
0.0210821852,
-0.0136978598,
0.0303132217,
-0.0476163812,
-0.0061459541,
-0.0425613523,
0.0464600921,
0.0440438278,
0.0030105712,
0.0410667919,
0.0218446366,
-0.0190138873,
-0.0157167781,
0.0437649302,
-0.0453447886,
-0.0146499816,
-0.046084255,
0.0531028248,
-0.0434990749,
-0.0177147351,
-0.0084582111,
-0.0197351091,
-0.0168956928,
-0.0385954455,
-0.0705981702,
-0.0000387825,
0.0156115443,
0.0024263565,
-0.0257886704,
-0.0087575661,
0.0171218384,
-0.0110286074,
-0.0021939392,
0.0644353926,
0.038979847,
-0.0174246226,
0.0028204101,
0.003399787,
0.0009015327,
-0.0554613285,
-0.0172210932,
0.0318590589,
-0.102930136,
-0.0058393781,
-0.021488646,
-0.0031769921,
0.0307043549,
0.0131800547,
0.0808574557,
0.074472256,
-0.0589958429,
0.0438729823,
-0.0182709284,
0.0917930007,
0.0010139861,
0.0210975744,
-0.0189131387,
0.0027152426,
-0.0495816916,
-0.0064111501,
-0.0511534475,
0.0163106639,
-0.0244468898,
-0.0126150539,
-0.0078210905,
0.0361929163,
0.0136710145,
0.0134192687,
-0.0002124009,
-0.0101561407,
-0.0396965072,
-0.0071677221,
-0.0074998275,
0.061647702,
-0.0176119674,
-0.0211433694,
0.0492969118,
-0.1099962518,
-0.0534811094,
-0.0117925182,
0.0179442186,
-0.0327534415,
0.0100596752,
0.060692247,
-0.0148973232,
-0.0783863291,
-0.0051600575,
-0.0176620744,
-0.0155554311,
-0.0674618259,
0.0150982523,
-0.0420962907,
0.0039251791,
-0.0009372662,
-0.0121930558,
-0.002953145,
-0.020052867,
0.0442602709,
-0.0126758171,
0.0519192629,
0.021038346,
-0.0099946829,
-0.012333761,
-0.0052698213,
-0.0277455691,
0.0738200322,
-0.0295724887,
0.0498234332,
0.0436277017,
-0.0044382028,
0.0455478355,
0.0592204668,
0.0096858833,
0.0095388535,
-0.0076186019,
0.0050155791,
0.0429572836,
-0.0042905309,
0.0329922996,
0.0456238724,
-0.0279791802,
0.0054195602,
0.0587657392,
0.0364952758,
0.0136813242,
-0.0353861898,
0.0389687866,
0.0087328684,
-0.0314878896,
0.0113460561,
-0.0750780851,
0.0573300794,
-0.0409913994,
0.0284344163,
0.0631057173,
0.0111182723,
-0.0634432361,
-0.0099594798,
-0.0085841455,
0.0159428567,
-0.046865195,
0.033085417,
0.0342991799,
0.0000076787,
-0.0805750936,
0.0516165905,
0.018076621,
-0.0552529022,
-0.0106032696,
-0.0785403177,
0.0308798011,
0.0732626766,
0.0695286393,
-0.0106503628,
-0.0192454904,
-0.0077187824,
0.0228356589,
0.0540649034,
0.0281387847,
0.0125537617,
0.0214488283,
-0.042533204,
-0.0248334482,
-0.0013819601,
0.0220341347,
0.0283855647,
-0.0037798439,
-0.0028703946,
0.0139619112,
-0.0149512682,
0.0138348835,
0.0096688475,
-0.0101583665,
-0.0429562666,
0.0002690956,
-0.0118054403,
0.009345416,
0.0204212554,
-0.0067163412,
0.0259995144,
0.0306394901,
-0.0235340819,
0.0077734743,
-0.0049165562,
-0.0654574633,
-0.0412595607,
0.0233722348,
0.0181125384,
-0.0098258881,
0.0179999024,
-0.03580999,
-0.0639590397,
0.0119961705,
0.018564688,
0.023794733,
-0.0503746755,
0.0384640247,
-0.0194895826,
-0.0114334626,
-0.036975421,
0.0295078717,
0.0074165831,
0.0409615412,
0.0143243903,
0.0238151122,
0.0055774413,
-0.0834340751,
-0.056788113,
0.027179068,
-0.0245414712,
0.0082211131,
0.0070936922,
0.0188163165,
-0.0332536101,
-0.0303462669,
-0.1057322845,
0.0559711866,
-0.0513629615,
0.0124525931,
0.0244981218,
0.0370796435,
-0.0103008235,
-0.0100904098,
-0.0078422623,
0.0031386833,
0.0328195244,
0.0470507741,
-0.0010922566,
-0.0214220043,
-0.0252375156,
-0.0391034596,
-0.0282163564,
-0.0035566292,
0.0246655215,
-0.0465353951,
-0.0115112159,
-0.0312688202,
0.0602853,
-0.0023902229,
0.02974125,
-0.018778313,
-0.0161680058,
0.0429249331,
-0.0469997041,
0.0295061525,
0.0637452528,
-0.0270870663,
-0.0313866138,
0.0303073246,
-0.0250632763,
-0.0590610579,
0.0136746336,
-0.0036717437,
-0.0726215094,
0.0223106407,
0.0261368118,
-0.0048126127,
0.0722016543,
-0.0143494373,
0.0092620887,
-0.064963147,
0.0045519262,
-0.0212747157,
-0.0053299693,
-0.0508326516,
0.014835719,
-0.0539092198,
0.0188779607,
-0.042836491,
-0.0439297929,
0.0532461293,
-0.0688405558,
-0.0379943848,
-0.0171824694,
0.0155394468,
-0.0155651588,
0.0621243194,
-0.0146289943,
-0.0176706016,
0.010915475,
-0.0506007299,
-0.0326642729,
-0.0066041052,
0.0014013551,
-0.0375055708,
0.040526595,
-0.0268338379,
0.0237775166,
-0.0472823568,
-0.0503741242,
-0.0439233333,
-0.0012137278,
-0.0234524962,
0.0514535531,
-0.0301790852,
0.0006264672,
-0.0277071763,
0.0030343113,
0.0168118067,
0.0615265928,
-0.0362299494,
-0.0073826793,
-0.0510568917,
-0.0033772716,
0.051123444,
0.0021937406,
-0.0258602593,
-0.0156367123,
0.0221495163,
0.0339558758,
0.0635414943,
0.0113785174,
-0.0082389163,
0.0083955508,
0.0356069468,
-0.0263850633,
-0.0126721794,
0.0603328645,
0.0681802332,
-0.0596346594,
-0.022648653,
0.0970883518,
0.0253909733,
-0.0756341219,
-0.0179404635,
-0.0322367959,
0.052324757,
0.0317805745,
0.023092797,
-0.1053930223,
-0.0487051122,
0.0384220891,
0.0107454406,
-0.0083234226,
-0.0152015686,
-0.0069808378,
-0.1382464319,
0.041676268,
0.0047668917,
-0.0260235369,
-0.0038267465,
-0.0290898588,
-0.0006001125,
0.0044097654,
0.0661805421,
0.0596456863,
-0.0091621308,
0.0026796684,
0.0002104881,
0.0413281769,
-0.0394150093,
0.0622301251,
-0.0352449976,
0.0692404807,
0.086074084,
-0.0097874468,
0.0074739913,
-0.0206262283,
0.0320906714,
-0.0184602942,
0.0115823951,
-0.0072393091,
0.0276703984,
-0.0074966573,
-0.0078275362,
-0.0099405246,
0.0121266395,
-0.0094753886,
-0.0171988811,
-0.0043708151,
0.0510894768,
-0.0296722632,
0.0057338756,
-0.0004529338,
-0.0230401941,
0.0089067342,
0.079457365,
0.0407102481,
0.0067767766,
-0.0534140058,
-0.0364628695,
-0.0112313405,
-0.0648141205,
-0.0348533913,
0.0290808063,
0.0139740696,
-0.016020393,
-0.0222350787,
-0.0124864336,
0.0533699542,
0.0450452641,
-0.0183571,
-0.0031556755,
-0.042844858,
0.0071554678,
-0.0333538465,
0.0375943407,
-0.0410754941,
0.0258658305,
-0.085380964,
0.0168457404,
0.0256956536,
-0.0081556924,
-0.0120376805,
0.0436051004,
-0.0398354232,
-0.069896251,
-0.0022049407,
0.0537773222,
0.0290233027,
0.0245176852,
-0.0205047224,
-0.0553503186,
0.0608007051,
0.032462772,
-0.0084850658,
0.0301541388,
0.0153109934,
-0.0034365461,
-0.0106474413,
0.0240715556,
-0.0666174814,
0.0148938168,
0.018077204,
0.0407216251,
0.0396110602,
-0.0322040543,
0.017137086,
0.0433562957,
0.0739212781,
0.0094285468,
-0.0042669736,
-0.0226716809,
0.01836822,
-0.0415949114,
0.0210359562,
-0.0498617627,
0.0157456193,
-0.0048392448,
-0.0527414754,
0.0198214296,
-0.0082431901,
-0.0542474948,
0.0564180352,
-0.0457464233,
-0.0021070784,
-0.0039293016,
-0.0163370278,
0.0393062085,
-0.0036713665,
-0.0364758857,
0.0397539884,
0.0073185526,
0.053027086,
-0.0271956753,
0.0693199933,
0.0092908069,
-0.0084407208,
-0.0317824893,
0.0614387691,
-0.0735709742,
-0.0535592437,
-0.0031590525,
0.0583284125,
0.0751838386,
0.0199677553,
0.0430098698,
0.0063352911,
0.0105296858,
-0.0376876406,
0.0257637352,
0.0434747525,
-0.0446973443,
0.014644946,
0.0427754857,
0.0028567174,
-0.0163479485,
0.0598753504,
-0.0296972711,
0.0203089304,
0.0082114739,
0.0336410701,
-0.0285920631,
-0.0071230447,
-0.0055757486,
0.0109999776,
-0.0149843497,
-0.0123795373,
-0.0357350297,
-0.0351489559,
-0.001712697,
0.0310802814,
-0.0188360009,
-0.0257114694,
0.0287134871,
0.0521116816,
-0.0028540324,
-0.0507638305,
-0.0211705584,
-0.0113074863,
0.0028229719,
-0.0327388383,
-0.0304210186,
-6.68883322e-33,
-0.0545574427,
0.011131458,
0.0325862207,
-0.0119160758,
-0.0127875982,
0.0178881027,
-0.0499282293,
0.0198064391,
-0.0099631334,
-0.0235491004,
-0.0573900603,
-0.0101202009,
0.031869486,
0.0062927278,
-0.0035897957,
-0.0195791535,
0.060000252,
-0.0131023834,
-0.0504098125,
0.0298756622,
0.0500894077,
0.0289945956,
0.0516723581,
0.0146782463,
0.0253483932,
-0.0106943101,
-0.0011888123,
0.0207186434,
0.0091569135,
0.0455260538,
0.0008511397,
0.0449546576,
0.0237138569,
-0.0557934158,
-0.0287965089,
0.0308231227,
-0.0497436821,
-0.0292639695,
0.0172117576,
-0.0040377341,
-0.0292117186,
-0.0326915681,
0.0119860973,
-0.0280419271,
-0.0309392624,
-0.0109954393,
-0.018273551,
0.0171451177,
-0.0448766053,
0.0129518881,
-0.0315014496,
0.0086124307,
0.0235477649,
-0.0481133126,
0.0332149491,
0.0484368838,
-0.0015411747,
0.0077885482,
-0.0395114012,
0.0113729117,
0.0063102827,
0.0690105706,
0.0523947477,
0.040722657,
0.0032063753,
0.0610809028,
0.0294423345,
0.0149022993,
-0.0095551219,
-0.0443737954,
0.0439246818,
0.0355691761,
0.0337020718,
0.0178069416,
0.0252233371,
-0.0015719424,
-0.0065500094,
0.0187751316,
0.0705367997,
0.0325153284,
0.0444903821,
0.0280823931,
-0.0387619324,
-0.0219187494,
-0.0256691035,
-0.0213950854,
-0.0563065521,
-0.050686013,
0.0627323538,
0.0091022588,
-0.0011982372,
-0.0356532708,
0.098547034,
-0.005425578,
0.0216102321,
0.0055763847,
-0.0254104305,
0.0362727344,
-0.0175324697,
0.0224690381,
-0.0168197583,
-0.0439785421,
0.0426208153,
0.0063758055,
0.0058668926,
0.0135156531,
-0.0024834832,
0.0398230627,
-0.0539451279,
-0.0073868982,
-0.0525889061,
0.0276706349,
0.0032050351,
0.0259819385,
0.018110266,
-0.0095171044,
-0.0038216917,
0.0686391518,
-0.0068495567,
-0.0253446177,
-0.0289960783,
0.011260543,
0.0090775704,
0.0124944486,
-0.0338061228,
0.0236154124,
-0.052351661,
0.0152101172,
0.0192062557,
-0.0154531756,
-0.0122162746,
0.002035033,
2.824e-7,
0.0058119548,
0.0239154026,
0.010704658,
0.0410110727,
0.0093748476,
0.0362078957,
-0.0208404604,
0.0393556952,
0.0330105647,
-0.0245250482,
-0.0185576491,
0.0089455508,
0.045140557,
0.0185932685,
-0.1234569103,
-0.0074805422,
-0.0650198609,
0.0055595352,
-0.0537846349,
-0.0283909179,
0.025390856,
0.0808144063,
-0.0069279224,
0.0074726241,
0.0339376628,
-0.0446753204,
0.020145677,
-0.0056295823,
-0.038835723,
-0.0044210241,
0.0441954285,
0.0068869498,
0.014446565,
0.0151152397,
-0.0080975499,
0.0059881285,
-0.0135940444,
0.0761643052,
-0.0263731256,
-0.0854808092,
0.009971275,
-0.00160218,
-0.0088658193,
-0.0566469654,
0.0976145789,
-0.0253847372,
-0.0081750425,
-0.0371615291,
-0.0277321413,
-0.0161849558,
0.0161443185,
-0.0003376906,
-0.0210362896,
0.0442379862,
0.0178745799,
-0.0043130862,
-0.0146061182,
-0.0715775341,
-0.042129606,
-0.006929893,
-0.0352701917,
-0.0602242686,
-0.0364880636,
-0.0376526341,
-0.0195479784,
-0.07839825,
-0.0258511957,
2.967655104e-34,
0.0517031662,
0.0028203155,
0.0610346273,
0.0353379697,
0.0080459164,
0.0087191807,
-0.0152303791,
0.0237644184,
0.0213396158,
-0.0814111084,
-0.049103763
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.08448v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.08448v1 | A Cross-institutional Evaluation on Breast Cancer Phenotyping NLP Algorithms on Electronic Health Records | 2023-03-15T08:44:07 | 2023-03-15T08:44:07 | Sicheng Zhou, Nan Wang, Liwei Wang, Ju Sun, Anne Blaes, Hongfang Liu, Rui Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG | Objective: The generalizability of clinical large language models is usually
ignored during the model development process. This study evaluated the
generalizability of BERT-based clinical NLP models across different clinical
settings through a breast cancer phenotype extraction task.
Materials and Methods: Two clinical corpora of breast cancer patients were
collected from the electronic health records from the University of Minnesota
and the Mayo Clinic, and annotated following the same guideline. We developed
three types of NLP models (i.e., conditional random field, bi-directional long
short-term memory and CancerBERT) to extract cancer phenotypes from clinical
texts. The models were evaluated for their generalizability on different test
sets with different learning strategies (model transfer vs. locally trained).
The entity coverage score was assessed with their association with the model
performances.
Results: We manually annotated 200 and 161 clinical documents at UMN and MC,
respectively. The corpora of the two institutes were found to have higher
similarity between the target entities than the overall corpora. The CancerBERT
models obtained the best performances among the independent test sets from two
clinical institutes and the permutation test set. The CancerBERT model
developed in one institute and further fine-tuned in another institute achieved
reasonable performance compared to the model developed on local data (micro-F1:
0.925 vs 0.932).
Conclusions: The results indicate the CancerBERT model has the best learning
ability and generalizability among the three types of clinical NLP models. The
generalizability of the models was found to be correlated with the similarity
of the target entities between the corpora. | [
0.0289976653,
0.0563604906,
0.0147850076,
-0.0384159759,
-0.0398754999,
0.0395408981,
0.0012020917,
0.0201231632,
0.0134870829,
-0.0735109076,
0.0296009853,
-0.0735038519,
-0.0153328124,
0.0017018904,
-0.0044931732,
-0.0474243052,
0.0047328542,
0.0141255325,
0.0094349468,
0.0121496981,
-0.0344212279,
-0.0044619762,
0.0032626418,
0.0249723755,
-0.0057422058,
0.0140819941,
0.049623277,
-0.0245233905,
0.0004934287,
-0.0428830981,
-0.0031372402,
-0.002864107,
-0.0498346463,
-0.0068760668,
0.0000019226,
-0.0918062329,
-0.0574840046,
0.0461596176,
0.0065446668,
-0.0368281119,
0.0145167597,
-0.0384334251,
-0.0185146444,
-0.0101894485,
0.0080981115,
-0.0367856212,
0.0147382533,
0.0628900528,
0.0165135972,
0.0705638751,
-0.0203930307,
-0.039030049,
0.0410787202,
0.0129646184,
0.0152318534,
0.0058485065,
0.0711375698,
-0.0247904733,
0.0081728017,
-0.0314345583,
0.0295326393,
0.0487707295,
-0.0231037308,
0.0547398925,
0.0089551508,
0.0327350721,
-0.0360901989,
-0.0138741545,
0.0257045086,
0.0630860627,
-0.0168120489,
0.001259439,
0.0408461131,
0.0038800607,
-0.0104564046,
0.0757273808,
-0.0122187808,
0.0299913045,
-0.0695648119,
-0.0058972025,
0.0040606484,
-0.0204962455,
0.0127086798,
-0.026380837,
-0.0434106179,
-0.0135090547,
0.0176449977,
-0.0322136097,
0.012916306,
-0.0282815844,
-0.0326751955,
-0.0094637657,
0.0405504256,
0.0178738926,
-0.004902564,
0.0463310778,
-0.0067320266,
-0.028320672,
0.0907893404,
-0.0749087483,
0.0257144682,
-0.0268201865,
-0.0503702648,
0.0285460111,
-0.0558488443,
-0.0161392726,
-0.0209232736,
0.0523320436,
-0.0255715214,
-0.0032680058,
-0.0675029531,
0.0087064775,
-0.0061167818,
0.0536248162,
0.0457543693,
0.0037054704,
-0.0812415108,
-0.0467398651,
-0.0009179175,
0.0317581743,
0.0649088994,
0.0158433449,
-0.0019755438,
0.0307672881,
-0.0061719692,
-0.0050964244,
-0.0191988796,
-0.020351259,
-0.0360274687,
-0.0503893383,
0.0536671467,
-0.0045104646,
0.0146545321,
-0.0248511564,
0.0446361937,
0.06634859,
0.0551511422,
-0.0501399226,
-0.0442781001,
-0.0144566707,
-0.0479589514,
-0.0336577706,
0.0110053308,
-0.0420828685,
0.0088245934,
0.0234888401,
0.0067356704,
-0.0068170615,
-0.0020671051,
-0.0153308855,
-0.0394427776,
0.0453213304,
-0.0096290028,
-0.0005466918,
0.0428786501,
-0.0045561227,
-0.0015221691,
0.0381958596,
0.0396799333,
-0.0513794646,
0.01354538,
-0.0349467099,
0.0001969419,
0.0324603915,
0.0412309021,
-0.0628934428,
-0.0207115859,
0.0314693302,
0.0083326017,
0.0545875989,
-0.0069111767,
0.0569106266,
0.0248770937,
-0.0308415834,
-0.002400961,
0.0668480918,
0.0705876052,
0.0670852959,
-0.0082075121,
-0.0076932847,
-0.0012781969,
-0.0189244468,
0.021153817,
-0.0417784788,
-0.0166464597,
0.0350156426,
-0.028119253,
-0.0055239806,
-0.016260596,
-0.0003399071,
-0.0738656968,
-0.0098781893,
-0.0288324337,
-0.0185699295,
0.0436085947,
-0.0044204537,
-0.0182602555,
0.0416655019,
0.0476635173,
0.0115110837,
-0.0288715214,
-0.0388216041,
-0.052372992,
0.0530194342,
0.0119039277,
-0.0487160049,
-0.017586546,
-0.036327675,
-0.0372584239,
-0.0289709643,
-0.0085904766,
-0.0068099704,
-0.0073471181,
0.0082645034,
0.0200268757,
0.0503922887,
0.0136244595,
-0.0145086255,
-0.0215674285,
0.029375637,
-0.0342086218,
-0.0747688711,
-0.0371834189,
0.0629007667,
-0.0469759032,
-0.0583166741,
-0.0385995917,
0.0201961622,
0.033653155,
0.0158373956,
-0.0435481593,
0.0281496365,
-0.0141365258,
-0.0422018319,
-0.0592982918,
0.0260821991,
-0.0149743035,
-0.0266638212,
-0.0012322324,
-0.0201540589,
-0.0057572955,
-0.0244251825,
-0.0143629359,
0.0051509147,
-0.0356111079,
-0.0468945801,
0.0393685959,
0.0070893774,
0.038548857,
0.0200805571,
-0.0348433331,
-0.0313574746,
0.0415733643,
-0.027244579,
-0.0036088158,
0.0092073856,
-0.0787626505,
0.024724761,
-0.0334540121,
-0.0210865289,
0.0238663368,
0.0008086848,
-0.0022312368,
-0.0343127027,
-0.0270329285,
-0.033090122,
-0.033166945,
-0.0913272947,
0.0028906488,
0.0166803449,
0.0342772864,
0.021950217,
0.0185889937,
-0.0046981797,
-0.0217857249,
-0.0551400296,
-0.037978705,
0.0089095524,
0.0523685329,
0.0544293933,
0.0279444121,
-0.0076682055,
-0.0417420752,
-0.0093607865,
-0.0537341386,
0.0654161721,
0.0187102929,
-0.0476561636,
0.0019442727,
0.0582916886,
-0.0051985057,
0.013012032,
0.0264423583,
-0.0069838921,
-0.0208878219,
-0.0284872986,
-0.0159722865,
0.06016827,
-0.0122376401,
0.0341069922,
0.002310327,
0.0083878124,
-0.0332801156,
-0.003953665,
-0.0158361048,
-0.0182941034,
-0.002500355,
-0.0444476902,
0.0109127443,
0.0549789853,
0.0389662571,
-0.0158635918,
-0.0244476907,
-0.0569126233,
-0.0498215519,
0.0577861145,
-0.0482432619,
0.0337551758,
-0.030689029,
-0.0138484817,
0.0098588029,
-0.0102474084,
0.1000414267,
-0.0015742159,
0.0671410188,
-0.0775425509,
0.0050985687,
-0.0183572657,
0.0219833292,
0.0001040195,
0.0064945333,
0.0330574661,
-0.0133037325,
0.0214272588,
-0.0268410668,
0.0147132529,
-0.0481586233,
0.0308097173,
0.0131168244,
0.056828212,
0.0158101637,
0.0074896351,
-0.0323098674,
-0.0212658085,
0.0265264753,
0.0229247883,
0.0297101885,
0.013533284,
-0.0598320924,
0.0650468916,
-0.0206839964,
0.0628059283,
0.0216444936,
-0.0184623189,
0.025622027,
0.023830805,
0.0322218426,
-0.0349836983,
-0.0365500189,
-0.003133646,
0.0182998441,
0.0053948509,
-0.0111633101,
0.0462962762,
-0.015173736,
0.0171913598,
-0.0228064116,
-0.0934687406,
-0.0303914808,
0.022708429,
0.0210977681,
-0.0652498826,
-0.0190412793,
0.1025534123,
0.0295985192,
-0.0141019328,
0.018387571,
0.0299464632,
-0.0324300043,
-0.0379979648,
0.0221749134,
-0.0462803692,
-0.0136483405,
-0.0185362622,
0.0095756315,
-0.0237948596,
-0.0678397939,
0.057144396,
-0.0442761779,
-0.0092899948,
-0.0179526266,
-0.0540965684,
-0.0224383343,
-0.0575820953,
0.0019446677,
-0.0193805005,
-0.0097040152,
-0.0331533365,
-0.0261990316,
-0.0170106348,
0.0160667431,
-0.1079783887,
-0.0829106495,
0.0042501902,
-0.0387634151,
0.0324415006,
0.0550659783,
0.0246349648,
-0.0384729654,
-0.0096084177,
-0.0206964202,
0.0113115087,
0.0098111173,
0.0238650162,
0.0886525363,
-0.0158006325,
0.0049731247,
-0.0414110124,
0.0039218632,
0.0168685336,
0.008469834,
-0.0204245448,
0.0607443042,
-0.0353348888,
-0.022349501,
-0.0291965883,
-0.017908562,
0.0221093465,
0.0615396202,
-0.0180726573,
-0.0168246739,
-0.0391388647,
0.0320751555,
0.0463218912,
0.0174447279,
0.0332739614,
0.0735732913,
-0.0469237305,
-0.0001346171,
-0.0405278169,
-0.0418760218,
0.0541410856,
-0.0088494606,
0.033089146,
0.0333948098,
0.0299584214,
-0.0054219025,
-0.0828457773,
0.0920503438,
0.0322196223,
-0.0047989073,
-0.0353879593,
-0.0894118771,
0.0656121746,
0.0053826883,
-0.0000299947,
-0.0019488884,
-0.0193138979,
0.0062714382,
-0.0057608704,
-0.0048101232,
0.0201594625,
-0.0116219167,
0.0061761895,
-0.0359262116,
0.0825971141,
0.0005763838,
-0.0302247331,
-0.0580601729,
-0.0183665119,
0.0092928279,
-0.001425297,
0.001093915,
-0.0237786621,
0.0165751986,
0.0295734107,
0.040774513,
0.0046179746,
-0.0040791132,
0.02056708,
0.0709242597,
0.0291015524,
-0.0005022992,
-0.0387387536,
-0.0249818489,
-0.0028280905,
-0.0012262203,
0.0257881545,
0.0140526006,
-0.0029792273,
0.0212707184,
0.0244499631,
-0.0296707489,
0.0154322498,
-0.0397483148,
-0.0347496234,
-0.0720775425,
0.0819959119,
0.0303375944,
0.0040686182,
0.0237587821,
-0.0244288072,
-0.0073925238,
-0.0224295165,
0.011095765,
-0.0124401776,
0.0099209948,
0.0356935076,
0.0103148567,
0.0672417805,
-0.0267850049,
0.0274025016,
-0.0280614831,
-0.0117157409,
-0.0381921306,
0.023334777,
0.043064449,
-0.0333618261,
0.0327599533,
-0.038759388,
0.0086525241,
-0.0085280072,
0.0237361994,
-0.0188289303,
0.0345558897,
0.0616360754,
0.0243868772,
-0.0243335571,
-0.0418109372,
0.0413913354,
0.0447647236,
0.0712043568,
-0.0444127657,
-0.0333473049,
-0.0588840246,
0.0128849512,
0.0649565905,
-0.0227537863,
-0.0672154576,
-0.0286665838,
-0.0594171509,
-0.0272375587,
0.0982303023,
-0.0339077525,
-0.0297316182,
0.0045878496,
0.0459707938,
0.0398511998,
0.0260051899,
-0.0335004441,
-0.0372873917,
0.0291877128,
0.0209814496,
-0.0228963271,
0.0010404161,
-5.201864825e-33,
0.0107464744,
-0.0169380233,
0.0131367957,
-0.0726458058,
0.0047220858,
0.0262242258,
-0.0157849826,
-0.0219835546,
0.0100510037,
0.010611102,
-0.0171777494,
-0.0031148966,
0.0111478409,
0.0370476395,
-0.0022028857,
-0.0570735112,
0.0432219207,
-0.0091136191,
0.0120935254,
-0.0216319915,
-0.005730914,
0.0847840458,
0.0318049155,
-0.0491371118,
0.0351688713,
0.0091510732,
0.0242345389,
-0.0223096423,
0.0128354207,
0.0680118725,
-0.0471352041,
0.0319270566,
0.0456548743,
-0.0173605755,
0.013569463,
0.0078552198,
-0.0673557371,
-0.0062647094,
0.0172046665,
0.0113711311,
-0.0086084949,
0.0002292349,
0.0878596082,
-0.0126264468,
-0.0194945671,
0.0169941448,
0.039308466,
-0.0342717543,
-0.0279754698,
-0.0365969092,
-0.0270751007,
0.0366905183,
0.0234874338,
0.0420409516,
0.0175328329,
-0.0474535972,
-0.0660789534,
0.021264473,
-0.014210904,
-0.0392464772,
0.0229869206,
0.0043287757,
-0.0032477069,
-0.0248863865,
-0.0133785866,
0.0779480338,
0.0248338897,
0.0029606312,
-0.0077798897,
0.0171766244,
-0.0315695181,
0.0332694612,
-0.009887564,
0.017195262,
0.0082182493,
-0.0123148784,
-0.0772843063,
0.029235417,
-0.0274959877,
-0.0006663649,
0.0353832804,
-0.0410254002,
-0.0577006377,
0.010481514,
-0.0423812643,
0.010268203,
0.0004207101,
-0.0030564438,
0.031837292,
-0.0304509159,
0.0112102954,
0.0213079918,
0.0015947983,
-0.0216203965,
-0.0515866354,
-0.012271177,
0.0503630191,
0.0313055962,
-0.0616448373,
0.0081601404,
-0.0228245854,
-0.0513268262,
0.0050785118,
-0.0109498007,
0.0452007875,
0.0056462153,
0.0311087687,
-0.0312346444,
-0.0762821436,
-0.0336170904,
0.020423077,
-0.0132348007,
-0.0271578804,
0.0518549941,
0.0444589742,
0.028583983,
0.0220091734,
0.0761605352,
0.0309146978,
-0.0102701755,
0.0112371957,
-0.0016737925,
0.011265737,
0.000051061,
-0.0096811783,
0.0052569141,
-0.0146062132,
0.0646966845,
0.024830956,
-0.0604049861,
0.0232798457,
0.0146356598,
2.703e-7,
0.1293454617,
0.0606302321,
0.014259018,
-0.032319393,
0.028812049,
-0.0304142963,
-0.00406483,
0.0042435578,
0.001033318,
0.0014787609,
0.0434618108,
0.0005653017,
0.0307672787,
0.0240268614,
-0.0605458394,
-0.0215056557,
-0.0866910517,
-0.0248691831,
-0.0308640208,
0.0361371748,
0.0542446524,
0.0425287597,
-0.0156144425,
-0.0279040933,
0.0295306388,
0.0029937476,
0.020631697,
-0.0635614321,
0.0144393528,
0.0391416512,
0.0059113405,
0.0019637288,
0.0305989441,
0.0799290314,
0.0248856749,
-0.0145692313,
0.0174141042,
0.067530714,
-0.0343459696,
0.0009386945,
0.0277187247,
-0.010922187,
0.020754274,
-0.0348583609,
0.0475873835,
-0.0466845073,
-0.066075176,
0.0079060923,
-0.0196646117,
0.0055213533,
0.0480371006,
-0.021124132,
-0.0242548864,
0.0358727127,
0.024804078,
0.0139699727,
-0.0365674347,
-0.0408116467,
0.0045435051,
0.0440780409,
-0.0385341421,
-0.0444809273,
0.0444553532,
-0.025634082,
0.0622457378,
-0.1002898291,
0.0177847687,
2.626596668e-34,
0.0200762376,
0.027072344,
0.0071629896,
0.0335171372,
-0.0078263786,
-0.005958342,
0.0143826511,
-0.002197278,
-0.0269966144,
-0.0673524067,
0.0131555032
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.08389v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.08389v1 | PR-MCS: Perturbation Robust Metric for MultiLingual Image Captioning | 2023-03-15T06:37:26 | 2023-03-15T06:37:26 | Yongil Kim, Yerin Hwang, Hyeongu Yun, Seunghyun Yoon, Trung Bui, Kyomin Jung | cs.CL | cs.CL | Vulnerability to lexical perturbation is a critical weakness of automatic
evaluation metrics for image captioning. This paper proposes Perturbation
Robust Multi-Lingual CLIPScore(PR-MCS), which exhibits robustness to such
perturbations, as a novel reference-free image captioning metric applicable to
multiple languages. To achieve perturbation robustness, we fine-tune the text
encoder of CLIP with our language-agnostic method to distinguish the perturbed
text from the original text. To verify the robustness of PR-MCS, we introduce a
new fine-grained evaluation dataset consisting of detailed captions, critical
objects, and the relationships between the objects for 3, 000 images in five
languages. In our experiments, PR-MCS significantly outperforms baseline
metrics in capturing lexical noise of all various perturbation types in all
five languages, proving that PR-MCS is highly robust to lexical perturbations. | [
0.0123731615,
0.0652658418,
0.0031346569,
0.0477339663,
-0.0056689586,
0.0010087489,
-0.0273626056,
0.02603852,
-0.0410926007,
-0.0246211253,
-0.0328052118,
-0.0216806363,
0.020823678,
0.0385694876,
0.0078846505,
-0.0721425116,
0.0241123922,
-0.041428078,
-0.0339347869,
-0.003411964,
0.0364264064,
0.0018460786,
0.0146730784,
0.0346321836,
-0.0112139015,
0.0246489458,
0.0338023789,
0.0018806352,
0.0395904332,
-0.0228765234,
-0.0256234426,
0.0698039234,
0.0161077809,
0.0169391502,
0.0000018637,
-0.008311565,
0.0028177823,
0.0211507864,
0.0522073917,
-0.0219952371,
0.0670878962,
-0.0621290244,
-0.0191198718,
-0.028666975,
-0.0045871781,
0.018471444,
0.0871961191,
0.0288493522,
0.0423650928,
0.0440252982,
-0.0287538581,
-0.0187622625,
-0.0439578258,
-0.0501585789,
-0.0312102735,
-0.0298425984,
-0.0048756381,
0.0573026948,
-0.0360880718,
-0.0005398707,
-0.0511204489,
0.0287269372,
-0.0075993799,
-0.0124006802,
-0.0199281517,
0.0286070742,
-0.0482508577,
-0.0353312641,
0.0005439132,
0.0813849345,
-0.0202495176,
0.0153005095,
-0.0522957519,
0.0022982704,
-0.0140404459,
-0.0214225706,
-0.0306978188,
0.007095268,
0.0638012663,
0.0168140363,
-0.0364471748,
0.0538169891,
0.0230490938,
0.0044042612,
0.0147863291,
-0.0278711338,
0.0332665443,
0.0113363713,
-0.0371034667,
0.0154180368,
-0.0357953236,
-0.0281075202,
0.04698468,
-0.0405844226,
0.0050472203,
-0.0147851901,
-0.0546008237,
-0.0475704037,
0.0000369681,
-0.0740646273,
-0.0059468877,
-0.0007497861,
-0.0565555431,
0.066878587,
-0.0122141242,
0.0624506436,
0.0319528878,
0.0270347055,
-0.0367673263,
-0.0119555984,
-0.0250127614,
0.0237240382,
0.0150067257,
0.0137871085,
-0.052580338,
-0.0345844924,
-0.0431507602,
-0.0164343957,
-0.0368011706,
0.0125464862,
-0.013818346,
-0.0016719293,
-0.02111632,
0.0063367146,
-0.0258234236,
0.0262240097,
-0.0311750229,
-0.0220348202,
-0.0357625447,
-0.0187221617,
-0.0294389687,
0.0439622514,
0.0090790549,
-0.0218905602,
0.0102262739,
0.0842227563,
-0.0426929258,
-0.0373327509,
0.0373833068,
-0.0096236989,
-0.0672354102,
-0.0408009402,
-0.0312238634,
-0.0418870449,
0.0359255895,
-0.0210519973,
-0.0011827217,
-0.0772724524,
0.0294987503,
-0.0064480421,
-0.0205437094,
0.1248065531,
-0.0059343386,
-0.0298915692,
-0.0362720862,
0.016596958,
-0.021117596,
0.088571772,
0.0311928988,
0.0072962889,
0.0727503225,
0.0304078162,
0.0000937491,
0.0629957691,
0.0036122501,
0.0163992718,
-0.0604142286,
-0.0259072185,
0.0175678749,
-0.0301716346,
0.0448093899,
0.0596242063,
-0.0193140879,
0.0173998345,
0.0725389719,
0.020132605,
-0.0842336714,
0.0507013984,
-0.0162239857,
-0.012417159,
-0.0282204766,
0.0240578353,
-0.0285680145,
0.0452840403,
0.0090051526,
-0.0074458746,
0.0266806018,
0.0230324958,
-0.0188833624,
-0.0243761446,
-0.0069847684,
-0.0328095146,
0.0118573606,
-0.0367431268,
0.0395375639,
0.0030608398,
-0.0225617141,
0.0669096038,
-0.0268989895,
-0.0393959172,
0.0135199092,
-0.0097009875,
-0.0530041829,
0.0299458746,
0.0594324954,
-0.0035503425,
-0.0268253274,
-0.0115660261,
-0.0015710606,
0.0640945956,
0.0097805019,
0.0207912009,
0.0584768839,
-0.0434249118,
-0.0463704951,
-0.0135223297,
0.0050472696,
0.0403391458,
-0.0070576547,
0.0303949155,
0.0412178896,
0.0040676151,
-0.0727823675,
0.0153521169,
0.0660583824,
-0.0112734772,
0.002908739,
0.0041270922,
0.0279456824,
0.0392009616,
-0.0434229784,
-0.0034993123,
-0.0113715306,
-0.0273049101,
-0.0068097371,
0.0802405924,
-0.0134034334,
-0.0535329282,
0.0407007746,
-0.0572101586,
-0.0349261723,
0.0069307871,
-0.0308815613,
-0.043100711,
0.0434625186,
-0.0326128975,
-0.0171558075,
-0.073791638,
0.0137433698,
-0.0347775854,
0.0560804494,
0.0178670529,
0.03384481,
-0.0056176633,
0.0078323493,
0.0242076237,
0.0089637684,
0.0249208678,
-0.0019993244,
-0.0834508315,
0.0194578879,
0.0000437085,
0.0228110086,
0.0440083817,
0.0559489578,
0.0029340892,
-0.0221335571,
-0.0354783125,
-0.0343578495,
-0.0206793938,
0.0110303247,
0.0063609155,
0.0089486493,
0.0314658508,
-0.0417572856,
-0.0182695426,
-0.0424212925,
0.0376506262,
0.024515124,
0.0272343364,
0.0382324755,
0.0134616299,
-0.0208500084,
0.007896781,
0.0615077168,
0.0639345273,
0.0177102331,
-0.0256859977,
-0.0380411968,
-0.0044897958,
-0.0422443226,
0.0003036307,
0.0022144048,
-0.0431671068,
-0.0205540191,
0.0299005341,
0.0380717181,
0.0210091379,
-0.0147158913,
0.0088826055,
0.0381159894,
-0.0024854741,
-0.0011088342,
-0.0044549382,
-0.0015171946,
-0.0736746639,
0.0371313468,
-0.0216387752,
0.0045647603,
-0.0237902775,
-0.0301012527,
0.0285404865,
-0.0697269961,
0.021557197,
-0.0433829091,
-0.0556358062,
-0.0317756981,
0.022840865,
-0.0138965873,
0.0263002496,
-0.0249277279,
-0.0325902663,
0.0434549488,
-0.0331937075,
-0.0362073593,
-0.0181103237,
0.0194680877,
-0.0148260687,
0.0679159909,
-0.0043214248,
0.0342099182,
-0.0331177823,
-0.0270034447,
-0.0201083925,
-0.0435146727,
0.0310292225,
-0.0279239491,
0.0376281552,
-0.0472842902,
-0.0221188162,
-0.0093169147,
-0.0325519852,
-0.0043110428,
0.0246506892,
-0.0053846254,
-0.0016272158,
0.0179823656,
-0.0192765016,
-0.0111944526,
0.0701968446,
0.0226017013,
0.0139209498,
-0.0358216166,
0.0349604823,
-0.0017885882,
0.0521720722,
0.0292497315,
-0.0233494248,
-0.0277728699,
-0.0410652682,
-0.008066915,
0.0106008938,
-0.0383550227,
-0.0379408151,
-0.027713472,
0.0317753218,
0.0211447384,
0.041516725,
0.0302865934,
-0.0175204203,
0.0615445748,
-0.0161900129,
-0.0199466981,
0.0819151327,
0.0015367083,
-0.0710355118,
-0.0221883841,
-0.0169298723,
0.0478901826,
0.0345039554,
0.0023814132,
-0.0389081202,
-0.0429893471,
-0.0016434732,
0.0042483513,
0.0445724688,
0.0177595168,
-0.0354282185,
-0.0795627609,
0.0072425194,
0.0387180522,
-0.0743487254,
-0.0930102095,
-0.0012008271,
0.0069351448,
-0.02249844,
0.0115985973,
-0.0490917377,
0.043994572,
0.0102709522,
0.0047739856,
-0.012763883,
-0.1044348329,
-0.0351014324,
-0.0507488064,
0.01539132,
0.0643752068,
0.0211111885,
-0.0443930812,
0.0081837522,
0.0114932172,
0.0099983178,
-0.0182544142,
0.0081608761,
0.069178082,
0.0020412025,
-0.0490248874,
0.024578169,
-0.0191143528,
-0.0023955037,
-0.0068407697,
-0.0143377045,
-0.0023803941,
0.0243570972,
0.0258165039,
-0.0194891635,
0.0222704615,
0.0098027661,
0.0521503016,
0.0325897783,
-0.0267567281,
0.0020364844,
-0.0237145089,
-0.0219347663,
-0.0967579484,
0.0089657567,
-0.0226261672,
-0.0219712202,
-0.0294400249,
-0.0830341578,
-0.0427743308,
-0.003635501,
-0.0076299962,
0.0348635614,
-0.0175173022,
-0.0298903398,
0.0423267223,
-0.0274454746,
0.0171054695,
-0.0375581495,
0.0060240449,
-0.0236814152,
0.0349393189,
0.0445882678,
0.0373889841,
-0.0132938735,
0.0451944172,
-0.0678685829,
-0.0287669618,
-0.0537787154,
0.0765521973,
0.0054780203,
0.0370498374,
0.0018578697,
-0.0222389456,
0.0119070755,
0.0411941335,
0.0438507423,
0.0031549567,
0.0479882322,
-0.0631112829,
-0.040544454,
0.0366392471,
-0.0356832705,
0.0132288393,
-0.0227485914,
0.0741443634,
0.0111168344,
-0.0474782623,
-0.0191285498,
0.0022418697,
0.0207683034,
-0.0788932368,
0.0144327814,
-0.0170792975,
-0.0246252585,
-0.0123602487,
-0.0254414473,
-0.0359857678,
0.0330783799,
0.0120450761,
0.0110032009,
-0.0057001789,
0.007697606,
-0.0217422117,
0.0052801599,
0.0080738915,
-0.0074588414,
0.0063703014,
-0.048538655,
-0.03079593,
0.0593535639,
-0.0033097432,
-0.0121837761,
0.0145782176,
0.0050722114,
-0.0546579584,
0.0005972294,
0.0140467938,
-0.0111520085,
0.0226424094,
0.0507399626,
0.0262954421,
0.0610987954,
-0.0619146749,
0.0182632543,
0.0869812667,
-0.014168784,
0.0832687244,
-0.0150356395,
-0.0035043373,
0.0074682436,
0.0192390792,
-0.0139965005,
-0.0324928984,
0.0010118705,
-0.0101065626,
0.0143891806,
0.0522807874,
0.0584354699,
-0.0465845913,
-0.0043264013,
-0.0110841431,
-0.0351425186,
-0.0130727906,
-0.0164070409,
-0.0322829597,
-0.0052452781,
-0.0209864546,
0.0153954132,
-0.0021828399,
-0.0767720938,
0.0073416326,
0.0118107041,
-0.0104635851,
0.0565093048,
0.0365919098,
0.0154067809,
-0.0045731403,
0.0301794205,
-0.0121171307,
-0.0361173674,
-0.0092648333,
0.047239989,
-0.0188719723,
-5.267688835e-33,
-0.0372690149,
-0.0258607678,
-0.0491141863,
-0.0129488502,
-0.0284721982,
0.0104146646,
-0.0438628979,
0.0354133993,
0.0270349961,
0.0083530648,
0.0321147889,
-0.0324545279,
0.025718037,
0.0311441142,
0.0169503894,
-0.0073206872,
0.0468608625,
0.0043136361,
-0.0227862075,
0.0109784212,
0.0007188351,
-0.0096602635,
0.0799654722,
-0.063855812,
0.054498516,
0.0145737752,
-0.046863813,
0.0016256262,
0.1076453775,
0.0560186096,
0.0039355471,
0.02962148,
-0.0096169971,
-0.0166534185,
-0.0380358249,
-0.0394368395,
-0.0358336307,
-0.0455765203,
0.0493634567,
0.0592491254,
0.0089725442,
-0.0141935339,
-0.0022390492,
-0.0377636477,
-0.029889252,
0.0017306983,
0.0427163765,
-0.0493224673,
-0.0008331303,
-0.0227768421,
-0.0005348939,
0.0348649919,
-0.033194866,
0.0000902556,
0.0547323897,
0.0642632097,
0.0184321739,
-0.0051044854,
-0.0332090743,
0.0250231456,
0.0066352156,
0.0377387553,
0.0835491568,
0.0522624329,
-0.00662026,
0.05140993,
-0.0183132198,
-0.0108102988,
0.0249435008,
-0.0209367108,
0.026577672,
0.0157543924,
0.0820790306,
0.0854628608,
0.0455397516,
0.0353564695,
-0.0246443339,
0.0482811816,
-0.0630510673,
0.0214063525,
0.0529467724,
0.0063520977,
-0.0175274946,
0.0160801057,
-0.0551865287,
-0.0428327844,
-0.0427452177,
-0.0464111641,
0.0165954903,
0.0005327914,
-0.0382819101,
0.0593655445,
0.0746095031,
-0.0268300977,
0.0215983801,
-0.0162354466,
-0.0143868942,
0.0267642271,
0.0031626134,
-0.0015731833,
0.0129022626,
-0.0279975161,
0.0339855626,
0.0104556084,
0.0390194878,
-0.0197245218,
0.0771913975,
0.0320305116,
-0.0242014416,
0.0141323907,
-0.0023210091,
-0.0072418251,
-0.0379071869,
0.0515666492,
0.0140855517,
-0.0028602513,
-0.0609337501,
0.0204632096,
0.0317638516,
0.040297471,
-0.0051426021,
-0.0135349976,
0.009922402,
0.0271450747,
-0.0361128561,
0.0338344947,
-0.0212534759,
-0.0198831297,
0.0066761691,
-0.058029253,
-0.0364497043,
0.0108235227,
2.532e-7,
0.0101662008,
0.062345352,
0.039904926,
0.0248352382,
0.0136879906,
0.0218819808,
-0.0403893329,
0.0151572265,
-0.0243348368,
0.0010268021,
0.0387221016,
-0.0050430116,
0.0317728966,
0.0074834041,
-0.0350751542,
-0.0201142095,
-0.0606112219,
0.000750317,
0.0011967509,
-0.0351749398,
0.0458131172,
0.081159018,
-0.0088159069,
-0.0037519282,
-0.0362158716,
-0.0932983309,
0.0864843354,
-0.0327164754,
-0.0075423005,
-0.018416049,
0.0094215292,
0.0615255199,
-0.0406003296,
0.0282993913,
-0.0444615893,
-0.00287659,
0.0767062828,
0.0416204557,
-0.0370543338,
-0.0344760418,
-0.0305510554,
0.0537755042,
-0.0158581249,
-0.0244708378,
0.0552823134,
-0.030737346,
-0.0232023243,
-0.0410493463,
-0.0139700426,
0.0264791977,
0.0520387329,
-0.0648102015,
-0.0762582645,
0.0427737385,
0.0626059473,
0.0391371623,
-0.0543874837,
-0.0543912202,
-0.0367687643,
-0.0104870005,
0.0094346618,
-0.0013554821,
-0.0381819978,
-0.0563938692,
-0.0128206164,
-0.0138626909,
0.0084078349,
1.984517777e-34,
0.0682539642,
-0.0252681952,
-0.0072763613,
-0.0138800181,
0.0171885639,
-0.0084293978,
0.0017291693,
-0.0216977801,
-0.0164965931,
-0.007974484,
-0.0118112639
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.13364v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.13364v1 | Reevaluating Data Partitioning for Emotion Detection in EmoWOZ | 2023-03-15T03:06:13 | 2023-03-15T03:06:13 | Moeen Mostafavi, Michael D. Porter | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | This paper focuses on the EmoWoz dataset, an extension of MultiWOZ that
provides emotion labels for the dialogues. MultiWOZ was partitioned initially
for another purpose, resulting in a distributional shift when considering the
new purpose of emotion recognition. The emotion tags in EmoWoz are highly
imbalanced and unevenly distributed across the partitions, which causes
sub-optimal performance and poor comparison of models. We propose a stratified
sampling scheme based on emotion tags to address this issue, improve the
dataset's distribution, and reduce dataset shift. We also introduce a special
technique to handle conversation (sequential) data with many emotional tags.
Using our proposed sampling method, models built upon EmoWoz can perform
better, making it a more reliable resource for training conversational agents
with emotional intelligence. We recommend that future researchers use this new
partitioning to ensure consistent and accurate performance evaluations. | [
0.0404605791,
0.0398244001,
-0.020694606,
0.0153769013,
0.0080898702,
0.0449698307,
0.0402559824,
-0.0280029736,
0.0492346883,
-0.0677980557,
-0.0870257542,
-0.0150026381,
-0.0616365783,
0.0338467956,
-0.0148712723,
-0.087159574,
0.0125193717,
0.034540955,
0.0873384252,
-0.002912994,
0.0303856544,
0.0234304573,
-0.028514633,
0.0142494245,
-0.0707162842,
-0.0136881806,
-0.0353036411,
0.0167391133,
0.0147775989,
-0.0400879458,
0.0494644865,
0.0496663041,
0.0019665761,
-0.0202666521,
0.0000021036,
-0.0327012986,
-0.0167293418,
-0.0341601707,
-0.0168173462,
-0.0382869206,
0.0932944119,
0.0000746855,
-0.0141734816,
0.0343721621,
-0.0376912504,
-0.0021803421,
0.0105034225,
0.0884159878,
0.0825305581,
0.0495517887,
-0.0406154543,
0.0021912926,
-0.011635283,
0.0061410186,
0.0127818044,
-0.0180439539,
0.0046686344,
0.0139051173,
0.0090213139,
-0.0463893376,
-0.0338747203,
-0.0087579684,
0.0210183728,
-0.0047271592,
0.0151187722,
0.0064795255,
-0.0477455743,
-0.0569449551,
-0.052333694,
0.0684052482,
-0.0140398182,
0.059764903,
-0.0134218857,
-0.0095203342,
0.0269323457,
-0.033289779,
-0.0373459943,
0.003871487,
-0.0108031426,
0.0123573095,
0.0121933296,
0.0565624908,
-0.0013716297,
0.0304175392,
-0.0260265544,
0.0669686422,
-0.0270437971,
-0.0014542536,
0.0359602459,
0.0034848368,
-0.0159950443,
0.001030565,
0.0060879416,
-0.0020685287,
-0.0133369509,
0.0224758126,
-0.061485488,
0.0026989749,
-0.0243574791,
-0.0361675695,
-0.0339213423,
0.0202599503,
-0.0151518425,
0.0239200778,
0.0436583422,
0.0070736301,
0.0661131516,
0.0003203225,
-0.0324372873,
-0.0245650262,
-0.0469281897,
0.035904292,
-0.0586595051,
0.0370337032,
-0.0623230822,
-0.0465252884,
-0.0735272989,
0.0176737756,
-0.0716541186,
-0.0280496776,
-0.0171684045,
-0.005118202,
-0.0024814508,
0.0219206791,
0.0205134694,
0.0124400845,
-0.0463657938,
0.0462010726,
0.0372955017,
-0.0855626091,
-0.0034216454,
0.0264383573,
-0.0102866488,
-0.0102712503,
0.0450745709,
0.0341855884,
0.013377985,
-0.0585962348,
-0.0348437689,
-0.0250582434,
-0.0347831361,
-0.0171064176,
0.0152077628,
-0.0322764888,
0.065459609,
-0.0047308682,
0.0224670023,
0.0213165544,
-0.0036656789,
-0.0435293242,
-0.0316041596,
0.0309832022,
-0.0104948888,
-0.0209121201,
0.0012818677,
0.0086497786,
-0.0231805686,
0.0778466985,
0.0510326996,
0.0328379646,
0.0628090054,
0.0106389625,
0.0377308168,
0.0088392887,
-0.0252812766,
4.569e-7,
0.0120450817,
-0.0256759301,
0.0002705452,
0.0397912636,
0.0678847954,
0.0171273537,
-0.06129089,
-0.0362700373,
0.0339059308,
0.0500765704,
-0.0339365266,
0.0465764254,
-0.0621748157,
0.0109300595,
0.0321070664,
-0.0362567231,
-0.0229601376,
0.0400372706,
-0.0023070273,
-0.0172465332,
0.0095373653,
0.03179878,
-0.0559237674,
-0.0436511263,
-0.0130805643,
-0.0013310087,
0.0150109045,
-0.0044749957,
0.0275731739,
-0.0221399199,
-0.0256297756,
0.0469094664,
0.0206218529,
-0.0641765371,
-0.0275948085,
-0.0504819155,
0.0011176608,
0.0630209148,
0.0068971049,
-0.056757547,
-0.0336060934,
-0.0312536806,
0.0093402537,
-0.0083508315,
0.0622759052,
-0.0208947416,
0.0765794739,
-0.0517662354,
-0.0209906306,
-0.0100208018,
-0.0025658321,
0.0121804047,
-0.0164213367,
0.0314434655,
-0.0214927085,
-0.032971032,
0.0138516091,
0.0203985646,
0.004961676,
0.025640659,
0.0025612954,
-0.0091692116,
0.0452756248,
0.0223056264,
-0.0214663986,
-0.0531596653,
0.012794177,
-0.0161089581,
-0.0046443287,
0.0171989631,
-0.0225516818,
-0.0804769918,
0.0368329547,
-0.0156008322,
0.0274491645,
0.0232422464,
-0.0764593557,
-0.0249902476,
0.0261735264,
-0.0175122004,
0.0257276073,
-0.0277613699,
0.0127840433,
-0.0101473173,
0.0490410477,
0.0126482826,
0.020867398,
-0.0053811539,
-0.0256140511,
-0.0225104317,
-0.0055633183,
0.0075037726,
-0.0412324071,
-0.0239194687,
0.0450721942,
0.0211895052,
0.0032272316,
-0.0100301802,
-0.0058687204,
-0.0933991224,
-0.0637988374,
-0.1000458598,
0.0117082391,
-0.0000854884,
0.0000894767,
-0.009658521,
0.0002811409,
-0.051622238,
0.0124887526,
-0.022992,
-0.0212793089,
0.0228409693,
-0.0028535458,
0.0056175492,
-0.0044417782,
0.0005947654,
-0.0669781119,
0.0082461769,
-0.0129341632,
0.003569064,
-0.0072037191,
-0.03528497,
-0.0038560843,
-0.0184741598,
-0.0420918055,
0.0149885705,
-0.0130768465,
-0.0707145259,
-0.0042975512,
0.0012405025,
0.0108685344,
0.0800709426,
0.0130454767,
0.1301666051,
-0.0080590229,
0.0044861394,
-0.0289362241,
0.0536933094,
-0.0245552007,
0.0490847863,
-0.0289902184,
-0.0346410163,
-0.0060193748,
0.0515194982,
-0.0104394192,
0.0223751701,
-0.0344573744,
-0.0002368935,
0.0169817712,
-0.0463971756,
0.0267298818,
-0.0108364346,
-0.0163254589,
-0.0256822016,
-0.0156568754,
-0.0490143262,
0.0137080839,
0.0266421493,
-0.0358352363,
-0.1137090325,
-0.0188166555,
-0.013817789,
0.0653722808,
-0.0680926144,
-0.0034773508,
-0.0115994811,
0.0033837992,
-0.0221990608,
-0.0479321666,
-0.035062369,
-0.0477381572,
-0.0269590542,
-0.0042478023,
-0.0385320857,
0.0303913839,
-0.0210303236,
-0.0369542204,
-0.0378847755,
-0.0448641703,
0.0233253352,
0.0228123739,
0.0161743741,
-0.0491789319,
-0.0052784202,
0.0307790916,
-0.0164999142,
-0.0204423089,
-0.0152069693,
0.015012647,
-0.0002265305,
0.0530448928,
-0.0000441059,
0.0525104776,
-0.0433833152,
0.0890882835,
0.0654884949,
0.0590098351,
-0.0032470431,
0.0090831062,
0.0456606857,
0.0048497776,
0.0148535408,
-0.007906531,
-0.052563481,
0.0384342521,
-0.0327970758,
0.0495794117,
0.1359877437,
0.0506426878,
-0.0260249991,
0.0224772617,
-0.0141811622,
0.0205169506,
0.0152849248,
0.013258202,
-0.0332942158,
-0.0452569127,
0.0144681605,
0.0363207087,
-0.0191000123,
-0.0361402296,
0.0308681913,
-0.0930298567,
0.0543403551,
0.0186427459,
0.0022468246,
-0.0252365191,
-0.0245433766,
0.0343458988,
0.0063991724,
-0.0134421913,
-0.0615427271,
0.0220079012,
-0.0156139629,
0.0439620726,
0.0005999944,
-0.0078823147,
0.0378221124,
-0.041760698,
0.0533342808,
-0.0191144422,
0.1114682853,
-0.0054015927,
-0.0356421843,
0.023410894,
0.0018594136,
-0.0419855714,
-0.0074160076,
0.0788284466,
-0.0474876799,
-0.0107146865,
-0.0196607318,
0.0483768657,
-0.0333750024,
-0.0069798906,
-0.0302142892,
0.0366725437,
-0.0613331757,
-0.04086807,
-0.0484465659,
0.0173815005,
0.0407071896,
0.0630982593,
0.0291571822,
-0.0523216464,
-0.0150287757,
0.0075832107,
0.025382895,
0.0044185366,
0.0474291071,
0.0427399687,
-0.0284820553,
-0.0290379226,
-0.0627504736,
-0.0975392684,
0.0388858616,
0.0724551752,
-0.0281116944,
-0.0353833921,
-0.0297702178,
0.0162791442,
-0.0148131931,
0.0332767852,
0.0319150016,
0.0080635473,
-0.0180324744,
-0.0351557359,
0.0133095914,
-0.0249344949,
-0.0159987323,
0.0162419453,
-0.0061584432,
-0.0450849943,
0.0445833765,
0.0426825322,
0.0261786692,
0.0244260412,
0.0027701273,
-0.0234061535,
0.0263670944,
0.0370176733,
-0.018692553,
-0.0065582427,
0.0463225283,
0.0204705298,
-0.0167631935,
0.0308299828,
-0.043943014,
0.0785092637,
-0.0300037544,
0.018778285,
-0.0232055243,
-0.0660430193,
-0.060474515,
0.0016387821,
0.0428407192,
0.0353389531,
-0.031807296,
-0.0298223253,
0.001875528,
0.0036085879,
0.017537903,
-0.0506882556,
-0.0056670746,
-0.0392569155,
0.0037135179,
-0.0416431837,
-0.0156880226,
0.0001183148,
-0.0477603078,
0.0143828448,
0.0304915588,
0.0136772124,
-0.0003325811,
-0.0354148373,
0.0447987989,
-0.0119030401,
-0.0236677229,
0.0313179754,
-0.0046486133,
0.0237137787,
0.0404970981,
0.0238494575,
-0.0284239799,
-0.0131710889,
0.0525777377,
-0.0522517674,
-0.0026585422,
-0.0092672305,
0.0382819511,
-0.0171531495,
-0.0237323325,
0.0482912399,
-0.0483102724,
0.0208194256,
-0.0011178713,
0.0293656439,
-0.0156429149,
-0.0313307866,
0.0097252503,
0.0083704414,
-0.0449850485,
-0.0174651779,
0.0231242049,
-0.046107281,
0.0901625976,
-0.0129079893,
-0.0254627764,
-0.0444986708,
0.0166593213,
0.0837160498,
-0.0293247793,
0.0036535573,
0.0235233903,
-0.0624778382,
-0.0342368037,
0.0427534617,
-0.0250349604,
-0.015352481,
-0.0335364453,
0.0359583609,
0.0590454303,
-0.0233413,
0.0242119301,
-0.0185421165,
0.0087041883,
-0.0535152964,
-0.0233636647,
0.0379141159,
-6.13683246e-33,
0.0088647259,
0.0200065784,
-0.0355689786,
-0.0103321271,
-0.030364031,
-0.0004436389,
-0.0069793635,
0.0158180092,
-0.0216888785,
0.0547397099,
-0.0236214604,
0.0543985479,
0.0209791809,
-0.0005563791,
-0.0083911875,
0.0030271888,
0.030206712,
-0.0314773433,
-0.0146276709,
0.0293812342,
0.0290656127,
0.0592403747,
0.0551057458,
-0.04450991,
0.0105741043,
0.009389448,
0.0119904373,
-0.0009694843,
0.0745492503,
0.0551242307,
0.0247543082,
0.065932855,
0.004325632,
-0.0088923089,
0.0066966312,
0.0251248181,
-0.0264864676,
-0.017413225,
-0.0335543528,
0.0383230336,
-0.014265378,
-0.0129325073,
0.007996669,
0.0493552871,
-0.0083719129,
-0.0233759191,
0.012893456,
-0.0348976217,
-0.0068389103,
-0.036391627,
-0.024167737,
0.013358213,
-0.0209304802,
-0.0461968407,
0.0138557358,
0.0484375618,
0.0055606407,
0.0072197099,
-0.0113020949,
-0.0032738228,
-0.000509412,
-0.0373921096,
0.0068029901,
0.015282332,
0.0130992401,
0.1080828682,
0.0426908396,
0.0117681585,
0.0439262278,
0.0351079553,
0.0273137819,
0.0565928668,
0.0082481978,
0.0064647985,
-0.0119237695,
-0.0072480063,
-0.0230805334,
0.0556762516,
0.0866920054,
-0.0059203864,
0.0349067338,
-0.0055578621,
-0.0324761383,
0.0167436674,
0.0349440873,
-0.0334007777,
-0.0048136241,
-0.0071268342,
0.0389473215,
-0.009105077,
0.0038179264,
-0.0045567709,
0.0206487961,
-0.0245502461,
-0.0036799181,
0.005312155,
-0.0453445576,
0.0431392305,
-0.0012942723,
-0.0025285021,
-0.0154243791,
-0.0378808677,
0.0627912655,
0.0340872668,
0.0512653925,
-0.0091609973,
-0.0049216542,
0.0299571734,
-0.0360076204,
-0.0110329073,
-0.0182322748,
0.0695682541,
-0.0236405004,
0.0619532317,
-0.0341659486,
0.0105693974,
-0.011141941,
-0.0070241634,
-0.017037861,
0.0415324159,
-0.025102146,
-0.0042814193,
-0.0109657561,
0.0131962923,
-0.0330376588,
0.002876621,
-0.0164861474,
-0.0527022593,
-0.0154748326,
-0.0269724652,
-0.0199242905,
-0.005649969,
2.86e-7,
-0.0061175283,
0.0217349119,
0.0135997627,
-0.0618191101,
0.00300912,
0.0578565001,
-0.0304559804,
0.0559584945,
0.0310093146,
-0.0246723499,
0.0355200991,
0.0123370904,
0.0588539727,
0.0231932476,
-0.0920674279,
-0.0334051587,
-0.0051711597,
0.0213088635,
-0.0223265868,
0.0025595906,
0.0952967405,
0.1280681193,
0.0457716919,
0.0012523318,
0.0198611245,
-0.0038595085,
0.014012916,
-0.0247220416,
0.0091146156,
0.0434170291,
0.0136149116,
0.0089377454,
-0.0174164064,
-0.006552265,
0.0139709264,
0.0061893198,
0.0134554189,
0.0483169071,
-0.016833812,
-0.0573064648,
0.0239493158,
0.0445755124,
-0.0095940605,
-0.0222248286,
0.0164444484,
-0.0293387659,
-0.0201534256,
-0.0180413965,
-0.0256988276,
0.0048754844,
0.0355129912,
-0.0252558403,
-0.023990633,
0.0487193316,
-0.0024508459,
-0.0558936931,
-0.0061035156,
-0.0881497264,
0.0201846026,
-0.011938463,
-0.0531808287,
-0.0703556836,
-0.0224779509,
0.0077003273,
0.0377322026,
-0.0114419628,
0.0051136408,
2.142157998e-34,
0.0120383939,
-0.0100027518,
-0.027514495,
0.0725178793,
0.0112473173,
0.0012617526,
-0.0402313136,
-0.0336492248,
0.0205965824,
-0.0450310372,
0.017766986
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.08335v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.08335v2 | FactReranker: Fact-guided Reranker for Faithful Radiology Report Summarization | 2023-03-15T02:51:57 | 2023-03-16T03:09:09 | Qianqian Xie, Jiayu Zhou, Yifan Peng, Fei Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Automatic radiology report summarization is a crucial clinical task, whose
key challenge is to maintain factual accuracy between produced summaries and
ground truth radiology findings. Existing research adopts reinforcement
learning to directly optimize factual consistency metrics such as CheXBert or
RadGraph score. However, their decoding method using greedy search or beam
search considers no factual consistency when picking the optimal candidate,
leading to limited factual consistency improvement. To address it, we propose a
novel second-stage summarizing approach FactReranker, the first attempt that
learns to choose the best summary from all candidates based on their estimated
factual consistency score. We propose to extract medical facts of the input
medical report, its gold summary, and candidate summaries based on the RadGraph
schema and design the fact-guided reranker to efficiently incorporate the
extracted medical facts for selecting the optimal summary. We decompose the
fact-guided reranker into the factual knowledge graph generation and the
factual scorer, which allows the reranker to model the mapping between the
medical facts of the input text and its gold summary, thus can select the
optimal summary even the gold summary can't be observed during inference. We
also present a fact-based ranking metric (RadMRR) for measuring the ability of
the reranker on selecting factual consistent candidates. Experimental results
on two benchmark datasets demonstrate the superiority of our method in
generating summaries with higher factual consistency scores when compared with
existing methods. | [
0.0613702275,
0.0052692709,
0.0314110145,
-0.0090521388,
-0.017670637,
0.0220298078,
-0.0631288141,
0.0296430588,
-0.0202415567,
0.0114156399,
0.0410925075,
-0.0068024565,
0.039630685,
0.006498232,
-0.0416398272,
-0.082582064,
0.0422779322,
0.0214913189,
0.0557657555,
-0.0089149596,
-0.0173249207,
-0.0022183848,
-0.0288401805,
0.0202901438,
-0.0302387197,
0.0330719277,
0.0482111722,
-0.0074099391,
0.055017259,
-0.0553915948,
-0.0293754376,
0.0091339787,
-0.0196365081,
0.0323803797,
0.0000020238,
-0.0459629409,
-0.0611235797,
0.0205350835,
-0.0223546457,
-0.0367745832,
0.051572118,
-0.0723821595,
0.0087858438,
0.0073208292,
-0.0019953228,
-0.0487271324,
0.0361295305,
0.0552871823,
0.0903851241,
0.056286063,
-0.0112007651,
-0.0225054994,
-0.0108601646,
-0.0069053415,
-0.013274991,
-0.0357198529,
0.0133494316,
0.0794427171,
0.0081210928,
0.0000223039,
-0.0320242941,
0.0214601979,
-0.002443651,
0.0114135863,
0.0388251729,
0.0513780937,
-0.0233436283,
0.0049644276,
0.0403217115,
0.055694215,
-0.0249713548,
0.0019813657,
0.0335174464,
-0.0097484021,
-0.0276711322,
0.0069254572,
-0.0218073279,
0.0123308115,
-0.0531077236,
0.0035863698,
-0.0070097647,
0.0319489129,
0.0008742223,
0.0031973806,
-0.0429180488,
0.0060427962,
-0.0230152849,
-0.0143381404,
-0.0030888778,
0.0312236827,
-0.004231777,
-0.0460451655,
0.0137746669,
0.02980561,
-0.0693916231,
0.0087990584,
-0.0195367038,
0.0023186288,
0.0627892017,
-0.0163113642,
-0.0362042114,
-0.0094570452,
-0.0078756753,
0.0702607557,
-0.0030141822,
0.0441398658,
0.0103909774,
0.0517800935,
-0.0692480206,
-0.002532871,
-0.0224856623,
0.0096298708,
-0.0121962186,
0.0425411128,
0.040084105,
-0.0094307391,
-0.0756166056,
-0.0212345254,
0.0057907659,
0.0579106286,
0.036888171,
0.0505579412,
-0.0602323487,
0.0289065577,
-0.0426319689,
0.0570385829,
0.0076925159,
-0.0322212875,
-0.0136143854,
0.0469517186,
0.0118284244,
0.0065457653,
0.0013897053,
0.0382888727,
-0.0042688395,
0.0083891395,
-0.015499494,
-0.0145562468,
0.0410214551,
-0.0536644235,
-0.02899676,
-0.0594382621,
0.0088519724,
-0.0827355608,
0.0449061505,
-0.0049516857,
0.0006616255,
0.0078753009,
0.0199497547,
-0.0061461469,
-0.0308592189,
0.0424855091,
-0.0346501246,
-0.0134844566,
0.0314064845,
0.0236133076,
-0.0200552437,
0.0071853017,
0.0147325816,
0.0431427769,
0.0227318909,
0.0403989069,
-0.0131349321,
-0.0312958956,
0.0136575568,
-0.0565070771,
0.0619706027,
-0.0049182051,
-0.0173486322,
0.0368177257,
0.0028667741,
0.0133587364,
-0.0226210672,
-0.0105885481,
0.0350058153,
0.0135144908,
0.0500293933,
-0.0296454243,
-0.006978801,
0.0055791931,
0.0111867394,
0.0689828917,
-0.0181831513,
0.0508603677,
0.0321383625,
0.0518074706,
0.0104168439,
0.0157763921,
-0.0068616741,
-0.0536703914,
-0.0136920167,
0.0009017799,
-0.0354643501,
-0.0093845651,
0.0479932837,
0.0056384718,
-0.0268573351,
0.0333235562,
0.063778013,
0.0069794296,
-0.0063284137,
-0.0266308989,
-0.0160162076,
0.0367100313,
0.0905796736,
-0.0769635662,
-0.0363128372,
0.0062155547,
0.0047474806,
-0.0012895806,
0.0479917862,
-0.0222179685,
-0.004146657,
-0.0338661857,
-0.0576611757,
0.0244457107,
0.0291604791,
-0.0001815947,
-0.0060952799,
0.0069356686,
-0.0260326564,
-0.0205157846,
-0.0445749275,
0.0226307511,
0.0115238931,
0.0009336874,
0.0127956383,
-0.0023204496,
0.0017668443,
0.0237456653,
-0.0458032228,
0.0135314716,
0.0256658569,
0.0243566595,
-0.0141210863,
0.0038648301,
-0.0526614375,
-0.0782321766,
0.0100356396,
-0.0861722976,
-0.0083300518,
-0.0007650426,
-0.0493347421,
-0.0194728468,
-0.0335514992,
-0.0815971717,
-0.018804213,
-0.006688673,
0.021867374,
0.0518928431,
-0.0345625505,
-0.0092031714,
0.0858496726,
-0.0254304521,
0.0017293132,
0.0318231806,
-0.0656974837,
0.0022546842,
-0.0632265285,
0.0126764597,
0.0200344566,
0.0088073416,
0.0189243667,
0.0367866345,
0.0106854085,
-0.0036133546,
-0.0258407034,
-0.0458927006,
-0.0149154253,
0.0138898809,
-0.049137231,
0.0500422493,
0.0112403193,
0.0263285656,
-0.0297794174,
-0.0193140898,
-0.048923865,
0.0624871589,
-0.0182570834,
0.0539965145,
0.031208355,
0.0279903617,
-0.0316729248,
-0.023142226,
-0.0124570709,
0.0019976366,
0.0514189601,
-0.012558572,
-0.0142587656,
0.0155745381,
-0.06822519,
-0.017812226,
-0.0047602574,
-0.0021744063,
0.0146170473,
0.0038196843,
-0.0433134064,
0.0563849248,
0.0373230316,
0.024229845,
0.0484863631,
-0.0017516485,
-0.0310404841,
-0.0059267883,
-0.0758419186,
0.0288131684,
0.0431724638,
-0.0670622066,
0.0220184829,
0.0056210253,
0.0441342555,
0.0148046501,
-0.0161955152,
-0.0140961967,
-0.030027112,
0.0075669657,
-0.0636771172,
0.0110261953,
-0.0034908666,
0.0230591167,
-0.0407027043,
-0.0026812109,
0.1156300679,
-0.0019565562,
0.0681808516,
-0.0897058994,
-0.0020496629,
-0.0328776762,
-0.0053655878,
0.0288465377,
0.0494184121,
0.005227325,
0.0095509235,
-0.0161906779,
-0.0073373006,
0.1152666956,
-0.0666435137,
0.0416795425,
-0.0000710264,
0.01545751,
-0.0009803382,
-0.0354531407,
-0.040497385,
-0.0192161519,
0.0461403318,
0.0024982344,
-0.0140448026,
-0.0068356399,
-0.1091338545,
0.0273251142,
0.0605230182,
0.0522702485,
-0.0095638027,
-0.021257868,
-0.0111459782,
0.0528137833,
0.0436859168,
0.007867136,
0.0271110833,
-0.0156963095,
0.0177767817,
0.0819705129,
-0.007857102,
0.0055669365,
0.0207244381,
-0.0149286557,
-0.0540558472,
-0.038340196,
0.0164925605,
-0.0135426875,
0.0065090745,
-0.0311196726,
0.0183779113,
0.0484485589,
0.0413050093,
-0.0043962449,
-0.0080213603,
0.0412205756,
-0.0203243941,
-0.0025730799,
0.0062117805,
-0.059889745,
0.0151466159,
-0.0161919259,
0.0548825152,
-0.0142221777,
-0.0396560617,
-0.0069560735,
-0.0429120176,
0.0477648303,
-0.0035277058,
-0.0337553024,
-0.0467872843,
-0.045525305,
-0.0028493267,
-0.0218328629,
-0.0530927517,
0.0255273357,
-0.0086600082,
-0.0158245619,
0.0060614897,
-0.0798447579,
-0.0380775519,
-0.0082454421,
-0.0541131012,
-0.0297829099,
0.0221495908,
0.0532473326,
0.0006938322,
0.0221500304,
-0.071965754,
0.0388242118,
-0.0105238399,
0.0077647753,
0.0902501121,
0.0083135869,
-0.0092423605,
-0.0546603166,
-0.004544843,
0.0746003091,
-0.0028536464,
-0.0279378518,
0.045599591,
0.0006976186,
-0.0135126049,
-0.0413275547,
0.0425167978,
-0.0076111867,
0.035000816,
-0.0128504178,
0.063675873,
-0.0243940931,
-0.007283329,
0.1003580242,
-0.0496098958,
-0.0407198854,
0.0286689196,
-0.086679019,
-0.0287804361,
-0.0849395543,
-0.0042519667,
-0.0143608628,
0.006667152,
-0.047884915,
-0.01912231,
0.010793888,
-0.0099501992,
-0.0653606728,
-0.0038914324,
0.0239157584,
-0.015673358,
0.0171998609,
-0.033962708,
0.0607264563,
-0.0414513163,
-0.0096893441,
0.0083643533,
0.0281874985,
0.0195979699,
0.0015251164,
0.0533275194,
0.0204502586,
0.0453501008,
-0.0039550737,
0.0325886793,
0.1010579318,
0.0504182912,
-0.041358076,
0.0150663592,
-0.0021936949,
-0.0424038656,
-0.0390131027,
-0.0227421913,
-0.0610596426,
0.0164636169,
-0.0387517698,
0.0293623023,
-0.0447396673,
-0.0268592332,
0.0529582798,
0.0567944273,
0.0166613031,
-0.029488435,
-0.0012557027,
-0.0184667408,
-0.0081208702,
-0.022846017,
-0.0119971279,
0.0005869246,
0.0382469967,
-0.00387805,
0.029819198,
0.0117061613,
0.0240290873,
-0.0190724153,
-0.0169776715,
-0.0164627843,
-0.0190154184,
0.0055009886,
-0.0349876285,
0.0025329217,
-0.0187086854,
-0.0388047323,
-0.0257565305,
0.0252283942,
0.0189103242,
0.0009775481,
0.0088583743,
0.0527292602,
0.034558285,
-0.0337696075,
0.0272196904,
-0.0641114414,
0.0044843364,
-0.0752543509,
-0.002968217,
0.0627523512,
0.0216116849,
-0.005162823,
-0.0330104791,
0.0010319829,
-0.0114093348,
0.0197034422,
0.0073991651,
0.0142681561,
-0.0025143563,
0.018083537,
0.0553084277,
0.0100765005,
0.0876569077,
-0.0297934301,
0.0135675268,
-0.0366590023,
-0.0713344216,
-0.0664142147,
-0.0575614125,
-0.0315501019,
0.0085646817,
-0.0279531367,
-0.0284663811,
-0.0781320408,
-0.0262464006,
0.0272224098,
0.0241671447,
0.014774547,
-0.0327054523,
0.049495317,
0.0234546885,
0.0274054166,
-0.0169788711,
-0.0186728425,
0.0158056729,
-0.0341056213,
0.0035924306,
0.0318241343,
-6.01286152e-33,
-0.0191978235,
-0.051092986,
0.0065071532,
-0.0069156634,
-0.0211303756,
0.0530691072,
-0.0294992961,
-0.0502772294,
0.0110638971,
0.0167771522,
-0.0082302531,
-0.0018151585,
0.0112486649,
0.012184443,
-0.0290503521,
0.0095235677,
0.0339693204,
0.0101886587,
-0.0534887686,
0.0096631134,
0.0063969721,
-0.0097111277,
0.0191743672,
-0.0907380655,
-0.0143453646,
0.0290151574,
-0.0093329968,
0.0127734961,
-0.0059624407,
0.0520152226,
-0.0047170543,
0.0058391853,
0.0237278063,
-0.067740649,
-0.0106967418,
-0.043625094,
-0.102648899,
-0.0559071377,
0.0037935115,
-0.0409967229,
-0.0516934693,
0.0392821766,
0.029030757,
-0.0123825017,
0.0079405699,
-0.072389923,
0.0426388681,
-0.0287208352,
-0.0332354531,
-0.0333589837,
-0.0061177225,
0.058982227,
0.0037474136,
-0.0122108106,
-0.0156641435,
-0.0161174312,
0.0015914086,
0.0175298434,
-0.0338813886,
0.0429794341,
0.0230336208,
0.045907367,
0.0037405244,
-0.0162448827,
-0.0216198843,
0.0749382824,
0.0179282315,
-0.0392675474,
-0.0242109634,
-0.0020715303,
-0.0637222305,
0.0294875093,
0.0325141475,
0.0580796972,
0.0452842079,
0.0015247501,
-0.0782781392,
0.0678682923,
-0.0147120561,
0.0697953701,
-0.0018608568,
-0.0338582583,
-0.0410375483,
0.0012606574,
0.0151834469,
0.031790778,
-0.0057222885,
-0.0372322388,
-0.004412292,
0.057651449,
-0.0438482128,
0.0326187387,
0.0035585025,
-0.002898027,
0.0423887894,
-0.013987828,
0.006027855,
0.0083523225,
-0.0432389267,
-0.0391812176,
-0.0327740945,
0.036874678,
0.0415812507,
0.0051909341,
0.0148014147,
0.0265187714,
0.0355970301,
-0.0033369202,
-0.0085250437,
0.0298878942,
0.0416910201,
-0.0195457675,
-0.0568791889,
-0.0017503886,
0.0101202298,
0.0185276531,
-0.013649283,
0.0270232372,
-0.006010781,
0.0558746271,
-0.0328497924,
-0.0129312798,
0.0148701789,
0.026603004,
-0.0210525561,
0.0051121339,
-0.0177633632,
-0.0015734953,
0.0094312821,
-0.0255251154,
-0.0219762996,
0.0211537797,
2.834e-7,
0.0524791293,
0.0270724893,
0.0449940972,
-0.0009366834,
-0.0025045443,
0.0111164693,
-0.0182948206,
0.0188467912,
0.0089299819,
-0.0299939141,
0.051653292,
0.0169645324,
-0.02248374,
0.0563200898,
-0.081633307,
-0.0106747225,
-0.0947827101,
-0.050354857,
0.0083893603,
-0.0619718209,
0.0620893762,
0.034342844,
-0.0295840111,
-0.0313642621,
-0.0076665194,
0.0279417299,
0.0238715932,
0.040179085,
-0.0242282748,
-0.002134236,
0.0778359622,
-0.0201059282,
-0.0079597272,
0.0318786986,
-0.005377993,
-0.0296453536,
0.0452762246,
0.027209226,
-0.0056676697,
-0.0105066551,
0.0175027475,
0.0169156138,
0.0327731557,
-0.0028465877,
0.0247259811,
-0.0578303151,
-0.0090448735,
-0.0003457791,
-0.050889615,
0.0169762094,
0.0382391736,
-0.0154553568,
-0.0588223524,
0.0667655841,
-0.0122251334,
0.0527348444,
-0.0116003538,
-0.0628884062,
-0.0181000475,
0.0208590813,
0.0245605428,
-0.0376172252,
0.078426376,
-0.0130340336,
-0.0122424113,
-0.0856835097,
-0.0140633443,
2.534346305e-34,
0.0664998963,
0.0208619311,
-0.0388882756,
-0.0685351342,
0.0273982547,
-0.018132383,
-0.0388396867,
0.0090597151,
0.0287576281,
-0.0153908627,
-0.0181946363
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.08329v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.08329v1 | Cross-speaker Emotion Transfer by Manipulating Speech Style Latents | 2023-03-15T02:34:03 | 2023-03-15T02:34:03 | Suhee Jo, Younggun Lee, Yookyung Shin, Yeongtae Hwang, Taesu Kim | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | In recent years, emotional text-to-speech has shown considerable progress.
However, it requires a large amount of labeled data, which is not easily
accessible. Even if it is possible to acquire an emotional speech dataset,
there is still a limitation in controlling emotion intensity. In this work, we
propose a novel method for cross-speaker emotion transfer and manipulation
using vector arithmetic in latent style space. By leveraging only a few labeled
samples, we generate emotional speech from reading-style speech without losing
the speaker identity. Furthermore, emotion strength is readily controllable
using a scalar value, providing an intuitive way for users to manipulate
speech. Experimental results show the proposed method affords superior
performance in terms of expressiveness, naturalness, and controllability,
preserving speaker identity. | [
-0.0283849146,
0.0689974353,
-0.0039186752,
0.0183352549,
0.0181624796,
-0.0021035308,
0.0268297326,
-0.0109033799,
-0.0276376195,
0.0131250657,
-0.0917993262,
-0.0293714032,
-0.0114100464,
0.0297271796,
0.0053902715,
-0.1523875743,
-0.0339317545,
0.0005667587,
0.0560288355,
-0.0357283764,
0.0750205293,
0.0054157232,
-0.0435630865,
-0.0082857516,
-0.0484922677,
-0.0107166339,
-0.0085415458,
0.0116413059,
0.07737194,
0.0281650107,
0.0210388862,
0.0026505822,
0.0448259152,
-0.0237871949,
0.0000017821,
0.0144515764,
0.0007586872,
-0.0017222344,
0.0482185408,
0.0331507251,
0.1073479876,
0.0258972608,
-0.0447773002,
-0.0169108119,
-0.0150432242,
-0.0176292993,
0.0505672023,
0.0871678963,
0.1114536002,
0.0576392747,
-0.0287184287,
-0.0208307169,
0.0102802739,
-0.0102141164,
0.0465361699,
-0.0323179178,
-0.0008120424,
-0.0265038628,
0.0169081502,
-0.032206513,
-0.0437618047,
0.0413141362,
-0.0095810425,
-0.0208056532,
0.0176592786,
-0.029604312,
-0.0283507444,
0.0021934859,
-0.0338239893,
0.0794714838,
0.0092212213,
0.0490561388,
0.0331088528,
0.005796025,
-0.0099685332,
0.013481319,
-0.0339707956,
-0.0303999837,
0.0361276045,
-0.0037209895,
-0.0457862616,
0.0483991839,
-0.0202300996,
-0.028798148,
0.015908286,
-0.0052939514,
0.0070797699,
-0.0237599313,
0.0389740281,
-0.0290242434,
-0.0274056252,
0.0343566462,
0.0583710223,
-0.0342790633,
0.0174848475,
0.0136558125,
-0.0652615279,
-0.061672762,
-0.0945176408,
-0.0443398394,
0.0283434279,
0.0282501932,
-0.0185926724,
0.0150440792,
0.0229189508,
0.0461822227,
-0.0454102084,
-0.012191548,
-0.002603272,
0.0057042507,
-0.0009584768,
0.013071171,
-0.0255041998,
-0.0214140341,
-0.0078215394,
-0.0214154385,
-0.0898248479,
-0.0189354345,
-0.0616464466,
-0.0271374658,
-0.02224092,
0.0081362147,
-0.0069692759,
0.0016776137,
0.027419094,
0.0152629325,
-0.0201466829,
0.0301360134,
0.0090188347,
-0.0214366894,
0.0055349492,
0.0424868688,
0.0575657003,
-0.0093015842,
0.0098139932,
0.0021207598,
-0.0429857075,
-0.0086329067,
-0.0361549966,
-0.0014183708,
-0.0374112204,
-0.0283350665,
0.0294953417,
-0.0149120633,
0.0152054504,
-0.0274054874,
0.0096908305,
-0.043566931,
0.0042416858,
-0.0320894793,
-0.0236632116,
0.0315287821,
0.0213141907,
0.0130307535,
0.0187661555,
0.0122167664,
-0.0109824622,
-0.0068622739,
0.0428927988,
0.0292596016,
0.0123489182,
-0.036482282,
0.0523519628,
0.0487741232,
0.0352862105,
0.0182331223,
-0.025159372,
-0.0894825533,
0.0058810478,
0.036076542,
0.0793247223,
0.0354402326,
-0.0218927115,
-0.0046529421,
0.0526227392,
0.0243640486,
0.060047511,
0.040516708,
0.0118282335,
0.0442217402,
0.0219859071,
-0.0113148401,
0.0017747642,
0.0324927643,
-0.0195765235,
-0.0153333861,
0.0609131046,
-0.0219411086,
-0.0316835977,
-0.0189376846,
0.0303443205,
-0.0105858622,
-0.0148046063,
-0.0158666838,
0.0117609473,
0.0182558913,
0.0073663779,
0.0111865588,
0.0212687813,
-0.1190954372,
0.0304072909,
0.0130102206,
-0.0128420079,
0.061186973,
-0.0272481311,
-0.0338822119,
0.0561585128,
-0.0092817424,
-0.0045718201,
0.0153595759,
0.0013697502,
0.002947723,
0.0390412882,
-0.0816210061,
0.0454256535,
0.0263624266,
-0.0205178689,
0.0094280457,
-0.0406773649,
0.0672276467,
-0.0104347477,
-0.0324370675,
0.0681171119,
-0.0118646948,
-0.0381178632,
-0.0571816154,
0.0174410231,
0.0230232757,
-0.0041314051,
0.0239033997,
-0.0166234281,
-0.0228770059,
-0.0063681789,
-0.0209407322,
-0.0185336396,
0.0522532351,
-0.0409934707,
0.0087138219,
-0.0036084841,
-0.046973519,
0.0303749535,
0.0209678933,
-0.0110185798,
-0.0498494469,
0.0742864311,
-0.0135442214,
0.0300130174,
0.0000334824,
-0.0002149715,
0.0136190802,
0.0351891741,
0.0488315038,
-0.022531908,
0.0100171668,
-0.0127497995,
0.0156251993,
0.0380625129,
-0.0591133572,
-0.0145456418,
-0.0160950795,
0.0102455476,
0.0244375356,
0.0326919518,
-0.0345553122,
-0.0321978368,
-0.0426936075,
-0.0596624687,
-0.0005161184,
-0.0220149457,
0.004991523,
-0.0207753815,
-0.0127589628,
0.026838107,
-0.0310518742,
0.0112186,
-0.0863152966,
-0.0040126098,
-0.004493257,
-0.0173555445,
-0.0275653657,
0.0034020143,
0.0148952259,
-0.0480141677,
0.0187904071,
-0.014111368,
-0.0001263342,
-0.0242837537,
0.006134144,
-0.0011068978,
-0.0021098815,
0.0137871066,
0.019791184,
-0.0283560548,
-0.0177120678,
-0.014349346,
-0.0199358966,
0.0424132869,
0.0189298131,
0.0050959871,
0.0325664841,
-0.0163438991,
-0.0491997562,
-0.0375654362,
0.037870381,
0.0123139983,
0.0426730141,
-0.0037963833,
-0.0030815927,
0.0058356524,
0.0330001563,
0.0369154438,
0.0235981867,
-0.053066697,
0.0026351125,
0.0407720245,
-0.0653299764,
0.0456344001,
-0.0199938212,
-0.0251065027,
-0.0297050308,
0.0165686179,
-0.0040869247,
0.0215061698,
-0.0278482847,
-0.0736226588,
0.0014994381,
-0.0047355178,
-0.0099631613,
0.0288379323,
-0.0875405893,
0.0083502037,
-0.0335820094,
-0.0076945447,
0.000108434,
-0.0351846367,
0.0208444055,
-0.0628490597,
0.0030304829,
-0.0333215185,
-0.0319011435,
0.0250918847,
-0.0048167231,
0.0154657587,
-0.0115576852,
-0.0077467719,
-0.0122805368,
0.0593208224,
-0.0475705005,
-0.007618865,
-0.0274752453,
0.0726271197,
-0.0257313419,
-0.0146989189,
0.0120797502,
0.0043217228,
0.0240129214,
0.0296797324,
0.0235642157,
-0.0467493199,
-0.0273021217,
0.009084953,
0.0170383807,
0.0682321787,
-0.0008817252,
0.0085413819,
0.04878534,
0.0200133473,
0.0338637605,
-0.0061021359,
-0.0390014388,
0.0382566974,
0.0027613472,
0.0602666177,
0.0561470278,
0.0149510708,
-0.039976161,
-0.0036549885,
-0.0582246892,
0.0177024547,
-0.0257164855,
0.0423106998,
-0.0492065251,
-0.0296132844,
0.0178091452,
0.0574087948,
0.0069111702,
-0.0282775555,
-0.013159045,
-0.0439784415,
0.0329774842,
0.0311029293,
-0.0213205386,
-0.0438546762,
-0.0194838215,
0.0326249823,
0.0011832741,
-0.0150336623,
-0.0171431713,
-0.0008174311,
-0.0097449645,
0.0395968333,
-0.0008989272,
-0.0117194224,
0.0001491343,
-0.0037131552,
0.0699892789,
-0.0002252617,
0.0997406915,
-0.0005959409,
-0.0601769313,
-0.0296484418,
-0.0056753862,
-0.0143755786,
-0.000011563,
0.0496984087,
0.0110289184,
-0.0191554707,
-0.0083696824,
0.0869264528,
0.0356179215,
0.0176658966,
0.0041605853,
0.0041231187,
0.0076801544,
-0.0363021307,
-0.0192013513,
0.0498742051,
0.0356265865,
0.0143923694,
0.0126658641,
-0.0884323269,
-0.0006291028,
-0.0356290266,
0.0608599819,
0.0090821153,
-0.1182520315,
-0.0074385032,
0.0013506111,
-0.0613998435,
-0.0708108023,
-0.0213000085,
-0.0033617048,
0.0337665677,
-0.0258790888,
-0.0541562811,
0.0132313576,
0.005099026,
-0.011634917,
-0.0125875352,
-0.0181949157,
0.0516579859,
0.0089260433,
-0.0222944077,
0.0105773192,
-0.0330779068,
0.0215410609,
0.0121814283,
0.0095170578,
-0.0661167353,
0.0453853644,
0.0281422883,
0.0056873453,
0.0207670666,
0.0202139076,
-0.0656199008,
0.0670587122,
0.0148042561,
-0.0258811172,
0.0361118019,
0.0798294544,
0.0437446572,
-0.0012252461,
0.0002666353,
-0.0244691819,
0.0244248211,
0.019161284,
0.0261506103,
-0.009677303,
-0.0540687591,
-0.0307362881,
0.0173985399,
0.0186601207,
0.0249615088,
0.0182205923,
-0.0198993329,
0.0004306052,
-0.0347419232,
0.0472605154,
-0.0604381226,
-0.0285240859,
-0.0123178624,
0.0321732424,
-0.0423807427,
-0.0506686009,
0.0031355987,
-0.0574890114,
-0.0032915424,
0.0551457852,
0.0156627018,
0.0252159033,
0.0022521396,
0.0553468131,
0.0200720206,
0.0103150215,
0.0124520911,
0.0156918392,
0.0000775627,
0.0238081925,
0.0150532788,
-0.0585293211,
0.024839133,
0.0286041498,
-0.0478906073,
0.0416358858,
-0.0137569476,
-0.0281405039,
-0.0313183069,
0.0087912343,
0.0710316077,
-0.033933688,
0.0495579503,
-0.0249514636,
-0.0039080847,
-0.0284345001,
-0.0301892851,
0.0119961612,
-0.0425479487,
0.0160693489,
0.006561995,
0.0055601057,
-0.0686257184,
0.0424086936,
-0.0494330563,
0.0384132825,
-0.0477732904,
-0.0060132244,
0.0569652393,
-0.056891758,
0.0164089929,
-0.0113132233,
-0.0350163281,
-0.04852245,
0.0553961396,
-0.0373499915,
-0.006448355,
-0.0532031804,
0.0208900198,
-0.0035180696,
-0.061792165,
0.043390356,
-0.0236208849,
-0.012132775,
-0.0273630619,
-0.0395158641,
0.0289294031,
-5.388099864e-33,
-0.0103705525,
0.0273592193,
-0.0341865942,
0.052776631,
-0.0735538229,
-0.0005395234,
-0.0372576751,
0.0540534444,
0.0159295369,
0.0497520119,
-0.0645987242,
0.0007411055,
0.0152630368,
0.0236578006,
-0.0236755759,
0.0109433327,
0.0246797353,
-0.0011102414,
0.0038775199,
0.0662917942,
0.0350343399,
0.0250485949,
0.0442333855,
-0.1267000884,
0.007686689,
0.0101637412,
-0.0425787568,
-0.0326482244,
0.0749106929,
-0.0125451908,
0.0048843566,
0.04583399,
-0.0448717326,
-0.0304297097,
-0.005681037,
0.0394381434,
-0.0011731036,
-0.022369463,
-0.0289798733,
0.0185488835,
-0.0537002124,
-0.023618618,
-0.0093532251,
0.0295912288,
-0.0027819956,
-0.0114306053,
0.0292987507,
-0.0029634289,
0.0395637415,
-0.1187962517,
-0.0136424145,
0.0327390656,
-0.0284560025,
-0.038706053,
0.049801372,
0.0400252193,
-0.0036111616,
-0.0307879783,
-0.0474315546,
0.0589238331,
-0.0144510185,
-0.0153656071,
0.0061499481,
0.0212435089,
0.0057301112,
0.0370292366,
0.0258008484,
-0.0362242609,
-0.0130717028,
0.0347695239,
0.0481250547,
0.0300249737,
0.0210262984,
0.0474108383,
-0.0152542982,
-0.0152622014,
0.0697867051,
0.0351663791,
0.0503057055,
-0.0425991602,
-0.0045424113,
0.0723494291,
-0.0091227237,
0.0230568331,
-0.0448317975,
-0.0305643026,
-0.0129573354,
-0.0307852738,
0.0248641279,
-0.0184182655,
-0.0035474915,
-0.0305124298,
-0.0011995626,
0.0201219879,
-0.0370717831,
-0.0290361196,
-0.0333667323,
0.0732614398,
-0.0332656465,
-0.0214086864,
-0.0058016255,
0.0025005778,
0.0869249776,
0.0215047467,
0.0532744527,
-0.0344600268,
-0.0372762084,
0.0561035164,
-0.0622166283,
-0.0175815076,
0.0316382125,
0.0760975778,
0.0123082642,
-0.034267392,
-0.0370474271,
-0.0018392262,
-0.013628698,
-0.0332559533,
0.0051738122,
0.0638910383,
0.0164142624,
-0.0207975637,
0.0008160174,
0.0218083318,
-0.0895519778,
0.0192664824,
-0.0027301398,
-0.0378037244,
0.0326825306,
-0.0407923684,
0.000931836,
-0.0048573227,
2.629e-7,
-0.064248763,
0.0179028325,
0.0168695617,
-0.0283449981,
0.0028137229,
0.0721253157,
-0.0007518396,
0.0405071639,
0.0341699719,
-0.0255725496,
0.0335406177,
0.010575979,
0.0814853832,
0.0072734393,
-0.0751335919,
-0.020507887,
-0.0092309527,
0.0170264412,
0.02633618,
0.0151502471,
0.0877278224,
0.0336043164,
0.046134308,
0.0039926488,
0.0313680097,
0.0428702347,
0.0341789685,
-0.0262754057,
0.0100728581,
-0.0246279854,
-0.0107711889,
-0.0830727518,
-0.0356891304,
-0.019496182,
-0.0054202182,
0.0042621871,
0.0415561795,
0.0565075427,
0.0066835633,
-0.0560887642,
-0.0015905626,
0.0633295402,
-0.0522889979,
0.057984706,
0.0052610571,
-0.0181880239,
-0.0409232415,
-0.024859529,
-0.0442202389,
0.01459336,
0.0025013417,
-0.0284411758,
-0.0560807623,
0.0233359728,
0.0072150985,
0.001213461,
-0.0074816532,
-0.0517313965,
0.0061938697,
-0.0073646391,
-0.0410840362,
-0.033588104,
-0.0412974283,
0.0433017239,
0.0124208881,
0.0159418285,
0.0114661064,
1.407307232e-34,
-0.0093897972,
-0.0156862643,
0.0060941158,
-0.0080292728,
0.0106400736,
0.0257769842,
0.0212429874,
0.0129273934,
0.0486410186,
-0.0624183491,
-0.0296444762
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.11163v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.11163v1 | Finding Similar Exercises in Retrieval Manner | 2023-03-15T01:40:32 | 2023-03-15T01:40:32 | Tongwen Huang, Xihua Li, Chao Yi, Xuemin Zhao, Yunbo Cao | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY | When students make a mistake in an exercise, they can consolidate it by
``similar exercises'' which have the same concepts, purposes and methods.
Commonly, for a certain subject and study stage, the size of the exercise bank
is in the range of millions to even tens of millions, how to find similar
exercises for a given exercise becomes a crucial technical problem. Generally,
we can assign a variety of explicit labels to the exercise, and then query
through the labels, but the label annotation is time-consuming, laborious and
costly, with limited precision and granularity, so it is not feasible. In
practice, we define ``similar exercises'' as a retrieval process of finding a
set of similar exercises based on recall, ranking and re-rank procedures,
called the \textbf{FSE} problem (Finding similar exercises). Furthermore,
comprehensive representation of the semantic information of exercises was
obtained through representation learning. In addition to the reasonable
architecture, we also explore what kind of tasks are more conducive to the
learning of exercise semantic information from pre-training and supervised
learning. It is difficult to annotate similar exercises and the annotation
consistency among experts is low. Therefore this paper also provides solutions
to solve the problem of low-quality annotated data. Compared with other
methods, this paper has obvious advantages in both architecture rationality and
algorithm precision, which now serves the daily teaching of hundreds of
schools. | [
-0.0028231691,
-0.0552853905,
-0.0406148396,
0.0188770313,
-0.0219414085,
0.0086569218,
0.019196406,
-0.0058449577,
0.0224326793,
-0.0660400018,
-0.0085564787,
0.0254240986,
-0.0445848964,
-0.0624176674,
0.0077775908,
-0.0648587868,
0.0353032015,
0.0219732877,
-0.0378771424,
0.000377579,
0.0060060271,
-0.0323750637,
-0.0159906223,
0.0088975197,
0.0069403248,
-0.0140586495,
-0.0299814083,
-0.035667669,
0.0227563716,
-0.0292759314,
-0.0137092741,
0.0115325069,
0.0265137367,
-0.0133502241,
0.0000019901,
-0.0420643091,
-0.0978281051,
0.0036496778,
-0.0178782102,
0.0121029699,
0.0221055448,
0.1095463857,
0.0348626636,
-0.0261454172,
-0.041775208,
0.0043872343,
0.0428141803,
0.0146538615,
0.1030820906,
0.0471064486,
0.0112702493,
0.0051404517,
-0.0129711125,
0.0440069363,
0.0658710375,
-0.0395381451,
0.0157261938,
0.0793184936,
0.064235419,
0.0850950032,
-0.0106170932,
0.006772812,
-0.0101210233,
0.0212391224,
-0.0035371601,
-0.0218825564,
-0.0178048667,
0.0548127443,
0.0184816029,
0.034139242,
0.0115580345,
0.0077600395,
0.0070478595,
-0.0036629499,
0.0216888711,
0.0374192297,
-0.0746851116,
0.0153279509,
-0.0126438867,
-0.0007452666,
0.0046562017,
0.0200988613,
-0.0147564756,
-0.0246940777,
-0.0136780581,
-0.0180792715,
0.0057348465,
-0.0328084752,
0.0033315758,
0.0097903609,
-0.0572913885,
0.0125013972,
0.0280654784,
0.039075166,
-0.011428182,
-0.0115039116,
-0.0024661922,
-0.0829098001,
0.0186272822,
-0.0246647485,
0.0344086587,
0.0281751864,
0.0210021455,
0.0164434072,
-0.0189598165,
0.0698767304,
0.006044135,
0.0405834131,
-0.0889256373,
0.0271092597,
-0.1074797809,
0.0144050764,
-0.0518563651,
0.1180710495,
0.0301306322,
0.0316012502,
-0.0630148575,
-0.0012910666,
-0.0703129321,
0.0280650649,
-0.0279859193,
0.0097041726,
-0.0220408086,
0.0372488983,
-0.0528404377,
-0.0170008466,
-0.0375696607,
-0.0097674746,
-0.02184706,
0.0266338438,
0.028088659,
-0.0019690839,
0.0187881328,
-0.0326059572,
0.0214968566,
0.0004371011,
0.0073102927,
-0.0035169851,
-0.0666751638,
-0.0434213951,
0.0231040921,
0.0172939375,
0.0082893856,
-0.0474447794,
0.0181610771,
-0.0258534569,
0.011404464,
0.0257668961,
0.0099197477,
0.0240710992,
-0.0110220993,
0.0674703717,
0.0002670855,
0.000359098,
0.0240109861,
0.0245135762,
-0.0107228914,
0.0127450097,
0.0061390088,
-0.0180759393,
0.0386460386,
-0.013092678,
0.0037554039,
-0.0088138217,
0.0146538476,
-0.0359885506,
0.0519430079,
-0.0037649495,
0.0060487399,
0.0285682324,
-0.0363586284,
0.0292482898,
-0.0269590374,
-0.0061152359,
-0.0288766045,
0.0450608134,
-0.0159904137,
0.0353987999,
-0.0117841624,
0.0202733278,
0.0036860919,
0.0650372878,
0.0014455962,
0.0123043414,
0.0062995241,
-0.0192117263,
0.0302619003,
-0.050806202,
-0.0212445166,
-0.0580337457,
-0.007702243,
-0.0183397271,
-0.0123642003,
0.0296168458,
0.0559620075,
-0.0011402474,
0.0164686665,
0.067459695,
0.0056534964,
-0.0313307308,
0.0074508893,
-0.0212269444,
0.023114169,
-0.0117531819,
0.0287752505,
-0.1147760525,
-0.0457390249,
0.0219432265,
0.0022037304,
-0.0429624878,
0.0530372225,
-0.054101456,
-0.0598456673,
-0.0589550436,
-0.0372321792,
-0.009213333,
-0.01008802,
-0.013301014,
-0.0292399023,
-0.0096295718,
0.0215560161,
-0.0365126245,
-0.0759102106,
0.0324099399,
-0.002501583,
-0.0256727636,
0.0057324748,
0.0313470475,
0.0371416844,
0.0449801907,
0.0172144715,
0.0362855159,
0.0306926426,
-0.0444705635,
-0.0054860502,
-0.0568496585,
-0.0193567909,
0.0073532928,
0.0710361823,
-0.0917848125,
-0.0156649351,
0.0177368075,
-0.0398814008,
-0.0848405883,
-0.0130400863,
-0.0203314777,
0.0255716722,
-0.0027629915,
0.037389461,
0.0041246852,
-0.0912267193,
-0.050914783,
0.0480093434,
0.07130941,
0.0812297314,
0.0208259877,
-0.0007212095,
0.0789304748,
-0.0709020719,
-0.0542141683,
-0.0218092166,
-0.0212993585,
0.0221729856,
0.0441062562,
-0.0145794619,
-0.0580823943,
0.0296149012,
-0.0639907196,
0.016396571,
0.0254978221,
0.0142999869,
0.0331644528,
-0.0210695807,
0.0297328681,
-0.0486378931,
-0.0657301173,
-0.0209778808,
-0.0257781111,
0.0163163804,
-0.0012558536,
0.0056215487,
0.0198237263,
-0.0279801302,
-0.0167543869,
-0.0642944798,
0.0069991071,
0.0421330668,
0.0136213368,
-0.0361207239,
0.0976578146,
-0.0293396525,
0.0123274121,
0.0284633636,
0.003534086,
0.017437024,
-0.0197985806,
0.0119473916,
0.0355264135,
-0.0040312228,
-0.0187763311,
0.0501746908,
-0.0039031524,
-0.0743007064,
0.018879842,
-0.0609591417,
-0.0371589959,
-0.0088505596,
-0.0642471313,
0.0103754094,
-0.036099229,
0.0256553888,
-0.0345330238,
-0.0142052667,
-0.0082014669,
-0.0366126224,
0.059962336,
-0.0928027108,
-0.006909627,
0.0202734601,
-0.0000722952,
0.0067542675,
0.0172918476,
0.0507822409,
0.0102629289,
0.0331422687,
-0.0603706278,
0.0170628317,
-0.0046710684,
0.0494559631,
0.0151133724,
0.0323471949,
-0.0186707787,
-0.0109916553,
-0.0658252612,
0.0330805667,
0.079915233,
-0.0590778887,
0.0010341628,
-0.011411068,
0.0036383795,
0.0018574659,
-0.0180094,
-0.0232250188,
0.0330261365,
0.028244175,
0.0106853181,
-0.063320443,
0.0332524516,
-0.0324027538,
-0.0028219984,
0.0157258455,
-0.0079600969,
-0.0128974756,
-0.0042408761,
0.0108112711,
0.0743005574,
0.0003714102,
0.006225992,
-0.0026386357,
-0.027197944,
-0.0208439156,
0.0532780401,
0.0579786487,
0.0112731112,
-0.0061236802,
0.0205523111,
0.0160176437,
-0.1051676348,
-0.0203989968,
0.0330751687,
0.0259726103,
-0.0566953607,
-0.0480413958,
0.0553347021,
0.0467412472,
-0.0061864108,
-0.0260064565,
0.0205514543,
-0.0569835342,
0.0397090167,
0.0342354849,
-0.0745587423,
0.01579744,
-0.0222666189,
0.0433558039,
-0.0367151834,
-0.0309827067,
0.0438067764,
-0.1080363989,
0.0102250837,
0.0500084013,
-0.0320636667,
-0.0220570732,
-0.0239319298,
-0.0257477798,
-0.0174397118,
-0.0450607352,
-0.00993618,
0.0247977097,
0.0353819318,
0.0498955064,
-0.0037861837,
-0.0004529969,
-0.0035428815,
-0.033242166,
0.022702612,
0.0084018875,
0.0102690281,
-0.0167072453,
-0.0726909861,
0.0035240755,
-0.0490906462,
-0.0257437415,
-0.0021488417,
0.0544541888,
0.001499159,
-0.0027397792,
-0.0121931741,
0.0316443779,
-0.0051496848,
-0.0173907802,
0.0393546112,
0.1258806139,
-0.0451110825,
0.0471401028,
-0.0553552099,
-0.0467364974,
0.0189468078,
0.0458975956,
0.0339435823,
0.0075545125,
0.0206932109,
-0.0284034256,
0.0581458844,
-0.034850359,
0.008172554,
0.0697469488,
-0.0768984184,
0.0616926961,
-0.0293975174,
-0.0165332668,
0.0309901573,
0.0495057777,
0.0094025824,
0.005509669,
0.0285338368,
-0.0033247259,
-0.0622240491,
0.0113106621,
-0.0080867931,
-0.0124680642,
-0.0076464536,
-0.052367378,
0.0460507423,
0.0445645228,
-0.0609173067,
-0.0292750895,
-0.0345534198,
0.0004661788,
-0.0100670159,
0.064646244,
0.0073971967,
0.0005650326,
0.0071164216,
0.0106292972,
0.005791951,
-0.0388457105,
-0.0401330218,
-0.0209494196,
-0.0191724449,
-0.0370625146,
-0.0346151106,
-0.0095896712,
-0.0220780019,
0.0326137021,
0.0220384281,
0.0577678047,
-0.0383933038,
-0.014224967,
0.0549008697,
0.0762746111,
0.0423913971,
0.0445488766,
-0.0206968915,
-0.0204457436,
0.023404358,
0.0297291689,
-0.0558970533,
-0.0088257892,
0.0234666169,
-0.0077004549,
0.0094019435,
0.0082507189,
0.0068951994,
-0.0056792209,
0.0622117035,
0.0009388077,
0.0082782917,
0.0345864818,
0.0330529697,
-0.0291879494,
-0.0054390407,
-0.0178717244,
-0.0201904979,
0.0430131517,
0.061259035,
-0.0120913591,
0.0480365753,
0.0524935238,
0.0294524394,
-0.0191904865,
-0.0094966013,
-0.0157442931,
-0.0054336991,
-0.034916725,
-0.0006148165,
0.0339772068,
-0.0253609773,
-0.0073593482,
0.0012226281,
-0.0219777022,
-0.0051213331,
0.020842772,
-0.0148820775,
-0.0078520197,
0.0161011089,
0.0421656743,
0.0434556901,
-0.0022258165,
0.0131364493,
-0.0725145414,
-0.0039158668,
-0.0231847335,
-0.0679623038,
-0.0355991311,
-0.0067796991,
0.0474719517,
0.0505305529,
0.0062022717,
-0.0448939987,
-0.0298898071,
-0.023066612,
0.0400981009,
0.0274170302,
0.0101140309,
0.0284461826,
0.0753703713,
0.0279902481,
-0.0035548839,
0.0012892784,
-0.0081964703,
0.0036835973,
-0.0460488535,
-0.0312838145,
-0.0233957283,
-5.00001518e-33,
-0.0356595516,
-0.0411632359,
0.0162616149,
-0.0047991667,
-0.0162190031,
0.0093332371,
-0.0162229557,
0.0034572219,
-0.0019062521,
-0.0033180378,
0.0085081821,
-0.0261997934,
-0.0036396175,
0.0086380262,
0.0409697816,
0.0088216104,
0.0356691442,
-0.0061240764,
-0.0118806986,
0.0176748615,
0.0436657444,
-0.0071730581,
0.0451206192,
-0.0534855463,
-0.0246611554,
-0.0127691058,
0.0394721702,
0.0090842191,
-0.0063939118,
0.055684749,
0.004924933,
0.0366433598,
0.023468636,
-0.0385210998,
-0.0135152796,
-0.0395691805,
-0.0593445823,
-0.0817018002,
-0.040418826,
0.0121850697,
-0.0084591787,
-0.0119857816,
0.0403940827,
-0.0201450605,
-0.0274690017,
-0.0074490258,
0.0613112412,
-0.0195261445,
-0.02173209,
0.0138038909,
-0.0010887774,
-0.0066188476,
-0.0292636864,
0.0370196328,
0.020353321,
-0.0057282527,
0.0028376384,
-0.0188508295,
-0.0240520667,
0.0544395931,
0.0135689704,
0.0626425147,
-0.0258758105,
-0.0149888573,
-0.0021224723,
0.0381476767,
0.0201659407,
-0.0337633714,
0.0475691892,
0.0113928588,
0.0161218233,
0.0245510545,
0.0547394119,
0.0328196175,
0.0471353531,
0.0308122672,
-0.0522785932,
0.0677717701,
-0.0179669634,
0.0143295415,
-0.0392132662,
-0.0176568255,
-0.0424919575,
-0.0268221796,
-0.0475986637,
0.0154385315,
-0.0188126806,
-0.023111932,
0.0449867584,
-0.0490698293,
-0.0424840674,
0.0729143247,
0.0220412668,
-0.0215551276,
-0.0275360812,
-0.0695468858,
0.0578559749,
0.0317043774,
-0.0296412073,
0.0124100214,
-0.0368926674,
-0.0774799809,
-0.0058540613,
-0.0575874001,
0.0277754813,
-0.0000750286,
0.0264877267,
-0.0002664331,
-0.0193681177,
-0.0014982264,
0.0145371929,
-0.1099281907,
-0.0169650316,
-0.0277791861,
0.0097843111,
0.0691399127,
0.0143678393,
0.0971200392,
-0.002864504,
-0.0134285996,
-0.0415017903,
-0.0440642796,
0.0265596062,
-0.0138062527,
0.0166717246,
-0.0088021029,
-0.0317838155,
0.0284631904,
-0.0190070309,
-0.0406594276,
0.0174585693,
0.0068894434,
2.593e-7,
0.0249867663,
-0.027404571,
0.0253629368,
-0.0175514538,
-0.0265453849,
0.0233627632,
-0.0095283752,
-0.0009259731,
0.014165327,
0.0064125569,
0.0528897904,
0.0004340525,
-0.005871247,
0.0641125217,
-0.0364643931,
-0.0207353625,
0.0336127542,
-0.0489243492,
-0.062186759,
0.0356043428,
0.0748742148,
0.0424577594,
0.0585494488,
0.0214163978,
-0.0071922354,
-0.0351336338,
0.036610838,
0.0102282939,
0.0094581591,
0.0474257842,
0.0090312622,
0.0148388259,
-0.0055664713,
0.0079675773,
0.0005070364,
-0.0143882316,
0.0569837689,
-0.016768327,
0.0156446733,
-0.0326499492,
-0.0011725841,
-0.0054358356,
0.0176889114,
0.0043959166,
0.008604927,
-0.0752282962,
0.0190610066,
0.0471562967,
-0.0475060605,
-0.0081760697,
-0.0285478737,
0.0368906744,
0.0118965618,
0.0131200934,
0.0088360859,
0.0162257496,
0.01847969,
-0.0505209379,
0.0330419727,
0.0165827163,
-0.0236457158,
-0.0146114333,
-0.0072256117,
-0.0102483658,
0.0029187554,
-0.0633255243,
-0.0105432598,
2.411056004e-34,
-0.0092611192,
0.0107671274,
0.0449413061,
0.0312569626,
-0.0430624783,
-0.0153610306,
-0.0051015131,
0.0129551766,
0.0258279834,
-0.009333265,
-0.0413031168
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.08302v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.08302v3 | ZeroQuant-V2: Exploring Post-training Quantization in LLMs from Comprehensive Study to Low Rank Compensation | 2023-03-15T01:27:15 | 2023-05-26T00:17:06 | Zhewei Yao, Xiaoxia Wu, Cheng Li, Stephen Youn, Yuxiong He | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Post-training quantization (PTQ) has emerged as a promising technique for
mitigating memory consumption and computational costs in large language models
(LLMs). However, a systematic examination of various quantization schemes,
model families, and quantization bit precision has been absent from the
literature. In this paper, we conduct a comprehensive analysis of these factors
by investigating the effects of PTQ on weight-only, activation-only, and
weight-and-activation quantization using diverse methods such as
round-to-nearest (RTN), GPTQ, ZeroQuant, and their variants. We apply these
methods to two distinct model families with parameters ranging from 125M to
176B. Our contributions include: (1) a sensitivity analysis revealing that
activation quantization is generally more susceptible to weight quantization,
with smaller models often outperforming larger models in terms of activation
quantization; (2) an evaluation and comparison of existing PTQ methods to
optimize model size reduction while minimizing the impact on accuracy,
revealing that none of the current methods can achieve the original model
quality for quantization with either INT4-weight or
INT4-weight-and-INT8-activation; (3) based on these insights, we propose an
optimized method called Low-Rank Compensation (LoRC), which employs low-rank
matrices to enhance model quality recovery with a minimal increase in model
size. | [
-0.0194734,
0.067120187,
0.0061226506,
0.0604876429,
-0.0000155792,
-0.0061531672,
0.013649161,
0.0406997874,
-0.0171192959,
-0.05862391,
-0.018593302,
-0.0761922002,
-0.0178984609,
-0.0111933108,
0.0404311493,
0.0052999565,
0.0698615313,
-0.0439107865,
-0.0138835479,
-0.0198685285,
-0.0253980048,
-0.0097619761,
0.0259196945,
0.0151075507,
0.0244497061,
-0.0052390196,
-0.0236283112,
0.0202960242,
-0.0156945568,
-0.0292594284,
-0.0107402373,
0.0560124703,
0.0368602052,
0.0383026823,
0.000002115,
-0.009228969,
-0.0064158347,
0.0084881466,
-0.0405950472,
0.0809393227,
0.0247101355,
-0.0125283571,
-0.0346985087,
0.0210416708,
0.0174340345,
0.0100690192,
0.0806430429,
0.0073390394,
0.0209189691,
0.0565571748,
-0.0076172114,
-0.0340989977,
0.0470497347,
0.0027126658,
-0.0019000696,
-0.0322731249,
0.0141375512,
0.0604987442,
-0.0162330158,
0.0163809601,
-0.023716623,
0.0176354442,
-0.0016653237,
0.0077649942,
-0.0227581859,
0.0131712751,
-0.054611586,
0.0169086102,
-0.0229308493,
0.0242319945,
-0.0716190264,
-0.0312185381,
-0.0034460027,
0.0133206313,
-0.0363011882,
-0.1018547863,
-0.0343992375,
0.0384607874,
0.0453119092,
0.0428172313,
-0.040250849,
-0.0184883233,
0.0511164032,
0.0029207091,
-0.0683101267,
0.0434221886,
0.0317318551,
-0.0179503448,
-0.039399039,
-0.0421153083,
-0.0776806474,
-0.0232395921,
-0.0216369685,
0.0041432003,
0.0186354145,
0.0051359599,
-0.0415376276,
-0.0166772194,
0.0010868123,
-0.0690544099,
0.0209097881,
0.0809619576,
0.0030811292,
0.0021899405,
-0.0413395166,
0.0494117215,
-0.0329794735,
0.0352481268,
-0.0271827579,
0.0292052515,
-0.0203412529,
0.0035971147,
-0.0274868086,
0.0644802004,
-0.0139806485,
-0.0117885051,
-0.0583403818,
-0.0067415154,
0.0086374283,
-0.0270372201,
0.0023191203,
0.0086228382,
-0.0224629249,
-0.002895378,
0.0158576351,
0.0419912226,
0.0314664431,
-0.0056145131,
-0.0244591422,
-0.0496468879,
-0.0172596164,
0.0190508831,
-0.0077670561,
-0.0476239882,
0.0247152727,
0.0138874119,
0.0038465899,
-0.0588616282,
-0.0287074018,
0.0085419966,
-0.0160458554,
-0.0483740568,
-0.0329263359,
-0.062901035,
-0.018270161,
-0.0062886123,
0.0006418172,
-0.0195572767,
0.018135909,
0.0090347687,
-0.0299919602,
0.0553402565,
-0.0222370885,
0.0027785148,
-0.0102346204,
0.0136490576,
0.04539207,
0.0754080191,
0.0533797629,
0.0101193972,
0.0114089847,
-0.0164743606,
-0.0443687849,
0.0467170738,
0.0338897593,
0.0067541939,
-0.0654900596,
-0.0384384692,
0.0053822659,
0.0222978536,
0.0866608545,
0.0831458345,
-0.0545429625,
-0.0124097746,
0.0330643654,
0.0518898778,
0.0514904521,
0.0493325517,
-0.0233554114,
0.0144937253,
-0.0010780888,
-0.0247818977,
-0.0373867564,
0.0243833177,
-0.0189487319,
0.0195325315,
0.074015379,
0.051438801,
-0.0322482027,
-0.0134924613,
-0.0454624966,
-0.0242702737,
0.0263201445,
-0.0083358744,
0.0525601283,
-0.026702201,
-0.0256920382,
0.1212091446,
0.0180706698,
-0.0808874965,
-0.0319084674,
-0.0996086374,
-0.0104019009,
0.014132686,
0.0327291004,
-0.014540188,
0.0153295062,
0.0215665214,
-0.0153333247,
0.0100331483,
-0.0195523202,
0.0326535441,
0.0044060913,
-0.0679571629,
-0.0330301002,
0.0099018514,
0.0066303522,
-0.0108076967,
0.0092724105,
0.0105593447,
0.0085410494,
-0.0357684642,
-0.0340726301,
0.0109099671,
0.019858662,
-0.0447583087,
0.0298304949,
-0.0256630071,
0.0228960626,
0.0410519652,
-0.0122947991,
0.0052116881,
0.0378211029,
-0.0225950219,
0.0263826959,
-0.0672065169,
-0.007360463,
-0.0070522972,
0.0863965377,
0.0565260537,
0.0696795359,
0.060974773,
-0.0177436527,
-0.0585868284,
0.0426408164,
-0.0144593278,
0.0437687412,
-0.0653516203,
0.0407327041,
-0.0329733156,
0.0232676454,
-0.0367552526,
0.0245115515,
-0.027872188,
0.0131222187,
0.0429692194,
0.0089974226,
0.025107991,
-0.039378304,
-0.0707073286,
0.0182940699,
0.0105734728,
0.0647280812,
0.0023565334,
0.0008600623,
0.0119869849,
0.0007017223,
-0.1155062094,
0.0188126806,
-0.0412123017,
0.0231177341,
0.0192776863,
0.0296500176,
0.0277672689,
-0.0061681871,
-0.0461094454,
-0.0505691282,
-0.0188470297,
0.0004102342,
-0.0213246401,
-0.0127265388,
-0.0382237397,
-0.0391713679,
-0.043649096,
0.0017393569,
0.0440359153,
-0.0678326115,
-0.0538231097,
-0.0697132871,
0.0470998511,
-0.0248448048,
0.0521349721,
-0.0087228902,
-0.0579628609,
0.0001006182,
-0.0150269018,
0.0054515926,
0.0164383091,
-0.0105324732,
-0.013430479,
0.0972607434,
0.035390079,
-0.0528990813,
0.0219725184,
-0.0017253604,
-0.0656355098,
-0.0068763173,
-0.0250182562,
-0.0337195359,
0.1020667776,
-0.0267945882,
-0.0215579104,
-0.0272508264,
-0.0241487008,
0.0119378166,
-0.011455249,
-0.0349244066,
0.0152411629,
-0.0348057821,
0.0480436161,
0.0002153925,
-0.0570031255,
0.0016330242,
-0.0306054354,
-0.0036540835,
-0.0254033953,
-0.0032192403,
-0.015374775,
0.0287747085,
0.0126301702,
0.0528938957,
-0.0195020568,
-0.0088782106,
-0.0342050865,
-0.0215686411,
-0.0221222769,
-0.0377044529,
0.0194054618,
-0.0018579544,
0.0572970659,
-0.0578734055,
0.0014869116,
0.0237984136,
0.0363197103,
0.001787727,
0.0460566245,
0.0091216536,
-0.0465472303,
0.0495625883,
0.083064571,
0.0037098492,
0.0253760237,
-0.0142650669,
0.0105865151,
-0.019787332,
0.0299458448,
0.0049683643,
0.0108401263,
0.0438443869,
0.0008981408,
0.0084195081,
0.0104796691,
0.0328117758,
0.0551841781,
-0.0450981893,
-0.0072602914,
0.0626419559,
0.0200201944,
-0.0346395262,
0.0398611613,
0.0449688584,
-0.0274400357,
0.0102004968,
0.0754088089,
0.028450219,
-0.0561017022,
0.0115127815,
-0.012919954,
0.0350075029,
0.0098872604,
0.011360961,
-0.1148785427,
0.0001941814,
0.0072276196,
-0.0079236357,
0.0075650746,
0.0232509486,
-0.0064312625,
-0.0725243688,
0.0167821087,
0.063235037,
0.0089367023,
-0.0357152447,
-0.0077962377,
-0.0226434767,
-0.0111454269,
0.055463504,
0.061436709,
-0.0024881531,
-0.0163901914,
0.0361930616,
-0.012923385,
-0.0599052906,
0.0217516944,
-0.0259140395,
0.0608594567,
0.0457385145,
0.0173469502,
-0.0011012582,
-0.0163753238,
0.0165443905,
0.0020267328,
-0.0166113153,
0.0083463974,
-0.0003541404,
0.0389093682,
-0.0100384941,
0.0154505903,
-0.0055703293,
0.0190217532,
-0.0119111286,
-0.0466719158,
0.0519595295,
-0.018671833,
-0.0064326478,
0.0104382196,
-0.0497537479,
-0.0335580781,
0.0421315394,
0.008564515,
0.0025906768,
-0.0613206998,
-0.0096873734,
-0.00559898,
-0.0486852266,
-0.0482628942,
-0.0004473629,
-0.0242965054,
-0.0371436365,
-0.0150157847,
0.0337353833,
-0.0048748618,
0.0084494324,
-0.0189824235,
0.0027960993,
0.0104162116,
0.0100178085,
-0.062285807,
0.0064123413,
-0.0491599068,
0.0305955391,
-0.060403768,
-0.0089880805,
0.0153419813,
-0.0040300251,
0.0015107053,
-0.0438075848,
-0.1179163232,
-0.0621825606,
-0.0148855532,
0.0284385309,
0.0216680989,
0.0317085758,
0.0148198754,
-0.0874656662,
0.0472820625,
0.03599976,
-0.0183415189,
0.0529982187,
0.0228755176,
0.0010754563,
-0.0135131124,
0.0262960512,
-0.0245817676,
0.0357873216,
0.0107348133,
0.0569742993,
-0.052449517,
-0.0395658985,
-0.0052097747,
0.0222264901,
0.0464914031,
-0.0002717455,
-0.0131636392,
0.0177775342,
0.0395541154,
-0.0412078388,
0.033605542,
-0.0430450737,
0.0035018062,
0.0162961502,
0.0049473434,
-0.011668792,
-0.0394747928,
0.0090781692,
-0.01278341,
0.0291416626,
0.0049082432,
-0.0473216213,
0.0072146067,
0.0647527054,
-0.0050370921,
-0.0396499895,
0.0067111836,
0.0127963042,
0.0243861489,
-0.016617205,
0.0174296014,
-0.0136320917,
0.0160487685,
-0.0474658087,
0.0495384745,
-0.0106913419,
-0.0436872356,
-0.0516414829,
-0.0112946881,
0.0779809654,
0.0419265926,
0.0363636017,
0.0186222438,
-0.0216153879,
-0.0227636248,
0.0235969294,
0.0205696374,
0.0081210667,
0.0369536877,
0.021438593,
-0.0323026925,
0.0127107101,
0.0387735143,
0.026642723,
0.0291398279,
-0.0208147392,
-0.0167310834,
0.0226032585,
-0.022070596,
-0.0418633968,
0.0355569497,
-0.0217129737,
-0.025277989,
-0.0438056961,
-0.0492200963,
0.013568446,
0.0079369508,
0.0041885106,
-0.0498053208,
0.0165848359,
0.0234878939,
0.0044505252,
-0.0180982966,
-0.0331605151,
-0.0744583234,
0.025079025,
-0.0138604492,
-0.0094774822,
-6.162757988e-33,
-0.0115783336,
0.0305797737,
0.0225799903,
-0.0092435079,
-0.0276670549,
0.0123129571,
-0.0108419256,
0.0050426885,
-0.0228212792,
-0.0406268388,
-0.0066347704,
-0.0000700606,
0.0137786064,
0.0056646694,
-0.0158351362,
0.033514142,
0.0693815649,
-0.0191840827,
-0.0088299001,
0.0323431939,
0.0056243646,
0.0164142922,
0.0412149206,
0.0255001914,
-0.0182906408,
0.0245523937,
-0.0052249962,
-0.0112559237,
0.0142940097,
0.0384731069,
-0.0348066203,
0.0380032659,
0.0064968392,
0.0021006127,
-0.0213574339,
-0.0206839442,
-0.0375847556,
0.0265355669,
0.030702617,
0.0126264868,
0.0409266986,
-0.041656062,
0.0260719042,
0.0347621739,
-0.0668206215,
-0.03409357,
-0.0255071558,
-0.020386016,
-0.0659159347,
-0.0631738156,
-0.0086293537,
0.035881348,
0.0304123349,
0.0288928878,
0.0740140229,
-0.0152647831,
-0.0535628162,
0.0091959564,
-0.0717946813,
-0.0112429252,
0.0542665869,
0.1065320969,
0.0608738698,
0.0623856746,
0.0205010511,
0.0306002237,
0.0509997085,
-0.012227972,
-0.0152513385,
0.0519630685,
0.070219636,
0.0149809411,
0.0535147637,
0.0083020665,
0.1017568111,
-0.0203067418,
-0.0693591908,
-0.0241423529,
-0.0042894967,
0.0139897903,
0.0386002138,
0.0725339502,
-0.0090766316,
-0.0450351648,
-0.0242279936,
-0.0025961786,
-0.0537237749,
-0.0691742226,
0.0085350163,
-0.0091353338,
-0.0296909995,
-0.0029901338,
0.0515016951,
-0.0327658728,
-0.0228121951,
-0.0252552498,
0.0016610983,
0.0506866798,
-0.0163876489,
0.0251739286,
-0.0313245729,
-0.0338092558,
0.0079349652,
-0.0068987519,
0.0146070514,
-0.0154440412,
0.0057765897,
0.0602978393,
-0.0663918182,
-0.0250290632,
-0.0250269938,
-0.0123619447,
0.0152027719,
0.0626399964,
-0.0134419762,
-0.0050255256,
0.0176313818,
0.057490591,
-0.0248146411,
-0.0068247817,
-0.0071938685,
-0.0009864224,
0.0235281829,
0.0482673794,
-0.0399626382,
0.0092339609,
-0.0550829843,
0.07944379,
0.0584190004,
-0.0465045199,
-0.059911564,
0.0268796049,
2.828e-7,
0.0360597335,
0.0082471576,
0.0131777562,
-0.0192767698,
-0.0239815693,
-0.0064848401,
0.0158333499,
0.018442817,
0.0090105245,
-0.006185642,
0.0065929317,
0.0138998246,
0.0112312045,
-0.0029144716,
-0.0497195423,
0.0305096172,
-0.0495140515,
0.0062952354,
-0.0447105542,
-0.0302606821,
-0.0001651051,
0.1044040993,
-0.0203929897,
-0.0055104089,
0.0332759172,
-0.0154291708,
0.0324420854,
-0.0042684888,
0.0039044563,
0.0283325445,
0.0509048551,
0.0001259316,
-0.011764735,
-0.0341253653,
0.01584097,
0.0126822805,
-0.0456402302,
0.0761551708,
-0.0427998118,
-0.0092455884,
0.0169465858,
-0.0067637055,
-0.0188792814,
-0.0304560065,
0.0589951724,
-0.0173978321,
-0.0202950072,
-0.0791911259,
-0.0085221948,
-0.0267218929,
-0.0160851367,
-0.0234260168,
0.0213171858,
0.0274177585,
0.0068711895,
-0.0108170761,
0.0190336984,
-0.0658754334,
-0.0408426449,
0.0315704681,
-0.026597118,
-0.0574201085,
-0.0359474458,
-0.0211021993,
0.0109048598,
-0.0461019874,
0.0166065935,
2.927917196e-34,
0.0415813364,
-0.0386046842,
0.0361463949,
0.069832705,
0.0037683037,
-0.0295083206,
-0.00743618,
0.0236191638,
-0.0216650423,
-0.0598074943,
-0.0285552796
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.08290v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.08290v2 | Rediscovery of CNN's Versatility for Text-based Encoding of Raw Electronic Health Records | 2023-03-15T00:37:18 | 2023-05-10T09:11:10 | Eunbyeol Cho, Min Jae Lee, Kyunghoon Hur, Jiyoun Kim, Jinsung Yoon, Edward Choi | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Making the most use of abundant information in electronic health records
(EHR) is rapidly becoming an important topic in the medical domain. Recent work
presented a promising framework that embeds entire features in raw EHR data
regardless of its form and medical code standards. The framework, however, only
focuses on encoding EHR with minimal preprocessing and fails to consider how to
learn efficient EHR representation in terms of computation and memory usage. In
this paper, we search for a versatile encoder not only reducing the large data
into a manageable size but also well preserving the core information of
patients to perform diverse clinical tasks. We found that hierarchically
structured Convolutional Neural Network (CNN) often outperforms the
state-of-the-art model on diverse tasks such as reconstruction, prediction, and
generation, even with fewer parameters and less training time. Moreover, it
turns out that making use of the inherent hierarchy of EHR data can boost the
performance of any kind of backbone models and clinical tasks performed.
Through extensive experiments, we present concrete evidence to generalize our
research findings into real-world practice. We give a clear guideline on
building the encoder based on the research findings captured while exploring
numerous settings. | [
0.0065074353,
0.1182089522,
0.0114645641,
-0.0291710217,
0.0244862884,
0.0368632637,
-0.0062788595,
0.0587996915,
0.0073414296,
0.0047258898,
0.0223797485,
-0.049430903,
-0.0065054488,
0.0785451382,
0.0139404358,
-0.069696337,
0.0060701962,
0.0423152894,
0.0033995123,
-0.0066379211,
-0.0458406433,
-0.0206518695,
0.0298211258,
0.062633045,
-0.0103568044,
0.0178701058,
-0.037149068,
0.0742841512,
0.0176589862,
-0.0376040377,
0.0261344779,
0.0105139352,
0.0426149182,
0.0029162408,
0.0000022666,
0.0164303295,
-0.0269497,
0.00706997,
-0.0778406039,
-0.0228335056,
0.0168518573,
-0.0915573612,
-0.0178562421,
-0.0311348867,
0.0019986655,
-0.0406410769,
0.0032200471,
0.0708230734,
0.0356442295,
0.0429088511,
-0.0290151704,
0.0306931045,
0.0470429584,
-0.0310383551,
0.0080041001,
-0.0011238754,
0.0132914362,
-0.0203540027,
-0.0321687534,
0.0079439161,
-0.0174323339,
0.0430944003,
0.0416485667,
0.0691782311,
0.027412124,
0.0531125888,
-0.0161691252,
-0.0089697195,
-0.0081479046,
0.0587595031,
-0.0900366157,
0.0098004406,
0.0107663991,
-0.024055155,
-0.0228755847,
-0.0734137744,
-0.0224264506,
-0.009646941,
-0.0172764231,
0.0089093093,
-0.0667265132,
0.0096250661,
0.0184829272,
-0.011523759,
-0.0314116068,
-0.0368200652,
-0.0056503988,
0.0029406657,
0.0096189426,
-0.0196156017,
0.0209400561,
-0.0390586108,
0.019655522,
0.0205902383,
-0.0162520949,
-0.0151002109,
-0.0521539822,
-0.0208666865,
0.0523630418,
-0.028675817,
0.0231634006,
0.0088642323,
-0.0109095406,
0.0116796354,
-0.0190723874,
0.0150677841,
-0.0812928528,
0.0133301318,
-0.0103106564,
-0.0046749203,
-0.0445347428,
0.0016706646,
-0.0208083391,
0.0373649485,
0.020434849,
0.0174577162,
-0.0320131108,
-0.0093786558,
0.0121344766,
0.0503214598,
-0.0056050862,
0.0795291811,
-0.0442450717,
-0.0061731418,
0.0002499739,
0.0240579545,
0.0062920935,
0.0052328929,
0.0277904216,
-0.0348369665,
0.0339485519,
0.015714664,
0.0461739562,
-0.0028775658,
0.0332290381,
0.0222986285,
0.0091093453,
-0.0146704921,
-0.0178756863,
-0.0520278178,
-0.0066369353,
-0.0024306653,
0.0390171595,
-0.0349642895,
0.0486880988,
-0.0089090047,
-0.0000692356,
-0.080341205,
0.0089599984,
0.0042035859,
-0.0600564219,
0.0588779226,
-0.0411796235,
-0.0382938795,
0.0570168346,
0.0262433216,
0.0038876461,
-0.0218797866,
0.052070953,
0.0109415147,
-0.0273010004,
-0.032831382,
-0.0178347751,
0.003710371,
0.0478622541,
-0.0722808093,
-0.0211727582,
0.0172327925,
-0.0163372569,
0.0616282821,
-0.0162433404,
0.0588145144,
-0.005109,
-0.0352739729,
0.0277379826,
0.0565809943,
0.0065760035,
0.0245644562,
-0.0139118535,
-0.0087329447,
-0.0020591475,
-0.0465929434,
-0.0124755669,
0.0375668146,
0.0787747651,
-0.0244850479,
-0.0482632853,
-0.0100163454,
-0.0535589345,
-0.0284916535,
-0.0146695413,
-0.0638629571,
-0.0138480421,
-0.0057502808,
0.0274372641,
-0.0106383963,
-0.030643316,
0.0482235141,
0.0148021569,
-0.0433071777,
-0.0021200438,
-0.0498676486,
-0.0659393743,
0.0669933632,
0.0305524673,
0.012610903,
-0.0447015055,
-0.0344235003,
0.0070319576,
-0.0386793055,
-0.0180642717,
-0.0080949208,
0.0459789783,
-0.0723262504,
-0.0446082577,
0.0021796839,
-0.0166552737,
-0.0232885182,
-0.000726443,
0.0033689523,
0.0003363913,
-0.0321104862,
-0.0156013696,
0.0106755504,
-0.0596127957,
-0.0037651255,
0.0472860932,
0.0446885154,
0.0376009196,
0.0223965067,
-0.0072698849,
-0.003493272,
0.0595533103,
-0.0561036393,
-0.0460028537,
-0.0465168655,
-0.0482447259,
-0.0049052676,
-0.0287714843,
-0.0264685471,
0.0227181949,
-0.013537569,
-0.0227846056,
-0.025221806,
-0.0623089597,
-0.0284795929,
0.0335163102,
-0.0092602456,
-0.0326014161,
0.0710800663,
-0.0121602099,
-0.0312431417,
0.0316921286,
-0.040491242,
-0.038308613,
0.0180212222,
-0.0358850323,
0.0329458266,
-0.0230082851,
0.0084534111,
0.0327777863,
-0.0317893587,
0.0094802873,
-0.0020663484,
-0.0136236809,
-0.0139401136,
-0.0186818652,
-0.1051271036,
0.0057930048,
0.0069444515,
-0.0091261035,
0.012352352,
0.0159518328,
0.033185292,
-0.0525233448,
-0.0752577633,
0.0156915151,
-0.0083742412,
0.0002541929,
0.0263102241,
0.0085508935,
0.0215989705,
0.0172837302,
-0.0317323431,
-0.0062327352,
0.0406772941,
-0.0333736092,
-0.0408348441,
0.0175459608,
-0.0523193851,
-0.0031253104,
0.0161716398,
-0.0124136433,
-0.0183956977,
0.0012401978,
0.0055285036,
0.0107753631,
0.0784635022,
0.0020104814,
0.0469481982,
0.005234506,
0.0292438045,
-0.0250341315,
0.0216553286,
-0.0342156738,
0.0072296117,
0.0135601526,
-0.0315739177,
-0.0144309159,
0.0362224989,
0.0154541973,
0.0226902701,
-0.0349619277,
-0.0451449826,
-0.0054485011,
0.0119742015,
-0.0742023513,
0.0214166827,
-0.0316401683,
0.0285609178,
-0.0069088098,
-0.037184678,
0.0438579209,
0.0232004337,
0.0236770194,
0.0254475027,
-0.0299748424,
-0.0355695374,
0.0281359665,
0.0295967162,
0.0406496152,
0.0297925118,
-0.0088886842,
-0.0315136686,
0.0277773887,
-0.0161743574,
-0.0664171204,
0.03863509,
0.0237966496,
-0.0021369329,
-0.0185093209,
-0.0601209551,
-0.0642730072,
0.0006883398,
0.0228463151,
0.0271624979,
-0.0242539831,
0.0098372763,
-0.0536243431,
-0.0131996358,
-0.0287892018,
0.0840381235,
0.0274662115,
-0.0131277759,
-0.0118895564,
0.0576045029,
0.0006369097,
0.0042465287,
0.002187415,
-0.0258508213,
0.0204656161,
0.0878276899,
-0.0077697271,
0.0397237055,
-0.0019282565,
0.0459896438,
-0.02349394,
0.0110696228,
-0.0181715377,
0.0419130772,
0.0237846598,
-0.0757591426,
0.03499493,
0.0486097373,
0.0325237177,
-0.0717429891,
0.0250860695,
0.0360963456,
-0.0207098946,
-0.0222488437,
0.0002303079,
-0.025640022,
-0.0143315606,
0.0171937924,
0.0309275035,
-0.0014686771,
-0.0262174327,
0.0473585203,
0.0138135981,
0.0393244624,
0.0073275869,
0.0302621145,
-0.0408420563,
-0.0291768517,
-0.0126555255,
-0.0076249391,
-0.0075398632,
-0.0208027232,
-0.0088409772,
-0.034160275,
0.0120760873,
-0.0328038968,
-0.0558632053,
0.0119238971,
-0.0133795915,
0.0181521624,
0.0727997497,
0.038457416,
-0.0023936029,
-0.0349259041,
-0.0360924453,
0.031605158,
-0.0151111726,
-0.0030079021,
0.1075151414,
0.0021033983,
-0.0056106644,
-0.0371544771,
0.0705846548,
-0.043292772,
-0.0486671403,
-0.0127080204,
0.0361911952,
-0.0418782011,
-0.0055412417,
-0.0546834432,
-0.054986801,
0.0246244296,
0.034533415,
-0.0138135329,
-0.016489109,
-0.0244444627,
-0.0032788343,
0.0610556118,
-0.0085930387,
-0.0077363504,
0.0806145221,
-0.0067859739,
-0.0178401172,
-0.0252720714,
-0.0236335211,
0.0200616624,
-0.0051015778,
-0.0203131288,
-0.0620521344,
0.0533409007,
-0.0245265737,
-0.0925698802,
0.0118278554,
0.0151731027,
-0.011303978,
-0.0539310612,
-0.0351068415,
0.0367906615,
0.0270516668,
-0.0134821329,
0.0027138989,
-0.0318254642,
0.0344096646,
0.0155545259,
0.0383655168,
0.0030100031,
0.0026310012,
0.0314717069,
0.0129797896,
0.0408361144,
0.0302781314,
-0.0676068887,
-0.0177897774,
-0.0011377807,
-0.0539009757,
-0.0405357778,
0.0269634556,
-0.0139443846,
0.0245312098,
0.0044355034,
-0.0099321147,
0.0182178393,
-0.0512769148,
0.0347160995,
-0.0018687103,
0.023246672,
-0.0296306107,
-0.0278384648,
0.0067139193,
0.0625085235,
0.0024574294,
0.0319362655,
-0.0383065678,
-0.0074847271,
0.0109732077,
0.014344465,
-0.0071113743,
0.0815770179,
0.0285883974,
-0.0221108701,
-0.0451154076,
0.016141044,
-0.0800697729,
0.0093522687,
0.0419952907,
0.0077635399,
-0.0199038778,
0.0581032895,
0.01921653,
0.0266244449,
-0.0189627372,
0.0182546824,
-0.0074941991,
0.0544529483,
-0.0344874561,
0.0670985132,
-0.0299103577,
-0.0344197601,
-0.0299507026,
-0.0159863252,
0.0385606997,
0.0026421743,
0.0134794656,
-0.0388684683,
0.0038973545,
-0.023885794,
0.0132099232,
-0.0023794651,
0.0113109723,
0.0283892229,
0.0018097929,
-0.0181687027,
-0.0213865265,
0.0698537007,
0.0495309159,
0.0498251803,
-0.0167905223,
0.0066905697,
-0.038335789,
0.0326762199,
0.0585900024,
-0.0009774156,
-0.0367016979,
-0.0077809934,
-0.0341748707,
-0.0388082191,
0.0711141229,
-0.0361143388,
-0.0251592081,
-0.0061634928,
0.0581467487,
-0.0164384488,
-0.0042768344,
-0.0171115305,
0.0096254814,
0.0131004406,
-0.0195113998,
-0.0329424478,
0.0140425069,
-6.460314179e-33,
0.0176038556,
-0.0313226096,
0.0004143532,
-0.0384802744,
0.0269908234,
0.0663681924,
-0.0353479944,
-0.0419488735,
0.0180367734,
-0.0201651771,
-0.0309108552,
0.0002626258,
0.0133729288,
0.0762545988,
0.0068019996,
-0.0185467936,
0.0514613949,
-0.0273953732,
-0.0104670599,
0.0562900864,
0.0061254832,
0.0346453078,
0.0243603103,
-0.0593030192,
-0.0443978235,
0.0330564044,
0.0234715994,
-0.0157586336,
0.0255432446,
0.0356259681,
-0.0417403281,
0.011425389,
0.0355411284,
-0.0314090587,
-0.0015774729,
0.0178814344,
-0.123432003,
0.0083834464,
-0.0941331536,
-0.0092874411,
-0.0573214628,
-0.0669877306,
0.044482436,
-0.020816246,
0.0100905877,
-0.0572018139,
0.0126591511,
0.0054887109,
-0.0359755382,
-0.0673309416,
-0.0010504646,
0.0576112531,
-0.0218061935,
-0.0029179184,
0.0301020853,
0.0150146149,
-0.0076815216,
0.0112651847,
-0.0750048161,
-0.0285007693,
-0.0065672635,
0.0187013522,
-0.010480918,
-0.0553653687,
-0.009986422,
0.0644014254,
0.0426303037,
0.0238234028,
-0.0772576854,
0.0357466787,
-0.0137421275,
0.0377110839,
0.0370544158,
0.0000630536,
0.0571605004,
-0.0655001849,
-0.0908081308,
0.0440598242,
-0.0726465955,
0.0439897589,
-0.0059102993,
-0.0000974378,
-0.0120266424,
0.0038084937,
0.0003114471,
0.0108722346,
0.014612807,
-0.0295310803,
0.0397968702,
0.0222425554,
0.0030644219,
0.0367159285,
0.0233740546,
-0.0518910922,
0.015720617,
0.020250123,
0.0620132238,
0.030473819,
-0.0075543234,
0.0244333446,
0.0089010755,
-0.0119497748,
0.0658168718,
-0.016988581,
0.0281628165,
0.0166281946,
0.0530204885,
0.0284413695,
-0.0523585267,
-0.0227111634,
0.0218128283,
-0.0070262114,
0.0080910176,
0.0316796154,
0.0445969328,
0.0078499159,
0.0252689049,
0.0543802604,
-0.0424383767,
-0.0134331593,
-0.0375606902,
-0.0216048937,
0.0370538756,
0.0336249769,
-0.0045349314,
-0.0107127083,
-0.1118209288,
-0.0113340989,
0.0418578163,
-0.0392314084,
-0.0016111999,
0.0211111363,
2.991e-7,
0.0344282836,
0.0293694958,
0.0463412404,
-0.0326664299,
0.0260154549,
0.0117624132,
0.0168539304,
0.0272740182,
-0.047977142,
-0.0439148955,
0.0578314587,
0.0248405691,
0.060604658,
0.041296646,
-0.0568336546,
-0.0024958428,
-0.0663493499,
-0.0337558985,
-0.0027260766,
-0.0044935304,
0.0829572082,
0.0907521695,
-0.049056422,
-0.0452053696,
0.0830494612,
0.0501476824,
0.0443501547,
-0.0173695125,
0.032222528,
-0.0031607929,
-0.0349256136,
0.0138048856,
-0.0165287517,
0.0437491797,
-0.0266271066,
-0.0219077729,
-0.0043516601,
0.1181162372,
-0.0536809601,
-0.0008792574,
0.0026165512,
-0.0138391526,
0.0036689457,
-0.006027936,
0.0741217136,
-0.0428777635,
-0.0384891741,
0.0019875271,
-0.0142835286,
0.0410694815,
0.0531223156,
-0.0193772186,
-0.0121107232,
0.0300928354,
0.0298535917,
0.0100092292,
-0.005458022,
-0.0617224909,
0.0116103729,
0.0441931561,
-0.0340699144,
-0.0129620088,
-0.0063500009,
-0.0250310134,
0.0491450578,
-0.034271393,
-0.0013149349,
2.873206429e-34,
-0.0236172341,
-0.0135596702,
0.0047530099,
0.0219401587,
-0.0152515573,
-0.0341956243,
0.0618768036,
0.0032048679,
-0.0033429712,
-0.0579497963,
-0.036231149
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.13648v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.13648v1 | ChatGPT or Grammarly? Evaluating ChatGPT on Grammatical Error Correction Benchmark | 2023-03-15T00:35:50 | 2023-03-15T00:35:50 | Haoran Wu, Wenxuan Wang, Yuxuan Wan, Wenxiang Jiao, Michael Lyu | cs.CL | cs.CL | ChatGPT is a cutting-edge artificial intelligence language model developed by
OpenAI, which has attracted a lot of attention due to its surprisingly strong
ability in answering follow-up questions. In this report, we aim to evaluate
ChatGPT on the Grammatical Error Correction(GEC) task, and compare it with
commercial GEC product (e.g., Grammarly) and state-of-the-art models (e.g.,
GECToR). By testing on the CoNLL2014 benchmark dataset, we find that ChatGPT
performs not as well as those baselines in terms of the automatic evaluation
metrics (e.g., $F_{0.5}$ score), particularly on long sentences. We inspect the
outputs and find that ChatGPT goes beyond one-by-one corrections. Specifically,
it prefers to change the surface expression of certain phrases or sentence
structure while maintaining grammatical correctness. Human evaluation
quantitatively confirms this and suggests that ChatGPT produces less
under-correction or mis-correction issues but more over-corrections. These
results demonstrate that ChatGPT is severely under-estimated by the automatic
evaluation metrics and could be a promising tool for GEC. | [
0.0685968176,
0.0565761849,
0.0077837436,
0.0164485779,
-0.0554026291,
0.0194355417,
-0.0359284393,
-0.0341605283,
0.0103642065,
-0.0516874827,
-0.0161009394,
-0.0459060222,
0.0268010702,
0.0169287492,
0.0087080775,
-0.0312901661,
0.0720981061,
0.0030986315,
0.0117177684,
0.0167522337,
0.0016898711,
0.0045477357,
-0.033989884,
0.067962721,
-0.0446861982,
-0.0658985376,
0.0072715059,
0.0084067434,
-0.0000209495,
0.0126477052,
0.0769476742,
0.0388978124,
-0.0540860444,
0.0838705674,
0.0000018302,
-0.0523062795,
0.0191424508,
0.001017646,
0.0005086783,
0.0874595791,
0.0543325655,
-0.0116896192,
-0.0428172201,
0.02782779,
-0.0194005314,
0.0032745497,
0.0337590985,
0.047453668,
0.0706405416,
0.0960111022,
-0.0041945074,
-0.0076679154,
0.0521218367,
-0.0149617856,
-0.0244717486,
-0.0175092276,
0.0061556282,
-0.000964955,
-0.0487913489,
-0.028746089,
-0.0307828486,
0.0428997613,
0.0344410241,
-0.0522020422,
-0.0057811332,
0.0090072444,
-0.059178371,
-0.0037079439,
-0.0370191373,
0.0229666699,
-0.0055597699,
-0.0395213738,
-0.0411729813,
-0.0000211008,
0.0194833893,
-0.0305543561,
-0.0299408212,
0.0094839055,
0.0218037143,
0.0145231625,
0.0423459038,
-0.0828152224,
0.0036327476,
0.0170948263,
0.0358373895,
0.0581519864,
0.0299250763,
-0.054368984,
-0.0106147882,
0.033792451,
-0.0536570959,
-0.072396867,
0.0003404468,
0.0182495806,
-0.0754716247,
-0.0236847773,
-0.0439376719,
-0.0279163644,
0.007783826,
-0.0505036227,
0.019690467,
0.0505174212,
-0.0257681329,
0.010761383,
-0.0227204952,
0.0755744055,
0.0363601968,
0.0429883525,
-0.0082298554,
-0.0105580129,
-0.0463909991,
-0.0155014154,
-0.0610246696,
0.0122142816,
-0.0307405666,
-0.0167116504,
-0.0624589883,
0.0044468949,
-0.0263950564,
0.0233760793,
0.0433490276,
0.0098181078,
-0.049964916,
-0.0159608554,
-0.0184786748,
0.0400352404,
-0.0106234392,
0.0411117263,
0.0381062068,
-0.0565485246,
-0.0242750365,
0.0196789335,
0.0085109323,
0.0057734805,
-0.0126531059,
0.0182503182,
-0.020788135,
-0.0246622637,
-0.0168512575,
0.0096182916,
-0.0419109054,
-0.065394707,
-0.0397208184,
-0.049224373,
-0.0161083806,
-0.0051893252,
0.0000308613,
-0.0109372893,
-0.0027364145,
0.0071907919,
-0.0155130522,
0.0498372279,
-0.0023077326,
0.0131746484,
0.0205513872,
-0.0213504285,
-0.0038646294,
0.0279005188,
0.0362333506,
-0.036280442,
0.0409749821,
0.028004365,
0.025402423,
0.0113238385,
-0.0284432545,
-0.0238809492,
0.035306979,
-0.0117522422,
-0.0031052474,
0.0611466654,
0.041756101,
0.0730492622,
-0.008239802,
0.0240590051,
0.0476199649,
0.0090788146,
0.0159060042,
0.0329200886,
0.042470403,
-0.0116598643,
0.0174489971,
0.034023013,
-0.0489312559,
0.0068940115,
-0.0476284958,
0.0124530317,
0.0055040875,
0.0054058535,
-0.0252680704,
-0.0573462285,
0.0026602962,
-0.0005104006,
0.0017041694,
-0.0530279279,
0.0240931157,
0.0412710756,
-0.023043735,
0.0409844071,
0.0225410871,
-0.0749751255,
-0.0209499337,
-0.0747820735,
0.0026945607,
0.0158168431,
0.0637485161,
0.0204398893,
-0.0547194779,
-0.0134979812,
-0.019915333,
0.0682108998,
0.0803983435,
-0.0025540753,
-0.0062368452,
-0.0306330323,
0.0309538022,
-0.033792492,
0.0409998,
-0.0167704988,
0.0394508839,
0.0049797976,
0.0102081411,
-0.013993063,
-0.0326756723,
0.0351204425,
0.0275031254,
-0.0086721005,
-0.0069141481,
-0.0240574758,
0.0312707759,
-0.0209657606,
-0.0265283473,
0.010290443,
-0.0273134168,
-0.000988414,
-0.0553027801,
-0.0139743779,
-0.0290725939,
-0.0753046796,
0.0322440416,
-0.0196870882,
-0.0474759489,
0.0612713546,
-0.0556965321,
-0.0419868119,
-0.0006606101,
-0.0329159163,
0.0394555181,
-0.0604537427,
0.03339196,
0.0094341431,
-0.0024437595,
-0.0047293343,
0.0291770622,
0.0088623902,
0.0003822538,
-0.0204221606,
0.0191679858,
0.0044469056,
-0.0479432344,
-0.0296821725,
-0.0140298959,
-0.0049172966,
0.0480604321,
0.0092935339,
0.0472444668,
-0.0408228524,
-0.0402205326,
-0.1202663556,
0.0090803709,
-0.0414694883,
0.0157328453,
0.0470903143,
0.001108124,
-0.0182532463,
-0.0178163126,
-0.0020412607,
0.0412025899,
0.024042137,
-0.0040399632,
0.0477787517,
-0.0256222282,
-0.009179323,
-0.058501631,
0.0110108722,
-0.0346488878,
-0.0134130716,
0.011377045,
-0.0143547393,
-0.0597871207,
0.0439782888,
-0.0414480865,
0.0139694549,
0.0494214743,
-0.0952352211,
0.008895861,
0.0058674347,
0.0661200359,
0.0359358564,
0.0032423076,
0.008662655,
-0.025663916,
-0.016232077,
-0.0141487755,
0.0257560071,
-0.0090087382,
-0.0666701198,
-0.0010021292,
0.0226190798,
0.0183191728,
0.0821681842,
-0.0045718835,
-0.0264989361,
-0.0345241316,
0.002667638,
-0.0447492935,
0.0052653798,
-0.0281295124,
0.0154520022,
-0.0199392475,
-0.0132065164,
-0.0441610515,
-0.022029113,
0.0504547432,
0.0037865075,
-0.0107193319,
-0.0617009997,
0.0229512677,
-0.0205066931,
0.0199196637,
0.0036631445,
0.025357794,
-0.0363229029,
-0.047856383,
-0.0420367718,
0.0083120549,
0.0446783043,
-0.0031033305,
0.0173683558,
-0.0749725103,
0.0402186513,
0.0344345532,
-0.0554449335,
0.0028887354,
-0.0374270044,
-0.0154797323,
-0.0073711341,
0.0113286432,
-0.0109940395,
-0.0195257068,
-0.0210283641,
-0.0233995933,
0.0312982872,
-0.0383956581,
-0.009793018,
-0.0143557349,
0.021289451,
0.0325097442,
0.0461800657,
0.0269488618,
0.0114822537,
0.020654859,
0.0849087611,
0.0066408822,
0.0437133312,
-0.0381079987,
0.010518902,
0.0090959473,
-0.0284788087,
-0.0271036308,
0.0030076525,
0.0835979059,
-0.0501170605,
-0.0528450385,
0.0952055305,
0.055235792,
-0.0235303231,
-0.0047762101,
-0.0052024196,
0.0403647386,
-0.006749888,
0.0186302233,
-0.0641106963,
-0.0325231068,
0.0358137414,
0.0118232081,
-0.0146057587,
0.0097123822,
0.0151057811,
-0.1282853633,
0.0641427487,
0.0162354261,
-0.0394674614,
-0.0144857988,
-0.0052544256,
0.0095096296,
0.0000159665,
0.048349686,
0.0546375178,
-0.0069328318,
-0.0066985898,
0.0093334587,
-0.0678262115,
-0.0626542196,
0.0160101093,
-0.0575350486,
0.0659544319,
0.0708030611,
0.0404419601,
0.0298060011,
-0.0234188158,
0.0885990039,
-0.0043529859,
-0.0025822972,
0.0088171465,
0.0433705077,
0.0216010474,
-0.0189425126,
-0.0363039896,
0.039243646,
-0.0366850756,
0.0086026732,
-0.0106538357,
0.0462188795,
-0.012146634,
0.0179032944,
0.0154822422,
0.0063871387,
0.000301577,
0.0345154069,
0.035550233,
-0.0365375802,
-0.0800076798,
-0.0750975832,
0.0074681714,
-0.0344380029,
0.003527933,
0.0511282086,
0.0008317256,
-0.022002181,
-0.0580305196,
-0.0879800543,
0.0092553394,
-0.0353578404,
-0.0067759627,
-0.0611680411,
-0.0249312408,
0.0090377256,
0.0164162349,
0.0020874324,
-0.0093646068,
0.0190845821,
-0.0757514685,
0.0074429386,
-0.0130726444,
0.0460309461,
-0.0293027405,
0.001072921,
-0.0777651072,
-0.0396712013,
0.0354386121,
0.048673857,
0.0166658722,
0.0055840733,
-0.0545654111,
-0.0342533402,
-0.0250864532,
0.0419474058,
-0.0440004766,
0.0634285957,
0.0072190096,
-0.0256204624,
0.0008675753,
0.0406344868,
0.0003591446,
0.0078516947,
0.0036008726,
0.0961492807,
0.0188647527,
-0.0172466878,
0.0599787831,
0.0465498231,
0.0708679408,
0.021615373,
0.0196726546,
-0.0383482948,
0.0136398338,
-0.0213682372,
-0.0000656602,
-0.0314443745,
0.0014537415,
0.0422557816,
-0.016406415,
-0.0393545739,
0.0141294291,
-0.0507503711,
0.0100828093,
-0.0468236804,
-0.0414547883,
0.0258235782,
0.0150973136,
0.0133987535,
0.0003718563,
-0.0415071361,
-0.0123687955,
0.0368832201,
0.0270643812,
-0.0071091717,
0.0502675548,
0.0381058641,
0.0192056522,
0.0009956879,
0.0119800651,
-0.0592593588,
-0.0019911884,
-0.0333875455,
0.0583737381,
0.1026404053,
0.0313742384,
0.0765827596,
-0.0356919132,
-0.0380328894,
-0.0294864848,
0.0533381216,
0.0084972205,
-0.017842209,
0.0031627056,
-0.0290137567,
-0.0053980853,
-0.0140842497,
0.0461774878,
-0.0346872546,
0.0492956564,
0.0049853171,
-0.0167468265,
-0.0248852707,
-0.024742268,
-0.0329504162,
-0.0272206441,
0.005686793,
0.003933649,
-0.0279999096,
-0.075938195,
-0.0425446555,
0.0648540184,
0.0177739505,
-0.0271037817,
-0.0023253888,
0.0473111421,
-0.0171189234,
-0.0521895029,
-0.0617020316,
-0.024418069,
-0.0228106901,
-0.0082281483,
-0.0509521179,
-5.865330367e-33,
-0.0458164737,
0.0324511714,
0.0092504639,
0.0276131667,
-0.0311260521,
-0.0147680724,
-0.0353650488,
0.0297616292,
0.0211492833,
0.0660667941,
-0.0286090877,
0.0560076647,
-0.0011944398,
0.0346015245,
0.0448651351,
0.0052092974,
0.0621834993,
-0.0133597627,
-0.0293830521,
-0.0105647705,
0.0002409715,
0.0351195224,
0.0617905557,
-0.0306346398,
0.026521394,
0.011971388,
-0.0304644629,
0.0147843007,
-0.0253806952,
0.04143342,
0.0271073468,
0.0583954565,
0.0101257814,
0.0266097318,
-0.0028164424,
-0.0108165853,
-0.0692903772,
-0.0462966375,
-0.0099208038,
0.0409365259,
-0.0543735474,
-0.0366193578,
0.0348643772,
-0.0017437006,
-0.0315688923,
-0.0235343985,
0.0021435344,
-0.0229583997,
0.0191914681,
0.0377233438,
-0.0543586537,
-0.004867191,
0.0044420944,
-0.0254292879,
-0.0647628605,
0.0092357127,
-0.0228682943,
-0.0319545716,
-0.0506719351,
-0.0353560112,
0.0134308096,
0.036896348,
0.0181879606,
-0.0415503122,
-0.0320557319,
0.0237697177,
0.006835293,
-0.0079157623,
-0.0167205725,
0.0101686064,
0.0145061789,
0.0115941539,
0.0376301743,
0.0310341269,
0.0339158922,
-0.0418620482,
-0.0386279114,
0.0197846871,
-0.0057484154,
0.0583636798,
-0.0175499413,
-0.0032947217,
-0.024663955,
-0.0300373696,
-0.0284974109,
0.0282452423,
-0.0290192999,
-0.022906635,
0.0585864633,
0.0012691321,
0.023085868,
-0.0356017463,
-0.0072446209,
-0.0201746617,
0.0162736326,
-0.0367745906,
-0.0209197775,
0.0555389747,
-0.0092288619,
0.0469133817,
-0.0190627333,
0.0016918709,
-0.0028467614,
0.0496829078,
0.0235084724,
0.0047695348,
0.0350046828,
0.0250258017,
-0.0603370927,
0.0343338549,
-0.0334991813,
0.0283308607,
-0.0209135935,
-0.0172921494,
0.0173151586,
0.0079147797,
-0.002004327,
0.0264793988,
-0.0172917992,
0.0395327583,
-0.0202940758,
-0.0522583947,
0.0028759809,
-0.0000097834,
-0.0238949936,
0.008114229,
-0.0232469626,
-0.0007466811,
0.0012291935,
-0.0559952594,
0.0000613775,
0.0170932338,
2.485e-7,
0.0521314107,
0.0704446957,
0.026423404,
0.0357791707,
0.0140895033,
0.0047426848,
-0.0132838981,
0.0067116655,
0.023498321,
0.061378967,
0.0187714957,
0.0129887536,
0.0667735562,
0.0170745663,
-0.0397038646,
-0.0052873814,
-0.0908487514,
0.0142574338,
-0.0217708033,
-0.0157183334,
0.0532771125,
0.0581446178,
0.0227878205,
-0.0064831269,
0.0015818918,
-0.0626691431,
0.0714833811,
0.0077598114,
-0.0588025488,
0.0331746787,
0.064466849,
0.0561426431,
0.0215202384,
0.0158905387,
-0.0060297241,
-0.0174598433,
0.0100841792,
0.0364618897,
-0.0248147082,
0.0194845665,
-0.003872341,
0.0074144946,
0.0025546446,
-0.0625438988,
0.0478540994,
-0.069822751,
0.0058308858,
-0.0189234857,
-0.0273877904,
0.0050981948,
0.0175908301,
-0.0132354042,
-0.0423119068,
0.0015678937,
0.0468727462,
0.0333130583,
-0.0308640469,
-0.0361009501,
-0.0121802948,
0.0381976664,
0.029930776,
-0.0236662459,
0.0006445518,
0.0292956289,
0.0424228273,
-0.0535312295,
-0.0064469869,
1.980532346e-34,
0.0623572059,
-0.0175948478,
0.0443650857,
-0.0059705754,
0.0616417117,
0.0143527025,
0.0492600314,
-0.0030138192,
-0.0289895572,
-0.0453070328,
-0.0356718041
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.08288v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.08288v1 | Attention-likelihood relationship in transformers | 2023-03-15T00:23:49 | 2023-03-15T00:23:49 | Valeria Ruscio, Valentino Maiorca, Fabrizio Silvestri | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | We analyze how large language models (LLMs) represent out-of-context words,
investigating their reliance on the given context to capture their semantics.
Our likelihood-guided text perturbations reveal a correlation between token
likelihood and attention values in transformer-based language models. Extensive
experiments reveal that unexpected tokens cause the model to attend less to the
information coming from themselves to compute their representations,
particularly at higher layers. These findings have valuable implications for
assessing the robustness of LLMs in real-world scenarios. Fully reproducible
codebase at https://github.com/Flegyas/AttentionLikelihood. | [
0.0262732562,
0.0381627493,
-0.0050977613,
0.0527499467,
-0.0201717969,
-0.0014485737,
-0.0035853484,
-0.0045059733,
-0.0404079631,
-0.0652731508,
-0.0224441011,
-0.0496760346,
0.0092353281,
0.0106255561,
0.0478396676,
-0.025566211,
0.0444615297,
-0.0459112711,
-0.0273827612,
0.0162305962,
-0.0035974337,
0.0117901545,
0.0307980999,
0.0878507718,
-0.0061814748,
-0.010941539,
0.0145779066,
0.0305714235,
0.0099331755,
0.0098095154,
-0.0004068986,
0.0180132091,
-0.0115387524,
0.0580037609,
0.0000019071,
-0.0231748447,
-0.0169835482,
0.0036267473,
0.0131964236,
0.0312270112,
0.058396738,
-0.040876396,
-0.0291407071,
0.020531537,
-0.005643086,
0.0048870607,
0.0826511979,
0.0400804617,
0.0290446077,
0.0522176698,
-0.0127300648,
-0.0058473172,
0.0459320284,
-0.0181478318,
0.0131112719,
-0.0347434692,
0.0227503814,
-0.051287014,
-0.0148807215,
0.012084214,
-0.0233387463,
0.034186013,
0.013928392,
0.0053550252,
0.0058499309,
0.0600744449,
-0.0285900142,
-0.0113513116,
-0.008403196,
0.0452147275,
-0.0603923947,
-0.0386903882,
-0.0109598218,
-0.0077517731,
-0.0158990715,
0.0131490519,
-0.0456836559,
0.0514030941,
0.0105651347,
0.0254002251,
0.0293272566,
0.0066275699,
0.0197310485,
-0.0231405068,
-0.091881305,
0.0535243638,
0.0271109194,
-0.0370576382,
-0.0532889962,
-0.0261930507,
-0.0300900005,
-0.0562327988,
0.0176561698,
0.0299349297,
0.0031675454,
0.0254352596,
-0.0521102138,
-0.0343875997,
0.0087106368,
-0.0546959862,
0.0219940841,
0.0478802286,
-0.0302902795,
0.0346908271,
-0.0163231697,
0.057196416,
-0.0412558205,
0.0439323112,
-0.0258084107,
-0.0243450869,
0.009143726,
-0.0146737639,
-0.0464983471,
0.0140507845,
-0.0475875027,
-0.0479818657,
0.0127962837,
0.0406303629,
0.0355535522,
-0.0470820032,
0.0054745129,
0.0161942244,
-0.0447859764,
0.0078363568,
0.0129100969,
0.0440515429,
0.0215861201,
-0.0224299021,
0.003311292,
-0.059338592,
-0.0393026099,
0.0175945871,
0.0006153916,
-0.0521684177,
-0.0251905043,
0.0705996156,
0.0219443683,
-0.0625963807,
0.0054485826,
0.0170784164,
-0.0351174325,
-0.0378776975,
-0.0157564245,
-0.0433256216,
-0.0176826995,
0.0386308916,
0.0000770643,
-0.0495754108,
0.0352830291,
0.0452010818,
-0.0498456061,
0.0486796983,
0.0090927975,
0.0071358737,
-0.014010244,
-0.0016237054,
0.0066618212,
0.0454538353,
0.0228907224,
0.0141585022,
0.0094965901,
-0.0204720106,
0.035282772,
0.0452432893,
-0.0044346582,
0.009827164,
-0.0373669975,
-0.0064529586,
0.0020852906,
0.0002507332,
0.0663080588,
0.0880740136,
-0.009834527,
-0.0244816635,
0.0742580742,
0.0696684346,
0.010202188,
0.0333936103,
0.0028117388,
0.0359980129,
-0.0243926812,
0.0201386884,
-0.0795826465,
0.0501930937,
-0.0008538481,
0.0071446779,
0.0373458117,
0.0237344652,
-0.0223356299,
-0.0116180275,
-0.0320173688,
0.0041268677,
-0.0013136527,
-0.008934103,
0.0501656123,
0.0205123089,
-0.0527288616,
0.1189458817,
0.0263001285,
-0.0480207168,
-0.0242228545,
-0.0573656149,
-0.0123027591,
0.0384260006,
0.049717024,
-0.0065237065,
-0.0146544781,
-0.0133814951,
-0.0085250055,
0.0482236035,
-0.0064531993,
0.0541976057,
0.0064060446,
-0.0196866728,
0.0097245416,
-0.0136498893,
0.0241991505,
-0.0150325932,
-0.004233011,
-0.0050237332,
0.0290698279,
-0.0281484053,
-0.018621413,
0.0554552749,
-0.0065694004,
-0.0025733036,
-0.0039457274,
-0.0119959628,
0.0059648901,
-0.0166432951,
-0.0192661025,
0.0357379057,
0.0351607017,
-0.0386181511,
0.0081987223,
0.0459732749,
-0.051123511,
0.0030097817,
0.0260661729,
-0.0236595459,
0.0235325713,
0.0337706506,
0.0156096732,
-0.0277065653,
0.0433607176,
-0.0762291327,
0.1012146622,
-0.0146620665,
0.0367705561,
-0.0210680868,
0.0806222185,
-0.0260415375,
0.0343964733,
-0.0174782034,
0.026910983,
0.0288651753,
0.0486848541,
-0.0091886427,
0.003344395,
-0.0213673227,
0.0024114149,
-0.0335433856,
0.0011214867,
-0.0000011473,
-0.0212130584,
-0.0068700798,
-0.0272602178,
-0.0519211777,
-0.0148707256,
-0.0376652218,
0.0070585697,
0.0354727283,
0.0485782288,
-0.0040148958,
0.0000601219,
0.0174787771,
-0.0004953836,
-0.0379243903,
0.0205056574,
0.0081619546,
-0.0396158062,
-0.0199197531,
-0.0539183766,
-0.0217429232,
-0.0085851159,
0.0708504543,
0.0121810194,
-0.0161822382,
-0.0860762522,
0.0248031951,
0.0042608073,
0.0216376428,
-0.0140292821,
-0.0546304546,
0.0033161542,
-0.01748183,
0.0914450884,
0.0495793819,
0.0217427537,
0.0249170195,
0.0731856078,
-0.0098232087,
-0.0516046248,
0.0073312502,
-0.0234893057,
-0.0145366834,
-0.0393662602,
-0.0231056698,
0.0221484322,
0.0968788266,
-0.0060895076,
-0.0141004939,
-0.0468055829,
-0.0051845894,
-0.0278995521,
-0.0184045993,
0.0391026698,
0.0210269447,
-0.0701088235,
0.0414198041,
-0.0025614386,
-0.0497122705,
0.065396145,
-0.0373282209,
-0.0283495933,
-0.0435428135,
0.0150177721,
-0.0369384587,
0.0419843532,
0.0088339495,
0.0145780472,
0.0139736971,
-0.0615139045,
-0.026038114,
0.0418389477,
-0.0384440683,
-0.0201598555,
0.0939762667,
0.0004641905,
0.0123817716,
-0.010661548,
-0.0085888784,
-0.0526848771,
-0.0550006069,
-0.0416087285,
0.0065423907,
0.0337468423,
-0.0333678275,
-0.0829923451,
0.040393509,
0.0350819416,
0.048772011,
-0.0143780904,
-0.0185667109,
-0.0210106876,
0.0140567729,
0.0543445423,
-0.0001047108,
0.0498880036,
-0.0217516534,
0.0140425833,
0.0559645444,
0.017888546,
0.0195524376,
-0.0147646191,
-0.0467268676,
0.0507331006,
-0.0146299722,
0.0047244993,
0.0230531115,
0.064206332,
-0.0653567389,
-0.05828299,
0.112707302,
0.0260842647,
-0.0781119987,
0.0302620623,
-0.051010374,
0.0265824441,
0.0359008946,
0.016773548,
-0.0553532057,
-0.0412634574,
0.010473568,
0.0181420501,
0.0205930006,
-0.0141157331,
-0.0050399019,
-0.0830140486,
0.0237164591,
-0.0115255369,
-0.0396738201,
-0.0542495735,
-0.0430316851,
0.036759194,
0.0022307502,
0.0444463007,
0.0242895745,
-0.0200073235,
-0.025634937,
0.0021903021,
0.0205438752,
-0.0096382108,
0.0253615286,
-0.0347740985,
0.0483401865,
0.0626412556,
0.0088177733,
-0.0032570045,
-0.0602742173,
0.0242919605,
-0.0213384908,
-0.0015497288,
0.0062558181,
0.0013405944,
-0.0066586686,
-0.0126968808,
-0.0001160199,
-0.0112810237,
-0.0496698953,
-0.0100895083,
-0.025399968,
0.0671999827,
-0.0054388368,
-0.0471134111,
-0.0368243195,
-0.0073178089,
-0.0018870794,
0.0776401237,
0.0598725267,
-0.0518557876,
-0.0562183484,
-0.0513908528,
0.0094711538,
-0.0106497221,
-0.036765188,
0.0027176086,
0.052007556,
-0.0704845339,
-0.0346028209,
-0.0085272212,
0.0003864043,
0.0012487818,
0.0058804997,
-0.0154112829,
0.0292976219,
-0.0075845807,
-0.025398057,
0.0234358497,
-0.0197119713,
0.0320821144,
-0.063930355,
0.0117129236,
0.0411521196,
-0.0205795839,
-0.0199011695,
0.013390352,
-0.1015486792,
-0.0483824238,
0.0403118171,
0.0181406885,
0.0182034597,
0.0228187274,
-0.0489174351,
-0.0665054172,
0.016595928,
0.0283653308,
-0.0578609854,
0.037111111,
0.0256915689,
0.0013953593,
0.0181046389,
0.0485550277,
-0.0419321805,
0.0259279851,
0.0304930266,
0.0516594462,
0.016062649,
-0.0411747359,
0.0146357771,
-0.0272097569,
0.0589776598,
-0.0167847294,
-0.0097964145,
0.0074911057,
0.0027842913,
-0.0032652081,
0.0135381818,
-0.0408747904,
0.0029536202,
0.0080674971,
-0.01708024,
0.0140576642,
0.0167395845,
-0.0291877706,
0.0074254479,
-0.0083745793,
0.0331667438,
-0.0283192731,
0.0073887347,
0.053055428,
-0.0006762545,
-0.0129242595,
-0.0221316516,
0.0006290844,
0.0235834699,
-0.0113057001,
0.0292848628,
-0.0016454005,
-0.0247616246,
-0.0326611176,
0.0173376072,
-0.0733509138,
-0.0078689959,
-0.0104126986,
0.0037293041,
0.025545029,
-0.0087997811,
0.0594353154,
-0.0118301287,
0.0001099849,
-0.0273473281,
0.0151155237,
-0.0063143135,
-0.010955926,
0.0236387197,
0.0054035163,
-0.0140376957,
0.0094212713,
0.0745136067,
0.0149975661,
-0.0093614738,
0.0258610528,
0.0016724824,
-0.0141757634,
0.0033955115,
-0.0244577639,
0.0479854606,
-0.0246763583,
0.0140179489,
-0.0581974387,
-0.072924681,
0.0254888143,
-0.0321199819,
-0.0002388013,
-0.0502913222,
0.0093990378,
0.0446268022,
0.0057546808,
-0.0135867316,
-0.0261552706,
0.0360526294,
0.0251184646,
-0.0178684704,
-0.0296218339,
-6.527168216e-33,
-0.0019856377,
-0.033326216,
-0.0162552185,
-0.0083080456,
-0.0186855346,
0.0104784174,
-0.0799419135,
-0.000678081,
-0.0055684079,
-0.0103677465,
-0.0344357975,
0.0405677594,
0.0074747987,
0.0511025302,
-0.0050724354,
-0.0236689802,
0.0323083289,
-0.0022939444,
-0.0213646274,
0.0391657464,
0.0174403079,
0.035742905,
0.0729592592,
-0.0280482415,
0.0132949669,
-0.0090608997,
0.0161120463,
-0.0146999611,
0.0085366797,
0.068897076,
-0.0442423858,
0.0550893098,
0.0092113623,
-0.0556042232,
-0.0413201042,
0.0232554246,
-0.0469069146,
0.0072030686,
0.0256217271,
0.0029225498,
-0.021572616,
-0.0468086191,
0.0894574225,
0.0112019572,
-0.0006433048,
-0.0403668433,
0.0348713882,
0.0066994582,
-0.0531923138,
-0.0034909043,
-0.0897853225,
0.0217937622,
0.0008465559,
-0.0213259924,
0.0217652023,
0.0302844848,
0.0013232992,
0.0561733693,
-0.0485841967,
-0.0016019472,
-0.0219171476,
0.0462729782,
0.0504092686,
0.0555551611,
0.0085046981,
0.0420297645,
0.0180989336,
-0.0117736217,
-0.0545833297,
-0.0512210019,
0.0544495545,
0.0236551128,
0.0293790381,
-0.0015042485,
0.0322517678,
-0.0212533846,
-0.0265319832,
-0.0323022716,
-0.0251007956,
0.0394446962,
0.0946498066,
0.0180451386,
-0.0278921146,
-0.0180615187,
-0.0150555996,
-0.0203289874,
-0.0459841155,
0.009512363,
0.0099163074,
0.0121893743,
-0.0432871804,
-0.0110548027,
0.0503429472,
-0.0598971881,
-0.0054317727,
0.0183075275,
-0.0090714302,
0.0222306494,
-0.0121984016,
0.0382580683,
-0.0410343222,
0.0119556412,
0.0033145722,
0.0054291603,
-0.0093541862,
0.0015793673,
0.0170127489,
0.0227748118,
-0.0677169859,
-0.0254117027,
-0.0513585396,
0.0084388796,
-0.0082541956,
0.04093308,
0.0391794741,
0.0077927527,
-0.0037607488,
0.0201138742,
-0.0004397302,
-0.0106550157,
-0.0270350277,
0.0385435931,
0.0108582275,
0.0224554483,
-0.0701929703,
-0.0207315721,
-0.0678826421,
0.0472036339,
0.043655958,
-0.0653140545,
-0.0455002263,
0.0381090194,
2.655e-7,
0.0649887994,
0.0567762889,
0.0015135065,
-0.009673737,
0.0376304016,
0.0213703625,
0.0217971019,
0.048275765,
0.0189404711,
0.010251563,
-0.0257552154,
0.0136905527,
0.027127089,
-0.0028609438,
-0.1036636457,
0.0061445194,
-0.0780234486,
0.0172640327,
-0.0295549147,
-0.0029623397,
0.0101260878,
0.1510560215,
-0.0025470522,
0.0015465645,
-0.00123429,
-0.0122192064,
0.0382534601,
-0.0327723511,
0.0389132425,
0.0174943209,
0.0073785395,
0.0264786892,
-0.0030311411,
-0.0185626466,
0.0038523502,
0.0162763689,
0.015398372,
0.0518186688,
-0.0171660744,
-0.0534600727,
-0.0050446414,
-0.0253251065,
0.0065458063,
-0.0986391529,
0.0554008968,
-0.0651875213,
-0.0308742467,
-0.0497546904,
0.0032057746,
0.0102816708,
-0.0261876751,
0.0032687117,
-0.0364036746,
0.0078935288,
0.0307522845,
-0.0068171998,
-0.0220676847,
-0.1041303575,
-0.0593401641,
-0.0400981382,
-0.048152715,
-0.0244873781,
-0.0654232204,
-0.0329160206,
0.0563456193,
-0.021175554,
0.0003366496,
2.689216079e-34,
0.0428116769,
0.0037684657,
-0.0136512611,
0.0326353125,
0.0103094699,
-0.0297873877,
0.0544629991,
0.0209750067,
-0.0026124648,
-0.0929743871,
-0.0307482313
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.08268v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.08268v3 | Chat with the Environment: Interactive Multimodal Perception Using Large Language Models | 2023-03-14T23:01:27 | 2023-10-11T16:17:20 | Xufeng Zhao, Mengdi Li, Cornelius Weber, Muhammad Burhan Hafez, Stefan Wermter | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | Programming robot behavior in a complex world faces challenges on multiple
levels, from dextrous low-level skills to high-level planning and reasoning.
Recent pre-trained Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown remarkable reasoning
ability in few-shot robotic planning. However, it remains challenging to ground
LLMs in multimodal sensory input and continuous action output, while enabling a
robot to interact with its environment and acquire novel information as its
policies unfold. We develop a robot interaction scenario with a partially
observable state, which necessitates a robot to decide on a range of epistemic
actions in order to sample sensory information among multiple modalities,
before being able to execute the task correctly. Matcha (Multimodal environment
chatting) agent, an interactive perception framework, is therefore proposed
with an LLM as its backbone, whose ability is exploited to instruct epistemic
actions and to reason over the resulting multimodal sensations (vision, sound,
haptics, proprioception), as well as to plan an entire task execution based on
the interactively acquired information. Our study demonstrates that LLMs can
provide high-level planning and reasoning skills and control interactive robot
behavior in a multimodal environment, while multimodal modules with the context
of the environmental state help ground the LLMs and extend their processing
ability. The project website can be found at https://matcha-agent.github.io. | [
0.0171888247,
0.0238311477,
-0.0081588505,
0.0201340076,
-0.054090552,
-0.002760713,
0.0143103153,
-0.0373665653,
0.0368932523,
-0.0542570688,
-0.043762099,
0.0132447295,
-0.0311455987,
0.067848593,
0.02207008,
-0.0470122397,
0.0408957265,
-0.0615559258,
-0.0040986305,
-0.007454385,
0.0055009662,
-0.0242352895,
-0.0587655194,
0.0579892732,
-0.020921981,
-0.0152695207,
-0.0667021498,
-0.0306585375,
-0.0225535575,
-0.044311326,
-0.0357570089,
0.0070865075,
0.0774059147,
-0.0022191738,
0.0000020859,
-0.06332127,
-0.0069812383,
-0.0312770568,
0.0242310371,
-0.0597056113,
0.0046600867,
0.0064653661,
-0.0028974675,
0.0038504149,
-0.0586476028,
-0.0248476062,
0.0669450611,
0.0510089658,
0.0646804124,
0.0557883009,
0.0010955945,
-0.027879905,
0.0018873686,
0.0265674274,
0.0376728028,
-0.0498536713,
0.0167814661,
0.0159645304,
0.0691760331,
0.011287583,
-0.0464111567,
-0.0507752486,
0.0176903512,
-0.0414335914,
-0.033654958,
0.0522365086,
0.0363009907,
-0.052742023,
-0.0181037728,
0.050574027,
0.0043735416,
-0.0022374219,
0.0206519887,
0.0259180944,
-0.016088441,
-0.0296939444,
-0.0284888875,
0.0333637148,
-0.0172025431,
0.0059731202,
-0.0353299417,
-0.0047340761,
-0.0078806011,
0.0181654524,
-0.0414417498,
0.1201286316,
-0.0228188895,
-0.0073981695,
0.0160184912,
-0.0322861895,
-0.0067277262,
-0.0759916902,
-0.0167961083,
0.0871493071,
-0.070730038,
0.0068746582,
-0.047236301,
0.015518479,
-0.0309645385,
-0.0131299281,
-0.0152150299,
0.0528817773,
-0.0191813782,
0.0602536425,
0.0035382838,
0.0374543443,
-0.0218829401,
0.037108928,
-0.0197943095,
-0.0053601349,
-0.0581600517,
0.014590838,
-0.0266965646,
0.0233834088,
-0.0402828939,
-0.0645649284,
-0.0149745159,
0.0660492778,
-0.0388803184,
0.0455566458,
-0.0638544261,
0.0106074391,
0.0214031916,
-0.008279047,
-0.0531915203,
-0.0133850817,
-0.0310948417,
0.0369958431,
-0.0012476927,
-0.0251101181,
-0.0020052579,
0.0369272567,
0.0147156352,
-0.0143140508,
-0.0183495395,
0.1338929981,
-0.0113791898,
-0.0159513429,
0.0217755903,
-0.0274131782,
0.0004758711,
-0.0682677254,
0.0167275127,
-0.0349363685,
0.004992622,
-0.0111011211,
0.0114549808,
-0.0426343828,
0.0021569787,
-0.0036447023,
0.0301240105,
0.104277499,
0.0099347886,
0.0253822245,
-0.0041582636,
0.0266597494,
-0.0189899299,
0.0369724184,
0.0457608178,
0.0458613634,
-0.0139153609,
0.0285249688,
0.0110671343,
0.0211809911,
-0.055045791,
-0.0345769003,
0.010779988,
-0.0296281762,
0.0089183534,
0.0465001687,
-0.0130749363,
0.0218248684,
-0.0300802756,
0.0119401542,
0.0450750329,
0.0161594078,
-0.0195994135,
-0.0248585343,
0.0296419282,
0.0208031237,
-0.0010715286,
-0.0228041224,
-0.0315437801,
0.0699434951,
-0.0096243257,
-0.0224791244,
-0.0063975216,
0.010341092,
-0.0130882859,
-0.0315104909,
0.011292465,
-0.015206391,
0.0333089828,
0.0062434333,
0.0632378161,
0.0026760586,
-0.0404562093,
-0.0364597626,
0.0165785812,
-0.0060895914,
-0.0326835699,
-0.0475405343,
0.0745619759,
0.0674710721,
0.0038290313,
-0.053958565,
-0.043696031,
0.0183980614,
0.0058371355,
0.0354463197,
-0.005476159,
-0.0224856399,
0.0510625169,
-0.0071868645,
-0.0384437256,
-0.0408699363,
0.0173073262,
0.0292989835,
-0.0219109859,
0.0002333786,
-0.0346904695,
0.0326199606,
0.0520003513,
0.0435182229,
0.0268424563,
0.003057441,
-0.0401532724,
0.0050147506,
0.0644043088,
-0.0137248188,
-0.0224364698,
0.0028338863,
0.025024388,
-0.0165603347,
0.0128587205,
0.0614625402,
-0.0087318458,
-0.0117517021,
0.0194028672,
-0.0181744732,
-0.0080930851,
0.0104970606,
-0.0204794426,
-0.0230906121,
0.0125385644,
0.0008556264,
0.0287811011,
-0.0047315597,
0.0048434846,
0.0093633095,
-0.0181950089,
-0.0160368718,
0.0105474144,
0.0009860698,
-0.031211026,
-0.0030999107,
0.0521170199,
0.0119635072,
-0.0148072345,
-0.0164270885,
0.0180206392,
0.0083847996,
0.0013310701,
0.0101801837,
0.0419190116,
-0.0239957105,
-0.0329282805,
-0.0956177264,
-0.0278537478,
-0.0007689902,
-0.0471778773,
-0.0196422804,
-0.0186600555,
0.0112759471,
-0.0167043265,
0.0359230936,
0.0653523132,
0.0124518974,
0.0288856756,
0.0142036062,
0.0422841422,
-0.0346496105,
-0.0392087996,
0.0276065134,
-0.0141407074,
0.0142159108,
0.0097115915,
-0.0205950215,
-0.0386877358,
0.03138908,
-0.0506977439,
0.0670710728,
-0.0396407582,
-0.0427947827,
0.0586454608,
-0.0496208034,
0.0049476041,
0.0813349932,
-0.0064896964,
0.0433836728,
0.102019459,
-0.0349111073,
-0.0365109667,
0.0341416448,
-0.0160638448,
0.0038525197,
-0.0478346758,
0.042997051,
0.0095306234,
0.0449168496,
-0.0051319571,
0.0059964517,
-0.0294560399,
0.0224720202,
-0.0092870751,
-0.060454011,
-0.0448566899,
0.0035832077,
-0.0361955464,
0.0532459766,
-0.0371952839,
-0.0286282506,
0.0655178279,
-0.0298597291,
0.0059462688,
0.0143791009,
-0.0194861963,
0.0107594524,
0.0775010437,
0.0262762681,
0.0178115591,
0.0079913083,
-0.0032315259,
-0.0291446857,
-0.0128187211,
-0.0005604859,
0.0101939924,
-0.0050202007,
-0.0930737928,
0.0237133652,
0.0237548761,
-0.0457589515,
-0.0300260317,
0.0101921707,
-0.0406568907,
0.0032209877,
-0.0331281051,
-0.0229303036,
-0.022340754,
0.0140934372,
0.0415530093,
0.0454233922,
0.0082599707,
-0.0181741789,
-0.0568791777,
-0.0339168869,
0.0392508768,
0.0707874224,
-0.0473867282,
-0.0356094614,
0.017955061,
0.0334047005,
0.0176832117,
-0.0290294401,
-0.0683982745,
0.0349444002,
0.0049129236,
0.0338982977,
0.0165875684,
0.0426264778,
0.0542285293,
-0.036078006,
-0.0222648289,
0.0741527006,
0.0053939512,
-0.0233354922,
0.0088036498,
-0.0100732362,
0.0080678342,
0.0205717348,
0.0329657495,
-0.0309336428,
-0.056995783,
-0.0065968013,
-0.0504623801,
0.0045933914,
-0.0410323031,
0.0001437109,
-0.0970991328,
0.0232563168,
-0.0137503538,
-0.0585324652,
-0.0470357798,
-0.0011809507,
0.0323641114,
0.0111570396,
-0.0301455949,
0.020723395,
0.0331273228,
-0.0169965159,
0.0033431095,
0.0227011424,
-0.016612459,
0.0440307185,
-0.0208355002,
0.0280688405,
0.0634980947,
0.04033795,
-0.0160287526,
0.0045799995,
0.0058969175,
0.0546314456,
0.0184707567,
-0.0418605879,
-0.0251566041,
-0.0232229717,
-0.0073054,
-0.004599106,
0.0184954964,
0.0020245274,
-0.0516557358,
-0.0114768418,
0.0629606619,
-0.0664896145,
0.0033499752,
-0.0229709018,
0.0245346781,
0.0232633557,
0.0322339237,
-0.0300256535,
-0.046852842,
-0.0538342334,
-0.0125256516,
-0.0816678032,
0.0123727964,
-0.0208231546,
-0.0142691936,
-0.0054548602,
-0.0132900691,
-0.0551193804,
-0.0156518687,
0.0443532281,
0.0585592426,
0.0042846841,
-0.0162958484,
0.0198164843,
0.0579877198,
-0.0009083378,
0.0139614027,
-0.0114726936,
0.0146082854,
0.0015620205,
0.0080696549,
0.0484670922,
-0.0643825382,
-0.0227654725,
0.0106851114,
-0.0187439434,
-0.0440383293,
0.0059868391,
0.065761894,
0.0218457282,
0.0125671681,
-0.0101837888,
-0.0282486696,
-0.0131399855,
-0.0087504722,
-0.0248938538,
0.054047212,
0.0068328902,
0.0338869244,
0.0297287162,
0.0334458388,
-0.0533638634,
0.012503366,
-0.0053282781,
0.0136741819,
-0.0268079694,
-0.054497838,
0.0242018867,
-0.022935899,
0.0361327566,
0.0094252387,
0.0002606933,
-0.0246468987,
-0.0002520631,
-0.0069018975,
-0.0017311447,
-0.0709869117,
0.0338901542,
-0.0243881401,
0.0355489254,
0.0510988608,
-0.000427292,
0.037488386,
0.0231676325,
0.0286784433,
0.0071255444,
0.0492460243,
-0.0285833236,
0.0163338892,
0.0235308036,
0.0167684723,
0.0083690314,
-0.0329421908,
0.0042954455,
0.0222234335,
0.0991303995,
0.0358405933,
-0.063214086,
-0.0535897687,
0.032767456,
-0.0485691689,
-0.0521970689,
0.0533189885,
0.0821390748,
0.0761011168,
0.0390529893,
-0.002287555,
-0.0943002328,
0.0234894417,
-0.002849513,
0.0688708425,
0.0314570628,
-0.0495402887,
0.0643960014,
0.0331592709,
-0.000050239,
-0.0082295071,
0.0392840728,
-0.0076237195,
0.0643365234,
0.00254158,
-0.0061616781,
-0.0370340683,
-0.0035282169,
0.0191530045,
0.0657791346,
0.0017033672,
0.0147585468,
-0.0125877587,
-0.0396892652,
-0.0163501017,
0.0674682111,
-0.0232762005,
-0.017016625,
0.0429225713,
0.0400327556,
0.0160731263,
-0.0533518083,
-0.0144186625,
-0.0455064513,
0.0242518578,
0.0090775089,
0.0004829657,
-5.723580442e-33,
-0.0279833134,
-0.0579441339,
0.0591713749,
-0.0134054581,
-0.0367921591,
-0.0433112979,
-0.0408373289,
0.0031820268,
-0.0253542475,
0.0112479283,
0.0132440832,
0.0125674708,
-0.002339744,
-0.001049676,
0.0423405766,
-0.00864607,
0.0037621604,
0.0129557913,
-0.0190107394,
-0.0048720194,
0.0632306486,
-0.0193979945,
-0.0102585293,
-0.0366575122,
-0.0198987313,
0.0279764924,
-0.0598867908,
0.0517664813,
-0.0747146085,
0.0349332727,
-0.0260450449,
-0.0010433446,
0.0164365005,
0.019558683,
-0.0196267255,
0.0447900631,
-0.0366520025,
-0.0446398817,
0.0113920514,
0.0134756779,
-0.0417097434,
-0.0154458182,
0.0110054119,
0.0003628743,
-0.0042363568,
0.045916643,
0.0165217649,
-0.0158221815,
0.014427687,
0.0387368239,
-0.0405754857,
0.0160241239,
-0.0048024282,
-0.074072808,
0.0191450864,
0.0048837033,
0.0054437676,
0.019081708,
-0.0136912875,
0.0238954984,
-0.0433034375,
-0.0086095771,
0.048707325,
-0.0000462231,
0.0557580478,
0.0569289327,
0.0292179249,
-0.0224317927,
-0.0340016931,
0.002737819,
0.0055067516,
0.0687156394,
-0.0274988841,
0.0841408074,
-0.0102175707,
0.0225320458,
-0.062895976,
-0.0004534775,
0.0086714672,
0.0950622857,
0.0590102971,
0.0366386808,
-0.0050670383,
0.0120694814,
-0.0201217551,
0.0606650971,
-0.0147538129,
-0.0210726932,
0.0387896448,
0.0036563093,
0.0205091536,
-0.0422035716,
0.0561277829,
-0.0303908866,
-0.0028274145,
-0.00737142,
-0.0491571613,
0.0481288247,
-0.0253788251,
0.0012595434,
-0.0453245342,
-0.0530016497,
0.0197116528,
-0.0479549021,
0.0033060766,
0.0320116244,
-0.0491632186,
0.0692360848,
0.0007322215,
-0.0267975274,
-0.0478271693,
-0.0133195464,
0.0413360819,
0.0079744309,
0.0487306379,
-0.0145155471,
-0.0456886329,
0.0375463329,
-0.0355689749,
-0.0548345521,
-0.0096557513,
-0.0531282686,
-0.0288616884,
0.0067409151,
-0.0293763503,
-0.019997349,
-0.0745941773,
-0.024870174,
-0.0319734626,
-0.0423941314,
0.0087345187,
0.0377321579,
3.027e-7,
-0.0443340838,
0.0157756638,
-0.0344181322,
0.0238934234,
0.0374445096,
0.0577981882,
-0.0332613513,
0.0466111638,
-0.0178084578,
-0.0324804485,
-0.0070476392,
0.0552514791,
0.0186294392,
-0.0212770551,
-0.0544937812,
0.0042851735,
0.0333261415,
-0.0703692883,
-0.0513617843,
-0.0075953328,
0.0886597782,
0.0683321804,
0.0170053598,
0.0067269984,
0.0511589646,
-0.0272213351,
0.040691752,
-0.0325949267,
-0.0044424422,
-0.0261021573,
-0.0071582859,
-0.0335342959,
-0.0042778854,
0.0258670263,
0.0358102843,
-0.0038822773,
-0.025623586,
0.0834357589,
-0.0211074445,
-0.0227295272,
-0.0041829171,
0.0242464691,
-0.0345778055,
-0.0428083688,
0.0705466568,
-0.0579070039,
-0.0034527124,
-0.0032059301,
0.0131686023,
-0.0443747342,
-0.0608429722,
-0.004002695,
-0.0162366759,
-0.0391334482,
-0.025367735,
-0.0225664619,
-0.0139699271,
-0.0490129106,
0.0195767004,
0.0022519357,
-0.0543843471,
-0.0450721681,
-0.0042165034,
-0.0442845039,
0.0446244441,
-0.0618923977,
-0.0416614488,
2.284169883e-34,
-0.0180725995,
0.0001298954,
-0.0002109476,
0.0265551265,
0.0209761187,
0.0318164639,
0.004554511,
0.016093066,
0.058220461,
-0.0297488943,
-0.0264167581
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.08262v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.08262v1 | Clinical Concept and Relation Extraction Using Prompt-based Machine Reading Comprehension | 2023-03-14T22:37:31 | 2023-03-14T22:37:31 | Cheng Peng, Xi Yang, Zehao Yu, Jiang Bian, William R. Hogan, Yonghui Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Objective: To develop a natural language processing system that solves both
clinical concept extraction and relation extraction in a unified prompt-based
machine reading comprehension (MRC) architecture with good generalizability for
cross-institution applications.
Methods: We formulate both clinical concept extraction and relation
extraction using a unified prompt-based MRC architecture and explore
state-of-the-art transformer models. We compare our MRC models with existing
deep learning models for concept extraction and end-to-end relation extraction
using two benchmark datasets developed by the 2018 National NLP Clinical
Challenges (n2c2) challenge (medications and adverse drug events) and the 2022
n2c2 challenge (relations of social determinants of health [SDoH]). We also
evaluate the transfer learning ability of the proposed MRC models in a
cross-institution setting. We perform error analyses and examine how different
prompting strategies affect the performance of MRC models.
Results and Conclusion: The proposed MRC models achieve state-of-the-art
performance for clinical concept and relation extraction on the two benchmark
datasets, outperforming previous non-MRC transformer models. GatorTron-MRC
achieves the best strict and lenient F1-scores for concept extraction,
outperforming previous deep learning models on the two datasets by 1%~3% and
0.7%~1.3%, respectively. For end-to-end relation extraction, GatorTron-MRC and
BERT-MIMIC-MRC achieve the best F1-scores, outperforming previous deep learning
models by 0.9%~2.4% and 10%-11%, respectively. For cross-institution
evaluation, GatorTron-MRC outperforms traditional GatorTron by 6.4% and 16% for
the two datasets, respectively. The proposed method is better at handling
nested/overlapped concepts, extracting relations, and has good portability for
cross-institute applications. | [
0.0525798909,
0.0310890339,
0.0173144322,
0.0158880502,
-0.0270503685,
0.0530668795,
0.0227108672,
-0.0153685343,
0.0307500456,
0.0091444189,
-0.0199209005,
-0.0392988659,
-0.0167813487,
0.0760795325,
-0.0151819633,
-0.0567803681,
0.040550556,
0.0121355895,
0.0311756209,
0.0341356285,
-0.0432542637,
0.0123737762,
-0.0519943908,
-0.0017265721,
0.0341184661,
-0.036347799,
0.0285539627,
-0.0164942574,
0.0555302314,
-0.1020345986,
-0.018463986,
0.0318346582,
-0.0361378044,
0.0065761725,
0.0000020983,
-0.0552549176,
-0.0455478467,
0.0187105816,
-0.0730701983,
-0.0434111655,
0.0362456404,
-0.0744400099,
0.0299327206,
-0.0084077371,
-0.0236386657,
-0.0515353195,
0.001442188,
0.0803001449,
0.0340941027,
0.0503838547,
-0.0239966698,
-0.0249571055,
0.0416735783,
-0.029508533,
0.0026224242,
-0.0656934977,
0.0352277979,
0.0077087325,
0.0071613169,
0.0133684259,
-0.011967794,
0.0551967919,
-0.0037278342,
0.0417041555,
0.0360406749,
0.0424144752,
-0.0053820214,
-0.0295408554,
-0.0309860539,
0.1400401145,
0.0180199258,
0.0267522559,
0.0124497656,
0.0023345037,
0.0030964289,
0.0473217443,
-0.0062651099,
-0.0030502316,
-0.0460281596,
0.0017305291,
0.0039453665,
0.0004309209,
0.0412940495,
-0.0023682199,
-0.0237565599,
0.0007422836,
0.0168683063,
-0.0367369168,
0.0540141352,
0.0187487137,
-0.0159629863,
-0.0072754989,
0.0804491565,
0.0223876871,
-0.0426995642,
0.0350773893,
-0.0064548664,
-0.0429350249,
0.0523681343,
-0.0206141528,
0.0012792118,
0.0279237162,
-0.043215543,
0.0638570637,
-0.0375927538,
0.0287295263,
-0.0381181613,
0.035585355,
-0.0403208546,
0.0106288726,
-0.0181686841,
0.008289732,
-0.0144709256,
0.0322377831,
-0.061061088,
-0.0287587624,
-0.0474325381,
0.0083443094,
0.0332141072,
0.0136682205,
-0.0007922216,
0.0422127582,
-0.0404024534,
0.0075786007,
0.0051099635,
0.0183390379,
-0.0122460155,
-0.0271553621,
0.0164022911,
-0.0539254732,
-0.006398133,
-0.0295076687,
0.033697769,
-0.0278794859,
0.0270332415,
0.0639387965,
-0.0125561869,
-0.0513590984,
0.0116116283,
-0.0165118016,
-0.0040069213,
-0.0074263471,
0.0103845596,
-0.0420684293,
0.078307569,
0.015835302,
0.0085350983,
-0.0232136454,
0.0106452564,
0.0076777865,
-0.0689355358,
0.0740026906,
-0.0198729821,
-0.0278272629,
0.0324509852,
0.041120179,
-0.0226233825,
0.0193701722,
0.0209779721,
-0.0424137786,
0.0221543703,
-0.0052177464,
-0.0124876872,
0.0002736139,
0.0186540522,
-0.0829040259,
0.0362584367,
0.0059765065,
0.0093816193,
0.070329152,
-0.0042304453,
0.0683761388,
-0.0168668758,
-0.038911365,
0.0046950923,
0.0438781567,
0.0242778044,
0.0270668883,
0.0354424194,
0.0125455158,
0.0047766347,
0.0006426729,
-0.0291017815,
-0.0204372294,
0.0148414541,
0.0106163584,
-0.0430377498,
-0.0007236979,
-0.0056441552,
-0.0125234751,
0.0178119056,
0.0231682062,
-0.0393571146,
-0.0021983571,
0.0467146859,
-0.0123113915,
-0.0885849446,
0.0704147443,
0.0226700213,
-0.0040752869,
-0.010209783,
-0.0037895788,
0.014582363,
0.0422609411,
0.0534672812,
-0.0308539607,
-0.0442333333,
-0.0233235117,
-0.0114170862,
0.0234547332,
0.0148983048,
-0.0152063575,
0.0504879802,
-0.0523549318,
0.0006863153,
0.0518764965,
-0.0028434009,
-0.0119719123,
0.0016523905,
0.0315284543,
-0.0223597381,
-0.0082711708,
-0.012730062,
0.0541263558,
-0.0446902178,
-0.0430541672,
0.0002184836,
0.0074839927,
0.0298381802,
0.0113417236,
0.0008674347,
-0.0004268645,
0.0228311997,
-0.0553757437,
0.0084805638,
-0.0216518603,
-0.1089509875,
-0.0704346299,
-0.0081360927,
-0.0220168233,
-0.0258762278,
0.0136777777,
-0.0297749527,
-0.003614739,
-0.050606329,
-0.0186866019,
0.0145117994,
-0.0037293329,
0.0030100786,
0.0444169827,
0.0198801961,
-0.0478179418,
0.0158665981,
-0.0311336834,
-0.0098596271,
0.0281349644,
-0.0215917677,
-0.0443300419,
-0.0055249087,
-0.0199346822,
0.0081420736,
-0.0248089954,
-0.0477486886,
-0.040764261,
0.0161847565,
-0.0495768934,
-0.0218147412,
-0.0541827865,
0.0301670041,
0.0276852883,
-0.0024301109,
0.0335422568,
0.0348026343,
-0.0231456868,
-0.0290514752,
-0.0027022492,
0.0061649205,
0.0166307371,
0.0024145576,
0.0520153195,
0.0631479025,
0.0034183851,
-0.0253189523,
-0.0231824275,
-0.039784044,
0.0574733466,
0.0141481562,
-0.0396558568,
0.0036573771,
-0.0100229885,
0.0001445248,
0.0053751217,
-0.0076506468,
0.0069988333,
-0.0058151265,
-0.0059257336,
0.0193988513,
0.0415893495,
-0.007065265,
0.0517360978,
-0.014824504,
-0.0238326751,
-0.0196890011,
0.0439495854,
-0.0281272288,
-0.0048238905,
0.0169593617,
-0.0356059894,
-0.0053981808,
0.0866481066,
0.0293039698,
-0.0013431218,
-0.000254741,
-0.03884314,
-0.0116285114,
0.0135846185,
-0.0811874047,
0.0390939265,
-0.0377956927,
0.0130589036,
-0.0335819498,
0.0045883688,
0.0974222869,
-0.0025441493,
0.0148771508,
-0.0829225406,
0.0127321323,
-0.0321528353,
0.0072394121,
-0.0014999894,
0.0004521059,
-0.0224223174,
-0.0524017848,
0.0068716765,
0.0145084262,
-0.0149615845,
-0.0460652187,
0.0658374429,
-0.0325327814,
0.0067673125,
-0.0159530863,
-0.0225723721,
-0.0623874888,
-0.0097031342,
-0.0222268719,
0.002248748,
0.0087603219,
0.029382553,
-0.0531980358,
0.0071288841,
-0.0221857857,
0.0832825825,
0.0150175821,
-0.0141326534,
-0.0284146778,
0.0628151372,
0.0396885611,
0.0036226937,
0.0084452191,
-0.0385743827,
0.0721106529,
0.0643446445,
-0.0201073922,
0.0013538249,
0.0246837977,
0.0289002266,
0.0157997534,
-0.0403569154,
0.01676373,
0.0055647031,
0.0421625674,
-0.086011678,
-0.0154590895,
0.0957353413,
0.0193239115,
-0.0486538298,
0.000439056,
0.0054253386,
-0.0096080303,
-0.0272601582,
0.026328681,
-0.0736199245,
-0.0573115125,
-0.0085801017,
0.0342708826,
-0.0146354139,
-0.0575816259,
0.0015235287,
-0.0257151704,
-0.0125942174,
-0.030999139,
-0.0794437975,
-0.0478555635,
-0.0407804213,
0.0042232894,
-0.008959596,
0.019395316,
0.0128585622,
-0.0074569741,
-0.0191256292,
-0.0078202486,
-0.0546011962,
-0.0478125103,
0.0238575581,
-0.0190777555,
0.0283426382,
0.0231876094,
0.0164649412,
-0.0022274894,
-0.0043491167,
0.0127286632,
-0.0341415107,
-0.0156571511,
-0.0111870281,
0.084458068,
-0.0127109597,
-0.016354477,
-0.0610219538,
0.0380560756,
-0.0526066795,
-0.0212707166,
-0.0159342866,
0.0765680671,
0.0030305544,
-0.0580214038,
-0.0521470718,
0.0375683382,
0.0232240688,
0.0602284223,
-0.00349516,
0.004045432,
-0.045768369,
0.0347197056,
0.0420205705,
-0.0414145887,
0.0184859838,
0.0167522673,
-0.0118686082,
0.0006360055,
-0.021870954,
-0.0611507632,
0.0331512764,
-0.0114750341,
0.0179514959,
-0.0015254719,
0.0459203124,
0.003604,
-0.0739683211,
0.0516785979,
0.023987297,
-0.0232531503,
-0.0686934069,
-0.0288148373,
0.0207161363,
-0.0076111639,
-0.0388278812,
0.0285500176,
-0.035591621,
0.0321251638,
0.0223302189,
0.0104572661,
0.0145423254,
0.0303242542,
-0.0000350987,
0.0289169401,
0.0524911135,
0.025658641,
-0.0472179651,
-0.0483396463,
-0.0196174663,
-0.0136762066,
-0.0186734851,
-0.0004842899,
0.0002635072,
0.0192051921,
0.0067722299,
0.048156932,
-0.0067873751,
-0.0259481203,
0.0157951508,
0.0150629086,
0.0544225238,
0.027393328,
-0.0186834726,
-0.0700298399,
0.0268254243,
0.009176597,
0.0438673608,
-0.0182221271,
0.0149251185,
0.0540452488,
-0.0315917581,
-0.0259588286,
-0.0172397736,
-0.0338104069,
-0.0219919663,
-0.0153805837,
0.0334557034,
0.0196374785,
0.0184290726,
0.0480727181,
-0.0442856029,
-0.0311302673,
0.0277412962,
-0.0068233907,
0.0342493169,
-0.0106263021,
0.0954801664,
0.0114434315,
-0.000339585,
0.0232175849,
0.0519135855,
-0.0309171621,
0.0137556223,
-0.0294619109,
0.0383374952,
0.0097398534,
-0.0024958199,
-0.0041942853,
0.0051262239,
0.0042639324,
-0.0076814196,
0.0157421231,
-0.0398167223,
0.0161713958,
0.051941622,
0.0113320732,
0.0274821948,
0.0035907843,
0.0539089777,
-0.0341969058,
0.025901949,
0.0224864148,
-0.0330275036,
-0.0697977543,
0.0014867068,
-0.0057106293,
0.0068394914,
-0.0433724783,
0.0183788482,
-0.0491240472,
-0.0397529751,
0.0592295825,
-0.0269222427,
-0.0040430818,
0.0096656475,
0.0236211941,
0.0567644611,
0.0060034394,
-0.0683624521,
-0.0342296101,
0.0681420267,
-0.0253747124,
-0.0276960414,
0.0038570184,
-6.039193328e-33,
-0.0126527334,
-0.013445247,
0.0067017353,
-0.0177057907,
-0.0227412488,
0.03499984,
-0.0522767529,
-0.0353269354,
-0.0295361076,
0.0619585104,
-0.0205795262,
0.0128108393,
0.0160477534,
0.0423400179,
-0.0145282317,
-0.0593384691,
0.0301553328,
0.0194948465,
-0.0254979748,
0.0253967978,
0.0092653465,
0.1286983937,
0.0407939292,
-0.0629328564,
0.0185432583,
0.0018349448,
0.0714672431,
0.0222342294,
0.0261962675,
0.0209706258,
-0.0801821277,
0.0160086937,
0.0574386679,
-0.0410698391,
0.0211286303,
0.0425531827,
-0.1555860937,
-0.0268192906,
-0.0255780015,
-0.0134653235,
-0.0818093866,
-0.0171232913,
0.0571905077,
-0.0044322782,
0.0261993315,
-0.0294613559,
0.0216722097,
-0.0236989949,
-0.0093949176,
-0.0092740599,
-0.0408819541,
0.0386402868,
0.0117336735,
-0.0078840479,
-0.0289356429,
0.0302839261,
-0.0327858515,
0.0592801832,
-0.0427074321,
-0.0491553955,
-0.0016609498,
0.0098937107,
0.0144605422,
0.0026293732,
-0.0436950363,
0.0589174367,
-0.0118528316,
-0.0359245986,
-0.0408949666,
0.0102116624,
-0.0466346741,
0.048757989,
0.0180472657,
0.0284156594,
0.0399830788,
0.0002217281,
-0.0871825144,
0.0296062455,
-0.0216075294,
0.0431735776,
-0.0012434459,
-0.0481319949,
-0.054982923,
0.0115385642,
-0.0207309593,
0.0044583809,
-0.0182064734,
-0.0112295141,
0.0337876715,
-0.024571998,
-0.023246251,
0.0210048854,
0.0221894644,
-0.0029339581,
0.0154246101,
0.0007137851,
0.0640321076,
0.0062081823,
-0.0329522304,
0.0172021184,
-0.052362524,
-0.0203469824,
-0.0055543827,
-0.0080396971,
0.0418474451,
0.0051332666,
0.0083717443,
-0.0378273949,
-0.0228214692,
-0.038346719,
-0.0162996054,
0.0181172248,
-0.0185529944,
0.0563246422,
0.0110438485,
0.0295319408,
-0.0123784114,
0.0753319487,
-0.0164893456,
0.0162356179,
-0.0115703261,
-0.0046789139,
0.0181254968,
0.0124696596,
-0.0226187222,
-0.03132388,
-0.015674362,
0.0656185448,
-0.0000044248,
-0.0828112066,
0.0278122816,
0.014486162,
2.849e-7,
0.0810605586,
0.0380783342,
0.0591653138,
-0.0217799339,
0.0090417629,
-0.0016559754,
0.0339921787,
0.0382112488,
0.0074737957,
-0.0322100967,
0.0346683785,
0.0167572256,
0.0133604985,
0.0195919387,
-0.0888765827,
-0.0742957816,
-0.0735318884,
-0.0089423368,
-0.0312722921,
-0.0322884284,
0.0810378492,
0.0589246377,
-0.0377127044,
-0.0475038365,
0.0150774997,
0.0072684283,
-0.0059699453,
-0.0264606047,
0.0118005993,
0.0544426218,
0.0199083276,
-0.0052010738,
0.0075147157,
0.0898570195,
-0.0085458718,
0.0069999197,
0.0111220554,
0.0776620656,
-0.0040780813,
-0.0265816916,
0.0079521062,
0.0105577484,
0.0324519016,
-0.0477449037,
0.0655395165,
-0.0642967522,
-0.046191711,
0.0232080389,
-0.0676144511,
-0.0259271823,
0.0257423054,
0.0196741447,
-0.0066619031,
0.0436068922,
0.0317896903,
-0.0033913462,
-0.0162046235,
-0.0698908865,
0.0074347281,
0.0326644219,
-0.0150499111,
0.0059764464,
0.0150245484,
-0.0601155199,
0.0104523925,
-0.0506748594,
-0.0079143532,
2.400859279e-34,
0.0106257647,
0.0163375158,
0.0287496243,
0.0220075231,
0.0023162768,
-0.0256817248,
-0.0134632625,
0.0039692046,
-0.0105700819,
-0.064884223,
0.0045942455
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.08259v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.08259v1 | Contextualized Medication Information Extraction Using Transformer-based Deep Learning Architectures | 2023-03-14T22:22:28 | 2023-03-14T22:22:28 | Aokun Chen, Zehao Yu, Xi Yang, Yi Guo, Jiang Bian, Yonghui Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Objective: To develop a natural language processing (NLP) system to extract
medications and contextual information that help understand drug changes. This
project is part of the 2022 n2c2 challenge.
Materials and methods: We developed NLP systems for medication mention
extraction, event classification (indicating medication changes discussed or
not), and context classification to classify medication changes context into 5
orthogonal dimensions related to drug changes. We explored 6 state-of-the-art
pretrained transformer models for the three subtasks, including GatorTron, a
large language model pretrained using >90 billion words of text (including >80
billion words from >290 million clinical notes identified at the University of
Florida Health). We evaluated our NLP systems using annotated data and
evaluation scripts provided by the 2022 n2c2 organizers.
Results:Our GatorTron models achieved the best F1-scores of 0.9828 for
medication extraction (ranked 3rd), 0.9379 for event classification (ranked
2nd), and the best micro-average accuracy of 0.9126 for context classification.
GatorTron outperformed existing transformer models pretrained using smaller
general English text and clinical text corpora, indicating the advantage of
large language models.
Conclusion: This study demonstrated the advantage of using large transformer
models for contextual medication information extraction from clinical
narratives. | [
0.0292934794,
0.0558494292,
0.0183909647,
0.0111799389,
-0.0076762275,
0.0264093895,
0.0081852702,
-0.0114049092,
0.0159504469,
-0.043343693,
0.0101037817,
-0.0266986191,
-0.0321750343,
0.0636161864,
-0.0090554897,
-0.0304661393,
0.0106724631,
0.0353479721,
-0.0150468871,
0.0527186543,
-0.0247621927,
0.0174501035,
-0.0382544994,
0.0295782275,
0.0020865926,
-0.0223752614,
0.0416901633,
-0.0201985016,
0.0500720292,
-0.0825569779,
0.0162019078,
0.0076106237,
0.0057709343,
0.0192280207,
0.000001957,
-0.0429861918,
-0.0170837175,
0.0176166557,
-0.0653366372,
-0.0623895377,
0.0672267526,
-0.0797279999,
-0.007171609,
-0.0021939271,
-0.0269325208,
-0.0862717852,
0.0231241137,
0.1052913889,
0.0076410254,
0.0781757161,
-0.0301465392,
-0.0480743274,
0.0518507659,
-0.0115551557,
0.0181631576,
-0.0668856502,
0.0422672927,
-0.0126606431,
0.0167322028,
0.0022105526,
0.0098865703,
0.011163393,
-0.012118469,
0.0116531095,
0.0188577175,
0.0391873531,
-0.0512855016,
-0.00982212,
-0.0155905569,
0.0842142254,
-0.0030718935,
0.0282440614,
0.0186276082,
-0.0134380711,
-0.0250038169,
-0.0199471097,
-0.015297222,
0.0028457239,
-0.0349296406,
0.0286157206,
0.0119234324,
0.0123328529,
0.0343261361,
0.0008659806,
-0.04066322,
0.0204222742,
-0.0016165727,
0.0141447335,
0.015542984,
-0.0055111698,
0.004131936,
-0.0327356867,
0.0558953397,
0.0093415426,
-0.0223734286,
0.024786016,
-0.0021398123,
-0.0418460518,
0.0503062792,
-0.0733666569,
-0.0066556414,
-0.0103826812,
-0.0293462351,
0.0373184904,
-0.0279457178,
0.0267716926,
-0.0288793314,
0.0026744208,
-0.0494690165,
0.0017410377,
-0.0463472791,
0.0087067243,
-0.0299325157,
0.0233754739,
-0.0259003304,
-0.0321706906,
-0.0374881774,
0.0007277552,
0.0019339265,
-0.0127098542,
0.0045608594,
0.0649669841,
-0.035487324,
0.005487923,
0.0304743983,
0.063050136,
0.0102176685,
0.0057855397,
0.0018656316,
-0.0489533693,
0.0265311729,
-0.0182873253,
0.0460160188,
-0.0226129629,
0.0267233811,
0.0624398664,
0.0139557272,
-0.0613702238,
-0.0433006585,
-0.0124000292,
0.0072405399,
-0.014694754,
-0.0064174579,
-0.0495655313,
0.0508911796,
-0.0260649137,
0.010048002,
-0.0306234546,
0.0125685064,
-0.0137635032,
-0.0575495139,
0.0784297734,
-0.0237469617,
-0.0433805771,
0.0486784391,
0.0090828864,
0.0369039886,
0.0150372013,
0.0513074994,
-0.00277265,
0.0231415704,
-0.0149890454,
0.0104733817,
-0.0035482908,
-0.0243962314,
-0.0925507173,
0.0446304418,
-0.0078609884,
0.0074080629,
0.0634316206,
-0.0386913568,
0.0380961858,
-0.0131338323,
0.0108928056,
0.0183541551,
0.0519616418,
0.0461803079,
0.0087089408,
0.0324682966,
-0.0255332217,
-0.0224605165,
-0.0362535343,
-0.0252960157,
-0.0289534554,
0.0308382902,
-0.004598591,
-0.0569422618,
0.0010379854,
-0.0205258653,
-0.0178901926,
-0.007248295,
-0.0439736098,
-0.008929655,
-0.0143050021,
0.0464440025,
-0.0086329877,
-0.0827783272,
0.0936122984,
0.0314207003,
-0.0341727361,
-0.0140249962,
-0.0025019119,
-0.0215394944,
0.0686277971,
0.0296775736,
-0.0449347682,
-0.0318493396,
-0.03673416,
0.0064734621,
0.0026098185,
0.0090663536,
-0.0266606566,
0.0441847891,
-0.0496951751,
0.0154590569,
0.0006936758,
0.0130738225,
-0.0208679046,
-0.0073459866,
0.0288140066,
-0.0145108383,
0.0029615706,
-0.0138538741,
0.0597923361,
-0.0346611254,
-0.0774462149,
0.0272191912,
-0.0130746588,
0.0025185717,
0.0134894866,
-0.008171564,
-0.0088550542,
0.0766570047,
-0.0573005788,
-0.0220054425,
0.0041255923,
-0.0213876609,
-0.0327772126,
0.0051006689,
-0.0239100996,
0.0280074999,
-0.0161577128,
-0.0543785654,
-0.0114292204,
-0.0068383259,
-0.0237188023,
0.0405823514,
0.0137949763,
0.009301303,
0.0387078114,
0.0350381769,
-0.055367019,
-0.0030746718,
0.0155978063,
-0.02341507,
0.0079704719,
-0.0453814678,
-0.0129625062,
0.027045086,
0.0154403159,
0.0540112071,
-0.0002046771,
0.001732973,
-0.0049167201,
-0.0102083581,
-0.0005938511,
-0.0171882808,
-0.0818171501,
0.0018455378,
0.0027963459,
0.0076416684,
0.0275030397,
0.0329433121,
-0.0029870332,
-0.0270075575,
-0.006258613,
-0.0270141214,
-0.0186250806,
-0.0161863714,
0.0479737967,
0.0696646869,
0.0176626891,
-0.0433466919,
-0.0188528579,
-0.0412278846,
0.0647447333,
-0.0024682397,
-0.0416591838,
-0.0150701934,
-0.0079220738,
0.0225908868,
0.0312481299,
-0.0207672976,
0.0145051675,
0.0095245922,
0.0130279902,
0.0229689945,
0.0613313466,
0.0055979746,
0.0531342216,
0.0074558714,
-0.0023159923,
0.0123690749,
0.0126104765,
-0.0533302166,
-0.0268203747,
-0.0027797411,
-0.0333796814,
0.0072045317,
0.0789028034,
0.0085801976,
0.0047435625,
-0.003355636,
-0.0572933927,
-0.0119045638,
0.0349969603,
-0.0064683412,
0.0114011951,
-0.0549848489,
0.0012580503,
-0.0007768631,
-0.0076458459,
0.061418768,
-0.0077256467,
0.0103317276,
-0.1095514074,
-0.0248776432,
-0.0497778282,
-0.0033231045,
0.0283097383,
0.0045252373,
0.0032688293,
-0.028527271,
0.0451111868,
0.0005910792,
-0.0051190569,
-0.0403362177,
0.0900345892,
-0.0154906288,
0.0378130414,
-0.0141168516,
-0.0234004483,
-0.0436211601,
-0.0349438339,
-0.0207323227,
0.0159568321,
0.0164100546,
0.0096427072,
-0.0685897544,
0.0169354975,
-0.0382002555,
0.1183779687,
0.0277043004,
-0.0200783089,
-0.0062337448,
0.0300744157,
0.0615424737,
-0.0269143786,
0.0167562887,
0.0053682253,
0.0522093289,
0.0754231215,
0.0278394725,
0.0290835407,
-0.0149041833,
-0.0097961966,
-0.0006114061,
-0.0527794138,
-0.0044726487,
0.0338904671,
0.0213138871,
-0.0657657608,
-0.0201624501,
0.0984635204,
0.0167875104,
-0.0497808047,
0.0359330885,
0.0293511059,
-0.0974242091,
-0.0103133945,
0.0088809952,
-0.0815509781,
-0.0409202576,
-0.0327269249,
-0.0036091083,
-0.0076440121,
-0.0297101699,
-0.0138654569,
-0.029916944,
-0.0071478803,
-0.013171983,
-0.0352733582,
-0.0105053307,
-0.0300284903,
-0.007937382,
-0.0316155851,
-0.0004880925,
-0.022259647,
-0.0376840122,
-0.0370312631,
0.008724397,
-0.0818735734,
-0.0663639978,
0.0138659878,
-0.0323270038,
0.0034066865,
0.0249446258,
-0.0014246744,
-0.0295328684,
-0.0124880532,
0.0321402326,
-0.0409632958,
-0.0113569349,
0.0301686022,
0.0799273774,
-0.033761479,
-0.0021641066,
-0.0238888487,
0.0434913263,
-0.0713012293,
-0.0551255681,
-0.0352955423,
0.0715494901,
-0.0197395179,
-0.0443443097,
-0.0370968357,
0.0321355574,
0.0108254915,
0.0250111409,
-0.0168635622,
0.0093387701,
-0.0252312589,
0.0218338091,
0.0411041528,
-0.0386005417,
-0.0028512292,
0.0037118234,
-0.0073301215,
-0.0117472438,
-0.0577225387,
-0.0407082364,
0.043131724,
-0.0344925262,
-0.0078058103,
-0.0061967461,
0.0394745953,
-0.0063944031,
-0.0547711328,
0.0550893322,
0.04501779,
0.0145105617,
-0.0439336188,
-0.025069613,
0.0369752087,
0.0353513621,
-0.0194339547,
0.0510615744,
-0.0589611679,
-0.0205302145,
0.0368923172,
-0.0034869045,
0.0117042651,
0.0138256429,
0.0080446387,
0.0055190288,
0.0304645877,
0.0326030254,
0.0203842521,
-0.0609260835,
0.0039717006,
-0.012879679,
-0.0056635807,
0.0045834095,
-0.0101455469,
0.0374726094,
-0.009156133,
0.0085930834,
-0.0087290881,
-0.0133381151,
0.008698673,
-0.0408099294,
0.0416178107,
-0.0018725418,
-0.0208859686,
-0.0628925711,
0.0265460853,
-0.0047989264,
0.0412406065,
-0.0082338527,
0.0010647269,
0.0278475415,
-0.0058449022,
-0.0279652029,
0.0316381045,
-0.054913599,
-0.0324850604,
-0.0352948047,
0.0403809622,
0.0326296352,
0.0088864602,
0.042825561,
-0.0123053752,
-0.0043049552,
-0.001230747,
-0.0053163571,
0.0453261398,
-0.0450773463,
0.0671671629,
-0.0049057174,
0.0264950227,
-0.0296958853,
0.0744754225,
-0.0467703417,
0.0055854646,
-0.0428804196,
0.0118111158,
0.0661366284,
-0.0568653084,
0.0353288502,
-0.0180328786,
0.0027874182,
-0.0280363206,
0.0120231416,
-0.0048564817,
0.0367271453,
0.0296077561,
0.0266137645,
-0.0212277789,
0.0017656155,
0.0617320016,
-0.0117503004,
0.0521094613,
0.0244815592,
-0.0144249722,
-0.0267030131,
0.0087636048,
-0.0190790948,
0.0322332047,
-0.0506124459,
-0.0048549445,
-0.0224631727,
-0.0143336682,
0.0576430671,
-0.0157624651,
-0.020136727,
-0.0148885651,
0.0285935663,
0.048679553,
0.0410788059,
-0.0454814695,
-0.0301637836,
0.040421389,
0.0301850233,
-0.009371656,
-0.0169009194,
-5.730479124e-33,
0.0248588137,
-0.0066852588,
-0.0211743414,
0.0166096147,
-0.0094151041,
0.0525127985,
-0.0399578996,
-0.0354346074,
-0.0252346862,
0.0496416576,
-0.0101840626,
0.0085775107,
0.0194106884,
0.0364946686,
-0.0088821398,
-0.0368330218,
0.0363303833,
0.0278855469,
-0.0102526788,
0.0252448283,
0.0008399672,
0.1111462489,
0.0995229855,
-0.0711752251,
0.0224300027,
0.0057635983,
0.0656232908,
-0.0040361276,
0.0328273624,
0.0588279255,
-0.0588087887,
0.0573065765,
0.0480611809,
-0.0870088339,
0.003411771,
-0.0070477342,
-0.0904657096,
-0.0094317934,
-0.0240299981,
-0.00161483,
-0.0176469181,
-0.0367119983,
0.038725201,
-0.014827529,
-0.021786496,
-0.0100368457,
0.042668473,
-0.0062567224,
-0.0124678938,
-0.0344225876,
-0.0744588524,
0.0390149727,
0.0077915685,
0.0006557961,
-0.010946651,
0.013732831,
-0.0129620945,
0.0477062427,
-0.0578403585,
-0.0365503579,
-0.0205415729,
0.0355638564,
-0.0090011004,
-0.015962027,
-0.0506375432,
0.0543389693,
0.0143164396,
0.0066621522,
-0.0338165425,
0.0018800965,
-0.0413777903,
0.0383411869,
0.0249032453,
0.0129126422,
0.0504252054,
-0.0080497526,
-0.0779730678,
0.0187714286,
-0.0478799753,
0.0522900671,
0.0011837386,
-0.0201904476,
-0.0203075279,
-0.0010297211,
0.0051904405,
0.0061602918,
-0.0059957234,
0.0104523003,
-0.0045144623,
0.0057264017,
0.0073419609,
0.0799199492,
0.0022649174,
-0.0541159473,
-0.0055420599,
0.006400554,
0.0360891931,
0.0321950056,
-0.0238671713,
-0.0036525021,
-0.0435606577,
-0.0124189258,
0.0245554578,
0.00496948,
0.039389357,
0.0110696945,
0.0297778919,
-0.0115747387,
-0.0417756848,
-0.0145292077,
-0.0041019893,
-0.0021684063,
-0.0086663198,
0.0872065574,
-0.0001107806,
0.0491056889,
0.0071087205,
0.0907795802,
0.0092649208,
-0.0166056156,
-0.0036586712,
-0.0181183256,
0.0611122213,
0.0186013598,
-0.0411916152,
0.0105474228,
-0.0289135315,
0.0847626254,
0.0414932296,
-0.0580055155,
0.0040006265,
-0.0048238016,
2.711e-7,
0.1033021882,
0.0346830226,
0.0528698638,
-0.0542941503,
0.0329456255,
0.0116235092,
0.021943897,
0.0284444094,
-0.0213772003,
-0.0013231748,
0.0359616913,
-0.0015006539,
0.0157041699,
0.0338705815,
-0.0508825928,
-0.0645291731,
-0.0813428238,
-0.0611995757,
-0.0590156317,
-0.0163521022,
0.0654737353,
0.0918403342,
-0.0184167065,
-0.0427222922,
0.0012723075,
-0.0176355857,
-0.0014132191,
-0.0421431996,
0.0182023216,
0.0445748456,
-0.0111137582,
0.0276282057,
-0.0166575871,
0.0285190176,
-0.0260197669,
0.0213464461,
-0.0367015935,
0.0722365603,
-0.0658262298,
-0.0120520545,
0.0127731152,
-0.0129498802,
0.002646124,
-0.0184945967,
0.0652606562,
-0.0400884449,
-0.0414372198,
-0.0358452089,
-0.0278021134,
0.0034123985,
0.0584804155,
-0.0181016531,
-0.0247585084,
0.0550942831,
0.0327907838,
0.0305346511,
-0.0427834019,
-0.0983500108,
0.0085780546,
0.0512992367,
-0.0267985091,
0.0242092088,
0.0424116068,
-0.0765157863,
-0.002144116,
-0.0425209031,
0.020475015,
2.352038611e-34,
0.0187364072,
0.028845543,
0.013127394,
0.0204753745,
0.0322873853,
-0.0054731793,
0.0004192824,
-0.0250867382,
-0.0284631327,
-0.0782603249,
-0.004525179
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.08233v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.08233v2 | NL4Opt Competition: Formulating Optimization Problems Based on Their Natural Language Descriptions | 2023-03-14T20:59:04 | 2023-03-27T01:10:12 | Rindranirina Ramamonjison, Timothy T. Yu, Raymond Li, Haley Li, Giuseppe Carenini, Bissan Ghaddar, Shiqi He, Mahdi Mostajabdaveh, Amin Banitalebi-Dehkordi, Zirui Zhou, Yong Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The Natural Language for Optimization (NL4Opt) Competition was created to
investigate methods of extracting the meaning and formulation of an
optimization problem based on its text description. Specifically, the goal of
the competition is to increase the accessibility and usability of optimization
solvers by allowing non-experts to interface with them using natural language.
We separate this challenging goal into two sub-tasks: (1) recognize and label
the semantic entities that correspond to the components of the optimization
problem; (2) generate a meaning representation (i.e., a logical form) of the
problem from its detected problem entities. The first task aims to reduce
ambiguity by detecting and tagging the entities of the optimization problems.
The second task creates an intermediate representation of the linear
programming (LP) problem that is converted into a format that can be used by
commercial solvers. In this report, we present the LP word problem dataset and
shared tasks for the NeurIPS 2022 competition. Furthermore, we investigate and
compare the performance of the ChatGPT large language model against the winning
solutions. Through this competition, we hope to bring interest towards the
development of novel machine learning applications and datasets for
optimization modeling. | [
0.032837484,
0.0769822225,
-0.0074935048,
0.0829612464,
-0.0330367088,
-0.0137704667,
-0.0022932086,
0.0333438888,
-0.0083143441,
-0.0378708467,
0.0028483113,
0.025436433,
-0.0280897375,
0.0404675789,
0.0471985601,
-0.0540387109,
0.0211363658,
0.0006894416,
0.004168028,
0.0355047844,
0.0074368981,
0.0019050724,
-0.0078131435,
0.0142443776,
-0.0524841025,
0.0189972594,
-0.012380586,
0.0000091202,
0.0137257362,
-0.0361870602,
0.0182364862,
0.0360498689,
0.0366674922,
0.0075412435,
0.0000025253,
-0.0666021183,
-0.0730754361,
-0.010258643,
-0.0357027799,
-0.0024443979,
0.0995325372,
-0.0313155986,
0.0287418514,
0.0139785754,
-0.0286957026,
0.0270150676,
0.0476894043,
0.0451162383,
0.0768610761,
0.0685885549,
-0.0261082575,
-0.0279690605,
-0.0198014714,
-0.0107943853,
0.006436937,
-0.0447528027,
0.0027331081,
0.0102096163,
-0.0148181515,
0.003771144,
-0.0131343901,
0.0313655138,
0.0242710467,
0.0249391161,
0.0330146961,
0.0005513739,
-0.0761219114,
-0.0152523369,
-0.0133075211,
0.0591620803,
0.0016688483,
-0.013223174,
0.0366228372,
-0.0320459083,
-0.0092731472,
-0.0383000411,
-0.0074676187,
0.0202944353,
0.0081863254,
0.0050443993,
-0.0190022737,
0.0310903508,
0.0207682457,
0.0151728084,
-0.0076319575,
0.0712064207,
-0.0074095568,
-0.0254081897,
0.0383687094,
-0.0306563955,
-0.0190871675,
-0.0197900832,
0.0741733238,
0.027594354,
-0.0157981701,
0.0296682306,
-0.0076862625,
-0.0262194183,
-0.0274029169,
-0.0612321272,
0.0516930036,
0.0212359112,
0.0510758609,
0.0378035009,
-0.010120227,
0.0565688051,
-0.0218842048,
-0.0370069593,
-0.0496698432,
0.022507472,
-0.0705060214,
-0.031367369,
-0.066309087,
0.0392455645,
-0.0689375401,
0.0068348516,
-0.0163279399,
0.0090224026,
-0.0285011251,
0.0032944561,
0.0125746494,
0.0259780567,
-0.0223129354,
-0.0274227746,
-0.0599010214,
0.0092634605,
-0.029910503,
-0.0144576738,
-0.047056742,
-0.0101231448,
-0.0036783644,
0.0397520475,
-0.0169712435,
-0.0301324278,
0.0189249311,
0.1295635551,
0.0157380328,
0.0147525202,
-0.0125216478,
-0.0696528852,
-0.0089840582,
-0.0681209266,
-0.0489557348,
-0.0766870975,
0.0587826855,
-0.0301911365,
-0.0170019493,
-0.0420923531,
0.0136192562,
-0.0007578103,
0.0001948739,
0.0934011489,
-0.037206389,
-0.0175545756,
0.0613567978,
-0.0069693467,
0.0122161247,
0.0771228373,
0.0487220511,
0.056509871,
0.0329128765,
-0.0027268894,
-0.0391990542,
0.0538045242,
0.0194012038,
-0.0278097261,
-0.0053287684,
-0.0096529098,
-0.0127525805,
0.0623150021,
-0.0047311466,
0.0191398002,
-0.0211934429,
-0.0084442291,
0.0390760116,
0.0581327043,
0.0323950201,
0.0085909814,
0.0027420083,
0.0610554554,
-0.0013438683,
-0.0864516944,
-0.0019350753,
-0.016525574,
-0.0522571057,
-0.0144972662,
-0.0244387109,
-0.0043847752,
0.0023545476,
-0.0701593831,
-0.0224351268,
-0.0180113893,
0.0048924666,
0.0052192514,
0.0393978991,
-0.0419118218,
-0.0700073242,
0.0621667653,
0.0128569547,
-0.0172030628,
0.0194359329,
-0.0277868249,
-0.01333501,
0.0304711983,
0.0247830953,
-0.0339844078,
-0.016988365,
-0.0054151816,
-0.0184979793,
0.0460006408,
0.0467625223,
-0.0135780005,
0.0042814775,
-0.0519536287,
-0.0194693841,
-0.017499838,
0.0014288743,
0.0122939982,
0.0181025639,
0.0030622445,
0.0313876905,
0.0029272109,
-0.0486356616,
0.0552676879,
-0.0126344562,
-0.037491709,
0.0328665562,
0.0093346462,
0.0404477604,
0.0313401408,
0.0106529295,
0.0139477216,
-0.0001810226,
-0.0382088982,
-0.0445569567,
-0.0140048377,
0.0150821367,
0.0029444378,
0.0398732238,
-0.0672315136,
-0.0136866551,
0.0390264206,
-0.0368055888,
-0.0258766301,
0.010610152,
-0.0547117032,
0.0207062624,
-0.009619697,
-0.0231341869,
0.0209389571,
-0.0426055901,
-0.0699746832,
0.0972309783,
0.0354899392,
0.0041110427,
-0.002209757,
-0.0074001066,
0.0338164829,
-0.0432836972,
0.0015099181,
0.008082022,
-0.0041875839,
0.0185341574,
0.0436081327,
0.068149209,
-0.0134594114,
-0.0015236805,
-0.0653239191,
0.0492566749,
0.0177773722,
0.0363124311,
0.0474965833,
-0.0323983505,
-0.0178656988,
0.0266346466,
-0.0326622464,
0.0384948999,
-0.0513014011,
-0.052293051,
0.0696328059,
0.0156354364,
0.010553509,
-0.0208791085,
-0.0081461854,
-0.0410821624,
0.0000325447,
0.0466210321,
-0.0404870249,
-0.0634621531,
0.0509900041,
-0.0241808817,
-0.0040693097,
0.0048981863,
0.0041141282,
-0.0417394377,
0.0023889574,
-0.0032995306,
0.0438391007,
0.0007941839,
0.064510718,
0.013004235,
-0.0077812509,
-0.062231604,
0.0444339588,
-0.055313468,
0.0226621423,
0.0128010707,
-0.057204105,
0.0610245727,
0.0621107779,
0.0091309249,
-0.0170111097,
-0.0410363898,
0.0654233247,
-0.0327724516,
-0.0061041736,
-0.0922680944,
0.0378276035,
0.0039424445,
0.0709519759,
0.0107099628,
-0.0466387458,
0.0736958534,
0.0033037879,
0.0110341907,
-0.0852073729,
-0.0192871895,
-0.0926077887,
0.0272026081,
0.0184610672,
0.0152437426,
-0.024081314,
0.0056685247,
-0.0252482817,
0.0167471413,
0.03952308,
0.0088209426,
0.0290407911,
-0.0291541778,
0.0110375956,
-0.0305246972,
-0.0504947603,
-0.009784637,
-0.0316127427,
-0.0108606908,
0.0016903898,
0.0747786164,
-0.0138886506,
-0.0336977057,
0.0317471549,
-0.019277472,
0.0283087883,
-0.0297904145,
-0.0008183381,
-0.030564731,
-0.0041738963,
0.0497658327,
-0.0040712692,
0.0183511749,
-0.0086587453,
-0.0289561134,
0.014794264,
-0.0032115448,
-0.0018579095,
-0.0333929323,
0.0489817336,
0.0185826253,
-0.0445709601,
-0.0098307254,
0.0053076525,
0.0110428371,
-0.0554309972,
0.020088464,
0.0911174193,
0.0495247543,
-0.0162119251,
0.0214128178,
-0.0229039397,
0.006183736,
0.0164281745,
0.0400022045,
-0.0493101627,
-0.0496307351,
-0.0133086871,
0.0463303849,
0.0207277108,
-0.044948943,
-0.0559603125,
-0.1042552292,
0.0224162359,
-0.0162834208,
-0.0425791889,
0.013201789,
-0.0453796536,
-0.0600649156,
-0.1098677292,
-0.0293462388,
-0.0374640189,
0.0128801782,
0.0101816757,
-0.0004698103,
-0.034772817,
-0.0252424553,
0.0102982949,
0.0007743045,
0.0142086064,
0.0525111146,
0.0326195993,
-0.035450723,
-0.0070080436,
0.0549433045,
0.0335080773,
-0.0304872487,
-0.0322347097,
0.0236120671,
-0.0199440867,
-0.0147720128,
-0.0182912871,
0.0458975807,
-0.0574881062,
-0.0155692706,
0.0690246895,
0.0546074994,
0.0203768369,
0.0072727208,
-0.00151735,
0.0072178263,
0.0305203348,
0.066748105,
-0.0048392755,
-0.0440576933,
-0.0372872315,
-0.0382962227,
-0.0005221826,
-0.0494093709,
-0.0203810036,
-0.0198226459,
-0.0144481407,
0.012564267,
-0.0469559915,
-0.0169008151,
0.0563991368,
0.0278100092,
0.0145044765,
-0.0258259606,
0.0332929716,
0.00997259,
-0.0737126023,
0.0462580211,
-0.0114569366,
0.0191675741,
-0.0310805347,
-0.0103523573,
0.0289884284,
-0.0045914296,
-0.0515018702,
0.0847770423,
-0.0757105276,
-0.0601972267,
-0.0488861874,
0.0551739298,
0.0292090494,
0.0224821344,
0.0074556908,
-0.0102499444,
-0.0046518343,
0.0311638992,
-0.0146367215,
-0.0404102169,
-0.0011172127,
0.0327206291,
-0.0098858466,
0.0085608969,
-0.015655566,
0.0338692777,
-0.0379216895,
0.0468790531,
-0.0016387323,
-0.0223613363,
0.0327728689,
0.0622166321,
-0.0084751863,
-0.0223016422,
-0.060188327,
-0.0248859469,
-0.0070217093,
-0.0310664997,
-0.0392771959,
-0.057626687,
-0.0050240359,
-0.004865197,
-0.0065389951,
0.0515726767,
0.0076807677,
0.01619252,
-0.0041840062,
0.0268327948,
0.015118164,
0.022183653,
-0.0069976333,
0.0035386265,
0.0062977187,
0.0241799336,
0.0280268565,
-0.0034114516,
0.0114954701,
-0.0174091384,
0.0110570788,
0.0541931689,
0.04396341,
-0.0340435617,
0.0203961879,
0.0326857381,
-0.0320485532,
-0.0471759215,
-0.026116861,
0.0168060921,
-0.0069886991,
0.0043211333,
-0.0704244077,
-0.0338796563,
0.0031709915,
0.0384662747,
-0.0100166015,
-0.0093775271,
0.0518379323,
0.0323075131,
-0.0290178843,
-0.054554522,
0.0603737794,
0.0372875817,
0.0130661121,
-0.0028166554,
-0.0136147374,
-0.0653219894,
-0.0003616472,
0.018116083,
0.0303654298,
-0.011083086,
0.0093799401,
-0.0611819029,
-0.0382643417,
-0.0332822911,
0.0064447462,
0.0181308929,
0.0233786553,
0.0829750821,
0.017480189,
-0.0181270149,
-0.021165181,
-0.0052711125,
0.0025189619,
-0.0468376018,
-0.0404346064,
-0.0111280559,
-7.066033194e-33,
-0.0220464189,
-0.0630589724,
0.0309349578,
0.0297687538,
-0.0133615034,
0.0240013339,
0.0018223929,
0.0076306718,
0.0168139767,
-0.0261646621,
0.0159001667,
-0.0336559005,
0.0078818453,
0.0128014907,
-0.0101519646,
0.003329403,
-0.0114397006,
-0.0335996337,
-0.0549427122,
-0.0334606059,
0.0080562606,
0.0068851742,
0.0648329258,
-0.0186043717,
0.0251482427,
0.0064074844,
-0.0144293038,
0.0421643183,
0.0254402887,
0.0367983915,
-0.0539679751,
0.0581278168,
0.0227073003,
-0.0632005185,
-0.0127294892,
-0.0071383105,
-0.0192913152,
-0.0662274212,
0.0270568877,
0.0011879727,
-0.078201361,
-0.024496438,
0.0428370908,
-0.0068964851,
-0.0631118268,
-0.0044682603,
0.0487766303,
-0.0044420636,
0.0045351554,
0.006638418,
-0.0584616922,
0.0264988765,
-0.0439319722,
0.0099405628,
0.0671845526,
0.010023159,
-0.0210736804,
-0.0025765807,
-0.0169485658,
0.0167630389,
0.0058581466,
0.0428310633,
0.0762147456,
0.0073743355,
-0.01031557,
0.0321199968,
0.0061022802,
-0.026025882,
-0.0419222079,
-0.0164438151,
0.014302535,
0.0325344987,
0.0475172289,
0.0212710276,
0.0439582393,
-0.0092993341,
-0.0518952087,
0.0244488232,
-0.0305242427,
0.0129364496,
0.0014449945,
0.0000059628,
0.0006968501,
-0.0278578624,
-0.0696324557,
-0.0128776263,
-0.0407465696,
-0.0198104065,
0.012552375,
-0.0074960999,
-0.0192900896,
0.021001121,
-0.0152219888,
-0.0395759977,
0.0266721714,
0.0113234883,
0.0038945428,
0.0001234544,
0.0261954181,
0.0288056768,
-0.0667489171,
-0.0468597636,
-0.0380069017,
0.0353966616,
0.0587702803,
-0.0180340987,
0.0123163704,
0.0089492109,
-0.0144632692,
0.0181626361,
-0.033517696,
0.0025809044,
-0.0040115742,
0.0518309176,
0.0336492546,
-0.0017313216,
-0.0044481959,
0.0369481295,
0.036911495,
-0.0227272864,
-0.0062232153,
0.0166743565,
0.0143578108,
-0.007674119,
0.0090220282,
0.0284668393,
0.0022173391,
0.0103751495,
0.0285485834,
-0.0085575236,
-0.0212970041,
-0.0205800738,
3.094e-7,
0.0770106465,
0.077964291,
0.0155279757,
0.0373390615,
-0.012600394,
0.028328253,
-0.01583042,
0.0062047113,
-0.0477660075,
-0.0036584099,
0.0358919092,
-0.0046548513,
0.058049947,
0.0260257721,
-0.0604801551,
0.0033406599,
-0.0097142793,
0.0069634877,
-0.0798256546,
0.0148898456,
0.1177496314,
0.0949459001,
0.0331312045,
0.001920438,
-0.0522172749,
-0.0075221187,
0.0248130504,
-0.0735988915,
0.0142274573,
0.0239076912,
0.0018056006,
-0.004283262,
-0.0215273984,
0.0180900395,
-0.0153470058,
0.023466479,
0.033666607,
0.1198306307,
0.0086056758,
-0.0377560891,
0.0379197337,
0.0061973664,
-0.0383181423,
-0.0484269112,
0.0403304882,
-0.0436955802,
-0.067448549,
-0.0118100531,
0.0207817461,
-0.0378518514,
0.0020811129,
-0.0500751324,
0.0207260903,
0.0048179463,
-0.0126379905,
-0.0185672082,
-0.0124467704,
-0.045335345,
0.0234339964,
0.0186557714,
-0.0250732061,
0.0091239074,
-0.0354543924,
0.0543108061,
0.0570583232,
-0.0390400738,
0.0147989867,
2.970363104e-34,
0.0229810346,
0.0107267918,
0.0192927346,
0.0097036427,
0.0376089402,
0.035268154,
-0.0450728834,
0.0247401688,
-0.0287512783,
-0.0609329194,
-0.0089387633
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.08179v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.08179v2 | MEDBERT.de: A Comprehensive German BERT Model for the Medical Domain | 2023-03-14T18:58:08 | 2023-03-24T23:05:31 | Keno K. Bressem, Jens-Michalis Papaioannou, Paul Grundmann, Florian Borchert, Lisa C. Adams, Leonhard Liu, Felix Busch, Lina Xu, Jan P. Loyen, Stefan M. Niehues, Moritz Augustin, Lennart Grosser, Marcus R. Makowski, Hugo JWL. Aerts, Alexander Löser | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper presents medBERTde, a pre-trained German BERT model specifically
designed for the German medical domain. The model has been trained on a large
corpus of 4.7 Million German medical documents and has been shown to achieve
new state-of-the-art performance on eight different medical benchmarks covering
a wide range of disciplines and medical document types. In addition to
evaluating the overall performance of the model, this paper also conducts a
more in-depth analysis of its capabilities. We investigate the impact of data
deduplication on the model's performance, as well as the potential benefits of
using more efficient tokenization methods. Our results indicate that
domain-specific models such as medBERTde are particularly useful for longer
texts, and that deduplication of training data does not necessarily lead to
improved performance. Furthermore, we found that efficient tokenization plays
only a minor role in improving model performance, and attribute most of the
improved performance to the large amount of training data. To encourage further
research, the pre-trained model weights and new benchmarks based on
radiological data are made publicly available for use by the scientific
community. | [
0.0310269222,
0.0417981744,
0.0168093704,
-0.0210113134,
-0.0220129527,
0.023648791,
0.0188736226,
0.0361193791,
-0.0264445953,
-0.0288633499,
-0.0090592345,
-0.0443483219,
0.0088995006,
-0.0058474224,
0.0357456021,
-0.0740975216,
0.0479795672,
0.0090373214,
0.0381748527,
-0.006656134,
0.0085793454,
-0.0214013588,
-0.0068115741,
0.0511928536,
-0.0159006976,
0.0218602605,
0.0439652801,
0.0254810695,
0.0146470796,
-0.0370253958,
-0.0037774304,
0.035086073,
-0.0278137811,
0.0445513055,
0.0000016024,
-0.0637618005,
-0.0537445992,
0.0376992561,
0.0124647655,
0.0006630324,
0.0285943132,
-0.05777926,
-0.0403682888,
0.0167972296,
0.0140168369,
-0.035575144,
0.0235516764,
0.0585760437,
0.0270191841,
0.065063335,
-0.0312951282,
-0.005745972,
0.0452000126,
-0.0090324003,
-0.0337778106,
-0.0083002616,
0.0468288139,
-0.0018309717,
0.0137065882,
-0.0092058321,
-0.0033970636,
0.0218764339,
-0.0351238176,
0.0329827182,
-0.0152596105,
0.0418005362,
-0.0636363551,
-0.015351424,
0.0343492627,
0.034415517,
-0.0185288582,
-0.0394056253,
0.0341355242,
0.0305768959,
-0.0033116012,
0.0209568553,
-0.0268204454,
-0.0040787249,
-0.031085819,
-0.0037166618,
0.0316772684,
-0.0188341681,
0.0157157239,
0.0042505381,
-0.0396623351,
-0.0235823467,
0.0341615826,
-0.0416365229,
0.0141547909,
0.0032534983,
-0.0534711443,
-0.0553504042,
0.0509831384,
0.0199386515,
-0.0026554281,
0.016369069,
-0.0611007437,
-0.0955412611,
0.0749567151,
-0.0319668911,
-0.0172488131,
0.007010397,
-0.0269653816,
0.0372055992,
-0.0383879803,
0.0344410352,
-0.0368232206,
0.0383373834,
-0.0229056086,
-0.0213747043,
-0.0454946086,
-0.0136956805,
-0.0711114109,
0.0460450016,
0.0393660478,
-0.0299883392,
-0.0757452995,
-0.0141956406,
0.0227148868,
0.011330761,
0.0189174172,
-0.0101401322,
-0.0279357079,
0.0193597563,
0.0230989978,
0.0189937837,
-0.0181513727,
-0.0091549344,
-0.0286908224,
-0.0207236335,
0.0261058044,
0.0144835692,
-0.0074750525,
-0.0163835548,
0.0200994648,
0.0182870161,
0.0179959275,
-0.0189783219,
0.0205118973,
-0.0277604107,
-0.0291194841,
0.00283723,
-0.0072333603,
-0.0652509704,
0.0137646776,
0.0285777859,
0.025394965,
-0.0268161055,
0.0060891956,
0.001922981,
-0.0657421201,
0.0673993751,
-0.0683613271,
0.005804528,
0.0353481174,
0.0052338601,
-0.0189687647,
-0.0036237785,
0.0253287479,
-0.0581982099,
0.0190758687,
0.0068169083,
0.0200188179,
0.0458534062,
0.0061376849,
-0.0458487906,
-0.031500373,
-0.0079440819,
-0.0065653119,
0.0448539369,
0.0014009717,
0.088485539,
-0.031127695,
-0.030422844,
-0.0073006637,
0.0797142088,
0.0473427363,
0.0169109181,
-0.0157669429,
-0.0398213752,
0.0461351499,
-0.0107062282,
0.0067436616,
-0.0553090163,
0.0393641368,
0.0388689227,
-0.0260406751,
-0.0215379167,
-0.0305309761,
0.0289904214,
-0.0282218158,
-0.0248434227,
-0.0238296539,
-0.045600947,
0.0420563668,
-0.0087317843,
-0.0424978025,
0.1187617257,
0.037915349,
-0.042240195,
-0.0192064904,
-0.0341036916,
-0.0449233539,
0.0659624711,
0.0904240012,
-0.0538459122,
-0.0738138035,
0.0037191955,
-0.003241274,
0.0256190971,
0.0338157974,
-0.0079579186,
0.0283266474,
-0.0391673818,
0.0016862788,
0.0425320826,
0.0296550114,
0.007564187,
-0.0077651623,
0.026003724,
-0.0211603101,
-0.071446754,
0.0031931731,
0.0481203459,
-0.0562396236,
0.0106578628,
-0.0327140205,
-0.0092468979,
0.0080958968,
0.0118705435,
-0.0540214628,
0.0411792658,
0.0230001193,
-0.0473685339,
-0.0027901239,
0.0318618417,
-0.0044605993,
-0.0238562413,
0.0349059924,
-0.0337846763,
-0.0029912207,
-0.0076248306,
-0.0100536672,
-0.0146783497,
-0.0544759817,
-0.0613367222,
0.0565035045,
-0.0127510326,
0.0690521747,
0.0032358943,
-0.0215031058,
-0.0364319868,
0.0234813821,
-0.0119047044,
0.0288407598,
0.0157223139,
-0.0431555472,
0.0661244914,
-0.0380776525,
-0.0540226698,
0.0049043875,
-0.0096608866,
0.0028507472,
-0.0067827459,
-0.0043583545,
0.00254536,
-0.0457629003,
-0.1047398895,
-0.0076229833,
-0.0027789653,
0.0223737583,
0.029972693,
0.0424020104,
-0.0106350463,
-0.0400842875,
-0.0130917784,
-0.0678642169,
0.0084321899,
0.0122854467,
0.049467966,
0.0286434442,
-0.0068387622,
-0.0347924493,
-0.0124164652,
-0.0499923006,
0.0446204245,
0.0112108653,
-0.0474172831,
-0.0077828513,
-0.0007770662,
-0.029346386,
0.0429913476,
0.0162427537,
-0.0408554971,
0.0158352386,
-0.0122568123,
0.0424713865,
0.017847633,
0.0073870765,
-0.0043362118,
-0.0098105995,
0.0218073428,
-0.0404602848,
-0.0093118241,
-0.0094768768,
0.0224418156,
0.0060587418,
-0.056947533,
0.0416851491,
0.0390690975,
-0.0317084976,
0.0170170199,
-0.0260119624,
-0.0378894992,
-0.0298118312,
0.0055336943,
-0.026648121,
-0.0146181732,
-0.0408309884,
0.0108286738,
0.0224278327,
0.0020720277,
0.0865435749,
-0.0304256342,
0.0273183249,
-0.0871608779,
0.0113132596,
-0.0202552341,
-0.0034238566,
-0.0105614252,
0.0252283495,
0.0284207314,
-0.0564153679,
0.0168849193,
0.0269390959,
0.0143233035,
-0.0589911304,
0.0159399752,
0.0188847613,
0.032689631,
0.0115985181,
-0.0527531952,
-0.0345810391,
-0.0384456329,
-0.0107467957,
0.0273517258,
0.0033616971,
0.0063414681,
-0.09098465,
0.0539903566,
-0.012264342,
0.0846086144,
0.0031350579,
-0.0009038214,
-0.0073531703,
0.0789985433,
0.0097343437,
-0.0391509533,
-0.0208205096,
-0.0310026407,
-0.0099782133,
0.0508417487,
0.0446977057,
0.0376141332,
-0.0250462759,
-0.0223974846,
0.0077113695,
-0.0784537047,
-0.0313626789,
-0.0277581345,
0.0124479225,
-0.0244087763,
-0.0054355231,
0.1367229819,
0.0375403501,
-0.0248799492,
-0.0086669726,
-0.011443438,
0.014526831,
-0.0441442505,
0.0199977588,
-0.0482291952,
-0.0204348974,
0.0214671884,
0.0303643476,
0.0052565318,
-0.0148313073,
0.0587317757,
-0.0480803549,
-0.011156925,
-0.0036536136,
-0.0239524134,
-0.0195749458,
-0.0556704812,
-0.0214620177,
-0.0095172571,
-0.0075836307,
0.0207616072,
-0.0190537795,
0.0011528339,
0.0389757529,
-0.0688007548,
-0.0799511448,
-0.0132975327,
-0.0768913999,
0.0246887878,
0.0484992154,
0.035491202,
-0.0508089624,
-0.0110604763,
0.0069378978,
0.004305555,
-0.0107415328,
-0.0038533781,
0.0891354978,
0.0009865924,
-0.0214471892,
-0.0483585186,
-0.0011730762,
0.0050479248,
-0.038022317,
-0.0183971878,
0.0336473957,
-0.0272842031,
0.0299196783,
-0.0511831418,
0.020799892,
-0.0180861093,
0.0600859188,
-0.0065060481,
-0.0197615921,
-0.0283944365,
-0.0021979446,
0.0510430112,
-0.0397329703,
0.0453921854,
0.014564435,
-0.0929623395,
-0.0476185493,
-0.0750484243,
-0.0100040538,
0.029474223,
0.0190842766,
0.0361650921,
0.0313991271,
0.0049785376,
0.0156665165,
-0.0832880735,
0.0680023655,
0.054769773,
-0.0011117602,
-0.0796094015,
-0.0369041152,
0.0628008246,
0.0383508764,
-0.0442402065,
-0.0164030511,
0.0092834672,
-0.0355015658,
0.0003175448,
0.0117368633,
0.0225499887,
0.0212205816,
-0.0188339762,
-0.045774892,
0.043604359,
0.0176909827,
-0.0275915228,
-0.0269107558,
0.0159229413,
-0.0422337353,
-0.0202697534,
-0.0115653183,
-0.0135238646,
0.0129484963,
-0.0005850693,
0.0373597071,
-0.0307539888,
0.0087612541,
0.013057041,
0.0437869392,
0.046460554,
-0.0175307095,
0.0001478259,
-0.0151777146,
0.0068750805,
-0.0034758484,
0.0371886641,
-0.0235407092,
0.0276412275,
0.0252991114,
-0.0087151052,
-0.0422454663,
0.0192110762,
-0.0744216889,
-0.0035975808,
-0.0240803193,
0.0585226454,
0.0019731331,
0.0161601603,
0.0351055488,
-0.0283944812,
-0.0010214709,
-0.0256703533,
0.0315584876,
-0.0024128992,
-0.0394138992,
0.0178365782,
0.0105509721,
0.0438495316,
0.0002825652,
0.0483718775,
-0.030177664,
0.0119267292,
-0.0377458446,
0.0391745307,
0.0298375208,
0.0170865674,
0.0759397894,
-0.0508552082,
-0.0120200589,
-0.0316315927,
0.0070464043,
-0.017383894,
0.0593658164,
0.0192248374,
0.0113965953,
0.0046787933,
-0.0213873442,
0.0966104865,
0.0297256261,
0.0378019288,
-0.0233860854,
-0.0694827139,
-0.043388024,
0.0093026366,
0.0563865006,
-0.0159215182,
-0.0616968162,
-0.0079271328,
-0.0330150239,
-0.0124927387,
0.0307547562,
-0.0040593655,
-0.0110076871,
0.0021366812,
0.0414085127,
0.0443667844,
0.0298036896,
-0.0002454367,
-0.0036544416,
0.0427929945,
0.0061839162,
-0.0509602129,
0.0271195062,
-4.82391731e-33,
0.0290549919,
0.0027995107,
0.0099144317,
-0.0430208594,
-0.0059723356,
0.0382783152,
-0.0264384057,
-0.0227536969,
-0.0048854062,
0.0355423763,
-0.0227664299,
-0.0152149685,
0.035718061,
0.0207433235,
-0.0028904644,
-0.00010855,
0.0349368043,
0.0240293406,
-0.0184222721,
-0.0023430034,
-0.0053984928,
0.0852566436,
0.045981925,
-0.0577728264,
-0.0318488628,
0.0063052904,
0.0316615924,
-0.0170953646,
0.0590170138,
0.0822168663,
-0.0123942047,
0.004262534,
0.0241946168,
-0.0004141732,
-0.010042252,
0.0290802903,
-0.1174818873,
0.0010609274,
0.0167890564,
0.0297603235,
-0.0007020052,
-0.0246022083,
0.0467655733,
-0.0281744692,
-0.0050476715,
0.0305961668,
0.0408595353,
-0.0204178877,
-0.0459852405,
-0.0427307449,
-0.0469720401,
0.0572935939,
0.0277120285,
0.0069809314,
0.0394598842,
0.0076365108,
-0.0267811678,
0.0511903428,
-0.0134569667,
-0.0037685274,
0.0639915466,
0.029898759,
-0.024715947,
-0.0649969131,
-0.0055868714,
0.0393908173,
0.0335346349,
0.0001121237,
0.0228443667,
-0.0148820877,
-0.0037966613,
0.0348995663,
0.0472221747,
-0.0192732904,
0.0438780189,
-0.0239953063,
-0.0608211644,
0.0469524264,
-0.0284015015,
0.0425079577,
0.0196675193,
-0.0236103795,
-0.0386569835,
0.0186355617,
0.0041725193,
0.0040498436,
0.0009322055,
-0.0096256277,
0.0285751689,
-0.0070515997,
-0.0007921218,
0.029000897,
0.0184395425,
-0.0077624074,
-0.0137661872,
-0.0359656923,
0.0409186371,
0.0439873151,
-0.0717137456,
0.0189029649,
-0.0222067591,
-0.0706577599,
0.0184191912,
-0.0040116333,
0.0315429717,
-0.0044804425,
0.0599244162,
-0.0326017626,
-0.0737495422,
0.011510402,
0.0440597609,
-0.0219939258,
-0.0316007845,
0.0552255623,
0.0340845101,
0.0232978426,
0.0448753349,
-0.0054620304,
0.022186704,
-0.0159311518,
-0.0331876129,
-0.0138694569,
0.0494926646,
0.0220647883,
-0.0309368744,
-0.0186358169,
-0.0228570625,
0.0450172238,
0.0283018555,
-0.0448002666,
-0.0125431539,
-0.0073023834,
2.299e-7,
0.1092538387,
0.0665738657,
0.0300913937,
-0.0443234704,
0.0307972711,
0.0017291121,
-0.0340369754,
0.0332913138,
-0.0035776207,
0.0599975735,
0.0251609143,
-0.0745353997,
0.0303712394,
0.0157184564,
-0.079321526,
-0.0455817915,
-0.0783191994,
-0.0238870047,
-0.0390314348,
0.0125647699,
0.0172906164,
0.0828667209,
-0.0295251831,
-0.035359934,
0.0057893754,
-0.0224692933,
0.0426832512,
-0.0228976384,
0.0067749512,
0.0508986339,
0.0477332212,
0.0279037263,
0.0330984034,
0.0511891842,
-0.0225770585,
-0.0173664037,
0.039036192,
0.07550098,
-0.0501210541,
-0.0011679581,
0.0547652245,
-0.0245944411,
0.0052349656,
-0.042051293,
0.0191035382,
-0.0291513,
-0.0146059133,
0.0027973575,
-0.0464980602,
0.0041013919,
0.0580773056,
-0.0116371764,
-0.0456536226,
0.0498080961,
0.0484648347,
0.016022725,
-0.0435528345,
-0.0686577633,
-0.0104363672,
0.0104677361,
-0.032300707,
-0.0330112167,
0.0209575091,
-0.0190427341,
0.0080477661,
-0.0774502158,
-0.0029891233,
2.3016898e-34,
0.0392796397,
-0.0082551418,
-0.0094709806,
0.0523311719,
-0.0183833372,
-0.0406500921,
0.0141862473,
0.017929662,
-0.020142857,
-0.0282291509,
-0.0094159618
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.08127v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.08127v3 | CB2: Collaborative Natural Language Interaction Research Platform | 2023-03-14T17:57:06 | 2023-05-30T00:45:39 | Jacob Sharf, Mustafa Omer Gul, Yoav Artzi | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.MA | CB2 is a multi-agent platform to study collaborative natural language
interaction in a grounded task-oriented scenario. It includes a 3D game
environment, a backend server designed to serve trained models to human agents,
and various tools and processes to enable scalable studies. We deploy CB2 at
https://cb2.ai as a system demonstration with a learned instruction following
model. | [
0.0823775157,
-0.0194326732,
-0.0338318907,
0.0442361832,
-0.034441296,
0.0107178316,
0.023640424,
-0.0154797146,
-0.0119294459,
-0.0254565161,
-0.0372635499,
-0.006079982,
0.0406127758,
0.0530471392,
-0.0117464988,
-0.0693983957,
0.0415495038,
0.0027822799,
-0.0000888853,
0.0391797461,
0.0253211427,
0.0194066204,
-0.0845347419,
0.0572481044,
-0.0065075872,
-0.0227912646,
-0.0555407256,
-0.0236327965,
-0.0103754112,
-0.0287964493,
0.0183180831,
0.0430981703,
0.062991485,
0.0057506617,
0.0000017101,
-0.02596342,
0.0132138832,
-0.0266780704,
-0.0190788191,
-0.0178221017,
0.0362090617,
0.0521505587,
-0.0119677475,
0.0141113019,
-0.0735142305,
0.0204087179,
0.0531583503,
0.0593317747,
0.087415494,
0.0111252023,
0.0185076036,
-0.0091295205,
-0.0447844937,
0.0092731668,
-0.0180609878,
-0.039236404,
0.0022866109,
0.0482745506,
0.0812405571,
0.0162230264,
0.0197011605,
0.0157128628,
0.0180886053,
-0.0279756784,
0.0086484458,
0.0512398668,
-0.0272403024,
-0.0481659472,
-0.0297210421,
0.0902231485,
0.0502859317,
0.0087831505,
-0.0024712663,
0.0269375313,
0.0147356065,
0.0037181871,
-0.0230681151,
-0.006773036,
-0.0176819935,
-0.0317957625,
-0.0291513931,
-0.0181086268,
-0.0329197906,
-0.0040073162,
0.0614052005,
0.0663388968,
-0.0404591672,
0.0141010564,
-0.0307853688,
0.0197222568,
-0.000324097,
-0.0430494063,
0.0168455821,
0.0089520216,
-0.0777648315,
0.0234139971,
-0.013636413,
0.0029848844,
-0.0064334869,
-0.0055699302,
0.0615034848,
0.0191472638,
0.0073214904,
0.0479727276,
0.0444564931,
0.0290251523,
0.0231890175,
-0.0113261398,
0.0170167144,
0.0117022041,
-0.0812752992,
-0.0119942799,
-0.0600732379,
0.0582671799,
-0.088508606,
-0.0535830855,
0.0244578812,
0.0265335627,
-0.0125026656,
0.0153145222,
0.0350526869,
0.0734342262,
-0.0388325229,
0.0409423858,
-0.038875252,
0.0392660648,
-0.0611595027,
0.0426205583,
0.0131955529,
-0.0944014117,
0.0085920934,
-0.0206112564,
0.0213615671,
-0.0130152004,
-0.0223294925,
0.0271107759,
-0.0185646191,
-0.0242663063,
0.0116920201,
-0.03917915,
-0.0007924332,
-0.0654533803,
-0.02814495,
-0.0551851057,
0.051045265,
-0.0210348573,
-0.0107455608,
-0.0179710276,
0.0171329714,
0.0137803489,
0.0020445052,
0.1008041352,
-0.0417807586,
-0.0304676834,
0.080581598,
0.0525472201,
-0.0290836301,
0.0299017411,
0.0422202572,
-0.0028430005,
0.0250850804,
-0.0015043166,
-0.0033016915,
0.011504028,
-0.0294743776,
-0.0350445062,
0.0414105132,
0.0167997386,
-0.0397606082,
0.0939644799,
-0.0378551595,
0.0296425987,
-0.0425151847,
-0.0158344619,
0.0610750578,
0.0938752219,
-0.0485853404,
0.0128680319,
0.0342207476,
0.0795336813,
0.0046721455,
-0.0201090593,
-0.0209138598,
0.0683702677,
0.0142865106,
-0.0268229917,
-0.0231316537,
0.022781115,
-0.0233676378,
-0.0570587441,
0.0306506753,
-0.0100808283,
0.0455324315,
-0.0382488854,
0.0162939634,
-0.0059933467,
-0.0324964561,
0.0127927773,
0.0101916166,
-0.0488260239,
-0.0025090338,
-0.0253381878,
0.0419919863,
0.0698789582,
0.0506795384,
-0.0243529473,
-0.0557091907,
-0.0082835434,
0.0340859368,
0.0447021611,
0.0193631724,
-0.0381421931,
0.0222509522,
-0.0282041226,
-0.0344409198,
-0.0027647042,
-0.0101115312,
0.0196641367,
0.0087756701,
-0.0154819321,
-0.0236099549,
0.0290937629,
0.0112113189,
0.0012090569,
-0.0148899332,
-0.0168552417,
-0.0598557889,
0.0145665053,
0.0248214416,
0.0297371149,
-0.0174444504,
-0.0219775252,
0.0409431048,
0.0124908555,
-0.0394967794,
0.0600632764,
0.0058599194,
-0.0485510156,
0.0182439722,
-0.0337188467,
-0.0089425091,
0.04936013,
-0.0061407182,
-0.0297907274,
0.0583612844,
-0.0203997809,
0.0328816734,
-0.0039994833,
-0.0050094132,
-0.0298430156,
-0.004328121,
-0.0104607809,
0.0063610268,
0.025720207,
-0.0111267548,
0.0224544145,
-0.0107362298,
-0.0204216987,
-0.0270733777,
0.0306586176,
0.0431181602,
0.0033171386,
-0.0005903239,
0.0125049902,
0.0148143703,
-0.0801390782,
0.0198880043,
-0.0575641543,
-0.0001174234,
-0.0159738716,
0.0113339499,
0.022213975,
-0.0047054952,
-0.0084641576,
-0.0491948128,
-0.0065229065,
0.0189265367,
0.0059653642,
0.0169761442,
0.0438360274,
0.0512763783,
-0.0019272903,
-0.0585973859,
0.0258619301,
-0.0113055874,
0.0164828226,
0.0473144874,
-0.0382000618,
-0.0482857749,
0.0194533449,
-0.047172755,
0.054106921,
-0.0130911814,
-0.0415375419,
0.0818055049,
-0.0108554801,
0.0170683246,
0.0631943271,
-0.0206741318,
0.0502125174,
0.0314647667,
-0.0348793864,
-0.0705291033,
0.0403324924,
-0.0087539395,
-0.0077054435,
-0.0567539223,
-0.0188880954,
0.0163437687,
0.0706732869,
0.0024236713,
0.0302002952,
-0.047586184,
0.0311684702,
0.0033251077,
-0.0262810718,
-0.0091761574,
-0.0471867882,
-0.056797836,
-0.0018942761,
-0.028051639,
0.0139015783,
0.0711834729,
-0.014993717,
-0.0532844439,
-0.0825012401,
-0.0002079867,
-0.0090790037,
0.0832577646,
-0.0120876534,
0.0011830758,
0.0178736299,
-0.0303618014,
-0.0130232936,
0.0017059565,
0.0261508431,
-0.0061492547,
-0.0474154577,
-0.1041839793,
-0.0031760007,
0.0198353082,
-0.0068306415,
0.0095512802,
0.0134066511,
-0.0804643109,
-0.0205271989,
0.0077894372,
-0.0226728134,
-0.0303718653,
-0.0074825585,
0.032474447,
0.0134770526,
0.0032604169,
-0.0238730833,
-0.0491370521,
-0.002822153,
0.0665657818,
0.0421861336,
-0.0206241701,
0.0052110665,
0.0390148424,
0.0967836604,
0.0254978538,
-0.0349470265,
-0.0182915106,
-0.0012082731,
0.0387345701,
-0.0295248441,
-0.0113932071,
0.023538271,
0.0207771026,
-0.0495415851,
-0.013514285,
0.0979790762,
0.031712357,
-0.0515375324,
-0.0148854312,
-0.0341923945,
0.0154773528,
0.0206652358,
-0.0099621238,
-0.0413730145,
-0.0525693372,
-0.0131703615,
-0.0082111843,
0.015426877,
-0.074090153,
-0.0024658488,
-0.1162910014,
0.0087002246,
-0.0319388136,
0.0063911257,
0.0094568944,
-0.0450086668,
0.0488138571,
-0.0041358243,
-0.0131886555,
-0.0093711009,
0.0277873352,
0.013711486,
0.0092166765,
-0.0093177948,
-0.0130984699,
0.0489097238,
-0.0626787245,
0.0861494914,
0.0247294046,
0.0448531806,
-0.0129605411,
-0.021635348,
-0.0122188376,
0.0341478363,
0.0316972546,
-0.0351286419,
0.0311825648,
-0.0005749051,
0.0192822777,
-0.0494611934,
0.0051040496,
-0.0208102893,
0.0122205345,
0.0348307937,
0.0764099658,
-0.0434550792,
-0.0150264967,
0.0022265939,
0.0583890639,
0.0691822618,
0.0391168334,
0.0139803002,
-0.0521633737,
-0.0110381218,
-0.0077207447,
-0.0118753463,
-0.0298583601,
-0.0495976098,
-0.0296977218,
-0.0003611789,
0.0346027203,
-0.0828018934,
-0.0594953299,
0.0614342242,
0.0106789758,
0.0058506476,
0.0273088254,
0.0245683901,
0.0336699076,
0.0297230445,
0.0411634371,
-0.0022306973,
0.0394472741,
-0.0428196192,
-0.0167302415,
0.0358103216,
-0.0265057534,
0.0077774981,
-0.0143030426,
-0.0480605327,
-0.0700908303,
-0.0017510037,
0.0544497147,
0.0223878063,
0.057708811,
0.0047287066,
-0.0347658284,
-0.0531208739,
-0.0193638224,
-0.0908399373,
0.0050946022,
-0.0232211389,
-0.0069917263,
-0.0010007019,
0.0109724086,
-0.0092131989,
-0.0096639162,
-0.0373024344,
0.0276427474,
-0.0832750276,
-0.0617565289,
-0.0038176975,
-0.0341185294,
0.0627208129,
0.0032069399,
-0.0259114467,
-0.018632656,
0.0324737579,
-0.0406803042,
0.0117996745,
-0.0540475622,
0.0193287227,
-0.0204880536,
-0.0197592489,
0.0506930389,
0.025880333,
-0.0340604559,
0.030871613,
0.0156689622,
0.0419987179,
0.0320674963,
0.004815035,
0.0183138084,
0.0391821302,
0.0057025589,
0.0160616152,
0.0066536344,
0.0635743365,
0.0182706006,
0.0844705105,
0.0091018863,
-0.0694602206,
0.0263800994,
0.0516918972,
-0.023992436,
-0.0191695355,
0.0370066613,
0.0275393333,
0.0195354559,
0.0423455164,
0.041592665,
-0.0297982637,
0.0247316584,
0.004874235,
0.028931288,
-0.0258587748,
-0.0701651499,
0.0227002874,
0.0151018649,
-0.0077356864,
0.0102551365,
0.0302578304,
0.0049239979,
0.038166821,
0.0014008287,
-0.0086701419,
-0.0332132541,
0.0043809689,
0.0007111574,
0.0377312303,
-0.0552029051,
0.0283689369,
-0.0115205944,
-0.0219939351,
-0.0337374583,
0.0429848619,
-0.0255539659,
-0.0678443983,
0.0581724979,
0.0244661998,
0.0093291765,
-0.0179530457,
-0.0318868309,
0.0415065363,
-0.0540983118,
-0.0198069271,
-0.0494270548,
-5.363018856e-33,
-0.041181948,
-0.0634285212,
0.0597162843,
0.0144818788,
-0.0019342436,
-0.0142854936,
-0.0387709066,
0.0281554218,
-0.0119788544,
-0.0168365873,
0.0149419662,
0.0329683349,
0.0096094571,
-0.0162993986,
-0.003622628,
-0.0123559982,
0.0103851166,
-0.0073443521,
-0.0085108774,
0.0331691727,
0.0368644372,
0.0114550889,
0.0286534429,
-0.0799731761,
0.0329319239,
0.0074059269,
0.0027865393,
0.0338056497,
-0.0129151102,
0.0470591523,
0.0048958254,
0.0236185826,
0.0068081925,
-0.0338246822,
0.007475053,
0.0466011986,
-0.0596727692,
-0.0357139781,
0.0074371658,
0.0367786773,
-0.0758200437,
0.0214352142,
-0.0327332877,
0.0055476334,
-0.0094044851,
0.0257315822,
0.0451743975,
0.0152197024,
-0.0233865418,
0.025538709,
-0.0561612397,
0.000555909,
-0.0531497076,
-0.0365206599,
-0.0033970743,
0.057728909,
0.0180835854,
-0.0558288172,
-0.0579645745,
0.0154460333,
-0.0410862081,
-0.0287824385,
0.0236337464,
-0.0041145515,
0.0174892973,
0.0484473109,
0.0124508739,
0.0055887555,
-0.064182058,
0.010760963,
0.0085578412,
0.0766618848,
0.044701606,
0.0642112345,
-0.0327832475,
-0.0020756337,
-0.005627586,
0.0430080369,
0.0640138909,
0.0609168746,
-0.0202563871,
0.0192962587,
-0.0394231901,
-0.0010381175,
-0.0344482549,
0.0333272256,
-0.0129979448,
-0.0466551222,
0.0320159495,
-0.0001888722,
-0.0109145641,
-0.0305586699,
0.0191504508,
-0.0075735529,
-0.0008958585,
0.0230852384,
-0.0038462707,
0.0310536418,
-0.0179563835,
-0.019665692,
-0.0425258242,
0.0045499322,
-0.0140658682,
-0.0198277049,
0.0391080156,
0.0264103394,
0.0069827479,
0.0206260942,
-0.0016866719,
-0.025263669,
-0.0355606638,
0.0461157747,
0.0374124013,
0.0357741155,
0.019041514,
-0.0191467144,
-0.0517421961,
0.0160082392,
0.0048961286,
-0.0101700714,
-0.0513040796,
-0.0124014057,
-0.0392214358,
-0.0172030833,
-0.0458959192,
0.0030363512,
-0.0672941282,
0.0262511037,
0.0357681774,
-0.0318131447,
-0.0266732667,
-0.0260772575,
2.485e-7,
-0.0288001597,
0.0538545474,
0.0040813289,
-0.0048941532,
0.0030993111,
0.0482902862,
-0.0136191538,
0.0523817539,
0.0199092608,
-0.0198361482,
0.0147313839,
0.0343310162,
0.0156191159,
0.0171375386,
-0.0994802043,
-0.0506361686,
-0.0135557996,
0.0254696347,
-0.0419965647,
0.0171891004,
0.0305493679,
0.0054307464,
0.0266229454,
0.022386292,
-0.0178555325,
-0.0095907198,
-0.0151608903,
-0.0380370468,
0.0151191251,
0.0136569096,
0.0120962728,
-0.0198728889,
-0.0189017337,
0.0029352522,
-0.0041677607,
0.0051624156,
-0.032599505,
0.0448911935,
-0.0397445187,
-0.0217826031,
-0.0027683908,
-0.0381828472,
-0.0110396007,
0.0025180934,
0.0551035106,
-0.0501353331,
-0.0259161927,
0.0102059059,
-0.0065803886,
-0.0460884608,
-0.0436778963,
-0.0101149827,
-0.034556821,
-0.030789068,
-0.0282823015,
-0.0426836424,
0.0194267184,
-0.0426645651,
0.0174272321,
-0.0064670523,
-0.0589751601,
-0.0385626815,
-0.0370843001,
-0.0395593345,
-0.0364481322,
-0.0127482982,
0.0060592773,
1.447290915e-34,
-0.034229096,
0.0178313311,
0.0462641791,
0.04538472,
0.0632954091,
0.0246879142,
-0.0120658558,
0.0104328627,
0.0507964827,
-0.0572543107,
-0.0334966779
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.08117v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.08117v2 | Do Transformers Parse while Predicting the Masked Word? | 2023-03-14T17:49:50 | 2023-10-16T03:27:53 | Haoyu Zhao, Abhishek Panigrahi, Rong Ge, Sanjeev Arora | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Pre-trained language models have been shown to encode linguistic structures,
e.g. dependency and constituency parse trees, in their embeddings while being
trained on unsupervised loss functions like masked language modeling. Some
doubts have been raised whether the models actually are doing parsing or only
some computation weakly correlated with it. We study questions: (a) Is it
possible to explicitly describe transformers with realistic embedding
dimension, number of heads, etc. that are capable of doing parsing -- or even
approximate parsing? (b) Why do pre-trained models capture parsing structure?
This paper takes a step toward answering these questions in the context of
generative modeling with PCFGs. We show that masked language models like BERT
or RoBERTa of moderate sizes can approximately execute the Inside-Outside
algorithm for the English PCFG [Marcus et al, 1993]. We also show that the
Inside-Outside algorithm is optimal for masked language modeling loss on the
PCFG-generated data. We also give a construction of transformers with $50$
layers, $15$ attention heads, and $1275$ dimensional embeddings in average such
that using its embeddings it is possible to do constituency parsing with
$>70\%$ F1 score on PTB dataset. We conduct probing experiments on models
pre-trained on PCFG-generated data to show that this not only allows recovery
of approximate parse tree, but also recovers marginal span probabilities
computed by the Inside-Outside algorithm, which suggests an implicit bias of
masked language modeling towards this algorithm. | [
-0.0039386991,
0.0698717609,
-0.0044531617,
0.0468135662,
-0.015919039,
0.0139474338,
0.0122826919,
-0.0130413277,
-0.0517060235,
-0.0473715067,
-0.0270863567,
-0.0340197869,
0.0036133009,
0.0134787066,
0.05700754,
-0.0620724,
0.0386301093,
-0.0007769107,
-0.0349073485,
0.0094359787,
0.0103211198,
-0.0184492804,
0.0146781066,
0.0491640903,
-0.0265671704,
-0.0126258908,
-0.0038621558,
-0.0280424207,
-0.0187581703,
0.0009177017,
0.0051018866,
0.0231142789,
-0.0017282197,
0.037694782,
0.0000018795,
-0.0352268703,
-0.0121585922,
0.0177524444,
-0.0213305186,
0.03231005,
0.0325998478,
-0.0228210334,
-0.0086683957,
0.005504129,
-0.0159738138,
-0.0576609224,
0.0515676104,
0.0561492406,
0.0451280251,
0.0806956962,
-0.0108787278,
-0.045023635,
0.0345852412,
-0.0417429581,
-0.0265197065,
-0.0027567607,
-0.0012899225,
-0.0665763915,
-0.0632636547,
-0.0150989462,
-0.0411694162,
0.00889639,
0.0218080338,
-0.0024537609,
-0.0111954929,
0.0556325242,
-0.0295229554,
-0.0198248774,
0.022926094,
0.0170279723,
-0.0590233169,
-0.0352219157,
0.0229722038,
0.0030437477,
-0.0238019396,
0.0038348895,
-0.0060996008,
0.0591665469,
0.0031798289,
0.0292207263,
0.0455039851,
0.0095198574,
0.0220013596,
-0.0323346555,
-0.0457008071,
0.0599285923,
0.0340515077,
-0.0363620371,
-0.0145227406,
0.0054169171,
-0.0481126197,
-0.0286629964,
0.0133567555,
-0.0486181714,
0.0345567912,
0.0314682201,
-0.0409712233,
-0.0557878129,
-0.0231958963,
-0.0184737854,
0.0334105045,
0.0429829136,
-0.0369939841,
0.0038928178,
-0.0322444774,
0.027401099,
-0.053716626,
0.0688299686,
-0.0552017987,
0.0128313545,
-0.0246415827,
-0.0434681773,
-0.0826353505,
0.0404549465,
-0.0399820022,
-0.0132491859,
-0.0103370417,
-0.0099827619,
-0.0131620076,
-0.0066038347,
0.024054924,
0.0127962716,
-0.0844013467,
0.0156515501,
0.0135482764,
0.0122989928,
0.0080382675,
-0.0252568517,
0.0082933595,
-0.0526014902,
-0.031843368,
0.0120948981,
0.0020363834,
-0.044097513,
-0.0135790519,
0.0357155837,
0.005376712,
-0.0232833568,
0.013799211,
-0.0047247461,
-0.037596494,
-0.0138369612,
0.0485472679,
-0.0302192774,
0.0029056182,
-0.0062340721,
0.010362925,
-0.0030994494,
-0.0040623113,
0.0422126725,
0.0032986253,
0.0840708017,
0.0649186671,
-0.0259042177,
0.0219885334,
0.0123442458,
-0.0000689088,
0.0295076054,
0.0096094208,
-0.0159901027,
0.0077256057,
-0.049636431,
0.0016437381,
0.0629865155,
0.0248392113,
-0.0260836799,
-0.0116512468,
-0.0304889791,
0.0398945808,
-0.0237669274,
0.0663979053,
0.0375959389,
-0.0352669768,
-0.0382256061,
0.007434201,
0.0285962988,
0.0194897149,
0.0512973294,
0.0621448904,
-0.0008500545,
0.0198856425,
0.0508214794,
-0.0170651767,
-0.0468173921,
-0.0081036286,
0.0068884427,
-0.0596586242,
0.0057467795,
-0.0298421159,
-0.0088085467,
0.0094286269,
-0.0245258529,
-0.0003760378,
-0.0439678058,
0.0773102269,
0.057817325,
-0.0548655428,
0.0833643824,
0.0201865118,
-0.0560395829,
0.0176043771,
-0.0395351797,
-0.0131481532,
-0.0355433561,
0.035107702,
-0.0116031729,
0.0099649215,
0.0179689415,
-0.0176847503,
0.0251083765,
-0.0015468166,
0.003864859,
0.0208418183,
-0.0036493626,
0.0106037119,
-0.0129671516,
0.03522861,
0.026893124,
-0.0289342199,
-0.0399824455,
0.0032505055,
-0.0200516488,
0.0295891557,
0.0686932355,
-0.0282538552,
-0.0231155884,
-0.0161749125,
-0.006829456,
0.0482430495,
0.0034684967,
-0.0360956267,
0.0588264018,
0.0313171633,
-0.0604012199,
-0.0163744036,
0.0203833058,
-0.0957709178,
-0.0774405003,
0.0117538823,
-0.0906941742,
0.0060550966,
0.055436451,
-0.0096492041,
-0.0235732887,
0.0142488992,
-0.0495050177,
0.0697022006,
-0.0462623686,
0.0245287307,
0.0057121068,
-0.0009653051,
-0.0481547676,
0.0676306784,
-0.0333011895,
0.0467365608,
0.001797367,
0.0262552593,
0.0410440154,
-0.0363025554,
-0.0432497896,
0.0181570202,
0.0009301256,
-0.0309246033,
-0.0036724212,
-0.0336292908,
-0.0380763002,
-0.0261197519,
-0.0730734095,
-0.0108221862,
-0.0124631245,
0.0348406918,
0.0453903973,
-0.0163302571,
0.0098337,
-0.0047129993,
-0.0088501349,
-0.0337497108,
-0.008123111,
0.0262223966,
0.0106579186,
0.0011195192,
-0.0231800992,
-0.0152117815,
-0.0364236273,
-0.0298125595,
0.0565452129,
-0.0232029893,
-0.0582287461,
-0.0504929945,
0.0565763414,
0.0229125805,
0.0435375869,
-0.0244309213,
-0.0668948144,
-0.0061274227,
-0.0315097831,
0.0438875556,
0.0550447702,
-0.0079465471,
0.0053968816,
0.0074700527,
-0.0062235277,
-0.0283802357,
-0.0158833899,
-0.0557127893,
-0.02699106,
-0.059273459,
-0.0057490231,
0.0199393462,
0.1089441925,
0.025711745,
-0.000551211,
-0.0312060006,
-0.0072593847,
-0.0469686985,
-0.0122892745,
0.0114691751,
-0.0314068608,
-0.0474611633,
0.0166728925,
-0.0333071798,
-0.0340459235,
0.0354958139,
-0.0540424548,
-0.032681305,
-0.0243302286,
0.015713267,
-0.0092537096,
0.0565898679,
0.0837119594,
0.0181827508,
0.0108305914,
-0.0623327978,
-0.0686345398,
0.0363437235,
0.0413129851,
-0.024974959,
-0.0043834406,
-0.0057788114,
-0.013472423,
-0.0123038879,
-0.0350234471,
-0.0450330786,
-0.0671132207,
0.0098645808,
0.0139208902,
0.0447986908,
0.0006089773,
0.0017122286,
0.0096001793,
0.0034622801,
0.0568818599,
0.0280428436,
0.0023241264,
-0.0163284969,
0.0434078686,
0.0257965904,
-0.0035636744,
0.0221546721,
-0.0302083138,
0.0193066038,
0.0349234268,
0.0435678102,
0.0259903986,
-0.0167484693,
0.0202223063,
0.0168057792,
-0.0080742203,
-0.0453155264,
-0.0087832324,
0.0016081906,
-0.0405108593,
-0.0345683582,
0.1080388948,
0.032858815,
-0.0324246809,
0.0186699461,
-0.01929098,
0.011063288,
0.0241158232,
0.0102495216,
-0.0714056417,
0.0197961219,
0.0309833754,
0.0192753077,
0.0090696244,
-0.0244661085,
0.024776211,
-0.1741312593,
0.0411061794,
0.0045688408,
0.026051987,
-0.0069993129,
0.0002618043,
-0.0320839286,
-0.0177440494,
-0.004801638,
-0.0068231993,
0.0013001822,
0.0070623481,
0.050492119,
-0.0555402115,
-0.0250478089,
-0.0064317342,
-0.0380839817,
0.0071822568,
0.081550397,
-0.009448153,
-0.0278939232,
-0.0561387092,
0.0342169479,
-0.0570781305,
-0.0105238389,
-0.0030018042,
0.0654111877,
-0.0008872152,
-0.0273167286,
0.0121680042,
0.0324709192,
-0.0068042357,
0.0008825301,
-0.0296835639,
0.0552317649,
-0.0119356373,
-0.0262024142,
0.0289966371,
-0.0062540602,
-0.0205080658,
0.0802900717,
0.0452704206,
-0.0312293265,
-0.0387178585,
-0.0359768793,
0.0447724611,
-0.0264233407,
-0.0336924531,
0.0532672405,
0.0195768625,
-0.0470604673,
-0.0836612657,
-0.0173126012,
0.0473936796,
0.0697568581,
-0.024720097,
-0.0232309401,
0.0152081056,
-0.0172688477,
-0.0210601445,
0.0405153595,
-0.0129160639,
-0.0154396733,
-0.0424863361,
-0.0262691025,
0.0259858295,
-0.0041313227,
-0.0541872941,
-0.0309026539,
-0.0480279066,
-0.0402941667,
0.0865658447,
0.0628889576,
0.0202485621,
0.0193507839,
-0.0245072972,
-0.055374939,
0.0356744267,
0.0191268139,
-0.0433922149,
0.0349765755,
0.0537976362,
-0.0296362732,
0.0101095801,
0.0189477,
0.0016260613,
0.0115486495,
0.0148606002,
0.0259330962,
-0.0030584852,
-0.0037990971,
0.0565140992,
0.0320297182,
0.1032198966,
-0.0341380648,
0.0367269814,
-0.0254019778,
0.009359464,
-0.038749285,
-0.0274624843,
-0.0568575151,
-0.0215341896,
0.0425476506,
0.0160984788,
0.0117101138,
0.0554024167,
-0.012943102,
0.0508143976,
-0.0159431286,
0.0216179024,
0.0248751957,
0.0037169727,
0.0071788761,
0.0442464128,
0.0142955426,
-0.0356357135,
-0.0008356068,
0.0133300917,
-0.0100668455,
0.0283004809,
0.0231766477,
0.0229895376,
-0.0430430658,
-0.0132966768,
-0.0636697486,
0.0098565724,
-0.0226153005,
-0.0338227004,
0.036240872,
-0.0512463711,
0.04524827,
-0.0320489258,
-0.0304342341,
0.0045470842,
0.0170036219,
0.0242207944,
-0.0333282351,
0.0710036829,
-0.017469231,
-0.0241828952,
-0.0408326723,
0.0971375927,
0.0510710143,
0.049589891,
-0.0126290265,
0.0082809394,
-0.0360559709,
-0.0206580702,
-0.0020504559,
0.0445450358,
-0.0019814668,
-0.0004948345,
-0.0401161164,
-0.0629816651,
-0.0015765018,
-0.0209050905,
0.0032807873,
-0.034491282,
0.0385055318,
-0.0000674929,
-0.0115910787,
-0.026945306,
-0.0079047494,
0.0545209944,
0.0373392664,
-0.0083050588,
-0.0251996815,
-5.814583541e-33,
-0.0533292592,
-0.0147260185,
-0.0150679396,
0.0233139452,
-0.0193693712,
0.0185748152,
-0.044465974,
0.0185953062,
0.0176048074,
0.0195975956,
-0.0115776155,
0.0006658511,
0.0094918823,
0.0642349124,
0.0099163698,
-0.0273824707,
0.0584944375,
-0.0557373092,
0.0108612385,
-0.0106729101,
0.0095114941,
0.048432257,
0.0606307276,
-0.0123324869,
-0.0135256462,
-0.0239417478,
-0.0346655771,
0.0205585733,
-0.0144606568,
0.0769000351,
-0.0250288844,
-0.0020917235,
0.0076351231,
-0.0287988894,
-0.0414390862,
0.0396891385,
-0.0995409116,
0.0008579705,
0.0078781061,
0.0258602817,
-0.0347168893,
-0.0080386475,
0.0321711935,
0.0000820367,
-0.0010943627,
0.0041655535,
0.0046037203,
-0.0228640996,
0.0017336435,
-0.0175721701,
-0.0168868024,
0.0030674285,
0.0042949161,
0.0234700199,
0.0687655658,
0.0314251259,
0.0119732423,
0.0629621893,
-0.0615703724,
-0.020425871,
-0.0349358171,
0.0534439608,
0.0542053245,
0.0429398045,
0.0277475324,
0.042263519,
0.0566926636,
-0.0118977008,
-0.0557513013,
-0.0141400397,
0.0478883274,
0.0211749803,
0.050368011,
0.0090776961,
0.0610315576,
0.0276243743,
-0.046684619,
-0.0059328512,
-0.0160650034,
0.0133617176,
0.0250408798,
0.0170665253,
-0.0277673006,
-0.0462714583,
-0.0447418056,
-0.0413939692,
-0.0086261304,
0.0198537223,
0.0351640992,
0.0177980512,
0.0000375051,
0.0263009779,
0.0306771304,
-0.0464391075,
0.0202542823,
-0.0027097531,
0.0000403371,
0.0479115993,
-0.0115723507,
0.0250533614,
-0.0642897189,
-0.0328201763,
-0.0101576084,
0.020011954,
0.0071093822,
0.0062256921,
0.0697363168,
0.0096748648,
-0.0825341791,
-0.0062481444,
-0.0543320403,
-0.0065008122,
0.0046121106,
0.0922772288,
0.0527482331,
-0.0022735239,
-0.0212766286,
-0.0064837686,
0.037669912,
0.0326464474,
-0.0114668328,
0.0500174202,
0.0054921354,
0.0110684084,
0.008693967,
-0.0179819241,
-0.0009956158,
0.0358591788,
0.0837454274,
-0.0347338356,
-0.0209287629,
-0.0040296167,
2.553e-7,
0.0924085155,
0.0124143129,
0.0423990227,
0.0000537285,
0.0397184119,
0.0291176848,
0.0003389876,
0.0412796512,
-0.0196646638,
-0.0134844445,
-0.0063691335,
-0.047234755,
0.0407733284,
0.017404519,
-0.0761666,
0.0226181857,
-0.045041088,
0.0212833639,
-0.015773071,
0.0115965437,
0.0085218102,
0.1224855334,
-0.0122603243,
0.0137438886,
0.0005663231,
-0.012188388,
0.0649032369,
-0.0260208771,
-0.0090847611,
-0.0055545252,
0.0115353791,
0.0335640498,
0.0033753577,
0.019253647,
-0.0412487425,
0.0449322537,
0.055103939,
0.0546185486,
0.01650667,
-0.0004523453,
0.0106271533,
-0.008019642,
-0.0218421128,
-0.0380237326,
0.0294490661,
-0.076763846,
-0.011375254,
-0.0200551003,
-0.052443549,
0.026703706,
-0.0231185239,
-0.0083363103,
-0.0139436694,
0.0080299303,
0.03076596,
-0.0247278921,
-0.0095404396,
-0.0597921759,
-0.0557290874,
0.0252478868,
-0.0660823733,
-0.0404903106,
-0.0283035152,
0.0147275971,
0.0434856899,
-0.0357737653,
-0.009146994,
2.860271859e-34,
0.015370057,
-0.007539168,
0.0169714801,
-0.0017367561,
0.03629205,
-0.0285669696,
0.0511433408,
0.0083041964,
0.0025394219,
-0.0857206732,
-0.011306949
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.08114v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.08114v1 | Simfluence: Modeling the Influence of Individual Training Examples by Simulating Training Runs | 2023-03-14T17:47:25 | 2023-03-14T17:47:25 | Kelvin Guu, Albert Webson, Ellie Pavlick, Lucas Dixon, Ian Tenney, Tolga Bolukbasi | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Training data attribution (TDA) methods offer to trace a model's prediction
on any given example back to specific influential training examples. Existing
approaches do so by assigning a scalar influence score to each training
example, under a simplifying assumption that influence is additive. But in
reality, we observe that training examples interact in highly non-additive ways
due to factors such as inter-example redundancy, training order, and curriculum
learning effects.
To study such interactions, we propose Simfluence, a new paradigm for TDA
where the goal is not to produce a single influence score per example, but
instead a training run simulator: the user asks, ``If my model had trained on
example $z_1$, then $z_2$, ..., then $z_n$, how would it behave on
$z_{test}$?''; the simulator should then output a simulated training run, which
is a time series predicting the loss on $z_{test}$ at every step of the
simulated run. This enables users to answer counterfactual questions about what
their model would have learned under different training curricula, and to
directly see where in training that learning would occur.
We present a simulator, Simfluence-Linear, that captures non-additive
interactions and is often able to predict the spiky trajectory of individual
example losses with surprising fidelity. Furthermore, we show that existing TDA
methods such as TracIn and influence functions can be viewed as special cases
of Simfluence-Linear. This enables us to directly compare methods in terms of
their simulation accuracy, subsuming several prior TDA approaches to
evaluation. In experiments on large language model (LLM) fine-tuning, we show
that our method predicts loss trajectories with much higher accuracy than
existing TDA methods (doubling Spearman's correlation and reducing mean-squared
error by 75%) across several tasks, models, and training methods. | [
-0.0049743527,
0.0284213554,
-0.0456302278,
0.0479514375,
0.0010604601,
0.0263216216,
0.0437681302,
0.0034250473,
-0.0804523304,
-0.0365081728,
-0.0226388779,
-0.0076325582,
-0.0014991873,
-0.0110598207,
0.0690359697,
-0.0753551051,
0.0241137259,
-0.0339145102,
-0.0499515533,
-0.0000245449,
0.0124541037,
-0.0127298692,
-0.0045309276,
0.0628731847,
0.0145299742,
-0.017037509,
0.0007807952,
-0.0004030853,
0.0426770374,
-0.0163233522,
0.0157720018,
0.0351900496,
0.0354098566,
0.0071417126,
0.0000024609,
-0.0297769438,
-0.0232999828,
0.0180791691,
-0.0472199507,
0.0495533273,
0.0454797745,
0.0682708994,
0.014927662,
0.0270843301,
-0.0333580263,
0.023022702,
0.0419020653,
-0.0131141981,
0.0446902178,
0.0299919415,
0.0038409277,
-0.0297699366,
-0.0240998678,
-0.0193857476,
0.0465999544,
0.0087320153,
0.0125690084,
0.0254230648,
-0.0563962385,
-0.0178290829,
-0.0333171226,
0.0219787806,
0.0212769527,
0.0067933272,
0.0361085869,
0.016236417,
-0.0176070798,
0.0248702504,
-0.0015801266,
0.0608046912,
-0.0077551459,
-0.0327581204,
-0.0074258107,
-0.0293474905,
0.0301668327,
0.036912486,
-0.0475535654,
-0.0189953875,
0.0293555427,
0.0032711201,
0.032235533,
0.0098624919,
0.0240486544,
0.0240905974,
-0.0118465517,
-0.0175391044,
0.0075980788,
-0.0391893275,
-0.0032717255,
0.0349732451,
0.0002741549,
-0.0006930141,
-0.0026131067,
-0.0106829479,
0.0183256585,
0.0243636277,
-0.0149040697,
-0.033375252,
0.0114276977,
-0.03429031,
0.1014134511,
0.0334969163,
-0.0207550861,
-0.0010642981,
-0.0416460298,
0.0437088087,
-0.0155166769,
0.0269734971,
-0.0215969849,
0.0436282419,
-0.0800570399,
0.0051669073,
-0.0166052729,
0.0070956498,
0.0126523329,
0.0176571775,
-0.0509350188,
0.0004686779,
-0.0688906088,
-0.0218170341,
-0.0078482367,
0.0288861245,
-0.0400211774,
0.0412046015,
-0.0130872624,
0.0280367211,
-0.037651822,
0.034318272,
-0.0024095648,
-0.0534267463,
0.0028527381,
0.0268596336,
-0.0426971167,
-0.0150747355,
0.0381117612,
0.0703011826,
0.0096384985,
-0.0185703486,
-0.0303479899,
-0.0547382012,
0.0245185755,
-0.0456418954,
0.0121245049,
-0.071520932,
-0.0196207855,
0.0161940176,
0.015700141,
-0.007814425,
-0.0289206095,
-0.0097088758,
-0.0243341457,
0.0460758954,
0.0526818372,
0.014909924,
0.0180173554,
-0.0001408258,
-0.0186337102,
0.0484028794,
0.0351822861,
-0.0042462288,
0.0019701656,
-0.0143538313,
0.0114582246,
0.0524312146,
0.0636171699,
0.0338113494,
-0.065529041,
-0.0062571005,
-0.0057307063,
-0.0020022469,
0.0354676805,
-0.0201488491,
-0.0502512753,
0.0313628018,
0.0555993319,
0.0183207318,
0.0337368958,
0.0255411901,
0.0466515161,
-0.0290161781,
0.0308206473,
0.0241948683,
-0.0602741428,
0.0142439026,
0.0055879126,
0.0086609088,
-0.0011951091,
0.0320285298,
-0.0205708332,
-0.0559118167,
0.0149764642,
0.0225159489,
0.0000178444,
0.0398104303,
0.0318885632,
0.0085517364,
-0.0141472546,
0.0450389124,
0.0338299051,
-0.0215987843,
0.0183293819,
-0.0638094172,
-0.0193934236,
0.0628703237,
0.0343944915,
-0.0306286439,
-0.008345373,
-0.0265332274,
0.032688614,
-0.0026837338,
0.0716863275,
-0.0263794102,
0.0045175119,
-0.0473561101,
-0.0367517993,
-0.0019766658,
0.0297718234,
0.0463742614,
0.0116401669,
-0.0002345976,
-0.0091190087,
-0.0118748145,
-0.0694579706,
0.0384211577,
-0.0314140767,
-0.0479994938,
-0.0222240072,
-0.0128782,
0.0258856583,
-0.0013543043,
-0.0286150966,
-0.0223809686,
-0.0026111098,
0.0068370299,
-0.0100844037,
-0.000607583,
-0.0434112437,
-0.0175584629,
0.0233909655,
-0.040441595,
-0.0295780301,
0.0511953495,
-0.0675287098,
-0.0413690992,
0.0235817749,
-0.0240115747,
0.0573074631,
-0.0013942665,
0.0229127035,
-0.0469607897,
0.0022124844,
-0.0415146574,
0.0246292036,
-0.0030942049,
0.0186090618,
0.0251034312,
0.0101185935,
-0.0002081099,
-0.0081829196,
-0.0149093987,
-0.0322793387,
-0.0104352999,
0.0267122965,
0.0051539741,
-0.0320497379,
-0.0446720757,
0.0162776448,
-0.033334896,
-0.0202777702,
-0.0179680325,
0.0580092035,
0.02711403,
-0.0090412674,
-0.0082385205,
-0.0218317527,
-0.0294584241,
-0.0364506692,
-0.0479136668,
0.0061413702,
0.0139865829,
0.0152553683,
-0.0161400642,
-0.0466858223,
-0.0134681035,
-0.0446607918,
0.0586553738,
0.0153479092,
0.0196039863,
-0.0748069435,
-0.0024402037,
-0.0183106232,
0.0046944991,
-0.000451089,
-0.0547268391,
0.0055366759,
0.0246421918,
0.0238334611,
0.083380118,
-0.0188927799,
0.0336243361,
0.0573955067,
0.0223297626,
-0.0998655707,
-0.008916582,
-0.0374735929,
-0.0328028612,
-0.0477395803,
-0.0713195726,
-0.0602669083,
0.0586683042,
0.0279347636,
0.000899856,
-0.0352878496,
0.0074020368,
-0.0306262709,
-0.0104093617,
-0.0187398326,
-0.0015046023,
-0.0245380998,
-0.0046571116,
-0.003068971,
-0.0726651922,
0.050623931,
0.0001242786,
0.0228465255,
-0.0344972424,
-0.0013587385,
-0.022534892,
0.0273344424,
-0.0161400251,
-0.002856096,
0.0100052916,
0.0104463091,
-0.0753060132,
-0.0028157921,
0.0790379494,
-0.0334772952,
0.0376664102,
-0.0511088781,
-0.0372482687,
0.014644145,
0.0252419114,
0.0064791804,
-0.006972691,
0.0259849392,
0.0046021049,
0.0347997285,
-0.029276913,
-0.0132356258,
-0.0652193576,
0.010376147,
0.031138381,
-0.033285208,
-0.0290101711,
0.0290916301,
0.0139653469,
0.0317893513,
-0.0077007152,
0.0168851502,
-0.0939979553,
0.0044386787,
0.013930575,
0.0762525126,
0.0072384188,
-0.0595447421,
-0.0027051289,
-0.0051844562,
-0.0326229222,
0.0188034158,
0.0459243171,
0.0344450809,
-0.0850694254,
-0.0182929635,
0.0662250891,
0.015606137,
-0.0437600687,
0.0109254895,
-0.0048934915,
0.068943955,
0.0355286375,
0.0262718033,
-0.072342515,
-0.0095589422,
-0.0230350122,
0.0579242855,
-0.0210995469,
-0.0117207486,
0.0423166417,
-0.0978636816,
0.0149376523,
0.0020858629,
-0.013565626,
0.034043204,
-0.039383579,
-0.0020652304,
-0.0593124218,
-0.0075875833,
-0.0509232506,
-0.0184166171,
0.0308704171,
0.0724882782,
0.008151615,
-0.0637723729,
0.0438347235,
-0.0148208234,
0.0478566736,
0.0517777763,
0.0052357586,
-0.0293938443,
-0.0100522181,
0.0219933614,
0.0101799481,
0.024367867,
0.008753147,
0.0997613445,
0.0097068306,
0.0110087469,
0.0076614614,
0.042645935,
0.0092878276,
0.0309699252,
0.0398674011,
0.0784487352,
0.0093465736,
-0.0094491383,
-0.041172903,
-0.0545865558,
0.0463129357,
0.0742478892,
0.0561012551,
-0.0625343844,
-0.0245570354,
-0.0142021785,
0.0026041917,
-0.0002075342,
-0.0491108857,
0.0151181091,
-0.0001465634,
-0.0258674193,
-0.0377011374,
-0.0240113214,
-0.0211255364,
0.0437857881,
0.0179384537,
0.0201806631,
-0.0291846506,
-0.0276260078,
-0.0201657917,
0.066674225,
-0.0195862353,
0.0387879647,
-0.0243713297,
-0.01265998,
0.0353912264,
-0.0038354383,
-0.0358080268,
0.0184859335,
-0.1268983036,
-0.0647498965,
0.0166622829,
0.0782547519,
0.0257605314,
0.0790310353,
0.0292814188,
-0.0377772041,
0.0702367052,
0.0126230484,
-0.0323602706,
0.0142682604,
0.0699365884,
-0.0693408847,
-0.0047422862,
0.0012425008,
-0.0277124643,
0.03436343,
0.0281715598,
-0.002123768,
-0.0338673629,
0.0313156247,
-0.0060510249,
-0.041248709,
0.0532729551,
-0.0134764509,
-0.0552186407,
-0.0210977346,
0.0434823111,
0.0059363577,
0.0009394733,
-0.0399676375,
-0.0336902514,
0.0299551897,
0.0264650416,
0.0100891497,
-0.0437903777,
0.0023561309,
0.004140636,
-0.0521634929,
0.0644448772,
-0.0177027434,
0.0501384474,
0.0201643463,
0.0337281302,
0.0012148925,
0.0010512975,
-0.0152213154,
0.0287243668,
0.0094908923,
0.0546015911,
0.0231814329,
0.0244520977,
0.0315017924,
-0.0045051863,
-0.0676089078,
-0.0140860965,
-0.0506357625,
-0.0175620783,
0.0112891356,
-0.0441768095,
0.0448619761,
-0.0200889651,
0.0021700396,
0.0220367797,
0.0047658077,
-0.053666506,
-0.0095704198,
-0.0115518924,
0.0234230664,
0.0119601525,
0.0321243331,
0.0426824838,
0.033676438,
0.0604781769,
-0.048351068,
-0.0181697607,
-0.0069809179,
-0.0285511576,
0.0579819642,
0.0415683649,
-0.0107926223,
-0.0354402326,
-0.0777371228,
-0.0766132101,
-0.0099452771,
0.0148860207,
0.0296061747,
-0.0159467664,
0.0553016253,
0.0355817713,
-0.075755991,
0.0260869581,
-0.0166631676,
-0.0196904354,
0.0029184888,
-0.0205580685,
-0.0214374736,
-6.565077909e-33,
-0.0013721425,
-0.0088837044,
0.0005958953,
0.028723726,
-0.0088384263,
0.0347636342,
-0.0372959189,
0.0047024703,
-0.0348952711,
0.0199877005,
0.0011548747,
0.0065025119,
0.0091763418,
0.0084856153,
0.0522613376,
-0.0076934528,
0.0613950416,
-0.0064339102,
-0.0111317756,
0.0353404768,
0.0095453253,
0.0207468141,
0.0614349321,
-0.1026654169,
0.0382559001,
-0.0287105795,
-0.0173497703,
-0.032812003,
-0.0549186915,
0.0880242065,
-0.0205247682,
0.0469274335,
-0.0005947035,
-0.128584668,
-0.029660197,
-0.0485813059,
-0.0641753823,
-0.0591462813,
-0.0065683695,
-0.0100410357,
0.0007784675,
0.0118809734,
0.0474435613,
0.025001945,
-0.0165328179,
-0.0412250869,
0.0601029918,
-0.0301775169,
-0.0059575508,
-0.0235898755,
-0.0625993907,
0.0219328199,
-0.0220622141,
-0.0109645752,
0.0370567441,
0.0087594828,
0.0016240068,
-0.0038825278,
-0.0324274041,
-0.0014671125,
0.0395127535,
0.0266344342,
0.0763434544,
0.0432118773,
0.0026940266,
0.0253793709,
0.0141052324,
0.0202565696,
0.0143751726,
-0.0623062365,
0.063847363,
0.0194832105,
0.0501612388,
0.0709889159,
0.0484184586,
0.0042277682,
-0.0520290956,
0.0137052573,
0.0312006865,
0.0082747545,
0.0010360045,
0.0079992581,
-0.0502587818,
-0.0119111286,
-0.0639510676,
-0.0112309419,
-0.0061465297,
-0.0463659093,
0.0378894098,
-0.0111201508,
-0.0308531485,
0.0345749408,
0.0233264938,
-0.0575542822,
-0.0483335778,
0.009101293,
-0.0280140936,
0.0555419959,
-0.0018728871,
-0.0207241997,
-0.0610268302,
-0.0479625687,
-0.0113878995,
-0.0059116278,
0.0740417689,
0.0065354132,
0.0937850028,
0.0282343198,
-0.0588459186,
-0.0050094975,
-0.0240389574,
-0.0365214944,
0.0374455899,
-0.0120662507,
0.0239018779,
0.0069738249,
-0.017672237,
0.0279916618,
0.04302435,
-0.0082372166,
-0.0452436768,
-0.0390777439,
-0.038141191,
0.0197617263,
-0.0482932068,
-0.0290037096,
-0.0335464887,
0.0103189256,
0.0622165762,
-0.0426780768,
-0.041033227,
0.0019372125,
2.989e-7,
0.0354454108,
0.0466651656,
-0.0092949495,
0.0100527052,
-0.003628483,
0.032767918,
-0.0142203672,
0.0114554539,
0.0166158937,
-0.0215690713,
0.015448547,
0.020295158,
0.0491379499,
0.0190782174,
-0.042819988,
-0.0244050156,
-0.0587667488,
0.0261050556,
-0.0514464527,
-0.0085387398,
-0.0060323984,
0.0688949823,
0.098467052,
-0.0087807858,
-0.0209901948,
0.0282496288,
0.0212906748,
-0.0414173603,
0.0179753862,
0.0269804187,
0.0136859994,
0.0244466551,
-0.0356642455,
0.0351903252,
-0.0547030978,
0.01985614,
-0.0161579493,
0.0317274742,
-0.0079703238,
0.0211064629,
-0.0143918479,
-0.0350108109,
0.0067337761,
-0.0754229203,
-0.003673333,
-0.0625023022,
0.0106426599,
-0.0217590835,
-0.0308393687,
-0.0004264731,
0.0426881239,
-0.0056541092,
0.0408508144,
0.0288932752,
-0.0313586593,
0.0046484955,
-0.0403868742,
-0.0709287077,
-0.0396132618,
0.0055578067,
-0.0072933855,
-0.0448140912,
-0.0575350262,
-0.0221969467,
0.0073460308,
-0.0656428337,
-0.0051660063,
3.001015726e-34,
0.0365194827,
-0.002856452,
0.0455148146,
0.0463609025,
0.0235035177,
0.0000681275,
0.047257632,
0.0262401812,
0.0455466472,
-0.0297245663,
-0.0248943008
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.09455v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.09455v1 | Learning Cross-lingual Visual Speech Representations | 2023-03-14T17:05:08 | 2023-03-14T17:05:08 | Andreas Zinonos, Alexandros Haliassos, Pingchuan Ma, Stavros Petridis, Maja Pantic | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | Cross-lingual self-supervised learning has been a growing research topic in
the last few years. However, current works only explored the use of audio
signals to create representations. In this work, we study cross-lingual
self-supervised visual representation learning. We use the recently-proposed
Raw Audio-Visual Speech Encoders (RAVEn) framework to pre-train an audio-visual
model with unlabelled multilingual data, and then fine-tune the visual model on
labelled transcriptions. Our experiments show that: (1) multi-lingual models
with more data outperform monolingual ones, but, when keeping the amount of
data fixed, monolingual models tend to reach better performance; (2)
multi-lingual outperforms English-only pre-training; (3) using languages which
are more similar yields better results; and (4) fine-tuning on unseen languages
is competitive to using the target language in the pre-training set. We hope
our study inspires future research on non-English-only speech representation
learning. | [
-0.0519580394,
-0.0042909635,
0.0012136514,
0.0477797575,
0.0166873876,
-0.0046043061,
0.0308187511,
-0.0155199328,
-0.0119912922,
-0.0247243382,
-0.1190250292,
0.0048987339,
0.0124526247,
0.0288967788,
0.0597096607,
-0.0819074214,
-0.0084426403,
-0.0522333309,
0.0062817475,
-0.0405550115,
0.018910706,
0.0089644073,
-0.0449929051,
0.0185937565,
-0.0355583057,
-0.0057407315,
-0.0120923622,
0.0171105564,
-0.0095231282,
-0.012797148,
-0.057082314,
0.0029441975,
0.0766942874,
0.0132925455,
0.0000016877,
0.0040905289,
0.0157734808,
-0.008272971,
0.0032324903,
0.0217515212,
0.0009368469,
-0.0643003732,
-0.0240594093,
0.0082128504,
-0.0098134913,
-0.0845579356,
0.0393143259,
0.0160170961,
0.0559920594,
0.0399514362,
-0.0421015956,
-0.0288997423,
0.0118653579,
-0.0322887339,
0.012487283,
-0.0140957236,
-0.0434527956,
0.0383114181,
-0.0369668044,
-0.0390326604,
-0.067935966,
0.0588180013,
0.001066486,
0.0108917458,
-0.0186913311,
0.0180893596,
-0.0560122877,
-0.0297259856,
-0.0097430265,
0.0835213587,
-0.0155043155,
0.0173687246,
-0.0349715911,
0.0064295526,
-0.0138861658,
-0.0159874279,
-0.037556693,
0.032824941,
0.0387814827,
0.0246759821,
-0.0356683582,
0.0421509221,
0.0121055823,
-0.0728279501,
0.0172285996,
-0.0280559938,
0.0124376351,
0.0119837122,
0.0092132445,
-0.0154278576,
0.0090771765,
0.0206878912,
0.0113143846,
-0.0222999882,
0.0271922201,
-0.0419853441,
-0.0037866125,
-0.0230585374,
-0.0537782274,
-0.0378755443,
0.0288050435,
0.0438610427,
-0.0885345042,
0.045466233,
-0.0417801216,
0.0466095358,
-0.0129437121,
0.0507422164,
-0.0202251282,
-0.0415888354,
-0.0267589409,
-0.0050346046,
-0.0624439903,
-0.0090506952,
-0.0111173242,
-0.0196647868,
-0.0447725803,
-0.0211804807,
-0.0591558367,
0.0370995775,
0.0152548607,
0.0090869088,
-0.0423583873,
-0.0143558327,
-0.025955271,
0.0589246824,
0.0109102037,
0.0306454077,
-0.0433046892,
-0.050819777,
0.0049189664,
0.0214121304,
0.0420978814,
-0.0113521628,
0.0166513063,
0.0938530341,
-0.0008342317,
-0.0070533366,
-0.0152831199,
0.0341809541,
-0.017786419,
-0.04414526,
0.0234791823,
-0.0603892878,
0.0173940677,
-0.0143806832,
0.0546179898,
-0.0269260611,
-0.0304408763,
-0.0520607308,
0.0368823633,
0.0700729713,
0.0161747057,
0.0052334941,
0.0200709831,
-0.0199272186,
0.0178366303,
0.0852143615,
0.0501427092,
-0.0094982916,
0.0157626085,
-0.0477664769,
0.005724113,
0.0654519871,
0.0015778827,
0.0257468503,
-0.0506497063,
-0.0185718536,
0.0384499319,
0.0107422303,
0.0540208928,
0.0255284347,
-0.0329361185,
-0.0368930548,
0.0367676541,
0.0316353776,
0.0393638052,
0.0000999796,
0.0695075989,
-0.0113868676,
0.0002344661,
0.0162175037,
0.0350750983,
0.0335867405,
0.0127577102,
0.014107964,
0.0401685983,
0.0078902766,
-0.0746787041,
-0.001031723,
0.034353666,
-0.0444348752,
-0.0086757429,
0.0056564212,
0.0326169059,
0.0200870298,
-0.0343540199,
0.0041959467,
0.0173210837,
-0.0371558629,
0.0466539375,
-0.0024231065,
0.0058829766,
0.0459617265,
-0.0127584161,
0.0044846833,
0.0236507058,
-0.0294531919,
0.0042583444,
0.019352559,
0.0290671233,
-0.0136862369,
0.0875170603,
-0.0525407344,
-0.0359982252,
-0.0422748066,
-0.0226376038,
0.0644817948,
-0.0803034678,
0.0478101708,
0.0063568922,
-0.0443018042,
0.005247938,
-0.013099324,
0.0148095191,
-0.0161635876,
0.0319345109,
0.0528742671,
0.0205256511,
0.015940683,
-0.046974916,
-0.0002440545,
0.0112147462,
-0.0373837017,
0.0533926822,
0.0269883536,
-0.0535101295,
-0.0471180156,
0.0157198273,
-0.0789320394,
0.0113266418,
0.0270897262,
0.0146864234,
-0.0422861874,
0.0762241259,
-0.0024268795,
0.0264448915,
-0.0375164896,
-0.0107092895,
0.0130839413,
0.0306627247,
0.0545640141,
-0.0335323326,
0.0416092649,
-0.0013543551,
-0.0080628898,
-0.0060410127,
0.05004026,
-0.0582493357,
-0.0284003876,
0.0425488539,
0.0031465278,
0.0002376758,
0.0022385747,
-0.0103349769,
0.0005005649,
0.0205096807,
-0.0851552188,
-0.0213216897,
-0.0256845877,
-0.0382588916,
-0.0300656445,
0.0038546694,
0.0124553302,
-0.062668778,
-0.0534057431,
0.008926617,
0.0229054093,
0.01989967,
-0.0236660335,
0.0131483544,
0.0189779587,
-0.0180254839,
-0.0138367116,
0.0474478081,
0.0064646495,
-0.0275119543,
-0.0055072377,
-0.0049778824,
-0.0219473317,
-0.0230895374,
0.0443825983,
-0.0009400103,
-0.0265718158,
0.0048576044,
0.0065202052,
0.0526768528,
0.0142689673,
-0.0354474373,
-0.0169715472,
0.0396651886,
-0.0200723838,
-0.0381930918,
-0.001181265,
0.0371178575,
0.0156303234,
-0.0423891991,
0.0251289103,
-0.0732851177,
0.0079702055,
0.0021170832,
0.0310766436,
-0.0879288614,
-0.0136032421,
0.0332026631,
-0.040900629,
-0.0524259172,
0.0092081577,
0.013170518,
0.0393080674,
0.0024182627,
-0.0548581146,
0.0487372689,
-0.0583192185,
-0.0599747449,
0.0094973128,
-0.0206564013,
-0.0295879245,
0.0577160083,
0.0095978007,
0.0230696816,
-0.0179874469,
-0.0200516414,
-0.0556565598,
-0.0091428785,
0.077926591,
-0.0177924559,
0.011289157,
0.0137637276,
-0.0254892092,
-0.0404374488,
-0.0062945127,
-0.0170892514,
0.0015149863,
-0.0339507274,
-0.0190925617,
-0.0290607307,
0.0198313426,
-0.0146640837,
0.0450686663,
0.0443998538,
0.0108198505,
0.0097305691,
0.0265341271,
-0.0221054051,
0.0321233645,
0.0244177319,
0.018217599,
-0.041436851,
-0.0461013503,
0.0331386738,
-0.0361573324,
0.039150428,
-0.0257205348,
-0.0554902367,
0.0600990243,
0.0352839939,
0.0800744593,
-0.0272046998,
0.0167194847,
0.028340308,
-0.0139881307,
0.0426653959,
0.075490579,
-0.0299870335,
-0.0426517017,
-0.0348122008,
-0.0029705295,
0.0057136691,
0.0323556513,
0.0248479359,
-0.0663642958,
-0.0305839702,
-0.008468844,
-0.0272257682,
0.0435478352,
0.0431435704,
-0.029456947,
-0.1062225029,
0.018075455,
0.0392857008,
0.0008679328,
-0.052669879,
-0.0165412184,
-0.0503310561,
-0.0632474646,
0.0182621218,
-0.0426522568,
-0.0254906379,
-0.0059729503,
0.0267132018,
-0.032897301,
-0.0398193561,
0.014054561,
-0.0629352331,
0.013344042,
0.0220258404,
0.0304538961,
-0.0239104424,
-0.0542314425,
0.0018335116,
0.0111206183,
-0.0269561857,
0.0050247624,
0.0617323332,
0.0140200602,
-0.0529565662,
0.0716929138,
-0.0115865199,
0.018572351,
0.008181286,
0.020880051,
0.0467454903,
-0.0116473092,
0.0232034903,
0.019163318,
0.0253318083,
0.0085368771,
0.0145983724,
0.0255693402,
-0.035625495,
-0.0038311244,
0.0104442863,
0.0479582474,
-0.0353262387,
-0.054240372,
0.0191683676,
0.0184918083,
-0.0579593554,
-0.0243813358,
-0.0099039217,
0.0329564065,
0.0514017195,
0.0281853992,
-0.0172408093,
0.0025225715,
0.0156538282,
-0.010298036,
0.0493044071,
-0.0123107685,
0.0420822725,
-0.0307338666,
-0.0460304618,
0.0311324,
-0.0273530539,
0.0123334378,
-0.0046356628,
-0.0081076734,
-0.0359746702,
-0.0622191578,
0.048706539,
0.0010617001,
0.0811148435,
0.0112353945,
0.0029016139,
0.0532323942,
0.00565306,
-0.0324139111,
0.0063641816,
0.064576,
-0.02678857,
-0.0178723671,
0.0041159047,
-0.0400551558,
0.0416450948,
-0.0196610484,
-0.0007865562,
0.0085021453,
-0.0244036652,
0.0011918573,
-0.0146964202,
0.0362641364,
-0.0282854903,
0.0476490706,
-0.05599894,
-0.0081191044,
-0.0399392694,
0.0345191844,
-0.0536375754,
-0.0309964642,
0.0404730774,
-0.0020681946,
0.016422322,
0.0363689549,
-0.0188926887,
-0.046908237,
-0.0322864912,
0.0633077547,
0.0155492006,
0.0180454422,
-0.0420623198,
0.0516906194,
0.0329630114,
0.044943165,
0.0286525451,
0.0254547354,
-0.0061946232,
-0.0312318821,
-0.0207834505,
0.0245811008,
-0.0095691076,
0.009143292,
0.0077362088,
-0.0176190473,
0.0148135349,
-0.0012454444,
0.0500102378,
-0.0356408171,
0.035910815,
0.0364501961,
0.0114985257,
-0.0149674965,
0.030344598,
-0.02915534,
-0.0062677143,
0.0401902981,
-0.0223560501,
-0.0222894177,
0.00643527,
0.0485258847,
0.0116913198,
0.0155258989,
-0.0414348356,
0.0579517782,
-0.0433128811,
-0.034580458,
0.0140873278,
-0.0221127905,
-0.005243252,
0.030856505,
0.0251077078,
-0.0880106539,
0.0141063062,
-0.0065315096,
-0.0188780613,
0.0158942938,
0.0444168746,
-0.0025648363,
0.0286930483,
0.0487923101,
0.0050878725,
-0.049220033,
0.0163651314,
-0.0028986873,
0.0251230467,
-4.598017785e-33,
-0.0418331027,
0.0396086499,
0.0153577086,
0.003930938,
0.0180692337,
-0.0078982003,
-0.0311355051,
0.0360113941,
-0.0116937673,
0.0012488894,
0.040979594,
-0.0043355883,
0.011532329,
0.0301252324,
0.0111908251,
0.0064209462,
0.0638935789,
-0.017684469,
0.0254128166,
0.0317280367,
0.0135990884,
0.0338711925,
0.0569783188,
-0.0671523511,
-0.0442871489,
0.0217960887,
-0.0171291176,
-0.0286944043,
0.064075008,
0.0585575849,
-0.006994315,
0.0357919969,
-0.035994716,
0.0171960779,
-0.0383429453,
-0.0168495122,
-0.0660980716,
-0.0089540109,
-0.0220865831,
0.0738708973,
-0.0652128085,
0.0128329061,
0.010106002,
-0.0048927045,
-0.0258319099,
-0.0069258665,
0.0654768124,
-0.035560485,
-0.0104598515,
-0.0036589839,
-0.0218125544,
0.0106351757,
-0.0429287329,
-0.0423188582,
0.1097383127,
0.1017586887,
0.0240299702,
-0.0097772675,
-0.0486968644,
0.0596073568,
-0.0417200662,
0.0285531338,
0.0668911114,
0.0273890439,
0.0314747021,
0.0340679809,
0.0539186299,
-0.0750436485,
0.0220084768,
0.009349958,
0.0412579998,
0.0198476799,
0.0121133383,
0.0382876545,
-0.0020781585,
-0.0419588536,
-0.053564094,
0.0306357201,
-0.0247102417,
0.0052838023,
-0.0050471169,
0.0213476792,
0.0200417135,
-0.0034029766,
-0.0447365977,
-0.050001841,
-0.0193335116,
-0.0303359479,
0.0288094878,
0.0066735325,
0.028390497,
0.0479594357,
0.092557326,
-0.0425871164,
-0.0350828916,
0.0148358485,
-0.0367439538,
-0.0035254047,
0.0077590449,
0.0360220857,
-0.0257667731,
-0.0445178859,
0.0440965407,
0.0036169766,
0.0362357982,
-0.0082443496,
0.0447506011,
0.0369504094,
-0.0620149747,
-0.0134997908,
0.0011620132,
-0.0010933937,
0.0008684141,
0.0174304154,
0.0244535431,
0.0072564636,
-0.0491753034,
0.0320224985,
-0.0340563729,
-0.0439642444,
0.0009328013,
-0.0574393496,
-0.0091014793,
0.0478383489,
-0.0288293753,
-0.0042184321,
-0.0414869413,
-0.0424238294,
0.0443432927,
-0.0134537956,
-0.0266653001,
0.0082878461,
2.42e-7,
-0.0254343767,
-0.0234143231,
0.0257020723,
-0.003265776,
0.025739193,
0.0423829816,
-0.0797042847,
-0.0100319749,
0.0112719098,
-0.0430839136,
-0.0057832482,
0.034298785,
0.061684899,
0.0158685297,
-0.0256386343,
0.0485539176,
-0.0514973998,
0.0287987441,
-0.0173500404,
0.0365376696,
-0.002131437,
0.1094257534,
-0.0202798285,
-0.0131697701,
0.021582175,
-0.0083635747,
0.1022109613,
-0.0297851227,
-0.0343710035,
-0.0443521179,
-0.0572315976,
0.0467420965,
-0.0457407683,
-0.009981676,
-0.0316868089,
0.0454419665,
0.0608991757,
-0.0034164414,
-0.0054375031,
-0.0401085317,
-0.0222367328,
0.0734022632,
-0.0536030605,
0.0599789843,
0.0614605658,
-0.0318215638,
-0.0538408794,
-0.0009492734,
0.0023017253,
0.0379224569,
0.0895989463,
-0.0259609241,
-0.0496060438,
0.0168057717,
0.0589839071,
-0.028261764,
-0.0337900594,
-0.0314557143,
0.0153497588,
0.0270039327,
-0.0241234284,
0.0284525044,
-0.0238605961,
-0.0026059598,
0.008534465,
0.0331851356,
-0.002487751,
9.686260566e-35,
0.024007272,
-0.0351668298,
0.0171121042,
-0.0510464646,
-0.0352271535,
-0.0519335456,
-0.0185925048,
-0.0244687162,
0.018764168,
-0.0166121591,
-0.0488721058
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.08044v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.08044v1 | Happy-GLL: modular, reusable and complete top-down parsers for parameterized nonterminals | 2023-03-14T16:23:23 | 2023-03-14T16:23:23 | L. Thomas van Binsbergen, Damian Frolich | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.PL, cs.SE | Parser generators and parser combinator libraries are the most popular tools
for producing parsers. Parser combinators use the host language to provide
reusable components in the form of higher-order functions with parsers as
parameters. Very few parser generators support this kind of reuse through
abstraction and even fewer generate parsers that are as modular and reusable as
the parts of the grammar for which they are produced. This paper presents a
strategy for generating modular, reusable and complete top-down parsers from
syntax descriptions with parameterized nonterminals, based on the FUN-GLL
variant of the GLL algorithm.
The strategy is discussed and demonstrated as a novel back-end for the Happy
parser generator. Happy grammars can contain `parameterized nonterminals' in
which parameters abstract over grammar symbols, granting an abstraction
mechanism to define reusable grammar operators. However, the existing Happy
back-ends do not deliver on the full potential of parameterized nonterminals as
parameterized nonterminals cannot be reused across grammars. Moreover, the
parser generation process may fail to terminate or may result in exponentially
large parsers generated in an exponential amount of time.
The GLL back-end presented in this paper implements parameterized
nonterminals successfully by generating higher-order functions that resemble
parser combinators, inheriting all the advantages of top-down parsing. The
back-end is capable of generating parsers for the full class of context-free
grammars, generates parsers in linear time and generates parsers that find all
derivations of the input string. To our knowledge, the presented GLL back-end
makes Happy the first parser generator that combines all these features.
This paper describes the translation procedure of the GLL back-end and
compares it to the LALR and GLR back-ends of Happy in several experiments. | [
0.0402396172,
0.0337189883,
-0.0196501371,
0.0154216196,
-0.0117027946,
0.021460399,
-0.030014975,
-0.0361028314,
-0.0456785224,
-0.0676078051,
-0.0247586779,
0.0285844319,
0.0040603727,
-0.0004830057,
0.0408766419,
-0.0779596865,
0.0483901314,
-0.0237358138,
-0.0043387916,
0.0411992446,
-0.0018435515,
0.0297610722,
0.0231446996,
0.0300187096,
-0.0219723545,
-0.0169505142,
-0.0275186617,
0.0035382493,
0.0009927767,
0.0106128659,
-0.0133640189,
-0.0499410965,
-0.0379851088,
0.015175391,
0.0000019986,
-0.0481862612,
-0.0776673183,
0.0289156809,
-0.0259333365,
0.0220170598,
0.0784045085,
-0.0051530707,
-0.0354304202,
-0.0144346515,
-0.0375187136,
0.018107418,
0.0491929539,
-0.0498462804,
0.0583878644,
0.0764099658,
-0.0099959979,
-0.0992441624,
0.0040725996,
0.0393935516,
-0.0012533308,
0.0107949292,
0.0087549556,
-0.0401263498,
0.0423692353,
-0.065238297,
-0.010692047,
-0.0107366927,
-0.0014720251,
-0.0227478202,
-0.0282332022,
0.0082746893,
-0.0195878465,
0.0027501688,
-0.0199087113,
-0.0184089392,
-0.0429563448,
-0.0226784535,
0.0412687175,
-0.0099190678,
0.0126208924,
-0.0426036865,
-0.0572480597,
0.0770027712,
-0.0146785891,
0.0274125636,
0.0983788148,
-0.0145165026,
-0.0151378261,
-0.0741926134,
0.008079974,
0.1076949909,
0.0272458214,
0.0045655565,
-0.0220068712,
-0.0015221746,
-0.0516206101,
-0.0314372554,
0.0168250874,
0.0041548857,
0.0248269588,
0.0135862576,
-0.0250787698,
-0.0498943813,
0.041789189,
-0.0078415358,
0.0033799827,
0.0277111679,
0.0331155658,
-0.0262397956,
-0.0186892077,
-0.0000982499,
-0.0172409136,
-0.0369029939,
-0.0261082016,
-0.006830967,
-0.017804997,
-0.0146307806,
-0.0812534913,
0.0588644482,
-0.0262147915,
0.0268367492,
-0.015096195,
0.0446056388,
-0.0032455355,
-0.0077971891,
0.0410351343,
-0.0232392792,
-0.0087645976,
0.0329247378,
0.0217676554,
0.0150437085,
-0.0395104997,
-0.0709692687,
-0.0008434661,
-0.0770490021,
0.001437483,
0.0303051453,
0.0359719358,
-0.0384643488,
-0.0370204113,
0.0485640019,
-0.016049942,
0.0264270883,
-0.0500892177,
-0.0481919311,
0.0163033493,
-0.0306196939,
0.0005993107,
-0.0596863925,
-0.0519373342,
0.010889438,
0.002591782,
-0.0338714644,
-0.0279761124,
0.0150279216,
0.0437953174,
-0.030591175,
-0.0680852905,
-0.0324649327,
-0.0317760706,
-0.0490543209,
-0.0077031278,
0.0543373302,
-0.0036266053,
0.0072437939,
0.0229391269,
-0.0327696726,
-0.0349716507,
0.007765695,
-0.026513597,
-0.0540374778,
-0.0172721464,
-0.0193166714,
-0.0157948732,
-0.0209105406,
0.02961565,
0.0576364733,
-0.0342936777,
0.0062943166,
-0.0580583401,
-0.0193732344,
0.0271140933,
0.0552428402,
0.1271725744,
0.0483693071,
-0.0156949461,
0.0285142809,
-0.0146920756,
-0.0318209417,
-0.0314674638,
0.0237067733,
-0.0937121361,
0.0498032942,
0.0344781503,
-0.0432712473,
0.0004255669,
-0.0358357355,
0.0359174497,
-0.0566540547,
0.020267792,
0.0148051893,
-0.0331942029,
0.0573075451,
-0.0025435095,
-0.0452970788,
-0.0255990848,
-0.0200099312,
0.0164136961,
0.0217386857,
0.0150822783,
-0.0266293343,
-0.0554791987,
-0.0258773807,
0.0190476794,
-0.0082940999,
-0.0074278205,
-0.0184965469,
0.0200475641,
-0.0332968459,
0.0184488222,
-0.0167755224,
0.0301508829,
0.0763379559,
-0.0419796035,
0.004900557,
0.0093570566,
0.015349743,
0.0256649107,
0.0077369311,
0.0602020435,
0.0136760473,
0.0163524225,
0.00929162,
0.0467836037,
0.0116164479,
-0.0235358998,
0.0251815636,
0.0359883681,
-0.0001317529,
0.0209828485,
0.0371820331,
-0.0451187938,
-0.0283632968,
0.0181291644,
0.0075105461,
-0.0409510471,
-0.0027368895,
0.0052275858,
-0.0342084952,
0.0501183085,
-0.0517109483,
0.0862530917,
-0.0170272999,
0.0419210941,
0.0033338764,
-0.0173426047,
-0.0253075752,
0.070965752,
0.0248190761,
-0.0116756959,
-0.0193298422,
0.0146362633,
0.0360720307,
-0.0218676608,
-0.0384789854,
0.0139293913,
-0.0268871076,
-0.0213414431,
0.0050098631,
0.0495814644,
-0.0199555252,
-0.0340570472,
-0.0445862748,
0.0053962348,
-0.036862731,
0.0345995948,
0.0359717794,
0.0385904536,
0.0350233354,
0.0139821572,
-0.002502349,
0.0608946085,
0.0230836216,
-0.0012599772,
0.036247693,
0.0005609673,
-0.0807985142,
0.0064970488,
-0.0075312853,
-0.0658118129,
0.0408259891,
-0.0094354646,
-0.033197131,
-0.0338257477,
-0.000709528,
-0.0110612223,
0.0437852181,
0.0422004052,
-0.0182989109,
0.0131313689,
-0.0607753359,
-0.0020524743,
0.0396018513,
-0.0274033472,
-0.0043919627,
0.0032915622,
-0.0523245484,
-0.0232058316,
0.0199937224,
0.0419601649,
-0.0203682948,
-0.006597375,
0.0061439849,
0.033439856,
0.0543585159,
0.0048853108,
-0.0042209621,
-0.0169439204,
0.0421630405,
0.0071687833,
-0.0169481542,
0.0123361023,
-0.0303119551,
-0.0388869643,
0.0057464927,
0.0312630124,
-0.0174967572,
0.0291718636,
-0.029972354,
-0.0662337095,
-0.0328767747,
0.0205236096,
-0.0484481193,
0.0236072652,
-0.0052534924,
0.0344520807,
0.0569218248,
-0.0797792301,
0.0634301379,
0.0174452756,
0.0435684063,
0.0217228718,
0.0070399614,
-0.0642893612,
-0.0001211234,
-0.0168803446,
-0.009559636,
-0.0363576822,
0.0216908511,
0.0006167503,
0.0187573507,
0.0084625194,
0.0118394354,
0.0243205987,
-0.0175508391,
-0.0335760489,
-0.021200465,
-0.0097288722,
-0.0066131651,
-0.0177530777,
-0.0006535881,
-0.0235987119,
-0.0151707623,
-0.0339585319,
0.0608717538,
-0.0125311567,
0.0282995868,
0.0078347297,
0.0133876214,
-0.0047868523,
0.0332187712,
0.019314032,
-0.0129365055,
-0.080814518,
0.0390429683,
0.0276910551,
-0.0412688553,
0.0021753323,
0.0676324815,
0.0282166731,
0.0036912984,
0.0479890257,
-0.0229542349,
0.0431059524,
0.0146428617,
0.0373070575,
-0.0704075918,
-0.0049499669,
0.0184713881,
0.010767322,
-0.0112429969,
0.0051874723,
0.0147186257,
-0.0721363053,
0.0751051605,
0.0281508118,
0.0372016244,
0.0360294133,
-0.0015955756,
-0.0445562042,
0.0031001926,
-0.0742141455,
0.0607625097,
-0.0460690781,
0.004624126,
-0.0205924362,
-0.0491473675,
-0.0032272199,
-0.003093652,
0.0061710784,
0.0213095602,
0.046279259,
-0.014711583,
0.0051473882,
-0.0335988924,
0.038097322,
-0.0385306403,
0.0145773739,
-0.0474969074,
-0.0611021444,
0.0153842466,
0.0046124435,
0.0289095361,
0.0206243955,
-0.0224390775,
0.0197659247,
-0.0279071964,
0.0509612411,
0.0215234514,
0.001916329,
-0.0011286378,
-0.0008261907,
0.0042142789,
-0.0113294078,
0.0334325247,
0.0426458865,
-0.0829964951,
-0.0815877244,
-0.0620547608,
-0.0240918528,
-0.0022214332,
0.0268194266,
-0.0215574894,
-0.0600226782,
-0.0116709881,
0.0153255817,
0.0387590751,
0.0258745383,
-0.0388006531,
0.0118521033,
0.0083925445,
-0.0134212663,
-0.0343425609,
-0.0407150835,
0.0204400867,
0.0259922426,
-0.0499605909,
-0.0499233492,
0.0202398952,
0.0654163137,
-0.0325648859,
0.0210241824,
0.0230216216,
-0.0533178672,
0.0291613024,
0.0920432582,
0.0114195812,
-0.0057284888,
-0.0486909561,
0.0136936847,
-0.0809670985,
0.0359797142,
-0.0086336937,
0.0117785847,
0.0223594923,
0.0131682698,
0.0317339525,
-0.0002193653,
0.0155354999,
-0.0350313149,
-0.0162597112,
-0.0013842775,
0.0012181546,
0.0605048686,
0.0491063595,
0.107514739,
-0.0146660525,
0.0085957283,
0.0135294115,
0.0594141223,
-0.0304119941,
-0.0803259984,
-0.0068014064,
-0.051760301,
0.0386382267,
-0.0155712878,
-0.0131779434,
0.0186632685,
-0.0654901043,
-0.0357114002,
0.0489720665,
-0.0066572991,
0.0644142479,
-0.01515444,
-0.0190534443,
-0.0047882376,
0.0342960507,
-0.0129780117,
0.0033814716,
0.0062306277,
0.0149345184,
-0.0519029796,
-0.0069436221,
0.0135558508,
0.0208387934,
-0.0470084809,
0.0179044213,
0.0123989368,
0.0112025086,
-0.0403762758,
-0.0093256207,
0.0476062335,
0.0501926839,
0.1143571287,
-0.0038757834,
0.0086560016,
-0.0001692639,
0.04674761,
-0.0012045829,
-0.0599176884,
-0.025141919,
0.0210167393,
-0.0237384979,
-0.1185161844,
0.053315822,
0.0324628912,
0.0031469148,
-0.0165157784,
0.0090307025,
-0.0573457107,
-0.0022653688,
-0.0134758353,
0.0141646732,
0.0129156196,
-0.0223569665,
-0.015930552,
0.0024506552,
-0.0211993773,
0.0290708337,
0.0319944434,
-0.0084261606,
0.0763156861,
0.0326826125,
0.017915206,
-0.0876638517,
-0.0318805277,
0.0102098631,
0.0368319526,
-0.0610008724,
-0.007548416,
-5.702910843e-33,
-0.0623061135,
0.0445661694,
-0.0089807631,
0.049026411,
-0.0323250666,
0.0016668176,
-0.0238020439,
0.0041545266,
0.059000168,
-0.0135984849,
0.0147041334,
-0.0297513437,
0.0076982235,
-0.0220541302,
0.0291551333,
-0.0129902139,
0.041779615,
-0.0085119624,
-0.0246636942,
-0.0091515435,
0.0592429303,
0.0231491849,
0.081904307,
-0.0515704267,
-0.0219726227,
0.0043410803,
-0.0250818729,
0.0405851193,
0.0097867055,
0.0213932041,
0.0336432457,
-0.0177976936,
-0.0032243514,
0.0150964987,
-0.0669514462,
-0.0320282988,
-0.0861161053,
-0.0293498673,
0.0423339605,
0.0115576778,
-0.0173563305,
-0.0573854484,
0.0312232673,
-0.0069304635,
-0.0182581712,
0.0553783588,
-0.0275617354,
0.0285633951,
0.0031806617,
0.0170272905,
-0.0552520864,
0.0276586916,
-0.0138846785,
0.0375893712,
0.029051654,
0.0207956266,
-0.0034082888,
0.0136425216,
0.0354002453,
0.0042715715,
0.0321675539,
0.0068976311,
0.0210758466,
-0.0681339428,
0.037482772,
-0.0054657082,
0.0168448426,
-0.0112753771,
-0.0362148322,
0.0695627481,
-0.0274062231,
0.0692598596,
-0.0561715886,
0.0094503304,
0.026987005,
-0.0223747678,
0.015707111,
0.0204081852,
0.0620930493,
0.0645700693,
-0.058152467,
0.0421834774,
0.0026449249,
-0.0296153706,
0.0098852236,
0.008138557,
-0.0046139536,
-0.0432285443,
0.0381870605,
-0.0448919497,
-0.0532918796,
0.0518798493,
0.0362083539,
0.0269394126,
0.0123190144,
0.0370216519,
0.0184548087,
0.054330498,
-0.0168793071,
-0.0054552336,
0.0498132966,
-0.0533320718,
-0.0069608609,
-0.0146260113,
0.0472509675,
0.0073368368,
-0.022261776,
0.0579448082,
-0.0112750661,
0.0347903408,
-0.0183283202,
0.012980314,
-0.0392030925,
0.0156232864,
0.0000487015,
-0.000679205,
0.0078686988,
0.0039256485,
0.0101105245,
-0.0210110154,
-0.0458974652,
0.0020029088,
0.0216032118,
0.0408583544,
-0.0215701107,
-0.0436674021,
0.0082854675,
-0.0102247708,
0.0785056278,
-0.0023061151,
-0.0004094818,
0.0168891717,
2.968e-7,
0.0372933708,
0.0179148875,
0.075435482,
0.0279811397,
0.0400365181,
-0.0020982204,
0.0392900631,
0.0352687277,
-0.0239071287,
0.0398437493,
-0.047154054,
-0.0486629643,
-0.047677137,
0.0296120495,
-0.0516886301,
0.0147449858,
-0.0071418621,
-0.0436374657,
-0.0185247902,
-0.0058122152,
0.0493877567,
0.0194771085,
-0.0293749347,
0.0037710355,
0.0071640201,
0.0013265365,
-0.0314676985,
0.0233671479,
-0.0048472169,
0.0061566429,
0.0044815624,
-0.0301043596,
0.0218809359,
-0.0561074279,
0.0329353474,
0.0213685017,
-0.0450608209,
0.080401741,
-0.0437526479,
0.0523257963,
0.0773905888,
-0.0543277636,
0.0034080767,
-0.0302397292,
0.0201825071,
-0.0116299298,
0.0046199928,
0.0130171841,
-0.0685505196,
-0.0030941241,
-0.0841788799,
-0.0319275111,
-0.0360778496,
0.0209935922,
0.0203855336,
-0.0328439847,
-0.04048343,
0.0051502637,
-0.037383996,
-0.0023227863,
-0.0266494956,
-0.0218853988,
0.0026472288,
0.0411658287,
0.0168980155,
-0.0325874276,
-0.0427303575,
2.833677447e-34,
0.0609578304,
0.0081714774,
0.0524786748,
0.0589076802,
0.0535073094,
0.0059458003,
-0.022406254,
0.0308157913,
-0.020896282,
-0.0317667611,
-0.0364160091
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.08038v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.08038v1 | Progress Note Understanding -- Assessment and Plan Reasoning: Overview of the 2022 N2C2 Track 3 Shared Task | 2023-03-14T16:17:55 | 2023-03-14T16:17:55 | Yanjun Gao, Dmitriy Dligach, Timothy Miller, Matthew M Churpek, Ozlem Uzuner, Majid Afshar | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Daily progress notes are common types in the electronic health record (EHR)
where healthcare providers document the patient's daily progress and treatment
plans. The EHR is designed to document all the care provided to patients, but
it also enables note bloat with extraneous information that distracts from the
diagnoses and treatment plans. Applications of natural language processing
(NLP) in the EHR is a growing field with the majority of methods in information
extraction. Few tasks use NLP methods for downstream diagnostic decision
support. We introduced the 2022 National NLP Clinical Challenge (N2C2) Track 3:
Progress Note Understanding - Assessment and Plan Reasoning as one step towards
a new suite of tasks. The Assessment and Plan Reasoning task focuses on the
most critical components of progress notes, Assessment and Plan subsections
where health problems and diagnoses are contained. The goal of the task was to
develop and evaluate NLP systems that automatically predict causal relations
between the overall status of the patient contained in the Assessment section
and its relation to each component of the Plan section which contains the
diagnoses and treatment plans. The goal of the task was to identify and
prioritize diagnoses as the first steps in diagnostic decision support to find
the most relevant information in long documents like daily progress notes. We
present the results of 2022 n2c2 Track 3 and provide a description of the data,
evaluation, participation and system performance. | [
0.0659523755,
0.0818713158,
-0.0028263077,
-0.0215237197,
-0.0323971212,
0.0421951339,
-0.0607586317,
0.0441024788,
0.0064031538,
-0.0151580321,
0.0561585538,
-0.0205262695,
-0.001365252,
0.0430078469,
-0.0186746307,
-0.06501849,
0.0183603447,
0.0248820111,
0.0304091964,
0.0612645857,
-0.0114044836,
0.0213851631,
-0.0539226569,
0.0460415035,
-0.0207193382,
-0.014589184,
0.0368601941,
-0.0093754735,
0.0223050248,
-0.1179234833,
-0.0007393208,
-0.0014982447,
-0.0323381275,
-0.0365975536,
0.0000020244,
-0.0742329061,
-0.0351112559,
0.0171491839,
-0.055932682,
-0.0659634545,
0.0111694466,
-0.068524532,
0.002569746,
0.0092135826,
-0.0474017188,
-0.0346603878,
0.0050957641,
0.0797386691,
0.0483961552,
0.0680742264,
-0.029134864,
-0.0037599583,
0.0003514368,
-0.0007187077,
0.0278348308,
-0.0452702865,
0.0166138466,
0.006521862,
0.0528271385,
-0.0527036674,
0.029928254,
0.0033888558,
-0.0214617215,
0.0228365231,
-0.0086190654,
0.044662673,
0.0124613959,
-0.0209333245,
0.0011618459,
0.032758031,
0.0152532682,
0.0439969525,
0.0526558235,
-0.0225811452,
-0.0383644439,
-0.0220956411,
-0.0094515113,
-0.0028963869,
-0.0702062622,
-0.0017450732,
0.0375261866,
0.0509741306,
0.0077759023,
-0.0025139421,
-0.0184313301,
0.0328657888,
0.0007389736,
-0.0407913998,
0.0221460108,
0.0271643102,
0.0144361695,
-0.0468070954,
0.0708381161,
0.023443941,
-0.0405015796,
0.0271564089,
0.041488599,
-0.015180354,
0.0629871711,
-0.04542391,
0.0054349862,
0.0012570937,
0.0161408242,
0.0415412895,
-0.0059594298,
0.0024712186,
0.0081829773,
-0.0369350128,
-0.03854312,
0.0120113585,
-0.0353880711,
-0.0067805233,
-0.0011361165,
0.0289939344,
0.0091290595,
0.0076684928,
-0.0643400401,
-0.0386326239,
-0.0146484571,
0.0446845852,
0.0757047758,
0.0328737386,
-0.005946001,
0.0205694009,
-0.029019149,
0.0009162826,
-0.0338298418,
-0.0216557551,
-0.0318632126,
0.0177414566,
0.0213970169,
-0.0161795393,
0.0290741753,
-0.0116655193,
0.0354720354,
0.0620226748,
0.0412729383,
-0.0207957681,
-0.0236144047,
-0.0433065295,
-0.004720347,
-0.0169898868,
-0.0270964894,
-0.0064234873,
0.0066615129,
0.0167757664,
-0.0038752789,
-0.0227716863,
0.0124651697,
0.0124866702,
-0.0106386878,
0.0335207544,
-0.0575354211,
-0.0035433616,
0.0021168555,
0.0126908952,
0.0259400029,
0.0010495948,
0.0123489518,
-0.0253716409,
0.0016677395,
-0.0074275634,
0.0057709431,
0.0079788826,
0.0060225092,
-0.0932597369,
0.0443473384,
0.0067889006,
-0.00036731,
0.0382854789,
-0.0418078266,
0.049845919,
0.036251191,
0.0185487829,
-0.0030342848,
0.0674054995,
0.0510102063,
-0.0229569599,
-0.0004776447,
-0.012110902,
-0.0166199394,
-0.0100784507,
-0.0105713634,
-0.0182118509,
0.0146181565,
0.0030822139,
-0.0303031709,
0.01403041,
-0.0098653398,
-0.0934811831,
-0.0734222233,
0.0144800758,
0.0121417539,
-0.0233488251,
0.0348530747,
-0.0058203782,
-0.0492956415,
0.0234620478,
0.0302527845,
0.0019948469,
0.0065026516,
-0.0341480635,
-0.031621106,
0.0712438598,
0.0392463505,
-0.0545592383,
-0.0458254218,
-0.0162347816,
-0.0189781152,
-0.0114358217,
-0.0022795747,
-0.0271223169,
0.0161761381,
-0.027650049,
-0.0120702377,
0.0454740189,
0.0054258551,
-0.05979288,
-0.0228165612,
0.0010757712,
-0.035987556,
-0.0139258243,
-0.040190734,
0.0752536058,
0.0058865859,
-0.0312046371,
0.0017643239,
0.0097118989,
0.0292718336,
0.043359708,
0.0080001736,
0.0173060261,
0.0356421657,
-0.0434919223,
-0.0399651453,
0.0465422273,
-0.0203628354,
-0.0353360176,
-0.0003252139,
-0.0148622533,
-0.0251270309,
-0.0309797414,
-0.0390493572,
-0.0329786912,
-0.015950419,
-0.0530721135,
-0.0348095819,
0.0319873318,
-0.0001733597,
0.0863877907,
-0.0212937389,
-0.0555302948,
0.0398373045,
-0.0198935922,
0.0224956311,
-0.0013029203,
-0.0532357581,
0.0077724927,
0.0004762694,
0.0009925109,
0.0339128561,
-0.0297014881,
-0.0088974861,
0.0182613358,
0.019399872,
-0.0485154428,
-0.0117395716,
-0.0890301839,
-0.0025867035,
-0.0071441513,
0.0357880257,
0.0297238454,
0.0257317796,
-0.0126176691,
-0.0319606178,
-0.0211241189,
-0.0277405828,
0.0476086028,
-0.0192955043,
0.0614234619,
0.0511629619,
0.0068138065,
-0.0185740963,
0.0078119165,
-0.0688932911,
-0.004073468,
0.0454404131,
-0.0547650047,
-0.0377225839,
-0.0190004483,
-0.0051432489,
-0.00536669,
0.0281631667,
0.0189539175,
0.0119864019,
-0.0367176235,
-0.0135209821,
0.0441161394,
-0.0073880288,
0.0621849932,
-0.0025591282,
-0.0238110553,
-0.0371272899,
0.0234490689,
-0.041795101,
0.0398990698,
0.008970351,
-0.072773084,
0.0199115742,
0.0882711858,
0.0352507345,
-0.0027389869,
-0.0377053916,
-0.0186970569,
-0.0728426203,
0.0391444229,
-0.0400214531,
0.0170900933,
-0.0134404097,
0.0224520173,
-0.0002918427,
-0.0203060359,
0.0955609158,
-0.0056993118,
0.0337489583,
-0.1110108718,
-0.0265499558,
-0.0481115356,
0.0531969331,
0.005421171,
0.0136301415,
0.0227427687,
-0.048895698,
0.0545085259,
-0.0200736169,
0.0032580206,
-0.0359196924,
0.0377509594,
-0.0500834733,
0.0436737947,
0.0103709744,
-0.0379057266,
-0.0285683814,
-0.011782866,
-0.0190765653,
0.0088532269,
-0.0179037508,
0.0183558855,
-0.0369450934,
0.0193616096,
-0.0441363566,
0.0728712156,
0.0280041918,
-0.0179922972,
-0.0002025839,
-0.0027825576,
0.0281618685,
-0.0015167244,
0.009439446,
-0.0201780926,
0.0109892227,
0.0726571679,
0.0307056438,
0.0429702513,
0.0252811331,
0.030468015,
-0.0060360404,
-0.0978080034,
-0.0112826219,
0.0311616994,
0.0308702532,
-0.0747383386,
-0.0087048011,
0.1049939543,
0.0354533084,
-0.0297502279,
0.028043652,
-0.000716546,
-0.0707590133,
-0.0122881746,
0.0326709338,
-0.0344603471,
-0.0188790336,
-0.0035434132,
0.0288007259,
-0.0146839479,
-0.0542155392,
-0.0036269873,
0.0006298042,
0.0327679217,
-0.0344036929,
0.0096880551,
0.0109956246,
-0.0786208957,
-0.000152504,
-0.048197452,
-0.0356583744,
-0.0524036139,
-0.0133460611,
0.0098020444,
0.0148941213,
-0.1115484685,
-0.0490398556,
0.0371142142,
-0.000519689,
0.0226874929,
0.0614105128,
0.0515614972,
-0.0081311315,
0.0047198785,
0.029974997,
-0.0353796221,
0.0242534578,
-0.0301103555,
0.0691183358,
0.0160209257,
0.0107880114,
-0.0627932176,
0.0098188864,
-0.0512054153,
-0.0199256428,
0.0135847004,
0.0892412215,
-0.0336130522,
-0.020608414,
-0.0487673655,
0.0308066439,
0.0435037054,
0.0343795791,
-0.0224441253,
-0.0075839073,
-0.0403496884,
0.0322779492,
0.0746099725,
-0.0200594589,
-0.003774052,
0.0031145797,
-0.0204421058,
0.0319240652,
-0.0588055886,
-0.0736401081,
0.0423343144,
-0.0115716215,
0.0147933336,
0.0188040938,
0.02234325,
0.0064570452,
-0.0809541345,
0.0462217256,
0.0802036449,
0.0272875242,
-0.0408782437,
-0.0276738349,
0.0266130436,
0.0505738966,
-0.0268346239,
0.0051777712,
-0.0380475968,
0.0229787827,
0.011999948,
0.0188748762,
0.0192110147,
-0.0280143488,
-0.0076705203,
-0.0149039989,
-0.0210123267,
-0.0306315403,
-0.0044641467,
-0.0458299592,
-0.0056291847,
0.0128048062,
-0.0223256666,
0.0014948935,
0.0135759031,
0.0409178101,
-0.0018676119,
0.0578810945,
-0.0005486686,
0.0077873771,
0.017873982,
0.0314845964,
0.0550673157,
-0.0180612579,
-0.0708704665,
-0.0483847819,
0.0024112775,
-0.0040933681,
-0.0103586549,
-0.004841073,
0.0302856769,
-0.0062949765,
0.0147071248,
-0.0317640454,
0.0348951295,
-0.0713227987,
-0.048967801,
-0.0599415563,
0.0560548976,
0.0355625823,
0.0073037343,
0.001731822,
-0.0311944298,
0.0339899212,
0.0202281196,
0.0264402609,
0.0504142083,
-0.0212397315,
0.0381118394,
-0.009930443,
0.0376642682,
-0.0061196322,
0.0360796303,
-0.0339507163,
0.0060258666,
-0.0175989866,
-0.0171531811,
0.0371735618,
-0.0053114207,
0.0305627603,
-0.0198992994,
0.025933167,
0.0072323335,
0.0258542188,
-0.0071011786,
0.0141311763,
0.029477004,
0.0151255932,
-0.0255416017,
-0.0372128822,
0.0416003801,
-0.0383733399,
0.0282141585,
-0.0088449437,
-0.0222724993,
-0.051438123,
-0.0259391982,
-0.0151258791,
0.0332929529,
-0.055406265,
0.0163763445,
-0.0590492003,
0.0074748169,
0.0628016889,
-0.001685521,
-0.0178708751,
-0.0121575752,
0.0196547788,
0.0086497441,
0.0216209721,
-0.0303514972,
-0.0366341695,
0.0092677297,
-0.0114683015,
-0.0121646775,
0.0151392138,
-5.836860996e-33,
-0.0083798431,
-0.0583684966,
0.0228152014,
-0.0165422931,
0.0072264951,
0.0678692684,
-0.0373694077,
-0.0283934269,
0.0096828993,
0.0259668976,
-0.0378437974,
-0.0010067656,
0.0242581759,
0.0232497435,
0.0202042628,
-0.0328046791,
0.0390242301,
0.0269243829,
-0.0376311317,
-0.0112404767,
0.0044340733,
0.0652988628,
0.0683095902,
-0.1034709439,
0.0407578237,
0.0356462337,
-0.0029410352,
0.0038488409,
0.0071820626,
0.0445401445,
-0.0455641039,
0.0203778595,
0.0637111813,
-0.0342345499,
-0.0080749663,
-0.0157032423,
-0.0850721747,
-0.0579532385,
-0.007422979,
-0.0071147513,
-0.0337475874,
0.0037476625,
0.0458293445,
-0.0030898957,
-0.0336418152,
0.0121532418,
0.0412009656,
-0.0263496079,
0.0228338167,
-0.0122891124,
-0.0427290313,
0.0780239627,
-0.0143388081,
0.0312934481,
0.0243738368,
-0.0246989988,
-0.0297560636,
-0.029361207,
-0.0248013996,
-0.0171864592,
-0.0134243919,
0.0457034744,
0.0092259431,
-0.0461914912,
-0.0517663285,
0.0611767881,
0.0297242012,
0.0022519471,
-0.0389352255,
0.0105252666,
-0.0586979054,
0.0180817917,
0.0489221402,
-0.0210830905,
0.0421388447,
0.0006610461,
-0.0680369288,
0.0729325116,
-0.0034371209,
0.0632421747,
0.0103101516,
-0.0375509076,
-0.064370513,
-0.0171639416,
-0.0313890316,
0.0017818731,
-0.0132312113,
-0.0014276458,
0.0353405662,
0.0173782222,
0.01562298,
0.0479671061,
-0.0167798977,
-0.0065486697,
0.0043518757,
-0.0052285721,
0.0742527097,
-0.0036147295,
-0.0421718135,
-0.0138411568,
-0.0463795103,
-0.0188498981,
-0.0023184209,
0.0029485535,
0.0580760613,
0.0043155686,
-0.002967421,
-0.0358378924,
-0.0249931291,
-0.0137186144,
0.0352824703,
0.0196036845,
-0.0435416661,
0.0442277677,
0.0458126292,
0.0314482264,
-0.0068895495,
0.0909509659,
0.0247945078,
0.0212884285,
-0.0237594731,
0.015623102,
0.0385739654,
0.0096203843,
-0.0151760038,
-0.0231231451,
-0.0069799251,
0.0249874163,
0.0239342526,
-0.0319153666,
0.0178480726,
0.0169693157,
2.798e-7,
0.0987100974,
0.0643548593,
0.0242905151,
-0.0192647967,
0.0012553848,
-0.0196533911,
-0.0075927945,
-0.0225825459,
-0.0172115788,
0.0009162604,
0.0494908914,
-0.0154283904,
0.0185971092,
0.0706743523,
-0.0159197133,
-0.0458623096,
-0.0372080691,
-0.047073625,
-0.0492127165,
0.0169985108,
0.0958108157,
0.0452948064,
-0.0465615764,
-0.0304366667,
-0.0172402896,
0.01560512,
-0.0137683079,
-0.0187290907,
0.0115615334,
0.0056851087,
0.0202010497,
-0.0302218553,
0.0289819892,
0.0491909161,
-0.0275205057,
0.0072425152,
-0.0019111243,
0.0979704931,
-0.0454338863,
0.0107580973,
-0.0054759672,
0.0013763349,
0.0154192736,
0.020303214,
0.0669127479,
-0.0167463478,
-0.0562889166,
0.0010311422,
0.0045472593,
-0.0109648267,
0.0325229838,
0.009078607,
-0.0247230269,
0.0452373736,
0.0161453038,
0.0211895127,
-0.0528785773,
-0.1055722609,
-0.0242733732,
0.0491057448,
0.0125326719,
0.0045206551,
0.0365805179,
-0.0122752646,
0.0024437518,
-0.0838278383,
-0.0288514309,
2.663067069e-34,
0.0139303003,
0.0192670431,
-0.0063859201,
0.0066749346,
0.0352241695,
-0.0043040616,
-0.0043056579,
0.0238701366,
-0.0138123706,
-0.1020476222,
-0.0136325862
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.08032v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.08032v2 | Verifying the Robustness of Automatic Credibility Assessment | 2023-03-14T16:11:47 | 2023-08-11T09:59:07 | Piotr Przybyła, Alexander Shvets, Horacio Saggion | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Text classification methods have been widely investigated as a way to detect
content of low credibility: fake news, social media bots, propaganda, etc.
Quite accurate models (likely based on deep neural networks) help in moderating
public electronic platforms and often cause content creators to face rejection
of their submissions or removal of already published texts. Having the
incentive to evade further detection, content creators try to come up with a
slightly modified version of the text (known as an attack with an adversarial
example) that exploit the weaknesses of classifiers and result in a different
output. Here we systematically test the robustness of popular text classifiers
against available attacking techniques and discover that, indeed, in some cases
insignificant changes in input text can mislead the models. We also introduce
BODEGA: a benchmark for testing both victim models and attack methods on four
misinformation detection tasks in an evaluation framework designed to simulate
real use-cases of content moderation. Finally, we manually analyse a subset
adversarial examples and check what kinds of modifications are used in
successful attacks. The BODEGA code and data is openly shared in hope of
enhancing the comparability and replicability of further research in this area | [
0.0497271158,
0.0346780755,
-0.0036379481,
0.0263769757,
-0.0638359338,
0.0061163753,
0.0252737477,
-0.023423044,
-0.0225349739,
-0.0342180245,
0.0055538034,
-0.015416,
0.0318901539,
0.0416806377,
0.0146680446,
0.004654319,
0.0467076041,
0.0447644331,
0.0209621489,
-0.0341089629,
0.0301553458,
0.0135124847,
-0.0104495157,
0.0222838931,
-0.0050754854,
-0.0125414943,
0.0279763211,
0.0058830292,
0.0258210748,
-0.0031943901,
0.0063904272,
0.0457933359,
0.0035414617,
0.1163922101,
0.0000016716,
-0.0190145485,
-0.0213571712,
0.0093429536,
-0.0400573425,
0.0298686717,
0.0679757521,
-0.0442021713,
-0.0250853039,
0.0176129937,
-0.0217504278,
0.0037375772,
0.0332696289,
0.064576976,
0.0795870498,
0.114620477,
-0.0102702053,
-0.0010161643,
0.05134001,
-0.0192496851,
-0.0176039003,
-0.0167311337,
0.0460406244,
-0.0052472781,
-0.0432835519,
0.0309172906,
0.0351475105,
0.0215697475,
0.0220226534,
-0.0145797329,
-0.0412905738,
0.0122331474,
0.0017806626,
-0.0197257791,
0.0125466809,
0.0241402332,
-0.0031651708,
-0.0698255226,
-0.0008130925,
-0.0111309737,
0.0296205766,
0.027113596,
0.0073096203,
0.0176760592,
-0.0190225746,
0.0075448351,
-0.0172890611,
0.0041997652,
0.072403647,
0.0497453548,
0.0582247339,
0.0209287144,
-0.0088050067,
-0.0172754712,
0.0264514498,
-0.0128041292,
0.0087776957,
-0.048381459,
0.0350205004,
0.0040715518,
-0.0055461712,
-0.0110954931,
-0.0797079876,
-0.058746513,
0.0280349664,
-0.0864748657,
-0.0139648877,
0.0047826301,
-0.0244754385,
0.0395657085,
-0.0132994782,
0.0027828948,
-0.0213898867,
0.0468057841,
0.0352767929,
0.018940419,
-0.0118032331,
0.0285584126,
0.0013479178,
0.0079006627,
0.0077100908,
0.0078150835,
-0.0709216446,
0.0009376697,
-0.0384588242,
0.0452191122,
-0.0283217859,
0.0347393975,
-0.0099601867,
0.0314287022,
-0.0036863957,
0.0067803841,
-0.0084783407,
0.0221777298,
-0.0035403704,
-0.0410039052,
0.0038378134,
0.0156947784,
-0.0273689218,
-0.0267178416,
0.0327266119,
0.0218476206,
0.0073198029,
-0.0155289462,
-0.0283963922,
-0.0389239304,
-0.0203802921,
-0.0497277789,
0.0101842796,
-0.0515506901,
-0.0280526672,
-0.0362141356,
-0.0278207008,
-0.067176491,
-0.0234206244,
0.0044942726,
-0.0203147493,
0.0708396733,
0.0118302563,
-0.0278875902,
0.0805231482,
0.0323375799,
-0.0280615874,
0.0469560511,
0.0126575269,
0.1009612679,
0.069140546,
0.0179905556,
0.0230809003,
0.0121894386,
0.0502690896,
0.0152969342,
0.0166100785,
0.0075326804,
-0.0279463865,
0.007527044,
-0.0253603626,
0.0308957957,
-0.0201086476,
-0.0656251088,
0.1008284315,
-0.054999698,
-0.0196561515,
0.0181652065,
0.0623467416,
-0.0083972318,
0.0207165629,
0.0163161717,
-0.0603742301,
-0.0075454698,
-0.0750287399,
-0.0559724867,
-0.0081049092,
0.040035978,
-0.0197445061,
-0.0351387709,
0.0140269184,
-0.000103056,
0.0428903513,
-0.0273441914,
0.0167791732,
0.012313745,
-0.0390232168,
-0.0224629361,
0.010630005,
0.014652024,
0.0092996452,
-0.0638638735,
0.0057959901,
-0.0183869228,
0.0264929943,
-0.0286578853,
0.0624720529,
-0.046068918,
0.0299380738,
0.0118903527,
0.0777364299,
-0.0241955649,
-0.0441803262,
-0.0000271007,
0.0151912756,
-0.0706708804,
0.0203426536,
0.0455795825,
0.0488381945,
0.0322200656,
-0.0053986199,
0.0181530416,
-0.0491081513,
0.0296590906,
0.0358403362,
-0.0348629393,
0.0035401797,
0.019943662,
0.02877515,
0.0272847526,
-0.0316228904,
-0.010089553,
0.0512491539,
0.0314028673,
-0.0479150005,
-0.0367348157,
0.0272991564,
0.0071987761,
0.0198882967,
-0.0297081955,
-0.0378293172,
0.0599149838,
-0.0239960812,
0.0378094986,
0.0543917343,
-0.0158813223,
-0.0571222901,
-0.055732023,
-0.0145033291,
-0.053873919,
0.0435009748,
-0.0008128413,
0.0656700581,
-0.0251005031,
-0.0054400065,
-0.010733583,
-0.0171799269,
-0.0026636934,
-0.0115443273,
-0.0227851458,
-0.0160685703,
-0.0389505886,
0.0209172629,
0.0121684736,
-0.0412828512,
0.0066798413,
-0.0162787754,
-0.0328984559,
-0.0380611196,
-0.0407499447,
0.0004353604,
0.0304243769,
-0.027115386,
0.0134242652,
0.0364491679,
-0.022331506,
-0.0211583786,
0.0006885311,
0.0274156854,
0.0023851274,
-0.0156781841,
-0.0042968607,
-0.0110143451,
0.0234445203,
-0.0234272182,
0.0529928766,
0.0357185341,
-0.0348392874,
-0.0072392221,
-0.0339915678,
-0.0398901291,
0.0251953863,
-0.0421547256,
-0.0404277369,
0.0240385681,
0.0338886976,
-0.0466279238,
0.0448734649,
0.0408729538,
0.0750444159,
0.0470987819,
0.0871980041,
0.0026497722,
-0.0320624262,
-0.0211869478,
0.0195084345,
-0.0367851779,
-0.047980018,
0.0180368051,
0.006602136,
0.0330393203,
0.0075493646,
-0.0096515529,
0.0626514703,
-0.0111297229,
-0.0464497134,
0.0201232601,
-0.020956777,
0.0096955309,
0.0009301275,
-0.0378396772,
-0.0490798727,
0.0948024988,
-0.0432236306,
0.0343225785,
-0.0207947325,
-0.0462320298,
0.0273104198,
-0.0042153145,
-0.0111206332,
0.0224179532,
0.0035111366,
0.0404683352,
0.0112465844,
-0.0140936896,
0.0839555711,
-0.0077067879,
-0.0175428689,
-0.0330069773,
0.0299749002,
0.0385539345,
-0.0171690229,
-0.0543066971,
-0.0976380259,
-0.0187572688,
-0.0010840986,
0.0043901722,
-0.0128779076,
-0.1056164876,
-0.0388209447,
0.0383040123,
0.0388479717,
-0.0152270989,
0.0026393682,
0.0132711958,
0.0280266181,
0.0026741363,
-0.0100453058,
0.056871824,
-0.0291127395,
-0.0015121824,
0.0417720675,
-0.0561715849,
0.0107844947,
-0.0478618816,
-0.0279123541,
-0.0256856643,
-0.0369712003,
0.0100090411,
-0.0056692921,
0.0230021812,
-0.0289688036,
0.0108964164,
0.0380800329,
0.007761044,
0.0056236768,
0.0101881362,
0.0375991873,
-0.0132071152,
0.0107667278,
-0.0093545774,
-0.0619043559,
0.0074945013,
0.0066779032,
0.03587972,
-0.062744379,
-0.0229879748,
-0.0226035472,
-0.0547877029,
0.0244566649,
-0.0188866481,
-0.0412948467,
-0.0072117383,
-0.0735377595,
-0.0173582099,
-0.0012080631,
0.00765735,
-0.0154741369,
0.0599433519,
-0.0086963261,
-0.014505065,
-0.0119909672,
-0.0577346534,
0.0063579716,
-0.0157517921,
0.048919566,
0.0375923216,
0.0339531228,
-0.0226876345,
-0.0243405011,
0.0109441523,
0.0397653058,
-0.0362541191,
-0.0043800301,
0.0906006247,
-0.0140693374,
-0.0052185366,
0.0168331712,
0.0465846397,
0.0191241875,
0.0034728367,
-0.0055745086,
0.0174420215,
0.0292457175,
-0.0790804029,
-0.0124564692,
0.0116044106,
0.0451725535,
0.0342907682,
0.0215763636,
-0.0156134302,
-0.0304785259,
-0.0524291061,
-0.0200631768,
-0.0283766054,
-0.0625405237,
0.0375016816,
0.0262760725,
-0.0550911948,
-0.0577879548,
-0.0129106138,
-0.0396530367,
0.0034772698,
-0.007763634,
-0.032556247,
-0.0194065813,
0.010100875,
-0.0269414969,
-0.0085072527,
0.0011288025,
0.0687325448,
-0.0253043678,
0.0167104881,
-0.0179629046,
-0.0402390063,
-0.0217839517,
0.0035149218,
-0.0675125271,
-0.0858382806,
0.034311939,
0.0294825602,
0.0201232284,
0.0306576379,
-0.0459555313,
-0.0676392317,
0.0613654368,
0.0436522141,
-0.0106365839,
0.0242893975,
0.0589927807,
-0.0348134041,
0.0081517417,
0.0056280917,
-0.0125256581,
0.0522542931,
0.0355488546,
-0.0529273972,
-0.0203476828,
0.0090317456,
0.0034251767,
0.0225678328,
0.0314777605,
-0.0176919214,
-0.0358027853,
0.0109627284,
-0.0178317744,
0.0077749225,
-0.0308367815,
0.0328741781,
0.0204595979,
0.0186140891,
0.0102292346,
-0.002426882,
0.0201478191,
-0.032593973,
0.033679191,
-0.0428002924,
-0.0173645988,
-0.0046804757,
0.08709272,
-0.0031856988,
0.0029662924,
-0.028598344,
0.0292138327,
0.0198903158,
0.0148280682,
-0.0117383674,
-0.0017708325,
0.0206432249,
-0.0006107949,
0.0095314281,
-0.0334376432,
-0.0717953593,
0.0353447497,
-0.0274661183,
0.0317378193,
0.0414604843,
0.0088570295,
-0.0196711551,
-0.0090697659,
-0.0265929494,
-0.0118241254,
-0.0305570643,
0.0146188159,
-0.0233819783,
0.0026340915,
0.0102082696,
-0.0271312185,
0.0602896996,
0.0122863445,
0.0136772888,
0.0359518975,
0.0332484767,
-0.0679864213,
-0.040923547,
-0.044485189,
-0.0298978053,
0.0352943689,
-0.0148768015,
-0.0402240269,
-0.0483937524,
-0.0490708612,
0.0412593931,
0.0328848809,
0.0404705666,
-0.009834175,
-0.0498584248,
0.0709265992,
0.0138574336,
0.0786311105,
-0.0409057289,
0.0222725458,
-0.0187200066,
-0.037171118,
-0.0174310692,
-5.74669911e-33,
0.0389119834,
-0.0448483229,
-0.0345543288,
-0.0078833578,
0.0233357456,
0.0435988531,
0.0053322921,
-0.0419140123,
-0.0353650637,
0.0314963832,
0.0047685932,
0.0247486494,
-0.0196721461,
-0.0136188548,
-0.0940545052,
-0.0457410142,
0.0596492887,
-0.022609001,
-0.0588674061,
0.0048267152,
0.0314466916,
-0.0207857471,
0.0026452718,
-0.1003577635,
0.0855248421,
0.0048469827,
-0.066043064,
-0.0023232556,
-0.0668720305,
0.0684212819,
0.0161049291,
0.0467669554,
0.0161680989,
-0.0235924385,
0.0380721204,
0.0128442403,
-0.0373421609,
0.004629476,
0.0212214272,
0.0001237195,
-0.0294264816,
0.0017622297,
0.0398017652,
0.0050354945,
-0.0256777368,
0.0177422855,
0.0254389271,
-0.0035619871,
-0.015388486,
-0.0315252431,
-0.0209409054,
-0.0004172384,
-0.0206897333,
0.0005677221,
-0.0206147209,
0.0247385744,
0.027075788,
0.0481497496,
-0.1070916876,
-0.0027588515,
-0.0134656597,
-0.0062144795,
0.0217794795,
-0.0500874259,
-0.0292165838,
0.0689478368,
0.0090280501,
0.039987687,
-0.0531767271,
0.0050936695,
0.0252544563,
0.0059811999,
0.1047485992,
0.1295323372,
0.0435161367,
-0.0630816147,
-0.1098086908,
0.023980001,
0.0519183688,
-0.0352869779,
0.011359809,
-0.0503708199,
-0.046649266,
0.0134361507,
-0.0452279113,
-0.0644627288,
-0.0474022776,
-0.012754593,
-0.0262248069,
0.0312170666,
-0.0480436869,
0.015645707,
-0.0287283845,
-0.0533011854,
0.0184302125,
0.0399854966,
-0.0199124943,
0.0040409882,
0.021843886,
0.0239890628,
-0.0255621616,
0.0048117554,
0.0258989334,
-0.0028235596,
0.0413430072,
-0.0261177011,
0.0884575546,
0.0270338003,
-0.0057279309,
0.0231970027,
0.0001601398,
0.0669543371,
0.0078666955,
0.0365753025,
0.0117107211,
0.0018877555,
-0.0081688343,
-0.0249538366,
0.0013216453,
0.0346319564,
-0.0037651416,
0.0056500104,
-0.0149324872,
0.0045998939,
-0.0169160739,
-0.0213535018,
-0.0079295728,
0.0203535594,
0.0121725835,
-0.0965296552,
0.0260380451,
-0.0275086332,
2.669e-7,
-0.0149058225,
0.0499733873,
0.0093468772,
-0.0222235788,
0.0438993275,
0.0534531064,
0.0135144405,
0.0400863066,
-0.0312065221,
-0.0887264088,
-0.0098540885,
0.0099703604,
0.0405739881,
0.0284469556,
-0.0341730081,
0.0041188598,
-0.0660630837,
0.0259901937,
-0.0282810479,
0.0060929731,
-0.0134813124,
0.0505960509,
0.056642402,
-0.0235263109,
-0.0148009472,
-0.02620719,
0.048573494,
0.0345085785,
0.0049006222,
0.0004617965,
0.0736413002,
-0.0265226681,
0.0059554065,
0.0071112984,
-0.0290257949,
0.0058020926,
-0.0207062773,
0.0317105986,
-0.0036110433,
-0.0008363746,
-0.0287232976,
-0.0477062054,
0.0281793419,
-0.0116291111,
0.0593395941,
-0.0219403468,
-0.020760119,
-0.0514284447,
-0.0515196919,
-0.0126950843,
0.0653441772,
-0.0177939329,
-0.0077511081,
0.0056154821,
-0.0302271079,
0.021458799,
0.0237201024,
-0.0404792465,
0.0034719626,
-0.0157041587,
-0.0233989172,
-0.0236099083,
0.0041123787,
-0.0158939883,
0.0569897145,
-0.0207535941,
0.0378241576,
2.146661381e-34,
0.0649275705,
-0.0222440604,
-0.0169653315,
-0.0668904558,
0.0345525891,
0.0127661973,
0.0199805908,
-0.0302049145,
0.0056081978,
-0.0034038064,
-0.0040915445
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.08021v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.08021v3 | OptBA: Optimizing Hyperparameters with the Bees Algorithm for Improved Medical Text Classification | 2023-03-14T16:04:13 | 2024-06-29T15:40:27 | Mai A. Shaaban, Mariam Kashkash, Maryam Alghfeli, Adham Ibrahim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | One of the main challenges in the field of deep learning is obtaining the
optimal model hyperparameters. The search for optimal hyperparameters usually
hinders the progress of solutions to real-world problems such as healthcare.
Previous solutions have been proposed, but they can still get stuck in local
optima. To overcome this hurdle, we propose OptBA to automatically fine-tune
the hyperparameters of deep learning models by leveraging the Bees Algorithm,
which is a recent promising swarm intelligence algorithm. In this paper, the
optimization problem of OptBA is to maximize the accuracy in classifying
ailments using medical text, where initial hyperparameters are iteratively
adjusted by specific criteria. Experimental results demonstrate a noteworthy
enhancement in accuracy with approximately 1.4%. This outcome highlights the
effectiveness of the proposed mechanism in addressing the critical issue of
hyperparameter optimization and its potential impact on advancing solutions for
healthcare. The code is available publicly at
\url{https://github.com/Mai-CS/OptBA}. | [
0.0151658999,
0.0121347876,
-0.0034934792,
-0.0428129025,
-0.0282417219,
0.0285178591,
-0.0085875308,
0.0418721884,
0.0387207046,
-0.0312599838,
-0.0098616993,
0.0166037828,
0.0161358677,
-0.0047045019,
-0.0284502693,
-0.0087739853,
0.0398356207,
0.0599205978,
0.0439306572,
-0.0165261142,
-0.0385421887,
-0.0150694475,
-0.0343942605,
0.0576324351,
-0.0100807743,
-0.0117559247,
0.0046288888,
-0.018171249,
0.0688031241,
-0.0297831446,
0.0135574695,
0.015352061,
-0.0178433005,
0.0262322556,
0.0000022081,
-0.0456533059,
-0.0250295717,
0.0005148838,
-0.0298177265,
-0.040291626,
0.0432699807,
-0.052891802,
-0.0089080147,
0.0226340201,
-0.0090981992,
-0.0313372985,
0.0529231019,
0.0296833664,
0.0499178208,
0.0783525184,
-0.0129561005,
0.0166445412,
0.0573946722,
-0.0084715784,
-0.0021026505,
-0.0580338836,
0.0375095271,
-0.0667533502,
0.0144796828,
-0.0399929062,
0.0055951211,
0.0345874727,
0.0149581814,
0.0104901772,
0.0225944165,
0.0354917124,
-0.0743748918,
-0.0552979112,
-0.0052046324,
0.0206299275,
-0.094866164,
0.0048094848,
0.0138314376,
-0.0037244873,
-0.0209922008,
-0.0172000192,
-0.0094738258,
-0.0055784611,
-0.01147673,
0.0001602693,
0.0143802268,
0.0057306183,
0.0337471589,
0.0000623073,
0.0174737237,
0.022395134,
-0.033060126,
0.003773232,
0.0118031465,
-0.03351596,
0.0060729692,
-0.0231770594,
0.0484734289,
0.0502132103,
-0.0425937325,
-0.0334657021,
0.0202689655,
-0.0656257868,
0.0593275651,
-0.0505749136,
0.0485453308,
0.0127220172,
0.0158570316,
0.0174591672,
-0.0013923553,
-0.0123768104,
-0.0190194845,
0.0121165542,
-0.0041807303,
0.0304804519,
-0.0441493504,
0.0198300444,
0.0078282021,
0.0498181805,
0.0571723692,
-0.0271895118,
-0.082717061,
-0.0231835954,
-0.0083539765,
-0.0061337547,
0.0171813145,
0.040449176,
-0.0221123006,
0.0245311316,
-0.0249832757,
-0.0516027771,
-0.0166430287,
0.0215079542,
-0.0193059519,
-0.0178098548,
0.0019080712,
0.0111103747,
0.0346471146,
0.030703038,
0.0377495848,
0.0588383339,
0.0081089297,
-0.0257514846,
0.0062986412,
0.0359420106,
-0.0546560101,
-0.0103214923,
0.0163859874,
-0.0461939909,
0.0049789706,
-0.0191856381,
0.0053741671,
0.0058633424,
0.0124768279,
-0.0113257635,
0.0014769627,
0.0399668179,
-0.0547660142,
-0.0439242534,
0.0501085259,
0.0169117022,
0.0137081258,
0.0678114891,
0.0416759774,
0.0201342385,
-0.0206372328,
-0.0208673365,
0.0436880663,
-0.0168631263,
-0.0077221496,
-0.0490589254,
0.0173023771,
-0.0348879583,
0.0074820421,
0.0947009176,
-0.0561816804,
0.0141648771,
0.01890455,
-0.0046227425,
0.0169531405,
0.0269741863,
0.0086477036,
0.0524485894,
0.0134995962,
-0.0066776788,
-0.0118518425,
-0.0608792417,
0.0077472511,
0.0108005591,
-0.0342144258,
-0.015165112,
-0.001936643,
-0.0165754221,
-0.0163824651,
-0.0808500499,
-0.0143884746,
-0.0536253788,
-0.0560068898,
-0.0121544208,
0.0285453852,
0.008075526,
-0.0197597109,
0.0460976586,
0.0376047306,
-0.0109109534,
-0.0673872903,
-0.0356127545,
0.0247435514,
0.0040771128,
0.021461498,
-0.0882846862,
-0.0250777379,
-0.0182550643,
-0.041556932,
-0.0037659223,
0.0434922352,
0.0090575656,
0.044048693,
-0.0706185475,
0.0150844306,
0.0505803116,
0.0250747707,
-0.0425421484,
-0.0274418965,
0.0173184276,
0.0137230745,
0.029824689,
-0.0424147733,
0.0315540619,
-0.0098174689,
-0.0122499764,
0.0125076799,
0.0345901884,
0.0818350762,
-0.0081965383,
0.0285279155,
-0.0196078122,
0.0249466226,
-0.0515077636,
-0.0501724854,
-0.0754287839,
-0.0054535442,
-0.039139241,
-0.0174744632,
-0.0504645556,
0.0096051535,
0.0758029297,
-0.0274566505,
-0.0159891006,
-0.0256349407,
-0.0426153652,
0.0112103978,
0.0090545556,
0.0111275529,
-0.0253202897,
0.0119943442,
-0.0344211832,
0.024844626,
0.0295728594,
-0.0123689286,
0.0111283269,
-0.0530074425,
-0.0070103169,
0.0178123601,
0.0220651049,
0.0275640711,
-0.0252321754,
0.0231243204,
0.0050861961,
0.0071224361,
-0.0384592861,
-0.0457841828,
-0.1168149188,
0.0144023225,
0.0043501225,
-0.0256588422,
-0.0229596291,
-0.0307984576,
0.0097327912,
-0.0012254268,
-0.0435426831,
0.0528564379,
-0.0275513884,
-0.0424493179,
0.0351344049,
-0.0036081185,
-0.0212136656,
-0.0212832224,
0.0133417686,
-0.0617964193,
0.0382259972,
0.0464296862,
0.0225314815,
0.026918387,
0.0493892245,
-0.0361561179,
-0.0069006369,
0.0042107916,
-0.037442904,
-0.0117281917,
-0.0259899553,
-0.0106713353,
0.1119736806,
0.03222863,
0.0076895971,
0.0185888447,
0.0918364152,
-0.0188866202,
0.0346952565,
-0.0732183605,
0.0025304323,
-0.0160344206,
0.0061254031,
0.0188416019,
0.0762693658,
-0.0092094922,
-0.0261691082,
-0.0398021378,
0.0771721303,
0.0257243551,
0.0284668636,
-0.0125992652,
0.0090252487,
-0.0274966974,
0.0299326945,
0.0130574061,
-0.1019437909,
0.0457172543,
0.0029565413,
0.0454098433,
-0.0734248236,
-0.031144008,
-0.048530966,
-0.0253083166,
0.0009898498,
0.040028017,
-0.0124111064,
0.0188525468,
0.0243612099,
0.0514452159,
-0.0239248183,
-0.0510287136,
-0.002993471,
0.0294057764,
-0.00208301,
-0.0084787784,
-0.0528053418,
-0.0515891463,
0.0191651266,
-0.0498895682,
0.0219053738,
0.0174779966,
0.0154219354,
-0.0888239294,
0.0020513043,
0.0111999996,
0.0459116288,
-0.0178421587,
-0.0121035436,
-0.0366316959,
-0.0303257629,
-0.0198600106,
0.018796742,
0.0299140234,
0.0133377137,
0.0042179576,
0.0236551911,
0.0278950892,
0.0699896812,
-0.0053694807,
0.0259069111,
0.0042716237,
-0.0359666981,
-0.0335314609,
0.0041010687,
-0.0116323568,
-0.0519583113,
0.0169831812,
0.0899266526,
0.0250963662,
-0.1165271103,
0.0208584312,
-0.034695413,
-0.0000670548,
-0.0081747575,
0.0362287946,
0.0054382719,
-0.0289045088,
0.02270942,
0.0215049889,
-0.0185771901,
-0.0245036855,
0.0137380343,
-0.0166872386,
0.0125961313,
0.0092162434,
-0.0731672347,
-0.0622482076,
-0.0509000793,
-0.0142167183,
-0.0316228531,
-0.0075235418,
-0.0381260477,
0.0173575133,
-0.0482223518,
0.0045948895,
-0.0566803031,
-0.0593492761,
0.0263741072,
-0.0154238893,
0.0087477816,
0.0413299613,
0.0406807587,
-0.0003486381,
0.0109866271,
-0.0330848768,
-0.006574858,
-0.0287082437,
-0.0289213471,
0.0693292916,
-0.0214288943,
-0.0265822075,
0.0378526486,
-0.003100615,
-0.0525463633,
0.0133323073,
0.0044051637,
0.043631237,
-0.0209034961,
-0.0567339025,
-0.0370976441,
0.0254824627,
0.0001801344,
0.0151027869,
0.0207515396,
-0.0434631519,
0.003903247,
-0.013076704,
0.0259332452,
-0.0444859266,
-0.0245046448,
0.0108025307,
-0.0266462956,
-0.04578593,
-0.0645781532,
-0.0007942449,
0.0242929962,
0.0446572527,
0.03533924,
-0.0131443636,
0.0618972443,
0.0108307423,
-0.0333994441,
0.0262513552,
0.0299681965,
0.0049517332,
-0.0552981198,
-0.0107269613,
0.1167606264,
-0.0117541337,
-0.032193549,
0.0435029455,
-0.0382432379,
-0.0248800311,
0.0266763326,
0.0583224073,
0.0070920209,
0.0318729207,
-0.0168016702,
-0.0639668107,
0.0645737946,
0.053786356,
0.0322117135,
-0.0190893188,
0.0354419351,
-0.0549000017,
-0.0263628047,
0.0178628545,
-0.004706135,
0.0565288998,
0.0152059393,
-0.0162099395,
0.0058042156,
-0.0195501428,
-0.0058063548,
0.0172204953,
0.0218681525,
-0.0092021963,
-0.0301621892,
0.0139455479,
0.0319213867,
0.0666961372,
0.0315570198,
0.0034755913,
-0.0076483674,
-0.00450172,
-0.0028358418,
0.0046149283,
0.0346828438,
0.0325585753,
-0.0921812505,
0.0311900135,
0.0591893941,
-0.0138659878,
0.0483524278,
0.0441083498,
-0.0137470346,
-0.0058159274,
0.0091416501,
0.0117374556,
0.0173630118,
0.0025104971,
0.0262551755,
0.0035906793,
0.0410492197,
-0.0745855421,
0.041558709,
-0.0369170681,
-0.0409863368,
-0.0037751521,
-0.014166777,
0.023925798,
-0.0157647133,
-0.0168662909,
-0.0266044196,
-0.0134730488,
-0.0198677294,
0.0074365996,
-0.0353305228,
0.0414996967,
0.0260904953,
0.0195374358,
-0.0167038757,
0.0128769921,
0.0467590913,
0.0121687353,
0.0458125286,
-0.0208095647,
0.0075427955,
-0.0579899326,
0.0237912368,
0.0357037187,
0.0464769043,
-0.0057542413,
-0.0253275149,
0.008009471,
-0.03358436,
0.1175815389,
-0.0355587564,
0.0215197764,
-0.0109642074,
0.0605677404,
0.0174208414,
-0.027302321,
-0.0146706318,
-0.0077674808,
0.0195568074,
-0.046390608,
0.0380317792,
0.0304860659,
-6.122008742e-33,
0.0240402389,
-0.0297842994,
-0.0099949427,
0.0049740905,
-0.0094646839,
0.0277588572,
-0.015363479,
-0.0107000088,
-0.0066503151,
0.0194357652,
-0.0178058539,
-0.0152647821,
0.0051702452,
0.0194213502,
-0.0068942565,
-0.0350391604,
0.0048595471,
0.0167258307,
-0.04209489,
0.0226216745,
-0.0402113795,
0.059981972,
0.0392766036,
-0.0495902523,
-0.0474022627,
0.0298701804,
0.0134028634,
0.0300585106,
-0.0397443585,
0.0528130569,
-0.0274820887,
0.0267784111,
-0.0001039012,
0.0011392197,
0.0377915204,
0.0249307435,
-0.0043535638,
-0.0365493521,
-0.0445028059,
-0.0094812503,
-0.0457880758,
-0.0714009181,
0.0492969975,
0.0287747271,
-0.0626786053,
0.0222464651,
0.0304970443,
-0.0451852866,
-0.0316952839,
-0.0926834941,
-0.0494959056,
0.044596564,
-0.0100538712,
-0.016903257,
0.0030876379,
0.0064271232,
-0.0257419255,
0.1155573279,
-0.0263632052,
0.0224487931,
0.0249948408,
0.0318839774,
0.0079617137,
0.0017231953,
-0.0073057637,
0.0422751307,
0.048412703,
0.030036509,
-0.0204760544,
-0.0173004959,
0.0143879037,
-0.0002262089,
0.0933157206,
-0.0016749082,
0.0077146608,
-0.0546634533,
-0.0798078403,
0.0277609639,
-0.0202255771,
-0.0168411434,
0.0096719731,
0.0041290433,
-0.0440628417,
0.0045262212,
-0.022361286,
-0.0078227166,
-0.0211119875,
0.0082761049,
0.0093738353,
0.0226397272,
-0.0363201313,
0.0180104859,
-0.0361550264,
-0.0212644842,
0.0751220807,
-0.0260816682,
0.0419690944,
0.0319268182,
0.0132893045,
-0.0219669119,
-0.0398324989,
-0.033123415,
-0.0108606657,
0.0235545263,
0.0567033142,
0.0012811758,
0.011076699,
-0.0135690272,
-0.0336556472,
0.0025474641,
0.0377558991,
0.0061834319,
0.0303595494,
0.0400141813,
0.0155481463,
-0.0161620378,
0.0248719603,
0.065853931,
0.0352602825,
-0.0068588168,
-0.0241652783,
0.0611827895,
-0.0135597847,
-0.0073216162,
-0.018968191,
-0.0388477109,
-0.0265941024,
0.0285132453,
-0.0423124619,
-0.1074631587,
-0.0115648927,
-0.015060016,
2.928e-7,
0.0577781051,
0.0870867744,
-0.0335163027,
-0.0473854467,
0.0084127672,
0.0238946248,
0.0251673106,
-0.035332568,
-0.0209421851,
0.0292953085,
0.044442419,
0.0116816266,
0.029620355,
-0.0092703225,
-0.0751131698,
-0.0237360895,
-0.0566913858,
0.0254637711,
-0.022555925,
0.0246406775,
-0.0181262996,
0.1228643209,
-0.019585954,
-0.0452981777,
0.034716364,
-0.0023939032,
-0.0045885839,
-0.0247712601,
0.0133501142,
0.0541578867,
-0.0553125478,
0.048970595,
-0.0177097954,
0.0214146934,
-0.013414762,
0.0311923902,
-0.0040076799,
0.0783588365,
-0.0393743627,
-0.0026733542,
0.0779096335,
0.0875788778,
0.0391391069,
-0.0468010418,
0.0507399216,
-0.0644832775,
-0.0429680236,
-0.0439604893,
0.0498924777,
-0.0218998715,
0.0826203525,
-0.033413209,
-0.0077256272,
0.0337299034,
-0.0185439587,
-0.0248828549,
-0.016741218,
-0.0777519941,
0.0095283883,
0.0377037786,
-0.0454398468,
-0.0265875868,
0.0120631717,
-0.0177012626,
0.0401232727,
-0.0112231579,
0.0122145219,
2.276271572e-34,
0.0018092045,
-0.0385825336,
0.0064034527,
0.0182658304,
-0.0276235864,
0.0039295196,
0.0010196781,
-0.0069188941,
0.0127782682,
-0.0368678123,
0.0063085789
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.07992v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.07992v3 | Can ChatGPT Replace Traditional KBQA Models? An In-depth Analysis of the Question Answering Performance of the GPT LLM Family | 2023-03-14T15:46:28 | 2023-09-20T05:25:22 | Yiming Tan, Dehai Min, Yu Li, Wenbo Li, Nan Hu, Yongrui Chen, Guilin Qi | cs.CL | cs.CL | ChatGPT is a powerful large language model (LLM) that covers knowledge
resources such as Wikipedia and supports natural language question answering
using its own knowledge. Therefore, there is growing interest in exploring
whether ChatGPT can replace traditional knowledge-based question answering
(KBQA) models. Although there have been some works analyzing the question
answering performance of ChatGPT, there is still a lack of large-scale,
comprehensive testing of various types of complex questions to analyze the
limitations of the model. In this paper, we present a framework that follows
the black-box testing specifications of CheckList proposed by Ribeiro et. al.
We evaluate ChatGPT and its family of LLMs on eight real-world KB-based complex
question answering datasets, which include six English datasets and two
multilingual datasets. The total number of test cases is approximately 190,000.
In addition to the GPT family of LLMs, we also evaluate the well-known FLAN-T5
to identify commonalities between the GPT family and other LLMs. The dataset
and code are available at
https://github.com/tan92hl/Complex-Question-Answering-Evaluation-of-GPT-family.git | [
0.0554364398,
-0.0292369779,
-0.0072650281,
0.0422216952,
-0.0456778891,
0.0424656868,
-0.0220974181,
0.0189593695,
0.071241118,
-0.0442943871,
-0.0335596018,
-0.0098328954,
-0.0292250533,
-0.0076144715,
0.018933963,
-0.0293781031,
0.058553081,
0.0095499903,
0.0031526764,
-0.0395334736,
0.0040904544,
0.0128637543,
-0.0165438913,
0.0186581537,
0.0288229249,
-0.0395239033,
-0.0115033928,
-0.0197430272,
0.0147571042,
0.0095437886,
0.0414932147,
0.0521528125,
-0.0250411034,
0.0260440279,
0.0000016943,
-0.0406580344,
0.0089044422,
0.0063050622,
-0.0291309394,
0.0500164293,
-0.0236005653,
0.041658096,
0.0361816883,
0.0354086235,
-0.0506517254,
0.0013512288,
0.0117739681,
0.0490126796,
0.0799178258,
0.0477850214,
0.015161816,
-0.0249101538,
0.0351917408,
-0.0015104327,
0.0484629162,
-0.0672455579,
0.0320447423,
0.0320383832,
0.0569939986,
0.0327994414,
0.0021230774,
0.0412214249,
0.0388022549,
0.0255060233,
-0.0179459527,
0.0183588434,
-0.0721395537,
0.0282593388,
0.009969891,
0.0810815617,
0.0159666166,
-0.0238174312,
-0.0108480314,
0.0254697986,
0.0173001252,
0.0235920269,
-0.0497182459,
-0.0061587817,
-0.02898716,
-0.0325408131,
0.0309284013,
-0.0295693148,
-0.0048955865,
0.015694432,
-0.0007640122,
0.0708079785,
0.0249796305,
-0.050653182,
0.0218076035,
0.0083178245,
-0.0535357594,
-0.0556829236,
-0.0130931931,
0.0475424081,
-0.0134933088,
0.0017725654,
0.0091716666,
0.0396690741,
0.0706546903,
-0.0566416308,
-0.0330223739,
0.0453890562,
-0.0147769023,
0.0698729753,
-0.0155879837,
0.077536121,
-0.0241248533,
0.0098538948,
-0.0440325998,
-0.0406766944,
-0.0722412392,
-0.0482113399,
-0.0265301652,
0.0410151035,
-0.0172773208,
-0.0179691445,
-0.0305431802,
0.0338357389,
0.015275022,
0.0041526752,
0.030677624,
0.0199512858,
0.0233617574,
0.0334903039,
-0.0610695742,
0.0284569804,
-0.0781818852,
0.0086384453,
-0.0091727655,
-0.060982313,
-0.0074969502,
-0.0005572535,
-0.0022316421,
-0.0531208366,
0.0161751192,
0.0233038403,
0.0145084979,
-0.0093800919,
-0.0101833325,
-0.0212892238,
-0.0150262471,
-0.0530280061,
-0.0064553278,
-0.0834401548,
0.0168223083,
0.0155820958,
-0.01735029,
0.0321329013,
0.0002302303,
0.0507893078,
-0.0195522103,
0.048681464,
0.0016502652,
0.0109324828,
0.0208991487,
0.0224776603,
-0.021620268,
0.0614314936,
-0.011270972,
-0.0278446358,
0.0610885546,
-0.0000455384,
0.0147763444,
0.0484607108,
0.0067947949,
0.0150372991,
0.0732948706,
0.0796022937,
-0.0044163493,
0.0131150112,
-0.0281240083,
0.0527002029,
-0.0095178504,
-0.0360650942,
0.0326723382,
0.0472422354,
0.0098723592,
0.0373752043,
0.0098576928,
0.0265659187,
0.0631891266,
0.0168304369,
-0.0253648423,
0.0205357708,
-0.0635525808,
0.0177486725,
0.0140346726,
0.0191609543,
-0.0409538187,
-0.0122851124,
-0.0038407866,
0.0102015324,
-0.0004425846,
0.0269646812,
0.0213003438,
-0.006220927,
-0.0171976909,
0.0555931441,
0.0088467421,
-0.0067116655,
-0.0145238191,
-0.0716156438,
0.0734978467,
0.0454173461,
0.0307344198,
-0.0546198152,
-0.0557527393,
0.0130209355,
-0.0018293215,
0.0190627966,
0.0347993299,
-0.0169973113,
-0.0071756491,
-0.0119978571,
-0.0025525063,
-0.0140127251,
0.0098638386,
-0.0083405105,
0.0608936213,
0.0412332863,
-0.0092061246,
-0.0661908239,
0.0123502696,
0.0138378069,
0.0029337227,
-0.0073229149,
-0.0215101894,
-0.0142655419,
0.0132469358,
0.0230074972,
-0.0049598766,
0.0097437175,
0.0363174304,
-0.0096984878,
-0.0399868749,
-0.0276579931,
-0.0116222044,
-0.0805146545,
0.041969467,
-0.0179957021,
-0.0196863189,
0.074509114,
-0.045121748,
-0.0495785996,
-0.0328418985,
-0.0284094904,
0.0131431278,
-0.0476675928,
-0.0443612859,
0.017146606,
0.0163142886,
-0.040762119,
0.0711694956,
-0.0001429464,
0.0297711827,
0.0032110605,
0.0163742453,
0.0086567821,
-0.0289024599,
-0.0544704907,
0.0173228458,
0.0104107484,
0.0168057289,
0.0263154339,
0.0391227789,
-0.0730765536,
-0.0076363594,
-0.120629333,
0.0403601304,
-0.0359152108,
0.0298020355,
0.026731424,
0.0045257034,
-0.0151471924,
0.0134366788,
-0.0875821263,
0.019527901,
0.0553586259,
0.0323212706,
0.0414561667,
-0.0017247447,
0.001106143,
-0.0192312822,
-0.0150870057,
-0.0063910033,
0.0271003582,
-0.0029527824,
0.0019848295,
-0.0106605068,
0.0171950813,
-0.0487175621,
-0.0051323022,
0.0016568142,
-0.0375155285,
0.0024582597,
-0.0076531484,
0.0127304597,
0.0167147927,
0.0125454161,
-0.0311548449,
-0.0181206521,
-0.003538816,
-0.0545774773,
0.0456493497,
-0.0053492631,
-0.0524895675,
-0.019418152,
-0.0282630716,
-0.0065372749,
0.0255135465,
-0.0102877477,
-0.0234205201,
-0.0607594475,
0.0201936495,
-0.009044745,
0.0184141677,
-0.0474631824,
0.023811115,
-0.0067721959,
0.0255560335,
-0.0116004143,
-0.0001703873,
0.0505489931,
-0.0211545732,
-0.0172509067,
-0.0559151694,
0.0132829277,
-0.0708668977,
0.0607788675,
-0.0029002153,
-0.002663529,
-0.0098025454,
0.0002141903,
-0.0354653336,
0.0051932051,
0.0079750074,
-0.039194487,
0.0293109585,
-0.0146962097,
0.0347024538,
-0.0130314566,
-0.0326137729,
-0.036930643,
-0.0055832681,
-0.0353886709,
0.0200986154,
-0.0126543129,
-0.0074693831,
0.0112301847,
0.0318623856,
0.0178127363,
-0.0045857797,
-0.0360070989,
-0.0093074869,
-0.0051123858,
0.0772214532,
0.0679716915,
0.0347051993,
0.0495551787,
0.0243259259,
0.0224206541,
0.0678808317,
0.0146116521,
0.0014209497,
0.0189711154,
-0.003648595,
0.0131094195,
-0.0514384992,
-0.0306979064,
-0.006611669,
0.040783193,
-0.0488608852,
-0.021145599,
0.1145166457,
0.0376440771,
-0.0133830998,
-0.0183536578,
-0.019045826,
0.0330155157,
0.0137526095,
0.0399327166,
-0.0957447588,
-0.0425775833,
-0.0141004827,
0.0287351198,
-0.0229213499,
-0.0245677102,
0.0104903672,
-0.1083609462,
0.0142238,
-0.0440234877,
-0.0363192558,
-0.0375107266,
-0.0327986181,
-0.0046307449,
-0.020490434,
0.0182655603,
0.0299220067,
-0.0029397313,
0.0157521591,
0.0015678315,
-0.0670364723,
-0.0239249337,
0.097627759,
-0.033390291,
0.0369606763,
0.0399117284,
0.0178391784,
-0.0342571028,
0.0016706424,
0.0084562842,
-0.0614655465,
-0.022485923,
-0.0019172074,
0.0225521866,
0.00597675,
-0.0136759495,
-0.0495709255,
0.0121632284,
-0.047030095,
0.0124260709,
0.063353166,
0.0702569261,
-0.0054077921,
-0.0173853803,
-0.0215997528,
0.0196261387,
-0.0244399905,
0.102567248,
0.0245552547,
-0.0088381451,
-0.0552020408,
-0.0223488975,
-0.0472334065,
-0.0350031741,
-0.0590886027,
0.033333987,
0.0353958011,
0.0378645584,
-0.0955985785,
-0.0553515665,
0.0338317417,
0.0011433077,
-0.0430276655,
0.0407452509,
-0.0197734144,
0.0279001631,
-0.014240426,
0.0138861546,
-0.0333581194,
0.0132718645,
-0.0357152112,
-0.0068917973,
0.030408144,
-0.0219884142,
-0.0415594354,
0.001417142,
-0.0871856287,
-0.0328374766,
-0.0014351314,
0.0450471118,
0.0238911267,
0.0003296843,
-0.0444145724,
-0.033373747,
0.0362326391,
0.0178727992,
-0.0709395632,
0.0054105441,
0.0045975978,
0.0238127038,
-0.0151524702,
0.0429639034,
-0.0629537255,
-0.0229697209,
-0.0249568857,
0.0547809452,
-0.0212981384,
-0.018192824,
0.018572513,
0.0460420698,
-0.030407602,
0.0365905613,
-0.0183537211,
-0.0044646049,
0.0092918957,
-0.0053466302,
-0.0152656557,
-0.0319822803,
-0.0077765719,
0.011767908,
-0.0469846353,
-0.0176596697,
-0.0067467992,
-0.006655084,
0.0126767429,
-0.0366256014,
-0.0082361,
0.0528819337,
-0.0171395615,
0.0000971218,
-0.0311729256,
-0.0460640006,
-0.0181720816,
0.0044823275,
0.069069609,
-0.0078396536,
0.0602541268,
0.0093301162,
-0.0357877277,
0.0098082917,
0.0085614948,
-0.0888910592,
-0.0731112286,
-0.000309384,
0.0587322079,
0.046140559,
0.0149059705,
0.0228405278,
-0.0286258422,
-0.037627209,
-0.0232819244,
-0.0278063677,
0.0013668417,
0.0091362307,
0.0655771494,
0.0330576561,
-0.0265492145,
0.0108625535,
0.0721532926,
0.0207517426,
0.0345216691,
0.030154245,
-0.0182290077,
-0.0320692733,
-0.0288082864,
-0.0281311814,
0.005418845,
-0.0034406376,
0.0232294165,
-0.0377689973,
-0.0668621361,
0.0224740244,
-0.0102191214,
-0.0058170781,
-0.006988781,
0.039772477,
0.0554961301,
0.0411466248,
-0.0371080115,
-0.0280932188,
0.0106875692,
-0.0622466356,
-0.0153412344,
-0.0195328053,
-6.171572359e-33,
-0.0293130111,
-0.014226513,
0.0303978715,
-0.0065447977,
-0.0115403915,
-0.0023131289,
-0.0121223023,
0.0075179008,
-0.0418848582,
0.0081763342,
-0.0297968909,
0.0105688125,
-0.002422573,
0.0221257843,
-0.0135230115,
-0.0799816027,
-0.0244422071,
-0.0173266288,
-0.0247960463,
0.0335235782,
-0.0037281276,
0.01527509,
0.0464489013,
0.0213996768,
0.0231899433,
-0.0420221537,
0.0063198679,
0.0329844877,
-0.055811584,
0.0965251103,
-0.0377572253,
0.0460748672,
0.0471294969,
-0.0294017103,
0.0336187668,
0.0112483343,
-0.101674825,
-0.0424274057,
0.0237594191,
0.011097366,
-0.0397214741,
0.0029640426,
0.0179948881,
0.0022899176,
0.0335162692,
-0.0111660138,
0.0210951492,
-0.0180712249,
0.0055844975,
0.0012346928,
0.006628627,
0.0255585592,
-0.0195003338,
-0.0028024095,
-0.0419928543,
0.0750858635,
-0.0220000017,
-0.0029027485,
-0.0406034514,
-0.019486757,
0.0211638603,
0.0162613392,
0.026048664,
-0.0170187894,
0.0087297903,
0.0337073877,
0.0182583407,
-0.0334321596,
-0.0464635566,
-0.0298692547,
-0.0057012378,
0.0049085319,
0.0776587725,
0.0716543645,
-0.0017696124,
0.0252785552,
-0.0840368643,
0.0447181761,
0.0284411088,
0.0487604551,
0.0177883431,
-0.0251508541,
-0.042832274,
-0.0177280474,
-0.0514678955,
0.044969786,
-0.052110523,
-0.0036315215,
0.0516614839,
-0.0165075548,
-0.0087133041,
-0.0373839214,
0.028455738,
-0.0329837203,
0.0229324028,
0.0317551233,
-0.0273199771,
0.0265930593,
0.0340909958,
0.0766564384,
-0.0365097858,
0.0350346416,
0.0145264138,
-0.026850583,
-0.0179937817,
0.0170466732,
0.0041110292,
-0.0096203014,
-0.0416509733,
0.0052988427,
-0.0224693827,
0.0256952997,
-0.0403789468,
-0.0013754689,
0.0088927783,
0.0312717929,
0.0053308541,
0.0238773543,
0.028338518,
-0.0020991885,
-0.0339111984,
-0.0409218222,
-0.002241926,
-0.009549194,
-0.0223971754,
0.0356882177,
-0.0207001921,
0.0323155448,
-0.0561229885,
-0.0342427716,
0.0078918291,
0.0418908074,
2.399e-7,
0.0852787867,
0.02130289,
0.0005780495,
0.0609772131,
0.0141173163,
0.0089070164,
0.0115460148,
0.0250179172,
0.0367997102,
-0.0079066297,
0.0111317728,
0.0363813825,
0.0429940633,
0.0462825857,
-0.063676253,
-0.0340559892,
-0.0605976023,
-0.0408213735,
-0.0422678217,
-0.0150569994,
0.0686902329,
0.0849650353,
0.0082687335,
0.0074906969,
-0.0245712996,
-0.0596439689,
0.0612027124,
-0.0225510709,
-0.0238034017,
0.0098915128,
0.0351691656,
0.0398239121,
0.0343333296,
0.0616699494,
0.0299143903,
0.0008216237,
0.035019286,
0.0334130675,
0.0182986557,
-0.0614908002,
-0.0182938371,
-0.0411122181,
0.0288873073,
-0.1001905948,
0.1287107468,
-0.0400841832,
-0.0101327794,
-0.0035679736,
-0.0427749269,
-0.0439939983,
0.0436383449,
-0.0263824239,
-0.033785589,
0.0118596116,
0.0042001302,
-0.0086819036,
0.0122503173,
-0.0652460828,
0.0006873954,
0.0249731429,
-0.0496420003,
-0.040089488,
-0.0359403268,
-0.0113271438,
-0.0198293012,
-0.044683136,
0.0082430774,
2.197502659e-34,
0.0172850341,
-0.0224953834,
0.0237151366,
0.0294539984,
0.0472593568,
-0.0004813073,
0.0079732211,
-0.0290967636,
0.0162860099,
-0.0953802839,
-0.0002041701
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.07991v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.07991v1 | Finding the Needle in a Haystack: Unsupervised Rationale Extraction from Long Text Classifiers | 2023-03-14T15:45:35 | 2023-03-14T15:45:35 | Kamil Bujel, Andrew Caines, Helen Yannakoudakis, Marek Rei | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Long-sequence transformers are designed to improve the representation of
longer texts by language models and their performance on downstream
document-level tasks. However, not much is understood about the quality of
token-level predictions in long-form models. We investigate the performance of
such architectures in the context of document classification with unsupervised
rationale extraction. We find standard soft attention methods to perform
significantly worse when combined with the Longformer language model. We
propose a compositional soft attention architecture that applies RoBERTa
sentence-wise to extract plausible rationales at the token-level. We find this
method to significantly outperform Longformer-driven baselines on sentiment
classification datasets, while also exhibiting significantly lower runtimes. | [
0.0396764092,
0.1048125997,
0.0141750388,
0.0289629661,
-0.0163653307,
0.0136077534,
0.0305379406,
-0.0215725563,
-0.0282261316,
-0.0741495043,
0.0239183102,
-0.0389433429,
0.0066177878,
0.0320610702,
0.0001734347,
-0.0448286757,
0.0031773665,
-0.0107673071,
0.085259974,
0.0149667598,
0.0027060665,
0.0264849178,
0.0557414033,
0.0470333211,
0.0252283048,
-0.0429389626,
0.0038059871,
-0.0226883031,
-0.0131938523,
-0.0007298787,
-0.0054155071,
0.0218879394,
0.0251377802,
0.02854505,
0.0000019494,
-0.0411963947,
-0.0443248451,
0.0062405146,
-0.021408366,
0.0258525573,
0.0051613147,
-0.005072603,
0.0109346956,
-0.000149242,
-0.0114171403,
0.029040359,
0.0186373647,
0.0772052333,
0.040363431,
0.0986690223,
-0.0120448675,
-0.0341591015,
-0.0013475148,
-0.0516683497,
-0.0243458077,
-0.0213753805,
-0.0066550495,
-0.0310691986,
-0.0151553275,
0.0051941276,
-0.0285621826,
0.0006815314,
0.0195902791,
-0.0595348589,
0.0193736069,
0.0161325149,
0.0012730268,
-0.0101324255,
0.0096190218,
0.058389239,
-0.0199241396,
-0.0272989888,
0.0291987732,
0.0079141324,
-0.0101082828,
-0.0239242557,
-0.0434329621,
0.0453144424,
0.0060783545,
0.040771272,
0.0745990723,
0.0046590539,
0.0225214362,
-0.0063062129,
-0.0688834637,
0.0332443006,
-0.0147310179,
-0.0125999814,
0.0141429864,
-0.0079223672,
-0.0090134041,
-0.064199619,
-0.0025597818,
0.046586819,
0.0119971186,
0.0025777267,
-0.0276655126,
-0.0030414718,
0.002362204,
-0.0584329478,
0.0016099813,
0.0069199139,
0.0080840858,
0.0543311164,
-0.0350557789,
0.0200204197,
-0.0258864108,
0.0269289166,
-0.0020979231,
-0.0075665493,
-0.0437653922,
-0.0159175862,
-0.0022485454,
0.0483949482,
-0.0648279563,
-0.0295214448,
-0.0112321824,
-0.0041377456,
-0.0251655541,
-0.0010503716,
0.0230341665,
0.0346877389,
0.0005314908,
-0.0130183557,
-0.0120536238,
0.0306278616,
-0.0600686148,
0.0083562378,
0.0397786424,
-0.010496119,
-0.0097045433,
0.0450010858,
0.0402848907,
-0.0266071204,
-0.018526502,
0.0541672297,
0.006866042,
-0.0370118394,
-0.0319222361,
-0.0376976058,
-0.050461866,
-0.0665512234,
0.0109877363,
-0.0053277663,
-0.0160775147,
-0.0047989348,
0.0007984733,
-0.0178513918,
0.0145383226,
0.0036677516,
-0.0073970635,
0.0644351169,
0.0266657528,
-0.0397414789,
-0.0311527345,
0.0065519721,
0.0075702253,
0.0286273528,
0.0065452359,
0.0365180224,
0.0504206084,
-0.0417622589,
0.0171528365,
-0.0349514633,
0.0113058472,
-0.0369308665,
-0.0127975717,
0.0388079397,
-0.0430991575,
-0.005676066,
0.0457553752,
0.0272257924,
0.0152197424,
-0.0098514259,
0.0243870001,
0.0283738077,
0.0468640961,
0.0460517518,
0.0234178919,
0.008265174,
-0.0390527695,
0.0200652126,
-0.0359496102,
0.0488369651,
0.0102556003,
0.032811299,
0.0206619445,
0.0056558764,
-0.0155001273,
-0.0370924138,
-0.007115325,
-0.0511303991,
0.0255741328,
0.0038802233,
0.0616422854,
0.0044379164,
-0.0517081507,
0.0321132354,
-0.0019938238,
-0.0520282015,
-0.0258253515,
-0.05690955,
0.0736958161,
0.0585181452,
-0.0116178468,
-0.0195254199,
-0.0136102075,
-0.0468895063,
0.0063053016,
0.0156454872,
0.031665314,
0.0025226879,
0.0054942761,
-0.0358494259,
-0.0233391281,
-0.0811671913,
0.0256531201,
-0.003531496,
-0.0232321564,
0.0276437495,
0.0419230908,
-0.0447085612,
-0.0389343724,
0.0253771413,
0.0101521658,
-0.0585972778,
0.002010515,
0.022178622,
0.0613809898,
0.0306181628,
0.0133012785,
0.022205051,
0.0160868913,
-0.0523827672,
-0.0540773161,
-0.001498125,
-0.0598105304,
-0.0418168791,
0.0103932647,
-0.0172490291,
-0.0235804431,
0.0248267129,
-0.0039701806,
-0.0384226181,
0.0284395926,
-0.0451921783,
0.0036670333,
-0.0461015627,
-0.0012862594,
0.0005432893,
0.0412290245,
-0.039133098,
0.0666083619,
0.0206938591,
-0.0016064744,
0.0162927508,
-0.0470070727,
0.0058352542,
-0.0031403319,
0.0082442248,
0.0372490697,
-0.0024466105,
-0.0094703911,
0.0163144376,
-0.0258042514,
-0.0170343108,
-0.0395975821,
-0.0475193262,
-0.0127327116,
-0.0475213453,
0.0050825342,
-0.0050844424,
0.0039783223,
0.0348884054,
0.0272495188,
-0.0319645628,
-0.0291062761,
-0.0224356595,
0.0145554775,
0.0389632843,
-0.0187288318,
0.0052900491,
-0.0348428451,
-0.0070964079,
-0.0281767119,
0.0712033659,
0.0027291148,
-0.0018740487,
-0.036575824,
-0.0178325847,
-0.0036489966,
-0.0246573705,
-0.0257629864,
-0.0468062162,
0.0009564432,
-0.0075136088,
0.0419009142,
0.1200572848,
0.0649157017,
0.0307203177,
0.0286011063,
0.0061556799,
-0.029411098,
0.0158845857,
-0.035474468,
0.0516491234,
-0.0292859711,
0.0196687244,
0.0253044795,
0.0736861452,
-0.0451950282,
-0.0029368256,
-0.0433641598,
0.0296310652,
0.0256416034,
0.0247831512,
0.0370253399,
-0.0294739939,
-0.0173948053,
0.0490044393,
-0.010783039,
-0.0256402958,
0.0738585666,
-0.0477158241,
-0.0125575401,
-0.0370076075,
-0.0267910957,
-0.0750871003,
0.0610379614,
-0.0124705117,
-0.0139035136,
-0.0208542813,
-0.0114483824,
0.0281222388,
-0.0580862761,
-0.0091819158,
-0.0003576477,
0.0719476342,
0.009900772,
0.014792324,
-0.0101881288,
-0.019759858,
-0.0039201514,
-0.0539081804,
-0.036056418,
-0.0092458427,
0.0083857356,
-0.0359356478,
-0.0190628879,
0.0312349983,
0.0215777904,
0.0467288345,
-0.0269392021,
0.0085849818,
0.0216082092,
0.0409956351,
0.0538052619,
0.0083884932,
0.0201683696,
-0.030208189,
0.0580792353,
0.0294001587,
-0.0164084993,
-0.0167857111,
-0.0302212723,
-0.0471875742,
0.0017486705,
-0.0288907532,
-0.002359502,
0.000748201,
0.0655494407,
-0.0850486606,
-0.0190251712,
0.126776129,
0.0001864373,
-0.0313443467,
0.0157150291,
-0.015997434,
0.0423396677,
0.0211014617,
-0.0154811889,
0.0063182446,
-0.0683953986,
0.0121992258,
0.0395180769,
-0.0057791392,
-0.0031939624,
0.0152928028,
-0.1003768444,
0.0194880459,
-0.031387981,
-0.0612993166,
-0.0211415365,
-0.0520389117,
-0.0079452954,
-0.0030011535,
-0.0203456786,
-0.0086051552,
0.0007087893,
0.0185452644,
-0.0021686126,
-0.0776848793,
0.0073907096,
0.0092738122,
-0.0104528824,
0.0043491158,
0.0526048765,
0.055015821,
0.0105635813,
-0.0512300543,
0.0412808061,
-0.0280077104,
0.0313123465,
0.0018353835,
0.0700076446,
-0.0060758404,
-0.0004228978,
-0.0283429921,
0.0800642669,
-0.0725171566,
0.005465447,
0.0058462224,
0.0915126279,
-0.0114603788,
-0.0586538911,
-0.0255221315,
0.0073855584,
0.0027395878,
0.0704425201,
0.0679612979,
-0.0480443798,
-0.0707792044,
-0.0361087248,
-0.0286097731,
-0.0836013854,
-0.015135874,
-0.0514731519,
0.0217414405,
-0.0271721892,
-0.0483863018,
-0.0636612624,
-0.0066558965,
0.0369834304,
-0.0168078635,
-0.0144759044,
-0.0014296721,
-0.0257251617,
-0.0455768183,
0.0432801172,
0.0047910777,
-0.00544341,
-0.0202413071,
0.0123967445,
0.0190095343,
-0.0181964114,
-0.0033524737,
-0.0227351505,
-0.0161315668,
-0.0296590496,
0.0009378032,
0.0123777352,
0.0111279245,
0.070764184,
-0.0066627823,
-0.0029901168,
0.0353042595,
0.0419752412,
-0.0372918919,
-0.0272786394,
0.0555181839,
-0.0021139157,
0.0177497268,
0.0449543893,
-0.0079714991,
-0.0099606719,
0.029781606,
0.0210834965,
-0.0102428617,
-0.0026958487,
0.0026796567,
0.0029270065,
0.046861928,
0.029965708,
-0.0181785896,
-0.0245055966,
0.0146619678,
-0.0329847671,
-0.0213077124,
-0.043770127,
0.0013106439,
0.0079379203,
0.0016187868,
-0.029188171,
0.0043919161,
-0.0142655633,
0.0126180891,
-0.0066798702,
0.1020418927,
-0.0078570638,
0.0104990741,
-0.0119878072,
0.008092178,
-0.0348103084,
-0.0241062026,
0.0049994807,
0.0433829427,
-0.0092949364,
0.0269016102,
0.024671901,
0.0225055125,
0.0191329829,
-0.0281291828,
-0.0836613849,
-0.0049708728,
0.0239023808,
-0.0243393872,
0.0049896585,
-0.0733337551,
0.0558060445,
0.0139023354,
-0.0070418352,
0.0094132004,
0.0707339942,
0.0252365116,
-0.0255819261,
-0.0250638947,
0.0204774644,
-0.0594825707,
-0.0074692424,
0.0578342266,
-0.029742023,
-0.007538253,
0.0296926238,
-0.0330680907,
-0.0392492376,
-0.0312949494,
-0.0047284616,
0.0240323655,
0.0233525038,
-0.0230401941,
-0.0139964428,
-0.0346735194,
0.0200338047,
-0.0546489134,
-0.0021177046,
-0.0285681896,
0.0143431788,
0.0597294495,
0.0057133338,
-0.0209571198,
-0.059820354,
0.0511571355,
-0.0044374876,
0.0025151991,
-0.0245617833,
-6.183541096e-33,
0.0196420774,
-0.0507913083,
-0.0323838405,
0.0103594773,
-0.0147433206,
0.0551751815,
-0.0501774736,
-0.0412735827,
0.0109239155,
0.0471881367,
-0.0124074882,
0.0336357765,
-0.0019179443,
0.0466599874,
0.0072979317,
-0.0123508368,
0.0481621437,
0.0464528427,
-0.0216296911,
0.023232555,
0.0638885945,
0.0257631391,
0.0360999331,
-0.0528543741,
0.0242770072,
0.0344991535,
0.0190001018,
-0.0120079042,
-0.0015713454,
0.0823753849,
0.0155554675,
0.0159208067,
0.0253389422,
-0.0729714334,
0.0039538504,
0.0576239489,
-0.090903759,
0.010881572,
0.0007368089,
-0.0234014168,
-0.0069354982,
-0.0764632672,
0.0408095792,
0.0243729949,
0.0415475965,
-0.0537064262,
0.0414503664,
-0.0167082697,
-0.0176205914,
-0.0586630255,
-0.0690992475,
0.0479253642,
-0.0326245837,
0.028324822,
0.0141787836,
0.0235827621,
-0.0041470858,
0.1262271553,
-0.0329691321,
-0.0254139137,
-0.0196905155,
0.048096776,
0.0160183776,
-0.0155147715,
-0.034775991,
0.0654894188,
-0.0197082218,
0.0124469325,
-0.0807904303,
0.0290422756,
-0.012832283,
0.0337324217,
0.0858897045,
0.0177503135,
0.0613562651,
0.0085940519,
-0.0913010985,
-0.012757347,
-0.0322263241,
0.0071243006,
0.0806072429,
-0.0009909642,
-0.0087376656,
0.0056944676,
-0.0059279501,
-0.0011315097,
-0.0303551611,
0.0181209035,
-0.0081796106,
0.0069708005,
-0.0423962884,
-0.0046441304,
0.0145947076,
-0.0279344358,
0.030470565,
0.0500131845,
-0.0154572912,
-0.0055878982,
0.0183741245,
-0.0195887759,
-0.0471785851,
0.0087415371,
0.0149137536,
0.0456710272,
0.0140007259,
-0.0000449537,
0.0698403791,
-0.0105245067,
-0.0810945928,
-0.0198616572,
-0.0302241314,
0.0164860915,
-0.05159932,
0.0629138723,
0.0379158109,
0.0017617428,
-0.0170089565,
0.0734017193,
-0.0136481328,
0.0248581301,
0.0165924374,
-0.0135634132,
0.0230741482,
0.0056996602,
-0.0261681229,
-0.0213780068,
-0.0046457425,
0.0297106449,
-0.0011627857,
-0.0720588788,
-0.0135409897,
0.0132243214,
2.606e-7,
0.0249448903,
0.0475717299,
0.027467845,
-0.0316741914,
0.007379957,
0.0575139932,
0.0488355272,
0.0235380568,
-0.0318194516,
0.0183306746,
-0.0038667021,
0.0075372332,
0.0225422587,
0.0024015903,
-0.0774764642,
-0.0173536986,
-0.0480359942,
-0.0272487681,
-0.0291751269,
-0.0015813912,
0.0790647119,
0.0972073674,
0.0055724033,
-0.0015928741,
0.026362244,
-0.0588359125,
0.030434113,
-0.0139320353,
0.0048358389,
0.0063901241,
0.0510817915,
-0.0466544963,
-0.0104824882,
-0.0184859019,
-0.0095915478,
0.0230879746,
-0.0341734588,
0.0665163547,
-0.0024721997,
-0.0706506371,
0.0213328786,
-0.008236181,
0.0162106939,
-0.052116286,
0.0855843499,
-0.061003767,
-0.0695388913,
-0.0563384742,
-0.0610170029,
-0.0004930127,
-0.0050281882,
-0.0048593627,
0.031042723,
0.0343822241,
-0.0324085094,
-0.0285429955,
0.0140564637,
-0.1107347161,
-0.0326589048,
-0.007178708,
-0.0077801538,
0.0150048202,
-0.0445235744,
0.023849044,
0.077279076,
-0.0492135063,
-0.0001162927,
2.656364915e-34,
0.0521107316,
0.0239178408,
-0.0326238722,
0.0053447965,
0.0664005578,
0.0002503631,
-0.008532675,
-0.0278724916,
0.0538105927,
-0.0439517684,
-0.0293494072
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.07971v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.07971v1 | A Theory of Emergent In-Context Learning as Implicit Structure Induction | 2023-03-14T15:24:05 | 2023-03-14T15:24:05 | Michael Hahn, Navin Goyal | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Scaling large language models (LLMs) leads to an emergent capacity to learn
in-context from example demonstrations. Despite progress, theoretical
understanding of this phenomenon remains limited. We argue that in-context
learning relies on recombination of compositional operations found in natural
language data. We derive an information-theoretic bound showing how in-context
learning abilities arise from generic next-token prediction when the
pretraining distribution has sufficient amounts of compositional structure,
under linguistically motivated assumptions. A second bound provides a
theoretical justification for the empirical success of prompting LLMs to output
intermediate steps towards an answer. To validate theoretical predictions, we
introduce a controlled setup for inducing in-context learning; unlike previous
approaches, it accounts for the compositional nature of language. Trained
transformers can perform in-context learning for a range of tasks, in a manner
consistent with the theoretical results. Mirroring real-world LLMs in a
miniature setup, in-context learning emerges when scaling parameters and data,
and models perform better when prompted to output intermediate steps. Probing
shows that in-context learning is supported by a representation of the input's
compositional structure. Taken together, these results provide a step towards
theoretical understanding of emergent behavior in large language models. | [
0.0111390818,
0.030249007,
-0.0201713443,
0.0061413902,
-0.0174226388,
0.0264019724,
-0.012791492,
0.0000997028,
-0.0472552888,
-0.0512078181,
-0.0431442335,
-0.0442777872,
0.0018281175,
0.0198368654,
0.0704000369,
-0.0297605824,
0.0303007886,
-0.0700137168,
-0.0596561395,
0.001797605,
-0.0392963625,
-0.0405127257,
-0.0081523024,
0.0476979688,
-0.0121627264,
0.0092723602,
-0.033819519,
-0.0199463144,
-0.058287818,
-0.0185339507,
-0.0179970749,
0.0236710254,
0.0576446317,
0.0522843078,
0.0000017724,
-0.0669612065,
0.0152293174,
-0.0064557702,
-0.0429784656,
-0.028178947,
0.013116709,
-0.014168757,
-0.023833828,
0.0166941099,
-0.0381299704,
-0.0274075139,
0.0452132449,
0.0362869352,
0.0268145353,
0.0469034165,
0.0002844571,
-0.0424802527,
0.0190441646,
-0.0304394718,
0.0083866604,
0.0038316848,
0.0318160206,
-0.0188110899,
-0.007174362,
0.0144403186,
-0.0395450406,
0.0002675244,
0.0484266803,
0.0069969781,
-0.015060625,
0.0903878286,
0.0041894875,
-0.021627754,
-0.0088569745,
0.0471786261,
-0.0164488126,
-0.041279003,
-0.0189074352,
-0.0157811791,
0.0091121839,
0.0108944597,
-0.0601928197,
0.0331566334,
0.0234000608,
0.0245592762,
0.0157201439,
-0.0132551398,
0.0467993058,
-0.0051658144,
-0.0257279538,
0.0778656304,
0.0043257489,
-0.062516436,
0.0194863919,
0.0018854763,
-0.0043819286,
-0.0745002627,
-0.0334561989,
0.0396054685,
-0.0248053111,
0.0397180691,
-0.0280055627,
-0.005728459,
-0.0062198606,
-0.0327877849,
0.0322729945,
0.0318663158,
0.0012861886,
0.0384353437,
-0.0474562049,
0.0670276955,
-0.0538880751,
0.0331043638,
-0.0448201336,
0.0162354037,
-0.0353689156,
-0.0445898995,
-0.0341156423,
0.0460428223,
-0.0194358435,
-0.0158083439,
-0.0247251932,
0.0581576787,
0.0126393363,
0.0063832444,
-0.0023971626,
-0.0071700811,
-0.0659121275,
-0.0056319591,
-0.0328854658,
-0.0050155129,
-0.000184264,
0.0426656082,
0.0029246914,
-0.0177107807,
-0.0279302672,
-0.0108242733,
-0.0092463614,
-0.0071718805,
0.0068942709,
0.0583799183,
-0.0301203448,
-0.0584601201,
-0.014927513,
-0.0182203781,
-0.0116373347,
-0.0489858724,
0.0431920253,
-0.0465513729,
0.0023447005,
0.0323041156,
-0.0076817116,
-0.010524312,
0.0129751693,
0.0231564827,
-0.0125072459,
0.083772257,
0.0369275324,
0.032637015,
-0.0129102217,
-0.0086216098,
-0.0067073731,
0.0606344827,
0.0240776408,
-0.005945588,
-0.0204090774,
0.0116357477,
0.0255031846,
0.046745237,
0.0454718247,
0.0118934261,
-0.0169135127,
0.0065066544,
0.01560154,
0.0362632945,
0.0103837615,
0.0469249934,
-0.0322142839,
0.0164243653,
0.0577246659,
0.0677292347,
0.0323808007,
0.0294653252,
0.06187227,
-0.0301464517,
0.0003506819,
0.0412301607,
-0.0813511685,
0.0073165526,
-0.0305568893,
0.0365031101,
0.0089411279,
-0.0019130561,
-0.039838586,
-0.0216277651,
-0.0157426465,
-0.0042918618,
0.0007603447,
-0.0255816542,
0.0702460185,
0.0858306065,
-0.0518990345,
0.0413246006,
0.0270398632,
-0.0249854177,
0.0195718799,
-0.0648630187,
0.0123864664,
-0.0031616737,
0.0280180089,
-0.0306024272,
0.0089886868,
-0.0091200592,
0.0354496501,
0.0471144244,
-0.0003606931,
-0.0374835432,
-0.0143590141,
-0.0112101054,
-0.0064112083,
-0.0162832886,
0.0110635366,
-0.0395343602,
0.0214676987,
-0.0205719639,
-0.0126355318,
-0.0419747233,
0.018704338,
0.0637848005,
-0.0528535247,
-0.0463801101,
-0.0174525063,
0.0201913007,
0.0278543625,
-0.0190866608,
0.0001173998,
0.0383045711,
0.0353596061,
-0.0241694078,
-0.0328977741,
0.0540471114,
-0.0926970989,
-0.0430640504,
0.0224122331,
-0.0038526035,
0.019227419,
-0.0333399773,
0.0044027651,
-0.0326406248,
0.0165177695,
-0.0529257394,
0.0820115581,
-0.0349237099,
0.0266730767,
0.0067235595,
-0.0146619044,
-0.0108982408,
0.0674395561,
-0.0116996625,
0.0099059613,
0.0391278304,
0.0388507359,
-0.0403881148,
-0.0047826632,
-0.0052556838,
-0.0097090555,
-0.0109215612,
-0.0030532817,
-0.0103164017,
-0.02125776,
-0.0318918973,
-0.0362640098,
-0.0417913534,
-0.0290880743,
-0.0157430097,
0.0085210782,
0.0299403425,
0.0051329001,
0.0197021496,
-0.013196758,
-0.0002152396,
-0.0018320726,
0.0356498361,
0.0440618843,
0.0525377356,
0.0338802822,
-0.0303518977,
-0.0146572879,
-0.0098976893,
-0.0307218153,
0.0826015323,
0.014321466,
0.030229954,
-0.0707253143,
0.0371482261,
0.034601938,
0.0451231934,
-0.0402598605,
-0.0346214511,
0.0390261933,
-0.019692786,
0.0662903041,
0.0667877197,
-0.0017616998,
0.0479737818,
0.0602069274,
0.0021845463,
-0.0305786394,
0.0055001611,
-0.0627260432,
-0.0352213383,
-0.0658602118,
0.016920656,
0.0132215424,
0.0916329697,
-0.0224079899,
-0.0040215747,
-0.0575452857,
0.0234649591,
-0.0256672055,
-0.028711969,
-0.0164936446,
-0.0579261854,
-0.0641356334,
0.028503811,
-0.0164386705,
-0.0502462983,
0.0592668988,
-0.0162319969,
-0.0248930939,
-0.0037396909,
0.0051237056,
-0.024516454,
0.082405962,
0.031831339,
-0.009861731,
0.0357925408,
-0.0302414,
-0.0919986218,
0.0100609623,
0.0034045461,
-0.0041845487,
0.044715628,
-0.0199247319,
0.0128517086,
0.0051494152,
-0.0589771569,
-0.0673989132,
-0.0258304439,
-0.0040497221,
0.0262428038,
-0.00137773,
-0.023817312,
-0.0010388552,
0.0046372735,
0.0441230312,
0.0543625467,
0.0203387365,
-0.0317586772,
-0.0222189669,
0.0157749858,
0.0111343749,
0.0438408591,
0.0296089202,
-0.0590927899,
0.0305954069,
0.025470702,
0.0615771934,
-0.0041500982,
-0.0306541882,
0.0155508257,
0.0054235053,
-0.016245259,
-0.0182057526,
0.0486347377,
0.0341248214,
-0.0465912595,
-0.043591693,
0.0778069347,
0.0156445373,
-0.0431444272,
0.0332029983,
0.0015961464,
0.0084276162,
0.0694413707,
0.0341129564,
-0.0754408464,
-0.0009915301,
0.0310694855,
-0.019797042,
-0.0221061818,
-0.0317540206,
-0.0167111922,
-0.1406276971,
0.0124572888,
0.0086727664,
-0.0693293959,
-0.0315765925,
-0.0297768302,
0.0174353328,
0.0110397534,
0.0019115139,
0.0229759775,
-0.0432538651,
-0.0026754602,
0.0172321275,
0.0073824483,
-0.0577545874,
0.0046450286,
-0.0479892045,
0.028642891,
0.044519607,
-0.006821048,
-0.0070029632,
-0.0038371265,
0.0728177652,
-0.0325145237,
0.0201577544,
0.0179722272,
0.0240760129,
-0.0031565106,
0.0089014396,
-0.0174927991,
0.0597898364,
-0.0187985748,
-0.0395682156,
-0.0449715555,
0.0928060412,
0.004625536,
-0.026809372,
-0.0011675478,
-0.0150554646,
0.0262134969,
0.0558757819,
0.0502602831,
-0.0487131551,
-0.0163292401,
-0.0185537115,
0.002939506,
0.0157108903,
-0.0514073968,
0.0279161986,
0.046377413,
0.0084912246,
-0.0754910186,
-0.025100505,
0.0230442155,
0.0430006497,
0.011507757,
-0.0145968376,
0.0069222148,
-0.0054253964,
-0.0205970462,
0.0006847742,
-0.0169297662,
0.0130367298,
-0.0593700409,
-0.010705404,
0.0530067459,
-0.070224613,
-0.0448311493,
-0.0267050304,
-0.0792675465,
-0.0678277984,
0.0214399211,
0.0400149524,
0.021212386,
0.0559710637,
-0.0006534497,
-0.0549212359,
0.0999980345,
0.0295497514,
-0.0205739215,
0.0250373185,
0.0394923836,
0.0043738945,
0.019356804,
0.0464495607,
-0.0382222123,
-0.0022162274,
0.0253780615,
0.0309063997,
0.0022251036,
-0.0011829891,
0.061066322,
-0.0323550217,
0.0288594235,
-0.0136701418,
0.021105364,
-0.0296763014,
0.0316810496,
0.0076960861,
-0.0117416354,
-0.0334254093,
-0.0029744529,
0.0092040366,
0.0416607223,
0.0132699618,
-0.0146268615,
0.0101864981,
0.0646850094,
0.0015959559,
-0.0061564911,
0.0416024961,
-0.0115431352,
0.0662758499,
0.0472450778,
0.0199739244,
0.0119921509,
-0.0151814446,
0.0181766972,
-0.0115057919,
0.0360074639,
0.0473468043,
-0.0019514461,
-0.049861446,
-0.0064890203,
-0.0869760737,
-0.0027709308,
-0.0339233838,
0.0146778747,
0.042571377,
-0.0179191288,
-0.005662628,
-0.0633665696,
-0.0097116996,
0.0117597301,
0.0098597445,
-0.0358986519,
-0.0438371599,
0.0608746223,
0.0319611728,
-0.0008475614,
0.0325712301,
0.0844143629,
0.0175196789,
0.0777996778,
-0.0133696701,
0.0551774614,
-0.0105409548,
-0.0160195976,
-0.0013554583,
0.0208659265,
-0.0187868513,
0.0269644763,
-0.0342622101,
-0.0670793802,
-0.0282967631,
0.0201032367,
-0.0149543285,
-0.0450472198,
0.0454770103,
0.0743790343,
0.0075101661,
-0.0395365581,
0.0087897144,
-0.0012083476,
0.045435369,
-0.0012511332,
-0.0140377386,
-5.862295755e-33,
-0.0208811741,
-0.0352690071,
0.0317926034,
0.0309901983,
-0.0159614906,
-0.0153658101,
-0.0319699235,
0.0042163362,
-0.0048627155,
0.0232609566,
-0.0461078994,
0.0058072633,
0.0008906648,
0.0254057385,
0.0188179128,
-0.0148357544,
0.0536521971,
-0.0545004383,
-0.0254651383,
0.0245995019,
-0.0000842063,
-0.0067229071,
0.0493010767,
-0.0411483906,
-0.0029602295,
-0.0022042396,
-0.0072476328,
0.0575281456,
-0.0350270346,
0.0661538318,
-0.0245523881,
0.0173660163,
0.0307194777,
-0.0538245812,
-0.0253453385,
0.0251637306,
-0.0662198067,
-0.0070421747,
0.0163102709,
0.0096610365,
-0.0588877499,
0.0017873395,
0.0804861113,
-0.0317805111,
-0.0346782692,
-0.012047857,
0.0062401313,
-0.0053185169,
-0.0096976832,
-0.0383397415,
-0.0789986774,
-0.0152412346,
0.015332968,
-0.0312961675,
0.0270570721,
0.0082984501,
-0.0036253864,
-0.0051828576,
-0.0389381275,
0.0332859792,
0.0062724054,
0.0283810347,
0.030457627,
0.045335643,
0.0147976959,
0.0385995544,
0.0312858373,
0.022278443,
-0.0194099173,
-0.058557909,
0.0382723026,
0.0245031621,
-0.0014794678,
0.0136343576,
0.0355655402,
0.0285805762,
-0.025569493,
-0.0325873904,
0.0170500688,
0.0221560299,
0.0332257114,
-0.0030117757,
-0.0263064504,
-0.0370200425,
-0.0685465783,
-0.0055249189,
-0.0191687681,
-0.024108611,
0.0325705074,
0.0435183235,
0.0109963957,
0.0000987496,
0.0242640804,
-0.0507057682,
-0.0409692042,
0.0092883529,
-0.0212667994,
0.0371014662,
-0.0233273711,
0.0036725141,
-0.0756644458,
-0.0361823626,
-0.0059449798,
0.0236620381,
-0.0036197631,
0.0183413886,
0.0118798483,
0.078580454,
-0.0692943409,
-0.0128150694,
-0.0303868074,
-0.0198835563,
0.0387823097,
-0.0148272458,
0.0771217272,
0.0361179449,
-0.0223475136,
0.0247970559,
0.0092827799,
-0.0181355141,
-0.0376666784,
0.0189918783,
-0.0020522773,
0.0360248163,
-0.0366031379,
-0.0363926329,
-0.0450208224,
0.0224369038,
0.0646970496,
-0.0578557141,
-0.0242077727,
0.0272753742,
2.629e-7,
0.0234163553,
0.0422711894,
0.0207213685,
0.0202542748,
0.0322387367,
0.0168404188,
-0.0414461978,
-0.0074880347,
0.0145262964,
-0.0248985197,
0.0194846317,
0.0125189163,
0.0180866513,
0.0117068058,
-0.0774955824,
-0.0073772059,
-0.0863952264,
0.0196344052,
-0.0199185424,
-0.0129481489,
-0.0076498599,
0.0996134654,
-0.001227138,
-0.0040696771,
-0.0175258145,
-0.0429014228,
0.0819511712,
-0.0044721165,
0.0431102738,
0.0009763648,
-0.069183588,
0.0261453781,
0.0043556704,
0.0244587157,
-0.0027007048,
0.0528526939,
-0.0196292624,
0.0232100356,
0.0153168365,
-0.0025647639,
0.0017997411,
-0.0059725572,
0.0048536123,
-0.0478526875,
0.0402601063,
-0.1385815889,
-0.0039481926,
-0.0311383065,
0.0261140931,
-0.0328336284,
-0.0222372785,
0.0149684837,
-0.0002660155,
0.0172087383,
0.0175218545,
0.0280422177,
0.0138659403,
-0.092565991,
-0.0444372967,
0.0180705674,
-0.06285768,
-0.0326419808,
-0.0406048633,
-0.006147889,
0.0294807535,
-0.0274724551,
-0.0200632755,
2.586241167e-34,
0.011906269,
-0.0148530314,
0.0529329367,
0.0457498841,
0.0014370785,
-0.0279503036,
0.0212989822,
0.0082128588,
0.0616265312,
-0.0931211412,
-0.0320035294
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.07924v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.07924v1 | Improving Accented Speech Recognition with Multi-Domain Training | 2023-03-14T14:10:16 | 2023-03-14T14:10:16 | Lucas Maison, Yannick Estève | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Thanks to the rise of self-supervised learning, automatic speech recognition
(ASR) systems now achieve near-human performance on a wide variety of datasets.
However, they still lack generalization capability and are not robust to domain
shifts like accent variations. In this work, we use speech audio representing
four different French accents to create fine-tuning datasets that improve the
robustness of pre-trained ASR models. By incorporating various accents in the
training set, we obtain both in-domain and out-of-domain improvements. Our
numerical experiments show that we can reduce error rates by up to 25%
(relative) on African and Belgian accents compared to single-domain training
while keeping a good performance on standard French. | [
-0.0592743643,
0.0654720888,
0.0209792051,
0.0262769088,
0.0006813822,
-0.0131849786,
0.0863478631,
-0.057217855,
-0.0276500098,
0.0166168604,
-0.0905339792,
-0.0649749488,
-0.0003603095,
0.0047065658,
0.0386149436,
-0.0296421647,
-0.0021695623,
-0.0764856264,
-0.0295982882,
-0.0591741949,
0.0363180228,
0.0324223861,
-0.0470006205,
0.0211272836,
-0.0076086437,
0.0526085012,
-0.0076667904,
0.0504225455,
0.0293726511,
-0.0173905436,
-0.0118346158,
0.0259193443,
0.0043145986,
-0.0182370357,
0.0000020692,
-0.0256287139,
-0.0325749293,
-0.0015338226,
-0.0461557135,
0.0194166247,
0.0220660158,
0.0064844848,
-0.0331943929,
0.0263855252,
-0.0037552037,
-0.0251056422,
0.0617090724,
0.005151107,
0.0134840859,
0.0648845658,
-0.014188922,
-0.0531125329,
-0.0494746752,
-0.0360484235,
-0.0771646053,
-0.0252247099,
-0.0095490804,
-0.0420024879,
-0.044575952,
-0.0350585617,
0.0052223485,
0.0113324625,
0.0024274974,
0.0151175363,
-0.0226370823,
-0.0014323102,
0.0046362663,
-0.0122227799,
-0.0126985321,
0.0446246415,
-0.008489484,
-0.0147240981,
-0.0250287447,
-0.0033288687,
-0.0175819024,
-0.00284202,
0.0138409352,
-0.0258121174,
0.0107335197,
0.0001349562,
-0.0135130221,
0.0761578083,
0.029935386,
-0.0379340388,
-0.0759210438,
0.0130767655,
-0.0058780643,
-0.0198568571,
0.0422589108,
-0.0222868323,
-0.0324474238,
0.0572169945,
0.0450556241,
0.001869315,
0.003788105,
-0.0329384692,
0.0070465812,
-0.0018926428,
-0.0004027378,
0.0136505216,
0.0191735476,
0.0359084904,
-0.0875743777,
-0.0155476974,
0.0088334484,
0.033082176,
-0.0253658965,
-0.0230385847,
-0.0162060857,
-0.0042138426,
-0.0463199355,
0.0172456726,
-0.0541286357,
0.0064317686,
-0.0149018466,
0.0399400964,
-0.0200209189,
-0.056291271,
-0.0056921043,
-0.0222973228,
0.0625116006,
-0.0002465144,
-0.0608829781,
-0.0540369935,
0.0431013256,
0.0706980079,
-0.0130662378,
0.0511152111,
-0.0033353898,
-0.0857240111,
-0.0167163033,
-0.0188996121,
0.0613251366,
-0.0078580249,
0.0285434686,
0.0523317754,
0.0023584985,
-0.0239549745,
-0.0350167155,
0.0023147268,
-0.0313095301,
-0.0503878705,
-0.0276158992,
-0.0761972368,
0.0251913108,
-0.015450431,
0.0407773592,
-0.0772169009,
-0.024420267,
-0.0583478585,
0.0530653968,
0.0906231925,
-0.0165763665,
0.01452359,
0.0656489208,
-0.0133796921,
-0.011181701,
0.0720698535,
-0.008235313,
-0.0548800156,
-0.0081219738,
-0.0420833491,
0.0087522147,
0.0836101845,
0.0337281562,
0.001793496,
-0.0026167608,
-0.022863498,
-0.0127558699,
0.0107783712,
0.083120577,
0.0173721686,
-0.0170027912,
-0.0299044978,
0.0414599627,
-0.0087532662,
0.0171344783,
0.0166089572,
0.0309223291,
0.0021168692,
0.0272535551,
-0.0032119229,
0.0022224162,
-0.0416932553,
0.0215733964,
0.0047940165,
-0.009675798,
0.0662350208,
-0.0538757257,
-0.0012772185,
0.0282137711,
-0.0318735354,
-0.0008056515,
0.0263653491,
0.0585503653,
0.0150124496,
-0.0252736863,
-0.0168560389,
0.0094627896,
-0.0510523394,
0.036195036,
-0.0074724844,
-0.0366315693,
0.0186087657,
-0.0204365142,
-0.0293671433,
-0.0424370691,
-0.0492921658,
0.0292826556,
0.0055951229,
0.0175064337,
0.0078091039,
0.1008329913,
-0.0746373162,
-0.0014574138,
0.0120700253,
-0.032683026,
0.0619667731,
-0.0466910452,
0.0498780161,
-0.0055924691,
-0.024553895,
0.0458651148,
-0.0144077614,
-0.0315834284,
-0.0155159878,
0.0286387894,
0.0258309171,
0.0366482809,
0.0336042531,
-0.0525686778,
-0.0288118813,
0.0066936808,
-0.0292513724,
0.040764831,
0.0406353176,
-0.0547695309,
0.0005021847,
0.0704196841,
-0.01996346,
-0.0032396566,
0.0263764299,
0.0184309315,
-0.0618012473,
0.0310858078,
0.0104112821,
0.0166619197,
-0.0422550589,
0.0490553454,
0.0437461473,
0.0234785601,
0.0144599788,
-0.007691469,
0.0424130782,
-0.0171550661,
0.0000446513,
0.0467492342,
0.0235873796,
-0.0389746204,
-0.0086933291,
-0.0199693255,
-0.0248833597,
0.0289860368,
0.0243051425,
-0.0057979431,
-0.0005308109,
0.0214402955,
-0.0482269488,
-0.0085178129,
-0.0410847217,
0.0446492955,
-0.0269832294,
0.0456668027,
-0.0266761854,
-0.057614103,
-0.0162297022,
-0.041504804,
-0.0443298928,
-0.0145214982,
-0.0275546852,
-0.0181825534,
-0.0049462509,
0.014652458,
0.0193085279,
0.0286074355,
-0.0051949075,
-0.0522099659,
0.0167584009,
-0.0327614918,
0.0136229945,
0.0282248519,
0.0423700325,
0.0069513712,
-0.0571308658,
-0.045875039,
-0.0123395128,
0.0116466284,
-0.0007830968,
-0.0116382577,
-0.0159042515,
0.0268311501,
-0.0125754215,
-0.0405039601,
-0.0015258356,
0.0025423591,
0.025675403,
-0.0272930674,
0.0461931936,
-0.0489994772,
0.0103872735,
0.0377366841,
0.0391460843,
-0.0178508349,
0.0016222507,
0.0102023119,
-0.039119646,
-0.0163294617,
0.0147297252,
-0.0109226825,
0.012652792,
0.0016332165,
0.0010118857,
0.0419507511,
-0.0749179274,
-0.0382218622,
-0.0346735194,
-0.0584337041,
0.0161281619,
-0.0050561293,
-0.0275331736,
0.0117500341,
0.0370635651,
-0.0505244173,
-0.0123424642,
0.0231125876,
0.0372615606,
-0.0294391103,
0.0732404962,
0.017061796,
-0.0244206954,
0.0035125003,
-0.0733270347,
0.0028289212,
-0.000808896,
-0.0488053188,
-0.0063604405,
0.0227097571,
-0.0197042394,
0.0113191409,
0.0124423234,
0.008025581,
0.1004019976,
-0.0077030621,
0.0034134111,
-0.0006204903,
0.0335556604,
-0.0029097698,
0.0637540147,
-0.0442917198,
-0.0137589797,
0.053496886,
-0.047308147,
0.0145566734,
-0.0463059209,
-0.0880714729,
-0.0094720172,
0.027983861,
-0.0135193979,
-0.0032411334,
-0.0188343208,
0.0596067607,
-0.0182910599,
-0.0062880665,
0.0807287917,
-0.0041331085,
0.0165348817,
-0.0076911119,
-0.0162670184,
0.0108005069,
0.0132482657,
-0.0268237349,
-0.0441375859,
-0.0402688459,
0.0372532196,
0.0169961266,
0.0185701791,
0.0605452769,
0.0275663976,
-0.1028112173,
0.0351377688,
0.0135206301,
-0.058885552,
-0.0247370135,
-0.0482408181,
-0.0526372679,
-0.092027545,
0.0421141163,
-0.023234278,
0.0082221637,
-0.0513674244,
0.0571657121,
-0.0649380162,
-0.0929596201,
-0.0215322748,
-0.0766544119,
0.0804779381,
0.0307198577,
-0.0091382135,
-0.026956182,
-0.0022410625,
0.0264910385,
0.0056689433,
0.0389881209,
-0.019733198,
0.0354914516,
0.0459721722,
-0.0247359835,
0.047253795,
0.00358733,
-0.0185365099,
0.0150539316,
0.0594670586,
0.0223627202,
-0.0418927222,
0.0683384016,
0.0137499925,
0.0055847075,
0.0014824786,
0.022371335,
0.0026574577,
-0.0293428805,
0.0113544269,
-0.0009473891,
0.0307337996,
-0.0451420769,
-0.0264546163,
0.0319039859,
0.009853431,
-0.043504402,
-0.0103663784,
0.0054072635,
-0.0026489412,
0.0612569638,
0.0133879958,
-0.011027311,
-0.0082730632,
0.0595028736,
-0.0248228628,
0.0175845195,
-0.0079908706,
0.0128173372,
-0.0388403051,
0.0025003448,
0.0468790494,
-0.0884138197,
0.0060298215,
-0.0032409935,
0.0074599967,
-0.0551203415,
0.0287747644,
0.0219790768,
0.0125691006,
0.0746782273,
-0.0330465771,
-0.0578527376,
0.0508208163,
0.0190013219,
-0.0237582456,
-0.0291393809,
0.095319204,
-0.0367323235,
-0.0264201909,
-0.0059270407,
-0.0098508988,
0.0944081321,
-0.0258324966,
-0.0135704968,
-0.0106918076,
-0.0491037592,
0.0008835113,
0.0325498395,
0.0840482265,
-0.0211266782,
0.0360257961,
-0.0263736676,
0.0344658792,
-0.0049808407,
0.0572572239,
0.0028075175,
-0.0157999955,
0.0376005918,
0.0068627796,
-0.0082996162,
0.0013284626,
0.0061532501,
-0.0660551116,
-0.0172781833,
0.0645401925,
0.0228326879,
0.0496091992,
0.0191380978,
0.0378718711,
0.0146154016,
0.0438176505,
0.0611550063,
-0.0033058045,
-0.02360221,
-0.0025996007,
0.0103961909,
0.0106672049,
-0.0038886147,
0.0110439286,
-0.0168078206,
0.0235871337,
-0.0243446492,
-0.0362253748,
0.0625614747,
-0.0240223017,
0.067725718,
0.0057559907,
0.0162209794,
-0.0334273204,
0.0073233005,
-0.0114146303,
0.0335624516,
-0.0014053244,
-0.0157218147,
-0.0116698397,
0.0256997589,
0.0398073606,
-0.0183939561,
0.0357914902,
0.0174272973,
0.0540313013,
-0.0413201526,
-0.0125067877,
-0.0129185002,
-0.0134223271,
-0.0493721217,
-0.0379157476,
0.0255353097,
-0.0680228248,
0.0258627925,
0.0107240593,
0.0279968195,
-0.0102826552,
0.0152246673,
-0.0147734089,
-0.0409941971,
0.0283784829,
0.0281430222,
-0.0173235089,
-0.0181968845,
0.011793918,
0.0427055135,
-5.811748763e-33,
0.0197168496,
0.0407411084,
-0.0097364867,
0.0448194742,
0.000822511,
-0.0158994012,
0.0017174046,
0.0343055613,
-0.0268428586,
-0.0042333468,
-0.011637981,
-0.0103162806,
0.0487136729,
0.00700203,
-0.0118517661,
-0.0004521098,
0.1124370247,
-0.0232512243,
-0.0109963054,
-0.0324145034,
0.0221283454,
0.0769424066,
0.0261830017,
-0.0749815032,
-0.0807843581,
0.0036535684,
-0.0450253896,
-0.012288644,
0.0172249209,
0.0664446801,
0.0227307118,
0.060869582,
-0.0278349519,
-0.0520618297,
-0.0137452632,
-0.0212316401,
-0.1335673183,
-0.00640414,
-0.0415327363,
0.0539408959,
0.0305170082,
-0.0303780381,
0.0283317957,
0.0143072642,
-0.0537050106,
0.0024658705,
-0.0010265515,
-0.056657739,
0.0188405048,
-0.024689598,
-0.0150265219,
0.050151065,
0.0091129076,
-0.002151645,
0.0832502842,
0.0387747288,
-0.0277012568,
-0.0513102785,
-0.0703860819,
0.0179579239,
-0.0046304311,
0.0196839888,
0.0243771169,
-0.0088630458,
-0.0244897623,
0.0132416934,
0.0771240741,
-0.0676737651,
0.0206924118,
-0.0166604407,
0.0712691993,
0.0151897268,
0.0144550912,
0.0525470562,
0.0497180633,
-0.0392727591,
-0.0591504946,
0.022170173,
0.0104212724,
-0.0287066847,
-0.0065152817,
0.0119841397,
-0.0247059707,
0.0267248042,
-0.0470444895,
0.0112689212,
-0.0131129641,
-0.0374562405,
0.034339685,
-0.0142516475,
0.0102801584,
0.0586587265,
0.054611247,
0.0224395655,
-0.0043323846,
-0.0134558668,
0.0039869687,
-0.0197136663,
-0.0127110165,
0.0385645591,
-0.0131897507,
-0.036707893,
-0.004799461,
0.0648691878,
0.0261613484,
-0.0245155245,
0.0697202384,
0.0668390468,
-0.0855334625,
-0.002208062,
0.0108816745,
0.026639618,
0.0108446218,
0.0372065715,
0.0385549217,
-0.0269874688,
0.0206886847,
0.0348828509,
0.0157185923,
-0.0370596647,
0.0114915064,
-0.016796615,
0.0201575812,
0.0280711278,
-0.0120369429,
-0.0113485688,
0.0115261627,
-0.0654976144,
-0.0050179902,
-0.0150880003,
-0.0398869142,
-0.0139363455,
2.745e-7,
-0.0202349424,
-0.0057538468,
0.0542498901,
0.0081540477,
-0.0156426635,
0.012537552,
-0.0514910184,
-0.0188909099,
-0.0352378152,
0.0167011153,
0.0166559406,
0.001833488,
0.0684889257,
0.0438164547,
-0.065897502,
-0.030370418,
0.0064143781,
0.027112253,
0.0182441566,
0.0083004339,
-0.0252280049,
0.0828686655,
-0.0243335515,
-0.0427263677,
-0.004326697,
-0.0030928624,
0.0248718821,
0.0046064178,
0.0255144965,
-0.0284056868,
-0.005815126,
0.0314512551,
-0.030596327,
0.0273940656,
-0.0301540606,
0.0314066894,
0.0050817123,
-0.0039789518,
-0.0200959779,
-0.0148524707,
0.035098955,
0.0166707821,
-0.0178955384,
0.0276118331,
0.0397140197,
-0.0110889496,
0.0003341235,
-0.0373095907,
-0.0645130649,
0.002540224,
0.0377922729,
-0.0261230171,
0.026575977,
0.0048410906,
0.0206714589,
-0.0030153044,
-0.0491317697,
-0.0454481132,
0.0048787477,
0.0387299582,
-0.0146829151,
0.0437150672,
0.0156621076,
0.0134321433,
-0.0009578214,
-0.0379278623,
0.0225093141,
1.828346924e-34,
0.0110498518,
-0.0441513099,
0.0196159557,
0.0234798938,
-0.0159109477,
-0.063393712,
-0.0306679793,
0.0028934856,
-0.0049184803,
0.0327341594,
-0.0279621016
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.07914v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.07914v2 | Adapting Offline Speech Translation Models for Streaming with Future-Aware Distillation and Inference | 2023-03-14T13:56:36 | 2023-10-26T11:27:24 | Biao Fu, Minpeng Liao, Kai Fan, Zhongqiang Huang, Boxing Chen, Yidong Chen, Xiaodong Shi | cs.CL | cs.CL | A popular approach to streaming speech translation is to employ a single
offline model with a wait-k policy to support different latency requirements,
which is simpler than training multiple online models with different latency
constraints. However, there is a mismatch problem in using a model trained with
complete utterances for streaming inference with partial input. We demonstrate
that speech representations extracted at the end of a streaming input are
significantly different from those extracted from a complete utterance. To
address this issue, we propose a new approach called Future-Aware Streaming
Translation (FAST) that adapts an offline ST model for streaming input. FAST
includes a Future-Aware Inference (FAI) strategy that incorporates future
context through a trainable masked embedding, and a Future-Aware Distillation
(FAD) framework that transfers future context from an approximation of full
speech to streaming input. Our experiments on the MuST-C EnDe, EnEs, and EnFr
benchmarks show that FAST achieves better trade-offs between translation
quality and latency than strong baselines. Extensive analyses suggest that our
methods effectively alleviate the aforementioned mismatch problem between
offline training and online inference. | [
0.0008232296,
0.0911227763,
0.0004000735,
-0.0188101977,
-0.0166510809,
-0.0089774709,
0.0258327443,
-0.002261206,
-0.0548547059,
0.0161244664,
0.0382144526,
-0.0642022043,
0.0049098502,
0.0548246689,
0.0087383045,
-0.0517864041,
0.0364247672,
-0.0174359642,
-0.0139884986,
0.003526947,
-0.0027950904,
0.0090134889,
-0.0259594079,
0.0186677165,
-0.0054666731,
-0.0108124595,
-0.0237205941,
0.0228809584,
0.0337309055,
-0.0159696545,
-0.0300935786,
-0.0049529658,
0.0829634666,
0.0236533079,
0.0000018897,
-0.0194880497,
-0.0327969752,
0.0044204686,
-0.0660737231,
-0.025147602,
0.0189473797,
-0.0387406163,
-0.0280200019,
0.0272280816,
-0.0033042247,
-0.0133004449,
0.0293415338,
-0.0232188981,
0.0242444631,
0.0696648434,
-0.0166454222,
-0.0420998968,
0.0478742309,
-0.029621629,
-0.0371479541,
-0.0248954296,
-0.0215278789,
-0.0176338833,
-0.0631072,
-0.0044360706,
-0.0359280519,
0.0525763221,
-0.007023396,
0.0162855946,
-0.008593116,
0.0053205015,
-0.0501663424,
-0.0553654246,
-0.0258659571,
0.0643457323,
-0.0185108334,
0.0117806997,
0.0212364141,
-0.0053419396,
-0.038941931,
-0.0540480129,
-0.0336659849,
0.0262514967,
0.0156087345,
-0.0065358044,
-0.0073337699,
0.0588174835,
0.0140124885,
-0.0009276324,
-0.0301003139,
0.0010148028,
0.0138729587,
-0.0130868768,
-0.0288780071,
-0.03211933,
-0.0410892479,
-0.0068657957,
0.0710340291,
-0.0091188289,
-0.027300939,
0.019694563,
-0.0336598083,
-0.0122001581,
-0.0665604547,
0.0244953074,
0.0211978946,
0.1117659882,
-0.0134663368,
0.0248227529,
-0.0338419825,
0.0377681032,
-0.0137598012,
-0.029211225,
-0.0305979084,
-0.0121969096,
-0.017919926,
0.0152437268,
-0.01496391,
0.0175150894,
-0.0816945508,
-0.0442540981,
-0.0070394618,
0.0270103198,
-0.0399123579,
0.0151472073,
0.0255340878,
0.0013178844,
-0.0804562345,
-0.029430002,
0.0149326632,
0.0807810053,
0.0072011682,
0.0381447673,
0.019804446,
-0.0858147368,
-0.0381202437,
-0.0021550222,
0.0307076052,
0.0082431016,
-0.0096050492,
0.0334996022,
0.0064724335,
0.0201373212,
-0.0002480676,
-0.0180556737,
-0.0048971525,
-0.057342995,
0.0331101902,
-0.0335659236,
0.0287111681,
-0.0132576665,
0.0434455089,
-0.0246077888,
-0.0110702692,
-0.0322670899,
0.0449544378,
0.0542474948,
0.0358378813,
0.0383786224,
0.0192533471,
-0.0030392157,
-0.0469752252,
0.0827728733,
0.0185401645,
-0.0175692961,
0.0152493538,
-0.0069362265,
-0.0691282824,
0.0527156591,
0.0397383682,
0.0490813665,
-0.0480691604,
-0.0110769011,
0.0024135192,
0.0550175831,
0.0568078458,
0.0073017026,
-0.0269135684,
0.008072542,
0.0737839639,
0.0272746254,
0.0414364822,
0.0038084562,
0.028097542,
0.0632811934,
-0.0433347858,
0.0231636968,
0.0036973441,
0.0493469201,
0.0493013449,
0.0295126177,
0.0504606813,
0.0718794763,
-0.0352904648,
-0.0198226068,
-0.0015041941,
-0.0050528776,
0.0029152918,
0.0087934434,
0.0285431948,
0.0294177029,
-0.0703080371,
0.0362830423,
-0.0214863066,
-0.0358894952,
0.0201198198,
-0.0266534649,
0.0108093834,
0.0492836572,
0.0389121659,
0.0232886486,
-0.0521473177,
-0.0463536493,
0.0213058777,
0.026607424,
-0.0047844369,
-0.0026466069,
0.0818930492,
-0.0289559085,
-0.0200271998,
0.0552908108,
0.0267025847,
0.0280141924,
-0.0119674178,
0.0495172031,
0.0286106206,
-0.0148362312,
-0.0079452498,
-0.0110447118,
-0.0335826091,
0.0015936261,
0.0020231178,
0.0253482237,
0.0509346537,
-0.0055169151,
-0.0207341537,
-0.0000586794,
0.0268291831,
-0.0377266444,
-0.0012906905,
0.053419169,
-0.0878906325,
-0.0684921369,
0.0379293263,
-0.0379588306,
0.0591221228,
0.0775498152,
-0.0205445308,
-0.0664053559,
0.0136648919,
0.033478003,
0.0471305326,
-0.0231416486,
0.0271318834,
0.04087805,
0.0086599151,
0.0656487569,
-0.010509951,
-0.0328729041,
0.0263820142,
0.0236292332,
-0.0099949436,
-0.0202956982,
-0.0730891004,
0.0013022972,
0.0288680233,
-0.0193835273,
-0.0020625531,
-0.0066884928,
-0.0172319077,
-0.0265673529,
0.0218857303,
-0.0395619832,
0.0287438687,
-0.0268410817,
0.0337633528,
0.0260355622,
0.035292197,
-0.0147735253,
-0.0221410133,
0.0088492576,
-0.03028748,
-0.0007639427,
-0.0032994668,
-0.0550746098,
0.0089740334,
0.0061327773,
0.0130724004,
0.0014170904,
0.0319209173,
0.0132393446,
-0.0855815113,
-0.0403728746,
-0.0424855351,
-0.0066199861,
-0.0201827586,
0.0101422165,
-0.0175858848,
-0.0236842595,
-0.0170670506,
-0.005793829,
0.0173884705,
0.0034216349,
0.0042640595,
-0.0206660777,
-0.002451245,
-0.0328564458,
-0.0606118999,
0.0121234711,
-0.0008785204,
0.0023233178,
-0.0016664562,
0.0044129123,
-0.0303072259,
0.0317632109,
-0.0151246572,
0.0101570589,
-0.0591450632,
-0.037969932,
-0.007406937,
-0.0240177568,
-0.0283455197,
0.0004679486,
-0.0503179617,
-0.0000086437,
-0.0026681498,
-0.059025608,
0.0595053285,
-0.0339643434,
-0.0517712086,
-0.0332297757,
-0.0184595101,
0.0075555239,
0.0244604312,
-0.0286957007,
-0.0054251212,
-0.0128612518,
-0.0118719209,
-0.0616833121,
0.035161294,
0.0081073409,
-0.0353628099,
-0.0176217463,
-0.0397987552,
-0.027795231,
-0.0103915539,
-0.0007862535,
-0.0119063416,
-0.0354493335,
-0.0074168933,
0.0028173889,
-0.0106487274,
-0.0056226784,
-0.0104842559,
0.021487752,
-0.0356575325,
0.0832494274,
-0.0237843767,
0.0174508449,
-0.0136366701,
0.0407019071,
0.0357011966,
0.0294339787,
0.0110891908,
0.0196237713,
0.0777429044,
0.0020450703,
0.0945683643,
-0.0405717231,
-0.0111479359,
-0.0073879599,
0.0487204008,
0.0330825485,
-0.0399279296,
0.0453306511,
0.0491858721,
-0.043269489,
0.0143688507,
0.092620708,
-0.0110101784,
0.0250400342,
0.0027553758,
0.0033966932,
0.0631925017,
0.0082740616,
-0.0018483915,
-0.0962309167,
-0.0282895453,
0.0244525131,
0.0437376238,
0.0041560098,
-0.0044008992,
-0.0559927896,
-0.0664821044,
0.0547064096,
0.0668915212,
-0.005164918,
-0.0170636177,
-0.0021076715,
-0.0361430794,
-0.0060720863,
0.0465857424,
-0.0102812313,
0.0377967879,
-0.0121799083,
0.0316488072,
-0.0306275766,
-0.0424884185,
0.0111549515,
-0.0105574569,
0.0681222826,
0.0248910449,
0.0411905013,
0.0259698257,
-0.0544581227,
0.0475122258,
-0.0866596997,
-0.0009727168,
-0.0121935988,
0.0310666133,
-0.0230432246,
0.0136694405,
0.0122062443,
0.0173901916,
0.0400986373,
0.0088874381,
-0.019285636,
0.0638003573,
-0.0106123602,
-0.0016022718,
0.0273818318,
-0.0000411064,
0.0748955756,
0.041259788,
-0.0205316022,
0.0032091362,
-0.0068535698,
0.005427571,
0.0244319383,
-0.0164608136,
0.0357852802,
-0.0327859297,
-0.0222515576,
-0.0328715369,
-0.0509267747,
0.0173228011,
-0.0307899024,
0.0389478095,
-0.023514282,
0.0272553768,
0.0123690199,
0.0226939451,
-0.0295803789,
0.0216503181,
0.0006850154,
0.0327405147,
-0.0000937899,
0.0095207207,
0.0604422092,
-0.0434165522,
-0.0085276272,
0.033280924,
-0.121690698,
-0.0558626726,
-0.0062976666,
0.0027518952,
0.0230803806,
0.0948821083,
-0.0418272913,
0.001074448,
0.058797475,
-0.0298990663,
-0.0709545761,
-0.0036504194,
0.0727522671,
-0.0013003803,
-0.0030561385,
0.0526315197,
-0.0193714518,
0.0385267027,
-0.060284026,
0.0455498062,
0.0327317454,
0.0026098476,
-0.0076087131,
0.0078881662,
0.0635997579,
-0.0032634542,
-0.044052504,
-0.0137176262,
0.0625073239,
0.0109083289,
0.0230334401,
-0.0322587863,
0.0251159314,
0.0394130535,
0.0048600566,
-0.0017659154,
0.0710932985,
-0.0050745937,
-0.0445441753,
-0.0140486229,
-0.0211034026,
0.0154236453,
-0.0432907306,
0.0095778592,
0.0114175705,
0.0066145649,
0.0061063608,
0.0155242467,
0.011263608,
-0.0454658456,
0.0298621468,
-0.0104744341,
0.0437186584,
0.0115963267,
0.0049060853,
-0.0781819895,
-0.0288249888,
-0.0108100018,
0.0127264922,
0.0005942022,
0.0165263657,
0.0783810988,
0.0172774494,
-0.0005008646,
-0.0319155008,
0.0251834597,
-0.0613664463,
-0.0434429422,
0.0408100523,
-0.0133299371,
-0.0130554456,
0.0543007553,
0.0246297326,
-0.0023834924,
0.0472100005,
-0.0315248631,
0.0043460545,
-0.0176992994,
-0.0262997597,
-0.0759708285,
0.0491051078,
0.0023271616,
-0.0149179138,
-0.002760485,
-0.0595787726,
0.0035898942,
-0.027361095,
-0.0318169706,
-0.0586413592,
-0.0037150499,
0.0071789869,
-0.0390570275,
-0.0277039725,
-0.0301773585,
-0.0301270429,
0.0448463969,
0.0056476453,
0.0000938544,
-6.607173097e-33,
-0.0259712767,
0.0250963829,
0.0091086887,
-0.0444563553,
-0.0773028955,
-0.0043069064,
-0.038677562,
-0.0315715075,
-0.0216248557,
-0.0136975637,
-0.0238963272,
0.0730011985,
0.0536686406,
0.0044058049,
-0.0311308522,
-0.0246791095,
0.0965151191,
-0.0289451182,
-0.0266136676,
0.0166598614,
0.0500037558,
0.0275002755,
0.0475661978,
-0.0216169432,
0.0050007012,
-0.0008972456,
-0.022171123,
0.0109373061,
0.0404724367,
0.027569823,
0.0182837192,
0.023332933,
-0.0107846819,
-0.0417716689,
-0.0734205171,
-0.000064313,
-0.0929960459,
0.0105027128,
0.0252750069,
0.0447755605,
-0.007238694,
-0.0297491141,
0.016723616,
0.0213747658,
-0.0123725925,
-0.0330764279,
-0.0343849212,
-0.0428027958,
-0.0405314416,
-0.0548000447,
-0.0344690159,
0.0272944141,
-0.0190196577,
-0.0112721948,
0.0559304059,
0.0635432452,
0.0236659236,
-0.0461180769,
-0.0683498308,
0.0560491011,
-0.0323019177,
0.0474792682,
0.0825048983,
-0.0052199461,
0.0155009069,
-0.0011612352,
-0.0230672993,
-0.065928258,
0.0115792034,
-0.013693748,
0.046314951,
0.0075338599,
-0.015713267,
0.0025421618,
0.0730447844,
-0.0543679632,
-0.000490749,
0.0098440582,
0.0358426049,
0.0030923095,
0.0201072861,
0.0428605378,
0.0031656357,
-0.0216423962,
-0.0557346269,
-0.047668349,
0.0088514509,
-0.0115339039,
0.0405074209,
0.0650177374,
0.0142421359,
-0.0131223844,
0.104860872,
-0.0389030911,
0.0336347483,
0.0046045715,
-0.0341631286,
-0.0000839914,
-0.006947699,
0.0381815992,
-0.0378638692,
-0.0103576006,
0.0698202699,
0.0094663678,
-0.011723862,
-0.0426664762,
-0.0005886707,
0.062756449,
-0.0539761968,
0.0015233711,
-0.0102565624,
0.0069229035,
-0.0050310874,
0.0009000437,
0.069702819,
-0.0290885922,
-0.0082859593,
0.0141890366,
-0.0097772349,
0.0245480873,
-0.0145788733,
0.003268427,
0.05096725,
0.0375389941,
-0.0763104409,
0.0207442362,
-0.0090992609,
-0.0064178691,
0.0335679762,
-0.0333824717,
-0.0535153039,
0.0161146875,
2.75e-7,
-0.0276050493,
-0.0172320846,
0.002057069,
-0.0322376788,
0.0399428308,
-0.0249307416,
-0.0211543236,
-0.0038578799,
0.0034744034,
-0.0180487633,
0.0405862108,
-0.0095358854,
0.127649501,
0.0343135335,
-0.0618860498,
-0.0468599312,
-0.0344659053,
0.0323868282,
-0.0250324011,
-0.0375883766,
0.0231650509,
0.0923575163,
-0.0158947557,
-0.0022050068,
0.0356417783,
0.0265205707,
0.0412779897,
0.0100013632,
0.0129649453,
-0.0593804084,
-0.0089759091,
-0.0016930166,
-0.0400984138,
-0.0189473294,
-0.0394722,
0.0204066373,
0.0145049775,
0.0839536488,
0.0164012127,
-0.0467824452,
-0.0411556326,
0.0181269981,
-0.0213660393,
-0.0018054801,
0.0684391558,
-0.0121505326,
0.0122514842,
-0.0353256315,
-0.0463587455,
0.0134978686,
-0.0092354296,
0.0078094373,
0.0039849244,
0.0304618422,
0.0183994696,
0.0198259223,
-0.0251068566,
-0.0537195392,
-0.0008681603,
0.0017146427,
-0.0470748544,
-0.0715035498,
-0.0369033962,
0.0004515924,
0.0279868748,
-0.0599106438,
-0.0257406887,
2.624437845e-34,
0.0217489209,
0.011425877,
0.0044191657,
-0.0013267254,
-0.023327006,
-0.0325928442,
0.0253104903,
-0.0037102639,
0.0097332858,
-0.0309751555,
-0.0622872785
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.08572v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.08572v1 | Distinguishing Cause from Effect on Categorical Data: The Uniform Channel Model | 2023-03-14T13:54:11 | 2023-03-14T13:54:11 | Mário A. T. Figueiredo, Catarina A. Oliveira | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.IT, math.IT, 62D20 | Distinguishing cause from effect using observations of a pair of random
variables is a core problem in causal discovery. Most approaches proposed for
this task, namely additive noise models (ANM), are only adequate for
quantitative data. We propose a criterion to address the cause-effect problem
with categorical variables (living in sets with no meaningful order), inspired
by seeing a conditional probability mass function (pmf) as a discrete
memoryless channel. We select as the most likely causal direction the one in
which the conditional pmf is closer to a uniform channel (UC). The rationale is
that, in a UC, as in an ANM, the conditional entropy (of the effect given the
cause) is independent of the cause distribution, in agreement with the
principle of independence of cause and mechanism. Our approach, which we call
the uniform channel model (UCM), thus extends the ANM rationale to categorical
variables. To assess how close a conditional pmf (estimated from data) is to a
UC, we use statistical testing, supported by a closed-form estimate of a UC
channel. On the theoretical front, we prove identifiability of the UCM and show
its equivalence with a structural causal model with a low-cardinality exogenous
variable. Finally, the proposed method compares favorably with recent
state-of-the-art alternatives in experiments on synthetic, benchmark, and real
data. | [
-0.0432630815,
0.1447112262,
-0.0179776829,
-0.0333613902,
0.0186178517,
0.0352103487,
0.0332078822,
0.0284514222,
-0.0252945572,
-0.0184428915,
0.0791115537,
0.0212419331,
-0.0362388156,
-0.0106347632,
0.0571422987,
0.0446877368,
0.0502181388,
-0.0098530799,
0.016822977,
-0.0207839943,
-0.0456121452,
-0.0509410016,
-0.0208090637,
0.0061182431,
-0.0127592972,
0.0084336065,
0.0142482324,
0.0170652159,
-0.0478998348,
0.0029210586,
-0.0189618226,
0.0299074072,
0.0085994191,
0.0170388315,
0.0000023679,
-0.0457741618,
-0.0452455841,
0.0052965255,
-0.0118906787,
-0.0169773232,
-0.0822702274,
-0.0059830984,
0.0091360584,
-0.0056004259,
0.0498840958,
-0.0421166196,
0.0646848977,
-0.0088145938,
-0.0843897685,
0.0401326865,
-0.0077967951,
-0.0770810321,
0.0261178911,
-0.0434302278,
0.0696445405,
0.0302969255,
0.0377690755,
-0.0130699901,
-0.0838017762,
-0.0795000196,
-0.0482511334,
0.018368952,
0.0499727055,
0.0129239969,
0.0486158654,
0.0328047909,
0.0594731905,
0.0072630788,
0.01572497,
0.0397664979,
0.0574182495,
-0.0423477776,
0.0301533639,
-0.005159087,
0.0021373597,
0.0915398374,
-0.0235252455,
0.0171583053,
-0.0018680798,
0.0094988532,
0.0462081805,
0.0651019961,
0.0525899678,
0.0138749117,
-0.0444369465,
0.0674568117,
0.0093941269,
-0.0466227904,
-0.0219349191,
0.0354693197,
-0.00839133,
0.0072736978,
-0.0580430143,
-0.0351277404,
-0.0180143192,
-0.000270609,
0.0776459202,
0.0271916185,
-0.0298838783,
-0.067848891,
-0.036102172,
0.0336132087,
0.0227318425,
0.0031881479,
0.0338624232,
-0.0223600175,
-0.0307285748,
0.0766065866,
-0.0141168712,
0.0422497131,
-0.0189231094,
0.0021024435,
0.0381996259,
-0.0087769823,
0.0294096693,
0.0360575095,
-0.0229032803,
0.0274117123,
-0.0356342159,
-0.0026429088,
-0.0098911794,
-0.0588161573,
-0.0049968064,
0.0265435167,
-0.0226206351,
-0.0148904361,
-0.0389823467,
0.0505775362,
-0.0348014757,
-0.0149517655,
-0.0075840093,
0.0121815093,
0.0255374741,
-0.0022398271,
0.0017942127,
0.0948795453,
0.0341213718,
-0.0078329714,
-0.0299454369,
-0.0165312327,
0.0198795479,
-0.0208328962,
0.0077786492,
-0.0415712409,
-0.022003714,
0.0265631694,
0.0482253283,
0.0020231169,
-0.0371039249,
-0.0729021728,
-0.0550438538,
0.0014544468,
0.0018772592,
0.0534039587,
-0.030459635,
-0.027587669,
0.053060025,
0.0462181494,
0.0222083814,
-0.0330325738,
0.042744495,
-0.0563615113,
0.0297065172,
-0.005866698,
0.0236520283,
0.0217804648,
-0.0057256254,
-0.0574626438,
-0.0000815462,
-0.0449010096,
0.0261147469,
-0.0535971932,
-0.0341697708,
0.0222172718,
0.0446705781,
-0.0491001531,
0.0335275158,
0.0108972136,
-0.0106823305,
-0.048871506,
-0.0311935768,
0.0586628951,
-0.017137561,
0.0077511938,
-0.0382604711,
-0.0073898756,
0.110835351,
-0.0584172346,
-0.0338794105,
-0.0463923663,
-0.0045025591,
-0.0234026667,
-0.0185522102,
0.0021184431,
0.0920579359,
-0.0313376896,
0.0158852004,
0.0156180905,
0.0320502594,
-0.014131641,
0.0029748012,
0.0221845396,
0.0932782069,
0.018833328,
0.0437541641,
-0.0290339515,
0.0345620625,
-0.0197327323,
-0.0467299223,
-0.0166507438,
-0.0468168892,
0.0073018419,
0.030173948,
0.0320083648,
0.0104290377,
0.0443815254,
0.0658331439,
-0.0060090041,
-0.0226616301,
-0.0125421537,
-0.0520044677,
0.0118682561,
0.0239556991,
0.0008607678,
0.0150710372,
-0.0330556445,
0.0138952052,
-0.0074301464,
0.0568934456,
-0.0149292592,
-0.0525113568,
0.0158255585,
-0.0038062141,
-0.0646196529,
-0.0303137861,
0.0794597194,
0.0317400917,
0.0319412723,
-0.0399616659,
-0.0328473672,
0.0071683275,
0.0131325284,
-0.0027431559,
0.0114010982,
0.0791042894,
0.0219861194,
0.0335949361,
-0.0134657035,
-0.009211679,
0.0092244111,
-0.0178938266,
0.0174540821,
0.0372405611,
-0.0054986575,
0.0347025879,
-0.0674185753,
-0.0260893069,
0.0366225988,
-0.0077515645,
0.0376666375,
-0.0157851502,
-0.0270024948,
-0.011964431,
0.0357216783,
-0.0543453284,
0.02993498,
-0.0064167026,
0.0122441472,
-0.0146943815,
0.001502992,
-0.0063181296,
-0.0085787373,
-0.0100963237,
0.00110647,
0.0084206173,
0.0158666428,
-0.012977914,
0.0288861208,
0.0385890491,
-0.0088401027,
-0.0421688035,
-0.0238234345,
-0.0323661156,
-0.0102586048,
-0.0550880395,
0.0178959761,
0.05894031,
-0.0465904251,
0.0093713598,
0.0434255749,
0.0110960482,
0.0016517786,
-0.0243754126,
-0.038331233,
-0.031211609,
-0.0305498149,
-0.0446893536,
0.0147863105,
-0.0301487818,
0.0179402214,
0.0038557306,
-0.0210384764,
-0.0054835742,
-0.0221893825,
-0.0831487104,
-0.0093419701,
-0.0074416981,
-0.0650931671,
-0.005256352,
0.0615892559,
0.0247330256,
-0.0141413221,
-0.0157932024,
0.0037351716,
-0.0167276207,
-0.0376937687,
-0.0779360011,
-0.0096371928,
0.0194739625,
0.0516287424,
0.010649587,
-0.0906082466,
-0.0144650079,
0.0317847282,
0.0342267528,
-0.0125163142,
-0.0021766741,
-0.0290169716,
-0.0016838652,
0.0404357165,
-0.0160266049,
0.0080183772,
0.0107948845,
0.0037273641,
-0.0249463543,
0.0321612321,
0.0276726838,
-0.0169974472,
-0.0697906241,
0.0599852018,
0.0091774436,
-0.0463083945,
-0.0084778294,
-0.0531657524,
0.0764060244,
-0.0105684754,
0.0291805603,
-0.03392566,
0.0425613225,
0.0663851649,
0.0202439427,
0.0010346165,
0.0179783422,
-0.0108432034,
-0.0028908951,
0.0133704096,
-0.0389280505,
-0.0563104674,
0.0289177522,
-0.0591880456,
-0.0145631069,
-0.0400428064,
-0.0138873607,
0.0626600981,
-0.0128388302,
0.0243933443,
-0.0133010466,
0.0147906318,
0.0574986637,
-0.0143306898,
-0.0037237902,
0.0199140254,
-0.0090321051,
0.0510416478,
0.0071875649,
-0.0316228606,
0.0368666761,
0.0410859101,
-0.0485772304,
-0.0242338777,
-0.0171994232,
-0.0880524293,
-0.0043250807,
-0.0140636824,
-0.0332886577,
-0.057059925,
-0.0248927772,
0.0527471192,
-0.0460425541,
0.0189633314,
0.0202765316,
-0.0409626067,
-0.0261721369,
-0.0542287529,
-0.0036395758,
-0.0802344829,
-0.0694203749,
-0.0488540716,
0.0173966903,
0.010685632,
0.0271029975,
-0.0031309712,
-0.0621909946,
-0.0421287008,
-0.0357173681,
0.057157781,
0.007513823,
-0.0193502717,
-0.0665329695,
0.0088078659,
0.0137768714,
-0.0158467069,
-0.0425070412,
0.0293523762,
0.0369066224,
0.0343998931,
0.0011524038,
0.0020920525,
0.0060328874,
0.0048116613,
0.0029611951,
-0.0180505309,
-0.0114935981,
-0.0214037728,
-0.044329524,
0.0182795208,
-0.0191720054,
0.0086825043,
0.0724235401,
0.0016674924,
0.027150657,
-0.0210200306,
-0.0104386723,
0.0050407927,
0.0207932573,
-0.0070350957,
-0.0100128902,
0.0060624937,
-0.1489651501,
-0.0253812131,
0.0245713666,
-0.0234207213,
0.0033049595,
-0.0063658631,
0.011449052,
0.0086347871,
-0.0409399606,
-0.0075177238,
-0.0041030422,
0.0063553248,
0.0120736128,
-0.0254737064,
-0.0762085691,
-0.0246499926,
-0.0175942145,
-0.0612019636,
0.0375181474,
-0.055286441,
-0.047565233,
0.0171123296,
-0.0054981224,
0.0237744637,
0.01774689,
-0.0194335226,
0.0148697551,
-0.0001915676,
0.044537995,
-0.0311398804,
0.0405913182,
0.0442986898,
-0.0067444332,
0.001651398,
-0.0000129196,
0.0033508209,
0.0296223089,
-0.0191711914,
0.0202325918,
-0.0597508922,
-0.0094346162,
-0.0013614557,
-0.0283228587,
0.0501049794,
0.0280411504,
-0.0438327678,
-0.0275806561,
0.0436072201,
0.0134172486,
0.0120968418,
0.0022398615,
-0.0345901549,
0.0377508737,
0.0788559541,
-0.0211162958,
-0.0471814536,
0.0032523244,
0.0036845182,
0.0481848046,
0.0135260336,
0.0103294225,
0.024807401,
-0.0337795131,
0.0004018254,
0.0339505523,
0.0485018976,
0.0137293926,
0.0589697249,
0.0352186039,
0.0240088012,
0.015212941,
0.0008850272,
-0.0161786545,
-0.0367792286,
-0.0562481545,
0.0079162735,
0.0365123861,
-0.0248713437,
0.0251076557,
-0.0305201877,
0.0073121819,
-0.0382449515,
0.0291424878,
-0.0338070653,
0.0374335386,
0.0053233919,
0.0428363085,
0.0063488064,
-0.0209133737,
-0.0468108878,
0.0023769741,
0.024767939,
0.0673249885,
0.0389768668,
-0.1091798991,
0.0135387881,
0.0269027296,
-0.0085644471,
0.0374122709,
0.0150247766,
-0.0210651401,
0.0213530585,
-0.083115153,
-0.0003559382,
-0.052662611,
-0.009789627,
0.0715399757,
0.0322875902,
-0.025898654,
0.0002238506,
-0.0308500957,
0.0334587358,
-0.0054064356,
-0.0139499549,
-0.0640035793,
0.0082332296,
-0.0474581048,
-7.233670443e-33,
-0.0069548246,
-0.0149256699,
-0.0428715684,
0.0046257912,
0.0443091281,
-0.0006523734,
-0.0446414873,
-0.0072214361,
0.0153843379,
-0.0317130908,
0.0410687067,
0.0209713243,
0.0206883829,
-0.0107253762,
0.0274950247,
-0.0212299507,
0.0269780699,
0.0158225335,
0.0087828515,
-0.0166980512,
0.0509228893,
-0.0267993994,
0.0173037443,
-0.0566363186,
0.0196804833,
-0.001357873,
-0.0241323337,
-0.0225706194,
-0.0537215397,
0.014148403,
0.0130403386,
-0.027513843,
-0.0000223557,
-0.047524441,
0.0084631164,
-0.0250666291,
-0.0223715026,
-0.0043755397,
0.0470759571,
-0.0052857776,
-0.00168207,
-0.0683409497,
-0.0296882354,
0.0089536402,
-0.0400887504,
0.0178647116,
0.0182426628,
0.0037074503,
0.0282021314,
-0.0472415052,
-0.0173150357,
0.0317926444,
-0.033751674,
0.0456647612,
-0.0157507025,
-0.0209491663,
0.0044710618,
0.0168136247,
-0.0334417894,
0.0599206798,
0.0451876111,
0.0131804403,
-0.0179269146,
0.0208716486,
0.0613352396,
0.039898321,
0.0461927652,
-0.0220989212,
-0.0010090714,
0.0208795331,
-0.0006070087,
-0.0028341345,
0.0493835323,
0.0594520792,
0.1284402758,
-0.0112689948,
-0.0979750603,
0.0191510841,
0.0258908048,
-0.052440118,
0.0291555356,
0.0229035504,
-0.0522464328,
-0.0373031162,
-0.0231069885,
-0.0240739156,
-0.0076587074,
0.0082350699,
0.0163590591,
0.0284213852,
0.0150322076,
-0.0052069132,
0.0856932998,
-0.0205752514,
-0.0214424264,
-0.0005051207,
0.0178199541,
0.0313473716,
-0.0268446021,
-0.0602561012,
-0.049145706,
-0.0124541866,
0.0206248183,
0.0490803905,
0.0663123801,
0.0448796451,
0.0168025661,
-0.0133931246,
0.0056896796,
-0.005470315,
-0.0217892621,
-0.048236724,
0.046418108,
-0.0430617519,
0.0373130925,
0.0223029964,
-0.0060203657,
-0.0008226004,
0.026137339,
0.0705413371,
0.0223479029,
0.0374009646,
-0.0515521728,
0.0159002617,
0.0194002874,
-0.0013714301,
-0.0446628816,
-0.0053726356,
0.0076937205,
-0.0466840304,
0.0107897669,
-0.0050123632,
3.137e-7,
0.0346994735,
-0.0164557714,
0.0280920509,
0.0461004488,
0.0540271476,
0.0005140363,
-0.0188044161,
-0.0157309677,
0.0026583946,
-0.0247909278,
0.0310832486,
0.0083921971,
0.0410372466,
-0.0330713615,
-0.0037286391,
-0.0397378206,
0.0197708793,
0.0346666984,
-0.0005172486,
0.0143296346,
0.0194536764,
0.0405083448,
0.0540421642,
0.0265372526,
0.0407586135,
0.0096433423,
0.0105540752,
-0.0529872812,
-0.0050195879,
0.0035268697,
-0.0477673598,
-0.0367642194,
-0.0183472894,
0.0565524846,
-0.0092515862,
-0.0288509149,
-0.0383417755,
-0.0078198453,
0.0201346017,
0.0260857288,
-0.0160291363,
-0.0187881123,
0.0213676579,
-0.0140216388,
0.0449888632,
-0.014838486,
-0.0486960448,
0.0778576508,
-0.0155833755,
0.0639869869,
0.0246030726,
0.0379267149,
-0.0216412172,
-0.0060611833,
-0.0348444097,
0.0342134386,
0.0299565773,
0.0018188593,
-0.0217780266,
-0.0423787422,
0.0028785015,
-0.094181776,
0.0045058485,
0.0085346336,
0.0219874512,
-0.0697920322,
-0.0188024323,
3.511458765e-34,
0.0327091999,
0.0397818089,
0.0037086101,
-0.0428797975,
0.031408105,
-0.0385043621,
-0.0625386909,
-0.0031222992,
0.0253927447,
-0.0568508096,
0.0342639312
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.12804v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.12804v1 | Features matching using natural language processing | 2023-03-14T13:31:19 | 2023-03-14T13:31:19 | Muhammad Danial Khilji | cs.DB | cs.DB, cs.CL, cs.LG | The feature matching is a basic step in matching different datasets. This
article proposes shows a new hybrid model of a pretrained Natural Language
Processing (NLP) based model called BERT used in parallel with a statistical
model based on Jaccard similarity to measure the similarity between list of
features from two different datasets. This reduces the time required to search
for correlations or manually match each feature from one dataset to another. | [
0.0220359676,
0.0202636588,
-0.0175123047,
0.031825684,
-0.0568036959,
0.0299475044,
0.0063029896,
0.0203528572,
0.0102961157,
-0.0692321956,
-0.0067842859,
0.0238263458,
0.0346549526,
0.0182798281,
-0.0305714011,
-0.0576605089,
0.011069065,
0.0512535088,
0.0199371427,
0.0149073889,
0.0366616771,
0.0166975632,
-0.021479506,
0.039308656,
-0.0220450163,
0.0469065495,
0.0014187623,
-0.0222076103,
0.036555469,
-0.0055850009,
-0.0210671723,
0.0232813489,
-0.0005245705,
-0.0403394252,
0.0000017083,
-0.0986526608,
-0.0304927826,
0.0336477049,
0.0410843454,
-0.0576887615,
-0.0210071001,
0.0067860335,
0.0173294321,
0.0316394456,
-0.0215262007,
0.0320952013,
0.0619505271,
0.0788797736,
0.0434679799,
0.0542919524,
-0.0414321534,
-0.0772542208,
0.0069210087,
0.0677440912,
0.0078590242,
0.0018931747,
0.0236238129,
-0.0086251674,
0.0404801816,
-0.0456653684,
0.029293688,
0.0026922838,
-0.0670196712,
0.0389375202,
0.0283346735,
-0.0051757125,
-0.0774923712,
0.0336355157,
-0.0347868614,
0.0450958423,
-0.0620801188,
-0.0512912571,
0.0373744294,
-0.0258359779,
-0.02997973,
0.0476066656,
0.0182750132,
-0.0327253193,
-0.0702310354,
0.0124844778,
-0.0132755181,
-0.0206646882,
-0.0282262135,
-0.0437368564,
0.0013381549,
-0.0125739919,
0.0302169379,
-0.0364727937,
-0.0529453941,
-0.0282868352,
0.032675527,
-0.0627134442,
0.0397215188,
0.0507473089,
0.0174711514,
-0.0218388643,
-0.0694560856,
-0.0610239692,
0.0237092748,
-0.0827385113,
-0.0220598038,
0.0240304396,
-0.067225866,
0.0371338986,
-0.0372096784,
0.0839804038,
0.0392497778,
0.0184102338,
-0.0548483618,
-0.007370878,
-0.0951724201,
0.0042771492,
-0.0470003076,
0.0407594703,
0.0471663438,
-0.0302374884,
-0.0088610118,
-0.0050497833,
-0.0062535428,
0.016815057,
0.0152850915,
-0.009563447,
0.0284433104,
0.0283057522,
-0.0644310117,
-0.0200150087,
-0.0194224808,
0.0251633562,
-0.0945961475,
-0.0081707295,
0.0762125775,
0.0051168525,
0.0699065551,
-0.0183856562,
0.03970249,
0.0581106171,
0.0125041213,
-0.0552412793,
-0.0468964018,
0.0197107941,
0.0398004241,
-0.0071965465,
-0.028121002,
-0.051384557,
0.0553407781,
0.0228105839,
-0.0263875332,
0.0227488447,
-0.008941927,
0.0329777561,
-0.0319589749,
0.1076356918,
-0.0339101069,
0.018725276,
0.031085616,
-0.0667678416,
0.0326369368,
-0.0215280261,
-0.0004557055,
-0.0384452902,
0.0162203778,
-0.0020548513,
0.0099188155,
0.0170024149,
-0.0494532734,
-0.0631661415,
-0.0309199784,
0.0453033857,
0.0159983449,
0.017182989,
0.0086558433,
0.0406878032,
0.0093782255,
-0.0019103799,
0.0162973609,
0.1111929268,
0.0455661975,
0.0202247854,
-0.0140432008,
0.0566510521,
0.0297428593,
-0.0091004018,
0.0246105567,
0.0072595431,
-0.0676063523,
0.0023132341,
-0.0146858115,
0.0354373753,
-0.0398714691,
0.0184083208,
-0.0389656313,
-0.0212157536,
0.0259473827,
-0.0015691797,
0.032659363,
-0.0253590811,
-0.0022815962,
0.0251886901,
-0.0045581604,
0.0040960126,
-0.0732173622,
-0.0530198924,
-0.0174073745,
0.0855006054,
0.0389222279,
-0.0262214821,
-0.0108800782,
0.0068144733,
-0.045242276,
-0.0041211112,
0.0240325276,
0.0078238463,
-0.059012372,
-0.0381643064,
-0.056503199,
0.0279530901,
-0.0153109822,
0.0016822575,
-0.019456055,
0.0436382554,
0.0091202771,
0.0152469575,
-0.0110598169,
0.0512618199,
-0.0022592582,
0.0195262115,
-0.0190760214,
0.0350634754,
0.0054370598,
0.0168933105,
-0.0100582708,
0.0290932972,
-0.0119802859,
-0.0205866527,
-0.0101272007,
0.0434976295,
0.0514923222,
-0.0133744376,
0.0571056493,
-0.0500752293,
0.0167477336,
0.0208160914,
-0.0052308859,
-0.0411321111,
-0.0097032432,
-0.0365496799,
0.0480596572,
-0.031082714,
0.0578057691,
-0.0346838683,
-0.0250832234,
-0.0535594821,
0.04400694,
0.0485544801,
0.0176075567,
-0.0286263395,
-0.0452634171,
0.0448562875,
-0.0215709917,
-0.0383828394,
-0.0041080741,
-0.000299413,
0.0400162712,
0.0416743159,
-0.0071990821,
0.0347087495,
0.0073089441,
-0.0814263523,
-0.0015020327,
0.0335566737,
0.0064806319,
0.0464591086,
-0.0098503632,
-0.0068867616,
-0.0125165582,
-0.030161107,
0.0225688834,
0.0184758324,
-0.0436477438,
0.0295953862,
-0.0139195817,
-0.0351097099,
-0.0468949303,
0.0183192268,
-0.0357318819,
0.0200311337,
0.0596955754,
-0.0757672787,
-0.0272819027,
0.0268302001,
-0.0381932035,
0.0363510549,
0.0143664787,
-0.0100878142,
0.0092343548,
0.0119031807,
0.00743521,
-0.0140889501,
0.0144964112,
-0.0610875934,
0.0276998058,
0.0047879503,
-0.0349439457,
0.013501429,
-0.0199684892,
0.0506790392,
0.0199511703,
-0.0209766235,
0.0334464088,
-0.0327728875,
0.0209505539,
-0.0121860886,
-0.0237623863,
-0.0251845308,
0.0401815958,
0.053213574,
-0.0613439679,
-0.0418531932,
0.0162272174,
0.0083666788,
-0.0207826346,
-0.0234179683,
0.0401174203,
-0.0423825979,
0.0580128953,
-0.0910833105,
-0.0007000496,
-0.0347730182,
0.0617312305,
0.0429281928,
0.033009015,
-0.0227278173,
0.006116882,
0.033108782,
-0.0018475136,
0.0688070431,
-0.0233494639,
0.0059997896,
-0.0179484915,
0.083138369,
-0.0057930178,
-0.0124071371,
-0.049385272,
-0.0091390843,
-0.0519172959,
0.0131371496,
0.0150126191,
-0.0651595742,
-0.0038626236,
0.0458546765,
0.0101502873,
0.0573676154,
0.0458665602,
0.0033610668,
-0.01435115,
0.0168407205,
0.0247987993,
-0.0152260121,
-0.0357978418,
0.0489261858,
-0.0074012051,
-0.0244021416,
0.0105872685,
0.0243090298,
-0.0555722006,
0.0010242402,
-0.0040051583,
-0.0576461703,
0.0135522494,
0.0156211508,
0.0048404881,
0.0076132664,
0.0434228592,
0.0883749053,
0.0387181416,
0.0078546302,
-0.0335137583,
-0.0234178212,
-0.0733516291,
0.0142979585,
0.0316310562,
-0.026801981,
-0.0336050205,
0.0232304633,
-0.0331709012,
-0.0199847333,
-0.0163331982,
-0.0114687253,
-0.0898388252,
-0.0250547826,
-0.0425042547,
-0.0372142829,
-0.0657439157,
-0.0787761882,
0.0104541341,
0.0021264451,
-0.0415767692,
-0.0243194457,
-0.0245511197,
-0.025817275,
0.0036977965,
-0.0835948363,
-0.0492082462,
0.0230008662,
-0.0785313323,
0.0086946469,
0.0838401318,
0.0432151221,
-0.0083553148,
-0.0350001343,
-0.0328769386,
0.0512888394,
0.0144365784,
0.0018201021,
0.0280667767,
-0.0021884101,
-0.0286581609,
-0.0319312513,
-0.023484651,
0.0288141221,
-0.0060065435,
-0.0115198037,
-0.0033638193,
-0.0525344945,
0.0078559527,
-0.0343331099,
-0.0120317135,
-0.0213447157,
0.053593535,
-0.0133264344,
0.0144364676,
-0.0251071639,
0.0506349653,
0.0039111986,
0.0236829743,
-0.0113648279,
0.0165335126,
-0.0623728186,
-0.0310769472,
-0.0871616229,
0.0104622338,
0.02935737,
-0.0177066643,
0.0362357274,
0.0186579563,
0.0455446281,
-0.0035855584,
-0.0903013572,
0.0246356893,
0.0256101098,
0.0477293432,
-0.0513556562,
-0.0093139671,
0.0296612587,
-0.0077388738,
-0.0467016138,
-0.0424994528,
0.0001777051,
-0.0304825827,
-0.0223069433,
0.0104186749,
0.0030004482,
0.0009635842,
-0.0193598606,
-0.019713508,
-0.0131724346,
0.0363352671,
-0.0287266467,
-0.0293361787,
-0.0479910448,
-0.0344201811,
0.0114836898,
-0.0169219933,
-0.0060022529,
0.0230329484,
-0.0019091172,
0.0091960561,
0.0236802883,
-0.0547280312,
0.0415106267,
0.053425312,
0.049269326,
0.0282946844,
0.0168305356,
-0.0539265461,
0.0100603299,
0.0125865508,
0.0236566495,
-0.0242896061,
-0.0041188076,
-0.0178393126,
0.0361797735,
0.0111079505,
0.0175118241,
-0.0357264727,
-0.0339868329,
0.0061715641,
0.0345548876,
-0.0037014803,
0.0733861998,
-0.0325209759,
-0.0478286259,
0.0139021082,
-0.0075127045,
0.0167286471,
-0.0003012404,
-0.0006805905,
-0.0000539648,
0.0170963351,
0.0077583739,
-0.0237548277,
0.0509742759,
0.0078982906,
-0.0539448075,
-0.0635469854,
0.0345235541,
0.0536174737,
-0.0330997296,
-0.0402637757,
-0.0205556527,
0.0038939393,
-0.0190552864,
0.0043462603,
-0.0003560608,
0.0252553169,
0.0460528359,
-0.0096109444,
-0.0319912136,
-0.0520689636,
0.0535626113,
0.0252613407,
0.0242359079,
-0.0220982507,
-0.0622834079,
0.0016336658,
0.016167609,
0.0843058228,
0.0050532767,
-0.026319176,
-0.0111836102,
0.0263235625,
-0.0037630955,
0.0442515649,
0.0036306954,
0.0108868945,
0.0531860255,
0.0618668646,
0.0162414182,
0.0063377596,
0.0027808782,
0.0053629423,
-0.0179887563,
-0.0085786441,
-0.0077650789,
-0.0161874183,
-5.385811324e-33,
-0.0232458487,
-0.0410306863,
0.0402011871,
-0.0001144711,
0.0371535942,
-0.0117469737,
0.0571240894,
-0.0293431375,
-0.0150501756,
-0.031627737,
0.0078379586,
0.007951742,
0.0126273679,
-0.0215223078,
0.0042980942,
-0.0174787566,
0.0269951094,
0.0179449134,
0.026483994,
-0.0594057068,
0.0260022096,
0.0218388364,
0.0667384788,
-0.0664262176,
-0.045410499,
-0.0171886906,
0.0184659455,
-0.0100875646,
0.052565109,
-0.0037797294,
-0.0459448732,
0.0100946929,
0.0106578125,
0.0043190424,
-0.0102791619,
0.0241968594,
-0.0174826011,
-0.054588329,
-0.0026060117,
0.0442833863,
0.0316341035,
0.0320903733,
0.0170739219,
-0.0231072176,
-0.044145979,
0.060586635,
0.0779561996,
-0.0323922075,
0.0278306548,
-0.0079728141,
-0.0511643924,
0.0452730954,
0.0064939135,
0.0079830587,
0.0508069284,
0.0063397414,
-0.0202978551,
-0.0347069874,
-0.0237474404,
0.0136736697,
0.0383089967,
0.0083894515,
0.017481884,
-0.0069623939,
0.0641579926,
0.0739541352,
0.0210568234,
-0.0910740048,
0.0042155827,
0.0229591019,
-0.0127151534,
0.0716498792,
0.0088164331,
0.0178274289,
0.0388990603,
-0.0127250301,
-0.0324083827,
0.0782960728,
-0.0255360529,
0.0314092375,
-0.0474613458,
0.0067804819,
-0.0310453977,
0.0127688674,
-0.0193973295,
0.0602702163,
-0.0550895929,
-0.0138892028,
0.0457624756,
0.01029066,
0.0026345621,
0.0318484008,
-0.0251627807,
-0.0336745828,
-0.0196048729,
0.0051332801,
0.023544088,
-0.024084501,
-0.004729188,
0.0046598138,
-0.0312217698,
-0.0462563969,
0.0214484297,
0.0120128449,
0.0468508266,
0.0069532744,
-0.0160680693,
0.0069990042,
-0.0623874441,
0.0322269946,
0.0349444151,
-0.0816696659,
-0.0426379442,
0.0084925592,
0.0196835548,
0.0350964703,
0.0045336303,
0.0217696577,
0.0002225066,
-0.0481127799,
-0.0420579873,
-0.029825205,
-0.0045174742,
0.0187466908,
0.0207830537,
0.0243429374,
-0.0736599937,
0.0113181937,
-0.0237099659,
-0.0185944755,
0.015905099,
0.0326675139,
2.529e-7,
-0.0092291655,
0.0126499571,
0.027359454,
-0.0163976252,
-0.0221413039,
-0.0053348313,
0.0053936657,
0.0608817153,
0.0011818833,
0.0399306417,
0.0284656323,
-0.0180740636,
-0.0148701416,
0.0310527682,
-0.0495183989,
0.0281179715,
-0.0383214653,
-0.0480020493,
-0.0904075056,
0.0104222698,
0.0721911788,
0.0423401557,
0.0128939748,
-0.0012375505,
0.0138857719,
-0.0421827212,
0.0191874374,
-0.0305835549,
0.0113132009,
0.0217026826,
0.0548560061,
-0.0065930868,
-0.002469646,
0.0971877649,
-0.0161384456,
0.0530446991,
0.0358346961,
-0.0122358901,
-0.0585762635,
-0.0092957439,
-0.0130531248,
-0.0124936868,
-0.0537473932,
0.0155156842,
0.0859783068,
0.0186790973,
0.0082063293,
-0.0434848256,
-0.0083393129,
0.00092874,
0.0170365293,
0.0317650586,
-0.0263953973,
0.0286187567,
0.0357548818,
-0.0331992172,
-0.0081677968,
-0.0576402098,
0.0171510745,
0.0256084558,
-0.0189068429,
0.0165519938,
-0.0491852798,
-0.0035914399,
0.0742408857,
0.00151234,
0.0385074876,
1.704028524e-34,
-0.0365507193,
0.0107236393,
-0.0111493999,
0.0182740781,
-0.0007609557,
-0.0086368043,
-0.0214270856,
0.0292815156,
-0.0387930945,
-0.0392632633,
0.0255762078
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.07895v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.07895v1 | The Learnability of In-Context Learning | 2023-03-14T13:28:39 | 2023-03-14T13:28:39 | Noam Wies, Yoav Levine, Amnon Shashua | cs.CL | cs.CL | In-context learning is a surprising and important phenomenon that emerged
when modern language models were scaled to billions of learned parameters.
Without modifying a large language model's weights, it can be tuned to perform
various downstream natural language tasks simply by including concatenated
training examples of these tasks in its input. Though disruptive for many
practical applications of large language models, this emergent learning
paradigm is not well understood from a theoretical perspective. In this paper,
we propose a first-of-its-kind PAC based framework for in-context learnability,
and use it to provide the first finite sample complexity results for the
in-context learning setup. Our framework includes an initial pretraining phase,
which fits a function to the pretraining distribution, and then a second
in-context learning phase, which keeps this function constant and concatenates
training examples of the downstream task in its input. We use our framework in
order to prove that, under mild assumptions, when the pretraining distribution
is a mixture of latent tasks (a model often considered for natural language
pretraining), these tasks can be efficiently learned via in-context learning,
even though the model's weights are unchanged and the input significantly
diverges from the pretraining distribution. Our theoretical analysis reveals
that in this setting, in-context learning is more about identifying the task
than about learning it, a result which is in line with a series of recent
empirical findings. We hope that the in-context learnability framework
presented in this paper will facilitate future progress towards a deeper
understanding of this important new learning paradigm. | [
-0.0052257548,
0.0246053878,
-0.0100216949,
0.0147206616,
-0.0078794695,
0.034205202,
0.0003247725,
-0.0199252777,
-0.0157111138,
-0.0329250395,
-0.0402752124,
-0.0489351973,
-0.0130485613,
0.0162578374,
0.0477950983,
-0.0300071929,
0.0061001512,
-0.0325700007,
-0.0058672428,
0.0048922575,
-0.0025633336,
-0.0563358739,
-0.0152964154,
0.0241707265,
0.0141055444,
-0.0321780369,
-0.0326901563,
-0.0336495712,
-0.0196872875,
-0.0075963805,
0.0411835983,
0.0211384203,
0.04424363,
0.0337420776,
0.0000018601,
-0.0377638489,
-0.0121379215,
-0.0210314654,
-0.0692014173,
0.0160051025,
0.017942274,
0.0297413673,
-0.0104866922,
0.0310505349,
-0.0201918222,
-0.0415420569,
0.0679741874,
0.0440106131,
0.0232430119,
0.0770573691,
-0.0055632074,
-0.010541698,
0.0180072039,
-0.0603390522,
-0.0116233919,
-0.0609801784,
0.0142133199,
-0.0549610183,
-0.0126656452,
-0.0049874149,
-0.0270376224,
0.0131480647,
0.0240268465,
0.0405342244,
-0.0126198884,
0.0261558518,
-0.0090643521,
0.0021703385,
-0.0170413461,
0.070709765,
-0.057707727,
-0.0276313778,
-0.0248824712,
-0.0261597764,
0.0043572374,
0.0106164012,
-0.0278251413,
-0.0077563599,
0.001079623,
0.0576507188,
0.0356914699,
0.0185259972,
0.0556222573,
-0.0103951823,
-0.030096896,
0.0577813983,
0.0001775918,
-0.0455537289,
0.035589423,
0.0105655426,
-0.0535035245,
-0.0345461182,
-0.0053532314,
0.0078487871,
-0.0438564792,
0.027377056,
-0.0486637056,
-0.0262251757,
-0.0168008823,
-0.0049931812,
0.0683381781,
-0.0040416778,
-0.0333865471,
0.0643451139,
0.0035027387,
0.0599622466,
-0.0232750755,
-0.0212415177,
-0.0355873778,
0.008229549,
-0.0460631922,
0.0053155832,
-0.0523734502,
0.0119206719,
-0.0253740363,
-0.0090565924,
-0.0315714255,
0.026473701,
-0.0389235839,
-0.0064803506,
0.0138444575,
-0.0303425621,
-0.0709975958,
-0.0066946475,
0.0048628608,
0.0303089544,
-0.0130749205,
0.0661050603,
-0.0151205119,
-0.0128316106,
-0.0006099868,
0.0057597738,
0.0244693644,
-0.014605796,
-0.0079857493,
0.040158134,
-0.038372729,
-0.0645456389,
-0.0514882095,
0.011704701,
-0.0214779526,
-0.0452349298,
0.0163897425,
-0.043191988,
0.0036600768,
-0.0217697546,
0.0071170991,
-0.0151225384,
-0.0101549523,
0.000200419,
0.0015104456,
0.1109152213,
0.01692806,
0.0026087763,
-0.0159265976,
0.0044370354,
-0.0022193911,
0.0683649927,
0.003317337,
0.0240827464,
0.0534067005,
0.0179047994,
0.0209778342,
0.0559248962,
0.0390947387,
0.0184937827,
0.001828202,
-0.0084063802,
0.0364273787,
-0.0097778291,
0.0197925474,
0.0273127779,
-0.019858608,
-0.0179209653,
0.0537152775,
0.0497885309,
0.0511449352,
0.0075697796,
0.0443885624,
0.0151231596,
0.0023023137,
0.0327511653,
-0.0567070395,
-0.0177695174,
-0.063294664,
-0.0004907355,
0.0058137723,
-0.0075764572,
-0.0653478056,
-0.0583512112,
0.0288526453,
-0.034772601,
-0.0030475915,
0.0057280506,
0.0707700253,
0.0399305485,
-0.0415372588,
0.0213753767,
0.0265465062,
-0.0369990356,
0.0161848012,
-0.0441494025,
0.0341711156,
0.0193347689,
0.0120985452,
-0.0712638423,
0.021570662,
-0.0168965571,
0.0604109243,
-0.0111627923,
-0.0079448624,
-0.042836003,
0.0619451031,
-0.0124130799,
-0.022825364,
0.0059386445,
0.0327214859,
-0.0077795484,
0.0080794515,
-0.0188399125,
-0.0069996137,
-0.0198259074,
-0.0174371544,
0.0257823616,
-0.0505776517,
-0.0822036043,
0.0054082815,
0.0455203094,
0.0607948899,
0.0063847918,
-0.0126352301,
0.0193746183,
0.0325798206,
-0.047278855,
-0.0017541619,
0.028828498,
-0.0546038747,
-0.0650593042,
0.0242513996,
-0.0120423399,
0.0107648149,
-0.0046428149,
-0.0414601602,
-0.048254665,
0.0086300299,
-0.0307537597,
0.0966168717,
-0.0310457572,
0.0392993242,
-0.0064837085,
0.0043427837,
-0.0108363824,
0.0712738186,
-0.0123865074,
0.0343907513,
-0.0122969169,
0.0458276644,
-0.01885668,
-0.0045797997,
-0.0384023115,
-0.0271118768,
0.0032137674,
0.007705275,
0.0237778183,
-0.0150537407,
-0.0168027543,
-0.0199566744,
-0.0635688528,
0.0147621036,
-0.0472554862,
-0.0029438809,
0.0103153186,
0.0131221041,
0.0045060227,
-0.0265687555,
-0.0445277616,
0.0005160842,
-0.0043439241,
0.0473177396,
0.0224724561,
0.0270248689,
-0.0178455077,
-0.0389401801,
-0.0253943186,
0.0278355535,
0.0518487841,
-0.0030811245,
-0.0125754327,
-0.0485673621,
0.0687830597,
0.0562463589,
0.0546570197,
-0.0497836694,
-0.0145649016,
-0.0050969631,
-0.0208784249,
0.0354513787,
0.0802404284,
-0.0067177117,
0.071416676,
0.0257003326,
0.0033005092,
0.0268428735,
0.0060214107,
-0.0477440618,
-0.0772898719,
-0.0260912888,
0.0109078558,
0.0481725819,
0.0885049328,
-0.0337823257,
-0.0412780084,
-0.040576335,
-0.0443574935,
-0.0414912179,
-0.0346295498,
-0.0237924587,
-0.0151017746,
-0.0299231298,
0.0254545249,
-0.033107087,
-0.060773842,
0.0452327989,
-0.0065663815,
-0.0148211746,
-0.0446233712,
-0.0457575433,
-0.0269260854,
0.056815546,
0.0641645715,
-0.0035983336,
0.0444344915,
-0.0357879549,
-0.0773989409,
0.0106064314,
0.0147987669,
-0.0076747723,
0.052318044,
-0.0434401743,
0.004547047,
0.0082732849,
-0.068169117,
-0.021187352,
-0.0166209545,
0.0112412339,
0.0330944918,
-0.0022308521,
-0.0150704281,
-0.0269034319,
-0.0123787299,
-0.0084969625,
0.0598101653,
0.0144450134,
-0.0174831897,
-0.0268774927,
0.0411984399,
0.0206317101,
0.0167115275,
-0.008823676,
-0.0459648073,
0.01205499,
0.0238561332,
0.0804783031,
-0.0212771669,
-0.0288190562,
0.0635855272,
0.0227656402,
-0.0278929137,
-0.0347132981,
0.0537699908,
0.042104166,
-0.0286164768,
-0.0203883704,
0.0822610259,
0.0074429573,
-0.0605833977,
0.0243323203,
0.0448309854,
-0.0236424822,
0.0401579738,
-0.0032989408,
-0.0597926043,
-0.0379574709,
0.0042533702,
0.0234507881,
-0.0158138741,
-0.038405396,
-0.0063294321,
-0.0867191777,
-0.0064174496,
0.0052375412,
-0.0952329263,
-0.0238054879,
-0.0401247852,
0.0190160982,
-0.0436745435,
0.0014872538,
-0.0112839146,
-0.0192247797,
0.0018926655,
0.0211719386,
0.0104384255,
-0.08457423,
0.0079958942,
-0.0587393679,
0.0535194203,
0.0308120195,
0.0073927427,
-0.0096356869,
-0.0080458745,
0.0234464109,
-0.0550681353,
-0.0374326855,
0.0149302166,
0.0230299961,
0.0035271584,
-0.0127674257,
-0.0103828358,
0.0662045553,
-0.0303971022,
-0.0019451572,
0.0168232545,
0.0910529345,
0.0332434364,
-0.0131059177,
0.0241876002,
-0.0519295409,
0.0774129033,
0.0752867758,
0.0146438917,
-0.0554626286,
-0.0121774571,
-0.007863408,
0.0124810804,
0.0344482772,
0.0200233292,
0.0032284597,
-0.0256856643,
-0.0006552247,
-0.0742249265,
-0.0024466028,
0.0248176791,
0.0795727149,
0.0008594106,
0.0272646323,
0.0561539121,
0.0095070926,
-0.066776596,
0.0198278148,
-0.0187631026,
0.007872439,
-0.0380067974,
-0.048298534,
0.0624853335,
-0.0008008913,
-0.0284635536,
-0.0010928194,
-0.0657290444,
-0.048813615,
0.0120649161,
0.0256452691,
0.0242741145,
0.0418758728,
-0.0075683496,
-0.0668211728,
0.088216275,
-0.0018468233,
-0.0220577251,
0.0057473434,
0.0642281696,
0.0067987684,
0.0186908394,
0.0646359548,
-0.0587393045,
0.0046851053,
0.0238753241,
0.0016672225,
-0.0531884506,
-0.0062070913,
0.0388515927,
-0.0306088515,
0.0278575812,
0.020399943,
-0.0125884423,
-0.0632225871,
0.011353476,
0.0143562248,
-0.0181400012,
-0.0537074544,
0.0019885544,
0.0205050297,
0.047439903,
-0.0018010241,
-0.0070337332,
0.0208822358,
0.0379629582,
-0.0189743843,
0.0018642972,
0.045174107,
0.0274937004,
0.0404975526,
0.0398800708,
0.0030486018,
0.0067046308,
-0.0027160069,
0.0314722136,
-0.0185882263,
0.0477128699,
0.0208097193,
0.0266181268,
-0.0469090939,
0.0053851726,
-0.0788318068,
0.0207001492,
-0.0367479026,
0.0731194317,
0.0510062575,
-0.0574122593,
-0.0058988705,
-0.0342541076,
-0.0216329452,
-0.024946209,
0.0220308062,
-0.0153167704,
-0.0535225607,
0.0316070877,
0.0374525487,
0.0067411368,
0.0364572555,
0.1197458953,
0.0422532447,
0.0510835424,
-0.0345517695,
0.0247871559,
-0.0510290973,
-0.0243281927,
0.0272403285,
0.0633100048,
-0.0216331985,
0.0637411624,
-0.0093230149,
-0.0885890648,
-0.0168109816,
-0.0136444736,
0.0167616308,
-0.0131368013,
0.0385808647,
0.0722921044,
0.0028305862,
-0.007798552,
-0.0370339155,
-0.0074794469,
0.0337054357,
-0.000912915,
-0.0106867161,
-5.849372296e-33,
-0.0186195411,
-0.0277701449,
0.0051631765,
0.0294629037,
-0.0001117745,
0.0237244554,
-0.0259472914,
0.0164035577,
0.0232900847,
0.0103447065,
-0.0195470955,
0.026082661,
-0.000130905,
0.0611602664,
-0.0364044867,
-0.0101258075,
0.0570899099,
-0.0389808677,
0.0045141,
0.0331887305,
0.0265107695,
-0.0026286396,
0.0123660844,
-0.0291309729,
0.0216594059,
0.0013256054,
0.007775405,
0.0620761104,
0.0244050547,
0.054659538,
-0.0162164625,
0.0326233655,
0.0310533214,
-0.0471026637,
-0.0116489613,
0.04094024,
-0.0828365386,
-0.0431276932,
-0.0017305461,
0.0002374201,
-0.031788677,
-0.0048468946,
0.0486985743,
-0.036164213,
-0.0051219524,
0.0021032058,
0.0270132888,
-0.0379974917,
-0.020594852,
-0.0520293936,
-0.0456097126,
-0.004027674,
-0.0076147378,
-0.000880296,
0.0185343586,
0.0165069997,
-0.0061066034,
-0.0136988675,
-0.0432422273,
0.0114021851,
0.0180961192,
0.0236238707,
0.0259470735,
0.0553297512,
0.0223314464,
0.0318252034,
0.0123381587,
0.0011410551,
-0.0204562116,
-0.0324219875,
0.0254327171,
0.0309269596,
0.0178924911,
0.0070234342,
0.0519498028,
0.0096329274,
-0.0756982788,
-0.0103620747,
0.0556342155,
0.0165275857,
0.0096787959,
0.0349482819,
-0.0611812584,
-0.0514484644,
-0.0519558787,
-0.0311687198,
-0.0146088013,
0.0188748799,
0.0225759316,
0.0445210077,
-0.0019335841,
0.0044528889,
0.0016948257,
-0.041485548,
-0.0154423648,
-0.012115418,
0.0242202673,
0.0085147955,
-0.0019939984,
0.0136153856,
-0.0758287162,
-0.0241215192,
-0.0245361719,
-0.0021810099,
0.0198733956,
-0.0059464192,
0.0522638112,
0.0566193014,
-0.0675659031,
-0.0179943666,
-0.0100954296,
0.0006232176,
0.0553457253,
0.050303176,
0.0629784837,
-0.0136149013,
-0.0050022486,
0.0294034053,
0.0198010299,
-0.0274334457,
-0.0209130496,
0.0064337798,
-0.0057449872,
0.0271390267,
-0.0490723588,
-0.0378593281,
-0.0230783205,
0.0394496024,
0.0733119622,
-0.0748077929,
-0.0118416464,
-0.0164093096,
2.54e-7,
0.004502906,
0.0083123194,
-0.0182382427,
-0.0310931746,
0.0631087497,
0.0241589006,
-0.0367870517,
0.0169881117,
-0.0276704691,
0.0061870031,
0.0276725944,
0.0085234484,
0.042336069,
-0.0063002585,
-0.0529884435,
-0.0041451617,
-0.0403502062,
0.0280415546,
-0.0269555207,
0.0039097858,
0.0316425152,
0.1002628803,
0.0184656121,
-0.0217221659,
0.0027584005,
-0.0805728137,
0.0620158873,
-0.0332530364,
0.048182603,
0.0058441386,
0.000034669,
0.0677358285,
-0.0163043775,
0.0183346178,
-0.0246155336,
0.0600209869,
0.0279853772,
0.0503003374,
0.0285360869,
-0.0051175393,
0.0110867238,
-0.0178603791,
-0.0034377885,
-0.0270707253,
0.0764305145,
-0.1116014197,
-0.0372973494,
-0.0501441881,
0.0118134888,
-0.0232544802,
-0.0181870647,
0.0238953587,
-0.0082316697,
-0.0162443947,
0.0114701223,
-0.00740238,
0.004697334,
-0.0796111748,
0.002755187,
0.0399567932,
-0.0338320173,
-0.0322699621,
-0.0455367342,
-0.0083580846,
0.042298086,
-0.0359558649,
0.0368587337,
2.522632917e-34,
0.0341320783,
-0.0302636493,
0.0511624925,
-0.0039623883,
-0.0060556214,
-0.0561311729,
-0.0219880603,
-0.0187311564,
0.0616639629,
-0.0765278786,
-0.0006970994
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.07865v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.07865v2 | Geolocation Predicting of Tweets Using BERT-Based Models | 2023-03-14T12:56:47 | 2023-05-08T15:55:10 | Kateryna Lutsai, Christoph H. Lampert | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T50, I.2.7 | This research is aimed to solve the tweet/user geolocation prediction task
and provide a flexible methodology for the geotagging of textual big data. The
suggested approach implements neural networks for natural language processing
(NLP) to estimate the location as coordinate pairs (longitude, latitude) and
two-dimensional Gaussian Mixture Models (GMMs). The scope of proposed models
has been finetuned on a Twitter dataset using pretrained Bidirectional Encoder
Representations from Transformers (BERT) as base models. Performance metrics
show a median error of fewer than 30 km on a worldwide-level, and fewer than 15
km on the US-level datasets for the models trained and evaluated on text
features of tweets' content and metadata context. Our source code and data are
available at https://github.com/K4TEL/geo-twitter.git | [
0.0435172878,
0.0164816491,
-0.0111261737,
-0.0179104656,
-0.0053498745,
0.0481990986,
0.0377963558,
-0.0363487974,
0.0262027346,
-0.0615677461,
0.0173220634,
-0.016125042,
-0.0133282831,
-0.0149834128,
0.0440654792,
-0.0636312589,
-0.0067924494,
-0.0053281011,
0.0119121866,
-0.0233460627,
-0.019807836,
0.0185326934,
-0.0043928456,
0.0436859801,
-0.0067267851,
0.033085607,
0.0045774379,
0.0240615103,
0.043618951,
0.0097287456,
0.0493255928,
0.0047647897,
0.0195989683,
0.0227664616,
0.0000016683,
0.0241221823,
-0.0434647501,
0.0068226419,
0.0546242893,
-0.0113284206,
-0.0470150262,
-0.0077353409,
0.0243093148,
0.0542508513,
-0.0424130447,
-0.0124496194,
0.0258530006,
0.0090073291,
0.0377007127,
0.0769516677,
-0.024121359,
-0.0405169837,
0.0037312673,
0.0003208063,
0.0184951164,
0.0044245543,
0.0145957023,
-0.018130172,
-0.0350644663,
0.0365717672,
0.0207860582,
0.0157046653,
-0.0160787497,
0.0463815816,
-0.0055107246,
0.0313157961,
-0.0650711879,
0.0439531058,
-0.0272221342,
0.0021331094,
0.0078135617,
-0.0258632861,
0.0436046496,
0.0322088189,
-0.024647722,
0.0188945681,
-0.036593806,
-0.0274829529,
-0.0048533217,
0.0550027601,
-0.0468413122,
-0.0050008749,
0.0022237352,
0.0371214971,
-0.0397569723,
0.0895537883,
0.0088120289,
-0.056317661,
-0.099600561,
0.0460238755,
-0.0420282893,
-0.0472149439,
0.0731684938,
0.0239365734,
0.0315316096,
-0.0108343735,
0.0008922575,
-0.0081398534,
-0.0329760797,
-0.0620976761,
-0.0158159845,
0.017953366,
0.0026276079,
0.0382707231,
-0.0238904692,
0.0155560765,
-0.0203892309,
0.0405950248,
0.0020624034,
-0.0747587904,
-0.0502499379,
0.0089205494,
0.0057826019,
-0.01263374,
0.0076853191,
0.0177112613,
-0.0653874651,
0.0142802494,
0.0097976467,
0.0007714911,
-0.0063800099,
0.0174740795,
0.0057942029,
-0.0193823483,
-0.0137234796,
0.0419457294,
-0.0120090712,
0.0086652683,
-0.026992796,
0.0243918411,
0.0092179021,
0.0160273779,
0.0787838772,
-0.0037541091,
-0.0253689531,
0.018660726,
0.050807029,
-0.0438008346,
-0.0538300127,
0.0224755295,
-0.0143311787,
0.00692925,
0.0376503952,
-0.0740854889,
-0.0203237738,
0.0513681769,
-0.0112181064,
-0.0069089211,
-0.018667547,
0.0005067562,
-0.0118715204,
0.0081105428,
-0.0223586559,
0.031371098,
0.065363735,
-0.0517912842,
0.0024178817,
0.0516845398,
0.0521695837,
0.1026045159,
0.0519928224,
-0.0187542718,
0.0215327609,
0.0227961279,
0.0133204944,
0.0164031442,
-0.0042795804,
-0.0140049336,
-0.0265907981,
-0.015136349,
-0.0162976645,
0.0239609145,
-0.0071078297,
0.0834098011,
0.0748992413,
0.052091714,
0.0100219129,
-0.011688807,
0.0643423274,
0.0463889018,
-0.0376983844,
-0.0623663552,
-0.0111041209,
-0.0281767305,
-0.0490343571,
-0.0057974206,
0.064897351,
0.0734363422,
-0.0409946665,
0.0075117652,
-0.0026880566,
-0.0342269726,
0.0300675742,
0.0117296763,
0.0678453371,
-0.0663425475,
-0.0277414415,
0.1010452956,
-0.0069270968,
-0.0125573985,
0.0254495982,
0.0159405228,
-0.0339060314,
0.0258933417,
-0.0092719505,
0.0022826518,
-0.051137343,
-0.0266390648,
0.017357165,
0.0041813101,
-0.0155269969,
0.0361221023,
-0.0164779872,
-0.0396247134,
-0.0662019923,
0.0327853188,
0.0036384671,
-0.0418229364,
0.0757223666,
0.0670845285,
0.0412689373,
-0.0921970308,
0.0225065667,
-0.0093159778,
0.0141008636,
-0.0008878353,
-0.013020616,
0.0430078022,
-0.0172463506,
0.0370458625,
0.0090832869,
-0.0152334068,
0.0343035758,
-0.0168876797,
-0.0306506734,
0.0331289396,
-0.0255033281,
-0.0217550043,
0.0383193009,
0.0042146961,
0.0154185472,
0.0290056281,
-0.0233779456,
-0.0262920167,
0.0037424318,
-0.060080193,
0.0580573156,
-0.0161376651,
0.0150749097,
-0.0210994408,
0.0200120285,
0.0155755533,
0.0245340932,
-0.0288144182,
0.0223233942,
-0.0362348519,
-0.0181268062,
0.0389687121,
0.0315300822,
-0.0130645726,
-0.0688773319,
-0.0354726799,
0.0200813506,
0.0121574355,
-0.0265857186,
-0.0191498082,
-0.0436733291,
-0.1221768036,
-0.0065095322,
-0.0419140309,
0.0332064703,
0.0138412667,
0.0090113655,
-0.0372850075,
-0.0249479841,
-0.0061011747,
-0.0155675951,
-0.0048866887,
0.0088478895,
0.0291194897,
-0.0342339985,
0.0019594471,
0.0427083075,
-0.0059352028,
-0.0400256217,
0.036081478,
-0.0479931571,
-0.0445633419,
-0.0378536545,
-0.0453010872,
-0.0237940345,
0.0137184449,
0.0188740697,
-0.0429676771,
-0.0114658028,
-0.0137720462,
0.0575671196,
-0.0448626764,
0.0087855561,
-0.0049393028,
-0.0308466796,
-0.0256289635,
-0.030176362,
0.0334848501,
-0.0531363674,
0.0039468314,
-0.0372732095,
-0.0732983425,
-0.0272076465,
0.0405077301,
-0.028262537,
0.0040231948,
-0.0191050563,
-0.012255379,
-0.0330778807,
0.0198718831,
0.0032167768,
0.0389133207,
-0.010669902,
0.0260473341,
-0.0020531414,
-0.059806481,
0.0330488831,
-0.0342509151,
0.00783577,
-0.034061335,
-0.0536723621,
-0.0053478801,
0.0266023632,
0.0199373066,
0.0156026864,
-0.022711765,
-0.0372348838,
0.0587438643,
-0.0356261693,
-0.0211604089,
-0.016117176,
-0.032895498,
0.0597736649,
-0.0083280709,
0.0139161116,
-0.0266412906,
-0.0146167837,
-0.0545385033,
-0.042461805,
-0.0040068841,
0.0001399146,
-0.0775300488,
-0.0046165353,
0.033265762,
0.0119756088,
0.0404727086,
-0.0347361229,
-0.0020420179,
-0.0041285655,
0.043184869,
0.0559283867,
0.0306285694,
-0.0718382299,
0.0097275032,
-0.0776138008,
-0.0127353501,
-0.0069126808,
0.0335568339,
-0.0210033413,
0.005753065,
0.0366664492,
-0.034645088,
-0.0175182447,
0.0211978778,
0.0952625424,
0.0345985182,
-0.0139635894,
0.1067221761,
0.0718185231,
-0.0202624816,
-0.0366374291,
0.002092459,
0.0027445308,
0.0025087413,
0.0591914244,
-0.0185825732,
-0.0030656387,
-0.0061917659,
0.0266203694,
0.0136031685,
-0.0265409667,
0.0140868463,
-0.0703956634,
0.015156799,
-0.0006635452,
0.011852623,
-0.0662194416,
-0.0753593966,
-0.0329709575,
0.0257095061,
-0.0096528288,
-0.0571008772,
-0.0079094963,
0.0205755662,
0.0817466676,
-0.1186692864,
-0.0435992181,
-0.0120526785,
-0.1001785994,
0.0044780993,
0.0219051111,
0.0544482097,
-0.026041897,
-0.0314256847,
-0.0336864516,
0.0441127494,
-0.0098724952,
0.0126470113,
0.0211608559,
-0.0323206112,
-0.0114777489,
-0.0251209699,
-0.0002855634,
-0.0294667631,
-0.0353769995,
-0.0133134909,
0.0847090557,
-0.0246808119,
0.0273790937,
-0.0125196232,
0.031142626,
0.0082267765,
0.0121510709,
0.0181707814,
-0.061220862,
-0.0065634078,
-0.0230016652,
0.0253068302,
-0.0485087745,
0.0258626714,
0.0228563938,
-0.0182057191,
-0.0996014997,
-0.0460301079,
-0.0191131737,
0.0452973433,
0.0066737076,
-0.0074816542,
-0.0115704155,
0.0645103157,
-0.0280364361,
-0.0503936671,
0.0337652229,
-0.0061335331,
0.0013546237,
0.0004136463,
-0.0084994249,
0.0422019176,
0.0123218205,
0.0026969807,
0.0200754348,
-0.0930330381,
-0.0495745689,
-0.0060449019,
0.0281576756,
0.0091332449,
-0.0094591742,
-0.0464352556,
-0.0327970088,
0.032003548,
0.0781025216,
-0.001875078,
-0.0150919678,
0.0089606782,
0.0570073798,
0.0119829159,
-0.0047340733,
-0.0344592743,
0.024732139,
-0.0025584649,
0.0048112972,
-0.0336530879,
0.026309507,
-0.0129871005,
0.0072114435,
0.118117854,
-0.0057406793,
-0.0453037024,
-0.0242571253,
-0.0279608853,
-0.0200177711,
0.0114116529,
-0.0177611448,
-0.0112699699,
0.0644424558,
0.0278149508,
-0.0385658108,
0.0517871082,
0.0133187966,
-0.0526027754,
-0.0534476377,
0.0215710886,
-0.0178809687,
0.0322488584,
-0.0300310012,
0.0238955617,
-0.0176780615,
-0.0391885042,
0.0206906404,
-0.0014363154,
-0.0220276415,
0.0095898965,
-0.0030268203,
0.0323842578,
-0.0274509545,
0.0378958657,
-0.053601522,
-0.0188330654,
-0.0268001389,
0.0348028801,
0.0592315197,
-0.0213634521,
0.0281953402,
-0.0135982484,
-0.0192319453,
0.0158658288,
0.0303209983,
0.019137701,
-0.0090767695,
0.0127047049,
-0.0382070318,
-0.0483507216,
0.0368841104,
0.0378960148,
0.0114180623,
0.0094918376,
0.0661058798,
-0.0705581382,
-0.0101945316,
0.035457097,
0.0121723879,
-0.0287061408,
-0.0152956154,
0.0041203815,
0.0370075554,
-0.0524618588,
0.0685717091,
-0.0564104542,
-0.0483270548,
-0.0143144755,
0.0123638539,
0.049277395,
-0.0230190828,
-0.0083973957,
-0.0595243908,
0.0219873711,
0.0182575975,
-0.0280718785,
-0.0177215394,
-5.990162724e-33,
0.0155819235,
-0.0654958561,
0.0052812053,
-0.0290470477,
-0.0151194846,
0.0195459053,
0.0036972917,
-0.0055866376,
-0.0004156413,
-0.0218712986,
-0.0266112257,
0.0137346238,
0.0197368897,
0.0520476475,
-0.0170862395,
-0.0051901699,
-0.0091202017,
0.0025662156,
0.0094539151,
0.0113273738,
0.054300081,
0.0476767011,
0.0721612424,
-0.0734803602,
-0.0166023299,
-0.0469660014,
-0.0404782854,
0.0071920655,
0.0682284087,
0.0332105085,
-0.0331015475,
0.0413303487,
0.0236408506,
-0.0027451853,
-0.0071807033,
0.0373669676,
-0.0412928089,
-0.0460489541,
-0.0400971137,
0.0187467821,
0.0071061216,
-0.0057548713,
0.0544809401,
0.0042393389,
-0.0072050286,
0.05703035,
0.0353054889,
0.0341799781,
-0.0445276089,
0.0012253973,
0.0004852734,
0.0185049735,
-0.0239605177,
-0.0249233879,
0.0196338817,
0.0585180521,
0.0521784574,
0.0060589048,
-0.0491892137,
0.0106679909,
0.0571267679,
0.0407546535,
0.0089389617,
-0.0168416779,
0.0029271867,
0.0292514097,
-0.0132338991,
0.0142487977,
-0.0607094914,
-0.0577820241,
0.0129087614,
-0.016451722,
0.0010434224,
0.0027679291,
-0.0156536251,
-0.0550262518,
-0.0411965251,
0.0775196552,
0.0044862353,
-0.0212747008,
0.0193781983,
-0.0014670608,
-0.0163222905,
-0.0275363214,
0.0164049361,
-0.0337303802,
0.0018744831,
-0.0231990591,
-0.0029825941,
-0.0074713873,
0.0296366923,
0.0665220916,
0.0329360887,
-0.0163322501,
-0.0057448912,
-0.0037116078,
-0.0086300001,
0.039860636,
-0.0174295325,
0.0479088277,
-0.0134998448,
-0.0611873493,
-0.0127588948,
0.0115982443,
-0.0353963859,
0.0127297118,
0.0224228576,
0.0399366245,
-0.041879449,
0.0221740548,
-0.0080214599,
-0.0019172144,
-0.0610861816,
-0.0046366891,
0.0182318166,
0.0120613165,
0.0191462766,
0.026441358,
0.0654981136,
0.0659996644,
0.0231638886,
0.0018241006,
0.0011505529,
0.0145033402,
0.0164914839,
0.0137782125,
-0.0485206842,
0.0542047545,
-0.0298327859,
-0.0433185324,
-0.0149912033,
-0.0364899933,
2.557e-7,
0.0751831084,
0.0946645811,
0.0059313336,
-0.0118771698,
0.0024639135,
0.009849105,
0.021387225,
0.0220850855,
0.0154538406,
0.0370098054,
0.0279031917,
-0.0160786416,
0.0296851397,
0.0421150513,
-0.1140113249,
0.031359382,
-0.0816652775,
0.0339716114,
-0.0503692441,
0.0597772896,
0.0310474467,
0.0770780668,
0.0461814292,
0.0169074051,
0.0113697508,
-0.0283112675,
0.0544865765,
-0.0607510172,
-0.0266079977,
0.0029429349,
0.0370935798,
0.0089465957,
0.0104568703,
-0.0555389524,
-0.0284553301,
0.0107968319,
0.0481419936,
0.0243475754,
-0.0292397439,
-0.0114732431,
-0.0325493291,
-0.0472201481,
-0.002659875,
-0.0746064335,
0.0349103361,
-0.0488702916,
-0.0596067905,
0.0333484113,
-0.0264405422,
0.0423578061,
0.0337031595,
0.0129350992,
-0.0388404168,
-0.0127361082,
0.0201828294,
0.009318118,
-0.005583303,
-0.0763525814,
0.0093972487,
-0.0110637806,
-0.0134211676,
0.0003591782,
-0.0130935237,
-0.0041155671,
0.0588242598,
-0.0148968389,
0.0503429994,
1.909914408e-34,
-0.0050160992,
0.0040896162,
-0.0139931403,
0.0246518608,
0.0350640491,
-0.0148995984,
-0.0030320908,
0.0050538229,
0.0134715009,
-0.0358080901,
-0.0079480922
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2303.07833v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2303.07833v1 | X-ReCoSa: Multi-Scale Context Aggregation For Multi-Turn Dialogue Generation | 2023-03-14T12:15:52 | 2023-03-14T12:15:52 | Danqin Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL | In multi-turn dialogue generation, responses are not only related to the
topic and background of the context but also related to words and phrases in
the sentences of the context. However, currently widely used hierarchical
dialog models solely rely on context representations from the utterance-level
encoder, ignoring the sentence representations output by the word-level
encoder. This inevitably results in a loss of information while decoding and
generating. In this paper, we propose a new dialog model X-ReCoSa to tackle
this problem which aggregates multi-scale context information for hierarchical
dialog models. Specifically, we divide the generation decoder into upper and
lower parts, namely the intention part and the generation part. Firstly, the
intention part takes context representations as input to generate the intention
of the response. Then the generation part generates words depending on sentence
representations. Therefore, the hierarchical information has been fused into
response generation. we conduct experiments on the English dataset DailyDialog.
Experimental results exhibit that our method outperforms baseline models on
both automatic metric-based and human-based evaluations. | [
0.0178876817,
0.0571990982,
0.0120811723,
0.0321960747,
-0.019404659,
0.0003856527,
0.0198398568,
-0.0297001898,
0.0024234585,
-0.0557223298,
-0.0240554977,
-0.0668641999,
0.0056744372,
0.0692348778,
0.0102221835,
-0.0855638087,
0.0104859276,
-0.0202118363,
-0.0037284866,
-0.021344563,
-0.0084115416,
0.0192895178,
-0.0228397641,
0.0526664741,
-0.0353855044,
-0.0182555448,
-0.0375050716,
0.0308448561,
0.0132846599,
-0.0355884247,
0.0313637406,
0.0240190066,
0.0333067402,
0.03143714,
0.0000018081,
-0.0256028399,
-0.0125622181,
-0.0172051489,
-0.0097661,
-0.0225759707,
0.0280380603,
-0.0499671027,
-0.0130932843,
0.0417211577,
-0.0328853168,
0.0071246102,
0.0367710888,
0.0415259637,
0.0778399855,
0.0582697913,
-0.0245670937,
-0.0825490132,
0.0276150927,
-0.0285588987,
-0.0020193462,
-0.0376279913,
-0.0199391078,
0.0248486344,
-0.0181654654,
0.0073523251,
-0.0124818645,
0.0168097056,
0.0184691548,
-0.0416554175,
-0.0047530569,
0.0246680398,
0.034237612,
0.0055689891,
-0.0345022194,
0.0828175843,
0.0096521936,
0.0420716181,
0.0085022524,
-0.0138754994,
-0.0118938368,
-0.0700152367,
-0.0363332815,
0.0283029247,
-0.0092077274,
-0.0062211654,
-0.0027744728,
0.0504411235,
-0.0410897359,
0.0135158673,
-0.0376961641,
0.036412131,
0.0181213878,
-0.0194155667,
-0.0335361026,
0.009822173,
0.0492288098,
-0.0601657145,
-0.0044434727,
0.0382403731,
-0.0659389049,
0.0271579102,
-0.0504517779,
0.0426068716,
0.0063511757,
0.0073255789,
0.0004901373,
0.0337606408,
0.0323672555,
0.0156755447,
0.036102891,
0.056941133,
-0.0302408803,
-0.0307906177,
-0.0536157303,
-0.0228986423,
-0.0076871673,
-0.0071561751,
-0.0443371199,
0.0115828253,
-0.0864489153,
-0.0424189642,
-0.0415960662,
0.0491909832,
0.0130373221,
-0.0218708254,
0.0174759906,
0.0168534406,
-0.0362725928,
-0.0031366476,
-0.0117757283,
0.0622812137,
-0.0312007051,
0.0178790074,
0.0592345521,
-0.0459500514,
-0.0118194949,
0.0446320735,
0.0171413124,
-0.0000660757,
-0.0344830081,
0.0629973784,
-0.0589205474,
0.0092678173,
-0.0017972077,
-0.0779446289,
-0.0747410432,
-0.0561971553,
-0.0264836997,
-0.0140564814,
0.0686944947,
-0.0341702215,
-0.0227672476,
0.0092828926,
0.0055925041,
0.0082468763,
0.0100829965,
0.009775457,
0.0090295915,
0.0097882571,
0.0452965461,
-0.0024399629,
-0.0117463274,
0.0460893326,
0.0547181144,
0.0522573441,
0.006129378,
0.0143941017,
0.0105304541,
0.025790697,
0.0211814735,
-0.0018147825,
0.0123297349,
-0.0006813239,
-0.0704446733,
0.0336114317,
0.0377214476,
0.0684170946,
-0.0534621477,
0.020164758,
0.0360955186,
0.0261653177,
0.0021521973,
0.002745454,
0.0495466031,
0.0304860584,
-0.0353929177,
0.0177040771,
0.0183623824,
0.0343354978,
0.0155409211,
0.0400717966,
0.0626971796,
0.0276820231,
-0.0309077129,
-0.0342205614,
0.0204921719,
-0.0029927164,
-0.0137401754,
-0.029824065,
0.0185614247,
0.0289887097,
-0.0827078074,
0.0109040542,
-0.012993562,
-0.0695472658,
0.0160713233,
-0.0201410055,
0.0262712911,
0.0725323185,
0.047245767,
0.0423663147,
-0.0262607895,
-0.0129550723,
-0.0344131812,
0.0652273819,
0.0045363354,
-0.0412383005,
0.0360922962,
-0.0672852546,
-0.0448952056,
-0.0134541988,
-0.0125601403,
0.0430708379,
-0.0356716327,
-0.0196569338,
0.0369469598,
0.0302730631,
0.037125323,
-0.0121251084,
0.0255910382,
0.0127188591,
0.0333031677,
0.0076748175,
0.0581032299,
0.0371930562,
-0.0066741444,
0.0152906543,
0.0243771132,
-0.0278106369,
-0.0181783661,
0.0318370983,
-0.0828109533,
-0.1031558141,
-0.0217524935,
-0.0483569354,
0.0106075602,
-0.0325363241,
-0.0286484398,
-0.0852388144,
0.0065267701,
-0.0563390739,
0.0497837178,
-0.044900462,
0.0076346369,
0.056603197,
0.0265678875,
-0.0264462214,
0.0632605702,
-0.0235079098,
-0.0314750671,
0.0444534235,
0.0631380081,
-0.0021130808,
-0.0610710122,
0.0073911855,
0.0183778815,
-0.0301539358,
0.0112945242,
0.0366248786,
0.0250642058,
-0.0407060906,
-0.0699216947,
-0.0809367225,
0.0056977794,
-0.007492817,
-0.0015128837,
0.0255432632,
0.0094215972,
0.0037622638,
-0.0064394749,
-0.0593845658,
0.0070615779,
0.0586595945,
0.0152427377,
0.0293762218,
-0.0063643148,
-0.0082758507,
-0.0284300167,
0.0042552771,
0.0247199144,
0.0388964303,
0.0045815897,
0.0084953783,
-0.0307718068,
0.0051767449,
-0.040585909,
0.0011296039,
-0.0145931616,
-0.0571375228,
0.0296408907,
0.0098179569,
0.0671890974,
0.0349888019,
0.0548191257,
0.0450578295,
-0.004754819,
-0.0192881208,
-0.0410654508,
0.0276662055,
-0.0311105028,
-0.0185037237,
-0.0018968583,
-0.021904517,
0.0430406556,
0.0605872013,
0.0614337474,
0.0534931459,
-0.0474354886,
-0.0005133413,
0.0292052273,
-0.0466708839,
-0.0311091542,
-0.0282229334,
-0.0380683579,
0.0451313406,
-0.0198198818,
-0.0325225145,
0.0442962125,
-0.0400190465,
-0.0256118085,
-0.0274067316,
0.0147228613,
-0.021706393,
0.032997258,
-0.0168166067,
0.0520576239,
-0.0052965833,
-0.0340694562,
-0.0205452032,
0.001508106,
0.0045315004,
-0.0533932447,
0.0430445932,
-0.037915919,
-0.0107445251,
-0.0210720729,
-0.0435619727,
-0.0508040078,
-0.0071314746,
0.010863008,
-0.0116685219,
0.0411259905,
-0.0315468274,
-0.0313003734,
0.0176183302,
0.0182525385,
0.0372899175,
-0.0072953259,
-0.0046885968,
-0.0170449391,
0.091587767,
0.0559721552,
0.0389004946,
-0.0193036869,
-0.00955295,
0.0681522712,
0.0372863971,
0.0236850213,
-0.0051381816,
-0.0007070984,
0.0105347876,
0.0264538731,
0.0509625413,
0.0132684037,
0.0394210406,
0.0546640903,
-0.0303937495,
-0.0317317322,
0.0973357782,
0.0102921724,
-0.0201994218,
-0.0168990139,
-0.0078574801,
0.0809262916,
-0.0098103406,
-0.0113266781,
-0.0725882947,
-0.0187741928,
-0.0060446872,
0.0181234479,
0.0035185516,
-0.0008969084,
-0.0168545749,
-0.1072060242,
0.0707130432,
0.0208480582,
-0.0648400411,
-0.0212390181,
0.0217855666,
-0.0165445283,
0.0063426006,
0.0272414144,
0.0184636135,
0.0058523435,
-0.0059785442,
0.0193795096,
-0.003699278,
-0.0232295673,
-0.0126297195,
0.0003114456,
0.0418060832,
0.0455726348,
0.0396817848,
0.0599003285,
-0.0090768905,
-0.0063505322,
-0.0469443053,
0.0049582552,
0.0127245607,
0.0198893715,
-0.0152789773,
-0.0142467553,
-0.020879399,
0.0478531905,
-0.0217501987,
-0.017820105,
0.0022061153,
0.0132309794,
-0.031141622,
0.0114938822,
-0.0187050421,
0.031817466,
0.0478333794,
0.0767412409,
0.0174321756,
-0.0361746512,
-0.0341517255,
-0.0258305464,
0.0320275053,
-0.0695325732,
0.0278887171,
0.010269111,
0.0176176932,
0.0080900714,
-0.1097361967,
-0.0551757738,
-0.0100834873,
0.0449973755,
-0.032362178,
-0.0278235245,
0.0167023353,
-0.0097620217,
-0.0084095336,
-0.0388980843,
-0.0017884427,
0.0129652927,
-0.0410938412,
-0.0078192223,
0.0498789437,
-0.0249893479,
-0.0139572676,
0.0433798991,
-0.0428632274,
-0.0506325476,
-0.0419888943,
0.0374167636,
0.0191450696,
0.0591295548,
0.010691232,
0.0023303078,
0.0323543213,
-0.0293571018,
-0.0083236871,
-0.0040156655,
0.0261206198,
0.0949667171,
-0.0422355123,
0.0233170856,
-0.0549227037,
0.0375855193,
-0.0438206755,
0.0523868054,
-0.0597671717,
-0.104683198,
0.0068287081,
-0.0279480852,
-0.0163637996,
-0.0432421491,
-0.0070202397,
-0.0081710806,
0.0276417341,
-0.0404134318,
-0.0168059226,
-0.0772832483,
0.0119306855,
0.0171168707,
-0.0480808541,
0.0196485706,
-0.0219887514,
-0.019791849,
0.0269144792,
-0.0025563885,
-0.0138464235,
0.0055507692,
0.0129489666,
-0.0100636333,
-0.007445544,
-0.0340084992,
0.0133082727,
-0.0181797538,
0.0260438733,
0.0057688281,
0.1033222675,
-0.0049045878,
-0.030526448,
0.0280901436,
0.0383320116,
-0.0361785851,
0.015703503,
-0.0511982925,
-0.028478248,
0.0241998285,
0.0428932756,
0.0581857152,
0.0080535794,
0.025563281,
-0.0003277183,
0.0740840435,
-0.0055038412,
-0.0617194511,
0.0488811247,
0.0066636573,
-0.0189291369,
-0.0005574336,
0.0691477135,
0.0004113095,
0.0008047021,
-0.0158332381,
0.0526191629,
-0.0611555278,
-0.0496814325,
-0.0137172705,
0.0157402847,
0.0060608964,
-0.0046157874,
-0.0429799035,
-0.0289944764,
0.0003907429,
0.0237416755,
0.0163447689,
0.004149077,
0.0583265163,
0.0165592004,
-0.0216244888,
-0.0017693532,
-0.0370277874,
0.0148183834,
-0.0358480886,
-0.0029568996,
-0.0483275764,
-5.898107557e-33,
-0.0515973605,
-0.0281190816,
0.0117965434,
-0.0197910015,
-0.0627018437,
0.0022597017,
-0.0653689504,
-0.0106284888,
0.0063203573,
0.0072555169,
0.0162527636,
-0.0129489833,
0.0074179443,
0.0878805667,
-0.0134337181,
0.0032166746,
0.0503436401,
-0.0005967463,
-0.0164855532,
0.0627373531,
0.0427691936,
-0.0191242583,
-0.0187215526,
-0.0698613077,
-0.0079393238,
-0.0400946364,
-0.037514884,
0.0244196281,
0.0199911501,
0.0491109788,
-0.0381440371,
0.0134949014,
0.0142109431,
-0.0389017314,
-0.0326173753,
0.0830696747,
-0.0209074449,
-0.0021824874,
0.00320705,
-0.0075460249,
-0.0308920797,
-0.036728885,
0.0018739441,
-0.0022741074,
0.0107438918,
-0.0162636805,
-0.0099530388,
-0.0145695778,
-0.0417271554,
-0.0593114831,
-0.0424299501,
0.0169510618,
-0.0335449614,
-0.044833608,
-0.0228980444,
0.068915531,
0.0409924649,
-0.0244057514,
-0.0220884383,
0.0441311076,
0.0056594908,
-0.0169303082,
0.0552590378,
0.0456924774,
-0.0094936732,
0.0624126047,
0.0146081978,
-0.0082120327,
-0.0348201469,
-0.0308854915,
-0.0461820513,
0.0477133952,
-0.0022662953,
0.073251009,
0.0006402698,
0.0167682581,
-0.0305289589,
0.0529267155,
0.0061880755,
0.027628677,
0.0044253338,
0.026360061,
0.0047308397,
-0.0035282562,
-0.0173609965,
-0.0325694084,
-0.0133236954,
-0.0337416418,
0.024500085,
0.0378329903,
0.010952251,
-0.0374374464,
0.069453381,
-0.0158766862,
0.0200161263,
0.056903787,
-0.033628989,
0.0305288993,
-0.0250806678,
0.017569771,
-0.0004026116,
-0.037307851,
0.0803920701,
0.0445723124,
-0.0066208001,
0.0301572047,
-0.0279895682,
0.0002185373,
-0.0482731313,
0.0199100915,
-0.0384309068,
0.0471233055,
-0.0594507866,
0.0037053644,
0.007308681,
-0.0231251288,
-0.0385840274,
0.0664752275,
-0.0343698189,
0.0124872178,
-0.0180985127,
-0.0362888649,
0.0392943248,
0.0245551504,
-0.0395630188,
0.0235080887,
-0.0033013897,
-0.034588743,
0.0559030659,
-0.0058882767,
-0.0156096881,
0.0076289163,
2.496e-7,
-0.0193890706,
0.0085206721,
0.0542426743,
-0.0016010829,
0.0375420637,
0.027477365,
0.0209609848,
0.0247544777,
0.0118770218,
-0.0067729969,
0.0227807201,
-0.0266325828,
0.0875066742,
0.000453924,
-0.0699456111,
0.006074389,
-0.101735577,
-0.0297200363,
-0.0333480872,
0.0186254941,
0.0937624574,
0.0682837442,
-0.0407462493,
-0.0045912536,
-0.0024756661,
0.0234443806,
0.0586757027,
0.0086377161,
-0.0143692875,
0.0359810181,
0.0114766983,
-0.0052067987,
0.0026144017,
-0.0040906593,
-0.0168595295,
0.0209166706,
0.0022488665,
0.0649691671,
0.0007758394,
-0.0755653307,
0.0162406862,
0.009721159,
0.0100830039,
-0.0422532372,
0.0195282213,
-0.0480282903,
0.0045990092,
-0.0197861083,
-0.024010554,
0.0157764945,
-0.005639425,
-0.0368222445,
-0.0188689381,
0.0040518441,
0.014873446,
-0.0069505814,
0.0329174958,
-0.0777917653,
-0.0342709683,
-0.006203135,
-0.0573555902,
-0.0266625769,
-0.0156123843,
-0.0179684199,
0.0258145165,
-0.0203220341,
0.0014902722,
1.861591373e-34,
0.031174453,
-0.0386767872,
-0.0044088899,
0.0384245962,
0.0402684622,
-0.0196898282,
-0.002030734,
0.0053353719,
0.0338276178,
-0.0789577514,
-0.0153052602
] |
Subsets and Splits
No saved queries yet
Save your SQL queries to embed, download, and access them later. Queries will appear here once saved.