id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10588v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10588v2 | A Better Way to Do Masked Language Model Scoring | 2023-05-17T21:51:58 | 2023-05-23T15:12:33 | Carina Kauf, Anna Ivanova | cs.CL | cs.CL | Estimating the log-likelihood of a given sentence under an autoregressive
language model is straightforward: one can simply apply the chain rule and sum
the log-likelihood values for each successive token. However, for masked
language models (MLMs), there is no direct way to estimate the log-likelihood
of a sentence. To address this issue, Salazar et al. (2020) propose to estimate
sentence pseudo-log-likelihood (PLL) scores, computed by successively masking
each sentence token, retrieving its score using the rest of the sentence as
context, and summing the resulting values. Here, we demonstrate that the
original PLL method yields inflated scores for out-of-vocabulary words and
propose an adapted metric, in which we mask not only the target token, but also
all within-word tokens to the right of the target. We show that our adapted
metric (PLL-word-l2r) outperforms both the original PLL metric and a PLL metric
in which all within-word tokens are masked. In particular, it better satisfies
theoretical desiderata and better correlates with scores from autoregressive
models. Finally, we show that the choice of metric affects even tightly
controlled, minimal pair evaluation benchmarks (such as BLiMP), underscoring
the importance of selecting an appropriate scoring metric for evaluating MLM
properties. | [
0.0058726962,
0.0683615357,
0.0049899216,
0.0363139249,
-0.0638085008,
0.0171032641,
0.0433037207,
0.0061961091,
-0.0209926683,
-0.0713144243,
-0.0255081188,
-0.0479373001,
0.0323660746,
0.0727693588,
0.0418237001,
-0.031867601,
0.045428697,
-0.031339366,
-0.0112967538,
-0.0188768022,
-0.004019985,
-0.0065563498,
0.0206762627,
0.0471881405,
0.0223691687,
-0.0029651911,
0.0386441797,
-0.0049426109,
0.0369211175,
-0.0099755684,
-0.002982246,
0.0210169777,
-0.0301599707,
0.0788384452,
0.0000019103,
-0.0732630342,
-0.0293695237,
0.0084059946,
-0.0151138436,
0.0394054875,
0.0286594834,
-0.0125938654,
0.0160721578,
0.0296823084,
-0.0393263288,
-0.0425729863,
0.0311491583,
-0.003625484,
0.0093145873,
0.0678359345,
-0.0068365508,
-0.0016582186,
0.0283417664,
-0.0491954014,
-0.0225601662,
-0.0387020707,
0.030016372,
-0.0255254079,
-0.0354857817,
-0.045305714,
-0.001785618,
0.0689614117,
0.0074003134,
-0.0035961876,
0.0409144685,
0.0344839394,
-0.0205537789,
0.0046011694,
0.0087847719,
0.0198786296,
-0.0293167569,
-0.0225469787,
0.0209608991,
-0.0178785045,
-0.0188919213,
0.0057847984,
-0.0339341313,
-0.0037255094,
0.0489973798,
0.0044139144,
0.0456432365,
0.0220050421,
0.0503631532,
0.0099292602,
-0.0555714406,
0.0669057146,
0.0405520052,
-0.0274310168,
-0.0243314393,
-0.014840032,
-0.0553648062,
-0.0443001688,
-0.0000715623,
-0.0235963073,
-0.0000469724,
0.0094315335,
-0.0368347801,
-0.0419570319,
-0.0104374737,
0.0028709653,
0.0538389236,
-0.0017098839,
0.0138407303,
0.0477374382,
-0.0475524887,
0.0746861994,
0.0470898114,
-0.0074492437,
-0.0330218635,
-0.0227260031,
0.0059666433,
-0.0084529752,
-0.0126611935,
0.0281256214,
-0.0472591557,
-0.0378764048,
-0.0215433445,
-0.0171764586,
-0.019339608,
-0.0125631634,
-0.0161473844,
-0.0238977727,
-0.0189609118,
-0.0052540218,
0.0072213579,
-0.0176178105,
0.0070852912,
0.0081728324,
0.0021454645,
-0.0593071282,
-0.0121064764,
0.0333203487,
0.0203833878,
-0.0229970571,
-0.0066188206,
0.0486957021,
0.022214558,
-0.0437115915,
0.0581372753,
-0.0326668099,
-0.0505487509,
-0.0470952429,
-0.0190743972,
-0.0830925778,
-0.0027664888,
0.0092723342,
0.0232057311,
-0.0293739699,
0.005330374,
-0.0030128066,
0.0068183388,
0.0354204997,
0.0021510967,
0.0044707167,
-0.0269313026,
-0.0078400215,
-0.0090015158,
0.0738698617,
0.0436146408,
0.0060337516,
0.04814386,
0.0054561947,
0.0030574503,
0.0622244626,
0.0243150741,
0.015629679,
-0.0221619122,
-0.0174225084,
0.0505111367,
-0.0145013947,
0.0296339728,
0.042386394,
-0.0202022903,
-0.0022557133,
0.0529001988,
0.0354527123,
0.0471620373,
-0.0281843562,
0.0220877994,
0.0038003852,
0.0179714337,
0.0175012425,
0.0083719008,
-0.0080526443,
-0.0556258075,
0.023267813,
0.0798514709,
0.0259503629,
0.0061120596,
-0.0593997054,
-0.0105407005,
0.0085726278,
0.0157800764,
0.0124361543,
0.0325771049,
-0.0142819108,
-0.0312789455,
0.0169984028,
0.0267420579,
-0.0259433556,
0.0181627832,
-0.0603661761,
-0.0322135165,
-0.0164296366,
0.0350566134,
-0.0000837248,
0.0097683864,
-0.0128776003,
-0.0462395474,
0.0603443012,
-0.0068562049,
0.0061207167,
0.0444028266,
-0.0083277328,
-0.0177433472,
-0.0287832748,
0.0424129814,
0.0246664807,
-0.0084216176,
0.0084398929,
0.037744388,
-0.0529277697,
-0.0018570831,
0.0325809754,
-0.043036975,
-0.0272341147,
0.021044001,
-0.0062101139,
0.0310662985,
0.0124994293,
-0.0217163507,
0.0525179803,
0.0200460143,
-0.0660894364,
-0.0290044304,
-0.0003551909,
-0.0443560742,
-0.0545125492,
0.0265951362,
-0.0495039783,
0.0188977458,
0.0790477991,
0.0037635306,
-0.0575868301,
-0.0005306528,
-0.0194944181,
0.0747507736,
-0.0308077913,
0.027624663,
-0.0023767971,
0.0517654531,
-0.0362010524,
0.037434943,
-0.0207788888,
0.0660726801,
-0.0140450336,
0.002067182,
0.029721627,
-0.0014164142,
-0.0394216515,
0.0133071784,
-0.0015547079,
0.0024450968,
0.0337962024,
0.006922408,
-0.0406776443,
-0.0186203383,
-0.0726583824,
-0.0046770736,
-0.0267924611,
0.0075961878,
0.0366395153,
0.0101849483,
-0.0295958873,
0.0117663834,
-0.0273719952,
-0.0522868708,
-0.0090781571,
0.0215914436,
0.0068755834,
0.0088563049,
-0.0336294994,
-0.0405173339,
-0.0180852786,
-0.0138633475,
0.0622228384,
-0.0138812959,
-0.0568562597,
-0.0355713852,
0.0636411905,
-0.041763287,
-0.0090056993,
-0.0181880835,
-0.0166241173,
-0.0143157784,
-0.0070398618,
0.0680417642,
0.0356709212,
-0.0010035088,
-0.0280367471,
0.0562688746,
-0.0173110869,
-0.0535902604,
-0.0173219647,
-0.0050332313,
0.0014165591,
-0.0032130603,
-0.044650659,
0.0181283336,
0.0325538777,
0.0210577622,
-0.018541513,
-0.024076134,
0.0031528361,
-0.048570022,
-0.054623507,
-0.033206962,
0.0213067289,
-0.0432888828,
0.0495537445,
-0.0171093084,
-0.0692111254,
0.0336799026,
-0.0543279164,
0.0114825461,
-0.0375216901,
-0.0239407308,
-0.0256958492,
0.0447833799,
0.023854753,
0.0125351865,
0.008629675,
-0.0248520598,
-0.0106342053,
0.0120124063,
0.0159570109,
-0.0440493599,
0.0398190729,
-0.0327834412,
0.0061589689,
0.0192586724,
-0.0168113057,
-0.009194646,
-0.0683111697,
-0.0249225665,
0.0226515122,
-0.0017879701,
-0.0253058206,
-0.0223089103,
-0.0005542309,
0.0188220181,
0.0242254063,
-0.0223140698,
0.0079857828,
-0.0127483057,
0.0260860752,
0.0973419771,
-0.0342185386,
0.0319642276,
-0.0411033742,
0.0439760052,
0.0110826995,
0.0485239811,
0.0767719597,
0.0051447484,
-0.0176356584,
0.0468558744,
0.005191301,
-0.0398957543,
0.0316255465,
0.0494998097,
-0.0141678574,
-0.0142938485,
0.1408926845,
0.0163323078,
-0.0191459283,
-0.0037649048,
-0.0156652834,
0.0778163224,
0.019828558,
-0.0056641027,
-0.0705385953,
-0.0103514912,
0.0226181448,
0.0158012845,
-0.0310511235,
-0.0160277635,
-0.0174966827,
-0.1239132956,
0.0098424722,
0.0157672446,
-0.0110454131,
-0.0123519395,
-0.0774737149,
0.0277962685,
-0.0096312994,
0.0248445198,
-0.0113834003,
-0.0138879521,
0.004699247,
0.0230082907,
-0.0489159301,
-0.0260938574,
0.0332456902,
-0.0528309792,
0.045729652,
0.043223463,
0.0259324573,
-0.0083320113,
-0.0357402973,
0.0416905954,
-0.0242948141,
-0.0227457136,
-0.0156051945,
0.0169028565,
-0.021127658,
-0.0185187161,
0.0241830721,
0.023992829,
-0.0133752618,
0.0122790569,
-0.0148668056,
0.0259531494,
0.0334312059,
-0.0169486236,
0.0036353895,
0.0183033589,
-0.0283788014,
0.0880968347,
0.0563987605,
-0.037670698,
-0.0142040998,
-0.0383412167,
-0.0007387293,
0.0105929077,
-0.0189792756,
0.0111996429,
0.012809691,
-0.0260798223,
-0.0560188629,
-0.0271336902,
0.0160866976,
0.0597054362,
-0.0194541961,
0.0665269569,
-0.0507814102,
-0.0254428815,
-0.0147422142,
-0.0051253829,
-0.0416329019,
0.0370579064,
-0.0390583239,
0.0264823362,
0.0127526419,
0.0071672197,
-0.0497980975,
0.0486434847,
-0.1000393033,
-0.0826287195,
0.0294509772,
0.0191768408,
0.0272844397,
0.0295924414,
-0.010959086,
-0.0468875207,
0.0572019592,
0.0476302914,
-0.0115705132,
0.0541829728,
0.0480115041,
-0.002991599,
-0.002480828,
0.0559721887,
-0.0417107902,
-0.027700264,
0.0322294794,
0.0634142607,
0.0038219925,
-0.024654163,
0.0156950764,
0.0406817906,
0.0927011371,
-0.0546017401,
-0.0346130766,
-0.009506505,
-0.0205233302,
-0.0444523469,
-0.0375648476,
-0.0284290127,
0.0123993,
0.0346691906,
0.0349967293,
-0.0317862406,
0.0657869279,
-0.0209358856,
0.0057269419,
-0.0795817152,
-0.0030796675,
-0.0091991117,
0.0126168653,
-0.0232237112,
-0.0099120457,
-0.0080063343,
-0.0339826457,
0.0201135613,
0.0153290657,
0.0026538579,
-0.0062134573,
0.0005869207,
0.005344294,
-0.0134947849,
0.0420428962,
-0.0945932642,
-0.006931073,
-0.0098774666,
-0.0218531732,
0.0442205817,
-0.0085667456,
0.0821125284,
-0.007786504,
-0.0172771513,
-0.0320522375,
0.0260901991,
0.0047569214,
-0.0287799109,
0.0185626242,
0.0058502774,
-0.0234212764,
0.0519388877,
0.0676188245,
0.0480022952,
0.0198882688,
0.0341789126,
0.0171937477,
-0.0262234695,
0.0056228614,
0.0075090509,
0.059277501,
-0.0048518293,
-0.0055406452,
-0.0651519522,
-0.081813544,
0.039539542,
0.007825139,
0.0269750729,
-0.0035636988,
0.0039101313,
0.0447060205,
-0.0133176511,
-0.0051668934,
-0.0676733404,
0.0112713464,
0.0629052147,
-0.0148254419,
-0.0129297273,
-6.907492802e-33,
-0.0295570549,
-0.0186823942,
-0.0402375981,
-0.003901948,
-0.0093146916,
0.0576843359,
-0.0230010487,
0.0218800288,
-0.0098492224,
-0.0028592257,
-0.0001998573,
-0.0043648211,
0.0132822013,
0.0104102707,
-0.0347279981,
-0.0071243024,
0.0189665947,
-0.004398074,
-0.0174903423,
-0.0157330465,
0.0301468428,
0.0436451286,
0.0627842993,
-0.0425838567,
0.0507259704,
-0.0035171043,
-0.0357302874,
-0.017932307,
-0.0031433187,
0.0410131998,
-0.0385665968,
0.0548991822,
0.009577319,
-0.0217073038,
-0.0378510468,
-0.0111988755,
-0.0495227724,
-0.0262754112,
0.0499451943,
-0.0376083478,
-0.0293369256,
-0.006482095,
0.045732446,
0.0089646494,
-0.070490025,
-0.0265221894,
0.0392693654,
-0.0197599344,
-0.0441609398,
-0.0297548734,
-0.0401620306,
0.0398397446,
-0.0118772201,
0.0090045445,
0.035802789,
0.0233241431,
0.0166793726,
0.0231767781,
-0.0450059883,
0.0080311988,
-0.008453914,
0.0737124905,
0.0598271936,
0.0405034423,
0.0257685725,
0.0837028995,
0.0409053415,
-0.0307164397,
0.0224985238,
-0.0109486952,
0.0934103653,
-0.0067497669,
0.0635595545,
0.0461255126,
0.0624912158,
0.0119579872,
-0.0714659989,
0.017930774,
-0.0076114102,
-0.0096232975,
0.0314673223,
0.0333948173,
-0.0472689047,
-0.0209644902,
-0.0814125091,
-0.0619112477,
-0.0443311222,
0.0289923772,
0.029345816,
0.0083131846,
-0.0324449837,
-0.0208855961,
0.0307666529,
-0.0398162752,
-0.0415673032,
-0.0127919912,
-0.014275304,
0.024218943,
0.0024358109,
0.0680279657,
-0.0474967249,
0.004613955,
0.015873421,
0.0632382184,
0.0292502455,
-0.0533892401,
0.0113021629,
0.0039868704,
-0.0887110382,
-0.0172709431,
-0.0549378879,
0.0051224469,
-0.0057467269,
-0.0307107214,
0.0383190885,
-0.0158869587,
-0.0181770977,
0.0379280299,
0.018413825,
-0.0269827433,
-0.0097214384,
0.0276999287,
-0.0214982033,
0.0135744186,
-0.0239842422,
-0.0050652814,
-0.0036993879,
-0.0035275293,
0.0967657119,
-0.0022775815,
-0.031075323,
-0.0014823386,
2.666e-7,
0.0521856174,
0.0244349279,
0.0116782226,
0.0143629014,
-0.0055839615,
0.0373085104,
-0.0158007108,
0.0338355228,
0.0311975349,
-0.0043430333,
-0.0430720523,
-0.0076044207,
0.054640878,
-0.0203431975,
-0.0373950638,
0.0251442865,
-0.0669980645,
-0.001911695,
-0.0389899537,
-0.0038098721,
0.017711971,
0.0972587243,
0.0339059271,
0.0273707621,
-0.013118688,
-0.0583897084,
0.0258926749,
-0.0645072907,
-0.0482933521,
0.0014509389,
0.0352609903,
0.0310828052,
0.0318597965,
0.0054110242,
-0.0183170252,
0.051153183,
0.0708970279,
0.0245595183,
0.0161391608,
-0.0188842453,
-0.0217571594,
0.0152381919,
-0.0123094693,
-0.0819809809,
0.0879208446,
0.0322171785,
-0.0327524655,
-0.0883855373,
-0.0584673844,
0.0217039119,
0.0602298006,
-0.0179572646,
-0.0707970113,
0.0321649238,
0.0267883297,
-0.0081022745,
-0.0291272197,
-0.0477117933,
-0.0728209093,
-0.0343682431,
-0.0239802711,
-0.0167811234,
-0.0223219916,
0.0296529625,
0.0008770617,
-0.0733968616,
0.0040691406,
2.954107762e-34,
0.0425993539,
-0.0118362969,
-0.003114782,
-0.0137722213,
0.0645319447,
-0.0216270015,
-0.0261484832,
0.0209908709,
-0.0016816625,
-0.1162097827,
-0.0026963106
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10568v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10568v2 | From chocolate bunny to chocolate crocodile: Do Language Models Understand Noun Compounds? | 2023-05-17T21:05:23 | 2023-05-24T21:30:11 | Jordan Coil, Vered Shwartz | cs.CL | cs.CL | Noun compound interpretation is the task of expressing a noun compound (e.g.
chocolate bunny) in a free-text paraphrase that makes the relationship between
the constituent nouns explicit (e.g. bunny-shaped chocolate). We propose
modifications to the data and evaluation setup of the standard task (Hendrickx
et al., 2013), and show that GPT-3 solves it almost perfectly. We then
investigate the task of noun compound conceptualization, i.e. paraphrasing a
novel or rare noun compound. E.g., chocolate crocodile is a crocodile-shaped
chocolate. This task requires creativity, commonsense, and the ability to
generalize knowledge about similar concepts. While GPT-3's performance is not
perfect, it is better than that of humans -- likely thanks to its access to
vast amounts of knowledge, and because conceptual processing is effortful for
people (Connell and Lynott, 2012). Finally, we estimate the extent to which
GPT-3 is reasoning about the world vs. parroting its training data. We find
that the outputs from GPT-3 often have significant overlap with a large web
corpus, but that the parroting strategy is less beneficial for novel noun
compounds. | [
0.0672486424,
0.042144116,
-0.031622503,
0.0309235696,
-0.0542266965,
0.037394274,
-0.0365921967,
0.0204723179,
-0.0621090569,
-0.0688358173,
0.0116595393,
-0.0298236497,
-0.000221066,
-0.0074090338,
0.0367944129,
-0.0573810488,
0.0484739207,
-0.0302827228,
0.0029444443,
0.0243707318,
0.0192970354,
0.0387572274,
0.0128680412,
0.0285971761,
0.0105238855,
0.0008028829,
-0.0083164014,
-0.0274531636,
-0.000386683,
-0.0141986422,
-0.0277597718,
0.0456774496,
0.0061626211,
0.0458497256,
0.0000016406,
-0.059522029,
-0.0031619659,
-0.0027068555,
0.0161183495,
0.0563937835,
0.0420877859,
-0.0621702895,
0.004503354,
-0.0141490586,
0.0060578818,
0.0106399581,
0.0348254107,
0.0376403369,
0.030983435,
0.0057906541,
-0.0073257457,
-0.0220308434,
-0.0171780717,
-0.0380440913,
0.0412197858,
-0.05715039,
0.0338998809,
0.0035772896,
-0.0154798124,
0.0169826075,
-0.0389207192,
0.0096636359,
-0.0041822982,
0.0510320067,
-0.0152213043,
0.044933904,
-0.0226966422,
-0.0371389724,
0.0397021919,
0.0693920553,
-0.0477438085,
-0.0252661705,
-0.0071686399,
-0.0004395033,
0.0071306513,
0.0457885191,
-0.0352130346,
0.0267872736,
-0.0215983316,
0.0260742996,
0.0247872062,
-0.0281933267,
0.0219189543,
0.0361511,
-0.0092234425,
0.0732759535,
0.0326585323,
-0.0244098585,
-0.0088176504,
0.0433877409,
-0.0394638143,
-0.0381255299,
0.0316842794,
-0.0166523959,
0.018977616,
0.0334970579,
-0.0181108508,
-0.024684893,
0.0285903942,
-0.022545889,
0.0432187356,
0.0277271047,
0.0263514146,
0.0639736727,
-0.0473401695,
0.0271592475,
-0.0537740029,
0.008616019,
-0.0457394049,
-0.0349964947,
-0.0832333043,
-0.001353016,
-0.0559555516,
0.0440548547,
-0.011852785,
-0.0103246532,
-0.0033694715,
0.0137547795,
0.0254588965,
-0.0609209128,
-0.0103174988,
0.0287466943,
-0.0531217679,
-0.0129324887,
-0.0637152269,
0.0387793183,
-0.0726016685,
0.0468589664,
-0.0012089082,
-0.0337923728,
-0.0196654946,
-0.0385212936,
0.0154407881,
-0.0231932532,
0.0083056195,
0.0654065087,
-0.0210233945,
-0.031535197,
-0.0241132658,
-0.0316564441,
-0.0388266556,
-0.0554386079,
0.0137598887,
-0.0744786561,
0.0418435596,
0.0021610402,
-0.0025187389,
-0.0415456332,
0.0003785867,
0.0339412168,
-0.0576068163,
0.1028762013,
-0.0212642103,
-0.0152896224,
-0.0272412337,
0.0233570263,
0.0110546295,
0.0438549817,
0.0552027784,
0.0229094904,
0.014126284,
-0.0012598493,
-0.0107362969,
-0.0070896274,
-0.0102783209,
0.0043611745,
0.0083934572,
-0.0297434125,
-0.0158769339,
0.0695584491,
0.0387636162,
0.062220376,
-0.0165102016,
-0.0158752687,
0.0755515546,
0.0564930029,
-0.0145524517,
0.0657444224,
0.0820655078,
0.014161801,
0.0142170023,
0.0157252513,
-0.0355431698,
-0.0343693346,
-0.0445549637,
0.0679511726,
-0.0533817299,
0.0484176464,
-0.017359646,
-0.0090700956,
-0.0252051633,
-0.0060393922,
0.0483044423,
-0.0408141054,
0.0590385348,
0.0388338082,
-0.039957229,
0.0585771315,
0.0207572617,
-0.0481931642,
0.0275966711,
-0.0170858521,
0.0438874401,
0.0406503603,
0.0433922336,
-0.0000058036,
-0.0190222319,
-0.0048690923,
-0.0183562711,
0.0262086242,
0.0117029818,
-0.0059948885,
0.0036888134,
-0.0104518821,
-0.0149859013,
-0.0185468644,
0.0261612069,
0.0360852443,
0.0282928348,
0.0105868615,
0.0392190181,
-0.091557622,
0.0365487486,
0.0236147996,
-0.0350234993,
-0.0140928524,
-0.0308328159,
-0.0001112782,
0.0115003688,
0.0415825248,
0.0131844357,
0.0339262709,
-0.0122793214,
-0.0288272537,
-0.0326738842,
0.0041923192,
-0.0028655708,
-0.033171799,
0.0065483511,
-0.0612800047,
-0.000282442,
0.0114980098,
-0.017034715,
-0.0263143703,
0.0493154824,
-0.0396764502,
0.0843155086,
-0.054677777,
0.0255002826,
-0.0129145915,
0.0323880091,
-0.0108482223,
0.0906751901,
0.0213718526,
-0.0005888219,
0.0108143287,
0.000041729,
0.0069993311,
-0.0038508561,
-0.0178435389,
-0.004843995,
0.0294787604,
-0.0104185725,
-0.0141580412,
-0.0058881138,
-0.0678521171,
0.0140690515,
-0.0296098236,
-0.0017137829,
0.0204674061,
0.0344057977,
0.0371707417,
0.0076534892,
-0.0089482451,
0.021152081,
0.0152872689,
0.0054807812,
-0.0606240109,
0.034145914,
0.0255574491,
0.0042035677,
-0.0387994982,
-0.0094388984,
-0.0038577886,
-0.0377514884,
0.0376763344,
0.0123092514,
-0.0320479386,
-0.0295071658,
0.0105238585,
-0.0752419978,
-0.0156156374,
0.0130659323,
-0.0359424353,
-0.0001384428,
-0.0099175014,
0.0463798568,
0.0250065159,
0.0217593331,
-0.0048359204,
0.0561509095,
-0.0065111611,
-0.013401852,
-0.0447635166,
-0.0423557237,
-0.0085898712,
-0.0310591608,
-0.0114495317,
0.0034942469,
0.1134435311,
0.0226410497,
0.0111931069,
-0.0419659205,
0.0468881465,
-0.0187836904,
-0.0308865774,
-0.0767469183,
-0.0001052784,
-0.0403617397,
0.0530320518,
-0.0243844129,
-0.0203623902,
0.1088203937,
-0.0481994972,
0.0148955518,
-0.0299002696,
-0.0038810696,
-0.0046604592,
0.0530607328,
-0.0132011883,
0.0168527607,
0.0937800035,
-0.0351584405,
-0.0497088432,
0.0213465709,
0.0233928263,
-0.0289652031,
0.0408728458,
-0.0632280707,
0.0096871108,
0.0060173967,
-0.027040353,
-0.0040790029,
-0.0301069673,
-0.0496612489,
0.0229853708,
0.0222020559,
-0.0106692836,
0.0255676787,
0.0247243904,
-0.0021799004,
-0.0110116052,
-0.0051163812,
-0.0105406363,
-0.0343925916,
0.0367197841,
0.0457336605,
0.0000780305,
0.0260317195,
-0.0235064346,
-0.0317436568,
0.0334937312,
0.056591697,
0.0038162558,
0.0096236039,
0.026038086,
0.0016086499,
-0.040077839,
-0.0236214027,
-0.0187280346,
0.0002230884,
-0.0216026139,
-0.0457949638,
0.1013872996,
0.0390882865,
-0.0111241275,
0.0395960957,
0.02330135,
0.0443725847,
0.0138226524,
0.0016799116,
-0.0589923449,
-0.0193766076,
0.0138446977,
-0.0427528806,
0.0075059952,
-0.0451998562,
-0.0231295433,
-0.1001641676,
0.0169453826,
-0.0082771722,
-0.0641903505,
-0.0121328691,
-0.0136523787,
0.0019648133,
-0.0156481881,
0.00838638,
0.0026856116,
-0.0358681418,
0.0331315733,
-0.0089058978,
0.0181022286,
-0.0555804931,
0.0426170044,
-0.0372725576,
0.0173697919,
0.0367067121,
0.0222129337,
-0.0087348009,
-0.0104304636,
0.0096339751,
-0.0612175241,
0.0081935944,
0.0138223879,
0.0018221118,
0.0106590707,
-0.0151711097,
-0.0203176737,
-0.0125215473,
-0.0546084717,
-0.0065283049,
-0.0157419704,
0.0847975761,
0.0247133989,
-0.0316010192,
0.0135825165,
-0.0044702943,
-0.0332283378,
0.1017939523,
0.0762025192,
0.0097882152,
-0.0258107409,
-0.0107899597,
-0.0386053398,
-0.022644056,
-0.0561382324,
0.0204355996,
-0.0221222583,
-0.043197114,
-0.0796900913,
-0.0619430244,
0.0490207262,
0.0382120796,
0.0088971537,
0.0335696116,
0.0195304751,
0.0105206361,
-0.0105884075,
0.0597012192,
-0.0197804682,
0.0108256973,
-0.0002976319,
-0.0110924346,
0.0154819097,
-0.0121296663,
-0.0717657804,
-0.0018742247,
-0.0793005154,
-0.0320122689,
0.0142074907,
-0.0070388615,
0.0341730639,
0.0130984522,
-0.0267020389,
-0.0075604212,
-0.00212891,
0.0126955146,
-0.003087769,
0.0199655686,
-0.0138300974,
0.0265037548,
0.0237314869,
0.0450506322,
-0.0125111779,
0.0254466943,
-0.0188916158,
0.055105105,
-0.0029504343,
-0.0132442489,
0.0598020218,
-0.0053671692,
0.0353483669,
-0.0289121643,
0.0073743872,
-0.0215974562,
-0.025080353,
-0.0055747977,
0.0029546439,
-0.0380051024,
-0.0208961628,
0.0462851338,
-0.0048312745,
-0.0354453474,
-0.0198755246,
-0.0134250382,
0.0155372089,
-0.0029816914,
-0.075604111,
0.0165130515,
-0.0306163393,
-0.0113227498,
-0.020046182,
-0.0046091466,
-0.0198772643,
-0.0672846213,
0.0139185414,
-0.073596105,
0.0250685029,
-0.0044377088,
-0.0048430441,
-0.0583917946,
0.0449647866,
-0.0457783118,
-0.0183124729,
-0.0205337424,
0.0286261626,
0.0300752521,
-0.0522028655,
0.0682545006,
-0.0538654141,
-0.0159683172,
-0.0022337083,
0.0273625553,
-0.0486568809,
-0.0133384457,
0.0436585993,
0.0296468642,
0.0002277669,
-0.0597756207,
0.0878398716,
0.0411943682,
0.0423020832,
-0.0076076323,
-0.0282597989,
0.0026145102,
-0.009105254,
-0.068672061,
0.0475325622,
0.0003943163,
0.0132644745,
-0.0908782482,
-0.0733834282,
-0.0153249707,
0.0133504765,
0.0258747432,
-0.0045737405,
0.0454818271,
0.0649032518,
-0.0271950122,
-0.0315414816,
-0.0109231053,
0.0169654712,
0.0216631088,
-0.027676139,
-0.046317596,
-5.918756218e-33,
-0.0442518257,
-0.0009465251,
-0.0256997105,
-0.0484073833,
-0.0077033141,
-0.0056084655,
-0.0518892035,
-0.0151838921,
-0.0189976301,
0.0210224334,
0.0044795382,
0.0097762318,
0.0262338351,
-0.0089684362,
0.0407978222,
-0.023517089,
0.0014632101,
0.0161173288,
-0.0118981041,
0.0000322737,
0.0183495041,
0.0402829908,
0.1184813306,
-0.0353642628,
-0.0048583201,
0.0080613922,
-0.0088812374,
-0.0431226455,
0.00565559,
0.0800409019,
-0.0287777241,
0.0455296896,
0.0533579327,
-0.0406008922,
-0.0187381916,
-0.0057044299,
-0.0945938751,
-0.0227114744,
0.0666095465,
-0.0498044901,
-0.0412344262,
-0.0217735656,
0.0577149615,
-0.017923709,
0.0060225506,
0.0165075175,
0.0392865203,
-0.0309157986,
0.0230293497,
-0.0049847304,
-0.1120818034,
-0.0124038309,
0.0289073586,
0.0153710051,
0.0108816214,
-0.0017115442,
-0.0132226506,
0.0763905346,
0.0169029161,
0.0384902842,
-0.0084041562,
0.0510180406,
0.0406589061,
-0.0068465509,
-0.0097994972,
0.0550853796,
0.012911669,
-0.0322422832,
-0.0291311834,
0.0382768512,
0.0347586162,
0.030712802,
0.0350726768,
0.0909681246,
0.0650431737,
0.0145724667,
0.0047049597,
-0.0084052095,
0.0175415073,
0.0022337367,
-0.0027199292,
-0.0252524018,
-0.0326387212,
-0.0180438776,
-0.0193601735,
0.0185315944,
-0.0441104025,
-0.0420223176,
0.0432349667,
-0.0242000446,
-0.0398112237,
0.0224577356,
0.0213478971,
-0.0117759388,
-0.0210233126,
-0.0099549461,
0.005963536,
0.0300272778,
-0.0034658078,
0.0208767299,
-0.0418859683,
-0.0693123788,
-0.0123525979,
0.0459082574,
0.0232655555,
-0.007238348,
0.0213926081,
-0.0067873038,
-0.046114523,
-0.008127572,
-0.069360055,
-0.0345953107,
-0.0009029749,
-0.0355735347,
0.0372024104,
0.0301040038,
-0.0079276823,
-0.0017964864,
0.0484837256,
-0.0459088571,
-0.0106950877,
0.0158308446,
-0.0033767112,
0.0231795348,
0.0016527448,
-0.0238595996,
-0.0248264987,
-0.0250754058,
0.0718202367,
-0.0318824574,
-0.0102175567,
0.0140136313,
2.59e-7,
0.075831376,
0.0635439828,
-0.0021237272,
0.0164880753,
0.0144398706,
0.0314044021,
0.0120865591,
0.0352710672,
-0.0031368425,
-0.0315876342,
-0.0010721619,
0.0116677498,
-0.0147451218,
0.0064132223,
-0.1052194759,
0.0259233974,
-0.0588428229,
0.0148481159,
-0.0529876649,
-0.0166870728,
0.0387407355,
0.0989611298,
0.0439154729,
-0.0221756697,
-0.0280748587,
-0.0417254455,
0.0573155023,
-0.0379124843,
-0.0263512116,
0.0031540813,
0.0009168629,
0.0554351956,
0.0306495111,
0.0397664942,
0.0125494609,
-0.013302641,
0.0508019961,
0.0155337052,
-0.0231672004,
0.023597559,
-0.0113833332,
-0.0832375363,
0.0012282842,
-0.0789220333,
0.0618868656,
-0.0233980045,
-0.0203417409,
-0.0013804755,
-0.0030480502,
0.0097813169,
-0.0189336613,
0.0022618687,
-0.0278257504,
-0.0004553117,
-0.0009996779,
0.0280909687,
-0.0130549539,
-0.0598574914,
0.0200359169,
0.0064456612,
-0.0346958674,
-0.0130457915,
-0.023059696,
-0.0338262096,
0.0433209501,
-0.094025597,
-0.0179467145,
2.188118679e-34,
0.0219331887,
0.0092658447,
0.0509335771,
0.0293250829,
0.0233810171,
0.0087657897,
0.0584943444,
-0.0048017246,
-0.0318358913,
-0.0301040169,
-0.0320751965
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10563v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10563v2 | HaSa: Hardness and Structure-Aware Contrastive Knowledge Graph Embedding | 2023-05-17T20:46:18 | 2023-10-15T02:15:41 | Honggen Zhang, June Zhang, Igor Molybog | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | We consider a contrastive learning approach to knowledge graph embedding
(KGE) via InfoNCE. For KGE, efficient learning relies on augmenting the
training data with negative triples. However, most KGE works overlook the bias
from generating the negative triples-false negative triples (factual triples
missing from the knowledge graph). We argue that the generation of high-quality
(i.e., hard) negative triples might lead to an increase in false negative
triples. To mitigate the impact of false negative triples during the generation
of hard negative triples, we propose the Hardness and Structure-aware
(\textbf{HaSa}) contrastive KGE method, which alleviates the effect of false
negative triples while generating the hard negative triples. Experiments show
that HaSa improves the performance of InfoNCE-based KGE approaches and achieves
state-of-the-art results in several metrics for WN18RR datasets and competitive
results for FB15k-237 datasets compared to both classic and pre-trained
LM-based KGE methods. | [
0.0004610789,
0.0023431682,
0.0146364775,
0.064665556,
-0.0337464213,
0.0009393467,
-0.0618942752,
0.0089629786,
0.0526551828,
-0.0359057486,
0.0133168222,
0.0072080917,
-0.0048430017,
0.0037094681,
0.050431937,
-0.0096149165,
0.0342342705,
0.0640617609,
0.0156815331,
-0.0207096804,
-0.0130047351,
-0.0000485696,
-0.0157154165,
-0.0389043353,
-0.0302960817,
-0.0023312876,
-0.0239740349,
0.0073758978,
0.0308237858,
-0.0422238335,
-0.0071834708,
0.0144152138,
0.0269916691,
-0.0084123695,
0.0000019891,
-0.0176777467,
0.0073291762,
0.0170303583,
-0.0484671108,
-0.0053448067,
-0.0061843572,
-0.0427845903,
0.0353733674,
0.0026383535,
-0.0253173653,
-0.0402233265,
0.0109234517,
0.1036046296,
0.0380936973,
0.0679055378,
-0.0215633325,
-0.0201035347,
0.032451883,
-0.0227682851,
0.0195015594,
-0.0019251285,
0.0379031301,
0.0333387554,
-0.0205207411,
0.0301148836,
-0.019970566,
0.0171574876,
0.0253839418,
0.0566400737,
0.0267768502,
0.0448749624,
-0.0325072221,
0.0353695191,
0.0146380356,
0.1230428889,
0.0025829782,
0.0215733219,
-0.0171711426,
-0.0455028005,
0.0061477376,
-0.021990262,
-0.012424971,
-0.0585069321,
0.0102581335,
0.017537728,
-0.0132732121,
-0.0055988566,
0.0468879975,
-0.0378226116,
-0.004666863,
0.0261483826,
0.0077788052,
-0.0318278894,
0.0366888531,
0.0134443091,
-0.0222360827,
0.0262956377,
-0.0310171843,
-0.0244607441,
0.0334224403,
0.0022299287,
0.0026129903,
-0.0019517672,
0.0261346847,
-0.060496375,
-0.0403090939,
0.0228262562,
-0.0170240067,
0.0621013977,
-0.0726834908,
0.0024921489,
-0.0165651329,
0.0156607237,
-0.0056761005,
-0.0092915446,
-0.0211603958,
0.0171492882,
0.0090567963,
0.04315814,
0.0096128732,
-0.0191607457,
-0.0125671988,
0.0173861552,
-0.0598147921,
0.0519807376,
0.0178030636,
0.0430120043,
0.044315327,
0.0075136391,
-0.0193240698,
0.0201343205,
-0.0374425128,
0.0216128752,
-0.0552604236,
0.0414728411,
-0.0065748543,
0.0001159429,
0.034688212,
0.0023166509,
0.0000862221,
0.0502924211,
-0.0054285643,
-0.0009850876,
-0.0488501899,
-0.0372960903,
0.031214498,
-0.0472308174,
0.0230480805,
-0.038061481,
0.0623788573,
-0.0056012687,
-0.0175181273,
-0.051123336,
0.0144433044,
-0.0253553297,
-0.062199872,
0.091257982,
-0.0292184092,
-0.0453840494,
-0.0529208593,
0.0264418647,
-0.0520756841,
0.0304710977,
-0.0035499197,
-0.0530140214,
0.0307530034,
0.0077808793,
-0.0491714068,
-0.0205939002,
0.0842915401,
0.0118255327,
0.0408278964,
0.0193901993,
-0.018797297,
0.0270743929,
0.0358284488,
0.044766359,
-0.0352086015,
-0.0628944486,
-0.0036313115,
-0.0353335291,
0.0233814344,
0.0203062687,
0.0241917409,
0.0392683111,
-0.0250293463,
0.0282413233,
-0.0625905469,
0.0306311417,
-0.0548654795,
0.0410395116,
0.0417093225,
-0.0303465202,
-0.0322460681,
0.0029451614,
0.0051156529,
-0.0209656786,
0.0592911877,
-0.0128901368,
0.0544322766,
-0.0273433812,
-0.071118772,
-0.0035971042,
0.0714349896,
-0.0243846104,
-0.0047395802,
0.0354016386,
0.0279522333,
0.0370422676,
0.0267960131,
-0.0264563821,
-0.0494276024,
0.0114907268,
-0.0453557707,
0.0008279632,
0.0398548096,
-0.037509609,
0.0009172678,
-0.0578850694,
-0.056216456,
-0.0060568852,
0.009447122,
0.0012870686,
0.0190056823,
0.0385174043,
0.0469880216,
-0.0308885835,
0.0279222764,
-0.0008033263,
-0.0554432645,
-0.0059002838,
-0.005072616,
0.0396604314,
0.0143124769,
0.0392227806,
0.0297867544,
-0.0210296493,
0.0572774038,
-0.0254030414,
-0.0342513472,
-0.0319532976,
-0.0310000386,
-0.1082685217,
0.062312264,
-0.0437027514,
0.0280783195,
0.0441102907,
-0.0497106351,
-0.04220137,
0.0128303403,
0.0004924401,
0.0585518219,
-0.0011028301,
-0.0428500734,
0.0354676433,
-0.0088847475,
0.0265851561,
0.0814754218,
-0.0573382229,
0.0183006506,
-0.0187441073,
-0.0550851636,
0.0350090303,
-0.0049833548,
-0.0402988605,
-0.0363183729,
0.02252746,
0.0209004469,
-0.0180256013,
-0.0368987285,
-0.0538573042,
0.0320441015,
-0.0295910146,
0.0280309916,
0.0177038293,
0.0112092067,
0.0028905,
-0.0239796154,
0.0549714491,
0.0100557562,
-0.0514612459,
0.016792845,
-0.0472576283,
0.0104652056,
0.0381287374,
0.0178008378,
-0.0158044398,
-0.0008172901,
-0.0132494373,
-0.0411564074,
0.0350930505,
-0.0346887447,
0.0000022963,
0.0110852262,
0.0761265755,
-0.0590715297,
0.0088101821,
-0.0611376725,
0.0067114048,
-0.0087017333,
-0.0012593507,
0.0019185767,
-0.0026523795,
-0.0624767393,
-0.0376491174,
0.0103368247,
0.0087581296,
-0.0186258145,
0.0015248681,
-0.0298452619,
0.0584825315,
-0.018337613,
-0.0392772891,
-0.0597765297,
0.0068001272,
0.0234132502,
-0.0250419471,
-0.0740827546,
0.0079462668,
-0.0101142768,
0.0198242087,
0.0054180743,
0.017251933,
0.0280253459,
-0.0115059968,
-0.0308179334,
0.0314117111,
0.0730202496,
-0.0124837086,
0.0040043881,
0.0178472195,
0.0033352911,
-0.0232046321,
0.0169049557,
-0.0125829242,
-0.000334828,
0.0261316802,
0.0289279912,
-0.0421383046,
-0.0506707095,
0.0465519503,
-0.0085925907,
0.0280206949,
0.0473984443,
-0.0163227152,
-0.0145930303,
-0.0509891249,
-0.0232072286,
-0.0087727187,
0.0232665781,
0.0373088196,
0.0205167178,
-0.0035531041,
-0.0165655594,
-0.0097447541,
0.0000857588,
-0.0014985329,
0.0122274896,
-0.0106365513,
-0.0297220442,
0.0512245446,
0.0290040448,
0.0068576918,
0.0402064659,
-0.0076773101,
-0.0189145636,
0.0492649041,
-0.0073577282,
-0.007767627,
-0.0012475058,
0.0128427474,
0.0013079157,
-0.0164722651,
-0.0343418531,
-0.0129838521,
-0.0145936189,
-0.0017948145,
0.0261244588,
0.0769186988,
0.0172593947,
-0.0318556577,
0.0250029564,
-0.0082591986,
-0.0111516044,
0.0490701012,
-0.0213571489,
-0.0987503827,
-0.0143625317,
-0.0284968428,
0.0083740503,
0.0132981287,
-0.0675069988,
-0.0048149056,
-0.095537439,
-0.0040531978,
0.0375347175,
0.0335119031,
-0.0734800175,
-0.0369073004,
0.0025689653,
-0.0401287526,
-0.0348167755,
-0.0255045705,
0.0056823688,
-0.0090065822,
0.003703099,
0.0016810321,
-0.0711955875,
-0.0100505706,
-0.0494744405,
0.034321636,
-0.0311399102,
0.00664471,
-0.021346068,
-0.0519094244,
-0.0016662893,
0.0062724366,
-0.039845828,
-0.0166559201,
0.0463320613,
0.0032006158,
-0.0043721618,
-0.0559658967,
-0.0018269356,
-0.0650213957,
0.011133804,
-0.0111561799,
0.1230299398,
0.007930777,
0.0034585681,
-0.0062650545,
-0.0136628635,
0.030236844,
0.0663054883,
0.0114857601,
0.0221374687,
0.0196540803,
-0.0097018396,
0.0369649231,
-0.0154649587,
-0.0044455742,
0.0237361025,
0.003868964,
0.0274976529,
-0.0471757427,
-0.0604046881,
0.0287712105,
0.0270937569,
-0.0181742832,
-0.0133641381,
-0.0065494594,
-0.0353099778,
-0.0609768368,
-0.0119942417,
-0.0092929946,
-0.002667045,
0.0116960974,
-0.0141307386,
0.0607263483,
-0.00991318,
-0.0240684543,
-0.0166761037,
-0.0240488667,
-0.0494631454,
-0.0717466846,
0.0413365178,
-0.0004158246,
0.0706876069,
0.0050656227,
0.0338445492,
0.1057852209,
0.0551800691,
-0.0275384206,
0.0092970431,
0.0648095682,
-0.0472128764,
0.0202984847,
0.0384660624,
-0.048442103,
-0.0398118086,
0.0111394152,
0.0720820054,
-0.0679879934,
0.0174675919,
-0.011209284,
0.0244052764,
0.0353336111,
0.0234647598,
0.0159573983,
-0.0619259216,
-0.0018208426,
-0.0286228973,
-0.0124657229,
-0.053832572,
-0.0007138622,
0.0232805014,
0.0031614872,
-0.0214143842,
-0.0021618248,
0.0201710332,
0.032405857,
-0.0053038276,
-0.0172859766,
0.0723931715,
-0.0150342882,
0.0417449586,
-0.0261660926,
-0.0561926253,
0.015941333,
-0.0105643868,
-0.0133252162,
-0.0545647629,
0.0199256055,
0.0100533087,
0.0162919611,
-0.0731404573,
0.014848127,
0.0194776747,
0.0433734655,
-0.0110013969,
-0.0269734059,
0.0729424581,
0.0124971922,
0.0285648908,
-0.0034062101,
-0.0202065129,
-0.0066151135,
0.0120729245,
-0.0539511032,
-0.0430410951,
0.0538353398,
0.0225045774,
0.0045033968,
0.0201800484,
0.0674278215,
-0.0048024859,
0.0637811497,
-0.0360194817,
-0.044173602,
-0.059001714,
-0.0278235395,
0.0555130355,
0.0676831082,
-0.0000898623,
0.0413803011,
-0.053583663,
-0.0804849491,
0.019576896,
-0.0068849078,
-0.0689350069,
0.0381739661,
0.0312182307,
0.0014145648,
0.0140260495,
-0.0669223815,
0.0003939377,
-0.0188813619,
-0.0449429974,
-0.0273203887,
0.0070049264,
-6.345736541e-33,
-0.0221479591,
0.0175805669,
0.0105274497,
-0.0268715136,
-0.0314308107,
0.0295608453,
-0.0167991668,
-0.0108486339,
-0.0390606374,
0.0387759432,
0.0082600117,
-0.0208338685,
-0.020294087,
0.005135891,
-0.0229110047,
-0.0159361288,
0.0379059762,
0.0233037733,
-0.0087454617,
0.0283037666,
0.0371565446,
0.0166954808,
0.064992331,
-0.0986967981,
0.0107371034,
-0.0186236538,
0.0290273242,
0.0190972108,
0.02582209,
0.0450062044,
-0.0258715376,
0.0603633188,
0.0217686631,
-0.030001035,
-0.0032058759,
-0.0868176445,
-0.1021783054,
-0.0760383829,
0.0210590921,
0.0177508201,
-0.0266089309,
-0.0137818111,
0.0276948344,
-0.0026923583,
0.0610015951,
-0.0453685783,
0.034318991,
0.0034691223,
-0.0382331237,
-0.0084100813,
-0.0361988693,
0.0108236717,
0.0255735517,
0.0013837073,
-0.0050596031,
-0.0033998135,
0.0504742712,
-0.0335015841,
-0.1291488856,
-0.0052506956,
-0.0011750576,
-0.0392735787,
0.0079727676,
-0.0166838132,
0.0140518583,
0.0336592644,
-0.0037981824,
0.0003777234,
0.0210410561,
0.0058607687,
0.0015245056,
0.0498849154,
0.0308095999,
0.0756971389,
-0.002381695,
-0.0139645254,
-0.1019450724,
-0.0075488943,
-0.0195119474,
-0.0066149426,
-0.0097701568,
0.0069396077,
-0.067229785,
-0.053276144,
0.005675022,
-0.0302208457,
0.0094211977,
-0.0397455208,
-0.0080841109,
0.0183157828,
0.0120568508,
0.0579878725,
0.0042675361,
-0.0571765564,
-0.0074008852,
0.0913935751,
0.0003380832,
0.0183623489,
-0.0064307014,
-0.0261832215,
-0.0866595656,
-0.0241771266,
0.0107980603,
-0.0254014302,
0.0067065768,
0.0162175614,
0.0759908259,
0.0070912009,
-0.0474806391,
-0.023962345,
-0.0150462333,
-0.0315944292,
0.033797536,
-0.0218799524,
0.0343809277,
0.0269395504,
0.0031281328,
0.0332976431,
0.0564723611,
0.0212014262,
0.0112777911,
0.0321425013,
0.0302729923,
0.0299535859,
-0.0121112382,
0.0026738287,
-0.0376426503,
-0.0167052578,
0.0309866667,
-0.0632558241,
-0.0291504394,
-0.0204256121,
2.664e-7,
0.0094133057,
-0.0075882445,
-0.0058477577,
0.0500017218,
0.008634246,
0.06435664,
-0.0189151615,
0.0151115637,
-0.0405137502,
0.0147952819,
0.0781528428,
0.0274579115,
-0.0356850587,
0.0439095087,
-0.061706651,
0.0181586519,
-0.025165448,
-0.0666575059,
0.0022405621,
-0.0025559245,
0.0825478062,
0.0624156743,
0.0796387643,
0.0183178931,
0.0120087378,
-0.0563843884,
0.0577999018,
0.0175040793,
0.0171917602,
-0.0156047484,
0.0120247034,
0.0267715957,
-0.0256069992,
0.0685471222,
0.0068774573,
0.0367642008,
0.002461602,
0.004865258,
0.0115409298,
-0.0308412071,
0.0201727226,
-0.0177210327,
0.0109797409,
-0.0043147267,
0.0830883533,
-0.0509693213,
-0.0307230148,
0.0159052629,
-0.0565862171,
0.0108953416,
0.0225004517,
0.0166334957,
0.0087026879,
-0.0151940696,
0.012609628,
0.0018396977,
-0.0011568117,
-0.0432872176,
0.0332871042,
0.0418251492,
0.0020087317,
-0.0553838313,
0.04276108,
-0.0097333882,
0.0388809852,
-0.0288856216,
0.0528744608,
2.409992319e-34,
0.02435112,
-0.0055046747,
0.0215760842,
-0.015725743,
0.0231506396,
-0.0347033218,
-0.0085602775,
-0.0650058538,
0.0571839623,
-0.0368618593,
0.009139549
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.11186v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.11186v2 | Compress, Then Prompt: Improving Accuracy-Efficiency Trade-off of LLM Inference with Transferable Prompt | 2023-05-17T20:45:13 | 2023-10-10T04:01:30 | Zhaozhuo Xu, Zirui Liu, Beidi Chen, Yuxin Tang, Jue Wang, Kaixiong Zhou, Xia Hu, Anshumali Shrivastava | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | While the numerous parameters in Large Language Models (LLMs) contribute to
their superior performance, this massive scale makes them inefficient and
memory-hungry. Thus, they are hard to deploy on commodity hardware, such as one
single GPU. Given the memory and power constraints of such devices, model
compression methods are widely employed to reduce both the model size and
inference latency, which essentially trades off model quality in return for
improved efficiency. Thus, optimizing this accuracy-efficiency trade-off is
crucial for the LLM deployment on commodity hardware. In this paper, we
introduce a new perspective to optimize this trade-off by prompting compressed
models. Specifically, we first observe that for certain questions, the
generation quality of a compressed LLM can be significantly improved by adding
carefully designed hard prompts, though this isn't the case for all questions.
Based on this observation, we propose a soft prompt learning method where we
expose the compressed model to the prompt learning process, aiming to enhance
the performance of prompts. Our experimental analysis suggests our soft prompt
strategy greatly improves the performance of the 8x compressed LLaMA-7B model
(with a joint 4-bit quantization and 50% weight pruning compression), allowing
them to match their uncompressed counterparts on popular benchmarks. Also, we
demonstrate that these learned prompts can be transferred across various
datasets, tasks, and compression levels. Hence with this transferability, we
can stitch the soft prompt to a newly compressed model to improve the test-time
accuracy in an ``in-situ'' way. | [
-0.0030927425,
0.0872708783,
-0.0031578681,
0.043127887,
-0.0461989455,
0.0044297096,
0.0204929076,
0.0207635816,
-0.0170473456,
-0.01639737,
-0.0055935355,
-0.0273665413,
0.0080605159,
-0.003725725,
0.0172134656,
-0.0028567815,
0.0481742173,
-0.0409902968,
-0.0072329566,
-0.028753832,
-0.0169274807,
-0.0122019649,
0.0188255794,
0.0177918226,
0.0258813743,
-0.0055871988,
-0.0505785421,
0.0341193676,
-0.0219252687,
-0.0067266217,
-0.0127731729,
0.0766931847,
0.043001499,
0.0299385376,
0.0000021326,
-0.0383417085,
-0.0051244446,
-0.0054154485,
-0.0825269371,
0.032931827,
0.0366383195,
-0.0183970761,
-0.0138616124,
0.0029766334,
-0.0105659021,
-0.0243386831,
0.0551687516,
-0.0103294607,
0.047974851,
0.0555005223,
0.0089735379,
-0.0052492078,
0.0180451684,
-0.055312667,
0.0033565375,
-0.0360908397,
-0.0039473325,
-0.0259176604,
-0.003553506,
0.0260882434,
-0.0370312184,
0.0298511442,
0.0505969673,
0.017445337,
-0.0535526574,
0.0156939831,
-0.0122457938,
-0.0281623229,
-0.0232037809,
0.0530482791,
-0.034125749,
-0.0338967964,
0.0017282839,
-0.0186072104,
0.0102730766,
-0.031832017,
-0.0552758612,
0.0599597134,
-0.0006037607,
0.0243737437,
0.0109195933,
-0.0071559842,
0.050079748,
0.0063354783,
-0.0185708962,
0.0409508161,
0.0244100187,
-0.0042442861,
-0.011385927,
0.0122720636,
-0.0349510238,
-0.0464619286,
-0.0325365625,
0.0205924548,
-0.0257556979,
0.0048916079,
-0.0880199224,
-0.0181900989,
0.0248847641,
0.0100629535,
0.0527978875,
0.0572621226,
-0.0235829502,
0.0348078534,
-0.0534674488,
0.0498821773,
-0.0042170389,
0.0171310212,
-0.0539676584,
0.0165418182,
0.0202127509,
0.0072435578,
-0.0258230716,
0.0434834473,
-0.0375397317,
-0.011982305,
-0.0360604823,
0.0137759764,
0.0043557878,
0.0036202928,
0.0245378911,
-0.0043886807,
-0.04143738,
0.0039613727,
0.0012390504,
0.009691393,
-0.0469748154,
0.0344988294,
0.0223306101,
-0.0950107723,
-0.0340884365,
0.022000432,
0.0129127372,
-0.0125052221,
0.0496289432,
0.0242399424,
-0.0046798736,
-0.0557063632,
-0.0454870537,
-0.0097575737,
0.0227197614,
-0.0624926463,
0.0132201929,
-0.0739208013,
0.0629101321,
-0.0124598518,
0.0073142555,
-0.0279249735,
0.0184249189,
0.0327414609,
-0.0127042541,
0.0613158718,
-0.0130213192,
-0.0022157375,
0.0095495172,
0.0058382344,
0.0067236465,
0.0805360377,
0.017753439,
0.0524738543,
0.0205377471,
-0.009466812,
-0.0282304436,
0.0336214788,
0.0746540949,
0.0196564887,
-0.0281120222,
0.0011057126,
0.0088322861,
0.0450378321,
0.0648075268,
0.0754166469,
-0.0350583792,
-0.0494265892,
0.0491313078,
0.0594175607,
0.0075534615,
0.0199936386,
0.0330921486,
0.0085047325,
-0.0085416222,
0.0119265057,
-0.0485177711,
0.0295274276,
-0.0395162329,
0.0202294663,
0.0738130957,
0.0301975217,
-0.0357941762,
-0.0351708904,
-0.0060494263,
-0.035191942,
0.0130840512,
0.0507874712,
0.0135096805,
0.0117178112,
-0.039810244,
0.0774334818,
0.0505721495,
-0.0557090193,
-0.0623580441,
-0.0985686481,
0.0536637232,
0.0178352036,
0.02022448,
0.0193354879,
-0.0228405185,
0.0045629605,
0.0103471084,
0.0242490303,
0.0225812644,
-0.0047084899,
0.0138068218,
-0.0679372177,
-0.0137571096,
-0.0193869211,
0.0129011674,
0.0192904491,
0.0477633737,
0.008811133,
0.0084359162,
-0.0218580887,
0.0128007289,
0.0282722469,
-0.0195106454,
-0.0435880236,
0.0366515554,
0.0029241631,
0.0302585121,
-0.0323490538,
0.0034729552,
-0.0025630039,
0.0570462681,
-0.0704256147,
0.0152844163,
-0.0529475845,
-0.0614790767,
-0.0653590411,
0.023472989,
0.0184826739,
0.0384683125,
0.0459169894,
-0.0681755468,
-0.0393039323,
-0.0116940988,
-0.0376989916,
0.0228938852,
-0.054090593,
-0.0045884587,
0.0199428611,
0.0584906526,
-0.0384613574,
0.0524509065,
-0.0439404771,
0.0101548731,
0.05647498,
0.0136676189,
0.012552592,
-0.0557649806,
-0.0267941337,
0.0182543565,
-0.0106508527,
-0.0051121246,
-0.0090638669,
0.0021723236,
-0.0050689322,
-0.0015263351,
-0.0907988772,
0.0146569088,
-0.0338616073,
0.0105843116,
0.0053771781,
0.0176014528,
-0.0085898619,
-0.0271995962,
-0.0285809264,
0.0073165363,
0.01716437,
0.0275708605,
-0.0054801158,
0.0097522251,
-0.0106310751,
-0.0153987212,
-0.0441056862,
0.0194511935,
0.0583150536,
-0.0612987727,
-0.038797956,
-0.0547206588,
0.0301854368,
-0.0098730866,
0.0217783526,
-0.0113876956,
-0.0158238877,
0.0017795322,
-0.025254352,
0.0338437222,
0.097541675,
-0.0087191481,
0.0118110152,
0.0556369461,
-0.0029582665,
-0.0591771752,
0.0307808463,
-0.0110165384,
-0.056617301,
-0.0097497543,
-0.0507738292,
-0.0247403979,
0.0769275576,
-0.0051619457,
-0.0077835829,
-0.0481864922,
-0.0152550675,
0.0050979452,
-0.0378979519,
-0.0358188674,
0.013962144,
0.0074930466,
0.0623635538,
-0.0079453913,
-0.0756267384,
0.0502156615,
-0.066973798,
0.0109829959,
0.0116180088,
-0.0293690339,
-0.0424037203,
0.0784231275,
0.0260005016,
0.0203093737,
0.0080095418,
0.005616507,
-0.0476625711,
0.01373416,
-0.0090391487,
-0.0369303711,
0.0115963053,
-0.0536753684,
0.0087875426,
-0.054855343,
-0.0574584082,
-0.0011362012,
-0.0174444243,
-0.0244856607,
0.012308781,
0.0202736668,
-0.0038578026,
0.0141334366,
0.0221479759,
-0.0164125208,
0.0510778017,
-0.0108484933,
0.0195778795,
-0.017601626,
0.0205482878,
0.0572761223,
0.0431168936,
0.0289816894,
-0.04502628,
0.004229059,
0.0536363386,
0.023077447,
0.0303740967,
-0.0562942922,
0.0177176613,
0.0590307452,
0.0140028,
-0.0353011936,
0.0585217364,
0.0570925772,
-0.0534823388,
-0.0099366494,
0.0850680768,
0.0087893708,
-0.0477894396,
-0.004708657,
-0.00637866,
0.0514021851,
0.0133156804,
0.034630686,
-0.0939152166,
-0.0581579469,
0.0457363054,
0.0138444724,
-0.0061443504,
0.0007539368,
-0.0201168992,
-0.1074644029,
0.0418925099,
-0.0086032106,
0.0235321727,
-0.0039269179,
-0.039694678,
-0.0114417775,
0.0015451763,
0.0290951431,
0.0157597102,
0.0024961664,
-0.0001911993,
0.0142733995,
-0.0039077424,
-0.0268677827,
0.02163692,
0.0163143165,
0.0491483472,
0.0497278981,
-0.0065859426,
0.0086201951,
-0.0438950993,
0.0217700936,
0.0149002476,
-0.0034875909,
-0.0307434686,
0.0185078587,
0.0090062553,
-0.0017187556,
0.010988283,
0.0346378461,
-0.0059867292,
-0.0238547456,
-0.0042075641,
0.0644379035,
-0.0142613016,
-0.0213281754,
-0.0168577302,
-0.0288321823,
-0.0115956822,
0.0750567913,
0.044037234,
-0.0299221184,
-0.0326458812,
-0.014026233,
-0.031639751,
-0.010569199,
-0.0265423842,
0.0061130575,
0.0162039921,
-0.0190770496,
-0.0249208175,
0.0081313215,
0.0045708655,
0.0294580124,
-0.0102827437,
-0.0019548181,
-0.0193219557,
0.0146650057,
-0.0926027447,
0.0343324319,
-0.0482886545,
0.0144343497,
-0.0859849453,
0.011675857,
0.0230115876,
-0.0163396169,
-0.0009429248,
0.0356354453,
-0.1323694289,
-0.0555941537,
-0.024751585,
0.0506085306,
0.02254113,
0.0451887287,
0.0166140776,
-0.044602599,
0.0467494354,
0.0552652553,
-0.0358633995,
0.0707820952,
0.032997895,
-0.0369822457,
0.0001211293,
0.054970149,
-0.0288153905,
0.0141511345,
0.0050951419,
0.0319793038,
-0.0208264459,
-0.0682988316,
0.0131683443,
0.0164551362,
0.0355597213,
-0.0185357686,
-0.0193707868,
0.0091891699,
0.0584996864,
0.0268157125,
0.0153684923,
-0.0465704054,
0.0059914105,
0.0205605682,
-0.0016260149,
0.0240390971,
-0.022307964,
0.0502474383,
0.0144516826,
-0.0326972492,
-0.0033845436,
-0.0106196208,
-0.009715653,
0.0257371664,
-0.0149132935,
-0.0305729304,
-0.0023034723,
0.0013686082,
0.0519214682,
-0.039304059,
0.0428088866,
0.0132832592,
0.0338716544,
-0.0324326158,
0.0419934914,
-0.0329493023,
-0.071540378,
-0.0360693187,
0.0343262516,
0.0300919991,
0.0209128037,
-0.0069584902,
-0.0012365597,
-0.0225264169,
-0.0123942969,
0.0229565743,
0.0064057582,
-0.023783287,
0.0859775245,
0.0293897931,
0.0012163625,
-0.0010635896,
0.061653845,
0.0023286007,
0.0477019623,
-0.0007706298,
0.028711196,
-0.0446831025,
-0.0549991317,
-0.0079759704,
0.0110933464,
0.0066492027,
-0.005488262,
-0.0130005376,
-0.0401702672,
0.0136034433,
0.0098180212,
-0.0185386352,
-0.0169404242,
0.0363765322,
0.0664223731,
0.0078861536,
-0.0388393737,
-0.0116653601,
0.0036967855,
-0.0146327065,
-0.0102313319,
0.0132101374,
-6.538694673e-33,
-0.0443422645,
0.0231186226,
0.0468030907,
-0.0370022729,
0.0046074213,
0.0153454244,
-0.0237223115,
-0.0132296095,
-0.0360920504,
-0.0231247507,
-0.042154815,
-0.0020714677,
0.027848525,
0.0317267291,
-0.0300141945,
-0.0131382756,
0.0506540686,
-0.0021787027,
-0.0228340887,
0.027211355,
-0.0109706502,
0.0249109678,
0.0248125512,
0.0286978725,
-0.0371890366,
-0.0065924088,
0.0034337747,
-0.0021648561,
-0.0361496992,
0.0397866219,
-0.0362697504,
0.0186997149,
-0.0033530502,
-0.0521526076,
-0.0162591785,
0.040357545,
-0.0688374266,
-0.0217503328,
0.0281776246,
0.0078460602,
-0.0369957425,
-0.0584024712,
0.0083609037,
0.0207491778,
0.0031218976,
-0.0237188507,
-0.0258605089,
-0.0282782596,
-0.057527326,
-0.0431165621,
-0.0066376785,
0.0033049844,
0.0223525651,
-0.0075963642,
0.0444970839,
0.0340120643,
-0.0334794633,
0.0385950729,
-0.0324697644,
0.0054830723,
0.036959555,
0.0984675661,
0.0745261908,
0.0147618707,
0.0056983433,
0.0269849338,
-0.0019399406,
-0.0284966417,
-0.0228896197,
0.0439393893,
0.0321621336,
0.0399266034,
0.0373250507,
0.051657863,
0.0713190883,
0.000576528,
-0.0849704668,
-0.0048501403,
0.0759127885,
0.0084638083,
0.0379202701,
0.0144835701,
-0.0062884782,
-0.045954179,
-0.0530244447,
-0.0004352504,
-0.0255944226,
-0.0245361552,
0.0318288133,
0.0465743057,
-0.0321906731,
-0.0356242396,
0.0563380569,
-0.0365208685,
0.0060326862,
-0.0093528582,
-0.0015799491,
0.0096253641,
0.0097143594,
0.0405639671,
-0.053230796,
-0.03879999,
0.0128145227,
-0.0377673879,
0.0344972387,
0.0025744049,
0.0132753225,
0.060923893,
-0.0825453252,
-0.0127711389,
-0.0414765514,
0.0147268455,
0.0076689236,
0.0154391164,
0.0368651338,
0.0126765072,
0.0023819713,
0.0416199975,
-0.0297342148,
0.003166581,
-0.0320172086,
-0.017424237,
0.0008091538,
0.0344516747,
-0.0354725458,
-0.0162580069,
-0.0544069037,
0.0400946662,
0.0186237954,
-0.068223834,
-0.0339284651,
0.0429215506,
2.848e-7,
-0.0015669627,
-0.0025797812,
-0.0122023225,
0.019646937,
-0.0183330234,
0.0151191195,
0.001621007,
0.011390496,
0.0135214496,
-0.0536343567,
0.0099382764,
0.0329544656,
0.0349103995,
0.0225984082,
-0.1029806659,
0.033368472,
-0.0534105822,
0.0103344684,
-0.0442806929,
-0.0218354594,
0.0289633516,
0.1567844748,
-0.0188244879,
-0.0263116285,
0.0424191579,
-0.0004005949,
0.0382787287,
-0.0373152047,
-0.0083217481,
0.009022953,
0.0431023203,
0.0020150447,
-0.0296652615,
0.0128502743,
0.0062484369,
-0.0086535281,
-0.0413356237,
0.0770203397,
0.0403292179,
-0.0509882085,
0.0113140289,
-0.0212277006,
-0.0197831839,
-0.0295590833,
0.084966287,
-0.0086651733,
-0.0157070812,
-0.0683523417,
0.0145446556,
-0.0358758494,
0.0128124161,
-0.0303592682,
0.0562213138,
-0.000747507,
0.0205046274,
-0.0174260587,
-0.0170193538,
-0.0798079967,
-0.0313116685,
-0.0219874848,
-0.0474464819,
-0.0548998043,
-0.0905715823,
-0.0063140295,
0.0132949771,
-0.0747262985,
0.0027581558,
2.874836968e-34,
0.0262300223,
-0.0080451202,
0.0132035399,
0.0549684316,
-0.0098096468,
-0.0401650444,
0.0055130864,
0.020413937,
0.0020477746,
-0.0995738357,
-0.0416712388
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10561v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10561v1 | Massively Multi-Lingual Event Understanding: Extraction, Visualization, and Search | 2023-05-17T20:41:51 | 2023-05-17T20:41:51 | Chris Jenkins, Shantanu Agarwal, Joel Barry, Steven Fincke, Elizabeth Boschee | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we present ISI-Clear, a state-of-the-art, cross-lingual,
zero-shot event extraction system and accompanying user interface for event
visualization & search. Using only English training data, ISI-Clear makes
global events available on-demand, processing user-supplied text in 100
languages ranging from Afrikaans to Yiddish. We provide multiple event-centric
views of extracted events, including both a graphical representation and a
document-level summary. We also integrate existing cross-lingual search
algorithms with event extraction capabilities to provide cross-lingual
event-centric search, allowing English-speaking users to search over events
automatically extracted from a corpus of non-English documents, using either
English natural language queries (e.g. cholera outbreaks in Iran) or structured
queries (e.g. find all events of type Disease-Outbreak with agent cholera and
location Iran). | [
-0.0095818099,
0.0153185669,
-0.0172126759,
0.0623318218,
-0.018723432,
-0.0096206376,
-0.0039315089,
0.0155252237,
0.0597123131,
0.03073138,
0.0090172123,
0.0013698495,
-0.0375480019,
0.0677507967,
-0.0226247963,
-0.0857984126,
0.0596216843,
0.0063874722,
-0.0194523353,
0.0345668122,
0.0274163,
0.0357818902,
-0.0132591501,
0.0219888855,
0.0219471939,
0.0305684432,
-0.0600315742,
-0.0390072465,
0.0400710292,
-0.0839139745,
-0.0392548777,
-0.0454701521,
0.0316067263,
0.0367247984,
0.0000018702,
-0.0272543952,
-0.0243881457,
-0.0263700299,
-0.0084100086,
0.0139432233,
-0.0128050763,
-0.0464154594,
0.0089051249,
-0.0416873395,
-0.0367557257,
-0.0391765013,
0.0357972533,
0.0311301593,
-0.007562371,
0.0435470194,
-0.0139991222,
-0.0187521186,
0.010737149,
0.0155936917,
0.0149352476,
-0.0430529155,
-0.0089101791,
-0.035652779,
0.0605073348,
0.0076037585,
0.0268767457,
0.0421047658,
-0.0136577599,
-0.0179920979,
-0.0473844819,
0.0437077954,
-0.0386830978,
-0.0518486537,
0.0070370208,
0.0225525033,
-0.0115622813,
-0.023681324,
0.0272545684,
0.0155843012,
-0.033321429,
0.0188979357,
-0.0733806938,
0.0075341142,
-0.0266005695,
0.028580524,
0.050241489,
0.0084989779,
0.0223490987,
0.0251319855,
-0.0259476397,
0.0515824594,
0.0057626837,
-0.0058540967,
-0.0336437672,
-0.0246164408,
0.0141215706,
-0.0536189415,
0.0600268655,
0.0497288071,
-0.0436112583,
0.0167543888,
0.0314412601,
-0.0101006357,
0.0267499313,
-0.0925672799,
-0.0523384474,
0.0212255511,
-0.0129715344,
0.0650764704,
0.0389395356,
-0.0170630012,
-0.0124772247,
-0.0055941315,
0.0132651776,
-0.0352992974,
-0.0376959257,
0.0257084332,
-0.0209748503,
-0.0153331757,
-0.0572553873,
0.051270809,
-0.0155758662,
-0.0048473775,
0.0307015534,
-0.0159866903,
-0.0269023888,
-0.0223545842,
-0.0371077992,
-0.0202978421,
-0.0055666529,
0.0405224673,
-0.0717288256,
-0.0290599316,
-0.0440756567,
-0.0408989601,
0.0078876652,
-0.0212356485,
0.0611103736,
0.0145091442,
-0.0320506617,
0.0176916011,
-0.0279909875,
-0.0078109112,
-0.0749078393,
-0.0338250212,
0.0053348653,
0.0134553667,
-0.0241444688,
-0.048139926,
0.0563612096,
-0.0105854804,
-0.0064986786,
-0.0073414133,
0.0128822709,
-0.0174885634,
-0.051978413,
0.0391168632,
-0.0478117764,
0.0117749358,
0.025260577,
0.0080425572,
0.0409186631,
0.0421314426,
0.001755164,
0.0103873285,
0.0690887645,
0.0170244295,
-0.008387858,
0.0328484923,
0.0065834494,
-0.00731572,
0.0147945629,
0.0038246587,
-0.0103468969,
-0.0146763567,
0.0197814889,
-0.0523974001,
-0.0167238358,
0.0020490668,
-0.0039652465,
0.0617519207,
-0.0235829838,
-0.0266434532,
0.000625281,
0.0071314643,
-0.0179382991,
0.010683923,
0.0396401063,
0.0068133865,
0.0298791565,
-0.0042859917,
-0.0154638523,
0.0325113274,
-0.0144421263,
0.0058905804,
0.0252005402,
0.035357397,
-0.0017028565,
0.0119538931,
0.049095165,
-0.0310777836,
0.0238218196,
0.0182312671,
0.038067542,
-0.0623230971,
0.0539168455,
-0.0013327844,
0.0164494086,
0.0862746537,
0.0285621323,
-0.0485861152,
-0.0415808409,
0.0294954609,
0.0319852531,
0.0405944139,
0.0050720023,
-0.0169893932,
0.0371855795,
-0.0237379931,
-0.0267516524,
0.0310153272,
-0.0017054604,
0.0224052891,
-0.0229075588,
0.0600938611,
-0.0097211702,
-0.0060618981,
-0.0302261282,
-0.0007042317,
-0.0447325557,
-0.0044394168,
-0.0378469117,
0.0284558795,
-0.0130641293,
0.0394724123,
0.0071423361,
0.0113057531,
0.0479986668,
-0.0634879544,
0.0240569375,
0.0605157837,
0.0546524525,
-0.0001883595,
0.0157015137,
-0.0621353053,
-0.0127451317,
0.0007537095,
-0.006828492,
-0.0233522672,
0.0145985978,
0.0064974758,
0.0221712999,
0.0040597813,
0.0335210636,
0.0065643508,
-0.0179711021,
-0.0188606232,
0.0493142493,
0.0203243643,
0.0088500082,
-0.0116757285,
-0.0628169551,
0.0420360863,
-0.0287302546,
-0.0057015666,
0.0888917819,
0.0212217383,
-0.0416934155,
0.0503444038,
-0.0416042432,
-0.0330233835,
0.0497077033,
-0.1109294221,
0.0240781624,
-0.0019263326,
0.0530294441,
0.035706792,
0.085829854,
-0.0175518803,
-0.0144076198,
-0.0196741559,
-0.0559423827,
0.0197136085,
-0.0060788295,
0.0374253467,
0.0230245776,
0.0152346082,
-0.0552134365,
0.0114885531,
-0.0401788242,
0.0281668957,
0.0401648767,
-0.0681455657,
-0.0029893897,
-0.0072628004,
-0.0384504236,
0.0189294554,
-0.0111505352,
-0.0390435904,
0.010871171,
-0.0314326435,
-0.0010934841,
0.0155709246,
-0.0116800983,
0.0321746394,
0.0376154706,
-0.0716080666,
-0.0622741729,
0.0063891355,
-0.0541114993,
0.0217842963,
0.0016971683,
-0.0386055186,
0.0407930575,
0.025999479,
0.0092239408,
0.0375501364,
-0.0191879775,
-0.0590273552,
-0.0553995185,
0.0112182098,
-0.0747317001,
-0.0230343305,
-0.0123879686,
0.0639394969,
-0.0314801745,
0.01118802,
0.0338389762,
0.0339461267,
0.0167541392,
-0.0592206344,
-0.022628013,
-0.0631378144,
0.0672789142,
-0.0619373359,
0.019386448,
-0.0121634174,
-0.0429228805,
0.0279302839,
-0.0192830544,
0.0397850834,
-0.0221213456,
0.0017718824,
-0.0256998725,
-0.0047335788,
-0.0202178489,
-0.0273943953,
-0.0153914588,
-0.0496653803,
0.0029575301,
-0.0446620062,
0.0416983701,
0.0097507248,
-0.0585115962,
0.034691561,
0.0580060147,
0.0405315422,
0.0269055981,
-0.0045444355,
0.0246160273,
0.0542640276,
0.009161246,
-0.0438671187,
-0.0354210213,
0.0070084287,
0.0031695627,
0.0198252667,
0.0180465635,
-0.0229751039,
0.0171719994,
0.0270711761,
0.0081912968,
-0.0514859296,
-0.0190981477,
-0.0307373349,
0.0342253223,
-0.0595868975,
0.0312818103,
0.0732768476,
0.055533357,
-0.044623673,
0.0075131869,
-0.0440642908,
-0.0340987928,
-0.0007361559,
0.0339316539,
-0.0850793496,
0.0134574855,
-0.0229908731,
-0.0371265821,
-0.0095662912,
-0.0402617604,
0.0058087786,
-0.0305422638,
0.0059873466,
0.0179858375,
-0.0203460213,
-0.0333359428,
-0.0541315489,
0.001094025,
-0.0122978901,
-0.0594403669,
0.001692595,
0.0051303566,
-0.008251599,
-0.0218372364,
-0.040717233,
-0.0587613769,
-0.0013737568,
-0.0393478796,
-0.0346609727,
-0.0060028723,
0.0674575493,
-0.0024461693,
0.0236218497,
-0.0011167502,
-0.0151859811,
0.0044695297,
-0.0144813033,
0.0560183972,
0.0326455571,
-0.0331830084,
-0.0650860444,
-0.0071303332,
0.0283079948,
-0.0340874568,
0.0220899731,
0.1049424559,
-0.0028779982,
0.0336143188,
-0.0092450511,
-0.0208049882,
0.029909512,
0.0025888304,
-0.0020999508,
0.0187546145,
-0.005428012,
-0.0302603953,
0.0375046805,
-0.0705836788,
-0.0508237034,
0.0402435847,
-0.091830723,
-0.1237277612,
-0.037783049,
-0.0536721162,
0.0471521355,
0.0017095977,
-0.0110212294,
-0.0279999264,
0.0295097735,
-0.0103393747,
-0.0248390548,
0.0382172912,
0.001963536,
0.0098589556,
0.0080536362,
-0.0085455105,
0.0131158084,
0.0554939173,
0.0066677155,
0.0786035508,
0.0004285136,
-0.0371973254,
-0.0073989551,
-0.0620133542,
0.0114709064,
0.0237751044,
0.0064397771,
-0.0111542288,
0.0078088762,
0.0127841765,
-0.0194769241,
-0.0746765882,
-0.0330956243,
0.0120693184,
-0.0046060109,
0.0119317779,
-0.0132422661,
0.0206222609,
-0.0551144332,
0.0466673188,
-0.1027646288,
0.0076408521,
0.0117156934,
0.0186960883,
0.0687657744,
-0.0115285227,
-0.0720083192,
-0.0626218766,
-0.0212677587,
-0.0324283876,
0.0007850341,
0.0334123373,
0.0255314503,
-0.0312841311,
-0.0333594978,
-0.005929105,
0.1169279516,
-0.0410745926,
-0.0433657691,
-0.0691388473,
0.0485436395,
0.0568358563,
0.0092472229,
0.0050141327,
0.0264419578,
0.001602664,
0.0211464055,
0.0133711724,
0.0161103699,
-0.0338708498,
-0.0173762273,
-0.0017568335,
-0.0125425337,
0.0154800015,
-0.0219902713,
-0.0608719476,
0.0432398953,
0.0157977231,
-0.0102235563,
0.112991862,
-0.0253793988,
0.0546170548,
0.0030514013,
-0.0134652071,
0.0311419647,
0.0235614013,
-0.0005986163,
-0.004878581,
-0.0162267555,
0.0049630525,
-0.0192531683,
-0.0132022239,
0.0580035076,
-0.024370769,
0.045735307,
0.0441382192,
-0.0467999317,
-0.0082852188,
-0.0095371399,
0.0706284717,
0.028473163,
-0.0387623198,
0.0112697566,
-0.0562638678,
0.0174169876,
0.0304995812,
-0.0192654599,
-0.0666421801,
-0.0129699958,
0.0289255362,
0.0265884623,
0.054154966,
0.0074880775,
-0.009994288,
0.0756151676,
-0.0515726507,
-0.0368557125,
-0.010503537,
-6.114408436e-33,
-0.0034099596,
-0.0392599553,
0.0146517651,
0.0140055949,
-0.0002020328,
0.0005560904,
-0.0530967899,
-0.011182446,
-0.0379933193,
0.0323624238,
0.0052998778,
-0.0042227749,
0.027626982,
-0.0456018671,
0.036504671,
-0.0088205785,
0.0320486315,
0.0324691199,
-0.0000934284,
0.0205519572,
0.1076005474,
0.0438399836,
0.0612642393,
-0.0775953308,
0.043642167,
0.0145807173,
0.0258806162,
-0.0127538806,
0.1195188537,
0.0327436924,
-0.0238777697,
0.0203156117,
0.0216848515,
-0.022594776,
-0.0128709516,
-0.0175124314,
-0.0510817729,
-0.0374689177,
0.0319279358,
0.0208557118,
-0.0130401272,
-0.033179082,
0.0105553158,
0.008356682,
0.017155515,
0.0403307267,
0.0396242402,
-0.0097304517,
-0.0161153525,
-0.0344693884,
-0.0372754,
0.0437963158,
-0.0368218943,
0.0119271334,
0.0482211746,
0.0281139761,
0.0217063017,
0.0189012215,
0.0007822491,
0.0482092537,
-0.0382037051,
0.0312600546,
0.0324323848,
-0.0207474548,
-0.0090335999,
0.0366021171,
-0.011616528,
-0.0222763252,
-0.0103291962,
0.048324503,
-0.009994776,
0.0389191397,
-0.013007978,
0.0739454925,
0.0180841386,
-0.0125341648,
-0.0906077623,
0.0856002569,
-0.0189028922,
0.0238416269,
-0.052248504,
0.0285544805,
0.001816724,
0.0126628112,
0.0246447176,
0.0157033112,
-0.0305765774,
0.0090329899,
0.0076974444,
-0.0285673924,
0.0291000046,
0.0651486441,
0.0019247698,
0.0552824326,
-0.0363648422,
0.0171613693,
0.0176540222,
-0.0088111954,
0.001134623,
0.0051222155,
-0.0319766067,
-0.0171076115,
-0.059238974,
0.012561569,
0.0219500456,
0.0391265526,
0.0026397316,
-0.0066704997,
-0.0239050314,
0.0167879835,
0.0015930033,
-0.0250091162,
-0.0323093757,
-0.0054301093,
0.0238105934,
-0.025020808,
0.006547228,
0.032354027,
0.0557173416,
0.0184171926,
0.0472723804,
-0.0526445173,
-0.0063415705,
0.0417409465,
-0.0029797894,
0.0004702245,
-0.0640147552,
0.0445909239,
0.0115315942,
-0.0374548733,
-0.0170715824,
-0.0008354236,
2.593e-7,
0.0589829683,
0.0303210746,
0.0303944666,
0.069178395,
-0.0120027568,
-0.012125819,
-0.0112592978,
0.0214608684,
-0.044253163,
0.0414939001,
-0.0197936706,
0.0127393333,
0.0360807069,
0.0921845883,
-0.0736228153,
-0.0460192785,
-0.0322937109,
-0.0193222631,
-0.0960663706,
-0.0075683016,
0.0507855043,
0.0433693528,
0.0162502937,
0.0406536311,
-0.0157351624,
-0.040948268,
0.0355622619,
-0.0172906481,
-0.0768537745,
0.0011663785,
-0.0345097445,
0.0134923849,
-0.0424869694,
0.0095804585,
-0.0436868668,
-0.024074249,
0.0093872994,
0.0005967229,
-0.0191092677,
0.0367174931,
-0.0197005086,
-0.0817416981,
-0.0262570437,
-0.0427216962,
0.0539250895,
0.0107550127,
-0.0034673063,
0.0528559349,
-0.0138965659,
0.0411147252,
0.0067225839,
-0.0226091463,
-0.059332788,
0.0413400829,
-0.0128807593,
0.004734695,
-0.0207981057,
-0.0201563574,
-0.01090205,
0.0106602982,
0.0124324812,
-0.0171044264,
-0.0106354272,
-0.020539254,
-0.0241936538,
0.011880477,
0.0388821885,
2.044103172e-34,
0.021788748,
0.0528238602,
-0.0309222192,
-0.0048810546,
0.0395504758,
-0.0258137453,
-0.034097407,
0.0245948434,
0.0265230834,
0.0064592781,
-0.0031686593
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10557v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10557v2 | Bring More Attention to Syntactic Symmetry for Automatic Postediting of High-Quality Machine Translations | 2023-05-17T20:25:19 | 2023-06-17T09:58:02 | Baikjin Jung, Myungji Lee, Jong-Hyeok Lee, Yunsu Kim | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automatic postediting (APE) is an automated process to refine a given machine
translation (MT). Recent findings present that existing APE systems are not
good at handling high-quality MTs even for a language pair with abundant data
resources, English-to-German: the better the given MT is, the harder it is to
decide what parts to edit and how to fix these errors. One possible solution to
this problem is to instill deeper knowledge about the target language into the
model. Thus, we propose a linguistically motivated method of regularization
that is expected to enhance APE models' understanding of the target language: a
loss function that encourages symmetric self-attention on the given MT. Our
analysis of experimental results demonstrates that the proposed method helps
improving the state-of-the-art architecture's APE quality for high-quality MTs. | [
0.045731701,
0.0696031824,
0.0062842816,
0.0269593205,
-0.0133355055,
0.0039872495,
-0.0187649671,
-0.0342877507,
-0.0357238799,
-0.0047636977,
-0.0440805592,
-0.0382810645,
0.0052526034,
-0.0187102016,
0.0343944244,
-0.0803904757,
0.0527100079,
0.001460149,
-0.0290469825,
-0.0131879039,
0.0393851586,
-0.0169834383,
0.045588918,
0.0197635274,
-0.0036707257,
-0.0095352996,
-0.0172809418,
0.0529186241,
0.0286993477,
0.0129433628,
-0.0280462857,
0.0446987189,
-0.016917713,
0.0606614426,
0.0000018368,
-0.0299554635,
-0.0293867197,
0.0007462025,
0.0140821226,
0.0267685894,
0.0626393333,
-0.0687524006,
-0.0492881238,
0.011712336,
-0.0072599482,
0.0008269665,
0.0941905528,
0.0081269601,
0.1055720672,
0.0496921614,
-0.0132930381,
-0.0140650896,
0.0127281556,
-0.0475429334,
-0.0298223794,
-0.0385660455,
-0.0126295527,
-0.0575389713,
-0.0374280661,
0.0229785126,
0.0159940701,
0.0541264564,
-0.0027403238,
-0.0510788225,
0.0200730525,
-0.0264066961,
-0.0570538081,
-0.0173967276,
-0.0185582861,
0.0444018394,
-0.0230468567,
-0.0348027125,
-0.0298766401,
0.0050083785,
0.0223058481,
-0.0149998069,
-0.0447952785,
-0.0005588639,
-0.0070026005,
0.0057253717,
0.0221534502,
0.0096620433,
0.0117681185,
0.0021528378,
-0.0156869255,
0.0099500343,
0.0131353196,
-0.033024732,
-0.0155538814,
0.0272491835,
-0.0606748946,
-0.0385744981,
0.0346812792,
0.0108413147,
-0.0096491221,
0.0067119068,
-0.058153823,
-0.0682420209,
-0.0328541473,
-0.018697029,
0.0466669165,
0.0476497188,
-0.0326216184,
0.0256752856,
-0.0068729348,
0.0518827774,
-0.0326963142,
0.0167399962,
-0.0794149563,
0.0067035784,
-0.0296840612,
0.0125388149,
-0.0662396401,
-0.0006182119,
0.001376147,
0.0133929551,
-0.0112012029,
0.0272634365,
-0.0148005951,
0.0029581094,
0.0050253472,
-0.0148913898,
-0.0685230345,
-0.046233546,
-0.0013579148,
0.0457161404,
0.0056229504,
-0.0438604169,
0.0018924169,
-0.0295915548,
-0.0321797989,
0.0261032861,
0.0117886495,
-0.0181690156,
-0.0306942128,
0.0341884382,
-0.0327315405,
-0.02456454,
-0.0034206947,
0.008995573,
-0.027682215,
-0.0356822833,
-0.046031151,
-0.0302555114,
0.0510830916,
0.0151896132,
-0.0184985045,
-0.0777830258,
0.0026426588,
-0.0091228178,
-0.0285225678,
0.0446221046,
-0.055845391,
-0.0005781752,
0.0029041213,
-0.0208039023,
-0.0215212014,
0.0544945002,
0.018870119,
0.0355653986,
0.0256261248,
0.025526749,
-0.0003252019,
0.0638499558,
-0.008773284,
0.0160241816,
-0.0379775129,
-0.0184143372,
-0.0075957673,
0.0340896063,
0.0758287534,
0.0865301117,
-0.0060953805,
0.0237451363,
0.0825886503,
-0.02228898,
0.0412356444,
0.0769841149,
0.0453761332,
0.0021702757,
0.0086144013,
0.0686982051,
-0.0377134979,
0.0223504752,
0.0170217138,
0.0114463018,
0.0183239859,
0.0038927633,
-0.0135092782,
-0.0487577878,
-0.0091468021,
-0.0394964814,
-0.0129962992,
-0.0378662162,
0.0329743996,
0.0289429259,
-0.0117046498,
0.0713097975,
-0.0106740557,
-0.0295622423,
0.0286583193,
-0.0382966362,
-0.0415714271,
0.0631958917,
0.0351353884,
-0.0556814857,
-0.0560982116,
-0.0399130508,
0.0072370139,
0.058278095,
0.0969459713,
0.0032599044,
-0.0073637334,
-0.0324634016,
-0.0222846791,
0.0146178156,
0.0174568109,
0.0112121394,
-0.0319507495,
-0.0038256459,
0.0280411877,
0.0022774267,
-0.058160048,
0.034032926,
0.0127382837,
-0.0127482936,
0.0072602294,
0.0009253774,
0.0063444725,
0.0135194594,
-0.0125570884,
0.027309604,
0.0099313259,
-0.0466780402,
-0.0121661546,
0.0608874299,
-0.0370106697,
0.0079658264,
0.0397174992,
-0.0167602822,
-0.0191417467,
0.0373228267,
-0.0334252827,
-0.0511009172,
-0.024443794,
-0.0665355995,
0.0040765456,
-0.0481521115,
0.0425705947,
-0.0216388125,
-0.0047580511,
-0.0351649597,
0.0193866026,
0.0076481132,
-0.0217698589,
0.0490912348,
-0.0777913556,
0.0399465933,
-0.0372773707,
-0.0479482599,
0.0014962757,
-0.0184891876,
0.0387560166,
0.0464983732,
0.010671949,
0.0035294937,
-0.009520405,
-0.0304281823,
0.0094568515,
-0.0510142148,
0.0451817848,
0.0478502922,
0.0638751462,
0.0117491819,
-0.0104650725,
0.016355671,
0.0005739639,
-0.0107079512,
0.0210512336,
0.0627032369,
0.0065437863,
0.0047153356,
-0.0328416526,
-0.0093814377,
-0.0021685364,
-0.0199504495,
0.020831557,
0.0014325586,
-0.131596595,
0.0716110393,
-0.0356814303,
0.0229774937,
0.0339112878,
-0.0855655149,
-0.0142175136,
-0.0172817372,
0.0132518625,
0.0997538269,
-0.0016682451,
-0.0255643614,
0.0363034829,
0.0662734136,
-0.0112946033,
0.0097841825,
-0.0033605739,
-0.0088209184,
-0.0187427346,
0.0012155158,
0.0079769511,
0.061552126,
-0.0160059556,
-0.0083855605,
-0.063891314,
-0.0138428565,
-0.031116033,
-0.001527681,
0.0119700767,
-0.0175030287,
-0.0265411455,
0.0507242158,
-0.032668449,
-0.0495667942,
0.0743908733,
-0.0040914025,
-0.0016226154,
-0.0415383168,
0.0404058024,
-0.0250765663,
0.0518783182,
0.0008910053,
0.0243542138,
-0.034798909,
-0.0318724811,
-0.0812651664,
0.010468048,
0.0436470471,
0.0157837644,
0.0119714579,
-0.058865577,
-0.0181521643,
-0.0237346329,
-0.0595400594,
-0.0233075321,
-0.0266814772,
-0.0418306328,
-0.0103069451,
0.0318318047,
-0.0097018154,
-0.0151333958,
0.016970152,
0.0187893864,
0.0731307492,
-0.0342998356,
0.0066888803,
-0.0194815453,
0.0206508711,
0.0309511181,
0.0272320993,
0.0164519791,
-0.0234320182,
0.0404007584,
0.0343969427,
0.0090356078,
-0.0421726182,
-0.0227963105,
-0.0299978424,
0.0419559665,
-0.0584951043,
-0.074216485,
-0.0289428867,
0.0628944784,
-0.0537925251,
-0.0132346386,
0.097827673,
0.0311630834,
-0.0324855074,
-0.0077028531,
-0.0413747467,
0.0664593354,
0.0304135829,
0.0262969285,
-0.0712127909,
-0.0296035185,
0.0135646211,
0.0300753787,
0.0234464686,
0.007202364,
0.0029457777,
-0.0736932904,
0.0145609956,
0.037672177,
-0.083065033,
-0.0408654548,
0.007167154,
0.0083057582,
-0.0514576435,
0.0273613129,
0.0254887883,
0.0021821666,
0.010428342,
0.0189204216,
-0.0452719107,
-0.0240445044,
-0.0422205292,
-0.0809516534,
-0.0024020814,
0.0742119849,
0.0231214426,
0.0100598438,
-0.0130427778,
0.0385141857,
0.0133553362,
0.0174178071,
-0.0025064307,
0.0234544408,
-0.0070405761,
-0.0098722307,
0.0007907597,
0.0210956689,
0.0113306846,
0.0155246248,
-0.018987054,
0.0821274668,
0.0071601598,
0.0393608734,
0.0157579668,
-0.0205682702,
-0.0049597453,
0.0313848816,
0.0356352143,
-0.0531122461,
-0.0320604481,
-0.0601017624,
0.0159332193,
-0.0797071308,
0.0098412484,
0.0246999618,
-0.0188935827,
-0.0706589073,
-0.091281496,
-0.0734157264,
-0.0062027057,
0.0253293216,
0.0235427767,
0.0038267565,
0.0089325309,
-0.0203107521,
-0.0158603825,
0.0041863634,
-0.0216505118,
-0.0129743144,
-0.0386826321,
0.0074737128,
-0.001537932,
-0.0275506955,
0.004494403,
0.016708158,
-0.0514961965,
-0.0551764145,
0.029772019,
0.0673152506,
0.0242825244,
0.0559131876,
-0.0437098481,
-0.0691620708,
-0.0416151918,
0.0304825623,
-0.0352648571,
-0.0262584426,
0.0554271452,
-0.0349090472,
-0.0172476526,
0.0632812083,
-0.0046403264,
-0.0035624621,
0.0031389208,
0.036443349,
0.0295616873,
-0.0743344203,
0.05296259,
0.04206644,
0.0297303218,
-0.0305843391,
-0.0334303938,
-0.0131692449,
0.0313705243,
0.0100017302,
-0.0146484161,
-0.0516075194,
0.0253493674,
0.0398129933,
-0.0125881834,
-0.0077545913,
-0.0193275418,
-0.0600321367,
-0.0018371211,
0.0029800707,
0.0013225701,
-0.0411757827,
0.0264090784,
0.0131832389,
0.033454109,
0.0116405459,
0.0199205521,
0.0268075969,
0.0111802034,
-0.0445113555,
0.0177692939,
0.0123161059,
0.0162361097,
0.004524732,
0.0618004501,
-0.0542412363,
-0.0109500103,
-0.0398640931,
-0.0163775831,
0.0926714167,
-0.0118554318,
0.1168919727,
-0.0114708785,
-0.0367490873,
-0.0215563383,
0.0418412834,
0.0129669234,
0.0007915615,
0.0009997492,
-0.0106855575,
0.0116291987,
0.0203306805,
0.0429537632,
-0.0520405136,
-0.0031144621,
-0.010692711,
-0.0317417011,
-0.0304800458,
0.0074183173,
0.0164441969,
-0.0185983572,
-0.0324959084,
-0.045151148,
-0.020647753,
-0.0598066896,
0.0113545973,
0.0104155587,
0.0132975727,
-0.0220282916,
0.0332881771,
0.0723488107,
-0.0620310158,
-0.0085148811,
-0.0166285634,
-0.0038355677,
0.0631863996,
-0.0130423224,
-0.0182534326,
-5.444866323e-33,
0.0003295125,
0.0439371243,
-0.0339287855,
-0.00839453,
-0.0417713486,
-0.0309279133,
-0.018243812,
0.005908492,
-0.0002352924,
0.0235224813,
-0.0356946699,
0.0001532983,
0.0230765939,
0.0012659624,
0.0346044376,
0.0063291308,
0.072434023,
-0.0158074778,
-0.025168119,
-0.0037167133,
0.0016848041,
0.0161823798,
0.0763993636,
0.0129379518,
0.0272874963,
-0.0001015151,
-0.0165865105,
0.032038752,
0.0370511077,
0.0420795456,
0.0268364884,
0.0246982053,
0.0200198758,
-0.0381148458,
-0.0368234068,
-0.0222432259,
-0.0454267003,
-0.004221858,
-0.000468808,
0.0421585664,
-0.0220213644,
-0.0536295176,
0.0442476384,
-0.0473661907,
-0.0174329076,
-0.0223503672,
0.0105064129,
-0.0310713053,
-0.0149712777,
0.0322184712,
-0.04422234,
0.0162980612,
-0.0061314143,
-0.0418157801,
0.0213832315,
0.0289737601,
-0.0019067058,
-0.0226212442,
-0.0255277269,
0.0119617172,
-0.0366290398,
0.0713188052,
0.0738926232,
-0.0405248925,
-0.045551613,
-0.0368899554,
0.0263815802,
0.0024825598,
0.0062810346,
0.0255184062,
0.0218280461,
-0.0057753692,
0.0756247193,
0.0183744878,
0.0213972777,
0.0017012879,
-0.0190194324,
0.0364650115,
-0.0236588921,
0.0614466481,
-0.0237117596,
0.0628914461,
-0.004880033,
-0.0098961107,
-0.0262964498,
-0.0375473164,
-0.0179616939,
-0.04032249,
0.0037799692,
0.0092124278,
-0.0454209,
0.0203770492,
0.062823981,
-0.0191891138,
0.0148326736,
0.0014587337,
-0.0319793597,
0.0494664349,
-0.001267215,
0.0246429164,
-0.0205460526,
-0.0054067955,
-0.0059063202,
0.0390696749,
0.0111638112,
0.0010739708,
0.0625684857,
0.0418071263,
-0.0465298258,
0.0231141672,
-0.0408446305,
0.0027194135,
-0.0274998676,
-0.0171238557,
0.0302305035,
-0.0055522947,
0.0167934801,
0.0615266487,
0.0447354764,
-0.0134565057,
-0.0784846172,
0.0388956256,
0.0390227698,
0.0207029693,
-0.0119731128,
0.034647204,
0.0058698901,
0.0095133428,
-0.0155047951,
-0.0628024265,
-0.0400493778,
-0.0254977681,
2.509e-7,
0.0844934583,
0.0517311767,
0.037161272,
0.0279088393,
0.0007255944,
0.010192466,
-0.0294168927,
0.0399032868,
-0.0120615987,
0.0652305335,
0.0549946502,
0.0106670102,
0.040635027,
0.0071465131,
-0.0878760964,
-0.0065532788,
-0.0665487796,
0.0403355211,
-0.0227259919,
-0.0232115295,
0.0641927347,
0.1028160676,
-0.028936021,
0.0080423588,
-0.0166143086,
-0.0480340309,
0.0606871732,
0.0116028972,
-0.0144395502,
0.0263448246,
0.0802982897,
0.0099181198,
-0.0578175597,
-0.0197934639,
-0.0368301794,
-0.0298593044,
0.0305522885,
0.0441391952,
-0.0190837178,
0.0177950393,
0.0180660412,
-0.0074805231,
0.0160697848,
-0.0510292575,
0.046680931,
-0.0273424294,
0.0188442711,
0.0028469588,
-0.0120253488,
0.0192904957,
0.0326258428,
-0.0379182994,
-0.0365051851,
0.0296878759,
0.05579108,
0.0268686004,
-0.0366803743,
-0.0243638232,
-0.0562379174,
-0.0020286383,
0.0051902495,
-0.0183014348,
-0.0209694393,
0.0077671027,
0.0215196572,
-0.0318748169,
-0.0172850844,
2.2117266e-34,
0.0445317663,
-0.0169356931,
0.0116001861,
0.0019124012,
0.032634154,
-0.0319736861,
-0.0018345197,
0.0210868996,
0.0235657133,
-0.01756889,
-0.0217025895
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10528v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10528v1 | Scalable and Safe Remediation of Defective Actions in Self-Learning Conversational Systems | 2023-05-17T19:22:24 | 2023-05-17T19:22:24 | Sarthak Ahuja, Mohammad Kachuee, Fateme Sheikholeslami, Weiqing Liu, Jaeyoung Do | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Off-Policy reinforcement learning has been a driving force for the
state-of-the-art conversational AIs leading to more natural humanagent
interactions and improving the user satisfaction for goal-oriented agents.
However, in large-scale commercial settings, it is often challenging to balance
between policy improvements and experience continuity on the broad spectrum of
applications handled by such system. In the literature, off-policy evaluation
and guard-railing on aggregate statistics has been commonly used to address
this problem. In this paper, we propose a method for curating and leveraging
high-precision samples sourced from historical regression incident reports to
validate, safe-guard, and improve policies prior to the online deployment. We
conducted extensive experiments using data from a real-world conversational
system and actual regression incidents. The proposed method is currently
deployed in our production system to protect customers against broken
experiences and enable long-term policy improvements. | [
0.0108873127,
0.0876014009,
-0.0210439526,
-0.0210065227,
-0.0092351548,
0.0042457604,
0.02789554,
-0.0199943781,
0.0005344679,
-0.027846761,
0.0360180549,
-0.009894724,
-0.0157712027,
0.1022779271,
-0.0236316863,
-0.0319602638,
0.0223458093,
-0.0346682258,
0.0209456552,
0.0179791283,
0.037085209,
-0.0033922649,
-0.0455711074,
0.0538416505,
-0.0454493649,
-0.0309910644,
-0.0192010403,
-0.0211770572,
0.0155931851,
-0.0314676799,
0.0200582277,
-0.0015078849,
0.0392004214,
0.0177849904,
0.0000020317,
-0.0740959793,
-0.0377451852,
-0.0059578624,
-0.0103411358,
-0.0260284785,
0.0146119082,
0.0190523211,
-0.0437388718,
0.0646439046,
-0.0244671479,
0.0532989912,
0.0206000768,
0.0201964416,
0.0399708375,
0.0323910564,
-0.0010379798,
0.0137973437,
0.0106985364,
0.0210524593,
-0.0264753941,
-0.0642062947,
-0.0034872473,
0.0349234901,
-0.0006690346,
-0.0837481543,
-0.0230430048,
-0.0113984849,
0.0115606943,
-0.0204967111,
-0.0154129136,
0.033795476,
-0.0278733764,
-0.0222900584,
-0.0380343981,
0.064638339,
-0.0300029572,
0.0016340101,
0.0370593667,
-0.0511649959,
0.0227150209,
-0.0426812842,
-0.0286661219,
-0.0097199464,
-0.0157056767,
0.0093348669,
-0.0604479611,
0.0127460398,
0.0196836218,
-0.0130839059,
-0.0256659891,
0.0454133227,
-0.0488696359,
-0.0289422143,
0.0275486372,
0.0003063601,
0.034232419,
0.0036235165,
0.0170579739,
0.0180674829,
-0.1077069193,
-0.0022770548,
0.0166772436,
0.0320599563,
0.0231915228,
-0.0066749905,
0.0377080739,
0.0187874399,
-0.00449639,
0.0244948622,
0.0184053387,
0.0595796928,
0.0412579924,
-0.0244975053,
0.0038653372,
0.0553804152,
-0.0595008209,
0.0275060143,
-0.0350479968,
0.0563834533,
-0.0228255261,
-0.0128821321,
-0.0217504036,
0.0577292033,
-0.0746168941,
0.0587077141,
-0.0186542068,
0.0092543652,
-0.0534669124,
0.0175098907,
-0.0492600985,
-0.0266654454,
-0.0401055701,
0.0071827942,
0.0074269329,
-0.0609524325,
-0.0002829286,
-0.0154858306,
0.0049283826,
0.0219453126,
-0.0013558497,
0.0761333406,
0.011295137,
-0.0196307376,
-0.0256792363,
-0.0481635146,
-0.0208746959,
-0.0134397382,
-0.0406242311,
-0.0181822833,
-0.0012233488,
-0.0541982912,
-0.0007243199,
-0.0202970915,
-0.0039704959,
0.0000870389,
-0.0136582917,
0.0364506096,
0.0147599531,
0.0104399277,
-0.0371392109,
-0.006138369,
-0.0064714383,
0.0737587363,
0.0520781837,
0.0343762189,
0.0491122566,
0.0135030271,
0.1067077443,
-0.0148138246,
0.039350085,
0.01524668,
-0.0132154003,
0.0054216492,
-0.0217705145,
0.0059486078,
0.0418553315,
0.0042801816,
-0.025456639,
0.0016313404,
0.0444889367,
0.0341816805,
-0.0600846969,
0.0035050712,
0.0241549034,
0.0036450333,
-0.0459779128,
-0.0138795106,
-0.0287604686,
0.0164882224,
0.0213351399,
0.0194458328,
0.0086449794,
0.0271603968,
-0.0473151989,
-0.0514856763,
0.042298615,
0.0065750959,
0.0162809715,
0.0416265987,
0.0321637541,
0.0105853872,
-0.0369444266,
-0.0126981726,
0.0131995743,
-0.0062044095,
-0.0294104386,
-0.0776027441,
0.0445839688,
0.1007162184,
0.0533004366,
-0.0580337718,
-0.047731515,
-0.0361416414,
0.0068656616,
-0.0051791556,
0.0252960082,
-0.0376257375,
0.0582320578,
-0.0202553142,
-0.0534945428,
0.0056056264,
0.0081576183,
0.0472152904,
-0.0087759979,
0.0126591343,
-0.0095673157,
0.0262028277,
-0.0496074483,
0.0284198485,
-0.0112267192,
-0.037647903,
0.0256548114,
-0.0049839406,
0.0577298328,
-0.0200202782,
-0.002448349,
-0.0402861312,
0.0031006797,
0.0512341224,
-0.0225746222,
0.0415768139,
-0.0319710709,
0.003014555,
0.0238611363,
-0.0235635266,
-0.0208942741,
0.0111289741,
-0.0596457273,
0.0018728937,
0.0145639237,
-0.0115249977,
0.0101281051,
-0.020302698,
0.027091438,
0.002127504,
-0.0162133351,
0.0127661824,
0.0021940265,
-0.000135337,
-0.0355324224,
-0.0742204636,
-0.0475381613,
0.007266561,
-0.0782721862,
-0.0076897033,
-0.020979559,
-0.0364566147,
0.031453725,
0.0301733855,
0.0050603328,
-0.0521219075,
0.01017744,
-0.0460601151,
0.0076486827,
-0.0229110643,
-0.0074884361,
-0.006733079,
0.0159680471,
-0.0326592326,
-0.0649993718,
0.0114984727,
-0.0184511691,
0.063289471,
0.0203240421,
0.0210110173,
0.0465493836,
-0.050903514,
-0.046184767,
0.0147483665,
-0.0149954725,
-0.0109397685,
-0.0114618633,
0.0237938259,
-0.0492584184,
0.0063363072,
-0.0515072793,
0.0129099963,
-0.0261246283,
-0.0673124343,
0.0321695395,
0.0022152606,
-0.0007737751,
0.0834508836,
-0.0238232054,
0.0677010342,
0.0542040356,
-0.0204128902,
-0.0583221801,
0.039079681,
-0.0365337506,
-0.0065588979,
-0.003840944,
0.0214828197,
0.0232813153,
0.0103673059,
-0.0215387326,
0.0195836518,
-0.0480018184,
0.015844455,
0.0139020635,
-0.0679271221,
-0.0360978618,
-0.015316451,
-0.0500021391,
0.015565129,
0.0013231572,
-0.0659470782,
0.0442658961,
0.0528251976,
0.003341631,
-0.0350796171,
-0.0483536869,
0.0160855968,
0.0451291837,
-0.0014954961,
-0.001076791,
-0.0233737621,
-0.0342359394,
-0.0196653605,
-0.0554680899,
0.0491177663,
-0.0445779897,
-0.0129872262,
-0.0810793638,
0.0098687541,
0.0551048853,
-0.064214021,
-0.0487805754,
-0.0681012273,
-0.0252575055,
-0.0526480004,
-0.0414558277,
-0.0008858716,
-0.0537922829,
0.0190368425,
0.0268728305,
0.0620524772,
0.0279199146,
-0.0529271923,
-0.0021478492,
-0.0747839808,
0.0319946744,
0.0166277606,
0.0119570876,
-0.0006651955,
0.0551856421,
0.025017824,
0.1256311685,
-0.0148380632,
-0.0388705209,
0.0028017303,
-0.0201925319,
-0.0307010561,
0.0283663087,
0.0803143904,
0.023830099,
-0.0295769032,
-0.0322650746,
0.0524478331,
0.0216301698,
-0.0012173048,
0.0267031249,
0.0491707698,
0.0225539617,
0.0143993124,
0.0071852598,
-0.0368919261,
0.0235254001,
0.0353193209,
0.0787321329,
-0.044841364,
-0.051584661,
0.0099104149,
-0.1260137856,
0.0430845283,
-0.0226349477,
-0.0416867621,
-0.0354894586,
-0.0437832288,
0.0242915209,
-0.0610813126,
0.0564467125,
-0.0017551718,
-0.005878889,
-0.018138919,
0.0420353301,
-0.0458047837,
-0.0639809445,
0.0064745876,
-0.0337233022,
0.0560849085,
0.0677066818,
0.0541455708,
0.0084169786,
0.0206371937,
0.0279442202,
0.0309944656,
0.0216021873,
0.0298152547,
0.0811592862,
0.0140488949,
0.0246746875,
-0.0120889042,
0.0377541594,
0.0013259532,
-0.0301797893,
0.0295078848,
0.0303036533,
-0.0421345681,
-0.0107688922,
-0.0020167865,
0.0234866086,
0.0664320439,
0.0510678552,
-0.0114263827,
-0.0437174737,
-0.0386716537,
0.0053896555,
-0.0258381367,
-0.0127630429,
-0.0022676298,
-0.0001669819,
-0.0256853662,
-0.0001756381,
-0.0522284806,
-0.0612411462,
-0.0108297011,
0.1074141189,
-0.0242733154,
-0.0560930558,
0.0159987435,
0.0769463927,
0.0482968204,
-0.0044569694,
-0.0298247188,
0.0340858921,
-0.0186550803,
0.0850040242,
-0.0210964326,
0.0295755882,
-0.0194087122,
-0.0375139453,
0.0150747886,
-0.0550587922,
0.054377012,
0.0923413634,
0.0312701873,
0.038118165,
-0.0204403978,
-0.0181252118,
0.0787477121,
0.0738052949,
-0.032745257,
-0.013438276,
0.0319405086,
0.0189456716,
0.0044005653,
0.0057883486,
-0.052695699,
-0.0114137847,
-0.020075487,
0.0110247796,
-0.0246485621,
-0.0063483221,
0.0132981641,
-0.0238894802,
0.0075852019,
0.0000986205,
0.0069581433,
-0.0090592029,
0.0480627157,
-0.0006837135,
0.0167156961,
-0.0314925686,
0.0509179235,
-0.0212068502,
-0.0281702355,
-0.0002007828,
0.0054521267,
-0.0312041156,
0.0128198583,
-0.0414755493,
-0.0322574824,
0.03453945,
0.0039383988,
0.0005961705,
-0.0012450186,
0.0179590154,
0.025410898,
0.0423424356,
0.062717773,
0.0587712601,
0.0307389461,
0.0326754153,
0.0353292525,
-0.0036784594,
0.0294896848,
-0.0777826682,
-0.0480939709,
-0.0071878443,
0.0183211751,
0.0099989055,
-0.0102207493,
0.0160400495,
-0.029645063,
0.0232264102,
0.0010433487,
0.0119466474,
-0.0048119952,
0.0210433695,
-0.0486813113,
0.022692211,
-0.022248676,
-0.0199824832,
0.0531912744,
-0.0138713028,
0.0446629785,
-0.0246236697,
0.003615649,
-0.0316887274,
-0.0164378006,
-0.0051051183,
0.0272073094,
-0.0052581672,
-0.0732262209,
-0.067086935,
-0.0392553024,
-0.0320494249,
0.0547307804,
0.0073420256,
-0.0328028463,
0.0131564476,
0.0248534642,
0.0042994269,
0.0715125427,
-0.0121509079,
-0.0513923019,
-0.0242730789,
0.0015085891,
-0.0247649867,
-5.458157123e-33,
0.0254734773,
-0.0207203273,
-0.0016711282,
0.0053857192,
-0.0063604224,
-0.0423349403,
-0.0065973084,
-0.0155939683,
0.0594424754,
0.0181317907,
-0.0326788425,
0.0455867052,
0.0200109892,
-0.0111405905,
0.0031733911,
-0.0052064932,
0.0435222052,
-0.0216452237,
-0.0691502467,
0.0481351502,
0.0609268583,
0.0132702747,
-0.0183131583,
-0.1062368974,
0.0125499619,
0.0388770886,
-0.0062912731,
0.0328939296,
0.0182959009,
0.0638513118,
0.0408862233,
0.0157401524,
0.0085662724,
-0.042151317,
-0.0086183539,
0.0079747522,
-0.0271534417,
-0.0492892265,
-0.0229533929,
-0.0170323774,
0.0419539809,
0.0166648757,
0.0116882687,
0.0080650253,
-0.0392066278,
0.0385088623,
-0.0016856387,
-0.0170946643,
0.0010002239,
-0.0325270183,
-0.0252939519,
-0.0139109371,
-0.0555827469,
-0.0155135337,
0.0022202157,
0.0143742608,
0.0032207028,
-0.0075221416,
-0.0046938155,
0.0002966049,
-0.0436576977,
-0.0534171984,
0.0373673476,
-0.0043266877,
-0.0019752742,
0.0340524316,
-0.022383716,
0.0428065881,
0.0030829087,
-0.0554911681,
0.0360874198,
0.0300828312,
-0.0299564153,
0.0576889329,
0.0338702351,
-0.0315395519,
-0.038180694,
0.0643429235,
0.0518223681,
0.0257935077,
0.0064450675,
0.0112344669,
-0.0826790705,
0.005033093,
-0.0105831986,
0.026292013,
-0.0061881817,
-0.0429907665,
0.0473591946,
0.052482076,
-0.0264166184,
-0.0165524054,
0.0109889545,
-0.0180418529,
-0.0257811751,
-0.0112414993,
-0.0091679795,
-0.0202543102,
0.0079360986,
-0.0145143308,
-0.0619988777,
-0.0476889573,
0.0006068848,
0.0315267257,
0.0428265519,
-0.0287718214,
0.0192535222,
0.0607412383,
-0.0448898673,
0.0482015386,
-0.0054241344,
0.059596777,
-0.0043406077,
0.0228370242,
0.0298498645,
-0.0065043005,
-0.0028676526,
0.0193601493,
-0.0051864712,
-0.0205969699,
-0.0305871442,
-0.0066085421,
-0.0367064215,
-0.0288922116,
-0.0453045592,
-0.0526217297,
-0.0276346002,
-0.0232145134,
0.0013999444,
-0.0241537727,
-0.0134653971,
-0.0123612443,
2.76e-7,
-0.0652362928,
0.013914248,
0.0192340109,
0.0273273401,
0.0369048528,
0.0414068848,
-0.0130362539,
0.0499799103,
0.0227079839,
-0.044665575,
0.0653960332,
0.0007951289,
0.0283233877,
0.0557117313,
-0.0298327431,
-0.0509545915,
-0.0446441285,
-0.0317153595,
-0.0530721955,
-0.0283024479,
-0.0057436512,
0.049699612,
0.0308809876,
-0.012174516,
0.0717848614,
-0.0011078374,
-0.0193434842,
-0.0312423743,
-0.0158337578,
-0.0161189921,
0.0541257374,
0.046046935,
-0.0048007304,
0.0048391442,
-0.0271816123,
0.0196952801,
-0.0747549981,
0.0266598575,
0.0048072645,
-0.0284269173,
-0.0256654192,
-0.0022112478,
0.0541165806,
-0.0205999184,
0.0268522259,
-0.0421357825,
0.0231801737,
0.007411187,
-0.0063985526,
-0.0310186185,
0.0104496367,
0.0158944782,
-0.0230434649,
0.0256437007,
-0.0047042142,
0.039165616,
0.0359474607,
-0.0573812202,
0.0417668782,
0.0250504073,
0.004302517,
-0.0955314487,
0.0013308296,
0.0134842433,
0.0052977735,
-0.0571648702,
0.013489929,
2.325411598e-34,
0.0136225913,
-0.0051821899,
0.0109055368,
-0.0428021587,
0.0185948797,
0.0618826374,
0.0333312973,
-0.0052088965,
0.0892379358,
0.0087334476,
-0.0074639255
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10519v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10519v2 | Statistical Knowledge Assessment for Large Language Models | 2023-05-17T18:54:37 | 2023-10-28T07:58:04 | Qingxiu Dong, Jingjing Xu, Lingpeng Kong, Zhifang Sui, Lei Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Given varying prompts regarding a factoid question, can a large language
model (LLM) reliably generate factually correct answers? Existing LLMs may
generate distinct responses for different prompts. In this paper, we study the
problem of quantifying knowledge contained in an LLM regarding a given set of
facts. We propose KaRR, a statistical approach to assess factual knowledge for
LLMs. The main idea is to estimate the ratio of LLM generating text
corresponding to the answer entity given diverse prompts of the subject and the
querying relation, versus it generating by random chances. Our assessment suite
contains a comprehensive set of 994,123 entities and 600 relations, with
1,395,905 text aliases. We use our method to evaluate 20 LLMs of various sizes,
including LLaMA, Alpaca, OPT, etc. Experiments show that our results have a
strong correlation (0.43 Kendall's $\tau$) with the results of human assessment
on LLMs. Our results reveal that the knowledge in LLMs with the same backbone
architecture adheres to the scaling law, while tuning on instruction-following
data sometimes compromises the model's capability to generate factually correct
text reliably. | [
0.0634402558,
0.015821116,
-0.0206070766,
0.0386416167,
-0.0302382074,
0.0160438754,
-0.0023703089,
0.0100734951,
0.0120976297,
-0.0724497363,
0.0126608936,
-0.035729818,
-0.0103150886,
0.0121351164,
0.0363538601,
-0.0393666662,
0.0208473764,
-0.041650895,
-0.0006134227,
-0.0245831795,
-0.0076747905,
0.0158156622,
-0.0212759487,
0.0188070498,
-0.0261007436,
-0.0164545849,
-0.0066432492,
-0.0171960164,
0.0056503261,
-0.0176765099,
0.0052503464,
0.0470340587,
-0.0162060764,
0.011762795,
0.0000018528,
-0.0776737556,
0.0161297079,
0.000540795,
-0.059181165,
0.0296928696,
-0.0000934042,
0.0312543623,
0.0176354889,
0.0291110296,
-0.0312485788,
0.0286487155,
0.0228253528,
0.0278864913,
0.0597343557,
0.0435940214,
0.0351582952,
-0.0102625862,
0.0237454735,
0.0091475947,
0.0466991812,
-0.0184078421,
0.0257955696,
0.0516899787,
-0.0068690027,
0.0393259078,
-0.0216797702,
0.0547751561,
0.0258511826,
0.0025812483,
0.0150222788,
0.0388584882,
-0.0217236038,
0.0204771701,
0.0178533699,
0.0660744011,
0.0219902527,
-0.006251601,
0.0025401195,
0.0062024067,
0.0161249693,
0.0577753522,
-0.0322707705,
0.0175863877,
-0.0238799844,
-0.0253779143,
0.0289721619,
-0.0179797877,
0.0201318283,
0.000173652,
-0.0118094049,
0.0641994327,
0.0196947008,
-0.0403682329,
-0.0054333471,
-0.0004912551,
-0.0229211561,
-0.0944778845,
-0.0007340905,
0.0515498444,
-0.0373891816,
0.0542571619,
-0.0280088,
-0.0152836246,
0.0769727007,
-0.077966027,
-0.0029644687,
-0.003118698,
-0.008873581,
0.0641084164,
-0.0017147257,
0.0689484179,
0.0120641524,
-0.00041701,
-0.0327057987,
-0.0017200534,
-0.0686968789,
0.0001904199,
-0.0002921762,
0.0589374341,
-0.0341676958,
-0.0032746573,
-0.0299939662,
0.0265640374,
0.0105178459,
0.0308630448,
0.0237292461,
0.01666875,
-0.0141699538,
-0.0060387799,
-0.0826678798,
0.0275279749,
-0.0575249754,
0.0032550164,
-0.0063170185,
-0.0441214517,
0.0120227411,
-0.000863165,
0.0232962724,
-0.0338042602,
0.0256768093,
0.0342334695,
-0.0023709508,
-0.0383286439,
-0.0561918356,
-0.054242596,
-0.0248717442,
-0.0603730343,
-0.0239225831,
-0.0959939808,
0.0219491646,
0.0437913202,
-0.0060764598,
0.0005869663,
0.0211515054,
0.0408658348,
-0.0261426046,
0.0386068523,
0.0383542851,
0.0318475515,
0.0308453366,
0.0049630506,
0.0144302147,
0.0792496428,
0.0139544699,
0.0109666027,
0.0545937903,
0.0217866525,
-0.0118080843,
0.0091071809,
0.0286173653,
0.0238859151,
0.0234454423,
0.0472143069,
0.0221767575,
0.009006233,
0.0120607102,
0.0894808471,
0.0050073643,
-0.0426296964,
0.0646338537,
0.0245220084,
0.0040980196,
0.0182306655,
0.0753977299,
-0.0010420359,
0.0597992353,
0.0390825197,
-0.0410799235,
0.030041879,
-0.051046662,
0.0289177261,
0.0200910233,
0.0633568615,
-0.0278839376,
-0.0364892818,
-0.0210236646,
0.0166949518,
-0.0785759911,
0.0377095565,
0.0336618088,
-0.0055365474,
-0.0213229172,
0.060758628,
0.0238129608,
-0.0036224048,
0.040742781,
-0.0480438396,
0.0409882553,
0.0438203104,
0.0486594178,
-0.0164127871,
-0.0544136092,
-0.0012989314,
-0.0116994865,
0.0407013595,
0.0498481765,
-0.0425771289,
-0.0201714523,
-0.0089081898,
0.0037238055,
-0.0071629891,
0.0210296493,
0.0097110514,
0.0392142683,
0.0243698992,
0.0150584066,
-0.099918589,
-0.0186715405,
0.0323784165,
-0.0602389947,
-0.0314078629,
-0.0073510674,
0.0047869249,
0.0138962725,
0.0235957839,
-0.0333748385,
0.0251790751,
-0.0022701556,
-0.0154069774,
-0.0117088817,
-0.0382851474,
-0.0015808068,
-0.0593831614,
0.0455649719,
-0.0132328691,
-0.0213543046,
-0.0280610584,
-0.023082871,
-0.0338439718,
-0.0291836858,
-0.0629743412,
0.0301313642,
-0.0515813343,
0.0067305001,
0.0067995661,
-0.0186186768,
-0.0287554115,
0.0791987553,
-0.0014379517,
0.0472064018,
0.0239591654,
-0.0064650779,
0.0143231386,
-0.0494686663,
-0.0381075926,
-0.0255552903,
0.0038720323,
0.0191274732,
0.0315579399,
0.0122619178,
-0.0573576204,
-0.0343854055,
-0.0890175626,
0.014577413,
-0.0149782756,
0.0160909537,
0.0366495959,
-0.0044512693,
0.0008969471,
-0.0011923104,
-0.0715382323,
-0.0302666984,
0.0062994282,
0.0439385138,
0.0420193672,
0.0217641164,
-0.0099580754,
-0.0228652377,
0.0222841278,
-0.0300804712,
0.0451018102,
0.0453680605,
0.0250251014,
-0.0468231328,
0.068058677,
-0.0599243343,
-0.0116207097,
0.0120409522,
-0.023403896,
0.0143427439,
0.0128105879,
0.0577265769,
0.0628817528,
0.0384760387,
-0.0130062774,
0.0371520594,
-0.0228151176,
-0.0571902804,
0.0085112145,
-0.0158326086,
-0.0070729675,
-0.0302325878,
-0.0684997141,
0.0109625431,
0.0466259941,
0.0306819025,
-0.0255739894,
-0.0445527993,
0.0122593865,
-0.0332814492,
-0.0334101841,
-0.0728231445,
0.0377287194,
0.0061976565,
0.0518347584,
-0.016129354,
-0.015499291,
0.0823389739,
-0.033641059,
0.0235906597,
-0.0326936208,
0.0042899256,
-0.0257623252,
0.0598843768,
0.0134404143,
0.0311891958,
-0.00446318,
0.0014678381,
-0.0829431936,
-0.0013626236,
0.0086427396,
-0.0585015379,
0.0358798206,
-0.0679329187,
-0.005268794,
0.0356610529,
-0.0315708742,
-0.0589078739,
-0.0297543481,
-0.0065880725,
0.0069981664,
0.0062822462,
-0.0390126705,
0.0005167041,
-0.0157625396,
0.0486401059,
-0.0204903558,
-0.0242568552,
-0.0290879086,
-0.0089257732,
0.0558756068,
0.0913010687,
0.0263408013,
0.0477416478,
-0.0260683838,
0.0273778439,
0.0447350629,
0.0417042188,
0.0112112202,
0.0080394326,
-0.0217341129,
-0.0039268974,
-0.0581578314,
0.0011034294,
0.0448862985,
0.0352059342,
-0.0126866335,
-0.0341699012,
0.1254040301,
0.0407807566,
0.0316774026,
-0.0160403587,
-0.0093818465,
0.0156253632,
0.0167994369,
0.06187867,
-0.0765141547,
0.0029807347,
-0.0217519607,
0.0148890475,
-0.0288157146,
-0.05249504,
-0.0024980295,
-0.1480214745,
0.0058225249,
-0.0391171314,
-0.0103131123,
-0.0332396515,
-0.0479803048,
0.0037739191,
0.0001575646,
0.0070593799,
0.0156929325,
-0.0199479535,
0.0226473287,
0.0281018931,
-0.002472369,
-0.0426574014,
0.0654623136,
-0.05407447,
0.0806647167,
0.0235136952,
0.041806601,
-0.0177682545,
-0.0331449397,
-0.0157151204,
-0.0308956727,
-0.0148326149,
0.0157916397,
0.0634073839,
-0.0170383789,
0.0004102661,
-0.0355062857,
-0.0138082858,
-0.0237256065,
0.0161816981,
0.0418217443,
0.0683256462,
-0.0140802311,
-0.0059742718,
-0.0184492022,
0.0052267495,
-0.0091815153,
0.1105509028,
0.0552892014,
-0.0114431921,
0.0038470402,
-0.02765687,
-0.0019499776,
-0.0404756814,
-0.0154825682,
0.025884714,
-0.0188634302,
0.0228683259,
-0.106036514,
-0.0458236113,
0.041335091,
0.0387133472,
0.0185058247,
-0.0058304155,
0.0209211856,
-0.001526544,
-0.0270999949,
-0.0300574657,
-0.0544744506,
0.0123080816,
-0.0565556176,
-0.0196819976,
0.031568069,
-0.0352062546,
-0.0372044332,
-0.0099944696,
-0.080332391,
-0.0400920734,
0.0084867682,
0.0462236367,
0.0247388445,
0.0064564138,
-0.0409534909,
-0.036041718,
0.062175829,
0.0756479576,
-0.0473755114,
0.0200859755,
-0.0280452278,
0.0017132986,
-0.0021201938,
0.0250080395,
-0.0623057932,
-0.0217903871,
0.0121983774,
0.0547964983,
-0.0499272682,
-0.0826359317,
0.0160183627,
0.0498328358,
-0.0061455402,
0.0024798012,
-0.0144658918,
-0.0235485137,
0.0103597976,
-0.0052495534,
-0.0211336166,
-0.0114274519,
-0.0010113805,
0.0178091992,
-0.0077833827,
-0.0035689683,
0.0014447505,
-0.0178894959,
0.0385067835,
0.008528485,
-0.0492249466,
0.0077387025,
0.0254510585,
0.0293668527,
-0.0231093485,
-0.0194303598,
-0.01344926,
0.023574831,
0.0525103733,
0.0230786242,
0.049791418,
0.0060403645,
-0.0175477434,
0.0052591297,
0.0031657375,
-0.0645726994,
-0.0210236125,
-0.0243607461,
0.0575483479,
0.0237848256,
0.0001339937,
0.0160109866,
-0.0483983941,
-0.0049552857,
-0.0145137943,
0.0002615895,
0.0202085283,
-0.0034262999,
0.0460167974,
0.021394223,
0.0038219229,
-0.0074164262,
0.0858980343,
0.004847398,
0.0608321987,
0.0093189552,
-0.042827677,
-0.0154790431,
-0.0352627747,
-0.0400013328,
-0.0226818528,
-0.0210823007,
0.0127412258,
-0.0994873494,
-0.1090692952,
0.0033074589,
0.0389731303,
0.0096886223,
-0.0006742929,
0.0208756626,
0.0708008185,
0.0123684565,
-0.0168734621,
-0.0612353124,
0.030472815,
-0.0401637852,
-0.0068178792,
-0.0069801351,
-6.41214536e-33,
-0.0557697192,
-0.0556999072,
0.0340602472,
-0.0165865906,
0.0176721271,
0.0234793648,
-0.0281426124,
0.0087246383,
-0.0233793315,
0.0116440989,
-0.0128964204,
0.0083761429,
-0.0023043016,
0.0196408182,
-0.0031432714,
-0.0354679041,
0.0076492103,
-0.011143297,
-0.0239559673,
0.0217205491,
0.0518261604,
-0.0088672955,
0.0176552702,
-0.0354530476,
0.04707513,
-0.0100444555,
0.024705762,
0.0443763733,
-0.0383002385,
0.0780596063,
-0.0192410983,
0.0526275821,
0.0367971957,
-0.0525140688,
0.0095452433,
-0.0123863043,
-0.056976784,
-0.0747352317,
0.0627391636,
-0.008038057,
-0.0036810089,
-0.0176982861,
0.0123949433,
-0.0023260817,
-0.0004830721,
-0.0200343691,
0.0605598688,
-0.015109919,
0.0062801354,
-0.047684785,
0.0017788152,
0.0099156657,
-0.0110369809,
-0.0199222155,
-0.0437036902,
-0.001401291,
0.0254607424,
-0.0218142252,
-0.0181340296,
0.0213574991,
0.0320589878,
0.0318766758,
0.0460651703,
0.0184143316,
-0.0100530554,
0.0626622811,
-0.029906977,
0.007689645,
-0.0378679186,
-0.0022845347,
0.002847505,
0.0186979156,
0.0253296755,
0.075553894,
-0.0021142547,
0.0239269603,
-0.0556278639,
0.0609686226,
0.0385313854,
0.0164922532,
0.0133261858,
-0.0510323979,
-0.0494797342,
-0.0144895185,
-0.0626778007,
0.0142669175,
-0.0504079685,
-0.0319076478,
0.046993196,
-0.0176659618,
-0.0256370567,
-0.0071484479,
0.0217824355,
-0.0278926212,
-0.0417636335,
-0.0003358663,
0.008069017,
0.025136333,
-0.0121787572,
0.0398353487,
-0.0426751859,
0.0070649348,
0.0246715993,
0.0052427407,
-0.0070061758,
0.0199919268,
0.013533866,
-0.0139284013,
-0.059972249,
0.0037694476,
-0.0411000624,
0.0016168791,
-0.0121078268,
-0.0341257565,
0.0084557636,
0.0278306566,
-0.0072621484,
0.0055275369,
0.0193205215,
-0.0218244735,
-0.0319937617,
-0.0146857901,
-0.0193809811,
0.0165562946,
-0.0441422462,
-0.0067736888,
-0.0391698554,
-0.0061151823,
-0.0279627927,
-0.0222956203,
0.008894261,
0.0079522505,
2.592e-7,
0.0483500548,
0.0346139595,
-0.0115472199,
0.0478088185,
-0.0085815322,
0.0318269879,
-0.0098604616,
0.0119570233,
0.0525408722,
-0.0715960637,
-0.0145241041,
0.0278632492,
0.0086575719,
0.0454965755,
-0.1013199762,
0.0033311227,
-0.0334953666,
-0.0066732322,
-0.0459969528,
-0.0123603884,
0.0435057767,
0.0419921987,
0.0362684429,
-0.01847714,
-0.0198956598,
-0.0383102596,
0.0484245643,
-0.0033814413,
-0.0394087471,
0.039554514,
0.0474939905,
0.0084568914,
0.0482785329,
0.0725585669,
-0.014821846,
-0.0228692722,
-0.005631383,
0.0384277627,
0.0360355936,
-0.0106199915,
-0.0183054302,
-0.0484988168,
0.0135072749,
-0.0839889422,
0.0692636371,
-0.0039596269,
0.0003512282,
0.0126389638,
-0.0073194695,
-0.0245463047,
0.008911564,
-0.0243488047,
-0.0192734841,
0.0052677048,
-0.0139891468,
0.0095249517,
0.0099838581,
-0.023059329,
-0.0158903711,
0.0200001989,
-0.0378610417,
-0.1052157432,
-0.0417219475,
-0.0168851148,
0.000383236,
-0.0797762424,
0.0145299071,
2.549864438e-34,
0.0125078363,
0.0316962078,
-0.0008582242,
0.0029873571,
0.0526672341,
-0.00750646,
-0.0301713608,
-0.0042048413,
0.0232778676,
-0.0965600163,
-0.004757693
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10512v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10512v2 | IMAD: IMage-Augmented multi-modal Dialogue | 2023-05-17T18:38:10 | 2023-12-16T10:18:21 | Viktor Moskvoretskii, Anton Frolov, Denis Kuznetsov | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC, I.4.10; I.7.m | Currently, dialogue systems have achieved high performance in processing
text-based communication. However, they have not yet effectively incorporated
visual information, which poses a significant challenge. Furthermore, existing
models that incorporate images in dialogue generation focus on discussing the
image itself. Our proposed approach presents a novel perspective on multi-modal
dialogue systems, which interprets the image in the context of the dialogue. By
doing so, we aim to expand the capabilities of current dialogue systems and
transition them from single modality (text) to multi-modality. However, there
is a lack of validated English datasets that contain both images and dialogue
contexts for this task. Thus, we propose a two-stage approach to automatically
construct a multi-modal dialogue dataset. In the first stage, we utilize
text-to-image similarity and sentence similarity to identify which utterances
could be replaced with an image. In the second stage, we replace those
utterances by selecting a subset of relevant images and filtering them with a
visual question answering model. We used this approach, along with additional
labeling, to create the IMage Augmented multi-modal Dialogue dataset (IMAD),
which can serve as a validated dataset for this task. Furthermore, we propose a
baseline model trained on this dataset, which outperforms model trained on the
same data without images and BlenderBot. | [
0.0364787392,
0.0638012588,
-0.0046316311,
0.0570489503,
-0.0372568294,
0.0147764971,
0.0407177843,
0.0155393463,
0.0230092686,
-0.0562091023,
-0.0407646075,
-0.0134034483,
-0.0106795728,
0.050653547,
0.0431644507,
-0.0850477964,
0.0078148171,
-0.0274731144,
0.0011704987,
-0.0009218644,
0.0613720268,
0.0139538012,
-0.024450982,
0.0462736152,
-0.0655285046,
-0.0412578434,
-0.0339637846,
0.030620968,
0.030160293,
-0.0100849252,
-0.0231001526,
0.0303754751,
0.0536472425,
0.0010684438,
0.0000016047,
0.0023711813,
0.018090345,
-0.0060196724,
0.0074645267,
-0.0248372331,
0.0189830381,
-0.0028646754,
0.0173690617,
0.0074329879,
-0.0500982143,
0.0229982454,
0.0713704675,
0.0584868789,
0.1028696373,
0.0498235188,
-0.0404765196,
-0.023812091,
-0.0098117171,
0.0028928549,
0.0268326793,
-0.0419986509,
-0.0210660268,
0.0574083775,
0.018988084,
0.00946071,
-0.0380739756,
0.0615279935,
0.0104155429,
-0.0479107238,
-0.0118138008,
0.0331608355,
0.0031466337,
-0.0340852551,
-0.0420423076,
0.1139062196,
0.0364607461,
0.0123837125,
-0.0219980534,
-0.008566604,
0.0160502568,
-0.0024422572,
-0.0567959808,
0.019146679,
-0.0065292632,
0.0175720342,
-0.0581058562,
-0.0104668671,
-0.0473867618,
0.0096655404,
0.0233443528,
-0.0222636554,
0.0283526704,
-0.0034895758,
-0.0515695326,
0.0050699743,
-0.0364168175,
-0.0733369589,
-0.0054303021,
0.0379642844,
-0.0038028962,
0.0265210867,
-0.0582236014,
-0.0078317793,
0.0020953037,
-0.0166332927,
-0.0013667182,
0.0088431146,
-0.0592459664,
0.0827310532,
0.027697783,
0.0382604375,
0.0026297446,
0.0145954909,
-0.035550449,
-0.018751286,
-0.0182915479,
-0.0190265495,
-0.0719983503,
-0.0090250047,
-0.0615328103,
-0.0579232834,
-0.0065262597,
0.0384142473,
0.0002340921,
0.0012270068,
0.0284230411,
0.0504801013,
-0.0296380278,
0.0010536361,
-0.0336079746,
0.0357813723,
-0.0255891066,
0.033816658,
0.0127584282,
-0.0487345792,
-0.0124403462,
0.0391326062,
0.0513023213,
-0.012363147,
-0.0093656806,
0.0562712476,
-0.0661381558,
-0.027991496,
0.0091991173,
-0.0309239179,
-0.0447432958,
-0.040081501,
0.0068741902,
-0.0235516746,
0.0444287136,
-0.0260338616,
-0.0126207881,
-0.0076355278,
0.0113161877,
0.0193005912,
-0.0039797612,
0.0955146626,
-0.0254013296,
0.0085729035,
0.0404281467,
0.0272332169,
-0.0075798524,
0.0583738126,
0.0252245981,
0.0135215065,
0.0582537092,
0.008357727,
0.0228785668,
0.043575,
-0.0038367955,
0.0038593695,
-0.019512089,
0.0297901202,
-0.0410811044,
0.0314695872,
0.0018830443,
0.0387062989,
-0.0592455417,
-0.0306236651,
0.0652760193,
0.0296289455,
-0.0244776551,
0.0016471221,
0.0121571925,
0.0333178565,
0.029003296,
-0.0004033948,
-0.0146290902,
0.0521210805,
0.0242904089,
0.0048666536,
0.0377398431,
0.0142885614,
-0.0546807051,
-0.0160179697,
0.0249248371,
0.0006375064,
0.0251502972,
0.0083590131,
0.0123668462,
0.037962541,
-0.047012642,
0.0402358659,
-0.0302664489,
-0.0349374786,
-0.0583479628,
-0.0124159977,
0.0381054543,
0.0249796268,
0.0391102321,
-0.0065890779,
-0.0239410736,
-0.0031255693,
0.0510995425,
0.0352387503,
-0.0185488742,
-0.0151917925,
0.0594463013,
-0.0651010722,
-0.0134123266,
-0.0288761165,
-0.0290612821,
0.0080563277,
0.0032741276,
-0.0015435599,
0.0034874287,
0.0362570323,
0.0303009544,
0.0280491523,
0.0517646223,
0.00736281,
-0.0038063272,
0.0259747989,
0.0064528394,
0.0102531146,
-0.0273231994,
-0.0254701804,
0.0216622856,
0.0013297618,
0.0017467894,
0.0453886837,
-0.0393163897,
-0.0763590261,
0.0307142232,
-0.0573692881,
-0.0266684107,
0.0053386292,
-0.0327423029,
-0.0394339226,
0.0244024321,
-0.0717855692,
-0.0037927399,
-0.0681070685,
-0.0039951368,
0.0436693579,
0.0434045605,
-0.0148847606,
0.0283133239,
0.0044610645,
-0.0296245031,
0.0347749926,
0.0456155315,
0.0194121692,
-0.0364280045,
-0.0154696843,
0.0048874216,
-0.0121964943,
0.026878044,
0.0093142996,
0.0340373442,
-0.0667238235,
-0.0166628081,
-0.1152684689,
-0.029562626,
0.0125267887,
-0.0380697511,
0.0213392116,
0.0007633727,
-0.0046784468,
-0.0547472201,
-0.0599598326,
0.0405348875,
0.0569230914,
-0.0017302216,
0.0435249731,
0.0177467205,
0.0100496989,
-0.0559811406,
0.0180578325,
0.0522285625,
0.0651474372,
0.0193347838,
-0.0038499334,
-0.0222187713,
0.0056072343,
-0.0410061851,
0.0575055182,
0.0009679737,
-0.0491872504,
0.0329715833,
-0.0003199546,
0.0388950743,
0.0455552675,
0.0295463502,
0.0089892717,
-0.0247345082,
-0.0366149321,
-0.0499033779,
0.0168643519,
0.0261312369,
-0.0061073853,
0.0231175795,
-0.0305279922,
-0.0179922208,
0.0103544015,
0.016670011,
0.040477749,
-0.0252617896,
0.0461163633,
0.0651423708,
-0.0501938015,
-0.0565141812,
0.004557868,
-0.0077559492,
0.0297991354,
-0.040381331,
-0.0721294135,
0.0487548374,
-0.034012422,
-0.0554912724,
0.0027324394,
-0.0003483501,
-0.0153682753,
0.0667058378,
0.0080413278,
0.0266183577,
0.0051928796,
0.0104016745,
-0.016584361,
-0.0269961283,
0.0243514702,
-0.0155067425,
0.0525413901,
-0.0499120392,
0.0135083199,
-0.0064092712,
-0.0423605144,
-0.0439319871,
-0.0441538952,
-0.0275481101,
-0.0541366823,
-0.0451345779,
-0.0255856253,
-0.0293728765,
0.0156843234,
0.0231067296,
0.0032988109,
0.0090497583,
-0.0046192296,
-0.0090167196,
0.0830028504,
0.0686011836,
0.0606608316,
-0.0448600948,
-0.0096549261,
0.0664761662,
0.0452723615,
0.0027936506,
-0.0218496453,
-0.0410187319,
0.0206196886,
-0.0101042818,
0.0777757764,
0.0207172614,
0.0134625016,
0.0581193417,
-0.0165733993,
-0.0145112947,
0.0557277724,
0.0184372757,
0.0013803707,
-0.0365739726,
-0.0025816734,
0.0402406827,
0.0237068236,
0.0188493039,
-0.0862425938,
-0.0570726134,
-0.0247314386,
-0.0347564667,
-0.0276899561,
0.0194636397,
-0.0446805693,
-0.0431300178,
0.0614752397,
-0.0107849911,
-0.0231618751,
-0.0254629124,
0.0385708287,
-0.0056960266,
0.0022503298,
-0.0143249193,
-0.0214711297,
0.0146626262,
-0.007399139,
-0.0246024355,
0.0425584763,
-0.0165306944,
-0.0096030701,
-0.0109826708,
0.0132479845,
0.0197872501,
0.0502696782,
0.0177260581,
-0.0371387303,
0.0188140739,
0.021908965,
-0.0033533778,
0.0220911428,
0.0717652217,
-0.0073825391,
-0.0562781617,
-0.0228059366,
0.0245342236,
0.0172035117,
-0.0285157822,
0.0133297257,
0.0048652454,
-0.0293252263,
0.03218567,
-0.0135339126,
0.0518022589,
0.0356931537,
0.0353600606,
0.0363273397,
-0.0367300808,
-0.0429540649,
-0.014705101,
-0.0135480836,
-0.0456929058,
-0.00882091,
0.0018599031,
-0.0072309258,
0.0264483392,
-0.0956633762,
-0.0091068679,
0.0397560745,
0.0419585146,
-0.0306318458,
-0.0185338557,
-0.0275858324,
0.0358926207,
-0.0101850694,
0.0391333438,
-0.0209906437,
0.0204217304,
-0.0264021028,
-0.0169112775,
0.03547341,
-0.0565750673,
-0.0122864516,
0.0432882942,
-0.0790238604,
-0.0376943536,
-0.0599408038,
0.0600323454,
0.0116252545,
0.0386932604,
0.0338290632,
-0.0544396862,
0.0010992819,
0.0140690794,
0.0184670258,
-0.0119247213,
0.0100747822,
0.0231786612,
-0.0087604765,
0.0142891305,
-0.0030923507,
0.0134775378,
-0.0298351422,
-0.0051744296,
-0.0394783802,
-0.0933895782,
0.0151811279,
0.0196870975,
-0.018115079,
0.0076945839,
-0.0025429991,
-0.0240070894,
0.0185922571,
-0.0166662298,
-0.0357685462,
-0.0912236795,
0.0301500671,
-0.021078309,
-0.034723673,
-0.0169089064,
-0.0173178669,
-0.0359603614,
0.0340819247,
-0.0113279857,
0.0159087479,
0.0373827592,
0.0025817752,
-0.0261126012,
-0.0084147882,
0.0137715349,
0.0127308322,
-0.0060394239,
0.0276800692,
0.0294548068,
0.1364401728,
-0.0016957616,
-0.0718287602,
-0.0054812869,
0.0517608263,
-0.0445285887,
-0.0299271476,
-0.0267679561,
0.0310781859,
0.0237298366,
0.0155502344,
0.0060375836,
-0.0177103896,
-0.0063944175,
0.0083261346,
0.0460936017,
-0.0042426167,
-0.04666356,
0.0735964254,
0.0063459757,
-0.0091416985,
0.0322074145,
0.0435407013,
-0.0129184974,
0.0140231829,
-0.0047741616,
-0.0057412232,
-0.0616301149,
-0.0198753346,
0.0270428546,
0.025404226,
0.0267765876,
0.0358384065,
0.009848942,
-0.0472241826,
-0.0132442154,
0.0257223267,
-0.0198036935,
0.0191279761,
0.0559314899,
0.0316963047,
0.0178616829,
0.0172656626,
-0.0168502592,
0.0171921607,
-0.0246379972,
-0.0117062461,
-0.0515988842,
-5.064256681e-33,
-0.0406112634,
-0.0392611399,
0.0410922244,
-0.0216527693,
-0.0270496719,
0.0046604471,
-0.0359805226,
-0.0018696089,
-0.02068373,
0.015897844,
0.014568571,
0.0000730263,
0.0066470564,
0.0510460846,
-0.0169367399,
-0.0125575755,
0.0173287354,
-0.0058235102,
-0.0070527471,
0.0207173862,
0.0170047767,
-0.0189370885,
0.020040527,
-0.0553811826,
-0.0422133654,
0.0035402367,
-0.0550167263,
0.0188059118,
0.0274626594,
0.0713369697,
-0.0302494485,
0.0182792675,
0.0114827901,
-0.0054849992,
-0.0321065448,
0.0542971827,
-0.0536287054,
0.0147828273,
0.0258896984,
0.0276179425,
-0.0620287172,
0.0126139,
-0.0051939278,
-0.0460982211,
0.041253034,
-0.0191243216,
0.0427954234,
-0.0257815607,
0.0137790628,
0.0143658677,
-0.0295887403,
0.0052910647,
-0.0525309779,
-0.077625826,
-0.0065092663,
0.0905902833,
0.0387191065,
0.0087738093,
-0.0180149227,
0.0487289056,
-0.0138322217,
-0.024857739,
0.0559589863,
0.0300731566,
-0.0007409938,
0.0597158372,
0.0420669243,
-0.0510648936,
-0.0139031997,
-0.0354806818,
-0.0304718502,
0.0784231275,
0.0357898623,
0.0957027003,
-0.0018034534,
0.0125100221,
-0.0217339899,
0.0299407225,
-0.0375413522,
0.034692198,
-0.0099025881,
0.0079864468,
0.0064335451,
0.0307216719,
-0.020798238,
-0.0020132645,
-0.0467351004,
-0.0091069657,
0.0422577076,
0.0296555497,
-0.0119513758,
0.0210935865,
0.0737705603,
-0.0377767123,
0.0082904501,
0.0070809852,
-0.0373087227,
0.0450130031,
-0.0157378595,
0.0169643946,
0.0087960158,
-0.0110635599,
0.1144563854,
0.012962224,
0.0050639086,
0.0157662109,
0.0304584391,
0.005450421,
-0.0525103547,
0.0018357182,
-0.0273048189,
0.0413942076,
-0.0479076132,
0.0292514525,
-0.0115035046,
0.0022856495,
-0.093045637,
0.0156593546,
-0.0417378657,
-0.023597464,
-0.0314264484,
-0.0746147186,
-0.0198707189,
0.0007881819,
-0.0375408828,
0.0275804996,
-0.0328155346,
-0.0654077679,
0.0044503408,
-0.058687266,
-0.0197494719,
0.0400615297,
2.242e-7,
-0.0051778648,
-0.0093531385,
0.0416193791,
0.0071950722,
0.0326862372,
0.0570845753,
-0.0222689193,
0.017068943,
0.0173559301,
-0.0369451754,
0.0291735623,
0.0163604766,
0.0506134629,
-0.0110620046,
-0.0198005922,
0.0018261709,
-0.0753990263,
-0.0502540357,
-0.0362412184,
-0.0003266197,
0.097101137,
0.0925720409,
-0.0209192112,
-0.0138251679,
0.0122530302,
-0.0518905669,
0.0739279315,
-0.0226940066,
-0.0064642229,
-0.0147833414,
0.0178127438,
-0.0101525541,
-0.0278696306,
0.0146185625,
0.0015106383,
0.0002471179,
0.0440596901,
0.037357185,
0.0000988242,
-0.0519506745,
-0.0321598984,
0.0496672206,
-0.0113089262,
-0.0461789295,
0.0767536163,
-0.0425991341,
-0.0244152974,
-0.0379732065,
-0.0245823245,
0.001357284,
0.0382610597,
-0.0455178954,
-0.057303939,
0.0277538262,
0.0606938154,
-0.0497693308,
-0.0026417519,
-0.0807293132,
-0.0235062521,
-0.0343252532,
-0.0685972795,
0.0014594676,
-0.0584058799,
-0.0296377838,
0.0207289606,
-0.0293787252,
-0.0331466421,
1.277738941e-34,
0.0219475422,
-0.0202331524,
0.0111663267,
0.0410123691,
0.0378912017,
-0.0017647506,
-0.0106069027,
-0.0171365906,
0.006669675,
-0.074755758,
-0.0087863309
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10510v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10510v1 | ChatGPT Perpetuates Gender Bias in Machine Translation and Ignores Non-Gendered Pronouns: Findings across Bengali and Five other Low-Resource Languages | 2023-05-17T18:30:05 | 2023-05-17T18:30:05 | Sourojit Ghosh, Aylin Caliskan | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL | In this multicultural age, language translation is one of the most performed
tasks, and it is becoming increasingly AI-moderated and automated. As a novel
AI system, ChatGPT claims to be proficient in such translation tasks and in
this paper, we put that claim to the test. Specifically, we examine ChatGPT's
accuracy in translating between English and languages that exclusively use
gender-neutral pronouns. We center this study around Bengali, the 7$^{th}$ most
spoken language globally, but also generalize our findings across five other
languages: Farsi, Malay, Tagalog, Thai, and Turkish. We find that ChatGPT
perpetuates gender defaults and stereotypes assigned to certain occupations
(e.g. man = doctor, woman = nurse) or actions (e.g. woman = cook, man = go to
work), as it converts gender-neutral pronouns in languages to `he' or `she'. We
also observe ChatGPT completely failing to translate the English gender-neutral
pronoun `they' into equivalent gender-neutral pronouns in other languages, as
it produces translations that are incoherent and incorrect. While it does
respect and provide appropriately gender-marked versions of Bengali words when
prompted with gender information in English, ChatGPT appears to confer a higher
respect to men than to women in the same occupation. We conclude that ChatGPT
exhibits the same gender biases which have been demonstrated for tools like
Google Translate or MS Translator, as we provide recommendations for a human
centered approach for future designers of AIs that perform language translation
to better accommodate such low-resource languages. | [
0.06384518,
0.0173343085,
-0.041936744,
0.0083198715,
-0.0434072763,
0.0017511188,
0.0494469218,
-0.0168538094,
0.0283245351,
-0.0328458659,
-0.0179698151,
-0.0627906322,
0.0637666136,
-0.0108393943,
0.0188475661,
-0.0462646261,
0.0325369649,
0.0402028076,
0.0069666537,
-0.0085297879,
0.0154099781,
0.048677925,
0.0047934023,
0.0670508966,
-0.01102072,
-0.0300433449,
0.0228449926,
0.0286562946,
-0.0126481885,
0.0154282227,
0.0303235687,
0.0379123613,
-0.0164641123,
0.03871952,
0.0000019405,
-0.0654258057,
0.0048639169,
0.0117039364,
-0.0196706019,
-0.0074967705,
0.0633574575,
-0.0008461253,
-0.033532992,
0.0327035487,
-0.0269569643,
-0.0199592579,
0.0717165247,
0.0331254862,
0.0352561176,
0.0516061969,
-0.0194539838,
0.0240612905,
-0.0610583089,
-0.0188184585,
0.024851108,
-0.0262907557,
-0.012736341,
-0.0307701509,
-0.011979619,
0.0029108832,
-0.0228518322,
0.0440837108,
-0.0248325411,
-0.0233441386,
-0.0216830689,
0.0260009635,
-0.0394702442,
-0.0796748921,
0.0227723066,
0.0425656438,
-0.0079199616,
-0.0088076768,
0.0092675276,
0.0380282626,
-0.0044944696,
-0.0250117537,
-0.0073485374,
0.0385095589,
-0.0330574177,
-0.0314190947,
0.0259642974,
-0.0050603147,
-0.0039507668,
0.0271890573,
-0.0082158884,
0.0186828878,
0.0074924203,
-0.0367871039,
0.0014746716,
0.0004622188,
0.0151996929,
-0.0510079935,
0.0273662843,
-0.0110937506,
-0.0176871996,
0.0187226534,
0.0004962639,
-0.017076917,
0.0158800893,
-0.05389167,
-0.0147286123,
0.1006585434,
-0.0032344079,
0.0223348122,
-0.0306548979,
0.0346463285,
-0.0050675832,
0.0068940278,
-0.0611080006,
-0.0287398435,
-0.0103574125,
-0.0308623817,
-0.0127781583,
-0.0189192947,
-0.0147452066,
0.0385952257,
-0.052209124,
0.0145490365,
-0.0335809402,
0.0211068019,
0.0179905742,
0.0185522698,
-0.0536520742,
-0.0098502962,
0.0174212866,
0.0521308929,
-0.0298173651,
-0.0105983643,
-0.0217993781,
-0.0996957272,
0.0064793737,
0.0060324757,
-0.0249503143,
-0.0155402515,
-0.0379119888,
0.0546268411,
-0.0400992557,
-0.0009015505,
0.0091770282,
0.0022916389,
-0.032012146,
-0.070382379,
0.0003495792,
-0.0407546088,
0.0603691749,
0.0667668581,
0.015427351,
-0.0361767896,
0.0160398483,
0.0322153009,
-0.0275611114,
0.0868501142,
0.0511565432,
0.034524601,
0.0882593617,
0.0428392366,
-0.0472036339,
0.0661779493,
0.0451525673,
0.0110179298,
0.0390103199,
0.0014557219,
0.0133872349,
0.0410507843,
0.0013858407,
0.0125421183,
0.0228576101,
0.0227891784,
-0.0135565298,
0.0542508401,
0.0498687923,
0.0365679078,
0.0095882807,
0.0316451229,
0.0376696102,
0.079284057,
-0.004951932,
0.1057704836,
0.0434955098,
0.0222046077,
0.0044889781,
0.035965275,
-0.0596496426,
0.0063940049,
-0.0133193638,
-0.0399041548,
-0.0180627424,
0.0378808752,
-0.0045878403,
-0.0205367487,
0.0180418994,
0.0007562559,
0.0453474671,
-0.0390178524,
0.0189776644,
0.0231602844,
-0.0047630039,
0.0409064107,
0.0197631791,
-0.0708425939,
-0.0105141364,
-0.0658721626,
-0.0160946175,
0.0416912287,
0.0201237891,
-0.0309825391,
0.0074069351,
-0.0303424448,
-0.0082988935,
0.036714673,
0.0919214636,
0.0167751405,
-0.0095072389,
-0.0246488303,
0.0098981513,
0.0777788758,
-0.0000529779,
0.0489675216,
0.03065346,
0.0815345868,
0.0442230366,
-0.0105274338,
-0.0700340867,
0.0112385703,
-0.002096494,
-0.0119898962,
0.0440285839,
0.0092441048,
0.015081902,
0.0129503654,
-0.0230628774,
-0.0069715041,
-0.031790372,
-0.0036476888,
-0.0308532473,
0.0871014372,
-0.0464096218,
-0.0204092618,
-0.0160735305,
-0.073581174,
-0.0632498339,
0.0180144608,
0.0002577416,
-0.0296191759,
0.048482012,
-0.0260092821,
-0.0120957168,
-0.0223789904,
0.0375301056,
0.0055166269,
0.0109851575,
-0.0131958602,
-0.0000188311,
0.0127446409,
-0.0504774675,
-0.0142588578,
-0.012564945,
0.0354484022,
-0.0462105311,
-0.0288892575,
0.0623741373,
0.0366419852,
0.0398668274,
0.0478500165,
0.0207918268,
-0.0298254825,
-0.0323396884,
-0.1129876152,
-0.0198426191,
-0.0001408065,
-0.01413434,
0.0057931072,
0.0622356199,
-0.0262155775,
0.0038553372,
-0.0189166348,
0.007529946,
0.0208254233,
0.017339522,
0.033023186,
-0.0225849338,
0.0443904735,
-0.0196385104,
0.0098729217,
-0.0397881158,
0.0225020144,
0.0429966561,
-0.0308218263,
-0.0296175554,
-0.0206414945,
-0.0272420458,
-0.0301738456,
-0.0007467662,
-0.0616476946,
0.0129012903,
0.0118196132,
0.0216528159,
0.0727169663,
0.015611806,
-0.0033938473,
0.018740816,
0.0122364191,
-0.0443650819,
-0.0133802369,
0.0213039741,
-0.0217457935,
0.0458672754,
-0.0819431469,
-0.0229421351,
-0.0113230404,
0.0297990628,
-0.0023822375,
-0.0479298905,
0.005525663,
-0.0463316254,
-0.0431968905,
-0.0347881392,
0.0190329999,
-0.0042656325,
0.0489247441,
-0.0112874275,
-0.0201354306,
0.0456914753,
0.005277839,
-0.0257559996,
-0.0331518613,
0.0380210876,
-0.0357470773,
0.0506454334,
-0.0527360439,
0.0349053442,
-0.0026210123,
-0.0269093495,
-0.0670621842,
0.0040694186,
0.024132343,
-0.035999991,
0.0086257393,
-0.076313898,
0.0072447322,
-0.0288241096,
-0.0549965836,
-0.03976053,
-0.0012105769,
0.0059765978,
0.0013410448,
0.0059459498,
-0.0132411392,
0.0032656044,
0.0258498378,
0.0030288175,
0.0147822462,
-0.0282897651,
-0.0045656264,
-0.0028359927,
-0.0263832044,
-0.0019433172,
-0.0051100762,
0.0074984874,
0.009953036,
0.006598515,
0.023496354,
-0.0280030034,
-0.0119155049,
0.0120022604,
-0.0218033623,
0.0358692296,
-0.0095281536,
-0.0381064601,
-0.034797024,
0.0442583896,
-0.028725177,
0.0136759412,
0.0986696407,
0.0052864645,
-0.0665837973,
-0.0054438575,
-0.0396333933,
0.0140744327,
-0.000230714,
0.0269497838,
-0.0747850984,
0.0081527894,
0.037077345,
0.0084981043,
-0.0312054344,
-0.0306201521,
-0.0456899963,
-0.1056673676,
0.0111083323,
0.0307754409,
-0.0633486137,
-0.0609874316,
0.0170415044,
-0.0189018399,
-0.0290447101,
0.0484387353,
-0.0009262447,
0.0033511887,
-0.004447679,
-0.024250092,
-0.0308524054,
-0.0161435194,
0.0271614715,
-0.0616788827,
0.0585278645,
0.0555425026,
0.062268991,
0.0016841026,
0.0409270301,
0.0373399295,
0.0079442589,
0.0017658776,
-0.0291040484,
0.0152479811,
-0.0388137661,
-0.0224279445,
-0.0140040861,
0.0130538205,
0.00398609,
0.0389500707,
0.0570145473,
0.0076576741,
0.0004056025,
-0.0333538055,
0.001649978,
-0.0158681758,
0.035301663,
0.0621898286,
0.0011311639,
-0.0389826857,
-0.0543679781,
-0.0604626201,
-0.0108552296,
0.022627173,
-0.0642025992,
-0.0168618616,
-0.0431163944,
-0.0654710531,
-0.0561820157,
-0.0960566029,
0.0164047405,
-0.0079463292,
0.0195961744,
-0.0602984056,
0.0252805632,
0.0433076918,
-0.0292128548,
-0.0248333178,
-0.0383709297,
0.030350294,
0.0112910233,
-0.002672055,
-0.0164611172,
-0.0332192481,
0.0166030787,
0.021180233,
-0.0068609039,
-0.0343179293,
0.0431327336,
0.0416094139,
0.0266634226,
0.0283650495,
-0.0287191123,
-0.0257508345,
-0.0107430369,
0.0443527773,
-0.0337437578,
0.0187875815,
0.0315077156,
0.0423761904,
-0.011134794,
0.0578256957,
-0.0012702087,
0.0005361215,
-0.0291898195,
-0.0143142361,
-0.0045763538,
-0.0528160483,
0.0283484291,
0.0238239784,
-0.0338131115,
-0.065308854,
0.0325539112,
-0.0300364047,
-0.0244669244,
-0.0132908821,
-0.0355404429,
-0.0096394587,
-0.0374869034,
0.0419157892,
0.0284631532,
0.018460108,
-0.0271040164,
-0.0567959361,
-0.0124673229,
0.0199256204,
0.0004542062,
0.0011587015,
0.0738490373,
0.0070561161,
0.0186437145,
0.0064298692,
0.0023413622,
-0.0148055954,
0.0234971065,
-0.0095928572,
0.0606622249,
0.0080915587,
0.0107587036,
0.022580687,
0.0312376879,
0.0006760563,
-0.017745005,
0.0128978789,
0.0313090757,
0.0612558387,
-0.0274421405,
0.0796570778,
-0.0371727943,
-0.0077600521,
0.0023012981,
0.0118605373,
0.0120191416,
0.0242413357,
-0.0271679051,
-0.0302688107,
-0.0100463424,
0.005319552,
0.0464499146,
-0.0066696675,
0.0326781571,
0.0122818835,
-0.0648156032,
-0.0356886685,
-0.0420697704,
-0.0245497599,
-0.0607190952,
0.0174100995,
-0.0100726718,
-0.0771472603,
-0.0486955307,
-0.0361271277,
-0.0285474192,
0.0302575752,
-0.0249043424,
0.0025630428,
0.1006295159,
-0.0164827611,
-0.0251292419,
-0.0571834818,
0.0244633611,
-0.0327687301,
0.0139924027,
-0.0386691056,
-6.018038838e-33,
-0.0297051556,
-0.02184771,
-0.0086004874,
-0.0033191377,
-0.0233076252,
-0.0063685179,
-0.0367325097,
-0.010381883,
0.0098947017,
0.0327591561,
-0.0568605028,
0.0299110375,
0.0197444037,
-0.0470337644,
0.049961362,
0.0068836347,
0.0647155419,
0.0133298067,
-0.0490465015,
-0.0122374976,
0.0129248295,
0.0057317833,
0.054659605,
-0.0937747434,
0.0811474323,
-0.0352031626,
-0.0553676225,
-0.0057201688,
-0.0201029461,
-0.0246419851,
-0.0013506549,
0.0472797304,
0.0202739388,
0.0048747449,
0.0032141749,
0.0651293844,
-0.1032236665,
-0.0157299917,
0.0104800146,
0.062068183,
0.0122162942,
-0.0429742746,
0.0197396073,
-0.0323015191,
-0.0500685684,
0.0202731956,
0.0188210681,
0.0073202699,
0.0575539395,
0.0334733538,
-0.0750361905,
0.0023373037,
-0.0375023857,
-0.0123353843,
-0.0020818736,
0.047809042,
-0.011640273,
-0.0744930208,
-0.0883303359,
0.0375356339,
-0.0285085682,
-0.0052007958,
0.050224755,
0.0137957912,
-0.000777487,
-0.0266758744,
0.0864543319,
0.0329010673,
-0.0103185643,
-0.0347259566,
0.009134789,
-0.0425351486,
0.0071764896,
0.048214674,
0.0202261657,
-0.0588793233,
-0.0109777618,
0.004768583,
0.0365069211,
0.0439164601,
0.0043158261,
0.0036354049,
-0.084317714,
-0.0569456257,
0.0036728778,
-0.0655895472,
-0.0110912593,
-0.0546597205,
0.0111864414,
-0.0145430015,
-0.0357845314,
0.0091390228,
0.027710868,
-0.0563896112,
0.0192807335,
-0.0458818376,
-0.043541979,
-0.0312924944,
0.0193398446,
0.0276591592,
-0.0358729661,
-0.0271421839,
-0.0010278808,
0.0602883957,
0.0237662569,
0.031726595,
0.0045907535,
0.0156513192,
-0.0545717515,
-0.0158907063,
-0.0439853519,
0.009908041,
-0.0149500724,
0.0071766023,
0.0237932205,
0.0222252291,
-0.0135889221,
-0.0267197099,
0.0692016706,
0.0534134209,
-0.062814869,
0.010574433,
-0.0234517772,
-0.012501834,
-0.0598206222,
0.0246720221,
-0.0453287289,
0.0198616739,
0.0433993563,
-0.0470844358,
-0.0160247181,
-0.0514008701,
2.722e-7,
-0.0037349327,
0.0743798837,
0.0111839594,
0.023954019,
0.0137331877,
0.0321668386,
0.0100083696,
0.0399944596,
0.0339777246,
0.053525351,
0.0333217569,
0.0417158343,
0.0399054848,
0.0436450504,
-0.0775432289,
-0.0231598187,
-0.0476248078,
0.0224756543,
-0.0053907968,
0.0352210142,
0.0142861661,
0.0577627346,
0.0240373891,
0.0082173953,
-0.0380953737,
-0.0181162395,
0.0547633395,
0.00890614,
0.0109655792,
0.029764181,
0.041109208,
0.0274891742,
-0.0052777408,
0.0066229226,
0.0157168936,
-0.0299384762,
0.0692802668,
0.0565316156,
-0.0367098339,
0.0350621641,
0.0086538587,
-0.0144340638,
-0.0044248346,
-0.0724290833,
0.0671987757,
-0.0012882188,
-0.0253039375,
-0.015562837,
0.0133434106,
0.0228902157,
0.0696641579,
-0.0122727454,
-0.050436426,
0.0273293331,
0.022666458,
-0.0025145672,
-0.0146608576,
-0.0358204469,
-0.0271991212,
-0.0227563567,
0.0094573125,
-0.0563344732,
0.0080382461,
0.0543067232,
0.015090866,
-0.0324577279,
0.016927328,
2.039211784e-34,
0.0191558599,
0.0272547435,
0.0330370031,
-0.0260339379,
0.0462638587,
-0.00436462,
0.0317039303,
0.0131672742,
0.0430604778,
0.0272218902,
-0.0385976434
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10496v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10496v1 | Incorporating Attribution Importance for Improving Faithfulness Metrics | 2023-05-17T18:05:49 | 2023-05-17T18:05:49 | Zhixue Zhao, Nikolaos Aletras | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Feature attribution methods (FAs) are popular approaches for providing
insights into the model reasoning process of making predictions. The more
faithful a FA is, the more accurately it reflects which parts of the input are
more important for the prediction. Widely used faithfulness metrics, such as
sufficiency and comprehensiveness use a hard erasure criterion, i.e. entirely
removing or retaining the top most important tokens ranked by a given FA and
observing the changes in predictive likelihood. However, this hard criterion
ignores the importance of each individual token, treating them all equally for
computing sufficiency and comprehensiveness. In this paper, we propose a simple
yet effective soft erasure criterion. Instead of entirely removing or retaining
tokens from the input, we randomly mask parts of the token vector
representations proportionately to their FA importance. Extensive experiments
across various natural language processing tasks and different FAs show that
our soft-sufficiency and soft-comprehensiveness metrics consistently prefer
more faithful explanations compared to hard sufficiency and comprehensiveness.
Our code: https://github.com/casszhao/SoftFaith | [
0.0354125015,
0.0422150865,
-0.0120977499,
0.0144532602,
-0.0390579849,
0.0312072858,
0.012962386,
-0.0128069846,
-0.024418395,
-0.0333542712,
0.041010689,
-0.0228862409,
0.0406481549,
0.0578178167,
0.0166429728,
-0.0268156454,
0.0440802053,
-0.0000394125,
0.0204429142,
0.0046350509,
0.0158647839,
-0.0081645409,
0.0204587169,
0.0901382565,
-0.0351984166,
0.0239118226,
0.0221341606,
-0.0075946539,
0.0228468031,
0.0097019123,
-0.0166225005,
0.0465115309,
-0.0207546726,
0.0148360366,
0.0000021015,
-0.056936197,
-0.0392982773,
0.0334645808,
-0.0193347782,
0.0088253515,
-0.0094140517,
-0.0152122285,
0.0213120952,
-0.0268916655,
0.0081352973,
0.0442630872,
0.0781609565,
0.0777470469,
0.0313294418,
0.0345092118,
-0.0125902565,
-0.0215989146,
0.0083288094,
0.0126980431,
0.0313568413,
-0.027364349,
0.0030393312,
-0.0399943627,
-0.0575424209,
-0.0198694542,
-0.0062561538,
0.0370186009,
0.0258176513,
-0.0016289178,
0.0704403818,
0.0217590928,
-0.0555517115,
-0.011665863,
0.0234783012,
0.0262879822,
-0.0097322473,
-0.0393983722,
0.013753497,
-0.0258567259,
-0.0161630847,
0.0254276916,
-0.0422470532,
-0.0237715393,
0.016191218,
0.0154324574,
-0.0007198104,
-0.0205342378,
0.0341626294,
0.0077070547,
-0.0137703409,
0.0442791544,
-0.0012502417,
-0.0145042054,
-0.0490906574,
0.0008157815,
-0.0824858621,
-0.0458107963,
0.0169452541,
-0.0023368334,
-0.0013050021,
-0.0092716701,
-0.0068351086,
-0.0237950925,
0.0412219949,
-0.0540605858,
0.0247159954,
0.021509612,
-0.0450639129,
0.0353446268,
-0.068771027,
0.0828793198,
0.0254178457,
0.0243264325,
-0.0187755674,
-0.02886164,
-0.0570452884,
-0.0244407002,
0.0088401856,
0.0593914166,
0.046229776,
-0.0197659023,
-0.0412046202,
-0.0313334167,
-0.0602175817,
0.0043175886,
0.0255058594,
0.0452162884,
-0.0321870856,
0.0287101474,
-0.0149850119,
-0.0046129976,
-0.0776943192,
0.0262232181,
-0.0252240729,
-0.0326832086,
-0.0277042389,
0.0281079318,
0.0005820514,
-0.0441011861,
0.0053857211,
0.0740038082,
0.036658071,
-0.0350567736,
-0.0194517747,
-0.0697903112,
-0.0445765257,
-0.0475089923,
-0.028921796,
-0.036202658,
-0.0051183407,
0.0094056875,
0.0095000025,
-0.0376519673,
-0.0236969125,
-0.0073301792,
-0.026497744,
0.0738855898,
0.0300968848,
-0.0091796611,
-0.0328660011,
-0.0214340053,
-0.0309445988,
0.01897946,
0.0296104699,
0.0669706538,
0.0211387742,
-0.0105671044,
0.0164752454,
-0.0207018014,
0.010544735,
-0.0164983794,
-0.0313413106,
-0.0108874524,
0.0056297034,
-0.033253476,
0.036505349,
0.0278061107,
-0.0242835302,
-0.0074381134,
0.0473068766,
0.0233320966,
0.0402464867,
0.0477880985,
0.0418908112,
-0.0140834767,
-0.0190283954,
0.0367026404,
-0.0908750817,
0.0468199439,
-0.0406954885,
-0.0053455438,
0.0122067519,
-0.0023737401,
-0.0036250132,
-0.0435483716,
-0.0148846516,
-0.0044554994,
0.0121461945,
0.0042740069,
0.0489321165,
0.0037114448,
-0.0065818098,
0.0718987212,
0.0130186127,
-0.0305779725,
-0.0029378624,
-0.0724375919,
0.0279817078,
0.0271077603,
0.0323678628,
-0.0271038376,
-0.0057352297,
0.0170495678,
-0.0063706278,
-0.0550898835,
0.0247429106,
-0.0083622709,
0.0492874049,
-0.0286814086,
-0.0564968884,
0.0021977865,
0.0449445657,
0.0268953498,
-0.0160689335,
-0.0053264378,
0.0373320356,
-0.0430012047,
-0.0248411261,
0.0378570296,
0.0451239571,
-0.0190553423,
0.0176708922,
0.0185661819,
0.0405228622,
0.0280860569,
-0.0066130073,
0.0251225177,
0.0201501325,
-0.0124151586,
0.002809152,
-0.0019143621,
-0.0661628395,
0.0110584749,
0.0220264643,
-0.0314602219,
-0.0006992476,
0.0508918986,
-0.0348841771,
-0.0390535742,
0.0383806229,
-0.0611769482,
0.0097322883,
-0.0463258475,
0.0047005787,
-0.0443566702,
0.0307735465,
-0.0174803082,
0.0515296124,
-0.0044282554,
0.0289110988,
0.008468328,
-0.0657917038,
0.0262895785,
-0.0287954621,
-0.0120193036,
-0.0104849525,
-0.033522699,
-0.0087912027,
0.036353644,
-0.0147945527,
-0.0457986444,
-0.0064512556,
-0.0805689245,
-0.0352602601,
-0.026621446,
0.0007802538,
-0.007321578,
0.0239802804,
0.0159494709,
-0.0234220307,
0.0023171958,
-0.0631651729,
-0.0246917848,
0.0115209389,
0.005780343,
0.0160727575,
-0.0367860533,
-0.0153887188,
-0.0180095248,
-0.0286735389,
0.0516483113,
0.0231013875,
-0.0112514403,
-0.0419169702,
-0.0047817403,
-0.0425595976,
-0.0252866764,
0.0081361644,
-0.0199074633,
-0.0026894489,
0.0206247382,
-0.0237797443,
0.0409514457,
-0.0030133831,
0.0135453735,
0.0564903133,
-0.0238733552,
-0.054911457,
-0.0028469728,
-0.0430782437,
0.0148057221,
0.0043915459,
-0.0541309007,
-0.0095002465,
0.0214614123,
0.0252400134,
-0.030764766,
-0.0750483498,
0.0194193572,
-0.0165605322,
-0.04534062,
-0.0142199527,
-0.0284715462,
-0.0082099102,
0.02755538,
-0.0320086665,
-0.0890873969,
0.0902198702,
-0.0561343543,
0.0203203261,
-0.00583386,
-0.005935776,
-0.0526461303,
0.0573361702,
0.0006711145,
0.0190673694,
0.0494571477,
-0.0252201874,
-0.0155571075,
-0.0181421861,
0.041065909,
-0.0134928776,
0.0508082882,
-0.0378512144,
0.0048251809,
0.0346756764,
0.0128705706,
-0.0013283106,
-0.0418525562,
0.006549011,
0.0461678095,
-0.0068986863,
-0.0187089108,
-0.0260899495,
0.0163047537,
0.0357544795,
-0.0017234747,
0.0011076074,
0.0018175089,
0.0004657202,
-0.0090906825,
0.0367243513,
0.0535750948,
0.0275886878,
-0.0129426019,
-0.008011763,
0.0208348744,
0.0575925186,
0.0308071934,
-0.0211540982,
0.0300543141,
-0.0097086448,
-0.0153848585,
-0.0314985886,
0.0084195668,
0.0956364721,
-0.0596185178,
0.0009080566,
0.1236842796,
0.0170113053,
-0.0329584181,
0.0340082459,
-0.0150825065,
0.0408487469,
0.0238362178,
-0.0022525948,
-0.0264338441,
-0.0458870381,
0.020156987,
0.0422394238,
-0.0122303413,
-0.0488755144,
0.019981809,
-0.0455071181,
0.0375388823,
-0.0110709192,
-0.0241955239,
-0.0578845255,
-0.0869514942,
0.0361621305,
-0.0625689551,
-0.005074814,
-0.0420559533,
0.0303280931,
0.0082328459,
0.0134088611,
-0.0381799378,
-0.0177700408,
0.0517514348,
-0.0482581593,
0.0185484923,
0.097047098,
0.0408333093,
-0.0074497168,
-0.0110108759,
-0.02549899,
-0.0032343366,
0.0314737074,
-0.0126318503,
0.0435011387,
0.0189562198,
-0.001683464,
-0.0136850607,
0.0187354665,
0.0183028691,
-0.0434121713,
-0.0176517572,
0.0743836015,
-0.0226231515,
-0.0542518087,
-0.0206956565,
-0.0477385968,
-0.0104236249,
0.0985659361,
0.0688937828,
-0.0011042034,
-0.0365026966,
-0.0144382417,
0.005270266,
0.0035039273,
-0.0498393103,
-0.0126630599,
-0.0034059603,
-0.0400340892,
-0.0560384281,
-0.0213405211,
0.0276515987,
0.0177271422,
-0.0107984096,
0.0195461549,
-0.0385033451,
-0.0259972513,
-0.0359529071,
0.0539284982,
-0.0201965291,
0.0378274843,
-0.0129950158,
-0.0010777103,
0.0109554129,
-0.0192760136,
-0.0385402851,
0.0414222032,
-0.0314212255,
-0.0198730398,
0.0373743847,
0.0247874092,
0.0253684949,
0.0535555594,
-0.0141800838,
-0.0654044747,
0.0819835216,
0.0302605033,
-0.0413688347,
0.0255828798,
0.043195039,
-0.0717755184,
-0.0040136455,
0.0577376522,
-0.0397350974,
-0.0154291317,
0.0287048034,
0.0521099195,
0.053407412,
0.0104260528,
0.0074289879,
0.0299566817,
0.0885562822,
-0.0056752199,
-0.0335725173,
-0.0130311716,
0.0031588881,
0.0379928946,
-0.0177982822,
-0.0294652097,
0.048232913,
-0.0015298305,
0.0430446863,
-0.013228788,
-0.0335827619,
-0.0061342521,
0.0180963483,
-0.0199993216,
0.0168944076,
0.0004109206,
0.0068099592,
0.006566416,
0.0176471192,
-0.0014907466,
0.0100155817,
0.0013699125,
0.0162125081,
-0.0162896179,
-0.0071321367,
0.0034623898,
0.0302738324,
-0.0535376146,
0.0211031977,
-0.0826148316,
-0.014460668,
-0.0651321933,
-0.000941016,
-0.0077058827,
-0.0608134121,
0.0528643541,
-0.0166899394,
0.0067353905,
-0.0307767317,
0.0599817336,
0.035507936,
-0.010451653,
-0.0330434367,
0.0270514097,
-0.0451062284,
-0.0090608383,
0.0552595071,
-0.0203810614,
0.0445958264,
-0.0595712028,
-0.0415700674,
-0.0122927409,
-0.038332101,
0.0279319417,
0.0480996892,
-0.0401125625,
-0.0095255757,
-0.0683605149,
-0.089803949,
0.0423932187,
-0.0349907987,
0.0103422841,
0.0131490882,
0.0244496502,
0.0667977408,
-0.0034459583,
0.0092860851,
-0.0235633105,
-0.0520200729,
0.0373050086,
0.0047656642,
0.0103277843,
-6.678629929e-33,
0.0036915275,
-0.0198568907,
-0.0366305336,
-0.0196770485,
-0.0052878018,
0.0372460634,
-0.0238998514,
-0.0250740517,
-0.0008146885,
0.005870109,
0.0035531258,
0.0204345733,
0.0208836887,
-0.0087167025,
0.0153398421,
-0.0324471854,
0.0476991273,
0.0334288664,
-0.0247872584,
0.0171230752,
0.0380504318,
0.0130957803,
0.088631779,
-0.083357431,
0.0800566003,
0.0446418114,
-0.0280034412,
0.0042779054,
-0.0274371095,
0.0849331915,
-0.0313705057,
0.0386003815,
0.030215133,
-0.059412498,
-0.0348704197,
-0.0138911549,
-0.04956102,
-0.0507100634,
0.0356136262,
-0.0123672104,
-0.0075704735,
-0.027573185,
0.0508321822,
-0.0012279194,
-0.01252901,
-0.0287590493,
0.057754349,
-0.0085821059,
0.0001842389,
-0.0244385526,
-0.0424588621,
0.0464727432,
-0.0383382626,
-0.0044114888,
0.0330102257,
0.0078431778,
0.0177254584,
0.0221540201,
-0.0079410132,
0.0054736128,
0.0050493218,
0.0318233259,
0.0671404749,
-0.0078938622,
0.01897314,
0.0933539793,
0.0528257936,
-0.0132346759,
-0.0326173492,
-0.0324804373,
0.0307217594,
0.0548611432,
0.0804526955,
0.0312410928,
0.084642984,
0.0151047735,
-0.0539632849,
0.0489541478,
-0.0175668262,
0.0741145164,
0.0307799391,
0.0373993292,
-0.0498590767,
-0.0263124406,
-0.0644965097,
0.0068441131,
-0.0585114211,
-0.0524362698,
0.0210721083,
0.0013648103,
-0.0835738182,
0.0464994386,
0.027356768,
-0.047418654,
-0.0098697897,
0.0208597574,
-0.0065446156,
0.0047441367,
0.0271896981,
-0.0082075661,
-0.0092866709,
-0.0167940389,
0.0281057227,
-0.0108691826,
0.0559915304,
-0.0225402787,
0.0500943847,
0.0360322855,
-0.0342971012,
-0.0087076603,
-0.0145044001,
-0.0481196865,
-0.0202045664,
-0.0174900778,
0.0166709851,
0.0340259224,
-0.0250923503,
0.0108421519,
0.0204430092,
0.0225300267,
-0.0485466532,
0.0337188914,
0.0042541325,
0.0208646506,
-0.0229800716,
-0.0508241393,
-0.0383339338,
-0.0504676513,
0.0429169051,
0.0030157182,
-0.0449581109,
0.0224690288,
2.901e-7,
0.0417456292,
0.01749596,
0.0158052146,
-0.0260241702,
-0.0123401238,
0.0547284447,
0.0051541035,
0.0193389226,
-0.0010220495,
-0.0229072571,
0.0237123035,
0.0247403812,
0.025757486,
0.0379491933,
-0.0774175301,
0.0120812571,
-0.0665283129,
-0.0387088582,
-0.0269639846,
0.0406834446,
0.0381422937,
0.1002459973,
0.0363501348,
-0.0206300691,
-0.0039136317,
-0.0312550291,
0.0029255257,
-0.0344562791,
0.0249399748,
0.0073880409,
0.0419312902,
-0.0341142155,
0.0214819182,
0.0199091304,
-0.0218030084,
-0.0198778864,
0.0430602692,
0.0209570285,
-0.0199894868,
-0.0574573539,
-0.0386520326,
-0.0070117959,
0.0600865819,
-0.0478341728,
0.0829923004,
-0.0046296301,
-0.0441421047,
-0.0635479018,
-0.0091222227,
0.0027186126,
0.0363399759,
0.0024507928,
-0.0124300746,
0.0637212768,
-0.0094443457,
0.0119668962,
-0.0411177501,
-0.0942265168,
-0.0614743158,
-0.0234374795,
-0.0395461135,
-0.0429092348,
-0.0476213209,
-0.0057456796,
0.0550831854,
-0.1026591957,
0.010342095,
2.864034129e-34,
0.0224616006,
0.0204271786,
0.0226320438,
0.0391460843,
0.0524890721,
-0.0023830081,
0.0121311815,
0.0326004513,
0.0149203576,
-0.0591554232,
-0.0307922941
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10429v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10429v4 | DoReMi: Optimizing Data Mixtures Speeds Up Language Model Pretraining | 2023-05-17T17:58:13 | 2023-11-21T02:01:53 | Sang Michael Xie, Hieu Pham, Xuanyi Dong, Nan Du, Hanxiao Liu, Yifeng Lu, Percy Liang, Quoc V. Le, Tengyu Ma, Adams Wei Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The mixture proportions of pretraining data domains (e.g., Wikipedia, books,
web text) greatly affect language model (LM) performance. In this paper, we
propose Domain Reweighting with Minimax Optimization (DoReMi), which first
trains a small proxy model using group distributionally robust optimization
(Group DRO) over domains to produce domain weights (mixture proportions)
without knowledge of downstream tasks. We then resample a dataset with these
domain weights and train a larger, full-sized model. In our experiments, we use
DoReMi on a 280M-parameter proxy model to set the domain weights for training
an 8B-parameter model (30x larger) more efficiently. On The Pile, DoReMi
improves perplexity across all domains, even when it downweights a domain.
DoReMi improves average few-shot downstream accuracy by 6.5% points over a
baseline model trained using The Pile's default domain weights and reaches the
baseline accuracy with 2.6x fewer training steps. On the GLaM dataset, DoReMi,
which has no knowledge of downstream tasks, even matches the performance of
using domain weights tuned on downstream tasks. | [
0.0282041188,
0.0505585596,
-0.0041886433,
0.0143254763,
0.0048154509,
0.0241928566,
0.0132229542,
0.0166218784,
-0.0279674269,
-0.0625023916,
-0.0616677701,
-0.0573285148,
0.0046406835,
-0.0361372493,
0.0287496373,
-0.0768709108,
0.0182792377,
-0.0280849822,
-0.0181939416,
-0.0276720803,
-0.0041958597,
-0.0039936854,
-0.0363028236,
0.0018712142,
0.0136670414,
0.0093278531,
0.0041754884,
0.0429028273,
-0.0057468479,
-0.0177769773,
0.0253154468,
0.0924615934,
0.0338068046,
0.0009129959,
0.0000023197,
-0.0326783918,
0.0150383683,
-0.012199128,
-0.0401246175,
0.0302013624,
0.0648873672,
-0.0005489803,
0.0000620758,
0.0283421893,
0.0095239747,
-0.0548137948,
0.0389272831,
0.0550911203,
0.0215439983,
0.0989161506,
-0.0069200634,
-0.0478002429,
0.0002368742,
-0.0456009768,
0.0027507124,
-0.0435682088,
0.0358509384,
0.0621731877,
0.0012177804,
-0.0038576282,
-0.0284780581,
0.0171299782,
0.0080295363,
0.0299693644,
-0.0042080488,
0.0217318106,
-0.0059777531,
-0.0265332107,
0.0172158554,
0.0865428299,
-0.0226163901,
-0.0187436305,
-0.0069988929,
-0.0190543868,
0.000681021,
0.0353054069,
-0.00370596,
-0.0077014696,
-0.0003374758,
0.0187222101,
-0.0195670836,
-0.0083510689,
0.0537485592,
0.01292028,
-0.050000336,
0.0284376722,
0.0250466447,
0.015118462,
0.0102124186,
0.00944323,
-0.063511394,
-0.0365349948,
0.0057108202,
0.0092920195,
-0.0188948344,
0.0181795042,
-0.0618546158,
-0.0836858824,
0.0181513522,
-0.0182727277,
0.0357126482,
0.0440442152,
-0.0127665978,
0.036349155,
0.0394771695,
0.0214456879,
-0.0241583101,
-0.0041889315,
-0.0391735248,
-0.0053232033,
-0.0470784865,
0.0097783525,
-0.0299754683,
0.0322100893,
-0.0447180495,
-0.0022533571,
-0.036233712,
0.0172083471,
0.0237391852,
-0.0773983598,
0.0493400283,
0.0102838771,
-0.0570378229,
-0.0294111092,
0.0120246802,
0.0606505275,
-0.0335359871,
0.0590539686,
0.0109641738,
-0.0309682582,
0.0024606977,
0.0064628702,
0.0055917264,
-0.0462138429,
0.0176654216,
0.055387076,
-0.0099887624,
-0.0475728661,
-0.081596911,
0.0144126024,
-0.0146886474,
-0.0685559362,
-0.0122054918,
-0.0694669709,
0.0196113903,
0.0181255247,
0.0179071128,
-0.0770562738,
-0.0102034062,
-0.0134726157,
-0.0382649451,
0.0895021707,
-0.0124789234,
-0.0042822375,
0.0410428941,
0.0221479088,
-0.0469131432,
0.1275884062,
0.0104791336,
-0.0152015863,
0.0214382801,
0.0186557472,
-0.0073256413,
0.0117212562,
0.0359885804,
0.0516297333,
-0.0109005896,
-0.0180464517,
-0.015448357,
-0.0025383281,
0.0694709122,
0.0286950693,
-0.0519017763,
-0.0152828945,
0.0708340183,
0.0151114296,
0.036130935,
0.005566048,
-0.0004807425,
0.0188174061,
0.000184599,
0.0043514031,
-0.0553880259,
-0.0129713649,
-0.0263218023,
0.0141852805,
0.0145884231,
0.0586464629,
-0.0536169782,
0.0099021755,
-0.0192072913,
-0.0178138297,
0.0199572723,
0.0189731419,
0.0760198459,
0.0071419282,
-0.0364811867,
0.0650882348,
0.0603912547,
-0.0338064544,
0.0112425676,
-0.022214083,
-0.0305976067,
0.0161677208,
0.0037841583,
-0.02443536,
-0.0074553764,
0.0065324334,
0.0720690787,
0.0292923767,
0.0186375231,
0.0178096257,
0.0456273779,
-0.0491628498,
-0.0201938692,
0.0156875961,
0.0404398739,
0.0419920571,
0.0364095531,
0.0346801244,
0.0195627492,
-0.0652140975,
-0.0074206134,
0.0414067172,
-0.0354876816,
-0.0023313158,
0.0135911573,
0.011620841,
0.0096378997,
0.0143975439,
-0.0385539494,
-0.0016956093,
0.0082100658,
-0.0198773313,
-0.0267257877,
-0.0262409821,
-0.0224250536,
-0.0507880077,
0.0724829957,
-0.0130352369,
0.024037702,
0.0298664626,
-0.0214332994,
-0.0401868708,
0.0283586979,
0.0002358592,
0.0513536558,
-0.0443759039,
0.0338251032,
-0.0261320174,
0.0270651411,
-0.0495825745,
0.0629895777,
-0.003055779,
0.0052261767,
-0.0118788956,
-0.0007763208,
0.0405630544,
-0.0101874629,
-0.0092692897,
-0.0125438171,
0.0008945042,
0.0461336337,
0.0119441589,
-0.0056703766,
-0.0339571089,
-0.0256822649,
-0.0859696046,
-0.0104113817,
-0.0612939671,
0.0180964079,
0.0258941725,
0.031321805,
-0.0198773257,
-0.0040142275,
0.023238685,
-0.0042681377,
-0.0535127372,
0.0250564832,
-0.0027845169,
0.0149202757,
-0.0098769525,
-0.0072501544,
-0.0242508855,
0.0100429347,
0.0323913656,
-0.0118115023,
-0.0001473445,
-0.0553124622,
0.0637437403,
-0.0277516134,
0.0294276904,
-0.0117089255,
-0.0465394296,
-0.0230119396,
0.017450761,
0.0572340973,
0.0644642562,
0.0121910172,
-0.0055973139,
0.0468672104,
0.0094959242,
-0.0324015059,
0.0048343707,
-0.0216740854,
-0.0218127687,
-0.0390511341,
0.0082930252,
-0.0214109868,
0.0632172972,
-0.0121752396,
-0.0290889889,
-0.0491239242,
-0.003633522,
-0.0248305798,
-0.0168319549,
-0.0307015795,
0.0007346485,
-0.016500039,
0.0238783695,
-0.0270363539,
-0.0323026255,
0.0786155611,
-0.0164301787,
-0.0034015281,
-0.0667446181,
-0.0181772411,
-0.0354756527,
0.002496849,
-0.0219476726,
0.0026477845,
0.0132033182,
-0.0172323957,
-0.0475018471,
0.0183048658,
0.0431668907,
-0.0206286237,
0.0467068329,
-0.0132872639,
0.0373389609,
-0.0332965888,
-0.0512086898,
-0.0245569386,
-0.0331526846,
-0.0131182196,
0.0009596593,
0.0189429577,
-0.041995991,
-0.0598363653,
0.0259269588,
0.0146803772,
0.0390968584,
-0.0375750177,
0.0014476662,
0.0078596193,
0.0277604144,
0.0437382497,
0.0025468888,
0.0049837902,
-0.0514193103,
0.0064196121,
0.0000210968,
0.058108978,
-0.0630264804,
-0.0213813875,
0.0214866996,
0.0278231706,
0.0000544801,
-0.0212285258,
0.0106645497,
0.0423446931,
-0.0125186192,
0.0186023396,
0.1037537828,
0.0005859918,
-0.0990823284,
-0.0058268984,
0.0039612525,
0.0568592437,
0.0319769196,
0.0401315466,
-0.0674072579,
-0.0438753441,
-0.0006410121,
0.0242277347,
0.0463694781,
-0.0195227098,
-0.0171987955,
-0.0900297463,
0.0040196711,
0.0134698208,
-0.0522295572,
-0.0117839426,
-0.0379242077,
-0.0170486029,
-0.0141031388,
0.0595746376,
0.0142801395,
-0.0156970937,
-0.0211795364,
0.0267062746,
0.043663878,
-0.0809061676,
0.0127185555,
-0.0688719675,
0.0455702543,
0.0274984073,
-0.0172440428,
-0.0078196963,
-0.013089044,
0.0793981701,
-0.0552204438,
-0.0228321534,
0.0085219769,
0.0610000752,
-0.0249486174,
-0.0020290581,
0.0183977615,
0.0178634934,
-0.0633667484,
-0.0245419312,
-0.0196656454,
0.0387903713,
-0.0021812788,
0.0025439092,
-0.0111012245,
-0.0302152913,
0.0322780721,
0.0613131635,
0.0303617008,
-0.0390959717,
0.0318237543,
-0.0079103122,
-0.0167457685,
-0.0405064039,
0.0070548314,
0.0234969612,
-0.0090858201,
-0.035124816,
-0.0504606329,
0.0008636361,
0.0252398755,
0.0584785603,
0.0055698724,
0.0324442685,
-0.0079621486,
0.0197633542,
-0.0628179908,
0.0473835133,
-0.0324954949,
0.0047757365,
-0.0958135948,
-0.0355595127,
0.0590537712,
-0.0105615715,
-0.0084703639,
-0.0041356878,
-0.1059636325,
-0.0919451341,
0.0020986826,
0.0220965222,
0.0267109312,
0.0532312132,
-0.0076020733,
-0.0949371755,
0.0461116061,
0.0379888378,
-0.0475064032,
0.0538557656,
0.0161858462,
-0.0625695735,
0.0074937767,
0.0252997,
-0.0652725771,
0.0133264996,
0.0310274344,
0.0016930297,
-0.0064177085,
0.0034334136,
-0.0104878135,
0.0013165026,
0.0498319119,
-0.025528403,
-0.0305654183,
-0.0284591075,
0.0376972668,
-0.0171318613,
0.0190005731,
-0.0190940909,
-0.002566739,
0.0257537272,
-0.0174047854,
-0.0124706877,
0.0115655465,
0.0048591183,
0.0321964845,
-0.0078854607,
0.0025056254,
-0.0468178466,
-0.0198530536,
0.0534715131,
0.0189407244,
0.0023293537,
0.0056592324,
0.029956175,
0.0241369326,
-0.0307901073,
0.0186728202,
0.0218167324,
0.0084722601,
-0.0594250225,
0.0117216064,
-0.0480468199,
-0.0244737752,
-0.0340975933,
0.002218998,
0.0709409118,
-0.0013885325,
0.063871637,
0.0035208103,
-0.0121254865,
-0.0550986715,
0.0133265853,
-0.0307912882,
0.0055699931,
0.0284340587,
0.0200922303,
-0.0084603643,
0.0458431914,
0.1054872796,
0.0576565079,
0.040845152,
0.0167293884,
0.0183241982,
-0.0194638539,
-0.0170098022,
-0.0108348709,
0.0659974962,
-0.0400923118,
0.0066065704,
-0.0517802089,
-0.0895676315,
-0.0147505924,
-0.0227181744,
-0.0210149996,
0.0116517041,
0.0297681596,
0.0414112322,
-0.0416858047,
-0.00991101,
-0.0390760601,
-0.018822154,
0.0002269234,
-0.0076801046,
0.0184938572,
-7.308263641e-33,
-0.0237542074,
-0.0066022836,
0.001823679,
-0.0090100076,
-0.0030611537,
0.002632258,
-0.0181902684,
0.0287985019,
-0.0294010285,
0.0190297682,
-0.0308807977,
0.0259438958,
0.0235841945,
0.0203106515,
-0.0296121947,
0.0162408315,
0.0324596427,
-0.0116872378,
-0.0193656348,
-0.0037259629,
0.001866603,
0.0581640638,
0.0399819054,
-0.0353552811,
-0.0465865694,
0.0031938532,
-0.0057479967,
0.0113561451,
0.0348897874,
0.0580538884,
-0.0181991942,
0.0491893813,
0.0163858254,
-0.0275017917,
-0.0457655787,
-0.0408384241,
-0.0946694985,
-0.0413610041,
0.0175285507,
0.0170966256,
0.0184838139,
-0.0121724466,
0.0360809006,
0.0170112438,
-0.0012931393,
-0.0228575841,
0.0321002007,
-0.0113084186,
-0.0358918644,
-0.0100398473,
-0.0381582268,
0.0260340963,
0.0269324668,
0.0030980157,
0.0295186993,
-0.0095576243,
0.0055078408,
0.0347820483,
-0.0491180718,
0.0167859234,
0.0521652065,
0.0613452792,
0.0360196419,
0.0774470046,
0.0089740949,
0.0389255881,
0.0200247429,
0.0155686792,
0.0071181781,
-0.0243484732,
0.0869735852,
0.0117380982,
-0.0038061517,
0.0646687895,
0.0553935356,
-0.0434589498,
-0.0927374214,
0.0264994949,
-0.0057346569,
0.002730289,
0.0158677492,
0.0446806327,
-0.0322007127,
-0.0418193005,
-0.0367192551,
-0.0058081853,
-0.0498452745,
-0.0374829322,
0.0034577185,
0.0482775308,
-0.043902725,
-0.0191653669,
0.0362727083,
-0.0408639945,
-0.0542254187,
0.0264859386,
-0.0092773139,
0.0107177431,
-0.0018031729,
0.0107459016,
-0.0403606147,
-0.0379265547,
0.0245952681,
0.0343079232,
0.0024969955,
-0.0170164369,
0.0293051656,
0.0161562562,
-0.0538914129,
-0.0042135455,
-0.0189394671,
-0.0051293843,
0.0319794007,
0.0872843862,
0.0297019612,
0.0160368383,
-0.0162107907,
0.0491254106,
0.0409811251,
-0.0434817374,
-0.021394711,
0.032178551,
0.0315197967,
0.037830051,
-0.0325330384,
-0.0288439225,
-0.0006032803,
-0.0196148623,
0.0805879086,
-0.0459488556,
-0.047485169,
-0.0263793953,
2.988e-7,
0.086805895,
0.0392162018,
0.0138236918,
-0.0055455817,
-0.0207322054,
0.0283664502,
-0.0296847578,
0.0012785359,
0.0094263349,
-0.0187354758,
0.0261213034,
0.0285742972,
0.029019611,
0.0011374186,
-0.1242108345,
-0.0040960223,
0.0163150802,
0.0233362392,
-0.0271852277,
-0.0273558348,
-0.0184305068,
0.1204681918,
0.02771708,
-0.0274392311,
-0.0036866304,
-0.0313039087,
0.0727052316,
-0.04050209,
0.0150661552,
0.027081525,
0.0045404709,
0.035834793,
-0.0057670036,
0.038679596,
-0.0305096898,
0.0339298062,
-0.0381079316,
0.0544617549,
-0.0423095748,
-0.0274536144,
0.009541465,
0.0084691765,
-0.0142570063,
-0.0367447734,
0.0436931662,
-0.057055667,
-0.0052475897,
-0.0124436598,
-0.0264527481,
-0.024846809,
0.0347363986,
-0.0342819393,
-0.0207572691,
0.0347687751,
0.0079201441,
0.0022840404,
-0.0201101322,
-0.0878707692,
-0.0184113774,
0.0092139263,
-0.0615544431,
-0.0380196646,
-0.0199928656,
-0.031269107,
0.0599359348,
-0.0424106494,
0.015762696,
3.009929509e-34,
0.0607975312,
-0.0133871799,
-0.0052829036,
0.063738659,
0.0061315396,
-0.0263824016,
-0.0307895504,
-0.0042599267,
-0.0220950525,
-0.0732652396,
-0.0036150815
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10427v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10427v1 | Accelerating Transformer Inference for Translation via Parallel Decoding | 2023-05-17T17:57:34 | 2023-05-17T17:57:34 | Andrea Santilli, Silvio Severino, Emilian Postolache, Valentino Maiorca, Michele Mancusi, Riccardo Marin, Emanuele Rodolà | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Autoregressive decoding limits the efficiency of transformers for Machine
Translation (MT). The community proposed specific network architectures and
learning-based methods to solve this issue, which are expensive and require
changes to the MT model, trading inference speed at the cost of the translation
quality. In this paper, we propose to address the problem from the point of
view of decoding algorithms, as a less explored but rather compelling
direction. We propose to reframe the standard greedy autoregressive decoding of
MT with a parallel formulation leveraging Jacobi and Gauss-Seidel fixed-point
iteration methods for fast inference. This formulation allows to speed up
existing models without training or modifications while retaining translation
quality. We present three parallel decoding algorithms and test them on
different languages and models showing how the parallelization introduces a
speedup up to 38% w.r.t. the standard autoregressive decoding and nearly 2x
when scaling the method on parallel resources. Finally, we introduce a decoding
dependency graph visualizer (DDGviz) that let us see how the model has learned
the conditional dependence between tokens and inspect the decoding procedure. | [
0.0130748525,
0.0988117903,
-0.0073755179,
0.038787052,
-0.026360441,
0.0351627395,
0.0275549274,
-0.0078113461,
-0.066842258,
0.0340259671,
0.0162901171,
-0.0020328285,
0.056556657,
-0.0045593856,
-0.0121887922,
-0.0161958914,
0.0127985356,
-0.0178315789,
-0.0330336504,
-0.0362301618,
-0.0120868245,
0.0270520672,
-0.0264774598,
0.0470861979,
-0.0278098658,
-0.0133591155,
0.01615813,
0.0262143444,
0.0284877345,
-0.0170782954,
-0.0442097336,
0.0230829697,
-0.0025538877,
0.0639402494,
0.0000022757,
-0.0174295641,
-0.0423387587,
-0.0004710372,
0.0040885108,
0.02800541,
-0.0074833357,
-0.0765653476,
-0.0172197986,
0.0284857955,
-0.0106319105,
-0.0674869344,
0.0801373646,
0.0189314093,
0.016370846,
0.0385028422,
-0.0231494829,
-0.0620086305,
-0.0154484035,
-0.056375701,
-0.0678966418,
-0.0557526238,
-0.0397904441,
0.0028923345,
-0.0429023094,
-0.0020070965,
-0.0396805815,
0.0855937302,
0.0403305888,
0.0190396421,
-0.0183933731,
0.0203645658,
0.0173091441,
-0.0250300206,
-0.0201177374,
0.037288256,
-0.0372770056,
-0.0340481699,
-0.0412628874,
-0.0103451302,
-0.0207520761,
0.0109862247,
-0.0205725972,
0.0208694208,
-0.0385401137,
0.0345359445,
0.0289457981,
0.0256792326,
0.0394308195,
-0.0127580361,
-0.0838986784,
0.0212170258,
0.0273314808,
0.0050114873,
-0.0203321464,
0.0369058773,
-0.0147366645,
-0.0037916414,
0.0639301091,
-0.0091432091,
-0.017750388,
0.0009563794,
0.0028944393,
-0.0785325989,
-0.0402413271,
0.0097336583,
0.0136111332,
0.0603888147,
-0.0051751588,
0.0037708983,
-0.0236913953,
0.0397802629,
-0.0780229643,
-0.005495118,
-0.0551250353,
-0.0207098331,
0.0010428926,
-0.004951146,
-0.0769454464,
0.0014609493,
-0.0071709557,
-0.0028801893,
-0.0325391926,
0.008307131,
0.012495405,
-0.0306614339,
0.047423441,
-0.0080614043,
-0.0747187212,
-0.0251730848,
0.0159878992,
0.0823394284,
-0.0378723182,
-0.0200336631,
-0.0438437648,
-0.0648142919,
-0.0510341227,
-0.0013050631,
0.0128341559,
-0.0243747644,
-0.0011712458,
0.0677120015,
-0.0223729871,
-0.0329278708,
0.0056646597,
0.0017250566,
-0.0134355249,
-0.0257587861,
0.0266912486,
-0.0653137863,
0.0274248514,
0.052278392,
0.0390111357,
0.0015841253,
-0.0048943493,
-0.0024336744,
-0.0161190275,
0.0648809224,
0.0246573426,
-0.0281755868,
0.0193292126,
-0.0221255254,
-0.0194558352,
0.0692666695,
0.0198957343,
0.0483180247,
-0.022438759,
-0.0093615884,
0.014774804,
0.0617071688,
0.0029454855,
0.0062932423,
-0.0077649439,
-0.0590912551,
-0.0056458111,
0.0267641544,
0.0101492424,
0.0457481109,
-0.0310287308,
0.0105109885,
0.0400370583,
0.0411667563,
0.0399608575,
0.0448645689,
0.0380814523,
-0.0020393222,
-0.0068483423,
0.0288561955,
0.0125397267,
0.0575838685,
0.0511253215,
0.0023691559,
-0.0203718226,
0.0756251886,
-0.0086830482,
-0.0322977528,
0.0075381408,
-0.0118711721,
-0.0000095577,
-0.0352523923,
0.0797786191,
0.0600346439,
-0.0753974095,
0.0765195861,
0.0065051788,
-0.0374476276,
-0.0211882964,
-0.026673615,
-0.0341743752,
0.0204379931,
0.0576641113,
0.0331622101,
-0.022235794,
-0.0017430654,
-0.028611796,
0.0318197198,
0.0210662987,
0.0295126494,
0.0221124999,
-0.0374010354,
-0.0189457349,
0.0569573827,
0.0111928247,
0.0591480248,
0.0109758209,
0.0090630073,
0.0447510257,
-0.0241893977,
-0.0176775679,
0.0099570015,
0.0082895849,
0.0006307841,
0.0705249608,
0.050972417,
0.0114056049,
0.0258736089,
-0.0162686948,
0.0138627328,
0.0272590164,
-0.0796547011,
-0.0215106048,
0.0786079764,
-0.0601138324,
-0.045364935,
0.0063893311,
-0.0775414258,
-0.0325629525,
0.0486368872,
-0.0229126588,
-0.0387698524,
0.0055157854,
-0.0766627416,
0.0531363264,
-0.0230400153,
0.0240089241,
0.010518969,
0.0408559367,
-0.005776458,
0.0139481397,
-0.024174653,
0.0048896614,
0.0202792045,
-0.0026790649,
0.0135280136,
-0.0072678314,
-0.016078135,
0.0308579337,
0.0047390098,
-0.0258916281,
0.0169601925,
-0.022293698,
0.0300992671,
-0.017981831,
-0.0413774513,
-0.0271263756,
-0.0350243412,
0.0302848816,
0.0010018962,
0.0734106079,
0.0383069813,
-0.0258018207,
0.017626442,
0.0467548333,
0.0025413111,
-0.0043023028,
-0.0111354729,
-0.0112196524,
-0.0351041406,
0.0107237259,
-0.0276286677,
-0.0005034761,
0.0659404024,
0.0331880189,
-0.0157462265,
-0.0682915524,
-0.0240121353,
0.006828689,
0.0201856922,
-0.0023967172,
-0.0675891116,
0.0421657674,
-0.0295163114,
0.0470330603,
0.0149715934,
0.0077171163,
0.004379408,
-0.0071754307,
-0.0009557143,
-0.0382512622,
0.0108767394,
-0.0662747547,
-0.0120333135,
-0.0359165482,
-0.0456281602,
0.00823755,
0.1010783464,
-0.0061841323,
0.006445358,
-0.0708350837,
-0.0399023779,
0.0027974281,
-0.0019533064,
0.0113464175,
0.0277396049,
0.0151302703,
0.0069810348,
0.0068592313,
-0.0707071424,
0.0818182975,
-0.0465218909,
0.0009302453,
-0.052241534,
0.0016310016,
-0.0261874292,
0.0751454383,
0.0043409569,
0.0137610352,
-0.02859083,
-0.0668724105,
0.0021478916,
0.1060343012,
0.0275932048,
-0.0201847795,
0.0359742604,
-0.0376745015,
-0.0023267467,
-0.0066899173,
-0.0261443667,
-0.028054269,
0.0202822983,
-0.0437131226,
-0.0273738876,
0.083017461,
-0.057702031,
-0.0515178815,
0.0194898378,
-0.0170683376,
0.0492172912,
-0.0007635537,
-0.0035623668,
-0.0079336371,
0.0267426576,
0.0084710345,
-0.0313611887,
0.0255676415,
-0.0541742146,
0.0252753384,
0.0223118197,
0.0268234871,
-0.0001566422,
-0.0559583455,
-0.041020073,
0.0347294845,
0.0162162147,
0.0270688999,
-0.0297944304,
-0.0088736573,
-0.0217867512,
-0.0273214355,
0.0955140889,
0.0106611792,
-0.079245232,
0.0131539721,
0.0224754792,
0.0398375019,
0.0081344247,
-0.0089035593,
-0.1056978256,
-0.01985275,
0.0133756315,
0.0184561424,
0.0246999059,
0.0063149128,
-0.0148488665,
-0.1066085473,
0.0167762898,
0.0243233219,
-0.0519563667,
-0.0527241118,
-0.0289035011,
-0.0636444092,
-0.0474803634,
0.0194540434,
0.017413307,
0.0151632549,
0.0089768795,
0.0143773397,
0.0099635795,
-0.0199319776,
-0.0281584244,
-0.0513232946,
-0.004152766,
0.0187208764,
0.0051016281,
-0.0089289723,
-0.0414434858,
0.0265575945,
0.0042584389,
0.0167224724,
-0.0395149067,
0.0215121079,
-0.0095270947,
-0.0398053154,
-0.0111877788,
0.002308486,
-0.019401025,
0.0167948566,
-0.0162368473,
0.0357597433,
-0.0237310696,
-0.0086134421,
0.0222211126,
-0.0236527734,
-0.0222710483,
0.0262282323,
0.0135582034,
-0.0589700975,
-0.0182785653,
-0.0397032015,
0.0143197766,
-0.074294202,
-0.0130498838,
0.0048127915,
0.0180854574,
-0.098907657,
-0.0538871177,
-0.0113961194,
0.0263269711,
0.0394541249,
0.0044215359,
-0.012842223,
0.0338818803,
-0.0001235466,
-0.0571875572,
0.0066512581,
0.0123570235,
0.0045423177,
-0.0510282181,
0.0366322622,
0.0156603623,
-0.0238824226,
0.00359923,
0.0610969365,
-0.1461686641,
-0.0584994331,
0.0247556251,
0.044177331,
0.0146055836,
0.0518940426,
-0.0314737745,
-0.0211611595,
-0.0075831469,
0.018628912,
-0.0444440357,
-0.0142666074,
0.0115861036,
-0.0308311507,
-0.0033986268,
0.0243073478,
0.0070684799,
0.015971275,
-0.0294444114,
0.0451035388,
-0.0226418115,
-0.0365724489,
0.0355162285,
-0.0025460641,
0.0561176725,
-0.0166396201,
-0.002446241,
-0.0257283337,
0.0667687207,
-0.0047239359,
0.0097954767,
-0.0440059565,
0.0181245115,
0.0420854054,
-0.0099947657,
-0.0143402861,
0.0034965847,
0.0564843602,
-0.0196086317,
0.0145943649,
-0.0027426954,
-0.0217731241,
-0.0075231548,
0.0365277678,
-0.0147746168,
0.0007532149,
-0.0048995498,
0.0335524827,
0.0101700556,
-0.0112707317,
0.0239608362,
0.0168893225,
0.0206923112,
-0.0395308696,
-0.0208594874,
-0.0439095721,
-0.0383643247,
0.0013841823,
-0.0201957002,
0.069734849,
-0.0140055632,
0.1110552922,
-0.0371019468,
0.0167836919,
0.010025667,
0.0342388712,
-0.017264761,
0.0221312642,
0.0046922998,
-0.0071017337,
0.0051968587,
0.0154244499,
0.0551591702,
-0.0270056967,
0.0116720516,
-0.035756465,
-0.0246252473,
-0.0254503898,
-0.0321490169,
-0.0336349644,
-0.0410000235,
-0.0296889804,
-0.009531307,
-0.0049849423,
-0.0727545694,
-0.001239804,
0.0028183609,
0.0140282102,
-0.0187986698,
0.0053472258,
0.0743565336,
-0.0031656742,
-0.0301711671,
-0.0003994507,
0.0411955714,
-0.0023065833,
-0.0331306681,
-0.0208547525,
-6.850939034e-33,
-0.0032214206,
-0.0515991338,
-0.0157447662,
-0.0120287994,
0.0018553758,
0.0080437073,
-0.0064858203,
-0.015378831,
0.0030159063,
0.0239843447,
0.006243533,
0.0360267088,
0.0310072266,
0.0235014763,
0.0165346749,
0.0394597165,
0.0809323564,
0.017925052,
-0.0078939209,
0.0056578652,
0.0418695807,
0.0625316054,
0.0687796772,
-0.0348564051,
-0.0068059266,
-0.0326769575,
-0.0125122508,
0.0169717185,
-0.0309619326,
0.0139660062,
0.0058297059,
-0.000697519,
0.0135162883,
-0.0649467185,
-0.0136043159,
-0.0224162601,
-0.1426679939,
0.0333475769,
-0.0001941922,
0.086714074,
-0.0195465554,
-0.0160789192,
0.0260460936,
-0.0055832192,
0.0081321876,
-0.0524918437,
-0.0041004806,
0.0031925645,
-0.0156674795,
-0.0259265751,
-0.0466244034,
0.0340404585,
-0.0238533486,
0.0061581656,
0.0734712407,
0.0654803365,
-0.0062641432,
0.0026279038,
-0.0484747551,
0.0112167839,
-0.0029000584,
0.0539655052,
0.0775440112,
0.0212026425,
-0.0001571754,
-0.0255042445,
0.0410268344,
-0.0346160159,
-0.0058218474,
0.0061742612,
0.0385646969,
0.0029428101,
0.0527484156,
-0.0343999788,
0.0479400642,
-0.0237328093,
-0.0588491373,
0.0031459937,
-0.0209206976,
0.0606240034,
0.0255195238,
0.0138962483,
-0.0216387045,
-0.000268377,
-0.0124784075,
-0.0202778149,
-0.0350924879,
-0.0142635591,
-0.0215400718,
0.0203665383,
-0.0517397746,
0.0100821471,
0.0563233905,
-0.0159527101,
0.0109653967,
0.0247178935,
-0.0060045351,
0.0168790538,
-0.0423298143,
0.0081752213,
0.0210575592,
-0.0116629591,
-0.0176776126,
0.0200178586,
0.0291156918,
0.0015424337,
0.0447135381,
0.0172423273,
-0.0555382669,
-0.0105242487,
-0.0681261718,
-0.0112018874,
-0.0060581528,
0.02994317,
0.0622982569,
-0.0019883919,
-0.0079652919,
0.0100760981,
0.030113671,
0.0449979939,
-0.0279381499,
0.043590527,
0.0164047796,
0.024106944,
-0.057926435,
-0.0140939802,
-0.0258253273,
0.038087815,
0.0429095067,
-0.0715421885,
-0.0661534369,
0.0429259203,
2.994e-7,
0.0717671588,
0.0591879748,
0.0647158921,
0.0446571372,
-0.0033118557,
-0.0089623854,
0.0076156505,
0.0112229176,
0.0236673076,
0.0444153585,
0.0467989594,
0.0229890905,
0.0867068395,
0.0307073686,
-0.0665417612,
-0.0137465652,
-0.0440635905,
0.0340949036,
-0.0252913311,
-0.0235734228,
0.0458918475,
0.0794600323,
-0.0229066387,
0.0095157363,
0.0155013371,
0.0076308516,
0.0474714078,
0.0081941411,
0.0026735221,
-0.0042346073,
0.0031672725,
0.000934643,
-0.0359813496,
-0.0282929372,
-0.0197275821,
0.0175250657,
0.0230831169,
0.0212927479,
0.0122455396,
-0.0204314031,
0.0349142328,
-0.0008964658,
-0.026699882,
-0.0294709913,
0.0336532407,
-0.0639322549,
0.0129897129,
0.0185457673,
0.0040004072,
0.0334747881,
0.0339379571,
-0.0073914588,
-0.0125722196,
0.0435311496,
0.0433712788,
-0.0150965862,
-0.0130018694,
-0.0486182123,
-0.0287253596,
-0.0226979256,
-0.0497492775,
-0.0217198916,
-0.0444581471,
-0.0188769344,
0.0250184629,
0.0257395357,
-0.017914746,
2.696934623e-34,
0.0452483036,
-0.022542445,
0.0074702003,
0.0436844751,
0.0444576554,
-0.0502942838,
-0.0022657942,
0.0387824029,
-0.0244886838,
-0.0777260736,
-0.0546195172
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10425v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10425v1 | SLiC-HF: Sequence Likelihood Calibration with Human Feedback | 2023-05-17T17:57:10 | 2023-05-17T17:57:10 | Yao Zhao, Rishabh Joshi, Tianqi Liu, Misha Khalman, Mohammad Saleh, Peter J. Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Learning from human feedback has been shown to be effective at aligning
language models with human preferences. Past work has often relied on
Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF), which optimizes the language
model using reward scores assigned from a reward model trained on human
preference data. In this work we show how the recently introduced Sequence
Likelihood Calibration (SLiC), can also be used to effectively learn from human
preferences (SLiC-HF). Furthermore, we demonstrate this can be done with human
feedback data collected for a different model, similar to off-policy, offline
RL data. Automatic and human evaluation experiments on the TL;DR summarization
task show that SLiC-HF significantly improves supervised fine-tuning baselines.
Furthermore, SLiC-HF presents a competitive alternative to the PPO RLHF
implementation used in past work while being much simpler to implement, easier
to tune and more computationally efficient in practice. | [
0.0499112308,
0.0626954436,
0.010928615,
-0.0092652906,
-0.0247965716,
0.021650197,
-0.0317941047,
-0.0081634307,
-0.0322171226,
-0.0481250845,
-0.0305655822,
-0.0487199575,
0.0488843843,
0.0121894814,
0.0163681321,
-0.0917129964,
0.0179334544,
-0.0189045258,
0.0238437057,
0.0008204842,
0.0243548118,
0.018539479,
-0.007402868,
0.0658852011,
0.0501774624,
0.0219138376,
0.003296105,
-0.0111387102,
0.0547663346,
-0.0105157793,
0.0043223985,
0.0896798298,
0.0176301114,
0.0141874058,
0.0000018759,
-0.0524425171,
-0.0350941271,
-0.018205801,
-0.004137842,
0.0039522368,
0.0542809069,
0.0282046683,
-0.0001412732,
0.0237608645,
-0.0110350158,
0.0137482034,
0.0427091271,
0.0113771036,
0.0428563021,
0.0812014937,
0.0232619774,
-0.0080634067,
-0.0095205316,
-0.0518868752,
0.0196738057,
-0.0046289903,
0.0114968549,
0.0102043338,
0.020498313,
-0.030284388,
-0.0095296893,
0.0165074375,
-0.0019763722,
0.009082892,
-0.0031252166,
0.0224729385,
-0.0115192607,
-0.0180524252,
-0.011282037,
0.0818505213,
-0.01647567,
-0.0280537792,
0.0080220625,
-0.0249749608,
0.0196064878,
-0.0157582313,
-0.0325334743,
0.0269031562,
0.0091261994,
0.0341209322,
-0.0010418766,
-0.014969334,
0.0208075549,
0.0084303357,
-0.006567644,
0.063877888,
0.0052547734,
-0.0300691538,
-0.0096249357,
0.012848773,
-0.0174167342,
-0.0607757494,
0.0275364984,
0.0074744336,
-0.0656865612,
0.0158797614,
-0.0665006712,
-0.0153746493,
0.0213029906,
-0.0458064675,
0.0426626019,
0.026133148,
0.0265889764,
0.0072127078,
0.0197658222,
0.0643922314,
0.0226401966,
0.0195887871,
-0.0623875596,
0.021338487,
-0.0448841192,
0.0144153498,
-0.008220654,
0.027925685,
-0.0364721566,
-0.0081006726,
-0.0865857154,
0.0142805204,
-0.0019993593,
0.0141953854,
-0.0019672858,
0.0158190206,
-0.0556073412,
0.0003665336,
-0.0406448767,
0.0535407551,
-0.0310113691,
-0.0103956591,
0.0366711654,
0.0103704426,
0.0143699208,
0.0145078348,
0.0209138375,
-0.0014128246,
-0.0040792935,
0.0357438549,
0.0024411106,
-0.0503257513,
0.0063585597,
-0.0300798863,
-0.0365658812,
-0.0494310521,
-0.0553325973,
-0.0808275864,
-0.0089724436,
-0.0103808548,
-0.0105631426,
-0.046675574,
0.0106739448,
0.0019185788,
-0.0371402577,
0.0639865249,
-0.0064709634,
-0.0325914882,
-0.0075923107,
-0.0215626117,
0.0136698531,
0.0650875717,
0.0659785569,
0.0516788699,
0.0276340451,
0.0115851723,
-0.0110861668,
0.0404150374,
0.0070908428,
0.005620697,
-0.0418976657,
-0.0088350028,
-0.0074191266,
0.0512426533,
0.0600007735,
0.0311676133,
-0.0167220365,
0.0179179274,
0.0677852631,
0.0495571792,
0.0226123855,
-0.0255887657,
0.0194631927,
0.058572311,
-0.019150747,
0.0420549214,
-0.0298780147,
0.0227607246,
-0.0468094796,
0.0583719425,
0.076540947,
0.0170510374,
0.0033969979,
-0.0637964383,
-0.0093671847,
-0.008766898,
0.0100141913,
0.0289871339,
0.0434052646,
-0.009588806,
-0.0619952902,
0.0213306416,
0.0657140389,
-0.0419619977,
0.0282703135,
-0.0276837777,
0.0419028886,
0.0928546041,
0.0515601039,
-0.0052319104,
-0.0272441972,
-0.0430417955,
-0.0488499179,
0.0409819894,
0.0488412715,
-0.0280308891,
-0.0325690545,
-0.0526364967,
-0.0727793798,
0.0456893407,
0.0000237618,
0.0350905433,
0.0062696058,
-0.0243323743,
0.0391777307,
0.0298495144,
-0.0709413737,
0.0288936887,
-0.0031833774,
-0.007108497,
0.0042747073,
0.0114430487,
0.0286422726,
0.0238489844,
-0.0077606156,
0.0106523884,
0.0188223403,
0.0057162973,
0.0025581068,
-0.0068921638,
-0.0459740199,
-0.0285672937,
0.0587591939,
-0.0313229822,
0.0089593297,
0.041949451,
-0.0192575715,
-0.042831663,
-0.0109764328,
-0.0187136754,
0.0112723103,
-0.0399694517,
0.0260368083,
-0.0214389432,
0.0016588102,
-0.0726135373,
0.0296570994,
-0.0147026535,
0.0448567271,
0.0165596213,
-0.022668995,
-0.0286363177,
-0.0620725937,
-0.0169981085,
0.0307632629,
0.0028944858,
0.0354255252,
0.0703943372,
0.0558798835,
-0.0496557429,
0.0003225308,
-0.07223396,
-0.0038533241,
-0.0365644954,
0.0129602617,
0.0374470279,
0.0063635046,
-0.0157450996,
-0.0270966012,
-0.0391604044,
-0.0116047859,
-0.0075554126,
0.0051807878,
0.0345286354,
0.0069678021,
-0.0099947881,
-0.0789136961,
-0.0149446027,
0.0008691495,
0.0021981522,
0.0050900667,
0.0030531194,
-0.0632628277,
0.0181829054,
-0.0327961482,
-0.0092053711,
0.0081350189,
-0.0319108702,
0.0152659155,
0.0008162978,
0.0340439454,
0.0665217042,
0.0459648408,
0.0069430661,
0.0571424626,
0.0184826814,
-0.0613348,
-0.0070071211,
-0.0508615114,
-0.0096437726,
-0.0368928909,
0.0018927894,
0.0225508194,
0.0844324604,
0.0025781784,
0.0255091786,
-0.0747053474,
-0.0128381411,
-0.0316270702,
-0.0276938938,
-0.046747949,
0.0166117158,
-0.0777468234,
0.0404854342,
-0.0048755212,
-0.0529453345,
0.1060581729,
-0.0301500093,
0.018591281,
-0.0769827738,
-0.0136786113,
-0.0187172927,
-0.0006690901,
0.0116703371,
0.0261465292,
0.0064038918,
-0.0193257648,
-0.0707203597,
-0.0416562408,
0.0301922616,
-0.0465814807,
0.0559085906,
-0.0492362753,
-0.0111168213,
-0.0096442625,
-0.0290755481,
-0.0336696841,
-0.0611714683,
-0.0364360809,
-0.0010070204,
0.0111655239,
-0.0421687774,
-0.0318080485,
0.0134914126,
0.0266576875,
0.0485851765,
-0.0206998363,
0.0010176072,
-0.0037986732,
0.0195482373,
0.1239907295,
0.0241808631,
0.0098669017,
-0.0195221882,
-0.0213971287,
0.0079066157,
0.0480490215,
0.0278530028,
0.014013744,
0.0134597067,
0.0302790068,
-0.0659218207,
0.0134352874,
0.070646584,
0.0427231118,
-0.0286434703,
-0.0119379098,
0.137561515,
0.0266573243,
-0.0760790035,
-0.0098943328,
0.0190269966,
0.0604068562,
0.0100090532,
0.0239650086,
-0.0521104932,
-0.0364535339,
0.0099406056,
0.069907628,
-0.0033198716,
-0.0044097002,
-0.0045967051,
-0.0971545354,
0.0030205483,
0.0174684301,
-0.0691344962,
-0.0288644508,
-0.0416439287,
0.0188254677,
-0.0233078171,
0.0301738996,
0.0264256857,
-0.0118496586,
0.0166161507,
0.0312146153,
-0.0131067336,
-0.0452383161,
0.0152924871,
-0.033679232,
0.0562967323,
0.1198004857,
0.0183148067,
0.0089171557,
-0.0060944669,
0.0103661614,
0.0034299388,
-0.0342276655,
-0.0085371248,
0.0225063264,
-0.0179400239,
0.0069517717,
-0.0185571276,
0.0600380413,
-0.0143653871,
0.0219364464,
-0.0265788827,
0.0405738428,
0.0142869223,
0.010321456,
0.0044229343,
0.042658709,
0.0139202634,
0.0573721379,
0.0498493165,
-0.0725577176,
-0.0060644089,
-0.0487071425,
-0.0361166,
-0.0713196993,
-0.038023632,
-0.0113998177,
-0.0142349899,
-0.0019845781,
-0.0915822387,
-0.0573055111,
0.0024986295,
-0.0017893059,
0.0058263936,
0.0124301864,
0.0100824693,
-0.0136134075,
-0.0250229742,
0.0172215253,
-0.0393816531,
0.005228586,
-0.0874338076,
-0.0217710137,
0.0178511925,
-0.0269382279,
-0.023028506,
0.0167406369,
-0.0839555934,
-0.0737608075,
-0.003640244,
0.0674414858,
0.0202319399,
0.0693942383,
0.0010245088,
-0.0488423295,
0.0458094999,
0.043745365,
-0.0069355685,
0.0103426725,
0.0022038594,
0.0371677689,
-0.0312458426,
0.042095013,
-0.0400961451,
-0.0238575134,
-0.0057633817,
0.0611027703,
0.0197456889,
-0.0794644579,
0.0301138964,
0.0059048459,
0.0486394092,
-0.0515728705,
-0.0801463723,
-0.0227946099,
0.0023371149,
-0.0059083132,
-0.036666844,
-0.0164276585,
-0.0235940423,
0.0166882742,
-0.0263422914,
-0.0023325721,
-0.0141433906,
-0.039358981,
0.0304813441,
-0.0523738153,
0.0210114345,
0.019977808,
0.0117995301,
0.0243299101,
0.0129658263,
0.0022692331,
0.0072265468,
0.0063362932,
0.0616298802,
0.0005300274,
0.0486663841,
0.0118440995,
0.0022375309,
-0.004658143,
0.0386404954,
-0.055650536,
-0.0005908636,
-0.055457823,
0.0146426866,
0.0709410757,
-0.0170808434,
0.0668131784,
-0.0014162607,
-0.0110945348,
-0.0266594682,
0.0414569266,
-0.0507150218,
0.0174347199,
0.0080133351,
0.0086522279,
-0.0173636898,
0.0144143058,
0.0773159787,
0.0255953204,
0.0126615539,
-0.0149838068,
-0.0042899945,
-0.0412998535,
-0.015080452,
-0.0203875061,
0.0317228399,
-0.0501637422,
-0.0271466784,
-0.0490352623,
-0.0456927121,
-0.0169599894,
0.0285662487,
0.01197246,
0.0076544159,
0.0495568141,
0.0236045066,
-0.0733468533,
0.0079031428,
-0.065281041,
-0.0063321646,
0.0143355234,
-0.0284200516,
-0.0489827767,
-6.231615876e-33,
-0.0531739816,
-0.0335177369,
-0.0070591141,
0.0118130939,
-0.0158349033,
-0.0173571911,
-0.0212107934,
0.0273166504,
0.0358228385,
-0.0174528006,
-0.0131302625,
-0.0267077945,
0.0181763098,
0.0157664698,
0.0258092936,
0.0054849391,
0.0361576527,
-0.0247550625,
-0.0567286648,
0.010932547,
0.0378077812,
0.0145796528,
0.0693198591,
-0.0168868117,
0.0506706834,
0.0167470891,
-0.0219594501,
-0.0093591232,
0.0102909897,
0.06840083,
0.0091394,
0.019882448,
-0.0028056153,
-0.03759633,
-0.0456224233,
0.0055755512,
-0.0691207647,
-0.0265608225,
0.0245847777,
-0.0125439959,
-0.0211709701,
-0.0133490786,
0.0523972139,
-0.0161531474,
-0.0368566476,
-0.0022008959,
0.0365600139,
-0.0329210237,
-0.0489789657,
-0.0072834217,
-0.0448862091,
0.0257513467,
-0.0076457281,
-0.016219059,
0.0367926545,
0.0486427769,
-0.0156638119,
0.028867254,
-0.0120249176,
0.0422655419,
0.0265815202,
0.0562664121,
0.0916664749,
0.0540524349,
0.00122248,
0.030297203,
-0.0071673901,
-0.0272499043,
0.021220142,
-0.0086433403,
0.0534649678,
-0.0111517599,
0.0146758985,
0.0537144691,
0.0299308412,
0.0097717084,
0.0006299654,
0.0720709711,
-0.017289374,
0.0218787044,
0.034506809,
0.032840386,
-0.0541728884,
-0.0140022133,
-0.0703168139,
-0.0358887874,
-0.0278505739,
-0.0326033421,
0.0061637871,
0.0208500549,
-0.0372684896,
-0.0179605838,
0.032007806,
-0.0249541122,
-0.0109624723,
0.0031108945,
-0.0177193508,
0.0043430743,
0.0114327548,
-0.0047402661,
-0.0705185384,
0.002932094,
0.0037203413,
-0.0056174463,
-0.0109693957,
-0.0137083344,
0.0333867446,
0.0025065592,
-0.0347158834,
0.0399713479,
-0.0051337411,
0.0016198662,
-0.0009158616,
0.0327507071,
0.0410805866,
-0.0242317449,
-0.0125774192,
0.060640052,
0.0073536453,
-0.0321496055,
-0.0149524454,
-0.0239138063,
-0.002788859,
0.0184411723,
-0.0335058272,
0.0155142769,
-0.0144310603,
0.0232044011,
0.0117601873,
-0.0069931271,
-0.017660059,
-0.0057204328,
2.513e-7,
0.0218810774,
0.0620896854,
0.0431490354,
-0.0121794743,
-0.0349321105,
0.0485427566,
-0.0140366303,
0.0142767904,
0.0296425596,
0.0143991737,
0.0562437288,
-0.0097502386,
0.0599284247,
-0.0131389834,
-0.0932313427,
-0.034251865,
-0.0627243817,
0.0324810147,
-0.0333452821,
-0.0421468429,
0.0367867425,
0.1004190221,
0.0422409475,
-0.0156631842,
0.0288639273,
0.0105216801,
0.0398441814,
-0.0563664027,
-0.0304592475,
0.0007428959,
0.0063960208,
-0.0080020456,
-0.025152754,
-0.025034219,
-0.0268848743,
0.0055860188,
0.0060488936,
0.0523049906,
0.0103618931,
-0.0541574433,
0.0009774702,
0.0199749507,
0.03747233,
-0.066879347,
0.035496898,
-0.0299826041,
0.0066928188,
-0.0361406989,
-0.0082394518,
-0.0199534167,
0.0239706803,
-0.0498947129,
-0.0172359142,
0.0250746254,
0.0077924845,
0.0269912034,
-0.0145944105,
-0.0547601804,
-0.0524439476,
0.0239075217,
-0.0044312128,
-0.0197099298,
-0.0378612466,
-0.009021108,
-0.0276876353,
-0.0623085126,
0.0119385086,
2.445804948e-34,
0.0416698381,
-0.0102107162,
-0.0183627028,
-0.0255950373,
0.0318825766,
0.0223386195,
-0.0085909497,
0.0154720061,
0.0451919623,
-0.08134415,
-0.0377181247
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10407v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10407v1 | BAD: BiAs Detection for Large Language Models in the context of candidate screening | 2023-05-17T17:47:31 | 2023-05-17T17:47:31 | Nam Ho Koh, Joseph Plata, Joyce Chai | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2, I.2.7, F.2.2, I.2.7 | Application Tracking Systems (ATS) have allowed talent managers, recruiters,
and college admissions committees to process large volumes of potential
candidate applications efficiently. Traditionally, this screening process was
conducted manually, creating major bottlenecks due to the quantity of
applications and introducing many instances of human bias. The advent of large
language models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT and the potential of adopting methods to
current automated application screening raises additional bias and fairness
issues that must be addressed. In this project, we wish to identify and
quantify the instances of social bias in ChatGPT and other OpenAI LLMs in the
context of candidate screening in order to demonstrate how the use of these
models could perpetuate existing biases and inequalities in the hiring process. | [
0.0280629694,
0.0459373482,
-0.0386689827,
0.0060565714,
-0.0245178603,
0.0091253063,
0.0100165866,
0.0082734236,
0.0683113337,
-0.0699614584,
0.0024242182,
-0.0263717901,
0.0152016068,
-0.0006172953,
0.0007200162,
0.0187016521,
0.0428571515,
0.0259710271,
0.0218247958,
-0.03920516,
-0.0094789751,
0.0400347821,
0.0156949628,
0.0696496814,
0.0023860149,
-0.0243075714,
0.0649043396,
-0.0129688056,
0.004814324,
-0.0037684531,
-0.0031184973,
0.0472234413,
-0.02721834,
0.0154156573,
0.0000017997,
-0.0589346141,
0.0197563469,
0.0070692911,
-0.0218835324,
0.0047575482,
0.0687744021,
0.0347716957,
-0.0079598995,
0.0533190742,
-0.045293998,
0.0074286168,
0.0296584927,
-0.0497595184,
0.0463238135,
0.0340950787,
0.0028285612,
0.0004572484,
-0.0361932144,
-0.0345752798,
-0.0093363505,
-0.0422268398,
0.0553974137,
-0.0918549374,
-0.0097229304,
-0.0246009585,
-0.0179370884,
-0.0173625406,
-0.042201288,
-0.0212240014,
0.0299383346,
0.0075252475,
-0.0373196751,
-0.0329071581,
0.002387089,
0.0222729631,
0.0250378363,
-0.0043683373,
-0.0172925461,
-0.0258723516,
0.0393590108,
0.0287569575,
-0.0109673664,
0.0317738913,
-0.0276863668,
-0.0101483883,
-0.022593746,
0.0195568781,
-0.0011691715,
0.036645256,
-0.00361235,
0.0717669353,
0.0127820149,
-0.0258094911,
0.0044641737,
0.0280797333,
0.072573632,
-0.041428633,
0.0384460576,
0.0019308411,
-0.0419738367,
0.0035235577,
0.0003624339,
0.0189834759,
0.030261822,
-0.0861236379,
-0.0167614631,
0.0664684996,
-0.0180711467,
0.0241973996,
0.0275521949,
0.0422283895,
0.0113602765,
-0.0271585677,
-0.0215849243,
-0.0268364046,
-0.0342847928,
0.0059646699,
-0.0212504733,
-0.0121187614,
0.0114485892,
0.0436901636,
-0.1107710302,
0.0078900717,
-0.0670529306,
0.0009239457,
0.0283421557,
-0.0151351495,
-0.0151650319,
0.0425563715,
-0.0677054375,
0.0039776438,
-0.0001025908,
-0.0051255743,
-0.0361951366,
-0.0757575333,
0.0309254918,
0.0178098325,
-0.0079660593,
-0.0463300012,
-0.015493853,
0.0432564504,
0.0607315786,
-0.0064820582,
-0.0279545523,
-0.0169061348,
0.007475262,
-0.0330857076,
-0.0387522951,
-0.0250424501,
0.0072001438,
0.0179242622,
0.0182894375,
-0.0510771349,
-0.011352364,
0.0297238603,
-0.0581984669,
0.0194102991,
0.0185487643,
0.0148535473,
0.0484823994,
0.018002009,
-0.0059531215,
0.0891354978,
-0.0012795961,
0.034353435,
0.0488587506,
-0.0679627284,
0.0526014231,
0.0797861069,
0.0062780376,
0.0016964474,
-0.0203412622,
0.0374376364,
0.0206735414,
-0.0077554025,
0.0537809134,
0.0048132748,
-0.0156399738,
-0.0131585142,
0.0212179031,
0.0988651738,
0.005459269,
0.0288514793,
0.0362457223,
0.0315184295,
-0.0278414879,
-0.0072807865,
-0.047931727,
0.0059305439,
-0.0148575976,
-0.0456507616,
-0.0074946778,
0.0703054443,
-0.03418025,
0.0048953174,
-0.0068639456,
0.0214161985,
0.0130047966,
0.0198945105,
-0.000193666,
-0.0251953639,
-0.0132235242,
0.0394882113,
0.0547047965,
-0.0280405004,
-0.0175632313,
-0.066748485,
-0.0357259549,
0.0650892556,
0.0272533745,
-0.0139963245,
0.0524075627,
-0.0323368758,
-0.0328218415,
0.0408106744,
0.1191389188,
0.0025058531,
-0.0128045771,
-0.0304683205,
-0.0125267599,
0.0772332177,
0.0210681967,
0.0197697319,
0.0428306125,
0.0519179106,
-0.0103052454,
0.0058779307,
-0.0706089661,
0.0218106341,
0.0230756812,
-0.0459850244,
-0.0082592098,
0.0063548177,
0.0236653034,
0.0152148129,
-0.0104900273,
-0.0107549448,
-0.0342299081,
0.0178503208,
0.0194892641,
-0.0017516859,
-0.0044905101,
0.0345564894,
0.0082621733,
-0.0145447301,
-0.0602035373,
0.0170368347,
-0.0167581253,
0.0242407415,
0.0613483228,
0.0344752744,
0.0347173065,
-0.0044740867,
0.0029524451,
-0.0397317782,
0.0275986865,
-0.0334459133,
0.0429606624,
0.017291287,
0.0012877493,
0.0178467222,
-0.0561072677,
0.0094577149,
-0.1028515026,
0.0001991978,
0.0338950381,
-0.007914681,
-0.0003574023,
0.0203301236,
-0.0064278422,
-0.0181354284,
0.0041823434,
-0.0945190266,
-0.0007915404,
0.0177733954,
-0.0116778659,
-0.0229238216,
0.0247575082,
-0.0151165109,
0.0031103655,
-0.026213767,
-0.0061340495,
0.0325046033,
0.0319827087,
-0.0110108806,
-0.0394296162,
-0.0445561297,
-0.0388189293,
-0.0406512693,
-0.0561846644,
0.0313835964,
0.0638566241,
0.0006689107,
-0.0596041121,
0.0366567299,
-0.0417918637,
-0.0097324969,
0.0167742781,
-0.0250529051,
-0.0010895153,
0.0268256925,
-0.0358262807,
0.0600426942,
-0.009378952,
0.057703454,
0.0413699485,
0.0100534866,
-0.0151045416,
-0.0241865143,
0.013579933,
0.035914544,
-0.0024249216,
-0.0542201251,
-0.023736611,
0.0077044326,
0.0420414247,
-0.0366936214,
-0.0462706126,
0.0474725552,
-0.0708609521,
-0.0028686898,
-0.0470267385,
-0.0367588848,
-0.0287749469,
0.0395006463,
-0.0074384259,
-0.032521233,
0.0163910557,
-0.0043209209,
0.0273888465,
-0.0418411009,
-0.0383326374,
-0.0478728451,
0.0372721851,
-0.0193140041,
0.021516256,
-0.0099206856,
-0.000643557,
-0.044484172,
-0.0402148999,
0.0343516655,
-0.0482720509,
0.0108181993,
-0.0080282725,
0.0141478358,
-0.0101392614,
-0.0036670128,
-0.0340446047,
-0.0197046772,
-0.0220472161,
0.0052007814,
0.0313269123,
-0.0043426673,
-0.0245349314,
0.0029519855,
-0.0296835806,
0.0198463835,
-0.0234391429,
-0.0203989707,
0.0052452004,
-0.0121249091,
-0.002832694,
-0.0137643525,
0.0336316563,
-0.0058532287,
0.0214331374,
0.0131938532,
0.0253154729,
0.0168712791,
0.0057108062,
0.0162187219,
0.0386328548,
-0.0617835149,
0.0056224731,
0.0306005348,
0.0082340278,
-0.0308375806,
0.0331685096,
0.0730275959,
-0.0066196281,
-0.0809394941,
0.0216767173,
-0.0137559166,
-0.0043280497,
0.046772033,
0.0334898233,
-0.0995493606,
0.0160413291,
-0.0010858346,
0.0281511955,
-0.0430721752,
-0.0281381477,
-0.0090722246,
-0.1079842448,
0.0763760805,
-0.0048380503,
-0.0436805785,
-0.0055166264,
-0.0184453465,
0.0011897109,
-0.0405520424,
0.0162225887,
-0.0200714413,
-0.0057274178,
0.0118169766,
-0.007194242,
-0.0583806373,
-0.0523445271,
0.0593310483,
-0.0733580962,
0.0286981389,
0.0314446427,
0.056959562,
-0.018129617,
0.0114967264,
0.0654606894,
-0.0170472227,
-0.0052367994,
-0.0131496843,
0.0171996504,
-0.0243314467,
-0.0142651945,
-0.0400796682,
0.0042319838,
-0.0208765417,
0.0462896638,
0.0363617875,
0.0683040768,
-0.0141599914,
-0.0282474551,
-0.0238102004,
-0.009931135,
-0.0109601868,
0.0926648825,
0.0035667114,
-0.0653445125,
0.0395955667,
-0.0693479106,
0.0189899448,
0.0430527627,
-0.1007938832,
0.0373289585,
0.0081341062,
-0.0430391021,
-0.0038620504,
-0.0657914504,
0.024337424,
0.0187670663,
0.0353434682,
0.0198477972,
0.0192028806,
-0.0099622626,
0.0130393291,
0.0430070944,
-0.0373425446,
0.0687459782,
0.0250964668,
-0.0171460044,
-0.0535895936,
-0.0094218701,
-0.033357244,
-0.0240455158,
-0.0450158045,
-0.019279005,
0.0283061564,
0.0004349981,
0.0417191237,
0.00838539,
-0.025744237,
-0.0526279733,
-0.0078614121,
0.0171837676,
-0.0182672776,
0.0444005206,
-0.0072348462,
-0.0198954269,
-0.0118699456,
0.0015683462,
-0.0144699262,
0.0360502936,
0.0439899452,
-0.0393893756,
0.0082529923,
-0.0560124852,
0.0040786127,
0.0291047506,
0.0233659968,
-0.0120129371,
-0.0066525931,
-0.0401229709,
-0.0149445599,
-0.0246808119,
-0.0311998874,
-0.0084715392,
-0.050249882,
0.0532338768,
0.0326004624,
-0.0133177405,
-0.0531144217,
-0.0628071278,
0.0241281874,
-0.0228099674,
0.0961612463,
0.0063176332,
0.0546536446,
0.035322234,
-0.0213578399,
-0.006189968,
0.0409327261,
-0.0139895137,
0.0366043784,
0.0089000287,
0.0607920624,
-0.0053160451,
0.0322448835,
0.0456833355,
0.0028691906,
-0.0344773121,
-0.0476685353,
0.0246740226,
0.0459689759,
0.0336680748,
-0.0361283682,
0.0129797282,
0.0199192073,
0.0150571242,
0.0036051576,
-0.0059140706,
0.0272132028,
0.0009494239,
0.0300035458,
-0.0099935103,
-0.0091574183,
0.0162983686,
0.051781062,
-0.0028403879,
0.0450604968,
-0.0390087552,
-0.029899491,
0.0158159565,
-0.0400914885,
0.0555631816,
0.0280961674,
-0.0295089409,
-0.0075619537,
-0.1162770241,
-0.0632235631,
-0.0362008587,
-0.0113156009,
0.038606409,
-0.0468510762,
-0.0130611975,
0.0669757649,
-0.0195124913,
-0.027087396,
-0.0320221521,
-0.0317672715,
-0.0662838295,
-0.0121203857,
-0.031114107,
-5.859445916e-33,
-0.0232695192,
-0.0392622054,
0.0010580426,
-0.0134687396,
-0.0117801232,
-0.0280382801,
0.0167103745,
-0.0021826935,
-0.0345341414,
-0.007755578,
-0.0265533458,
0.0325260051,
0.0016875627,
-0.0180344544,
0.0314970501,
0.0188600793,
0.0360444747,
0.0041694343,
-0.0173497722,
-0.0047115972,
-0.0596479811,
0.0074421954,
0.0094772177,
-0.0178269949,
0.0670156926,
-0.0061864648,
-0.0035462114,
0.0151181407,
-0.0022212858,
0.0319145955,
-0.0097891586,
0.0481988862,
0.0297976583,
-0.0446119048,
0.0269051436,
0.0124289105,
0.0171679817,
-0.033881668,
0.0266510043,
0.0414364859,
0.081776455,
-0.0191136915,
0.0006323209,
-0.0065406943,
-0.0877500772,
0.001949164,
0.0662702397,
-0.0070794672,
0.0360338166,
0.0587981232,
-0.0236331113,
0.0319764428,
-0.0492644757,
0.0593257621,
-0.0164115634,
-0.0009921241,
0.0042571123,
0.0391156264,
-0.0541163683,
0.0012555049,
-0.0520022996,
0.0047342605,
0.0183596052,
-0.0076781907,
-0.0293300152,
0.0338290073,
0.0678268597,
0.0420798585,
0.0150695471,
-0.0929261148,
0.0036016705,
-0.0047629001,
0.007638453,
0.0429085828,
0.0296987295,
-0.0369278975,
-0.0376943946,
0.0006983041,
0.0658729151,
0.0091692973,
-0.0106982682,
-0.0022923145,
-0.0779591724,
-0.0559341945,
0.0061098053,
-0.0704220235,
-0.0303698983,
-0.0125730792,
0.0367573723,
-0.0237028543,
0.0077727237,
0.0311911963,
0.015909221,
-0.0637603924,
-0.0168306082,
-0.0050188852,
-0.0463028699,
-0.0230201911,
-0.0010179247,
0.0052936827,
-0.081402272,
0.008595055,
-0.0085380785,
0.0274601709,
0.0459620953,
0.0600019395,
-0.034457434,
-0.0076136929,
-0.0544870012,
0.0071890228,
-0.0080059022,
-0.0126412613,
0.0089461226,
0.0218261834,
0.0478530191,
0.0184178427,
0.0468161628,
0.0203633234,
0.0407224372,
0.0137071675,
-0.0440317206,
-0.0516529046,
0.0047369758,
0.0146962851,
-0.0267991051,
-0.0108265551,
-0.0139149111,
0.0008897977,
0.0461129472,
-0.0548652932,
-0.0188401118,
-0.051646933,
2.441e-7,
0.0012746763,
0.0503165461,
-0.0456315689,
0.033546973,
0.0059229974,
0.0183601342,
-0.0104786633,
0.0452593416,
0.064428553,
0.0271312036,
-0.0229630284,
0.0263075158,
0.0023736386,
0.0206214413,
-0.073785916,
0.0077025318,
-0.0700713396,
-0.0209331904,
-0.0497167706,
0.0281975809,
0.0319814608,
0.0801960751,
0.0659017712,
-0.0123825893,
-0.0315580741,
-0.0446853265,
0.0219962597,
-0.0064254296,
0.01168257,
0.0400864892,
0.0473262034,
-0.0131661436,
-0.0136069115,
0.0716205388,
-0.010282347,
0.0314850211,
0.0139762759,
0.0310354698,
-0.048505839,
0.1004716456,
-0.0068146642,
-0.017830519,
-0.0303673968,
-0.0621656217,
0.0453279205,
0.0141183697,
-0.0292232502,
-0.0903403759,
0.0085070394,
-0.035271164,
0.0402261838,
0.0409956649,
-0.0005976746,
-0.0035949878,
0.0308038238,
-0.0234483536,
-0.0270516966,
-0.0423773229,
0.0075059501,
-0.0681054965,
-0.0188419893,
-0.0952908397,
0.0339442454,
0.0231060572,
0.0466322973,
0.0096444758,
0.0202971175,
2.120894407e-34,
0.0524721369,
0.0315899998,
0.0263032541,
-0.0259057395,
0.0605988018,
0.01037193,
0.0042213257,
-0.0056640529,
0.0168514885,
-0.0159929227,
0.0009638938
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10403v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10403v3 | PaLM 2 Technical Report | 2023-05-17T17:46:53 | 2023-09-13T20:35:45 | Rohan Anil, Andrew M. Dai, Orhan Firat, Melvin Johnson, Dmitry Lepikhin, Alexandre Passos, Siamak Shakeri, Emanuel Taropa, Paige Bailey, Zhifeng Chen, Eric Chu, Jonathan H. Clark, Laurent El Shafey, Yanping Huang, Kathy Meier-Hellstern, Gaurav Mishra, Erica Moreira, Mark Omernick, Kevin Robinson, Sebastian Ruder, Yi Tay, Kefan Xiao, Yuanzhong Xu, Yujing Zhang, Gustavo Hernandez Abrego, Junwhan Ahn, Jacob Austin, Paul Barham, Jan Botha, James Bradbury, Siddhartha Brahma, Kevin Brooks, Michele Catasta, Yong Cheng, Colin Cherry, Christopher A. Choquette-Choo, Aakanksha Chowdhery, Clément Crepy, Shachi Dave, Mostafa Dehghani, Sunipa Dev, Jacob Devlin, Mark Díaz, Nan Du, Ethan Dyer, Vlad Feinberg, Fangxiaoyu Feng, Vlad Fienber, Markus Freitag, Xavier Garcia, Sebastian Gehrmann, Lucas Gonzalez, Guy Gur-Ari, Steven Hand, Hadi Hashemi, Le Hou, Joshua Howland, Andrea Hu, Jeffrey Hui, Jeremy Hurwitz, Michael Isard, Abe Ittycheriah, Matthew Jagielski, Wenhao Jia, Kathleen Kenealy, Maxim Krikun, Sneha Kudugunta, Chang Lan, Katherine Lee, Benjamin Lee, Eric Li, Music Li, Wei Li, YaGuang Li, Jian Li, Hyeontaek Lim, Hanzhao Lin, Zhongtao Liu, Frederick Liu, Marcello Maggioni, Aroma Mahendru, Joshua Maynez, Vedant Misra, Maysam Moussalem, Zachary Nado, John Nham, Eric Ni, Andrew Nystrom, Alicia Parrish, Marie Pellat, Martin Polacek, Alex Polozov, Reiner Pope, Siyuan Qiao, Emily Reif, Bryan Richter, Parker Riley, Alex Castro Ros, Aurko Roy, Brennan Saeta, Rajkumar Samuel, Renee Shelby, Ambrose Slone, Daniel Smilkov, David R. So, Daniel Sohn, Simon Tokumine, Dasha Valter, Vijay Vasudevan, Kiran Vodrahalli, Xuezhi Wang, Pidong Wang, Zirui Wang, Tao Wang, John Wieting, Yuhuai Wu, Kelvin Xu, Yunhan Xu, Linting Xue, Pengcheng Yin, Jiahui Yu, Qiao Zhang, Steven Zheng, Ce Zheng, Weikang Zhou, Denny Zhou, Slav Petrov, Yonghui Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We introduce PaLM 2, a new state-of-the-art language model that has better
multilingual and reasoning capabilities and is more compute-efficient than its
predecessor PaLM. PaLM 2 is a Transformer-based model trained using a mixture
of objectives. Through extensive evaluations on English and multilingual
language, and reasoning tasks, we demonstrate that PaLM 2 has significantly
improved quality on downstream tasks across different model sizes, while
simultaneously exhibiting faster and more efficient inference compared to PaLM.
This improved efficiency enables broader deployment while also allowing the
model to respond faster, for a more natural pace of interaction. PaLM 2
demonstrates robust reasoning capabilities exemplified by large improvements
over PaLM on BIG-Bench and other reasoning tasks. PaLM 2 exhibits stable
performance on a suite of responsible AI evaluations, and enables
inference-time control over toxicity without additional overhead or impact on
other capabilities. Overall, PaLM 2 achieves state-of-the-art performance
across a diverse set of tasks and capabilities.
When discussing the PaLM 2 family, it is important to distinguish between
pre-trained models (of various sizes), fine-tuned variants of these models, and
the user-facing products that use these models. In particular, user-facing
products typically include additional pre- and post-processing steps.
Additionally, the underlying models may evolve over time. Therefore, one should
not expect the performance of user-facing products to exactly match the results
reported in this report. | [
0.0445413627,
0.0453760289,
0.0042325803,
0.0289538428,
-0.0309253447,
0.0079808421,
0.040919356,
-0.0201993436,
0.0152738094,
-0.0556903519,
-0.0579660349,
0.0159278847,
-0.0051854886,
0.0614037029,
-0.0129061798,
-0.0376566313,
0.0572624169,
-0.0236708801,
-0.0041623348,
0.0061941901,
-0.0127840936,
0.0316149965,
0.0070426762,
0.055395361,
-0.0322760083,
-0.0349435732,
-0.0026593637,
-0.0214809757,
0.0342105068,
-0.0081562866,
0.0114326393,
0.0488575436,
0.0132651282,
0.0398884751,
0.0000023818,
-0.0343692712,
0.0000316263,
0.0043635578,
-0.021065563,
-0.0240843166,
0.047749918,
-0.0129922247,
-0.0092322705,
0.0363650508,
-0.05278809,
-0.0295899957,
0.0261829235,
0.0719661266,
0.030004885,
0.0530324206,
-0.0205154065,
-0.0259127282,
0.0266675409,
-0.029004477,
-0.0347969756,
-0.0193679947,
-0.0008758966,
-0.03603727,
0.0378633663,
-0.0179906953,
0.0004609112,
0.0349711962,
0.0632473677,
-0.0054080882,
-0.0283929184,
0.0338599831,
-0.0436333567,
-0.0444644801,
-0.0119982315,
0.0913535208,
-0.0232282449,
-0.0253056195,
-0.0268640798,
0.0073838145,
-0.00467026,
-0.0056043491,
-0.002509689,
0.0099439323,
-0.0099195531,
0.0020998202,
0.0315039381,
0.0108854976,
0.044302132,
0.0201854371,
-0.0395662896,
0.0862170756,
0.0148457559,
-0.0054246522,
0.0335550532,
0.0109224059,
-0.0024158678,
-0.0448766015,
0.0213792864,
0.0295629986,
-0.0338881351,
0.0105359554,
-0.0365187153,
-0.0144706508,
0.0093321688,
-0.0664759651,
0.0339133702,
0.0383700803,
-0.0243216939,
0.0683885962,
-0.0185318384,
0.0258436259,
-0.0359736569,
0.0338663384,
-0.0473549813,
-0.0373663269,
0.001950138,
-0.0052308897,
-0.0183830708,
0.0070194537,
-0.042912215,
-0.0420221314,
-0.009012999,
0.0147266528,
-0.0229190104,
0.0020830962,
0.0438676402,
0.037112467,
-0.021469051,
-0.025871519,
-0.0330030844,
0.0623374246,
-0.0426723324,
0.0343605876,
0.0131152095,
-0.0785423294,
0.0056701959,
0.0099381879,
-0.0242845044,
-0.031883616,
0.0277713928,
0.0945199654,
-0.0402310304,
-0.027183596,
-0.0182437282,
-0.010166008,
-0.0263347942,
-0.0966841951,
-0.0107344575,
-0.0474522188,
0.039056439,
0.0125739016,
0.0079072528,
-0.0320354551,
0.0150916642,
0.0331021734,
-0.0169067774,
0.0717849508,
-0.0029731509,
-0.0172200389,
0.0314949602,
0.022626454,
-0.060946241,
0.0437159427,
0.0234584063,
0.0260083452,
0.0165379606,
-0.0056185531,
-0.0007607639,
0.0427135043,
-0.03436023,
-0.02921433,
-0.006777049,
0.000653877,
-0.0295543149,
0.0149913244,
-0.0023225516,
0.0549597256,
-0.0172051862,
-0.0063271159,
0.0528585985,
0.05231563,
-0.0218273997,
0.0259618443,
0.0630830824,
-0.0144087914,
-0.0240166839,
-0.0313166603,
-0.0776928291,
0.0260988753,
-0.0364561938,
-0.0138119739,
-0.0354089439,
0.0378069431,
-0.009159198,
-0.0467286818,
0.0016134577,
-0.024487637,
0.0403905287,
0.0381164886,
0.0553742349,
0.0073943045,
-0.011849218,
0.0482811257,
0.0133673316,
-0.0378302112,
-0.0381041542,
-0.0546205007,
0.0425738208,
0.0752251223,
0.024904374,
0.0024834913,
-0.0282080974,
-0.0052891085,
-0.030187577,
0.040372543,
0.0566554144,
-0.0211539771,
0.0178295486,
-0.0446227118,
-0.0201512612,
-0.0286609754,
0.0014019333,
0.0368803293,
0.0248028208,
0.0269521717,
0.0250219088,
-0.0053927288,
-0.0006929223,
0.0171490759,
-0.020477796,
-0.010693226,
0.0187940486,
0.02439804,
0.0216302779,
-0.0239063222,
0.0240987409,
-0.0019478818,
0.0363101996,
-0.0364231244,
-0.0135351643,
0.021562865,
-0.0612636767,
-0.0331212245,
0.0351841263,
-0.0310585033,
-0.0330669172,
0.0623834543,
-0.0050772079,
-0.0446489789,
0.0065896381,
0.004071502,
0.0183906574,
-0.0324350633,
0.0203753728,
-0.0155861126,
-0.0023706201,
-0.0021090754,
0.0875109583,
-0.0007563664,
-0.0301616229,
-0.0081506781,
-0.0095607424,
0.0239423309,
-0.0166341513,
-0.0208397675,
0.0063590831,
-0.0222854856,
-0.015186633,
0.0179874282,
0.019273594,
-0.0285068862,
-0.0186817572,
-0.1112962738,
-0.0000585925,
-0.0314203426,
-0.0177877117,
-0.0110483384,
0.024882948,
0.0166207869,
-0.02351523,
-0.0350723304,
-0.0110909538,
0.0043974738,
0.0217557251,
-0.0202712286,
-0.0016729909,
0.014888701,
-0.0349583738,
-0.014356304,
-0.0060592,
0.0275750421,
0.0081746355,
-0.012898854,
-0.0393601283,
-0.0099342857,
-0.0324075036,
0.0354133472,
-0.020911362,
-0.0174410045,
0.0472231954,
-0.015603126,
0.0468736291,
0.1017913446,
-0.0048705917,
0.0482296981,
0.0436770245,
0.0207274035,
-0.076098606,
0.0375069231,
-0.0109076528,
-0.0066939178,
-0.0510131307,
-0.0025545291,
-0.0278005041,
0.0947797224,
-0.0167076569,
0.0016487198,
-0.0609764084,
-0.0304113794,
-0.0061383094,
-0.0617521442,
0.0002500187,
-0.0251236986,
-0.013060051,
0.0128439851,
-0.0354511663,
-0.0339196287,
0.088263914,
-0.0216902792,
0.0118549122,
-0.0520319082,
-0.0168816261,
-0.0040523168,
0.0655110702,
-0.0005818949,
0.0317676216,
-0.019587351,
0.0034750174,
-0.045364514,
0.0104388781,
0.0024105455,
-0.0258568618,
0.0531144664,
-0.0597660765,
-0.007362979,
-0.011055165,
-0.0901739597,
-0.0412434228,
-0.0156017542,
-0.0595209152,
0.0196058992,
0.0199613199,
-0.0285807829,
-0.0444539711,
-0.011359999,
0.0193708185,
0.0663278326,
0.0085842256,
-0.0230831597,
-0.0065101013,
-0.0219947081,
0.0673658475,
0.0096188597,
0.0578607395,
-0.0167440884,
0.0361281894,
0.0926582366,
0.0103124855,
-0.0545373037,
-0.0476423129,
0.0423807167,
0.0421749838,
-0.0002043018,
-0.0601536334,
0.0011488381,
0.049522806,
-0.0740159824,
-0.007051297,
0.1119077355,
0.0140216304,
-0.0444209725,
0.0098981876,
-0.007789413,
-0.0020837884,
0.0474139191,
0.036978133,
-0.0463432372,
-0.0675288066,
0.0166970808,
0.0105237029,
0.0207277574,
-0.0048595136,
0.0007002088,
-0.1184884906,
0.0367396139,
-0.02486738,
-0.0206316225,
0.0125576071,
-0.0321986601,
-0.0050272173,
-0.0136452308,
0.0154279619,
-0.0146089578,
0.0167109817,
-0.0267274026,
0.0025488017,
0.0131935766,
-0.0218865555,
0.0568103455,
-0.0180357322,
-0.0216718651,
0.0314400829,
0.002666679,
0.0147116147,
-0.0634999275,
0.0535062626,
0.0224559382,
0.0216137264,
-0.0372449718,
0.0018172045,
0.0082647596,
-0.0106932372,
-0.0185988918,
0.0487737954,
-0.0238171667,
-0.0152154025,
-0.0105216503,
0.1036927924,
-0.0068126372,
-0.021578094,
-0.0209273007,
-0.0213626493,
-0.0047993641,
0.0672245994,
0.0070815771,
-0.0480388477,
-0.0580824502,
-0.0204558372,
-0.0451506115,
-0.0159061961,
-0.006509935,
0.0120470952,
0.0109637352,
-0.069408834,
-0.0641345754,
-0.0464556366,
0.0224296171,
0.0476292223,
-0.0021068447,
-0.0469073839,
-0.0060421145,
0.0145910569,
-0.0197154228,
0.0328396074,
-0.0113700191,
0.04558523,
-0.0786367506,
0.0589310564,
0.0226956438,
-0.0156549718,
-0.0332482792,
-0.0010374304,
-0.0384280458,
-0.0714979693,
-0.0067432341,
0.08595258,
0.023819156,
0.0259865336,
-0.0595973022,
-0.0396730341,
0.0111854924,
-0.002706395,
-0.0533737056,
-0.0142319696,
0.0556289367,
-0.0498682596,
-0.004001427,
0.0602434091,
-0.0369832106,
0.0258196015,
0.0105397701,
0.0273590591,
-0.0527703725,
-0.0562619567,
0.016693417,
-0.0017951914,
0.0684473664,
-0.0096889986,
0.0313583016,
-0.0126267066,
0.0397534147,
-0.0043256814,
-0.0366132706,
-0.0384686887,
0.0134639218,
0.0225490537,
0.011448347,
-0.0164211839,
0.0112937903,
0.0354489088,
0.0182542279,
-0.0137367491,
0.008371857,
0.0407453924,
0.0186305027,
0.0057488191,
0.0154905608,
-0.039212089,
0.0184651259,
0.0033371525,
0.0456464775,
-0.0371878482,
0.0803876966,
0.0114345588,
-0.0177879557,
-0.0261741672,
0.0298386645,
-0.0342781954,
-0.0740598738,
0.0073677464,
-0.0029458238,
0.0282786116,
-0.0154286223,
0.0414566547,
-0.02083732,
-0.0295748543,
-0.0233581886,
0.0159517732,
0.0033121638,
-0.0554624312,
0.0254546255,
0.0138963778,
-0.0100535257,
0.0127818715,
0.0621796176,
-0.0044457861,
0.0388606787,
-0.0011298616,
-0.0121344961,
-0.0397584438,
-0.0377063975,
0.0094294036,
0.0136483535,
-0.0210527033,
0.0128858257,
-0.051961232,
-0.0821999684,
0.0078189373,
0.0075465473,
-0.0083909305,
0.0082998211,
0.0325315073,
0.0671829581,
0.0050946451,
-0.0221699364,
-0.0325469226,
0.0016556147,
-0.0121815791,
-0.004510493,
-0.0165249836,
-6.833339679e-33,
0.0053698611,
0.0038202503,
0.0156715624,
-0.0136933615,
0.010271661,
-0.0064293537,
-0.0380052552,
0.0162681881,
-0.0724520832,
0.0604994483,
-0.0227731559,
0.0274557695,
0.0046566916,
0.0040280297,
0.0149792098,
-0.0362051539,
0.0162350871,
0.0287214443,
-0.0291361772,
0.0200243313,
0.0758813173,
0.028846588,
0.0732273534,
-0.0603860132,
-0.0237063859,
0.0353858434,
-0.0168621559,
0.0129346084,
-0.0614002347,
0.0711890683,
-0.0032636328,
0.0381251462,
0.0180687271,
-0.0375748947,
-0.0012345298,
0.0214434881,
-0.1215454563,
-0.0137152011,
-0.0030826181,
0.0207964629,
-0.0410512835,
-0.0221787468,
0.0273300149,
0.0188750848,
-0.0143738138,
-0.0293997712,
0.032633312,
-0.043866843,
-0.0184184387,
-0.0607254542,
-0.0522695072,
0.0018839887,
0.0008508783,
-0.0327217206,
-0.010013381,
0.0604441203,
-0.0153503455,
0.0136472052,
-0.0651105642,
-0.0070224917,
-0.0264143012,
-0.0096866963,
0.0823206007,
0.000747861,
-0.0120264795,
0.0491561778,
-0.031151861,
-0.0214139186,
0.003446545,
-0.0220649112,
0.0265177041,
0.0906110629,
0.0714547038,
0.0399352945,
0.0288250633,
-0.0012544033,
-0.0689578205,
0.0340349786,
0.0232184213,
0.0701568648,
-0.0036187042,
-0.0057183984,
-0.0511470847,
-0.0076595079,
-0.0266947411,
0.0252762306,
-0.0472834148,
-0.0166026261,
0.0215472635,
0.0168586541,
-0.0371472239,
0.024395667,
0.0385240801,
-0.0467847139,
0.0153802233,
0.0165863894,
-0.000676297,
0.0131120672,
0.0103649218,
0.0342099667,
-0.0652156472,
-0.0065760906,
0.0108083077,
0.0086865127,
0.0002723471,
0.0089365076,
0.0561772287,
0.0252958201,
-0.060196992,
0.0000332853,
-0.0546347909,
0.0312470198,
0.0076632681,
0.0467128083,
0.043389637,
0.0024156726,
-0.008577778,
0.0423993021,
-0.0063489778,
0.0135801695,
-0.0417149477,
0.009932396,
0.0246269982,
0.0136227794,
-0.0335546508,
0.0078759985,
-0.0571332723,
0.0411737114,
0.0280284714,
-0.08008001,
-0.0176564846,
0.0492816903,
3.012e-7,
0.0456509776,
0.0159410089,
0.0050772801,
-0.0115663204,
0.0028370221,
0.0640288144,
0.033268787,
0.0257504992,
-0.0072134938,
0.0192149263,
0.0020868522,
0.0430272594,
0.0684913322,
0.0443823412,
-0.0649193823,
0.006411396,
-0.0709290504,
0.0173626114,
-0.0462686084,
0.0054459674,
0.0415796936,
0.1112919226,
0.0122592906,
-0.0404984616,
0.028575277,
-0.0283975992,
0.0561743528,
-0.0394013748,
0.0340581499,
-0.0026886654,
0.0208265036,
0.0510350764,
-0.0113056256,
0.0051678428,
-0.0355390422,
0.0087609543,
0.0050597638,
0.0774897113,
-0.0071354085,
-0.0180731434,
0.0177100748,
-0.0411635451,
0.0060748048,
-0.0792834759,
0.1152301133,
-0.0385159813,
-0.018593546,
-0.01688293,
-0.021591166,
-0.011388706,
-0.0005286354,
-0.0273733903,
-0.0170648322,
0.0221442226,
0.020701874,
-0.0315345265,
-0.0164844152,
-0.094616212,
-0.0272340477,
0.0110559929,
-0.0247476045,
-0.0151403164,
-0.0509001464,
-0.023829693,
0.0353691466,
-0.0192987546,
-0.0093036266,
2.81122826e-34,
0.0171285868,
-0.0103544546,
0.0111666676,
0.0225925967,
0.0444133095,
0.0031474959,
0.0163784511,
-0.0149679864,
0.0166752227,
-0.0856048837,
-0.0192897748
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10400v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10400v4 | What You See is What You Read? Improving Text-Image Alignment Evaluation | 2023-05-17T17:43:38 | 2023-12-26T15:58:24 | Michal Yarom, Yonatan Bitton, Soravit Changpinyo, Roee Aharoni, Jonathan Herzig, Oran Lang, Eran Ofek, Idan Szpektor | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Automatically determining whether a text and a corresponding image are
semantically aligned is a significant challenge for vision-language models,
with applications in generative text-to-image and image-to-text tasks. In this
work, we study methods for automatic text-image alignment evaluation. We first
introduce SeeTRUE: a comprehensive evaluation set, spanning multiple datasets
from both text-to-image and image-to-text generation tasks, with human
judgements for whether a given text-image pair is semantically aligned. We then
describe two automatic methods to determine alignment: the first involving a
pipeline based on question generation and visual question answering models, and
the second employing an end-to-end classification approach by finetuning
multimodal pretrained models. Both methods surpass prior approaches in various
text-image alignment tasks, with significant improvements in challenging cases
that involve complex composition or unnatural images. Finally, we demonstrate
how our approaches can localize specific misalignments between an image and a
given text, and how they can be used to automatically re-rank candidates in
text-to-image generation. | [
0.0256381985,
0.066157952,
0.0149930688,
0.0529617481,
-0.0273394585,
0.0093658445,
0.0030496495,
-0.0028180047,
-0.002052967,
-0.0150994407,
-0.0033655018,
-0.0268180352,
0.0377180614,
0.0225454737,
0.0562867932,
-0.0633197725,
0.0067200447,
-0.020788582,
-0.0262657925,
0.0257098507,
0.0686214566,
0.0359674618,
0.0010867153,
0.0101620005,
-0.030558994,
-0.0535546318,
-0.0141681731,
0.052098643,
0.0393574201,
0.002872661,
-0.0156235015,
0.0324905068,
0.004328866,
0.0214511231,
0.0000014801,
-0.0175448563,
0.0131769031,
0.00935065,
0.0346917287,
-0.0318146721,
0.0187539756,
-0.0566066764,
0.0106389811,
-0.0034002271,
-0.0246928576,
0.0081620682,
0.0771096945,
0.0300437491,
0.1025201827,
0.058519043,
-0.0268576089,
-0.0020451841,
-0.0057385294,
-0.0225831866,
0.0410346128,
-0.0126911718,
-0.0046029328,
0.0050096195,
-0.0372272395,
-0.0043538543,
-0.0349673666,
0.0423453972,
0.0190153942,
-0.0426989831,
0.02179843,
0.031050276,
-0.0207994767,
-0.0395503044,
-0.0181979965,
0.080844067,
-0.0299717616,
-0.0381163321,
-0.0331101604,
-0.0244036745,
0.0030153915,
0.0105145182,
-0.0250097457,
0.0183988325,
-0.0125659043,
0.0225213338,
-0.0409832038,
-0.0074268002,
-0.0068240375,
-0.0011535151,
0.0077699125,
-0.0010554363,
0.0319537148,
0.0112263979,
-0.0473001227,
0.045951914,
-0.0337514468,
-0.0813346654,
0.0187015198,
0.0310940668,
-0.0140591478,
-0.0067067603,
-0.0684377924,
-0.0319227763,
-0.0191480666,
-0.0203629844,
0.0355750136,
0.0235219672,
-0.045904547,
0.0501679517,
-0.0307176262,
0.0795549825,
-0.0151340077,
0.030107474,
-0.0633092225,
0.0141333621,
0.024393484,
-0.0125716971,
-0.0157314539,
-0.0400300026,
-0.05090167,
-0.0432229787,
-0.0215728581,
0.0237071086,
0.0104076015,
0.0297422223,
0.0106851477,
0.0345755741,
-0.0493761003,
-0.010798608,
-0.035178259,
0.0331447124,
-0.0092612188,
0.0229802579,
-0.0001319763,
-0.000993605,
-0.0113852983,
0.0506593958,
0.0345493741,
-0.02511774,
-0.0404303558,
0.0488315597,
-0.0724337474,
-0.0169374961,
0.0057218093,
-0.0140255298,
-0.0409768596,
-0.0695395097,
0.0203602966,
-0.0306477249,
0.0385078229,
-0.0122577604,
-0.0260023847,
-0.0412080586,
-0.0020498317,
0.0299514756,
-0.0002848954,
0.0930485651,
0.0157711878,
0.0197765548,
0.028530037,
-0.022745477,
0.0232101846,
0.0120951748,
0.0465745702,
0.0799948201,
0.0249979775,
0.0071079172,
0.028261099,
0.0603146739,
0.0001016549,
-0.03318014,
-0.0187725518,
0.0239749216,
0.0015394241,
0.0584258027,
0.0217746776,
0.0475653075,
0.0082784649,
0.0017809318,
0.0956127197,
-0.0011322391,
0.0183666367,
-0.0321106501,
0.0387276597,
0.0300726611,
-0.0130329337,
0.0300006717,
-0.0427329764,
0.0607434958,
0.0179007109,
0.0426622368,
0.0423788168,
0.0453322083,
-0.0103299888,
-0.0319493786,
-0.0071719587,
0.019628454,
-0.0231836382,
-0.001164251,
0.0395922437,
0.0498388149,
-0.0927650705,
-0.0095015354,
-0.0320966318,
-0.0365542918,
-0.0021245535,
-0.0061203954,
0.0511622615,
0.0428871885,
0.0457339734,
0.0246116538,
0.0063202251,
0.0288108978,
0.0267058797,
0.089909263,
-0.0213235263,
0.014453385,
0.0066350675,
-0.0317777582,
-0.0253963936,
-0.0047508804,
-0.0287442729,
-0.0084353155,
0.0104621258,
-0.0127451764,
0.0136909597,
-0.0310051031,
-0.0268766955,
0.0754262283,
0.0496774465,
-0.0131838685,
-0.0424274728,
0.0621095859,
-0.0291523822,
-0.0296506137,
-0.0217118915,
0.0123243472,
-0.0184723698,
-0.0224012509,
0.026390316,
0.030313164,
-0.0174916219,
-0.0637121499,
0.0043719043,
-0.0595829859,
-0.0406814106,
-0.0006655738,
-0.0275575705,
-0.0372565463,
-0.0173096899,
-0.0325158723,
-0.0453255512,
-0.0784083903,
0.0052841315,
0.0255549327,
0.0068682809,
-0.0400447212,
0.0306285806,
0.0053959158,
-0.0140581094,
-0.0225332826,
-0.0110929916,
0.0159681458,
-0.0323738717,
-0.0159691777,
-0.0300531015,
-0.013828095,
0.0212740712,
0.0067503387,
0.0271888934,
-0.0493432581,
-0.029673947,
-0.057621967,
0.0256200545,
-0.0212003421,
0.0035542718,
0.0296654515,
-0.0142696183,
0.0113419425,
-0.0350863114,
-0.0694816858,
0.0292981435,
0.0526135117,
-0.0137670804,
0.0808308572,
-0.0217613652,
0.0299625713,
-0.0577045903,
0.0115467245,
0.0163227431,
0.0780488029,
0.0630319417,
0.0039480492,
-0.0476399399,
0.0124064302,
-0.0392703041,
-0.0061234664,
0.0062725516,
-0.0281394515,
0.0250626765,
0.0056890207,
0.0549405292,
0.082795307,
0.012401158,
-0.0006867201,
-0.0129175,
0.0108465347,
-0.0310648251,
-0.0131074283,
-0.0041569606,
-0.0281624123,
0.0224954449,
-0.0400552191,
-0.0215580817,
0.0287284479,
0.0105775595,
0.0153000075,
-0.0529896505,
0.0491126738,
0.0022238826,
-0.0297699086,
-0.0602224395,
0.0210981015,
0.0006910748,
0.0289672632,
-0.0936028287,
-0.0868379772,
0.0511660762,
-0.0600880384,
-0.0220701359,
0.0086519606,
0.0181202795,
-0.0032564376,
0.0532880239,
0.040645767,
0.0443201549,
0.0026765922,
-0.0043033198,
-0.095868744,
-0.027691735,
0.0176549386,
-0.0223858692,
0.0334897377,
-0.0343916304,
0.0308793876,
-0.0327842608,
-0.0332967341,
-0.0562515669,
-0.0207457207,
0.0124386605,
-0.0382551849,
-0.0334691517,
-0.0063985782,
-0.0217307415,
0.0225139987,
0.0143375397,
0.0241619814,
-0.0119070765,
-0.0175515413,
-0.0296630934,
0.0946461111,
0.0623851977,
0.016227359,
-0.0348152034,
-0.0512161702,
0.0020013878,
0.0331023,
0.0056971465,
0.0267168563,
-0.0420024097,
-0.0029609704,
-0.0026382525,
0.0363088995,
0.0664740354,
0.0299360398,
0.0748557225,
-0.0474033616,
-0.0407994464,
0.042965617,
0.0236853156,
0.014483531,
-0.0341824256,
0.0408333056,
0.0350214802,
0.0157284308,
0.0304315146,
-0.0743756443,
-0.0415685289,
-0.0165911242,
-0.0157215856,
0.028388923,
0.0238940492,
-0.0421104394,
-0.0649111271,
0.0321340114,
0.0169308707,
-0.0140956538,
-0.0350788198,
0.0400495902,
-0.0039028353,
0.0110497791,
-0.0120964367,
-0.0030958131,
0.0170601904,
0.0307277348,
-0.0027357161,
0.0344524309,
0.0101706879,
-0.0333392695,
-0.0435966253,
-0.0120652188,
0.0746885687,
0.0238948297,
0.0190556441,
-0.0436759479,
0.0281725917,
0.0017672176,
0.0173956882,
0.0409642607,
0.065904066,
-0.0187022816,
-0.0465186276,
-0.0175227039,
0.042524673,
-0.0017637133,
0.0131817684,
0.0105274701,
0.012955931,
0.002361055,
-0.0222779103,
-0.0439731404,
0.0394698232,
0.0145881204,
0.0253293049,
0.0234135017,
-0.0436043963,
-0.0576521307,
-0.0151274214,
0.022552127,
-0.095382683,
-0.0148505708,
0.0127139222,
0.0211788584,
0.0297208652,
-0.0957977846,
-0.0031846322,
0.0378960706,
0.0440650657,
0.0038910024,
-0.0345617644,
-0.0104225334,
0.0004863166,
-0.0575245321,
0.0770394132,
-0.0068784282,
0.0470850095,
-0.0209242497,
0.0079806587,
-0.0081875697,
-0.0503771231,
-0.0303903874,
0.0290224645,
-0.1219766662,
-0.0310763475,
-0.0585749075,
0.052762039,
0.0100742839,
0.0268832762,
0.0045147194,
-0.0030886868,
0.00781684,
0.0372942053,
0.0010225902,
0.0233039632,
-0.0450416841,
-0.0205187127,
-0.014892024,
0.0086659091,
-0.0133840004,
0.0109014213,
0.0201055631,
0.0241720583,
0.0155418627,
-0.0543945618,
0.0213426705,
0.0109490883,
0.0139150312,
-0.0342917554,
0.0146003487,
-0.044149071,
-0.0168901086,
0.0028218885,
-0.0346013457,
-0.0951072499,
-0.0039626574,
0.0050120987,
0.0398793854,
-0.0036775982,
-0.0178983826,
-0.0035467572,
0.0511991754,
-0.0353543572,
-0.0458025411,
0.0157801472,
-0.0035248504,
0.0075701224,
0.0197361633,
-0.0046178997,
0.0449854843,
-0.0266042463,
0.0563764386,
0.0201490335,
0.0823171735,
0.0373069979,
-0.0075236089,
-0.0139530245,
0.0267895479,
-0.0041948212,
-0.011484527,
-0.0627750903,
0.0296322443,
0.048079323,
-0.0020448004,
0.0187295377,
0.0176966768,
-0.0267372057,
0.0018196469,
0.0648052394,
-0.0116548324,
-0.0400148369,
0.0478898548,
-0.0121667543,
0.014725253,
-0.0224720854,
0.0405176505,
0.0092194444,
-0.0044794455,
-0.0112388609,
-0.0173437912,
-0.045545727,
-0.0278594755,
-0.0000279543,
-0.0305206254,
0.0128357736,
0.025974704,
0.0027938928,
-0.053520415,
-0.0057374956,
0.0892342106,
-0.0315841548,
0.0374654457,
0.0239190962,
0.028763717,
-0.0063349167,
-0.0082725082,
0.0011140315,
-0.0107214972,
-0.0510953851,
-0.005377017,
-0.0168269798,
-4.955870224e-33,
-0.0467844047,
-0.0854249001,
0.0265665837,
-0.0341156721,
-0.0476032495,
0.0083118929,
-0.0468473956,
0.0118936878,
-0.0056006764,
0.0255090203,
0.044783134,
-0.0195905007,
0.0095526688,
0.0510164015,
-0.0337615386,
0.0064840959,
0.0384873971,
-0.0201908182,
-0.033526022,
-0.000371016,
0.0090089226,
0.0144632105,
0.0095769102,
-0.0225885026,
0.0017933795,
-0.0201859847,
-0.058191672,
0.0213010069,
-0.0033392997,
0.0407503471,
-0.0159120876,
-0.0074458839,
0.012386553,
0.0113329161,
-0.0227764454,
0.0616945662,
-0.0497413576,
0.006409599,
0.0190978199,
0.0193538759,
-0.1105202287,
0.004841811,
0.0427640863,
-0.0620148405,
0.0259143375,
-0.0396824591,
0.0751172453,
-0.010815748,
0.0334032252,
-0.008547198,
-0.0558197908,
-0.023115309,
-0.0503933467,
-0.0523599684,
0.0030333023,
0.041082859,
0.0436127335,
0.0393743105,
-0.0298385378,
-0.0041903681,
-0.0085829161,
0.0284191705,
0.0692653954,
0.0515244193,
-0.0353743508,
0.0391233265,
0.0023493208,
-0.0364156179,
-0.0133494642,
-0.0016130055,
-0.001286233,
0.044304017,
0.0685245693,
0.0925576985,
0.0116921905,
0.03151026,
-0.042509228,
0.0470980555,
-0.07737156,
0.006853512,
0.0004910401,
-0.0108736726,
0.0117642153,
0.0232455824,
-0.0306628272,
-0.0032999536,
-0.0485382453,
0.0105930381,
0.0584251769,
0.0129556144,
-0.0084670736,
0.0310198516,
0.054207854,
-0.0120644569,
0.0171321742,
-0.0243353359,
-0.0567051508,
0.0505039357,
-0.0289294459,
0.0278914887,
-0.0058799293,
-0.0161888413,
0.0766781494,
0.0486518331,
-0.0016845098,
0.0156275686,
0.0446470715,
-0.0143905887,
-0.0262236316,
0.014980128,
-0.0552679077,
0.0175838172,
-0.044857502,
0.0242099836,
0.0182585884,
0.0083998786,
-0.0587541386,
0.0057457057,
-0.007981848,
-0.0225837193,
-0.0377560519,
-0.0169489402,
0.0074599618,
0.0242740009,
-0.0371451937,
0.0351511501,
-0.0249152631,
-0.0274356995,
0.025621647,
-0.0509204119,
-0.0006506271,
0.0590982288,
2.061e-7,
0.0491509251,
-0.0076850043,
0.0464496873,
0.0287927873,
-0.0000523584,
0.0396720804,
-0.0288771857,
0.0202627089,
0.0106935706,
-0.0214752201,
0.0191018805,
0.0180258267,
0.0845893845,
-0.0340696163,
-0.0107955607,
0.0397702083,
-0.0495404378,
0.0071821474,
-0.0539044961,
0.0022961786,
0.077436924,
0.0401339494,
-0.0393977091,
-0.0223924667,
0.0239886194,
-0.0453329273,
0.0690077096,
-0.0130837271,
0.0059281331,
0.000128273,
-0.0038366376,
-0.022411298,
-0.0201823376,
0.0252886061,
-0.0012195436,
-0.0296437126,
0.0822312757,
0.0198802203,
-0.0106819645,
-0.0061403778,
-0.0548573509,
0.0342259593,
0.0111592133,
-0.0821196511,
0.0640390739,
-0.0751272738,
-0.0141200954,
-0.0261574239,
-0.0279573631,
0.002579822,
0.0202952251,
-0.0158184711,
-0.0283650383,
0.0410130359,
0.0897063315,
0.0048641204,
-0.0265717618,
-0.049903322,
-0.068834424,
-0.0094887298,
-0.0453820489,
0.0080004809,
-0.0739048049,
-0.0000017775,
0.0202301424,
-0.0541436933,
-0.0565812364,
1.302549334e-34,
0.0030696944,
-0.0028107443,
0.0088224532,
-0.022416953,
0.0248377062,
-0.0061181067,
-0.007676152,
-0.0263541117,
-0.0194831304,
-0.0639890432,
-0.0245482214
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10387v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10387v3 | Elaborative Simplification as Implicit Questions Under Discussion | 2023-05-17T17:26:16 | 2023-10-24T14:00:22 | Yating Wu, William Sheffield, Kyle Mahowald, Junyi Jessy Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automated text simplification, a technique useful for making text more
accessible to people such as children and emergent bilinguals, is often thought
of as a monolingual translation task from complex sentences to simplified
sentences using encoder-decoder models. This view fails to account for
elaborative simplification, where new information is added into the simplified
text. This paper proposes to view elaborative simplification through the lens
of the Question Under Discussion (QUD) framework, providing a robust way to
investigate what writers elaborate upon, how they elaborate, and how
elaborations fit into the discourse context by viewing elaborations as explicit
answers to implicit questions. We introduce ElabQUD, consisting of 1.3K
elaborations accompanied with implicit QUDs, to study these phenomena. We show
that explicitly modeling QUD (via question generation) not only provides
essential understanding of elaborative simplification and how the elaborations
connect with the rest of the discourse, but also substantially improves the
quality of elaboration generation. | [
0.0110201743,
0.005419964,
-0.0498752855,
0.0311179571,
-0.0112567255,
0.0161951929,
-0.0030476956,
-0.0119178137,
-0.0544027835,
-0.0077179661,
0.0328638032,
0.0526776314,
0.0455719903,
-0.0266849976,
0.0357100293,
-0.0772195905,
0.0136266416,
-0.0168011133,
-0.0006268299,
-0.030264698,
0.0286060497,
0.0155725144,
0.0022958363,
0.0202753954,
0.0277618654,
-0.024034705,
-0.0666790977,
0.0161772408,
-0.0001206956,
0.0343675874,
-0.0005902419,
0.0544430539,
0.0201180112,
-0.022859009,
0.0000020632,
-0.0102868062,
-0.0086573176,
-0.0136258155,
-0.0027919286,
0.0512429662,
0.0241813064,
-0.0281308535,
0.0329454318,
0.002471481,
-0.038086284,
-0.017903246,
0.0232246313,
0.0392160341,
0.0611906983,
0.0328345709,
-0.0180845093,
-0.0100563271,
-0.0311105829,
0.0321370587,
0.0066570858,
-0.0319647603,
-0.0221726652,
0.0203577187,
-0.0080041401,
0.0389598012,
0.0005564264,
0.0631991476,
0.0615639836,
-0.0501630045,
-0.0076996284,
-0.0017290721,
0.0026489929,
-0.0184376724,
0.0176793598,
0.052756194,
0.0298914164,
-0.0460518785,
-0.0128761632,
-0.0021232234,
0.0119868824,
0.066264838,
-0.0798689723,
0.0056306184,
-0.0156890824,
-0.0119159156,
-0.0001404799,
-0.0218034126,
-0.0010621474,
0.0093013737,
0.0292677116,
0.0244293921,
0.0083685936,
-0.0081741884,
-0.0395071693,
-0.0030820374,
-0.0011079347,
-0.1053605601,
0.0449464917,
0.0731682777,
-0.0120224236,
-0.0092362426,
-0.0303473882,
-0.0731407255,
-0.0023601463,
-0.0305770785,
0.012253006,
0.0269393455,
0.0022419658,
-0.0028944323,
-0.027770102,
0.0402539745,
-0.0069492082,
-0.0395901725,
-0.0509970449,
-0.0017424315,
0.0259124972,
-0.0209152214,
-0.0876037478,
0.0487867966,
-0.0627810955,
-0.0066603175,
0.0014347273,
0.0417416543,
0.0540392995,
-0.014332125,
-0.0461143181,
0.0119308913,
-0.0419168286,
0.0044246451,
-0.019428635,
0.0211371705,
-0.0885476619,
0.0177853312,
-0.0020773571,
-0.0054128729,
-0.0242138151,
0.0475110225,
0.0481127724,
0.0017402457,
-0.0640366897,
-0.0028028416,
-0.0430129431,
0.0281428937,
0.0100484556,
-0.0646540597,
0.0146113802,
-0.0379062817,
-0.0188338719,
-0.0500813499,
0.0158403143,
0.0314206406,
-0.0203948449,
-0.0128214108,
0.0016511353,
0.0316176564,
0.0116938185,
0.045280192,
-0.0319631062,
0.0250153299,
0.0508545078,
-0.001090261,
0.0100657307,
0.0476707481,
0.0392456576,
-0.0029846812,
0.0462402627,
-0.0207015648,
0.0423833877,
0.0069725518,
0.0146204969,
0.0151288947,
0.0280475449,
0.0134199392,
-0.0842029154,
0.0163407773,
0.0143172713,
0.0631934255,
-0.0515666902,
0.0248525105,
0.050244797,
0.0423897468,
-0.028947819,
0.0439122617,
0.0842150524,
0.040615771,
0.0208533518,
0.0978573561,
0.0389113985,
0.0310290046,
-0.0072369669,
0.0134516694,
0.0385894626,
-0.0176668428,
-0.0368817262,
-0.0830808282,
0.0150403781,
0.0115782442,
0.0797161534,
0.024533838,
-0.0076378076,
0.0490927212,
-0.0267794002,
0.0501443036,
-0.0237710681,
-0.0743783861,
0.0174894687,
-0.0259707868,
0.0477671549,
0.0316794515,
0.0222750381,
0.0180822592,
-0.0277676415,
-0.0184430387,
0.0330410711,
0.0526741222,
0.0288014207,
-0.0477082133,
0.0080233337,
-0.0474557616,
0.0023073892,
-0.0469365381,
0.0298361611,
-0.0130176581,
0.0022911832,
-0.0288983528,
0.0442092866,
-0.0504418425,
-0.0398230329,
0.0141741252,
-0.040204227,
-0.0255381539,
0.0186282489,
0.0249235146,
-0.0396342725,
0.0395907648,
0.0431636274,
0.0080020484,
0.022697201,
-0.0213875286,
-0.0427168086,
0.0389654413,
-0.034296196,
-0.0593061373,
-0.0200452376,
-0.0692597106,
-0.0076344861,
-0.0120606441,
-0.0390164033,
-0.0391250402,
0.0238621384,
-0.0573101975,
0.0519742854,
-0.0318746679,
0.0269729365,
-0.010553767,
-0.0258546937,
-0.0111030377,
0.0470861085,
0.0184220467,
0.0298239235,
0.0650840774,
-0.0200430285,
0.0393004678,
-0.0091911182,
0.0363313332,
-0.0451212488,
-0.011150931,
-0.0093852198,
0.0469625778,
0.0141337309,
-0.0081703858,
0.0122392485,
-0.1031306088,
-0.0168306231,
-0.0446630754,
0.0188795868,
0.0841492862,
0.0396761447,
0.0297442917,
-0.0086378669,
-0.0216161013,
-0.010406279,
-0.0336457156,
0.0109155606,
0.0838699415,
0.0088495435,
0.0211149342,
-0.0230209958,
0.0116280904,
0.0182774737,
0.0532467179,
0.0549938008,
-0.0301145222,
-0.0619056858,
-0.0007517019,
-0.0425624326,
-0.0277067889,
0.0002313607,
-0.0221456606,
0.0289346222,
0.0327386037,
0.0496951938,
0.0548479222,
0.0014672467,
0.0444444902,
0.01009773,
0.0004715016,
-0.0430723578,
0.0121224355,
-0.0292039588,
-0.0100407498,
-0.0059164269,
-0.0524646156,
0.0375724621,
0.063836202,
0.0107014142,
-0.0087223044,
-0.0669489428,
0.0227044467,
-0.0163092185,
-0.0241430122,
-0.0456084795,
-0.0682732835,
-0.0316017792,
0.0660933033,
-0.026797859,
-0.0255311374,
0.0674454793,
0.0038305826,
-0.0131114554,
-0.054558713,
0.0176738091,
-0.0312378388,
0.0343028158,
-0.0165192802,
0.0303102657,
0.0149626248,
-0.0288921911,
-0.0454215109,
0.0121986745,
0.0354058817,
-0.0112750623,
0.0729523376,
-0.072600998,
-0.0111724027,
0.012409036,
-0.0571754575,
-0.028784059,
-0.0196451787,
0.0348858312,
-0.0126218116,
0.0164765157,
-0.0236112196,
0.0025163549,
-0.0169677064,
0.0319544785,
0.06748496,
-0.0513407104,
-0.0095839994,
-0.0253809206,
0.0477600358,
0.0544802696,
0.0050547286,
0.0193032119,
-0.0704015046,
0.0438700132,
0.0453923605,
-0.0547315888,
0.0151449405,
0.0267642401,
-0.022129206,
-0.0147594493,
-0.0247377362,
-0.0141646042,
0.0064598448,
0.0848505348,
-0.0564414971,
-0.0140442112,
0.0840906426,
0.0353704393,
-0.0040680841,
0.013742419,
-0.0743523613,
0.0283520296,
0.0042630788,
0.0232882369,
-0.0958227217,
0.0062693423,
-0.0026021942,
-0.0042906334,
-0.0037079339,
-0.0082620783,
-0.0138148442,
-0.0586694218,
0.0209259056,
-0.0040736855,
-0.0674388185,
-0.0175349396,
-0.0340981148,
0.0105130291,
0.0578808077,
0.0423973203,
0.0295817759,
-0.0106176753,
0.0178141631,
-0.0290525574,
-0.0357387215,
-0.021831397,
-0.0597546473,
-0.0070687067,
-0.0419097431,
-0.0094371494,
0.0385537036,
0.0202011857,
0.0382873341,
0.0456400178,
-0.0096994713,
-0.0065679247,
-0.0111710597,
0.0527221449,
0.0223570559,
0.0262358729,
-0.0470196232,
0.0504530668,
0.0112764779,
0.007785283,
0.0430394635,
0.0109361755,
0.006379352,
-0.0275993105,
0.0186380595,
0.0180798247,
-0.0140519254,
0.0577434972,
0.0904845893,
-0.0089218207,
-0.0035455092,
-0.0502399318,
-0.0119958678,
-0.0732586458,
-0.0193571355,
-0.0039837668,
0.024677597,
-0.0222125407,
-0.1019226015,
-0.0794497281,
0.030047264,
-0.0299567543,
0.0241965521,
0.0254418813,
0.0365540013,
-0.0592236705,
-0.0408176742,
-0.0117499884,
0.0238952227,
-0.014762559,
0.0489869751,
-0.0237175599,
-0.040197622,
-0.0161263533,
0.0130508514,
0.0327676535,
-0.0723029822,
-0.0507385582,
-0.0531980321,
0.0198397692,
0.0160889048,
0.0793432817,
-0.0117091117,
-0.0514745228,
0.0257718861,
-0.0114345616,
-0.0271440521,
0.0441715457,
0.0043467376,
0.0162676759,
0.0107121505,
0.059402369,
-0.01558821,
-0.007004451,
-0.0458469652,
0.0120057808,
-0.0567602776,
-0.0576243289,
0.0211311895,
0.014798305,
-0.0297235399,
0.007974321,
0.0003252702,
-0.0234956276,
0.023631854,
-0.0825378373,
-0.0143118855,
-0.0372862108,
0.0370521396,
-0.0326959603,
0.0021396838,
-0.0121694393,
0.0271112993,
-0.029517062,
0.036096476,
-0.0279812776,
0.0217621252,
-0.0114022437,
-0.0062358971,
0.0091647767,
0.0146945864,
-0.0250087045,
0.0025940954,
-0.019868264,
0.0504598208,
-0.0101003889,
0.0444344878,
0.0027900364,
0.0338565595,
0.0034054834,
-0.004244525,
-0.0317618102,
-0.045488894,
0.0074175522,
0.0104097798,
-0.0007621123,
0.0099451719,
0.1051101685,
-0.0153280441,
-0.0186093859,
0.0132885519,
0.0623817854,
0.0115752928,
-0.0558744371,
0.0309831761,
0.0067253299,
-0.0146757551,
0.0372139923,
0.0501384735,
-0.0618789122,
0.0304564442,
-0.0125716822,
0.0074666734,
-0.0367000662,
-0.0500471666,
0.011405766,
0.0261238087,
-0.0000041119,
0.0032041159,
-0.0226823501,
-0.0430704765,
-0.0155605562,
-0.0056520337,
-0.0027334166,
-0.0469470881,
0.0140000554,
0.0563297495,
-0.0074808658,
-0.0719676688,
-0.0530395992,
0.0478307083,
-0.050589636,
-0.0349110104,
-0.0409197174,
-6.482430371e-33,
-0.035567455,
-0.0459480882,
0.0146074258,
-0.0101379016,
-0.0465608649,
0.023399232,
-0.0982178897,
0.0034117603,
0.0058190636,
0.044987645,
-0.0105182156,
0.0161745287,
0.0048362506,
0.0252762549,
-0.0200547706,
-0.0051056123,
0.0613606051,
0.0141394204,
-0.0389358997,
0.0344952568,
0.001546244,
-0.0303779822,
0.0248357784,
-0.0211086329,
0.0328712389,
-0.0464908518,
-0.0355356149,
0.011825026,
0.0203311183,
0.0303690042,
-0.0160700157,
0.0293030553,
0.0061127706,
-0.0041163662,
-0.0076455344,
0.0370370783,
-0.0662442744,
-0.0293648504,
0.0695800036,
0.0086319903,
-0.1253234893,
-0.0586117543,
0.0680812076,
-0.0100483261,
0.0289548133,
0.0047580441,
0.0391268507,
-0.000568915,
0.0039282981,
-0.0348093994,
-0.0595405772,
0.0135506336,
-0.0397093892,
-0.0108256033,
0.0023844109,
0.1016568094,
-0.0039968793,
-0.0535524115,
-0.0278038103,
0.0211505145,
0.0467347242,
0.0376453586,
0.0331812687,
-0.02607763,
0.0139644053,
-0.006048975,
-0.0261114165,
0.0091676041,
-0.0426127017,
0.05380968,
-0.0120051429,
-0.00937822,
0.0096463524,
0.0394379608,
0.0044307676,
0.0312067159,
-0.0287213977,
0.0273057874,
0.0004473697,
0.0380107276,
0.0218239445,
-0.0304697044,
-0.0342132226,
-0.041062396,
-0.0586308576,
0.0164585132,
-0.0058414945,
-0.0564232506,
0.0025902702,
-0.0064020562,
-0.0462058745,
-0.0303107314,
-0.0024244958,
-0.0213858001,
-0.0077327872,
-0.002871644,
-0.0379602313,
0.0323966108,
0.0010099629,
0.025501268,
0.0154448096,
0.0431610756,
0.0060972152,
0.0200957991,
0.0485840812,
0.0516141169,
0.0230037197,
0.0164825991,
-0.0474079289,
0.0078468127,
-0.0138972457,
0.0062610232,
-0.0400228575,
0.0116615687,
0.0052681277,
0.0547298528,
-0.0233957339,
0.0531475507,
0.0115510952,
-0.0124123897,
-0.0385519192,
-0.0060146619,
0.0257105157,
0.0227073636,
-0.0194775537,
0.0113520753,
-0.0126555869,
0.0186734237,
0.0191039443,
-0.0663897023,
-0.0285533238,
0.0186564028,
2.676e-7,
0.0497324467,
0.0531898439,
0.0491813123,
0.0107143568,
0.0201921593,
-0.0047042002,
0.0469213426,
-0.0216420982,
0.0200045295,
-0.0260722265,
0.0274912659,
0.0144258039,
0.0271919649,
0.0248520076,
-0.105609484,
-0.0093632033,
-0.044302702,
-0.0300188959,
-0.0275220815,
-0.0034696856,
0.0754551589,
0.0025937168,
-0.0289551206,
0.0215405561,
-0.0332019329,
0.0120790089,
0.0608852655,
0.0133481706,
-0.0133140292,
0.0433312319,
-0.0198572222,
-0.0121340984,
0.0076859454,
0.0123987775,
-0.0212993771,
0.0061784559,
-0.0005339209,
0.0895034522,
0.0010316116,
-0.009274506,
-0.0124886595,
-0.055707857,
0.0160686094,
-0.0616650432,
0.0681088269,
-0.0564729124,
-0.0058810879,
0.0324180387,
-0.0181067027,
0.0095968414,
-0.0011596843,
-0.0110918339,
-0.0558653437,
0.0528973304,
0.0083966441,
-0.01693701,
0.0105156489,
-0.0451378934,
-0.0397334509,
0.0067845397,
-0.0188434478,
0.0093499348,
-0.013446481,
0.0017178927,
-0.0172523707,
-0.0305441022,
0.0423514992,
2.133387937e-34,
0.0366597809,
-0.0006153076,
0.0266322251,
0.01634253,
0.0288811475,
-0.0350122638,
-0.029905146,
-0.0001736539,
0.0461725481,
-0.03808707,
-0.0318944827
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10384v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10384v1 | Logit-Based Ensemble Distribution Distillation for Robust Autoregressive Sequence Uncertainties | 2023-05-17T17:21:10 | 2023-05-17T17:21:10 | Yassir Fathullah, Guoxuan Xia, Mark Gales | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Efficiently and reliably estimating uncertainty is an important objective in
deep learning. It is especially pertinent to autoregressive sequence tasks,
where training and inference costs are typically very high. However, existing
research has predominantly focused on tasks with static data such as image
classification. In this work, we investigate Ensemble Distribution Distillation
(EDD) applied to large-scale natural language sequence-to-sequence data. EDD
aims to compress the superior uncertainty performance of an expensive (teacher)
ensemble into a cheaper (student) single model. Importantly, the ability to
separate knowledge (epistemic) and data (aleatoric) uncertainty is retained.
Existing probability-space approaches to EDD, however, are difficult to scale
to large vocabularies. We show, for modern transformer architectures on
large-scale translation tasks, that modelling the ensemble logits, instead of
softmax probabilities, leads to significantly better students. Moreover, the
students surprisingly even outperform Deep Ensembles by up to ~10% AUROC on
out-of-distribution detection, whilst matching them at in-distribution
translation. | [
0.0058490089,
0.1231016889,
0.0073772036,
-0.0095781842,
-0.0146388393,
0.0302175935,
-0.0122102266,
-0.0411182977,
-0.0663396046,
0.0025203582,
0.0248272475,
-0.1189038083,
0.0398013555,
0.0036554495,
0.0087729162,
-0.0329265594,
-0.0036633257,
-0.0182106979,
-0.0036387416,
-0.010222937,
-0.0160439778,
-0.0245108157,
-0.0098262597,
0.0401169062,
0.0178404674,
0.0071439771,
-0.037980549,
0.0156328753,
0.0277920477,
-0.0172828399,
0.0087102,
0.0766199529,
0.0285485983,
0.0383384749,
0.0000020042,
-0.0102342227,
-0.0354984067,
-0.021784395,
-0.0467657819,
0.0162901077,
-0.0405901372,
0.0252104867,
-0.0057972092,
0.0261293501,
-0.0073941858,
-0.0473689027,
0.0726285651,
-0.0048436825,
0.0223191325,
0.0539064482,
0.0173441116,
-0.0438422374,
0.0282749385,
-0.0557647012,
-0.009364441,
-0.0233953185,
-0.0021072936,
-0.0397057831,
-0.006535951,
0.0064683198,
-0.0335173756,
0.036516808,
0.0490357839,
-0.0090267509,
-0.0249488484,
-0.0038483217,
-0.0542893112,
-0.0754754394,
-0.0066871038,
0.0663281456,
-0.0303011332,
-0.0049237036,
-0.0126941623,
-0.0192887001,
0.0275867227,
0.0040428378,
-0.0013789866,
0.0503254272,
0.0035404966,
0.029570898,
-0.0351241678,
0.0317500085,
0.0463491045,
-0.0059276144,
-0.0758062229,
0.0101043377,
-0.028302202,
0.0168553218,
-0.0128440708,
0.0258603115,
-0.0694441572,
-0.0385688804,
0.0276019536,
0.0206943285,
0.0000731292,
-0.0008021126,
-0.0403930843,
-0.032550443,
-0.0158460531,
0.0550018549,
0.0154320262,
0.0313408524,
0.0006400766,
-0.0193095505,
0.0189885832,
0.0615396723,
-0.0097763017,
-0.0075788372,
-0.0082992157,
0.0005304024,
-0.0375091992,
0.0303656943,
-0.0065320535,
0.0148897721,
-0.0446779765,
0.0018011067,
-0.0541873761,
-0.0368150845,
-0.0078058336,
0.0145965768,
0.0470337234,
0.0595825389,
-0.0520984568,
0.0019918045,
-0.0033476548,
0.050258901,
0.0188425034,
-0.010312058,
0.0609135814,
-0.064103663,
-0.0228085052,
0.013682805,
-0.0003873274,
-0.0028460019,
-0.0091318814,
0.0131541612,
-0.0151989534,
-0.0568536445,
-0.0054769637,
0.0040253932,
-0.0676756948,
-0.0634873509,
0.0213199798,
-0.0937002748,
0.0033019397,
-0.0107293483,
0.0169553477,
-0.068524383,
0.0402702503,
-0.0203448161,
0.0274488498,
0.0890417695,
0.0374446921,
-0.0362426899,
0.005967021,
0.0272826683,
0.0155257573,
0.0573660843,
0.0429881886,
0.0454292111,
-0.0022367281,
0.0263431631,
0.0234476496,
0.0013729098,
0.0249713156,
0.007032983,
-0.0055553275,
-0.0239444505,
-0.0334130526,
0.0079293298,
0.0250312462,
0.0550385304,
-0.0157789961,
-0.029470738,
0.0831570923,
-0.0168917496,
0.0304034725,
-0.0166530795,
0.0038486186,
0.0017500925,
-0.0220608823,
0.0324212834,
-0.0380865373,
0.0434494019,
0.0448598713,
0.0144004393,
0.0349799283,
0.0753867179,
-0.0180409756,
-0.0458383821,
-0.0102306185,
0.0036225384,
-0.0187111553,
0.0310023315,
0.0289513227,
0.0008291673,
-0.0120042423,
0.0417236164,
-0.0198803078,
-0.0235220231,
0.0301165693,
-0.0128233405,
-0.0182361379,
0.0000283131,
0.0124588199,
-0.0188407302,
-0.0027824307,
-0.0613761917,
-0.0012722965,
0.0175165404,
-0.0102043105,
0.0105052954,
0.0384163857,
-0.0467236526,
-0.0518430322,
0.0273707267,
0.0070663737,
0.0162169375,
0.0388280116,
0.0501833893,
0.0347529054,
-0.0328248665,
-0.0205391794,
0.0092140874,
-0.0182503406,
-0.0754751489,
0.0589684322,
0.024018174,
0.0651628152,
-0.0046484824,
-0.0464099832,
0.0027590301,
0.0270250738,
-0.0244896654,
-0.0762370229,
-0.0009969628,
-0.0644885525,
-0.0572856367,
0.0601202436,
-0.0321419612,
0.0034703803,
-0.0300788712,
-0.0546515509,
-0.0651463717,
0.0038318813,
-0.0226869378,
-0.023686897,
-0.0347612575,
0.0550645813,
0.0516232103,
0.097556144,
-0.0326706953,
0.0117703164,
-0.0481707007,
-0.0364214033,
-0.0448067822,
0.001545738,
0.0122060357,
-0.0078304429,
-0.0174566563,
0.0385791138,
0.0019463173,
0.003932632,
0.0532127656,
-0.0236355942,
-0.0081719346,
-0.0325190127,
0.0031858033,
0.0202606376,
-0.0584449954,
0.0325754099,
-0.0057839626,
0.0397933647,
0.0169687755,
0.0003305164,
-0.0316303968,
0.0041810037,
0.0004005623,
-0.0151902186,
0.0163680576,
-0.0017382518,
-0.0068220943,
-0.0040837363,
-0.0202184003,
0.0236418545,
0.0399285816,
-0.042391941,
-0.0104259616,
-0.0459267795,
-0.0072805891,
-0.027182484,
0.0045364252,
0.0003448843,
-0.0519112982,
0.0037481564,
-0.0185611509,
0.0325071178,
0.0333482847,
-0.0023145527,
0.0108612143,
0.0463016517,
-0.0173871592,
-0.0366193391,
0.0071869334,
-0.0298453942,
-0.0054108552,
0.0107289897,
-0.0193858016,
-0.0476700179,
0.0402962528,
-0.0280504972,
-0.0281949379,
-0.0450166613,
-0.0231525246,
0.0177640412,
-0.0186049975,
-0.0082498463,
0.0064759469,
-0.0045678797,
0.0318129174,
-0.0182200763,
-0.0316089876,
0.0820200443,
-0.0407832451,
0.0035913424,
-0.0452078842,
-0.0404882208,
0.0019594475,
0.0407003537,
-0.0042527644,
-0.0169903245,
0.0346999615,
-0.0129560251,
-0.0705314726,
-0.0217314791,
0.0291898977,
-0.0363816731,
0.0669022426,
-0.0781967118,
0.0044383393,
-0.0287064556,
-0.0251491182,
-0.0320314169,
-0.0101685645,
0.0133150956,
0.0159900598,
0.0234526303,
-0.0791678652,
-0.0892808363,
-0.0150557468,
0.0153928818,
0.0584178753,
-0.0120177958,
-0.0011425301,
-0.0026618822,
0.0602206588,
0.0144231217,
0.0012988099,
0.0590020344,
-0.0354734063,
0.0142819909,
0.0353822373,
0.0186453313,
0.0042007319,
-0.0507699586,
-0.0226705,
0.0353851058,
-0.0191833097,
-0.0237992983,
0.0282928143,
0.0604749806,
-0.0381487831,
-0.0151758967,
0.0801059902,
-0.0176313873,
-0.0137973558,
0.0037826363,
0.0629920587,
0.0767223537,
0.0012342483,
-0.0164684244,
-0.0723905563,
-0.0473628007,
0.0096275201,
0.017645292,
0.022335697,
-0.03506805,
-0.0069296858,
-0.0612851121,
0.0253152214,
0.0158270225,
-0.044497367,
-0.0603587851,
-0.0375835411,
0.0013877909,
-0.0441962667,
0.0291415304,
-0.0137663316,
0.0133894542,
0.0228262935,
0.0451541357,
-0.0128597822,
-0.0775224641,
-0.040335115,
-0.039229732,
0.0253887512,
0.0644047484,
0.0149079552,
0.0078061875,
-0.019983856,
-0.0482076183,
-0.055010505,
0.0074350876,
0.0385811515,
0.0579299554,
0.0395787098,
-0.011897238,
0.0429858416,
0.0354535691,
-0.059630461,
0.0199743994,
-0.0187610816,
0.0455020443,
-0.0298860632,
-0.0332752466,
-0.0205874834,
-0.0453983769,
0.0568161793,
0.0503665134,
0.0053986213,
-0.0045825532,
-0.0301872939,
-0.0389767103,
-0.0039572753,
-0.0256072525,
0.0533960462,
0.0042819981,
0.0188417453,
-0.0728378668,
-0.080831103,
-0.0305049717,
0.008664229,
0.049171906,
-0.0284051895,
-0.0185659472,
0.0168050863,
0.0375264697,
-0.0655177459,
-0.0138571383,
0.0177381951,
0.0363930948,
-0.0203096494,
0.0401476957,
0.0227532648,
0.0208413173,
-0.0055711693,
0.0731238872,
-0.1252762675,
-0.0954705849,
0.0108129457,
0.0177798662,
0.0152536705,
0.0209174957,
0.022490846,
-0.0356271528,
0.0845073014,
0.0903999433,
0.0366063863,
-0.0089651784,
0.0298335552,
-0.0409059823,
-0.0186922792,
0.0326187536,
-0.0073827649,
0.0232991874,
0.0032696344,
0.0423316211,
-0.0317614637,
-0.08925879,
-0.0056247753,
0.0153515721,
0.0447448343,
-0.050338421,
-0.015245677,
0.0143010383,
0.0257135108,
0.0399541631,
0.0038710323,
-0.0246304739,
0.0212965813,
0.080934979,
-0.0105014006,
0.0059958706,
0.0803015083,
0.0539803021,
-0.0069084559,
-0.0044711814,
0.0196354408,
0.0258768965,
-0.0042605768,
0.0176659096,
0.0187858995,
0.0314636044,
0.0326809548,
0.0386101231,
0.051968623,
0.0005452012,
0.0305743665,
0.022580348,
0.0517382585,
0.0160452891,
-0.003704638,
-0.0957306102,
-0.0208937116,
-0.0355891734,
0.0211051218,
0.0391657725,
0.009598271,
0.0419047885,
-0.0301344153,
-0.0152276019,
-0.0334892422,
0.0074968543,
-0.0220259689,
0.0442624763,
0.0339418687,
0.0173657387,
-0.0002867656,
0.0472332425,
0.0632806569,
-0.0131188072,
0.0424485132,
-0.0044029043,
-0.001156231,
-0.0200539548,
-0.0461574756,
-0.0094639165,
-0.0183345191,
0.0119802067,
0.0046666795,
0.031726826,
-0.053653881,
0.0021557505,
0.0087675611,
0.0181770418,
-0.0179181527,
0.0266547129,
0.0372784324,
-0.0173361879,
0.013529622,
-0.0190366749,
0.0001073615,
0.010426743,
0.002459286,
-0.0237286352,
-6.295812561e-33,
0.0161979757,
-0.0209709574,
-0.0169792213,
-0.0374866687,
0.0088930773,
-0.0155548928,
0.0115392311,
-0.0008994913,
-0.0123621114,
0.0386910103,
-0.024718374,
0.0359105393,
0.0253235642,
0.0638249964,
0.0056808679,
0.0068820002,
0.103970401,
0.0030170716,
-0.0192080885,
0.0277931597,
0.0614918731,
0.0454836749,
0.0763676539,
-0.0522083491,
-0.0051345541,
0.0267879702,
-0.0081189089,
-0.0161211081,
0.0027623351,
0.0006721501,
0.0152544593,
0.0576156564,
-0.0368193053,
-0.0456208587,
-0.0498930216,
-0.0501080267,
-0.0952961817,
-0.0327085033,
-0.0387238078,
0.0173228458,
0.0237299036,
-0.0149547169,
0.0554371923,
-0.0161615554,
0.0058834022,
-0.0410255902,
0.0027093142,
-0.0277936328,
-0.0049026161,
-0.0895278528,
0.0105206389,
0.0293180086,
-0.0129218753,
-0.0309096575,
0.0292860661,
0.0231519025,
-0.0102948304,
0.0010619914,
-0.0509054959,
0.0016803547,
0.01343715,
0.0833209455,
0.0518071689,
0.033083275,
-0.0063778101,
0.004865082,
-0.0152274547,
-0.0379882678,
-0.0305053405,
-0.0243151654,
0.0116378311,
0.0162467565,
0.0230311975,
0.0699299276,
0.0806177929,
0.0092775663,
-0.0740382969,
0.0337265767,
0.0077026812,
0.0091784513,
0.0022691318,
0.0300858635,
-0.0035448186,
-0.0213049147,
-0.0431200713,
-0.0477825366,
0.0156266615,
0.006893442,
0.0176443905,
0.0363908075,
-0.0213398281,
0.0385196097,
0.0484245792,
-0.031260062,
-0.0440898612,
0.0278255846,
-0.006461239,
-0.0238326211,
0.0182814002,
-0.0146876769,
-0.0393242724,
0.0034405235,
0.027354395,
0.062403664,
-0.0330955759,
0.0022395591,
0.0428618826,
0.0440925658,
-0.0498087443,
0.0154341087,
-0.0318699144,
0.0685566664,
-0.0029131104,
0.0392825119,
0.0307696126,
-0.0425141454,
-0.0120824929,
0.0086954599,
-0.0194401499,
0.0177019183,
0.00717167,
0.0398832932,
0.0368011519,
0.0269859247,
-0.0337122269,
-0.0020895719,
-0.0220582467,
-0.0295047853,
0.0373018347,
-0.0437576137,
-0.0087487465,
0.0131066507,
2.797e-7,
0.0305960104,
0.0026787075,
0.0417238958,
-0.0322957262,
0.000514099,
0.027349038,
-0.0119973663,
-0.0259663817,
-0.0149462605,
-0.0734954551,
0.0121261403,
0.0344191864,
0.0508303456,
0.036870461,
-0.0582050979,
-0.0283092055,
-0.0500155799,
0.0162547957,
0.0039783493,
-0.049300205,
0.0300475601,
0.1329406947,
-0.0008524635,
-0.0185090266,
0.0353528783,
-0.0189107489,
0.015008226,
0.0274918303,
0.0507836677,
0.0154138692,
0.0463537537,
-0.0089172628,
-0.0135831488,
0.0177636296,
-0.0259133372,
0.0089094276,
-0.0126946578,
0.034556102,
0.0018472045,
-0.01374665,
-0.0015810952,
0.0023286347,
0.0109395357,
-0.0531913489,
0.018257603,
-0.076256901,
-0.0099629806,
-0.0135586923,
-0.0579491518,
-0.0203719214,
0.0678615123,
0.00610606,
0.0547964349,
0.0193565376,
-0.0112594422,
0.0087402929,
-0.0284241121,
-0.0956267342,
0.0008215961,
0.0034078276,
-0.0271411464,
-0.015824711,
-0.0373425968,
-0.0255668946,
0.0092360573,
-0.0055525671,
-0.0413637869,
2.408803509e-34,
0.0329897106,
0.0140076317,
-0.0168938562,
-0.0340476334,
0.0085648093,
-0.0275311489,
-0.0642185435,
-0.0113578197,
0.0078557776,
-0.0356115028,
-0.038618166
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10383v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10383v2 | Large-Scale Text Analysis Using Generative Language Models: A Case Study in Discovering Public Value Expressions in AI Patents | 2023-05-17T17:18:26 | 2023-05-18T12:34:47 | Sergio Pelaez, Gaurav Verma, Barbara Ribeiro, Philip Shapira | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Labeling data is essential for training text classifiers but is often
difficult to accomplish accurately, especially for complex and abstract
concepts. Seeking an improved method, this paper employs a novel approach using
a generative language model (GPT-4) to produce labels and rationales for
large-scale text analysis. We apply this approach to the task of discovering
public value expressions in US AI patents. We collect a database comprising
154,934 patent documents using an advanced Boolean query submitted to
InnovationQ+. The results are merged with full patent text from the USPTO,
resulting in 5.4 million sentences. We design a framework for identifying and
labeling public value expressions in these AI patent sentences. A prompt for
GPT-4 is developed which includes definitions, guidelines, examples, and
rationales for text classification. We evaluate the quality of the labels and
rationales produced by GPT-4 using BLEU scores and topic modeling and find that
they are accurate, diverse, and faithful. These rationales also serve as a
chain-of-thought for the model, a transparent mechanism for human verification,
and support for human annotators to overcome cognitive limitations. We conclude
that GPT-4 achieved a high-level of recognition of public value theory from our
framework, which it also uses to discover unseen public value expressions. We
use the labels produced by GPT-4 to train BERT-based classifiers and predict
sentences on the entire database, achieving high F1 scores for the 3-class
(0.85) and 2-class classification (0.91) tasks. We discuss the implications of
our approach for conducting large-scale text analyses with complex and abstract
concepts and suggest that, with careful framework design and interactive human
oversight, generative language models can offer significant advantages in
quality and in reduced time and costs for producing labels and rationales. | [
0.0466955341,
0.0803921968,
-0.0095402086,
-0.009213225,
-0.0471746773,
-0.0100080371,
0.0223554205,
0.0015015947,
0.0043258979,
-0.0844421014,
0.0245048497,
-0.0071573295,
-0.0272343177,
0.0624712631,
0.0015257176,
-0.0407262444,
0.0319532044,
0.0284321085,
0.0932085216,
0.0053081727,
0.0183632616,
0.0467082188,
-0.0104244212,
0.0444943793,
-0.0260995794,
-0.0097904792,
0.0213730279,
-0.0280694626,
0.0384551808,
-0.0741472766,
-0.0170925967,
0.0517074689,
0.0280263163,
-0.0021304153,
0.0000018993,
-0.0866151974,
-0.0398448296,
0.0213280618,
0.0265119057,
0.0384142883,
0.0671337321,
0.0394474007,
-0.0146503281,
0.033307083,
-0.0478033982,
0.0126938345,
0.0085916324,
0.0625954121,
0.0191319566,
0.062854521,
-0.0353669226,
-0.0302283634,
0.0469527543,
-0.0475210287,
0.0319667086,
-0.0837662071,
0.0368189663,
0.0121381879,
0.0331581533,
0.0197728071,
0.0252539087,
0.0251535885,
-0.0215289313,
-0.0447087958,
0.0604591072,
0.0448112227,
-0.0056719584,
0.0088747656,
-0.0110148937,
0.0447439291,
0.0663451999,
-0.0293476321,
0.05743118,
-0.0242457129,
0.0312827006,
-0.0082421638,
-0.0225928295,
0.0716819391,
-0.0216705948,
0.0309480093,
0.0590233468,
-0.006003099,
-0.001073458,
0.0304347575,
0.0012204398,
0.0183003116,
0.0127272932,
-0.0483164303,
0.0035338646,
-0.0092599094,
-0.0290763061,
-0.0701783299,
0.0408091545,
0.0237515252,
0.0562445447,
0.037536189,
-0.0571373403,
-0.0598075911,
0.0257173702,
-0.0565756895,
-0.0244035497,
-0.0104096029,
-0.0162842572,
0.0605081767,
-0.035299249,
0.0264523849,
-0.0202964824,
0.0126963528,
-0.0119768726,
-0.0175574552,
-0.0775540993,
-0.0254371744,
-0.040104866,
0.0702986792,
-0.0229532029,
-0.0383270979,
-0.0369800664,
0.0091619613,
-0.0259164069,
0.0200587679,
-0.015890548,
0.017007472,
0.0075985203,
-0.0217153765,
-0.0362421647,
-0.021027578,
-0.027796112,
0.0135369496,
-0.021720795,
-0.0223582014,
0.0211382732,
0.0230762959,
0.0302863698,
-0.012499704,
-0.002330835,
0.0003735175,
0.0202462468,
-0.0408597253,
-0.0298155118,
-0.0259838942,
0.0000013171,
-0.0042986115,
-0.0040235836,
-0.0184454042,
-0.016324738,
-0.0087738689,
-0.0059943898,
-0.0461064465,
0.0214470085,
0.0213746745,
-0.0052703973,
0.0339976922,
-0.0015826152,
-0.0164796356,
0.0117498124,
-0.0083264681,
0.0390363634,
-0.0061512045,
0.0511186086,
0.0362112671,
0.0414777696,
-0.0256936941,
0.0382078923,
-0.0016215268,
0.0117262164,
-0.0263637975,
0.0045003626,
0.02658277,
-0.0098374682,
0.0193503518,
-0.0165709034,
0.062607713,
0.0045825462,
0.0520411246,
0.0600996464,
0.075301148,
-0.0047709155,
0.0058199931,
-0.0197969265,
0.0540202819,
-0.0119290957,
-0.0700853616,
0.0343713313,
0.0147829568,
-0.0421456993,
0.0140743731,
0.0126907388,
0.0050796699,
0.0010477705,
-0.0770256221,
-0.0341930911,
0.022242818,
0.0233305395,
-0.020522831,
0.076571852,
-0.0040079211,
-0.0655367598,
0.0048164022,
-0.0045433026,
-0.0566877127,
0.0034711217,
-0.0584784262,
0.0447357185,
0.0579202995,
0.0572959818,
-0.0390667766,
0.0181072727,
-0.0380696245,
-0.0348925963,
0.0593245737,
0.0437460616,
-0.0289587062,
-0.0771790072,
-0.0299148113,
-0.0196971335,
-0.022877099,
0.0256552175,
0.0142147373,
-0.0223326664,
0.0226802416,
0.0141066751,
-0.0817926154,
0.0131059596,
0.0546642765,
0.001836999,
-0.0457160063,
0.0464956239,
-0.0081775589,
0.0211827178,
0.0525813624,
-0.0185276307,
0.0365967304,
0.0277835559,
-0.0368917882,
-0.0481742062,
0.0072635035,
0.0308903567,
0.017321378,
0.0064622583,
-0.0376346558,
-0.0125398869,
-0.0072181723,
-0.0461663306,
-0.0190606862,
0.0021428885,
-0.0256525036,
0.0108820032,
-0.0855060294,
-0.0426790379,
-0.0072874064,
-0.0097186482,
-0.0434611514,
0.091874294,
0.0074587646,
-0.0347238742,
-0.0246596653,
-0.0198232923,
0.0540199466,
-0.0518107153,
0.0128489668,
-0.0036664049,
-0.0269115604,
0.0245605931,
0.0446965583,
-0.021887714,
0.0240358654,
-0.0017798363,
-0.0948385894,
0.0055698194,
-0.0108557567,
0.0324275419,
0.012861535,
-0.0158524662,
0.0032129958,
0.0231185108,
-0.0308047477,
-0.0436681584,
-0.0086923521,
-0.0356977694,
0.0647123307,
-0.0003403075,
-0.0121331587,
-0.0141397379,
0.0021964714,
-0.0672900602,
0.0121894367,
0.0609072857,
-0.0008247434,
-0.0299725998,
0.0143379122,
0.0005726522,
0.0061853467,
-0.00209613,
0.0263919905,
0.0023633121,
-0.0029013383,
-0.0097818319,
0.0278617423,
0.0575033017,
0.0679351985,
0.0213958714,
0.0340787657,
-0.0417037718,
0.0287465304,
-0.0152813541,
0.0589469932,
0.0005338294,
-0.0105860978,
0.0749523789,
0.0264156964,
0.0185369793,
-0.0142196361,
-0.0857010186,
0.0037966373,
-0.0239432063,
-0.0028512385,
-0.0287638772,
-0.0105150091,
0.0042098491,
0.0600717366,
0.0091790408,
-0.0529905111,
0.0510590039,
-0.0131340269,
0.0309705939,
-0.0780601799,
-0.0090601165,
-0.0373611599,
0.0798327923,
-0.0352300406,
-0.0018091932,
0.0203866754,
-0.0156088574,
0.0335002318,
-0.0130681638,
0.0240622517,
-0.0275564026,
0.0323463455,
-0.0551622473,
0.0572705902,
-0.0023303449,
-0.0239710957,
-0.0076149418,
-0.0550770052,
-0.0082706334,
0.0162711069,
0.0382303447,
-0.0043426729,
-0.0129908416,
0.0031402144,
0.0131269321,
-0.002787922,
0.0082677407,
-0.0045521581,
-0.0129214423,
0.0436987914,
0.0575404949,
-0.0541411489,
-0.0125827575,
-0.0072819255,
-0.0409393087,
0.0027984288,
0.0222293623,
0.0325978473,
-0.021728972,
-0.0402021222,
-0.009632078,
-0.0631584078,
0.0062894239,
0.0153619321,
0.0024118833,
-0.0072843735,
0.034192577,
0.0966660529,
0.0187314786,
0.0438013263,
0.0145949684,
0.0317117907,
-0.0070720389,
-0.0024978512,
0.0453412086,
-0.1099307686,
0.0109346826,
-0.0381176844,
0.010141789,
-0.0186318625,
-0.0078554517,
-0.0264240149,
-0.1472605765,
0.0687650442,
-0.0212808512,
0.0202189963,
-0.0246228613,
-0.0416861475,
-0.0206724815,
-0.0233765226,
-0.0452107415,
-0.0284511764,
-0.0110191591,
0.0090309633,
0.028983254,
-0.0351098441,
-0.0221766476,
0.0286099296,
-0.0111047942,
-0.0130372159,
0.0806282908,
0.0546420626,
-0.0246485081,
-0.061347831,
-0.0059678676,
-0.0132942889,
-0.0086100111,
0.0174514987,
0.0339901149,
-0.0223465245,
0.0124563649,
0.0030334538,
0.037215624,
-0.0302548595,
-0.0279124044,
0.025772661,
0.0624758266,
-0.0432536379,
-0.036362607,
-0.040269278,
-0.0149710635,
-0.000419094,
0.0730851963,
0.0016054427,
-0.0373524353,
-0.0404166989,
-0.0374357328,
0.0322033837,
-0.102773495,
0.0240596663,
-0.0432973318,
-0.0042413464,
-0.0391577706,
-0.0899859294,
-0.020139575,
0.0038353282,
0.0192071144,
0.0216943137,
0.0063594645,
0.0462548099,
0.0118769268,
-0.0178793203,
0.0386139527,
-0.0027065736,
0.0005362242,
-0.0282460768,
-0.0246750377,
0.0363735035,
-0.0382212847,
-0.0590418875,
0.0230038539,
-0.0234011225,
-0.049623441,
-0.018778611,
-0.0134092495,
0.0183626171,
-0.0217070803,
-0.0471226946,
-0.0142998798,
0.0762190893,
0.0646060482,
-0.0030609423,
-0.0333302319,
0.0257926062,
-0.0192299001,
-0.0110895941,
-0.0144169126,
-0.0354236513,
0.0419276021,
-0.0016969214,
0.0485116579,
-0.006417322,
-0.0246398691,
0.0254259109,
0.0308692846,
0.0391661525,
0.0095021408,
-0.0031990111,
-0.0741816685,
-0.0264055189,
-0.0061664297,
-0.02131458,
-0.0574032217,
-0.003282943,
0.0362934507,
-0.0353440829,
-0.0636372566,
0.0224744361,
-0.0273286346,
0.0395020247,
-0.0385548584,
0.0267564189,
-0.0153631615,
0.0371427052,
-0.0075045181,
-0.0504753217,
0.0115496535,
0.0130893858,
-0.0250717103,
0.0386361666,
-0.0135358758,
0.0303458218,
0.0214917175,
-0.0138049591,
0.0291217789,
0.022274375,
-0.0381573774,
-0.0357654206,
-0.0451171547,
0.0441755913,
0.0161915682,
0.0347011611,
0.0329551995,
-0.0553821065,
-0.0120008597,
-0.0101671796,
0.0654686391,
0.0178814959,
-0.0584254004,
0.0062076831,
0.0152233019,
-0.0337877795,
-0.0428042077,
0.0180004332,
0.0070629921,
0.0342098959,
-0.0166011453,
-0.013939118,
-0.0649128184,
-0.0105763189,
0.0343662836,
0.0139875608,
-0.0115269125,
0.0102759749,
-0.0689445138,
0.0037618009,
0.0304638613,
0.0333349742,
0.0127092851,
-0.0045083952,
0.0309666973,
0.080272004,
-0.0277196076,
-0.0431035459,
-0.0774359629,
-0.0098894676,
-0.0559930131,
-0.0287020933,
-0.0523100905,
-5.954177536e-33,
-0.0005887183,
-0.0463754535,
0.0127288559,
-0.0062256525,
0.008184582,
-0.0173533354,
-0.0508199371,
-0.027606599,
0.0174096841,
0.0232811142,
-0.0144005679,
-0.0066879056,
0.0109831197,
0.0303546451,
0.0332417749,
0.0063722762,
0.0457059368,
-0.0067801569,
-0.0331611,
0.0473757684,
0.0340472162,
0.0164343528,
0.0450027436,
-0.0848824158,
0.0341218784,
0.0254206769,
-0.0498705395,
-0.0066282731,
-0.0233987588,
0.0365422107,
-0.0248706136,
0.0207888037,
0.0171610881,
-0.06700138,
0.0226732548,
0.0377056859,
-0.043766778,
-0.0004236925,
-0.0309574436,
-0.0553198792,
-0.0057183998,
-0.0330480784,
0.0131309899,
0.0061188261,
-0.035055235,
0.0394573584,
0.0901784524,
0.0025190488,
-0.0016189298,
-0.0821459219,
-0.0849659219,
0.0389752425,
-0.0277021062,
0.0271160938,
0.0297916885,
0.0116567733,
-0.0138284471,
0.07234364,
-0.0260357298,
0.0307499915,
0.0030187769,
-0.029586941,
0.0265537817,
-0.03838633,
0.0286643617,
0.0230779145,
-0.0229136944,
0.0338922031,
-0.016722016,
-0.0061852545,
0.0058161193,
0.0494057983,
0.0238142665,
0.0186658464,
0.0504085682,
-0.0113132773,
-0.0420602746,
0.0415290445,
-0.0236793049,
-0.016790716,
0.0230573583,
0.0007346295,
-0.0187924355,
-0.0003259752,
0.008220627,
-0.0130494935,
-0.0059153968,
0.0326873884,
0.0105193509,
0.0093487361,
-0.0445894599,
0.0362809859,
0.0078205373,
-0.0342525877,
-0.0428194627,
-0.0029975325,
0.0131153855,
0.0493249372,
-0.005055896,
-0.021734789,
-0.0945077538,
-0.0349620134,
0.0209692325,
0.0186423715,
0.0132581238,
-0.0025946361,
0.0118058268,
-0.0402195007,
-0.0303171966,
0.0145738721,
-0.0039776131,
0.0087329047,
-0.0209204946,
0.0207768828,
-0.0031533672,
0.0490538031,
0.0332223102,
0.0192762576,
0.0172395166,
0.0224871691,
-0.0341032892,
-0.0376788974,
-0.0019672227,
-0.0182061233,
-0.0028044707,
0.0064277095,
0.0026771636,
0.0405831598,
0.0428677313,
-0.0221589375,
0.0034174577,
0.039187558,
2.68e-7,
0.069741182,
0.0668868944,
0.0257103313,
0.0219100229,
-0.0105761737,
0.0616572388,
0.0324008018,
0.0504636653,
-0.0172168184,
-0.0195810702,
0.0337393917,
-0.0010068521,
0.0331052132,
0.0154600758,
-0.0735122412,
-0.0213621054,
-0.0369833186,
-0.0220220014,
-0.0656627342,
0.0397572443,
0.1007903367,
0.0278992094,
0.0265946072,
0.0054347627,
0.0140905594,
-0.0243861582,
0.061541751,
0.0008320356,
0.0121382223,
0.0267965551,
0.0661732629,
-0.0082270969,
-0.0342621543,
0.0203005318,
-0.0369529352,
0.0315112509,
-0.0078437841,
0.0541246496,
-0.0221711304,
0.0056251166,
-0.0214281175,
-0.0195315648,
-0.0018770974,
-0.0433601998,
0.0286760814,
-0.0073395665,
-0.0125582078,
-0.0298969708,
-0.0180736203,
0.0118919592,
-0.012208838,
0.0008373666,
-0.0161733404,
-0.0253101289,
-0.01153241,
-0.0168244429,
-0.0076336465,
-0.0705633461,
0.0419277772,
-0.0142984744,
-0.0427597575,
0.0301341172,
-0.0163108036,
0.061939586,
0.04017663,
-0.0531907789,
0.0348529816,
2.35580731e-34,
0.0455112755,
-0.0405514427,
-0.0435925052,
-0.0203786064,
0.0922177285,
0.053942427,
0.0170570072,
0.0116491094,
-0.0172048453,
-0.0737592503,
0.0062795891
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10355v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10355v3 | Evaluating Object Hallucination in Large Vision-Language Models | 2023-05-17T16:34:01 | 2023-10-26T02:52:40 | Yifan Li, Yifan Du, Kun Zhou, Jinpeng Wang, Wayne Xin Zhao, Ji-Rong Wen | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.MM | Inspired by the superior language abilities of large language models (LLM),
large vision-language models (LVLM) have been recently explored by integrating
powerful LLMs for improving the performance on complex multimodal tasks.
Despite the promising progress on LVLMs, we find that LVLMs suffer from the
hallucination problem, i.e. they tend to generate objects that are inconsistent
with the target images in the descriptions. To investigate it, this work
presents the first systematic study on object hallucination of LVLMs. We
conduct the evaluation experiments on several representative LVLMs, and show
that they mostly suffer from severe object hallucination issue. We further
discuss that the visual instructions may influence the hallucination, and find
that: objects that frequently occur in the visual instructions or co-occur with
the image objects, are obviously prone to be hallucinated by LVLMs. Besides, we
find that existing evaluation methods might be affected by the input
instructions and generation styles of LVLMs. Thus, we further design an
improved evaluation method for object hallucination by proposing a
polling-based query method called POPE. Experiment results demonstrate that our
POPE can evaluate the object hallucination in a more stable and flexible way.
Our codes and data are publicly available at https://github.com/RUCAIBox/POPE. | [
0.0018303015,
0.0552243292,
0.009999359,
0.0680147409,
-0.051647108,
0.0205041301,
0.0062623774,
0.0150284888,
0.0107414024,
-0.0589361675,
-0.0227983538,
-0.0673645362,
0.0102022756,
-0.0212368052,
0.0134575423,
-0.069050841,
0.0250915084,
-0.0685264245,
-0.0751776844,
-0.013882434,
-0.0389337204,
-0.0261779297,
-0.0077883154,
0.0308419038,
-0.0108470116,
-0.0419336185,
-0.0370435081,
0.0172005408,
-0.0040643825,
-0.0117760096,
-0.0496335402,
0.0402701832,
0.007346489,
0.0393657871,
0.0000021494,
-0.062257193,
0.0096212327,
0.0111660007,
0.047878515,
-0.0075153857,
0.0426401161,
-0.0224098358,
-0.0161175579,
-0.0086760065,
-0.0101155434,
-0.0056729862,
0.0897257626,
0.0641139597,
0.0502347723,
0.0285390411,
-0.0028788059,
-0.0266226064,
0.0136340512,
0.0300939269,
0.0789176002,
-0.0111155482,
0.0386223793,
0.0222457405,
0.0080324272,
-0.0228362717,
-0.0285886321,
0.0269678254,
0.0563105978,
-0.0030007109,
-0.0008938234,
0.0284596905,
-0.0540063903,
-0.0443823338,
-0.0139056835,
0.0419028774,
-0.0902408659,
-0.024442574,
0.0140360286,
0.0284866039,
0.0020623815,
-0.0069084475,
-0.0338753685,
0.0407532863,
-0.0139058568,
-0.0141645428,
-0.0387251265,
0.0129706748,
0.0241862759,
-0.0141978711,
-0.0400745757,
0.0170895271,
0.034107767,
0.0056054741,
-0.0055226316,
0.0072785928,
-0.0326037258,
-0.0762029588,
0.0283791255,
0.0378472731,
-0.0773389339,
-0.0223729722,
-0.0491187721,
0.0042014602,
0.0170874055,
-0.0706874058,
0.0588992946,
-0.0033265615,
-0.0990272015,
0.0679394975,
-0.0437825099,
0.0894315615,
-0.0617932901,
0.0437357016,
-0.0423947349,
-0.0138894226,
-0.0393626951,
0.0086868117,
-0.0146015389,
-0.0001850953,
-0.0329688117,
-0.0590580478,
0.0002432062,
0.011411258,
-0.0400745831,
0.0284334626,
-0.0391485617,
0.0003465214,
-0.0075492328,
-0.0337112024,
-0.0273226388,
0.0169444643,
0.0095841819,
-0.0288266949,
-0.0319436565,
-0.0665161908,
-0.0018333469,
0.0263022333,
-0.0070277969,
-0.013219892,
-0.03203227,
0.0970221683,
-0.0067874198,
-0.0085796183,
-0.0102276104,
-0.0112887202,
-0.0073189056,
-0.0618473478,
0.0449796245,
-0.0672230795,
0.0046819686,
-0.0261243992,
0.0196577627,
-0.0217129141,
0.0425876565,
0.0308553074,
0.0087723443,
0.0806538537,
-0.0082927365,
0.0229544528,
0.0011003523,
0.0285342615,
-0.0045478591,
0.0751443654,
-0.001297961,
0.068033427,
-0.0149118239,
-0.0156609733,
0.0678738728,
0.0328526162,
-0.0368490107,
0.0105015822,
-0.0758724883,
-0.0082522174,
0.0199308861,
0.0338027254,
0.0239568911,
0.0891329944,
-0.0329306982,
-0.0385819525,
0.0660052523,
-0.0070840335,
0.0078629199,
-0.0207870584,
0.0346454941,
-0.0171046536,
0.0020142507,
0.0231974535,
-0.0683035553,
0.06394995,
-0.0097810104,
-0.0051959972,
-0.0067969128,
0.0184086412,
-0.0379946679,
-0.0272661485,
-0.0024886155,
-0.0252032001,
0.0062235957,
0.0256629176,
0.048790995,
0.0235095229,
-0.0543061122,
0.0095533719,
-0.0018422386,
-0.0335815512,
-0.0063475757,
-0.0533715002,
-0.003457047,
0.0870106742,
0.0433207601,
0.0223106034,
0.0002347976,
-0.0011735911,
0.0493194088,
0.05783768,
0.0040710848,
0.0103581753,
0.0188809633,
-0.0225602668,
-0.027455844,
0.0014883785,
0.007138771,
0.0191571955,
0.0023502579,
-0.0082717901,
0.0192811545,
-0.0406235568,
-0.0081270756,
0.0527666435,
0.0366541333,
0.0253524035,
-0.0454155691,
-0.0104434174,
-0.0052531878,
-0.0176326018,
0.0034454749,
0.027535608,
0.0182348024,
-0.0319388919,
0.0159663893,
-0.0005548148,
-0.0259468462,
-0.0008190617,
0.0392586738,
-0.0264105033,
-0.0006881477,
0.0025129486,
-0.0139180934,
-0.0089419391,
0.0057335142,
-0.0195112806,
0.0269333329,
-0.0370646566,
0.0489051677,
-0.0230534859,
0.0064807478,
-0.0244736969,
0.0550276898,
-0.0459409207,
0.0071633006,
0.0366517864,
0.0598160364,
-0.0216476917,
-0.0278242193,
-0.02776061,
0.0419491753,
0.0065677096,
0.008772959,
-0.0237972718,
-0.0293503068,
-0.0582326353,
-0.0384063758,
-0.066432558,
-0.0281530265,
-0.0234595612,
-0.038969595,
-0.0051346575,
-0.0243889708,
0.0218622722,
-0.0226454716,
0.0020189739,
0.038395796,
-0.0220898557,
0.0392170995,
-0.0159447752,
-0.0046087028,
-0.0410760008,
0.0048600659,
-0.0022373549,
0.033677645,
0.0518031567,
-0.0061303894,
-0.0432173647,
-0.0853178129,
0.0589697137,
-0.023868883,
0.0287688076,
-0.011172818,
0.0109098228,
0.0086404355,
-0.0388228074,
0.0561569557,
0.1064528972,
0.0044490625,
0.0138242301,
0.0643196553,
-0.0493681617,
-0.0344007798,
-0.0339179039,
0.0221420731,
-0.0460330695,
-0.0117003703,
-0.0045207255,
-0.0090784999,
0.0238997564,
-0.0296657141,
0.0265417341,
-0.0530631877,
0.0282667745,
-0.0460959114,
-0.082467027,
-0.0184174515,
0.0006412891,
-0.0193049368,
0.0141961174,
-0.0379579291,
-0.064728573,
0.016971156,
-0.0585853867,
-0.0099790869,
0.0397216752,
0.0479017086,
0.0239495784,
0.0779916272,
0.0591248423,
0.0293820333,
-0.0482368171,
-0.0015822808,
-0.0451773703,
0.0218556449,
-0.0605049357,
-0.0376284383,
0.0178798847,
-0.0538803823,
-0.0106239775,
-0.0167627651,
-0.0066326191,
-0.0445992015,
0.0093135266,
-0.0106030339,
-0.0149455899,
-0.0738672316,
-0.0020337822,
-0.0348629244,
0.0621977523,
-0.005210829,
-0.001269626,
-0.0245371591,
-0.0256430861,
-0.032127358,
-0.0082253963,
0.0578748584,
0.0227272138,
0.0129694678,
-0.0410671309,
-0.0031600688,
0.0840224251,
0.062784031,
0.021785181,
-0.0874338672,
0.0334373005,
0.0223210305,
0.0433987156,
-0.023446938,
0.019425232,
0.041299209,
-0.0775800496,
-0.0146761974,
0.0569227524,
0.0304049086,
-0.0435800999,
0.0014529591,
-0.0001112334,
0.0474815629,
0.0147791747,
0.0034055174,
-0.054028172,
-0.0217020772,
-0.0052586063,
-0.0324112773,
0.0006638145,
-0.0063258754,
-0.0211156402,
-0.0999559239,
0.0710098371,
0.0265028346,
0.003792464,
-0.0650532767,
0.0359617695,
0.01822659,
0.0202130508,
0.0146847107,
0.0314881243,
0.0033937457,
-0.0046817274,
0.0237090345,
0.0304339007,
-0.0043164906,
0.016389383,
-0.0356535576,
0.0033321399,
0.1056102589,
0.0071155764,
0.0270378757,
-0.0844150633,
0.0478672609,
0.019015165,
0.001200584,
0.0052315025,
0.0021972207,
0.0134767853,
-0.030947553,
0.0123695647,
-0.0088577308,
-0.0064350059,
-0.0339469127,
-0.0340839885,
0.0276174862,
-0.0365556814,
-0.0326583982,
-0.018394459,
-0.0051253587,
-0.0106987832,
0.0450207852,
0.0198029075,
-0.0296388175,
-0.0350307114,
-0.0116838431,
0.013327051,
-0.0321610123,
-0.0498799719,
0.054626625,
0.0400748961,
-0.0484220199,
-0.0604477972,
0.004130533,
0.0222125258,
0.0578473844,
-0.0103055062,
0.0228706077,
-0.0240115747,
0.0042428677,
-0.0310326293,
0.0468544327,
-0.0338166207,
0.0326387547,
-0.0333172642,
0.0099530928,
0.0339030065,
-0.0098614842,
0.0021731781,
0.0362018049,
-0.1035336778,
-0.0274338908,
0.018936839,
0.0560891852,
0.0234364755,
0.0274341907,
-0.0182168949,
-0.0603475124,
-0.0003533743,
0.0522120409,
0.0450629964,
0.0446640737,
-0.0202797186,
-0.0095196702,
0.0129422238,
0.0160251278,
-0.0418329611,
-0.0107271271,
0.0212440286,
0.0105212647,
-0.0069706934,
0.0079390537,
0.0098709278,
-0.0014677681,
0.0124612851,
-0.0200191736,
0.0299212337,
0.0046646949,
0.0146310832,
-0.0037917739,
-0.0242641736,
-0.0790855438,
0.0228804201,
0.0239835139,
0.0038577898,
0.0538593233,
0.0018416784,
0.0176076908,
-0.0202475954,
-0.0403850637,
-0.032642819,
0.0225793049,
-0.0357985683,
0.0526545234,
0.0246239584,
0.0056975186,
0.0198196899,
-0.0019806616,
0.0598211028,
0.0131451003,
0.0544241481,
0.011881086,
-0.0369033962,
-0.0642049015,
0.0392925292,
-0.0076603987,
-0.0734757558,
-0.0363354236,
0.0742359534,
0.0650265887,
0.0087168477,
0.0554124862,
-0.0481433272,
0.0126100564,
-0.0415800028,
0.0320141092,
0.0572286993,
-0.0356989726,
0.0233558919,
0.0191383176,
-0.0080613215,
-0.0291668568,
0.0468921363,
0.0067862547,
0.0073785488,
0.0152443647,
0.0139894597,
-0.022558745,
-0.0295663346,
-0.0070556146,
-0.0184986349,
-0.0114126038,
-0.0099099129,
-0.0118201068,
-0.0299019143,
-0.0200296417,
0.0254178531,
0.001574707,
-0.0045712772,
0.0428181477,
0.066341348,
-0.0122494996,
-0.0148640722,
-0.0121183982,
-0.0478635691,
0.062245097,
-0.0148039423,
0.0232412964,
-5.805286483e-33,
-0.0411261618,
-0.0438593701,
0.0432834886,
-0.0465149432,
-0.0141515024,
-0.019543482,
0.0005590266,
0.0141332028,
0.0188192911,
-0.0120060463,
0.0256800838,
-0.0032598132,
0.0158294626,
0.0066161347,
-0.0031593137,
-0.0145901432,
0.0462802723,
0.0200168081,
-0.0178437904,
-0.0119256219,
-0.0067278999,
0.0082767811,
0.0026170255,
-0.0670551881,
-0.0002050662,
0.0048492127,
-0.0265476257,
0.0078613125,
0.0080744643,
0.053953182,
-0.0343344361,
0.0223313682,
0.0082141766,
-0.0133603048,
-0.0628054887,
0.0138042038,
-0.0178113375,
0.0059630526,
-0.0113098063,
0.0766856372,
-0.0707286224,
0.0015424588,
0.0628410205,
0.0044407635,
-0.0103732646,
-0.0186403617,
0.0086952941,
-0.0502763428,
-0.0495836549,
0.0528847612,
-0.0472470522,
0.0003765504,
0.0272373296,
-0.0466997437,
0.0817479417,
-0.0001453407,
0.0037227187,
0.0269015133,
-0.0462120622,
0.0083716707,
-0.0146584464,
0.015659241,
0.0855779275,
0.070630908,
0.0318694673,
0.0699409246,
0.0898805633,
-0.0186143853,
0.0014759786,
-0.0082086045,
0.0228303466,
0.0842086822,
0.0249764733,
0.0274918061,
0.0502706841,
0.0405509286,
0.0100680785,
0.0121542169,
-0.0786790997,
0.0461104922,
0.0705621019,
0.0170872007,
-0.0021336579,
-0.0053515551,
-0.0111299157,
0.0247033332,
-0.0477693789,
-0.0098263565,
0.0491689965,
0.0188564453,
-0.0168584436,
-0.0148737142,
0.0714661554,
-0.0251794159,
-0.0291290823,
-0.0197873637,
-0.0479086563,
0.0587644726,
-0.0114221526,
0.0021178834,
0.0133723635,
-0.0330708288,
0.0590238459,
-0.0114223938,
0.0115933893,
0.0147334542,
-0.0243149158,
-0.0044908165,
-0.057467591,
-0.0015950416,
-0.0448028073,
-0.0163488779,
0.0305633117,
0.023669295,
0.0613690913,
-0.0307318773,
-0.0190316755,
0.0251670536,
-0.0110187531,
-0.0280310251,
-0.0155179482,
0.0193348732,
-0.0326793939,
0.0084710065,
-0.0178645514,
0.0041593332,
-0.0700617656,
-0.02206189,
0.0237847939,
-0.0443844385,
-0.0269176047,
0.0078897374,
2.83e-7,
-0.0081386501,
0.0350690261,
-0.018154338,
0.030495204,
0.0117017562,
0.0237426031,
-0.0039836424,
0.0177779812,
0.0083756894,
-0.0708384067,
-0.0229355656,
0.0400809906,
0.0544568487,
0.0085462686,
-0.0509602316,
0.0080845356,
0.0153651508,
0.0252944119,
-0.0736413151,
-0.0231464095,
0.0067281686,
0.0443312265,
-0.0262706857,
-0.0246054325,
0.0677111,
-0.0629854873,
0.0682337284,
-0.0189474709,
-0.0149491215,
-0.0055309553,
0.0148735736,
0.0533409156,
0.0186528265,
0.0368283652,
0.0018238403,
-0.0492006876,
0.0610724837,
0.0135646155,
-0.0428897962,
-0.0356818251,
-0.0205829702,
0.010591683,
-0.0302163009,
-0.0451921076,
0.0747541785,
-0.0107324729,
0.016156204,
-0.0116977356,
0.0060804738,
-0.0322477669,
0.0249324124,
-0.0045735738,
-0.0162553657,
0.0190649815,
0.0276356228,
0.0054012607,
-0.046981398,
-0.0270685982,
-0.0264176074,
-0.031014502,
-0.0332462713,
-0.0491951033,
-0.0520807952,
-0.0106246397,
-0.0052732266,
-0.0095492555,
-0.0589210056,
2.571635879e-34,
0.0164426845,
0.0148122841,
0.0406498946,
0.020350229,
0.0304377172,
0.0059704878,
-0.0059644487,
0.0485870466,
-0.0432035886,
-0.0198297072,
-0.0144719668
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10349v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10349v1 | Interactive Learning of Hierarchical Tasks from Dialog with GPT | 2023-05-17T16:32:40 | 2023-05-17T16:32:40 | Lane Lawley, Christopher J. MacLellan | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL | We present a system for interpretable, symbolic, interactive task learning
from dialog using a GPT model as a conversational front-end. The learned tasks
are represented as hierarchical decompositions of predicate-argument structures
with scoped variable arguments. By using a GPT model to convert interactive
dialog into a semantic representation, and then recursively asking for
definitions of unknown steps, we show that hierarchical task knowledge can be
acquired and re-used in a natural and unrestrained conversational environment.
We compare our system to a similar architecture using a more conventional
parser and show that our system tolerates a much wider variety of linguistic
variance. | [
0.0197969098,
0.037008781,
-0.0323433504,
0.0254678018,
-0.0050487653,
0.0414056964,
-0.0232806597,
-0.0197024159,
0.0330134742,
-0.0369022749,
-0.0221196376,
0.0257494841,
-0.0150493523,
0.0621068366,
-0.0028770228,
-0.1050465405,
0.0409972705,
-0.0359869935,
0.0487902649,
0.006661979,
0.012703998,
0.0057544867,
-0.0403891392,
0.0571607091,
-0.0125488294,
-0.0614495575,
-0.0714565068,
-0.015192057,
-0.0110715311,
-0.003136761,
-0.0193865784,
0.0193081498,
0.0566191226,
0.0354351513,
0.0000018656,
-0.0274142511,
-0.0205020383,
-0.029914353,
-0.0567190237,
-0.0715594068,
0.0294086803,
0.0233116969,
-0.0325732045,
-0.0240172502,
-0.0501717143,
-0.0300887749,
0.0337786302,
0.0497308895,
0.0708057657,
0.0440736078,
-0.0023279632,
-0.0080307368,
-0.0015492869,
0.010644,
0.0169060994,
-0.0450058989,
-0.0211607814,
0.0307942666,
0.0159019381,
0.0389309265,
0.0128553007,
-0.0269251969,
0.0284470133,
-0.0191575475,
-0.0441686176,
0.0103088683,
0.0131703811,
-0.0068373559,
-0.0376880728,
0.0625988096,
-0.0053944797,
0.0190213043,
0.00907222,
0.0059901522,
0.017487349,
-0.0220949687,
-0.0733877048,
0.0415232852,
-0.0409875587,
0.017031977,
0.0128770983,
0.0024882818,
-0.0163000934,
-0.0288194157,
-0.0005967407,
0.0821318775,
-0.0322429948,
-0.0153503064,
0.0251270533,
0.0116594527,
-0.026301533,
-0.0269464366,
0.0262124315,
0.0216355473,
-0.0733203441,
0.0527937002,
0.0035847574,
0.017191302,
-0.0094869519,
-0.0110476539,
0.0081586093,
0.0453727841,
0.0091260765,
0.0293312501,
0.0456362143,
0.0743084103,
-0.0068430011,
-0.0073233461,
-0.0415230133,
-0.0116505912,
-0.1040332392,
-0.0500768945,
-0.077252917,
0.0612940304,
-0.0449444279,
-0.0064500142,
-0.0036849396,
0.0525284186,
-0.0179480594,
0.010544735,
0.0268104691,
0.0031038485,
-0.0742363855,
0.0154061541,
-0.0499916263,
0.0122902654,
-0.0463919677,
0.0202648714,
0.0248681773,
-0.0152468383,
-0.0290073473,
-0.0047266288,
0.0249973815,
-0.0048594135,
-0.0694966093,
0.0624025501,
-0.0333634466,
-0.0071832673,
-0.0070062694,
-0.0466051139,
-0.0053221574,
-0.0207858309,
0.0037286014,
-0.0164349787,
0.0295988265,
-0.0335038528,
-0.0036398543,
0.0009686973,
-0.0028768729,
0.0236769337,
0.0129481712,
0.0560317896,
0.0215321537,
-0.0274450034,
0.0016465522,
0.0124130575,
-0.0931497887,
0.0569743589,
0.0424439982,
0.0443264171,
-0.0021493882,
0.0164938718,
-0.001636642,
0.0210189614,
-0.0135363964,
-0.0339398235,
0.0432680286,
0.0081880065,
-0.0317601375,
0.0174452644,
0.0220569689,
0.0309849735,
-0.0492864661,
0.028701188,
0.0376709141,
0.0670376644,
-0.0366495326,
-0.0033575057,
0.0436414778,
0.0578943081,
0.0070809061,
0.0325694866,
-0.0794221088,
-0.0027103748,
0.0014980378,
-0.0093887895,
-0.0685937628,
-0.0274337698,
-0.0093219569,
-0.0450705849,
0.0378349647,
-0.0005535645,
0.022672791,
-0.0185497161,
0.0329690911,
0.0388225839,
-0.0372702591,
0.0177512616,
-0.0024565605,
-0.0550742261,
-0.0248694774,
-0.0333598815,
0.0274397805,
0.055682797,
0.0293739624,
-0.0448883884,
-0.0318874232,
-0.0274050161,
-0.0002524,
0.0154027529,
-0.0235260557,
-0.0373170041,
0.0275715832,
-0.0093573295,
-0.0269973818,
-0.0019880738,
0.0300806947,
0.0118026119,
-0.0206061862,
-0.0550860316,
0.005657787,
-0.0095567014,
0.0232915096,
-0.0096884044,
0.0294804294,
-0.0213082526,
-0.0033893217,
0.0053253965,
0.0442163385,
0.0256978646,
0.0208208095,
-0.003849155,
0.0110615967,
0.0135146435,
-0.0110505754,
0.0363338031,
-0.0596236028,
-0.0551033355,
-0.0001698068,
-0.0244538374,
-0.0291371606,
0.0074696336,
-0.0576245598,
-0.0539355539,
0.0117720217,
-0.0537638552,
0.013608749,
-0.0269548036,
-0.0027863493,
0.0447634608,
-0.0627667606,
-0.020034017,
0.090825893,
0.0348176546,
-0.0177150983,
-0.0010641712,
0.0307901278,
-0.0138112325,
-0.0876118392,
0.0306917708,
0.0161310621,
0.0052687721,
-0.024784591,
-0.0013658989,
0.0201149825,
-0.0484086573,
-0.0096287457,
-0.1063862517,
0.0142888697,
-0.0078741554,
0.0321399048,
0.0338512249,
-0.0059660734,
0.0254982579,
-0.0389428586,
-0.0396473259,
0.0353223234,
0.0288718957,
-0.0111376271,
0.0558973067,
0.0006214332,
-0.0124394782,
-0.0347095504,
0.0103623848,
-0.0387625732,
0.0032216222,
0.0247359127,
-0.0054322509,
-0.0239155479,
-0.0126277292,
0.0004830981,
0.0546362773,
-0.021539364,
-0.0147934863,
0.0562107228,
-0.0115256608,
0.0455619358,
0.0660588592,
-0.0261228755,
0.075772129,
-0.0115026431,
-0.0529827885,
-0.0361105092,
0.0468947776,
-0.0123333717,
-0.010113257,
-0.0363388248,
0.006594012,
0.0214372166,
0.1080933213,
0.0105875181,
0.0338293202,
-0.0463591553,
0.0484989099,
-0.0110330079,
-0.0069695278,
-0.0377220362,
-0.0327046998,
-0.0402306616,
0.0357774757,
-0.0166239738,
-0.0499382578,
0.0689094439,
-0.0032729132,
-0.041504547,
-0.0548120998,
-0.0175217371,
-0.0110405674,
0.0984281301,
0.0227007419,
0.0022780767,
0.0658958256,
-0.0839361548,
-0.0442909077,
0.0292966124,
0.0371812396,
-0.0052357935,
0.0340200216,
-0.0843384564,
-0.0156091284,
-0.0014455866,
-0.0444267876,
-0.0254703239,
0.0299639031,
-0.0158927813,
0.0317438208,
0.0270427261,
-0.0018251415,
-0.0012618597,
-0.0233566016,
0.0095580555,
0.0453261733,
0.0036223556,
-0.0160836894,
-0.0806607828,
0.0049977824,
0.0185615495,
0.0332686454,
-0.0391193107,
0.0171032827,
0.0584045686,
0.052636344,
0.0489454679,
-0.0511910506,
-0.0165509768,
0.029876817,
-0.0149723534,
-0.0414032936,
-0.0431140997,
0.0105652791,
0.0356126912,
-0.0774305984,
-0.0095530059,
0.1108449996,
0.0335049853,
-0.0258691013,
0.006150946,
-0.0226067975,
-0.0009178086,
-0.0105253346,
0.0139154876,
-0.0932986885,
-0.0328732282,
0.0204397198,
-0.0023945849,
-0.0102778226,
-0.0527571626,
0.0203147233,
-0.0635253936,
0.0461521968,
0.0021047634,
-0.0010976095,
0.0293300282,
0.0091042528,
-0.0155793633,
-0.0142330583,
-0.0184173118,
0.0194253586,
-0.0024476729,
-0.0031571542,
-0.0050273743,
-0.0149362758,
0.0094819069,
0.0495891869,
0.0025950773,
0.0033853636,
0.0552817136,
0.0375178866,
0.0232010987,
0.0190502796,
-0.0016034469,
-0.0055920738,
-0.008127789,
-0.0095068496,
0.0024274806,
-0.0067378534,
0.0088417111,
-0.0411919616,
0.0417203456,
-0.034951251,
-0.0106973667,
0.0339349397,
0.0897605345,
-0.0603131466,
0.0190378446,
0.0164781008,
-0.0183652788,
0.0222382005,
0.0628693774,
0.0027241956,
0.0089846943,
-0.0557961874,
-0.0754500628,
0.0021322151,
0.0112210875,
0.0021177637,
0.0176653676,
0.0116430465,
0.0040678806,
-0.0647992566,
-0.0661349595,
0.0469201989,
0.016724728,
-0.006101761,
-0.0137340566,
0.0701119676,
0.0214822814,
-0.0222433899,
0.0192997362,
-0.0143170496,
-0.0120585235,
-0.0183538422,
-0.026979927,
0.0338618085,
0.0044856193,
-0.0269639976,
0.0301929638,
-0.0192958172,
-0.0158613585,
-0.0571458898,
0.0819226876,
0.0255836714,
0.0353326723,
-0.0205365494,
0.0066739074,
-0.0392952561,
-0.0435700752,
-0.0299242083,
-0.0422069989,
0.0472722016,
0.0546256304,
0.0053755338,
0.0368767604,
-0.0287262853,
0.0189481881,
-0.0568334684,
0.0304517373,
-0.0404667482,
-0.0208749417,
0.0586534366,
-0.0130889118,
0.0635163561,
0.0391093902,
-0.013889526,
-0.0403970107,
0.0264497083,
-0.0447352491,
-0.0129516209,
-0.0973423794,
0.0286483299,
-0.0081878752,
-0.0063443272,
0.0411350392,
-0.0300266966,
-0.024806682,
0.0296386387,
-0.0227378197,
-0.0064179483,
0.0132166659,
-0.0108954273,
0.0084010251,
0.0079617994,
-0.0167291965,
-0.0257699527,
0.0180478133,
0.0348683484,
0.0071169548,
0.1096793264,
0.0294518359,
-0.0242759474,
-0.00125658,
0.0207161736,
-0.0547116734,
-0.0530969575,
0.0195837747,
0.000827308,
0.0088180043,
0.018036129,
0.0134649221,
-0.0651482642,
0.0361269414,
0.013584408,
0.0621155277,
0.037673533,
-0.0421065651,
0.0398346782,
0.0320581309,
0.002399029,
-0.0557476394,
0.0750808418,
0.0103436885,
0.0087350728,
-0.0061221342,
0.000509661,
-0.0524994433,
-0.0602957159,
-0.0008977083,
0.0370866545,
-0.0083679194,
0.0015791656,
-0.0146078598,
-0.0294877049,
-0.044839289,
0.0062519074,
-0.0092951404,
-0.0605257936,
0.0832447186,
0.0376869775,
-0.0238741785,
-0.0767160356,
-0.0218550991,
-0.0036330416,
-0.0073607643,
-0.0136811994,
-0.0459978692,
-5.03089211e-33,
-0.0657657906,
-0.0229773149,
0.0500357412,
0.0346886329,
-0.0212510191,
-0.0206737388,
-0.0580525957,
0.0108257225,
0.0237306375,
0.0326147042,
0.0136362491,
0.0152192693,
0.0113051403,
0.020349266,
0.0142892422,
-0.0117627643,
0.0364827253,
-0.0329146571,
-0.0055811442,
0.0292264875,
0.0581427775,
0.0043432564,
0.0383470207,
-0.0451687872,
0.0356967971,
0.0173896383,
0.0004528046,
0.0720273331,
0.0067621926,
0.0419962518,
0.0019471266,
0.0174192116,
0.0240496323,
-0.0387738198,
-0.0234070905,
0.0656156242,
-0.0850824341,
-0.0494735204,
0.0483501107,
0.0143623967,
-0.0484956875,
-0.001328985,
-0.0152117908,
-0.0045168493,
0.0138865057,
-0.0137440721,
-0.0024055883,
-0.0004444118,
-0.0072417413,
0.0153320292,
-0.0580695905,
-0.002297923,
-0.01678285,
-0.0309352353,
0.0246418621,
0.0408815332,
0.006705042,
-0.0119763641,
0.007561719,
-0.0233020466,
0.0123160211,
0.0029505859,
0.0347720236,
-0.0031161534,
0.0240859371,
0.0449716747,
0.0262372531,
-0.0008570859,
-0.0694086626,
0.0139018837,
-0.036256928,
0.0557821132,
0.0040888446,
-0.0130320778,
0.0043193917,
0.0624709278,
-0.0234936606,
0.0149145592,
0.0565487482,
0.08396516,
-0.0500060283,
0.033833079,
-0.0053018988,
0.0075662504,
-0.0247638822,
0.0242957082,
-0.0002459496,
-0.0470274203,
0.0325904712,
-0.0153128542,
0.0276823398,
-0.0181091893,
0.0100434003,
0.0091812117,
-0.0006408293,
0.0043300325,
0.0086691976,
0.0056091268,
-0.0149596203,
0.0248955917,
0.0010152034,
-0.0375159346,
0.0341450013,
0.0032200546,
0.023629006,
0.0350147821,
-0.0036346277,
0.0214909595,
-0.0198784396,
0.0151970312,
-0.0528953783,
0.0294535737,
-0.0381046981,
0.0476218238,
0.0406790785,
-0.0119146127,
-0.0235515404,
0.0581073947,
-0.0352021419,
-0.0382614993,
-0.0502644107,
0.0300493315,
-0.0078500211,
-0.0074690892,
-0.0351983607,
-0.0429710895,
-0.0028034132,
-0.0107456157,
0.0123640308,
-0.0362497829,
0.0156431962,
0.0128244609,
2.543e-7,
-0.0006772417,
0.0213471912,
0.0373697169,
0.0468082838,
0.0616874248,
0.0320050307,
-0.0014174741,
0.0299247038,
-0.0059151426,
-0.0569386445,
0.0142478244,
0.0127534149,
0.0392320976,
0.0276371446,
-0.1025864631,
-0.0488240421,
-0.0145222712,
-0.0468772314,
-0.034259215,
0.0368015803,
0.1057406068,
0.0699151903,
-0.0099684084,
0.0327161476,
0.0107937781,
-0.0218496155,
0.0374190025,
-0.007803638,
0.0158838779,
-0.0181535557,
0.0001959363,
-0.0324688889,
-0.006829869,
0.0302865244,
0.0044829589,
-0.0020149718,
-0.0164553467,
0.0861351714,
-0.0009699979,
-0.010634833,
-0.0136913126,
-0.0244736932,
0.0302314591,
-0.0316117406,
0.0262329914,
-0.0993011519,
-0.0290790182,
0.019852737,
-0.0126361307,
-0.0616238005,
-0.086125575,
0.0257241633,
-0.0100311423,
0.0104191937,
-0.0046932055,
0.0034980879,
0.0404127948,
-0.0523400344,
0.0081085516,
0.018857196,
-0.0549854822,
-0.0475245379,
-0.018845031,
-0.0291145239,
-0.003544892,
-0.0160911717,
-0.0146217663,
2.030789321e-34,
0.0035762035,
0.0026527746,
0.0303830393,
0.0665870458,
0.0498210937,
0.0084043574,
-0.0198541004,
0.020737309,
0.0777422637,
-0.0534357727,
-0.0175252724
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10321v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10321v2 | Controllable Speaking Styles Using a Large Language Model | 2023-05-17T16:01:50 | 2023-09-19T16:35:57 | Atli Thor Sigurgeirsson, Simon King | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Reference-based Text-to-Speech (TTS) models can generate multiple,
prosodically-different renditions of the same target text. Such models jointly
learn a latent acoustic space during training, which can be sampled from during
inference. Controlling these models during inference typically requires finding
an appropriate reference utterance, which is non-trivial.
Large generative language models (LLMs) have shown excellent performance in
various language-related tasks. Given only a natural language query text (the
prompt), such models can be used to solve specific, context-dependent tasks.
Recent work in TTS has attempted similar prompt-based control of novel speaking
style generation. Those methods do not require a reference utterance and can,
under ideal conditions, be controlled with only a prompt. But existing methods
typically require a prompt-labelled speech corpus for jointly training a
prompt-conditioned encoder.
In contrast, we instead employ an LLM to directly suggest prosodic
modifications for a controllable TTS model, using contextual information
provided in the prompt. The prompt can be designed for a multitude of tasks.
Here, we give two demonstrations: control of speaking style; prosody
appropriate for a given dialogue context. The proposed method is rated most
appropriate in 50% of cases vs. 31% for a baseline model. | [
0.0323680677,
0.060984727,
0.0095685972,
-0.0272477698,
-0.0319903307,
-0.0219811741,
0.0442215763,
-0.0033048543,
-0.0418656245,
0.0040454799,
-0.0595847629,
-0.0451772884,
-0.0057534119,
0.0432663672,
0.0756170899,
-0.0932476372,
0.0065250793,
-0.0689751431,
0.015120877,
-0.0388240479,
0.0184990484,
0.0193745401,
-0.0177246258,
0.0309076421,
-0.0157525167,
-0.030668376,
-0.0178428721,
0.0163589194,
-0.0106031606,
0.0195840467,
0.0126413926,
0.035618566,
0.0556073822,
-0.020078266,
0.0000020418,
-0.0212283563,
0.0064094542,
-0.0171405729,
0.0020332844,
0.0359865502,
0.0434849113,
0.0504001975,
-0.0233413242,
0.0364833996,
-0.023701828,
-0.0156013165,
0.0334903188,
0.0235750116,
0.0695953146,
0.0753856376,
0.0056156702,
-0.048759345,
-0.0202409141,
-0.0394511148,
0.0076607428,
-0.0177479386,
-0.0175399948,
-0.039941892,
0.0401043221,
0.0142136328,
-0.0462013111,
0.0484169014,
0.0132520795,
-0.0311896764,
0.0044533019,
-0.0060229134,
-0.0128447721,
-0.0235781521,
-0.0248792414,
0.0479375124,
0.0201608259,
-0.0169124026,
0.0246627741,
0.0021822939,
-0.0141448211,
0.0153680937,
0.0044209305,
0.0262377393,
0.0096478406,
0.0025241089,
0.0003576545,
0.0247261282,
-0.0001573763,
-0.0199966673,
-0.0137335109,
0.0105865076,
0.0403591022,
-0.0428467505,
0.0055414867,
-0.0124969138,
-0.0033549999,
-0.0396171771,
0.0313497819,
0.0069792191,
-0.0683863983,
0.0207156129,
-0.0446095094,
-0.0114110801,
-0.0239944737,
0.0218611937,
0.0416579843,
0.0295659415,
-0.0248251725,
-0.0151278889,
0.0031636741,
0.0515198596,
-0.0351301804,
-0.0083684037,
-0.0329315811,
-0.0057025058,
-0.0069810278,
-0.0047409493,
-0.0680949688,
-0.0342009738,
-0.0417588875,
-0.0132692,
-0.0206935667,
0.0251450855,
-0.0277963597,
0.0069243284,
0.0208992455,
0.0149977207,
-0.0419900082,
-0.0047592735,
0.0174185559,
-0.0042544398,
-0.0198661834,
0.0360530242,
0.0316199176,
-0.0613120236,
-0.0047602262,
0.0194676947,
0.0455626696,
-0.0013699427,
-0.0025460778,
0.0100233154,
-0.0402332097,
0.005311518,
-0.0355384387,
-0.0206790622,
-0.0518772155,
-0.0250055306,
-0.0227166116,
-0.0451086536,
-0.0018471491,
-0.0241647065,
0.0024425937,
-0.0449475124,
-0.0221551135,
-0.0065190322,
0.021212602,
0.0390777849,
0.0292553175,
0.0428093821,
0.0773079768,
-0.0176632926,
0.0148338247,
0.0364809446,
0.0602990389,
-0.001120704,
-0.0211957432,
-0.0070964065,
0.0042838724,
0.0814072862,
0.0196965933,
0.0276824143,
-0.0220606979,
-0.0287374053,
0.0626516342,
0.0363965221,
0.075935632,
0.0567746311,
-0.0182181429,
0.0048908275,
0.0910086855,
-0.0069402391,
0.0276837908,
-0.0099461982,
0.0893419683,
0.0467166118,
-0.008910872,
-0.0138165578,
0.0106175449,
-0.0208389014,
-0.0147976773,
0.0416342206,
0.0619051196,
-0.0022790311,
-0.0581195503,
-0.0099684745,
0.0368517861,
-0.0073402133,
-0.0382932611,
0.0162698124,
0.0202609561,
0.0616024248,
-0.0556638911,
-0.0074181482,
0.0264988635,
-0.0831941664,
0.0451039411,
-0.0169562977,
0.039996963,
0.0645837337,
0.0001950888,
0.0170437135,
-0.0019564948,
-0.0381544419,
0.001548238,
0.0609121248,
0.0074638911,
-0.0248513967,
0.0251768399,
-0.0725488886,
0.0050972556,
-0.0006284304,
-0.0191975925,
0.0155115714,
-0.0460703112,
0.0271682981,
0.0056831748,
0.0305312108,
0.0489792079,
0.0058877971,
-0.0606408902,
-0.0285394304,
0.0368507504,
0.0205187947,
0.0369864553,
0.0150571149,
-0.0512053743,
0.0023934043,
-0.0046095122,
-0.0381086171,
0.0224576779,
0.0319734924,
-0.0909847319,
-0.0551186129,
-0.0230893902,
-0.0177009609,
0.0103517137,
-0.0245979317,
0.0031642772,
-0.1187241524,
0.0102705965,
-0.0360576808,
0.0206972286,
-0.0463434979,
-0.0023862973,
0.0168128815,
-0.0069799167,
-0.0104539534,
-0.0014449345,
0.0275223888,
-0.0197224058,
0.0859597325,
0.0768040866,
-0.0403033085,
-0.0928359181,
-0.0140947122,
-0.013183279,
0.0137490667,
0.03864526,
-0.005390991,
0.0217811745,
0.0041491888,
-0.065647468,
-0.0312637687,
0.0050405036,
-0.0375594534,
-0.0082787415,
0.0200527459,
0.018788496,
-0.0287883412,
-0.0129733728,
-0.0699896291,
-0.048582565,
0.0361273661,
-0.019240763,
-0.0233358648,
0.0113920374,
-0.0152217885,
-0.027762685,
0.0176727194,
0.0267891828,
0.0148669844,
-0.0046799523,
0.0163459927,
-0.0608473234,
0.0392106324,
0.01272236,
0.0258001741,
0.0113366684,
-0.0310015492,
0.0106097646,
-0.0073434971,
0.1145224571,
0.0434335619,
0.035292428,
-0.0123500293,
0.0273019969,
-0.0365654416,
-0.0479314737,
0.0106592635,
-0.0263570994,
-0.0407409444,
-0.0204017702,
-0.0356602706,
0.0206955802,
-0.0002707451,
0.0702883601,
0.0288618412,
-0.0915148407,
0.0147051448,
0.0267256238,
-0.0597052127,
0.0097288219,
-0.0358929858,
-0.05266691,
0.0103086028,
-0.0073950649,
-0.020315228,
0.0369174182,
-0.0531215146,
-0.0477990545,
0.000223226,
-0.0181203932,
-0.0002519381,
0.0122457901,
-0.0025896379,
0.0246415548,
0.0467685834,
-0.036771711,
-0.0326097459,
0.0230939481,
0.0374725088,
-0.0329118595,
0.0264011435,
-0.0467502847,
-0.0165222678,
0.0293642394,
-0.0507682227,
-0.0329426192,
-0.032238815,
0.0029896682,
0.0421224013,
0.0270951502,
-0.0032029897,
0.0240630414,
0.0147740068,
0.038532827,
0.051429797,
-0.0213273037,
0.0216989312,
-0.0422282033,
0.0087322723,
0.051686544,
0.0467820466,
-0.0790923089,
-0.0271498915,
0.0057330825,
-0.0280713476,
0.0265850462,
0.0320246965,
-0.0442743599,
0.0335833505,
0.0290226396,
0.0017460119,
-0.0129474318,
0.0228488948,
0.0568297692,
-0.025378475,
-0.0443718173,
0.120343253,
-0.0043188422,
-0.0374809094,
-0.01950166,
0.0156935733,
0.0599853769,
-0.0075336541,
0.0142260697,
-0.0543789603,
-0.0266746189,
0.0299097765,
0.0608960353,
-0.0365765728,
0.0258179493,
-0.0334425122,
-0.1189011186,
0.0555072576,
0.0317637064,
-0.0368379653,
-0.0272584222,
-0.0360199995,
-0.009597647,
-0.0079508098,
0.0020838729,
0.045962695,
-0.0097324047,
0.008472722,
0.0425290056,
0.0033272752,
-0.0474064872,
-0.0238533802,
-0.0524094217,
0.0902010202,
0.0835677013,
0.0149295805,
0.0299991556,
-0.0419756435,
-0.0383926146,
-0.0229921062,
0.0071251434,
-0.0117550893,
0.0008212461,
-0.0005173942,
-0.0210284423,
-0.0146536585,
0.1027122512,
-0.0087276716,
0.0486001894,
0.0263051819,
0.0363443792,
-0.0332572535,
0.0010674464,
0.016328264,
0.0392407887,
0.0671833083,
0.0447307862,
0.0506594777,
-0.0999671891,
-0.0150938686,
-0.0316675305,
0.0111953309,
-0.0267444737,
-0.028371837,
-0.0109672984,
0.016304452,
-0.0103165349,
-0.0700062066,
0.0132066859,
-0.0108127762,
0.0370940976,
0.0263586193,
-0.0292467847,
-0.001700777,
-0.0073905741,
0.0035408968,
-0.0260841623,
-0.0359208472,
0.0348750353,
-0.0757810622,
-0.0477452502,
0.0669119731,
-0.0937064439,
-0.0196836274,
0.0197697207,
-0.0120038036,
-0.0797256604,
-0.0065894099,
0.0573756173,
0.0105422027,
0.0643288568,
-0.0282830168,
-0.0672108456,
0.0579916239,
0.0265548993,
-0.0166971255,
0.040989425,
0.0469751954,
0.0311043486,
-0.0141089102,
0.0162965525,
-0.0308461376,
0.0363651477,
0.0069008898,
0.0297921635,
0.007615522,
-0.0970089659,
0.0013738727,
0.0081360461,
0.0265430287,
-0.0227502044,
0.0490516797,
-0.0487466007,
-0.0091613783,
0.0079847565,
0.0125722997,
-0.0450375602,
0.0010139468,
0.0114866216,
0.0202043764,
-0.0080456277,
-0.0131005486,
-0.0242925975,
0.0306638498,
-0.0437026843,
0.0151492627,
0.0237718355,
0.046281036,
0.0062509398,
0.0320656076,
-0.0115979733,
0.0361828618,
-0.0040240805,
0.0086811129,
-0.0037699526,
0.0409860499,
0.04041503,
-0.0164221302,
0.0126914019,
0.0032207007,
-0.0637577102,
0.0108455466,
0.0027371182,
0.0160781369,
0.0412203372,
0.0167438965,
0.0488645621,
-0.0190923009,
0.0388916321,
-0.0175652988,
0.0386019014,
0.0103215547,
-0.0377776735,
0.0275514442,
-0.0173024721,
-0.0069326111,
-0.0028241451,
0.0389241874,
0.0180508215,
0.0200933572,
-0.0454104133,
0.0405150279,
-0.0351644531,
-0.0316382311,
-0.0433455631,
-0.0236353297,
0.0004680159,
-0.0154878534,
-0.0211951062,
-0.030535968,
0.01847714,
0.0174661297,
0.0017544214,
-0.0311895758,
0.0694965646,
-0.0153835742,
-0.062534146,
-0.0129575459,
-0.0252478793,
0.0078585427,
0.0125492727,
-0.0280091148,
-0.0300589725,
-6.024731442e-33,
-0.0394176766,
0.0267866328,
0.0137511147,
-0.0006359267,
-0.0552456044,
-0.0491452627,
-0.0508665852,
-0.0232316516,
0.0131196631,
0.0005257504,
-0.0527551696,
-0.0297109187,
0.0162784718,
0.0592303351,
-0.0031900317,
0.029950317,
0.10195072,
-0.0030623437,
-0.0157730691,
0.0773251429,
0.0502020419,
0.0147262244,
0.0081579955,
-0.0357094742,
-0.0064174109,
-0.0577872247,
-0.0344716646,
-0.0058570467,
0.0108683901,
0.0174679179,
0.0177256502,
0.0419813059,
-0.0274934415,
-0.0602643341,
-0.0511876568,
0.0656105429,
-0.0518788695,
-0.0166705623,
0.015866762,
0.0099212695,
-0.0091626998,
-0.0540652201,
0.0032477449,
-0.0126654096,
-0.0195428375,
0.0219162796,
0.0346424989,
-0.0201056413,
-0.0179759078,
-0.0507801734,
-0.0060470062,
0.0046752305,
-0.015690323,
-0.0439207926,
0.0193420388,
0.0670678839,
-0.0449513532,
-0.0269660577,
-0.0058261524,
0.0521245226,
0.0424548425,
0.0089566205,
0.0349492952,
0.0696351156,
0.0211826414,
0.007656815,
0.0137147494,
-0.0242676623,
-0.0061444319,
-0.0338161178,
0.0096492413,
0.0378087498,
0.0123629011,
0.0311025716,
-0.0409243368,
-0.0245318636,
-0.0043934863,
-0.0115042049,
0.0393179208,
-0.0183032453,
0.0284089874,
0.0296051241,
0.0073510143,
-0.0190247875,
-0.0912232548,
-0.0505073927,
0.0024529947,
-0.0033234195,
0.0569841526,
0.0108008226,
0.0075468295,
-0.0227353554,
0.0700040385,
0.0219760705,
0.0100426115,
0.0153311975,
-0.0690851212,
0.0294519477,
-0.0165575352,
0.0054288027,
-0.0657105297,
-0.0165612716,
0.0791774318,
0.0191581529,
-0.0110519482,
0.0236357953,
-0.0286492053,
0.0364142507,
-0.0461890213,
0.0222777072,
-0.0229299534,
0.061091885,
-0.0297843013,
-0.0241689533,
0.0303600226,
0.0015017167,
-0.0154378796,
0.0385797992,
-0.0191296935,
-0.0436289348,
0.0128747867,
-0.0385088883,
-0.0001885711,
0.0270083994,
-0.0669203177,
0.0431653187,
0.0024532257,
0.0343415216,
0.029492382,
-0.0177144296,
0.0078147165,
0.0148816798,
2.811e-7,
-0.0600954741,
-0.0168218967,
0.017982984,
0.0480312109,
0.0471557006,
0.0221461989,
0.0094676809,
0.020944858,
0.0336015187,
-0.020244658,
0.0111733088,
-0.0018646175,
0.0778391883,
-0.0260980465,
-0.1047417447,
-0.010345947,
-0.0691075027,
0.038896244,
-0.0272761863,
-0.0108960615,
0.0386178158,
0.0536988825,
0.0002028243,
-0.0004014168,
0.0276997164,
-0.0104668345,
0.0343944728,
-0.0208906177,
0.0071500265,
-0.0017728462,
0.0125150727,
-0.040286012,
-0.0236875359,
0.0287741404,
-0.0305804368,
0.0137865804,
-0.0038017354,
0.0937577486,
0.0328271128,
-0.0184038412,
-0.0033879201,
0.0407154672,
-0.0503701344,
0.0017436539,
0.0518852398,
-0.0009310687,
0.0078065097,
0.0039109848,
-0.0390176177,
-0.000568873,
-0.0283408221,
-0.0492264591,
-0.0119648566,
0.0166335795,
0.0037832058,
0.018001521,
0.0076910541,
-0.0373425074,
0.0094461115,
-0.0015561639,
-0.0648600534,
-0.0319910459,
-0.0370771699,
-0.0012241064,
-0.0123737929,
-0.0215268005,
-0.0104045235,
2.172259607e-34,
0.0195302591,
-0.0172808841,
0.0357289985,
0.0042625815,
-0.0191623978,
0.0059846826,
0.022382332,
0.0393639952,
0.0691944584,
-0.0765295848,
-0.0657454357
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10314v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10314v2 | LeTI: Learning to Generate from Textual Interactions | 2023-05-17T15:53:31 | 2024-03-19T11:53:15 | Xingyao Wang, Hao Peng, Reyhaneh Jabbarvand, Heng Ji | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SE | Fine-tuning pre-trained language models (LMs) is essential for enhancing
their capabilities. Existing techniques commonly fine-tune on input-output
pairs (e.g., instruction tuning) or with numerical rewards that gauge the
output quality (e.g., RLHF). We explore LMs' potential to learn from textual
interactions (LETI) that not only check their correctness with binary labels
but also pinpoint and explain errors in their outputs through textual feedback.
Our focus is the code generation task, where the model produces code based on
natural language instructions. This setting invites a natural and scalable way
to acquire textual feedback: the error messages and stack traces from code
execution using a Python interpreter. LETI iteratively fine-tunes the model,
using the LM objective, on a concatenation of natural language instructions,
LM-generated programs, and textual feedback. Prepended to this fine-tuning
text, a binary reward token is used to differentiate correct and buggy
solutions. LETI requires no ground-truth outputs for training and even
outperforms a fine-tuned baseline that does. LETI not only improves the
performance of LMs on a code generation dataset MBPP, but also generalizes to
other datasets. Trained on MBPP, it achieves comparable or better performance
than the base LMs on unseen problems in HumanEval. Furthermore, compared to
binary feedback, we observe that textual feedback leads to improved generation
quality and sample efficiency, achieving the same performance with fewer than
half of the gradient steps. LETI is equally applicable in natural language
tasks when they can be formulated as code generation, which we empirically
verified on event argument extraction. | [
0.0231884588,
0.060477104,
-0.00641486,
0.0234531481,
0.0162506066,
0.0345338061,
-0.0325601585,
0.0015637005,
0.0174001958,
-0.0488591231,
-0.01204619,
0.0143597368,
-0.0032298488,
0.0558727197,
0.0591298863,
-0.0250559486,
0.0305355433,
-0.0226088613,
-0.0066615692,
0.0264689699,
0.0145426868,
0.0425033458,
-0.0153264813,
0.0662510172,
-0.0288253501,
0.0001387432,
-0.0413614251,
0.0248257238,
-0.0013118543,
-0.0161750875,
0.0253109988,
0.0371072255,
0.0244421307,
-0.0004739106,
0.0000021325,
-0.028635256,
0.0052796216,
-0.0198640935,
-0.0104962178,
0.0079947105,
0.0038279737,
-0.0138913421,
-0.0136582078,
0.0295357946,
-0.0338461399,
-0.0444650836,
0.0526586659,
0.0030975598,
0.0888864994,
0.0905872062,
0.0055988356,
0.0210148096,
0.0087862415,
-0.014069967,
0.0407200418,
-0.0131947463,
-0.0068354234,
0.0090972679,
-0.0223031081,
0.0072862031,
0.0257643536,
-0.0053704153,
0.0314363912,
-0.025132088,
0.0034504833,
0.0567806773,
-0.0104157915,
-0.0156774577,
-0.0204653442,
0.0663787574,
-0.0575589277,
-0.0492809638,
0.0136520108,
-0.035860315,
-0.0156928673,
-0.0492021702,
-0.0021479407,
0.0397957824,
-0.0095149865,
0.0275265649,
0.0366609395,
-0.0292999111,
0.0212840252,
-0.0041402895,
-0.0105297808,
0.0416295603,
-0.0043941871,
-0.0126872286,
-0.0224952307,
0.013862811,
-0.0102855302,
-0.0887733251,
0.0044812621,
0.0686527863,
-0.0473374873,
0.0069979881,
-0.056183584,
-0.0003420817,
-0.0121762725,
-0.042397555,
0.0422070809,
0.0309363455,
-0.0162408017,
-0.0026923828,
-0.02589822,
0.0447195619,
0.0138336159,
0.0359296426,
-0.0157236569,
0.0348826684,
-0.0255848411,
0.0132499086,
-0.0306629464,
0.0537293963,
-0.0188090596,
0.020977037,
-0.0194760505,
0.0514735766,
0.0065196129,
0.0654392466,
-0.0157752782,
-0.0127295339,
-0.0733684674,
0.0186292753,
-0.0092052286,
-0.0161306914,
-0.0303528421,
-0.0298023112,
0.0024631815,
-0.0516272336,
-0.033482302,
0.0381746851,
-0.0040212958,
-0.0284366924,
0.0216844771,
0.0713178515,
0.0006163262,
-0.0011148236,
-0.0550958365,
-0.0427453443,
0.0039336598,
-0.0408288203,
-0.0125983581,
-0.0660108402,
0.00411112,
-0.0139147835,
-0.020168772,
-0.0385492593,
0.0382494964,
-0.0186789688,
-0.0189859252,
0.0543135405,
-0.0523119532,
-0.0165659599,
0.0014699808,
-0.0075801415,
0.0038317826,
0.0482239649,
0.093363151,
0.0246984139,
0.0142677631,
-0.0141959563,
0.0361027606,
0.0257197432,
0.0449429266,
0.007592449,
0.0263134092,
-0.0090057738,
-0.0099866148,
0.0141174253,
0.0443056449,
0.0309753343,
-0.0156509764,
0.0423997603,
0.0157150943,
0.0103503261,
0.0108230114,
0.0208174698,
0.1066535711,
0.0116167497,
-0.0358638726,
0.0221802704,
-0.035606835,
0.0268023293,
-0.0297291949,
0.0069822283,
0.0343537442,
-0.0084584216,
-0.0323874764,
-0.0872569904,
0.0091946637,
-0.0297407266,
0.0022706247,
-0.0033363034,
0.0403464586,
0.0339071192,
-0.0757154003,
0.0122769326,
0.0364390425,
-0.0686999634,
0.0111911921,
-0.0621482171,
0.0386757106,
0.0338684022,
0.0509230308,
-0.0414003395,
0.0095358687,
-0.0138238864,
-0.0174154695,
0.0087002097,
0.0377178341,
-0.026283972,
0.0454792418,
-0.0195292048,
0.0177574661,
-0.057588134,
0.0115574151,
0.0049238964,
0.0316513181,
-0.0375683978,
0.0246709939,
0.0418014042,
-0.0645072684,
0.0580768697,
-0.0018596605,
-0.0372893289,
0.0167177022,
-0.0065743071,
0.025041502,
-0.0357347503,
-0.0399932116,
0.0282167308,
0.0225392412,
-0.0031004548,
-0.0172165856,
-0.0101709329,
-0.0326405168,
-0.073259674,
0.0303933267,
0.0027747187,
-0.0026969165,
0.0250207838,
-0.0565779023,
-0.0106416587,
0.0458151624,
-0.0499104671,
0.0148512805,
0.0050544459,
0.0280676521,
0.0101066874,
-0.0467812829,
-0.0256764144,
0.0311590768,
0.0172151923,
0.0091613932,
-0.0508738346,
0.0651914924,
-0.0002382152,
-0.0021830404,
0.0005206084,
0.0039009298,
-0.0241196435,
0.0204658024,
0.0407371745,
0.0532771386,
-0.0283416435,
-0.0283921137,
-0.0890986547,
0.0404704399,
-0.0326454751,
0.0048019118,
0.0431412645,
0.0120729329,
0.005999696,
-0.0091733495,
-0.0233822521,
-0.0286828447,
0.0125549445,
-0.0041606636,
0.0712634623,
0.0300761629,
-0.0143737588,
-0.0957791954,
-0.0009109696,
-0.0374367423,
0.0427435935,
0.0275999177,
0.0076801409,
-0.0846656412,
0.0658772811,
-0.0293278564,
0.0418958515,
-0.0090526566,
-0.0427903011,
0.0451911986,
-0.040226087,
0.0553867482,
0.0651667565,
-0.009811678,
0.062087819,
0.0392009318,
-0.0028380216,
-0.0877105594,
0.0322067551,
-0.0264743585,
-0.0558357276,
0.0031294073,
-0.0241125412,
0.048334159,
0.1032199115,
0.0194828734,
-0.0000285484,
-0.0683091283,
0.03332863,
0.0393938869,
-0.0190820787,
0.0053032129,
-0.047829695,
-0.0055318344,
0.053564962,
-0.0359425358,
-0.0955703184,
0.0893311277,
-0.0397335887,
-0.0127135031,
-0.0382309668,
-0.0219969414,
-0.024756724,
0.0640362799,
0.0033584805,
0.0078231581,
0.0052768183,
-0.0267249718,
-0.0243321899,
0.0081416192,
0.0035366185,
-0.026782833,
0.0288486946,
-0.0767912418,
-0.0046041505,
0.0036133938,
-0.0411229655,
-0.0531105027,
-0.0236404948,
0.0105399322,
-0.0200929083,
0.0429240465,
-0.0013245172,
0.0202023592,
-0.011278864,
0.0043137823,
0.040272247,
0.0085522654,
-0.0419504158,
-0.0412389897,
-0.0306572188,
0.0043432005,
-0.0444653146,
-0.0077780737,
-0.0190493073,
-0.0184139833,
0.0183678903,
0.0278492067,
0.0383237749,
-0.0615606084,
0.0168852303,
0.0116128903,
-0.0080569731,
-0.0258501917,
0.0501208268,
0.0969446674,
-0.0446836352,
-0.062826179,
0.1128087938,
0.0414197519,
-0.0206511579,
0.0323497653,
0.0198903978,
0.0410784297,
0.0155461635,
0.0330284275,
-0.0682059675,
-0.0322248824,
-0.0110735279,
0.0278144665,
-0.022396991,
-0.0149219511,
-0.024679251,
-0.1242362782,
0.0064633721,
0.0233427491,
0.0058802995,
-0.0383494161,
-0.0470524356,
-0.0272179861,
-0.0037652247,
-0.0338543691,
0.0119891707,
0.0062795025,
0.0411381237,
0.0184164587,
-0.0152128264,
-0.0132820792,
0.0170707405,
-0.0386658423,
0.0327187926,
0.1025059745,
0.0148921832,
0.0273664314,
0.0069658239,
0.035802599,
-0.006174061,
0.0167532954,
-0.0288902614,
0.0487950966,
-0.0204159319,
-0.014995235,
0.000686014,
0.0427327342,
-0.0542765222,
0.0011789525,
0.0163327437,
0.0233806409,
-0.022272652,
-0.0198738333,
0.0030467347,
0.0233313255,
0.026283389,
0.0126189692,
0.0624307841,
-0.0349565409,
-0.0522275157,
-0.0572355501,
0.0034252172,
-0.080421634,
-0.0227601789,
-0.0244879015,
0.005958362,
-0.0207659435,
-0.0834799558,
-0.0553947687,
0.024605738,
0.0335764401,
0.0041796863,
-0.0739739537,
0.0030481368,
-0.0118413568,
-0.0234771557,
0.0419209227,
-0.0136221321,
0.008022991,
-0.0359294079,
-0.0376353785,
0.0053976551,
-0.0006463855,
0.0028711224,
0.0408305712,
-0.093156822,
-0.073584117,
-0.0714223608,
0.0990643129,
0.0139409034,
0.0721759275,
-0.0355934985,
-0.0285151172,
-0.046311114,
0.0335787311,
-0.0383470319,
-0.0002930633,
0.0392662324,
-0.0001212305,
0.0203874968,
0.0032752396,
-0.0480220169,
0.0320048817,
0.025601916,
0.0181929097,
-0.0228871778,
-0.0276220553,
0.0469593704,
0.0047534574,
0.0486861914,
-0.0103885252,
-0.0408119187,
-0.0091474885,
-0.0138389394,
-0.0079144416,
-0.0237309411,
-0.0678410158,
0.0315204933,
-0.0161617324,
-0.0153116165,
0.0111722685,
-0.0291166604,
-0.0641351491,
0.0756687298,
-0.0352373421,
0.0124137653,
-0.0073527521,
0.0640955269,
0.0495503061,
0.0041110772,
-0.0311523508,
0.0391622335,
0.0005517711,
0.0324684791,
0.0083085876,
0.0527147762,
0.032809291,
0.0395791493,
0.0240226835,
0.0133277876,
-0.0307375342,
-0.0475421436,
-0.0449897721,
-0.0249040388,
0.082240276,
0.0308076739,
0.0594768114,
-0.012770568,
0.0233822316,
-0.0014078122,
0.0879491568,
-0.0103536611,
-0.0559236817,
0.0160580408,
0.0254408009,
-0.0109827584,
-0.035698276,
0.0693739429,
-0.0102443844,
0.0341082029,
0.0069306181,
0.0271431189,
-0.0447945856,
-0.0199935734,
0.0289510265,
0.0107679078,
-0.0123420972,
0.0247821026,
0.0014372132,
-0.0530295707,
-0.0330105759,
0.0572526082,
0.0273038521,
-0.0120169185,
0.040707726,
0.0561190136,
-0.0068869973,
0.0170686021,
-0.0457796752,
0.0145331817,
0.0126785263,
-0.0506968945,
-0.0662782192,
-6.135183095e-33,
-0.0656063855,
-0.0519291237,
0.0107026277,
0.0432940759,
-0.0132303806,
-0.0191572886,
-0.0906497464,
0.0167460423,
-0.0002609132,
-0.0193781108,
0.0300982334,
0.0157401692,
-0.0231702477,
-0.0232799426,
0.0089027397,
-0.0077831293,
0.035869509,
-0.0026952464,
-0.0727122724,
0.055539079,
-0.0142359417,
-0.0033864544,
0.0110283652,
-0.0717879534,
0.0191490315,
-0.0197408423,
-0.0235336013,
0.020006977,
0.005790784,
0.038924247,
-0.0018534248,
0.0132203838,
0.0024654088,
-0.0081008421,
-0.0174712595,
0.0081072561,
-0.0251938179,
-0.0380377397,
0.0083156396,
-0.0018278575,
-0.0452581495,
-0.0414558798,
0.0509773567,
-0.0069189994,
-0.0168791041,
-0.0024099343,
0.0313236825,
0.0276712738,
-0.0031991189,
-0.031157691,
-0.0645766407,
0.017100947,
-0.0457341745,
-0.0627056584,
-0.023339808,
0.0352558158,
0.0064258743,
0.0356535353,
-0.0006119631,
0.0076500876,
0.0232947096,
0.0338303968,
0.0355644226,
-0.0127665447,
0.0083269905,
0.0265433174,
0.006285321,
0.0251550209,
-0.0450216606,
0.0303845573,
0.0445318595,
0.0275528152,
0.0393710434,
0.0093997391,
0.0412350222,
0.0196992587,
-0.0556949005,
0.026902983,
-0.0062431949,
0.0024298783,
-0.0011106771,
0.0061267694,
-0.0279958006,
-0.0144034484,
-0.0570179895,
0.0069948118,
-0.0075011924,
-0.0466190279,
0.0206419844,
0.0236573908,
-0.0095487572,
0.0065237829,
0.0049464973,
-0.0048982315,
-0.0043421658,
-0.0129723493,
-0.0549786128,
0.0091129066,
-0.0317605399,
-0.0047939559,
-0.03066344,
-0.0278619602,
0.0500666425,
-0.009138762,
0.0778437108,
0.0377636105,
0.0243970621,
0.0272297561,
-0.0481634438,
0.0093079582,
-0.0731010139,
0.0243852474,
-0.0104580028,
0.0275166035,
0.0007967568,
-0.0069377949,
-0.0194064844,
0.0593719408,
-0.0221934207,
-0.0269926321,
-0.0590073392,
0.0065755146,
-0.0015730902,
0.0290409252,
-0.0627028421,
-0.0354692377,
-0.0387520567,
0.016078284,
0.0254675839,
-0.0535737947,
-0.0545429401,
-0.002789614,
2.768e-7,
0.0158623625,
0.0313811377,
0.0465684198,
0.0566957332,
0.0090723922,
0.0580271557,
-0.0284264572,
0.0152657079,
0.0105168158,
-0.0160797834,
-0.0188475046,
0.0196093842,
0.0355878249,
0.0271101594,
-0.022826476,
-0.0105877016,
-0.06049693,
0.0142497718,
-0.0595388673,
-0.0192154013,
0.0650839731,
0.0667018369,
0.0305208601,
0.0169444494,
0.0327440463,
-0.0007440075,
0.0395233147,
-0.0072440477,
-0.0038966401,
0.0372413211,
-0.0568233319,
0.0302257538,
-0.0360419042,
-0.0103963669,
-0.0170168169,
-0.0299342815,
-0.0313235484,
0.0742532164,
-0.0305952821,
0.0167897996,
0.0238198042,
0.0042652353,
0.0294639748,
-0.0509152301,
0.0333374925,
-0.0443276241,
-0.0003325702,
-0.0037433438,
0.0225532614,
0.0049888245,
-0.0127366278,
-0.0260793511,
-0.0143043771,
0.0197368264,
0.0034259646,
0.017580267,
-0.0018507437,
-0.0634528473,
-0.0502137206,
0.0265953746,
-0.0058410806,
-0.0277164783,
-0.0330977067,
0.0063948729,
0.0122004617,
-0.0495409146,
0.0097983563,
2.847338207e-34,
0.0130619816,
-0.0340368748,
0.0129138045,
0.0302802753,
0.0830348507,
0.0154283885,
-0.0158665404,
0.019798236,
0.050614275,
0.0121510755,
-0.0382110327
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10307v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10307v4 | FACE: Evaluating Natural Language Generation with Fourier Analysis of Cross-Entropy | 2023-05-17T15:44:57 | 2023-10-25T13:32:58 | Zuhao Yang, Yingfang Yuan, Yang Xu, Shuo Zhan, Huajun Bai, Kefan Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Measuring the distance between machine-produced and human language is a
critical open problem. Inspired by empirical findings from psycholinguistics on
the periodicity of entropy in language, we propose FACE, a set of metrics based
on Fourier Analysis of the estimated Cross-Entropy of language, for measuring
the similarity between model-generated and human-written languages. Based on an
open-ended generation task and the experimental data from previous studies, we
find that FACE can effectively identify the human-model gap, scales with model
size, reflects the outcomes of different sampling methods for decoding,
correlates well with other evaluation metrics and with human judgment scores. | [
-0.0198332351,
0.0836515948,
-0.0354410708,
0.0202061441,
-0.0522019975,
0.0089103542,
-0.0108013693,
0.0144733414,
-0.0368620828,
-0.0231067389,
-0.0271413308,
-0.0692562833,
0.056265004,
0.0289547015,
0.042611599,
-0.0540196076,
0.0017739701,
-0.0041465885,
-0.0346209332,
0.0266533773,
-0.0282986555,
-0.0131182708,
-0.0033795889,
0.0558530912,
0.024703294,
-0.0148271127,
-0.0132755181,
0.008831514,
0.0428824387,
0.0139345815,
-0.0406807475,
0.0658022538,
-0.0304080863,
0.070429787,
0.0000015518,
-0.06188621,
0.0166991092,
-0.0135286618,
0.0278256349,
0.0339485593,
0.0474179648,
-0.0148632554,
-0.0660790801,
0.0028016916,
-0.0102862762,
-0.0225898642,
0.0431143604,
0.0386556573,
0.0032903843,
0.013600762,
-0.0097562792,
-0.0112722833,
0.0385356545,
-0.0048974706,
0.0291521475,
0.0490573533,
-0.0305790398,
-0.007773296,
-0.0174572039,
-0.0583747625,
0.0016204128,
0.0468004234,
0.0302421153,
0.0120018972,
0.0103462432,
0.0551612377,
0.0263400692,
-0.0162711982,
0.0063730269,
0.0600222461,
-0.0307181515,
-0.0395871513,
-0.0024275302,
-0.0190565381,
-0.0091725374,
-0.0123464232,
0.0236248691,
0.0421457179,
0.0044924021,
0.0107727163,
0.0373038612,
0.005396191,
0.0009172622,
-0.0135894055,
0.0285534095,
0.0274140071,
0.0311640147,
-0.0491933301,
0.0122469617,
0.0105886143,
-0.0234856792,
-0.0546998195,
-0.0102710947,
0.0067505906,
-0.0111286547,
-0.0002164115,
-0.0664552301,
-0.0309403557,
0.0358709581,
-0.0274927262,
0.0467365421,
0.0146975974,
-0.0041538989,
-0.0316974036,
0.0034960122,
0.0702546686,
-0.0022226805,
0.0031861744,
-0.0407227464,
0.0540508144,
-0.0450304896,
-0.0031473094,
-0.0116908187,
-0.0261679981,
0.0008460397,
-0.0065411096,
-0.0658121407,
0.0072368379,
-0.0116846683,
-0.019684067,
0.022297373,
-0.0021115413,
-0.0075315442,
0.0291232374,
-0.0199297033,
-0.0130690373,
-0.0306352042,
0.0223025437,
0.0269357618,
-0.0486486144,
0.0204902776,
0.0289985165,
-0.0140919108,
-0.0053903651,
0.0104511259,
0.0558655746,
-0.0148524037,
-0.0091289422,
-0.0287619457,
-0.0570706613,
-0.0095443418,
-0.0806092396,
-0.0208367221,
-0.0658003464,
-0.0113956612,
-0.0102300048,
-0.0343717933,
-0.0084820837,
-0.0113258744,
0.0257676579,
0.0193636063,
0.0121265836,
-0.0460647084,
0.0260855816,
0.0514074005,
-0.001657873,
0.0106501076,
0.0354977809,
0.0563498624,
0.0238340721,
0.0004655677,
-0.0206189603,
-0.0031233535,
0.0276158117,
-0.0031287204,
-0.0174270589,
-0.0546794869,
-0.0461528599,
-0.0210526101,
0.0568701476,
0.0609797873,
0.0984228849,
-0.0255287588,
0.0047116801,
0.0473024808,
0.0436728634,
0.0418589786,
0.0538060702,
0.073879011,
0.0285600945,
0.0110227466,
0.0626107156,
0.0182527676,
0.0224293452,
-0.0005523374,
0.0503213555,
0.0765099004,
0.020110812,
-0.0016104098,
-0.0440772623,
0.0157598611,
-0.0052472912,
-0.0074571869,
-0.0484414846,
0.0062460252,
0.0123791974,
-0.0458852351,
-0.0125250062,
0.0262340978,
-0.0697627962,
0.0352237374,
-0.0185605139,
0.0369505733,
0.1026530266,
0.0290198848,
0.0460744128,
0.0567128994,
-0.0042800941,
-0.0506097674,
0.0578879602,
0.0283623077,
0.0055272952,
0.019439958,
-0.0142010059,
0.0049904133,
0.0217433088,
0.0119292662,
0.0191485602,
-0.0348115787,
0.0324476734,
0.0343671665,
-0.0462860949,
-0.0230982918,
0.0303418972,
-0.0605905019,
-0.0150941154,
-0.0097262617,
0.0085199615,
0.0404631495,
0.0115018487,
-0.0693996102,
0.0550402142,
-0.0054306304,
-0.0582539923,
-0.0226996373,
0.0350310877,
-0.0162178893,
-0.0137832873,
-0.0008099684,
-0.0616731644,
0.0220945142,
0.0187148992,
0.0505230501,
-0.0230996087,
0.060994789,
-0.0645783246,
0.0508344211,
-0.075006038,
0.019549422,
-0.0236339681,
0.0409281999,
-0.0326326415,
0.0555412099,
-0.006229016,
0.0628620684,
0.0122899814,
-0.0340887196,
0.0228741542,
-0.0319096483,
-0.0008040999,
0.0370522961,
-0.0257132184,
0.0275465492,
0.008892905,
0.0235676207,
-0.0400677361,
-0.0437629335,
-0.0604197606,
-0.0101727489,
-0.0058814241,
0.0168121886,
0.0306409057,
-0.0312067717,
-0.0131208198,
0.0415547937,
-0.0464871004,
-0.0039540497,
0.0440048836,
-0.0063716671,
0.0297830477,
-0.0039422354,
-0.0496175252,
-0.0235140026,
0.0003435494,
0.0076210778,
0.0418712609,
0.0333504006,
0.0673237145,
-0.0446220636,
0.0779480189,
-0.0452221856,
-0.0385602191,
0.0461875647,
-0.0521884821,
0.0093170814,
0.0068947948,
0.0706102028,
0.0077279336,
0.0449395478,
0.0017322755,
0.0414885767,
-0.0110361734,
-0.0071175927,
-0.050217893,
-0.0208108276,
0.0272755548,
-0.0155027052,
-0.088908568,
0.038461335,
0.072335951,
0.0682567209,
0.0380728059,
-0.0637821257,
0.0154184327,
-0.0233655442,
-0.0571685545,
0.0006178933,
-0.0034376152,
-0.0326478742,
0.044229947,
-0.0221596323,
-0.0754997283,
0.0675830394,
-0.0496347733,
0.0243060067,
0.007030257,
-0.0257373024,
0.0044371309,
0.0504545085,
0.0040015872,
0.0341484062,
0.0454830155,
-0.0103001688,
-0.046369046,
0.0179050006,
0.0292246304,
-0.0376098193,
0.0011152226,
-0.0370830745,
-0.0106149763,
-0.0002381428,
0.0134855993,
-0.0308013726,
-0.0104045216,
-0.0035839959,
-0.0181749798,
0.0490781106,
-0.0291531421,
0.0236452203,
0.0019173606,
0.0290451124,
-0.034576796,
0.0107307239,
-0.0360257402,
0.0040165344,
0.0146653149,
0.0568815097,
-0.0024536178,
0.0103301657,
-0.0420733094,
0.0276219249,
-0.0001451487,
0.0508846343,
0.074662514,
-0.0122323595,
0.0069566933,
0.0058427001,
0.0314858668,
-0.0187980365,
0.0674628019,
0.0506279916,
0.0179242622,
-0.0057841931,
0.1001637131,
0.0012205957,
-0.0080804899,
0.0537368879,
0.0049855337,
0.0884741172,
-0.0242335368,
0.0096119028,
-0.0176163353,
-0.0063360874,
0.0087566236,
0.0458054058,
-0.0492707789,
-0.010647268,
-0.0143292956,
-0.0599484965,
0.0213954728,
0.0242592916,
-0.0538472496,
-0.0663110539,
-0.0339894071,
-0.0169823188,
0.0163396616,
-0.0132610835,
-0.0063609616,
-0.0106852856,
0.0204327963,
0.0273387562,
-0.0360988826,
-0.0525421798,
-0.0116509823,
-0.0303951334,
0.0563907027,
0.0624592751,
0.0448693894,
-0.0010824782,
-0.0840107724,
-0.0307136867,
-0.0552192554,
0.0087487465,
0.0077270856,
0.0408589318,
0.0465647131,
-0.0009114817,
-0.0359861329,
0.0107380832,
-0.0337143019,
-0.0080356356,
-0.0198122319,
0.0534009039,
-0.0184986368,
-0.0407992043,
0.00909968,
0.0332043357,
0.0181852467,
0.0717681572,
0.074540928,
-0.0398359448,
-0.0591677167,
-0.0227091778,
0.0439979471,
-0.0870018303,
-0.0553159975,
-0.0002735287,
0.0187486093,
-0.0878404006,
-0.1051257849,
-0.0380079262,
-0.0530710146,
0.0395323224,
0.0116048018,
-0.002283805,
0.0230868328,
-0.0101675075,
-0.0573463254,
-0.0430491529,
0.0155270342,
0.0484935604,
-0.0651760623,
-0.0397854596,
-0.0377407596,
-0.0374626406,
-0.0138722295,
0.0244400371,
-0.1019217446,
-0.0557693988,
0.0232535005,
-0.0011104996,
0.0238172859,
0.0005422537,
0.0258503184,
-0.0359444357,
0.0479497872,
0.0306748021,
-0.0503087938,
0.0425662659,
0.0022127191,
-0.0132465828,
0.005110235,
0.0260182433,
0.0015173272,
-0.0075396807,
0.0057438994,
0.0380847156,
0.022454394,
-0.0842328891,
0.0224162042,
0.0211365446,
-0.00544579,
-0.063857533,
-0.0459638461,
-0.0216329936,
-0.0608318076,
-0.002112824,
0.0233990308,
-0.0443094037,
-0.0421563014,
0.0474804677,
0.028652709,
0.0040185316,
0.0144619569,
-0.0346919671,
-0.0023905288,
0.0139299231,
0.0087579517,
-0.0363983065,
0.0846241638,
-0.0029220085,
0.0101797022,
-0.0052373135,
-0.0106716352,
-0.0382233448,
0.0277724396,
0.0089707188,
0.033009626,
0.006030078,
0.013186682,
0.0329590999,
0.0261308942,
-0.0478127338,
-0.0133766392,
-0.0197591167,
-0.0343155973,
0.0460216627,
0.0298929345,
0.087051712,
-0.0386081636,
0.0401808023,
-0.0332877077,
0.0489362814,
-0.0359060206,
-0.0201865751,
-0.0134221129,
-0.0008735086,
-0.0348889679,
-0.0530412272,
0.0841500685,
0.0206657033,
-0.001205812,
-0.014971694,
0.0051846113,
-0.0338536873,
-0.0272195935,
-0.0306015443,
-0.048094254,
-0.0216214191,
0.0296333879,
-0.0744691342,
-0.0745585337,
-0.0017806049,
0.0395180546,
0.0466523282,
-0.0040259412,
0.0429505296,
0.0480929054,
-0.0274373312,
0.0303602442,
-0.0443270989,
0.0241486896,
-0.0221848208,
-0.0036940137,
-0.0464840233,
-5.342605661e-33,
-0.0258419216,
-0.0279206969,
-0.0204217006,
0.0122808153,
-0.0403032079,
-0.02660916,
-0.0447462611,
0.0448310636,
0.0034866673,
0.0116573256,
0.0473788902,
-0.0359867886,
0.0092765568,
-0.0022543157,
0.016576929,
-0.009536352,
0.0322595462,
-0.0313843414,
-0.032663174,
0.0325622298,
0.0229954105,
-0.0034352511,
0.0171016976,
-0.0276320484,
0.012512384,
-0.0088410843,
-0.0061323703,
-0.0361394063,
0.0362531357,
0.023914393,
-0.0554547384,
0.0483221747,
0.0145187993,
-0.0434381776,
-0.0253339782,
0.0108233523,
0.0090319691,
-0.0335461833,
-0.007901934,
0.0050558886,
-0.0271726809,
-0.0266956687,
0.0057404591,
-0.0261697639,
-0.0822763294,
0.0011426759,
0.0352389514,
-0.017528072,
-0.0039402018,
-0.0737558603,
-0.0627494454,
0.0243214034,
-0.0260350928,
-0.030828042,
0.0024928413,
0.0541678257,
-0.0317110308,
-0.0513957553,
-0.0273093097,
0.0648162588,
0.0101225218,
0.0364281535,
0.0473269299,
-0.0039486592,
0.0236740541,
0.052415207,
0.0694745854,
-0.0102873445,
-0.0125679113,
0.0651666522,
0.0476306751,
0.018260479,
0.0107029993,
0.0620953143,
0.0672911331,
-0.0362780429,
-0.0079657789,
0.0505168177,
-0.0226504207,
-0.0207513049,
0.0001694045,
-0.0017567769,
-0.0170814898,
-0.0125535745,
-0.0231290888,
-0.047262527,
-0.0209875181,
-0.0238654073,
0.0384513102,
-0.0032688389,
0.0276113153,
-0.0803723484,
0.0278630927,
-0.0159468241,
0.0253227055,
-0.0086068138,
-0.0327685028,
0.025729198,
0.0225629602,
-0.0121471137,
-0.0226568468,
-0.0359618478,
0.0587641709,
0.0794482008,
0.0550557934,
-0.015405261,
0.007041635,
0.0113154342,
-0.0449164994,
0.0219940208,
-0.041194804,
0.0186351165,
0.0243749917,
-0.0514516681,
0.0165916886,
-0.0519088283,
-0.0354773887,
-0.016987266,
-0.0340019055,
0.0073280642,
-0.0357360505,
0.0398501828,
-0.0065277508,
0.0480591282,
-0.0382197164,
-0.0077424003,
-0.0465652905,
-0.027287405,
0.073434785,
-0.0281917099,
-0.0317606032,
-0.0131022949,
2.359e-7,
-0.0190384258,
0.0058331862,
0.0294398349,
0.0238629114,
0.0198039915,
0.0356157981,
-0.0069339056,
0.0149423704,
-0.0163616017,
0.0056731822,
-0.0052126092,
-0.0178206638,
0.0903536156,
0.0274999999,
-0.0140158171,
0.0013518514,
-0.0564218201,
0.018830562,
-0.041504778,
0.0075394991,
0.0814385191,
0.0296692029,
-0.0178462174,
-0.0296897981,
0.0433317982,
-0.0027085601,
0.0325382687,
-0.0338561311,
0.0053366739,
-0.0116725862,
0.0250165761,
-0.0215575229,
0.0125420783,
0.0084619578,
-0.043953836,
-0.0498626344,
0.0096645113,
-0.0177464914,
0.044528801,
-0.0217204019,
0.0215332862,
0.0018939672,
-0.008382027,
-0.0372931436,
-0.0019192003,
-0.0022457817,
-0.0355831683,
0.0089190742,
-0.0099929674,
0.0319397114,
0.018390324,
-0.0406477042,
-0.0259851385,
-0.0039364663,
0.0356312692,
0.0003857592,
0.0235523358,
0.0222151969,
-0.0670046657,
0.0197995696,
-0.0512769148,
-0.0237281937,
-0.0558667555,
-0.0245507285,
0.0579641052,
-0.0334481075,
-0.0013021172,
1.986515658e-34,
0.0162692852,
-0.0082604801,
0.022255687,
-0.0478550717,
0.0258145314,
0.0153474482,
0.0265554599,
0.0066800304,
0.0023524573,
-0.0264025815,
-0.0075081349
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10306v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10306v3 | UniEX: An Effective and Efficient Framework for Unified Information Extraction via a Span-extractive Perspective | 2023-05-17T15:44:12 | 2023-05-22T05:25:33 | Ping Yang, Junyu Lu, Ruyi Gan, Junjie Wang, Yuxiang Zhang, Jiaxing Zhang, Pingjian Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We propose a new paradigm for universal information extraction (IE) that is
compatible with any schema format and applicable to a list of IE tasks, such as
named entity recognition, relation extraction, event extraction and sentiment
analysis. Our approach converts the text-based IE tasks as the token-pair
problem, which uniformly disassembles all extraction targets into joint span
detection, classification and association problems with a unified extractive
framework, namely UniEX. UniEX can synchronously encode schema-based prompt and
textual information, and collaboratively learn the generalized knowledge from
pre-defined information using the auto-encoder language models. We develop a
traffine attention mechanism to integrate heterogeneous factors including
tasks, labels and inside tokens, and obtain the extraction target via a scoring
matrix. Experiment results show that UniEX can outperform generative universal
IE models in terms of performance and inference-speed on $14$ benchmarks IE
datasets with the supervised setting. The state-of-the-art performance in
low-resource scenarios also verifies the transferability and effectiveness of
UniEX. | [
0.029280765,
0.0370129831,
0.0032161218,
0.0492216647,
-0.0049739229,
0.0407282971,
-0.0027396446,
-0.0236793477,
0.0064353594,
-0.0451702364,
-0.0276864283,
-0.0068507036,
-0.0538590476,
0.0554881059,
0.0281859525,
-0.0343282297,
0.0575448982,
-0.0005494937,
0.0605207868,
0.0152901504,
0.0028000476,
-0.0079320846,
0.0031326525,
-0.0222685095,
-0.044614587,
-0.001030676,
-0.0021583445,
-0.0102051152,
0.0332368985,
-0.0338235982,
0.0212993063,
0.0365601033,
0.0167421848,
-0.0193894356,
0.0000022107,
-0.0452584364,
-0.0402695648,
-0.0321844667,
-0.0187126473,
-0.0359711386,
-0.010488593,
-0.0157675929,
0.0294077359,
-0.020687392,
-0.0222907159,
-0.0672725737,
0.0114337066,
0.0511395261,
0.0248709414,
0.0641260445,
-0.0365271494,
-0.0341713428,
0.046497222,
-0.0339945704,
-0.0078352261,
-0.0743963942,
0.0288321115,
-0.0367309898,
-0.0105084637,
0.0126574766,
-0.0042334241,
0.0245182756,
0.0148119703,
0.0075503397,
0.066940546,
0.0434973054,
-0.0778458118,
-0.0267897192,
-0.0441075377,
0.1256053746,
-0.0152996387,
0.0275291204,
0.0502942279,
0.00929181,
-0.0065267379,
-0.0108785471,
-0.0251594577,
0.0050659324,
-0.0271018464,
0.0162918027,
0.0113285528,
0.019415969,
0.0103818262,
-0.0389800742,
-0.0256222244,
0.0586254969,
0.0064582741,
-0.0229653176,
0.0320910737,
0.0226888508,
-0.0018861922,
-0.051747296,
0.0239321757,
0.0329649523,
0.0094166882,
0.0133565785,
-0.0266323816,
-0.0394373946,
-0.0136337355,
-0.0090526966,
0.0021272269,
0.0064155003,
-0.0413276181,
0.0854249969,
-0.0410022512,
0.0269958805,
-0.0145109892,
0.0220219605,
-0.013920866,
-0.0358554646,
-0.0234646648,
0.0301414952,
-0.0297069307,
0.075264588,
-0.0514899641,
-0.0219657738,
0.0025581548,
0.0341388918,
-0.008231964,
0.0336641781,
0.002985141,
0.0065305848,
-0.0113295736,
0.0230494309,
-0.0094829379,
0.0169663634,
-0.0579545908,
-0.0089203082,
-0.0042160945,
-0.0400324464,
-0.0366419628,
0.020110691,
0.0675676316,
-0.0386801772,
0.0062151025,
0.0865005404,
0.0018319996,
-0.0570067056,
-0.0349546373,
-0.0262382124,
-0.0111346748,
-0.0367017724,
0.0099365506,
-0.0359047838,
0.1142321154,
0.022783516,
-0.0392028913,
0.0044242684,
0.0248187892,
-0.0185635593,
-0.0353109054,
0.0336824544,
0.0055105509,
-0.0077284048,
0.0130190682,
-0.0204045381,
0.0218032114,
0.0547081418,
0.0175401401,
0.0714639276,
0.0535939038,
0.0056022848,
0.0059036971,
0.0302529801,
0.0316176862,
-0.0157985426,
0.033695288,
0.0471850745,
0.0664958134,
-0.0340553522,
0.0353722535,
0.0516672879,
-0.0218634438,
0.0075117708,
0.0356865413,
0.0009203488,
-0.016826896,
0.0242961105,
0.0328390375,
-0.0179672893,
-0.0094585773,
-0.0141480453,
-0.0481233597,
0.0266426522,
-0.0109323896,
0.020260822,
0.0547290221,
0.0220038686,
-0.0226196628,
-0.0302821416,
0.006062137,
-0.0329941846,
-0.015024106,
0.0179956239,
0.0690883696,
0.0131690558,
-0.0642542765,
0.0823784769,
0.0622316003,
-0.0633126944,
0.0437717997,
0.0354291424,
0.041128777,
0.0413754247,
0.0283822678,
-0.0464093611,
0.0008439504,
-0.0285743214,
0.0257519279,
0.0134815648,
-0.0044962149,
-0.040433649,
0.0414220206,
-0.0326619335,
-0.0474942289,
-0.0011238786,
-0.0157418307,
0.0139910318,
0.0258568227,
0.0066700112,
-0.0067197583,
-0.0303609874,
-0.0280052256,
0.0298413225,
-0.0123656802,
-0.055044122,
-0.0046037552,
0.0405806936,
0.0287266914,
0.0405501388,
0.0026316745,
-0.0314499661,
0.0508332625,
-0.0654663965,
-0.0539499,
-0.0056720409,
-0.0681536496,
-0.0642918497,
-0.0049648252,
-0.0265110545,
-0.0179371778,
0.0076387012,
-0.0361555442,
-0.0378864184,
-0.0171882752,
0.024749076,
0.0272269789,
-0.0176235344,
-0.0078458767,
0.0328291357,
0.0090154614,
-0.0317961834,
0.0990632847,
-0.0178474709,
-0.0102047147,
-0.0188997276,
-0.0231309161,
-0.01551528,
-0.0309576709,
-0.0430363379,
0.0358344316,
0.0101940325,
-0.0404692926,
0.0262120944,
-0.01113874,
-0.0579525866,
-0.044023551,
-0.0838823542,
0.0140315155,
-0.0272250492,
0.0489255004,
0.017680129,
0.0366707407,
-0.0082712537,
-0.0340680778,
-0.024736857,
-0.0081821559,
-0.0374707244,
-0.0168107171,
0.0564952195,
0.0356398448,
0.0329856873,
-0.035080269,
-0.0018032122,
-0.0281201918,
0.0314605087,
0.0239336248,
-0.0505165495,
0.0026437656,
0.0292935725,
-0.014456532,
0.0369001776,
-0.002501416,
0.0142955948,
-0.035818439,
-0.0059290952,
0.0207404215,
0.0706301853,
0.010456888,
0.047217723,
-0.0257964171,
-0.0199670624,
-0.0314946696,
0.0587660931,
-0.0611349195,
0.0397187769,
-0.0033875352,
0.007481826,
0.0587478839,
0.0659703389,
0.0245585665,
0.0143997734,
-0.0245007444,
-0.0349499919,
0.019055048,
-0.0068110838,
-0.0387910232,
0.0038622017,
0.0066019786,
-0.0162926037,
-0.0519794077,
-0.0185222533,
0.0714305714,
-0.0407032073,
-0.0140442699,
-0.0225402042,
0.0165586714,
-0.0777763948,
0.0450321585,
0.0080120396,
0.0311014205,
-0.0061467667,
-0.0599783845,
0.0278449301,
0.0290080458,
-0.0258458909,
-0.0144130941,
0.0364855565,
0.0027463348,
0.0181983318,
-0.0177513342,
-0.036821451,
-0.0571825914,
-0.0298259314,
0.0062900903,
0.0125365919,
0.0011139372,
0.0146421893,
-0.0094242515,
0.0214446746,
0.0143363699,
0.0207513589,
-0.0282810014,
0.0102138249,
-0.0347095132,
0.0577914715,
0.040300034,
-0.0307475701,
-0.0478957854,
-0.0073064808,
-0.0172381159,
0.0504224114,
-0.0054868287,
0.0246799719,
0.0201074108,
0.0145696606,
0.0101793678,
-0.0422077924,
0.0223196037,
-0.0395548679,
0.0458889939,
-0.0306610148,
-0.011219874,
0.1185849234,
0.0111098802,
-0.0390515625,
-0.010144785,
0.0318661928,
-0.0050452994,
0.0103736715,
0.0082722064,
-0.0755746141,
-0.0478445813,
-0.0097192973,
0.0228958204,
0.0568561181,
-0.0551530309,
0.0318191573,
-0.0738770217,
-0.0251566954,
-0.0103703225,
-0.0770956501,
-0.0363508351,
-0.0351618342,
0.0488506518,
-0.0229313709,
0.004310742,
0.0002200734,
-0.0137578929,
0.0195569731,
-0.0024750398,
-0.0036613911,
-0.0226367172,
0.0205346327,
-0.0364900939,
0.0242442749,
0.0705687106,
0.0099252975,
0.0027277523,
-0.0184312966,
0.0229530148,
-0.0166273136,
-0.0066826544,
-0.0200213399,
0.0811802447,
-0.088018164,
-0.0025521861,
-0.0052176537,
0.0390974097,
-0.039489042,
0.0228094682,
0.0219097733,
0.0811464936,
0.0205626003,
-0.0304408222,
0.0021379853,
-0.0608657114,
0.0307568349,
0.1061693281,
0.0314107053,
-0.0161777902,
-0.0289578643,
0.0068180491,
0.0094456151,
-0.0663472265,
-0.0035196282,
0.0054533007,
-0.0226180181,
-0.0488098636,
-0.0515649095,
-0.0770301223,
0.0597300828,
0.0332828872,
-0.0105455685,
-0.012288251,
0.0183617231,
-0.0085923653,
-0.0456208549,
0.0349009931,
-0.0295517165,
-0.0503150411,
-0.0429036468,
-0.0384841673,
-0.0207694713,
-0.0072937147,
-0.0385984965,
0.019001998,
-0.0252639446,
-0.0371397473,
-0.0057060709,
0.0272025261,
0.0040686582,
0.0471204892,
-0.0098765614,
0.0073939194,
0.0602418818,
0.0201368127,
-0.0775646642,
0.006191717,
-0.0031640697,
0.0222858042,
0.0187706836,
0.0466656238,
-0.0594062358,
0.0471276157,
0.0184183177,
0.0562498383,
-0.0174204689,
-0.0528371148,
0.0002506656,
0.014423104,
0.0720185563,
0.0225161947,
-0.0126615614,
-0.049813576,
0.0129541615,
0.0092932899,
-0.0149077326,
-0.028259242,
0.0305960458,
-0.0304657258,
-0.0127132051,
0.0026344103,
0.0460223854,
0.0132583324,
0.0218962263,
-0.0427554101,
0.0041971509,
-0.0091473563,
0.0524081476,
-0.0029258523,
-0.0248384178,
-0.032275863,
0.006160106,
0.0354884081,
0.0052319365,
-0.0327921957,
0.0049944622,
0.0238451045,
-0.0122107696,
0.0178860705,
0.02479841,
-0.0181311648,
0.025249755,
-0.0319260322,
0.0200593546,
0.000600605,
-0.0115962327,
0.013396685,
0.0249302164,
0.0018790091,
0.0153206764,
0.0062488206,
-0.0151714552,
-0.0245565604,
0.0331594311,
0.013258161,
-0.0342874601,
-0.0390724055,
0.0670300424,
-0.0539121591,
0.0209165625,
0.0009817372,
0.0135451164,
-0.0783573538,
0.0096451081,
-0.0062291822,
0.0029629124,
-0.0170124602,
0.0089433314,
-0.0113985874,
-0.0150392521,
0.0191156399,
-0.0098411683,
-0.0320012085,
0.0031889183,
0.0407589339,
0.0478514284,
0.0239039939,
-0.0351037122,
-0.0319452249,
0.0560160019,
0.0124394409,
-0.0101619475,
-0.0051830546,
-7.088947987e-33,
-0.0473191366,
-0.0220006648,
0.0062234737,
0.0306162387,
-0.0281981397,
0.0211617704,
-0.0594748333,
-0.0350435302,
-0.0146636944,
-0.0248328727,
0.0098896017,
0.0007739646,
0.0007807107,
0.0528050177,
-0.0089484788,
-0.029198017,
0.0365976803,
0.0248946827,
-0.0229944251,
0.0343221463,
0.0830284357,
0.0731838197,
0.0482808203,
-0.0933266878,
0.0287126079,
-0.029548401,
0.0352457799,
0.0198090915,
0.1026259363,
0.0165460389,
-0.0235868413,
0.0239832103,
0.0167202223,
-0.0476558693,
0.0202014726,
0.0784557164,
-0.1630007476,
-0.0364473723,
-0.0087740449,
-0.0214351323,
-0.0544996262,
-0.0473984256,
0.0311662387,
-0.0089967865,
0.047494553,
-0.0216955133,
0.046810057,
0.0110772764,
0.0248086452,
-0.0515745506,
-0.0623545535,
0.009335869,
0.0253387336,
0.0336560234,
0.0309411436,
0.0390175097,
0.0323195867,
0.0460342728,
-0.06079299,
-0.0130136795,
-0.0285117626,
0.0231259838,
0.0373837464,
0.0030009483,
-0.0022764693,
0.0595487468,
-0.0002644517,
-0.032126341,
-0.042695757,
0.0040995632,
-0.0270474069,
0.0614447333,
-0.0311527345,
0.0021871682,
-0.0316832028,
-0.0182942785,
-0.0814928114,
0.0235207416,
0.0316519588,
0.0188447908,
-0.0177051313,
0.0105384523,
-0.0402983986,
0.0205897186,
0.0149447648,
-0.0020839944,
-0.0231964067,
-0.0198786408,
0.0235809796,
0.0076206499,
-0.0085806884,
0.0264893975,
0.0109689077,
0.0156492256,
-0.0181916039,
0.0522058979,
0.0385492221,
0.0178271271,
0.0037061495,
0.0199860521,
-0.06874796,
-0.0336974189,
0.0024298262,
0.0255656932,
0.0130467676,
0.025628956,
0.0532073826,
-0.0032644609,
-0.0476556122,
-0.0229559727,
-0.0401446931,
0.0303936936,
-0.0365881585,
0.0018402705,
0.0077477721,
0.0248488169,
-0.0298428833,
0.0441732109,
0.0154066375,
0.0418974943,
-0.0441137142,
0.0019074274,
0.0248779394,
0.0307508055,
0.008999398,
-0.0234736931,
-0.0244117025,
0.0301953703,
-0.0026100683,
-0.0541789159,
0.0138486642,
0.0173434503,
2.945e-7,
0.0440127067,
0.0122356359,
0.0467683822,
-0.0052207424,
0.0048561576,
0.0234840419,
0.0199726112,
0.0683343634,
-0.0162511878,
-0.0253022239,
-0.0034424718,
0.0255014505,
-0.0134059377,
0.0107211145,
-0.0885827988,
0.0034472053,
-0.0337057263,
-0.031711977,
-0.0505355,
0.0121221272,
0.0570555329,
0.0522286817,
0.0037422737,
0.0314182788,
-0.0224448387,
-0.0176408216,
0.0386755839,
-0.0091186995,
-0.0032423988,
0.0373039134,
-0.002178719,
0.0083360551,
-0.049034331,
0.0352008604,
-0.0095730051,
0.0582012348,
0.014373973,
0.048377756,
-0.0231339466,
-0.0499720275,
0.0009882576,
-0.0375687182,
0.0124597438,
-0.0497820713,
0.0958308876,
-0.0580347963,
-0.011466709,
-0.0019066053,
-0.0367227085,
0.0496920533,
-0.0422382951,
0.0339062177,
-0.0092830872,
0.0384775996,
0.0186839513,
-0.0376967043,
-0.0334799662,
-0.0952010229,
0.0250227563,
0.0325732417,
-0.0220486708,
-0.0140130688,
-0.0261042714,
-0.0000635113,
-0.0067067067,
-0.0766543671,
0.0215199739,
2.660884599e-34,
-0.0248342212,
0.02358987,
-0.0292232484,
0.0088482732,
0.0141926343,
-0.0664759204,
-0.1203005016,
-0.0242102072,
-0.0216491725,
-0.0579434596,
-0.001658253
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10284v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10284v1 | Towards More Robust NLP System Evaluation: Handling Missing Scores in Benchmarks | 2023-05-17T15:20:31 | 2023-05-17T15:20:31 | Anas Himmi, Ekhine Irurozki, Nathan Noiry, Stephan Clemencon, Pierre Colombo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The evaluation of natural language processing (NLP) systems is crucial for
advancing the field, but current benchmarking approaches often assume that all
systems have scores available for all tasks, which is not always practical. In
reality, several factors such as the cost of running baseline, private systems,
computational limitations, or incomplete data may prevent some systems from
being evaluated on entire tasks. This paper formalize an existing problem in
NLP research: benchmarking when some systems scores are missing on the task,
and proposes a novel approach to address it. Our method utilizes a compatible
partial ranking approach to impute missing data, which is then aggregated using
the Borda count method. It includes two refinements designed specifically for
scenarios where either task-level or instance-level scores are available. We
also introduce an extended benchmark, which contains over 131 million scores,
an order of magnitude larger than existing benchmarks. We validate our methods
and demonstrate their effectiveness in addressing the challenge of missing
system evaluation on an entire task. This work highlights the need for more
comprehensive benchmarking approaches that can handle real-world scenarios
where not all systems are evaluated on the entire task. | [
0.0321457684,
0.0645796806,
0.0005798197,
0.037629813,
-0.0291034803,
-0.0037456376,
-0.0011523552,
0.0093952501,
0.0285720937,
-0.0213112738,
0.0029645343,
-0.0031808354,
0.010805958,
0.0355366766,
-0.0017586603,
0.0056839865,
0.0249123089,
0.0465489663,
-0.0195007324,
-0.0097783394,
0.0058532292,
0.0124020725,
-0.0031650171,
0.0261184685,
-0.0006697625,
0.0228516497,
0.0104545411,
-0.0090344595,
0.0394057967,
-0.0357314274,
0.0028415679,
0.0218349732,
-0.0324724205,
0.0063589327,
0.0000019911,
-0.0524743795,
-0.0397125892,
0.0097487457,
-0.0239908304,
-0.0067399,
0.0223468821,
0.0215296745,
0.0127202198,
0.0337494425,
-0.0367131829,
-0.0124044511,
0.0225376468,
0.0250323545,
0.0535917468,
0.0659414902,
0.0051356056,
0.0290936083,
-0.0102540003,
0.0053508901,
-0.02138157,
-0.0954575017,
-0.0151978415,
0.0048718178,
0.0155168837,
-0.0216907673,
0.014107435,
0.0309500024,
0.0053671715,
-0.0035376872,
0.0175744426,
0.0201514289,
-0.0676000714,
-0.0021140275,
-0.0096271886,
0.0454065651,
0.0163211934,
-0.0007403448,
0.0091045117,
-0.0099475412,
-0.0061803451,
-0.0260558166,
-0.0431304462,
-0.0185479466,
0.0189769808,
0.0241799541,
0.0166945383,
0.0706823096,
0.0277678426,
0.0203347616,
0.0214785803,
0.0689876974,
0.0172212403,
-0.0251545552,
-0.0150598418,
0.0248470381,
-0.0529704802,
-0.038831301,
0.057101883,
-0.0089901192,
-0.0558512621,
0.0106631769,
-0.0025910405,
-0.0315374769,
0.0200055018,
-0.0105257379,
0.0601450875,
0.0187224727,
-0.0007216588,
0.077985242,
-0.0208941922,
0.0558741316,
0.0280493293,
-0.0137390951,
-0.0129164206,
-0.0013088593,
-0.0707400516,
-0.0125031108,
-0.0088186311,
0.0654038414,
-0.0488078445,
-0.0238779504,
-0.0430739783,
0.0013840874,
-0.0513724014,
0.0031922024,
0.0228198152,
0.0487288274,
-0.0148432311,
0.0229852144,
-0.0320998728,
0.0013405974,
-0.025466729,
0.000455125,
-0.0139489817,
-0.0439042114,
-0.0192671884,
-0.0278777685,
0.0217183195,
-0.0355015025,
0.018031409,
0.0609194376,
0.0636445284,
-0.0563142858,
-0.0041843713,
-0.0215197131,
-0.0222693421,
-0.0759965405,
-0.0215305239,
-0.0451708585,
0.0247265697,
0.0297948252,
0.0405845717,
-0.0097731911,
0.0002030244,
0.0402477197,
0.0002628546,
0.0539575145,
0.0057167201,
-0.0195859857,
-0.0484418795,
-0.0175662488,
-0.0098524075,
0.0728486255,
-0.0048748613,
-0.0079898853,
0.0706301481,
0.0276779979,
0.002727895,
0.0047788592,
0.0294140391,
0.0005932867,
0.0141347907,
0.0016082767,
-0.0269601364,
-0.0074764229,
-0.0234492067,
0.0311562717,
-0.0047236807,
-0.0322547741,
0.0221275724,
0.0173119493,
-0.0166612528,
-0.0150271757,
0.0176176317,
-0.0240480453,
0.0204827487,
0.0222837403,
-0.0262144115,
-0.0150861712,
-0.0569780208,
-0.0079403194,
0.0758027881,
0.0176054519,
0.014041936,
-0.0478203185,
-0.0333275534,
0.0106454417,
-0.0151073486,
-0.0191698559,
0.0684155673,
0.0153830368,
-0.0312571153,
0.0002604975,
0.0010703841,
-0.0479349047,
0.0234038793,
0.0133657632,
-0.039239224,
0.0812074766,
0.0855597928,
-0.0626532882,
0.0027779441,
0.0228329655,
-0.030343039,
0.025339717,
0.0244214181,
-0.0214084536,
0.0470685624,
-0.0194888469,
-0.0133524844,
0.0261397939,
0.0582796745,
-0.0230070185,
0.0125550805,
-0.0118828397,
0.0231299605,
-0.0885214061,
-0.0603973456,
0.0282502677,
-0.0103337402,
-0.0066637602,
0.0254449435,
-0.0429575592,
0.0268625021,
0.0563902594,
0.0058424384,
0.0256431606,
0.0577046871,
-0.0095198005,
-0.0457098484,
-0.0512227677,
0.0037719263,
-0.0734236762,
0.0403522812,
-0.0398248695,
-0.0334101841,
0.1352412403,
-0.0484384522,
-0.0452256873,
-0.020997934,
-0.0489223227,
0.0033657025,
-0.0178851709,
0.0317149162,
0.0229005963,
-0.0186508354,
-0.0542111211,
0.0759025589,
-0.0118954619,
0.0858558714,
-0.033189442,
-0.0236611832,
0.0260029417,
-0.0526895188,
-0.0779524073,
0.0045633093,
-0.0180177763,
-0.0180364586,
0.0418633297,
-0.0113982232,
-0.0757522807,
0.036067836,
-0.1184168532,
0.0327730216,
-0.0038167629,
0.0356565788,
0.0353466012,
0.0159895066,
0.0191919375,
-0.0257643573,
-0.0044753868,
-0.0378319584,
0.0480108075,
0.0314854458,
0.023059031,
0.0027922275,
0.00785839,
-0.0335735045,
-0.0306864139,
-0.0213658549,
0.0601394437,
-0.0240653325,
-0.0030167606,
-0.0187345482,
0.0666840076,
-0.0419546738,
0.0192240998,
0.0160320289,
0.0189083852,
0.0003101245,
0.013752494,
-0.0016280244,
-0.0057348935,
-0.0295633171,
0.0114256106,
0.0157424863,
0.0008847361,
-0.0725669414,
-0.011519473,
-0.0429885201,
0.0175526384,
-0.0085467761,
-0.0323087052,
-0.0033754245,
0.0095401835,
-0.0002023693,
-0.0280436538,
-0.0373905897,
0.0438622423,
-0.0689923465,
-0.0298652295,
-0.0569076911,
0.0140181445,
0.0070016589,
0.0287006237,
-0.0138470633,
-0.0207454823,
0.0373314582,
-0.0026001791,
0.0186206456,
-0.0882410556,
0.0129222646,
-0.0299126375,
0.043331977,
0.0414299369,
0.0130829373,
-0.0295325331,
-0.0258968268,
-0.0008130193,
0.0247475468,
0.0200283527,
-0.0611250959,
0.0135378828,
-0.0221316647,
0.0120371897,
-0.0005985284,
-0.0332121588,
-0.0385503396,
-0.0037868062,
-0.022520557,
0.0269357655,
0.0444037654,
0.0080104768,
-0.0328520797,
-0.0128629711,
0.0056012566,
0.0441502817,
0.0217162762,
-0.0320416056,
-0.0159598906,
0.0283496976,
0.005851177,
-0.0263411049,
0.0671576411,
-0.0130004333,
0.0064852713,
0.0420154966,
0.1367276609,
0.0056700585,
-0.0043972726,
-0.0221564714,
0.0343513936,
-0.0384174995,
-0.0141162202,
0.0076198471,
0.0231211577,
-0.0261207763,
-0.0147349574,
0.1118664369,
0.0487839766,
0.0039786883,
0.0110726105,
0.0307606347,
-0.0261555072,
0.0316252485,
0.0103422534,
-0.062212415,
-0.0243245251,
0.0097242603,
0.0271792971,
-0.059403237,
-0.0532253161,
-0.0076232161,
-0.1537276208,
-0.0038242498,
-0.0236381553,
0.0142328609,
0.0068146968,
-0.0831686035,
0.0247229747,
-0.0702913254,
-0.0377382375,
-0.0145513695,
0.011538391,
0.0197962057,
0.0122546135,
-0.0269721337,
-0.0587605983,
0.0211884473,
-0.0315493718,
0.0527436584,
0.0306816641,
0.0559848174,
-0.0195952505,
0.0128411045,
0.0129716964,
-0.0020517386,
-0.0140209412,
-0.0137295127,
0.0783475861,
0.0159080457,
-0.0115388529,
-0.012240042,
-0.0517730638,
-0.031138083,
-0.0018485325,
-0.0361374468,
0.0621585324,
0.0096619576,
0.0251991898,
0.0139674535,
-0.0217892583,
-0.0176652707,
0.0866309628,
-0.0340624191,
-0.0078042489,
-0.0179377664,
0.0052825138,
-0.0228572898,
-0.0573894382,
-0.0107560866,
0.0173536558,
-0.0260617491,
-0.0187167935,
-0.0781095773,
-0.0619259328,
0.0554250069,
0.0505148545,
-0.0128163164,
0.0248223394,
0.0318437815,
-0.0128378104,
-0.0280127618,
-0.0006552433,
-0.0317505747,
0.0310943276,
-0.0025459863,
0.0222185627,
0.0006005185,
0.0371848382,
-0.0363229178,
0.0129926261,
-0.0335191451,
-0.0566214025,
0.0174592789,
0.0309482515,
0.0223621763,
-0.0202965606,
-0.0540028699,
-0.0316944197,
0.0069875647,
0.0600038916,
-0.0616376474,
0.0034437762,
0.0017485509,
-0.0657281056,
0.0008274899,
0.0386413001,
-0.0156466905,
0.0050258599,
0.0337105133,
0.0778177232,
0.0191330668,
0.0400085151,
0.0579870827,
0.0292149764,
0.0589761473,
-0.0207143016,
-0.033264488,
-0.0078096134,
0.0013203727,
-0.0343232527,
-0.0509084016,
-0.0353610478,
-0.0054001976,
0.0438801385,
0.0443327166,
-0.0476208404,
0.051877059,
-0.0325484946,
0.0673753619,
-0.0642176569,
-0.0141782686,
0.0634305775,
-0.0268529821,
-0.0066469889,
-0.0338376723,
-0.0084819589,
-0.0309944581,
0.0219935477,
0.0457038879,
-0.0053324914,
-0.0008161278,
0.0108440528,
0.0223333277,
0.004031972,
0.0522603542,
-0.0624201298,
0.0061658784,
-0.052941341,
0.0378468074,
0.0380614363,
-0.0359246172,
0.0658035055,
0.0276807752,
-0.0106257079,
-0.0292720105,
-0.0205331258,
0.0334692188,
-0.0156608857,
-0.0533387586,
0.0346063152,
0.0119777694,
0.0626917705,
0.0799907073,
-0.001759866,
0.0573959053,
-0.0314740539,
-0.0393873751,
-0.0297422763,
-0.01632802,
-0.0207319204,
0.0281249247,
-0.0089577828,
0.0083458545,
-0.0573730059,
-0.0864929408,
0.0155967735,
0.0226745773,
0.0434629992,
0.0120191025,
0.0347243026,
0.0403390154,
0.0086392974,
0.0158172604,
-0.0571305007,
-0.0361153521,
-0.0283601563,
-0.0079776198,
-0.0407511741,
-6.447696717e-33,
-0.0337532945,
-0.0734040961,
-0.018043654,
-0.0255659204,
0.0184178296,
0.0294984505,
0.0116783828,
-0.0162841454,
0.0196860358,
0.0062012998,
-0.0313181058,
0.0145571679,
0.0223666374,
0.0102840886,
0.0128275296,
-0.0153159034,
0.037375249,
0.0139052924,
-0.0566291772,
-0.0335338451,
0.0634351149,
0.0288395565,
0.0782215446,
-0.0722129941,
0.0496738702,
0.0185271818,
-0.032358095,
0.0028924749,
-0.0015770888,
0.0306030735,
-0.0128924865,
0.0420449749,
0.0418455303,
-0.080203481,
-0.0091457004,
-0.0395815447,
-0.0335984454,
-0.0162844267,
0.0147779547,
0.0021451593,
-0.0027637503,
0.0428541563,
0.0098393541,
-0.0166309401,
-0.032307867,
0.0385832079,
0.0338839106,
-0.0317194313,
-0.0180149507,
-0.0292361826,
-0.0223087873,
0.0360639878,
-0.0193215832,
0.0214958601,
-0.0040053353,
0.0500809923,
-0.0262198448,
-0.0233184434,
-0.0513852499,
-0.0217255261,
0.0024896252,
0.0279934891,
0.0213044435,
-0.0419807918,
-0.0166775063,
0.0646259636,
0.0232281815,
-0.0123240957,
0.0154609215,
-0.0267730001,
0.0032322661,
0.0232790429,
0.077865079,
0.0339936465,
0.0624611974,
0.0433300696,
-0.06660752,
0.0430740863,
-0.0241111964,
0.037902236,
0.0037598012,
0.0229710788,
-0.0806981698,
-0.0118889138,
-0.0482898839,
0.0019932077,
-0.0545537584,
-0.0108196829,
0.0234484524,
0.0334223658,
-0.0570172332,
0.0193754472,
-0.0102877244,
-0.062074054,
-0.0364960171,
-0.0250296369,
0.055657994,
0.0092153987,
0.0233911611,
0.0107572945,
-0.0315886177,
0.0044030719,
0.0076665911,
0.0368796326,
0.0295338016,
-0.0720092878,
0.0451686308,
-0.004822019,
-0.0491352081,
0.0235710852,
-0.0544611253,
0.0202726461,
-0.024100285,
0.011822544,
0.0516569167,
-0.0088963322,
-0.0377263688,
0.0149870496,
0.0353795066,
0.0337545909,
-0.0498937219,
-0.0180751737,
0.0133706396,
-0.0380162112,
-0.0020261225,
-0.0231378656,
-0.0071795764,
0.0027524987,
0.00023022,
0.0205306355,
-0.0137333414,
-0.0022035406,
2.806e-7,
0.0536671802,
0.0225513093,
-0.0039621522,
0.0106037576,
-0.0067698881,
0.020925343,
-0.0170903299,
0.0488841385,
0.0309241787,
-0.0000975319,
-0.0446741097,
-0.0189999416,
0.0273541808,
0.0388463773,
-0.0669493154,
-0.0437028781,
-0.011271216,
-0.0540616885,
-0.0154493796,
-0.0142889703,
0.0558884516,
0.0531572364,
0.0156792421,
0.0085353367,
-0.0409043431,
-0.0499385074,
0.0189650729,
0.0076169069,
-0.080760777,
-0.0248513129,
0.0645780116,
0.0222655125,
0.0458381064,
0.0269398652,
-0.0456161834,
0.0347429402,
0.0658226982,
0.0299748816,
-0.0132308193,
-0.0116960853,
-0.0067661167,
-0.0212581754,
0.0181603581,
0.0147843454,
0.0727734938,
0.0038462933,
-0.0145852165,
0.017088443,
-0.0474974625,
0.0077509363,
0.0490481071,
0.0274051689,
-0.051682841,
-0.0002663528,
0.004625292,
-0.0045272987,
-0.0373291895,
-0.0527014546,
-0.0244807974,
0.0106748203,
-0.0011594407,
-0.0673120394,
-0.0040244255,
0.0184498653,
0.0107261371,
-0.0754734352,
0.0008259457,
2.810220825e-34,
0.0401693024,
0.0094801402,
0.0166956112,
-0.0315904319,
0.04174532,
-0.0046632513,
-0.0465506129,
-0.0049303374,
-0.0045035495,
-0.0474731699,
0.01324818
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10276v6 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10276v6 | Chain-of-Symbol Prompting Elicits Planning in Large Langauge Models | 2023-05-17T15:07:50 | 2023-10-04T02:03:45 | Hanxu Hu, Hongyuan Lu, Huajian Zhang, Yun-Ze Song, Wai Lam, Yue Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we take the initiative to investigate the performance of LLMs
on complex planning tasks that require LLMs to understand a virtual spatial
environment simulated via natural language and act correspondingly in text. We
propose a benchmark named Natural Language Planning and Action (Natala)
composed of a set of novel tasks: Brick World, NLVR-based Manipulations, and
Natural Language Navigation. We found that current popular LLMs such as ChatGPT
still lack abilities in complex planning. This arises a question -- do the LLMs
have a good understanding of the environments described in natural language, or
maybe other alternatives such as symbolic representations are neater and hence
better to be understood by LLMs? To this end, we propose a novel method called
CoS (Chain-of-Symbol Prompting) that represents the complex environments with
condensed symbolic spatial representations during the chained intermediate
thinking steps. CoS is easy to use and does not need additional training on
LLMs. Extensive experiments indicate that CoS clearly surpasses the performance
of the Chain-of-Thought (CoT) Prompting in all three planning tasks with even
fewer tokens used in the inputs compared with CoT on ChatGPT and InstructGPT.
The performance gain is strong, by up to 60.8% accuracy (from 31.8% to 92.6%)
on Brick World for ChatGPT. CoS also reduces the number of tokens in the prompt
obviously, by up to 65.8% of the tokens (from 407 to 139) for the intermediate
steps from demonstrations on Brick World. Code and data available at:
https://github.com/hanxuhu/chain-of-symbol-planning | [
0.035888534,
-0.018316254,
-0.0175306853,
0.0309788845,
-0.060887672,
0.0092011178,
-0.0071258312,
0.0104911141,
0.0556088723,
-0.0290267896,
-0.0456371009,
-0.0173099786,
-0.0012465153,
0.0134758521,
0.0203203056,
-0.0560337119,
0.0591861717,
-0.0592655241,
-0.0232070498,
-0.0083681596,
-0.0454538986,
-0.0155697558,
-0.06381993,
0.0411496572,
0.0018852381,
-0.0025709025,
-0.0673403963,
0.0097465701,
0.0192179866,
-0.0835774615,
-0.0379805006,
0.002245937,
0.0660423189,
0.0045070667,
0.0000019534,
-0.0464018844,
0.0195010789,
-0.0337109119,
0.0011788231,
-0.0411515944,
0.0056264778,
-0.0110324277,
-0.0011713316,
0.0103918416,
-0.0514980815,
0.0215796623,
0.0154505335,
0.0441446118,
0.0258605666,
0.0626645386,
0.007105635,
-0.0055796229,
0.0026596403,
0.0371930748,
0.0260049608,
-0.0145537145,
-0.0178039316,
-0.0073911194,
0.0781708062,
0.0496242307,
-0.0118867205,
0.0349616967,
0.0503791943,
0.0173060037,
-0.0471767932,
0.0499739535,
0.0172591526,
0.0071627386,
-0.0431994088,
0.0310047623,
0.0001503939,
-0.0102470983,
0.0398248509,
0.0148332082,
0.0187996924,
-0.0050472044,
-0.0473326817,
0.0413539633,
-0.012546137,
0.0121828821,
0.0001708593,
-0.0070939418,
-0.0024291496,
-0.0007610258,
0.0023439827,
0.076983422,
-0.0097853411,
-0.0290184394,
0.0138209723,
-0.0145594189,
0.0184168015,
-0.0725402087,
0.0025753146,
0.0739665404,
-0.0606565811,
0.0296252519,
-0.0179013293,
0.0536145456,
-0.0238811579,
-0.0368316881,
0.0222065896,
0.0703000352,
-0.0108576361,
0.0317755155,
-0.0381458849,
0.0917531997,
-0.002731978,
0.0700469837,
-0.0375554077,
0.0362191349,
-0.038253881,
0.0128687713,
-0.0487786792,
0.0380266793,
-0.0819943994,
-0.0377326459,
0.0025020719,
0.0317808799,
0.0022580789,
0.0359802283,
-0.0079392688,
0.0324212834,
0.0282127392,
-0.0006977587,
-0.0637227818,
-0.0418657549,
-0.0418079533,
-0.0038934143,
-0.0013089532,
-0.037314035,
0.0133134732,
0.0204840507,
-0.0136955846,
-0.0045573502,
-0.0041579972,
0.1223336756,
-0.0088601047,
-0.0297748018,
-0.0332319252,
-0.0158167426,
0.0099750366,
-0.0569319353,
0.0713108256,
-0.0577145591,
0.0245796703,
-0.0017329094,
-0.0160935689,
0.0039658011,
0.0208325256,
0.0144001814,
0.0150600923,
0.0379287265,
0.0025862195,
0.0285755023,
0.0218119733,
0.0081681879,
-0.0416403972,
0.0528477766,
0.0591654181,
0.0557795241,
-0.0317471214,
0.0449462198,
0.019185001,
0.0684359446,
-0.0446582176,
-0.0104300175,
-0.0072280141,
-0.008014584,
-0.0149019165,
0.072992079,
-0.0029778699,
0.0457357801,
-0.0329992101,
0.0003392528,
0.0337633453,
0.0695518926,
0.0371527895,
-0.0037864598,
0.0715329871,
0.0199614111,
0.0228661299,
-0.0221622046,
-0.0921984687,
0.0611582361,
-0.0604377314,
0.0118686855,
-0.0506190248,
0.0041614282,
0.0055301124,
-0.0450514033,
-0.0132759856,
0.0173809472,
0.0119197248,
-0.028170241,
0.0140152695,
-0.0015056552,
-0.0640438795,
0.0006180865,
-0.0177908726,
-0.011400993,
-0.0090072863,
-0.026005039,
0.0208676942,
0.057375852,
0.0214748159,
-0.0213757809,
-0.0378233902,
-0.0020612769,
0.0009859798,
0.0463922955,
0.0087976884,
0.009921534,
-0.0213986356,
-0.0087894145,
-0.0336224288,
-0.0212203413,
-0.009249243,
0.0430550463,
0.0339096636,
0.0234266948,
-0.0268560834,
-0.006238339,
0.0199089609,
0.0285865311,
-0.0020473583,
-0.0203011036,
-0.0522235855,
0.0106841736,
0.0189667493,
0.0214516688,
-0.0217395667,
0.000146348,
0.0276170895,
-0.0282692835,
-0.0132527323,
0.0153882494,
-0.0703442618,
-0.0603117943,
0.0352699235,
-0.0402012356,
-0.0071051912,
0.0102143325,
-0.020639725,
-0.0273171961,
0.0028342716,
-0.0287174862,
0.0230705161,
0.0079229381,
0.0047082198,
0.0379652083,
-0.0514610186,
-0.022280205,
0.0679497272,
-0.0263436884,
-0.0041031679,
0.0707057342,
0.0412156098,
0.0152038755,
-0.0225422885,
0.0172053352,
0.0085854735,
0.001709919,
-0.0198313389,
-0.0037773941,
0.0651279688,
-0.0393486582,
-0.0324888639,
-0.1055448651,
-0.0187325906,
-0.0403158888,
0.0067356345,
0.013418464,
-0.0674308389,
-0.0286261383,
-0.004115907,
-0.0360752903,
0.0429993421,
-0.007234565,
-0.0062708221,
0.0179458279,
-0.0166957229,
-0.0251456443,
-0.0233223792,
0.0230844673,
-0.0336898156,
-0.0117384521,
0.0022148634,
-0.0608012974,
-0.0432165787,
0.048838947,
-0.0275789648,
0.0267623328,
-0.0280744936,
-0.0305209775,
0.0540826395,
-0.0210042335,
0.033799056,
0.0142970765,
-0.019851828,
0.0109823961,
0.0683208182,
-0.027215207,
-0.0523645654,
0.0485450774,
-0.0089201406,
-0.0021003352,
-0.0485196672,
-0.003892161,
0.0139287431,
0.046228081,
0.0016686558,
0.0406664014,
-0.0443058424,
-0.0084505295,
0.0029598929,
-0.0535544232,
-0.0016513362,
0.0185707174,
-0.049507454,
0.0561883189,
-0.0181304011,
-0.0327899307,
0.0241058562,
-0.0454974174,
-0.0337743275,
-0.0141638964,
-0.0080489907,
-0.0243272632,
0.086481832,
0.000466714,
0.0121608051,
0.0018815711,
-0.0246109422,
-0.0424321629,
-0.0053448663,
-0.043028269,
0.0051179542,
0.0289945323,
-0.0940725133,
0.0192273147,
-0.0061894632,
-0.0276873112,
-0.03223655,
0.0336098149,
-0.040642865,
0.0208839215,
-0.0186728928,
-0.0417406186,
0.0068333861,
-0.0079502687,
0.0441417955,
0.0569426976,
-0.0157198291,
-0.0194069911,
-0.0449418426,
-0.0157631189,
0.0321713313,
0.0773152187,
-0.0033580002,
-0.0072422745,
0.0100188581,
0.0275323801,
-0.0028903717,
-0.0257661697,
-0.030282028,
0.0456029847,
0.0188222695,
-0.0063837967,
-0.024800159,
0.0705334023,
0.0563620068,
-0.0392360687,
-0.035607785,
0.103578262,
0.0373356007,
-0.0008941873,
0.0238343719,
-0.0547846556,
0.0282169357,
0.0470646098,
0.0144477393,
-0.0650662556,
-0.0175449699,
0.0135505078,
-0.0444572568,
0.0089357859,
-0.0473753735,
0.0013511094,
-0.1021752954,
0.0492010787,
0.0043678926,
-0.0755348653,
0.0101696448,
0.0221851151,
-0.0095101502,
0.0443878919,
-0.0024339503,
-0.0086848773,
0.0114239529,
0.0032613487,
-0.0061463076,
-0.0581312701,
0.0169470813,
0.003791674,
-0.0154237887,
0.0541780554,
0.0041106232,
0.01899058,
0.0067453384,
-0.0353863835,
0.0236323737,
0.0749295205,
0.0820065364,
-0.0577009432,
-0.0062751966,
0.0135819353,
-0.0108245322,
-0.0014741804,
-0.0052182875,
-0.0467544794,
-0.0516493171,
0.0292833615,
0.0853991583,
-0.0517333895,
0.0166500397,
-0.0422835983,
0.0437255837,
-0.0014741962,
0.0367108174,
0.0092354156,
-0.0117523568,
-0.0545350872,
-0.0585524924,
-0.0501582623,
-0.0132841682,
-0.0590692088,
0.0021308956,
0.0091678677,
0.0287870187,
-0.0815519169,
-0.0538206287,
0.0653030798,
0.0912134424,
0.005253423,
-0.0009194509,
-0.0190643165,
0.0062203328,
0.010527147,
-0.0006414675,
-0.0320752151,
0.0330749415,
-0.0097199921,
0.0118640587,
0.0099674799,
-0.0607580058,
0.0039878646,
0.0242143665,
-0.0309093706,
-0.0538322031,
-0.0104023255,
0.0781690553,
0.0235388353,
0.0014101022,
0.0154065061,
-0.006940797,
0.0309902132,
0.0213333741,
-0.0193403568,
0.0447853692,
0.010292301,
0.0852611437,
0.0346226208,
0.0171373617,
-0.0313384905,
-0.0096779875,
0.0081957243,
0.0720953122,
-0.0295737553,
0.0157602914,
0.0110897794,
-0.001233667,
0.0159589183,
-0.0222740658,
0.0007050043,
-0.0162357502,
0.0035151329,
-0.0448452905,
-0.0140345432,
-0.0578612611,
0.031480629,
-0.0035833863,
0.0150086032,
0.0300039668,
-0.0121500259,
0.009607275,
0.0130778626,
0.0366558395,
0.0016136782,
0.0183691997,
0.0072051464,
0.0207177754,
0.026245445,
-0.0158431958,
0.0175425,
-0.0182293244,
0.0253119711,
0.0185924638,
0.0659627765,
0.0131395534,
-0.0399822183,
-0.0565341599,
0.013012399,
-0.0284524597,
-0.1199936792,
0.0350518934,
0.0759740025,
0.0716838837,
0.0183358211,
0.0014958861,
-0.0884052441,
0.0345153026,
0.0221389793,
-0.0177638382,
0.0243372303,
-0.0391131565,
0.0543994866,
0.031029081,
-0.0033374063,
-0.0640320331,
0.0143409157,
-0.0176103357,
0.0452016369,
0.0217017084,
0.0196385086,
-0.0561887696,
-0.0280265007,
0.0219172165,
0.0300268419,
0.0085539725,
-0.0040910826,
-0.0637381971,
-0.0328009836,
0.0127812373,
0.060537003,
-0.022466369,
-0.0491281748,
0.0732267946,
-0.005401046,
0.0113297608,
-0.0436855629,
0.0037323916,
-0.0453283973,
0.0420547202,
-0.0434166975,
-0.041130539,
-5.189900864e-33,
-0.0366189703,
-0.0653426349,
0.0876807719,
-0.0335156769,
-0.0184580255,
-0.0382432006,
-0.0457292423,
0.0282835979,
-0.0044244081,
-0.0108574536,
-0.0275093485,
-0.0275970716,
0.0152334664,
-0.0127469134,
0.0185779296,
-0.0321288109,
0.0060999906,
-0.0125071965,
-0.0348235071,
-0.0311946031,
0.0029390985,
0.0255726688,
0.0450553112,
-0.051192902,
-0.0131877866,
0.0143632786,
-0.0124611752,
0.0232629944,
-0.0291844606,
0.0282024126,
-0.0237333272,
0.0043367627,
0.0191444661,
-0.0116735836,
-0.0152407968,
0.0209096503,
-0.0264419299,
-0.0705909282,
0.0355956256,
0.0175707471,
-0.0675543323,
-0.0270307455,
0.0128647033,
0.0058848863,
-0.0562000312,
0.0097402381,
0.0062714294,
0.0044392883,
-0.023699645,
0.0335497968,
-0.0589622743,
0.0009234355,
0.0030917202,
-0.0244303439,
0.0267252047,
0.0230116863,
-0.002148489,
-0.0132430261,
-0.0196223278,
0.0054034488,
0.0078052222,
-0.0116632301,
0.0655589476,
0.0095117483,
0.0119370129,
0.07123629,
0.0540459119,
-0.0015653267,
-0.0407835022,
0.0057822121,
0.0273732468,
0.0715402141,
0.0064935028,
0.0316070877,
0.0130638517,
0.0611355677,
-0.0303698089,
0.0130687375,
-0.0199225396,
0.0683974996,
-0.0059654592,
0.0213202201,
-0.0226601083,
0.0065604453,
-0.0289419889,
0.0303543117,
0.0043574763,
-0.0334590524,
0.0355893783,
0.0075003118,
0.0428564548,
-0.0595069192,
0.0316480473,
-0.0033980052,
-0.0201776158,
-0.0070276163,
-0.0093034785,
0.0498178378,
-0.0017987787,
0.0181774162,
-0.0559696779,
-0.0414140597,
0.004158739,
-0.0068179327,
0.0190836284,
0.0228876565,
-0.0222993381,
0.0671848357,
-0.0454314649,
-0.0014282967,
-0.0425458439,
-0.0029852157,
0.0240869112,
-0.020188706,
0.0460993759,
-0.0620938055,
-0.0280452762,
0.0280787889,
-0.0294753574,
-0.0966590047,
0.0032584365,
0.0024815239,
-0.0315385498,
0.0085336175,
-0.0222312231,
0.0118425759,
-0.0346489474,
0.0301008299,
0.0268003941,
-0.0575592108,
0.0161297228,
0.0467116684,
2.806e-7,
-0.012480244,
0.0402481258,
0.0172866192,
0.0397757292,
-0.0000246568,
0.0135017922,
-0.0183617659,
0.0128654325,
-0.0302459113,
-0.0383602567,
0.0339669697,
0.0581315607,
0.0153541323,
-0.0009784994,
-0.1096004769,
0.039047122,
-0.0125500159,
-0.0386052057,
-0.0636048019,
0.021403987,
0.0893976763,
0.0228272304,
-0.0116033703,
0.0040990068,
0.0060300152,
-0.0212507322,
0.0111054294,
-0.0655304939,
0.0245624967,
-0.0337046273,
0.0252186731,
-0.0150322961,
-0.0123725357,
-0.0271072369,
0.0229914766,
0.0170861743,
-0.0113960588,
0.0366642065,
-0.0037356627,
-0.0268921964,
0.0096434895,
-0.0470156893,
-0.0077577718,
-0.0312220119,
0.0525615029,
-0.0356958918,
0.036780607,
0.0148227485,
0.0339562073,
-0.0233535897,
-0.0336448774,
-0.0134705352,
0.0116672935,
-0.0093528191,
-0.0038794766,
0.0098670013,
0.0019698285,
-0.0504279919,
0.0022394839,
0.024129102,
-0.0310434792,
-0.0178530309,
-0.0723287389,
0.0462444201,
-0.0037719915,
-0.0357196108,
-0.069609791,
2.269308604e-34,
-0.0175801981,
-0.030190587,
0.0384146534,
0.0618099682,
0.0406250581,
0.0306238662,
-0.0047987988,
0.0331581943,
0.0169791151,
-0.0421181656,
-0.0410037562
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10270v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10270v3 | Boosting Local Spectro-Temporal Features for Speech Analysis | 2023-05-17T15:02:20 | 2023-08-04T22:58:39 | Michael Guerzhoy | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | We introduce the problem of phone classification in the context of speech
recognition, and explore several sets of local spectro-temporal features that
can be used for phone classification. In particular, we present some
preliminary results for phone classification using two sets of features that
are commonly used for object detection: Haar features and SVM-classified
Histograms of Gradients (HoG). | [
-0.024523871,
0.0124405082,
-0.0110538825,
0.0034608226,
-0.0055408804,
0.0003208252,
0.0805657208,
-0.02542134,
-0.0233407561,
-0.0163255427,
-0.0407813787,
-0.0310862083,
0.0616421849,
0.0438728817,
0.0056838072,
-0.0737063289,
-0.014077222,
-0.046692308,
0.0261914693,
-0.0148822442,
-0.0003571135,
-0.0108354725,
-0.039872136,
0.0370550603,
-0.0611917265,
0.0352196097,
-0.0187233668,
-0.0150835048,
0.0226695873,
-0.0133119458,
-0.0302522909,
0.0045691179,
0.0343778953,
0.0321758315,
0.0000012667,
-0.0280788597,
-0.0039989143,
0.0066005583,
-0.0473752245,
-0.0343788639,
-0.0198052265,
0.0423283614,
-0.0457462259,
0.0234668199,
-0.0195995122,
-0.0167532396,
0.0042730835,
-0.0163852163,
-0.012837748,
0.0513675697,
-0.0014854738,
-0.0161138382,
0.0048891576,
-0.0109508019,
0.0407424197,
0.0403299332,
-0.0244807582,
-0.0130944885,
0.0213028807,
-0.0081032766,
0.005354648,
0.0343112387,
-0.0277940203,
0.0074743335,
0.0780013129,
0.0177832749,
-0.0532299429,
0.0173047986,
0.0008793822,
0.0366282053,
-0.0207312368,
-0.0621037856,
0.0186421517,
0.0006179529,
-0.0638284311,
-0.0089990497,
0.0030203152,
-0.0409516171,
0.0263948943,
0.0103169009,
-0.0186576881,
0.03728652,
-0.0040635462,
-0.0144925918,
0.0764067769,
-0.0138348779,
-0.0075260266,
-0.0392785557,
-0.0141576631,
-0.0287817772,
0.0352525674,
0.0222526416,
0.034157224,
0.0405914001,
-0.0002456172,
-0.0225423872,
-0.0096910428,
-0.0329657272,
-0.0022044715,
-0.0377721563,
0.0188506488,
0.0197675005,
-0.1099257246,
0.0445981361,
-0.0086390274,
-0.0020647047,
0.0192360505,
-0.0762500837,
0.0004357574,
0.0101035703,
-0.0401575118,
0.0106193796,
-0.0362144895,
0.0001888068,
0.0104257027,
-0.0081071379,
-0.0498251393,
-0.0112742418,
0.0157261025,
0.0147890225,
-0.0078850472,
-0.0156842768,
-0.0020354996,
0.0273436215,
0.0409659706,
-0.0055482239,
0.0162421428,
0.0135979019,
-0.0881040245,
-0.0585794635,
-0.0064049778,
0.0234928392,
0.0352578536,
0.0273564681,
0.00455062,
0.0223035328,
-0.0105805127,
-0.0518357456,
0.0133851217,
0.0041358885,
-0.0149167683,
-0.0057518655,
-0.0028941904,
-0.0227728933,
0.0485609509,
-0.0105165951,
-0.0238779802,
0.0630398095,
-0.0085119894,
-0.0302038472,
0.0638062432,
0.0152367055,
0.0136751356,
0.0114852292,
0.1114884987,
-0.0319048204,
-0.0322416946,
0.0024926951,
0.0421500169,
-0.0192433707,
-0.0075522964,
-0.0704982206,
-0.0079723941,
0.0620613731,
-0.046351511,
-0.0253195986,
-0.066589877,
-0.0548348539,
-0.0252655968,
-0.0146822957,
-0.0109518291,
-0.013511952,
0.001772268,
-0.0104236808,
0.0198578071,
0.1008761302,
0.0142465048,
-0.0126071991,
0.0453833193,
0.018866308,
0.0252614729,
-0.0189985316,
0.0088472264,
-0.0150493328,
-0.058976166,
-0.0077418298,
-0.0340912677,
0.0176429655,
-0.0468679145,
0.0204426944,
0.0123819457,
-0.000545406,
-0.0595802777,
0.0332652926,
0.0953139812,
-0.0525857843,
0.0187250152,
0.0165522955,
0.0017617184,
0.0068186242,
-0.0044573159,
-0.0510876253,
0.0725206882,
0.0367851257,
0.0014989281,
-0.0670473799,
0.0254539475,
-0.0330750756,
-0.0445451029,
0.0085613905,
0.0052671405,
-0.0362654552,
0.0415031835,
-0.0207933672,
-0.0117407534,
0.0245695822,
0.0028871621,
0.0288174059,
-0.0294694249,
0.0167213809,
0.0280386433,
0.0131492475,
0.0340500809,
-0.0064713401,
0.0463125296,
0.0039549111,
0.0156765878,
0.030393973,
0.0239518527,
-0.0140534407,
0.0111386161,
-0.0041948315,
0.0014250266,
-0.0459173471,
0.0399869755,
0.0020036674,
-0.0052125836,
-0.0127241826,
0.0446323641,
0.0036973942,
0.0375035517,
-0.0008920449,
-0.017779367,
-0.0726417974,
0.0500064157,
-0.0160291418,
-0.0077308347,
-0.0419761986,
0.056352485,
0.0365873054,
0.0570980608,
0.0124663729,
0.0185406897,
0.0415623523,
-0.0146157937,
-0.0587301701,
0.0300729759,
0.0479313023,
-0.0875615031,
-0.0077624167,
0.0238322895,
-0.0354556851,
-0.0156970713,
-0.0086946897,
-0.0332964584,
-0.0169615131,
0.0354304835,
-0.0817841887,
-0.0075511881,
-0.0213881284,
-0.0020250129,
-0.0301255435,
-0.0144634247,
0.0101512307,
-0.0458837524,
0.008356005,
0.0249826349,
-0.0050790538,
-0.0388250686,
-0.0262549687,
-0.0065246383,
-0.0578250177,
0.005322021,
-0.0476828963,
0.0081254076,
0.0523012578,
-0.0509253815,
-0.0587194227,
-0.0017952722,
-0.0901400521,
0.0399452485,
0.0186658967,
-0.0062323483,
0.0085483016,
-0.015065074,
0.0242549218,
0.0091981441,
0.075026229,
0.0660580248,
0.000804465,
0.0197850484,
0.0424525812,
0.0014407146,
0.0119192135,
-0.0012169889,
0.0582164116,
0.0150437029,
0.0238010269,
-0.0184839517,
0.0108832726,
0.028358506,
0.0732930228,
0.0220996328,
-0.0434062667,
-0.0233588666,
-0.0652618259,
-0.0579266883,
-0.0274294484,
-0.038438268,
-0.0184830222,
0.0204531625,
-0.0033170858,
-0.0236307271,
-0.0399568528,
0.0201867651,
0.0066686668,
-0.1125816628,
-0.0474243537,
0.0118167158,
-0.0284188855,
-0.0114496592,
-0.0096012661,
-0.0262772907,
0.0364900641,
-0.0507152602,
0.0218457188,
-0.0346148349,
-0.002091757,
-0.0245774128,
0.0013832216,
-0.0222782269,
-0.0318701155,
-0.0347254388,
-0.0557278581,
-0.0196366217,
-0.0246835668,
-0.0509548485,
-0.0118243247,
-0.0178399812,
0.0569266975,
-0.0348355547,
0.0369993486,
-0.0029217957,
0.0121053904,
-0.000947569,
0.0930659324,
0.0213315804,
-0.0152055984,
-0.0351441279,
0.0135862688,
0.0246453322,
-0.0219817869,
0.0448924713,
0.0098575661,
-0.097997494,
0.013335974,
0.0085795717,
0.0038326071,
-0.1007610112,
-0.0142319268,
0.0368927047,
-0.0563912615,
0.0388887562,
0.0574232154,
-0.0175145697,
-0.0243509319,
-0.0165687241,
0.0126955081,
-0.0446205214,
-0.0277665816,
0.0125833508,
0.0032694577,
-0.0034086725,
0.023615079,
-0.034543369,
-0.0073428508,
0.0486894362,
-0.0211134311,
-0.0117362216,
0.0196245331,
0.0395220146,
-0.0316464044,
0.0231807902,
-0.0057785832,
-0.0113733914,
-0.0477949828,
0.0165095609,
-0.0542902052,
-0.0192054212,
-0.0321699418,
0.0587315671,
-0.0670891181,
-0.0133968694,
0.0448181219,
0.0473378412,
-0.0178108998,
0.0182715375,
-0.0022246998,
-0.014292514,
-0.0309595112,
0.0087594427,
-0.0100836204,
0.0412147976,
-0.0098309079,
0.0206219479,
-0.0063663078,
-0.0083772112,
0.0574312285,
0.0281091444,
0.0298507828,
-0.0132967783,
0.0063373316,
0.0665167272,
-0.043650195,
-0.020273773,
-0.026871603,
0.0019700695,
0.022617653,
0.0325915404,
-0.0095265862,
-0.0130786942,
-0.0416346379,
0.0572539233,
0.0093731238,
0.0098708281,
-0.0020955959,
-0.0034121708,
0.0421913378,
-0.1065663993,
0.0102917021,
0.0159063004,
-0.0118859326,
0.0320241526,
-0.0111847129,
0.0084691113,
-0.005397168,
0.0669201091,
-0.0353203677,
0.0608462431,
-0.0095491335,
0.0316747166,
-0.0557097979,
-0.0231352393,
0.0722106621,
-0.0436447039,
-0.0222397801,
-0.0689914227,
-0.0323128402,
-0.0191775858,
0.0071790661,
-0.045277942,
0.0186360255,
-0.0208620038,
-0.0556019805,
-0.0877313912,
0.0622122437,
-0.0016242977,
-0.046033781,
-0.0029309054,
0.035210561,
-0.0380843617,
-0.0575936958,
0.0070331483,
-0.0285889935,
0.0638571531,
-0.0095683178,
-0.0402784348,
-0.0379735604,
-0.0095221354,
-0.0104153249,
-0.0316324644,
0.1346344799,
-0.0204360057,
-0.0228028204,
0.0192230009,
-0.0058474923,
0.0681826249,
0.0647041723,
0.0151050296,
0.0143952388,
-0.011060426,
0.0440606922,
-0.0235536005,
0.0250498615,
0.0108394669,
-0.0319167562,
0.0192359537,
0.0575918891,
0.0284674615,
-0.0231919512,
-0.0359356254,
0.0212035775,
-0.0252967551,
0.0522610918,
0.038896922,
-0.0205445886,
0.0198564716,
0.0343295746,
-0.0070429519,
0.0232811477,
-0.013430004,
0.0401990078,
-0.0205011349,
-0.0124963047,
0.0073523363,
0.000844227,
0.0431257114,
-0.0247835945,
-0.033327613,
0.0053321263,
-0.0248964056,
-0.0295203589,
0.0522090122,
-0.0134055614,
0.0157242529,
0.0341504775,
0.0075514168,
-0.0312651098,
0.0602838062,
0.023115553,
0.0270984154,
-0.0225190111,
0.0448249057,
0.0251921769,
-0.041653201,
-0.0053214175,
-0.0193174779,
-0.0002444464,
-0.0065832986,
0.0112191224,
-0.0265658163,
-0.0534974933,
-0.0051899725,
-0.047187224,
0.0265255067,
0.0365644433,
0.0276196301,
0.0140993726,
0.0079702334,
0.0194344968,
0.0389462374,
-0.0154624283,
0.039002914,
0.0128823435,
-0.0276974142,
-4.611685845e-33,
0.0029897795,
-0.0242776871,
-0.0132455267,
0.0671149939,
0.015034195,
-0.0034079233,
0.0206957385,
0.0059562782,
0.0337708443,
-0.0168625545,
-0.0481363684,
0.0125212148,
0.0387683026,
-0.00555848,
0.0320135467,
-0.0217717942,
0.0977986231,
-0.0070549892,
0.0037931784,
-0.0213230364,
0.0710631162,
0.0338563584,
0.0687683821,
-0.045812577,
-0.0968702435,
0.0366040319,
-0.0041841627,
0.0007181009,
0.0223968402,
-0.0030208365,
-0.0428704992,
0.0432616025,
0.0021128661,
-0.0042901831,
0.0130393561,
0.0437896773,
-0.0713932812,
-0.0043851929,
-0.0409735218,
0.0868896171,
-0.0116321845,
0.0032060153,
-0.0276883636,
0.0100233359,
-0.0772370622,
-0.0321094841,
0.0327952765,
-0.0279513858,
-0.0517937317,
-0.0382529646,
0.0256881863,
0.0490369461,
-0.0081730746,
0.0080853375,
0.0730432495,
0.0047067907,
-0.0169982091,
-0.0258437935,
-0.0259032529,
0.0596216023,
-0.0300689582,
0.0025203885,
-0.0050433595,
0.0413999893,
0.0204152968,
0.0358379073,
0.09327849,
-0.0767840669,
0.0335095599,
-0.0330516659,
0.0143510932,
0.0138872992,
0.0116494568,
-0.0482785553,
0.0850829408,
-0.0500494093,
-0.033136677,
-0.0044458983,
0.0820724592,
0.0050688488,
-0.0119384602,
0.0065126815,
-0.0341260917,
0.0232957099,
-0.0006958834,
0.0099201845,
0.0075291437,
-0.0244517624,
-0.0205274094,
0.0297857858,
0.0304492135,
0.0573625155,
0.0057547111,
0.0322804824,
0.0153768687,
0.0328919813,
-0.0060241777,
0.0044724024,
0.0551510714,
-0.0055161961,
-0.005187606,
-0.0475032814,
0.0263646282,
-0.0024064861,
0.0412168317,
-0.028783489,
0.0090342574,
0.0737374201,
-0.0349460617,
-0.0057289549,
0.0442630872,
0.0092391511,
-0.0097749894,
0.0024886935,
0.0614731088,
0.004403153,
-0.0063422136,
0.1106871963,
-0.0816829875,
0.0722127184,
0.0292289481,
0.0108865937,
0.0109741669,
0.0409832485,
-0.0173460096,
0.026681548,
-0.0234641843,
-0.0068340586,
0.0305773914,
0.0042437525,
0.0203533601,
-0.0210983902,
2.157e-7,
-0.0691650212,
-0.0214021709,
-0.0137622822,
-0.0183591247,
0.0301363058,
0.0376276374,
-0.0373905487,
-0.0094283242,
-0.0178489983,
-0.0233100709,
-0.0035211297,
-0.0363260992,
0.0648055896,
0.0154186226,
-0.0407942496,
-0.0531260855,
-0.0079451455,
0.0259172972,
-0.0421698317,
0.0556393266,
-0.0068195346,
0.07815139,
0.0290910807,
-0.0482381545,
-0.0154201873,
0.0374906175,
0.0435621664,
0.0145205436,
-0.0415467992,
-0.0150448242,
0.0575955734,
-0.0088118911,
0.009771199,
0.0521814786,
-0.037216384,
0.0289197098,
-0.0136640463,
-0.0010567196,
0.0073313736,
-0.0789566934,
-0.0371502973,
0.0696172267,
-0.0253556203,
0.0438961573,
0.0353809334,
0.0557367727,
-0.0585575104,
-0.0342831612,
-0.0299922954,
0.0340768062,
-0.0157222822,
-0.0058998172,
0.0070289774,
0.00216304,
-0.0040622535,
-0.0558130741,
-0.0047583352,
-0.0907548144,
0.0036054251,
0.0725321397,
-0.0091144061,
0.00196216,
0.0138133457,
0.04200086,
0.0482156761,
0.0578601062,
0.0064851712,
1.109648415e-34,
0.0139403958,
0.0214390382,
-0.0048702587,
-0.0062471279,
-0.0619131848,
-0.036632143,
0.0097616678,
-0.0050467853,
0.0378317237,
-0.0022169577,
0.006234352
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10266v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10266v1 | Searching for Needles in a Haystack: On the Role of Incidental Bilingualism in PaLM's Translation Capability | 2023-05-17T14:58:06 | 2023-05-17T14:58:06 | Eleftheria Briakou, Colin Cherry, George Foster | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large, multilingual language models exhibit surprisingly good zero- or
few-shot machine translation capabilities, despite having never seen the
intentionally-included translation examples provided to typical neural
translation systems. We investigate the role of incidental bilingualism -- the
unintentional consumption of bilingual signals, including translation examples
-- in explaining the translation capabilities of large language models, taking
the Pathways Language Model (PaLM) as a case study. We introduce a mixed-method
approach to measure and understand incidental bilingualism at scale. We show
that PaLM is exposed to over 30 million translation pairs across at least 44
languages. Furthermore, the amount of incidental bilingual content is highly
correlated with the amount of monolingual in-language content for non-English
languages. We relate incidental bilingual content to zero-shot prompts and show
that it can be used to mine new prompts to improve PaLM's out-of-English
zero-shot translation quality. Finally, in a series of small-scale ablations,
we show that its presence has a substantial impact on translation capabilities,
although this impact diminishes with model scale. | [
0.0024722151,
0.0138668148,
-0.0238007046,
0.0753997937,
-0.0335123241,
0.032332316,
0.0713580474,
0.0150140086,
-0.0329356156,
0.010607182,
-0.0629219636,
-0.038148202,
0.0292421766,
0.0017209389,
0.0167027283,
-0.0029767992,
0.0481297337,
-0.0327862278,
-0.0495375805,
0.0060393284,
-0.0268624183,
0.028500136,
0.0373761766,
0.0528987311,
0.0034618315,
-0.0191919692,
0.0059909793,
0.0393966958,
0.0246765465,
-0.015435609,
-0.0490392037,
0.027813429,
-0.0235978663,
0.1125524491,
0.0000022172,
-0.0240358822,
-0.0016332706,
0.0274785515,
-0.0166531038,
0.0265129339,
0.0708430111,
-0.0489433706,
-0.0188617408,
-0.001327985,
-0.0109845717,
-0.0191088282,
0.0629405007,
-0.0007488076,
-0.0082087638,
0.0267864112,
-0.0132743847,
0.0161717311,
-0.0262248833,
-0.0511721633,
-0.0230928212,
-0.0102050276,
0.0010970418,
-0.0605227947,
-0.0163165424,
0.0306340065,
-0.0261138976,
0.0759714991,
0.0641618595,
-0.0124440799,
-0.0366816558,
0.0157884043,
-0.0344863422,
-0.033678513,
0.0292232204,
0.0614124686,
-0.0478296988,
-0.0112170381,
0.0028234837,
-0.0231710449,
-0.0069224774,
-0.0263120569,
-0.0425746776,
0.0001302028,
0.0103818048,
0.0005994744,
0.0426790677,
0.0213004835,
0.055078771,
-0.0268772468,
-0.0460474864,
-0.0115334289,
0.0357043445,
-0.0103857126,
0.0013601651,
0.0407869853,
0.0694176108,
-0.0604151599,
0.0361614414,
-0.0048421416,
-0.0130027272,
0.0176724978,
-0.0182731077,
-0.0078401538,
0.0235396381,
-0.0896224901,
0.0277392939,
0.0560733378,
-0.0550630018,
0.0459531881,
-0.0299625844,
-0.0025301659,
-0.0579163395,
0.0486451089,
-0.0826089755,
-0.0060977433,
0.0164427254,
0.0233558472,
-0.0022592521,
-0.0245774817,
-0.0485300347,
-0.0263726413,
-0.0033423405,
0.0131333917,
0.025544649,
-0.0165492166,
0.0098837651,
-0.0207303185,
-0.0485913791,
0.0023906208,
0.0210805237,
0.0996699259,
-0.0174616873,
-0.0297111832,
0.0108515387,
-0.0649681985,
-0.0398590714,
0.0156938564,
-0.0410946682,
-0.0633216053,
-0.0111683859,
0.1058714688,
-0.0072154701,
-0.034354385,
-0.009011996,
-0.0123386364,
-0.0268573128,
-0.0522486717,
0.0101672979,
-0.0618038476,
0.0481494702,
0.0252337735,
0.0329705067,
0.0086849062,
0.0049792756,
-0.0008961998,
-0.0381190553,
0.0324687585,
0.0032042973,
-0.0110384971,
0.0300422851,
-0.0036947618,
0.0261594635,
0.0872291848,
0.0078987693,
0.000329768,
0.03221168,
-0.0177971758,
-0.01698751,
0.0636960268,
0.0079860454,
0.0403790809,
-0.0214097165,
-0.0225791503,
0.0321496539,
0.0210101623,
0.0724326596,
0.0256507508,
-0.0447983444,
-0.0168034546,
0.0293743815,
0.0619769245,
-0.0494981408,
0.0407013334,
0.0899025351,
-0.0333307721,
-0.0193882268,
0.0391948409,
-0.0308123399,
0.0228949673,
-0.0141629595,
-0.0090214619,
0.0066001187,
0.032142695,
-0.0336845405,
-0.0307901502,
0.0089921867,
0.0067556254,
0.0362907872,
-0.0082446039,
0.0426154919,
0.0020858268,
-0.0169959366,
0.0318495929,
0.0053421049,
-0.0154978372,
0.0367317349,
-0.0250488203,
-0.0720548928,
0.0633523911,
0.0388258845,
0.0183443706,
-0.0063168094,
-0.0165282115,
-0.0049134702,
0.0795983151,
0.0482838526,
0.0118860546,
0.0473664366,
-0.0352511294,
-0.008582403,
-0.0069969869,
0.02252011,
0.0234595109,
-0.0349108614,
0.046566762,
0.0153611414,
-0.0171769988,
-0.0726793334,
0.0178718604,
-0.0698853955,
-0.0195427481,
0.0443296917,
0.0063268328,
-0.0135853812,
0.0070042321,
-0.0230433457,
-0.0042775343,
0.0271299556,
-0.0363564268,
-0.0102416305,
0.0482466668,
-0.0417708196,
-0.0233090818,
0.018198641,
-0.0083469264,
-0.0190467183,
-0.0415604785,
-0.0210635215,
-0.0375686884,
0.026978191,
-0.0147780385,
0.0227907337,
-0.0086658131,
0.0441446602,
-0.0193472542,
0.0047778571,
-0.024766298,
0.025768647,
-0.0019891537,
0.0073202676,
0.0003270325,
-0.0548662022,
0.0599507391,
-0.0597442016,
-0.0239667185,
0.0446799099,
-0.0062548527,
0.0097560631,
0.034938287,
0.0230405554,
-0.0105994763,
-0.0067130942,
-0.0768125504,
-0.0042946083,
-0.0089570787,
0.0242644679,
0.064490065,
0.0249040704,
0.0140172299,
0.0037754746,
0.007992628,
0.0008769053,
0.0032336074,
0.0357895866,
-0.0144396881,
0.0091624884,
0.0019112093,
-0.0245753936,
-0.0291516799,
0.0108178621,
0.0630479679,
0.0032038249,
-0.0365677178,
-0.0437971205,
0.023306625,
0.0002130443,
-0.0145860156,
0.0184902456,
-0.0668735802,
0.0255830623,
-0.0173264388,
0.0159526281,
0.060815528,
-0.0652512759,
0.0073432387,
0.052636452,
-0.0263841376,
-0.0522241257,
-0.0132465847,
-0.0212146901,
-0.0142814862,
-0.0540811457,
-0.0228870679,
-0.0134296082,
0.065565899,
0.0341829658,
-0.0143582085,
-0.0562317185,
-0.0594260879,
-0.0524707548,
-0.0480741262,
-0.0510890596,
0.0093119033,
-0.0041379496,
0.0547958054,
-0.0252929963,
-0.0340574607,
0.0577051342,
-0.0286388081,
-0.0017593501,
-0.0427253135,
0.0015373343,
-0.0042232955,
0.0275178533,
-0.0050516818,
0.0429686457,
-0.0067967549,
-0.0241929013,
-0.0340106636,
0.0081081288,
-0.0100723691,
0.0035038125,
0.0204217527,
-0.0711032078,
-0.0203355532,
-0.0067051258,
-0.0264591202,
-0.0316209942,
0.0020991163,
-0.0105976937,
-0.0034387421,
-0.0002099544,
-0.0209984798,
-0.0275118966,
-0.0368752852,
0.060447108,
0.0816587359,
-0.0088175042,
-0.0091245268,
-0.0156776886,
0.0088940971,
0.0102058137,
-0.0475089736,
0.0647138432,
-0.0738751516,
0.0456769466,
0.0259630308,
-0.0151055371,
0.0026756874,
-0.0123721082,
-0.0249873251,
0.0287005901,
0.0184211861,
-0.0821786746,
0.0034392111,
0.0585677288,
-0.0589857958,
-0.0350470394,
0.0787668154,
0.0173874646,
-0.0822857097,
0.0060484675,
-0.0240011718,
-0.0104036154,
0.0409923829,
0.0252489746,
-0.0913178325,
0.0012671055,
0.0157339089,
0.0025103013,
0.0228593852,
0.0307294391,
-0.0093563078,
-0.1094184592,
0.0101522589,
0.0290571582,
-0.0674094558,
0.0112748174,
0.0066142525,
-0.0285946745,
-0.0248968899,
0.0457839817,
-0.0241299067,
0.0333891958,
-0.0125342356,
-0.0087300269,
0.073860541,
-0.0717148855,
-0.0081864493,
-0.0298491437,
0.0256052054,
0.0293386839,
0.0256886762,
-0.0185674001,
-0.0146378325,
0.0795652047,
-0.0364046954,
0.0074808258,
-0.0042610406,
0.0308812838,
0.0515791848,
-0.0167998299,
0.0020193846,
0.001360036,
-0.036070928,
0.0014686182,
0.0016157747,
0.0625328943,
-0.0115699479,
-0.0004528571,
0.0151816849,
-0.0238476191,
-0.0167411733,
0.0332768895,
0.0523464307,
-0.0427045152,
-0.0033204195,
-0.0213133916,
-0.0202906951,
-0.0370738581,
-0.0363302007,
0.0023397959,
-0.0292661134,
-0.0554744825,
-0.0595850497,
-0.0537865907,
-0.0113657489,
0.0355958529,
0.0336425826,
0.0289246012,
-0.0086356746,
-0.0465039127,
0.0414903164,
0.0424870886,
-0.0371577442,
0.0382596888,
-0.0766622201,
0.0312491804,
-0.0388382636,
-0.0229742657,
0.0027469497,
0.0494284891,
-0.0683223009,
-0.0633829236,
-0.013659358,
0.0497768335,
0.027444819,
0.0033301024,
-0.0664873868,
-0.0464751795,
-0.0064970297,
0.024551563,
-0.0093132788,
0.0221306942,
0.0192196593,
0.0017109332,
-0.0172839779,
0.0511646755,
0.0008002779,
-0.0090214061,
0.0257405359,
0.0388647467,
-0.0481587313,
-0.0574108399,
0.0021694666,
-0.0121263694,
0.0403043628,
-0.0402115993,
0.0240431689,
-0.0195056666,
-0.0088794688,
-0.0343109109,
0.0090476712,
-0.0144916913,
-0.0313678086,
0.0511410907,
-0.006199189,
0.020260293,
-0.0179770105,
-0.0195755903,
0.001224242,
0.0088087209,
-0.0397679135,
0.002439308,
0.0123838196,
0.0080769761,
0.0524891354,
-0.0058270735,
0.0488791764,
-0.0229351353,
0.033578109,
-0.046742063,
0.0468381606,
0.0142363682,
0.0189462565,
-0.0012052723,
0.0401902609,
-0.0368551202,
-0.035579171,
0.0227920357,
0.0102053992,
0.1000121832,
-0.0110188127,
0.1082755923,
0.025864305,
-0.0302682817,
-0.025931133,
0.0425109155,
0.0342818201,
-0.0281008799,
-0.0314182043,
-0.0133767929,
0.000211346,
-0.0089297974,
0.0623836145,
-0.0286081377,
0.026237106,
-0.0116704525,
0.0035690537,
0.0059883622,
-0.0025151824,
0.0144820232,
0.0142024634,
-0.0416916013,
-0.0043964293,
-0.0822464526,
-0.0787655562,
-0.0485557914,
0.0151660396,
0.0197412055,
-0.0298110414,
-0.0003584536,
0.0447962321,
-0.0317413546,
0.0045292722,
-0.0206208136,
0.0284209084,
0.0265282951,
-0.0287685022,
-0.0296375137,
-6.383497093e-33,
-0.0056503871,
-0.0051750266,
0.0077906968,
-0.0168568119,
-0.0009518624,
0.029069772,
-0.0740823075,
-0.0022394315,
-0.0201867986,
0.0162368529,
0.001340362,
0.0014714543,
0.0147568909,
-0.0208758619,
0.034617018,
-0.0048668911,
0.0606229678,
0.0015292396,
-0.0206130706,
0.0433644354,
0.0794809759,
0.0044518113,
0.0907217041,
-0.0610105209,
0.0317825228,
-0.0023420148,
-0.0214043427,
0.0182496384,
-0.0174263846,
0.0477257073,
-0.0254247691,
0.029232325,
0.0102690151,
-0.0386017896,
-0.0272758901,
-0.0493204519,
-0.0783352405,
-0.0106393527,
0.0356755517,
0.0340139344,
-0.0203536153,
-0.0793089494,
0.0198083185,
-0.0290361643,
-0.036446657,
-0.0100489734,
0.010206284,
-0.0350090861,
-0.032236591,
0.0065899813,
-0.083880417,
-0.0061945431,
0.0102976542,
-0.0015320267,
0.0108096441,
0.0458728187,
-0.0392056592,
-0.0233448595,
-0.086466752,
-0.0102283275,
-0.0067631449,
0.041509144,
0.0788445324,
0.015783852,
-0.0042764996,
0.0327021629,
0.017896723,
0.0174832102,
0.0587010346,
0.0065144375,
0.0609078407,
-0.0249089543,
0.0485815257,
0.0624817424,
0.0526916459,
-0.0147076314,
-0.0450050049,
0.0256779008,
-0.000569037,
-0.0047195354,
0.0357405171,
0.0000666821,
0.0007720717,
-0.0218550041,
-0.0551860332,
-0.0727623478,
-0.0328270681,
-0.0464620218,
0.0105378134,
0.0147683769,
-0.002426014,
-0.0324979909,
0.1040033028,
-0.027123211,
0.0039720456,
0.0490436964,
-0.0170790292,
0.0094158258,
0.0228069648,
0.0265244152,
-0.0483258702,
-0.0218359083,
0.0106680002,
0.0213292763,
0.0270245187,
-0.0194311459,
0.0470095314,
0.0094700158,
-0.0180197265,
0.0261859149,
-0.0456275307,
-0.0019269725,
0.010699098,
0.0325696655,
0.0345596373,
-0.004868594,
-0.0181162078,
0.062261425,
0.0268233139,
0.0166495219,
-0.0229213368,
0.0318192616,
0.0020718584,
0.0535638519,
-0.0539314412,
0.0142877288,
-0.0458076485,
0.0429790765,
0.0651070327,
-0.0594929792,
-0.0496347286,
0.0011517652,
2.885e-7,
0.0479946099,
0.026884485,
-0.0068284324,
0.0084065478,
0.0527116247,
0.0362058915,
-0.0302687697,
0.0159483608,
0.0043490306,
0.0126775475,
-0.0224488676,
0.020848386,
0.0838629529,
0.0299759917,
-0.043977946,
-0.0078924783,
-0.0304250177,
0.0312731117,
-0.0606252812,
-0.0076401718,
0.0087053068,
0.0894668102,
0.0095905624,
-0.0116647324,
0.0325954854,
0.0033169773,
0.0496779233,
-0.0040720063,
-0.0136307888,
-0.0391078182,
-0.0304509643,
0.0210950952,
-0.0169978812,
-0.0127449054,
-0.0224807113,
-0.0012279209,
0.0163099598,
0.0667440519,
-0.0043969229,
0.007703077,
0.036963705,
-0.0394520201,
-0.013935551,
-0.0937871635,
0.0570029654,
-0.0302756298,
0.0054950039,
0.0070554684,
0.0144255776,
0.012055832,
0.0602214746,
-0.046634201,
-0.056917049,
0.0252890047,
0.0451374687,
0.007098618,
-0.009453916,
-0.0265932493,
-0.0287053511,
0.0056654057,
-0.0174318589,
-0.0357546471,
-0.0356386937,
0.0224158447,
-0.0081689572,
-0.0235772878,
-0.0018107959,
2.838871433e-34,
0.0363301151,
-0.0099218218,
0.0338761657,
-0.0371575952,
0.0216964204,
-0.0254139099,
-0.0172421876,
0.0030673794,
0.0011405786,
-0.0601238906,
-0.0156450886
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10263v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10263v2 | M3KE: A Massive Multi-Level Multi-Subject Knowledge Evaluation Benchmark for Chinese Large Language Models | 2023-05-17T14:56:31 | 2023-05-21T03:57:11 | Chuang Liu, Renren Jin, Yuqi Ren, Linhao Yu, Tianyu Dong, Xiaohan Peng, Shuting Zhang, Jianxiang Peng, Peiyi Zhang, Qingqing Lyu, Xiaowen Su, Qun Liu, Deyi Xiong | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models have recently made tremendous progress in a variety of
aspects, e.g., cross-task generalization, instruction following.
Comprehensively evaluating the capability of large language models in multiple
tasks is of great importance. In this paper, we propose M3KE, a Massive
Multi-Level Multi-Subject Knowledge Evaluation benchmark, which is developed to
measure knowledge acquired by Chinese large language models by testing their
multitask accuracy in zero- and few-shot settings. We have collected 20,477
questions from 71 tasks. Our selection covers all major levels of Chinese
education system, ranging from the primary school to college, as well as a wide
variety of subjects, including humanities, history, politics, law, education,
psychology, science, technology, art and religion. All questions are
multiple-choice questions with four options, hence guaranteeing a standardized
and unified assessment process. We've assessed a number of state-of-the-art
open-source Chinese large language models on the proposed benchmark. The size
of these models varies from 335M to 130B parameters. Experiment results
demonstrate that they perform significantly worse than GPT-3.5 that reaches an
accuracy of ~ 48% on M3KE. The dataset is available at
https://github.com/tjunlp-lab/M3KE. | [
0.0068725822,
0.0245799962,
-0.0058457968,
0.0351648778,
-0.0234365873,
0.0308551639,
0.0376073495,
-0.0173546989,
0.0209751781,
-0.0555938967,
-0.030293934,
-0.0620386302,
-0.0273211561,
-0.0103012817,
0.0090150042,
-0.0440280363,
0.0308470502,
-0.0056609772,
-0.0216810256,
-0.0137571702,
-0.0140298083,
-0.0081538372,
-0.0117056351,
0.0259863101,
0.0496822819,
-0.068968676,
-0.0076922458,
-0.0070260554,
0.0230635777,
-0.0228232872,
0.0292579141,
0.0511941724,
-0.0038212955,
0.0373071171,
0.0000021934,
-0.0514894351,
-0.0271004271,
-0.0175533034,
-0.0049119834,
0.0392215475,
0.045785062,
0.0236819498,
-0.0054982617,
0.005341405,
-0.0223477688,
-0.0385232568,
0.0224368181,
0.0476108864,
0.0440249965,
0.0458525047,
0.0118051721,
-0.011252786,
0.0365201682,
-0.019902382,
-0.0000999542,
-0.052335944,
0.0496337898,
0.0498795062,
-0.0199940037,
0.02668483,
-0.0567476973,
0.0083484119,
0.0252916832,
0.0088581489,
-0.0376237668,
0.024019435,
-0.0290038828,
0.0118654836,
0.016509302,
0.0834965259,
-0.0039823581,
0.0035819935,
-0.0101537257,
0.0128278211,
-0.0073153786,
0.0486939438,
-0.07073351,
0.0199057125,
0.0013353401,
-0.0251698662,
0.0078288941,
-0.0422400944,
0.0103607932,
0.0337431692,
-0.0070411069,
0.0438953154,
0.0358681642,
-0.0462252647,
0.021613,
0.0103218118,
-0.0340470262,
-0.0329066738,
-0.0233457908,
0.0104891537,
-0.0329119675,
0.0224267021,
0.0235176571,
-0.0267834384,
-0.0020271193,
-0.0401051268,
0.0246514361,
0.0339724086,
-0.0231782552,
0.0653383136,
0.0004326906,
0.0721789151,
0.0026477915,
0.0033814418,
-0.0547593236,
-0.0185619313,
-0.065411754,
0.0028397266,
-0.004495421,
0.0466423817,
0.000390376,
-0.0127304737,
-0.0489795357,
-0.0068646469,
-0.03057478,
0.0138352718,
0.006412948,
-0.0247533452,
-0.03878567,
-0.0167017765,
-0.0162005257,
0.0830807462,
-0.0287246779,
0.0094321044,
-0.0184030551,
0.0308518391,
0.0037188374,
0.0115656937,
-0.0026312887,
-0.0391759872,
0.0145356469,
0.0350135602,
-0.0187042337,
0.0013691289,
-0.0240342971,
-0.010073524,
-0.0326666683,
-0.0752445534,
0.0245052632,
-0.058240559,
0.0043496806,
0.0004348642,
0.0376671776,
0.0112096714,
0.0057340027,
0.0181002207,
0.0004282399,
0.0069217305,
0.0410049148,
-0.0088235913,
-0.004240769,
0.0355203785,
0.0031970306,
0.07875067,
0.0101914452,
0.0140219927,
0.056720946,
-0.0289866012,
-0.0337496698,
0.0388933159,
-0.0028416363,
0.0201116167,
0.0043061026,
0.0233050995,
0.0442888252,
0.0134198777,
-0.0175357983,
0.0182002354,
-0.011253248,
0.0131139522,
0.0525194108,
0.0339056142,
-0.0065948921,
0.0015896461,
0.0431948602,
0.0312929861,
0.032368429,
0.0255353693,
-0.040080566,
0.0071945591,
-0.0341158472,
0.0099184597,
0.004182219,
0.0260247383,
-0.0283729564,
-0.0504266396,
-0.0033401847,
0.0086809052,
-0.0117471963,
0.0395748056,
0.0864868015,
-0.0307177473,
-0.0043312917,
0.0201180577,
0.0305311717,
-0.0373832136,
0.0194303486,
-0.0267763119,
0.0348476768,
0.0494102985,
0.0457284562,
-0.0507239141,
-0.059075769,
0.0090264184,
0.0453395694,
0.046211239,
0.0660289079,
-0.0384397209,
-0.0157769695,
-0.0472969711,
-0.0191556681,
-0.0089714611,
0.0344301388,
-0.0057085706,
0.0230552498,
0.0069922251,
0.0068786815,
-0.0481798835,
-0.0195551161,
0.0089969598,
-0.0688134804,
-0.0409511477,
-0.0250880104,
0.0012811632,
0.0151068112,
0.012711145,
-0.0197843201,
-0.0136597138,
0.0149839912,
-0.0194851737,
-0.0272705778,
-0.0240757056,
-0.0376731679,
-0.0347563103,
0.069648385,
-0.0252986215,
-0.0542126223,
0.0734928772,
-0.0626693293,
-0.0504905507,
0.0291627571,
0.0365158319,
0.0105031226,
-0.0388289355,
0.0386329219,
-0.0632866919,
-0.0108908936,
-0.0352482572,
0.0786636323,
0.0160307679,
0.0624611191,
0.0069153719,
-0.0030242784,
0.0374858603,
-0.0002103663,
-0.0811905414,
-0.0125743821,
0.001344629,
0.0458848625,
0.0216237362,
0.0219279993,
-0.0672376603,
-0.0428277999,
-0.1035535038,
0.048723232,
-0.030392779,
0.0048392825,
0.0255057625,
-0.017205745,
0.0083319908,
0.024940256,
-0.0353761017,
0.0175279286,
-0.043551296,
0.00380256,
-0.0265388377,
-0.0228526983,
0.0170476399,
-0.010662552,
-0.0145552093,
-0.0482512526,
0.0225247908,
-0.0036161214,
0.0539218634,
-0.0006802652,
0.0250052493,
-0.030297095,
-0.017147731,
-0.0098338891,
-0.0352961794,
0.0007576128,
-0.0196097363,
0.0686436221,
0.0781746209,
0.002003639,
0.0111886254,
0.0423346497,
-0.0145961251,
-0.0364219733,
0.0296344906,
0.0046466514,
-0.0354169942,
-0.051074218,
-0.0058638626,
-0.0539019778,
0.0807679221,
0.0160198491,
-0.0486246683,
-0.0301260222,
-0.0029505403,
-0.0804865509,
0.0006396814,
-0.0640428886,
0.0575345792,
-0.0262726042,
-0.0266172793,
-0.0331815518,
0.011001545,
0.0552676246,
0.0093730334,
-0.0069939122,
-0.0491526388,
0.0312458724,
-0.0242667459,
0.0846229792,
-0.0037807464,
0.0045414171,
-0.0111774234,
0.0086758528,
-0.0852314755,
0.0514225997,
0.0137672005,
-0.0488135293,
0.0543188713,
-0.0433485582,
-0.0192908458,
-0.0228036121,
-0.0190279763,
-0.0006824051,
-0.0083011454,
0.0029866933,
0.0280585177,
-0.012380518,
-0.0143487416,
0.0023886347,
-0.0015156587,
0.0288487896,
-0.0087574944,
-0.0302587356,
0.0110972933,
-0.0211346671,
0.0465394668,
0.0579554886,
0.0213007256,
-0.0239206329,
-0.0511902533,
0.0682359263,
0.0568534359,
0.0577073209,
0.0203223862,
0.0126963854,
0.0056236754,
0.0228038002,
-0.0317893252,
-0.0087650325,
0.0130315945,
0.0586562827,
-0.0824929103,
0.0069361944,
0.1419354081,
0.0130549753,
-0.0092515238,
-0.0103935981,
-0.0126261553,
-0.0148266824,
0.03095497,
0.0007399896,
-0.0760419294,
-0.0172703285,
-0.0133868176,
-0.0067662653,
0.0271601975,
-0.0444585644,
0.0347650051,
-0.1467176676,
0.0146590713,
-0.0013991985,
-0.0339297988,
0.0090514598,
-0.0213911086,
0.010492635,
-0.014931404,
0.0333843268,
-0.0057513672,
-0.0009151319,
-0.0181826614,
0.0279004872,
-0.0018359827,
-0.0647788569,
0.1030008197,
-0.0281079859,
0.061324127,
0.0098241717,
0.0562603027,
-0.0529106334,
-0.0001757282,
0.0181939602,
-0.0066923168,
-0.0589659326,
0.0374266505,
0.0343542583,
0.0026874533,
-0.0082899667,
-0.0115527073,
0.0164437182,
-0.0186303537,
0.0208091103,
0.0747392848,
0.0920351073,
0.0059589329,
-0.0463304557,
0.0088787898,
-0.0166307632,
-0.0338189378,
0.1085976288,
0.0152680818,
-0.0740262046,
0.0076243654,
-0.0334299989,
-0.0479600541,
-0.0580940209,
-0.026642317,
0.0651094019,
-0.0297451615,
0.0052618068,
-0.0491860956,
-0.0250613727,
0.0538005382,
0.0028141919,
0.01435473,
0.0093755359,
0.0557020679,
0.0085882582,
-0.0449632481,
0.0142704044,
-0.0291648693,
0.0047781644,
-0.0521021001,
-0.0384210236,
0.030589195,
-0.0016615496,
-0.0179789532,
0.0211460497,
-0.087887764,
-0.0353729464,
-0.0076792473,
0.0131969871,
-0.0010000119,
0.0070659816,
-0.0189861096,
-0.0035622111,
0.0182797313,
-0.0572235808,
-0.0187781993,
0.016362533,
0.0122731887,
-0.019184703,
-0.010444616,
0.0092118438,
-0.0372572802,
0.029022228,
0.0511480235,
0.0400776118,
-0.028786784,
0.0121723954,
0.0102098519,
0.0285649877,
0.0320384018,
0.0084457658,
-0.0175376218,
-0.0449085683,
0.0147322481,
-0.0273332503,
-0.0373878442,
-0.0220604949,
-0.0158731192,
0.0749737397,
-0.0300929304,
-0.0126819899,
0.0228754748,
0.0409621857,
0.0160185788,
-0.0489225127,
-0.0048317504,
-0.0227839462,
0.0259372965,
0.0254938602,
-0.0067407941,
-0.0385960937,
-0.0053710509,
0.0144941211,
0.0437464677,
-0.0073865768,
0.0863939747,
0.0186376814,
0.0068287416,
0.0383898839,
-0.00366426,
-0.0479174666,
-0.041553244,
-0.0203338843,
0.0287304223,
0.0559679233,
0.0037005073,
0.0384427682,
-0.0263475254,
-0.0138008967,
-0.0515303575,
0.0049173743,
0.015587125,
-0.0428082682,
0.0073454818,
0.0387895368,
0.0058624386,
0.022340605,
0.0796915963,
0.0202151276,
0.0409971327,
0.0399684943,
0.0034887779,
-0.0346032605,
-0.0077719032,
0.027200032,
0.0418491438,
-0.0157688092,
0.0420756787,
-0.079526566,
-0.0693674013,
-0.0090556908,
0.0172119495,
-0.0088279918,
0.0011968095,
0.0032378901,
0.0681519657,
-0.0446026325,
0.0101663945,
-0.059304595,
0.0043934667,
-0.0334892683,
0.0025799228,
0.0023172162,
-6.559185744e-33,
-0.0258787032,
-0.0099901259,
0.0399911664,
-0.007843704,
0.0015177436,
0.0182127897,
-0.0336196646,
0.0138174882,
-0.0459842235,
0.0190915372,
0.0140453503,
0.0114582032,
-0.0077842879,
0.0377690345,
0.0348233767,
-0.0021105795,
0.0311085433,
0.0002558213,
-0.0023257677,
0.032968387,
0.0502182953,
0.0041442928,
0.0771370083,
-0.0305585507,
0.0333286747,
0.0001379393,
0.0216557179,
-0.0136253629,
-0.0410178341,
0.0808324665,
-0.0202588569,
0.0576837026,
0.0447623059,
-0.0646920428,
0.0080840131,
-0.0017009041,
-0.0810279548,
-0.0454852134,
-0.0043952428,
0.0022676131,
-0.0204630401,
-0.0238436405,
-0.0229215063,
0.0170170479,
-0.0039721495,
-0.052993007,
0.0478236601,
-0.0408343114,
-0.0022586973,
-0.0244675465,
-0.0454760902,
-0.0030503259,
-0.0325051136,
-0.0164180845,
-0.0464436002,
0.033267159,
0.00357802,
0.025507411,
-0.0369275808,
-0.0074116266,
0.007825152,
0.0542490743,
0.0437743217,
-0.0064799138,
0.0185867157,
0.0538597777,
-0.0125643937,
0.0210501067,
0.0094241658,
-0.0071038208,
0.055097688,
0.0291197561,
0.0326258652,
0.0702897757,
0.017888302,
0.0132802706,
-0.0946389362,
0.0306201074,
0.0487308875,
0.0224918965,
0.0133787189,
-0.0306166559,
-0.0173793267,
-0.0026671917,
-0.0601457022,
0.0293743853,
-0.0332277231,
-0.0144140497,
0.0468771122,
-0.0199167151,
-0.0261957869,
-0.007054213,
0.0356971733,
-0.0819822848,
-0.0155330431,
0.0368815139,
-0.0213845521,
0.0149932625,
-0.0275653638,
0.0593797155,
-0.0642440394,
-0.0371137336,
-0.0076838727,
-0.0284671318,
-0.0025101393,
0.0184308197,
0.0369309485,
-0.009749596,
-0.032253433,
-0.0176202226,
-0.029867731,
-0.061958015,
0.0475941077,
0.0483907759,
0.0219412651,
0.016962966,
0.0122887092,
0.0297221839,
0.0396701694,
-0.01391715,
-0.02819442,
-0.0376421399,
-0.0084480708,
-0.0219230112,
-0.0022965823,
0.0052510947,
-0.0378556252,
-0.0453061275,
0.0336342305,
-0.035820663,
-0.00414153,
0.0152861821,
2.723e-7,
0.0466332622,
0.0436441787,
-0.0246446244,
0.0310995653,
-0.0133562293,
0.0342071243,
-0.0424937233,
0.021210758,
0.0164501537,
0.0085613849,
0.0007592587,
0.0335364193,
0.0747215748,
0.0195429362,
-0.1141491085,
-0.0190404281,
-0.0001821642,
-0.0126068844,
-0.043953456,
0.0411464944,
0.0177207701,
0.0705532283,
0.0179553684,
0.0143230557,
0.0016083311,
-0.0467803478,
0.0498648882,
-0.0031545467,
-0.0444300845,
0.0682612658,
-0.0046286453,
0.0237987563,
-0.004244816,
0.0319616087,
-0.0170275774,
0.0058986885,
0.0505792685,
0.0808728933,
0.0219512414,
0.0057379194,
-0.0181005113,
-0.0302795414,
-0.0019788675,
-0.0528033637,
0.0639384314,
-0.0400641635,
-0.0161689781,
0.00933652,
-0.0309877191,
-0.0203432515,
0.0059759272,
-0.0250231083,
-0.0057480545,
-0.002471006,
-0.011151379,
-0.019300608,
0.0151784802,
-0.0183533989,
-0.0183105282,
0.0254022982,
-0.0269133542,
-0.1129316539,
0.0104888203,
-0.0567391999,
0.0040602903,
-0.0936456099,
-0.0035539747,
2.262114441e-34,
0.0474432781,
-0.0088982359,
0.0211981088,
0.0094373384,
0.0253267642,
-0.0411483757,
-0.0647447407,
-0.0329426229,
-0.0269660745,
-0.0848651305,
-0.01278116
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10250v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10250v3 | MemoryBank: Enhancing Large Language Models with Long-Term Memory | 2023-05-17T14:40:29 | 2023-05-21T06:20:28 | Wanjun Zhong, Lianghong Guo, Qiqi Gao, He Ye, Yanlin Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Revolutionary advancements in Large Language Models have drastically reshaped
our interactions with artificial intelligence systems. Despite this, a notable
hindrance remains-the deficiency of a long-term memory mechanism within these
models. This shortfall becomes increasingly evident in situations demanding
sustained interaction, such as personal companion systems and psychological
counseling. Therefore, we propose MemoryBank, a novel memory mechanism tailored
for LLMs. MemoryBank enables the models to summon relevant memories,
continually evolve through continuous memory updates, comprehend, and adapt to
a user personality by synthesizing information from past interactions. To mimic
anthropomorphic behaviors and selectively preserve memory, MemoryBank
incorporates a memory updating mechanism, inspired by the Ebbinghaus Forgetting
Curve theory, which permits the AI to forget and reinforce memory based on time
elapsed and the relative significance of the memory, thereby offering a
human-like memory mechanism. MemoryBank is versatile in accommodating both
closed-source models like ChatGPT and open-source models like ChatGLM. We
exemplify application of MemoryBank through the creation of an LLM-based
chatbot named SiliconFriend in a long-term AI Companion scenario. Further tuned
with psychological dialogs, SiliconFriend displays heightened empathy in its
interactions. Experiment involves both qualitative analysis with real-world
user dialogs and quantitative analysis with simulated dialogs. In the latter,
ChatGPT acts as users with diverse characteristics and generates long-term
dialog contexts covering a wide array of topics. The results of our analysis
reveal that SiliconFriend, equipped with MemoryBank, exhibits a strong
capability for long-term companionship as it can provide emphatic response,
recall relevant memories and understand user personality. | [
0.0807009041,
0.0308373049,
-0.0546819642,
0.0270828605,
-0.0316237956,
0.008491721,
0.0112231383,
-0.0134869218,
0.0792918429,
0.013118865,
-0.0281978715,
-0.0421998836,
-0.040566206,
0.0448752902,
-0.0059092552,
-0.0645738468,
0.063976869,
0.024800159,
0.0294289775,
-0.0017762384,
0.0318355598,
0.0080656735,
-0.0129314978,
0.0342877395,
-0.0341884792,
-0.0166437533,
-0.0334878005,
0.007198629,
0.0091591012,
-0.047105588,
0.0190825071,
0.0083557302,
0.0195862316,
-0.0182899777,
0.0000021174,
-0.0562216863,
-0.0123442961,
-0.0324890502,
-0.0236044172,
-0.0665968508,
0.054535605,
0.0206789263,
-0.0223647878,
0.0092633292,
-0.045846954,
0.0247927215,
0.0391332768,
0.0448468477,
0.0768035874,
0.0667540208,
-0.003941481,
-0.0027330942,
0.0245063622,
-0.0021106708,
0.0442413613,
-0.0267049205,
-0.0059686895,
-0.0103622377,
0.0270613562,
-0.0269902106,
-0.0212558284,
0.0176322088,
0.0276273359,
-0.0140423859,
0.0493571088,
0.015100074,
0.0102355834,
-0.0413927659,
-0.0175384227,
0.0535831302,
0.0333523713,
0.0042340676,
0.017362956,
0.0375015214,
0.0237810872,
-0.0119639421,
-0.0370399542,
-0.0035110682,
-0.0270963497,
-0.021869462,
0.0068536517,
-0.0110798711,
-0.0261969585,
0.0092172623,
-0.0153766889,
0.0294044185,
-0.0142451432,
-0.0221064165,
-0.0114691108,
-0.042591352,
0.0122262342,
-0.0406980217,
0.0509093516,
0.072071597,
-0.0121026002,
0.0378050283,
-0.0469764657,
0.0215795171,
0.0337272733,
-0.035403125,
-0.0088410275,
0.0391450226,
-0.0056526274,
0.0259475093,
0.0084496979,
0.0396382846,
0.0220959466,
-0.0166365802,
-0.0178628489,
0.0180688631,
-0.0559541434,
-0.0164658669,
-0.0268348046,
0.0669322237,
0.0501825288,
-0.0417206138,
-0.0527281575,
0.0775409192,
-0.0001680744,
0.0099033341,
-0.0264878515,
0.0193872917,
-0.0138751576,
0.0147595629,
-0.0705791786,
0.011438597,
-0.0631695166,
-0.0331735611,
0.016225405,
-0.0649786443,
-0.0103923734,
0.0018648767,
-0.0056703752,
-0.0083344672,
0.0159813315,
0.0757525638,
0.0119796302,
-0.0519985445,
-0.0264578871,
-0.0200212896,
-0.0124722393,
-0.0538479835,
0.0256248713,
-0.0159908608,
0.0635413602,
-0.0138591407,
-0.0144320196,
-0.0495004132,
0.0246291254,
-0.000001257,
-0.0167281404,
0.0573184304,
0.0009523089,
-0.0124758203,
0.0178342815,
0.0271503907,
0.0061427816,
0.0152448798,
0.0145661235,
0.0018582627,
0.0106249684,
-0.0093356557,
0.0344609506,
-0.0026753959,
0.0011955908,
-0.0338821337,
0.0153441522,
-0.0164555237,
0.0056973267,
0.0486337952,
0.0164425429,
0.0354338028,
-0.0276126359,
-0.0356906429,
0.0515444055,
0.0919658393,
0.0192755163,
0.078499116,
-0.0095164636,
0.0022496225,
0.0386584215,
0.011150782,
-0.0509006456,
0.0694222525,
-0.031065179,
-0.0149385547,
-0.0439444408,
0.002081448,
-0.0149654429,
-0.0249988381,
0.0210253745,
-0.0352618769,
0.0405011252,
-0.0055834167,
-0.0024930539,
-0.0090905027,
-0.0058718128,
0.0654267296,
0.0183023326,
-0.0540570132,
-0.0378616229,
-0.0623484105,
0.0429041646,
0.1353356242,
0.0237384625,
-0.0436686873,
-0.0473879203,
0.0183025338,
-0.0501267761,
0.0192281175,
0.0560328178,
0.0035176163,
0.004313516,
-0.0248093735,
0.0352514274,
-0.0077154497,
0.0020965196,
0.0427927226,
0.006590155,
0.0408504531,
-0.0198923722,
0.0735264719,
0.0266928356,
0.0109542543,
-0.0620131791,
0.0147124929,
-0.0325494073,
-0.0215679407,
0.0124270646,
0.0167620368,
0.0152352368,
-0.0108224759,
0.0490383431,
-0.0191829409,
-0.0078518195,
0.0810560733,
-0.0734447315,
-0.0033351337,
0.0508370847,
0.0268994216,
0.014745513,
-0.006525862,
0.0176329054,
-0.0189899448,
0.0446930863,
-0.0536694601,
0.1024806499,
-0.0233041178,
0.0492919087,
-0.031793125,
0.0211735051,
-0.0074451016,
0.0243199058,
-0.0127085922,
-0.0282257516,
-0.0080935592,
0.0470971726,
-0.0253591929,
-0.0612990819,
0.0118367644,
0.0154816471,
0.0241950843,
-0.0055404841,
0.0158439372,
-0.018308958,
-0.1072749272,
-0.061875958,
-0.1238734797,
0.0079136547,
0.032092832,
-0.0283446275,
0.0071104425,
-0.004531933,
-0.0094202245,
-0.0263435207,
-0.0639326572,
0.0542051122,
0.0076713823,
0.0190976746,
0.0335408039,
-0.0026855899,
-0.0127548976,
-0.0726815239,
0.016417956,
-0.0146415019,
0.0042600394,
-0.0107459975,
-0.030213071,
-0.0333047807,
0.0306232907,
-0.064052403,
0.0281481221,
-0.0425453857,
-0.0420900062,
0.0282563362,
-0.0271620657,
0.0563542321,
0.0978797674,
0.0459549949,
0.0434593633,
0.0037185496,
-0.0099208644,
-0.0667028204,
0.0275232475,
-0.0042415182,
-0.0132275559,
-0.0180538353,
-0.0171056688,
-0.016922852,
0.0156231336,
-0.0178349894,
0.0248187501,
-0.0377665646,
0.0303182155,
0.0376534946,
-0.0374681614,
0.0363619179,
0.0071578571,
-0.0305374525,
-0.030384656,
0.0018423524,
-0.0643094927,
0.0894574896,
0.0237684473,
-0.0110527305,
0.007180877,
-0.0263302401,
-0.0139717218,
0.0924179032,
-0.0146478685,
0.0236946587,
0.0071030017,
-0.0086168619,
-0.0213259254,
-0.0365167037,
-0.0313947089,
-0.0673207492,
0.0073919138,
-0.0324922837,
-0.0324549414,
0.0368697084,
-0.0086408202,
-0.052843079,
-0.0027219842,
-0.031975124,
-0.0242417417,
0.0019616385,
-0.0261271261,
-0.0223178957,
-0.0150066428,
0.034168005,
-0.0039278083,
-0.0193131752,
-0.0059736357,
-0.0130412495,
-0.0265224259,
0.0405154228,
0.0197122749,
0.0387370735,
-0.0070849652,
0.0582769103,
0.0524764471,
-0.0109785879,
-0.0168120004,
0.0100817392,
0.0192341041,
-0.0045459596,
-0.0119314333,
-0.0167224333,
-0.0074191387,
0.0439016633,
-0.0437735319,
-0.0471186973,
0.1225969419,
0.0205933601,
-0.0506463051,
0.0122928917,
-0.0378560126,
0.0215419531,
0.0130177122,
0.0345942304,
-0.0342779011,
-0.008720031,
-0.001829732,
-0.0164060909,
-0.0348309167,
-0.0400642455,
-0.0295286439,
-0.0789559036,
-0.0244562626,
0.040530365,
-0.0115959831,
0.0116401426,
-0.0221498851,
-0.0272909813,
0.0251289289,
0.0272144787,
0.0173296612,
-0.0012737234,
-0.0253973696,
-0.026944153,
-0.0463058762,
0.0325091071,
0.0589028262,
-0.0377263799,
0.0899817571,
0.0388472304,
0.0887393579,
0.0276973546,
-0.0285772532,
-0.0328998454,
0.0427922234,
0.0317461453,
-0.007528916,
0.0321116187,
-0.0116858156,
0.0085014282,
-0.0202692188,
0.0289286561,
-0.0283897724,
0.0076964996,
0.0335262455,
0.0123243853,
-0.0544059612,
0.004285587,
-0.0199627187,
0.0309385117,
0.0025371262,
0.051141724,
-0.0077531827,
-0.0710971877,
-0.0447096713,
0.0028700843,
0.0068573463,
-0.0057757474,
-0.030503789,
-0.0310390536,
-0.02118125,
0.0140899504,
-0.0590771586,
-0.0757120922,
-0.0093434686,
-0.0018288709,
0.0110860923,
-0.0316324681,
-0.0004575249,
0.0119806714,
-0.0252055097,
0.0103793507,
-0.024166869,
0.0100104474,
-0.024031993,
-0.00926218,
0.0513659194,
-0.0404973887,
0.0355877131,
0.0229286738,
-0.0259202551,
-0.0341548435,
0.0288367253,
0.0372727439,
0.0302806105,
0.0714744627,
0.0208555292,
-0.014995385,
-0.0108004613,
0.0171705596,
-0.0329636559,
0.0258084014,
0.0114694647,
0.0735655352,
0.004218949,
0.0230820086,
-0.0173290428,
0.0127818808,
-0.0242077392,
0.000331922,
-0.0217013005,
-0.0698631033,
0.0267170407,
0.025702171,
-0.0330402367,
0.0247847941,
-0.0155679891,
0.0123028262,
0.0087208878,
-0.0333399437,
0.0186930969,
-0.0333271697,
-0.0310004912,
0.0086951861,
-0.0083685378,
0.0036289333,
-0.1104128435,
-0.0381899327,
-0.0011287618,
0.007785941,
-0.0315373503,
0.0062170238,
-0.0210600235,
-0.0099696973,
0.017273536,
-0.0258770399,
0.0155749246,
-0.0159050729,
0.042382665,
-0.0177012458,
0.0914022252,
-0.0355394296,
-0.0412306041,
-0.0018854515,
0.059909571,
-0.0599863753,
-0.070172146,
0.0082275271,
0.0311496817,
0.0358210504,
0.0193693899,
0.0344151706,
-0.0600544102,
0.0189727582,
-0.0132010477,
0.0190568138,
0.0110835601,
-0.0356292091,
-0.0252231974,
0.0188336093,
-0.0214060284,
0.0084345406,
-0.0022544609,
-0.0610896647,
0.0545068569,
-0.0239052176,
0.0072240634,
-0.036409121,
-0.0042097913,
0.0339542627,
0.0158654898,
0.0069429134,
-0.0490039997,
-0.0740549862,
-0.0371612012,
0.0628586933,
0.0085560717,
-0.0067410185,
-0.0454483852,
0.0396289378,
0.0148773817,
-0.0204928108,
-0.0149426293,
-0.0342002921,
0.0231908746,
-0.0450045466,
0.0051705339,
-0.0130099505,
-5.577491106e-33,
-0.042551998,
-0.0186609142,
0.021863807,
0.021325605,
-0.0626220703,
-0.0186556149,
-0.0560771264,
0.0142940693,
-0.0250023566,
-0.0307914019,
-0.0383276083,
0.0379486009,
0.005372698,
-0.0255792569,
0.0075829891,
0.0005940261,
0.0214227661,
0.0031704702,
-0.0006396636,
0.0624731518,
0.0531922653,
0.0656145737,
0.0203664452,
-0.0725589246,
0.0292127207,
-0.0093674287,
0.0123801818,
0.0233642627,
0.0066164974,
0.0420393385,
-0.0308987405,
0.0236519054,
-0.0032998635,
0.0050280397,
0.002690925,
0.0403479524,
-0.0847607702,
-0.0241049174,
-0.0042394991,
-0.0129298093,
-0.0376676098,
-0.0515970252,
0.0115978243,
-0.03026223,
0.0000367486,
0.0062610046,
-0.000131757,
-0.0327303223,
-0.0075260927,
0.002242309,
-0.0280599222,
-0.0244549308,
-0.0025958016,
-0.0354168192,
-0.0289481357,
0.013114511,
-0.0120509295,
0.0169482846,
-0.0419424996,
0.023225477,
-0.0500165187,
-0.0147412661,
0.0039984058,
0.0110566905,
0.04746731,
0.0829560086,
0.0690862164,
0.0448719822,
0.0185092445,
0.0088625131,
0.0414100662,
0.0153344329,
0.0497630872,
0.0009391484,
0.0153041752,
-0.0452339873,
-0.0006129132,
-0.0008283789,
0.1096451953,
0.0173975732,
0.0091953333,
0.0216814447,
-0.0312972777,
-0.0134893209,
-0.0175176524,
0.0360737965,
-0.0155224307,
-0.0760759637,
-0.0023966061,
0.0214269441,
-0.0269133188,
-0.057178583,
0.0086855069,
-0.0504218936,
0.017201772,
0.0008375189,
-0.0051776096,
0.0011679392,
-0.0087677473,
0.0211454984,
-0.0156823769,
-0.030402692,
-0.0009514041,
0.0114809368,
0.0508714542,
0.0307304841,
0.0028899235,
0.0252061319,
-0.041295357,
-0.0127151469,
-0.0382491238,
0.0400314294,
-0.0066035599,
-0.0307128187,
-0.0210820865,
0.0132112345,
-0.0275658183,
0.0532195978,
0.0329156891,
0.019148903,
-0.0780161545,
-0.0014268608,
0.0063880682,
0.0003902076,
-0.0298113208,
-0.0234703422,
-0.0636016801,
0.0442051701,
0.0218281839,
-0.0742663294,
0.0192006323,
-0.020149203,
2.84e-7,
-0.0651381239,
0.0372358151,
0.0210056752,
-0.0101708407,
0.060480237,
0.0258039907,
-0.0013917617,
0.0493465178,
0.040123675,
-0.0549598671,
0.0006267146,
0.0485728942,
0.0422126465,
0.0128033599,
-0.0573888086,
-0.0081067625,
-0.0219210889,
-0.0514294244,
-0.0273631494,
0.0181789212,
0.0788080916,
0.0568776615,
0.0613737255,
-0.0269189458,
0.0192642156,
-0.0231853668,
0.0508914888,
-0.0503420345,
-0.0117376773,
0.0100203073,
0.0051596728,
0.0419303924,
0.0011034195,
-0.0024236443,
0.0098951533,
-0.0226806626,
-0.0429958142,
0.0765723661,
-0.0217890088,
-0.0654570088,
0.0277137402,
0.0359352753,
-0.0314156078,
-0.0044353274,
0.0439495556,
-0.0496668704,
-0.0172450095,
-0.0222765449,
0.0088630393,
-0.0419455469,
-0.0063607353,
-0.0064731226,
-0.022465745,
0.0458830222,
-0.0297131613,
0.0125106359,
0.0247950666,
-0.0933656991,
0.0043087141,
0.0118288426,
-0.0482254364,
-0.0680919215,
-0.0193716194,
0.0070815878,
-0.0076964111,
-0.0919052362,
0.0168905444,
2.19792074e-34,
0.0019454672,
0.0136084119,
0.0256205648,
0.0614575669,
0.067344673,
0.0198344439,
0.0589561462,
0.0318098031,
0.0631494448,
-0.0435585193,
-0.028380584
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10236v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10236v1 | A quantitative study of NLP approaches to question difficulty estimation | 2023-05-17T14:26:00 | 2023-05-17T14:26:00 | Luca Benedetto | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent years witnessed an increase in the amount of research on the task of
Question Difficulty Estimation from Text QDET with Natural Language Processing
(NLP) techniques, with the goal of targeting the limitations of traditional
approaches to question calibration. However, almost the entirety of previous
research focused on single silos, without performing quantitative comparisons
between different models or across datasets from different educational domains.
In this work, we aim at filling this gap, by quantitatively analyzing several
approaches proposed in previous research, and comparing their performance on
three publicly available real world datasets containing questions of different
types from different educational domains. Specifically, we consider reading
comprehension Multiple Choice Questions (MCQs), science MCQs, and math
questions. We find that Transformer based models are the best performing across
different educational domains, with DistilBERT performing almost as well as
BERT, and that they outperform other approaches even on smaller datasets. As
for the other models, the hybrid ones often outperform the ones based on a
single type of features, the ones based on linguistic features perform well on
reading comprehension questions, while frequency based features (TF-IDF) and
word embeddings (word2vec) perform better in domain knowledge assessment. | [
0.0383576006,
-0.0194351543,
-0.0291733313,
0.0112930955,
-0.0467951186,
0.0312250573,
0.0252338648,
-0.0129202912,
0.0149231181,
-0.0516302623,
0.030703932,
-0.0265203677,
-0.0142114274,
-0.0130918715,
0.0210406184,
-0.0268115271,
-0.0081456965,
0.0223583039,
-0.0143842297,
0.0038500121,
-0.0027729839,
-0.0201012399,
-0.0349654034,
0.023764275,
0.0282717478,
-0.0309956484,
-0.0064303977,
0.0037197457,
0.016561022,
-0.0130851222,
0.0358549766,
0.0804000795,
-0.0116587738,
-0.0017568865,
0.0000019081,
-0.0600690506,
-0.0490299836,
-0.0157239269,
-0.0170199517,
-0.0204912871,
0.0340696126,
-0.0027302674,
0.0291698072,
0.0577749014,
-0.027507389,
-0.0192281399,
0.0298732743,
0.0263173897,
0.0468124747,
0.0479573905,
0.0055130497,
-0.0155796837,
0.0346925482,
0.0378898941,
0.02351816,
-0.0408097729,
0.0030924564,
0.0072086249,
-0.0136667527,
0.0219915602,
-0.0601013154,
0.0315671191,
0.0330699831,
0.0164995901,
-0.0064842356,
-0.0201592464,
-0.0336113125,
0.0002770653,
-0.0059721349,
0.0757255331,
0.0069211172,
-0.00169611,
-0.0464616567,
-0.0014924301,
0.0210384149,
0.0799964666,
-0.013368737,
-0.0163705014,
0.0050841928,
-0.0426272713,
0.0028920465,
-0.0093607744,
-0.0280140713,
-0.0032096251,
-0.0107529368,
0.0254754182,
0.0244347528,
-0.0616791323,
0.018171845,
0.0071933162,
-0.0537855886,
-0.0037877702,
0.033982452,
0.0220190082,
0.0020729965,
0.0317350253,
-0.0083403243,
-0.0742832199,
-0.006882037,
-0.0020067643,
-0.004373224,
0.0382834673,
-0.0338813737,
0.0346413851,
-0.0117764249,
0.099296324,
0.048992373,
0.0097100595,
-0.0745851099,
-0.0118792988,
-0.0263636187,
-0.0054350276,
-0.0343061723,
0.0115955947,
0.0020952099,
0.0148786632,
-0.0443485603,
-0.0171935558,
-0.0097521031,
0.0059199911,
0.0026699235,
-0.0206931569,
-0.0165179465,
0.0264114756,
-0.0177777205,
0.061098516,
-0.0533491783,
0.0062192925,
-0.0100095356,
-0.0088403374,
0.0142897405,
0.0042200126,
0.0409139283,
-0.0236247405,
0.0150811728,
0.0368932374,
0.0225912444,
-0.0591968819,
0.0033996624,
-0.0173742287,
-0.0296038184,
-0.0121875554,
0.0171738267,
-0.0428396799,
0.0298692696,
0.0390176848,
0.0154898493,
-0.0153085431,
-0.0130513012,
0.0288044102,
0.0071906461,
0.0744347498,
0.0441736728,
0.0039009624,
0.0408577286,
0.0031410677,
-0.0196542535,
0.0489160642,
0.0230878554,
-0.0501833521,
0.0872725546,
-0.0476700179,
0.0235762708,
0.0078143282,
-0.0128548658,
0.003057857,
0.0229827967,
0.0240884256,
-0.0189659856,
0.0223157182,
-0.0371466689,
0.0476693772,
0.0145083265,
-0.0138735678,
0.009930091,
0.0534318201,
0.038512297,
-0.0085249953,
0.0137632089,
0.0634345636,
0.0395628065,
0.0555548705,
-0.0241551474,
0.0007338962,
-0.0319765918,
-0.0054860604,
0.0209810771,
0.0201185718,
-0.0084845256,
-0.0815880075,
-0.0362246595,
0.0265881717,
0.0510140546,
0.0237506106,
0.0404750705,
0.0099741295,
-0.0252804793,
0.0168909375,
0.0059282472,
-0.0506332107,
0.0047797961,
0.0027442384,
0.0131425047,
-0.022306107,
0.0541416295,
-0.0606104247,
-0.0581827536,
-0.002956891,
0.0192491412,
0.0285870992,
0.0416090377,
-0.0122876745,
-0.0080206832,
-0.0557469614,
-0.0423358642,
0.0038578385,
0.0170227177,
-0.0497333556,
0.0124542182,
0.0096985316,
0.007005523,
-0.0773469359,
-0.0237092674,
0.0327373296,
-0.0331475437,
-0.0737688169,
-0.0150880395,
0.0306025092,
-0.0116675524,
0.0182408225,
0.0239117704,
0.0131652057,
0.0018009343,
-0.0344539694,
-0.0064187841,
-0.0133704692,
-0.0320088193,
-0.0537348054,
0.0514321662,
-0.0730924085,
-0.0176459253,
0.0691059232,
-0.0300411694,
-0.0257194005,
-0.0119506521,
-0.0696031377,
-0.0215176847,
0.006943862,
0.0156776831,
-0.0325749554,
-0.0444898419,
-0.06844078,
0.0440164581,
0.0030243292,
0.110209167,
-0.0283688493,
-0.021039363,
0.0425981246,
0.0357596762,
-0.0608799644,
-0.0384144224,
-0.0245179553,
0.0133646261,
0.0359635092,
-0.0038264657,
-0.0707771629,
-0.0200487524,
-0.0598880425,
0.0199143011,
-0.0279249158,
0.0170475096,
0.0210434087,
-0.000039236,
-0.0135036139,
-0.0037005008,
-0.0897966102,
-0.0168217309,
-0.0148045188,
0.0122881122,
0.0250342507,
0.0072667501,
-0.0043394086,
-0.0224369671,
-0.0258992035,
-0.0507552288,
0.0326405615,
0.0289975945,
0.0540793948,
-0.019875098,
0.0553251095,
-0.0174055658,
-0.007032251,
0.01607861,
-0.019259423,
0.0201719534,
0.0128615061,
0.0807773247,
0.0310245082,
-0.0000429871,
0.0071901702,
0.0148930708,
-0.0029032298,
-0.0425668918,
0.0449966528,
-0.0616850592,
-0.0248270389,
-0.0158749949,
-0.0633625686,
0.0138924113,
0.0543813296,
0.0147757949,
-0.0647203177,
-0.032518398,
0.0663300604,
-0.0653669611,
0.0214616582,
-0.0434315428,
0.0359226651,
-0.0018155362,
0.0328198485,
0.0014818734,
-0.0102350414,
0.0938542709,
-0.0116943074,
0.0004037814,
-0.1199826747,
0.0218455251,
-0.0414537154,
0.0356548615,
0.017046459,
0.0112260589,
0.0389601998,
-0.0099996049,
-0.0845527574,
0.0231275484,
0.030731516,
-0.0647085086,
0.0526941977,
-0.0362201706,
-0.0562688224,
-0.0058252104,
-0.0277440939,
-0.0386389121,
0.0017456842,
0.0222023726,
-0.0011943344,
0.0297840144,
-0.0336059071,
-0.0037083621,
-0.0374819227,
0.0220188778,
0.0006585979,
-0.0156196626,
-0.0295690428,
-0.0063008931,
0.0892898366,
0.0489092842,
0.0695122108,
0.0533336215,
0.0021572837,
0.0449644215,
0.0299448222,
0.051419843,
0.0074747992,
0.0584742278,
0.0249724258,
0.0423954092,
-0.064858906,
0.0058244253,
0.0142559037,
0.0718434677,
-0.0596591383,
-0.0208072942,
0.1173080057,
0.0759573579,
0.0017516873,
-0.0038996227,
-0.0456617735,
-0.0183763187,
0.0296641048,
0.0241660289,
-0.0449108146,
-0.0294670165,
0.0000238833,
0.0394765101,
-0.0236107539,
-0.0372888073,
0.0091457358,
-0.0883858129,
0.0048401509,
-0.04108968,
-0.0001282407,
-0.0322541967,
-0.0586113445,
-0.0234356653,
0.000323723,
0.0211214051,
-0.0248847622,
0.0187313426,
0.0268784016,
0.0375520661,
-0.0425556898,
-0.0266889315,
0.029267218,
-0.0188677572,
0.004704054,
0.0113562541,
0.0198576059,
-0.0453572199,
-0.0396112315,
-0.0075744092,
-0.0458682403,
-0.0527949966,
0.0100061288,
0.0403351262,
0.0114859315,
-0.0060612154,
-0.0521212891,
0.0264731608,
-0.009971885,
0.0284003504,
0.0330472551,
0.0481482074,
0.0223900769,
0.0049336441,
-0.0397347473,
0.0030159475,
-0.0111090401,
0.1015363857,
0.0383317843,
-0.0788208768,
0.0192512982,
-0.0551649071,
0.0061377375,
-0.0661632717,
-0.0539814755,
0.0397349261,
0.0251052584,
0.0292295609,
-0.0620492063,
-0.0581876226,
0.0669403374,
-0.0034432893,
0.0098539302,
-0.0117842043,
0.0339676961,
0.0060259691,
-0.0601602197,
0.0038221329,
0.0158934779,
0.0084910877,
-0.0473608263,
0.0076550101,
0.0047214781,
0.0170024224,
-0.0412623957,
-0.0025651776,
-0.0491113029,
-0.0242246799,
0.0036768711,
-0.0037200165,
0.0081041222,
-0.0416643918,
-0.0080919452,
-0.0177021772,
0.0286340863,
-0.0092736324,
-0.032240212,
-0.0067000971,
-0.0084113022,
-0.0214036796,
-0.0081995428,
0.0236401875,
-0.0073708729,
-0.0098389918,
0.0190494601,
0.0725878105,
-0.0150973545,
-0.0448775813,
0.0359387212,
0.013581926,
0.0423842333,
0.019202007,
-0.0254510678,
-0.0066661714,
-0.0037825403,
0.0014035748,
-0.0215193927,
-0.0363213867,
-0.0086444886,
0.0384289175,
-0.0163555816,
-0.0359023288,
0.015588657,
-0.0343168601,
0.0302929468,
-0.0424202047,
0.0779050216,
0.0188345388,
0.0181416236,
-0.0130524887,
-0.0252195466,
-0.0085838567,
-0.0256645754,
0.0125484038,
0.0557137504,
0.0402217247,
0.0844458565,
-0.0104150353,
-0.0029773428,
0.0209755935,
0.0055383029,
-0.0402553678,
-0.0171895772,
-0.0018689886,
-0.0017631612,
-0.0111936284,
-0.0254592188,
-0.0164736379,
-0.002930267,
-0.0029043683,
-0.0190150049,
-0.0089062257,
0.0207523499,
0.0004828754,
0.0578534044,
0.0325972661,
0.0252119321,
-0.0040098396,
0.0529305115,
0.0318676382,
-0.0033551392,
0.0287709851,
-0.0361436754,
-0.0311748944,
0.0085660219,
0.0194399077,
0.0401510112,
-0.0043299808,
0.0567856431,
-0.08732678,
-0.0613989085,
0.0500342101,
-0.0101912767,
0.0240101479,
-0.014581196,
-0.008277935,
0.0483364277,
-0.047809232,
-0.0239025801,
-0.0502094142,
0.0243055038,
-0.0532362387,
-0.0551313721,
0.0015304534,
-5.801641716e-33,
0.002259179,
-0.0476155914,
0.0000733815,
-0.0086495578,
0.0316652879,
0.0326536708,
0.0000406608,
0.039574109,
-0.0490329042,
0.0121539189,
-0.0024414526,
0.0023766786,
-0.0121098068,
0.022006372,
-0.0136324149,
-0.0390319638,
0.0051767523,
-0.0145123769,
-0.0341657139,
-0.0278627016,
0.0133989044,
0.0127535043,
0.0495481156,
-0.0408573709,
0.0587222911,
-0.0413691774,
0.0394510329,
-0.0062965406,
0.03059268,
0.0422763452,
-0.0062315189,
0.0658240393,
0.0331976525,
-0.0872674659,
0.022965746,
0.0146912932,
-0.049588155,
-0.0412946567,
0.0025425181,
0.030170491,
-0.0252842754,
0.0032526413,
0.0253005829,
0.003808381,
-0.0081566842,
-0.041182965,
0.0571773015,
-0.0206752308,
0.0198639967,
-0.0269074701,
-0.0271731503,
0.0036032973,
-0.0443482473,
-0.0426182151,
-0.0072256345,
0.0998921916,
0.0160838403,
0.0245937891,
-0.067282334,
0.0041815396,
0.0180431306,
0.0316661932,
0.000952295,
-0.047446616,
-0.029870661,
0.0250065196,
-0.0058708848,
-0.0266543906,
0.0194437299,
-0.0141405258,
0.0313041098,
0.0069246744,
0.1127604097,
0.0585166961,
0.0692056939,
0.0137672843,
-0.0790099949,
0.0776515678,
-0.0251574833,
0.0083351703,
-0.0044528954,
-0.0417606868,
-0.0887625739,
-0.0070309085,
-0.0527207851,
0.063973397,
-0.0411880985,
-0.0107879397,
0.046301052,
-0.0418908074,
-0.047216747,
-0.0185033791,
0.0200887267,
-0.0351775065,
0.0032451104,
-0.0079388143,
0.0071605491,
0.048811283,
-0.0234052874,
0.0395868719,
-0.0148747014,
0.036652565,
0.0110541023,
-0.0179262776,
0.0057714861,
-0.0054972013,
0.0395906754,
-0.0068429611,
-0.0548004918,
-0.013729468,
0.0056155804,
-0.0163371358,
-0.0225088149,
0.1050279588,
0.0085267052,
0.0419588536,
-0.0153023088,
-0.0085998066,
0.0134457704,
-0.010235996,
-0.0527858548,
-0.007238999,
-0.0062663299,
-0.0029263205,
-0.0103256041,
-0.0346732549,
-0.001041343,
0.0119567253,
-0.0158499088,
-0.0357281826,
0.0102600111,
-0.026639387,
2.5e-7,
0.0757487938,
0.0427431427,
0.01927834,
0.006056447,
-0.0251993649,
0.0348481871,
0.0130849481,
0.0014136573,
0.0403104424,
-0.0055746245,
-0.0038695738,
0.0113959536,
0.0409673452,
0.0150834518,
-0.0934199095,
-0.0491982885,
0.0431651026,
0.0292040445,
0.0103385868,
0.0323144756,
0.0967188403,
0.0734937191,
-0.0126165878,
0.0124178231,
-0.0360628888,
-0.0500386059,
0.0007281781,
-0.0351208039,
0.0015871687,
0.0452932939,
0.0350876078,
0.0338233784,
0.0384563133,
0.0349504128,
-0.0497362353,
0.0241678152,
0.0506849773,
0.0131865293,
0.0459992029,
-0.0378510356,
-0.0095589422,
0.0013642268,
0.0065435064,
-0.0470246933,
0.0513515249,
-0.0481823869,
-0.0163432173,
0.035680946,
-0.0395455286,
0.0025703865,
0.0440542549,
-0.010776286,
-0.0273096897,
-0.0101313926,
0.032169804,
-0.0278591681,
0.0507056117,
-0.0450703911,
-0.0172104891,
0.0268375985,
0.0190179143,
-0.0442348719,
-0.0547391027,
-0.0663630366,
0.0308262035,
-0.0545105077,
-0.0123770088,
2.210427128e-34,
0.0431598388,
0.0065460545,
0.0396898873,
0.0068008564,
0.0212886501,
-0.0131872771,
0.0017605252,
-0.0446841605,
0.0110033685,
-0.0984453112,
0.0109724626
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.15425v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.15425v2 | Language Model Tokenizers Introduce Unfairness Between Languages | 2023-05-17T14:17:57 | 2023-10-20T10:09:55 | Aleksandar Petrov, Emanuele La Malfa, Philip H. S. Torr, Adel Bibi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent language models have shown impressive multilingual performance, even
when not explicitly trained for it. Despite this, there are concerns about the
quality of their outputs across different languages. In this paper, we show how
disparity in the treatment of different languages arises at the tokenization
stage, well before a model is even invoked. The same text translated into
different languages can have drastically different tokenization lengths, with
differences up to 15 times in some cases. These disparities persist even for
tokenizers that are intentionally trained for multilingual support.
Character-level and byte-level models also exhibit over 4 times the difference
in the encoding length for some language pairs. This induces unfair treatment
for some language communities in regard to the cost of accessing commercial
language services, the processing time and latency, as well as the amount of
content that can be provided as context to the models. Therefore, we make the
case that we should train future language models using multilingually fair
subword tokenizers. | [
0.0393711217,
0.0868376791,
-0.0164796505,
0.0528084375,
-0.0282305032,
0.0214850903,
0.0765321553,
0.0336197726,
-0.0441678949,
-0.0355363786,
-0.0215245169,
-0.0625329837,
0.0001430178,
0.0239093136,
0.0179237705,
-0.0696943849,
0.0715938061,
-0.021062864,
0.0185698885,
-0.0238373466,
0.0220172163,
0.0075794235,
0.0633701906,
0.0618485995,
-0.0331561938,
0.0075333393,
0.0336610712,
0.0041897171,
-0.0378895849,
0.0071763326,
0.0118699428,
0.0289073624,
-0.0198689625,
0.0665648431,
0.0000017858,
-0.0454980507,
-0.0302044228,
0.0163408443,
0.0081585338,
0.0616465434,
0.0863307416,
-0.0579124466,
-0.0090054041,
0.0382271782,
-0.019066764,
-0.0013399429,
0.0462783091,
0.0267643873,
0.024559509,
0.0409938581,
-0.010397397,
-0.0131269861,
-0.0008569711,
-0.0294065867,
-0.0503695197,
-0.0076238262,
-0.0064900438,
-0.0166037939,
-0.0338532291,
-0.0091341408,
-0.0356711522,
0.0284281019,
0.0092639755,
0.0092089083,
-0.0320388563,
0.0184115544,
-0.0591592304,
-0.0385395288,
-0.0033597017,
0.0226189736,
-0.0632627383,
-0.022972405,
0.0010822226,
0.0083863214,
-0.0036519463,
-0.023884628,
-0.0301767047,
0.0593592711,
0.0055768178,
0.0259224493,
0.0428195074,
0.0109054977,
0.0392598137,
-0.0054358193,
-0.0478336401,
0.0764390528,
0.0313188247,
-0.0257985815,
-0.0538808517,
0.0193465576,
-0.0161129292,
-0.0692774728,
0.0312561989,
-0.0284659136,
-0.0300316419,
0.0063049393,
-0.0546415895,
-0.0526668876,
0.0373918712,
-0.0407843888,
-0.0137004061,
0.0471097939,
-0.0386951193,
0.0141029684,
-0.0393132642,
0.0343625136,
-0.0092079621,
0.0394091792,
-0.0568854213,
-0.041824542,
0.0067665805,
-0.0156681985,
-0.0398609936,
0.0232393034,
-0.0580113344,
0.0089310287,
-0.01617245,
0.0210855361,
0.0103136757,
-0.0049117845,
0.00701907,
-0.0235690642,
-0.0418957919,
-0.0161388312,
0.0026689342,
0.0320056826,
-0.0447295047,
-0.0089354562,
-0.0073883086,
-0.0595897548,
0.0121011715,
0.0063364282,
-0.0123483846,
-0.0311848037,
0.0110921208,
0.0811887383,
-0.0031290748,
0.0045998888,
-0.0137881208,
-0.0259353034,
0.0028852436,
-0.0294850487,
-0.0368112214,
-0.0795808509,
0.0292358827,
0.0412940942,
0.0080210902,
-0.0367911905,
-0.0290605035,
-0.0156484172,
-0.0533211455,
0.0587059483,
-0.014507765,
-0.0141722849,
0.0332758427,
-0.0118774502,
-0.0064242012,
0.0848994181,
0.0238405298,
0.0097642466,
0.0906918496,
-0.0221157651,
-0.0310784578,
0.0583444089,
0.0089510912,
0.0210249741,
-0.0376057662,
-0.0094873533,
0.0584725998,
-0.002735514,
0.0748009086,
0.0855668485,
-0.0150641203,
-0.0222482923,
0.000586626,
0.0755800605,
-0.0183416959,
0.0216338411,
0.0241547544,
-0.0204511974,
-0.0453076921,
0.0263595972,
-0.0298935082,
-0.0259814598,
0.0325412787,
-0.0111699728,
0.0431691259,
0.0711604431,
-0.031072557,
-0.0329496562,
-0.0137601933,
-0.0264503695,
0.0439169854,
-0.0330155976,
0.0397522934,
-0.0241869353,
-0.0165898725,
0.0814104304,
0.0469046161,
-0.0626299009,
0.0430315807,
-0.0643098205,
0.0008312234,
0.0549336448,
0.0385831818,
0.0049829781,
0.0359169766,
-0.010727128,
0.0316732526,
0.0590204373,
0.0739645138,
-0.0131753236,
0.0056670955,
-0.0457608029,
-0.004283492,
0.0020448328,
0.0265159886,
0.0242872573,
-0.0111187715,
0.0497773997,
0.0115036685,
-0.0613945127,
-0.0507801175,
0.031991154,
-0.012260207,
0.0161426961,
-0.0129476348,
0.0103731481,
-0.0140812295,
0.0310298093,
-0.0327047519,
-0.0009331183,
-0.0004517128,
-0.0408996232,
0.0025471575,
0.0386832952,
-0.0334053971,
0.0036997206,
0.0662242696,
-0.0034066057,
0.0310873985,
0.0193650331,
-0.0261389595,
-0.0313348137,
0.059454903,
0.0127636204,
0.0943038613,
-0.0089500444,
0.0641902164,
-0.0448069125,
0.0024869342,
-0.039834056,
-0.0014579282,
-0.0068246061,
0.0337187573,
-0.0140804267,
-0.0363483839,
0.0519410446,
-0.0176851507,
-0.0397891439,
0.0723361,
-0.0271495581,
0.0039175297,
0.051626958,
0.0088847987,
0.0085766884,
-0.0044806227,
-0.0940012857,
-0.0215397179,
-0.0449340567,
0.0248990748,
0.0125351297,
0.0621960536,
-0.0071374974,
-0.0186445955,
-0.0402180105,
-0.0365993716,
0.0101736449,
0.0394339114,
0.017741384,
-0.0050154603,
-0.0101997023,
-0.0384878889,
-0.0435792878,
0.0101210941,
0.0709514171,
-0.0088035744,
-0.0395483039,
-0.0678320155,
-0.008008034,
-0.0263801739,
0.0306905322,
-0.0235815421,
-0.0671039745,
0.0112774633,
-0.0067966431,
0.0194726121,
0.0508414097,
0.0137747955,
0.0123508843,
0.0429039486,
0.0324528851,
-0.0772670284,
-0.0115603292,
0.0338186175,
-0.012795981,
-0.0342536941,
-0.0468519069,
0.010104808,
0.0719721839,
-0.0172711834,
-0.0137016783,
-0.0612208433,
0.007532408,
-0.0768015012,
-0.0323835649,
0.0022033395,
-0.0148856528,
-0.000231928,
0.0370658487,
-0.0077391034,
-0.0518606193,
0.0457480662,
-0.0407981649,
0.0034097543,
-0.045499213,
-0.0024295517,
-0.0374854431,
0.0321660787,
-0.0073537924,
0.0632216707,
-0.0344699807,
-0.0600887015,
-0.031537652,
0.0167985559,
0.0294182859,
-0.0073771342,
0.0361280404,
-0.006080349,
-0.0065965038,
-0.0464669131,
-0.0516208075,
-0.0107190488,
-0.0188234765,
-0.0339871459,
0.022615999,
0.0693018213,
-0.0269715507,
-0.0112917349,
0.0437646918,
-0.0009826367,
0.0534484237,
-0.0117917489,
0.0186782889,
0.0003690426,
0.0127018569,
0.001665681,
-0.0245261639,
0.0052356967,
-0.0327026211,
-0.0019978015,
0.0362869129,
0.0367876478,
-0.022850303,
0.0159348194,
-0.003023067,
0.0394305438,
-0.05062503,
-0.0526187159,
-0.0239581093,
0.0603702515,
-0.0426107123,
0.0024998856,
0.1164993197,
0.041361291,
-0.0588025041,
0.0128757125,
-0.0559850335,
0.0278601907,
0.028444184,
0.0030004422,
-0.1057670861,
-0.0098794997,
0.0353152603,
0.0287448708,
0.0055046105,
-0.0000680809,
0.0064944569,
-0.0861419588,
-0.0006904427,
0.0213137884,
-0.0780121461,
-0.020092871,
-0.0228717756,
-0.044979617,
-0.004308654,
0.0770010799,
0.0040801261,
0.0047031003,
0.0198658295,
0.0407279357,
-0.0369737633,
-0.0193101913,
-0.0117599191,
-0.0619375855,
0.0708473399,
0.0482413806,
0.0084082875,
-0.0295278318,
-0.0114398198,
0.05255685,
0.028575398,
-0.0053243148,
-0.0338322148,
0.014473239,
0.0017913423,
-0.0292205736,
0.0198263004,
-0.0262960754,
0.0088486578,
0.00569674,
-0.0111907162,
0.0236419775,
0.034290988,
-0.0270369798,
-0.0146793239,
-0.0479871519,
-0.0177594796,
0.0723722801,
0.0083622402,
-0.0417851061,
-0.0489668921,
-0.0619573221,
-0.0256702285,
-0.0546816625,
0.016279662,
0.0033658682,
-0.0082608396,
-0.050068032,
-0.056622874,
-0.0391407721,
-0.0095243845,
0.0205441341,
0.0017982589,
-0.0021491065,
-0.0217149481,
-0.0176672619,
-0.0409288965,
0.0069557829,
-0.0285013225,
0.0151447002,
-0.0890675187,
0.010230815,
-0.0189508703,
-0.0091478918,
-0.0198022258,
-0.0280132946,
-0.0505340323,
-0.074781619,
0.0031226492,
0.0311975423,
0.0235706698,
0.062756069,
-0.0095492918,
-0.0740871727,
0.0152956247,
0.0427623503,
-0.0400893986,
0.0164208766,
0.0522676036,
-0.0131708421,
-0.0071750176,
0.0393779427,
-0.0552878082,
-0.0044381153,
0.0105962157,
0.0141398599,
0.0071909041,
0.0073298491,
-0.0128574008,
0.0579455644,
0.0095317587,
-0.0416439027,
-0.0030305274,
-0.0219125357,
0.0094894171,
-0.0465330929,
-0.0069030523,
-0.0260068998,
0.004621679,
0.0217014272,
0.02547911,
-0.0102155479,
0.0100433268,
-0.0156950019,
0.0243041478,
0.0138310716,
0.0335437842,
-0.0152514949,
0.0300427135,
0.0484205931,
0.0195656996,
-0.0039129751,
-0.0250265934,
-0.0113171469,
0.0241258014,
-0.0792011842,
-0.0317328386,
0.0107852863,
0.0157939699,
-0.0381862223,
0.0307974983,
-0.033003591,
-0.0505384095,
-0.004855731,
0.0096601928,
0.0407314487,
-0.0097718323,
0.0568691865,
0.0016927352,
-0.009510342,
-0.0076643582,
0.0005102016,
0.0392515212,
-0.0294552613,
0.0143741043,
-0.0218088422,
-0.0557874888,
-0.0067390227,
0.0997777656,
0.0117231077,
0.0535849668,
-0.0337578356,
-0.0252993442,
-0.0116362683,
0.0231322534,
0.0154722761,
0.0204780493,
-0.0491897091,
-0.0373643227,
-0.0285627209,
-0.0703154653,
-0.0063495189,
0.0256572962,
0.0250062179,
0.0184476469,
-0.0213402435,
0.0754033029,
0.0092364075,
-0.0148264281,
-0.0416658372,
-0.0020961524,
0.0262423586,
-0.0358851738,
0.0055074934,
-5.824054352e-33,
0.0133977579,
0.0188857112,
-0.0223438516,
-0.0276547503,
-0.0009469314,
0.019848289,
-0.0130681489,
0.000379994,
-0.0273681711,
-0.0193050131,
-0.0377861969,
0.0104086753,
0.0324298739,
0.0162255149,
0.035518501,
0.0168483239,
0.0720954686,
0.0024373636,
-0.0314035267,
0.004668796,
0.0252075177,
0.0194090493,
0.0639157221,
-0.0002539764,
0.0467460006,
-0.0009157722,
-0.0019906443,
0.0149011584,
0.0479242578,
0.0622437149,
-0.0121223554,
0.0502791815,
0.0232020244,
-0.0022197268,
-0.0302563328,
-0.0002234205,
-0.0862294286,
-0.0088321194,
0.0477375574,
0.0526566692,
0.0163827315,
-0.0565161817,
0.0420436449,
-0.0037231974,
-0.0342156067,
0.0107955867,
0.0142066581,
0.0017145056,
-0.0196411237,
-0.0053259484,
-0.0553268827,
0.0090377526,
-0.0183120389,
0.0603788681,
0.048721727,
0.0226046052,
0.0232904833,
0.0375066437,
-0.0601107404,
0.0241307858,
-0.0036014284,
0.0402378924,
0.0827992558,
0.0105012497,
-0.0045423345,
0.0372380167,
0.0334930606,
0.0208526291,
0.0154032717,
0.0074449829,
0.0609787777,
-0.0278952755,
0.0231890213,
0.038702812,
0.0357841365,
-0.0596504919,
-0.0696999207,
0.0173712727,
0.0380882733,
-0.0013430991,
0.0123501886,
0.0531998649,
-0.0362528712,
-0.0391369611,
-0.0337749757,
-0.0594135262,
-0.0331184044,
-0.0468918011,
0.0330975838,
0.0089323148,
0.0081899241,
-0.0150098652,
0.0543966107,
-0.0435410999,
-0.0596327186,
0.011823033,
-0.0023103314,
-0.0012160705,
-0.0130998921,
0.0420031697,
-0.0312889963,
-0.0379262418,
-0.0211810581,
-0.0080391802,
-0.0055987085,
0.0044397195,
0.0399918295,
-0.0103389286,
-0.0794997364,
0.0294373836,
-0.0101635177,
0.0253186673,
0.0192559268,
0.0372265019,
0.036789421,
-0.015578039,
0.0069228481,
0.0088053029,
0.0310372617,
-0.0159209911,
-0.04350999,
-0.0016988892,
-0.0064456854,
0.0295099895,
-0.0462961197,
-0.0027152796,
-0.0564109907,
0.0526881181,
0.0419245921,
-0.0336991213,
-0.0368889421,
-0.0159519985,
2.467e-7,
0.0517118052,
0.0515151545,
0.0330759287,
-0.0209176838,
0.0146824373,
0.0191591736,
-0.004194255,
0.0446266457,
-0.0062380047,
0.0541216061,
-0.0425104052,
-0.001087699,
0.0306388512,
0.0339766592,
-0.0721164644,
0.0283254012,
-0.0815429091,
0.0123812137,
-0.0575591773,
-0.0003888831,
0.0130890338,
0.0949797109,
-0.0033332156,
-0.0047983821,
-0.0223644637,
-0.0512134433,
0.0236745514,
-0.0323922336,
-0.0260038488,
0.0155399255,
0.0221757423,
0.0370190591,
0.0294179972,
-0.0128162652,
-0.0246865135,
0.0025978179,
0.0254399721,
0.0259991493,
-0.010237827,
0.0258272383,
-0.0034613241,
-0.053461317,
-0.0068417974,
-0.0832315013,
0.0579436608,
0.0455712266,
0.009811976,
-0.0492934808,
-0.0050618048,
0.0104749668,
0.0331863947,
-0.0187248643,
-0.040439982,
0.058923535,
0.0413882881,
0.0049702642,
0.003372475,
-0.0655096918,
-0.053033784,
-0.0129244039,
-0.0151539948,
-0.0418828353,
-0.0087174047,
0.0465835296,
0.0201064218,
-0.0068174172,
0.0225530006,
2.262727673e-34,
0.0605216436,
-0.004163038,
0.0341245085,
0.016186744,
0.0180560965,
-0.0306633208,
-0.0016202126,
0.0091907959,
-0.0206844006,
-0.0095161013,
-0.0150714116
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10231v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10231v1 | OpenSLU: A Unified, Modularized, and Extensible Toolkit for Spoken Language Understanding | 2023-05-17T14:12:29 | 2023-05-17T14:12:29 | Libo Qin, Qiguang Chen, Xiao Xu, Yunlong Feng, Wanxiang Che | cs.CL | cs.CL | Spoken Language Understanding (SLU) is one of the core components of a
task-oriented dialogue system, which aims to extract the semantic meaning of
user queries (e.g., intents and slots). In this work, we introduce OpenSLU, an
open-source toolkit to provide a unified, modularized, and extensible toolkit
for spoken language understanding. Specifically, OpenSLU unifies 10 SLU models
for both single-intent and multi-intent scenarios, which support both
non-pretrained and pretrained models simultaneously. Additionally, OpenSLU is
highly modularized and extensible by decomposing the model architecture,
inference, and learning process into reusable modules, which allows researchers
to quickly set up SLU experiments with highly flexible configurations. OpenSLU
is implemented based on PyTorch, and released at
\url{https://github.com/LightChen233/OpenSLU}. | [
0.0248495657,
0.026155049,
0.0153807225,
0.0450302921,
-0.0134614119,
0.0211558565,
0.0366844237,
-0.0305299908,
-0.0074084201,
-0.0149237514,
-0.0613231249,
-0.015011793,
-0.0118217301,
0.0511013009,
-0.0064468519,
-0.0619445257,
0.0750611052,
-0.0444538817,
0.0124365902,
0.0321809985,
0.0034068099,
0.0387890488,
-0.0580629148,
0.0348025337,
0.0351907797,
-0.0169052538,
-0.0505805239,
0.0314323418,
-0.0109847793,
-0.0165926591,
-0.0108833583,
0.0436614566,
0.0450710207,
0.0555812307,
0.0000019508,
-0.0472723879,
-0.0179238971,
-0.0441133529,
-0.0892287791,
-0.0340557732,
0.0055280784,
0.0217130687,
0.0218420383,
0.0228757374,
-0.0319160745,
-0.0038196645,
0.0002265146,
0.0435184017,
0.0375360213,
0.0466750301,
0.0153049659,
-0.0081590982,
-0.0251656305,
-0.0119171217,
0.0095241815,
-0.0734140649,
-0.0073575964,
-0.0048490218,
0.0077584395,
-0.0124056777,
0.010354368,
0.0407174863,
0.0276332423,
-0.0218976531,
-0.0097089326,
0.0084235165,
-0.0188828502,
-0.0822845325,
-0.034204144,
0.097080037,
-0.0042097108,
-0.0016435068,
-0.0031464845,
-0.022108512,
0.0021181074,
-0.0395097546,
-0.0552178174,
-0.0077162557,
-0.0124342991,
-0.0227290802,
0.0021332554,
0.0136810569,
0.0030366068,
0.0142488722,
-0.0113776503,
0.0676563606,
-0.0000243015,
0.0045937784,
-0.0055702245,
-0.0404121689,
0.0228378326,
-0.0818016678,
-0.0054528611,
0.029771626,
-0.0815925002,
0.036850702,
-0.0284140371,
-0.0382541455,
-0.0049112579,
-0.0076846299,
-0.0085547576,
0.0382517315,
-0.0653438717,
0.0563969128,
0.030417446,
0.0354889557,
0.0127215534,
0.0392139964,
-0.0536764674,
0.0047750594,
-0.0429683477,
0.0119224824,
-0.048917979,
-0.0136354892,
-0.0601951592,
-0.0038374367,
0.0073519861,
0.047449816,
0.0134699512,
0.0109328851,
0.0126355058,
0.0116259549,
-0.0445195884,
0.0078020878,
-0.0250985883,
0.0632820874,
-0.0189025793,
0.0385446735,
-0.0123581532,
-0.0465468504,
-0.0541808046,
0.0418587923,
0.0316468067,
-0.0495312922,
-0.0103483722,
-0.0170875359,
-0.0005055245,
-0.0397647433,
0.00007148,
-0.0057314131,
0.0152333407,
-0.0625427216,
-0.0376395732,
-0.026193982,
0.018385848,
0.0014189584,
-0.0077936854,
-0.0254368149,
0.0024897843,
-0.0143558402,
-0.0006273643,
0.0771919712,
-0.0322545134,
0.0086634811,
0.0164952613,
0.0217748247,
-0.0081163459,
0.0610973388,
-0.0340621322,
0.0474260561,
0.0228191279,
-0.0288248453,
-0.0167463589,
0.0023635991,
0.0110814739,
-0.0438718945,
0.0327766798,
0.0501559377,
0.0189659949,
0.0214679297,
0.0349799506,
0.0088645043,
-0.0439550057,
-0.0216246489,
0.0291181132,
0.0587688088,
0.0233509224,
-0.0225672293,
0.0335537046,
0.0656763092,
0.0167492628,
-0.0199343953,
-0.0623969883,
0.0312179234,
-0.0026474155,
-0.0077231042,
-0.0159067586,
0.0332371183,
-0.0376845114,
-0.0311178584,
-0.0075932993,
-0.0180680677,
0.0149420733,
0.0115787135,
0.0656186119,
0.003262559,
-0.0249306746,
0.0639591068,
0.009183703,
-0.0457356237,
0.0040641064,
-0.0586541407,
0.0540765636,
0.0515777878,
0.028418662,
-0.0320425145,
-0.0585845411,
-0.0480981357,
-0.0484301113,
0.0173959173,
0.0295518208,
-0.0543906353,
0.0910704359,
-0.0551062711,
-0.0090146298,
-0.005835013,
-0.0065888097,
0.0367672853,
-0.0440454632,
-0.0484032519,
0.0070514902,
-0.0389510542,
0.0416777059,
0.0166444071,
-0.0012383822,
-0.015485689,
-0.0249963533,
-0.0068020746,
0.0673766732,
0.0501527078,
-0.0032931347,
-0.0289538577,
0.0146737713,
-0.0026170628,
0.0228362307,
0.0355915576,
-0.0503302924,
-0.0463274829,
0.0245077815,
0.0335523412,
-0.0419660434,
0.0464419723,
-0.0498917885,
-0.0740302876,
0.0376807302,
0.0126416041,
0.0100841569,
-0.0783414394,
-0.0137148052,
0.0074128169,
0.0367317982,
-0.009764079,
0.0196311902,
0.0339109153,
-0.0218144562,
0.0659894869,
0.0059372992,
0.0529585853,
-0.0498995036,
-0.0125094475,
0.0071610166,
-0.0570415482,
-0.0135662491,
-0.0089549934,
0.0282257106,
-0.0737468004,
0.0195248984,
-0.110621646,
-0.0062395944,
-0.0456368849,
0.0248318836,
0.0395637341,
0.05355509,
-0.0264847968,
-0.0576054938,
0.0225605089,
-0.0119836088,
0.0203721393,
-0.0378226191,
0.0031158505,
0.0244146753,
-0.0193969645,
-0.0391315483,
0.0198670737,
0.0059395181,
0.0235274937,
-0.0066856258,
-0.0267094001,
-0.0377795249,
0.0070422138,
-0.0279139113,
0.0320576876,
-0.0059236367,
-0.024553271,
0.0056300387,
-0.0020792654,
0.0075400914,
0.0844322369,
0.0128145702,
0.0226834919,
0.0208945423,
-0.0462405905,
-0.0533224009,
0.0461891741,
-0.0103193037,
0.0136573231,
-0.0364151411,
0.0319285691,
0.0096396664,
0.0836777911,
0.0324902348,
0.0217333287,
-0.0187208802,
-0.0429482535,
-0.0079986081,
-0.0547763668,
-0.0401294939,
0.0154439295,
-0.0316403061,
0.0461185649,
0.0080479831,
-0.0248977896,
0.0628845319,
-0.048423849,
-0.0497365631,
-0.0745448917,
-0.035893824,
-0.0217472035,
0.0801019743,
-0.0260804035,
0.0059274789,
0.0526276194,
-0.0501404777,
-0.010361773,
0.0141371591,
-0.0083955647,
-0.0284669083,
0.0253599137,
-0.0349166319,
0.0085486704,
-0.0381128937,
-0.0247062128,
-0.0552047603,
-0.0550879315,
-0.0456348322,
-0.0062767225,
-0.0205306299,
0.0029502138,
0.0003150619,
0.0300799739,
0.0286936145,
0.0331833027,
-0.0059089139,
0.0307035204,
-0.0213758238,
0.0280597452,
0.0309151132,
0.0421693623,
-0.0115561895,
0.0076336148,
0.0529163182,
0.0248571038,
0.0433376692,
-0.0097480398,
-0.0251223408,
0.0148901166,
0.0396818407,
-0.0087584266,
-0.0218416844,
0.0193634722,
0.0830979124,
-0.0564728864,
-0.0032380384,
0.132643044,
0.0197064746,
-0.0248647109,
-0.0342571586,
-0.051007349,
0.0314284042,
0.0419175923,
0.0273322724,
-0.0933345258,
-0.0791293234,
0.0028330151,
0.0235298146,
0.0268131662,
-0.0090605831,
-0.0090217525,
-0.0489519387,
0.0358098932,
-0.0246119574,
-0.0528099015,
-0.0039443253,
-0.018890122,
0.0293667987,
-0.0421428308,
0.0320152007,
0.0382415056,
0.0205409657,
-0.0088918572,
0.0163766872,
-0.0146625685,
-0.0017319499,
0.0547283702,
-0.004736118,
0.0835574046,
0.0268278532,
0.0426319465,
0.0126989661,
-0.0086351009,
0.0019040208,
-0.0220113434,
-0.0133847268,
-0.0335239545,
0.029033985,
0.0141845476,
-0.0118082063,
-0.0068694879,
0.0387076139,
-0.0473523103,
-0.0141934985,
0.0018685488,
0.0234340206,
-0.0593253896,
0.0070044324,
0.0132876541,
0.0124458279,
0.0450618677,
0.0705132931,
0.0417019613,
-0.0142891034,
-0.0471601374,
-0.0153658465,
-0.0320459232,
-0.0388403684,
0.0215010047,
0.0147691853,
0.0135256182,
-0.0128817186,
0.0066481885,
-0.0424488746,
0.0318398066,
0.0254139509,
-0.0205828436,
0.0130110327,
0.0000965827,
0.0246121716,
-0.0260392185,
0.0618959963,
0.0030180942,
0.0444161557,
-0.0529015251,
-0.0364862941,
0.0259091165,
-0.0695078447,
-0.0382695831,
0.0425109453,
-0.1092044339,
-0.0310493968,
0.016414823,
0.035510838,
0.0297271926,
0.0607499219,
-0.0398433916,
0.0104113668,
-0.0285657588,
-0.0330749564,
-0.0389647186,
-0.0118910624,
0.0464096591,
0.0157363527,
-0.0068753189,
0.0373555534,
-0.0384506546,
0.0345388092,
-0.0464049429,
0.0199754201,
-0.0475312881,
-0.066359818,
0.0097919907,
0.0200201608,
0.0777207911,
0.04552738,
-0.0139948949,
-0.0610649139,
0.0412373655,
0.0314727724,
0.0054742028,
-0.0335356817,
0.0095650675,
0.0052653458,
-0.0420532003,
0.015379346,
-0.0151964398,
-0.0198907591,
0.033810813,
-0.0201542117,
0.0260477792,
0.048422806,
0.0004036468,
0.0015041354,
-0.0413214602,
-0.0248962883,
0.0428496115,
0.0166480467,
0.0592282303,
0.0044541946,
0.1012568325,
-0.0118206516,
-0.0199509319,
0.0282815006,
0.0525023602,
-0.0620444231,
-0.0527539626,
0.0137920091,
0.0017920802,
-0.002639709,
0.0116276434,
0.0479908548,
0.0244109798,
0.0488103814,
-0.0042285905,
0.0606421828,
-0.0168942977,
-0.0091351168,
0.0593836345,
-0.0117885331,
-0.0183585007,
-0.0001828445,
0.0253755413,
-0.0361343734,
0.0252315067,
0.0163131636,
0.0366905443,
-0.0572469011,
-0.0433175974,
-0.0074434648,
0.0421496145,
-0.0450618714,
0.0304257069,
-0.0187595226,
-0.0140117183,
-0.0014358797,
0.0114961518,
0.0050091115,
-0.003624558,
0.0415158197,
0.0525918193,
-0.0247212313,
-0.0139931999,
0.0015176083,
-0.0077006076,
-0.0122998171,
-0.0119941402,
0.0079990197,
-6.333830987e-33,
-0.0572462752,
0.0145099834,
0.0155057553,
-0.0232542828,
-0.0112661282,
-0.0035364185,
-0.0562954396,
-0.0169840679,
-0.0438723415,
-0.0434829332,
0.0140343728,
0.0280661955,
0.0251266062,
0.0334540643,
-0.0217026453,
-0.0341411941,
0.0291137602,
0.0003094584,
-0.0103644533,
0.0321755707,
0.0591258444,
0.053117156,
0.0506491922,
-0.0296940599,
0.0032319119,
0.0281544924,
0.0120790545,
0.0311646294,
-0.0058497153,
0.0335807577,
-0.0048265504,
0.0054475348,
0.0120822061,
-0.0383212976,
-0.015050197,
0.0414613523,
-0.0825014338,
-0.0132642519,
0.033682581,
0.0210743304,
-0.0757075995,
0.0312668011,
-0.006655409,
0.012242876,
0.0282215513,
0.0150976116,
-0.002541302,
0.0198093783,
0.0074750758,
0.0184504278,
-0.0315589979,
0.031278111,
-0.0436794981,
-0.0474187508,
0.0308381189,
0.0657481998,
0.0038067878,
-0.0337599479,
-0.0161895994,
-0.0070142481,
-0.0516536646,
-0.0102954833,
0.0791084096,
0.0308501795,
-0.0282982569,
0.0417484008,
0.0041299434,
-0.0733501911,
-0.0067974892,
0.0119687356,
-0.003557228,
0.0642933771,
-0.0148926983,
-0.0117916046,
-0.020586567,
-0.0157883931,
-0.0236828998,
0.0206078533,
0.0726545453,
0.0417478606,
-0.0014333283,
0.0547337495,
0.0001874537,
0.0108417189,
-0.0362427123,
-0.0136879636,
-0.0268957932,
-0.0030507033,
0.0454644635,
-0.0112571642,
-0.0172534212,
-0.0058009359,
0.0780717134,
-0.0033592859,
0.061304532,
0.0306621902,
0.030038368,
-0.0128141837,
-0.0065355119,
0.0704707503,
-0.0451501161,
-0.021613257,
0.0507738777,
0.0156016992,
-0.0025365767,
0.0044227713,
-0.0245573893,
0.00283485,
0.0123444097,
-0.0056401296,
-0.0421858318,
0.0330125466,
-0.0699181706,
0.0541611016,
0.0513887107,
0.0136073297,
-0.0375015326,
0.0485618524,
-0.004454135,
-0.0357244276,
-0.0600998662,
-0.0666809902,
0.0304497164,
0.0019879988,
-0.0495864674,
-0.0182298888,
-0.015481215,
-0.0538256653,
-0.001178047,
-0.0344983898,
0.0040031737,
0.0258993898,
2.763e-7,
0.0324577466,
0.0219563115,
0.0341119431,
0.0219865162,
0.0067726248,
0.0484884493,
-0.0136960698,
0.0316645131,
0.0022729901,
-0.0158702936,
0.0165328607,
0.0098899296,
0.0233552605,
0.0092449207,
-0.0823697969,
-0.0044140951,
-0.0302613191,
-0.0081121549,
-0.0448760428,
0.0170055199,
0.0646996051,
0.0866377428,
-0.007950725,
-0.0184418,
0.0369081832,
-0.0192925259,
-0.0056899958,
-0.0209051408,
0.0217457581,
0.006280839,
0.0259169694,
-0.0016606802,
0.021632636,
0.0104553346,
0.0156197147,
0.0282352567,
0.0125669511,
0.0443617515,
-0.0223712567,
-0.0734095499,
-0.0270632003,
-0.0114602605,
0.0338484943,
-0.0845144913,
0.0689901859,
-0.0053514247,
-0.0323072374,
-0.0686824173,
0.0000975166,
0.0102102729,
-0.0332012065,
0.0254151132,
0.0205790326,
0.0341898575,
-0.0037054482,
-0.0612742864,
-0.0459946282,
-0.0998547524,
-0.0146722794,
-0.0241336972,
-0.048686374,
-0.0313129984,
-0.0429759175,
-0.0226720572,
0.0276737157,
-0.0528082289,
-0.0324306823,
1.933708411e-34,
0.0298212934,
0.0085848235,
-0.0186750293,
0.0469751991,
0.0362751298,
-0.0238662772,
-0.0354323983,
-0.0165048148,
0.0377082452,
-0.0688561723,
-0.014436163
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10204v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10204v1 | Shielded Representations: Protecting Sensitive Attributes Through Iterative Gradient-Based Projection | 2023-05-17T13:26:57 | 2023-05-17T13:26:57 | Shadi Iskander, Kira Radinsky, Yonatan Belinkov | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Natural language processing models tend to learn and encode social biases
present in the data. One popular approach for addressing such biases is to
eliminate encoded information from the model's representations. However,
current methods are restricted to removing only linearly encoded information.
In this work, we propose Iterative Gradient-Based Projection (IGBP), a novel
method for removing non-linear encoded concepts from neural representations.
Our method consists of iteratively training neural classifiers to predict a
particular attribute we seek to eliminate, followed by a projection of the
representation on a hypersurface, such that the classifiers become oblivious to
the target attribute. We evaluate the effectiveness of our method on the task
of removing gender and race information as sensitive attributes. Our results
demonstrate that IGBP is effective in mitigating bias through intrinsic and
extrinsic evaluations, with minimal impact on downstream task accuracy. | [
0.0031227833,
0.0931438878,
-0.02623461,
0.038675677,
-0.0152815897,
-0.0022780974,
0.0082746986,
-0.0165842716,
-0.0100162458,
-0.0462493859,
-0.0311154574,
-0.0395010747,
0.0248188749,
0.0030989177,
0.0144485915,
-0.0432385504,
0.0335428901,
0.0430635586,
0.0209321696,
-0.054099787,
0.0026820013,
0.030591486,
0.0447183475,
0.0415628441,
-0.013302491,
-0.0467063263,
0.0367120765,
-0.0359718613,
-0.0086204205,
-0.0112363938,
0.0626080632,
0.0330992974,
-0.0176699851,
0.0030881695,
0.0000021286,
-0.0311844535,
-0.0234541483,
0.0222618245,
-0.0218108501,
-0.0023761184,
0.0284266118,
-0.0279808175,
0.0101945018,
-0.0063708695,
-0.0520375818,
-0.024582034,
0.0261128955,
0.0638415143,
0.0455278084,
0.0474112555,
-0.0099107306,
-0.0108054737,
-0.0499024764,
-0.0102748526,
-0.010780016,
-0.0392960794,
0.0155349318,
-0.0821629539,
-0.0757267326,
0.0429926291,
-0.0269022528,
0.0205167215,
-0.0010649485,
0.0400355011,
0.0695919171,
0.0282733161,
-0.0125843836,
-0.0212871544,
0.0042215311,
0.0710351691,
-0.0266167,
0.0051347781,
-0.0096166115,
-0.005967204,
0.0364870988,
-0.0485635027,
0.0195887461,
0.0107382601,
0.0155862737,
0.0256600231,
-0.051776398,
-0.0212178621,
0.0349685475,
0.0184631292,
0.0476654768,
0.05020459,
0.0004776316,
-0.016596524,
-0.0109736957,
-0.0134957777,
0.0098705003,
-0.0194005314,
0.0367436484,
-0.0104104578,
0.0108875483,
-0.0079799118,
-0.0258308388,
-0.0433162674,
-0.0219981726,
-0.0598236993,
0.05127519,
0.0361385643,
0.0200460795,
0.0060198088,
-0.0435809232,
0.0419074111,
-0.0206041019,
0.0244686566,
0.0041572801,
-0.0089302128,
-0.014551905,
-0.0377879329,
-0.0054357671,
0.0617700554,
-0.0445907488,
0.0464106649,
-0.0036891671,
-0.0072132405,
-0.1079580635,
0.0084177628,
-0.0173401386,
0.0740396455,
-0.0305573326,
0.0230728369,
-0.0245704073,
0.0202679504,
-0.0180107877,
0.0059305234,
-0.0485028997,
-0.038620349,
-0.0134735787,
-0.0144290766,
0.0412663408,
-0.0035320409,
0.0002954164,
0.0874097124,
0.0143941827,
-0.0325602442,
-0.0377896205,
-0.017065879,
-0.0016597372,
-0.0493159927,
0.0432078317,
-0.0041674254,
0.0269758012,
-0.032575462,
-0.0272404626,
-0.1102383807,
-0.0086312406,
0.0160325412,
-0.0452746898,
0.1054779962,
0.0363597907,
-0.0282408688,
0.0442060158,
0.0365494303,
-0.0659149662,
0.069078736,
0.0103249578,
0.0285187606,
0.0244493056,
-0.0230903886,
-0.0064206119,
0.0270374678,
0.0459445864,
-0.0263687689,
-0.041305732,
-0.0001909426,
0.0626639351,
-0.0231461897,
0.0570452847,
0.0156886559,
0.0031479907,
-0.0690461844,
0.0717318356,
0.0639452115,
-0.0263845697,
0.0891762823,
-0.0061834487,
0.0282272324,
-0.0173853021,
-0.010495007,
-0.0903490707,
0.005744589,
-0.0416687466,
-0.0721343756,
-0.0280435309,
0.0247089732,
-0.0438875891,
-0.0201941319,
0.0250837468,
-0.0256782304,
0.100196369,
-0.0093608992,
-0.00334772,
0.039488893,
-0.0110314135,
0.0611866377,
0.0309773274,
-0.0179432388,
0.0311739054,
-0.0299025383,
0.0190068614,
0.0239397436,
-0.0053848037,
-0.0482721813,
0.0196831319,
-0.034642648,
-0.023533605,
0.0157741569,
0.0159239415,
-0.0025201954,
0.0813618675,
-0.0233261846,
-0.0342564732,
0.0034046513,
0.0296269115,
0.0349439904,
0.0459040143,
0.0026440583,
0.0228180513,
0.0093694814,
-0.0446057692,
0.0445485339,
0.0123142926,
-0.071345821,
0.0547240973,
0.0068974402,
0.0284916759,
0.0201050919,
0.0191545207,
-0.0111746993,
-0.0175340604,
-0.0043848818,
-0.0402634181,
-0.0134202326,
-0.0464599468,
-0.0185892489,
0.0260306541,
-0.0719477236,
-0.0629672855,
0.0517132394,
-0.0045683254,
0.0065125646,
0.0849998072,
-0.0275952797,
0.0119308885,
0.0022567788,
-0.0108084073,
-0.0180849135,
0.0603954457,
-0.0217520632,
0.0324657224,
0.0016503398,
-0.0380675755,
-0.0139022134,
-0.0552785285,
-0.0310264081,
-0.0355059244,
-0.011855742,
0.0113023063,
0.0197162051,
0.0076569482,
0.0070479251,
-0.0217523221,
-0.023264898,
0.0187023915,
-0.0290005952,
-0.0242962632,
0.0004406289,
-0.0037268712,
-0.0033714685,
0.0072843097,
0.0191961024,
-0.0312447324,
-0.0197546892,
-0.0049226722,
-0.0315765738,
0.0184513424,
0.015103993,
-0.0257820133,
0.0190471299,
-0.0047688372,
-0.0366142094,
-0.0337963216,
0.0756239817,
-0.0329528823,
0.0259861592,
-0.0175854042,
-0.0466188081,
-0.014380944,
0.0664134845,
0.0267788656,
-0.03105928,
-0.0065318132,
0.0125426473,
-0.0097652348,
0.0585953034,
0.0177631509,
0.0260470826,
0.0410133637,
-0.0079052337,
-0.0399904512,
0.003730736,
-0.0459066816,
0.0654865429,
0.0333829746,
-0.0233062766,
-0.030521309,
0.037745662,
0.0528384596,
-0.0332660936,
-0.0675164089,
0.0445720404,
-0.0296833348,
-0.07110589,
-0.0473918431,
-0.0389164351,
-0.0065790964,
-0.0132378228,
-0.0591226183,
-0.0116352858,
0.0576778688,
0.014033529,
0.0177558362,
-0.0223071035,
0.0218093023,
-0.0113773858,
0.0471859314,
0.0013320498,
0.0304830056,
-0.0017157344,
-0.0228859987,
-0.0191909205,
-0.0148184849,
0.0051366957,
-0.0413761213,
-0.0135020195,
-0.0274205729,
-0.0254181474,
0.0102315405,
-0.0385197513,
-0.0508534238,
-0.0818613991,
0.0285573192,
0.0049816174,
-0.0453979895,
0.0020885398,
-0.0064653209,
-0.0162013825,
0.0039893724,
0.0130037693,
-0.032708589,
-0.0062744124,
-0.0168510173,
0.0017886268,
-0.0179689117,
0.0071662711,
0.0020103683,
0.0234172959,
0.0128427595,
0.0525909364,
-0.0090600159,
0.0318340808,
-0.0098300055,
0.0353071839,
0.0227824878,
-0.0122226207,
-0.0193658099,
-0.0226643588,
0.0397628546,
-0.0405801274,
0.0041052615,
0.0892436728,
-0.0097668571,
-0.048702348,
0.0269435998,
0.0091037815,
0.0045074313,
0.0226972457,
-0.012093151,
-0.057111118,
-0.0017673795,
0.005377972,
-0.0091554541,
-0.0197924525,
-0.0444973968,
-0.0085490393,
-0.0857815519,
-0.0119507844,
0.0116103105,
-0.0459956117,
-0.0355752595,
-0.0396551378,
0.0264919344,
-0.004539771,
0.0463333763,
-0.0350173898,
0.0218931604,
-0.0060683582,
-0.0052491939,
-0.036700476,
-0.0270794537,
0.0286578536,
-0.0265208147,
0.0089999726,
0.0395677648,
0.0745355934,
-0.0258698035,
-0.022899583,
-0.0017334803,
0.0367678553,
0.005653623,
-0.025813885,
0.0713531226,
-0.0277593788,
-0.0291604027,
0.0017100365,
0.0453699604,
0.0076389029,
0.0035892704,
-0.0083025489,
0.041338753,
-0.0079138791,
-0.0054974705,
-0.0028454857,
-0.0511113852,
0.0082129985,
0.0774771124,
0.020300772,
-0.0670485124,
0.0013687378,
-0.0472126678,
0.0237799119,
0.0201505981,
-0.0379048921,
0.0511695109,
0.0156928748,
-0.028550908,
-0.0273693819,
-0.0397704989,
-0.0084757581,
-0.0119712362,
0.0310381912,
-0.0664865375,
0.0521320142,
-0.0060400735,
-0.0737179592,
0.042394381,
-0.0273879878,
-0.0025716831,
0.0627799705,
0.0044488478,
0.0030828153,
-0.0469587669,
-0.0319419503,
0.0248642042,
0.004444282,
-0.074023962,
0.0518754274,
0.0285084751,
0.0067083067,
0.0539775752,
-0.0323279761,
-0.0850125924,
0.0653887615,
0.032578446,
-0.0099512869,
0.0240651593,
0.0391676649,
-0.0002098181,
-0.0058855689,
0.0446102321,
0.0127418721,
0.0456511378,
0.0484246574,
-0.0345495865,
0.0121087618,
-0.0251442399,
-0.0019891972,
-0.0052296347,
0.0481843539,
0.005888164,
0.0061453339,
-0.0139565608,
-0.0292526297,
-0.0538891628,
-0.0165135078,
0.004593215,
-0.0072034718,
0.0389405005,
0.0211121254,
-0.0273135677,
-0.0282711051,
0.0215755943,
0.0229105745,
-0.0573909804,
0.0082776947,
0.004158752,
0.0019909458,
-0.0288411193,
0.0538022444,
0.0056075365,
0.0411981903,
-0.0060837562,
-0.020974027,
-0.0021509442,
0.0125697209,
0.0229120906,
0.026726285,
-0.0801757723,
-0.0013784232,
-0.0308976993,
0.020815568,
-0.0184570905,
0.0133230397,
-0.0041783033,
-0.0147918472,
-0.0061695133,
0.0262546465,
-0.0342137404,
0.0027849101,
-0.0040966431,
-0.0091025503,
-0.0080222478,
0.0595180951,
0.0052841585,
0.0017444238,
-0.0040274747,
0.0546345562,
-0.0153389778,
0.0567915402,
-0.0516772382,
-0.0318812802,
-0.0498600155,
-0.0090114139,
0.032057941,
0.0521915257,
-0.0129494816,
0.0199566782,
-0.0410753787,
-0.064445734,
0.0038445094,
-0.0322153196,
0.0253568888,
0.003686286,
0.0387446024,
-0.0013693238,
-0.0165843312,
-0.0624512918,
-0.0037469645,
-0.0026516872,
0.0021049178,
-0.0059063844,
-0.0192686841,
-6.62612427e-33,
0.0033865869,
-0.0126708662,
-0.0601354241,
0.02320843,
-0.0055688014,
0.0324237719,
0.0101942364,
-0.011811805,
-0.0006726603,
0.0213246439,
-0.0197253544,
0.0466727503,
0.0080387341,
0.0078494269,
-0.0089067062,
-0.0000698921,
0.069730483,
-0.0136714382,
-0.0099997092,
0.0073249992,
0.0107603325,
0.0468259752,
0.0760606825,
-0.1009242535,
0.0573958606,
0.0349116847,
-0.0400898308,
0.0119470945,
0.010620716,
0.0220627878,
-0.067999348,
0.0596954376,
0.0347821862,
-0.0673994124,
0.0055786786,
0.0793434978,
-0.1114594713,
-0.0298270546,
-0.0297808889,
0.0412554331,
-0.0204299185,
-0.0609666556,
0.0579357669,
-0.0062273201,
-0.0424922593,
-0.0301847421,
0.0373019688,
0.0045001875,
0.0415265262,
0.0396756418,
-0.0363479108,
0.0147736082,
-0.0204049665,
0.0355065353,
0.04679868,
-0.0267032664,
-0.0049626334,
0.0052854829,
-0.0950793102,
-0.0143525079,
-0.0621252283,
-0.0054370225,
0.004403058,
0.0341252759,
0.0446029902,
0.0592217557,
0.0811270177,
0.03767699,
-0.0156354345,
-0.0495679677,
0.0460564904,
-0.0409264937,
0.0312701613,
0.0518232062,
0.0459930561,
-0.0502618812,
-0.063756004,
-0.0077427896,
-0.0331377611,
0.0051063513,
0.0248404145,
-0.0000979331,
-0.0383366607,
-0.0195992049,
-0.0513794683,
-0.0541768633,
-0.0190572757,
-0.0219077542,
-0.0060583227,
-0.0099299802,
-0.0388022996,
0.0687543452,
-0.0218737721,
-0.0620124415,
-0.0032686316,
0.028312115,
0.0203185566,
-0.0169317368,
0.0530307926,
-0.0228830911,
-0.0279712137,
0.0017153255,
-0.014905123,
-0.0023636066,
0.0435792282,
0.0106016714,
0.0229575206,
0.0355661623,
-0.0450407676,
-0.0123469504,
-0.0404921658,
0.0135389762,
0.0282688327,
0.0757001266,
0.0469102673,
0.0276323762,
-0.00813244,
0.0048517543,
0.0646819696,
0.0726145133,
-0.0179481637,
0.0214871764,
0.0200357661,
0.029551575,
-0.0156353042,
-0.0419783257,
0.0113302143,
-0.0113763744,
0.0506610163,
-0.0775508881,
-0.0108874487,
-0.0446553081,
2.775e-7,
-0.0197103396,
0.0557366833,
0.0133889336,
-0.0001132153,
0.0306303222,
0.0591564104,
0.055114083,
0.0642773733,
-0.0048230267,
-0.0118968859,
-0.0207158569,
0.0524474643,
-0.0128737986,
0.0383272879,
-0.0768208653,
-0.0081354463,
-0.0213585701,
-0.0073336973,
0.0030297204,
0.0252404138,
0.0240650345,
0.0820832476,
0.0624760166,
-0.0186298322,
-0.0300239939,
0.009178984,
0.0429687724,
-0.0035396405,
0.0215601251,
0.000292683,
-0.0023714975,
0.0284113102,
0.0166255608,
0.0478265285,
-0.003751016,
0.0324560441,
0.0193935763,
0.022473326,
-0.0484501496,
-0.0194169413,
-0.0093115326,
0.0080799796,
-0.027221838,
-0.0333906338,
0.0554963648,
-0.0131548261,
-0.0843465403,
-0.0498433746,
-0.018519586,
0.0182415862,
0.0510903373,
0.0138683142,
-0.0105136354,
-0.0160875432,
-0.0078324378,
-0.0097384937,
-0.0206095669,
-0.1006058156,
-0.0284584723,
-0.013026746,
-0.0359947719,
-0.0190851074,
0.020277055,
0.0520706251,
0.0409495421,
-0.0774676725,
0.0431496613,
2.052127758e-34,
-0.0342196897,
0.0003379078,
0.0038665005,
-0.00416697,
0.0005520642,
-0.0094700875,
-0.0169657823,
-0.0282040294,
0.0585608371,
-0.0230948627,
-0.0161909107
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10196v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10196v1 | A Survey on Zero Pronoun Translation | 2023-05-17T13:19:01 | 2023-05-17T13:19:01 | Longyue Wang, Siyou Liu, Mingzhou Xu, Linfeng Song, Shuming Shi, Zhaopeng Tu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Zero pronouns (ZPs) are frequently omitted in pro-drop languages (e.g.
Chinese, Hungarian, and Hindi), but should be recalled in non-pro-drop
languages (e.g. English). This phenomenon has been studied extensively in
machine translation (MT), as it poses a significant challenge for MT systems
due to the difficulty in determining the correct antecedent for the pronoun.
This survey paper highlights the major works that have been undertaken in zero
pronoun translation (ZPT) after the neural revolution, so that researchers can
recognise the current state and future directions of this field. We provide an
organisation of the literature based on evolution, dataset, method and
evaluation. In addition, we compare and analyze competing models and evaluation
metrics on different benchmarks. We uncover a number of insightful findings
such as: 1) ZPT is in line with the development trend of large language model;
2) data limitation causes learning bias in languages and domains; 3)
performance improvements are often reported on single benchmarks, but advanced
methods are still far from real-world use; 4) general-purpose metrics are not
reliable on nuances and complexities of ZPT, emphasizing the necessity of
targeted metrics; 5) apart from commonly-cited errors, ZPs will cause risks of
gender bias. | [
0.0600896776,
0.0354891084,
0.0135460505,
0.0509315357,
-0.0232035518,
-0.0078899721,
0.0410208739,
-0.0250192508,
-0.0250398796,
-0.0377995186,
-0.0298185032,
-0.0505325124,
0.0355004705,
-0.0087287007,
0.0215788968,
-0.0122099165,
-0.0005008735,
0.0678095594,
0.0170175806,
-0.015430578,
-0.0044273953,
0.0007323443,
-0.01035308,
0.0278758761,
-0.0264044032,
-0.0200734958,
-0.0123716043,
0.0645606741,
0.0132172536,
0.0078045735,
0.0168683715,
0.0174629968,
-0.0414238945,
0.0840958059,
0.0000021715,
-0.0532931089,
-0.0118712457,
-0.0084459977,
-0.0102276327,
-0.0367420316,
0.0414371565,
-0.0277308729,
-0.0417808816,
-0.0039563184,
-0.0196873099,
-0.0268963035,
0.0698901564,
0.0463217348,
0.0156825036,
0.108817786,
-0.0264726505,
0.0117799621,
-0.0215699468,
-0.0387632884,
-0.0014248454,
-0.0300704036,
0.0011989503,
-0.090792045,
-0.0629533604,
0.0017871049,
-0.0405098759,
0.0574850924,
0.0029925061,
-0.0204224512,
-0.0133276619,
0.0420739762,
-0.022144258,
-0.0717360079,
-0.0018529487,
0.0959776342,
-0.0037667302,
0.011619797,
0.0184390806,
0.0000882545,
-0.0089786686,
-0.040963009,
-0.0157167558,
0.0741545856,
0.0399160683,
0.0000282472,
0.0053169997,
0.0198628474,
0.0047809896,
0.0070243138,
-0.0347902291,
0.0628397986,
0.0172643512,
-0.0645743087,
0.045127891,
0.0107084103,
-0.0046477546,
-0.0481408164,
0.0113710454,
-0.0029481794,
0.0374077298,
0.0054660039,
-0.0050965012,
-0.0420447625,
-0.0150431935,
-0.0443596579,
0.0190618653,
0.049663309,
0.0003138916,
0.0036592896,
-0.0402887762,
0.054494191,
0.0096244253,
-0.0043618605,
-0.068204239,
-0.0313355587,
-0.0128392698,
0.0099402303,
-0.0112802414,
0.0488852151,
-0.0705162287,
-0.005474594,
-0.0322086178,
-0.000934221,
0.0105455723,
-0.006593782,
-0.0133776935,
0.025467569,
-0.0514674075,
-0.013542993,
0.0191450585,
0.1204874739,
-0.0330520906,
-0.0108949468,
-0.031128116,
-0.0880562887,
-0.0291679967,
0.0612075627,
-0.0025173693,
-0.0149794277,
-0.0453326069,
0.0504344963,
-0.0362102687,
-0.0365765691,
0.0005627508,
-0.0194000471,
-0.0542970672,
-0.0883795694,
-0.0082276734,
-0.0134687899,
-0.0031807225,
0.0065003233,
0.0417466946,
-0.0788383037,
0.0168847851,
0.0276048724,
-0.0197912604,
0.032991454,
-0.0001357466,
-0.0070744799,
0.0160958227,
0.0262749791,
0.0225306582,
0.0632950738,
0.04339936,
0.0202164818,
0.0191773176,
0.0388721377,
-0.0026551378,
0.0140390759,
0.0427429788,
0.014995683,
-0.0227406565,
-0.0188493449,
0.0054694624,
0.0426632985,
0.0589250587,
0.0172123015,
0.0155264838,
-0.0407950841,
0.057454627,
0.0531096011,
0.015837485,
0.0500798523,
0.0399027988,
0.0105378618,
0.0019205662,
-0.0096425489,
-0.0340977758,
0.0084016426,
-0.0277708024,
-0.0137130767,
0.0140756434,
-0.0268324967,
-0.0289516915,
-0.0209115762,
0.0054833475,
-0.0344268195,
0.0198652167,
-0.0430588908,
0.0337412916,
0.0148999291,
-0.0194309223,
0.0292358696,
-0.0015426802,
-0.0881007984,
-0.0014408539,
-0.0098502059,
0.0010266961,
-0.0152779147,
-0.0005430268,
-0.011700592,
-0.0210118312,
-0.0165857039,
0.0038330043,
0.0602659062,
0.0305937584,
0.0268299133,
0.0821146965,
-0.0531700961,
-0.0040445034,
0.0198891405,
0.0227117427,
0.0013697706,
-0.0005110166,
0.0617168844,
0.0718443841,
0.0052002002,
-0.0375925191,
0.0247725938,
-0.0024752647,
-0.0317969061,
0.0811921582,
0.0331636518,
0.0318464525,
0.0330698527,
-0.0056459662,
-0.0013957593,
0.0403593071,
-0.0255468413,
-0.0437559374,
0.0115496777,
-0.0527839474,
-0.0607861131,
0.0117094843,
-0.082478933,
-0.0166355893,
0.0439933985,
-0.0092360107,
-0.065544486,
0.0361414962,
0.0038299516,
-0.0195809938,
-0.0458063595,
0.0309425276,
0.0178908445,
0.0296628643,
-0.0228732787,
0.0156118618,
0.0072173066,
-0.0056863162,
0.0169964172,
0.0139019601,
0.0485884696,
-0.0685023665,
-0.0616128966,
0.0129816914,
-0.0152837392,
0.0450863838,
0.035553433,
0.0216213968,
-0.0112539064,
-0.0179832913,
-0.068036966,
0.0122235436,
-0.0192429051,
0.0168643091,
-0.0009199232,
0.0540779047,
-0.0056089684,
-0.0209798366,
-0.0051554949,
0.0179046299,
-0.0081310207,
0.0033408741,
0.0300085489,
-0.0201192088,
0.0448486805,
-0.0040835286,
0.0062188567,
-0.0394691043,
0.0212586056,
0.0393374898,
-0.0144800637,
0.0089890892,
0.0106896283,
-0.0661431849,
-0.0149915479,
0.0055024056,
-0.0390808284,
-0.009843274,
0.0048131188,
0.0192967299,
0.0747631192,
-0.0493840389,
0.0219696015,
0.0047455379,
-0.0107067619,
-0.0477942377,
0.0055951602,
-0.0129332859,
-0.0321171395,
0.0165653359,
-0.0357331112,
0.0022937628,
0.0581570752,
0.027086148,
-0.0375455618,
-0.0507717542,
-0.0028052572,
-0.0507242978,
-0.0350684784,
0.0022399982,
0.0435514748,
0.0057103531,
0.0294813979,
-0.0359507762,
-0.0235717464,
0.0564429909,
-0.0213717259,
-0.0478008017,
-0.0207650233,
0.0065773232,
-0.0623635538,
0.0148461265,
-0.0327444412,
0.025554575,
0.0561568663,
-0.0255417265,
-0.0147199426,
-0.0166902915,
-0.0419354998,
-0.0068171564,
0.0161480624,
-0.054400757,
0.0284628291,
-0.0507945307,
-0.0221032929,
-0.0089556798,
-0.0266940854,
0.0010894153,
0.0086765038,
-0.0383195393,
-0.029066259,
0.0034393924,
0.0069719427,
0.0126679307,
0.0279576164,
-0.038764257,
0.0049966015,
-0.0397821702,
0.0078132339,
-0.0103020454,
-0.0009338236,
-0.0116622699,
-0.035335239,
0.0035063231,
0.0362453721,
0.0351112857,
0.0471155941,
-0.0114618093,
-0.006770649,
0.0130062494,
-0.016612215,
-0.0303447992,
0.0007803866,
0.0355804227,
-0.0369543247,
0.0150143811,
0.1243994609,
0.0142715294,
-0.0621855892,
-0.0172051825,
-0.0232676324,
0.0276502371,
0.0107435035,
0.0008319477,
-0.0887883008,
-0.0301318336,
0.0003087487,
0.0110113649,
0.000005277,
-0.0460949577,
-0.0366323665,
-0.1146514416,
-0.0094971778,
0.0165137239,
-0.0569089912,
-0.0452044867,
-0.0122377351,
-0.0005597734,
-0.0595926642,
-0.0132012246,
-0.0052123568,
0.001011601,
-0.0345638804,
0.0022912226,
0.0088933809,
-0.0276737008,
0.0028118864,
-0.0592875481,
0.0505933017,
0.054155983,
0.078911975,
0.0064676772,
0.0200667251,
0.0229474176,
-0.0426921844,
-0.0115802232,
-0.0421182439,
0.0287292581,
-0.0454600826,
-0.0108483676,
0.0034458307,
0.0318242796,
0.0046644555,
0.0696472824,
0.0251300205,
0.0412532873,
0.0142544415,
-0.0287203211,
0.0072368439,
0.0099543817,
0.0274172705,
0.0738276765,
0.0164866708,
-0.0527931936,
-0.0597378276,
-0.0345792361,
-0.0048335181,
-0.0023217492,
-0.0260096453,
-0.0251206048,
-0.013320677,
-0.0733351931,
-0.0471591763,
-0.0960211307,
0.0337436572,
0.0215073042,
0.0286031626,
-0.0321385674,
0.0310201347,
-0.0275986288,
-0.0072254837,
0.0117211128,
-0.0740184337,
0.0259559881,
-0.0395242609,
0.0437101535,
0.0229945723,
-0.0086454814,
0.035062246,
0.003303654,
-0.0348913223,
-0.05765884,
-0.0168390814,
0.0526078418,
0.0211891141,
0.0382501036,
-0.0463408381,
-0.0572738163,
0.0487833358,
0.0259010084,
0.004907609,
0.0287582502,
0.0604881346,
0.0053294478,
-0.0080784289,
0.0743954554,
0.0317858569,
-0.0082458416,
0.0109160766,
0.0464627519,
-0.0189685449,
-0.061951071,
0.0258399565,
-0.0169438105,
0.0149482451,
-0.0044491263,
0.0146297608,
-0.0400386229,
0.0074729961,
-0.0409071222,
-0.0179821569,
-0.0190162789,
-0.0127670122,
0.0657782704,
0.0351786874,
0.0041471231,
-0.032991603,
-0.0528848991,
0.0119618624,
-0.0062764203,
-0.0191263855,
0.0227821805,
0.0604056269,
-0.0116810827,
0.0176013913,
-0.0015828854,
0.0273553338,
0.0158928484,
0.0146546708,
-0.0084378328,
0.0338536091,
0.0094730593,
0.0206015222,
-0.0057926527,
-0.0163375512,
0.0038333365,
0.0666130111,
0.0090933526,
-0.0124486983,
0.0610929839,
0.0013755517,
0.1004044861,
0.0080071641,
-0.0001782954,
-0.0188270789,
0.0340379141,
-0.0080373632,
0.0060304794,
-0.0303203017,
-0.0144803142,
0.0120279351,
0.0566691384,
0.0394565687,
0.0606668517,
-0.0039435844,
-0.0108100772,
0.0017307012,
-0.0300601907,
0.0071253683,
-0.0067826863,
-0.0464474969,
-0.0291141793,
0.0172689278,
-0.0864085183,
-0.0572188869,
0.0201920941,
-0.0363547765,
0.0376251638,
-0.0197529271,
0.0016489665,
0.0348293148,
-0.0316138268,
-0.0265078396,
-0.0739747435,
0.0044053942,
0.0270623099,
-0.001110137,
-0.0661916658,
-7.069816816e-33,
-0.04557807,
-0.0249960627,
0.0003384873,
0.0051637129,
-0.0530957468,
0.0126815289,
-0.0605770312,
-0.0087468149,
-0.0015173106,
0.0286121368,
-0.0216176528,
0.0149989966,
0.0179960523,
0.0113328788,
-0.000459753,
0.0077394336,
0.0527923405,
0.0265046563,
-0.0538595133,
-0.0081262672,
0.0384338424,
0.0400277972,
0.0573611781,
-0.0662457719,
0.0719771683,
-0.0337267481,
-0.0398225263,
0.0329448842,
-0.0042321188,
-0.0176947676,
0.0163994189,
0.0350786373,
0.0203070808,
-0.0527911745,
0.0208419915,
0.0271878112,
-0.1120432541,
-0.0191345513,
0.0011126072,
0.0132295983,
-0.001894827,
-0.0448957086,
0.0564183593,
-0.004604362,
-0.0184407718,
0.023726467,
0.0329238698,
0.0236173049,
0.0035749823,
0.027019769,
-0.0714544877,
0.010754047,
-0.0318565108,
-0.0241566673,
0.0218989085,
0.0484631956,
-0.0317049399,
-0.0314807631,
-0.1103027016,
0.0139272856,
-0.0269561317,
0.0147361876,
0.0196563341,
0.0262490511,
-0.0108079929,
-0.0292467773,
0.0568674318,
0.0061285184,
-0.0090493038,
-0.0071170167,
0.0479889885,
-0.0551556423,
0.0306144357,
-0.0023014939,
0.0226268191,
0.0067633442,
-0.062310379,
0.0000078856,
-0.0030167976,
0.0169622917,
-0.0048001842,
-0.0207360592,
-0.0418109857,
-0.0436740294,
0.0006333775,
-0.0838846639,
-0.0318460949,
-0.0166221485,
0.0116157914,
0.0126668811,
-0.0701147243,
0.0305658262,
0.0281483531,
-0.0260038283,
0.0170928873,
-0.0101056742,
0.0129806371,
0.0047925124,
0.010345743,
0.0389097556,
-0.0915821493,
0.0096606417,
-0.004087151,
0.0399655476,
0.0226194672,
-0.024055155,
0.0479320474,
0.0156168137,
-0.0339338928,
-0.0308170393,
-0.0487462617,
-0.0077129165,
-0.0166002251,
0.0817059204,
-0.014530696,
0.0346542597,
-0.0130785406,
0.0175801814,
0.0580276325,
0.0347670838,
-0.0428862311,
0.0125055229,
0.0399527811,
0.0042255162,
-0.0541475452,
0.0200385805,
-0.0042893752,
0.051020667,
0.0571567491,
-0.048725199,
-0.0235006809,
-0.0087905088,
2.907e-7,
0.0142376926,
0.0251443256,
0.0408107638,
-0.0168974008,
-0.0136982072,
0.0631546453,
-0.0114331553,
0.0463157445,
0.0239259508,
0.0894327536,
0.0103423782,
0.0468558557,
0.0652064905,
-0.0187457167,
-0.1114766821,
0.0181457177,
-0.0101770069,
0.0132518029,
-0.0394324958,
0.0381165408,
0.0102276523,
0.0590427704,
0.0331091434,
0.0123808552,
-0.0273897741,
0.0274403803,
0.0534618646,
0.0566817559,
-0.0061247395,
0.0398633257,
0.0676820651,
0.030711554,
-0.033203911,
-0.0103447018,
0.0086040637,
0.0276213605,
0.0417109951,
0.0640421808,
-0.0207038093,
-0.0143348286,
0.0388832279,
0.0038584108,
0.0003935511,
0.0164694469,
0.0763893276,
-0.0399008319,
-0.0270029288,
0.0499870442,
0.0169632286,
0.062300045,
0.0680408254,
-0.0347082354,
-0.0528296754,
0.0008949949,
0.0318903662,
-0.0261435732,
-0.0494555347,
-0.0289544705,
-0.0430551097,
-0.0445492156,
0.0248980001,
-0.025613483,
0.0141864102,
0.0138733638,
0.0115609579,
-0.0359804295,
0.0026819403,
2.498995609e-34,
-0.0019688655,
-0.0110452799,
0.0134988232,
-0.0170445032,
0.014129417,
-0.0005137209,
-0.0280656163,
-0.0176750198,
0.0039892988,
-0.0139778033,
-0.0348789692
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10195v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10195v1 | Boosting Distress Support Dialogue Responses with Motivational Interviewing Strategy | 2023-05-17T13:18:28 | 2023-05-17T13:18:28 | Anuradha Welivita, Pearl Pu | cs.CL | cs.CL | AI-driven chatbots have become an emerging solution to address psychological
distress. Due to the lack of psychotherapeutic data, researchers use dialogues
scraped from online peer support forums to train them. But since the responses
in such platforms are not given by professionals, they contain both conforming
and non-conforming responses. In this work, we attempt to recognize these
conforming and non-conforming response types present in online distress-support
dialogues using labels adapted from a well-established behavioral coding scheme
named Motivational Interviewing Treatment Integrity (MITI) code and show how
some response types could be rephrased into a more MI adherent form that can,
in turn, enable chatbot responses to be more compliant with the MI strategy. As
a proof of concept, we build several rephrasers by fine-tuning Blender and GPT3
to rephrase MI non-adherent "Advise without permission" responses into "Advise
with permission". We show how this can be achieved with the construction of
pseudo-parallel corpora avoiding costs for human labor. Through automatic and
human evaluation we show that in the presence of less training data, techniques
such as prompting and data augmentation can be used to produce substantially
good rephrasings that reflect the intended style and preserve the content of
the original text. | [
0.1201928034,
0.0344388373,
-0.043588046,
-0.0141933914,
-0.034802597,
0.0123628732,
0.0007379897,
0.0248714816,
0.0549392961,
-0.0216869395,
-0.0179412514,
0.0041171103,
0.0058867629,
0.0395815372,
-0.0187444799,
-0.0800050944,
-0.0125086801,
0.035760425,
0.0900233611,
0.0199663751,
0.0448188633,
0.0390076935,
-0.0252255443,
0.0698693767,
-0.036226213,
-0.0339185074,
0.0141700571,
0.0299514309,
0.0055671972,
-0.0471604131,
0.0366557539,
0.0361855924,
-0.0159833748,
0.0163111668,
0.0000021807,
-0.0171230473,
-0.0298100803,
0.0166105051,
-0.0005765032,
-0.0512257516,
0.0697913766,
-0.0560136102,
-0.0172548778,
0.0399489105,
-0.0426302627,
-0.009689088,
0.081851244,
0.0555501767,
0.1163918301,
0.0886407048,
-0.0415462516,
0.0336621627,
0.0193713922,
0.0122230165,
-0.0197783671,
0.0154274907,
-0.0020815872,
0.0155330636,
0.0589916781,
0.0026542167,
-0.0029556483,
0.0362073593,
-0.0104471967,
-0.0177087113,
0.0100719789,
-0.0074366336,
-0.0158517268,
-0.0689288527,
-0.0076434072,
0.0721593946,
0.045328632,
0.0189187415,
-0.0062442943,
-0.0060602883,
0.0402938761,
0.0238830075,
-0.0390716456,
0.0239195917,
-0.0267517213,
-0.0089333178,
0.0067888238,
0.0134447478,
-0.033091031,
-0.0280584544,
0.0234116502,
-0.0097832726,
-0.0076140342,
-0.0399269536,
-0.007716699,
-0.0096789831,
-0.0063033416,
-0.0909786597,
0.0104664061,
0.0259902887,
-0.0585035905,
0.0043823635,
-0.0601981506,
-0.0402605161,
0.0097079799,
-0.0103870416,
-0.002683073,
0.0498329625,
-0.0241012052,
-0.0266977344,
0.0367629454,
0.0373823494,
0.0330157876,
0.0255797412,
-0.0370004363,
0.0267040487,
-0.0674585626,
-0.0219184849,
-0.0632091835,
0.0267636329,
-0.0328930803,
-0.0072832131,
-0.0453432463,
0.049990356,
-0.0277661011,
-0.0047124466,
-0.0379129685,
-0.0131882466,
-0.0259399191,
0.0322809406,
0.0025277818,
0.000575261,
-0.0288892556,
-0.0008971499,
0.0211750288,
-0.0909363031,
0.020372197,
0.009691176,
-0.0154355578,
-0.0224050768,
0.0183646679,
0.0697108507,
-0.0242647137,
-0.0130532477,
0.0092137652,
-0.0345827118,
-0.0537984334,
-0.0133957695,
0.0092802905,
-0.0132970791,
0.0322179534,
-0.0138909668,
-0.0101953307,
-0.0581345409,
0.0248963181,
0.0111150863,
-0.0620302558,
0.0666763633,
-0.0633708313,
-0.0035654947,
0.0177074764,
0.021393409,
-0.0059157023,
0.0112515688,
0.0344899222,
0.0249071997,
0.0601057112,
-0.0386841707,
0.0473328792,
-0.0165593866,
-0.001189606,
-0.0097147804,
0.0247347355,
-0.0027193807,
-0.0229085069,
0.0535923168,
-0.0160560962,
0.0625628978,
-0.0347634554,
-0.0120090898,
0.0520680808,
0.0649338737,
-0.0201266855,
0.0542108566,
0.003955082,
0.0384118147,
0.0098179309,
0.0164953601,
-0.0324389637,
0.0043760845,
0.0047528041,
-0.0217948016,
0.0109557239,
-0.0009605225,
-0.01366843,
-0.0590321943,
-0.0067061125,
-0.0059501897,
0.0340041146,
0.0093706166,
-0.0331627354,
0.0299831238,
-0.0074225483,
-0.0532871075,
0.0095942216,
-0.0416847654,
-0.0726182088,
-0.0746508241,
0.0087526795,
0.078141883,
0.0567558184,
-0.0295179915,
-0.0355546512,
-0.0391984731,
0.0042536664,
0.0376319103,
0.0363941565,
-0.0136849256,
0.0088263946,
-0.019511668,
-0.0095524723,
-0.0022654724,
-0.0301895291,
0.0000299669,
-0.0168166906,
-0.0068005444,
-0.0451153442,
0.0069805719,
-0.0441701114,
0.0548094623,
0.0291114319,
-0.0368794091,
0.0256901309,
0.0104705961,
0.0666720569,
0.0346022174,
-0.0050528701,
0.0059919916,
0.0090449005,
-0.0114587536,
-0.0267230775,
0.0470077358,
-0.0222080369,
-0.0445872843,
0.0207497496,
-0.0339160785,
-0.0208202433,
0.0443834774,
-0.01716711,
-0.0098096961,
0.0087552452,
-0.0612705648,
0.0583078228,
-0.0066319564,
0.008087487,
0.0086396392,
0.018544253,
-0.0437256545,
-0.0178742483,
0.0031896222,
-0.0066214683,
0.0158952456,
-0.0223028213,
-0.0149107836,
-0.0177651215,
0.014827447,
0.0328239389,
-0.0238931272,
-0.0166881979,
0.0093656313,
0.0436693653,
-0.0425026193,
-0.0350359753,
-0.0994323641,
-0.0157216955,
-0.0147729963,
-0.0101491362,
0.0135655971,
-0.0054918206,
-0.0235398114,
-0.021368796,
-0.0462181307,
-0.0099371625,
0.0228323508,
0.0300534163,
0.0476090834,
0.0233725421,
-0.0284235943,
-0.0253512505,
-0.005127579,
-0.0206664186,
-0.0118347025,
0.0376684889,
-0.0197640304,
-0.0581665337,
-0.0247390885,
-0.0494147427,
0.0018572704,
0.0013945549,
-0.0706416741,
0.0433321707,
0.0080708573,
0.0738218278,
0.0397838168,
0.0425979719,
0.0671858639,
0.001544117,
0.0341970697,
-0.0401607342,
0.0070605143,
0.008552934,
-0.0476761907,
-0.0095636966,
-0.0952612981,
0.0573391505,
0.0260650031,
0.0433049537,
0.0307398234,
-0.0865478292,
-0.0011429398,
0.0264574513,
-0.0276361369,
0.0064697545,
-0.0119168544,
0.0086390683,
-0.0024494592,
0.0083248066,
-0.0525198691,
0.0979417786,
-0.00694854,
-0.0408088751,
-0.0401434861,
-0.0751492754,
-0.0065271379,
0.0243768096,
-0.0189704429,
0.0350238644,
0.0955477208,
-0.0276852287,
0.0044002086,
-0.0240899064,
0.0122467438,
-0.0359326638,
-0.0595294051,
-0.0596467778,
-0.0058584171,
0.0256448742,
-0.0385824367,
-0.045543503,
-0.100497812,
0.0171288997,
-0.0215571783,
0.0328130387,
0.0057443911,
-0.0171433296,
-0.0180164669,
0.0400104262,
0.0471162945,
-0.0033416043,
-0.0331685916,
-0.0012710214,
-0.0039927936,
0.0159407537,
0.0021812485,
0.0101406667,
-0.0044779941,
0.033871945,
0.0735311583,
0.0157464854,
0.0160207581,
0.0084237661,
-0.0167493522,
-0.0059171058,
0.0102429744,
0.0029854304,
0.0023678232,
0.0524999537,
-0.009436504,
-0.0408531502,
0.0890268609,
0.0301514324,
-0.0469888933,
0.0228047054,
-0.0378303938,
0.0333865359,
0.0051052575,
0.008992603,
-0.0558211952,
0.004511897,
-0.0200672597,
0.0764064789,
-0.06701684,
-0.0223670639,
-0.0008301862,
-0.0563524403,
0.0415641516,
-0.0087771146,
-0.0155323343,
-0.0467983894,
0.0003028361,
0.0068996516,
0.0296811946,
-0.0141333416,
-0.0414308906,
0.0206499025,
0.0257741753,
0.0173621345,
-0.0535763688,
-0.0346373171,
0.0045921742,
0.0034966564,
0.1106196865,
0.0473909453,
0.0496132299,
0.0191082302,
-0.0122701162,
0.0016380691,
0.0377338342,
0.0023432223,
0.0071913055,
0.0601469167,
-0.0164175648,
0.0149946678,
-0.0157772955,
0.0666500852,
-0.0353903547,
-0.0144964298,
0.0296133161,
0.0371942893,
-0.0413852632,
0.016560277,
-0.0160744768,
0.0358376168,
0.0812425837,
0.0359905325,
0.0508717671,
-0.0285002012,
0.0022500458,
-0.0290424246,
0.040317595,
0.0005945216,
-0.0231663603,
-0.0218123905,
-0.0521359332,
0.0131567959,
-0.1160692722,
-0.0563477017,
0.0283153448,
0.0127881551,
-0.0051410208,
-0.0668602958,
-0.0133095663,
0.0298407935,
-0.0368179418,
0.0067324983,
-0.0141306603,
0.0134845702,
-0.0371225588,
-0.0287936851,
-0.0173536185,
-0.0285812113,
0.0147124492,
0.0003996311,
0.0132873897,
-0.0316501446,
0.0168162864,
0.0675405785,
0.0183318239,
0.0132742291,
0.0120739164,
-0.0110549722,
-0.0194177404,
0.0433108769,
-0.0261226762,
0.0019725235,
0.0563965663,
0.0478472263,
-0.0082027921,
0.0038653358,
-0.0062177218,
0.0399227217,
0.0294058733,
0.017175056,
-0.0109357806,
-0.0356748961,
0.0503086112,
0.0645701811,
-0.0105017181,
-0.023467185,
-0.024514325,
0.0220952798,
-0.0251576155,
-0.0322214514,
-0.0119287102,
-0.0544658154,
0.0052581583,
0.0084125185,
-0.0189707894,
0.0114121251,
-0.0025333569,
-0.0820740759,
-0.0031546797,
-0.0488836057,
-0.0040866151,
-0.0094664646,
0.0296652596,
-0.0233759433,
0.0056447079,
0.0015407247,
0.0506416596,
0.0127002951,
0.0646217242,
-0.0159221366,
0.0811657533,
0.0314838216,
-0.0318665989,
0.0119977966,
0.0753287375,
-0.0679849312,
-0.0742516741,
-0.0129442373,
0.0047878739,
0.0057307333,
0.0397381186,
0.0369954631,
-0.0426455066,
0.0169672463,
0.0125344871,
0.0302904304,
-0.0159412362,
-0.037066862,
-0.0190029852,
-0.008769583,
-0.0310258921,
-0.0087469658,
0.0301616993,
-0.0266990345,
0.0042663794,
-0.004392596,
-0.0306887738,
-0.0619086288,
-0.0247331355,
0.0201301966,
0.0424304456,
0.0147876227,
-0.0172450189,
-0.0338707678,
-0.0388761796,
0.0006057436,
-0.0234746467,
0.0047303103,
-0.0487017147,
0.0180896521,
0.0196775179,
-0.0030575546,
-0.0049128481,
-0.0575029552,
0.0567491911,
-0.0116096297,
-0.0148230437,
-0.0677386224,
-5.84325642e-33,
-0.0021058607,
-0.0303076245,
-0.0180666726,
0.0191852842,
-0.0382058099,
-0.009915974,
-0.0343302898,
-0.0065089264,
-0.0050859731,
0.0203609131,
-0.0100987591,
0.044850871,
-0.0035431776,
0.0047906484,
-0.0022134958,
0.015416164,
0.0389325656,
-0.0212556925,
-0.0564300232,
0.0213006902,
-0.0088511501,
0.0286315344,
0.0417152829,
-0.1284368932,
0.04515047,
-0.0068913619,
-0.0357624814,
0.0169923883,
0.03371666,
0.0434220359,
-0.0071774907,
0.0316508189,
0.03467381,
-0.001111591,
0.006913879,
0.0566284023,
-0.0353071876,
-0.0397613458,
0.0124104703,
-0.0043581747,
-0.0664028674,
-0.0318855643,
0.018791873,
-0.0424329787,
0.009536148,
-0.0123456139,
0.0140086515,
-0.0251108408,
0.0520349331,
0.0323702283,
-0.0374638997,
-0.0133184865,
-0.0358553827,
-0.0514089949,
-0.0153529029,
0.0889506713,
-0.018745847,
0.0145455804,
0.0011543633,
0.01964093,
-0.0114594419,
-0.0212383717,
0.0064046332,
-0.0258836634,
0.0030959013,
0.048087474,
0.0098981857,
0.0368441455,
-0.0210360885,
0.0123759946,
-0.0275112186,
0.0177359693,
0.051943887,
0.0819571614,
0.0080658589,
-0.0302950032,
0.012874011,
0.0354748107,
0.0273984652,
-0.029399626,
-0.00184142,
0.0338615477,
-0.0581819452,
-0.0245203041,
-0.0031974497,
-0.0163310673,
-0.0022101924,
-0.0543866977,
0.0291130356,
-0.01169826,
-0.0384750776,
-0.0251996722,
-0.0108949561,
-0.045973096,
0.0371129662,
-0.0176630616,
-0.0106493458,
0.0543406978,
-0.0053179408,
-0.0250612572,
-0.0177518409,
0.0090212822,
0.0669761077,
-0.0010591118,
0.0744641051,
0.0029399893,
0.029426856,
0.01760602,
-0.0520782322,
-0.0241734404,
0.0169181433,
0.079852283,
0.0057807518,
0.0029553112,
-0.0242596697,
0.029922517,
-0.0290012769,
0.0368465073,
0.0159025881,
0.0218377132,
-0.0828465819,
-0.0268579219,
-0.0138967708,
-0.0238015279,
-0.0408478267,
-0.0234505329,
-0.0193089284,
0.0073787253,
0.0226879325,
-0.0334797204,
-0.0336896814,
-0.0443947762,
2.963e-7,
0.0043091364,
0.0502380617,
0.0479548909,
-0.0195106957,
0.01924791,
0.0406716131,
0.0339531898,
0.0407540239,
0.014325656,
-0.0378755033,
0.0395380706,
0.0144404462,
0.0485348888,
0.0317448825,
-0.0198882464,
-0.0365314521,
-0.0241625514,
-0.039710369,
-0.0400782712,
0.0607512109,
0.1139793992,
0.0447082259,
0.0214070585,
-0.0271137543,
0.0059534321,
0.0134131806,
0.0040105637,
-0.0351612866,
-0.0005671782,
0.0497528277,
-0.0237704255,
-0.0251282938,
0.0249122251,
0.0119269462,
0.0166994501,
-0.0240761805,
-0.0088025331,
0.0835521743,
-0.0468981303,
-0.0163919181,
0.0047363262,
0.0432066098,
0.0164589472,
-0.006565047,
0.0136990016,
-0.0681166947,
-0.0523424968,
-0.0561853163,
-0.0361924097,
-0.0497071333,
0.0324356407,
-0.0417250395,
-0.0444197543,
0.0619427413,
0.013991992,
0.03357796,
0.0094046909,
-0.0355988368,
-0.0030760865,
0.005656749,
-0.0453638323,
-0.0385801494,
0.0038218198,
0.0053939666,
-0.0088579655,
-0.0391470939,
0.0339360945,
2.697249619e-34,
-0.0054085203,
0.0146275153,
0.0247305576,
0.0563124456,
0.0362993069,
0.0204906967,
-0.0111707281,
0.0519108884,
0.0236067232,
-0.0575207435,
-0.0260074586
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10190v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10190v1 | Variable-length Neural Interlingua Representations for Zero-shot Neural Machine Translation | 2023-05-17T13:15:10 | 2023-05-17T13:15:10 | Zhuoyuan Mao, Haiyue Song, Raj Dabre, Chenhui Chu, Sadao Kurohashi | cs.CL | cs.CL | The language-independency of encoded representations within multilingual
neural machine translation (MNMT) models is crucial for their generalization
ability on zero-shot translation. Neural interlingua representations have been
shown as an effective method for achieving this. However, fixed-length neural
interlingua representations introduced in previous work can limit its
flexibility and representation ability. In this study, we introduce a novel
method to enhance neural interlingua representations by making their length
variable, thereby overcoming the constraint of fixed-length neural interlingua
representations. Our empirical results on zero-shot translation on OPUS, IWSLT,
and Europarl datasets demonstrate stable model convergence and superior
zero-shot translation results compared to fixed-length neural interlingua
representations. However, our analysis reveals the suboptimal efficacy of our
approach in translating from certain source languages, wherein we pinpoint the
defective model component in our proposed method. | [
-0.0143832965,
0.0250500944,
0.0004086359,
0.068815589,
-0.0385732986,
0.0232036952,
0.0533814318,
-0.010426729,
-0.063959606,
-0.0010857382,
-0.057778433,
-0.0581584908,
0.0325207412,
-0.0481385365,
0.0493261553,
-0.0330407545,
0.0222636778,
-0.0011365674,
-0.0393639319,
-0.0142830936,
0.0095443698,
0.01048995,
0.0124296034,
0.0123706795,
-0.0031300008,
-0.0240233224,
-0.0003459046,
0.0257881954,
0.0228222124,
-0.0170201268,
-0.0156695563,
0.0181998555,
0.0362283699,
0.1065142527,
0.0000019369,
0.0055240062,
-0.0213831645,
-0.0201378036,
-0.0175601337,
-0.0145352753,
0.0265059061,
-0.0817485005,
-0.0125971325,
-0.0093349274,
0.0027490659,
-0.020653924,
0.0695408657,
-0.0198750366,
0.0422524177,
0.0928135663,
-0.025755275,
-0.0352318175,
-0.027842395,
-0.0707343668,
0.022074936,
-0.0076842494,
-0.0330144949,
-0.0322807841,
-0.0610108338,
0.0161711462,
-0.0293030851,
0.048430983,
0.0326913595,
0.040713314,
-0.0367146954,
0.0161900111,
-0.0222690329,
-0.0338972844,
-0.0024075247,
0.078530699,
-0.0686744153,
-0.0056512519,
-0.0294952821,
0.0007400388,
0.0111051081,
-0.0642415956,
-0.0774513558,
0.0261549801,
0.0260995328,
-0.0004622811,
0.0026649206,
0.0951616019,
0.0183208454,
-0.0363941491,
-0.0754220784,
0.0190470647,
0.0342378356,
-0.026847532,
-0.0213178359,
-0.0113656214,
-0.0062832111,
0.0286079366,
-0.0079649463,
0.0079670828,
0.0213201419,
0.0068187984,
-0.0310928468,
-0.0437024795,
0.0100162486,
-0.0548484549,
0.0608334467,
0.0647652373,
0.0181923043,
0.0363809615,
-0.0228765514,
0.0593774468,
-0.0310852304,
0.0257149134,
-0.022278754,
-0.0279684141,
-0.059999302,
0.0108165843,
-0.0112078534,
-0.00199392,
-0.0144284274,
-0.009350027,
-0.0087592714,
0.0184260327,
-0.0138938455,
0.0002841662,
-0.0154377799,
-0.0104280123,
-0.050788302,
-0.030098021,
0.0322493799,
0.1120985895,
-0.0267764665,
-0.0204427447,
-0.0243612379,
-0.0330073908,
-0.0564484783,
0.0146216415,
-0.0035760517,
-0.0255737174,
-0.0031610471,
0.1063827649,
-0.0217774678,
-0.0366101339,
0.0011855821,
-0.0135426437,
-0.0152423549,
-0.079280667,
0.025801396,
-0.0708961338,
0.0919966847,
-0.0023961195,
0.01145788,
-0.0575280003,
-0.0326334499,
0.0048971092,
-0.0417409167,
0.0491623804,
-0.0288769249,
-0.0264731627,
-0.0105118286,
-0.0059266463,
0.0128134293,
0.0874658152,
0.0448958948,
-0.0149335107,
0.0231572706,
0.0247750878,
-0.00309812,
0.0679149553,
0.0169650279,
0.0267630536,
-0.048937615,
-0.028679749,
0.0278127212,
-0.001615665,
0.0471728668,
0.0109270308,
-0.039117787,
-0.0272060465,
0.0441384576,
0.0449971594,
0.0291185547,
0.0162118264,
0.0507805943,
-0.0049551846,
-0.0360157043,
0.0173237678,
0.0058933054,
0.061019253,
0.0216014385,
0.0088514471,
0.0082187736,
0.0380955152,
-0.0419722721,
-0.0100463219,
0.0100324219,
-0.0234779269,
0.0069651138,
-0.038782794,
0.0111602265,
0.0047244644,
-0.0244629271,
0.0468848236,
0.0180140454,
-0.0401544757,
0.0220083296,
0.0144475298,
-0.007251909,
0.0591719896,
-0.0111444145,
0.0012660121,
-0.0548360907,
-0.0372291692,
0.0010905707,
0.0793175325,
0.0219278578,
0.0152884265,
0.0564459153,
-0.0605387203,
-0.0077939918,
-0.0105517004,
0.0208934378,
0.0496094562,
-0.0433990099,
0.05555664,
0.0420878083,
-0.0015162897,
-0.0232363828,
0.0020047026,
-0.0520840511,
-0.0323009789,
0.0147894397,
0.0233639441,
0.0138867283,
0.01623022,
-0.0269838814,
0.0097083338,
0.0077801985,
-0.05084062,
-0.0425435305,
0.017867472,
-0.0363189951,
-0.0423936509,
0.0290916283,
-0.0298185386,
0.0122719109,
-0.0499977469,
-0.0320264101,
-0.0348402858,
0.0299106371,
0.0094975978,
-0.007314011,
0.0021111569,
0.013632603,
0.0117630903,
0.0205738489,
-0.0523365103,
-0.0173972603,
0.0065325033,
-0.0127337091,
0.0178771485,
-0.0298979692,
0.0403745137,
-0.030231338,
-0.0246120505,
0.092580609,
0.0236612558,
0.0124302935,
0.0149474768,
0.0172079876,
0.026645951,
-0.0209725313,
-0.0661103502,
0.013942603,
-0.0212400239,
0.0258249994,
0.023676753,
0.0444926582,
0.0133999512,
0.0015564561,
-0.0296859331,
0.0148461852,
0.0056600692,
0.0050496976,
0.0224926416,
-0.0205487758,
0.0120377541,
-0.0113283787,
-0.0190511253,
0.002991874,
0.0585437901,
-0.0367319137,
-0.0300233886,
-0.0536206439,
-0.0231625997,
-0.0597289689,
-0.0014120077,
-0.0158951506,
-0.0634024814,
0.0049542841,
-0.0431139655,
-0.0193597097,
0.0210491624,
-0.027848538,
-0.0361823291,
0.0200624857,
-0.0014254682,
-0.0687372908,
0.0200680774,
-0.0131997904,
-0.0057642604,
-0.0071473434,
0.0052996776,
-0.0059029376,
0.078482464,
-0.0073190439,
0.0053351172,
-0.0515102707,
0.0185205918,
0.0110806683,
0.0046415157,
-0.0165203474,
0.0451459847,
0.0381555259,
0.0191418342,
-0.0320416018,
-0.0269328579,
0.0424972363,
-0.0274124891,
-0.014427349,
-0.0268200245,
0.0030709333,
-0.0614608601,
0.0405060798,
-0.0465506315,
0.0301451683,
0.003711768,
0.0098824045,
-0.0274789035,
0.0106960637,
-0.0193326417,
0.0184211768,
0.0287471991,
-0.0098073408,
-0.009886058,
-0.0273398552,
0.0033810255,
0.0115384012,
-0.0107447123,
0.0005326525,
-0.0033889643,
-0.006295837,
-0.0078586647,
-0.0127160428,
0.010877423,
0.0451033674,
0.0642121434,
-0.0281148236,
0.0277513079,
-0.0234542154,
0.0153452884,
-0.0217618234,
-0.0202030838,
-0.0071657356,
-0.0235716868,
0.0509399474,
-0.0065081948,
-0.0202970132,
0.032179229,
-0.0245422032,
0.0081237294,
0.0140348729,
0.008321994,
-0.0271028597,
-0.0291944407,
0.0222888794,
-0.0444962978,
0.009533925,
0.093194373,
0.0119564533,
-0.0695834011,
0.0135621335,
-0.0023037193,
0.0685941055,
0.0188695043,
0.0247069206,
-0.0811189786,
-0.0281482674,
-0.011331263,
-0.0037793741,
0.035616979,
0.0136283999,
-0.0351714119,
-0.1093322709,
-0.00886478,
0.0922171399,
-0.0516128205,
-0.0545257442,
0.0094511984,
-0.0713525712,
-0.0204728097,
0.027561076,
-0.0021284986,
0.0215060394,
-0.0338315442,
-0.0072756908,
0.0313728862,
-0.0656826571,
-0.0224152356,
-0.0475081578,
0.0253798515,
0.061623387,
0.0312025156,
0.0012006615,
-0.0108209159,
0.0181799848,
0.0096300067,
-0.0066691786,
0.0114305606,
0.043550685,
-0.0165937692,
-0.0423965454,
0.0639915019,
-0.0189369936,
-0.0064275078,
0.0321307257,
0.0049268776,
0.0595993772,
0.0149608273,
0.0114278328,
-0.0077918833,
-0.0326668993,
-0.0206650905,
0.0526518077,
0.015241011,
-0.0466079414,
0.018214196,
-0.0157511458,
-0.0250439551,
-0.0696806386,
0.0116065796,
0.0237287357,
-0.0270016063,
-0.0644616708,
-0.0549663976,
-0.0813438743,
0.011105001,
0.0576346219,
0.0103213256,
-0.0108613474,
0.0006814812,
-0.0074844421,
-0.0098752882,
0.015770819,
-0.0425444655,
0.0147481989,
-0.0443022363,
0.0378146917,
0.0133770714,
-0.0047850353,
0.0270591471,
-0.0003544137,
-0.0684842542,
-0.0821228251,
-0.0473727137,
0.0934684649,
0.023163477,
0.059984237,
-0.0175617859,
-0.0345654935,
0.0443376824,
-0.0080988714,
0.0196687132,
-0.0031068563,
0.0378449261,
0.0095119672,
0.0048359474,
0.0529434681,
-0.0092820926,
0.0207064301,
0.0176458284,
0.0371791869,
-0.0087477732,
0.0024258094,
0.0071961386,
-0.0125769041,
-0.0252996106,
-0.0107888561,
0.0156506617,
-0.0055877357,
0.0113688065,
-0.0478680208,
-0.0194337573,
-0.062762998,
0.0050975131,
0.0402691215,
-0.0255484823,
-0.0049182973,
-0.0235410165,
-0.0088679418,
-0.0360691026,
0.0017328293,
-0.0334962532,
-0.0205821395,
0.0072683338,
-0.022072766,
0.0340830833,
-0.018734064,
0.0486725494,
-0.0553764924,
-0.0307530165,
-0.0333608724,
0.0438809395,
-0.0062556011,
0.0286045074,
-0.0548005775,
0.0381282605,
-0.0288097579,
0.0141900023,
0.0051836688,
0.0062628565,
0.0904423371,
0.0410701744,
0.0863301754,
0.0387334414,
-0.0101090055,
-0.0088400934,
0.0317709297,
-0.0082401866,
-0.0069359639,
-0.0186464582,
0.0246110503,
-0.002522761,
0.0027962853,
0.0961396992,
-0.0069507994,
0.0054048966,
-0.0397357233,
0.0150282737,
-0.0127116097,
0.0159600228,
0.0161282085,
0.0092275981,
-0.0063460441,
-0.0201606601,
-0.0478923395,
-0.0659748539,
0.0384469889,
-0.0046159807,
0.0356885344,
0.007703241,
-0.0106217507,
0.0367291942,
-0.0336881503,
0.0415198766,
-0.0102457386,
-0.0254208073,
0.0148279266,
-0.0225063488,
-0.0557172149,
-6.073114789e-33,
-0.0390744321,
0.0565800294,
0.0166568793,
-0.0440635309,
-0.0597914904,
-0.0050524194,
-0.0287731942,
-0.0010158377,
-0.0007780294,
-0.0026638224,
0.0143261449,
-0.0116462065,
0.0023775899,
0.0010475538,
0.0478577502,
-0.0109653436,
0.0373567417,
0.0156967752,
-0.0121657541,
0.0116297873,
0.0558673479,
0.0266934,
0.0871622115,
-0.0028032933,
0.0546284206,
-0.0312238056,
-0.0021469835,
0.0171317458,
0.017053429,
0.0275054965,
0.0096261632,
0.0084693311,
0.0472958125,
-0.0310079958,
-0.0191295482,
-0.0251155943,
-0.0451025814,
-0.0171246938,
-0.011240229,
0.0361713506,
0.0135148987,
-0.0906227529,
0.0813676044,
-0.0489644632,
0.008972601,
-0.0356904343,
-0.0059561552,
-0.0028213791,
-0.020899957,
-0.0071439962,
-0.0779476091,
0.0051507209,
0.0070066154,
-0.0083046239,
0.0393432155,
0.0865771472,
-0.0086614471,
0.0380241126,
-0.1175927818,
-0.0248187371,
-0.0487731546,
0.0339669809,
0.065903835,
0.0146212336,
-0.0134427976,
0.0068287356,
0.0585882179,
-0.0125733418,
0.0272316001,
0.0285392255,
0.0474141799,
-0.0403372198,
0.0755213946,
0.0407736227,
0.0689854547,
-0.000534745,
-0.0496426299,
-0.0030413948,
-0.00625289,
-0.0028246786,
0.0151656354,
0.0013116479,
0.0034962709,
-0.0053394353,
-0.0262639076,
-0.1112389937,
-0.0383630469,
-0.0514148287,
0.0083362162,
-0.0080194762,
0.0176617634,
-0.0058640307,
0.1190813631,
-0.0156773068,
-0.0003031124,
0.0233346503,
-0.0315050445,
0.0384698734,
0.0193328764,
0.0284962542,
-0.000649702,
-0.0244362801,
-0.0157440398,
0.0179390106,
0.0187983233,
0.0037229678,
0.0891408324,
0.0275507309,
-0.0103833536,
-0.0413904935,
-0.0535760894,
-0.0401534922,
0.0160573311,
0.0522811636,
0.0171610024,
0.0140532162,
-0.0126126204,
0.0308015086,
0.0265707821,
-0.0217406955,
0.040172901,
-0.0168296713,
0.0010907652,
0.0575291067,
-0.0427136011,
0.0002478827,
-0.0127395233,
0.0047767875,
0.0169683322,
-0.06598261,
-0.0281000249,
-0.0082736509,
2.664e-7,
0.0081288535,
0.0335396081,
0.0067803613,
0.0087068258,
0.0216360074,
0.0156751145,
-0.0545442477,
0.0581688136,
-0.0190873295,
0.0380012095,
-0.0060080648,
0.0449771024,
0.0542969666,
-0.0007335066,
-0.0710416734,
-0.0429655164,
-0.007577918,
0.0406935625,
-0.0515529998,
0.0006290409,
0.0608091131,
0.1080707982,
0.0265711825,
0.014781002,
0.0141760884,
0.0045703468,
0.0707726702,
0.030956503,
-0.0237065181,
-0.0129788257,
0.0144600431,
0.0265574511,
-0.036778871,
-0.0147698121,
0.0028700184,
0.0259860251,
0.0213561077,
0.0440058671,
-0.0343896523,
-0.0058218255,
0.0235491935,
-0.029856002,
-0.0433691032,
-0.0043109171,
0.0758782178,
-0.0800959915,
-0.0103923893,
0.0192157812,
-0.0347869284,
0.0610686131,
0.0665982068,
-0.0283117443,
-0.0307347439,
0.0204824973,
0.06965103,
-0.0093578398,
-0.0171802416,
-0.0263985284,
-0.0523307398,
-0.0031601968,
-0.0039029773,
0.0188302957,
-0.0056346813,
-0.0334355608,
0.0334037617,
-0.0481518432,
0.0028853999,
2.232171248e-34,
0.022755051,
-0.0228777863,
0.0304973163,
-0.0085797934,
0.0002372301,
-0.0601331815,
-0.0429965332,
0.0158108193,
-0.0019630077,
-0.0056722858,
-0.0387004465
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10172v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10172v1 | Knowledge-enhanced Mixed-initiative Dialogue System for Emotional Support Conversations | 2023-05-17T12:55:52 | 2023-05-17T12:55:52 | Yang Deng, Wenxuan Zhang, Yifei Yuan, Wai Lam | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Unlike empathetic dialogues, the system in emotional support conversations
(ESC) is expected to not only convey empathy for comforting the help-seeker,
but also proactively assist in exploring and addressing their problems during
the conversation. In this work, we study the problem of mixed-initiative ESC
where the user and system can both take the initiative in leading the
conversation. Specifically, we conduct a novel analysis on mixed-initiative ESC
systems with a tailor-designed schema that divides utterances into different
types with speaker roles and initiative types. Four emotional support metrics
are proposed to evaluate the mixed-initiative interactions. The analysis
reveals the necessity and challenges of building mixed-initiative ESC systems.
In the light of this, we propose a knowledge-enhanced mixed-initiative
framework (KEMI) for ESC, which retrieves actual case knowledge from a
large-scale mental health knowledge graph for generating mixed-initiative
responses. Experimental results on two ESC datasets show the superiority of
KEMI in both content-preserving evaluation and mixed initiative related
analyses. | [
0.0756260082,
-0.0371795632,
-0.0473137796,
0.0231842455,
-0.0366116799,
0.0225716587,
0.0098488182,
-0.0142868189,
0.0687773228,
-0.0369927026,
0.0026078708,
-0.0135113979,
-0.0354656018,
0.0536260307,
-0.0261495765,
-0.0819420516,
-0.0005303488,
0.0318887159,
0.115345262,
0.0143188164,
0.0402915701,
0.0095798494,
-0.0470186621,
0.0445054062,
-0.0396822765,
-0.0095883133,
-0.009038792,
0.0230530817,
0.050528463,
-0.0545886494,
0.0344459005,
0.0264667254,
-0.0382796265,
-0.008016306,
0.00000208,
-0.0414234698,
0.0046988772,
-0.0246091038,
-0.0021802022,
-0.0643115416,
0.0096641071,
-0.0015928186,
0.0093185548,
-0.0099506089,
-0.0155643066,
0.0151400166,
0.0315668844,
0.090214707,
0.0675062761,
0.0385907665,
-0.0376174226,
0.0196908526,
-0.0182785373,
0.0124356886,
-0.0345649458,
0.0062352275,
-0.0048278063,
0.0222489648,
0.0557628572,
-0.0478121825,
0.0028044251,
0.0210666154,
-0.031583,
-0.0208032466,
-0.0137372715,
-0.0203482658,
-0.0392545573,
-0.0284368731,
-0.0144013474,
0.1039172411,
0.0345219783,
0.0629655346,
0.015183744,
-0.040147908,
0.0072636665,
0.0243101642,
-0.0273558293,
-0.0253257491,
-0.0182406716,
-0.0229809079,
0.0223028008,
0.0702942982,
-0.0436197892,
-0.0035662963,
0.0136260176,
0.0594455302,
-0.037868388,
-0.0332075246,
0.0043659224,
-0.0115655083,
-0.0080101006,
-0.045188494,
-0.0050914697,
0.033501327,
-0.0511073358,
0.033176247,
-0.0114362491,
-0.0541331321,
0.0036021478,
-0.0325861908,
0.0081815124,
0.0397218391,
-0.0163552854,
0.0087541528,
0.0461134315,
0.0278883483,
0.0241370406,
0.0162430052,
-0.012434463,
-0.0037768483,
-0.0656687245,
-0.0092264889,
-0.03124726,
0.0277740173,
-0.0503011756,
-0.0322174989,
-0.0464235917,
0.052711539,
-0.0484400466,
0.0119588654,
0.0214085709,
-0.0020338323,
0.0132348016,
0.0259559862,
-0.018918002,
0.0295149703,
-0.0291508604,
0.0398261212,
0.0268033706,
-0.0383908302,
0.0345046334,
0.0008352798,
0.0273607988,
-0.0035733243,
-0.0058510252,
0.0191655029,
0.0063164802,
-0.0244112089,
-0.03727654,
-0.0462583788,
-0.051386781,
-0.0263391491,
-0.0350005776,
-0.010580916,
0.0513774455,
0.0139897354,
-0.0082877092,
-0.0044154506,
0.0440682024,
-0.0192491356,
-0.0554998517,
0.042013552,
-0.0491647907,
0.0107341474,
0.0145265274,
0.0511717089,
-0.0129028857,
0.0478747897,
0.0083968844,
-0.0342039391,
0.0574545339,
-0.0062321476,
-0.000133199,
-0.0119251423,
0.0039102389,
-0.0130553506,
0.0656030253,
0.0004843913,
-0.0428315736,
0.0264928322,
-0.0237951688,
0.0281081237,
-0.0074579427,
0.0042168684,
0.035236612,
0.0885127634,
-0.0084020859,
0.0420506932,
-0.033572413,
0.0411629379,
0.0236531626,
0.0124740442,
0.0262032077,
0.0400187187,
-0.0194629505,
-0.037065614,
0.0079394374,
-0.0364274718,
-0.027454013,
-0.0532980859,
-0.0136868153,
0.0018367734,
0.01280702,
-0.0172665622,
-0.0276570879,
-0.0203309823,
-0.0029548348,
0.004084317,
-0.0163560007,
-0.0463631488,
-0.0469259545,
-0.0269590728,
0.0078696432,
0.1086898595,
0.0348794125,
-0.0594788641,
-0.0508146249,
0.0172841176,
-0.0409124382,
0.0056797643,
-0.0021148098,
-0.007539263,
0.0213227924,
-0.0173919685,
-0.0268634092,
0.0197310857,
-0.0130588999,
-0.0195735693,
-0.0521315522,
0.0411600843,
-0.0290537942,
0.0057903705,
0.0040740818,
-0.0064452388,
0.0271534584,
0.0129807647,
0.0143866921,
0.0179769918,
0.0689461231,
0.0611618087,
-0.0191379357,
0.0157623831,
0.0038834235,
-0.0248392876,
-0.0949926376,
0.0597972274,
-0.042498894,
-0.0561301,
0.0124090854,
-0.0246938039,
0.0076205255,
-0.0140299965,
0.0079921596,
-0.0617282465,
0.0200050939,
-0.0385728329,
0.0295959115,
-0.0217475202,
0.0151034957,
0.0091978144,
-0.0269934498,
-0.0158713516,
0.0143239424,
-0.0154981166,
0.0270326678,
-0.0069866083,
-0.0431052446,
-0.0024458936,
-0.056751471,
0.0006765348,
0.0422442295,
0.0033278477,
-0.0169026423,
-0.0353758037,
-0.0174955633,
-0.0697084516,
-0.0241254382,
-0.1915299594,
-0.0114297764,
-0.022206502,
-0.0212403238,
-0.0108528398,
0.0216292124,
-0.0270968806,
-0.0102487914,
-0.0603549555,
0.0223605558,
0.0634532869,
0.0047137449,
-0.0007212629,
0.0644830614,
0.0291946772,
-0.0593898147,
0.0225047898,
-0.0141576091,
0.0241719522,
-0.0152046373,
-0.0506147109,
-0.0053676842,
0.0204356648,
-0.0749225691,
0.0074935714,
-0.0186243225,
-0.0312893949,
0.0015201357,
0.0082006631,
0.0373019911,
-0.0138255982,
0.0359698012,
0.0509943366,
-0.0304514095,
-0.0439332686,
-0.0585774072,
0.024011543,
0.0056599895,
0.0422758833,
-0.0243028942,
0.0026011623,
0.0238875188,
0.0300401542,
0.0335987285,
0.0158464294,
-0.0380152352,
-0.0346745998,
0.0133821554,
-0.019493131,
-0.0281698648,
-0.0456063598,
0.0095922817,
-0.0028011962,
0.0027284303,
0.0055549731,
0.0438995399,
0.0004064639,
-0.0161748156,
-0.0424923711,
-0.0460697599,
-0.0333368219,
0.0434761234,
-0.059112478,
0.0224839132,
-0.0030373367,
-0.0029835538,
0.0037713868,
-0.0161703043,
-0.0041230158,
-0.0534631759,
-0.0135210315,
-0.0645226166,
-0.0045968313,
0.0321398489,
-0.0384446234,
-0.0334802419,
-0.0007997079,
-0.0487181731,
-0.0037786418,
0.0651625395,
0.005058316,
0.0232122019,
-0.0096982308,
0.0728530437,
0.0265660305,
0.0308578964,
-0.0205203798,
0.0118550565,
0.0266636368,
0.0181552973,
0.0158726256,
0.0001373304,
0.0330376886,
0.0979076698,
0.068411082,
0.0421196222,
-0.0050024972,
0.0356765054,
-0.0061008735,
-0.0140654529,
0.0277927835,
-0.0130191101,
-0.0218190774,
0.0492013879,
-0.00020183,
0.0252771024,
0.0953411311,
0.0359018631,
-0.0374930277,
0.0103200981,
-0.0726219714,
-0.0249713287,
-0.0031295076,
-0.0145466318,
-0.0501992591,
0.0030025083,
-0.0328322984,
0.0334623531,
-0.0672328621,
-0.0661033541,
0.0114831068,
-0.0379024893,
0.0344599076,
-0.0177812222,
0.0243493337,
-0.0147873852,
0.0160483196,
0.0608218946,
0.0353091545,
-0.0517358966,
-0.0420435034,
0.0411507189,
-0.0220224764,
0.0042102062,
-0.0433799364,
-0.0078435764,
0.0063188206,
0.0062363902,
0.0689748451,
0.0026657097,
0.0792729631,
0.042016454,
0.0251215659,
-0.0165785532,
0.0675663427,
0.0005610235,
-0.0122676846,
0.0382151753,
-0.0326647647,
0.0050680451,
-0.0322617777,
0.0598463975,
-0.010103792,
0.00359684,
0.0474627391,
0.0700352564,
-0.0673243552,
0.0051922239,
-0.0274031516,
-0.014405298,
0.0848364905,
0.0422890484,
0.0277796462,
-0.0382742397,
0.006869602,
0.030227052,
0.0333707929,
-0.0043959175,
-0.0510140732,
0.0241242498,
-0.0075574745,
0.044655025,
-0.0461797006,
-0.0698869973,
0.0324248448,
0.0168044548,
-0.0332966484,
-0.0247137975,
0.0356328338,
0.0218180846,
-0.0402480066,
-0.0184488036,
0.0220643897,
0.0499001034,
-0.0158946179,
-0.0150014544,
0.0081588719,
0.0090149948,
-0.0020910504,
0.0227516927,
0.054514531,
-0.018763246,
0.0126550365,
0.0336775221,
0.0082820253,
-0.0081331003,
0.0254264027,
-0.0438319221,
0.0479220338,
-0.0046676937,
-0.0187327173,
-0.0102554597,
0.0095530795,
0.067311503,
-0.0096780369,
0.0409281068,
-0.0357228369,
0.0351660959,
-0.0097990576,
0.0455805101,
-0.0255371723,
-0.0706888288,
-0.0328944586,
0.028613368,
0.0306435227,
0.019913679,
-0.0219882298,
-0.0041255266,
0.0197015312,
-0.0487986542,
-0.0125028538,
-0.0497158691,
0.0054771421,
-0.0338304527,
-0.0191186871,
-0.0052387002,
-0.0348057635,
-0.0345577113,
-0.0181684941,
-0.0028771609,
0.0075405752,
0.0231551584,
-0.0124129932,
0.0024884152,
0.0084880376,
-0.0093037551,
0.0389510654,
0.0211229175,
0.0117523959,
0.0147930533,
0.0964763761,
0.0222962592,
-0.0407937579,
0.0355713293,
0.0475370958,
-0.0507850759,
-0.0415051803,
0.0053612324,
0.0238201488,
0.0149267325,
0.0357195735,
0.0093479268,
-0.0172844753,
0.0160824228,
-0.0073535973,
0.0389457308,
0.0025903021,
-0.0236298144,
0.0068987338,
0.0096202148,
-0.0183261577,
0.0296361372,
0.0109632993,
-0.0566926561,
0.0195435435,
-0.0581302345,
-0.0424197987,
-0.050051678,
-0.0063758199,
0.0065582111,
0.0513859503,
-0.0011381272,
0.0213596337,
-0.0885398462,
-0.0157465022,
0.0309117753,
-0.0318744294,
-0.0100454316,
-0.0169309825,
0.0505239181,
0.0346194841,
0.021387687,
-0.0081199594,
-0.0187818762,
0.0087624583,
-0.108002238,
-0.0028021235,
-0.0194193497,
-5.787729005e-33,
-0.0071075475,
-0.0467475727,
-0.0327500254,
0.0243054572,
-0.0008082089,
0.0155521724,
-0.0109972097,
0.0540122651,
0.0163908862,
0.0423365124,
0.0039132698,
0.0482705273,
-0.0038874028,
0.0142622115,
-0.0158913881,
0.0259653591,
0.0063979686,
-0.0088707516,
-0.0112576755,
0.0435651429,
0.0452396944,
0.0454006791,
-0.003583808,
-0.1432293653,
0.0444342867,
0.029996736,
0.0317235664,
0.0136212092,
0.05193251,
0.0211451165,
-0.0091334609,
0.067909494,
0.0440414213,
-0.0045010573,
0.0202864073,
0.0476745479,
-0.0105262594,
-0.0340417996,
0.0228507016,
-0.0115500558,
-0.0823979154,
-0.0178651772,
-0.0237287153,
0.0276612099,
0.0048113139,
-0.0280569308,
0.0036847885,
0.0027758328,
0.0410094224,
-0.0489060432,
-0.0121854357,
0.0027659261,
-0.0380614139,
-0.0285811573,
-0.0345467776,
0.0598224699,
-0.0085175866,
-0.0157022551,
-0.0004374462,
-0.0101273227,
-0.0694783702,
-0.0378195569,
-0.008015411,
-0.0256522931,
-0.0324830189,
0.0637502372,
-0.0398549959,
0.0140150059,
-0.0625236705,
0.0185034703,
-0.0330925323,
0.0565355122,
0.0654096752,
0.0096618598,
-0.0882271975,
-0.004008384,
-0.0117298774,
0.0289140325,
0.0462184511,
-0.0187936854,
-0.0147020286,
0.0245357659,
-0.0621737689,
0.0062990799,
-0.029934587,
-0.0418791659,
-0.0159282759,
-0.0242193304,
0.0383840799,
-0.016978452,
-0.0129956799,
-0.026403835,
0.0036492681,
-0.0134953149,
0.0262969229,
0.0182976052,
-0.0192062967,
0.0538378097,
-0.0008224271,
-0.0095243044,
-0.0267488007,
0.0069600698,
0.0477017201,
0.0392024294,
0.0506461412,
-0.0262794178,
0.0097012175,
-0.0107737295,
-0.0246859752,
-0.014943243,
0.0125545859,
0.0662252605,
-0.0175652802,
-0.0177240949,
-0.0517498404,
0.0126897171,
-0.023550339,
0.0055140429,
0.0127411298,
0.0332448259,
-0.0453964919,
-0.1043474078,
-0.0272738785,
0.0039158883,
-0.0535857454,
-0.0324157849,
-0.009319162,
-0.0293784272,
-0.0209819339,
0.012933624,
-0.0029542719,
-0.0205730405,
2.874e-7,
-0.0097861988,
0.028472811,
0.0221702326,
-0.0218660664,
0.049815353,
0.0282350294,
0.0385509841,
0.049157653,
0.0299659874,
-0.0629619882,
0.0514777675,
0.0122026773,
0.0278491341,
0.0329424851,
-0.0204563327,
-0.0744084194,
-0.00085962,
-0.0474954396,
-0.0458712503,
0.0486994609,
0.1297471672,
-0.0070344424,
0.031561099,
0.0140616959,
-0.0015013361,
0.0269734357,
0.0206089299,
-0.0159745682,
0.0180198383,
0.0183394141,
0.0634887218,
0.0062895305,
0.0154758515,
0.0135298902,
0.0172156524,
0.0492844805,
0.0052365828,
0.0528563969,
-0.039721854,
-0.06327831,
0.0111609614,
0.0337970778,
0.0011055624,
-0.0130940182,
0.0286262259,
-0.0966537893,
-0.011649942,
0.019168498,
-0.0166346803,
-0.0532945246,
0.0041609798,
-0.0097757252,
-0.0422125757,
0.0441586189,
0.0027631233,
-0.0182955917,
0.0370114446,
-0.0535584502,
0.0275765341,
0.0154681439,
-0.0295408703,
-0.0610344969,
-0.005911536,
-0.0020296208,
0.0017916429,
-0.0180356465,
-0.0002064026,
1.98271252e-34,
-0.006737045,
0.053740751,
-0.0014271277,
0.0144527229,
0.0308377557,
0.0019297034,
-0.0642054975,
0.0050194622,
0.0172414351,
-0.0656403974,
0.0086448686
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10167v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10167v1 | Pragmatic Reasoning in Structured Signaling Games | 2023-05-17T12:43:29 | 2023-05-17T12:43:29 | Emil Carlsson, Devdatt Dubhashi | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | In this work we introduce a structured signaling game, an extension of the
classical signaling game with a similarity structure between meanings in the
context, along with a variant of the Rational Speech Act (RSA) framework which
we call structured-RSA (sRSA) for pragmatic reasoning in structured domains. We
explore the behavior of the sRSA in the domain of color and show that pragmatic
agents using sRSA on top of semantic representations, derived from the World
Color Survey, attain efficiency very close to the information theoretic limit
after only 1 or 2 levels of recursion. We also explore the interaction between
pragmatic reasoning and learning in multi-agent reinforcement learning
framework. Our results illustrate that artificial agents using sRSA develop
communication closer to the information theoretic frontier compared to agents
using RSA and just reinforcement learning. We also find that the ambiguity of
the semantic representation increases as the pragmatic agents are allowed to
perform deeper reasoning about each other during learning. | [
0.027400082,
0.0171792991,
-0.0317413211,
0.006282357,
-0.0389663838,
0.0031704037,
-0.0413583666,
0.0471952148,
-0.0632808432,
-0.0206569284,
-0.0115117291,
0.0002385439,
-0.0004579298,
0.0038672718,
0.0008059178,
-0.06788899,
0.0269165989,
-0.0211618301,
0.0560982488,
-0.0429613329,
-0.018140953,
-0.0371664576,
-0.0186000615,
0.0069592861,
-0.0093880557,
-0.032375861,
-0.0529060885,
-0.0339221954,
0.0119202845,
0.0063783461,
-0.056427598,
-0.0362854563,
0.025538357,
0.0062803221,
0.0000019914,
-0.0403750278,
-0.0126691004,
-0.0321745202,
-0.0026185822,
-0.0204604305,
-0.0073694438,
0.0010684722,
0.0010360579,
-0.013284049,
-0.0490033478,
-0.0130698644,
0.0735540614,
0.0767873302,
0.0435729623,
0.0736567229,
0.0157691482,
-0.0284094214,
0.0316769369,
-0.0106420908,
0.0046095042,
-0.07307823,
0.0253973361,
0.0407614596,
0.0343943201,
0.0053485474,
-0.0142589658,
0.0010960952,
0.0286550205,
-0.0072912644,
-0.0479803346,
0.0187677741,
0.066002056,
0.0106158908,
-0.00193031,
0.0235968754,
-0.0008292285,
0.0265301969,
0.0002210514,
-0.0107696494,
-0.0219200216,
0.0029924647,
0.0042969245,
0.0380394645,
-0.007027701,
0.0362446792,
0.0108770356,
0.0136879841,
0.0031629989,
-0.0098982928,
-0.0192952417,
0.1036312431,
-0.0510006808,
0.0158195607,
-0.022937892,
-0.0146466512,
0.0181168485,
-0.0609063432,
-0.0643279701,
0.0308020394,
-0.0502847917,
0.0451691113,
0.0105777523,
0.0334389955,
-0.0037126283,
-0.0178515688,
-0.0356591493,
0.0253487304,
0.0673863739,
0.0441095755,
0.0115536842,
0.0178024769,
-0.0181158334,
0.0729790106,
-0.0239988528,
-0.0100906575,
-0.0636826605,
-0.0375373922,
-0.0290664677,
0.0831398442,
0.0012152237,
-0.0072449218,
-0.0190201402,
0.010897601,
-0.0851605088,
0.0556457303,
-0.0252565276,
-0.0247390047,
-0.0426560082,
-0.0093267625,
-0.0979895443,
-0.0053047277,
-0.0917584002,
0.0268833134,
-0.0142080477,
-0.044114396,
0.0001701831,
-0.0319006965,
-0.0145957312,
0.0187606756,
-0.0401903316,
0.0995318964,
-0.0119478479,
0.0293596275,
-0.026584018,
-0.0606097877,
0.0479606874,
-0.0610165335,
0.0262873862,
-0.0301355775,
-0.0073271049,
-0.0280451588,
0.0126423603,
-0.0874679908,
-0.0210744906,
-0.0263738688,
-0.0056379666,
0.0773125365,
-0.01956149,
0.0207519028,
-0.0369918942,
0.0200038962,
-0.0159721747,
0.1164727956,
0.0391876362,
-0.0130510814,
0.0223341752,
-0.0034945884,
-0.0111160446,
-0.0039388528,
0.0094252564,
0.0048609818,
-0.0088683013,
-0.0220755748,
-0.0032144734,
0.0327926762,
0.0060965843,
0.0163659845,
-0.0316910222,
-0.069626078,
-0.0366618186,
0.044252988,
0.0562650114,
-0.0229888614,
0.035179317,
0.0499930084,
0.0034129771,
0.0435307883,
-0.0061727222,
0.0333242193,
-0.0343987793,
-0.0045852843,
-0.0478452221,
-0.0337024257,
-0.0390451811,
-0.0505489334,
0.0309498869,
-0.0242554769,
0.0692823976,
0.0007508799,
0.0439874269,
0.0117456634,
0.0058614006,
-0.0276998859,
0.0409753993,
0.0080827614,
-0.0316798389,
-0.0588223413,
0.0707120746,
0.042931892,
0.0063209753,
-0.0531578027,
0.0084487461,
0.0262755398,
-0.0031089885,
0.0301990807,
-0.003831872,
-0.0227764715,
0.0265835244,
-0.040956866,
-0.0249430723,
-0.0032562835,
-0.0069026304,
0.0616554432,
-0.0330933705,
0.017656371,
-0.0549781471,
0.0288441777,
0.057876721,
0.0067130262,
0.0350080393,
-0.0109889265,
-0.0077655618,
0.0049553555,
0.0627476126,
-0.0183817279,
-0.0252650231,
0.0391951911,
0.001053828,
0.0081272451,
-0.0085558333,
0.012135501,
-0.0438628159,
-0.0132392999,
0.0016525325,
-0.0295029152,
0.0003360033,
-0.0091213835,
-0.0007698005,
-0.0034952869,
0.0728861019,
-0.0370959453,
0.0531475358,
0.0168660544,
-0.0044363798,
-0.0132858055,
0.0019018853,
0.022036463,
0.0626785085,
0.0150491493,
-0.0439643972,
-0.0072488235,
-0.0239230115,
0.0170634892,
-0.0751219317,
0.0759603158,
0.0419608019,
0.0343766473,
-0.0007914226,
0.0242676567,
0.0151201403,
-0.013317192,
0.0022847832,
0.0402821191,
-0.0415259376,
0.0148425829,
-0.0186472069,
0.0083890315,
-0.0079139285,
0.0337228552,
-0.0185863152,
-0.0295882467,
0.0412142128,
0.0146293137,
0.0180334877,
0.0109251682,
0.0391774736,
-0.0468900204,
0.0055588414,
-0.015625054,
-0.0393248834,
0.0166607946,
0.0266860016,
-0.0251989197,
-0.0606195405,
-0.0174749382,
-0.0524627194,
0.0425149538,
-0.0474406779,
-0.0257862788,
0.026300028,
-0.0170856137,
-0.0452914797,
0.048137702,
-0.0005465111,
0.0372861065,
0.0272315871,
-0.0361932144,
-0.0314000212,
0.0219308212,
-0.0394057259,
0.0172983985,
-0.0545865819,
-0.033353921,
0.0056899004,
0.068285577,
-0.0051588928,
0.027368689,
-0.065468505,
0.0239926875,
0.0172115695,
-0.0662745982,
-0.0512802564,
-0.049113553,
0.02995014,
0.0635871887,
-0.0166993868,
0.0178106409,
0.1014579311,
0.0255535822,
0.0084596183,
-0.0316899158,
0.0051974473,
-0.026307499,
0.0723129958,
0.0020210301,
0.001181607,
0.028777821,
0.0068490161,
-0.0411845185,
-0.1085525379,
0.043971777,
0.0005527906,
0.0616608262,
-0.042379383,
0.0190880522,
-0.0015572808,
-0.0246818997,
-0.0067028301,
0.0011703437,
-0.0466124825,
0.0148979342,
-0.0139201107,
-0.0174445007,
-0.0104236715,
0.0357294008,
0.0322530419,
-0.0587378852,
0.0372601636,
-0.0197088569,
-0.0115140043,
-0.0283723641,
-0.0021978561,
0.0353106372,
0.0104888119,
-0.029461788,
0.0775571615,
0.0493121669,
0.0070978538,
-0.0030498866,
0.0086176805,
0.024716014,
0.0172545314,
0.0150063224,
-0.0407333523,
0.0356551521,
0.0364984572,
-0.0294387899,
0.0157919712,
0.0217281859,
0.0060653724,
0.0129437763,
0.0294420682,
-0.0294210222,
0.0412763841,
-0.0283310246,
0.0332788154,
-0.0484554544,
-0.0327844247,
-0.0035451488,
-0.0223088469,
-0.0492507443,
-0.052831877,
-0.0267511699,
-0.0641749576,
-0.0142613556,
0.0265526082,
-0.0327601656,
0.0032954572,
0.0344747864,
0.0002481249,
0.0318858884,
-0.0260630809,
-0.0123361526,
0.0174245089,
0.0055894223,
0.0115986485,
-0.0059503918,
0.0266038701,
0.0159621667,
-0.000677321,
0.0396042578,
0.0506778844,
0.0445709527,
-0.0100061139,
-0.090583533,
-0.0537417606,
0.0278924592,
0.0082300529,
-0.0001662614,
-0.0191426929,
0.0216228738,
-0.008382204,
0.0183996335,
-0.0262024887,
0.004596706,
-0.0234122705,
0.0479130261,
0.0498038791,
-0.0287559293,
-0.0436840989,
-0.018004626,
0.041889511,
-0.0064209243,
0.0433036387,
0.0004689468,
-0.0019728886,
-0.0483584441,
-0.057037808,
0.0136376647,
-0.0005113711,
-0.0444877557,
-0.0064092772,
-0.0073121362,
-0.0544790961,
-0.0617592447,
-0.0298212841,
-0.0029585678,
0.0444326438,
-0.0151938051,
0.01393151,
0.0540232956,
0.0312593766,
0.0151426448,
-0.0438955165,
-0.0500432439,
0.0179493334,
-0.0056773378,
-0.0403756127,
-0.003757244,
-0.0513037629,
-0.013384467,
-0.0708130375,
0.0041817101,
-0.0223479364,
0.0057261935,
0.0160647184,
0.0239088666,
0.004350191,
0.0031892266,
-0.0349245109,
0.0052299649,
-0.0040740706,
-0.0370236896,
0.0622602366,
0.0630930439,
-0.0052908668,
0.0450612456,
0.0609214045,
-0.0475839004,
0.0317850374,
0.0068108477,
0.0375382453,
-0.0591511801,
0.044040326,
0.030170124,
-0.0100594284,
-0.0118296454,
0.073534593,
-0.0545183532,
0.0389212444,
0.0031524864,
-0.0391232185,
-0.02921593,
-0.0304880943,
-0.0019679356,
-0.0452847742,
0.0234129094,
0.0312082618,
0.0026416171,
0.0282270201,
-0.0087981056,
0.1027677581,
0.0030844279,
0.0845696479,
0.0312199946,
-0.0202585533,
0.0024007191,
0.0436647721,
0.0068923994,
-0.0182047896,
0.0360656604,
0.0333891883,
0.0590087287,
0.0783612132,
-0.0323895328,
-0.0344712846,
0.008116832,
-0.0391819552,
-0.1146223024,
0.1313952953,
0.0458014011,
0.0247506686,
0.0509298109,
-0.0443135574,
-0.0620400496,
0.034962818,
0.0237508938,
-0.0079256976,
0.0274604373,
-0.0611613765,
0.0650523975,
0.035293933,
-0.0025808311,
0.0017610329,
0.0487820208,
-0.0244177766,
0.0288043153,
-0.0609072074,
0.0129602728,
-0.0157533549,
-0.0222683866,
-0.0171662811,
0.0499207899,
0.0356878191,
0.0294061154,
-0.0563917197,
-0.0205800664,
-0.022413075,
0.0445133001,
-0.0120575102,
-0.0065632025,
0.0505888313,
0.0120353969,
0.0046266918,
-0.0175321084,
-0.0572137497,
-0.0063140076,
-0.0380088873,
0.0033271271,
0.0150514487,
-5.923275626e-33,
-0.0327446535,
-0.0376472138,
0.0330735706,
-0.0048349644,
0.0007298385,
-0.0077535943,
-0.0269477703,
-0.032703083,
-0.035097722,
0.0560192131,
-0.0093366653,
0.0066699861,
0.0108565288,
-0.0065028523,
-0.0349133871,
-0.0394688249,
-0.0002062346,
0.0169880297,
-0.0250757709,
0.0040728226,
0.0110451821,
-0.049508173,
0.021602191,
-0.0542612523,
-0.0258432012,
0.0479996465,
-0.0336393081,
0.040406283,
-0.0249332823,
0.0273137987,
0.0103815738,
0.0015166129,
0.0006224596,
-0.0153481336,
-0.0021171041,
0.0491903648,
-0.0426980965,
-0.0708960742,
0.0138424058,
0.0032811514,
-0.1063139364,
0.0037144849,
0.0177091695,
0.0038726397,
-0.0047200029,
0.0126964794,
0.0130481394,
-0.0245104395,
-0.0009743159,
0.0280293878,
-0.0136893885,
0.0035766028,
-0.0166688245,
0.0031669044,
-0.0113636153,
-0.0215082932,
0.0062047904,
-0.0058342144,
-0.0444435589,
0.0614182092,
-0.0068590906,
-0.0389567465,
-0.0065521072,
0.0450370982,
0.0578697249,
0.0538137816,
0.0574739687,
-0.016583303,
-0.0117351506,
0.0040782257,
-0.0327082239,
0.0247945581,
0.0086902063,
0.0638252422,
-0.011832363,
0.0127652008,
-0.0578216612,
-0.0082622506,
0.0699111521,
0.0679718703,
-0.0121946931,
0.017499242,
-0.0549438372,
-0.0235737339,
-0.0144383479,
0.0712076798,
0.0068551018,
-0.0601785816,
-0.002848828,
-0.0243218523,
0.0055338969,
-0.0211888198,
-0.0116914427,
-0.0482832715,
-0.0348269008,
0.0031614176,
-0.003414083,
0.0215067957,
0.0023297365,
-0.0146434149,
-0.0326882824,
-0.0181870386,
-0.0040698219,
-0.0489655361,
0.0091061089,
0.0222282968,
-0.0142511409,
0.0496122986,
-0.0141873332,
-0.0021159193,
0.0060155876,
0.0095804846,
0.0257181991,
-0.076377593,
0.0453246683,
0.0096030869,
-0.0096723419,
0.0097008506,
-0.0103982911,
-0.0594016574,
0.024839187,
-0.0004179652,
-0.038062565,
0.0509541556,
-0.0375669301,
-0.0164779257,
-0.0687755868,
-0.0078512197,
0.0343026668,
-0.0323695801,
-0.0055763642,
0.0178769827,
2.918e-7,
-0.0285628736,
-0.0263565108,
-0.0094712814,
0.0333614573,
0.0270776488,
0.0635832697,
-0.0339112505,
0.0062106638,
-0.0037361523,
-0.0453894958,
0.0181218069,
0.040441636,
-0.0125215594,
0.0156947654,
-0.0633347258,
0.0166305639,
-0.008876916,
-0.0097331461,
0.0071627768,
0.0059966324,
0.045604974,
0.0532130674,
0.0771378502,
0.0012483197,
0.0371420048,
-0.0166647267,
0.0271015074,
-0.0301678237,
0.0526266806,
0.0120683694,
-0.0295071956,
-0.016500378,
0.0179055706,
0.0381561741,
0.0666596368,
0.0168512668,
-0.0400383472,
0.0119736744,
0.0045125559,
-0.0382317454,
-0.0502891988,
-0.0403226204,
0.0030639404,
0.0177970435,
0.0492392145,
-0.0194006972,
-0.0937875733,
0.0223325212,
0.0293256529,
-0.0193774719,
-0.0576794371,
0.0440555401,
-0.0610623918,
-0.0336676911,
-0.0225770753,
-0.0101333149,
0.0252420269,
-0.0498504043,
0.0616902858,
-0.018884955,
0.013521539,
-0.0375457667,
-0.0001627883,
0.0240340978,
0.0123985363,
-0.0586849637,
-0.0268885531,
2.289289483e-34,
0.013830631,
-0.0267746467,
0.0112065692,
0.0045785839,
0.0206826236,
0.0052725472,
-0.0295446794,
-0.0069778841,
0.1145216599,
-0.0004784043,
-0.0074311155
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10163v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10163v4 | Large Language Models Leverage External Knowledge to Extend Clinical Insight Beyond Language Boundaries | 2023-05-17T12:31:26 | 2024-01-30T03:58:19 | Jiageng Wu, Xian Wu, Zhaopeng Qiu, Minghui Li, Yingying Zhang, Yefeng Zheng, Changzheng Yuan, Jie Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | $\textbf{Objectives}$: Large Language Models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT and
Med-PaLM have excelled in various medical question-answering tasks. However,
these English-centric models encounter challenges in non-English clinical
settings, primarily due to limited clinical knowledge in respective languages,
a consequence of imbalanced training corpora. We systematically evaluate LLMs
in the Chinese medical context and develop a novel in-context learning
framework to enhance their performance.
$\textbf{Materials and Methods}$: The latest China National Medical Licensing
Examination (CNMLE-2022) served as the benchmark. We collected 53 medical books
and 381,149 medical questions to construct the medical knowledge base and
question bank. The proposed Knowledge and Few-shot Enhancement In-context
Learning (KFE) framework leverages the in-context learning ability of LLMs to
integrate diverse external clinical knowledge sources. We evaluated KFE with
ChatGPT(GPT3.5), GPT4, Baichuan2(BC2)-7B, and BC2-13B in CNMLE-2022 and
investigated the effectiveness of different pathways for incorporating LLMs
with medical knowledge from 7 perspectives.
$\textbf{Results}$: Directly applying ChatGPT failed to qualify for the
CNMLE-2022 at a score of 51. Cooperated with the KFE, the LLMs with varying
sizes yielded consistent and significant improvements. The ChatGPT's
performance surged to 70.04 and GPT-4 achieved the highest score of 82.59. This
surpasses the qualification threshold (60) and exceeds the average human score
of 68.70. It also enabled a smaller BC2-13B to pass the examination, showcasing
the great potential in low-resource settings.
$\textbf{Conclusion}$: By synergizing medical knowledge through in-context
learning, LLM can extend clinical insight beyond language barriers,
significantly reducing language-related disparities of LLM applications and
ensuring global benefit in healthcare. | [
0.0576771833,
0.0192844123,
0.0192380864,
-0.0204529483,
-0.0118384175,
0.0306715406,
0.0107507249,
0.0464643724,
0.0026520554,
-0.0194087569,
-0.0418164469,
-0.054934442,
-0.023614889,
-0.005999628,
0.0319798253,
-0.0428174883,
0.030071998,
0.0325393677,
0.0226663072,
-0.0162337422,
-0.0034298981,
0.0060974751,
-0.0221400168,
0.0342436954,
0.0534962714,
-0.027464319,
0.0362672769,
-0.0013515439,
0.0360216498,
-0.0798331797,
0.0054061068,
0.0262086522,
-0.0044778851,
-0.0044170669,
0.00000225,
-0.0661991686,
-0.0188909601,
0.0443367511,
-0.0542887188,
-0.0211707503,
0.0271629542,
-0.046554286,
0.0017871546,
0.0144336568,
-0.0434941463,
-0.0352213643,
0.0056848349,
0.0505044088,
0.0509332232,
0.0614906363,
-0.0005015319,
-0.0052448353,
0.0327867009,
-0.026710147,
0.0323033407,
-0.0733316988,
0.0402177386,
0.0235722717,
0.0481045581,
0.0133951697,
-0.0007139033,
0.0442609563,
0.0107928012,
0.0449420102,
0.0077081053,
0.0611205772,
-0.0473862998,
0.0174696203,
0.014411754,
0.0652415752,
-0.0017460035,
-0.004425854,
-0.0023519828,
0.0063592372,
-0.0029720147,
0.0034030445,
-0.0783674344,
-0.0017283781,
-0.0227742828,
-0.0171474572,
0.0222040452,
-0.0214482006,
0.0403279103,
0.0167283211,
-0.0058683772,
-0.0438375883,
0.0192617532,
-0.0202459358,
0.0111223506,
-0.0103229405,
-0.0201943927,
-0.021139672,
0.0098950732,
0.0585393608,
-0.0330822729,
0.0272195078,
0.0310711041,
0.0035646237,
0.0714878663,
-0.0621849447,
-0.0039288369,
0.0152031695,
-0.020823095,
0.060360264,
-0.0257929433,
0.015451042,
-0.0113744885,
0.0339608304,
-0.0708002746,
-0.0272761062,
-0.0544899367,
-0.0258237682,
-0.0212842878,
0.019085411,
0.0038987335,
0.0018603605,
-0.0827106163,
-0.0109879132,
0.0164959803,
-0.0034831751,
0.0224014539,
0.0304213986,
-0.0234783608,
-0.0095318072,
-0.0338123776,
0.0414191596,
-0.0055474038,
0.0012984369,
-0.0274147112,
-0.0425230749,
-0.0010993415,
-0.0116981314,
-0.005328618,
-0.0266377628,
0.0417506918,
0.0519269742,
0.0052350792,
-0.012695563,
0.000873581,
-0.0095060356,
-0.0238618031,
-0.0389387719,
-0.0093101421,
-0.0735437796,
0.0115117785,
0.008767779,
0.0247763526,
-0.0088118855,
0.0212293845,
0.0317798816,
-0.0371149816,
0.0536617972,
-0.0418173485,
-0.0077894544,
0.0111425789,
0.0502512604,
-0.0086094467,
0.0404465981,
-0.0038406563,
-0.089214839,
0.009882113,
-0.018206995,
-0.0118940379,
-0.0073281103,
0.0394808576,
-0.0389616042,
0.0030509231,
0.037408106,
0.0329981931,
0.0689969584,
-0.0466878526,
0.0534643419,
-0.0150131965,
0.0025855822,
0.0182294473,
0.0825284272,
0.0162383243,
0.0093595553,
0.0162200946,
-0.0332733132,
0.0057968325,
-0.0246237982,
0.0018948914,
0.0135429595,
-0.0063120718,
0.012315454,
-0.0174711961,
0.00897968,
-0.043662969,
-0.0220021494,
-0.0424367376,
-0.0016034989,
-0.0274920203,
0.0262155607,
0.045115862,
-0.0290976632,
0.0037048617,
0.0678873435,
0.0525567047,
-0.0112136835,
0.0111742429,
-0.0447533838,
-0.0165795591,
0.0610107072,
0.0532931462,
-0.039129477,
-0.0478653684,
-0.0221946985,
0.0228141546,
0.0219765585,
0.023515109,
-0.0417467207,
0.0021039154,
-0.0422663651,
0.0011056659,
0.0134233413,
-0.0096073151,
-0.0466773435,
0.0151281562,
0.0633218437,
-0.0149371596,
-0.0404458232,
0.013487692,
0.0282717347,
-0.0834656805,
-0.02909315,
-0.0043594772,
-0.0107811354,
0.0125108548,
0.0196308084,
-0.0103045274,
0.0263069756,
0.0252022315,
-0.048456233,
-0.0261289906,
0.0041022701,
-0.0566005521,
-0.0854220688,
0.054104913,
-0.0139110964,
-0.0072858725,
-0.0494813658,
-0.0558157898,
-0.0389822796,
-0.0391619802,
-0.0203139428,
0.0369176753,
-0.02659362,
-0.0051623494,
0.0092108212,
-0.0111122131,
-0.0619086847,
0.0368473865,
-0.0180382263,
0.0298751537,
0.0235884693,
-0.0143093392,
0.0157191288,
-0.0075054797,
-0.0140946945,
0.0126856295,
0.0067902831,
0.0119368304,
-0.0107487524,
0.0336241648,
-0.0438886099,
-0.0196565501,
-0.1033651605,
0.0109067569,
0.0136270514,
-0.0128742624,
0.0540162176,
0.0403412245,
0.0000998297,
-0.0141424369,
-0.0717939287,
-0.0089399265,
0.0239764284,
0.0184496231,
0.0236722529,
0.0554526709,
0.0231115147,
-0.0060436931,
-0.0046488727,
-0.0398950055,
0.0022143878,
-0.0068157651,
-0.0078953719,
0.0131115168,
-0.0003864774,
-0.0402576402,
-0.0258361343,
-0.0136611778,
-0.0097941142,
0.0016859503,
-0.0174539275,
-0.0193121769,
0.0313096158,
-0.0219858009,
-0.0126395999,
0.0211582761,
0.0168452226,
-0.0275846329,
0.0292243343,
-0.0018482307,
-0.0441422462,
-0.0085268607,
-0.0177588519,
-0.0212189779,
0.0560576171,
0.0215144362,
-0.0179786161,
-0.0443583243,
-0.0180469174,
-0.0359772891,
0.0190344136,
-0.0908376276,
0.0327403657,
-0.0370172039,
0.0206130054,
-0.0035883596,
0.0055276933,
0.1042795852,
0.0190010387,
0.0316175818,
-0.1100533456,
-0.0085136052,
-0.0451527163,
0.0062613292,
-0.0305947177,
0.0213686191,
0.0046740738,
-0.0128799994,
-0.0470059142,
0.0226897765,
-0.0125756171,
-0.0648263246,
0.0557797998,
-0.018018093,
0.013543088,
-0.0113522075,
-0.0551219732,
-0.0512563884,
-0.0148857208,
-0.0234215185,
0.0313233808,
-0.0080275778,
0.0329629667,
-0.0094088186,
0.0260596368,
0.0188027881,
0.0543371849,
0.0286312904,
-0.0245377161,
0.0123748202,
0.0329410471,
0.0439389758,
0.0083377631,
0.0207324103,
-0.0343481004,
0.0745524988,
0.0845552012,
0.0217050016,
-0.017810503,
0.0608690679,
0.0119309789,
0.0014201589,
-0.0223982986,
-0.00821032,
0.0265000276,
0.0419137068,
-0.0633885562,
-0.0271849409,
0.1274805814,
0.0291080233,
-0.0477668829,
0.0131394081,
-0.0342810899,
-0.0207547825,
0.0225344617,
0.0301610641,
-0.0810093656,
-0.0336455591,
-0.0351058766,
0.0302839205,
-0.022769941,
-0.0085525755,
0.0165741295,
-0.0860686675,
0.0146714523,
0.0024969927,
-0.0754698664,
-0.0070439591,
-0.0375317186,
0.0061773378,
0.0048207347,
0.004929807,
-0.0018615541,
-0.0230380036,
-0.0073368531,
0.0141867427,
-0.0551505573,
-0.0852393284,
0.0643461943,
-0.029348854,
0.0402491242,
0.0416778587,
0.0162038133,
-0.0157581661,
0.0108955363,
0.0155047877,
-0.033801958,
0.0059866793,
-0.0105529325,
0.0536136925,
0.0229771491,
-0.0014015981,
-0.0471149385,
0.0417518653,
-0.0481498763,
-0.0174066518,
0.0108800791,
0.1005004272,
-0.0097795557,
-0.0083427364,
-0.0309723504,
0.0245663896,
0.0019709135,
0.068637751,
-0.005270387,
-0.0200262163,
0.0127769085,
0.0206887703,
0.006805968,
0.0076920171,
-0.007099418,
0.0604373701,
-0.0128147816,
0.0053812722,
-0.0627477169,
-0.0352931246,
0.0342194661,
-0.0317119583,
0.0019213663,
0.0847308561,
-0.0056819385,
0.0137019549,
-0.0349319167,
0.0230389647,
0.0131678572,
-0.0007452167,
-0.0395758674,
-0.0322030969,
0.0753671154,
-0.0023991689,
-0.0171858761,
0.0029187922,
-0.0239956602,
0.0026729577,
-0.0261145774,
0.0344363265,
0.003781344,
0.0194236692,
-0.022030564,
0.0003045088,
0.0671529099,
0.0303011853,
-0.0451719686,
-0.0273641814,
-0.0027034748,
-0.0039614262,
-0.0039939317,
0.0225837547,
-0.0274368059,
0.0028196359,
0.0336420909,
0.0489525087,
-0.0268979967,
-0.0110799903,
0.0446687229,
0.0325109437,
0.0152625619,
-0.0129576474,
-0.0168352388,
-0.0183199961,
0.038063217,
-0.020878097,
0.0113882544,
-0.0029222067,
-0.0279559884,
0.0588298328,
-0.0341660939,
-0.0121862842,
0.0113661252,
-0.02575434,
-0.0399046242,
-0.0436618626,
0.0414260961,
0.0369066708,
0.0067619104,
0.033116024,
-0.0070940349,
-0.0156687386,
0.0022999537,
0.0039341985,
0.0243515652,
-0.0340245701,
0.0880452767,
-0.0137462309,
0.0085129486,
0.019150544,
0.0314405859,
-0.0698719323,
-0.0300094523,
-0.0229641609,
0.0298904181,
0.0704866499,
0.0014442451,
0.0026133773,
-0.005260285,
-0.014069465,
-0.0384217836,
-0.0117779169,
-0.0417398885,
-0.0121025555,
0.0662466735,
0.0215784162,
0.0084216995,
0.0033374452,
0.1056448519,
-0.0094373636,
0.0693574026,
0.0148714306,
-0.0130375642,
-0.0395103358,
-0.0044084229,
0.0377035476,
0.0171535574,
-0.0620206594,
0.0636861473,
-0.0690455735,
-0.0643954948,
0.0015182035,
-0.0109644374,
-0.0329304859,
-0.0061173285,
0.055091124,
0.041951362,
0.0118540162,
-0.0235079322,
-0.038186878,
0.0621897876,
-0.0348405503,
-0.0223118793,
0.0319127105,
-6.426211619e-33,
-0.0015442753,
0.0121398252,
0.0366385542,
-0.0450600013,
0.0245217215,
0.0277346522,
-0.0458412878,
-0.0071488675,
-0.0474680327,
0.026943218,
-0.0366659835,
0.0037433575,
-0.0033743111,
0.0367716029,
0.0117211966,
-0.0416480601,
0.004449009,
0.0181014296,
0.0115061617,
0.0416309014,
-0.01472848,
0.0693315417,
0.0617685504,
-0.0516703837,
-0.0052088615,
-0.0000014769,
0.0477931537,
0.0213252269,
-0.0183675848,
0.0806960389,
-0.035818357,
0.0302910767,
0.0577829033,
-0.0323703103,
-0.0101303514,
-0.0457576141,
-0.1031542569,
-0.0238659792,
0.0004929399,
-0.0163842645,
-0.0145133892,
-0.0318818614,
0.0361012965,
-0.0330660865,
0.0026126998,
-0.0284059905,
0.0177891497,
-0.0467750989,
-0.0289792866,
-0.0458324067,
-0.0297936387,
0.0352307819,
0.0047897557,
0.0095764315,
-0.064925015,
0.0055943131,
-0.0424142703,
0.0449801832,
-0.0261208024,
-0.0278984774,
0.0204128455,
0.0314488374,
0.0149712544,
-0.013065978,
-0.0088809188,
0.0387278497,
0.0003186298,
-0.0428960621,
-0.0018634635,
-0.0078058783,
-0.0324467719,
0.0076997294,
0.0628297105,
0.0696633458,
0.0232128464,
-0.0041899937,
-0.1440873295,
0.0465928167,
-0.0353938714,
0.0556790791,
0.0082545457,
-0.0286276508,
-0.0474235229,
-0.0127138114,
-0.0157417823,
0.0298288073,
-0.0256085582,
-0.0322284363,
0.0325937048,
-0.0090194633,
-0.0007564884,
0.0037963192,
0.0307317786,
-0.0491882898,
0.0091513572,
0.011120772,
0.0348891839,
-0.0115492847,
-0.0277116895,
0.0364701785,
-0.0986627713,
0.0084816301,
0.003905202,
-0.017021209,
0.0245574731,
0.0196842179,
0.0468835793,
-0.0383791663,
-0.0444870107,
-0.0231355075,
0.0040603681,
-0.0060112644,
0.0113580339,
0.0466752388,
0.0115277627,
0.0475127287,
0.0085101193,
0.04217555,
0.0195802655,
-0.0228106901,
-0.035712719,
-0.0498793051,
-0.0083990535,
-0.0224854387,
-0.0383051857,
0.0376131274,
-0.0285701193,
0.062356513,
0.032711979,
-0.0477619469,
-0.0211234912,
0.0123169813,
2.978e-7,
0.1109715402,
0.0294076558,
-0.0117504532,
-0.030380968,
0.0265474357,
-0.0021703141,
-0.0306968465,
0.0061357361,
-0.0049639703,
-0.0123062832,
0.0429728515,
0.0163710285,
0.0376944989,
0.0550874136,
-0.0852579251,
0.0038212307,
-0.0793109164,
-0.0268492959,
-0.0045038648,
-0.0033676075,
0.0334836133,
0.095239155,
-0.0469618924,
-0.040684443,
0.01749135,
-0.0411477201,
0.066411078,
-0.0257194173,
-0.0175690409,
0.060950242,
-0.0023252917,
0.0308681354,
0.0244579688,
0.044004593,
-0.0258708,
-0.002605631,
0.0141392509,
0.0893877149,
-0.0311377589,
-0.0096175484,
0.0187603422,
0.0066006556,
0.0331109576,
-0.0737570077,
0.0793315545,
-0.0548919365,
-0.0564313419,
-0.0091435174,
0.0035864434,
-0.0290877372,
0.0714537799,
-0.0196663179,
-0.0546470955,
0.0309005361,
0.0333449543,
0.0193071831,
-0.0177489966,
-0.0654648319,
-0.0269907974,
0.038010139,
-0.0280912947,
-0.0541637614,
0.0454262793,
-0.0321661681,
-0.0314092152,
-0.0574295819,
0.0152479224,
2.60113941e-34,
0.0148344012,
-0.0047552339,
0.0226808097,
0.0486303344,
0.0026107591,
-0.0074119312,
0.0026425894,
-0.0078832814,
0.020214295,
-0.0589928962,
-0.0156136956
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10160v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10160v2 | Stop Uploading Test Data in Plain Text: Practical Strategies for Mitigating Data Contamination by Evaluation Benchmarks | 2023-05-17T12:23:38 | 2023-10-18T13:17:13 | Alon Jacovi, Avi Caciularu, Omer Goldman, Yoav Goldberg | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Data contamination has become prevalent and challenging with the rise of
models pretrained on large automatically-crawled corpora. For closed models,
the training data becomes a trade secret, and even for open models, it is not
trivial to detect contamination. Strategies such as leaderboards with hidden
answers, or using test data which is guaranteed to be unseen, are expensive and
become fragile with time. Assuming that all relevant actors value clean test
data and will cooperate to mitigate data contamination, what can be done? We
propose three strategies that can make a difference: (1) Test data made public
should be encrypted with a public key and licensed to disallow derivative
distribution; (2) demand training exclusion controls from closed API holders,
and protect your test data by refusing to evaluate without them; (3) avoid data
which appears with its solution on the internet, and release the web-page
context of internet-derived data along with the data. These strategies are
practical and can be effective in preventing data contamination. | [
0.012093056,
0.1288314462,
-0.0324869156,
0.0492705964,
-0.0185503569,
-0.0225269347,
0.0491565168,
0.0418746658,
0.0044715381,
-0.0332262404,
-0.0164046958,
0.0328803696,
-0.0217000898,
0.07340765,
0.0414444841,
-0.00468435,
0.0332910381,
-0.0063534435,
-0.0280600488,
-0.0207992848,
-0.0089545846,
-0.0333748497,
0.0291837268,
0.0067680655,
0.003775365,
-0.0249164794,
-0.0187965389,
-0.0227268394,
-0.0194569416,
-0.0460940525,
0.0078087542,
0.0532633401,
-0.0206839852,
0.0550357364,
0.0000018442,
-0.0165968463,
-0.0453139469,
0.0468297303,
-0.0585483015,
0.0111471387,
0.0195459593,
0.0446865521,
0.0214250367,
0.0525054075,
-0.0403991677,
-0.0061598211,
0.0199826993,
0.0051342547,
0.1105900258,
0.0525775962,
0.0032943264,
0.047746826,
-0.0118970955,
-0.0006736744,
-0.000217062,
-0.0354977883,
-0.0024074896,
-0.0221003387,
-0.0031597232,
0.0071787559,
-0.040504884,
0.0415247455,
0.0233627744,
0.0408372581,
-0.0008334246,
0.0390076227,
-0.0538790934,
-0.0459517166,
0.0099983988,
0.0577769764,
0.0020730414,
-0.0232956558,
0.0133372415,
0.0026239315,
0.0142083615,
0.0214997716,
-0.0173137542,
0.0527496338,
0.0022435603,
0.0038682122,
-0.0648021176,
-0.0227936469,
0.008655211,
0.0103362175,
-0.0113971438,
0.0564595088,
0.0093885623,
-0.0448138639,
0.0179299582,
0.0331999436,
0.0148100983,
-0.0671519265,
0.0271375272,
-0.0188648272,
0.0079561155,
0.0006114182,
-0.0430979654,
-0.0984006897,
0.023316035,
-0.0047582509,
0.032427147,
-0.0104782814,
-0.0010934295,
0.0135841239,
-0.0185743105,
0.0378968045,
0.0123886392,
0.0543556288,
0.0054338276,
0.037746761,
-0.0161519777,
0.0023333034,
-0.0019376642,
0.0732886121,
-0.0144915096,
0.0244302973,
-0.0026999009,
0.0570168793,
-0.0594261289,
0.028875744,
-0.0449562669,
0.0443949923,
-0.0122949351,
0.0425212607,
-0.0053786761,
-0.0443533733,
-0.0134759713,
0.0093185408,
0.0066802818,
-0.0492466763,
-0.0202945769,
-0.0044843517,
0.0074725552,
-0.0035415147,
0.0239354223,
0.0861082748,
0.0546864793,
-0.0092040142,
0.009624985,
-0.0898526087,
0.0133622084,
-0.0025191221,
0.006799804,
-0.0085059842,
0.0090693841,
-0.0170357171,
-0.0160697959,
-0.0329951309,
-0.0325938091,
0.0378392115,
-0.0634687096,
0.0429356247,
-0.007579979,
-0.0030979803,
-0.0207905881,
0.0121479919,
-0.0341801308,
0.0346179381,
0.0125418426,
0.0325391851,
0.0569749773,
-0.0338003822,
0.0483359247,
0.0261535663,
0.066335842,
-0.0019542896,
0.0038839923,
0.0412056185,
0.0349365622,
0.002148407,
-0.0388576351,
0.0450916551,
-0.0232939664,
-0.0442965478,
0.0790079832,
0.0311652068,
-0.00226933,
-0.024786666,
-0.0474764965,
0.0020082912,
0.0105105601,
-0.000833933,
-0.0571948029,
-0.0353247598,
-0.0587686524,
-0.0251912065,
0.0057502799,
0.0203701798,
-0.0131688854,
-0.0174362417,
-0.0079680178,
-0.0370899327,
0.0317447297,
0.0676069707,
0.0358318575,
-0.0057965964,
-0.0153337596,
0.0106109269,
0.0015316725,
-0.0391644351,
0.0144711025,
-0.08867383,
0.0148976957,
0.0237197429,
0.0562370196,
0.0069901058,
-0.024152901,
-0.0331837758,
0.0088259624,
-0.0326511227,
-0.0091471672,
-0.0299565941,
0.0153663475,
-0.0154770939,
-0.0737493932,
0.0145009374,
-0.0063155806,
-0.0418117456,
0.0148763983,
0.0361495428,
0.0010781238,
-0.038583044,
-0.0409799516,
0.0418408327,
0.0228637364,
-0.0329586081,
0.0122437626,
0.0191022288,
0.0415511839,
0.0282495786,
-0.0199373197,
-0.0058721527,
0.0509415641,
0.0606383681,
-0.0016148757,
-0.0331061631,
0.0549547635,
0.0515965074,
0.0223801527,
-0.078280054,
-0.0190195553,
0.1009951159,
-0.0506947786,
0.0046683564,
-0.0326141529,
0.0100716511,
0.0106506972,
0.007537039,
-0.0070913802,
-0.0192821734,
0.0305024423,
-0.0451584607,
0.0032269936,
0.0111465594,
0.0113982018,
-0.0360437632,
-0.009947069,
0.0445945524,
-0.0416528769,
-0.0355443731,
0.0294792708,
-0.0320509337,
0.0208177883,
0.0173143577,
0.01908019,
-0.0598670281,
0.033760298,
-0.0604432262,
0.0009885498,
0.0053042336,
0.0537915863,
0.009600766,
-0.0233624019,
-0.0278381407,
-0.0371739157,
-0.0190021284,
-0.0442346744,
0.033322569,
0.0368755125,
0.0054467618,
0.0070923581,
0.0217867885,
0.0107004242,
-0.034696091,
-0.0162222032,
0.0738755688,
0.00634414,
0.0104979798,
-0.0323657431,
0.029587917,
-0.0452937707,
0.023778243,
0.0293015204,
-0.0164336879,
-0.0020556629,
0.0163334813,
-0.0946654007,
0.0733075887,
0.0168984532,
-0.0007655235,
0.0266053434,
0.0122362347,
-0.0477080569,
-0.0090533234,
0.0155289769,
-0.0389804468,
-0.0054807211,
-0.0127796186,
0.0490310714,
0.001936545,
-0.0123038916,
-0.0688593537,
-0.0186874624,
0.053702563,
-0.0587512888,
-0.0420376025,
-0.0467492603,
-0.016628813,
-0.020066943,
-0.0044694277,
-0.0072749374,
-0.0454258583,
0.0737970024,
-0.0077513815,
0.0279943924,
-0.0383902937,
-0.0083468491,
0.0136027681,
0.0280020069,
-0.0174697433,
0.0039995476,
0.0264718682,
-0.0104866186,
-0.0459970273,
0.0091221128,
0.0544558428,
-0.0813099593,
-0.0358937718,
-0.0020790661,
-0.0152573716,
-0.0029271715,
-0.0653863251,
-0.0235027224,
-0.0908319056,
0.0186672602,
-0.0097581092,
-0.0203540996,
0.023194667,
0.0162023511,
-0.0134600857,
0.0095523288,
0.0121509144,
-0.0060487529,
-0.0134364041,
-0.0005826616,
0.0186046958,
0.0167889185,
-0.031170018,
0.0269546881,
-0.0627511069,
-0.030204244,
0.0837216899,
0.0818049461,
0.0247112066,
0.0017460327,
-0.0016890164,
0.0085443035,
-0.0216050297,
0.0099148713,
0.021787703,
-0.0194355212,
-0.0371128768,
0.006342974,
0.0422694571,
0.0106724007,
-0.0086487345,
-0.0103961919,
0.0386603512,
0.0025985665,
-0.00878751,
0.0214608926,
-0.1256656498,
0.0367788486,
0.0301163811,
0.0717375949,
-0.0336195566,
-0.0517383069,
0.0170147661,
-0.0923490748,
0.0210436471,
0.0010900158,
-0.0387654044,
-0.0061478498,
-0.043549832,
-0.0159238707,
-0.0389386266,
0.0144224828,
-0.0292796772,
0.0179983638,
0.0511765033,
0.0503328666,
-0.0075537213,
-0.0361754671,
0.0292439722,
-0.0603277162,
0.0299238209,
0.0424179398,
-0.0062171593,
-0.0388482139,
-0.0191138387,
0.0136248041,
-0.0119768074,
-0.013178112,
0.0005650458,
0.0538794771,
-0.0155084468,
-0.0146372002,
0.018981209,
0.0274912715,
-0.0122707784,
0.0187791735,
0.0268310066,
0.0660083741,
-0.0166445673,
-0.0350356475,
-0.0414869413,
-0.0536991134,
0.0320127867,
0.0546705611,
-0.0067668674,
-0.0607534647,
0.0019397376,
-0.0141218537,
0.0452795625,
-0.0140715139,
0.0026783117,
0.0244112313,
-0.0336568989,
-0.0252383929,
-0.0664688498,
-0.0688958168,
0.0017205604,
0.0599474721,
0.0188556742,
-0.0354471542,
-0.0233519301,
0.0209411345,
-0.0564290732,
0.0575141907,
-0.0407234356,
0.0061960099,
-0.0366108976,
-0.0014033053,
-0.0083225621,
0.0099332882,
-0.0477714427,
0.0168598276,
-0.056615591,
-0.0604842529,
0.0437058695,
0.0774835795,
0.0339893065,
0.0166137349,
-0.0118164783,
-0.0500615984,
0.0723468289,
0.0228076354,
-0.0683937371,
0.0128794461,
0.0494387709,
-0.0808001831,
-0.0025580316,
-0.0188867878,
-0.0676974505,
-0.0082947547,
0.0603471473,
-0.028015798,
0.0028157835,
0.0056551686,
0.0124697182,
0.05249786,
0.067929104,
-0.0013155843,
-0.0273393318,
-0.0120123643,
0.040463835,
0.0045048832,
-0.0254537575,
-0.0267755575,
0.0131226564,
0.0129829682,
0.0286063477,
0.0078491913,
0.0363342501,
0.0324844681,
0.0376418233,
-0.0553001501,
-0.0022146045,
0.0494285189,
0.0199868921,
0.0293014627,
0.0126186181,
-0.0120935692,
-0.0150651513,
0.0303522237,
0.0392852463,
0.0039746827,
0.0052399328,
0.0283267051,
0.0155066485,
0.0251596961,
0.0501331054,
-0.0634720027,
-0.0467163287,
-0.0430521816,
0.0125493575,
-0.0093566515,
0.0469764806,
-0.044554282,
-0.0123139396,
-0.0072334227,
-0.0040530725,
-0.0393080637,
-0.0275516529,
-0.0287154894,
-0.0004129919,
-0.0131601281,
-0.0033120727,
0.0260369126,
0.0562856719,
0.0290264096,
0.060341645,
-0.0649199411,
-0.0252944361,
-0.0359494761,
0.027566677,
0.0472360291,
0.012031273,
-0.0098162647,
-0.0607707277,
-0.0160564687,
-0.0978148505,
0.0130983442,
0.0398650803,
0.0301726032,
0.0219329372,
0.0095779421,
0.0424553305,
0.0157315023,
0.0007370014,
-0.0343009792,
0.0093040178,
0.003591727,
-0.0500785969,
-0.0201601703,
-5.754533779e-33,
0.0246686526,
-0.0440932922,
-0.0079787299,
-0.0035746014,
-0.014551485,
0.0517907776,
0.0090827234,
-0.0372750051,
-0.020567799,
-0.0171822142,
-0.0415511318,
0.0329345763,
0.0197841898,
0.0262563657,
0.027407337,
-0.0313091502,
0.0441305451,
-0.0447461717,
-0.0624275915,
0.0302410312,
0.0024168347,
0.0373415016,
0.0180166457,
-0.0784968436,
0.0301642139,
-0.0203957185,
-0.0468008816,
0.0125546139,
-0.0557247773,
0.0486813597,
0.0050624553,
-0.0036826755,
0.0187579971,
-0.0147707807,
-0.0094026709,
-0.0076428968,
-0.0403994359,
-0.0308456346,
-0.0440276489,
0.0264127236,
-0.0058576628,
-0.0126397284,
0.1001022682,
-0.056784939,
-0.0011284942,
0.0134888105,
0.0106357168,
0.0067998352,
-0.0440429635,
-0.0238663405,
0.0366479047,
0.0009716873,
-0.0166952405,
0.0400752723,
0.073073715,
0.0619461909,
0.0312326606,
-0.0489328653,
-0.0217708722,
0.0264906045,
0.0530482568,
-0.0300380886,
0.0564912558,
0.027408326,
0.0138423378,
0.0734956488,
0.032899484,
0.0014755853,
0.0688618869,
-0.040822044,
0.0489525534,
0.0106601203,
0.0395770669,
0.0272509363,
0.0278373603,
-0.0383880362,
-0.0376483314,
0.0394077748,
-0.0215296503,
-0.0315781124,
-0.0147218956,
-0.0206913967,
-0.0695146397,
0.0003097712,
-0.0416775458,
-0.021362694,
-0.0311201401,
-0.032042183,
0.0381015092,
0.0257008299,
-0.0438671559,
0.0093326159,
0.0320319794,
-0.0773925483,
-0.0213842336,
-0.0081970496,
0.0468468741,
0.0319361128,
-0.0023740332,
-0.0136951199,
-0.0025079681,
-0.0175078921,
-0.0241069645,
-0.018263977,
0.0512100756,
-0.0245030113,
0.0203725062,
0.0390725099,
-0.035805352,
0.0152987195,
-0.036856886,
0.0185765699,
0.061371617,
-0.0201630015,
0.0302484129,
0.0336814113,
0.0365208536,
0.0104999486,
0.0397931412,
0.0301344767,
-0.0633997172,
0.0429156572,
0.0310670417,
-0.0362873152,
0.0312182046,
-0.0422259532,
0.0246656239,
0.0541811995,
0.0161790587,
-0.0521197282,
0.0007334385,
-0.0109964292,
2.601e-7,
0.015620565,
0.0322041214,
-0.0097241411,
-0.0385728553,
0.0077302083,
0.022287935,
-0.0127493739,
0.0566228665,
-0.0009651678,
0.0060660392,
0.009779416,
-0.0320618376,
0.0364987366,
0.0675064623,
-0.0675562099,
-0.0569558367,
-0.0220831279,
-0.0221978109,
-0.0727741718,
0.0128069576,
0.0467899852,
0.0655767545,
0.0292030107,
-0.0173092652,
0.0258442666,
-0.0426160507,
0.007794477,
-0.0189801808,
0.0044529466,
0.0014474064,
0.0354558751,
0.0280610286,
0.0174172651,
0.01492061,
-0.0417126417,
0.0031012769,
-0.01070303,
0.0271916352,
0.0130515136,
-0.027701417,
-0.0422798917,
-0.0852057487,
0.0001220111,
-0.0185437631,
0.0768614188,
0.0101362504,
-0.0183521025,
-0.0382279791,
-0.0261434484,
-0.1095125452,
0.0525631346,
-0.0166037679,
0.0210282467,
0.0184576847,
-0.0226641409,
-0.0080531584,
0.0025023604,
-0.0608681999,
0.0051330444,
-0.0169136524,
-0.0305317845,
-0.055869475,
0.022805443,
0.0160538405,
0.0035994388,
-0.0485204943,
0.0279400907,
2.537528864e-34,
-0.0089247525,
-0.0672320873,
0.0276313201,
-0.0141482344,
0.0287383627,
-0.0106441705,
0.0315892771,
-0.0168572627,
0.0021380826,
-0.0445788465,
-0.0285702497
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10156v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10156v3 | Personality Understanding of Fictional Characters during Book Reading | 2023-05-17T12:19:11 | 2023-10-29T08:57:47 | Mo Yu, Jiangnan Li, Shunyu Yao, Wenjie Pang, Xiaochen Zhou, Zhou Xiao, Fandong Meng, Jie Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Comprehending characters' personalities is a crucial aspect of story reading.
As readers engage with a story, their understanding of a character evolves
based on new events and information; and multiple fine-grained aspects of
personalities can be perceived. This leads to a natural problem of situated and
fine-grained personality understanding. The problem has not been studied in the
NLP field, primarily due to the lack of appropriate datasets mimicking the
process of book reading. We present the first labeled dataset PersoNet for this
problem. Our novel annotation strategy involves annotating user notes from
online reading apps as a proxy for the original books. Experiments and human
studies indicate that our dataset construction is both efficient and accurate;
and our task heavily relies on long-term context to achieve accurate
predictions for both machines and humans. The dataset is available at
https://github.com/Gorov/personet_acl23. | [
0.0235082228,
0.0283096302,
-0.0435696207,
0.0232961848,
0.0126426117,
0.0292709898,
0.0416859202,
-0.0438840091,
0.0212432034,
-0.0165075269,
-0.0117212096,
0.0288413111,
0.0224833209,
0.0087668588,
0.0232060459,
-0.0769002065,
0.0222084131,
0.0019974185,
0.0263379384,
0.0253259931,
0.0339122042,
0.0651012585,
-0.0065692877,
0.0277951434,
0.0031982618,
-0.0887780562,
0.0035864564,
-0.0113048237,
0.0473053902,
-0.0425360464,
0.0416624956,
0.0388042927,
0.0284431223,
-0.0148826875,
0.0000017009,
-0.0107253315,
0.0101514272,
-0.0178303402,
-0.0050397883,
-0.0353195406,
0.0381255783,
0.013551577,
0.0354540683,
-0.0168544035,
-0.025349291,
-0.0085777575,
0.0138429673,
0.0553962365,
0.0695917234,
0.0575208068,
-0.0074359365,
-0.0346614458,
-0.0388461575,
0.0048164702,
0.0603630506,
-0.0395484567,
-0.011265683,
-0.0018859425,
0.0015408412,
0.0247492455,
-0.0089236544,
-0.0058640917,
-0.0130951907,
0.0279281251,
-0.0078321761,
-0.0041232766,
-0.0049421806,
0.0154503351,
-0.0096297115,
0.1049358174,
0.0453978963,
-0.014623479,
-0.0180444997,
-0.016958423,
0.00645218,
0.0176327955,
-0.000106823,
-0.008199987,
-0.0389996283,
0.0065784338,
0.0082473829,
0.030243922,
0.0108312489,
0.0012502512,
0.0054282085,
0.038749028,
-0.0252024177,
-0.0137954317,
-0.0101092635,
0.0042885733,
-0.0237327777,
-0.0469241329,
0.0060666902,
-0.0005500215,
0.0175637454,
0.0358480699,
-0.0816277415,
0.0093010282,
0.0028801123,
-0.0173834134,
0.0302226208,
0.0038026175,
-0.0505153686,
0.0270119328,
0.0579347275,
0.0089420984,
0.0141953118,
-0.005272225,
-0.0127455499,
-0.0071954802,
-0.0571521372,
0.0204875879,
-0.0149640227,
0.0111675886,
0.0012749436,
-0.0241376776,
-0.0534457155,
0.0000162615,
-0.0098951468,
0.0289431028,
-0.0042708092,
0.0102172242,
-0.0288488641,
0.0157153197,
-0.0596419163,
0.0091780741,
-0.0886235833,
-0.0053276997,
-0.0238729678,
0.0074780001,
0.0397052355,
-0.0247329343,
0.0405648984,
-0.0472204611,
0.0248812679,
0.0340306014,
0.0597909205,
-0.0513533801,
-0.0687844306,
-0.063583076,
0.0105160428,
-0.0641938671,
-0.0255587045,
-0.0174802486,
0.0705816969,
-0.0102676591,
0.0123658301,
-0.0561480671,
0.0038021896,
0.0498571768,
0.0043379944,
0.1001488939,
-0.0362860858,
-0.014381133,
-0.0054423818,
0.0210961122,
-0.033338245,
0.0421090499,
0.0047389092,
0.00116574,
0.0638645068,
-0.021696711,
-0.0109636905,
0.0401602499,
-0.0082464311,
-0.0385173559,
0.0224677958,
-0.001381185,
-0.0113307638,
0.0530130416,
0.0215875097,
0.0002038335,
-0.0327585079,
-0.0413737558,
0.0736599267,
0.0844070166,
0.0074550565,
0.0400864556,
0.0070752967,
0.0325527005,
0.0325081237,
0.0191363897,
-0.0296188761,
0.0133311339,
-0.0139968023,
-0.0056944038,
-0.0487655178,
-0.0032535228,
0.0074244803,
-0.0206376184,
-0.0247903205,
0.0046157474,
0.0047114617,
0.0062482837,
0.0051088659,
0.0083900811,
0.001403004,
-0.0078615937,
0.0650823638,
-0.045648884,
-0.0008186737,
0.00927932,
0.0212622155,
0.1083455682,
0.0308615658,
-0.0584049262,
-0.0351311676,
-0.032052625,
0.003218605,
0.0012649138,
0.0098759606,
-0.0521509238,
0.0418050811,
-0.0449361205,
0.0317491107,
-0.0093029542,
-0.013422519,
0.0142315365,
0.0221034307,
-0.0024149991,
-0.0222710092,
-0.0185055546,
-0.0286003593,
0.0424912684,
-0.0922336951,
-0.0418410897,
-0.0156305842,
0.0369543806,
-0.0004673007,
0.0320126973,
0.0122013018,
-0.0518079996,
0.0178897064,
-0.0139162773,
0.0360589847,
0.0501374938,
0.0067123398,
-0.0140915988,
0.0523794964,
-0.0648269504,
-0.0567010045,
0.0269747805,
0.0056324448,
-0.0081492448,
-0.0323444717,
-0.0028262744,
0.0256786887,
-0.0117175682,
-0.0178408492,
0.011803057,
0.0511752963,
-0.0316154547,
0.0537305735,
0.0114122871,
0.0220223181,
0.0053359624,
0.0034949009,
-0.0254887138,
-0.0220754594,
-0.045669008,
-0.0505296662,
0.0535017513,
-0.0092994068,
0.0006273114,
-0.0130202733,
-0.056791231,
-0.0104360767,
-0.0733162761,
0.026347287,
0.0246005673,
-0.0139543666,
0.0401558541,
0.0036126671,
-0.039932169,
-0.0088658007,
-0.0502982214,
0.0128553929,
-0.0453294627,
0.0100768078,
0.0474583544,
0.013873376,
0.025231503,
-0.0298373215,
0.0081778113,
-0.0548625551,
0.0443678312,
0.00104195,
0.0225344878,
-0.0425700098,
-0.022057252,
-0.0181783494,
0.0192767866,
-0.005409867,
-0.0042436807,
0.0444813222,
-0.0036574234,
0.0027957326,
0.0579268187,
0.006198524,
0.0602535121,
0.0035849616,
-0.0450202972,
-0.0167030543,
0.0111427708,
0.0135904979,
0.037147902,
-0.0190010145,
-0.0529801175,
-0.0108816512,
0.0430401489,
0.001661842,
0.0038617996,
-0.0556100048,
0.0416126437,
0.0302542262,
-0.0319793485,
0.0077233529,
0.0334171392,
-0.0179179143,
0.0694005191,
-0.0243160278,
0.0245934129,
0.0818376914,
-0.0263268482,
0.0191093367,
-0.0222232454,
0.0108860033,
-0.0170752946,
0.0921279788,
-0.0132530713,
0.0120107811,
0.0183234494,
-0.0119803082,
-0.0120141739,
-0.0021824518,
0.0279652197,
-0.0103807496,
0.0380620956,
-0.0206493624,
-0.0416869111,
0.0195274688,
-0.0038424195,
-0.0401385091,
-0.0436464176,
-0.0706106052,
-0.0717605874,
-0.0160547588,
-0.037794441,
-0.0338986702,
-0.0314951986,
-0.0226307549,
-0.0042823497,
-0.0211431254,
-0.0351827815,
0.017322965,
-0.0178272109,
0.0633236542,
0.0140119269,
-0.0094754454,
-0.0398788042,
0.0059643532,
0.0421409234,
-0.0692987666,
0.0014154273,
-0.0103699677,
0.0220243521,
0.0114549538,
-0.05453391,
0.0063321502,
-0.0195339117,
0.0394419171,
-0.0756272376,
-0.0032210646,
0.1103016883,
0.0262019839,
-0.0491832159,
0.0222325847,
0.0083215265,
-0.0101361973,
0.0305585153,
0.0324655771,
-0.0907932594,
-0.0434872955,
-0.0146123106,
0.0445804074,
-0.0110531915,
-0.073312737,
-0.042004589,
-0.0810451582,
0.0144596221,
0.0086533939,
-0.0312159024,
0.010820929,
-0.0083170692,
0.0129455188,
-0.0303310584,
0.0282272846,
-0.0579154193,
-0.0006508413,
-0.0023509418,
-0.0271536205,
-0.0244490243,
-0.0090175653,
0.0776742846,
-0.0462093577,
0.0509085804,
0.0152151203,
0.0565716773,
0.0249996372,
-0.013777459,
-0.0352275372,
-0.0031751846,
0.0066781961,
0.0216074772,
0.0998053923,
-0.0540703498,
-0.0026641362,
-0.0644044802,
0.0721121132,
-0.0380876437,
-0.0424411744,
0.0443197042,
0.0426671728,
0.0147922849,
0.0242242366,
-0.0396183245,
0.0321486704,
0.0461204275,
0.0497701429,
-0.0049969503,
-0.0823812857,
-0.0278917365,
-0.0071707475,
0.0170421433,
-0.0464769602,
-0.0476185642,
0.0291864295,
-0.0088882372,
0.0001764184,
-0.0388759077,
-0.1059259772,
0.0355011038,
0.0326719023,
0.0404070094,
-0.0052412902,
0.0333434716,
0.0317919776,
-0.0586101599,
0.0386841483,
-0.0104101105,
0.0042207837,
0.0065384409,
-0.0541315377,
0.0496125557,
-0.0520544872,
0.0226459075,
0.042530328,
-0.0833074898,
-0.0363907143,
0.0463221706,
-0.0134060616,
0.0200900976,
0.0728793517,
-0.0067221895,
-0.0727207959,
0.0129770804,
-0.0077445311,
-0.0367590077,
0.0083564818,
-0.0350706428,
0.0348810293,
-0.0214218013,
0.0187178887,
-0.0102772443,
0.0045072464,
-0.0460008048,
-0.0514792204,
-0.0446923636,
-0.0566478148,
0.001973147,
0.0207740758,
0.0151595268,
-0.0246819388,
-0.0139734922,
-0.0632834285,
-0.031495288,
-0.0254596584,
-0.037073791,
0.0197248869,
-0.0628142804,
0.030504033,
-0.0338274315,
-0.06296812,
-0.0063853632,
-0.0211375225,
0.0221888088,
-0.0551814511,
0.0316449627,
0.0460722074,
0.0328228027,
-0.0341785364,
0.023715185,
-0.0135745127,
0.0034978257,
-0.0386264697,
0.0862591043,
0.0056760623,
0.0357414931,
0.0177645646,
0.0294183623,
-0.0235241465,
0.0382956043,
-0.0274438411,
0.0331321433,
0.0024582346,
-0.0076148957,
0.0025299375,
-0.0369735993,
0.0617686734,
0.002633645,
-0.0062278691,
0.0120743904,
0.0550551414,
-0.0051848036,
0.0000565855,
-0.0076832864,
0.0313653834,
-0.0004704649,
0.0113039734,
0.0666223913,
-0.0144088361,
0.012036073,
0.038985353,
-0.0590075105,
-0.0551968738,
0.0301403496,
-0.0210759565,
0.0642293766,
0.0157047939,
0.0046426668,
-0.0801276267,
-0.0682558864,
0.0715431273,
-0.0064919079,
0.0016329499,
0.0239870902,
0.0066048885,
0.0200474635,
-0.0037846426,
-0.0151716527,
-0.0515438914,
0.0290533267,
-0.0232615247,
-0.0287853256,
-0.0011804175,
-5.094293133e-33,
-0.0509129502,
0.0018724689,
-0.0062087663,
0.0453237593,
-0.0508338697,
-0.0018063879,
0.0141888391,
-0.0027740775,
-0.0084408708,
0.0212373789,
-0.0236224271,
0.004771546,
0.0042238836,
0.0008160044,
-0.0063113645,
-0.0161141604,
0.0134943817,
-0.0113159325,
-0.0187062733,
0.0358219482,
0.0587626994,
0.0263738222,
0.068249844,
-0.0962575451,
0.0223066509,
-0.0485168397,
-0.0142077776,
-0.0076930993,
0.0417068079,
0.0554193184,
-0.0185697749,
0.0597419105,
0.0251738001,
0.0087729897,
-0.0019054255,
0.0371562913,
-0.1137540415,
-0.0529703908,
-0.0007631812,
0.060743738,
-0.0100832283,
-0.0365997478,
0.0022373262,
-0.0022866786,
0.0304631982,
-0.0525690354,
0.088354513,
-0.0256787613,
0.0387007035,
0.033948537,
-0.0489760824,
0.0151084205,
-0.032354895,
-0.0145068085,
0.0296405964,
0.0018718102,
0.0102991257,
0.0016858032,
-0.0991722345,
0.0058621308,
-0.026772419,
-0.0165357813,
-0.030799238,
0.0421277247,
0.0138751715,
0.0885761678,
0.0816488713,
0.0490261912,
-0.0028132442,
0.0270602796,
0.034574151,
0.0060571595,
-0.0176517721,
0.0705003366,
0.0208250321,
-0.0190934483,
-0.030934969,
0.0308295935,
0.0719810203,
-0.0380810425,
0.0321210325,
-0.0280110314,
-0.0255268998,
-0.0191674288,
-0.0211656373,
-0.0511384159,
-0.0108131161,
-0.0182661023,
-0.0167060029,
-0.0544236563,
-0.0216800924,
0.0237383824,
-0.0053664623,
-0.0399733484,
0.0000679332,
0.0257628039,
-0.0251019876,
0.0190008078,
-0.0010438573,
-0.0020156491,
-0.0228747502,
-0.0063778511,
-0.0120975263,
0.0312922858,
0.0892932564,
-0.0006382231,
0.0394940786,
0.0139210606,
-0.0388974324,
-0.0361814089,
0.007665412,
0.0321375541,
-0.0373386294,
0.0505586714,
0.0199747421,
0.0100862859,
-0.0316855162,
0.0516115762,
0.010073171,
0.020837076,
-0.0386115275,
-0.0138430307,
0.0429912545,
-0.0235866681,
0.0028387716,
-0.0216432773,
-0.012478021,
-0.0202680081,
0.0241943318,
-0.0643994212,
0.0180416089,
0.0139022628,
2.312e-7,
0.0152764367,
0.0302198045,
0.0360264406,
0.0296466574,
0.0233016182,
0.0330665931,
0.0051942384,
0.0404879935,
0.0043398519,
-0.053078305,
0.0170163345,
0.0264920238,
0.016582828,
0.0672917441,
-0.0882924944,
-0.025973795,
-0.0029838157,
0.0355116837,
-0.0473953187,
0.0043771323,
0.0827018991,
0.0461863726,
0.0625376105,
-0.0283209216,
0.0529290549,
0.0149893798,
0.0157816466,
-0.0182299726,
0.0017854556,
0.0202129446,
-0.0128697073,
0.0317252018,
-0.0051965122,
0.0034187168,
-0.0044743367,
-0.0087360088,
0.0015331288,
0.0296193436,
-0.0283891298,
-0.0282140207,
-0.0019228715,
0.0277747288,
-0.025788134,
0.0004750675,
0.0543593056,
0.0065161884,
-0.0615965948,
-0.0253545996,
-0.0072176247,
-0.0142301107,
-0.0292908028,
0.0232397821,
-0.0150848553,
0.0393583439,
0.0168151557,
-0.0268550143,
-0.0137418238,
-0.1129870489,
-0.0131196445,
0.0280182026,
-0.0469376035,
-0.0136777787,
0.0073554153,
-0.0208797939,
0.0207171105,
-0.0751481056,
0.0298884548,
1.507125758e-34,
-0.0437690504,
0.0332074203,
-0.0114276921,
-0.0144590903,
0.0463058241,
-0.0214722026,
0.0252345633,
-0.0138134137,
0.0541791394,
-0.0454195403,
-0.0229425635
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10154v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10154v2 | Cultural evolution via iterated learning and communication explains efficient color naming systems | 2023-05-17T12:18:44 | 2024-04-16T12:44:07 | Emil Carlsson, Devdatt Dubhashi, Terry Regier | cs.CL | cs.CL | It has been argued that semantic systems reflect pressure for efficiency, and
a current debate concerns the cultural evolutionary process that produces this
pattern. We consider efficiency as instantiated in the Information Bottleneck
(IB) principle, and a model of cultural evolution that combines iterated
learning and communication. We show that this model, instantiated in neural
networks, converges to color naming systems that are efficient in the IB sense
and similar to human color naming systems. We also show that some other
proposals such as iterated learning alone, communication alone, or the greater
learnability of convex categories, do not yield the same outcome as clearly. We
conclude that the combination of iterated learning and communication provides a
plausible means by which human semantic systems become efficient. | [
0.0166436192,
0.0608641915,
-0.0530754067,
0.0224876851,
-0.017254794,
0.0150004169,
-0.0000117654,
0.0647470653,
-0.0792064592,
-0.0088998713,
-0.0455445908,
-0.0308540761,
0.0181241482,
-0.0283168796,
0.0300119296,
-0.0498281941,
0.0067670541,
0.0091157779,
0.0044774292,
-0.0381529033,
-0.0487208068,
-0.0519137532,
0.0531463288,
-0.0140310368,
-0.0120541975,
0.0356714912,
0.0059166295,
-0.0583011806,
-0.0308275186,
0.0098949885,
-0.0344990939,
0.0187789351,
-0.0151671777,
0.0906960368,
0.0000014711,
-0.0551601164,
0.0490427054,
-0.0388645455,
-0.0291259736,
0.0082613807,
0.026211869,
-0.0040213498,
-0.007901473,
-0.0860692412,
-0.0006611691,
-0.0352304615,
0.0633313656,
0.0002972392,
-0.0482651144,
0.028121572,
0.0251541547,
-0.0485504121,
0.0196308065,
-0.0472111702,
0.0371049494,
-0.0081116445,
0.0382527113,
0.0394250564,
0.0043062321,
-0.0142618855,
-0.0676948503,
0.028902892,
0.0413937382,
0.0503164083,
-0.0123496605,
0.0182746965,
0.024895981,
-0.0279327296,
0.021407662,
0.0252618063,
-0.0282171052,
0.0188197345,
-0.0120895896,
0.020496957,
-0.0175229795,
-0.0379826948,
0.0008111969,
0.0275776554,
-0.0190252308,
0.0126343379,
0.0163211096,
-0.0006263737,
0.0269802455,
0.0373404324,
0.0303506237,
0.0723182485,
0.0050495076,
-0.0126212658,
-0.0346738696,
-0.0333711579,
-0.0005820559,
-0.0716372877,
-0.026912665,
-0.0001703657,
0.0566337705,
0.0175962858,
0.0276724827,
0.0161358081,
-0.0002007913,
-0.0321215205,
0.0442938954,
0.0350891724,
0.0384131819,
0.0122595988,
0.0081311017,
0.0450632907,
-0.0425413884,
0.0050864625,
-0.0314553156,
0.0003656814,
-0.0475982726,
-0.0087965047,
0.012911763,
0.0102903834,
-0.0006901484,
0.003967559,
-0.0331901759,
-0.0083635394,
-0.0152493045,
-0.0198753402,
-0.0543082878,
-0.0411295556,
0.0199699327,
0.0218026526,
-0.0659450963,
-0.0369669609,
-0.0496000499,
0.0079126796,
-0.0126215387,
-0.006585524,
0.0296767652,
0.0059386343,
-0.0333334059,
0.0323641449,
-0.0100571197,
0.0687783957,
0.0139549375,
-0.0333240032,
-0.0406697877,
-0.0143931406,
0.0372247845,
0.0166261345,
0.0588191412,
-0.021233907,
-0.0044386229,
0.0039399248,
-0.010805117,
-0.074873805,
-0.029396465,
-0.0394968763,
-0.0403569713,
0.0263181459,
-0.0718395188,
0.0424303003,
0.0568969734,
0.0256306846,
0.0125243915,
0.0602294169,
0.0488654524,
0.0116864238,
0.0392507501,
-0.020024363,
-0.0260996297,
-0.0018256829,
0.0107735619,
-0.0116050821,
-0.0100036543,
-0.0812008083,
0.0418865122,
0.0358628221,
0.0496673286,
0.0386055708,
-0.0424302407,
-0.0754290968,
0.0121907089,
0.0583662093,
0.0440473892,
0.0589858778,
0.043836575,
-0.0324091911,
-0.0346273966,
0.0554491095,
-0.008175862,
0.0068837432,
-0.05312071,
-0.0397762209,
-0.0087408395,
0.0134722143,
-0.0404153205,
-0.0142687764,
-0.0044609676,
0.0225756224,
0.0376277417,
-0.0067414911,
0.0343503468,
0.0243248083,
0.0210233666,
-0.0303520635,
0.0519492775,
-0.00250955,
-0.0270076394,
-0.0550295971,
0.0644257516,
0.0407823659,
-0.0402596258,
0.0157198217,
0.0624115169,
0.0705176815,
0.0375718251,
0.0279231109,
0.022965949,
-0.0063833632,
0.0324166678,
-0.0235416088,
-0.0099042077,
-0.0056349444,
-0.0263939016,
0.0460582376,
-0.0129289282,
-0.0086860396,
0.0107120816,
0.0675017163,
-0.0300003029,
0.0110654421,
-0.0210414678,
-0.0088959355,
-0.0191362575,
-0.0071420567,
0.0392974168,
-0.0280709006,
-0.0231254771,
0.0141627891,
-0.034778256,
-0.0224403236,
-0.0261507872,
0.0285746939,
-0.0443659276,
0.0213791616,
0.012315887,
-0.0377012305,
0.0101857046,
-0.0323055722,
0.0403934903,
-0.0089770481,
0.0554034412,
-0.0446628705,
0.0641907975,
0.0125832902,
0.0249563456,
-0.0312049575,
0.0334955603,
-0.0207985267,
0.0663338155,
-0.0349558443,
0.0457608961,
-0.0459802859,
-0.0110106338,
0.0000381183,
-0.0452735871,
0.019167278,
0.038411852,
0.017878728,
-0.0167119857,
-0.0093781454,
0.0311085805,
-0.0202421434,
0.0331198499,
-0.0311651323,
-0.0059423805,
0.0157612022,
0.0013740996,
-0.0257764589,
-0.0134700984,
-0.0030594997,
-0.0094505381,
-0.0067317584,
0.1089746207,
0.0081317667,
0.061008323,
-0.0140936719,
0.0049736467,
-0.087971203,
0.0065834597,
-0.0696074069,
0.0090185739,
0.065758355,
0.0052157729,
-0.0219437834,
-0.0391277,
-0.0222607702,
-0.0625360012,
-0.0016570141,
-0.0390304886,
0.0059304638,
0.0127382157,
0.0031257411,
0.022741301,
0.0190327447,
0.0129289897,
-0.0005688145,
0.0519421026,
-0.0077587138,
-0.0125809321,
-0.0370636322,
-0.0471506417,
-0.0038131664,
0.0242724475,
-0.0524335913,
0.010829241,
0.1009316742,
-0.0010572709,
-0.0175082721,
0.005339874,
0.0674526393,
-0.0302265119,
-0.0856841803,
-0.0379774645,
-0.0830112547,
0.0144238854,
0.0776891038,
-0.058943633,
-0.0460369103,
0.0502360538,
0.0398534425,
0.0010611586,
0.0364466496,
-0.0161159225,
-0.0116936956,
0.0820943266,
0.0434144363,
0.0224697944,
0.0465411581,
-0.0141110485,
-0.0243260507,
0.0121445805,
0.0389139801,
-0.0096618617,
0.0345620848,
-0.0435297452,
-0.0273115579,
-0.0358888879,
-0.0535369366,
-0.013114891,
0.0353040993,
-0.0152037758,
0.0133248456,
0.0114491237,
-0.0063959197,
0.013560758,
0.0219958909,
0.0251606237,
-0.0191656481,
0.0353241563,
0.0078765275,
0.0280565582,
-0.0353932567,
-0.030908972,
0.0385490023,
0.0072773844,
-0.01705244,
0.0136905201,
0.0514819138,
0.0201255362,
0.0563630015,
0.0126824854,
0.062466383,
0.0486614332,
-0.0112045594,
-0.0628507435,
-0.0305710901,
0.0134004056,
-0.0262612849,
0.0449076183,
0.0336554833,
0.0043247258,
-0.0185947083,
0.0352383666,
-0.0380671807,
-0.0155673856,
0.0190535951,
0.0193317402,
-0.0458750464,
0.0150172589,
-0.0125654899,
-0.038584847,
-0.0255033094,
-0.0787305608,
0.0135224815,
-0.0589085929,
-0.0770694688,
0.0325014889,
-0.0756207034,
-0.007766983,
0.0122738378,
-0.0075688111,
0.0576422065,
-0.0170817822,
0.0313177072,
0.0374301672,
0.0012147891,
-0.0022687926,
0.0210855026,
-0.0145391542,
-0.0296178553,
-0.0346698277,
0.0095378207,
0.0465685539,
-0.0069483169,
-0.020123722,
-0.0720817447,
0.0735336244,
-0.0201633442,
0.0103063639,
-0.0215049163,
0.0034915905,
0.0552565679,
-0.004037308,
-0.0097436579,
-0.0306440741,
0.0404172316,
-0.0068521746,
0.0088663818,
0.003056444,
0.0265940353,
-0.0593256168,
-0.004521369,
-0.0082404632,
-0.0346307009,
0.0417622775,
0.0425627045,
-0.0647249967,
0.015495114,
-0.0440065637,
0.007995341,
0.0267346688,
-0.0834864527,
0.0288215913,
-0.0241702106,
-0.0966422632,
-0.0725908801,
0.0096232817,
-0.029795995,
0.0465897173,
0.0289827976,
-0.0815751925,
-0.0245533474,
-0.0223282762,
-0.0354803614,
0.0226183459,
0.0069593578,
-0.0503405333,
-0.0403105728,
-0.043244347,
-0.0027801497,
-0.0400564447,
0.0224498939,
-0.0016386473,
-0.0085883532,
-0.044271335,
0.0317935273,
0.0333438665,
0.0220495872,
-0.0073546492,
0.0528933033,
-0.098504439,
0.0054305294,
0.0254511032,
0.0696737617,
0.0388806313,
-0.0246333256,
0.0000282751,
0.0233905129,
0.0216482282,
0.0094672637,
0.0564425811,
0.0459912494,
0.0199875589,
-0.0466168784,
0.0369337387,
0.0200801939,
-0.0205696132,
0.0142880986,
-0.0379964635,
-0.0558921918,
0.0314299017,
-0.0172381662,
0.0173001047,
-0.001111208,
0.0159410667,
-0.0615145303,
0.0000256858,
0.0504103154,
-0.0039417632,
-0.0052270596,
0.0847666487,
-0.0047871331,
-0.0073109064,
-0.0087700458,
-0.0165023971,
0.0629507676,
-0.016208645,
0.050354559,
0.0172878858,
0.0843968615,
-0.0437995978,
0.0084943818,
-0.0050254599,
0.033269573,
0.0550999008,
-0.0135714924,
0.0002181875,
-0.0004715625,
-0.0360608511,
-0.0609627143,
0.0517819487,
0.0072146226,
0.0807658583,
-0.0187035203,
-0.0162261166,
-0.0298399609,
-0.0250375457,
-0.0119217383,
-0.0178812556,
-0.00483495,
-0.0506492481,
0.0028696221,
0.0300829373,
-0.0068935901,
-0.0217248946,
0.0419967286,
-0.0208835974,
-0.0032116061,
-0.0411293581,
-0.0294549167,
0.0159507282,
-0.0004685532,
0.0155509869,
0.0087463912,
0.0264490079,
0.017555777,
-0.035165254,
-0.0495115854,
-0.0171586443,
0.0370866694,
0.0702868029,
0.0521692373,
0.0482198,
0.0562520139,
0.0100248437,
-0.0412969515,
-0.0056959246,
0.0230694786,
-0.0434696227,
-0.0004355188,
0.0247340538,
-5.178520609e-33,
-0.0127408709,
-0.0131406132,
0.0003192127,
0.0622395314,
0.0196524579,
0.0168484636,
-0.0197769292,
0.0441433489,
-0.0582482591,
0.004678742,
0.0179054029,
-0.0451349616,
-0.0011708577,
0.0069938302,
0.0303040817,
0.0038715131,
-0.0336703435,
-0.0102664251,
-0.003779165,
-0.0407619029,
0.0292271953,
-0.006393353,
0.0474622361,
-0.0420012698,
-0.0585930198,
0.0800770894,
0.047087606,
0.0349774137,
0.0242764894,
0.006760289,
-0.0386870764,
0.0314359069,
0.0463878699,
-0.0274938792,
0.0032422703,
-0.0105735287,
-0.0494333468,
-0.0642736927,
-0.0036114517,
-0.0008508192,
-0.0498970449,
-0.0363204032,
0.0734426528,
-0.0185183305,
-0.0264965575,
0.0462564118,
0.0050577046,
-0.016202474,
-0.0525191389,
-0.0198594239,
-0.0277977474,
0.0190713648,
0.0521245748,
0.0413504206,
0.00877403,
-0.0420509465,
-0.0010295003,
-0.051121071,
-0.0581179783,
0.0611473508,
-0.0077342521,
0.0065948628,
0.015392486,
0.079095006,
0.0462251902,
0.0093586016,
0.1201508492,
0.0587569885,
-0.010559286,
-0.0229902864,
0.0379674882,
-0.0125758927,
0.0212736297,
0.0035134058,
0.0368346535,
-0.0552315079,
0.0240458157,
-0.0200166684,
0.0364623182,
-0.0281267185,
-0.0291776173,
0.0492476858,
-0.0383211523,
-0.0100049516,
-0.0068000089,
0.0399907716,
-0.0111040473,
-0.0283208247,
-0.0170846749,
0.0061373864,
0.0589408055,
0.0216835197,
-0.0057413969,
-0.0317460746,
-0.0418259203,
-0.0591817982,
0.0169948637,
0.0281642731,
0.0206265189,
-0.0410098247,
-0.0471305139,
-0.0000787472,
-0.0629549101,
0.0342876352,
0.0024467676,
0.0163225941,
0.0251806155,
0.0021729143,
-0.019876454,
-0.0048415917,
-0.0065765819,
-0.05802292,
0.0492927469,
-0.1226691231,
0.058888834,
-0.0163664427,
-0.0082187084,
-0.0463538431,
0.0929914638,
-0.0021393981,
-0.0411468707,
-0.0371922329,
-0.0480308756,
0.0462207347,
-0.0214555245,
-0.0007970334,
-0.0418914147,
0.0378612205,
0.0128705185,
-0.0231382512,
-0.0165241696,
-0.005656736,
2.396e-7,
0.0013841954,
0.000515848,
-0.0224019885,
0.025613647,
0.0299298614,
-0.0212459303,
0.0019951221,
-0.0061577549,
-0.0334737711,
-0.0415205397,
-0.011882606,
0.0141161475,
0.00071468,
0.0129286796,
-0.0294383839,
-0.0599041991,
0.0110526774,
0.0218053646,
-0.0262301564,
0.0358744673,
-0.0131262206,
0.0423799492,
0.037469998,
-0.0246422198,
-0.0113802897,
-0.0181703623,
0.0388939157,
-0.0487095006,
0.0618161336,
0.0011588982,
0.0208506733,
-0.0081938338,
-0.0163206942,
0.0162931774,
0.0356440879,
-0.0025645897,
-0.0181659553,
-0.0433746204,
0.025328666,
0.0399054736,
0.000464923,
0.0123516712,
-0.0020285116,
-0.0013153586,
0.0423968025,
0.020804178,
-0.0667544231,
0.033762455,
0.038985692,
0.0296694357,
-0.0396848172,
0.0314555578,
-0.0233779196,
0.0000801932,
-0.0199406389,
-0.0125410501,
0.0101020196,
-0.0708660334,
0.0322582945,
0.0271645561,
-0.0383431166,
-0.0454640985,
-0.034624029,
-0.014055117,
0.0071158195,
0.0242841188,
-0.0393408537,
1.608659427e-34,
-0.0213119965,
-0.0511093289,
0.027311977,
-0.0244890675,
-0.0036105711,
-0.0148203662,
-0.020504225,
-0.0124024171,
0.0528043918,
0.0005180837,
-0.0123814046
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10149v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10149v1 | Multi-Grained Knowledge Retrieval for End-to-End Task-Oriented Dialog | 2023-05-17T12:12:46 | 2023-05-17T12:12:46 | Fanqi Wan, Weizhou Shen, Ke Yang, Xiaojun Quan, Wei Bi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Retrieving proper domain knowledge from an external database lies at the
heart of end-to-end task-oriented dialog systems to generate informative
responses. Most existing systems blend knowledge retrieval with response
generation and optimize them with direct supervision from reference responses,
leading to suboptimal retrieval performance when the knowledge base becomes
large-scale. To address this, we propose to decouple knowledge retrieval from
response generation and introduce a multi-grained knowledge retriever (MAKER)
that includes an entity selector to search for relevant entities and an
attribute selector to filter out irrelevant attributes. To train the retriever,
we propose a novel distillation objective that derives supervision signals from
the response generator. Experiments conducted on three standard benchmarks with
both small and large-scale knowledge bases demonstrate that our retriever
performs knowledge retrieval more effectively than existing methods. Our code
has been made publicly
available.\footnote{https://github.com/18907305772/MAKER} | [
0.0578840114,
0.024801014,
-0.0029668291,
0.0403360575,
0.0071910997,
0.0041694194,
-0.012297119,
0.0074878819,
0.0287446622,
-0.0416154601,
-0.0233786181,
-0.0025041264,
-0.0677592382,
0.0372016616,
-0.0076721916,
-0.026281273,
0.0341430828,
-0.0022285003,
0.0475207642,
0.014715963,
0.0187818054,
0.0107410327,
-0.0361983478,
0.0375357158,
-0.0153289055,
-0.0071915765,
-0.0400415882,
0.0153178619,
0.0043884083,
-0.0356538631,
0.0597504489,
0.0320889242,
0.0119805383,
0.0062529538,
0.0000020234,
-0.0340748988,
-0.024283085,
0.0135145374,
-0.063378565,
-0.0500492528,
-0.0031365906,
0.0297232457,
0.0367605984,
0.0217293128,
-0.0563268326,
-0.0065903524,
0.0394638143,
0.103302151,
0.0522467196,
0.07088238,
-0.0077784983,
-0.0344825834,
0.0097360108,
-0.017908603,
0.0353532843,
-0.0398636647,
0.0094071729,
-0.0088717705,
0.029230129,
0.0495518669,
0.0131977964,
0.0169138368,
-0.0064209457,
-0.0249260142,
0.0069102752,
0.0082987947,
-0.012541268,
-0.0065612542,
-0.0019423927,
0.0908976346,
0.0533670783,
0.0376049317,
0.0249002837,
0.0226183832,
0.0229970142,
0.0042481003,
-0.0575238205,
-0.0179352872,
-0.0485665388,
-0.0267745443,
-0.053042464,
0.019572217,
-0.0417034999,
-0.0161294769,
-0.0190446842,
0.0370957553,
-0.0154916272,
-0.0374213494,
0.0215104744,
0.0071621821,
0.0319743268,
-0.0524150319,
0.007928377,
0.0330735184,
-0.0674840957,
0.0029693113,
0.0060604094,
-0.0009055047,
0.0306562744,
0.0038012986,
0.0054190941,
0.0256274585,
-0.0167250298,
0.0304540023,
0.0009193457,
0.0374760479,
-0.0085851634,
0.0038440118,
-0.0263429582,
-0.0318745002,
-0.1065935716,
-0.0138159171,
-0.0589976385,
0.0694053695,
-0.0518756956,
-0.0119613567,
-0.0029723463,
0.0197300017,
-0.0334043354,
-0.0104825301,
0.005458937,
0.0569724478,
-0.0392669663,
0.0156849567,
-0.0715206191,
0.0776953176,
-0.0513342284,
0.0302813109,
0.0472558849,
-0.0340510607,
-0.0289747994,
0.0044185813,
0.0248769689,
-0.0258297529,
-0.0031968551,
0.0652399585,
-0.0338912047,
-0.0117664589,
-0.0147905173,
-0.0536968447,
-0.0172017571,
-0.0746732056,
0.0120663932,
-0.0093993051,
0.0558282435,
-0.0078417351,
-0.0400737748,
-0.0415083021,
0.0291289911,
0.0247243624,
-0.0035169092,
0.0214127246,
0.003305949,
-0.0202511828,
0.0117390938,
0.0100362478,
-0.0291896891,
0.0858327746,
-0.022852283,
0.0383548476,
0.0322023407,
0.0204940345,
-0.0009550038,
-0.0429259613,
0.0356711298,
-0.0040013832,
0.0378790833,
0.0575904995,
-0.0243144222,
-0.0035726919,
0.0345361494,
0.0439409465,
-0.0552622378,
0.0119553367,
0.0479649454,
0.0048245061,
0.0369420908,
-0.0106750289,
0.0193827078,
0.0535184033,
-0.0134965228,
-0.0047870656,
-0.0452315882,
0.0473186262,
-0.023992667,
0.0107368175,
0.0442696102,
0.0234060679,
-0.0417045578,
-0.0460517779,
0.0555153005,
0.0158468168,
-0.0060296156,
0.0678487718,
0.0597222745,
0.0358693339,
-0.0529790595,
0.0396335348,
0.0187051445,
-0.0417167433,
-0.0276126377,
-0.0467491075,
0.0055148047,
0.0398943722,
0.0197642669,
-0.0356790498,
-0.0554536358,
-0.0189447999,
0.00722697,
0.0252571106,
0.0323828496,
-0.0256191976,
0.0378890894,
-0.035238035,
-0.0555770434,
-0.0033030997,
0.0055141393,
0.0275405645,
0.003309028,
0.0204376485,
0.0314489864,
-0.0186849628,
0.0060438365,
0.0169101022,
0.0363232978,
-0.0343612432,
0.0320452452,
0.0316636935,
0.0391169824,
0.045184087,
-0.0202143136,
0.0049424828,
0.0444077998,
-0.0226578414,
-0.0216530785,
-0.0272761732,
-0.0304313209,
-0.068512693,
0.0104682324,
-0.0111371828,
-0.001321714,
-0.0152282985,
-0.0186042879,
-0.069799073,
0.0280687828,
-0.018170638,
0.0164837688,
-0.0362050459,
-0.0174068213,
0.034310881,
-0.0064777485,
-0.0498892069,
0.0622649826,
0.0416199826,
-0.0106753875,
0.0089158071,
-0.0283835344,
0.0248880647,
-0.0733729377,
0.0105054909,
0.0165046528,
-0.0328877084,
0.0357825495,
0.0382381864,
-0.0039137229,
-0.042272713,
-0.0416187532,
-0.0912865028,
0.0204955488,
-0.0229529124,
0.0221788101,
-0.0260988716,
0.0302949362,
0.015847547,
-0.030460557,
-0.0409315117,
0.0166771375,
0.0243031848,
0.009699489,
0.0220127366,
0.0605854653,
0.0086534237,
-0.0188777763,
0.0138494167,
0.0242114123,
0.0227775108,
-0.005699249,
0.0233027115,
-0.0356170647,
-0.0028793765,
-0.0656270236,
0.0510434955,
-0.0042530145,
0.003321375,
0.04424477,
-0.0267394017,
-0.0038309237,
0.0412474088,
0.0329923555,
0.0375428163,
-0.0260106307,
-0.020993039,
-0.0934923589,
0.0707715079,
-0.0321508385,
-0.000238354,
-0.0124973282,
0.0249888152,
0.0289984047,
0.0633273944,
0.0047193351,
-0.0025018917,
-0.047491733,
0.0370951779,
0.0454843864,
-0.0249344185,
-0.0484677032,
0.0176816937,
-0.0026393526,
0.0296223946,
-0.0349430218,
-0.0038853588,
0.0739906654,
0.0016687805,
-0.0342694744,
-0.0304256901,
-0.0187777746,
-0.0219242461,
0.0516476184,
-0.0282986946,
0.0215596166,
0.0689754263,
-0.0282046404,
-0.0486890264,
0.0209073611,
0.0427172035,
-0.041663412,
0.034825813,
-0.0266439319,
0.0255258754,
-0.0166057218,
-0.0731677562,
-0.0553155318,
0.0036861182,
0.0147727123,
0.0010315366,
0.0083085196,
0.0057745399,
-0.0358914211,
-0.0190879405,
0.0380340293,
0.0117007708,
-0.0104013588,
-0.0242846627,
-0.0088877836,
0.0327295549,
0.0665815175,
0.0177373067,
-0.0158395246,
-0.0066179773,
0.0315271765,
0.0652305931,
0.042224668,
-0.0670896098,
0.0106427642,
-0.0299248025,
0.0227859393,
-0.0242332928,
-0.0027162805,
-0.010629449,
0.063494049,
-0.0489364415,
-0.0177554414,
0.0858208016,
0.0043465728,
0.0116418963,
-0.0224653147,
0.0176106263,
0.030725209,
0.0242742989,
0.0438786149,
-0.0916685387,
-0.0480824746,
-0.0119251115,
0.0393104665,
0.015124972,
-0.0377208665,
-0.0006385513,
-0.0933297798,
0.0529546514,
-0.0400949009,
-0.0178638864,
-0.0694825277,
-0.0106128668,
0.0074992497,
0.0107772434,
-0.0034221888,
0.0326419249,
-0.0032951108,
-0.0007070572,
0.0181760527,
0.0511653721,
-0.0063160881,
0.0201825835,
-0.0112984311,
0.0226983912,
0.058622174,
0.0360145643,
0.0577604957,
0.0031560764,
-0.022623077,
-0.0522483438,
-0.0053093028,
-0.0070825503,
0.0674197152,
-0.00777674,
-0.0144301271,
-0.0180650111,
0.0022111929,
-0.0271449983,
0.0118175298,
0.0330957063,
0.0346551724,
-0.0436891317,
0.005792045,
-0.0189797934,
-0.0142156687,
0.0631612167,
0.0679085106,
0.0056422921,
-0.0318363383,
-0.0592790395,
-0.0208858736,
-0.0204705968,
-0.0560631268,
0.0000926056,
-0.0063554845,
-0.0167149622,
0.0347255915,
-0.0777322426,
-0.0585142747,
0.0116218822,
0.0439690948,
-0.0208255686,
-0.0049538235,
0.0158075504,
0.0207501184,
-0.0395225808,
-0.0003290015,
-0.0188185386,
-0.0103840278,
-0.0289301388,
-0.0338586085,
0.0235078149,
-0.0493083596,
-0.026751196,
0.0275906753,
-0.0176242981,
-0.0520703755,
-0.0581205375,
0.0544169769,
0.0217716619,
0.0510414205,
-0.0024570313,
0.0147117814,
0.0382974148,
0.0329378918,
-0.0843643621,
-0.0399400331,
0.0419897884,
0.0338595994,
-0.0221357644,
0.0451585054,
-0.0775296688,
0.0417012945,
-0.0241783094,
0.0327287726,
-0.0112099983,
-0.0672450066,
0.0088599306,
0.0081158904,
0.0409233496,
0.053560663,
-0.0171610229,
-0.0491453707,
0.0387748405,
-0.0109367464,
-0.0279466193,
-0.0737785995,
0.0071859439,
-0.0286582317,
-0.0416376591,
0.0412816219,
0.0066109076,
0.000647884,
0.0594113544,
-0.0387996212,
-0.0287675168,
-0.0029009357,
0.0225159116,
0.0393117145,
-0.0117644016,
-0.0138588501,
0.0353601426,
0.0644085705,
0.0553565361,
-0.024345953,
0.0911996141,
0.0274279322,
-0.0054738182,
-0.0026637181,
-0.0066121151,
-0.0832515806,
-0.030595405,
-0.0208166912,
-0.0011421858,
-0.0185494572,
0.0223916285,
0.0292726438,
-0.0052386909,
0.0013863608,
-0.018542286,
0.0477380827,
0.0000068657,
-0.0170826837,
0.0080376305,
0.0383309685,
-0.0030640489,
-0.0207701586,
0.0861342251,
-0.009887822,
0.0279612653,
-0.0174626093,
0.0006570196,
-0.0815122351,
-0.063718617,
-0.0069321916,
0.0262638517,
0.005541984,
0.0004158742,
-0.0385314636,
-0.0259424262,
-0.0216027517,
-0.0154566057,
-0.0413769782,
-0.0160767362,
0.0690823719,
0.0440442339,
0.012531898,
-0.0522078648,
-0.039202515,
-0.02469128,
-0.0600662082,
-0.0091463272,
-0.003134802,
-5.95871274e-33,
-0.0523568355,
-0.0048615858,
0.0435108319,
-0.009470298,
-0.0291549359,
-0.0262496639,
-0.0368872732,
-0.0123367971,
-0.051470872,
0.0324864164,
-0.0064419731,
-0.0002178742,
-0.0000318369,
0.0392640606,
-0.0148752872,
-0.0187505465,
0.0609328672,
-0.0207279567,
-0.0054866336,
0.0766327456,
0.0771510899,
0.0469691679,
0.0167774502,
-0.0674540699,
0.0296490695,
0.0130091291,
0.0155529231,
0.0462657064,
0.0258768518,
0.0531914383,
-0.0128471106,
0.0778902397,
0.0046104807,
-0.0519391932,
-0.0126155047,
-0.0033099374,
-0.1106994152,
-0.0518430322,
-0.0222667959,
-0.0287456848,
-0.0344290473,
-0.0147638982,
0.0322200581,
-0.0202680212,
0.0463204682,
-0.018019313,
0.0211417247,
-0.000434811,
-0.0077706226,
-0.046207875,
-0.064192839,
-0.0218489803,
-0.0301697012,
-0.0531569012,
-0.0060595768,
0.0614325665,
0.0414504558,
-0.0461763665,
-0.0153153334,
0.00977863,
-0.0037039749,
0.0004183774,
-0.0027011922,
0.0358105712,
0.0018344991,
0.0595411621,
0.0305207819,
0.0258401781,
-0.0171118081,
-0.0539469719,
-0.0256303325,
0.0874777287,
-0.0129431598,
0.0580664463,
0.0204968639,
-0.0247139316,
-0.061640162,
0.0408798493,
0.0001848137,
0.064770259,
-0.0103787603,
0.0040977937,
-0.0244454071,
-0.0146009168,
-0.0204011109,
0.015308449,
-0.0352988653,
-0.0219572261,
0.0555385798,
0.0499786064,
-0.0037916913,
-0.0223466121,
0.0279791094,
-0.0249906555,
0.0132094696,
0.0492307246,
-0.0262537021,
-0.0370623209,
-0.0036532024,
-0.0371508636,
-0.0450571105,
-0.0192594826,
0.0560596101,
0.0124691585,
-0.0184752755,
0.0228963923,
-0.0005068809,
-0.0325563028,
-0.0525803491,
0.0084770601,
-0.0502114445,
0.0864849016,
-0.0348484553,
0.0138191786,
-0.0023018615,
0.0020174254,
-0.0182662848,
0.0564812124,
-0.0190466922,
-0.0133908903,
-0.0491293557,
-0.0139314141,
0.060835842,
0.0005200881,
-0.0236188248,
0.0245003831,
-0.0075809238,
-0.0308950879,
-0.0063488293,
-0.0168475918,
0.0073517566,
0.0039432575,
2.682e-7,
0.0001283546,
0.0095312139,
0.0338857248,
0.0338324793,
0.0046931701,
0.0496608615,
0.0373280905,
0.0082265595,
0.0292510092,
-0.0381137393,
0.0073039364,
0.0420638695,
0.0391780809,
0.0287737846,
-0.1239426509,
-0.0405633263,
0.0073781624,
-0.060211055,
-0.0274774618,
-0.025195986,
0.0663970262,
0.0314957947,
-0.0229467694,
0.0083436426,
0.0054299873,
-0.0219220892,
0.0375339985,
0.0043948968,
0.0306080543,
0.032992512,
0.0443916395,
-0.0229669753,
-0.0049668849,
0.0470860973,
-0.0098738251,
0.021654278,
-0.010542498,
0.0474332273,
0.001975398,
-0.0793994367,
-0.0048562903,
-0.0147126028,
0.0347986594,
-0.0178429689,
0.0609598495,
-0.0582927763,
-0.0008405704,
-0.024768468,
-0.0289804153,
-0.040155828,
-0.0304341614,
-0.0008483095,
0.0114471745,
-0.0031999392,
0.0028182024,
0.0049662008,
0.0131457187,
-0.0813412592,
0.0172539931,
0.0259128362,
-0.0379590057,
-0.0620063581,
-0.0208304506,
-0.0338388383,
0.0083461385,
-0.0402028747,
-0.0111417435,
2.190376914e-34,
0.0001654205,
0.0038056246,
0.0107595231,
0.0335138738,
0.0459459089,
-0.0022534202,
-0.0608531311,
-0.0139410775,
0.0337365009,
-0.0660940185,
-0.0138647566
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10142v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10142v1 | Improving Language Model Negotiation with Self-Play and In-Context Learning from AI Feedback | 2023-05-17T11:55:32 | 2023-05-17T11:55:32 | Yao Fu, Hao Peng, Tushar Khot, Mirella Lapata | cs.CL | cs.CL | We study whether multiple large language models (LLMs) can autonomously
improve each other in a negotiation game by playing, reflecting, and
criticizing. We are interested in this question because if LLMs were able to
improve each other, it would imply the possibility of creating strong AI agents
with minimal human intervention. We ask two LLMs to negotiate with each other,
playing the roles of a buyer and a seller, respectively. They aim to reach a
deal with the buyer targeting a lower price and the seller a higher one. A
third language model, playing the critic, provides feedback to a player to
improve the player's negotiation strategies. We let the two agents play
multiple rounds, using previous negotiation history and AI feedback as
in-context demonstrations to improve the model's negotiation strategy
iteratively. We use different LLMs (GPT and Claude) for different roles and use
the deal price as the evaluation metric. Our experiments reveal multiple
intriguing findings: (1) Only a subset of the language models we consider can
self-play and improve the deal price from AI feedback, weaker models either do
not understand the game's rules or cannot incorporate AI feedback for further
improvement. (2) Models' abilities to learn from the feedback differ when
playing different roles. For example, it is harder for Claude-instant to
improve as the buyer than as the seller. (3) When unrolling the game to
multiple rounds, stronger agents can consistently improve their performance by
meaningfully using previous experiences and iterative AI feedback, yet have a
higher risk of breaking the deal. We hope our work provides insightful initial
explorations of having models autonomously improve each other with game playing
and AI feedback. | [
0.0553621985,
0.0641531497,
-0.0380479693,
0.015522087,
-0.0473467223,
-0.0286579859,
0.0194916259,
-0.0001286947,
-0.0060005998,
-0.0444665141,
-0.0767431259,
-0.0228976328,
0.0121998731,
0.0450092256,
0.0156547353,
-0.0397844687,
0.0154058728,
-0.0440075099,
0.0533076711,
-0.0561248548,
-0.0048470269,
-0.0492320061,
0.0017714204,
0.020966446,
-0.0134847537,
-0.0015730279,
-0.0391916558,
-0.0439069644,
-0.0129499538,
-0.0251686666,
-0.0189491324,
0.0361083001,
0.0147496788,
0.0096840868,
0.0000020677,
-0.0647575781,
-0.016527608,
-0.0434972867,
-0.026967926,
0.0010306576,
0.0685753152,
-0.0128920926,
-0.0079946117,
0.0195044857,
-0.0852297768,
-0.0097944867,
0.020525163,
0.0468784384,
0.0764812008,
0.0683650151,
0.0081093069,
0.0313838869,
-0.016304642,
-0.0344373696,
-0.0079011228,
-0.0814735889,
0.0097064674,
-0.0022954429,
0.0005683182,
0.0127083808,
-0.0310562626,
0.0018295324,
0.0079735368,
-0.0560842715,
-0.0642467588,
0.0623523965,
-0.043114543,
0.0038486393,
-0.0203940943,
0.0285882726,
0.0144469636,
-0.0042083669,
-0.0047949036,
-0.0090629496,
0.0320359021,
-0.025745146,
-0.0290796384,
0.0330416746,
0.0443923809,
0.0171418786,
0.0090901954,
0.0054019592,
0.0573863313,
0.0118135381,
-0.0135273961,
0.0767456517,
-0.0402454883,
-0.0446561575,
-0.0027568296,
0.0047906027,
-0.0091517437,
-0.0799272656,
-0.0419955514,
0.0542911217,
-0.0715091079,
0.0326073207,
-0.0170462448,
0.0581284054,
0.0022648864,
-0.0450753756,
0.0407855287,
0.0207924601,
0.0199768357,
0.0607976019,
0.0355639979,
0.0161248464,
0.0251243301,
0.0253872145,
-0.0013037272,
0.0315657966,
-0.0258258749,
-0.0198911317,
-0.0629744902,
0.0613566004,
0.0157865304,
0.0019229496,
-0.0125449896,
0.0032338637,
-0.0645686761,
0.0611121804,
-0.0179787446,
-0.003360997,
-0.0191359725,
-0.0045992634,
-0.0721123666,
-0.0069092563,
-0.0375220999,
-0.0039434452,
0.0352621004,
-0.0389198922,
-0.0152579052,
-0.0162005164,
-0.0256628916,
0.0172344055,
0.0314446017,
0.0756663308,
0.0071383375,
-0.0123737482,
0.0209815316,
-0.0160480719,
0.0219298583,
-0.0858667046,
-0.031233849,
-0.0420823954,
0.0203666277,
-0.014012984,
-0.0459334143,
-0.0591159649,
0.0023234561,
-0.0440490469,
-0.0136026731,
0.101944685,
0.034398105,
0.0243257731,
0.0352837332,
0.0063593779,
-0.0609207749,
0.0669440031,
0.0745969936,
-0.0064411834,
0.0488114916,
0.0064253602,
0.0552402809,
0.0657366738,
-0.0023389799,
0.0458890423,
0.0291711576,
-0.0091932574,
0.0169191286,
0.058335539,
-0.0195872039,
0.0238943342,
-0.0341652967,
-0.0199539885,
0.0856280401,
0.0476516597,
-0.0001253611,
0.0311021935,
0.0101472391,
0.0372612439,
0.023447806,
-0.0034836109,
-0.0385224298,
0.0185446069,
0.0011701299,
-0.0110190511,
-0.016378263,
-0.039965231,
-0.0187140461,
-0.0631104484,
0.0347262137,
-0.0254040379,
0.0563051254,
0.0595511831,
0.0272216909,
0.0038059913,
-0.05384361,
-0.0083024502,
0.0078115058,
-0.0046551009,
-0.0042675482,
-0.0686827824,
0.0120541817,
0.0359032564,
0.0606543981,
-0.0476721711,
-0.0150107536,
-0.0040361048,
-0.0667921454,
0.0686438382,
0.0627508685,
-0.0204241835,
-0.0062079448,
-0.0025506434,
-0.0067234104,
-0.0261072554,
0.0002954607,
0.0487065539,
-0.0246935803,
-0.013752819,
-0.0229685195,
0.0298118722,
0.0172966272,
-0.0003576523,
0.0123439971,
-0.0375486612,
-0.0057086591,
-0.0067821303,
0.0239800047,
-0.0271368157,
-0.0062164213,
0.0078438018,
0.0066300356,
0.0039429953,
-0.0319408253,
0.0442739502,
-0.047617767,
-0.0003491637,
0.0414200574,
0.0158435237,
0.0006354515,
0.0032088072,
-0.0016721634,
-0.0170600098,
0.0572644398,
0.0112650879,
0.0424845293,
0.0132195773,
0.0178414155,
-0.0154857244,
-0.0163090993,
-0.0080509176,
0.0253646635,
0.0226537529,
-0.0283678677,
-0.0128394524,
0.0195298791,
0.0008038253,
-0.0289489385,
0.0228811204,
0.0540582649,
0.0022625115,
0.0309395138,
0.0531968586,
0.0118489536,
-0.008014611,
-0.0337377861,
-0.0472181439,
-0.0309754312,
0.0161059368,
-0.0100650573,
0.0230432656,
-0.0330862403,
0.002705497,
0.0085460898,
-0.0106929578,
0.0182300657,
0.063407667,
0.008796188,
0.0269087609,
0.0237660073,
-0.0352928117,
-0.056585256,
0.0008207891,
-0.0145552168,
0.0179542061,
0.0162939671,
0.0373959616,
-0.0771084651,
0.0137046296,
-0.035203848,
0.0464489758,
-0.0413632281,
-0.0724588707,
0.0290309731,
-0.0192488451,
-0.0257074311,
0.0720913336,
-0.0181124508,
0.0722215325,
0.0664268881,
-0.0489056893,
-0.0726518035,
0.0335162729,
0.0113675399,
0.0075928797,
-0.1147955507,
-0.0011520468,
-0.0008352186,
0.0898133144,
-0.0118039073,
-0.0017205635,
-0.017754443,
0.063780196,
0.0240182653,
-0.0605249703,
-0.0021054402,
-0.0460580289,
-0.029728137,
0.0545552969,
-0.0161406714,
-0.0296311565,
0.0500408374,
-0.0021957487,
-0.0173589904,
-0.012214019,
0.0289195292,
-0.0193242896,
0.111360006,
-0.0115099587,
-0.0018683361,
-0.0223291013,
-0.0055031185,
-0.0497939363,
-0.0346926115,
0.1162152663,
-0.0233067293,
0.060824234,
-0.0546002425,
0.011653726,
0.0125544053,
-0.0627781004,
-0.0316353701,
0.0022757507,
-0.0349724144,
0.0312619247,
0.043816153,
-0.0151531724,
-0.0431535803,
0.0025074673,
0.0146047529,
0.0157014579,
0.0280751754,
-0.0170957446,
0.0004979009,
-0.0655289367,
0.0174865816,
0.0259135701,
0.0035175933,
-0.0434050001,
0.0803031623,
-0.0003833749,
0.0084807966,
-0.0100220693,
0.0021114815,
0.0114509529,
0.0167250186,
-0.0350292437,
-0.0031257817,
0.0193828009,
-0.0171499364,
-0.0496419407,
-0.0259655118,
0.0600156598,
0.0253879204,
-0.0095894514,
0.0330147892,
-0.0340509713,
0.0032957557,
0.0153546371,
0.0331622362,
-0.0763260722,
0.0155268265,
-0.0043097106,
0.0082638822,
-0.0113059804,
-0.0351763926,
-0.0241339356,
-0.1189826876,
0.0116939023,
0.0071045789,
-0.0342761986,
0.0433740616,
0.0076259701,
-0.03886481,
-0.0209293906,
0.0307381935,
0.023743229,
0.0156204356,
-0.0266959965,
-0.0331302807,
0.0206238218,
0.0201216172,
0.0184891224,
-0.0260496978,
0.0605509058,
0.057892818,
0.0269914772,
0.0005015663,
0.0364587791,
0.0297365617,
0.073435761,
-0.0086956723,
-0.0063694082,
0.0165766086,
0.000449335,
-0.0047397949,
0.0253108647,
-0.0098188324,
0.0176370572,
-0.0129679041,
0.0179096945,
-0.0000615539,
-0.0065533752,
-0.0430814959,
0.0464558452,
-0.0074226139,
-0.0083469748,
0.0526185706,
-0.0186998714,
-0.043979723,
-0.0448375195,
-0.028785184,
-0.0448842347,
-0.0184100661,
-0.0693209916,
0.0071235071,
0.0558344685,
0.0233959481,
-0.0504593551,
-0.1005996391,
-0.0030953377,
0.0162856858,
0.0180022698,
0.0246205796,
0.0251085497,
0.0280000102,
0.0393714085,
-0.0500534177,
-0.0218206719,
-0.0330520347,
-0.02191291,
-0.0156360772,
0.0240731239,
-0.0795286447,
-0.0186048392,
-0.0282646157,
-0.0422316417,
-0.0478141792,
0.003301061,
0.0928270444,
0.0266269837,
0.0382494703,
0.0079920795,
-0.0305143129,
-0.0340268202,
-0.0000284374,
-0.0225834101,
-0.007166625,
0.0652198941,
0.031346634,
0.0121630048,
0.053671129,
-0.0344184339,
0.0216874182,
0.0303120501,
0.0295808855,
-0.0031475248,
-0.0150602376,
0.0658522174,
-0.012842915,
-0.0451018363,
0.0012982991,
0.0008438769,
-0.004962692,
0.0357797109,
-0.0431156829,
-0.029504355,
-0.0298813321,
-0.0239810683,
0.0134466235,
-0.0036841091,
0.0314114764,
-0.0117159374,
-0.0072281044,
0.0020803758,
0.0232023299,
0.0315825455,
-0.0097756851,
0.0062923296,
0.0193678569,
0.0096007427,
0.0340772122,
0.0375886187,
0.0165692475,
0.0183192268,
0.0145779252,
0.0341396146,
0.0480726734,
-0.0537988879,
-0.0052088024,
0.0075740507,
-0.0419579372,
-0.0680304244,
0.0528194904,
0.0496994182,
0.0618963577,
0.0107561257,
0.0114466911,
-0.057077188,
0.0191692188,
0.0072892262,
-0.0198031012,
0.0009627416,
-0.066189304,
0.0154938092,
0.0101027237,
-0.0028895675,
0.0388424918,
0.0538869649,
-0.0308922771,
0.0654133931,
-0.0175318792,
0.024324853,
-0.0395676196,
-0.012589274,
-0.0213641413,
-0.0262217633,
-0.0315507092,
0.0112633575,
-0.026128171,
-0.010080629,
-0.0468966626,
0.0301838405,
-0.0076446626,
-0.0104067512,
0.0011479963,
0.0428944305,
-0.0078169713,
0.0002528662,
-0.0357101336,
0.0071269856,
-0.0124677708,
-0.014640945,
-0.0107167,
-5.993189255e-33,
0.0105465287,
-0.0428110212,
0.0353752784,
0.0463839471,
0.0045370329,
-0.0456312001,
-0.0351556614,
0.0086338269,
-0.0048318543,
0.0298759136,
-0.0304591861,
-0.0044215103,
0.017879786,
-0.0236427225,
0.0388379581,
-0.020983316,
0.0415114351,
-0.011844445,
-0.0746313632,
-0.0033522048,
-0.0620401204,
0.0055633727,
0.0634840727,
-0.0310308672,
0.0266472418,
-0.0406674556,
-0.0687383488,
0.0369855464,
-0.0383979157,
0.056668207,
0.0171531886,
-0.0137350354,
0.0066692606,
-0.0534790903,
0.0074331514,
-0.0228605326,
-0.0342501327,
-0.0062240879,
0.0118408743,
-0.0145040499,
-0.0317429528,
-0.0126905637,
0.0275228843,
0.0012488193,
-0.0562895089,
0.0114779556,
-0.0118776644,
-0.0095168687,
-0.0054884749,
0.0480419584,
-0.0512466058,
0.0031084318,
-0.0409167968,
-0.0232431684,
0.0198828429,
0.004926817,
0.0000997367,
-0.0421666466,
-0.061322201,
0.0617587417,
0.0069276416,
0.0217243545,
0.0300155394,
-0.0155832469,
0.0324379541,
0.0515891351,
0.0170104187,
0.0692560449,
0.0375889875,
-0.1074560657,
0.0149717005,
0.0546640158,
0.0114890151,
0.0525940433,
-0.0227042139,
-0.0088179251,
-0.0159189776,
-0.0177979525,
0.0646560937,
0.0383151472,
-0.0188304782,
0.0050939303,
0.0086302152,
-0.0137898605,
-0.0642125979,
-0.0343589447,
-0.0101596974,
-0.066549018,
0.0141137484,
0.0365700349,
0.0346721448,
-0.0180474482,
0.0146292821,
-0.0507178307,
-0.0902259946,
-0.0305965375,
-0.0034549991,
0.0343360119,
-0.0144692883,
-0.0153375473,
-0.040693175,
-0.0330357589,
-0.0367384739,
-0.0042756237,
0.0155823734,
0.0534920953,
-0.0008539403,
0.0440241359,
-0.0387147665,
0.0055939853,
-0.0225170292,
0.0313563459,
-0.0011420995,
-0.0413562693,
0.0150217246,
-0.0115888985,
-0.0150050176,
-0.0100247441,
0.0104430104,
-0.0517012589,
-0.0638437718,
0.0495794378,
-0.0426145606,
0.0137717361,
-0.0173998158,
0.010132649,
-0.0437785648,
0.035220921,
0.0216413941,
-0.0193496924,
-0.0190539155,
-0.0584583245,
2.844e-7,
-0.0134110395,
0.0770711675,
-0.023936158,
0.0679490343,
0.003071558,
0.0891815126,
-0.0734686553,
0.0187312979,
0.0051032859,
-0.0197753105,
0.02960141,
0.0442659892,
0.0296616349,
0.0393101498,
-0.040049538,
0.030015273,
-0.0556182228,
-0.0477662385,
-0.0092376396,
-0.0645228028,
0.0253002029,
0.0324226394,
0.03389927,
0.0073684556,
-0.020489363,
-0.0398580022,
0.0483091362,
-0.0619631559,
-0.0106466161,
0.0607505552,
-0.0177445821,
-0.0169545207,
-0.0091736019,
-0.0017975665,
-0.0022417544,
0.0317136794,
-0.058830265,
0.0131251421,
0.0090086618,
-0.0140264221,
-0.0207432415,
0.0103923921,
-0.0014723742,
-0.0431240276,
0.0236661099,
-0.045700945,
-0.0369938947,
-0.0365950204,
0.0376748964,
-0.0367948338,
0.0051148837,
-0.0115022687,
-0.0162471645,
0.0233274773,
-0.0155583173,
0.0248785242,
0.0500390753,
-0.0342982747,
-0.0320839994,
0.0024461516,
-0.004334494,
0.0019373008,
0.0056461226,
0.0184801351,
-0.0096599879,
-0.0459492244,
0.011186827,
1.95012171e-34,
0.0413965024,
-0.0284887962,
0.0251457896,
0.0774209052,
0.0659395456,
0.0199064054,
-0.00533769,
0.0240882989,
0.0402102992,
0.009340357,
-0.0309466943
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10136v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10136v1 | Additive manifesto decomposition: A policy domain aware method for understanding party positioning | 2023-05-17T11:39:31 | 2023-05-17T11:39:31 | Tanise Ceron, Dmitry Nikolaev, Sebastian Padó | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | Automatic extraction of party (dis)similarities from texts such as party
election manifestos or parliamentary speeches plays an increasing role in
computational political science. However, existing approaches are fundamentally
limited to targeting only global party (dis)-similarity: they condense the
relationship between a pair of parties into a single figure, their similarity.
In aggregating over all policy domains (e.g., health or foreign policy), they
do not provide any qualitative insights into which domains parties agree or
disagree on. This paper proposes a workflow for estimating policy domain aware
party similarity that overcomes this limitation. The workflow covers (a)
definition of suitable policy domains; (b) automatic labeling of domains, if no
manual labels are available; (c) computation of domain-level similarities and
aggregation at a global level; (d) extraction of interpretable party positions
on major policy axes via multidimensional scaling. We evaluate our workflow on
manifestos from the German federal elections. We find that our method (a)
yields high correlation when predicting party similarity at a global level and
(b) provides accurate party-specific positions, even with automatically
labelled policy domains. | [
-0.034226723,
0.0491559058,
-0.0038472097,
-0.0048695509,
-0.0491341427,
0.0118021639,
-0.0003553001,
-0.0153447008,
0.018660415,
-0.0094172442,
0.0351432711,
-0.0145278517,
-0.0057130712,
0.0448836572,
-0.0266113859,
-0.0978570879,
0.0279849265,
0.0508317389,
-0.0196633171,
-0.015887551,
0.0095913447,
-0.027678851,
-0.0106194196,
0.0623365454,
-0.0080180615,
0.0019268452,
-0.0786098242,
0.0024797891,
0.0942979008,
0.0050691967,
-0.0048488895,
-0.0225835536,
-0.0213856623,
0.0039236336,
0.0000018405,
-0.0360089652,
-0.0718075857,
-0.0196878426,
0.1164385676,
-0.0407089964,
0.0708100051,
0.0139301503,
-0.0278255045,
0.0015827548,
-0.033626914,
0.0014733293,
0.0628570244,
0.0285476353,
0.0518585332,
0.0064900862,
-0.0081179077,
-0.0469241925,
-0.0353904516,
-0.0126756718,
-0.0261467639,
-0.034908969,
0.0022402427,
-0.015873,
-0.045339413,
-0.0167830456,
-0.0162930209,
-0.0054303571,
-0.0364214815,
0.0154462699,
-0.0368564762,
0.0130102029,
0.0433437154,
-0.0398461185,
-0.0056441389,
0.0081466418,
0.0197738893,
-0.0235808492,
0.0472804271,
-0.0343339108,
-0.0171034448,
0.096045427,
-0.0429415368,
-0.0162381232,
-0.0273280758,
0.0294608381,
0.0419103839,
0.0327816978,
-0.0155603392,
0.0011309877,
-0.0387516916,
0.1031003296,
-0.0167070553,
-0.0232679695,
-0.0147574628,
0.0038753087,
-0.0003139801,
-0.0428341776,
0.0017768086,
-0.0296192933,
0.0161571335,
0.019212801,
0.0020543239,
0.0074930894,
0.0274785608,
-0.0061977217,
0.011358371,
-0.0009357168,
-0.0008431048,
0.0715515614,
0.0711581558,
0.0001767829,
-0.0316534154,
-0.0081687542,
-0.0274452548,
-0.0331722461,
-0.0485986099,
0.0091581438,
0.0051098713,
-0.0025369946,
-0.0349897295,
0.007313706,
-0.0298436284,
0.0040309611,
-0.0462327823,
0.0193044581,
0.0147717912,
0.0252474044,
0.0241101403,
-0.0123268496,
-0.0744595006,
0.0571785867,
-0.0654874146,
0.028525155,
-0.0467603803,
0.0745948777,
0.0362406299,
0.0455377176,
0.0246872604,
-0.0035008518,
-0.0053745452,
0.0492077097,
0.0216718763,
0.0309630558,
0.0617417879,
-0.003840934,
-0.0299596917,
-0.009832928,
0.0580359399,
-0.0744603202,
0.0719048157,
-0.0248320736,
0.0173120573,
-0.0821263418,
-0.0187324192,
0.0157871824,
-0.0141809415,
0.0040052491,
0.0062586358,
0.0133754676,
0.0087065864,
0.0095254779,
0.0124874944,
0.0169902667,
0.0107872738,
0.017776886,
0.0198669415,
-0.0157775395,
-0.0122514069,
0.0083312094,
0.0095096426,
0.0419404246,
0.0067413021,
0.0170605853,
-0.010526482,
-0.0611128956,
0.0385384969,
-0.008653285,
0.0339170322,
-0.0166943949,
0.0165788606,
0.0864776745,
0.0010510425,
0.012967675,
-0.019154869,
0.0083665513,
-0.0101097468,
0.0172817688,
0.0037986541,
0.0183475353,
0.0354042165,
-0.0216076151,
0.0473991297,
0.0185061935,
0.0095644714,
-0.0011975644,
0.0031356863,
-0.0035469113,
0.0278938971,
-0.0358189717,
0.0195065234,
-0.0152032683,
0.0089855539,
0.0219242852,
0.0099503631,
-0.0372481346,
-0.033278726,
0.0004608454,
0.0248961318,
-0.000418858,
-0.0079592112,
-0.0518279746,
-0.0170192979,
0.0001216682,
0.0540173948,
0.006132191,
0.070619598,
-0.0541937426,
-0.0161976945,
-0.0056801429,
-0.0409843512,
0.0189908873,
0.0061913827,
0.0392690189,
0.032081183,
-0.0107496008,
-0.0111758625,
-0.012535478,
0.0308297276,
0.0080724908,
-0.0031894192,
0.0398836136,
0.0291103274,
0.0318874903,
0.0470881611,
0.0482919067,
0.0198888648,
-0.0181990601,
0.0479690917,
-0.0091705006,
-0.0184775125,
0.0091347164,
0.0210493971,
0.0623963885,
0.0064381394,
-0.0627501011,
0.0192887112,
0.0131972637,
-0.0433850884,
0.0000167619,
0.0546329431,
0.001057938,
-0.0504330806,
-0.0299006812,
0.0256143901,
-0.0244466849,
-0.0629717112,
-0.0601930954,
0.0965186283,
0.012071305,
0.0012979498,
-0.030316662,
-0.050209567,
0.036405094,
0.0222272966,
0.0254190546,
-0.0307370331,
0.0066460529,
0.0640558228,
0.0327472575,
-0.0508073568,
0.009071907,
-0.0367064439,
-0.0120445332,
0.0123291649,
-0.0045933486,
0.0565909445,
0.0339652821,
-0.0162133984,
-0.0049132141,
0.0305912457,
0.0192820597,
-0.0169929825,
-0.0464439802,
-0.023954317,
0.0619831122,
-0.0102332709,
-0.0447551273,
-0.0034639577,
0.0082657458,
-0.0238474794,
0.0018870042,
0.0132651841,
-0.0483780615,
0.006587063,
0.011248189,
-0.0662506521,
0.0013417625,
-0.023007609,
-0.0025147523,
-0.0160581134,
0.0197578147,
0.0059994431,
-0.0111733014,
0.0468036085,
0.0518248491,
0.0384290181,
0.0367790237,
-0.0749983937,
-0.0121589908,
-0.0898156464,
0.0622535609,
0.0019600582,
-0.0233065188,
0.0751312226,
0.0691272244,
0.0098527456,
0.0111174341,
0.0169274043,
0.0338867381,
-0.0035131036,
0.0275739636,
-0.0325797945,
-0.0138781359,
0.00089922,
0.0173142292,
0.0367489345,
-0.0637214482,
0.0121240895,
-0.0046421229,
0.0708178207,
-0.02971467,
-0.0503017195,
-0.0442980789,
0.0642567426,
0.0007845151,
0.0103658093,
-0.0017529206,
0.0283906553,
0.0014280922,
-0.010584644,
0.0477373712,
-0.0248930715,
0.0810115039,
-0.0418265797,
0.0197737776,
-0.0032026363,
-0.0359360054,
-0.0096654836,
-0.0392780937,
-0.0085265841,
-0.006187777,
-0.031129187,
-0.0436668471,
-0.0362657085,
0.0331002846,
0.0366106331,
-0.0036023895,
0.053934209,
-0.0023996986,
0.0065561174,
0.0054931585,
-0.0009387512,
-0.0456878617,
-0.0262808762,
-0.0196377821,
-0.0534307435,
0.041703064,
0.0024218266,
0.0251625162,
-0.0369535163,
-0.0599217676,
-0.0381906182,
-0.0355758592,
0.0111338645,
-0.012307873,
0.0098381182,
-0.0034880778,
0.0346661657,
0.0274610668,
0.0337422714,
-0.0323233977,
0.0005478838,
0.0154467281,
0.0005272679,
0.0269954223,
-0.0040714843,
-0.0752125382,
0.0171583965,
0.0417751297,
0.0111342156,
-0.0585917644,
-0.0386198908,
-0.0007533514,
-0.0004030951,
-0.0010346686,
0.0127518671,
-0.0077287909,
-0.024645498,
-0.0621757545,
0.0427411571,
-0.0079026427,
-0.1171016693,
-0.0341941118,
-0.0014056899,
0.0109856306,
-0.0093883555,
-0.0882127732,
-0.0372374617,
-0.0111691607,
-0.0345971137,
-0.0076009287,
0.0003165792,
0.0808992311,
0.0244148932,
-0.0053586676,
0.077705659,
-0.0077651534,
-0.0025476839,
0.0457478389,
0.0068529579,
-0.0002875589,
0.0128088947,
-0.0286450237,
0.0460918657,
0.0456867181,
-0.0575683415,
0.0459601618,
0.0376306325,
-0.067596443,
-0.0515267365,
-0.00203908,
0.0299048889,
0.0528519154,
0.0614583939,
0.03823689,
0.0147617022,
-0.0057665259,
-0.0225112643,
0.0105052106,
0.0016696715,
-0.0257839113,
-0.0308659431,
-0.0693198368,
0.038490165,
-0.0037369851,
0.0179077387,
-0.0169798955,
0.0419077724,
-0.0097564198,
0.0134264426,
0.0212193485,
-0.0128032248,
-0.0645053238,
-0.0316274799,
-0.0100001078,
0.0316770822,
0.0271156896,
-0.0625616238,
-0.0014440431,
0.0601322502,
-0.0962936059,
-0.0200762618,
-0.0334415659,
-0.0225331057,
-0.0105070062,
-0.0467889085,
0.0248030461,
0.011570924,
-0.0149846878,
-0.002777583,
0.0289686639,
0.1037679538,
0.0003823462,
-0.0167639311,
-0.0112584913,
0.0168679878,
0.0206502359,
0.0007488585,
0.0087508867,
0.0484155193,
0.013359583,
-0.0543477908,
-0.025011804,
-0.0076136198,
0.0013852403,
0.0082134567,
0.0497424528,
-0.010486695,
-0.0862299278,
-0.0494301431,
-0.0057721948,
0.0165987369,
-0.0202719998,
0.0056034252,
-0.0129397884,
0.0160398651,
-0.0329776704,
-0.0110494317,
0.078869991,
0.0136990137,
0.0389471427,
-0.0332009681,
0.0689803138,
-0.0054764366,
0.0451239161,
0.0286632739,
-0.0247625429,
0.0010659902,
-0.0099626305,
-0.0003966678,
0.0753500015,
0.0116406074,
-0.0192220733,
0.0351995267,
0.026903566,
0.0399549529,
0.0099661313,
-0.0482121296,
-0.0525327921,
-0.0403767191,
0.0520561077,
0.0073758108,
0.0330227241,
0.0219422635,
-0.0130565809,
-0.0232540127,
0.0011010437,
0.000542554,
-0.0087040151,
-0.0362441391,
0.031187864,
-0.011536831,
-0.0378233753,
-0.0242072921,
-0.0003488484,
0.0159425866,
0.0141535597,
0.0207349975,
-0.0295192804,
-0.0187906343,
-0.0682313517,
0.0065869493,
0.0064693345,
-0.0627305135,
-0.0645395666,
-0.0739888325,
0.0008186549,
0.0113470331,
0.0032479642,
-0.0245207865,
0.0550868884,
0.0005707847,
0.0192849673,
-0.0225189161,
0.0772664994,
-0.0308045242,
0.046251718,
-0.074229829,
-0.0343539193,
0.0376605727,
-5.630721164e-33,
-0.0344375819,
-0.0256054904,
0.0093943821,
-0.0161236953,
-0.0082553048,
-0.0219307598,
-0.0303765107,
-0.0081652356,
0.0171052199,
0.0349708088,
0.0251816139,
0.0189087838,
0.0298933014,
-0.0273262002,
-0.003939217,
-0.007669399,
0.0013924222,
0.0219778717,
-0.0455595255,
0.009876431,
0.0464022346,
-0.0113852611,
0.0299607757,
-0.0676640496,
0.0147612728,
0.0424447991,
0.0125062531,
-0.0461083278,
0.0639336482,
0.0288909841,
-0.0003823829,
-0.0559575595,
0.0337487534,
-0.0367249995,
-0.0095845619,
0.0773830637,
-0.0212888699,
-0.041194547,
-0.0128626162,
-0.0512816608,
0.0334826969,
0.0078151263,
0.0047108107,
0.0352174677,
-0.0555890128,
-0.0517202541,
0.0615252331,
0.0033673686,
0.0077429879,
-0.0190794859,
-0.0169044398,
0.0249607731,
-0.0251243915,
0.0384159461,
-0.0376535989,
0.0518455729,
0.0486244857,
0.0174592994,
-0.0540053919,
0.0574492775,
-0.0566810071,
-0.0122975903,
0.0233918317,
-0.0673403367,
0.0196941234,
0.0875501856,
0.0053900606,
-0.0095853172,
-0.0739300475,
0.0271851532,
0.0117422128,
0.0211656764,
0.0140038533,
0.0345011614,
0.0365304835,
-0.0312915221,
-0.0837127715,
0.0854078829,
0.0071966965,
-0.049371127,
0.0028973194,
-0.0104669826,
0.0147349341,
-0.0201453716,
-0.0143706463,
-0.0025825335,
0.0013309828,
-0.0088197468,
0.0021649424,
0.0144613208,
-0.0335705057,
0.0621118434,
-0.0075480002,
-0.073478654,
0.0116841597,
0.0162353385,
-0.0167668406,
0.0113860853,
-0.0234996323,
-0.0286149532,
-0.0209084414,
-0.0895702317,
-0.0510141775,
0.0448574461,
0.0655712038,
-0.0219389927,
0.0058405399,
-0.0521997958,
-0.0664949939,
-0.0076385746,
-0.0036901732,
-0.0387842208,
-0.0364725403,
0.0240554605,
0.0308274459,
0.0202684812,
0.0324417874,
0.0014230126,
-0.0053861411,
-0.0078463769,
-0.0011748602,
0.0431524403,
-0.047237806,
0.0171926599,
-0.0064199064,
-0.0352307968,
-0.0336109623,
-0.0138306329,
0.0318488888,
-0.0061387685,
-0.016538782,
-0.0357045121,
2.499e-7,
0.0612710156,
0.0167197231,
0.0266004987,
-0.0125147048,
0.0151042668,
0.0387777463,
0.0148669863,
0.0549909286,
-0.0962411761,
-0.0321484283,
0.0090437662,
-0.0116439359,
0.0183752328,
0.0417056344,
-0.0749376491,
0.0182973724,
-0.024840137,
-0.0340397954,
-0.0950037539,
0.0615044422,
-0.0410404652,
-0.0001489282,
0.0487682931,
-0.0023681023,
0.0063343756,
0.0406618752,
0.0375055447,
-0.0075375233,
-0.0062614996,
0.0551247187,
-0.0168259032,
-0.0777062774,
0.0236373991,
0.0285302233,
0.0201391,
-0.0022920698,
-0.0119854398,
0.0695002824,
0.004615095,
0.0289333034,
-0.07635203,
-0.0532332473,
0.0251296032,
-0.0264131296,
0.0360299125,
-0.0615175329,
0.0030489503,
-0.0369264558,
-0.0413572937,
0.0219498388,
0.0583728142,
0.0401859321,
0.0314491503,
0.0381902047,
-0.0128441732,
-0.0322259068,
0.0385461152,
-0.0193150751,
-0.0022935371,
-0.0229888782,
-0.011051327,
-0.0391310528,
0.0266306791,
0.0208182186,
0.0737881139,
-0.0427603759,
-0.0338045768,
2.127306361e-34,
-0.0002918058,
0.0239749309,
-0.0417301133,
-0.0345369689,
0.0458027087,
-0.0383722186,
0.0025583708,
0.0341594443,
-0.0360525548,
-0.0270508099,
0.021468468
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10122v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10122v1 | Empirical Analysis of Oral and Nasal Vowels of Konkani | 2023-05-17T11:01:38 | 2023-05-17T11:01:38 | Swapnil Fadte, Edna Vaz, Atul Kr. Ojha, Ramdas Karmali, Jyoti D. Pawar | cs.CL | cs.CL | Konkani is a highly nasalised language which makes it unique among Indo-Aryan
languages. This work investigates the acoustic-phonetic properties of Konkani
oral and nasal vowels. For this study, speech samples from six speakers (3 male
and 3 female) were collected. A total of 74 unique sentences were used as a
part of the recording script, 37 each for oral and nasal vowels, respectively.
The final data set consisted of 1135 vowel phonemes. A comparative F1-F2 plot
of Konkani oral and nasal vowels is presented with an experimental result and
formant analysis. The average F1, F2 and F3 values are also reported for the
first time through experimentation for all nasal and oral vowels. This study
can be helpful for the linguistic research on vowels and speech synthesis
systems specific to the Konkani language. | [
0.0246894527,
0.0107926363,
-0.0027525239,
-0.0389756188,
-0.0503990129,
-0.0189699028,
0.0411111154,
0.0068634134,
0.0174395759,
0.0444795974,
-0.0436468311,
-0.0439067297,
0.0846665949,
0.0042165886,
0.0460712835,
-0.0724005774,
-0.0330441855,
-0.0422686562,
0.059982989,
0.0238664895,
0.0411505885,
0.0322107635,
-0.1075176373,
0.0211623311,
-0.0289674308,
0.0130535671,
-0.0103543913,
-0.057537891,
0.0248137806,
-0.0072859302,
-0.0128488494,
0.0005073359,
-0.0242875852,
-0.0278629698,
0.0000015795,
-0.0470909365,
0.0154327406,
-0.0101646949,
-0.0319152921,
0.0267552193,
0.0900245905,
0.0523226336,
-0.036502108,
0.022701269,
0.029349789,
0.045704443,
0.1005163491,
0.0044582533,
-0.0092757139,
0.0163458306,
-0.0199009087,
-0.0697987229,
-0.008406423,
0.0277405065,
-0.0147902286,
0.0497973636,
0.0110756755,
-0.0726286098,
-0.002689695,
-0.080196254,
-0.0160377659,
0.0177663956,
-0.0413415432,
0.00587655,
-0.0355791524,
0.0089622429,
-0.045832891,
-0.0815585777,
0.0538327694,
0.0133588668,
-0.0068747797,
-0.0330785215,
0.033268109,
0.0391435996,
-0.072055839,
-0.0224793945,
-0.0003833604,
-0.0208677799,
-0.0213965382,
-0.0052931355,
0.0422452427,
0.0468369387,
-0.0514795743,
-0.051223889,
0.0461203977,
-0.0393385664,
0.0225352719,
-0.021649614,
0.0051513733,
-0.0341587663,
-0.0091538103,
-0.0013756532,
0.0100651067,
0.0608192459,
-0.0340657085,
0.0157438815,
0.0684556887,
-0.0943676904,
0.0270756278,
-0.0059622414,
0.0179310031,
-0.0401337892,
-0.0147605259,
-0.0430742688,
-0.0312108938,
0.0419353917,
0.010738587,
-0.067592144,
-0.0167573821,
0.0188248083,
0.0433086641,
-0.0525762625,
-0.0075812866,
-0.053121835,
-0.0023104434,
0.040180061,
-0.0348718278,
-0.0055473722,
-0.0074916668,
-0.0268645473,
-0.0000832398,
-0.0080201775,
-0.0208724793,
0.003660473,
0.0038783511,
0.0035939571,
-0.0210426189,
0.0539077818,
-0.0339374021,
-0.0922627375,
0.043083068,
0.0408973098,
0.0047873813,
0.041350726,
-0.0328944772,
0.0089248056,
-0.0152745871,
0.0500187427,
0.006925147,
0.0322412029,
-0.0397287607,
-0.0513395369,
-0.0520492494,
-0.0334202722,
0.0368995704,
0.0186369978,
-0.0433695503,
-0.0251870826,
-0.0207247268,
-0.0089487871,
0.0411972329,
-0.0118472083,
0.032388147,
0.0474557839,
0.0599530861,
0.0178824514,
0.0864498094,
0.0070050363,
-0.0258665718,
-0.0051353402,
0.0297013428,
-0.074485153,
0.03634011,
0.0106741153,
0.0389517359,
0.0209342055,
-0.0131375771,
-0.0034324354,
-0.0179636218,
0.0351574086,
0.0009528294,
0.0435732417,
0.0211124457,
-0.0096817082,
0.0025154706,
0.0471225753,
0.0999678895,
0.026300285,
0.0211458113,
0.0263249222,
0.0537041649,
0.0228730701,
0.0399520956,
-0.0127188144,
0.0336653292,
0.0013061693,
0.0343320481,
0.0212477818,
0.0166615713,
0.0224828143,
-0.0256528761,
-0.0153863616,
-0.0531469584,
-0.0295969564,
0.0167626161,
0.0214797743,
-0.0279084593,
0.0044983146,
0.0312299058,
-0.0379105173,
0.036633458,
-0.0295281578,
0.084737964,
-0.0308263935,
-0.0307540447,
-0.0228383914,
0.0737982169,
0.0095209908,
-0.0628554299,
0.015018316,
0.0027481525,
-0.0372188278,
0.021318363,
-0.0664014071,
0.0122379651,
0.0532017127,
0.0033248502,
0.0456257798,
-0.0236579645,
0.0697630718,
0.0192347057,
-0.0093329186,
0.0470027737,
-0.0140128508,
0.0008682084,
0.029897688,
-0.0435562879,
0.0019877984,
0.0257481355,
0.0091468189,
0.0004242512,
0.0583461151,
0.0221067704,
0.0024648916,
0.0772386417,
0.0151115274,
0.031206442,
0.011970086,
-0.0229968596,
-0.0275639556,
0.0508799516,
-0.0062941336,
0.0372121185,
-0.0620463006,
0.0596329458,
0.0038644013,
0.0354290418,
0.0048618279,
-0.0069994335,
-0.0162068624,
0.019134501,
0.0175116025,
-0.0291917305,
0.0726705566,
-0.0349831581,
0.0079748472,
-0.0380664542,
0.0086688781,
-0.096543096,
-0.014176338,
0.0662174299,
-0.0165282004,
0.0144411577,
-0.0236447379,
-0.0520208143,
-0.0502891876,
-0.023328783,
-0.0809040442,
-0.0592806228,
0.0423623063,
0.015084343,
-0.039612595,
0.0295036007,
0.0030336052,
0.0307374746,
-0.0199215394,
-0.0071749515,
0.0297293551,
0.0010894014,
-0.0167635176,
-0.0090843989,
-0.0086314064,
-0.0145494025,
-0.0238058697,
0.0145476814,
0.002158121,
-0.0099819144,
-0.0370397195,
-0.0260605495,
-0.0035430479,
-0.0112912748,
-0.0186370481,
-0.0030188684,
-0.0281344336,
-0.0025865852,
-0.0094262594,
0.0812129974,
-0.013558628,
-0.0212589838,
-0.0248496644,
-0.0229392946,
-0.0400209501,
0.0056579406,
-0.0365055986,
0.0174506363,
0.0903436244,
-0.0252016503,
0.0178217087,
-0.0053421282,
0.0260302927,
-0.0067052185,
-0.0055280309,
-0.0094899312,
0.0445863046,
-0.035820052,
0.0130982772,
0.0099032056,
-0.0027941079,
-0.0203681458,
0.0501460768,
-0.0073952777,
-0.0076066675,
-0.006035408,
-0.0549088195,
-0.0425525121,
-0.05702677,
0.0113535114,
-0.0171079803,
0.00702427,
-0.0154656768,
-0.0334725603,
0.030782152,
-0.0185866784,
-0.0342931859,
0.0238688271,
0.0123432148,
-0.029248463,
0.0039975327,
-0.0382631011,
-0.0343043208,
-0.0216321275,
0.061291337,
-0.0161306392,
-0.0516684018,
-0.0194336399,
-0.0239890255,
0.0173270144,
-0.0099979276,
0.100670889,
0.0448659584,
-0.0242386498,
-0.0563251115,
-0.024052605,
0.0753501579,
0.0286589488,
-0.0055453107,
0.0361673906,
0.0252085738,
-0.0269780606,
0.0444765799,
0.0409714244,
-0.0497339591,
0.0261485353,
0.0468236171,
0.050929267,
-0.012577069,
-0.0031316394,
0.0134908017,
0.0183246247,
-0.0220018625,
-0.0100081451,
0.0292446278,
0.0506274663,
-0.0257880781,
-0.0085342554,
0.0615048409,
0.0175573174,
-0.0262959264,
0.0411484204,
-0.0336064957,
0.024183413,
0.0308963619,
0.0612172745,
0.0317607038,
0.0351269729,
-0.0104192682,
0.0329996608,
-0.0051028803,
-0.0784338042,
-0.0459414907,
0.0089452276,
-0.0194624551,
-0.0002147216,
-0.0387463607,
-0.0089511378,
0.009720806,
-0.019935498,
0.1001228392,
-0.0256430134,
0.0030123945,
0.0512764566,
-0.0569090173,
-0.0271451827,
-0.0234022234,
-0.010802567,
0.0328602828,
-0.026243899,
-0.0158147216,
-0.0745627359,
-0.0342944674,
-0.0033335981,
-0.0333303139,
-0.0328584537,
-0.0072060674,
0.0164622683,
0.0884624124,
-0.0370131172,
-0.0405802168,
0.0244337991,
-0.0027711026,
-0.0000886121,
0.0273145474,
-0.0212224722,
0.0195578411,
-0.0271670651,
0.0051948414,
0.0641302764,
-0.0098071545,
-0.0449449606,
0.0307663474,
-0.0438731015,
0.0265324488,
0.0202582981,
0.0203445107,
0.0114520583,
-0.0477001481,
0.0044197994,
0.0381725505,
-0.0752896219,
-0.0602963194,
-0.0297882613,
-0.0140001168,
0.0505153276,
0.0500571169,
0.028409794,
-0.0185230616,
0.0095773637,
0.0008926308,
-0.0493709892,
0.0413653366,
0.0545418151,
-0.0058176462,
0.0364153348,
0.0448553264,
-0.0369164497,
-0.0248475168,
-0.0429417901,
0.022775108,
-0.0152251814,
0.0872634873,
0.0351970382,
0.0250272341,
-0.0012384554,
-0.0214072205,
-0.0495911278,
0.0139677785,
-0.0409487337,
-0.008129565,
0.0393574871,
0.0204524733,
-0.0335474052,
0.0247937124,
-0.0032501409,
-0.0133967223,
0.0058772732,
-0.0273492876,
-0.0533220731,
0.0305716023,
-0.0272321813,
-0.010605732,
0.0272877775,
0.0051992154,
-0.0066021886,
0.0200383104,
-0.0219263714,
-0.0134513155,
0.0488121063,
0.0401616544,
0.0082123335,
-0.0222468823,
0.0442987196,
0.0804558173,
-0.0323324502,
-0.0471393503,
-0.0207043532,
-0.0033646971,
0.0656148717,
0.0816795379,
0.0370373316,
0.0777159855,
0.0323516577,
0.0147821689,
-0.0542419739,
0.0383395441,
-0.0607702695,
0.0168815833,
0.0042722882,
-0.0408555232,
-0.0278074034,
-0.0433201529,
0.0461581722,
0.0179092064,
0.0870137662,
0.061966788,
0.0142644234,
-0.0257726479,
-0.0080325119,
-0.005368182,
0.0279557537,
-0.0265805125,
0.0190350525,
-0.0303257182,
0.0006337038,
-0.057901103,
0.0291789118,
0.0096759014,
0.0080029704,
-0.0311195981,
0.0026512472,
-0.0049434071,
-0.0196096785,
0.0078828773,
-0.0083767967,
0.0309407022,
-0.0033243769,
-0.0071300394,
-0.0844003782,
-0.0277634636,
-0.0120251449,
-0.043424964,
-0.0182350427,
-0.0631371737,
0.0316466354,
-0.0076183327,
0.0311415922,
-0.0251833145,
0.0006770868,
-0.0331002139,
0.0213578027,
0.0542817861,
0.0296146665,
-0.0212036073,
-0.0169867873,
0.0231885128,
0.0443449616,
-5.383440131e-33,
-0.0049538147,
0.0317371339,
0.0190765001,
0.0366000123,
-0.0481320545,
-0.025904499,
-0.024538124,
-0.0040064738,
-0.0627861097,
0.0151624521,
0.0222980995,
-0.0379802585,
-0.0037200598,
-0.0453413539,
-0.00674708,
0.032445427,
-0.0148933548,
-0.0091661522,
0.0126224086,
-0.0319463275,
0.0260101836,
-0.0212069172,
0.0631037652,
-0.0484326035,
0.0039696088,
-0.0320487581,
-0.0518341437,
-0.0107594049,
-0.0551415049,
0.0098221572,
0.0049561937,
0.0804749727,
0.0009171154,
-0.0179781523,
0.0179739054,
-0.0124782054,
-0.0223173033,
-0.0057776803,
0.0199432224,
0.0622461811,
-0.0031873998,
-0.0139786378,
0.0032373758,
-0.0184922889,
0.0042594406,
0.0122047225,
-0.0454506539,
-0.0112607004,
-0.0007750223,
-0.0082608545,
-0.0343210585,
-0.0152466437,
0.0064045549,
-0.0320334136,
0.0369512476,
0.0540333018,
-0.008820273,
-0.1003439203,
0.0337296054,
0.041719459,
0.0179452673,
0.0334452465,
-0.0008638692,
0.0171892326,
-0.0360791311,
-0.0615705289,
0.0823768154,
-0.0774646625,
-0.0190059152,
0.0027055286,
0.0248998702,
0.0444016121,
-0.0144794313,
-0.0106156683,
-0.0012934764,
-0.0907297209,
0.0054497323,
-0.030822441,
0.0192312673,
0.053325247,
-0.0633297488,
0.0214359332,
-0.0127726784,
-0.0387950763,
0.0166860633,
-0.0453833155,
-0.0233631227,
0.0141306883,
0.0338975191,
-0.0422401763,
0.0441788323,
0.01045168,
0.0043726466,
-0.009959653,
0.0212753136,
-0.0217056256,
-0.0257182028,
0.0236321539,
-0.0005989026,
0.006563053,
-0.0004871687,
0.000025553,
0.0622089542,
0.0150678223,
0.0437366702,
-0.0315473042,
-0.0193195231,
0.0199920349,
-0.0279960204,
0.0042519034,
-0.0024166899,
0.0248128846,
0.0499148667,
0.0420433469,
-0.000652635,
0.0068903859,
0.0055698748,
-0.034897659,
0.0466694161,
-0.0381488986,
0.0111010047,
0.036746379,
0.0284018405,
-0.0067888517,
-0.0493721291,
0.0232505053,
0.0314796157,
-0.0371623971,
0.0030878487,
0.0341700651,
-0.0017484701,
-0.0048931548,
2.649e-7,
-0.0365782455,
-0.0092672519,
0.0660885051,
-0.0132017974,
0.0247947574,
-0.0235022455,
-0.0544175059,
-0.0074454308,
0.01465753,
0.0672127753,
-0.0019523748,
-0.0465847477,
0.0472218581,
0.0391316004,
-0.0542156845,
0.0033088818,
-0.0749430582,
-0.021336684,
-0.0354378223,
0.0122340824,
-0.0341841243,
0.0036699313,
-0.0056811199,
-0.071134977,
-0.0032014437,
0.043465361,
-0.0048958017,
-0.0095635904,
0.0356782265,
-0.0094508519,
0.0115332408,
-0.053341832,
0.0186132602,
0.0157395285,
-0.0611322485,
0.0527419299,
0.0699757189,
0.026789967,
-0.0008220251,
-0.0119741485,
0.0446610451,
0.039407175,
-0.0423786342,
-0.0120633375,
0.0189971589,
0.0777319595,
-0.0165432263,
-0.0237459056,
0.0177994519,
-0.017052481,
-0.0006319341,
-0.0010676035,
0.0321033224,
-0.0151752355,
0.0025825619,
-0.0418647639,
0.0018072963,
0.0309835449,
-0.0399014875,
0.0076083792,
-0.0262173209,
-0.0769432411,
0.0093027754,
-0.0010996314,
0.0478786528,
0.0111991242,
-0.0165738165,
1.600891751e-34,
-0.0125211393,
-0.0325503349,
0.0268898625,
-0.0172713846,
-0.0145355742,
-0.020800855,
0.0501424856,
0.0673450306,
0.0553114638,
-0.0578895956,
-0.0588215627
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10096v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10096v1 | Use of a Taxonomy of Empathetic Response Intents to Control and Interpret Empathy in Neural Chatbots | 2023-05-17T10:03:03 | 2023-05-17T10:03:03 | Anuradha Welivita, Pearl Pu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | A recent trend in the domain of open-domain conversational agents is enabling
them to converse empathetically to emotional prompts. Current approaches either
follow an end-to-end approach or condition the responses on similar emotion
labels to generate empathetic responses. But empathy is a broad concept that
refers to the cognitive and emotional reactions of an individual to the
observed experiences of another and it is more complex than mere mimicry of
emotion. Hence, it requires identifying complex human conversational strategies
and dynamics in addition to generic emotions to control and interpret
empathetic responding capabilities of chatbots. In this work, we make use of a
taxonomy of eight empathetic response intents in addition to generic emotion
categories in building a dialogue response generation model capable of
generating empathetic responses in a controllable and interpretable manner. It
consists of two modules: 1) a response emotion/intent prediction module; and 2)
a response generation module. We propose several rule-based and neural
approaches to predict the next response's emotion/intent and generate responses
conditioned on these predicted emotions/intents. Automatic and human evaluation
results emphasize the importance of the use of the taxonomy of empathetic
response intents in producing more diverse and empathetically more appropriate
responses than end-to-end models. | [
0.0843625069,
0.0120588858,
-0.0360841453,
-0.0088628521,
-0.0073454073,
0.0304859485,
0.0039874851,
0.0002511615,
0.0523138829,
-0.0120596867,
-0.0175008494,
0.001783143,
-0.0302509181,
0.0359547287,
-0.0006039122,
-0.0973353237,
0.0348940529,
0.0448047221,
0.0572255887,
-0.0138624711,
-0.004186858,
0.0354829766,
-0.0219446644,
0.0730056986,
-0.0679444671,
-0.0284210239,
-0.0463139787,
0.0276054479,
0.0053781001,
0.0015821734,
0.0649017245,
0.0090846475,
0.0250449367,
0.0018791941,
0.0000019179,
-0.0374382026,
0.0118579455,
-0.0152266193,
0.0127556156,
-0.0585869923,
0.0744181648,
-0.0162027217,
0.010179433,
0.0288006198,
-0.0463342629,
-0.0306690056,
0.0498193502,
0.0368003137,
0.065249458,
0.0625982136,
-0.0279614236,
-0.0071459697,
-0.005115577,
-0.0235650018,
-0.0167025309,
-0.0036541815,
-0.0136189079,
0.0002565084,
0.0262550712,
-0.0462971814,
-0.018508669,
-0.0086404858,
0.01628167,
-0.0041645379,
0.0242130514,
0.0238541998,
0.0375775583,
-0.0680712759,
-0.0368955061,
0.1007887423,
0.0159812421,
0.0234058779,
0.0041963663,
-0.0086380048,
0.0464931503,
-0.0342722312,
-0.0332773924,
0.0137308044,
-0.0235360954,
0.0044025467,
-0.0002915583,
0.0358938202,
-0.023647381,
0.0399882011,
-0.0011648447,
0.0008876701,
-0.0100747542,
0.0232637338,
-0.0002744615,
0.0080904895,
-0.0140257394,
-0.0461893566,
-0.0038696707,
0.0550342686,
-0.0411843508,
0.0133744981,
-0.0477818325,
0.0384709239,
0.0025570395,
-0.0313297361,
0.012696133,
0.0715079308,
-0.0022120024,
0.0060730525,
0.0062842616,
0.0203191973,
-0.0048717237,
0.015507414,
-0.0465202779,
-0.0061784061,
-0.0460043252,
-0.0029702617,
-0.0221077856,
0.0402541459,
-0.0279606935,
-0.0145140197,
-0.0550153218,
0.0407751501,
-0.0275728758,
-0.0213667434,
-0.0270619374,
0.0192693081,
-0.0307512898,
-0.0054038432,
-0.0374337658,
-0.0010292979,
-0.0653392896,
0.0135044577,
0.0384403542,
-0.0589010194,
-0.0226336159,
0.0336778499,
0.0086669661,
0.0010864727,
0.0134396646,
0.0586354919,
0.0002124566,
-0.0208864603,
0.0171006881,
-0.0199654177,
-0.0165353529,
-0.0328997783,
0.0323569812,
0.0123865893,
0.047732953,
-0.0095233135,
-0.0214562006,
-0.0077982405,
0.0199788418,
-0.0185764953,
-0.0449509434,
0.0386547036,
-0.0009811164,
-0.0014827182,
0.0131899118,
0.0163504593,
-0.0324479491,
0.0102134394,
-0.0000383403,
0.0343750305,
0.0222230144,
0.0019882149,
0.0574302189,
-0.0009612655,
-0.0161366295,
-0.0575995073,
0.0076659895,
-0.0194641631,
-0.0311082527,
0.0650408193,
0.0652900189,
0.025322983,
-0.0534525625,
-0.0581845492,
0.0246312506,
0.0792988315,
-0.004915304,
0.095118247,
0.0478858203,
0.0156173939,
0.0133527862,
0.0073885494,
-0.0443885364,
0.082357578,
0.0063325814,
-0.0358252674,
-0.0207663905,
-0.015979819,
-0.0446055904,
-0.0442840196,
0.0258198567,
-0.0130532915,
0.0444257893,
-0.0113139851,
-0.0079191895,
-0.0134649202,
-0.0370570086,
-0.015666591,
0.0063841403,
-0.0616989136,
-0.0408731997,
-0.0844465643,
0.0042662965,
0.0764697865,
0.0404512323,
-0.0402250513,
-0.0650337189,
0.0103343753,
-0.0580186024,
0.0645142645,
0.0423531309,
-0.0034773564,
0.0636748821,
-0.0364614874,
0.0187718347,
-0.0210985821,
-0.0044580842,
0.0305546559,
-0.0394246988,
0.0031805905,
-0.0345311575,
0.0281988122,
0.0281918366,
0.0524945706,
-0.0012910313,
0.0143182185,
0.0153598664,
-0.0001056913,
0.0406791642,
0.0102165947,
0.0214739647,
-0.0222238116,
0.0064627291,
0.0047012893,
-0.0275692567,
0.0622499958,
-0.0441661961,
-0.0499581024,
0.0284099542,
-0.0352438614,
-0.0274891015,
0.0453620218,
-0.0022717142,
-0.0085413558,
0.0412242003,
-0.0369042903,
0.0297553819,
-0.0783365443,
0.0150350332,
-0.016862331,
0.0212864615,
0.020675309,
0.0199877732,
-0.0062426995,
-0.0281395316,
0.0053738714,
-0.0102986898,
-0.0085770851,
-0.0164338537,
0.00166562,
0.0057312399,
-0.010287229,
-0.0231463797,
0.0053910059,
0.0208889116,
-0.0674478486,
-0.0504440628,
-0.0803200752,
-0.0211642403,
0.0215485189,
-0.0226861034,
0.0048330948,
0.0038471876,
-0.0149241071,
-0.0044177035,
-0.0408052504,
0.1050097868,
0.0321790166,
-0.0196031965,
0.0355180949,
-0.0145988362,
-0.0148486262,
-0.0729657635,
0.0217973907,
-0.0127282729,
0.0152664632,
-0.0086294934,
0.0142614972,
-0.046815332,
0.0034877744,
-0.0640888363,
0.0619607829,
-0.0132515719,
-0.1098837107,
0.0227113273,
-0.0153124295,
-0.0283410475,
0.0632658377,
0.0456587374,
0.0600753054,
0.003786169,
0.0082769105,
-0.0909097195,
0.0604674779,
-0.0405531451,
0.022572631,
-0.0237436462,
-0.0322093777,
-0.0113608185,
0.0490609743,
-0.0010530668,
-0.0048289816,
-0.0844630897,
0.0013388462,
0.043676082,
-0.0712195039,
-0.0052167657,
-0.0258240849,
-0.0003496175,
-0.0252503008,
-0.0026295215,
-0.0427764133,
0.0839060694,
0.062680088,
-0.0392654017,
-0.0481706373,
-0.0134758465,
0.0112488223,
0.0601802915,
-0.0504283011,
0.0274656601,
0.0165144205,
-0.0010752871,
-0.0498705357,
-0.0324449465,
-0.0188632589,
-0.0349600092,
-0.0008686385,
-0.0189860947,
-0.0362480991,
0.0286247618,
0.0017601482,
-0.0490769409,
-0.036130257,
0.0168253221,
0.0104528973,
0.0381247699,
-0.0058237538,
-0.0255534966,
-0.0186739359,
0.0227003619,
0.0122137005,
-0.0210615508,
-0.0302912723,
-0.0190883987,
0.0065221926,
0.0367141776,
0.0471081026,
0.0425330922,
-0.0044725342,
0.1049384177,
0.0353918672,
0.0178626888,
0.0078658806,
0.0013577538,
0.0195693318,
0.008090212,
0.019742826,
0.0211412404,
-0.013686466,
0.039532356,
-0.0048658079,
-0.0150538757,
0.105280593,
0.0293166712,
-0.0454521179,
0.0220255367,
-0.0524806641,
-0.0002257925,
0.0010216812,
0.0261151064,
-0.0236069262,
0.0053953519,
-0.0145972576,
0.0199043751,
-0.0219931472,
-0.0372850299,
0.0007557879,
-0.0568311289,
0.0354612283,
-0.0150693106,
0.0063895001,
-0.0515844077,
0.0177148823,
0.0199761558,
0.0214560349,
-0.0040117023,
-0.0228277445,
0.0386193246,
-0.0148249557,
0.0105563933,
-0.0091791628,
0.0146091077,
0.0302001256,
-0.040997237,
0.0895741209,
0.0342289098,
0.0871497467,
0.0133180702,
0.025072787,
-0.0002770285,
0.0193274822,
0.0113739436,
-0.0092281848,
0.0249495301,
0.0006621509,
0.0098606693,
-0.0464347787,
0.0347458199,
-0.0048497962,
0.0043126931,
0.000680283,
0.0396218598,
-0.059139777,
-0.0283181053,
-0.0253748409,
0.0543377511,
0.0275348648,
0.0607693717,
0.0284363478,
-0.0552195944,
-0.0311211292,
-0.0027150209,
0.0338837467,
-0.026093645,
0.0035655505,
0.0029726101,
-0.0161895249,
-0.0411496311,
-0.0720797628,
-0.108674936,
-0.0029506297,
-0.0029431002,
-0.0159588344,
-0.0841703564,
0.0239605252,
0.020806456,
-0.0082315989,
0.0108133303,
0.0203246586,
-0.0015023971,
0.0163452961,
-0.0071760118,
0.029883001,
-0.045139119,
-0.0012191863,
0.0135868834,
0.0340345949,
-0.0307507683,
0.0090280874,
0.0766123906,
0.0123907113,
0.0142751634,
0.0064759417,
-0.0236220136,
-0.0048868302,
0.0206256472,
-0.0179695357,
0.0116650183,
0.0579668246,
0.0923899114,
-0.0152569953,
0.0325456224,
-0.0474122241,
0.0667653829,
0.0291454289,
0.0327322409,
0.0135846278,
-0.0668907017,
0.0296833534,
0.0037094483,
-0.0242528412,
0.0042613316,
-0.0222633053,
0.0006919556,
-0.0359258354,
-0.0323642343,
0.0338689499,
-0.0624839738,
-0.0155811096,
-0.0122927073,
0.0249650721,
-0.0166840814,
-0.0845617577,
-0.0549284965,
-0.0042412686,
-0.0182294026,
-0.0132435961,
-0.016766401,
0.0162510984,
-0.0606776923,
0.0245160013,
-0.0119339628,
-0.0167781059,
-0.0375214666,
-0.015080981,
-0.0119789736,
0.104873918,
0.0237122439,
-0.0314118527,
-0.0194171742,
0.0454338379,
-0.0284612402,
-0.0090571661,
0.0034236982,
0.0396751128,
0.0285591297,
0.0609512627,
0.0113654882,
-0.0562279671,
0.0314963087,
0.0184424035,
0.0478849486,
-0.015489948,
-0.0347501375,
-0.0168341063,
-0.0001528505,
-0.0117567489,
-0.0463503152,
0.0158055387,
-0.0799180716,
0.0536218956,
-0.0101427007,
-0.0024914825,
-0.0440616682,
-0.0120334486,
0.0561214499,
-0.0219836291,
0.0049307826,
0.0437423363,
-0.0614136308,
-0.0335324891,
0.0163958464,
0.0076691625,
-0.0126154125,
-0.0257590618,
0.0208287537,
0.0331383981,
-0.0100159813,
-0.0150142815,
-0.0176318586,
0.037483409,
-0.0812253058,
-0.0132546108,
-0.0164929442,
-5.732498403e-33,
-0.0075052315,
-0.0012943698,
-0.0268795174,
-0.0170991011,
-0.0527111925,
-0.0088905431,
-0.0387163237,
-0.0065233973,
-0.0190319866,
0.0435035899,
-0.0163398627,
0.0690754429,
-0.0103320237,
-0.0275077578,
-0.0068895756,
-0.0119771492,
0.0073156119,
-0.0232469421,
0.0055065723,
0.0640908182,
0.0044448264,
0.0417692363,
0.0221156888,
-0.0674914792,
0.0024917296,
0.0155712096,
-0.021570988,
0.0153197376,
0.046726197,
0.0381994136,
-0.0213604122,
0.0483333543,
0.0315447524,
0.0127107492,
0.026084248,
0.0330135748,
-0.0340276212,
-0.0358152315,
-0.0196940452,
-0.0375353321,
-0.0747261867,
-0.0384762883,
0.0201443434,
-0.0044636745,
-0.0234141666,
-0.0196412243,
-0.0074912505,
0.0078079905,
0.049701076,
-0.0111710699,
-0.033419013,
-0.0468771085,
-0.0235756617,
-0.0820937678,
-0.0289255939,
0.0843606219,
-0.0123953065,
0.0214728657,
-0.0216040425,
0.0171678215,
-0.0481847413,
-0.0599910766,
-0.0176386852,
-0.0108811855,
0.026888309,
0.0865629986,
0.031553369,
0.0201659799,
-0.0293883272,
-0.0039317533,
0.020826865,
0.0269607604,
0.0322020203,
0.0663818195,
-0.0143771032,
-0.0479886793,
-0.024585681,
0.0529718101,
0.0629311055,
0.031190237,
0.0228017941,
-0.0210854039,
-0.0186282564,
0.0321681872,
-0.007604294,
-0.0305645559,
-0.0243637431,
-0.0210721996,
0.0076688668,
-0.0108556999,
0.005141811,
-0.0716443956,
0.0159910824,
-0.0520143248,
0.0623097457,
0.0070644156,
-0.0200146362,
0.0161318183,
0.0170266461,
0.031860929,
0.0142539516,
-0.0490789525,
0.0634198934,
-0.0132240858,
0.033211071,
0.0176657215,
-0.0360902064,
0.0289679244,
0.0135971624,
-0.0169304758,
-0.0407293662,
0.0593526401,
-0.0130495047,
-0.0257641841,
-0.0499474034,
0.0411251336,
-0.0113149229,
-0.0386316814,
0.0275999382,
0.03168815,
-0.028087182,
-0.0179948062,
0.0128143094,
0.0393703543,
-0.0577196404,
-0.0028580683,
-0.0179276075,
-0.0292921979,
-0.0039473251,
-0.0344892666,
-0.0501168817,
-0.0038272787,
2.616e-7,
-0.0322215594,
0.0196698233,
0.0036870539,
0.0202687979,
0.0292451736,
0.0561521202,
0.0132558104,
0.0690369084,
0.0232637227,
-0.0410776325,
0.048296757,
0.0127326734,
0.0631484315,
-0.0147806043,
-0.0622205921,
0.0101175383,
-0.0036162171,
-0.0247195326,
0.0114923492,
0.0090508424,
0.0931312591,
0.0405403972,
0.0196161382,
-0.0094816135,
0.0367254056,
0.0580243468,
0.0107808607,
-0.0572999567,
0.0088383304,
0.0104811452,
-0.0007662006,
-0.0236524101,
0.0315481313,
0.0181695819,
0.0509500019,
0.0157644786,
-0.0010157938,
0.0387688503,
-0.0357136801,
-0.0838516876,
0.0352689736,
0.0317564569,
0.0100627607,
-0.0655673817,
-0.0054641925,
-0.0884302557,
-0.0346681215,
-0.0105511704,
-0.0002849381,
0.0098491106,
-0.0087907072,
-0.0257888921,
-0.0455921702,
0.0277209729,
0.0068374639,
0.0040729782,
0.0110552888,
-0.0640486702,
0.0344675072,
-0.0070668953,
-0.0679118112,
-0.0700991601,
-0.0238344725,
0.0199440029,
0.0416529216,
-0.0260384213,
0.0275253411,
1.513357715e-34,
-0.0147600817,
0.0016764372,
-0.0188609976,
0.0532414094,
0.0487863198,
0.0057737259,
-0.0025769174,
0.0214548185,
0.066521816,
-0.0683879629,
-0.0211680923
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10046v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10046v1 | Probing the Role of Positional Information in Vision-Language Models | 2023-05-17T08:38:59 | 2023-05-17T08:38:59 | Philipp J. Rösch, Jindřich Libovický | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV, I.4; I.7 | In most Vision-Language models (VL), the understanding of the image structure
is enabled by injecting the position information (PI) about objects in the
image. In our case study of LXMERT, a state-of-the-art VL model, we probe the
use of the PI in the representation and study its effect on Visual Question
Answering. We show that the model is not capable of leveraging the PI for the
image-text matching task on a challenge set where only position differs. Yet,
our experiments with probing confirm that the PI is indeed present in the
representation. We introduce two strategies to tackle this: (i) Positional
Information Pre-training and (ii) Contrastive Learning on PI using
Cross-Modality Matching. Doing so, the model can correctly classify if images
with detailed PI statements match. Additionally to the 2D information from
bounding boxes, we introduce the object's depth as new feature for a better
object localization in the space. Even though we were able to improve the model
properties as defined by our probes, it only has a negligible effect on the
downstream performance. Our results thus highlight an important issue of
multimodal modeling: the mere presence of information detectable by a probing
classifier is not a guarantee that the information is available in a
cross-modal setup. | [
0.0390350968,
0.0354915187,
-0.0151838353,
0.077101469,
-0.0488558337,
-0.0006592638,
0.0170028582,
-0.0063234149,
-0.0085142711,
-0.0938499421,
-0.036750868,
-0.0476500653,
0.0296363477,
0.0470663272,
0.0444684401,
-0.0625813901,
0.0390785933,
-0.0460192859,
-0.0325577185,
0.0023742055,
0.0283583552,
-0.0086888392,
0.0036796133,
0.0232291911,
-0.009618788,
-0.0193873327,
-0.0304670762,
0.007470333,
0.0118070543,
0.0031524715,
-0.0069403723,
0.034471903,
0.0547143184,
-0.0017325671,
0.000001825,
0.0044176681,
0.0196166206,
-0.0000256225,
0.0398617163,
-0.0213471446,
-0.0042153667,
-0.0718178153,
0.0010826072,
0.0022704906,
-0.0364113934,
-0.0309865642,
0.0621200278,
0.0177602861,
0.0462511964,
0.0388593748,
-0.0130007071,
0.0085565597,
0.0308497716,
-0.0168178827,
0.059634421,
-0.0120519456,
-0.0048657479,
0.0124511011,
0.0143667189,
0.0472571254,
-0.0925995633,
0.0473070964,
0.0279025603,
0.0144482916,
-0.0247638877,
0.0434539057,
0.0246176366,
-0.0117738144,
-0.036226701,
0.0521453284,
-0.0284621306,
-0.0329051428,
-0.0354302861,
-0.0146792158,
0.0254579037,
-0.0058567184,
-0.0312285032,
0.0438423455,
-0.0028134584,
0.0047064233,
-0.0265970435,
-0.0107019357,
-0.0062558185,
-0.0070574465,
0.0211202074,
0.0020790815,
0.0156351589,
-0.0074845958,
-0.0585812218,
0.0130531089,
-0.0133934021,
-0.0453836098,
-0.0349912532,
0.0245203376,
0.0192774367,
-0.000134842,
-0.0465666614,
-0.0132395336,
-0.0068243281,
-0.0369758569,
0.0338055193,
0.0360725857,
-0.0759879798,
0.0636240542,
-0.0131210722,
0.0860720724,
-0.0355107076,
0.0524407439,
-0.0599695891,
-0.0231654737,
0.0050247833,
-0.034493614,
-0.0326554962,
0.0000295167,
-0.0473817624,
-0.0668689981,
-0.0091714803,
0.0199039932,
-0.0182473604,
-0.0358940922,
-0.0215654727,
0.0422872119,
-0.0171867218,
0.0043757842,
-0.0382528417,
0.0620447434,
0.0021330798,
0.0319650806,
-0.040789701,
-0.0519607887,
0.0054380791,
0.0356844924,
0.0143952556,
-0.0236939788,
-0.0053844419,
0.0724818036,
-0.0364493206,
-0.0578725636,
0.0091164419,
-0.0037617085,
-0.0198742878,
-0.0114581864,
0.0648348778,
-0.0450974442,
0.0345100202,
0.0013912068,
-0.0054324972,
-0.0120543791,
0.0150642181,
0.0382372253,
-0.0134554245,
0.1246340647,
0.0074086706,
-0.0008718428,
-0.004500391,
0.0068158843,
0.0167624783,
0.0354210772,
0.0238192584,
0.0166914221,
0.0030951963,
-0.014305668,
0.0191006754,
0.0429050811,
-0.0066344575,
-0.0131149096,
-0.0504463613,
0.0122301476,
0.0109119676,
0.0044619548,
0.0326604694,
0.027837269,
-0.0108158244,
-0.0464369282,
0.0868651196,
0.0491962843,
-0.0032576711,
-0.0131048476,
0.0234127641,
-0.013175752,
-0.0064048367,
0.003274759,
-0.0491214357,
0.0528194495,
-0.0040341811,
0.0080125621,
-0.0029381865,
0.0197940748,
-0.0387841761,
-0.0251315497,
-0.0230601672,
0.0024920164,
0.0278756153,
0.0507976674,
0.038186308,
0.0187581889,
-0.0235189907,
0.0279849265,
0.0030846628,
0.0072228345,
-0.0312652066,
-0.023069039,
0.0285774618,
0.0393689945,
0.0163434166,
0.0011538303,
-0.0074288114,
0.0369278714,
0.0291882455,
0.0581395887,
0.0258731991,
0.0099381106,
0.0236370489,
-0.0146399671,
-0.0613627173,
-0.0293257888,
-0.0058940458,
0.0173962824,
0.0267552566,
-0.0333670639,
0.0016996958,
-0.0182535611,
0.0420846455,
0.0311858896,
0.0612752177,
0.0003694701,
-0.0641078576,
0.0301294103,
-0.0202929601,
-0.0390965454,
-0.0035801779,
0.0189246032,
0.0373026095,
-0.0408828072,
0.0576575249,
0.0064770277,
-0.0317540132,
-0.0253626555,
0.0398170426,
-0.0578415059,
0.0130733801,
0.0420809127,
-0.0136654871,
-0.0116341105,
0.0395225324,
-0.0548743233,
0.0047468133,
-0.0269841403,
-0.0163119324,
0.0326957405,
0.0227911603,
-0.0364135168,
0.0582123287,
-0.0280055311,
0.0013375548,
-0.0012063487,
0.0175093096,
0.022554962,
-0.0197391529,
-0.0134931803,
-0.021418998,
-0.0158853326,
0.0300930608,
-0.0034259055,
-0.0177758317,
-0.0197686385,
-0.0091928504,
-0.0801273808,
-0.0282953531,
-0.0098498454,
-0.0384110659,
0.0171078313,
0.0022905765,
0.0126298759,
-0.0631904826,
-0.0587835796,
0.0029677451,
0.0204863716,
0.0282028075,
0.0446495488,
0.0140052093,
0.0123126702,
-0.0389667563,
-0.0134433769,
-0.0034079053,
0.0595032871,
-0.0038861667,
-0.0312160105,
-0.0246474408,
0.0371511355,
-0.0337953083,
0.0679063573,
-0.0201966539,
-0.0182615165,
0.031930428,
-0.0318770446,
0.0263514742,
0.0816255361,
-0.0131967524,
0.032556612,
0.0124741783,
-0.0173217114,
-0.0508400798,
-0.0025918153,
0.0034673633,
-0.0121273184,
-0.0119307237,
-0.0108399624,
-0.0408240296,
0.0619421676,
-0.0058172634,
-0.0090444908,
-0.0712358654,
0.030770665,
0.0089666303,
-0.0319193341,
-0.0661541522,
0.026272295,
0.0075980471,
0.0184942372,
-0.0652366877,
-0.0814443082,
0.0405809321,
-0.0518982448,
0.0045153927,
0.011271474,
-0.0131729152,
-0.0332410373,
0.0848510563,
0.0474363901,
0.0171809234,
-0.0179027114,
0.0125966957,
-0.0775807723,
-0.0249484759,
-0.0065143025,
-0.0061724102,
0.0366701223,
-0.0454233363,
0.0255137943,
-0.0452836826,
-0.0330251195,
-0.0271736216,
-0.0363223068,
-0.0338324383,
0.0177519247,
-0.0530303158,
0.0081522064,
-0.0127306394,
0.0448675938,
0.0389939621,
0.0285621565,
-0.0052258717,
0.0022256593,
-0.0300412327,
0.0169202052,
0.0516885929,
0.0594885349,
-0.0279799867,
-0.0375214852,
-0.034405604,
0.0612810664,
0.0194577407,
0.0092890002,
-0.0571926385,
0.0512935519,
0.0364050828,
0.0597822778,
-0.0294500124,
0.0261914786,
0.0415253751,
-0.0565436184,
-0.0332849845,
0.0271386486,
0.0201382805,
-0.0206162073,
-0.0298444983,
0.0171816964,
0.0061803507,
0.0424086228,
0.0280801449,
-0.0672323257,
-0.0518524349,
-0.0164559931,
-0.0328258239,
0.019536918,
0.0392059796,
-0.0361702405,
-0.0938371196,
0.0465558916,
-0.0280497074,
-0.0389098041,
-0.0874471068,
0.0545352288,
-0.0129422545,
0.0238173567,
-0.005789767,
-0.0187448896,
-0.0139376204,
0.0065141059,
0.0096923383,
0.0226525329,
-0.0099935215,
0.0005984119,
-0.0432552285,
-0.0333487913,
0.0493231304,
-0.0037423079,
0.0068184081,
-0.0742320642,
0.0127302185,
-0.0055808639,
0.0279250871,
0.0179740116,
0.0446834788,
-0.0330765657,
-0.0546367392,
0.0004260566,
0.0050596334,
-0.020188123,
-0.0391657688,
-0.0667079091,
0.0348681174,
0.0023257306,
0.0285453405,
-0.0358162895,
0.0204042066,
-0.0279288962,
0.0381908342,
0.0271845423,
-0.0383598842,
-0.0457508452,
-0.0241874848,
0.0113594988,
-0.0118786693,
-0.0208187103,
0.0046548443,
0.0344156884,
0.050190039,
-0.0551287159,
-0.0307873134,
0.0421203338,
0.05679233,
-0.0182192493,
-0.006086329,
-0.0627653003,
0.0144663285,
-0.0764397979,
0.0938008279,
-0.0192127079,
0.0554324165,
-0.022253193,
-0.0001560742,
0.0258691888,
-0.0635056049,
-0.0261110701,
0.017751528,
-0.0895319134,
-0.0278513897,
-0.0305347349,
0.0642158091,
0.0133397095,
0.0470983833,
0.006881556,
-0.0432794653,
0.0156566706,
-0.0023545469,
0.0230701007,
0.0426677689,
-0.0063241259,
-0.0502799638,
-0.007346774,
-0.0032562916,
-0.0355977565,
-0.0087637175,
0.0284910668,
0.0025555885,
-0.0273749717,
-0.0353402905,
0.051596716,
-0.0094041303,
0.0518335849,
0.0156879295,
0.0313289426,
-0.0152059188,
0.0056775818,
0.0274113175,
-0.0126846097,
-0.0912955552,
-0.0085917925,
0.0170844812,
0.02048802,
0.0163002983,
0.0034050548,
0.0289689433,
0.0107757486,
-0.0279387236,
-0.0201476533,
0.0530388728,
-0.0229127835,
-0.0343804546,
0.0460280776,
0.0117121283,
0.0410275236,
-0.0325863622,
0.0692720935,
0.0132786706,
0.0596073531,
0.0225400105,
-0.051155027,
-0.0666182861,
0.0491699502,
-0.0529008955,
-0.0191468634,
-0.0402687676,
0.0598088689,
0.0479131751,
-0.0078085838,
-0.0314659998,
-0.0085599609,
-0.0321238376,
0.0198363736,
0.0224854741,
0.0196866021,
-0.0289351549,
0.0932564288,
0.0428441837,
0.0042375941,
-0.0354212709,
0.0585660748,
0.0499859676,
0.0316153914,
-0.0164204445,
0.0045026247,
-0.0150967576,
0.0064837434,
0.067046456,
0.02101757,
-0.0031194675,
0.0384261496,
-0.0239591077,
-0.0658949167,
-0.0065821153,
0.0734923035,
-0.0129759805,
-0.0085001895,
0.0463562161,
0.0542814322,
0.0552843064,
-0.0345618054,
-0.0239590853,
-0.0173769407,
0.0042452291,
0.0291419998,
0.0110459952,
-5.572213871e-33,
-0.0549420081,
-0.0239575207,
0.0361289456,
-0.0051989071,
-0.0174722429,
0.0422009192,
-0.0034314739,
0.0089451708,
-0.0222076848,
0.0008955988,
0.0270176306,
-0.0017411442,
0.0062577515,
0.0270985272,
-0.0002664601,
-0.0230124034,
-0.0122722229,
-0.0137939434,
-0.0026384057,
-0.0581214987,
0.012326871,
0.0076651373,
0.045605652,
-0.0177807529,
-0.0079634842,
0.0053615719,
-0.0113986228,
0.0302534141,
-0.0359314196,
0.0939070359,
-0.0466914438,
0.0000179315,
0.0141342692,
-0.007077774,
-0.0239850841,
0.0569728129,
-0.069871664,
0.0010163914,
0.0459021032,
0.0480109788,
-0.0789498538,
0.0173671339,
0.0597330332,
-0.0373649374,
0.0197000299,
-0.0244208686,
0.0328046717,
-0.0282447208,
-0.0003099947,
0.0309602711,
-0.0455888472,
-0.0073265578,
0.0140613904,
-0.0662208721,
0.0532848611,
0.0327920392,
0.0477690212,
0.0234916024,
-0.0153443422,
0.0186927151,
0.0094929375,
0.0513482653,
0.0775671452,
0.0757997259,
-0.0091486461,
0.0641813725,
0.0342412442,
-0.0464577153,
0.0007906908,
-0.0364207439,
0.0235452037,
0.0282638054,
0.0517403558,
0.0573883429,
0.0117392661,
0.0629690289,
-0.0331265293,
0.00080155,
-0.0468751304,
0.0309822522,
-0.0008753659,
0.0029835505,
-0.0230477601,
-0.0101892017,
-0.0438163169,
-0.0113078663,
-0.0434917361,
0.0068746195,
0.0745193139,
0.0408795886,
-0.0077053015,
0.0319874994,
0.0698330551,
-0.049309507,
0.0187363867,
-0.0067619043,
-0.0300909746,
0.0651162192,
0.0055563007,
0.0270890221,
-0.0296599437,
-0.0010633805,
0.0507273823,
-0.0108849918,
-0.0165788829,
0.0279318839,
0.0112036439,
0.0097659398,
-0.0412750952,
-0.0100986697,
-0.0426534861,
-0.0276031252,
-0.0380614288,
0.044881627,
0.0462040976,
0.0115042562,
-0.0524869934,
0.01122919,
-0.0121497493,
-0.0094938921,
-0.0296191163,
-0.0307828709,
-0.0445117839,
0.0355368704,
-0.0044720662,
-0.0094383964,
-0.0671771392,
-0.0104405703,
0.0089407414,
-0.0496150143,
-0.00994513,
0.0706712455,
2.508e-7,
0.0516845658,
-0.0164020583,
0.023854021,
0.0122390976,
0.0279540513,
0.0575944707,
-0.0357033908,
0.0329352953,
0.0141731706,
-0.0223203972,
-0.0141968997,
0.0447742343,
0.0212091412,
-0.0219258536,
-0.0017468811,
0.0623946302,
-0.018481655,
-0.0106257433,
-0.0396415405,
0.0058127372,
0.0032308395,
0.1038090587,
-0.0447516926,
-0.0121176811,
0.024525227,
-0.0552599467,
0.0910375342,
-0.0266236737,
-0.0046866075,
-0.0353980772,
-0.0021982414,
0.0153330006,
-0.0336194523,
0.0333907492,
0.0062746671,
0.0019247349,
0.0518156551,
0.0065636756,
-0.0317785665,
-0.0447784178,
-0.0506592654,
0.0173518062,
-0.0376489274,
-0.0660130233,
0.0766615644,
-0.0629016086,
0.0000832484,
-0.0726617798,
-0.0147828814,
0.0038146537,
0.0033599797,
-0.0074049742,
-0.0336364321,
-0.0178377572,
0.0289605372,
-0.0429101996,
-0.041432336,
-0.0683611929,
-0.0508103147,
-0.0038166412,
-0.0312298164,
-0.0034716683,
-0.0802703798,
-0.0430320464,
0.0582513362,
-0.0293713007,
-0.0710712895,
1.652480571e-34,
-0.0011086209,
-0.0227411911,
-0.0012122556,
0.0016435976,
0.0054510972,
-0.0073470199,
-0.0144409612,
-0.0048673404,
0.0112625128,
-0.0436751656,
-0.0088937059
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10037v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10037v3 | Can Language Models Solve Graph Problems in Natural Language? | 2023-05-17T08:29:21 | 2024-01-06T01:01:38 | Heng Wang, Shangbin Feng, Tianxing He, Zhaoxuan Tan, Xiaochuang Han, Yulia Tsvetkov | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly adopted for a variety of tasks
with implicit graphical structures, such as planning in robotics, multi-hop
question answering or knowledge probing, structured commonsense reasoning, and
more. While LLMs have advanced the state-of-the-art on these tasks with
structure implications, whether LLMs could explicitly process textual
descriptions of graphs and structures, map them to grounded conceptual spaces,
and perform structured operations remains underexplored. To this end, we
propose NLGraph (Natural Language Graph), a comprehensive benchmark of
graph-based problem solving designed in natural language. NLGraph contains
29,370 problems, covering eight graph reasoning tasks with varying complexity
from simple tasks such as connectivity and shortest path up to complex problems
such as maximum flow and simulating graph neural networks. We evaluate LLMs
(GPT-3/4) with various prompting approaches on the NLGraph benchmark and find
that 1) language models do demonstrate preliminary graph reasoning abilities,
2) the benefit of advanced prompting and in-context learning diminishes on more
complex graph problems, while 3) LLMs are also (un)surprisingly brittle in the
face of spurious correlations in graph and problem settings. We then propose
Build-a-Graph Prompting and Algorithmic Prompting, two instruction-based
approaches to enhance LLMs in solving natural language graph problems.
Build-a-Graph and Algorithmic prompting improve the performance of LLMs on
NLGraph by 3.07% to 16.85% across multiple tasks and settings, while how to
solve the most complicated graph reasoning tasks in our setup with language
models remains an open research question. The NLGraph benchmark and evaluation
code are available at https://github.com/Arthur-Heng/NLGraph. | [
0.0366378315,
0.0275467876,
0.0015596949,
0.0420017652,
-0.0747574121,
-0.0012030411,
-0.0169266388,
-0.0074677877,
0.0761971697,
-0.0304854475,
0.0177866817,
-0.0084861629,
-0.0063223001,
0.0427540131,
0.005895243,
-0.0204607006,
0.0228638779,
-0.0413299389,
0.0152821094,
-0.0094981557,
-0.0146932937,
0.0427771211,
-0.0098151872,
0.0132683981,
-0.0356253274,
-0.0143518038,
-0.0457904078,
0.0248067137,
-0.0243653599,
-0.0644321516,
-0.0468048006,
0.0075090858,
0.0376979038,
0.0051401923,
0.0000020583,
-0.0201236084,
-0.0084023252,
-0.0088701518,
-0.0397992618,
-0.041460488,
0.0176664852,
-0.0276334938,
0.044687409,
0.0033385674,
-0.0628033802,
-0.0200532246,
0.0349672362,
0.0361008383,
0.0669227913,
0.0764771402,
-0.0171071552,
-0.0271097906,
-0.0255524684,
0.0013699126,
0.0076004821,
-0.0488962382,
0.0159450397,
0.037010096,
0.0465771332,
-0.0175150819,
-0.0554684401,
0.0098297419,
0.0371094532,
-0.0159886461,
0.0244278051,
0.0398405977,
-0.0132943932,
0.011061687,
-0.0142165534,
0.1346869171,
0.0020506578,
-0.0149973705,
0.0175954998,
-0.0128384354,
-0.0138700213,
0.0397509187,
-0.0432735756,
0.0003086783,
-0.0188850965,
-0.0007640183,
-0.0100603029,
-0.0592657104,
0.0439151153,
0.0108743692,
0.004671108,
0.1235649064,
-0.0159855373,
0.0173173156,
0.0453286618,
0.001485158,
-0.0264292993,
-0.0527470522,
0.0227571074,
0.0717184916,
-0.0557092577,
0.0279383939,
-0.0187880825,
0.0377646163,
-0.0277860537,
0.0120355859,
0.0404139087,
0.0262670442,
0.0262707677,
0.0460853577,
0.0075051864,
0.0610672608,
-0.021728579,
0.0606446378,
-0.0525421388,
0.002202119,
-0.0591548458,
-0.0092619341,
-0.0711466074,
0.034184657,
-0.017704742,
-0.0571000874,
-0.0102157937,
0.0541746356,
-0.0100889783,
0.021752581,
0.0295216925,
0.0338624492,
0.0152298613,
-0.022757953,
-0.0337928832,
0.0141543597,
-0.0271868184,
0.0043451292,
-0.0247227699,
0.0035391233,
-0.0181713179,
0.0174087696,
0.0423040837,
-0.0381566137,
0.0218927525,
0.0778356418,
0.0426532291,
-0.0250924733,
-0.0174955353,
-0.0401163138,
-0.0147742033,
-0.0706855357,
0.0510623679,
-0.1040186286,
0.0423937328,
0.0346655734,
-0.0233200956,
-0.0177384,
0.0298318267,
-0.0035137085,
-0.0512764603,
0.0717030168,
0.0311348438,
0.031570144,
-0.0081414999,
-0.010812656,
-0.0097929277,
0.0337756127,
0.0413708016,
0.0017020704,
0.0066802325,
0.0257471092,
-0.0274145026,
0.0311847348,
0.0119993789,
0.0062707034,
0.0152114583,
-0.009624565,
-0.0403244719,
0.025324421,
-0.024808431,
0.071878396,
-0.0209209863,
-0.0431633741,
0.0272567496,
0.0692241415,
-0.0165384393,
-0.052747272,
0.0377622023,
0.0154936435,
-0.0145640168,
0.016785698,
-0.0706114098,
0.024651397,
-0.0046665296,
0.0158572793,
-0.038930025,
-0.0355251618,
0.005680535,
-0.0329631306,
-0.0254915841,
0.0095935473,
0.0846631303,
0.0068419068,
0.0624916591,
0.0181574039,
-0.0668128356,
-0.0006716923,
0.0065651149,
0.0000336097,
0.0063699945,
-0.0062039844,
-0.0280901324,
0.0783721358,
0.08225476,
-0.0043744971,
-0.0466010161,
0.0097815357,
0.0073731313,
0.0114267385,
0.0457677878,
-0.028516164,
-0.0099796485,
-0.0388385914,
-0.0150084216,
-0.0486527123,
-0.0220844802,
0.0134189799,
0.0351378135,
0.000009715,
-0.0210230332,
-0.0637639016,
-0.0355557241,
0.0101995477,
0.0046385564,
0.0124522429,
-0.0073769502,
0.0015743652,
-0.0016288236,
0.0247499496,
-0.0052511664,
0.0427010283,
0.0207995512,
-0.0091492506,
-0.0323763676,
0.0115156444,
-0.0488395169,
-0.0659437925,
0.0608647875,
-0.0188488774,
-0.0551506318,
0.0055918745,
-0.0420987979,
-0.038239602,
0.0545941815,
-0.0687558949,
0.0250620358,
0.0137256961,
0.0021392407,
0.0248999689,
-0.0595697761,
-0.0013490795,
0.0721484497,
0.0175812673,
0.0089571513,
0.017643813,
0.0317718424,
-0.0041588023,
-0.0467985012,
0.0059696748,
0.0237268694,
0.0154934265,
-0.0154406019,
0.014360453,
0.0205807798,
-0.0470164753,
0.0270799492,
-0.07962621,
-0.0016145114,
0.0073768371,
0.0080911592,
-0.0015906033,
-0.0065314882,
0.0107591199,
-0.0376294814,
-0.0507001057,
0.0528457351,
0.0336578824,
0.0107004745,
0.0394017994,
0.0000777355,
-0.0151201505,
-0.0216662325,
-0.0360474437,
-0.0644041449,
0.0477669165,
0.0468581691,
-0.0389540121,
-0.013093478,
0.0604427643,
-0.055420015,
0.0474436879,
-0.0065500662,
0.010885423,
0.0260904878,
-0.0301708244,
0.0500506461,
0.0638525486,
-0.0423591658,
0.0381199941,
0.0739659145,
-0.0428211801,
-0.0312709697,
0.0229856335,
-0.0560049601,
-0.0056587411,
-0.0218126476,
-0.0325724669,
-0.0466808043,
0.0227426272,
0.0075406833,
0.0024360607,
-0.0312729664,
0.0109203877,
-0.0167035945,
0.0437527448,
-0.0217973869,
-0.0417969115,
0.0249850657,
0.0140643874,
-0.0497177318,
-0.0309163332,
0.1021748334,
0.0074878363,
-0.0018122399,
-0.0029274044,
-0.0167444851,
-0.0635683015,
0.0999351889,
0.0665345937,
0.0302699469,
0.0010133224,
-0.0282598045,
-0.0525093637,
-0.0057152938,
0.0411293916,
-0.0168854669,
0.0102491109,
-0.0583621897,
0.039174933,
0.0132812271,
-0.022047719,
-0.0203733612,
0.0142136635,
-0.0341521874,
0.0256682858,
0.0045119566,
-0.0437726453,
0.0124517512,
0.0024144358,
-0.0190083943,
0.007695477,
-0.0167912263,
0.0021496394,
-0.0338052399,
0.0366104171,
0.0406806655,
-0.0017812268,
0.0092502059,
-0.030359095,
0.01507203,
0.0339869745,
0.0222219825,
-0.0136055984,
-0.0318986662,
0.0449126847,
-0.0104683321,
-0.009528893,
-0.0033385633,
0.0023760279,
0.0436474606,
-0.0638999343,
-0.0179746468,
0.0816865042,
0.0470619425,
-0.0068335831,
-0.0021274516,
0.0012243026,
0.013105005,
0.0395331047,
0.0404671505,
-0.099489674,
-0.0290831849,
0.0059112725,
-0.0013699284,
0.0194905549,
-0.0675151125,
-0.0295376834,
-0.1156654432,
0.0144348331,
0.0185525361,
-0.0139001589,
-0.03273388,
-0.0703125745,
-0.0338476598,
0.0208310783,
-0.0435549878,
-0.0368250832,
0.0019495877,
-0.0021319783,
-0.0004051361,
-0.022396015,
0.0016480418,
0.0240004174,
-0.0082188435,
0.0035950018,
-0.0130985985,
0.0418268479,
0.0227063894,
0.0040583955,
0.0424680375,
0.0568841696,
0.0019334765,
-0.0422875062,
0.0220137239,
0.0210144166,
-0.0071885027,
-0.0368672349,
0.0193562973,
-0.0712816268,
-0.0370640233,
-0.0293152928,
0.0883159935,
-0.0131131848,
-0.0380519219,
-0.0172059666,
0.0240435041,
-0.0056143948,
0.0447361767,
0.0152454702,
0.0314978771,
-0.0800225288,
-0.0647583902,
0.0224211309,
-0.0610104539,
-0.0541738644,
0.0238882955,
0.0071959589,
0.0395513996,
-0.0413307399,
-0.015125649,
0.0576146133,
0.0181672443,
0.0006282425,
-0.0123100551,
0.0527804121,
-0.0279036593,
-0.0682586432,
0.036414165,
-0.0280791782,
0.0426752232,
-0.0115047302,
-0.0209195465,
0.001555369,
0.0120517174,
-0.0070545911,
0.0265927259,
-0.0697392225,
-0.0909120813,
-0.0595481656,
0.0060520666,
0.017026078,
0.045003932,
-0.0238351375,
0.0267676152,
-0.0171179175,
0.0270544682,
-0.0203183722,
-0.0131631615,
-0.0049795206,
0.003337872,
0.0035153779,
0.0221679099,
-0.0557426177,
0.0041103549,
0.018205015,
0.0724083856,
-0.0313299671,
-0.0253993757,
0.0282544196,
0.0626693368,
-0.0052310261,
0.0433257967,
0.009299336,
-0.0403669961,
-0.0353278331,
-0.0274139326,
-0.0627551526,
-0.0196489971,
-0.0202704072,
0.002861554,
0.0012738133,
0.00825084,
-0.0292467885,
0.0086195245,
0.0428702086,
-0.0058293007,
-0.0137369288,
0.0448932946,
-0.0409253128,
0.0418207273,
-0.0042944821,
-0.0056102392,
0.0011875656,
0.0012995657,
0.0190183707,
-0.0055468222,
0.0443105698,
0.0390411951,
-0.0381100662,
-0.0560198054,
-0.0298334789,
-0.0466650948,
-0.0624346212,
0.0205075853,
0.0225442722,
0.0417535789,
0.0004010416,
-0.0108827194,
-0.0418143906,
0.0114455577,
-0.0005296266,
0.0257879812,
0.02105885,
-0.0615939163,
0.0740052089,
0.0475200564,
0.0215219241,
0.0150757367,
0.0262596477,
0.0468345955,
0.0457176007,
0.0377972536,
-0.0468431152,
-0.0214895885,
-0.0365730934,
-0.0085670315,
0.0154602462,
0.0034938485,
0.053792771,
-0.0605817959,
-0.0776298568,
-0.0039409949,
0.0152020352,
0.0147068994,
-0.0009845058,
0.0475157835,
0.0100951334,
0.040650662,
-0.05427178,
-0.0222155973,
0.0635227859,
-0.0370134525,
-0.0372662768,
-0.0092245005,
-6.044863619e-33,
-0.0139557635,
-0.1073875055,
0.0640928373,
0.0089368001,
-0.0363660045,
0.0232764259,
-0.0841041207,
0.0096616456,
-0.0341616496,
0.0143994242,
-0.0028374367,
0.0214210618,
-0.0015578906,
0.0079534417,
-0.0211450737,
-0.0160681717,
-0.0028447646,
0.0018556511,
-0.0177596305,
0.000783141,
0.0261420719,
-0.0144533487,
0.0171031188,
-0.036128588,
0.0101411911,
-0.0092037227,
0.0268043019,
0.0569580421,
-0.0086231846,
0.0241108742,
-0.0071239015,
0.0147894928,
0.0354712568,
0.0151667232,
0.007988329,
0.0426406004,
-0.0796345547,
-0.0530537926,
0.0260423701,
0.0216895323,
-0.0910448581,
-0.0093940124,
0.0420880057,
0.0089151636,
0.0204622913,
-0.024623761,
0.028215114,
0.0179740898,
-0.014218824,
0.0400010906,
-0.0222845674,
0.0092136329,
-0.0335059427,
-0.0288301669,
0.0199310035,
0.0232060626,
-0.0044985875,
0.0013482521,
-0.035705585,
0.0415770561,
-0.0581890084,
-0.0226781126,
0.0235075224,
0.0029398776,
0.026069086,
0.037097007,
-0.0135719236,
-0.0038382858,
-0.0337943472,
0.0368055999,
-0.0025502373,
0.0982765481,
0.0063061542,
-0.0277826302,
-0.011109734,
0.0267220475,
-0.0903789625,
-0.0159822609,
0.0049153767,
0.0408925191,
0.0020304127,
0.0125779472,
-0.0190621428,
-0.0590870976,
-0.0462166779,
-0.0166777708,
-0.0344030745,
-0.0022908894,
0.0054654484,
-0.0141171198,
-0.0149777932,
0.0065104128,
-0.006032201,
-0.0438146442,
-0.0330284312,
0.0826676711,
-0.012115079,
0.0394043662,
-0.0169728119,
0.057581678,
-0.0294478778,
-0.0166268442,
0.0067904252,
-0.0120107755,
0.0351318717,
0.0346169919,
0.0143966246,
0.0233451817,
-0.026286697,
-0.0136581548,
-0.069056794,
-0.0057412665,
-0.0220811237,
-0.0174954757,
0.0639241561,
0.0471323878,
-0.0114675034,
0.0592460781,
0.0275770687,
0.0004959693,
-0.016460266,
0.0414899439,
-0.0155490981,
0.0195027329,
-0.0275597889,
-0.0044498928,
-0.019996224,
0.0367671438,
0.0187238939,
-0.0524640419,
-0.0280064084,
0.0117326202,
2.763e-7,
0.0333125778,
0.0583034344,
0.0432503559,
0.086081773,
0.0153817069,
0.0185087826,
-0.0178300906,
-0.0077026081,
-0.0144744879,
-0.0349927619,
0.0173142366,
0.0779576004,
-0.0232810173,
0.0442437679,
-0.0472598635,
0.057293117,
-0.0325576589,
-0.0429576971,
-0.0393030867,
0.0142562753,
0.0495545194,
0.0169011001,
0.0358520821,
0.0124548292,
-0.0380605459,
-0.0891029462,
0.024147654,
0.0041788924,
-0.0026023102,
-0.0235783961,
-0.0358158536,
-0.0041674892,
-0.0213538092,
0.0378548279,
0.0069608642,
0.0051466161,
0.022404043,
0.0260385964,
-0.0129521601,
-0.014242392,
-0.0033305893,
-0.0467008352,
0.0046403329,
-0.0058903745,
0.0740200356,
-0.0440105572,
-0.051039461,
-0.0131043848,
-0.0031510512,
-0.0219244678,
-0.0050859111,
0.0160151068,
-0.0093674632,
0.0116740828,
0.0263563041,
-0.0155236339,
0.019808365,
-0.0472711064,
0.0105011016,
0.0165274572,
0.0087226778,
-0.0264530778,
-0.0148375826,
0.0459485985,
0.0142784202,
-0.0117948242,
-0.0133649642,
2.728954676e-34,
0.0209192764,
-0.0112334043,
-0.0035008031,
0.0063293525,
0.0581881851,
-0.0288397428,
-0.0396569073,
0.0148217753,
0.039809294,
-0.09339495,
-0.0342720561
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10036v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10036v3 | Are You Copying My Model? Protecting the Copyright of Large Language Models for EaaS via Backdoor Watermark | 2023-05-17T08:28:54 | 2023-06-02T06:56:29 | Wenjun Peng, Jingwei Yi, Fangzhao Wu, Shangxi Wu, Bin Zhu, Lingjuan Lyu, Binxing Jiao, Tong Xu, Guangzhong Sun, Xing Xie | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated powerful capabilities in both
text understanding and generation. Companies have begun to offer Embedding as a
Service (EaaS) based on these LLMs, which can benefit various natural language
processing (NLP) tasks for customers. However, previous studies have shown that
EaaS is vulnerable to model extraction attacks, which can cause significant
losses for the owners of LLMs, as training these models is extremely expensive.
To protect the copyright of LLMs for EaaS, we propose an Embedding Watermark
method called EmbMarker that implants backdoors on embeddings. Our method
selects a group of moderate-frequency words from a general text corpus to form
a trigger set, then selects a target embedding as the watermark, and inserts it
into the embeddings of texts containing trigger words as the backdoor. The
weight of insertion is proportional to the number of trigger words included in
the text. This allows the watermark backdoor to be effectively transferred to
EaaS-stealer's model for copyright verification while minimizing the adverse
impact on the original embeddings' utility. Our extensive experiments on
various datasets show that our method can effectively protect the copyright of
EaaS models without compromising service quality. | [
0.0497611873,
0.0670542419,
-0.0124789374,
0.0607075244,
-0.0450657904,
0.0178133845,
0.0290543903,
-0.0068375543,
0.0415169485,
-0.0744649768,
0.0193173923,
0.0265254732,
-0.0180532411,
0.0416129604,
0.0509739146,
0.0408569276,
0.0302954223,
-0.0053958576,
0.0189798903,
-0.0099608274,
0.0172023308,
0.0068293125,
0.0535390526,
0.0353825726,
-0.0035308949,
0.028984949,
0.0030890664,
-0.0121311322,
0.0175882038,
-0.003731671,
-0.0321728438,
0.0434572846,
0.0105775418,
0.094325006,
0.0000016481,
-0.0582858622,
-0.0447806567,
0.0467051677,
-0.0489998162,
0.0733773261,
0.0634923205,
-0.0097288424,
-0.0026685335,
0.0260399245,
-0.0238089692,
0.0337112062,
0.0396757722,
0.0376926735,
0.0970330536,
0.0661226436,
-0.0222239923,
-0.0441370457,
0.0462562926,
-0.0266229194,
-0.0205992479,
-0.0447094999,
0.0358411036,
-0.0008652289,
-0.011868896,
0.0078294892,
0.0160114951,
0.087327674,
-0.0006421654,
0.0003267037,
-0.0071439184,
0.0255209822,
-0.0066155749,
0.0089925975,
-0.0158392359,
0.0518942401,
-0.0146900751,
-0.0238004383,
0.0079405801,
-0.0126027344,
0.034644682,
0.0544645041,
-0.0037617595,
0.0463088974,
0.0460628308,
0.015585307,
0.024625482,
-0.0317198858,
0.0495921262,
0.014358297,
-0.0041905907,
0.0093548214,
0.0341956802,
-0.0512867458,
-0.0150376158,
-0.02974624,
-0.0142364223,
-0.0511794798,
0.0351348855,
-0.0120214177,
0.0581929088,
0.0151908267,
-0.0895658061,
-0.0508199446,
0.0157004371,
-0.0310754124,
0.0477338023,
0.0175954159,
-0.0116168298,
0.0391955301,
-0.051833529,
0.0314759277,
-0.0306711681,
0.0249447506,
0.022686759,
0.0062831561,
-0.0193182081,
-0.0474805422,
-0.0418427065,
0.050011456,
-0.0469525382,
-0.0453071594,
-0.0439035781,
0.0177136827,
-0.0172838382,
0.0476491116,
-0.0255743861,
0.0245405734,
0.0361399464,
0.0000313918,
0.036845535,
-0.0438566208,
0.0450456366,
0.0041000792,
-0.0122034643,
-0.055580195,
-0.003473873,
-0.0007959403,
0.0016169061,
0.0135058528,
0.0066917306,
0.071782507,
0.0544529893,
-0.0628363192,
-0.0194148142,
-0.0567718819,
-0.0044872677,
-0.0006693269,
0.0032234758,
-0.0557829328,
0.005693153,
-0.0308885574,
0.0004740772,
-0.0532552004,
0.0099550998,
0.014901218,
-0.0648568198,
0.0763272569,
-0.0003818689,
0.0042132265,
0.0136655429,
-0.0015511311,
-0.0202504359,
0.0570822731,
0.057041835,
0.0026328734,
0.0892392695,
-0.0012650136,
0.0071581961,
0.0657941625,
0.0169229619,
0.0291305073,
-0.0171724632,
-0.0259800609,
-0.0034768987,
-0.0164359249,
-0.0107792895,
0.0395911448,
-0.0119847646,
-0.0436403938,
0.0751452819,
0.0760983676,
-0.0523946285,
0.0303008929,
0.0212113038,
-0.004037058,
-0.0038842571,
-0.0146850245,
-0.0324192196,
-0.0450695604,
-0.0578241833,
-0.0239604674,
0.0118407821,
0.0040228348,
0.0112901758,
0.0122397421,
-0.0112023782,
-0.0225711986,
0.0013538704,
-0.0073780497,
0.0044192271,
0.0177806839,
-0.0081047891,
0.0732098892,
-0.0310701467,
-0.0345977135,
0.0049557686,
-0.0615231432,
-0.0202021655,
0.0344565064,
0.0915125683,
0.015114856,
0.0528341904,
-0.0328472219,
-0.0421871804,
0.0534908846,
0.0024580713,
-0.0065425592,
-0.0085770804,
-0.0309414677,
-0.031206606,
-0.0417430699,
0.0241817608,
0.0209462885,
0.0116123315,
0.0378282145,
0.0537896901,
0.0003207537,
-0.0284236036,
0.0231380071,
-0.0362150595,
-0.0500297137,
-0.0065714289,
-0.0007849305,
0.0327054001,
0.0197010078,
-0.0385456234,
0.0446330756,
0.0168561395,
-0.03632842,
-0.0425703414,
0.0024465593,
0.019896457,
0.007682329,
0.0308449045,
-0.0387333557,
0.0103439465,
0.0585984364,
-0.0332976542,
-0.0073726107,
0.0053466936,
-0.0556740239,
0.0512133054,
-0.044783365,
0.0234805401,
-0.0250857081,
0.0432199799,
-0.0193342194,
0.0199251119,
-0.0142184542,
0.0245006662,
0.0155491391,
-0.0307964142,
0.0229584873,
-0.0090939151,
-0.0725188255,
-0.0083081536,
-0.0010234367,
0.0123786926,
-0.0080944821,
-0.0195860397,
-0.0198696684,
0.0025592884,
-0.0570879206,
0.0016544255,
0.0003624659,
0.0347361453,
0.0176119376,
0.0015522047,
-0.0163679272,
-0.0017669155,
-0.0163823776,
-0.073711887,
0.0098228371,
0.0396167375,
0.007688046,
-0.0302305147,
-0.0565331094,
-0.003915967,
-0.0031209744,
-0.0123120351,
0.0861451924,
-0.0017623567,
0.0151088694,
-0.0799505487,
0.0132837445,
-0.0060958234,
0.0142243886,
0.0206317157,
-0.0160484258,
-0.0122376457,
0.0342934392,
-0.032820899,
0.0364744589,
0.0016671657,
0.0103916051,
0.0403407328,
0.0106815007,
-0.0441641659,
-0.0366770811,
-0.0255471487,
-0.004589125,
-0.0250048041,
-0.0111952126,
0.0380484946,
0.0257473718,
0.0184782874,
-0.0288288612,
-0.0243020263,
0.0389140993,
0.0002265943,
-0.0078043626,
-0.0348544158,
-0.0376431122,
-0.0526674464,
0.002214147,
-0.0049133589,
-0.0656314939,
0.048617553,
-0.0620747469,
0.0167953409,
-0.0226486474,
0.0107263196,
-0.0057015694,
0.0188567843,
-0.0061420654,
0.0285120532,
0.0086523285,
-0.0229053628,
0.0030327437,
0.0120191844,
0.0590157174,
-0.0675083622,
-0.0009174222,
-0.0001002483,
-0.0149990255,
-0.0031226233,
-0.012294109,
-0.0469814166,
-0.0789284557,
-0.0378919505,
0.0396412052,
0.0072677629,
0.0075511565,
-0.0229338333,
-0.0160483215,
0.0289614983,
0.0154840378,
-0.004436403,
0.0059181061,
-0.0448781475,
0.0867168531,
0.0414552614,
-0.0351893567,
0.0373452194,
0.0144442506,
0.0187670477,
0.0612637773,
0.0180273317,
0.015681928,
-0.0346074291,
0.0143329278,
0.0220105927,
-0.0264618099,
0.0114244558,
-0.0057545481,
-0.0103199156,
-0.0184893757,
0.0182613656,
0.0695534497,
0.0231479406,
0.0083261756,
0.0127454596,
0.0151587818,
0.0241164602,
0.0243869685,
0.0012935135,
-0.0872918367,
-0.023611391,
0.0500927903,
0.0201358981,
-0.0271133967,
0.0029055027,
-0.0280883256,
-0.1314187497,
0.0344315767,
0.0083891349,
-0.0162058882,
-0.0155147202,
-0.0345745943,
-0.0248412788,
0.030496709,
-0.0247987919,
-0.0485920943,
0.0216449723,
-0.0103099635,
0.0132681625,
0.0121618789,
-0.070899114,
-0.002382932,
-0.0346623324,
0.0282964129,
0.0673588365,
0.0090727145,
-0.0191371627,
-0.0502016917,
0.0223306324,
-0.0268782098,
-0.0216157027,
0.024020141,
0.0368610285,
-0.037361104,
-0.0170338955,
0.0063561862,
0.048790291,
0.0047135958,
-0.0167825185,
-0.0141258277,
0.0751585811,
0.0131158493,
0.0100916233,
-0.0212256145,
-0.0311773401,
0.0345571972,
0.0562928841,
0.0375965387,
-0.0145989358,
-0.0165013932,
-0.0483055487,
0.0158702508,
-0.0156782959,
-0.0468412824,
0.0400399864,
-0.0290299188,
-0.0424474292,
-0.075210385,
0.0101337004,
-0.0350574367,
0.0247697197,
0.046936933,
0.0131586576,
0.0196305942,
-0.0258992724,
-0.0201246776,
0.001667305,
-0.0889851078,
0.0451136939,
-0.0166010708,
0.0203541014,
0.0378956608,
0.0141588422,
-0.0502298623,
-0.0120864091,
-0.0684039593,
-0.1070384681,
0.0051786313,
0.0276123825,
0.023669323,
0.0261168461,
-0.0217213333,
-0.0531444177,
0.1264072955,
0.0467104316,
-0.0300963819,
0.0053263754,
0.0578577779,
-0.0330574214,
-0.0128474794,
0.0533707663,
-0.0405423716,
-0.0293435939,
0.0372282006,
0.0112122372,
0.0101436516,
0.0017921965,
0.0013241894,
0.0887596309,
0.0197367463,
-0.0394981168,
0.0267314985,
-0.0179227181,
0.030996412,
-0.0195725523,
-0.008127694,
-0.0385177098,
0.0193230882,
0.0010871456,
-0.0326713324,
0.0027673505,
0.005676371,
-0.0040202914,
0.0038618436,
-0.0227542464,
0.040397618,
-0.0025608751,
0.0053854724,
0.023306923,
0.0035942164,
-0.01032741,
0.0409901589,
-0.0084427716,
0.0072496166,
-0.0345161557,
0.0046686465,
0.0234575327,
0.0046231821,
-0.0394770838,
0.0588373989,
-0.0383297727,
-0.0226122309,
-0.0070729293,
0.0321899131,
0.0430209115,
-0.0327827223,
0.0336687602,
-0.0392262116,
-0.0189188179,
0.0001702757,
0.0096983351,
-0.0222060867,
-0.0585981607,
0.0338784866,
-0.013568325,
-0.0329002403,
0.0488873497,
0.0635174885,
0.0342628658,
0.0993153751,
-0.029366184,
-0.0457419455,
-0.0320130549,
-0.0283404514,
0.0617509633,
-0.0086404691,
-0.046091456,
-0.0116595645,
-0.0612090454,
-0.0928806439,
-0.0251237433,
0.004082873,
-0.0134211043,
0.0159898121,
-0.0138606252,
0.0484237745,
0.0217352528,
0.0011565201,
-0.0566254705,
0.0369610675,
-0.0282346196,
-0.040473178,
0.0188272111,
-5.568372943e-33,
0.0347400643,
-0.0240671951,
-0.0270634852,
-0.008959665,
0.0188178997,
0.0603484139,
0.0052697374,
-0.0149388146,
0.021275904,
-0.0043744761,
-0.0259290207,
-0.0064663948,
0.0122288661,
0.0147305392,
-0.0159350224,
-0.000848626,
0.0183312371,
-0.024603352,
-0.0298311971,
-0.0064618518,
0.0425400138,
0.0084952209,
0.0118910046,
-0.0404873714,
0.0265706982,
-0.024742825,
-0.0360153876,
-0.0272098314,
-0.0565913059,
0.0684643611,
-0.0356608331,
0.0173878856,
0.0000963856,
-0.061045114,
-0.0078107761,
0.0320063643,
-0.0193008222,
-0.0109693212,
0.0061197607,
-0.009064381,
0.0217249878,
-0.0416742191,
0.0465819612,
-0.0221666135,
-0.0196253099,
0.0260698665,
-0.0024814033,
-0.0293409992,
-0.0290484168,
-0.0149149066,
-0.0265920684,
0.0213591885,
-0.0233263709,
0.0303029418,
0.0634985045,
-0.0107057504,
0.0247687642,
0.0264658183,
-0.0637663454,
0.0091499398,
-0.0007511743,
-0.0227651373,
0.0441104956,
-0.0241794735,
0.0205230918,
0.0717070103,
-0.0238154754,
-0.0539309792,
0.0122499848,
-0.0101898042,
0.0113871731,
0.0505675897,
0.0393677168,
0.0499916337,
0.0658731386,
-0.0450434759,
-0.022277385,
0.0331637077,
-0.0309719574,
0.0010990226,
0.0687479526,
-0.0167474821,
-0.04061573,
0.0007706557,
-0.0794432163,
-0.0447189733,
-0.0337324217,
-0.0201865286,
0.0358794257,
0.0413256958,
-0.0627975985,
0.00524871,
0.0129434401,
-0.0767069235,
-0.0384707637,
-0.0027280385,
-0.0029901611,
-0.0017546251,
0.0088463034,
-0.0015418894,
-0.026244821,
-0.0122018661,
0.0062609981,
-0.060019657,
0.0436547697,
-0.0251297839,
0.0602265932,
0.0194987133,
-0.0823882595,
0.0289330333,
-0.0053077377,
0.0072238268,
0.0100853499,
0.0006755574,
0.0287749842,
-0.0148455426,
-0.0005983229,
-0.0334166363,
0.0150997946,
0.028601611,
-0.0057445038,
0.0369621925,
0.0068367403,
0.0401178971,
-0.0215810854,
0.0022531175,
0.0004802799,
0.0676938072,
0.0551631115,
-0.0140612815,
-0.0113985958,
-0.0307564791,
2.514e-7,
0.0143252751,
0.0058978987,
0.0270202868,
-0.0048829857,
0.0219012536,
0.0874991789,
-0.0026602088,
0.0467279553,
-0.0156440046,
-0.0145087428,
-0.0377145708,
-0.0167415868,
0.0549715534,
0.0019884927,
-0.0726715848,
-0.0176630784,
-0.060611777,
0.0334448442,
-0.0382326655,
-0.0166758988,
0.0630464777,
0.0881326571,
0.0411015414,
-0.0300349873,
-0.0333826169,
-0.0713198632,
0.0495771468,
-0.0181517601,
-0.0088895336,
-0.03479461,
0.033561945,
0.0525600165,
0.0144277196,
-0.0007672379,
-0.0518014058,
0.0401353016,
-0.0206379294,
0.0417104363,
0.0071542049,
0.0088932738,
-0.0377515033,
-0.0299246442,
-0.0309697203,
-0.0434354544,
0.0715450719,
0.014839231,
-0.0606281757,
-0.1025883704,
-0.0424626581,
-0.0539633818,
0.0186153762,
-0.0265794098,
-0.013370323,
-0.0021578765,
-0.0144517515,
-0.0058156503,
-0.000767179,
-0.1015905291,
0.0153454924,
-0.0527482666,
-0.0240233447,
0.0057744663,
-0.030055562,
0.0001374617,
0.0445778444,
-0.0633583814,
0.0153415175,
2.539881001e-34,
0.0050254115,
-0.0366252027,
0.0230764095,
0.06986662,
0.0409945957,
0.0024115252,
0.0592899919,
0.0080371182,
-0.0127864461,
-0.0601088442,
-0.0159498118
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10013v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10013v1 | When Gradient Descent Meets Derivative-Free Optimization: A Match Made in Black-Box Scenario | 2023-05-17T07:48:28 | 2023-05-17T07:48:28 | Chengcheng Han, Liqing Cui, Renyu Zhu, Jianing Wang, Nuo Chen, Qiushi Sun, Xiang Li, Ming Gao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large pre-trained language models (PLMs) have garnered significant attention
for their versatility and potential for solving a wide spectrum of natural
language processing (NLP) tasks. However, the cost of running these PLMs may be
prohibitive. Furthermore, PLMs may not be open-sourced due to commercial
considerations and potential risks of misuse, such as GPT-3. The parameters and
gradients of PLMs are unavailable in this scenario. To solve the issue,
black-box tuning has been proposed, which utilizes derivative-free optimization
(DFO), instead of gradient descent, for training task-specific continuous
prompts. However, these gradient-free methods still exhibit a significant gap
compared to gradient-based methods. In this paper, we introduce gradient
descent into black-box tuning scenario through knowledge distillation.
Furthermore, we propose a novel method GDFO, which integrates gradient descent
and derivative-free optimization to optimize task-specific continuous prompts
in a harmonized manner. Experimental results show that GDFO can achieve
significant performance gains over previous state-of-the-art methods. | [
0.0393730886,
0.0438270308,
0.0055869785,
0.0347306654,
-0.0249691512,
0.0082982117,
0.0453348868,
0.0009518933,
-0.0003944312,
-0.0325135067,
-0.0661535561,
-0.0195342023,
0.0252537709,
0.0166115128,
-0.0073213107,
-0.0264914632,
0.014595909,
-0.023631122,
0.0005141997,
0.00561328,
0.0077975211,
-0.0032222655,
-0.0197215155,
0.0093397256,
-0.0267794952,
-0.0422389582,
-0.020180691,
0.0036847533,
0.0142747629,
-0.0026074559,
0.0509923622,
0.0631284788,
0.025265798,
0.0346554741,
0.0000024057,
-0.0322242714,
-0.0370345861,
-0.0168324132,
-0.0946321413,
0.0053065373,
-0.007756569,
0.0214301497,
0.0434101261,
0.0296674259,
-0.0734669194,
-0.0475978181,
0.0100765061,
0.0308165979,
0.0847966969,
0.1214022562,
0.0116088856,
-0.0325164311,
0.0062761842,
-0.0451260842,
-0.0096432185,
-0.0274517927,
0.0067631225,
-0.013322969,
-0.0268035997,
-0.0221858472,
-0.0168849584,
0.0466837212,
0.0076507893,
0.0090214964,
-0.0129419863,
0.0160941556,
-0.0297480319,
-0.0245524663,
-0.0551909693,
0.1180342361,
-0.0658749864,
-0.0076690423,
0.0163718574,
-0.0381882712,
-0.0107291089,
-0.0230735932,
-0.0166195799,
-0.0133823669,
0.008154925,
0.0254369453,
-0.0151914004,
-0.0144993691,
0.0116628213,
-0.0157871861,
-0.038086351,
0.0851527378,
-0.018540876,
-0.0426929146,
0.0551529489,
-0.0323823877,
-0.0532069653,
-0.0458349548,
0.0136891296,
0.0210253987,
-0.0136226397,
0.0074277367,
-0.0503030717,
-0.0639484674,
-0.017433174,
-0.0297513381,
0.0616463237,
0.0450273529,
0.0121663213,
0.0439006574,
-0.0155999633,
0.0352852568,
0.0000491791,
0.0259222053,
-0.0259064939,
0.0400840417,
-0.0605794266,
-0.0210530609,
-0.063123785,
0.0521832518,
-0.0747146383,
-0.0295593645,
0.0065336567,
0.0057336646,
-0.0059184646,
-0.0338293649,
0.0510657802,
0.0302818045,
-0.0195131823,
-0.0101559749,
-0.01406659,
0.016381776,
-0.0217856802,
0.0101462491,
-0.0147188762,
-0.0397694185,
-0.0373434909,
0.0227151029,
0.026058713,
-0.0159113277,
0.0200145654,
0.0555356368,
-0.0035836457,
-0.0275018867,
-0.014347339,
-0.0131265251,
0.0076451236,
-0.0600793213,
-0.0045167231,
-0.0245780461,
0.0364212021,
-0.0259257369,
0.0315457135,
-0.0723269507,
0.0141232545,
-0.0065590013,
-0.0080809966,
0.1009868383,
-0.0261735283,
-0.0043993522,
0.0324068554,
-0.0072900075,
-0.0149143171,
0.0897760391,
0.0119366646,
0.0196267702,
0.0252617318,
0.0183363073,
-0.0238690954,
0.0312042125,
0.0388850309,
0.0041051093,
0.0150659122,
-0.0009166317,
-0.0137984054,
0.028596146,
0.0265087895,
0.0137822675,
-0.0131543251,
0.0247524437,
0.0594745167,
0.0366158746,
0.0579233728,
-0.0251651853,
0.0418962352,
0.0391003042,
0.0188889224,
-0.0093582049,
-0.0463427566,
-0.0592475198,
-0.0266800318,
0.0073578637,
0.0228832141,
0.0339679718,
-0.0298458338,
-0.0543102212,
0.0238100886,
-0.0329822488,
0.0127583584,
0.0204296373,
0.0093831522,
0.0093904017,
-0.048304908,
0.0397424325,
0.0083135245,
-0.0047067455,
-0.0152608771,
-0.0322047472,
0.0188394431,
0.0431402139,
0.0329373106,
-0.0550990775,
-0.0268836878,
-0.0331095196,
0.0422748998,
0.0491975658,
0.0023583064,
0.0087790117,
0.0324078687,
-0.0750427991,
-0.0602913015,
0.0086362902,
0.0064559183,
0.0464609601,
0.0281138159,
0.0296496805,
0.040957544,
0.0104420763,
-0.0472475514,
0.031342268,
-0.0037677616,
-0.0819972605,
0.0476549827,
0.0006797602,
0.0411059819,
0.0078855073,
-0.0203968119,
-0.0058014751,
0.0107390052,
-0.0437832251,
-0.0096180467,
-0.032374084,
-0.0545907058,
-0.0662624314,
0.0340662524,
-0.0088774236,
0.0264564157,
0.0455327965,
-0.0546536371,
-0.0497139953,
-0.0198673513,
0.015327638,
0.0654269457,
-0.0033078711,
0.0216739997,
0.0105186217,
0.0329903699,
-0.0476524346,
0.0563701242,
-0.0023534023,
-0.0166273285,
-0.0147076044,
0.0119511578,
0.0146463206,
-0.0257732067,
-0.0139974235,
-0.0171344355,
0.0079759443,
0.0304374602,
0.025494568,
0.0776814371,
-0.0193873569,
0.0139290998,
-0.0965698585,
0.0513909012,
-0.0614264496,
0.0219356176,
0.0222692881,
0.0400975011,
-0.0414733104,
-0.0415327623,
-0.0095828697,
0.0103933429,
-0.0235670451,
-0.0317927934,
0.0269942675,
0.0350006595,
0.0302838255,
-0.0232117511,
-0.0089509133,
0.0283784792,
0.0258814115,
-0.0329786167,
0.013585587,
-0.0018840863,
0.0675071105,
0.0073210476,
0.0705728754,
0.0088283625,
0.0217443854,
-0.0084188078,
0.0011304853,
0.0454803705,
0.0617115684,
0.0164029859,
0.0020890716,
-0.0044747372,
0.0022875245,
-0.0805152729,
0.0417508744,
-0.053319674,
-0.0059450748,
-0.0131739462,
0.0248522107,
0.0524304211,
0.0876779482,
0.0059001027,
-0.0097426577,
-0.0564952418,
0.0310004354,
-0.0083118388,
-0.0275970157,
-0.0663749352,
0.0260112397,
-0.0488240458,
0.0152159566,
-0.0048871371,
-0.0600098744,
0.0787721351,
-0.0448835045,
0.0042709075,
-0.062925972,
-0.0106038824,
-0.0434704162,
0.013436541,
-0.0235130694,
-0.024424443,
0.0222622175,
-0.0238830447,
-0.0121012973,
0.0093564801,
0.039608188,
-0.018609127,
0.0367929488,
-0.0199184548,
0.0159240868,
-0.0147851733,
-0.0305620041,
-0.049959369,
-0.0766818225,
-0.0023203716,
-0.0106945112,
0.011374088,
-0.007951092,
-0.0049546412,
0.0175715778,
-0.0085585928,
0.1005580723,
-0.033293955,
0.0058648149,
-0.0536719114,
0.0140534453,
0.0389050655,
-0.0061973352,
0.0053603547,
-0.0098965773,
0.0251553953,
-0.0167639479,
0.0437186211,
-0.0096903779,
-0.0037252216,
0.0015044126,
0.0073633064,
-0.0470665097,
-0.0379169025,
0.0003046536,
0.0133256251,
-0.0644957498,
-0.014907117,
0.1405226886,
0.0293802749,
-0.0639466345,
-0.0192494597,
0.0272015017,
0.0289181154,
0.0028550273,
0.0092550796,
-0.0896425769,
-0.0715384409,
-0.0143627198,
0.0635362267,
0.0026777396,
-0.0192054417,
-0.0353891551,
-0.1081602573,
-0.013448881,
0.0070006684,
0.0192916263,
0.0052349009,
-0.0195343588,
-0.0147966612,
-0.0178313293,
0.0199900642,
-0.0178356748,
0.002675083,
0.0158375632,
0.0270513576,
-0.0367537737,
-0.0730334744,
0.0011623488,
-0.0055279061,
0.0076093017,
0.0904454514,
-0.0079407217,
0.0195762087,
-0.0058427583,
0.0563836507,
-0.0110519407,
-0.0060986714,
-0.0359141193,
0.014791958,
-0.0418555588,
-0.0084178271,
0.0296493564,
0.0290963538,
-0.0666440278,
0.0081011383,
0.0183263198,
0.0481614098,
-0.0223081037,
-0.0065682987,
0.0088124312,
-0.036780946,
0.0501549579,
0.0600427762,
0.0306361858,
-0.080937095,
-0.0444366299,
-0.0102927163,
0.0049597835,
-0.0569900237,
-0.0036134259,
-0.014784677,
-0.0017085541,
0.0061641531,
-0.0320566706,
-0.0133148357,
0.0233840644,
0.042393662,
0.00727625,
-0.000994692,
0.0160214175,
0.0056659118,
-0.0520687439,
0.0395045467,
-0.0155107118,
-0.0098158717,
-0.0845510513,
-0.0284830071,
0.0356229059,
-0.0041428078,
-0.0254749004,
0.033043474,
-0.0775260329,
-0.0609832145,
-0.0065334993,
0.0682946518,
0.0123653794,
0.0446298905,
-0.0155764995,
-0.0575085469,
0.0819213688,
0.0367486998,
-0.0044576307,
-0.0061215535,
0.035453584,
-0.0224783029,
-0.0035711448,
0.02109937,
-0.0135452244,
0.0202532262,
0.0570288375,
0.0287710596,
-0.0135964304,
-0.0027547556,
0.0133246323,
0.027398726,
0.0689625517,
-0.0077629653,
-0.0160266589,
-0.0381904989,
0.0392390117,
0.0312771946,
-0.0164617226,
-0.0575461499,
0.014079608,
0.0074319746,
-0.0435474962,
0.0040218802,
0.0143685089,
0.0111834202,
-0.0057038767,
-0.0392470807,
0.0261483323,
0.0338252075,
-0.0204945933,
0.0484884009,
-0.0140159773,
0.0172699206,
0.0681807473,
0.0314678401,
0.022290865,
-0.020621689,
0.0471339561,
0.0204326268,
0.0163693372,
-0.0315775387,
0.0444391221,
-0.0410723388,
-0.0846909508,
-0.0571483821,
0.0276998542,
0.0613822415,
-0.0010988116,
0.0183721371,
-0.0041554091,
-0.0018240944,
-0.0260576271,
-0.0076200217,
0.015351627,
0.0428820774,
0.0021522294,
0.0090704849,
-0.027265748,
0.0336852744,
0.0962729007,
0.0169669613,
0.0482548662,
-0.0076396945,
0.0083286716,
-0.0780823827,
0.0015234041,
0.011062637,
0.0388373472,
-0.0046554063,
0.0433233939,
-0.0093513066,
-0.0518902987,
0.0058139977,
-0.0269467887,
-0.0193074346,
0.0138952816,
0.0824320391,
0.0148589388,
-0.0463377535,
-0.0086989542,
-0.0278606843,
-0.0103989113,
-0.000915841,
-0.0407323055,
0.0018556556,
-6.876362038e-33,
-0.0323686264,
-0.0045786584,
-0.0161992144,
0.0216049161,
-0.0416588113,
0.0179075487,
0.0092042871,
-0.0204073768,
0.0055065621,
-0.0073475149,
-0.0575733893,
-0.001661769,
0.0354955867,
0.0294893831,
-0.0254755393,
-0.0120308055,
0.034723036,
-0.0380708314,
-0.0594825223,
0.0221090112,
0.0429926515,
0.0809669048,
0.0172795821,
-0.0054117334,
0.0113146463,
0.0012780657,
-0.012867284,
0.031878788,
0.0196535885,
0.0162234008,
-0.0341451876,
0.0349505767,
0.0037540642,
-0.0396585949,
-0.0549368411,
0.0172963608,
-0.0580080003,
-0.0221920256,
0.0237945169,
0.0098038688,
-0.0244718976,
0.0080694035,
0.0323320143,
0.0070976121,
0.0123618599,
0.0057274159,
0.0005758607,
-0.0050345222,
0.0023412346,
-0.0292380173,
-0.0196526982,
0.0195877571,
-0.0084323836,
-0.0483626761,
0.0740114823,
-0.0075152228,
-0.0300010163,
-0.0333187208,
-0.0521791652,
-0.0014790251,
0.0466489978,
0.0441505872,
0.0301896743,
0.0600373857,
0.0274818465,
0.0142940171,
-0.0064211572,
-0.0134580256,
0.0011187213,
-0.0318351947,
0.0404621512,
0.0146260448,
-0.0201123599,
-0.0012023842,
0.0383595861,
-0.024583336,
-0.0729158446,
-0.0023116125,
-0.0168824326,
-0.0025091099,
0.0097115571,
0.0083575491,
-0.0276979301,
-0.0275571849,
-0.0536055192,
-0.0119425422,
-0.0031767387,
-0.0196614824,
0.0342745185,
0.048667863,
-0.0545359217,
-0.0284980182,
0.0376019478,
-0.0489427969,
0.0788549259,
-0.0017322513,
0.0216561519,
-0.011282648,
0.0314622186,
-0.0002049922,
-0.0625612289,
-0.0489977486,
-0.0265053995,
-0.0026686911,
0.0194287933,
-0.0149196079,
-0.0153120719,
0.0197543744,
-0.0514343269,
0.0104510896,
-0.0039146449,
0.0416172408,
0.0154014546,
0.0979126319,
0.0260425545,
-0.010926025,
-0.0146872746,
0.0480645746,
0.0161642786,
-0.0247831289,
-0.0099543622,
0.0154843954,
0.0273337699,
0.0420223437,
-0.0253776703,
-0.0047985413,
0.0118055288,
0.0019976201,
0.0004302933,
-0.0447107367,
-0.0042281309,
-0.0077861799,
3.002e-7,
0.0302664954,
0.0284898132,
0.0013641504,
0.0248508118,
0.0061353552,
0.0307005607,
0.0072048907,
-0.000614406,
-0.0418939963,
-0.0172342565,
0.0288112126,
0.0190579668,
0.0568150468,
-0.0059186616,
-0.1187327579,
-0.0516532958,
-0.0317901038,
0.018041255,
-0.0512709469,
-0.0614695251,
-0.0077706724,
0.0888218284,
0.0039835991,
-0.0063372804,
-0.0187017694,
0.0056558596,
0.0454396307,
0.006375419,
0.0174467266,
0.0470138229,
0.0312116556,
0.0083757704,
-0.0406157635,
0.0289142672,
-0.0353294536,
0.0712640733,
0.0049891085,
0.0975556821,
0.0085962052,
-0.0539297014,
0.0043133451,
0.0102750491,
0.0011316185,
-0.0269088503,
0.0690838322,
-0.0295154601,
0.0071678502,
-0.0311754234,
0.0291749369,
-0.0488409959,
0.0702894479,
-0.0557221361,
0.006431567,
0.0306304432,
0.0184474792,
-0.0029437281,
-0.0273766257,
-0.1002008766,
-0.008669286,
0.0114449011,
-0.0260213222,
-0.016798351,
-0.0453979634,
0.0130754318,
0.0287246034,
-0.0394507162,
0.0274379011,
2.913173696e-34,
0.0283997729,
-0.0129193757,
0.0181181487,
0.026394194,
-0.0087012174,
0.0053800577,
-0.0098825302,
-0.0165148135,
0.0154863726,
-0.0999418199,
-0.010258466
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10010v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10010v1 | AD-KD: Attribution-Driven Knowledge Distillation for Language Model Compression | 2023-05-17T07:40:12 | 2023-05-17T07:40:12 | Siyue Wu, Hongzhan Chen, Xiaojun Quan, Qifan Wang, Rui Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Knowledge distillation has attracted a great deal of interest recently to
compress pre-trained language models. However, existing knowledge distillation
methods suffer from two limitations. First, the student model simply imitates
the teacher's behavior while ignoring the underlying reasoning. Second, these
methods usually focus on the transfer of sophisticated model-specific knowledge
but overlook data-specific knowledge. In this paper, we present a novel
attribution-driven knowledge distillation approach, which explores the
token-level rationale behind the teacher model based on Integrated Gradients
(IG) and transfers attribution knowledge to the student model. To enhance the
knowledge transfer of model reasoning and generalization, we further explore
multi-view attribution distillation on all potential decisions of the teacher.
Comprehensive experiments are conducted with BERT on the GLUE benchmark. The
experimental results demonstrate the superior performance of our approach to
several state-of-the-art methods. | [
-0.0043726237,
0.0700938925,
-0.0122935083,
0.0592732616,
-0.0168302767,
0.0074976338,
0.0164601132,
-0.0090583162,
-0.0465949662,
-0.0077887229,
-0.0224316251,
-0.0032933776,
0.0064347531,
-0.0076459013,
0.0492611267,
-0.0483942144,
0.0151765514,
-0.0350694656,
0.0207104385,
-0.006855418,
0.0009917046,
-0.0036463547,
0.0245586168,
0.0554826632,
-0.0132238586,
-0.0116729513,
-0.000755231,
0.0125894025,
0.0095676929,
0.0461541191,
0.0165455006,
0.056565363,
0.0205500759,
0.0146051534,
0.0000022541,
-0.0086394735,
-0.0210674424,
0.0176594555,
-0.0489070937,
0.0532131493,
0.0014785487,
0.0254667383,
0.0258737095,
0.002685843,
-0.0402109474,
0.0129609993,
0.0299093965,
0.0228513423,
0.0900987238,
0.0416226462,
-0.0086690299,
-0.0435684696,
-0.0100715756,
-0.0236374941,
-0.0243610386,
-0.0262602344,
0.0213729236,
0.0047521503,
-0.0676039681,
-0.0369441658,
-0.0439714417,
0.0689095706,
0.0361659117,
-0.0260349996,
0.0117804259,
-0.0027700949,
-0.0337765254,
-0.0218882654,
0.0137551287,
0.0734169558,
-0.0450931937,
-0.0327645019,
0.0096250074,
0.0017858939,
0.0215451531,
0.0103183212,
-0.0516709872,
-0.0199254788,
0.0285263676,
0.0383233763,
-0.0189964622,
0.0009544172,
0.0395849645,
-0.0071492414,
-0.0511205792,
0.0225031935,
0.0098274928,
-0.0187441334,
-0.001406979,
-0.0045014522,
-0.0395461246,
-0.0549919344,
0.0064135729,
0.0396420062,
0.0432229266,
0.0170769021,
-0.0674217418,
-0.0354225822,
-0.0032445353,
-0.0144342491,
0.0639067218,
0.0357836001,
-0.0017749135,
0.0256990343,
-0.0380918011,
0.0665777475,
0.0037003702,
0.0400724746,
-0.0369612686,
-0.0146666486,
-0.0703674629,
-0.0214117691,
-0.0509778671,
0.0372777171,
-0.0042430549,
-0.0060924911,
-0.0050442615,
-0.0122907674,
-0.0399675965,
-0.0323006213,
0.0511058122,
-0.0023641374,
-0.0046376172,
-0.0041918885,
0.0067183501,
0.0729451403,
-0.0443614759,
0.0088999961,
0.0135158598,
-0.0174459554,
-0.0527019203,
0.0130142188,
0.0042393045,
-0.0168804284,
-0.0085487841,
0.0145428376,
-0.0278728064,
-0.010843928,
-0.043503046,
-0.0325756334,
-0.0122253671,
-0.0657940805,
-0.0068203146,
-0.0643981323,
0.0476372689,
-0.0179144125,
-0.0152996322,
-0.0982485339,
-0.0140253073,
-0.0256165359,
-0.0359230936,
0.0382520258,
-0.0081126587,
0.024334209,
-0.0037107284,
0.0274821706,
0.0095864907,
0.0595849492,
0.0143878106,
0.0390248261,
-0.0093820384,
-0.0202253293,
-0.0134959407,
0.0158980656,
0.1034521013,
0.0266484264,
-0.0614858493,
-0.0200303663,
-0.0307439975,
-0.0194105245,
0.0472628698,
0.0661644861,
-0.0571391732,
0.0207241718,
0.0406226069,
0.0242941305,
0.0241633281,
0.0297409575,
0.04194998,
0.0088033173,
0.020370502,
0.0097260494,
-0.0360546485,
-0.005535509,
-0.0045577865,
-0.008904974,
0.0324819423,
0.0550853126,
-0.0302251149,
-0.0436965264,
0.0123532992,
-0.0190762207,
0.0205737278,
0.0283777751,
0.0361278392,
0.0399323404,
0.001471023,
0.1119046286,
0.0268561561,
-0.065077126,
0.0251209959,
-0.0739710256,
-0.0214983523,
0.0336398445,
0.032205604,
-0.0214614291,
-0.0586183853,
0.0103778383,
-0.0006018915,
-0.0267921779,
0.0339055546,
-0.0407246053,
0.0344110839,
-0.0510306954,
-0.0560412332,
-0.0054919878,
0.0416738838,
0.0022758276,
0.0205348823,
0.0124382814,
0.0326722898,
-0.0659236386,
-0.0227593742,
0.0302055851,
-0.0095826499,
-0.0352443308,
-0.0207157079,
0.0170962662,
0.017235864,
0.0081893327,
-0.0138170496,
-0.0118093034,
0.0268373508,
-0.0303311422,
-0.0030247851,
-0.0028742545,
-0.0620902218,
-0.0944517851,
0.0343442522,
-0.014781096,
0.0157180429,
0.0210571494,
-0.0496616401,
-0.0568894669,
0.0242762081,
-0.0013902609,
0.087952666,
-0.0313216262,
0.0281394124,
-0.0191524755,
-0.0066552088,
-0.0017473107,
0.0426958241,
-0.0360401981,
-0.0319256447,
0.0262279604,
-0.0296473708,
0.0156523827,
0.0383375697,
-0.0301210601,
-0.0119385496,
-0.031790778,
0.0253072716,
0.0121027092,
-0.0072848196,
-0.0094559379,
-0.0150235211,
-0.0365470573,
-0.0197972357,
-0.0144551564,
0.024263246,
0.0206956007,
0.0243674833,
0.0176586136,
-0.0088143656,
-0.0297609121,
-0.0406913683,
-0.0386421569,
-0.0201851148,
-0.0078818146,
0.010968484,
0.0035916483,
-0.0247716475,
-0.0214621499,
-0.0007399108,
0.0554482155,
-0.0415740274,
0.008565627,
-0.0183871184,
0.014233835,
-0.0428824201,
0.0311800092,
-0.0026091961,
-0.0527903959,
-0.0103661222,
-0.030123366,
0.0147474036,
0.0569764487,
-0.028461339,
0.0537734739,
0.0680028647,
-0.0152928112,
-0.1004461497,
0.0428274497,
-0.0249504671,
0.0153151657,
-0.0488298126,
-0.0227928329,
-0.011525278,
0.0952749178,
-0.0039124461,
-0.0314685442,
-0.0809277073,
-0.0178398471,
-0.0155718094,
-0.0513984002,
-0.0327507555,
-0.0096269762,
0.003902135,
0.0010186197,
-0.0130356662,
-0.044326175,
0.0796686038,
-0.0378309451,
0.008540432,
0.0027385063,
0.0082428074,
-0.0108997962,
0.0611246079,
-0.0257234424,
0.0226462092,
0.0043625799,
0.0105124498,
-0.0487164743,
-0.003907741,
0.0313759223,
-0.0285096727,
0.0215178691,
-0.062579833,
-0.0099253347,
0.0129650682,
-0.0143007198,
-0.0140554626,
-0.0239571389,
0.0128267091,
0.029827984,
0.0347182602,
-0.0377407297,
-0.0207881667,
-0.0043926495,
0.0131232264,
0.0236442294,
-0.000417654,
0.0269748848,
-0.0030599267,
0.0178983621,
0.0203497056,
-0.0053462246,
0.0034602289,
-0.0215726178,
0.0019186622,
0.0383855663,
0.0584748723,
-0.003063878,
-0.0156840552,
-0.0014664464,
0.0229574367,
0.012198193,
-0.0464650393,
0.002682226,
0.0520913303,
-0.0783316344,
0.0012253631,
0.1060133502,
0.014186631,
-0.0271416549,
-0.0044032605,
0.0127970194,
0.0929144993,
0.0045733242,
0.0288701151,
-0.0695890784,
-0.0501144715,
0.0083236657,
0.0149033982,
0.044953417,
-0.0172729939,
-0.0262498017,
-0.0770502388,
-0.0038186456,
0.0218139142,
0.0086265216,
-0.0168475993,
-0.0163985491,
-0.0013849767,
0.0073306523,
-0.0106531046,
-0.0138145052,
0.0061962921,
0.0244475622,
0.0263650361,
-0.0194557328,
-0.0631450787,
0.0084925462,
0.0083243446,
0.0351105519,
0.0517393872,
0.0555659644,
0.0190195292,
-0.0428971685,
-0.0204674266,
0.0080129039,
-0.0099020666,
-0.0181045681,
0.0543968342,
-0.0138786491,
0.0080818571,
0.0477299541,
0.0506574064,
-0.0318496078,
0.0106411818,
-0.0025897203,
0.0839140713,
0.0192598104,
-0.048700016,
-0.0229659155,
-0.0714062452,
0.0217226855,
0.1058408171,
0.0629981756,
-0.0159902107,
-0.037137799,
-0.0007510763,
-0.0303363949,
-0.0128165986,
-0.0292776171,
0.0215427577,
-0.012713233,
-0.0285357237,
-0.0605157726,
-0.010615252,
0.0374101847,
0.0415608622,
0.0104361735,
-0.0183567703,
0.0008026931,
0.0012404559,
-0.0549528822,
0.0090061994,
-0.0094186431,
-0.0022058093,
-0.0257448982,
-0.0132895112,
-0.0191530604,
-0.0071462439,
-0.0301179793,
0.0160084907,
-0.0699160844,
-0.0741668791,
0.0173403714,
0.0682918057,
0.0238579344,
0.0929256901,
-0.0229967032,
-0.0517687909,
0.1065745056,
0.0138502195,
-0.0088638496,
-0.0037736313,
0.0753130093,
-0.0670507401,
0.0216868762,
0.0676280335,
-0.0474321581,
0.0210438315,
0.0399221368,
0.0237103812,
-0.0328207463,
0.0058381436,
0.0075933058,
0.0249367077,
0.0408811979,
-0.0188925881,
-0.0124178473,
-0.0195120163,
0.0204666834,
0.0141547695,
-0.0136075793,
-0.0895216912,
0.0314158387,
0.0319049396,
-0.0010597794,
0.0213444531,
-0.0026570328,
0.0665486455,
-0.00316036,
-0.0104749566,
-0.0008292643,
0.009938811,
0.0122200418,
0.0660119355,
0.0092852665,
0.0102582332,
-0.0004574994,
0.0032860874,
-0.0011792773,
-0.0456701666,
0.0145649891,
0.0465633422,
0.0394564904,
-0.0030247825,
0.0274927635,
-0.0607032441,
-0.0635149181,
-0.0515534692,
0.011737763,
0.0064385813,
0.0020621729,
0.0622960664,
-0.0191889983,
0.0061403783,
-0.0008945157,
0.0288958065,
0.0082345419,
-0.0019292014,
0.0056455638,
0.00579315,
-0.00545786,
-0.0028814394,
0.1062482595,
-0.0097300839,
0.0630242676,
-0.057078056,
-0.0095515661,
-0.0367632173,
-0.0600588098,
0.0619684309,
0.0140777659,
0.0200366247,
0.0146890171,
-0.0373897254,
-0.0853901058,
-0.0542511418,
-0.0107518043,
-0.0250658076,
-0.0163314342,
0.0433618426,
0.0496314578,
-0.026159646,
-0.0241052695,
-0.0071920562,
-0.0329471007,
-0.0106618898,
-0.0243753772,
0.0240896717,
-6.678128874e-33,
-0.0251647159,
0.0541773662,
-0.0058545293,
0.0002335837,
-0.0376885124,
0.0162240826,
-0.0185866021,
-0.0367641784,
-0.0345095731,
0.043661464,
-0.0255189762,
0.044353541,
0.0126471668,
0.0434759036,
-0.0078644464,
0.0192830861,
0.084857069,
0.0081465105,
-0.0119228652,
0.0661405474,
0.0201759543,
0.0335154608,
0.0599340163,
-0.0340511501,
0.0095696198,
-0.0008923005,
0.0025827228,
0.0191466063,
0.0042266487,
0.0328675881,
-0.0250372086,
0.0199688189,
-0.0097025139,
-0.0565970205,
-0.0489204712,
0.0042521209,
-0.0959137902,
-0.0613392144,
0.0215688497,
-0.0276282113,
-0.0507366285,
-0.0282947496,
0.057435248,
0.0078293672,
0.0502107143,
-0.030176701,
0.0150461169,
0.001115278,
-0.0021900053,
-0.0590455346,
-0.0470761172,
0.0050767777,
-0.046248246,
-0.0543970093,
0.0634387285,
-0.003896402,
-0.0199392214,
-0.0210914761,
-0.0385451131,
0.0053253002,
0.0449833646,
0.0588458404,
0.081220232,
0.0144307725,
0.0031086456,
0.048070915,
-0.0262264609,
-0.001297991,
-0.0282592047,
-0.0199413002,
0.0697103664,
0.0946656987,
0.0264582019,
0.0252267458,
0.0418311171,
-0.0237231422,
-0.041717492,
0.0068093375,
0.0215706285,
0.030017918,
-0.0174744353,
0.0122470632,
-0.0007668221,
-0.0461198613,
-0.0623147488,
-0.0467175543,
-0.0004364672,
-0.0333189704,
0.0217565335,
-0.0001647311,
-0.0644363165,
-0.0127839744,
0.0274556186,
-0.0777379423,
0.0024280366,
0.0457215719,
-0.0143671008,
0.0067299237,
0.0123810731,
0.0379189514,
-0.0668454766,
-0.0081739537,
0.0264984202,
0.0027772805,
0.0207962096,
0.026893001,
0.0655088276,
0.0452256203,
-0.0268326327,
-0.0087798163,
-0.036706686,
-0.01866748,
0.0093777934,
0.0054867216,
0.0340310559,
0.0259716548,
-0.0112990225,
-0.0176261105,
0.0486591943,
0.01765671,
-0.0199593753,
0.0247011725,
0.0266039874,
0.0204323214,
-0.0199642349,
-0.0401447266,
-0.041894421,
-0.0360540785,
0.035595201,
-0.0443773679,
-0.009229213,
0.0115696592,
2.8e-7,
0.0465526469,
0.0211985633,
0.0001917168,
-0.0421468206,
0.0016614367,
0.022693174,
0.0026247459,
0.0064832116,
0.0143570742,
-0.0213776659,
0.0336908698,
0.048219569,
0.0348170437,
0.0304821078,
-0.0741151646,
0.0030191848,
-0.0414702706,
-0.0412409827,
-0.014286112,
-0.039236486,
0.0246979408,
0.0755063817,
0.0543743074,
-0.024398597,
-0.0070465235,
-0.008188935,
0.0155538293,
0.0009922418,
0.0545574576,
0.0564960204,
0.0544173755,
-0.0293854252,
-0.0096712066,
0.0238359477,
-0.020557452,
0.0273266099,
-0.0199225601,
0.0798299462,
-0.0246772841,
-0.0149063719,
-0.0332844965,
-0.0262854416,
-0.0044969958,
-0.0869501904,
0.0618253648,
-0.0403569154,
0.0220750254,
0.0101592029,
-0.0194046088,
-0.0391171314,
-0.0025772073,
0.0045042192,
0.0320567451,
0.037670061,
0.0058555328,
-0.0200322233,
-0.0114957467,
-0.1103212759,
-0.0387669466,
-0.0236821193,
-0.0280109569,
-0.0304142311,
-0.0120555097,
-0.0443322957,
0.0154545587,
-0.0710819587,
0.0332348645,
2.474692033e-34,
0.0295451004,
0.0133006666,
0.0254368111,
0.0192814674,
0.012468745,
-0.0248035323,
-0.056626644,
0.0120431585,
0.0120256394,
-0.0691339448,
-0.0329794586
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10006v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10006v2 | EfficientSCI: Densely Connected Network with Space-time Factorization for Large-scale Video Snapshot Compressive Imaging | 2023-05-17T07:28:46 | 2023-05-18T05:13:09 | Lishun Wang, Miao Cao, Xin Yuan | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, eess.IV | Video snapshot compressive imaging (SCI) uses a two-dimensional detector to
capture consecutive video frames during a single exposure time. Following this,
an efficient reconstruction algorithm needs to be designed to reconstruct the
desired video frames. Although recent deep learning-based state-of-the-art
(SOTA) reconstruction algorithms have achieved good results in most tasks, they
still face the following challenges due to excessive model complexity and GPU
memory limitations: 1) these models need high computational cost, and 2) they
are usually unable to reconstruct large-scale video frames at high compression
ratios. To address these issues, we develop an efficient network for video SCI
by using dense connections and space-time factorization mechanism within a
single residual block, dubbed EfficientSCI. The EfficientSCI network can well
establish spatial-temporal correlation by using convolution in the spatial
domain and Transformer in the temporal domain, respectively. We are the first
time to show that an UHD color video with high compression ratio can be
reconstructed from a snapshot 2D measurement using a single end-to-end deep
learning model with PSNR above 32 dB. Extensive results on both simulation and
real data show that our method significantly outperforms all previous SOTA
algorithms with better real-time performance. The code is at
https://github.com/ucaswangls/EfficientSCI.git. | [
-0.0742816702,
0.1240584999,
0.0091799134,
0.0192207173,
-0.011926149,
-0.014803051,
0.0301015135,
0.0322901942,
-0.0274226107,
0.0057189399,
0.0431873351,
-0.0317031555,
0.0139464634,
0.0472459048,
-0.0145534007,
-0.0172487944,
0.0035371238,
0.0906553641,
0.0055676899,
-0.0025827354,
0.0158327147,
-0.0246366169,
-0.0106651625,
-0.000571932,
-0.0930167735,
-0.0119838053,
-0.0262870826,
-0.0047869487,
0.0317778848,
-0.027976431,
0.0184770972,
0.0404328518,
0.0595683903,
0.0182609782,
0.0000025075,
0.0056569958,
-0.0470836684,
-0.0327300392,
-0.0372905843,
0.0655275509,
-0.0223692842,
0.0016121535,
-0.050532192,
-0.0024872003,
-0.0496146195,
-0.0133014712,
0.0339435078,
0.0040791598,
0.0103718173,
-0.0232661813,
-0.008233346,
-0.0155300573,
0.0213985872,
-0.0279499386,
-0.0245479792,
-0.0017042086,
-0.0146656027,
-0.0525409691,
-0.0163021442,
0.0004848649,
-0.0124265058,
0.0206556749,
0.0638305992,
0.0008000481,
-0.0070586661,
-0.0265212189,
-0.0177571829,
-0.0013717752,
-0.0203912631,
-0.0025082952,
0.0088153118,
-0.018470265,
-0.0210602731,
0.0326621532,
-0.0048290743,
-0.0748834461,
-0.0480307266,
0.0164188296,
0.0483086705,
0.0309586972,
-0.0940193385,
0.0385464504,
0.0388568975,
0.0355256014,
-0.000296342,
-0.036032103,
0.0226630289,
0.0788369328,
-0.0563292652,
0.0245220009,
0.0114086093,
0.0046875221,
0.0030623344,
0.0068350383,
-0.0422389247,
-0.0326689817,
-0.0422589034,
-0.0473451503,
-0.0003010448,
0.0659270659,
-0.0082876235,
-0.0216470324,
0.0074619357,
0.0360647812,
-0.0273322463,
0.0009001103,
-0.0428088158,
0.0438940413,
0.0057027959,
-0.0034760048,
-0.0253588557,
-0.038910903,
0.030922994,
0.0540931821,
0.0161408987,
0.009791512,
-0.0449642539,
-0.0171639621,
-0.0410754867,
-0.0145642795,
-0.0541918688,
0.0708628669,
-0.0288710408,
-0.036124289,
0.0225027148,
0.0269795265,
0.039033927,
0.0357608013,
0.0334826671,
-0.0260127913,
-0.0422593355,
0.0056347898,
0.0309701134,
0.0246651433,
0.0339381024,
-0.040526595,
-0.0411270075,
-0.0368640684,
-0.0508239418,
0.0349195227,
0.007262134,
0.0115389759,
0.0129102329,
-0.0827526823,
0.0337286554,
-0.0045420844,
0.0393006839,
-0.0563627258,
0.0247670691,
-0.0128479153,
-0.0174308456,
0.040402066,
-0.0517877713,
-0.0548667833,
0.0450099371,
0.0174473859,
0.046263501,
0.0009372371,
0.0184688773,
0.0202090871,
-0.0185911097,
0.0322278701,
0.0198362656,
0.0179533102,
0.0376202613,
0.0421509333,
-0.0770960078,
-0.0624221414,
-0.0415039584,
0.0146451825,
0.0491274856,
0.0424757972,
-0.0063923369,
-0.0380918644,
-0.0040827203,
0.01176327,
0.0242926292,
0.0369930789,
0.0102388849,
0.0354201421,
-0.0066910759,
-0.0312944762,
0.025321776,
0.1111382023,
0.0156424809,
-0.0139429327,
0.0156398825,
0.0256469101,
-0.0591515787,
-0.0467681177,
0.0219383482,
0.0041289493,
-0.0125708207,
0.0170714539,
0.0762632489,
0.0097677894,
-0.0236080848,
0.0357625782,
0.0424271375,
0.0126827676,
0.0234975703,
-0.0089348564,
-0.022982046,
0.0053349556,
0.0339926332,
-0.0520666689,
0.0088516576,
-0.0102745155,
-0.0033017914,
0.001397177,
0.0018721942,
0.0022386787,
0.0604903884,
0.0030496439,
-0.0492361076,
-0.0098120617,
0.0149859414,
0.0249390062,
0.0126392646,
-0.0104214409,
-0.0218345169,
0.0021797463,
0.0114671597,
0.0010187323,
-0.011174378,
0.0239267796,
0.052770596,
0.0097989226,
-0.0020674439,
0.0105457893,
-0.0360792764,
-0.0281719062,
0.0414519683,
-0.0367092341,
0.0081528146,
-0.0198189821,
-0.0669761598,
-0.0221190378,
0.0008144237,
-0.0404012986,
0.0142176915,
0.1383806169,
-0.0381084196,
-0.0551846623,
0.0436712429,
-0.0035039699,
-0.0198835135,
-0.0711350739,
-0.013810317,
0.0222743563,
0.0179543253,
0.0076918332,
-0.0162324067,
-0.0271136761,
-0.0505463779,
0.0607126169,
-0.0005414492,
0.0270043015,
-0.0145729426,
-0.0109730065,
-0.0821839049,
-0.0532925352,
-0.0252755079,
0.062610127,
-0.0016574442,
-0.0068558394,
0.071874924,
0.0195355229,
-0.004587607,
-0.0316532329,
-0.0478063934,
0.0060764304,
0.0224315524,
0.051313445,
-0.00664812,
0.01845707,
0.0484026484,
0.0141980574,
0.0097260373,
0.0113863312,
0.0327219255,
0.0079918774,
-0.0401437879,
-0.0334826633,
0.0365952216,
0.0005732527,
-0.0523779429,
-0.0498452634,
0.0103631867,
0.0504737422,
0.0668184459,
0.0205472261,
-0.0286622643,
-0.055112619,
-0.0311182197,
-0.0503893532,
-0.0151382741,
0.0513878018,
0.0039298078,
-0.0123323957,
-0.016372025,
0.0142466407,
0.0271638501,
-0.0148853362,
-0.0159430653,
-0.0228390321,
0.0205146093,
-0.01066087,
-0.010409371,
0.0124592325,
-0.0095636845,
0.0173336826,
-0.0257760789,
-0.0376714244,
0.0235921238,
-0.0298557039,
-0.0488942452,
0.0323598869,
-0.0035826799,
-0.0183652733,
0.0026986429,
-0.0173801985,
-0.0184044484,
-0.0111618284,
0.0143242637,
0.0357944742,
-0.0235831086,
0.0083103497,
0.0382958204,
0.0473284572,
0.0202985201,
-0.0612632222,
-0.0074827839,
-0.0473153181,
0.0202586763,
-0.0063403524,
-0.0105134128,
-0.039451208,
-0.0413727798,
-0.0137451496,
-0.0283616632,
-0.0450621583,
-0.0410695337,
-0.0049084621,
0.004146182,
0.019007111,
-0.0013760893,
-0.0007559036,
-0.0396872014,
-0.0617486089,
-0.0196897332,
0.0395424441,
0.0441992804,
-0.0113392668,
-0.0042890455,
0.0656222031,
0.0469827987,
0.0200299956,
0.0619389154,
0.0154827712,
0.0764695853,
0.086716719,
0.0264840815,
0.0566344783,
-0.1016209424,
0.0484656058,
-0.0045117605,
0.0362438411,
-0.0091311652,
0.0426536128,
0.0039601661,
-0.031735193,
-0.0235798657,
-0.0136692943,
-0.0060069058,
-0.0941214189,
0.0160840936,
0.0510979146,
0.0242698956,
-0.0067141582,
-0.0441146865,
-0.0465018451,
-0.0350506864,
0.0037019779,
-0.0655125156,
0.0134788314,
0.0204305593,
0.0093328543,
0.0034050669,
0.020905111,
0.0176232066,
0.0334658511,
-0.0143465074,
-0.0265773777,
0.0006541521,
-0.0116074234,
0.0275823437,
-0.0352397114,
0.0379282348,
0.000603385,
-0.0221217424,
0.0318344422,
0.0014933601,
0.016385315,
0.0137733584,
0.0118148699,
-0.0144031178,
-0.0094131604,
-0.0184386373,
-0.0008901528,
-0.0218177978,
0.0027646273,
-0.0049252114,
0.0250945427,
0.0518686473,
0.0119022625,
-0.0131360637,
-0.0064297062,
0.0693114102,
-0.0686693341,
-0.0079894336,
-0.0130047472,
0.0299611874,
0.0160128083,
0.0624174997,
-0.0286861174,
-0.0350403674,
-0.007987895,
-0.0108365808,
-0.0197147913,
0.0125596374,
-0.0190087929,
0.0156746823,
0.0413842238,
-0.050983835,
-0.0302075297,
0.0150216753,
0.0497700758,
0.0125667425,
0.0197134949,
0.0101927798,
0.0286411904,
-0.0078401249,
-0.038600944,
-0.0554055795,
-0.0240556989,
0.0340060256,
-0.1063784733,
0.0107806586,
-0.0370934643,
0.0338655673,
-0.0494889989,
0.044781819,
0.0185069088,
0.0100115836,
0.023208404,
0.056634441,
-0.1082215309,
0.0149129089,
-0.0185308959,
0.0279007442,
-0.0015529055,
0.0656053796,
0.0392273441,
0.0704679415,
0.0006644488,
0.0266973861,
-0.0479339845,
0.0159125831,
0.0350450389,
-0.0536201596,
-0.0242880918,
0.0554434396,
-0.0194519926,
0.0283795893,
0.0042311023,
0.0222867783,
-0.0142869521,
0.0217328947,
0.0236419812,
-0.059557993,
0.0766501948,
0.0176892802,
0.0246071648,
0.0304367747,
0.0203565769,
0.0203966126,
0.0293936413,
-0.0204700604,
0.0057874462,
-0.0039510764,
-0.0125815403,
-0.0205935668,
0.0132437823,
0.0897127539,
-0.0103095025,
-0.01191625,
-0.0455792472,
-0.0447641723,
-0.0584820397,
-0.052981697,
0.005851822,
0.0396792702,
0.003774452,
0.0346583985,
0.0106431916,
-0.0075055421,
-0.0036862905,
-0.0013602482,
0.0230823103,
-0.0150292683,
0.0263166372,
0.0325055644,
-0.0219604466,
-0.0392086431,
0.01377586,
0.0677724704,
-0.0406011119,
0.0480619408,
0.0086085238,
0.0023973903,
-0.0693461299,
0.0273667611,
-0.0019188653,
-0.0157446414,
0.0097570233,
-0.0248956308,
0.0554988831,
0.0405497849,
0.0800734386,
-0.0081811976,
-0.0047068647,
-0.0167051461,
0.0588665009,
-0.0137366792,
-0.0175623875,
-0.0021955771,
0.0058078505,
0.0036011939,
-0.0194165986,
0.0282723252,
-0.0141548431,
-0.0067501506,
-0.0227450859,
0.0050370255,
-0.0407974124,
0.0113794692,
-0.0259443447,
-0.0042616953,
-0.0088571878,
0.0414017178,
0.0101447972,
0.0334206857,
-0.0575978942,
-0.0060132826,
-6.277881864e-33,
0.0347066708,
-0.015396948,
0.0276026912,
-0.0497324616,
0.0525743924,
0.0468071662,
-0.0229283795,
0.0110668056,
-0.0249494985,
0.0241185315,
-0.0436226837,
0.0569070578,
-0.0054126401,
0.0799043104,
0.0098968875,
-0.009871115,
0.0260585975,
-0.0347847044,
0.0151624596,
0.0225248802,
0.0082951607,
0.0044757696,
0.026937874,
0.0083120326,
-0.1635621488,
0.0123058874,
0.0035494154,
-0.0398308635,
0.0471189246,
-0.0146660469,
-0.0179715864,
-0.0388722457,
0.0042684758,
-0.0855392367,
-0.0000715116,
-0.0194022506,
-0.0624137186,
-0.036709778,
-0.0588281378,
-0.0263863467,
-0.0835739896,
-0.0145063959,
-0.0341804251,
0.0126775587,
0.0001221528,
-0.0347644649,
-0.0037926454,
-0.008786873,
0.0178362597,
-0.0585954599,
0.0319406055,
0.0116166212,
-0.0652722046,
-0.0274069104,
0.0149347223,
-0.0061922176,
-0.0718907565,
0.0118976282,
-0.0704994649,
0.0021635846,
-0.0365890823,
0.0377750248,
0.0247648936,
-0.0253441446,
0.0150965611,
0.0592245348,
-0.0651032627,
-0.0316715389,
-0.020324789,
0.0332781747,
0.0372109413,
0.0042595882,
0.0315431319,
0.0588688552,
0.0649231747,
-0.0152915884,
-0.0458377413,
0.0476758927,
0.007909257,
0.0315193236,
0.0051002274,
0.0217516739,
0.0587216727,
-0.0582249537,
-0.0107996566,
0.0254049674,
-0.0001908071,
0.0058010444,
-0.0113896588,
0.0543371402,
0.0059917783,
-0.0599356778,
0.0351095758,
-0.0218349248,
0.0496232882,
0.0434388071,
-0.0073942626,
0.0326684341,
0.0339421108,
-0.0202291179,
-0.0356145613,
0.0482336059,
0.0317797586,
0.0253915507,
-0.012347484,
-0.0031741152,
0.006765035,
0.0641870871,
0.035637375,
-0.0158035923,
-0.0313942395,
0.0054684775,
0.0311317183,
-0.0656614453,
0.0510747619,
-0.0237183217,
0.034725491,
0.0278878976,
-0.0391440578,
0.065479517,
-0.0274151433,
0.0181111563,
-0.0043096142,
0.0388314351,
-0.0187850446,
-0.0075288224,
-0.1045163646,
-0.0729050785,
0.0496658459,
-0.0914525017,
-0.0065101646,
-0.0538679361,
3.077e-7,
-0.0489306748,
-0.0301045943,
0.001050435,
-0.0604264885,
0.004336867,
0.0135744605,
0.0511533245,
0.0080873789,
-0.016194202,
-0.0719064921,
0.0446524881,
0.0356619284,
-0.0108830398,
-0.0046240999,
-0.0237411167,
0.032752756,
-0.0251567196,
0.0131336385,
0.02934983,
-0.0440814868,
-0.0045471936,
0.0675280616,
0.0060768872,
-0.0308247544,
0.0384011976,
0.0348873362,
0.0208942052,
0.022983646,
0.0419127643,
0.0079757916,
0.0034322906,
0.0113061452,
0.0083770137,
-0.0220737886,
0.0078368941,
-0.0245919973,
-0.008197003,
-0.0112769986,
-0.0411133096,
-0.0803075656,
-0.0235654432,
0.028052019,
-0.0140647339,
0.005783468,
0.0079609165,
-0.000053378,
-0.0166731346,
-0.0449716151,
-0.0504827015,
0.0539965443,
-0.0142470719,
0.0078088734,
0.0294068623,
-0.0120399306,
-0.0215095542,
0.0055765007,
-0.0033556235,
-0.0449401774,
0.0542461798,
0.0286763199,
-0.0297415163,
0.0464448445,
-0.0467869118,
-0.0220255256,
0.0624995418,
0.0168130007,
-0.0616148487,
2.124929659e-34,
-0.0408265814,
0.0258318726,
0.0042623114,
-0.0293282475,
-0.033985395,
-0.0252295695,
-0.037088871,
0.0420752689,
-0.0235681739,
-0.0230641384,
-0.0117751267
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10005v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10005v2 | DinoSR: Self-Distillation and Online Clustering for Self-supervised Speech Representation Learning | 2023-05-17T07:23:46 | 2024-01-16T05:43:20 | Alexander H. Liu, Heng-Jui Chang, Michael Auli, Wei-Ning Hsu, James R. Glass | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we introduce self-distillation and online clustering for
self-supervised speech representation learning (DinoSR) which combines masked
language modeling, self-distillation, and online clustering. We show that these
concepts complement each other and result in a strong representation learning
model for speech. DinoSR first extracts contextualized embeddings from the
input audio with a teacher network, then runs an online clustering system on
the embeddings to yield a machine-discovered phone inventory, and finally uses
the discretized tokens to guide a student network. We show that DinoSR
surpasses previous state-of-the-art performance in several downstream tasks,
and provide a detailed analysis of the model and the learned discrete units. | [
-0.0515151918,
0.0315136723,
-0.0124226008,
0.0293051191,
0.0116696209,
-0.0169277359,
0.0845232531,
-0.0496890061,
0.0273859072,
-0.003913729,
-0.0441384092,
0.0148715442,
-0.018882595,
0.0316848159,
0.0437381789,
-0.0336762592,
0.0295271743,
-0.0481060706,
-0.0122908726,
0.0009638727,
0.0104802363,
0.0248528104,
-0.063701503,
0.034118969,
-0.0365355574,
-0.0524745621,
-0.0102705713,
-0.0203050952,
-0.0258241408,
-0.0219351798,
-0.01631427,
0.0259138551,
0.0844341069,
0.0469413064,
0.000001871,
-0.0198124498,
-0.0554485023,
-0.0071559963,
-0.069220677,
0.023460323,
0.0524593666,
0.0001084568,
-0.0168395303,
0.0048520993,
-0.0308054052,
-0.0077781035,
0.0127043435,
0.0064414134,
0.0541120432,
0.0331881978,
-0.0170371365,
-0.0413989462,
0.0156735815,
-0.0307655428,
-0.052506052,
0.0223003011,
-0.0286242049,
0.0262643266,
-0.0171898324,
-0.0164559837,
-0.0218101535,
0.0649017543,
0.0034075251,
-0.0171034429,
0.0358461775,
0.0336052552,
-0.0592082515,
-0.0267586038,
0.0115670934,
0.078003712,
-0.0058151009,
-0.0013819728,
0.0305651743,
0.016286185,
-0.0117208222,
-0.0334098451,
-0.0338514112,
-0.0091214897,
0.0514905378,
0.0343516991,
-0.0362954959,
0.0570653751,
0.0426985547,
-0.0162405502,
-0.0385786891,
0.0295985341,
-0.0283091348,
-0.0145653086,
-0.0540561862,
-0.0305480473,
-0.0361551493,
0.0306970999,
0.0484035574,
0.00891707,
0.0424188636,
-0.0158641394,
-0.0041265944,
-0.0254567992,
-0.0141815832,
0.0180077236,
-0.0325663052,
0.0122949705,
-0.0407155454,
0.0217474326,
-0.03635142,
0.0516290106,
0.0141016878,
0.0008406874,
-0.0281568486,
0.0017002561,
-0.0463408008,
-0.0119001102,
-0.0824963972,
0.0663387328,
-0.0079960991,
-0.0330142044,
-0.0447024964,
0.0139678875,
-0.0610371865,
0.0110414866,
0.0122710038,
0.0125911878,
-0.0187240951,
0.0139313666,
0.03942414,
0.0321505964,
-0.0238789953,
0.0190776177,
0.015044908,
-0.0352264605,
-0.0193693917,
-0.014932435,
0.0417746492,
0.0089559043,
-0.0310470406,
0.0734389797,
0.0013641893,
-0.0070723975,
-0.00329566,
-0.0386240818,
-0.0523220375,
-0.0170174055,
-0.0486880727,
-0.0712674335,
0.0414603017,
-0.0268060751,
0.0178636946,
-0.0272720903,
-0.0137020955,
-0.040788047,
0.0547630265,
0.0602477379,
0.0120041827,
0.011804672,
0.0699505582,
0.0192829408,
-0.0116543733,
0.0397002771,
0.0569827259,
-0.0164845884,
0.0277503692,
-0.0494131409,
-0.0210937336,
0.0135166636,
0.0344250612,
-0.0136243412,
-0.0374650471,
-0.0391319357,
0.0102863768,
0.0568192787,
0.050194405,
0.0286695287,
-0.0724048316,
-0.0340335928,
0.0287899282,
0.0795239285,
0.0342165269,
0.0439990275,
-0.0060749454,
0.0348234996,
-0.0275982805,
0.0103487857,
-0.0062220851,
-0.0080697788,
0.0308320709,
-0.006742876,
0.0575727746,
0.0119428141,
-0.0398718268,
-0.046817679,
0.0486459471,
-0.0188252088,
0.0140763409,
-0.0102158673,
0.0448793806,
0.034531422,
0.0170810558,
0.0473806709,
0.0115644978,
-0.0473921522,
0.0554506406,
-0.0442357063,
0.0424266905,
0.030721534,
0.0265427697,
-0.0508946031,
0.0012240704,
-0.0319218114,
-0.0034891947,
0.0028706132,
-0.0341645367,
-0.0234662481,
0.0497930758,
-0.0599902831,
0.000043042,
-0.0382522121,
0.0102773039,
0.0070634447,
-0.0456184968,
0.0149091771,
0.036471162,
-0.066807352,
0.0523706786,
0.0046967939,
0.0103560975,
-0.0605123229,
0.0427604094,
0.0450889245,
0.0195934717,
0.0272621997,
-0.0123882014,
0.0154356649,
0.0384261757,
-0.0361981317,
0.0123919509,
-0.0528074056,
-0.1057589948,
-0.0623267815,
0.0279030949,
-0.0266699456,
0.0158034936,
0.0115659581,
-0.0255657639,
-0.0633628964,
0.0829622,
0.0089934031,
0.0563518144,
-0.046845451,
0.004433685,
0.0347825103,
0.0583666265,
0.0255245622,
0.0036503049,
0.020035971,
-0.0052766856,
-0.0146591552,
0.0384169184,
-0.0049964902,
-0.0360462777,
-0.0209443606,
-0.0547901429,
-0.021734735,
0.0290388819,
-0.0286703557,
-0.0900596976,
-0.0122791668,
-0.0104840538,
-0.0667428821,
-0.0349724442,
-0.0157208461,
-0.0372878574,
0.0200859848,
0.020214472,
0.0254216641,
-0.065215379,
-0.0276061837,
-0.0704795271,
-0.0029802038,
0.0149819627,
-0.0183281545,
-0.0055531049,
-0.0162060428,
-0.0453879721,
-0.0207618102,
0.001121303,
0.0010317197,
-0.0539160557,
-0.0232456475,
-0.0028856962,
-0.0386374742,
-0.0094586127,
0.0322551578,
0.0054699117,
-0.0111791315,
0.0104101365,
-0.0300940778,
0.0375265405,
0.0511572286,
0.0049410448,
-0.0012626895,
0.0386240371,
-0.0229089465,
-0.0579851717,
-0.0010687602,
-0.0255369414,
0.0415804945,
0.0012834297,
0.0368329808,
-0.0162243396,
0.0557659343,
0.032975778,
0.0024874215,
-0.0307711624,
-0.0693085864,
-0.0286486857,
-0.0188446548,
-0.0736654699,
-0.01816261,
-0.0091547547,
-0.0206545629,
-0.0088627543,
-0.0477929153,
0.0414902419,
-0.0322492793,
-0.0363303237,
-0.0230762232,
-0.0935179368,
0.0075465566,
0.0260947403,
0.0126117077,
0.0195402522,
0.0081747137,
-0.0383732431,
-0.0284940451,
0.0093378033,
0.0334994495,
-0.0440571755,
0.0177769363,
-0.0177659784,
-0.0073808562,
0.0104804076,
-0.0329074301,
-0.0346519426,
-0.0597176813,
0.0085715959,
0.026281951,
0.0001601764,
0.0064360052,
-0.0104833385,
0.0541669466,
0.0069702384,
0.0510905124,
0.0084645264,
0.0104038287,
-0.0068684155,
0.0747432411,
0.0243770573,
0.0332131684,
0.0018440665,
0.0315451138,
0.0762418807,
0.0261517502,
0.1046738252,
-0.013853224,
-0.0425567292,
0.0310711078,
-0.0134792877,
0.015873272,
-0.021697171,
0.0138336206,
0.0326250084,
-0.0229465645,
-0.017043069,
0.1197884306,
0.0075397026,
-0.0216151141,
0.000440504,
0.0034279262,
0.0214604475,
0.0114819948,
-0.002865704,
-0.0144539876,
0.003181037,
-0.0059984047,
0.0391273499,
0.0335449949,
-0.0069572022,
-0.0078673707,
-0.0739949271,
0.0302860569,
0.0594994314,
-0.0200373568,
0.0017174028,
-0.0661687329,
-0.026489567,
-0.0538659431,
0.0559014156,
-0.0318573341,
-0.0058314255,
-0.0287321061,
0.0532418452,
-0.1087748632,
0.0058045192,
0.0093273586,
-0.0255139694,
0.043538373,
0.0386137068,
0.0190660637,
0.0090670884,
-0.0396398716,
0.0101949777,
-0.0159388147,
-0.0203818083,
0.0173574407,
0.0443913974,
-0.0058472636,
-0.0050723967,
0.0236687772,
0.0429655984,
-0.0323055349,
-0.0218627043,
0.0071854275,
0.0896870717,
0.003333041,
0.0350633599,
-0.0075356397,
0.0136079341,
0.0232001264,
0.0418976024,
0.0096047828,
-0.0058300109,
0.0079282001,
0.0075672008,
0.0749783218,
0.0453480557,
0.0042626099,
0.0020124048,
-0.0049812142,
0.0216459837,
-0.0544854663,
0.0080862995,
0.0215122867,
0.050582312,
-0.0081200572,
0.015696777,
0.0190985035,
-0.0046523283,
-0.033198908,
0.0107581681,
-0.0207647812,
0.0133418851,
-0.0384148769,
-0.0143789928,
0.0589285679,
-0.0060477997,
-0.0220572483,
0.0119172055,
-0.0475627854,
-0.057148274,
0.0409992598,
-0.0016050562,
0.0102560194,
0.0677683428,
-0.0510422923,
-0.0118393488,
0.1218995675,
0.0301988013,
-0.0921081081,
-0.0134560512,
0.0211658478,
-0.0059863674,
-0.0163938571,
0.0368313678,
-0.0397344343,
0.0745327696,
-0.0417051129,
0.0089962874,
-0.0837419555,
0.0068127248,
-0.0085947094,
-0.0372468419,
0.1065518111,
0.0322350115,
0.0610041209,
-0.0502821989,
0.0021307834,
0.0021674845,
0.0150240669,
-0.0164157692,
0.0013132294,
0.032176856,
-0.0047207791,
-0.0089133447,
0.035877239,
0.0094659869,
-0.0097662676,
-0.0009609954,
0.0173523389,
0.0230232812,
-0.0078521417,
-0.0273865964,
0.0403837562,
0.0004566481,
0.0387246981,
0.0197539292,
0.009365567,
-0.012243038,
0.0012596558,
-0.0133406585,
0.0528857596,
-0.037519563,
0.027004173,
-0.0413081199,
-0.0295600146,
-0.0484329909,
-0.0344782323,
-0.0134582389,
-0.0358936042,
0.000686814,
0.0147144869,
-0.001151144,
-0.0225329809,
0.0152288238,
-0.0484990999,
0.0198339894,
0.0079732146,
0.0207510013,
-0.0270724334,
0.0262270384,
0.0370952785,
-0.0183758065,
0.0096631087,
0.0010851371,
0.0427949652,
-0.0507030487,
-0.0169985499,
-0.0196446702,
0.0590544529,
0.0082405843,
-0.0126807261,
0.023549946,
-0.0955639556,
0.0042444388,
-0.0186168645,
-0.02376239,
-0.0197552107,
0.0357625224,
-0.0133934729,
-0.0127531737,
0.0590060316,
0.0015779454,
-0.0100062573,
0.0333401896,
-0.0220420286,
0.0286790393,
-5.994428667e-33,
-0.0312214866,
-0.0061300988,
-0.0196929853,
-0.0412955843,
-0.0221286993,
0.0193491261,
-0.0058388514,
0.0291376803,
0.0327054448,
-0.0060262815,
-0.0007897838,
0.0294634867,
0.0219356082,
0.0308769438,
-0.0167389661,
0.0149713568,
0.0891374424,
-0.0225437861,
0.0068190708,
0.0405547209,
0.0468114093,
0.0476233512,
0.0118227033,
-0.0602783598,
-0.0596344769,
-0.0085368818,
-0.0068533425,
-0.003749623,
0.0377091095,
0.0698892102,
-0.0334694274,
0.039755296,
-0.0166133922,
-0.0150299566,
-0.0416163653,
0.0434159301,
-0.1329014599,
-0.0404017046,
-0.0606307983,
-0.0081077321,
-0.0210583769,
0.0116232671,
0.0600945204,
-0.0026884482,
0.0015798085,
-0.0054553403,
0.0372183397,
-0.0084567312,
-0.0441424362,
0.0212073941,
0.0048217825,
0.02087708,
-0.0417890064,
-0.0263072923,
0.0997931883,
0.0051000272,
0.0072232508,
-0.0191902742,
-0.1083982363,
0.0329143256,
-0.0395623259,
0.0307252966,
0.0541395247,
0.038972646,
0.0338171124,
0.0615691356,
0.0693287104,
-0.0477486886,
-0.0136074079,
-0.0267210603,
0.0506638959,
0.058766149,
0.0139836343,
-0.0128405616,
0.0265953094,
-0.0294142645,
-0.0232457593,
-0.0189168639,
-0.0151291043,
-0.0244443621,
0.0165689699,
0.0468062386,
-0.0378335118,
-0.0113831768,
-0.0326030403,
-0.0653802752,
-0.0263933428,
-0.0231131539,
0.0263069123,
0.0152924312,
-0.0434869044,
-0.0008648871,
0.0277908165,
-0.0334799513,
-0.0161961503,
-0.0285278261,
0.0083073182,
-0.0364886969,
0.0389347374,
0.0203301627,
-0.0397004746,
-0.0254233647,
0.0426527075,
0.0083896117,
0.003988211,
-0.006292663,
0.0109169483,
0.0306395032,
-0.0346169621,
-0.022945879,
0.0119891288,
-0.003586666,
-0.0215881765,
0.0135905519,
0.0417249352,
-0.0111803738,
-0.0133456644,
0.0246018842,
-0.0024428987,
-0.0070811762,
0.0162394792,
0.0479221195,
-0.006476678,
0.0222852845,
-0.0245864857,
-0.0410592221,
-0.0146660563,
0.0245144684,
0.095848605,
-0.0396231264,
-0.0038776465,
-0.0012229875,
2.568e-7,
-0.018540429,
0.0015178462,
0.0274743829,
-0.0647721365,
0.0475520864,
0.0227915589,
-0.0301773883,
0.0006843171,
0.0030007011,
-0.0472559929,
0.0321458764,
0.0388375372,
0.0515124761,
0.0599746704,
-0.0626548454,
0.0519519225,
-0.0463875532,
0.0419014245,
-0.024917081,
0.0000987268,
-0.022719821,
0.1179603264,
0.0401753895,
-0.0072542313,
0.0045749671,
-0.0184947439,
0.0161240064,
0.0017507698,
0.0332052149,
-0.0256040283,
-0.0379809216,
0.0285862237,
-0.0220894702,
-0.0121815922,
-0.0194414463,
0.0418691561,
0.0419893637,
0.0337599702,
0.0047153113,
-0.0632832348,
-0.0076343752,
0.0322325341,
-0.0035460808,
-0.0100801233,
0.0372948349,
-0.0625279695,
-0.0026724664,
-0.034399271,
-0.029533904,
-0.0017307951,
0.0331851617,
0.0102194166,
-0.0222541578,
0.0257835686,
0.0165047161,
-0.0233116653,
0.0093772057,
-0.0771481842,
0.0211627036,
0.0187760182,
-0.0708267614,
-0.0328596421,
-0.0312311091,
-0.0162970778,
0.0421046279,
0.0295999534,
0.040315304,
1.760881469e-34,
-0.0062978617,
-0.0127556901,
-0.0004482763,
0.0104581034,
-0.0099671911,
-0.0323830545,
-0.0099753449,
-0.002846346,
0.0467968136,
-0.0586492047,
-0.0428516269
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.09993v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.09993v2 | Reprompting: Automated Chain-of-Thought Prompt Inference Through Gibbs Sampling | 2023-05-17T06:35:43 | 2024-05-23T21:23:12 | Weijia Xu, Andrzej Banburski-Fahey, Nebojsa Jojic | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | We introduce Reprompting, an iterative sampling algorithm that automatically
learns the Chain-of-Thought (CoT) recipes for a given task without human
intervention. Through Gibbs sampling, Reprompting infers the CoT recipes that
work consistently well for a set of training samples by iteratively sampling
new recipes using previously sampled recipes as parent prompts to solve other
training problems. We conduct extensive experiments on 20 challenging reasoning
tasks. Results show that Reprompting outperforms human-written CoT prompts
substantially by +9.4 points on average. It also achieves consistently better
performance than the state-of-the-art prompt optimization and decoding
algorithms. | [
0.0017314547,
0.0387525521,
-0.0047271014,
-0.0106186671,
-0.064819321,
0.0224701744,
0.0007677334,
-0.000494201,
0.0385826789,
-0.0243668705,
-0.0043032728,
0.022561308,
-0.006024152,
-0.0075170835,
-0.0046487539,
-0.0672327727,
0.0086373454,
-0.064685449,
-0.0077632726,
-0.0255839527,
-0.0379422307,
0.0221284702,
-0.0649705455,
0.0187582597,
0.0065128352,
-0.0455850177,
-0.0514217354,
-0.0002154478,
0.0338360406,
-0.0408862866,
-0.0364042707,
0.0873085707,
0.0059227608,
0.0276818611,
0.0000021418,
-0.0474010296,
-0.0358834639,
-0.0167909022,
-0.0749269053,
-0.0323326401,
-0.0104346387,
0.0327181555,
0.012552754,
0.0296140611,
-0.0377492756,
0.0247703679,
0.0218774229,
0.045302283,
0.0395962223,
0.0310261399,
0.0170929804,
-0.0022312582,
-0.024953004,
-0.0105075436,
0.0373490416,
-0.045176968,
-0.0024853013,
0.0135354595,
0.0361050963,
0.0053808573,
-0.0021614677,
0.0176986232,
0.0333344676,
0.0192548316,
-0.034872435,
0.0390814506,
0.0429616123,
-0.0040283059,
-0.0390976146,
0.068728447,
0.0250530448,
0.0007010102,
-0.0287792441,
-0.013162314,
0.0317280143,
0.0355728082,
-0.0279466994,
0.026510831,
-0.0567918792,
0.0190799721,
-0.0067282952,
0.0129486136,
-0.0063776174,
-0.0369682536,
-0.007026331,
0.1078367233,
-0.0108224517,
-0.0352771692,
0.061397098,
0.0415787958,
0.0128891999,
-0.06998723,
0.0219537504,
0.0288815554,
-0.0573163368,
-0.004626581,
-0.012345626,
-0.0365266502,
-0.0072503728,
0.056212157,
0.0621014871,
0.0394991413,
-0.0038498358,
0.0259103645,
-0.0202645101,
-0.0041050054,
-0.00940465,
0.0073777162,
-0.0623357259,
0.0327939838,
-0.0752570406,
-0.0063809464,
-0.0629777014,
0.0438996777,
-0.043646235,
-0.0005584407,
-0.0129978014,
0.0185802542,
0.0140151083,
-0.0070834169,
0.0193355493,
0.0301230866,
-0.011355523,
-0.0090146661,
-0.0482748598,
0.0210196823,
-0.0863129422,
0.0177669916,
0.0652025938,
-0.008115096,
-0.0254369788,
-0.035672348,
0.0127454177,
-0.0005976235,
0.0221023951,
0.0727738366,
-0.0512342826,
0.0009362202,
-0.0542513803,
-0.0504613183,
-0.0197669603,
-0.0477834865,
0.0300042108,
-0.0721611306,
0.0363746807,
-0.0069339308,
-0.0129472511,
0.0231231339,
0.0010079289,
0.0538095906,
-0.0134676443,
0.0681622475,
0.0057035638,
-0.0326311924,
0.0233701542,
0.0003071705,
-0.062766932,
0.0733798742,
0.0033526155,
0.0609916076,
0.0040919958,
0.0438477583,
0.0193285532,
0.0221944228,
0.0017257808,
-0.0038838817,
0.0325866565,
-0.0171694513,
0.0262059886,
0.0560052209,
0.0286928564,
0.0042575235,
-0.0372621976,
0.0230733342,
0.0374294072,
0.0493690185,
-0.0453425422,
0.0125258015,
0.068425484,
-0.0016057936,
0.0203894526,
0.0327884145,
-0.066619508,
0.0333386771,
-0.0520955957,
0.0002450569,
-0.0135904904,
0.0127972001,
-0.0198403876,
-0.0308334678,
0.0332708508,
0.0395997167,
0.0028593007,
0.0397457257,
0.0144015783,
0.0319545753,
-0.0374162458,
0.0179880355,
0.0089435689,
-0.0055502928,
-0.0303987581,
-0.0072261053,
0.0517297126,
0.0489085652,
0.0193789825,
-0.0207680371,
-0.0079065496,
-0.0210091565,
0.0251483787,
-0.0151667967,
-0.0038368558,
-0.015252416,
0.008998815,
-0.0295221917,
-0.036357414,
0.0094117355,
0.0212811176,
0.0429368056,
0.0077272695,
-0.0264620837,
-0.0013182657,
-0.0184780266,
0.0476959497,
0.0146530792,
-0.0105191497,
-0.0216618441,
0.0365196727,
0.0171065871,
0.0297299065,
0.0012284665,
0.017504923,
0.0141934808,
-0.0260488261,
-0.0465328209,
-0.0183298141,
-0.0051165274,
-0.045820158,
-0.1010148972,
-0.0033016175,
-0.0601990372,
-0.0558858477,
-0.0105460212,
-0.0561018661,
-0.0287855864,
0.0085888999,
-0.0312534459,
0.003399116,
-0.0188854206,
-0.0111034838,
0.0419445969,
-0.0466955863,
-0.055118259,
0.0985860974,
-0.0014137515,
-0.0171584859,
0.0394314602,
-0.0142591828,
0.018758459,
-0.0473908,
0.0495118909,
-0.0311314836,
-0.0140210344,
-0.0370760486,
-0.0017999241,
0.0419781841,
-0.071317859,
-0.0244748276,
-0.0654021725,
0.0184763391,
-0.0071837329,
0.0301364735,
-0.0011731338,
0.000093422,
-0.0269229785,
-0.0196347311,
-0.05165416,
0.0109107131,
-0.039005883,
0.0100467727,
-0.0002592721,
-0.0109524084,
0.0074516726,
0.0134187285,
-0.0139908204,
-0.0456459038,
0.0365022086,
0.0086693196,
-0.0071314615,
-0.0384123959,
0.0223775636,
-0.0009950858,
0.0029969292,
0.0066120899,
0.0170727633,
0.0414610505,
-0.0302002579,
0.0685319677,
0.0785993859,
-0.0112225087,
-0.0348335803,
0.0381668098,
-0.0223214179,
-0.0426695794,
0.0260823686,
-0.0214791633,
-0.019982066,
0.0248337816,
-0.0432130061,
0.0024274434,
0.0587268248,
0.0353174955,
0.0245318208,
-0.0424224921,
0.0074122087,
0.0150628239,
-0.0325287171,
-0.0668433234,
0.0082505001,
-0.0044621304,
0.0588942058,
-0.0161750708,
-0.0030549346,
0.0985966921,
-0.0257274881,
0.0303260665,
-0.0762998313,
0.0458465554,
0.004975291,
0.051341556,
-0.0074815052,
0.0108404709,
0.0609169304,
-0.0366482288,
-0.0670627952,
0.0296384748,
0.0377413258,
-0.0186266117,
0.0193839055,
-0.0633351505,
-0.0175460633,
0.0129667725,
-0.0597102195,
-0.051791776,
-0.0031563947,
-0.0525571704,
-0.0050470801,
-0.0030018336,
-0.0036953895,
-0.0099874064,
-0.0462726802,
0.030741388,
0.0153661184,
-0.0069180462,
-0.0345307924,
-0.0346833169,
0.0131037487,
0.0416000187,
0.0085028671,
0.0332096964,
-0.0076829493,
0.0087677371,
0.0450093672,
0.0453566834,
0.0341988206,
0.0033042722,
0.0456489176,
-0.0053559956,
-0.029316429,
-0.0024138177,
0.0607159287,
0.0333700143,
-0.0300876517,
-0.0206697062,
0.0812123939,
0.0308659188,
-0.0777931958,
0.0074398313,
-0.0107978024,
0.0326081179,
-0.0012966625,
0.0323278382,
-0.1077345759,
-0.062216863,
0.0389829874,
0.0192393493,
-0.0277111735,
-0.0730962902,
0.0284895878,
-0.1239085719,
0.0422866605,
-0.0243242085,
-0.0369249247,
0.0042908671,
-0.0603312515,
-0.0012629434,
0.0092300512,
-0.0303567126,
0.0060100197,
-0.0051669921,
0.0313653201,
0.0306412205,
-0.011761168,
-0.0020586778,
0.0300291795,
-0.0231114365,
0.0090220347,
0.0722444355,
-0.0155741842,
0.0401634201,
-0.0282814242,
0.0091280686,
-0.0263716523,
0.0188285019,
-0.0101779727,
-0.0039915983,
0.0132455016,
-0.0067870859,
-0.0535452701,
0.106190078,
-0.0546496399,
-0.0330729894,
0.0539468192,
0.0930560678,
-0.0292747393,
-0.0019825816,
-0.0244974028,
0.0351587161,
0.0435300097,
0.0600441508,
0.0402679108,
-0.0235231072,
-0.0245831199,
-0.0440620407,
0.0072367834,
-0.0553814955,
-0.0102638509,
0.0448086634,
0.0222772416,
0.012470888,
-0.0575760901,
-0.027891444,
0.0527719595,
0.099815473,
-0.0065413811,
-0.0005130055,
0.0021514485,
0.0328594111,
-0.0191950463,
-0.0066866395,
-0.0613055639,
-0.012044359,
-0.0269369539,
-0.0059655053,
-0.024621496,
-0.0276634246,
-0.0363653824,
0.0368943885,
-0.0816857442,
-0.0154886162,
-0.00694083,
0.0885394439,
0.0230863113,
0.0480025634,
-0.0313655883,
-0.0060025887,
0.0234798361,
0.0435651615,
0.0114038913,
0.0021595613,
-0.0030033579,
0.0439011976,
-0.0066850553,
0.0139084421,
-0.040678449,
0.0290959422,
0.004519755,
0.0519481674,
-0.0103424825,
-0.0176770184,
0.0731217861,
0.002413814,
0.0261772741,
-0.0451939143,
0.0156491622,
-0.017192604,
0.0410945155,
-0.0086269286,
-0.0198192596,
-0.0177475009,
0.046247229,
0.0117762284,
-0.046984639,
0.0334078595,
-0.0699993148,
-0.0061365319,
0.0324217863,
-0.0121939695,
-0.0259107724,
0.0292947423,
0.0753761977,
0.0470190309,
-0.0350843817,
-0.023958547,
0.0089654354,
0.0156708956,
0.0455307625,
0.009422563,
0.1160910428,
0.0614293851,
-0.0268844105,
-0.058120437,
0.0095530171,
-0.0842775926,
-0.0543176495,
-0.0067243776,
-0.0162295718,
0.0475528613,
0.0203034617,
-0.0447392128,
-0.0234502442,
0.0045782807,
0.02865953,
0.0358766541,
0.0137512805,
-0.0087589566,
0.0017628496,
0.0307550766,
0.0331830606,
-0.0388113111,
0.0642278567,
-0.0422123633,
0.0260531735,
0.0138215479,
0.0202802494,
-0.0372368731,
-0.0456311665,
-0.0639557019,
0.0258630998,
-0.0008824298,
-0.0134405354,
-0.0478834882,
-0.0330164582,
-0.0273206923,
0.016069077,
0.0213561039,
0.0217049997,
0.0731055588,
0.0589084551,
-0.0230069142,
-0.0509205461,
0.0128795831,
0.0632062927,
-0.0090425983,
-0.0485453084,
-0.0116696507,
-6.291236215e-33,
-0.0238096844,
-0.0147209438,
0.0276887044,
0.0232654773,
0.0205615088,
-0.0366604403,
-0.0477982648,
0.018847568,
0.0057591004,
0.0388713256,
-0.0242025219,
-0.0236496832,
0.0197249074,
0.0241687782,
0.0297136698,
-0.036225453,
0.0099143023,
-0.0144558661,
-0.0517462604,
-0.0001903887,
0.0412417501,
0.0279355552,
0.0037320582,
-0.0448040478,
-0.0213566199,
-0.0013603253,
0.0063627437,
0.0322677344,
-0.0180013832,
0.0306593049,
-0.0058253217,
0.0145880533,
0.0180707611,
-0.0624259077,
0.0122424802,
0.031838268,
-0.095882602,
-0.0717537031,
0.0000759369,
-0.0220438056,
-0.0744965598,
-0.0534922816,
-0.0461038463,
0.0034693908,
0.0123518491,
-0.0272423346,
0.0039725206,
-0.0283601824,
-0.0156258941,
-0.0050387699,
-0.0042941733,
-0.0280845892,
-0.0210058857,
-0.0263539944,
-0.0122950599,
0.0636971891,
-0.0088418322,
-0.0320782624,
0.0195405483,
0.0103105148,
0.0312764272,
0.004259896,
0.0324966833,
0.0139614344,
0.0036423958,
0.0496025421,
0.0257949587,
-0.0147092901,
-0.0558761656,
0.0129853887,
-0.0127597945,
0.0240396112,
0.0213088635,
0.0302398577,
0.0343676396,
0.0508717261,
-0.0578168705,
0.0361283533,
0.0383412056,
-0.0179417692,
-0.0059910687,
-0.023199629,
-0.0099697551,
-0.0211376213,
-0.0635821596,
-0.0393998846,
-0.0264470316,
-0.0268333387,
0.0394985639,
0.0074961516,
-0.0244305134,
-0.0270611495,
0.0399794094,
0.0234857891,
0.0104309479,
-0.0163073763,
0.0212290213,
0.0173459984,
-0.0146304844,
0.0097263716,
-0.0302245524,
-0.0036863284,
0.0323559791,
0.014744157,
0.0467984602,
0.011573595,
0.0380790532,
-0.0269154646,
-0.0269945581,
-0.0046455115,
-0.0633988604,
0.0443400368,
0.0165517554,
-0.0122754388,
0.0362490602,
0.0057319291,
0.0077057322,
0.0230664294,
-0.0174681209,
-0.0051756939,
-0.0177864134,
0.0408281535,
-0.0010657401,
-0.0035490755,
0.0077132238,
-0.0093117077,
-0.0018369281,
-0.0175228473,
0.007927049,
-0.0525097921,
-0.0108412215,
0.0570977852,
2.765e-7,
0.0234429464,
0.0164102819,
0.0435755104,
0.0087907566,
0.0056010624,
0.0357170217,
0.0383270346,
0.0206381809,
0.0262278337,
-0.083309114,
0.0012892502,
0.0307004713,
0.016683314,
0.0617423393,
-0.1040202826,
-0.0573125668,
-0.0199805815,
0.0067128888,
-0.0394099243,
-0.0080735302,
0.0836535022,
0.0484646186,
0.0054615401,
-0.0326912664,
0.0254717544,
0.0280604474,
0.0067188255,
-0.010763173,
0.0383514725,
-0.0038648876,
-0.021660462,
-0.0394766107,
0.0200678501,
0.0729852766,
-0.0101561174,
-0.0233920328,
-0.0097352378,
-0.0025999441,
0.0220212359,
-0.0453694351,
-0.0150850574,
-0.0118655534,
0.0401973836,
-0.0248572361,
0.0674454942,
-0.059652891,
-0.0046118521,
0.02197944,
-0.038278196,
-0.0491237082,
-0.002884757,
0.0056526349,
0.0364295356,
0.0140198283,
0.0015496869,
0.0394111574,
0.0100528607,
-0.0598703884,
-0.0018335122,
0.026155347,
-0.0312992111,
-0.0104821995,
-0.0364913307,
-0.0193860456,
0.0333951861,
-0.0846422538,
-0.0108078113,
2.547125674e-34,
0.0050314027,
-0.0252924766,
0.0380385816,
0.0464034788,
0.0162713081,
-0.0078602368,
0.002484001,
0.0021782999,
0.0395778604,
-0.0903693363,
-0.031059131
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.09990v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.09990v1 | Dual Semantic Knowledge Composed Multimodal Dialog Systems | 2023-05-17T06:33:26 | 2023-05-17T06:33:26 | Xiaolin Chen, Xuemeng Song, Yinwei Wei, Liqiang Nie, Tat-Seng Chua | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.MM | Textual response generation is an essential task for multimodal task-oriented
dialog systems.Although existing studies have achieved fruitful progress, they
still suffer from two critical limitations: 1) focusing on the attribute
knowledge but ignoring the relation knowledge that can reveal the correlations
between different entities and hence promote the response generation}, and 2)
only conducting the cross-entropy loss based output-level supervision but
lacking the representation-level regularization. To address these limitations,
we devise a novel multimodal task-oriented dialog system (named MDS-S2).
Specifically, MDS-S2 first simultaneously acquires the context related
attribute and relation knowledge from the knowledge base, whereby the
non-intuitive relation knowledge is extracted by the n-hop graph walk.
Thereafter, considering that the attribute knowledge and relation knowledge can
benefit the responding to different levels of questions, we design a
multi-level knowledge composition module in MDS-S2 to obtain the latent
composed response representation. Moreover, we devise a set of latent query
variables to distill the semantic information from the composed response
representation and the ground truth response representation, respectively, and
thus conduct the representation-level semantic regularization. Extensive
experiments on a public dataset have verified the superiority of our proposed
MDS-S2. We have released the codes and parameters to facilitate the research
community. | [
0.0618496239,
0.0173305124,
-0.0018279345,
0.048582308,
-0.0054346039,
0.0018985717,
0.0224241205,
-0.017271135,
-0.0023923623,
-0.0749645531,
-0.026191406,
-0.0174122211,
-0.0286799651,
0.0608280525,
0.0451419242,
-0.06110112,
0.0350132138,
-0.0088443635,
0.0057117147,
-0.008933669,
0.0426036045,
0.025311172,
-0.0340506509,
0.0611816198,
-0.0628761724,
-0.0262754243,
-0.0588364601,
0.0268180482,
0.0140761342,
-0.0434436761,
0.0303246491,
0.0195297468,
0.0609532893,
0.0093270764,
0.0000019105,
-0.0386153124,
0.0109667014,
-0.0032203493,
-0.0016190552,
-0.0652721599,
0.0143363411,
0.0029171233,
0.0468891487,
-0.0019482838,
-0.0337104537,
-0.0452182107,
0.0540456884,
0.0796702206,
0.068740882,
0.0519204251,
-0.036158137,
-0.0409566425,
0.0169752706,
0.0029394028,
0.0436264053,
-0.0215375405,
-0.0110887615,
0.020052176,
0.0145651568,
0.0033715507,
-0.0252122935,
-0.00083787,
-0.015164244,
-0.0384498164,
0.0047314521,
0.0213279724,
0.0440572575,
-0.0198091641,
-0.0136971073,
0.1324029267,
0.0428299904,
0.0291949995,
0.0003214325,
0.0085377013,
0.0112110553,
-0.0147756534,
-0.0524239726,
0.0101939151,
-0.034568049,
-0.0246396773,
-0.0739113241,
0.0108633516,
-0.0296486001,
-0.0174977034,
-0.0184684582,
0.0420779064,
-0.0058869612,
-0.0257388558,
-0.0041787219,
0.0034314343,
-0.0037548598,
-0.0433032773,
-0.0239765849,
0.0288969837,
-0.0544063188,
0.0072404365,
-0.0400526635,
-0.0358786881,
-0.0054639033,
-0.0052559357,
0.0123659922,
0.0291471891,
-0.0100201601,
0.0444866233,
-0.0067891125,
0.0513405502,
-0.0203249529,
0.0291601866,
-0.025592763,
-0.0350794606,
-0.0686423853,
-0.0191262197,
-0.0262642279,
0.0535619557,
-0.0532156564,
-0.0319644772,
-0.0101757133,
0.0515969992,
-0.0244688094,
0.0047746021,
0.0054589952,
0.0628989339,
-0.0230930671,
0.025981918,
-0.0493880883,
0.0567672029,
-0.0367117152,
0.0334222168,
0.0280161425,
0.0150289172,
0.0124219181,
0.0447691008,
0.0439171195,
-0.0138504924,
-0.0183841158,
0.0929884017,
-0.0302516781,
-0.0047577447,
-0.0026961409,
-0.0657919869,
-0.0288818814,
-0.0735927746,
0.0183245149,
-0.0070960242,
0.0732861459,
-0.0054982645,
-0.0383528098,
-0.0148317423,
0.0194119979,
0.0245212335,
-0.0113476245,
0.0603435151,
0.0027963798,
-0.0189635903,
0.0133414036,
0.0132595953,
-0.0291190594,
0.0599095859,
0.0226573981,
0.0277349837,
0.0148131866,
0.0116550718,
-0.0380378477,
-0.0324521512,
0.0119734071,
-0.0261786133,
0.0295821186,
0.0035141974,
-0.034484148,
0.0167524479,
0.0594303794,
0.0705260932,
-0.0398828797,
-0.024435468,
0.0370862298,
0.0096710911,
0.0204203427,
-0.0066491743,
0.0413544215,
0.028896207,
-0.0154706351,
0.0149469953,
-0.0262782332,
0.0478914902,
-0.0265057255,
-0.0042162533,
0.0409172922,
0.0235883538,
-0.0341675393,
-0.0163291711,
0.0431174412,
-0.0055297357,
0.0241699722,
0.0045071039,
0.0401183441,
0.0191570241,
-0.0662735105,
-0.0120437248,
0.0060444702,
-0.041178178,
0.0003467594,
-0.0126205059,
0.0435893647,
0.0426018424,
0.0359855406,
-0.0236631148,
-0.0357615463,
-0.0161595996,
-0.0026332489,
0.0371122137,
-0.0056743566,
-0.0280167088,
0.0363050327,
-0.0578235164,
-0.0541367531,
-0.0317312256,
-0.0297795963,
0.0348964483,
-0.0503271893,
-0.0132084591,
0.0250912625,
0.0061651426,
0.0702227056,
0.0039110528,
0.0673157349,
0.0350849479,
0.0043149642,
0.0105398865,
0.0580133423,
0.0411760658,
0.0073613874,
0.009180597,
0.0164091662,
-0.0397245549,
-0.0424051471,
0.0172129218,
-0.0316976793,
-0.1273725927,
0.0089922063,
-0.039765209,
0.0129876034,
-0.0174200479,
-0.0306741353,
-0.0724910572,
0.0583785363,
-0.0505002104,
0.0074886829,
-0.048772078,
-0.0308573917,
0.0649577156,
-0.0018221181,
-0.0481291376,
0.0549837202,
0.0035405741,
-0.0013434968,
0.0272353869,
-0.0080556748,
0.0262629744,
-0.0286691878,
-0.0111814858,
0.0114059821,
-0.0175811742,
0.0258332882,
0.0176885445,
0.0003173339,
-0.0259432234,
0.0224455483,
-0.0798624679,
-0.0111105684,
0.0089224568,
0.007847853,
-0.0165307987,
0.0292427987,
0.0418382548,
-0.0214723796,
-0.0808439478,
0.0786246583,
0.0609333776,
0.0114767356,
0.0348671079,
0.0395107791,
0.0104330471,
-0.0130326422,
0.0180294048,
-0.0032103071,
0.0637188479,
-0.0199513324,
-0.0033645562,
-0.0366713367,
0.0037285704,
-0.0673623905,
0.0574540757,
-0.006186679,
-0.0204358045,
0.0315667689,
-0.0200804807,
0.0613663048,
0.0090703508,
0.0177637264,
0.0479280055,
-0.0157443322,
-0.036111623,
-0.0584600791,
0.0673761815,
-0.0313287228,
0.014542996,
-0.0227705184,
-0.0006551215,
-0.0047190599,
0.0449548252,
0.0307956245,
-0.0049573928,
-0.0634237453,
0.0141736493,
0.041072648,
-0.0557697602,
-0.0422991402,
0.0188186839,
-0.0044735591,
0.0070454939,
-0.0315226465,
0.0191800892,
0.0642233342,
-0.0053589852,
-0.0302690323,
-0.0056441119,
-0.0126107652,
-0.0101897633,
0.0844480321,
0.0059192451,
0.0632505044,
0.0055884239,
-0.0273477938,
-0.0767446011,
-0.0015121627,
0.0433298275,
0.0035264501,
0.0050795921,
-0.0089064902,
0.0088570872,
-0.0265000742,
-0.0243988577,
-0.016126873,
-0.0193440393,
0.0020950963,
-0.0192639139,
0.0194434114,
-0.0064908662,
-0.0086696725,
-0.0024437285,
0.0430447981,
-0.0031925789,
0.0000992743,
-0.0138123948,
-0.021659106,
0.0623228177,
0.0489702076,
0.0590634905,
-0.0213323422,
-0.0310400743,
0.0461246334,
0.0832636654,
0.0339582823,
-0.057321094,
-0.000975734,
-0.0215182193,
0.018271178,
0.03852899,
-0.0036231992,
-0.0095583107,
0.0375462808,
-0.0412469767,
0.0093434388,
0.0528159812,
-0.0024054828,
-0.0121736322,
-0.0026713952,
-0.0034447922,
0.0289043374,
0.0225328226,
0.0048881639,
-0.0825114772,
-0.0539604053,
-0.0238830373,
-0.0102592623,
0.0047081993,
-0.0254943874,
-0.002306646,
-0.0637694672,
0.0359152928,
-0.0354856439,
-0.050013639,
-0.0420289077,
0.0035062279,
-0.0046118437,
0.0403322317,
-0.0322887972,
-0.0000437064,
0.0256699398,
-0.0062779039,
0.0202394947,
0.0261309594,
-0.0109574283,
0.004433081,
-0.0012773196,
0.0163213871,
0.0217557009,
0.0431096181,
0.0426319763,
-0.0024481129,
-0.0128735537,
-0.0068023959,
-0.0080349585,
-0.0110230613,
0.0340266339,
-0.0347174555,
-0.0070845811,
-0.0359285846,
0.0164551996,
-0.0165830385,
-0.012752044,
-0.0104517704,
0.0516340286,
-0.0735210404,
-0.0071994234,
-0.0429225564,
0.0301137846,
0.029048549,
0.0584707968,
0.0114548597,
-0.0356563888,
-0.0597021207,
-0.0093567306,
-0.0014674986,
-0.0695956275,
0.0162070338,
0.0091211954,
0.0039814613,
0.0346406586,
-0.0829198658,
-0.0402879193,
0.0083453739,
0.0518512391,
-0.0376739092,
-0.0144008351,
0.0114494879,
0.0061118822,
-0.0520129278,
-0.0096561396,
0.0104382224,
0.0248194057,
-0.0202568453,
-0.0152432434,
0.0289218035,
-0.0314554162,
-0.0255993344,
0.0066865403,
-0.0488437861,
-0.0558807105,
-0.0780652463,
0.0725841671,
0.0091566052,
0.0049115247,
0.0279065352,
-0.0185800549,
0.025626529,
0.006268851,
-0.0631321296,
-0.0210960824,
0.0383505858,
0.0382969938,
-0.0322880372,
0.0197364427,
-0.0841454118,
0.0121152531,
-0.0272460766,
0.051207263,
0.0041396837,
-0.0682855844,
-0.0054729832,
0.0002138697,
0.0191116128,
0.0092693344,
-0.0041038925,
-0.039234139,
0.0225190036,
-0.0514666252,
-0.0293264743,
-0.1027199998,
0.0130806072,
-0.0303906929,
-0.0202580225,
0.0255926102,
-0.0258045141,
0.00541797,
0.049050238,
-0.0163329523,
0.0029607574,
0.0390348583,
-0.0248145573,
0.013690847,
0.011916548,
-0.0151040722,
0.0008812932,
0.0204904918,
-0.0018196991,
-0.0014502249,
0.0963674858,
0.0184284169,
-0.0510460064,
0.0072690435,
0.03338084,
-0.0496976301,
0.0213752426,
-0.0029798271,
-0.0029873436,
0.0235187542,
0.0699853227,
0.0201992262,
-0.0082285022,
0.0065956651,
-0.0100224698,
0.0894646496,
0.0147408145,
-0.0469163321,
0.0680593401,
0.0121818464,
-0.0073896474,
0.0010637753,
0.0889459774,
0.0103300679,
0.0277494416,
-0.0251898095,
-0.0071960357,
-0.0697590858,
-0.0395817794,
0.020330837,
0.0595467277,
0.000782674,
0.010062498,
-0.0428847559,
-0.0464761145,
-0.0160188191,
-0.0001451414,
-0.0154008605,
0.00776284,
0.0675662607,
0.0243318994,
0.0381199159,
-0.0496050604,
-0.04008146,
-0.0048335358,
-0.0438251607,
0.0112029957,
0.0109400451,
-5.754171213e-33,
-0.037148118,
-0.0399163067,
0.0296743289,
-0.0166366175,
-0.0332337208,
-0.0099459169,
-0.0394094959,
0.0142582543,
-0.0013687923,
0.0252057128,
0.0256402437,
-0.0327440314,
-0.0181815922,
0.0623849481,
-0.0393975489,
-0.0030154032,
0.0445685051,
-0.0100114951,
0.0115892254,
0.0571194142,
0.0937494859,
0.0105205989,
0.0245733969,
-0.0632355586,
0.0154245039,
-0.0009651521,
-0.0184428543,
0.0274404828,
0.0121604847,
0.0560673103,
-0.0299580693,
0.0873273686,
0.0188658535,
-0.0277060624,
-0.0222608373,
0.0211237632,
-0.0747138187,
-0.0277572293,
0.0282087531,
-0.0124728642,
-0.0825755894,
0.0043419814,
0.0009211181,
-0.013454766,
0.0655285567,
-0.026614001,
0.0182475727,
0.014999534,
-0.0121349599,
-0.0574010238,
-0.0567682497,
-0.0048834938,
-0.0336870849,
-0.0306724422,
-0.0138527872,
0.0909736007,
0.0432430319,
-0.0355295539,
-0.0065446794,
0.0079542547,
-0.0744284317,
-0.0387199894,
0.0325543694,
0.0443370864,
-0.0049279411,
0.0476241671,
0.0091003133,
0.0109146079,
-0.0593553185,
0.0110314358,
-0.0345808677,
0.0654193833,
0.0086711068,
0.0832735077,
-0.0335006006,
-0.0078492668,
-0.0629710481,
0.0415017866,
0.0037890442,
0.0572353229,
-0.0069305222,
0.0244438294,
-0.008586077,
-0.0136449691,
-0.027124228,
0.0336904638,
-0.0294327624,
-0.0329118073,
0.0480167046,
0.0186535977,
-0.000728426,
-0.0025562521,
0.0701627061,
-0.0162962936,
0.0044412771,
0.0314748883,
-0.0084050084,
0.0232887845,
-0.0044938643,
-0.0100848619,
-0.0216402486,
-0.0321660638,
0.0839967355,
-0.0166460481,
0.0013185722,
0.0389541537,
0.0191591438,
0.0103353327,
-0.02230631,
-0.0117688533,
-0.030582903,
0.0373169631,
-0.0536011383,
0.0124262348,
-0.0046351152,
-0.0178340953,
-0.0446546823,
0.0390305556,
-0.0388775989,
-0.0055656498,
-0.0287725218,
-0.040863011,
0.0358927958,
0.0303256232,
-0.0270053688,
0.002814613,
0.0028797861,
-0.0760441422,
0.0257226601,
-0.0282072071,
-0.0014446413,
0.0222989153,
2.599e-7,
-0.012807223,
-0.0063428753,
0.002004117,
0.0300420616,
0.0135886604,
0.061489962,
0.0241384376,
0.0390561782,
-0.0029614198,
-0.0441244133,
0.0140552903,
0.0156130223,
0.0140128648,
0.0079330048,
-0.0450530201,
-0.0157564171,
-0.0112757478,
-0.0503741503,
-0.0447391868,
0.0253776386,
0.1159435138,
0.0417085588,
-0.0164012369,
-0.005015356,
0.0089287143,
-0.0066967555,
0.0646919981,
0.0132752154,
-0.0070502171,
-0.0264629424,
0.0655326173,
-0.0272201505,
0.0178747121,
0.0370670035,
-0.0009678499,
-0.0059809303,
0.0406334326,
0.0244671516,
-0.0084331743,
-0.0726406872,
0.0085498961,
0.0078349495,
0.0071991477,
-0.0132456804,
0.0596056022,
-0.0368222333,
-0.0507009737,
-0.0120963259,
-0.0178377591,
-0.0305901337,
-0.037628565,
-0.0075711957,
-0.0237192847,
-0.0075559616,
0.0347307883,
-0.0114796674,
0.0074995439,
-0.1070882753,
0.0131100211,
0.0151452655,
-0.0517658331,
-0.0424162596,
-0.0171239153,
-0.0036522443,
0.0516334958,
-0.0345934592,
-0.0508371443,
2.140495316e-34,
0.0064706136,
-0.0034108367,
-0.0056902077,
-0.0114064896,
0.0337057114,
-0.0127419,
-0.0254191924,
-0.0193485469,
0.0511477068,
-0.0930023417,
-0.0395383425
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.09975v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.09975v1 | Smart Word Suggestions for Writing Assistance | 2023-05-17T06:15:41 | 2023-05-17T06:15:41 | Chenshuo Wang, Shaoguang Mao, Tao Ge, Wenshan Wu, Xun Wang, Yan Xia, Jonathan Tien, Dongyan Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Enhancing word usage is a desired feature for writing assistance. To further
advance research in this area, this paper introduces "Smart Word Suggestions"
(SWS) task and benchmark. Unlike other works, SWS emphasizes end-to-end
evaluation and presents a more realistic writing assistance scenario. This task
involves identifying words or phrases that require improvement and providing
substitution suggestions. The benchmark includes human-labeled data for
testing, a large distantly supervised dataset for training, and the framework
for evaluation. The test data includes 1,000 sentences written by English
learners, accompanied by over 16,000 substitution suggestions annotated by 10
native speakers. The training dataset comprises over 3.7 million sentences and
12.7 million suggestions generated through rules. Our experiments with seven
baselines demonstrate that SWS is a challenging task. Based on experimental
analysis, we suggest potential directions for future research on SWS. The
dataset and related codes is available at
https://github.com/microsoft/SmartWordSuggestions. | [
0.0760083497,
-0.0220132209,
-0.007172747,
-0.0098463055,
-0.0680745542,
-0.02533409,
0.0034794551,
0.0231039282,
0.0200244561,
-0.0590628684,
-0.0322834402,
0.0058121355,
0.017462071,
0.0160912536,
0.0482949093,
-0.0475203469,
0.0422486886,
0.0054766368,
0.0348190963,
0.0312707238,
0.0506340824,
0.0145505108,
-0.0264443494,
0.066082105,
-0.0115264179,
-0.0185898822,
0.0481452867,
-0.0139419427,
-0.0087145856,
-0.0131923202,
0.069489792,
0.0793873817,
-0.0162772443,
-0.0001391932,
0.0000016806,
-0.0494680814,
-0.0056225248,
-0.0180792119,
0.0118079856,
0.0011597422,
0.0340537727,
-0.0215968546,
0.00962401,
0.0290117413,
-0.0376658216,
0.0246967319,
0.0402414948,
0.0436544083,
0.02459196,
0.0543831959,
-0.0136638191,
0.052250009,
-0.0016933561,
-0.0201256536,
-0.0043277433,
0.0199999381,
0.0031382395,
-0.0267756712,
-0.0049700192,
-0.036786221,
-0.0154917585,
0.0392831452,
-0.0150340395,
-0.0803592876,
0.076268889,
-0.0120824892,
-0.0280420817,
0.0206204522,
-0.0275419541,
0.0668648556,
-0.0316798203,
-0.0033431167,
-0.0278906021,
-0.0423051678,
-0.0098898811,
0.0362880938,
0.0156909134,
-0.0464457981,
-0.0038829446,
-0.0004525169,
0.0298209693,
-0.0367636085,
0.0205638036,
0.0632829443,
0.0628735274,
0.0640940145,
0.0329370536,
-0.0421116054,
-0.0118374554,
0.0204143766,
-0.0124427965,
-0.0593502931,
0.0726263747,
-0.0067258272,
-0.0676334277,
0.0047969436,
-0.0836729407,
-0.0451193564,
0.0211143177,
-0.0364207886,
0.0947156847,
0.0215494651,
0.0139216715,
0.026304882,
-0.0279188287,
-0.0200644359,
0.0154065629,
-0.0028077865,
-0.0214533955,
0.014446347,
-0.0300020911,
-0.0145042548,
-0.048766017,
0.0158989225,
-0.0366227962,
-0.0564839542,
-0.0524919666,
-0.0174518749,
-0.01995348,
-0.0131316325,
0.0093707955,
0.0196103975,
-0.019422343,
-0.0027174333,
-0.0182654075,
0.0088615604,
-0.037259452,
0.0472637266,
0.0127496887,
-0.0006369673,
-0.0024960958,
0.0054285978,
0.0482792147,
-0.0541229397,
0.007161885,
0.0282695349,
-0.0244148653,
-0.0722677186,
-0.0144368988,
-0.0259522349,
-0.0206190031,
0.0133950338,
-0.0518282317,
-0.0612991899,
-0.0154910451,
-0.0351050347,
-0.0170725547,
-0.0225643236,
0.0121558188,
0.0379830971,
-0.0095278369,
0.0710907578,
-0.0770901665,
-0.0031301524,
0.0395283289,
-0.0205377433,
-0.0114944624,
0.0026217562,
0.0309186522,
0.0153686721,
0.0789184198,
0.0015509133,
0.0520577356,
0.0178848207,
-0.0396243483,
-0.0031041165,
-0.0094317738,
-0.022967618,
-0.0358605534,
0.0817502141,
-0.0081181694,
0.0318403207,
-0.0220930632,
0.032858856,
0.0916937292,
0.0176937655,
0.0490857475,
0.0215341579,
0.05275397,
0.0264293533,
-0.0082104309,
-0.0134451399,
-0.0307213999,
0.0219809748,
-0.0492869392,
-0.0095213642,
-0.0076448084,
-0.0019846414,
-0.0126963612,
-0.0426015183,
-0.0200504363,
-0.0074064247,
-0.0065532494,
-0.0115034999,
0.0424459502,
0.0642380342,
-0.0284029935,
-0.0129356524,
0.0089654792,
-0.044976972,
0.0198940188,
-0.032862436,
0.0459108017,
0.1307680458,
0.0990600064,
-0.0315419286,
-0.0470103361,
-0.0163475703,
0.0001462902,
0.0188970137,
0.0450248495,
-0.0142821306,
0.018708352,
-0.065729782,
-0.0065807854,
0.012633726,
0.006638906,
-0.0378882401,
0.0620141439,
-0.0073477523,
0.0120210005,
-0.0317499936,
-0.0549568459,
0.0602784231,
0.0231782999,
0.0051750466,
0.0567362756,
0.0149205374,
-0.00883401,
0.0101318136,
-0.0122772614,
0.0241393894,
-0.0185098611,
-0.0396757573,
-0.0800948739,
0.0195129998,
-0.0289933458,
-0.0106957387,
0.007197829,
-0.0556274615,
0.0086644096,
0.0298321452,
0.0139864245,
-0.0424797162,
-0.007834414,
-0.0499445423,
0.0012517456,
-0.0619137846,
0.0258863568,
0.0002603829,
0.0186695699,
-0.0216843039,
0.0060650152,
0.0326285847,
0.0435637534,
0.0097609423,
0.0278833471,
0.0095270919,
0.0260111,
-0.0189686455,
-0.0343637578,
-0.0287942514,
-0.0098561589,
0.0392814577,
0.0235039108,
-0.0623770617,
-0.0388576537,
-0.0569506399,
0.0247852579,
-0.0112415422,
0.0120865842,
0.0377764069,
0.0325674713,
-0.0165198147,
-0.009903755,
0.0130959013,
0.0166273247,
-0.0156203564,
0.0161641203,
0.0700797662,
-0.0421659201,
-0.010057711,
-0.0764393136,
-0.0152008412,
-0.0216639228,
-0.0133760385,
0.0111874221,
-0.0351181477,
-0.0237820484,
-0.0166534856,
0.0145727647,
-0.0098683555,
0.0468368791,
-0.0767003894,
0.0042256732,
0.0005909623,
0.0822993293,
0.0591275506,
0.0137758963,
-0.031736102,
0.0446732976,
-0.0061560506,
-0.0129753165,
-0.0300404541,
-0.0034322932,
0.0356037095,
0.0137196947,
-0.0102573689,
-0.0041542961,
0.015393842,
0.0579311848,
-0.0431286357,
-0.0522370748,
0.038802091,
-0.0229331143,
-0.00996802,
-0.0178068858,
-0.0092495857,
-0.0400123633,
0.0035224941,
-0.0375923626,
-0.0455001704,
0.0574775077,
-0.0097080898,
0.0058351578,
-0.0389819592,
-0.034675356,
-0.0347337611,
-0.0021704556,
-0.0370191596,
-0.0038367908,
-0.0402172469,
-0.0143609159,
-0.0242462121,
-0.0276457723,
0.0454404429,
0.0033966352,
0.0225866437,
-0.0738058761,
-0.0028139835,
0.0286803599,
-0.0152740423,
-0.0115427589,
-0.0835177898,
0.0042367456,
-0.002741647,
0.041694276,
-0.0451098755,
0.0113302758,
-0.0345384404,
-0.0149591975,
0.1129644364,
-0.0219672248,
-0.0181579888,
-0.0313723199,
0.0161712542,
0.0336802565,
-0.029483635,
-0.0366658345,
0.0309509002,
0.0549903363,
0.0249116495,
0.0124262357,
-0.0319633819,
-0.0323920995,
0.0224319138,
0.0053491606,
-0.0586438291,
-0.0148777515,
0.0090961903,
0.084248364,
-0.0416769795,
-0.0235596169,
0.1041221097,
0.0456513502,
-0.0411650576,
0.0011196004,
0.0094757918,
-0.0201927125,
0.039603997,
0.0199522246,
-0.0286917593,
-0.05211588,
0.0124338781,
0.0427171811,
-0.003501805,
-0.0330349095,
-0.0108950436,
-0.0767633542,
0.0152559998,
-0.0201880205,
0.0019999302,
0.0024513202,
0.0141947763,
-0.0010048451,
0.010550756,
0.0004055839,
-0.0432129577,
-0.0161358602,
0.0134306392,
-0.0185339712,
-0.0632234216,
-0.0085576707,
0.0203355122,
-0.0462760739,
0.0478142984,
0.0785874873,
0.0414288826,
0.0162256155,
-0.0094918562,
-0.0178854726,
-0.0153377187,
0.0086529059,
-0.0272252541,
0.0480005182,
-0.0087071555,
0.0029144692,
-0.0506211258,
0.0585558265,
-0.0486707427,
-0.024442751,
0.0603613034,
0.0424239151,
-0.0240580998,
-0.0166405197,
-0.0107832449,
0.0280457139,
0.039323099,
0.0461848825,
0.0410430543,
-0.0695194378,
-0.0110363783,
0.017433282,
-0.0197663289,
-0.0477279946,
0.003162727,
-0.0096408268,
-0.0319166481,
0.0085205017,
-0.0999679714,
-0.0529708713,
0.0968678892,
0.0551548004,
0.0613389425,
0.0528942198,
-0.046246212,
-0.0095936749,
-0.0194062591,
0.0058882711,
0.019345725,
0.0739115253,
-0.0360275097,
-0.0211080946,
0.0045968653,
-0.0040215128,
0.0151698133,
0.0141979493,
-0.0132130925,
-0.0470998697,
0.0357865356,
0.0347778611,
0.0106423469,
0.0165411457,
-0.0566639304,
-0.1077351049,
-0.0149012031,
0.0156437587,
-0.0029726934,
0.0098479781,
0.0206898935,
-0.0269417819,
0.034675099,
0.0374367423,
0.0151459314,
0.0035562087,
0.010701187,
0.0480213203,
0.0240444839,
-0.0394940004,
0.0118391113,
0.0133284545,
0.0365351327,
-0.0529286489,
0.0158936847,
-0.0650944784,
-0.0136390589,
-0.0282375216,
-0.0402626917,
-0.0292306598,
0.0255699251,
0.0335354507,
-0.0059745656,
-0.0423904322,
0.0157463979,
-0.0825690106,
-0.0078960424,
-0.0131479222,
0.0170950349,
0.0140451817,
0.0151217636,
0.0071035083,
0.0370604098,
-0.0104419105,
0.0415806398,
-0.0201615673,
0.0145728998,
-0.0021993781,
0.0577618815,
0.0035717825,
-0.0123591926,
-0.0023235809,
0.0499735996,
-0.0442470089,
-0.0121543724,
-0.0143326838,
0.0596437156,
0.0377955548,
-0.0369964503,
0.0397977047,
-0.0352038816,
-0.0005518415,
0.0115574785,
0.0526995771,
-0.0376993492,
-0.0140499119,
0.0207418874,
-0.0055281483,
-0.0109813912,
-0.0141424453,
0.0600422621,
-0.0471826233,
0.0337072723,
0.0324281715,
-0.0121787675,
-0.0369078368,
-0.0061648535,
0.0364335477,
0.0656977743,
-0.0194253176,
-0.0035656234,
-0.0116427932,
-0.0293380748,
0.0138783064,
-0.0099454988,
-0.037275888,
0.0223532449,
0.029405443,
0.0421635881,
-0.0302227568,
-0.0096948268,
-0.0708913207,
-0.0195525885,
0.0108373491,
-0.0236830842,
-0.0331495292,
-5.605192732e-33,
0.0148116499,
-0.0543857738,
-0.0025753095,
0.0076793558,
0.0084865494,
-0.0012090444,
-0.0146514382,
-0.0068441718,
0.0481417216,
0.0465172715,
-0.0325160138,
0.0383535065,
0.0114696017,
0.0226935782,
0.035660442,
0.0265346039,
0.0364772975,
0.0023787785,
0.0012033425,
0.0020259051,
0.0116386376,
0.0356836654,
0.0675736666,
-0.0252056848,
0.0529241078,
0.0131104421,
-0.0437714905,
0.0346690826,
0.0096231624,
0.0373274051,
-0.0245441943,
0.0595097095,
-0.0031278881,
0.0273499843,
-0.020050155,
0.0380682349,
-0.0067779608,
-0.0334412009,
0.0269300342,
-0.0050884448,
-0.0378001519,
-0.0587344319,
0.0164465252,
-0.0377709828,
-0.016726559,
0.0624632388,
0.0565184988,
-0.0153849144,
-0.0269774515,
-0.0083380546,
-0.0765954554,
0.0204482209,
-0.0031219616,
-0.0336512886,
-0.0534329861,
0.0127210412,
-0.011730413,
-0.0552338213,
-0.0460650735,
0.0200846121,
0.0042376653,
0.0451773889,
0.0084310705,
-0.0358577073,
-0.0422999263,
0.0468420163,
0.0225942694,
0.0047434084,
0.0836167336,
-0.0154880704,
0.0412240848,
0.0419987477,
0.1026780084,
0.0669147074,
0.0542327426,
-0.016292138,
0.0408673622,
0.019715989,
0.0085499166,
-0.0056614191,
0.0172993671,
-0.0217446592,
-0.0564226061,
-0.0313964635,
-0.0137537438,
0.0078824284,
-0.0350685529,
-0.044296369,
0.0556556955,
0.018420957,
0.0068551847,
0.0061004828,
-0.0364671126,
0.0027434181,
0.0205671638,
-0.0196802001,
-0.0142801274,
0.0361006223,
0.002593186,
-0.004486328,
-0.0461156592,
-0.0397312082,
0.016371876,
0.0592080802,
0.0017445046,
-0.0068591288,
0.0271762069,
0.0387560837,
-0.0824051574,
0.0080934856,
-0.0069345869,
0.0064498289,
-0.0227692574,
-0.0539409854,
-0.0101744197,
0.0118256193,
-0.0291986018,
0.0525731407,
0.0504553877,
-0.0044458439,
-0.0224709455,
-0.0448997021,
0.0071436749,
0.0060997098,
0.003593717,
0.0011309959,
-0.0378308184,
-0.0289209206,
0.0027036404,
-0.0305435974,
0.0212639458,
-0.006252707,
2.381e-7,
0.0425304323,
0.0712786615,
0.0031079878,
-0.0102831358,
-0.0322189778,
0.0212758575,
0.0159696862,
0.0172105618,
0.005508313,
0.1182439253,
0.0569744892,
-0.0327958576,
0.0288850516,
-0.0175993629,
-0.0929804295,
-0.0240644831,
-0.0630012378,
0.0215188153,
-0.0383373573,
-0.0668429881,
0.0273019746,
0.0352185629,
0.0322159901,
-0.0376568735,
-0.0533474945,
-0.0862869695,
0.023659911,
-0.0620875545,
-0.0130004724,
-0.0058345222,
0.0522017218,
0.0295651145,
0.0042164838,
0.0092059402,
-0.056669917,
-0.0075518559,
0.0052440329,
0.0349154025,
-0.0265880581,
0.0104366746,
0.0002992192,
0.0017598184,
-0.0048268638,
-0.0076957536,
0.0644780248,
-0.0412342623,
0.0188259594,
-0.0260498896,
0.0078823408,
-0.0042919004,
0.0224222485,
-0.0604820214,
-0.0088787349,
0.0255727936,
0.0082789892,
0.0264076944,
-0.0304653272,
-0.0481474623,
-0.0241314471,
0.0038655896,
0.0281804167,
0.0212297775,
-0.0711267889,
0.0161973052,
-0.0029806013,
-0.0517119989,
-0.0070071714,
1.780561471e-34,
0.0197902881,
0.0016666058,
0.0471019782,
0.02043451,
0.0218376238,
0.0264616851,
0.0095086237,
0.009835449,
0.023730021,
-0.0603859164,
-0.0372183099
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.09955v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.09955v3 | Knowledge Card: Filling LLMs' Knowledge Gaps with Plug-in Specialized Language Models | 2023-05-17T05:25:27 | 2024-03-22T04:04:41 | Shangbin Feng, Weijia Shi, Yuyang Bai, Vidhisha Balachandran, Tianxing He, Yulia Tsvetkov | cs.CL | cs.CL | By design, large language models (LLMs) are static general-purpose models,
expensive to retrain or update frequently. As they are increasingly adopted for
knowledge-intensive tasks, it becomes evident that these design choices lead to
failures to generate factual, relevant, and up-to-date knowledge. To this end,
we propose Knowledge Card, a modular framework to plug in new factual and
relevant knowledge into general-purpose LLMs. We first introduce knowledge
cards -- specialized language models trained on corpora from specific domains
and sources. Knowledge cards serve as parametric repositories that are selected
at inference time to generate background knowledge for the base LLM. We then
propose three content selectors to dynamically select and retain information in
documents generated by knowledge cards, specifically controlling for relevance,
brevity, and factuality of outputs. Finally, we propose two complementary
integration approaches to augment the base LLM with the (relevant, factual)
knowledge curated from the specialized LMs. Through extensive experiments, we
demonstrate that Knowledge Card achieves state-of-the-art performance on six
benchmark datasets. Ultimately, Knowledge Card framework enables dynamic
synthesis and updates of knowledge from diverse domains. Its modularity will
ensure that relevant knowledge can be continuously updated through the
collective efforts of the research community. | [
0.0427958034,
0.0094466358,
-0.0138944564,
0.0152294012,
-0.0328405425,
0.0110615147,
-0.0265885387,
0.0290142875,
0.0193638001,
-0.0838116854,
-0.0157266427,
0.0375523344,
-0.023981763,
0.0170621295,
0.0274918452,
-0.0336198881,
0.0575503148,
-0.0184380263,
-0.0150912702,
0.0000563231,
0.0027504708,
0.0345327556,
0.0094962977,
-0.0097357146,
-0.016871566,
-0.0027956385,
-0.0028150969,
-0.009182333,
0.0087384796,
0.0041185259,
0.0465859547,
0.0568293855,
0.047172036,
0.0254958458,
0.0000021049,
-0.0451701805,
-0.0088002803,
-0.0064456472,
-0.0479809307,
-0.0239841491,
0.0328142419,
0.0031707839,
0.0190258659,
-0.0095202075,
-0.0369313508,
0.0039959089,
-0.0013279021,
0.0250254795,
0.0310838856,
0.0646943599,
-0.0028321948,
-0.0003910729,
0.0321326219,
-0.0272629298,
0.0280474797,
-0.01492263,
0.0357239172,
0.0372019857,
0.0222012103,
0.0337498039,
0.0013226568,
0.0393411592,
0.0090757459,
-0.049642168,
0.032219477,
0.0510889664,
-0.0078638848,
0.0234919582,
0.0080907317,
0.0796411186,
-0.0189855453,
-0.0271394346,
0.0195216555,
-0.013250323,
0.0043414268,
0.0178482234,
-0.0676403567,
0.0256394576,
-0.0063323644,
-0.0051410478,
0.0271988604,
-0.0172940381,
0.0498127081,
0.0454417504,
-0.0045098062,
0.036779549,
0.0239632502,
-0.0329712816,
0.014137432,
0.0044945888,
0.006967979,
-0.073264651,
-0.0161213372,
0.0476364531,
-0.0107110627,
0.0464848243,
-0.0334930643,
-0.0088125672,
0.0621884204,
-0.0513502546,
-0.0082033025,
0.024994459,
-0.0352977253,
0.0941823274,
-0.0281195901,
0.0101064527,
0.0054034828,
0.0162064843,
-0.0332242027,
-0.0225214455,
-0.0465662107,
-0.0102655562,
-0.0047658696,
0.0530775115,
-0.0422606058,
-0.011382808,
-0.0056047956,
0.0360408276,
-0.0084971189,
0.0401288234,
0.0311364364,
-0.00133689,
-0.0357277505,
-0.0213919505,
-0.0341234058,
0.0247287583,
-0.0357078426,
0.0177987553,
-0.013510027,
-0.0351755843,
0.0030321514,
0.0289616827,
-0.0124352714,
-0.0353947021,
0.0029792171,
0.0396324284,
-0.0115381656,
-0.0378120095,
-0.0927683711,
-0.0165710021,
0.0116000166,
-0.0866701305,
0.0149327219,
-0.0788339451,
0.0374867208,
0.0055363681,
-0.0055121602,
-0.0527906865,
0.0094210403,
0.0144354757,
-0.0300093219,
0.0566651933,
-0.0428775437,
-0.0070036012,
0.0333609879,
0.0095654596,
0.0103970161,
0.1051197797,
0.0209729075,
-0.0058811051,
0.0742026418,
0.0177943017,
-0.0096818581,
0.0149830729,
0.0183927622,
0.0399231389,
-0.0127986828,
0.0195545219,
-0.0193253122,
0.0256909486,
0.030924907,
0.0017528408,
-0.0315805152,
-0.0005358245,
0.0820328295,
0.0058529843,
0.0244587995,
0.0332839377,
0.0596812926,
-0.0012542299,
0.0125461966,
0.0335868225,
-0.0330665521,
0.0403471999,
-0.0293235537,
0.0173966978,
-0.0074199159,
0.0239246115,
-0.0331600569,
-0.0249137077,
-0.0111716483,
-0.0438092276,
-0.0018114412,
0.0031024425,
0.0585744828,
0.0117241358,
-0.0034168633,
0.0902773887,
0.0448606014,
-0.037053518,
0.0229528286,
-0.0153043447,
0.0492470674,
0.0622602776,
0.0469147488,
-0.0538986251,
-0.0585122071,
-0.008862352,
0.0209418945,
0.0483672023,
0.0687714741,
-0.0270947274,
0.0100442367,
-0.0543293618,
-0.0492455736,
-0.0265344605,
0.0193967074,
0.0157286897,
0.0704971403,
0.0282582752,
0.0186019931,
-0.0683649331,
-0.0179678649,
0.0427675694,
-0.0775097385,
-0.0046728393,
-0.0084548332,
-0.0228898916,
0.0011383204,
0.0154765248,
-0.0004953712,
-0.0237483922,
0.0587765649,
-0.0294445697,
-0.015433915,
0.0212344527,
-0.0195751954,
-0.0379243754,
0.061106354,
-0.0283022039,
-0.0205186922,
-0.0108107952,
-0.0734314173,
-0.045675654,
-0.0038097952,
-0.0073792785,
0.0363003612,
-0.073720254,
-0.0268060695,
0.0226038601,
-0.0048649833,
-0.0148040587,
0.0842662156,
-0.0119255399,
0.0082113566,
0.0501304865,
-0.0167007875,
0.0001151256,
-0.0389953367,
-0.0106115676,
0.0181420762,
0.0285135284,
0.0103625022,
0.0175935607,
0.0144961383,
-0.0536662489,
-0.0208602156,
-0.0755493864,
0.0070586894,
-0.0155517571,
-0.0123732034,
0.009789072,
0.0055046766,
-0.0208472144,
0.001207432,
-0.0286403261,
-0.0137903765,
-0.0071725002,
-0.0053269691,
0.0337516963,
0.0387916341,
0.0455491133,
-0.0545908399,
-0.0003613469,
0.0396451727,
0.0276221242,
0.0095038433,
-0.0176611394,
-0.0426164269,
0.0219797846,
-0.0553295501,
0.0194810797,
-0.0259954985,
0.0107483957,
-0.0306415316,
-0.023884438,
0.0102925338,
0.0118470415,
-0.0048584379,
0.0034895886,
0.0373881534,
-0.0008837211,
-0.0987410843,
0.0323835164,
-0.0295698456,
0.0206198376,
-0.0671414509,
-0.0262220744,
0.0151474401,
0.0253784955,
-0.0026473084,
-0.0109723723,
-0.032903865,
-0.0119430944,
0.006367017,
-0.0052580959,
-0.0369309187,
-0.0114834923,
-0.002864473,
0.0113785816,
-0.0234625693,
-0.0622749254,
0.0583572686,
-0.0319197401,
0.0144585632,
-0.0208974425,
-0.003591331,
-0.0531280711,
0.0480881073,
-0.0137397787,
0.0014905778,
-0.013267016,
0.017413862,
-0.0698575452,
-0.0246739089,
-0.0079419781,
-0.0442838073,
0.0516426191,
-0.055512391,
0.0313062668,
-0.0037609702,
-0.0198868252,
-0.0436340645,
0.0011417107,
-0.0073214946,
0.0277020484,
-0.0136553822,
-0.0260324702,
-0.0180765148,
-0.0278716609,
0.0410748199,
0.0653037503,
0.0007609108,
-0.0054614469,
-0.0156647135,
0.0326948948,
0.062215019,
0.0499487184,
0.0154357525,
-0.00684566,
0.0031536624,
0.0588579588,
-0.0102209728,
-0.0410518125,
-0.0019185615,
0.0043551731,
0.0400315449,
-0.0671456084,
-0.0220876988,
-0.0117187444,
-0.0032628155,
-0.058047846,
-0.0080567356,
0.1237279251,
0.0181047861,
-0.0521027744,
-0.0265172273,
-0.0088785784,
0.0198658854,
0.0330915637,
0.0483292378,
-0.0971064344,
-0.0192203075,
0.0010116146,
0.0288194865,
0.0083323317,
-0.0295345876,
-0.0262679756,
-0.1094230339,
0.0440606177,
-0.0074269646,
0.0087209875,
-0.0202851798,
-0.0296276473,
0.0191459414,
0.0246428419,
-0.014190889,
0.0057722973,
-0.0112930033,
-0.0203371327,
0.0129673555,
-0.0561220646,
-0.0533643626,
0.0147665655,
0.0045451038,
0.0268453471,
0.0268848762,
0.045835495,
0.004567564,
-0.0213777293,
0.0300443769,
-0.0299703702,
-0.0160034243,
-0.0450414345,
0.0501713902,
-0.0465567671,
0.021046767,
0.0404473767,
0.0274660364,
-0.0264312513,
-0.0147000328,
-0.0059132865,
0.0826790258,
-0.0169604141,
-0.0032397998,
-0.0387458466,
-0.0204516798,
0.0362319648,
0.1143728942,
0.0180060398,
-0.0103314212,
0.0217786133,
-0.0198021382,
0.0037481901,
-0.0284542721,
0.0019512476,
0.0243724715,
-0.0430148728,
0.011619091,
-0.0890080407,
-0.0228848178,
0.0332043245,
-0.0021014153,
0.0209280737,
0.0305069145,
-0.0182043817,
-0.0292015504,
-0.0459453911,
0.0106032128,
-0.0485864654,
-0.020827705,
-0.03071809,
-0.0565615334,
0.0347992107,
-0.0750805289,
-0.0048520598,
0.0161014292,
-0.0647045448,
-0.0434807651,
-0.0107704978,
0.0522946417,
0.0278467294,
0.0835539997,
-0.0247256346,
-0.0429224186,
0.0606670454,
0.0470860377,
-0.0552192591,
0.0105869509,
0.0210206807,
-0.0009454553,
-0.0005183873,
0.0524345301,
-0.0873437896,
-0.0061280592,
0.0113059999,
0.0459003448,
-0.0390063711,
-0.0373648331,
0.0009704675,
-0.0239312574,
-0.0077222921,
-0.0267054122,
0.0158647262,
-0.0575789958,
0.0322005302,
0.0045883832,
-0.0435751937,
-0.0337217897,
0.0324301682,
-0.0071197189,
0.0060879281,
0.0007353773,
0.0343428031,
-0.0192306582,
0.0651795641,
-0.0362409502,
-0.0420926288,
0.0131277209,
-0.0049436009,
0.0150305927,
0.0034650683,
-0.0233990327,
0.0105715441,
-0.0336916558,
0.0154962903,
-0.0464342125,
0.0367135443,
0.0108191203,
-0.0281620622,
-0.0109129949,
-0.0130804116,
-0.0633432716,
-0.0336383767,
-0.0210443679,
0.053950835,
0.0686779469,
-0.0234124195,
0.0402959846,
-0.067595914,
-0.0337724648,
-0.0184463635,
0.0036604353,
0.0334567651,
-0.0132652475,
0.0197442994,
0.0293268804,
-0.0308082756,
0.0316930227,
0.0770096928,
-0.0182390958,
0.0680196807,
-0.0123907607,
-0.0008061428,
-0.0428072922,
-0.0376870744,
0.0210743863,
0.0264563039,
-0.0267876294,
-0.0000488612,
-0.0740536749,
-0.0543853417,
0.0630408227,
-0.0100467633,
-0.0334937908,
-0.0072442177,
0.0448815599,
0.0518757999,
0.0103625171,
-0.0001414911,
-0.0478604436,
0.0367156453,
-0.0015371375,
-0.0099723954,
-0.0017364649,
-6.688676732e-33,
-0.0322678462,
-0.0136894127,
0.0227434691,
-0.0107957404,
-0.004713384,
0.0378873497,
-0.0304950029,
-0.04666977,
-0.0125933643,
0.0099417996,
-0.0185423456,
-0.0032119546,
0.0083762994,
0.0225144718,
-0.0160451904,
-0.0051858691,
0.0511012264,
0.0103454133,
-0.0063559697,
0.042190697,
0.0625703931,
0.0403627604,
0.0896933079,
-0.0648321658,
0.0652750134,
-0.0170615483,
0.014740861,
0.02584056,
0.0136422096,
0.0754774958,
-0.0089188693,
0.0578125492,
0.0276611596,
-0.0488258824,
-0.0176038537,
-0.0146707622,
-0.103641741,
-0.0328049995,
0.0499864705,
-0.0184975434,
-0.0138253123,
-0.0450524949,
0.0320007429,
0.0014706552,
0.0290804971,
-0.0303547718,
0.0495149717,
-0.0366086438,
-0.049708616,
-0.0586132817,
-0.0417994559,
0.0326313302,
0.0131366188,
0.0210341439,
-0.0169229023,
-0.0146814231,
0.0239098109,
0.0303114951,
-0.0683368519,
0.03675979,
0.0207186695,
0.0439530127,
0.0560748689,
-0.0504636131,
0.001889327,
0.0724977925,
-0.0489718132,
-0.0113342395,
0.0058913999,
0.0202981476,
0.0120098563,
0.049128022,
0.0188981984,
0.0759303197,
0.0138750095,
-0.0268276762,
-0.050200142,
0.0402402356,
0.026778426,
0.061938379,
0.0131814927,
-0.0009333863,
-0.008417502,
0.0032513635,
-0.0291544646,
0.0224381145,
-0.0065379464,
-0.0320712216,
0.011680807,
0.0422880836,
-0.0084645199,
-0.0111478921,
0.0177976228,
-0.023197148,
-0.0186016746,
0.0370784178,
-0.0155526558,
0.0122387912,
0.0304228254,
0.019401839,
-0.0539146625,
-0.0411710367,
0.0359316021,
-0.0065089613,
-0.0347242057,
0.0170373842,
0.0546530858,
0.038203679,
-0.0399848819,
0.0264603049,
-0.0286692865,
0.0176685415,
-0.0152789457,
0.0101752505,
0.0096948296,
0.0444902927,
-0.0103909429,
0.0309922602,
0.0257487856,
-0.0030237148,
-0.0162074305,
-0.0194077697,
0.0170299821,
0.0406590924,
-0.0177870113,
-0.0171139743,
-0.0241116956,
-0.0065148366,
0.0206477791,
-0.0350966603,
0.0236204658,
0.0214257948,
2.869e-7,
0.0643702373,
0.0322250351,
-0.0089149969,
-0.0013976125,
0.0324269943,
-0.0097758044,
-0.0412927344,
0.0250102635,
0.0100483075,
-0.0469454564,
0.0088337781,
0.0422202609,
0.0490631014,
0.0371266231,
-0.1154837161,
-0.0259410571,
-0.0359650478,
-0.0347735621,
-0.0636878908,
-0.0156564973,
0.0310861375,
0.0742785707,
0.0210696533,
-0.0246130601,
-0.0223773792,
-0.0713013038,
0.0723954439,
-0.0503095649,
-0.0116907861,
0.0196301043,
0.0829868466,
0.0528880358,
-0.0150322122,
-0.0021566055,
-0.0447656028,
0.0142041976,
-0.0242817681,
0.0665519685,
0.0350511931,
-0.0298113339,
-0.0061222427,
-0.0370025896,
0.0146937473,
-0.0456757098,
0.0603152066,
-0.0342452079,
0.0470964089,
-0.0136047425,
-0.0315526128,
0.0031703131,
0.0019718737,
-0.0444089808,
-0.0204336196,
0.031933561,
0.0041340743,
-0.0000438858,
-0.0377573296,
-0.0881058276,
-0.0375221632,
0.0034243553,
-0.0565491728,
-0.0662059858,
-0.0220625997,
-0.0483277477,
0.0088927997,
-0.0951558426,
0.0242607985,
2.733453237e-34,
0.0293594655,
0.0260810517,
-0.0462614223,
0.0386818461,
0.0129896291,
-0.016645059,
-0.024199862,
0.0089653702,
0.0142535716,
-0.0543237701,
-0.0016174285
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.09941v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.09941v4 | "I'm fully who I am": Towards Centering Transgender and Non-Binary Voices to Measure Biases in Open Language Generation | 2023-05-17T04:21:45 | 2023-06-01T20:42:13 | Anaelia Ovalle, Palash Goyal, Jwala Dhamala, Zachary Jaggers, Kai-Wei Chang, Aram Galstyan, Richard Zemel, Rahul Gupta | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG, I.2; I.7; K.4 | Transgender and non-binary (TGNB) individuals disproportionately experience
discrimination and exclusion from daily life. Given the recent popularity and
adoption of language generation technologies, the potential to further
marginalize this population only grows. Although a multitude of NLP fairness
literature focuses on illuminating and addressing gender biases, assessing
gender harms for TGNB identities requires understanding how such identities
uniquely interact with societal gender norms and how they differ from gender
binary-centric perspectives. Such measurement frameworks inherently require
centering TGNB voices to help guide the alignment between gender-inclusive NLP
and whom they are intended to serve. Towards this goal, we ground our work in
the TGNB community and existing interdisciplinary literature to assess how the
social reality surrounding experienced marginalization of TGNB persons
contributes to and persists within Open Language Generation (OLG). This social
knowledge serves as a guide for evaluating popular large language models (LLMs)
on two key aspects: (1) misgendering and (2) harmful responses to gender
disclosure. To do this, we introduce TANGO, a dataset of template-based
real-world text curated from a TGNB-oriented community. We discover a dominance
of binary gender norms reflected by the models; LLMs least misgendered subjects
in generated text when triggered by prompts whose subjects used binary
pronouns. Meanwhile, misgendering was most prevalent when triggering generation
with singular they and neopronouns. When prompted with gender disclosures, TGNB
disclosure generated the most stigmatizing language and scored most toxic, on
average. Our findings warrant further research on how TGNB harms manifest in
LLMs and serve as a broader case study toward concretely grounding the design
of gender-inclusive AI in community voices and interdisciplinary literature. | [
0.0440362804,
0.0452844575,
-0.0117339902,
-0.010585539,
-0.0003081184,
0.0005287435,
0.0593779832,
-0.0284644458,
-0.0044857259,
-0.0613000691,
0.0186614394,
-0.0596083812,
-0.0009571716,
0.0181782283,
0.0269968547,
0.004876087,
-0.0054538888,
0.0544392839,
0.0076914271,
-0.0137828961,
0.0252949391,
0.0723156556,
0.0200061705,
0.1010779142,
0.0160050523,
-0.024624493,
0.0387949422,
0.0314321518,
-0.0017446522,
0.0019992983,
0.0457523353,
0.0480148718,
-0.0191738047,
0.0435998328,
0.0000020125,
-0.074816063,
0.0094551239,
0.0355683379,
-0.0026731982,
-0.0112549495,
0.0239807703,
-0.0047844364,
-0.0113331722,
0.0590062365,
-0.0108608138,
-0.0367437974,
0.0574826449,
-0.007529323,
0.0240123775,
-0.0036286053,
-0.0097447829,
0.018630879,
-0.0290570296,
-0.0091964277,
0.0179313943,
0.04165297,
0.0011286319,
-0.0721147209,
-0.0400093794,
-0.02488029,
0.017368326,
0.0247568171,
0.0056452788,
-0.0193687826,
0.022045318,
0.0056053749,
0.0048598805,
-0.0789942741,
0.0342630111,
0.0548144318,
0.0663994625,
0.0094279125,
0.0289828479,
0.0261894241,
0.0072175423,
-0.0041513611,
-0.0303559639,
0.0814016685,
-0.00634052,
-0.0266733114,
-0.037645191,
-0.0443494283,
0.018492505,
0.0539714471,
0.0141389836,
0.0849266946,
0.018976232,
0.0164608508,
-0.0107305301,
-0.017206775,
-0.0148884971,
-0.0605405122,
0.0123298289,
0.0203613564,
-0.029322179,
0.0289483946,
-0.0219925921,
-0.052045323,
0.0385662951,
-0.0090167196,
0.039411854,
0.0623545535,
-0.0071812901,
-0.0381656662,
-0.0091106156,
0.0314755216,
0.0104126465,
0.0227298513,
0.0065975185,
-0.0002972215,
0.0335867591,
-0.045150429,
-0.0112559358,
-0.0184319466,
-0.0276415702,
0.0638659969,
-0.0146419369,
0.0036968598,
-0.0454025976,
0.0058690901,
-0.0020535768,
0.049800247,
-0.0145205399,
0.016694827,
0.0173706934,
-0.001408429,
-0.0381027833,
0.0097158132,
0.0090522841,
-0.077963613,
0.0379309766,
-0.0028714193,
0.0102660106,
-0.0243802927,
-0.0223159622,
0.0112522775,
0.0083634565,
-0.0364056379,
-0.0070592538,
-0.0590776764,
-0.055266764,
-0.0317634046,
-0.016626237,
-0.0643395185,
0.0001358467,
0.0590481199,
-0.0135010527,
-0.0820702612,
0.0162699576,
0.0203430578,
0.0073312088,
0.0292617083,
0.0361182019,
-0.0067996201,
0.0802950561,
0.0443979912,
0.0307103433,
0.0641343668,
0.0567878075,
-0.0215700511,
0.0305983871,
-0.0147938943,
-0.0284935962,
0.0187278017,
0.034702912,
0.0260322485,
-0.0348345488,
0.0209541675,
0.0090165054,
0.0313579626,
0.0563122295,
0.0447556823,
0.0078248112,
-0.0138452277,
0.0437113494,
0.0575820804,
0.0001672468,
0.0353551246,
0.0471507795,
0.0291639026,
-0.0573198646,
-0.0247994643,
-0.0370710045,
-0.0219353978,
-0.0109095918,
-0.0390073992,
0.0132357543,
0.0290312003,
-0.021710122,
-0.0313759334,
-0.0432070419,
0.0145878019,
0.0414657444,
0.0066901841,
-0.0272302572,
0.0319850482,
0.0111741563,
0.0856821314,
0.0254842658,
-0.1037109941,
0.0328534059,
-0.0544792973,
0.0161320958,
0.0134665407,
0.0313193873,
-0.0144057665,
0.0080069387,
-0.0676820427,
-0.0245447755,
0.0350464508,
0.0403901525,
0.0350793079,
-0.0260251351,
-0.0076945052,
-0.0033622251,
0.0434783399,
0.0157230664,
0.0121350503,
0.0428910963,
0.0249729697,
0.0303541683,
-0.0250279233,
-0.0599928498,
0.0391489081,
-0.0108088804,
-0.0662823692,
0.0355161652,
0.0048552444,
0.0078967223,
0.0332550369,
-0.0410222188,
0.011531475,
-0.0155502651,
0.0186273828,
-0.0490411408,
0.0253483634,
-0.0300787557,
0.0261597633,
0.011002304,
-0.0346412212,
-0.0193292052,
0.0515463911,
0.0039633047,
0.0189937204,
0.078400813,
-0.0209829751,
-0.0127048558,
-0.0249505006,
-0.040432509,
-0.0079673361,
-0.0026186858,
-0.042279575,
0.0007896429,
-0.0331323333,
0.026400445,
-0.0255249515,
-0.0481290631,
0.0021412652,
-0.0202143509,
-0.0460508764,
0.0214411877,
-0.0576425083,
0.0233244915,
0.0359486826,
-0.0123408884,
-0.005066507,
-0.0413081124,
-0.071703434,
-0.030211702,
-0.0163949206,
-0.0209248997,
-0.0069548618,
0.0152293406,
-0.0328581966,
0.036740575,
-0.0180411227,
-0.0470397472,
0.0391324647,
0.0034937654,
0.014814063,
-0.0165903959,
0.0040404126,
-0.0172903333,
-0.016382074,
-0.0348120667,
0.0532830358,
0.0211743433,
0.0126443449,
0.0006547973,
-0.0154771674,
-0.0372447111,
-0.0451263711,
0.0137791866,
-0.0137462905,
0.0503120683,
0.0379986912,
0.0820078328,
0.016443627,
0.0546063706,
0.0411920026,
0.0404698737,
0.0234550852,
-0.0462194495,
-0.0212651342,
0.0154388407,
-0.0343560763,
0.0156619512,
-0.0896049663,
-0.0051032091,
-0.0044494746,
0.0566648953,
-0.0370196253,
-0.0511176102,
0.0420894958,
-0.0853174925,
-0.0386082828,
-0.0243506972,
-0.0490535311,
-0.0310033169,
0.0073894132,
-0.0190042593,
-0.0238363836,
0.0206898563,
0.0113288565,
-0.0301869251,
-0.0028661073,
-0.0040740254,
-0.0252109505,
0.0601389259,
-0.0371155106,
0.0645468608,
0.0584806874,
-0.03941245,
-0.0411984921,
-0.040404059,
0.0135322297,
-0.0487374142,
0.0323134288,
-0.0429015085,
0.0234515928,
0.0040251282,
-0.0097042434,
-0.0434517078,
-0.0325291418,
0.0057674777,
-0.0022362622,
0.0099477293,
-0.0190820247,
0.0231245942,
-0.0026108085,
0.0003547804,
0.014493213,
-0.0183481369,
-0.0176387038,
0.0011275138,
0.0071263402,
-0.0144893602,
-0.0125911422,
0.0700212941,
-0.008757703,
-0.0241490714,
0.0394107848,
0.0210418645,
0.0490798838,
0.0211502798,
-0.0204587784,
0.0373422913,
-0.024643071,
0.0078106932,
-0.0156321842,
0.0653765798,
-0.0253603272,
-0.0076973331,
0.0698992312,
0.0197189227,
-0.0024691878,
0.019672012,
-0.0055377735,
0.070331119,
0.0231739897,
-0.0072242967,
-0.1078792214,
0.0425321013,
0.0038155611,
0.0580218658,
-0.0918617845,
-0.0413907282,
-0.0243978351,
-0.0954625756,
0.0180917289,
-0.0110112624,
-0.0011942023,
-0.0079348041,
-0.0067163934,
0.0243658684,
0.0139562609,
0.0245286915,
-0.0102255922,
-0.004530902,
0.0094267251,
0.0123544242,
-0.0695094541,
-0.0250063259,
-0.0136086447,
-0.0617732406,
0.0406846739,
-0.009377961,
0.0604573674,
-0.0131397927,
0.0036826546,
0.0437481217,
-0.006330925,
-0.0277421959,
-0.038473621,
-0.0109897619,
0.0075612315,
-0.0170730706,
-0.0600167923,
0.0549628362,
-0.0068954392,
0.005542323,
-0.0155029017,
-0.0188772418,
0.01994697,
-0.0303187408,
-0.03502772,
0.0339411721,
-0.0025367776,
0.0744328573,
0.0469950289,
-0.0439418219,
0.0240006726,
-0.0657602549,
0.0573274121,
0.0139859822,
-0.0903328136,
-0.048102323,
0.0522580631,
-0.0188573748,
-0.0477827378,
-0.0530727766,
0.025122812,
-0.0172125995,
0.02795613,
-0.0904470533,
-0.0416150279,
-0.017223563,
-0.0419161618,
0.0304700099,
-0.0219392329,
0.0328818001,
0.0221593436,
-0.0037532458,
-0.0368819498,
-0.0070964061,
-0.0324604847,
0.048839651,
-0.0049221711,
-0.0564418435,
0.0681803524,
0.0010151077,
0.020514464,
0.0007449804,
0.0012955137,
-0.0635185763,
0.0431242511,
0.0730237886,
-0.0116748801,
0.0277360715,
0.0086459927,
0.0035096041,
-0.012132002,
0.0265156236,
0.0018345411,
-0.0172496084,
-0.0041873576,
-0.0124939419,
-0.0063691791,
-0.0494634286,
-0.001643275,
-0.0014253376,
-0.0120398821,
-0.0781910047,
0.039045874,
-0.0414171629,
-0.0699222982,
-0.0225619171,
-0.0333348773,
-0.0085374927,
-0.0409730077,
0.0258854534,
0.030617075,
-0.023506796,
0.0116487788,
-0.0471709445,
0.0526370481,
-0.0331183076,
0.0183327459,
-0.0037671691,
0.0785870403,
-0.021751184,
-0.0063516409,
-0.0066640815,
0.002643405,
-0.0697427318,
0.0060903402,
0.0233204123,
0.0345623158,
0.0004814191,
0.0277721938,
0.0286376067,
-0.012519083,
-0.0020726109,
-0.0460314415,
-0.0246612243,
-0.0305371955,
-0.0042697242,
0.0091515146,
0.0429095477,
-0.0149173932,
-0.0116273891,
-0.0151054319,
-0.0061593843,
0.0038817655,
-0.0163555946,
0.0120677138,
-0.0085233124,
-0.0039909836,
-0.0405797586,
0.0041663754,
0.0682433769,
0.0474575385,
-0.0031961289,
0.0038179117,
-0.0021703206,
-0.0262532942,
-0.0196602419,
-0.025819134,
-0.0095775332,
0.0214110799,
-0.1088046953,
-0.0326548256,
0.0187802631,
-0.0112430947,
0.0342607312,
-0.0306729805,
0.0012147558,
0.0469350554,
-0.0152974445,
-0.0632859692,
-0.032438755,
0.01292706,
-0.0076789279,
-0.022467345,
0.0006332636,
-5.979597234e-33,
-0.0525359251,
-0.0596008226,
-0.0207464639,
-0.011455101,
-0.0546721891,
-0.0114290463,
-0.0128903994,
0.0119798165,
0.0260192454,
-0.0015116,
0.0137527492,
0.0306684207,
0.0105056036,
0.0326012671,
0.0015453094,
-0.0136105511,
0.054175932,
-0.0198709182,
-0.0444088168,
0.0030641332,
-0.0062680827,
0.003765452,
-0.0074978615,
-0.0744393915,
0.1195709333,
-0.0030861264,
-0.0255425405,
-0.0181494877,
-0.0087554138,
-0.0193055589,
-0.0156519841,
0.0729572251,
-0.0095850751,
0.0146381026,
0.0482192189,
0.1185639873,
-0.0472166017,
0.0059285038,
0.010432126,
-0.0029440294,
0.016605461,
-0.0398615934,
0.035562627,
-0.005052059,
-0.0480690189,
-0.0279380493,
0.0476648174,
0.0263344478,
0.0680618212,
0.0007653791,
-0.0385204554,
0.0083373347,
-0.041715689,
0.0038819886,
-0.0246379487,
0.0575827174,
0.0035022821,
-0.0283369813,
-0.0792679936,
0.0019930534,
-0.0177568663,
-0.0184808839,
0.0285222474,
0.0084185405,
0.0334897377,
0.029417295,
0.0296746772,
0.0264219269,
-0.0369331986,
-0.0182294361,
0.0543012843,
-0.0274546091,
0.0346180275,
0.0454061143,
-0.0237633381,
-0.0442823842,
-0.0104403645,
-0.0170216225,
-0.0014618565,
-0.0226983856,
0.0535742491,
-0.0529775806,
-0.0352473445,
-0.0500505716,
-0.0648446083,
-0.1062321663,
-0.0045236154,
-0.0069362368,
0.0131162563,
-0.0184645262,
-0.0959119201,
-0.0222409163,
-0.0130276158,
-0.0131293572,
-0.0578868687,
-0.0026706429,
-0.0002456363,
-0.0247410741,
0.0253393799,
0.03165254,
-0.0318283141,
0.0237488579,
-0.0003197098,
0.0199353769,
0.0277811587,
0.0253619999,
-0.0248559061,
0.0317897424,
-0.0697837099,
0.0009102657,
-0.0155823994,
0.0595156141,
-0.0257659983,
0.0237595513,
0.035044156,
0.0392404683,
-0.0094487425,
0.0014316351,
0.0728233531,
0.0540207513,
-0.0419439971,
-0.0042687962,
-0.0366808772,
0.0264006592,
-0.0175625551,
-0.0093689999,
-0.00407054,
0.0565198734,
0.106478028,
0.0126307709,
-0.0123245623,
-0.0818426833,
2.624e-7,
0.015162318,
0.0232602954,
0.0026343225,
0.0404505022,
0.0059177172,
0.0248611048,
0.0591805503,
0.0530771986,
0.0766066685,
-0.0144021465,
-0.052621536,
0.0315415487,
0.0001761548,
0.0116203483,
-0.0103455065,
0.0187479742,
-0.0423093624,
0.0383051112,
-0.0258580763,
0.013064702,
0.000311379,
0.0387824737,
0.0500157177,
-0.007272834,
-0.028792629,
-0.0087404754,
0.0397005789,
-0.0107348021,
0.0210931879,
0.0100847911,
0.0563269109,
-0.0008775573,
0.0685914606,
-0.045603767,
0.0204269588,
-0.0038870156,
0.0005652634,
-0.0055694631,
0.0211090073,
0.0210769363,
0.0177876111,
0.0156595372,
-0.0198859461,
-0.0754582509,
0.0454841591,
-0.0151597764,
0.0179963168,
-0.0310152676,
-0.0373077095,
-0.0312341414,
0.0647739768,
-0.0524342582,
-0.0570118837,
0.0296012238,
0.0130408192,
-0.0077359956,
0.0447417535,
-0.0804614499,
-0.0489674844,
-0.0133694522,
-0.0088440478,
-0.0201269723,
-0.002434985,
0.0493598692,
-0.0517288893,
-0.0038395543,
0.0429019406,
2.291568381e-34,
-0.0115200691,
0.0447085649,
-0.016912248,
-0.0348672494,
0.0417287424,
0.0271228626,
0.0235020202,
-0.0238335207,
0.0223922171,
0.0139461812,
0.0043453579
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.09900v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.09900v2 | Efficient Equivariant Transfer Learning from Pretrained Models | 2023-05-17T02:20:34 | 2023-10-10T19:01:41 | Sourya Basu, Pulkit Katdare, Prasanna Sattigeri, Vijil Chenthamarakshan, Katherine Driggs-Campbell, Payel Das, Lav R. Varshney | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | Efficient transfer learning algorithms are key to the success of foundation
models on diverse downstream tasks even with limited data. Recent works of Basu
et al. (2023) and Kaba et al. (2022) propose group averaging (equitune) and
optimization-based methods, respectively, over features from group-transformed
inputs to obtain equivariant outputs from non-equivariant neural networks.
While Kaba et al. (2022) are only concerned with training from scratch, we find
that equitune performs poorly on equivariant zero-shot tasks despite good
finetuning results. We hypothesize that this is because pretrained models
provide better quality features for certain transformations than others and
simply averaging them is deleterious. Hence, we propose {\lambda}-equitune that
averages the features using importance weights, {\lambda}s. These weights are
learned directly from the data using a small neural network, leading to
excellent zero-shot and finetuned results that outperform equitune. Further, we
prove that {\lambda}-equitune is equivariant and a universal approximator of
equivariant functions. Additionally, we show that the method of Kaba et al.
(2022) used with appropriate loss functions, which we call equizero, also gives
excellent zero-shot and finetuned performance. Both equitune and equizero are
special cases of {\lambda}-equitune. To show the simplicity and generality of
our method, we validate on a wide range of diverse applications and models such
as 1) image classification using CLIP, 2) deep Q-learning, 3) fairness in
natural language generation (NLG), 4) compositional generalization in
languages, and 5) image classification using pretrained CNNs such as Resnet and
Alexnet. | [
-0.020835707,
0.1060319096,
-0.0126276696,
0.0250004698,
0.021310512,
0.0270580389,
0.0664936602,
-0.0373191386,
-0.0906923786,
-0.0295173544,
-0.0607868917,
0.0063359356,
-0.0084867673,
0.0187258516,
0.0083620101,
-0.0636930019,
-0.0069225738,
0.0419999287,
-0.0374040864,
-0.0340603217,
-0.0046733888,
0.0146560417,
-0.0251849201,
0.0173687935,
-0.0006455132,
0.0397081003,
0.0155609054,
0.0113381706,
0.0510675646,
0.0125538483,
0.0533060841,
0.0599205568,
-0.0273516644,
0.0028992535,
0.000002588,
-0.0281866062,
0.0048986939,
0.0022737288,
-0.0074998559,
0.0139592057,
0.0175511781,
-0.01940904,
-0.0078232354,
-0.0182334054,
-0.0277366694,
-0.0364299342,
0.0635392591,
0.0105860224,
0.0193452835,
0.0368593968,
-0.0330558755,
-0.0352102034,
-0.0556386933,
-0.0490740277,
0.0121103963,
-0.0624904968,
0.0350453965,
-0.0441388302,
-0.0526880361,
-0.0396839119,
-0.0436212458,
-0.0067851664,
0.0197953191,
0.0044943886,
0.0317100473,
0.0207731593,
-0.0624333099,
0.0138956122,
-0.000896949,
0.0896888301,
-0.0667696893,
-0.0051305336,
0.0061044437,
-0.0401956402,
0.0047047329,
0.0087646879,
-0.0667800084,
-0.0025509971,
0.0371573567,
0.0215224028,
-0.042265784,
0.0531295016,
0.0191424545,
0.0109493071,
-0.0392130353,
-0.0249949433,
0.023663478,
0.0851128623,
0.0185204279,
0.0579137616,
-0.0739252791,
-0.0328841545,
-0.0243929531,
0.021864567,
-0.0051908735,
-0.0541327409,
-0.0570674203,
-0.0273443591,
-0.0205326099,
0.0068458524,
0.0604121014,
0.0195336118,
-0.017040085,
0.0479355529,
-0.0386847965,
0.0230791997,
-0.0174532458,
0.0900656134,
-0.0359553918,
-0.0350179598,
-0.0290120114,
0.0269243978,
-0.0218865033,
0.040959429,
0.01180497,
-0.0089863697,
-0.0398768075,
-0.0066802171,
-0.0377911516,
-0.0558682792,
0.0141974548,
0.0227899812,
-0.0332660675,
-0.0262439549,
0.0229563452,
0.054857403,
-0.0154847344,
0.0797864571,
-0.0198995844,
-0.0669535846,
-0.0158874001,
0.0196160041,
0.0063600307,
-0.0349381492,
0.0407269821,
0.0277483594,
-0.0104357852,
-0.0209539086,
-0.0087203737,
0.0395995267,
-0.0024363962,
-0.0215888601,
0.0262748264,
-0.058723215,
0.033577092,
-0.0088541787,
0.0100477403,
-0.0344620422,
-0.0259898864,
-0.0130240796,
-0.0649814755,
0.0661548898,
0.0771866962,
-0.0099425223,
0.0047247619,
-0.0313982144,
-0.0546557158,
0.0501041189,
0.0416311175,
0.0171949398,
-0.0378549956,
-0.0120948786,
0.0140169244,
0.0259142667,
0.0336230248,
0.0287446994,
-0.0084689623,
-0.0659620911,
-0.037737146,
-0.0362095796,
0.0823864341,
-0.0172082726,
-0.0311719682,
-0.0580906644,
0.040805731,
0.0135753946,
-0.0089612277,
0.037527822,
0.0328556709,
-0.0045361519,
-0.0358293541,
-0.0103215184,
-0.0864119977,
0.055078283,
0.0001816176,
-0.057019297,
-0.0288223661,
0.0474503934,
-0.0761981905,
0.0042440197,
0.0677224174,
-0.0176108219,
0.0083599342,
-0.0208375584,
0.0734064057,
0.0149884941,
-0.020592602,
0.0129740881,
0.0109858094,
0.0038939205,
0.0240662768,
-0.0296193715,
0.0137601951,
-0.0425522961,
-0.0039368556,
-0.0251298677,
-0.0423698872,
0.0130331693,
0.0056395489,
-0.0284592379,
0.0445966013,
0.0150978407,
0.0431029536,
-0.0129095707,
-0.0579769425,
-0.022141153,
0.0314279869,
0.0273673497,
-0.0303162076,
0.0506549217,
0.0295529664,
-0.0107418299,
0.0067171585,
0.0401979722,
-0.0081388075,
-0.0303420387,
0.0626881793,
0.0345665365,
0.0093438486,
-0.0198622774,
-0.0236800499,
-0.0066771097,
0.0002068671,
-0.0485390238,
-0.0167171992,
0.0247916579,
-0.0389901586,
-0.0151288621,
0.0231734272,
-0.049051147,
0.0587509349,
0.0401434675,
-0.061072614,
-0.0313956626,
0.0568456762,
0.0502667241,
-0.0125753265,
-0.0207362194,
0.0029776266,
0.0009891803,
0.0439794064,
-0.0148698296,
0.0013193751,
0.0417742394,
-0.040419247,
-0.0147978188,
-0.0366722383,
-0.0030201513,
-0.040567182,
-0.0114118727,
0.0090546571,
-0.0011176522,
0.0118301995,
0.0219183471,
0.0051896418,
0.0360986888,
0.0203288868,
-0.0521947145,
0.0332931019,
-0.0050603976,
0.0267998986,
0.0360787697,
0.0083906595,
0.0002788971,
-0.025902519,
-0.0300689153,
0.0213035997,
-0.0012274123,
-0.0161686726,
0.0352623127,
0.0081400787,
0.0022491957,
-0.0022427216,
-0.0459942631,
0.0162945893,
0.0489147343,
-0.005948443,
0.006599505,
0.0156676434,
-0.0054853237,
0.0068260143,
0.0247729793,
0.0050044991,
-0.0321094133,
-0.045254726,
-0.0065351236,
-0.0717099383,
0.1053298786,
0.0203794241,
-0.0052434169,
-0.0098664248,
0.0322969966,
-0.0215556473,
-0.0149942879,
-0.0476443022,
-0.0209682062,
0.0312382206,
0.0098091755,
0.0034079484,
0.0315714739,
-0.0499505512,
-0.0411720984,
-0.0728020221,
0.0471137166,
0.0235767346,
-0.008222118,
-0.0434291996,
0.0347156636,
0.0354374982,
-0.0679866001,
-0.0420226827,
-0.017252041,
-0.0040789726,
0.0169155635,
0.0186552145,
0.001996957,
0.010652557,
-0.0162300915,
-0.0153624117,
0.0016562619,
0.0062255664,
-0.0105223311,
-0.0117071932,
-0.0806026459,
-0.0123848682,
0.0372945033,
-0.0196761116,
0.0120531898,
-0.0243817903,
0.0287463572,
-0.028831305,
-0.0605585873,
-0.0255618636,
-0.0382249914,
-0.0096535059,
0.0298863836,
-0.0366367176,
-0.0414385386,
-0.0423414484,
-0.0130425245,
-0.0142801693,
0.0561352074,
-0.0425221063,
0.0275295246,
0.0059611164,
0.0310178939,
-0.0176065024,
0.0208605677,
0.0089290952,
-0.0385039039,
0.0134569155,
0.041291967,
0.0283405352,
0.0469021536,
-0.0356982872,
0.040026743,
0.0079626646,
-0.0034106092,
-0.0292562731,
-0.0104154376,
0.0620098226,
-0.016983375,
0.0430240482,
0.0205144323,
-0.0474284254,
-0.0473802648,
-0.0040319408,
0.0259866212,
-0.0114487475,
0.0043918472,
0.0140623646,
-0.0534916036,
-0.0614730567,
0.0073855459,
0.0351078883,
0.0454218052,
-0.0332535431,
0.0094835591,
-0.0617763326,
0.0071830289,
0.04232556,
-0.0786681473,
-0.0213341564,
0.0457994156,
0.0687323585,
-0.0651367903,
-0.0221987423,
-0.0517605022,
-0.0200258438,
-0.0129554784,
0.0265507177,
0.003838822,
-0.0282947067,
0.0215541814,
-0.0711445138,
-0.0048440918,
0.0539851785,
0.006061519,
-0.0123953111,
-0.0269802567,
0.0101342592,
-0.0459289216,
-0.0644365847,
0.0442119576,
0.0583367236,
-0.0355608761,
-0.0238191132,
0.0401585773,
0.0612453893,
-0.002568993,
0.0115967533,
-0.0225130133,
0.0011949959,
0.0014290177,
-0.0318923928,
-0.0267919786,
-0.050020054,
-0.0118827987,
0.044911515,
0.0122521389,
-0.0224528648,
-0.0523824692,
0.0189574342,
-0.0397097655,
-0.0307710394,
-0.0440932699,
0.0393144637,
0.0001085208,
-0.0504443012,
-0.0544294976,
0.012181689,
0.0384538583,
0.025193518,
-0.0173173212,
-0.0778634623,
0.0209970586,
-0.0195400864,
-0.018588569,
0.0218037944,
-0.0340994485,
0.0413065553,
-0.0369043201,
0.0084103271,
0.040463984,
-0.0223772302,
-0.0154621564,
-0.0492772646,
-0.0476495102,
-0.011588295,
-0.0297168382,
0.0657352731,
0.0009429093,
0.0144512709,
-0.0646891966,
0.0033395495,
0.0772727951,
0.0802400857,
0.0374459848,
0.0329280719,
0.0473049805,
-0.0807688683,
0.0074896459,
0.0432781801,
-0.0168716852,
0.0741534606,
0.0302212723,
-0.0249606334,
0.0163375121,
-0.0361137055,
-0.0096345777,
-0.009627928,
0.0578519627,
0.0249011908,
0.0210569073,
-0.0203518271,
-0.0061109411,
0.0534977503,
0.0216052141,
-0.0675499737,
-0.0301951524,
-0.0007709863,
0.0497329608,
-0.018822886,
-0.0153693883,
0.0339512117,
0.0267367437,
-0.0525764935,
-0.0128829041,
-0.0442828685,
0.0030120015,
-0.0279676542,
0.0455465056,
0.0253771413,
0.0066257794,
0.034490861,
0.0571046472,
-0.0427929834,
-0.0146089885,
0.0628478006,
0.0644946024,
-0.0570522435,
0.0285616554,
-0.0357092321,
-0.0748507828,
-0.0664096922,
0.0042129266,
0.0572325327,
-0.0503389947,
0.0344157219,
0.0019536789,
-0.0239412729,
-0.0485795029,
0.0294573791,
0.0023864268,
0.0633033663,
0.0431231707,
0.0063168244,
0.0235084239,
0.0030791105,
0.0590350367,
-0.0083713504,
0.0311565381,
-0.005651277,
0.0335837081,
-0.0031369384,
0.009380416,
0.050876487,
-0.0362086967,
0.0032706719,
-0.0023639135,
-0.0245360807,
-0.0258220546,
-0.0009139787,
-0.0447592065,
0.0157350246,
0.0279650651,
0.0351641439,
-0.0064278957,
-0.0407186747,
-0.0523492731,
-0.0149639631,
-0.0348996855,
0.0054421904,
0.0069433236,
0.0487962849,
-6.703930975e-33,
0.0001528726,
0.0388307385,
-0.0004390198,
0.0295231845,
-0.0203491766,
-0.0170930102,
0.0109414104,
-0.0361154824,
-0.0260460004,
0.0449689478,
-0.0324611217,
0.0049180975,
0.0106589803,
0.0133545613,
-0.000097782,
-0.0290978476,
0.0654913336,
-0.0131717231,
-0.0343015902,
0.0547748245,
-0.0030940238,
0.0299663227,
0.0471583493,
-0.0577117801,
-0.089799352,
0.0052872025,
-0.0205764603,
-0.0008362522,
0.0154016186,
-0.0159599632,
0.0204520132,
-0.0299283732,
0.0132669583,
-0.0350715891,
-0.0426895954,
-0.0168628469,
-0.0542620197,
-0.010201674,
-0.077535674,
0.026486028,
-0.0065427036,
-0.0066954759,
0.0424736887,
0.0114774145,
0.0107657826,
-0.0621099882,
0.0228234604,
-0.0213321578,
0.0102145215,
-0.0058400785,
-0.0113296146,
0.0319557413,
-0.023628613,
-0.0474337935,
0.0246737413,
0.0217630602,
-0.0115130506,
0.0384354182,
-0.0144273648,
-0.0071826139,
-0.0222797748,
0.0045228782,
0.0233232975,
0.0352666005,
0.0269703101,
0.0205527041,
0.0294419564,
-0.0459344126,
-0.043634899,
-0.0266397949,
0.0502346531,
0.0283759814,
0.0007681708,
0.0354450122,
0.129155606,
-0.0113541614,
-0.0718758777,
0.0481069833,
-0.0496307313,
0.0598371997,
-0.0086194975,
0.0171054788,
0.0231230427,
-0.0233818442,
-0.0063614203,
-0.0375180021,
0.0117322933,
0.0079788323,
0.0076885209,
0.0079456475,
-0.0665731132,
0.0382353477,
0.0247156546,
-0.0404862016,
-0.0222517624,
0.0511550792,
-0.0219624024,
0.0254989062,
0.0057226913,
-0.0165089797,
-0.0480669625,
-0.0535942838,
0.0182864778,
0.0015281666,
0.0164920576,
0.0286080521,
0.0376607478,
0.058280088,
-0.009368985,
-0.027866615,
-0.0198378097,
0.0232346859,
0.033657413,
0.0656000748,
0.0134780994,
0.0301668514,
0.0017397316,
0.0364039652,
-0.020978814,
-0.0300103948,
-0.0083074141,
0.0026877797,
0.0537182651,
0.0442862585,
-0.0199567787,
-0.0329027176,
-0.0351319797,
-0.0231658965,
0.0041397586,
-0.0757553354,
-0.0220283475,
-0.0060794451,
3.299e-7,
0.0325844213,
-0.0523790792,
0.019335717,
-0.0440867878,
-0.0205088574,
0.0627192333,
-0.0161758885,
0.082284376,
0.0086450623,
0.0148789296,
0.0375150777,
0.0990741327,
0.0387367569,
-0.0142758461,
-0.0381132625,
0.016832808,
-0.0319777392,
0.0242512394,
-0.0028602844,
-0.047107961,
-0.0314610712,
0.0475197807,
0.0354299396,
-0.0189747643,
0.063313596,
0.025672311,
0.0412024036,
-0.0016632754,
0.0678639114,
-0.0010192571,
0.0142104607,
-0.0050647077,
-0.0155301737,
0.0712928399,
0.005919381,
0.0631439015,
0.0213595852,
0.0194627251,
-0.0307327881,
0.0005789984,
-0.0528395139,
0.0184744615,
0.0534716919,
-0.0072363974,
0.0652506128,
-0.067145355,
0.0076405122,
-0.0444137752,
-0.0705041438,
0.0238245521,
0.038822867,
0.005047373,
0.0042618061,
0.0378662013,
0.0454323292,
0.0083939433,
-0.021254953,
-0.0568345636,
0.0430237763,
-0.0066532046,
-0.0284431223,
0.0082684094,
-0.0012096135,
-0.0082662255,
0.0450293496,
0.0229958426,
-0.0082817422,
2.54907052e-34,
-0.0303388331,
0.0130470134,
0.0301850811,
0.0041437787,
-0.0465586074,
-0.0034602713,
-0.0427223295,
-0.0238896757,
0.0226543006,
0.0111721344,
-0.0177018624
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.09898v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.09898v1 | Balancing Lexical and Semantic Quality in Abstractive Summarization | 2023-05-17T02:18:31 | 2023-05-17T02:18:31 | Jeewoo Sul, Yong Suk Choi | cs.CL | cs.CL | An important problem of the sequence-to-sequence neural models widely used in
abstractive summarization is exposure bias. To alleviate this problem,
re-ranking systems have been applied in recent years. Despite some performance
improvements, this approach remains underexplored. Previous works have mostly
specified the rank through the ROUGE score and aligned candidate summaries, but
there can be quite a large gap between the lexical overlap metric and semantic
similarity. In this paper, we propose a novel training method in which a
re-ranker balances the lexical and semantic quality. We further newly define
false positives in ranking and present a strategy to reduce their influence.
Experiments on the CNN/DailyMail and XSum datasets show that our method can
estimate the meaning of summaries without seriously degrading the lexical
aspect. More specifically, it achieves an 89.67 BERTScore on the CNN/DailyMail
dataset, reaching new state-of-the-art performance. Our code is publicly
available at https://github.com/jeewoo1025/BalSum. | [
0.0329320244,
0.0364044644,
0.0259854961,
0.018951213,
0.0057491292,
0.0083982404,
-0.0505230054,
-0.0212438814,
-0.016814677,
-0.0351582095,
0.0003853923,
-0.0314371809,
0.0302726012,
0.0144226141,
0.0100126481,
-0.0813546181,
0.0257805735,
0.0272280779,
0.0008837172,
0.0057644825,
0.0318586454,
-0.0051399954,
0.0214469284,
0.0295772329,
0.0229217857,
0.0111225331,
0.0085792933,
0.0101699755,
0.0783820525,
-0.0212597288,
0.006461455,
0.0133457649,
0.0228063483,
0.0377803668,
0.0000017946,
-0.0379062295,
-0.0466351621,
-0.0170800202,
0.0466790199,
0.0188104492,
0.0084803943,
-0.0223511551,
0.0154534159,
0.0199818183,
-0.0052291141,
0.0108707333,
0.0293302312,
0.0537694395,
0.0904617012,
0.0580224171,
-0.0062016225,
-0.0143203838,
0.0312839746,
-0.0516553,
-0.0351322629,
-0.0196283646,
0.0002044023,
0.0216643177,
-0.0522653423,
0.0002588776,
-0.0298522804,
0.0477891341,
0.0195713677,
0.0177589729,
0.0312454123,
0.0408687815,
-0.0794846937,
-0.0016245361,
0.013901731,
0.0653792843,
-0.0424972512,
-0.0050782156,
0.0043185833,
0.0052616759,
0.0290448777,
-0.0223186985,
-0.0482216105,
0.0390176736,
0.0054589612,
0.028689336,
-0.0102298371,
0.0690987855,
0.0030235746,
0.0561098717,
-0.0379314721,
-0.0099888146,
0.0042532091,
-0.028419951,
-0.033221893,
0.0238346513,
-0.0257313326,
-0.0417036787,
0.0444425642,
0.0031050374,
-0.0057280064,
-0.0124391634,
-0.0437253937,
-0.072275199,
0.0128022786,
-0.0548095703,
0.0342348218,
0.0284835603,
0.0127825271,
-0.0049002157,
-0.025376955,
0.041677136,
0.0416615829,
0.0421706438,
-0.0554887615,
0.0127986437,
-0.0153708179,
-0.002204983,
-0.0387868993,
0.058244437,
-0.0286268294,
-0.0218121726,
-0.063405104,
-0.0124379182,
-0.0257482845,
0.0004556649,
-0.018553324,
0.0178315472,
-0.0320905857,
0.0369008295,
-0.0301053766,
0.0006783069,
-0.021020608,
-0.0306333564,
0.042268008,
0.0184272341,
-0.021062322,
-0.0051690429,
0.0204618052,
0.0024886574,
0.0072851847,
0.0209650211,
-0.0247530378,
-0.0315443091,
0.0276734047,
-0.0208016094,
-0.0146183558,
-0.0159137473,
-0.0151655767,
-0.0630203784,
0.0074016061,
-0.0201846678,
0.0163922422,
-0.0005017465,
0.0101056062,
0.0320805237,
-0.0289431345,
0.0329059474,
0.0183723904,
-0.0165524017,
0.0201754291,
0.0253213998,
0.0310926735,
0.0115219643,
0.0480973199,
0.0578822568,
0.0384241119,
0.033601474,
-0.0068188738,
-0.0045300797,
0.0293598045,
-0.0237122085,
0.0338215567,
-0.0229113977,
-0.0592608005,
0.0233230237,
0.0401460603,
0.05633834,
-0.0562817678,
-0.0012170441,
0.0647503808,
0.0249224063,
0.0065547773,
0.0443894975,
0.0233782791,
0.0315680206,
-0.0011755384,
0.0641474575,
-0.011014482,
0.0303867608,
-0.0039582583,
0.0547674112,
0.0929797217,
0.0378549807,
-0.0256650206,
-0.0644634143,
0.022512231,
-0.0079512531,
0.0033259452,
-0.0086376267,
-0.0031304641,
0.0529841669,
-0.047831092,
0.0710604787,
0.0039366758,
-0.057026729,
0.0051687919,
-0.0072066197,
-0.0041162889,
0.0298111644,
0.045817934,
-0.0100555597,
-0.0502088703,
0.0084412405,
-0.0433586203,
0.0501775034,
0.0181426425,
-0.0053204601,
0.0084513221,
-0.0633198395,
-0.0347681679,
-0.0384475067,
-0.0093547245,
0.0054791919,
-0.0070108986,
-0.0148210945,
0.0624782853,
-0.0190871079,
-0.0811742991,
0.0201736856,
-0.0105588501,
-0.0223521981,
0.007159004,
0.0044583636,
0.0383393019,
0.0268476494,
-0.0090059293,
0.0290469751,
0.0167722665,
-0.0460942201,
-0.0383412875,
-0.0042236573,
-0.0603591986,
-0.0676322728,
0.0136329075,
-0.0919939354,
-0.0005519787,
0.0941781029,
-0.072725907,
-0.0397320315,
0.0229358021,
-0.0646106005,
0.0161686335,
-0.0513796657,
0.0092823245,
0.0272545274,
-0.0046137776,
-0.0275508296,
0.086492613,
-0.0388743281,
0.0245841946,
0.048081547,
-0.0281123947,
-0.0042451117,
-0.0559434332,
-0.0400455296,
-0.0126189794,
-0.0122845247,
0.0282286666,
0.0440613553,
0.0094591714,
-0.0334152393,
-0.0046359911,
-0.082413651,
0.0081344126,
-0.0057504843,
0.0053261681,
0.0451512896,
0.0108176973,
0.0276580118,
-0.0133792404,
-0.0576805137,
-0.0377962366,
-0.007118219,
-0.0046825418,
0.0380335115,
0.0134137906,
0.0167752448,
-0.0401812419,
-0.0349447541,
-0.0009168086,
0.0431081392,
-0.0299509093,
-0.0337902382,
-0.0110111861,
0.0287113227,
-0.0595639385,
-0.0319935344,
0.0075673177,
-0.0077453069,
-0.0407500155,
0.0167090632,
-0.0009267163,
0.0128398761,
0.0532963835,
0.0153985694,
0.0413914956,
0.0166385695,
-0.0311245453,
-0.0058984542,
-0.0295823067,
0.0416622125,
0.051784113,
-0.0341662169,
0.0046213232,
0.0548928864,
0.0142716179,
0.0064995345,
-0.0232282523,
0.0078069074,
-0.0281153973,
-0.0158894248,
-0.057079196,
-0.0217459779,
-0.0025420811,
-0.0059846099,
-0.0476708598,
-0.015794944,
0.0844291598,
-0.0101273442,
0.0177916586,
-0.0850169286,
0.0030842179,
-0.0521101542,
0.0146564171,
0.017547423,
0.052892983,
-0.0072988481,
-0.0278947484,
-0.0426581539,
-0.0513801426,
0.0111799072,
-0.0340166576,
0.0608526282,
-0.0018764274,
-0.0032242923,
-0.0396267287,
-0.0417049266,
-0.0165735465,
-0.0449143387,
0.0255745854,
0.0340063199,
-0.0087871142,
0.0065086298,
-0.0566337369,
0.0209242832,
0.0197138377,
0.0781499892,
-0.0333044082,
-0.0204102639,
-0.0212949682,
0.0892625079,
0.062155731,
-0.0180356111,
0.0371179283,
-0.0438464172,
0.0215036757,
0.0405624472,
0.0124087138,
-0.0151777491,
-0.0115766004,
-0.015850421,
-0.0006452159,
-0.0574153475,
0.0296468139,
-0.0144724054,
0.0248519145,
-0.0286782794,
-0.0245918781,
0.0910836086,
0.0165588763,
-0.0203765072,
0.0117988363,
0.0330887772,
0.0612982102,
-0.0062286449,
-0.006831903,
-0.039197389,
-0.0031954483,
-0.0026550374,
0.0196368396,
0.017610874,
-0.012868749,
0.0082472851,
-0.0991631001,
0.0017216214,
0.0139880637,
-0.073784925,
-0.0306923538,
-0.0035623377,
0.0009638352,
-0.0239027422,
0.0348113067,
0.0115564419,
-0.0142289205,
0.0134122092,
0.0072027128,
-0.0363155939,
-0.0119087929,
-0.0206482839,
-0.0463169962,
-0.0210524499,
0.0570913553,
0.062432874,
-0.0256946515,
0.0144820334,
0.0089687454,
-0.0521000326,
-0.0121880546,
0.0297226645,
0.0700583681,
-0.0235448387,
0.0141725717,
-0.0314225927,
0.0112199578,
0.0279703923,
-0.0071001914,
-0.0250132345,
-0.0123490356,
0.0021176536,
-0.0144115807,
-0.0609240197,
0.0394455753,
-0.0278007351,
0.07312949,
0.0329240821,
-0.0130807441,
-0.001400432,
-0.0198602695,
0.0213295966,
-0.0705572516,
-0.0228233915,
0.0082373917,
-0.0382614695,
-0.0292468909,
-0.1112491712,
-0.0666368753,
-0.0221213009,
0.0032331699,
-0.0070806993,
-0.0241322964,
-0.0355704241,
-0.0016031846,
-0.0469026566,
0.028370209,
0.0201947335,
0.0116675468,
-0.0146326581,
-0.0082395617,
0.0434658043,
-0.0299545191,
-0.0533547625,
0.03308082,
-0.0422101095,
-0.030273281,
-0.0379146226,
0.0508365631,
0.0210194327,
0.0744649023,
0.00854271,
-0.0009342561,
0.1120106056,
0.0203925706,
0.0470304936,
0.0186773799,
0.0299388338,
0.0338269472,
-0.009637109,
0.0305139888,
-0.0664303601,
0.0351050906,
-0.0129008405,
0.0716036931,
-0.0113444021,
-0.0312683359,
0.0229855496,
0.0105673987,
0.0275700409,
-0.0440214537,
0.0085282074,
-0.0279918835,
0.0072746309,
-0.0116676558,
-0.0251212101,
-0.0483583957,
0.0329817496,
0.020083053,
0.0118007632,
-0.0194067247,
0.0744674727,
0.0160762686,
0.0080337534,
-0.0419179052,
-0.0241867453,
-0.0294220317,
-0.0334328972,
-0.0618679076,
0.0124329077,
-0.0796874687,
-0.0451803133,
-0.0298907254,
0.0145453289,
-0.0089346375,
-0.0254188981,
0.0436543599,
0.0317954272,
-0.0218953099,
0.096099861,
-0.0937402025,
0.020498924,
-0.090409331,
-0.0139981015,
0.0346376002,
-0.0458045192,
0.0784534067,
0.0201908797,
-0.0079218708,
-0.0114559261,
0.0040347255,
0.0192027595,
-0.0362302475,
-0.0236781519,
0.0142502347,
0.0340819731,
-0.0107132243,
0.0743302926,
-0.0653566271,
0.0036901147,
0.0097620692,
-0.0438053049,
-0.0356211476,
0.0041315323,
0.0170690846,
0.0497705974,
-0.000171053,
-0.0352753662,
-0.0197086688,
-0.0333550014,
0.0402474217,
0.0148731451,
0.0300652217,
-0.0052703531,
0.0644621477,
0.0211275853,
0.0031165085,
-0.0058883051,
-0.0321570523,
-0.0417473689,
-0.0237254146,
-0.0120921573,
-0.0435537882,
-5.911650722e-33,
-0.0524083376,
0.0061596707,
-0.0538770854,
0.0151876044,
-0.0471532755,
0.0565405488,
-0.0628740638,
-0.0262906048,
-0.0117711136,
0.0177862719,
0.0106858546,
0.0189696364,
0.0120220399,
0.0555865057,
-0.0084412675,
0.042494148,
0.0496346019,
0.0380183421,
-0.049510058,
0.0391135179,
0.027698474,
0.0221957304,
0.0542614087,
-0.0204782989,
-0.0129587473,
0.0081146928,
-0.0183430258,
-0.0082244473,
0.0273191165,
0.0377006941,
-0.0010807993,
0.0223252494,
0.0426473022,
-0.0204266179,
-0.0477117673,
0.0121704079,
-0.0616888143,
-0.0446044318,
0.0120464871,
-0.0581203364,
-0.062194366,
-0.0250755269,
0.0620099977,
-0.0246536471,
-0.0124610914,
-0.0539152808,
0.0568624549,
-0.039582748,
-0.0363200009,
-0.0958800986,
-0.0192986168,
0.0241303537,
-0.0251183715,
-0.0447302759,
0.0158252455,
0.0518333949,
0.0065819053,
0.0163409989,
-0.0437406152,
0.0277674813,
0.0169548243,
0.0533692949,
0.0315494463,
0.0285979919,
-0.0266333353,
0.0620296746,
-0.0068889502,
-0.0165745504,
0.0227885321,
0.0093658306,
-0.010507104,
0.0184621941,
0.0343313441,
0.0208525993,
0.0373237692,
0.051099401,
-0.0415582992,
0.0984707326,
-0.028034592,
0.0258306339,
0.0348302126,
0.0146248965,
0.0025412997,
-0.0095923254,
-0.0285537504,
-0.0043606171,
-0.0192225035,
-0.0034549478,
-0.0030982639,
0.0328981616,
-0.0206328854,
0.0328296758,
0.0065892301,
-0.0414976813,
0.0234558564,
0.0088071506,
-0.0112465909,
-0.0006759004,
0.0205018297,
-0.014361579,
-0.0348456688,
0.0180237368,
0.0079496596,
0.0217258073,
-0.0075532529,
-0.0028191004,
0.0871311575,
0.0171015617,
-0.006203454,
0.0163225103,
-0.0042121327,
-0.0174316131,
-0.0559904575,
0.0418419689,
-0.0245487932,
-0.0092316698,
-0.0075461897,
0.0464562103,
0.0153700067,
0.0420072936,
0.0006710298,
0.0366636999,
0.0465674363,
0.043754369,
-0.0156631265,
0.0245617963,
-0.0138889765,
0.0333482549,
0.0368900634,
-0.0573303625,
-0.0320303291,
-0.0214434601,
2.475e-7,
0.0350347012,
0.0042873374,
0.0437882841,
0.0151534742,
-0.0084654829,
0.0291790627,
0.0057371226,
0.0802764148,
0.0249284059,
0.0137767838,
0.0445485748,
-0.0028159271,
0.0337733738,
0.0090221623,
-0.0789890587,
0.0042525711,
-0.1219850034,
-0.0388391279,
-0.0175177474,
-0.0020629102,
0.0637744442,
0.0807010829,
-0.0107854437,
-0.0119643016,
0.0105240149,
-0.0190743357,
0.0435178503,
-0.0066989698,
-0.009348074,
0.0125014996,
0.0264863595,
0.0050511057,
-0.017896371,
-0.0229480322,
-0.0421298854,
0.0106988456,
0.0685917065,
0.0111077065,
-0.0258387793,
-0.0299670324,
0.0199151151,
-0.0092680082,
0.0207129624,
-0.0394438244,
0.0300406683,
-0.0567219034,
-0.0259070173,
-0.006062943,
-0.0607675053,
0.0437033549,
0.021874588,
0.0011726468,
-0.0550350212,
0.0412447006,
0.0059314403,
0.0264253113,
-0.000667438,
-0.0819137394,
-0.0541629642,
0.0154207312,
0.0086170575,
-0.0228366237,
-0.0162825342,
-0.0274345111,
-0.0055475184,
-0.10489095,
-0.0264248494,
2.387364971e-34,
0.0916681737,
-0.0077180499,
-0.0234834664,
-0.0146247512,
0.014948898,
-0.0158657711,
0.0012790904,
-0.0180807412,
-0.0018442231,
-0.0450917855,
-0.0255578347
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.09892v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.09892v1 | Clustering-Aware Negative Sampling for Unsupervised Sentence Representation | 2023-05-17T02:06:47 | 2023-05-17T02:06:47 | Jinghao Deng, Fanqi Wan, Tao Yang, Xiaojun Quan, Rui Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Contrastive learning has been widely studied in sentence representation
learning. However, earlier works mainly focus on the construction of positive
examples, while in-batch samples are often simply treated as negative examples.
This approach overlooks the importance of selecting appropriate negative
examples, potentially leading to a scarcity of hard negatives and the inclusion
of false negatives. To address these issues, we propose ClusterNS
(Clustering-aware Negative Sampling), a novel method that incorporates cluster
information into contrastive learning for unsupervised sentence representation
learning. We apply a modified K-means clustering algorithm to supply hard
negatives and recognize in-batch false negatives during training, aiming to
solve the two issues in one unified framework. Experiments on semantic textual
similarity (STS) tasks demonstrate that our proposed ClusterNS compares
favorably with baselines in unsupervised sentence representation learning. Our
code has been made publicly available. | [
-0.0157649722,
-0.0325055756,
-0.0545619689,
0.0211589616,
-0.0685049593,
0.0047828932,
0.000518747,
-0.0035637754,
0.0322691351,
-0.047761675,
-0.0211760122,
-0.0100518791,
-0.0214126725,
-0.0155582791,
0.0494969971,
-0.077135399,
0.0338699222,
0.041005794,
0.0180624984,
0.0003814704,
0.0636331663,
0.019558575,
-0.0176538453,
0.0006969146,
-0.0363013037,
-0.0467917845,
-0.0062895305,
-0.0301098805,
0.046468813,
-0.0290798601,
0.0267300587,
0.0166024975,
-0.0104789538,
0.0145334918,
0.0000016234,
-0.0510999411,
-0.0049230289,
-0.0226072539,
0.0308910329,
0.0190639589,
0.0943298191,
-0.0535933822,
0.0314183459,
0.0006920861,
-0.0207948741,
0.0054064482,
0.0176206715,
0.0634519532,
0.0663469955,
0.030629294,
-0.0159415752,
0.0105009116,
-0.0107026221,
-0.0011326146,
-0.0156993922,
0.0308317859,
0.012749888,
-0.008084205,
0.0202036109,
0.0113197798,
-0.0162653215,
0.0216437411,
0.0204181466,
0.0351396166,
-0.0270034149,
0.0411040448,
-0.0688671172,
0.0363167375,
0.007030983,
0.0788769051,
0.0385634042,
-0.0347180702,
0.0037393733,
-0.0291716401,
-0.0154628428,
-0.0015398563,
-0.0314791426,
0.0223521218,
0.0076960577,
0.0457196012,
-0.008931743,
0.0457846969,
0.0093114823,
-0.0047287722,
0.0142012006,
0.0195732247,
0.0247972012,
-0.0705321059,
0.0021256802,
0.0148507869,
-0.0527726673,
0.0457919687,
0.0504093133,
-0.0356171355,
0.0351412743,
-0.0332391709,
-0.017968772,
-0.0760096759,
0.0340926312,
-0.0287878402,
-0.0136677409,
0.013575675,
-0.0155746248,
0.0279348586,
-0.0393182263,
-0.0037849732,
0.0134297563,
0.0073727896,
-0.0535675846,
-0.035102129,
-0.0570950657,
-0.0097340131,
-0.041573707,
0.0652928427,
-0.0291485824,
0.0056919679,
-0.0087865228,
-0.0026460162,
-0.0801754072,
-0.011892085,
-0.0019183605,
0.0176726431,
-0.0311797913,
-0.0012071023,
-0.0078361724,
0.0131919896,
-0.0545442402,
0.0261999946,
-0.0363059454,
-0.0091482084,
-0.0409217961,
0.0253484547,
0.0359940268,
-0.0015264234,
-0.0175457243,
0.0307859294,
0.0033862102,
0.0099817161,
-0.0638061538,
-0.0134807546,
-0.0219342485,
-0.0078443633,
-0.0629070997,
-0.0565378666,
-0.0038283556,
0.0092272302,
-0.0049011637,
-0.0203888379,
-0.0189248212,
0.0257726554,
0.0039651268,
0.0276460145,
0.0132367602,
-0.0430178344,
-0.021142032,
-0.0144474218,
-0.0200896543,
0.043964792,
-0.0067768185,
-0.0105769718,
0.0377342552,
0.0593075417,
0.00506448,
0.0010673507,
0.0471244715,
0.02339123,
-0.0287539326,
0.0000073397,
0.0251279753,
0.0037483098,
0.0336417556,
0.0376448259,
-0.0369087122,
-0.0324155986,
0.029651003,
0.0250084139,
-0.035577815,
0.0109681115,
0.0242441539,
0.0662841797,
-0.0585454777,
-0.0062938211,
-0.0166414659,
0.0115705431,
-0.054025583,
0.0176514518,
0.0290990751,
-0.0266207717,
-0.0593745112,
0.0212331116,
0.0242242981,
-0.0430042967,
0.0444560312,
-0.0529386476,
0.05515939,
0.0362461135,
-0.0325293988,
0.0318366513,
0.0272924565,
-0.045475278,
0.004491169,
0.0471030734,
0.0484693386,
0.0186008438,
0.0111997016,
-0.0482749827,
-0.0143960696,
-0.007826291,
-0.036379002,
0.0309585165,
0.0113626635,
-0.0331260748,
0.0267996583,
-0.0506968573,
0.010458217,
-0.0188350659,
0.0123315183,
-0.0187365282,
-0.0095738936,
0.0328497402,
0.0703341961,
-0.0816954821,
-0.0382672735,
0.0398232043,
0.0371575914,
0.0134014199,
0.0113708777,
0.0250695124,
0.0209954828,
0.0114223436,
0.010783623,
-0.005679029,
0.0339806043,
-0.0422181524,
-0.0335523672,
-0.0227552056,
-0.0785053149,
-0.1297765225,
0.0134015447,
-0.066250734,
0.003320338,
0.0871077627,
-0.0615761131,
-0.0372471064,
0.073349461,
-0.0246195495,
0.0317982286,
-0.0320436694,
-0.0127282385,
0.0138360541,
0.005214422,
-0.0231600162,
0.0518704467,
-0.0115295397,
-0.0026828821,
-0.0464766845,
-0.0099747442,
-0.0048178644,
-0.038494233,
-0.0387614071,
-0.070426017,
0.0264883973,
0.0197010189,
0.0024400328,
-0.0330075845,
-0.0688944161,
0.0319268219,
-0.0877135247,
0.0156542752,
-0.0223124586,
-0.0037543594,
0.0671661124,
-0.0001386112,
0.0147245461,
-0.0387266763,
-0.0175817534,
-0.0068113594,
0.0132109122,
0.0034888876,
0.062095698,
0.0018082922,
0.0192019865,
-0.0209421385,
-0.0018789433,
-0.0317685753,
0.0307241268,
-0.0622612722,
-0.0027641552,
-0.0302490201,
0.05916401,
-0.010315991,
-0.0198635273,
0.007899194,
-0.0081681535,
-0.0072196503,
-0.0237517897,
0.0004612194,
0.0342540294,
0.0162502378,
-0.044514522,
0.0279505849,
0.031660419,
-0.0475828648,
-0.0199559592,
-0.024042733,
0.0698462799,
0.0143082272,
-0.0187729858,
0.0189672261,
0.0717726648,
0.0454571135,
-0.0291820131,
-0.0578173362,
-0.017249437,
-0.0187757034,
0.0202955902,
0.002902224,
0.0134960664,
0.0013903739,
0.0005840173,
-0.0524585843,
-0.0314754508,
0.0741213784,
-0.015254641,
-0.0513780341,
-0.0397058576,
-0.0113128582,
-0.0035089541,
0.0353534929,
0.0085228691,
-0.0011374698,
0.0308048297,
0.0357965901,
-0.0056556351,
-0.0370135531,
0.0169835966,
0.0425537266,
0.0161822159,
-0.0156562421,
-0.0135929724,
-0.002956114,
-0.0185395274,
-0.037859194,
-0.0489160791,
-0.0005942642,
0.0147697441,
0.0020136493,
0.0785139278,
-0.0454007238,
0.0103824735,
0.0077557522,
0.0217826813,
-0.0196674131,
-0.0211851783,
-0.0314911306,
0.0596709363,
0.0419712998,
-0.0281375889,
0.0299594179,
-0.0102885002,
0.0015265148,
0.0545045733,
0.0229851995,
-0.0148405237,
-0.0154640516,
0.005242236,
-0.0014649853,
-0.0319700018,
0.0111945523,
0.0167435873,
0.0147245759,
0.007963758,
-0.0166136082,
0.0957688615,
0.040801663,
-0.0494177528,
0.0161515139,
-0.0249116179,
0.0258348119,
0.0254623797,
-0.035978239,
-0.0092828339,
-0.0214582197,
-0.0454866029,
0.045972418,
0.0078338804,
-0.0308938995,
0.0167102404,
-0.1193871424,
-0.0117308218,
0.0438839719,
-0.0799979791,
-0.0176187269,
-0.0207555946,
0.0050255265,
-0.0498395935,
-0.002107559,
0.0176049098,
0.0129390936,
0.0182175077,
-0.0007720353,
-0.0375028551,
-0.0178608652,
0.0006040469,
-0.0799555257,
0.0099008875,
0.0031428374,
0.0206187554,
0.0153390635,
0.0055958088,
-0.0378122181,
-0.080724366,
-0.0173836593,
-0.0263049919,
0.0456430912,
0.004458854,
0.0108461287,
-0.0546469502,
0.0256748013,
-0.0768602341,
-0.0317083299,
0.0492399372,
0.0784730837,
-0.0172064789,
-0.0159172043,
-0.0149354907,
0.0183395687,
0.0196155552,
0.0643110648,
0.0003940397,
-0.0068511865,
-0.0027084525,
0.0272739995,
0.0301172622,
-0.0367440693,
0.0284619797,
-0.0444651507,
0.0094609074,
0.0875148773,
-0.073501654,
-0.0732858479,
0.0419635288,
0.0553546399,
-0.0097658634,
-0.004669562,
0.0095475325,
-0.0309029836,
-0.055912897,
0.0085255653,
-0.0505945943,
-0.0295763072,
0.0057316809,
-0.0460357815,
0.0546043664,
0.002712741,
-0.0242359471,
-0.013384033,
-0.0340017304,
-0.0512853041,
-0.0149317272,
0.0346159935,
-0.0025263911,
0.0701550469,
-0.0155831212,
-0.008614555,
0.0875632986,
0.0444466211,
-0.0481039472,
0.0021736284,
0.0536418669,
-0.0068931901,
0.0295765828,
0.0525424182,
-0.0292797573,
0.0386603326,
0.0279541072,
0.0216740835,
-0.0725944862,
-0.0045303456,
0.0104487389,
0.0119413687,
0.09637025,
0.013807104,
0.015729513,
-0.031410411,
-0.0244366229,
-0.0203072615,
-0.0267318599,
-0.0077932328,
0.009957687,
-0.0014441559,
0.0135666216,
-0.0347782709,
0.0790693015,
-0.0349859372,
0.0121525619,
0.0132839065,
-0.0013331849,
0.0813818127,
0.0321868733,
-0.028659163,
0.0179838091,
-0.0382073633,
-0.0532682464,
-0.005279508,
0.0100480746,
-0.0228504632,
0.0034494854,
0.008276239,
0.0469642393,
-0.0607460961,
0.0332189389,
-0.0364239737,
0.085049361,
-0.0269954763,
-0.0191109609,
0.0096168714,
-0.0623950772,
0.0406981744,
0.0014897719,
-0.00313904,
-0.0361054167,
0.0133136706,
-0.0151983546,
-0.0082523385,
-0.0060531213,
0.016081335,
-0.0006260587,
0.0304730684,
0.0677590743,
-0.0958038494,
0.0293569639,
0.0016173471,
-0.0282632243,
-0.0393236987,
-0.0004698719,
0.0294755772,
0.0537268929,
0.0248993337,
-0.0020001589,
-0.0166964382,
-0.0349127129,
0.0898250341,
-0.0110840714,
-0.0025737181,
0.0059267827,
0.0884955749,
0.0137058292,
-0.001084748,
-0.0009053908,
-0.0084882649,
0.0070095132,
0.0106440373,
-0.0329435244,
-0.0607549958,
-5.696760069e-33,
-0.00905215,
0.0060382867,
-0.0434800535,
-0.0331906676,
0.0032222969,
-0.0058541056,
-0.0099008949,
-0.020103123,
0.0376877449,
0.0547717847,
0.0352586843,
-0.0156531204,
-0.003481173,
0.0460033156,
0.0021485721,
0.014754097,
0.0564477891,
0.0076780459,
-0.0040207445,
0.0353249945,
0.0562370792,
0.0386528857,
0.0413299464,
-0.0304015335,
-0.0124154044,
-0.0438287482,
0.010480877,
-0.0140083423,
0.0714837313,
0.0259208307,
-0.0108899744,
0.0728922188,
0.0320021063,
-0.0317315087,
-0.0308377612,
-0.0338929072,
-0.0472959839,
-0.0807610229,
0.0085132951,
-0.0326132961,
-0.0105105061,
-0.0043968442,
0.034815982,
-0.0041815969,
-0.0012758854,
0.0595505573,
0.0389775671,
-0.0152979167,
-0.0178694241,
0.0248236749,
-0.0495145023,
0.0093660848,
-0.0249277465,
0.0156429671,
-0.0046284823,
0.0336856022,
-0.0026664243,
0.0744852573,
-0.0477942266,
0.0052638222,
-0.0407744274,
0.0215426609,
-0.0008971592,
0.0303892847,
0.015169343,
0.0616478249,
0.0042742668,
-0.0292474702,
0.0101080546,
0.0383438244,
0.0133436499,
-0.0098460941,
0.0284585562,
0.1150404662,
-0.023640031,
-0.0110336859,
-0.0257553123,
0.0549020581,
-0.0320914127,
-0.0033923534,
0.0200121813,
0.0107588246,
-0.0430608205,
-0.0353820473,
0.0195215289,
-0.077071026,
-0.003787616,
0.0115845427,
0.018734511,
-0.0091728959,
-0.0526308157,
0.043115668,
-0.0073779756,
-0.0219748206,
0.0326297842,
-0.0053243088,
-0.0253890306,
-0.0112782987,
0.0412442721,
-0.0245794766,
-0.0732662454,
-0.0130143519,
0.0358365513,
0.0307272356,
-0.001174546,
-0.0143349981,
0.0823863149,
-0.0283774994,
-0.0570379905,
0.0135939121,
0.035822209,
-0.0051041823,
-0.0228283741,
-0.0327895023,
0.000986742,
0.016516516,
0.0048410152,
0.0559820943,
0.0375293903,
-0.0567080006,
-0.0184171163,
0.0175510272,
-0.0072986684,
0.0168672707,
-0.0308234412,
-0.0199150257,
-0.0276924875,
0.0134484312,
0.0319856368,
-0.0663226396,
-0.0153154172,
-0.0178965852,
2.212e-7,
0.012673608,
-0.0078066383,
0.0309432019,
-0.0167351253,
0.0308071543,
0.0779451653,
-0.0215752777,
0.0379518345,
-0.0075459131,
0.0504485071,
0.0485800467,
0.0333091505,
-0.0119372616,
0.0377219021,
-0.0651950017,
0.1129329875,
-0.0556186028,
-0.0317799225,
-0.02629086,
0.0223053377,
0.0686404333,
0.0934942141,
0.0405937359,
0.0078360867,
0.0143962707,
-0.061450582,
0.0594657846,
-0.0051162294,
0.0082231453,
-0.0289576557,
-0.031566605,
0.0016715104,
-0.0126024708,
0.0449302495,
0.0312170833,
0.0215679705,
-0.0087319277,
0.0005526023,
-0.0044788467,
-0.0488278717,
0.0229898673,
0.0045094783,
0.0145902559,
-0.0382781625,
0.0767376944,
-0.0841469765,
0.0078857066,
-0.0089270519,
-0.0518117361,
0.0220893994,
0.0205661133,
0.0220472571,
-0.0382308066,
0.0117920311,
0.0163222272,
0.0261105448,
-0.0354027376,
-0.0409951732,
0.0004844738,
0.0145200258,
0.002223863,
-0.0315944664,
0.0073717223,
0.0445214622,
0.0343991406,
-0.0151441842,
0.0533382408,
1.410175025e-34,
0.0395912044,
0.0175317805,
-0.0339709893,
-0.0282712616,
-0.0166267101,
-0.0440658666,
-0.0459449254,
-0.0422538891,
0.0286675207,
-0.0267445203,
0.0035597142
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.09877v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.09877v1 | Semantic Similarity Measure of Natural Language Text through Machine Learning and a Keyword-Aware Cross-Encoder-Ranking Summarizer -- A Case Study Using UCGIS GIS&T Body of Knowledge | 2023-05-17T01:17:57 | 2023-05-17T01:17:57 | Yuanyuan Tian, Wenwen Li, Sizhe Wang, Zhining Gu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | Initiated by the University Consortium of Geographic Information Science
(UCGIS), GIS&T Body of Knowledge (BoK) is a community-driven endeavor to
define, develop, and document geospatial topics related to geographic
information science and technologies (GIS&T). In recent years, GIS&T BoK has
undergone rigorous development in terms of its topic re-organization and
content updating, resulting in a new digital version of the project. While the
BoK topics provide useful materials for researchers and students to learn about
GIS, the semantic relationships among the topics, such as semantic similarity,
should also be identified so that a better and automated topic navigation can
be achieved. Currently, the related topics are either defined manually by
editors or authors, which may result in an incomplete assessment of topic
relationship. To address this challenge, our research evaluates the
effectiveness of multiple natural language processing (NLP) techniques in
extracting semantics from text, including both deep neural networks and
traditional machine learning approaches. Besides, a novel text summarization -
KACERS (Keyword-Aware Cross-Encoder-Ranking Summarizer) - is proposed to
generate a semantic summary of scientific publications. By identifying the
semantic linkages among key topics, this work provides guidance for future
development and content organization of the GIS&T BoK project. It also offers a
new perspective on the use of machine learning techniques for analyzing
scientific publications, and demonstrate the potential of KACERS summarizer in
semantic understanding of long text documents. | [
0.0276508685,
0.007502751,
-0.0096165668,
-0.0054755681,
-0.0272401888,
0.0260061845,
0.0107722366,
-0.0343780033,
-0.0234982595,
-0.0688676685,
0.0110897319,
0.0639898628,
0.0393560231,
0.0335390456,
-0.0055845273,
-0.0791102201,
0.0375763178,
0.0283735506,
0.0115733715,
0.0346937291,
0.0028234853,
0.0048175752,
-0.0135153867,
0.0340822227,
0.0447398983,
0.0192016903,
-0.0017711145,
-0.0571150035,
0.0545947254,
-0.0477896668,
0.0284717996,
-0.0187702738,
0.0148171522,
0.0264618341,
0.0000019133,
-0.0453534573,
-0.0696620494,
0.0261799917,
0.052172862,
0.0027789182,
0.0508549437,
-0.0326422229,
0.0218490679,
-0.0175830182,
-0.0149232354,
-0.0073020486,
0.0199052282,
0.0478527024,
0.01342443,
-0.0058435672,
-0.0035593612,
-0.0773523673,
0.0472496487,
0.037137989,
-0.0223381873,
0.023525672,
-0.0187176224,
0.0412983857,
0.0144642573,
0.0681238398,
-0.0082885791,
0.0237004496,
-0.0139328511,
0.0122747896,
0.0394015722,
0.0421606824,
-0.0439392179,
0.022755662,
0.023872016,
0.0244162008,
-0.0011787065,
-0.0187772438,
0.079413034,
-0.0002838469,
-0.058563821,
0.0678285956,
-0.0661361739,
0.0191470776,
-0.0153293209,
0.0290789604,
0.0005211997,
0.0297053494,
-0.0059711868,
0.0482528396,
-0.0346368104,
0.0969447419,
0.0031220715,
-0.0420717187,
-0.018828975,
0.011414092,
0.0233881585,
-0.0521055982,
0.0154737262,
0.0466021299,
0.0005525541,
-0.0242411848,
0.0291789733,
-0.0323754437,
0.0495689064,
-0.0440479033,
-0.025900498,
0.0051949117,
-0.0038656162,
0.0468697585,
0.0105655929,
0.0258764103,
0.0154092759,
0.0388106182,
0.0101839397,
-0.0319664814,
-0.0599298216,
-0.0238864645,
0.0089020254,
0.0255348906,
-0.0035238948,
0.0068805097,
-0.0058252476,
-0.0029021197,
0.0140758473,
0.0159642119,
-0.0303451698,
0.0411868133,
-0.0061268206,
0.0067332801,
-0.0401405804,
0.0304687042,
-0.0343199261,
0.0110360999,
-0.0240324885,
0.0610720851,
0.0394625254,
0.0143207805,
0.0599560626,
0.0386763699,
-0.0204004887,
-0.0040370524,
0.0248429682,
-0.0227344241,
-0.040537145,
-0.0533219203,
0.0164273251,
0.0040661301,
0.0261761248,
-0.0804356039,
-0.0193085577,
0.0043167742,
-0.0403985716,
-0.0090474011,
-0.0356355831,
0.0428823642,
-0.0437001772,
0.0234885272,
-0.0722801611,
-0.0192882214,
0.1283555329,
0.0157869328,
0.0367066115,
0.0219762996,
0.0166344978,
0.063862808,
0.0558656901,
0.0255349148,
-0.0140973795,
-0.0449789837,
-0.0000238204,
-0.019833196,
0.0206505675,
-0.022330394,
-0.0393218547,
0.0123181576,
0.0118854921,
0.0556798652,
-0.0351140462,
0.0117962062,
0.0068332916,
0.0803324431,
0.0115785655,
0.0278756786,
0.0333926268,
0.0761697665,
-0.0176975783,
0.0152204065,
0.0135230785,
-0.0050110952,
-0.0153689887,
0.0196701679,
0.0563542321,
0.0225876532,
-0.0051789181,
-0.0492565073,
0.0051617362,
0.0168649871,
0.0316406786,
-0.0535532422,
0.0711527988,
-0.0012524225,
0.0226659756,
0.0096019758,
0.0308246184,
-0.0026813995,
0.0361957476,
0.0287511367,
0.0143936165,
-0.0148428893,
0.0252676085,
-0.0139860446,
-0.0176482275,
-0.0064024595,
0.0102130137,
0.0094100619,
0.0223926697,
-0.0136135034,
-0.057569392,
-0.0603971183,
-0.0632202104,
-0.0401571207,
0.0018294812,
-0.0396900401,
-0.0022849643,
0.0607649535,
0.0598684102,
-0.0417354181,
0.00111225,
0.0397474207,
-0.007436248,
0.0142419245,
-0.0267520975,
0.0107310954,
-0.0176615361,
0.0216453876,
-0.0023951426,
0.0352139175,
0.0427329354,
-0.0342768207,
-0.0394002572,
0.0019871774,
0.0215238295,
0.0140111391,
0.0193271823,
-0.0808194876,
0.0290531032,
0.0246271063,
-0.0343114436,
-0.0345390663,
0.0450135246,
-0.0256621595,
0.0241456423,
-0.014862556,
0.0197609756,
-0.0212681592,
0.004604206,
-0.0619305298,
0.0506249554,
0.000928899,
0.0539435446,
0.0063555026,
-0.053716071,
0.0387841128,
-0.0070358706,
0.0087032234,
-0.0456130952,
-0.0173275191,
-0.008037881,
0.0469299518,
0.0000385217,
-0.0227481443,
-0.0169622805,
-0.0831449032,
0.018223865,
-0.0141430087,
0.0111238062,
0.0319612175,
-0.0288403351,
0.0035925955,
0.0152466698,
0.0001418431,
-0.0080552874,
0.0143879438,
-0.025269961,
0.0564843491,
-0.0376135595,
0.0441718847,
-0.0208011959,
-0.0184609182,
-0.0392369106,
0.0798420608,
0.0346342847,
-0.0436466001,
-0.0137350243,
0.0154484855,
-0.0279818736,
-0.0126757463,
-0.0099619301,
0.0038667615,
0.001829215,
0.0096412441,
0.0060594673,
-0.0155559182,
0.043084722,
0.0143837566,
0.0520011894,
-0.0233488195,
-0.0609286763,
0.0017193101,
-0.0369267836,
0.0386851206,
0.0178358648,
-0.0088043474,
0.0630491748,
-0.0040808036,
0.0105338739,
-0.0129435491,
0.0164847076,
0.0301605593,
-0.0480089784,
0.0160240736,
-0.0403252654,
0.0062924745,
0.05548729,
0.0465467311,
-0.0045686681,
-0.0274340492,
0.0360337012,
-0.0163150281,
0.0335661136,
-0.105765447,
-0.0049404246,
-0.0748145059,
0.0295556784,
0.008627248,
0.0268372186,
-0.0109793041,
0.0127968043,
0.0092169419,
-0.0223408695,
-0.0137585159,
0.0164808258,
-0.0227666162,
-0.0536162928,
-0.014967937,
0.0031840636,
0.0275227278,
-0.0040767249,
0.008982298,
-0.0214058142,
0.0286111068,
0.0279289912,
-0.0015337496,
0.0157582946,
0.0555953011,
0.0436943918,
0.0198732503,
-0.0211469308,
-0.0169084929,
-0.0275470987,
0.0830356479,
0.0758387074,
0.0073270448,
-0.0201383922,
0.0687504262,
-0.0406397432,
0.0175553448,
-0.0302473065,
0.0381656811,
-0.0205156393,
-0.0045911656,
-0.0165355913,
-0.0949993208,
-0.0190170687,
-0.0212563667,
-0.0178252552,
-0.0532922074,
-0.0068396507,
0.080446884,
0.0598597676,
-0.047178071,
-0.0155588062,
-0.038340833,
-0.0083004199,
0.0037991544,
-0.0132415835,
-0.0219147112,
0.0205059461,
-0.0271073021,
-0.0411365889,
-0.0248756316,
-0.0355532616,
-0.0158154983,
-0.057235565,
0.0193729028,
-0.0348465741,
-0.0905169696,
-0.0277232956,
-0.111926131,
-0.041078683,
0.0038669489,
-0.0410054736,
-0.0407835469,
0.0092848586,
0.0095192064,
0.0277592409,
-0.0986761972,
-0.0022569902,
-0.0546281375,
-0.0754488185,
-0.0115642827,
0.0353233032,
0.0918793306,
-0.0449964553,
-0.0241217185,
-0.0053048003,
-0.0027601663,
0.011114385,
0.0023555153,
0.0190493837,
0.0047785989,
0.0124662323,
0.005849224,
-0.0126356557,
-0.0251018014,
-0.0021672114,
0.0271640122,
0.0728882179,
-0.0550691448,
0.0021233761,
-0.0985696912,
0.0200882219,
-0.0129240779,
-0.0061061177,
0.0013284412,
0.0418526158,
-0.046005331,
-0.0301873628,
0.0094960975,
-0.004237459,
-0.0244154017,
0.0182576869,
-0.0077391011,
-0.0432116613,
-0.0575525649,
-0.0587808602,
-0.0117392633,
-0.0315727182,
-0.0168084037,
0.0228056088,
0.0746969357,
-0.0449282713,
-0.098653689,
-0.003443395,
-0.0059774658,
0.0054971371,
0.0120859183,
0.0058460003,
0.0730301663,
0.0159517601,
-0.0457569472,
-0.0173086151,
-0.004360741,
-0.034076158,
-0.0281965677,
0.0135873044,
0.007687367,
0.0064032581,
-0.0224158876,
-0.0393032208,
0.0813089684,
0.0212169774,
-0.0151952943,
-0.0367468558,
-0.0282226,
0.0053404165,
-0.0304859243,
-0.0453575328,
-0.0308744125,
0.0219933297,
-0.0530982837,
-0.0294157621,
-0.0481161885,
-0.039869193,
-0.0270100497,
0.0136777945,
0.0933153108,
0.0011188532,
-0.021909086,
0.0165701956,
-0.0358649082,
-0.0102473013,
0.0031583924,
0.0014909724,
0.0365977734,
-0.0048102578,
0.0409921035,
-0.0195960756,
0.0800278038,
0.0272293165,
-0.0272702109,
-0.0002631485,
0.0084814522,
-0.0011101494,
0.0491480045,
-0.0744372904,
0.0145207746,
-0.0610167831,
-0.0372420885,
-0.046380844,
-0.0165615138,
-0.0316266306,
-0.0282317474,
0.059023995,
0.02596692,
-0.0332290716,
0.0727199987,
-0.0641418546,
-0.0130248554,
-0.0347842202,
0.004215728,
0.0377108157,
0.000107463,
-0.0211766139,
-0.0002130469,
-0.0205464642,
-0.0057346635,
0.034174595,
0.0238863807,
-0.0170591362,
-0.0045915963,
0.0025738052,
-0.0283338111,
0.0004271937,
0.0433046594,
0.0282543711,
-0.033521194,
0.0196243506,
-0.0537514761,
0.0031591801,
0.0156350285,
-0.0075316783,
0.0444603004,
-0.0025586223,
-0.0377112739,
-0.0123679722,
0.0099835265,
0.0607980862,
0.0214473046,
0.0024992346,
-0.0122869881,
0.065292269,
0.0339938216,
-0.0202177167,
-0.0134009421,
-0.0199290644,
-0.0023218561,
-0.0723980814,
-0.0326229297,
-0.0343959555,
-5.857577614e-33,
-0.0020251151,
-0.0760014132,
0.0375690162,
0.0233731456,
-0.0383511595,
0.0024180131,
-0.0335180722,
-0.0586861782,
0.0047902442,
0.0125974864,
-0.0036184096,
0.0080113467,
-0.0036360042,
0.0175306629,
0.0521296412,
0.0426091999,
0.0135668647,
0.0121302726,
-0.02071031,
0.0401211977,
0.0336697549,
-0.0101134554,
0.0375385135,
-0.0988421813,
0.0287986118,
0.0171048008,
0.0289979968,
-0.0345163792,
0.0440215841,
0.059170939,
-0.0305386055,
0.0298404582,
0.0593213923,
-0.0665633082,
-0.0130879981,
0.026535254,
-0.0454274788,
-0.0749521405,
-0.0114429574,
-0.0329290554,
-0.0142626856,
-0.0407713838,
0.0554456562,
0.0162094049,
0.0208173841,
-0.0001976974,
0.0977705121,
0.0159074068,
-0.0835454762,
-0.0722213387,
-0.0341254994,
0.0440639928,
-0.0390224494,
0.0319799744,
0.0193655975,
-0.0001149632,
0.0042858152,
0.0774037614,
-0.0145830456,
0.0572382621,
0.0150972754,
0.0178203993,
0.0257406514,
-0.0113382023,
0.0225526653,
0.0591402799,
-0.0314531922,
-0.0604178831,
-0.035857711,
0.007315326,
0.0661137626,
0.0196275786,
0.0207042005,
0.0620510541,
0.0454746,
-0.0166931543,
-0.0478246249,
0.1031363904,
-0.0634775236,
0.0286159534,
-0.0213461518,
0.0015249164,
-0.004990336,
-0.0329834148,
-0.022592783,
-0.0163508207,
0.0011492958,
-0.0102279615,
-0.005329249,
-0.024253577,
-0.0288772602,
0.0698391944,
-0.0114344135,
-0.0565876253,
-0.0052415109,
0.0504388139,
0.01124423,
0.0211259499,
0.0034398439,
0.0109168142,
-0.0576686002,
-0.0287940893,
-0.0199738331,
0.0302770063,
0.0017684607,
0.0035741688,
0.0073307506,
-0.0218566041,
-0.0058133993,
0.0028012956,
0.0485133976,
-0.0807817131,
-0.0368230492,
0.0253348611,
-0.0488392226,
0.0049877996,
0.0239986461,
0.0215628669,
0.0416188762,
0.025883479,
0.0027393585,
-0.0149686979,
-0.0042215739,
0.0222084876,
0.0038793504,
-0.012313026,
-0.0183667038,
0.0119153112,
-0.0021204662,
-0.0188208241,
0.0104545131,
-0.0077766138,
2.716e-7,
0.0427729674,
0.0552292615,
0.0269562863,
-0.0179957114,
-0.0122277616,
0.0065170224,
0.055015184,
0.0315224975,
-0.0170279723,
0.0258889031,
0.0317680649,
0.0155908233,
-0.0127088809,
0.0404192694,
-0.0734266192,
0.0004790533,
-0.0591458455,
-0.065403387,
-0.0771037564,
-0.009379942,
0.0702808276,
0.003887685,
0.0080097793,
-0.0041377288,
-0.026577061,
-0.0085579809,
-0.0088132992,
-0.0025991714,
0.0073617827,
0.0288931727,
0.053256724,
-0.0300644152,
0.0152543774,
0.0079317335,
0.0107398937,
-0.0006692704,
0.047472164,
-0.0175747722,
-0.0263247117,
0.003100086,
0.031718161,
-0.0591495894,
0.0053614154,
-0.0556227081,
0.0393038727,
-0.0606138632,
0.0158529822,
-0.0152173843,
-0.0089392504,
0.0408358835,
0.0255618598,
0.0143207768,
-0.0226723775,
-0.0096452758,
0.0056659877,
-0.0066290176,
0.0007330027,
-0.079267025,
0.0216215011,
0.0553974472,
0.0235120803,
-0.0113101834,
-0.0291869752,
-0.0044288719,
0.0560870357,
-0.0295469891,
0.0195858143,
2.113095048e-34,
0.0357238166,
0.0087452,
-0.0434559435,
-0.0456980877,
0.0090175094,
-0.0003214204,
-0.0257360395,
0.0131311025,
-0.0341313519,
-0.0338717252,
0.0424616821
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.09864v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.09864v1 | The Jaseci Programming Paradigm and Runtime Stack: Building Scale-out Production Applications Easy and Fast | 2023-05-17T00:34:36 | 2023-05-17T00:34:36 | Jason Mars, Yiping Kang, Roland Daynauth, Baichuan Li, Ashish Mahendra, Krisztian Flautner, Lingjia Tang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.DC, cs.PL, cs.SE | Today's production scale-out applications include many sub-application
components, such as storage backends, logging infrastructure and AI models.
These components have drastically different characteristics, are required to
work in collaboration, and interface with each other as microservices. This
leads to increasingly high complexity in developing, optimizing, configuring,
and deploying scale-out applications, raising the barrier to entry for most
individuals and small teams. We developed a novel co-designed runtime system,
Jaseci, and programming language, Jac, which aims to reduce this complexity.
The key design principle throughout Jaseci's design is to raise the level of
abstraction by moving as much of the scale-out data management, microservice
componentization, and live update complexity into the runtime stack to be
automated and optimized automatically. We use real-world AI applications to
demonstrate Jaseci's benefit for application performance and developer
productivity. | [
0.0263657197,
0.0159892272,
-0.0180565976,
-0.0142974397,
0.0033102795,
0.0111597348,
0.0524293408,
-0.0158281177,
0.0020024548,
0.0223723222,
0.027769722,
0.0272240732,
-0.009981676,
0.1483542472,
-0.009872485,
-0.0383605845,
0.0197550785,
-0.016087614,
-0.0550449826,
0.0122787897,
0.0087039554,
0.005461921,
0.0035240569,
0.006990321,
-0.0366855562,
-0.032029178,
-0.0118592242,
0.0621346608,
-0.0170827508,
0.0257619601,
-0.0176853072,
-0.0297539923,
-0.0108186174,
0.0348318778,
0.0000021623,
-0.0485632457,
0.0135286236,
0.0137269273,
-0.0206413157,
0.0318075605,
-0.0009452845,
-0.0238942318,
-0.0433466136,
0.0583954379,
-0.0060251537,
-0.0445000678,
0.0759236813,
-0.0349989049,
0.0544049777,
-0.0450129062,
-0.0016162139,
-0.0241205078,
0.007941464,
0.0274567995,
-0.0338248201,
-0.0099342316,
0.0070681539,
0.0391201787,
0.0376009531,
-0.0491463915,
0.0366018303,
-0.0104929972,
0.0397565141,
-0.016257273,
0.0288845636,
0.0462459326,
0.0052878675,
-0.0410801768,
-0.0151790576,
-0.0548095293,
0.0321312323,
-0.0212040357,
0.0372937955,
-0.0000246074,
-0.0428864174,
-0.0457480326,
0.0029645078,
-0.0068021673,
0.0238535106,
-0.036578957,
0.0125812544,
-0.0110040866,
-0.0549623072,
-0.0346026421,
-0.0251608845,
0.0116694961,
-0.0053811269,
0.0280090626,
-0.0603660084,
0.0002634014,
0.0341782533,
-0.0351760313,
0.0183059555,
0.0512724482,
-0.071648784,
-0.0623872466,
-0.0140698291,
-0.0327084064,
-0.0110044861,
-0.0628339648,
0.026309263,
-0.0158914905,
-0.0079981703,
0.0249582399,
0.0560004339,
0.0750607252,
0.0185977947,
-0.077723138,
0.0113322828,
-0.0149254566,
-0.0077654887,
-0.0041912389,
-0.0494444184,
0.0385723412,
-0.0270212442,
-0.0149906222,
-0.0146286469,
0.0790031925,
0.0121463742,
0.0551514067,
0.0090051843,
0.0191985853,
-0.0356342867,
0.0410433225,
0.0238270983,
-0.0157719404,
-0.057055451,
-0.0103651499,
0.0053917612,
-0.0752149075,
0.0165089313,
0.0089088408,
-0.0125145782,
0.019633472,
0.0159304161,
0.039430853,
0.0397458784,
0.0446588211,
-0.05767278,
-0.0357098617,
0.0756460428,
-0.0373858213,
-0.0992837697,
-0.0363304242,
-0.0423623472,
-0.0172853284,
0.0062242341,
0.0102558434,
-0.0512504652,
-0.0559535474,
0.0242797583,
-0.0010438559,
-0.0361674875,
0.0285933986,
0.0541422218,
0.0193339512,
0.0330901295,
0.0473074205,
0.0335516743,
0.0331351198,
0.0267560892,
0.0082902964,
0.031083161,
0.0182082076,
-0.0842960477,
-0.0192862656,
-0.0167403985,
0.0648637861,
-0.0249564853,
0.0150203267,
-0.0091220252,
0.0057111378,
0.0447363965,
0.016411541,
0.0258274786,
0.0363894403,
0.0099688666,
0.0348553322,
0.0678010136,
0.033113908,
-0.0069622132,
-0.075820595,
-0.0053601442,
0.0699934661,
0.0736382678,
0.0015168316,
-0.0220850203,
0.09846434,
-0.0220419671,
-0.0170811322,
-0.0025666687,
-0.0155923367,
-0.0674408972,
-0.0036717693,
0.0218254216,
0.0442454889,
-0.0089136893,
-0.0215005204,
-0.0289588012,
-0.0112158898,
-0.0266817603,
-0.0419773422,
-0.0611661151,
0.0528606325,
0.0656383559,
-0.0175437406,
-0.0310827326,
0.0260091089,
-0.0584111661,
0.0025723551,
0.0735678971,
-0.0424138382,
-0.0259242523,
-0.0075315745,
-0.0132025089,
0.0325284339,
0.0230884459,
0.0347472765,
0.0034880354,
0.0187624358,
-0.0575626381,
0.0167086143,
-0.0103396298,
0.003435231,
-0.0301048569,
-0.0512246974,
0.0161069166,
0.0075670872,
0.0459490344,
-0.0205719266,
-0.0362489708,
-0.0609161407,
0.028246535,
0.0511631146,
-0.0074078292,
0.0332816951,
0.0204835571,
0.0793733597,
-0.0178341437,
0.0464947969,
0.0544341952,
0.0235174764,
-0.0612398684,
-0.0387600586,
0.0188723765,
0.0027322648,
-0.0122098466,
0.0356734805,
0.0400261916,
-0.0283314064,
0.0006147625,
-0.0192740746,
-0.0194465183,
0.0430073179,
-0.0536125116,
-0.0700188577,
-0.0153432619,
0.0138036972,
0.039816197,
0.0117681213,
0.0621768869,
-0.0090912944,
-0.0017092521,
-0.0146237146,
-0.0066598337,
-0.0029511556,
0.0463470891,
-0.0776171386,
0.0394940451,
0.0255355462,
0.0238254871,
0.0649515539,
0.096118331,
0.0130848158,
-0.010445415,
0.0481679067,
0.082650885,
-0.0184020624,
0.0130013777,
0.0137597779,
0.0430950075,
-0.0095790867,
0.0087323533,
-0.0102833984,
-0.003317754,
0.0215372667,
0.025674846,
0.045930583,
-0.0762768984,
0.0132130291,
-0.0395328477,
0.0050850948,
0.0172304548,
-0.0307813454,
-0.0104767364,
-0.0393687189,
0.0308371689,
0.0470246188,
-0.0572434403,
0.028778879,
0.0300859045,
-0.0021105085,
-0.0128736086,
-0.0103985611,
0.0200669821,
0.0057189832,
0.0086878333,
0.0367309973,
-0.0000526474,
0.026767455,
-0.0504409522,
-0.0231565814,
-0.014567472,
-0.0210430734,
-0.0208926685,
-0.000595214,
0.0526203997,
-0.0093097854,
-0.0569453575,
0.0183672998,
0.0137618203,
-0.056576211,
0.0504422113,
0.0192176066,
-0.0331976861,
-0.0186980255,
-0.0823122635,
-0.0775021911,
0.0280683134,
0.0187133048,
-0.0013410875,
-0.0373766832,
-0.0322379917,
-0.019594159,
-0.0063450066,
-0.0406151935,
-0.0241745841,
-0.0343701392,
-0.0525974259,
-0.041066587,
0.0338027142,
-0.0302677229,
0.0165384766,
0.0644560158,
-0.0630865619,
-0.0279036835,
-0.0164776519,
-0.0201815981,
-0.0527748205,
0.0072128032,
0.0275961217,
0.0782776624,
0.0125246868,
-0.0486887395,
0.0149464486,
-0.0425327942,
-0.0141406916,
-0.010328616,
-0.0011885598,
0.0513538606,
0.0031931789,
0.0291183926,
0.034247756,
-0.0513904691,
-0.0775660351,
-0.0552055277,
0.0598532446,
-0.0325648934,
0.0121673234,
0.0328849405,
0.026605498,
-0.0180305131,
-0.0809117556,
0.0054681404,
-0.0198049806,
-0.0317899361,
0.0186299551,
0.0120810419,
0.0585855655,
0.0607172512,
0.0539166704,
-0.0475958809,
0.0121733136,
0.0089907665,
0.0454135835,
-0.0127139343,
-0.006022031,
-0.0075301104,
-0.036624983,
0.0740472451,
-0.0296421293,
-0.039869342,
0.0076908721,
-0.1124531254,
0.0498121977,
-0.0235258881,
-0.047876697,
0.0256002434,
-0.0001967357,
0.0258833393,
-0.0141409514,
0.0129583841,
-0.0083707236,
-0.0083126519,
-0.0305614714,
0.0727074966,
0.0601791441,
-0.0070991223,
0.0116954297,
0.0359718129,
0.0596875809,
0.0374008194,
0.0196682215,
-0.0782517493,
0.0082339272,
0.0233026296,
-0.0116990004,
-0.002350454,
0.0215374269,
-0.0280371606,
0.0117475884,
0.0559250675,
0.066102758,
-0.0282153729,
-0.0202774759,
-0.0608537197,
-0.0325218812,
0.0293492563,
0.0348325931,
0.0273152776,
-0.0276164543,
-0.014112819,
0.0010266678,
-0.0093281707,
0.0417651124,
-0.0626567602,
-0.023198802,
-0.0085963309,
-0.0314397141,
0.0141635314,
-0.0296071712,
0.0043135826,
0.0332167707,
0.0013208176,
-0.0535695367,
-0.0186095703,
0.0270618089,
-0.0157468431,
-0.07032758,
-0.0007718224,
0.0234452318,
-0.0093229534,
0.0471850894,
0.0291134417,
0.0042310432,
-0.021321062,
-0.0290367045,
-0.0074156532,
-0.0324710272,
0.0747576281,
0.0744296089,
0.0349848792,
-0.0217462704,
0.0217796341,
-0.0254688915,
0.0139177311,
0.0402906463,
-0.0513610244,
0.0523988679,
-0.053167142,
-0.0046442403,
-0.0005840676,
-0.024330724,
-0.0759446695,
0.0047197221,
0.0032333867,
-0.0362170041,
-0.0312167592,
-0.0324673429,
-0.0427679755,
0.0216616597,
-0.0474001728,
0.0133290421,
-0.0321321748,
0.04084941,
0.024993049,
-0.0086265486,
0.0040136818,
-0.0397929363,
0.0673821047,
-0.0444021411,
0.0050767306,
0.0313540585,
0.0346953534,
0.0367519557,
-0.018715715,
-0.0252736695,
-0.0039617936,
-0.0312135965,
0.037131831,
0.0231196266,
0.0156206265,
-0.0106849996,
-0.0264285505,
-0.0005807928,
0.0539212488,
-0.0129869878,
-0.0108878557,
0.0132756829,
-0.0165363848,
0.0062346957,
0.0002556727,
-0.03831793,
-0.0546598658,
0.0268432964,
0.0242823716,
-0.0182734374,
0.0606433563,
0.0256520584,
-0.0440373532,
0.0285528265,
-0.0386078022,
-0.0225559585,
-0.0125268586,
0.0213923026,
-0.0755111501,
-0.0000221441,
-0.0061838394,
-0.0080142589,
0.0315330625,
0.0150417211,
0.0016174075,
-0.0443032123,
-0.0424028449,
-0.0396093167,
0.0121226804,
-0.0120261749,
0.0670807064,
-0.031570442,
-0.0453654565,
-0.0342361368,
-0.0027266464,
-0.0171611439,
0.07179185,
0.0105490154,
-0.0582463816,
0.0083906399,
0.0311952252,
0.0577410012,
0.0042062523,
0.0242426991,
0.0114324195,
-0.0510559604,
-0.0216412731,
0.0307826716,
-6.189038001e-33,
0.0271900222,
0.0072685615,
0.0373598076,
0.0263809822,
0.0054355809,
0.0382848755,
-0.0310113411,
-0.026336778,
0.009918117,
-0.0085773589,
0.031262774,
0.0394375138,
0.0381497964,
-0.031031087,
0.0368734151,
0.0896772444,
0.0436620079,
-0.0067070834,
-0.026466528,
0.0478491783,
0.021528203,
-0.007207396,
-0.0346625261,
-0.091916509,
-0.0278164763,
-0.0216555148,
0.0230613146,
0.041561,
-0.0130777741,
-0.0245954003,
0.0220017061,
-0.0001340669,
-0.0336020216,
-0.0245490558,
0.0088171652,
-0.0335675813,
-0.0618033297,
-0.0053530433,
-0.0084792934,
-0.0046642045,
-0.0459282808,
0.0003720387,
0.0024647459,
-0.0011334951,
-0.013688175,
0.0063078152,
0.0208201353,
0.0255096983,
0.019208394,
-0.0371564925,
-0.0167052653,
-0.0337937735,
-0.0227746442,
0.0580262095,
0.0227817744,
-0.0225297939,
0.0050484235,
-0.0060415124,
-0.0320622027,
-0.0217627119,
-0.0340011083,
-0.0118545759,
-0.0073999758,
0.0438418537,
0.0040909573,
-0.0352183543,
0.0061249477,
0.0188952424,
0.0129249748,
-0.0080552669,
-0.0234661326,
0.0269079916,
0.019406572,
0.0022764471,
0.0186462197,
-0.0294966679,
0.0052820798,
0.0164720062,
0.0039540408,
0.0100171622,
-0.0082849953,
0.0112141995,
-0.0545908324,
0.0355418809,
0.0604667179,
-0.017659694,
-0.0290342718,
0.0042390493,
0.0101200603,
0.0215672702,
-0.0305079073,
0.0456493124,
0.0264273416,
-0.0450611934,
0.0369884297,
0.0436139405,
0.0060719331,
-0.0100327637,
0.0112857893,
0.0094526373,
-0.0047469954,
-0.003849712,
-0.0492279604,
0.0546646193,
0.0539782532,
0.007091389,
0.0083195008,
0.0050552278,
-0.0341920853,
0.0545298643,
-0.0256812759,
0.0270392094,
-0.0148246996,
-0.0672972053,
-0.0056184032,
-0.0283458885,
0.0574650206,
0.0512089729,
0.0016958964,
-0.0646067932,
0.0120659349,
0.0039362437,
0.0053617405,
-0.0284778625,
-0.0559436679,
-0.0036188671,
-0.0661584809,
0.0278784614,
0.0364039429,
-0.000999297,
-0.0459255502,
0.0276293512,
3.024e-7,
-0.0474999361,
0.0364626125,
0.0158987083,
0.0029727281,
0.0616165772,
0.0472174101,
0.071036309,
-0.0306554362,
0.0286212433,
0.0398858413,
-0.0072674337,
0.0302535221,
0.0362413265,
0.0276261624,
0.0218698774,
-0.0191634558,
-0.0355910584,
-0.0234299507,
-0.0761484131,
-0.0112095512,
0.0263776407,
-0.0041361675,
0.0705631971,
-0.0243545342,
0.0514341965,
0.0006713716,
-0.0684486181,
0.0252066255,
0.0989420786,
0.0155803431,
-0.0528935865,
0.0664293021,
-0.0208870564,
-0.0141140381,
-0.042116981,
-0.0428524129,
-0.0693381876,
0.0430581905,
-0.0318576358,
0.0450192019,
0.0321853757,
-0.0575884096,
-0.0371358953,
-0.0483494923,
0.031343475,
-0.0385475643,
-0.0235303286,
-0.0359731019,
-0.0171360895,
-0.0468386151,
-0.0367956907,
0.0105728861,
-0.0140655534,
-0.0049316604,
-0.0199794676,
-0.0630267411,
-0.0343164168,
-0.0227403622,
0.0172830187,
0.0280714948,
-0.0035139963,
0.0158275589,
-0.0429458842,
0.0111925192,
-0.0039040088,
0.0185347386,
0.0132461386,
2.945437572e-34,
-0.0157503504,
0.0119180838,
0.0431809053,
0.0216214769,
-0.0150367953,
0.0094192689,
-0.0335832722,
-0.0092128897,
0.0266973954,
0.0080175688,
-0.0241236705
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.09863v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.09863v2 | Explaining black box text modules in natural language with language models | 2023-05-17T00:29:18 | 2023-11-15T17:19:10 | Chandan Singh, Aliyah R. Hsu, Richard Antonello, Shailee Jain, Alexander G. Huth, Bin Yu, Jianfeng Gao | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, q-bio.NC | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable prediction
performance for a growing array of tasks. However, their rapid proliferation
and increasing opaqueness have created a growing need for interpretability.
Here, we ask whether we can automatically obtain natural language explanations
for black box text modules. A "text module" is any function that maps text to a
scalar continuous value, such as a submodule within an LLM or a fitted model of
a brain region. "Black box" indicates that we only have access to the module's
inputs/outputs.
We introduce Summarize and Score (SASC), a method that takes in a text module
and returns a natural language explanation of the module's selectivity along
with a score for how reliable the explanation is. We study SASC in 3 contexts.
First, we evaluate SASC on synthetic modules and find that it often recovers
ground truth explanations. Second, we use SASC to explain modules found within
a pre-trained BERT model, enabling inspection of the model's internals.
Finally, we show that SASC can generate explanations for the response of
individual fMRI voxels to language stimuli, with potential applications to
fine-grained brain mapping. All code for using SASC and reproducing results is
made available on Github. | [
-0.0029454732,
0.0434117801,
-0.0315932631,
0.0155899739,
-0.0082321856,
0.0440703519,
0.0240570847,
0.0101683587,
-0.0017840449,
-0.0030167657,
-0.007220496,
-0.0046811816,
0.0494939685,
0.0967206731,
0.0512098894,
-0.0558118969,
0.0079148393,
-0.0193691831,
-0.0069781393,
0.003698566,
0.0082819508,
0.0288323015,
-0.0059548393,
0.058869414,
0.0290988777,
-0.0011790737,
-0.0256323889,
-0.0084885145,
0.0192861054,
0.0037833836,
-0.0394196734,
0.0358074978,
0.0441454649,
0.0021237519,
0.0000021021,
-0.0254060924,
-0.0241627488,
0.0160133988,
-0.050224416,
0.0217992999,
0.0088264933,
0.0239859298,
0.0261682365,
0.0048912596,
-0.0077582477,
0.0294182114,
0.0639744177,
0.030358199,
0.0322690234,
0.0377758145,
-0.013154868,
-0.0068439725,
0.006272709,
-0.0096355388,
0.0431672111,
0.0181410015,
0.0159559269,
-0.0031336294,
0.0034301865,
0.0077524912,
-0.0155298002,
0.0150496559,
0.043531891,
-0.0141676981,
0.0288376156,
0.0595892891,
-0.0157025326,
-0.0221616235,
0.0212244019,
0.0586519875,
0.0279336255,
-0.017973695,
0.0338049717,
0.0002177855,
-0.0214355048,
0.0083018523,
-0.0602617413,
-0.0027178784,
0.0013878783,
0.0134285958,
0.0218707621,
-0.0257845819,
0.0393568017,
-0.005117116,
-0.0163077619,
0.0693872795,
-0.0004215754,
0.0055823973,
-0.0098316427,
-0.0000269733,
-0.0276034139,
-0.0742542595,
0.0374698229,
0.0469966047,
-0.0049682464,
0.0118472455,
0.0050121481,
-0.0426191986,
0.0190450847,
-0.0406963043,
0.0086585907,
0.0317319371,
-0.0519064441,
0.0316502415,
-0.0089634098,
0.0547567382,
-0.0261106603,
0.0756681487,
-0.0233732313,
-0.0123238061,
-0.0714083314,
-0.0482557155,
0.0051888418,
0.0128287524,
-0.053716924,
-0.0194404963,
-0.0340356827,
-0.0022594987,
-0.0182448402,
-0.0286472403,
-0.0007711477,
0.047095146,
-0.0257131401,
0.0075357975,
-0.0504024699,
0.0107800458,
-0.0444538668,
0.0003315805,
-0.0111180386,
-0.0432618372,
-0.0330218785,
0.0348353796,
-0.0011503299,
-0.0208597127,
0.0018178086,
0.0740099847,
-0.0117648663,
-0.0136544742,
-0.019976642,
-0.0540588237,
-0.0549606904,
-0.0332360938,
0.0256548133,
-0.0640452281,
0.0029442336,
0.0402910747,
-0.0226312764,
-0.0148899574,
0.0032389911,
-0.0322486497,
-0.043547757,
0.0547987707,
-0.0509508774,
-0.0138484063,
0.0148302922,
0.0135962749,
-0.0057178065,
0.0335781202,
0.0398492888,
0.0110351397,
0.011707156,
-0.0242678877,
-0.0018505406,
0.024501279,
0.0144199654,
-0.0191606786,
-0.052454073,
-0.0218430832,
-0.0065037091,
0.0184780322,
0.0180571415,
-0.0087179849,
-0.0035840096,
-0.0024334975,
0.0589313805,
0.0823383406,
-0.0108505683,
0.0094660092,
0.0240067616,
-0.0200421941,
0.0128440065,
0.0352072008,
-0.0441907048,
0.0592065156,
-0.0234237127,
-0.0139917135,
0.0471601151,
0.0131890923,
-0.0063675749,
-0.0693755895,
-0.0031191367,
-0.0126415854,
0.020431174,
0.0325358808,
0.0542508252,
-0.0166940019,
-0.0065132906,
0.0414760299,
0.0535781197,
-0.0270070862,
0.0299106427,
-0.0616588704,
0.0357054099,
0.0592058189,
0.0462653302,
-0.0563413203,
0.0015224665,
-0.0044405037,
-0.0067106737,
0.062273927,
-0.0132435095,
0.0200130474,
0.0582181998,
-0.0283310618,
-0.0475202054,
-0.0123710902,
0.027241379,
0.0116081312,
-0.0153422616,
-0.0611102656,
-0.0122768944,
-0.051089175,
-0.0336091779,
0.0366518572,
-0.0573299825,
-0.0254720524,
0.0078865048,
-0.0254136268,
0.0283224937,
-0.0183459036,
-0.0197400246,
0.0336964428,
0.0133410264,
-0.0249784347,
-0.0160675962,
0.0229874048,
-0.0222518798,
-0.0321935676,
0.0136832334,
-0.0377539285,
-0.0034565844,
0.0458164215,
-0.0155945867,
-0.0519518852,
0.0238822158,
-0.0928092599,
0.0204684585,
-0.0233320184,
-0.0211544465,
-0.0218112394,
0.0209985543,
-0.0343117751,
0.0452747494,
0.0021701287,
0.0155218355,
0.0315476023,
-0.042817615,
0.0324920453,
-0.0086232666,
-0.0050277188,
0.0026501724,
-0.0196051374,
-0.0157497432,
0.0012290847,
-0.0213327594,
-0.0293436218,
0.0023095394,
-0.0627940595,
-0.0197515991,
-0.0016691547,
0.0135092,
0.0464064889,
-0.0292207506,
0.0071616727,
-0.0046276557,
-0.0210357681,
0.002001032,
0.0177034885,
0.0016263489,
0.0438329428,
-0.003653442,
-0.0295470487,
-0.0658375099,
-0.0062866462,
-0.0605273172,
0.0770070925,
0.00706972,
0.0216871388,
-0.051787626,
-0.0058063967,
-0.0309782438,
-0.0141863441,
-0.0190496668,
-0.0506143942,
0.0433686785,
-0.0130966119,
0.0121778343,
0.0578780323,
0.0013691779,
0.0737023279,
0.0656447932,
0.0083444472,
-0.0470292531,
-0.0304665547,
-0.0374523215,
0.031586457,
-0.0378471054,
-0.0931624919,
0.0019774614,
0.120602347,
0.0496880896,
0.0045372527,
-0.0587520227,
0.0096866358,
0.0005177744,
-0.0282632746,
-0.0239289589,
-0.0168548748,
-0.0233771615,
0.0908899754,
-0.0374348797,
-0.0705437139,
0.0851361454,
-0.0412938334,
-0.0129432036,
-0.0018332675,
-0.0325466059,
-0.0416239649,
0.0744676888,
0.0149505315,
0.0084360633,
0.0301627871,
-0.0118908947,
0.0012376059,
-0.034154024,
0.0039118077,
-0.0215390157,
-0.0007402062,
-0.0535340644,
-0.022371497,
0.0301883817,
0.0253813285,
0.0024159169,
-0.0086215651,
-0.0234751254,
0.0239299722,
0.0242345016,
-0.0178260598,
-0.0581765324,
-0.0171019863,
0.0767962933,
0.0131714968,
-0.0554182678,
-0.000075011,
-0.0379808582,
0.0199639294,
0.018263286,
0.0337559097,
0.0547191389,
-0.0641835779,
-0.0301647447,
0.0310758594,
-0.0148166884,
0.0672222525,
-0.0631715804,
0.0095435102,
-0.0189134367,
-0.0007157846,
-0.003570159,
0.0155086368,
0.0397907123,
-0.062126521,
-0.0125748841,
0.1230278462,
0.0265315548,
-0.0109023927,
0.0103399958,
-0.0357512459,
0.046226982,
0.0061741183,
0.018414516,
-0.0337575935,
-0.0168254506,
-0.0035791171,
0.0302983504,
0.0044276821,
-0.0106173763,
0.0134971077,
-0.0710914582,
0.0439753719,
-0.0077949218,
-0.0588737391,
-0.0269072633,
-0.0536542051,
0.0032059166,
0.0044290721,
-0.0204825215,
-0.012516194,
0.0400892086,
0.0220703762,
0.0435943529,
-0.0402908586,
-0.0111114196,
0.046108678,
-0.0070180208,
0.0573993884,
0.0560510494,
0.049600672,
-0.0249688551,
-0.0138678662,
-0.0144956643,
0.0152874254,
0.0053093131,
-0.0020478305,
0.1015373319,
0.0465041772,
-0.0189879239,
-0.0472422913,
0.019990962,
-0.0117205624,
-0.0495797284,
-0.0748289898,
0.0750191137,
-0.0448679514,
-0.0101434439,
-0.0281094424,
0.0653359145,
-0.0076352558,
0.0876574293,
0.0708176792,
-0.0296517666,
-0.0110083064,
-0.0189602394,
0.0252003595,
-0.0566883981,
-0.0722779781,
0.0100710811,
-0.0125381239,
-0.0062446906,
-0.0330930687,
0.0029501361,
0.0567286834,
0.0007535067,
0.0152193559,
-0.0071156267,
-0.0042613717,
-0.0509247817,
-0.0393147394,
0.0825957358,
0.003890154,
0.0073170043,
0.0163925495,
-0.0429948941,
0.0161629897,
-0.0637548044,
-0.0376892351,
0.023143271,
-0.036807254,
-0.056725651,
-0.0018222486,
0.0378836282,
0.0307885967,
0.0043248036,
0.0102014635,
-0.0867606103,
0.0323790573,
0.0329680815,
-0.0283284839,
0.0211745556,
0.0075232266,
0.030213071,
-0.0028918891,
0.0240903087,
-0.0336788595,
0.0049019204,
0.0177464783,
-0.0001934167,
-0.0226887353,
0.0091465302,
0.0230262354,
-0.0041357409,
0.0647924617,
-0.0140406284,
-0.0247298069,
-0.0317326672,
-0.0088589489,
-0.006810124,
-0.007986363,
-0.0494822673,
0.0070048291,
0.0115553048,
-0.0116401771,
0.0001545542,
-0.0205183458,
-0.0463623106,
0.0258290749,
-0.0110808127,
0.0028508487,
-0.0113647478,
-0.0412960872,
-0.0334017389,
0.0271111336,
0.0036232534,
0.0047751241,
-0.0549897924,
0.0302000847,
0.0298211724,
0.0361231342,
0.0253047813,
0.0187614635,
-0.0030613495,
0.0012032009,
-0.071882762,
-0.0698950365,
0.0139714135,
0.0177067854,
-0.0073707341,
-0.0098216366,
0.0695403665,
0.0134832384,
0.0089526577,
-0.0178530347,
0.0627958328,
0.0107847964,
-0.0006368072,
0.048300758,
0.0343255289,
-0.002182754,
-0.0643235669,
0.0636692569,
0.0359963998,
0.0180889815,
0.0045862659,
-0.0176072679,
-0.0159539469,
-0.0276845954,
0.0274716578,
0.0194841735,
-0.0416451655,
0.0015841721,
-0.0444914438,
-0.0632415861,
-0.0057450077,
0.0303150415,
-0.0039212019,
-0.0426127166,
0.0171514563,
0.0316566117,
-0.0178275183,
-0.0350006558,
-0.0032968032,
0.0176733863,
-0.0294982102,
-0.0035798082,
-0.0150419641,
-6.613516358e-33,
-0.0549150407,
-0.0754212439,
0.000576114,
0.0019767813,
0.0137705533,
0.027479168,
-0.0865809172,
0.0184055865,
0.0372311324,
0.0408989713,
0.0198323764,
0.0056496472,
0.011934353,
0.0277095754,
-0.0119191958,
-0.0184491202,
-0.0145422276,
0.0049815141,
-0.0305413119,
0.0101820789,
0.0437608883,
0.0188671071,
0.1003383473,
-0.0769485012,
0.0592023507,
0.0432607755,
-0.0265765563,
0.0286381319,
-0.0359410383,
0.0486342609,
-0.0471952818,
0.0095015215,
0.0360605232,
-0.0224011727,
-0.0130039565,
0.0431613475,
-0.0447396524,
0.0025240122,
0.067899622,
-0.0122094536,
-0.0855268613,
-0.024075577,
0.0777404085,
-0.0332538933,
0.0223103929,
-0.0301614944,
0.0754873976,
-0.0376179628,
-0.0142385783,
0.0150126629,
-0.0442509465,
0.0116291046,
-0.0539599657,
-0.0273538139,
-0.0134092001,
0.0379834808,
-0.0155985989,
0.0402112789,
0.0116814263,
-0.0080315042,
0.049889598,
0.0241089575,
0.0374798328,
0.0104666864,
0.0204661749,
0.0919445455,
0.0606526546,
-0.0154869659,
-0.0787298903,
-0.0410777219,
0.0424505286,
0.0598258302,
0.0926529989,
0.0172111709,
0.0468483381,
0.0548464395,
-0.0336889885,
0.040657565,
-0.0323502459,
0.0165485945,
0.0368249416,
-0.0052426038,
0.0133132832,
-0.0054274607,
-0.0594911687,
-0.0235246234,
-0.0309580788,
-0.0127851693,
0.0012913455,
-0.04428472,
-0.0501983613,
-0.0114874467,
0.0241680797,
-0.0261025783,
0.0508514829,
-0.0263365302,
0.0072321985,
0.0118210493,
0.043434862,
0.0001490023,
-0.0142284529,
0.0053634918,
0.028011648,
-0.0121905711,
0.0582582615,
0.0089542242,
-0.0135869486,
0.0172569938,
-0.0135641564,
0.0020936222,
-0.0534131639,
-0.050383497,
-0.0191949382,
0.0384449437,
0.0055016573,
-0.0034797164,
-0.0476674177,
-0.0379900225,
0.0015128831,
0.0182069819,
-0.0418079235,
-0.0046942108,
-0.0349894427,
0.0373981483,
-0.0192482434,
-0.0359130055,
-0.0272514448,
-0.0448204204,
0.0790488273,
-0.0348351598,
-0.0187182855,
-0.0029547985,
2.755e-7,
0.1028408334,
0.0390948988,
0.0200261902,
0.0452484898,
0.0231004022,
0.0383311063,
-0.0208957866,
0.0083538247,
0.0258811656,
-0.0638507903,
-0.0143764643,
0.0595352761,
0.0627741143,
0.0122068301,
0.0029614992,
-0.0174578149,
-0.0606048629,
-0.0275024883,
-0.0382372439,
-0.0099161854,
0.0531054065,
0.0495836399,
0.008411061,
-0.0323567055,
0.0184074529,
-0.0165499877,
0.0740641579,
-0.0493311957,
0.0184938647,
0.0188112054,
0.0140312193,
-0.0079498962,
-0.0001947077,
0.0065432698,
0.0118035339,
-0.0180301834,
-0.0133249201,
0.0734281242,
-0.0265076086,
-0.039216049,
-0.012485561,
-0.0343455486,
0.0095494799,
-0.0634388402,
0.0400786512,
-0.0367191173,
-0.0481619984,
-0.0258668605,
-0.0077554742,
-0.02505555,
0.0515033156,
-0.0157260299,
-0.0022817913,
0.0316861644,
-0.0213824715,
-0.0351857319,
-0.0051473472,
-0.0603625625,
-0.0617795251,
0.006126577,
-0.0774159431,
0.003863787,
-0.0290380139,
-0.0199264139,
0.0205378942,
-0.0985437185,
-0.0118322931,
2.799477679e-34,
0.012944676,
0.0253472421,
-0.0185045656,
0.0398341641,
0.0568935908,
-0.0141549008,
0.0135068279,
0.001659464,
0.0269451216,
-0.0714837834,
-0.0182695389
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.09860v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.09860v2 | Epsilon Sampling Rocks: Investigating Sampling Strategies for Minimum Bayes Risk Decoding for Machine Translation | 2023-05-17T00:11:38 | 2023-05-18T02:24:56 | Markus Freitag, Behrooz Ghorbani, Patrick Fernandes | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Recent advances in machine translation (MT) have shown that Minimum Bayes
Risk (MBR) decoding can be a powerful alternative to beam search decoding,
especially when combined with neural-based utility functions. However, the
performance of MBR decoding depends heavily on how and how many candidates are
sampled from the model. In this paper, we explore how different sampling
approaches for generating candidate lists for MBR decoding affect performance.
We evaluate popular sampling approaches, such as ancestral, nucleus, and top-k
sampling. Based on our insights into their limitations, we experiment with the
recently proposed epsilon-sampling approach, which prunes away all tokens with
a probability smaller than epsilon, ensuring that each token in a sample
receives a fair probability mass. Through extensive human evaluations, we
demonstrate that MBR decoding based on epsilon-sampling significantly
outperforms not only beam search decoding, but also MBR decoding with all other
tested sampling methods across four language pairs. | [
0.0004456636,
0.0464283638,
-0.0109871663,
-0.0115656815,
-0.0224558376,
0.008560569,
-0.0191728659,
0.0289343782,
-0.0401548594,
0.0232306179,
-0.0305730626,
-0.0293137208,
0.0036510115,
0.0032849207,
0.007706278,
-0.0393541232,
0.0142667321,
-0.0469309725,
0.0162376408,
-0.0055687921,
-0.0330804661,
0.0264002085,
-0.0127735566,
0.0681909844,
0.0164441653,
0.0184046738,
-0.0028581496,
0.0546747744,
0.0316164121,
-0.0303829238,
-0.0384719856,
0.0298807863,
-0.0197589993,
0.0538238175,
0.0000019763,
0.0024451066,
-0.0380009115,
0.0095622661,
-0.0338448659,
-0.0049795802,
0.0725844055,
-0.0473648198,
-0.0205451585,
0.026894033,
-0.006929432,
-0.0343155079,
0.0771326572,
0.0015054352,
-0.0020754144,
0.0673140809,
0.0110204453,
0.0106105981,
0.0024029552,
-0.0365670696,
0.0119845793,
-0.0843510404,
-0.020049626,
-0.0132608851,
-0.0223199558,
0.014727138,
-0.0318685584,
0.0558880381,
0.0137520228,
0.010969569,
-0.027296517,
0.0236563552,
0.0059386371,
-0.0197271574,
-0.0308288597,
0.0343099833,
-0.0470100604,
-0.0174602456,
-0.018554749,
-0.0272862855,
-0.0266414601,
-0.0237409957,
-0.0382506363,
0.0598695129,
-0.0392089598,
0.0394741893,
0.065743342,
0.0298146904,
0.0344510898,
-0.019184472,
-0.0317135639,
0.0528223664,
0.024541853,
-0.0305805635,
0.0059144301,
0.0355848074,
0.0238169301,
-0.009938132,
0.0856314003,
-0.0607078224,
-0.0225377884,
0.0166909508,
-0.0450475067,
-0.0572487973,
-0.0126780607,
-0.0067183692,
0.0261946116,
0.0740114003,
0.0302137658,
0.0254156981,
0.0222197399,
-0.0229582302,
-0.0023068385,
0.0071273218,
-0.0436575972,
0.004128099,
0.0026700953,
0.0262018349,
-0.0474473499,
-0.0063103968,
-0.079407528,
-0.0181971509,
-0.0010436752,
-0.0039837342,
0.0494260825,
-0.0619321093,
0.0449635275,
-0.0156467725,
-0.0932017341,
0.0142793143,
0.0176703557,
0.0473850444,
-0.0344308987,
-0.0223420262,
0.0221983735,
-0.0870093182,
-0.057393264,
0.0028439057,
-0.0133290151,
-0.0509226136,
-0.0359845906,
0.0610519387,
-0.0260094386,
-0.0398177318,
-0.0072537223,
0.0036954149,
-0.0399354994,
0.0180177782,
0.0218165461,
-0.0603354014,
0.0564442463,
-0.0007243378,
0.0022196169,
-0.0112709776,
0.0008422124,
-0.0005899093,
-0.0394609943,
0.030735625,
0.0221906304,
-0.0233154036,
0.0180678759,
-0.0123957219,
-0.0343390442,
0.097385779,
0.0487037413,
0.0525761954,
0.0172533877,
0.0435465351,
-0.0256102309,
0.0541591085,
0.0113377841,
0.0227372274,
-0.0069104536,
-0.0368423685,
-0.0082686497,
0.0375231355,
0.077860333,
0.0429454967,
-0.0779126212,
-0.0091774883,
0.052008424,
0.0400414839,
-0.0066279094,
0.0070783924,
0.0075914706,
0.0060494123,
-0.0016065974,
-0.0163126271,
-0.0115219746,
0.0244081989,
-0.0071007176,
-0.0065124449,
0.0598339736,
0.0544691794,
0.0096882489,
-0.0102500133,
-0.0027149587,
-0.0096908789,
0.0043723737,
-0.0021634407,
0.0554476157,
0.0200496651,
-0.0473959483,
0.0705789775,
0.0016047577,
-0.0252928454,
0.0339495912,
-0.0194785465,
-0.0242407601,
0.0538685098,
0.0691018924,
0.0043949182,
-0.0184944589,
-0.0145156551,
-0.0551545322,
0.0224870872,
0.0465216152,
0.0195208155,
0.0601720661,
-0.0499049947,
-0.026076911,
0.0481992625,
0.02368862,
0.0584645756,
-0.0106690871,
0.02325866,
0.0034717151,
-0.0602418184,
-0.0794319808,
0.0398850851,
-0.0044714855,
-0.0140797226,
0.0576073639,
-0.0143819917,
0.0338906348,
0.0152444802,
-0.0232516751,
0.0108722849,
0.0056112763,
-0.0366755575,
-0.0073998547,
-0.0041249744,
-0.0484009199,
-0.09406434,
0.0096336892,
-0.0574732833,
-0.011521738,
-0.0062536681,
-0.0335738547,
-0.0268140435,
0.0177922286,
-0.054489769,
0.0047435495,
-0.0390684307,
0.0219430961,
0.0266645718,
0.0128341187,
-0.0409853086,
0.0174988769,
-0.0400185697,
-0.0452973805,
0.0002130308,
-0.0381122604,
-0.0014298359,
-0.1057272851,
-0.0165857617,
0.0233415086,
0.0166477822,
0.0203440897,
0.0343978666,
0.0417816788,
0.0026403868,
-0.0300017912,
-0.0551348701,
0.0168454386,
-0.0302947853,
0.0272424277,
0.0145511562,
0.0551388301,
-0.004500065,
-0.022096118,
0.0124503672,
-0.01369844,
-0.0211242083,
0.0240455959,
-0.0057298159,
0.0143806124,
0.0367789045,
-0.0094529418,
-0.0397144333,
-0.0079688486,
0.0463974401,
-0.0001996858,
-0.0114451954,
-0.0720945746,
0.0350711904,
0.0300139636,
-0.0159743223,
0.0154032931,
-0.0388576463,
0.01388482,
-0.051408641,
0.0157118458,
0.053524781,
-0.0086004445,
0.0141703067,
0.0082996581,
0.0171732418,
-0.0620738789,
-0.0142827043,
-0.030013727,
0.0075579518,
-0.0229260009,
-0.0615905225,
0.0500394143,
0.0394872688,
0.0384928547,
0.0109969582,
-0.0591077916,
0.0308266878,
0.0113028008,
-0.0612223707,
0.0124539454,
0.0362792127,
-0.0093408357,
0.0595464259,
-0.0344205573,
-0.0130842505,
0.0754024237,
-0.0201342292,
-0.0176475644,
-0.0717237368,
0.0195941292,
-0.0168231111,
-0.0145111009,
-0.0198844988,
0.0245797336,
-0.0201899782,
-0.0788535774,
-0.0196709875,
0.0130522829,
0.0159852561,
-0.0156362262,
0.0376165658,
-0.0542633869,
-0.01194508,
-0.0070159677,
-0.0104321577,
-0.0113463942,
0.0051173298,
0.0036633022,
0.004375794,
0.0142482277,
-0.0112665715,
-0.035580311,
0.0088489372,
0.0009666223,
0.036776159,
-0.0276868064,
-0.0019912445,
-0.0274478532,
0.0469711088,
0.0315058567,
-0.0348059013,
0.064883478,
-0.0397244357,
-0.0177872181,
0.0384742916,
0.0491944924,
0.0225634258,
-0.0206039492,
0.00192522,
0.0530581288,
0.0017774719,
-0.0251029339,
0.015903458,
0.0315894112,
-0.0406491384,
-0.0073328828,
0.0815431476,
-0.0007092702,
-0.0384672396,
-0.0022180136,
-0.0014105266,
0.0416904874,
-0.0178132225,
0.0186662525,
-0.0665133074,
-0.0264889523,
0.0213521421,
0.0719162896,
0.02244596,
-0.0212433487,
0.0189304333,
-0.1054850519,
0.0453288481,
0.0489244089,
-0.0821161121,
-0.0404984243,
0.0040051783,
-0.037657328,
-0.0679151639,
0.0447935686,
0.0390012898,
0.0377227589,
0.0157201272,
0.0286951773,
0.0313133299,
-0.0747351274,
-0.0227479041,
-0.0824505091,
0.0441007428,
0.0959321707,
0.03527008,
0.0095114503,
-0.0125327734,
-0.0128828641,
-0.0278456844,
0.0015233345,
-0.0231577307,
0.0037527841,
0.0115494691,
-0.0071557127,
0.045071587,
0.0002774664,
-0.0091481255,
0.0225993153,
-0.0096545666,
0.0541918948,
-0.0525048748,
-0.0088133467,
0.0074965786,
-0.0163138751,
0.0480306931,
0.0564390868,
0.0179551914,
-0.0244901907,
-0.011747146,
-0.0770878494,
0.0212259013,
-0.076988928,
0.0201908406,
0.0139825214,
-0.0225124806,
-0.0798201263,
-0.0867352411,
-0.044823207,
0.0243417807,
0.0670051649,
-0.0113905426,
0.0057733986,
-0.0027006397,
0.0055434438,
0.0150707457,
0.016793279,
-0.0552144088,
-0.0417130254,
-0.0097878538,
0.0265696198,
-0.0509818271,
-0.0558432415,
-0.0193418916,
0.0545849688,
-0.0605070852,
-0.0478429534,
-0.0025632747,
0.0734016523,
0.0291309003,
0.0239930544,
-0.0427320935,
-0.0527352542,
0.0357755162,
0.0407915451,
-0.0133581981,
-0.012103036,
0.0065583996,
-0.0145238824,
-0.0161331221,
0.0325364769,
-0.0387949571,
-0.0189986415,
-0.0166365281,
0.0968413576,
-0.0316311605,
-0.0163201764,
0.0200532712,
0.0032838099,
0.0404148027,
-0.0660436973,
-0.0383518413,
-0.0314423293,
0.024346292,
0.0007114023,
0.0382229127,
-0.0162606351,
0.0059388406,
0.0671084449,
-0.0088622067,
-0.0029561478,
-0.0090491772,
0.0066899233,
0.0192555636,
0.0194107182,
0.0069350381,
0.0215196852,
0.0628118962,
0.0523332767,
-0.0018773527,
0.0006119849,
0.015755197,
0.0172578432,
0.0230004098,
-0.0341689289,
0.0082992725,
0.0186547078,
0.0092221703,
-0.0054829665,
0.0025114708,
-0.0721373409,
-0.0271227695,
-0.02803744,
-0.0007847083,
0.0640109181,
0.0014659632,
0.0987373367,
-0.0085498514,
-0.0043834504,
-0.0309756622,
0.0078311134,
0.038435284,
-0.0023694425,
-0.0023600131,
-0.0034255907,
0.0082247891,
0.0011644787,
0.0619655922,
-0.0409937389,
0.0357063189,
-0.0432771705,
-0.0149163287,
-0.0044185747,
-0.023827536,
-0.0245120451,
0.0116117522,
-0.0292207897,
-0.0389137007,
-0.0591476858,
-0.00560197,
0.0352930166,
0.0286861435,
0.0140981823,
-0.0212039091,
0.0305647105,
0.0562252663,
-0.049393788,
0.019757133,
-0.031169381,
-0.0197249707,
-0.0203345772,
-0.0434530526,
-0.0614528731,
-6.671586514e-33,
-0.0187125243,
0.0176156275,
-0.0017959747,
-0.028323045,
-0.018855935,
-0.0196632519,
-0.0479252748,
-0.043869894,
0.0119642923,
0.0008059649,
-0.0180693176,
0.0023030217,
0.032658197,
0.0078920247,
0.0231545754,
0.0016156386,
0.0545899011,
-0.0306809135,
-0.0305928271,
0.0075426362,
0.0414782986,
0.0474436246,
0.0537258424,
-0.0099187605,
0.0085430034,
0.0334586501,
0.0035812492,
-0.0049377349,
0.0102715911,
0.0597005151,
0.0165393315,
0.0235960223,
-0.0031402532,
-0.0714781061,
-0.0326516032,
-0.0379499123,
-0.0879677609,
0.0022906037,
-0.0027971086,
0.0370240211,
0.0331575386,
-0.0397542939,
0.0114651648,
-0.0168502033,
-0.0213363376,
-0.0020831001,
-0.0231893156,
-0.0503041856,
-0.0659747198,
-0.0413917638,
-0.0021207971,
0.0216930415,
-0.0000667048,
0.0452867299,
0.0352451615,
0.0097659696,
-0.0323556773,
0.0107322643,
-0.0405574962,
0.0155239683,
0.0158995949,
0.0628754795,
0.0606777407,
0.0108949486,
-0.0052555157,
0.0280856956,
0.0572347976,
-0.0387929231,
0.0327752307,
-0.009483235,
0.0484536327,
-0.023744639,
-0.0052679656,
0.030544715,
0.061742764,
0.0032930926,
-0.0360015333,
0.0351378359,
0.0720260814,
0.0068041515,
0.0266407933,
0.0490424596,
-0.0412876308,
-0.0157274287,
-0.0523135662,
-0.1157555059,
-0.0352146737,
-0.0298586059,
0.0181011464,
0.0269356743,
-0.0336653069,
-0.0104011195,
0.1022941917,
-0.013860492,
0.0435091928,
-0.0054200632,
0.0111876447,
0.0023255518,
-0.0222139005,
0.0195152331,
-0.0067766639,
-0.0003405436,
0.0435416251,
-0.0342656933,
-0.0101507679,
-0.021107737,
0.0094548697,
0.0036713991,
-0.0306312256,
0.0073026707,
-0.0407069586,
0.0278563742,
0.0217750948,
0.0409892797,
0.0578685068,
-0.023587212,
0.0301069487,
0.0027527313,
0.0176367555,
0.0031374632,
-0.0218890142,
0.022050716,
0.021882331,
0.0216812175,
-0.0442737378,
0.0311909784,
-0.0288976002,
-0.0016779997,
0.0209082104,
-0.0578020103,
-0.0505835563,
0.0777568221,
2.7e-7,
0.0536624976,
0.061741706,
0.0624983869,
0.0105091389,
0.0246733259,
0.0158401933,
0.0016400148,
0.0156432725,
0.0079732053,
0.0603101216,
0.0135276318,
0.0064462237,
0.0899370238,
0.0431289487,
-0.12883313,
-0.0299217887,
-0.0048782956,
0.0206294488,
-0.0364902839,
-0.0255778506,
0.0166417006,
0.0828066915,
-0.0221410785,
-0.0208347254,
0.0163817499,
-0.0252097528,
0.0300847143,
0.0046373401,
-0.0154707842,
0.0120338732,
-0.0055828928,
0.013417325,
-0.0190659128,
-0.0076856678,
-0.0236864425,
-0.0225806367,
0.0324990787,
0.0591337197,
0.0129171927,
-0.0635727942,
0.040672835,
0.0110862572,
-0.0016670455,
-0.0183354076,
0.0204958618,
-0.0127470577,
0.0242269412,
0.0071505071,
-0.0346844457,
-0.0021498308,
-0.0274868254,
-0.0464841053,
-0.0012056095,
0.0093837986,
0.0284813475,
0.0203289315,
-0.0117148431,
0.0024517819,
-0.0030867381,
-0.0220752247,
-0.0115382783,
-0.0658975989,
-0.0067807236,
0.0368849374,
0.0265208147,
-0.0541296378,
-0.0461722463,
2.809605986e-34,
0.0577624403,
-0.0207635462,
-0.0001356216,
0.0302055143,
0.0343547128,
-0.0120521681,
0.0006235402,
0.0206543673,
0.0040960643,
-0.0549172573,
-0.0579326116
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.09859v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.09859v4 | Smaller Language Models are Better Black-box Machine-Generated Text Detectors | 2023-05-17T00:09:08 | 2024-02-24T19:47:14 | Niloofar Mireshghallah, Justus Mattern, Sicun Gao, Reza Shokri, Taylor Berg-Kirkpatrick | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | With the advent of fluent generative language models that can produce
convincing utterances very similar to those written by humans, distinguishing
whether a piece of text is machine-generated or human-written becomes more
challenging and more important, as such models could be used to spread
misinformation, fake news, fake reviews and to mimic certain authors and
figures. To this end, there have been a slew of methods proposed to detect
machine-generated text. Most of these methods need access to the logits of the
target model or need the ability to sample from the target. One such black-box
detection method relies on the observation that generated text is locally
optimal under the likelihood function of the generator, while human-written
text is not. We find that overall, smaller and partially-trained models are
better universal text detectors: they can more precisely detect text generated
from both small and larger models. Interestingly, we find that whether the
detector and generator were trained on the same data is not critically
important to the detection success. For instance the OPT-125M model has an AUC
of 0.81 in detecting ChatGPT generations, whereas a larger model from the GPT
family, GPTJ-6B, has AUC of 0.45. | [
0.0451487303,
0.0563133433,
-0.013752616,
0.0558665842,
-0.0525436401,
0.015765246,
0.037032716,
0.0618155114,
-0.0014420496,
-0.0294631999,
0.0150973266,
-0.0417312533,
-0.0090024574,
0.0689147934,
0.0357791409,
0.0076474827,
0.0258779023,
0.004507476,
0.0173783489,
0.0018945261,
0.0158662349,
0.0250293091,
0.0257145371,
0.0472093709,
-0.011302093,
-0.0186298285,
0.0166856032,
0.024281228,
0.0355118997,
0.0089325393,
0.0024381394,
0.0513105877,
0.0082936333,
0.1187510565,
0.0000018889,
0.003975118,
-0.0273283776,
-0.009345375,
-0.0393844396,
-0.0012861771,
0.0891920626,
-0.0043522371,
-0.0510239899,
0.038476266,
-0.02970949,
-0.0325289145,
0.0276454445,
0.0556199886,
0.0061521055,
0.1076391786,
-0.0251048766,
0.019200068,
0.0753077939,
-0.0007917388,
0.0075259549,
0.0022653982,
0.0186976288,
-0.0021403355,
-0.0168382451,
0.0313936546,
0.0296316873,
0.0205811393,
0.0248819683,
-0.0467869043,
-0.0264938772,
0.0278173741,
-0.0142185036,
-0.0157055706,
0.0037855844,
-0.0120722959,
-0.0382195525,
-0.0595101304,
0.0232221819,
-0.0115646068,
0.0232893042,
0.0334114507,
0.0281353649,
0.0311668757,
-0.0496278405,
0.0042729066,
0.0126294419,
-0.0117418068,
0.0132493386,
0.0099174418,
0.022608228,
0.0244531482,
0.0183136463,
-0.0448526703,
-0.0139039,
-0.0033581113,
0.0119825769,
-0.0476058386,
0.0181500483,
-0.0017398004,
0.0239159986,
-0.0103420764,
-0.0842478499,
-0.0175598413,
0.0040336903,
-0.0384737067,
0.0222625751,
-0.0064542764,
-0.0164855812,
0.0332861952,
-0.0515031368,
0.0507917851,
-0.0373107456,
0.0337544382,
-0.0118118459,
0.0263555665,
-0.0043000602,
-0.0291246586,
-0.029263543,
-0.0154044898,
-0.0160560329,
-0.0294605903,
-0.0574409403,
-0.0004221,
0.0086542219,
0.0007980424,
-0.0332821459,
-0.0145016368,
-0.0226263274,
-0.024880439,
0.0141679486,
-0.0215085652,
0.0235160422,
0.0164552666,
-0.0144450413,
-0.0962426439,
-0.0258482415,
0.0688456148,
0.0155140162,
0.0119881677,
-0.0069612944,
0.0297848172,
-0.0127175888,
-0.0314074159,
-0.0270745177,
-0.0513412431,
-0.0560659207,
-0.050068751,
0.0082012219,
-0.0510183908,
-0.0514168479,
-0.0293105971,
-0.0068978886,
-0.030638203,
-0.0045353319,
0.0151570663,
0.0114733018,
0.0216670204,
-0.0071968539,
-0.0153473504,
0.0416758731,
-0.0043750037,
-0.0055245142,
0.0590904765,
0.0220314041,
0.0906531811,
0.0268306062,
0.0055730715,
0.038630005,
0.0459537506,
0.0236803908,
0.0224785209,
0.0077955923,
-0.0444441698,
-0.016284151,
-0.0137263341,
0.0234605763,
0.0390235037,
-0.0211283732,
-0.0396636799,
0.1036128178,
0.0154545307,
-0.0175103247,
0.0201174188,
0.0671580359,
0.0359656848,
-0.0098674884,
0.0602663457,
0.0283626784,
-0.035174679,
-0.0686224774,
-0.0286932252,
0.0394799039,
0.0271406155,
0.0154789146,
-0.0258852895,
-0.0138124488,
-0.0101696532,
-0.0229686853,
-0.0491511375,
0.0457175598,
0.0241932552,
-0.0423444137,
-0.0368806086,
0.0152264666,
-0.0202897675,
-0.0094152708,
-0.0955105796,
0.044858221,
0.0137086837,
0.0428467244,
0.0441173986,
0.0600001141,
-0.0528280661,
-0.0362307839,
0.0671108067,
0.0158810932,
0.0073505891,
-0.0236021169,
-0.0034264512,
-0.0173369609,
-0.005517507,
0.0282026362,
0.0246033967,
0.0579111576,
0.0167138502,
0.0276569352,
-0.0043341294,
-0.0419151038,
0.0231915396,
-0.037556015,
-0.0273877811,
-0.013571105,
-0.0072695799,
0.0587249584,
-0.0067917891,
-0.0280403346,
0.0068112807,
0.0207876954,
-0.0457057655,
-0.0466864742,
0.0128031252,
-0.012511027,
-0.0290833078,
-0.0050544371,
-0.0373750813,
0.0125872251,
0.0262133405,
-0.0078935437,
-0.0088109802,
0.0161404405,
-0.0672573075,
0.0308942422,
-0.0760393888,
0.0212215539,
-0.0376089998,
0.0258693825,
0.0000430924,
0.0731949136,
-0.0141752856,
-0.0113494024,
0.0159577485,
-0.0031699894,
0.0393824838,
-0.0372931361,
-0.0059033385,
-0.020809859,
-0.0182721913,
0.0003153612,
0.0423125066,
0.011187952,
-0.0014641359,
-0.0347907618,
-0.0599536598,
-0.01303853,
-0.0352181308,
-0.0035559263,
0.0473548919,
-0.0225579329,
-0.0203136411,
0.0108099803,
-0.0240065288,
-0.0071351067,
0.0427261889,
-0.0011008065,
0.007886624,
-0.0198710728,
0.0122927753,
-0.0160633586,
0.0248693917,
-0.002030235,
0.0538989827,
0.0474039838,
-0.027176166,
-0.0838874876,
0.0625923648,
0.002030089,
0.0145464288,
-0.0187643785,
-0.052539099,
-0.0031795187,
-0.0057262438,
0.0454300605,
0.0813451484,
0.0513677225,
0.0364495292,
-0.0047335587,
0.0721594393,
-0.0148244929,
-0.0267094485,
-0.0088217342,
0.0033484353,
-0.0313900635,
-0.0837019756,
0.0419355109,
0.0580808371,
0.0314069241,
-0.0014960737,
-0.0250123683,
0.0444561914,
-0.0111368112,
-0.0341706276,
0.0237296596,
-0.0503389686,
-0.0533712171,
0.014626544,
-0.0261942875,
-0.0893197656,
0.0531474091,
-0.0472646058,
0.0229607821,
-0.0060767811,
-0.0436062664,
0.008208828,
0.0143013513,
0.0502237864,
0.0398394726,
0.0192864407,
0.0050154394,
-0.0211124029,
0.0218511391,
0.0590096824,
-0.0237629507,
-0.0272713844,
-0.0026509005,
0.0323257782,
-0.0002903187,
-0.0286485516,
-0.0457311198,
-0.049263332,
0.0068795313,
-0.0244796891,
0.0508413389,
-0.0578240342,
-0.0386218987,
0.0204968732,
0.016595209,
0.0634497479,
-0.0403257571,
0.0076165358,
-0.0187402517,
0.0667758957,
0.0463933423,
-0.0726418272,
0.0364338048,
-0.0514139645,
-0.0053118989,
0.0503699593,
-0.0013014965,
0.0400249287,
-0.0259269681,
-0.0609898195,
0.0021741507,
0.0329958871,
-0.0260215476,
0.0111724846,
0.0265078079,
-0.0365070365,
-0.0132093141,
0.0948545113,
-0.0166987423,
-0.0240297411,
-0.0177948102,
0.0038977978,
0.0445500501,
-0.0080447039,
-0.0230060183,
-0.0702709705,
-0.0028735509,
0.0166045334,
0.0224470496,
-0.0690928325,
0.0016971992,
-0.0145876408,
-0.1058356091,
0.0282215644,
0.0301188901,
-0.0361219682,
-0.0323305577,
-0.0086560985,
-0.0239306502,
0.0031297444,
-0.0173300505,
-0.0002053923,
-0.0009186254,
-0.0012256465,
0.0018496256,
-0.0292583928,
-0.0434346758,
-0.0189955216,
-0.0210568532,
0.0406313837,
0.055413276,
0.0343754068,
0.0044378745,
-0.0253215488,
0.0229044147,
0.0233896989,
-0.019454537,
0.0072330167,
0.0795843378,
-0.020838026,
-0.0081025138,
0.0020207241,
0.0414455831,
0.0160181299,
0.0260175187,
-0.0065372139,
0.0208636671,
-0.0056940275,
-0.0961789712,
-0.0152306762,
0.0162866432,
0.0240678098,
0.0666974261,
0.0364156887,
-0.0163814351,
-0.0579352565,
-0.0215170383,
0.0616514646,
-0.070940122,
-0.0403980389,
0.0228313878,
0.0090179434,
-0.079950124,
-0.0719738752,
-0.0044268258,
-0.0408840068,
0.0225964375,
0.0020491446,
0.0091141267,
-0.0052486416,
-0.0091630258,
-0.0263697542,
-0.0352118909,
-0.0471948646,
-0.0055519422,
-0.0562330522,
-0.0227161422,
-0.0012868947,
-0.0350629315,
-0.0352260284,
0.0368619598,
-0.1036259905,
-0.0448133089,
0.0019954699,
0.010544545,
0.0229572207,
0.0287301298,
-0.0092508094,
-0.0490060002,
0.0875340477,
0.0207194183,
-0.0237725582,
0.0113712838,
0.0158961713,
-0.0261231437,
-0.0214879047,
0.0117016202,
-0.0082941055,
0.0520503148,
0.0348247103,
-0.0506701656,
-0.040760573,
-0.016695518,
0.035513062,
0.0149275763,
0.0208697207,
-0.0319624431,
0.0149561847,
-0.0353475362,
-0.0121370992,
-0.0015118392,
0.0100009413,
-0.0488701239,
0.0245345011,
0.0270174593,
0.008972805,
-0.0027803243,
-0.0147094959,
-0.0519079417,
0.0681850091,
-0.0423424058,
-0.0188261028,
0.0112540964,
0.0786851794,
0.0253266059,
-0.0229578465,
-0.0088909594,
0.0599298812,
-0.0002535142,
0.0224364717,
-0.000030501,
0.0414390564,
0.0115449196,
-0.0283978246,
0.0435390435,
0.0203767847,
-0.0779625624,
0.0065630083,
-0.0736000314,
0.0469067954,
0.035588067,
0.0090243826,
0.0425295383,
-0.0402888097,
-0.0122934254,
-0.0218846146,
0.0193951633,
0.0251474138,
-0.0537102856,
-0.0184784476,
0.000265239,
-0.052648779,
0.0308536813,
0.0723462924,
0.0635777339,
0.0468317829,
0.0048652729,
-0.0418672375,
-0.0562994666,
-0.0194859188,
0.0217416678,
-0.0226804391,
0.0056066187,
0.0355324745,
-0.0470911451,
-0.0378079638,
0.0005955285,
0.0130624203,
0.0358606689,
0.0022278279,
-0.0185623057,
0.0551889203,
-0.0402688868,
0.0029111169,
-0.0401688069,
0.0146639524,
-0.0060320809,
0.0055107791,
-0.0086475918,
-5.882565318e-33,
-0.012728638,
-0.0771219805,
-0.0516121686,
-0.0106310537,
0.0172871687,
0.0292069782,
-0.0082544815,
-0.0251640137,
-0.002477891,
0.0273898002,
0.0036454375,
0.0277183726,
0.0067129559,
0.0251385346,
-0.0517068021,
0.0077509927,
0.0678907409,
-0.0224398114,
-0.0450087339,
0.0531719774,
0.063617453,
-0.0058368659,
0.0231442507,
-0.0430608988,
0.0398628004,
-0.0386190452,
-0.0461421199,
-0.0278400891,
-0.0463126302,
0.0601920336,
-0.0190164894,
0.0268255658,
0.0175854526,
-0.0111109782,
-0.0164735932,
0.0309243742,
0.0119065642,
0.0221736096,
-0.0039333492,
-0.019759303,
-0.0149820624,
-0.0530481786,
0.0357104391,
-0.0327012427,
-0.0479924902,
0.0076698232,
0.0395819396,
-0.0371357799,
-0.0098885037,
-0.0477292165,
-0.0576963089,
0.0307583883,
0.0112757925,
0.0132587468,
0.0019128949,
0.0552710034,
0.0202014297,
-0.002558751,
-0.0351705626,
0.0300924871,
0.0451339483,
0.0408130214,
0.0109197656,
0.0114068938,
-0.0186082516,
0.0488748737,
0.0297776889,
-0.0081994832,
-0.0207911897,
-0.010373896,
-0.0063959607,
0.0025959515,
0.0706376284,
0.096153982,
0.0422120653,
-0.0433036648,
-0.0554346517,
0.0207955148,
0.007232605,
-0.0045081931,
0.0710332543,
-0.0145675633,
-0.0472261645,
0.0070703961,
-0.0122482497,
-0.0864733979,
-0.0083136838,
-0.0169546492,
0.0161400139,
0.0539764725,
-0.0429640822,
-0.0411073938,
0.0279607736,
-0.0504401214,
0.0265110619,
0.0163523965,
-0.0539925806,
-0.0158987436,
0.0165628698,
0.048246894,
-0.0169041865,
-0.0097803259,
0.0701549798,
0.0298777781,
0.0170064718,
-0.0162212383,
0.0456633978,
0.0236389376,
-0.0807124898,
0.0204654466,
-0.0255525056,
0.0408200845,
-0.0036217191,
0.0070818197,
0.0285300501,
-0.0412772745,
-0.0072400845,
-0.005793978,
0.0133312,
0.0006047707,
-0.0269870665,
0.0008505196,
-0.0256410521,
0.018597411,
-0.0368146412,
0.024971297,
-0.0124819269,
0.0251601245,
0.0425012037,
-0.0433659367,
0.0269225203,
-0.0198553912,
2.59e-7,
0.0050708796,
0.0265377294,
0.0351441354,
-0.025899047,
0.0419136584,
0.0496635698,
0.0260600504,
0.0081260595,
-0.0122902188,
-0.0153455604,
-0.0234239157,
-0.0029982112,
0.0826766491,
0.001651365,
-0.0697750524,
0.0289155096,
-0.1064226404,
0.0221029557,
-0.0627265647,
-0.0049333726,
0.0660255328,
0.0704149455,
0.0068701995,
-0.0374601595,
0.0276736505,
-0.083101593,
0.0606676191,
-0.0067672636,
-0.0136194564,
0.0143837333,
0.0630992129,
0.0066198446,
-0.0024032001,
0.0149869034,
-0.0208920166,
-0.0077787861,
-0.0221899655,
0.0755070895,
0.0227229912,
0.0294057019,
-0.0114157395,
0.001956556,
0.0074891732,
-0.0667393655,
0.065571636,
0.0050921845,
-0.0031217602,
-0.0778940246,
-0.0251127407,
-0.0487493724,
0.0250531361,
-0.0362415649,
-0.024670396,
0.0215464365,
-0.0019090298,
0.0184553452,
0.007214353,
-0.0185351949,
-0.0079626245,
-0.0316637643,
-0.0523769595,
-0.0349729992,
-0.0654481202,
0.009999969,
0.0349468626,
-0.0275717359,
0.0408486575,
2.546991594e-34,
0.0304514989,
-0.0127791474,
-0.0117802201,
-0.0063244468,
0.0386057422,
0.0160411317,
0.0237541236,
-0.0038769192,
0.0018914334,
-0.0289479624,
0.0025466259
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.09858v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.09858v1 | Knowledge Graph Completion Models are Few-shot Learners: An Empirical Study of Relation Labeling in E-commerce with LLMs | 2023-05-17T00:08:36 | 2023-05-17T00:08:36 | Jiao Chen, Luyi Ma, Xiaohan Li, Nikhil Thakurdesai, Jianpeng Xu, Jason H. D. Cho, Kaushiki Nag, Evren Korpeoglu, Sushant Kumar, Kannan Achan | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Knowledge Graphs (KGs) play a crucial role in enhancing e-commerce system
performance by providing structured information about entities and their
relationships, such as complementary or substitutable relations between
products or product types, which can be utilized in recommender systems.
However, relation labeling in KGs remains a challenging task due to the dynamic
nature of e-commerce domains and the associated cost of human labor. Recently,
breakthroughs in Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown surprising results in
numerous natural language processing tasks. In this paper, we conduct an
empirical study of LLMs for relation labeling in e-commerce KGs, investigating
their powerful learning capabilities in natural language and effectiveness in
predicting relations between product types with limited labeled data. We
evaluate various LLMs, including PaLM and GPT-3.5, on benchmark datasets,
demonstrating their ability to achieve competitive performance compared to
humans on relation labeling tasks using just 1 to 5 labeled examples per
relation. Additionally, we experiment with different prompt engineering
techniques to examine their impact on model performance. Our results show that
LLMs significantly outperform existing KG completion models in relation
labeling for e-commerce KGs and exhibit performance strong enough to replace
human labeling. | [
0.087801531,
-0.0083349543,
0.0081783487,
0.0304463357,
-0.022452781,
-0.0056361016,
0.0169859845,
0.0195429735,
0.0802975446,
-0.075162515,
-0.0250459947,
0.0118073076,
-0.0360232741,
0.0353762396,
-0.0173756033,
-0.0255808439,
0.0262594651,
0.0106860306,
0.0091336714,
-0.0016623086,
-0.0124939913,
0.0422276258,
0.0097303279,
0.0057258816,
0.0082593793,
-0.0291910749,
0.0178525187,
-0.0141019206,
-0.0135069638,
-0.0383162126,
0.0212280937,
0.0421994776,
-0.0070216395,
-0.0024393017,
0.0000018593,
-0.0790313855,
-0.0049539972,
0.0007420799,
-0.0636164993,
0.0165731795,
-0.0103872353,
-0.0016552459,
0.0670374185,
0.024011407,
-0.0376438722,
-0.0249428153,
0.0279806852,
0.0925393328,
-0.0140135717,
0.0378300063,
-0.0150003638,
-0.0445386358,
0.0226528589,
-0.0570024475,
0.0309444647,
-0.0436954014,
0.0460047051,
-0.0287188366,
0.0275408681,
0.0207644869,
-0.0122887408,
0.008820409,
-0.0003424302,
0.012233167,
0.0665155202,
0.0582778566,
-0.0010916119,
0.0072706733,
0.0000548694,
0.1089073345,
0.0380965583,
0.0307669248,
-0.0060362113,
-0.0009523843,
-0.0105488831,
0.0182756912,
0.0101272408,
-0.0406851135,
-0.0501387082,
-0.00836471,
-0.0263382029,
-0.0118493224,
0.0459902287,
0.0213310216,
0.0009267326,
0.1035400555,
0.0071739675,
-0.0504171997,
0.0351018086,
-0.0010884956,
-0.0265246984,
-0.045639392,
0.0104726646,
0.0062862858,
-0.0552850328,
0.0430129133,
-0.0021515044,
0.0600988008,
-0.0013738092,
-0.0291159563,
-0.0146620478,
0.0001739561,
0.026128998,
0.0843287557,
-0.030766286,
0.026405381,
0.0098239556,
-0.0135702603,
-0.040068794,
0.0125725335,
-0.0574190728,
0.000983719,
-0.0346651338,
0.0412937291,
-0.0209058076,
-0.0384677947,
-0.0600339472,
0.0023467417,
-0.0267479401,
0.0571625642,
0.0319911428,
0.0157443229,
0.003027566,
-0.0384943299,
-0.072872676,
0.0294303764,
-0.0494321585,
0.0309784375,
-0.0205728188,
0.003281876,
0.0222949479,
-0.0188912954,
0.0190650001,
-0.0676484108,
0.0166221932,
0.0546201952,
0.0254846346,
-0.0416568369,
-0.0559548661,
-0.0530973598,
-0.0221836474,
-0.0546420366,
-0.0141815189,
-0.0487853996,
0.0427943431,
0.0562140197,
0.0017578013,
-0.0306627154,
0.0368330218,
-0.0174908005,
-0.0550554506,
0.0958226845,
-0.0327330679,
-0.0149163865,
-0.0125609832,
-0.0144419987,
-0.0327592008,
-0.006793004,
-0.0002474696,
0.0195207503,
0.0519072376,
-0.0085741971,
-0.0002238429,
0.0072114426,
-0.010808547,
-0.0458363593,
-0.0123049868,
0.0076851705,
0.0039396435,
0.0345433652,
0.024700094,
0.0343711562,
-0.0198817346,
-0.0155342938,
0.0701967627,
0.0066705733,
-0.0121898418,
0.0504165329,
0.038476523,
0.0315299258,
0.0182080958,
-0.0031334262,
-0.0393287316,
-0.0003522461,
-0.0335864089,
0.0160284117,
-0.0097667873,
0.0113684097,
-0.0307634417,
-0.0090400185,
0.0112346392,
-0.028337596,
0.0147200488,
0.0331442617,
0.0786202028,
0.0159642994,
-0.0342388302,
0.0043386393,
0.0367335454,
0.0121430559,
-0.0021917601,
-0.0010718902,
0.030052593,
0.1176800728,
0.0463759415,
-0.0397705436,
-0.0341510475,
-0.0300000291,
-0.015892623,
0.012042366,
0.0421602018,
-0.0327984132,
-0.0084766001,
-0.0409671701,
-0.0651811138,
0.006099835,
-0.0112639964,
0.0267562047,
0.0491169952,
-0.0002599995,
0.0227663349,
-0.0489418283,
0.0341199562,
-0.0017862291,
-0.0126010263,
-0.032900136,
0.0405344367,
0.0343165621,
0.0229852851,
0.0224932879,
0.0059833718,
-0.0038623435,
0.0145929679,
-0.0252808388,
-0.0480352826,
-0.0199318808,
0.0145238573,
-0.0293345693,
0.0527423956,
0.0065649264,
-0.0321944132,
-0.0222083759,
-0.0214688778,
-0.0405608565,
-0.0167130437,
-0.006702119,
0.071029067,
0.0035332241,
-0.0035582457,
0.0201715101,
-0.0174228586,
-0.0167706218,
0.0908055827,
0.0180768929,
0.029631447,
-0.0063634575,
-0.0701612309,
-0.037127737,
0.0084026437,
-0.0300957412,
0.0008683557,
0.0183050279,
0.0058997707,
0.044869788,
-0.0188545901,
-0.0538078211,
0.0052756593,
-0.0755994022,
0.0106242951,
0.0497462116,
0.0163702536,
-0.0539449304,
0.0135372384,
0.0074336692,
-0.0240474716,
-0.0048844418,
0.0405146554,
-0.0483255237,
0.0158656258,
0.0240761116,
0.0320660956,
-0.0419843495,
-0.0005868691,
-0.0280752182,
-0.0019766684,
0.031870164,
0.0209547617,
-0.0265918877,
-0.0074819378,
0.0449956022,
-0.0342715494,
0.0001917186,
-0.0150265647,
0.0346224904,
-0.0412582755,
0.010599616,
0.0498799756,
0.0072891749,
-0.0329374485,
-0.0010290436,
0.0182672776,
-0.0118385907,
-0.0516163148,
0.0183083657,
-0.0324365906,
-0.022980243,
-0.0253751464,
0.0105573619,
-0.045873791,
0.0739015862,
-0.0315753408,
-0.0037358254,
-0.0375646353,
-0.0217278767,
0.0278942939,
-0.0077231061,
-0.060454946,
0.0135277929,
0.0144428229,
-0.0056506786,
-0.066498816,
-0.027081931,
0.0602868758,
0.0344918631,
0.0184996054,
0.0118526146,
0.0037525557,
-0.0276261736,
0.0502473898,
0.0294040795,
0.0089352485,
0.0017480765,
-0.0456649922,
-0.0389248133,
0.0362772197,
0.0671443865,
-0.0140137048,
0.0122186774,
-0.0197114907,
0.0282340143,
0.0090539372,
-0.0306529235,
-0.0391091034,
-0.0245285165,
-0.0471919551,
0.0105638662,
0.0006668639,
-0.0036703639,
-0.0142936809,
-0.002846139,
0.01328706,
0.0146561069,
0.0139179146,
-0.0440214016,
-0.01711585,
0.0216454044,
0.0568773337,
-0.0501425005,
-0.0007246656,
-0.0105690323,
0.0386745445,
0.0076377452,
0.0060080425,
-0.0390194878,
-0.0070398259,
-0.0019052905,
0.0147428084,
-0.0705105513,
-0.0439611189,
0.0611509643,
-0.0427196808,
-0.03081044,
0.026707856,
0.1088144183,
0.0108993864,
-0.0565644465,
-0.007516217,
0.0564017147,
0.0078420229,
0.0666841567,
0.0226984657,
-0.0703914687,
-0.0164209474,
0.0087672742,
0.0126850335,
0.0336352326,
-0.0792516172,
-0.0086669261,
-0.1464685798,
0.0017667182,
-0.0153401336,
-0.0214397367,
-0.0333969295,
-0.070007205,
-0.0020286939,
-0.0076342006,
-0.0006495553,
-0.008612819,
-0.0335503481,
-0.0042714281,
0.0201597959,
0.0027549157,
-0.0604549795,
0.0318598226,
-0.0558627956,
0.0429578982,
0.0044357125,
0.0171736479,
-0.0236259941,
0.0172101501,
0.0017015277,
0.0375933982,
-0.0258423686,
-0.0099294074,
0.0479870066,
-0.0255006906,
0.0069654994,
-0.0076372507,
-0.0161344577,
-0.0505958088,
0.005504868,
0.0059031728,
0.0793249607,
0.0464296043,
-0.0317315944,
0.0062815379,
-0.0505900793,
-0.0346272737,
0.0638660416,
0.0025867925,
-0.0374163315,
-0.0211675037,
-0.0181584656,
-0.0001332209,
0.0123829748,
0.0247074421,
0.032431744,
-0.0423851386,
-0.0101116467,
-0.0481006615,
-0.0382227004,
0.0859490484,
-0.0119534498,
0.0346425064,
0.0392678529,
0.0258971229,
0.0241465978,
-0.0540552735,
-0.0000567716,
-0.0382835642,
0.0429278351,
-0.0536154844,
0.0301151033,
0.0108042685,
-0.0588356219,
-0.0210449696,
-0.03713689,
-0.0318342559,
-0.0281255692,
-0.0473750122,
0.0208784938,
0.0202147495,
0.0585853383,
-0.0366334654,
-0.0742343962,
-0.0149589432,
0.1128166765,
-0.0374102294,
-0.0352634639,
-0.0094285551,
0.0271263346,
0.0021725288,
0.0298121274,
-0.059229441,
-0.015069522,
0.0134170633,
0.0626867265,
-0.0180384554,
-0.0411585495,
0.0463338904,
0.0202448126,
0.0332871787,
-0.0157669112,
0.055335734,
-0.0485541672,
0.0286810249,
0.0005053969,
-0.0374559723,
-0.0453732125,
-0.0344116986,
0.0466138162,
0.0078855567,
-0.0182237178,
-0.0225036666,
0.0212269854,
0.048298575,
-0.0133957453,
-0.0500635691,
0.0066017359,
-0.0322123319,
0.0375422016,
-0.0095467102,
-0.0049655233,
0.0274915956,
0.0613129772,
0.0043919566,
-0.0188111532,
0.0496603213,
0.0084753893,
-0.0228295717,
-0.0372578651,
-0.017521603,
0.0029609322,
-0.0218154602,
-0.0313282236,
0.0511456989,
0.0562785231,
-0.0212983862,
0.0102905165,
-0.0580749847,
-0.0376508273,
-0.0334828161,
0.0338683091,
-0.0330554657,
-0.0118006356,
0.0438394807,
0.0434042029,
-0.046600312,
0.0356520452,
0.0959623381,
0.0254999958,
0.0597769842,
0.0092332279,
-0.078224346,
-0.0406633578,
-0.0186277386,
0.0087442221,
0.0246310513,
-0.0345223099,
0.0526695214,
-0.078927651,
-0.0833880231,
0.0034865828,
-0.0485929623,
0.0012892537,
0.0050582201,
0.0553835742,
0.0414938517,
0.0137518886,
-0.019613253,
-0.0323676243,
-0.006463612,
-0.0028571866,
-0.0168408826,
-0.0245635603,
-5.695918488e-33,
-0.0045942273,
-0.056049943,
0.0068861367,
0.0214557182,
0.0028027662,
0.0087418994,
-0.0043968423,
0.0127338553,
0.0079260459,
0.0562975928,
-0.0174222328,
-0.0072983117,
0.0089239543,
0.0035600229,
0.026477037,
-0.0373817682,
0.0484367087,
0.0262516029,
0.0153293191,
0.0147818383,
0.0068190112,
0.0575133897,
0.0589296445,
-0.061872337,
0.030409839,
-0.0071632867,
-0.007744492,
0.0261149164,
-0.0031726186,
0.0668383017,
-0.0339071825,
0.0567647442,
0.0292070415,
-0.0099610789,
0.0295437332,
-0.0197338797,
-0.1408412308,
-0.0064874263,
-0.0029010121,
0.0058410564,
-0.0201974809,
0.0073861643,
0.0325110145,
0.0087249316,
0.0378069021,
0.0013254501,
0.0586184785,
-0.03010883,
-0.0875331461,
-0.0754068121,
-0.032032758,
0.0128549971,
0.0134183625,
-0.0186701063,
0.0326070301,
0.0321973078,
-0.0110861352,
0.0066342773,
-0.0139894374,
0.004058307,
-0.0214074571,
-0.0033082452,
0.0058050663,
-0.0037006172,
-0.0150536085,
0.0312763564,
0.0015874214,
0.0057815602,
0.0029668992,
0.0042135683,
-0.0224150475,
0.071578294,
-0.0144634759,
0.0423393138,
0.0264961123,
0.0034556261,
-0.0344430767,
0.0038562184,
0.0365356654,
0.0150600681,
-0.0009582429,
-0.0052660825,
-0.0475057811,
-0.0437033549,
-0.0158020239,
0.0108174039,
-0.0643768609,
-0.0116369789,
0.0142018087,
0.0218962226,
-0.0226083305,
-0.0106710996,
-0.0123051601,
-0.0682818443,
-0.0740136281,
0.0110926982,
0.0162867513,
0.0170932636,
0.0268896371,
-0.0043997974,
-0.0873676538,
-0.0449099243,
-0.0129623041,
-0.0478615947,
-0.013205328,
0.0016221665,
0.0467929915,
-0.0110626882,
-0.0514141805,
0.013793678,
-0.0217042677,
-0.0237245243,
0.0021999092,
-0.0026700026,
0.058543358,
0.0292060506,
-0.0138976788,
0.0577776134,
0.0530155748,
0.0062620337,
0.0010255816,
-0.0052946815,
0.0155360112,
-0.000632775,
0.0190933384,
-0.0089879707,
-0.0145807369,
0.0091343094,
0.0149697727,
-0.0352518223,
-0.0323052183,
0.0122766867,
2.754e-7,
0.021214908,
0.0652515665,
-0.0102798222,
0.0409868471,
0.0252166949,
0.0449320711,
0.0373772271,
0.0407406092,
0.0127668381,
-0.0320165083,
0.0593272857,
-0.0282130353,
0.0241126157,
0.0036361073,
-0.0926505923,
-0.0187065601,
-0.0334599614,
-0.0111348536,
-0.054503575,
-0.0045561693,
0.0579797998,
0.0567876212,
0.0685919002,
0.009081685,
-0.0197748914,
-0.0652193874,
0.0683413595,
-0.0476050377,
0.0154751576,
0.0089934552,
0.0419947207,
0.0549858585,
-0.0354488865,
0.0628741309,
-0.0082163559,
0.0317676812,
0.0392026864,
0.0530816279,
0.0001614351,
0.0361582339,
-0.0093773594,
-0.0257568322,
-0.0054436103,
-0.0296452362,
0.0817841887,
-0.0650163442,
0.0067969286,
0.028693717,
-0.0276767816,
-0.0580516569,
-0.0008204433,
-0.022530796,
0.0208708066,
-0.0089485142,
0.0166368708,
-0.0143634723,
-0.0277225375,
-0.0415075235,
0.0278645474,
0.0401276127,
-0.0111930389,
-0.0232285988,
0.0058893375,
0.0098278541,
0.003920482,
-0.0272225868,
0.0095940605,
2.496752067e-34,
0.0332846455,
-0.0031762344,
0.0056656864,
0.0393310972,
0.0298468042,
-0.0214067213,
-0.0558610782,
0.0057563521,
0.0163366962,
-0.0820967332,
0.004361161
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.09857v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.09857v2 | CoEdIT: Text Editing by Task-Specific Instruction Tuning | 2023-05-17T00:05:24 | 2023-10-23T23:17:13 | Vipul Raheja, Dhruv Kumar, Ryan Koo, Dongyeop Kang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7 | We introduce CoEdIT, a state-of-the-art text editing system for writing
assistance. CoEdIT takes instructions from the user specifying the attributes
of the desired text, such as "Make the sentence simpler" or "Write it in a more
neutral style," and outputs the edited text. We present a large language model
fine-tuned on a diverse collection of task-specific instructions for text
editing (a total of 82K instructions). Our model (1) achieves state-of-the-art
performance on various text editing benchmarks, (2) is competitive with
publicly available largest-sized LLMs trained on instructions while being
nearly 60x smaller, (3) is capable of generalizing to unseen edit instructions,
and (4) exhibits abilities to generalize to composite instructions containing
different combinations of edit actions. Through extensive qualitative and
quantitative analysis, we show that writers prefer the edits suggested by
CoEdIT relative to other state-of-the-art text editing models. Our code, data,
and models are publicly available at https://github.com/vipulraheja/coedit. | [
0.0790669471,
0.0153508205,
0.0134726372,
0.0047443425,
-0.0334206931,
0.020591747,
0.012797079,
0.0125495242,
-0.0261966325,
-0.0665866286,
-0.0689553767,
0.0060767112,
-0.0024770442,
-0.0187594518,
0.0290092491,
-0.0674222261,
0.0455252342,
-0.0058502983,
-0.0071064341,
0.0285247322,
0.0387070142,
0.0118377199,
-0.0064778659,
0.0390033498,
0.0132244602,
-0.0504356474,
-0.0263810996,
0.0371201448,
0.011137153,
0.0390252955,
0.0471483134,
0.0663060546,
0.0057040495,
0.028499173,
0.0000019833,
-0.0156288687,
-0.018916633,
-0.0376758799,
0.000414384,
0.0296224263,
0.0457837731,
-0.0092091998,
-0.058364775,
0.0035011186,
-0.0202538893,
0.0285154935,
0.0361889154,
0.0451542288,
0.0910991132,
0.1120850518,
-0.0029449728,
0.0035460028,
-0.0317439064,
-0.0383589901,
0.0308927801,
-0.0031551425,
0.0259693824,
-0.0203058645,
-0.0017568183,
0.0326745957,
0.0036699835,
0.0300618038,
0.0018275718,
-0.0684362426,
0.0330754556,
0.0153516503,
-0.0054543428,
0.0181980189,
-0.0161893163,
0.0538567118,
-0.0213155244,
-0.0040927706,
-0.0111570237,
0.0001195444,
0.0125275413,
-0.0333567075,
-0.0371509418,
0.0126945162,
-0.0077212867,
-0.0006563511,
-0.0049793357,
-0.0629976094,
0.0046885274,
0.0178378467,
0.0519329123,
0.0310177915,
0.0032957031,
-0.0385050848,
-0.0214394499,
0.0003129433,
0.0034822326,
-0.0904558524,
0.0422802269,
0.0341818184,
-0.0320428163,
-0.0367749706,
-0.0645332336,
-0.0434867181,
0.0169576146,
-0.0214283206,
0.0919105932,
0.031439133,
0.0215837993,
0.0547748581,
-0.0293629728,
0.0380766317,
0.010415256,
0.0283547696,
-0.0105327964,
0.0321421176,
-0.0589442253,
0.0168285184,
-0.0490195416,
0.0149378926,
-0.0570578016,
0.0197034124,
-0.0379543528,
0.0331971385,
0.0042829514,
0.0229046922,
0.0364841558,
0.0231380891,
-0.0399375632,
-0.0282183476,
0.0013168475,
-0.0203663372,
-0.0043636239,
0.0402558297,
0.0200292133,
0.0035847365,
-0.0008214189,
0.0055473493,
0.0261966903,
-0.0521030091,
0.0161402095,
0.0367275812,
-0.0466393493,
-0.0209794622,
-0.0469729416,
-0.0247937776,
0.0203815084,
-0.0334691256,
-0.05993177,
-0.0613759272,
0.0316468142,
-0.0030742858,
-0.0276829489,
-0.0842759535,
-0.0013907409,
0.0308420118,
-0.0287409406,
0.0516535267,
-0.0297880117,
0.0071906284,
0.0504867062,
0.0169586893,
-0.0210609511,
0.0082721533,
0.0455727577,
0.0567168891,
0.0481052808,
0.0190906618,
0.0370626301,
0.0429147147,
-0.0326079912,
0.0164485667,
0.0068760561,
-0.0156362057,
-0.0054894816,
0.0156378169,
0.0463298373,
0.0509344041,
-0.028408736,
-0.0119427117,
0.1106741577,
0.0191241112,
0.0084713697,
0.0274671689,
0.0454015359,
0.004642176,
0.0107636889,
0.0087128673,
-0.050189402,
0.0475332178,
-0.0269909203,
0.0052036974,
0.0395051762,
-0.0369258747,
-0.0121518001,
-0.0518804602,
-0.0244655311,
-0.0163884591,
0.0021939725,
-0.0310624167,
0.0042948774,
-0.0105763758,
-0.0808956772,
-0.0344367251,
-0.0108397426,
-0.0649994835,
-0.0143612875,
-0.0369367525,
-0.0045552854,
0.1120797694,
0.0504609756,
-0.0330865011,
-0.0387166589,
-0.0547316521,
0.0531060286,
0.0272888802,
0.0487699024,
-0.0332058631,
0.0125201102,
-0.0451696776,
-0.0144344186,
-0.0738599524,
0.0182978492,
-0.0039911498,
0.0388106406,
-0.0319779925,
0.0227974225,
0.0215541981,
-0.0602602139,
0.0422946811,
0.0030994187,
-0.0541845039,
0.0110580511,
0.0211979374,
-0.0196771976,
-0.0163554493,
-0.0454867408,
-0.0017190232,
-0.0136444988,
-0.0276099779,
-0.0232832581,
-0.0081968131,
0.0079707,
-0.0305798911,
-0.0051259529,
-0.0179134458,
-0.0211330149,
0.0198577195,
-0.0471282937,
-0.0308548901,
-0.0277382657,
-0.0329199396,
0.0186670832,
-0.0305586401,
0.0333306603,
0.0031576739,
-0.0621781088,
-0.0365146175,
0.0139270592,
-0.015306022,
0.0039979401,
0.035166923,
0.0319799669,
-0.0035214955,
-0.0189239644,
-0.0383409075,
-0.0604594871,
0.0367537737,
-0.0098268436,
0.0174521487,
0.0462208465,
-0.0152786234,
-0.0760661587,
-0.0797850341,
0.0311109461,
-0.0459718071,
0.0355390608,
0.0521187484,
0.0127141746,
-0.026306022,
-0.029444987,
0.0043257172,
0.0006687937,
-0.0225298237,
0.0381194428,
0.0625701994,
0.01364832,
0.0115840081,
-0.0826163813,
0.004353167,
0.0047182711,
-0.0186247453,
0.022993559,
-0.0446886159,
-0.0479673743,
0.058011394,
-0.0031013109,
0.0106491921,
0.0213958174,
-0.0614510514,
0.0031256045,
-0.0244800542,
0.0792258531,
0.1231139898,
0.0089798747,
0.0204888396,
0.0593134463,
0.0066818316,
-0.0353076719,
0.0149750328,
0.014333982,
-0.0195660684,
-0.0030351609,
-0.0558284558,
0.0241485611,
0.1008870006,
0.0021079488,
-0.0074518011,
-0.0382545218,
0.0250955634,
0.021915799,
0.0106377872,
0.0062632216,
-0.0055127866,
-0.031987492,
0.0094899302,
-0.0668234229,
-0.0746689811,
0.0429969653,
0.0092445686,
-0.0047446885,
-0.01017207,
-0.0296577141,
-0.016323166,
0.0345934667,
-0.000906985,
0.0247357134,
-0.0283324253,
-0.0076495577,
-0.0654477477,
0.0129041299,
0.0351532474,
0.0152802793,
0.0380485356,
-0.0720685497,
0.0122126285,
-0.0391367078,
-0.0577371605,
-0.029955091,
-0.0286195185,
-0.0100708511,
0.008546181,
0.0500755347,
-0.0323429741,
-0.0331943035,
-0.0195145234,
0.0306899566,
0.1014477611,
-0.0268184543,
-0.0372174457,
-0.0359341092,
-0.0225373227,
0.044640094,
-0.0168961808,
-0.0440142527,
-0.0388214625,
0.0275005288,
0.0685347021,
0.0127541116,
-0.0250188373,
-0.0130809331,
-0.015114354,
-0.0003231287,
-0.092915222,
-0.0443449095,
0.0093661351,
0.0858932361,
-0.0369178653,
-0.0255113728,
0.1318232566,
0.031707596,
-0.0716832355,
-0.0150940046,
-0.012546665,
-0.0107791182,
0.0584942065,
0.0566381328,
-0.063707985,
-0.0521684773,
0.0275481604,
0.0377105325,
0.0005167826,
-0.0282248519,
-0.0230683628,
-0.0253741872,
0.0191829186,
-0.003201606,
0.0102348458,
-0.0240253359,
-0.0298483931,
0.0161082204,
-0.0020879691,
-0.0319309756,
0.0424653105,
-0.0376459025,
-0.004866587,
-0.0210824367,
-0.0048954249,
-0.0077040712,
-0.0050994935,
-0.0158154052,
0.0324103832,
0.0681271777,
0.0072635352,
0.0350149684,
-0.0021227016,
0.0459157228,
0.0501726978,
0.0221286472,
-0.0209510792,
0.0438429229,
-0.0259163007,
0.0263737291,
-0.0229007918,
0.0506279804,
0.004439021,
-0.0002903209,
0.0506110229,
0.0364539437,
-0.039586205,
0.0230331421,
0.0022518176,
-0.044658754,
0.0262290947,
0.0420398489,
0.0500971377,
-0.0701031312,
-0.0569625087,
-0.076520063,
-0.0576455593,
-0.0902396366,
-0.0315631777,
-0.0373497047,
-0.0402660556,
0.0432042331,
-0.0771984234,
-0.0534736961,
0.0572492816,
0.0168488454,
0.048339054,
-0.0151010994,
0.0127945207,
-0.0230613798,
-0.047139395,
-0.0116063077,
-0.006471199,
0.0268905368,
-0.0870334059,
-0.0570650883,
0.0152639616,
-0.0094401808,
0.0054366179,
-0.0243186653,
-0.0584113449,
-0.0521229692,
-0.0147938607,
0.0584754199,
0.012128246,
0.0402061827,
0.0117836911,
-0.0900890827,
-0.0339517295,
0.0207606256,
-0.0095765367,
0.0413080566,
0.0292897001,
0.0066547631,
0.0133621925,
0.0489775911,
-0.0507335067,
0.0067570824,
0.0601186194,
0.0123725943,
-0.0356332324,
-0.0211273581,
0.0040840264,
-0.0083922474,
-0.0051639313,
0.000204204,
0.0255893338,
-0.0657520592,
0.0399124548,
-0.0197573267,
-0.0114015024,
-0.036729034,
0.0276973993,
-0.0042737303,
-0.017603172,
-0.0198190752,
0.041509077,
-0.0287048183,
0.0276039448,
-0.0676258802,
0.029615989,
-0.0335562117,
0.0165956039,
0.0421336219,
0.0086938385,
-0.0405259579,
0.0469980501,
0.0010732119,
0.0199636184,
-0.0022345434,
0.0701639727,
0.0176680125,
0.0073289317,
0.003184608,
0.0609376244,
-0.0741700307,
0.0076378793,
-0.0212260354,
0.0288653169,
0.0525483452,
-0.0099021764,
0.0515309051,
-0.0306181051,
-0.0300071798,
-0.0300180223,
0.0589595102,
0.0269216504,
-0.0068802005,
-0.0105961617,
0.0041337279,
0.022685837,
0.0165330488,
0.0789873153,
-0.0276471209,
0.0623353049,
0.0287764575,
-0.0343550667,
-0.0297167003,
-0.0401710048,
0.0110492064,
0.0059469878,
-0.0042993403,
-0.0102446256,
-0.0020388677,
-0.015697794,
0.002945838,
0.0342712738,
-0.0153535912,
-0.0191957317,
0.01911119,
0.0164051745,
-0.0226553176,
-0.0161574166,
-0.0465037562,
0.021098271,
-0.0078559117,
-0.0264465101,
-0.035766419,
-5.342159341e-33,
-0.0129783433,
-0.0135828657,
0.0202092435,
0.034768559,
0.0069574029,
0.007483393,
-0.0319653079,
0.0130915437,
0.0183674954,
-0.0043891766,
-0.0441646948,
0.0150168724,
-0.0081012957,
0.0015244243,
0.0387253352,
0.048779767,
0.0820125043,
-0.0109968195,
-0.0427013598,
0.0166637469,
-0.0026848775,
0.037035536,
0.0581655689,
-0.0279936194,
0.0350703299,
-0.0055952799,
-0.0248386431,
0.0284572914,
-0.0139803244,
0.0457554609,
0.0027924245,
0.0064081876,
0.0024577628,
-0.0298863985,
-0.0275108367,
-0.0029776159,
-0.0281427409,
-0.0144476043,
-0.0083438847,
0.0219537187,
-0.0305431485,
-0.0775727928,
0.0384715088,
-0.0218618549,
-0.0338928178,
0.001786989,
0.0394054241,
-0.0092330417,
0.0283291209,
-0.0108688837,
-0.0422169454,
0.005007972,
0.0120468568,
-0.0529079922,
0.0048766364,
-0.0048868041,
0.0092656668,
-0.026292922,
-0.0818521678,
0.0006902242,
0.0153120998,
0.0679123327,
0.0390683562,
-0.009147591,
-0.0201653223,
0.0324930549,
-0.0110319359,
0.0557376929,
-0.0253588706,
0.026728034,
-0.0306317098,
0.0348305069,
0.0218054522,
0.0352727696,
0.005146483,
-0.0129412003,
-0.0354519561,
0.044131659,
0.0238952488,
0.0321742594,
0.0143088931,
0.0296999346,
0.0077170851,
-0.0099387607,
-0.0264702141,
0.0171121638,
-0.0206410121,
-0.0134440819,
0.0375529677,
0.019062994,
0.0081683388,
-0.0217498019,
0.0130845355,
0.0200310722,
-0.0152442493,
0.0042495378,
-0.0412342735,
0.047765404,
-0.0094864303,
-0.0382940508,
-0.0305744931,
0.0005730332,
0.0191571228,
0.0110082291,
0.0258082189,
0.016746195,
0.0532815866,
0.0168222655,
-0.0850086138,
0.0082215257,
-0.0337864645,
0.0422520526,
0.0059289103,
0.0066536553,
-0.0093201278,
-0.019033147,
0.0086341072,
0.0604254156,
0.0014505832,
-0.0315017514,
-0.0533905067,
-0.01866729,
0.0215081517,
0.0165894683,
-0.0282592401,
0.0280371346,
-0.0206463356,
0.0268266425,
-0.0127484268,
-0.0152130099,
0.0022001567,
-0.0008783279,
2.454e-7,
0.0312510245,
0.0676064938,
0.0140656903,
0.0263490211,
0.0155470129,
0.0331999883,
-0.0199331343,
0.0375317559,
0.0144058019,
0.0092429304,
0.0109887226,
0.0449400619,
0.0305752531,
-0.0043140911,
-0.0664731562,
0.0104253991,
-0.0379536375,
0.0233434886,
-0.0566886738,
-0.0346144885,
0.0282491855,
0.0138496468,
0.0116007123,
0.0003721722,
0.0038568818,
-0.0175848082,
0.057850901,
-0.0232926514,
0.024070682,
0.0263918322,
0.0357416645,
0.0096149677,
-0.0157243926,
-0.0174106583,
-0.031400539,
-0.0311335977,
-0.0214540791,
0.1336094886,
-0.0384580158,
0.0117398901,
0.0484143943,
-0.016407799,
-0.0027123566,
-0.0098580196,
0.0763660148,
-0.0160170402,
0.0338236466,
-0.0080259005,
0.0205829628,
0.017037686,
0.0088189961,
-0.0419651568,
-0.0011696287,
0.0030603041,
0.021177426,
0.0054276227,
-0.0361679047,
-0.0550365485,
-0.0409192927,
0.0054211318,
0.0012459053,
-0.0201500338,
-0.0771428272,
0.04174475,
-0.0114091989,
-0.0711667836,
-0.021457782,
2.096044181e-34,
0.0008255047,
0.0091002667,
0.0342813805,
0.0269976184,
0.0394518003,
0.0131256012,
-0.0217605066,
-0.0075264126,
0.033472795,
-0.0696885511,
-0.0571154878
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.09846v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.09846v3 | CPL-NoViD: Context-Aware Prompt-based Learning for Norm Violation Detection in Online Communities | 2023-05-16T23:27:59 | 2024-04-16T20:43:53 | Zihao He, Jonathan May, Kristina Lerman | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SI | Detecting norm violations in online communities is critical to maintaining
healthy and safe spaces for online discussions. Existing machine learning
approaches often struggle to adapt to the diverse rules and interpretations
across different communities due to the inherent challenges of fine-tuning
models for such context-specific tasks. In this paper, we introduce
Context-aware Prompt-based Learning for Norm Violation Detection (CPL-NoViD), a
novel method that employs prompt-based learning to detect norm violations
across various types of rules. CPL-NoViD outperforms the baseline by
incorporating context through natural language prompts and demonstrates
improved performance across different rule types. Significantly, it not only
excels in cross-rule-type and cross-community norm violation detection but also
exhibits adaptability in few-shot learning scenarios. Most notably, it
establishes a new state-of-the-art in norm violation detection, surpassing
existing benchmarks. Our work highlights the potential of prompt-based learning
for context-sensitive norm violation detection and paves the way for future
research on more adaptable, context-aware models to better support online
community moderators. | [
0.0842128396,
0.0314201824,
-0.0069749048,
0.0347002372,
-0.0176111292,
0.0142332455,
0.0238895994,
0.0352559611,
0.0223262627,
-0.0408493206,
-0.0271744449,
-0.0389385037,
-0.0258206353,
0.0110111916,
-0.0203853808,
-0.0123899169,
0.0490838215,
0.0162260309,
0.0349322297,
0.0143871345,
0.0591225289,
0.0015280818,
-0.0151133668,
0.0302272364,
-0.0225170478,
-0.005727517,
0.0315285847,
-0.0128425257,
0.0232193787,
-0.0187313128,
0.0539546683,
0.0604620874,
0.0248727631,
0.0567749254,
0.0000017604,
-0.0858420953,
-0.0217613522,
-0.0270199161,
0.0279781893,
-0.0361938924,
0.0427566394,
-0.059398789,
-0.0098105539,
0.0410416611,
-0.0382595994,
0.0190264229,
0.0509658605,
0.0539121293,
0.0527506247,
0.0768533498,
-0.0170703791,
0.007401708,
-0.0083157979,
-0.0161468834,
-0.0092968466,
-0.0432745889,
0.0584827475,
-0.0502275005,
-0.0305622984,
0.0100528104,
-0.0264136419,
-0.0008239393,
0.0116833597,
-0.0390568972,
-0.0223435406,
-0.0564953834,
-0.0094225984,
-0.0247169267,
-0.0217315871,
0.1057222188,
-0.0117013911,
-0.004191142,
0.0408869497,
0.0125052799,
0.016495673,
0.0281430744,
-0.0507881194,
0.0303333942,
-0.0275134817,
-0.0089099985,
-0.013460529,
0.0237222705,
0.0427984446,
0.0398684405,
0.0204608738,
0.0270370897,
-0.0227280539,
-0.0316722877,
-0.0521659367,
-0.0207266323,
-0.0198403243,
0.0181702543,
0.0578885153,
0.0345751867,
-0.0740328208,
0.0028048367,
0.0074695549,
0.0045993943,
0.0760744214,
-0.0090791415,
0.0066539776,
0.0208568331,
-0.0172704421,
0.0457015894,
-0.0082143787,
-0.0031602872,
-0.0070218919,
0.0373388529,
0.0161092672,
0.0039751432,
-0.0347006135,
0.024323402,
-0.015012918,
-0.0060458551,
-0.0387548283,
-0.0017009701,
-0.0327834152,
0.0379336923,
-0.0631981269,
0.0298934635,
-0.01522067,
-0.0248772949,
-0.0116518028,
0.0124538643,
0.0166384652,
-0.0058981963,
-0.0469159447,
0.0314548984,
-0.001441573,
-0.0368260331,
-0.0021624325,
-0.0018115812,
0.0068797478,
0.0255497023,
0.0004528248,
0.0656275675,
0.0344292931,
0.0129635567,
-0.0028079175,
-0.0529503897,
-0.0406964347,
0.0053634769,
-0.019795863,
-0.0407260545,
0.0610696636,
-0.04167955,
-0.0205441881,
-0.0231141914,
0.015983317,
0.0239049308,
0.0166184772,
0.065585874,
-0.0170155615,
-0.0262025427,
0.0468229651,
0.066612117,
-0.0167115293,
0.0523826256,
-0.0484239347,
-0.0063406187,
0.0561891049,
0.0124644907,
0.0156253371,
0.018116504,
0.0318545997,
-0.0179445315,
0.0017116393,
0.0394312032,
0.0351743549,
-0.0008693791,
-0.0408913419,
0.076270774,
-0.0120070558,
-0.0709316209,
0.0175666865,
0.0629090741,
-0.0475744195,
-0.0041041011,
0.0374480449,
0.0046090726,
-0.0187892783,
-0.0164028257,
-0.0485874228,
-0.0482082851,
-0.0417647399,
-0.0559416823,
-0.017362887,
0.0345931575,
0.0042727818,
-0.0383858159,
0.0142730046,
-0.012381657,
0.033972133,
-0.0337103531,
0.009898643,
-0.0027445457,
-0.004148243,
-0.0291247573,
0.0411593616,
0.0003762924,
0.0157747511,
-0.041331999,
0.0617376231,
0.0408933125,
0.0400110595,
-0.0650869757,
-0.0002994906,
-0.075763002,
0.0678003952,
0.0218107849,
0.0422173589,
-0.023543736,
-0.0222089104,
-0.0302245729,
-0.035928797,
0.050255768,
0.0159351844,
-0.0060239006,
0.0258882716,
-0.0205888059,
-0.0006721956,
0.0522339977,
-0.0262782909,
0.0217695553,
0.0440345779,
-0.0064442065,
-0.0406200998,
0.0181644429,
0.0122851022,
0.0053567626,
0.0324679017,
-0.0346844047,
-0.0112195658,
-0.0064493539,
-0.0450739861,
-0.0315154791,
-0.090946734,
-0.0295167044,
0.0689510331,
-0.0398849212,
-0.0312538482,
0.0052763131,
-0.022544831,
0.0237184055,
-0.0075366902,
-0.0099423472,
-0.0100710709,
-0.0208586473,
-0.0462563634,
-0.0306304675,
0.0026759149,
-0.0307292119,
0.033236254,
-0.0487844944,
0.0141682997,
0.097286135,
-0.026010694,
0.0346471034,
0.0395811759,
-0.028707983,
-0.0367779359,
-0.0694614202,
0.0250934362,
0.0539351329,
0.0133899339,
-0.042767223,
-0.0017938514,
-0.0623123161,
-0.0432022847,
-0.0493680872,
0.0055772876,
0.038671758,
-0.0123192612,
0.0023635102,
-0.039774958,
-0.0402106047,
-0.0448113941,
-0.0041047274,
0.0374512114,
0.0561249107,
-0.017367404,
-0.0385657139,
-0.0221551824,
-0.0251998845,
-0.0383503102,
0.0101111801,
0.0160063468,
-0.0393371172,
0.012946818,
-0.0077606202,
-0.03125301,
0.012168671,
-0.0228485409,
-0.0183741134,
0.0345178396,
-0.003920896,
0.0210624281,
0.0371576771,
0.0777784362,
0.054004509,
0.0110079655,
0.0375424884,
-0.027172653,
-0.0324618407,
-0.0258815084,
-0.0000946545,
-0.0073068589,
0.0270579401,
0.064298749,
0.0221172404,
0.002617901,
-0.0015864644,
-0.064774029,
0.0388659723,
-0.0669912398,
-0.0492332019,
-0.0840517804,
-0.0470353328,
0.0041371309,
0.0284398124,
-0.0056242906,
-0.0255575143,
0.0795164257,
0.0385447405,
0.0181556065,
-0.0109765315,
-0.0404397696,
-0.0240241569,
-0.004069515,
0.0172043908,
0.0523456372,
0.0041060275,
-0.0703030378,
0.0038461937,
-0.020383453,
0.1040275395,
-0.038361866,
-0.0006985617,
-0.0210014731,
-0.0136052566,
0.018142473,
-0.0743019432,
-0.0631164461,
-0.046139013,
0.0225892477,
0.0044257222,
-0.0057928264,
0.0089376289,
0.0386368372,
-0.0094343759,
-0.0370563753,
0.0107920514,
0.021044435,
-0.0277988501,
0.0108380625,
0.0280457567,
0.0188349448,
-0.0272773169,
-0.0223962292,
-0.0152551802,
-0.0152216433,
0.0834795758,
-0.0107676629,
-0.0449067727,
0.0338376202,
0.0347577743,
0.0337714888,
-0.0210634936,
0.0308589227,
0.0408669971,
0.0518825613,
-0.0499836206,
0.0055959704,
0.0746988282,
0.066062361,
-0.0423805006,
-0.0269069374,
-0.0239458438,
0.0094930977,
0.0001209871,
-0.0198721308,
-0.0958513916,
-0.0097498344,
-0.0183530506,
0.042631533,
-0.0537571274,
-0.0530577525,
0.0009337278,
-0.0553778186,
-0.0121562975,
-0.0020774228,
-0.0624924637,
-0.0213844068,
-0.03693977,
0.0103383074,
-0.029687779,
0.0510812365,
-0.0075119562,
-0.0029922514,
-0.0209802631,
0.0290094018,
-0.0805954561,
-0.031686943,
0.0039814068,
-0.0504938997,
0.0808572918,
0.0229852367,
0.0041179601,
-0.012579021,
-0.0376509465,
0.05753766,
0.012702099,
0.003941244,
-0.037527211,
0.0013437411,
0.0067577385,
-0.0165447276,
-0.0494019128,
0.0536434352,
0.0025411781,
-0.0484978035,
0.0180896576,
0.0841262266,
0.029780075,
-0.0227518156,
-0.0383750722,
0.0369523354,
0.051918488,
0.0422561541,
0.0332477577,
-0.0220062025,
-0.027351765,
-0.0709926635,
-0.0232719071,
-0.000783048,
-0.0171455089,
-0.0640344769,
0.036480803,
0.0070426585,
-0.0617976561,
-0.002591887,
-0.0062936568,
-0.0013460972,
0.023536399,
-0.034230981,
-0.0139280502,
0.0177785456,
-0.0148706902,
-0.0217619333,
-0.050758224,
0.0037785522,
-0.0235175453,
0.0733042881,
-0.0122980392,
0.0523951314,
-0.0249239821,
0.0162679572,
0.0115871206,
-0.0595463328,
0.0306462348,
0.044180274,
0.0107324105,
0.0310557596,
-0.0255249962,
0.0096132588,
0.0329091251,
0.0654334724,
-0.0174960252,
-0.050903216,
0.0798709318,
0.0107843224,
-0.0055609308,
0.0234207679,
0.0019407211,
0.0155438995,
-0.0186634734,
-0.0003027815,
-0.0637142733,
-0.0297366995,
0.0021531151,
-0.005975245,
-0.0214278065,
0.0313893929,
-0.0524885841,
-0.0212101229,
-0.0499392487,
0.0019710823,
-0.0372513346,
0.0366668813,
0.0517948382,
0.0182040557,
-0.0492512211,
-0.010250642,
0.0445883721,
-0.0307316612,
0.0595554262,
-0.0880271569,
-0.0005777188,
0.0596740805,
0.0393041261,
0.0282653794,
-0.0097618541,
-0.0129194092,
0.0495376512,
0.0528429896,
0.0384491161,
-0.009303214,
0.0502413251,
0.0247009825,
-0.0110084526,
-0.0127092116,
0.0166023038,
-0.015870722,
0.0166453142,
0.0124011347,
0.0407221876,
0.0098489346,
0.0075375061,
-0.0144495433,
0.0044970899,
-0.0231545102,
-0.0115053197,
0.0370425507,
0.001315255,
-0.0385098122,
0.0374869779,
0.0209181421,
-0.0127883973,
0.025100274,
0.0113701392,
-0.0745608956,
0.0235130414,
-0.00035065,
-0.0407237485,
-0.0389367118,
0.0465917177,
0.0242573842,
0.0583936907,
-0.018048048,
0.0272379257,
-0.0504046679,
-0.0074031819,
-0.0017964685,
0.0005893136,
0.0093213739,
0.0387132801,
-0.02149022,
0.0349537842,
0.038465485,
0.0042016241,
-0.0099442042,
-0.0057022665,
-0.0086249691,
-0.0251668766,
-0.0185980238,
-5.258530632e-33,
-0.0062669055,
-0.0654570386,
-0.0246333648,
0.0104037374,
-0.0071258508,
-0.0383108631,
-0.0023145706,
-0.0064476905,
-0.0058243778,
0.0308094621,
0.0168095008,
0.012996925,
-0.0120972451,
-0.0044734506,
-0.0085646175,
-0.0636997372,
0.0440742485,
-0.0013163354,
-0.0150456782,
0.0350553244,
0.052893851,
0.0203950685,
-0.0380252004,
-0.0732947439,
0.0545085035,
0.0154431099,
-0.0188312251,
0.0508551374,
0.0114949141,
0.0486426875,
-0.0057110623,
0.060713999,
0.0398293585,
0.001053303,
-0.0082884273,
0.0904876664,
-0.0607528873,
-0.0294312295,
0.0037224423,
-0.0281989984,
-0.0135427695,
0.0029078126,
0.0329174176,
-0.0348074175,
0.0243706051,
0.0052035698,
0.0208460502,
-0.0285398252,
0.0106695518,
-0.0356853791,
-0.0780536309,
0.0106036952,
-0.0467329957,
0.004488925,
-0.0257321261,
0.0667238683,
0.0237560514,
-0.0078839622,
-0.0668038353,
0.0275921319,
-0.0332013182,
-0.0178297423,
0.0145966969,
-0.0102574527,
-0.0400114022,
0.0471799746,
0.0034997296,
0.0420776382,
-0.0141232964,
-0.0031251917,
-0.0076431078,
0.0495704524,
0.0449717715,
0.0775583684,
-0.0379663147,
-0.0325482711,
-0.081243217,
0.0243347026,
0.0829357505,
-0.0062882933,
0.0211580787,
-0.0224605519,
-0.0602952577,
-0.023062434,
-0.0028061799,
-0.0212313328,
-0.0335719064,
-0.0055559571,
0.0301803071,
0.0040931203,
-0.0373522155,
-0.0327165686,
0.0027757024,
-0.0664960593,
-0.0356275849,
0.0642461404,
0.0072549302,
-0.0544183888,
0.0535745881,
0.0356651135,
-0.0320760645,
-0.0255832653,
0.0327087045,
-0.0588617027,
0.0066063479,
-0.035054449,
0.0607183687,
0.0577879027,
-0.0579451695,
-0.0174318012,
-0.0001741507,
0.0471993722,
-0.0384450108,
0.0482851975,
0.0209194925,
-0.0013234876,
-0.0031551726,
0.0388303325,
0.0396990366,
0.0016197221,
-0.0024943079,
0.0132711511,
-0.0374866985,
-0.0109361429,
-0.0431091003,
-0.0177615881,
-0.0027045947,
0.0760891661,
0.0215448812,
-0.0346642584,
0.021568317,
-0.0426504649,
2.361e-7,
0.0181351155,
0.0310211685,
0.0250335149,
-0.0315525457,
0.0252304561,
0.01546524,
0.0186298992,
0.0510567725,
-0.0003529966,
-0.013523276,
0.0118461801,
0.0368444584,
-0.0044043069,
0.0197302774,
-0.0361094065,
-0.061844632,
-0.0561590083,
-0.0159091223,
-0.0297507904,
0.0329027511,
0.0067899614,
0.0341415145,
-0.0140708974,
-0.0311437156,
0.0169987772,
-0.0402284823,
0.031737119,
-0.0551402755,
-0.0077933711,
-0.0079970062,
0.0992391631,
-0.0357691422,
0.0648988485,
-0.0072058756,
-0.0094919428,
0.009567528,
-0.019969061,
0.0616056994,
0.0367955156,
0.0079642665,
-0.0047475398,
-0.0210250523,
0.0213474967,
-0.0548395105,
0.0534782372,
-0.0352040678,
0.0087762056,
-0.0870404765,
0.0095546469,
-0.0705807433,
0.0613429956,
-0.0298488438,
-0.033528477,
-0.0164413806,
0.0159617234,
0.0340555944,
0.0388008915,
-0.0752112046,
0.0050181891,
-0.0084136901,
-0.0061772051,
-0.0467212573,
0.0198625252,
-0.0238298327,
0.0084528718,
0.0034965293,
0.0549761429,
2.022457775e-34,
0.0407988355,
-0.0359802954,
0.0153334709,
-0.0064094947,
-0.0170070194,
0.0270147119,
-0.0209170859,
0.0019609418,
0.0542407036,
-0.0036637385,
0.0043169595
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.09807v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.09807v2 | On Dataset Transferability in Active Learning for Transformers | 2023-05-16T21:10:54 | 2023-09-29T09:05:00 | Fran Jelenić, Josip Jukić, Nina Drobac, Jan Šnajder | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Active learning (AL) aims to reduce labeling costs by querying the examples
most beneficial for model learning. While the effectiveness of AL for
fine-tuning transformer-based pre-trained language models (PLMs) has been
demonstrated, it is less clear to what extent the AL gains obtained with one
model transfer to others. We consider the problem of transferability of
actively acquired datasets in text classification and investigate whether AL
gains persist when a dataset built using AL coupled with a specific PLM is used
to train a different PLM. We link the AL dataset transferability to the
similarity of instances queried by the different PLMs and show that AL methods
with similar acquisition sequences produce highly transferable datasets
regardless of the models used. Additionally, we show that the similarity of
acquisition sequences is influenced more by the choice of the AL method than
the choice of the model. | [
0.0104875341,
0.0378647782,
-0.0151739307,
0.0039983108,
0.0098174894,
0.0490177907,
0.0222870428,
-0.0008436258,
-0.032656759,
-0.058950752,
-0.0713796318,
-0.0136832725,
-0.011512842,
0.0156998597,
0.0070200223,
-0.0101349251,
0.0272745676,
-0.0156947616,
-0.03259103,
-0.0032444363,
-0.0163345616,
-0.0130180428,
-0.0006659661,
0.0123951817,
0.0100539187,
0.0488034636,
-0.0058390335,
-0.0293070972,
-0.0005886842,
0.019027805,
0.019088814,
0.0500401184,
0.0082437694,
0.0106796157,
0.0000019462,
-0.034007486,
-0.0476884395,
0.0073673963,
-0.0263016671,
0.0193307865,
0.0210466515,
0.0203902125,
0.0380892195,
0.0015724984,
-0.0513598435,
-0.0709058866,
0.0544569157,
0.0241073035,
0.0617757738,
0.0565891676,
-0.0395433605,
-0.0157137979,
0.0188698936,
-0.0390516557,
0.0054277619,
-0.0580818951,
0.0498311855,
-0.0237118099,
-0.0343996882,
0.0039327643,
0.0135774277,
0.0395084582,
-0.0189829729,
0.0027860566,
-0.006908311,
0.021426253,
-0.02209449,
-0.0083688535,
0.0191915035,
0.0466884114,
-0.0086244252,
-0.0296821445,
-0.0100385733,
-0.0400996543,
-0.0020559179,
0.0683900565,
-0.0260342564,
0.0194781646,
0.0093785962,
0.0404401533,
-0.0003158687,
-0.0134411408,
0.016572101,
-0.0172544587,
-0.059940625,
0.0135285528,
0.0076209437,
-0.0215124451,
0.0400595292,
0.0597332902,
-0.0101260506,
-0.0041829427,
0.012981155,
0.0269977823,
0.0039906777,
0.0169541258,
-0.0511635579,
-0.0260086246,
-0.0066352957,
-0.0219470318,
0.0322524086,
-0.0113451537,
-0.0434567779,
0.0408229567,
-0.0272136442,
-0.0007153982,
-0.0029046545,
0.0647830665,
-0.0510579944,
-0.0095297443,
-0.0785835385,
-0.011057172,
-0.050748758,
0.0407376476,
0.0540860072,
0.0061313403,
-0.0515024774,
0.027706001,
0.009723722,
-0.0425815098,
0.0169724971,
-0.0326167196,
-0.0612791069,
0.0213115532,
-0.0028758044,
0.0065902206,
0.0374620594,
0.0685648918,
-0.04976229,
-0.0541920401,
0.0064118165,
0.0026761191,
0.0448520221,
-0.044591222,
0.0286107082,
0.048462823,
-0.0207129419,
-0.0771842301,
-0.0358200707,
0.0522048511,
0.0449584499,
-0.0106132561,
0.0116159366,
-0.0231676325,
0.0224947408,
0.0310073011,
0.0217609014,
-0.0599488392,
-0.0248759072,
0.0086916219,
-0.0509197004,
0.0824414343,
0.0105171213,
0.0223295018,
0.0201150011,
-0.0372814015,
-0.0090135438,
0.0389150977,
-0.012290935,
0.0141949439,
0.052733995,
-0.0564682223,
0.0185130388,
0.0426002853,
0.0188902225,
0.0040114927,
-0.0049208608,
0.0013326947,
-0.0034890387,
-0.0677425563,
-0.0583186857,
0.01786373,
-0.0080378493,
0.0097593674,
0.0704391152,
0.0036660472,
0.0248323139,
-0.0053268261,
0.017588757,
-0.0116873756,
0.0210579876,
0.0124416659,
-0.0149947358,
-0.0133513445,
-0.0361423567,
-0.0240700413,
-0.0479380377,
0.0247608982,
-0.0462541543,
-0.0377072841,
-0.0039428072,
-0.0268400032,
-0.0230098777,
0.0134368148,
0.0732329935,
0.0558609813,
-0.0186936073,
0.126164183,
0.046379894,
-0.0305687543,
-0.0115422299,
-0.0581587553,
-0.0080204858,
-0.0527841374,
0.0085530132,
-0.0501748025,
-0.0419668294,
-0.0067504616,
0.0405259319,
-0.0280862954,
0.0407420546,
-0.0057489588,
0.0042965696,
-0.0379506387,
-0.0467858203,
0.0370112062,
0.0230918061,
0.0191495884,
0.0184988342,
-0.0003267631,
0.0096285455,
-0.0294393562,
-0.0258416366,
0.0620990321,
-0.0414119922,
-0.0333479382,
0.0013446963,
-0.0100773638,
0.0353414416,
-0.0471322536,
-0.0223813187,
-0.0110436846,
0.0410781726,
0.0010748671,
-0.01611856,
0.0358300321,
0.0010323443,
0.0385774188,
-0.005079417,
-0.0185398832,
0.000197149,
0.0377589501,
-0.0463135801,
0.0055770511,
-0.0781131834,
-0.0162455626,
0.0023697247,
-0.0271879658,
0.0780769661,
-0.0444440953,
0.0300060008,
-0.0474937707,
0.0441536196,
0.0105723869,
0.00933515,
0.0040491293,
-0.0437364429,
0.0089289136,
0.0189814456,
-0.0371232033,
-0.0135251768,
-0.0223572087,
-0.0137340901,
-0.0069560837,
-0.0010532378,
-0.010273288,
-0.0206675716,
0.0050579761,
-0.0261221975,
-0.0160118788,
0.0085075432,
0.0402478278,
0.0035369287,
0.0047179884,
0.0198420472,
-0.0086625172,
0.0234994702,
-0.0167445429,
0.0366116278,
0.0195301548,
0.0035614336,
0.0036258928,
-0.033914879,
-0.0281621367,
0.0287145674,
0.0870212317,
0.0048273713,
-0.0106678624,
-0.0737352818,
0.0286791548,
-0.0015745419,
0.0077717323,
0.001906606,
-0.0336380415,
-0.0345054828,
-0.0390664935,
-0.0293140076,
0.0521632507,
0.0200598259,
0.0328462981,
0.0255564209,
-0.0006190369,
-0.0316326916,
-0.0228730459,
-0.0808232427,
-0.0423904285,
-0.052031029,
-0.0311730225,
0.0311381612,
0.0649255663,
-0.038633123,
-0.0234508757,
-0.0149864098,
0.0030709461,
-0.0308882203,
-0.0120872157,
-0.0098674288,
0.0169389788,
-0.0034027565,
0.0281623527,
0.0186787993,
-0.0532829501,
0.0380300172,
-0.0332198516,
-0.0017592362,
-0.029628098,
-0.031013798,
-0.0234338734,
0.0258936044,
0.0721612722,
-0.0063756374,
-0.011727008,
0.0020777592,
-0.034080375,
-0.011200686,
0.044954218,
-0.0264333095,
0.0741948634,
-0.024107853,
0.0190831535,
-0.0220395718,
-0.0260283258,
-0.0456649102,
-0.0135838008,
0.011614535,
0.0037954103,
0.0463232584,
-0.0034755403,
-0.0784885585,
0.0542831756,
0.004502154,
0.0650535524,
0.0050414111,
-0.0306852404,
-0.000034831,
0.0314460211,
0.0185961202,
-0.021012418,
-0.0173430201,
-0.0350809954,
-0.0196861681,
0.0212894827,
-0.0067082248,
-0.0034786691,
-0.0009456521,
0.0178615265,
0.0580810308,
-0.0455980524,
-0.0019672939,
0.001195618,
0.0031707757,
-0.0010044504,
-0.0430370159,
0.090028137,
0.0337484665,
-0.0829176009,
-0.0194858108,
-0.0005205436,
-0.0343440846,
0.0195357595,
0.0437831655,
-0.0174898617,
-0.0130980322,
-0.0002060008,
0.0503366366,
-0.0020706579,
-0.0262506567,
-0.0114188185,
-0.0881919041,
0.0149757424,
-0.0201184712,
-0.0546615981,
-0.0090556266,
-0.0356947035,
0.0130858598,
-0.0594424605,
0.0001684511,
-0.0191278756,
-0.0278664716,
-0.0035566217,
0.066110827,
-0.0230312608,
-0.0424460433,
-0.0284849498,
0.0009508287,
-0.0048796423,
0.013684269,
0.0078161117,
-0.0316531472,
-0.0476007089,
0.0717942342,
-0.0291187651,
-0.0018078723,
-0.0116224634,
0.0670548975,
0.0144963767,
-0.0144855035,
0.0242432579,
-0.0039682705,
-0.0069873109,
-0.0262584575,
0.0130647998,
0.0224173721,
-0.0060346676,
-0.0023235544,
0.0104797827,
-0.0256727394,
-0.0149492845,
0.0318745933,
0.0130915372,
-0.0240680035,
0.0198200941,
0.0196632575,
0.0326156877,
0.0049668173,
-0.0685337111,
0.0515780523,
-0.0750288889,
-0.06710089,
-0.0613562986,
0.0132644726,
0.0271410868,
0.0880937502,
0.041188769,
0.0015907872,
0.0410642847,
-0.0104645714,
-0.01602537,
0.0223222189,
-0.0302305017,
-0.0030850226,
-0.065889962,
-0.0801745877,
0.0731327981,
-0.0387409106,
-0.0502334945,
-0.0527158082,
-0.0468983948,
-0.0344166532,
0.0785409659,
0.0518905446,
0.0242715292,
0.0342398137,
0.017657781,
-0.0387025774,
0.0220464692,
0.0522957258,
-0.0069981357,
-0.010905209,
0.0530894697,
-0.0883645117,
-0.0142594147,
-0.0133770509,
-0.0458251387,
0.058263585,
0.0954797268,
-0.0146722775,
-0.0271021165,
-0.0545064919,
0.0109055797,
0.0153587852,
0.1038344651,
0.0214063115,
-0.0252470095,
-0.0155322114,
0.0561507232,
0.0476544984,
-0.0007129795,
-0.0402830169,
-0.0169827826,
0.029961627,
0.078468211,
-0.0451224335,
0.0498692207,
0.0055167717,
0.0844356641,
-0.0297325291,
0.0273867585,
0.002604855,
0.039676819,
0.0109933745,
0.0118103558,
-0.0024851107,
-0.0015204046,
0.0520663895,
0.0510228723,
-0.0171022825,
0.0543875396,
0.0218188856,
0.0892133117,
-0.0226905923,
0.0347904004,
-0.0766774341,
-0.0408886559,
-0.0449306965,
-0.016430743,
0.0332843252,
-0.0734179839,
0.0428919718,
0.0008030829,
-0.0249552131,
-0.0008081101,
0.0147836348,
0.0250302907,
0.0028071678,
0.0234327,
0.0025531312,
0.004936696,
0.0198880993,
0.0742609426,
-0.010030535,
0.0381206311,
-0.0334418714,
-0.028478168,
-0.0233277045,
-0.0198418181,
0.0625075996,
-0.069134295,
0.0100498563,
-0.0092502171,
0.0141634885,
-0.060165748,
0.0083330804,
-0.0937636867,
0.0204159897,
-0.020765394,
0.0556380413,
0.0786160454,
0.0289974585,
0.0284293294,
-0.0207029004,
0.0042923214,
0.0418227427,
0.0243832171,
0.0322921202,
-6.336518461e-33,
-0.0196576547,
-0.0065247044,
-0.0183700584,
0.0318452679,
0.0021054002,
0.0240011122,
0.0058370009,
-0.0383762754,
0.0095418692,
-0.0065617603,
-0.0168852732,
-0.0067206398,
0.0348864645,
0.0376702547,
-0.0202883407,
-0.0305389203,
0.0330611654,
0.0223885458,
-0.0243199598,
0.0103540504,
0.0148565508,
0.0407062843,
0.0521558002,
-0.0782030448,
-0.0216911566,
0.0115288794,
-0.0018295556,
0.008051957,
-0.0051265587,
0.0436254963,
0.0117015252,
0.0248427633,
0.0181243122,
-0.071911037,
-0.00255591,
-0.0263949223,
-0.068082124,
-0.003597314,
-0.0133028198,
0.0522809811,
0.0335211046,
0.0373501591,
0.0160915814,
-0.0079572015,
0.0125988116,
-0.0159781929,
0.0545249879,
-0.0266450029,
-0.048520159,
-0.0749484077,
-0.0435828604,
0.0115219001,
-0.010107711,
0.0197494272,
0.0439468659,
0.0178344678,
-0.0044538341,
0.0337760858,
-0.0607352592,
0.0133680748,
0.0425421745,
0.0463827513,
0.0052603642,
0.0154723302,
0.0039351187,
0.013043372,
0.0318575799,
-0.019604519,
0.0038368506,
0.0122675216,
0.009913695,
0.0512743406,
0.0240707248,
0.006310069,
0.0093423007,
-0.0456936061,
-0.0373770185,
0.0279963072,
-0.0088121695,
-0.0095027424,
0.0361503065,
-0.0042183995,
0.0141657405,
-0.0320123769,
-0.0398775637,
0.0384164862,
-0.0147729823,
-0.0138893621,
0.0052825082,
-0.001462773,
-0.065908514,
0.0071650594,
0.034099333,
-0.0234087165,
-0.0591577068,
-0.00543366,
0.0020952108,
0.0090783723,
-0.0471886322,
-0.0334924497,
-0.0269077644,
-0.1011589393,
0.0257587265,
-0.0062422473,
0.0279295705,
0.0017340243,
0.0523982458,
0.0646095946,
-0.0650094375,
-0.0117350798,
-0.0069762762,
-0.0000718682,
0.0188324451,
0.0607116744,
0.0132969329,
0.020325454,
-0.013114267,
0.0470866039,
0.0377893858,
-0.0329567529,
-0.0333139524,
-0.002154174,
0.0061554578,
0.0374938957,
-0.0409484841,
-0.0169629678,
-0.0343315043,
0.0003397882,
0.0261755604,
-0.0707113296,
-0.0029745935,
0.0069707646,
2.675e-7,
0.0660486147,
0.0402793884,
-0.0403702147,
-0.0213217661,
0.0134146465,
0.0320012495,
-0.0497726761,
0.0055573802,
0.0590935349,
0.0659110695,
0.0347740278,
0.0020839628,
0.0322496444,
0.0440681241,
-0.0651604459,
-0.0682636425,
-0.0709754527,
0.0199185051,
-0.0236231647,
0.010522061,
0.0249155965,
0.0852662846,
0.0278199874,
-0.0337052345,
-0.009619602,
-0.0596992262,
0.0322272889,
-0.0567820705,
0.0431054905,
0.0516311489,
0.0200958773,
-0.0149965053,
0.0000805888,
0.0485208854,
-0.0447054319,
0.0157547388,
0.0392803364,
0.0209377985,
0.0051727686,
-0.0161785595,
-0.0031892143,
0.0080449861,
0.0206058752,
-0.0185983013,
0.0756957904,
-0.1027697474,
-0.0408585817,
0.0248995256,
-0.032869339,
-0.0289804209,
-0.0076155402,
0.0287285447,
0.0283869971,
0.0427852646,
0.0161985196,
0.0262209829,
-0.0793291032,
-0.0914237127,
0.0133085763,
-0.0316375978,
-0.0182880554,
-0.0431731082,
-0.0256054234,
-0.000674509,
0.0172651894,
0.0204668436,
0.0353857651,
2.303357533e-34,
0.0136544984,
0.0272628032,
0.0103480201,
0.0361360647,
0.0077178287,
-0.017033793,
0.0686128587,
0.0282294322,
-0.0356354006,
-0.0766789094,
0.0251524113
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.09800v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.09800v2 | Mirages: On Anthropomorphism in Dialogue Systems | 2023-05-16T20:50:46 | 2023-10-23T09:26:22 | Gavin Abercrombie, Amanda Cercas Curry, Tanvi Dinkar, Verena Rieser, Zeerak Talat | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automated dialogue or conversational systems are anthropomorphised by
developers and personified by users. While a degree of anthropomorphism may be
inevitable due to the choice of medium, conscious and unconscious design
choices can guide users to personify such systems to varying degrees.
Encouraging users to relate to automated systems as if they were human can lead
to high risk scenarios caused by over-reliance on their outputs. As a result,
natural language processing researchers have investigated the factors that
induce personification and develop resources to mitigate such effects. However,
these efforts are fragmented, and many aspects of anthropomorphism have yet to
be explored. In this paper, we discuss the linguistic factors that contribute
to the anthropomorphism of dialogue systems and the harms that can arise,
including reinforcing gender stereotypes and notions of acceptable language. We
recommend that future efforts towards developing dialogue systems take
particular care in their design, development, release, and description; and
attend to the many linguistic cues that can elicit personification by users. | [
0.0625401437,
0.0393973291,
-0.0578404404,
0.0339437462,
0.032969933,
-0.0033702494,
0.0229956005,
-0.0214285217,
0.0211850312,
-0.0819070488,
-0.0455071218,
0.0205797348,
0.0254703257,
-0.0023416833,
0.0271733645,
-0.0745662004,
0.0040737842,
0.0071685826,
-0.0088182939,
0.0240199901,
0.0214764718,
0.0572417565,
-0.006841687,
0.0841009989,
-0.0298050586,
-0.039051041,
0.0301102791,
0.0090249572,
-0.0134238759,
-0.0330137573,
0.0062829349,
0.0069124843,
-0.0010940477,
-0.0092138024,
0.0000018736,
-0.0718780607,
0.0902694836,
-0.0026329784,
-0.0341164172,
-0.0220172405,
0.0328696705,
0.0275629796,
-0.0176817607,
-0.0032476729,
-0.0366767682,
-0.0181547776,
0.0323412381,
0.0337896124,
0.0661877841,
0.0131373024,
-0.0233101808,
0.0030600836,
-0.04313346,
0.0395411663,
-0.0401649438,
-0.0054398887,
-0.0384461768,
-0.0254590921,
0.0571361482,
-0.0117303878,
0.00604745,
0.0110736573,
-0.0236321148,
-0.027672058,
0.0057199416,
-0.0004131449,
-0.0206379853,
-0.0757959858,
0.008008427,
0.0807784721,
0.0436120778,
0.0006763109,
-0.0189495925,
0.0372426435,
0.0232732464,
0.002777488,
-0.0084470967,
0.0293778926,
-0.0198755953,
-0.031823989,
-0.0706527159,
0.0068713473,
-0.0137051176,
0.0222932845,
0.0002937749,
0.048879236,
-0.0070294384,
0.0047382466,
-0.0120428773,
-0.0134373549,
0.0078993579,
-0.0569213666,
-0.0141959498,
0.0206166543,
-0.0672795475,
0.0173093062,
-0.0351106115,
-0.0138191255,
0.0117298216,
-0.053596437,
0.0028278001,
0.0321604759,
-0.0050041303,
0.0093838088,
0.0245789401,
0.0336084515,
0.0387240909,
-0.0215261113,
-0.0223533511,
0.0264632329,
-0.0186689664,
-0.0475731492,
-0.0431489088,
-0.0068317964,
-0.0014650814,
-0.00087072,
0.0312485714,
0.0488853864,
-0.04348436,
-0.0017977036,
-0.065866366,
0.0491710566,
-0.0143510569,
-0.0022965122,
-0.0151753854,
-0.0271114856,
-0.0622155033,
0.0339527912,
-0.038391605,
-0.0966991037,
0.0448372513,
0.0058460017,
0.0019897413,
0.0166641455,
-0.0190548338,
0.0857196599,
-0.0072332011,
-0.0228753984,
0.013281865,
-0.0090911211,
-0.0179187991,
-0.0251395069,
-0.0298097692,
-0.0107136378,
0.0076064859,
0.0176682789,
-0.0177296977,
-0.0330309458,
0.0182544701,
0.0513160489,
-0.0165956095,
0.0853350237,
-0.0086982381,
0.0072725774,
0.0873022154,
0.0232603699,
-0.0206011627,
0.0261796769,
0.0714101493,
0.0120392693,
0.0122056641,
-0.0400426276,
0.0163820423,
0.0259573404,
-0.0459743254,
0.0021747292,
0.0234263092,
0.0249516163,
-0.0402126983,
0.0158773754,
0.0445453487,
0.0250349548,
-0.0094837202,
0.0259217508,
0.0359365866,
0.0932199284,
-0.0406059474,
0.0579840094,
0.0433007702,
0.0085347192,
-0.0029001012,
0.013654544,
-0.0246790908,
-0.000793085,
0.0203868132,
-0.0409352817,
-0.0233634673,
0.0194268152,
-0.0135632977,
-0.0278158076,
0.0119872987,
0.019606879,
0.0401814617,
-0.0106650461,
-0.0167846698,
0.0695462003,
0.022487253,
0.0078662354,
-0.0008470493,
-0.0530511141,
-0.0158042368,
-0.0450182147,
-0.0293589253,
0.0856964365,
0.0267882757,
-0.0083519164,
0.0280588064,
-0.0405744836,
0.0199154727,
0.0587947182,
0.0272014141,
0.0066094138,
-0.0491187908,
0.0285295472,
0.0285956431,
0.0236210693,
0.0019326167,
0.0459439643,
-0.0565038733,
0.0449446253,
0.0062853084,
0.0305695906,
-0.0424944796,
0.0052211536,
0.0123021016,
-0.0812060833,
-0.0086811204,
0.0201262701,
-0.0157554466,
0.0219080579,
-0.0085650487,
0.016981326,
-0.0068800445,
-0.0118116429,
-0.0138496663,
0.0892582685,
-0.0191386901,
0.0197341889,
0.0174377505,
-0.0629295334,
-0.0329540148,
0.0208884869,
0.0328325294,
-0.0119084958,
0.0849005729,
-0.0771243572,
0.0379564539,
-0.0382108651,
0.0134308245,
0.0061255987,
0.0297182053,
-0.0362449624,
-0.0381566994,
0.0078871315,
-0.0395941325,
-0.0180106126,
0.0207142979,
0.0166358054,
-0.021602625,
-0.0347051546,
0.0568411946,
-0.0204558484,
0.0508882292,
0.0157392584,
-0.0454457924,
-0.0493967831,
0.0163825396,
-0.0869386196,
-0.0649844259,
0.0172411259,
-0.0165938511,
-0.0037796991,
-0.0071196319,
-0.0307036303,
-0.0361701585,
-0.0006544275,
-0.0367967151,
-0.0103297206,
0.0239094589,
0.056085486,
-0.0128541375,
-0.0075773518,
-0.0376939699,
0.0157726463,
-0.0335209854,
0.05028129,
0.0128366016,
-0.0452859029,
-0.073286593,
-0.0081700049,
-0.0221818257,
-0.0012743643,
0.0177563317,
-0.0467688665,
0.0681943148,
0.060648445,
0.0556279421,
0.0547527783,
0.0486698858,
0.0488961264,
0.0079611475,
0.0132033061,
-0.031338498,
-0.0100625129,
0.0607567094,
-0.0018890734,
0.0526737198,
-0.0643792748,
0.0598203875,
0.0010082327,
0.0177991856,
0.0336394422,
-0.0335633121,
0.0934778675,
-0.0345819443,
-0.0668656603,
-0.0073347776,
-0.0470341183,
-0.0274260249,
0.035763178,
0.0048617842,
-0.019809179,
0.0471964926,
-0.0231850427,
-0.0326043367,
0.007789325,
-0.0001454104,
0.0076716188,
0.0402596481,
-0.0142825376,
0.0418794341,
0.0902812704,
-0.0452166982,
-0.0641659275,
-0.0152737917,
0.0105927521,
-0.0228267666,
0.0199116282,
-0.0396991037,
-0.0044450141,
0.0275555942,
-0.0581335798,
-0.0224136319,
-0.0278853998,
-0.0378810167,
-0.0358794555,
-0.0094237383,
0.0035795432,
-0.017516708,
0.0149950301,
-0.0004003331,
0.0038417068,
0.0176484007,
-0.0123711554,
-0.0186741073,
-0.03113948,
0.0417387709,
0.0576006919,
-0.0017063477,
0.0554652475,
0.062473949,
0.0055709346,
0.0170069113,
0.0139854252,
-0.0257026795,
0.0082075475,
0.0185582712,
-0.0051602768,
-0.019601997,
-0.0049709897,
0.0505483411,
-0.0442350917,
0.0180969592,
0.0575755201,
0.0084901173,
-0.010278861,
0.0273433328,
-0.0161855631,
-0.0207328238,
0.0184888244,
0.0252220407,
-0.0662698671,
0.0125935078,
-0.0030599746,
0.0124535663,
-0.0227208864,
-0.023718806,
-0.0239863694,
-0.0782170966,
0.018024724,
0.0070917173,
-0.0250235107,
0.0037984869,
0.0319781788,
0.0289232433,
0.0466480963,
0.0300725643,
-0.0092484606,
-0.0289814863,
-0.0081211235,
-0.0000547161,
-0.0613700598,
0.0366079062,
0.001576164,
-0.0216963422,
0.0481834896,
0.0566440374,
0.0631980449,
0.0149758253,
-0.0169002973,
0.0208236016,
-0.0011228725,
0.0259104464,
-0.0098287323,
-0.0102745416,
-0.0456473902,
-0.0167232696,
-0.0378381163,
0.0048185838,
0.0130559159,
-0.0022138252,
0.0121697485,
0.0352218114,
-0.0388163663,
-0.0361670516,
-0.0597346984,
0.0108865723,
0.0214180034,
0.0090856357,
0.0442237109,
-0.0612608902,
-0.0287852697,
-0.038033694,
0.0194141939,
0.0445230715,
-0.0858495384,
-0.00763326,
-0.0026467238,
-0.0347799547,
-0.0731030703,
-0.1091821864,
-0.0114756264,
0.0065997494,
0.0235585682,
-0.0763600245,
0.0165514275,
0.047895465,
0.0033084659,
0.0227535255,
0.0004949688,
0.0215868764,
-0.006678022,
-0.0032424028,
0.0235983822,
-0.0190570503,
0.0367497839,
0.0289586522,
0.0681046546,
-0.0282535348,
0.0091259936,
0.0480091944,
0.0219982192,
0.0333104767,
0.00005613,
-0.0750946626,
-0.0083544739,
0.0086572822,
-0.0216480438,
0.0012963074,
0.0168488268,
0.0679585859,
-0.0331464,
0.0219216272,
0.0011378244,
0.037600521,
-0.0498310477,
-0.0205875058,
-0.0562753454,
-0.0739174336,
0.0021041015,
0.0347118042,
-0.004138486,
-0.0375972167,
0.0479659252,
0.0190962777,
-0.0233751256,
-0.0148139261,
-0.0273974985,
-0.0205694977,
-0.0133214584,
-0.0136042824,
0.0522142425,
0.0185048431,
-0.0472965613,
-0.054068245,
0.0331904925,
0.0356025398,
-0.0002377922,
0.0296202395,
0.048609525,
-0.03488186,
0.0100413943,
0.001023573,
0.0401162095,
-0.0266003888,
0.0417226031,
0.029615147,
0.0555571914,
0.0004076907,
-0.0051859803,
-0.0230694283,
0.051780533,
-0.0100846821,
-0.0360672921,
0.0090105301,
-0.0018047569,
-0.0053236349,
-0.008295754,
0.0407564454,
0.0016676486,
0.0218246114,
0.0347866155,
0.0013535201,
0.0252432916,
-0.0073248981,
-0.0201896708,
0.0191878825,
-0.0202585999,
-0.0380108133,
0.0118035749,
-0.0046748887,
0.0190120656,
-0.0144117717,
-0.0285540391,
-0.056226667,
-0.0312401615,
-0.0272505879,
-0.0323726349,
0.002162159,
0.0032463789,
-0.0759665295,
-0.0576084927,
-0.0375358723,
-0.031111896,
0.0310734622,
-0.0471334979,
0.0114526581,
0.0162511393,
0.0172325391,
-0.0435219966,
-0.0081622321,
0.0235218257,
-0.0266325083,
0.020858027,
-0.036262881,
-5.399934521e-33,
-0.0359128751,
-0.05311938,
0.0011422217,
0.0200450663,
-0.0339687616,
-0.0636047944,
-0.0347666293,
0.0261827204,
0.0061986553,
0.0067851744,
-0.0141309649,
-0.022906106,
0.0001786752,
-0.018754553,
0.0466571711,
0.0062159174,
0.0660355389,
0.0050448347,
-0.0433052145,
-0.0120871533,
0.01541554,
-0.0164495278,
-0.018129658,
-0.1100470051,
0.0734067932,
0.0010711404,
-0.0293531548,
-0.022831535,
0.0444287285,
-0.0190283749,
-0.0088860774,
0.0606107488,
0.0167739987,
0.0151001327,
-0.0096913781,
0.1437263191,
-0.0320520513,
-0.0552191548,
0.0177453421,
0.0490335971,
0.0246077385,
-0.0221761838,
0.0132928966,
-0.0333887711,
-0.016854763,
0.0410332568,
0.0420081019,
-0.00118852,
0.0480029099,
0.0285368674,
-0.1019736677,
-0.0181558374,
-0.0220769867,
-0.0506328531,
-0.005547476,
0.0825206786,
-0.0328169353,
-0.0814626738,
-0.0394614339,
0.0152974306,
-0.0480925366,
-0.0570201278,
0.0396889038,
0.0366010144,
0.0178610515,
0.0425437428,
0.0646412596,
0.0841698796,
-0.0588804968,
-0.0112423422,
0.0449901782,
-0.0046741054,
0.0139141278,
0.0356302932,
-0.023019379,
-0.0470939614,
0.0347536765,
-0.0227776188,
-0.0123998644,
0.0339226499,
-0.0060717748,
0.0170587096,
-0.0844570622,
-0.0235786214,
0.0133936573,
-0.032522887,
-0.0092729209,
-0.0652139932,
-0.007362376,
-0.0420738794,
-0.0258844811,
-0.0146726249,
-0.0231886301,
-0.034602873,
-0.0035838748,
-0.071070388,
-0.0234946031,
-0.0302723963,
0.0045478684,
-0.0238430612,
0.0296417195,
0.0085037444,
0.013237291,
0.0412190743,
0.0566996895,
0.0217343736,
-0.0290416237,
0.0029178341,
-0.0345152318,
-0.0339783244,
-0.0012076583,
0.0209640134,
0.0035487127,
0.0253334884,
0.0213353094,
0.0205710568,
-0.031833794,
-0.0121737244,
0.0268311538,
-0.0063195284,
-0.0603889152,
0.0408643372,
-0.058853291,
-0.0062564104,
-0.0536626093,
-0.0255221762,
-0.052051764,
0.0248724949,
0.0628247708,
-0.063516736,
-0.0253084172,
-0.0647638589,
2.67e-7,
-0.0352495611,
0.0559078418,
0.0109182987,
-0.0239728577,
0.0326121114,
0.0574539453,
0.0372470655,
0.0658962205,
0.05884308,
-0.0187515132,
-0.0036956109,
-0.0019321016,
0.0298071858,
0.0346475765,
-0.0753382221,
-0.026394384,
-0.0338766724,
0.0523473695,
-0.0325739197,
0.0287593883,
0.0608799718,
0.0154627366,
-0.0035506706,
-0.0217992254,
-0.0530825481,
-0.0308971852,
-0.0078910841,
-0.0186326299,
0.0290260836,
-0.00644409,
-0.0008320945,
0.0217166822,
0.0104093477,
0.0173065178,
0.0089864144,
0.019284483,
0.0481721126,
-0.0005639057,
-0.0275013112,
-0.0224132072,
0.0004090922,
0.0091238199,
-0.0048033572,
-0.0252378769,
0.0156303495,
-0.0304674227,
-0.0209823996,
-0.0365327671,
-0.0065776343,
-0.0302345008,
0.0153986756,
-0.0296049193,
-0.037567459,
0.0391403437,
0.0141083784,
-0.0229291189,
0.0402461775,
-0.0589303076,
-0.0072681275,
0.0146274315,
-0.0070339167,
-0.0228184797,
-0.0051338319,
0.0317532197,
0.0217917468,
-0.0216646828,
0.0433914922,
1.508265781e-34,
-0.0232331213,
0.0387894884,
0.0454842262,
0.0181358028,
0.0454027057,
0.0445687808,
0.0597692207,
0.022731008,
0.0854096115,
-0.0132854236,
-0.0043270569
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.09798v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.09798v1 | The Ways of Words: The Impact of Word Choice on Information Engagement and Decision Making | 2023-05-16T20:46:36 | 2023-05-16T20:46:36 | Nimrod Dvir, Elaine Friedman, Suraj Commuri, Fan Yang, Jennifer Romano | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.SY, eess.SY, stat.AP, 28-08, H.5.2; H.1.2 | Little research has explored how information engagement (IE), the degree to
which individuals interact with and use information in a manner that manifests
cognitively, behaviorally, and affectively. This study explored the impact of
phrasing, specifically word choice, on IE and decision making. Synthesizing two
theoretical models, User Engagement Theory UET and Information Behavior Theory
IBT, a theoretical framework illustrating the impact of and relationships among
the three IE dimensions of perception, participation, and perseverance was
developed and hypotheses generated. The framework was empirically validated in
a large-scale user study measuring how word choice impacts the dimensions of
IE. The findings provide evidence that IE differs from other forms of
engagement in that it is driven and fostered by the expression of the
information itself, regardless of the information system used to view, interact
with, and use the information. The findings suggest that phrasing can have a
significant effect on the interpretation of and interaction with digital
information, indicating the importance of expression of information, in
particular word choice, on decision making and IE. The research contributes to
the literature by identifying methods for assessment and improvement of IE and
decision making with digital text. | [
0.0639320612,
-0.0238627978,
-0.0206524227,
-0.0450907536,
-0.0274941605,
0.0125127118,
-0.0456088595,
0.0069875927,
-0.01337153,
-0.0188077539,
-0.0208583754,
0.0182156656,
0.0327925645,
0.0074743791,
-0.0294509046,
-0.0317188129,
-0.0066911657,
0.0193113722,
0.0340222903,
0.0406166315,
0.0339712091,
0.0250748545,
-0.0162945278,
-0.0020177525,
-0.0009888598,
-0.0087592332,
0.0089891674,
0.0264167506,
-0.0059791682,
-0.0802176595,
0.0185500272,
0.0253783204,
0.0336555056,
0.0308658183,
0.0000024166,
-0.0417030193,
-0.0105177965,
-0.0158113576,
-0.1329786777,
0.0604492202,
0.0516699031,
0.0578599684,
0.0094760852,
0.0000817528,
-0.0092894416,
0.0301755704,
0.0528278537,
0.0412336737,
-0.0248940103,
-0.0355348699,
-0.0214555971,
0.0263322704,
0.0009019795,
0.0284008197,
0.0120481718,
0.0068603936,
-0.0111347465,
0.0257619377,
0.0036732552,
-0.0133775668,
0.0058430629,
0.0099274134,
-0.0355767533,
0.0004409082,
0.0063079284,
0.0340145342,
0.0498702563,
-0.0614494383,
0.0108286617,
-0.0067688003,
0.08652661,
0.0551061369,
-0.0415672883,
-0.0373289026,
0.0016182705,
0.0411664099,
-0.0274229497,
-0.0398890339,
-0.0029556423,
-0.006950317,
-0.0361918546,
0.0648995638,
0.0019254251,
0.0410731472,
-0.0106873335,
-0.0017365881,
-0.0163143445,
-0.0337450877,
0.024411248,
0.0015256328,
0.0404134467,
-0.0326954201,
-0.0344490558,
-0.0403615348,
0.0289569665,
0.0368561409,
0.0222494826,
0.0147559242,
0.0203347933,
-0.0974152088,
-0.0166581534,
0.0187267009,
0.0557287075,
0.0280165784,
0.0428323708,
-0.036732845,
-0.007639837,
-0.029002443,
-0.0000320591,
0.0630741268,
-0.013124153,
-0.0340495184,
0.0238787867,
0.0491685756,
0.0264212862,
-0.0719599575,
-0.0226345081,
0.0028541014,
0.0230176207,
0.0337296277,
-0.0461683869,
0.0015919169,
-0.0237260815,
-0.0016618787,
-0.0728029311,
0.026478963,
-0.0531903207,
0.0229185242,
-0.0544735268,
-0.0272996128,
0.0611901693,
0.0015106469,
0.0070924596,
-0.0584312119,
0.0468558483,
-0.0002255282,
0.0116587281,
-0.0588661283,
-0.0691215619,
-0.06021256,
0.0246055145,
-0.0119623607,
-0.0281602815,
0.0037686734,
-0.0077707577,
0.070622474,
-0.02407673,
-0.0562729985,
0.0015515599,
0.0270988848,
-0.0022366561,
0.0509487726,
-0.068409048,
-0.0129140476,
0.0556786358,
0.0300247967,
0.075297989,
0.0230319127,
0.0346011892,
0.051740285,
0.0390304662,
-0.0071634739,
-0.0200303309,
-0.0088537345,
-0.061386317,
-0.0041579879,
0.0280822515,
0.0172269549,
-0.0220411178,
-0.0048478115,
-0.0004298217,
0.0130608771,
-0.0576641634,
0.091270186,
0.0718644038,
0.0374360755,
0.0346662402,
-0.0253268015,
-0.0469348356,
0.0537755601,
0.018841058,
-0.007202222,
0.0599585027,
-0.0084593119,
0.0710580349,
0.0518339016,
0.0344838649,
-0.015892854,
-0.0380036309,
-0.0724459663,
-0.0453434549,
-0.0079883151,
0.0667369068,
0.0179707967,
0.0056573465,
-0.0180697963,
-0.0371961109,
-0.0090264184,
0.0034830943,
0.0051769456,
0.0089341532,
0.0013870624,
0.0114739528,
0.1340063065,
0.0393159837,
0.0165216029,
0.0052108294,
-0.0281579774,
0.0518258773,
0.0315005518,
-0.0096008079,
0.0433049388,
-0.0435555317,
-0.0429563113,
-0.022412248,
-0.0482533164,
-0.0312774405,
0.017197175,
-0.0106478687,
0.024235677,
-0.0155298952,
0.05570985,
-0.0210886765,
0.0141402129,
0.0148239732,
-0.0584133379,
-0.0625366792,
0.0262141433,
0.0226174798,
0.0316549875,
-0.0246518776,
0.0041875476,
0.00326523,
0.0679920837,
-0.0150861358,
0.0256274138,
0.07249064,
0.1041567028,
-0.0116164191,
-0.0101803029,
0.0122800712,
-0.0924444571,
0.0553066842,
0.0172025207,
-0.0090748426,
-0.0401063561,
0.0469737872,
0.0064760773,
-0.0309766941,
-0.015043892,
-0.0109650036,
-0.0568187498,
0.0313732848,
-0.026510518,
0.0081780702,
0.0374283791,
-0.0350691229,
0.0143880444,
0.0220628045,
-0.046574261,
0.0167373363,
-0.0095078535,
-0.0052859806,
0.0357441381,
-0.0312951021,
-0.0458616801,
0.0076091439,
-0.0240363292,
-0.0644882396,
0.0343618542,
0.0491754115,
0.0203760527,
0.0046126968,
-0.0381092802,
0.0355141573,
0.0827029273,
-0.0668816045,
-0.0291073713,
0.0247405488,
0.0290387627,
0.022385681,
0.0225962941,
-0.0140384063,
-0.0197695978,
0.0017900843,
-0.0175327193,
0.0839004591,
-0.0886326879,
-0.0009705043,
-0.048436489,
-0.0174381696,
-0.1142834201,
-0.0009295793,
-0.0126503399,
0.0424679965,
0.0417008847,
0.0324583203,
-0.0409742817,
0.0396018624,
0.0399183705,
-0.0129537024,
-0.0213120654,
-0.0410312079,
0.0056073773,
-0.0139933722,
0.0048773456,
0.0024881409,
-0.0462528877,
0.0345337912,
-0.027845744,
0.0276243202,
0.063900806,
-0.006569088,
0.0119719468,
-0.0432546027,
-0.0156594329,
-0.0109690875,
-0.0801718608,
-0.0196039416,
0.0269053746,
0.0278822668,
-0.0140160732,
-0.0065706111,
0.0160951298,
0.0154691413,
-0.022753194,
-0.0005338269,
0.0200714916,
0.0205872171,
-0.0594357848,
0.0151863489,
0.035575293,
-0.0703440905,
0.0322895572,
-0.0770841613,
0.0582805313,
-0.0383829474,
0.0044783265,
0.0392401554,
-0.0187572539,
0.0405708067,
-0.0003720455,
0.0083477069,
-0.0300064608,
-0.0380717926,
-0.0698802173,
0.0705799013,
-0.0006986311,
-0.0263381246,
0.004615325,
0.079874441,
-0.0374711528,
0.0440902859,
-0.0490134731,
0.0038139687,
-0.0334003568,
0.0118760597,
0.0279483665,
0.050521981,
0.0066240798,
0.0025561964,
0.0224394463,
-0.0435259752,
-0.0369749144,
0.0253865719,
-0.0400671922,
0.0381963067,
-0.0283104721,
-0.031316068,
0.0180160962,
-0.0181654207,
-0.0029150189,
0.030650612,
0.0541723259,
0.0201947242,
-0.0131340781,
-0.0213770792,
-0.0622766353,
-0.0071809008,
-0.0081399893,
0.0176755507,
-0.0319689363,
0.0035017957,
-0.017121857,
-0.0096433982,
-0.0248122457,
0.056642428,
-0.0131017435,
0.0090353368,
0.009370191,
-0.0030583234,
0.1105311736,
0.0053560347,
-0.0016803917,
-0.0159379411,
0.0571026392,
0.0166476183,
0.0105095059,
-0.0409176201,
0.0094301403,
0.0348715223,
-0.0465161055,
-0.0044646598,
-0.0156148104,
0.0039455625,
-0.0185336322,
0.0643089488,
-0.0125520006,
-0.0817250758,
-0.0549414344,
-0.023961192,
-0.0133279851,
-0.0164709557,
-0.0053576683,
0.0467526391,
-0.0334529765,
0.0516895652,
-0.03827288,
0.0026390012,
0.0237090494,
-0.0407044217,
-0.040766947,
0.0078508733,
0.020529842,
0.0245618951,
-0.0036447637,
-0.009932084,
0.0244455002,
0.0003474218,
0.0051707546,
-0.0464239419,
0.0142465644,
0.0119212708,
0.016492445,
0.0150660388,
-0.0372036844,
-0.0382202566,
-0.0187793579,
0.005923043,
-0.0361610763,
-0.0398366712,
0.0088344729,
0.0601328872,
0.0114694359,
0.0560526922,
-0.0173981041,
0.0003370108,
-0.0246314611,
-0.0066327956,
0.0451680422,
0.0181995295,
-0.0432030074,
-0.0009956694,
-0.0463644862,
-0.0445037261,
-0.0014596035,
-0.0065249894,
0.0512035117,
0.0175314788,
0.00599636,
0.0128658041,
0.0298581496,
-0.0451294445,
0.0165871587,
-0.030158421,
0.0147253266,
-0.0135694994,
0.0240653362,
-0.021555569,
0.0483193099,
0.0263303481,
0.0050386405,
-0.0226698834,
0.0550942644,
-0.0558797978,
0.0326546766,
-0.0004389135,
-0.0259423759,
-0.0014421692,
0.0197232775,
0.0167873651,
-0.0030698585,
-0.0705630332,
-0.0102818124,
-0.0021019259,
-0.0389526784,
0.0137123317,
-0.0355131924,
0.0126960212,
-0.048044011,
0.0147745321,
-0.0267444402,
-0.0164854396,
0.0128103001,
-0.0411533453,
-0.0206346028,
-0.0498725101,
-0.0037822104,
-0.0021430547,
0.0348441526,
-0.0170620158,
0.0040614312,
-0.0005134367,
-0.0125328554,
0.0199764594,
-0.0094398269,
0.01783913,
0.0490490459,
-0.0062874099,
-0.007823972,
-0.0391940437,
0.0179819074,
0.0160361007,
0.0022416483,
-0.0028213069,
-0.0248301886,
-0.0159662068,
-0.0220932849,
-0.0157958511,
-0.012674599,
0.0010012034,
-0.0110032288,
-0.0055975593,
-0.0201809462,
-0.0218828116,
0.0283077899,
0.0212299116,
-0.0319356881,
-0.0390672684,
0.0157167576,
-0.0497884713,
-0.000749446,
-0.0551422276,
-0.0287336744,
-0.0107130576,
-0.0050038137,
-0.0043959036,
0.088466458,
-0.0501204506,
0.0080403434,
-0.0651320145,
-0.0005815071,
0.0181177054,
0.0009104536,
0.0173491575,
-0.0436141752,
0.0407716371,
0.0303461328,
0.0241715759,
-0.0256626531,
-0.0313255601,
0.0258968845,
-0.0475983284,
0.0026525385,
-0.0479878262,
-6.319983664e-33,
0.0056389011,
-0.0398468077,
0.0218007304,
0.0495778695,
-0.0538683273,
-0.009251033,
0.0067656357,
0.064756155,
0.0089459009,
0.000105896,
-0.0228620376,
-0.0329519361,
0.0061577763,
-0.0477516763,
0.0390101187,
-0.0409720875,
0.0191371087,
0.027204169,
-0.0452640057,
-0.0559354499,
-0.0287877489,
-0.0150352325,
0.0060654655,
-0.0569067486,
0.0541427508,
0.0276284982,
-0.0133517282,
-0.063346386,
0.0619580112,
0.0403798893,
0.0079429038,
-0.0232568718,
0.0358033739,
-0.026433887,
-0.0038120325,
0.077086404,
0.0001710012,
-0.0209533628,
0.0758457929,
0.0334281735,
0.0118355649,
0.0043786285,
0.0253863335,
-0.0337471515,
-0.0484112538,
0.0547485575,
0.031020008,
0.0187444892,
-0.0509100556,
0.0151280677,
-0.0791167021,
0.0129919536,
-0.0051766844,
0.0082294187,
-0.0159523748,
0.0464622043,
0.0023711112,
0.01743095,
-0.1142795831,
0.0174219608,
-0.049636852,
0.0174901001,
0.0389847159,
0.0157307759,
0.0337331556,
0.0467140973,
-0.0367769301,
0.0171002652,
-0.0133699682,
0.0435049906,
0.0183291119,
0.0077165635,
-0.0093933763,
0.0372626707,
-0.0136632621,
-0.1014553979,
0.0257458054,
0.0202169567,
0.0067478358,
0.0248864759,
0.0760864317,
0.0451735556,
-0.0937522501,
-0.0194955766,
0.0063664392,
0.0193083566,
-0.0293033365,
-0.0678366199,
-0.003727884,
-0.0040691257,
-0.0619904175,
-0.016231589,
-0.0014362076,
0.0294307396,
-0.0657452419,
-0.016953215,
-0.0204688832,
0.0497485921,
0.0025396836,
-0.0079427678,
-0.0074475026,
0.005271967,
-0.0966447294,
0.0303582307,
0.00117966,
-0.0037725836,
-0.02123552,
0.0316164792,
-0.0197154637,
-0.0109805148,
0.0275738575,
-0.0285102651,
0.030229494,
-0.084469609,
0.0453415737,
0.0262794141,
-0.0057036099,
-0.0344884321,
0.0093836468,
-0.0371017531,
-0.0019740611,
-0.0868543386,
-0.0373755172,
0.0088002402,
0.0127842976,
0.0006315785,
-0.0242043436,
0.0137251318,
0.0066770772,
-0.0173946097,
-0.0106552057,
0.020640634,
3.128e-7,
0.0216452535,
0.0721518546,
-0.0179763325,
0.0180752538,
-0.0014163137,
0.006382308,
0.0108050555,
-0.0377885699,
0.0152178202,
-0.0238584653,
0.0909287184,
-0.0258569848,
-0.0265916623,
0.0126889953,
-0.0392416008,
-0.0285486858,
0.0002643177,
0.0873593837,
-0.0501688384,
0.0231748018,
0.0553071536,
-0.0239561722,
0.0012952002,
0.0333999135,
-0.0354681239,
-0.0048675085,
-0.0133991605,
-0.0412091054,
0.0310468916,
0.0087246131,
0.0278696697,
0.0284238569,
-0.0025432948,
0.0105309002,
-0.0101087,
-0.0352381952,
0.0411765575,
0.027806757,
0.0556940176,
0.0171794929,
-0.0121592972,
-0.0273472704,
0.0204052813,
-0.0133268591,
0.029459808,
-0.0245693568,
-0.0673500225,
0.014026517,
-0.0126326764,
-0.0587988012,
0.0715197772,
-0.0145795504,
-0.0790800005,
-0.0161825642,
0.0273196772,
-0.0084935473,
-0.0234389771,
-0.0376063958,
0.0397791043,
0.0078666573,
-0.036248982,
0.0202476792,
-0.039368432,
0.0078393193,
0.0275246296,
0.0331235044,
0.0158588327,
2.005495759e-34,
0.0014463088,
-0.0371453874,
0.0210078005,
0.0386798196,
0.0217347816,
0.0493534468,
0.0167915802,
-0.0151126254,
0.0257773381,
-0.0342303663,
0.0082269246
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.09785v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.09785v1 | Distilling Semantic Concept Embeddings from Contrastively Fine-Tuned Language Models | 2023-05-16T20:17:02 | 2023-05-16T20:17:02 | Na Li, Hanane Kteich, Zied Bouraoui, Steven Schockaert | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Learning vectors that capture the meaning of concepts remains a fundamental
challenge. Somewhat surprisingly, perhaps, pre-trained language models have
thus far only enabled modest improvements to the quality of such concept
embeddings. Current strategies for using language models typically represent a
concept by averaging the contextualised representations of its mentions in some
corpus. This is potentially sub-optimal for at least two reasons. First,
contextualised word vectors have an unusual geometry, which hampers downstream
tasks. Second, concept embeddings should capture the semantic properties of
concepts, whereas contextualised word vectors are also affected by other
factors. To address these issues, we propose two contrastive learning
strategies, based on the view that whenever two sentences reveal similar
properties, the corresponding contextualised vectors should also be similar.
One strategy is fully unsupervised, estimating the properties which are
expressed in a sentence from the neighbourhood structure of the contextualised
word embeddings. The second strategy instead relies on a distant supervision
signal from ConceptNet. Our experimental results show that the resulting
vectors substantially outperform existing concept embeddings in predicting the
semantic properties of concepts, with the ConceptNet-based strategy achieving
the best results. These findings are furthermore confirmed in a clustering task
and in the downstream task of ontology completion. | [
0.0124496398,
0.0557510667,
-0.0079362364,
0.0569112487,
-0.0191052984,
0.0116152819,
-0.0135095213,
-0.0259928741,
-0.0559553429,
-0.0490354225,
-0.0168248862,
-0.0363618433,
-0.015189236,
0.0099741174,
0.0312214158,
-0.0447794199,
0.0147736864,
0.0283565149,
-0.0220605787,
0.0076660556,
0.0091450773,
0.0079322429,
0.0014206367,
0.0475357883,
-0.0098024681,
-0.0174825937,
0.0242841281,
-0.0408921987,
0.0151883019,
-0.0075545385,
0.0130916536,
0.0436761491,
0.0607275479,
-0.0195004549,
0.0000019118,
-0.0360277481,
0.0077574053,
-0.017981153,
0.0078787971,
0.0100578591,
0.0800074339,
-0.0387650169,
0.0508922711,
-0.0233229157,
-0.0294269528,
-0.0697587207,
0.040739391,
0.0652758852,
0.0076018721,
-0.0059380056,
-0.0170545559,
-0.0352219529,
0.0327193588,
-0.0255736541,
0.0111117568,
-0.0248769447,
0.0263333581,
0.0252508055,
-0.0474223346,
0.0464281924,
-0.0504572988,
0.0160446484,
-0.0131469406,
0.0357448459,
0.0430475846,
0.0538290553,
-0.0242408551,
0.0053138109,
0.0267889183,
0.0896110013,
-0.033779297,
-0.0047375625,
-0.001924542,
-0.0065707802,
-0.0291079301,
0.0074680247,
-0.0239677187,
0.0041318764,
0.02011282,
0.0443184376,
0.0424913168,
0.0465152711,
0.0268090628,
0.0146769704,
-0.044914268,
0.0303980485,
0.0160859041,
-0.0001153516,
-0.0327972658,
0.0125926519,
-0.0825101361,
0.0057927021,
-0.0235776901,
-0.0169040132,
0.0099214809,
0.0355682373,
-0.0295641553,
-0.0265603065,
0.0206286162,
-0.0369952358,
0.0396716073,
0.0446734056,
-0.055273585,
0.0678950548,
-0.0661165193,
0.0208954066,
-0.0223580115,
0.002039125,
-0.0747242793,
-0.0174773764,
-0.0538747646,
0.0030335197,
-0.0281944927,
0.0608990528,
-0.0196351893,
-0.0502165817,
0.0026345407,
0.030772794,
0.0022512407,
0.0147876386,
-0.0256226659,
0.0167266112,
-0.0205931738,
0.0031224198,
-0.0124877971,
-0.0218732748,
-0.0550264679,
0.043524906,
-0.0437863804,
-0.0338677652,
-0.0046335976,
-0.0010872047,
0.0292149819,
-0.0104414364,
0.0012143111,
0.0369914249,
0.0386507921,
-0.0542591922,
-0.0492159203,
-0.0231473148,
-0.0303168539,
-0.0180897713,
-0.0137052024,
-0.063500233,
0.0584094636,
0.0213027336,
-0.028454788,
-0.0526645109,
-0.0001096297,
0.0112525467,
-0.0420909449,
0.1044990048,
-0.0014789798,
-0.0137099009,
-0.0051936214,
0.0086918017,
-0.0360965282,
0.0409016199,
0.0114468522,
0.0135007119,
0.0356672555,
0.0013626732,
-0.0532263108,
-0.0272224285,
0.0269969366,
-0.0003008899,
-0.0535114445,
0.0117201647,
0.0446993783,
0.0350010321,
0.0441131555,
0.0448219292,
-0.0585010573,
0.0208133738,
0.0444480442,
0.0798223689,
-0.0038777711,
0.0268452801,
0.062566936,
0.0086833937,
-0.0482841842,
0.0030223199,
-0.0498375185,
-0.0044461829,
-0.0087938197,
0.0037096604,
0.0475315973,
0.0133714424,
-0.0587336868,
-0.0311940014,
0.0073538395,
-0.0279345792,
0.0230277628,
-0.0154673485,
0.0627064854,
0.0411568061,
-0.0134444796,
0.0340553634,
0.094944723,
-0.0264642853,
0.0215606112,
0.0127780698,
0.0314866565,
0.0406945683,
0.029097911,
-0.0177311003,
-0.032026954,
-0.0028933405,
-0.0077370843,
0.0299708843,
0.0311682373,
-0.0281074625,
0.0098007387,
-0.0452221707,
-0.0279641952,
-0.0550279096,
0.0240395889,
0.0085948724,
0.0105854888,
0.0034167226,
0.0391754285,
-0.081092827,
-0.0029715362,
0.0434504971,
0.0089165652,
-0.0275797546,
-0.0069279573,
0.0280925352,
0.0141641544,
-0.0075406791,
-0.0000767761,
0.0199350864,
0.0218781102,
-0.0583014041,
-0.0151008423,
0.0026656485,
-0.0624850616,
-0.0865673646,
0.0212489124,
-0.0225280635,
0.0322295688,
0.0200956147,
-0.0433876887,
-0.0108493874,
0.0367265977,
0.0150608215,
0.0676216111,
-0.0480787531,
-0.0088450862,
-0.0207126997,
0.0264940467,
-0.0055109793,
0.088673532,
-0.0188188646,
0.0484760031,
-0.0331722572,
0.0385181233,
0.0025530395,
0.0166976564,
-0.070206359,
-0.0306505375,
0.0231825914,
-0.0014065265,
0.0012058706,
-0.0236498062,
-0.0189889353,
0.0129099125,
-0.0739453658,
-0.0050912444,
0.0095825652,
-0.0121816648,
0.0322018042,
-0.0135441562,
0.0323248506,
-0.0057502491,
-0.0092541929,
0.0017664257,
-0.0385928228,
0.0136735328,
0.0414760076,
0.0034962592,
-0.0397376679,
-0.0573110171,
-0.0136384638,
-0.0170848388,
0.0681286156,
-0.0363088436,
0.0071194586,
-0.0281157605,
0.0656567588,
-0.061004851,
0.0134703331,
-0.0181451142,
-0.0163497161,
-0.0137969358,
-0.0235199686,
0.0138369342,
0.0452944152,
0.0038147878,
0.0394344106,
0.0695962161,
0.0132733993,
-0.0292437226,
-0.0289171301,
-0.0527531356,
0.0305130929,
-0.0095499335,
0.0276933908,
-0.0087251542,
0.0595736429,
0.0287010856,
-0.021134397,
-0.057787165,
0.0233141463,
-0.0417922996,
0.0104074497,
-0.0413370878,
0.003259822,
0.0076539377,
0.0269592535,
-0.038246911,
-0.013927334,
0.0657837018,
-0.0223095082,
-0.0043794056,
-0.0118602561,
-0.0284163933,
-0.0138480924,
0.0473016351,
0.0315421,
0.0442373827,
0.0170524549,
-0.0082569029,
-0.0384090319,
-0.0282263923,
0.0108000953,
-0.0035158535,
0.0414830185,
-0.0076868245,
-0.0196104646,
0.0230663605,
-0.0125680454,
-0.0475267917,
-0.0268043932,
-0.0206288975,
0.0369728357,
0.0535240658,
0.0180686414,
-0.0009371541,
0.0325211883,
-0.0152916899,
0.0181879159,
0.0336789675,
-0.0276068151,
-0.0356847085,
0.0351327248,
0.0493471958,
-0.0517483428,
0.004827911,
0.0288843904,
0.0119896363,
0.0349100307,
0.0096102506,
-0.020117864,
-0.0490741692,
0.0241894424,
0.006787871,
-0.0424675941,
-0.0369893238,
-0.0015479334,
-0.0136829847,
0.0019317939,
-0.0344655439,
0.1213782281,
0.0324507803,
-0.0169541836,
0.0240876563,
0.0176281705,
-0.0003778128,
0.0214211326,
-0.0292815194,
-0.0405979045,
-0.010839968,
-0.0173528921,
-0.0282381643,
0.0564125478,
-0.0435152315,
-0.0124110878,
-0.0789076984,
0.0063608517,
0.0082512507,
-0.0879948288,
-0.0258585978,
-0.0489419438,
0.014780188,
-0.0276307464,
0.0112601593,
-0.0160283297,
0.0202197004,
0.0106544197,
-0.0159959588,
-0.0124317212,
-0.0162928291,
0.0639845356,
-0.0698867813,
0.03317146,
0.0491462387,
0.0374163277,
-0.0101106623,
-0.0331997164,
-0.0217789132,
-0.0939845294,
-0.0031080148,
0.0073801563,
0.0629732385,
-0.0539909191,
-0.0083887111,
0.0079456242,
0.0265046824,
-0.0600617304,
-0.0438355319,
-0.0287638456,
0.0533612147,
-0.0019850538,
-0.0110630682,
-0.0121349646,
0.0170023236,
-0.0000264946,
0.0781834945,
0.0386336409,
-0.0442128852,
0.0156997535,
0.0310403053,
0.0170392748,
0.0133160045,
-0.0106829107,
-0.0251542926,
0.0232603215,
0.0319059566,
-0.066631861,
-0.0582451895,
0.046051532,
0.0069450522,
-0.0056021255,
0.0198067706,
-0.0008135889,
-0.0321550108,
-0.0543129854,
0.0439103246,
-0.0181037374,
-0.0188967809,
0.0193191208,
-0.0009119189,
0.0742054954,
-0.0245367698,
-0.0607459284,
-0.0391336977,
-0.03370535,
-0.0258419774,
-0.0116627943,
0.0052036657,
0.0004150423,
0.0469379202,
-0.0291146208,
-0.0146751301,
0.0663519353,
0.0167206805,
-0.0411965884,
-0.0010261834,
0.0126576256,
0.0270348322,
0.0388254263,
0.050818596,
-0.0561429113,
0.0548170134,
0.0300944578,
0.0436194055,
-0.0091636041,
-0.0543000698,
0.0215903688,
-0.0271388013,
0.0906391814,
-0.0152693251,
-0.0105365179,
-0.0486006066,
-0.0176913962,
0.0178928822,
-0.0195375271,
-0.0419367068,
0.0080963178,
0.0295389276,
0.0338380635,
-0.0160664469,
0.0128728431,
-0.0063874787,
0.0407329984,
0.0213679317,
-0.0140960766,
0.0021422524,
-0.0052950289,
0.0104174465,
0.0466075465,
-0.0466067493,
-0.0154630728,
-0.06635499,
-0.0192992054,
-0.0500156209,
0.016035907,
0.0020483036,
0.0027759608,
-0.0768341795,
0.0477962531,
-0.051819291,
-0.0241192225,
-0.0632029548,
0.0022393258,
0.0426385663,
-0.0583352409,
-0.0101398127,
-0.0493744276,
-0.0186373405,
-0.0212224834,
0.0246481225,
-0.0183886979,
-0.0174751431,
0.0657141507,
0.0361722223,
-0.0189783648,
-0.0175195225,
0.0751167238,
-0.0424400717,
0.0688447058,
0.0352924541,
0.0055221836,
-0.0366260707,
0.0339020342,
0.0432627015,
0.0668244287,
-0.0262741912,
0.0359861329,
-0.0177890249,
-0.0717314258,
0.0507588163,
0.0051397178,
-0.0496016107,
0.0407317467,
0.0723581463,
0.0347020216,
-0.0071483562,
-0.0067323577,
-0.0123029854,
0.0116964057,
-0.0036286362,
-0.0163571667,
-0.0208836533,
-6.199710021e-33,
-0.0187580492,
-0.0070709335,
-0.0273285676,
0.0258336086,
-0.0007654083,
0.0069967168,
-0.0101701906,
-0.0142958798,
-0.0382034332,
0.0466727316,
0.0150706489,
0.0061926153,
-0.0078882277,
0.0118270526,
-0.0123542277,
-0.0201239511,
0.02751638,
0.0163270514,
0.0076642334,
0.0345501527,
0.0358028635,
0.0197777916,
0.0519202463,
-0.0683456957,
0.0083438698,
-0.0220667496,
0.0340615064,
0.036329098,
0.0578525141,
0.0657976419,
-0.0437444039,
0.0578517839,
0.0170987267,
0.0039319228,
-0.0156580508,
0.0052176258,
-0.0781413242,
-0.0576509982,
0.0118957898,
-0.0230922494,
-0.0397015996,
-0.0285561141,
0.0251642819,
-0.0173544977,
0.0203312486,
-0.0151706925,
0.062175855,
-0.0120791839,
-0.0501181297,
-0.0078860428,
-0.0826464817,
0.0182498563,
-0.0001836952,
-0.0082645034,
0.041944094,
-0.0335952416,
0.0315458998,
0.0359673388,
-0.0626682565,
0.0099372827,
-0.0346823856,
0.0141699454,
0.0017921277,
0.0044417265,
0.035087958,
0.0784439296,
0.0124405343,
-0.041350618,
0.0028321648,
-0.0072357897,
0.0421012565,
0.0626449436,
0.0065490752,
0.0402212776,
0.0319545418,
-0.0166795105,
-0.0379926935,
0.0090152044,
-0.042784106,
0.0151476245,
0.0385901704,
0.015572736,
-0.0422036983,
-0.0374902301,
-0.0774704888,
-0.0648241714,
-0.052102264,
-0.0607752837,
0.0280830245,
-0.0010010035,
-0.0109995557,
-0.0192883816,
-0.0048482036,
-0.0746366382,
-0.0095293922,
0.0408580378,
-0.0200788677,
-0.0057402118,
-0.0018678274,
0.0130957039,
-0.0575564951,
-0.0588368662,
0.0059245266,
-0.007725575,
-0.0141962077,
0.0231341776,
0.0456053466,
-0.0006706859,
-0.0262925141,
-0.0039920202,
-0.0053553376,
-0.0947519541,
-0.013411887,
-0.0308364015,
0.0404713675,
0.0338658616,
-0.0295791663,
0.0399382003,
0.0578973554,
-0.0220864918,
-0.009556978,
-0.0186709054,
0.0049752025,
0.0285937432,
-0.0208758917,
-0.0243354365,
-0.0263977516,
0.0224840231,
0.0750722438,
-0.0315549038,
-0.0225988738,
-0.011609667,
2.604e-7,
0.0643424615,
0.0122459633,
-0.0031261886,
-0.0007526308,
-0.0039783777,
0.0332593992,
0.0160264987,
0.0360646881,
-0.0179862939,
-0.0087820068,
0.0246039089,
0.0545063056,
-0.0227829851,
0.020882437,
-0.0540930368,
0.0621585324,
-0.0224047881,
-0.0136307068,
-0.0153087396,
-0.0000417454,
0.0708357319,
0.1130458489,
0.0353476033,
0.0076326914,
-0.0128098652,
-0.0604925863,
0.0661877915,
-0.0555677749,
-0.0129114604,
0.0099514062,
-0.0350156799,
0.0409067199,
0.0065369452,
0.0239147022,
0.0153770857,
0.04196354,
0.0443064384,
0.0228005014,
0.0137798637,
-0.0080133984,
-0.0451231487,
-0.0025359467,
0.0237881429,
-0.065302074,
0.0829233676,
-0.0913050473,
-0.0133376066,
-0.0252172705,
-0.0204736013,
0.0412073769,
0.0314923413,
0.0282489341,
-0.0239444729,
-0.0074590291,
0.0262631625,
0.0375323892,
-0.025151344,
-0.0979791284,
-0.000679489,
0.0840714648,
-0.0198094267,
-0.0476117879,
0.0227567069,
-0.0175758824,
0.0737458616,
-0.0259673316,
0.0133387735,
2.27748403e-34,
0.0007410993,
0.0366556384,
0.0133316265,
0.0063099153,
0.010469703,
-0.0304269698,
-0.0127359303,
-0.0143953525,
0.0310396608,
-0.0672672912,
0.0074060736
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.09781v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.09781v4 | SpecInfer: Accelerating Generative Large Language Model Serving with Tree-based Speculative Inference and Verification | 2023-05-16T20:12:59 | 2024-04-01T02:18:42 | Xupeng Miao, Gabriele Oliaro, Zhihao Zhang, Xinhao Cheng, Zeyu Wang, Zhengxin Zhang, Rae Ying Yee Wong, Alan Zhu, Lijie Yang, Xiaoxiang Shi, Chunan Shi, Zhuoming Chen, Daiyaan Arfeen, Reyna Abhyankar, Zhihao Jia | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.DC, cs.LG | This paper introduces SpecInfer, a system that accelerates generative large
language model (LLM) serving with tree-based speculative inference and
verification. The key idea behind SpecInfer is leveraging small speculative
models to predict the LLM's outputs; the predictions are organized as a token
tree, whose nodes each represent a candidate token sequence. The correctness of
all candidate token sequences represented by a token tree is verified against
the LLM in parallel using a novel tree-based parallel decoding mechanism.
SpecInfer uses an LLM as a token tree verifier instead of an incremental
decoder, which significantly reduces the end-to-end latency and computational
requirement for serving generative LLMs while provably preserving model
quality. Our evaluation shows that SpecInfer outperforms existing LLM serving
systems by 1.5-2.8x for distributed LLM inference and by 2.6-3.5x for
offloading-based LLM inference, while preserving the same generative
performance. SpecInfer is publicly available at
https://github.com/flexflow/FlexFlow/ | [
0.0050258837,
0.0789710954,
-0.0000927007,
0.0399515815,
-0.0368393101,
0.0014182776,
0.0059745074,
0.0113021592,
-0.016712673,
-0.0149398046,
0.0313258916,
-0.0712372139,
0.0065778862,
0.0311741009,
0.0107121244,
-0.0023687351,
0.0273711104,
-0.0390218943,
0.0324754454,
-0.0540549643,
-0.0226197708,
0.0326994024,
0.0174263734,
0.0250109714,
-0.0275363103,
-0.0456463397,
-0.0102712549,
0.0031369119,
-0.0266113076,
-0.0279335435,
-0.0191774573,
0.0337028205,
-0.0139511032,
0.0497480705,
0.0000020443,
-0.0264534429,
-0.0037005702,
0.038975656,
-0.0493748523,
0.0379150584,
0.0199914034,
0.0187663566,
-0.0558298789,
0.0403799117,
0.0012756485,
-0.036052525,
0.0479101278,
-0.0158289447,
0.0090946751,
0.0577548221,
-0.0030163096,
-0.051718235,
0.0240613762,
-0.0017137156,
-0.0190495551,
-0.0163673069,
0.0308400504,
-0.0196029097,
-0.00337292,
0.0069868113,
0.0066722883,
0.0027568939,
0.0466436073,
-0.017622456,
-0.031750489,
0.0407421663,
-0.0258044172,
-0.0134612797,
-0.0334795453,
0.0158674698,
0.0107103242,
-0.0621886924,
-0.0243152585,
-0.0052303788,
-0.0320685543,
-0.0035672022,
-0.0304607674,
0.0663300455,
-0.0345403254,
0.0256616324,
0.0724671036,
-0.0116566727,
0.0527078323,
-0.0091984672,
-0.0693020001,
0.0928389952,
0.0642040446,
-0.00809325,
-0.0804814845,
-0.0115285041,
-0.0325259939,
-0.0802806616,
-0.0066071982,
-0.008528919,
-0.0712168142,
0.0127645275,
-0.0367859416,
-0.0386923254,
0.0454868153,
-0.0311493129,
0.0204793159,
0.0381091461,
-0.0071674786,
0.0094915666,
-0.0254099183,
0.0241778772,
-0.0190890711,
-0.0223577693,
-0.0240178369,
-0.0522355847,
0.0321380161,
-0.0081456145,
-0.0473994501,
0.0225381535,
-0.0795666203,
-0.0305166487,
-0.0162015818,
0.0221068263,
0.0026449915,
0.0391707607,
0.0212605968,
-0.0202020407,
-0.0118585648,
-0.0019225574,
0.00858548,
0.0255715977,
-0.024127923,
-0.0103147132,
0.0040358189,
-0.0846402347,
-0.0090936627,
0.033074826,
-0.0055672135,
-0.0147965588,
0.0178723391,
0.0705454201,
0.0368176512,
-0.0151027394,
0.0023054467,
-0.0374023914,
0.0057130069,
-0.0760352537,
-0.0105044125,
-0.070185855,
-0.0086243879,
0.0214000605,
-0.0081490744,
0.0104744518,
-0.0199242383,
0.0014367945,
0.0243166648,
0.0223054308,
-0.0168530941,
-0.0031793416,
-0.012538041,
0.0011446634,
-0.0046304343,
0.0630868152,
0.0196298957,
0.0329971425,
0.0252980478,
-0.0110019781,
0.0035315489,
0.0617218874,
0.0062584323,
-0.0008807678,
-0.0265371632,
0.0168368276,
0.0425758027,
0.0136172483,
-0.0140009597,
0.0719602108,
-0.0374834388,
-0.0141588403,
0.0302896723,
0.0806659013,
-0.0151897678,
0.0007578874,
0.0548662953,
0.0172137823,
0.0090906192,
-0.0030433144,
-0.0286257863,
-0.0104651572,
0.0068246429,
0.0279758573,
0.0230150148,
0.0707007051,
-0.006255927,
0.0031651179,
-0.0543377921,
0.0048666168,
-0.04858201,
-0.0105460556,
0.0619840436,
0.0081513263,
-0.0378692597,
0.0558499135,
0.0369898565,
-0.0669786632,
-0.0412462652,
-0.0405461267,
0.0567200296,
0.0694157332,
0.0640709028,
0.0362818502,
-0.0074005867,
0.0248674117,
-0.0222442187,
0.0473183282,
0.0093253609,
-0.0004630236,
0.0082714614,
-0.0231841784,
-0.0032248762,
0.051952485,
0.0336377136,
0.0464298576,
0.0751975328,
-0.0094513008,
-0.0052722641,
-0.0221603271,
-0.038690906,
0.014669992,
-0.0085879266,
0.0033863755,
0.0162514076,
-0.0193232521,
0.0674617738,
-0.0011197425,
-0.0257298872,
0.0190350655,
0.0731723532,
0.0085358582,
-0.0116835022,
0.0157770067,
-0.0461506397,
-0.0272478852,
0.0437376685,
0.0087116547,
-0.0264223069,
-0.0174663644,
-0.0380190387,
-0.0324524902,
0.0128706153,
-0.0377437249,
0.0614477359,
-0.0530478023,
0.0563172512,
-0.0041676359,
0.0045959484,
0.0278986115,
0.0296746437,
-0.0073582884,
0.0197288711,
-0.0034379391,
0.0245128516,
-0.0104204891,
-0.030582685,
-0.0097557679,
0.0273065772,
-0.010854234,
-0.0196265634,
-0.0219691787,
-0.012173106,
-0.0156490169,
0.0251973961,
-0.0887724683,
0.0076281903,
-0.0218071323,
0.0538436733,
0.0128885861,
0.0366506688,
-0.0105711678,
0.0148980366,
-0.0052874601,
0.017820904,
0.0349252932,
0.0229559783,
-0.0108760288,
-0.0130853057,
-0.0732587054,
0.0319944099,
-0.0067506447,
0.004600531,
0.0666347072,
-0.003681347,
-0.0101165194,
-0.0761808455,
-0.020155197,
-0.0053826524,
0.0337998308,
-0.0070128995,
-0.0057061319,
0.0294976346,
-0.0405582562,
0.0423376337,
-0.0161972716,
0.0118630575,
-0.033304885,
-0.0000270571,
-0.0043596071,
-0.0537512004,
-0.0130781727,
-0.0029411928,
-0.012482048,
-0.0429923721,
-0.0134590864,
-0.0153275756,
0.0678648502,
-0.0150618972,
-0.0262920875,
-0.0272830613,
-0.0318992585,
0.0132162496,
-0.011953759,
0.0069649527,
-0.0539288335,
-0.027682893,
0.0128364116,
-0.0101889456,
-0.0778249204,
0.0715297461,
-0.1103685796,
-0.0075598774,
-0.0079516154,
-0.0023191338,
-0.0133714238,
0.0624644123,
0.0011489637,
0.018332215,
-0.0051021203,
-0.0313587375,
0.0314995907,
0.0425057188,
0.0007546277,
-0.0269549713,
0.0112936618,
-0.0232926682,
0.0125825154,
-0.0257315673,
-0.0377310626,
-0.035300836,
-0.0219446961,
-0.0408935994,
0.0094446456,
0.0734471828,
-0.0455000177,
-0.0009865767,
0.0432234555,
-0.0600727014,
0.0613062009,
-0.0177633148,
0.0192465354,
-0.0102423774,
-0.0125738252,
0.0144783864,
-0.0435587838,
0.0543004908,
-0.0302439723,
0.000571698,
0.0785642788,
0.0151122864,
-0.0254321694,
-0.0485975221,
-0.0263774991,
0.0444918275,
-0.0197255425,
0.0170186628,
0.0445767678,
0.030259449,
-0.0753141791,
-0.0232129544,
0.1048178151,
0.0111377602,
-0.0439353213,
0.0123297125,
0.0082627032,
0.054069344,
-0.0063485643,
0.0358833075,
-0.1231004968,
-0.0177122373,
0.0431929156,
-0.0032303142,
-0.0130383801,
0.0071573104,
-0.0207976922,
-0.1192634776,
0.0784714594,
0.0186793059,
-0.0081664659,
0.0200309735,
-0.0470495895,
-0.0307159591,
0.0539458655,
0.0241573881,
0.0513555594,
0.0071483124,
-0.0103465645,
0.008064473,
0.0137665756,
-0.0245432444,
0.0243353229,
-0.0338997468,
0.0469665974,
0.0362188518,
-0.014207813,
0.0268318281,
-0.0365925021,
0.0412837267,
0.0125318225,
-0.0285829455,
-0.0250387527,
-0.0392857529,
-0.0162285976,
0.0148807298,
-0.0024175043,
0.0087944856,
-0.0055970461,
-0.0051383507,
-0.0299450308,
0.0809214711,
-0.0119044306,
-0.0327831432,
-0.0072778985,
-0.0296645891,
-0.0109261358,
0.0683014765,
0.0189782437,
0.0189835299,
-0.0491417274,
-0.0620379858,
-0.0328059308,
-0.0089664171,
0.0209929533,
-0.0022991565,
0.0219787639,
-0.0226430297,
-0.0156217562,
0.0454027243,
0.0250806492,
0.039077051,
-0.0177501328,
0.0315461271,
0.0007674982,
-0.0377945006,
-0.0386204571,
-0.0062258425,
-0.0522062592,
0.0259260125,
-0.0668075606,
0.0341126136,
0.0461593345,
-0.0030171259,
-0.0279278345,
0.0467535444,
-0.0985712186,
-0.075600177,
-0.0325103514,
0.0089075658,
0.0253491793,
0.0312631056,
-0.0453488417,
-0.0281008407,
0.040541105,
0.0623434409,
-0.0923618004,
0.0127474368,
0.0037136271,
-0.0331599079,
0.0134063289,
0.0240254868,
-0.0266308971,
0.0072626462,
-0.0155581739,
0.0163532551,
0.0331723578,
-0.02080971,
-0.0104183974,
0.0826981515,
0.0318303108,
-0.0382399783,
-0.0097798435,
0.0080422061,
0.0892807841,
-0.0348765403,
-0.0173960999,
-0.008675484,
0.0279147625,
-0.0229538269,
-0.0453064106,
-0.0098816641,
-0.0080063511,
0.038600374,
0.0160383545,
-0.0130356289,
-0.0127095841,
-0.000879853,
-0.0443083346,
0.076412186,
-0.0389834717,
0.0107649146,
-0.0391183347,
0.0142190242,
0.0345785432,
-0.0311987028,
-0.0212400649,
0.0253448132,
0.0014226433,
-0.0091588721,
-0.0079618786,
-0.0313472897,
-0.0662118793,
-0.0328500159,
0.041309204,
0.0661746636,
0.0574786961,
0.0492527448,
-0.0324707106,
-0.0029898952,
-0.0207948685,
0.0058197929,
0.0117317075,
-0.0692012906,
0.0414596908,
0.0138348565,
-0.0387622453,
0.0030992937,
0.0511382334,
0.05126803,
0.0470799655,
0.0049781655,
-0.0359223336,
-0.0278480388,
-0.0781495944,
-0.0671675429,
0.0141337132,
-0.0395673327,
-0.034584254,
-0.0338535793,
-0.0535150431,
-0.0131817479,
0.0426961482,
0.0057047904,
0.0013101953,
-0.0061233989,
0.0607800744,
0.0191283673,
-0.0505569093,
-0.0176757649,
0.0136360014,
0.0464518145,
-0.0286732558,
0.0071315276,
-6.489758843e-33,
-0.0130132632,
-0.0337747335,
0.0349772908,
-0.0318068489,
-0.0100411186,
-0.0139720226,
-0.0396075696,
-0.0467323065,
0.0436079726,
0.0203123502,
0.0088101607,
0.0401031077,
0.0310910419,
0.0323696174,
0.0168614108,
0.023490645,
0.0620122291,
0.0114765568,
-0.0264137238,
0.0061889053,
0.050440751,
0.0106176203,
0.0226499625,
0.0095224176,
-0.0119479932,
-0.0671777949,
-0.000959454,
0.0009670577,
-0.0578526743,
0.0328189619,
-0.0006518143,
0.0129676331,
-0.0053080879,
-0.0411737189,
-0.0183976553,
-0.0267265588,
-0.0650809184,
0.0356435515,
0.0428611673,
-0.0041364743,
-0.0226479396,
-0.015254939,
0.0050729406,
0.0248278622,
-0.0111464811,
0.0167013314,
-0.0400596894,
0.01000972,
-0.0165635869,
-0.0465645194,
-0.0144308629,
0.0247571506,
0.0407822952,
0.0709711984,
0.0233160909,
0.0159457251,
0.0167832486,
0.0129576717,
-0.0059705973,
0.0334096476,
0.005990712,
0.0505920649,
0.0709418356,
-0.0074462402,
0.0285246298,
0.0357140228,
0.0230389163,
-0.0509580448,
-0.0162655506,
0.0260863714,
-0.0068169078,
0.0333275013,
0.0196828973,
0.0424619541,
0.0535034128,
-0.0181988236,
-0.0699518993,
0.010848715,
0.0367497504,
0.0383932218,
0.0392199121,
0.0107822912,
0.0062410505,
-0.0355956629,
-0.0411174111,
0.008970039,
-0.0336452574,
-0.0008375497,
0.0092244074,
0.0266837217,
-0.0145833902,
0.0043766038,
0.0471219681,
-0.0400261395,
-0.0524499007,
0.0476527028,
-0.0153189441,
-0.0221473407,
-0.0096925283,
0.0594061129,
-0.0116333263,
-0.0159513429,
0.0165272579,
-0.0265113097,
-0.0094576133,
0.0118996231,
0.0102231838,
0.0047791316,
-0.0654925033,
0.0282716714,
-0.0481003225,
0.0299534481,
-0.003028227,
-0.01001848,
0.0692366958,
0.0129689192,
0.0322352238,
0.0317849033,
0.000287255,
0.0460667238,
-0.0169425607,
0.0186227299,
0.0105273798,
0.0113835027,
-0.0180330109,
0.0217425972,
-0.0509582646,
0.0417005569,
0.0411559306,
-0.0440547056,
-0.020456804,
0.0616537035,
2.769e-7,
0.0159655642,
0.0302730482,
0.0526780747,
0.0327727869,
0.0425678827,
-0.0018290065,
0.0060081724,
-0.0098850215,
0.0236140639,
0.004623991,
-0.0199977253,
0.0178193245,
0.0456100069,
0.0351299755,
-0.1016750336,
-0.0141442586,
-0.0986355171,
0.0128855146,
-0.0570092574,
-0.0273630265,
0.0003271694,
0.1000277847,
-0.0135025214,
-0.0213639382,
0.0510731079,
-0.0251962356,
0.0102833034,
0.0019778982,
-0.0177978259,
0.0054857228,
-0.0245863888,
-0.0087454896,
0.0260618236,
0.0119032823,
-0.0048704175,
0.0005706144,
-0.0838370398,
0.0479001142,
0.0109532569,
0.0157932639,
0.020829197,
-0.054627642,
-0.0138389748,
-0.035683088,
0.0566889346,
0.0085623758,
-0.0070728804,
-0.0449266098,
-0.040664427,
-0.0441226289,
-0.0562230833,
0.0109924125,
0.0259570815,
0.0480672866,
0.0040307916,
-0.0415990092,
0.0014423945,
-0.0586631149,
-0.0510268733,
-0.0660988986,
-0.0697413459,
-0.0636799037,
-0.0266651493,
0.0359344073,
-0.003187628,
-0.0500643216,
-0.0022636394,
3.072368003e-34,
0.0528389551,
0.0351524353,
-0.0186908916,
0.0827856362,
0.0465291366,
-0.0268149748,
8.056e-7,
0.0260163043,
-0.0198650267,
-0.0803225413,
-0.0428568609
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10450v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10450v1 | Understanding of Normal and Abnormal Hearts by Phase Space Analysis and Convolutional Neural Networks | 2023-05-16T19:52:40 | 2023-05-16T19:52:40 | Bekir Yavuz Koc, Taner Arsan, Onder Pekcan | eess.IV | eess.IV, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG, cs.NE, eess.SP, 68, I.5.1 | Cardiac diseases are one of the leading mortality factors in modern,
industrialized societies, which cause high expenses in public health systems.
Due to high costs, developing analytical methods to improve cardiac diagnostics
is essential. The heart's electric activity was first modeled using a set of
nonlinear differential equations. Following this, variations of cardiac spectra
originating from deterministic dynamics are investigated. Analyzing a normal
human heart's power spectra offers His-Purkinje network, which possesses a
fractal-like structure. Phase space trajectories are extracted from the time
series electrocardiogram (ECG) graph with third-order derivate Taylor Series.
Here in this study, phase space analysis and Convolutional Neural Networks
(CNNs) method are applied to 44 records via the MIT-BIH database recorded with
MLII. In order to increase accuracy, a straight line is drawn between the
highest Q-R distance in the phase space images of the records. Binary CNN
classification is used to determine healthy or unhealthy hearts. With a 90.90%
accuracy rate, this model could classify records according to their heart
status. | [
-0.0295787901,
0.001424659,
-0.0153492773,
0.0232728329,
0.0192604586,
0.0069072014,
0.0311271809,
-0.0050431588,
-0.0319804735,
0.0721036568,
0.0532849692,
-0.0583518818,
-0.0046600527,
0.0645651594,
0.0140114576,
-0.0515873954,
-0.0021048214,
0.0258960519,
0.0166144464,
-0.0265320316,
-0.0100553613,
-0.0451556854,
0.0069158627,
0.0408061668,
0.0057133497,
-0.0149625763,
-0.022705432,
-0.0157166217,
0.0715652183,
-0.047682859,
-0.0157977939,
-0.0082500167,
-0.052399043,
0.0226633511,
0.0000020114,
-0.0230587926,
0.0190684497,
-0.0038150277,
-0.0083189653,
-0.0301435851,
-0.0174176935,
-0.0013715391,
-0.0049605449,
-0.0560629219,
-0.0776613206,
0.0140041225,
-0.0089648617,
0.0658027455,
0.0738092512,
0.0236786585,
-0.0239858404,
-0.0001105362,
0.0319893882,
-0.0364763215,
-0.0182282813,
-0.0181093439,
0.0091293305,
-0.019700408,
0.035202384,
-0.0321964584,
-0.0176091921,
0.0875464678,
0.0475525297,
0.041608844,
0.0788875967,
0.0301485676,
0.0058303876,
-0.0197076965,
-0.0294719543,
0.0740049854,
-0.0799253583,
0.0135843558,
-0.003241918,
0.0085764285,
0.0107547808,
0.0154261887,
-0.0221885145,
-0.0027066453,
-0.029777674,
-0.0169404186,
-0.0306421239,
-0.017312387,
0.010109893,
-0.0424034335,
-0.0177471042,
-0.0089788204,
-0.0162426401,
0.0010407297,
0.0225157067,
-0.0282724388,
-0.0058627957,
-0.0055137211,
-0.0139539195,
0.0008730211,
0.0167974047,
-0.0254378635,
0.0154545186,
-0.0258571412,
-0.0008440415,
-0.0399828888,
-0.0123487301,
-0.0319400206,
0.0027956711,
-0.0061009983,
-0.0225404557,
-0.0308688302,
-0.0832057223,
0.0654159635,
-0.0196356904,
0.0724221244,
-0.0661834404,
0.0272605084,
0.0127024502,
0.0482652709,
0.0547638685,
-0.0007704838,
-0.0568409041,
-0.0118915122,
-0.0297441743,
-0.024303481,
0.0026088241,
0.0692390949,
0.0563501604,
0.0319057927,
-0.0148526933,
-0.0073262332,
0.0083117709,
0.0077441921,
-0.0122477682,
-0.0139028402,
0.0143047608,
-0.0299168266,
-0.0044237631,
0.0010738561,
-0.008779454,
-0.0450736731,
0.0341026597,
0.0004886282,
-0.0760123059,
-0.0134653766,
-0.012339294,
-0.0071475776,
0.0131850261,
-0.0101214508,
-0.026368482,
-0.0068228226,
-0.0002045993,
0.0348820277,
0.0082533062,
-0.0219962988,
0.0323508643,
0.0631915107,
-0.0490797423,
-0.0197818335,
0.0407089144,
0.0146085769,
0.0065195491,
0.0203561299,
0.05679271,
-0.03512742,
-0.0235405024,
-0.0313913152,
0.0255527999,
-0.0321222804,
-0.0173310265,
-0.0724083111,
-0.0556980334,
-0.0512510426,
-0.0479694828,
0.0401026122,
0.0141252335,
-0.008277989,
0.0189617835,
-0.0272578225,
0.013469331,
0.0315641575,
0.0488914996,
0.0850805193,
0.0081760082,
-0.0259260815,
0.0342240855,
-0.0465882085,
0.0187890213,
0.0341444537,
0.0045315675,
-0.0076822946,
-0.091320917,
-0.0365305282,
0.000247576,
-0.0660340637,
0.0013998726,
-0.0479463488,
0.0018871027,
-0.0520609803,
0.0380864106,
-0.0476861447,
-0.0234813206,
0.0048854481,
-0.0093347616,
0.0260592438,
-0.0714102387,
-0.000166294,
0.0234268345,
0.0234619007,
-0.0254258625,
-0.042564176,
0.0555502214,
-0.0338627733,
-0.0020149176,
-0.0475549176,
0.0140277138,
0.0340586305,
0.0294252206,
-0.0325299241,
-0.0459330641,
0.013292267,
-0.0278620273,
0.0005706358,
-0.0568714365,
0.0362107567,
-0.0139126843,
-0.0095548686,
0.0303735398,
-0.0367913917,
-0.01773143,
0.0174161252,
0.0301461648,
0.0578405671,
0.0457474887,
0.0197375733,
-0.0065659722,
-0.0272568353,
0.0045462283,
-0.0436122417,
-0.0490915254,
-0.0049454961,
-0.0144049125,
-0.0024479297,
0.004068776,
-0.0101031717,
0.0042187357,
-0.0158583764,
-0.0254239477,
-0.0651425347,
-0.0035330241,
-0.004739949,
-0.0191335678,
-0.0319677256,
-0.0250188466,
0.0150621282,
0.0447333008,
-0.0250697378,
-0.04540883,
0.0144894486,
0.0009797724,
-0.0075139068,
0.0302814003,
0.0348992012,
-0.0072764661,
-0.0686673373,
-0.0092966789,
-0.0397980772,
-0.0525654852,
-0.0011324359,
-0.0048723207,
0.0225440674,
0.0345763005,
0.0057483739,
-0.0336498432,
0.0428080782,
-0.0103456005,
-0.0325282663,
0.0437446088,
-0.0012881263,
0.0058801072,
0.0298998877,
0.0904031992,
-0.003896401,
-0.0530560315,
0.0714582577,
0.0263758656,
-0.0211339574,
-0.0047296225,
-0.0096659362,
-0.0418243818,
0.019376358,
0.0383081548,
0.0101162884,
0.017401062,
-0.0024725695,
0.0026083174,
0.0269879941,
0.0089775128,
-0.0590280853,
-0.0248306785,
-0.0138229346,
-0.0422597714,
0.1009624749,
0.0337169841,
-0.0171738658,
-0.0082397535,
0.0780324489,
0.0515289716,
0.045000907,
-0.0479053222,
0.0263884384,
0.0089209042,
-0.0067383642,
-0.0148708755,
0.0402503647,
0.0458312407,
-0.0070024412,
0.0426533632,
-0.0218920223,
0.0190946385,
0.0277716946,
-0.0233025495,
0.0131724412,
-0.0180725567,
-0.0187802427,
0.0267607756,
-0.0275471359,
0.021211369,
0.0378070846,
0.020721335,
0.0378792994,
-0.0339521207,
-0.0302129462,
0.015314782,
0.0088599874,
0.0119948369,
-0.0137964692,
0.0180625655,
-0.0009164304,
-0.0183175281,
-0.0437573716,
-0.0314698331,
0.0260782819,
-0.0676987097,
0.0220589936,
0.0264311135,
0.0079630194,
-0.0541185439,
0.0210286621,
0.0158265866,
-0.005776315,
-0.0581282824,
0.0190041773,
0.0509948954,
0.0669855475,
-0.0058088233,
-0.0058161691,
-0.0091100661,
-0.0349145234,
-0.0229368601,
0.079740122,
0.0143825458,
0.0130891977,
0.0370816849,
-0.0112791006,
0.0684679598,
-0.0155915599,
-0.0044542747,
0.0721204206,
-0.0722683445,
0.0086176079,
-0.0812575296,
0.0140313674,
0.0108822547,
-0.0141130937,
-0.0214046054,
0.0079580052,
0.0057208799,
0.0478963479,
-0.005763723,
-0.0483610034,
0.0094846627,
0.033196304,
-0.0690546706,
-0.0021818047,
-0.0318482257,
-0.006320735,
0.0107109696,
0.004332005,
0.0058172173,
0.0091397222,
-0.0179379378,
0.0276620109,
0.0270294417,
0.0148763321,
0.0160507131,
0.0250739809,
-0.06645336,
-0.0374985337,
0.0022025253,
-0.0678254962,
-0.0120935915,
-0.0357074663,
0.0040431968,
-0.0103666969,
0.010830069,
-0.0441572256,
0.0380120575,
0.0124215446,
-0.0162387658,
-0.0209803581,
0.0275500212,
-0.0110628493,
-0.0264512952,
0.0020861768,
-0.0187486093,
0.0395175479,
-0.0063930964,
-0.0062453975,
0.0086509688,
0.1144879311,
-0.0178606585,
-0.0104589341,
0.070011653,
-0.037608441,
0.0294961594,
-0.0333001092,
0.0356767438,
-0.0245474149,
-0.0355655812,
-0.0600182489,
0.0175452195,
0.0612447336,
0.0137153799,
0.005365693,
-0.01422738,
-0.0494486243,
0.0191736314,
0.0901112854,
-0.032627672,
-0.0194174126,
0.0167574361,
0.0120902928,
-0.0384499617,
0.0068246755,
0.0288011599,
-0.0729282871,
0.0363539755,
0.055214107,
0.0012018763,
0.1855794787,
-0.0094570098,
-0.0265158936,
0.0343891941,
0.0723325461,
0.0334488004,
0.0081176218,
-0.0273886193,
-0.0077955732,
0.0008609204,
-0.040454153,
-0.0122053316,
-0.0555157699,
0.0634671152,
0.027052775,
0.0270898975,
0.0021154482,
-0.0159973446,
-0.0450406298,
0.0107533215,
0.0092280786,
0.000107771,
0.0218631458,
-0.0324884281,
0.0009308638,
0.0168447141,
-0.0298477281,
0.0189144462,
0.04980148,
0.0322736874,
-0.0081001371,
0.0081891082,
-0.0136247119,
-0.0169951394,
-0.0328705795,
-0.0069956984,
0.0716492012,
0.015714623,
-0.0566273518,
0.0068306755,
0.0463972054,
0.0480953641,
0.0693114549,
-0.0019841918,
-0.031437587,
0.0182548352,
-0.0110247312,
-0.0201994013,
-0.0548948832,
0.0444697775,
-0.125900507,
-0.006940898,
0.0568454489,
-0.0235767588,
0.0131736314,
-0.0111570032,
0.0235665068,
0.0099496171,
0.0567461178,
0.0169855282,
-0.0302402172,
0.0339463763,
0.0462958105,
-0.0269109793,
0.0393293425,
-0.0188957173,
0.0126411039,
-0.0365652889,
0.0612082444,
-0.004978199,
-0.0337369703,
0.0287674498,
-0.0445181876,
-0.0150578553,
-0.0121480729,
0.0110757817,
-0.014612902,
0.0090583954,
-0.0794212148,
0.0737881139,
0.0845364705,
-0.0028658493,
-0.0127895614,
0.0053617079,
0.0401291065,
0.0086120768,
0.0090498962,
-0.0130308969,
0.0051487638,
-0.0304076858,
0.0485556163,
0.0141767142,
-0.0423079953,
0.0007070709,
0.0164244082,
-0.0226195138,
-0.026952941,
0.0722938925,
0.003951123,
-0.0445432849,
-0.0242057629,
0.0558830798,
0.0006428775,
-0.0362798199,
-0.0163894035,
0.015128837,
0.0243147761,
0.0102290474,
-0.0341792554,
-0.0596252382,
-5.353038174e-33,
0.0187671147,
-0.0288918987,
-0.0045024781,
-0.01550062,
-0.0019770619,
0.0257131606,
-0.0226030238,
-0.0346115716,
0.0165933296,
0.0031857658,
-0.01069389,
0.0021567275,
0.0146501902,
0.0378467143,
0.0338408686,
-0.0717683882,
-0.0014342749,
-0.0026794428,
0.0587239377,
0.0308516379,
-0.0006136255,
0.0659170821,
-0.0061271135,
-0.0669680238,
-0.0735188723,
0.0807718784,
-0.0078996969,
0.0024710346,
-0.0016687728,
-0.0279999953,
-0.0092417449,
0.0198266134,
-0.013786789,
-0.0134476116,
0.0102508217,
0.0166286044,
-0.0221825764,
0.025712017,
-0.018511802,
-0.0112461671,
0.0450245403,
-0.021412326,
0.071075134,
-0.0328538977,
-0.0080625247,
-0.0083103552,
0.0463653728,
0.0038291374,
0.0382676236,
-0.0815474093,
0.0142563852,
0.0086812433,
-0.0440895148,
-0.0132131148,
-0.0104060322,
-0.0220609494,
-0.0522251651,
-0.0132341776,
-0.0635448471,
-0.0093833962,
0.0121065257,
-0.0142424963,
-0.0212346409,
0.0061480203,
0.0450792946,
0.0096677821,
0.0894326419,
-0.0235754754,
-0.0165439025,
0.032463301,
-0.0384633504,
0.0874512196,
0.0348319225,
-0.0388715118,
-0.0051439111,
-0.0568190515,
-0.0910723731,
0.0267923195,
-0.0130786225,
-0.0219765007,
-0.0941201299,
-0.0153418323,
0.002612748,
0.0364460424,
0.0758430213,
-0.0124008823,
-0.0065583377,
0.0303907413,
-0.0223375205,
-0.0575035177,
0.0741336048,
0.007739611,
-0.0439003147,
-0.0526104756,
0.0484570824,
-0.0381475613,
0.090079084,
0.0011314399,
0.0894764736,
-0.0292688087,
0.0482368283,
-0.0104322946,
-0.0025494618,
0.0141289672,
0.0469899252,
-0.0321453996,
-0.0059802774,
0.0244620331,
0.0007789453,
-0.0347017124,
0.0213073231,
-0.0215457901,
0.0046618301,
0.0046508852,
0.0378895439,
-0.0306786168,
0.0145061174,
0.0378039889,
-0.0332582705,
0.0221407041,
-0.0273837838,
-0.0349743217,
-0.007295128,
0.0329216905,
-0.0179527719,
-0.0467747822,
-0.032978747,
0.0245580114,
-0.0482700132,
-0.0601938441,
-0.0240136646,
-0.0045911395,
3.05e-7,
-0.0080939084,
0.0181237385,
0.0211247653,
-0.0290823076,
0.003511366,
0.010648272,
-0.0435870737,
-0.0197614562,
-0.0439476296,
-0.0226036701,
0.0552482381,
0.0222691018,
0.0425189957,
-0.0016744084,
-0.0492960997,
-0.0276335515,
-0.0138522647,
0.0502425022,
0.0107359383,
0.0204043128,
0.0132633466,
0.0174475051,
-0.0138496505,
-0.024764441,
0.0806015059,
0.0056382548,
0.0049700085,
0.0318927728,
0.0290954784,
-0.0033232796,
0.016914485,
-0.0263265073,
0.02650542,
-0.0434615612,
0.0238409769,
0.0315457359,
0.0187454503,
0.0036616658,
-0.0004738256,
-0.0337930173,
-0.0156538803,
0.0057509183,
0.0718754977,
-0.0116327181,
0.0844495893,
0.0040198807,
-0.0329606608,
-0.0394839644,
0.0092862397,
0.0323405042,
0.0796798095,
-0.0112235118,
-0.0061511663,
0.0309009142,
-0.0210521147,
-0.0784367844,
0.0332001001,
0.0211229157,
-0.0048199957,
0.0861901864,
-0.0296794642,
0.002115922,
-0.0374564603,
0.0270214677,
0.0871622115,
0.0063611763,
-0.0254401919,
1.952573488e-34,
-0.0324126668,
0.0077161831,
-0.0036551813,
-0.0228529964,
-0.0366952941,
0.0129659148,
-0.0177195985,
-0.0337291695,
-0.0632148907,
-0.0356566459,
-0.0043077432
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.09770v6 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.09770v6 | ConvXAI: Delivering Heterogeneous AI Explanations via Conversations to Support Human-AI Scientific Writing | 2023-05-16T19:48:49 | 2023-10-27T16:08:32 | Hua Shen, Chieh-Yang Huang, Tongshuang Wu, Ting-Hao 'Kenneth' Huang | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL | Despite a surge collection of XAI methods, users still struggle to obtain
required AI explanations. Previous research suggests chatbots as dynamic
solutions, but the effective design of conversational XAI agents for practical
human needs remains under-explored. This paper focuses on Conversational XAI
for AI-assisted scientific writing tasks. Drawing from human linguistic
theories and formative studies, we identify four design rationales:
"multifaceted", "controllability", "mix-initiative", "context-aware
drill-down". We incorporate them into an interactive prototype, ConvXAI, which
facilitates heterogeneous AI explanations for scientific writing through
dialogue. In two studies with 21 users, ConvXAI outperforms a GUI-based
baseline on improving human-perceived understanding and writing improvement.
The paper further discusses the practical human usage patterns in interacting
with ConvXAI for scientific co-writing. | [
0.0428837389,
-0.012330927,
-0.016970586,
-0.0140553229,
-0.0202491861,
-0.0042253747,
0.0484850705,
0.001987607,
0.0184778646,
-0.0173285063,
-0.0209975038,
-0.0006634363,
0.0436215512,
0.0525699854,
-0.0218351167,
-0.0717832744,
0.0018026807,
-0.0297133103,
0.0787373185,
0.0152438935,
0.0340378173,
0.0119028324,
-0.0554104,
0.0735583454,
-0.0467072316,
-0.0711108223,
-0.050985992,
-0.0453022607,
-0.0136702266,
-0.0007171369,
0.0040601864,
0.0493444502,
0.0225371718,
0.0251206793,
0.0000020758,
-0.0169986282,
0.0192170031,
0.03003034,
-0.0342758782,
-0.016195206,
-0.0128905652,
0.0039820871,
-0.0081308708,
0.0018312312,
-0.0352874771,
0.0344780013,
0.0536191203,
0.0649887919,
0.0365045778,
0.0109210424,
-0.0156316571,
0.0252508074,
0.0318562724,
0.0339251235,
0.0021794932,
0.0050548813,
-0.0469296128,
0.0408814885,
0.0936165079,
0.0279524345,
0.0220085997,
0.043596182,
0.0331771858,
-0.0894761905,
-0.0128493048,
0.0372600704,
-0.0015981222,
-0.0389828235,
-0.0268681124,
0.0580214337,
0.0802695826,
0.001375383,
-0.0221415814,
-0.009294223,
0.0088676112,
0.0144828744,
-0.0700826421,
0.0025200855,
-0.0454286337,
-0.0523166843,
-0.0083722621,
-0.0287945215,
0.0018201981,
0.0444989763,
0.0158511624,
0.0313484035,
-0.0046281395,
-0.016113013,
-0.0275301784,
-0.0011668409,
0.0473352484,
-0.0623014458,
-0.0110873068,
0.1037821248,
-0.095061034,
0.0096439114,
-0.0180226937,
-0.060488224,
0.012066572,
-0.000366938,
0.0302323643,
0.0360289365,
-0.0038003081,
-0.0033499941,
0.0382138304,
0.0613605343,
0.0113625927,
0.0093612615,
0.0380527414,
-0.0127061456,
-0.0566461496,
-0.0479394235,
-0.0336847492,
0.0213494711,
-0.0307400096,
-0.0186494999,
-0.0021809649,
0.0211907886,
-0.0111144055,
0.0182004869,
-0.0150556955,
0.0087660318,
-0.0581740253,
0.0144558195,
0.0019578335,
0.0197209828,
-0.0451958142,
0.0038816414,
0.033783026,
-0.0481206216,
-0.0264957342,
0.0249819811,
0.0027812435,
-0.0257369317,
-0.045887433,
0.0246365201,
-0.0254565924,
-0.0168589093,
0.0119449943,
-0.0595267341,
-0.0125196874,
-0.0320994183,
-0.0174604133,
-0.0009812169,
0.030990405,
0.0330864154,
-0.0276961345,
-0.0259317458,
0.0030868633,
0.0080968877,
-0.0301480684,
0.0303325094,
-0.0634533986,
0.0018416173,
0.0705476403,
0.0020577861,
-0.0470109656,
0.0073473817,
0.0593136624,
-0.0033929502,
0.0096968841,
0.0092580505,
0.0678616315,
-0.0350587703,
-0.0130505636,
-0.0093017025,
0.0170115866,
-0.0117892371,
-0.0400302634,
0.0714358687,
-0.0096502285,
0.0160087384,
-0.0062453649,
0.0798400491,
0.0397176817,
0.0691700205,
0.0054363506,
0.0376440883,
0.0458139218,
-0.0009937787,
0.0379458256,
0.0352306589,
-0.0086266072,
0.0764192417,
0.0279941298,
0.0052154418,
-0.0096195564,
-0.0214900151,
-0.0135346772,
-0.0800032541,
-0.0093540894,
0.0124316774,
0.0076675662,
-0.0398240723,
0.0169948582,
0.0142900534,
0.0018428945,
-0.0504452214,
0.0087047219,
-0.0966767594,
-0.0297071747,
-0.0270866901,
0.0605723932,
0.1106849685,
0.0504263453,
-0.0560432151,
-0.0274873208,
0.0089485971,
0.0304020923,
0.0666762739,
0.0306218881,
-0.0127859339,
-0.009246951,
-0.009107003,
-0.0027548994,
-0.067375578,
0.0054041035,
-0.0010212632,
-0.0009936941,
0.0214985572,
-0.0116456691,
0.0060571088,
-0.0375899114,
0.0499595515,
-0.0381351672,
-0.0055427495,
-0.0383512676,
0.0202761572,
-0.0145071596,
0.0428616293,
-0.0134316022,
0.0276709814,
-0.0015060992,
0.004652808,
-0.0461101644,
0.0532350317,
0.0411081202,
-0.0250816364,
0.0104781091,
-0.0432420149,
-0.003496849,
-0.0310217142,
0.0185298994,
-0.0393039286,
0.027383754,
-0.0413182117,
0.0327096581,
-0.0147139719,
-0.0347251408,
0.0179060791,
-0.0181338359,
0.0027527374,
0.014535035,
0.0267459918,
-0.0101152286,
0.0506874472,
0.0305226427,
-0.0070056617,
-0.028089691,
0.0480624326,
0.0336682163,
0.0019717512,
-0.0153678562,
0.0018711974,
-0.0260808039,
-0.0215110872,
-0.0053618262,
-0.0738084018,
-0.0253367722,
-0.0095130131,
-0.0425044969,
0.0064396933,
-0.0019414669,
0.0170099866,
0.0069894399,
-0.0156978387,
-0.0055886805,
0.0011072219,
0.0078645423,
0.0722371936,
0.0168552473,
0.0003236059,
-0.0486396477,
0.0178789254,
-0.030157119,
0.0154423295,
0.0701679364,
-0.042451065,
-0.071774818,
0.0037435237,
-0.0225402527,
-0.053172145,
-0.0196456574,
-0.0275750849,
0.0684051216,
0.0061172247,
0.0038635517,
0.0673733577,
0.0004955902,
0.0904742554,
0.0671910271,
0.0049997703,
-0.0108784633,
0.0137881413,
0.0260131471,
0.0320739746,
0.0581696108,
0.0148482593,
0.0246457532,
0.0487936921,
-0.0194007568,
0.0314896367,
-0.0683882684,
0.0057735196,
-0.0119647412,
-0.035846632,
0.0023953156,
-0.0586393513,
-0.0107129561,
0.035268683,
-0.0154639119,
-0.0311645642,
0.0671656132,
-0.0202496126,
-0.0174693037,
-0.030161649,
-0.0301177111,
-0.0365148559,
0.0559870824,
-0.0866128802,
0.015571082,
0.0143876253,
0.007563821,
-0.0454133414,
-0.0050645969,
0.000277492,
0.0208647586,
-0.0148698045,
-0.0610595159,
0.0062854672,
0.0154078696,
-0.0037849692,
-0.003091976,
0.001471449,
-0.0310047362,
0.0238883086,
0.0537120625,
-0.0583978519,
-0.0185864065,
-0.0106884139,
0.0583523884,
0.0393999666,
-0.0275316034,
-0.013918695,
-0.0366029926,
-0.0222508144,
-0.0018676128,
0.0413832404,
-0.0093438169,
-0.0277563278,
0.0453650281,
0.0376005918,
-0.0176716242,
-0.016941037,
-0.0077221082,
-0.0464777499,
0.0004637217,
-0.0291758385,
-0.0429585055,
-0.0083160391,
0.0902950093,
-0.0477302037,
-0.01713337,
0.0876332372,
0.0263136141,
-0.056146577,
0.0059347171,
-0.0663998276,
0.0338420868,
-0.0251001343,
0.0473811962,
-0.0632927418,
-0.0116727576,
0.0043408535,
0.0388333946,
-0.0100715989,
-0.0055542369,
-0.0215574,
-0.0361683108,
0.0300472472,
-0.0200188197,
-0.0422770381,
0.0198677778,
-0.0458402522,
0.0268165879,
0.0500922874,
0.0074657425,
0.0174355395,
0.0298656411,
0.0109223891,
0.0020195115,
-0.0290100239,
-0.0222829934,
-0.017328674,
-0.0048364019,
0.0070842975,
0.0326192081,
0.094357945,
0.0258390438,
-0.0194526184,
-0.0110614039,
0.0331357792,
0.0604004972,
-0.0164209791,
0.0577277951,
-0.0185755733,
0.0232466366,
-0.0645508766,
0.0716957077,
-0.0173901226,
-0.0599343441,
0.0052455906,
0.0401962735,
-0.0785202011,
0.0191763286,
-0.0422131121,
-0.0037242116,
0.0274969097,
0.0405127406,
0.053057339,
-0.0399588831,
-0.0583898313,
-0.0273359902,
0.027481487,
-0.0067550186,
0.0009307452,
-0.0274546184,
-0.0080789002,
-0.0258766767,
-0.0618845075,
-0.0803970471,
0.0582208671,
0.0413853638,
0.0426904224,
-0.0041538016,
0.0046746759,
0.0256378204,
0.0071818288,
-0.0101686353,
0.0313790217,
0.0375931188,
-0.0130853998,
-0.0401592031,
-0.0103856428,
-0.0233569965,
0.0418917239,
0.0024011601,
0.0077990186,
-0.0592235178,
-0.018219687,
0.0446205661,
0.0223865081,
0.0150235817,
-0.0010524988,
-0.0920427516,
-0.0368678756,
-0.0161037277,
0.0187719204,
0.0029782981,
0.0144193219,
0.0275040176,
0.0054061133,
0.0221162755,
-0.0283397138,
-0.0426987708,
-0.0537765622,
0.0244617369,
-0.0493386239,
-0.0441050716,
0.0211601742,
-0.0004513048,
-0.0072969408,
-0.0466213711,
0.0017680264,
-0.0318862274,
0.026376484,
-0.0706429034,
-0.0093920678,
-0.046360597,
0.026929209,
-0.0546779893,
-0.0249017123,
0.0279734023,
0.003204071,
-0.058978878,
-0.0055945572,
-0.0206351131,
0.0537027642,
-0.0170934852,
0.0298592579,
-0.0106316805,
0.0078462642,
-0.0130217914,
0.0289356131,
-0.038695462,
0.0496211462,
0.0291756578,
0.0803906471,
0.0355636813,
-0.0214165375,
0.0140958102,
0.0185663532,
-0.0951856375,
-0.0752126873,
0.0332136974,
0.031687595,
-0.0090431049,
0.0251250695,
0.0174427442,
-0.0353656262,
0.0038959363,
0.0314845406,
0.0991656855,
0.0492980704,
-0.0083467364,
-0.0001829513,
0.000819591,
-0.01328333,
-0.0574984923,
0.0971948728,
-0.0518335402,
0.0160966422,
-0.0333174914,
-0.0175381284,
-0.0231114738,
-0.0332061462,
-0.0116346292,
0.0216252003,
0.0074473587,
-0.0246679746,
-0.0741261765,
-0.0235018488,
0.0061761835,
-0.0097821224,
-0.0403311811,
-0.0663427785,
-0.0105237607,
0.046081651,
0.0012261118,
-0.0488246754,
-0.0267322753,
0.0450555682,
-0.0452996381,
-0.0100438287,
-0.0581408404,
-5.77871076e-33,
-0.0364765972,
-0.0716826469,
0.0184645392,
0.0306518022,
0.002225789,
0.017188428,
-0.0830669478,
0.0504907705,
0.0119073363,
0.04504418,
-0.0334018916,
0.0337386169,
-0.0173084941,
-0.0117273759,
0.0027089654,
0.0237285979,
0.0278933365,
0.0156121161,
-0.0392747559,
0.0292072222,
0.0505990162,
-0.00087247,
-0.0088329269,
-0.1060562357,
0.0782534406,
-0.020311296,
0.0095955655,
0.0054508429,
-0.0362934656,
0.0204627197,
-0.0253325682,
0.0268958509,
0.029888276,
0.009998736,
0.0041163955,
0.0806976929,
0.0018035062,
-0.0428352915,
0.0072082495,
0.015915636,
-0.0536137484,
-0.0475573987,
-0.0253380034,
0.0017664231,
-0.0194891673,
0.0177418198,
0.0481055155,
0.0067357509,
-0.0076908842,
0.0157480482,
-0.0746222511,
0.0048434553,
-0.0459180772,
-0.0563926362,
-0.0114175677,
0.03620217,
-0.001103384,
-0.0218790546,
-0.0117679536,
0.0278907306,
0.0116469758,
-0.0125436317,
0.0260634553,
0.0059447894,
-0.0155733442,
0.0375559926,
0.0285034347,
0.0736804157,
-0.062010508,
-0.0021880427,
-0.0110983355,
0.0249866359,
0.0608939677,
0.0578107126,
-0.0185754262,
0.0063765612,
0.01305346,
0.0440147892,
0.0056406856,
0.0215305053,
-0.0224817023,
0.0240601003,
-0.0457322225,
-0.0158642661,
-0.0195937939,
0.013978513,
-0.0092142094,
-0.032335259,
0.0072004125,
-0.0375648476,
0.0003335112,
-0.0438159816,
-0.0292508397,
-0.0003564779,
-0.0089423973,
0.0188170411,
-0.0404260233,
0.0485704094,
-0.0055358778,
-0.0290998388,
-0.0360847861,
0.002299811,
0.0019426782,
0.056852866,
0.0698301643,
0.0382343605,
0.0291916579,
0.0312690884,
0.0203724429,
-0.0174624696,
-0.0330498032,
-0.0001460079,
0.0362344831,
-0.0173905883,
0.0105599603,
0.0415499099,
-0.0302011911,
0.021199258,
0.0043241582,
0.0380446501,
-0.0329609327,
-0.0537126474,
-0.0286454726,
-0.0374387503,
-0.0226635691,
-0.038362138,
-0.0329945646,
0.0006024897,
0.0113956323,
-0.0768491477,
-0.0045535848,
-0.0092279054,
2.749e-7,
0.0129905352,
0.034234412,
0.025029039,
-0.0077090543,
0.0241575707,
0.0187959913,
-0.0078313304,
-0.0116550056,
-0.0277658869,
-0.0092173433,
0.0195047259,
0.0322607271,
0.0540162027,
0.0168116856,
-0.0313171372,
-0.0609468892,
-0.027023809,
-0.0093249539,
-0.0689782128,
0.0270240698,
0.0830378458,
-0.0589114428,
-0.0089455443,
-0.0245964602,
-0.0195411369,
-0.0024324125,
0.0409303755,
0.0200533029,
0.0550444685,
0.0231348332,
-0.0107978759,
0.0049960371,
0.0270327963,
0.0149002112,
-0.014636917,
-0.028636774,
0.0019019558,
0.0500897691,
-0.0351760089,
-0.0209531039,
0.0416861139,
0.0152140744,
0.0194125287,
-0.0289295595,
0.0391845591,
-0.0171308089,
-0.0294412319,
-0.0325915702,
0.0163563825,
0.0011827974,
-0.020398831,
-0.021049181,
0.0208416115,
0.0440013111,
-0.0436305068,
-0.0167450961,
0.0197746679,
-0.0194171984,
-0.0254372768,
0.0085024443,
-0.0011814968,
0.0058556772,
-0.068623513,
-0.0473278277,
0.0208348241,
-0.0411349721,
0.0116374176,
2.2282625e-34,
0.0019428526,
-0.0143104661,
0.0289712157,
0.0835404173,
0.045524206,
0.0325932093,
0.0365111791,
0.0363544039,
0.0809693635,
-0.0046580341,
-0.0070908261
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.09764v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.09764v1 | Application-Agnostic Language Modeling for On-Device ASR | 2023-05-16T19:31:18 | 2023-05-16T19:31:18 | Markus Nußbaum-Thom, Lyan Verwimp, Youssef Oualil | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | On-device automatic speech recognition systems face several challenges
compared to server-based systems. They have to meet stricter constraints in
terms of speed, disk size and memory while maintaining the same accuracy. Often
they have to serve several applications with different distributions at once,
such as communicating with a virtual assistant and speech-to-text. The simplest
solution to serve multiple applications is to build application-specific
(language) models, but this leads to an increase in memory. Therefore, we
explore different data- and architecture-driven language modeling approaches to
build a single application-agnostic model. We propose two novel feed-forward
architectures that find an optimal trade off between different on-device
constraints. In comparison to the application-specific solution, one of our
novel approaches reduces the disk size by half, while maintaining speed and
accuracy of the original model. | [
0.0148912873,
0.0404525995,
-0.0121492809,
0.0412445031,
-0.0423151739,
-0.0070409914,
0.0757698938,
-0.0230812002,
0.001283214,
-0.0346402824,
-0.0231134482,
-0.0607104115,
0.0370031707,
0.0231056269,
0.0283757746,
-0.0018215915,
0.0338587128,
-0.0704071075,
-0.011880341,
-0.0392089151,
0.0159187932,
0.0276316162,
0.0019371745,
0.0333557241,
-0.0005677285,
0.0047250483,
-0.0085555967,
0.0323390663,
-0.0165448245,
0.0164989941,
-0.0132971769,
-0.0300335493,
0.0313625559,
0.0053595733,
0.0000018639,
0.0041097738,
-0.0268114451,
0.0232474729,
-0.0602895953,
0.0157024786,
0.0968177766,
0.0035790137,
-0.0442191213,
0.0471718609,
0.0009408001,
-0.0592915975,
0.063154608,
-0.0111913318,
0.0185372867,
0.0457312837,
-0.0142294625,
-0.0405964777,
0.0196615253,
-0.0169486012,
-0.0656517446,
-0.023408182,
-0.0137416357,
-0.045637764,
-0.001878379,
0.0004695013,
-0.0178152639,
0.0531344451,
0.0208410341,
0.0469575115,
0.007361955,
-0.0183866825,
-0.0458827466,
-0.023307886,
-0.0415606201,
0.0210904572,
-0.0153518366,
-0.0456819087,
0.0501193963,
0.0098920334,
-0.0715100691,
-0.0079207504,
0.0145668192,
0.0162952952,
-0.0290505514,
-0.0095606679,
0.0217467062,
-0.0248029605,
0.0347726084,
-0.0144479536,
-0.0343482196,
0.0186751839,
0.0278990269,
-0.0043372973,
-0.0163823739,
-0.0177698676,
0.000839129,
-0.0277558118,
0.0786177889,
0.0068597854,
-0.0309518389,
0.0057239989,
-0.0642705113,
-0.0238600075,
-0.0326524451,
-0.0771162882,
0.0597303249,
0.0393245295,
-0.0216196999,
-0.004693829,
0.011853979,
0.0344608575,
-0.003744995,
-0.0551946834,
-0.0112949684,
0.0027603663,
0.0117048845,
-0.0042584892,
-0.0744488314,
0.0441108868,
-0.0518442467,
-0.0803849995,
-0.0302281026,
0.0328446478,
0.0148655502,
-0.0063693724,
0.0521104299,
-0.0028679019,
-0.0267499816,
-0.0158029199,
0.057462953,
0.041881986,
0.0177658349,
0.0310610645,
-0.0194638986,
-0.0997672379,
0.0344457999,
0.0109103508,
0.0261098146,
0.0142949959,
0.0057569728,
0.0603538938,
0.0120157553,
-0.0308428686,
-0.0471927002,
-0.0033447156,
0.0183782186,
-0.030008113,
-0.0074012321,
-0.0533760451,
0.041741658,
0.0037510074,
0.019545462,
-0.030294707,
0.0010952061,
0.029438803,
0.0101175085,
0.0612490326,
-0.0187439695,
0.0013650917,
0.0660543889,
-0.0133340368,
0.0355814062,
0.0741892159,
0.0647637546,
-0.0065883603,
0.0151764425,
-0.0399704389,
-0.0521396734,
0.0552062877,
-0.0078592384,
-0.0313245617,
-0.0441409126,
0.0083860457,
-0.0164519809,
0.0017261342,
-0.0053084739,
0.0596733317,
0.0049577891,
0.002534898,
0.0440808907,
0.0693023205,
0.0403109081,
0.03599957,
0.0070532542,
0.0162874702,
-0.0266203079,
-0.0453724936,
-0.0197585858,
0.0017313021,
0.0211383831,
0.0448692925,
0.0465485416,
0.0711787269,
-0.0129911425,
-0.0173592046,
-0.0248407312,
-0.035450533,
-0.0490281805,
0.062522471,
0.0455697812,
-0.0027417256,
-0.0146517446,
0.0417936109,
-0.0096350927,
-0.050732404,
-0.0060829809,
-0.0402357057,
-0.0361701883,
0.0503018908,
0.052025117,
-0.0213838648,
-0.0183397084,
0.0218939036,
-0.0100074923,
0.0435213223,
0.0176281054,
0.0013237818,
0.0371949375,
-0.0490909852,
0.0151492283,
0.0516548865,
0.0041991146,
0.0630278215,
-0.0250332635,
0.0399016403,
0.0139298989,
-0.0002888028,
0.0146075087,
-0.0259853248,
-0.0212564506,
-0.0030558435,
0.041732531,
0.0197276101,
0.0488312691,
0.002663288,
-0.0343630351,
-0.0024463972,
0.0176771227,
-0.0419915244,
0.0507397391,
0.0043877335,
-0.0598015748,
0.0096071763,
0.0315929353,
0.0261171553,
0.0618083477,
0.0304067135,
0.013912797,
-0.0775246993,
0.0535014421,
-0.0762324184,
0.095385842,
-0.0199879352,
0.0711813197,
0.0245129149,
0.0206090435,
0.0427721217,
-0.0049356194,
0.0127316853,
0.0150414323,
0.0205402318,
-0.0069076638,
0.0008503229,
-0.0307664778,
-0.0307455566,
0.0024346176,
-0.0064730118,
0.037298508,
0.007417853,
-0.0476944558,
0.0265773796,
-0.0013315493,
-0.0814368427,
0.0112356311,
-0.0242092945,
0.0294478182,
0.0048373588,
0.0751865953,
0.0377133898,
-0.0328923203,
-0.0279000048,
0.0125312861,
-0.0161586031,
0.0310591199,
-0.0697189048,
-0.0328502655,
-0.0652594045,
-0.0072625801,
-0.0195616484,
0.0240710974,
0.0164504386,
-0.0455602631,
-0.0108132083,
-0.0754424408,
-0.0223539453,
-0.0074926815,
0.0715045333,
-0.0219410881,
-0.0193590168,
0.0019479138,
-0.0041046827,
0.029007962,
0.054952316,
-0.0334411711,
-0.0320458636,
0.0302680731,
-0.0082066376,
-0.0443556048,
0.0009661703,
0.0377468616,
0.0350111276,
-0.004513036,
-0.0132052964,
-0.0343127064,
0.0610738508,
0.0024250362,
0.0185920671,
-0.0162020717,
-0.0134781906,
-0.0260384176,
-0.0246082079,
-0.013366905,
-0.0063783722,
-0.0403581299,
0.0104015451,
-0.0143830646,
-0.0581037104,
0.0322658084,
-0.0750100091,
-0.0263351798,
-0.0462522358,
-0.0237812921,
-0.0248344876,
0.0346406251,
0.0185318831,
0.0002198753,
-0.0126670366,
-0.0228153598,
0.0115889562,
0.0610190742,
-0.0055695409,
-0.0735185295,
0.0775996968,
-0.0434621684,
0.0231266245,
-0.0089209434,
-0.0230177473,
0.0266622994,
0.0246385112,
-0.0586768873,
0.0156451743,
0.0044821552,
-0.0294824503,
-0.0344316997,
0.0979874879,
0.0061612506,
0.098871924,
0.0302251521,
0.0012842325,
-0.0398393422,
0.0056241425,
0.0492849462,
-0.0052685975,
-0.0365064181,
0.0112836296,
0.0277053844,
-0.0253378749,
0.0840062499,
-0.0163351111,
-0.0487052649,
0.001772126,
0.0839853734,
0.0092564253,
-0.0432105921,
0.0660644099,
0.0308703389,
-0.0368354954,
-0.0241420642,
0.0827744156,
-0.002662784,
-0.0218964759,
-0.0064005866,
0.0123170791,
0.0454297587,
0.0118193282,
0.0139650367,
-0.0501203239,
-0.0339354053,
0.0493688695,
0.0257868469,
0.0437254645,
0.0586096086,
-0.0476674885,
-0.0704175159,
-0.0036230967,
0.0290988702,
-0.013950279,
-0.0248212013,
-0.0251909848,
-0.0209799409,
-0.0275663715,
0.0300807972,
-0.0015609419,
-0.0095812045,
-0.0284352209,
0.0118111623,
-0.0766822994,
-0.0476347394,
0.0093406867,
-0.0099935699,
0.0943356156,
0.0726576373,
0.0049884217,
0.0312522836,
-0.0116781555,
-0.0007495121,
-0.0127350148,
0.0351782702,
-0.0254528336,
-0.0125396671,
0.0196241792,
-0.0200012103,
0.007095289,
-0.0069115353,
-0.0381143019,
0.017531598,
0.0084293559,
0.0434586555,
-0.0247206893,
0.0069746692,
-0.0159816388,
-0.0251133442,
0.0011831083,
0.0220274962,
-0.0230906233,
-0.0254584402,
-0.0494534448,
0.0007317034,
0.0110170823,
-0.0219790805,
0.0051129982,
-0.0098806424,
-0.0172264948,
-0.074941121,
0.0037828586,
0.0305821169,
-0.0167610701,
0.0332301632,
0.0306819994,
0.0303267371,
0.0514818616,
0.038972389,
-0.0488408878,
-0.0307740886,
-0.0325732343,
0.0339065343,
-0.0455614738,
-0.0261769947,
0.0356854387,
-0.0420461074,
-0.011689947,
0.0286202822,
-0.0564590655,
-0.07227391,
0.0324840173,
0.0154245934,
0.0271272697,
0.0568561777,
-0.0268128254,
-0.0594909228,
0.0222142301,
0.0137410201,
-0.0551387817,
0.061754331,
0.0319411792,
-0.018352598,
0.007652876,
0.0299168676,
-0.0496069752,
0.0475079827,
-0.0132860905,
0.0269094035,
-0.0108890226,
-0.0543986447,
-0.008459406,
0.0324402042,
0.0218250174,
-0.0145709962,
-0.0208072197,
0.0003611234,
0.0789010227,
-0.001322186,
0.0502145179,
-0.0520288013,
-0.0034552498,
-0.0283807833,
0.0296438001,
-0.0177089237,
-0.013228084,
0.0088272421,
-0.0416563265,
-0.0038672108,
0.0548314787,
0.028083317,
0.0074295071,
0.0473122112,
-0.0061173243,
-0.0240495894,
0.0245449059,
0.0301433746,
0.0234776847,
-0.0634892881,
0.0355294459,
-0.0218474623,
0.0013702967,
-0.017903598,
0.0346732549,
-0.014442374,
-0.0140890768,
-0.0152782425,
0.0591820292,
0.0100298338,
-0.016791977,
0.0358479023,
-0.0044019166,
0.0373873413,
-0.0634900779,
0.0434664972,
0.00999026,
-0.0239658393,
0.0219238997,
0.0084896348,
-0.0115160411,
-0.0029270113,
0.026855832,
0.0003735852,
0.003438375,
-0.0418221429,
0.0167078916,
-0.0388104357,
-0.0386949219,
-0.0234472249,
0.0137554202,
-0.0521933995,
-0.024829749,
-0.0278354455,
-0.0939771459,
0.0025396103,
-0.004490545,
0.0400978327,
-0.0670005307,
0.0006176367,
0.0298488829,
0.0177952442,
-0.0091523118,
-0.000063799,
-0.0225945935,
-0.0764592513,
-0.0067360676,
0.0104350662,
-5.849698863e-33,
-0.0244421512,
0.0605550073,
0.0078246994,
-0.0248738006,
-0.0021033408,
0.0523131266,
-0.0166449547,
-0.0266364478,
-0.0187338572,
-0.0608736537,
-0.0416895151,
0.009452072,
0.0400142036,
0.0268334784,
-0.0242237933,
0.0366496965,
0.0664205328,
-0.0332013294,
-0.0086085349,
0.0255108178,
0.0145973302,
0.0279915817,
0.0036528462,
-0.005144692,
-0.0410217941,
-0.0061989543,
0.0373174548,
-0.0503255911,
0.0240084007,
0.0252400208,
-0.0093028164,
0.0460642204,
0.0128385769,
-0.0508804545,
-0.0084066074,
0.0471118204,
-0.0716106147,
-0.0128147835,
0.0427761711,
0.0523069501,
0.0179877635,
0.0016690362,
0.0312528536,
0.0167999789,
-0.0545519292,
0.0104904305,
0.0108701,
-0.007980966,
-0.0693372861,
-0.0321944878,
-0.0065437867,
0.0186730605,
0.0413243212,
0.0005922486,
0.0755048469,
0.0112904031,
-0.0425922573,
-0.0338539444,
-0.0455020815,
0.029286962,
-0.0001392441,
0.0767580867,
0.0716231093,
0.0420191884,
0.0136832874,
0.0191103667,
0.0597723797,
-0.0733998045,
-0.0208880734,
-0.0147337858,
0.0155402971,
0.0059594689,
-0.0137403673,
-0.0076968446,
0.0351898186,
-0.0500364043,
-0.0176866297,
-0.0609853826,
0.0600429326,
-0.011674488,
0.0256659202,
0.0197660308,
-0.0382426009,
-0.0124646146,
-0.0425167568,
0.0248141978,
-0.0605328456,
-0.0159999412,
0.0691333562,
0.0254536252,
-0.021483127,
0.0076759304,
0.0376388878,
-0.036116004,
0.0116701359,
-0.0002120835,
0.0560241379,
0.0007719385,
0.0122783799,
0.0322723053,
-0.0606321245,
-0.0224539693,
-0.0094648926,
0.0155932074,
0.0174510628,
-0.0210125893,
-0.0410106778,
0.0687000751,
-0.0826890245,
-0.0108701801,
-0.0243294686,
0.0206614453,
-0.0084728068,
0.0435195826,
0.0642977878,
-0.0221497975,
-0.0047716135,
0.0542436391,
-0.043318931,
-0.0334744267,
-0.0304275863,
0.0051100077,
0.0158948246,
0.0312106572,
-0.0579653494,
0.0089648226,
-0.0320989564,
-0.0077264933,
0.0195270758,
-0.0189589784,
-0.0272786748,
0.0156331286,
2.681e-7,
-0.0558642708,
0.0065177828,
0.0096735191,
-0.0122045111,
0.0170805864,
-0.0037912065,
0.0327756107,
0.0126398103,
-0.0101039251,
0.0254320893,
-0.0249242485,
-0.0023119715,
0.0790071785,
-0.0075846398,
-0.0728188083,
0.0284215081,
-0.0665001944,
0.0693631694,
0.0074063139,
0.0058627082,
-0.0207786672,
0.1014777422,
-0.0309386067,
-0.0413696878,
-0.0009458293,
-0.0079753408,
-0.0161622465,
-0.0057940469,
0.0308202151,
-0.0068231439,
-0.0164688043,
0.0065426882,
-0.0740975738,
0.0202202853,
-0.0229768548,
0.0120833768,
-0.0251774397,
0.064233914,
-0.0417369641,
-0.027865909,
0.0185638405,
-0.0065603852,
-0.0646199137,
-0.0165826026,
0.0499689169,
0.0195748433,
-0.0163939875,
-0.0383128375,
-0.0204572827,
0.0114591056,
-0.0497434773,
0.0108537525,
0.0317628123,
0.0023544028,
0.0103295054,
-0.0371310487,
0.0005197789,
-0.0599891543,
0.0061952439,
0.0183563773,
-0.0163455103,
-0.0099058766,
-0.0856587961,
-0.0000935713,
0.0196239501,
-0.0321703926,
-0.0163668115,
2.150524441e-34,
0.0228176732,
-0.0451747775,
0.0071559022,
0.0221704245,
-0.0085858442,
-0.0351052657,
0.0451490395,
0.0650678352,
-0.0112848459,
-0.0653262958,
-0.0721006989
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.09758v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.09758v3 | A Video Is Worth 4096 Tokens: Verbalize Videos To Understand Them In Zero Shot | 2023-05-16T19:13:11 | 2023-10-26T10:08:31 | Aanisha Bhattacharya, Yaman K Singla, Balaji Krishnamurthy, Rajiv Ratn Shah, Changyou Chen | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Multimedia content, such as advertisements and story videos, exhibit a rich
blend of creativity and multiple modalities. They incorporate elements like
text, visuals, audio, and storytelling techniques, employing devices like
emotions, symbolism, and slogans to convey meaning. There is a dearth of large
annotated training datasets in the multimedia domain hindering the development
of supervised learning models with satisfactory performance for real-world
applications. On the other hand, the rise of large language models (LLMs) has
witnessed remarkable zero-shot performance in various natural language
processing (NLP) tasks, such as emotion classification, question-answering, and
topic classification. To leverage such advanced techniques to bridge this
performance gap in multimedia understanding, we propose verbalizing long videos
to generate their descriptions in natural language, followed by performing
video-understanding tasks on the generated story as opposed to the original
video. Through extensive experiments on fifteen video-understanding tasks, we
demonstrate that our method, despite being zero-shot, achieves significantly
better results than supervised baselines for video understanding. Furthermore,
to alleviate a lack of story understanding benchmarks, we publicly release the
first dataset on a crucial task in computational social science on persuasion
strategy identification. | [
0.0469565205,
0.0718492419,
0.0042429594,
0.0474006645,
-0.0133171808,
0.0106590847,
0.0061911838,
0.0075259302,
-0.0374584757,
-0.1075628996,
-0.0264836233,
-0.0697369426,
-0.0110006789,
0.0412043482,
0.0173866302,
-0.0671465322,
0.0153519893,
0.0156836621,
0.0753411949,
0.0403351896,
0.0425956175,
0.0506418124,
0.0084145255,
0.0446676463,
-0.0387581065,
-0.0290827863,
0.007841263,
0.0058860225,
0.0566556565,
-0.039125286,
-0.0226282794,
0.0453912467,
0.1015300453,
0.0087869363,
0.0000016015,
-0.0479871258,
0.0229607653,
-0.037666034,
-0.0298810489,
0.0316067599,
0.078637749,
-0.0368604474,
0.0150281386,
0.0184456985,
-0.0294162072,
0.0172944237,
0.0383724235,
0.0636640787,
0.0419171415,
0.074182786,
-0.0333873592,
-0.0553067811,
-0.0152681908,
-0.0328700021,
0.0318999775,
-0.0499585234,
0.0007223757,
-0.0405932963,
0.0158441514,
0.0009455471,
-0.0392799042,
0.0212817006,
-0.0098771024,
-0.0211670995,
-0.0145206787,
0.0363830067,
-0.0511274338,
-0.0177992787,
-0.0128916437,
0.0787712708,
-0.0063068429,
0.0170179922,
0.0118279671,
0.0015329685,
0.0083084283,
-0.0277837906,
-0.0504335165,
0.0549533889,
0.0272105411,
0.0296709724,
-0.0192044619,
0.0047768522,
0.0280056149,
-0.0134240724,
0.0337141491,
0.0088399472,
-0.0058144624,
0.0028258518,
0.017620327,
-0.0138501739,
-0.0156125557,
-0.0684633628,
-0.0305791926,
0.0017957971,
0.018482374,
0.0149902198,
-0.0206168015,
0.0334672406,
-0.0209589694,
-0.1033468843,
0.0367662981,
0.0181318894,
-0.0061491337,
0.0617441311,
-0.0052234833,
0.0280046351,
-0.0059418846,
-0.0066836826,
0.0032385921,
0.0177726932,
-0.0944968238,
0.0155392382,
-0.0027871379,
0.0289571732,
-0.0316365808,
-0.0437926985,
-0.0364969037,
0.0019878058,
-0.0450970866,
0.0251201726,
-0.0600552149,
0.0364130959,
0.0258866865,
-0.0261958297,
-0.0308297444,
0.0574716479,
-0.0419276841,
0.0421612337,
-0.0273921061,
-0.0390687846,
-0.0005595592,
0.0197065081,
0.0048360764,
-0.0167582296,
0.0414276123,
0.0238676965,
-0.0372016057,
-0.042688407,
-0.0408912376,
0.0068309968,
-0.0314424261,
-0.0529002063,
0.0033624698,
-0.0408186316,
0.0407526642,
0.0109525044,
-0.0030673444,
-0.0413893461,
0.0163324997,
-0.0086776959,
-0.0641368404,
0.0750589743,
0.0562848523,
0.0007454269,
-0.0007607142,
0.0295831691,
0.01829849,
0.0700260475,
0.020385664,
0.0784711316,
0.0600667,
0.0085329823,
0.0350161865,
0.0325907022,
-0.0085061546,
0.0161923356,
-0.0481625386,
0.0011190355,
-0.0095717832,
0.0424641594,
0.0149842855,
0.0365839191,
-0.0332159214,
-0.036204312,
0.0911754966,
0.0391259044,
-0.0324499495,
-0.0303141363,
0.0286610574,
0.0535080433,
0.0079527963,
-0.0154138254,
-0.0168480966,
0.0368614197,
0.0012565459,
-0.0178864561,
0.0341073163,
0.0007940286,
-0.0769564435,
-0.0062509752,
-0.0244631711,
-0.0196006596,
0.0014815845,
0.0142241102,
0.0250551086,
-0.0101522543,
-0.064609006,
-0.0036485216,
0.0230064485,
-0.0034161876,
0.0406994894,
-0.010875769,
0.0318189859,
0.0605904423,
0.0050512939,
-0.0148530602,
0.0015878767,
-0.0521258153,
0.0444222763,
0.0241811275,
0.0304841157,
-0.0529207624,
0.015824113,
-0.0500799976,
-0.0215653908,
-0.0539822318,
0.0156228924,
0.0505458042,
-0.0271707531,
0.0264029671,
-0.0041164672,
-0.0126390532,
0.0116744265,
-0.001314152,
0.0571992286,
-0.0470611788,
0.0153473914,
0.0249543302,
0.0475382134,
0.0265713744,
-0.0450708307,
-0.0414454564,
0.0121284081,
-0.0295456927,
-0.0153529868,
0.003650839,
-0.0179008916,
-0.0349085517,
0.0321362056,
-0.0567582026,
-0.0338861793,
0.0265700929,
-0.0308338646,
-0.0112402067,
0.0506744906,
-0.0151564367,
0.0125577739,
-0.0377131477,
-0.0091185533,
0.0050269566,
0.0238597672,
0.0144268749,
0.0321332812,
0.0401352681,
-0.0483742207,
-0.0253404099,
-0.0155094629,
0.0247721951,
-0.0247164071,
-0.0371837541,
-0.0099056447,
0.0080854427,
-0.0067164367,
0.0200934187,
-0.0353547558,
-0.038485501,
-0.0311543029,
-0.1126247123,
0.0103607513,
-0.0130971791,
0.0240419917,
-0.0180258453,
-0.0132388072,
-0.0024274543,
0.004709268,
-0.0359045826,
-0.0108349873,
-0.0244029704,
0.0087817656,
0.0157715492,
0.0329807587,
-0.015422591,
-0.0101913475,
0.0017780614,
-0.000701854,
0.0619166605,
0.0173993837,
-0.0260932632,
-0.0093687447,
-0.01031218,
-0.0132539561,
0.0205407944,
-0.0243179984,
-0.0220426694,
0.0034662348,
0.0200117752,
0.0141451471,
0.0572985038,
0.033349555,
0.0500638559,
0.014848657,
0.0227854662,
-0.039451465,
-0.0081836628,
-0.0116709583,
0.0030085663,
-0.0699526891,
-0.0171569567,
-0.0327348374,
0.0319403633,
-0.005389811,
0.0341841094,
-0.0537777394,
0.0109337037,
0.0341678336,
-0.017116785,
-0.0594914667,
0.0063644308,
-0.0056259376,
0.029570451,
-0.0085184919,
-0.0289002005,
0.044993449,
-0.0258365683,
-0.0268503353,
0.0144300349,
-0.0214922037,
-0.0337219574,
0.081010662,
-0.0197959058,
0.0268018637,
-0.0011042021,
-0.0348796621,
-0.0386080891,
-0.0609184466,
0.003384535,
-0.0120657012,
0.0226136316,
-0.0275200754,
0.0054368232,
0.002950323,
-0.0369620621,
-0.0545796119,
-0.0765706003,
-0.0492999926,
-0.0320854858,
-0.0131503474,
-0.0148322834,
-0.0603384636,
-0.012855771,
0.0368362963,
-0.0120463762,
-0.0100496225,
0.0165321082,
0.0260508079,
0.0430605114,
0.0750998706,
-0.0260080155,
-0.0326167643,
-0.0450055599,
0.0343857519,
0.0509797297,
0.0101496326,
-0.0107692368,
-0.0485678576,
0.0101545779,
0.0008858143,
-0.0100571187,
0.0079139322,
0.0080878828,
0.0266984701,
-0.0311388355,
0.0315127485,
0.1270811558,
0.0026968892,
-0.0384734422,
0.0005638095,
0.0173580907,
-0.0095577249,
0.0432667136,
0.0225402527,
-0.0992944986,
-0.0546352118,
-0.0179228447,
-0.0024089231,
-0.0043087061,
0.011078978,
-0.0281951055,
-0.1220877469,
0.0565895997,
0.0071826489,
0.025768023,
0.0042199027,
-0.0306986235,
-0.022735022,
-0.0397807062,
-0.0208207183,
-0.0413984135,
-0.0275589935,
0.0019776421,
-0.0049597872,
-0.0044648442,
-0.069168441,
0.0626055375,
-0.0261888225,
0.0559246838,
0.0066224402,
0.0486367457,
-0.0224134941,
-0.0280264206,
0.021232307,
0.0262219273,
0.0074906838,
-0.0157612842,
0.0932023525,
-0.0747366622,
-0.0048383852,
0.0383702889,
0.032572832,
0.0120670926,
-0.0336243957,
0.0124193514,
0.0566626191,
0.005373315,
-0.0295357853,
-0.0088379839,
0.015213497,
0.0284121707,
0.1063643172,
0.0096850572,
-0.0459446646,
-0.0263429414,
0.0089558456,
-0.0436720736,
-0.030906966,
-0.0405620672,
-0.0353468396,
0.009734394,
0.0170569383,
-0.0100165503,
-0.0250876099,
0.0600516312,
0.030995978,
0.0032334172,
0.0001295727,
-0.01375861,
0.0342734531,
-0.0583729073,
0.0532717407,
-0.0177175868,
0.0057416623,
-0.056257993,
-0.0192801617,
0.0145049794,
-0.0527462922,
-0.0327593051,
-0.0086792493,
-0.0470126197,
-0.0540771484,
-0.0616909824,
0.0271283332,
0.0191789772,
0.0848809928,
0.0590237528,
-0.0280825645,
0.049832195,
0.0443897694,
-0.0057116146,
-0.0029034719,
0.0144193526,
0.0025164157,
-0.0067074285,
0.025808258,
-0.0071583167,
0.0510821566,
0.0400384143,
0.0046421275,
-0.0287779737,
0.0242418107,
-0.0177304652,
-0.0232555345,
0.0465065241,
-0.0311231017,
-0.0249917619,
-0.0592224002,
-0.0241718479,
-0.0017457971,
0.0121653294,
-0.0659226626,
-0.0013247224,
0.0559546575,
-0.0080711413,
-0.0426861569,
-0.0090155909,
-0.0645905286,
-0.0039170692,
-0.0153312404,
-0.0010861167,
0.0148677118,
-0.0248279925,
0.004024324,
0.0078669386,
0.0229887273,
0.0343334153,
0.0189949833,
0.0334140062,
0.0246915892,
0.0360555127,
0.0135356374,
0.0037200311,
-0.0040375385,
0.0158444233,
0.001092919,
-0.0149030033,
-0.0013495327,
0.0468852259,
0.0442485735,
-0.0526854135,
-0.0108953584,
-0.0206346381,
0.0054599391,
-0.0244132485,
0.0287534725,
-0.0614972524,
-0.0777356252,
0.0202272777,
0.0153413266,
-0.0386934839,
0.0402326845,
0.0701667592,
-0.0092538195,
0.019913787,
0.013970823,
-0.0029589091,
-0.032954786,
-0.0087099681,
0.0730542615,
0.0259233825,
0.0009889837,
0.0390710048,
-0.0664741248,
-0.0479074307,
0.0084265871,
-0.0486092232,
0.0105652902,
0.0137847234,
0.040180251,
0.0233333968,
-0.0089442907,
0.0310285818,
-0.0324126482,
-0.0334963314,
-0.0206813961,
-0.028827602,
-0.0070149307,
-5.541835424e-33,
0.0293420609,
0.0038831674,
-0.0147727439,
0.0259669814,
0.0035265824,
0.0233622491,
-0.0083113192,
0.0161850695,
0.0094363941,
0.0514296256,
0.0036617147,
0.0074678846,
0.0048808139,
0.0311260596,
0.0091175586,
-0.0358621255,
0.0587491058,
-0.0255605411,
-0.04459415,
0.0150452191,
0.0624577738,
0.0265651997,
0.0384594873,
-0.0827916339,
-0.0160299912,
-0.0131314173,
-0.020113254,
0.0047862711,
0.0720453709,
0.0520334318,
-0.0062449346,
0.0030128791,
0.0169113893,
-0.0573732331,
0.0217180494,
0.0448501706,
-0.0341803133,
0.0182083547,
0.0338124372,
-0.0156543273,
-0.0381145962,
-0.0141962916,
-0.0049923812,
0.0022902584,
-0.036032524,
-0.0430808887,
0.0433867685,
-0.0133475093,
0.0383776054,
-0.0070121321,
-0.058051724,
-0.0130930329,
-0.0423743129,
-0.0474363752,
0.0396667384,
0.01760263,
0.0160516277,
0.0430401675,
-0.0464528985,
0.015387021,
-0.0551949032,
0.0169205852,
0.0645437315,
-0.0157104451,
-0.0303524528,
0.1001578569,
0.0300274324,
-0.0392983034,
-0.0487481579,
0.0189938713,
-0.0142954206,
0.0404062085,
0.0199797638,
0.0335581973,
0.0488740392,
-0.020823352,
-0.0603296608,
0.0151969036,
0.0161697492,
0.015357703,
0.0218784325,
0.0019058007,
0.0073335646,
0.012732612,
-0.0366370045,
-0.0429993831,
-0.032886751,
-0.0207780711,
0.0246464964,
0.002280219,
0.0141445734,
0.0329765156,
0.0679525435,
-0.0512752794,
-0.0032201442,
0.0581570268,
-0.0107884705,
0.059176106,
0.0222066473,
0.0027565307,
-0.0587654412,
-0.0042292015,
0.0274422262,
0.0264126174,
0.0158016644,
-0.0070255292,
0.0396763459,
0.0279932786,
-0.0356040671,
-0.0017088726,
-0.0061693233,
0.0071248175,
-0.0322997719,
0.0384580977,
0.0108696464,
0.0360029116,
-0.0249286853,
0.0239939541,
-0.0332897194,
-0.0033572519,
0.0369324274,
-0.0440002978,
-0.0263306927,
0.0283915922,
-0.0369250476,
0.0185082573,
-0.0095120957,
-0.0238865558,
0.0185427815,
-0.0588626973,
0.0150907226,
0.0038628608,
2.466e-7,
-0.0340624675,
0.0428094044,
-0.0152731361,
0.0010487803,
0.0274976771,
0.0772232488,
-0.0157560818,
0.0570147745,
0.0197600052,
-0.0631791726,
0.0220851041,
0.0577246919,
0.0366951674,
-0.0228820853,
-0.0898821354,
0.0245317426,
-0.0444040895,
0.0025307911,
-0.062131241,
0.0173805933,
0.0510464869,
0.1292416304,
0.0546787195,
-0.0079707382,
0.0114617934,
-0.0324479491,
0.075519003,
-0.0167253297,
-0.0351364203,
0.0175525695,
-0.0215071682,
-0.02734733,
-0.0250105709,
-0.0141036455,
-0.0252630338,
0.0011987238,
0.0022490118,
0.0772142261,
-0.0013068721,
-0.0325088874,
-0.0397868454,
0.0251358636,
-0.0355088376,
0.0164163783,
0.0689209253,
-0.0523786768,
-0.052683752,
-0.0447726101,
-0.004210019,
-0.0091734957,
0.008749024,
0.0241981689,
0.0273932349,
0.005914086,
0.0128611811,
-0.0454389714,
-0.0286337957,
-0.1021486521,
0.0343376286,
0.0011168068,
-0.0293983333,
0.0123081021,
0.0063806181,
0.0371216163,
0.0563497432,
-0.0423123874,
-0.0434615389,
1.715368945e-34,
0.0382785723,
-0.0210329592,
-0.0150780873,
-0.0195778329,
0.007553271,
0.032937482,
-0.0456763804,
-0.0228036363,
0.030360451,
-0.0359434262,
-0.0016408416
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.09756v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.09756v1 | Clinical Note Owns its Hierarchy: Multi-Level Hypergraph Neural Networks for Patient-Level Representation Learning | 2023-05-16T19:08:18 | 2023-05-16T19:08:18 | Nayeon Kim, Yinhua Piao, Sun Kim | cs.CL | cs.CL | Leveraging knowledge from electronic health records (EHRs) to predict a
patient's condition is essential to the effective delivery of appropriate care.
Clinical notes of patient EHRs contain valuable information from healthcare
professionals, but have been underused due to their difficult contents and
complex hierarchies. Recently, hypergraph-based methods have been proposed for
document classifications. Directly adopting existing hypergraph methods on
clinical notes cannot sufficiently utilize the hierarchy information of the
patient, which can degrade clinical semantic information by (1) frequent
neutral words and (2) hierarchies with imbalanced distribution. Thus, we
propose a taxonomy-aware multi-level hypergraph neural network (TM-HGNN), where
multi-level hypergraphs assemble useful neutral words with rare keywords via
note and taxonomy level hyperedges to retain the clinical semantic information.
The constructed patient hypergraphs are fed into hierarchical message passing
layers for learning more balanced multi-level knowledge at the note and
taxonomy levels. We validate the effectiveness of TM-HGNN by conducting
extensive experiments with MIMIC-III dataset on benchmark in-hospital-mortality
prediction. | [
0.0352547243,
0.039069064,
0.0168329161,
-0.0237286314,
-0.0164687596,
0.0330055431,
-0.027733624,
0.0367160626,
0.0262937918,
-0.023224039,
-0.0047671059,
-0.0527045354,
-0.0075546275,
0.0239788592,
-0.0160272494,
-0.0585362874,
0.0332707241,
0.0504094101,
0.0501278825,
0.0009453903,
-0.0179322381,
0.035891708,
-0.0171925295,
0.0371598676,
-0.041686397,
-0.0036466112,
0.0112135671,
0.0546243638,
0.0223553907,
-0.0710353479,
0.0232986733,
0.0065736007,
-0.0154968221,
0.0075705349,
0.0000018856,
-0.0278978869,
-0.0122681363,
0.0031736542,
-0.0395325944,
-0.0651573241,
0.0571905859,
-0.1068522036,
0.0039593102,
-0.0169740934,
-0.0103109768,
-0.0666965097,
0.0040960945,
0.0644726679,
0.0166279431,
0.0562367998,
-0.019154802,
0.0038894084,
0.0658091754,
-0.02966474,
0.0241283197,
-0.0517355315,
0.0365895294,
0.0157273151,
-0.0212459825,
-0.0315002613,
-0.0069250828,
0.0153971631,
0.0019053177,
0.0194246061,
0.0346902311,
0.0468476713,
-0.0080637187,
0.0092533557,
0.0041533108,
0.0904681757,
-0.0659257248,
0.0348819159,
0.0137657197,
-0.0258021988,
0.0076814978,
0.0113139832,
-0.0029653434,
0.001963991,
-0.0413901806,
0.0123468796,
0.0315212123,
0.0110932663,
0.026868226,
-0.0009033163,
0.0327623934,
-0.0044498374,
-0.000048525,
-0.0229537617,
0.0327277593,
-0.0237802602,
0.0020680199,
-0.0135758305,
0.0392066687,
0.0204102974,
-0.0142962113,
0.0275794063,
0.0220709089,
-0.0092581622,
0.0775467977,
-0.0733211786,
0.0077647455,
-0.0108996462,
0.032356713,
0.0196975674,
0.0382640585,
-0.074799031,
-0.0194754824,
0.027296219,
-0.0219815988,
-0.0131400786,
-0.0331566855,
-0.008853144,
-0.0358112082,
0.0466075316,
0.0451268554,
-0.0168320127,
-0.0805056766,
-0.025579391,
-0.0339373164,
0.009918482,
0.0259999353,
0.0516294017,
-0.0134929614,
-0.0220908374,
0.0002384023,
0.0284662358,
0.0159055069,
0.0178096034,
-0.0201761536,
0.0446359366,
0.0424780026,
0.0514253117,
0.0058547566,
0.0150091192,
0.0220239665,
0.0299373195,
0.0492065176,
-0.0212341025,
-0.0148520926,
-0.0518591218,
-0.0119412336,
0.0187849533,
0.0448204987,
-0.0575664043,
0.0009008489,
-0.0321648978,
-0.0166580956,
-0.0174300894,
0.0069503156,
-0.0075068041,
-0.0701422244,
0.012909851,
-0.077220507,
-0.0437951498,
0.025251871,
0.0263880938,
-0.0372622199,
-0.0018980298,
0.0307354629,
-0.0053856741,
0.0098946942,
-0.0029645346,
0.0233369898,
-0.0162136704,
0.0159536023,
-0.049289275,
0.0028369534,
-0.0372645073,
-0.0193636827,
0.0662562922,
-0.0134863704,
0.038700629,
0.0043552304,
-0.0573072396,
0.0040297131,
0.0247169212,
0.0230882708,
0.0222673323,
0.0068239113,
-0.0167166721,
-0.0537726544,
-0.0006885301,
0.007478653,
-0.0018816697,
0.0264181457,
0.0220520366,
-0.0320651419,
-0.0350214913,
-0.0294716135,
-0.034106236,
-0.0216358043,
-0.0325965397,
0.0007333683,
-0.0337203033,
0.0607262664,
0.0008853125,
-0.0208712425,
0.0740414262,
0.0615940094,
-0.0068454333,
-0.0053459438,
-0.0239118133,
-0.0371994376,
0.0744034648,
0.0219570994,
-0.0589653775,
-0.0422485881,
-0.005465664,
-0.0277048741,
-0.0159494635,
0.0120603116,
-0.0206445623,
0.0105687585,
-0.052131325,
-0.0016263037,
0.02208554,
0.0313251615,
-0.009314456,
-0.0751958415,
0.0136282593,
0.0051819542,
-0.0253443401,
-0.0345589444,
0.0048991605,
0.0043706419,
0.0155089851,
0.0092181051,
0.0160269123,
-0.0194928367,
0.0435309187,
-0.009506789,
0.0148527632,
0.0242277384,
-0.0215546209,
-0.0775498524,
-0.0821328461,
-0.063492775,
-0.0540421344,
0.0119426604,
-0.0423836634,
0.0014205737,
0.0190296751,
-0.03710467,
-0.0064137378,
-0.0207511541,
-0.0203137603,
0.0616885684,
-0.0127406511,
0.0007798884,
0.0596873686,
-0.0175001081,
-0.008006949,
0.0391892418,
-0.037815854,
0.0145489359,
-0.0324943587,
-0.0536960624,
0.0061167134,
0.0086711869,
0.0088882707,
0.0462730713,
0.0014352258,
0.0280120019,
-0.0040531782,
0.0050627855,
-0.026467314,
-0.0002942357,
-0.0869124606,
-0.0077886786,
0.002231369,
0.0096133417,
-0.0108112358,
0.0158416163,
0.0158671439,
-0.0383143723,
-0.0678828284,
0.0561636202,
0.0126074301,
-0.0161787737,
0.0369198695,
0.0172738302,
0.002400575,
0.0156903453,
-0.063785322,
-0.0528058186,
0.0399379916,
-0.0020757832,
-0.0097139534,
0.0475876108,
-0.0353469588,
-0.0515688024,
-0.0243582204,
0.0149907256,
0.0218432825,
-0.0119545273,
-0.0229407437,
-0.0563809946,
0.0288713891,
0.0028838122,
0.0209561829,
0.0155282766,
0.046302408,
-0.0033189389,
-0.0000127418,
-0.0584597886,
0.0039994875,
0.0017748581,
-0.0142373657,
-0.0256817658,
0.0638872087,
0.0472442731,
-0.0250175744,
-0.0235188231,
-0.0325277746,
-0.0068005919,
0.0562645346,
-0.0331317149,
0.0021830564,
-0.0273134317,
-0.0166588835,
-0.0058830073,
-0.0478620604,
0.0426535159,
0.0283938684,
0.0582961962,
-0.0450921692,
-0.0219663847,
-0.0388676934,
0.0035758668,
-0.0141940787,
0.0343148559,
0.0178793985,
-0.0415871963,
0.0071860906,
0.0120608583,
-0.0024800694,
-0.0281400196,
0.0165444128,
0.0105360057,
-0.0071959994,
0.005454157,
-0.0142303966,
-0.0128385592,
-0.0394019634,
-0.0011343887,
0.0517346561,
-0.031566631,
0.0281492602,
-0.0531435125,
-0.0135481376,
-0.0578080043,
0.0863385499,
0.0287460573,
-0.0308871605,
0.0034186176,
0.0761220083,
0.0261482596,
-0.0185150057,
0.0351955704,
-0.0114335995,
0.0169114713,
0.0732075274,
-0.0572823621,
0.0238280576,
0.0220987741,
0.0162375197,
-0.0194222331,
-0.022136027,
-0.0091354856,
-0.0018330652,
-0.0429900885,
-0.048548162,
0.0534494184,
0.0781788304,
0.0464971773,
-0.0893844813,
0.045990508,
0.0090729874,
-0.0110622132,
-0.0182762984,
-0.0300385542,
-0.0694829673,
0.0049307365,
-0.0095383534,
0.037941847,
0.0124447914,
-0.0468676686,
0.0718461573,
0.0058304439,
-0.0042193029,
0.0143666323,
-0.0074450267,
0.0213809945,
-0.0286916383,
0.0083693685,
0.014470513,
-0.0242539179,
-0.0494090989,
0.0124759208,
-0.0587781519,
-0.0027001943,
-0.0593480952,
-0.0359805338,
0.0366128385,
-0.0122933248,
0.0296697691,
-0.0110802362,
0.0760047063,
-0.020397678,
-0.0317427032,
0.0135123786,
0.0119414702,
0.0021376263,
-0.0158969965,
0.0735004246,
-0.0014114178,
0.0104926275,
-0.0464081876,
-0.0028404754,
-0.0609743856,
-0.021494735,
-0.0363600925,
0.0719270557,
-0.0281188637,
-0.0664765835,
-0.0711752549,
0.0075456332,
0.0427803732,
0.0012271225,
-0.024407126,
0.0017443309,
0.0027727147,
0.0155105609,
0.0733754784,
0.024013795,
0.0583781339,
0.063961342,
-0.060514871,
-0.0463126749,
-0.0557495095,
-0.0322355628,
-0.0266391225,
0.011875649,
-0.0251275208,
-0.0175181646,
0.0478250422,
-0.0263710245,
-0.0427731015,
0.0464427806,
0.0275398381,
-0.0101516144,
-0.0027121927,
-0.076008305,
0.0652219281,
0.0271424949,
-0.0372675806,
-0.0478214994,
0.0379030406,
-0.0143016661,
-0.0266480874,
0.0222419295,
0.0020292923,
0.0004392932,
0.0119047193,
-0.0159849282,
0.0331985466,
0.0089656943,
-0.0359643474,
-0.0681047812,
0.0316925123,
-0.0327388123,
-0.039760448,
0.0423626713,
-0.024285173,
0.0568894595,
0.0209746398,
0.0235955119,
0.0040262756,
-0.0318433456,
-0.0180050693,
-0.0072928136,
0.023815237,
-0.0140990624,
-0.0192223471,
-0.0188128985,
0.042723693,
0.0125037041,
0.0190992914,
0.0101470212,
0.0017509033,
0.023954656,
0.0095327087,
-0.0222489554,
0.0004785036,
0.0008254101,
-0.040734347,
-0.0421996452,
0.0063785068,
-0.0133135021,
-0.0065882946,
0.0235839598,
-0.0020906718,
-0.0329126976,
0.0286202338,
0.0038254645,
-0.006479552,
-0.0158131961,
0.013155099,
0.0006487796,
0.0341971889,
-0.0688503832,
0.0270137805,
-0.0234013554,
-0.0074495208,
-0.0304540321,
-0.0365622453,
0.0796839148,
0.0049751587,
-0.0279453974,
-0.0496223643,
0.0019025734,
-0.0127605395,
0.0343992189,
-0.0382460989,
-0.014566116,
0.033700414,
0.0059544914,
-0.0073910295,
0.0149015272,
0.0731893852,
0.0213521235,
0.0497743152,
-0.0001066144,
-0.0344414376,
-0.0364359766,
0.0177886374,
0.0716192275,
0.073786892,
-0.0417483449,
0.0157851074,
-0.0689939708,
-0.0449936949,
0.0958796591,
-0.0118202902,
-0.0043352786,
0.0208748486,
0.0542431995,
0.0195693318,
0.0111133633,
-0.0216687191,
-0.0260941237,
0.0059674806,
-0.0351930708,
0.0084177339,
0.0100813629,
-5.725988369e-33,
0.0335341506,
-0.0287486315,
-0.0072523989,
0.0109478217,
-0.029683305,
0.0488730967,
-0.0248663742,
-0.0241543967,
0.0224696174,
0.0639468282,
-0.0137541359,
0.0036846215,
-0.0102872178,
0.0511129163,
0.0354050919,
-0.0244794413,
0.0079009058,
0.0057403729,
-0.0117013576,
0.069074057,
0.0132074393,
0.0400086381,
0.0628327131,
-0.107805945,
0.0023606741,
-0.0044857785,
0.0530988909,
0.0107405009,
-0.0194161832,
0.0498363599,
-0.0153674502,
0.0791999325,
0.0626726821,
-0.0067436355,
0.0144321602,
0.0376419947,
-0.0680323169,
-0.028108716,
-0.0494666956,
-0.0303082969,
-0.0078740008,
-0.0525763929,
0.047892835,
0.0278352555,
-0.01154448,
-0.0373030677,
0.0469918028,
-0.0000123503,
-0.0603983775,
-0.1247523725,
-0.0318036489,
0.0591595061,
-0.0130586103,
0.0118808299,
-0.0409236997,
-0.0349576026,
-0.0063283471,
-0.0031068753,
-0.0611769073,
-0.0110344943,
-0.0402196497,
-0.0234417561,
-0.014943664,
-0.0336446874,
-0.037356209,
0.0650834665,
0.0254435632,
0.0702109635,
0.0056835976,
0.0473374762,
-0.0152380699,
0.0165012274,
0.018191671,
-0.0088607287,
0.049748145,
-0.0742942095,
-0.0851383135,
0.0309815947,
-0.0794221237,
0.0209302492,
0.0124294795,
-0.0035907186,
-0.0501981601,
-0.0062913685,
0.0038925102,
0.0395311415,
-0.0062392806,
-0.0268128458,
-0.0202328712,
0.0154153891,
0.0322104953,
0.0584333427,
-0.0119159119,
-0.0237404201,
-0.0311720185,
0.0251375455,
0.0830070898,
0.0396086909,
-0.028011065,
0.0039174338,
-0.0175004229,
-0.0090422975,
0.0083871596,
-0.0199766923,
0.0406761989,
0.0310049076,
0.055280026,
-0.0329899825,
-0.0365452319,
-0.0077509801,
0.0474365018,
-0.0299566202,
0.0204418227,
0.034262877,
0.0398100019,
-0.0032839274,
0.0188385174,
0.0842794329,
0.005179937,
0.0158396773,
-0.0331382975,
0.0588696226,
-0.016861964,
-0.0188421682,
-0.0452099629,
-0.005179673,
-0.0282057729,
-0.0081595499,
0.0503897555,
-0.0596710183,
-0.0203344226,
0.0120302783,
2.77e-7,
0.0845147371,
0.0320003293,
0.0045811869,
-0.063431941,
0.0424681753,
-0.0011128993,
0.0075385054,
0.0134359514,
-0.0435011499,
-0.0093431566,
0.0553344749,
-0.0045288596,
0.0148427822,
0.0521910414,
-0.0848676935,
-0.0013566198,
-0.0692161098,
-0.0223929714,
-0.0310449544,
0.0054354207,
0.0886768252,
0.0614770688,
-0.0398909412,
-0.0462255329,
0.0037452125,
-0.0086188624,
0.0135678267,
0.0237022396,
-0.0010274283,
0.0187184755,
0.0348607227,
0.0106069343,
-0.0076386505,
0.0613609813,
-0.002297645,
0.006947808,
0.0154334754,
0.0634963363,
-0.0661132932,
-0.0173442736,
0.037188638,
0.0004384649,
0.0351163931,
-0.0051940917,
0.0316014998,
-0.0505771935,
-0.0519993789,
-0.0193368047,
0.0073591322,
0.0198267512,
0.061502479,
-0.0234005693,
-0.0159569923,
0.038442973,
0.0238177422,
-0.0120556261,
0.0196630713,
-0.0646000654,
0.0359540582,
0.0968848914,
-0.0093958499,
-0.0463627018,
0.0715615675,
-0.0183373485,
0.0046084598,
-0.0210844297,
0.0290200934,
2.281460736e-34,
0.0407711118,
-0.0192318,
-0.0222327858,
0.0048145987,
0.0157506987,
-0.0242361315,
0.0243665129,
-0.0142465159,
0.0167911127,
-0.0824093223,
-0.0036918523
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.09731v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.09731v1 | What In-Context Learning "Learns" In-Context: Disentangling Task Recognition and Task Learning | 2023-05-16T18:05:19 | 2023-05-16T18:05:19 | Jane Pan, Tianyu Gao, Howard Chen, Danqi Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) exploit in-context learning (ICL) to solve tasks
with only a few demonstrations, but its mechanisms are not yet well-understood.
Some works suggest that LLMs only recall already learned concepts from
pre-training, while others hint that ICL performs implicit learning over
demonstrations. We characterize two ways through which ICL leverages
demonstrations. Task recognition (TR) captures the extent to which LLMs can
recognize a task through demonstrations -- even without ground-truth labels --
and apply their pre-trained priors, whereas task learning (TL) is the ability
to capture new input-label mappings unseen in pre-training. Using a wide range
of classification datasets and three LLM families (GPT-3, LLaMA and OPT), we
design controlled experiments to disentangle the roles of TR and TL in ICL. We
show that (1) models can achieve non-trivial performance with only TR, and TR
does not further improve with larger models or more demonstrations; (2) LLMs
acquire TL as the model scales, and TL's performance consistently improves with
more demonstrations in context. Our findings unravel two different forces
behind ICL and we advocate for discriminating them in future ICL research due
to their distinct nature. | [
-0.018376058,
0.0218260512,
-0.0097490223,
0.0415038057,
-0.021883972,
0.0339202359,
0.0083750673,
0.0069059762,
-0.0174269397,
-0.0315353349,
-0.0914530307,
-0.0124431569,
0.0157265533,
-0.0095318602,
0.0533719286,
-0.0250983145,
0.0223186314,
-0.0474576913,
-0.0338283069,
0.004216712,
-0.0338606834,
-0.024655344,
-0.0104726097,
0.0152732013,
-0.0103687225,
-0.014677058,
-0.0221954044,
-0.0368398614,
-0.0309661031,
-0.0280869231,
0.0083318865,
0.0410827398,
0.0591333807,
0.0091533614,
0.0000020699,
-0.0387812033,
0.0135426773,
-0.0384963863,
-0.0393556394,
0.0180844553,
0.0099910889,
0.0055028838,
-0.0088400748,
0.0102093024,
-0.0398932435,
-0.0491341799,
0.0141220912,
0.0568024628,
0.003353921,
0.0670874119,
0.0056428951,
0.0119662462,
0.0056262361,
-0.0377093181,
0.0351712853,
-0.0609413236,
0.0208124258,
-0.0090689054,
0.0114233829,
0.0052162921,
-0.0192938391,
0.0128892269,
0.045816645,
0.0255175848,
-0.019830374,
0.0726747811,
0.0031845267,
0.0097283805,
0.0007136289,
0.0287149549,
-0.0290796012,
-0.0368659832,
0.0039007245,
0.0033896384,
0.0095667364,
-0.0082856435,
-0.0634839088,
0.0122241424,
0.0207990352,
0.0307433549,
0.0101546459,
-0.0016057375,
0.0472969599,
0.0070231589,
-0.0022902638,
0.0638599992,
-0.0379502773,
-0.0482963286,
0.023588296,
0.0008339063,
-0.0365362689,
-0.0738433152,
-0.0196553972,
0.0222391151,
-0.0454857573,
0.0281798821,
-0.0433668569,
-0.0291213188,
0.00306259,
-0.0203578304,
0.0520493425,
0.0184900239,
-0.0143948495,
0.0484171063,
-0.0378207415,
0.097106792,
-0.0022422115,
0.0621090345,
-0.0379081517,
0.0219620503,
-0.0735286698,
-0.0131014753,
-0.0247155651,
0.0359022357,
-0.0097136619,
-0.0112261102,
0.0013496069,
0.0641020536,
-0.0183734745,
-0.004657099,
-0.0227780193,
-0.0105310138,
-0.0527449511,
0.0164701771,
-0.018527139,
-0.0011697781,
0.0202177465,
0.0809811056,
-0.0034615162,
-0.0409476161,
-0.0420129225,
-0.013950632,
0.0038530128,
-0.013508887,
0.0226152968,
0.0477852449,
-0.0505377389,
-0.0812219158,
-0.0154254418,
0.004103567,
-0.0019275192,
-0.0730177015,
0.0262255035,
-0.0417917594,
0.0155044356,
0.0214106981,
0.0131840426,
-0.0402169004,
0.0023906571,
0.0126638124,
-0.0074702641,
0.0849058703,
0.0552728362,
0.0345336311,
0.0216730833,
0.014457792,
-0.036952883,
0.0415093079,
0.0146218129,
0.0006613444,
-0.0259201471,
0.0187391993,
0.025716478,
0.061307475,
0.0480669364,
0.0266057923,
-0.0175544452,
0.003763742,
0.0723616555,
0.0267530531,
0.0445488878,
0.0111124106,
-0.0224171299,
0.0421020016,
0.0908788368,
0.0573373288,
-0.0221229754,
-0.0472780205,
-0.0056335819,
-0.0002467389,
0.0238828044,
-0.0046910723,
-0.1169363484,
-0.0022329576,
0.0111733247,
-0.0030067745,
0.0083364705,
-0.0224794894,
-0.0372724943,
-0.0050490233,
-0.0222936738,
-0.00285516,
-0.0021872926,
0.0259963982,
0.0556888469,
0.0404488295,
-0.0585493445,
-0.0056562028,
0.0023767073,
0.0074975789,
0.0140160462,
-0.071625337,
0.0028627017,
-0.0100895781,
0.0203158818,
-0.0386411324,
-0.0105566885,
-0.013132167,
0.0722077191,
0.0274270382,
0.0062684645,
-0.0298318472,
-0.0033199389,
-0.0087327929,
-0.0229537934,
-0.0497484431,
0.024193706,
0.0049567022,
0.0184974838,
-0.0215987563,
-0.0185079779,
-0.0685259849,
-0.011896899,
0.0429961495,
-0.0584467798,
-0.064792119,
-0.0100191263,
-0.0062561487,
0.0269221123,
-0.021938866,
-0.0102043133,
0.0139209032,
0.0417006314,
-0.0284680501,
0.0273806453,
0.0086649423,
-0.075507395,
-0.0655576363,
0.0222539064,
0.0224247929,
-0.018515816,
0.0202363525,
-0.0314861014,
-0.0420908034,
-0.0140077798,
-0.0223616157,
0.0572495982,
-0.0256848056,
0.0264719967,
-0.0091528473,
-0.0219151378,
-0.0219683573,
0.084764868,
-0.013022868,
-0.0119632576,
0.0315522701,
0.0291068591,
-0.0198552813,
-0.0052166325,
0.0025337778,
0.0155987442,
-0.0044644647,
0.0195467416,
-0.0510327853,
0.0135390898,
-0.0431248024,
0.0080362344,
-0.0956225619,
0.0142001873,
-0.0200909544,
0.0165393073,
0.0208712127,
-0.0359321162,
-0.0159385502,
-0.0310056191,
-0.0239722207,
-0.0393053852,
0.0089140162,
0.0274529289,
0.0150776654,
0.0418217257,
0.0022696969,
-0.00750968,
0.0207254179,
-0.008696069,
0.0502802469,
-0.0292178802,
-0.0049634101,
-0.0440494753,
0.0686940178,
0.0313394777,
0.0305681285,
-0.0307465047,
0.0297848284,
0.0311896019,
-0.0106057264,
0.0367110185,
0.0683968961,
-0.0356758945,
0.0465938076,
0.0490412042,
-0.0033714497,
-0.0440416671,
0.0012309664,
-0.0131530073,
-0.0403396003,
-0.0441205315,
0.0116803413,
0.0244243555,
0.0575512014,
0.0146299284,
-0.0037151622,
-0.0297546089,
0.0182850454,
-0.0286075678,
-0.0416816324,
-0.0597517192,
-0.019917313,
-0.0630483478,
0.0246881563,
-0.0439327955,
-0.0614271238,
0.0285288244,
-0.0088648451,
-0.0097397938,
-0.0497514717,
-0.0090886531,
0.0027279635,
0.0680344924,
0.008390367,
-0.0122464839,
0.017913416,
-0.0455413871,
-0.060311567,
0.0084085269,
-0.0128488811,
-0.0337518975,
0.0590166003,
-0.0588509105,
0.0146822575,
-0.012293797,
-0.0508342572,
-0.0596492924,
-0.0056341635,
0.0049099219,
0.0461774021,
-0.0556958616,
0.0139478687,
0.0025985071,
-0.0193360448,
0.0500212945,
0.0588430166,
0.0004507658,
-0.0057168189,
-0.0389947146,
0.0054762401,
-0.0089781322,
0.0252817087,
-0.0174500123,
-0.0722802877,
-0.0239435565,
0.017894743,
0.1266616732,
-0.0234800484,
-0.0176354628,
0.0223249029,
0.0131447483,
-0.0005419297,
-0.0177764241,
0.0548095703,
0.0594331101,
-0.0554223619,
-0.0263556857,
0.0732970685,
-0.0003656422,
-0.0619678572,
0.0094764521,
0.0283726081,
-0.0173746068,
0.0391809903,
0.0097890077,
-0.0458576456,
-0.024735231,
0.037191961,
-0.0005209356,
0.0088080121,
-0.0062675504,
-0.0160320979,
-0.1290252507,
0.0196937416,
0.0104987118,
-0.071947895,
-0.0204005837,
-0.0392670073,
0.0300268959,
0.0198979061,
0.0503171794,
0.0036875368,
-0.0196722709,
-0.006497792,
0.0593222082,
0.0514258817,
-0.1006706432,
0.0394978151,
-0.0205353778,
0.0283006225,
0.0364254043,
0.008585589,
-0.014322076,
-0.027326012,
0.083395727,
0.0090267761,
0.0126340715,
-0.0053975838,
-0.0020694707,
0.0107304975,
-0.0087673832,
0.0165089816,
0.0521715805,
-0.051700972,
-0.0460565761,
-0.0079171341,
0.0826331005,
-0.019105291,
0.0029732278,
0.0225145686,
-0.0652228147,
0.0250305794,
0.0690599754,
0.0345748998,
-0.0470297635,
-0.0222919211,
0.003673662,
-0.0047826222,
0.0253546387,
-0.012703171,
0.0112992348,
-0.0176749919,
0.002944778,
-0.0380586237,
-0.0192075558,
0.0482428297,
0.037514843,
0.02689353,
-0.002796205,
-0.029224392,
-0.0145371947,
-0.0447028205,
0.0521775745,
-0.0332416967,
0.0202131476,
-0.0559121929,
-0.0233410243,
0.0305871274,
-0.0376564376,
-0.0218563639,
0.0098923063,
-0.086611785,
-0.047599908,
-0.0033914989,
0.0151780853,
0.0173085332,
0.0489567444,
0.0243192352,
-0.0258481838,
0.0807110667,
0.0330315158,
-0.0095468806,
0.0738716349,
0.0075124381,
-0.0213856436,
-0.0045831762,
0.0208136048,
-0.0283087026,
-0.0014106199,
0.0429571681,
0.0051789493,
-0.0129616801,
0.0389679223,
0.0422144867,
-0.0534552224,
0.0877424702,
0.0000448645,
-0.0340804867,
-0.0333417468,
0.0016811029,
0.0327118523,
-0.0165574905,
-0.0089613609,
-0.0434591919,
0.0186474323,
0.071444802,
0.0151692713,
0.032211367,
0.0286179278,
0.0670853853,
-0.0069250399,
-0.027873056,
0.0325914957,
-0.0240064394,
0.0147387553,
0.0475123189,
-0.0083305016,
-0.0050640847,
-0.0004481518,
0.0300076306,
-0.0014428081,
0.0491005443,
0.0404290184,
-0.0165084619,
-0.0116397645,
0.0097010629,
-0.0663803741,
-0.0295322537,
-0.0332965851,
0.0110116359,
0.0504405312,
-0.0274335593,
0.0141348829,
-0.0360972136,
-0.0013011938,
-0.0296160933,
-0.020608576,
-0.0223364215,
-0.0199054778,
0.0221943185,
0.0187984779,
0.0255771764,
0.0252655633,
0.0792588964,
0.0140632149,
0.0726537928,
-0.0052133147,
0.0248411596,
-0.017541403,
-0.0100162346,
0.0531286336,
0.0367550254,
-0.0024250278,
-0.0079263747,
-0.0129070636,
-0.0514963754,
-0.0008494221,
0.0006719779,
-0.0249631237,
-0.0490050428,
0.0387563705,
0.0468902215,
-0.0250371508,
-0.042648986,
0.0004898628,
-0.0209403709,
0.0385131054,
-0.0285533369,
-0.0067541604,
-6.289592727e-33,
-0.0203538034,
-0.0319429711,
0.0300959852,
-0.0084642097,
0.0039772196,
0.0199506152,
-0.040792495,
0.0039017049,
-0.0098545123,
-0.0055173668,
-0.0296530556,
-0.0015125208,
0.0097107515,
0.0109729217,
0.0275521278,
-0.026747765,
0.0285915043,
-0.0412402488,
-0.0210698228,
0.0375231802,
0.01657998,
0.0038826906,
0.0754638091,
-0.0729212686,
0.0336585492,
-0.001194611,
-0.0206865184,
0.0278798491,
-0.0246354211,
0.0397907607,
-0.0401301049,
0.0286128353,
0.046251487,
-0.0662818402,
-0.0437499061,
0.0271622669,
-0.0581923984,
-0.0175973494,
0.0118760597,
0.0152422069,
-0.029643802,
-0.011302691,
0.0598371811,
-0.0043082917,
-0.0487414002,
0.0054993695,
0.013179888,
-0.0064668339,
-0.016373584,
0.0016877481,
-0.0404101685,
-0.0135836359,
0.0295639411,
-0.0535996929,
0.0301130377,
-0.0013002695,
-0.029256776,
-0.0284071285,
-0.0645643249,
0.0155137917,
0.0070074452,
0.0173851456,
0.065868251,
0.0590808801,
0.0272628758,
0.0610475168,
0.0153437871,
0.0307063852,
0.0179898068,
-0.0721186846,
0.0428397059,
0.0451732241,
-0.0016191492,
0.0015226635,
0.0454211012,
0.0284293108,
-0.0358674601,
-0.0106934253,
0.0321521759,
0.0075455401,
0.0471377335,
0.0195554346,
-0.0305791609,
-0.0428819619,
-0.052869793,
0.0186135266,
-0.0266083628,
-0.0056869378,
0.0703971386,
0.0410123207,
0.0215373412,
0.0138028841,
0.0449052937,
-0.0411254279,
-0.0422425643,
0.002932312,
-0.0153445164,
0.0322198458,
0.0019943004,
-0.0235744752,
-0.0724150836,
-0.061384812,
-0.0182636734,
0.0097399261,
0.0136341704,
0.0015847096,
0.0311970264,
0.0469384529,
-0.0511568375,
-0.0049838442,
-0.0431142785,
0.0194772705,
0.0597685687,
-0.0000494446,
0.0752087161,
-0.0074961521,
-0.0078385454,
0.0407747552,
0.0226683058,
-0.0669622347,
-0.022286782,
0.027976729,
-0.0614220276,
0.0034465929,
-0.0211420748,
-0.0164283738,
-0.0300987922,
0.0162787307,
0.0293296296,
-0.0180532895,
-0.004375393,
0.0129394587,
2.835e-7,
-0.0130946944,
0.0352594703,
-0.0073085781,
-0.0074971812,
0.0611610748,
0.0502718613,
-0.0560817569,
0.0443821885,
0.0203574114,
-0.0220141131,
-0.013605848,
0.0294548254,
0.0437822156,
0.0037351162,
-0.0525484569,
-0.0476032123,
-0.0191649422,
0.0146090761,
-0.0536029674,
0.005534004,
-0.0232738368,
0.0681283772,
0.0237583015,
-0.0124378186,
-0.0108886762,
-0.0574364401,
0.0894535854,
-0.0485204607,
0.0260632411,
-0.0040362929,
-0.0529169478,
0.0262384564,
0.0062051425,
0.0654343143,
-0.0059823096,
0.044059135,
0.0112137562,
0.0674158931,
0.0274742879,
-0.0118864086,
-0.0162701011,
0.0244014747,
0.0081411665,
-0.0504520275,
0.0795596614,
-0.1123944968,
-0.0166960936,
-0.0201754402,
0.043973133,
-0.0495299213,
-0.0021043057,
0.0330702178,
0.005442034,
0.0011239622,
-0.0027288306,
0.0121092154,
-0.0384064615,
-0.0747521892,
-0.0425107814,
0.0489834808,
-0.0857925117,
-0.0313762166,
-0.0267518684,
0.0251917932,
0.0262279324,
-0.0492935255,
-0.0061078407,
2.466668366e-34,
-0.0268628206,
-0.0016369545,
0.0433234982,
0.0473656096,
-0.0230913348,
-0.0227178689,
0.0024285861,
0.0089869648,
0.0441256985,
-0.0518053547,
0.0134193301
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.09656v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.09656v3 | SatLM: Satisfiability-Aided Language Models Using Declarative Prompting | 2023-05-16T17:55:51 | 2023-10-11T21:38:22 | Xi Ye, Qiaochu Chen, Isil Dillig, Greg Durrett | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Prior work has combined chain-of-thought prompting in large language models
(LLMs) with programmatic representations to perform effective and transparent
reasoning. While such an approach works well for tasks that only require
forward reasoning (e.g., straightforward arithmetic), it is less effective for
constraint solving problems that require more sophisticated planning and
search. In this paper, we propose a new satisfiability-aided language modeling
(SatLM) approach for improving the reasoning capabilities of LLMs. We use an
LLM to generate a declarative task specification rather than an imperative
program and leverage an off-the-shelf automated theorem prover to derive the
final answer. This approach has two key advantages. The declarative
specification is closer to the problem description than the reasoning steps
are, so the LLM can parse it out of the description more accurately.
Furthermore, by offloading the actual reasoning task to an automated theorem
prover, our approach can guarantee the correctness of the answer with respect
to the parsed specification and avoid planning errors in the solving process.
We evaluate SATLM on 8 different datasets and show that it consistently
outperforms program-aided LMs in the imperative paradigm. In particular, SATLM
outperforms program-aided LMs by 23% on a challenging subset of the GSM
arithmetic reasoning dataset; SATLM also achieves a new SoTA on LSAT and
BoardgameQA, surpassing previous models that are trained on the respective
training sets. | [
0.0221906211,
0.0528895743,
-0.0167023931,
0.0266429298,
-0.0650009215,
0.0036087227,
-0.0226924084,
-0.013260819,
0.0318094268,
-0.0285198912,
0.0225019343,
0.0106710177,
-0.0181830004,
0.038889505,
0.0409336723,
-0.0051768073,
0.0412356965,
-0.0673068166,
0.015738884,
0.0012548055,
-0.019227419,
0.0025020505,
-0.0279040635,
-0.004742811,
-0.0352332741,
-0.0419424474,
-0.0514382534,
0.0096021201,
-0.0171878152,
-0.046984002,
-0.0421535335,
0.0610457435,
0.0286359321,
-0.0010317323,
0.0000024851,
-0.0619267486,
-0.0316179171,
-0.0069937725,
-0.0578348972,
0.0409249477,
-0.0053434419,
0.0208642073,
0.0017308814,
0.0290451292,
-0.0440367498,
0.0061652577,
0.0126281586,
0.0013756956,
0.0779600814,
0.0617939457,
0.0043268376,
-0.0110996729,
0.0183587149,
0.0159085374,
-0.0056845266,
-0.0485893078,
0.0231736843,
0.0639456362,
0.0521240011,
0.0004583147,
-0.0122498032,
0.0340696201,
0.0410566442,
-0.0056997538,
-0.0390836671,
-0.0019065717,
-0.0390689261,
0.0199278444,
-0.0022810374,
0.0440779366,
0.0196380727,
-0.0382568762,
-0.0007295806,
0.0048174611,
-0.0094881635,
-0.0182041973,
-0.0193507336,
0.0676154196,
-0.0183199234,
0.0155105703,
0.0029426895,
-0.0215084739,
0.0221007969,
-0.0011859932,
-0.0514028519,
0.0973196626,
-0.0105934599,
-0.0706904903,
-0.0095691755,
-0.0220499914,
-0.0473783016,
-0.0635226816,
0.008908554,
0.0527994595,
-0.0850433558,
0.0360109694,
-0.0177855473,
0.0019983887,
0.003385294,
-0.0152305411,
0.0491726175,
0.0466738828,
0.0074950755,
0.0369432196,
-0.0403436981,
0.1137361825,
0.0197365619,
0.035487745,
-0.0565986782,
-0.0044084806,
-0.0376178809,
-0.0045327102,
-0.0497716516,
0.0543655306,
-0.0256975591,
0.0013845538,
-0.0252179354,
0.0260267034,
-0.0359798931,
0.0710285977,
-0.0039226143,
-0.0344115309,
0.00140945,
-0.0447667018,
-0.0658678561,
-0.0256205406,
-0.0305615552,
0.0029967714,
0.0206650402,
-0.0379665159,
-0.0110242553,
-0.002406501,
-0.0037417428,
-0.0016800729,
0.0293039717,
0.0254528839,
0.0039253207,
-0.0023768926,
-0.0514410995,
-0.0267290659,
0.0132374773,
-0.0785501897,
-0.0050554322,
-0.0924366862,
0.028804075,
-0.0030588391,
-0.0377563462,
-0.0114871105,
0.0244488735,
0.0310915802,
0.0398894846,
0.0921470746,
0.0406981297,
0.0271742549,
-0.018041851,
-0.0088113295,
-0.0327436179,
0.0568375289,
0.0355871059,
0.0387203172,
0.0066096666,
0.0157767087,
0.023950493,
0.0542506576,
0.0117940549,
-0.0119549567,
-0.0247829668,
0.0423247591,
0.0251403973,
0.0461916886,
-0.0585354902,
0.0578298643,
0.0109004602,
0.0433117561,
0.0161895305,
0.0444466248,
0.0227280315,
-0.0073132543,
0.0224931296,
0.0328048021,
0.0103319855,
0.0033260984,
-0.0716224462,
0.0411688648,
-0.0345843509,
0.0147442073,
0.0148240114,
0.0455300473,
0.0006367827,
-0.0902952924,
-0.0246091615,
0.0237849988,
0.0161776841,
0.0476145595,
0.0553592332,
-0.0314032175,
-0.0400265194,
0.077418521,
0.0182396416,
-0.033754766,
-0.0281575639,
-0.0620828718,
0.0376618579,
0.0105277896,
0.065821059,
-0.0516668931,
-0.031383004,
-0.0115254018,
0.0572189204,
0.0570470616,
0.0117581701,
0.0105420779,
-0.0362299755,
-0.031626571,
-0.0216565505,
0.0013291744,
0.0164093468,
0.0010445117,
0.0422129296,
-0.0086384825,
-0.006368944,
-0.0293208286,
-0.022699859,
0.0355628058,
-0.0398189127,
-0.0668962449,
-0.0015611246,
0.0307646077,
0.0081907874,
0.0135284001,
-0.0134304976,
0.0449181534,
0.0138321565,
-0.0140436655,
-0.0346302986,
-0.0426790752,
-0.0355771855,
-0.0197251439,
0.0492630266,
-0.0352297015,
-0.0286928304,
0.0408996791,
-0.0462606139,
-0.0227970313,
0.0191373955,
-0.0230802093,
-0.0383236893,
-0.0287679993,
0.0189861674,
0.0254338589,
-0.0542912334,
-0.0321414098,
0.0607965887,
0.008518409,
-0.0078529511,
0.0375609361,
0.0054903207,
0.0259591639,
-0.0195633825,
-0.007167479,
0.0152737685,
-0.0222117305,
0.0091398964,
0.0151864858,
0.0419382267,
-0.0222373288,
-0.0226746425,
-0.0502863042,
0.0206819102,
0.001029369,
0.0169966463,
0.0018225313,
-0.0299992375,
-0.0101236254,
0.0128397718,
-0.0450803638,
-0.0057266182,
0.0342949033,
-0.024767939,
0.0115896109,
0.0146268727,
-0.0381731763,
-0.0073276004,
-0.0170790516,
-0.0426794589,
-0.0048985886,
-0.0012292138,
-0.0243299548,
-0.0430652462,
0.0657729581,
-0.0431795605,
0.0355830938,
-0.0198439993,
-0.0008915132,
0.0255283993,
-0.0476978905,
-0.0125966724,
0.0638546273,
-0.0143065322,
-0.0306051672,
0.079193987,
-0.0511166565,
-0.0579124205,
0.0457785502,
0.0054709492,
-0.028151812,
0.0160199124,
-0.0588505678,
0.0157830175,
0.0113477334,
-0.0235673524,
-0.0061607878,
-0.0409957394,
0.0118769165,
-0.0111561008,
0.0134485755,
-0.042739369,
0.0034623302,
-0.0116453338,
0.0604683533,
-0.0284304973,
-0.0350561254,
0.0829237029,
-0.0284224339,
-0.015636446,
-0.0453274213,
0.013041635,
-0.0559241548,
0.0983542427,
-0.0005183599,
-0.0042622024,
0.0457210429,
-0.0053472263,
-0.0491383597,
-0.0262419824,
0.0163264815,
-0.0435544476,
0.0685074404,
-0.0643393621,
0.0235615727,
-0.0111439405,
-0.0184323527,
-0.0626535192,
0.0220198911,
-0.0208413955,
0.0331117436,
0.0008652653,
-0.0047555752,
-0.0166943576,
-0.0061933538,
0.0152217196,
0.0131658604,
-0.0104089482,
-0.0074879285,
-0.046180781,
-0.0308327731,
0.0316004269,
0.0457667783,
0.0120995343,
-0.0161494128,
0.0334300958,
0.0229572654,
0.0324695893,
-0.0200037621,
0.0158696994,
0.0080601368,
0.0106875831,
-0.0101652285,
0.0179372467,
0.0508279279,
0.0050460454,
-0.0676432624,
-0.0043694754,
0.1268218607,
0.054017704,
0.0271759778,
-0.0076344521,
-0.036137484,
0.0183994733,
0.0283975489,
0.0694398284,
-0.1239664704,
-0.0378957205,
0.0159948394,
-0.0251013562,
0.0032856842,
-0.0272843018,
-0.0294446349,
-0.1163816005,
0.0419961251,
0.0105957696,
-0.0026916412,
-0.0159786511,
-0.0038536252,
-0.0216839034,
0.0136417039,
-0.0252422355,
0.0166819021,
0.0229398701,
-0.0029972368,
0.0105482712,
-0.0252607726,
0.0039986344,
0.0516017228,
-0.0474783108,
0.0266760476,
0.0346548185,
0.0084891338,
-0.002060805,
-0.0740333721,
0.0586827919,
0.0732281432,
-0.0109208534,
-0.0231517907,
-0.0358569026,
-0.0045467215,
0.0059057055,
-0.0033260069,
0.0105893724,
-0.0309084877,
-0.0201371256,
0.0694213361,
0.119804807,
0.0075198109,
0.0023189941,
0.0029227003,
-0.0216622278,
-0.0048427572,
0.0665567666,
-0.0163587537,
0.0210234709,
-0.0398199596,
-0.0575497895,
-0.0491490252,
-0.0296957642,
-0.0343884006,
0.0040696175,
0.0087981317,
0.0414557829,
-0.025217291,
-0.0121574588,
0.0477354079,
0.0325993299,
0.0051683774,
-0.013174288,
0.0286932774,
0.0088353632,
-0.0490572266,
0.032379847,
-0.0734007284,
0.0413674153,
-0.0562932864,
-0.0124625312,
-0.0076526874,
-0.0388143249,
-0.0164364092,
0.0258890539,
-0.0549676418,
-0.0393422171,
-0.0342709944,
0.0508774593,
0.0158153586,
0.0071796407,
0.0062795505,
0.0092019411,
0.0031328667,
0.0331193991,
-0.0203835424,
0.010564453,
0.0078605246,
-0.0269678012,
0.008279305,
0.0183100943,
-0.0166819468,
0.0274372865,
0.0057555363,
0.0633408427,
0.0311059318,
-0.0291301347,
0.07076931,
0.0855059922,
0.0054174936,
0.0098457551,
-0.0399897546,
-0.0099431826,
0.0269755963,
-0.0636514351,
-0.0448188074,
-0.0537449643,
0.0120492708,
-0.0177135691,
0.0052568531,
0.0516124293,
-0.0138441678,
-0.0273830909,
0.0205032825,
0.0136127891,
0.0232214835,
-0.0026206241,
-0.0052620512,
0.0365803316,
-0.0386507623,
0.0119684841,
0.0027950371,
0.0096760271,
0.0355404317,
-0.0081943898,
0.0643785223,
0.0362132303,
0.0073291766,
-0.0678535551,
0.0008513985,
-0.0121601773,
-0.0810992271,
0.0177767184,
0.0027414691,
0.0626505315,
0.0406819209,
-0.0418851674,
-0.0625974685,
0.0045903982,
-0.0098162908,
0.0071189143,
0.0534085259,
-0.0337427817,
0.0411614962,
0.0409280732,
0.0277390294,
-0.0397013836,
0.0263290852,
-0.0096519804,
0.0291128904,
0.003512332,
-0.0191724356,
-0.0569774322,
-0.062204361,
-0.0279807691,
0.0183122586,
-0.0322322622,
0.0095853209,
-0.0661798194,
-0.0723655671,
0.0053352709,
0.0502954647,
-0.0027217993,
-0.0125679262,
0.0251597874,
0.0566455424,
0.0294467527,
-0.0339424796,
-0.0131003009,
0.0060456847,
-0.0220135823,
-0.0266423486,
-0.0108076185,
-6.363606259e-33,
-0.0399670564,
-0.0173105169,
0.0848052576,
-0.015254017,
0.0030759948,
-0.004328894,
-0.0619617365,
0.0262685474,
-0.0007781052,
0.005723801,
-0.0153965987,
-0.0030084897,
-0.0008718233,
0.0166805219,
-0.0036459758,
-0.0223586112,
0.0043588597,
0.0047807028,
-0.0442494713,
-0.0264939461,
0.0039758743,
-0.02304768,
0.0161851905,
-0.0077334521,
0.0119087426,
-0.0094687715,
-0.0293646175,
0.0596394464,
-0.0791447088,
0.053708531,
-0.0096905995,
0.022999933,
0.0016546778,
-0.0376420468,
-0.0103309862,
0.0391713716,
-0.0368170738,
-0.0272895023,
0.0415840186,
-0.0153454244,
-0.0313656554,
-0.0199763998,
0.0140449684,
0.0106764864,
-0.0464395583,
-0.0097935209,
0.0106039699,
-0.0313146859,
0.0108881248,
0.0165073071,
-0.0271943621,
0.0145516032,
0.0029683472,
-0.0427491665,
0.0183175001,
0.0492591709,
-0.0227026716,
0.0020500445,
0.0304087009,
0.0351534635,
0.0546548292,
0.0176732652,
0.0760401636,
0.0157629196,
-0.0084374938,
0.0459216759,
0.0060944268,
-0.0254061874,
-0.089672409,
-0.006702601,
0.0198011473,
0.0387743041,
0.0528183654,
0.022176316,
0.0073657339,
0.0353611335,
-0.0813657045,
0.0202365573,
0.0203006286,
0.0610236712,
0.0326582119,
-0.0163518805,
-0.0640557557,
-0.0393826962,
-0.0456295721,
0.0701674819,
-0.0510922559,
-0.0043235854,
0.0560084656,
-0.0124642085,
-0.0271333661,
-0.0373925865,
0.0198119134,
-0.0342912674,
-0.0312808231,
0.0226357523,
0.0240632612,
0.0102384733,
-0.0289609823,
0.0393113904,
-0.0237910375,
0.0024717809,
0.006848353,
-0.0152692785,
0.0126548521,
0.0228733681,
-0.0139698125,
0.0519369729,
-0.028069675,
0.005801402,
-0.0792862326,
-0.0069011808,
-0.0065701776,
0.0087482743,
0.0341383107,
0.0092127351,
0.0060092118,
0.0142153697,
-0.0231862385,
-0.0727325603,
-0.0189838912,
0.0429110229,
0.0154540893,
0.0160553008,
0.0067690206,
0.0067278314,
-0.0656306446,
0.0111039868,
-0.0069532786,
-0.0096883737,
0.0136933019,
0.0147067141,
3.147e-7,
-0.0067956741,
0.0632438287,
0.0075454232,
0.0730504841,
-0.0312266592,
0.0283554513,
-0.0353527479,
-0.0158158541,
0.027964782,
-0.0625111684,
0.0191339292,
0.0605330653,
0.0340340324,
0.0189272948,
-0.0804068297,
0.0205413215,
0.0038148325,
-0.0267452393,
-0.075095281,
0.0360064022,
0.1264733523,
0.0511484742,
0.0073848926,
0.0025431211,
-0.011531855,
-0.0369577222,
0.0077075209,
-0.0252963975,
-0.0129150124,
0.0129798744,
-0.0257261693,
-0.0218516644,
-0.0014902336,
0.0437353961,
-0.0027881586,
0.0095379604,
-0.0072229328,
0.0894180909,
0.0279480126,
0.0045013069,
-0.0142054567,
-0.0061759506,
-0.0036464385,
-0.0371879488,
0.0758671835,
-0.0222949143,
-0.0150271356,
-0.0134155592,
0.0043199207,
-0.0200948268,
-0.0481895395,
-0.0010548752,
-0.0109820412,
-0.0033664452,
0.0093600703,
-0.0005936525,
0.0196937528,
-0.0541081801,
-0.0180389509,
-0.015045655,
-0.0362964049,
-0.023570409,
-0.0378839634,
0.0511598773,
0.0008784457,
-0.0484078489,
-0.0219723787,
3.417519318e-34,
0.0353518911,
0.0041895346,
0.0300819967,
0.0030231851,
0.0438229367,
0.0272063892,
-0.0386406966,
0.0235512648,
0.0278234836,
-0.0896684155,
-0.0279419161
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.09652v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.09652v2 | The Interpreter Understands Your Meaning: End-to-end Spoken Language Understanding Aided by Speech Translation | 2023-05-16T17:53:03 | 2023-10-17T14:59:28 | Mutian He, Philip N. Garner | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | End-to-end spoken language understanding (SLU) remains elusive even with
current large pretrained language models on text and speech, especially in
multilingual cases. Machine translation has been established as a powerful
pretraining objective on text as it enables the model to capture high-level
semantics of the input utterance and associations between different languages,
which is desired for speech models that work on lower-level acoustic frames.
Motivated particularly by the task of cross-lingual SLU, we demonstrate that
the task of speech translation (ST) is a good means of pretraining speech
models for end-to-end SLU on both intra- and cross-lingual scenarios.
By introducing ST, our models reach higher performance over baselines on
monolingual and multilingual intent classification as well as spoken question
answering using SLURP, MINDS-14, and NMSQA benchmarks. To verify the
effectiveness of our methods, we also create new benchmark datasets from both
synthetic and real sources, for speech summarization and low-resource/zero-shot
transfer from English to French or Spanish. We further show the value of
preserving knowledge for the ST pretraining task for better downstream
performance, possibly using Bayesian transfer regularizers. | [
-0.0191521384,
0.0613684915,
0.0031546785,
0.0422779992,
0.0210968163,
-0.0001192474,
0.001914145,
-0.035536591,
-0.0329928473,
-0.0177434012,
-0.0624975562,
-0.0150195658,
0.0173611101,
0.0044948356,
0.0243751146,
-0.049993109,
0.0636649728,
-0.0261897594,
-0.0260683559,
-0.0097193252,
0.004670993,
0.0144945355,
-0.0068784221,
0.0232304893,
0.0250284392,
0.0143705979,
-0.0332635604,
0.0154816583,
0.0418692753,
0.0055981153,
-0.0463097245,
-0.0086175445,
0.0477181301,
0.0267588887,
0.0000022094,
-0.0589286014,
-0.0288976673,
-0.0206458364,
-0.059366785,
-0.0189179964,
0.0319603868,
-0.0433672555,
0.018199645,
0.0162248984,
0.0010981911,
-0.0005090355,
0.0557445697,
0.0146205239,
0.0539132357,
0.0721184909,
-0.0025904211,
-0.0573685057,
0.01944438,
-0.0458124205,
0.0185131449,
-0.0896647722,
-0.0113489954,
-0.0164440759,
-0.0114294188,
-0.0390308499,
-0.0517032072,
0.0787574127,
0.0030634692,
0.010704821,
-0.0005863194,
-0.0304036923,
0.0039577293,
-0.0180828311,
-0.0060677738,
0.0940318778,
-0.0152625917,
-0.0179588441,
-0.015763361,
0.0055835908,
-0.0308030415,
-0.0246855449,
-0.0477713868,
0.0189291611,
0.016300993,
-0.0009143185,
0.0164070539,
0.0368518382,
0.0344943665,
-0.0186187793,
-0.0866826922,
0.0211417992,
0.0130725736,
0.0080755092,
0.0136255799,
-0.0179857668,
0.0021093281,
-0.0612654164,
0.0199592989,
0.0482446924,
-0.0405251794,
0.0391215198,
-0.0234147478,
-0.0393921547,
-0.0167336129,
-0.0160047412,
-0.0031412309,
0.0991838872,
-0.0444092192,
0.0296114627,
0.0018559778,
0.0309157241,
-0.0409749001,
0.0365027748,
-0.0681400225,
-0.0553394035,
-0.0366675481,
0.0154449688,
-0.0423438251,
-0.0054467712,
-0.0792069361,
0.0043431474,
0.000292602,
-0.0066342754,
0.0123119587,
0.0018778141,
-0.015614043,
-0.0327711441,
-0.0793883726,
-0.0097975582,
0.0002794623,
0.1165790036,
-0.0128236115,
0.0163105037,
0.0084150238,
-0.0268642232,
-0.0303531028,
0.0085389065,
0.0060302992,
-0.0108031034,
0.0070993081,
0.0767726973,
-0.0131080542,
-0.0268208496,
-0.0347824506,
-0.0174640641,
-0.0075588929,
-0.0884208307,
-0.0061544245,
-0.0391213074,
0.0796253681,
-0.002858921,
0.0051479894,
-0.026111247,
-0.0058854087,
-0.0295761563,
-0.0153371273,
0.0525947362,
-0.0102934986,
-0.0075724553,
0.0155969644,
-0.0033645092,
-0.0052897832,
0.0670072213,
0.0127116917,
0.0131456824,
0.023980815,
-0.0178482272,
-0.0516593233,
0.0730052143,
0.0477233306,
0.0350974537,
-0.0111387148,
0.0165610909,
0.0506633744,
0.0286780484,
0.0405626632,
-0.0100871809,
-0.0345285311,
0.0007820643,
0.0222137962,
0.0201842375,
0.0161961317,
0.020016402,
0.0509830676,
0.0432578772,
-0.0110031795,
0.0187006053,
-0.0082182027,
0.0097503085,
-0.0222901665,
0.0038523867,
0.0463141203,
0.034577854,
-0.0349862389,
-0.0286201593,
0.0207886174,
-0.0095584337,
0.0074723247,
0.0575051382,
0.0596133173,
0.0242436044,
-0.0383981727,
0.0722547472,
0.021795962,
-0.0681817606,
0.0710085109,
-0.0246564001,
-0.0095142098,
0.0329088233,
-0.0091812797,
-0.0164504629,
-0.0130846789,
-0.0675707385,
0.0061582425,
0.0198224336,
0.0225393549,
0.001281744,
0.0927042961,
-0.0456298739,
-0.0134271113,
0.0014998956,
-0.0138182286,
0.0757617801,
-0.1004891172,
0.0194747373,
0.0141435293,
-0.0392095298,
-0.0099795246,
-0.0042852638,
-0.0503931008,
-0.0048604133,
0.0171184167,
0.0237189066,
0.0372424871,
0.050399933,
-0.02131024,
-0.0216942243,
0.0428752042,
-0.0446989983,
0.0091796778,
0.0334137417,
-0.0477921255,
-0.0438199118,
0.0321839675,
-0.0264428686,
-0.0009807189,
0.0334264673,
-0.0360460654,
-0.0938821733,
0.0477265157,
0.0182699915,
0.0466485508,
-0.0309442263,
0.0182786249,
0.0060564112,
0.0313763916,
-0.0011426877,
0.0079806559,
0.0508522987,
-0.0018117878,
0.0441521071,
-0.0275370553,
0.054043062,
-0.0557821095,
-0.0137648433,
0.037993826,
-0.0151661402,
0.0110586202,
0.0373443849,
-0.0068644681,
-0.0089089144,
0.0290057156,
-0.1022577658,
0.033581581,
-0.0251218062,
0.0338308774,
0.0504263379,
0.0729951113,
0.007580332,
-0.0374410152,
-0.0079337107,
-0.0256745983,
0.0190742929,
-0.0413490795,
-0.0064613717,
0.0396009721,
-0.0006259925,
-0.0252935104,
0.0107126236,
0.0078304149,
0.0372723676,
0.0041027241,
-0.0173780024,
-0.046361547,
0.0112049431,
-0.017206097,
0.0093350979,
-0.0168153197,
-0.0488689877,
-0.0370045193,
0.000039989,
-0.0224118363,
0.0288568716,
0.0054539172,
-0.039815288,
0.0136364084,
-0.0270551797,
-0.0419558845,
0.0348404683,
0.0097595984,
-0.0292442348,
-0.0750255585,
0.0006763009,
-0.003575424,
0.0806997493,
0.0139411213,
-0.0145577909,
-0.0568843,
-0.0352029167,
0.0008393824,
-0.0124491733,
-0.0594605468,
-0.0000190991,
-0.0094857132,
0.0623259656,
-0.0337067172,
0.0091046263,
0.0414499976,
-0.0822540447,
-0.0270287357,
-0.077041544,
-0.0206107106,
-0.0308386348,
0.0368150771,
-0.0448116772,
0.0248149578,
-0.0260683745,
-0.031980399,
-0.0412738286,
-0.0122073041,
-0.0022852023,
0.0136048552,
0.0604432374,
-0.0387775674,
-0.002389017,
-0.0209622066,
0.0054574688,
-0.0333905593,
-0.029135175,
-0.0428802222,
-0.0141626494,
0.0197806284,
0.0005094858,
-0.0271948464,
0.0045392518,
0.046762459,
0.048787497,
0.0024465153,
0.0383159183,
-0.0202288777,
0.0194451697,
0.0032123611,
-0.0049270191,
-0.0113634486,
-0.0314224847,
0.0377785414,
-0.0130528836,
0.0520888865,
-0.0397168472,
-0.0271654576,
-0.0053080027,
0.0221836157,
-0.0066185785,
-0.0504139178,
-0.0035315058,
0.096156396,
-0.053905461,
0.0277719852,
0.0950368717,
-0.0253723487,
-0.0305077732,
-0.0157301966,
-0.0212546457,
-0.0057419748,
0.03404852,
0.0233011879,
-0.1023858488,
-0.0722294226,
0.0135580841,
0.0012663329,
0.0565014184,
-0.0025823689,
-0.0370794088,
-0.0740280822,
0.0046987268,
0.0194352139,
-0.1129889116,
0.0020120181,
-0.0153074171,
-0.0161580704,
-0.0075588427,
0.0301593896,
-0.0151260439,
0.0012105301,
-0.0162928049,
0.0205084402,
0.0124171479,
0.0124901654,
0.0298424046,
-0.0121898632,
0.0156523697,
0.0214631278,
0.0513082705,
-0.0105133057,
-0.0056819147,
0.0470793508,
-0.0370394327,
0.0040940205,
-0.0067164246,
0.0622254871,
-0.0072207656,
-0.0271543004,
0.060590405,
0.017533211,
-0.0064555896,
0.0401255228,
0.0312473979,
0.0566129871,
0.0141615188,
0.0452765375,
0.0487114191,
0.0139657836,
0.0214846842,
0.0521088615,
0.021599276,
-0.0219219085,
-0.0198087879,
-0.013777486,
-0.0100160949,
-0.0303713866,
0.0056520617,
0.0090987384,
-0.0325106569,
-0.046865698,
-0.0117822438,
-0.0508806705,
0.0096081709,
0.012660753,
0.0218047202,
0.0180924926,
-0.0010353818,
-0.0038158768,
-0.0120904148,
0.0564666055,
-0.0327450447,
0.0415635742,
-0.0240108073,
0.0042078001,
-0.0019210319,
-0.0870782807,
-0.0176900439,
0.0187762808,
-0.0494264066,
-0.0601495728,
-0.0202225447,
0.0252690464,
0.0208167788,
0.0908965841,
-0.0310234241,
-0.018131787,
0.0239271894,
-0.0755503848,
-0.0636918694,
-0.0061134109,
0.0846414864,
0.0151903788,
-0.0154277021,
0.0498247184,
-0.049260471,
0.027194228,
-0.0092822453,
0.018998811,
0.013763465,
-0.0896504819,
0.0050656549,
0.0300308764,
0.0326148719,
-0.0059798635,
0.0049288971,
-0.0292498469,
0.0275795255,
-0.0160754565,
0.0279859696,
-0.0338813514,
-0.0259050466,
0.0495932028,
-0.0344972461,
0.0259348247,
-0.0116652483,
-0.0519012548,
-0.0206033997,
0.0214398708,
0.0285113994,
0.0055283457,
0.0333835073,
0.0108917924,
0.0200475771,
-0.0035377659,
-0.0003501344,
0.0283324458,
0.0409508087,
-0.0363017805,
0.0296557285,
0.0081757484,
0.0285848007,
-0.0028584483,
-0.0050759902,
-0.0471797511,
-0.0718722418,
0.0290582143,
-0.0004954268,
0.0498500504,
-0.0092831906,
0.0793288276,
0.0450198166,
0.0026772048,
-0.0183810703,
0.0741211325,
-0.0391297378,
-0.0183806885,
0.0119100651,
-0.0328592174,
0.0018322142,
0.0146548813,
0.0388281047,
-0.0139003703,
0.0451137424,
-0.0084872963,
0.0286154617,
-0.0348329321,
-0.0261932574,
0.0024082379,
-0.0110194301,
-0.0386483185,
0.0055068252,
-0.0177629776,
-0.067702435,
0.0376723334,
-0.0336202085,
-0.0128886746,
-0.0211331304,
0.0112409256,
0.0342869796,
-0.0261031017,
-0.0109624434,
-0.0175992418,
-0.0178909563,
0.010346205,
0.0245784633,
0.0216785036,
-6.474600109e-33,
-0.0126582673,
0.048658397,
0.0152471708,
-0.0281014461,
-0.0334340595,
-0.0365042128,
-0.0503317975,
-0.0311339814,
-0.0278712884,
-0.0081920642,
-0.0075445352,
0.014901544,
0.0193034373,
0.048530113,
-0.0172443967,
-0.0166121088,
0.0767942518,
-0.0157369841,
-0.0194754843,
0.035772793,
0.0581808425,
0.0495500565,
0.1057441384,
-0.0189071558,
0.0108558945,
-0.0103534963,
0.0025347869,
0.0396052785,
0.0253485795,
0.0021135181,
0.0045141685,
0.0208205376,
0.006875948,
-0.0623485334,
-0.0392751954,
0.0212911125,
-0.0854832977,
-0.0190146286,
0.0397663191,
0.0287017468,
-0.0323880799,
-0.0323651507,
0.0046731718,
-0.0220248755,
0.0505669788,
-0.0392872542,
0.0154602481,
-0.0278866459,
-0.0014896315,
0.0063823238,
-0.0430237427,
0.0065410016,
-0.0551383533,
-0.0306533966,
0.0330625698,
0.0904007703,
-0.0209914036,
-0.0180954505,
-0.0369768254,
0.0029727465,
-0.0321736559,
-0.0073166708,
0.0885865986,
0.0118384808,
-0.0032815235,
0.0140785677,
0.032369338,
-0.0506788902,
0.0455967672,
0.0048610177,
0.0242753308,
-0.002135176,
-0.0299935509,
0.0578334592,
0.0519523062,
-0.0134272333,
-0.0818258896,
0.0055929231,
-0.0185247045,
0.0308741126,
-0.0203307979,
0.0105193453,
0.0173238702,
-0.0056059039,
-0.0760863721,
-0.0386809632,
0.006169932,
-0.0293955225,
0.0072395485,
-0.0019640636,
-0.0230699331,
-0.0255514029,
0.0992377624,
-0.0301493537,
0.0349164233,
0.0170843974,
-0.0078856414,
-0.0256912801,
0.0112050539,
0.0650607198,
-0.0499444604,
0.0025282535,
0.0044574966,
0.0052047884,
0.0179311689,
-0.0307356175,
0.0264220163,
0.0046434309,
-0.0129660331,
0.0169264954,
-0.0479853824,
0.0363756232,
-0.0271560084,
0.0418786742,
0.038569022,
0.0103064124,
-0.0225921031,
0.1014080346,
-0.0259331893,
-0.0047834879,
0.0049173669,
-0.0266012792,
0.0419852622,
0.0397311039,
-0.0618481822,
-0.0101444414,
-0.0011018242,
-0.001958197,
0.0454528481,
-0.0460665748,
-0.0207366329,
0.0140676666,
2.883e-7,
0.0579816587,
-0.0263747163,
0.0543925613,
0.0330380909,
-0.0056168954,
0.0278758295,
-0.0306785256,
-0.0153658884,
0.0076897582,
0.0176076274,
-0.0010806549,
0.0312677957,
0.0755720139,
0.0005725496,
-0.0815914497,
-0.0435778536,
0.0065806569,
0.0276289713,
-0.0225403886,
0.0077409516,
0.046085272,
0.1018803865,
-0.0234317277,
-0.004641158,
-0.0080042165,
-0.0262850337,
0.0615242757,
-0.0186423678,
-0.0178968869,
0.0059946314,
-0.0019632713,
-0.0002673797,
-0.0307270363,
0.0193504952,
-0.0215454902,
0.0525910407,
0.0068532932,
0.0556129813,
-0.0077938144,
-0.0580046028,
0.0017901304,
0.0102587892,
-0.0157939252,
-0.0070044929,
0.0559878759,
-0.0591673143,
-0.0061759991,
-0.0019912636,
-0.0527940094,
0.0063969004,
0.0116795907,
0.0189681537,
0.0129754832,
0.0184945576,
0.0241078828,
-0.0231016949,
-0.0205465015,
-0.0585707314,
-0.0121067688,
0.017357612,
-0.0307825767,
-0.0136818215,
0.0016692112,
-0.031743817,
0.0335940942,
-0.0471750163,
0.0081242109,
2.245444691e-34,
0.0561224669,
-0.02149464,
-0.0023278329,
-0.0316358954,
0.0455392301,
-0.071844779,
-0.0381540395,
-0.0065815393,
0.043076016,
-0.0394385755,
-0.0262521692
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.09651v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.09651v3 | Tailoring Instructions to Student's Learning Levels Boosts Knowledge Distillation | 2023-05-16T17:50:09 | 2024-05-15T15:32:27 | Yuxin Ren, Zihan Zhong, Xingjian Shi, Yi Zhu, Chun Yuan, Mu Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | It has been commonly observed that a teacher model with superior performance
does not necessarily result in a stronger student, highlighting a discrepancy
between current teacher training practices and effective knowledge transfer. In
order to enhance the guidance of the teacher training process, we introduce the
concept of distillation influence to determine the impact of distillation from
each training sample on the student's generalization ability. In this paper, we
propose Learning Good Teacher Matters (LGTM), an efficient training technique
for incorporating distillation influence into the teacher's learning process.
By prioritizing samples that are likely to enhance the student's generalization
ability, our LGTM outperforms 10 common knowledge distillation baselines on 6
text classification tasks in the GLUE benchmark. | [
0.0530185029,
0.0244286172,
-0.0042668842,
-0.0034237104,
0.0107079446,
0.0184594952,
0.0201712083,
-0.029183371,
-0.0448841937,
-0.0017532806,
0.0198768768,
-0.0097331023,
-0.0654182434,
-0.0117967427,
0.0189377107,
-0.1369552761,
0.036685694,
0.0074084536,
0.0060858992,
0.0010349199,
0.0065563233,
-0.0161968563,
-0.0127397394,
-0.0051432885,
0.0068562413,
-0.0132055162,
-0.0070927162,
0.0163090732,
0.0433220305,
0.000167378,
0.0219972804,
0.038290672,
0.0478343964,
-0.0377915315,
0.0000022481,
-0.0361758061,
-0.0399638116,
-0.0265096407,
-0.0181546174,
0.023933053,
-0.0183537416,
0.0187970661,
0.0521683618,
0.0140803838,
-0.0420399792,
0.0268808659,
-0.0132863643,
0.0265562106,
0.0692238361,
0.0158016346,
0.0049390467,
-0.0319984555,
0.0104353018,
0.0130806891,
0.0581576042,
-0.0481398925,
0.0298605226,
0.0624895729,
-0.0185383707,
-0.0198835507,
-0.0784793571,
0.0107445521,
0.0191265624,
0.0176823344,
0.0576967038,
-0.0025332663,
-0.0338851251,
0.0134553611,
0.0208073854,
0.0438671857,
0.0017978291,
0.0111466888,
0.0086387629,
0.0018784335,
0.0723705739,
0.0361888073,
-0.0817333534,
-0.0418634936,
-0.0306684263,
0.0141233187,
0.0000645808,
0.0123940418,
-0.0071279942,
0.0108433478,
-0.015018709,
0.0156856757,
-0.027555814,
-0.0434395485,
0.0371728763,
0.0618848689,
-0.0361226723,
0.0058782115,
0.0129288267,
0.0446830168,
0.0403051525,
0.0182287768,
-0.0288694408,
-0.0063133733,
-0.0198486168,
0.0210841037,
0.0034989323,
0.0235422458,
0.0185100287,
0.0268799365,
-0.0187145043,
0.0555902272,
0.0498822406,
0.0758112893,
-0.0354215354,
0.0065380204,
-0.1420967579,
0.0117044421,
-0.0211770497,
0.0579248667,
0.0628871769,
0.0111463461,
-0.0401563793,
-0.0246022213,
-0.0246487539,
-0.0226486139,
0.0186670162,
0.0184318442,
-0.0025039681,
0.0444730967,
-0.0500514731,
0.068117477,
-0.0384305939,
0.0059738471,
0.0134574827,
-0.0045769769,
-0.0217844043,
-0.0192714259,
0.0122815734,
0.0240392685,
0.0168219339,
-0.047879301,
-0.0646661669,
-0.0317710973,
-0.0793104991,
-0.0154207163,
-0.0003446552,
-0.0558805428,
0.0078607537,
-0.0549882017,
0.0235960297,
-0.0049457508,
0.0026035781,
-0.0651387721,
0.0002584537,
-0.0211810358,
0.0054401164,
-0.0019297928,
-0.0066748662,
-0.0067154155,
0.0147101926,
0.0642971843,
-0.058217369,
0.0443146154,
-0.0167998765,
0.0275879968,
0.0009078891,
-0.0241201743,
0.0172181856,
-0.0055427067,
0.0418142714,
0.039004676,
-0.0200419426,
-0.0121565666,
-0.0106139407,
0.0227362774,
0.0432423986,
0.0163235608,
-0.0497251153,
0.0501839221,
0.0569923669,
0.0215954836,
0.0345274024,
0.0063509797,
0.004360484,
0.0428909622,
0.0216187555,
0.0495333597,
-0.0448049642,
-0.0250588153,
0.0414436683,
-0.0019688334,
0.0060545569,
0.0266013164,
-0.0271065179,
-0.0618870668,
0.0297519583,
0.0018165285,
0.0068711489,
0.0202676132,
0.0567930937,
0.0307663195,
0.0208735224,
0.0527666733,
0.0434943847,
-0.0377682596,
0.0678159148,
-0.0766823217,
0.0171781741,
0.055034332,
0.0230594203,
-0.0326703079,
-0.0216596313,
-0.0426312648,
0.0488206446,
-0.0280407127,
0.0497654416,
-0.029994281,
0.0117362514,
-0.0308169536,
-0.0650187656,
-0.0085862428,
0.0341801979,
0.0007663378,
0.0222686157,
0.0421687476,
0.0058159013,
-0.0439419709,
-0.054596819,
0.04971141,
-0.0078459764,
-0.0887482762,
-0.0400922075,
0.0077161323,
0.0143911336,
0.0237107668,
-0.003731421,
-0.0593921505,
-0.0076106046,
-0.0193843972,
-0.0295552034,
-0.0442611314,
-0.0617629327,
-0.0310198124,
0.0202964507,
-0.0652052313,
-0.0192672201,
0.0028903899,
-0.0423701927,
-0.0560614243,
0.010140311,
0.030778572,
0.0522079282,
0.0135306502,
0.0218051188,
-0.0229722727,
-0.0253709573,
-0.0180021729,
0.0222451128,
0.0092889778,
-0.0327150337,
-0.0427697711,
-0.0134310564,
-0.0009846841,
0.0476920381,
-0.0059680985,
-0.0382318459,
-0.026323691,
0.0417395607,
-0.0017176684,
-0.0040135952,
-0.0758916736,
0.0202466603,
0.0232849531,
-0.0058766222,
-0.0273176674,
0.0161535889,
0.0086821355,
-0.0071473517,
-0.0027984744,
0.0008237363,
-0.0551840365,
-0.0401793905,
-0.0432123877,
-0.0226580817,
-0.0062475991,
0.0534068979,
0.0125436913,
-0.0230654683,
0.0009315355,
0.0033603599,
0.0021385471,
0.0109805139,
0.0341831222,
-0.0010489437,
0.0457575023,
-0.0170592181,
-0.0112357661,
-0.002916323,
-0.0241397899,
-0.0049234168,
-0.0334928632,
-0.0141738169,
0.042733375,
-0.0255071241,
-0.0003020393,
0.0424021818,
0.0172792487,
-0.0809256285,
0.0208428018,
-0.0257561579,
0.0021616672,
-0.0222315043,
-0.0406097099,
-0.0294649284,
0.0545855649,
0.0110200038,
-0.0227867886,
-0.0433609448,
-0.0029512346,
-0.0282759294,
-0.0227082018,
-0.0561220273,
-0.0055755205,
0.0258143079,
-0.017852379,
-0.0196106602,
-0.0487287678,
0.0538068078,
0.0492653735,
0.0313800238,
-0.0532785319,
-0.0240717232,
0.0062552835,
0.0165860783,
-0.0083516873,
-0.0018118151,
-0.0283786338,
0.0033176676,
-0.0517546125,
0.0166131072,
0.0559222586,
-0.020984171,
0.04669258,
-0.0787521526,
-0.0550800748,
-0.0225349497,
-0.0194586609,
-0.028052384,
0.02066461,
0.0166152883,
0.007449219,
0.0454429872,
-0.0096398564,
-0.0421508476,
-0.0165026877,
0.0307250302,
0.0137372334,
-0.0265893266,
-0.0341057628,
0.0122843469,
-0.0106847472,
-0.0005414809,
-0.0122402506,
-0.0624787472,
-0.0692977756,
0.0111153256,
0.0485797636,
0.046242211,
-0.060305059,
-0.0042576385,
0.0102570653,
0.0240483563,
-0.0094032055,
0.0066140746,
0.0049226591,
0.0307227317,
-0.0485029072,
-0.0048976289,
0.0442509502,
0.0173831936,
-0.0191555992,
-0.0209117476,
0.0050551402,
0.0610098951,
0.026407741,
0.0331247188,
-0.0589672774,
-0.0361621231,
-0.0350791439,
0.052819211,
0.0219171476,
-0.0359208882,
-0.0020636751,
-0.0440561809,
-0.0106774997,
0.031477347,
-0.0460724123,
-0.0373658165,
-0.0316655263,
-0.012074749,
-0.0183617752,
-0.001089987,
-0.0241730064,
-0.0232807305,
0.0321248807,
0.0872303918,
-0.0351146497,
-0.0705144927,
-0.0306291319,
-0.014584152,
-0.0197114926,
0.0351721719,
-0.0105665745,
-0.0189221613,
-0.0434199572,
-0.0445161574,
0.0153798442,
0.0101339854,
0.0022531899,
0.1202033758,
-0.025855314,
0.033514265,
0.0151595678,
0.042980209,
-0.0005161432,
0.0364422537,
0.0592301562,
0.0658904612,
0.0435530171,
-0.0594598204,
-0.0292159002,
-0.0304395948,
0.0412174538,
0.0671095252,
0.0217529815,
-0.0464771837,
-0.0131663494,
-0.0072276988,
-0.0001740749,
-0.0138606858,
-0.0081894584,
0.0237033404,
-0.0586411245,
0.0284243301,
-0.0267712455,
-0.0052354936,
0.0325267538,
0.0496299006,
0.0052014044,
0.0077414662,
-0.0337011218,
0.0191995017,
-0.0024302166,
0.0004690498,
0.0244060941,
-0.0121844858,
-0.0272911824,
-0.0622947067,
0.012209638,
-0.0113227982,
-0.0431623198,
-0.0258354563,
-0.0715898573,
-0.0522126146,
0.0352977328,
0.0587628447,
0.020437004,
0.0643341541,
0.036220666,
-0.0427740291,
0.0802755579,
0.0114144664,
0.018078154,
-0.0225690156,
0.0442754999,
-0.0280148834,
0.0232064705,
-0.0132411541,
-0.0194033552,
0.0531920902,
0.0257964656,
0.0070220823,
-0.0349562503,
0.034407638,
-0.0044576791,
0.0061220969,
0.0362385809,
0.015387401,
0.0010650328,
-0.0366901085,
0.0267847162,
0.0524936132,
0.0121816229,
-0.025599001,
0.0080113243,
0.071362637,
0.0186449885,
-0.0110823736,
0.0301262159,
0.0309654735,
0.0075112935,
-0.0444856435,
-0.0074032163,
-0.0048190681,
0.0218699109,
0.0384547189,
-0.0022747207,
-0.0353832021,
0.0049025738,
0.0358008817,
0.0220171474,
0.0036888889,
0.0485666953,
0.0468816794,
0.0662372038,
0.035601519,
-0.0242502801,
-0.0812344328,
-0.0589400418,
-0.0361623019,
0.0212834813,
0.0003328107,
0.0029764692,
0.0306492131,
-0.0029643564,
0.0034624327,
0.0259730034,
-0.016445294,
-0.0419500843,
0.0305694938,
-0.0019184615,
0.021280529,
0.0304102842,
0.0175846536,
0.0326801836,
-0.0354331434,
0.0425691456,
-0.056599509,
0.0126102101,
-0.033015985,
0.0079230135,
0.0900431275,
0.063880682,
0.0444755033,
0.0098462785,
-0.0380684063,
-0.0362742059,
-0.0074062152,
-0.0081611099,
0.0294438694,
-0.0320320986,
0.0449769609,
0.0477553606,
-0.0513946824,
-0.0290924627,
0.00578715,
-0.0606690422,
0.0358549207,
0.007284163,
0.0173028316,
-6.326107255e-33,
0.006440354,
0.0498151109,
-0.0004409424,
0.0803793147,
0.000247366,
-0.0241909027,
0.0349004082,
0.0087198047,
-0.0192200802,
0.0290484708,
-0.0133805415,
0.0346239768,
0.0082546296,
0.0422293618,
0.0317265987,
0.021988539,
0.0755420178,
0.0196143184,
-0.0135867512,
0.0673578233,
0.0181729812,
0.0560023934,
0.0598148406,
-0.069921121,
-0.0070243594,
-0.0026558535,
0.0199523959,
-0.0417803265,
-0.0028752189,
-0.0226086341,
0.0084324218,
0.0354783125,
0.0169407297,
-0.0499006324,
-0.0377009772,
-0.0167668518,
-0.0900313854,
-0.068060644,
-0.0176027417,
-0.0231274143,
-0.025963597,
-0.0233582892,
0.0172995757,
0.0029729842,
0.0117430519,
-0.0505706109,
0.0636398345,
-0.0011961217,
-0.0203494616,
-0.0577554218,
-0.0631400719,
-0.0029056659,
-0.0389225073,
-0.0044410024,
0.0054359152,
0.0181850344,
-0.0039823367,
0.0030121147,
-0.0650810152,
0.0332163833,
0.0774030611,
0.0270210076,
0.021978531,
0.0249355137,
-0.0603251159,
0.0408256054,
-0.0025960207,
0.0163394418,
0.0267305132,
-0.0508602262,
0.0529425144,
0.069717899,
0.0009524332,
0.0629182458,
0.1206571013,
-0.0327369645,
-0.0592669845,
0.0307581667,
0.016906552,
-0.0039042931,
-0.037804272,
-0.0200081244,
-0.038987536,
-0.0420072041,
-0.0495968573,
0.0087319119,
0.0169463977,
-0.0268919356,
0.031613417,
0.0257388465,
-0.0390973501,
-0.0018620561,
-0.0126575399,
-0.0440035202,
0.0104040289,
-0.0030865578,
-0.0288659986,
-0.0085248714,
0.0014198731,
-0.0497427769,
-0.1088807136,
-0.0468713939,
0.0135160629,
-0.0085579809,
0.0210485253,
0.0175270718,
0.1010915115,
0.0115939192,
-0.0236877631,
-0.0246886872,
-0.0187231544,
0.0113779949,
0.0314496346,
-0.0287889261,
-0.0011985356,
0.0046789409,
-0.0155928824,
0.0310955159,
0.0328835919,
-0.0114254188,
-0.0038326124,
-0.0134828966,
0.0119045833,
-0.0156442486,
-0.0126342382,
-0.0442850031,
-0.0067747803,
-0.0381256975,
0.0274639782,
-0.0933440849,
-0.0095599135,
-0.0067184642,
2.844e-7,
0.0041850712,
0.0248968676,
-0.0231651738,
-0.0571403429,
-0.0333456025,
-0.0075198282,
-0.0146531574,
0.0173286442,
0.0180169642,
-0.0462427773,
0.0344080813,
0.0497142039,
0.0215372927,
0.0442271717,
-0.0658401921,
-0.0338612571,
-0.0110406131,
-0.0442864634,
-0.0274846479,
-0.0195298754,
0.065141052,
0.0074569122,
0.0582909584,
-0.042246595,
0.0321241841,
-0.0323871039,
0.0294032134,
0.0041403458,
0.0664410591,
0.0532507487,
0.0486036353,
-0.0032189328,
-0.0077753854,
0.0644181073,
-0.0254440811,
0.0302795637,
-0.0170787591,
0.0409696475,
-0.0187870897,
0.0250742789,
-0.0121256886,
0.0263676345,
0.0056624976,
-0.0507732034,
0.0438104793,
-0.0808626264,
0.0233744364,
0.0589534789,
-0.0489757359,
-0.0267993566,
0.0179360844,
0.0250145998,
0.0490040295,
0.0020453627,
-0.0133743929,
-0.0015800741,
-0.0489798188,
-0.0515919961,
0.0105761113,
-0.0160605535,
-0.0071910247,
-0.0792226046,
0.0003005189,
-0.0367535464,
-0.0390435942,
-0.0159640666,
0.0172676463,
2.062437899e-34,
0.0220057704,
-0.0070284102,
0.0609432571,
-0.0104043549,
0.0044741267,
-0.0159176607,
-0.0768413767,
0.0136404438,
0.0229555462,
0.0100006834,
-0.0061440389
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.09645v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.09645v2 | StructGPT: A General Framework for Large Language Model to Reason over Structured Data | 2023-05-16T17:45:23 | 2023-10-23T07:51:23 | Jinhao Jiang, Kun Zhou, Zican Dong, Keming Ye, Wayne Xin Zhao, Ji-Rong Wen | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we study how to improve the zero-shot reasoning ability of
large language models~(LLMs) over structured data in a unified way. Inspired by
the study on tool augmentation for LLMs, we develop an \emph{Iterative
Reading-then-Reasoning~(IRR)} approach for solving question answering tasks
based on structured data, called \textbf{StructGPT}. In our approach, we
construct the specialized function to collect relevant evidence from structured
data (\ie \emph{reading}), and let LLMs concentrate the reasoning task based on
the collected information (\ie \emph{reasoning}). Specially, we propose an
\emph{invoking-linearization-generation} procedure to support LLMs in reasoning
on the structured data with the help of the external interfaces. By iterating
this procedures with provided interfaces, our approach can gradually approach
the target answer to a given query. Extensive experiments conducted on three
types of structured data demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach, which
can significantly boost the performance of ChatGPT and achieve comparable
performance against the full-data supervised-tuning baselines. Our codes and
data are publicly available at~\url{https://github.com/RUCAIBox/StructGPT}. | [
0.0084223878,
0.0466255508,
-0.0019445732,
0.0707353801,
-0.0272979252,
0.0425556712,
-0.0060684225,
-0.0008742443,
0.0148022771,
-0.0699428096,
-0.013642665,
-0.0019543562,
-0.0346334241,
0.0306907967,
0.007749686,
-0.0303106587,
0.0370945334,
-0.0541704185,
0.0255150273,
-0.0075114015,
0.0064221076,
0.0185319465,
-0.0107430331,
-0.0189582761,
0.0322110243,
-0.0391651578,
-0.0088353045,
0.0059062378,
-0.0083738482,
-0.0475415476,
0.0173528921,
0.0157576408,
0.0311913155,
0.0238306262,
0.0000021719,
-0.0183861684,
-0.0145797981,
0.0040247599,
-0.0536351688,
-0.0129651697,
-0.018484829,
-0.0248205122,
0.002773419,
0.0091133136,
-0.0433632024,
-0.0234388579,
0.0169931091,
0.0407053381,
0.0615702905,
0.0896115825,
0.0046361974,
-0.0670993924,
0.0225187689,
-0.0021354496,
0.0495129675,
-0.0245845243,
0.017617926,
0.0799315423,
0.0433730222,
0.086625509,
0.0061701671,
0.0423967317,
0.023276981,
-0.0086353365,
0.0068835369,
0.0434991494,
-0.0712017938,
0.026079461,
0.0120413983,
0.0817229524,
0.0170389116,
-0.0148141356,
-0.0118669178,
0.0015977501,
-0.0179306176,
-0.022106722,
-0.0605120473,
0.0273163039,
-0.037110433,
0.01828398,
0.0223060232,
-0.0378803201,
0.0308008026,
0.0204735678,
-0.0416119061,
0.1191285774,
-0.0043596369,
-0.0115577606,
-0.0039880192,
-0.0121282684,
-0.0368298851,
-0.0545354523,
-0.0387986712,
0.0999804065,
-0.0465893261,
0.033435367,
-0.0070578866,
-0.032476835,
-0.0067200889,
-0.0370262638,
-0.0144644184,
0.0444380529,
0.0151941339,
0.1055418029,
-0.0512616485,
0.0212185457,
-0.0668624416,
0.0376417339,
-0.0732235461,
-0.0436949916,
-0.0659803972,
-0.0320236906,
-0.0248075072,
0.0459384806,
-0.0512604527,
-0.0214148182,
0.0179484729,
0.0557471439,
0.0308610592,
0.0106590204,
-0.0087852767,
-0.0163897276,
-0.0143566933,
-0.0288537163,
-0.0210023411,
0.0207909737,
-0.0548373833,
-0.0221478101,
-0.0151103819,
-0.0134229967,
-0.0126215583,
0.0099907275,
0.0111681726,
-0.0380231142,
0.0199587531,
0.0615072958,
-0.0141033977,
-0.0048302971,
-0.0746022165,
-0.0501006693,
-0.0000889925,
-0.0842004344,
0.0138823483,
-0.0568750761,
0.0274024475,
0.0403772444,
-0.0249537583,
-0.0038663289,
-0.0063744034,
0.0116451848,
-0.0549797602,
0.0862238258,
-0.021371007,
0.0004663901,
0.0003182148,
0.0252933893,
-0.0127289603,
0.0637370199,
0.0056939791,
-0.0036731078,
0.0042043179,
-0.0034655053,
-0.031472601,
0.0181448832,
0.0205149557,
0.0157635473,
-0.0381611437,
0.0683728307,
-0.017745873,
0.000453672,
-0.0065212958,
0.030813694,
-0.0547835194,
-0.0070142085,
0.0016041653,
0.0251697358,
0.0477150008,
0.0172646195,
0.009369758,
-0.0018245649,
0.0112867886,
0.0067276242,
-0.0519057661,
0.034448795,
-0.0596877486,
0.0318360962,
-0.0083218766,
-0.023680523,
-0.037372943,
-0.0452667885,
-0.0326167047,
0.0348386727,
-0.0199397877,
0.0379106328,
0.0569217503,
0.0167581607,
-0.01754977,
0.0118051609,
0.0259647444,
-0.0025737518,
-0.0129663106,
-0.0221511237,
0.059942849,
0.0498114899,
0.0730272382,
-0.0547100902,
-0.0714054331,
-0.0065216338,
0.0329403765,
0.0039337091,
-0.0202926025,
-0.0245337449,
-0.0177304242,
-0.04118995,
-0.0332086422,
-0.0343361571,
-0.0086299181,
0.0171792209,
0.0310071893,
-0.0094853314,
0.0130502423,
-0.049675025,
0.0283985268,
0.0091263894,
0.0025788767,
-0.0449573025,
-0.0063182483,
-0.0175793488,
0.0291381404,
0.0005778603,
-0.0119499285,
0.0193811543,
0.0250505432,
-0.0317083187,
-0.0107667251,
-0.0170148406,
-0.0303673167,
-0.0527351424,
0.0434332974,
0.0021747334,
-0.0351755843,
-0.0260063447,
-0.0572274849,
-0.0376751982,
-0.0022983763,
-0.007050666,
0.0278261211,
-0.0401230194,
0.0122118546,
0.0281575173,
-0.015104915,
-0.0590963177,
0.0715808868,
0.0072450149,
-0.0037928824,
0.020663904,
0.005222593,
0.0227857102,
-0.0302731544,
-0.0020951875,
0.0440752879,
0.0213160422,
-0.0092344787,
0.008382895,
0.0086245667,
-0.0686282068,
-0.0027736505,
-0.047862418,
0.0216784962,
-0.0101619875,
0.0290480182,
0.0277496874,
0.0249495283,
0.0075013288,
-0.0172047652,
-0.0686336905,
0.0077578975,
0.0249718931,
0.0134398686,
0.0411005765,
0.012438423,
-0.0288555566,
-0.0204011612,
-0.0316128954,
-0.0517451912,
0.0079166535,
0.0088399267,
-0.0042596501,
-0.0727116838,
0.01409561,
-0.0513349846,
0.0431591086,
-0.0247272551,
0.0047203414,
0.0162203871,
-0.0523324423,
0.0259575415,
0.1018721685,
-0.0426722914,
-0.0422931425,
0.0359097533,
-0.010718666,
-0.0700989068,
0.0322349332,
0.0083794994,
0.0108032655,
-0.0231987946,
0.0101276031,
-0.0045613744,
0.0421481915,
-0.0217813011,
0.0053277775,
-0.0248437524,
0.0164093785,
0.0192495082,
0.0217287559,
-0.0419185013,
-0.0045505241,
0.0360029377,
0.0348852612,
-0.0302816648,
-0.0209217314,
0.0756151006,
-0.0363555886,
-0.0230200272,
-0.0207893513,
0.0051856791,
-0.0939586982,
0.0748411939,
0.0182191152,
0.0050157616,
-0.0281995982,
-0.0205456037,
-0.0310585573,
-0.0445857197,
0.0332483724,
-0.0176667776,
0.0359487087,
-0.0413675681,
0.0351976752,
-0.0135320742,
-0.0257706959,
-0.0294856708,
0.0045902673,
-0.0485360809,
0.0131144347,
0.0065188822,
-0.0112475334,
-0.0079814689,
0.0090498999,
0.0077856164,
0.0283536427,
-0.0069711329,
-0.0108860005,
-0.0283833016,
0.0372202732,
0.0336070731,
-0.0012067059,
-0.0025302449,
-0.0095767891,
0.0332936309,
0.0507221185,
0.0227810983,
-0.0147357322,
-0.0368701816,
0.01315758,
0.0192579795,
-0.0256717801,
-0.0142100267,
-0.0239812005,
0.0243468955,
-0.0826344192,
-0.0140778339,
0.1152433455,
0.0284498595,
-0.0260986164,
-0.0276025217,
-0.02316292,
0.053716559,
0.0315303206,
0.044310566,
-0.0916157663,
-0.0439425632,
-0.0040094065,
-0.0095551619,
0.0300373081,
-0.0435587168,
-0.0097839376,
-0.1107798815,
0.0244810469,
0.0119063566,
-0.0352405421,
-0.0287245736,
-0.0170545615,
-0.0045126462,
-0.0034177087,
-0.000500715,
0.0414154045,
-0.0087452475,
0.0121347765,
-0.0061673201,
0.0195554867,
0.0120645128,
0.0424779765,
-0.0263870507,
0.0520877279,
0.0367549062,
0.0148368981,
0.0346592404,
-0.0314802676,
0.0756099448,
0.043329902,
-0.0066801528,
-0.0399410874,
0.0252732765,
-0.0183523092,
-0.0081776725,
-0.0201170947,
0.0513088927,
-0.0417060442,
0.0130174011,
0.0052505392,
0.0883812308,
-0.0232428033,
0.0108419778,
-0.0497118197,
-0.0258487426,
-0.0241891481,
0.0683852136,
-0.0055850181,
0.0166721363,
-0.0587449968,
-0.0282388702,
-0.0533697195,
-0.0238572061,
-0.0170299262,
0.0511954017,
0.0061743613,
0.0441103652,
-0.0453151539,
-0.0197348054,
0.0768135265,
0.0283535291,
-0.0288307387,
0.0233697668,
-0.0107263513,
-0.0189728215,
-0.0402204357,
0.0280186944,
-0.0696584657,
0.0205882005,
-0.0507064536,
-0.0079823136,
0.0046052458,
-0.0257008467,
-0.0129626477,
-0.0058649969,
-0.0866718218,
-0.0546072088,
-0.0151199345,
0.0275987908,
0.0167054497,
0.0732414424,
-0.0402489938,
-0.0294994209,
0.0114529533,
-0.0064325281,
-0.0699326172,
-0.0290813185,
0.0071803252,
0.0235539414,
0.0132326577,
0.038981799,
-0.0354690179,
0.0123292692,
0.0193491504,
0.046053566,
-0.0309793353,
0.0168588851,
0.03649427,
0.0587498695,
-0.0009799832,
0.0368884169,
-0.0018111753,
-0.003129988,
0.0417444259,
-0.0413039476,
-0.0439920463,
-0.0285170358,
0.0261692889,
-0.0011844815,
-0.0836403221,
-0.0011869535,
-0.0076900013,
-0.0193554517,
0.041016873,
-0.0041170483,
0.0122711398,
0.0293344203,
-0.0130091002,
0.0495335497,
-0.0314674862,
0.0047021979,
0.0494416803,
0.003094655,
0.0653679147,
-0.0091200778,
0.0630407706,
0.058376845,
-0.0281511303,
-0.0697279871,
-0.005929925,
-0.066972658,
-0.0575709902,
0.0281336531,
0.0199395902,
0.0269956216,
-0.0079881139,
0.008930631,
-0.0033468341,
-0.0252477676,
-0.0001984057,
0.0275978372,
0.0340653881,
-0.0099249603,
0.0513206199,
0.0551292151,
-0.0036687234,
0.0036764629,
0.0666269809,
0.0460517816,
0.0269195121,
0.0284750368,
-0.0120498445,
-0.0376953706,
-0.0106659792,
-0.0219154451,
0.0137989642,
-0.0169295538,
0.0417131484,
-0.0262876805,
-0.0671030059,
-0.0301815942,
0.0197162051,
-0.0223453045,
-0.0012298687,
-0.0024653499,
0.0432264693,
0.0254813191,
-0.0439297594,
-0.0225742012,
0.0277769007,
-0.0166528542,
-0.0468080267,
-0.0096132159,
-6.322889339e-33,
-0.0198680013,
-0.0445094332,
0.0682319105,
0.0229207333,
-0.0022852749,
-0.0061967438,
-0.0194490943,
0.0077247061,
-0.0357876495,
-0.0085117072,
-0.0288684797,
0.0395406149,
-0.0067047896,
0.0201599691,
-0.0130249942,
-0.0331640281,
-0.0080921743,
0.0333502553,
-0.0221818574,
0.0028132028,
0.0274873674,
0.0017862333,
0.0516438372,
-0.0512136333,
0.0135705583,
-0.0142796356,
0.009791309,
0.0675835311,
-0.0226303097,
0.0504229181,
0.001927419,
-0.0188292731,
0.0463630445,
-0.0192830451,
0.0076356907,
0.0220756661,
-0.1255715489,
-0.0107109696,
0.0404371582,
0.0116817141,
-0.0581414029,
-0.0170875322,
0.0033151861,
-0.0254209898,
0.0682506561,
-0.0417839959,
0.0035848524,
-0.033535663,
-0.0170980487,
-0.0031275507,
-0.0332882106,
0.0537315942,
-0.0282752533,
-0.0092801359,
0.0229460336,
0.0208234731,
0.0035456154,
0.0558437742,
-0.0164989065,
-0.0060817227,
0.0064144558,
0.0186527893,
0.0317615196,
0.0441371128,
0.0123565225,
0.0138712702,
0.0000432697,
-0.0130591849,
-0.0707108453,
0.0030025125,
-0.0195235554,
0.0296536367,
0.0066587511,
0.0189441629,
0.0384856649,
0.0495131873,
-0.0918543786,
0.0106865121,
0.0016630117,
0.0646887422,
-0.006662,
0.0384634957,
-0.0348777659,
-0.0199856386,
-0.0375233628,
0.0026534188,
-0.0532434843,
-0.0118333781,
0.0210484713,
-0.0172888637,
-0.0353176109,
-0.0266906451,
0.0379050598,
-0.0395774953,
-0.0042765322,
0.0481494591,
0.0010942065,
-0.0021070754,
-0.0284947027,
0.0713298097,
-0.0451455787,
-0.0037289618,
0.0086311623,
-0.0231153909,
-0.0083921961,
0.0374729484,
0.0515551344,
-0.0078413924,
-0.0410639867,
-0.0269899331,
-0.0545708798,
-0.0010070197,
-0.0451641604,
0.0395329669,
0.0377888717,
0.047257401,
0.0181500632,
0.0726447478,
0.0151274567,
0.0097961742,
-0.032109879,
0.0001048119,
0.0088620381,
-0.0059848763,
-0.0120888734,
0.0145312995,
-0.0210528392,
-0.0349665768,
0.0231250077,
-0.0534123778,
0.0061845393,
0.0557627492,
2.836e-7,
0.0638366342,
0.0397294015,
0.0097497394,
0.0905867442,
0.007724938,
0.0087460177,
-0.0151027916,
-0.0351290964,
0.0402418636,
-0.0373830646,
0.0172107033,
0.0740556493,
0.002434093,
0.0420974493,
-0.0603451245,
-0.0095205819,
-0.0073833661,
-0.0309185442,
-0.0406949446,
-0.0214478076,
0.0610708036,
0.0902421623,
-0.0034044508,
0.0002004721,
0.0213825703,
-0.0558888465,
0.0377808623,
0.0223072711,
-0.0134268086,
0.0363561325,
-0.0125542348,
0.0388274007,
0.0027277786,
0.030762732,
0.0375983641,
0.0150351962,
-0.0074481796,
0.0628693551,
-0.00852188,
0.0049898028,
-0.0210775007,
-0.073521167,
0.0176049098,
-0.0185405668,
0.1144450307,
-0.0345881283,
-0.0411802456,
0.0168154053,
-0.0226982795,
-0.0212787259,
-0.0110899191,
-0.0004073587,
-0.0132498425,
0.0168141834,
0.0365969986,
-0.0465376489,
0.0081788767,
-0.0764417127,
-0.0199992657,
0.0055691935,
-0.0142079974,
-0.012904685,
-0.0081885671,
-0.0124651724,
0.0208162703,
-0.0553043894,
-0.031008834,
2.695326813e-34,
0.0402913913,
0.0028558073,
0.0119930822,
0.0566596501,
0.0691830292,
-0.0065237507,
0.0010934995,
-0.0235865414,
0.0498639829,
-0.0991335139,
-0.0129779642
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.09620v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.09620v3 | AI-Augmented Surveys: Leveraging Large Language Models and Surveys for Opinion Prediction | 2023-05-16T17:13:07 | 2024-04-07T02:10:04 | Junsol Kim, Byungkyu Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) that produce human-like responses have begun to
revolutionize research practices in the social sciences. We develop a novel
methodological framework that fine-tunes LLMs with repeated cross-sectional
surveys to incorporate the meaning of survey questions, individual beliefs, and
temporal contexts for opinion prediction. We introduce two new emerging
applications of the AI-augmented survey: retrodiction (i.e., predict year-level
missing responses) and unasked opinion prediction (i.e., predict entirely
missing responses). Among 3,110 binarized opinions from 68,846 Americans in the
General Social Survey from 1972 to 2021, our models based on Alpaca-7b excel in
retrodiction (AUC = 0.86 for personal opinion prediction, $\rho$ = 0.98 for
public opinion prediction). These remarkable prediction capabilities allow us
to fill in missing trends with high confidence and pinpoint when public
attitudes changed, such as the rising support for same-sex marriage. On the
other hand, our fine-tuned Alpaca-7b models show modest success in unasked
opinion prediction (AUC = 0.73, $\rho$ = 0.67). We discuss practical
constraints and ethical concerns regarding individual autonomy and privacy when
using LLMs for opinion prediction. Our study demonstrates that LLMs and surveys
can mutually enhance each other's capabilities: LLMs can broaden survey
potential, while surveys can improve the alignment of LLMs. | [
0.0291662831,
0.1829934269,
-0.0210066028,
-0.0176071972,
-0.051101841,
-0.0015342656,
0.0316088535,
-0.0180846285,
0.0538636744,
-0.022843508,
0.0347784497,
-0.0627223328,
-0.0284952372,
0.0027861088,
-0.0248348806,
0.0119817564,
0.0313406326,
0.0249824747,
0.0362763219,
-0.0452117175,
-0.0100124162,
0.0098208012,
0.0084641827,
0.0464021154,
-0.0233853199,
0.0067397421,
-0.0336771794,
-0.0349735543,
0.0136274612,
-0.0238947701,
0.0268887077,
0.0450526923,
-0.0071819141,
0.009386234,
0.0000020713,
-0.0335930325,
0.0053905873,
0.0007777485,
0.0139642982,
-0.0041831811,
0.0591712929,
0.0264530331,
-0.006726841,
0.0203890968,
-0.0664686933,
0.0118430667,
0.0444044396,
0.0058416906,
0.0525618903,
0.0015943011,
-0.0067641409,
-0.0293141808,
0.010198025,
-0.0220591184,
0.0040171226,
0.0103883538,
0.0458904691,
-0.0822594538,
-0.0449553169,
0.0025004174,
-0.0026610612,
0.0100483792,
0.0048571387,
-0.0140279494,
-0.0269059483,
0.0278771799,
-0.0178805105,
-0.0399640203,
-0.0097246654,
0.0243048854,
0.0762686431,
-0.0369610488,
-0.0006623994,
0.0129642449,
-0.0110971723,
0.0528128445,
-0.0666292161,
0.0026718078,
0.0175678674,
0.0178933814,
0.0297897775,
-0.0116505818,
0.0150586814,
0.0539436303,
-0.0061926893,
0.1041828766,
-0.0021976575,
-0.0226776022,
-0.0009447261,
0.0170747787,
0.0227989946,
-0.0221266393,
0.0539845154,
-0.0051690745,
-0.001046515,
0.0215473846,
0.0171004776,
-0.0082356967,
0.0298073161,
-0.0316677839,
0.0326442383,
0.0277624466,
-0.0246907361,
0.0291766841,
0.0376716591,
0.0445670113,
0.00863529,
-0.0228269361,
-0.0059425458,
0.0050194156,
-0.0615243688,
0.0009717814,
0.0191338453,
0.0117779477,
-0.0368757173,
0.0598891117,
-0.040361587,
-0.0134531148,
-0.0435608327,
0.0172340292,
-0.0364147276,
0.0075849816,
-0.0154432757,
0.0019335024,
-0.0734682158,
0.0638292208,
-0.0183169488,
0.053877335,
-0.0113796797,
-0.0237496868,
0.0229376666,
-0.002371703,
-0.0031325789,
-0.0061109802,
0.019773934,
0.0249555577,
0.026446199,
0.047749389,
-0.013156848,
-0.019221209,
-0.0395803973,
-0.0498609282,
0.0245509874,
-0.061292313,
0.085105896,
-0.0143172387,
0.0053241877,
-0.0320460051,
0.0044759568,
0.0375906006,
-0.036368072,
0.0466701053,
0.0146152638,
0.0327845588,
-0.0190737564,
-0.0036299697,
0.1001883224,
0.0392152406,
-0.0049732141,
0.0316481516,
0.0166577231,
-0.0125844302,
0.0061113602,
0.0107638938,
0.0105113098,
0.0571693555,
-0.0529214777,
0.0294741094,
-0.0362929143,
-0.0261693951,
-0.0223020017,
0.0625455081,
0.0409367159,
-0.0312299114,
0.0854939222,
0.0712141842,
-0.0484103113,
0.0585520156,
-0.0041583288,
-0.0084492229,
0.0050407192,
-0.0218651444,
-0.0432054438,
-0.0019817296,
-0.0296015497,
-0.0360729434,
0.0016847408,
0.0160946772,
-0.0144875739,
-0.0538708754,
0.0069021056,
-0.0073640556,
0.0599670485,
0.0468868166,
0.0228430703,
-0.0319863036,
0.0100710848,
-0.0295285508,
0.0207954943,
-0.0452263877,
-0.0013023203,
-0.0173158608,
0.0555466712,
0.0676508173,
0.0059715719,
-0.0016233398,
-0.0230766982,
-0.0411844887,
0.0104482854,
0.0263039861,
0.0419952236,
-0.023299465,
-0.0134722069,
-0.0069267116,
-0.0139966002,
0.0706753954,
0.0441545211,
0.0180985983,
0.010241433,
0.0154752778,
-0.000910126,
-0.0669952258,
0.0084806299,
0.0171357114,
-0.0259150639,
-0.005595969,
0.0148980431,
0.0091784559,
0.062632516,
0.0427973419,
-0.000567016,
0.014399847,
0.0474386998,
-0.016540369,
-0.0535440519,
-0.0307118446,
-0.0113530057,
0.0026658631,
0.0198587179,
0.0106831733,
0.0202096403,
0.0560127869,
-0.0316653363,
-0.0191481318,
0.0521007441,
0.0241958667,
0.0526963957,
-0.0274064876,
0.0013499901,
-0.0227978304,
0.0013777042,
-0.0404278412,
0.0398097336,
-0.0506988093,
-0.0053469245,
-0.0238808077,
-0.0822514072,
0.024785772,
0.0023359307,
-0.0587095954,
0.007498553,
0.0308620259,
0.0286306664,
0.0398792364,
-0.002860503,
-0.0284025446,
-0.0313245021,
-0.0955542251,
0.0202556085,
-0.0039861188,
0.0029433635,
-0.0008811709,
-0.0063965949,
0.0131341061,
-0.0074274219,
-0.0351835527,
-0.0263132993,
-0.0214929935,
0.059549965,
0.0224198792,
0.0121207731,
0.0203328077,
-0.0221939683,
-0.0497203916,
-0.0570887551,
0.0016699913,
0.017157333,
-0.0163467471,
0.0196050107,
-0.0164211094,
-0.1056043133,
0.0219891798,
-0.0176034681,
-0.0417137221,
-0.0202905703,
-0.0238743145,
0.0028555635,
0.0397585258,
0.0154690137,
0.0239320584,
0.0612894967,
0.0386747643,
-0.0518396385,
-0.0095569249,
-0.0498977527,
-0.0121759316,
-0.0287671331,
-0.0235228743,
0.001454473,
0.0449079014,
0.0312604681,
-0.0263656843,
-0.0282592997,
0.0336974151,
-0.0435008965,
-0.04074293,
-0.0305803977,
-0.0035270383,
0.0085339025,
0.0557349771,
-0.0178403091,
-0.0402012095,
0.039944306,
0.0424477719,
0.0344503112,
-0.0112125119,
-0.0177410729,
-0.0244223792,
0.0286667086,
0.0332609527,
0.0142834345,
0.0001379548,
0.0288704801,
-0.0626193732,
-0.0252245013,
-0.0301529188,
-0.0740956143,
0.0254132729,
-0.0462550819,
0.0083390996,
0.0258057993,
-0.04373293,
-0.0150952544,
-0.1201379225,
-0.0400373675,
0.0045139887,
0.0114947129,
-0.0146512603,
0.0051584677,
-0.0042610392,
0.0148139363,
-0.0385098308,
0.0140106054,
-0.0041923476,
0.019460097,
-0.0036973392,
0.0366128162,
-0.0188059397,
0.0210398249,
-0.0046166871,
-0.0075939805,
0.0168674197,
0.0569598824,
0.0563216284,
-0.022639161,
-0.0004906705,
0.0218743589,
0.023678802,
-0.0299539622,
0.0050852075,
0.0221915171,
-0.0309192818,
0.0280602016,
0.0828653947,
0.0324663892,
-0.0264723096,
-0.0303519852,
0.0178103503,
0.0104731917,
0.0422921032,
0.005280131,
-0.0738361403,
0.0166344307,
0.0074756285,
0.0133131761,
-0.0549510121,
-0.0552677214,
0.0122057088,
-0.1445013434,
0.0153569588,
-0.0103106834,
0.010302959,
0.0057449373,
-0.0660467446,
0.0490024239,
-0.040128801,
-0.0224155467,
-0.0439964123,
0.049435176,
0.0104242396,
-0.0025245575,
-0.0503781363,
-0.0202125348,
0.0280109774,
-0.0180997513,
0.0561347827,
0.0933500752,
0.1061419919,
-0.0130599812,
-0.0177627169,
0.030103609,
-0.0037806581,
-0.0225890446,
-0.0108689815,
0.0567258969,
0.0154376924,
-0.0134327784,
-0.0452293865,
0.0531164408,
-0.0118938452,
0.0155788893,
0.0095321843,
0.0525647067,
-0.0266022887,
-0.0381426215,
-0.0001463928,
0.0462605357,
0.0207035057,
0.0503625385,
-0.0236869082,
-0.0720273107,
-0.0012161178,
-0.0508068241,
0.023035191,
-0.0046390272,
-0.0180793777,
-0.0044408664,
-0.0104585877,
-0.0155946491,
-0.0320218317,
-0.0390788168,
0.0271447599,
-0.0150765013,
0.0597590916,
0.0052672932,
0.0867365375,
-0.0444631651,
-0.0340588503,
-0.0169518106,
-0.0460018292,
0.0049958914,
0.0144773321,
-0.0305890925,
0.0238198731,
0.0255276635,
-0.0147132659,
-0.0075851232,
-0.0638906658,
-0.0361578241,
0.0858863592,
0.0211680252,
0.0145495571,
0.0323594585,
-0.0046358588,
-0.0136693576,
0.0716711432,
0.0569793098,
-0.0043266998,
0.0040389942,
-0.0020037559,
0.0836453512,
-0.0055823177,
0.028848242,
0.0090990011,
-0.0025433491,
0.0288521126,
-0.0129102422,
-0.0624293387,
-0.0445068404,
0.0362226255,
-0.0007243576,
0.0358923897,
0.0135744093,
0.0228099301,
-0.0156948436,
-0.0388974212,
-0.0222349502,
-0.022806162,
-0.0120986048,
-0.0499530286,
0.0347803421,
-0.0077320412,
-0.0243056584,
0.0232867859,
-0.0149688572,
0.0417136997,
-0.0688549802,
0.0424894989,
0.0062114163,
0.0422960408,
0.0135623869,
0.0042699147,
0.0218435079,
0.0085602114,
0.023072416,
0.0502174124,
0.0083795497,
0.0339270718,
-0.020535456,
0.0078683263,
0.0183517989,
-0.0138200009,
-0.0687982515,
-0.0479987785,
-0.0355905443,
0.0301517919,
-0.0559451021,
-0.0144306868,
-0.0131322276,
0.001361265,
-0.0240719188,
-0.0202302355,
0.0252903774,
0.0290136803,
-0.0362354778,
0.0421388038,
-0.0226992685,
-0.0360993929,
0.0211615171,
0.0300054401,
0.0028980684,
0.0460657999,
0.0123359971,
-0.0237487778,
-0.0292960685,
-0.0229101833,
0.009595843,
-0.0029873,
-0.0007998233,
-0.0259592477,
-0.0495735593,
-0.049192667,
0.0234497655,
-0.0258761439,
0.0066673178,
-0.0249762908,
-0.0319910832,
0.0112033263,
-0.0303139426,
0.0431332514,
-0.0765349567,
0.0137738492,
-0.0742548257,
-0.0328052342,
-0.0607495643,
-6.485394821e-33,
-0.0217309408,
-0.0236753244,
-0.0113656428,
-0.0706730708,
-0.0308444686,
-0.0204926785,
-0.0320132598,
0.0099842548,
-0.0215834882,
0.0097650075,
-0.018725859,
0.0072639678,
0.011760965,
0.0483945087,
0.0604460053,
-0.0252369884,
0.0597548671,
-0.016124662,
0.0041336757,
0.007367094,
0.0178352296,
-0.0030160216,
0.0098722791,
-0.1075077578,
0.03651575,
0.0228522662,
-0.0265344009,
-0.0178437941,
-0.0143803582,
0.0151819158,
-0.0298923571,
0.0334872194,
0.0225393549,
-0.0379612409,
0.0065925657,
0.0878857449,
-0.0521588847,
-0.0240602884,
-0.0155199273,
-0.0211072024,
0.0389837697,
-0.0126228156,
-0.0323579647,
-0.0049399384,
-0.0461884104,
0.0194472913,
0.0265221447,
-0.0424296185,
0.0237821061,
-0.0074883942,
0.0181546267,
-0.0308462474,
-0.0399898961,
0.0245876089,
-0.0647940189,
0.1014611572,
0.0053811804,
0.0503418446,
-0.0450474806,
0.0485077053,
0.0152382832,
-0.0214148927,
0.0270750783,
-0.0255175531,
0.0581718758,
0.0454462953,
0.0668679252,
-0.0135282669,
-0.0425905325,
0.0018587915,
0.0260741338,
-0.0343075804,
0.0150421113,
0.0590102859,
0.0089275371,
-0.0429097116,
0.0069989231,
-0.010244213,
0.0466952994,
0.0045106863,
0.0637069494,
0.0021967751,
-0.0467260778,
-0.0470396802,
-0.0609014258,
-0.0819798484,
-0.020927459,
-0.0052709063,
0.0203050133,
0.0120411795,
-0.0328748189,
0.0074994811,
0.0321395434,
-0.0515750684,
-0.0412145071,
0.0079763792,
-0.0304118786,
-0.0053669168,
0.0114212437,
0.0187535174,
-0.0376916379,
0.0203003399,
-0.0220903605,
0.0181534514,
0.0343810767,
-0.0102097122,
0.0155773899,
0.0047808653,
-0.1026176736,
-0.0395558737,
-0.0260986984,
0.0290959924,
0.0527404733,
-0.0000173576,
0.04747881,
0.0177304149,
0.0239090845,
0.0319240838,
0.0158071462,
0.065736644,
0.0051425118,
-0.055123575,
-0.0169822238,
-0.0234593917,
-0.0352422446,
-0.0299933534,
-0.010623184,
-0.0080048991,
0.001843037,
-0.0228888392,
-0.0212066751,
-0.0259586032,
2.69e-7,
0.0322546251,
0.0414469428,
-0.0292214137,
-0.0098301489,
-0.0005824239,
0.0393333808,
0.0135408044,
-0.0031638825,
0.0240509342,
0.0223197173,
0.0141031127,
-0.0138713634,
0.0359197184,
0.0054628849,
-0.0515086688,
-0.0117276516,
-0.0181417782,
-0.0186716802,
-0.0700896829,
0.0372123867,
0.0429451093,
0.1068802699,
0.0769600496,
-0.0095989062,
-0.0434145518,
0.0027466421,
0.0376573913,
-0.0461797453,
-0.067717053,
0.0045165089,
-0.0129820593,
0.053204082,
0.0011228359,
0.0261320006,
-0.0230244305,
0.0034821921,
-0.0248259753,
0.0514044166,
0.0170451216,
-0.0484080352,
0.0097753517,
0.0291796923,
-0.0050589391,
-0.0132115064,
0.0869731903,
-0.0445598029,
-0.037322443,
-0.0910644084,
-0.046527788,
0.0168034974,
0.0385518633,
-0.0138329025,
-0.0079504903,
-0.0251232591,
0.0040071621,
0.0149133988,
-0.0133643262,
-0.0091269724,
-0.0038145268,
0.0123291248,
-0.0252622906,
-0.059462782,
0.018092325,
0.0543219447,
-0.0177490804,
-0.049171865,
0.0474951044,
2.427101731e-34,
0.0524536707,
0.0199698769,
0.0063767983,
-0.0289028715,
0.0383527912,
0.0004285636,
0.0070431954,
-0.0025485158,
0.0268290285,
-0.0316490903,
-0.0030513646
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.09617v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.09617v1 | Towards Expert-Level Medical Question Answering with Large Language Models | 2023-05-16T17:11:29 | 2023-05-16T17:11:29 | Karan Singhal, Tao Tu, Juraj Gottweis, Rory Sayres, Ellery Wulczyn, Le Hou, Kevin Clark, Stephen Pfohl, Heather Cole-Lewis, Darlene Neal, Mike Schaekermann, Amy Wang, Mohamed Amin, Sami Lachgar, Philip Mansfield, Sushant Prakash, Bradley Green, Ewa Dominowska, Blaise Aguera y Arcas, Nenad Tomasev, Yun Liu, Renee Wong, Christopher Semturs, S. Sara Mahdavi, Joelle Barral, Dale Webster, Greg S. Corrado, Yossi Matias, Shekoofeh Azizi, Alan Karthikesalingam, Vivek Natarajan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Recent artificial intelligence (AI) systems have reached milestones in "grand
challenges" ranging from Go to protein-folding. The capability to retrieve
medical knowledge, reason over it, and answer medical questions comparably to
physicians has long been viewed as one such grand challenge.
Large language models (LLMs) have catalyzed significant progress in medical
question answering; Med-PaLM was the first model to exceed a "passing" score in
US Medical Licensing Examination (USMLE) style questions with a score of 67.2%
on the MedQA dataset. However, this and other prior work suggested significant
room for improvement, especially when models' answers were compared to
clinicians' answers. Here we present Med-PaLM 2, which bridges these gaps by
leveraging a combination of base LLM improvements (PaLM 2), medical domain
finetuning, and prompting strategies including a novel ensemble refinement
approach.
Med-PaLM 2 scored up to 86.5% on the MedQA dataset, improving upon Med-PaLM
by over 19% and setting a new state-of-the-art. We also observed performance
approaching or exceeding state-of-the-art across MedMCQA, PubMedQA, and MMLU
clinical topics datasets.
We performed detailed human evaluations on long-form questions along multiple
axes relevant to clinical applications. In pairwise comparative ranking of 1066
consumer medical questions, physicians preferred Med-PaLM 2 answers to those
produced by physicians on eight of nine axes pertaining to clinical utility (p
< 0.001). We also observed significant improvements compared to Med-PaLM on
every evaluation axis (p < 0.001) on newly introduced datasets of 240 long-form
"adversarial" questions to probe LLM limitations.
While further studies are necessary to validate the efficacy of these models
in real-world settings, these results highlight rapid progress towards
physician-level performance in medical question answering. | [
0.0552223921,
0.0394988954,
0.0108666234,
-0.0130173387,
-0.0201042872,
0.0213398226,
0.0094180387,
0.0240987316,
0.0194779187,
-0.0297785383,
-0.0196426883,
-0.0442885347,
-0.0152542843,
0.0189051889,
0.0233391952,
-0.022786174,
0.0017018414,
0.0085991556,
0.0436212346,
-0.01658017,
-0.0209828299,
0.0135511486,
-0.0233889502,
0.0406785719,
0.0571516007,
-0.0129693877,
0.039934814,
-0.0147931129,
0.0298055261,
-0.0707572326,
0.0060249115,
0.0383883938,
-0.0043967576,
-0.0168594215,
0.0000019247,
-0.0551808402,
0.0036303855,
0.0409299694,
-0.0678866431,
-0.0212195814,
-0.0110817887,
-0.0262367651,
0.0217439476,
0.0253435802,
-0.0588180684,
-0.0120891044,
-0.0167633016,
0.0569023192,
0.0476080552,
0.0501503684,
0.0036234085,
-0.0189782958,
0.0502270311,
-0.0323961787,
-0.0075120581,
-0.0487907156,
0.0491860956,
0.0103484336,
0.0365139097,
0.0078480057,
0.0077821892,
0.0279026721,
0.0052376497,
0.0310654845,
0.0090077156,
0.060697563,
-0.0223799348,
0.0238896962,
0.0131818177,
0.0930251107,
0.0048279366,
-0.0031889384,
0.0078932745,
0.0183752943,
0.0038890035,
0.0215947907,
-0.058612518,
-0.0026828335,
-0.0213578474,
-0.0065360307,
0.0142416973,
-0.0150173362,
0.044593025,
0.0330759473,
-0.0078145927,
0.0216371939,
0.0218505524,
-0.0257134363,
0.0307835899,
-0.0078191496,
-0.0138741396,
-0.0528249554,
0.0441295579,
0.0516534187,
-0.0577641129,
-0.0043960121,
0.0150773777,
-0.0261678398,
0.0733929351,
-0.0152856121,
0.0269058868,
0.0000645545,
-0.012179411,
0.0635867566,
-0.0223232601,
0.0245656874,
-0.037357714,
0.0404681452,
-0.0673697665,
-0.0147754923,
-0.0312933326,
-0.0312485099,
-0.011904004,
0.0254573654,
-0.0173632801,
0.0076789125,
-0.0506250896,
-0.0190517437,
0.0019795382,
0.006075216,
0.0021845312,
0.0611883141,
-0.0020364716,
-0.0193418078,
-0.0379089229,
0.0461448878,
-0.0489515103,
0.0287443083,
0.0117786555,
-0.0515011512,
0.0004997979,
-0.0042953799,
-0.0146021703,
-0.0160087962,
0.0450436585,
0.0719812438,
0.0010911805,
-0.0076741748,
0.030532917,
-0.0310651828,
-0.0265782699,
-0.0373632088,
0.0020522112,
-0.0806343779,
0.0446909368,
0.022593597,
-0.0119138397,
-0.0422257371,
0.0144047327,
0.0336613134,
-0.0415998362,
0.0680806488,
-0.0185860079,
0.0028127278,
0.0480978712,
0.0430363491,
-0.0183111224,
-0.0044199261,
0.0091270823,
-0.0307498146,
0.0087114247,
-0.0280310642,
0.0253167972,
-0.0093205012,
0.0191458706,
-0.0329532064,
0.0196300894,
0.0542222969,
-0.0050101238,
0.1001530886,
-0.0365550891,
0.0856705904,
-0.0088699982,
-0.0445776023,
0.0274963118,
0.0763073936,
-0.0140310237,
0.0037682825,
0.0236055963,
-0.0387366414,
0.0092263771,
0.00507008,
-0.0144044161,
0.0064068479,
-0.0111740939,
-0.0098791318,
-0.0135358032,
-0.0034842871,
-0.0376299433,
-0.0358702987,
-0.0248735156,
0.0037908456,
-0.0319018364,
0.0196712278,
0.0469759405,
-0.0191012044,
-0.0127987079,
0.0383177325,
0.0212191027,
-0.0016665357,
-0.0055824276,
-0.0512151979,
0.0147696994,
0.0644960701,
0.05827168,
-0.0371553302,
-0.0307902545,
-0.0218242444,
0.0166951884,
-0.0059097651,
0.0432957597,
-0.0391217992,
0.0197246596,
-0.0332199596,
0.0109324129,
0.0123880692,
-0.0014579719,
-0.0256171152,
0.0137426164,
0.026023725,
-0.0147539461,
-0.0470459871,
-0.0133041898,
0.0478728563,
-0.0746654794,
-0.0368198864,
0.0129524963,
-0.0104075829,
0.02326506,
0.0016400592,
-0.0062623732,
0.0481132008,
0.0549178533,
-0.0453788675,
-0.0425244756,
-0.0417953804,
-0.0343276747,
-0.0471497178,
0.0340709276,
-0.0411875322,
-0.0285291243,
0.0036424473,
-0.0561834536,
-0.0343287215,
-0.0512513444,
-0.0391898341,
-0.0038108134,
-0.0017355998,
-0.0211154874,
0.0399578325,
-0.0023188645,
-0.0899899974,
0.0190582573,
-0.0322719887,
0.014070672,
0.0407779701,
-0.0362392068,
0.0006668739,
-0.0374482758,
-0.0054629422,
0.0132458601,
0.0061552036,
0.0155167021,
-0.0178404022,
-0.0069651064,
-0.04414526,
-0.0512919575,
-0.1087003648,
0.0026994545,
0.0053750635,
0.0044644922,
0.0273792148,
-0.0023383254,
0.0074608768,
-0.0163366366,
-0.076894626,
-0.0266617406,
0.0418211706,
0.0231784601,
0.0475793406,
0.0526260138,
0.009298766,
-0.0332858413,
-0.025717685,
-0.0359381251,
0.0184841473,
-0.0023044033,
0.0244160853,
-0.0144538293,
-0.0444761179,
-0.0560464859,
0.0074023772,
-0.016148001,
-0.0142316716,
0.0178444292,
-0.0223900229,
-0.0270099752,
0.0842318907,
0.0042757136,
0.010840375,
0.0385343283,
0.0289526954,
-0.0346644148,
0.028479021,
-0.0253672786,
-0.0277466867,
-0.0070976205,
-0.027985571,
0.0153876217,
0.0504312851,
0.0299669281,
-0.0066864081,
-0.0174160078,
0.0127015868,
-0.0083896695,
0.0025400687,
-0.0456371494,
0.0162209254,
-0.0275548473,
0.048593346,
0.00372303,
-0.0217481479,
0.1206451282,
0.0016904122,
0.021369243,
-0.0701673999,
-0.0087422114,
-0.044743076,
0.0200779587,
-0.0205059573,
0.0208940003,
-0.0013203037,
0.0147148529,
-0.04622145,
0.0022290214,
-0.022360716,
-0.0737176463,
0.0634794459,
-0.0272727814,
0.0288622733,
0.0098962625,
-0.0752785653,
-0.046492286,
-0.0517232642,
-0.0503350794,
0.0241510533,
-0.0006216412,
0.0120498529,
-0.0485510044,
-0.000605065,
-0.0046419334,
0.0243449099,
0.0083178394,
-0.0250644535,
0.0025303385,
0.0577596575,
0.0543083586,
0.0458626598,
0.0154791577,
-0.00809588,
0.0661505684,
0.0694666132,
0.0096911611,
0.010670037,
0.002764154,
-0.003687792,
0.0123398956,
-0.0248394962,
0.0016181539,
0.0241017509,
0.0402062647,
-0.0676677972,
0.0069219563,
0.1146184206,
0.0329800025,
-0.0240718834,
0.0149504589,
-0.025954105,
0.0076068733,
-0.004460488,
0.0449156575,
-0.0409576148,
-0.0544433258,
-0.015430579,
0.0559647866,
-0.0106652332,
-0.0230146442,
0.0222261306,
-0.0811657533,
0.0118658775,
-0.0162704606,
-0.0314558782,
-0.0157796778,
-0.0396665297,
-0.0109597417,
0.0017135369,
-0.0040395642,
0.0001037281,
-0.0025478879,
0.0023460879,
0.0060931444,
-0.0332573652,
-0.0695171729,
0.0785166845,
-0.0324158259,
0.0532706939,
0.0694769248,
0.0364928581,
-0.031067783,
-0.0277245529,
-0.0068735792,
-0.0232924689,
0.0174924321,
-0.0001250812,
0.0786042735,
0.0116072567,
0.0042941947,
-0.0561405122,
0.0594349802,
-0.0430702865,
-0.0105994968,
0.0043625655,
0.0878243148,
-0.0335460715,
-0.0406115204,
-0.0448987968,
0.0225580037,
-0.0198663492,
0.0606033206,
0.0096414238,
-0.007843581,
-0.0297725964,
-0.0060913526,
0.0176468194,
0.0018531159,
-0.0159983318,
0.0341122076,
0.0320550688,
0.0282686464,
-0.0708258525,
-0.0369369239,
0.0735601336,
-0.0093762344,
0.001479815,
0.0388062261,
-0.0068532494,
0.0059614345,
-0.0405209288,
0.0430555865,
0.0097783934,
0.0257511605,
-0.0640740842,
-0.0240740459,
0.065902032,
-0.0074211238,
-0.0321787074,
0.0060101021,
-0.0246301424,
-0.0118144145,
-0.0176180229,
0.0610082,
0.015512458,
-0.0090218326,
-0.0427534729,
-0.0544911698,
0.0337585695,
0.0401279368,
-0.0382736288,
-0.0192400217,
0.0157748014,
-0.0228828937,
-0.0106942803,
0.0275936089,
-0.0350257829,
0.0174566563,
0.02108768,
0.0296273902,
-0.016137898,
-0.053458456,
0.0416598767,
0.0508884862,
0.0251102541,
-0.0034804647,
-0.0044174921,
0.0068639102,
0.0282356553,
0.0062703933,
0.0114868758,
-0.0139281638,
-0.0105192969,
0.0420300849,
-0.025613429,
-0.0082906969,
0.0042303177,
-0.0338770598,
-0.0200339612,
-0.0603771135,
0.0362253748,
0.029601125,
0.0027944511,
0.0431507044,
-0.023042649,
-0.0302600525,
0.0168946814,
0.0032008032,
0.0536183938,
-0.0048949081,
0.0701953918,
0.0109386137,
0.0290486719,
-0.0066217766,
0.0466590188,
-0.0865710974,
-0.0803429484,
-0.0065712919,
0.0377071053,
0.0336923897,
0.0134932818,
-0.0095525235,
0.0109388782,
-0.0150049618,
-0.0409991294,
-0.013642773,
-0.0172203593,
0.0120991208,
0.0935367867,
0.0238286275,
-0.0057191099,
0.0110460557,
0.0955509171,
0.013659385,
0.0580122471,
0.0218524504,
-0.0281596929,
-0.0442193449,
-0.0262810029,
-0.0085439337,
0.0054372689,
-0.0458138324,
0.0339154229,
-0.0683660209,
-0.0348678343,
0.0046132263,
-0.0131996544,
-0.0108535402,
-0.0329612754,
0.0551040582,
0.0412206501,
0.0125363292,
-0.0064496598,
-0.0351554863,
0.0740826577,
-0.0528109893,
-0.0229194127,
-0.0115448786,
-5.959317385e-33,
0.0100861629,
-0.0342426971,
0.0271368083,
-0.0601364188,
-0.0021382319,
0.0285905581,
-0.0437706597,
-0.0158418659,
-0.0341391452,
0.0503249504,
-0.049614355,
-0.000881228,
-0.0104889935,
0.0352003798,
0.0055796118,
-0.0782526508,
0.022991389,
-0.0025937096,
-0.0292427465,
0.0323928148,
-0.0315033123,
0.0493781418,
-0.0002981913,
-0.0570212379,
0.0085588172,
-0.0069266809,
0.0401025414,
0.0136426305,
-0.0623460896,
0.0672597364,
-0.0224965028,
0.017318815,
0.0619502291,
-0.0296868309,
-0.0080367504,
0.0035816266,
-0.0811806619,
-0.0085096015,
-0.0055095488,
-0.033275567,
-0.0573698916,
-0.0222195853,
0.0522382222,
-0.0009562584,
-0.0180290528,
-0.007765145,
0.0243960712,
-0.0431205705,
-0.0207925364,
-0.0568519235,
-0.0001612539,
0.0336105749,
-0.0020396588,
-0.0307606664,
-0.055563055,
0.0284338146,
-0.0394079648,
0.0731917396,
-0.0039930544,
-0.023353938,
0.0367023572,
0.0260890964,
0.0282581039,
-0.0344798751,
-0.020807568,
0.0490925424,
0.004663398,
-0.0217543487,
-0.0523195341,
-0.0177424662,
-0.0669499859,
0.0338516459,
0.0873985738,
0.0327269472,
0.0281241369,
0.0089221904,
-0.1002080515,
0.0558398515,
-0.0512243807,
0.0556843691,
0.0163943544,
-0.0226762816,
-0.0491835624,
-0.0096642403,
-0.0462596007,
0.0153778847,
-0.0284620486,
-0.0074087214,
0.0409152843,
-0.0276905112,
0.0006560994,
-0.0017066626,
0.0022170765,
-0.0311724953,
0.0006840894,
-0.0065628225,
0.0236118287,
-0.0072031892,
-0.0051643183,
0.02005326,
-0.0603753105,
0.0377751291,
0.0204430148,
-0.0165039878,
0.0365684852,
0.033427868,
0.01369204,
-0.0590646341,
-0.0417142101,
-0.0162841547,
0.0028904765,
0.0062928777,
0.0045135752,
0.0616799034,
0.0230256654,
0.0430035517,
0.006337475,
0.0463167243,
-0.0244144015,
-0.0041851373,
-0.0453023426,
-0.0287902281,
0.0192203559,
-0.0123202596,
-0.0552854203,
0.0233222693,
-0.0263717081,
0.0367773958,
0.0019262272,
-0.0547714047,
-0.0241707433,
0.0101938043,
2.651e-7,
0.111840941,
0.0636240244,
0.0096566984,
-0.0338433497,
0.0255790949,
0.0313814431,
-0.0043167514,
-0.0029778231,
0.0046598972,
-0.0181793179,
0.0238214303,
0.0237770602,
0.0230253283,
0.0453526601,
-0.0666179433,
-0.0042126779,
-0.0932364389,
-0.0134263197,
-0.0248811878,
-0.0400758125,
0.0608977042,
0.0921805277,
-0.0310734939,
-0.0436413214,
0.0203666892,
-0.0293768756,
0.0416780002,
-0.0233934056,
0.0143089648,
0.0332557969,
0.037817385,
-0.0035557263,
0.0226929933,
0.0617148541,
-0.0223056693,
-0.0205186009,
0.0169788804,
0.1000824347,
-0.0405845605,
-0.0002650073,
0.0104496926,
-0.0298260711,
0.0411173478,
-0.0516580641,
0.0754165724,
-0.0605238415,
-0.0669575706,
-0.0148888063,
-0.0248399526,
-0.0283987373,
0.0689103305,
-0.0288459565,
-0.015749801,
0.0301679913,
0.025273487,
0.0090681408,
0.0110490173,
-0.0624062903,
-0.0139148152,
0.0216670521,
-0.0392589979,
-0.0282560885,
0.0199933741,
-0.0134613095,
-0.0047498532,
-0.0588228442,
-0.003484457,
2.349881395e-34,
0.0186225045,
0.0139923524,
0.0199787859,
0.0448053665,
0.0121373395,
0.0070791938,
0.0066991276,
-0.0173120014,
0.0316004865,
-0.0861737207,
-0.000420384
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.09612v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.09612v1 | Large Language Models are Built-in Autoregressive Search Engines | 2023-05-16T17:04:48 | 2023-05-16T17:04:48 | Noah Ziems, Wenhao Yu, Zhihan Zhang, Meng Jiang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Document retrieval is a key stage of standard Web search engines. Existing
dual-encoder dense retrievers obtain representations for questions and
documents independently, allowing for only shallow interactions between them.
To overcome this limitation, recent autoregressive search engines replace the
dual-encoder architecture by directly generating identifiers for relevant
documents in the candidate pool. However, the training cost of such
autoregressive search engines rises sharply as the number of candidate
documents increases. In this paper, we find that large language models (LLMs)
can follow human instructions to directly generate URLs for document retrieval.
Surprisingly, when providing a few {Query-URL} pairs as in-context
demonstrations, LLMs can generate Web URLs where nearly 90\% of the
corresponding documents contain correct answers to open-domain questions. In
this way, LLMs can be thought of as built-in search engines, since they have
not been explicitly trained to map questions to document identifiers.
Experiments demonstrate that our method can consistently achieve better
retrieval performance than existing retrieval approaches by a significant
margin on three open-domain question answering benchmarks, under both zero and
few-shot settings. The code for this work can be found at
\url{https://github.com/Ziems/llm-url}. | [
0.0247269347,
0.0663955584,
0.0069262949,
0.0236736238,
-0.0072636213,
0.0251378138,
0.0257281717,
0.0101044253,
0.0154685015,
-0.0631952286,
-0.0112904124,
-0.0492366962,
-0.0705281869,
0.021390019,
0.0248524453,
-0.007704346,
0.017215291,
-0.0318198204,
-0.007253326,
-0.0282256138,
-0.0218535494,
0.0284855496,
0.0241978988,
0.009883794,
0.0157092996,
-0.0002775527,
-0.0332048349,
0.024189068,
-0.0383311659,
-0.0318418629,
0.0279315021,
0.0330068991,
0.0534403734,
0.0486585833,
0.0000016855,
-0.0586562157,
-0.0182871595,
-0.0087281866,
-0.0469865054,
0.0160593111,
-0.0061880322,
-0.0009597378,
0.0295172911,
0.0350687951,
-0.0117988447,
-0.0221870858,
0.0110830693,
0.0292089339,
0.0503065102,
0.0754829198,
0.0109072998,
-0.0416862257,
0.060781166,
-0.0377124101,
0.0362631902,
-0.0512504503,
0.0236617029,
-0.0100830104,
0.0094489502,
0.055869218,
0.0120354919,
0.043680463,
0.0264092125,
-0.0170661025,
0.0228912998,
0.0313523859,
-0.043040961,
-0.008044472,
0.0177585743,
0.0765059367,
-0.0317122675,
-0.0245165844,
0.0131677268,
0.0254994091,
-0.0387891009,
0.0374206677,
-0.0643007755,
0.0360591337,
0.0116753122,
-0.0031609058,
-0.0137739666,
-0.0058072959,
0.0209739488,
0.025551606,
-0.0038365158,
0.0367782973,
0.0384267792,
-0.0437648855,
0.0306961574,
0.0324782841,
-0.0043757516,
-0.0429710038,
0.0044858898,
0.0569447204,
-0.0309639201,
0.0160414632,
-0.0204395447,
-0.0318468995,
0.0336899944,
-0.0520633347,
0.0116618155,
-0.0042497655,
-0.0197155271,
0.0781777501,
-0.0607941151,
0.0592621341,
-0.0619810373,
-0.0027336238,
-0.0577858984,
-0.0415466987,
-0.0124561666,
-0.0281536803,
-0.0507180355,
0.0439070836,
-0.020039944,
-0.0298691466,
-0.0019541567,
0.0491805449,
0.0106496131,
-0.000680716,
-0.0122879036,
0.0346573479,
-0.0413297899,
-0.0152772246,
-0.0379223786,
0.0297005605,
-0.0429958217,
0.0127422372,
0.0106694773,
-0.0559647568,
-0.008760524,
0.0260130018,
0.0361320525,
-0.0446599498,
0.0097539639,
0.0504078455,
-0.0173489098,
-0.0275877062,
-0.0432329103,
-0.0470319875,
0.0596723929,
-0.0227514785,
-0.0014259829,
-0.0697402954,
0.0323213451,
0.0164428633,
-0.0049695144,
-0.0587978587,
0.0056828442,
0.049351681,
-0.0129043674,
0.0414100513,
0.0131324762,
0.0104373079,
0.0472772568,
-0.0057262881,
0.0207513776,
0.0612090603,
-0.0112087624,
0.0404659025,
0.0549161732,
0.0088344431,
0.0477678925,
0.009500064,
0.0476484261,
0.0239521526,
0.0167493932,
0.0519377142,
0.0266607068,
0.0477412082,
0.0290861297,
0.0677550137,
-0.0210244022,
-0.0312119555,
0.022961909,
0.0480488911,
0.0381021276,
0.031734895,
0.0585472323,
-0.0131252967,
-0.0030077423,
-0.0315556489,
-0.0301146638,
0.0323023535,
-0.0309292134,
-0.0003864674,
0.0620073676,
0.0110721942,
-0.0709396377,
0.0049865339,
-0.0026308072,
-0.0183366388,
-0.0376469381,
0.017474791,
0.0536428615,
-0.0082924468,
-0.0425065607,
0.0406877995,
0.0120849004,
-0.0135410763,
0.0451189168,
-0.0515420735,
0.0150583601,
0.0315247588,
0.056655407,
-0.0073336083,
0.023570871,
-0.0318321735,
0.0135914683,
0.0151134618,
0.0454334728,
-0.0326550417,
-0.0105240019,
-0.0362126492,
-0.0437958874,
-0.0363663286,
-0.0176154114,
0.0224358831,
0.032090392,
0.0386025719,
0.0639877841,
-0.0650514066,
0.0017974699,
0.0308246296,
-0.0664375275,
-0.0468593948,
0.0245707147,
0.0022731235,
-0.0026921551,
0.0017328941,
-0.0073092808,
0.0199855715,
0.0473908707,
-0.0265005808,
-0.0415089466,
-0.0320339538,
-0.0208037738,
-0.021549657,
0.0271079205,
-0.0247791484,
0.0248413868,
0.0420011505,
-0.014652838,
-0.0324143358,
-0.0031504058,
-0.0189644564,
0.0239742715,
-0.0636309981,
-0.0109961173,
0.0179497916,
0.0199257676,
-0.0432666875,
0.0514021069,
0.0173433777,
0.0364945829,
0.0186796412,
0.0101098018,
0.00300689,
-0.0666954443,
-0.0389220938,
0.0003135775,
-0.0137207508,
0.0437407866,
0.0422477871,
0.0071658655,
-0.0573282279,
-0.0207986347,
-0.0841875449,
0.0064526051,
-0.0530645773,
-0.0112470686,
0.0118315369,
0.0163729805,
0.0079999724,
-0.0204959083,
-0.0483202226,
-0.0123294136,
0.0437424034,
0.0347333401,
0.0180486385,
0.039580863,
0.0061900769,
-0.0166055933,
-0.044525899,
0.0131443515,
0.0395731367,
-0.0053999918,
0.0339428894,
-0.0409487635,
0.0308448579,
0.000928129,
0.0127921086,
-0.0089154812,
-0.008241063,
-0.0190829877,
-0.0645915121,
-0.0326884389,
0.0827814266,
0.0234473329,
0.0313255265,
0.0277830865,
0.00807581,
-0.1033537909,
0.0076782624,
-0.045296289,
-0.0326083153,
-0.0400378741,
-0.0006913334,
0.019271953,
0.0091741616,
-0.0280465502,
-0.0051288432,
-0.0039180885,
0.0188352,
0.0244386606,
0.0001184307,
-0.0777715594,
-0.0093583269,
0.0100748474,
0.050038062,
0.0053363093,
-0.0384537838,
0.0739461258,
-0.0128456745,
-0.0053421734,
-0.0176553018,
0.0001447195,
-0.0588722304,
0.0307247546,
-0.0054113474,
0.0233081728,
-0.0074041486,
-0.0080346512,
-0.0082201399,
0.0484029502,
0.0000102058,
-0.04519476,
0.0318915732,
0.0035794163,
0.0512658432,
-0.0096902018,
-0.0704390928,
-0.0649138242,
-0.0672960281,
0.0058868709,
0.038319651,
-0.0320549235,
-0.0063362205,
-0.0582663156,
0.0203186274,
0.0350972787,
0.0243364703,
-0.0259533562,
-0.0236567799,
-0.0069540497,
0.0496641099,
0.076216273,
0.0041196928,
-0.0047411537,
0.0026144078,
0.0225144681,
0.0359178334,
0.0509938486,
-0.000062903,
-0.0050139925,
0.0105944863,
0.0307073593,
-0.0506322272,
0.0095247878,
-0.0031283679,
0.0112860249,
0.0007471999,
-0.0575949177,
0.1118443534,
0.0324495733,
-0.0620433651,
-0.0488552377,
-0.0051662596,
0.0194716919,
0.0357691869,
0.0507877655,
-0.0522512682,
0.0017381428,
0.0113055669,
0.0559777692,
0.0223232321,
-0.0098686246,
0.0231144894,
-0.1651542336,
0.0167977531,
-0.0172056071,
0.0124981953,
-0.0014783223,
-0.0670039132,
-0.0018098267,
-0.0078017162,
-0.0168697666,
0.0380717851,
-0.0390581675,
-0.0049858848,
0.0328999385,
0.0530724674,
-0.0424497128,
0.027935626,
-0.0483117178,
0.0021471214,
0.0488433987,
0.001240968,
0.0121029615,
-0.0221577566,
0.0473165512,
-0.0523787141,
-0.0107153216,
-0.0065534902,
0.0255069584,
-0.0211187731,
0.006672129,
0.0000705921,
0.0329572707,
-0.0441032536,
0.0281950589,
-0.0055698617,
0.0718797073,
-0.0273549035,
-0.0043271352,
-0.0390499048,
-0.0609986074,
-0.0134454444,
0.0726896524,
0.0158972684,
-0.013033174,
-0.0392832309,
-0.0267510228,
0.0071405186,
-0.022370141,
-0.042848561,
0.0071210768,
-0.0076343771,
0.0164534003,
-0.0602834262,
-0.0480014272,
0.0292398389,
0.042662289,
-0.0149194794,
-0.0065502306,
-0.0179750267,
-0.0045826458,
-0.0378249474,
0.0178147946,
-0.047303047,
0.0115805548,
-0.0780816823,
-0.0124495141,
0.0659116283,
-0.0374197699,
-0.0483555421,
-0.0050157178,
-0.0459117927,
-0.0575708263,
-0.0317326933,
0.0474223122,
0.0218930822,
0.04966975,
-0.0326971561,
-0.0549965911,
0.0476785749,
0.0459353775,
-0.032379806,
-0.005698177,
-0.0133385574,
0.0111407954,
-0.015682904,
0.0370054767,
-0.0932694823,
0.0087981662,
-0.0119244661,
0.0396696888,
-0.0134220552,
-0.0726644471,
0.0354226045,
0.0360659547,
0.0613482073,
0.0130344862,
0.0590019636,
-0.0224222802,
0.030791007,
-0.0045818528,
-0.0189984497,
-0.0282777697,
0.0219276324,
0.0438863374,
-0.021620566,
0.0018512214,
0.026371384,
0.0336397141,
0.0499941744,
-0.0437397547,
-0.0213327426,
0.0375506356,
0.0140111092,
0.0195221249,
0.0157710668,
-0.0242910013,
0.0196264386,
0.0330829062,
0.0693591982,
-0.0462539531,
0.0322094224,
0.0163725391,
0.0125174858,
-0.0290877186,
-0.0082800565,
-0.0843407065,
-0.0641320497,
-0.0578994378,
-0.0021733488,
0.0461078137,
-0.0220646113,
0.0032674454,
-0.0273524094,
-0.0251481049,
-0.0445648879,
-0.0190033764,
0.0078892307,
-0.0303071532,
0.0422992595,
0.0252037328,
-0.0167853627,
0.0231356211,
0.0717426613,
0.027453417,
0.0440015718,
-0.0149804661,
-0.0133649111,
-0.0183924921,
0.0105640488,
0.0252526775,
0.0016983873,
-0.0191820785,
0.0068943314,
0.0313589573,
-0.0563829616,
0.0223944858,
-0.0315235741,
0.0060675563,
-0.0089063542,
0.0559723675,
0.1010559052,
0.0074491352,
0.0009928613,
-0.0356797911,
0.037376862,
-0.0514969938,
-0.0478101112,
-0.0364036523,
-6.269600506e-33,
-0.0069155805,
0.0003004429,
-0.0008377021,
-0.0462186448,
0.00518568,
0.0038200265,
-0.0188273806,
-0.0113940481,
-0.0654702559,
-0.0353197642,
-0.0166624524,
-0.0109786894,
0.0040210946,
0.0377168842,
0.0243381299,
-0.0274953395,
0.0515297428,
-0.0283125658,
-0.0162445027,
0.0278561004,
0.0355878398,
0.0383410603,
-0.004728151,
-0.0305733774,
-0.0104337875,
-0.048064582,
-0.0003449137,
0.0351230949,
0.024118606,
0.0747376308,
-0.0341543183,
0.0374903046,
0.0179940239,
-0.0220615249,
0.0129337106,
0.0192766264,
-0.1083314195,
-0.0138980579,
-0.0395565629,
-0.0100835366,
-0.0111224093,
-0.0235481262,
0.0459816083,
-0.029149875,
0.0013692081,
0.0090630809,
0.0288116205,
0.0272467453,
-0.0155668491,
-0.0651256889,
-0.0201149583,
-0.0156206973,
-0.0190719832,
-0.0206547119,
0.0203692857,
0.0360040478,
0.0167297628,
0.0451223291,
-0.0226348471,
-0.0009417778,
-0.0304656979,
0.0526928939,
0.0350767635,
0.0168145131,
0.0001233499,
0.0484402142,
-0.0179428216,
-0.009474515,
-0.0229923092,
-0.0057182265,
0.0162849743,
0.0157072488,
0.0201870427,
0.0463870727,
0.0244813897,
0.0056108101,
-0.0511798896,
0.0516789556,
0.0287937224,
0.0439902134,
0.0258626137,
0.0286286194,
-0.0151506569,
-0.0121238697,
-0.0590935349,
-0.0032931198,
-0.0606503151,
-0.0332941711,
0.0500026457,
0.0492428094,
-0.017379107,
-0.0142661948,
0.0768506825,
-0.0504183061,
-0.0315849446,
0.073443085,
-0.0191369988,
0.0112546477,
-0.009543255,
0.0067123612,
-0.0271290075,
-0.0259299316,
0.0097423932,
-0.0070071942,
-0.0374655612,
0.0215612631,
-0.0128618302,
-0.0015867313,
-0.0675431862,
-0.0009368336,
-0.0397089086,
0.0128642777,
0.0007997353,
0.0024304506,
0.0126471296,
0.0326456241,
0.0009075889,
0.0424429663,
0.0121458983,
0.0069066868,
-0.0299062692,
-0.0295088254,
0.03177315,
0.0025497638,
-0.015242734,
0.0376318209,
-0.057202097,
0.0322607756,
0.0060500638,
-0.0654216781,
0.0073924204,
0.0389564522,
2.519e-7,
0.038959682,
0.0427151918,
0.0138641261,
0.0440176055,
0.0124969622,
0.0168452095,
-0.0022556421,
0.0243222471,
0.0541924536,
-0.0331741087,
-0.0065409518,
0.0181716178,
0.0357596874,
0.0154509423,
-0.0996075198,
0.0074606324,
-0.0852580965,
-0.0248675607,
-0.0503600501,
-0.0424750708,
0.0342446789,
0.0892331749,
-0.008393744,
0.0002333296,
-0.0148607604,
-0.0894889608,
0.0806076825,
0.0293943528,
-0.0028848823,
0.0176363606,
-0.0042668511,
0.0509664677,
0.0212409962,
-0.0234427303,
-0.0190772433,
0.0395226255,
0.0265716314,
0.0420261323,
0.0059686573,
-0.0495299958,
-0.0030953782,
-0.0528777391,
0.0052417247,
-0.0550033674,
0.0891803056,
-0.014780622,
0.0113094281,
-0.0147683052,
-0.031356018,
-0.0297762062,
0.0416630693,
-0.0528911203,
-0.0107198386,
0.0032799661,
0.0084240828,
0.0140651586,
0.0113779875,
-0.0979813039,
-0.0075088749,
-0.01837264,
-0.0540983491,
-0.007739814,
-0.0395778716,
0.0300613809,
0.0013743287,
-0.0057495851,
0.0091882963,
1.916482138e-34,
0.0438099131,
0.0155339651,
-0.0130199958,
0.0224702805,
0.0215030145,
-0.0026372054,
-0.0295516513,
0.0156019665,
0.0161599461,
-0.1259551048,
-0.0101699913
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.09598v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.09598v1 | Boosting Event Extraction with Denoised Structure-to-Text Augmentation | 2023-05-16T16:52:07 | 2023-05-16T16:52:07 | bo wang, Heyan Huang, Xiaochi Wei, Ge Shi, Xiao Liu, Chong Feng, Tong Zhou, Shuaiqiang Wang, Dawei Yin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Event extraction aims to recognize pre-defined event triggers and arguments
from texts, which suffer from the lack of high-quality annotations. In most NLP
applications, involving a large scale of synthetic training data is a practical
and effective approach to alleviate the problem of data scarcity. However, when
applying to the task of event extraction, recent data augmentation methods
often neglect the problem of grammatical incorrectness, structure misalignment,
and semantic drifting, leading to unsatisfactory performances. In order to
solve these problems, we propose a denoised structure-to-text augmentation
framework for event extraction DAEE, which generates additional training data
through the knowledge-based structure-to-text generation model and selects the
effective subset from the generated data iteratively with a deep reinforcement
learning agent. Experimental results on several datasets demonstrate that the
proposed method generates more diverse text representations for event
extraction and achieves comparable results with the state-of-the-art. | [
0.0126421619,
0.0406891145,
0.0177389476,
0.0631841198,
-0.002666034,
0.0186850205,
-0.0383798555,
0.0148644513,
0.0214983374,
-0.0512851514,
0.0141253779,
0.0295252874,
-0.0654582828,
0.0674221739,
-0.0161375031,
-0.0472866595,
0.063556537,
0.0183202997,
0.0373477302,
0.0504819378,
0.0246983785,
0.0361241214,
-0.01812388,
0.0222107023,
-0.0207615886,
0.0184639804,
-0.0118172877,
-0.0135616241,
0.0547219217,
-0.0684168264,
0.0318595581,
-0.0200035404,
0.05162986,
0.0244599339,
0.0000018554,
-0.0332780667,
-0.024111677,
-0.0086994078,
-0.0634418726,
-0.0035281212,
0.0028083541,
-0.0268227998,
0.0010724327,
-0.0287651923,
-0.0213186815,
-0.0485742353,
0.0240243338,
0.1040280312,
0.0185452923,
0.1338205934,
-0.0303085484,
-0.0308380965,
0.042921003,
-0.017562205,
-0.0051772632,
-0.0268426053,
0.0324259438,
0.010558676,
0.0089546964,
0.0111087356,
0.0404421799,
-0.0031502258,
0.0282816384,
-0.0071475739,
0.0131881498,
0.0191927589,
-0.0222461484,
0.0044337357,
-0.0269514695,
0.064298071,
-0.0157412998,
-0.0197495017,
0.0518689901,
-0.0267882682,
-0.0002859629,
-0.0133164534,
-0.0335264169,
0.0120827332,
-0.0009562705,
0.0555232167,
0.0932892561,
0.0233751498,
0.0260843001,
0.0123695107,
0.0228641257,
0.0324497819,
-0.0025821375,
-0.0199219026,
-0.0397526175,
0.0343586206,
0.0224848185,
-0.0479897074,
0.0403310396,
0.0254279543,
-0.0473918021,
0.0092698373,
-0.0694361106,
-0.0313511565,
-0.032597933,
-0.0944764987,
-0.0245118812,
0.0258173887,
-0.0035448745,
0.0541852973,
-0.0297244471,
-0.0009137884,
-0.0108924303,
0.0160094574,
-0.0210286174,
-0.0052343421,
-0.0358124375,
0.0488675535,
-0.0205055047,
0.0517834984,
-0.0800446123,
-0.0084403977,
-0.0250543039,
0.0044869864,
0.0120164054,
0.0077156685,
-0.0345294885,
0.0242040381,
-0.0724692941,
0.0001852685,
-0.0129530933,
-0.0226870179,
-0.0671972707,
0.0161377192,
0.0278130528,
-0.038746547,
-0.0402199253,
0.0166682731,
0.0515871868,
-0.0174985137,
-0.0168925915,
0.0270351637,
-0.0466114841,
-0.0335477665,
-0.0799969584,
-0.0317957252,
0.0140893562,
-0.0118340682,
-0.0256467089,
-0.03947597,
0.049916368,
-0.0511030182,
-0.0295698084,
-0.0592828915,
0.0383797251,
-0.0246903282,
-0.0294718985,
0.0389512405,
-0.0577680245,
-0.0270234887,
0.0078567844,
-0.0059928084,
-0.0149053698,
0.0657512248,
0.0640265197,
0.0445771962,
0.0575962625,
0.0449631549,
-0.00260077,
0.0075995345,
0.0226513483,
-0.0163361654,
0.0244254507,
0.016141912,
-0.035707552,
-0.0030213115,
0.0693273693,
-0.0316850357,
-0.0500203408,
0.0094376002,
0.0277511422,
-0.0152353607,
-0.0161131322,
-0.0130823627,
0.0053666285,
0.005231177,
-0.0062180758,
0.0024594376,
-0.0254731551,
-0.0238843877,
-0.0017555273,
-0.0011347278,
0.014732332,
-0.0168797355,
-0.0173917525,
-0.0348962918,
0.0269367769,
-0.0227345694,
0.0236098077,
0.0228602197,
0.0205003563,
0.0281040687,
-0.0370171778,
0.0060873297,
0.0389672592,
-0.0270066205,
0.0304976832,
0.0135901216,
0.0319615416,
0.0046464331,
0.0355118103,
-0.0648854673,
-0.0430319756,
-0.0241531171,
0.0065375143,
0.0453072228,
0.0274238139,
-0.0360246226,
0.0584787689,
-0.0370479375,
-0.0102236094,
-0.0301355161,
0.0324070267,
-0.0201470796,
0.0226673912,
-0.0002160423,
0.0120388083,
0.024382351,
-0.0524856225,
0.0573726967,
-0.0080021778,
-0.0858805478,
-0.0019938997,
-0.019673517,
0.0270821545,
0.0031677852,
-0.0088328877,
-0.0293810721,
0.0410978459,
-0.0594892502,
-0.0279811732,
0.0271345619,
-0.0373668224,
-0.0815954581,
0.0145968981,
-0.0079330914,
-0.0616028532,
0.0110810678,
-0.0643772259,
-0.0522038378,
-0.0070486539,
0.0076085944,
-0.0003651209,
-0.0242824703,
-0.0025578735,
0.0276336353,
-0.0125076855,
-0.0329156518,
0.0866287872,
0.0264695249,
-0.0281238761,
-0.0061254739,
-0.000012262,
0.0106686149,
-0.0472187772,
-0.013454454,
0.016630752,
0.0046867314,
-0.0222830996,
0.0530976653,
-0.0292106606,
-0.0607350282,
0.0292901378,
-0.0406390019,
0.0414658114,
-0.0364095569,
0.054698173,
0.0629544184,
0.0253831558,
-0.0130750686,
-0.0335313827,
-0.0322634317,
-0.1037577763,
-0.0011855362,
-0.0151885683,
0.0534406379,
0.035881158,
0.0085840123,
-0.0804590359,
0.0223030671,
-0.0210352633,
0.0314971618,
0.0367816053,
-0.0347079225,
-0.0357564054,
0.0475498438,
0.0124569582,
0.0464541726,
-0.0187937785,
-0.017107429,
-0.0190020986,
-0.0046957545,
0.0025780308,
0.0648353696,
-0.0098438226,
0.0508183278,
-0.0139185507,
-0.0110470513,
-0.0528271943,
0.0297863223,
-0.0619565286,
0.0627480745,
-0.0404892862,
-0.013841249,
0.0482237078,
0.0464802347,
0.0064032357,
0.0393109843,
-0.0347858928,
-0.0305880178,
-0.0196177829,
-0.0249945745,
-0.0000572114,
-0.025800569,
-0.0330586843,
0.0321043395,
-0.0543318465,
0.0083565041,
0.0998060405,
0.0367060304,
-0.0181639399,
-0.0631973967,
-0.0269812103,
-0.0516903214,
0.0251730587,
-0.0101139015,
0.0056543392,
-0.0002499727,
-0.0404533669,
0.009666807,
-0.0501977839,
0.0257759336,
-0.0098996926,
0.038769681,
-0.0277362,
0.0314581692,
-0.0159122162,
-0.0330247693,
-0.0672504157,
-0.0400502831,
0.0191230271,
-0.0060330415,
-0.0174583048,
0.0277100559,
-0.0523780994,
-0.0195962638,
-0.0030208046,
0.0512339994,
-0.0074035595,
-0.0044270675,
-0.0183235873,
0.0850581527,
0.0525940694,
0.0130186044,
-0.0266893152,
-0.0103766508,
-0.0150114354,
0.0630687252,
0.0126069402,
0.0043831691,
-0.0349653475,
-0.0035020544,
0.003849186,
-0.0519126393,
0.0124051664,
-0.0025607436,
0.0607316196,
-0.0897307396,
-0.0054155965,
0.0756314248,
0.0153540261,
0.0032575091,
0.006759569,
0.0394170992,
0.0245337896,
0.0056568203,
0.0090117594,
-0.0742952079,
-0.0283665247,
-0.0159790646,
0.0116797686,
-0.0100571727,
-0.0296528097,
0.0333069786,
-0.0504923202,
0.013899765,
0.0007708977,
-0.0216825288,
-0.0641221181,
-0.0360066369,
0.0374991037,
-0.0326599553,
0.0117599601,
0.009957239,
0.0050353194,
0.0046641002,
0.0191145223,
-0.0447866358,
-0.0882626623,
-0.016737584,
-0.0383308195,
0.0362762213,
0.0469251983,
0.0453928225,
0.0114033865,
0.0378873236,
0.0012970292,
-0.0070911474,
-0.0169628244,
0.0090290708,
0.0540757924,
-0.0110631306,
-0.0118883653,
-0.0054578651,
0.0735173747,
-0.0136508718,
-0.0365718193,
0.0046789888,
0.0641556084,
-0.0061538755,
0.0152825946,
-0.0034680031,
-0.0316754021,
0.0426518098,
0.0466823876,
0.0030151312,
0.0253042262,
-0.0234725941,
-0.0247290935,
0.0180253088,
-0.095625475,
0.0290085282,
0.0277577899,
-0.0399014205,
-0.0212492794,
-0.0889843702,
-0.0731576681,
0.0046541397,
-0.0079529062,
-0.0129828136,
-0.0015812155,
0.0128638539,
-0.0240275208,
-0.0250244308,
0.0700332224,
-0.0198274627,
-0.0270454288,
0.0134726055,
-0.0030346334,
-0.0314423032,
0.0174835157,
-0.0079559544,
0.0582498536,
-0.0158699304,
-0.0355749652,
-0.0059450688,
-0.0217395704,
0.0041132523,
0.0763426349,
-0.0011429329,
-0.0048063006,
0.0109348036,
0.0148787517,
-0.03879283,
-0.026688803,
0.0438655056,
0.0034858098,
0.0037503054,
0.0149389161,
-0.0331474543,
0.0477860644,
-0.005907082,
0.0644138083,
-0.0702449232,
0.0180802066,
0.0302688666,
0.0040354738,
0.0352819301,
-0.0162762403,
-0.0161116943,
-0.0747714937,
-0.0094942357,
-0.0367073417,
-0.0074258847,
-0.036019899,
0.0536597781,
0.0002719785,
0.0082667693,
0.0032148708,
0.0538210571,
-0.0393453613,
0.0302134957,
-0.0673060715,
0.0173232071,
0.0624448396,
0.0184138548,
-0.0029297166,
0.0220031478,
-0.0308977477,
0.0472717136,
0.0162177458,
0.0241660364,
-0.042743098,
-0.0023433445,
0.0579258054,
-0.0038804871,
0.0066529755,
-0.0251465905,
-0.0578593649,
0.0787411705,
-0.0222339705,
-0.0337754712,
0.0827738494,
-0.0389724113,
0.0636425912,
-0.0123688104,
-0.0173740443,
0.0212763809,
0.0261967424,
0.010708537,
0.0049125128,
-0.0000244063,
0.0136130163,
-0.0257484745,
0.0170627851,
0.0329162106,
-0.0138492128,
0.0705552548,
0.0182968471,
-0.0076130065,
-0.0527850129,
-0.0295764152,
0.0295459852,
0.0755560622,
-0.0223405603,
-0.02271384,
-0.0111534894,
0.0116319945,
0.0152998073,
-0.0114822313,
-0.0273354109,
-0.033702381,
0.0499519631,
0.006116909,
0.0188986715,
-0.0116939405,
-0.0345643759,
0.0103064394,
0.016146902,
-0.0281826109,
-0.0651974753,
-5.998843383e-33,
-0.0253470279,
-0.0160750169,
-0.0022382564,
0.0331827216,
-0.0301246941,
0.0227391776,
-0.0649809688,
-0.0214182325,
-0.0178895388,
0.0413177386,
0.0135074798,
0.0040264507,
0.0168445222,
0.0077360147,
-0.0253122188,
-0.0277231615,
0.0560392551,
0.0047224988,
-0.007730552,
0.0315795764,
0.0472604744,
0.0392128341,
0.0609191097,
-0.1046155915,
0.0570370033,
0.0121141821,
-0.0114862733,
-0.0147787379,
0.0807601362,
0.041341532,
0.0011419774,
0.0317814946,
0.0172596164,
-0.0627909899,
0.0007607806,
-0.0164458081,
-0.1044833735,
-0.0342197046,
0.0158910267,
-0.0135141779,
-0.0311565623,
-0.0219878405,
0.0308071338,
-0.0014192857,
0.0299236681,
0.0169095751,
0.0370396785,
-0.040202979,
-0.0088454075,
-0.0510155708,
-0.0936732069,
0.0498423204,
-0.006134171,
-0.0055505414,
0.0401048101,
-0.0015279995,
0.0278118812,
0.0222861115,
-0.0422200561,
-0.0181366764,
-0.0264487155,
0.0278226957,
-0.0142478142,
0.0169462226,
-0.0453501157,
0.0568406135,
-0.0250613131,
-0.0048753237,
-0.0554401539,
0.0550334863,
-0.0049888208,
0.0770060867,
0.0159260891,
0.076733008,
0.039363578,
0.026551472,
-0.099692598,
0.0439476781,
0.037848562,
-0.0031679554,
-0.0174676385,
0.0252647847,
-0.0452980064,
-0.0000865291,
-0.019080637,
0.0389870256,
0.0053818449,
0.0048705274,
0.0097200368,
0.0391296037,
0.0012210269,
0.0564581342,
-0.0080281263,
-0.017370455,
0.0126897627,
0.0089263134,
-0.0222534053,
-0.0097640995,
0.0028995464,
-0.0042657852,
-0.0557931662,
-0.0346431434,
0.0257298183,
0.0004702498,
0.0327904411,
-0.0122623537,
0.0257511996,
-0.0127186095,
-0.0120113371,
0.0368429273,
-0.0085361125,
0.016281927,
-0.0206032023,
0.035350699,
0.0023541003,
-0.0095108729,
-0.0092305588,
0.0532584526,
0.0283542331,
0.0592030659,
0.0174241364,
-0.0289565735,
-0.0007719624,
0.0384248011,
-0.0094797108,
0.003595314,
-0.0295095295,
0.0320715718,
0.0063088387,
-0.0462258942,
0.0033264526,
-0.0061692167,
2.462e-7,
0.0287289042,
0.0359323621,
0.059170194,
0.0316720679,
-0.0005986516,
0.0437765941,
0.0193315446,
0.0274076257,
-0.0050907806,
-0.0035137327,
-0.006540528,
0.008270029,
0.0358866714,
0.0511403941,
-0.0454533435,
-0.0502861924,
-0.0677509978,
-0.0026054962,
-0.0659130439,
-0.0109593943,
0.0523720756,
0.0709749311,
0.060371004,
0.0037317234,
0.0011282652,
-0.0235760529,
0.0206273906,
0.0169772096,
-0.0564837418,
0.0480928011,
0.0112787709,
0.0391374528,
-0.077887103,
0.0246737227,
-0.0418267921,
0.0439895838,
-0.0147800213,
0.0545364618,
-0.0263878629,
0.0072645484,
-0.0121375872,
-0.0253618676,
0.0087361857,
-0.0320414454,
0.0560519397,
-0.046443861,
-0.018736355,
-0.0048703132,
-0.0726357251,
0.0577770844,
-0.0392675661,
0.0108272135,
-0.036550317,
0.0041536051,
0.0324327908,
0.0235157926,
-0.0455736555,
-0.0744699985,
-0.0121607417,
0.0220006816,
-0.009389176,
-0.0047867214,
-0.0085429819,
-0.0145494873,
-0.0150512615,
-0.0521834232,
0.0026709281,
2.114850942e-34,
-0.003101578,
0.022141777,
-0.0339986011,
0.0174285546,
0.0223818701,
0.003627446,
-0.0076414016,
-0.0165960696,
0.0187275,
-0.0145194652,
0.0135698142
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.09574v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.09574v1 | UOR: Universal Backdoor Attacks on Pre-trained Language Models | 2023-05-16T16:11:48 | 2023-05-16T16:11:48 | Wei Du, Peixuan Li, Boqun Li, Haodong Zhao, Gongshen Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR | Backdoors implanted in pre-trained language models (PLMs) can be transferred
to various downstream tasks, which exposes a severe security threat. However,
most existing backdoor attacks against PLMs are un-targeted and task-specific.
Few targeted and task-agnostic methods use manually pre-defined triggers and
output representations, which prevent the attacks from being more effective and
general. In this paper, we first summarize the requirements that a more
threatening backdoor attack against PLMs should satisfy, and then propose a new
backdoor attack method called UOR, which breaks the bottleneck of the previous
approach by turning manual selection into automatic optimization. Specifically,
we define poisoned supervised contrastive learning which can automatically
learn the more uniform and universal output representations of triggers for
various PLMs. Moreover, we use gradient search to select appropriate trigger
words which can be adaptive to different PLMs and vocabularies. Experiments
show that our method can achieve better attack performance on various text
classification tasks compared to manual methods. Further, we tested our method
on PLMs with different architectures, different usage paradigms, and more
difficult tasks, which demonstrated the universality of our method. | [
0.0349721909,
0.060440056,
-0.0076368609,
0.0511157699,
-0.0477171913,
-0.0088516362,
0.0443786979,
-0.0104570054,
0.0408626311,
-0.0579618961,
-0.0209124554,
0.0181224328,
-0.0002684284,
0.0412110463,
0.070315972,
0.026146397,
0.055541195,
-0.0406238586,
-0.0485273749,
-0.0048988406,
-0.0321312472,
0.005961414,
0.0117388899,
0.0128377005,
0.0230152588,
0.0056343968,
-0.0170665793,
-0.0034156744,
0.0231491365,
-0.0099153258,
0.0274080727,
0.0300176069,
-0.0042405971,
0.042327743,
0.0000021431,
-0.0298566036,
-0.0596013479,
-0.0066725332,
-0.0135110645,
0.02743911,
0.0316036306,
-0.0172805749,
-0.0306862425,
0.036674574,
-0.0548752062,
-0.0060161892,
-0.0046187318,
0.0361758471,
0.0317229331,
0.1040760577,
-0.0167560186,
-0.0162699204,
0.0390034057,
-0.0445433669,
-0.0209616609,
-0.0488274843,
0.0229647588,
-0.0319689251,
-0.0156775657,
0.0262071732,
0.0106417863,
-0.00945812,
-0.0147911999,
-0.0115385037,
-0.0487190522,
0.0331300534,
-0.00249925,
0.0010321875,
-0.0106020672,
0.0596064925,
-0.076756455,
-0.0078809522,
0.0082082916,
-0.0278344341,
-0.0107387062,
0.0026100622,
0.0624875538,
-0.0053679347,
-0.014092369,
0.009362597,
0.043433167,
-0.0104012862,
0.0507628918,
0.0189163834,
-0.0176632963,
0.0209645312,
0.0116263796,
-0.0078619644,
0.0251024496,
-0.0723846331,
0.0136310253,
-0.0613628775,
0.0066324011,
0.0047001373,
0.0105074625,
0.0154777532,
-0.0821174979,
-0.0770425647,
0.03379694,
-0.0498307087,
0.0381117873,
0.0320800543,
-0.0354174227,
0.0328468345,
-0.0244999174,
0.028588729,
-0.030879477,
0.0384609252,
0.0052086636,
0.0311450008,
-0.0172305219,
-0.0102168499,
-0.0265383162,
0.0194144789,
-0.0232969318,
-0.0185301397,
-0.0390063897,
0.0179089345,
-0.0087754121,
-0.0131108668,
-0.0076273913,
0.0010713793,
-0.0329122767,
0.0266965777,
0.0130250975,
-0.0256055798,
0.0136338836,
-0.0157110803,
-0.0471138582,
-0.0579366796,
-0.0130997049,
0.0048190928,
-0.0353852585,
-0.0194365606,
0.0134664215,
0.0883430392,
0.0106311608,
-0.0541133806,
-0.0834031105,
-0.0296863355,
-0.0115216523,
0.0161628798,
-0.0133353211,
-0.0583754741,
-0.0364981778,
-0.028572388,
-0.0099314293,
-0.0383033678,
0.0164254438,
0.0173499621,
-0.0258265473,
0.1057421565,
-0.0112159634,
-0.0477272831,
0.0431885831,
-0.0003424589,
-0.013580001,
0.0576625876,
-0.0130490568,
0.0798273012,
0.0323598981,
-0.0173312146,
0.0353206843,
0.0411053486,
0.0283027794,
-0.0018632399,
-0.0401536115,
0.005759012,
0.0349510312,
-0.0428411104,
0.0128301485,
0.0421933867,
-0.011869668,
-0.0433198139,
0.0717367828,
0.028626306,
0.000580603,
0.0561121181,
0.0102325492,
-0.0191376545,
-0.0456430539,
0.00307947,
-0.0605574101,
-0.0319227502,
-0.0893725529,
-0.0293919519,
0.0431890339,
0.006253168,
0.0006424355,
-0.0371341966,
0.010795339,
-0.0348814167,
0.020170331,
0.0010601209,
0.0582972839,
0.0649361536,
-0.0478173904,
0.0293991324,
0.0067478451,
-0.0161737185,
-0.0280357283,
-0.0674481019,
-0.0486182123,
0.0423454791,
0.059272211,
-0.0362505764,
0.0088991923,
-0.0417352207,
-0.0177270956,
0.0343041681,
-0.0137464805,
0.0277163573,
0.0099533927,
-0.0279546026,
-0.0089467876,
-0.0249138325,
0.0318507329,
0.0352283195,
-0.0025769463,
0.0000554785,
0.0165336002,
-0.0008183007,
-0.0318401642,
0.0390277468,
-0.0268043298,
-0.0846251771,
0.0292314067,
0.0320536382,
0.0203045718,
-0.0182351917,
-0.02817747,
0.0393305793,
0.0374457985,
-0.0240083914,
-0.0101148486,
-0.0469820723,
0.0217160638,
-0.0003938092,
0.0204176586,
-0.0085271653,
0.0206996184,
0.0912149251,
-0.0413675457,
-0.0205125809,
0.0571236089,
-0.0248744078,
0.0428873189,
-0.0197450183,
-0.0074729468,
-0.0007014353,
0.0224277098,
-0.0285397414,
0.0694757104,
-0.0144547466,
-0.0158847477,
-0.0217684396,
0.0226978604,
0.0203736853,
0.0049489695,
-0.0494134389,
-0.0149680385,
-0.0387625359,
0.0197468698,
0.010267823,
0.0030448062,
-0.010907474,
-0.0229641106,
-0.0371903367,
0.0168572478,
-0.0419570692,
0.031122962,
0.0432957821,
-0.0030950014,
-0.0200508535,
-0.0348442234,
0.0049973503,
-0.0246892683,
-0.0368729383,
0.0199633986,
-0.0084078228,
-0.0258321632,
0.0100605367,
-0.0392741933,
-0.0206753258,
-0.0193704069,
0.0786903799,
-0.017549945,
0.0054377504,
-0.0153837726,
0.0316943452,
0.0205661468,
0.0433380827,
-0.0466598459,
-0.0473360717,
0.0230826531,
0.016917374,
-0.0409242138,
0.0684895888,
0.0351878032,
0.0444658361,
0.0733168572,
0.0247973651,
-0.0435771495,
-0.0054684454,
0.0057968339,
-0.0295090619,
-0.0508330092,
0.0166904517,
0.0233335383,
0.0558147728,
0.0576346777,
-0.0007523914,
-0.0186240412,
0.0074181291,
0.0227891132,
-0.0003269206,
-0.0281203426,
-0.0539063886,
-0.0437986143,
-0.0022681803,
-0.0108812544,
-0.0897183791,
0.0524168089,
-0.0391029604,
0.0547610708,
-0.0569785684,
-0.0457342044,
-0.000281459,
0.0340046957,
-0.0025888288,
0.01599163,
0.0334551558,
-0.0386193655,
-0.023801811,
-0.018484477,
0.0175045375,
-0.033675842,
0.0204037037,
0.0041459436,
0.0047180029,
0.0000475414,
-0.0183302164,
-0.0722523779,
-0.0664522722,
-0.0373434164,
0.0076317955,
0.024272861,
-0.0117046544,
0.0049287048,
-0.0125220818,
-0.0156241627,
0.0347402357,
-0.0109406533,
-0.0136363395,
-0.0278698448,
0.0060718469,
0.0493053459,
-0.1110395864,
-0.0024730891,
0.0263415016,
0.009119181,
0.0541987643,
0.0344525278,
-0.0081245732,
-0.0608752072,
0.0151831703,
0.0234630853,
-0.0256582033,
-0.0349163748,
0.0038287865,
-0.0289663523,
-0.0222703721,
-0.0097801434,
0.061082989,
0.0203178972,
-0.0654868707,
0.0010126045,
0.0201054607,
-0.0097951079,
0.0118539892,
0.0135120647,
-0.0697790459,
-0.0406301841,
0.0072918418,
0.0375424437,
-0.0212964155,
-0.0065438906,
-0.0134087093,
-0.1280545294,
-0.0266997274,
0.0290885046,
-0.0468780808,
0.0058431798,
-0.0421951897,
-0.0170917436,
0.0102200834,
0.0085743787,
-0.0125954561,
0.001723612,
-0.0031731823,
-0.0101826917,
-0.0099578099,
-0.0337873176,
0.0126227438,
-0.0232951082,
0.0262639895,
0.0946306959,
0.0119645139,
-0.0190534182,
-0.0088935122,
0.0701566562,
-0.0279608723,
0.0185600314,
-0.0171901137,
0.0722684786,
-0.0199420545,
-0.0202765521,
0.0254606027,
0.0679390058,
-0.0219946168,
-0.0103486618,
0.001071331,
0.0350609981,
-0.026583124,
0.0059907935,
-0.0137520554,
-0.0361851305,
0.0622683913,
0.0377825759,
0.0097279064,
-0.0548800975,
-0.0176544469,
-0.0604870431,
0.0040958007,
-0.0273773745,
-0.0626326278,
0.0196660161,
0.0059295921,
-0.0749135688,
-0.0266763121,
0.0069021313,
-0.0053329058,
0.0191735178,
0.0263741836,
0.0165099446,
-0.0150653832,
0.0108046299,
-0.0535276905,
0.0060157687,
-0.0060610711,
0.0394059904,
-0.0576758273,
-0.0179851279,
0.0204052869,
-0.018928919,
-0.0202799793,
0.0333041176,
-0.0503513888,
-0.0921001509,
0.0081019755,
0.0563505739,
0.0139872553,
0.0083585875,
-0.0374712348,
-0.0727172643,
0.1306909323,
0.0109233009,
-0.0083136754,
-0.0115765613,
0.1069828048,
-0.0572549552,
-0.0004952849,
0.0272534396,
-0.0305702612,
0.0056602694,
0.0710719377,
-0.0068750572,
-0.0221607983,
-0.0060142265,
0.0155697772,
-0.0079132579,
0.1094019413,
-0.0354252905,
0.0207997635,
0.0067300028,
0.0233809724,
0.0058183409,
-0.017102303,
0.0044722687,
0.0334323458,
0.0259593949,
-0.0015215012,
0.0173542928,
-0.0399571434,
-0.0070961192,
-0.0020046351,
0.0034685512,
0.023015162,
0.0597698167,
0.0799901783,
0.0720974803,
0.0141617088,
-0.022961786,
0.0412387438,
0.0092153186,
0.0116846813,
-0.0353846364,
0.0337281749,
0.0061670272,
0.0207950566,
-0.0521242544,
0.0333674811,
-0.0577734411,
-0.0232556611,
-0.0080414265,
-0.0079911947,
0.0444293916,
-0.0333231799,
0.013374364,
-0.0030462826,
0.0061191204,
-0.0276029892,
-0.0011335511,
0.0062032929,
-0.0297701154,
0.007790776,
-0.0141879553,
-0.0181447845,
0.0545200445,
0.077865921,
-0.0213750098,
0.0698938444,
0.0332404003,
-0.0159597397,
-0.0230818428,
-0.0060786786,
0.0184753463,
0.0421337448,
-0.0436954945,
-0.0196218956,
-0.0250988919,
-0.0779284462,
0.0256190766,
0.0099266944,
-0.0100116776,
0.0351113118,
0.0110936165,
0.0599131845,
0.0162227284,
0.0517827831,
-0.08393576,
0.0331475586,
0.0003705233,
-0.0373250172,
0.0168168936,
-5.868458284e-33,
0.0504730232,
-0.0453679673,
-0.0306384005,
0.0284806695,
0.0485818014,
0.032168068,
-0.0187273417,
0.0160891134,
-0.0178016108,
-0.0137125002,
-0.0049361852,
0.0034579881,
-0.0040616668,
0.0221227296,
-0.0252441652,
-0.0053828475,
0.009746532,
-0.0050488072,
-0.0206402969,
0.0199069288,
0.0937702879,
0.0415293612,
0.0463778041,
-0.0513668396,
0.0252685044,
0.0053860461,
-0.0248746332,
0.0054851524,
-0.0227571521,
0.0684800819,
-0.0136327744,
0.0348231494,
-0.0073590931,
-0.0375695787,
-0.0141590768,
0.0582349226,
0.0105699217,
-0.0139751583,
-0.03199476,
-0.0230052862,
0.0096848654,
-0.0630577728,
0.0284496322,
-0.0130964257,
0.0020116495,
-0.0041920403,
0.0239650011,
-0.0224867165,
-0.0272403266,
-0.0381510407,
-0.0270796269,
0.0271018222,
0.0044968799,
-0.0005773773,
0.0056208363,
0.0033629066,
0.0233581029,
-0.0034034264,
-0.0576008148,
0.0372541696,
0.0478982516,
0.0281550512,
0.0474920757,
0.0254117697,
0.0120857339,
0.0739237815,
0.0029744529,
-0.0272489749,
0.0085603511,
-0.0010335705,
0.0201379526,
0.0592093021,
0.0546908863,
0.0476757772,
0.0866687596,
-0.0625095144,
-0.0564027876,
-0.0193313863,
0.0202959683,
-0.0030605462,
0.0468970165,
0.0136482734,
-0.0537646525,
0.0101093184,
-0.0259719305,
-0.0359792896,
-0.0325892866,
-0.0489723012,
0.0065611289,
0.0219008531,
-0.0341078117,
-0.0060158493,
-0.0011605143,
-0.0419289842,
-0.0005984181,
0.0531953461,
-0.0100885136,
-0.0389814749,
-0.0101543088,
0.0039633401,
0.0141183892,
-0.0177917052,
-0.0120129604,
-0.0727003291,
0.0450526364,
0.0072063673,
0.0044671483,
0.0167738199,
-0.0832602531,
-0.0038485588,
-0.0270573292,
0.00888055,
0.0319320001,
0.0455880128,
0.0388807729,
-0.0163256042,
0.0017986775,
0.0294971038,
0.0159319974,
0.0039996556,
-0.0503241532,
0.0448903218,
-0.0246035215,
0.0365207009,
-0.0078630475,
-0.0114999739,
-0.0063481182,
0.0771733746,
0.0425736979,
-0.0427594259,
0.0055041206,
-0.0041572889,
2.982e-7,
0.0312425736,
0.0111387884,
-0.0055071204,
0.0096435323,
-0.0030213741,
0.078745164,
-0.0004397032,
0.0800569579,
-0.0146756694,
-0.0284170043,
-0.0346556194,
-0.0076967557,
0.0513429604,
0.0279926844,
-0.0574073158,
0.0298383422,
-0.0535015054,
0.0363276601,
-0.0425038077,
-0.0089516258,
0.04579065,
0.1044684425,
0.0157268271,
-0.0349169001,
-0.0325870626,
-0.0591134168,
0.0146727273,
-0.0159457494,
-0.0086267274,
-0.0104366504,
0.0403739922,
0.0555228405,
-0.0290387049,
0.0388021283,
-0.0637516826,
0.0192812011,
-0.0611935481,
0.0166851487,
0.0128887501,
-0.0796108693,
-0.0278937258,
-0.0217717886,
0.0058470154,
-0.0260735415,
0.074398987,
-0.0054459162,
-0.0067625777,
-0.0452423729,
0.0045975912,
-0.0105330693,
0.0629428029,
-0.067954652,
0.0097841071,
0.0230766572,
0.0067825383,
0.0115731694,
0.0018477817,
-0.1089344323,
-0.00851849,
0.0034086243,
-0.0196962114,
0.0052259006,
-0.0224268865,
0.0439637378,
0.0194847751,
0.0159575567,
0.0322563127,
2.684869275e-34,
0.007286917,
-0.0368770361,
-0.0147595247,
0.0106573934,
0.0165578704,
0.0026312827,
-0.0020612283,
0.0059282342,
0.0031987482,
-0.0498912372,
-0.0208747219
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.09556v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.09556v2 | Adapting Sentence Transformers for the Aviation Domain | 2023-05-16T15:53:24 | 2023-11-29T14:45:46 | Liya Wang, Jason Chou, Dave Rouck, Alex Tien, Diane M Baumgartner | cs.CL | cs.CL | Learning effective sentence representations is crucial for many Natural
Language Processing (NLP) tasks, including semantic search, semantic textual
similarity (STS), and clustering. While multiple transformer models have been
developed for sentence embedding learning, these models may not perform
optimally when dealing with specialized domains like aviation, which has unique
characteristics such as technical jargon, abbreviations, and unconventional
grammar. Furthermore, the absence of labeled datasets makes it difficult to
train models specifically for the aviation domain. To address these challenges,
we propose a novel approach for adapting sentence transformers for the aviation
domain. Our method is a two-stage process consisting of pre-training followed
by fine-tuning. During pre-training, we use Transformers and Sequential
Denoising AutoEncoder (TSDAE) with aviation text data as input to improve the
initial model performance. Subsequently, we fine-tune our models using a
Natural Language Inference (NLI) dataset in the Sentence Bidirectional Encoder
Representations from Transformers (SBERT) architecture to mitigate overfitting
issues. Experimental results on several downstream tasks show that our adapted
sentence transformers significantly outperform general-purpose transformers,
demonstrating the effectiveness of our approach in capturing the nuances of the
aviation domain. Overall, our work highlights the importance of domain-specific
adaptation in developing high-quality NLP solutions for specialized industries
like aviation. | [
0.0426286422,
0.0489599258,
-0.0262748674,
0.0428877734,
-0.0115020564,
-0.001595495,
0.0152132763,
-0.0270326938,
-0.0494577996,
-0.0988091826,
-0.0128284832,
-0.0136890449,
-0.0352976136,
0.0335507393,
0.0504456498,
-0.0326783024,
0.0297672544,
-0.0240049381,
-0.0167951193,
0.007939213,
0.0241736118,
0.0402462482,
-0.0342294686,
0.0627236515,
-0.0164880138,
0.0255710464,
0.0297671743,
-0.0038100008,
0.0396835804,
-0.0015100945,
0.0574977025,
0.0408290401,
0.0944932252,
0.0143665671,
0.0000021848,
-0.012891992,
0.0016517959,
-0.0324037261,
-0.0334780924,
0.0215907637,
0.0733152106,
0.0036813971,
0.0252215751,
0.0386740603,
-0.0325895846,
-0.0130450688,
0.0097658029,
0.0666646957,
0.0698108003,
0.0684409961,
-0.0305582117,
-0.0604853109,
0.0132024959,
-0.0261949934,
-0.0464906283,
-0.0189777277,
-0.0118264547,
-0.0124108763,
-0.0115445508,
-0.0145628611,
-0.0480437614,
0.047921963,
0.0247786157,
0.0056409999,
0.0853514895,
0.0349599607,
-0.0367832407,
0.0095744496,
-0.0372461341,
0.0410474464,
-0.0006361125,
-0.0271798838,
-0.0306169763,
-0.0028287007,
-0.015733147,
-0.0177642573,
-0.0067839054,
-0.028135594,
0.0180508252,
0.0361685753,
0.0038379354,
0.0276393984,
-0.0028451965,
-0.0280367881,
-0.0523606688,
0.0341794156,
0.0128175896,
-0.057880085,
-0.020233037,
0.0024879752,
0.0130889816,
-0.0236620195,
0.0356403105,
-0.0096776308,
-0.0270379931,
-0.0096156299,
-0.0291072335,
-0.0376814678,
-0.011696904,
-0.0311530717,
0.0071608382,
0.0116575714,
-0.0231368095,
0.0213782154,
-0.0794564933,
0.0138652753,
0.0092922291,
0.0280251298,
-0.0650331527,
-0.0188930649,
-0.0643284768,
-0.0344193205,
-0.0539622009,
0.0328341648,
-0.0533286259,
-0.0338872448,
-0.0617367961,
-0.0158787072,
-0.0069204317,
0.0163254142,
0.0617508255,
0.0489490815,
-0.0694921613,
0.0031273388,
-0.0066583268,
0.0378422998,
0.0088778809,
0.0519928373,
-0.0056038783,
-0.0119657032,
0.0018762464,
0.0387219228,
0.0413062349,
-0.0101512177,
-0.033627063,
0.0657548904,
-0.0522641502,
-0.0166293606,
-0.0551503412,
-0.0011251341,
-0.0019916189,
-0.0141395126,
-0.0064089587,
-0.0368322469,
0.0082787303,
0.014200246,
0.0095693432,
-0.0661093518,
0.0008403179,
-0.0202985555,
-0.0042508487,
0.0658794492,
0.0054095099,
-0.0192586668,
-0.0000035685,
-0.011604704,
0.0558218211,
0.0458008386,
0.0390888937,
0.0174740162,
0.0389074273,
0.0066774376,
0.0163213648,
0.0066355332,
-0.0129682431,
-0.022644816,
-0.0321100317,
0.0295254942,
-0.0410956778,
0.0275499299,
0.0490037985,
-0.025938008,
-0.0034381654,
0.0344031192,
0.0063374196,
0.0118830558,
0.0659636706,
0.0124122631,
0.0590320341,
0.0577225909,
-0.0510388017,
-0.0258504599,
-0.0080714608,
0.0067939823,
-0.0272543766,
-0.0097943107,
0.0296789017,
0.0392077118,
-0.0224327371,
-0.0444648899,
0.0300221518,
-0.0084555978,
0.0227422938,
-0.0116059398,
0.0160959754,
-0.007568616,
-0.0507349707,
0.0670905262,
0.0381401777,
-0.0249052662,
-0.0076814545,
0.0017852248,
-0.0439380407,
0.0580162555,
0.0146285817,
-0.0149128912,
-0.0334273838,
-0.0794384629,
0.0045949202,
0.0546624251,
-0.0008040259,
0.0011342507,
0.0164872389,
-0.0525888614,
-0.0587781928,
0.0035090614,
0.025837183,
-0.0274735931,
0.0011281354,
0.0339743048,
0.0440285392,
-0.0708815232,
-0.0398474,
0.0564632863,
-0.0103866067,
-0.0253714044,
0.0150525924,
0.0373245887,
0.0322242714,
0.0273876879,
-0.0335168168,
-0.0143164033,
0.0290929582,
-0.0463582538,
-0.0404155627,
0.0040025683,
-0.0322120376,
-0.0088707525,
-0.0198892299,
-0.0535287857,
-0.0387750976,
0.0748729706,
-0.0332901999,
-0.0244607143,
-0.0138293169,
-0.0281859767,
0.0262633432,
-0.0072807847,
-0.0141357556,
0.0105601698,
0.0098990444,
-0.0215236172,
0.0471469238,
0.0027026124,
-0.0325331688,
-0.0229710583,
-0.0231941584,
0.0630971342,
0.0164737515,
-0.0350847393,
-0.0079830587,
-0.0172320046,
0.0250404868,
0.0567344204,
-0.0219300725,
-0.0266634226,
0.032609798,
-0.0627401695,
0.0080044046,
-0.0445050336,
-0.0126838703,
0.0081583653,
0.0020215926,
-0.0360495299,
-0.0293621421,
-0.0023833141,
0.0047646197,
-0.0030776751,
-0.0100320559,
0.0420222618,
-0.0084351953,
-0.0398698673,
-0.0400044061,
-0.0224150345,
-0.0259035751,
0.0430388525,
0.0008058318,
-0.0181803163,
-0.0850088522,
0.0702809766,
-0.052303575,
0.0111641604,
0.0105912443,
-0.0705588609,
0.0248634852,
-0.0004676471,
0.0180620048,
0.0492858142,
0.0706328377,
-0.004264534,
0.0293487143,
0.015009555,
-0.0466822274,
0.0214741305,
-0.0425406545,
-0.0002124551,
-0.0330470428,
0.0040931976,
0.0379413515,
0.0425181389,
-0.0096656689,
0.0068932059,
-0.0468429103,
-0.0094251214,
0.0051256367,
-0.01415121,
-0.0064683859,
-0.0120179038,
0.0086493157,
0.0427433811,
0.0199333467,
0.0010378079,
0.0672320276,
0.0091775535,
0.0097013488,
-0.0798222274,
-0.023850577,
0.0037357763,
0.0239014756,
0.0077351267,
0.0033213436,
0.0518573895,
0.0109710721,
-0.0140066352,
0.0084016826,
0.0123264231,
0.0214484315,
0.0173276477,
0.0225125365,
0.0033451312,
0.0058337054,
-0.045382984,
-0.0394570082,
-0.0430399068,
-0.0471259691,
0.0050651794,
0.0065952418,
-0.0175464265,
-0.0730234608,
0.0036108175,
0.0252179243,
0.0361286849,
0.0128162019,
-0.0276986267,
-0.0346798375,
0.037911091,
0.0970067307,
0.0060555218,
0.0331002586,
0.0072524087,
-0.0327037908,
0.0132624479,
-0.0000267717,
-0.0158277228,
-0.0236042868,
-0.0131728631,
0.025168797,
-0.0497400127,
0.0365276523,
0.0340221822,
0.0505839698,
-0.0246796981,
-0.0012404184,
0.0876865909,
0.038155254,
-0.0156811997,
0.0390027761,
0.0444297753,
0.0173348412,
0.0219405144,
0.0346480794,
-0.0543177091,
-0.0605829097,
-0.0425085723,
-0.0084982617,
0.0337509662,
0.0061017876,
0.0297761336,
-0.0726008043,
0.0142206354,
-0.0205050372,
-0.0211501326,
-0.0572711602,
-0.0490125008,
-0.0106822122,
-0.056468267,
0.0465742834,
-0.0176280905,
-0.0314942487,
-0.0072923601,
0.0263644494,
-0.0363223515,
-0.1048230454,
-0.0134788426,
-0.0708314925,
0.0315095,
-0.0056507355,
-0.0109007936,
-0.0155412434,
-0.0222498402,
0.0073789079,
-0.0242875908,
0.0136513682,
0.0120476317,
0.0484399125,
-0.0508819148,
0.0083683906,
-0.0023712839,
0.01788757,
-0.0798170865,
0.0043439362,
0.0248927698,
0.0484459214,
0.0164001361,
-0.0069527039,
-0.0509206876,
-0.0138144838,
-0.0178298857,
0.0429496318,
0.0021176871,
-0.0324915014,
-0.0496953353,
-0.0392787643,
0.0197982453,
-0.068248719,
-0.0476018526,
0.011223916,
0.0353043675,
-0.0387568735,
-0.0449096002,
-0.0455338247,
0.0328910463,
0.0009619158,
-0.0114792492,
0.0074441214,
0.0038281842,
0.0025529566,
-0.0607798696,
0.0208569989,
-0.0243527964,
0.0042947279,
-0.0295333713,
0.0228431802,
0.0436037146,
0.0225336235,
-0.0448064394,
-0.0043052738,
-0.0759372339,
-0.031606026,
0.0298169497,
0.0026692068,
0.0050322753,
0.04036358,
0.0041204276,
-0.0350240134,
0.0632579029,
0.0483739264,
-0.0706475154,
0.0003845268,
0.0097643621,
-0.0568006523,
0.0009259514,
0.0272245184,
-0.0385787785,
0.0165481754,
0.0034499632,
0.0258330554,
-0.0001084043,
-0.040874023,
0.0090590212,
0.0037987195,
0.0265208166,
0.0001446315,
-0.0091199586,
-0.045928482,
0.0328858681,
0.0010889104,
0.0126353158,
-0.0263287146,
-0.0045386716,
-0.0159404688,
0.029611174,
-0.0172634143,
0.0444673933,
-0.0001648163,
0.0225892495,
-0.0605805516,
0.0129390722,
0.0141039966,
-0.0184594039,
-0.0073155728,
0.0270722061,
-0.0056163068,
-0.0408374257,
0.0343917795,
0.0059139682,
-0.021469675,
0.0058178096,
0.0621236153,
0.0281199086,
-0.046846807,
0.0805025622,
-0.067362763,
0.0434725136,
-0.040443819,
-0.0212279968,
0.0498322211,
-0.032929685,
0.0153088095,
-0.0256656036,
0.0269852541,
0.0174990408,
0.0289307479,
-0.0323190726,
0.0062056812,
0.0341034457,
0.0097551951,
-0.009678659,
0.0103596291,
0.0952534974,
0.0014811931,
0.0310241524,
-0.0100492835,
-0.0123408744,
-0.0747573823,
-0.0010626514,
0.0293474812,
0.0094843404,
0.0072652712,
0.0482788831,
-0.0111397458,
-0.0439368412,
0.0326321013,
-0.0288607609,
-0.0244731195,
-0.0541496202,
0.0371341296,
0.0593604408,
0.0371612646,
-0.0295148548,
0.0204827338,
-0.0489306711,
0.0342484601,
-0.0255229324,
-0.0492598526,
-6.692899696e-33,
-0.0091339555,
0.0081609376,
-0.0232352875,
-0.0152169038,
-0.0363123491,
-0.0146700758,
0.0004115393,
-0.0271697268,
-0.0215169359,
0.0072688591,
0.0173010491,
0.0436030775,
-0.0024063929,
0.0304068197,
0.031942267,
-0.0370202623,
0.0861818269,
0.005623491,
0.0042972611,
0.0054056672,
0.0177822243,
0.0307929013,
0.0285462774,
-0.0500280485,
-0.0313928276,
-0.0028000595,
-0.0122836772,
0.0215871893,
0.0481249504,
0.0642378554,
-0.029124856,
0.0981218442,
0.0082915612,
-0.0334656537,
-0.0048236302,
-0.0091027636,
-0.0402312204,
-0.0372609906,
-0.0012150473,
0.0007080699,
0.034368068,
-0.0294919256,
0.0526749715,
0.0066061793,
0.0043169013,
-0.0041933595,
0.0787146986,
0.0042167623,
0.0118260086,
-0.0275356341,
-0.1239353567,
-0.0098452736,
-0.0191363003,
-0.008451134,
0.0434546247,
0.086200811,
0.0074645043,
0.04713016,
-0.0307636559,
0.0227465238,
0.017274864,
0.061137747,
0.0256518535,
-0.0228117425,
-0.0261499118,
0.0509907193,
-0.0304276347,
-0.0019244772,
-0.0599513054,
-0.0241243336,
0.0276824925,
0.0191668235,
0.0439744256,
0.0493433662,
0.0324175172,
-0.0285246987,
-0.060883861,
0.0248765033,
-0.0629351586,
0.0660960972,
0.0395173281,
0.0424101278,
-0.0251965001,
-0.0243817829,
0.0103946198,
0.0213926025,
-0.0142151341,
-0.0089368792,
0.0313446708,
0.0408647209,
-0.0389546975,
0.0371664129,
0.0404173732,
-0.0335929357,
0.022673022,
-0.0084266094,
-0.0031530315,
-0.0001103257,
0.0150612583,
0.0101052299,
-0.0618442185,
0.0403121896,
0.0433802344,
0.0188626591,
0.019467717,
-0.0444903485,
0.0362700373,
0.0322479606,
-0.0405926779,
0.0179789998,
-0.0107574333,
-0.015663268,
-0.0254925266,
0.0152144413,
0.0184682533,
0.0725779757,
-0.0220196471,
0.0126902768,
0.0151976161,
-0.050105989,
-0.0325072668,
-0.0130478991,
0.0108378418,
0.028137356,
-0.0442426987,
-0.0122080268,
-0.0388834588,
0.0327896513,
0.0132797919,
-0.1014455259,
-0.0337027349,
-0.0038742058,
2.67e-7,
0.0350496508,
0.0359729305,
0.05615969,
-0.0113309668,
0.0048403875,
0.026798984,
0.0396814942,
0.0164529942,
0.016305292,
0.015584372,
0.0332944021,
0.0102379499,
0.0249652956,
0.0050899442,
-0.0759407207,
0.0236675963,
-0.0564081036,
0.0159670319,
-0.0613594986,
0.0144887725,
0.1158874705,
0.1114020944,
-0.0368001126,
0.0249985959,
-0.0274925176,
-0.0023148321,
0.0108747799,
-0.0370520912,
0.0022806674,
0.0139336837,
-0.0165055674,
0.0716020912,
-0.0226792842,
0.0257898308,
-0.0416664667,
0.0523529276,
0.0158157032,
0.0072833723,
-0.0275127683,
0.0034525883,
0.0117564723,
-0.0009279828,
-0.0233098827,
-0.0411232002,
0.0431026369,
-0.1216002628,
0.0079541672,
0.0105955508,
-0.0615247823,
0.0544060543,
0.0248736702,
0.0094859963,
-0.0510940105,
-0.0125916153,
0.0265729018,
0.0504710525,
-0.0052282927,
-0.1025551409,
0.0193942096,
0.0626044571,
-0.0340172537,
0.0604250059,
-0.0299952067,
-0.0112527292,
0.0831754357,
0.0105467197,
0.0035756826,
2.310747535e-34,
0.0215503518,
0.0426651277,
-0.030254785,
0.0312978961,
0.0278275367,
-0.040710073,
-0.035790801,
-0.0226109568,
-0.0014848235,
-0.0768159479,
-0.0231649429
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.09550v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.09550v2 | Life of PII -- A PII Obfuscation Transformer | 2023-05-16T15:48:36 | 2023-05-17T12:32:26 | Ajinkya Deshmukh, Saumya Banthia, Anantha Sharma | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.IT, math.IT | Protecting sensitive information is crucial in today's world of Large
Language Models (LLMs) and data-driven services. One common method used to
preserve privacy is by using data perturbation techniques to reduce
overreaching utility of (sensitive) Personal Identifiable Information (PII)
data while maintaining its statistical and semantic properties. Data
perturbation methods often result in significant information loss, making them
impractical for use. In this paper, we propose 'Life of PII', a novel
Obfuscation Transformer framework for transforming PII into faux-PII while
preserving the original information, intent, and context as much as possible.
Our approach includes an API to interface with the given document, a
configuration-based obfuscator, and a model based on the Transformer
architecture, which has shown high context preservation and performance in
natural language processing tasks and LLMs.
Our Transformer-based approach learns mapping between the original PII and
its transformed faux-PII representation, which we call "obfuscated" data. Our
experiments demonstrate that our method, called Life of PII, outperforms
traditional data perturbation techniques in terms of both utility preservation
and privacy protection. We show that our approach can effectively reduce
utility loss while preserving the original information, offering greater
flexibility in the trade-off between privacy protection and data utility. Our
work provides a solution for protecting PII in various real-world applications. | [
0.01264909,
0.1137797758,
-0.042119924,
0.0732321441,
-0.0646893084,
-0.0149461469,
0.0347840823,
0.0162368994,
-0.0087403897,
-0.0047281324,
-0.010302905,
0.0129974876,
0.0148881739,
0.0601635315,
-0.002993789,
-0.0028031566,
0.0517861471,
-0.0180896129,
0.0044397218,
-0.0049291453,
-0.0329127796,
0.0133097423,
0.0661860779,
0.0226573832,
0.0055824677,
0.0041926326,
0.0001157789,
0.0005839583,
0.003099754,
0.007445212,
-0.002596576,
0.0025610947,
0.0286133029,
0.080393739,
0.0000022023,
-0.0396049172,
-0.0555784367,
0.057109531,
-0.0432977527,
-0.0154391639,
0.0733866096,
-0.0360588841,
-0.0152015984,
0.0102381436,
-0.0284787212,
0.0075354157,
0.0681657121,
0.0575835742,
0.0692043528,
0.0725171715,
-0.0245418232,
-0.0448810272,
0.0127811925,
-0.002166254,
0.0099134166,
-0.0302344356,
0.0252248291,
-0.0645363405,
-0.025627289,
0.0373571627,
0.004193855,
0.0374563411,
-0.011348905,
0.0051451386,
-0.0432491116,
-0.0024140636,
-0.0097877933,
-0.0008220153,
0.0245439615,
0.0279178917,
-0.0335949361,
-0.0376566947,
0.0114888148,
0.0191608351,
0.0327582583,
0.0162567291,
-0.0014704402,
-0.0010811886,
0.0121101672,
0.0075806957,
0.0338155814,
0.0209520701,
0.0405268967,
0.0067236149,
-0.0442684144,
0.0389296897,
0.0090134917,
-0.0139721017,
-0.0478925183,
-0.0815554112,
-0.0150278006,
-0.0405432135,
0.0441776924,
0.0063844929,
0.0198071338,
0.0260391161,
-0.0978185534,
-0.0584765449,
0.0028855898,
-0.0394422486,
-0.005233956,
0.0257280171,
0.0230704024,
0.0460402668,
-0.0161111318,
0.0464255325,
-0.016056424,
0.0129649248,
-0.0044358503,
-0.0350998528,
-0.0097030001,
-0.0246586092,
-0.0294195656,
0.0859862342,
-0.0723373741,
-0.0337747075,
-0.0025079427,
0.0690056458,
-0.0158797987,
0.0163514726,
-0.0407449454,
0.0110141225,
-0.0397506356,
-0.0060476339,
0.0173096266,
-0.0080758687,
0.0052663367,
-0.0049648038,
-0.0099443989,
-0.0288625937,
-0.002122897,
-0.0200001802,
0.0187924542,
0.0119111929,
-0.0166065916,
0.0602953881,
0.037739411,
-0.0390611738,
-0.052420076,
-0.0631795228,
0.0395390466,
0.0076947971,
-0.0214232076,
-0.0502150655,
0.0177448876,
-0.013832503,
-0.0280477758,
-0.1054411978,
0.0028354556,
0.0157767422,
-0.0582881756,
0.0898300707,
-0.0184618365,
-0.0243259743,
0.0053780675,
0.0357609838,
-0.0022074215,
0.0388619006,
0.0358017571,
0.022679003,
0.051839821,
-0.0336602964,
0.031068081,
0.0098904278,
0.0140806763,
0.0023580336,
0.0255380552,
0.0113834031,
-0.0109598683,
-0.0432614572,
0.0044195107,
0.018447658,
0.0065256665,
-0.035741128,
0.0390727036,
0.0599904507,
-0.0319452249,
0.0522458665,
-0.058063291,
0.0591298118,
-0.0447897874,
-0.0235471409,
-0.0343609639,
-0.0153956767,
-0.0512013026,
-0.0356545039,
-0.0455207042,
0.0163856726,
0.0164077934,
-0.0121956477,
0.0253851619,
-0.0606064126,
0.0491727628,
0.0115574542,
0.0102052679,
0.0559870116,
-0.0308882874,
0.0553644784,
-0.0116024613,
-0.0489021912,
-0.0048300708,
-0.061646387,
-0.0313007534,
0.0893635899,
0.0736308172,
-0.0336740837,
0.0140514318,
-0.0311938673,
-0.0054905745,
-0.0017503164,
-0.0030918482,
0.0074761701,
0.069898583,
-0.0254460741,
-0.0404225141,
-0.0149167515,
0.0297996607,
0.0276077259,
0.0189887118,
-0.0194427781,
0.0376961417,
-0.0386001393,
0.0243632197,
0.0180987827,
-0.0268114768,
-0.0693918392,
0.0586012751,
0.0140966615,
0.0226809531,
-0.0005555134,
0.0033205894,
0.0089985821,
0.0502383374,
0.0000942489,
0.0286714789,
-0.0224915836,
0.0296022911,
0.0264123976,
-0.0251922552,
-0.0213414729,
0.021404624,
0.0411342196,
-0.0253707785,
-0.0047904891,
0.0104960138,
-0.0324668773,
0.0676981807,
0.0141169922,
0.0130284186,
-0.0098474072,
0.0675064549,
-0.0527677275,
-0.0042356639,
-0.0228028186,
-0.0075140884,
-0.0168695096,
0.0020440295,
-0.0003451214,
-0.0131872194,
-0.0025260225,
-0.0164524447,
-0.0226319749,
-0.0089383293,
0.0086319409,
-0.0164343845,
0.0252907351,
-0.0437318161,
-0.0235318001,
0.0214949045,
0.0130878659,
0.0277712401,
0.0145188691,
0.0562827066,
-0.0144698992,
-0.0141149294,
-0.0353706814,
-0.0421508476,
-0.0429576933,
0.0185331181,
0.0236646254,
0.0167962629,
-0.0530958138,
0.0323534086,
0.0004835136,
0.0071652881,
0.0266364794,
-0.0554791875,
-0.0298896562,
-0.0562121011,
0.0089551425,
-0.0044154846,
0.0294191577,
-0.0187103488,
-0.0012526035,
-0.0129467947,
0.0136512062,
0.0323886238,
0.0536601096,
-0.0053891428,
0.0074859355,
0.0202235393,
-0.0272886325,
-0.0512787551,
-0.013218496,
-0.0220541079,
-0.0104117524,
-0.024847459,
-0.0441425294,
0.0451669842,
-0.0252516661,
0.0021859501,
-0.0149274701,
-0.0247210953,
0.0446589142,
0.00768753,
-0.0436519496,
0.0143944183,
-0.0376447067,
-0.0096034491,
0.0277892854,
-0.0020691098,
-0.0354433209,
0.0834470466,
-0.017608257,
0.0521405078,
-0.0343359523,
-0.0152492234,
-0.001084501,
0.067964673,
-0.0036237361,
0.0368321091,
0.0327884108,
-0.0440749414,
-0.0156648494,
0.036490988,
0.0114803212,
-0.0667075738,
-0.0079178577,
-0.0408128351,
-0.0462765545,
0.0433292054,
-0.0394116454,
-0.0379040055,
-0.0956200436,
0.0310973395,
-0.0192391817,
0.0430056974,
-0.0371873491,
-0.0331277885,
-0.0341054387,
0.0063283239,
0.02917853,
0.0064804433,
-0.0104144337,
-0.0343477689,
-0.0158616118,
-0.001749719,
-0.0412387624,
0.0248460267,
0.0443332382,
-0.0213719886,
0.0627088994,
0.027346883,
-0.0430889092,
0.0364008993,
-0.0209907088,
0.0337713324,
-0.0082674529,
-0.0316475816,
0.0243511833,
-0.0053212671,
-0.0466585942,
-0.0355721563,
0.0699713305,
0.0338257328,
-0.0374069847,
-0.0043011457,
-0.0042878492,
0.0226308908,
-0.0134102115,
0.0172834098,
-0.084797658,
0.0057083974,
0.0304210577,
0.0669071972,
-0.0416249782,
-0.0259796269,
-0.0452307761,
-0.0625176281,
0.0051085693,
0.0192788616,
-0.0100238724,
-0.0361633711,
-0.0795291662,
0.0004929138,
0.0206866264,
-0.0076106763,
-0.0532657504,
0.0175735764,
-0.0366565473,
-0.039006602,
0.0047656884,
-0.0467225164,
-0.0392320789,
0.0015584499,
0.0293293986,
0.0558623262,
0.0224615205,
-0.0059184246,
-0.0258370768,
0.0152050294,
0.0554370768,
-0.0311082341,
-0.0135609889,
0.0390173458,
0.0116236676,
0.0018779851,
-0.0104491971,
0.0572113097,
-0.0129286442,
-0.0287306029,
-0.000691625,
0.0169233195,
-0.0251379702,
0.0138775036,
0.0061836652,
-0.0708275512,
0.0472196788,
0.0790624768,
-0.0161569007,
-0.0094674416,
-0.0139272129,
-0.0342053212,
0.0263807997,
0.003122695,
0.0308015682,
-0.0040425183,
-0.0251990277,
-0.0945392698,
-0.030582672,
0.0448513068,
-0.0268415678,
0.0064558866,
0.047955431,
-0.0103478646,
0.0335603058,
-0.0157886669,
-0.0581785887,
-0.0242119338,
-0.0736850277,
0.0334167369,
-0.0114217512,
0.0255166199,
0.0170642789,
0.0288073495,
-0.0036707649,
0.0132257352,
-0.0519354977,
-0.0580266081,
0.0627962872,
0.054045748,
0.0223810431,
0.0638630763,
-0.0537662469,
-0.0761134103,
0.0513451621,
0.0776230469,
-0.0611956939,
-0.0130172744,
0.0589878932,
-0.0207883399,
0.0222565029,
0.0211824812,
-0.0465548262,
-0.0308035035,
0.0221359562,
-0.0394060276,
-0.0726675317,
-0.024924688,
0.0081593776,
0.0534278005,
0.0236949567,
0.0047043171,
0.0363304988,
0.0091500198,
0.0386836007,
-0.0555593222,
-0.015419309,
-0.008236927,
-0.0073846127,
0.0685698241,
0.0174772404,
0.0405417085,
0.0137780467,
0.002034646,
-0.0231479928,
-0.0145360846,
-0.0085253641,
0.0165475234,
-0.0047625275,
0.0238542296,
0.0067200465,
-0.0198996272,
0.0436210148,
0.0345615894,
0.0615560189,
-0.0526226684,
0.0355662815,
0.0092644095,
-0.0038004825,
-0.0520725101,
0.0610953197,
-0.0503209941,
-0.0010390035,
-0.0107543422,
0.0408216715,
-0.0530281179,
0.0205050204,
0.0142343519,
-0.0588885508,
-0.0144707132,
0.0043036374,
0.0114723807,
-0.0080102226,
-0.0311213136,
-0.0293530244,
-0.0111662475,
-0.0156547688,
-0.0015939676,
0.0813599825,
0.0162446834,
0.0149902413,
-0.0326944515,
-0.0242520999,
-0.0638382584,
-0.002794479,
-0.0020608716,
0.1002856717,
-0.0165992528,
0.009038345,
-0.066345565,
-0.0437884666,
-0.0242433175,
-0.0188823957,
0.0213912483,
-0.0315815881,
-0.0186281353,
0.0402501374,
-0.0048442222,
-0.0316962153,
-0.076136604,
0.0346438922,
0.0364112258,
-0.0520067811,
-0.0199327581,
-5.808397135e-33,
-0.0096730357,
-0.0157828573,
-0.0459183156,
0.0637616962,
0.0372062251,
0.0207863152,
0.0158268102,
-0.002747573,
-0.0034622743,
-0.0378908776,
-0.0405550823,
-0.0054186136,
0.0141040087,
0.018163003,
-0.0632479861,
-0.015086093,
0.0213211607,
0.0308579206,
-0.0213179514,
-0.0042184102,
0.053879451,
0.0076945694,
0.0178041719,
-0.1271903962,
0.0433381498,
-0.0012681469,
-0.0348608643,
0.0233187731,
-0.0111297416,
0.026672652,
0.0012008197,
0.0175160356,
-0.0050358269,
0.0067404876,
-0.0082511846,
0.0765348598,
-0.0875322297,
-0.0099155679,
0.026836507,
0.019357305,
0.0471093543,
-0.0855384171,
0.0776426941,
-0.0293876026,
0.0047780508,
0.0221668277,
-0.0212948397,
-0.0236368105,
-0.0240876414,
-0.0164529905,
-0.0309091527,
0.0030537446,
-0.0169789195,
-0.0111437934,
0.0504428558,
-0.0003545368,
0.0221784152,
0.0084261531,
-0.0604374968,
0.0025461165,
0.003990347,
-0.0156704448,
0.0407120958,
0.027670389,
0.032054361,
0.0273904596,
0.0176154654,
0.0378355645,
0.0055836658,
-0.0054910649,
0.0210361388,
0.0239644945,
0.0138386255,
0.0564678572,
0.057720378,
-0.0630816668,
-0.0103140473,
0.0269529317,
-0.0087745711,
-0.0178193264,
0.0474303886,
0.0304001365,
-0.0707573518,
-0.0069606262,
-0.0410817526,
-0.0073511614,
-0.0249029696,
0.0110811377,
-0.0136356102,
-0.0040561431,
-0.0667210296,
0.0218609758,
0.0133570433,
-0.0888851956,
0.0044901427,
-0.0029590847,
0.0448579825,
-0.0194336232,
-0.008694862,
0.0192893278,
0.0108876256,
-0.0188877396,
0.0169713069,
-0.0468936861,
0.021077266,
0.0028646393,
0.0491481833,
0.015642494,
-0.0810462758,
-0.0267280694,
-0.0164067447,
0.0241563637,
0.0370097868,
-0.0153759196,
0.0355727822,
0.0231862403,
0.0138071254,
-0.0301501025,
0.0379753672,
0.0167784952,
-0.0317999274,
0.0139270499,
-0.0143756773,
-0.0172191001,
-0.0034242875,
-0.017932687,
0.0104595441,
0.0110806907,
0.0787820593,
-0.0313684456,
-0.0204967707,
0.0178914648,
2.981e-7,
0.0503446832,
0.0300869886,
-0.0161765609,
0.0092020342,
0.0104018701,
0.0518310629,
0.0537106954,
0.0361185931,
0.0024234224,
-0.0050806357,
-0.0152290529,
-0.0255477931,
0.0238215495,
0.015012946,
-0.0934974328,
-0.036950212,
0.0367341936,
-0.0002313542,
-0.0536985733,
0.0240423325,
0.0491160825,
0.1120939553,
0.0551369712,
-0.0201650374,
-0.0188294891,
-0.0218668319,
0.0085539948,
-0.0520057604,
0.0024398856,
-0.0083575416,
-0.0110151619,
0.0697370544,
0.0438191183,
-0.0056235245,
-0.0498058386,
0.0255549755,
-0.036613781,
0.0881497785,
0.0056588212,
-0.0258947704,
0.0028803202,
-0.0881744847,
-0.025174832,
-0.0356298573,
0.0501948856,
-0.0037052676,
-0.0382705778,
-0.0156875663,
-0.0352789797,
-0.0302718114,
0.0047396389,
-0.0199245494,
-0.057396628,
0.0258526634,
0.0262934957,
0.0033082119,
0.016552493,
-0.0474023782,
-0.0203094594,
-0.025926359,
-0.0063492716,
0.0023583288,
-0.0010314146,
-0.0086260429,
0.0412892103,
0.0061814352,
0.0562493019,
3.086310468e-34,
0.0031563703,
-0.0394557528,
-0.0245973151,
0.0272973254,
0.0556814149,
-0.0067441436,
0.0427981839,
0.0386805236,
0.0158939175,
-0.0498421118,
0.0120861102
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.09548v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.09548v2 | Measuring Social Dimensions of Self-Presentation in Social Media Biographies with an Identity-based Approach | 2023-05-16T15:45:59 | 2023-10-11T19:57:43 | Navid Madani, Rabiraj Bandyopadhyay, Briony Swire-Thompson, Michael Miller Yoder, Kenneth Joseph | cs.CL | cs.CL | Social media users on sites like Twitter, Instagram, and Tiktok use the
profile description, or bio, field of user profiles to present themselves to
the world. In contrast to the ``offline'' world, where social context often
encourages us to adopt a single identity, the profile description is a
free-text field in which users are encouraged to present the self using
multiple, sometimes conflicting, social identities. While sociologists, social
psychologists, sociolinguists, and increasingly computational social
scientists, have developed a large and growing array of methods to estimate the
meaning of individual social identities, little work has attended to the ways
in which social meanings emerge from the collections of social identities
present in social media bios. The present work proposes and evaluate three
novel, identity-based methods to measure the social dimensions of meaning
expressed in Twitter bios. We show that these models outperform reasonable
baselines with respect to 1) predicting which sets of identities are more
likely to co-occur within a single biography and 2) quantifying perceptions of
entire social media biographies along salient dimensions of social meaning on
Twitter, in particular partisanship. We demonstrate the utility of our method
in a computational social science setting by using model outputs to better
understand how self presentation along dimensions of partisanship, religion,
age, and gender are related to the sharing of URLs on Twitter from low versus
high quality news sites. | [
0.0400616899,
0.0689546987,
-0.0362382382,
-0.0289596617,
-0.0163253564,
0.0002139448,
0.0528661534,
-0.0407802351,
0.0308486484,
-0.0364156105,
0.0579827726,
-0.0432894044,
0.0377659313,
0.0328963399,
-0.0143675851,
-0.0066332212,
0.0204070918,
0.0402873643,
0.036998339,
-0.0335296206,
-0.0058532483,
0.0685166419,
0.0433053449,
0.0254526772,
-0.0219545085,
-0.0453317799,
0.049902495,
0.0356312357,
0.0428516082,
-0.0211752094,
0.0251234751,
0.0524678603,
-0.0200380385,
0.0465040691,
0.0000019034,
-0.0636339635,
-0.015686132,
-0.0070641451,
-0.0139951203,
0.0035685657,
0.0860839784,
0.0584558137,
0.0150090093,
0.0103671663,
-0.0761701614,
0.019120438,
0.0248883311,
-0.0008618628,
-0.0110642146,
0.0022620158,
-0.0168038271,
-0.0490325391,
-0.072933808,
-0.0018626569,
0.006836711,
0.0229962189,
0.0163443238,
-0.0318076722,
-0.0734794289,
0.0017969289,
0.0332912281,
0.0477628,
-0.0093049975,
0.0122641111,
0.044891879,
0.0040007569,
0.01273089,
-0.0202883054,
0.0483812019,
0.0057344022,
0.089192532,
-0.0082425838,
0.0422910526,
0.015976347,
0.0226976238,
0.041772496,
-0.017306285,
0.0286226589,
-0.0146392612,
-0.0245881919,
-0.0365076624,
0.0579227433,
0.0098653948,
0.0477980524,
-0.0166359898,
0.0544285439,
-0.0175417997,
0.0112353936,
0.018932987,
-0.0279700141,
0.0332572423,
-0.0364365913,
0.0105712861,
-0.0335044749,
0.0507006161,
0.0236970484,
-0.0254868343,
-0.0039239638,
0.0037750872,
-0.0607411377,
0.0194806829,
-0.0074397335,
0.0174568817,
-0.0007145078,
0.0718102008,
0.0000507926,
0.0101629002,
-0.0384881981,
0.035638731,
0.0073068673,
-0.0564307123,
-0.0018044694,
0.0168072004,
0.0193730555,
0.0130035058,
0.013759085,
-0.0392560512,
0.0142016634,
-0.0316198841,
-0.0234440137,
-0.0355268307,
0.0231819581,
-0.0038659726,
-0.0075837686,
-0.0316586159,
0.0325328782,
-0.0207029432,
-0.016078217,
-0.0450227931,
0.0093944799,
0.0484239049,
-0.005601617,
0.0464497916,
-0.0530105196,
0.013563484,
-0.0150464699,
0.0430536158,
-0.0379148088,
-0.0052594878,
-0.0491495132,
-0.0186657906,
-0.0557351373,
-0.0178610813,
-0.0586865731,
0.0656412542,
0.0771916285,
0.0263840239,
-0.1028716713,
-0.0000758124,
0.0110920826,
-0.0420190133,
0.0042234589,
0.0043646647,
0.0533167571,
0.0314133763,
0.0533064753,
0.0272163302,
0.0377285853,
0.0227265824,
0.0124934642,
0.0696813166,
-0.0394561514,
0.0013329884,
0.0028507712,
-0.0178386569,
0.013899683,
0.0280451905,
0.0047254921,
-0.0152470684,
-0.0424187221,
-0.0012562157,
0.0186874345,
0.0388528369,
0.0228003282,
0.0529392026,
0.0859361961,
0.0139800031,
0.0363118649,
0.0278309882,
0.0647957399,
0.0377550386,
-0.0114949159,
-0.026710555,
-0.0031209365,
0.0083670411,
-0.0370126255,
0.0403653942,
0.0680439845,
-0.0243746378,
0.0046177348,
0.0058955462,
-0.0010998194,
0.0776540712,
-0.0004797734,
-0.0246705115,
-0.0378397107,
0.0385204442,
0.0044456953,
0.0292749126,
-0.0810256079,
0.001573074,
-0.0330267064,
-0.0132543389,
0.0713669732,
-0.0303726699,
0.0283483323,
0.0175219513,
-0.0433642827,
0.0468314104,
0.0308984313,
-0.0034738923,
0.009153828,
-0.0195144359,
0.0100839287,
0.0022008908,
0.0079563446,
0.0186423324,
0.0316553153,
0.0568898991,
0.0291601382,
0.0178001318,
-0.0074560959,
-0.0329798087,
-0.0279622078,
-0.0193174556,
-0.0196827799,
0.0264012516,
0.0428872108,
0.0289165638,
0.0777963251,
0.0338296071,
-0.0417930819,
0.0025396161,
0.0407166891,
-0.0269577857,
0.0214598142,
0.0165458769,
0.0605792925,
-0.0046172678,
-0.0176994707,
-0.0460384935,
0.0446705073,
0.0231314525,
0.0044542379,
0.1185480505,
-0.0202019196,
-0.0101423506,
0.018549988,
-0.0298011787,
-0.0512621477,
0.0072692358,
0.000553904,
0.0732295439,
-0.0184612274,
-0.0048393486,
-0.0221241694,
-0.0996777341,
0.0083498014,
-0.0270424988,
-0.0017039488,
-0.0851709321,
-0.0544378236,
0.0267594624,
-0.0048725121,
-0.0774999186,
-0.0426864214,
-0.019464422,
-0.0564862713,
0.0023331931,
-0.0224982258,
0.0014995808,
0.0187381227,
0.0114276456,
-0.0145235723,
0.024598293,
-0.0253026001,
-0.0497059412,
-0.0087773437,
0.0220391396,
0.0046936404,
0.0094539607,
-0.0077990587,
-0.0162583105,
-0.0122078098,
-0.0679725856,
0.0463170819,
0.0188138597,
-0.043575909,
0.0372838601,
-0.0611142181,
-0.0733716488,
-0.0260059293,
-0.026108088,
0.0051404205,
0.0151091879,
0.0330552086,
0.0275575276,
0.0037781384,
0.0617392398,
0.045190677,
-0.0189445168,
0.0073320968,
0.0011255313,
-0.0226349309,
-0.0097676804,
0.0073084426,
0.0007667596,
-0.0910164118,
-0.0021135584,
-0.0425363258,
0.0190021191,
0.0078016045,
-0.0405624919,
0.0569785796,
-0.0367616154,
-0.0074292663,
-0.0017593672,
0.0089308312,
0.0182592757,
0.0274194926,
0.018444268,
0.0173913352,
-0.003286951,
0.024436906,
0.0534782596,
0.0641223937,
-0.0722314343,
0.0082428632,
0.0634183958,
0.0271200966,
0.0306475069,
0.0617835298,
0.0022266405,
0.0257415511,
-0.0059113614,
0.0321915634,
-0.0481972583,
-0.0179076176,
0.037641339,
0.0062566125,
0.0325711407,
0.0013972514,
0.0011937568,
-0.1000529528,
-0.0345104076,
-0.033602871,
-0.0215445329,
-0.0493731946,
0.0351844355,
-0.0045574764,
0.0360662118,
-0.1051949039,
-0.0340001285,
-0.0177780185,
0.0175419804,
0.0015670845,
-0.0061964439,
-0.0052471883,
0.0230717678,
0.0076352805,
-0.0248651747,
-0.028478317,
0.0124645066,
0.0322077051,
-0.0106807444,
-0.0487253815,
-0.0042699706,
-0.0384330899,
-0.0229859632,
0.0104996543,
0.0518553257,
0.0009995893,
0.0391680114,
0.0834785476,
0.0033001679,
0.0260412414,
0.0057513486,
0.0354954749,
-0.0090223607,
0.0200788788,
0.0269837584,
-0.0579340868,
0.0377666876,
-0.0427222066,
0.0281009655,
-0.0458105393,
-0.0272960886,
-0.0286773108,
-0.0562918335,
-0.001274883,
0.0121423295,
-0.0041992455,
-0.0042777807,
-0.0381656252,
0.0107013835,
-0.0261699799,
-0.0281956978,
-0.0115827778,
-0.0462588556,
0.0047403621,
-0.0174952727,
-0.0482825451,
-0.0549686551,
0.0157492906,
-0.0592058934,
0.0054095373,
-0.0139023289,
0.0556804724,
0.0060055507,
-0.0496225841,
-0.0288888086,
-0.0017720744,
0.0086246077,
0.0055331262,
0.0681043491,
-0.0494521558,
0.0357018299,
-0.0547279418,
0.0178904124,
0.0025482806,
-0.0259311348,
-0.0601294078,
-0.034866441,
0.0287313014,
-0.0526209362,
0.0100257685,
0.0236965567,
0.0270737056,
0.0623616315,
0.032366354,
-0.0461942479,
0.0170048233,
-0.0273430645,
0.0523517281,
-0.0310944021,
-0.074973613,
-0.0056187506,
-0.0195616689,
-0.0511254296,
0.0080503346,
-0.0461219139,
0.0030427612,
-0.0077486625,
-0.0073995059,
-0.0111586265,
0.0221926887,
-0.0132301776,
-0.0918922052,
0.0050991559,
-0.0779605061,
0.0401365608,
0.0338027626,
-0.0429799333,
0.0089680208,
-0.0017128441,
-0.0001308784,
-0.0070761987,
-0.0051956177,
-0.0347616635,
0.0432702117,
-0.0291431062,
0.0263809208,
0.0268435944,
-0.0175415538,
-0.0277360659,
0.0411379337,
0.0664850101,
-0.0067891846,
0.0318298228,
0.0253982991,
0.061487712,
-0.0301552694,
0.0223624147,
0.0066708443,
-0.0237324163,
0.0115742153,
-0.0659464672,
-0.0675171763,
-0.018143069,
-0.0519565493,
0.0026914827,
0.0255364329,
0.0082751354,
-0.0286633112,
0.0090762405,
-0.0933448896,
-0.0198752545,
-0.0278546661,
0.0203083046,
-0.0628569126,
0.0272597205,
0.0285558887,
-0.0337954126,
0.0094514331,
-0.0162966475,
0.020106269,
-0.1046358868,
-0.0346711539,
-0.0322204083,
0.0215306953,
-0.0493181758,
-0.011693649,
-0.0060425969,
-0.0085670287,
0.0504246838,
-0.0024569666,
0.0250004288,
-0.0193062127,
-0.0338839404,
0.024343906,
0.0167329926,
0.0377599448,
-0.0315787345,
-0.0126187205,
0.0171492193,
0.0029033937,
-0.0208562557,
0.0047003534,
0.0523194224,
0.024263218,
-0.0058165365,
0.0012929901,
0.0191960167,
0.0148399891,
-0.0446155407,
-0.0033687523,
-0.0011237172,
-0.0148583949,
0.0046459464,
0.0285347924,
0.0330226161,
0.0047931587,
0.0143998824,
-0.0508306362,
-0.0121272467,
0.0083253281,
-0.0221818611,
0.0692178383,
-0.0045933006,
-0.0086073354,
-0.1000334248,
-0.0479236208,
0.0680667609,
-0.0158951208,
0.0493382551,
-0.0086741494,
-0.0019106891,
0.02505235,
0.021201767,
-0.026564341,
-0.0193617959,
-0.029278148,
-0.0384570472,
-0.0333689004,
0.0142812468,
-6.694291187e-33,
-0.0112974178,
-0.0504929647,
-0.0302371345,
0.0054543079,
-0.0501265116,
-0.0101660006,
-0.0182794482,
0.0333681516,
0.0107832244,
-0.0200277623,
-0.0286110733,
0.0088085392,
0.017416602,
0.0089318324,
0.0085710241,
0.0041194609,
0.0359090194,
0.0290185697,
-0.0303641409,
0.0360600241,
0.0025158036,
-0.0285857487,
-0.0141981244,
-0.085569337,
0.0298473202,
-0.0189551488,
-0.0102720568,
-0.0089641074,
0.0520690046,
-0.0104185818,
-0.0075938087,
0.0356415957,
0.0330976769,
0.0119012492,
0.0273674224,
0.0977061093,
-0.0889745578,
-0.0294014253,
0.0111197308,
0.0087490361,
0.0113140373,
-0.054740455,
0.010142494,
0.0066596172,
-0.0876199678,
-0.0162409823,
0.0742806494,
0.0567230582,
0.0802146047,
-0.0111896889,
-0.0054530953,
0.0025251394,
0.0066899424,
-0.013651466,
-0.0239151455,
0.0271560811,
0.0160663184,
-0.003455563,
-0.069519788,
0.021929564,
-0.0436943173,
-0.0340729579,
0.0227260068,
-0.0182907358,
0.0055898787,
0.0236146096,
0.0087480675,
0.0506818667,
-0.0481525362,
-0.0069056624,
0.0209830292,
-0.0009564663,
0.0055796239,
0.0616033599,
-0.0297981165,
-0.0711733922,
-0.0213646423,
0.0030669051,
0.0579536557,
-0.0728916302,
0.0413042046,
-0.0225138161,
-0.0268356726,
-0.0314840376,
-0.0278301984,
-0.0928168744,
-0.0394562893,
-0.0088180825,
-0.032297004,
-0.020556571,
-0.1236471906,
0.0516922548,
0.0227724649,
-0.0373317823,
-0.0781217217,
0.0003949137,
-0.0014062945,
0.0426424816,
0.0330707692,
0.0085130902,
0.0074481177,
-0.0106103588,
-0.0025456129,
0.033587642,
0.030409608,
-0.0071424413,
0.0003238942,
0.0118496874,
-0.0454086624,
-0.0268297736,
0.0257823486,
0.0152469007,
-0.0143140377,
-0.0642855093,
0.0279904995,
0.0666631311,
-0.0187201034,
-0.037865907,
0.0682123601,
0.0599240065,
0.0077743931,
-0.0305743665,
-0.0328340307,
-0.0101844575,
0.0138639873,
0.0062920554,
-0.0135952495,
0.0220380928,
0.055817388,
0.0092635406,
-0.0263587404,
-0.0475237221,
2.767e-7,
0.0047234884,
0.0566826202,
-0.0244031157,
0.0075300089,
0.0337849334,
0.0384137854,
0.0713675842,
0.0294683911,
0.000153085,
-0.0898177102,
-0.0350301787,
0.0466141552,
0.037727572,
-0.0131164053,
-0.0035468885,
-0.005947534,
0.0076859756,
0.0082838805,
-0.0596284494,
0.0387163721,
-0.0017299374,
-0.0063216216,
0.0744805038,
0.01493748,
-0.0413147621,
-0.0114004659,
0.0206028596,
0.0062755509,
-0.0215571877,
0.0191529952,
-0.0147236679,
-0.0155627867,
0.0297872871,
0.0044009765,
-0.0012133565,
0.0183275305,
0.0131123047,
0.0152007295,
0.0197363403,
0.0457650498,
0.0027990048,
0.0107251182,
0.00571466,
0.0044328077,
0.0454118513,
-0.0197000261,
-0.0389073379,
-0.0719833747,
-0.0186120383,
0.0232655071,
0.0318523236,
0.013735963,
-0.0576601364,
0.0209045261,
-0.0017455044,
-0.0188302733,
-0.0331230424,
-0.045341257,
0.0114164185,
-0.0133347102,
0.0093508037,
-0.0137464516,
0.0199310184,
0.0192111041,
0.0489663146,
-0.0147896679,
0.0427164584,
1.952732593e-34,
-0.0025492089,
0.029406812,
-0.0109581333,
-0.0725255609,
0.0346558131,
0.0105303936,
-0.0528880954,
-0.0286326669,
0.0097907884,
-0.0281666182,
0.0124049522
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.09534v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.09534v1 | MetaSRL++: A Uniform Scheme for Modelling Deeper Semantics | 2023-05-16T15:26:52 | 2023-05-16T15:26:52 | Fritz Hohl, Nianheng Wu, Martina Galetti, Remi van Trijp | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite enormous progress in Natural Language Processing (NLP), our field is
still lacking a common deep semantic representation scheme. As a result, the
problem of meaning and understanding is typically sidestepped through more
simple, approximative methods. This paper argues that in order to arrive at
such a scheme, we also need a common modelling scheme. It therefore introduces
MetaSRL++, a uniform, language- and modality-independent modelling scheme based
on Semantic Graphs, as a step towards a common representation scheme; as well
as a method for defining the concepts and entities that are used in these
graphs. Our output is twofold. First, we illustrate MetaSRL++ through concrete
examples. Secondly, we discuss how it relates to existing work in the field. | [
0.0411206335,
0.0065977285,
-0.0090517728,
0.0337502696,
-0.0574400984,
0.0115560116,
-0.0275233481,
-0.0262396913,
-0.0295840837,
-0.0997040942,
0.0347596668,
0.0016489453,
-0.0070283338,
0.065734297,
-0.0402497351,
-0.0956344083,
0.039568942,
0.0030730458,
0.0067055542,
0.0179140065,
0.0215835366,
0.0284325313,
0.0163536947,
0.0275051054,
-0.0619559102,
-0.005093575,
-0.0454871282,
-0.0196843874,
-0.015454771,
-0.0057832557,
-0.0192884449,
0.0237452108,
0.0697045773,
0.0435708575,
0.0000020917,
-0.0387259312,
-0.0125837363,
0.0073377253,
-0.008457927,
-0.0061591263,
0.0304173045,
-0.0647299364,
0.0080938982,
-0.0417785868,
-0.0106740743,
-0.0545063913,
0.0620953329,
0.0426382236,
0.0399499461,
0.0477375984,
-0.0152002582,
-0.0750891045,
0.0108670332,
0.0039210925,
0.0107422294,
-0.0677450299,
0.0212841518,
0.0558420159,
0.033297129,
0.0281768683,
-0.0473531969,
0.0260560531,
0.015657017,
0.0068542887,
0.0106212972,
0.0065566772,
0.0337191783,
-0.020616116,
-0.0023768209,
0.0688087046,
0.0449073203,
-0.0165269561,
-0.0009239892,
0.0026717656,
-0.0479411334,
-0.0067030597,
-0.0505232699,
0.0520446114,
0.0063327895,
0.0291374326,
0.0164589286,
-0.0018634746,
0.0552244931,
-0.0054764329,
-0.0399371795,
0.0342978612,
-0.0123564173,
-0.009123235,
0.0024111506,
-0.0227208696,
0.0079670958,
-0.0393291228,
0.0016911204,
0.0247389004,
-0.0101349754,
0.0173379984,
-0.0119097233,
0.0000811681,
0.0203742348,
-0.0138455937,
-0.0006398521,
0.0415809341,
0.0139472466,
0.0666441843,
0.0024050272,
-0.0253941864,
-0.0440801606,
0.0415337831,
-0.0319208205,
-0.0221951343,
-0.088530764,
-0.0102329291,
-0.0730483308,
0.0663917139,
-0.0497267656,
-0.0260614995,
-0.0320671797,
0.0631864518,
-0.0210110024,
-0.0444491319,
0.0325551704,
0.0251114741,
-0.0417959541,
0.0379226282,
-0.0276345257,
0.0282399394,
-0.0134366844,
-0.006481187,
-0.0290712733,
-0.024959635,
0.0457038134,
0.0333936065,
0.0121918004,
0.0029820795,
-0.0521495081,
0.1152867153,
0.0487485491,
-0.0309800319,
0.0163586941,
-0.0553690791,
-0.0011839235,
-0.0059889038,
0.0194149576,
-0.061051067,
0.0167998169,
-0.0196130127,
0.0411458276,
-0.0412973464,
-0.0276182666,
-0.0056858822,
-0.0060145943,
0.0637248978,
-0.0319029875,
0.0102750063,
-0.0463498943,
0.0348646343,
-0.005656796,
0.0205489788,
0.0094294129,
0.0162757244,
0.0275294669,
-0.0007853123,
-0.0426511951,
-0.0208095107,
-0.0061713452,
-0.0185518898,
-0.0268772431,
0.0083592013,
-0.0554473624,
0.02002858,
-0.0083619393,
0.05004666,
-0.0295534283,
-0.0467239693,
-0.0065082484,
0.0286776796,
0.0211051311,
0.0433010012,
0.0805713013,
0.0068463981,
-0.0266339555,
-0.0214891061,
-0.0571855567,
0.0084507959,
0.0023081817,
0.0025890986,
-0.0337902531,
-0.017189309,
-0.0269905739,
-0.0067470227,
-0.0048635411,
-0.0433353968,
0.0515652113,
-0.0245638806,
0.0352653749,
-0.0160271898,
0.0128549067,
0.0499559268,
0.0174383335,
-0.0006225732,
0.0290583707,
-0.0426974557,
-0.0080251712,
0.0420494042,
0.0064378511,
-0.035411261,
-0.0192596503,
-0.0368797109,
0.0000121809,
0.0471444875,
0.0443837009,
-0.0275479089,
-0.0034049873,
-0.0221044794,
-0.0512673929,
-0.0431739353,
0.0159457121,
0.0404428467,
-0.0472329259,
-0.0420057215,
0.0177620351,
-0.0346274115,
0.0104497932,
0.0295626614,
0.0380053334,
0.0047561298,
0.0040437966,
0.0002433045,
0.0495403856,
0.0419073403,
0.0025224539,
0.0220326409,
0.0293017328,
-0.0016708578,
-0.0214490369,
0.0362384319,
-0.0522839874,
-0.0460585095,
0.0488048904,
-0.0637179241,
-0.0363488495,
0.053137999,
-0.056930352,
-0.025403766,
0.0242824294,
-0.0385010056,
0.0474705249,
-0.0428395309,
-0.0161698461,
-0.0005624361,
-0.0308799744,
-0.0155930901,
0.0771066695,
0.0102870073,
-0.019366987,
0.0025269242,
0.0171471015,
0.0530649461,
-0.0306273866,
-0.0495570377,
0.025109306,
0.0009607167,
0.0390173383,
0.0768632069,
0.0133029986,
-0.0355590098,
-0.005730568,
-0.0709373727,
-0.0163063221,
-0.0031528503,
-0.0142118763,
0.0427524932,
0.0312545076,
0.0265732184,
-0.0211060755,
-0.019895317,
0.0176662691,
0.0046861665,
0.0178472847,
-0.011055545,
0.0008781486,
-0.0259319581,
0.0033966815,
-0.0385060534,
-0.0447796285,
0.0195614491,
0.0059329444,
-0.0319385976,
-0.0099149356,
-0.0016594125,
-0.061222218,
0.029350277,
0.0021224131,
0.0193914585,
0.0185717344,
-0.0377753973,
-0.0151437419,
-0.0151781132,
-0.0062416676,
0.0854849666,
0.027273519,
-0.0212334301,
-0.0306013301,
0.0020116072,
-0.0542105064,
0.031217359,
-0.0590931587,
-0.0183497611,
-0.0075344318,
0.0778207704,
0.0296177771,
0.0045004282,
-0.0230281614,
0.0094789807,
-0.0085208798,
-0.0340477675,
-0.0434905551,
0.0149168167,
0.0002810214,
0.008910696,
-0.027784368,
-0.0292302035,
0.0936387107,
0.0297279954,
0.018591227,
-0.0497315079,
-0.0246273447,
-0.0472550504,
0.0732351318,
-0.0143673578,
0.0403976664,
-0.0086613521,
-0.0239825118,
-0.0083236564,
-0.0374510773,
0.0114958836,
0.0204453338,
0.0332821682,
-0.0171978325,
0.0509836227,
-0.0044505713,
0.0021473228,
-0.011716851,
-0.0332781821,
-0.0700569972,
0.079015255,
-0.0519337393,
0.0316740796,
-0.0286400132,
0.0066321143,
-0.0032409697,
-0.0366044976,
0.0200658664,
0.0015964048,
-0.0675324649,
0.0348978788,
0.0316601023,
-0.0151189314,
-0.0184723847,
0.0541644618,
0.0490382463,
0.0338444263,
0.0027621111,
0.0514472723,
-0.058340501,
0.0298321415,
0.0066787526,
-0.0303866398,
-0.0291868951,
0.0114319641,
-0.0003560892,
-0.0565331355,
0.0149441948,
0.1073811203,
0.0275224019,
0.0006391631,
0.0268001053,
0.0198634751,
0.0364913233,
0.0236977395,
-0.0167251192,
-0.0940848514,
-0.047208488,
-0.0144780604,
-0.0523737594,
0.0135441441,
-0.0339234322,
0.0254746545,
0.0109279593,
0.0105390446,
-0.0072407285,
-0.0648062602,
0.0112509718,
-0.0535959192,
0.0004738906,
-0.006550387,
-0.0007783557,
-0.0350785367,
-0.0167808793,
-0.0158367194,
-0.0070624277,
0.0115301413,
-0.0242054909,
0.0568826236,
-0.022854561,
-0.0007415349,
0.0324537009,
0.0323192477,
-0.009189981,
-0.0020154498,
0.0476140715,
-0.0034050997,
0.0327360705,
-0.0499070473,
-0.0203696322,
-0.045673091,
-0.0172540322,
-0.0522686392,
-0.0015709094,
-0.061519634,
-0.0066232109,
-0.0765722543,
0.1049185991,
-0.0287993383,
-0.0135375205,
-0.0617116988,
-0.0101666562,
0.004139015,
0.0642683879,
0.018988993,
0.0014411022,
-0.0346349031,
-0.0201533791,
0.0020125366,
-0.000847467,
-0.0522964336,
0.0392173715,
-0.0174348056,
-0.0374155715,
-0.0013897012,
-0.0669195727,
0.0089277569,
-0.020001689,
-0.0162729844,
0.0050108247,
0.028936388,
-0.0346941538,
-0.0631058514,
0.012704107,
-0.0450940169,
0.0242908727,
0.0157260727,
-0.0373101085,
0.0436011292,
0.0308504067,
-0.0297279544,
-0.0124978926,
-0.0299834888,
-0.0410549603,
-0.0028566143,
0.0207550451,
0.0155294873,
0.0196223557,
-0.0200902279,
-0.0496406071,
0.0494951047,
-0.0000316132,
-0.0463786758,
0.0155802565,
0.0082908543,
0.0201711785,
0.0072747408,
0.0361473039,
-0.053403493,
0.064460665,
-0.0105282273,
0.0723527074,
-0.0101775555,
-0.019288959,
0.0628629327,
0.0021757034,
0.019140061,
0.0327717811,
-0.0407946184,
-0.0114429323,
-0.0479805097,
-0.0430588908,
-0.0256877113,
-0.0248540901,
0.0447288305,
-0.0033670999,
0.0024194557,
-0.0108626774,
0.0188006777,
-0.0142944818,
0.0343731828,
0.0270852763,
-0.0060790395,
0.0564319678,
-0.0110570965,
-0.0415874384,
0.0565358251,
-0.0216895044,
0.0117565645,
-0.0546336435,
-0.0213393029,
-0.0170864668,
0.0249274243,
0.0234320424,
-0.011783517,
-0.0382821187,
0.0169992615,
-0.0504001938,
-0.0517110825,
0.0477002449,
0.0466285013,
0.0538388602,
-0.000655413,
0.0159638487,
-0.024529824,
-0.0053933188,
-0.0253964029,
0.064733386,
0.0172060803,
-0.0409420133,
0.0580932125,
0.0333846882,
0.0028145753,
-0.018891098,
0.0064268517,
-0.0186743233,
0.0439111143,
0.0451299548,
-0.0236569252,
-0.0449578054,
0.0063564018,
0.0438487232,
0.0652513728,
-0.0318954438,
0.0064188028,
-0.0683043972,
-0.0626121983,
0.0148149943,
0.0320756212,
0.0077197789,
-0.0023825744,
0.0609485358,
0.0393604264,
0.0192467775,
-0.025751112,
-0.0218916405,
0.0302791614,
-0.0539657511,
-0.0147305531,
-0.0183213707,
-5.982801191e-33,
-0.0145520456,
0.0108552566,
0.0180024132,
0.0059408182,
-0.0493922569,
0.0107768299,
-0.0233460441,
-0.0214718338,
-0.0280592646,
0.0375506356,
0.0312720612,
0.0247455928,
-0.008176568,
0.0121276425,
-0.0417086072,
-0.0323410705,
0.032072708,
-0.0078826444,
0.0053498428,
0.0140288416,
0.0723625124,
0.0000575995,
0.0662661791,
-0.084015958,
0.0355119929,
0.0170444362,
0.040023189,
0.043818973,
0.0383178666,
0.0708404556,
-0.0327220708,
0.0813115388,
0.0625810698,
0.0163329057,
-0.021193739,
0.0241010897,
-0.0803713351,
-0.038082324,
0.026034141,
0.0005425566,
-0.058478836,
-0.0084009171,
0.0605513826,
-0.0192882083,
0.0404585004,
-0.0282617547,
0.0453064144,
0.0160279777,
-0.0184546262,
0.0313215889,
-0.0590764619,
0.0155368866,
-0.0152938906,
-0.010540776,
0.0315271318,
-0.0036264728,
0.0167440586,
-0.0015355143,
-0.009955951,
0.0071236333,
-0.0309150852,
0.0222883839,
0.0119371871,
0.0042743483,
0.0325967148,
0.0538384318,
0.0010220457,
-0.0468240418,
-0.0155216008,
0.0234713741,
0.0147872791,
0.0547278598,
-0.0391328,
0.0694629326,
0.0124906367,
0.0320645608,
-0.0959934518,
0.0120228268,
0.0010086907,
0.0838400498,
-0.0186127257,
0.0323070437,
-0.021521071,
-0.015168353,
-0.0818172023,
0.0047080382,
-0.0369138308,
-0.058416903,
0.0369320363,
-0.0147668868,
-0.028493166,
0.0593069494,
0.0193282645,
-0.0781104714,
0.0087867603,
0.0589455999,
0.0265354719,
0.024349967,
-0.0026178369,
0.028161237,
0.0013439987,
-0.069799237,
0.0037761591,
-0.0162898675,
-0.0016638082,
-0.0018331937,
0.0032806792,
0.0086259954,
0.0331333987,
0.0196218137,
-0.0271764677,
-0.0826513469,
-0.046085339,
-0.0019464579,
0.0449600331,
0.0484159328,
-0.0211136453,
0.029911181,
0.0195840467,
0.0054801521,
0.0044923015,
-0.0137837818,
0.0151716126,
0.057861682,
-0.0006742659,
-0.0374768414,
-0.0512999594,
-0.0134207252,
0.0801105127,
-0.0395019948,
-0.0072688023,
-0.0403581001,
2.814e-7,
0.0309942439,
0.0005004687,
0.0638811886,
0.0000666903,
0.0322663821,
0.0309623554,
0.0261419378,
0.0626570731,
-0.0166935623,
-0.0402817503,
-0.0066343043,
0.060640756,
-0.0581626855,
-0.0116886478,
-0.0456138104,
0.0630767867,
-0.0302485432,
0.0145086804,
0.0150719769,
0.035279274,
0.0850576386,
0.0717713609,
0.0095772464,
-0.0038340283,
-0.0355690718,
-0.0139890471,
0.0627767369,
-0.0341878012,
-0.0010379471,
0.0207242612,
-0.0141151454,
0.0077266702,
0.029122347,
-0.0056211818,
0.0594812818,
0.0191515014,
0.0296623949,
0.0422436073,
-0.0769021735,
0.0174142104,
-0.0369312763,
-0.0595142432,
-0.0107897669,
-0.017452443,
0.0175842028,
-0.062844187,
-0.047467459,
-0.0310931951,
-0.0490216091,
0.0202785954,
-0.0262041744,
0.0119872727,
-0.0374158882,
-0.0074886209,
0.0070288377,
-0.0175920893,
-0.0179861281,
-0.0639299527,
0.0054152934,
-0.007536171,
-0.0093715331,
-0.003682401,
-0.0164254103,
0.0006067533,
0.0664224848,
-0.0795703381,
-0.0059047649,
2.086648262e-34,
0.0313277133,
0.0432982892,
0.0085198255,
-0.0116819628,
-0.009820302,
-0.0296599492,
0.0005485215,
0.0245653242,
0.0393381678,
-0.06780494,
-0.0473270714
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.10448v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.10448v1 | Sequence-to-Sequence Pre-training with Unified Modality Masking for Visual Document Understanding | 2023-05-16T15:25:19 | 2023-05-16T15:25:19 | Shuwei Feng, Tianyang Zhan, Zhanming Jie, Trung Quoc Luong, Xiaoran Jin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper presents GenDoc, a general sequence-to-sequence document
understanding model pre-trained with unified masking across three modalities:
text, image, and layout. The proposed model utilizes an encoder-decoder
architecture, which allows for increased adaptability to a wide range of
downstream tasks with diverse output formats, in contrast to the encoder-only
models commonly employed in document understanding. In addition to the
traditional text infilling task used in previous encoder-decoder models, our
pre-training extends to include tasks of masked image token prediction and
masked layout prediction. We also design modality-specific instruction and
adopt both disentangled attention and the mixture-of-modality-experts strategy
to effectively capture the information leveraged by each modality. Evaluation
of the proposed model through extensive experiments on several downstream tasks
in document understanding demonstrates its ability to achieve superior or
competitive performance compared to state-of-the-art approaches. Our analysis
further suggests that GenDoc is more robust than the encoder-only models in
scenarios where the OCR quality is imperfect. | [
-0.0127664134,
0.0741404295,
0.0224506371,
0.0399202891,
0.0035672688,
0.015240836,
0.0092073241,
0.0086676888,
-0.0271484107,
-0.0301191956,
-0.0331067964,
-0.0198921133,
0.0115042375,
0.0911095962,
-0.0146580217,
-0.0502740033,
0.038555827,
-0.0397112407,
-0.0273684915,
0.0434768014,
0.0057301116,
-0.0089157969,
0.0049687526,
0.0003029599,
0.0011522545,
-0.0470504574,
-0.060691189,
0.015454622,
0.0115743913,
-0.0320496447,
-0.0169435963,
0.0464209616,
0.0873126462,
0.0336273536,
0.0000020238,
-0.0106078014,
-0.006592371,
0.001691655,
-0.0419106632,
-0.032282304,
0.0080214422,
-0.0994300023,
0.0139292628,
-0.0236177146,
-0.0015968655,
-0.0160588883,
0.042336382,
0.0580034293,
0.047384806,
0.066599533,
-0.0257466584,
-0.0297277439,
0.0250201039,
-0.0402959399,
0.0281722005,
-0.0178598613,
0.0097396513,
-0.0176151078,
-0.0173553918,
-0.0024995706,
-0.0469420701,
0.0203108527,
0.0508299805,
0.0068280394,
0.0346244015,
0.0459584557,
0.0588478893,
-0.032522466,
-0.0507895947,
0.0717015937,
-0.0500880703,
0.0011958939,
-0.0035658563,
-0.0138296643,
-0.0056475629,
-0.002638157,
-0.0303688645,
-0.0138146952,
-0.0369584747,
-0.0017790275,
-0.0095032416,
0.0377834029,
0.0002217816,
0.0007217617,
-0.0398715138,
-0.0294796024,
-0.0184030253,
-0.0149171511,
-0.0222333204,
-0.0030329095,
0.011658703,
-0.0314254463,
0.0548070222,
0.0498175621,
0.0170721877,
0.009014857,
-0.0767138228,
-0.0957537591,
-0.0243967846,
-0.0087058907,
0.0047641057,
0.0342034362,
-0.0385985747,
0.0681366026,
-0.0407233201,
0.0593867339,
-0.0297269989,
0.0567593351,
-0.0320814885,
-0.0073518087,
-0.0274747387,
-0.0063874871,
-0.0468258671,
0.0114549706,
-0.0625625029,
-0.0545009561,
0.043042656,
-0.0095581934,
0.0176742617,
0.0293709952,
0.0071864049,
0.0029283811,
-0.0860196948,
-0.0662533417,
-0.0129131582,
0.0158497803,
0.0021108212,
-0.0087627042,
0.0070832302,
-0.0326377116,
-0.0302320942,
0.0374974161,
0.0044966796,
-0.0113183726,
-0.005458829,
0.0773620456,
-0.0728350133,
-0.0399786718,
0.0000188385,
0.0043853223,
0.0080713108,
-0.0312590189,
0.0406427458,
-0.0110775959,
0.0319943763,
0.0074057719,
-0.0000272131,
-0.0306004211,
-0.0060770111,
-0.0185825024,
0.0038740491,
0.0871877298,
-0.0159077756,
-0.0465407781,
0.0253007058,
0.0339511037,
-0.0209633298,
0.0681074932,
-0.0041257949,
0.0769310892,
-0.0178014189,
0.0080095967,
0.011302501,
0.0220830403,
0.0168115813,
-0.0184902102,
0.0164458025,
0.0262372792,
0.0112101603,
-0.0120216338,
0.0570342913,
0.0122504933,
-0.048177518,
-0.0417671576,
0.0567470752,
0.0010648263,
0.0296522956,
0.048010435,
0.0043515055,
0.0289084036,
-0.0058065853,
0.0225518737,
-0.0363212042,
0.0444711372,
0.0303031895,
0.0208742693,
-0.0183304958,
0.0108703617,
-0.0230583083,
-0.0418058671,
0.0176154673,
-0.0018540763,
-0.015509773,
0.0029860251,
0.0527387187,
0.0106544299,
-0.1107594296,
-0.0002654952,
-0.0386787876,
-0.0116411336,
0.0204840954,
-0.0088009126,
0.0039158016,
0.0562626496,
0.0386650525,
-0.0439728759,
-0.0215188209,
-0.0165721998,
-0.0130024785,
0.0315475948,
-0.0294615198,
0.023251066,
0.0547291413,
-0.0754785538,
-0.0325210653,
-0.0414360911,
-0.0175387003,
0.0638997033,
-0.0058017541,
0.0015463462,
0.0089732353,
-0.0415944457,
0.0252041221,
0.0581934974,
0.0199169703,
-0.0595879816,
-0.0452885702,
0.0081682429,
0.0422511697,
-0.010735481,
-0.0136080598,
-0.0175793953,
0.0261659268,
-0.0383963957,
0.0453887433,
-0.0170451421,
-0.0858324841,
-0.0666914955,
-0.0061506457,
-0.0605293512,
-0.036161799,
0.0542643815,
-0.036437504,
-0.0430838726,
-0.0106594078,
-0.0138861779,
0.0155140245,
-0.0438988656,
-0.0344991758,
0.03494386,
0.0360030085,
0.0156496037,
0.0461691692,
-0.0334863812,
-0.0265181661,
0.0399037413,
-0.0032997166,
0.0147904558,
-0.0074127805,
0.0105884448,
-0.0000287319,
-0.0023287553,
-0.0298384055,
-0.0231893156,
0.0083240615,
-0.0468244329,
-0.0535774678,
-0.0954937488,
-0.021266032,
-0.0438022017,
0.0243338235,
0.0317808241,
-0.004659012,
0.0030140241,
-0.0582546107,
-0.0187005941,
-0.0113268672,
-0.0035225179,
-0.0382917337,
0.017882932,
0.020392891,
0.014682102,
0.0251786783,
-0.0176087804,
0.0252773724,
0.0354952216,
0.0122153964,
-0.0494049489,
-0.0219144002,
-0.0027932103,
0.0253352914,
0.0068187905,
-0.043931298,
0.0049947929,
-0.0002382216,
0.0015862318,
0.0535113066,
0.1116974428,
0.0198054276,
0.0594542995,
-0.0049582259,
-0.0167798121,
-0.0042706062,
0.0080790147,
0.0043141274,
0.0323505178,
-0.0105510559,
-0.0006910888,
0.0169053655,
0.07232669,
-0.0337660126,
0.0445714779,
-0.0402610637,
-0.0248392858,
0.0102018816,
-0.0541919023,
-0.0653094575,
-0.0168465953,
0.0189903807,
0.037093576,
-0.0379465111,
-0.0376559496,
0.0577670932,
-0.0459043197,
-0.0493010171,
-0.0243555401,
0.0257025529,
-0.0216708276,
0.0276123136,
0.032981813,
0.0085175568,
-0.0087357862,
-0.0557903945,
-0.0394404382,
-0.0061851814,
0.0043488075,
-0.0077482704,
0.0175904222,
-0.0302479398,
0.0354362689,
-0.0357745662,
0.0003135734,
-0.0145549057,
-0.0344978459,
0.0160856936,
0.0225527342,
0.0251136012,
0.0118247168,
-0.0555020422,
0.0502483658,
0.0102075348,
0.0769660324,
-0.0089535313,
-0.0120274154,
-0.0421453118,
0.0996346027,
0.0134048043,
-0.0139031401,
0.0023393545,
-0.0956277177,
0.0261501819,
0.0377305225,
0.0095214797,
-0.0210999101,
-0.0254358575,
0.0299307033,
-0.0010596879,
0.0168106239,
0.0138629237,
0.0356005132,
0.0384217128,
-0.101284951,
-0.0113505814,
0.0627573505,
-0.00084668,
-0.0544415228,
-0.0627639964,
0.0000110215,
0.0163049791,
-0.0046404018,
0.0067726825,
-0.0715216324,
-0.0466295369,
-0.0000723906,
0.0088493582,
0.0523130931,
0.0157795642,
-0.0027866086,
-0.0141357938,
0.0327719525,
0.0085787391,
-0.0441407785,
-0.0631478354,
-0.0171369016,
-0.0188694485,
0.0050770557,
0.0159060732,
-0.0079885516,
0.0058153458,
-0.0330030508,
0.0151255745,
0.0414736867,
-0.0179478563,
-0.0184534583,
0.0193434451,
-0.012107606,
0.0489971898,
-0.0085077072,
0.0107266214,
-0.0405725427,
0.0057691457,
0.0077217212,
0.03081722,
-0.0013013219,
0.070250392,
-0.0586079173,
0.0009142363,
-0.036815688,
0.0230423696,
-0.017905904,
-0.0206919163,
-0.0232208837,
0.0048744627,
-0.0021366714,
-0.0260682665,
-0.0347077772,
-0.0363522395,
-0.0135243339,
0.0335730352,
0.0203606263,
-0.001466849,
-0.0603427924,
-0.0272955429,
0.0786377713,
-0.0662816465,
0.0415598229,
0.0244966354,
-0.0160848107,
-0.0494165383,
-0.0133226998,
-0.0197069291,
0.0130135119,
0.036932528,
0.0056569264,
-0.0268115997,
0.0189687721,
-0.0103063565,
-0.0616538525,
0.0478870012,
0.0013299566,
-0.0125771789,
-0.0763523057,
0.0031194014,
-0.0010564063,
-0.0416174904,
-0.0195195284,
0.0219340213,
-0.072642155,
0.0050728535,
-0.0033278086,
0.0599470027,
0.0106424363,
0.0788368508,
0.0228860304,
-0.0189672764,
0.0795712769,
-0.0020977878,
-0.0160198435,
-0.0311255362,
0.0485828668,
-0.049266912,
-0.0157610793,
-0.0128371399,
-0.0224102288,
0.0316979922,
0.0391570218,
-0.0583317168,
-0.0167217795,
0.0167917106,
0.0138408309,
-0.0355578773,
0.0142667107,
0.0004027484,
0.031816557,
-0.0106974142,
0.0421105102,
0.0186035838,
0.0057573882,
-0.0278027151,
-0.0154137947,
0.0207750741,
0.0034699026,
0.0145581663,
0.0810419247,
0.0344872028,
0.0094037568,
-0.0058025937,
0.0398995019,
-0.0072100689,
0.0218155868,
0.0054052593,
-0.0019489083,
-0.0167844333,
0.006522222,
-0.0004859438,
0.0582198873,
-0.0064432197,
0.0710542277,
0.0308951661,
0.015366408,
0.0073338593,
0.0355206802,
-0.043480318,
0.0039540562,
-0.0514835678,
0.0144209629,
0.01219323,
-0.0207940228,
-0.0055083418,
0.0072258511,
0.0101904888,
0.00532672,
0.0239997916,
0.0131124659,
-0.010233216,
0.004698209,
0.0168642439,
0.0329741947,
-0.0145149194,
0.0880810618,
0.0133809485,
0.0052327155,
0.0103101591,
-0.0098769916,
-0.0728195906,
0.012137711,
0.0695697144,
0.0565509647,
-0.0021639054,
0.0162774324,
0.0167398583,
-0.0004699651,
0.0145119186,
0.012309419,
0.0032392049,
0.0280064251,
0.0274643525,
0.0230172668,
-0.01034634,
-0.0499637462,
0.0125072645,
0.0426544547,
0.0351159535,
-0.007287886,
0.0028261503,
-6.084782305e-33,
-0.0410305448,
-0.0472739786,
0.0032548788,
-0.0256118849,
-0.0007447274,
0.0227048472,
-0.0348201208,
-0.0447287634,
0.0035817456,
-0.0154703073,
-0.0148385735,
0.0108101554,
0.0246003494,
0.061196886,
-0.034086749,
-0.0003533118,
0.0729677975,
-0.0131001072,
-0.0229718052,
-0.0076784603,
-0.0070540099,
0.0426638238,
0.0388553254,
-0.0428705588,
0.0109651405,
-0.0079464568,
-0.0109019885,
-0.0257821158,
0.0034375149,
0.0183245223,
-0.0166524649,
-0.0029616754,
0.0237664618,
-0.0289772842,
-0.0542284139,
0.0568500496,
-0.1189023405,
0.0092821913,
-0.0185537636,
0.0503579602,
-0.0470294319,
-0.0276278779,
0.0371878929,
0.0014019035,
0.0358058698,
-0.0465583615,
0.0486787148,
0.0027046986,
-0.0033733156,
-0.0169596467,
-0.0416978672,
0.0173786301,
-0.0345230028,
-0.030333858,
0.0914183259,
0.0141895805,
0.0181416869,
-0.0035939624,
-0.0810708553,
-0.029206574,
0.0345519111,
0.0444544889,
0.0670469552,
0.0768328607,
0.0037655272,
0.0014290962,
0.0104364557,
-0.0104538947,
-0.023525184,
0.0004212006,
0.0188226476,
0.0330255553,
0.0341697149,
0.0198905673,
0.086007908,
0.0360582545,
-0.0487308763,
0.0384220816,
-0.0588917658,
0.0488130972,
0.0268943459,
0.0395368896,
0.0180685427,
0.02897067,
-0.0204403885,
-0.0202959888,
-0.019461384,
-0.0139115714,
0.0353978798,
0.0489038005,
-0.0068896227,
0.0218260922,
0.086418286,
-0.0257895403,
0.0093077281,
0.0156879332,
0.0190432407,
0.0386272892,
-0.0129892314,
0.0114059402,
-0.0636167899,
-0.0410669222,
0.1011297554,
-0.0085816095,
-0.0174886305,
-0.0134648392,
0.0417548157,
-0.0075316615,
-0.0538071617,
-0.0219724141,
-0.030514393,
0.0280975327,
0.0385104641,
0.0594323762,
0.0410200469,
-0.0101023884,
-0.055883795,
0.041915033,
-0.0394370779,
0.0043053953,
-0.0301915109,
-0.0172761716,
0.0008270065,
0.047047209,
-0.0159612969,
0.0060896128,
-0.0495447032,
-0.0299313981,
0.0305114258,
-0.0096723409,
0.0101887966,
0.0747955441,
2.565e-7,
0.0426896177,
0.0232419763,
0.0654599443,
-0.0293592792,
0.0408674777,
0.0307512954,
-0.0011304106,
0.0147579089,
-0.0250889361,
-0.077129893,
0.0330239907,
0.0325401835,
0.0494490266,
0.0113867028,
-0.041329436,
-0.015332453,
-0.0040104864,
-0.0008818544,
-0.0520134643,
0.0070503131,
0.0476669297,
0.0787139535,
-0.0640212372,
0.0076088957,
0.0557328388,
-0.0166477766,
0.0649688467,
0.0074463002,
0.0225984901,
-0.0105690267,
0.0199829899,
-0.0163080338,
-0.0419789664,
0.0468928181,
0.0027490156,
0.0013479949,
0.0382313952,
0.0338018984,
-0.0438522622,
-0.015358096,
-0.0089426814,
0.0457216091,
-0.0274531916,
-0.0677784607,
0.0484664403,
-0.0419685729,
-0.0202323347,
-0.0291916989,
-0.0858669877,
0.0067685191,
-0.0139297508,
0.0181032065,
-0.0084622884,
0.0512989685,
0.0295185745,
-0.0182448793,
-0.0135157062,
-0.0578692481,
-0.0103998436,
-0.0311434753,
-0.0228580739,
0.0073324195,
-0.0904621631,
-0.012713179,
0.0578945503,
-0.0310792197,
-0.0535831265,
2.105200868e-34,
0.0135729918,
-0.0293088686,
0.0072934306,
0.028608406,
0.0431479029,
-0.0490390919,
-0.0391948596,
-0.0019808332,
0.0037503983,
-0.097493574,
-0.0120308027
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.09520v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.09520v1 | DLUE: Benchmarking Document Language Understanding | 2023-05-16T15:16:24 | 2023-05-16T15:16:24 | Ruoxi Xu, Hongyu Lin, Xinyan Guan, Xianpei Han, Yingfei Sun, Le Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL | Understanding documents is central to many real-world tasks but remains a
challenging topic. Unfortunately, there is no well-established consensus on how
to comprehensively evaluate document understanding abilities, which
significantly hinders the fair comparison and measuring the progress of the
field. To benchmark document understanding researches, this paper summarizes
four representative abilities, i.e., document classification, document
structural analysis, document information extraction, and document
transcription. Under the new evaluation framework, we propose \textbf{Document
Language Understanding Evaluation} -- \textbf{DLUE}, a new task suite which
covers a wide-range of tasks in various forms, domains and document genres. We
also systematically evaluate six well-established transformer models on DLUE,
and find that due to the lengthy content, complicated underlying structure and
dispersed knowledge, document understanding is still far from being solved, and
currently there is no neural architecture that dominates all tasks, raising
requirements for a universal document understanding architecture. | [
0.03596792,
0.0382970385,
0.0197395962,
0.045158498,
-0.0063761054,
0.0503361151,
0.0147828739,
-0.0131386369,
-0.0445518158,
-0.018222129,
-0.0618256815,
-0.0302064177,
0.0093745384,
0.0299604908,
-0.0174660254,
-0.0354900546,
0.0378776453,
-0.0186765138,
-0.0020471215,
0.0561314374,
-0.0168330409,
-0.003130107,
-0.0131765995,
-0.0090812678,
0.0064388993,
-0.0492797568,
-0.0166827738,
0.0139799891,
0.0091491686,
-0.0152402138,
0.0008692355,
0.0355769023,
0.052390825,
0.0823670775,
0.000001877,
-0.0293486342,
-0.0307570044,
0.0164608732,
-0.0311919991,
-0.0262834691,
0.0577422231,
-0.0837706625,
-0.0039437404,
-0.0319629163,
-0.0090659689,
-0.0409579575,
0.0162118655,
0.0844437554,
0.0211559925,
0.0898056105,
-0.0246550236,
-0.0630498976,
0.057437554,
-0.0371672735,
0.0480592884,
-0.0713496804,
-0.0024438673,
0.0155069521,
0.0115271518,
0.0216756947,
-0.0209029559,
0.0307116359,
0.0190139599,
-0.0399812274,
0.0250718575,
0.0171139091,
-0.0209105927,
-0.0273632091,
0.0062678908,
0.0920649171,
0.0046218783,
0.0079778582,
0.0216600783,
0.0219340809,
0.0122719901,
-0.0011988811,
-0.0660338253,
-0.0059798355,
-0.0282352138,
-0.0185605139,
0.0387519896,
0.0373139717,
0.0354662091,
-0.0043306956,
-0.0351627767,
0.0494810678,
-0.0165205766,
-0.0276346356,
0.0310939066,
0.0048247837,
0.0177418124,
0.0079875719,
0.0353204906,
0.0319629312,
0.0049417592,
0.0105552999,
-0.0050440738,
-0.0691795796,
0.0078587132,
-0.0733394325,
0.0083321938,
0.0090657873,
-0.0149905095,
0.1149120629,
-0.0733921528,
0.077960372,
-0.0287629981,
0.019874718,
-0.0254973229,
-0.0125318347,
-0.0386211537,
0.0071511087,
-0.0246106386,
0.0101675419,
-0.023695197,
-0.0708974972,
0.0171864927,
0.014426006,
0.0137601616,
0.0275151152,
0.0126817031,
-0.0147487111,
-0.0566595271,
-0.0380686484,
0.0162070002,
0.023335902,
-0.0229612831,
0.0105705447,
-0.0253419001,
-0.0158710517,
-0.0015007204,
0.0254697856,
0.0004056176,
-0.0190149602,
-0.0005327045,
0.0498032384,
-0.0212090202,
-0.0319235735,
-0.0240741186,
0.0174911637,
0.0447466746,
-0.0576732457,
0.0552529804,
-0.0176066663,
0.0503727645,
0.000362077,
0.0041364473,
-0.0130617376,
-0.0303262454,
-0.0221417416,
-0.000752302,
0.0954089314,
0.0094717462,
-0.0102849295,
0.0667558312,
0.0368243083,
-0.0295715686,
0.0570491105,
0.0068575586,
0.0435990654,
0.0115341516,
-0.011027527,
0.006691345,
0.022461351,
-0.0118527822,
-0.0434235819,
0.027580861,
0.0229416601,
-0.0123959705,
0.0072093611,
0.0298113022,
-0.0070842206,
-0.0240247995,
-0.0301006157,
0.0224722978,
0.0371859558,
0.0425905213,
0.0142201753,
0.0203164835,
0.0069699287,
0.0172811784,
0.0116774039,
-0.0447044745,
0.0210874099,
0.0171151999,
0.0149542922,
-0.0602350943,
-0.0048095379,
-0.0275546852,
-0.0049961833,
-0.0194487199,
-0.0109028732,
0.0142709604,
-0.0293105263,
0.0772083029,
0.0235599168,
-0.0424105376,
0.0362202413,
-0.009513733,
-0.0431930684,
-0.0016935027,
-0.012304618,
0.0268137641,
0.0222646166,
0.050886862,
-0.04231105,
-0.039568115,
-0.0171927325,
0.0039893803,
0.0533179156,
0.0443346873,
-0.0199832227,
0.0425780527,
-0.0593907982,
-0.0092289345,
-0.026710216,
0.0138549358,
0.0115248775,
-0.0134282168,
-0.0206178557,
0.0274806041,
-0.1116149947,
-0.0190565716,
0.0473191924,
-0.0170381069,
-0.0577488579,
-0.0037493717,
0.0165184569,
0.0128402859,
0.0026555767,
-0.0142077794,
-0.0098721115,
0.0106308581,
-0.0367650464,
0.0134358257,
-0.0117871286,
-0.0354099683,
-0.0126722716,
0.010408218,
-0.0636361688,
-0.0607562996,
0.0527159534,
-0.0640476421,
-0.0432498008,
0.0058807833,
-0.0241494626,
-0.0102779474,
-0.0387708545,
-0.0034921521,
-0.0217193514,
0.021822691,
-0.0251759663,
0.0465201885,
0.011265222,
-0.0014505649,
0.0174225401,
-0.0165192597,
0.026478963,
-0.0045298049,
-0.0414405651,
0.0047969427,
-0.0070759133,
-0.0065548867,
0.0041600922,
0.0170846693,
-0.035708826,
-0.0512216128,
-0.0560756922,
-0.0000330396,
-0.0206291247,
0.0510155223,
0.0442695767,
0.0113478908,
0.000538671,
-0.0478324108,
-0.0761466995,
-0.0057867956,
-0.0167288538,
-0.0356475823,
0.0502446629,
-0.0086595556,
-0.0053695422,
-0.0210238136,
-0.0325027257,
-0.0232582316,
0.0520496555,
0.0571186878,
-0.0244753864,
-0.0180558693,
0.0208587758,
0.0205721818,
0.0087847374,
-0.0265612304,
0.0001305779,
-0.0044738958,
-0.0390326232,
0.0205946453,
0.1001747698,
0.0059249625,
0.043003656,
-0.0011787839,
-0.0038261448,
-0.0394380689,
0.0068779895,
0.0015416939,
0.0636258796,
-0.0309663974,
-0.0325030573,
0.0319481231,
0.0919071957,
-0.0123479366,
0.0288055539,
-0.0179627966,
-0.0237552598,
-0.0291571971,
-0.0166426934,
-0.028172316,
-0.0134632094,
0.0286080576,
0.0350355916,
-0.0299373008,
0.006106637,
0.0587365963,
-0.0469832867,
-0.0319950655,
-0.0397380926,
0.0049376045,
-0.0599456206,
0.043642737,
0.0062372875,
0.0149545092,
-0.0218503624,
-0.0668184906,
-0.0146423168,
0.0091045219,
0.0234608594,
-0.0290887337,
0.0292749777,
-0.0068724444,
0.0298947208,
-0.0492896475,
-0.032529369,
-0.0170342904,
-0.0248446874,
0.0052784365,
0.0264978185,
0.016916167,
-0.0224328339,
-0.0711658746,
0.0202681441,
0.0099435262,
0.0948682353,
-0.0377390645,
-0.0260082856,
-0.0106997974,
0.0944490358,
0.0180615596,
0.0121826781,
0.0482110344,
-0.052874431,
0.0333589055,
0.0371649861,
0.0047317357,
-0.011377383,
-0.0494287089,
0.0177071858,
-0.003291897,
-0.0600389242,
-0.0061859442,
-0.0457226969,
0.0100320205,
-0.0887876004,
-0.0186298955,
0.1349551082,
0.0164638516,
-0.055192031,
-0.0504916348,
-0.0480508953,
-0.0035591242,
0.0139325503,
0.0261543449,
-0.0852933303,
-0.0177710522,
0.0118681509,
0.0198613945,
0.0587777756,
-0.0246693958,
0.0231824126,
-0.0346405655,
0.0480101667,
-0.0133988643,
-0.0366427228,
-0.0175299868,
-0.0163157396,
0.0005896845,
-0.0168023724,
0.0127215516,
0.0011178628,
-0.0080619985,
-0.0306387134,
0.0093366029,
-0.0113896225,
-0.0127990609,
0.0324125327,
-0.0051134406,
0.0105136409,
0.0382765532,
0.0382446423,
-0.0139020495,
-0.0225775093,
0.0392556116,
-0.0094298515,
0.0102161197,
0.0179227628,
0.0529779084,
-0.0011486734,
0.0111466302,
-0.0072641568,
0.0171145853,
-0.0782870725,
0.0156015269,
-0.0107650906,
0.0435628481,
-0.0205945522,
-0.0317022949,
-0.0277056787,
-0.0132311415,
-0.0235965587,
0.0841479599,
0.0390088223,
-0.0210292488,
-0.0533867143,
-0.0106768031,
0.0219650678,
-0.0629111975,
0.0330080949,
0.0070622256,
0.0119907921,
-0.009245323,
-0.0508442149,
-0.0563840307,
-0.0069110901,
-0.0210415125,
-0.0090172933,
-0.0374662504,
0.0076358686,
-0.0406093672,
-0.0613191091,
0.0404556282,
0.017868327,
-0.0007410593,
-0.0572984405,
0.0346033797,
0.0213502999,
-0.0102335317,
-0.0331834666,
0.0201209411,
-0.0878349319,
0.0057601859,
0.0138165234,
-0.008276986,
0.0225146487,
0.0408943146,
-0.0375754014,
-0.0043976353,
0.0226883162,
-0.0076280674,
-0.066861622,
-0.0236929804,
0.0407251529,
-0.0348439887,
-0.0097208079,
0.0352024175,
-0.0424268469,
0.0326181501,
-0.0046218038,
-0.0019567818,
-0.0126360534,
0.0040586418,
-0.017579291,
0.0061570732,
-0.0017548811,
0.0297860391,
0.0482607707,
-0.0448913239,
0.0327905603,
0.0022277101,
-0.020785518,
-0.0192972105,
-0.0204870831,
0.0588956252,
-0.0152972909,
-0.0190692861,
0.0654982105,
0.0045828945,
0.0324725136,
-0.0237219464,
0.0217425432,
0.0432404839,
-0.0068871672,
-0.0292890705,
-0.0115695857,
-0.0222939439,
0.0144005707,
0.013147315,
0.0720904395,
-0.0072824256,
0.0649564192,
0.0259759147,
0.0208902638,
-0.0124817425,
0.0239545852,
-0.0855732411,
-0.0145321637,
-0.0014502211,
0.0062684584,
0.0121148787,
-0.0252377931,
0.0378064923,
-0.0015620554,
-0.0059693158,
0.0057569682,
0.0221902337,
0.0105471341,
0.0114566972,
0.003251195,
0.022420736,
0.0399710499,
-0.0092792492,
0.0719585344,
0.0000057261,
0.00425037,
0.0088973017,
-0.0009953849,
-0.0717636496,
0.016879417,
0.0022425787,
-0.0018531259,
-0.0205176957,
0.0175792724,
-0.027269043,
-0.0157407038,
0.0474680439,
0.0138930297,
0.0107741356,
0.0046803849,
-0.008196339,
0.0626747161,
0.0061083003,
-0.0204927735,
-0.0431182422,
0.0247606896,
-0.0306112319,
-0.0123659214,
-0.0109037878,
-5.846290664e-33,
-0.0481862165,
0.0035602222,
-0.016069103,
0.0275229476,
-0.0116380583,
0.0442737676,
-0.0683263913,
-0.0473554246,
-0.018498145,
0.0387375727,
-0.0293543637,
0.0272757951,
0.0164927654,
0.0190403387,
-0.0153925866,
-0.0037383693,
0.0442379415,
-0.0303691048,
-0.0350083187,
0.0229600053,
0.0424628146,
0.0475677475,
0.0715235174,
-0.0753843561,
0.054560028,
0.0074037784,
-0.0205407925,
0.0197163709,
0.0328888558,
0.0632022321,
-0.0126035325,
-0.05186674,
0.0553976931,
-0.0573331006,
-0.0251875613,
0.0460080616,
-0.1551201791,
-0.0139504382,
-0.0183391124,
0.060794998,
-0.0189287178,
0.0010533531,
0.0392461829,
-0.0190529339,
0.0447601937,
-0.0671850741,
0.0483522788,
-0.0194009393,
-0.000954805,
-0.0551473089,
-0.0839029476,
0.0445438772,
-0.0383055843,
-0.0010721637,
0.0593056604,
0.0384092629,
-0.0319843329,
0.0460680723,
-0.0940147862,
-0.031400729,
-0.0300719123,
0.0170862302,
0.0435647555,
0.0082509145,
-0.028646294,
0.0310345795,
0.014337643,
-0.0144652855,
-0.028290851,
-0.0266192872,
0.0476672724,
0.0379523374,
0.0175424106,
0.0070983078,
0.0550162941,
0.0291164741,
-0.0532222092,
0.0804830864,
0.0310183913,
0.0598866381,
-0.0071787606,
0.0140245818,
-0.0270939954,
0.0325173065,
-0.0320303291,
-0.0160536114,
-0.0519608855,
0.0073440033,
-0.0021505831,
-0.020182481,
-0.0146469316,
-0.0186934937,
0.0571307912,
-0.0712508634,
0.0192267485,
0.0512177125,
-0.005292282,
0.0224261153,
0.0161208268,
0.00316951,
-0.0314643309,
-0.0350747108,
0.0290140491,
0.0581111908,
0.0110391546,
-0.0182223823,
0.0753933489,
-0.0051346957,
-0.02335044,
-0.0241774414,
-0.0312497467,
-0.0054259598,
-0.0091863908,
0.0931906104,
0.007667074,
-0.0114848847,
-0.0254031736,
0.0439074785,
-0.0060820831,
0.037698105,
-0.0101714507,
0.0315774083,
0.0267633963,
0.055067353,
-0.0590245724,
-0.0330575705,
-0.0090095662,
-0.0092793526,
0.0444374904,
-0.05861222,
0.0255334824,
0.0443830416,
2.473e-7,
0.0654958636,
0.0394922122,
0.0715851262,
-0.0003400481,
0.0288658217,
0.0308629069,
-0.024556499,
0.0171859339,
-0.0247826707,
-0.0072144009,
0.0137254894,
0.0199290495,
0.0661844313,
0.014727571,
-0.0787691027,
-0.0216221437,
-0.0588971376,
-0.009062645,
-0.041176334,
0.012322953,
0.016720105,
0.0720677525,
-0.0585758537,
-0.03980783,
0.014338416,
-0.0406830721,
0.0740218535,
-0.0126337595,
0.0284587536,
0.0355280675,
0.0466382764,
-0.0085362568,
-0.0034850994,
-0.0006362341,
-0.0000550992,
0.0505361781,
0.0512398407,
0.0708595812,
0.0002812581,
0.0187056176,
0.0099956552,
-0.0281610824,
0.0230639391,
-0.0793958306,
0.0423343964,
-0.0373003297,
-0.0417937674,
-0.0311430003,
-0.0429916866,
-0.0062884474,
0.0108986991,
-0.0038796852,
0.0215492565,
0.0346680097,
0.0325874537,
-0.0506410673,
-0.0164591931,
-0.0631545633,
-0.0143010281,
0.0001426273,
-0.0160800666,
0.019926779,
-0.0265117753,
0.0039510159,
0.0239624288,
-0.0230884254,
-0.0177222695,
1.916001035e-34,
0.0284139328,
-0.0005164343,
-0.0281188786,
0.0174573325,
0.023625534,
-0.0311606005,
-0.0185812302,
-0.0089315204,
-0.0270368475,
-0.0993701816,
0.0209613536
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2305.09515v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2305.09515v3 | AR-Diffusion: Auto-Regressive Diffusion Model for Text Generation | 2023-05-16T15:10:22 | 2023-12-13T10:24:00 | Tong Wu, Zhihao Fan, Xiao Liu, Yeyun Gong, Yelong Shen, Jian Jiao, Hai-Tao Zheng, Juntao Li, Zhongyu Wei, Jian Guo, Nan Duan, Weizhu Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Diffusion models have gained significant attention in the realm of image
generation due to their exceptional performance. Their success has been
recently expanded to text generation via generating all tokens within a
sequence concurrently. However, natural language exhibits a far more pronounced
sequential dependency in comparison to images, and the majority of existing
language models are trained with a left-to-right auto-regressive approach. To
account for the inherent sequential characteristic of natural language, we
introduce Auto-Regressive Diffusion (AR-Diffusion). AR-Diffusion ensures that
the generation of tokens on the right depends on the generated ones on the
left, a mechanism achieved through employing a dynamic number of denoising
steps that vary based on token position. This results in tokens on the left
undergoing fewer denoising steps than those on the right, thereby enabling them
to generate earlier and subsequently influence the generation of tokens on the
right. In a series of experiments on various text generation tasks, including
text summarization, machine translation, and common sense generation,
AR-Diffusion clearly demonstrated its superiority over existing diffusion
language models and that it can be $100\times\sim600\times$ faster when
achieving comparable results. Our code is available at
https://github.com/microsoft/ProphetNet/tree/master/AR-diffusion. | [
0.0097643025,
0.0448023081,
0.0116988355,
-0.0000149512,
-0.0187266171,
-0.0163772851,
0.0132011222,
-0.0084710149,
-0.0164801013,
-0.0002744862,
0.0260362364,
-0.0610879399,
0.0168583039,
0.0507575907,
0.0416740477,
-0.0473816842,
0.0152420299,
-0.0298904739,
-0.0089429105,
0.0011749704,
0.0049685682,
0.0101762973,
0.0044150688,
0.018684661,
-0.0402677357,
-0.0269925557,
-0.0164692421,
0.0346875526,
0.0241597723,
-0.0183536392,
-0.0141599141,
0.0516611561,
0.0371727161,
0.0003505639,
0.0000019628,
0.010154089,
-0.0033412101,
0.0132268276,
0.0424759649,
-0.0024497309,
0.0488495901,
0.0143540306,
-0.015841024,
0.0048066219,
-0.0228110701,
0.0075065331,
0.0453717075,
0.0355218761,
0.1059505716,
0.0668866187,
-0.0144588891,
-0.058136899,
0.0221409574,
-0.0661863089,
0.0439728051,
-0.0089095486,
0.0174679291,
0.020589618,
-0.0053440002,
-0.0220564771,
-0.03694994,
0.0225492734,
0.040150173,
-0.0330502689,
0.0493005142,
0.0711902305,
0.021660449,
-0.0510763638,
-0.0159910508,
0.0743359178,
-0.0272016749,
-0.0231533758,
0.0309909973,
0.0043097092,
-0.0209061187,
-0.0160951372,
-0.0485949181,
0.038932886,
0.0117390985,
0.0432011969,
-0.0123505183,
-0.0085194213,
0.0136052286,
0.0193516705,
-0.017761698,
0.0021682098,
0.0052644084,
-0.0056798421,
-0.0637933835,
-0.0006722812,
0.0004817857,
-0.0820662081,
0.0272453707,
0.0395549461,
-0.0069069075,
0.0004654885,
-0.0732935816,
-0.0626488104,
0.0050345371,
0.0046120323,
-0.0044378201,
0.024306545,
0.0103450287,
0.0150091797,
-0.0681758597,
0.0293099452,
-0.0241924599,
-0.0212371983,
-0.0511104688,
0.0123545649,
-0.0057002637,
-0.0132122086,
-0.0472515225,
0.0612680912,
-0.0495697856,
-0.0504226945,
-0.0917250216,
0.0137605099,
0.0178643558,
-0.025723977,
0.0242465772,
0.0146568101,
-0.0492495298,
-0.0060644262,
0.0119286813,
-0.0073617031,
-0.0302355047,
-0.0226162933,
0.0595759079,
0.0190963801,
-0.0308489725,
0.0361466557,
0.0401517265,
0.0006783793,
-0.0293339808,
0.0694610476,
-0.0498453826,
0.0117859179,
-0.0202638544,
-0.0453560911,
-0.0091531808,
-0.0428215005,
0.0072669513,
-0.0766834766,
0.0062300703,
-0.0086139496,
-0.0248939451,
-0.0214977115,
0.0275555942,
0.0430124216,
-0.0094018532,
0.0138051789,
-0.0273059662,
-0.0052558021,
0.0559520647,
0.0017187929,
0.0309103765,
0.0529346876,
0.0452277809,
0.0729289129,
-0.0195685904,
0.0375156067,
-0.0288933441,
0.0090964073,
0.0597094856,
0.0243060105,
-0.028230004,
-0.0428178199,
-0.0354917347,
0.0493613109,
0.0763156563,
0.0810165405,
-0.0716364831,
0.0141996294,
0.065326862,
0.0345439538,
-0.0146418121,
-0.0031891481,
0.0913762227,
0.0140278833,
-0.0371601135,
0.0409192629,
0.0093902219,
0.0395808369,
0.0461100265,
0.0357457213,
0.0648550913,
0.0299487468,
-0.0365405791,
-0.0479539484,
0.0430482253,
-0.0341043212,
0.0430346392,
-0.0603589341,
0.0379678719,
0.0690094158,
-0.0657296777,
0.030123353,
-0.014003858,
-0.0567207448,
0.010093675,
-0.0460830107,
0.0282473061,
0.0361111201,
0.051566124,
0.0239552036,
-0.0101143681,
-0.0026144888,
0.0307358969,
0.0680238307,
0.0171709545,
0.0242626406,
-0.0276304446,
-0.0556726046,
-0.0109717362,
0.0033182064,
-0.0124588655,
0.0329535604,
-0.0314079188,
0.0499324091,
0.044023551,
0.002164203,
-0.0346898623,
0.0290904325,
-0.0311170854,
-0.0073012402,
0.0273510888,
-0.0020928544,
-0.0015348792,
-0.0079403538,
-0.0170456767,
0.0366583727,
0.0083523802,
-0.0538581386,
-0.0510541163,
0.0418477207,
-0.0921520069,
-0.054893937,
0.0089822263,
-0.0376732275,
-0.0106764743,
-0.000155366,
-0.0252317637,
-0.06330733,
0.0613768958,
-0.0226028189,
0.0162476841,
-0.0603747033,
0.0027890373,
0.0681893453,
0.0322826207,
0.0017350661,
0.0736345723,
-0.0442701615,
0.0049806843,
0.0075386688,
0.0231139455,
-0.0076944805,
-0.0137943905,
0.0255644526,
-0.0638656467,
-0.0129615217,
0.0036233691,
0.0128836948,
0.018466983,
-0.0258249864,
-0.0204647891,
-0.0582783557,
0.0252157822,
-0.0201086346,
-0.0091559179,
0.0235741306,
0.0316181034,
0.0095725143,
-0.0171636026,
-0.0581981689,
0.0140668675,
0.0261491723,
-0.002944292,
0.057218384,
-0.0186631735,
0.0032562695,
-0.0406802483,
-0.0208103135,
0.0054458603,
0.0357648097,
0.0043045664,
-0.0006036324,
-0.0228576139,
-0.014804096,
-0.0353378877,
0.0001684859,
-0.0105785988,
-0.0473472886,
0.0108279772,
-0.0073462469,
0.0682393163,
0.01825458,
0.0483399779,
0.048165068,
-0.0352091566,
-0.0047858479,
0.0132647362,
0.0098065333,
-0.0334625579,
0.0770230368,
0.011487091,
-0.0540584289,
-0.0032521903,
0.0678596944,
0.0303243604,
-0.0023520512,
-0.0559050776,
0.0192268379,
-0.0262024142,
-0.0590646043,
-0.0119963288,
-0.040559113,
-0.0260743909,
-0.0097801322,
-0.0683777332,
-0.064050287,
0.0478443094,
-0.0517992489,
0.0009811603,
-0.0229149405,
0.007963731,
-0.0181762259,
0.020187486,
0.0484716631,
0.0500909686,
0.0013770168,
-0.0208603404,
-0.0383614935,
-0.0034653242,
0.0185156483,
-0.0200042315,
0.0390172005,
-0.03121024,
0.0157982111,
-0.0326444358,
-0.0114728501,
-0.0324936993,
-0.0473145209,
0.0471772365,
0.0146499975,
0.0024024132,
-0.0191278532,
-0.0042246585,
0.0001521549,
0.0124443723,
0.0441069044,
-0.0227581654,
-0.0089927958,
-0.022446312,
0.0862313956,
0.057001289,
-0.0230012722,
-0.0153506054,
-0.0514895767,
0.0263634324,
0.0501968637,
0.0426799096,
0.0042474507,
-0.0383636579,
-0.0024380162,
-0.0521857813,
-0.0067496221,
-0.0055496166,
0.0199854206,
0.1029284373,
-0.0240221992,
-0.0173796434,
0.0735896677,
0.0038279137,
-0.0179529842,
0.0044947644,
0.0362277701,
0.1002881452,
0.012074206,
-0.0335742161,
-0.0822668374,
-0.0165845864,
-0.0092324335,
0.0133453533,
0.0111638475,
-0.0239312947,
-0.0298815724,
-0.0646218732,
0.048417069,
0.028431505,
-0.0445805825,
0.0040900535,
-0.0278188791,
-0.0459204242,
0.032663215,
0.0075200307,
0.0006307233,
-0.0072874739,
0.023621086,
0.0428301692,
0.0110863056,
-0.015468007,
-0.0394713134,
-0.0291583892,
0.0064277933,
0.0529927313,
0.0296419095,
-0.008595868,
-0.0495387577,
0.0481683016,
-0.0009275071,
0.0163923129,
-0.0040894998,
0.0094547672,
0.0139836362,
-0.0173061322,
-0.0019010722,
0.0279737767,
-0.0413776897,
-0.0079407105,
-0.0306480266,
0.0434846133,
0.0088819312,
-0.051066611,
-0.0574306883,
0.0299170427,
0.046240285,
0.0501166545,
0.0518823452,
-0.0398493484,
-0.0700972974,
-0.0175265633,
0.0302278586,
-0.0599205755,
-0.0408856981,
-0.0373140797,
0.019765541,
-0.0635841861,
-0.1233512908,
-0.0274863727,
-0.0245503876,
0.0706687421,
-0.0304804686,
0.0293607805,
-0.0049822419,
-0.0472887158,
-0.0415269583,
-0.0127705615,
0.0117129507,
0.0059932144,
-0.047082141,
-0.0167302899,
0.0057662795,
-0.0236220397,
-0.0311937723,
0.0320432223,
-0.1168690473,
-0.067648761,
-0.0128896702,
0.0549655855,
0.0205662809,
0.0459674187,
-0.0077264924,
-0.027530795,
0.0757184848,
0.0368544944,
0.0375652313,
0.0083232541,
-0.0132369865,
-0.032168027,
-0.018057799,
0.0178345647,
-0.0232974477,
0.0390430056,
-0.0005194057,
0.04586621,
-0.006067676,
0.0282091293,
0.0087451534,
-0.0088362228,
0.0052255616,
-0.0433261581,
0.0457351506,
-0.0301320758,
-0.0121342242,
-0.0207767747,
-0.0051767919,
-0.0603416897,
0.0258582495,
0.0266347826,
-0.0068771858,
-0.0100313677,
0.0036006002,
0.0034911297,
0.01834164,
0.0037823084,
-0.0087704165,
-0.0111531289,
0.0443966985,
0.0223264843,
-0.024369413,
-0.0199336968,
-0.0198068731,
-0.0463816114,
0.0121343331,
-0.0293886494,
0.0259066224,
0.0129396692,
0.0213382076,
-0.0000877293,
0.0265815202,
-0.0405748412,
-0.0155706704,
-0.0374256931,
0.0179300886,
0.0564870127,
0.014647983,
0.0713592619,
-0.0154236974,
0.0259315446,
-0.0183227547,
0.0433822721,
-0.0051377038,
-0.0149932066,
0.0021188653,
0.0069330311,
0.0015173671,
-0.0015682372,
0.1038541049,
-0.0091240844,
-0.0016361899,
-0.002367992,
0.0143320942,
-0.0330734514,
-0.0181402713,
-0.0156239569,
-0.0218699239,
0.0093864873,
0.0155551843,
-0.0012156534,
-0.0769904777,
0.0231176168,
0.0218159445,
0.0276464671,
0.0074323541,
0.0653295889,
0.0456392094,
0.0028524238,
0.0008308868,
-0.0522764884,
0.039421767,
-0.0170639958,
-0.0237337146,
-0.0028767008,
-6.283863661e-33,
-0.0236048829,
-0.0374769829,
0.0176261626,
-0.0431424864,
-0.0558813848,
-0.0165494531,
-0.057815928,
0.0053547514,
0.0291692074,
0.0210364908,
0.0029390857,
0.0186360907,
0.0082758646,
0.0411060974,
-0.0149290524,
0.0604282245,
0.0628132001,
-0.038967751,
-0.0127364751,
0.061745055,
0.0213453695,
0.0292861033,
-0.0040799766,
0.0045728572,
-0.0188530982,
-0.0216761772,
-0.0050695031,
-0.0164826121,
0.036745362,
0.0182171222,
-0.0201296434,
-0.0011167438,
0.0283570159,
-0.0005376707,
-0.0611937493,
0.0306549929,
-0.0516630821,
-0.0345908366,
-0.0255248547,
-0.0269847065,
-0.0742797479,
-0.0286536403,
0.0805450007,
-0.0278043393,
0.017085366,
0.0384146608,
0.0487908535,
0.0231545977,
-0.0405595228,
-0.0151693588,
-0.0535100251,
0.0380895212,
-0.0255683456,
-0.034634497,
-0.0277295187,
-0.0053011659,
0.0007431565,
0.0066429628,
-0.0602525659,
0.0036897664,
-0.0134656196,
0.0643785894,
0.0292162541,
0.0206086896,
0.0173460841,
0.0508414581,
0.0328062139,
0.0160107818,
-0.0215402208,
0.0273309499,
0.0063549294,
0.029440539,
0.0142701603,
0.0014150772,
0.0272454508,
-0.0313902982,
-0.0846249238,
0.0419130325,
-0.0350452587,
0.0292555466,
0.0339845344,
0.0063080005,
0.0199747849,
0.0099512255,
-0.0108459108,
-0.0366477817,
-0.0007117492,
-0.0200035628,
0.012317745,
0.0531546064,
-0.0281197671,
-0.0301109385,
0.0308937617,
0.0082566598,
-0.0226346515,
0.0063532391,
-0.0354569554,
0.0147861158,
0.0035720137,
0.0267131124,
-0.0672584474,
-0.0323779695,
0.0184232742,
0.0670930967,
-0.0008438334,
0.0276065674,
0.0212097466,
0.002259017,
-0.0403124094,
0.0032838795,
-0.0274447165,
0.0616242066,
-0.0031267365,
0.0268824212,
0.0183383059,
-0.0204239711,
-0.0211267453,
0.0260259639,
-0.0079419035,
0.0056528896,
0.0142401252,
0.0295345932,
-0.0073247501,
0.0479413979,
-0.0526934192,
0.0048496784,
-0.0508278199,
0.0737579688,
0.0571566857,
-0.0693128705,
-0.0449830964,
0.0487441346,
2.615e-7,
0.0087023629,
0.0070002512,
0.0612243414,
0.0217024609,
0.0306058843,
0.0057392567,
-0.021250587,
0.0350700021,
-0.0048344941,
-0.0228586346,
0.0069450079,
0.0236621946,
0.0308853649,
0.0009548785,
-0.0873006657,
0.0181504954,
-0.0821855143,
0.0362309627,
-0.0142389713,
-0.0126860775,
0.0274305567,
0.0459997989,
-0.0485346355,
-0.0186601896,
0.0282889381,
-0.0108028594,
0.0936811939,
0.0610567592,
0.0005559637,
0.0041979817,
0.0087543782,
-0.0323488638,
-0.0225868765,
-0.0389090776,
-0.0360138901,
-0.0107295671,
0.0475695133,
0.0129062748,
-0.0256618876,
-0.0394602716,
0.0446574502,
0.0060581272,
0.0103122909,
-0.0156230824,
0.0512303188,
-0.0230022632,
-0.0078676157,
-0.0473658182,
-0.0489004627,
0.0412046388,
0.0228194054,
-0.0281398706,
-0.0813342854,
0.0313676149,
0.0450939536,
0.0169099662,
-0.0117444955,
-0.0613218695,
-0.0264700148,
-0.0340373367,
-0.0622071289,
-0.0206721351,
-0.083886683,
0.0006770306,
0.0056479671,
0.0170519669,
-0.049686458,
2.305261053e-34,
0.0700332224,
-0.0425094254,
-0.0175324604,
-0.0110099334,
0.0065811891,
-0.0172321443,
-0.0169955436,
0.0309544448,
-0.0106559331,
-0.0463978872,
-0.0497814119
] |
Subsets and Splits
No saved queries yet
Save your SQL queries to embed, download, and access them later. Queries will appear here once saved.