id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.03569v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.03569v1 | Text Simplification of Scientific Texts for Non-Expert Readers | 2023-07-07T13:05:11 | 2023-07-07T13:05:11 | Björn Engelmann, Fabian Haak, Christin Katharina Kreutz, Narjes Nikzad Khasmakhi, Philipp Schaer | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | Reading levels are highly individual and can depend on a text's language, a
person's cognitive abilities, or knowledge on a topic. Text simplification is
the task of rephrasing a text to better cater to the abilities of a specific
target reader group. Simplification of scientific abstracts helps non-experts
to access the core information by bypassing formulations that require domain or
expert knowledge. This is especially relevant for, e.g., cancer patients
reading about novel treatment options. The SimpleText lab hosts the
simplification of scientific abstracts for non-experts (Task 3) to advance this
field. We contribute three runs employing out-of-the-box summarization models
(two based on T5, one based on PEGASUS) and one run using ChatGPT with complex
phrase identification. | [
0.0290867854,
-0.0256783869,
-0.0019886224,
-0.0070177219,
-0.0474725626,
0.0144696133,
0.0113150859,
0.0272921026,
0.0065542744,
-0.0176538434,
0.0016003991,
0.0148991589,
0.0247217398,
0.0232007913,
0.0101631135,
-0.1264943033,
0.0206701551,
0.0090573067,
0.0507864319,
-0.0057688504,
0.0245877188,
0.0032622034,
-0.0077414238,
0.0229133666,
0.100040786,
-0.0370582044,
0.0474462807,
-0.0039602066,
0.0300179403,
-0.021619074,
0.0384806469,
0.0377290957,
-0.0053935442,
0.0142508149,
0.0000019824,
-0.0458877273,
-0.0616806485,
0.035920471,
0.0262506846,
0.0659253523,
0.1139376909,
-0.015722977,
0.0095816171,
0.0218270905,
-0.002216225,
0.0060684001,
0.0163468309,
0.0561028682,
0.0409298241,
0.0410953164,
-0.0211404208,
-0.0274800248,
-0.0158257131,
-0.017663857,
0.0232179407,
-0.0458836034,
0.0097872391,
0.023120746,
0.0164504312,
0.0341479927,
0.0271569844,
0.06317579,
-0.0314112157,
-0.0084937979,
0.0188062657,
0.0298631694,
-0.0407522395,
-0.0099027054,
0.0185000021,
0.0348108783,
0.0060560228,
-0.0321796387,
0.0540257394,
0.0149180628,
-0.0108228549,
0.044143416,
-0.0949091762,
-0.0157151613,
-0.0083838971,
-0.0087800715,
-0.0018597692,
0.0168370754,
-0.0189573374,
0.0174269509,
0.0125247594,
0.0014024314,
0.0215486549,
-0.0124883894,
-0.0300937444,
-0.0183607768,
-0.0046425164,
-0.060865704,
0.0701186582,
0.0270171892,
0.0264573861,
-0.0288242772,
-0.0224130042,
-0.1167821214,
0.0339568891,
-0.039950531,
-0.0461108088,
0.0167105496,
0.0398218445,
0.0332067274,
-0.0241081025,
-0.0260217711,
0.022772748,
0.0021257359,
-0.0231429506,
0.0253712106,
0.0111568021,
-0.0001950663,
-0.0430295803,
0.0184474494,
-0.0631829873,
-0.0129787289,
-0.0589020103,
-0.0186022092,
0.0379831791,
-0.0245798379,
-0.0132825105,
-0.0076536345,
-0.056999471,
-0.0343046598,
0.0306851882,
0.0535016023,
-0.01360921,
-0.024011597,
0.0035206266,
-0.046738565,
-0.0064299633,
0.0144173801,
0.0382702388,
0.0192179102,
-0.0149075454,
0.0091649042,
-0.0569739342,
-0.0204749759,
0.0301645435,
-0.0523674935,
0.0237147082,
-0.0100293411,
-0.002864124,
-0.0508970059,
0.0042142817,
0.0245477594,
0.0205629431,
-0.0277714822,
-0.0056316783,
0.0075824005,
-0.0576111414,
0.0305126272,
-0.0562864169,
-0.0075167664,
0.0527904183,
0.0380080119,
0.0046620616,
0.0076906886,
-0.0053293118,
-0.0003860685,
0.0388090722,
-0.0193674229,
0.0389119126,
-0.0116297537,
0.0049309516,
-0.0020116705,
0.0710158721,
-0.0127735473,
-0.0605451614,
0.0204178728,
0.0055309492,
0.0674271882,
-0.0340560637,
0.0414495133,
0.0491746441,
0.0908467621,
0.0126321828,
0.0349061377,
-0.0189055316,
0.0476528294,
0.0701901168,
0.0374880545,
0.0167477503,
0.018661147,
-0.0257607941,
0.0595423281,
0.0375197604,
0.0224716365,
-0.0137635972,
-0.0279888082,
0.0042927624,
0.0195539426,
0.0162462592,
-0.0250653755,
0.0333525352,
0.0001153744,
-0.0459849015,
-0.0164757986,
0.0112652844,
-0.0459924713,
0.0196117554,
-0.0184919033,
-0.0319236144,
0.0308130961,
0.067038402,
-0.0429137051,
-0.0438516326,
-0.0088608693,
0.0200116653,
0.0530627035,
0.0383769237,
-0.0099765165,
-0.0261723492,
-0.0766359717,
-0.0076649697,
0.0174805,
0.0130220372,
-0.0171991643,
0.0096139237,
-0.0234141853,
0.035180781,
-0.0268182475,
-0.0350885727,
0.0229718387,
-0.0404776111,
-0.0107438192,
-0.0270750225,
-0.0203148164,
0.0204310026,
0.0198436286,
0.0089407647,
0.0373796411,
0.0123110572,
-0.0116414316,
-0.0056467946,
0.0299216229,
0.0076217833,
-0.0146697629,
0.015491711,
-0.1075411364,
-0.0001466359,
0.0400061421,
-0.0190072581,
-0.0095749907,
0.0164659359,
-0.0453485362,
-0.0102344006,
0.0059748194,
0.035723947,
0.0163434613,
-0.0207585096,
-0.0166634358,
0.0317893662,
0.0152694602,
0.0292543359,
0.0445678011,
-0.0854422599,
-0.00617518,
-0.0549256839,
0.0097821066,
-0.0516742207,
-0.0090601956,
-0.0310785677,
0.0486704297,
0.0099974973,
-0.010951261,
0.0081689209,
-0.0764047354,
-0.0239621382,
0.0098816063,
0.0236173011,
0.0594163351,
0.0242158473,
-0.0051974333,
-0.0037763633,
-0.0206093229,
-0.0073149251,
-0.0083910963,
-0.0043146522,
0.0556540117,
0.0003737598,
0.0081092361,
-0.0507854745,
-0.0220506359,
-0.0221181009,
0.0273853559,
0.0633529499,
-0.075118117,
-0.0010946353,
0.0264630727,
0.0187688321,
-0.0291701108,
0.0251113214,
-0.0004727226,
-0.0314954184,
-0.0058996757,
0.0227645468,
0.046825178,
0.0418862626,
0.0087695038,
0.0157391597,
0.0195422228,
-0.0075564282,
-0.0029628878,
-0.0462216884,
0.0102839116,
0.0304287057,
-0.0761710405,
0.0613858439,
0.0445967801,
0.0001860205,
0.0049120449,
-0.0295099262,
0.0013794367,
-0.0288290866,
0.0076366975,
-0.0411473066,
0.0161639433,
-0.0073622777,
0.0250417292,
-0.0042453432,
-0.0096994853,
0.0807396844,
-0.0121981651,
0.0050386377,
-0.1309440285,
-0.001239491,
-0.0266824514,
-0.0185178034,
-0.0330982208,
0.0423420109,
0.0333565436,
-0.0057058986,
-0.0227208976,
-0.0178333409,
0.0326058194,
-0.0272836443,
0.0354472101,
-0.0453814231,
0.0058752904,
-0.0247144774,
-0.0223219283,
0.030031709,
-0.0383933,
-0.0198672973,
-0.0059178588,
0.0839825869,
-0.0473702438,
-0.06208051,
0.0201338399,
0.0630054027,
0.0846794471,
-0.0151494509,
-0.0238822009,
-0.0082942871,
0.0175329223,
0.0588327311,
-0.017509548,
0.0090725292,
-0.0465824753,
0.0169918761,
0.0759851933,
0.0007220921,
-0.0359094851,
0.05396761,
-0.044590991,
-0.0064642471,
-0.0895541385,
-0.0029228299,
0.0013430981,
0.0312483851,
-0.0309872348,
0.0175090302,
0.0872853845,
0.0235402901,
-0.0257773288,
-0.0052286154,
-0.0242625196,
0.0053626848,
-0.0248445384,
0.0322360322,
-0.0788268521,
0.0084018465,
0.0077856751,
0.0477719232,
-0.0062627248,
-0.0168008972,
-0.0262722857,
0.0005518816,
0.0427150615,
0.0352031179,
-0.0700785518,
-0.0323012173,
-0.0471347123,
-0.0018635184,
-0.002792696,
-0.0111729084,
0.0325458236,
-0.0442247093,
0.0141310329,
-0.016056478,
-0.0926702321,
-0.0476559959,
-0.0314773694,
0.0018488959,
0.0120674567,
-0.0015298998,
0.0228952412,
-0.002782413,
0.0410641357,
0.0402058028,
0.0018620415,
-0.0255683698,
-0.0247270558,
0.0618073158,
0.0286914837,
0.020288948,
-0.057200741,
0.0779391602,
0.0058468287,
-0.0203034412,
0.0095487544,
0.0209583417,
0.0232375022,
-0.034112107,
-0.0323153324,
0.055426877,
-0.019301096,
0.0700167492,
0.0257448796,
0.037826106,
-0.0479457416,
-0.0360071659,
0.0275983606,
-0.0300879478,
-0.0559921078,
-0.0431033224,
-0.0610971451,
-0.0702219233,
-0.0748502389,
-0.0126225417,
0.066008009,
-0.002299937,
0.0151911741,
0.0260530189,
0.0264323335,
0.003564165,
-0.0575269721,
0.008451499,
-0.0108811958,
-0.0122995395,
-0.0334759019,
-0.0436230451,
0.0176503435,
0.0111431731,
-0.026522506,
0.0379623547,
-0.0145041663,
-0.0395186022,
-0.022554392,
0.0031501546,
0.0345923975,
-0.0156519078,
-0.0109053515,
-0.0334870927,
0.03145032,
0.0295923464,
-0.0035234089,
0.0496061035,
-0.0157324262,
0.0063165058,
-0.0216392353,
-0.0082353912,
-0.0314385965,
0.0160049647,
-0.0367340259,
0.0216162521,
-0.0384751745,
-0.0133245997,
0.0206896774,
0.0855575353,
0.002383407,
-0.0110760638,
-0.012450031,
-0.0082270559,
-0.0239154808,
-0.049458392,
0.0189890452,
-0.018087415,
0.0236090384,
-0.0034561865,
0.0375925042,
0.005306466,
0.0870921463,
-0.0241451524,
-0.0180375762,
-0.0362340696,
0.0333962291,
-0.0564102866,
-0.0113475835,
0.022349637,
-0.0355114676,
-0.0326401293,
-0.0445572995,
-0.0656083748,
0.0051446403,
0.000384956,
-0.0067868484,
0.0401486754,
0.0145939216,
-0.0375848264,
0.0297922771,
-0.0911482871,
-0.0102353226,
-0.0538981259,
0.0550775938,
-0.0009229251,
0.0187778454,
0.0781349242,
-0.0506953485,
-0.0335757248,
-0.0475845709,
0.0437620655,
0.0171272308,
0.0276080575,
-0.0100855539,
0.0004674294,
0.0147363003,
-0.0200478826,
0.1097191274,
-0.0359798558,
-0.0069588637,
0.0276407637,
-0.0481189601,
-0.0442007072,
-0.0333705284,
-0.0316104516,
0.0317437313,
0.000741222,
-0.0467993915,
-0.0532362051,
-0.0139787616,
0.0368922129,
0.0292492565,
0.0049882415,
-0.0309274159,
0.030807443,
0.0179462861,
-0.0164089575,
-0.0800175145,
-0.0200423747,
0.0515427068,
-0.0088360179,
-0.0427284688,
-0.0208504759,
-6.095920481e-33,
-0.0037371235,
0.0030726462,
-0.0297154468,
0.0099887652,
-0.0051537175,
0.0230827276,
-0.0961376801,
-0.0276068933,
0.0319341607,
0.036137417,
-0.0221887548,
0.0031284266,
0.0127899535,
-0.0013241566,
-0.0374693237,
0.0473518334,
0.0545076579,
-0.0014240757,
-0.016962979,
0.0288981125,
-0.000312551,
0.0281512272,
0.0099625159,
-0.0781812146,
0.0185128227,
-0.0021606758,
-0.0395978466,
-0.0110857273,
0.0582437366,
0.0068081031,
-0.0203558132,
-0.0196089409,
0.0263209846,
-0.0229301341,
-0.0306886155,
0.0074825715,
-0.0861449167,
0.009427825,
0.0590763502,
-0.029088106,
-0.0555605963,
-0.0611052364,
0.0543787032,
-0.0329919159,
-0.0168892797,
-0.047233291,
0.0404364765,
-0.0318375342,
-0.0170201231,
-0.0651577264,
-0.0335532017,
0.0467329025,
-0.0300351046,
0.0107736029,
0.0089153843,
0.0270913374,
-0.0284440685,
0.0034381966,
0.0443975776,
0.0487904064,
0.0818736032,
0.0511580147,
0.0305031948,
-0.035722807,
0.0269401465,
0.0188202634,
-0.0035967079,
0.0124959182,
-0.0162209366,
-0.0088349395,
-0.0067599458,
-0.0265774485,
0.0397401303,
0.0178062692,
0.0320583358,
0.0263285153,
-0.0373258106,
0.0856503844,
-0.014273027,
0.0114990808,
0.0093986345,
0.0217506122,
-0.0161906239,
-0.0214842074,
0.0089011695,
0.0441076458,
-0.0091008786,
-0.0263481084,
-0.0252502635,
-0.0188957509,
-0.0624711402,
0.0121329995,
-0.0172639973,
-0.0250247978,
0.0156883914,
-0.0098632211,
0.032101471,
0.0496145636,
-0.0285492092,
-0.0407445878,
-0.0089316471,
0.0197731592,
0.0139130605,
0.0009082675,
0.0041386969,
0.000951855,
0.0083164964,
-0.0137112187,
-0.0482252687,
-0.0125552351,
0.0409977138,
-0.0155024417,
0.0237845052,
0.0177235715,
-0.0175261199,
0.0072144782,
0.031419348,
0.0337615088,
0.0247312672,
-0.0091471206,
-0.0005980907,
0.0371523499,
0.0171961486,
0.0274874289,
-0.0042767227,
0.0197582785,
0.002370734,
0.0009207302,
0.0454549007,
-0.020689521,
-0.0176083893,
-0.0319881886,
2.664e-7,
0.0864614546,
0.0738772005,
0.066724956,
-0.0285613611,
-0.0032793754,
-0.0056864698,
0.0188697726,
0.0038843248,
-0.0177323576,
0.058434654,
0.062089771,
-0.0011379468,
0.0384848826,
-0.01113539,
-0.0852382109,
-0.0361876972,
-0.0517755188,
-0.0602898747,
-0.0145142404,
0.00515965,
0.0490754247,
0.002672459,
-0.0322055407,
0.0188016519,
0.0013090174,
-0.0233646706,
0.0219047833,
-0.0649987832,
-0.0000776592,
0.0678159818,
0.0291811209,
-0.0122624496,
0.0193598773,
-0.0085474197,
-0.0380669013,
-0.0525761358,
0.0442800932,
0.1031702682,
0.0106602246,
0.0606373064,
0.032880988,
-0.0399285704,
0.0369466133,
0.0071163895,
0.0126696248,
-0.0784909055,
-0.0216640979,
0.0081793433,
-0.055917345,
-0.0099458499,
-0.0054034027,
0.0142290024,
-0.0800590739,
0.0513919666,
0.0010234436,
0.0017907582,
-0.0170293767,
-0.0583807975,
-0.023859892,
0.0308839139,
-0.0233926922,
-0.0299336929,
-0.0039599459,
0.0072132242,
0.0230440982,
-0.0542105511,
0.0074399551,
2.725148324e-34,
0.0828260556,
-0.0000246072,
-0.0426058844,
0.0118708657,
0.0185814556,
-0.0508147925,
0.016630657,
0.0212455671,
0.0202024039,
-0.0641484335,
0.0042635608
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.03550v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.03550v1 | DWReCO at CheckThat! 2023: Enhancing Subjectivity Detection through Style-based Data Sampling | 2023-07-07T12:34:57 | 2023-07-07T12:34:57 | Ipek Baris Schlicht, Lynn Khellaf, Defne Altiok | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG | This paper describes our submission for the subjectivity detection task at
the CheckThat! Lab. To tackle class imbalances in the task, we have generated
additional training materials with GPT-3 models using prompts of different
styles from a subjectivity checklist based on journalistic perspective. We used
the extended training set to fine-tune language-specific transformer models.
Our experiments in English, German and Turkish demonstrate that different
subjective styles are effective across all languages. In addition, we observe
that the style-based oversampling is better than paraphrasing in Turkish and
English. Lastly, the GPT-3 models sometimes produce lacklustre results when
generating style-based texts in non-English languages. | [
0.0524067134,
0.0469293892,
-0.0142969508,
0.0031311554,
-0.0338309892,
-0.0056758169,
0.0032638921,
-0.0065512438,
-0.0272556767,
-0.0563499406,
-0.0519317836,
-0.0035781851,
-0.0236887746,
-0.0329831876,
0.0108613959,
-0.0390452966,
0.009896474,
0.0377273448,
0.0317556113,
-0.0097087929,
0.0625770614,
0.0448511392,
-0.0100828819,
0.0041534733,
-0.0205550008,
-0.0096273469,
0.0217079967,
0.0229547098,
0.025540974,
-0.0057350891,
0.0537720248,
0.0661708415,
-0.050852567,
-0.0030740269,
0.0000016864,
-0.0132136559,
-0.013068147,
-0.0261546653,
0.0598853342,
-0.0110251196,
0.1066201702,
-0.0262583047,
-0.0016930865,
0.0195220876,
-0.0264826156,
-0.0151887257,
0.0246616583,
0.0816083997,
0.1004238054,
0.0867298394,
-0.0178492814,
0.0016314539,
-0.0036158848,
-0.0059157102,
0.0072884983,
0.0101621496,
-0.0120546166,
-0.0174505282,
-0.0496193655,
0.0231076498,
-0.0019922615,
0.0098727951,
0.0044251019,
-0.0066752085,
-0.0352166332,
-0.0291523729,
-0.097836636,
0.0073784916,
0.0162383839,
0.0299845226,
0.051633779,
-0.0383863561,
0.0003657099,
0.016618235,
0.0302051529,
0.0077058477,
-0.0365030654,
0.022321092,
-0.0335929431,
0.0083817858,
-0.0275985226,
0.0684412569,
-0.0331625938,
0.0172480047,
0.0483958274,
0.0220672805,
0.0073053334,
-0.0346325673,
0.0185236838,
0.0718098059,
0.0287125446,
-0.0092282016,
0.0585006401,
-0.0171540044,
0.0433546454,
-0.0225647707,
-0.0388505161,
-0.0141374543,
0.0267003663,
-0.0571735725,
-0.0055763694,
-0.0081884107,
-0.0052450239,
0.0033573217,
0.0043854099,
-0.0107290046,
0.0078664143,
0.0284498259,
-0.0421008654,
-0.0194674097,
-0.0346187912,
0.0018346451,
-0.0121692847,
0.0187589452,
0.0106097152,
0.0490575396,
-0.0508328788,
-0.0178545266,
-0.0115531795,
-0.0478398018,
0.0098477667,
0.0024621724,
-0.0361874327,
0.0224270783,
-0.0258913096,
0.0755882561,
-0.0148787322,
-0.0050114621,
-0.0355230495,
-0.0165931974,
-0.0017323226,
0.0406754427,
-0.0032955043,
-0.0605790056,
0.0099817049,
-0.0202569906,
-0.0090047838,
-0.031116968,
-0.0507930666,
0.0150508806,
-0.0116453581,
-0.0619601533,
0.0303548891,
-0.0634459257,
-0.0039143981,
-0.0164616741,
0.0111568756,
-0.0192288589,
0.0073978729,
0.0390038304,
-0.0032248946,
0.0237432793,
0.0254460927,
-0.0295287091,
0.007661425,
0.0008470055,
0.03351878,
0.052050665,
0.0045424798,
0.0414440595,
0.044995334,
0.0245354846,
0.0393182002,
0.0024113376,
0.017312482,
0.032888867,
-0.0079871751,
-0.0344538763,
-0.0322829746,
0.016602084,
0.0583014563,
0.0521363951,
0.0005125445,
-0.0301401019,
0.1026956365,
-0.0093216989,
-0.0010195291,
0.0327987671,
0.0229195748,
0.0364888385,
0.0296954699,
0.0506270267,
-0.0056686956,
0.019169271,
-0.0206783935,
0.0116305957,
-0.0525911152,
0.0605390482,
-0.0281045735,
-0.0621980317,
-0.0075089978,
-0.0102812108,
0.0125623439,
-0.0126463529,
-0.001918832,
0.0500020087,
-0.0289886016,
0.0293367971,
0.0153279416,
-0.0969621614,
0.0029181235,
-0.0279745813,
0.0404684246,
0.0601352453,
0.0178872701,
-0.0131604411,
-0.0124190673,
-0.0476476997,
0.0060819425,
0.0406681374,
0.0534002557,
0.0010123445,
0.0210178196,
-0.061300341,
0.0012177854,
-0.0187942591,
0.0114027159,
0.0130543597,
-0.0032197796,
0.0477573983,
0.0173744671,
-0.0153249353,
-0.0446057692,
0.0183893982,
0.009037232,
-0.0157137867,
0.0182225406,
0.0033776292,
-0.0142474072,
0.0346079916,
-0.0270075388,
-0.0204825196,
-0.0095448475,
-0.0376714915,
-0.0190749038,
0.0325919352,
-0.0152898785,
-0.0816549063,
-0.0143897682,
-0.0713424981,
-0.0260140412,
0.0544369556,
-0.0271313302,
-0.0208586231,
-0.0055842656,
-0.035225831,
-0.0079165008,
-0.0475687981,
-0.0150774485,
-0.0147569096,
0.0157151967,
-0.0565875322,
0.0135526769,
0.0142466221,
0.0013720113,
-0.0008717806,
-0.0680056512,
0.0236792248,
0.0023906785,
-0.0462248102,
0.0135827353,
0.0213534199,
0.0329532549,
0.0457763858,
0.0131822154,
-0.0269555617,
-0.0505159646,
-0.0873532072,
-0.0004372789,
-0.0207666773,
0.0203044116,
0.0218505021,
-0.0240980778,
-0.0200278033,
0.0153902611,
-0.064199239,
-0.0736804828,
-0.0268269815,
0.0057450444,
0.0497887358,
-0.0319006369,
0.050762374,
-0.0237946548,
-0.0242641661,
-0.0400018282,
0.0322390161,
0.0172368921,
0.0349689648,
-0.032136526,
0.0007020999,
-0.0375252962,
-0.0155936424,
0.0210120957,
-0.0683512613,
-0.0056959563,
0.0072139017,
0.0518737137,
0.0934243724,
0.0602912456,
0.006071799,
0.0194846597,
0.0175350718,
-0.0000803075,
-0.0063719093,
-0.0278787911,
0.0013431476,
0.0009410397,
-0.0841567218,
0.047059644,
0.0064145154,
0.0173449963,
-0.0188991334,
-0.0516410917,
0.0226836186,
0.0003411678,
0.0047068978,
0.0707330406,
0.0302340705,
-0.0192349162,
0.0303735491,
-0.0021811519,
0.0144186318,
0.0585470833,
-0.0138316927,
0.0009094269,
-0.0659476668,
0.0196764041,
-0.0354489423,
0.0207692757,
-0.0183494296,
0.0148405638,
0.006057329,
-0.0116943661,
-0.0362846665,
-0.0286664478,
0.0632203445,
-0.0294397771,
0.0032238825,
-0.0067076702,
-0.0239761751,
0.0181211103,
-0.0314379372,
-0.0171972997,
-0.0611462444,
0.0170201063,
0.0010654428,
-0.0047403611,
0.0139709134,
-0.0100347036,
-0.0002912762,
-0.0016836409,
0.0176790804,
-0.0712654069,
-0.0164649151,
0.0241838619,
0.0594907962,
0.0288902689,
-0.0220825858,
0.0350525752,
-0.0028754759,
-0.0220610667,
0.0574439988,
-0.0265488233,
0.056942068,
0.0188584812,
-0.0278451722,
0.0372230038,
-0.0481812097,
-0.0449366681,
-0.049559772,
0.0569765419,
-0.0290940348,
-0.0121130329,
0.115503639,
0.0224287622,
-0.0482781492,
-0.0271913968,
0.0240109973,
-0.0069383509,
0.0315962173,
0.0347975343,
-0.0275403205,
0.0058035445,
-0.0385419503,
0.0179488715,
-0.0368585885,
-0.0171976779,
-0.0035210832,
-0.104252696,
0.0214905832,
-0.0110856229,
-0.0306448434,
-0.0299315136,
-0.0065931808,
0.0022172409,
-0.0159943569,
-0.0058659553,
-0.0258525927,
-0.0110957855,
0.0280404724,
0.0263672005,
-0.0224577915,
-0.0608427115,
0.0076935655,
-0.0207384489,
0.0136090033,
0.0346534066,
0.081623517,
-0.0253942739,
-0.0647079498,
-0.0182324108,
-0.037726406,
-0.0254217945,
0.0041381153,
0.0952469036,
-0.0345906727,
-0.0157045051,
-0.0433284678,
0.024848979,
0.0042305845,
0.0235382393,
0.0005985494,
0.0068988502,
-0.0060047181,
-0.030680988,
-0.0311342832,
0.0573400445,
0.0241207536,
0.0515162572,
0.0265724529,
-0.0528383255,
-0.0127602918,
-0.0210016035,
0.0318161584,
-0.0578656718,
-0.0560902655,
0.0116785001,
-0.0126179326,
-0.0364994407,
-0.0939539447,
-0.0588191934,
-0.0287751704,
0.0405144617,
-0.0283686146,
-0.0470759086,
0.0088396911,
0.0192163792,
-0.035271924,
-0.008780404,
0.0084440336,
0.0171050299,
-0.0159329791,
-0.0307520293,
0.0606463961,
-0.0190398861,
-0.0164638944,
0.0358181931,
-0.0452022776,
-0.0181121156,
0.0187560413,
0.0690824836,
0.0121309757,
0.011200347,
-0.0013944916,
-0.0181673653,
-0.005264678,
0.0538137555,
-0.0159737002,
0.0086724283,
0.0480093993,
0.0157516301,
-0.0053173751,
0.0237254892,
0.0337615944,
0.0597853847,
0.0210623387,
-0.0168130305,
0.0064282003,
-0.0147109618,
0.0134519897,
0.0056697382,
0.0376078524,
0.0048087933,
0.0283744428,
-0.0182981882,
0.0028826639,
-0.0218077265,
-0.0207322352,
-0.0183118731,
-0.0084472112,
0.0131631717,
-0.0031830028,
-0.0610894077,
0.0196565241,
-0.0445566028,
0.0310326479,
-0.0801615715,
0.0234976988,
0.0152487746,
0.0005542513,
-0.0362383164,
0.0179996584,
-0.0350201875,
0.0091756992,
0.0276005417,
0.0238363463,
0.0093281027,
0.0542171039,
0.0212322138,
0.0195324887,
0.0104274284,
0.0199963264,
-0.0732210353,
0.0608700998,
-0.0343247913,
0.0310506485,
-0.001664269,
-0.0524444394,
0.058031965,
-0.0149577605,
-0.0000399824,
0.0156559292,
0.033840362,
-0.0043530115,
-0.0170500875,
0.0059866151,
-0.0043265373,
0.005093093,
-0.0212163739,
0.0584241375,
-0.0274034757,
0.0132236267,
0.0213955082,
-0.0513042547,
-0.03546023,
-0.0350210667,
0.0462733842,
-0.0105313156,
0.0476165265,
0.0091167716,
-0.0595345795,
-0.0360751078,
0.051677905,
-0.006677954,
0.0304270443,
-0.0444199741,
0.0244535431,
0.0802546144,
-0.024186749,
-0.0027102642,
-0.0472150594,
0.0088821361,
0.0063899402,
-0.0102030775,
-0.0307080355,
-5.935295791e-33,
-0.0143228024,
0.0045094602,
-0.0592247769,
0.0608824901,
-0.0406997912,
-0.0051768413,
-0.0041021728,
0.0095156748,
-0.0129133761,
0.0514642261,
-0.0269872062,
0.0276594479,
0.0041703209,
0.0355266593,
0.0117799742,
0.0166070033,
0.0653412938,
0.0005387596,
-0.0570633151,
0.0235282164,
0.0194030851,
0.0065668933,
0.1554118991,
-0.0820782632,
0.0120974304,
0.0037981009,
-0.0356625319,
-0.0255053379,
0.0348327085,
0.0399757475,
0.0329664275,
0.0762207285,
0.0286422893,
-0.0657159984,
0.0218672808,
-0.0362092257,
-0.0260352734,
-0.0627915114,
0.023911342,
0.0467459969,
0.0295234416,
-0.0208136346,
0.0415899269,
-0.0203221254,
-0.0138422167,
-0.0032196874,
0.0515293889,
-0.0115804682,
0.0333771072,
-0.0944808125,
-0.0464010611,
0.015998045,
-0.0003934912,
-0.0290820189,
-0.0184165556,
0.022807993,
-0.007001508,
0.020001011,
-0.0299962685,
0.0144938948,
-0.0323267505,
0.017652506,
-0.0084790289,
-0.03484964,
-0.0306162778,
0.0371059366,
-0.0320890546,
0.0695136786,
-0.0182918496,
0.0050573596,
0.038112767,
-0.0231727324,
0.034104526,
0.1250546724,
-0.0162074342,
-0.0228560306,
0.0160523541,
0.0365965776,
0.0969059393,
-0.0150649026,
0.0275663678,
-0.0594889298,
-0.0350520723,
-0.0392324291,
-0.0107712978,
-0.0665824786,
-0.0078979479,
-0.0048210453,
-0.0135127073,
-0.0120394966,
-0.0488861427,
0.0368127897,
-0.0002026299,
-0.0336617604,
-0.0115053542,
0.0266536959,
-0.0874429792,
0.0487044975,
-0.023245303,
-0.0087288618,
-0.0347048752,
0.0321944058,
-0.0001635754,
0.0588932857,
0.0036628053,
-0.0193828568,
0.0689730123,
0.0423676595,
-0.0894687623,
-0.0087275151,
0.0045331018,
0.0759755746,
0.000264915,
0.0424416438,
-0.0119330753,
0.0129604749,
-0.0221045818,
0.0250595286,
0.0214599818,
-0.0062636021,
-0.0480847657,
-0.0216935948,
0.0305270813,
0.0317194238,
-0.0321041755,
-0.0280689467,
-0.0128496056,
-0.0459772572,
-0.0200192276,
-0.0613426641,
-0.0109051475,
-0.0218620952,
2.557e-7,
0.0377642475,
0.0212406013,
-0.0035300457,
-0.0140500739,
0.0088891154,
0.0200607795,
0.0455613621,
0.0343591049,
0.0031340697,
-0.0016199482,
0.0077610025,
0.0065779733,
0.023915736,
0.0439822339,
-0.1152264252,
-0.0091336071,
-0.0427206829,
0.0250014476,
-0.0292210449,
-0.0079623163,
0.0782340169,
0.073988989,
0.021983454,
-0.0279463381,
0.0079101883,
0.0135543682,
0.0841942281,
0.0024050542,
-0.005909529,
0.0476684049,
0.0565368347,
-0.0366904587,
0.0141325239,
-0.0031322949,
0.0007987688,
-0.0189046208,
0.0310554244,
0.0602741726,
0.027062621,
-0.0079756519,
0.0356523171,
0.0293549243,
-0.0151177915,
-0.0574619547,
0.0442053564,
-0.0251682382,
-0.0287111755,
-0.0881688222,
-0.04984238,
-0.0320705809,
0.0680921376,
-0.0382258967,
-0.054596357,
0.0600603744,
-0.0004770741,
-0.0019203912,
-0.0106885312,
-0.0430077687,
-0.0211688187,
-0.0442005135,
-0.007804824,
-0.0272270609,
0.0286185313,
-0.0163575076,
-0.0259042345,
-0.0377033129,
0.0509517454,
2.098289559e-34,
0.0621922724,
0.0031660262,
0.0139283221,
-0.0162871294,
0.0167834703,
0.0218698829,
0.0364512727,
-0.0144472634,
-0.0033712978,
-0.0010834803,
-0.0080231773
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.04766v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.04766v1 | Why machines do not understand: A response to Søgaard | 2023-07-07T12:31:56 | 2023-07-07T12:31:56 | Jobst Landgrebe, Barry Smith | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.0 | Some defenders of so-called `artificial intelligence' believe that machines
can understand language. In particular, S{\o}gaard has argued in this journal
for a thesis of this sort, on the basis of the idea (1) that where there is
semantics there is also understanding and (2) that machines are not only
capable of what he calls `inferential semantics', but even that they can (with
the help of inputs from sensors) `learn' referential semantics
\parencite{sogaard:2022}. We show that he goes wrong because he pays
insufficient attention to the difference between language as used by humans and
the sequences of inert of symbols which arise when language is stored on hard
drives or in books in libraries. | [
0.0205189101,
0.0333185494,
-0.040789403,
0.0376417302,
-0.0333350301,
0.0225358885,
-0.0149955051,
0.0306386221,
-0.0030772721,
-0.0751404613,
-0.0009580274,
0.0444008671,
0.009591274,
0.0028364125,
0.0377543196,
-0.0337645784,
0.0493799224,
-0.0222498216,
-0.024972342,
-0.02279355,
-0.0348427333,
-0.0074456478,
-0.0116334511,
-0.0076233991,
0.0125082135,
-0.0120157236,
-0.0410824195,
-0.0471297018,
-0.0390539914,
0.0103564542,
-0.0808829442,
-0.0293609556,
0.0054386924,
0.0395372957,
0.0000018855,
-0.0414446779,
-0.0051299063,
-0.0013812194,
-0.0614684708,
-0.0131577337,
0.0356701091,
-0.0567560494,
0.028771786,
-0.0507575646,
-0.0314365476,
-0.0022355129,
0.02210797,
0.0150854466,
0.0165806897,
0.0230707657,
-0.0137681719,
-0.0243969224,
0.016111549,
0.0339467861,
0.0684884489,
-0.0344283059,
0.0059955963,
0.0422333963,
0.0373690054,
-0.0187605005,
-0.0427780934,
0.0519427285,
0.0144443633,
0.0365770385,
0.0064978236,
0.0232071467,
0.0110656964,
-0.0284166299,
0.0151371742,
0.0129630864,
0.0155053679,
-0.0131102726,
0.0004346148,
0.0417466871,
-0.0113000488,
0.0314750932,
-0.0011872236,
0.0357653014,
-0.062766023,
0.0225510877,
0.0178686213,
-0.0276818946,
0.0415779799,
0.0130652385,
-0.0408261642,
0.0747822523,
-0.0464325398,
-0.031721402,
0.0327976942,
-0.000847936,
-0.0105376467,
-0.0528545529,
-0.0465955622,
0.0239459854,
0.0045874272,
0.020506097,
-0.0165539198,
0.008831487,
0.0012372048,
-0.0764869303,
0.0348922908,
-0.009634519,
0.040033862,
0.0402880721,
-0.0033567436,
0.0351010226,
-0.0385411829,
0.047773391,
-0.0551892594,
0.0041693435,
-0.0770481527,
-0.0417176411,
-0.0278758537,
0.0577317737,
0.0427574217,
0.0094747441,
0.0287600216,
0.0410010442,
-0.0080161123,
0.0330747142,
-0.0940679461,
-0.027961487,
-0.0335163996,
0.0140970713,
-0.0557683855,
-0.0263889991,
-0.0115352524,
0.0435881093,
-0.0621652082,
-0.0642506704,
0.0147539936,
0.031964466,
-0.0117857121,
0.0127379056,
0.0080638211,
0.0922022015,
0.0234475397,
0.0053780852,
0.0133976825,
-0.0354280584,
0.0247157644,
-0.0279415138,
0.0220495239,
-0.0247671753,
0.0189688765,
0.0704639256,
-0.0126715535,
-0.0591238849,
-0.0202868823,
0.0146139301,
-0.0348248892,
0.1100714728,
-0.0567406937,
0.0128744142,
0.0142737506,
-0.013168091,
-0.0630081818,
-0.0116827544,
-0.0002896621,
-0.0079535432,
0.0289949197,
0.0124756405,
0.0432793647,
-0.0024190834,
0.0014454765,
-0.0671625659,
-0.0358681679,
0.0072556897,
-0.014652051,
0.0159349721,
-0.0076647312,
0.0511030219,
0.0195562411,
-0.0289431345,
0.0214355532,
0.0594525076,
-0.0467288978,
0.0505485199,
0.0313585997,
-0.0008442684,
0.017975051,
0.0561278835,
-0.0379813798,
-0.0249889642,
-0.008806794,
0.0118438574,
-0.0105764205,
-0.0663901567,
0.0035448638,
-0.0510795191,
-0.013896903,
0.0067388248,
0.0010419467,
-0.0056665423,
0.0466872938,
0.0083783269,
-0.0021719132,
0.0042062509,
-0.0048975395,
-0.0036387402,
0.018944528,
-0.0547256991,
0.0689419881,
0.0021727253,
0.0036884332,
-0.0191230606,
0.0388415717,
-0.0162404031,
-0.019501159,
-0.0170954261,
0.0413236916,
-0.0111369966,
-0.0088623911,
-0.0010219669,
0.0068641244,
-0.0203063004,
0.022992298,
0.0293314122,
-0.1338126957,
-0.0005035504,
-0.0091011887,
-0.0568758808,
-0.0001542584,
0.0392600447,
0.0232892893,
-0.0114904223,
-0.0907470137,
-0.0095792366,
0.0429374464,
-0.0013596532,
-0.0448533408,
0.0305971578,
0.0625319555,
-0.0292423461,
0.002186205,
0.0592531599,
-0.0050269226,
0.0176146235,
0.0044022743,
-0.1114520803,
-0.0068895337,
0.0291142613,
0.0118827401,
-0.0333776176,
0.0541514382,
-0.0797982067,
0.0265116543,
-0.0013785427,
0.0155849727,
-0.0283407047,
-0.0156074772,
-0.0065761358,
0.0676265955,
0.0060193716,
0.045327656,
0.0008180882,
-0.0116431434,
0.0332468264,
-0.0084127858,
-0.0321397446,
0.0932292417,
0.0298770443,
0.0047056852,
0.0021114552,
-0.0511311814,
-0.0252744984,
0.0074743642,
-0.027492946,
-0.0505622029,
0.0047289985,
0.0019592687,
0.0206264481,
-0.0210221764,
0.0256706551,
-0.0369338766,
0.0323151313,
0.0410143547,
0.0000575798,
0.0408116132,
0.0435231328,
-0.0061291535,
-0.024041906,
0.0462380312,
-0.0008847588,
-0.0337328278,
0.0116991624,
0.0288289506,
-0.0312758647,
-0.0450722277,
0.0157481711,
-0.0247982666,
-0.0199710801,
-0.0390971303,
0.0071657104,
0.0207872912,
-0.0127665559,
-0.0251285359,
0.0610653833,
-0.0099983662,
0.0731772408,
0.0076686181,
0.0232081674,
-0.0225091595,
-0.013731014,
-0.0070776073,
-0.0239822846,
-0.056100145,
-0.0207011309,
0.0014904023,
0.0316281579,
0.0121139381,
0.0198022891,
-0.0259841103,
0.0704051629,
-0.0340494588,
-0.0333710164,
-0.0769274533,
-0.0471365675,
-0.034105245,
0.0665690675,
-0.0205811188,
-0.025662927,
0.0743249059,
0.0060198093,
-0.0412251577,
-0.0419280119,
-0.0299329404,
0.0069289687,
0.0843337402,
0.0255087819,
0.0086034937,
0.0183907077,
0.0022547604,
-0.0334477834,
-0.0097234035,
0.0349039473,
0.0172804557,
0.0055877888,
-0.0083522666,
0.0142332269,
0.0049731359,
-0.0025483116,
-0.0206795316,
0.0220090281,
-0.0729330033,
-0.0081947548,
-0.0469119065,
-0.0000766472,
-0.0441002995,
0.0082067065,
0.0440631248,
0.0047235931,
0.0448299088,
-0.0139756268,
-0.0539581925,
-0.0537446812,
0.0216801558,
0.0221781097,
-0.0097686537,
-0.0272781402,
0.0264705997,
0.0373779833,
0.003912787,
-0.0077407826,
0.0127611812,
0.0203813892,
0.0207918473,
0.0109077794,
-0.0877589583,
-0.005814896,
0.018899804,
-0.0149141168,
-0.0365134887,
0.0476121418,
-0.0131689515,
-0.0232907142,
0.0449898429,
-0.0341079794,
-0.0479438342,
0.0258867946,
-0.0081406739,
-0.0594614446,
-0.005653712,
0.016521791,
0.0393581949,
-0.0041280868,
-0.0297148898,
-0.0050254078,
-0.0366860367,
0.0258343574,
0.0045520151,
-0.0765282288,
-0.0693150014,
-0.0265187882,
-0.0287012178,
-0.0042913128,
-0.0108894641,
0.0180815235,
0.0086336387,
0.0422806963,
0.0272523612,
0.0202371739,
-0.0209069159,
-0.0288727004,
0.000818609,
0.0141718155,
0.053922344,
0.0614812784,
-0.0414292254,
-0.06074512,
0.0349450633,
-0.0351829231,
0.0015312555,
-0.0301856212,
-0.000477973,
0.014300839,
-0.0071803355,
-0.0217745453,
0.0266371164,
-0.0419314355,
-0.0021275023,
0.0410407856,
0.085628584,
-0.0562122278,
-0.0703465194,
-0.0020521942,
-0.0192267485,
-0.0432812534,
0.0493853875,
0.0278865583,
0.0043025655,
-0.0493925996,
-0.0673198476,
0.0040962105,
0.0467128865,
-0.0369985998,
0.0022983174,
-0.0133098084,
-0.0453637019,
-0.0466493964,
-0.0938279852,
-0.0248127077,
0.0200752206,
0.0274862852,
0.0041954406,
0.0571068153,
-0.0016582592,
-0.0583412871,
-0.0038627917,
-0.0060311127,
-0.0231854282,
0.0085458793,
-0.0197311435,
0.0020999657,
-0.0230543073,
-0.0318798535,
-0.0216085222,
0.0658985451,
-0.0401962809,
0.0496432446,
0.0565442145,
0.0413044095,
0.0012175831,
0.0148623334,
-0.0045151073,
-0.0063081118,
0.0353564508,
-0.0288355108,
0.0417518988,
0.0222825706,
-0.0179101899,
-0.012648846,
0.0563068278,
0.0085345423,
0.0114144664,
-0.0388356522,
-0.0306187347,
-0.0253115613,
0.0013666367,
0.0438452661,
0.0329511464,
-0.0017813987,
0.0358755402,
-0.0251169,
0.0196827371,
-0.0036922456,
0.0427700542,
-0.0261037443,
-0.0343789347,
-0.0240827575,
-0.0100140776,
0.0400430225,
-0.012312999,
-0.0371001847,
-0.0251991861,
0.0315553173,
0.0687841475,
0.0518437177,
0.0465597026,
0.0945352241,
0.0028113916,
0.0172278937,
0.0296258815,
0.0399614349,
-0.0180351697,
0.058964733,
-0.0237945914,
0.0208274536,
0.0694048256,
0.0191020798,
-0.0241610575,
-0.0145895248,
-0.0989931896,
-0.062946789,
0.0583386458,
0.0024852827,
0.0366774537,
-0.0224785898,
0.00993123,
-0.034846507,
0.0207809284,
-0.0028214143,
0.0591231845,
0.0587778464,
-0.0113384482,
0.0242475346,
0.0279495586,
-0.0272458233,
0.0043775602,
0.0442145802,
-0.0682052225,
0.0560644642,
0.0058442415,
-0.0300286282,
-0.052164413,
-0.0357821994,
-0.0168099832,
0.0092882738,
0.0112379072,
0.0590680093,
-0.0273976345,
-0.0744389221,
0.0244672727,
0.0146875409,
0.0515129156,
-0.0313621536,
0.0128793772,
0.0734284893,
0.029464839,
-0.0507482812,
-0.0590696372,
0.0957193673,
-0.0472491421,
-0.0014234309,
-0.0140999788,
-5.349246837e-33,
-0.0145370299,
-0.029959185,
-0.0120384749,
0.0019295083,
0.0169792157,
-0.0094137378,
-0.052374091,
-0.0104282787,
-0.0418048166,
0.0306633059,
-0.010580292,
-0.0078108371,
0.0076097054,
-0.0134875467,
0.0358771086,
-0.0417910777,
0.0155417658,
-0.0106663872,
-0.0063212616,
-0.0335712433,
0.0394283347,
-0.0185482986,
0.0545615591,
-0.0621370971,
0.0781231746,
-0.0764526725,
-0.0028246068,
0.0021591573,
-0.0184687618,
0.0186041668,
-0.0130184637,
0.0628579929,
0.0295938477,
0.002426218,
-0.0258535016,
0.0185906254,
-0.0622705929,
-0.038533479,
0.046438653,
0.0560982525,
-0.0019460612,
-0.0388463773,
0.041794192,
-0.0405335575,
-0.0563469678,
0.0487404168,
0.0428010523,
-0.0134852855,
0.007767892,
0.038680695,
-0.026896717,
-0.0145721063,
-0.0345670134,
0.0056998678,
0.0573023856,
0.0230848677,
-0.0161020495,
-0.048290126,
-0.0791490152,
0.0187071245,
-0.0328517891,
-0.0170067046,
0.0616891235,
-0.0133399814,
0.0287205372,
0.0428165644,
0.0809500068,
0.0004110374,
0.0017224177,
0.0170021765,
0.0175929349,
0.0165704526,
-0.0083955238,
0.016629912,
0.0685301647,
0.0075936401,
-0.0144438557,
-0.0192879234,
0.011590071,
0.0507531948,
0.0276960135,
-0.0017596743,
-0.0457568616,
0.0041046226,
-0.0301370677,
-0.0728001818,
-0.0124852601,
-0.027534306,
-0.0036499654,
-0.0414573289,
0.0375224873,
0.0268244799,
0.0164619423,
-0.0784382969,
-0.0084919939,
-0.0149522088,
0.0262025166,
-0.018915534,
0.0267576613,
-0.0071056816,
-0.0104846302,
-0.0555729046,
-0.0415525101,
0.0442369543,
0.0566166118,
0.0265782587,
0.0049484973,
-0.0208767857,
0.0258551408,
-0.0326953083,
-0.0114180613,
-0.0333566777,
-0.005909509,
-0.0295620915,
0.0685410127,
0.0384961553,
0.0006396887,
-0.0037996068,
-0.0083798356,
-0.0197822247,
-0.0286777932,
0.0454616509,
-0.0403107181,
0.0129813002,
-0.0444885418,
-0.064188689,
-0.0478304029,
0.0314542353,
0.04006093,
-0.0239975546,
0.0140938191,
-0.0148472581,
2.684e-7,
0.0483225621,
0.0115982322,
0.0248151198,
-0.0212879274,
0.0022227138,
0.0327828638,
-0.0350052714,
0.0342769995,
-0.0114663383,
0.0056018019,
0.0013072415,
0.046749521,
-0.0145625342,
0.0087200543,
-0.0445605367,
-0.0116143748,
-0.0228813291,
0.0034594492,
-0.0276064798,
0.0953082964,
0.0697418079,
0.0406996496,
-0.0138376681,
-0.0128476238,
-0.0158333536,
-0.028876422,
-0.0145918671,
-0.040647693,
0.0618617944,
-0.017647475,
0.0404581726,
0.0172029044,
0.009503115,
0.0575418137,
0.0466917567,
-0.0042145276,
0.0147407018,
0.0274263639,
0.007902367,
-0.0021392524,
-0.0604058318,
-0.0264579803,
0.0202467628,
-0.0175283402,
0.0565936528,
-0.0215255208,
-0.086819306,
0.023520017,
-0.0200245064,
0.0213695653,
0.0073347474,
0.0505613759,
0.0020817325,
0.0064642662,
0.0104961079,
-0.0432282574,
-0.0015832409,
-0.0266720466,
0.0350500904,
0.0428376831,
-0.0401355959,
-0.0288039781,
-0.0060014622,
0.0071944883,
0.0736017078,
-0.0468613431,
-0.0235288665,
1.383600932e-34,
0.0115936892,
-0.0231227372,
0.0143469013,
0.0241838247,
0.004254933,
-0.0258047618,
0.0341179743,
0.0632095635,
0.0638738051,
-0.0329698808,
-0.0104077347
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.03539v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.03539v1 | Large Language Models as Batteries-Included Zero-Shot ESCO Skills Matchers | 2023-07-07T12:04:12 | 2023-07-07T12:04:12 | Benjamin Clavié, Guillaume Soulié | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Understanding labour market dynamics requires accurately identifying the
skills required for and possessed by the workforce. Automation techniques are
increasingly being developed to support this effort. However, automatically
extracting skills from job postings is challenging due to the vast number of
existing skills. The ESCO (European Skills, Competences, Qualifications and
Occupations) framework provides a useful reference, listing over 13,000
individual skills. However, skills extraction remains difficult and accurately
matching job posts to the ESCO taxonomy is an open problem. In this work, we
propose an end-to-end zero-shot system for skills extraction from job
descriptions based on large language models (LLMs). We generate synthetic
training data for the entirety of ESCO skills and train a classifier to extract
skill mentions from job posts. We also employ a similarity retriever to
generate skill candidates which are then re-ranked using a second LLM. Using
synthetic data achieves an RP@10 score 10 points higher than previous distant
supervision approaches. Adding GPT-4 re-ranking improves RP@10 by over 22
points over previous methods. We also show that Framing the task as mock
programming when prompting the LLM can lead to better performance than natural
language prompts, especially with weaker LLMs. We demonstrate the potential of
integrating large language models at both ends of skills matching pipelines.
Our approach requires no human annotations and achieve extremely promising
results on skills extraction against ESCO. | [
0.0368676744,
0.0567411296,
-0.003502822,
-0.00940903,
-0.0150020374,
0.0023706872,
-0.0039217197,
0.0047199284,
0.0438281819,
-0.0568992756,
0.0042666956,
0.0020316686,
-0.0290549919,
0.0039683222,
0.027891051,
-0.0089654373,
-0.0027993685,
-0.0120970281,
-0.0403270572,
0.0214483868,
-0.0153611349,
0.0543214306,
-0.0024409113,
0.0526199825,
-0.0008451659,
-0.0105515644,
0.0270698797,
-0.0250185244,
0.0268224999,
0.0034089431,
0.028267961,
0.0121622095,
-0.0003185112,
0.0088396501,
0.0000019793,
-0.014702349,
-0.0174159929,
0.0265320987,
-0.0227007605,
-0.0505392179,
0.0257681403,
-0.025382068,
-0.0053767506,
0.0403829068,
-0.0217625946,
-0.043880403,
0.0377518758,
-0.0288250633,
0.0387349091,
0.0649419725,
0.0058831135,
0.0027587207,
-0.0011297582,
-0.0105522517,
0.0517943464,
-0.0338638239,
0.0410087742,
-0.0307327099,
0.0459385365,
0.0344007462,
0.0322124399,
-0.0045354832,
-0.0167875662,
-0.0498806238,
-0.0014504405,
0.0308600161,
-0.0291314758,
0.0243750345,
0.015175676,
0.0141119957,
-0.0468129106,
-0.0488276742,
-0.0027758838,
-0.0068491963,
0.0074671819,
0.0668220073,
-0.0324037634,
0.0315443836,
-0.0221048091,
-0.0070894682,
-0.0000182384,
0.0045091426,
-0.0135252737,
-0.000223043,
0.0259678736,
0.0732179284,
-0.0040371823,
-0.0510460474,
0.0465715751,
0.0150892753,
0.0285204481,
-0.0437409505,
0.0215086304,
0.043251548,
-0.0338717811,
-0.0003559444,
-0.0223892145,
0.0201306436,
0.0156304762,
-0.0409323424,
-0.0044633728,
0.0246364772,
-0.0172209255,
0.0613907948,
-0.030647615,
0.0258156974,
0.0195080955,
-0.0082478002,
-0.0611439832,
-0.0630929619,
-0.123021923,
-0.041614987,
-0.0201360974,
0.0079584997,
-0.0195796955,
0.0363401771,
-0.0278004222,
0.0051394897,
-0.052051045,
0.038463071,
0.0062636128,
-0.0064690956,
-0.02752796,
0.0319307745,
-0.0351105928,
0.0213127509,
0.0304111987,
-0.0099771246,
-0.0312783234,
-0.0406037085,
0.006708852,
0.0232595075,
0.0184553787,
-0.0346721634,
0.0467427596,
0.0525226742,
0.0358899198,
0.006122042,
-0.0037750816,
-0.0261366125,
0.0048983363,
-0.0190544389,
-0.015893884,
-0.0468855202,
0.0151306177,
-0.0240580216,
-0.0053018988,
-0.0518769734,
0.02583085,
0.0414907448,
-0.0284555852,
0.0607840829,
-0.0202335995,
0.0215418562,
0.0202885456,
-0.0240094997,
-0.0199190322,
0.0339678936,
-0.0044099875,
0.0289701931,
0.0100366864,
-0.0441114046,
0.0861515552,
0.0596242398,
-0.0508185476,
-0.0444254316,
-0.0042252089,
0.0516886711,
0.0611161478,
0.0011400806,
0.0881785005,
-0.0474697538,
-0.0038948571,
0.0356277823,
0.0381211489,
0.0757367909,
0.0194733795,
-0.0022355171,
0.0915359482,
0.0710531399,
-0.0035262064,
-0.0478391424,
-0.033758454,
0.0225049276,
-0.0165557545,
0.0014834411,
-0.0292343926,
0.0356098115,
-0.046859391,
0.0125572504,
0.0135107003,
-0.0152091878,
-0.0451481156,
0.0593244247,
0.0498249494,
0.0008632228,
-0.0169116221,
0.0498988628,
0.0425951108,
-0.0137816845,
0.0024634416,
-0.0257990528,
-0.0397715494,
0.0978144035,
0.0313079171,
-0.0405676849,
-0.041984152,
-0.02674108,
-0.0045321416,
0.0412832238,
0.0354741402,
-0.0354874432,
-0.0162907802,
-0.0230703671,
-0.0312157311,
0.0059506013,
-0.0087310784,
0.0293286238,
0.024722876,
0.0054047704,
0.0220936947,
-0.0220927745,
-0.0510886014,
0.0348287858,
-0.0212646853,
-0.0493481122,
0.0359279029,
0.0038531341,
-0.0149738388,
0.0110848164,
-0.0105625354,
0.0111719109,
-0.0024999215,
-0.0386532284,
-0.0069743022,
0.0009266381,
-0.0094490582,
0.0145745147,
0.0361757539,
-0.0116625838,
-0.0418371893,
0.0216304418,
-0.0575871915,
0.0139180729,
-0.0285401233,
0.0140544409,
-0.0033239084,
-0.0131940497,
0.0223513581,
-0.0307825562,
-0.0039181728,
-0.0278374329,
0.0755207539,
0.0833493546,
0.0310998559,
-0.0263691973,
0.0000204889,
0.0008720807,
-0.0910062492,
-0.0030653162,
-0.0239934307,
0.0031016171,
0.0577082299,
0.0150154606,
0.0313757025,
-0.0137672788,
-0.0157144908,
-0.0962317213,
0.0474179685,
0.0300349873,
0.0117843803,
0.0374086984,
-0.0221998934,
-0.0044355951,
-0.0157761201,
-0.0514745601,
-0.0506729931,
-0.0055745794,
-0.0058650388,
0.0186058823,
-0.0106921587,
-0.0338506736,
-0.0018766224,
0.0024764528,
-0.0385460258,
0.0339966863,
0.0214447975,
0.0359707512,
-0.0572515912,
0.0690369383,
-0.0124037433,
0.027855223,
0.028836282,
0.0074303444,
-0.0501353033,
0.0017858833,
-0.0292013939,
0.0407222398,
-0.0138596995,
-0.0202799346,
0.0466857441,
0.0182655323,
-0.0249591488,
-0.0049008043,
-0.0013820995,
-0.0051181917,
-0.0086317267,
-0.0283683725,
-0.0025575617,
0.018487053,
0.0051311036,
-0.0113870073,
-0.0193094518,
0.0155066708,
-0.0093255294,
-0.000541471,
-0.058938574,
0.0433602631,
0.0007879665,
0.0110980496,
-0.0212352499,
-0.0174345877,
0.035670694,
-0.0316491351,
0.0176308714,
-0.0170734171,
-0.0852757394,
-0.0632597283,
0.0384357199,
-0.0111350864,
0.0134319523,
-0.0312539041,
-0.0040274616,
-0.0291607007,
0.0043880492,
-0.001268848,
-0.0269008987,
-0.0347785763,
-0.0325036459,
0.0264366549,
0.007240817,
-0.0444101319,
-0.0407457799,
-0.0303043127,
-0.0206969418,
0.063375406,
-0.0068266015,
-0.0050739739,
-0.0458665416,
0.0128374351,
0.0170744006,
0.0725455731,
0.0138040427,
-0.0208732728,
-0.0165483225,
0.0238747094,
0.0709782094,
-0.0046875798,
-0.0639448985,
-0.0198845677,
-0.0124548832,
0.0183918197,
-0.0011836812,
0.0360042229,
-0.0300262515,
0.0002732896,
0.021496499,
-0.0934577808,
0.0127242608,
0.0063215853,
-0.0213326942,
-0.0665386245,
-0.0058304514,
0.104502961,
-0.0116730519,
-0.031496793,
-0.0092657646,
0.0083191143,
-0.0706195086,
0.0558398925,
0.0961450711,
-0.0841001123,
0.0045971386,
-0.0041265422,
0.032885462,
-0.0115004117,
-0.0236927029,
-0.0208010897,
-0.1604501307,
0.0739857852,
-0.0015272382,
-0.05777511,
-0.0201763194,
-0.0499116741,
0.0076882667,
-0.0375498012,
-0.0345078185,
-0.0157770477,
-0.0366382413,
0.0056335144,
0.0432422273,
-0.0047384705,
-0.0491793975,
0.0826850161,
-0.045119781,
0.0344871916,
0.0396809094,
0.0272983704,
-0.0049711494,
-0.0005115137,
0.0114472238,
-0.011556671,
-0.0059710792,
0.0249038544,
0.0291716829,
-0.0532873236,
-0.0159845296,
0.019548595,
0.0107666831,
-0.0426931828,
0.0134528866,
0.0413261726,
0.0979929939,
-0.0140012372,
-0.0069363858,
-0.0089586452,
-0.0228460766,
0.0108248563,
0.1030583158,
-0.0180292539,
-0.0686767995,
-0.0124429706,
-0.0317535996,
-0.0303341579,
0.0265403856,
-0.0686148927,
0.0396083407,
-0.0275773071,
0.0088374149,
0.0002735025,
-0.0443323888,
0.0793527365,
0.0125325797,
0.0123427268,
0.0149029205,
-0.0040623271,
-0.0128306281,
-0.0645106956,
0.0437371917,
-0.0551836602,
0.0480249077,
-0.0379146375,
-0.0054663052,
0.0136419712,
-0.0498586819,
-0.0678654388,
-0.0650200024,
-0.0615372322,
-0.0079061314,
-0.0556648821,
0.0219300464,
0.01948018,
0.0491838977,
-0.0185462199,
-0.0708873793,
0.0267207306,
0.075906679,
-0.0452811979,
-0.0081495903,
-0.0399521552,
0.0086679067,
0.0044693169,
0.0061767832,
-0.0666477606,
0.0448342077,
0.0377917178,
-0.0268083606,
0.0113123432,
-0.0037219184,
0.0365399383,
0.0293140989,
0.0141489562,
0.0331748351,
-0.0126344739,
-0.0590614118,
-0.0082301525,
-0.00910189,
-0.0356686302,
-0.0240118839,
0.007344387,
0.0717723146,
0.0080684219,
0.054962825,
0.0181400646,
0.0024928804,
0.0394479632,
-0.0756581575,
0.0002318485,
-0.0330300853,
0.0266542733,
-0.0043139355,
-0.019280443,
-0.0107428925,
-0.0174386799,
0.008524132,
0.0621379092,
-0.0199381225,
0.0059000561,
-0.0068746852,
0.019851489,
0.0019194863,
0.0279713534,
-0.0429130271,
-0.0980682597,
-0.0268415883,
0.0515116602,
0.084902294,
-0.0676898807,
0.0119809294,
-0.0108805103,
-0.0157812815,
-0.0171562638,
-0.0196502712,
0.0313745029,
-0.0021216674,
0.0237525124,
0.0373909771,
-0.0218027066,
0.0034203026,
0.060178034,
0.0125420522,
0.0447989255,
0.008433613,
-0.063491568,
-0.0462566875,
0.0220753122,
0.052562654,
-0.0113759199,
-0.0312608518,
-0.0073943315,
-0.0379518904,
-0.0599657297,
0.0242413674,
-0.0129809324,
-0.0325492024,
-0.0030699936,
0.0303530823,
0.0523743033,
-0.0214992594,
0.0022528407,
-0.0478292853,
-0.0308730565,
0.0256344397,
-0.0124363564,
-0.0585271418,
-6.052955796e-33,
-0.0240310617,
-0.0574911311,
0.0532149896,
0.02045561,
0.0385915935,
0.0309026372,
0.0487726629,
-0.046952337,
0.0003049149,
-0.0060211173,
-0.0044409875,
-0.0001506875,
0.0169567075,
-0.0057993019,
0.0477679633,
0.0349913314,
0.0439610332,
0.0155160883,
0.0159174055,
0.0071253199,
0.0241255108,
0.0121964961,
0.0616778284,
-0.0715714768,
0.0153405201,
0.00324041,
0.0172539018,
0.0238042194,
0.0485021546,
0.049256701,
-0.0064976197,
0.0334051475,
0.0407246985,
-0.0472327843,
0.0246382654,
0.0017269801,
-0.0390109718,
0.0034649803,
-0.0097360658,
0.0016673838,
0.0616714694,
-0.0432531424,
0.0212481432,
-0.0196834132,
-0.020792963,
-0.0063636568,
0.0722326711,
-0.0392071083,
0.0225794706,
-0.0122999018,
-0.0417705365,
0.0157396067,
-0.0425281487,
-0.0103172781,
0.0248457734,
0.0583441593,
0.0031049277,
0.0137878954,
-0.0676805824,
0.0183525421,
-0.0440859981,
0.0517503656,
0.0482732803,
-0.02122695,
0.0243867114,
0.0442359224,
0.0275740828,
-0.0189075042,
0.038910117,
0.0028033517,
-0.0108588208,
0.0323727466,
-0.0237637945,
0.0007752412,
0.0710964501,
-0.0226811059,
-0.0431714989,
0.0361447223,
0.0057290262,
0.0298575833,
0.0145560326,
0.0024548336,
-0.0695992336,
-0.0276636668,
0.0094904117,
-0.0174095109,
-0.0260968376,
-0.0174844731,
0.0773840547,
0.0108033903,
0.0194879547,
0.03932276,
-0.017557729,
-0.0432856977,
0.0255664885,
0.0056124507,
-0.0375523008,
-0.0173593462,
0.0050688232,
-0.0091691399,
-0.0490656383,
-0.06333258,
0.0026543303,
-0.0121577429,
0.0515024513,
0.0625875816,
0.0158515312,
0.0106338784,
-0.0698042437,
-0.0011719892,
-0.0371571742,
0.0151885161,
-0.0357107595,
0.0673253387,
0.0365921929,
0.0061782617,
0.03351276,
0.0058060214,
0.0313068368,
-0.0392631181,
0.009919744,
0.0127835348,
0.0152986273,
-0.0074229436,
0.014957564,
0.0126186367,
-0.0285379104,
-0.0294443071,
-0.0147145912,
-0.034288656,
-0.0038764116,
-0.0060729603,
2.705e-7,
0.0247484241,
0.0117409341,
-0.0496233627,
0.0457889624,
-0.0078349868,
-0.0016744662,
-0.0113456463,
0.0179558583,
0.0103860963,
0.0402080752,
-0.0297933053,
0.0036226385,
0.0414975509,
0.0187414642,
-0.0909567326,
-0.0057073059,
-0.0248602591,
-0.0440405123,
-0.0874437168,
-0.0037194453,
0.0579554215,
0.0724282041,
0.0267838202,
-0.0182264242,
-0.021372987,
-0.0713227019,
0.0416809134,
0.0028253451,
-0.0107556982,
0.0353809446,
0.0042971089,
0.0337175503,
-0.026578404,
0.063640736,
-0.0018901135,
0.0483203754,
0.0487799868,
0.0555043668,
-0.0467318706,
0.0626778454,
-0.0084826387,
-0.0319612063,
-0.0292264093,
-0.0184309799,
0.0520454273,
-0.0396453738,
-0.0017862215,
-0.0512479171,
-0.0712323189,
-0.0173998326,
-0.015475872,
0.0151808867,
-0.0259666406,
-0.0202298462,
0.0276787858,
-0.0336689018,
-0.0774647519,
0.0049982932,
0.0198646504,
0.0187812764,
-0.0239570886,
-0.0546526015,
0.032762114,
0.0188602116,
0.0410940908,
-0.0325867906,
0.0073111681,
2.61874657e-34,
0.0118469475,
0.0489257202,
0.0246880371,
0.0117029818,
0.0214165822,
0.0186321419,
-0.016234573,
0.013338685,
-0.0245357417,
-0.0325303376,
-0.0120413965
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.03534v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.03534v1 | Quantifying the perceptual value of lexical and non-lexical channels in speech | 2023-07-07T11:44:23 | 2023-07-07T11:44:23 | Sarenne Wallbridge, Peter Bell, Catherine Lai | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IT, math.IT | Speech is a fundamental means of communication that can be seen to provide
two channels for transmitting information: the lexical channel of which words
are said, and the non-lexical channel of how they are spoken. Both channels
shape listener expectations of upcoming communication; however, directly
quantifying their relative effect on expectations is challenging. Previous
attempts require spoken variations of lexically-equivalent dialogue turns or
conspicuous acoustic manipulations. This paper introduces a generalised
paradigm to study the value of non-lexical information in dialogue across
unconstrained lexical content. By quantifying the perceptual value of the
non-lexical channel with both accuracy and entropy reduction, we show that
non-lexical information produces a consistent effect on expectations of
upcoming dialogue: even when it leads to poorer discriminative turn judgements
than lexical content alone, it yields higher consensus among participants. | [
0.0367021263,
0.0405697003,
-0.0235832632,
0.0141299032,
-0.0685418174,
-0.0302596819,
-0.0372962095,
0.0086650988,
-0.0464084186,
-0.0422733873,
-0.0750253871,
-0.0272862017,
0.0625984445,
0.0092500485,
0.0418219194,
-0.0881566256,
0.0068445643,
-0.0250586253,
0.0062975991,
-0.0214039907,
0.0197042003,
-0.0330995806,
-0.0395820662,
0.0191833545,
-0.0004551657,
0.015004226,
-0.0392230339,
0.0654030293,
-0.01076065,
0.0134416455,
-0.0454785191,
0.0608450249,
-0.0204807427,
0.0284181293,
0.0000014552,
-0.0377018228,
0.042149622,
-0.0256200414,
-0.0443421975,
0.013880861,
0.0013394825,
0.0202702507,
-0.0403290838,
-0.0379634202,
-0.0176610723,
-0.010344604,
0.0696309209,
0.0392074734,
-0.0359373279,
0.0288615972,
0.0051785032,
-0.0138304885,
-0.0089160129,
-0.0215303246,
0.0238446891,
-0.0347485542,
0.0124935489,
-0.033902593,
-0.055909317,
-0.0350202508,
-0.0791835412,
0.0316356309,
-0.0198340677,
-0.0029790178,
-0.0070647351,
0.0442577191,
-0.0116487844,
-0.0114903934,
-0.0334045179,
0.0635685921,
0.0405437648,
-0.0030400068,
-0.01050846,
-0.0134616736,
-0.0039427071,
-0.005762835,
0.0059831399,
-0.004896245,
0.0518019311,
-0.0117582045,
-0.057665538,
0.0384196639,
-0.0398633257,
-0.0326928534,
0.0042532459,
0.1017967314,
0.0144444471,
-0.0545101948,
0.0227624159,
-0.0179413743,
0.0102261081,
-0.0371105932,
-0.0155721931,
-0.0370487571,
0.0069868243,
0.0287474543,
0.0115269478,
0.0281383097,
-0.0155072017,
-0.0594613552,
-0.0496535115,
-0.0150787104,
-0.0022620093,
0.0154299382,
0.0695057511,
0.0181367565,
-0.0323327407,
0.0304907579,
-0.0325486958,
0.0247360095,
0.0218341332,
-0.0006876885,
-0.0179644488,
-0.0128676258,
-0.0196617264,
-0.0351996385,
-0.009498707,
-0.0119668925,
-0.0209841616,
-0.0008622332,
0.0144110741,
0.019402286,
-0.02000973,
-0.006666874,
-0.0063189333,
0.0427988656,
-0.0045285989,
0.04308654,
-0.0126036294,
-0.0835840628,
-0.0006850887,
0.0447867103,
0.0385687426,
0.0015450717,
-0.0271883402,
0.074501425,
0.0108178193,
-0.0202603955,
0.0040482683,
0.0066290852,
-0.0608822852,
-0.0386152007,
-0.0138437226,
-0.0043634353,
0.0075659743,
-0.0228476264,
0.0067096748,
0.0136835724,
0.0000877658,
-0.0454853885,
-0.0287914481,
0.0396043919,
0.0546657667,
0.0486808307,
0.0114322081,
0.0040323376,
0.0012675114,
0.0607577078,
0.0395092592,
-0.0530168079,
0.0707084015,
-0.0469852164,
0.0008885582,
0.0568470061,
0.0264178421,
0.0107076056,
0.0138242953,
-0.0233008452,
0.0131114693,
0.0178931579,
0.0578154922,
0.0481636897,
-0.0433082506,
-0.0578253195,
0.0666362047,
0.0689774901,
0.0053126025,
-0.0347988755,
-0.0063406788,
0.0258901864,
0.0055067204,
0.0919029787,
-0.0100488355,
0.0023165974,
-0.011550067,
-0.0109820087,
0.0765156299,
-0.0295506008,
-0.0338488296,
-0.014771604,
-0.0128044663,
0.0194782764,
0.0637185648,
-0.0143177668,
0.0113302721,
0.0156705976,
-0.0222968571,
0.0089482162,
0.0131372111,
-0.0426464565,
0.0157906953,
-0.0113311056,
-0.0284365974,
0.0342374668,
0.0057502007,
0.0480963588,
0.0153060779,
0.003186018,
-0.0500490069,
0.0669883788,
0.014293205,
-0.0046856785,
0.0657630563,
-0.0224577375,
0.0171340555,
0.0222826507,
-0.0030608454,
0.0120438812,
-0.0499558225,
0.022477882,
-0.0155038228,
-0.0089802276,
0.0569594838,
-0.0154892299,
0.0316992179,
-0.0279872268,
0.0015180235,
0.0146459285,
0.064583376,
-0.0168906618,
-0.0446777157,
0.016998006,
0.0242562424,
0.0313466601,
0.0041544978,
0.0859948546,
-0.0275685769,
-0.0446323715,
0.0117026083,
-0.0592203997,
0.0055448702,
-0.0113999126,
0.0267606676,
-0.0470031239,
0.0662580356,
-0.0607264191,
0.115177229,
-0.0212377422,
0.0133154541,
0.0174803268,
0.0374402069,
-0.0095114559,
-0.0330980718,
-0.0072175302,
0.0476341583,
-0.0260690972,
-0.0174278729,
0.0077512912,
-0.046777077,
0.0036692806,
0.0349849127,
-0.0122972596,
0.0008534375,
0.0146935228,
-0.0582863316,
-0.032446593,
-0.0249917489,
-0.0444126502,
-0.0436780564,
-0.0058947429,
0.0016314427,
0.0381348059,
0.0039575258,
0.0078923451,
0.0056779552,
-0.0358067527,
-0.0258774739,
-0.0123642366,
0.0297268983,
-0.0291863307,
0.0292431675,
-0.0487989597,
-0.0164731778,
0.0102447495,
0.0233699325,
0.0370035395,
-0.0186647102,
0.0138393827,
0.0000787073,
0.0175444987,
-0.0117346253,
0.0385325141,
-0.0074115344,
-0.0647341534,
-0.0080191214,
0.0440595113,
0.0339905992,
0.0047073318,
0.0216959566,
0.0069067334,
0.0129857315,
-0.0831677914,
-0.0282899868,
-0.0117751528,
-0.026683012,
0.0136264684,
-0.0441388302,
-0.0446532667,
0.045083113,
0.0224173702,
0.0604854487,
0.040224418,
-0.0393013321,
-0.0705188662,
0.004202127,
-0.10425473,
0.0049110316,
-0.037592832,
-0.0563300252,
0.0713448375,
0.0071110195,
-0.0086154109,
0.0441823602,
-0.0480771735,
-0.0669583157,
-0.0059653344,
0.0153869502,
0.0230927132,
0.0175862275,
-0.0168179348,
0.0124581829,
0.0151246162,
-0.0639157146,
-0.0470678285,
-0.0482226573,
0.0433819443,
-0.0146461017,
0.0466283299,
-0.0121502001,
-0.0132198883,
0.0266571138,
-0.0141745396,
0.0036083215,
-0.0314898118,
0.0109266713,
-0.0054722102,
0.0773236975,
-0.0461529456,
0.0572247803,
0.0460343026,
0.0281345882,
-0.0040286747,
0.0249605328,
-0.000815704,
0.0173792057,
0.0249268804,
0.0361273997,
0.0392903723,
-0.0010514845,
0.0137881842,
0.0146386856,
0.0225801934,
0.0235051736,
0.0377897173,
-0.0022700115,
0.0010337861,
0.0629774481,
0.008157772,
-0.0320907533,
0.034261398,
0.0229359772,
0.0149639538,
0.013367611,
0.0545334816,
-0.0062307082,
-0.0445824377,
0.0161782,
-0.0420063287,
0.0427602939,
-0.0082026292,
-0.0206922628,
-0.067217797,
0.0004495582,
0.0181383602,
-0.0022707593,
-0.0448281467,
0.0113728121,
-0.0390023179,
-0.0773910806,
0.0369601212,
0.0272060204,
-0.0464614034,
-0.0428588204,
-0.0146075524,
0.0489983894,
-0.015555216,
0.0132838292,
0.0100132525,
-0.0045484668,
-0.0230978411,
0.0098946011,
-0.0614021569,
0.0085582193,
-0.0002795153,
0.0122184092,
0.0489395037,
0.04119372,
0.0258038826,
-0.0049492456,
-0.0464884564,
-0.0050528976,
-0.0321371257,
-0.0167814232,
-0.0009167352,
0.04148544,
-0.0169275999,
-0.0053493646,
-0.0459500328,
0.0135270618,
0.0448600352,
-0.0130639775,
-0.0137429014,
-0.0085675409,
-0.0544768088,
-0.0166974869,
0.0084764017,
0.0659798905,
0.0320464931,
0.0700801462,
0.0538617186,
-0.0452637523,
0.0275662541,
0.0082523124,
0.0444225781,
0.0334937349,
-0.0604856163,
-0.0173903164,
0.044173684,
-0.1184674874,
-0.0629571751,
-0.0328927599,
-0.0407106988,
0.0383896232,
-0.0068232352,
-0.0010179623,
0.026407931,
-0.0109842718,
0.0184855387,
-0.0810260996,
-0.010682364,
0.032094162,
-0.0447542556,
-0.0266118031,
0.0200348757,
-0.0248138588,
-0.0205831099,
0.0450002626,
-0.0056873532,
-0.0844553486,
0.0445685536,
-0.0343265198,
0.0226693638,
0.0557246171,
0.0141943311,
-0.0118824746,
0.01006955,
-0.0122435102,
-0.0149115771,
0.0727249682,
0.0563832857,
0.0759739876,
0.0122977355,
0.0382051095,
0.016865667,
-0.0033968627,
0.0069115013,
0.0088826148,
-0.0768859684,
-0.1453050077,
-0.007222936,
-0.0075494307,
0.0843241811,
0.0172652211,
0.0130120944,
0.0124415709,
0.0300468542,
0.0161345508,
0.0047617052,
-0.0236575287,
-0.0390488841,
0.0053504286,
0.0247490928,
-0.045328185,
0.0122437999,
-0.0741306543,
0.0067698103,
0.0256364085,
-0.0018418871,
0.0391697772,
-0.004898244,
-0.009827164,
0.0149875386,
0.0074991374,
0.0266469344,
-0.008625797,
0.0276644733,
0.0550259016,
0.0281441603,
0.0252332911,
-0.0635893419,
0.0256410595,
-0.0011541792,
-0.0697208047,
0.0135456556,
0.0400857851,
0.0080192462,
-0.0260880161,
0.0120073119,
0.0178759303,
-0.0225596745,
0.0550758243,
0.0039319973,
0.0125898337,
-0.0557322241,
-0.0301461704,
0.0717810243,
-0.0087965243,
-0.0225054789,
0.0444489978,
0.0298380107,
-0.0277632177,
0.0082472796,
-0.0221091285,
0.0424736701,
-0.0365249738,
-0.0593220368,
0.0120549519,
0.0104347011,
-0.0093857525,
0.023401143,
-0.0605150461,
-0.0317058414,
-0.0086572906,
0.0062031504,
0.0529514104,
-0.0157590788,
0.0531513169,
0.0393654853,
-0.038703192,
-0.010261639,
0.0061855111,
-0.0196842477,
0.0337140523,
0.0168088321,
-0.042593427,
-5.462544289e-33,
-0.0108208256,
-0.0203071833,
-0.0266382005,
0.065650709,
-0.0328928865,
-0.0034045223,
-0.0253339503,
0.0235381853,
-0.0143458406,
0.0260186642,
-0.0016833257,
0.0229855888,
0.0151006617,
-0.0281596258,
-0.0002185966,
-0.0337116048,
0.0399834029,
0.0046222275,
-0.034261398,
-0.0077331206,
0.0365756117,
-0.0386770107,
0.0729555637,
-0.0725617409,
0.02872728,
0.0225150269,
-0.0519152544,
-0.006340384,
0.0099476725,
-0.0270455647,
-0.0033337458,
0.035677474,
-0.0192090515,
-0.0730371922,
-0.0085824188,
0.0344782621,
0.0311662871,
-0.0335005596,
0.0767776892,
0.0736978874,
-0.0116869621,
0.0225292239,
0.0113296071,
-0.0100311963,
-0.0589647144,
0.0096603213,
-0.0017178608,
0.0266832318,
-0.0048322375,
-0.0001703523,
-0.0234756619,
0.0091757393,
-0.054139182,
-0.0507573634,
0.0112789189,
0.0247808285,
0.0061725313,
-0.0999070331,
-0.0637529045,
0.0823601037,
-0.021487359,
0.0226730891,
0.0186684057,
0.0220530387,
0.0494936071,
0.0365669802,
0.0607286319,
-0.0260889716,
0.0184311476,
-0.0424238034,
0.0351420864,
0.0298476275,
-0.0255752988,
0.0411992893,
0.0232666414,
-0.0072091562,
0.0282944608,
-0.0361838676,
0.0054955892,
0.0278733019,
-0.0328764617,
0.0536188893,
-0.0675033256,
-0.0548807979,
-0.0308913067,
-0.0336267874,
-0.0136979213,
0.0013674062,
-0.010358423,
-0.0358530618,
0.0345042758,
0.0338449553,
0.086013332,
-0.0355445333,
-0.0216929317,
0.0212814007,
-0.0010201443,
0.0566569529,
-0.008886531,
-0.0172218382,
-0.0233186278,
0.0088835265,
0.0733639076,
0.0516291261,
0.0248984452,
0.0123548964,
-0.0343558714,
0.0314810574,
-0.0488222614,
-0.0285005346,
0.0132357525,
-0.011820863,
-0.0109013291,
-0.0923284069,
0.0455660298,
0.0039094877,
-0.0459327921,
0.0028016316,
-0.0352961384,
0.0025725265,
-0.0245900601,
0.0303719975,
-0.004373603,
0.0416614823,
-0.0756257474,
-0.0351265706,
0.0126919895,
-0.0760608092,
0.051116392,
0.0128500015,
-0.0225996915,
0.009875657,
2.52e-7,
-0.0125768501,
0.0232470296,
0.0169728268,
0.0011701928,
0.0465693809,
0.0324922353,
-0.0031552648,
-0.0211022273,
0.0366898477,
-0.049419824,
0.021848686,
-0.0391140766,
0.0269243605,
-0.0070505417,
-0.0645407513,
-0.035702493,
-0.0694028884,
-0.0157923494,
0.0372474305,
0.0000893696,
0.0302343722,
0.0478158295,
0.0194879025,
0.016143471,
-0.0043574115,
0.0312708803,
0.0058779889,
-0.054864224,
0.0463327281,
0.0048240232,
0.0047441241,
-0.040928714,
0.0051516904,
0.0483687557,
-0.011639962,
0.0268125497,
-0.0058950582,
0.0199150126,
-0.0197061431,
-0.086970292,
-0.0237933863,
0.0052659749,
-0.0527977571,
0.0046933698,
0.0012958565,
0.0148723386,
-0.0380031355,
-0.006579353,
-0.03706792,
0.0301807914,
0.0547542386,
0.0026548211,
-0.0220262669,
0.0090687452,
0.0099861519,
0.014813412,
-0.0362620279,
-0.0182002783,
-0.0010715438,
0.0025707493,
-0.0309925023,
-0.0500691608,
0.0193728767,
-0.0190375298,
0.0296140984,
-0.070145227,
-0.0283832811,
1.473251547e-34,
0.0208795108,
0.0072352062,
0.0568221547,
0.0254736692,
0.0172447897,
-0.0317584313,
0.0560004376,
0.0121812662,
0.0605094023,
-0.0534114018,
-0.0180239603
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.03506v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.03506v2 | Derivative Free Weight-space Ensembling | 2023-07-07T10:42:44 | 2023-07-26T09:06:22 | Dean Ninalga | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent work suggests that interpolating between the weights of two
specialized language models can transfer knowledge between tasks in a way that
multi-task learning cannot. However, very few have explored interpolation
between more than two models, where each has a distinct knowledge base. In this
paper, we introduce Derivative Free Weight-space Ensembling (DFWE), a new
few-sample task transfer approach for open-domain dialogue. Our framework
creates a set of diverse expert language models trained using a predefined set
of source tasks. Next, we finetune each of the expert models on the target
task, approaching the target task from several distinct knowledge bases.
Finally, we linearly interpolate between the model weights using a
gradient-free-optimization algorithm, to efficiently find a good interpolation
weighting. We demonstrate the effectiveness of the method on FETA-Friends
outperforming the standard pretrain-finetune approach. | [
0.025237428,
0.0626129285,
-0.0205239337,
0.0344979763,
0.0015148501,
0.0078893192,
0.0060946066,
-0.0185402445,
0.0060279802,
-0.0311647579,
-0.0871450827,
-0.0390269347,
0.0197376572,
0.0201842263,
0.0269429367,
-0.0718734413,
0.0127053233,
-0.0366878249,
0.0112523586,
-0.0183310881,
-0.0091871219,
0.0045048236,
-0.018564323,
0.0337681808,
0.015090216,
-0.00559142,
-0.0423447974,
0.0140946116,
0.0110719372,
0.057453461,
0.0540975258,
0.028844215,
0.026035374,
0.0068770447,
0.0000019512,
-0.0098888818,
-0.0130160917,
-0.0429111049,
-0.0298366044,
-0.0453597642,
0.0445017666,
0.0048077116,
0.0235680826,
0.0172578879,
-0.0437635854,
-0.0116512561,
0.0411491878,
0.0604863763,
0.1095853373,
0.0901122168,
-0.0101728598,
-0.0190372951,
-0.0040389174,
-0.0629682988,
0.0066850521,
-0.0662766099,
0.0274679959,
0.0195207912,
-0.0313965343,
-0.0108268484,
-0.0176294167,
0.0327654183,
0.0198841523,
-0.0442872569,
0.0058476762,
-0.0054768925,
0.0260270014,
-0.0062270751,
-0.0507910028,
0.137553215,
-0.0650128573,
0.0329840519,
-0.0062427437,
-0.0046639116,
0.0370835476,
0.0208885949,
-0.0587406941,
-0.0186583158,
-0.0009877544,
0.0242143366,
-0.0041872845,
-0.0164973419,
0.0160305593,
-0.0068988004,
-0.01706177,
0.0813102946,
0.0058400198,
-0.0168993473,
0.0315205827,
-0.0230127219,
-0.0625914261,
-0.0443049967,
0.0099378079,
0.0088192848,
-0.0348861106,
-0.0122507466,
-0.0874031261,
-0.0535015725,
-0.033489041,
0.0241344236,
0.0854304582,
0.011741017,
0.0135320546,
0.028754564,
-0.0136834662,
0.0398038775,
-0.0119485436,
0.0205311254,
-0.0743162408,
-0.0193777177,
-0.0899456292,
-0.0155755077,
-0.0430818051,
0.0289041512,
-0.108983621,
-0.0291031078,
0.006545973,
0.008645311,
-0.0396500006,
-0.0324106999,
0.0387908295,
0.0159633551,
-0.0519611351,
-0.0131137082,
-0.0236906726,
0.0550478734,
0.0120672612,
0.0703835487,
0.0287061948,
-0.0220276881,
-0.0547146201,
0.0017009007,
-0.0099236686,
-0.0269049406,
0.0065602493,
0.068041712,
-0.0650156066,
-0.0010231279,
0.0020604385,
-0.0243391972,
0.0155488169,
-0.0592021681,
0.0306473896,
-0.0384873003,
0.0390449986,
-0.0236545056,
0.02254772,
-0.0821074396,
-0.0232521929,
-0.0046495129,
-0.0600625202,
0.0820754394,
-0.0313729942,
0.0177883878,
0.0527662262,
0.0061146691,
-0.0390872099,
0.0591675006,
0.0088146152,
0.0000390795,
-0.0073332847,
0.0183861759,
-0.022943506,
0.001079279,
0.0215503573,
0.0219832566,
-0.0096906703,
0.0073114051,
0.0406886227,
0.021193685,
0.0818005502,
0.0242244657,
-0.067881301,
0.008696883,
0.0708583444,
0.0454747416,
0.0158813708,
-0.0202284865,
0.0366276838,
0.0322724096,
0.0193253737,
0.0123734018,
-0.0464098528,
0.0193709061,
0.0155667318,
-0.0526097752,
0.0215882193,
0.0296551716,
-0.0347271599,
-0.0410874262,
0.0561937615,
-0.0194924492,
0.0166515931,
-0.009082675,
0.0286112502,
0.0390974507,
-0.0502850339,
0.0484751612,
0.0300772544,
-0.023932768,
-0.0089178877,
-0.0172877423,
0.0012307137,
0.0750430971,
-0.0309807342,
-0.0097937975,
-0.0480380505,
-0.0305326786,
0.0589647777,
0.0155115044,
-0.0012357241,
-0.0395508483,
0.0425783023,
-0.0556235537,
-0.0238397084,
-0.0236353371,
-0.0073423893,
0.035609711,
-0.0176765714,
0.0048295464,
0.0220981538,
-0.0007059384,
0.0025232835,
-0.0034549451,
-0.030781325,
0.0098000802,
0.0200919453,
-0.0080862809,
0.0249967538,
0.0055046747,
-0.0117321433,
-0.0107270349,
-0.0075145643,
-0.0359706953,
-0.0302671641,
0.0003963679,
-0.0409696624,
-0.0412284583,
0.0348346718,
-0.0308474172,
0.0052947048,
0.0069652237,
-0.0437727906,
-0.0792590603,
0.0455621257,
0.0141527401,
0.0115978308,
-0.023157917,
0.0053556771,
0.0317333452,
0.0063888999,
-0.061419636,
0.0299182832,
0.0244667456,
-0.005466959,
0.0207513012,
0.0054316707,
0.0025528478,
-0.0327722915,
0.0049098856,
0.0324466676,
0.0123500628,
0.020397203,
-0.0390554816,
0.0156570096,
-0.0277617928,
-0.0567048714,
-0.1126409248,
0.0091792056,
-0.0139398184,
0.0247520208,
0.0359982438,
0.0187248141,
-0.0095173065,
-0.0324992277,
-0.0434116796,
0.0152084222,
-0.0098572485,
-0.0238295235,
0.0288896337,
0.0392078608,
0.0209963564,
-0.038727399,
-0.0056192717,
0.0361078829,
0.0158022195,
-0.0034963633,
-0.0022484662,
-0.0589498058,
-0.0125451256,
-0.0134295765,
0.0519577526,
-0.0386682861,
-0.0377760604,
-0.0198716559,
-0.0096296612,
0.0120267151,
0.0715458766,
-0.0183223579,
-0.0090184938,
0.0275653414,
-0.03284638,
-0.034732908,
0.0453506932,
-0.0017866293,
-0.0044105165,
-0.0738079697,
0.0517484881,
-0.0034463734,
0.0529792979,
-0.0279281996,
-0.0026414325,
-0.0806766301,
0.0096436795,
0.0154065499,
-0.0300765652,
-0.0103075039,
0.0074004079,
0.0055788741,
0.0018191646,
-0.0463781394,
-0.0270398837,
0.0520706996,
-0.0039738142,
-0.0293374453,
-0.0476614647,
-0.024440594,
-0.008307118,
0.0202532578,
-0.0095362281,
-0.0019208733,
0.0216008183,
-0.01993143,
-0.0571006574,
0.0144700781,
0.0318937413,
-0.0051970896,
0.0307297986,
-0.0743132085,
0.0313654207,
0.0001406004,
-0.0622491091,
0.0028599089,
-0.0330086388,
-0.0029434275,
0.0156665929,
0.0219638161,
-0.0457752347,
-0.0158286151,
-0.0119389901,
-0.0034361407,
0.0414769389,
-0.0145263579,
0.0077343085,
-0.0482788011,
0.0151968561,
0.0720382854,
0.0569144189,
-0.0378858186,
-0.0527158529,
-0.0051487372,
-0.0106100915,
0.055650536,
0.0060076518,
0.002487306,
0.0421102159,
0.0296941623,
-0.0243398286,
-0.052632302,
0.0000349734,
0.0508418754,
-0.0016142015,
0.0033136846,
0.0792324394,
-0.0029638051,
-0.0449102372,
-0.0062729488,
0.0067769648,
0.0148778483,
0.0097133182,
0.0270371176,
-0.0512497053,
-0.0794245675,
0.0153268473,
-0.0126156863,
0.0383653045,
-0.0462662578,
-0.0175554976,
-0.1259270608,
0.0002437225,
0.0218867119,
0.0023660362,
-0.0255245622,
0.0164608993,
0.015925074,
-0.0129477317,
0.0009172939,
-0.0178285539,
-0.0099808974,
0.0135917468,
0.0282146465,
0.0511191711,
-0.0828966871,
-0.0048818444,
0.0051030521,
0.0731457323,
0.0328873992,
0.0094366083,
0.0091833482,
-0.0209458806,
0.0052751862,
0.0164628513,
-0.02529018,
0.0032709972,
0.0773505718,
0.0123489676,
-0.0314784944,
0.0367650129,
0.0409883745,
-0.0333812162,
0.0192628633,
0.0221222509,
0.028197594,
-0.0168979783,
0.0016334266,
0.0347347707,
-0.0553361699,
0.0797162727,
0.0564559847,
0.0014558947,
-0.0451093242,
-0.0181198828,
-0.0251135807,
-0.0207934659,
-0.0017555001,
0.0101535106,
0.0341798887,
-0.0145758828,
0.0302322619,
-0.0713603497,
0.0038362467,
0.0475213826,
0.0553595796,
0.0236812998,
0.0071347472,
0.0088060899,
-0.0047171274,
-0.0517309345,
0.02029722,
-0.0132764159,
0.0251122322,
-0.0271871015,
-0.0421883538,
0.0466163158,
0.0044255359,
-0.0189863555,
-0.0022305376,
-0.077617839,
-0.0529418662,
-0.0217196029,
0.0662943497,
0.0215482842,
0.0433662385,
-0.0170644335,
-0.0409725308,
0.0648856834,
0.0099624395,
-0.0355043225,
0.010092658,
0.0902040228,
-0.0478295758,
0.0115092294,
0.0687166974,
-0.0396967046,
0.0158619005,
0.0105537344,
0.0044600801,
-0.0093009798,
-0.0639106333,
-0.0269386191,
0.0059644561,
0.0286916401,
0.0463378206,
-0.0084007289,
-0.026781464,
0.0428818204,
-0.0081907241,
-0.0111846719,
-0.1110531688,
0.004447612,
0.0204299577,
0.0270590819,
0.0372282453,
0.0166401844,
0.0548803844,
0.0088168532,
-0.0118839052,
-0.0303656086,
-0.0254247859,
0.0353059396,
0.028086286,
0.0112286862,
0.029565908,
-0.0150589608,
0.0446764752,
0.0122015188,
0.0065108025,
0.0286741294,
0.0484433062,
0.0020414477,
-0.0206086673,
0.0277814437,
-0.0590313897,
-0.0674204528,
-0.0245918985,
0.005250277,
0.0607670322,
0.0170367546,
0.1100135148,
0.0099113109,
0.0030228074,
-0.0061803125,
0.0520060658,
-0.0033147063,
0.0331118107,
0.0384764932,
0.0022363081,
-0.0019475487,
0.0163302924,
0.1098438427,
-0.0013389514,
0.0599851869,
-0.022003185,
0.0355697945,
-0.0492024049,
-0.0569032803,
0.0293003768,
0.0118885869,
0.0406088047,
0.0264095888,
0.0213952027,
-0.0367228165,
0.0226426851,
-0.0416927785,
-0.0215370972,
0.0083992407,
0.0756271854,
0.0384900533,
-0.019009674,
0.0036810758,
-0.0163772665,
-0.0702042952,
0.0110730967,
-0.0161577165,
-0.0150666302,
-6.263689974e-33,
-0.0506039895,
-0.0036498671,
0.0064668916,
0.006420637,
-0.0518386848,
-0.021886453,
-0.0085802572,
-0.0111937765,
-0.0122744432,
0.0300633125,
-0.0047596837,
0.0244048797,
0.0206299275,
0.0337177627,
0.0159785151,
-0.0101517569,
0.0386010706,
0.0131847663,
-0.0153285973,
0.0527770258,
0.0181745216,
0.0581401438,
0.0416016728,
-0.04388896,
-0.0100932112,
0.0369429775,
0.0019712697,
0.0311710797,
0.0038342166,
-0.0039800345,
0.0103772758,
0.0309041329,
-0.0166204926,
-0.0635269657,
-0.0586930625,
0.0161430072,
-0.0617798194,
-0.0648356304,
0.0383129045,
-0.0285305846,
-0.0066458653,
-0.0319003463,
0.0283788536,
0.0184209589,
0.0624171384,
-0.034104906,
0.0271839947,
-0.0307501759,
0.0230687261,
0.023465313,
-0.0095041562,
-0.0189952943,
0.0021008179,
-0.0458091758,
0.0330703333,
0.0168039035,
-0.0080684703,
-0.0637547076,
-0.0020666029,
-0.0050847596,
-0.0035101483,
0.0552822053,
0.0117091294,
0.0343799405,
-0.0003080788,
0.0486077704,
-0.0206793174,
-0.0064219646,
0.0198971368,
-0.0324063823,
-0.0047267866,
0.042649094,
0.0119424555,
0.0213480797,
0.0185900033,
0.0076412493,
-0.0412028208,
-0.0128558315,
0.0139513304,
0.0130854174,
-0.0337358415,
0.0118623516,
0.0147399316,
-0.04836303,
-0.0479292832,
-0.0189749915,
0.0117586339,
-0.0424486063,
0.0223050453,
0.005365171,
0.0151675474,
0.0187173393,
0.0237198099,
-0.0320780277,
-0.0031402884,
0.0171989352,
-0.0477816239,
-0.0016258322,
0.0206489693,
-0.0099036898,
-0.0512299538,
-0.0752175674,
0.036000412,
0.026560396,
0.031785924,
0.013243774,
0.0110905552,
0.0168256704,
-0.0376119092,
-0.0244411249,
-0.0219680816,
0.0358912833,
0.0048673591,
0.0951413214,
0.0247669071,
0.0187778305,
-0.0341332257,
0.0088577168,
-0.025199471,
-0.0272486024,
-0.0304907914,
-0.0315199345,
0.0350237451,
0.0199423581,
-0.041127231,
0.002775908,
-0.0297493543,
-0.0237138662,
-0.0016714109,
-0.0480638444,
-0.0108597362,
0.0083690593,
2.811e-7,
-0.0171617586,
-0.0087693995,
0.01491402,
-0.0077753612,
0.0110109681,
0.0322874598,
-0.031806916,
0.0591525324,
-0.0051518581,
-0.0201300848,
-0.0287216716,
0.0636271387,
0.0630082712,
-0.018017333,
-0.1092911586,
-0.0441943929,
-0.0354090482,
-0.0213156193,
-0.0032368223,
-0.0444093794,
-0.0099895019,
0.0481427535,
0.0548739247,
-0.0112175485,
-0.003134002,
-0.0128449704,
0.0518475063,
-0.0174555704,
0.0003932816,
0.0473140329,
0.0206494294,
0.0045555206,
-0.0387402885,
0.0794251338,
0.0033661292,
0.0229002126,
0.037038926,
0.0602118187,
-0.0096715987,
-0.0003499202,
-0.0464206152,
0.0165467076,
0.002041881,
0.0299546514,
0.0594117641,
-0.0842248499,
-0.0182241164,
0.0091982344,
-0.0261025168,
-0.0256230254,
0.0267890934,
0.0003785311,
0.0121697532,
0.0324926339,
0.0333435237,
0.0333351679,
0.0090321498,
-0.0714470446,
-0.0011238619,
0.0624274537,
-0.0590847172,
-0.0563717559,
-0.0308050979,
-0.0511507131,
0.0217463318,
-0.0485516004,
0.0471468195,
2.179450785e-34,
0.0035115639,
0.0052312883,
0.0310937129,
0.0338250659,
-0.0060100425,
-0.0241802447,
-0.0458556563,
0.0113807106,
0.0174650233,
-0.0643140599,
-0.007736031
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.04643v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.04643v1 | MultiQG-TI: Towards Question Generation from Multi-modal Sources | 2023-07-07T08:14:15 | 2023-07-07T08:14:15 | Zichao Wang, Richard Baraniuk | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We study the new problem of automatic question generation (QG) from
multi-modal sources containing images and texts, significantly expanding the
scope of most of the existing work that focuses exclusively on QG from only
textual sources. We propose a simple solution for our new problem, called
MultiQG-TI, which enables a text-only question generator to process visual
input in addition to textual input. Specifically, we leverage an image-to-text
model and an optical character recognition model to obtain the textual
description of the image and extract any texts in the image, respectively, and
then feed them together with the input texts to the question generator. We only
fine-tune the question generator while keeping the other components fixed. On
the challenging ScienceQA dataset, we demonstrate that MultiQG-TI significantly
outperforms ChatGPT with few-shot prompting, despite having hundred-times less
trainable parameters. Additional analyses empirically confirm the necessity of
both visual and textual signals for QG and show the impact of various modeling
choices. | [
0.0196181759,
0.0371267349,
0.0042112293,
0.0319515876,
-0.0484983437,
0.0209274907,
0.042192135,
0.0302114952,
0.0248911865,
-0.0329784863,
0.0151163535,
-0.0384569839,
-0.0213187635,
0.0455149896,
0.0404258557,
-0.0555147566,
0.0017042703,
-0.0443559214,
-0.0387854017,
0.0072339005,
0.0227294862,
-0.0028237815,
-0.0124893235,
0.0291898251,
-0.0299188569,
-0.0209365934,
-0.0738253519,
0.0161097795,
0.0076401825,
-0.0290884729,
-0.0345272012,
0.0410665683,
0.0179518349,
0.0023863195,
0.0000018706,
-0.0149494158,
-0.030324284,
0.0085261231,
0.0152315469,
-0.0342444405,
0.0442035012,
0.0066608884,
0.0310536847,
0.025232967,
-0.0487200692,
0.0188423786,
0.0624860711,
0.0554022603,
0.0732426047,
0.0704278126,
-0.0235285591,
0.0102596311,
0.016909508,
-0.0040539224,
0.0889316872,
0.0004807519,
-0.0174588226,
0.0321774893,
0.0522430651,
0.0323475525,
-0.0082268696,
0.0678568333,
0.021456942,
-0.0292420164,
-0.0161600001,
0.0658888668,
-0.0105070081,
-0.0373167433,
-0.0460755825,
0.1141410321,
0.0238771476,
0.0197295174,
0.0126502123,
0.0065656351,
0.0298944656,
0.0289249159,
-0.0518138707,
0.0364882946,
-0.0303851608,
-0.0268445313,
-0.0186959412,
-0.0140377833,
-0.0370456204,
0.0016451395,
-0.0014251687,
-0.0160196628,
0.0598313101,
-0.0186457653,
-0.0519021079,
0.0191639531,
-0.0388417207,
-0.0762142241,
-0.0170813836,
0.0549474768,
0.0102092288,
0.0218600091,
-0.045386713,
-0.0169184208,
0.0103622722,
0.0256256424,
0.012787411,
0.0378053375,
-0.0510302819,
0.0454441197,
-0.017232338,
0.0554111861,
0.0238852035,
0.0260860473,
-0.0613530688,
0.0065303463,
-0.0140255,
-0.0153982574,
-0.0453997999,
0.0030567532,
-0.0677989796,
-0.0438103043,
-0.0167852473,
0.0385829508,
0.0663788691,
-0.0145211592,
0.0204576757,
0.0186864324,
-0.0404386185,
0.0017310373,
0.014917478,
0.0231698658,
-0.0175061934,
0.0024495521,
0.0523889437,
-0.0440275744,
-0.0199010223,
0.0529187657,
0.051550746,
-0.0023366837,
-0.0117254416,
0.0683121011,
-0.0600281246,
-0.0447048396,
0.0130308857,
-0.0486549623,
-0.0450353473,
-0.0506956652,
0.0255536549,
-0.0109010246,
0.0473108552,
-0.0004747486,
-0.0358987413,
0.0264090393,
0.0190281123,
0.045086883,
0.0067014634,
0.0736927018,
-0.0239621755,
-0.0125949597,
0.0684211403,
0.0162711889,
-0.0061765555,
0.0381528921,
0.0305157024,
0.0173920039,
0.0283915494,
0.0048061875,
0.009404622,
0.0211326722,
0.0078266701,
0.0001321311,
-0.0197577607,
-0.0028320032,
0.0144636268,
0.0378765576,
-0.0285229441,
0.0722409114,
-0.0344374962,
0.0313354917,
0.0509545207,
0.0349580087,
-0.0051079118,
-0.0036138205,
0.0326519199,
0.0316830277,
0.0046804622,
0.020380307,
-0.0400706232,
0.0746208057,
0.0081465747,
0.0270854961,
0.0121775605,
0.0216792282,
-0.0273629334,
-0.0126445917,
0.0141209718,
0.0155091761,
0.0065012216,
0.0037455605,
0.0217189249,
0.0270938072,
-0.0580740087,
-0.0148532651,
-0.0073725926,
-0.0595617294,
0.0030413538,
-0.0199636053,
0.0608418509,
-0.0129805654,
0.0437697656,
0.0073863626,
-0.0211061463,
-0.0015784699,
0.0256350599,
0.0505848005,
0.0163366664,
-0.0015633618,
0.0065571275,
-0.0771457851,
-0.0165145881,
-0.029108746,
-0.0163396392,
0.0120347505,
-0.0073849028,
0.028871987,
0.0101106353,
0.0138863688,
0.0083940942,
0.0563223474,
0.006248476,
-0.0428263955,
0.0025421593,
0.0057726451,
-0.0364960022,
-0.0122713158,
-0.020276187,
0.0232995711,
0.0197133888,
-0.0328392647,
-0.0113525121,
0.0314130373,
-0.0515224263,
-0.0978316441,
0.0161055923,
-0.0429433174,
0.0047384091,
-0.0277419034,
-0.0263577346,
-0.0465266369,
-0.0011211424,
-0.0366436839,
-0.0323183499,
-0.0656499937,
-0.0302320067,
0.0532168821,
-0.0050809002,
-0.0564268939,
0.0375106744,
0.0121441334,
-0.0131937778,
0.016044829,
0.0026263569,
0.0272659548,
-0.030225005,
-0.0141153494,
0.0042714765,
-0.0355013944,
0.0186456628,
0.0098725194,
0.0708911493,
-0.0589460284,
-0.0352254137,
-0.0871545598,
-0.0009073143,
-0.0081453826,
-0.0244180206,
0.0265961401,
0.0344439149,
-0.0114359222,
-0.0150497342,
-0.0988960117,
0.0264257845,
0.0486189947,
-0.0224396475,
0.0642222092,
0.0281621851,
0.0380984172,
-0.0138349282,
-0.002780488,
0.0031698034,
0.0510512292,
0.0541477166,
0.0066967304,
-0.0457735583,
0.0030053286,
-0.0410847701,
-0.006605688,
0.0062012835,
-0.0220836475,
0.022926189,
-0.0498102717,
0.0558084585,
0.0701780543,
0.0232835375,
-0.0239190627,
0.0053949626,
-0.0076063955,
-0.0360055603,
0.0314898789,
-0.0161718186,
-0.0036772592,
0.0597041845,
-0.0362463109,
-0.0054261349,
0.030310059,
0.0190998465,
0.0235534105,
-0.0485135652,
0.0622219406,
-0.0145696653,
-0.0045594964,
-0.0816175565,
0.0295940209,
-0.0162633322,
0.028575195,
-0.0148106329,
-0.0545094609,
0.0406228155,
-0.0177419912,
-0.0334896185,
-0.0284310617,
0.0244723037,
-0.0090200268,
0.0755563974,
0.0113890301,
0.0533805825,
0.0635566488,
0.0006022844,
-0.0843266472,
0.0056529106,
0.0067951726,
-0.0046764719,
0.0058709085,
-0.0590459481,
0.0048245364,
-0.021211978,
-0.0495114699,
-0.0371289775,
-0.026390804,
0.011058107,
-0.0418185741,
-0.0326888599,
-0.0200426858,
0.0111676054,
0.0300859921,
0.0173850004,
0.0272102132,
-0.0483687446,
-0.014579948,
-0.0316866711,
0.1257636249,
0.0681075081,
0.0151342815,
-0.0075586666,
-0.0465142205,
0.0463422239,
0.0423719808,
0.0081709391,
0.0174810048,
0.0306446664,
0.0288068336,
-0.0185631551,
0.0497244671,
0.0136871738,
0.0269472357,
0.0945716128,
-0.0267723128,
-0.052297011,
0.0562055223,
0.046482902,
-0.0038121995,
-0.0349001698,
0.0216095708,
0.0359009057,
-0.0063891043,
0.0313042253,
-0.1091402099,
-0.0451894142,
-0.013969807,
0.0106409835,
0.0015329599,
-0.0052201636,
-0.0499879159,
-0.0553472117,
0.0502372533,
-0.0099917809,
-0.0201819241,
0.0110386992,
0.0357247032,
-0.0340180732,
0.0193567742,
-0.0379562639,
0.0235018842,
-0.0002233347,
0.0291963369,
0.0124727935,
0.0305179674,
-0.0090211462,
-0.0175646115,
-0.0158956274,
-0.0013835955,
0.0359711945,
0.0036757637,
0.0184212904,
-0.031007411,
0.0119806845,
-0.0075176097,
0.0027137084,
0.0123002725,
0.0309410822,
-0.0068650204,
-0.0343062356,
-0.0259288251,
0.0700373352,
-0.0019412973,
0.0147193028,
0.0439275652,
-0.0009674113,
-0.010448385,
-0.0232548453,
-0.0155585567,
0.0248069856,
0.0074320734,
0.0581364371,
0.0170979239,
-0.0606981143,
-0.0352523811,
-0.0353185721,
-0.0014264715,
-0.1062247008,
-0.023093272,
-0.0023704022,
0.0239318144,
0.0267638359,
-0.1111869067,
-0.0071929581,
0.0423173085,
0.0327435769,
-0.01679812,
-0.0441194065,
-0.0118591692,
0.034064997,
-0.0359127596,
0.0223589949,
-0.004778388,
-0.0205393005,
-0.0430903398,
0.0178087074,
0.0185638256,
-0.0566309653,
-0.0212746821,
0.0163351465,
-0.1055912524,
-0.0455188155,
-0.023728665,
0.0687811971,
0.0097150719,
-0.0159323048,
0.0033288598,
0.006148125,
-0.0020767311,
0.0322422087,
-0.00318221,
-0.0070432941,
-0.0481156297,
-0.0087717278,
-0.0258099753,
0.001148871,
-0.0199692212,
0.0039230189,
-0.0210694298,
0.0234011393,
-0.0415595099,
-0.0322576687,
0.048352398,
0.0228703152,
-0.0052638324,
-0.0262547527,
0.0250883922,
-0.0245190151,
-0.0151730692,
-0.0187949743,
-0.0247476716,
-0.0912658125,
0.0309761036,
-0.0255466774,
-0.0191226564,
0.0140876072,
-0.0402988084,
-0.0327066891,
0.0508626923,
-0.0253856126,
-0.0095866146,
0.0253869835,
-0.0035325952,
0.0202344339,
-0.0255650822,
-0.0027969847,
0.0208323523,
-0.0322086737,
0.0274436958,
-0.0105285998,
0.1169575676,
0.0142501295,
-0.0380722098,
0.0193687491,
0.0375136919,
-0.0315888859,
-0.0504208095,
-0.0375844389,
0.0452480093,
0.0157203078,
0.0625675917,
-0.0390820056,
-0.0110932682,
-0.0166735407,
-0.0058698682,
0.0581602976,
0.0281554125,
-0.024811849,
0.0666730106,
-0.0006848815,
-0.0057087508,
-0.0175844301,
0.0499973521,
-0.0198925715,
0.0186143853,
0.0226268489,
0.0395166948,
-0.0799408406,
0.0117786229,
0.0189684145,
-0.0100843562,
0.0148212891,
0.0512235463,
-0.0198329277,
-0.0213300344,
-0.0014367651,
0.032115601,
-0.0126883266,
0.0128225097,
0.0460860841,
0.0319388099,
-0.0232664347,
-0.0047083646,
-0.014926686,
0.0230977293,
-0.0556103848,
-0.0412627682,
0.001038217,
-5.743869474e-33,
-0.0246718917,
-0.0524074994,
0.0351513289,
-0.0379105173,
-0.0074008307,
0.0127703855,
-0.035651464,
0.0393730626,
0.001362809,
-0.0215971544,
0.0164066348,
-0.0404662453,
-0.0066833752,
0.0454765633,
-0.00846007,
-0.0265827067,
0.0099594584,
-0.0461418703,
-0.0191085525,
0.042061612,
0.0216553472,
0.0113486992,
-0.0138910972,
-0.0069390978,
0.0160390455,
-0.0352658965,
-0.0513142794,
-0.0028535964,
0.0137236034,
0.0491853282,
-0.0454442427,
-0.0159438271,
0.0192501601,
-0.0014691484,
0.0099740699,
0.0712985545,
-0.0303572845,
-0.0225451123,
-0.0188933741,
-0.0320288241,
-0.0873124897,
-0.0115603581,
-0.0298819486,
-0.0627820417,
0.0183437411,
-0.0249431599,
0.0219440944,
0.0295294281,
0.007461858,
-0.0269276462,
-0.0191257149,
0.0068562571,
-0.0213512219,
-0.0788539946,
-0.0376046002,
0.1246226057,
0.0338074118,
0.0112048676,
0.0085364059,
0.036532376,
0.0221113414,
-0.0035386709,
0.0328351334,
0.0314309224,
-0.0314783864,
0.0278150085,
0.0123172347,
-0.0556818061,
0.0006611781,
-0.0002902127,
-0.0100239906,
0.0582862198,
0.0861693993,
0.0686081499,
0.0163504407,
0.0425596535,
-0.0513183959,
0.0518813431,
-0.0061376989,
-0.0291930232,
-0.0163559671,
-0.0420965888,
0.0177921019,
0.0233046003,
-0.024888169,
0.0088578388,
-0.0488810651,
-0.0139923478,
0.0658852756,
0.0208339747,
-0.0298803039,
-0.0236383099,
0.0711216256,
-0.0014987583,
0.0332561508,
-0.0371041112,
-0.0452014208,
0.0455405451,
-0.0183756575,
0.0212652404,
-0.04805924,
-0.0064303679,
0.0725361034,
0.0258746892,
-0.0234227926,
0.0391061604,
0.0162213705,
-0.0068673631,
-0.0420107991,
0.0043032384,
-0.0059595685,
0.042934604,
0.0016913312,
0.0280339643,
0.0001184806,
0.0000060677,
-0.0515698604,
0.0174520109,
-0.0003016021,
0.0061237677,
-0.0495182574,
-0.0450577661,
-0.004627299,
0.0249462277,
-0.0252296515,
0.0346690305,
-0.0229440592,
-0.01960239,
-0.0026237343,
-0.0413021781,
-0.001436173,
0.050535962,
2.485e-7,
0.0285174828,
0.0182241425,
0.0440192558,
0.0213580672,
-0.0199257117,
0.0406604074,
-0.0056424299,
0.0207056943,
-0.0067264056,
-0.0074661858,
0.0002006031,
0.0100046415,
0.0218685828,
-0.0110597936,
-0.0834653378,
-0.0106855379,
-0.0380933844,
-0.0200660154,
-0.0643178895,
0.0050465581,
0.1053884327,
0.058386825,
-0.0645174012,
-0.0061808894,
0.0245758127,
-0.0656791776,
0.0878557712,
0.0201420002,
-0.0334764272,
0.0126354387,
0.004515958,
-0.0103356428,
-0.0196760278,
-0.0079356218,
-0.0067398651,
-0.0306819528,
0.02720383,
0.0292914826,
0.0226760097,
-0.0354194343,
0.0062529622,
0.0458380617,
-0.0019603742,
-0.0663554221,
0.0786690265,
-0.0507868864,
-0.0035223986,
-0.0220785365,
-0.0143768927,
-0.0184851661,
0.0316328742,
-0.0391573869,
-0.0486683175,
0.0162638929,
0.0543280318,
-0.0211318359,
0.0179341882,
-0.0428057723,
-0.0165613573,
-0.0293992329,
-0.0155427745,
-0.0289456006,
-0.0754324943,
-0.0466444828,
0.0092494115,
-0.0503659919,
-0.0484259725,
1.930076087e-34,
0.0165322497,
-0.0114029851,
0.0080111772,
0.0208433382,
0.0147635881,
-0.0099663446,
0.010301725,
-0.0270751473,
0.0120216645,
-0.095188193,
-0.0207625646
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.03385v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.03385v1 | AI-UPV at EXIST 2023 -- Sexism Characterization Using Large Language Models Under The Learning with Disagreements Regime | 2023-07-07T04:49:26 | 2023-07-07T04:49:26 | Angel Felipe Magnossão de Paula, Giulia Rizzi, Elisabetta Fersini, Damiano Spina | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG | With the increasing influence of social media platforms, it has become
crucial to develop automated systems capable of detecting instances of sexism
and other disrespectful and hateful behaviors to promote a more inclusive and
respectful online environment. Nevertheless, these tasks are considerably
challenging considering different hate categories and the author's intentions,
especially under the learning with disagreements regime. This paper describes
AI-UPV team's participation in the EXIST (sEXism Identification in Social
neTworks) Lab at CLEF 2023. The proposed approach aims at addressing the task
of sexism identification and characterization under the learning with
disagreements paradigm by training directly from the data with disagreements,
without using any aggregated label. Yet, performances considering both soft and
hard evaluations are reported. The proposed system uses large language models
(i.e., mBERT and XLM-RoBERTa) and ensemble strategies for sexism identification
and classification in English and Spanish. In particular, our system is
articulated in three different pipelines. The ensemble approach outperformed
the individual large language models obtaining the best performances both
adopting a soft and a hard label evaluation. This work describes the
participation in all the three EXIST tasks, considering a soft evaluation, it
obtained fourth place in Task 2 at EXIST and first place in Task 3, with the
highest ICM-Soft of -2.32 and a normalized ICM-Soft of 0.79. The source code of
our approaches is publicly available at
https://github.com/AngelFelipeMP/Sexism-LLM-Learning-With-Disagreement. | [
0.0790046081,
0.0791063681,
-0.0137365218,
0.0277215037,
0.0016284301,
0.0358269736,
0.0223349538,
0.0046430421,
-0.0007084912,
-0.0651561692,
0.0034432639,
-0.0376744084,
-0.0052018082,
-0.010660057,
-0.0008406691,
-0.0102779809,
0.0337028168,
0.0652362257,
0.0092708748,
-0.047221031,
0.0384248495,
0.0046899305,
0.0135904877,
0.0265327953,
-0.0183336772,
-0.0030313071,
0.0326840095,
0.0066088066,
0.0210518129,
-0.0138072167,
0.0787331164,
0.0606226735,
-0.0046254201,
0.0799287111,
0.0000020683,
-0.0871712938,
-0.0050661834,
0.0197838396,
-0.0037589625,
-0.0518944934,
0.0297149867,
0.000520738,
-0.0186067317,
0.0528925471,
-0.017065689,
0.0156763326,
0.0451595448,
0.0552721359,
0.0692670345,
0.0473362319,
-0.0073182671,
-0.0161117017,
-0.0230065379,
-0.0036567296,
-0.0243842304,
0.0207519643,
0.058304619,
-0.0567870401,
-0.0404914133,
0.0045076837,
0.0005474892,
0.0048504919,
0.0002776995,
-0.0011033041,
0.0014023489,
-0.000022248,
-0.0638433322,
-0.0628219321,
0.0157481898,
0.0606599599,
-0.0173239075,
-0.0079152966,
0.0179168526,
0.0068858112,
-0.0163049847,
-0.0114470301,
-0.0206190199,
0.0170148816,
-0.042512659,
0.0195191354,
0.0035977741,
0.0013414238,
0.0566528775,
0.0894308314,
-0.005480425,
0.0444671027,
-0.021178849,
-0.0455907993,
0.0433420762,
0.0106564621,
-0.0266062189,
0.0037036946,
0.0264354553,
0.0159932952,
-0.0110022305,
-0.001973842,
-0.0161448177,
-0.0383476242,
0.0295291543,
-0.107929267,
0.0252860226,
0.0360401794,
0.030395424,
0.0012490461,
-0.0038489059,
0.0265985541,
0.0197322387,
0.0099181402,
-0.0035739099,
-0.0332916416,
-0.0475277342,
0.0306535512,
-0.006721159,
0.0093354462,
0.0164130442,
0.0505846329,
-0.0654028952,
-0.0080825752,
-0.0817400217,
-0.0115714865,
0.0260131303,
0.0168732572,
0.0143960109,
0.0249933228,
-0.0039846096,
-0.0107683651,
-0.028556658,
0.0079325717,
-0.0597701184,
-0.0855292752,
0.0184028279,
0.0492183864,
-0.029430341,
-0.0210073832,
0.0494096242,
0.0363023952,
0.0227564927,
-0.0443634763,
-0.0056004599,
-0.0021185004,
-0.0415585451,
-0.0944857895,
0.0310328081,
-0.0767810643,
0.0314879715,
-0.001729947,
-0.0064332606,
-0.0394763798,
0.0063022515,
0.0198420417,
-0.0223980602,
0.0667636693,
0.0142995343,
-0.0003138072,
0.0800680444,
0.0405242331,
-0.0300461352,
0.072382167,
0.0133056268,
0.0167319141,
0.0388285182,
0.0296166819,
0.0184327811,
0.043575678,
0.0430722684,
0.0560507998,
-0.0471806414,
0.0352241173,
-0.0392086543,
-0.0004947631,
-0.0044485512,
0.0276799276,
0.0216746498,
-0.0729380623,
0.0299191382,
0.0231384281,
0.0127483243,
0.0436436012,
0.0527810454,
0.0000689858,
0.0018601115,
-0.0321545303,
-0.0598865449,
-0.018915331,
-0.0554110296,
-0.0577423312,
0.0179467257,
0.0295092501,
-0.0301867183,
-0.060174752,
-0.0362877883,
-0.0093083,
0.015866274,
-0.014246312,
0.045266252,
-0.0020109708,
-0.0039842497,
0.0056585246,
0.0490746461,
-0.0231799744,
-0.0059307436,
-0.0782975629,
0.062202204,
0.0385744683,
0.0196125507,
-0.0390796401,
0.0086345449,
-0.0704426989,
-0.0107065821,
0.0236805398,
0.0374989435,
-0.0053088563,
-0.0037792469,
-0.0246790256,
-0.0154100582,
0.0596919395,
0.0128207766,
-0.0042503714,
0.0749983191,
0.0463967733,
-0.0078884196,
0.0283260364,
-0.0832460746,
0.033268176,
0.0340374559,
-0.0057020248,
0.0414320678,
0.0283994116,
0.0646649897,
0.0148877325,
-0.0437655151,
-0.0547439829,
0.0070282086,
-0.0031073198,
-0.0657356083,
-0.0262945071,
-0.0129855135,
-0.0274777897,
0.0531223752,
-0.0373655111,
-0.0618097819,
0.0224023368,
-0.0104249734,
0.02327477,
0.0525133349,
-0.0314094834,
-0.0506612621,
-0.0303528812,
0.0035301202,
-0.0565669835,
0.0508915558,
-0.0264224298,
0.0679685473,
-0.0562788807,
-0.0222210325,
0.0129112639,
-0.0554563999,
0.0127073471,
-0.0246008579,
-0.0714147091,
0.0135844182,
-0.0012810318,
0.0212869532,
0.0045853434,
0.0098697552,
-0.0100328224,
-0.0181465726,
-0.0832533464,
-0.0019531072,
-0.0083235931,
-0.0320048518,
-0.0188077036,
-0.0045175878,
-0.0155470446,
0.0438028984,
0.0054881107,
-0.0036367578,
0.049360089,
0.0043282672,
0.0217720028,
-0.0533320233,
-0.0211207997,
-0.0338801853,
-0.0063940403,
-0.0228247158,
0.0516793728,
0.0303758495,
-0.0659006014,
0.00832312,
0.0073181437,
-0.0421391502,
0.0205095727,
-0.0144668771,
-0.0493647605,
0.0109503083,
0.023374889,
0.0002661312,
0.0476882495,
0.065680787,
0.0983958095,
0.0327003822,
0.0159297027,
-0.0333868936,
0.0002078333,
-0.0054441295,
0.0250486098,
-0.0039208448,
-0.039828971,
-0.0197296143,
0.046573896,
-0.0046418761,
-0.020505555,
-0.0397015475,
0.0554267652,
-0.0334253162,
-0.0522379763,
-0.0282440111,
-0.0345756374,
0.014494257,
-0.0462657958,
-0.0215637963,
-0.072409071,
0.063650839,
-0.0144256596,
0.0113212988,
-0.0317585915,
-0.0654155165,
-0.0195738468,
0.0293754246,
-0.0126760742,
0.0415042266,
-0.0181227531,
0.0071628946,
-0.0147324689,
-0.0608585216,
0.0020551085,
-0.0342708603,
0.0138579579,
-0.0258505736,
0.0379030704,
0.0257291626,
-0.0326205827,
-0.0673823357,
-0.0329423659,
-0.0250633676,
-0.0135555379,
-0.02680365,
-0.0010441089,
-0.0386905745,
0.0208886135,
-0.0300360881,
-0.0299139395,
-0.0120461313,
-0.0119143268,
0.0284991059,
-0.0362757407,
0.006674774,
-0.0063582943,
0.032099586,
-0.0398024395,
-0.0141230421,
0.0455665439,
-0.048557464,
0.0169556011,
-0.0141425682,
0.0101558762,
0.0306111667,
-0.0238802657,
0.0156970005,
-0.0470045283,
0.006788468,
-0.0155168111,
-0.0049766772,
0.0963928103,
0.0225047898,
-0.0619761199,
-0.0029471931,
0.008493837,
-0.0173463542,
0.0296516772,
-0.0019782765,
-0.0565832444,
0.0047233831,
-0.0116209993,
0.0203221273,
-0.0761130974,
-0.0557971708,
-0.0142554278,
-0.0959106237,
0.0226457529,
0.0156943761,
-0.0348640606,
-0.0331195444,
0.0063324585,
0.0087283449,
-0.0259683877,
0.0415565856,
-0.0434591807,
0.0343735516,
0.0137038361,
0.0097035896,
-0.0330267325,
-0.0453178473,
0.029644521,
-0.07128039,
0.0493064597,
0.0124817109,
0.0732947886,
-0.0379611515,
-0.0063854484,
0.0409552604,
-0.0219460167,
-0.0111838924,
-0.0702677965,
0.0288547352,
-0.0218457486,
-0.0252548493,
-0.0485267118,
0.0208525695,
0.0121740866,
0.0144078964,
0.0156386569,
0.0396048464,
-0.0031665934,
-0.0381901786,
-0.0677960813,
-0.0102850925,
0.0146059711,
0.0586967953,
0.0036229235,
-0.0264411233,
-0.0029983905,
-0.0373161323,
-0.0146479486,
0.0303219818,
-0.0239625797,
-0.0233481973,
-0.0097152069,
-0.0107491231,
-0.0169817954,
-0.0284294467,
0.0300350599,
0.020075161,
-0.0124765085,
-0.0414618142,
-0.0065525277,
0.0237008836,
-0.0776589736,
-0.0233127866,
0.003062356,
0.062348403,
0.0088525126,
-0.022629777,
0.0001988274,
0.0055798478,
-0.0259601753,
0.0084592514,
-0.0136945937,
-0.053303007,
0.027422756,
0.0589453019,
0.0224232581,
0.0380392261,
-0.0183667783,
-0.0519223884,
0.0631180704,
0.0798950493,
0.0220525078,
0.0271594543,
0.0463065393,
-0.0072103301,
0.0075279246,
0.0399197564,
-0.0053403154,
0.0373615734,
0.0267994851,
-0.0465256162,
-0.0402826332,
0.0056259781,
-0.0242791418,
-0.008560583,
-0.0100600813,
-0.0017125148,
-0.0713661388,
-0.0284546316,
-0.026869474,
0.0277661234,
-0.0605797507,
-0.0076430752,
-0.0114254951,
-0.0022858591,
0.0101050017,
-0.0433912501,
-0.0035622469,
-0.0216774028,
0.0154674742,
-0.00895877,
0.0382795893,
0.033117868,
0.0489183739,
0.0150014609,
0.014832858,
-0.0060754423,
0.0095824273,
0.0165152103,
-0.0060232864,
0.0152148921,
0.0089661656,
0.0045492803,
0.0133699151,
-0.0241287369,
-0.0031030395,
0.0339808799,
0.0088584321,
-0.0477014743,
0.0255442411,
0.0238589719,
-0.0122168865,
0.0259873942,
0.032516133,
-0.03071188,
-0.0409059674,
0.0056042098,
-0.0461839437,
-0.0138797993,
0.0315256342,
0.0300201308,
-0.0195772033,
0.0093537532,
0.0184859615,
0.0035140205,
0.0302652325,
0.0020798126,
-0.0601679869,
-0.0102190049,
0.0067047244,
0.0345607251,
-0.0020628145,
0.0065068654,
0.0344396345,
-0.0390397683,
-0.0317805484,
0.0000145092,
-0.0599623881,
0.041131489,
0.026381582,
-0.0097482642,
0.0816327557,
-0.0056557585,
0.002996006,
-0.0364814028,
-0.0243307427,
0.0015120476,
-0.0502002053,
-0.0019966795,
-6.091390787e-33,
-0.0197675303,
-0.0654853359,
-0.0239160098,
-0.0314684249,
-0.0274420772,
-0.0048257695,
0.0117793782,
-0.0215827096,
0.0033884381,
0.0317358561,
0.026861446,
0.0525676012,
0.0068452964,
-0.0140408222,
-0.0191480666,
-0.0190674644,
0.0479176864,
-0.0031587854,
-0.0104709575,
-0.0158245787,
0.0074192635,
0.0199486986,
0.0254779309,
-0.0909203142,
0.0716164783,
-0.0117817689,
-0.0235726722,
0.0180060901,
-0.0194666032,
0.0714862645,
-0.0041599185,
0.0859472379,
0.0296890233,
-0.0056130025,
0.0448290035,
0.0335105099,
-0.0530086383,
-0.0185273904,
-0.0232890956,
0.0339542925,
0.0499805845,
0.001363766,
0.0459341407,
0.0353569202,
-0.0622563474,
-0.0255738348,
0.0627119541,
-0.003974956,
0.0678943247,
-0.0198773798,
-0.0460425355,
0.0267819632,
-0.025416119,
0.0054752505,
0.0047460059,
0.0029799771,
0.020046873,
0.0124296574,
-0.1030273512,
0.0208602566,
-0.0141307944,
-0.0507299602,
0.0077511668,
-0.002293593,
0.0189145654,
0.0496550314,
0.0372777842,
0.0394461378,
-0.0210581142,
-0.0186918862,
0.0248180795,
0.0470244773,
0.0526172668,
0.0383591577,
-0.0003222594,
-0.0446679071,
-0.0871496871,
-0.0148180937,
0.086891517,
-0.0230017453,
0.0186692085,
-0.0304979701,
-0.0714868978,
-0.0574532822,
0.0157531481,
-0.0923418179,
-0.0359486751,
-0.0130482139,
0.0173056908,
-0.0020478265,
-0.0713177249,
-0.0103771221,
-0.0058843987,
-0.0822122619,
-0.0608795173,
0.0265877564,
-0.0063612908,
-0.0229658857,
0.0618928783,
0.0098737692,
-0.0320029594,
-0.0063708406,
-0.0083170095,
-0.0038069657,
0.0210962836,
0.0058405702,
0.03765231,
0.0401424319,
-0.058632087,
0.0119353281,
-0.0114655579,
0.0269656014,
-0.027119169,
0.069031395,
-0.0234347396,
0.0433913246,
-0.0083815726,
0.0295353811,
0.0383629277,
0.029555643,
-0.0014219111,
-0.0070487102,
-0.0023202815,
0.0189567674,
0.0038408104,
-0.0202406049,
0.0093449159,
0.0016676332,
0.0266604982,
-0.0586271435,
0.0102647077,
-0.0621853657,
2.726e-7,
-0.0095535396,
0.039844919,
-0.0031241658,
-0.017648574,
0.0170989055,
0.0456038751,
0.0148426937,
0.0258644111,
0.0155041907,
0.0056268587,
-0.0050871125,
0.0681551024,
-0.0126510924,
0.05158972,
-0.0132179568,
-0.0027250221,
-0.0660775006,
-0.0066075898,
-0.0272646639,
0.0317660049,
0.0206361301,
0.0794140697,
0.0955615044,
-0.0500918999,
-0.0341217145,
-0.0093585588,
0.0250900704,
0.00584673,
0.0011796276,
0.019719176,
0.0512882732,
-0.0000596533,
0.0271585416,
0.0141676189,
0.0118018091,
0.0310100019,
0.0249485839,
0.015129461,
-0.0070983008,
0.0513742715,
0.0268622376,
0.0018024652,
0.0095933499,
-0.0568948127,
0.0634215102,
-0.019898029,
-0.0467194133,
-0.0795060396,
-0.0171933863,
-0.0348908454,
0.0905636027,
-0.0147728901,
0.0012646514,
0.0218049232,
0.0149722518,
-0.008741268,
-0.0225805361,
-0.0899179205,
0.0238447692,
-0.0192065202,
-0.0262479763,
-0.0593079999,
0.0109700551,
0.0195101816,
0.0491460003,
0.0214688163,
0.0528542697,
2.339518678e-34,
0.0228286255,
0.0131461127,
-0.0132830385,
-0.0054327757,
0.0307219848,
0.0305078384,
-0.0139506804,
-0.0009255322,
0.042485334,
0.0075724442,
0.0175963957
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.03378v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.03378v1 | A Side-by-side Comparison of Transformers for English Implicit Discourse Relation Classification | 2023-07-07T04:12:25 | 2023-07-07T04:12:25 | Bruce W. Lee, BongSeok Yang, Jason Hyung-Jong Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL | Though discourse parsing can help multiple NLP fields, there has been no wide
language model search done on implicit discourse relation classification. This
hinders researchers from fully utilizing public-available models in discourse
analysis. This work is a straightforward, fine-tuned discourse performance
comparison of seven pre-trained language models. We use PDTB-3, a popular
discourse relation annotated dataset. Through our model search, we raise SOTA
to 0.671 ACC and obtain novel observations. Some are contrary to what has been
reported before (Shi and Demberg, 2019b), that sentence-level pre-training
objectives (NSP, SBO, SOP) generally fail to produce the best performing model
for implicit discourse relation classification. Counterintuitively,
similar-sized PLMs with MLM and full attention led to better performance. | [
0.0532909036,
0.0358528309,
0.0108655849,
0.0319386087,
0.0003393635,
0.0029975313,
0.0303890668,
0.0007823475,
-0.0047364659,
-0.1026667878,
-0.0793048888,
0.0258350763,
-0.0008507801,
-0.0007388626,
-0.0208750255,
-0.0196829773,
0.0347785838,
-0.0026412401,
0.0293271299,
-0.0145435184,
0.0025554837,
0.0032389783,
-0.0121433735,
0.015693292,
-0.0186493471,
-0.038446907,
0.0131418575,
-0.0134797972,
0.0049877064,
-0.0476861112,
0.0807344541,
0.0904817581,
0.0014176567,
0.0150805535,
0.0000018673,
-0.0415586047,
0.0072084488,
-0.0124622583,
-0.0167892762,
0.0470141992,
-0.0008586974,
0.0070235017,
0.0408675596,
0.0267485548,
-0.0416865908,
-0.0317029208,
0.0132930055,
0.1328707784,
0.0734429359,
0.0590733401,
-0.0202890504,
-0.0297893099,
0.0084078917,
-0.0061961985,
-0.071453616,
-0.0465587974,
0.0256643463,
-0.0025389574,
-0.0669320449,
0.0669766441,
0.0268525481,
0.0244462695,
-0.0096876072,
-0.0259866938,
0.0080487104,
0.0472239889,
-0.0328742899,
-0.0269654412,
-0.0148560731,
0.0353407376,
0.0846803859,
-0.0281619597,
0.001607131,
0.0037539531,
-0.0238982048,
0.010190757,
0.0175837949,
0.00713492,
-0.0022584759,
0.0324585773,
0.0384318829,
0.0259324852,
0.0038246503,
0.0266281795,
0.0394262671,
0.05002518,
-0.0157223046,
-0.0117980335,
0.0248144008,
0.0243806485,
-0.0491877273,
-0.0595083609,
0.0201720521,
0.0007724031,
-0.0102026751,
-0.0036130666,
-0.0180145502,
-0.0288893245,
0.0299825761,
-0.1034433171,
0.0826750621,
0.0123365754,
-0.0175518077,
0.0082995733,
-0.023948418,
0.0407185778,
-0.0331903622,
-0.0290295277,
0.0103915511,
-0.0016240531,
-0.019739842,
-0.0496241935,
-0.0401208475,
0.0621823892,
-0.0740070269,
-0.0019215766,
-0.0418403596,
-0.0129917311,
0.0010373776,
-0.0358477905,
0.0443376154,
0.0247171149,
-0.0331232734,
0.0427771136,
-0.0544169135,
-0.0037003737,
-0.0159714743,
0.0426529087,
-0.0612334907,
-0.0395693518,
-0.0073740901,
-0.0088816741,
-0.0043422952,
-0.0125146322,
-0.0162907988,
0.058660347,
-0.0227355249,
-0.032467965,
0.0065385723,
0.0027393869,
-0.0026387854,
-0.0229330342,
0.0050182687,
-0.0252864733,
-0.0228673294,
0.0011479218,
0.0120638432,
-0.0273713339,
0.050066404,
0.0220420845,
-0.0166895799,
0.0408512019,
0.0351120718,
0.0003504567,
0.0486667491,
-0.0091812508,
0.0299607962,
0.0569907278,
0.0271881111,
-0.0319257975,
0.0219943672,
0.0167136341,
-0.0248461701,
0.0014627444,
0.0272171721,
-0.0176531803,
0.0402629226,
0.0458848104,
-0.0427100286,
0.0045480616,
0.0242107008,
0.0412508547,
-0.0092129819,
-0.0464877114,
0.0136581967,
0.0417456776,
-0.0420098491,
0.0498911552,
0.0464402847,
0.0319104157,
0.0248719789,
-0.0024046414,
-0.0134427929,
-0.0311680995,
-0.0230428465,
-0.0464657545,
-0.0012623747,
-0.0117279477,
-0.0173465833,
-0.0437441953,
0.0049049291,
-0.0078525208,
0.0129086617,
-0.0259143878,
0.0306988042,
0.0256114993,
-0.0536844432,
0.0986387879,
0.0443895347,
-0.0326176062,
-0.0737622455,
-0.0345620327,
0.0051007261,
-0.0489202403,
-0.009287159,
-0.0434647053,
-0.0163906794,
-0.0271062404,
0.0475915372,
0.0759954974,
0.040597342,
-0.0055689295,
0.022368582,
-0.0049673165,
0.0003261089,
-0.0435210317,
0.0350331105,
0.033122208,
0.0295356549,
-0.0275549032,
0.0056802989,
0.0316324309,
-0.029644113,
0.0252692364,
-0.0681741312,
-0.0121584022,
0.0323578827,
-0.0054076351,
0.0512141325,
0.027720442,
-0.0067080092,
-0.0071373819,
0.025617823,
-0.0405275337,
-0.0199211575,
-0.0015279192,
-0.0555277057,
-0.01460821,
0.0345424078,
-0.0339649506,
-0.0322322287,
0.0204386525,
-0.0271929819,
-0.0057751383,
0.0257981047,
-0.0347834229,
0.0371729545,
-0.0420288965,
-0.007722103,
-0.0165100452,
0.0039788317,
-0.016196005,
0.0500970371,
-0.0044929362,
0.023110874,
0.0316973105,
-0.0545450039,
0.0635787845,
0.0112178354,
0.0057545747,
-0.0284760315,
-0.0029567876,
-0.0054724109,
0.0476100892,
0.010840157,
-0.0184925646,
-0.0288657248,
-0.1546372771,
0.0010132416,
-0.0026413014,
0.0332463458,
0.0159026962,
-0.0326500647,
0.0049160942,
-0.0080200918,
0.0127581526,
-0.0311083365,
-0.027172856,
-0.0096438965,
0.0766807497,
-0.015415051,
0.0373176895,
-0.0278832689,
0.011777916,
-0.0475134663,
0.0702484697,
0.0047698226,
0.0006721627,
-0.0223668925,
0.0417471789,
-0.0312502421,
0.0262588877,
-0.0118471598,
-0.0772664174,
0.0234838594,
0.0420671143,
0.0687654167,
0.0328139886,
0.0355594084,
0.0530355945,
-0.0077544977,
-0.0266023837,
-0.0559822097,
0.0436900444,
0.0003632555,
-0.0050668656,
-0.0516021848,
0.0063855792,
-0.0281803161,
0.102773197,
0.0000581268,
-0.0142161809,
-0.0336374715,
0.0293638986,
-0.0128418384,
-0.0234539099,
0.0191986635,
-0.032106813,
-0.0134278433,
0.013916648,
-0.0299122594,
-0.001335701,
0.025911266,
-0.0453525335,
0.0130622666,
-0.0384703428,
-0.0184255317,
-0.0356532037,
0.0779834986,
0.0049599484,
-0.0234296098,
0.0351882353,
-0.0425104201,
0.0021161728,
-0.0276498683,
0.0397558287,
-0.0145196933,
0.0734335557,
-0.0087203979,
0.0307003465,
-0.0269372873,
-0.0744781494,
-0.0645943359,
-0.0996491164,
-0.0239010658,
0.0088591874,
-0.0529104732,
-0.0155917834,
-0.0025379888,
0.0067545297,
-0.0210176762,
0.0213704482,
-0.0226276796,
-0.0063173962,
-0.019855829,
0.0359333791,
0.0029669916,
0.017588513,
0.008126922,
-0.0022332368,
0.0109056495,
0.0206625909,
-0.0595975295,
0.0030939702,
-0.0557106063,
0.0012171607,
-0.0190042872,
-0.051959116,
-0.0514340401,
-0.0348517559,
0.0599511862,
-0.023132557,
-0.0190941785,
0.1354927868,
0.0084662409,
-0.0099515524,
-0.0096463347,
-0.0143535705,
-0.0118875578,
0.0495252311,
0.0011122477,
-0.0303643588,
-0.0172414929,
-0.0075970665,
-0.0084838001,
-0.0436686091,
-0.0581117794,
0.0035980421,
-0.0735704228,
-0.0217399336,
-0.044168517,
0.0353822745,
0.0196237508,
-0.0603754036,
0.0247700829,
0.0004612958,
0.023054691,
-0.0543115586,
-0.0240955204,
0.0017347573,
0.0212292131,
-0.0086980984,
-0.0098360619,
0.0372796953,
0.0069868853,
0.0176479612,
-0.0211935118,
0.0784856081,
-0.0347518586,
0.0296051409,
0.0948851332,
-0.0430735089,
-0.0273923688,
-0.0262314845,
0.0522091649,
0.0020941568,
-0.0038179955,
-0.0223672297,
0.0141040012,
-0.030933613,
-0.0019666194,
-0.0075492519,
0.0154542467,
-0.0264262185,
-0.0076662037,
0.0021091467,
0.0329477526,
-0.0109573463,
0.0526512228,
0.0270324312,
-0.0031916313,
-0.0322894901,
-0.0384415463,
0.0339465588,
0.004271158,
-0.0291289017,
-0.0146839311,
0.0487678759,
-0.0046961294,
-0.026539756,
-0.0643078387,
-0.0161916669,
-0.0098130945,
0.0109252343,
-0.0025920158,
0.0335400812,
0.0037771191,
-0.0410483666,
0.0321979858,
0.0017804073,
-0.0212459508,
-0.0192507319,
-0.0296148397,
0.0805335939,
0.0129427789,
-0.0490171611,
-0.0241877846,
-0.0478695333,
-0.0452962369,
0.0089141177,
0.0294352062,
0.0064468761,
0.0399419852,
-0.002539447,
-0.0033201789,
0.0561792701,
0.0701708421,
-0.0466536619,
0.0217698365,
0.073378928,
0.0188468434,
-0.0011261944,
0.0306103192,
0.010975061,
0.044861827,
-0.0074698897,
0.0089142956,
-0.0017535808,
-0.0296848677,
-0.007761321,
0.0096387221,
0.0750354603,
0.0192169994,
-0.0085308319,
-0.0475284047,
0.0097469576,
-0.0548722781,
-0.0331975594,
-0.0364236906,
-0.0035314346,
-0.0094114142,
-0.0150233516,
-0.053454794,
-0.0303795598,
-0.0467881374,
0.0822654814,
-0.0267886296,
0.0397758894,
0.05928877,
0.0156885404,
-0.0351337343,
-0.0216422379,
-0.0314731747,
0.0080045993,
0.0103537589,
0.0249487963,
-0.0113497125,
0.0409729071,
0.0072811581,
0.0370740481,
0.0015641901,
-0.0010820992,
-0.0480895936,
0.0494986065,
-0.0214731153,
-0.00746998,
0.0405078046,
-0.0527485311,
0.0832439288,
-0.023377765,
0.0074994043,
-0.0038189529,
0.0788559169,
-0.0103901792,
-0.0104930541,
0.0206749141,
-0.0080765467,
-0.0284192301,
0.0357978381,
0.054165218,
-0.0109199677,
0.0446714498,
0.0703193396,
-0.011232187,
-0.0558133684,
-0.0736811757,
-0.0052774372,
-0.0247298162,
0.0219674427,
0.0454985052,
0.0110210357,
0.0015993498,
0.0519799888,
-0.0623897836,
-0.0204755031,
-0.0393192731,
0.0067952406,
0.0477182157,
0.0189910904,
-0.0282527413,
-0.0659150332,
-0.0211037956,
-0.0005744597,
-0.0023593816,
-0.0826036409,
-6.272038188e-33,
-0.087275058,
-0.0305813737,
-0.007469126,
0.0376852304,
-0.0387662239,
0.0703401789,
-0.0729345679,
0.0020006893,
0.0065347301,
0.0587739162,
-0.0163388234,
0.0305704959,
0.0128002288,
0.0215003211,
0.0118962163,
-0.0329817459,
0.0654849187,
-0.0265775844,
-0.0142139811,
0.003724904,
0.0259016808,
0.0293407422,
0.0678981841,
-0.0558033064,
-0.0005069638,
0.0047872979,
0.0033842693,
0.0355586857,
0.0062874183,
0.0548145659,
-0.032366883,
0.0242502894,
0.038169384,
0.0283214729,
0.0261621382,
0.0147604886,
-0.1009519622,
-0.0532554165,
0.0193717796,
0.0062627681,
-0.0071092909,
-0.009054834,
0.0087822201,
0.0162082929,
-0.0148636932,
-0.0350405239,
0.056057211,
0.0032101551,
0.0260053612,
-0.0491545647,
-0.0165487323,
0.0210890863,
-0.0094481073,
0.0055376221,
0.0339692086,
0.0379871689,
0.0295893475,
-0.0289737824,
-0.0322540104,
-0.0164484028,
-0.0081190066,
0.0255016796,
-0.0245729275,
-0.0248907786,
0.0178516712,
0.0458972342,
-0.0397511125,
0.0133928712,
-0.0407446958,
-0.0086442735,
0.015816154,
0.0105776424,
-0.030144399,
-0.0183200799,
-0.0162572749,
0.0137885297,
-0.0774768218,
-0.0216001365,
0.0164592415,
0.0552314445,
0.0470843054,
-0.0562299788,
-0.0084621878,
-0.0234286562,
-0.0575267039,
-0.0412576124,
0.0038381615,
-0.0240659658,
-0.0026564389,
-0.013544783,
0.0012820793,
-0.00076493,
0.0139154373,
-0.0348300599,
-0.0545151904,
0.0266719982,
0.0083679557,
-0.0101613719,
0.0068265544,
0.036902722,
-0.0508429296,
-0.0216731373,
-0.0155649986,
-0.0033203147,
0.0422818512,
-0.0008583517,
-0.0158230364,
-0.005931492,
-0.0641419515,
-0.0177354757,
-0.012517863,
0.0181009341,
-0.0634184182,
0.127069667,
0.0009144561,
0.0483400375,
-0.0020169069,
0.0589278713,
0.0133653311,
0.0145804211,
-0.0391406044,
0.026135724,
0.0133132422,
0.0483228564,
0.0000171237,
-0.0125123393,
-0.0264355894,
0.0216337945,
-0.0286484528,
-0.0463603549,
-0.0126829986,
-0.0014539374,
2.424e-7,
0.0237778202,
0.0667138174,
0.0341429561,
0.0178334247,
0.0120193632,
0.0309270527,
0.0389393531,
0.0358433723,
0.0004089343,
-0.012918422,
-0.0220637433,
0.0234155003,
0.0412875563,
0.0419288874,
-0.0646093115,
-0.0532908812,
-0.1012827903,
-0.0169740096,
-0.025569912,
-0.0051646819,
0.0358564407,
0.0777614191,
0.0124417646,
0.0226454977,
-0.0446404144,
0.0236757658,
0.0598240644,
-0.0240120254,
0.001063697,
0.0603577234,
0.003364021,
0.0127769681,
0.0127572156,
0.0253767017,
-0.0085521117,
0.0494427159,
-0.0069745472,
0.0659257472,
-0.0020783017,
-0.0468063727,
-0.006218229,
0.0123622809,
0.0164415967,
0.0057148584,
0.0161068738,
-0.0639810488,
-0.0411727801,
-0.0049397941,
-0.0328687504,
-0.0074319071,
0.0463013798,
0.0195111632,
-0.0030466355,
0.0375245251,
0.003098642,
-0.0254507363,
-0.0015789449,
-0.0692657903,
-0.0218325686,
-0.000126716,
-0.0336468443,
0.0047471854,
0.0022811173,
-0.0069882651,
-0.0024821591,
-0.0104259457,
0.0405492596,
2.060925369e-34,
0.0284815896,
-0.023900507,
0.0003385482,
0.0237574372,
0.0521734096,
0.0086957663,
0.0378915444,
-0.0048043272,
0.0148082236,
-0.0587718934,
0.0426915623
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.03377v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.03377v1 | Mitigating Negative Transfer with Task Awareness for Sexism, Hate Speech, and Toxic Language Detection | 2023-07-07T04:10:37 | 2023-07-07T04:10:37 | Angel Felipe Magnossão de Paula, Paolo Rosso, Damiano Spina | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | This paper proposes a novelty approach to mitigate the negative transfer
problem. In the field of machine learning, the common strategy is to apply the
Single-Task Learning approach in order to train a supervised model to solve a
specific task. Training a robust model requires a lot of data and a significant
amount of computational resources, making this solution unfeasible in cases
where data are unavailable or expensive to gather. Therefore another solution,
based on the sharing of information between tasks, has been developed:
Multi-Task Learning (MTL). Despite the recent developments regarding MTL, the
problem of negative transfer has still to be solved. Negative transfer is a
phenomenon that occurs when noisy information is shared between tasks,
resulting in a drop in performance. This paper proposes a new approach to
mitigate the negative transfer problem based on the task awareness concept. The
proposed approach results in diminishing the negative transfer together with an
improvement of performance over classic MTL solution. Moreover, the proposed
approach has been implemented in two unified architectures to detect Sexism,
Hate Speech, and Toxic Language in text comments. The proposed architectures
set a new state-of-the-art both in EXIST-2021 and HatEval-2019 benchmarks. | [
0.0592516996,
0.0494025573,
-0.0325976834,
0.04145623,
-0.0056168977,
0.0411786698,
0.0137656676,
0.0050383518,
-0.006018294,
-0.0590341687,
-0.0436054505,
-0.0396793522,
-0.0389457829,
0.028767718,
-0.0098247984,
-0.0314844362,
0.0357667468,
0.0480536446,
0.0274835788,
-0.0017010047,
0.0557368323,
-0.004077917,
0.0229625124,
0.0010217612,
-0.0146512259,
-0.0151254749,
0.0221328717,
0.0131585607,
0.0520304665,
0.0295876265,
0.0504485629,
0.0084392922,
-0.0082247499,
0.0247764699,
0.0000020936,
-0.0441730693,
-0.0173430983,
-0.0110279145,
0.0085648866,
-0.0834930539,
0.0913067684,
-0.0201012716,
-0.0201738346,
0.0368184857,
-0.0207137745,
0.041135028,
0.0586533882,
0.0960263759,
0.0831835046,
0.0453851856,
-0.0244583581,
0.0215389058,
-0.0048851976,
0.0163530856,
-0.0145851513,
-0.0213034488,
0.0706090555,
-0.0353682898,
-0.0408561677,
-0.0002596844,
-0.0355495624,
0.0161445159,
-0.0117269903,
0.0101216594,
0.021314241,
-0.0090914536,
-0.0051250015,
-0.0292371642,
-0.0255389009,
0.0532074459,
-0.0594021194,
0.0178490188,
0.0131558804,
-0.0091158738,
-0.0073926151,
-0.0272100773,
-0.0247870144,
-0.0001749779,
-0.032324452,
0.0006583163,
-0.0396650061,
-0.0131800305,
0.0524599403,
0.0651407987,
0.033227127,
0.0350953639,
-0.0292829983,
-0.0444801897,
0.0335721634,
0.0091896793,
0.0046978476,
0.0018469213,
0.0349322073,
0.0034232952,
-0.0040513068,
0.0140344454,
-0.0596295446,
-0.1047841534,
-0.0190804098,
-0.1134679317,
0.0130944476,
0.0302135181,
-0.035853073,
0.0129185701,
-0.0117484527,
0.02166331,
-0.0164203104,
-0.0131238922,
-0.0274335481,
-0.0253214706,
-0.0318739377,
0.0248200633,
-0.0284375288,
0.0399093777,
-0.0144710597,
0.0396287031,
-0.0129381614,
0.0176033843,
-0.0945020318,
-0.0551227704,
-0.0206721742,
0.0048468555,
-0.0175498407,
0.0213415958,
0.0051204218,
0.0058183437,
-0.0221955329,
0.0145183876,
-0.0597445481,
-0.0518258624,
-0.0146071631,
0.0358279645,
0.0024060998,
-0.013736777,
0.0247607958,
0.0782037228,
0.0010825271,
-0.0196783617,
-0.0607930012,
0.0086851632,
-0.0099025117,
-0.0643692464,
0.0253285039,
-0.0483035594,
0.0055777188,
-0.0032089555,
-0.021255184,
-0.0313836746,
-0.0006610248,
0.0236912612,
-0.0527294725,
0.0847341418,
0.0118414965,
-0.0413156226,
0.0593860745,
0.0523671471,
-0.0604162998,
0.0930963457,
0.0173451602,
0.0180705413,
0.0323693119,
0.0180284735,
-0.0350294746,
0.0139422622,
0.0553967468,
0.0441534221,
-0.0136311855,
0.0049191215,
-0.0498897694,
-0.0359837003,
0.0179012157,
0.0319083333,
0.0150341783,
-0.0281545557,
0.0624414049,
0.0288066864,
-0.0415574014,
0.0302623436,
0.0133412033,
0.0177092757,
-0.0538168624,
-0.0129456725,
-0.0522915758,
0.0043235221,
-0.0265606754,
-0.0693040416,
-0.0112209218,
0.0227934085,
-0.0392625518,
-0.0304509476,
-0.0071913446,
-0.0550188459,
0.0389456637,
-0.0371131115,
0.0544666797,
0.0004484545,
-0.0259155668,
0.008425191,
0.0675196797,
-0.016267743,
0.0002217791,
-0.0681497529,
0.0394709669,
0.0409094691,
-0.0217313357,
-0.0493928306,
-0.0403831154,
-0.0918806717,
0.0147493612,
0.0102588404,
0.0143487593,
0.0154218059,
0.0303963386,
-0.0218207315,
-0.034740001,
0.0607843213,
-0.000679534,
0.0103636095,
0.0379840583,
0.0435694978,
0.006395685,
0.0440891162,
-0.0343711451,
0.0269857813,
0.0104334913,
0.0112099545,
0.0267772079,
0.0105222333,
0.0627060905,
-0.0065138247,
-0.0225845445,
-0.0508849733,
0.0063926447,
-0.0273047853,
-0.0674155056,
0.0187784992,
-0.060024254,
0.0137177529,
0.0008444162,
-0.0430233777,
-0.0125507405,
0.0983199477,
0.0075709876,
0.0088492725,
0.0563876815,
-0.0261610616,
-0.0119435228,
-0.0021992882,
-0.0269767027,
-0.0337873101,
0.0531755462,
-0.0075778472,
0.0581616014,
-0.0200701635,
-0.0506783538,
0.0083162477,
-0.0487092882,
0.0041246754,
-0.0061390465,
-0.0625326484,
-0.0433716401,
0.0067431759,
0.0040720389,
0.009612103,
0.0224722922,
-0.0257564597,
0.0158958696,
-0.0688561574,
0.0003944552,
-0.034236636,
-0.0159912873,
0.0181249566,
-0.0053722626,
0.0108209206,
-0.0036063613,
-0.0124487961,
0.0188176744,
0.0179340988,
0.0137571618,
0.0293110292,
-0.0447815172,
0.0197031759,
-0.0096881008,
-0.0002104204,
0.0030251672,
-0.026277367,
0.0205060374,
-0.103132911,
-0.0163697582,
0.0077990042,
0.0156775601,
0.0361826457,
-0.0000570338,
-0.0195368715,
-0.0228917506,
0.0275692791,
0.0008474475,
0.0880994201,
0.0276424084,
0.0581160411,
0.0067905439,
0.0122426422,
-0.0056664408,
0.027049195,
0.0141441589,
0.0760439038,
0.0029831813,
-0.0030050748,
-0.0095098801,
0.0560910292,
0.0059662089,
-0.0270716585,
-0.0555852689,
0.0187881496,
-0.0461565517,
-0.0648175403,
-0.0083647352,
-0.0606904924,
-0.0171398632,
-0.0571289137,
-0.0573285557,
-0.0555533394,
0.0291153751,
0.0223377775,
0.0053523588,
-0.0424234234,
-0.0276262015,
0.0059310514,
0.0499630794,
-0.0103059569,
0.0515972003,
-0.0179786868,
-0.0077335811,
-0.0146275358,
-0.0303986594,
0.0254042353,
-0.0103404028,
-0.0114178322,
-0.0344597697,
0.0156905334,
-0.0048331199,
-0.0672437921,
-0.071557723,
-0.0155554218,
-0.0108598722,
-0.0144066876,
0.0005898002,
-0.0235183984,
-0.0243969075,
0.0238742307,
-0.0041530472,
-0.0010394198,
-0.0099042542,
-0.0203188118,
0.0168377347,
-0.0332904831,
0.0435833484,
-0.0060574831,
0.028133817,
-0.0121658416,
-0.0238536689,
0.0903436393,
0.0148590766,
-0.0054954118,
0.0117616644,
0.0084761651,
0.0351101607,
-0.0157009177,
-0.0139789982,
-0.035989631,
0.0179745834,
-0.0112692183,
-0.0145144891,
0.0761814788,
0.0005302522,
-0.0446139164,
0.0000291518,
-0.011352323,
-0.0461056158,
0.004680098,
-0.0294373874,
-0.0568792708,
-0.0318581499,
-0.0089835683,
0.0121248532,
-0.0518431477,
-0.0593957901,
-0.0181564186,
-0.0680006444,
-0.013163982,
-0.0102104293,
-0.0249565188,
-0.052698873,
0.0156561062,
0.0383893214,
-0.0165641271,
0.0171606448,
-0.0321246758,
0.0189579558,
-0.0314437896,
0.01860765,
-0.0340095498,
-0.0025418813,
0.0026732674,
-0.0690537021,
0.0426924378,
0.0454892106,
0.061099302,
-0.0502015948,
-0.0050400943,
0.026227491,
0.0406543985,
0.0002792712,
-0.0493271835,
0.0582394898,
-0.0303127915,
-0.0382522754,
-0.0347129628,
0.0348084345,
-0.0033279273,
0.0261600427,
0.0200824495,
0.07844349,
0.0217086282,
-0.0141371386,
-0.0651608631,
-0.0137096522,
0.0407947302,
0.0987138301,
-0.034290012,
-0.0667769387,
0.0007842255,
-0.0011225594,
-0.0291052889,
-0.0199574269,
-0.0187143385,
-0.0152007965,
-0.0430070683,
-0.0225735214,
-0.0467740409,
-0.0208174679,
0.0078249266,
0.0218865424,
0.033641696,
-0.0159614384,
0.0206353236,
0.0058828243,
-0.0782632828,
-0.0351399481,
0.0008425206,
0.0441721529,
0.0070645316,
-0.0017898401,
-0.021181833,
-0.0137443636,
-0.0310582668,
0.0278484244,
-0.0722490773,
-0.0379492417,
0.0330843851,
0.0682189018,
0.0101328529,
0.0415004119,
-0.0345817693,
-0.0419931933,
0.0205846932,
0.0439230576,
-0.0460904129,
0.0054259063,
0.0952987969,
-0.0281828567,
0.008931323,
0.0447285883,
-0.0044385898,
0.0490092933,
0.0594217964,
-0.0573324896,
-0.0304338057,
0.0341606215,
-0.0292652845,
0.0045941379,
0.0445144139,
0.018042855,
-0.0466679446,
-0.0181789789,
0.0005427975,
0.0041189562,
-0.0290511511,
-0.0443467312,
0.0107269455,
0.0144428769,
0.0119594503,
-0.0431512333,
0.026161449,
0.0199767351,
-0.0075421212,
-0.0261564683,
0.0126290442,
0.0311224293,
0.0421659015,
0.0164536834,
0.0416077077,
-0.0209708381,
-0.0254591387,
0.0633376986,
-0.0156632904,
0.0038800295,
0.026094513,
0.0321193598,
0.018399369,
0.0211085957,
-0.0006068529,
-0.0033033795,
0.008112926,
-0.0298403408,
0.0053897281,
0.0102522494,
-0.0086524598,
0.0490486994,
0.015912164,
-0.0233293325,
-0.0233423561,
-0.002258573,
-0.0273238979,
0.0086089764,
0.0185237788,
0.0122805499,
0.0061256615,
-0.0040510474,
0.0359052159,
-0.0159652121,
0.0250925887,
-0.0186031759,
-0.0512815453,
-0.0198862124,
0.0125663327,
0.0432681851,
0.010446771,
0.0226016063,
0.0558337122,
-0.0217801202,
-0.0227266029,
0.0162054449,
-0.0984435454,
0.0496009104,
-0.0024393357,
0.0436595529,
0.0624976829,
-0.0103245461,
-0.0328028351,
-0.0160875842,
-0.0020080693,
0.0303277634,
-0.007256222,
0.0191442277,
-5.924986338e-33,
-0.0135497982,
-0.0127276881,
-0.0204290673,
0.0199728739,
-0.0210901592,
-0.0130729266,
0.0358531959,
-0.006444504,
-0.0008068572,
0.0370098166,
0.0194005165,
0.0435752571,
0.0036971052,
0.0103868805,
-0.0006957265,
-0.0139505528,
0.0516814888,
-0.0037453801,
0.0099229645,
0.0161402747,
0.0491447933,
0.0673675314,
0.051710546,
-0.0755930021,
0.0353679471,
-0.0147835277,
0.0169989225,
0.0092471559,
0.0106350202,
0.0225970615,
-0.0004206071,
0.0751402378,
0.0510600656,
-0.0388907455,
-0.0079661543,
0.0619801655,
-0.072199285,
-0.0507106446,
0.0012253294,
0.0313513018,
0.0022603928,
0.0142576927,
0.0674022511,
0.0363286845,
-0.0221998096,
-0.0198436044,
0.0412847996,
-0.0223889928,
0.0549474992,
-0.0229155067,
-0.0817171186,
0.0238089375,
-0.0051472699,
-0.0003047988,
0.0304517336,
0.0557202958,
0.0018632656,
-0.0358755775,
-0.0715296343,
0.0060071205,
-0.0396878719,
-0.0373090059,
0.007596659,
0.0276833959,
-0.0173905995,
0.0575590283,
0.0178434737,
0.0342613384,
-0.0201904718,
-0.0176456757,
0.0222274363,
0.0379163064,
0.0331979208,
0.0304516722,
-0.0028573035,
-0.0539088994,
-0.0947996601,
-0.0192179643,
0.0679728761,
0.0228208918,
0.0217328966,
-0.0318265893,
-0.0769352019,
-0.0382765606,
0.0166070666,
-0.0307712425,
-0.0121675963,
-0.0262314249,
0.0284119267,
-0.0104810558,
-0.0387630798,
0.018652536,
-0.0068766666,
-0.0647600964,
0.0133659132,
0.02405384,
-0.0160503834,
-0.0451433621,
0.0527571142,
0.0032639171,
-0.0786862224,
-0.0145919751,
-0.0170963965,
-0.0036020195,
0.0156692043,
-0.0117270797,
0.0911560953,
0.03699442,
-0.0677484795,
-0.0195745043,
-0.0291150548,
0.0639186725,
0.0226654299,
0.0990863368,
0.000989566,
0.037575718,
-0.0045339344,
0.0303009711,
0.0546662323,
-0.0106327357,
-0.0420170873,
0.0248080958,
-0.0221041497,
-0.0064778654,
-0.0178969856,
-0.0276396908,
-0.0060888068,
0.0034393964,
0.0130693577,
-0.1180484891,
0.0078279553,
-0.0516296774,
2.739e-7,
-0.0252482779,
0.0256978441,
-0.0029709118,
-0.0251072105,
0.0276073888,
0.0635526329,
-0.0016440004,
0.0654480904,
0.0072889333,
0.0273190178,
-0.0228977203,
0.0606824309,
-0.0206347201,
0.0360349417,
-0.0378042385,
-0.0275065172,
-0.0527871698,
0.0148833217,
0.0045330059,
0.0279679894,
0.0210099686,
0.0546313077,
0.0766449645,
-0.0471125655,
0.00491984,
-0.0132810595,
0.0282105114,
-0.0220716652,
0.0213255398,
-0.0214609411,
0.0329993106,
0.0058325673,
-0.0205297805,
0.0584287941,
-0.000657537,
0.0067105815,
0.0121745886,
0.0646212101,
-0.0113344397,
0.0184991229,
0.0188277848,
0.0028658195,
-0.0018612648,
0.0111407023,
0.0821792483,
-0.0232227892,
-0.0189666022,
-0.0618848167,
-0.0010992835,
0.0031444435,
0.0357245356,
-0.0000406044,
0.0009489977,
-0.0171819609,
0.031788446,
-0.0064282529,
-0.0366525687,
-0.0779235289,
0.0224366728,
-0.0246123392,
-0.0115824314,
-0.0592855997,
-0.0206077602,
-0.0101839164,
0.0413007438,
-0.0208835565,
0.0371758267,
2.043723891e-34,
0.0025763051,
-0.0152816977,
0.0062952791,
-0.0226053856,
-0.0232421029,
0.0248527545,
-0.0595888905,
-0.0125889862,
0.0522217788,
0.0327176265,
-0.0013412596
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.03360v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.03360v1 | Evaluating Biased Attitude Associations of Language Models in an Intersectional Context | 2023-07-07T03:01:56 | 2023-07-07T03:01:56 | Shiva Omrani Sabbaghi, Robert Wolfe, Aylin Caliskan | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Language models are trained on large-scale corpora that embed implicit biases
documented in psychology. Valence associations (pleasantness/unpleasantness) of
social groups determine the biased attitudes towards groups and concepts in
social cognition. Building on this established literature, we quantify how
social groups are valenced in English language models using a sentence template
that provides an intersectional context. We study biases related to age,
education, gender, height, intelligence, literacy, race, religion, sex, sexual
orientation, social class, and weight. We present a concept projection approach
to capture the valence subspace through contextualized word embeddings of
language models. Adapting the projection-based approach to embedding
association tests that quantify bias, we find that language models exhibit the
most biased attitudes against gender identity, social class, and sexual
orientation signals in language. We find that the largest and better-performing
model that we study is also more biased as it effectively captures bias
embedded in sociocultural data. We validate the bias evaluation method by
overperforming on an intrinsic valence evaluation task. The approach enables us
to measure complex intersectional biases as they are known to manifest in the
outputs and applications of language models that perpetuate historical biases.
Moreover, our approach contributes to design justice as it studies the
associations of groups underrepresented in language such as transgender and
homosexual individuals. | [
0.0282693617,
0.1250771135,
-0.028296141,
0.0517314561,
-0.0090554534,
0.0264616832,
0.0431380607,
-0.0341962948,
0.0341334529,
-0.0879760012,
-0.0229881369,
-0.0367889442,
0.0174419172,
-0.0007511083,
0.0159488004,
-0.0253711641,
0.0423725322,
0.0824021474,
0.0433988199,
-0.0420283563,
0.0166336633,
0.0392693095,
0.0294403862,
0.0416978374,
0.0050105592,
-0.0280421395,
0.0579616725,
-0.0135069378,
0.0128558101,
-0.0202064309,
0.0576631427,
0.0695223957,
0.0046452638,
0.0168661978,
0.0000019259,
-0.0677886605,
0.0021969005,
0.0294632558,
0.0213925913,
0.0028119937,
0.0712812468,
-0.0425388031,
-0.0174880438,
0.0162127297,
-0.0298135579,
-0.0078783045,
0.0359876193,
0.038985718,
0.0303769019,
-0.0204904135,
-0.0206359066,
-0.0227777772,
-0.0581608862,
0.0038297146,
0.0232603271,
0.0156938247,
0.0561826862,
-0.026746951,
-0.0694997907,
-0.0248906296,
-0.0175405592,
-0.0225062426,
0.0072647128,
0.0317939296,
0.0524408184,
-0.0122402059,
-0.022898633,
-0.0214644279,
0.0179761741,
0.0334994495,
0.0475579463,
0.0101067983,
-0.0027834105,
0.0050197747,
0.0048266063,
-0.0102196625,
-0.0169179104,
0.0168791413,
-0.0077172779,
0.0014727376,
0.000190457,
0.0027664492,
0.0264362562,
0.0698478594,
-0.0196051039,
0.0906421021,
0.0339995399,
-0.0155526605,
-0.0072148424,
0.0146700367,
-0.0198026747,
-0.0195562076,
0.0145743378,
-0.0319657139,
0.0105558801,
0.0293965191,
-0.0230556335,
-0.014860169,
0.0352653824,
-0.0556384958,
0.0205044076,
0.0548783764,
0.0027093131,
-0.0000842834,
0.0198180974,
0.0489822812,
0.0108873807,
-0.0054951459,
0.0095683606,
-0.0101380674,
-0.0005361621,
-0.0152635137,
0.010370722,
-0.0088891555,
-0.0030278759,
0.0608380102,
-0.0480697192,
-0.0147565221,
-0.0921606496,
0.0015964342,
-0.0372819155,
0.0259558782,
-0.0158211756,
0.0116474451,
-0.0470122918,
-0.0056179604,
-0.0267650783,
0.0321818404,
-0.0805162117,
-0.0532747209,
0.0406152941,
-0.0176134054,
-0.012546353,
-0.0593332611,
-0.0122978073,
0.0329306349,
0.0186348632,
-0.0241872463,
0.0007532213,
-0.0100432318,
-0.0355380177,
-0.0286220573,
-0.0076569882,
-0.0363592096,
0.0213664416,
0.0505215824,
0.0071015386,
-0.0714504346,
0.010380066,
0.0301469658,
-0.0782714561,
0.0921970978,
0.0612423792,
-0.0124056349,
0.0288307201,
0.0173890367,
-0.0002579426,
0.0797237381,
0.0292187706,
-0.0035683669,
0.0358647853,
-0.0002316262,
-0.0362772718,
0.0086695645,
0.0265097413,
0.0155765694,
-0.06483154,
0.0169539806,
0.0102703664,
-0.000812845,
0.0103409328,
0.06136081,
0.0287335329,
-0.0235592183,
0.0345921591,
0.0510343239,
-0.0221796725,
0.0461971611,
0.0056683752,
-0.0070943036,
-0.022075709,
-0.0062582307,
-0.0868283585,
-0.031585563,
-0.0113614714,
-0.0449957773,
0.0070289462,
0.0586548857,
-0.0121522741,
-0.0184551682,
-0.0475862585,
0.0299789365,
0.0697579458,
-0.010393301,
0.0196663272,
0.0047532311,
0.0034282003,
0.0131365499,
0.0688699186,
-0.0441882201,
0.0168335345,
-0.0355484076,
0.010741557,
0.0342854895,
0.0018678142,
-0.0252318773,
0.0121799977,
-0.0239566825,
-0.0531478673,
0.033705771,
0.071188271,
-0.0168551486,
-0.0179717802,
-0.008161691,
-0.0104203327,
0.0477174968,
0.0288040359,
0.01318816,
0.0491632521,
0.039833121,
0.016483862,
-0.0632704496,
-0.0282165445,
0.0370310768,
-0.0142842084,
-0.0128988475,
-0.004540829,
0.0192937758,
0.0461704992,
0.0186099131,
-0.0184334014,
-0.0086685074,
-0.0228940193,
-0.0049104118,
-0.0367891304,
0.0338281244,
-0.052830223,
-0.0032258397,
0.009580004,
-0.0641535819,
-0.0282021891,
0.0236771908,
-0.0033413952,
0.0133900912,
0.0740133524,
-0.0072779208,
0.0595054552,
-0.0219880342,
-0.0152804526,
-0.0600752272,
0.0073452839,
-0.050222408,
0.0452984981,
-0.0113550862,
0.0071784551,
0.0087480955,
-0.0546597019,
0.0270911865,
0.0105181001,
-0.0586116798,
-0.0051624891,
-0.0017134502,
-0.0042588846,
0.0265953001,
-0.0416605584,
-0.0255330559,
-0.0349851698,
-0.1200409755,
-0.0315831937,
0.0065148757,
-0.0185489804,
-0.0245653763,
-0.010345594,
-0.01112507,
0.0087363292,
-0.0136852246,
-0.0131408107,
0.0139289573,
0.0591375493,
-0.0036138436,
-0.0452528298,
0.018829966,
-0.0561027639,
-0.0306703337,
-0.0690804124,
0.0568983518,
0.0309214778,
0.0040746848,
-0.0154486764,
-0.033831533,
-0.072404936,
0.0055628167,
0.0080871787,
-0.0411399119,
0.0315645859,
0.0498224758,
0.0725013167,
0.0280650631,
0.04841315,
0.0495901108,
0.0718681514,
-0.0024608544,
-0.0428188071,
-0.0160304122,
-0.0080480659,
0.0431360938,
0.0112281535,
-0.0799585432,
-0.0538521148,
0.0532870702,
0.0667805523,
-0.0419139415,
-0.0640847087,
0.0706634596,
-0.0751073658,
-0.0458588973,
-0.012257589,
-0.0396349765,
-0.0002251766,
-0.0091217579,
-0.0501019396,
-0.0316944197,
0.039683979,
0.0343879312,
-0.0033214972,
-0.0227388144,
0.0248403139,
-0.0306203198,
0.0413124934,
0.0070659658,
0.0511425212,
0.0317286588,
-0.0022488984,
-0.0502927527,
-0.0397566967,
-0.005979334,
-0.0487648807,
0.0358051397,
-0.0450013541,
0.0122547448,
0.0056957323,
-0.029734768,
-0.0739368424,
-0.0492486916,
-0.0331796966,
-0.0043298686,
-0.0002971187,
-0.0024181842,
0.0208596401,
0.0096085416,
-0.0064420025,
-0.0339915678,
-0.0237878747,
-0.0124960691,
0.0027457923,
-0.0372342132,
0.0199182127,
-0.0117974347,
0.062355455,
0.0153725352,
-0.0287022851,
0.0088606179,
0.0019617828,
0.0430285484,
-0.0103370147,
0.0111153517,
0.0186494328,
-0.0188817792,
0.0111851208,
-0.0321661159,
0.0359952636,
-0.0066883853,
0.0200856589,
0.0947664902,
0.046978537,
-0.0602507293,
0.0235167369,
0.0080387583,
0.0071632247,
0.0503183417,
0.0060932767,
-0.0728256106,
0.029569352,
0.003304464,
-0.0099359965,
-0.0537454486,
-0.0422631949,
-0.0153929237,
-0.0948586091,
-0.0028145898,
0.0040845843,
-0.00901304,
-0.0392401516,
-0.0250698663,
0.0613736734,
0.0009513978,
0.0362591259,
-0.0348333344,
0.0134792943,
0.0303506404,
-0.0141995866,
-0.029261414,
-0.02677387,
0.0367272086,
-0.0223955587,
0.0487939417,
0.0141385673,
0.0913270786,
-0.0206165109,
-0.0058169295,
0.0332278684,
-0.054061193,
-0.031130055,
-0.0296008382,
0.0211964622,
-0.0183944125,
-0.0263407137,
-0.0246952754,
0.0208895225,
0.004765776,
-0.0109018665,
-0.019863857,
0.0275791604,
0.0141368741,
-0.0260158572,
-0.0497602224,
0.006121642,
0.0108581055,
0.1133062094,
0.0044346722,
-0.0331498869,
0.0228807013,
-0.0731165037,
0.0271424465,
0.0580529869,
-0.067106165,
-0.0005378295,
0.0297878273,
-0.0175133944,
-0.0483245403,
-0.0543963499,
0.0163163468,
-0.0095640449,
0.0329556279,
-0.0634701252,
0.0223746467,
-0.0304085296,
-0.0775808915,
0.0207678508,
-0.0037927234,
0.0432127602,
0.0344401672,
-0.0118978079,
-0.0104952175,
-0.0223926287,
-0.0384985916,
-0.0107871303,
0.011416412,
-0.0534551889,
0.0742798969,
0.0019511265,
0.0170071572,
0.0086771846,
-0.0217178538,
-0.0334242545,
0.0462962426,
0.0272262711,
0.0043795849,
0.030664444,
0.020946065,
0.0245758537,
0.016187923,
0.0320949145,
-0.0244001374,
0.0533825532,
0.0356834456,
-0.0208242293,
-0.0191699993,
-0.0498226359,
-0.0033420883,
-0.0142147541,
0.0071975151,
-0.0320040882,
-0.007498343,
-0.0325256102,
-0.0683409274,
-0.0379901975,
-0.068557106,
0.0016320007,
-0.0688966438,
0.0163609106,
0.007307128,
-0.0590252988,
-0.0257403869,
-0.0518916845,
0.0274432935,
-0.0411832854,
0.0195476264,
0.0140317362,
0.0303033087,
-0.0079013668,
0.0186213702,
0.0001116563,
-0.0212171078,
-0.0607699826,
0.0219583493,
-0.0041545555,
0.0405920111,
0.0183476135,
0.0054328698,
-0.0394939519,
-0.0098531665,
-0.0247923918,
0.0267424937,
-0.0084195817,
-0.0286346134,
-0.0104528498,
-0.0393531658,
0.0251252893,
0.0071603213,
-0.0173780452,
-0.0154337352,
0.0052236202,
0.0213878509,
-0.0319178067,
0.0666132346,
0.0046484163,
-0.0031270145,
-0.0052536628,
0.0067791822,
0.0032822934,
0.0487230234,
0.0114814145,
-0.0369333513,
-0.0158557799,
0.0034704737,
0.0514210686,
-0.0061978842,
-0.015625678,
0.0126392087,
-0.1092523858,
-0.0571943298,
0.0129599031,
-0.0106936423,
0.02875112,
-0.0330306254,
0.0026129992,
0.0549134649,
-0.0203747023,
-0.0134360176,
-0.0028423436,
0.008021187,
-0.0425661169,
-0.0176243186,
-0.040814627,
-5.886110903e-33,
-0.0424836986,
-0.0314106718,
-0.0435423739,
-0.0361039266,
-0.0371832289,
-0.0008680706,
-0.0251226462,
0.0027198205,
-0.0337883271,
0.0202284921,
0.0042574555,
0.0311705191,
0.0117610935,
-0.0045625744,
0.0197008159,
0.005093026,
0.06502112,
0.0025306842,
-0.0051724245,
-0.0188745353,
-0.0129258204,
-0.0045988779,
0.0290143881,
-0.0862572119,
0.0794747919,
0.0153069738,
-0.0076841228,
-0.0047743572,
0.0079936143,
0.0160175972,
-0.0539955348,
0.085217841,
0.0321533829,
0.008346647,
0.0388449356,
0.0885887593,
-0.0297016278,
-0.0230631009,
0.0255309474,
0.0132197263,
0.0395907536,
-0.0082513448,
0.0016594735,
0.0135621345,
-0.0478116237,
-0.019040985,
0.0657550469,
-0.0036828988,
0.0616186224,
0.019104749,
-0.0783854648,
-0.0085044922,
-0.0107218008,
0.0300611351,
0.012864273,
-0.0097623896,
0.0396271423,
0.0265853908,
-0.0267154537,
0.0060071773,
-0.0314513966,
-0.0261680875,
0.0095932046,
0.0126059158,
0.0300945453,
0.0690355524,
0.0170631371,
0.0444815941,
-0.0158220623,
-0.0086984532,
0.0779466555,
-0.0463071316,
0.0116207283,
0.0554368198,
0.0228244364,
-0.0207086895,
0.0168381203,
-0.020112887,
0.0680372268,
-0.0127298832,
0.0560627431,
0.0030617325,
-0.0389672257,
-0.0500289612,
-0.0597412623,
-0.1070395932,
-0.0338409171,
-0.018845154,
0.0252966136,
-0.0198059045,
-0.0424156561,
-0.0043927273,
-0.0078139426,
-0.0417739674,
-0.0807957053,
0.0414048247,
-0.0234018005,
-0.0301001836,
0.0345199481,
0.0345156081,
-0.0454238914,
0.0204898678,
0.0021841007,
0.0606409162,
0.0258717593,
0.0044701137,
-0.0233473405,
0.0076638688,
-0.0612006225,
-0.0043287552,
-0.0121323625,
-0.0173940733,
-0.0097747268,
0.0073329899,
0.0286823511,
0.0624919683,
0.0079177869,
0.0001311563,
0.0491797812,
0.0163079593,
-0.045800779,
-0.0147287063,
-0.0260458402,
0.063994877,
-0.0363523141,
-0.0404160209,
0.0079008527,
0.0249949582,
0.0568350926,
-0.0237019043,
-0.0185146574,
-0.0508549586,
2.537e-7,
0.0163279288,
0.065692164,
-0.0123892548,
0.0453988314,
0.0294327494,
0.0343096778,
0.0407545827,
0.0294453539,
0.0538799129,
-0.0028666297,
-0.0484790578,
0.0360289961,
0.0073516383,
0.0442099459,
-0.0207044519,
0.0193742383,
-0.0161534827,
0.0169740822,
-0.026486421,
0.0313170366,
0.0376950391,
0.0697149113,
0.0588856116,
0.0034042464,
-0.0543558337,
0.0153358029,
0.0243486669,
-0.0349920616,
0.0112176873,
0.0091750678,
-0.0151528614,
0.0082553988,
0.0475727394,
0.0176668279,
0.0149002979,
0.0273135547,
0.0130566927,
-0.0059948754,
-0.0256475955,
0.036200732,
-0.041601792,
0.016535176,
-0.0359564833,
-0.0684867501,
0.0642379895,
-0.0286883153,
-0.0173666403,
-0.0560106486,
-0.0292133559,
-0.0077264272,
0.0376143903,
0.0114241401,
-0.0479405858,
0.0124343345,
0.0293179955,
-0.0107257608,
0.0032182676,
-0.0803569555,
-0.0156737585,
-0.001361014,
-0.0202899612,
-0.0313226916,
0.0114007462,
0.0393156782,
0.0015356921,
-0.0251022596,
0.0260142069,
2.188998233e-34,
0.0170970876,
0.0216964558,
0.011837489,
-0.0315339528,
0.0573444031,
0.0081970729,
0.0033794984,
0.0003899068,
0.0469444618,
-0.0361346938,
0.0096171759
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.04642v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.04642v2 | TRAQ: Trustworthy Retrieval Augmented Question Answering via Conformal Prediction | 2023-07-07T02:42:06 | 2024-04-05T20:08:57 | Shuo Li, Sangdon Park, Insup Lee, Osbert Bastani | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | When applied to open-domain question answering, large language models (LLMs)
frequently generate incorrect responses based on made-up facts, which are
called $\textit{hallucinations}$. Retrieval augmented generation (RAG) is a
promising strategy to avoid hallucinations, but it does not provide guarantees
on its correctness. To address this challenge, we propose the Trustworthy
Retrieval Augmented Question Answering, or $\textit{TRAQ}$, which provides the
first end-to-end statistical correctness guarantee for RAG. TRAQ uses conformal
prediction, a statistical technique for constructing prediction sets that are
guaranteed to contain the semantically correct response with high probability.
Additionally, TRAQ leverages Bayesian optimization to minimize the size of the
constructed sets. In an extensive experimental evaluation, we demonstrate that
TRAQ provides the desired correctness guarantee while reducing prediction set
size by 16.2% on average compared to an ablation. The implementation is
available at $\href{https://github.com/shuoli90/TRAQ.git}{TRAQ}$. | [
0.0586431809,
0.0495077074,
-0.0047219759,
0.0149487173,
-0.011884165,
-0.0431305878,
-0.0456101336,
-0.0025685469,
0.0068894434,
-0.016594965,
-0.0166283511,
-0.0643843487,
-0.0142171336,
0.0129758278,
0.0156676844,
-0.0067811413,
0.0542894825,
-0.0258112289,
-0.0125914058,
-0.0367596447,
-0.0008040552,
0.0115031851,
0.0056781312,
0.0269225631,
0.000249135,
-0.0248123258,
0.0139101371,
-0.0032264285,
0.0104049332,
0.0259472094,
0.0413047448,
0.0467869304,
0.0076371408,
0.0584036857,
0.0000020712,
-0.0459175631,
-0.0328774676,
0.0012793578,
0.0043430803,
0.0192837361,
-0.016169237,
0.0354035571,
0.0365250967,
0.0610101894,
-0.0452639386,
-0.0093848798,
0.0412729271,
0.0646396428,
0.0545429736,
0.0666233227,
0.0139077175,
-0.0200659409,
0.0441928841,
-0.0161524825,
0.061893221,
-0.0431923792,
0.0141275823,
-0.009699258,
0.011515242,
0.0275622569,
-0.0064152912,
0.0370402411,
0.0333666317,
0.0234019309,
0.023971105,
0.028838966,
-0.048586946,
-0.0083035612,
-0.0058971071,
0.0387822278,
0.0433068685,
-0.0687353909,
-0.0110830395,
0.0209361259,
-0.0121128811,
0.0497789495,
-0.0393295884,
0.0130941616,
-0.0394492373,
0.006177241,
-0.0128268637,
0.0108676674,
0.0200508591,
0.0296903271,
-0.0171095766,
0.0796355605,
0.0357297622,
-0.0508130752,
-0.004230639,
0.0080090808,
-0.0316576287,
-0.0348534994,
-0.0213545971,
0.0414700098,
-0.0598265752,
0.0331378467,
-0.0280059483,
0.0065044202,
0.0749855489,
-0.0221923012,
-0.0083622932,
0.0128548052,
-0.0062001706,
0.0384311564,
-0.0369564779,
0.0474534929,
-0.037382964,
0.0248220172,
-0.0330388136,
-0.0278702192,
-0.015394371,
-0.0340129063,
-0.0336025618,
0.0343150087,
-0.0492285602,
-0.0078060334,
-0.0398455076,
0.0187224206,
-0.0123114539,
0.0016527232,
0.0044742441,
0.0807776526,
-0.0219937749,
-0.0342929028,
-0.0619350672,
0.03377584,
-0.0470093228,
0.0230142791,
0.0163166057,
-0.0770034567,
-0.0181874111,
0.0214798097,
-0.018231824,
-0.0245204326,
0.0117530869,
0.0534147471,
-0.0136845903,
-0.027407065,
-0.0154053504,
-0.0644473433,
-0.0270783305,
-0.0429938547,
0.0335172527,
-0.0639948919,
0.0184640642,
-0.0128068123,
-0.0342970602,
-0.0419297405,
0.0226063747,
0.0753292069,
-0.0449865721,
0.0350781754,
-0.0021139462,
-0.0099041052,
0.0245773923,
0.033024516,
-0.0038801669,
0.0317621715,
0.0061498918,
0.0478912741,
0.0515888892,
0.0113084968,
0.0539829396,
0.0084571503,
0.0507220104,
0.0043596746,
-0.0031792268,
0.0622709319,
0.028432969,
-0.0129004614,
-0.0156150516,
0.06224446,
-0.0205168128,
-0.0445307419,
0.045812387,
-0.0127889672,
-0.0080793677,
-0.0111567257,
-0.0006601305,
-0.0304110795,
0.0120248208,
0.0177166034,
-0.0757313669,
0.036448326,
-0.0798473731,
0.0184909962,
0.0582450293,
0.0135578532,
-0.0328464732,
-0.0503336005,
-0.0173803642,
0.0050880094,
0.0025286451,
0.0294615645,
0.017087603,
0.027987292,
-0.0527670644,
0.0251782667,
0.0109340046,
-0.0230209045,
-0.001217167,
-0.0426752307,
0.0989352167,
0.0285815932,
0.0877418444,
-0.026407307,
-0.0004697511,
-0.00056055,
0.0157541763,
0.0205477457,
0.0188627709,
0.0207507554,
-0.007690635,
-0.044351209,
-0.0019057152,
0.0087146955,
0.0076441574,
0.013836341,
0.0679027289,
-0.0013282854,
0.0078810193,
-0.0341146514,
-0.0139319412,
0.0224510171,
-0.0064605735,
-0.0377441384,
0.0174655318,
-0.0118359569,
0.0098345308,
-0.0092688939,
-0.001050317,
0.0459397845,
0.0542407893,
-0.0179288164,
-0.0708073452,
-0.0221877433,
-0.0266094562,
0.0257520359,
0.023366075,
-0.0107569173,
-0.0113186724,
0.0342587009,
-0.018171303,
-0.0367100798,
0.0218884945,
-0.0362088382,
0.0482785702,
-0.0692736357,
-0.0161439702,
0.0312787965,
0.0320007391,
-0.0370086692,
0.06189337,
-0.0228650384,
0.0095310649,
-0.0125356307,
0.0134346597,
-0.009467002,
-0.0040062773,
-0.0228381231,
-0.0038106381,
-0.0272667166,
0.0310385786,
0.0615562946,
-0.0221545845,
-0.0426161885,
-0.0250163842,
-0.0405991264,
0.0242684279,
-0.0269581471,
0.0096277045,
0.0068847071,
0.0074593751,
-0.0026666238,
-0.0245800111,
-0.0497216173,
-0.0028256366,
0.0360164829,
0.0317444503,
0.0090759778,
0.0102388375,
-0.0227950495,
-0.0081837485,
0.002045997,
-0.0049551497,
0.0179010555,
-0.0071930545,
0.0288192388,
-0.0732493326,
0.0298521779,
-0.0685646981,
0.0366225205,
-0.0101097887,
-0.0165143516,
-0.0192199983,
-0.0062887794,
0.0147703793,
0.0376463458,
0.0351385437,
-0.037396878,
0.0555756874,
0.0359133333,
-0.0311806314,
0.0035534657,
-0.0492786057,
-0.0559517182,
0.0258968435,
-0.0541994423,
0.0222585909,
0.0083981454,
0.0199716873,
-0.0069120768,
-0.060596589,
0.0130088534,
0.0001250593,
-0.0352393761,
-0.019335987,
-0.0171787404,
-0.028762985,
0.0565787852,
-0.0251828022,
-0.0593453981,
0.089155294,
-0.0314049833,
0.0014027307,
-0.0489607602,
0.0175077207,
-0.0143174762,
0.0165046472,
-0.0007016955,
0.0143330507,
0.0014875752,
-0.0123006059,
-0.0605132133,
-0.0432749316,
0.0019497783,
-0.0662077144,
0.0351332054,
-0.0191255994,
0.0019355448,
0.0253155883,
-0.0191088449,
-0.0848256126,
-0.059627682,
-0.0111325905,
0.0142592322,
-0.0461377986,
-0.0186643079,
-0.0412347279,
-0.0332883298,
0.0271640923,
-0.0013144802,
-0.0549189448,
-0.0136458557,
-0.0077875652,
0.0343626887,
0.105745405,
-0.0107433582,
0.0324208923,
-0.0059851538,
-0.0300518926,
0.1194161549,
0.034116663,
0.0028372111,
0.0001720887,
-0.0582283139,
0.0370395705,
-0.0079131788,
-0.0154612493,
0.0443828143,
0.0485859662,
-0.0264332984,
-0.038510032,
0.0869405419,
0.0503550433,
-0.0054423213,
-0.027289832,
-0.0440486521,
0.0661056563,
0.0094506452,
0.0511234067,
-0.1006536037,
-0.0349526256,
-0.0081080487,
0.066852279,
0.0022711032,
-0.0221315976,
0.0088809552,
-0.1056022272,
0.0080369199,
-0.0011045029,
-0.0140633322,
-0.0536270812,
-0.053432323,
-0.0026948124,
0.0023342217,
0.0250898302,
0.0404482782,
0.004733054,
-0.0029273387,
0.0215930343,
0.0050111101,
0.027502887,
0.0401925109,
-0.022825649,
0.0218294375,
0.0936271995,
-0.0169342421,
-0.006058129,
-0.1051226705,
-0.0235034823,
-0.0327826105,
-0.0113622919,
0.0008297546,
0.0192083847,
0.0104066515,
0.0198297147,
-0.0153384609,
0.0358322188,
-0.03490353,
-0.0339879841,
0.0130727952,
0.0833012536,
-0.0357883684,
-0.0146894539,
-0.0378454439,
0.0507057123,
0.013078169,
0.0804605186,
0.0060613453,
-0.0184498411,
-0.0320410319,
-0.0187098999,
0.0101116756,
-0.0009857218,
0.0188225247,
0.0048439489,
0.0412791185,
0.0107756872,
-0.0830841511,
-0.0087801842,
-0.0033723316,
0.0301448852,
-0.0273810681,
0.0018521569,
-0.0177612342,
0.0105439937,
-0.0185217392,
0.0109073706,
-0.0844676718,
0.0249638893,
-0.0480896719,
0.0522187166,
0.0229072552,
-0.0408581868,
-0.0127481446,
0.0611185133,
-0.0388567075,
-0.0716367513,
0.003679743,
0.0699260086,
0.0303961691,
0.0224016421,
-0.0282086004,
-0.0427671224,
0.0080898311,
0.0054691378,
-0.0139849586,
0.0207040664,
0.0303200204,
-0.0308801532,
0.0034693507,
0.0239509176,
-0.0451440178,
-0.001696074,
-0.0080275889,
0.0288888309,
0.0257272478,
-0.0431584902,
0.0370689593,
0.0278207269,
0.0302620903,
-0.0055448925,
0.0357212611,
-0.0003515467,
0.0405247435,
-0.017340783,
-0.006253357,
0.0185102578,
0.0392156392,
0.0160292629,
-0.0392522216,
0.011930136,
-0.0269911848,
-0.0368590169,
0.0609778352,
-0.0165563356,
-0.0445957147,
0.0139930816,
0.0082183955,
0.0358829238,
-0.0100504998,
-0.023568593,
0.0079241348,
0.0166244321,
0.1065164208,
0.0060199508,
0.0472776741,
0.0118033253,
-0.0195676554,
-0.0455394387,
-0.0196284633,
-0.1023289189,
-0.051606454,
-0.0226252787,
0.0390584432,
0.0191563163,
0.0130436402,
0.0229258817,
-0.0267984197,
-0.0129973944,
-0.017556956,
-0.0132927205,
0.0198123306,
-0.0258897878,
0.0402435735,
0.024820799,
-0.0191894621,
0.0068696677,
0.0681644753,
-0.0609770045,
0.0437513478,
-0.034997195,
-0.0305318851,
-0.0218820963,
-0.0328513086,
-0.0188529994,
0.0406807885,
-0.0314024128,
-0.0260820165,
-0.052581951,
-0.050866019,
0.0603927523,
0.0187112689,
-0.0201503877,
-0.0170795359,
0.0281700194,
0.0743331537,
0.0214763097,
0.0009459725,
-0.0330684222,
0.0199483726,
-0.0032864187,
0.0087676244,
-0.0247291718,
-6.798264397e-33,
0.0187399164,
-0.0176820867,
0.0106256157,
-0.0538842753,
0.0168483388,
-0.0181738269,
0.0034818579,
-0.0161063597,
-0.0223057587,
0.003586282,
-0.0325116701,
-0.0007125828,
0.0071226964,
0.0427653491,
-0.0104746995,
-0.03458203,
0.0253783241,
-0.0075724982,
-0.0412783325,
0.0291792396,
0.0760583654,
0.0106675262,
0.0183046088,
-0.0298071504,
0.029591443,
-0.0393198654,
-0.0300626904,
0.0656616241,
-0.0455001965,
0.072148338,
-0.000840194,
0.0504793674,
-0.0023861735,
-0.0468893796,
0.0208321512,
0.0039983955,
-0.0590694249,
-0.0338126868,
0.0337877385,
-0.0207834002,
-0.0490126051,
-0.0140332347,
0.0107873855,
-0.0247376002,
0.0038644657,
-0.0157238618,
0.0096972305,
-0.0246359613,
-0.0254798569,
-0.0000895604,
-0.0132855894,
0.001450344,
0.0420697145,
-0.0315837786,
-0.051267691,
0.0914855823,
0.0160757247,
0.0064707184,
-0.0525267348,
0.0269007292,
-0.015862599,
0.0189947113,
0.0363850556,
-0.0012340867,
-0.0017936816,
0.0579274856,
0.0422020778,
-0.0453805104,
-0.0434540659,
-0.0504229255,
-0.0246564988,
-0.0017186034,
0.0524124205,
0.0569436885,
0.0096191298,
0.0022935509,
-0.066979453,
0.0449580476,
-0.0104012061,
0.054270111,
0.0268746838,
-0.0219128206,
-0.0642499551,
-0.0058402787,
-0.044581376,
0.0368676893,
-0.0399602726,
-0.012020302,
0.0191403236,
0.0505142249,
-0.0444426164,
-0.0034805862,
0.0250793267,
-0.0580803342,
0.0573042855,
0.0529555865,
-0.0296304673,
-0.0297273677,
-0.0114845047,
0.0423790924,
-0.0005347656,
0.019910492,
0.0362404995,
-0.0629689619,
-0.04630097,
0.0360996574,
0.0333874859,
-0.016465785,
-0.0648213997,
0.0361871831,
-0.0517898984,
0.0500584207,
0.0097602187,
-0.049582772,
0.0380783081,
0.0288261566,
-0.0137700913,
0.0232826155,
0.0104654301,
0.0632533953,
-0.0409334376,
-0.0022967728,
-0.0002858797,
0.0145180179,
-0.0268650036,
0.021445943,
-0.0086756339,
0.0121408664,
-0.0280057807,
-0.0578881204,
-0.008680379,
0.0262047369,
2.85e-7,
0.0394349545,
0.0099173058,
0.0214867648,
0.0189708695,
0.0112702195,
0.0054590232,
0.0256490931,
0.0303385165,
0.0443305671,
-0.0260403939,
-0.026656488,
0.0148304766,
0.0351402648,
0.0442491882,
-0.0834777653,
-0.0385214053,
-0.0903390422,
-0.0091151791,
-0.013509538,
-0.0389531031,
0.0487997457,
0.0935223401,
0.0104862461,
-0.0377489254,
-0.0181740876,
-0.0147711672,
0.063414067,
0.0255813263,
-0.0210290644,
-0.0026502265,
0.0485171005,
0.0087629985,
0.0332218781,
0.0037996161,
-0.0192408804,
-0.0008150525,
-0.0190278273,
0.0426123962,
0.0182394739,
-0.0789412409,
-0.0319523886,
-0.0134509858,
0.0183285829,
-0.0545644648,
0.0713339224,
-0.0329838768,
-0.0017255128,
-0.0212336611,
-0.0498968922,
0.0022624615,
0.0574317724,
-0.0073372973,
-0.0157939848,
0.0101014953,
-0.0090628024,
0.0539844334,
0.0034950818,
-0.0466993749,
-0.0126844365,
-0.0188759156,
-0.0437442288,
-0.0377399065,
-0.013896863,
-0.0112663787,
-0.0309919063,
-0.1014535129,
0.0057893158,
2.675253869e-34,
0.0203316063,
-0.0076875123,
0.0155082028,
-0.0080849091,
0.0237802807,
-0.010800018,
0.050106056,
0.0240828265,
0.0507603623,
-0.0866831392,
-0.0272337478
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.03354v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.03354v2 | Token-Level Serialized Output Training for Joint Streaming ASR and ST Leveraging Textual Alignments | 2023-07-07T02:26:18 | 2023-10-02T08:59:09 | Sara Papi, Peidong Wang, Junkun Chen, Jian Xue, Jinyu Li, Yashesh Gaur | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | In real-world applications, users often require both translations and
transcriptions of speech to enhance their comprehension, particularly in
streaming scenarios where incremental generation is necessary. This paper
introduces a streaming Transformer-Transducer that jointly generates automatic
speech recognition (ASR) and speech translation (ST) outputs using a single
decoder. To produce ASR and ST content effectively with minimal latency, we
propose a joint token-level serialized output training method that interleaves
source and target words by leveraging an off-the-shelf textual aligner.
Experiments in monolingual (it-en) and multilingual (\{de,es,it\}-en) settings
demonstrate that our approach achieves the best quality-latency balance. With
an average ASR latency of 1s and ST latency of 1.3s, our model shows no
degradation or even improves output quality compared to separate ASR and ST
models, yielding an average improvement of 1.1 WER and 0.4 BLEU in the
multilingual case. | [
-0.0534096658,
0.0269857273,
0.0281552505,
-0.0061880322,
-0.0261877459,
-0.0101954462,
0.0162807424,
-0.0235694926,
-0.0724136382,
-0.0083090337,
-0.0203338116,
-0.0292551853,
0.049883429,
0.049771782,
0.0298786517,
-0.0310915764,
0.0405051857,
-0.0211834665,
-0.0249733087,
-0.0114844488,
0.0198371094,
0.0250039753,
-0.0350207239,
0.0212892182,
-0.0195529517,
-0.0006617142,
-0.0093904696,
0.0050692633,
0.0432796106,
-0.0442247018,
-0.0375590101,
-0.0106744645,
0.0401622616,
0.0659961104,
0.0000020585,
-0.0158880893,
-0.0542118773,
0.0318713188,
-0.0518808141,
-0.0315738991,
0.0321307145,
-0.0356157757,
-0.0259828493,
0.0770396069,
-0.0026035036,
-0.0359188803,
0.0589678176,
0.0208597798,
0.0019265182,
0.0357194506,
-0.0236861352,
-0.0461343117,
0.0032865964,
-0.0097413864,
-0.0810871869,
-0.004301256,
-0.0448660515,
-0.0335026719,
-0.0674764961,
0.0055026161,
-0.0237220787,
0.0610076673,
0.0246896818,
-0.0256828833,
0.0179807041,
-0.0013408163,
-0.0569330603,
-0.0245468896,
-0.0587052107,
0.0345254354,
0.0095567014,
-0.0341791287,
-0.0131531358,
0.0068416661,
-0.0137442788,
-0.0688569248,
-0.0102035813,
0.0078597413,
-0.0104322061,
0.0311763845,
-0.0145557113,
0.0127955126,
0.0221037958,
-0.0441398993,
-0.0390095562,
-0.0292084739,
0.0358047076,
-0.0289386474,
-0.0166924633,
0.0086069154,
-0.0051615746,
-0.0056052464,
0.0656260252,
0.0041107177,
-0.0526662655,
-0.0031918141,
-0.0481142402,
-0.0992438346,
-0.026804097,
0.0077612526,
0.0250130333,
0.0948804617,
-0.0180912074,
-0.0035572418,
-0.0345135555,
0.0912071913,
0.0133546628,
-0.0035713285,
-0.0451591834,
-0.0107737435,
0.0010260231,
-0.0291344412,
-0.0471606217,
0.0230166372,
-0.0634870157,
-0.0414070413,
-0.0182393603,
0.0134313842,
0.0338114463,
0.0212965291,
0.0281675626,
-0.0237930659,
-0.0852109343,
-0.0259218514,
0.0526430681,
0.0919254869,
-0.0069286879,
0.0246849954,
0.0221491996,
-0.0477457903,
-0.0147249512,
0.0389200263,
0.0325304009,
0.0044607208,
-0.023744449,
0.0253262036,
-0.0393450335,
0.0076947357,
-0.0144159999,
0.0126088616,
-0.011081364,
-0.0260670949,
-0.0159014091,
-0.0561991446,
0.0622091256,
0.0257605016,
0.0032456121,
-0.0315118916,
-0.0005043765,
-0.0206555054,
0.0774849802,
0.0490698814,
-0.034138456,
0.0184901413,
0.0101636434,
-0.0327022448,
0.0093633402,
0.0777075738,
0.0602948107,
-0.0168647245,
0.0155898072,
-0.0310547873,
-0.0552026257,
0.0649600998,
-0.0090685776,
-0.0083934627,
-0.0248057693,
-0.0143161342,
0.0499076135,
0.0273673087,
0.0538215935,
0.0415873826,
-0.0158993881,
0.0308209937,
0.0442579389,
0.0486622788,
0.0224198904,
0.029285349,
0.0480638705,
0.0440999307,
-0.0529093593,
0.0199664254,
0.0307830703,
0.0145860715,
0.0677586719,
0.0331959911,
0.0455330499,
0.0811913684,
-0.0230376609,
-0.0201858021,
-0.0062868292,
-0.0414159931,
-0.0041652368,
-0.0025154573,
0.0515100583,
0.0304883812,
-0.0802805722,
0.084906593,
-0.0026654806,
-0.0683836564,
0.0331788249,
-0.0216286536,
-0.046002917,
0.0501028523,
0.019096911,
0.0079450775,
-0.0344484709,
-0.0139649892,
-0.0032839559,
0.0541805327,
0.0072381436,
0.0217084046,
0.0593649894,
-0.058534313,
-0.0078694439,
0.0494162738,
-0.023241356,
0.0616860203,
-0.0153969713,
0.0339652076,
0.0133451093,
-0.0319533981,
0.0122052543,
0.0105558336,
-0.011985152,
0.0054398128,
0.0263047758,
0.0109176897,
0.0328354686,
0.0325994156,
-0.0122195883,
-0.0072748899,
0.0470048003,
-0.0418545157,
0.0096007781,
0.0991620421,
-0.0611571223,
-0.0299258828,
0.0356561318,
-0.0002149976,
0.0222997367,
0.0578132905,
0.0101475157,
-0.0646451116,
0.0042429129,
-0.0356874578,
0.0282899421,
-0.0172260199,
0.0616179146,
0.0289244205,
-0.0083048027,
0.0197109319,
-0.0157272965,
0.0148831215,
0.0299618598,
-0.0202106759,
-0.0356900208,
0.0181748345,
-0.0534787737,
0.0254780538,
0.0224986561,
-0.0454021506,
-0.0251939036,
0.0260193367,
-0.0053370935,
0.0006945801,
-0.0249945968,
-0.0582347289,
0.0045031742,
-0.0338133238,
0.0523126684,
0.0079832831,
0.047659792,
0.0164621472,
-0.03111431,
-0.0282287374,
-0.0381947011,
0.0343469009,
-0.0301656518,
-0.0032673329,
-0.0105605414,
-0.0216555186,
-0.0099853631,
0.0295744669,
0.0214025341,
0.0063734362,
0.0049580391,
-0.0053942003,
-0.0988936648,
-0.0407933854,
0.0297207404,
0.0144449528,
0.0173864681,
-0.0303258747,
-0.0000298082,
0.05168318,
0.0456817225,
0.0040070834,
0.0226842724,
-0.0108723203,
-0.0147166029,
0.0056839506,
-0.0673845038,
0.0016351257,
-0.000051941,
0.0143255237,
-0.0304953512,
0.0143899862,
0.0092268763,
0.0229282454,
0.0045354296,
0.0345113426,
-0.0654493719,
-0.0655030459,
-0.0107749579,
-0.0298554935,
-0.0058396054,
-0.0361553207,
-0.0425767154,
0.0001826377,
-0.0148337735,
-0.0547591262,
0.022430893,
-0.0802101642,
-0.0487708412,
-0.0698760599,
0.0008005641,
-0.034263771,
0.0109270355,
-0.0204337686,
0.0205367301,
-0.0487462468,
-0.0736789778,
-0.0159736462,
0.0483710803,
-0.0076496801,
-0.0392920822,
0.0265854429,
-0.0169928297,
-0.0109831318,
-0.0240761302,
-0.0590653792,
-0.0079684779,
-0.0041661924,
0.0013955004,
0.0042078476,
0.0584130362,
-0.0338785835,
-0.0494224019,
0.0188188981,
0.0009121235,
0.0651903003,
-0.0077312212,
-0.0017568561,
-0.0265487861,
0.0348828696,
0.0186705645,
-0.0015269216,
-0.0196497291,
-0.0152607569,
0.0453942679,
0.0211356226,
0.0769906715,
-0.0129090445,
-0.0416689217,
-0.0309066139,
0.0625245795,
-0.012339591,
0.0021954507,
-0.0048191645,
0.065605104,
-0.0208691284,
-0.0056349118,
0.1155804396,
0.0026508297,
-0.0060710567,
-0.0280035678,
-0.0256130323,
0.0598316267,
0.0109800035,
0.0018768865,
-0.0849117264,
-0.0182460975,
0.0329474472,
0.0632765591,
0.0549430326,
0.0513817929,
-0.0313772857,
-0.0839033127,
0.0077473209,
0.0517113432,
-0.0669307932,
-0.0541569404,
-0.065791294,
-0.0658107176,
-0.0092624705,
0.0569458641,
0.0118626291,
-0.0084769633,
-0.0089229494,
0.0437060781,
-0.0545979924,
-0.0323811173,
-0.0427793637,
-0.0428750813,
0.0468778349,
0.0698301792,
0.0294368975,
0.0043365983,
-0.0192594472,
0.0222472511,
0.0054122466,
-0.0107451472,
0.0102553964,
-0.0267790817,
-0.0266229454,
-0.0150927948,
0.006170725,
0.0330353715,
-0.0090148663,
0.0147470776,
0.014512619,
0.016057387,
0.0170169715,
0.0398623869,
0.0408174954,
-0.0013474269,
0.0047077872,
0.0411026627,
-0.0163942948,
-0.0173937753,
0.0003259232,
-0.0063466849,
0.0768193603,
-0.0247071609,
0.0233593173,
0.0058127539,
-0.0212053079,
-0.0563967638,
-0.0367774665,
-0.0085452022,
0.0192299336,
0.0326472819,
0.0187624246,
0.0252357293,
-0.0072739199,
0.0060305465,
-0.0418622307,
-0.0234509986,
0.0033911658,
0.0244449936,
-0.094956547,
0.0005576967,
0.0065850005,
-0.0618456304,
0.0018429667,
0.0003175566,
-0.083251752,
-0.067898415,
0.017541755,
-0.0159178767,
0.0101913912,
0.0912086666,
-0.0320237689,
0.0273014009,
0.0154291596,
0.0469103307,
-0.0494688414,
0.0051375497,
0.0419888496,
-0.0024279074,
-0.0163889974,
0.0108997989,
-0.0465739481,
0.0076390081,
-0.0599943548,
0.0259036943,
0.0223124158,
-0.0012275205,
0.0170054995,
0.0479275882,
0.0563878156,
-0.0502538048,
-0.0076677678,
0.0138948001,
0.0558252409,
-0.0294605233,
0.039878767,
-0.0228588115,
0.0152678238,
0.0127768768,
-0.0019758558,
-0.0009355184,
0.0527872816,
0.0111614717,
-0.0548933558,
0.0046796165,
0.023134917,
-0.0313762687,
-0.0361203626,
0.0203088783,
0.0208203942,
-0.0263118986,
-0.0239811391,
0.0497484878,
0.0177353956,
-0.0499755219,
0.0401246995,
0.0242207572,
0.0404786691,
0.0342626497,
0.0412593223,
0.0010941158,
0.0284937657,
-0.0224502925,
-0.0045889989,
0.0323099755,
0.0049522598,
0.0747012198,
0.0187179912,
0.0282287374,
-0.0332284644,
0.0419422463,
-0.0368000232,
-0.0209806543,
0.0036574847,
-0.0214433521,
-0.0252922308,
0.0167866889,
0.0548591986,
-0.03891268,
0.0036225736,
-0.0064428425,
0.0155459493,
-0.0300671365,
-0.012327183,
-0.0542955995,
-0.0196728092,
-0.0226894822,
-0.0409294404,
0.0346466713,
-0.0437209159,
0.0182379354,
-0.0143187251,
0.016306676,
-0.0378191844,
0.0005085721,
0.054787904,
-0.0482684746,
-0.010388881,
0.0076088007,
-0.0504406691,
0.0402255543,
0.0103444308,
-0.0128595829,
-6.328032861e-33,
-0.0296458211,
0.0165869165,
0.0039918092,
-0.0129197417,
-0.0532900654,
0.0153383566,
-0.0107176024,
-0.0213012993,
-0.0006300037,
-0.0221849158,
0.0020246757,
0.0208715554,
0.0457956791,
0.0403765738,
-0.0219051857,
-0.00282371,
0.1004363075,
-0.0272920541,
-0.0381712466,
-0.0037277592,
0.0458081923,
0.028299639,
0.0129486946,
-0.0069172969,
-0.0457136743,
0.0058066375,
0.0023026203,
-0.000051836,
0.0601996481,
0.0235600304,
0.0320279151,
0.0313154794,
-0.0081504025,
-0.0441406518,
-0.0194362924,
0.0433225296,
-0.1032960638,
0.0095748687,
0.0029682196,
0.0853462368,
-0.0039441269,
-0.031568367,
0.0182122048,
-0.0158011205,
-0.02782958,
-0.0295946449,
-0.0005538515,
-0.0017972762,
-0.02010151,
-0.0565774143,
-0.0362261124,
0.0131232366,
-0.0375284478,
-0.0081421612,
0.0361282974,
0.0668310672,
0.0085724834,
-0.0400669761,
-0.0862495452,
0.047685463,
-0.0119284587,
0.0484133847,
0.060649436,
0.0089523848,
0.0028133553,
0.0056871953,
0.015408841,
-0.0653818324,
0.0044462285,
-0.0072416724,
0.0192306936,
-0.0302588083,
0.0257716216,
-0.0292498413,
0.0519089215,
-0.0382313095,
-0.0270272736,
-0.0076390053,
-0.0067011998,
0.0153791523,
0.0322219282,
0.0312231742,
-0.0224270094,
0.0074798926,
-0.0533757508,
-0.003216435,
0.0000576897,
-0.0317197777,
0.0467614904,
0.0354546867,
0.0076211966,
-0.0133450357,
0.0765256435,
0.01012496,
0.0158712454,
-0.0004739132,
-0.0078935418,
0.0123235313,
-0.0505901054,
0.0414752737,
-0.0375725552,
-0.0205143746,
0.0460631289,
0.0424596742,
0.0008937042,
-0.0136795901,
0.0294878855,
0.0651293769,
-0.0803020746,
0.0280356854,
-0.009853553,
0.0421375744,
0.0009131136,
-0.0213371757,
0.0625733361,
-0.0054798555,
-0.0008055443,
0.0464010052,
-0.0404087156,
0.0218093824,
-0.0107785845,
-0.0062692151,
0.0179249998,
0.0394134,
-0.0342284665,
0.0344341919,
-0.0159663055,
0.0107131284,
0.0313081667,
-0.0241461061,
-0.0428923704,
0.000918763,
2.818e-7,
-0.0042896597,
0.0329723284,
0.0642575026,
-0.0209610667,
0.0063890261,
-0.0159547906,
0.0027862673,
0.0174255464,
0.0037616345,
0.0623406805,
-0.0100406064,
-0.0235139299,
0.081850335,
0.0329193063,
-0.0911837071,
-0.0154754762,
-0.0990169272,
0.0446554534,
-0.0128431134,
0.0239600372,
0.0362828486,
0.0656656325,
-0.0573938675,
0.0122667477,
0.0207692832,
-0.0119337784,
0.0345289074,
0.0100696431,
0.033362288,
0.0018272303,
-0.004830034,
-0.014554006,
-0.0395939313,
-0.0008192182,
-0.0559959635,
0.0144222779,
0.014665233,
0.0305026695,
-0.017702885,
-0.03054896,
0.0101420972,
0.0338716507,
-0.0373823009,
-0.0038275935,
0.0464279912,
-0.01807414,
-0.0143543445,
-0.0085126888,
-0.0887941942,
0.023607295,
-0.0422334597,
0.0024823905,
-0.0106333559,
0.0466599613,
0.0360142514,
0.026047105,
-0.0266732462,
-0.0226108693,
-0.0239549708,
-0.0389709026,
-0.0382498391,
-0.0036295438,
-0.0425221957,
0.0069922144,
0.0030662317,
-0.0156604927,
-0.0230970625,
2.614718206e-34,
0.0279032066,
-0.0254640747,
0.0174953621,
0.0300759338,
0.0037934713,
-0.0618602969,
0.0259957444,
0.0416441448,
-0.0295015387,
-0.0212398507,
-0.0303813946
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.03322v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.03322v1 | BiPhone: Modeling Inter Language Phonetic Influences in Text | 2023-07-06T22:31:55 | 2023-07-06T22:31:55 | Abhirut Gupta, Ananya B. Sai, Richard Sproat, Yuri Vasilevski, James S. Ren, Ambarish Jash, Sukhdeep S. Sodhi, Aravindan Raghuveer | cs.CL | cs.CL | A large number of people are forced to use the Web in a language they have
low literacy in due to technology asymmetries. Written text in the second
language (L2) from such users often contains a large number of errors that are
influenced by their native language (L1). We propose a method to mine phoneme
confusions (sounds in L2 that an L1 speaker is likely to conflate) for pairs of
L1 and L2. These confusions are then plugged into a generative model (Bi-Phone)
for synthetically producing corrupted L2 text. Through human evaluations, we
show that Bi-Phone generates plausible corruptions that differ across L1s and
also have widespread coverage on the Web. We also corrupt the popular language
understanding benchmark SuperGLUE with our technique (FunGLUE for Phonetically
Noised GLUE) and show that SoTA language understating models perform poorly. We
also introduce a new phoneme prediction pre-training task which helps byte
models to recover performance close to SuperGLUE. Finally, we also release the
FunGLUE benchmark to promote further research in phonetically robust language
models. To the best of our knowledge, FunGLUE is the first benchmark to
introduce L1-L2 interactions in text. | [
0.0235084351,
0.0699240416,
-0.0282431506,
0.0309534222,
-0.0260690022,
0.0095778452,
0.0293835737,
0.0000167758,
0.007115256,
-0.023067873,
-0.022655936,
-0.0690531582,
0.0587325245,
-0.01806546,
0.0673877224,
-0.0657411367,
0.0382257588,
-0.0259246528,
0.0035469134,
-0.0239559747,
0.0405539908,
0.0198023114,
0.0060711475,
0.0366290174,
-0.0284072366,
-0.0179162715,
0.0084532937,
0.0607813857,
-0.0159552582,
0.0340680778,
-0.0155927464,
0.0419424102,
-0.0094196703,
0.0839781165,
0.0000021467,
-0.0374778844,
-0.0296418015,
0.014072923,
-0.0187154766,
0.0649641156,
0.0172542296,
0.0020428684,
-0.0906962901,
0.0481930412,
-0.0020520845,
0.012144451,
0.0488856547,
-0.0279762018,
0.0365959443,
0.0672675371,
-0.0272008907,
-0.00910707,
0.0271345377,
-0.0185557678,
0.0315829851,
-0.0175244194,
0.0124836285,
0.0058418275,
-0.0275799092,
-0.0602592565,
0.0051390636,
0.0053641745,
-0.025549138,
-0.0017764809,
-0.0228902251,
0.0172615256,
-0.0061650537,
-0.048250787,
0.0243941359,
0.0557887107,
-0.0930989608,
-0.0372554585,
0.0063124057,
0.0107650785,
-0.0127587439,
0.007187007,
0.010495835,
0.0231581219,
-0.0307013132,
0.0199956484,
0.0266128927,
-0.0159075726,
0.0576168709,
-0.0120263919,
-0.013530001,
0.0083759679,
0.0320453495,
-0.0443783998,
-0.0277382247,
0.0138813611,
-0.0117086414,
-0.0167808086,
0.0586749725,
-0.002337805,
-0.0069587184,
0.0370195135,
-0.0388539881,
-0.0486756377,
0.0311509408,
-0.0654416606,
0.0235393327,
0.0115449317,
-0.0384936631,
0.0195093285,
-0.0354055092,
0.0290570576,
0.0018018625,
0.004853535,
0.0173395257,
-0.0148735503,
0.00513743,
-0.0090534361,
-0.036184337,
-0.0087174587,
-0.0275220852,
0.0170814618,
-0.0059498311,
-0.0332355015,
-0.0087326542,
0.0167227108,
-0.0139037743,
-0.0313189961,
-0.0567577146,
-0.0319288746,
0.0094592478,
-0.0109255984,
-0.0117955217,
0.0556594916,
-0.0531872325,
-0.0929755196,
0.0059476886,
0.0343759246,
-0.0093079088,
-0.005578205,
0.0195406526,
0.0716308877,
-0.0304710176,
0.0105958302,
-0.0686078891,
-0.048174303,
-0.034412466,
-0.0227280594,
-0.0555253215,
-0.0731603727,
0.0090538748,
-0.0252918899,
0.0022815648,
-0.0687872767,
-0.0025847091,
0.0164073296,
-0.0236631781,
0.0753057301,
-0.0434529632,
0.0095004579,
0.0171786267,
0.0010754087,
0.0183770433,
0.045462627,
0.0451081805,
-0.0209261086,
0.0522781312,
-0.0252540633,
-0.0036545058,
0.0670180246,
0.0234565251,
0.006476358,
0.0067254701,
-0.0523523092,
0.0216386188,
0.026507251,
0.0546733551,
0.0764369667,
-0.0152300904,
-0.0266660005,
0.0778460279,
0.0318596065,
0.0202137418,
0.0622331649,
-0.0048297751,
0.0062628915,
0.0027846568,
0.0438517034,
-0.0022025965,
-0.0217623543,
-0.0441932715,
0.0266824327,
0.0566841029,
0.0425739102,
-0.0270568132,
-0.0305210352,
-0.0213110745,
-0.01789793,
-0.0155326538,
-0.0076219537,
0.0273503736,
0.035913974,
-0.059276063,
0.0261491332,
0.0185291488,
-0.0758840591,
0.0412892811,
-0.0343425535,
0.0151229631,
0.0718244836,
0.0558685884,
-0.0222335178,
0.0224414729,
-0.0119035486,
-0.0465739071,
0.0725498945,
-0.004881612,
-0.0178071503,
0.0357901789,
-0.0483686179,
0.0307139382,
0.0593606234,
0.0008709324,
0.0339044407,
0.0077116513,
-0.0032729516,
0.0089241927,
-0.0606340468,
-0.017895557,
-0.000455499,
-0.0448887013,
0.0093809012,
0.0054010726,
0.0198468529,
0.0007135834,
0.0220565423,
-0.061990045,
0.0008961674,
-0.0096592195,
-0.0440265983,
0.0085097067,
0.0153006595,
-0.0426966362,
-0.0240928084,
0.0577740483,
-0.0505133085,
0.0105442014,
0.0186983161,
0.0047824834,
-0.0401716679,
0.0728391558,
-0.0417638905,
0.060454227,
-0.073563002,
0.0346885212,
0.000793208,
0.0206959937,
-0.0102189416,
0.0209307671,
0.0084346589,
0.0085882433,
-0.004691842,
0.0223016273,
0.0078394143,
-0.0381769799,
-0.0425708517,
0.0335315876,
-0.0351860002,
0.0549067333,
-0.0229601152,
-0.0124137159,
-0.0378731415,
-0.0489457101,
-0.0320634618,
-0.0087338248,
-0.0373014733,
0.0389087349,
0.036526069,
0.0066659139,
-0.0192036293,
-0.0477727465,
-0.0256542489,
-0.0234309398,
-0.0095028272,
-0.0144423889,
0.0053391466,
-0.0129728597,
0.0165148228,
-0.0587616786,
-0.0109327976,
0.0026432162,
0.0268505998,
0.015899295,
-0.0421947986,
-0.0719829202,
-0.0055081863,
-0.0157796238,
0.0112107247,
0.0128662484,
-0.0658351555,
-0.0159578957,
-0.0216097962,
0.0707974806,
0.0199739654,
-0.0116822608,
-0.0057090307,
0.0277004205,
-0.0106572974,
-0.0334760956,
-0.0145236021,
0.0170513261,
-0.0059639835,
-0.0275120847,
-0.0469847433,
-0.024386676,
0.0737253726,
0.0103179561,
0.0061281328,
-0.0381766595,
0.0126943104,
-0.0309147891,
-0.0230822954,
0.0005501268,
-0.0278324541,
-0.0219928566,
0.0459340587,
-0.0481284633,
-0.0500858165,
0.0700478405,
-0.0740054622,
-0.0133076236,
-0.0565965772,
-0.0119424742,
0.0137008447,
0.0217534211,
-0.0319760256,
0.040881224,
0.0231760461,
-0.0634115487,
-0.0461015217,
0.0105777485,
0.0576218329,
-0.0556279756,
0.0017826768,
-0.0480551608,
0.0145266904,
0.0072545521,
-0.0407920219,
-0.0185108241,
-0.014901787,
-0.0003054496,
-0.0276517719,
0.0259857476,
-0.0480160266,
0.0258839987,
-0.0055801244,
0.0011485921,
0.0155911623,
0.0143626276,
0.0035866692,
-0.0134252002,
0.059765622,
0.0061270492,
-0.0005856638,
-0.000307877,
-0.0395357385,
0.0087029338,
0.008830715,
0.0130398571,
0.0088125253,
0.0147817414,
0.0031877542,
0.0399285369,
0.0184110347,
-0.0346010998,
0.0105464226,
0.027964469,
-0.0176729802,
-0.0233222228,
0.0894013345,
0.0353256203,
-0.0127308667,
-0.0019762837,
-0.0167604089,
0.0808251128,
-0.0051306821,
0.0084847556,
-0.0610609464,
-0.0297076683,
0.0448948182,
0.0461258851,
0.007681034,
-0.0091936374,
-0.0077504013,
-0.1393577158,
0.0011328778,
0.0443709716,
-0.0069655543,
-0.0137275849,
-0.0287403222,
-0.0093859136,
-0.0055906791,
0.0342293233,
0.0152060213,
0.0126330666,
0.0081470711,
0.0313816406,
-0.0745201781,
-0.0766465738,
-0.0076797106,
-0.0261137187,
0.0681721494,
0.0531152822,
0.0223236103,
-0.0130912848,
-0.0127459364,
0.0307259019,
-0.0193121005,
0.0079200761,
-0.0103527652,
0.073628217,
0.0451519452,
-0.0357283242,
-0.0333269127,
0.0120388288,
-0.0060879122,
0.0032582548,
-0.029224908,
0.031671606,
0.032523267,
0.000234245,
0.0322074853,
0.0245693531,
0.0402760878,
0.0609694868,
0.040532507,
-0.0532093942,
-0.0450842902,
-0.0411366932,
0.04341368,
-0.0679778233,
-0.0311476383,
0.0350769013,
0.0479226373,
-0.0907116011,
-0.0856993124,
-0.0461494476,
-0.0374856368,
0.032474786,
0.0445016921,
0.0064271754,
0.0065713897,
0.0112872785,
-0.031547673,
-0.0306835566,
-0.0183548797,
0.0677380115,
-0.0565844476,
-0.0058815717,
0.0093509797,
-0.0474555306,
0.0016313535,
0.0199436322,
-0.0705783293,
-0.091558069,
0.017041659,
0.0205213521,
0.0301645808,
0.0515674129,
-0.0607571937,
-0.0925135985,
0.0062754331,
0.0544822924,
-0.0337988101,
0.0091180922,
0.0753682107,
-0.0667773485,
0.014820816,
0.0498700999,
-0.0091048507,
0.0244598631,
-0.0040684887,
0.0082902983,
-0.0555955991,
-0.0165492203,
0.0358342342,
0.022331791,
0.0194244254,
-0.041649349,
0.0015370116,
-0.0449285842,
0.0091084996,
0.0160133243,
0.0309608486,
-0.0021924283,
-0.0268814899,
0.0375721119,
-0.0022263129,
-0.0056903521,
0.0088418145,
-0.0218737684,
-0.0003909584,
0.0312316976,
0.0368093438,
0.0240425002,
0.0781612843,
0.0266254675,
0.0164465383,
0.0201834589,
0.0209298879,
0.0050937072,
0.0491044149,
0.0166926533,
-0.0255334359,
-0.0091958037,
0.0025433507,
0.017626293,
-0.0121045085,
-0.0176747274,
-0.0223443154,
-0.0207728222,
-0.0326580591,
0.0756430402,
-0.0116628269,
0.0908694416,
0.0120320302,
0.01919985,
-0.0297844075,
0.0316607468,
-0.0398706682,
-0.0176310968,
-0.008614148,
-0.0221150797,
-0.027194472,
-0.0030161424,
0.0967154205,
-0.0099613853,
0.052706752,
-0.030581044,
0.00236337,
-0.029325882,
-0.031825494,
-0.0208075196,
0.0313739814,
-0.0433097146,
-0.0260636061,
-0.0578429326,
-0.0969826281,
0.0006284909,
0.0148418359,
0.0677319616,
0.0289916452,
-0.0007681897,
0.0494454168,
-0.0109659377,
0.0975349024,
-0.0103905471,
-0.0030758071,
0.0112834694,
-0.0184957739,
0.0243974905,
-6.661317101e-33,
0.0051414696,
-0.0051913983,
-0.0380797945,
-0.0230039004,
0.0253221299,
0.025722919,
-0.0383283906,
0.0242364444,
-0.0469585769,
-0.0048704832,
-0.0086244186,
0.0050705387,
0.0271281805,
0.0214900412,
-0.0337362252,
0.0189783461,
0.0796489269,
0.015729852,
0.0073694088,
0.0060315197,
0.0543970019,
0.0333540142,
0.0432900637,
-0.0623997524,
0.0072802445,
-0.0304658078,
-0.0472593904,
-0.0216696393,
0.0031469737,
0.0604651533,
-0.0099609243,
0.0853114128,
-0.0019694401,
0.0359337255,
-0.0562210716,
0.0428179689,
-0.0928618312,
-0.0271263476,
0.0255811624,
0.0459102765,
0.0069857468,
-0.0173173118,
0.0548514798,
-0.0005970113,
-0.0182700064,
0.0021705499,
0.0454856902,
-0.009899524,
0.0026349924,
0.0052708583,
-0.0517690741,
0.0336796455,
-0.001232238,
-0.0118440334,
0.0529792979,
0.0361118503,
-0.0057489132,
0.0013764327,
-0.0831402242,
0.0613754056,
0.0120658791,
0.0388756022,
0.0450436994,
0.0095087076,
-0.0260476675,
0.0509791449,
0.0384132192,
-0.0124484254,
0.017547857,
-0.0149582988,
0.049414929,
-0.0081208842,
0.0372750498,
0.0777162537,
0.0672064945,
-0.0555546246,
-0.0575327352,
0.0237740297,
0.0532212257,
-0.0712973475,
-0.000456255,
0.0170006379,
-0.0399455205,
-0.0252645276,
-0.0267279092,
-0.0373873971,
-0.037019562,
-0.0363733098,
0.0182159431,
-0.011784235,
-0.0083336141,
0.0171673372,
0.0040983381,
-0.0311927497,
-0.0081929676,
-0.0207977723,
-0.0167043246,
0.0058067534,
-0.0037448572,
0.0307866242,
-0.0287362728,
-0.0149325086,
0.0227834117,
0.0307949465,
0.0050813979,
0.0186623801,
0.039843753,
0.013554601,
-0.0938428566,
0.0186117385,
-0.0316840746,
0.0370758735,
0.0241171196,
0.0074626966,
0.0412857421,
0.0003463948,
-0.0191638172,
-0.0372681618,
0.0121024605,
0.0312833041,
-0.0225147717,
-0.0010626545,
-0.0619206801,
0.0331010781,
-0.0269904286,
-0.0211606175,
-0.0156505574,
-0.0267416872,
0.0351144299,
-0.045984,
-0.021513233,
-0.013471161,
2.899e-7,
0.0235703159,
0.0372012444,
0.0581881255,
0.0019762723,
0.0632770807,
0.0172767863,
-0.0451932512,
-0.0002148179,
-0.0170828849,
-0.0097106146,
-0.0181875098,
-0.0097791357,
0.0799789205,
0.029160751,
-0.0813800395,
0.0142418528,
-0.0529135913,
0.0349950641,
-0.0364728197,
-0.0172729492,
0.0379182063,
0.0846162513,
-0.0010465713,
-0.0651145503,
0.01107038,
-0.03029841,
0.02889226,
-0.0174423289,
-0.0082236184,
-0.0174769778,
0.0058090254,
0.0129696727,
0.0071604284,
0.0335117802,
-0.0491065048,
-0.0383963175,
0.0307091679,
-0.0047173109,
-0.02408427,
-0.0062334789,
-0.0288409498,
-0.0060300357,
-0.0254927371,
-0.0425586812,
0.0401768163,
0.077485837,
-0.0080939615,
0.007429637,
-0.0457828715,
0.0047279801,
0.019703757,
-0.0271724444,
-0.0377092063,
0.0295069627,
0.0124325464,
0.0105863633,
-0.0204677545,
-0.0164149031,
-0.0395719968,
0.0306098163,
-0.0132402536,
-0.0273579676,
-0.0276043601,
-0.0051341904,
0.019073477,
-0.0539597496,
0.0380686708,
2.534482681e-34,
0.0397613682,
-0.0075356071,
0.040571142,
-0.0042292592,
-0.0072332015,
0.0009192453,
0.0213586241,
0.0161362141,
0.0114582898,
0.022970885,
-0.0141981766
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.03319v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.03319v1 | Covering Uncommon Ground: Gap-Focused Question Generation for Answer Assessment | 2023-07-06T22:21:42 | 2023-07-06T22:21:42 | Roni Rabin, Alexandre Djerbetian, Roee Engelberg, Lidan Hackmon, Gal Elidan, Reut Tsarfaty, Amir Globerson | cs.CL | cs.CL | Human communication often involves information gaps between the
interlocutors. For example, in an educational dialogue, a student often
provides an answer that is incomplete, and there is a gap between this answer
and the perfect one expected by the teacher. Successful dialogue then hinges on
the teacher asking about this gap in an effective manner, thus creating a rich
and interactive educational experience. We focus on the problem of generating
such gap-focused questions (GFQs) automatically. We define the task, highlight
key desired aspects of a good GFQ, and propose a model that satisfies these.
Finally, we provide an evaluation by human annotators of our generated
questions compared against human generated ones, demonstrating competitive
performance. | [
0.0662152544,
0.0461777784,
-0.0207503717,
0.0092287827,
-0.0330610238,
0.0038119489,
-0.010889574,
-0.0102178352,
-0.0049513816,
-0.0456254892,
0.0464673974,
-0.0286308955,
-0.0199232344,
0.0073029683,
0.0258812159,
-0.0890199244,
0.0182158407,
-0.00231326,
0.0022865923,
0.0028545107,
-0.0041184672,
-0.0131112579,
-0.0369212069,
0.012446722,
-0.0201432277,
-0.0291893166,
-0.0775252655,
-0.0041686324,
0.0097665098,
-0.0359211154,
0.0386847816,
0.0818669572,
-0.0294601284,
-0.011559234,
0.0000019269,
-0.0391602218,
-0.000901242,
-0.0054277251,
-0.0374682248,
-0.0014213972,
-0.0360645019,
0.062292967,
0.0274189319,
0.0151847741,
-0.0763850808,
-0.0062886146,
0.0266248807,
0.0002703371,
0.1041983068,
0.0337898172,
0.0063523077,
-0.0058858022,
0.0211514141,
0.0124493651,
0.0776566789,
-0.0525632948,
-0.0188883934,
0.0494777076,
0.0359836482,
0.0035108568,
0.0022295795,
0.0027239542,
0.0401962288,
-0.0493751615,
0.038808357,
0.0143663967,
-0.0353690386,
-0.0233167876,
-0.0069296462,
0.1105861142,
0.0283990819,
-0.0040124175,
-0.0010816213,
-0.0051770411,
0.0536133535,
0.0245967545,
-0.0351341404,
0.0101168789,
-0.0358266495,
-0.0423100777,
-0.0044370624,
0.0271232259,
-0.0178488977,
0.022529738,
0.014224208,
0.0271980613,
0.0106403669,
-0.044437062,
-0.0357980132,
0.0200753994,
-0.0655120388,
-0.0780574605,
0.0107657248,
0.0688418895,
-0.0486533493,
0.0056034941,
-0.0297425501,
-0.01802334,
0.0374078453,
-0.0053843134,
-0.0165959839,
0.0184912458,
0.0071318261,
0.0213665273,
0.0027695622,
0.0582832322,
-0.007283634,
-0.0101420823,
-0.0360360965,
0.028540466,
-0.047281716,
-0.0212723985,
-0.0315285921,
0.0436887331,
-0.032815598,
-0.0032677462,
-0.0125519093,
0.0189394094,
-0.0190004557,
0.0277026743,
-0.0010493593,
0.0329243578,
-0.0298555829,
0.0233749263,
-0.0406809486,
-0.0004857348,
-0.0797450691,
-0.0107845347,
0.0396541618,
-0.0483349636,
-0.0043947855,
0.0393903852,
0.0119002396,
0.0226012059,
0.0042027305,
0.038628269,
-0.0246141888,
0.0102563472,
-0.0126394741,
-0.0624574907,
0.0284451395,
-0.0399194546,
-0.0304094404,
-0.0313811824,
0.0345038995,
0.0213169251,
-0.0515701659,
0.000716141,
0.0466061905,
0.071785666,
0.0490326919,
0.0422347933,
-0.036237523,
0.0133261858,
0.094123736,
0.0099669034,
0.0159401707,
0.0223247912,
0.0466666259,
0.0060439678,
0.0440927222,
0.0022387614,
0.0104906568,
-0.0181391221,
0.037258327,
-0.0408452377,
0.0505821444,
0.0338346921,
0.0141430069,
0.0516030304,
-0.0545312501,
0.0449723229,
-0.0103282752,
0.0045662909,
-0.0043495619,
0.0295486655,
-0.0317219831,
0.0187740661,
0.0542255938,
0.0313721932,
0.0125984298,
0.0670098588,
-0.0065806191,
0.0283088852,
0.0240869448,
0.0132193221,
0.0509120151,
0.0056568906,
0.0007286139,
-0.0781117454,
-0.0087006791,
0.0235749502,
0.0243892465,
0.023151638,
0.0118392901,
0.0275391638,
-0.044753883,
0.0482881665,
-0.0090292152,
-0.055122517,
0.0309111122,
-0.0439577326,
0.0555041805,
0.0278911944,
0.062996693,
-0.0110829752,
-0.074197039,
-0.0168933365,
0.0104502235,
0.0202015042,
0.0496526808,
-0.0628289729,
-0.0429781526,
-0.0397986397,
0.0002316661,
-0.0108655179,
-0.003579173,
-0.0042391671,
0.0428558029,
-0.0077838302,
0.0351437964,
-0.0547422394,
-0.0108756712,
0.0476685092,
0.0230742004,
-0.0098331086,
0.002781356,
0.0008397867,
-0.0111645395,
0.0377914906,
-0.0023190125,
0.0294371992,
0.0212877579,
-0.021847127,
-0.0314620174,
-0.015358272,
-0.0462223813,
-0.0362472013,
0.0055350261,
-0.0676340833,
0.0014404721,
-0.0140351746,
-0.0391611494,
-0.0467230715,
-0.0107015492,
-0.0367230885,
0.013703241,
-0.0581808016,
0.0096717337,
0.0360097513,
-0.0296152979,
-0.0724813417,
0.0657496527,
0.0263170004,
0.0389129929,
0.0051710932,
0.0435761735,
0.0452937782,
-0.0770613626,
0.0205372665,
0.009550943,
-0.0285372548,
0.0026786998,
0.0317332856,
0.0348358564,
-0.0651048496,
-0.0365968831,
-0.0937654302,
0.0012342811,
-0.0218230132,
0.0292515028,
0.0307204071,
-0.0126209427,
-0.002864243,
-0.0317565612,
-0.0962255001,
-0.0147430459,
0.0170543958,
-0.0319593251,
0.074164778,
0.0278149061,
0.0438045822,
-0.0362544023,
-0.0074451491,
-0.0186587777,
0.0187500492,
0.0780938342,
0.0270093475,
-0.0550635681,
-0.0097009428,
-0.0438776948,
0.0064748446,
0.0548340455,
-0.0156059628,
0.0401674584,
-0.0053705722,
0.008602866,
0.0606323034,
0.0386332683,
0.0389129668,
-0.002541201,
0.0022752678,
-0.0429219902,
0.0445450358,
-0.0039445367,
0.0280687194,
0.0145523082,
-0.0353099369,
-0.0045176684,
0.0402747653,
0.0332811475,
-0.0118976487,
-0.0441957451,
0.0451234467,
-0.0456346162,
0.0065026148,
-0.06962955,
-0.0136403795,
-0.0185405184,
0.0460236818,
-0.0168717932,
-0.0092172027,
0.0748032555,
-0.0083387597,
0.0123411613,
-0.0458741076,
0.0416667312,
-0.0331495181,
0.063093476,
-0.015412583,
0.0038963729,
0.006608631,
-0.0302887484,
-0.0632544011,
0.0456186123,
0.0528604016,
-0.0455391705,
0.0024156906,
-0.0447825789,
-0.0187093168,
-0.0069453306,
-0.0129364524,
-0.0776638016,
-0.0458046831,
0.0246174317,
-0.0068555158,
0.0068731951,
-0.0052213031,
-0.0048809359,
-0.003952235,
-0.0241539013,
0.0208012033,
-0.0499864258,
-0.0002432539,
-0.0146981198,
0.0933132842,
0.0506892055,
0.0213486925,
0.0149760125,
-0.0412485898,
0.0490320958,
0.0594306439,
0.004916308,
0.0573540628,
0.0353284739,
-0.0231811143,
0.0015069235,
-0.0360403061,
0.0077727302,
0.0153371077,
0.0668560639,
-0.0563634187,
-0.0385809503,
0.0917151719,
0.0759497732,
0.0151544008,
-0.0141475443,
-0.0412618294,
0.0478248857,
0.0167532898,
0.0464914292,
-0.0846504197,
0.0000891429,
-0.0225066934,
0.0307795741,
-0.0373093076,
-0.0122376941,
0.0133142192,
-0.0959560648,
0.0183916707,
-0.0084162001,
-0.0127151422,
0.0049830698,
0.0135525996,
-0.0020721951,
0.0405267067,
-0.0297820605,
0.026425859,
0.0365615524,
0.0408637375,
0.03790446,
-0.0140859755,
-0.0117237261,
0.0018818453,
0.0225672368,
0.0366618372,
0.0643222332,
0.0254118145,
0.0240444914,
-0.0559525974,
-0.0103655243,
-0.0381795727,
-0.0176270604,
0.0168701131,
0.0479920581,
0.0050342917,
-0.0225390904,
-0.0392368138,
0.059745349,
-0.0129279094,
0.0010862238,
0.0610068701,
0.0339937322,
-0.039488107,
0.0309318714,
-0.0121828001,
0.0342023782,
0.0236912481,
0.0508262813,
0.0454801582,
-0.0565186553,
-0.0150538711,
-0.0102220885,
0.0495132841,
-0.0992881879,
0.0031379184,
0.0317800529,
0.0376621038,
0.0192668084,
-0.0849290416,
-0.0664264336,
0.0501495525,
0.0339280292,
-0.0103639597,
-0.0325740837,
-0.0144500649,
0.0323633999,
-0.0194565635,
-0.0012620632,
0.0415978916,
-0.0081491871,
-0.0445476584,
-0.0434682928,
-0.0356842987,
-0.0367851257,
-0.034983281,
0.0057841996,
-0.0986087918,
-0.0355185755,
-0.0009330781,
0.0315534398,
0.0139992936,
-0.0084970202,
-0.0198683497,
-0.0094329426,
0.0028447332,
0.0099741174,
-0.0118583459,
-0.0343597196,
-0.0109051056,
0.0012186407,
-0.021600049,
0.0068098754,
-0.018240951,
-0.0066447821,
-0.0258209053,
0.060466256,
-0.0266772341,
-0.0681003407,
0.0548645109,
0.0131812198,
-0.0062285052,
-0.0275876503,
0.0085240779,
-0.0256195851,
0.0318018235,
-0.0107202185,
-0.0290901568,
-0.0425962172,
0.0144040892,
-0.0127049545,
-0.0394546501,
0.036153432,
-0.0532807931,
-0.0409732871,
0.0687359124,
-0.0258528236,
-0.0014867111,
0.0117402216,
0.0232253317,
-0.0012502973,
-0.0202030037,
-0.0151728252,
-0.0079198563,
-0.0040402333,
0.0632451549,
0.023802232,
0.1122844368,
0.0056974697,
0.0029265755,
0.0525216572,
-0.0099791661,
-0.0184454322,
-0.0205317289,
-0.0513320528,
0.0617885105,
-0.0001254275,
0.0608335063,
-0.0358124748,
0.0252346285,
-0.0112458821,
0.042059429,
0.0178381708,
0.0056274622,
-0.0438840277,
0.0245073698,
0.031322591,
0.0118659819,
-0.0187482685,
0.0363271832,
-0.0186290331,
0.012383963,
-0.0174850188,
0.0174369141,
-0.062474262,
-0.0084701208,
-0.0444810055,
0.0220212322,
0.0300089698,
0.0585551038,
-0.0587783195,
-0.0339927562,
-0.0176532753,
0.0795717463,
0.013526638,
0.0133379241,
0.0306017492,
0.0515107699,
-0.0200749841,
-0.0359517708,
-0.0753763542,
0.0399523005,
-0.0367263928,
-0.0347539112,
-0.0481475145,
-5.750593302e-33,
-0.0717574805,
-0.080976516,
0.0153772458,
0.0193393417,
-0.0193438493,
-0.0241260864,
-0.0348540954,
0.0338529311,
-0.0075331433,
0.0162781831,
0.0227578711,
-0.0087096952,
-0.0080801705,
0.0416475311,
0.0136001399,
-0.046729371,
0.0363445058,
-0.001842332,
-0.0111186346,
0.0506765433,
0.0052174991,
-0.0092367018,
-0.009094445,
-0.015487819,
0.0618116446,
-0.0841900408,
-0.0297986604,
0.0495720915,
-0.0075831069,
0.0292211436,
-0.0074545485,
0.00676437,
0.0231086146,
-0.0159633849,
0.0002380791,
0.0247022882,
-0.042986244,
-0.0509984456,
-0.017960554,
-0.0286553204,
-0.0774373487,
-0.0263044275,
0.0102694575,
-0.0364854187,
0.0469223671,
-0.0024143569,
0.0332105421,
0.0063621886,
0.0213864427,
-0.0098630525,
-0.0427158065,
0.0116544841,
-0.0360523574,
-0.0507450067,
-0.0596715324,
0.1002588198,
0.0091308337,
-0.0601507388,
0.0105507802,
0.0367990658,
0.0590313785,
0.0144428993,
0.0226972774,
0.0148854051,
-0.0162864774,
0.0348686725,
0.0212837458,
0.0009855859,
-0.0006909821,
-0.0065149083,
-0.0494192429,
0.0090765506,
0.065307349,
0.0486813709,
0.0212678164,
0.0201131441,
-0.0378129035,
0.0486924686,
-0.0169249326,
0.0000125788,
-0.0420336127,
-0.0624345243,
-0.0354413241,
0.0132762212,
-0.0530974045,
-0.0094987415,
-0.019164063,
-0.0427746028,
0.0579298735,
-0.0206717681,
-0.0489393584,
-0.0055241715,
-0.0177500229,
-0.0057544722,
0.0318763144,
-0.0210300498,
-0.026192328,
0.0183299538,
-0.0274853911,
-0.0074551092,
-0.0039425348,
0.0026211871,
0.0219192635,
0.007786023,
0.0164720584,
0.0192297921,
-0.009753149,
-0.0220651869,
-0.0313650854,
-0.0136940191,
-0.030467879,
0.0437440164,
-0.0254187286,
-0.03972812,
-0.0043841307,
0.0093327221,
-0.0570195131,
0.0590088777,
0.011099956,
0.0065610292,
-0.0575185306,
-0.0350401402,
0.0023988835,
0.0240256581,
-0.0242529307,
-0.0007315155,
-0.0023504465,
0.0049258145,
-0.0502200797,
-0.0360988826,
0.0149798607,
-0.0004267051,
2.445e-7,
0.0297636874,
0.0007924879,
0.0357742235,
0.0210432857,
0.0027308932,
-0.0131891817,
0.0306105092,
-0.0201856866,
0.0152201094,
-0.0365266688,
0.0188224986,
0.0074862763,
0.0226669274,
0.0314063132,
-0.0800610408,
0.0153635796,
-0.0555050895,
-0.0469150208,
-0.0228414107,
-0.0026070697,
0.1190010309,
0.0049616382,
-0.004777079,
0.0002654883,
-0.0235979445,
-0.0028006157,
0.0273704156,
0.0449826121,
-0.0415037312,
0.0496876314,
0.0460876226,
-0.0115628885,
0.0117469151,
0.0662130043,
-0.026681263,
-0.0248194765,
0.0374781787,
0.0122751612,
0.0253343955,
-0.0382164456,
-0.0315055698,
0.0219312701,
0.0329392105,
-0.0482539088,
0.0406073667,
-0.0418056399,
0.0003721021,
0.0125281205,
-0.0230302364,
-0.0191131122,
-0.0209004544,
-0.0087360358,
-0.0005022809,
0.0081688073,
-0.0009498828,
-0.0149407275,
0.0343937427,
0.0051562544,
-0.0452872142,
0.0191410407,
-0.0381895751,
-0.0308179315,
-0.0274417643,
-0.0558311753,
-0.0382849611,
0.0111504085,
-0.0320214368,
1.878377984e-34,
0.0292076804,
0.0065806224,
0.0240269694,
0.0168536045,
0.0245060828,
0.0045879143,
-0.0219513867,
0.0016409672,
0.032885585,
-0.036336951,
-0.0128335003
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.03313v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.03313v1 | InfoSync: Information Synchronization across Multilingual Semi-structured Tables | 2023-07-06T21:55:15 | 2023-07-06T21:55:15 | Siddharth Khincha, Chelsi Jain, Vivek Gupta, Tushar Kataria, Shuo Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.IR | Information Synchronization of semi-structured data across languages is
challenging. For instance, Wikipedia tables in one language should be
synchronized across languages. To address this problem, we introduce a new
dataset InfoSyncC and a two-step method for tabular synchronization. InfoSync
contains 100K entity-centric tables (Wikipedia Infoboxes) across 14 languages,
of which a subset (3.5K pairs) are manually annotated. The proposed method
includes 1) Information Alignment to map rows and 2) Information Update for
updating missing/outdated information for aligned tables across multilingual
tables. When evaluated on InfoSync, information alignment achieves an F1 score
of 87.91 (en <-> non-en). To evaluate information updation, we perform
human-assisted Wikipedia edits on Infoboxes for 603 table pairs. Our approach
obtains an acceptance rate of 77.28% on Wikipedia, showing the effectiveness of
the proposed method. | [
0.0146786962,
0.0425529629,
-0.0214978363,
0.0054058717,
-0.029105708,
0.048140768,
-0.0208228808,
0.0560630746,
-0.0008249387,
0.0126772262,
-0.0329016,
-0.0162188653,
0.0269709434,
-0.0072949925,
0.0287406165,
0.0021101669,
0.0495946929,
0.0312420055,
-0.0671659708,
-0.0065513896,
-0.002976069,
-0.0018975893,
-0.0234587882,
-0.025410261,
0.0113545228,
-0.009272947,
-0.0687372386,
0.0180262886,
0.0268241074,
0.0112317335,
0.0081328945,
0.0892820731,
-0.0316109881,
0.0263093039,
0.0000019982,
-0.0117917974,
-0.0397018455,
-0.0041738525,
-0.0530731976,
0.0333451703,
-0.0046563572,
-0.0797013044,
-0.0343650877,
-0.0431183688,
0.0025395188,
-0.0231435951,
0.0552243702,
0.0248463787,
0.0450557992,
0.0299155805,
-0.0101892576,
0.0101677878,
0.0119841499,
-0.0069450163,
0.0722451285,
-0.0139296511,
0.0281608924,
0.0453017913,
-0.0401871949,
-0.0464753956,
0.0036840558,
0.0529061221,
-0.0148865869,
-0.0365404747,
0.0159711745,
-0.0091101592,
-0.0322045721,
-0.0198081397,
0.0242882781,
0.0572916307,
0.0527444147,
0.0089560635,
0.0117830485,
-0.0058350335,
0.0207660515,
0.0338111892,
-0.034725897,
-0.0470016263,
0.0070214374,
-0.0372922644,
0.0185313784,
-0.0806933343,
0.0097883418,
-0.0157602783,
-0.0065026586,
0.0569742993,
0.0330631547,
-0.0268504675,
-0.0258394927,
-0.026495954,
0.0269950964,
-0.080944933,
0.0085276328,
0.0298328251,
-0.0213955231,
-0.0104801496,
-0.0363150202,
-0.0342101417,
0.0396272875,
-0.063476339,
-0.0390297249,
0.0539208464,
0.0210169386,
0.0426438302,
0.0302114226,
0.0298431758,
-0.0257666707,
0.0157011766,
-0.0000710491,
-0.0062451181,
-0.039514821,
0.0189657956,
-0.0057608532,
-0.0041111275,
-0.0394121148,
0.0281724408,
-0.0176912863,
0.0154616693,
-0.0227949359,
0.0871551856,
0.0127561083,
-0.0324918814,
-0.0071975454,
-0.0174273979,
-0.0547782294,
0.0056736534,
-0.0143568348,
-0.0306466594,
-0.0392387547,
-0.0253738128,
0.0160929449,
-0.0387095548,
0.036094863,
-0.0319769718,
0.0117403027,
0.0347719379,
-0.0249541923,
0.0309486818,
-0.0453783758,
-0.0444570594,
0.0130416863,
-0.0203393344,
-0.0451357216,
-0.0689009577,
0.0632175282,
0.0204052366,
-0.016463574,
-0.0694142133,
-0.0134281069,
0.0110173728,
-0.0088842111,
0.0661176816,
-0.1041243523,
0.0461957194,
0.0142210573,
-0.0266063213,
-0.002781322,
0.0622953363,
0.0145499725,
-0.0594317243,
0.0221449267,
0.0074100024,
-0.0467531458,
0.0302015767,
0.010288449,
0.0379160456,
0.0364441909,
0.0531641617,
0.07669615,
0.0615777299,
-0.0184346344,
-0.0043609207,
0.0078893155,
0.0147566171,
0.0570112057,
-0.0043466557,
0.0222813636,
0.0536595136,
-0.0229646452,
-0.0070560225,
0.0138444202,
0.0212988518,
-0.0251875333,
0.044960916,
0.0553967394,
0.0179907251,
0.0469602011,
0.0293182768,
-0.0174263865,
0.0110409679,
0.0069736848,
0.0081726993,
0.0021850052,
-0.0263854861,
0.0301739164,
0.0091000674,
0.0266753025,
0.045816049,
-0.0018368643,
-0.0546043329,
0.0243328791,
0.0328066498,
-0.0104375891,
0.1417578906,
0.0542323142,
-0.0383756794,
-0.0538677908,
-0.010352415,
0.0373881571,
0.013642922,
0.0651610643,
-0.065233998,
-0.0098776231,
-0.0149508109,
-0.0561953746,
0.0336989835,
-0.0078015835,
-0.0121296998,
-0.010637193,
0.0457598381,
0.0018217316,
-0.0421344228,
-0.0220753085,
0.0119820051,
-0.0090480093,
0.0319871679,
-0.0651597753,
0.0293827225,
-0.0005549311,
0.0541306175,
-0.0274911541,
-0.0086348262,
0.0196691956,
0.0040018717,
0.0185909625,
-0.0002528472,
0.0461895615,
0.0208317712,
0.0765814707,
0.0164125785,
-0.0474490039,
-0.0257112663,
-0.0194636919,
-0.0404579863,
-0.043522846,
0.0009214791,
-0.0165690705,
0.0238046031,
0.0610752255,
-0.0042219805,
-0.0057302993,
0.0150347594,
0.0458400697,
0.0013073065,
0.0529042967,
0.0431929864,
-0.0827272385,
0.0503531732,
-0.0348436274,
0.014327053,
0.0403887816,
-0.003815772,
-0.0102043785,
0.001701072,
-0.011218478,
-0.0619817749,
0.0405004658,
-0.0941290557,
0.0068545514,
-0.0144238314,
0.0474103428,
0.0521991365,
0.0117682638,
-0.0165667273,
-0.0229081735,
-0.0453786887,
0.0067884671,
-0.0400156453,
0.0227458104,
0.0551162325,
0.0117152492,
0.0017137687,
-0.0446290933,
0.0011077995,
-0.0186912473,
0.005307531,
0.0277042575,
-0.0758156702,
-0.0383455455,
-0.0291617196,
-0.0422065668,
0.0036139314,
0.0518302731,
-0.0046511744,
-0.0331831872,
0.0194521938,
0.025711827,
0.0037670331,
-0.0160502773,
-0.0432370454,
0.0047395704,
-0.0500994846,
-0.0366664566,
0.0020639505,
0.0341569334,
0.0222193506,
0.0014902194,
-0.05497998,
0.0098343492,
-0.0059286999,
-0.0351581015,
0.0054125991,
-0.0231770687,
-0.0317137986,
0.0136379665,
0.0451145358,
-0.0746860951,
0.0312709771,
0.0035312537,
0.0373378843,
-0.0525753647,
0.0398783833,
0.0209615473,
-0.0332519971,
0.0372231081,
0.0020046504,
-0.00205498,
-0.0164885055,
0.0377715826,
-0.009499955,
0.0230509341,
-0.0267302971,
-0.0169151183,
-0.0727864727,
0.0245179087,
0.0486896634,
-0.0182975493,
0.0457815602,
-0.0139252814,
0.0349496044,
-0.0355127715,
-0.0305806473,
0.0205701701,
-0.0189775322,
0.0050778966,
-0.0324225351,
0.0607868396,
-0.0512476638,
0.0071850312,
-0.0211272929,
0.0342940018,
0.0536244027,
0.0404098257,
-0.0174493268,
-0.0121764634,
0.0071513522,
0.0181696676,
0.0096048219,
-0.0705833584,
-0.0178949833,
0.0006611368,
0.0484150946,
0.0101315249,
-0.0352179632,
0.0388631411,
0.0072697117,
0.0025414133,
-0.0593952872,
-0.0178638864,
-0.0419930778,
-0.0294716079,
-0.0227131099,
0.0347510614,
0.0842623264,
0.0090473555,
-0.0450797044,
-0.0275148395,
-0.0215330161,
-0.0150066586,
0.0231408868,
0.0098053804,
-0.103891924,
0.0040360591,
0.0053693256,
-0.0044252812,
0.0124467351,
-0.0619666539,
0.0086168228,
-0.042947717,
-0.0251200572,
-0.0043370752,
-0.0509740748,
-0.0921789259,
-0.0057004015,
0.0322714522,
-0.0045096753,
-0.0022855608,
0.0718465671,
0.0167494547,
0.0034172204,
-0.012743786,
-0.0348741598,
-0.0327385515,
-0.0477192961,
-0.0857594162,
0.0560996607,
0.0431490168,
0.0578347482,
0.0140796602,
-0.0075031286,
0.0073401001,
0.0618924797,
-0.0274470672,
-0.0092860451,
0.0813258514,
0.0037538405,
-0.0237230342,
-0.0011585839,
-0.031476777,
-0.0033912717,
-0.0066820011,
0.0253765136,
0.0465350822,
-0.0125328498,
0.0520819873,
0.0415769666,
-0.0537674576,
0.013135734,
0.0323161669,
0.0259784907,
-0.018304782,
0.0141521739,
-0.0282482207,
-0.0140909748,
-0.0449174754,
0.0514418036,
0.0452947691,
-0.0713604987,
-0.0670571849,
-0.0873521417,
-0.0559630245,
0.0301315226,
-0.0047028512,
0.0548727848,
0.033649683,
0.0179361831,
-0.0381913371,
-0.0572499894,
-0.0591705143,
-0.0234327447,
-0.0023398937,
-0.0052259895,
-0.0541504733,
-0.0494512543,
-0.0062312772,
0.0024471958,
-0.0023712544,
-0.0176904257,
-0.0231844876,
0.0233516265,
0.0090265824,
0.011348174,
-0.0001577305,
0.0251294747,
-0.020998748,
-0.0356215499,
0.0430654474,
-0.0412316173,
-0.0291417036,
-0.0484874435,
-0.016226409,
0.0037550996,
0.0325460248,
-0.0480148681,
-0.0693474188,
-0.0213176496,
0.0143972198,
0.0355827361,
0.024926722,
0.0184920914,
0.0567442663,
-0.0210564919,
0.0070728972,
-0.0493219234,
-0.021159064,
0.0634544343,
-0.0260396041,
-0.0271609984,
0.0489198267,
0.0075399973,
0.0044372128,
-0.0159005485,
0.0089940848,
0.0810500532,
0.032266926,
-0.034843035,
-0.0424197279,
-0.0415738411,
-0.0203350112,
0.01342081,
0.0340952165,
-0.0160505977,
-0.0163297318,
0.0080457088,
0.0112801054,
0.0077447719,
-0.0378244631,
-0.0221782923,
0.0393414274,
-0.0380284265,
-0.0154094305,
0.047483623,
-0.0274841953,
-0.0310341697,
-0.0192712639,
-0.0175289158,
0.0699117333,
0.0462783687,
0.0453807451,
-0.0161797944,
-0.0490441248,
0.0119323693,
-0.0141706001,
0.0462215953,
0.0082918033,
0.0003067593,
0.01126552,
-0.0046268953,
0.0213984884,
0.053217262,
-0.0368849523,
0.0252503809,
-0.0358468182,
-0.0528384745,
-0.0285892431,
0.0310585517,
-0.0268999431,
-0.0099218916,
-0.0678695068,
-0.0856958032,
-0.0084801354,
-0.0216166954,
0.0288143456,
0.0800352395,
-0.0480782278,
0.0284999665,
0.0136324987,
0.0331602693,
0.0488608554,
0.0077200872,
-0.0048278691,
0.0230150297,
-0.0399974212,
-0.0299072582,
-0.00286961,
-6.072447329e-33,
-0.0494133271,
-0.0150405765,
-0.0068803434,
-0.0027792617,
-0.0033347844,
-0.0431231707,
-0.0438494533,
0.0009583784,
-0.0136660496,
0.0332100429,
-0.0175279398,
0.0529029518,
0.0254414827,
-0.0417876057,
0.0443674512,
-0.0622683391,
0.0304930266,
0.0159077123,
-0.023071656,
-0.0095641017,
0.0202635843,
0.0327681638,
0.047167819,
-0.0485996008,
0.0859193131,
-0.0216526315,
0.0325809009,
0.0053414437,
0.011494901,
0.0027471383,
-0.0145934448,
0.0337004624,
0.0114501538,
-0.019073924,
-0.0097144907,
-0.0247500185,
-0.1107705906,
-0.0019306766,
0.0114751216,
0.0619681403,
0.0127351312,
-0.0146219274,
0.0443119816,
-0.0011317673,
-0.0357852988,
0.0314964578,
0.0239281319,
-0.0218428914,
0.008017024,
0.026960969,
-0.0179895647,
0.0050181136,
-0.0132649662,
0.0142576387,
0.0308557674,
0.0368742123,
0.0590270236,
-0.0720974132,
-0.0927150398,
0.0232432224,
-0.0073567503,
0.0335239768,
0.0758252665,
-0.0364740863,
0.0206531342,
0.0457768552,
0.002291562,
0.0194991119,
0.0006039305,
0.0485110767,
-0.0542084314,
0.015747834,
0.0290686004,
0.0386356413,
-0.0208233129,
-0.0120631494,
-0.0403982028,
0.0656995475,
-0.0144537473,
-0.0051307613,
-0.0392722934,
0.0162764639,
-0.0218811799,
-0.0177929103,
0.0060593146,
0.0028770419,
-0.0202686414,
-0.0359804742,
0.0006173211,
-0.0306980629,
0.03345754,
0.0208363906,
-0.0138395438,
0.0104491785,
-0.0588526204,
0.0222352911,
-0.0153028276,
0.0289034899,
-0.0012138059,
-0.0386352018,
0.0114391912,
-0.0201540552,
-0.0233156756,
0.0112994136,
0.0504711233,
0.051881332,
0.0246225167,
0.0243139397,
-0.052928891,
0.0066950065,
-0.0147001501,
0.0000797452,
-0.0225485545,
-0.0499249324,
0.024237223,
0.0034001444,
0.0220674612,
0.0268385243,
0.081481196,
-0.0191772524,
0.0047026193,
-0.0364556499,
0.0104123419,
0.0030899935,
0.0600905754,
0.0234940536,
-0.037284337,
0.0240372121,
0.0012304501,
0.007262188,
0.0120977033,
0.007571972,
2.681e-7,
0.076812163,
0.0161005985,
0.0645586774,
-0.0004364829,
0.0193412881,
-0.0072322283,
-0.0631704703,
0.0063122828,
-0.06188187,
-0.0128621813,
0.0505334213,
-0.0109916199,
0.0491093174,
0.0415239148,
-0.0454091355,
-0.0723732784,
-0.0376343578,
-0.0331576094,
-0.0686259717,
0.013817505,
0.018359188,
-0.0032688142,
-0.0280649122,
0.0252035521,
0.01319513,
0.0045930613,
-0.0021383052,
-0.0614751242,
0.0161209758,
0.0308174696,
0.029787302,
-0.0154228574,
-0.0208246894,
0.0682504848,
-0.0450592302,
-0.0312074106,
0.0043908092,
-0.0042186524,
-0.0273453798,
0.0786750168,
-0.0093648471,
-0.0934910253,
0.022134196,
-0.0457419306,
0.0453063212,
0.0193255059,
0.0059696203,
0.1042310372,
-0.0325264335,
0.0130024897,
0.0418896228,
0.0091036763,
-0.0224829894,
0.0000701331,
0.0184449255,
0.0437117666,
-0.030042043,
-0.0081055714,
-0.0251648258,
0.0187349413,
-0.00395892,
-0.0131226871,
-0.0244430341,
-0.0453458205,
-0.0096251043,
-0.0426000543,
-0.0105590448,
1.940052407e-34,
0.0014277033,
0.0058129397,
0.0346998684,
0.0308388099,
0.057796441,
-0.0538479947,
-0.0073596472,
0.0028100447,
-0.0258020051,
-0.0210255049,
-0.0126778902
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.04804v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.04804v2 | S2vNTM: Semi-supervised vMF Neural Topic Modeling | 2023-07-06T21:44:31 | 2024-02-08T11:09:53 | Weijie Xu, Jay Desai, Srinivasan Sengamedu, Xiaoyu Jiang, Francis Iannacci | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T50, I.2.7 | Language model based methods are powerful techniques for text classification.
However, the models have several shortcomings. (1) It is difficult to integrate
human knowledge such as keywords. (2) It needs a lot of resources to train the
models. (3) It relied on large text data to pretrain. In this paper, we propose
Semi-Supervised vMF Neural Topic Modeling (S2vNTM) to overcome these
difficulties. S2vNTM takes a few seed keywords as input for topics. S2vNTM
leverages the pattern of keywords to identify potential topics, as well as
optimize the quality of topics' keywords sets. Across a variety of datasets,
S2vNTM outperforms existing semi-supervised topic modeling methods in
classification accuracy with limited keywords provided. S2vNTM is at least
twice as fast as baselines. | [
0.0405924879,
0.0072055678,
0.013545746,
0.0297996923,
-0.01925667,
-0.0103557883,
-0.0116192289,
0.027502412,
-0.0375934727,
-0.0858698785,
-0.04006375,
-0.0303912312,
-0.0733918548,
0.0445928723,
0.0085439244,
-0.0125782201,
0.0560888164,
-0.0173713155,
0.0146023668,
0.0100242058,
0.0029596875,
0.0243727807,
0.011969096,
-0.0384626985,
-0.0204154346,
0.0025423996,
-0.022504149,
-0.0120181805,
-0.0096793193,
-0.0143285012,
0.0337510183,
0.0390331484,
0.0348802991,
-0.0061335149,
0.0000019178,
-0.0284722783,
-0.0225364938,
-0.0367774926,
0.0104996143,
0.0562319979,
0.0730091408,
-0.0226969048,
0.012379894,
0.0282231346,
-0.0145529173,
-0.028910175,
-0.0243538953,
0.0866464972,
0.0852275118,
0.0614037998,
-0.0234955549,
0.0378994942,
0.0127867125,
-0.0442587622,
0.0284783579,
-0.0674248412,
0.0182395931,
0.00882266,
0.0003459851,
0.0691598654,
-0.0121129043,
0.0379865393,
-0.0146375084,
0.0002628471,
0.0946170613,
0.0286800712,
-0.0567726716,
-0.0276132282,
0.01479661,
0.063323617,
-0.0144508369,
-0.0415406674,
0.0308978837,
-0.0280694459,
-0.0682978183,
0.0157791805,
-0.0180340782,
0.0061963014,
-0.0102265971,
0.0302737746,
0.0449878611,
0.0016705543,
0.0398776308,
0.0285916515,
0.0139520243,
0.003656084,
-0.017369777,
-0.0292036142,
-0.0289984234,
-0.0252755415,
-0.014648471,
-0.0230274331,
0.0112903509,
0.0162095539,
0.015018261,
0.0037175815,
-0.0152052613,
-0.0399079807,
0.0368412212,
-0.0994284898,
-0.0425340608,
-0.0144718047,
-0.0338743255,
0.0529682152,
-0.0045135878,
-0.0324461572,
-0.0208358783,
-0.0100676687,
-0.0707431659,
-0.0252939779,
-0.024194764,
-0.0056799781,
-0.0141743589,
0.0492722392,
0.0455551073,
-0.023679791,
-0.0038455098,
0.0309756901,
0.0085963923,
-0.008655753,
-0.0066903844,
0.0150884427,
-0.0321029685,
-0.0202138238,
-0.0375270136,
0.0196390282,
-0.0187462661,
0.0331092328,
-0.0746490657,
0.0321505703,
0.0222924892,
0.0159639549,
0.0285471994,
0.0067852638,
0.033943411,
0.023250971,
-0.0318272114,
-0.0768640861,
-0.0687348247,
-0.0064956006,
-0.0074661877,
0.0019703209,
0.0442143418,
-0.0465947799,
-0.0334115587,
0.0061595687,
0.0090189688,
0.0349459313,
0.0197207741,
0.036972627,
-0.0311150365,
0.0699471012,
-0.0301108118,
0.0075623076,
0.0929458216,
0.0366643108,
0.0599129982,
0.0485626012,
-0.0123449937,
0.0603711344,
0.0447044335,
-0.0029089362,
-0.0014000122,
-0.0237175319,
0.0361217931,
-0.0125109339,
-0.0260220878,
0.0056798309,
0.0146371676,
0.0003434482,
0.0165630281,
0.0561029762,
0.0060928385,
-0.0024889421,
0.0199259166,
0.0658452958,
-0.0013848653,
0.0395119898,
0.0058406377,
0.0507535562,
-0.0297801718,
-0.0251745787,
0.0210259333,
0.0054139942,
-0.0228680968,
-0.0223402437,
0.0732148588,
-0.0439430736,
-0.0653372481,
-0.0492721237,
-0.0121328393,
-0.0267164689,
0.0374452323,
-0.0299187321,
0.0734640136,
0.0192049947,
0.0117362197,
0.0312574841,
0.0337719359,
0.0069844513,
0.0043904954,
-0.0259846393,
0.0545158722,
0.0114584677,
0.0592059754,
-0.0525119491,
0.0061969603,
-0.0513185114,
0.0289862733,
0.0172769632,
0.0426878184,
0.0031670551,
-0.0266727563,
-0.0505177453,
0.0105805555,
-0.0363391265,
0.0542415939,
-0.0157820899,
-0.0180999003,
-0.0030911993,
0.030824773,
-0.0374420956,
0.0096622175,
0.0323079154,
0.0220058877,
-0.0167158656,
0.0407267138,
-0.0184676237,
0.0666057169,
0.0137863234,
-0.0183182713,
0.012347037,
0.0387388133,
-0.0238690246,
-0.0625757053,
-0.0622847714,
-0.0095610581,
-0.024099404,
0.0166052543,
0.0018690131,
0.0537042469,
-0.0129467128,
-0.0107182758,
-0.0128513873,
0.0150494138,
-0.0236355923,
-0.0171108413,
-0.0681039244,
-0.0008295604,
-0.0152599681,
-0.0020850052,
-0.0110733276,
0.0308751781,
0.0117275482,
0.0518143661,
-0.0453333072,
-0.0213001091,
0.0236990396,
-0.0139016593,
-0.0044043064,
0.0133166742,
-0.0484604053,
0.0237259157,
0.0081481673,
0.0108541213,
0.002574208,
-0.0218104757,
-0.1068415418,
0.0200815536,
-0.0141999675,
-0.0053603705,
-0.0250868183,
0.0033979556,
0.001211888,
-0.0004822379,
-0.013665311,
-0.023698017,
0.0001092911,
-0.0221362989,
0.0283846352,
-0.0222093873,
0.06043135,
-0.0505091324,
-0.0167518891,
-0.0317028835,
0.0536429174,
-0.0160479508,
-0.0261605997,
-0.0167685337,
0.0478856973,
-0.0236961618,
-0.0037443524,
-0.0328205749,
0.0077843592,
-0.0150431804,
-0.0532256402,
0.0339246616,
-0.0159289744,
0.0412954465,
-0.0039685681,
0.045519352,
-0.0053003565,
-0.0425970964,
0.0153430225,
-0.0131148426,
0.0302555617,
0.0256902371,
-0.0274188407,
0.016120255,
0.0679356605,
-0.0112040183,
-0.00336897,
-0.0428649969,
0.018773783,
-0.0060589835,
0.0374446064,
-0.0504309982,
0.0016706048,
0.0212339349,
-0.0006402571,
-0.0311494339,
-0.0646522641,
0.040415708,
-0.0384026803,
0.0308209229,
-0.0700526163,
-0.0398869552,
-0.0592491105,
0.0241272748,
0.0214277394,
0.0068892012,
0.0160832424,
0.0322546475,
0.0123685468,
-0.00789876,
-0.0073645697,
-0.0156740621,
0.0420076475,
-0.0127635319,
0.0349563994,
-0.0124144182,
0.0133247254,
-0.0316394493,
-0.084896706,
0.0029345739,
0.0114786858,
-0.0011525318,
0.0405899025,
0.0241332818,
0.00985358,
-0.0089029772,
0.045313295,
-0.0087444624,
-0.0069866204,
-0.0028821831,
0.0314047188,
0.0411061756,
-0.0688288882,
-0.0696128085,
-0.012606916,
0.00586646,
0.0127875516,
0.0321522132,
0.0118403323,
-0.0180621594,
0.0035208298,
0.0165605806,
-0.0351362079,
-0.0382815525,
-0.0107004801,
0.0064413296,
-0.0035763024,
-0.0069194725,
0.1038734987,
0.0474071503,
-0.0751862749,
-0.0142509751,
-0.0381516591,
-0.048335772,
0.024699321,
0.016117353,
-0.039445024,
-0.0056742309,
-0.0299200322,
0.0297715571,
0.0192953143,
0.0311282966,
-0.0206831098,
-0.0193278901,
0.0035049105,
-0.0033329569,
-0.05257136,
0.0041730884,
-0.0978984982,
-0.029721817,
-0.0314720571,
-0.0683946684,
-0.0246644784,
-0.0209141672,
-0.0074758562,
0.0130612981,
-0.0695973188,
-0.0574382134,
0.0229734145,
-0.0504572317,
0.0519977733,
0.0147345597,
0.0126172975,
-0.0298886355,
0.022943629,
0.0210528318,
-0.0255096648,
-0.0134012178,
-0.0430987962,
0.0433079973,
-0.0545170754,
0.0037298719,
0.0087634195,
0.024520047,
-0.0109129976,
-0.0281320158,
-0.0154074896,
0.0737212971,
-0.0534845591,
-0.0205102321,
-0.0430567935,
-0.0227409154,
-0.0388172902,
0.0488051847,
0.0021872027,
-0.0484582037,
0.0409775265,
0.0301679429,
0.0352707691,
0.0339225978,
-0.0379045308,
-0.0587708987,
-0.0312138032,
-0.0792121962,
-0.0206752494,
-0.0369284973,
0.0000860603,
0.0035973582,
-0.0252531972,
0.0538567342,
0.0119089205,
-0.028181579,
-0.0500687435,
0.0553925335,
-0.0200596247,
0.0061783949,
-0.0225282237,
-0.0433334485,
0.0898605213,
-0.0581976809,
-0.010763281,
-0.0474386923,
-0.0693159923,
-0.0263020694,
-0.0455248468,
0.0350223854,
0.000774071,
0.0146861244,
-0.0074359686,
-0.0413477197,
0.0420821011,
0.0395012684,
-0.0305188708,
-0.0130605493,
0.0000212881,
-0.0000142324,
-0.0082063312,
-0.0153401438,
-0.0424429663,
0.0457096137,
-0.0052461727,
0.0239029247,
-0.0589811467,
-0.0249966756,
-0.0357575975,
-0.0109489653,
0.1139598712,
0.0066819787,
-0.0125275319,
-0.0847700685,
-0.0117257042,
0.0264742598,
0.0048571159,
-0.0297533553,
0.0256413184,
0.0348963439,
-0.0016189928,
-0.0588871203,
-0.0014490701,
-0.080199033,
0.0582045428,
0.049045831,
0.0010105876,
-0.0063296771,
0.0295916721,
-0.0434334353,
0.0156698171,
-0.0004119103,
0.0025129137,
0.0098154945,
-0.0229655039,
-0.0306723528,
0.0394064225,
-0.0163309406,
0.0147045981,
-0.0378361419,
0.0097999722,
-0.0246727299,
-0.0117813414,
-0.0428788178,
0.0606184714,
0.0746812746,
-0.0289882775,
0.0031149525,
-0.0073581473,
-0.0091059571,
-0.0423864834,
0.0632934719,
0.0181139056,
-0.0140122771,
0.0302199647,
0.0349911116,
-0.0298891347,
0.0384370051,
0.0437472463,
0.0263666678,
0.0065720202,
0.0261529759,
-0.0448071808,
-0.047427319,
0.0377491154,
0.0625134334,
0.0503922068,
-0.0446853787,
0.0224202927,
-0.0061364705,
-0.0136282891,
0.0499063469,
-0.0325892791,
-0.021089172,
-0.0118404385,
0.0537314974,
0.0859440491,
-0.0052078743,
0.0258572176,
-0.0634111837,
0.0000291526,
0.0016953468,
-0.0217728522,
-0.0397043489,
-6.552288531e-33,
-0.0078219557,
0.0102243293,
0.0119141359,
0.0324537493,
0.0078698583,
0.0456881747,
-0.015830325,
0.0136000309,
0.0014258655,
-0.0146737834,
-0.0004881971,
0.0333808139,
-0.0080327587,
0.0079577435,
0.0069019911,
-0.0181650929,
0.0602497198,
-0.0243732259,
0.0162814576,
0.0199644249,
-0.0264889617,
0.0508201532,
0.0280189589,
-0.0871192068,
0.0300704036,
-0.0145224668,
0.0274294037,
0.0093488544,
0.0670825392,
0.0216050744,
-0.0530676469,
0.0628719851,
0.0646230653,
-0.0404583178,
0.0242238324,
0.0308299828,
-0.0202265773,
-0.0388096236,
-0.0398475863,
-0.0367268883,
-0.0126919877,
-0.02154346,
0.0165131558,
0.0266721062,
0.0007652208,
0.0389599912,
0.1072997898,
0.0065937173,
-0.0434363447,
-0.0722327679,
-0.0063369325,
0.0444733277,
0.019278992,
-0.0290697012,
0.0114341127,
-0.0092432881,
0.0020600844,
0.0518271588,
-0.0137572866,
-0.0032617047,
0.0146496799,
0.0335124321,
0.0013640225,
-0.0207192749,
-0.0240659993,
0.0339118466,
0.0136007648,
0.0159015786,
-0.0315889344,
0.0396629907,
0.0413753018,
0.0372728668,
0.0390993357,
-0.0006721286,
0.0480652936,
0.0208449028,
-0.0388120897,
0.0493643917,
0.0114749102,
0.0430623144,
0.0048146695,
0.0252958369,
-0.0051423595,
-0.0131683461,
-0.0393143855,
-0.0281273294,
-0.0330170318,
-0.0279750824,
0.0021292351,
0.0362610221,
-0.0185260195,
0.0244248062,
0.019621864,
-0.0183804408,
-0.031331297,
0.0615292639,
0.0017333789,
0.0065326784,
-0.0065841842,
0.0125170164,
-0.0949509293,
-0.0496063754,
0.004408502,
-0.0223865211,
-0.0135769676,
-0.0031243905,
-0.024330847,
0.0034097126,
-0.0274811145,
-0.0154191023,
0.0187018253,
-0.0852428079,
-0.028844595,
0.0836870074,
-0.0098675014,
0.0100121852,
0.0055318605,
0.0746765062,
0.0290813893,
0.0181446541,
0.0099705877,
-0.0697238445,
-0.0185428225,
0.0300900508,
0.0270805918,
0.0342624784,
-0.0172018446,
0.0293751713,
0.0103684356,
-0.058063142,
0.0065644849,
-0.0085971858,
2.582e-7,
0.0611067824,
0.0674260035,
-0.0437429734,
-0.0159779713,
-0.0128357373,
0.0580895431,
-0.0429208428,
0.0417178273,
-0.0126905618,
0.0085029593,
0.0458131917,
0.0535555147,
0.0002903382,
0.0435164683,
-0.0698508024,
0.0035471132,
-0.0764226317,
0.027899649,
-0.0467333831,
-0.0202720314,
0.049956914,
0.0878533125,
0.0399816073,
-0.0258271508,
-0.0081422776,
-0.0287022367,
0.0602779761,
-0.0151200453,
-0.0499372929,
0.063443467,
0.0429050103,
0.0913104042,
-0.0204328336,
-0.0222073365,
-0.0415906496,
0.0119487206,
0.0277866889,
0.0597740933,
-0.0121178925,
-0.0032467914,
0.0331864245,
0.0118048359,
-0.0130462563,
0.000267867,
0.087257728,
-0.0299411174,
0.0005372781,
-0.00547241,
-0.009358963,
0.0356993899,
0.056113515,
-0.0154328998,
-0.038645383,
0.0040202113,
0.0036051483,
-0.0385266021,
-0.043081142,
-0.0876630023,
-0.0044598626,
0.0135589689,
-0.0447592214,
0.0228685755,
-0.0337389633,
0.0356433839,
0.064208895,
0.0109224934,
0.0359043367,
1.964460675e-34,
0.040624477,
-0.0349903703,
-0.0582663715,
0.0035234259,
-0.0428500324,
0.0124888169,
-0.0367141701,
0.0037748739,
-0.0322296955,
-0.0160196014,
0.0214133598
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.03296v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.03296v2 | Gammatonegram Representation for End-to-End Dysarthric Speech Processing Tasks: Speech Recognition, Speaker Identification, and Intelligibility Assessment | 2023-07-06T21:10:50 | 2024-03-20T19:08:06 | Aref Farhadipour, Hadi Veisi | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | Dysarthria is a disability that causes a disturbance in the human speech
system and reduces the quality and intelligibility of a person's speech.
Because of this effect, the normal speech processing systems can not work
properly on impaired speech. This disability is usually associated with
physical disabilities. Therefore, designing a system that can perform some
tasks by receiving voice commands in the smart home can be a significant
achievement. In this work, we introduce gammatonegram as an effective method to
represent audio files with discriminative details, which is used as input for
the convolutional neural network. On the other word, we convert each speech
file into an image and propose image recognition system to classify speech in
different scenarios. Proposed CNN is based on the transfer learning method on
the pre-trained Alexnet. In this research, the efficiency of the proposed
system for speech recognition, speaker identification, and intelligibility
assessment is evaluated. According to the results on the UA dataset, the
proposed speech recognition system achieved 91.29% accuracy in
speaker-dependent mode, the speaker identification system acquired 87.74%
accuracy in text-dependent mode, and the intelligibility assessment system
achieved 96.47% accuracy in two-class mode. Finally, we propose a multi-network
speech recognition system that works fully automatically. This system is
located in a cascade arrangement with the two-class intelligibility assessment
system, and the output of this system activates each one of the speech
recognition networks. This architecture achieves an accuracy of 92.3% WRR. The
source code of this paper is available. | [
-0.0294158813,
0.0082047302,
0.0040798094,
0.0651551113,
-0.0105872648,
-0.0124787772,
0.0984632671,
-0.0164530966,
-0.0028610227,
-0.0187602397,
-0.0570058301,
0.0113709942,
0.0240266789,
0.0041700266,
-0.0079881651,
-0.0352923349,
0.0193923321,
0.0160404928,
0.0184334945,
-0.0582305603,
0.0013934033,
-0.0138319321,
-0.0817536339,
0.0310799386,
-0.0349133499,
-0.0023812833,
0.0125104198,
0.0416743159,
0.03097938,
-0.0195003767,
-0.0051507899,
0.0235143527,
-0.0001306433,
0.0450134687,
0.0000019645,
-0.0297788549,
-0.020407863,
-0.0169432126,
-0.0338709205,
-0.0289741904,
0.0041188383,
0.0405224375,
-0.0221713819,
0.0067372965,
0.0040112948,
-0.0453990586,
0.0469599739,
0.0728034824,
-0.0013627385,
0.0641372427,
-0.0197009668,
-0.0424293093,
0.0582407489,
0.0064771287,
-0.0144182108,
-0.0233043674,
0.0046823518,
0.0105002495,
0.0030067284,
-0.0405033864,
0.0183947869,
0.0708988085,
-0.0114886323,
0.0187375825,
0.0383789055,
-0.0298173875,
0.003565432,
-0.0024768233,
-0.0313940383,
0.0719523132,
-0.038697049,
0.0229761787,
0.0143487966,
-0.0179109145,
0.0047915545,
-0.0148842763,
-0.0160801634,
-0.0370708592,
0.0160547607,
-0.0014468788,
-0.0414004549,
0.0201400239,
-0.0054014111,
-0.0247751363,
0.0030403631,
0.0097094718,
0.004303419,
0.0126235867,
-0.0057991575,
-0.0243071541,
0.0102936877,
0.0096295364,
0.0598607883,
-0.0101195006,
-0.0080029517,
-0.0311269239,
-0.0177806467,
-0.0730683953,
-0.0256258547,
-0.018945301,
-0.0416345447,
0.0078624673,
-0.0672195479,
0.0212802812,
-0.0302599687,
0.054425139,
-0.0174594391,
0.0105953775,
-0.0365324728,
0.0076470748,
-0.0146295363,
0.0235605594,
-0.0622557178,
0.0350860842,
0.0551061891,
-0.0415387452,
-0.0534482598,
-0.0193628315,
-0.043240115,
-0.0187506974,
0.0018716187,
0.0383974798,
-0.0384331755,
0.0110548157,
0.0190023854,
0.0371363685,
-0.0092723165,
0.0514520034,
-0.0097286031,
-0.0568335764,
0.012756261,
0.0156405605,
0.0585216358,
0.0225097798,
0.0156042036,
0.0350571126,
0.0103344275,
-0.0419101231,
-0.0171354786,
0.005875886,
-0.0170879364,
0.0023773308,
0.0538517833,
-0.0728809685,
0.0157713275,
0.0210909937,
0.0054337303,
-0.0459007137,
-0.0197294168,
-0.020570565,
0.007709804,
0.0401224867,
-0.0061856923,
0.0099781062,
0.0886586457,
-0.0173599776,
-0.0251163598,
-0.0200783163,
0.0666554719,
-0.0504018106,
0.0035235288,
-0.0453385487,
0.0076486631,
0.0281187464,
-0.024658408,
0.0143017005,
-0.0391416214,
-0.0413436927,
-0.0261266865,
0.0177630298,
0.013013253,
0.0034196132,
0.0205627363,
-0.0171299167,
0.0521208942,
0.0376623832,
0.0407749452,
0.0262044854,
-0.031061057,
0.0069070682,
0.0199098121,
-0.0403919555,
0.0381562337,
0.0261464398,
0.0125831179,
-0.0289149564,
-0.0219563339,
-0.0047825775,
-0.0241184477,
-0.0001933951,
0.0233251732,
-0.0515876412,
0.0126187699,
0.0243464597,
0.0446093716,
-0.0195062775,
-0.0428558625,
-0.0097443014,
0.0024066358,
-0.054294657,
-0.0431621969,
-0.0554800779,
0.0209723469,
0.0297852997,
0.0225462001,
-0.0415230207,
0.0260069687,
-0.0253388323,
-0.0426008701,
-0.0444768257,
-0.010833825,
0.0391287021,
0.0092231408,
-0.0419926085,
-0.0595499836,
0.0310632996,
-0.0370990187,
0.0768989921,
-0.0763679147,
0.0429659784,
0.0293747913,
0.0260202754,
-0.0023240261,
-0.0179772712,
0.0463679656,
-0.0257263947,
0.0042439327,
0.0167138502,
0.0697800815,
0.0156332795,
-0.0113153169,
-0.0202116612,
0.0114182374,
-0.0504523069,
-0.0011439582,
0.0185631011,
-0.0787386447,
-0.0169418752,
0.0576076135,
-0.0603351071,
0.051922597,
0.0849887207,
0.0111155501,
-0.0771931782,
0.0236415733,
-0.0186423846,
0.0122046135,
-0.0177672766,
0.0300596319,
0.0339931026,
0.0462247729,
0.0122418003,
0.0010989321,
0.0339716189,
-0.0130151566,
-0.0451673456,
-0.0014996019,
0.0167133696,
-0.0568830781,
-0.0393129401,
0.012225219,
-0.018836569,
0.027697444,
-0.0094066253,
-0.0014076744,
-0.0120781185,
0.0151987914,
-0.0708997697,
-0.008982135,
-0.0224719718,
-0.031231543,
-0.0106176334,
-0.0159207601,
0.0001701757,
-0.05098591,
-0.0387566313,
0.0565689951,
0.0088863038,
-0.0440199003,
-0.0341191553,
-0.0022083155,
-0.0531469174,
0.001992852,
-0.0310543049,
0.0123728728,
0.0086463569,
-0.0042067268,
-0.0758503303,
0.0184180234,
-0.0074628545,
0.0501810685,
0.0471454449,
0.0017645193,
-0.0237047113,
-0.0084282607,
0.0317909196,
0.019623084,
0.009874397,
0.0360062718,
-0.0401764102,
-0.0123953363,
-0.0028716726,
-0.017569242,
0.0152238598,
0.0299299154,
0.0853821039,
0.0264483262,
0.0480742566,
-0.0493404567,
-0.0277371276,
0.0501177311,
0.0071006864,
0.0366155989,
-0.0463563837,
0.0142508289,
0.008808203,
-0.010647106,
-0.0312526003,
-0.0274506677,
-0.0170561317,
0.0461580418,
-0.0544958264,
-0.0318493098,
-0.0852370188,
-0.0410143025,
-0.0348721743,
-0.0529190935,
0.0279541295,
-0.0227428265,
0.0298322756,
0.032310687,
-0.0684457347,
-0.026366761,
-0.0204092618,
-0.011103238,
0.0121805528,
-0.0735061765,
0.0826210082,
-0.0018991299,
-0.0054679173,
-0.0519478805,
0.0174497832,
-0.0464505367,
0.0393132009,
-0.0304296166,
0.007483033,
-0.0073451856,
-0.0092087118,
-0.0302848425,
0.0429847576,
0.0322418511,
0.0492715761,
0.0271911621,
0.0299962088,
-0.0174034871,
0.0645932257,
0.0070649516,
0.0397725143,
-0.0153188007,
0.0332916826,
0.0141173238,
-0.0229126085,
0.0322617553,
0.0370401256,
-0.0733652487,
-0.0010340725,
0.0025422715,
0.0111161061,
-0.0231221952,
0.0079164663,
0.0219724812,
-0.0212067924,
0.0445896126,
0.068053402,
-0.0050968439,
-0.0888407752,
-0.0162704289,
0.0057039694,
-0.0785640627,
0.0013241188,
-0.0063138497,
-0.039801918,
-0.0488196313,
0.0427794978,
0.0225839876,
0.0059849964,
0.0444748476,
-0.0129038133,
0.0055092685,
0.0164069086,
0.0352777354,
0.026153218,
-0.0627023801,
0.0537803844,
-0.0031912324,
0.0352888927,
0.0412612967,
-0.0090848161,
0.0234582629,
-0.0458721817,
0.0191380959,
-0.0683642998,
0.0237126146,
0.0401031375,
0.0088106124,
0.0988734737,
0.048505988,
0.0197421573,
-0.021105431,
-0.0415780284,
0.0356189013,
-0.002660834,
0.007247794,
0.0003294746,
0.0473374054,
0.023929337,
-0.0237813406,
0.0659604967,
0.039104972,
-0.0372336656,
-0.011008027,
0.0326540209,
-0.0096253632,
-0.0142160468,
0.0010511052,
-0.0515212975,
0.0204114113,
0.0370723195,
0.0579052903,
-0.006581706,
0.0099188853,
-0.0323655717,
0.003661308,
0.0243138541,
0.0262966976,
0.0001416645,
0.0309800357,
0.0143351275,
-0.083073698,
-0.0297527779,
0.0210476648,
-0.008738705,
0.0235158987,
0.0285241343,
-0.0057452093,
0.0157680195,
0.0672510713,
-0.0227931589,
0.0184411425,
0.0110614561,
0.0471021533,
-0.0877257064,
-0.0338337459,
0.0386385545,
-0.0762355924,
-0.0241351388,
0.0599935837,
0.0151294684,
0.0308032222,
0.0535678677,
-0.0545120835,
0.0095165325,
0.0244502146,
-0.0379308537,
-0.014204599,
0.0718112066,
0.0069029736,
-0.0283502564,
0.0001271535,
0.0755242407,
0.0079315482,
-0.0204173476,
0.0339640491,
-0.0270558372,
0.0842119828,
-0.0167446863,
-0.0154025191,
-0.0223266315,
-0.0715387538,
-0.0344631821,
0.0310540106,
0.0343009941,
0.0188475307,
0.0287954416,
-0.0461758338,
0.0521922708,
0.0027220724,
0.0556420758,
-0.0481498167,
0.0050586369,
0.0066561704,
-0.007077402,
-0.0166331977,
-0.0254396088,
0.0051268511,
-0.0668871477,
0.016625803,
0.0925319716,
0.0169375669,
0.0213728454,
-0.0252553578,
-0.0291367359,
0.0027626099,
-0.0122972196,
0.0449225865,
0.0038156705,
0.005962993,
0.0363677442,
-0.0323786885,
-0.029103294,
-0.0205403734,
0.0343078338,
0.0005219,
0.0212915037,
0.0032629727,
0.0306574497,
0.0028481439,
0.0208075643,
-0.0107273525,
-0.0099238437,
0.0415728651,
-0.0515365526,
0.0110039432,
0.0010989263,
0.0262645632,
0.0380722284,
-0.0107039372,
-0.0089604985,
0.0313529819,
-0.0043404913,
-0.0238540415,
-0.0004287483,
-0.0439663082,
0.0063059903,
-0.0518183,
-0.0227168724,
-0.0641639978,
0.0393422693,
-0.0223999489,
0.0025370631,
0.0463647619,
-0.0410109498,
0.0129564516,
-0.0493749082,
0.0533102453,
-0.026731642,
0.0341505185,
-0.0502682962,
-0.0494345091,
-0.0106037911,
0.0480709784,
-0.0377728939,
-0.0464934148,
0.0303299073,
0.013109074,
-5.331081409e-33,
-0.0160474461,
-0.0168108754,
-0.0401107073,
0.0363469981,
-0.0002391182,
0.008772538,
0.0047338954,
0.0294196531,
-0.0307040531,
-0.0056425217,
-0.0055333171,
0.0021810415,
0.0425380506,
0.0229269806,
-0.0488687903,
-0.0356515273,
0.0538570099,
-0.0474108085,
0.0358885378,
0.0491906889,
0.0527264215,
0.0353431851,
0.047997456,
-0.0870181695,
-0.0553486347,
-0.0157231726,
-0.0125307422,
-0.0704789832,
-0.0056509278,
-0.0360141397,
0.0177342501,
0.0294964295,
-0.0197952092,
-0.0179853085,
0.0028387688,
0.0726693124,
-0.0596067756,
0.0083811292,
-0.0791598707,
0.0758178085,
-0.024623543,
-0.0339184366,
0.0563008077,
0.0249522869,
-0.043893218,
-0.0217353441,
0.0411613993,
-0.0254205819,
-0.0107514551,
-0.0228565354,
0.0013016656,
0.0415312164,
-0.0336037986,
-0.0173292831,
0.0221056882,
-0.0111829946,
-0.0018474816,
-0.0165776145,
-0.0807921886,
0.0093175601,
-0.0096318359,
0.0115873972,
0.0293292757,
0.0106024537,
0.0163864847,
0.0273462627,
0.0723105147,
-0.0786073878,
0.0595257543,
-0.054688964,
0.0070866384,
0.0730913281,
0.0491809174,
-0.033073768,
0.0526591539,
-0.0920587033,
-0.0700328127,
-0.0104044257,
0.0574361943,
-0.0100220749,
0.0221915711,
0.0156182162,
-0.0559732988,
0.0332924165,
-0.0171310883,
-0.0156000787,
-0.025125796,
0.0110471249,
0.0402796268,
-0.0302966256,
0.0091939336,
-0.0334477574,
0.038177073,
-0.0579989441,
0.0448867679,
0.0388838761,
-0.0230833795,
0.0198962763,
0.010326664,
-0.0291011892,
0.0099671995,
-0.049390018,
0.0567041747,
0.0558217205,
0.0343150981,
-0.0183572862,
0.0024079685,
0.0773539245,
-0.0441280827,
-0.0326509178,
0.0255011953,
0.0313055776,
-0.0055291047,
0.0174852367,
0.0087550711,
-0.027985543,
-0.0176056307,
0.047081098,
-0.0321256332,
-0.0126587152,
0.0027387841,
-0.0134044215,
-0.0048100622,
0.0173576213,
-0.0866722316,
-0.0035316742,
-0.0155706173,
-0.019044254,
0.060232833,
0.0020109077,
0.0143268788,
0.0244244374,
2.893e-7,
-0.0569565743,
0.0172816236,
0.007092773,
-0.0445264503,
0.0323777236,
0.0291175433,
-0.0019501563,
0.0065190527,
0.0153042655,
0.0409730598,
0.0208739508,
-0.0247083809,
0.068423219,
0.0157962404,
-0.0574749336,
0.0066575701,
-0.0156069817,
0.0576550923,
0.0021820043,
0.0793939307,
0.0287646204,
0.0282224528,
0.0071571772,
-0.0392025933,
0.0462684892,
-0.0763595849,
-0.0079333382,
-0.0038792677,
0.0832957253,
-0.0501628406,
0.0598931275,
0.0078119794,
0.0132072307,
0.0413722359,
-0.0207228046,
0.0645105913,
0.0206664875,
0.0319738612,
-0.0210779179,
-0.070162423,
0.0089775417,
0.0304218531,
0.0054512685,
0.0475469939,
0.0607643761,
0.0034942261,
-0.0162595734,
-0.0282948911,
-0.0323043764,
-0.0388788916,
0.0161653385,
0.0287365969,
0.0331180096,
-0.0398516059,
0.0114505645,
-0.0549100339,
-0.0429454781,
-0.0494287983,
0.0185546651,
0.0339464098,
-0.0783630162,
-0.0315712094,
-0.0061002159,
-0.0156563148,
0.0515751652,
-0.0146676339,
-0.0216959137,
1.790308891e-34,
-0.0369028263,
-0.0211314596,
-0.0133485869,
-0.033155445,
-0.0357069187,
-0.0295580085,
-0.0087618027,
0.0062385942,
0.0260434318,
-0.0258128177,
-0.0551105998
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.04765v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.04765v1 | Performance Comparison of Pre-trained Models for Speech-to-Text in Turkish: Whisper-Small and Wav2Vec2-XLS-R-300M | 2023-07-06T21:01:18 | 2023-07-06T21:01:18 | Oyku Berfin Mercan, Sercan Cepni, Davut Emre Tasar, Sukru Ozan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | In this study, the performances of the Whisper-Small and Wav2Vec2-XLS-R-300M
models which are two pre-trained multilingual models for speech to text were
examined for the Turkish language. Mozilla Common Voice version 11.0 which is
prepared in Turkish language and is an open-source data set, was used in the
study. The multilingual models, Whisper- Small and Wav2Vec2-XLS-R-300M were
fine-tuned with this data set which contains a small amount of data. The speech
to text performance of the two models was compared. WER values are calculated
as 0.28 and 0.16 for the Wav2Vec2-XLS- R-300M and the Whisper-Small models
respectively. In addition, the performances of the models were examined with
the test data prepared with call center records that were not included in the
training and validation dataset. | [
0.0132603953,
-0.0204358064,
-0.0001991694,
-0.0124747055,
-0.0248600338,
-0.0014548677,
0.0440004952,
0.0100937886,
-0.0302659199,
-0.0265581217,
-0.0612302609,
-0.0746452808,
0.0604834743,
0.0127687557,
0.0294744466,
-0.047212068,
0.0224031527,
-0.0700137764,
0.0305874757,
0.0018227039,
0.0269089527,
0.0327858552,
-0.0539093539,
0.0183601696,
-0.0368021131,
-0.0137185752,
0.0052370224,
-0.0131226433,
0.0064169229,
-0.0179703664,
0.0026980762,
-0.0168814864,
-0.0049412432,
-0.006547099,
0.0000023272,
-0.0521223173,
0.0026030336,
0.0328735337,
-0.0091483593,
-0.002390211,
0.0549872406,
0.0074654161,
-0.0478562824,
0.0065331636,
0.0120741427,
0.0327564403,
0.0226196274,
0.0516724922,
0.0403074473,
0.0726717785,
-0.0096481852,
-0.0656950474,
0.0573168918,
0.0325181298,
-0.0218611304,
-0.0436678715,
-0.0342058614,
-0.010322771,
-0.0426103249,
-0.0289283078,
0.0335836187,
0.0666554123,
-0.0335900374,
-0.0225610845,
-0.0528887287,
-0.0041886899,
-0.0495104454,
-0.0821381137,
0.0019654471,
0.0266761426,
-0.0224144571,
-0.0191806816,
0.0133956689,
0.0101958979,
-0.0217930228,
-0.0296216104,
-0.0170581173,
-0.0281534996,
0.0037478348,
-0.030020209,
-0.0135220783,
0.0743057579,
-0.0224495586,
-0.0689833611,
0.0015318951,
-0.0048768395,
0.0252909493,
-0.0506460927,
0.0400808342,
-0.0189838037,
0.0220357273,
0.0156249655,
0.0434373021,
0.0194767974,
-0.0314450674,
0.0060776491,
0.0022257131,
-0.092763342,
-0.0091331713,
-0.0913851857,
0.0621696934,
0.0285156611,
-0.0315085091,
-0.0407689214,
-0.0740740076,
0.0244419239,
0.0299788788,
-0.0280948859,
-0.0515168086,
-0.0067933635,
-0.0034481043,
0.001363736,
-0.0608238913,
0.0317810476,
-0.0353014991,
0.0110012991,
-0.0548730455,
-0.0351571701,
-0.0131652355,
-0.0153288413,
0.0192549992,
-0.0233463515,
-0.0436194427,
0.0063987859,
-0.0235418417,
-0.0073637054,
0.0053383452,
0.0438065827,
-0.0397401974,
-0.0586367995,
0.0693499446,
-0.0014168366,
0.0253065135,
0.0164766312,
0.0073460047,
0.0423577838,
-0.0290391967,
0.0030806074,
-0.0637626722,
0.0082745422,
-0.0214515198,
-0.0895974562,
-0.0375398621,
-0.0409690663,
0.0312103089,
0.0167839024,
-0.0017188712,
0.010436221,
-0.0227818564,
0.0082432507,
0.0175297409,
-0.0039679348,
0.0147113074,
0.0489585884,
0.0820383504,
-0.0265687741,
0.0452639386,
0.0656057894,
0.0527357385,
-0.0102068046,
-0.0089832405,
-0.0456752963,
-0.0152291236,
0.0538222268,
0.0284620095,
-0.0033666538,
0.0091551524,
0.0308637731,
0.0199175104,
0.0145668881,
0.0178891663,
0.0648679361,
0.0107117919,
0.0204310343,
0.0739239082,
0.0593696088,
0.0857393518,
0.0336806253,
0.0490941331,
0.0314561054,
0.0424203239,
-0.0188915581,
0.0374152251,
-0.0408031419,
-0.0297709797,
0.0313761868,
0.0359334871,
0.0411479995,
-0.0228194147,
-0.0374806672,
-0.0057544587,
-0.0104069989,
-0.0059344904,
-0.0112778321,
0.0509100407,
0.0100613609,
-0.0738109797,
0.0175959338,
0.0225285385,
-0.0617175438,
-0.013979204,
-0.0512152053,
0.0316655971,
-0.0147590321,
-0.0553399101,
0.0122329136,
0.0377507173,
-0.0527994521,
-0.0081426576,
0.0027341757,
0.037818823,
0.0034349258,
0.0272365715,
-0.0393113308,
0.0123999203,
0.0406837277,
-0.0009451889,
0.0180984624,
-0.0231162366,
0.070136033,
0.0306666326,
-0.0121824015,
-0.0112397345,
-0.0069668875,
0.0031568445,
0.0384892039,
-0.0180148445,
-0.0081142746,
0.0487954952,
0.063607581,
0.0011765497,
0.0242908131,
0.0165493321,
0.0020240641,
0.0315917619,
0.0050837584,
-0.062045373,
0.0099667227,
0.0455975719,
0.0343299583,
0.0390372425,
0.0350013338,
0.0449110195,
-0.0815307423,
0.0410811305,
-0.0193142686,
0.0793810263,
0.0028130119,
0.0539428107,
-0.0024685855,
0.0103358701,
0.0612946786,
-0.0157138985,
0.0357552841,
0.0001111182,
-0.0309818443,
0.0426212214,
0.0446853861,
-0.0367196798,
-0.0266236309,
0.0375041291,
-0.0595591255,
0.0288611855,
0.0080876425,
-0.0139827691,
-0.0265203957,
-0.0005598977,
-0.073066622,
-0.014949874,
-0.0028485651,
0.0096925767,
-0.0370578803,
0.0007936898,
-0.0016534626,
-0.0165158585,
-0.0268406291,
-0.0031683473,
0.0390910879,
-0.037098553,
-0.0276280995,
-0.003285802,
-0.012737371,
-0.0380266644,
-0.0090989834,
0.0070491834,
0.0008715168,
0.0093123233,
-0.03187057,
-0.0231869984,
0.0507791638,
0.0133451698,
-0.0097514931,
0.007637592,
-0.0582414083,
0.0169030149,
0.0360992923,
0.0863521174,
-0.0014871028,
0.0087410873,
-0.0220544077,
-0.0304906368,
0.0132924849,
-0.0313079171,
-0.0113084167,
0.0160620175,
-0.0248876028,
-0.0576564744,
-0.0004737589,
-0.0053769415,
0.0501325019,
0.0103113288,
0.0157575905,
-0.0277479179,
-0.0447312929,
-0.0420548283,
-0.027395267,
0.0035886951,
-0.009651863,
-0.0261107143,
0.0387618504,
0.0469052829,
-0.0094480468,
-0.0159926806,
-0.0823118538,
-0.0189276263,
-0.0594793819,
-0.0494404845,
-4.96e-8,
-0.0128542362,
-0.0387102924,
0.0169966985,
-0.0395880118,
-0.0256468989,
-0.0362556092,
-0.0038422467,
0.0123974113,
-0.0229907427,
0.015469647,
0.0186073873,
0.0057219644,
-0.0125896018,
0.0067229271,
-0.009578811,
-0.0184622742,
-0.0278190151,
0.0463909768,
0.063937515,
0.0081305727,
-0.0195546839,
0.0872268304,
-0.0160156265,
0.0208258908,
-0.0080183009,
0.0200064518,
-0.0070664729,
-0.0101840599,
0.0285282638,
-0.012342928,
-0.0277722944,
-0.0015848028,
0.0683499575,
-0.0210547335,
-0.0036754394,
-0.0057669887,
-0.0476010516,
-0.0235225633,
0.0039646938,
-0.0193613954,
-0.0287910812,
0.0143097676,
0.0382007547,
-0.0307531282,
0.0447441526,
0.0669899955,
-0.0311751831,
0.012557188,
-0.0315593854,
-0.0068198112,
0.015999468,
-0.004881822,
0.0311211161,
0.014791823,
0.0237192474,
0.0254571475,
0.0433069095,
0.0003265771,
0.0401684977,
0.0167188011,
-0.1155866832,
0.0159866679,
0.0038083026,
-0.088023901,
-0.0246210583,
-0.0576945022,
-0.0312418956,
-0.0014723298,
0.03877832,
0.0019821359,
-0.0311727133,
-0.020993486,
0.0574214086,
-0.1005344316,
-0.0348721445,
-0.0186593942,
-0.0257475488,
0.0576897338,
0.0510548092,
0.0317098051,
-0.0151596302,
0.0010020618,
0.0087955166,
0.0272984225,
0.0024542022,
0.007833004,
0.0106756799,
-0.0044416492,
-0.005214477,
-0.0254043527,
0.0135785136,
0.0293265004,
0.028781686,
0.0039312406,
-0.0006361514,
0.0138750877,
-0.0454751514,
0.0106387585,
0.0964249298,
0.0013234871,
0.0246565193,
-0.0036521151,
-0.0402688906,
-0.0058108885,
0.0397431962,
0.0163987037,
-0.0031662465,
-0.0285197645,
0.0241253451,
-0.0097081503,
-0.0447673909,
-0.0287913699,
-0.0133539243,
0.0021845161,
0.0494806841,
0.0203733072,
0.0769025311,
0.007779893,
0.0378688313,
0.0081237974,
-0.0444906913,
0.0372289568,
0.0474925674,
-0.070098713,
-0.0164983291,
0.0426937677,
-0.0437409207,
-0.0264441855,
-0.0596398897,
-0.0960610956,
-0.010730668,
0.0298837572,
0.0333352946,
0.0110747451,
0.017177837,
-0.0203284379,
-0.0426917709,
0.0756590292,
-0.0466596298,
-0.1209505796,
0.0087163188,
0.0335824676,
0.0343005434,
-0.0124736996,
0.0072413734,
-0.0096540805,
0.0464027524,
0.0136337969,
-0.0147661939,
-0.0025027778,
-0.0354660302,
-0.0201871879,
0.0474197343,
0.0019287036,
0.0071304371,
-0.0113204625,
-0.0400887467,
0.0275451038,
0.0025106238,
0.0412864983,
-0.0173809156,
0.0088961469,
0.006671079,
0.0357549116,
-0.0019297305,
-0.0613103732,
-0.0377937071,
-0.0507675409,
0.0129587548,
0.0360547304,
0.0534186512,
0.0378584489,
0.0429191031,
0.0347669497,
-0.0410642996,
0.0428834036,
-0.014290926,
0.0243404415,
-0.0271950848,
-0.0028773409,
-0.0332152396,
-0.0137455035,
0.0369637981,
0.0259332638,
0.0129488446,
-0.0340676084,
-0.0477357917,
0.0262022596,
-0.0053854142,
0.0012812242,
0.0645859987,
0.0017732832,
0.0407363288,
-0.0233766884,
0.0225650631,
-0.0348113589,
0.0378327519,
0.0125449151,
-0.0471728742,
-0.0422055461,
0.0187580436,
0.0075040348,
0.0344183221,
0.0110493535,
-0.0214535948,
0.0339544155,
-0.0078045293,
-0.0111106653,
0.0113892937,
0.0391144529,
-0.0403892919,
-0.0174680259,
-0.033029221,
-0.081218034,
0.0160868857,
0.0015645352,
0.0028738568,
-0.0367628559,
0.0122196479,
0.0134158013,
0.0267432183,
0.0382892415,
-0.0313556679,
-0.0539015681,
0.0159617662,
0.0004549696,
0.0032653613,
-6.313467752e-33,
-0.0357412659,
0.0484958552,
0.0083199702,
-0.0013919357,
-0.0214082338,
-0.0284744948,
0.004863027,
0.0016579574,
-0.0127836987,
0.002594505,
-0.0431985781,
0.0051788175,
0.0342859365,
-0.0112108085,
-0.0328627303,
0.0150671704,
0.0643767789,
-0.0420563966,
0.0094059771,
-0.0035267463,
0.0253813211,
0.0577403568,
0.0631687194,
-0.0584572218,
0.001733417,
-0.0558927394,
-0.0089539113,
-0.0450875014,
0.0405040048,
0.0313178189,
0.0090527944,
0.0443318449,
-0.0130376834,
-0.0144015681,
-0.0201773979,
0.0016395481,
-0.0220587403,
0.0240822975,
0.0232000947,
0.0772132948,
0.0264472906,
0.0258939434,
-0.0148152784,
0.000467437,
-0.0445702001,
-0.0032880034,
0.0212113112,
-0.0143353296,
-0.0197317582,
-0.030038001,
-0.082716167,
0.0203849301,
-0.011410865,
-0.0205105264,
0.0725722462,
0.0785721242,
-0.0529730767,
-0.0584873296,
-0.0506668352,
0.0141635351,
0.0028788212,
0.0278898478,
0.026352467,
-0.0072946064,
-0.0369981155,
-0.0132514974,
0.0505187511,
-0.0238892008,
0.0224722624,
0.0080912625,
0.050081294,
0.0200368017,
-0.0022328452,
0.0363541953,
-0.004588936,
-0.0709884465,
-0.0462567881,
0.0120592825,
0.002512981,
-0.0199266244,
0.003612499,
0.0049040713,
-0.0149113666,
-0.0237306021,
-0.0452258512,
-0.0377074964,
-0.000009683,
-0.0481380336,
0.0737928972,
-0.0322410241,
0.0443335548,
-0.0045401612,
0.0521220788,
-0.0169605594,
0.0197912399,
-0.0751301348,
-0.0283658169,
0.0174187012,
-0.0397085063,
0.0543144941,
-0.0613443404,
-0.0434054993,
0.0477844663,
0.049192436,
0.0468109809,
-0.0358193032,
-0.0245897826,
0.0060237381,
-0.0491055697,
0.0081266733,
0.0134650953,
0.0087610213,
0.0448605865,
0.0387826562,
0.0142433913,
-0.0335586369,
-0.0064956388,
0.0557261482,
-0.0275519211,
-0.0381543227,
0.0002750765,
-0.0537711047,
0.0324259698,
0.0139237484,
-0.0557804033,
0.0353479646,
-0.0290473513,
0.0147924451,
0.0576158948,
0.0084629217,
-0.0051904391,
0.0039903526,
3.062e-7,
-0.0128204413,
-0.0063811969,
-0.0200735331,
-0.0168949645,
-0.0127218906,
0.0113553489,
-0.0118777715,
-0.0013798045,
0.0224633049,
0.0739718527,
-0.0063437317,
-0.0810103491,
0.0927437097,
0.0216342025,
-0.0606224276,
-0.087689437,
-0.1058416665,
0.0377728753,
-0.0594585352,
0.0573474839,
0.0062193959,
0.0657951683,
-0.049927339,
-0.0487052202,
-0.0236117318,
0.0257321335,
0.037826255,
-0.0597007833,
-0.0403696224,
0.0121517191,
0.0374999754,
0.0007294325,
0.0115172192,
0.001978172,
-0.0616331585,
0.0854870453,
0.0627903268,
0.0669230148,
-0.0041348124,
-0.0022505464,
0.0467544757,
0.0256357696,
-0.0553280935,
-0.0358863659,
0.0634351075,
0.0150132403,
-0.021040149,
-0.004931001,
-0.0107832821,
0.0067068879,
-0.0183311962,
-0.037507765,
0.0151054375,
0.0076394426,
0.0167679749,
0.0008054532,
0.0186099596,
0.0103036677,
0.0167152844,
0.023146959,
0.0153509649,
-0.0688708201,
-0.0278919097,
-0.0001975883,
0.0642118305,
0.0576549321,
-0.0066274647,
2.237586787e-34,
0.01761695,
-0.0456527397,
0.0340748243,
0.0141871907,
0.0292997882,
-0.0259875059,
0.0653552189,
0.0323468782,
-0.0032750557,
-0.0342588685,
-0.0349283367
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.03274v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.03274v1 | It is not Sexually Suggestive, It is Educative. Separating Sex Education from Suggestive Content on TikTok Videos | 2023-07-06T20:23:17 | 2023-07-06T20:23:17 | Enfa George, Mihai Surdeanu | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, I.2.10; I.4.9; I.2.7; I.5.4 | We introduce SexTok, a multi-modal dataset composed of TikTok videos labeled
as sexually suggestive (from the annotator's point of view), sex-educational
content, or neither. Such a dataset is necessary to address the challenge of
distinguishing between sexually suggestive content and virtual sex education
videos on TikTok. Children's exposure to sexually suggestive videos has been
shown to have adversarial effects on their development. Meanwhile, virtual sex
education, especially on subjects that are more relevant to the LGBTQIA+
community, is very valuable. The platform's current system removes or penalizes
some of both types of videos, even though they serve different purposes. Our
dataset contains video URLs, and it is also audio transcribed. To validate its
importance, we explore two transformer-based models for classifying the videos.
Our preliminary results suggest that the task of distinguishing between these
types of videos is learnable but challenging. These experiments suggest that
this dataset is meaningful and invites further study on the subject. | [
0.0602691807,
0.0364644304,
-0.0257557202,
-0.0174494367,
0.014874436,
0.0339972526,
0.0723855272,
-0.0118179396,
-0.0128787905,
-0.0650892183,
-0.0454169959,
-0.0516325273,
-0.0038909449,
0.0157189127,
0.0027711247,
-0.0525055379,
0.0019394177,
0.0503620841,
-0.0167715922,
0.0335795358,
0.033478573,
-0.0019253276,
0.02627193,
0.0444598459,
0.0074459631,
-0.006353538,
0.0418655872,
0.0230352134,
0.0108517883,
-0.0278634634,
0.0617251918,
0.0416993238,
-0.0128966328,
0.0585288592,
0.0000020236,
-0.0188189242,
-0.0079962648,
-0.0077257408,
0.0400455147,
-0.0106326444,
0.0674924031,
-0.0420757979,
-0.0213211644,
0.0510018021,
-0.0434095301,
0.0186337046,
0.0750628635,
0.0236712024,
0.0616448559,
0.0322304778,
-0.032829918,
-0.0063989139,
-0.001643384,
0.0142513681,
0.041165337,
0.0428448655,
0.0355094783,
-0.0126570417,
0.0071044238,
0.0116573274,
-0.0368676372,
0.0304048117,
0.0333784297,
-0.0259732995,
0.0276582744,
-0.0328082182,
-0.0117833056,
-0.1037248075,
0.0068520624,
0.0200807955,
-0.0041835103,
0.0004895763,
0.0461133569,
0.0249960683,
0.0145289814,
0.024666341,
-0.0624602251,
0.039433714,
-0.0161775798,
0.004271362,
-0.0552775413,
0.0056524207,
0.0714511275,
0.0554489866,
0.0717531368,
-0.0302110501,
0.0211436581,
-0.0072165695,
-0.0429980233,
-0.0143085197,
0.0369703844,
-0.0255835783,
0.07544256,
-0.0274698921,
0.0342338867,
-0.0113721676,
-0.0266152956,
-0.0653718263,
0.006618123,
-0.0438620187,
0.035951823,
0.0487007499,
-0.0422049724,
0.002053936,
0.0143741202,
0.0078424206,
0.0017666531,
0.0782195404,
0.0140542258,
0.0088241771,
-0.0217777211,
0.0287434291,
0.0141870556,
-0.0218601525,
0.0351414457,
0.0437551513,
-0.0558069758,
0.00702549,
-0.0345755219,
-0.0473753028,
-0.0488183312,
0.0207351949,
-0.0084364815,
0.0184033625,
0.0153931426,
0.0180633552,
-0.0264184158,
0.048313491,
-0.0008733128,
-0.0268293731,
0.0232396498,
-0.0066121253,
0.0228600241,
-0.0031877542,
0.0135236941,
0.0239716973,
0.0224120934,
-0.0418323614,
-0.0119611584,
-0.0075959363,
-0.0370902829,
0.0062172925,
0.0362821817,
-0.0519921035,
0.0194308143,
0.0049380064,
-0.0190541614,
-0.0299876034,
-0.006449033,
-0.0076798955,
-0.0270411931,
0.064293772,
0.0942123234,
-0.0042703808,
0.063579455,
0.0723433346,
-0.0355396047,
0.0635204315,
0.0259748604,
0.0321154781,
0.0493834317,
-0.0320061557,
-0.0128276208,
0.0189320985,
0.0121381367,
0.0214163121,
-0.0094361743,
-0.000871552,
0.0096788956,
0.0173473451,
-0.0384144597,
0.009294007,
-0.0191006716,
-0.0334756561,
0.0538814366,
0.021519389,
0.0230693519,
0.0621424653,
0.0256864559,
0.0282782987,
-0.0039988616,
-0.0028275389,
-0.0777760819,
0.0418341905,
-0.0143905766,
-0.0431487858,
0.0334710255,
0.0253343191,
-0.0556245185,
-0.0585049503,
-0.0126785096,
-0.0148970606,
0.0575216934,
-0.0275942702,
0.0351864509,
0.0465451293,
-0.020651577,
0.0287443902,
0.0522472449,
-0.0080964044,
0.025204353,
-0.0437094085,
0.0325534344,
0.0039344588,
-0.0346239433,
-0.0556940511,
-0.0017330459,
-0.0627329797,
0.0069190245,
-0.0109200105,
0.0030145759,
0.0025807431,
-0.0097086513,
-0.0304765534,
-0.0699530989,
-0.0171610825,
0.0368462987,
-0.024908876,
0.0090602599,
0.030527804,
0.0102907913,
0.0107387872,
-0.0321189798,
0.0223045722,
0.0281164199,
-0.0000812921,
0.0254024472,
0.0481846407,
0.0261151567,
-0.0049275565,
0.0244288668,
-0.0344078206,
0.020459434,
0.0019159081,
0.0025475956,
-0.0122113749,
0.0023607071,
0.0045096758,
0.0361950584,
-0.0899140388,
-0.0265812948,
0.0989905074,
-0.0113067925,
0.0332063697,
0.0955640897,
-0.0186443031,
0.011186799,
-0.0059704329,
-0.0172641724,
-0.0180141274,
0.0060994215,
0.0467299372,
0.0082885344,
-0.014554413,
-0.0082459291,
0.0094540054,
-0.068774648,
-0.0165019017,
0.0480368771,
-0.0168327391,
0.0015148639,
-0.0876384601,
0.0339050852,
0.0173626132,
-0.0212999005,
-0.0447014719,
-0.064407751,
-0.0492388345,
-0.0126945619,
-0.0455028564,
-0.0016544593,
0.0237295553,
0.0141994776,
0.0035361336,
-0.0056662671,
-0.0154981911,
-0.02451564,
-0.0075778291,
0.040153604,
-0.0240941271,
-0.0455529876,
-0.0075456891,
-0.0050901072,
-0.0223222114,
-0.028968133,
0.0464860201,
0.0359289609,
0.0022785061,
0.0711277276,
-0.0477753244,
-0.0334455818,
-0.0123981098,
0.0025343436,
-0.0437294282,
0.0126337763,
0.0422527865,
-0.004633138,
0.03973113,
0.0682203993,
0.0623993725,
0.0405471213,
0.0403056182,
-0.0218656193,
-0.019640455,
-0.0000643802,
-0.0225251652,
0.0095923748,
-0.0647856295,
-0.0120247928,
0.004673773,
-0.0064979601,
-0.0026275304,
-0.0374910459,
0.0526323095,
-0.0271608569,
-0.0125552714,
0.0007012408,
0.0070000272,
0.0128168724,
-0.0186509527,
-0.0201555546,
-0.0395592079,
0.043509569,
0.0489919297,
-0.0190110486,
0.0057864483,
-0.0423897468,
0.009241147,
-0.0066558081,
-0.0343446471,
0.0615206212,
0.0268306062,
-0.0382765606,
-0.0351530351,
0.0027766237,
0.0380740613,
-0.0327189155,
0.030231325,
-0.0020482468,
-0.0210817326,
0.0041121528,
-0.0464315452,
-0.0603294224,
-0.0782960728,
0.0051275771,
-0.024744533,
-0.0424593054,
0.0175501369,
-0.0406920128,
0.0169361457,
-0.034192916,
-0.0016566846,
-0.0104567688,
-0.0251615234,
0.0333116986,
0.0077602412,
0.0242151637,
-0.0347839892,
-0.0284717511,
0.0120332083,
0.0050494252,
0.0718622208,
-0.074222587,
-0.0005240648,
0.0010609926,
0.0189619213,
0.0127959475,
-0.0020714754,
-0.0299762897,
-0.0096948007,
0.0239077453,
-0.0367069356,
-0.0003607916,
0.0290616527,
-0.0038508729,
-0.0332787149,
0.0084098903,
0.0200507995,
-0.0502915643,
-0.0127191357,
-0.008012672,
-0.0907323435,
-0.0075651435,
-0.0371665843,
0.0203174558,
-0.0309502464,
0.014463746,
0.0204905663,
-0.0190548729,
0.0204340778,
0.0170469414,
-0.0276868679,
-0.0384604931,
-0.0377086736,
0.0091638472,
-0.0099248262,
0.0208109356,
-0.0542961545,
-0.0322575308,
-0.000632446,
0.0087460708,
0.008759046,
-0.0631490871,
0.0376965068,
-0.0396368913,
0.0288378969,
0.0306126475,
0.0584894232,
-0.0352148227,
-0.0478353724,
-0.0039842827,
0.0400467142,
-0.040185634,
-0.0047382009,
0.0028827118,
0.0075630345,
0.0024695781,
0.0104775224,
0.0612263754,
0.0283429492,
-0.0099038035,
-0.0070309439,
0.0721125603,
0.0320329592,
-0.021886671,
-0.0404151604,
0.0437275246,
0.0306908078,
0.0601077378,
0.0077903508,
-0.0620649047,
0.0617176406,
-0.0692982823,
0.0039500347,
0.0296465587,
-0.0789264515,
-0.015646318,
0.0195591711,
-0.0386935137,
-0.0556482039,
0.0128716901,
-0.0080654845,
-0.0203295741,
0.0097949859,
-0.0575360395,
-0.0198932625,
0.0042536049,
-0.059196502,
0.0282697678,
0.0634582564,
-0.0185734257,
-0.0596627854,
-0.0506144017,
-0.0394463018,
-0.0704789832,
0.0124877058,
-0.0066965129,
-0.0467819087,
-0.0402144231,
0.0061285761,
0.0538291261,
0.0226622764,
0.0215714406,
-0.0105191581,
0.0169679485,
0.0481141508,
0.0815458819,
-0.0342509709,
-0.0711207613,
0.0600021183,
-0.020578837,
-0.0133779356,
0.0222447831,
-0.0335251912,
0.0010592932,
0.0067615299,
-0.0682453439,
-0.044064071,
0.0135468077,
-0.0238240641,
-0.0430018269,
0.0666485801,
-0.0193831548,
-0.0428615622,
-0.0067024222,
-0.0515196323,
0.019729428,
0.0123493457,
-0.0076086042,
0.0124034677,
0.0591916218,
0.0145066679,
-0.0501647554,
0.0339776129,
0.001721111,
-0.0410939418,
-0.0963940322,
0.0114263827,
0.0237760954,
0.0097279586,
-0.0129134636,
0.0175610222,
0.0054929685,
0.0113692535,
0.0498518795,
-0.0038293817,
-0.0132715572,
0.025705073,
-0.0044021588,
0.0449175686,
0.0270187333,
0.0251901653,
-0.0163832474,
-0.0071245939,
-0.0318070427,
-0.0145290727,
-0.014216084,
-0.0212823991,
0.0047307103,
0.002374293,
-0.0338228159,
-0.0359187536,
0.0408872366,
-0.0268718656,
-0.0731422603,
0.0266231261,
-0.0307567306,
-0.0053103203,
0.0129241049,
0.0201017689,
-0.016283283,
0.0241466388,
0.0390452072,
-0.0171021409,
-0.0156695228,
0.0418782532,
0.029912753,
0.0089791482,
-0.0119929956,
0.0540265106,
-0.0294366516,
-0.0367034227,
-0.0071466868,
-0.0879423916,
0.0504693016,
-0.01215031,
0.0037333083,
0.0116379801,
-0.0219935756,
0.0046921181,
-0.0045581069,
-0.0471452698,
0.0109011913,
-0.0372463204,
-0.0174385253,
-6.186957376e-33,
0.0252083801,
0.0166171119,
-0.0448019765,
0.0414874032,
-0.005721088,
0.001614294,
-0.011764653,
-0.0157426279,
0.0040694699,
-0.0126991346,
0.0242297892,
0.0328891017,
-0.0003609134,
0.0169724058,
0.0237734728,
-0.0726892352,
0.0575907007,
-0.0137171764,
-0.0632167906,
0.0269851536,
0.0367435589,
0.0360008441,
0.0422535501,
-0.1057192832,
0.0257207789,
0.007106503,
-0.0175817665,
-0.0439444259,
-0.0015667478,
0.0533382148,
-0.0343387127,
0.0337117612,
-0.0024828161,
-0.0559633449,
0.0155520672,
0.069426991,
-0.0852324069,
0.0152109433,
-0.0049760439,
0.0403100662,
-0.0180575643,
-0.0342513323,
0.0535672791,
-0.0047274325,
0.0036584721,
-0.0797233656,
0.0483778492,
-0.0257618558,
0.0339704193,
-0.0445760004,
-0.0381392278,
-0.0282698013,
-0.0410160422,
-0.0687412098,
0.039353665,
0.0944748223,
-0.0020336893,
0.0020340197,
-0.0878509507,
0.0398183465,
0.0095392559,
-0.0073673627,
0.0445006974,
-0.0540684126,
0.0173339471,
0.0422222577,
-0.0037438679,
-0.0378449485,
-0.0157741159,
-0.0461574793,
0.0232732147,
0.0670892969,
0.0176882651,
0.0015837944,
0.056052871,
-0.0764012858,
-0.0630164593,
0.0048983661,
0.0154944425,
-0.0188327096,
-0.0093404017,
-0.0025101854,
0.0090430388,
-0.0061757728,
-0.0088248653,
-0.095471479,
-0.0230835285,
-0.048527725,
-0.0072155152,
-0.010605406,
-0.0618508272,
0.0220408011,
-0.0230154004,
-0.070442684,
-0.0176788196,
-0.0055050715,
-0.0188567601,
0.014380862,
0.0227317493,
-0.002507925,
-0.0467577092,
0.031882517,
0.0386381522,
-0.0171074346,
0.0488684475,
0.0322022587,
0.0182879157,
0.0717245266,
-0.0417962223,
-0.0235296749,
-0.0229362175,
0.0337818675,
0.0320557877,
0.0195024982,
-0.0033654759,
0.0410694592,
-0.0205664914,
0.0261913594,
0.0342667773,
0.0775361136,
-0.0231030248,
0.0011241313,
-0.0196875595,
0.0328999683,
-0.0125345001,
-0.0032292081,
-0.040189039,
-0.0009990279,
0.0301146284,
-0.0522522442,
-0.0038274413,
-0.0269844458,
2.78e-7,
-0.018702507,
0.0430091731,
-0.025427781,
-0.0563560128,
0.0179057885,
0.0645948723,
0.0150810573,
0.046215035,
0.0905540064,
-0.0203642938,
-0.0200899784,
-0.0049110823,
0.0442506373,
0.0548026264,
-0.0249448754,
-0.048706647,
-0.0497090518,
0.0411936417,
-0.011966547,
0.0202363376,
-0.0135434065,
0.1212900132,
0.0628834143,
-0.0300866328,
0.0056476174,
-0.0139719183,
0.0553744435,
-0.0098109916,
0.0287357233,
-0.0318171307,
0.0579633936,
-0.0119361673,
0.0364984125,
-0.0195753407,
-0.0594709888,
-0.0270890296,
0.0302390531,
0.0190612096,
0.019195443,
0.0342559926,
-0.027828021,
0.0090109911,
-0.0170124006,
-0.0390359089,
0.0708528087,
-0.0344434902,
-0.0321192145,
0.0024231146,
-0.0194957871,
0.0210211966,
0.0603800416,
-0.0260632541,
-0.0120831532,
0.0153540699,
0.0037249571,
-0.008162912,
0.0173918959,
-0.0713422298,
0.0047613387,
-0.0176606048,
-0.0079860883,
-0.0054314458,
-0.0142919803,
0.0173731092,
0.0050110379,
0.0306360926,
0.013202901,
1.895848883e-34,
0.010339492,
-0.0328538902,
0.0261742827,
-0.0849484354,
-0.0069515104,
0.0096912812,
0.0868076235,
-0.0123542063,
-0.0020314788,
0.0190464426,
-0.0053465813
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.03254v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.03254v1 | Vision Language Transformers: A Survey | 2023-07-06T19:08:56 | 2023-07-06T19:08:56 | Clayton Fields, Casey Kennington | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Vision language tasks, such as answering questions about or generating
captions that describe an image, are difficult tasks for computers to perform.
A relatively recent body of research has adapted the pretrained transformer
architecture introduced in \citet{vaswani2017attention} to vision language
modeling. Transformer models have greatly improved performance and versatility
over previous vision language models. They do so by pretraining models on a
large generic datasets and transferring their learning to new tasks with minor
changes in architecture and parameter values. This type of transfer learning
has become the standard modeling practice in both natural language processing
and computer vision. Vision language transformers offer the promise of
producing similar advancements in tasks which require both vision and language.
In this paper, we provide a broad synthesis of the currently available research
on vision language transformer models and offer some analysis of their
strengths, limitations and some open questions that remain. | [
0.0591932684,
0.0607541762,
-0.0131934695,
0.0417550094,
-0.0073232898,
-0.000946405,
0.0072854999,
0.0015255054,
-0.0088988151,
-0.088656269,
-0.043766547,
-0.0186022222,
0.0223220848,
0.0402348898,
0.0215551313,
-0.0896365941,
0.0122360792,
-0.0404660814,
-0.0410936959,
0.0236110073,
-0.0005655671,
-0.0115891322,
0.0232679155,
0.0388161279,
-0.022828754,
0.0105384281,
0.0105352169,
0.000132884,
-0.0077878023,
0.0153911598,
-0.0120418267,
0.0420690514,
0.0467139073,
-0.025385607,
0.0000016744,
-0.020923106,
0.020020904,
0.0073100869,
0.0204989035,
-0.0436399914,
0.0464355126,
-0.080901958,
0.0189841241,
0.0210707393,
-0.0559144281,
-0.0573390312,
0.0891423225,
0.0408347696,
0.0824863389,
0.0538889617,
-0.0354846567,
-0.0304011852,
0.04011577,
-0.0167430416,
0.002231766,
-0.0129696969,
0.0212667324,
0.0310497377,
-0.0287380945,
-0.0030557604,
-0.0606764145,
0.0472101867,
-0.0122389467,
-0.0278510824,
0.0126712956,
0.0043792352,
-0.0639110953,
-0.0463428684,
-0.0415422991,
0.0604918264,
-0.0211828928,
-0.0091258762,
-0.0382029228,
0.0218618326,
0.0040771696,
0.0294970796,
-0.0377848111,
0.0384314917,
0.0345430747,
0.0175380018,
-0.036396835,
0.0095030749,
-0.0331914127,
-0.0168264359,
-0.0327596888,
0.0020606003,
0.0253958106,
0.0277440399,
-0.0061767814,
0.037656527,
-0.0366455428,
-0.0561848618,
-0.0058272243,
0.0481179208,
0.0027141357,
-0.0093758414,
-0.0727687255,
-0.0463531278,
-0.0353517681,
-0.0241184104,
0.0551410206,
0.0193567052,
-0.0633422732,
0.0482133776,
-0.0546531193,
0.0881589428,
-0.0358249024,
0.0559527725,
-0.0579945035,
-0.0583369695,
-0.0337277651,
-0.0205218177,
-0.0702350512,
0.0095914621,
-0.034962479,
-0.0358087048,
-0.0293171909,
0.0354365557,
0.0041575828,
-0.0493988991,
0.0213141404,
0.0296347737,
-0.0497220233,
-0.0326890163,
-0.0405563824,
0.0514778718,
0.0455084555,
0.0295375809,
-0.019234363,
-0.0641362146,
0.0054941075,
0.0610778965,
0.0291770659,
-0.0203370638,
-0.0108767049,
0.0781167075,
-0.0435970612,
-0.0405834243,
-0.0124158897,
0.0243855324,
-0.0202844813,
-0.0140304752,
0.0302925855,
-0.0465752035,
0.0298963897,
0.0120825171,
-0.0063351872,
-0.019163454,
-0.0019856449,
0.0214614924,
-0.0273193289,
0.1099565476,
-0.0135454629,
0.0029228171,
0.0181780551,
-0.0083819162,
0.0123594496,
0.0400613025,
0.0236532353,
0.0360274501,
0.0195795298,
-0.0316942967,
0.0635699704,
0.0575651452,
-0.0192941111,
-0.009831381,
-0.0364820324,
0.0122408699,
-0.0093583828,
-0.0186951626,
0.0391887203,
0.0681766868,
-0.0069511551,
-0.0036875268,
0.0750755146,
0.0582727008,
0.0108545125,
0.0315038376,
0.0528504662,
0.0031368253,
0.0057355976,
-0.0035139492,
-0.0519582406,
0.0440098159,
0.0051207417,
-0.0207417049,
-0.0726185814,
0.0191312283,
-0.0481985696,
-0.0292594992,
0.0133589506,
-0.0365249477,
0.0102363592,
0.0191999953,
0.0540416203,
0.0544163547,
-0.0453978963,
0.0575446673,
-0.003598779,
-0.0371528715,
0.0110618994,
-0.0653213412,
-0.0255658496,
0.0185354706,
0.0173746347,
-0.0172763802,
-0.0034296308,
-0.0040495163,
0.0387355462,
0.044571694,
0.0269793104,
0.0136916554,
-0.0060610166,
-0.0377753824,
-0.0368117094,
0.0090068821,
0.0001991471,
0.0006243947,
-0.0118918,
-0.0047615711,
0.0195585024,
-0.0129353078,
-0.0273398887,
0.0619898103,
0.039176669,
-0.0015568819,
0.0040290579,
0.0183788948,
-0.011003131,
-0.0437340513,
-0.0122731915,
0.0023878508,
-0.0009574859,
-0.0488030463,
-0.0156100895,
0.0380650274,
-0.0247432645,
-0.0244382825,
0.0307067763,
-0.0868351609,
0.009595789,
0.0639531836,
-0.030896876,
-0.0365452319,
0.0037176735,
-0.0452401824,
0.0081930077,
-0.0495434888,
0.0262227207,
0.0089413524,
0.0498656444,
-0.0320966654,
0.0222101603,
0.0093984762,
-0.0350541361,
0.0061918413,
-0.0307892486,
0.002664045,
-0.0135375885,
-0.0319819823,
-0.0224334747,
-0.025071105,
0.0253676418,
0.0125149209,
0.0099437432,
-0.0019357153,
-0.0333290435,
-0.0539821461,
-0.0323077999,
-0.0358887725,
-0.0218616445,
0.016514698,
0.0044267918,
0.0282802284,
-0.0243824553,
-0.0533498675,
0.046701394,
0.0387456268,
0.0083763786,
0.0569777377,
0.0012517829,
0.0033541045,
-0.0144557264,
-0.0147225158,
0.0249946956,
0.0684184656,
0.025755519,
-0.0386834107,
-0.0486106537,
0.0421543084,
-0.0030781203,
0.0511820503,
-0.0101139229,
-0.033002317,
-0.0100401798,
-0.0209705625,
0.0384996869,
0.0436590314,
0.0266253725,
0.0302611925,
-0.0094329435,
-0.0127475029,
0.0010258679,
-0.0100174705,
-0.0333073437,
-0.0802252963,
-0.027141979,
-0.0333699249,
0.00141283,
0.0397755019,
-0.0371056721,
-0.0041912892,
-0.0719457716,
0.0073599829,
-0.0091071101,
-0.0261721704,
-0.0317217596,
0.0078561688,
0.0030095496,
0.0390380397,
-0.0294034332,
-0.0744221509,
0.0096851578,
-0.0377753936,
-0.0239872392,
0.0134398704,
0.0208171755,
-0.0331221148,
0.0764167011,
0.0420688055,
0.0027230033,
0.0036709798,
-0.0122924345,
-0.0625187755,
-0.0145286974,
0.0026651567,
-0.0213417336,
0.0973966271,
-0.0467716604,
0.0272712857,
-0.0540210754,
-0.0104603656,
-0.0465732664,
-0.015509841,
-0.0155604845,
0.0079072798,
-0.0214406028,
-0.0199472867,
-0.0453935228,
0.0473267622,
0.016603183,
0.0392125696,
0.014397407,
-0.0221695956,
-0.0132510616,
0.0496217906,
0.0810997114,
0.0702529773,
-0.0030461363,
-0.0071210805,
-0.0091371741,
0.0445860289,
0.019477671,
-0.004602713,
-0.0577532239,
0.0052121445,
0.0511786453,
0.0163605604,
0.0084484806,
0.0271225106,
0.039201133,
-0.0539071672,
-0.0160242468,
0.0734681711,
0.0079136584,
-0.0149059463,
-0.0249285176,
0.0379656292,
-0.0148066748,
0.0413959734,
0.0459866449,
-0.0796789676,
-0.0271727126,
-0.0433862507,
-0.0099176839,
0.0166083574,
0.0020310949,
-0.0522491187,
-0.074882634,
0.0620978996,
-0.0140384957,
-0.0107055204,
-0.0480115637,
0.0310586318,
-0.0104763536,
-0.0213793479,
-0.0247759037,
-0.0415741056,
-0.0194351934,
-0.0103434026,
0.0009207673,
0.0067205164,
-0.0038872648,
-0.0012889395,
-0.0423767641,
-0.0060425256,
0.0593168773,
-0.0160545092,
-0.0285554621,
-0.0520425178,
0.0054569799,
-0.0291387178,
0.0127455369,
0.0200301595,
0.0658275783,
-0.0085405977,
-0.0593771525,
0.0243029036,
0.0026641891,
-0.0382750779,
-0.0151266614,
-0.0249958709,
0.0275741741,
-0.0042086346,
-0.0303296428,
-0.0069658533,
-0.0029862202,
-0.0087364232,
0.0399288572,
0.0122227538,
-0.0473334454,
-0.0329144113,
-0.0020561193,
0.0013903874,
-0.052105464,
-0.0707668811,
0.0075447829,
0.0339212641,
-0.0122844903,
-0.0818211883,
0.0041650282,
0.0457801893,
0.0412335657,
-0.000792255,
-0.0419130549,
0.0575954691,
-0.0056426744,
-0.0422108695,
0.0634616986,
-0.0422505066,
0.0143322339,
-0.0557089522,
-0.0108248862,
0.0577567704,
-0.035972625,
-0.0045909765,
-0.0035692938,
-0.0703503042,
-0.0057784705,
-0.0116816321,
0.1000758111,
0.015974883,
0.0154629368,
-0.0034825541,
-0.0386111364,
0.0199463051,
0.042133458,
0.0173131116,
0.0312001873,
0.0091073588,
-0.0486966223,
-0.023287097,
0.0173053518,
-0.0274840035,
0.0321832299,
0.0356197134,
-0.0042507099,
-0.0028154359,
-0.0445514657,
0.0308696609,
0.0037977565,
0.0589708723,
0.0090813423,
0.0520094335,
-0.0182564948,
0.008093914,
0.0050809467,
0.0029698196,
-0.098827295,
-0.011761453,
0.0319763832,
0.0414136387,
0.0105102519,
-0.0012237538,
-0.0399130583,
0.013200053,
-0.0241555814,
0.0140777463,
0.0175823979,
-0.0188147016,
0.0025927229,
0.0351376683,
0.0026946724,
0.000107036,
0.0226272214,
0.0377253443,
0.0026554754,
0.0511090681,
0.0153071834,
0.005678874,
-0.0323885344,
0.0348056182,
-0.0381192714,
-0.0357002579,
-0.0455471836,
0.0461038202,
0.0088904509,
-0.0124363359,
0.0156156486,
0.0013630218,
-0.0211651083,
-0.0202041697,
0.0482152626,
0.0116554229,
-0.0054775015,
0.0753978342,
-0.005480093,
-0.0098022334,
-0.0172463953,
0.0565943681,
-0.0021949038,
0.0194777306,
-0.0004804381,
-0.0151347164,
-0.0412446819,
-0.0297330264,
0.0072149141,
-0.0731727481,
0.0078716995,
0.0560582951,
-0.0107529229,
-0.057484217,
0.0229185,
-0.0218624901,
0.0128973369,
0.0104343239,
0.0493909568,
0.035366267,
0.0197442304,
-0.0151185608,
-0.0232084207,
-0.0270469561,
0.0126185203,
0.0222433973,
0.0014479781,
-5.223907181e-33,
-0.0328299403,
-0.0223693382,
0.0348624885,
0.0365019143,
-0.0278682131,
0.0052399416,
-0.0099636978,
0.022511512,
-0.0367350914,
0.0015890937,
0.0136988023,
-0.0170535371,
0.0191291329,
0.0682792589,
-0.0274647623,
-0.0057020802,
0.0408849306,
-0.007460766,
-0.0070046778,
-0.0205964725,
-0.0175007712,
0.000352363,
0.0479408726,
-0.0368339494,
-0.0418732092,
0.0142696099,
-0.0135903331,
0.0121300528,
0.0459231064,
0.0604588874,
-0.0119066918,
0.0336138234,
0.0308133196,
-0.03513024,
-0.0362173989,
0.0608358681,
-0.0714658499,
0.0135916891,
0.0091277696,
0.0616622083,
-0.0601345189,
0.0256544072,
0.052178666,
-0.0253226161,
0.0288739149,
-0.0436961874,
0.0493605398,
-0.0342716873,
0.0040503587,
-0.0154817309,
-0.0607029833,
-0.0021973287,
0.0073869172,
-0.0422816873,
0.0381210744,
0.0626726598,
0.0001526697,
0.0333452486,
-0.026631685,
0.009406168,
0.0302189644,
0.0337036997,
0.068788588,
0.0636831373,
-0.0135395946,
0.0199542996,
0.0006732631,
-0.036243435,
-0.0242234766,
-0.0119992308,
0.0281462204,
0.0701837316,
0.0608325191,
0.0594856367,
-0.0080936402,
-0.0038621025,
-0.0244539641,
0.0105075948,
-0.0874360353,
0.0568821095,
0.003725338,
-0.0076817507,
0.0352234654,
-0.001698485,
-0.0235557258,
0.0166692995,
-0.0249329619,
0.009276649,
0.0517805777,
0.030037187,
-0.046890758,
0.0504130125,
0.0757692754,
-0.0733164921,
0.0058845314,
-0.0173174217,
-0.0206388552,
0.0659254491,
-0.0114867333,
0.0269510001,
-0.0386909395,
-0.0355703346,
0.0569554083,
0.0220020283,
-0.0015727106,
0.0080849733,
0.0425854847,
0.0472845957,
-0.0570232086,
0.0002046481,
-0.0207280889,
0.0250347722,
-0.0165873934,
0.0577289611,
0.0078315753,
0.0219952464,
-0.0616853721,
0.0061241533,
-0.0245773084,
-0.0488396101,
-0.0240552165,
0.0102089625,
0.0357673317,
0.0334010832,
-0.0276469737,
0.0146434363,
-0.0454466343,
0.0025575657,
0.0136738755,
-0.050574664,
-0.0219803732,
0.0266806725,
2.282e-7,
0.07106141,
0.0179090817,
0.0261870734,
0.0036435926,
0.0018520348,
0.0363582745,
0.004826054,
0.0321719125,
0.0348272212,
-0.0122129479,
0.010136677,
0.0379396603,
0.0215143729,
-0.0243721623,
-0.0045568999,
0.0137263136,
-0.0255382638,
-0.0110606048,
-0.0069650686,
-0.0170906186,
0.0676192567,
0.0998670757,
-0.0521657057,
-0.0284716859,
-0.0009552312,
-0.0758317485,
0.1025161818,
-0.0223347228,
0.0070065572,
0.0178890359,
-0.0001687567,
0.0514891334,
-0.0334309116,
0.060839653,
-0.0159437042,
-0.0137856742,
0.0608028136,
0.0197539926,
-0.0216419231,
-0.0046799961,
-0.0159173254,
0.0346309543,
-0.0159643125,
-0.0442953892,
0.0754512548,
-0.1277451068,
-0.0095087886,
-0.0258458089,
-0.0395736769,
0.0171774831,
-0.0002940459,
-0.0219891444,
-0.006084858,
0.02605482,
0.0795723125,
0.010969541,
-0.055994831,
-0.0707808807,
0.0012225305,
-0.0254330877,
-0.0296172183,
-0.0077144331,
-0.0528159663,
-0.031488236,
0.0295365639,
0.0050417227,
-0.0188272167,
1.624519073e-34,
0.0079533532,
0.0180495549,
0.0002304411,
-0.0021464948,
-0.0077391891,
-0.0127212275,
0.0058415886,
0.0166180693,
-0.0162939504,
-0.0883537754,
-0.0201000962
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.03172v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.03172v3 | Lost in the Middle: How Language Models Use Long Contexts | 2023-07-06T17:54:11 | 2023-11-20T23:09:34 | Nelson F. Liu, Kevin Lin, John Hewitt, Ashwin Paranjape, Michele Bevilacqua, Fabio Petroni, Percy Liang | cs.CL | cs.CL | While recent language models have the ability to take long contexts as input,
relatively little is known about how well they use longer context. We analyze
the performance of language models on two tasks that require identifying
relevant information in their input contexts: multi-document question answering
and key-value retrieval. We find that performance can degrade significantly
when changing the position of relevant information, indicating that current
language models do not robustly make use of information in long input contexts.
In particular, we observe that performance is often highest when relevant
information occurs at the beginning or end of the input context, and
significantly degrades when models must access relevant information in the
middle of long contexts, even for explicitly long-context models. Our analysis
provides a better understanding of how language models use their input context
and provides new evaluation protocols for future long-context language models. | [
0.0481021851,
0.022911435,
0.0110142808,
0.0480119213,
-0.0365499891,
0.0032706885,
0.026490096,
-0.0009783348,
-0.0423781946,
-0.058993239,
-0.0277321767,
-0.0604955815,
0.0015106244,
0.0038275463,
0.0009755061,
-0.0397279337,
0.0463475361,
-0.0339422859,
0.0003961294,
-0.0175667647,
-0.0106484881,
-0.0019792679,
0.0209493674,
0.0193497706,
0.0084847147,
-0.013149241,
-0.0226355195,
0.0030149254,
-0.0163797121,
0.0113062179,
0.025023168,
0.0264382996,
0.0050457446,
0.0022970706,
0.0000015001,
-0.0321868174,
-0.0218283627,
-0.0084181046,
-0.0186842978,
0.0259100758,
0.0252702013,
-0.0072039254,
0.0093979537,
0.0119730029,
-0.0217638891,
-0.0064546475,
0.0143966181,
0.0201466233,
0.0197756588,
0.0641663745,
0.0116869062,
-0.0278042722,
0.0096437205,
-0.0381973162,
0.0433046743,
-0.0924606472,
0.0245484971,
0.0023017712,
0.0582713485,
0.0382027701,
-0.0102170352,
0.0404952057,
0.0293799508,
0.0322855935,
-0.0408508219,
0.0619603693,
-0.0281209517,
0.0264212061,
0.0291090272,
0.037888974,
-0.0102081057,
-0.0151903564,
0.0022063979,
0.0135047231,
0.004469112,
-0.0105833979,
-0.065866977,
0.0195038412,
-0.0224535856,
-0.0174628943,
0.0554829389,
0.0032771011,
0.0228789877,
0.0413350351,
-0.0515873693,
0.0951796621,
0.0321441703,
-0.0357441716,
-0.0201558527,
-0.0019964671,
-0.0422647744,
-0.0348831117,
0.0187113993,
0.0456091501,
-0.001956013,
0.0474120229,
-0.0424506702,
-0.0078766029,
0.052210737,
-0.0605487041,
-0.0264756903,
0.0362087041,
-0.0417443104,
0.0881159082,
-0.0302732792,
0.0464820564,
-0.0300858319,
-0.0191823673,
-0.0650971681,
-0.0448061749,
-0.0082181133,
-0.0339989774,
-0.0490769483,
0.0293745548,
-0.0412698835,
-0.0530983247,
-0.0000731768,
0.044278536,
0.028328158,
-0.023580201,
-0.0225075167,
0.0131667638,
-0.015842028,
-0.0042075785,
0.0136903124,
0.0509024784,
-0.0587604418,
0.0193826593,
0.0083597284,
-0.0267752521,
-0.0112317856,
0.0134579381,
0.0075124339,
-0.0671598613,
0.0093586994,
0.0435020663,
0.013736546,
-0.0297694597,
-0.0051298882,
-0.0145333838,
-0.0427225977,
-0.054813195,
0.0058653429,
-0.0702225789,
0.0275313929,
0.0398862511,
-0.0126309358,
-0.0282763969,
-0.0004838364,
0.0295423605,
-0.0377487317,
0.061913006,
0.0474414639,
0.0042919964,
0.0441083536,
0.0132672368,
0.0212939065,
0.0722500011,
-0.0024196072,
-0.000885741,
0.0610465743,
0.0004864177,
-0.0155567955,
0.0292649586,
0.0250908174,
0.0134847136,
-0.0022927145,
0.0541932434,
0.0363113545,
0.0107302237,
0.0156454872,
0.0513638966,
-0.0246519446,
-0.0520192496,
0.0182487536,
0.059577886,
0.0413712375,
-0.0367158502,
0.0393093042,
-0.0256931502,
-0.0130688585,
0.0209838729,
-0.053442847,
-0.000006044,
-0.0401390716,
0.0498117059,
0.0229806434,
0.0018929357,
-0.0302494932,
-0.0295922104,
-0.0525000729,
0.001944419,
0.0063805506,
0.0309713595,
0.0562029183,
-0.0131309945,
-0.0150451902,
0.0456024148,
0.0105067892,
-0.0430331752,
0.0249265302,
-0.014976033,
0.022869844,
0.050617002,
0.0341941155,
-0.0311804917,
-0.0299975649,
0.0269095171,
0.0567958467,
0.0048205308,
0.0470202975,
-0.0165378954,
0.0423408039,
0.0103460755,
-0.0122387856,
-0.0190693829,
0.0176023599,
0.0176845808,
0.0395468213,
0.0178933702,
0.0398632325,
-0.0645687208,
0.0392645448,
0.0305738412,
-0.0376574211,
-0.0149405831,
-0.0292134397,
0.0122482041,
0.0002458227,
-0.0034856426,
0.0061032833,
0.0404014774,
0.0481716916,
-0.0420041345,
-0.0039044423,
-0.0282211769,
-0.0793970004,
-0.0295766555,
0.049843438,
0.0229216684,
0.028266551,
0.0052761999,
0.003052097,
-0.0464827716,
0.0066595688,
-0.0190231372,
0.0395554639,
-0.0142423855,
-0.0013017727,
0.0138903968,
-0.0061822538,
-0.0694610775,
0.0715132132,
-0.0062308079,
0.0639266595,
0.0109930942,
0.0347308666,
0.0147931157,
-0.0438777134,
-0.0332674012,
0.0373002328,
-0.0044096252,
0.0120197432,
0.0388358571,
-0.0157634951,
-0.0218682103,
-0.0427225716,
-0.0988743901,
0.0012090086,
-0.0360077024,
0.0180485584,
0.0186189916,
0.0267055091,
-0.0048334026,
-0.0163254831,
-0.0678277984,
-0.0453682058,
0.0171802472,
0.0659339949,
0.0232939553,
0.0574089885,
-0.0231752656,
-0.069086507,
-0.0528043397,
-0.012763625,
0.0810045525,
-0.0361684486,
-0.0293516908,
-0.0375803858,
0.0229867715,
-0.0329606645,
0.0438290127,
-0.0347116925,
-0.0046571437,
0.0051370985,
-0.0488941185,
0.0342072658,
0.0734496266,
0.0171567034,
0.0212234482,
0.0317039117,
-0.0171280839,
-0.0567177162,
0.0138652278,
-0.0189456623,
-0.0199900027,
-0.0411783345,
0.0126631837,
-0.0154382084,
0.0569002852,
-0.0042238305,
-0.0050567184,
-0.0217403229,
-0.0025628312,
-0.0277096089,
0.0171134621,
-0.0536365509,
-0.0090534035,
-0.0177747682,
0.0595479943,
-0.035371609,
-0.0063040201,
0.0634212643,
-0.0505467318,
-0.013732913,
-0.0355653763,
-0.0100767454,
-0.0532753207,
0.0812045261,
-0.0214342922,
0.0186840668,
-0.0392089821,
-0.0352347791,
-0.0411541015,
-0.0021968179,
0.0011697559,
-0.0514211133,
0.0560702123,
-0.010805388,
0.0411960557,
-0.0226328522,
-0.052384872,
-0.0354734696,
-0.0251359995,
-0.0149754407,
0.0401886776,
-0.016476037,
0.0082222009,
-0.0073533636,
0.0382458456,
0.0216829088,
0.0610894337,
-0.0404239632,
0.0071671163,
-0.0102960514,
0.0585236363,
0.061849378,
-0.0032258469,
0.0057987301,
-0.0204047151,
0.012130673,
0.0471064001,
0.0616874397,
0.0035249991,
-0.0084638651,
-0.0047669304,
0.0304999445,
-0.0456041694,
-0.0508496314,
-0.0085632997,
0.029402528,
-0.0804050267,
-0.0296869446,
0.1050221249,
0.0303198528,
-0.0363845415,
-0.0028695138,
-0.0348983184,
0.0181240141,
0.0321940258,
0.0262520257,
-0.0775746703,
-0.0374074392,
0.0070608836,
0.0236669164,
0.0195552148,
-0.0068223076,
0.0001855798,
-0.0952467695,
-0.0159260388,
-0.0226926077,
-0.0717592239,
-0.0321288109,
-0.0458170213,
0.0130982781,
0.0131606413,
0.0348387398,
0.0582765788,
-0.0219897348,
-0.0099348193,
-0.0070329672,
0.0173454154,
-0.0347849727,
0.0527336895,
-0.0300791431,
0.0087863104,
0.0408764966,
0.0022745221,
0.0110028433,
0.0117206769,
0.0538919531,
-0.056819208,
0.0113118319,
0.0106284041,
0.0061993389,
-0.0435123667,
-0.0070961001,
0.0275620222,
0.0073107448,
-0.0429695435,
0.0111833606,
0.0029643425,
0.0488644503,
-0.0086210184,
-0.008201519,
-0.0206673704,
-0.0021872194,
-0.0057800617,
0.1040969416,
0.0429172441,
-0.0353868529,
-0.0613354668,
-0.0322885998,
-0.0174360946,
-0.0215434562,
0.0002145331,
0.006527822,
0.0222262982,
0.0146434326,
-0.0470228307,
-0.077328071,
0.0328579843,
0.0391996205,
-0.0384019986,
0.0519193113,
-0.0338128135,
-0.012896508,
-0.0368062593,
0.0211491454,
-0.0262917504,
0.0242923237,
-0.0529103093,
0.0337983929,
0.0373145081,
-0.0192639995,
-0.0337276198,
0.0258683693,
-0.0948786363,
-0.047366485,
0.0131096207,
0.0003453648,
0.0279996023,
0.0253734104,
-0.0258843973,
-0.028400261,
0.0038300755,
-0.0271408111,
-0.0317189172,
0.034715876,
0.0232710335,
0.0133861154,
0.0113528809,
0.0452119708,
-0.0870696679,
-0.0018877643,
0.0053497842,
0.0586434752,
-0.035292007,
-0.0436449423,
0.0203987118,
-0.0022677639,
0.0071245744,
0.0229889452,
-0.0045388821,
0.0075934753,
0.0251942296,
-0.0272449348,
-0.0473011993,
-0.006328939,
0.0062819105,
0.0228377022,
-0.0304414257,
0.0071071079,
0.0089314049,
0.0128170149,
0.0596985668,
-0.0510354415,
-0.0046805223,
0.0455905758,
-0.0106204059,
0.025340626,
0.0028559968,
-0.0414589457,
0.0099572316,
-0.0230600741,
0.0578561686,
-0.0420285314,
0.0226755776,
0.0254674423,
-0.034032274,
-0.0317092277,
0.0283551551,
-0.1216908544,
-0.010178227,
0.0001867211,
0.0087457616,
0.0401815064,
-0.0150235798,
0.0291148406,
-0.0018949825,
-0.0255974513,
-0.0382532775,
-0.0104434723,
0.0347356573,
-0.0512828268,
0.0357332379,
0.0537573136,
-0.0096662408,
0.0274694972,
0.0897654593,
0.0404683165,
0.0570938997,
0.0045652711,
-0.0002784704,
-0.0050204312,
0.0006312046,
-0.0246460903,
0.0495419502,
-0.038245488,
0.0074181128,
-0.0289365016,
-0.0536228567,
0.0275633112,
-0.0135815432,
-0.0167080648,
-0.0266156774,
0.0073650782,
0.1103142351,
0.0370398983,
-0.0132061131,
-0.0319535509,
0.0224950984,
-0.03170361,
-0.0178137198,
-0.0418253727,
-5.733033988e-33,
-0.0491095036,
-0.0085291145,
0.0240669567,
-0.0307163652,
-0.0155827319,
0.0391750894,
-0.0414923169,
0.0342698321,
-0.0522274859,
-0.0125982817,
-0.0384934098,
0.014080599,
0.009123371,
0.0135729229,
-0.008973307,
-0.0455880426,
0.0005714492,
0.0100909835,
-0.0173737742,
-0.0125516746,
0.0493179895,
0.0318567269,
0.043270018,
-0.0094891833,
0.0127607621,
-0.0167762823,
0.0201848838,
0.027366668,
0.0093235495,
0.084593378,
-0.0045777871,
0.0256322026,
0.0443149358,
-0.0464693457,
-0.0234548133,
0.0409914218,
-0.1139385551,
-0.0139030619,
0.0309702773,
-0.0039088563,
-0.0344101638,
-0.0393331721,
0.0416196696,
-0.0117688477,
0.0360181928,
-0.0203901194,
0.0210075881,
-0.0302590802,
-0.0631987527,
-0.0058863247,
-0.0503902473,
0.0169036724,
0.0095604267,
-0.0136922309,
0.0005529884,
0.0372671299,
0.0091899503,
0.0425287075,
-0.0334233381,
-0.0138934851,
-0.0241254345,
0.0695974752,
0.042061083,
0.0292535089,
0.0001307637,
0.0338591486,
-0.0018436264,
0.0035355468,
-0.0284779891,
-0.0480214916,
0.0495352112,
-0.0109151332,
0.0225325264,
0.0310632531,
0.0153091801,
0.0047196564,
-0.041539643,
0.001667243,
0.0194992889,
0.0357525051,
0.0225379858,
0.0052460935,
-0.0520129204,
-0.0356129631,
-0.0603893995,
0.0079005295,
-0.0468153395,
-0.0099870348,
0.0517105348,
0.0148111684,
-0.0038132658,
0.0016613153,
0.0719461814,
-0.0340743773,
-0.0130029274,
0.0935348645,
-0.0213274769,
0.0360991433,
-0.0020758989,
0.055796247,
-0.031784866,
0.0043188049,
0.0066053267,
-0.0084878681,
-0.031843666,
0.0040804329,
0.0143696247,
-0.0066883648,
-0.062080428,
-0.028968133,
-0.0427387692,
0.0104201809,
-0.0294103883,
0.0125652542,
0.0516867973,
0.0166726541,
0.0167482067,
0.0852315351,
0.0168888308,
0.0114198448,
-0.0316052772,
-0.0523199476,
-0.0112748314,
0.0047273529,
-0.0322422311,
0.0044871294,
-0.0294009391,
0.0479336381,
0.0038477064,
-0.0220385194,
0.0088742441,
0.0540763065,
2.203e-7,
0.0886176303,
0.0114822555,
0.0535529926,
0.0314164273,
0.010349798,
-0.0032316404,
0.0086079976,
0.0133949798,
-0.0065478208,
-0.019946564,
-0.0135639571,
0.0382648371,
0.0233324282,
0.0144926095,
-0.0638247132,
-0.0212401282,
-0.0646751672,
0.0061773062,
-0.0383062176,
-0.0112549253,
0.0218601953,
0.1017331034,
-0.0064182281,
0.0047324519,
-0.0286617745,
-0.0696942508,
0.0578699037,
-0.0233467985,
-0.0034328559,
0.0036654663,
-0.0026202993,
0.0131051065,
0.0432210602,
-0.0113116931,
0.0212842021,
0.0580651276,
0.0306785963,
0.0768957734,
0.0131070316,
-0.0642903298,
-0.0103179635,
-0.0505742282,
-0.019214727,
-0.071694769,
0.1151304394,
-0.030926818,
0.0154406875,
-0.062166106,
-0.0156499036,
0.0038357114,
-0.0029907734,
0.0018380518,
-0.0157402121,
0.0196409114,
0.0103059737,
-0.0322926901,
0.0159810465,
-0.1030535623,
-0.0484380946,
0.0194353051,
-0.0396949612,
-0.0095726727,
-0.0282980446,
-0.0244307891,
0.0264098644,
-0.0585927442,
-0.0280686077,
2.004202945e-34,
0.0546070077,
-0.0248009712,
0.0015834748,
0.0430483967,
0.0233537089,
-0.0227035508,
-0.0348819159,
0.0058308244,
0.0120459944,
-0.0845155418,
-0.0225442946
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.03170v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.03170v2 | Focused Transformer: Contrastive Training for Context Scaling | 2023-07-06T17:52:10 | 2023-11-30T17:15:34 | Szymon Tworkowski, Konrad Staniszewski, Mikołaj Pacek, Yuhuai Wu, Henryk Michalewski, Piotr Miłoś | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models have an exceptional capability to incorporate new
information in a contextual manner. However, the full potential of such an
approach is often restrained due to a limitation in the effective context
length. One solution to this issue is to endow an attention layer with access
to an external memory, which comprises of (key, value) pairs. Yet, as the
number of documents increases, the proportion of relevant keys to irrelevant
ones decreases, leading the model to focus more on the irrelevant keys. We
identify a significant challenge, dubbed the distraction issue, where keys
linked to different semantic values might overlap, making them hard to
distinguish. To tackle this problem, we introduce the Focused Transformer
(FoT), a technique that employs a training process inspired by contrastive
learning. This novel approach enhances the structure of the (key, value) space,
enabling an extension of the context length. Our method allows for fine-tuning
pre-existing, large-scale models to lengthen their effective context. This is
demonstrated by our fine-tuning of $3B$ and $7B$ OpenLLaMA checkpoints. The
resulting models, which we name LongLLaMA, exhibit advancements in tasks
requiring a long context. We further illustrate that our LongLLaMA models
adeptly manage a $256 k$ context length for passkey retrieval. | [
0.0378194191,
0.036115367,
0.0148378713,
0.028039122,
-0.021407662,
-0.0102746803,
0.0030728769,
0.0166189,
-0.0300607588,
-0.0371684246,
-0.0512974299,
-0.0411169715,
-0.0163247716,
0.0154706743,
0.0040239161,
-0.0765634477,
0.0321513489,
-0.0332621038,
-0.0369790494,
0.026081495,
-0.0271550585,
-0.0139994584,
0.0451335087,
-0.0069564888,
0.0182744693,
-0.0360261388,
-0.0048325742,
0.0056606624,
0.0392690562,
-0.0112927621,
0.018380465,
0.0548400171,
0.000928255,
0.0335408337,
0.0000022463,
-0.0385907963,
-0.0214734524,
-0.013885417,
-0.0337897502,
0.0139940558,
0.0728266016,
-0.0178627372,
-0.0137907909,
-0.0018539955,
-0.013268291,
-0.0590119734,
0.011772912,
0.085022144,
0.028271785,
0.0698181838,
-0.0100718914,
-0.0532983504,
0.042504631,
-0.0450523272,
0.0318273827,
-0.0733640715,
0.0270346887,
-0.0481662638,
0.0005419269,
0.0498084389,
-0.0154850977,
0.0639552996,
0.0304605421,
0.0098129055,
0.0581308901,
0.0711214095,
-0.0163636934,
0.0134610226,
-0.0041752192,
0.0373980626,
-0.0535010919,
-0.0421440043,
-0.0133264838,
-0.0381074958,
0.0009432249,
-0.0060635828,
-0.0373684168,
-0.007518685,
-0.0222069491,
0.0063473457,
0.0644302964,
0.0299083889,
0.0321750119,
0.0072603482,
-0.0579701625,
-0.0687553883,
0.0233098846,
-0.0345754251,
-0.0058346558,
-0.0376265422,
-0.0086982986,
-0.0540834963,
0.0190740991,
0.0327583738,
-0.0178452879,
0.0149881821,
-0.0430729464,
-0.0200172048,
0.0251104515,
-0.0809678137,
-0.0084576327,
0.0150989881,
-0.0743479729,
0.0654286519,
-0.0172987804,
-0.0019328533,
-0.0472509041,
-0.0063690227,
-0.0204610098,
-0.0063604303,
-0.0058600241,
0.0266824625,
-0.0347238071,
-0.0053532235,
-0.0310718343,
-0.0239258651,
0.0159359761,
0.0393233933,
0.0257699471,
-0.0142558534,
0.0135365315,
-0.0045596054,
-0.0469874889,
-0.0248320736,
0.0478658006,
0.050001312,
-0.035564959,
-0.0079626916,
-0.0043272609,
-0.0407257527,
-0.0087262923,
0.0124968654,
0.0252476968,
-0.0552977547,
0.0086129308,
0.0157873239,
0.0013605573,
-0.0709537491,
-0.077819556,
0.037359409,
-0.016058363,
-0.0346524194,
-0.0127609447,
-0.0418175198,
-0.0272497982,
0.0019634683,
-0.0059074941,
-0.0366254263,
-0.008214158,
0.035266269,
-0.0305729918,
0.0689317286,
0.0275038201,
-0.0285941027,
0.051029373,
0.0114721311,
0.017015269,
0.0489541329,
-0.01250285,
0.0218141023,
0.0224385522,
-0.0251267795,
-0.0035344476,
0.0088889673,
0.0205096137,
0.0161224492,
0.00271305,
0.0078200046,
0.0159247015,
0.0119699091,
0.0300106406,
0.0634810179,
-0.0470271073,
-0.0262633394,
0.0497600958,
0.0137629407,
0.0609378219,
0.0237361249,
-0.0074591259,
-0.0043869852,
-0.0506840348,
0.0224261526,
-0.0601365678,
0.0247056913,
-0.0164738651,
0.0221976005,
0.0618100166,
0.0034720369,
-0.0398263969,
-0.0056759743,
0.0088777514,
-0.0046292455,
-0.0034602978,
-0.0078481464,
0.0722226948,
0.02301904,
-0.0445885435,
0.0655859187,
0.0166539121,
-0.0247900262,
-0.0132294567,
-0.0346996263,
0.0077198045,
0.0489665419,
0.0453995317,
-0.0345509201,
-0.0177653078,
-0.0086033037,
0.0443133861,
0.0362260379,
0.0226373151,
-0.0028844166,
0.0017938425,
-0.0559473708,
-0.0190091506,
-0.0144867636,
-0.0076415059,
-0.0236694217,
0.0331368446,
0.0161940493,
0.016063923,
0.0157671142,
0.0315410271,
0.0226237569,
-0.0363275446,
-0.0548840612,
-0.0050101872,
0.0188498199,
-0.0043409974,
0.0162577219,
-0.0051376373,
0.0243097097,
0.0312170386,
-0.0299380198,
0.0282074846,
-0.0253239684,
-0.0479337461,
0.0174294841,
0.0298930109,
0.0182450041,
0.0049044932,
0.0239343643,
-0.0098967366,
-0.0273809582,
0.0284935944,
-0.0161084421,
0.0816972554,
0.0063910601,
0.0317446962,
0.0064636413,
0.0181304067,
-0.0523660816,
0.086584121,
-0.0109830946,
0.0136661157,
-0.0071360706,
0.0494073033,
0.0078351423,
-0.0171227865,
0.0264355056,
0.0107115246,
0.0039750105,
0.0148625579,
0.0028142275,
-0.0182441957,
-0.065355882,
-0.0356637836,
-0.0429370478,
0.0085089793,
-0.035523802,
0.0631806403,
0.03221507,
0.0378407091,
-0.0017074085,
-0.0231900141,
-0.0088723265,
-0.0153480303,
-0.019116465,
0.0065304716,
-0.0111432495,
0.0133431191,
-0.0074460981,
-0.052655939,
-0.0476958118,
0.0180598348,
0.0561791249,
-0.0086311046,
-0.030537609,
-0.0541460812,
0.078466922,
0.0603208654,
0.0427127853,
-0.0270555783,
0.0182752982,
0.0015753971,
-0.0553608499,
0.0423112214,
0.079746969,
0.0350454263,
0.0097605949,
0.0090382434,
-0.0272147618,
-0.0248733629,
0.0138834892,
-0.0048748064,
-0.0090880878,
-0.0199718121,
0.0160198752,
0.0097869523,
0.0522390231,
-0.0386694074,
0.0007803597,
-0.0597211532,
-0.0278061554,
0.0062012044,
-0.0145195564,
0.001295825,
0.0080608325,
-0.0486608632,
-0.0008150592,
-0.0290465988,
-0.0210181139,
0.0434942394,
0.0054376968,
0.0095464708,
-0.0566258132,
-0.0032657709,
-0.0333212018,
0.0658390373,
-0.029581869,
-0.0076449565,
0.023836134,
-0.0417378061,
-0.0447924659,
-0.0204426255,
-0.0521138869,
-0.0090801055,
0.1057357192,
-0.0136946347,
0.034592811,
-0.0020605761,
-0.0704709589,
-0.0636604726,
-0.0433241315,
-0.026197901,
-0.0003253949,
0.0263143107,
-0.0273030214,
-0.0545590036,
-0.0014597409,
0.0351454839,
0.1026000753,
0.0100039244,
-0.0375324115,
-0.0037504509,
0.0587017834,
0.0352726169,
0.0114016216,
0.0332139693,
-0.0267511532,
0.0020726703,
0.0685627982,
0.0705975592,
-0.0320903026,
-0.0121965921,
-0.0274722856,
0.0361252949,
-0.0569399521,
-0.0386203192,
-0.0133025916,
0.0202624928,
-0.0686716437,
-0.0465134606,
0.0805472955,
0.0158151891,
-0.1067187935,
-0.0025389236,
-0.0449302979,
-0.0031179201,
0.0048348447,
0.0323095731,
-0.0555064678,
-0.0469450168,
0.0068562427,
0.0459889285,
0.0314295553,
0.016612526,
0.0084258281,
-0.1042970493,
0.0378694721,
0.0262767337,
-0.0527095236,
-0.0289171543,
-0.0617564954,
0.0096475845,
-0.0209398009,
0.0149088698,
0.0489939414,
-0.0410857648,
-0.0269152895,
-0.0120147662,
0.0825512707,
-0.0490786918,
0.0418277048,
-0.0315680653,
0.0129412254,
0.0009605588,
-0.0019893204,
0.0142738763,
-0.0368950181,
0.04128718,
-0.075017862,
0.0063801878,
-0.0026396113,
0.0374568999,
-0.0525855236,
0.0032427234,
-0.0247946884,
0.0284724422,
-0.040944688,
-0.0552574582,
-0.0040961732,
0.0361695439,
0.0012319422,
0.0115691926,
-0.0034670578,
-0.0248165894,
0.008798413,
0.0497307368,
0.0368417613,
-0.0302555952,
0.0020379471,
-0.0047669881,
0.0409402773,
-0.0320118666,
-0.0128073748,
0.0005709634,
-0.0100382008,
-0.0094125522,
-0.0545907319,
-0.0517744608,
-0.010901426,
0.0375384688,
-0.0375321843,
0.0152618987,
-0.0412687436,
-0.0246234536,
-0.0619854406,
0.0437880754,
-0.027764935,
0.0124560958,
-0.0613552518,
0.0195922665,
0.0076800594,
-0.0474694408,
-0.0025784732,
0.0343516842,
-0.0977583304,
-0.0529740676,
0.0273153484,
0.0320527032,
0.0201818682,
0.0505432375,
-0.0160489827,
-0.0799027011,
0.0335569493,
-0.0023310925,
-0.0470754877,
0.0308055356,
0.0219872184,
-0.0483643711,
-0.0112151895,
0.030626066,
-0.0425169691,
0.0014285147,
0.0195480809,
0.017599972,
-0.036061231,
-0.0149550121,
-0.0060381442,
-0.0559106804,
0.0282122921,
-0.0001835009,
0.0228050817,
-0.0338667706,
0.0325852223,
0.0075100111,
-0.001002501,
0.0186919533,
0.0171984024,
-0.0067764889,
0.0024341827,
-0.0059212344,
0.0206921827,
-0.0101324823,
-0.0014313824,
-0.036222849,
0.0298699681,
0.0358112827,
0.0239063017,
0.0252028722,
-0.018334927,
-0.038739983,
-0.0154567985,
0.0275714621,
0.0626643971,
-0.035248071,
0.0446448587,
0.0327114575,
-0.023808185,
-0.0494570211,
0.0519988053,
-0.1009304225,
0.0000162248,
-0.017009547,
-0.0254940167,
0.0499536693,
-0.0247051585,
0.0489132144,
-0.0109147057,
-0.0325910598,
-0.0395767987,
-0.0061436254,
0.0078379726,
-0.004364335,
-0.0284296405,
0.0434198193,
0.036859151,
0.0340568796,
0.0659103692,
-0.0311166774,
0.0572243705,
0.0014252107,
0.023730915,
-0.0299281795,
0.0161539484,
-0.0226888936,
0.0574042462,
-0.0219269991,
-0.0092174467,
-0.0508902818,
-0.0511547551,
0.0481680185,
0.0039585014,
-0.0020503148,
-0.0323945992,
0.0376457796,
0.0454389863,
0.0153749464,
-0.039838165,
-0.0033988433,
0.0320357867,
0.0101561062,
-0.0074186325,
-0.0053086607,
-6.993937921e-33,
0.0119236745,
0.0112807024,
0.0178649649,
-0.0027626925,
-0.0314150788,
0.0466708317,
-0.0535053089,
-0.0278939586,
-0.027223872,
-0.0191910677,
-0.0601740256,
0.034957163,
0.0195116699,
0.0192529745,
0.0064457078,
-0.0088369995,
0.0599235147,
0.0112220226,
-0.0055910251,
0.0680421293,
0.0554585196,
0.032944113,
0.0698993951,
-0.0675884634,
-0.0018426444,
0.0106966412,
0.0191237982,
0.0041686594,
0.0094721522,
0.0612665787,
-0.0296482891,
0.031672217,
0.0219633505,
-0.0977599993,
-0.0175038334,
0.0341763273,
-0.0910265893,
-0.0139092449,
-0.0096633006,
0.005514754,
-0.0218096972,
-0.0701659173,
0.0524680689,
-0.0033307525,
0.0307548903,
-0.0526993275,
0.0114771947,
-0.0112145226,
-0.0616498999,
-0.0047135195,
-0.0587770715,
0.0543356836,
0.0392409898,
0.007670613,
0.035516642,
-0.0074284701,
-0.015604686,
0.0109829465,
-0.051845789,
-0.003219038,
0.0575632825,
0.0585240535,
0.0134149231,
0.0633146763,
-0.020510992,
0.0469297506,
0.0384151489,
-0.0043802247,
0.0124676013,
-0.0606607646,
0.0111395502,
0.0207788367,
0.0146154603,
0.0496644191,
0.0385591649,
0.0028548201,
-0.0575359203,
-0.0075514135,
-0.0223962069,
0.0717073604,
0.0290603209,
0.0514300615,
-0.0349639207,
-0.0145632764,
-0.0343383588,
-0.0146053694,
-0.0403788947,
-0.0077010323,
0.0241513122,
0.0345230065,
-0.0061541195,
0.0398687981,
0.0450336561,
-0.0146673117,
0.0015503786,
0.0623844154,
0.0159943067,
0.0392272137,
-0.0082833981,
-0.0154500343,
-0.0477016047,
-0.009892677,
0.0378592499,
0.0012755917,
-0.0080902893,
0.0111162039,
0.0032809945,
0.0172220208,
-0.0664039552,
-0.0035502785,
-0.0060364571,
0.0041527981,
0.0182189941,
0.0433318242,
0.0660319477,
0.0003932661,
0.0160702951,
0.080152683,
0.0310535301,
0.0175628997,
0.0013067989,
-0.0071455766,
0.0085730003,
0.0435529277,
-0.0038681729,
0.0190222077,
-0.0520595051,
0.0439353436,
0.0541157164,
-0.0652219951,
-0.0148010049,
0.0139503004,
2.927e-7,
0.0308150407,
0.0359296277,
0.0413255095,
0.0078471554,
0.0090950876,
0.0330932923,
0.0259510595,
0.0361460149,
0.0122367954,
-0.0062742806,
-0.0063860663,
0.0231746193,
0.0118311094,
-0.0041017388,
-0.0845560282,
-0.0226295646,
-0.0318245105,
0.0168260932,
-0.025328638,
-0.0209375769,
0.035694886,
0.1413829625,
0.0095446324,
-0.0315516964,
0.0353636481,
-0.0120649887,
0.0403955951,
-0.0218495335,
0.0123329125,
-0.0078296307,
0.0011858143,
0.0038929489,
-0.021769071,
0.0049929689,
-0.0155099388,
0.043790549,
-0.006464086,
0.062731795,
0.0047310255,
-0.0492700189,
0.0307450369,
0.0004555121,
-0.0361029692,
-0.0621540397,
0.0701613203,
-0.0586731993,
-0.0112111242,
-0.0320356227,
-0.0421084017,
0.0021206532,
-0.0167085249,
-0.0128209284,
-0.0168975107,
0.0187475886,
-0.0084475987,
0.034008272,
-0.0244426951,
-0.1187963039,
-0.0304083489,
0.020056542,
-0.0304108858,
0.0005061451,
-0.0531172156,
-0.027002953,
0.0134040676,
-0.0277968999,
0.0038362783,
2.58704886e-34,
0.0434101187,
-0.0096028242,
-0.0032901249,
-0.0059636887,
-0.020032648,
-0.0121450908,
-0.0397644043,
0.0261728577,
0.0484068058,
-0.1007160768,
-0.0267628711
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.03135v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.03135v3 | Distilling Large Vision-Language Model with Out-of-Distribution Generalizability | 2023-07-06T17:05:26 | 2023-10-11T23:38:36 | Xuanlin Li, Yunhao Fang, Minghua Liu, Zhan Ling, Zhuowen Tu, Hao Su | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Large vision-language models have achieved outstanding performance, but their
size and computational requirements make their deployment on
resource-constrained devices and time-sensitive tasks impractical. Model
distillation, the process of creating smaller, faster models that maintain the
performance of larger models, is a promising direction towards the solution.
This paper investigates the distillation of visual representations in large
teacher vision-language models into lightweight student models using a small-
or mid-scale dataset. Notably, this study focuses on open-vocabulary
out-of-distribution (OOD) generalization, a challenging problem that has been
overlooked in previous model distillation literature. We propose two principles
from vision and language modality perspectives to enhance student's OOD
generalization: (1) by better imitating teacher's visual representation space,
and carefully promoting better coherence in vision-language alignment with the
teacher; (2) by enriching the teacher's language representations with
informative and finegrained semantic attributes to effectively distinguish
between different labels. We propose several metrics and conduct extensive
experiments to investigate their techniques. The results demonstrate
significant improvements in zero-shot and few-shot student performance on
open-vocabulary out-of-distribution classification, highlighting the
effectiveness of our proposed approaches. Poster:
https://xuanlinli17.github.io/pdfs/iccv23_large_vlm_distillation_poster.pdf
Code: https://github.com/xuanlinli17/large_vlm_distillation_ood | [
-0.0010654939,
0.0282703973,
0.0087021431,
0.0642567426,
-0.000313812,
0.0164452884,
-0.0043046079,
-0.0069780061,
-0.0344429649,
-0.0565278158,
-0.0149294855,
-0.0386947766,
0.0101049719,
0.0204936042,
-0.0122531373,
-0.1136793643,
-0.0208275616,
-0.0547405109,
-0.0401818864,
0.0100410273,
-0.0112042734,
0.0011338938,
0.0074830959,
0.0168852005,
0.0424859151,
-0.0334403664,
-0.0000914356,
0.0317661986,
0.0300030746,
0.0278929919,
-0.0334587544,
0.0232964959,
0.0471669771,
-0.0102205817,
0.0000022383,
-0.0421795882,
0.0049846577,
0.0039023233,
0.025675917,
0.0445597284,
0.0543923229,
-0.0177755505,
0.0179578941,
0.0042920783,
-0.0158310384,
-0.0222194418,
0.0858775005,
-0.0045977738,
0.0285265595,
0.0190736223,
-0.0115164062,
-0.0194246359,
0.0340549797,
0.0152145931,
0.0205787048,
0.0048060636,
0.0134821534,
0.0456554629,
-0.0041479873,
-0.0205192659,
-0.0781637356,
0.0561377667,
0.0286822505,
0.0151312994,
0.019356003,
0.0205204673,
-0.018066328,
-0.0384943597,
0.0049978672,
0.0808082893,
-0.0616612323,
-0.0071515399,
-0.0072163655,
-0.0108476179,
0.0000699998,
0.0270925444,
-0.0583371557,
0.0435165614,
0.0024527311,
0.0443034694,
-0.0446989238,
0.0048252004,
0.0031207646,
0.0049228901,
-0.0469299965,
-0.0572919697,
0.0117578041,
0.0130382339,
-0.031553939,
-0.0032757071,
-0.0649997294,
-0.0316672102,
-0.0272540804,
0.0385139696,
0.0427680612,
0.0130048636,
-0.0818638802,
-0.0250708703,
-0.027499048,
-0.007980844,
0.0823561028,
0.0275520664,
-0.0550657101,
0.0321280509,
-0.0006077771,
0.0833915398,
-0.0187395997,
0.0881203488,
-0.0413061194,
-0.0169138964,
-0.0613155514,
0.0140030812,
-0.0198970437,
0.0055775261,
-0.0071407207,
-0.0105681997,
-0.0296422839,
-0.0183515809,
-0.0352413505,
-0.0341176204,
0.0092984745,
0.0315163955,
-0.0147164464,
-0.0202125199,
-0.0120124929,
0.0761440247,
0.0392873362,
-0.0089678466,
-0.0405667424,
-0.0757646561,
-0.0053125201,
0.0191120375,
0.0214081891,
0.0230031218,
-0.0248800889,
0.0396366753,
-0.0266950168,
-0.0641101003,
-0.0363778919,
0.0011714546,
-0.0129143065,
-0.0507180728,
0.0114032375,
-0.0962320715,
-0.0405622683,
0.0088923462,
0.0143798394,
-0.0735997409,
0.0250347126,
0.0069651492,
-0.0007340827,
0.0109454505,
-0.036402747,
0.0085024172,
0.0018296717,
0.0242064279,
0.0337103531,
0.0666702986,
0.0301079098,
-0.0018421737,
-0.0003385803,
-0.0031726079,
0.0407140665,
0.0461400226,
-0.0037761242,
0.0273386799,
-0.0899004042,
-0.0268130414,
0.0360685997,
0.0017573627,
0.0436810032,
0.0488580428,
-0.0356804915,
-0.0085515808,
0.0501169302,
0.0113320947,
0.0339684524,
-0.0474835746,
0.0115331877,
0.0411973372,
0.0150503311,
0.0107128546,
-0.0191396885,
0.004454542,
0.0453279391,
-0.0017298908,
-0.0223510135,
0.0648550838,
-0.0384851582,
-0.0674720779,
-0.019724736,
-0.0343653113,
0.0092921378,
0.0382603221,
0.1008025333,
0.0246738642,
0.0143149048,
0.0344272591,
0.0748094544,
-0.0343539231,
0.0146678332,
-0.0943434983,
-0.01790227,
0.0072174119,
0.0193335954,
-0.0234809089,
0.0119457012,
0.0025775945,
0.0242282618,
0.0145687545,
-0.001977423,
-0.0099489,
0.0268615931,
-0.0753075629,
-0.0563814491,
0.0248746816,
0.0234658439,
-0.0173866954,
0.0168258846,
-0.0033528274,
0.0392288938,
-0.0851992294,
-0.0491004474,
0.0341589153,
-0.0030889991,
-0.0491882823,
-0.0159406196,
0.0143807,
-0.0032715979,
0.0005270154,
-0.0142176887,
-0.0203895848,
0.0132327015,
-0.0333921425,
0.0585014038,
-0.0384098701,
-0.0526555367,
0.0161067229,
0.0533428416,
-0.0485785119,
0.0120699946,
0.0250906069,
-0.032531254,
-0.042162396,
0.0192417521,
-0.0180344786,
0.0102027776,
-0.014377675,
0.0302324221,
-0.0164106917,
0.0067746886,
-0.0229256507,
0.0448412932,
-0.0251069404,
-0.0245625824,
0.0246490054,
-0.0056328699,
0.0300319698,
-0.0006997631,
-0.0161809735,
0.0219751354,
-0.0304929409,
0.0535661615,
-0.0217027534,
-0.0003173889,
-0.0311840139,
-0.0078507634,
-0.0378537364,
-0.0371849351,
-0.031854324,
-0.0275786165,
0.0259137452,
0.009622721,
0.0085995337,
-0.0318563767,
-0.008934658,
0.0424043983,
-0.0265475512,
-0.0286626313,
-0.0252978951,
-0.0086072274,
-0.0444408134,
0.0258481279,
-0.0163558405,
0.0151631497,
0.0606577061,
-0.009189913,
-0.0043685604,
-0.034910854,
0.0372527055,
-0.024663128,
0.0468196496,
-0.001163092,
0.0146460766,
-0.0022219974,
-0.0403601937,
0.01247901,
0.0795321316,
-0.0144755794,
0.0258879699,
0.0927292928,
-0.0148839215,
-0.0516536273,
-0.0137200747,
0.0230855923,
-0.0450399034,
-0.0042542256,
0.0013839344,
-0.0611697137,
0.0183643177,
0.0007233068,
-0.0152125005,
-0.0614115037,
-0.0060906671,
-0.0254930872,
-0.030824177,
-0.06583599,
0.0331716873,
-0.0107520651,
0.0091269361,
-0.0177165009,
-0.0779995322,
0.0096576586,
-0.0131573686,
0.0218833666,
-0.0235425942,
0.0078739533,
-0.009870586,
0.0548722595,
-0.015505339,
0.0044283681,
0.0141812451,
0.0087092137,
-0.0813955367,
-0.0300902762,
0.0014318625,
-0.0274706297,
0.0832394138,
-0.0862731561,
-0.0174086951,
-0.0388979092,
0.0112850014,
-0.016738683,
-0.0193297956,
-0.0162973907,
0.0338255055,
-0.0733590573,
-0.0300740674,
-0.0455594771,
0.0047757523,
-0.0005210486,
0.0297335442,
-0.0099500148,
0.00697737,
-0.0137210628,
0.0405420028,
0.0454641506,
-0.0080727078,
-0.0544398315,
-0.0428001285,
0.0014842667,
0.0569396839,
0.0346164629,
-0.0203984436,
-0.037845064,
-0.005506631,
0.0488173515,
0.0553397499,
-0.0188600626,
0.0667427555,
0.0452451445,
-0.066961728,
-0.0110965837,
0.0468688682,
0.0182994623,
-0.030040456,
-0.0212124828,
0.0033915092,
0.0550956465,
0.0174153615,
-0.0128578302,
-0.0697570667,
-0.0394379571,
-0.0261225905,
-0.0027296937,
0.0493747555,
0.0039575971,
-0.0296305418,
-0.0846098363,
0.0265475027,
0.043248374,
-0.0140837701,
-0.0441805907,
0.0028686756,
0.0179791823,
-0.0143641764,
-0.0193627514,
-0.0279736742,
-0.0335275717,
0.0141607933,
0.0245063938,
0.0352873206,
-0.0403954163,
0.0235303435,
-0.0166888218,
-0.0271150749,
0.0449680947,
0.0014801138,
0.003678455,
-0.074066177,
0.0098399222,
-0.0264309961,
-0.0034427615,
0.0138035137,
0.0662268996,
0.0149412109,
-0.0134327151,
0.0241681114,
0.0545276739,
-0.0090813152,
-0.019252345,
-0.0195660014,
0.0584555566,
0.0254767835,
-0.0096857101,
-0.042818822,
-0.0399203151,
0.0184836034,
0.0300193448,
0.0288009662,
-0.0520972274,
-0.0162403807,
-0.0113062086,
-0.0177883022,
0.0115531245,
-0.0205482766,
0.0322427191,
0.0109760407,
-0.0669900998,
-0.025409719,
0.0023269863,
0.0383834057,
0.0497133359,
-0.0103903692,
-0.0312768742,
0.0134912794,
0.0208503176,
-0.0541102439,
0.0383865424,
-0.0395094864,
0.0276559014,
-0.02620974,
-0.0339135081,
-0.0085921036,
-0.0389793515,
-0.0341043435,
0.0279245079,
-0.0901580155,
-0.0589833334,
0.0344214477,
0.0404332839,
0.0217983369,
0.038653791,
0.03179745,
-0.0476698764,
0.1021622345,
0.0165381059,
0.0621650703,
0.0332864299,
0.0094146114,
-0.0364777632,
0.0111597609,
0.027202066,
-0.0252845623,
0.0163543858,
0.047032211,
-0.0190807246,
-0.0299609806,
0.0080770766,
0.0018190223,
-0.0144938724,
0.0738980174,
0.0026789063,
-0.0135884378,
-0.0414758325,
0.0117335152,
0.0102424016,
0.0192613751,
-0.0816115439,
0.0122830607,
0.066435568,
0.0153478961,
0.020618625,
0.0206122603,
0.0121345511,
0.0087316148,
-0.0249906052,
-0.0011551122,
0.0109222308,
-0.0445915237,
0.0344192758,
0.0351917446,
-0.0070686061,
0.0369485468,
-0.0190903619,
0.011611945,
0.0100892456,
0.0698595941,
0.0004383916,
0.0429915041,
-0.0208897982,
0.0089574549,
-0.0436500125,
-0.030799428,
-0.0573145486,
0.0525240861,
-0.0016902649,
0.0104875825,
0.0243259817,
-0.0060993624,
-0.0154220797,
-0.0528474748,
0.0511467569,
-0.0232369993,
-0.006002544,
0.0563308969,
0.0114573026,
0.0228777193,
-0.0375636183,
0.0714464337,
0.013226293,
0.0045237844,
-0.0083922064,
0.046880316,
-0.0220853668,
0.0013884957,
0.0598680116,
0.0085520959,
0.0351338051,
0.0669617429,
-0.0322268195,
-0.040906515,
-0.0145238321,
0.0118157687,
-0.0067254165,
-0.0315945819,
0.0649753809,
0.0377642773,
-0.0207735635,
-0.0028378137,
-0.0142160039,
-0.0687217787,
0.0256608389,
-0.0292622764,
0.0320334248,
-5.931340987e-33,
-0.0122995814,
0.0093783224,
0.0128372619,
-0.0028774783,
-0.0031475071,
0.0172093827,
0.0242214985,
0.0392093547,
-0.0525913015,
0.0162551124,
0.0319283754,
0.0267768055,
0.0215452723,
0.0718801469,
-0.0188998915,
0.0288426764,
0.0468865298,
0.0108259842,
0.011228892,
0.0297654346,
0.0243467018,
0.0095274393,
0.0548805371,
-0.069166854,
-0.0193324778,
-0.0119514083,
0.0060892329,
-0.0071348874,
0.0114164501,
0.0421846546,
-0.0243627522,
0.0808421671,
0.0198039282,
0.0030171154,
-0.0554522276,
0.0097593404,
-0.0395897143,
-0.0215696506,
-0.0032445625,
0.0144568114,
-0.0548843332,
0.0077523803,
0.0559230074,
0.0163930599,
-0.0296852347,
-0.0946688876,
0.0640757158,
-0.0270300247,
-0.0372556411,
0.0343825407,
-0.0503507927,
0.016232403,
-0.0006376026,
-0.0722303465,
0.0632624105,
-0.0063528204,
-0.0100207925,
0.0102264602,
-0.0126165766,
0.0275701135,
0.0757640898,
0.0475766324,
0.0879902169,
0.0935028195,
-0.0004266966,
0.0658036172,
0.0027895661,
-0.0390576087,
-0.0259082559,
-0.0674947724,
0.0725063235,
0.0611720979,
0.0206077434,
0.0623703189,
0.0603952371,
0.0172052346,
-0.0776858106,
-0.0013737625,
-0.0818438753,
0.0334685631,
-0.0136487251,
0.0017869467,
-0.0087641608,
-0.0395203829,
-0.0311291926,
-0.03934839,
-0.0263745897,
0.0136536565,
0.0439498462,
-0.0028655052,
-0.0297222827,
-0.0132904993,
0.0413479395,
-0.0617065877,
0.0006194759,
0.0263706204,
-0.0243441015,
0.0328208283,
-0.0032817326,
-0.0130986618,
-0.0617489628,
-0.0343144983,
0.0274323057,
0.0183918271,
-0.0016062413,
0.0203930531,
0.0359772332,
0.0261318088,
-0.0429272428,
0.000645328,
-0.0444928855,
-0.0426978469,
0.0258009639,
0.0675917342,
0.0277447756,
0.0022448241,
-0.0320602022,
0.0663628206,
0.0178198386,
-0.0315766409,
-0.0051337914,
-0.0330172107,
0.0176546164,
0.0052336804,
-0.0029268439,
0.0094733303,
-0.0285465326,
-0.0177292787,
0.0574029349,
-0.017779123,
-0.005658627,
0.0156900082,
2.658e-7,
0.0534003749,
-0.0083551276,
-0.0121066431,
-0.0367302708,
-0.0185840372,
0.0482657552,
0.0039071389,
0.0189350229,
0.0140343886,
-0.0955410302,
-0.0009562973,
0.0604209565,
0.0283483639,
-0.0065598669,
-0.036469128,
0.0763769299,
-0.0007751887,
0.0000104571,
-0.0158631895,
0.0089383619,
0.0616242476,
0.0824332386,
0.0037287346,
-0.0289198104,
0.0143936425,
-0.0370228104,
0.0443055071,
-0.0200447496,
0.0373945124,
-0.013507599,
0.0020311305,
-0.0140576717,
0.0084667141,
0.0126296077,
0.0068197497,
0.0128213353,
0.034797959,
0.0061445036,
-0.050336346,
0.0293980986,
-0.026012253,
0.0257344674,
-0.0442046933,
-0.0795950294,
0.0508743227,
-0.0549026206,
-0.0062775207,
-0.003473066,
-0.0198702905,
-0.0033461023,
0.0225046221,
0.0013065799,
0.0249282718,
0.0000477865,
0.0027719494,
-0.0307459272,
-0.0395901985,
-0.0495559126,
-0.0435437597,
-0.0334463641,
-0.0213636942,
-0.0537836403,
-0.0100032995,
-0.0223640464,
0.0168677792,
0.0154156135,
-0.0017484271,
1.984311147e-34,
0.0107794665,
0.0287200008,
0.0059153182,
-0.0250987839,
-0.0290886145,
-0.0367807448,
-0.0445382223,
0.0048427493,
0.0031661848,
-0.0651987121,
-0.0060158256
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.03132v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.03132v2 | T-MARS: Improving Visual Representations by Circumventing Text Feature Learning | 2023-07-06T16:59:52 | 2024-03-18T22:18:02 | Pratyush Maini, Sachin Goyal, Zachary C. Lipton, J. Zico Kolter, Aditi Raghunathan | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | Large web-sourced multimodal datasets have powered a slew of new methods for
learning general-purpose visual representations, advancing the state of the art
in computer vision and revolutionizing zero- and few-shot recognition. One
crucial decision facing practitioners is how, if at all, to curate these
ever-larger datasets. For example, the creators of the LAION-5B dataset chose
to retain only image-caption pairs whose CLIP similarity score exceeded a
designated threshold. In this paper, we propose a new state-of-the-art data
filtering approach motivated by our observation that nearly 40% of LAION's
images contain text that overlaps significantly with the caption. Intuitively,
such data could be wasteful as it incentivizes models to perform optical
character recognition rather than learning visual features. However, naively
removing all such data could also be wasteful, as it throws away images that
contain visual features (in addition to overlapping text). Our simple and
scalable approach, T-MARS (Text Masking and Re-Scoring), filters out only those
pairs where the text dominates the remaining visual features -- by first
masking out the text and then filtering out those with a low CLIP similarity
score of the masked image. Experimentally, T-MARS outperforms the top-ranked
method on the "medium scale" of DataComp (a data filtering benchmark) by a
margin of 6.5% on ImageNet and 4.7% on VTAB. Additionally, our systematic
evaluation on various data pool sizes from 2M to 64M shows that the accuracy
gains enjoyed by T-MARS linearly increase as data and compute are scaled
exponentially. Code is available at https://github.com/locuslab/T-MARS. | [
0.0125479624,
0.0616251156,
0.0020783967,
0.0697270781,
-0.0438786969,
0.0166005865,
0.0357350856,
0.0498353615,
0.0115912072,
-0.0757016614,
-0.0371712074,
0.0294682123,
0.0026187452,
0.0652048439,
-0.0340424366,
-0.0517450534,
-0.0196372904,
0.0002477803,
0.0020071871,
-0.0068101939,
0.0345911942,
0.0031251514,
-0.0022188886,
0.0158300456,
0.0125063537,
-0.011923464,
0.020724671,
0.0124386279,
0.0568167455,
-0.0294466615,
-0.0073758834,
0.0320327282,
0.024394175,
0.0498822816,
0.0000022909,
-0.0114063062,
0.0079584653,
0.009422427,
0.0340495482,
0.0062849647,
0.0699326321,
-0.0168419555,
0.020164622,
-0.0334152877,
-0.0250272248,
0.0063809911,
0.0941062421,
0.0392814539,
0.0499770083,
0.0235579554,
-0.0361109413,
-0.0089909537,
-0.0311286468,
-0.0153761273,
0.0370078348,
-0.015934946,
0.0296138469,
0.0188726913,
-0.0212470032,
-0.0193920806,
-0.0560109541,
0.0492655672,
-0.0206451323,
-0.0049220575,
0.0116872825,
0.0668354854,
-0.0369499139,
-0.0477470085,
0.0197627693,
0.0898929909,
-0.0338080861,
-0.0064646429,
-0.0056599658,
-0.0215719622,
-0.0249964595,
-0.0038551306,
-0.033009965,
0.0156935006,
0.0276212115,
0.0472479537,
-0.1152951196,
0.0136124734,
-0.0021644144,
0.0102894353,
-0.0478505567,
-0.0617565438,
0.0110571655,
0.0276312325,
-0.0228175875,
0.0036147055,
-0.0156314336,
-0.0195214059,
0.0375093892,
-0.0055579566,
0.0346332192,
-0.0393013954,
-0.038182389,
-0.0330508947,
0.0094581321,
-0.0209727995,
0.0512033179,
0.014627791,
-0.0737530738,
0.0869426876,
-0.0639208183,
0.0460950658,
0.0285448581,
0.0290310718,
0.0107626747,
-0.009256226,
-0.0332052745,
-0.0011584404,
0.0209964924,
0.012305594,
-0.0140200844,
-0.0187732913,
-0.0175347719,
-0.0468087681,
-0.0500460267,
0.0265410095,
-0.0560695454,
0.0229357798,
-0.0263738353,
-0.0034639544,
-0.0304512121,
0.0148644857,
0.0254937317,
0.0234705973,
-0.043720033,
-0.0427837446,
0.0082147699,
0.0312866531,
0.0571084432,
-0.0087755257,
0.0417864695,
0.0826009884,
-0.0251869597,
-0.0680451915,
0.0149768619,
0.0021851289,
-0.050557632,
-0.0317651853,
0.0196309816,
-0.0361049548,
0.0245555285,
-0.0398430191,
0.0191483814,
-0.0307947714,
0.0212255977,
0.0480454452,
-0.0213127062,
0.1245105118,
-0.0043723183,
-0.0468906909,
-0.002793747,
0.0149964374,
-0.036793787,
0.038014058,
0.0317612998,
0.0559004433,
0.0198936909,
0.0128622884,
0.0154396957,
0.023428455,
0.0185088981,
-0.0020629719,
-0.0322613865,
-0.0225236993,
0.0102256294,
0.0105256038,
0.0538295731,
0.0128925312,
-0.0379696786,
-0.0385218002,
0.0721664354,
0.0098914336,
-0.0462808833,
0.0073170364,
-0.0135963922,
0.0351145156,
-0.0027665973,
-0.024293758,
-0.0229388177,
0.0532023683,
0.0031345563,
-0.0222528167,
0.0015615597,
0.0383541733,
-0.0432709418,
-0.0232591797,
0.0192743111,
-0.023414243,
0.028567981,
0.0023193033,
0.0622035861,
-0.0058935801,
-0.0175304636,
0.0133946529,
0.0159519091,
-0.026026722,
-0.0162121728,
-0.0458318219,
-0.0002646113,
0.0220510568,
0.0478613377,
-0.0474578477,
-0.0128378291,
-0.0056884363,
0.0293410514,
0.0427997261,
-0.0204599928,
0.0180604719,
0.055330433,
-0.0754177943,
-0.0565842129,
-0.0138730323,
-0.0421882458,
0.0121493535,
-0.0137982601,
0.0150410654,
0.0402417518,
-0.001948548,
-0.0329338983,
0.0630401969,
0.0344166271,
-0.0284786187,
-0.0041561546,
0.0310522057,
0.0185085461,
0.0033363863,
-0.0204771012,
-0.0203656908,
0.0228646751,
-0.0458040051,
-0.0169982389,
-0.0176848583,
-0.0143920695,
-0.0215677507,
0.060123574,
-0.0954124853,
0.0264162701,
0.0601504147,
-0.0229568835,
0.0072696232,
0.0016352115,
-0.0267116409,
-0.0322373919,
-0.0443453752,
-0.016072236,
-0.0211261157,
0.0305564031,
-0.0078780828,
0.0467824861,
-0.0089024594,
0.0020594387,
0.0090335952,
-0.0429862514,
0.024569625,
-0.0113453129,
-0.033108931,
-0.0111319833,
-0.0186884254,
-0.0061109029,
0.0082003148,
0.0313555487,
-0.0262593664,
0.0208860394,
-0.0623787306,
-0.0227855723,
0.0053366087,
-0.0423758365,
-0.01445032,
-0.0192901343,
0.0251948778,
-0.0590077117,
-0.0252626054,
-0.0089173084,
-0.0475208685,
0.0145639079,
0.0290648118,
0.0147581631,
-0.0114158392,
0.0004729382,
-0.012367459,
0.022233678,
0.0621928498,
-0.0060217935,
-0.0580240451,
0.0123663787,
0.0312370919,
-0.0226932541,
0.0139186019,
-0.0141913556,
0.0054128729,
0.0073671956,
-0.0114700226,
-0.0243853498,
0.0435065515,
0.0110838078,
-0.01750651,
0.0226966199,
0.0033037183,
-0.017461177,
-0.0126896221,
0.0115770521,
0.0149350474,
0.0243855342,
-0.020041896,
-0.0333824605,
-0.0139456699,
-0.0366321504,
0.0513231419,
-0.0757057369,
0.0214358941,
0.0051124059,
-0.0376819409,
-0.0690454468,
0.0398663022,
-0.0085666273,
-0.021904001,
-0.0539285839,
-0.037752863,
0.0252673402,
-0.0156575534,
-0.0317084007,
-0.0123312799,
0.0295835044,
-0.0203626808,
0.0709954351,
0.0391314216,
0.0513659231,
0.0211455002,
-0.0171775613,
-0.0320434794,
-0.0149927242,
0.0112054758,
-0.0234463532,
0.0367909335,
-0.0021343764,
0.0046827481,
-0.0200834256,
-0.0441190228,
-0.0177931041,
-0.0219792686,
-0.0302221309,
-0.0310157854,
-0.0615113638,
-0.0234877467,
-0.026431689,
-0.0101421792,
0.0079817232,
0.0510100424,
0.0175813884,
-0.0049540871,
-0.0014214164,
0.0598401539,
0.0093633756,
0.0098039703,
-0.026678104,
-0.0087073436,
0.0030489468,
0.0440286882,
0.0038032338,
-0.0307044499,
-0.001741568,
0.018599974,
0.0301667284,
0.0408057198,
0.0244003404,
0.0246803779,
0.0397445001,
-0.0341324024,
0.0011767108,
0.0679833815,
0.0160795525,
-0.0345333107,
-0.0364381447,
0.0228268467,
0.040417172,
0.031121742,
-0.0266496874,
-0.093880713,
-0.0666765943,
-0.0111542791,
-0.0147550516,
-0.0029153095,
0.0103659267,
-0.0516967475,
-0.0474861823,
0.0303955153,
0.0373499654,
-0.049795907,
-0.0427893735,
-0.0075113098,
0.000674603,
-0.040655084,
-0.0424887985,
-0.0252218358,
-0.0105509935,
-0.0172803793,
0.0107004959,
0.0253784973,
-0.0505370311,
0.0080890637,
-0.0421838351,
-0.0297606438,
0.0431040712,
0.0744782016,
-0.0107907895,
-0.0455072336,
-0.0269248597,
0.0093467953,
0.0119170602,
-0.0187119953,
0.1328407675,
-0.0362831801,
-0.0418873504,
0.0017256016,
0.0489319414,
-0.0195709653,
-0.02023785,
-0.0131240645,
-0.0016490292,
0.012327089,
-0.02179542,
-0.0446436331,
-0.0025846479,
-0.0037300638,
0.0433588997,
0.0430652462,
-0.0339821205,
-0.0269506238,
0.009259426,
-0.004446859,
-0.040949747,
-0.0227237381,
0.0076174093,
-0.0085338298,
-0.024653716,
-0.0469860286,
-0.0140516916,
0.0333749503,
0.0066897217,
-0.0045554931,
-0.0212883782,
-0.0672013164,
0.0462065041,
-0.0678307265,
0.021977216,
-0.080500856,
0.011063992,
-0.0034136171,
0.0286592655,
0.0329770148,
-0.0460034348,
-0.0496649183,
0.0338247269,
-0.104237847,
-0.0260003023,
-0.0145374294,
0.0409048162,
0.0161277112,
0.0067399642,
0.0396618731,
-0.0402925722,
0.0693717301,
0.0836194307,
0.0049797934,
-0.0014299437,
0.0488751978,
-0.0656488389,
-0.0068481942,
0.0250628702,
-0.0340843238,
0.0612357147,
0.0128297936,
-0.0285818465,
-0.0006683171,
0.0258668885,
0.0025029536,
0.0034486467,
0.0651616082,
-0.0512568578,
0.0045944238,
-0.0244625695,
-0.0002060594,
0.0198667757,
-0.0068151611,
-0.04785024,
0.0088232728,
-0.0112455785,
0.0267867055,
-0.0265800878,
0.0259821843,
0.0321276896,
0.0052747009,
-0.017021453,
0.0106437542,
0.015674809,
-0.0094615966,
0.0082050068,
0.0267346893,
0.0146845505,
0.0258408338,
0.023570383,
0.0085082892,
-0.0014529286,
0.026898982,
0.0296882447,
-0.005061713,
-0.0452472605,
0.0541770943,
-0.0181944016,
-0.0168436188,
-0.0703939497,
-0.0063299169,
0.0564120449,
-0.0204053968,
0.0218419805,
-0.0245762784,
-0.0206730068,
-0.0387676135,
0.0015236161,
-0.0108731017,
-0.0069739139,
0.0195849277,
0.0044351146,
-0.0178140663,
0.0033956908,
0.0933333039,
0.0199636761,
0.0271179415,
0.0197942108,
-0.0053991596,
-0.0434144773,
-0.0018462841,
0.0457097962,
0.0338307507,
-0.0020950937,
-0.0067996718,
-0.0274233427,
-0.0324859768,
0.0276939403,
-0.0441209339,
0.0123702167,
0.0290308706,
0.0440191664,
-0.0117620891,
0.0222638566,
0.0080136228,
0.0205924865,
0.0002296612,
0.0159674007,
-0.0074624084,
0.0215079039,
-6.230065693e-33,
0.0107430182,
-0.0179498587,
-0.0071925665,
0.0246743225,
-0.0019615151,
0.0275244359,
-0.0031029077,
-0.0101208463,
-0.0209781919,
0.0088802036,
0.0337136015,
0.0024442291,
0.0220382437,
0.0195091348,
-0.0212611221,
-0.0001845489,
0.0720809922,
-0.0127026755,
-0.0083233817,
0.0239175223,
0.0073955529,
0.0390181951,
0.0000776457,
-0.0744562671,
-0.019082211,
0.0077993614,
-0.0597018525,
-0.050122831,
0.0511853956,
0.0596694723,
-0.0507163964,
0.0327354819,
0.0168848932,
0.0018890696,
-0.0465353988,
0.0042507858,
-0.07549081,
-0.0072816927,
-0.0486573018,
0.0245175287,
-0.016271092,
-0.0313390307,
0.0602936298,
-0.0189722776,
-0.0266472958,
-0.044172354,
0.0665166527,
-0.0393738709,
0.0029079046,
-0.0168805085,
-0.0299491193,
0.0404271223,
-0.0211842712,
-0.0289187245,
0.1045799032,
0.0364776738,
0.0337867327,
0.0951038897,
-0.0727183297,
0.0322476588,
-0.0129216164,
0.0024607987,
0.0698993802,
0.0431365594,
0.0354839936,
0.1199250072,
0.021952996,
-0.0388025381,
0.0199473687,
-0.0192546677,
0.0597092248,
0.0500598215,
0.070038259,
0.0392167978,
0.0882272497,
-0.0239939112,
-0.0740003213,
0.0244284626,
-0.0840741917,
0.0127244042,
0.030616153,
0.045170702,
-0.0301154945,
0.0244986583,
-0.0278443862,
-0.0295028705,
-0.0686388612,
-0.0081133964,
0.0328090601,
0.0325947516,
-0.0469919518,
0.024922464,
0.0430111811,
-0.050136365,
-0.0124996249,
-0.0202919133,
-0.0199889317,
0.0371606871,
0.0114576854,
-0.0472056121,
-0.0572058633,
-0.0381728709,
0.0485764854,
-0.0156537499,
0.0125532895,
-0.0216892269,
0.0789515376,
0.0440120697,
-0.0450786911,
-0.0308075398,
-0.0281170718,
-0.0314539857,
0.0331320688,
0.0637368113,
0.0190194193,
0.0157749802,
-0.0147603489,
0.0204020627,
0.0040902211,
0.0005810662,
-0.0181571692,
-0.0395122953,
0.0257615931,
-0.0059242556,
-0.0033520358,
0.0017374525,
-0.0286220778,
-0.0066903266,
0.0310851745,
-0.0668803528,
-0.0520688109,
0.0052393535,
2.79e-7,
-0.0002398076,
0.0370972939,
0.02081188,
-0.023111783,
-0.0039459257,
0.0787354931,
-0.0155434767,
0.0321271718,
-0.0057130461,
-0.0213705432,
0.0357402638,
0.0163193624,
0.030816121,
0.0106190424,
-0.0305811577,
0.0211679731,
-0.0080333753,
-0.0615177155,
-0.0297100842,
-0.0095711146,
0.055086799,
0.1014861837,
0.0241272226,
-0.0361550078,
0.0701162219,
-0.065209344,
0.0972925574,
-0.040941447,
0.0403120629,
-0.0259635653,
-0.0156357065,
0.0453856289,
-0.0433018766,
0.0065152831,
-0.0318101384,
-0.0178411938,
0.0839870498,
0.0329216048,
-0.0394430123,
-0.0000390559,
-0.0079352278,
0.0534281023,
-0.011592241,
-0.0223665182,
0.0882174596,
-0.0181403756,
-0.0257830434,
-0.0507824458,
-0.0245583635,
0.0132643795,
0.0412881896,
-0.0283119194,
-0.0383489206,
0.031904541,
0.022620324,
0.0134838643,
-0.0389634371,
-0.0963722914,
-0.0463400632,
-0.0337157883,
-0.0378112011,
0.0033459053,
-0.083214052,
-0.0041502849,
0.0262027886,
-0.0304352473,
-0.0300351828,
2.50565506e-34,
-0.0191712324,
-0.0458346754,
0.0012303457,
0.002936156,
-0.0123290094,
0.0244803745,
-0.0367052816,
-0.0076825363,
-0.0064108376,
-0.0472198837,
0.0090150703
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.03131v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.03131v2 | BLEURT Has Universal Translations: An Analysis of Automatic Metrics by Minimum Risk Training | 2023-07-06T16:59:30 | 2023-07-10T15:59:49 | Yiming Yan, Tao Wang, Chengqi Zhao, Shujian Huang, Jiajun Chen, Mingxuan Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automatic metrics play a crucial role in machine translation. Despite the
widespread use of n-gram-based metrics, there has been a recent surge in the
development of pre-trained model-based metrics that focus on measuring sentence
semantics. However, these neural metrics, while achieving higher correlations
with human evaluations, are often considered to be black boxes with potential
biases that are difficult to detect. In this study, we systematically analyze
and compare various mainstream and cutting-edge automatic metrics from the
perspective of their guidance for training machine translation systems. Through
Minimum Risk Training (MRT), we find that certain metrics exhibit robustness
defects, such as the presence of universal adversarial translations in BLEURT
and BARTScore. In-depth analysis suggests two main causes of these robustness
deficits: distribution biases in the training datasets, and the tendency of the
metric paradigm. By incorporating token-level constraints, we enhance the
robustness of evaluation metrics, which in turn leads to an improvement in the
performance of machine translation systems. Codes are available at
\url{https://github.com/powerpuffpomelo/fairseq_mrt}. | [
0.0070429868,
0.0519907996,
-0.0028943992,
0.0221981537,
-0.0178269837,
0.0040397057,
-0.0110033127,
-0.0105236126,
-0.0400261544,
-0.0216425266,
-0.055348631,
-0.0510987528,
0.0166464634,
-0.0032773563,
0.0414766185,
-0.0502683632,
0.0342560485,
0.0432746224,
-0.0185824148,
0.0080201169,
-0.0041570305,
0.0017206571,
0.0041378113,
0.0624178983,
-0.035206899,
-0.0049595805,
0.0545221977,
0.0412288643,
0.0470087416,
-0.0177311283,
0.0033145179,
0.0140971038,
-0.0276101269,
0.0755653381,
0.0000020202,
-0.0469273292,
-0.0132791344,
0.0047368798,
0.0147343716,
-0.0069742627,
0.0531946532,
-0.0681633279,
-0.0016130208,
0.0103634717,
-0.0411158241,
-0.0372925624,
0.0656656325,
0.0169583187,
0.0315141343,
0.0904022381,
-0.0127109075,
-0.0445897244,
0.0078364033,
-0.0576627925,
-0.0292305462,
-0.0778898448,
-0.0226729605,
0.014813941,
-0.0750947893,
0.0031379978,
-0.0124222683,
0.0320531018,
0.0435910337,
0.0119232703,
0.0246245489,
0.0096735274,
-0.0234794971,
-0.0333664194,
-0.0168496221,
0.0512487032,
-0.0387066081,
-0.0141389314,
-0.0338643938,
-0.0099412445,
-0.001082017,
-0.0632845089,
-0.0156365037,
0.0045039793,
0.0074603972,
0.0061987368,
-0.0340222456,
0.059247151,
0.0457950197,
-0.007165222,
-0.0262841359,
0.0032575368,
0.0253915414,
-0.0206332635,
0.0060153608,
0.0094646979,
-0.054068733,
-0.0164239872,
0.0390423499,
0.0122929169,
-0.0026754506,
-0.0022030061,
-0.0400893278,
-0.0578582436,
0.044653222,
-0.057173036,
0.029186612,
0.0427788943,
-0.0115025695,
0.0363148972,
-0.0244910475,
0.0977146327,
0.0017084513,
0.0564137511,
-0.0557035506,
0.0174505617,
-0.0179533884,
0.0191427171,
-0.0366279595,
-0.0325285159,
-0.0320825689,
-0.0150627783,
-0.0412707329,
0.0116044004,
-0.0156628974,
0.0044249711,
0.0247402359,
-0.0101907374,
-0.0836968943,
0.0017694589,
-0.0189822614,
0.0221524499,
-0.0441184677,
-0.0066068573,
0.0085428897,
-0.0300744642,
-0.0294496678,
0.0364413857,
-0.044512216,
-0.0593879074,
0.0007125188,
0.1176506728,
-0.0111279404,
-0.0383891165,
0.0148548624,
-0.0058968891,
-0.0715044439,
-0.0719931051,
-0.0110363979,
-0.0274569634,
0.0274561755,
-0.0126740029,
0.0013977634,
-0.0378839225,
0.0005567765,
-0.0032182315,
0.0008592244,
0.045471184,
0.0559821501,
-0.016533738,
-0.0089490721,
0.0118015138,
0.0019944219,
0.0640987381,
0.0315993428,
0.0486872494,
0.0571430176,
0.0234561004,
-0.0299314633,
0.0494126752,
0.0284077879,
0.0425042212,
-0.0189095065,
0.0115068937,
0.0186308455,
0.040639963,
0.0399184749,
0.028864298,
-0.0460079797,
-0.0256498288,
0.0980060622,
-0.0201811753,
0.0108118868,
0.0315230042,
0.0369333439,
-0.0408843942,
-0.0045284671,
0.0091406498,
-0.0414561629,
0.0342193097,
-0.0020673785,
-0.0097085098,
0.0343184136,
0.05484429,
-0.0112951789,
-0.0549089126,
0.0026856849,
-0.015124009,
-0.0024371629,
-0.0439817645,
0.0314253904,
0.0505315475,
-0.0256764237,
0.0390286706,
-0.0311480723,
-0.0439266711,
0.0240342226,
-0.0149020255,
-0.0343727693,
-0.0178514812,
0.065603897,
-0.0206898768,
0.0032608723,
-0.0089294035,
-0.0200290214,
0.0250979122,
0.0553968474,
0.0109721916,
0.0456416532,
-0.0304849632,
-0.0091340411,
-0.0346680842,
0.0478647985,
0.0212793332,
0.0114786057,
0.0489904322,
0.0371042304,
-0.1005348712,
-0.0672085211,
0.0532280467,
0.042744901,
-0.0314700715,
0.0327014625,
0.0333936661,
0.0340069272,
0.0068168081,
-0.0321072154,
0.0175891053,
0.0250269379,
-0.0317735448,
-0.0217573922,
0.0255544484,
-0.0219055712,
-0.0225369073,
0.0381902866,
-0.0616227947,
-0.0050264425,
0.058434099,
-0.0421176143,
0.004975596,
0.0077347802,
-0.0234773364,
-0.0049795778,
-0.0267893728,
0.0182506498,
-0.0084268954,
0.0146817975,
-0.0519198738,
0.0423320942,
-0.0176956765,
0.0011203194,
-0.0496424288,
-0.0143743316,
0.040107213,
0.0080542266,
-0.0153295556,
0.0257545449,
-0.0026060571,
0.0639598966,
0.0604339838,
0.0362440087,
-0.0135010285,
-0.0621278249,
-0.056624338,
0.0367874838,
-0.0495612212,
0.0347108431,
0.0756961107,
0.0286422968,
-0.0057866662,
-0.0162028018,
-0.0326921679,
-0.0129271401,
-0.0143385213,
0.0057960432,
0.0358157493,
0.0192687381,
0.0094530219,
-0.0046079252,
-0.0191982407,
0.0009380784,
0.0445407592,
-0.0057468466,
0.0318553001,
-0.0119070997,
0.0367124192,
-0.0319524109,
-0.0196818169,
-0.0159527175,
-0.0872062966,
0.0080470508,
0.0278875604,
0.0277170185,
0.0831915438,
0.0130400658,
0.0407098681,
0.0287776198,
0.0449513234,
-0.0301735736,
-0.0079876017,
-0.056282863,
-0.0511636361,
-0.0062278267,
-0.038516961,
0.0171904992,
0.0308749061,
0.0239145719,
-0.0236106403,
-0.0533753708,
0.0207709521,
-0.0288642924,
-0.0575379133,
-0.0200837646,
0.0323656276,
-0.0089568943,
0.0305823777,
-0.0542525686,
-0.0552750006,
0.052216623,
-0.0222893693,
-0.0134025821,
-0.0682084262,
-0.0113015762,
-0.0295472182,
0.0425840542,
0.0138118453,
0.0322170295,
-0.0424497984,
0.0030555171,
-0.0544079468,
-0.0057787728,
0.028124271,
-0.0042533139,
-0.0023463515,
-0.0228481237,
-0.0251422208,
-0.0414681882,
-0.0205789544,
-0.0152437957,
-0.015634777,
0.0250828862,
-0.0003057155,
0.0034431317,
-0.0122767482,
-0.0446607135,
-0.0020518759,
0.0052738972,
0.0372708142,
-0.0495779179,
-0.0067555876,
-0.0180281214,
0.0280767828,
0.0138878226,
-0.0237834547,
0.0456284434,
-0.038741786,
-0.0104363952,
0.0290439855,
-0.009624769,
0.0176649541,
-0.0257454179,
-0.0165395942,
0.0074306545,
0.0235901419,
0.0134199969,
0.0170361754,
0.0926275104,
-0.0157115869,
-0.0393917635,
0.062618494,
0.0038989126,
-0.0021964104,
0.0201466568,
0.0128748976,
0.0768329576,
0.0272893701,
-0.0375983566,
-0.0475845858,
-0.0292684231,
-0.0043858951,
0.0380475931,
0.0247287471,
0.001725576,
-0.0063516977,
-0.0341723673,
-0.0257240664,
0.0427632779,
-0.0817585886,
-0.037723802,
0.0018127722,
-0.0053056995,
-0.0644934475,
0.0569259413,
-0.0374169759,
0.0340328924,
0.0161316376,
0.021459572,
0.0088595469,
-0.0491686091,
0.0013315052,
-0.0437219068,
-0.0112278704,
0.0973523036,
0.0362240337,
-0.0125955492,
-0.0084003685,
0.0267846975,
-0.0175492335,
-0.008045557,
0.0331944898,
0.0603132173,
-0.0233434383,
-0.0225673504,
0.0283380952,
-0.0054671564,
-0.0029375185,
0.0249868017,
-0.0005786307,
0.0130583728,
0.0104413433,
-0.0080522057,
-0.0162816551,
-0.004005197,
0.0253766365,
0.0615611821,
0.0458225757,
-0.043806117,
-0.0314979106,
-0.0139344083,
0.0255067907,
-0.0733152777,
-0.0129545443,
0.0128229922,
-0.0423126183,
-0.060774751,
-0.0854241103,
-0.0871758759,
-0.0215769969,
0.0499915257,
0.0014576024,
-0.0420661531,
-0.0402215309,
-0.0114608053,
-0.0212930236,
0.0413090922,
-0.02010311,
0.0276730396,
-0.0316683725,
0.0265232101,
-0.0090100048,
-0.0029458092,
-0.0184373781,
0.0554242171,
-0.0870238319,
-0.048620902,
-0.0168362968,
0.063280426,
0.0294391643,
0.0093032075,
-0.0551392175,
-0.0122116869,
0.0518245809,
0.0404599309,
-0.0381912291,
0.0265181717,
0.0708548203,
-0.0379892103,
-0.0108663533,
0.0545683578,
-0.0264972951,
-0.0021103271,
0.0296855755,
0.0650466904,
0.0064894347,
-0.0369166322,
0.0393978134,
0.0109150819,
0.056935925,
-0.0423067212,
-0.0314520262,
-0.0051599117,
-0.0116651449,
0.0047185388,
-0.018714888,
-0.0374967232,
-0.0175412558,
0.0621564835,
0.0472975634,
-0.0242488366,
0.025590403,
-0.0005069044,
0.0219846815,
0.0142386993,
-0.0084813116,
0.0177485105,
0.0510387234,
0.005992827,
0.0348428972,
-0.0439654626,
-0.0039655869,
-0.0050066803,
-0.0018745542,
-0.0052851681,
0.0105560431,
0.0411025882,
0.0331463851,
0.0112627586,
0.0764395744,
-0.0409312956,
0.0174062867,
-0.0397192799,
-0.0028553293,
0.0601492412,
-0.001389379,
0.0829515159,
-0.0043648034,
-0.0310833808,
-0.0484352112,
0.0330470763,
0.0090342555,
-0.0157174636,
0.0021082815,
-0.0269346926,
0.0129831173,
-0.0026332128,
0.0667333826,
-0.0621489584,
0.0392920002,
0.0028386386,
-0.0185707416,
-0.0332062952,
-0.0203671958,
0.0111704124,
-0.0258816183,
0.0130867539,
-0.0360596962,
-0.0585420802,
-0.0790534914,
0.0010986326,
0.0408983231,
0.0052511855,
0.021335423,
0.0142891044,
0.0861034319,
-0.0431080759,
0.0258600805,
-0.0488624163,
-0.013981319,
-0.0151989534,
0.0103261126,
-0.0319732465,
-6.397427436e-33,
-0.0200679544,
-0.0094167432,
-0.023192374,
-0.0640297681,
-0.0448121466,
-0.0027362066,
-0.0182156768,
-0.0304453056,
-0.0222638547,
0.0242271964,
0.027946705,
0.0061181276,
-0.0063473131,
-0.0183973256,
-0.0277421139,
-0.0128975343,
0.0429775827,
0.0082919002,
-0.068242237,
0.0023531069,
0.0144472113,
-0.0083914315,
0.06195857,
-0.0689087361,
0.0454680324,
0.0301043168,
-0.028688604,
0.0145293316,
0.0264833272,
0.0305827372,
-0.0027185553,
0.0586954989,
0.0216238238,
-0.011846289,
-0.0362198725,
-0.0208838694,
-0.070276238,
-0.0415782332,
0.013014745,
0.0486568697,
-0.0320422351,
-0.0393571146,
0.052542299,
-0.0339416787,
-0.0346946083,
-0.0253107138,
0.0175599884,
-0.036985755,
-0.0444338024,
-0.0156096742,
-0.0391109064,
0.0063124984,
-0.0290142205,
-0.0045680651,
-0.0072667743,
0.0338848345,
0.009915689,
-0.0119781224,
-0.0276849288,
-0.0026319528,
-0.0404353403,
0.052248843,
0.0420410335,
-0.0029622847,
0.0087763723,
0.0325288139,
0.0487908013,
-0.0088439975,
0.0148947947,
-0.0222032573,
0.0357831419,
-0.0263194963,
0.0673135221,
0.0764999166,
0.0422998071,
-0.0002203165,
-0.1006350368,
0.0492347851,
-0.0387470797,
0.031074198,
0.0005593044,
0.0220569186,
-0.0343216546,
0.0165493283,
-0.0408224575,
-0.0723522604,
-0.0261228234,
-0.0189513322,
0.0273827855,
0.0061602173,
-0.0108970823,
-0.009368889,
0.0064145825,
-0.0171379447,
0.0399357751,
0.0021570125,
-0.0054833144,
-0.0106371352,
0.0060360543,
0.0502514578,
0.004283282,
0.0253340602,
0.023050474,
0.051081907,
0.0524097122,
-0.0191759747,
0.0853977427,
0.0156171396,
-0.02473142,
0.0152232097,
-0.0447392091,
0.0208000541,
0.0010717118,
0.0188421234,
0.0155711155,
-0.0261378828,
-0.0233257767,
0.0269591827,
0.0303151216,
0.0101347724,
-0.0280421618,
0.0123920487,
0.0287162773,
0.0621748306,
-0.0590067282,
-0.0097295037,
-0.011014658,
0.0108505916,
0.0550036393,
-0.0862952098,
-0.0212379023,
-0.0088197626,
2.686e-7,
0.0675131828,
0.0347250924,
0.0199477859,
0.0143896965,
-0.0003762468,
0.0446414202,
-0.0382882729,
0.0669711605,
-0.0105506843,
0.0193556175,
0.0201564301,
0.0141169028,
0.0557635315,
0.0149048585,
-0.0505759269,
0.0020266846,
-0.0687442794,
0.0441608727,
-0.0364094563,
0.0104409717,
0.0507274456,
0.0757025331,
0.0151752736,
0.0197975673,
0.0043661864,
-0.0673439354,
0.0623984374,
-0.0200196411,
0.019275954,
0.0034412583,
0.0540300719,
0.0254682731,
0.0054146983,
0.0102791972,
-0.0238782503,
-0.0003393787,
0.0589725152,
0.0526234545,
-0.0043225167,
-0.0285247434,
-0.0153473131,
-0.0208348949,
-0.0109468857,
-0.060314022,
0.0432611443,
-0.0490566902,
-0.0304728877,
-0.004203883,
-0.0383300111,
0.0229250323,
0.0930577517,
-0.0256767254,
-0.0525581911,
-0.0045365761,
0.0403187498,
0.0237583145,
-0.0011411716,
-0.060054265,
-0.0238612052,
-0.0105978455,
0.0183051061,
-0.0714814439,
-0.00928682,
0.0572349802,
0.000100924,
-0.0573753044,
-0.0132267009,
2.592453838e-34,
0.0535576791,
-0.0342573747,
0.0319765061,
-0.0590270422,
0.0304823723,
-0.0380921848,
-0.0018764611,
-0.0426614285,
-0.0092356205,
-0.0279569309,
-0.0244793985
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.03130v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.03130v1 | VisKoP: Visual Knowledge oriented Programming for Interactive Knowledge Base Question Answering | 2023-07-06T16:58:27 | 2023-07-06T16:58:27 | Zijun Yao, Yuanyong Chen, Xin Lv, Shulin Cao, Amy Xin, Jifan Yu, Hailong Jin, Jianjun Xu, Peng Zhang, Lei Hou, Juanzi Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | We present Visual Knowledge oriented Programming platform (VisKoP), a
knowledge base question answering (KBQA) system that integrates human into the
loop to edit and debug the knowledge base (KB) queries. VisKoP not only
provides a neural program induction module, which converts natural language
questions into knowledge oriented program language (KoPL), but also maps KoPL
programs into graphical elements. KoPL programs can be edited with simple
graphical operators, such as dragging to add knowledge operators and slot
filling to designate operator arguments. Moreover, VisKoP provides
auto-completion for its knowledge base schema and users can easily debug the
KoPL program by checking its intermediate results. To facilitate the practical
KBQA on a million-entity-level KB, we design a highly efficient KoPL execution
engine for the back-end. Experiment results show that VisKoP is highly
efficient and user interaction can fix a large portion of wrong KoPL programs
to acquire the correct answer. The VisKoP online demo
https://demoviskop.xlore.cn (Stable release of this paper) and
https://viskop.xlore.cn (Beta release with new features), highly efficient KoPL
engine https://pypi.org/project/kopl-engine, and screencast video
https://youtu.be/zAbJtxFPTXo are now publicly available. | [
0.0473643839,
0.0038135846,
-0.0092211431,
0.0180845968,
0.0206208881,
0.0147780413,
-0.0555233471,
0.0325361788,
0.0121697504,
-0.0049368753,
0.0118209329,
0.0825763941,
-0.0114199994,
0.0653684959,
0.0439576432,
-0.1058053151,
0.0206916742,
0.0097759198,
0.0217464492,
0.016234627,
0.0341063365,
0.0061493749,
-0.0571342111,
0.0176665802,
0.0019710052,
-0.03920215,
-0.0348054022,
-0.0338010639,
-0.0028822764,
-0.0253762137,
-0.0319421589,
0.044280123,
0.0113059878,
-0.0274964552,
0.0000024167,
-0.0277390163,
-0.0096629411,
0.0206538346,
-0.0800196081,
0.0125817573,
-0.0540017188,
0.0000070052,
0.0150608635,
0.0073416415,
-0.0364749581,
-0.0360237993,
0.0544403382,
0.0481686033,
0.1066046208,
0.0224325638,
0.0036135614,
-0.0000402687,
0.0191536769,
0.0201138649,
0.0208748933,
-0.0262174886,
0.0053996756,
0.0365176536,
0.0236127861,
0.0137705877,
0.0206219796,
0.0644687265,
0.004057873,
-0.0381570533,
0.0395196117,
0.0180446319,
-0.0187904574,
-0.034479022,
-0.0069817198,
0.0822170451,
0.0012582139,
0.0036941606,
0.0181288347,
0.0199891683,
0.0415070578,
0.0305579081,
-0.0490968302,
-0.0041055591,
-0.0239029787,
-0.0763657317,
-0.0277507156,
-0.0136011904,
-0.0069965613,
-0.026111247,
-0.0081255725,
0.0172088593,
0.0123599805,
-0.0377308503,
0.0101863341,
-0.0006471691,
-0.0211011395,
-0.0658060238,
0.012977506,
0.0780865029,
-0.0371413492,
0.0289486367,
0.007562906,
-0.0093784407,
0.0242033377,
-0.0559337735,
0.0075668492,
0.0315403007,
-0.0043445774,
0.0529889502,
-0.0063630263,
0.067088142,
0.0088138701,
-0.0123589365,
0.0095916111,
0.0005231883,
-0.0789425075,
-0.0252935793,
-0.0650096089,
0.0035561221,
-0.0409314297,
0.007513795,
0.0032055639,
0.0604600683,
-0.0230267718,
0.0534479432,
-0.0266247559,
0.0559141003,
0.0322417729,
0.0148049528,
-0.1130834594,
0.0511462428,
-0.0831881762,
-0.0381814726,
-0.0430245623,
-0.0041455138,
0.0003268719,
0.0021431353,
0.0083859097,
-0.0048630466,
0.0123645226,
0.0368901789,
-0.002057645,
0.0497851707,
-0.0323528387,
-0.0707935616,
0.0204985272,
0.0027371764,
0.0012577533,
-0.0802565068,
0.0451323427,
0.0014833743,
-0.0463994443,
-0.0372996554,
0.0087431148,
0.0558599122,
-0.0282021724,
0.0575548261,
-0.1052505225,
-0.0113605093,
0.0254741609,
-0.0054359627,
-0.0361755863,
0.0380544588,
0.003196016,
-0.0046976027,
0.0277958773,
-0.0022184416,
0.0086154183,
0.0008829635,
0.0542277358,
0.0001304102,
0.0223902669,
0.0581777506,
-0.0177441835,
0.0576932877,
-0.009142464,
-0.0136246374,
-0.0366265178,
-0.0052888524,
-0.0126783829,
0.0218902808,
0.0248085167,
0.032773111,
0.0145004326,
0.0062715476,
0.0443559736,
-0.0222137664,
-0.0614909232,
0.0716461614,
-0.0240812823,
0.0130556375,
-0.0261890106,
0.0115913767,
0.0056737005,
-0.0233879667,
-0.0003896709,
0.0430847369,
0.0132840332,
0.0072094132,
0.0246747639,
0.0361594297,
-0.0084020384,
0.052168496,
0.0098496424,
-0.019673042,
-0.0460692048,
-0.0296769459,
0.0491124839,
0.0980880335,
0.0347001962,
-0.0561181456,
-0.0349884182,
-0.0036114196,
-0.0387278348,
0.0308415797,
0.008811825,
-0.0544949993,
-0.0513401255,
0.0112947207,
-0.0357537642,
-0.0183475781,
0.0014443166,
0.0090537015,
0.0273587536,
0.0071188319,
-0.0169600807,
-0.0348985903,
0.0545518398,
0.030963745,
0.0274869818,
-0.0117828976,
-0.0522696748,
0.0523821898,
-0.0322832242,
0.030171236,
0.0135873361,
0.0344109386,
0.0290081315,
-0.0081422441,
-0.0558960065,
-0.041513674,
0.0103408052,
-0.0912317038,
0.0463044457,
-0.0121833226,
-0.0402344242,
-0.0507014245,
-0.0361861996,
-0.0289435778,
0.0370235033,
-0.031145459,
0.0039290613,
-0.0097178863,
-0.0202739686,
0.0114576193,
-0.0301113911,
-0.0327676758,
0.0740356669,
0.0402467102,
-0.0021002598,
0.0544171296,
-0.0048193294,
0.033241652,
-0.0492766835,
0.0138264848,
0.0030644734,
-0.0154708307,
0.004169073,
0.0017101658,
0.019509038,
-0.0569060147,
0.0505864099,
-0.1086879298,
0.021972822,
-0.001505591,
0.0184087064,
0.0306373816,
0.0260807425,
-0.0022509452,
-0.0579810143,
-0.0413421839,
0.0225210264,
-0.0202630069,
0.0141065866,
0.0488623716,
0.0249053556,
0.0384596512,
-0.0149324425,
-0.0115293665,
-0.0176544171,
0.0374145061,
0.0348925665,
0.0129174422,
-0.0415167436,
0.019748589,
-0.0608712621,
0.0240668636,
0.032403443,
0.0084300712,
0.0095710186,
-0.0220371895,
-0.0102111679,
0.0464078709,
-0.0245497972,
0.0105920248,
0.025713224,
-0.0053969794,
-0.0622886643,
0.0391754434,
0.0289337374,
0.0284457859,
0.0300183557,
0.0196234323,
-0.005954612,
0.0409079902,
-0.0117309773,
-0.0016054643,
-0.0339258686,
0.0674321651,
0.0389060266,
0.0336602367,
-0.0696577802,
-0.0070161517,
0.0317474939,
0.0273356084,
-0.0254811738,
0.0178773031,
0.062311843,
0.0088600451,
-0.0164255295,
-0.0202267151,
0.0062473649,
-0.0074915597,
0.091966711,
0.003074585,
0.0103817862,
0.0000277365,
-0.0183729865,
-0.0293892343,
0.0291029699,
0.0099370563,
-0.0100392289,
0.0197419506,
-0.0255179293,
0.0022718117,
-0.016063232,
-0.0060630171,
-0.0453590378,
0.015774617,
-0.0437554233,
0.0082265735,
0.0446163379,
-0.0242739823,
0.0293747354,
-0.0190402865,
0.0392559953,
-0.0265640225,
0.0189691056,
-0.0374359824,
0.0159780271,
0.0022366804,
0.031580586,
0.0623460338,
-0.0032598397,
0.0392478444,
0.0226582047,
0.0662060007,
0.00027336,
-0.0047990857,
-0.0134799303,
0.005582287,
-0.0237621516,
-0.0569221675,
-0.0420266911,
-0.0200413745,
-0.0120024709,
-0.0696400627,
0.0263413768,
0.0733947009,
0.0277439859,
-0.0010502094,
-0.0047032028,
-0.0172567759,
0.0069377883,
0.0503748246,
0.0862952769,
-0.1159465015,
-0.0306880604,
-0.0164697487,
0.0254792813,
-0.0068453928,
-0.0502770543,
-0.0036635522,
-0.0949366614,
0.0111572146,
-0.0440193899,
-0.0511582606,
-0.0298374631,
-0.0496317782,
0.010205809,
-0.005800006,
-0.0426225141,
0.0534584522,
-0.0141897015,
0.0248683412,
-0.0229205601,
-0.0212610811,
-0.0117490469,
0.0469944291,
-0.0350762717,
0.020958351,
0.0613538101,
0.0476896986,
0.0120940348,
-0.0176561568,
-0.0587463304,
0.0086109703,
0.0103690578,
-0.023808131,
0.0843389481,
0.0239597019,
-0.034588974,
-0.0634453744,
-0.0294427853,
-0.0051267277,
0.0254433621,
0.0492230691,
0.0721787661,
-0.011394185,
0.0130650988,
-0.0215824042,
-0.0192839857,
-0.0114815328,
0.0075073051,
0.0115819117,
0.0023555963,
-0.043450132,
-0.0566087067,
-0.0245223865,
-0.0559016429,
-0.032937184,
0.0252592843,
-0.0200193077,
-0.0116855297,
-0.1169637963,
-0.0070317336,
0.090555802,
0.0479448736,
0.0064853402,
-0.0333515182,
0.0376700535,
0.0028010523,
-0.0469943136,
0.0121129192,
-0.0099832853,
0.0165422224,
0.0087281764,
-0.0336219557,
-0.0150232492,
-0.0014228947,
-0.0290588792,
-0.0161625277,
-0.0092670685,
-0.0293629039,
-0.0178363379,
0.040072374,
0.010142534,
0.0183582455,
-0.0204599705,
-0.0137873041,
0.0421204157,
0.0510957837,
-0.060959544,
-0.0443588533,
-0.0406129695,
-0.010429699,
-0.0002426457,
-0.0122132199,
-0.0828552321,
-0.0680828393,
-0.044627551,
0.0199526921,
-0.0432734638,
0.0208868347,
0.0139496494,
0.0406433977,
-0.0313923769,
0.0437654033,
-0.0273216311,
-0.0127338236,
-0.0067150733,
-0.0099775027,
-0.024878839,
-0.0313299485,
0.0344933569,
-0.0376730077,
-0.0380394869,
0.0760122016,
0.0023337833,
0.0069997092,
-0.0415348671,
-0.015428653,
-0.0008543406,
0.060932532,
0.0253060069,
0.0215964392,
0.0170287248,
-0.0210989509,
0.0352138802,
0.011759839,
0.0756269917,
-0.0414508916,
0.0419058017,
0.0228422265,
-0.0323995054,
-0.0130906748,
0.0021011757,
-0.0362283401,
-0.0901192054,
0.0377498195,
0.045843821,
0.0753471479,
0.0415712669,
0.0073426771,
-0.0138908485,
-0.0201357435,
0.0469392389,
-0.0347607546,
-0.0020403678,
-0.0141562885,
0.0355015621,
0.0285527501,
0.016827032,
-0.0456448942,
0.0509703681,
-0.0045589986,
0.0476235077,
-0.0148955984,
-0.0384205766,
-0.0405704789,
-0.0027627805,
0.0040833591,
0.0152712185,
-0.0378051847,
-0.0071803331,
-0.0239648577,
-0.0547190569,
-0.0019835553,
0.0045626201,
-0.0490659773,
0.0354446582,
0.0770009831,
0.0151330288,
0.0731299296,
-0.051788263,
-0.0140986955,
0.0584760234,
-0.0556695089,
-0.0309814326,
0.0096488213,
-6.276931918e-33,
-0.0718226433,
-0.048908107,
0.04323145,
-0.0271973182,
-0.0148595199,
-0.0645533055,
-0.0236720257,
0.0320434608,
-0.0213421918,
0.0257409085,
0.0042015254,
-0.0175664537,
-0.0075236335,
-0.0237432774,
0.0129867587,
-0.0200071111,
0.0278633013,
0.0294884518,
0.0080377795,
0.0090730703,
0.0418437235,
0.0356297754,
-0.0009013081,
-0.0663859472,
0.0390336029,
0.0233204253,
0.0174234007,
0.0284729674,
-0.0171918776,
0.0532959998,
-0.0115077365,
0.0548717268,
0.0045535676,
-0.0318329558,
-0.0126821408,
-0.020017134,
-0.0958904773,
-0.0509118922,
0.0070584426,
0.0337448195,
-0.0741761401,
0.0077185845,
0.0522333831,
0.0042399918,
0.0603366718,
-0.0083874157,
0.0491884351,
-0.0115790805,
-0.0000727716,
0.0092419395,
-0.0325628594,
-0.0019252439,
-0.0121125439,
-0.0298059117,
-0.0468804352,
-0.006794157,
0.0077575869,
-0.0534245409,
-0.0679847151,
-0.0048914491,
0.0268042516,
-0.0052532651,
0.0147487829,
0.0094425734,
0.0179194026,
0.003180838,
0.0101685887,
-0.0200282242,
-0.0394226424,
0.0658907443,
-0.0093672685,
0.0750341415,
0.0887830928,
0.0081525901,
0.0232237056,
-0.0094435327,
-0.0316153429,
0.0184247587,
-0.0299328193,
0.0461208299,
-0.0473133177,
-0.0122010522,
-0.0160326343,
-0.0252309162,
-0.029871542,
0.0107220402,
-0.0539085232,
-0.0496762432,
0.0234411974,
0.0058994121,
-0.0053343088,
-0.0219826698,
-0.0334147066,
-0.015493473,
0.0233869962,
0.0203760881,
-0.0004261478,
0.0058873082,
-0.0065002386,
0.0079133231,
-0.0073049972,
0.0391097888,
0.0138084618,
-0.0535693541,
0.0160029903,
0.0642179325,
-0.0008311265,
-0.0163899995,
-0.0449489504,
0.0093073957,
-0.0242302958,
-0.0138408793,
-0.0050873095,
-0.0090339156,
-0.0057707373,
-0.0037349362,
-0.0259797536,
0.0137151033,
0.0325993858,
0.0108692301,
-0.0220729485,
-0.0488898233,
0.0169746839,
-0.0054387921,
-0.018970266,
-0.009852034,
-0.0288467482,
0.0045757308,
-0.0618831925,
-0.0438477732,
-0.0180770252,
0.0025157684,
2.973e-7,
0.0497526526,
0.0376599878,
0.0306368005,
0.0685033575,
0.0037237804,
0.0167546943,
0.0251637977,
0.0064300671,
0.0144861117,
-0.0303876549,
-0.0103591494,
0.0079255672,
-0.0153362527,
0.0422766805,
-0.0761648491,
-0.0443334132,
0.0206253622,
-0.0450948738,
-0.0532128476,
0.0094764875,
0.097064659,
-0.0010322453,
0.0162465405,
0.0184411351,
0.0413184203,
-0.0423228554,
0.024319578,
0.0615943186,
0.0191897377,
0.0034550005,
0.017818179,
0.0626493543,
-0.0214515533,
0.0554814152,
0.0014736078,
-0.0050184438,
0.0072680805,
0.0164363254,
-0.0318724662,
0.0127195027,
0.0029383095,
-0.0755596235,
0.0429982431,
-0.0585018024,
0.0734578297,
-0.0393552147,
0.023077121,
0.0472850055,
-0.0145470779,
-0.0460861325,
-0.0031779103,
-0.0392079204,
0.0065253945,
-0.0154167498,
-0.0055990336,
-0.0097074499,
-0.0073600467,
-0.0210842881,
-0.0205776207,
0.0293570403,
-0.001381828,
-0.0186596271,
-0.0296629705,
-0.0270198528,
-0.0018503862,
0.0196982361,
-0.0208273642,
2.605088106e-34,
0.0058626067,
0.0361797884,
0.0113145346,
0.0086579956,
0.0529615693,
-0.0033547953,
-0.0309118442,
-0.0327236094,
0.0335294046,
-0.053963609,
-0.0285562091
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.03214v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.03214v1 | PREADD: Prefix-Adaptive Decoding for Controlled Text Generation | 2023-07-06T16:56:46 | 2023-07-06T16:56:46 | Jonathan Pei, Kevin Yang, Dan Klein | cs.CL | cs.CL | We propose Prefix-Adaptive Decoding (PREADD), a flexible method for
controlled text generation. Unlike existing methods that use auxiliary expert
models to control for attributes, PREADD does not require an external model,
instead relying on linearly combining output logits from multiple prompts.
Specifically, PREADD contrasts the output logits generated using a raw prompt
against those generated using a prefix-prepended prompt, enabling both positive
and negative control with respect to any attribute encapsulated by the prefix.
We evaluate PREADD on three tasks -- toxic output mitigation, gender bias
reduction, and sentiment control -- and find that PREADD outperforms not only
prompting baselines, but also an auxiliary-expert control method, by 12% or
more in relative gain on our main metrics for each task. | [
0.0359995551,
0.044661779,
-0.0176842008,
-0.0273084529,
0.014579895,
0.0063757719,
0.0583650284,
0.022099698,
0.0018520696,
-0.036822021,
-0.011769399,
-0.0147322994,
-0.0257227942,
0.0677148253,
0.0397208966,
-0.0530912615,
0.0244432632,
0.028436251,
0.0534548424,
-0.0045939577,
0.0549495816,
0.0245600101,
0.0039646579,
0.0564395487,
-0.0225671083,
-0.0159962866,
0.016466001,
0.0391872153,
0.0035341431,
-0.0125481291,
0.0404037125,
0.0645946413,
-0.0299164113,
0.0107516851,
0.0000020013,
-0.0305545796,
-0.0166122559,
-0.0025555124,
0.0053319465,
-0.0276352521,
0.0397310778,
0.0059881615,
-0.0226457231,
0.0555726252,
-0.0373349227,
-0.0327141955,
0.0530559346,
0.039083004,
0.1010485664,
0.0714304298,
-0.018527057,
0.0429403745,
-0.0201349203,
-0.0230255146,
0.0143929496,
0.0239470694,
-0.002803711,
-0.0693877041,
-0.0398775749,
0.0255329628,
0.0051607555,
0.0303386655,
0.010719968,
-0.0333658382,
0.0279836357,
0.0244064443,
0.0685476959,
-0.0476888344,
-0.0383324996,
0.0432518721,
-0.0159398168,
-0.0036710054,
0.0065882998,
-0.0285455808,
0.0376025699,
-0.0581815392,
-0.0459178388,
0.0303918421,
-0.0272759832,
-0.0198687743,
-0.0280801859,
0.0207467545,
-0.0171800032,
0.0283745006,
0.0164212584,
0.050802853,
0.017868951,
-0.0493088365,
-0.0039980705,
0.0605765358,
0.0318544023,
-0.062274158,
0.0419545211,
-0.0031158603,
-0.0497594997,
0.0020465481,
-0.0739433691,
-0.0830766186,
-0.0061963201,
-0.0119002461,
0.0209453274,
0.0396948606,
0.0008084566,
-0.0257746577,
-0.05720466,
0.0589545183,
-0.0039821025,
0.0481020547,
-0.0066627595,
0.0248576794,
0.0047044619,
-0.0381515808,
-0.0426233783,
0.0246831626,
-0.0417818688,
0.0133515941,
-0.0385164507,
0.0190419368,
-0.0329477862,
-0.007267708,
0.0436775647,
0.0383827053,
-0.041515287,
0.0027810331,
0.0177814346,
0.0067367186,
-0.0530780889,
0.0172080416,
0.0393982343,
-0.0310199354,
-0.0200219732,
0.0315802991,
0.0144577632,
-0.0148010384,
-0.0339611098,
0.0594667345,
-0.0398477465,
0.0212834924,
0.002266763,
-0.0586545318,
-0.0237833932,
-0.0130325286,
-0.0098437481,
-0.0332390964,
0.0220750123,
0.002831178,
-0.0084573086,
-0.0753162503,
0.0134323239,
0.0311767478,
-0.014324679,
-0.0012111729,
-0.0392778777,
-0.0293437187,
0.0379414558,
0.0283549316,
-0.0245938767,
0.0421430953,
0.0221068095,
0.0771033317,
0.0148117486,
0.0122291856,
0.0011113351,
0.0143408924,
0.0674298555,
0.0140957562,
-0.0478086695,
-0.0077206525,
-0.0154686514,
0.0097125014,
0.0603849515,
0.0357158072,
-0.0242577959,
-0.0064778677,
0.0947042033,
0.0010501659,
-0.032120306,
0.0264243335,
0.0723076314,
0.0159492027,
-0.0196032319,
0.0307842586,
-0.0221528858,
0.0140888924,
-0.0604221895,
-0.0167523697,
0.0200559739,
0.0238722041,
-0.0162669215,
-0.0474718995,
0.0102571836,
0.0057261134,
-0.0165511407,
-0.0035442708,
-0.0228719003,
0.0466995649,
-0.0643619224,
-0.0378395505,
0.0135328341,
-0.0851747096,
0.0359319635,
-0.0503263436,
0.0100340303,
0.081792362,
0.0336843543,
0.0138799092,
-0.0198718999,
-0.0403304435,
-0.0287010781,
0.0448489152,
0.0362658501,
0.0112964017,
-0.0053990479,
-0.0553101301,
-0.0359470323,
0.0313755646,
0.009449726,
0.0259143692,
0.0104871821,
0.0292502847,
0.0184548609,
0.042287413,
-0.0322423503,
0.0331777558,
-0.0000799989,
-0.0453282669,
0.0396691486,
-0.0002841104,
0.0141343614,
0.0186121184,
-0.0192000642,
0.0306753945,
-0.0113335624,
-0.0140813952,
-0.0766612813,
-0.0009133603,
-0.074206017,
-0.0567638502,
-0.0211952273,
-0.0328890756,
-0.0345934592,
0.0126945321,
0.0043798266,
-0.0374456681,
-0.0033848337,
-0.0495018922,
0.0072681047,
-0.0362595692,
0.0060668476,
0.0156302582,
-0.0034670427,
-0.0327251963,
0.0360919833,
-0.0132476352,
-0.0307937302,
0.0335592031,
0.0077550034,
-0.0355292559,
-0.0353757814,
-0.0148583567,
-0.0104300259,
-0.0036289254,
-0.0003958651,
0.0556166656,
0.0253199507,
-0.0203173235,
-0.0393746532,
-0.0415874831,
0.0041949218,
-0.0245261397,
-0.0182233267,
0.0378262885,
0.0073219412,
-0.0050146636,
0.0050823726,
-0.0601436123,
-0.0277795196,
0.0364907086,
0.0162783675,
0.0223684981,
0.0245235749,
0.0332005695,
-0.0374521576,
-0.0153490407,
-0.0233323276,
0.0319284871,
0.0298276749,
-0.0462335795,
-0.031006271,
0.0104191601,
-0.0066946512,
-0.0174155571,
0.028781129,
-0.0643886626,
0.00615808,
-0.0019882713,
0.0729618073,
0.055322554,
0.0386604667,
0.0479466505,
0.0004784609,
0.0284906887,
-0.0556272045,
-0.0002252987,
-0.0208570119,
0.000515577,
0.0111193275,
-0.0427032374,
0.0455452949,
0.0551386513,
0.0712472051,
0.014340586,
-0.1081136912,
0.0490734242,
-0.0153568387,
-0.0949171782,
-0.0276464056,
-0.0485837087,
-0.0112277288,
0.0390970968,
-0.0335314833,
-0.0476381965,
0.0811896697,
0.0086271837,
-0.006832541,
-0.0054463446,
0.0018291866,
-0.0050301589,
0.0029328924,
-0.0294963773,
0.0385527276,
0.0366676822,
-0.0359918326,
-0.0446318351,
0.0037872402,
0.0369370095,
-0.0222745333,
-0.0320313498,
-0.0254090782,
-0.0311399177,
0.0163075346,
-0.0511281192,
-0.0380088501,
-0.0508105271,
0.026944207,
-0.0239955764,
0.0659580454,
-0.0213652626,
-0.0052903686,
-0.0053458954,
0.012276439,
0.0203752238,
-0.0648798794,
-0.0115001062,
-0.02045778,
0.0242636763,
0.040684022,
-0.0462568104,
0.0217951387,
-0.0560799427,
0.008775888,
0.0812474042,
-0.0053548245,
-0.0123913037,
0.0214796513,
0.0172930192,
0.0433751643,
-0.0195057876,
-0.0149253672,
0.0153316883,
0.0215569027,
-0.0510851443,
-0.0077330936,
0.0998106301,
0.0245146602,
-0.0624310337,
-0.0148404092,
0.0130223967,
0.0571797043,
0.0115362797,
0.0044948822,
-0.069722265,
-0.0147206923,
0.0145951817,
0.0530021377,
-0.0480494387,
-0.0421182401,
-0.0276324712,
-0.1272992641,
0.0080989487,
0.0135273328,
-0.025838051,
-0.0199183971,
0.0244303308,
-0.0183821544,
0.0089354441,
-0.0117986109,
0.0162019152,
0.0069719669,
0.0105050793,
0.0220520701,
-0.0297890343,
-0.0296469517,
-0.046729371,
-0.0057373196,
0.0612515137,
0.0772021711,
0.0143472617,
0.0366176963,
0.0178692695,
0.0028455064,
0.0000390019,
0.0316196792,
-0.0445981696,
0.0650914162,
-0.0431768149,
-0.0058298544,
-0.0567117892,
0.0593799017,
0.0307241362,
0.0289667491,
-0.0020885149,
0.0274532307,
0.0044762469,
-0.0362273529,
-0.0461751334,
0.0246770885,
0.0629997551,
0.0732539445,
0.030480057,
-0.0677813217,
-0.046324674,
-0.0517466627,
0.0174091663,
-0.0551609136,
-0.0555462614,
-0.0109410519,
-0.0127328634,
-0.0682802573,
-0.1104965881,
-0.0545611121,
0.0279693138,
0.0402047597,
-0.0120111592,
-0.0625314415,
-0.0031577914,
0.0014508087,
-0.0349231102,
-0.0195548236,
0.0159935467,
-0.0065944511,
-0.0564026535,
-0.0166956,
-0.0086069116,
-0.032354597,
0.0078451475,
0.0480729081,
-0.0243461505,
-0.068441689,
0.0330820531,
0.089051351,
0.021988688,
0.0318865627,
-0.00282032,
-0.0864118785,
0.0375924595,
0.0433258377,
-0.0211659875,
0.024527248,
0.0452016294,
0.0189125929,
0.0036249638,
0.0360100716,
-0.0259671789,
0.0332909413,
0.0181455854,
0.0101314038,
0.0085621495,
-0.0335790403,
0.0270460453,
0.0190092437,
-0.0100238388,
-0.0640345514,
0.0166547,
-0.0462743007,
-0.0043301368,
-0.070687063,
-0.0143130831,
-0.0390934721,
0.0298024397,
0.0078729782,
0.0063868896,
-0.0237969924,
0.0144024594,
-0.0329767279,
0.0120346751,
-0.0755021721,
-0.0010338932,
-0.0456140228,
0.0573778264,
0.0348474085,
0.023029618,
-0.0369293578,
0.0164045617,
-0.001344508,
-0.0113330781,
-0.0115918107,
0.0218821205,
0.0317462981,
0.0130868787,
-0.0012368778,
0.0230150074,
-0.0509598106,
0.0175525751,
-0.0315770172,
0.033541061,
-0.0030097752,
0.0381527916,
0.0671065897,
-0.0168714859,
0.0084213838,
0.0147678349,
0.0284199268,
0.0138682714,
-0.0114562791,
-0.0142059932,
-0.0140810171,
-0.0166271403,
-0.068276383,
0.0512977652,
0.0011817098,
0.0196172018,
-0.0241204016,
-0.0246738829,
-0.0374213606,
-0.0360071659,
0.0374670886,
-0.0099126641,
0.0086814528,
0.006204695,
-0.0659724697,
-0.0152939865,
0.0105137918,
-0.0047101951,
0.0236815456,
-0.0007955863,
0.0294068679,
0.0206816252,
-0.0216262452,
-0.0031632753,
-0.0109818568,
0.0197862796,
-0.0209705885,
-0.028631255,
-0.0193714928,
-6.550636227e-33,
-0.0477211364,
-0.0234347228,
-0.0247575287,
-0.0339600742,
-0.0212024767,
-0.0027837732,
-0.0281639844,
0.0130081568,
0.0462457836,
0.0317632928,
-0.0170194805,
-0.0002836291,
0.0154034616,
0.0158633478,
-0.0062759523,
0.0265881177,
0.0937038288,
-0.0129273795,
-0.0480009615,
0.0608656444,
0.0456599593,
0.0445871726,
0.020315269,
-0.0824525505,
0.0581288114,
-0.0001496626,
-0.03809724,
-0.0191167351,
0.0093755526,
0.0208886545,
0.0153323328,
0.0490678847,
0.0165956616,
-0.0306555945,
-0.0481461398,
0.0819402486,
-0.0539266989,
-0.0512997657,
0.0228268132,
-0.0153662469,
-0.0292213149,
-0.0471404009,
0.0115969796,
-0.0017168124,
-0.0315339416,
-0.0182340275,
0.0309637468,
0.0064176186,
0.0367775932,
-0.085373275,
-0.0338145643,
0.0175016038,
-0.0230037179,
0.0151372217,
-0.0189799517,
0.0613750443,
0.0025501552,
-0.0013332635,
-0.0236263145,
0.0416906998,
0.0090275407,
0.0133636715,
0.0231208131,
0.003990293,
-0.018206371,
0.0341469385,
0.0391283259,
0.0388353616,
-0.0186247155,
0.0067737591,
0.0095168753,
-0.0061689639,
0.0484178029,
0.0797452778,
0.0201874375,
-0.0603095777,
-0.0198868681,
0.0377982557,
0.0379714631,
-0.0335565247,
0.0259801224,
-0.0214858949,
-0.0475259162,
-0.0204050783,
-0.025103448,
-0.0307143163,
-0.0115395011,
-0.0433883034,
0.0514847785,
0.0236994065,
-0.068382822,
-0.0096103204,
0.0265227482,
-0.0043199239,
0.0371962488,
0.0295672137,
-0.046508681,
0.0096598677,
-0.0155759212,
0.0037097265,
-0.0120732607,
0.0105582559,
0.0696638823,
0.0131830713,
0.0147109851,
0.0075816866,
0.0290593263,
0.0298657045,
-0.0812711418,
-0.000612827,
-0.0197957382,
0.0816371515,
0.0337744802,
-0.0110706901,
0.0048180483,
0.0124077518,
-0.0103052501,
0.0306524783,
0.011402484,
0.0069465172,
-0.0422217622,
-0.0281911287,
0.034447331,
0.0093959812,
-0.0358036645,
-0.002024981,
0.002610069,
-0.011575765,
0.0322242901,
-0.057332512,
-0.0228929184,
-0.037459597,
2.73e-7,
-0.0150909862,
0.054956276,
0.0553837791,
0.0154695427,
0.0071879835,
0.0257811956,
0.0480839051,
0.0702101141,
0.0207664277,
-0.0125429668,
-0.0045908503,
0.0231371392,
0.0160857476,
0.026383128,
-0.0485413559,
-0.0288367569,
-0.0762949139,
0.0316183157,
-0.0446682833,
-0.0004526618,
0.0975851715,
0.0173200741,
0.0134595688,
-0.0019294446,
0.0315718874,
0.035349004,
0.0479968823,
0.0153740095,
0.0102331201,
0.0175468232,
0.0349062495,
-0.0381773598,
0.0092046252,
0.0070353304,
-0.0078286342,
-0.0223835316,
0.0163634084,
0.0768407881,
0.0066516427,
-0.0307467673,
0.0377825275,
0.0010959009,
0.0095178531,
-0.0136914244,
0.0512711443,
-0.012989291,
0.0032425104,
-0.0440796539,
-0.0278852768,
-0.0165110826,
0.0156068979,
-0.0501438528,
-0.0229847282,
0.0265366882,
0.0116932075,
0.0459550656,
0.0067824367,
-0.0612093247,
-0.0575709678,
-0.0373608246,
-0.0276854746,
-0.0722591132,
-0.0624015033,
0.0608595833,
0.0054877363,
-0.0640623122,
0.0203396864,
2.802178331e-34,
0.0057902094,
0.0051886779,
0.0281218011,
-0.0045380378,
0.0124900229,
0.0084371706,
0.0158794168,
0.026079597,
0.0763268396,
-0.010123278,
-0.0478628427
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.03122v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.03122v2 | Extracting Multi-valued Relations from Language Models | 2023-07-06T16:48:32 | 2023-07-07T07:25:36 | Sneha Singhania, Simon Razniewski, Gerhard Weikum | cs.CL | cs.CL | The widespread usage of latent language representations via pre-trained
language models (LMs) suggests that they are a promising source of structured
knowledge. However, existing methods focus only on a single object per
subject-relation pair, even though often multiple objects are correct. To
overcome this limitation, we analyze these representations for their potential
to yield materialized multi-object relational knowledge. We formulate the
problem as a rank-then-select task. For ranking candidate objects, we evaluate
existing prompting techniques and propose new ones incorporating domain
knowledge. Among the selection methods, we find that choosing objects with a
likelihood above a learned relation-specific threshold gives a 49.5% F1 score.
Our results highlight the difficulty of employing LMs for the multi-valued
slot-filling task and pave the way for further research on extracting
relational knowledge from latent language representations. | [
0.0581026375,
0.0755251721,
-0.0016516362,
0.0599383079,
-0.0061311517,
0.0049612918,
-0.0121082151,
0.0015650151,
0.0073240981,
-0.0974124074,
-0.0485952049,
-0.0418748483,
-0.0248395465,
0.0215424746,
-0.0156725626,
-0.0546061024,
0.0302113406,
-0.0313017555,
0.0419766568,
0.0016114729,
-0.0286598746,
0.0443273224,
-0.0368901603,
0.012142295,
-0.0139423218,
-0.0186978392,
0.0188703686,
-0.0407190993,
0.0078704506,
-0.0139971981,
0.0063054678,
0.0965939909,
0.0170819461,
-0.0498233661,
0.0000020085,
-0.0625052601,
-0.0205365494,
-0.03893473,
-0.030083796,
-0.035852246,
0.0206949674,
-0.0273122285,
0.0307446551,
-0.0224080496,
-0.048784826,
-0.0749829412,
0.0116276769,
0.0164984986,
0.0141598377,
0.0411655754,
-0.011307938,
0.0177944396,
0.005022624,
-0.0255963821,
0.0149778491,
-0.0472849794,
0.0319985822,
0.0390581153,
-0.0064442232,
0.049302794,
-0.0006308014,
0.0011207348,
0.0036759858,
-0.0134339621,
0.0337676965,
0.0521181785,
-0.0420395955,
-0.0058571771,
0.0089437012,
0.0944653302,
-0.0126530454,
0.0078906165,
-0.0108539518,
-0.0144274645,
-0.0289609637,
0.0502351858,
0.0026301742,
0.0188925024,
-0.0002881813,
0.0028735229,
0.0321969055,
0.0223232079,
0.032255739,
0.0337721407,
-0.0215272568,
0.0314925164,
0.0282622706,
-0.0148820067,
0.0471992306,
0.0173052382,
-0.0342324413,
-0.0638921484,
-0.0254421942,
0.0051227794,
-0.0554767698,
0.055636961,
-0.0267184488,
-0.0020982765,
-0.0051959362,
-0.0469230451,
0.0199091993,
0.0077960254,
-0.0226697065,
0.044228144,
-0.0165466201,
0.0066190688,
-0.0096143074,
0.0057881372,
-0.064830333,
0.0033454457,
-0.0240698662,
-0.0247346647,
0.0082493015,
0.0487174131,
-0.0230894871,
-0.0062957313,
-0.0112378653,
-0.0074462611,
-0.0273599327,
0.0138601456,
-0.0051836376,
0.0338938572,
-0.0208286401,
-0.0072271675,
-0.090722993,
0.0183196552,
-0.0128603429,
0.0058497116,
-0.0378432758,
-0.0223233216,
-0.0071123736,
-0.0228207875,
0.0119836358,
-0.0751084238,
-0.0095904712,
0.0542748608,
-0.0073887324,
-0.0473810509,
-0.0006023412,
-0.0172131527,
0.0087142717,
-0.0611158386,
0.05357733,
-0.0422687605,
0.05442518,
0.053390976,
0.0268637445,
-0.0262290165,
0.0392908342,
0.0004067585,
-0.0415463634,
0.0755461529,
0.0103399111,
0.0040186686,
-0.0147910407,
0.0184818953,
0.0300565697,
0.0543497987,
-0.012217531,
0.0145445159,
0.0229028929,
-0.0118669393,
-0.0139913866,
0.0079111345,
0.0022551781,
-0.0043191169,
-0.0270559713,
0.0138546824,
0.0266986284,
0.0087585701,
0.0379091389,
0.0120473262,
-0.0265495107,
-0.0117208054,
0.021447463,
0.0172458477,
0.0396825597,
0.0138404341,
0.0586107969,
-0.0213228986,
0.0228900872,
0.0250237472,
-0.0698079914,
0.0467759594,
-0.0358973145,
-0.0173400808,
-0.0218709651,
0.0174678173,
0.0104577616,
-0.004540273,
0.0117047718,
-0.0469977558,
-0.0211856384,
0.011428833,
0.0966999158,
0.0131388251,
-0.0132393232,
0.0720380843,
0.0705051869,
0.0027687075,
0.0022491084,
-0.0117554488,
-0.0108905546,
0.0322663784,
0.0330670923,
-0.0605050586,
-0.0463576056,
0.0025502311,
-0.0316485502,
0.0030920501,
0.058734227,
-0.0436647572,
0.0292413253,
0.007311861,
-0.0412898287,
0.0007226431,
0.0036271191,
0.0424175411,
0.0307295546,
0.0103911133,
-0.0007925038,
-0.029217625,
0.0164171755,
0.0176918972,
-0.0247756429,
-0.0172980241,
0.0011281851,
0.0175960977,
0.0243235473,
0.0082574207,
0.0088609448,
0.0100366408,
0.0392766632,
-0.0348949134,
-0.0116940392,
-0.0056153741,
-0.0663461536,
-0.0217581205,
0.0226280652,
0.0034534233,
-0.0419744402,
0.0001704105,
-0.0298726633,
-0.0033041816,
0.0286634006,
0.0672733113,
0.0516290963,
-0.0330083035,
-0.0091158133,
0.0290296227,
-0.0118498262,
-0.0327587686,
0.1261642277,
0.0172181148,
0.0315316692,
0.0485067554,
-0.0541771911,
0.0015335795,
-0.000911832,
-0.020332478,
0.0162691586,
0.0000529913,
0.0031088749,
0.017805865,
0.0113260271,
-0.0543759428,
-0.0110751996,
-0.0587485507,
-0.0012013527,
0.0127143888,
-0.0105483392,
0.0028637249,
-0.0097044203,
0.0102578057,
-0.0127181029,
-0.0283815749,
-0.0159982815,
-0.0198536348,
-0.0026703184,
0.0225063935,
-0.0053255316,
0.02828403,
-0.0346636102,
-0.0006332713,
-0.045134902,
0.0775383562,
-0.0068515823,
0.0142351482,
0.0049567963,
0.0659141019,
-0.0422987491,
0.0333235972,
-0.0120173758,
0.0119133946,
-0.0000585961,
-0.0387059301,
0.0424423963,
0.0379431359,
0.0041515646,
0.0878319144,
0.07923311,
-0.0101886829,
-0.0528891943,
0.0024916718,
-0.0328846127,
0.0104485638,
-0.012979134,
0.0226267204,
-0.007574874,
0.027329661,
0.0247367825,
-0.0116555318,
-0.0350335166,
0.0350128189,
-0.0230780654,
-0.0286386386,
-0.065147087,
0.026721105,
0.0187905431,
0.0570614375,
-0.0089278435,
0.0053620143,
0.063615188,
0.005043264,
0.0084461942,
0.0061099618,
0.0068953149,
-0.0469828211,
0.0833742768,
0.0035756233,
0.0264208149,
-0.021429576,
-0.0081533054,
-0.0663211867,
0.0116856582,
0.0143194478,
-0.0268587135,
0.0180159304,
-0.0486088246,
0.0064636506,
-0.0134233078,
-0.0373950563,
-0.0523597375,
-0.0470890738,
-0.0220845677,
0.0180854946,
-0.0157231223,
0.0264414456,
-0.0104505075,
-0.0124444561,
-0.0144230425,
-0.0003521903,
0.008780323,
-0.0058869375,
-0.0061436393,
0.046893876,
0.0653218478,
-0.003838338,
-0.0083719855,
0.0005554261,
0.0115496283,
0.0342187099,
-0.0296581313,
-0.0001919876,
-0.0165933706,
0.058157552,
0.0439127088,
-0.0360755846,
0.0042728707,
-0.0152794542,
-0.0071302271,
-0.0145700462,
-0.0060979151,
0.1281882972,
0.0483876169,
-0.046358142,
0.0038920969,
0.0084684798,
-0.0009143487,
0.0311524868,
0.0406187214,
-0.1053461879,
0.0168193709,
-0.0372057185,
-0.0396076739,
0.0242006723,
-0.06511987,
-0.0269370954,
-0.1287996322,
0.0131220417,
-0.0201373901,
-0.0349814184,
0.0086887339,
-0.0192886442,
0.0042605205,
-0.0088388221,
-0.0122724408,
-0.0337175056,
-0.0174224395,
0.0144245895,
0.009953904,
0.0445808582,
-0.0437393934,
0.0648698956,
-0.0305490866,
0.046885144,
0.0277013518,
0.0489308052,
-0.0306624994,
0.0045940364,
-0.029494293,
0.0263784062,
-0.0179550871,
-0.019679131,
0.0412880145,
-0.0350204706,
-0.0328289531,
-0.0200072471,
-0.0215563234,
-0.0359005928,
-0.0540299937,
-0.0253670439,
0.0707917958,
-0.0062833033,
-0.0205611717,
0.0002841489,
-0.0177386142,
0.0209556427,
0.074848555,
-0.0006813259,
-0.0402760394,
0.0396842137,
-0.0504800864,
0.0530035868,
0.0154795386,
-0.0563958287,
0.0096838456,
-0.0137620848,
0.0069727022,
-0.0546620898,
-0.0189119317,
0.101700902,
0.0114069767,
0.008936421,
-0.0052706609,
0.0570383482,
-0.007405594,
-0.0408183858,
0.023823183,
-0.0244389903,
-0.0172055382,
-0.0235962886,
-0.0531458072,
0.0396224931,
-0.0656073838,
-0.0520166866,
-0.0765812322,
-0.0186259784,
-0.0065330495,
-0.0110092033,
0.057285253,
0.0206895079,
0.0038268832,
-0.0274045467,
-0.0092989467,
-0.0201860107,
0.0287736766,
-0.0494566262,
-0.0158174038,
0.0014820325,
-0.0094799176,
0.0015703597,
0.0383934341,
-0.0509031191,
0.0418068133,
0.0248738546,
0.0405214541,
0.0049153771,
-0.0821937844,
0.0615950041,
0.0018744599,
0.0772925168,
0.0047453903,
0.0070648524,
-0.0644315481,
-0.0068986868,
-0.0487848669,
-0.0600124113,
-0.043400608,
0.0267787073,
0.0163138155,
0.0140168853,
-0.0221143402,
-0.077212058,
0.0025386233,
0.0715977326,
-0.0032857242,
-0.055079516,
0.0764717236,
-0.0220872387,
0.0465979464,
0.0188172106,
-0.0225977357,
0.0002090359,
-0.0038833055,
0.0394391231,
-0.0611964427,
0.0445478819,
-0.0028366756,
-0.0283919796,
-0.0192286763,
0.0045840256,
-0.007624872,
-0.028660886,
-0.0154496813,
0.0082571376,
0.0427239798,
-0.062213473,
0.038801685,
-0.0335937627,
0.0130044427,
-0.0089574791,
0.036670465,
0.0231643859,
-0.0052575101,
0.0388011821,
0.037654873,
-0.0188366119,
0.0299411695,
0.0869239569,
0.0075739818,
0.0399989709,
0.0269024987,
-0.0210771598,
-0.0276675783,
-0.0159216579,
-0.0255463198,
0.0428442731,
-0.0199540872,
0.0488995276,
-0.0752186999,
-0.0650154352,
-0.0156123545,
-0.0102531742,
-0.053443864,
0.0150769427,
-0.0019973225,
0.0613217726,
0.011690421,
-0.0084577426,
-0.0597174652,
-0.0216969606,
-0.0179285444,
-0.0201592911,
-0.0173319969,
-6.407469831e-33,
-0.0593084022,
-0.0390240438,
-0.0038879451,
-0.0113854809,
0.0116851898,
0.0300947465,
-0.0137121417,
-0.002161497,
-0.0166246165,
0.0346817076,
-0.0101994751,
-0.0234491974,
0.0084361145,
-0.0003837332,
0.0379317664,
-0.0183004756,
-0.0061703376,
-0.002586867,
0.0251459815,
-0.0202619154,
0.0628948584,
0.0332164988,
0.0617891364,
-0.0870044306,
0.0372499898,
0.0139687788,
0.014643617,
0.0279997028,
0.0019316355,
0.0465409681,
-0.0353386886,
0.0278395005,
0.0400528647,
-0.0049940287,
0.0355516523,
0.0105067287,
-0.1178470552,
-0.0730701685,
0.0280278698,
-0.0216884483,
-0.0039108293,
-0.0092371842,
-0.0299841817,
0.003792532,
0.0839861408,
-0.0369649716,
0.0373681821,
-0.0232234802,
-0.0293327644,
-0.0351854227,
-0.0771547481,
-0.0107281841,
0.0151494602,
0.0043365299,
0.028118724,
0.0336794294,
-0.0077944659,
0.0204621051,
-0.0368092731,
0.0084718131,
-0.0474420264,
0.0139192855,
0.034425091,
0.0323106758,
-0.0309543479,
0.0852989927,
-0.0116249025,
-0.0231078658,
-0.0133392001,
0.0308589172,
0.0104506407,
0.0674162284,
-0.0327732228,
0.0111595457,
0.0122240484,
0.009773301,
-0.0651588067,
0.015234475,
-0.0017114441,
-0.0171773471,
0.0004635186,
-0.0141478255,
-0.015285003,
-0.0435709618,
-0.0496265143,
0.0016991183,
-0.0559053198,
-0.0605684407,
0.0441893302,
-0.0184686519,
-0.0340967514,
0.0326663889,
0.0027643749,
-0.0237645153,
-0.0820897371,
0.0050212801,
-0.0003886096,
0.0187848434,
-0.0171532352,
0.0305945911,
-0.046163518,
-0.0324195176,
0.0300571807,
-0.044903554,
0.0175499693,
0.0457208939,
0.0240252465,
0.0029312982,
-0.0356565565,
-0.0144687528,
-0.0495063812,
-0.0446646698,
0.0029923921,
0.04616661,
0.0091197854,
0.0365891457,
-0.0171008054,
0.0422772877,
0.0445591137,
-0.0112769175,
-0.04810315,
0.0288020354,
0.0102819372,
0.0324057452,
0.0018993326,
-0.0414555855,
-0.0293920841,
-0.0210396796,
0.0822572336,
-0.0010055455,
0.0060711028,
-0.0208071489,
2.645e-7,
0.0823269859,
0.0350668766,
-0.0302473567,
0.0510735661,
-0.0340768807,
0.0347441547,
-0.0016179841,
0.0438235663,
0.0473498292,
0.0101413457,
0.0016980822,
0.0327292569,
-0.0019337441,
0.0678463578,
-0.0701876804,
-0.0361781679,
-0.0208377931,
-0.0719505623,
-0.0291098915,
-0.0378883369,
0.0846836641,
0.0705441833,
0.0580712706,
0.0160895884,
-0.0442483351,
-0.0157996546,
0.0659180656,
-0.0483793095,
-0.0255504493,
0.0075224005,
-0.0119107887,
0.029135948,
-0.0052816682,
0.0512775369,
-0.0151210818,
0.0090928404,
0.0498049781,
0.0711917356,
0.0023304704,
-0.0254591089,
-0.0231301002,
0.0085445829,
0.0193546768,
-0.0176020134,
0.0820728987,
-0.0846993402,
-0.0028144934,
-0.0039997869,
-0.0197009202,
0.0178352296,
0.0163277984,
0.0035270236,
-0.0098634753,
0.0132522276,
0.0059490381,
0.0220931079,
-0.0100165429,
-0.059368439,
-0.0059275222,
0.0387127288,
0.0148855876,
-0.0360379666,
0.0255934242,
-0.0585155226,
0.0334522724,
-0.0356377214,
0.0163025297,
2.4626912e-34,
-0.0219333414,
0.0525822677,
-0.0062421747,
0.0562091768,
0.0567594804,
-0.0309052095,
-0.0299202558,
0.020855058,
-0.0146124475,
-0.0599137545,
0.0090384027
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.03115v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.03115v1 | KoRC: Knowledge oriented Reading Comprehension Benchmark for Deep Text Understanding | 2023-07-06T16:35:25 | 2023-07-06T16:35:25 | Zijun Yao, Yantao Liu, Xin Lv, Shulin Cao, Jifan Yu, Lei Hou, Juanzi Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Deep text understanding, which requires the connections between a given
document and prior knowledge beyond its text, has been highlighted by many
benchmarks in recent years. However, these benchmarks have encountered two
major limitations. On the one hand, most of them require human annotation of
knowledge, which leads to limited knowledge coverage. On the other hand, they
usually use choices or spans in the texts as the answers, which results in
narrow answer space. To overcome these limitations, we build a new challenging
benchmark named KoRc in this paper. Compared with previous benchmarks, KoRC has
two advantages, i.e., broad knowledge coverage and flexible answer format.
Specifically, we utilize massive knowledge bases to guide annotators or large
language models (LLMs) to construct knowledgable questions. Moreover, we use
labels in knowledge bases rather than spans or choices as the final answers. We
test state-of-the-art models on KoRC and the experimental results show that the
strongest baseline only achieves 68.3% and 30.0% F1 measure in the
in-distribution and out-of-distribution test set, respectively. These results
indicate that deep text understanding is still an unsolved challenge. The
benchmark dataset, leaderboard, and baseline methods are released in
https://github.com/THU-KEG/KoRC. | [
0.0267265867,
0.0011201801,
0.0214072149,
0.0540414453,
-0.0268476345,
0.037033122,
0.0216665454,
-0.0269807838,
0.033473853,
0.0032439856,
-0.0136958482,
0.0130561478,
-0.0247359723,
0.0598796047,
-0.01531028,
-0.03169135,
0.0340937637,
-0.0308242626,
0.0161988493,
0.0162940565,
0.0089584282,
0.0297242608,
-0.0449779518,
-0.011029711,
0.0189670511,
-0.0572118014,
-0.0018687312,
-0.0074039535,
0.0470067896,
-0.0330150761,
0.0299372282,
0.0204176251,
0.0182854328,
0.0601230226,
0.0000019989,
-0.0210381523,
-0.0195058435,
0.008352547,
-0.0578499846,
0.0367257968,
0.0065767476,
-0.0187331997,
0.0362237394,
-0.0240417477,
-0.0134881325,
-0.0020325915,
-0.0036908339,
0.0633838251,
0.0650337413,
0.0480417833,
0.0020377634,
-0.0084870681,
0.0188024957,
-0.0006466586,
0.0353520103,
-0.0838267282,
0.007977576,
0.0505475886,
0.0079888636,
0.0141382059,
-0.026263807,
0.0734070763,
0.0458243266,
-0.019385986,
0.0105217481,
0.0253309608,
-0.0148123689,
-0.0096316952,
-0.0019480526,
0.1197214574,
-0.0031665503,
-0.0113681043,
-0.0075573525,
-0.008189017,
-0.0257083364,
0.0076548448,
-0.0260754935,
-0.0274420734,
-0.0507946014,
-0.0096417358,
-0.0200331621,
0.0246422105,
0.039521575,
0.0066272011,
-0.0138425129,
0.0812929943,
0.0021378293,
-0.0197798982,
0.0387313217,
0.0054210462,
-0.0382117219,
-0.016241923,
0.0428224616,
0.022531325,
-0.0030421368,
0.0194998849,
-0.0182640087,
-0.0545846559,
0.0200968832,
-0.0487341508,
-0.0109684598,
0.0499228686,
-0.040598534,
0.1044856682,
-0.056159813,
0.0717827752,
-0.0353048667,
0.0129605941,
-0.0488010943,
0.0003845398,
-0.0119018583,
-0.0142017026,
-0.0236269943,
0.0029505542,
-0.0813005492,
-0.0330145806,
0.0238648318,
0.0321560279,
0.0379461646,
0.034384843,
-0.0059690499,
0.0157393087,
-0.0248602498,
-0.0240049288,
-0.0119373295,
0.050636705,
-0.0807389542,
0.0019004693,
-0.005035141,
-0.0113122668,
-0.0074740578,
-0.0058558644,
-0.0048085181,
-0.0465089492,
-0.0168771986,
0.0312677622,
-0.0522985198,
-0.0113336546,
0.0168689657,
-0.0239203051,
0.0083775455,
-0.0419896841,
-0.0150601435,
-0.0335382707,
0.0316867679,
0.0209069252,
-0.0018378227,
-0.0147047872,
-0.0118465004,
0.0338880271,
-0.0105224391,
0.0707565099,
-0.0023225883,
-0.0393624902,
0.0550158396,
0.042158667,
-0.0142602837,
0.061805997,
-0.0024698414,
0.0010486471,
0.0282725431,
0.0201343689,
-0.0345812775,
0.02806402,
0.0096762348,
0.0130688213,
0.0463046134,
0.059647657,
-0.0053528319,
0.0481183752,
0.0256961547,
0.008577575,
-0.0421446748,
-0.0650976449,
0.0401223153,
0.0060593123,
0.0091810711,
0.0071025956,
0.0090221418,
0.0383623168,
0.0463658907,
-0.0049622725,
-0.0106252562,
0.0095477421,
-0.0449173301,
0.0125365928,
0.0234657265,
-0.0136951385,
-0.0077467756,
-0.0153782293,
-0.0123256668,
0.0441622511,
-0.0168877523,
0.0165794417,
0.0632537827,
0.014649095,
-0.0372253694,
0.0403711423,
-0.0044453936,
-0.0205257889,
0.0059134499,
0.0132946614,
0.0624109246,
0.0292563941,
0.0546558611,
-0.0621669665,
-0.0376872793,
0.0060823914,
0.0138693266,
0.0493047908,
0.0294306353,
-0.0263363365,
0.0286447685,
-0.07169085,
-0.0009139861,
-0.0161568988,
-0.0082867844,
0.0236080419,
-0.0081921285,
0.0123098511,
0.0066134334,
-0.0955365449,
-0.0033906312,
0.033799313,
-0.018647166,
-0.0275942199,
-0.0459846035,
0.0037458406,
0.0242370833,
0.0360976234,
0.0048346473,
-0.0152779268,
0.0274817012,
-0.0419574454,
0.0088701602,
-0.0196181033,
-0.0620429069,
-0.0877957791,
0.016634129,
-0.0718297735,
-0.0334243737,
0.0525990613,
-0.0372056253,
-0.0553224087,
-0.0373081863,
0.0066925213,
-0.0056550787,
-0.0382967256,
-0.0140045593,
0.0058643795,
-0.0008154349,
-0.0429471321,
0.0652629584,
-0.0073477728,
0.0202836152,
0.0340126082,
0.0137193948,
0.0473519675,
0.0118619949,
-0.0433243774,
-0.004291025,
-0.0044066603,
-0.006594785,
0.0232997257,
0.0223837979,
-0.0936205909,
-0.004253462,
-0.0880279317,
0.0496745668,
-0.0054075648,
0.0096768392,
0.0210516769,
0.0126600936,
0.0116764959,
-0.0207201988,
-0.0387645476,
0.0011869468,
-0.030123651,
0.0009716855,
0.015520528,
0.0382200778,
0.0249632653,
-0.0013902598,
-0.0139352735,
-0.0070761787,
0.0504813269,
0.0357648358,
0.0283487849,
-0.0233510341,
0.0219447594,
-0.0121493759,
0.0077972906,
-0.0416744128,
0.0028976733,
0.0080191744,
-0.0354621895,
0.0100327469,
0.0621090904,
-0.0014194071,
0.0130275795,
0.0035888443,
0.0032527286,
-0.061534863,
0.0409950539,
0.0179534294,
0.0119777089,
-0.0483948812,
-0.0132828113,
-0.0201057065,
0.0834209844,
-0.0112883076,
-0.0175785068,
-0.0388190188,
-0.0206601806,
-0.0322895087,
-0.0362648107,
-0.1068717837,
0.0228954442,
0.008812286,
0.0280689206,
-0.0611429624,
0.0167162716,
0.0832207575,
-0.038073685,
-0.0417472422,
-0.068060942,
0.040054813,
-0.0305149965,
0.0611363724,
0.0235288572,
0.0020655433,
-0.0505182743,
-0.0128721558,
-0.0230503008,
0.021579532,
0.0109636066,
-0.0163008161,
0.0206787772,
-0.0514879636,
0.0277924147,
-0.0285855886,
-0.0157634187,
-0.0409300067,
-0.0245946385,
-0.0452470183,
-0.0056089689,
0.0163989179,
-0.0196367372,
-0.019638652,
0.0071889139,
0.0225236956,
0.080728367,
-0.0174820963,
-0.0051087001,
-0.0263473224,
0.0571315661,
0.0455700569,
0.000296899,
0.0110633308,
-0.0389976539,
0.0529246964,
0.0646534339,
0.012192741,
-0.0116606792,
0.0179375224,
0.0297584459,
0.0077341232,
-0.0318930894,
0.0271462779,
-0.0371645689,
0.0545898713,
-0.0768063366,
-0.0304829981,
0.0875932053,
0.0245860722,
-0.0505559295,
-0.0336636938,
-0.0421390198,
0.0482476838,
0.0120507507,
0.0058715898,
-0.0890166983,
-0.0383655988,
-0.0068326886,
0.0123826079,
0.0172798261,
-0.0398680568,
-0.0012176572,
-0.0516944416,
-0.0233211536,
-0.0334291346,
-0.0931883901,
-0.0172300767,
-0.028887311,
0.0091818133,
-0.0064530028,
0.0218949094,
0.0447248854,
0.0370531417,
-0.0098761367,
0.0039241728,
-0.0000858285,
-0.0093803462,
0.0441734418,
-0.0173874274,
0.0167357065,
0.0440251678,
0.0449619405,
0.0199107267,
0.023127282,
-0.0065786596,
-0.0372166559,
-0.0216795094,
-0.0106208976,
0.0657008886,
-0.0110459076,
-0.0195807014,
-0.0233561266,
0.0498941615,
-0.0702874586,
0.0257648658,
0.0561217777,
0.018700026,
0.0128951073,
-0.0332012288,
-0.0115823066,
0.0060194465,
0.0049557067,
0.100994356,
0.0171198286,
-0.0192230288,
-0.0397504643,
-0.0319924615,
0.0056698159,
-0.0971497893,
-0.027897073,
0.0367562883,
0.0220687333,
0.0241813473,
-0.0461691543,
-0.0601639971,
0.0249468517,
0.0195664484,
0.010967466,
0.0164829902,
-0.0134138567,
-0.0152655588,
-0.0452100821,
0.0401170775,
-0.0238631088,
0.0107940203,
-0.037027359,
0.0063241883,
-0.014362785,
-0.0445689261,
-0.0464383811,
0.0461088866,
-0.0938910395,
-0.0112392856,
0.0136714438,
0.0045183594,
0.0163986739,
0.0569408312,
-0.0337544344,
-0.0316078737,
0.0463463739,
-0.0212407168,
-0.0477947518,
0.0030487867,
-0.0136267291,
-0.0123062721,
-0.0195334479,
0.0268884767,
-0.0425326303,
-0.0010850442,
0.0051946864,
0.0423672535,
-0.0209092703,
-0.044015862,
-0.0061704884,
0.0246535055,
-0.0104832249,
0.0180523749,
0.0003806584,
-0.0365594178,
0.0419547595,
-0.0351948142,
-0.0126252091,
-0.0183772761,
-0.0009969,
0.0356466882,
-0.0587273575,
-0.0198602509,
0.061989598,
0.036229033,
0.0440428443,
-0.0032673678,
0.0232845899,
0.0784667134,
0.0303889941,
0.0405338891,
-0.0299077388,
-0.055439502,
0.0073374696,
-0.0218263175,
0.0669758022,
0.0207230467,
0.0660178065,
0.0570957139,
-0.0395949893,
0.0219727345,
-0.0000051763,
-0.0760212615,
-0.0200352799,
-0.0105952583,
0.0458283424,
0.006778941,
-0.0068193343,
0.0558599234,
-0.0395950489,
-0.0273619778,
-0.023072334,
-0.0029356733,
0.0125037767,
0.0037494316,
-0.0012678227,
0.0285877995,
0.0381066427,
0.0236682165,
0.0547048822,
0.0574188568,
0.0415698476,
0.0240392964,
-0.0125411116,
-0.0698243305,
0.0225777756,
-0.0288482513,
0.0354851857,
0.000678076,
0.0083760926,
-0.0382293351,
-0.0484798811,
0.0655757785,
0.0052854917,
-0.0015180671,
0.0158715677,
0.0156704672,
0.0657478422,
-0.0146922618,
-0.042750895,
-0.0220019743,
0.050653927,
-0.058621157,
-0.0310754403,
-0.0154274711,
-6.462188358e-33,
-0.0294034686,
-0.01032208,
-0.0026785508,
-0.0635370612,
-0.021193387,
0.0294359084,
-0.0434877016,
-0.0380723104,
-0.018442532,
0.0316390395,
-0.0169546194,
0.0282036886,
-0.0018573834,
0.0518991053,
-0.0531067997,
-0.0229179524,
0.028917985,
-0.0111512393,
-0.0287709124,
0.0244417246,
0.0494048037,
0.0516656376,
0.0182610247,
-0.0344131365,
0.0514513813,
-0.0342789888,
-0.0008743668,
0.0375561304,
0.0021971704,
0.0295993946,
-0.060360346,
0.0297246631,
0.0427510142,
-0.0179585516,
-0.0032962316,
0.0192395672,
-0.1482448727,
-0.024146907,
0.0126352664,
0.0297165532,
-0.0727769881,
0.0039561167,
0.0094946362,
-0.0000642277,
0.0810621902,
-0.0526695326,
0.0410021134,
-0.0241148509,
-0.0349390246,
-0.001522718,
-0.0365833901,
0.0269215293,
-0.049979616,
-0.032090161,
0.0222993754,
0.0477106273,
0.0129491799,
0.0254635122,
-0.0605488829,
-0.0343114249,
-0.0032566236,
0.0187009592,
0.0269287508,
0.0429330021,
0.0037801357,
0.0438032039,
-0.0359767601,
-0.0115551678,
-0.0454933904,
-0.0169719048,
0.0260151979,
0.0178229846,
0.0355066061,
0.0671151578,
0.0340747535,
0.02528302,
-0.0780909732,
0.0485828929,
0.011260692,
0.0011691048,
0.0113275768,
-0.0107766874,
-0.0579043292,
0.0073135216,
-0.0804910883,
-0.0114989253,
-0.0638403445,
0.0107488176,
0.0501321703,
-0.0234992411,
-0.0301160272,
0.0012499487,
0.038006112,
-0.0228955206,
0.0207799487,
0.0644145086,
0.0070651891,
0.0270576496,
-0.0130606759,
0.0864643902,
-0.0288251974,
0.0055694496,
0.0085117156,
0.0093122981,
0.0108230356,
-0.0237671025,
0.0146306129,
-0.0275733173,
-0.0210269839,
-0.0314611569,
-0.0362811349,
0.0031048316,
-0.0238708109,
0.0477738418,
0.0093414439,
0.0112486295,
-0.0095981583,
0.0663676336,
-0.0016877783,
0.0108937509,
-0.0111721242,
-0.0109500391,
0.0203586444,
0.0100061977,
-0.0408515148,
-0.0080358041,
-0.0075679603,
-0.0367518961,
-0.0212251469,
-0.0751325414,
0.0421725772,
0.0569966845,
2.532e-7,
0.0338374414,
0.0071923505,
0.0484685488,
0.0167197101,
0.0072852289,
0.0217680223,
0.0149348704,
0.0237928536,
0.0173138883,
-0.0452570096,
0.0117495051,
0.0409069173,
0.0514800213,
0.0126464823,
-0.0964175686,
-0.0407393537,
-0.0314318836,
-0.0125739025,
-0.0263898838,
-0.0239254143,
0.045359619,
0.0413898081,
-0.0107635977,
-0.0219602454,
0.0356020145,
-0.0258020498,
0.0409233049,
-0.0130678602,
0.0243278425,
0.0226125084,
0.0538883209,
0.0145302713,
0.0067235744,
0.0517672673,
-0.0025070223,
0.0001165654,
0.0528300405,
0.0468394794,
0.0285472535,
-0.0386143997,
-0.0125085004,
-0.0065884287,
0.0200110115,
-0.0537905358,
0.0783728659,
-0.0066686864,
-0.0056731561,
0.0046642763,
-0.0553979017,
-0.0560056083,
-0.0009141133,
0.0081875203,
-0.0088497633,
0.0317902528,
0.0114798928,
-0.0434468277,
0.021925142,
-0.0779033154,
-0.0412386358,
-0.0011552726,
-0.0485336743,
-0.0163819864,
-0.0590322874,
-0.0079361945,
0.0290859304,
-0.0446699336,
-0.0028716445,
1.908675203e-34,
0.0159171019,
-0.0264052842,
-0.0039113816,
-0.006418196,
0.0149310697,
-0.0181437377,
-0.0262490809,
-0.0207936745,
0.0270159077,
-0.1212355047,
0.0065047666
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.03109v9 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.03109v9 | A Survey on Evaluation of Large Language Models | 2023-07-06T16:28:35 | 2023-12-29T02:12:03 | Yupeng Chang, Xu Wang, Jindong Wang, Yuan Wu, Linyi Yang, Kaijie Zhu, Hao Chen, Xiaoyuan Yi, Cunxiang Wang, Yidong Wang, Wei Ye, Yue Zhang, Yi Chang, Philip S. Yu, Qiang Yang, Xing Xie | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) are gaining increasing popularity in both
academia and industry, owing to their unprecedented performance in various
applications. As LLMs continue to play a vital role in both research and daily
use, their evaluation becomes increasingly critical, not only at the task
level, but also at the society level for better understanding of their
potential risks. Over the past years, significant efforts have been made to
examine LLMs from various perspectives. This paper presents a comprehensive
review of these evaluation methods for LLMs, focusing on three key dimensions:
what to evaluate, where to evaluate, and how to evaluate. Firstly, we provide
an overview from the perspective of evaluation tasks, encompassing general
natural language processing tasks, reasoning, medical usage, ethics,
educations, natural and social sciences, agent applications, and other areas.
Secondly, we answer the `where' and `how' questions by diving into the
evaluation methods and benchmarks, which serve as crucial components in
assessing performance of LLMs. Then, we summarize the success and failure cases
of LLMs in different tasks. Finally, we shed light on several future challenges
that lie ahead in LLMs evaluation. Our aim is to offer invaluable insights to
researchers in the realm of LLMs evaluation, thereby aiding the development of
more proficient LLMs. Our key point is that evaluation should be treated as an
essential discipline to better assist the development of LLMs. We consistently
maintain the related open-source materials at:
https://github.com/MLGroupJLU/LLM-eval-survey. | [
0.0378452875,
0.0716825351,
-0.0123833893,
0.0481067672,
-0.0764936581,
0.0164789315,
0.0254313778,
0.0018519151,
0.0298847705,
-0.0375894606,
-0.0286249667,
-0.0725627914,
0.0125286737,
0.0318196155,
0.0071472246,
-0.0180290323,
0.0254820883,
-0.0484138057,
0.0049444386,
0.0128236981,
-0.0124025308,
-0.0221430343,
0.0291677434,
0.0579860657,
0.0175999682,
0.0001300091,
0.0328441411,
-0.0169595182,
0.0144592933,
-0.0393477865,
-0.0433437116,
0.0238361061,
0.0013076155,
0.0667224601,
0.0000021378,
-0.0853855163,
0.002198928,
0.0363904238,
-0.0203837454,
0.0518673658,
0.0719796941,
-0.0140808383,
-0.0362150706,
0.0052858205,
-0.0237771012,
0.0071229478,
0.033074975,
0.0062356922,
0.0399650559,
0.0693515912,
-0.0027560121,
-0.0431340262,
0.0404243618,
-0.0207932331,
-0.0397077203,
-0.0358628221,
0.0595488213,
0.0229913183,
0.0319243893,
-0.0065459302,
-0.0113389464,
0.0531102233,
0.0269923843,
-0.023415599,
-0.0083456645,
0.0239625126,
-0.0231750309,
-0.0295625012,
-0.0070019718,
0.0480361395,
-0.0049387198,
0.0158105772,
0.0257711615,
-0.0075032986,
-0.0266864896,
-0.0058223968,
-0.0450230688,
0.0439109169,
0.0198584422,
0.0342156813,
0.0212182961,
0.0253300499,
0.0498016402,
0.0344329663,
-0.036535047,
0.087976262,
0.0151564488,
-0.0228509158,
0.0046425806,
0.00127542,
-0.0189453904,
-0.0486474745,
0.0132506406,
0.0230265092,
-0.0254120715,
0.0279958788,
0.0013035221,
-0.0177349932,
0.0608172417,
-0.0789510608,
0.049765408,
-0.0023799506,
0.0189928915,
0.0654828176,
-0.0076573268,
0.0723811835,
-0.0265099537,
0.0182271171,
-0.0384873822,
0.0006938813,
-0.0437843092,
0.0126958936,
-0.0115042999,
0.0152730206,
-0.0178000648,
-0.0187128782,
-0.0440519676,
0.0032837568,
-0.009377908,
0.0167896096,
0.0023947994,
-0.0243487079,
0.0177003834,
-0.022010047,
-0.0357576236,
0.0030272265,
-0.0097801089,
0.0149877016,
-0.0206785612,
-0.0498060361,
0.0443748273,
0.0232931674,
-0.0438784622,
-0.0186626539,
0.0028601384,
0.0944030434,
0.0452928692,
-0.0253023654,
-0.017075019,
-0.0127756288,
-0.0419765972,
-0.0990178585,
-0.0325668231,
-0.0853075981,
-0.0111943027,
0.0022936792,
0.0111911753,
-0.0381701589,
0.0087817507,
-0.0104895011,
-0.0389164202,
0.060994707,
-0.0082696453,
0.0315012187,
0.0079481704,
0.0234921761,
0.0131407715,
0.086747393,
0.0667185783,
0.0114879096,
0.0352948196,
-0.0113960421,
0.0068584508,
0.0572408363,
-0.0303644054,
0.0105921282,
-0.0366857499,
0.023366442,
-0.0016454272,
0.0523097813,
-0.022101339,
0.1033987328,
-0.0124075115,
-0.01326897,
0.0448162593,
0.076101549,
0.018691361,
-0.0181715786,
0.0473701097,
-0.0057748863,
0.0104269544,
-0.0306537263,
-0.026018735,
-0.0341983661,
-0.0275931433,
-0.0022236782,
0.016614208,
0.0520212911,
-0.0017471296,
-0.0546700098,
-0.0460914485,
-0.0046158396,
0.0344412066,
0.015954867,
0.073547639,
-0.0463321991,
-0.0163144656,
0.0130153708,
0.0157633368,
-0.047035668,
0.015208086,
-0.0817335844,
0.0071687168,
0.0690981373,
0.0710443333,
-0.0113709094,
-0.0172640681,
0.0003038383,
-0.0130517222,
0.0396928675,
0.0262196865,
0.0013985117,
-0.0082437973,
-0.0408000797,
-0.0188629404,
0.0299740974,
0.0094375741,
-0.0059104427,
0.0137608321,
0.017318543,
0.0213365071,
-0.0483786575,
-0.0651779473,
0.0332792215,
-0.0437706001,
-0.0100256326,
-0.0232350193,
-0.005099941,
0.0585451275,
0.0173482038,
-0.024508493,
0.0420293249,
0.0316826701,
-0.0371449813,
-0.0065454752,
-0.0195345376,
-0.0062896935,
0.0037402303,
0.0502200313,
-0.0379559956,
-0.0001789327,
0.0302142929,
-0.0148206986,
-0.0344064794,
-0.0018062205,
-0.0425932668,
0.0262035541,
-0.024535019,
0.0379008129,
-0.0506020673,
0.0012144224,
-0.0549003668,
0.0449416675,
-0.0159441046,
0.0258805547,
0.0089524193,
0.0005593423,
0.0233510472,
-0.0331711695,
-0.080608815,
0.0325930491,
0.0056220191,
0.0215855688,
0.0241324883,
0.0084448187,
-0.0476959124,
-0.0510609336,
-0.0908023641,
0.0093272952,
-0.0184800141,
0.0401000045,
-0.0093876077,
-0.0196173694,
-0.0170911904,
0.0208536591,
-0.0278946646,
-0.0059908172,
0.0308326539,
0.0265152082,
0.0073446468,
-0.003901921,
-0.0624582767,
-0.0278024897,
-0.0257083811,
-0.0157205798,
0.0637205914,
0.0192360375,
-0.0007041428,
-0.0376929902,
0.044288408,
-0.0264863968,
-0.0050913086,
-0.0010687822,
-0.0330254138,
0.0247020219,
0.0115467384,
0.0249747448,
0.0380123705,
0.0012580674,
0.0205385387,
0.0459689908,
-0.0162395891,
-0.0323473029,
-0.0328855366,
-0.0124470191,
-0.012923873,
-0.0529972315,
-0.0505271442,
-0.027322758,
0.0549948588,
-0.0058460673,
-0.0076644504,
-0.0308227725,
0.0086269351,
-0.0883446261,
-0.0387130827,
-0.0311151259,
-0.0133530358,
-0.0235564634,
0.0534924828,
-0.0010972152,
-0.0608998835,
0.0734991208,
-0.0482868738,
0.0355414413,
-0.0396551751,
-0.02626976,
-0.0665542632,
0.0757464245,
-0.0124243619,
0.009966095,
-0.0080985148,
-0.0094132302,
0.0063991402,
-0.0127925714,
-0.0165142678,
-0.0508566275,
0.0740049481,
-0.0556302294,
0.0370347016,
-0.0050135995,
-0.0054473355,
-0.0218454991,
-0.0480755456,
-0.0603218265,
0.0331631117,
0.0163209327,
0.0133683747,
-0.0325713754,
0.0616137348,
0.0284441896,
0.0034447524,
0.0068972725,
0.011372162,
-0.0143514434,
-0.0002458979,
0.0317644104,
0.0010820059,
0.0550026037,
-0.0228960142,
0.0497777238,
0.0496034473,
0.0325533375,
0.0442669429,
-0.0378253534,
0.0083907656,
0.0283475872,
-0.0373100452,
-0.0007545549,
0.0208471585,
0.0457456298,
-0.0687231123,
-0.0026992112,
0.1352573037,
0.0344358832,
-0.0167362485,
0.030172227,
0.0103049669,
0.0047908607,
0.0045500947,
-0.0076386663,
-0.0611504391,
-0.0132727744,
0.0035815365,
0.005262109,
-0.032505922,
-0.0340197496,
0.0274116676,
-0.1142267212,
0.036692854,
0.0213556457,
-0.0152502852,
-0.0272647962,
-0.0568335913,
-0.0010856901,
-0.042246528,
0.0355777703,
0.01039577,
-0.0128329862,
-0.0447760895,
0.0138314134,
-0.0515171327,
-0.0711021498,
0.0535916127,
-0.0534028262,
0.068158403,
0.0667669699,
0.0212545525,
-0.0210086349,
-0.0302153658,
0.0114164185,
0.0076370072,
-0.0198651217,
0.0115491077,
-0.0040450781,
0.0221884809,
-0.0154179251,
-0.0304457657,
-0.0006162077,
-0.0444537401,
-0.0109625123,
0.011131336,
0.0968559682,
-0.0277715717,
-0.024983108,
-0.030912986,
0.0007835079,
-0.0227645133,
0.0959663019,
0.0271049924,
-0.0328842551,
-0.0461063981,
-0.0099593038,
-0.036501497,
-0.00028847,
-0.0443983115,
0.0207019523,
-0.0000620224,
-0.017170798,
-0.0276647806,
-0.0109104002,
0.0240879059,
-0.0182376616,
0.0046569449,
0.0236886572,
0.0245749112,
-0.0030629677,
-0.0145111317,
0.0245876834,
-0.0216448307,
0.0562063158,
-0.0833163857,
0.015819326,
0.0386710241,
0.0152380746,
-0.020845687,
0.0264224913,
-0.0739653111,
-0.0774892047,
-0.0029124464,
0.0164103881,
0.0230106805,
-0.0004883913,
-0.0439498909,
-0.0525443107,
0.0399482101,
0.0211630035,
-0.0319227055,
0.0100768609,
0.0090570822,
0.0091772769,
0.0116260573,
0.0327211693,
-0.016137775,
0.0228749346,
-0.0068844981,
0.0462960191,
-0.0363479331,
-0.0442666262,
-0.0089947181,
0.0509627946,
0.025945982,
-0.0409498028,
-0.022782784,
0.001638664,
-0.0188735761,
-0.0623201132,
-0.0206288137,
-0.041553054,
-0.0097492551,
0.0500852987,
0.0167112537,
-0.0272569247,
0.0095730592,
-0.0302973539,
-0.0047142175,
-0.0283581316,
0.0679042265,
-0.0026669968,
-0.0108123831,
0.0375455208,
-0.0050203553,
-0.0158184767,
0.0167893916,
-0.0386954769,
0.0167539828,
0.0023163711,
0.0436523929,
0.0001459099,
-0.0020117636,
0.0187316816,
0.0467271917,
-0.0465633385,
-0.0435127392,
-0.0092114815,
0.054205168,
0.0465161838,
0.0124643538,
0.0615826547,
-0.0392126441,
0.0122621357,
-0.0534301288,
0.0116709927,
-0.0090700258,
-0.0436636433,
0.0320425443,
0.027218191,
-0.0355094261,
0.018190328,
0.067706123,
0.0362367518,
0.0085865753,
0.0114441514,
-0.0195413325,
-0.0255120713,
-0.0327685624,
0.0017314771,
-0.032039661,
-0.0633103028,
0.0032543752,
-0.0985705033,
-0.0680538192,
-0.000088481,
0.0420933813,
0.011830247,
-0.0181931742,
0.0259778015,
0.0595321134,
0.0118183009,
0.0076517886,
-0.063939698,
-0.0033509354,
-0.0152477045,
-0.0192913339,
0.0000886389,
-6.491904855e-33,
-0.0056906329,
-0.0255279411,
0.0315734707,
-0.0268525258,
-0.0387192145,
0.0105555709,
-0.0294079222,
0.0128506133,
-0.0092310198,
-0.0048394715,
0.0178209301,
-0.0147820394,
0.008049394,
0.0135091431,
0.0008493473,
-0.0205406919,
0.009133839,
0.0111999605,
-0.0125819873,
-0.0067736548,
0.0031544603,
-0.0018872265,
0.0520284101,
-0.0518653505,
0.0392635763,
0.0027611349,
0.0015344523,
0.0078463648,
-0.0272051636,
0.087516591,
-0.0459611304,
0.0377578251,
0.0179606434,
-0.0521528535,
-0.0076486384,
0.0052667633,
-0.0278406292,
0.0118354904,
0.0303389169,
0.0107016135,
-0.0233377591,
-0.0303286426,
0.0683393776,
0.0020303125,
-0.073022902,
0.0101478156,
0.0136769395,
-0.0468303598,
-0.0296916775,
0.0161000974,
-0.0571493879,
0.060905423,
-0.0033635821,
-0.004756873,
0.0218570363,
-0.015500186,
-0.0415166281,
0.0342416614,
-0.0342061147,
0.0128517123,
0.0619247183,
0.0052656913,
0.0897486135,
-0.0000108242,
0.0175438672,
0.0643649697,
-0.001312155,
-0.004207639,
-0.0260631163,
-0.0293721128,
0.0362532735,
0.0499732792,
0.0516708083,
0.0320601687,
-0.001471266,
0.0029317446,
-0.0859295502,
-0.0005617666,
0.0183225274,
0.0501040034,
0.0328494683,
0.0132239833,
-0.056865409,
-0.0303344782,
-0.0680815876,
0.0015668862,
-0.0208330657,
-0.0095644491,
0.0486713052,
-0.0221602283,
-0.0089109633,
0.0099300612,
0.0356360823,
-0.0907309428,
-0.0258026738,
-0.001461817,
0.0153941195,
0.03807991,
0.0025751204,
0.0512788817,
-0.075577274,
-0.0131931622,
-0.005516951,
-0.0000750754,
0.0123167885,
-0.0285224244,
-0.0196185168,
0.0048353132,
-0.0305874161,
-0.0030000657,
-0.0181834158,
-0.0246057026,
0.0190798081,
0.0181202106,
0.0359535329,
-0.0167184193,
-0.0004382409,
0.0362604819,
0.0038889402,
-0.0021165588,
-0.0027979969,
-0.0003594549,
0.0066644857,
0.0105837975,
-0.0306075457,
0.0143071255,
-0.0415153988,
0.0203328263,
0.050917279,
-0.0100523327,
0.0000744582,
0.0152883139,
2.827e-7,
0.0474298336,
0.0538541675,
0.0081650838,
0.01231746,
0.0050489437,
0.0243256688,
-0.0429240763,
0.0081310375,
0.0018172774,
-0.0072604003,
-0.0066128923,
0.0279860254,
0.0751242936,
0.0174757652,
-0.0551093817,
-0.0101597803,
-0.0671753734,
-0.0128884362,
-0.0523248948,
0.0176651701,
0.037853159,
0.0976922885,
0.0065415744,
0.0038617083,
-0.0212434623,
-0.0615239032,
0.0475305729,
-0.0594760478,
-0.0292839557,
0.0486285128,
0.0272558574,
0.0285562146,
0.0290819611,
0.0153324362,
0.0359858572,
0.0168958213,
0.0354731008,
0.0919169486,
-0.0081613539,
0.0052538393,
-0.0001642753,
-0.0558017828,
0.0005041882,
-0.0745497793,
0.0826858357,
-0.0360787809,
-0.0525487699,
-0.0388818942,
-0.0093618175,
-0.0169095844,
0.0604390688,
-0.0061314553,
-0.0328670219,
0.0204863343,
0.0351582654,
-0.0279507283,
-0.0176788624,
-0.0423358008,
-0.0135220122,
-0.0101181073,
-0.0428842269,
-0.0815627277,
-0.0248854179,
0.0036663108,
0.0029318773,
-0.0608129129,
-0.0006302026,
2.826402469e-34,
0.0414933152,
-0.0171173327,
-0.0021995897,
0.0108488873,
0.034036655,
0.0298568588,
-0.0326518118,
0.0079392754,
-0.0156632513,
-0.1129857898,
0.0248912405
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.03104v6 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.03104v6 | Efficient Domain Adaptation of Sentence Embeddings Using Adapters | 2023-07-06T16:26:34 | 2023-09-24T20:25:57 | Tim Schopf, Dennis N. Schneider, Florian Matthes | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7 | Sentence embeddings enable us to capture the semantic similarity of short
texts. Most sentence embedding models are trained for general semantic textual
similarity tasks. Therefore, to use sentence embeddings in a particular domain,
the model must be adapted to it in order to achieve good results. Usually, this
is done by fine-tuning the entire sentence embedding model for the domain of
interest. While this approach yields state-of-the-art results, all of the
model's weights are updated during fine-tuning, making this method
resource-intensive. Therefore, instead of fine-tuning entire sentence embedding
models for each target domain individually, we propose to train lightweight
adapters. These domain-specific adapters do not require fine-tuning all
underlying sentence embedding model parameters. Instead, we only train a small
number of additional parameters while keeping the weights of the underlying
sentence embedding model fixed. Training domain-specific adapters allows always
using the same base model and only exchanging the domain-specific adapters to
adapt sentence embeddings to a specific domain. We show that using adapters for
parameter-efficient domain adaptation of sentence embeddings yields competitive
performance within 1% of a domain-adapted, entirely fine-tuned sentence
embedding model while only training approximately 3.6% of the parameters. | [
0.023068361,
0.0160313491,
-0.0052321339,
0.0807825029,
-0.0238903183,
0.019417502,
0.0090234643,
-0.0446257778,
-0.0173734464,
-0.070212312,
-0.0220240559,
0.0268462654,
-0.0342881046,
-0.0166395623,
0.0077319159,
-0.0512047708,
0.0304932855,
0.0331134126,
-0.0223615821,
0.0122454735,
0.0288118888,
0.0022658003,
0.0174665451,
0.0333124623,
0.0234849025,
-0.0053081834,
0.0161846094,
0.0056093186,
0.0387322083,
-0.0079077082,
0.0490154848,
0.0130069302,
0.041822657,
0.0001398524,
0.0000016119,
-0.0228535999,
-0.0264595281,
-0.025986474,
0.0200456046,
0.014154003,
0.059336856,
-0.0283323154,
0.0224118177,
0.005587392,
-0.0233954694,
-0.0345879421,
0.0339423083,
0.0672354475,
0.0287494864,
0.0866903216,
-0.0330283977,
-0.0122144753,
-0.0096508618,
-0.0428429656,
-0.0382119678,
-0.0482050255,
0.0171541404,
-0.0157127604,
-0.0120582478,
0.0312804654,
-0.0420026705,
0.0015257754,
-0.0058900192,
0.0340429023,
0.0088239377,
0.002502834,
-0.010895811,
0.0473744646,
0.0007031668,
0.0578695014,
-0.0123953,
-0.0333239026,
0.0014155578,
-0.0020255209,
0.0255806241,
0.0018423581,
-0.025161542,
-0.020558469,
0.0357237048,
0.0392414778,
0.0073864958,
0.0488317236,
0.0215293374,
0.0009582269,
-0.0400161855,
0.0085800188,
0.0246242993,
-0.0304535087,
-0.0126270112,
0.0320309699,
-0.0441014618,
-0.0015277851,
-0.0141011719,
-0.0181115661,
0.0133282626,
-0.0194668714,
-0.094285287,
-0.0470588282,
0.000739812,
-0.027100049,
0.0595510602,
0.0240441393,
0.0132463938,
0.0459818095,
-0.0614935569,
0.0266985204,
-0.0166930798,
0.0015010344,
-0.0726776868,
-0.0311597642,
-0.0742265955,
0.0169432648,
-0.0528634079,
0.0520285629,
-0.0341586657,
-0.048280973,
-0.0118763773,
0.0467638299,
-0.000980208,
-0.0217158236,
-0.0063519687,
0.0142403999,
-0.0313007645,
-0.0195260048,
0.0266830139,
0.0440294407,
-0.0681377351,
0.0619742945,
0.0101761678,
-0.0028024199,
-0.033241652,
0.0338700153,
0.0552939847,
-0.039927192,
-0.0135982968,
0.0374933928,
0.0236689094,
-0.037388999,
-0.0181271452,
0.0137189906,
-0.0166883674,
-0.0295928661,
-0.0024983943,
-0.0566833839,
0.0342358872,
-0.0032208243,
0.0194252729,
-0.0506041795,
-0.0071427189,
0.0046462337,
-0.0460909605,
0.0544948913,
0.0353597626,
-0.0260612462,
-0.0460117459,
0.0018171443,
0.0198917761,
0.0740805417,
0.0203940738,
-0.0014882464,
0.031377051,
0.0212869719,
-0.0329902545,
0.0061280658,
0.0064906431,
0.030994935,
0.0221701432,
0.0121702394,
0.0083164759,
0.0468964055,
0.0414459556,
0.0089724548,
-0.019108193,
-0.0238299537,
0.0359030664,
0.0149856582,
0.0516451448,
0.0008551793,
0.0536805131,
0.0115934322,
-0.051974535,
0.0185971428,
-0.0774466395,
0.008788947,
-0.0073663816,
0.0020090197,
0.0073471568,
0.0393449441,
-0.0466389507,
0.0027453911,
0.0039652996,
-0.0361759923,
0.0068249642,
-0.0232836958,
0.0058060978,
0.0444823913,
-0.023678286,
0.0673583299,
0.0368202403,
-0.0451855026,
-0.0466687195,
0.013056987,
-0.007429387,
0.0208061803,
0.0201007891,
-0.0050700149,
-0.011479252,
-0.0097570075,
0.0753143802,
0.0254312232,
0.0731522664,
0.0031254627,
0.0344178006,
-0.0545232221,
-0.0475015417,
-0.0293045416,
0.039153982,
0.0075681484,
0.0141922161,
0.0277501624,
0.0488125682,
-0.0612655841,
-0.0181897879,
0.0352095552,
-0.0221845508,
-0.0207751617,
0.0418008976,
0.0291313287,
0.0109873768,
-0.0006158248,
0.0029852611,
0.0129587762,
0.0158587061,
-0.071354337,
-0.0328676067,
-0.0011434699,
-0.058262147,
-0.0758514106,
0.0213486347,
-0.0714714676,
0.010024366,
0.0551976152,
-0.0683305785,
-0.0051677497,
-0.0056118323,
-0.0087904288,
0.0294075552,
-0.0250410512,
0.0017542238,
-0.0146756042,
0.0348796137,
-0.0188248344,
0.031509351,
0.0254752394,
-0.0104653491,
-0.0262831617,
-0.0046029473,
0.0465606563,
-0.0096457414,
-0.0427141935,
-0.0570503324,
0.0054086684,
0.0344695039,
0.0164598264,
-0.0091557866,
-0.0131638199,
-0.025230227,
-0.0714846104,
0.0376667976,
-0.005734561,
0.019162979,
0.0286710318,
0.055984512,
-0.0050113932,
-0.0182232708,
-0.0142465765,
0.0198007915,
-0.037823353,
0.0344233587,
0.0528269038,
-0.0342657231,
0.0017228172,
-0.0534096211,
0.0303459577,
-0.0142864352,
0.0540663749,
-0.0365172811,
0.0013793589,
-0.0618709177,
0.0175940748,
-0.005696937,
-0.0019256549,
0.0226657987,
-0.0472482108,
-0.0369213857,
0.0110770678,
0.0291194879,
0.0571258701,
0.0121830106,
0.0181104206,
0.0409717523,
0.0523829795,
-0.040815413,
0.0103523517,
-0.0345217176,
0.0394527167,
-0.049911771,
-0.003702478,
0.0385645181,
0.0428660922,
-0.0239564721,
-0.0142733678,
-0.0510745943,
0.0308169536,
0.0041272445,
0.0153393317,
-0.0107743414,
0.0191736575,
-0.0125346053,
-0.0220452454,
-0.0182783399,
-0.0008751622,
0.053162232,
-0.0150307668,
0.0161204766,
-0.0762975514,
-0.0361051708,
-0.04115187,
0.0162082575,
0.0130499452,
0.0270243827,
0.0344217941,
0.0335150361,
-0.0483173169,
0.0084433453,
0.0544450022,
0.0268446673,
0.0599328503,
0.0285671577,
0.0098044546,
-0.0413465835,
-0.0714563504,
-0.026490286,
-0.0470454767,
-0.0452439152,
0.0090682982,
-0.0197501387,
0.0027016257,
-0.0780408978,
0.0012030386,
-0.0079800468,
0.0132053131,
-0.033583533,
-0.0061954986,
-0.0377815962,
0.0634772032,
0.0977365449,
0.0316655971,
-0.0226415675,
0.0085957926,
0.0496415533,
0.0345059484,
0.0140639115,
0.0252267253,
-0.059330821,
-0.0115321334,
0.0000032006,
-0.0366170295,
0.0140362829,
0.0065312963,
0.0792297721,
-0.0026933346,
-0.0041868836,
0.1012214869,
0.0005769781,
-0.0100996504,
-0.0058315517,
0.0101695992,
0.0483134948,
0.0241113137,
0.004942873,
-0.0768492296,
-0.078801617,
-0.0005430925,
0.0011893103,
0.0339362882,
-0.0095082335,
-0.0009072116,
-0.0909951106,
-0.0199464057,
0.0285609011,
-0.0093226405,
-0.035957519,
-0.008057788,
0.0244781245,
0.0035655431,
0.0053345342,
-0.0511426292,
-0.0154739348,
-0.0235633403,
-0.0032894074,
-0.0345845297,
-0.0413470827,
0.0119296554,
-0.0653571188,
0.0235827491,
0.0275200792,
0.0074519818,
0.0116485516,
0.0161142666,
0.0165584963,
-0.0480738692,
-0.0325955749,
0.0061455765,
0.0381241925,
-0.0283186641,
0.0042499546,
0.0155968023,
0.0303261913,
-0.061149735,
-0.0031055938,
0.047241278,
0.0888543576,
0.0204300843,
-0.0294427965,
-0.0575926676,
-0.0066338405,
-0.0194301531,
0.0985742584,
0.0667655244,
-0.0550887883,
-0.0294252317,
0.00234088,
-0.0541284829,
-0.056186337,
-0.0259660091,
-0.0159143098,
0.0117585463,
0.0193090364,
-0.0778065845,
-0.0563636608,
0.0052683176,
0.005183558,
-0.0033162162,
0.0124660106,
-0.0254161544,
-0.0266929511,
-0.0449285246,
0.0012421816,
-0.0580160879,
0.0234194286,
0.0044250255,
0.0410297289,
0.0581676103,
0.0215042289,
-0.0293809902,
-0.0498270653,
-0.08230073,
-0.0418379903,
-0.0358183309,
0.0145650348,
-0.0035707378,
0.0562460385,
-0.0283017531,
-0.0033578898,
0.0467880256,
0.0520071127,
-0.0107866507,
0.0483947173,
0.047641065,
-0.0356078111,
0.0062950682,
0.0707449093,
-0.0604651868,
0.0326830409,
0.0362706855,
0.0354867391,
0.017008381,
-0.0571544766,
-0.0133762266,
-0.0291812345,
0.0230471995,
0.0369171277,
-0.0258155502,
-0.0109346956,
0.016335696,
0.0063905809,
-0.0208022185,
-0.0323613063,
-0.0013647786,
0.0124945417,
0.027644882,
-0.0231871903,
0.0250633247,
0.0062200767,
0.0434174761,
-0.0511598438,
0.0352522358,
0.019383816,
0.0256668255,
-0.0123336539,
0.0107881939,
-0.0444660597,
-0.0369812623,
0.0033242067,
0.0010770801,
-0.0510581583,
-0.0185771361,
0.026595531,
0.0083858212,
-0.0446478799,
0.0455617458,
-0.0577845797,
0.0365506969,
-0.0220437143,
0.0025352207,
0.0398977883,
-0.0563794076,
0.0383852273,
-0.0062690005,
0.0015139648,
-0.02032681,
0.0422105342,
-0.0208449606,
0.0238127746,
0.0316382609,
0.0102260495,
-0.0414287969,
0.0064257439,
0.0659602508,
0.0142277014,
0.0759715587,
0.0152500691,
-0.0049089408,
-0.0345224105,
-0.0246621687,
0.015707057,
0.0346825831,
0.0117680654,
0.0099620055,
-0.0042047575,
-0.0428061001,
0.0369236991,
-0.0477106869,
-0.0281693935,
0.0008607201,
0.026749501,
0.0194178447,
-0.0181444772,
-0.0069742375,
-0.0039227963,
0.0101856384,
-0.0027094109,
-0.0512857772,
-0.0250328686,
-5.511623382e-33,
-0.0117796846,
0.0445615724,
-0.0231799036,
-0.018562058,
-0.0272833463,
-0.027292436,
-0.0144300442,
-0.0249265675,
-0.0497748032,
0.0309746619,
0.0173349213,
-0.0022167836,
0.0044746394,
0.0440992117,
-0.0282685254,
-0.002321688,
0.057371553,
0.005155629,
-0.0274342224,
0.0017419843,
0.0125228791,
0.0243317783,
0.0279326793,
-0.0419098586,
-0.0454620123,
-0.0043383641,
0.0185491461,
0.0048994143,
0.092579864,
0.0737030283,
-0.0042178337,
0.0375228748,
0.0449501313,
-0.0108651845,
-0.0244049281,
0.0384389609,
-0.0981297791,
-0.0536475889,
-0.0043980507,
-0.0223625135,
0.0035505849,
-0.0410389602,
0.0287712589,
0.0130361794,
0.0339094922,
-0.056056045,
0.0352381654,
-0.0499733947,
-0.0137949893,
0.0147085078,
-0.0799696445,
0.0083113667,
0.023203671,
-0.0030968275,
0.0035135585,
0.0445410572,
0.0233362559,
0.0433464982,
-0.0147970049,
-0.0026374692,
-0.024756765,
0.0543904379,
-0.0184745882,
-0.0269587468,
-0.0333063342,
0.0645944774,
-0.0353320204,
-0.0467019677,
0.0076065338,
0.0053683207,
0.0149225425,
0.0330712982,
0.0425549708,
0.0945424885,
0.0171142481,
-0.0255762246,
-0.0807209536,
0.0267271865,
0.0069374456,
-0.0082292818,
0.0424750485,
0.0188963395,
-0.0364892296,
-0.0021399402,
-0.0284958109,
0.034452755,
-0.0278646927,
-0.0253632553,
0.0637984127,
0.0168090798,
-0.0247286279,
0.0032353096,
0.0254962295,
-0.0916003287,
0.0083610276,
0.0202362593,
-0.0149228908,
-0.0127182305,
0.0160847493,
-0.0062699886,
-0.0039991392,
-0.0317982584,
0.0290739127,
0.0034642508,
0.0027971894,
-0.0185681544,
0.115784131,
-0.0285702199,
-0.0769571215,
-0.0149777383,
-0.0251185298,
-0.0459680632,
-0.0586938672,
0.0456920527,
-0.0167415626,
0.0468130819,
-0.0123974765,
0.0449874736,
0.0178048648,
-0.0604236722,
-0.0021631957,
-0.0119931912,
0.0140084885,
0.0365176685,
-0.0227713641,
-0.0308197252,
-0.0354700759,
0.0395744033,
0.000817743,
-0.0607033819,
-0.0172111802,
-0.017476242,
2.263e-7,
0.0271451846,
-0.0069398633,
0.0118274596,
-0.0463970788,
0.027982574,
0.0572171882,
0.0187974684,
0.0829631463,
-0.0134027991,
0.0362035036,
0.0193281379,
0.0194933675,
0.0591832139,
-0.016392976,
-0.103771165,
0.0547748022,
-0.0403361209,
-0.0336036198,
-0.02589982,
-0.0133607667,
0.0484219678,
0.1030610725,
0.0422840789,
0.007416612,
-0.0002860565,
-0.0688745677,
0.054948356,
-0.0396497026,
0.0027697661,
-0.0002660112,
-0.0274296515,
0.0446011983,
-0.0004963483,
-0.0279661845,
-0.0131078288,
0.0617004856,
0.0063575613,
0.0466109999,
0.0090421978,
-0.00166291,
-0.0232474077,
-0.0104280319,
0.0052229255,
0.0008345684,
0.071165204,
-0.0881685317,
0.0031064576,
-0.0442886837,
-0.0008635441,
0.0275330544,
0.0087253377,
0.0350074358,
-0.0334239379,
0.0117912916,
0.0732915699,
0.011380435,
-0.0443369672,
-0.0724370033,
0.0136714531,
0.020483207,
-0.0412957296,
-0.0101806866,
-0.057641238,
0.0055971583,
0.0796353593,
-0.0840345621,
0.0193910804,
2.162759684e-34,
0.0092998641,
-0.0037959428,
0.0032863419,
0.0110460604,
0.0171838403,
-0.0252300184,
0.0005470118,
-0.0230294876,
0.032482367,
-0.0884570032,
0.0232531782
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.06775v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.06775v4 | A Novel Site-Agnostic Multimodal Deep Learning Model to Identify Pro-Eating Disorder Content on Social Media | 2023-07-06T16:04:46 | 2023-11-05T13:52:26 | Jonathan Feldman | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SI | Over the last decade, there has been a vast increase in eating disorder
diagnoses and eating disorder-attributed deaths, reaching their zenith during
the Covid-19 pandemic. This immense growth derived in part from the stressors
of the pandemic but also from increased exposure to social media, which is rife
with content that promotes eating disorders. This study aimed to create a
multimodal deep learning model that can determine if a given social media post
promotes eating disorders based on a combination of visual and textual data. A
labeled dataset of Tweets was collected from Twitter, recently rebranded as X,
upon which twelve deep learning models were trained and evaluated. Based on
model performance, the most effective deep learning model was the multimodal
fusion of the RoBERTa natural language processing model and the MaxViT image
classification model, attaining accuracy and F1 scores of 95.9% and 0.959,
respectively. The RoBERTa and MaxViT fusion model, deployed to classify an
unlabeled dataset of posts from the social media sites Tumblr and Reddit,
generated results akin to those of previous research studies that did not
employ artificial intelligence-based techniques, indicating that deep learning
models can develop insights congruent to those of researchers. Additionally,
the model was used to conduct a time-series analysis of yet unseen Tweets from
eight Twitter hashtags, uncovering that, since 2014, the relative abundance of
content that promotes eating disorders has decreased drastically within those
communities. Despite this reduction, by 2018, content that promotes eating
disorders had either stopped declining or increased in ampleness anew on those
hashtags. | [
0.0801817998,
0.0698880404,
-0.0064757369,
-0.0077088601,
-0.0195855591,
0.0306403246,
-0.0046222853,
-0.0019504883,
0.0273905285,
-0.0415804684,
0.0045681437,
-0.0207996629,
-0.0453014001,
0.0426892675,
0.0017178046,
-0.0196453817,
0.0353003293,
0.0598028153,
0.024161052,
0.017203236,
0.0431633182,
0.0207634009,
-0.0006456893,
0.0393205099,
-0.0259514786,
-0.0257636774,
0.0637360141,
0.0038698844,
0.0327038802,
-0.0598477423,
0.0620792508,
0.0041410783,
0.0142277125,
0.0756197944,
0.0000019937,
0.0194899831,
0.0050673736,
-0.0261337534,
0.0089658825,
-0.0151707148,
0.0755555183,
-0.0657152832,
0.0177557506,
0.0115610361,
-0.0375783034,
0.0178081039,
0.0982368886,
0.0698573515,
0.0627345145,
0.0364343673,
-0.0241019316,
-0.0674515218,
-0.0023538142,
0.0231927391,
-0.0250279848,
0.0341007002,
0.0339905694,
-0.0397497416,
0.0156821404,
0.0022306759,
-0.0064049945,
0.0651782677,
0.0099108098,
-0.0039693331,
0.0166611392,
0.0068804189,
0.0110075315,
-0.0831566006,
0.0239449032,
0.0858672559,
-0.0263059158,
0.005817981,
0.0199719612,
-0.0003940875,
-0.0430735089,
0.0178007856,
0.0032711742,
-0.0109142503,
-0.0078156618,
0.0404484272,
-0.0036704291,
0.0063206609,
0.0759428591,
0.0653626025,
0.0109169781,
0.0126210758,
-0.024796579,
-0.010331424,
-0.007877484,
-0.0407978185,
-0.0424619652,
-0.0353388861,
0.0191176534,
-0.0025243317,
0.0028498801,
0.0144616347,
-0.0038519425,
-0.0687603652,
0.0489613675,
-0.0487758666,
0.0009637561,
0.0089076422,
-0.065630056,
-0.0034330348,
0.0201351047,
-0.0268375799,
-0.0423522666,
0.0286701657,
0.0004779962,
0.0585046634,
-0.0627240166,
0.0052235639,
0.0493767001,
-0.0069585512,
-0.0216481127,
-0.0398969948,
-0.0351648144,
-0.0237600394,
-0.045238521,
-0.0343895182,
-0.0270466171,
0.0717284977,
0.0034117787,
0.0239350647,
0.0204244293,
0.06785357,
0.0286862236,
0.0401468165,
-0.0061265188,
-0.0001990151,
0.0325638615,
-0.017461706,
0.0319522396,
-0.0165968612,
0.0269252043,
0.0413832814,
0.0210295077,
-0.0316663682,
-0.0429608747,
-0.0297704451,
-0.0609118938,
-0.0428352579,
0.0422591045,
-0.0500783622,
0.0184931699,
-0.0209959615,
0.0233081449,
-0.0236094892,
0.0087216403,
0.0256314706,
-0.0274599567,
0.0697802529,
0.01532399,
0.013929571,
0.0715289041,
0.0315901041,
0.0383506641,
0.062246751,
0.0256989431,
0.0546530411,
0.0185488276,
-0.0244861301,
-0.0371252634,
0.0148167936,
0.0339567736,
0.0091824075,
-0.0139134154,
-0.0197410006,
-0.0390308648,
-0.0048573795,
-0.0340546928,
0.0275992118,
-0.0013063753,
-0.0013760644,
0.0644639656,
0.0301952194,
-0.0182915684,
0.0421948582,
0.023288589,
0.0181629267,
-0.0261152834,
-0.03913562,
-0.0294283889,
0.0000126687,
-0.0029733705,
-0.0292414408,
0.0390109532,
0.0387998,
-0.0166280586,
-0.0045901285,
-0.0231926534,
-0.019706212,
0.0410866737,
-0.0357956812,
0.0149305956,
-0.0338574499,
-0.0554836467,
-0.0314818211,
0.0368966274,
-0.0109815532,
-0.0104517499,
-0.0361734368,
0.0251458548,
0.0422816835,
0.0019384067,
-0.0211834125,
0.0174410567,
-0.0418019518,
0.063060917,
0.0296946168,
0.0037402096,
0.0380126089,
-0.0035295414,
0.0036394233,
-0.0437848642,
-0.0147570288,
0.0281675737,
-0.0186635628,
-0.0177537668,
0.0546636693,
-0.0234539192,
0.0816333741,
-0.0288201701,
0.0017719585,
0.0299828649,
-0.0109757958,
-0.0085211759,
0.0218531452,
0.015155945,
0.035695456,
-0.0122353155,
0.0062550465,
-0.0221409332,
-0.0169206727,
-0.0806137398,
-0.0085430089,
-0.0178821646,
0.0153523609,
0.003403015,
-0.0681074858,
0.0104608322,
0.0570930727,
-0.0416717306,
0.0058319294,
0.070357047,
-0.0539815687,
-0.0056002699,
-0.024588516,
-0.0902222916,
-0.0257888231,
0.0251140203,
0.0216565486,
0.059602838,
-0.0349959955,
-0.008130243,
0.0087904595,
-0.0785665736,
-0.006534209,
0.022500677,
-0.0182246137,
-0.0574056283,
-0.0211667828,
0.0020876483,
0.0190549064,
0.0022687493,
-0.0045683095,
0.0069583571,
-0.0839388743,
0.0150608784,
-0.0380831137,
-0.0278968811,
-0.0339652151,
-0.0081828246,
-0.002822435,
-0.0028023261,
-0.0122320233,
0.0181973502,
0.0185297057,
0.0769052655,
-0.0102695785,
-0.0028691036,
0.0197644979,
-0.0496865213,
-0.0271090418,
-0.0367951281,
0.0419384539,
0.0443216339,
-0.0778842494,
0.0358009972,
-0.0553270467,
-0.0715728551,
-0.0071845506,
0.0243846588,
-0.0695123523,
0.0074977069,
0.0005416559,
-0.0175014697,
0.0205640737,
0.0191437192,
0.0315340459,
0.0102496343,
0.0395362377,
-0.0188486259,
0.012378809,
-0.0318333805,
-0.0147643918,
-0.0179317687,
-0.0542476512,
-0.0042330083,
0.0405330621,
0.0263577793,
0.0152656669,
-0.0242766961,
0.015970353,
-0.006287552,
-0.0188048352,
-0.0346154012,
-0.0289908051,
0.0204637814,
-0.0028343715,
-0.0415997803,
-0.0352463238,
0.0364603586,
0.046003595,
0.0095713595,
0.0113865808,
-0.0467340089,
-0.0049809497,
-0.017951997,
0.0521729626,
0.0777206719,
0.0139593529,
0.009099545,
0.058040075,
-0.0263907462,
-0.0152453342,
-0.0224205777,
-0.0112214182,
-0.0083965417,
0.0034468058,
-0.0108480379,
-0.0257585328,
-0.0359366462,
-0.0586369224,
-0.0550661013,
-0.0645959973,
-0.0337981507,
0.003050589,
-0.0247533023,
-0.0024696218,
-0.0054126773,
0.0213797595,
0.0099802129,
-0.0163781885,
0.0191878248,
-0.0003933696,
0.0454153456,
-0.0464799851,
-0.0287888497,
-0.018768169,
0.0107110608,
0.0297306608,
-0.0596309975,
0.0492283739,
-0.0855443478,
0.0442618392,
-0.0182194393,
0.0360626988,
-0.007140147,
-0.0231776759,
0.0065398356,
-0.0074923411,
0.0319130458,
0.057168223,
-0.0198829938,
-0.0416642837,
0.0123969065,
0.0433338806,
-0.0405511111,
0.0015802548,
-0.0101873362,
-0.0576733127,
-0.0478503965,
-0.0558631644,
0.0014113311,
-0.0738332644,
-0.0273591261,
-0.0012269366,
-0.0267914012,
0.0207666401,
-0.0148567697,
0.0079980213,
-0.0009203077,
-0.0244342946,
0.0191857293,
-0.033104375,
-0.0018430486,
-0.0639749989,
-0.0109923119,
-0.0082645472,
-0.0108169587,
-0.0575790107,
-0.0524042323,
0.0143724931,
-0.0346392877,
0.0171948057,
0.0159845613,
0.0607126728,
-0.0010347186,
-0.0614634715,
0.0367912427,
0.0594677404,
0.0150164384,
-0.0310340431,
0.0806658268,
-0.0088235913,
-0.0200251192,
-0.0262945462,
0.0380183496,
-0.0533528738,
0.0086747641,
-0.0384806618,
0.0874596611,
0.0062751938,
-0.0306047574,
-0.0931818634,
0.0229798928,
0.0251667406,
0.031971734,
0.0433998965,
-0.0360304005,
-0.0134621216,
-0.024666179,
-0.0002145282,
-0.0631095245,
-0.0007959048,
0.0115160244,
-0.0247115456,
-0.0517739169,
-0.0151780546,
0.0118155954,
-0.0013286783,
-0.0539196804,
0.0192421265,
-0.0199904125,
-0.0275795441,
-0.0112434272,
-0.0597259477,
0.039376881,
0.0324377269,
0.0500835851,
0.0013635858,
-0.0152847655,
0.0537345111,
0.0153421257,
0.0035707236,
0.0287363175,
-0.0595733374,
-0.0417372547,
0.0041738069,
0.0200554319,
0.0089630289,
0.0069089588,
0.0203337185,
-0.036965888,
0.0347815678,
0.0760926977,
-0.0303761996,
-0.0603823923,
0.015252226,
-0.0463308021,
0.002633844,
0.0108505636,
-0.0005278341,
0.0265498143,
-0.0122704832,
-0.0589134172,
-0.0630188435,
0.0039603584,
-0.0315980352,
-0.0342799723,
0.0366560966,
-0.011011322,
-0.0560518727,
-0.0105179055,
-0.0746278092,
0.044195503,
0.0158062615,
-0.0215696637,
-0.0233688056,
0.0562427677,
-0.0037289648,
-0.0449617915,
-0.0041070976,
-0.0079638334,
0.0447568521,
-0.0648815334,
0.0424348079,
0.0345637761,
0.0295148846,
-0.0355172642,
0.014320205,
-0.0118775638,
0.0458040945,
-0.0074062296,
-0.0356847756,
-0.0106355771,
0.0446666852,
0.0126737952,
0.0141840726,
0.0215543844,
0.0342634432,
-0.0081012836,
-0.0052128392,
-0.0465843342,
-0.0805203989,
0.0439846031,
-0.027943017,
0.0286351331,
0.0285203028,
-0.027972063,
-0.0213044155,
0.0531578958,
-0.0676705614,
-0.0427612178,
0.0486928485,
-0.020914821,
0.0167110488,
0.0088521121,
0.0343880057,
-0.0110571906,
0.0127444984,
0.0706456304,
-0.0208925959,
-0.0207663011,
0.0230949558,
0.0354535058,
0.0417568535,
-0.0042884885,
0.0545097254,
0.0104160933,
-0.0743704662,
0.0317772999,
-0.0618962348,
-0.0109250722,
0.0137711829,
0.0310264099,
0.0434717201,
0.036142718,
-0.0166446213,
-0.015137203,
-0.0076509039,
-0.0011864052,
-0.0235181805,
-0.0298271384,
-6.156315177e-33,
0.0502363183,
-0.0019488776,
-0.0027401082,
-0.0075307423,
-0.0310104694,
0.0258110072,
-0.0130170835,
-0.0072020339,
0.0309746172,
0.010409072,
0.0312387329,
0.0358721949,
-0.007899967,
0.0116877565,
0.0114661604,
-0.0411997102,
0.0359103642,
0.0030512316,
0.0086412728,
0.0356834047,
0.0086955922,
0.0341836549,
0.0211206619,
-0.0537034497,
0.0332510471,
0.0357765444,
0.0037628044,
-0.0078660175,
0.0363889411,
0.0409306586,
-0.0523157902,
0.0897446349,
0.0462188125,
-0.0219694711,
0.0027874012,
0.0917200148,
-0.028245382,
-0.0400872938,
-0.0002656447,
-0.0496796444,
-0.0652283132,
-0.0446748883,
0.0618984625,
0.0155596919,
0.0087388316,
-0.0002637475,
0.0660679489,
-0.0037189,
0.0727672353,
0.0256437361,
0.0059995311,
-0.0063439398,
-0.0474612974,
0.0184768382,
0.0168641116,
0.0482893921,
0.0271265935,
0.053519465,
-0.0532307886,
0.0266762376,
0.0074111233,
-0.0467631891,
0.0500227809,
-0.0179045629,
-0.0083821854,
0.0632768273,
-0.0128784133,
-0.0117425751,
-0.0396591611,
0.036839474,
-0.0082553616,
0.0842251033,
0.0359480493,
0.0354516581,
0.0191196445,
-0.0462714285,
-0.0493314527,
0.0229252912,
0.0058700279,
-0.008675646,
-0.0149894506,
-0.0286659859,
0.0216945261,
0.0040774145,
0.0020698782,
-0.0445500389,
-0.0481651351,
-0.0208544359,
-0.0135065978,
-0.0040081302,
-0.0210316516,
0.0626660436,
0.0043125357,
-0.0066237045,
-0.0373804197,
0.0279549807,
0.0539758429,
0.0090684956,
0.0282209869,
0.0177845135,
-0.0622053109,
0.0358383022,
-0.0161414314,
0.0232329592,
0.049355492,
-0.005439423,
0.0208531152,
0.0451286212,
-0.0044199862,
-0.0231138244,
0.0089550968,
-0.00530825,
-0.0411016792,
0.0644139573,
-0.0154412622,
0.0524175055,
-0.0102199819,
0.0002897142,
0.0349644609,
0.0578636751,
-0.0423487276,
-0.0394624546,
-0.0211910214,
0.0012247376,
-0.00774416,
-0.0560897328,
-0.037075039,
0.0143369278,
0.0267407559,
-0.1229153797,
0.0181316454,
-0.006097124,
2.662e-7,
0.0575498641,
0.0333368182,
-0.0164561868,
0.0017022897,
0.0203087777,
0.0363750607,
0.0228357129,
0.0599727146,
0.0210950486,
-0.0451852866,
-0.0323590524,
0.0425640605,
-0.0284852684,
0.0466149487,
0.032958746,
0.008298018,
-0.0571296178,
0.0336513035,
-0.0728011057,
0.0212895665,
-0.0056605134,
0.060117688,
0.0326653123,
-0.0794410408,
0.0008918006,
-0.0171077866,
0.0547992289,
-0.0344729163,
-0.0016406033,
-0.0065996787,
0.062164288,
0.0303206928,
0.019871071,
-0.0548174568,
-0.0127562545,
-0.0302376244,
0.0076078358,
0.0071724551,
-0.0381304324,
-0.0129559506,
0.0016546964,
-0.000406539,
-0.0330690853,
-0.0189076383,
0.0670775697,
-0.0907042101,
-0.025412919,
-0.0364411958,
-0.0238736887,
-0.0126139019,
0.0583275706,
-0.0147870705,
-0.0314306803,
0.0275074895,
0.0169979576,
-0.0028561282,
0.0056253383,
-0.0993007049,
-0.0029193251,
-0.0119216414,
-0.0547855757,
0.0312532112,
-0.0287881643,
-0.0130257122,
0.0201135408,
-0.0386012048,
0.0084749255,
1.82657358e-34,
0.0340815671,
-0.0328313597,
0.0156874359,
-0.045756273,
-0.0317317434,
0.034843307,
-0.054661952,
-0.0276166182,
-0.011071844,
-0.0577564649,
0.0102660721
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.04648v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.04648v1 | Can ChatGPT's Responses Boost Traditional Natural Language Processing? | 2023-07-06T15:42:05 | 2023-07-06T15:42:05 | Mostafa M. Amin, Erik Cambria, Björn W. Schuller | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The employment of foundation models is steadily expanding, especially with
the launch of ChatGPT and the release of other foundation models. These models
have shown the potential of emerging capabilities to solve problems, without
being particularly trained to solve. A previous work demonstrated these
emerging capabilities in affective computing tasks; the performance quality was
similar to traditional Natural Language Processing (NLP) techniques, but
falling short of specialised trained models, like fine-tuning of the RoBERTa
language model. In this work, we extend this by exploring if ChatGPT has novel
knowledge that would enhance existing specialised models when they are fused
together. We achieve this by investigating the utility of verbose responses
from ChatGPT about solving a downstream task, in addition to studying the
utility of fusing that with existing NLP methods. The study is conducted on
three affective computing problems, namely sentiment analysis, suicide tendency
detection, and big-five personality assessment. The results conclude that
ChatGPT has indeed novel knowledge that can improve existing NLP techniques by
way of fusion, be it early or late fusion. | [
0.0729094073,
0.0559513718,
-0.0364682339,
0.0083473995,
-0.0610337444,
0.0286557581,
-0.0181804951,
-0.0143514192,
0.0653491095,
-0.0583514273,
-0.0059405165,
0.0060238759,
-0.0429881662,
0.0365083627,
-0.0191762093,
-0.0758515224,
-0.0023550279,
0.0496283509,
0.0397892669,
0.0069932756,
0.0296631269,
0.0278760921,
-0.0123359524,
0.0595550351,
-0.0057061212,
-0.0057949517,
-0.0062634391,
-0.0025563089,
-0.0028049161,
-0.0150954304,
0.0105661461,
0.0418678187,
-0.02195362,
-0.0154534495,
0.0000019701,
-0.0313997865,
-0.0205111578,
0.01379955,
0.0074762949,
-0.0314091854,
0.086471945,
0.013944027,
-0.0016955712,
0.0256385878,
-0.0726941749,
-0.0234334897,
0.0626417845,
0.0865920782,
0.0775391981,
0.089810431,
-0.0357186869,
-0.0160734709,
0.0428134836,
0.0026739107,
0.015229214,
0.0124822725,
0.0134389559,
0.0098028863,
0.0242684968,
-0.0096661439,
-0.02835715,
-0.0002391153,
-0.0033142027,
0.0348964855,
-0.0071942117,
0.0137914773,
-0.0572976619,
-0.0290094726,
-0.0361664481,
0.0241700169,
-0.0205753688,
0.0055249343,
0.0154589768,
-0.0133767575,
0.0025330607,
-0.0162595585,
-0.0260675233,
-0.0167193431,
-0.0338670611,
-0.0026216905,
0.0351321809,
0.0237113871,
-0.0240499396,
-0.0016869833,
0.0453747921,
0.0469619073,
-0.0162294023,
-0.0251730923,
0.0522759147,
0.0252385065,
-0.0336758792,
-0.036923103,
-0.0065891659,
-0.0029171295,
0.0179387201,
0.0075536785,
-0.0176040083,
0.0198085383,
0.0015508374,
-0.0551348031,
0.0003080936,
0.0844654664,
-0.0403472185,
-0.0059097754,
0.0104918266,
0.0100422809,
0.0176175162,
-0.0244324692,
-0.0480011515,
0.0137535734,
-0.1130554602,
-0.0051356386,
-0.0158630293,
0.0530277789,
-0.0469367802,
-0.0467121936,
-0.0864085779,
0.0260227825,
0.0108142681,
-0.0542489327,
0.0074435933,
0.0051489528,
0.003951753,
0.0215805564,
-0.034263812,
0.0277887043,
-0.039053414,
0.0118514998,
-0.0032952339,
-0.0940683484,
0.0341647603,
-0.0001808619,
-0.0240806043,
-0.0402964018,
0.0359878577,
0.0591730513,
0.0138229299,
-0.0336626358,
-0.0350329019,
-0.0138127571,
-0.0240655802,
-0.0658912361,
0.019353997,
-0.0247056782,
0.0231261887,
0.0358877145,
-0.0102543887,
-0.0133345015,
0.0150606539,
-0.0056090634,
-0.024044212,
0.0810533464,
0.0020744007,
-0.0061461176,
-0.0048772292,
-0.006099801,
-0.033813417,
0.0692483634,
-0.0237744283,
0.0272919834,
0.0142593756,
-0.041526664,
0.0100582223,
-0.0103149367,
-0.018825464,
-0.0438372269,
0.0045841853,
-0.008143723,
-0.0500369482,
-0.0110705197,
0.0159407221,
0.036146123,
-0.0226073377,
0.0059933118,
0.0378526896,
0.0717223063,
0.0158407465,
0.0902210474,
-0.0004730851,
0.0213216096,
0.0185381956,
0.0127688721,
-0.0440935083,
0.0201985966,
-0.067691952,
-0.002069721,
-0.0174459852,
0.0195124708,
-0.0172899272,
-0.0710085481,
-0.0328823999,
-0.0031820547,
0.045151446,
0.0183289256,
0.0015406141,
-0.0196846388,
-0.019117156,
-0.0309315566,
0.0279234666,
-0.0526502803,
-0.0361789949,
-0.0789339989,
-0.0217036027,
0.0565853454,
0.0176726151,
-0.033027973,
-0.0196646191,
0.0120139271,
-0.0354085639,
0.0235209689,
0.0523252077,
0.0200955905,
-0.0016285422,
-0.024957886,
0.0158840846,
-0.0031504207,
0.0013835598,
0.0094029438,
0.0061683869,
0.0064341538,
-0.0393715091,
0.041843567,
-0.0020377855,
0.0018290683,
-0.0063247085,
-0.0267396346,
0.0115683749,
0.0012807276,
0.0354268737,
0.0120571693,
-0.005638394,
0.0216852222,
0.0076915589,
0.0026543355,
-0.0847984552,
0.0262487661,
0.0041630338,
-0.0558169261,
0.0069457232,
0.0042541376,
0.0141718695,
0.0223509129,
-0.0119779715,
-0.0236423295,
0.0275088735,
-0.0479479507,
0.054370936,
-0.0275033005,
0.0135552455,
-0.0045413873,
0.0263997614,
-0.0285694599,
0.078544572,
-0.0036390857,
0.0099384096,
-0.042727571,
-0.0289952904,
-0.0167838726,
-0.0500194244,
-0.0681164563,
-0.0132126817,
0.0187517311,
0.0331048742,
0.016455749,
-0.0076720845,
-0.0597009771,
-0.0656325892,
-0.1563290656,
0.0437412187,
0.0229263604,
0.005992339,
-0.0110042309,
0.009495507,
-0.0311385002,
0.0042756754,
-0.0450653918,
0.0139010455,
0.0451477692,
0.0556808338,
0.0099841198,
0.001009921,
0.0150017282,
-0.0632128492,
-0.0190543514,
-0.0430781431,
-0.0126008112,
0.0021779099,
-0.0441532135,
-0.002308191,
0.0247912481,
-0.0488200635,
0.0316921063,
-0.0112805078,
-0.0704769865,
0.0196217652,
-0.0284260325,
0.021563774,
0.0652614087,
-0.0010699529,
0.0826084837,
-0.0249379035,
-0.0311757866,
-0.0021051194,
0.0540891811,
-0.0722231194,
-0.0104405247,
-0.0070676459,
-0.011162187,
-0.0319799446,
0.0480736159,
0.0307279006,
-0.0049843504,
-0.0626722798,
0.0183274187,
0.0016172428,
-0.0016807201,
0.00735967,
-0.0083434125,
0.0091213286,
0.0073192711,
0.0033922051,
-0.0429888628,
0.0557942018,
0.030458387,
-0.0274230558,
-0.0690352321,
-0.037197046,
-0.0446722582,
0.0704160258,
0.0031539912,
0.0062244609,
0.0134861451,
-0.0047367145,
-0.0032617529,
-0.0644609705,
-0.0181269236,
-0.0466711335,
0.003256039,
-0.0000883527,
-0.0088259382,
0.0298467986,
-0.0392840728,
-0.0252526999,
-0.0578848794,
-0.0596307032,
-0.0063631055,
0.0264674947,
-0.0087995855,
-0.0151236337,
-0.0091978293,
0.018004939,
-0.0286380108,
-0.0246454794,
-0.0446368717,
0.0145252496,
-0.0018352498,
0.0281321611,
-0.0027060679,
0.0475693345,
0.010070228,
0.0340215415,
0.0570508502,
0.021564506,
0.0066377851,
-0.0199460015,
0.0394574888,
-0.0185208395,
0.0086455978,
-0.0367574096,
0.0003829352,
0.012267584,
-0.0257719662,
0.0252349395,
0.1103057861,
0.0281540677,
0.0031033522,
-0.0045335223,
-0.0134566147,
-0.0061978027,
0.0133360289,
0.0187897217,
0.0017715637,
-0.0388877355,
-0.0186300278,
0.0144640477,
-0.0446093529,
-0.0305929929,
0.0012956735,
-0.1113199815,
0.0537339784,
-0.0115231993,
-0.0319905169,
0.0414955206,
-0.0075362995,
0.0176528841,
-0.0376636982,
-0.0325562768,
-0.060337428,
-0.019754,
0.0054886937,
0.0241562426,
-0.0635020956,
-0.0308959708,
0.0162868146,
-0.0003721769,
0.0700166672,
0.0244043805,
0.0729758441,
0.0135755846,
0.0019044257,
0.0317968987,
0.0153055331,
0.0441725589,
-0.0258699916,
0.0810398459,
-0.0019517032,
-0.0000318883,
-0.0577556267,
0.0144875115,
-0.0211564973,
0.0194213875,
-0.0031450042,
0.0500135273,
-0.0380054787,
-0.0059751938,
-0.0348004811,
0.0496495999,
0.0339639075,
0.0642917976,
0.0066496669,
-0.0589570627,
-0.0512316078,
0.0048918943,
0.0120965112,
0.0204028841,
-0.0989712849,
-0.0215012897,
0.0145439487,
-0.0380102098,
-0.0681860223,
-0.0723933354,
0.0081661092,
0.0215797368,
-0.0436012782,
-0.010281981,
0.0103993602,
0.0373609215,
-0.0389826782,
0.0531397276,
0.0390001014,
-0.0137548018,
-0.0249215458,
0.0067647202,
0.045513574,
-0.0231030229,
-0.0277709831,
0.0012633088,
-0.0559575148,
-0.0534725338,
0.0380238183,
0.0259175804,
0.0350754298,
-0.0378712416,
-0.0178690162,
-0.047907833,
-0.0295423418,
0.0685291663,
-0.0532537848,
0.0102375951,
0.0228617713,
0.0417272486,
-0.0003380674,
0.0024084041,
0.007140602,
0.0603497252,
0.0291066784,
-0.0098316455,
0.0082988925,
-0.0138532212,
0.0059220195,
0.0380718261,
0.0636275038,
0.0317252204,
-0.0200987104,
0.0013706547,
-0.0461357236,
-0.0107625471,
-0.0080235414,
-0.0493849479,
-0.0596521981,
0.0160149671,
0.0522601679,
-0.0467584841,
-0.043461293,
-0.0352755859,
-0.005908689,
-0.0243389197,
-0.0111542437,
0.0629892275,
-0.0009209563,
-0.0039502974,
0.0258515477,
-0.0228245594,
0.0156934615,
0.013216624,
0.0140590919,
-0.0173213203,
0.0635590181,
-0.0034848067,
0.0020423478,
0.0308170691,
0.0398102216,
-0.0756610408,
-0.0723120272,
-0.017529564,
0.034330342,
0.0038403347,
-0.0101416716,
0.0255516488,
-0.0562266707,
0.0071460544,
-0.0143239368,
0.0171088111,
0.0036585839,
-0.010636026,
0.0036884705,
-0.0039423462,
-0.0380375311,
-0.0498469844,
0.0199698955,
-0.0350802168,
0.0296878777,
0.0160660781,
-0.025404226,
-0.0362406559,
-0.0258244444,
0.0372000076,
-0.0018540524,
0.0246748887,
0.060194917,
-0.0728654638,
-0.0614416972,
0.0543375313,
-0.0252184048,
-0.0112632327,
-0.0320572853,
0.0414635167,
0.0620698407,
0.0027949738,
-0.0072248075,
-0.0371128358,
0.02751166,
-0.0616409555,
0.009280541,
-0.0148728015,
-6.116843179e-33,
-0.0223924518,
0.0155088175,
-0.005432684,
0.0587472431,
-0.0256326441,
0.021699762,
0.021026874,
0.0554262511,
0.0086496817,
0.0205335319,
-0.0290282201,
0.0580642857,
0.0094314395,
0.0042023687,
0.008159359,
-0.0139268264,
0.020093035,
0.0008666031,
0.0081259813,
0.0002551284,
0.0265570972,
0.0297497492,
0.0394006819,
-0.109129481,
0.0189966131,
0.0232088305,
-0.0095710978,
0.0102287708,
0.0232148673,
0.063215442,
-0.0260832813,
0.0708081648,
0.0318998359,
-0.0074300244,
0.0024116703,
0.0294180326,
-0.0244910214,
-0.0495451428,
0.0522159971,
-0.0144656906,
-0.0086777788,
0.0047297743,
0.0406765528,
0.0097192656,
-0.0280835647,
-0.0361182131,
0.0132191377,
-0.0225710161,
0.0373508222,
-0.016428154,
-0.031088246,
0.0168797206,
-0.0019525087,
-0.0055333534,
-0.0140738739,
0.0126072485,
-0.0245846119,
0.0018432959,
-0.0277013369,
-0.0122075109,
-0.014374081,
0.0228179116,
-0.030596165,
-0.0328146517,
-0.0056796325,
0.0691074431,
0.0322743766,
0.0116890566,
-0.0290532392,
0.0203668177,
0.0213971063,
0.0668213591,
0.0846430585,
0.041175615,
-0.001385738,
0.0033291283,
-0.0168774799,
0.0291208122,
0.1028280556,
-0.0124838082,
0.053175088,
0.0012040548,
-0.0541664511,
-0.0105596855,
0.0082464302,
-0.0074986452,
-0.0404324234,
-0.0414932668,
0.0350820161,
-0.0001211997,
0.0165891591,
-0.0066585126,
-0.0048293057,
-0.0331652053,
0.0390577577,
0.0144210197,
-0.0419427752,
0.0542359352,
-0.0070914654,
0.0219899472,
-0.0362719297,
-0.0069016963,
0.0203637388,
0.0308045335,
0.0355399288,
-0.013907576,
-0.0094991038,
0.0330128111,
-0.0748206079,
-0.0244022552,
-0.0076504378,
0.0777443051,
-0.0107182423,
0.0089555038,
-0.0101011246,
0.0392075628,
-0.0096236961,
0.0314157493,
-0.0003558942,
0.0502379611,
-0.0634302124,
-0.0360933319,
0.0036150343,
-0.0063935709,
0.0050938884,
-0.0142309517,
0.0207463037,
-0.0164172407,
-0.0212829076,
-0.0235478077,
-0.0255103987,
0.0066324873,
2.769e-7,
0.0269187894,
0.0427489802,
-0.0029613788,
0.0038509585,
0.0081421807,
0.039177496,
-0.0052062417,
0.0331661962,
0.0881468207,
-0.0201634485,
-0.0015578293,
0.0405037142,
0.0470241942,
0.0442153886,
-0.043372646,
-0.0143897012,
-0.0201481581,
0.0003915324,
-0.0351028889,
0.0623541027,
0.1116039902,
0.0995859653,
0.0496982299,
-0.0110341897,
-0.00892659,
0.0095038321,
0.0721494332,
-0.0398277566,
-0.0460866056,
0.0042781662,
0.0339028612,
0.0234574713,
-0.0093814349,
0.0247181449,
0.0237733293,
-0.0016808327,
0.0285929348,
0.0495332405,
-0.0109505514,
-0.0236989874,
0.0390027165,
0.0204298925,
-0.0244329516,
-0.0024892853,
0.0815245211,
-0.078274861,
-0.041481927,
-0.0504659191,
-0.0208375994,
-0.0434411503,
0.0514679104,
-0.0038799667,
-0.0419064723,
0.0186518002,
0.0199255757,
-0.0116132908,
-0.0194649268,
-0.0906117558,
-0.0129633257,
0.0305364542,
-0.0406279415,
-0.0466455519,
-0.0286042951,
0.0339514129,
0.0529757552,
-0.0586982518,
-0.0001084856,
2.357663076e-34,
0.0239134189,
0.0528940633,
0.0306186881,
-0.006158717,
0.0436898842,
0.0301605593,
0.0044704052,
0.0000570715,
0.0104390727,
-0.0818469897,
0.0002023012
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.03067v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.03067v2 | DeepOnto: A Python Package for Ontology Engineering with Deep Learning | 2023-07-06T15:35:02 | 2024-03-09T02:17:42 | Yuan He, Jiaoyan Chen, Hang Dong, Ian Horrocks, Carlo Allocca, Taehun Kim, Brahmananda Sapkota | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.LO | Integrating deep learning techniques, particularly language models (LMs),
with knowledge representation techniques like ontologies has raised widespread
attention, urging the need of a platform that supports both paradigms. Although
packages such as OWL API and Jena offer robust support for basic ontology
processing features, they lack the capability to transform various types of
information within ontologies into formats suitable for downstream deep
learning-based applications. Moreover, widely-used ontology APIs are primarily
Java-based while deep learning frameworks like PyTorch and Tensorflow are
mainly for Python programming. To address the needs, we present DeepOnto, a
Python package designed for ontology engineering with deep learning. The
package encompasses a core ontology processing module founded on the
widely-recognised and reliable OWL API, encapsulating its fundamental features
in a more "Pythonic" manner and extending its capabilities to incorporate other
essential components including reasoning, verbalisation, normalisation,
taxonomy, projection, and more. Building on this module, DeepOnto offers a
suite of tools, resources, and algorithms that support various ontology
engineering tasks, such as ontology alignment and completion, by harnessing
deep learning methods, primarily pre-trained LMs. In this paper, we also
demonstrate the practical utility of DeepOnto through two use-cases: the
Digital Health Coaching in Samsung Research UK and the Bio-ML track of the
Ontology Alignment Evaluation Initiative (OAEI). | [
0.0084986351,
0.078124918,
-0.0061077019,
0.0089707682,
-0.0076640998,
0.0100987935,
-0.0116601111,
0.0064544752,
0.0136366105,
-0.0200993717,
-0.0128087783,
0.0193023775,
0.0043418226,
0.0918118209,
-0.0394276418,
-0.0512918122,
0.0190336592,
0.0483675338,
0.0063256561,
0.0133869527,
-0.0309122074,
0.0615643039,
-0.0266941097,
0.0698098987,
-0.0168718044,
-0.0464812405,
-0.0089032473,
-0.0067905136,
0.0002357373,
-0.0128106214,
0.0151951835,
0.0185990408,
0.0028202953,
0.0898932889,
0.0000019128,
-0.0455546044,
-0.0188021492,
0.0124443639,
-0.01370221,
-0.0296361279,
0.0736562982,
-0.0225497521,
0.0110192616,
0.0071363878,
-0.0311698578,
-0.0134981396,
0.0796238333,
0.0430881456,
0.0232636426,
0.0157958213,
-0.010772693,
-0.0113001401,
0.0598257929,
0.0068579973,
0.0101830401,
-0.0268678106,
0.0280619469,
0.0080667092,
0.0143125337,
-0.0036601466,
0.0310811698,
0.0441921242,
-0.0117509896,
-0.0013576337,
0.0036382084,
-0.0151872803,
0.0036457286,
-0.0375162438,
-0.011520532,
0.0451879837,
0.002981561,
0.0136958119,
-0.0149817811,
0.0000220862,
-0.0075985868,
-0.0115098432,
0.0070371288,
-0.0089512253,
0.0232514795,
0.0017844106,
0.0105001917,
-0.0025744918,
0.0410791039,
0.0249255579,
-0.0140175559,
0.140193373,
0.0035095995,
0.021271769,
-0.0179416854,
-0.0065595056,
0.0373879746,
-0.0406311825,
0.0054756915,
0.041953519,
-0.0443784557,
0.0060774768,
-0.0197054204,
-0.0170894749,
0.0511072427,
-0.0227990281,
-0.0175138284,
0.0206038989,
-0.0429569036,
-0.0074660326,
0.0383400358,
-0.0078085186,
-0.0415858962,
0.0286051054,
-0.0343617089,
-0.0394473597,
-0.0934915319,
-0.0071957526,
0.0067686136,
0.0164177474,
0.0103120282,
-0.0261892714,
-0.0817033574,
0.0271375068,
-0.0635073557,
0.0205975212,
-0.015495521,
0.0516282283,
-0.006353152,
0.001479189,
-0.0409249812,
0.0318884104,
0.0402654819,
0.0281436406,
0.0033895264,
-0.0320129991,
0.059640348,
-0.0043199426,
0.024268033,
-0.02275832,
0.0024604946,
0.0899411216,
0.0446714871,
0.0077842702,
-0.0103420578,
-0.0705628991,
0.0102601778,
-0.0283574946,
0.0101317503,
-0.0785268024,
0.0215831734,
-0.0247778334,
0.0107915802,
-0.0933707654,
0.0164038222,
-0.008249321,
-0.0424345024,
0.0683071539,
-0.0650867447,
-0.0181455538,
0.0495003946,
0.0286208317,
-0.0080271801,
0.027553618,
0.0165883731,
0.0071964408,
0.0247018412,
-0.0142093375,
-0.0527624525,
-0.0146981813,
0.0004915217,
-0.0458665229,
0.0235336311,
0.0089300238,
-0.0241482332,
0.0884508491,
-0.0206996091,
0.0061843097,
0.0265757479,
0.0217195302,
0.0291663799,
0.0443996452,
0.0679306984,
0.0140970508,
0.0263254326,
0.0218058806,
-0.0197938997,
-0.052790612,
-0.0424387567,
0.0340880454,
0.0208033677,
0.0311437659,
-0.0039447132,
0.04051226,
-0.0192097202,
-0.0504140556,
-0.0276633594,
-0.0126644177,
-0.0169792343,
0.017205134,
0.0477089286,
-0.0242711827,
0.0012555363,
0.0785973147,
0.0308532342,
-0.0299043618,
0.0462193787,
-0.0413951389,
-0.0022278021,
0.0685790777,
0.0423058234,
-0.0804921761,
-0.0655207485,
-0.0224216506,
-0.0722459182,
0.0618860424,
0.0183398966,
-0.0215074308,
0.0008584386,
-0.0406269804,
-0.0363994986,
-0.0326220579,
0.0167156197,
-0.0101241935,
0.0077201193,
0.0424690433,
0.0162477382,
-0.0242108982,
-0.0142355673,
0.0490733907,
-0.0255854186,
-0.0082066469,
-0.01388276,
0.0188342948,
0.0542614348,
0.0756320059,
0.0115172323,
0.0146262804,
0.0391893946,
-0.0053327819,
-0.0377808064,
-0.0320251361,
-0.0169240572,
0.0209262613,
0.0553476363,
-0.0197248887,
-0.0054785595,
0.075602062,
-0.0524877347,
-0.0267706867,
-0.0021291133,
0.0302718282,
0.0441621169,
-0.0071262373,
-0.014673694,
0.0002847968,
0.0224469677,
0.0039091306,
-0.0007294557,
0.0287192594,
0.0012097555,
-0.0142910369,
-0.0701558739,
0.0148514304,
-0.0085737249,
-0.0094565973,
-0.0182905775,
-0.052006349,
0.0605002418,
0.0261632875,
0.0154024865,
-0.0539115444,
0.0442350768,
-0.056892965,
0.0349114314,
0.0221222937,
0.020448098,
0.0146457441,
0.0077200662,
0.0331987143,
-0.0090013584,
-0.0350259393,
0.0128487311,
-0.0240667406,
-0.009331936,
0.0424201153,
-0.0081155775,
-0.0071437391,
-0.0177882332,
-0.0215982404,
-0.0425937735,
0.025099542,
-0.0262038596,
-0.0011777682,
0.0009799106,
-0.0481492467,
-0.1042331755,
0.0153624406,
0.0368775763,
0.0045633363,
0.0101090306,
0.0184886456,
-0.0261137933,
-0.005059531,
-0.0025083618,
0.0140873035,
0.0774955675,
0.0134316459,
0.0033312577,
-0.0048698317,
-0.0317646712,
-0.0150676649,
-0.0150678754,
-0.0239831377,
-0.0094967838,
0.046451658,
-0.037268158,
-0.0297471806,
-0.0485614464,
-0.0041877348,
-0.0173699912,
0.0416891947,
-0.0592005216,
0.0471806712,
0.0063513946,
0.058026392,
-0.0104207257,
-0.0183515567,
0.0873173326,
0.0091758482,
0.0448901132,
-0.03458919,
-0.0131911151,
-0.0336353332,
0.0851500407,
-0.0128840543,
0.0430159867,
0.0522535257,
-0.0551489964,
-0.0071515003,
-0.0255698469,
-0.0094576841,
-0.057432469,
0.0159597378,
-0.0198640861,
0.0213807486,
0.0155346896,
0.0113100922,
-0.0365384929,
0.0742586255,
-0.0620020218,
0.0687768981,
-0.0276934262,
-0.0121194376,
-0.0566452704,
-0.0356314443,
-0.0162245464,
0.0363373682,
0.0728749558,
-0.0117304269,
-0.0165982936,
0.0190700777,
0.0490902551,
0.0107466411,
0.0046303407,
0.0308233667,
0.0060806563,
0.0230278,
-0.0323418453,
-0.0109384246,
-0.0026997176,
0.010399092,
0.0141087202,
-0.0967566893,
0.0129194967,
0.0281373113,
-0.0276126377,
-0.0639748499,
0.0189431403,
0.0832006112,
0.0448880717,
-0.0020484976,
0.0308283698,
-0.0254490171,
-0.0469224043,
0.0105211642,
-0.0014104028,
-0.0967949405,
-0.0196486991,
-0.0107340775,
0.0025545717,
-0.0041979733,
-0.0096537303,
0.0219962932,
-0.018301107,
0.027739061,
-0.0086953025,
-0.0528387502,
-0.016704021,
-0.0232319925,
0.0092542069,
-0.0560466908,
0.0200338606,
-0.0085290736,
0.0138060385,
-0.0385003872,
-0.0165610202,
-0.0112939812,
-0.0089862309,
0.0642586946,
-0.0530742817,
0.0609810762,
0.0285012722,
0.0775208324,
-0.0060855388,
-0.0317509957,
-0.0333006717,
0.0293171797,
-0.0345785096,
0.0010973673,
0.0744361132,
-0.0065185875,
-0.0007085611,
-0.0444122814,
0.0412591919,
-0.1022822037,
-0.019000357,
-0.0472967587,
0.0805374086,
-0.0033266833,
-0.0217529237,
-0.0502725914,
-0.0023727587,
-0.0047148704,
0.0443487018,
-0.0470191538,
-0.0059985369,
-0.0303209387,
-0.0043932111,
-0.0277945511,
-0.0175541751,
-0.0297708679,
0.0416349396,
-0.0490699857,
-0.0460566096,
-0.0453794412,
-0.0062551787,
0.0281432811,
-0.0600733906,
-0.0015782663,
0.0011273938,
0.0370773412,
-0.0114525035,
-0.0965647325,
0.036083512,
-0.0045365733,
0.0390757173,
-0.0283979941,
-0.0472512059,
0.0741199479,
0.0029127162,
-0.0228076633,
0.0231582373,
-0.0087716905,
-0.0456467308,
0.0103918789,
-0.011078327,
0.0138995862,
0.005329967,
0.0160396826,
0.0140888244,
0.0598263927,
0.0771658048,
-0.0457074307,
-0.054626178,
0.021006899,
0.0160414428,
-0.0103666335,
0.0520750359,
-0.0477557294,
-0.002639072,
-0.0182131529,
0.0215226244,
0.0146031193,
-0.0461039059,
0.03683668,
0.0089380788,
0.0124111362,
-0.0026409752,
-0.0478109457,
-0.040338207,
0.0006606844,
0.0034886254,
-0.0185300931,
-0.0182110295,
-0.0012353359,
0.0072553209,
-0.0129212532,
0.0265516099,
0.0386493392,
-0.0095878597,
-0.0049814703,
-0.0126825236,
0.0252634361,
-0.0135320481,
0.0232850686,
0.020115938,
-0.0018936361,
-0.028422216,
0.0260133091,
-0.0446603037,
0.0246193483,
-0.050381761,
0.0071728821,
-0.005082895,
0.0572386682,
-0.0471732728,
0.0157158077,
0.0081805056,
-0.0774796158,
-0.0177534334,
0.0276285596,
0.0418307707,
-0.0104332184,
0.0297434572,
-0.0728545859,
-0.018438125,
-0.0246544182,
0.0234498475,
-0.0504787788,
-0.0130771296,
-0.0164154023,
-0.0137862237,
-0.0112799918,
-0.0093416311,
0.0762464553,
0.0259601474,
0.0429175757,
0.0111324573,
-0.0443537347,
-0.0358360708,
-0.0274729859,
0.0795005411,
0.0585756116,
-0.0897017196,
-0.0190187078,
0.0224007778,
-0.0897049159,
0.0397784188,
0.0261792373,
-0.0529638045,
0.0110097909,
0.0429763347,
0.0161609016,
0.0077362549,
-0.0474897586,
-0.0161460042,
0.0066008447,
-0.0512533598,
-0.032617256,
0.0163483247,
-5.72193475e-33,
-0.0006196508,
-0.0309485346,
0.0273200367,
0.0492602289,
0.0083920145,
0.0104172388,
-0.0059914147,
0.0159576237,
-0.0207425673,
0.0531251766,
0.0375582427,
0.005676873,
-0.01030239,
0.032396365,
0.0210744292,
-0.0062733372,
-0.0063326969,
0.0088865571,
0.051340241,
0.0244687572,
0.0358085446,
0.0292437039,
0.0262446553,
-0.0458724387,
0.0552377813,
0.0341540352,
0.0086978823,
-0.00020851,
-0.0350141525,
0.0642100424,
-0.0407160893,
0.0755673423,
0.0168630127,
-0.0094666127,
0.0159105882,
0.0042559141,
-0.0805809349,
-0.0442019887,
-0.0261724405,
-0.0107014747,
-0.0749816895,
-0.0447949395,
0.0634850934,
0.028440509,
-0.0008819373,
-0.042487517,
0.0564900152,
-0.0310476199,
-0.016998725,
-0.0650914535,
-0.097864911,
0.0001147496,
-0.0231108926,
-0.0348011181,
0.0370230712,
-0.0427016132,
0.0091321645,
-0.0080268774,
-0.0549194328,
0.003621751,
-0.0295240842,
0.0098922038,
0.076234661,
0.0270454716,
-0.0247059166,
0.0113007156,
-0.0258549061,
-0.0091765765,
0.0343256965,
0.0354771838,
0.0171084851,
0.0878610238,
-0.0095292311,
-0.0133183617,
-0.0099436492,
-0.0306711551,
-0.071468778,
0.0449225269,
-0.0145193702,
0.0049295435,
-0.024155654,
0.0332961529,
0.0266949181,
0.0128455656,
-0.0323824063,
0.0358675122,
-0.0508884713,
-0.0310600623,
-0.0278064534,
-0.0495925508,
-0.0284951758,
0.0254660696,
-0.0221827906,
-0.0802775323,
0.0013966346,
-0.0253720898,
0.0128489155,
0.0093102325,
-0.0247600842,
0.044324711,
-0.0425522886,
-0.0339319445,
-0.0379547961,
-0.0234219264,
0.0144677041,
0.013908973,
0.0348497964,
0.0160489716,
-0.0173347145,
0.0263818223,
-0.0103671253,
-0.0304815508,
-0.0083615948,
0.0117874127,
0.025648538,
0.0090558464,
0.013575986,
0.02863371,
0.0284697656,
0.0112641081,
-0.0385077633,
0.0242720768,
0.0204890743,
-0.0181364547,
-0.0506816283,
-0.023517644,
-0.0818020999,
-0.0497875698,
0.0107525494,
0.0073025371,
-0.0214006174,
-0.0098578855,
2.663e-7,
0.0673427135,
0.0284310244,
0.0089152306,
0.025719041,
0.0122166239,
0.0244527515,
0.0424824543,
0.0290304814,
-0.0406629965,
-0.0339411683,
0.029729886,
-0.0111337965,
0.013683632,
0.0071512521,
-0.0583030395,
-0.0230086725,
0.0018918575,
-0.0313139856,
-0.0602014586,
0.0459615327,
0.0226314384,
0.0507151447,
0.0251565538,
-0.0203188118,
0.025429463,
0.0147903077,
0.0117245186,
-0.0101073626,
0.0494049303,
0.069187589,
-0.0102711134,
0.0262612887,
0.0117929177,
-0.0054658027,
0.0009579461,
-0.0275315512,
0.0008197465,
0.0591251031,
-0.0520525351,
-0.0292770714,
-0.0398010351,
-0.0209533498,
0.0403746441,
-0.0825669542,
0.0117587922,
-0.0343439057,
-0.0639385208,
-0.0484280773,
-0.0157861132,
0.0330110751,
0.0050935373,
-0.0100551173,
0.0202805102,
0.0292096455,
0.0273636747,
0.0237102527,
-0.038695544,
-0.069474712,
0.0080423206,
0.0509636849,
-0.0224921796,
-0.0115538286,
0.0071671978,
-0.0413928032,
0.0445656031,
-0.0861578211,
0.022751959,
1.885780269e-34,
-0.0114458939,
0.0397469178,
-0.0166833866,
0.013024631,
0.0101646837,
-0.0100080939,
0.0348975658,
0.0058400915,
0.0001167329,
-0.0256448947,
-0.0042167883
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.03056v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.03056v1 | Generalizing Backpropagation for Gradient-Based Interpretability | 2023-07-06T15:19:53 | 2023-07-06T15:19:53 | Kevin Du, Lucas Torroba Hennigen, Niklas Stoehr, Alexander Warstadt, Ryan Cotterell | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Many popular feature-attribution methods for interpreting deep neural
networks rely on computing the gradients of a model's output with respect to
its inputs. While these methods can indicate which input features may be
important for the model's prediction, they reveal little about the inner
workings of the model itself. In this paper, we observe that the gradient
computation of a model is a special case of a more general formulation using
semirings. This observation allows us to generalize the backpropagation
algorithm to efficiently compute other interpretable statistics about the
gradient graph of a neural network, such as the highest-weighted path and
entropy. We implement this generalized algorithm, evaluate it on synthetic
datasets to better understand the statistics it computes, and apply it to study
BERT's behavior on the subject-verb number agreement task (SVA). With this
method, we (a) validate that the amount of gradient flow through a component of
a model reflects its importance to a prediction and (b) for SVA, identify which
pathways of the self-attention mechanism are most important. | [
-0.0215514824,
-0.0012941324,
-0.0152062047,
0.0460735671,
-0.0101669664,
0.0051569869,
-0.0079063401,
-0.0200066902,
-0.0339874215,
0.005411007,
-0.0537488125,
-0.0135978302,
-0.0041115894,
-0.0192735065,
0.0443513133,
-0.0208761301,
0.0248862654,
-0.0095992964,
0.0071182279,
0.0033993314,
-0.0138294585,
-0.0487869196,
0.014173313,
0.056768667,
-0.0329995938,
-0.0280985422,
-0.0073615075,
0.0002215306,
0.0367798656,
0.0323976688,
-0.0217579957,
0.0160270669,
-0.0187149439,
0.042277474,
0.0000020319,
-0.0148915024,
-0.0290349331,
0.0077573685,
-0.0784608349,
0.0234725159,
-0.0533390976,
0.0310156457,
-0.0187613349,
-0.022022184,
-0.0251678824,
0.0482963435,
0.0549888313,
0.0318465792,
0.0417313538,
0.0454698168,
-0.0090049375,
-0.0336627401,
0.0408039354,
-0.0382016934,
0.0179726761,
0.0083409529,
-0.0128773432,
-0.0349385813,
-0.0828045458,
-0.0315629393,
-0.0520562902,
0.0188548099,
0.0608361289,
-0.0058360067,
0.0155900037,
-0.0111105889,
-0.0315421037,
-0.0201047864,
0.0201868061,
0.068691507,
-0.0252805799,
-0.010196954,
0.0003740257,
-0.0114080384,
0.0033411563,
-0.0037226421,
-0.0178294592,
-0.0118075274,
0.0345174484,
0.0378477015,
-0.0144307716,
0.0005555032,
0.0451425239,
-0.0284266267,
-0.0491540208,
0.0584671795,
-0.0065197833,
-0.0260357261,
-0.0373779498,
0.0065537551,
-0.0254643522,
-0.0282325484,
0.0204066075,
0.0207334161,
0.0504656136,
0.0253814887,
0.0111630699,
-0.0448632725,
0.0154144075,
-0.0339798555,
0.0405760333,
0.0299623702,
-0.0566255674,
0.0005553092,
-0.0339599885,
0.0815614462,
-0.0200215131,
0.0622233152,
-0.0378629118,
0.0059526772,
-0.0285429675,
-0.0376181304,
-0.0319100954,
0.0390352942,
0.0325128213,
-0.0078563336,
-0.0842881277,
0.0104445936,
-0.0236462615,
-0.0232552439,
0.0221416429,
-0.0136121809,
-0.0305051319,
0.0078700427,
-0.0147105679,
0.0485708043,
-0.0290176384,
0.0219570771,
-0.0126156332,
-0.014484331,
-0.0244899374,
0.0191086717,
-0.0085810386,
-0.0201820657,
-0.0203078482,
0.064052701,
0.0181247722,
-0.0429253317,
-0.0338145941,
-0.0315317027,
-0.040423017,
-0.0136562521,
0.0547780097,
-0.0275250319,
-0.0060150572,
0.0032049117,
0.0118649146,
-0.0094224326,
-0.0027626143,
-0.0120404363,
0.0095992098,
0.0283679906,
0.003347453,
-0.0255739503,
-0.0298542175,
-0.0049199057,
0.0035793933,
0.0486572124,
0.0434788913,
0.0857825056,
0.0224641934,
-0.0111079011,
-0.0010630537,
0.0163554531,
0.0570905209,
-0.019761065,
-0.0217708126,
-0.0469380394,
-0.0298715476,
-0.0182048399,
0.0433373936,
0.0162287895,
-0.0436529294,
-0.0792881548,
0.0581810623,
0.0707902834,
0.0367151089,
0.0198923554,
0.0324416831,
-0.0194726363,
0.0395902097,
0.0637960136,
-0.0639575943,
0.0315815173,
-0.0194269475,
-0.0036674628,
0.0207240973,
-0.0487033315,
-0.0186745729,
-0.0853493214,
-0.0068834382,
0.0104060397,
0.0119547136,
-0.0107897222,
0.0710281804,
0.0132821389,
-0.0047702282,
0.0451260135,
-0.016051583,
-0.0469436646,
-0.0082706362,
-0.0714328364,
0.0153729422,
0.0321861021,
-0.014590377,
-0.0407192707,
-0.0067796856,
0.0006640403,
0.0012361665,
-0.0235616229,
0.0124731893,
0.0194281749,
0.036148943,
-0.0241098981,
-0.020992998,
-0.0148796169,
0.0299654342,
0.0434112251,
-0.0733941868,
-0.0558351129,
-0.0073118531,
-0.0289944969,
-0.030560527,
0.0143089322,
0.0104349069,
-0.0609307624,
0.0331250764,
0.0274922717,
0.0520761386,
0.0304438844,
-0.0163939241,
0.0409536362,
0.0280376729,
-0.0261486191,
-0.0113793779,
0.0345265754,
-0.0024569763,
-0.0335429236,
0.0234503001,
-0.0135021405,
-0.0364703722,
0.0261639729,
-0.0217703786,
-0.0636792481,
0.0649968237,
-0.0911582485,
0.0428742096,
-0.024366023,
-0.0126227699,
0.0251471531,
0.0366663747,
-0.0220644344,
0.0229385663,
-0.0181039236,
0.010603861,
-0.0288163591,
-0.0289668068,
0.0349454321,
-0.0228213686,
-0.0248262193,
-0.0201509036,
-0.039051149,
-0.0233343542,
0.0318394154,
-0.0271184612,
-0.0127261663,
0.0221236646,
-0.062892057,
-0.0168336108,
-0.0451566838,
0.0676096156,
0.0051150466,
-0.0226271339,
0.0351205729,
-0.0290842783,
0.0176045205,
-0.0037415274,
-0.0543428697,
0.0168139543,
0.0425889008,
-0.0150601855,
-0.0282350369,
-0.063982822,
-0.0672148168,
-0.0459595434,
0.0597120225,
0.0046957177,
0.0545413494,
-0.0098102782,
-0.044133354,
0.0035650511,
0.003024678,
-0.0238631144,
-0.0650620311,
0.0413953252,
-0.0019461486,
0.0205340907,
0.0750011206,
-0.0179067347,
0.0806873962,
0.0141335186,
0.0361049362,
-0.0353891104,
-0.015530182,
-0.0381494872,
0.0012607588,
-0.0128316442,
-0.0637804493,
0.0025471395,
0.1122233942,
0.0113212429,
-0.0209966097,
-0.0525626428,
-0.0417188704,
-0.0051610596,
-0.0603063367,
-0.0299138986,
0.0137195466,
-0.0187500063,
0.0614684075,
-0.0121142296,
-0.0731592104,
0.0696841925,
0.0125819705,
-0.0067822877,
-0.0164893232,
-0.0152860777,
-0.0301635917,
0.0639492199,
0.0368098319,
-0.0011826371,
0.0243150517,
-0.0395727493,
-0.0055461377,
-0.0331656151,
0.0397715643,
-0.0146931922,
0.0277512446,
-0.0186664984,
-0.0072715478,
0.0075731562,
0.0006131795,
-0.0072948579,
-0.0184901152,
0.017162757,
0.0248769298,
0.0201150887,
-0.034450721,
0.0176066868,
-0.017886268,
0.0275440011,
0.0162266959,
-0.0166136622,
-0.0134262005,
-0.006606041,
0.0303144827,
-0.0171484463,
-0.0197477303,
0.0571194105,
-0.0341957137,
-0.0197411291,
0.0170955956,
0.032604143,
0.0674332827,
-0.0808881819,
0.01687002,
-0.0104403989,
-0.0400637388,
-0.0355530716,
-0.0058251237,
0.0371968597,
-0.0625044852,
0.0105718598,
0.0491825454,
0.0251701418,
-0.0424971171,
0.0284376014,
-0.0394377783,
-0.0459258072,
0.0079750149,
0.0009183491,
-0.0367773846,
-0.0240798686,
-0.0076282932,
0.0043391879,
-0.0051189824,
-0.0056499899,
0.0405442677,
-0.0387954898,
0.0334559269,
-0.0333960801,
-0.0340737589,
-0.0105107976,
-0.0388192683,
0.0189569946,
-0.0398243628,
-0.0257220101,
-0.0302806422,
-0.0023015458,
-0.0001535016,
0.0436767116,
-0.0240847338,
-0.0038451366,
0.0165740326,
-0.0260371082,
0.0080618309,
0.1031328142,
0.0627460778,
-0.0264525991,
-0.0229931232,
0.0085489415,
0.0201191679,
0.0086641544,
0.010410998,
0.0776028186,
0.0044739717,
-0.043133311,
-0.0157593992,
0.0124424361,
-0.0282577183,
0.0059578763,
-0.0556153767,
0.0550710671,
0.0163476113,
-0.0118264789,
-0.0206610598,
-0.0395227559,
-0.0185338371,
0.0550045297,
0.0727075711,
-0.010890441,
-0.0623129867,
-0.0340141132,
0.0150552383,
-0.0064615961,
-0.0535221584,
-0.0010777635,
0.0123273004,
-0.0763223916,
-0.0477364324,
-0.0045388169,
0.0071568782,
-0.0045628198,
-0.0142234592,
-0.0579205677,
0.0412509777,
-0.0223026667,
-0.0508210734,
0.0761726126,
0.0109519428,
-0.0030223017,
-0.0196966715,
-0.0299276877,
0.0691761076,
-0.0023878091,
-0.0275420547,
0.0203028284,
-0.0183865782,
-0.0148765109,
0.0325336382,
0.0510659516,
0.0268024318,
-0.0099545792,
0.0017954443,
-0.0348156281,
-0.0019454241,
0.0222824272,
-0.0008859142,
-0.0128847305,
0.0799706653,
0.00761363,
-0.0206936654,
0.0577284172,
-0.0187227391,
0.0390327051,
0.0339352079,
-0.0123691466,
-0.0369626805,
0.0058008539,
0.0410224386,
0.0119857332,
0.0585117489,
0.0455727838,
-0.0239579547,
0.0108329654,
0.0078709256,
0.0115364725,
0.0291071236,
-0.0654929653,
0.0175695773,
0.006989297,
-0.0291396324,
-0.0220593195,
-0.0023104905,
0.0143497605,
-0.0097889248,
-0.0408079736,
0.0313007012,
0.0026772979,
0.0443214774,
-0.0329431519,
0.0230351891,
0.0155347921,
0.0059161722,
-0.0105667599,
0.0236609746,
0.041438397,
-0.0039848224,
0.0181441177,
0.0418381579,
-0.0359557457,
0.0228527822,
-0.1007359773,
-0.0658692271,
-0.0149318166,
0.037374001,
0.03104431,
0.0132343667,
0.0564645417,
-0.0341512896,
0.0166025627,
-0.0157300457,
0.0180198587,
-0.0130147459,
0.0227563605,
0.0115989428,
0.0265202168,
0.0054068989,
-0.0423264578,
0.0532646403,
0.0043710982,
0.0081293527,
-0.0108696371,
-0.0242048819,
-0.0347373933,
-0.0246405881,
0.0554928258,
0.0303370804,
-0.0128912954,
0.0188366268,
-0.0435989015,
-0.0991072208,
0.000107104,
0.0165210143,
0.0562821701,
0.0107117314,
0.0373081081,
0.0740391016,
-0.0310195182,
-0.0217551235,
-0.0234098639,
0.0189535432,
-0.0271678586,
-0.0039380095,
-0.0222133286,
-5.956322446e-33,
-0.0411516428,
-0.0407006331,
-0.0219209883,
0.0041169678,
0.0142055852,
0.0108438274,
-0.0432310179,
0.0022288279,
-0.0009185083,
0.0602679886,
-0.0040189498,
0.0493520722,
0.0179170016,
0.0162587967,
-0.0130431093,
-0.0641119108,
0.0489106812,
-0.0199356247,
0.0187212955,
-0.0108719366,
0.0699599162,
0.0122808823,
0.123047933,
-0.0698340684,
0.0541843846,
0.0460652076,
-0.027535053,
0.0070669451,
-0.0370035097,
0.0745942816,
-0.0242125317,
0.0328491963,
0.0204532295,
-0.1090926677,
-0.0284817722,
0.0126198214,
-0.0445478335,
-0.0641807467,
0.0224198475,
0.0132776629,
-0.0831109658,
-0.0221189484,
0.1070030853,
-0.0215130672,
-0.0303099155,
-0.0048153098,
0.0322917327,
0.0114018675,
-0.0001629394,
-0.0443448573,
-0.0435126424,
0.0014004709,
-0.0386439897,
-0.0532815754,
0.0368367285,
0.0193366297,
-0.046738755,
-0.0003140284,
-0.0396142751,
0.0067426357,
0.0137185827,
-0.0057505611,
0.0432361774,
0.0003100394,
0.0212044064,
0.0491549149,
0.1051414832,
-0.0233679414,
-0.0120048067,
-0.0444596075,
0.0218537338,
0.0426124148,
0.0591541901,
-0.0144355455,
0.0759299174,
0.0301268939,
-0.0686481073,
-0.0261666942,
0.0220927279,
0.0158526301,
0.0395995453,
0.0056241532,
-0.0337822288,
0.0015766406,
-0.0120883072,
-0.057185106,
-0.0257084798,
-0.0095377415,
0.0163590331,
-0.0307528786,
-0.0134123946,
0.0511139929,
0.0303936899,
-0.0588433072,
0.0226772111,
0.0288431253,
0.0101074725,
0.0377808064,
0.0364498831,
-0.0044136532,
-0.0141128637,
0.0044777626,
-0.0294555444,
0.0049416623,
0.0651545674,
0.0162602775,
0.0294479132,
0.0042489301,
0.0114247678,
-0.0194354355,
-0.0185115691,
-0.0484428667,
-0.0260250513,
0.059509296,
0.0480924845,
-0.0074611893,
-0.0308456644,
0.0529548079,
-0.0143703017,
0.0659272373,
-0.0242936704,
0.0471980795,
-0.0417486578,
0.0437864624,
-0.0139091173,
-0.0524914861,
-0.0090126665,
0.0127502196,
0.0469009131,
-0.0389992669,
-0.014645447,
0.013961263,
2.826e-7,
0.058338251,
0.0364020281,
0.0291349571,
0.0290953685,
0.0370634831,
0.0359009095,
0.01176784,
0.0264090411,
0.0249886326,
-0.0399439968,
0.0143541591,
0.0271576345,
-0.0079468573,
-0.0035520084,
-0.0324171372,
-0.0275203884,
-0.0406272858,
-0.000156786,
0.0438371785,
0.0594632104,
0.0326840244,
0.101670973,
0.0107254647,
0.0068244911,
0.0524262376,
0.0170808677,
0.0394807868,
-0.0298187993,
0.0304607525,
0.0164718293,
0.0771841556,
-0.049199257,
-0.0080019515,
0.0353043452,
0.0154272821,
0.0186484642,
0.0039899661,
0.0489166789,
-0.02579787,
-0.0363661014,
-0.0302985925,
-0.0137929199,
0.0275251884,
-0.006317283,
0.0350517295,
-0.0531525016,
-0.08502689,
-0.0038010471,
0.0200374555,
0.0072549768,
0.0763784796,
0.0295353085,
0.0245166384,
0.0111857317,
0.0052533075,
-0.0254123267,
-0.0070989304,
-0.056984745,
-0.0192618594,
-0.0211432427,
-0.0752938241,
-0.0235570949,
-0.0628559589,
-0.0131539339,
0.0390332304,
-0.0837612525,
-0.0516666248,
2.493660885e-34,
0.0391325168,
-0.0113736214,
0.0422887504,
0.0566665269,
-0.0098210219,
-0.0162757952,
-0.013592246,
-0.0177588947,
0.0334045924,
-0.0311160441,
-0.042443864
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.03042v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.03042v3 | Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning of LLaMA for the Clinical Domain | 2023-07-06T15:06:41 | 2024-06-09T17:00:36 | Aryo Pradipta Gema, Pasquale Minervini, Luke Daines, Tom Hope, Beatrice Alex | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Adapting pretrained language models to novel domains, such as clinical
applications, traditionally involves retraining their entire set of parameters.
Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning (PEFT) techniques for fine-tuning language
models significantly reduce computational requirements by selectively
fine-tuning small subsets of parameters. In this study, we propose a two-step
PEFT framework and evaluate it in the clinical domain. Our approach combines a
specialised PEFT adapter layer designed for clinical domain adaptation with
another adapter specialised for downstream tasks. We evaluate the framework on
multiple clinical outcome prediction datasets, comparing it to clinically
trained language models. Our framework achieves a better AUROC score averaged
across all clinical downstream tasks compared to clinical language models. In
particular, we observe large improvements of 4-5% AUROC in large-scale
multilabel classification tasks, such as diagnoses and procedures
classification. To our knowledge, this study is the first to provide an
extensive empirical analysis of the interplay between PEFT techniques and
domain adaptation in an important real-world domain of clinical applications. | [
0.0534044541,
0.0481016226,
-0.0025296635,
-0.011188129,
0.0408576243,
0.0400389917,
0.0069017163,
0.0264313463,
-0.0419754758,
-0.014861349,
-0.0842726827,
-0.0556880012,
0.0066731609,
0.0120044993,
0.0252228267,
-0.027342312,
0.0457035713,
0.0009960546,
0.046660807,
-0.0198474173,
-0.0341835916,
-0.0008583061,
-0.0132899042,
0.0412370823,
0.0373319127,
0.0260318536,
0.0544363484,
-0.0189985465,
0.0186893512,
-0.0638046712,
0.0251096524,
0.0293622203,
-0.0269491058,
-0.0159317013,
0.0000019964,
-0.0835879371,
-0.0179311056,
0.0020642502,
-0.0227539521,
0.0129496111,
0.0495827831,
-0.0080927443,
0.010433834,
0.0476027466,
-0.0311192721,
-0.0421002358,
0.0382760614,
0.0543515906,
0.0338216275,
0.0860337913,
-0.0154031636,
-0.0176395141,
0.034464974,
-0.0517148077,
-0.0179639105,
-0.072190091,
0.0386048257,
-0.0273264237,
0.0168605912,
-0.0262433048,
-0.0230063666,
0.0267326199,
-0.0080055846,
0.0141955335,
0.0053427708,
0.0335999206,
-0.0325002186,
-0.0260797106,
0.0073456173,
0.0475810133,
-0.04045384,
-0.014168092,
-0.0077426541,
-0.0121245291,
0.009194511,
-0.0125449635,
-0.0311680809,
-0.0321565345,
0.0069171269,
0.0101871891,
0.0383143388,
-0.0132289911,
0.0455358028,
0.0169926006,
-0.0286248401,
0.03654835,
0.0105997045,
0.0194169562,
0.038670212,
0.0117958263,
-0.0281692259,
-0.0249416474,
0.0179826096,
0.0395921357,
-0.0441758111,
-0.0021668102,
-0.0427637324,
-0.0125053953,
0.0634048507,
-0.0552500673,
0.0806388706,
0.0249107908,
-0.027710462,
0.0124536315,
-0.0829084441,
-0.0083228806,
-0.0250371601,
0.0703105778,
-0.0347289145,
0.0054222471,
0.0091822483,
0.0190939829,
-0.0355503038,
-0.0004949616,
-0.0043506282,
0.0106773553,
-0.0877690613,
0.0074377465,
0.0079165017,
-0.0186333191,
0.035108678,
0.0153057221,
-0.0394576229,
-0.0165420268,
-0.0008428191,
0.0197769683,
-0.0033709188,
0.0777105093,
-0.0292963795,
-0.0386072919,
0.0035204433,
0.0186034385,
0.0016270779,
-0.0167230517,
0.0511746593,
0.0764342174,
0.0263529662,
-0.0508843623,
-0.0315398574,
-0.0037981565,
-0.0404096991,
-0.0212008618,
0.0176481344,
-0.0449197926,
0.0117474496,
0.0073415735,
0.0570317209,
-0.0671026409,
-0.0044362806,
-0.0531509779,
-0.0310326144,
0.0629196614,
-0.0466999784,
-0.0113643613,
0.0515095592,
0.0129550789,
0.0180778112,
0.0496939756,
0.0557147935,
-0.0211356897,
-0.0139313377,
-0.0370603055,
-0.0209625009,
0.0343359746,
0.0063135438,
-0.0203955062,
-0.0108392974,
0.0081799207,
0.0300763324,
0.0793603435,
-0.0025707793,
0.0101471096,
0.0214054231,
-0.0393674523,
0.0288725737,
0.0095507726,
0.0762536302,
0.0059492062,
0.0062869377,
-0.0855203867,
0.0202536192,
-0.0400969572,
-0.0261505507,
0.0119293351,
-0.0201154482,
-0.0175698679,
-0.003318633,
0.0187258106,
-0.0356062725,
-0.073456116,
-0.0161322393,
-0.0124409618,
-0.0680232942,
-0.0053219004,
0.0363880917,
0.0090561742,
-0.0427093022,
0.0350529887,
0.0559576154,
0.0050210352,
-0.0180105809,
-0.1061596051,
-0.0304190964,
0.0208155699,
0.0407802574,
-0.058941368,
-0.0539120957,
-0.0137976585,
0.0262329336,
-0.0174473338,
0.0232644957,
0.0235638805,
0.026861975,
-0.034692429,
-0.007230097,
0.0104547692,
0.0253669396,
-0.0265669655,
-0.0132727819,
0.0397506431,
-0.0304073319,
-0.0628173947,
-0.0327696875,
0.068634741,
-0.0473095067,
-0.0415775664,
0.0535010286,
0.0000029791,
0.0176969059,
-0.0350901932,
-0.0169719011,
0.0046214922,
0.0083748102,
-0.0459373556,
0.0020492119,
-0.0397944413,
-0.0262155011,
-0.0200683642,
0.0171777681,
0.010930757,
0.0407762416,
0.0146257719,
-0.0460623913,
-0.02221331,
-0.0289955717,
-0.0141054085,
0.0222949143,
0.0147861736,
0.0556983426,
-0.0047392105,
0.0727909282,
-0.0182316601,
-0.0166879501,
0.0095950654,
-0.0391446799,
-0.0301393792,
-0.0022454534,
0.003948574,
0.0162608214,
-0.0352972113,
-0.0042634672,
-0.0128485924,
0.008785286,
-0.0429285988,
0.0164571758,
-0.0016305117,
-0.0622230023,
-0.0625253469,
0.0257935468,
0.0052959844,
0.0010502995,
0.0263364427,
0.0298789926,
-0.0217344444,
-0.027194785,
-0.0140575115,
0.0155336028,
0.0105374781,
0.0256302543,
0.0377807505,
0.0249508787,
-0.040718127,
-0.0489621647,
-0.0002107226,
-0.0026874116,
0.0122306608,
0.0047370503,
-0.0259565543,
-0.0354385935,
0.0221637692,
-0.0278714821,
-0.0247217268,
0.0186762046,
-0.0336921625,
-0.0148672545,
0.0121289454,
-0.0371956415,
0.0740543827,
-0.0289423913,
0.0299297664,
0.0534912907,
0.0495672338,
0.0101738637,
0.0018712602,
-0.0211780053,
-0.0740537643,
-0.0208194461,
-0.0023158982,
0.0086851744,
0.0957903862,
-0.0213075317,
-0.0090320371,
-0.0428591147,
-0.0296458248,
-0.0217707362,
0.0115878219,
-0.0112860138,
0.0117419716,
-0.0318384878,
0.0409695543,
0.0219784863,
-0.0726991966,
0.0628046766,
-0.0134757906,
0.0421142317,
-0.0452810153,
-0.0473455116,
-0.0359403752,
-0.0158538371,
-0.0033328086,
0.0134724043,
0.0169906691,
-0.0145112332,
-0.0112455208,
-0.0088571869,
-0.0226376336,
-0.0636781827,
0.0787490383,
-0.0141212931,
0.0085808504,
-0.0014113747,
-0.0388080515,
-0.0157150384,
-0.0075599179,
-0.0275701415,
0.0114963129,
-0.0372694246,
0.0044323588,
-0.063026458,
0.0216191225,
-0.0488104932,
0.0706682727,
-0.015139739,
-0.0252083372,
-0.0004223765,
-0.0037162865,
0.0183470696,
0.0236021001,
0.0216901377,
-0.0208645444,
0.0284878854,
0.0078008277,
-0.0119704166,
0.019811023,
0.0027378015,
0.012048048,
0.0266923979,
-0.0364302397,
-0.0084313648,
0.0297952145,
0.0454021581,
-0.0438610651,
0.0110162934,
0.0973091349,
0.0206698794,
-0.0599706583,
0.0206297319,
-0.0204623602,
0.0189021267,
-0.0051846788,
0.0255647637,
-0.0372733362,
-0.0464789011,
0.0117909694,
0.0459161364,
-0.0180406068,
-0.0107223745,
0.0239135902,
-0.0056181801,
0.012726089,
0.0030880678,
-0.046035897,
-0.0088752965,
-0.0533068255,
0.0241207462,
-0.0141572133,
0.0034013977,
-0.0216380749,
-0.0044243117,
-0.0264513679,
0.0267321542,
-0.0653209537,
-0.0836538523,
0.0198678337,
-0.0026869185,
0.057298135,
0.0384078473,
0.011205893,
-0.0380290858,
-0.0068375431,
0.0242393538,
-0.0034624913,
0.0088052498,
-0.0247187205,
0.0371684283,
0.0253130812,
-0.0169006716,
0.0166533105,
0.0134991882,
-0.0475357547,
0.0085306177,
-0.0207375288,
0.0614835061,
-0.0297457483,
-0.0405630842,
-0.0181814004,
-0.0033825405,
-0.0217916146,
0.0227632988,
0.0086553665,
-0.0297915414,
-0.003063513,
0.0087444596,
0.0137530463,
-0.0098020379,
-0.0120874476,
0.0164842848,
-0.0559267774,
-0.02534068,
-0.0238711983,
0.0073641231,
0.0350566655,
-0.020849457,
0.0320685543,
0.0312926657,
-0.0132326307,
-0.0160858333,
-0.0568083711,
0.0416538864,
0.0046133273,
0.0312597565,
-0.0749136209,
-0.0179423559,
0.1041159034,
-0.0015488195,
-0.01477654,
0.0083562005,
-0.0052323979,
-0.0298355278,
0.0331022665,
0.060020119,
0.0116019025,
-0.0204711724,
0.0025571168,
-0.0806769878,
0.0575809218,
0.0499014258,
-0.0036667362,
0.04254077,
0.0180114079,
-0.0361242965,
-0.0148240216,
0.0270295776,
-0.0293106847,
0.0385279357,
0.031254258,
0.0149045167,
0.0310893506,
-0.0794934854,
-0.0089396453,
0.0188044216,
0.062977314,
-0.0520239025,
-0.0674703345,
-0.0339086801,
0.0562416464,
0.0205455888,
0.0418897718,
-0.0019754751,
-0.0198012032,
0.0555617288,
0.0064345803,
-0.036927145,
0.0008350837,
-0.0549240671,
-0.019829087,
-0.028598763,
0.0763556287,
0.0029875573,
0.0041469974,
0.0512876473,
0.0000743956,
0.0102191661,
0.0112589058,
0.0513191074,
0.0315940045,
-0.014748157,
0.0317225717,
-0.0150042241,
0.0791967064,
-0.0313360877,
0.0736867115,
-0.0095255999,
-0.0195638482,
-0.0364072435,
0.0285794884,
0.0085742809,
-0.0026657099,
0.0219748989,
0.0091168405,
0.0117814355,
-0.025673734,
0.021788951,
-0.0458652899,
0.0388845392,
0.065179348,
-0.0121241035,
-0.0115495967,
-0.0094057228,
0.06017562,
0.0210346933,
0.0802582726,
-0.0190902222,
0.0110898698,
-0.0251463875,
-0.0227702744,
0.0529040582,
-0.0260095466,
-0.0633399189,
-0.0237603597,
-0.0211319923,
-0.0455683395,
0.0339701809,
-0.0467463508,
-0.0241291374,
-0.0189204589,
0.0038148775,
0.0234772768,
0.018892955,
-0.0078397412,
-0.0127317719,
-0.0357901454,
0.0176791009,
-0.0056863986,
0.0482560173,
-6.048005495e-33,
-0.0272886176,
-0.0007793973,
0.0106772007,
-0.0155113079,
-0.0063580358,
0.0200599711,
0.002137538,
0.0112936208,
-0.0135189565,
0.0258289799,
-0.0468141362,
0.0057649179,
0.0148373302,
0.0104261488,
-0.00843162,
-0.0288895592,
0.0328917913,
0.0001036192,
-0.0338203274,
0.0234036464,
-0.0370269343,
0.0329079442,
0.0371687934,
-0.063592121,
-0.0060001682,
0.0229630377,
0.0097682765,
-0.0001105515,
-0.0179699883,
0.0746072307,
-0.0275638681,
0.0625333115,
0.0309563428,
0.0120993918,
-0.0092680948,
0.0043985862,
-0.0700255781,
-0.024907507,
0.0165715292,
-0.0009375698,
-0.0114810644,
-0.037372835,
0.0789848343,
0.0230440963,
-0.0440058336,
-0.0031602259,
0.0135623626,
-0.0588307343,
-0.0310028363,
-0.0361553021,
-0.0409682803,
0.0497016609,
0.0089674676,
-0.0131916692,
-0.0021901152,
-0.0338555872,
-0.0197134614,
0.0275410004,
-0.038110055,
-0.0262206253,
0.0282971356,
0.0538685285,
0.0130040422,
0.015056435,
-0.0486064069,
0.0293927826,
-0.0078509124,
-0.0129510118,
0.0116917025,
0.0109441755,
-0.0115599111,
0.0315121748,
0.0362722538,
0.0127055598,
-0.0000536585,
-0.0720957145,
-0.1048538238,
0.0350494608,
-0.0690035671,
0.0371763147,
0.0162619352,
-0.0159997214,
-0.0277115591,
0.01037776,
-0.0376831479,
0.0429738387,
-0.0252975263,
-0.006608115,
0.0288487747,
-0.0071657361,
-0.0090913475,
0.0148484996,
0.0032768208,
-0.0321288705,
0.0043813274,
-0.0426380299,
0.0185376797,
0.0232830197,
-0.0048095044,
0.0185331739,
-0.0130403126,
-0.0348660573,
0.031628035,
-0.0265562981,
0.0619588532,
-0.0407345444,
0.0412515365,
-0.0064096949,
-0.1008967683,
0.001747319,
0.0294189434,
-0.0161671434,
0.0471734442,
0.0814801008,
0.0107265944,
0.0198139083,
0.0015186914,
0.0613705628,
-0.0068352926,
-0.026680287,
-0.0298416577,
-0.0124146985,
0.014054643,
0.0178120509,
-0.0750602484,
-0.0041676271,
-0.0060139056,
0.0566619039,
0.0306140892,
-0.0804914162,
-0.0443970338,
-0.0088784313,
2.821e-7,
0.1194110885,
0.0519284122,
-0.038376525,
-0.0403438956,
0.0081913583,
0.0101719145,
0.005407427,
0.0300637148,
0.0042493562,
0.0158271119,
0.0293564275,
0.0182759482,
0.0424294397,
0.024568703,
-0.0333564579,
0.0054424456,
-0.0571872853,
0.0500227995,
-0.0303033236,
-0.0467308648,
0.0391885489,
0.1108766124,
-0.0214289408,
-0.0628238171,
0.0033676215,
-0.035456311,
0.0398653038,
-0.0333943851,
0.0052015255,
0.0861160532,
0.0281203296,
0.035859745,
0.0027539192,
0.0223053694,
-0.02777417,
0.0320522934,
-0.0348140784,
0.0984453335,
-0.0577259734,
0.0118033225,
0.0515389889,
0.0313266553,
0.0315369405,
-0.0498807989,
0.0677506253,
-0.0579127409,
-0.0415890478,
-0.0336125121,
0.0387489833,
-0.007454108,
0.1287164092,
-0.0595499463,
-0.0014597782,
0.0371876769,
0.0429872647,
0.0118677933,
-0.0894590765,
-0.0630292371,
-0.0142929135,
0.0286221467,
0.002513194,
-0.0201383103,
0.0028383771,
-0.0338085666,
0.010797265,
-0.0690251067,
0.0447664224,
2.305154753e-34,
0.0274734106,
-0.0343519039,
0.0144999046,
0.0276713595,
0.0071625421,
-0.0222955029,
0.0224543568,
0.0499695987,
0.0039520091,
-0.0810703933,
0.0206314847
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.03027v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.03027v1 | Improving Retrieval-Augmented Large Language Models via Data Importance Learning | 2023-07-06T14:44:07 | 2023-07-06T14:44:07 | Xiaozhong Lyu, Stefan Grafberger, Samantha Biegel, Shaopeng Wei, Meng Cao, Sebastian Schelter, Ce Zhang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.IR | Retrieval augmentation enables large language models to take advantage of
external knowledge, for example on tasks like question answering and data
imputation. However, the performance of such retrieval-augmented models is
limited by the data quality of their underlying retrieval corpus. In this
paper, we propose an algorithm based on multilinear extension for evaluating
the data importance of retrieved data points. There are exponentially many
terms in the multilinear extension, and one key contribution of this paper is a
polynomial time algorithm that computes exactly, given a retrieval-augmented
model with an additive utility function and a validation set, the data
importance of data points in the retrieval corpus using the multilinear
extension of the model's utility function. We further proposed an even more
efficient ({\epsilon}, {\delta})-approximation algorithm. Our experimental
results illustrate that we can enhance the performance of large language models
by only pruning or reweighting the retrieval corpus, without requiring further
training. For some tasks, this even allows a small model (e.g., GPT-JT),
augmented with a search engine API, to outperform GPT-3.5 (without retrieval
augmentation). Moreover, we show that weights based on multilinear extension
can be computed efficiently in practice (e.g., in less than ten minutes for a
corpus with 100 million elements). | [
0.0301762018,
0.0943748429,
0.008198861,
0.0210951958,
-0.0222844929,
0.0230287556,
-0.0379873738,
0.0043334314,
0.0435324758,
-0.06665124,
0.0127857989,
-0.0355211794,
-0.0363168791,
0.0031284404,
0.0251005962,
-0.04093723,
0.0435892828,
0.0005257314,
0.0334511362,
-0.035853941,
0.0059064738,
-0.0092022987,
0.0207191054,
0.015969906,
0.0157437157,
0.0193353072,
0.0172793269,
-0.0098137148,
0.0263117757,
-0.007071523,
0.0345599018,
0.049267929,
0.0305859726,
0.0072785942,
0.0000019136,
-0.0499605872,
-0.0585701764,
0.0074828039,
-0.0105238669,
0.000768507,
0.0306124557,
0.0154228173,
0.0332688279,
0.0076183374,
-0.0265790783,
0.0089538982,
0.0514260866,
0.037656635,
0.058382865,
0.0598892644,
0.00355114,
-0.0005131212,
0.0239889435,
-0.0303702466,
0.061254926,
-0.060820926,
0.0413225181,
0.0328738578,
0.0145548498,
0.0214081984,
0.0277356952,
0.0334275514,
-0.0145731363,
0.009718297,
0.0105022006,
0.0017352533,
-0.0699103698,
0.0589960478,
0.0098505262,
0.0614579357,
0.003658497,
-0.028951494,
-0.0151122911,
0.0145028774,
0.0223911125,
0.035394378,
-0.0683678314,
-0.0469082296,
0.0093711801,
0.0036548893,
-0.0011686587,
-0.0347112715,
0.0246545766,
0.0685467869,
-0.032522019,
0.0731353909,
0.0205804501,
-0.047687605,
-0.0110374466,
0.0197054669,
-0.109056361,
0.0135762887,
0.008359774,
0.0176794771,
-0.0064988108,
0.0089750942,
0.0215232261,
-0.058227092,
-0.0020188116,
-0.0399054103,
0.0093705859,
0.0266042128,
-0.007119535,
0.0626528785,
-0.0297766943,
0.054907538,
0.0057010385,
-0.0188132133,
-0.0218852181,
-0.0232301466,
-0.0480277613,
-0.0281439237,
-0.0238518175,
0.0684037507,
-0.013277065,
0.0044693109,
-0.0185442157,
0.0161046628,
-0.033170823,
-0.0500689559,
-0.0054900502,
0.0337291844,
-0.0415231399,
-0.0146158319,
-0.0381053537,
0.0438946113,
-0.011778052,
0.0342217572,
-0.0239832159,
-0.0494767614,
-0.0185468849,
-0.0226009656,
0.0378869101,
-0.0343174227,
0.0469889715,
0.0183606669,
-0.0068603666,
-0.0852860138,
-0.0118354522,
-0.0139812035,
-0.0062826197,
-0.036052987,
-0.0477269255,
-0.0723909363,
0.0058851345,
-0.0100215804,
-0.0088251308,
-0.0221617967,
-0.0097329188,
0.0307526756,
-0.0382342711,
0.0671532005,
0.0303574484,
0.0199008379,
0.0286624506,
-0.0194377434,
-0.0199399162,
0.0412958413,
-0.0058966922,
0.0273436196,
0.0543051548,
-0.005577174,
-0.0039746007,
0.0061584478,
0.0202719644,
0.0444529466,
-0.0206302647,
0.0083166081,
-0.0222067982,
-0.0072486624,
0.0216727685,
0.0153693305,
-0.0590852574,
0.0168683808,
0.0541822501,
0.0229620356,
0.0373815075,
-0.0081032272,
-0.0027157071,
0.0414456539,
0.0023493501,
-0.0112864627,
-0.0380342789,
0.0230929591,
-0.0290543064,
0.0013369124,
0.0429448187,
0.0036870528,
-0.0237704497,
-0.0360179469,
0.0300808344,
0.0063132839,
0.0071113151,
0.0683207884,
0.0619881824,
-0.0177525543,
-0.0374733768,
0.032943733,
0.0309107788,
-0.0440442041,
0.0012177945,
-0.032035064,
0.0039197127,
0.0604730994,
0.0452829488,
-0.0937411487,
0.0036674631,
0.0219449755,
-0.0020715401,
-0.032074932,
0.0180172194,
-0.010200765,
0.0008039072,
-0.0377089456,
-0.0327491611,
0.0090305507,
0.034687683,
0.0221795887,
0.0351898558,
0.0043299105,
0.0170394965,
-0.0696736053,
-0.02851546,
-0.0098186359,
0.0018571035,
-0.0415311493,
0.0381328426,
0.003555631,
-0.0057091736,
0.0243427753,
-0.0093609886,
0.022049984,
0.0259419251,
-0.0147323105,
-0.0393332615,
-0.0560677834,
0.0078226412,
0.0007349764,
0.0424312428,
-0.0007230738,
0.0130279232,
0.083300136,
-0.0437553525,
-0.0435019955,
0.0238682665,
-0.046461124,
0.028645521,
-0.0649815872,
-0.0047664572,
0.0074542458,
0.0205415897,
-0.0816132799,
0.0777420476,
-0.0258314908,
0.0716151223,
0.0195409749,
-0.0025608484,
-0.0022733926,
-0.0729195252,
-0.0552319288,
0.0161091387,
-0.0131231807,
0.0487471335,
0.0680249184,
-0.0143568087,
-0.0191718228,
-0.0028826809,
-0.1033639312,
0.0002892985,
-0.0317063592,
0.0464106426,
0.0066602966,
0.0559377111,
0.0010414853,
-0.0359154455,
-0.0144720543,
-0.0297719892,
0.0045263707,
0.0447781496,
0.005361313,
0.0176503975,
0.0212905649,
-0.0234241225,
-0.0446852222,
0.0146626299,
0.0318829566,
-0.0231859386,
-0.0210338421,
-0.0155438688,
-0.0128024891,
-0.0653726608,
0.0289807804,
-0.0183634367,
-0.0084820464,
-0.021699829,
-0.0316491462,
-0.0089443754,
0.0342461206,
0.014939676,
-0.0152878407,
0.0310315657,
0.0309593622,
-0.0907634795,
0.0226952154,
-0.0662184879,
0.0060392432,
-0.0026908214,
-0.0177127533,
0.0062970561,
0.0053620432,
-0.0217436589,
-0.0492555872,
-0.0504954346,
0.0061089555,
0.0197953545,
-0.0383203588,
-0.0605345927,
0.0160859413,
-0.0251813177,
0.0077620842,
-0.0353444628,
-0.0615646876,
0.0431704894,
-0.0058580851,
0.0100400653,
-0.0328444764,
-0.0191832688,
-0.0466164164,
0.0459371731,
0.006020322,
0.0210947711,
-0.0505602546,
-0.040869955,
-0.0282896459,
-0.00437456,
0.0292566214,
-0.0862368867,
0.0638032332,
-0.0432245582,
0.0503217764,
0.0436071791,
-0.0496275648,
-0.0032479707,
-0.0370078422,
-0.0084675364,
0.0017991342,
-0.0235922672,
-0.0034247802,
-0.0273696743,
-0.0147183333,
0.066492781,
0.0388945378,
-0.0095468275,
-0.0153292455,
-0.0093252929,
0.0170943812,
0.0631715879,
0.0519250259,
0.0063516307,
0.0162771065,
-0.0235237889,
0.037630897,
0.0503001846,
-0.0296755042,
-0.0004293558,
0.0161945857,
0.0543006659,
-0.0660951138,
-0.0195753984,
0.0017399525,
0.0023766384,
-0.0275779683,
0.0051996582,
0.0722566992,
0.0144103505,
-0.0665075034,
-0.0173211135,
-0.022772843,
0.0190410297,
0.0371768512,
0.0597797148,
-0.0551309027,
-0.0293854214,
0.0190403592,
0.0564072765,
-0.0249813255,
-0.0447090641,
-0.0112484852,
-0.1281398982,
0.0213990752,
-0.0334127322,
0.0012816912,
-0.0351733826,
-0.084535189,
0.0253144503,
-0.0387689471,
-0.0214853399,
0.0086952513,
-0.011393562,
0.0057744468,
0.0255337059,
0.0277778506,
-0.0486060902,
0.0116999438,
0.0061866068,
-0.0220081396,
0.0684627518,
0.0164594837,
-0.0220154431,
-0.0178339034,
0.0415200479,
-0.0015959728,
-0.0218040869,
0.0056295539,
0.0602315813,
-0.0198650658,
-0.0063219015,
-0.0145014254,
0.0260127727,
0.0013981926,
0.0105996365,
-0.0145410746,
0.0725515261,
-0.0112913772,
0.0225327611,
-0.0037952843,
-0.0678569227,
0.0272655599,
0.049559474,
-0.0100339158,
-0.010553644,
-0.0087366803,
-0.0256913062,
0.0017276786,
0.0040519945,
-0.0215307344,
0.0027341547,
-0.0246410575,
-0.0119372718,
-0.0655081347,
0.0051023145,
0.0112826042,
0.0292505845,
-0.0397840254,
0.0482032523,
-0.0329111926,
0.0079061864,
-0.0481410585,
0.0583216697,
-0.0402615741,
0.0034026452,
-0.0452314578,
0.0184651837,
0.0424474813,
-0.0372066982,
-0.0544083044,
-0.017800631,
-0.0330286212,
-0.0489470139,
-0.02251851,
0.0390717387,
0.0231825467,
0.0456387624,
-0.017736787,
-0.0775568485,
0.028502129,
0.0594551824,
-0.049781695,
-0.00043308,
0.0271494929,
-0.0485486984,
-0.0329618379,
0.0401612483,
-0.0875477046,
0.0218552202,
-0.0151642822,
0.0775320381,
-0.0019292643,
-0.0255817696,
0.0423240364,
0.0716737509,
0.0495904349,
0.0276611652,
-0.0182623304,
-0.0615152121,
0.0096922303,
0.0112586133,
-0.0395685248,
-0.051630456,
0.0401213467,
0.0253936574,
-0.0108893979,
-0.0106094284,
-0.0120302243,
0.0135248648,
-0.0019842109,
-0.0500277169,
-0.0258329827,
-0.0033369623,
-0.0166981686,
0.0398627706,
-0.024626296,
-0.0216529388,
-0.0048400662,
0.0302916002,
0.01982099,
-0.021529777,
-0.0002037929,
0.0076233866,
0.004828854,
-0.0276383962,
0.0013109951,
-0.0955292657,
-0.0543756671,
-0.0396857634,
-0.0219664406,
0.0208618529,
-0.015668124,
0.0714796111,
-0.0117652379,
-0.0565880276,
-0.0525387004,
-0.0100285336,
0.0480478294,
-0.0095449705,
0.0144681158,
0.042356424,
0.0139522012,
0.0602283701,
0.0941172019,
-0.0112011284,
0.0566467494,
-0.0465976149,
-0.0513990298,
-0.0175180025,
-0.0511654578,
0.0138219893,
0.0762692839,
-0.0229427479,
0.0398070589,
-0.0263893921,
-0.0548166037,
-0.0085432604,
-0.0283731651,
-0.0269040335,
-0.046285715,
0.0656643063,
0.0642483756,
0.0061922665,
0.0233878084,
-0.0769711956,
0.0051080165,
-0.0279073808,
-0.018176863,
0.0015922532,
-6.192133959e-33,
0.0239096545,
-0.0288795754,
-0.0216236636,
-0.0221831985,
-0.001344171,
0.0433168299,
-0.0048102499,
0.0067565995,
-0.0310083851,
-0.0139913848,
0.0040795589,
0.0180706345,
-0.0005490464,
0.0225412417,
-0.0225454941,
0.0118954116,
0.0171223804,
0.0401210859,
-0.0265474953,
0.0030961232,
0.0588779002,
0.0358319096,
0.0767917633,
-0.0248180982,
0.0351967514,
-0.0073167514,
-0.0062060175,
0.0325077772,
0.0147891166,
0.0663128793,
-0.0010925677,
0.0568027422,
0.0326706842,
-0.0797534361,
-0.0055532735,
-0.0040318239,
-0.069329761,
-0.0423006676,
0.01027318,
-0.0433054231,
-0.0174768269,
-0.0134064704,
0.0326584168,
0.00059988,
0.0055406499,
-0.0217889622,
0.0473231822,
-0.0257346965,
-0.045036573,
0.00073505,
-0.0041098502,
0.0512006097,
-0.0156548172,
0.0079233069,
0.0374444649,
0.0664206967,
-0.003887682,
0.0537868589,
-0.0007014958,
0.0262493696,
-0.0187421031,
0.0444796197,
0.035057772,
0.0052201049,
0.0026314445,
0.0552437939,
-0.0051830313,
-0.024810981,
0.0040977872,
-0.0726417005,
0.0135060232,
0.0142622925,
0.0088695632,
0.07406158,
0.056813769,
0.0038952834,
-0.0497162454,
0.0647715181,
0.0163307674,
0.0396595858,
0.0240609832,
0.0200145524,
-0.017604379,
-0.0227493905,
-0.0551134534,
0.0175198913,
-0.0526907779,
-0.0201489199,
0.0187181309,
0.037473958,
-0.0335261822,
-0.0066173975,
0.0347086079,
-0.0502596013,
-0.0202299226,
0.0536363721,
-0.0293414425,
0.0174428616,
0.0173849631,
0.0211723205,
-0.0198907498,
-0.0023946436,
-0.0170394965,
-0.0473887771,
-0.0007302783,
-0.0304639526,
0.0315921791,
0.0096820854,
-0.0399537794,
-0.0075551234,
-0.0137548214,
-0.0063315555,
-0.0166136026,
0.0456773601,
0.03412937,
0.0147661716,
0.0127534335,
0.065736942,
0.0322391912,
0.0543829612,
-0.0148301078,
-0.0638884455,
0.0125597836,
-0.009039592,
-0.0301662162,
0.016366642,
-0.0394139402,
0.0385424607,
-0.0098698605,
-0.0163300633,
-0.038814649,
0.0134745454,
2.773e-7,
0.0728235841,
0.0105601437,
0.0177894514,
0.033224307,
-0.0055167638,
0.0217808951,
0.0160460193,
0.0304521825,
0.0315311626,
0.0119031407,
0.0297386739,
0.0138192661,
0.0372796282,
-0.0146340374,
-0.0876447558,
-0.0100959959,
-0.0296415724,
-0.0242174305,
-0.0203992706,
-0.0062850616,
0.0206575468,
0.0884093791,
0.0085957404,
-0.0010728234,
-0.0152185569,
-0.0410955362,
0.0882554129,
-0.0309195798,
-0.0249667391,
0.0210985988,
0.0739464238,
0.0451742597,
0.0091467071,
-0.0136876944,
-0.0120544573,
0.0145693505,
0.0814034715,
0.0488208793,
0.0031501369,
-0.0064891526,
-0.0067131957,
-0.0118126636,
0.0463585407,
-0.0382774733,
0.0967788473,
-0.0159577224,
-0.0287559927,
-0.0160510018,
-0.0557005592,
-0.0158160999,
0.0361383408,
-0.0326823741,
-0.0163709,
-0.0016063468,
-0.0006453781,
0.0048860237,
-0.0174311697,
-0.0704231262,
-0.0026519336,
0.0481739007,
-0.0285672676,
-0.0447171368,
-0.0151813971,
-0.0246044658,
-0.0009971049,
-0.0856777281,
0.0265434235,
2.532208605e-34,
0.0358266234,
0.0358808599,
0.0081521189,
-0.0001088521,
0.0319843665,
-0.0088471947,
-0.0005290234,
0.0135926045,
0.0346751474,
-0.0993000865,
-0.0106835151
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.03025v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.03025v3 | Style Over Substance: Evaluation Biases for Large Language Models | 2023-07-06T14:42:01 | 2023-11-12T06:25:32 | Minghao Wu, Alham Fikri Aji | cs.CL | cs.CL | As large language models (LLMs) continue to advance, accurately and
comprehensively evaluating their performance becomes increasingly challenging.
Ranking the relative performance of LLMs based on Elo ratings, according to
human judgment, is gaining more popularity. However, the extent to which humans
and LLMs are capable evaluators remains uncertain. This study investigates the
behavior of crowd-sourced and expert annotators, as well as LLMs, when
comparing outputs from different models. To achieve this, we curate a dataset
of intentionally flawed machine-generated answers. Our findings reveal a
concerning bias in the evaluation process, as answers with factual errors are
rated more favorably than answers that are too short or contained grammatical
errors. To address this issue, we propose independently evaluating
machine-generated text across multiple dimensions, rather than merging all the
evaluation aspects into a single score. We instantiate this idea with the Elo
rating system, resulting in the Multi-Elo Rating System (MERS). Empirical
results from our study reveal that this proposed approach significantly
enhances the quality of LLM-based evaluations, particularly in terms of factual
accuracy. However, there is no significant improvement in crowd-sourced-based
evaluations, indicating the need for further investigation. | [
0.074820362,
0.0664077401,
-0.0155502101,
0.0347256921,
-0.0202907789,
0.0079545956,
0.009567583,
0.0117149809,
-0.0127193742,
-0.0792365,
-0.0476686172,
-0.0371299721,
0.0250560343,
-0.0023928003,
0.0467926972,
-0.0145220933,
-0.0095724612,
-0.0239760671,
0.0635662526,
-0.0308983717,
0.0467690043,
0.0158412121,
0.0218956657,
0.0448188037,
0.0037748737,
-0.0009854067,
0.0409715995,
0.0002855535,
0.0086863767,
-0.0318588242,
0.0061223088,
0.0827025324,
-0.0342426039,
0.0623788275,
0.0000018118,
-0.0389217511,
0.026365092,
0.0093210293,
-0.0147937797,
0.0652922094,
0.0604463257,
0.0382965021,
-0.0046491325,
0.0172533225,
-0.0251792967,
-0.0008540353,
0.0280528534,
0.0182389654,
0.0820817128,
0.0516065136,
0.0148755535,
-0.0153628867,
0.0271543097,
-0.0109926127,
-0.0004311831,
-0.0104552163,
0.0189167578,
0.0140940575,
-0.0042387471,
0.0077543166,
0.0134048294,
0.0116763189,
-0.0088154981,
-0.0279163215,
0.0379566401,
0.0183957145,
-0.0627401695,
-0.032060273,
-0.0021408433,
0.0664398819,
0.0262995549,
-0.0235078875,
-0.0233423728,
-0.0180488229,
0.0208173748,
0.0227893628,
-0.0347477794,
0.0231529064,
0.00904248,
0.0101791043,
0.0043399185,
-0.0121225417,
0.0357680991,
0.0428982601,
0.0263344422,
0.067181848,
0.0067222482,
-0.0467589125,
-0.0066157286,
0.0239397604,
-0.0087006744,
-0.0707604215,
-0.0036816678,
-0.0010457971,
-0.0117861275,
0.0112709785,
-0.0141937695,
-0.0079720635,
0.0590732358,
-0.0866631195,
0.0493626669,
-0.0371744037,
0.0132391695,
0.0359290056,
-0.0069585009,
0.0423026495,
0.0183808338,
0.0259233117,
-0.0189278349,
0.0151070841,
-0.0251070894,
-0.0190867186,
0.0255320128,
-0.0009501718,
0.0164379645,
0.0314058624,
-0.0393346474,
-0.0277546626,
-0.0609564446,
0.0019552747,
0.0032730224,
0.0165993813,
0.0218771566,
-0.0130833136,
-0.0702768713,
0.037895754,
-0.0273027997,
0.052289471,
-0.0178618059,
-0.0870024189,
0.0308540929,
0.0278306454,
-0.0122732734,
-0.0084251007,
0.0298392475,
0.0352370143,
0.026704289,
-0.0147122201,
0.0039947056,
-0.0123384288,
-0.0326444134,
-0.0486783162,
-0.0151171898,
-0.0959857479,
0.0078324648,
0.020822458,
-0.0199509878,
-0.0249412395,
0.0168487541,
0.0420102254,
-0.0425295047,
0.0077642133,
-0.0490601808,
0.0263826326,
0.0450675525,
-0.0108980145,
-0.0069600572,
0.0462885872,
0.0623025522,
0.0277735423,
0.0344149843,
-0.0149243353,
0.0555920489,
0.0535751097,
0.0021196704,
0.0192027744,
0.0154040139,
0.0149278641,
-0.0513839312,
0.0431276895,
0.0159768201,
0.0845827162,
-0.0011031814,
0.0121158939,
0.1001911312,
0.0281982291,
-0.0225972775,
0.0114216618,
0.0219576973,
0.0115009565,
0.0504247881,
-0.003036774,
-0.0377372392,
0.0097808316,
-0.0495696068,
-0.0046105525,
0.0455783382,
0.0261735637,
0.0184941962,
-0.0595961437,
-0.0438582674,
0.022919938,
0.0041033691,
0.0071975561,
0.0272409394,
-0.0171935242,
-0.0142848752,
0.0254402403,
0.0083999,
-0.0465232171,
0.0220041983,
-0.047215201,
0.0178237967,
0.0819072202,
0.0315880626,
0.0238315016,
0.0047378843,
-0.0206785481,
0.0029232497,
0.0472686104,
0.0528448261,
-0.028495919,
-0.0351631939,
-0.0007622825,
-0.0190926101,
-0.0041053519,
0.0031152144,
-0.0097418353,
0.0114183482,
-0.0051496001,
0.0059349844,
-0.0754073113,
-0.0934177414,
0.0305854995,
0.0022585981,
-0.0157284215,
-0.0360548422,
-0.0044260453,
0.0121832602,
0.0369949788,
-0.0401169732,
0.0489255115,
0.0072573218,
-0.006855764,
-0.0374457724,
-0.0248334706,
-0.0072666756,
0.029409606,
0.0359399468,
-0.0576955639,
-0.0388391875,
0.0268782042,
-0.018658964,
-0.0004259331,
-0.0167898815,
-0.0530469716,
0.0049557141,
-0.03304144,
-0.0062431982,
-0.0289315376,
-0.0054713823,
-0.0444044396,
0.0426333211,
-0.0131315608,
0.0647664443,
0.0109053701,
-0.0299115479,
0.0029514758,
-0.0172415134,
-0.0363221057,
-0.0121043958,
0.022594614,
0.0512268543,
0.0485458001,
0.0002154669,
-0.0525005907,
-0.0334013402,
-0.0859289765,
-0.0340861827,
-0.0161396805,
0.0150189064,
0.0274751838,
-0.0598313473,
-0.0125388615,
0.0106420126,
-0.0601285808,
-0.05374524,
0.0099885948,
0.0267133154,
0.0319378302,
-0.018662978,
0.0074774353,
-0.0444068648,
-0.0225082524,
-0.0136948796,
0.03959677,
0.0526194088,
0.0273657013,
-0.0539556444,
0.0111644277,
-0.0648450404,
-0.0226876549,
0.0298612677,
-0.0447944105,
0.0025201247,
0.0071480246,
-0.0112086246,
0.0159136225,
0.0398854837,
0.0260584261,
0.0567705631,
0.0093983226,
-0.0351846516,
-0.0549887307,
0.0045270468,
-0.0123262601,
-0.0260741692,
-0.0715906546,
0.0097126812,
0.0101507185,
0.0245070253,
0.0104630236,
-0.0327722244,
0.0303272251,
-0.0511038229,
-0.0538645722,
-0.0137387905,
-0.0225369371,
-0.0322518758,
0.0524606369,
-0.0135626402,
-0.0505846404,
0.0663624778,
-0.0438278951,
0.022289481,
0.0049500731,
0.0164292976,
-0.0229648259,
-0.0012117591,
0.0124350432,
0.0315431841,
-0.0270977039,
0.0132364398,
-0.0396166556,
0.0047799805,
0.0531150848,
-0.0654994696,
0.013660159,
-0.0371719301,
-0.0096264146,
0.0152324075,
-0.0259153303,
-0.0143521503,
-0.0789213553,
-0.0436440818,
-0.0044593061,
0.0466078259,
-0.0093150027,
-0.0024402339,
-0.0202640016,
0.019883262,
-0.0252762828,
-0.0258826297,
-0.0119448211,
0.0214724075,
0.0574136451,
0.0426504277,
0.0314060748,
0.0567223132,
-0.0487573296,
-0.0054711336,
0.0525817163,
0.0182029065,
0.0209136736,
-0.0004859008,
-0.0158507507,
0.0488683395,
-0.0056301472,
-0.0469522141,
0.0184715874,
0.0500485748,
-0.040363431,
0.0213110689,
0.1089349017,
0.0276572518,
-0.0197415054,
-0.0096097039,
-0.0256410856,
0.0317666121,
0.0248448513,
0.0173400342,
-0.0731694102,
-0.0073192124,
0.0036799603,
0.060774032,
-0.0198494382,
-0.0103738261,
0.013617781,
-0.1569572091,
0.034248732,
0.0007226442,
-0.0460695475,
-0.0184958614,
-0.0553614162,
-0.0039588558,
-0.0143226143,
-0.0053752023,
0.0270807594,
-0.0113888504,
0.0240097232,
0.0278441478,
-0.0620196164,
-0.0633250102,
0.0500892773,
-0.0273022074,
0.0883568302,
0.0562641136,
0.0462008342,
-0.0613698512,
-0.0728029981,
0.0073712249,
0.0008354545,
-0.016830707,
0.0149310287,
0.0588273332,
-0.0263659786,
0.0042405487,
-0.0561985075,
0.007126308,
-0.004816127,
0.0020813334,
-0.0130413994,
0.0677119642,
0.0311349481,
-0.0240434017,
-0.0169499312,
-0.0192666389,
-0.0052763768,
0.084661521,
0.0307862107,
-0.0715465844,
-0.0422086641,
-0.0601024516,
-0.0032110813,
-0.0109645445,
-0.0499796532,
0.0544782355,
-0.0043889084,
-0.0327839591,
-0.0745845065,
-0.0650308952,
0.0086929509,
-0.0113478834,
0.0157896057,
-0.0082999822,
-0.0050826389,
0.0113097196,
0.0210843794,
0.0089252293,
-0.0098779639,
0.0525691733,
-0.0514811762,
0.0186638292,
-0.013240614,
-0.0050044362,
-0.0101433573,
0.0165044442,
-0.0665847734,
-0.0436086804,
0.0233605132,
0.0561121814,
0.018444607,
-0.0042886343,
0.0075455438,
-0.0880190879,
0.0458393805,
0.046428483,
-0.0370079912,
0.0241547227,
0.013178166,
-0.0002666753,
0.0032656146,
0.02495322,
-0.0574856214,
0.0060436148,
0.0072286702,
0.0270332228,
-0.0101552047,
-0.0431904681,
0.0187277831,
0.0492180027,
0.0226329137,
-0.0542343855,
0.0133266225,
-0.0152326301,
-0.0319230407,
-0.0260522999,
-0.0376204588,
-0.0126799233,
-0.0005283834,
0.0039327503,
0.0067636776,
-0.0069457996,
0.0198989864,
-0.0059498968,
0.034118522,
-0.0578938574,
0.0322341621,
0.0491480753,
0.0119581595,
-0.004314953,
-0.0065084537,
-0.0250437818,
-0.0103862612,
-0.0258165281,
0.0326246209,
-0.0078567471,
0.0248823427,
0.0121124722,
-0.0076166298,
0.0273102764,
0.0241666175,
-0.0589030385,
-0.0498308539,
-0.045378875,
0.0350333303,
0.0394775085,
0.0051714662,
0.0932269916,
0.018361643,
-0.0200516172,
-0.0224020518,
-0.0135946963,
0.0026006764,
-0.0239245128,
0.0225802306,
0.0168876927,
-0.0332442597,
0.0307041612,
0.0765361115,
0.0231922045,
0.0248489063,
-0.0444712453,
-0.030834835,
-0.0173607692,
-0.0103673507,
-0.0292354524,
-0.0099807354,
-0.0024075399,
-0.0377477184,
-0.1015680954,
-0.0618349761,
-0.0164472703,
0.0435198881,
0.0219886079,
-0.0301406588,
0.0092040319,
0.0584052615,
-0.0065413723,
0.0191292893,
-0.0816832855,
-0.000086384,
-0.0063403561,
0.0217696391,
-0.0302243493,
-6.233479769e-33,
-0.0024153369,
-0.0527275279,
-0.0213708356,
-0.0008547275,
-0.0064882347,
-0.0003726011,
-0.0100042149,
0.0268467329,
-0.016356403,
0.0402482301,
-0.0121705271,
-0.0175744109,
-0.001704463,
0.0002965911,
0.0616201647,
-0.021414265,
0.0262477826,
-0.0305059105,
-0.0472987965,
-0.0046941661,
0.0204413943,
-0.0242850576,
0.0548727214,
-0.0623907447,
0.1020110697,
-0.0315769948,
-0.041334372,
0.0051989327,
-0.0159396101,
0.0524344146,
0.0000996255,
0.0556928217,
0.020778764,
-0.0561098345,
-0.0161875822,
-0.0116169043,
-0.0248758271,
0.0032798336,
0.021035606,
-0.0047789742,
-0.0179873165,
-0.0057704542,
0.0802402273,
0.0053419522,
-0.0590621009,
0.0038613535,
0.0657559633,
-0.0314031094,
0.0167533811,
-0.0300993007,
-0.0273939855,
0.0329083949,
-0.0155752683,
0.005065308,
-0.0123958718,
0.0469013192,
-0.0184517428,
0.0423496254,
-0.0673168749,
0.0196583867,
0.003444422,
0.0101016602,
0.064084813,
-0.0074281013,
-0.0121973362,
0.0725620016,
0.0143836727,
0.034811832,
-0.039058011,
-0.0264266469,
0.0073645962,
0.0114655718,
0.0890795216,
0.0955079049,
0.0193555932,
-0.0165949427,
-0.0302142203,
0.0286628138,
-0.0145837842,
0.0286399778,
0.0192808174,
-0.0263345782,
-0.055411648,
-0.025721496,
-0.0633240491,
-0.0476513803,
-0.0367316939,
0.0001268364,
0.0107578002,
-0.0274620336,
-0.0083722929,
-0.0214677639,
0.014631019,
-0.0534753203,
-0.0430280603,
0.0135664903,
-0.0504793338,
0.031927187,
0.0240788665,
0.0155616514,
-0.0600657798,
0.0486284494,
-0.0125381527,
0.0307383705,
0.028802786,
-0.0011302381,
0.0230783913,
-0.0000620594,
-0.0677291602,
0.0153718404,
-0.0189244226,
-0.0145017188,
0.0094536589,
-0.0404700488,
0.036041338,
-0.0211977884,
-0.0102551654,
0.00524987,
0.0063795131,
0.0638001338,
-0.0104358634,
-0.0152882487,
0.0031816596,
-0.0063200351,
-0.0431529135,
0.012005697,
-0.0240748748,
-0.0127945431,
0.0136018395,
-0.0208740681,
-0.0176947806,
-0.0262035914,
2.466e-7,
0.0711028054,
0.0747042373,
-0.000900579,
0.0181817207,
0.0252811424,
0.0586173944,
-0.0006321909,
0.0168333966,
0.0372467786,
0.0032930374,
-0.0132131791,
-0.009308055,
0.0545222536,
0.0565593839,
-0.0565285534,
-0.0056435489,
-0.1122517511,
0.0188687555,
-0.0119862109,
0.0021444911,
0.0674560964,
0.0467524044,
0.0179496109,
-0.0239223987,
-0.0425062589,
-0.0353234857,
0.0698156282,
-0.0209431406,
-0.0101188226,
0.012403301,
0.0658666864,
0.00798399,
0.0189550407,
0.0030360036,
-0.0102319717,
-0.0147914803,
0.0556572974,
0.0419418886,
0.0087906579,
-0.0028520727,
-0.0011224779,
-0.0339246914,
0.0119234901,
-0.0722153857,
0.0591155775,
0.0131792249,
-0.0318621211,
-0.0780348778,
-0.0506926365,
-0.0121817319,
0.0508280769,
-0.0307581685,
-0.0354384072,
0.0322570801,
0.0007387112,
0.0030365018,
-0.0012712524,
-0.0063563841,
-0.0452028401,
0.0073872465,
-0.020353958,
-0.0760437176,
0.001193902,
0.0124069043,
-0.0126200747,
-0.048603937,
0.0169126708,
1.886972523e-34,
0.0383034199,
-0.042010311,
0.0318801999,
0.001919436,
0.0367431268,
0.041958496,
-0.0158480462,
-0.0180111546,
-0.0008089567,
-0.0591265783,
-0.0055673178
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.04683v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.04683v1 | CORE-GPT: Combining Open Access research and large language models for credible, trustworthy question answering | 2023-07-06T13:41:36 | 2023-07-06T13:41:36 | David Pride, Matteo Cancellieri, Petr Knoth | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In this paper, we present CORE-GPT, a novel question-answering platform that
combines GPT-based language models and more than 32 million full-text open
access scientific articles from CORE. We first demonstrate that GPT3.5 and GPT4
cannot be relied upon to provide references or citations for generated text. We
then introduce CORE-GPT which delivers evidence-based answers to questions,
along with citations and links to the cited papers, greatly increasing the
trustworthiness of the answers and reducing the risk of hallucinations.
CORE-GPT's performance was evaluated on a dataset of 100 questions covering the
top 20 scientific domains in CORE, resulting in 100 answers and links to 500
relevant articles. The quality of the provided answers and and relevance of the
links were assessed by two annotators. Our results demonstrate that CORE-GPT
can produce comprehensive and trustworthy answers across the majority of
scientific domains, complete with links to genuine, relevant scientific
articles. | [
0.0484144427,
0.0380435362,
0.0073725022,
0.0055664578,
-0.0291023981,
-0.0070741018,
-0.0040060962,
0.0074984301,
0.0209117159,
-0.0278253052,
-0.0155616812,
0.0380828455,
-0.0227158908,
0.0150860855,
0.0101768486,
-0.0181605555,
0.0396138616,
-0.0165119581,
0.0526828244,
-0.0348926932,
0.0187284201,
0.0319392309,
0.0012249987,
0.029345829,
0.0383432135,
-0.0519030392,
0.0171455145,
-0.0218291581,
0.0366211832,
-0.0291362349,
-0.0038179606,
0.0617447123,
-0.008432922,
0.051407896,
0.0000019567,
-0.0410335399,
-0.0281991716,
0.0598293878,
-0.0118847433,
0.0319483206,
0.0036286509,
0.0221149381,
0.02669576,
0.0280495379,
-0.0479502864,
-0.0063228779,
0.0550823957,
0.0227820817,
0.0662125424,
0.0164842587,
0.0075260387,
-0.0031565533,
0.0672234073,
-0.0025323865,
0.0196463969,
-0.0196308605,
0.0273477528,
0.0451848395,
0.0534449443,
0.0554328859,
0.0273574982,
0.0440866053,
0.0235729236,
-0.0097585609,
0.0168290064,
0.0442623906,
-0.0680941418,
-0.0012925741,
0.0243950412,
0.0467735529,
0.0376930311,
-0.0600584261,
0.0227473322,
-0.002756949,
-0.0398440249,
0.0443344079,
-0.0816071332,
0.0269108042,
0.0010588694,
-0.0257388353,
0.0091184834,
-0.0146835716,
0.0164254066,
0.0308030751,
0.0434757881,
0.1041637138,
0.0349257924,
-0.0275606085,
0.0194647219,
0.0111739822,
-0.001717506,
-0.0776371136,
0.0279286336,
0.0346142314,
0.0205081645,
0.0097939828,
0.0107878121,
0.0294522326,
0.0815590769,
-0.0396106169,
-0.0389173217,
0.0082314136,
-0.0291807409,
0.0389713384,
-0.0118704075,
0.0135398312,
-0.0471667126,
0.0036992726,
-0.0042179152,
-0.0330648236,
-0.0629377812,
-0.0370863676,
-0.0089808702,
0.0169608723,
-0.0161199328,
0.0109764505,
-0.0388092548,
-0.0034409417,
0.0331222825,
-0.0229637977,
0.0326314159,
0.0053936224,
-0.0207555927,
-0.0191973243,
-0.0186988674,
0.0566053316,
-0.0409668498,
0.0222066976,
-0.0144962119,
-0.0879900679,
-0.0217287987,
0.0030541625,
-0.0050409595,
-0.0220672898,
0.0203063227,
0.024327971,
0.0248043183,
-0.0089334119,
-0.0019342204,
-0.0509933718,
-0.014762817,
-0.0556889847,
-0.0258450378,
-0.0964715779,
0.0150445653,
0.041862119,
-0.0036234884,
-0.0465465896,
0.0004921402,
0.0464482233,
-0.044817578,
0.0233344901,
-0.0780711174,
-0.0203915872,
0.055848334,
0.0137992073,
0.0427067839,
0.0130113969,
0.0116352346,
-0.0146644739,
0.0266343858,
-0.0052969093,
0.0153404679,
-0.0154722165,
0.0337217748,
-0.0064963186,
0.0670019835,
0.0733240545,
-0.0181206092,
0.0102120023,
-0.0345794745,
0.0752501786,
-0.0078796418,
-0.0208816137,
0.0460197143,
0.068457,
-0.0470129289,
0.0208873991,
-0.0000465318,
-0.0232874397,
0.0374513939,
-0.021872256,
-0.0412168019,
0.0607010871,
-0.007560845,
-0.0065384447,
0.0314704217,
0.0257404316,
0.0042728824,
-0.0085026091,
-0.0271133445,
0.0173248313,
-0.0325016752,
0.0063472083,
0.0107498066,
-0.037159659,
-0.0092620905,
0.0539688282,
0.0092115588,
-0.0365076959,
0.0109560601,
-0.0290199406,
0.0560226478,
-0.0007510137,
0.0441580787,
-0.0181711577,
-0.015429859,
-0.0399837792,
0.058616817,
0.0553685352,
0.0093057631,
-0.007965452,
-0.0258528329,
-0.0344930142,
0.0028759991,
-0.0084693357,
0.008518802,
-0.0020238075,
0.0261785891,
0.0377241559,
0.0080643566,
-0.0605972148,
-0.0225859042,
0.0058305403,
-0.0176444054,
-0.0162945949,
-0.0199305341,
-0.0504251495,
0.0213590413,
0.035332378,
-0.0135122165,
0.0535289906,
0.0388118178,
0.0027663733,
-0.0490413308,
0.0180221647,
0.0098218517,
0.054701753,
0.0438885838,
-0.056720484,
-0.021380607,
0.0227609035,
-0.0223262385,
-0.0487987846,
-0.0107199065,
-0.0592721999,
0.0232785828,
-0.0496667102,
-0.0493323356,
-0.0066213412,
0.003849664,
-0.0312364381,
0.0511935353,
0.0126205236,
0.0454706401,
0.0191380568,
-0.0170803946,
0.0436264127,
-0.056489259,
-0.0150640989,
0.0110480059,
-0.0063924291,
0.0116072185,
0.0510039143,
-0.0123160612,
-0.0608727895,
0.0164659787,
-0.061075069,
0.0173812471,
-0.0015411205,
0.0321016572,
0.040637821,
-0.012407314,
0.0029717823,
0.0072054029,
-0.0361808017,
0.0024460491,
0.0393197685,
0.0118471971,
0.0318642333,
0.0157735236,
0.0242589843,
-0.0549698286,
-0.025115937,
-0.0373820923,
0.014165597,
0.03389588,
0.0214384925,
-0.0283563342,
-0.0323105864,
-0.035572093,
0.0103316307,
0.0070032938,
-0.0069301496,
0.0178382881,
-0.0170420744,
-0.016617991,
0.0472945347,
0.0031148721,
-0.0264563747,
0.037494164,
-0.016099805,
-0.0481649637,
-0.0135272974,
-0.0140964659,
-0.049075909,
0.0043551889,
-0.0213411823,
0.0201399121,
0.0187226627,
0.017823685,
-0.0218966138,
-0.0471893884,
0.0255022589,
-0.0414895937,
-0.014618827,
0.0111321975,
-0.0124936448,
-0.0187927168,
0.0377241708,
0.0152729806,
-0.0296210647,
0.0590743572,
-0.0411223993,
0.0054969518,
-0.0699736476,
-0.0061564427,
-0.0189507399,
0.007768176,
-0.0111758802,
0.015809074,
0.0497097112,
0.0027264499,
-0.0255126655,
-0.0151369767,
0.0119221136,
-0.0318501629,
0.0108520687,
-0.057037767,
0.0366619863,
0.0088188844,
-0.0059034266,
-0.0081885681,
-0.0127281267,
-0.0657608733,
0.0281899739,
-0.0026013979,
-0.0408776626,
-0.030893201,
-0.0084035136,
0.0769571364,
0.0083833281,
-0.0273060035,
-0.0095833559,
-0.0065889996,
0.0326269902,
0.0913326219,
-0.0031027999,
0.0486311838,
0.0085617099,
-0.0202033725,
0.0978476405,
0.0114797186,
0.0196486749,
-0.0064683105,
-0.0427268595,
0.0020398602,
-0.0675186217,
-0.0297210068,
0.0014876393,
0.0142483637,
-0.0455306955,
-0.0245679189,
0.115110971,
0.0474508256,
-0.062819235,
-0.0459192544,
-0.0641464293,
-0.0144620193,
0.0110559119,
0.0299553219,
-0.080691576,
-0.0214453302,
-0.0347790532,
0.0212565307,
0.0087054595,
-0.0252910182,
-0.0028261377,
-0.0669817552,
0.0346180275,
-0.0210961327,
-0.0578554533,
-0.0161452238,
-0.0866496563,
0.0032977739,
-0.037219204,
-0.0323463455,
0.0332170092,
-0.0000391877,
0.0344998986,
0.0146116093,
-0.0038408681,
-0.0017764496,
0.0677738562,
-0.0280522387,
0.0200929791,
0.0738065392,
0.0433251113,
-0.0391153693,
-0.0421973802,
-0.0027335063,
-0.062341895,
-0.0385764651,
-0.0221943874,
0.0065121688,
0.0091715623,
0.0244127214,
-0.0421162359,
0.0606166758,
-0.029304428,
-0.0176793039,
0.0469681993,
0.1085028648,
0.0083523942,
0.0004327187,
-0.0553522035,
-0.004849379,
-0.0173648968,
0.0826983675,
-0.0156798344,
0.0108471699,
-0.0454227217,
-0.0246681497,
0.0138421645,
0.0001591036,
-0.0702925548,
0.0115614552,
0.0168409869,
0.0179466214,
-0.0708343163,
-0.0071889511,
0.0327576883,
-0.0076317159,
0.0036314165,
0.0266819149,
0.0305543151,
0.0114660067,
-0.0375007428,
0.013756847,
-0.04616227,
0.0159980729,
-0.0584306978,
0.0281135477,
0.0748099163,
0.0214605182,
-0.0381721593,
0.0691403598,
-0.0020744654,
-0.0506663211,
-0.0357766114,
0.0387736596,
0.0277373344,
-0.0207890179,
-0.0118004372,
-0.0490630232,
0.0043696295,
0.0176755134,
-0.0299534928,
0.0032889738,
-0.0114004621,
-0.0275336187,
-0.0024556809,
-0.0053541367,
-0.0708817542,
-0.0006880686,
-0.0390548036,
0.0212897137,
-0.0258083977,
-0.0310922526,
0.0506625473,
0.0407453701,
0.0310590863,
0.0043422375,
0.0452275872,
0.0118857082,
0.0229429491,
-0.0258940738,
0.0130428178,
-0.0075185988,
0.0328961536,
0.0176986624,
-0.0207503326,
0.0029050726,
0.0164583642,
-0.0596231222,
0.0297278147,
-0.0434644781,
0.0086001223,
0.0518927649,
0.010380215,
0.0151955979,
-0.0389010832,
-0.0360020511,
-0.0532053895,
-0.022438297,
0.0715937689,
-0.0180350747,
0.0461598448,
0.0016861097,
-0.0455653667,
0.0642145276,
0.0143256839,
-0.12589176,
-0.0617611855,
-0.0342847258,
-0.0036028135,
0.0050035594,
0.0375507213,
0.0744972751,
-0.0480788946,
-0.0482876562,
-0.0279271007,
0.0019537651,
0.049546361,
-0.002357593,
0.0666654259,
0.0270267222,
-0.03582488,
-0.01386528,
0.0654078349,
0.0216533076,
0.022224756,
-0.0096365362,
-0.0359315872,
-0.0170789044,
-0.0428164676,
-0.0901230797,
0.0204032063,
-0.0130998902,
-0.0135893868,
-0.0348724537,
-0.0355422087,
-0.0030852577,
0.0309103038,
0.0207393486,
-0.0139621273,
0.0297828428,
0.0324873216,
0.0260053203,
-0.0716338977,
-0.040848311,
0.0718457177,
-0.0619414188,
-0.0546248704,
-0.014370257,
-6.512709636e-33,
0.0026523813,
-0.0250767246,
-0.0051679043,
-0.0153749064,
0.0102814147,
0.0391262025,
-0.0463649556,
-0.0171788968,
-0.0520509891,
0.0349323712,
-0.0144911762,
0.0300538689,
0.0070807724,
0.0069820965,
0.0142404977,
0.0036923059,
0.0027933673,
0.00295782,
-0.0120796757,
0.0515625998,
0.0427747704,
-0.0065979115,
0.0651709437,
-0.059923701,
0.0611122437,
-0.0414861292,
-0.0127811143,
0.0089853955,
-0.0354127362,
0.0661011487,
-0.0309413373,
0.022494439,
0.0089135543,
-0.0793302283,
0.0230466686,
-0.009659295,
-0.0859084129,
-0.0072978968,
0.0567192249,
-0.0438804403,
-0.04751724,
0.0033401358,
0.0088871671,
-0.011773305,
0.021830298,
-0.0326407962,
0.0401586033,
-0.0189302117,
-0.0028604683,
-0.0270400271,
-0.0172503293,
0.0334361903,
-0.0067881662,
0.0564231202,
-0.0293629523,
0.0488283373,
-0.0294724591,
0.0621528588,
-0.009343829,
0.0269400552,
0.0114901029,
0.0113314921,
0.038576141,
-0.0569736511,
0.0143703967,
0.0077317054,
-0.0367861353,
-0.0532553531,
-0.0085904505,
0.0012415247,
-0.0475385301,
0.0192569755,
0.0963972956,
0.1084581017,
-0.0059141214,
0.0363820232,
-0.0906751305,
0.0373927988,
0.0009255245,
0.0463045426,
0.0130096693,
-0.001802129,
0.0067317341,
0.0110055963,
-0.0305325687,
0.0044995495,
-0.0232536625,
-0.0498086661,
0.013614268,
-0.0433617793,
-0.0463032313,
0.0221578106,
0.0283643771,
-0.0372702852,
-0.010230476,
0.0583242327,
-0.0142608928,
0.0139199868,
0.0189822651,
0.0592597164,
-0.075413391,
0.0502989255,
-0.0021992116,
0.0008981154,
0.0147514092,
0.0170352347,
-0.0054254462,
-0.0127500277,
-0.0337086134,
0.0100473315,
-0.0083733033,
0.0288419314,
-0.0215080641,
-0.0203324128,
-0.0193441845,
0.0294941161,
0.032260336,
0.0533213876,
0.0215450563,
0.0307979118,
-0.0249117203,
-0.0112589356,
-0.0011449696,
0.0188908204,
-0.0326857902,
0.0154050542,
-0.0045124176,
0.0449438766,
-0.0279674996,
-0.0592997931,
0.012614755,
0.0112715513,
2.698e-7,
0.0808631107,
0.0292330645,
0.0229629036,
-0.00886585,
0.035525687,
-0.0004697024,
0.0277309883,
0.040425133,
0.0339764394,
-0.0437957272,
-0.0335091464,
-0.0131360339,
0.006444836,
0.0638398975,
-0.0598110333,
-0.0377983563,
-0.0869708359,
-0.0365335383,
-0.0457521193,
-0.0028068011,
-0.000425065,
0.0412367247,
-0.0014300772,
0.0108722541,
-0.0252396222,
-0.0164302625,
0.0429675393,
0.0079891384,
0.024192268,
0.0281242058,
0.0149361948,
0.0030397342,
0.0203181412,
0.015902916,
-0.0290244389,
-0.0191040039,
0.0135355387,
0.0421373434,
-0.0015163404,
-0.0414505117,
0.0102952002,
-0.0649504066,
0.0541496612,
-0.1016728282,
0.0878048912,
-0.0330120251,
-0.0307211727,
-0.0203909017,
-0.063940607,
-0.0280140992,
0.03403797,
-0.0245092046,
-0.0136488928,
0.0145796472,
-0.044002898,
0.0277276803,
-0.0100921225,
-0.0315343663,
-0.0325682387,
0.0111804027,
-0.0302868132,
-0.0486801006,
-0.0160784125,
-0.0269153956,
-0.0361262001,
-0.0369890481,
0.0074758898,
2.117024229e-34,
0.019896619,
0.0123110367,
0.0078920284,
0.0123167029,
0.0297121312,
0.0234066341,
0.009450445,
0.0074403491,
0.0219729394,
-0.0586829036,
-0.0192551296
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.04762v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.04762v1 | How word semantics and phonology affect handwriting of Alzheimer's patients: a machine learning based analysis | 2023-07-06T13:35:06 | 2023-07-06T13:35:06 | Nicole Dalia Cilia, Claudio De Stefano, Francesco Fontanella, Sabato Marco Siniscalchi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Using kinematic properties of handwriting to support the diagnosis of
neurodegenerative disease is a real challenge: non-invasive detection
techniques combined with machine learning approaches promise big steps forward
in this research field. In literature, the tasks proposed focused on different
cognitive skills to elicitate handwriting movements. In particular, the meaning
and phonology of words to copy can compromise writing fluency. In this paper,
we investigated how word semantics and phonology affect the handwriting of
people affected by Alzheimer's disease. To this aim, we used the data from six
handwriting tasks, each requiring copying a word belonging to one of the
following categories: regular (have a predictable phoneme-grapheme
correspondence, e.g., cat), non-regular (have atypical phoneme-grapheme
correspondence, e.g., laugh), and non-word (non-meaningful pronounceable letter
strings that conform to phoneme-grapheme conversion rules). We analyzed the
data using a machine learning approach by implementing four well-known and
widely-used classifiers and feature selection. The experimental results showed
that the feature selection allowed us to derive a different set of highly
distinctive features for each word type. Furthermore, non-regular words needed,
on average, more features but achieved excellent classification performance:
the best result was obtained on a non-regular, reaching an accuracy close to
90%. | [
-0.0148016345,
0.063885957,
-0.0159301236,
0.0261454172,
-0.0702380762,
0.0106566558,
0.038145598,
0.0718333423,
0.03078725,
-0.0518218465,
0.015916964,
-0.0136693064,
0.101147376,
0.0137021942,
0.0044860546,
-0.036215812,
0.0207441021,
-0.0220293775,
0.0456373058,
0.0018003384,
-0.0195633918,
-0.0027959119,
-0.0447284877,
0.0403858572,
-0.0383752845,
0.0015775739,
0.0229003802,
-0.0041721775,
-0.0283738691,
0.0174309239,
-0.0628675222,
0.0354233198,
-0.0152427703,
0.0415887535,
0.0000017948,
-0.0660898462,
0.0123019302,
0.0010566496,
0.0363788642,
-0.0547395088,
0.0584747195,
-0.0095473286,
-0.0136603024,
0.0040800669,
0.0175851025,
0.0011828734,
0.0855487362,
0.0396629758,
-0.0280667953,
0.0343311429,
-0.0223105997,
0.0099444147,
0.0605148412,
-0.0049293474,
0.0250928644,
0.0090487022,
0.0407184139,
-0.025283277,
-0.022718247,
-0.0805368051,
-0.0140200071,
0.0502849445,
-0.0606093779,
0.0098913871,
-0.0290529542,
0.0205607899,
0.028077757,
0.0007003626,
0.0044279918,
0.0137883611,
-0.0212665908,
0.0008776698,
0.0169748943,
0.0030768856,
0.0090157548,
0.0704707727,
-0.0038954993,
-0.0048388941,
-0.0052111964,
-0.0088999067,
0.0165897794,
0.0066557326,
0.0034868666,
-0.0079544745,
0.0433460027,
-0.001452934,
-0.0022341362,
-0.0284422245,
0.062377423,
-0.0057058153,
0.0068465443,
-0.0264231339,
0.0649677962,
0.0103314053,
-0.000294124,
-0.007446114,
-0.0375120267,
-0.0730000362,
0.0505780354,
-0.0290271305,
0.1117812321,
0.0048177917,
-0.02239714,
0.008694943,
-0.0328888148,
0.0153272385,
-0.0327072889,
0.0174747519,
-0.0245099422,
0.0476702377,
-0.0249834359,
-0.0165374894,
-0.0278904606,
0.0309473351,
0.0514243655,
-0.0191680398,
-0.0437936559,
-0.0286006629,
0.0331399702,
-0.0597253069,
0.006660834,
0.0217719451,
0.002950774,
0.0382919572,
-0.0113171786,
-0.0271343831,
-0.0153671755,
0.0533880629,
-0.0377676114,
-0.0027886194,
0.0354419239,
0.0436212495,
0.0160126854,
-0.0372027308,
0.0441340692,
0.0747864693,
-0.0178525485,
-0.0267205965,
-0.0125314314,
0.0047699986,
-0.0638304576,
-0.0137813995,
-0.0022906226,
-0.0476895161,
0.000420569,
0.0035925333,
-0.0095406035,
-0.0480296127,
-0.0463151112,
0.0094344141,
-0.0324698053,
0.0380370356,
-0.0011283783,
0.0111470334,
0.1073508933,
-0.0363250934,
-0.0377356969,
-0.0376398861,
0.0663071722,
-0.0348216482,
0.0106388442,
-0.0287795328,
0.0151485037,
0.0470326357,
-0.0140783507,
-0.0309095941,
-0.0387179665,
-0.0624102801,
-0.0021244099,
0.0525761843,
0.0385662802,
0.0605448857,
0.0359224081,
-0.0447344482,
0.0339529328,
0.0945596099,
0.0417339019,
0.0359809361,
0.0044636303,
-0.0264651608,
0.0278792623,
0.0147261182,
0.0153233241,
-0.0132176885,
-0.0260802805,
-0.0047370959,
-0.0109385625,
-0.0129085025,
0.0196851101,
-0.0184093378,
-0.0228989236,
-0.0239344928,
0.0088177472,
-0.0073640123,
0.0116240112,
0.0165707283,
-0.044000376,
-0.0689788088,
-0.0267619342,
-0.0305397809,
-0.0397212952,
-0.0438619331,
0.0085985214,
0.0506553724,
0.057873968,
-0.052952826,
0.0257204492,
-0.0015766763,
-0.0372424722,
0.0111426897,
-0.0386796854,
0.0086342916,
0.0444029346,
-0.027434336,
0.01135338,
0.0518581122,
-0.0051454776,
-0.0303486325,
-0.0254072025,
0.0700643435,
-0.0230735671,
0.0051678177,
-0.0452768505,
0.0608676337,
-0.0254127104,
-0.0269873887,
0.0123500573,
0.0300757643,
0.0099778874,
0.0072131548,
-0.013732818,
0.0010951289,
-0.0084523614,
-0.0505969077,
0.0054919487,
-0.018242754,
-0.0596843064,
0.0131881684,
-0.0009479412,
0.0124202622,
0.0249147415,
-0.0120851221,
0.0493614674,
-0.0267671868,
-0.0443668105,
-0.05259021,
0.016865965,
-0.0464884415,
0.0302706864,
-0.0257509239,
-0.0232466776,
-0.0282084066,
0.0539737977,
0.0051425337,
-0.0100510968,
-0.0103766397,
-0.0305925384,
0.0082247648,
-0.0414063632,
-0.0413180031,
-0.0008408151,
-0.0249354206,
0.0244720448,
-0.0040229643,
0.0077549377,
-0.0063119633,
-0.0123086404,
-0.0636095405,
-0.0239158534,
0.0262332205,
-0.0110340388,
0.003371262,
-0.0313418284,
-0.0039201425,
-0.0173720438,
-0.0133579085,
0.0158153102,
-0.0209393594,
0.001463054,
0.0316168368,
-0.0295258332,
-0.0221879613,
-0.0218850747,
-0.0289365351,
-0.0264650676,
0.0477042012,
0.0570295788,
-0.0596644953,
-0.0117442785,
0.0296501871,
0.0082399864,
-0.0083544925,
0.0301047713,
0.0181804802,
-0.0041676513,
-0.0100939712,
-0.0158948768,
0.057101652,
-0.026439527,
0.023742497,
0.0595360436,
0.0034651323,
0.0443456434,
-0.0483809076,
-0.0114013646,
0.093216151,
-0.0121236704,
-0.0200288109,
0.0341422781,
0.0172835905,
0.0678083152,
0.0448771231,
-0.0130472034,
-0.003853082,
-0.0569870621,
0.0232892726,
-0.0363764055,
-0.0536877289,
-0.0577083081,
-0.014486731,
-0.0167567562,
-0.0568867251,
0.0433607027,
-0.0433090441,
0.0046699853,
-0.0255448464,
-0.0051616221,
-0.0350483283,
0.0633787736,
-0.0314252451,
0.0277415048,
-0.0300936755,
-0.0717138499,
-0.0083340351,
-0.0044831568,
0.035699416,
-0.0290351827,
0.0313517861,
-0.0155043649,
0.0256854761,
0.0133688794,
-0.0051910034,
0.0032950058,
0.0394766741,
0.0026340054,
0.0286369734,
-0.0186506547,
-0.0507036336,
-0.0275914911,
-0.0269367304,
0.0050518857,
0.0753439292,
0.0038278403,
0.0071073687,
-0.0073945732,
0.0751302689,
0.0032214643,
-0.0070569157,
-0.0920910016,
-0.028099874,
-0.0364130773,
-0.0288560893,
-0.0488710925,
0.0275503416,
-0.0040793093,
0.0209615976,
0.004534537,
-0.0466991663,
-0.0403695852,
0.0345277563,
0.021276895,
-0.0055901739,
0.0046194731,
0.0811130628,
0.0218851417,
-0.0592875183,
-0.0066344389,
0.0045090853,
0.001562017,
-0.0240339544,
0.0141783794,
0.0010975116,
-0.0294694081,
0.0174956713,
0.0522059873,
-0.0166108608,
-0.0011329118,
0.0086689983,
-0.0039480105,
0.0302338693,
-0.0188564938,
-0.0882202163,
0.0114683975,
-0.0272304248,
-0.0054003517,
-0.0070632636,
-0.0123116206,
-0.0226738211,
-0.0333859771,
-0.016907135,
0.0068519311,
-0.0888472497,
-0.0337569602,
0.0193622969,
-0.0005928853,
0.0175330043,
0.0491352044,
0.0529963262,
-0.0407112986,
-0.0790574402,
-0.011767529,
-0.0064304457,
0.0534261838,
-0.036853075,
0.0922619402,
0.0423825532,
0.0152498484,
-0.0525461063,
0.0474758632,
-0.0362325385,
-0.0112944376,
-0.0191236958,
0.0387899354,
-0.0786210671,
-0.0221753325,
0.0043214597,
-0.016553212,
0.0238869134,
0.0314249508,
0.0144944778,
-0.0513314717,
-0.0719115511,
0.0007310141,
0.0389920548,
0.0012093296,
-0.0136427358,
-0.003697779,
-0.0337441713,
-0.0733183175,
-0.0914110318,
-0.0074370322,
0.067613773,
0.0496929474,
0.0434511602,
0.0588843264,
0.0380258113,
0.0310200416,
-0.0799316913,
0.005683417,
0.051579494,
0.055337429,
-0.0826918259,
-0.0520261563,
-0.0201732591,
0.0176538266,
-0.025909327,
-0.0083048213,
-0.0142673114,
-0.0363814384,
0.0914046541,
0.0120977331,
0.0159239154,
0.002386881,
-0.0065327208,
-0.063683331,
0.0308110435,
0.0226556119,
0.0596290231,
0.0154177854,
0.0046432051,
-0.0487661622,
-0.0139453225,
0.002442677,
0.0229238421,
-0.0098894741,
0.0015422946,
-0.0589840673,
-0.0202747677,
-0.0414993651,
-0.0230091363,
0.0198581368,
0.0332629718,
-0.0257841181,
-0.0030947411,
-0.0379952081,
-0.0104252268,
0.0438329615,
0.0375090241,
-0.030976899,
-0.0419350676,
0.0331133679,
-0.0139743863,
-0.019327959,
-0.0554204956,
-0.0298581496,
-0.0296572726,
0.0320644528,
0.067572102,
-0.0144787412,
0.1182191297,
-0.0006446324,
-0.0001960811,
0.0036011122,
0.0806999728,
-0.0368277617,
0.0357301533,
0.0191912353,
0.0087878238,
-0.0018237091,
0.0170560051,
-0.0158400908,
0.0054363785,
0.0151166357,
-0.0070264852,
-0.0449378677,
0.0139213158,
0.0324914344,
-0.0527510718,
0.0270194784,
-0.0126947081,
0.0373937301,
-0.0257671904,
-0.0176724251,
0.0066634715,
0.0040274523,
-0.0180673357,
-0.0135782361,
-0.0013141753,
-0.0211516283,
0.0502140187,
-0.0358689725,
-0.0333663598,
-0.0131202135,
-0.050033357,
-0.0151176378,
-0.0536815636,
0.0811094791,
0.0120360935,
-0.0678788126,
-0.0129143437,
-0.0240065772,
-0.0201784372,
0.0946390107,
-0.0417731255,
0.0652934238,
0.0106177954,
0.006046772,
-0.0009758666,
-0.0203149915,
0.0190035682,
-0.0442525856,
0.0043644928,
-0.0307261199,
-0.0069477372,
-0.017544724,
-5.145526687e-33,
0.0173236094,
-0.0664372072,
0.0175974164,
0.0422093086,
0.0097446591,
0.0268382728,
-0.0164910331,
0.0468515828,
0.0031467224,
0.0394955836,
0.0064771157,
-0.0366434418,
0.0273229331,
0.0196142085,
0.0108731389,
-0.0021356025,
0.0046118535,
-0.0337613933,
-0.0302132368,
-0.0328584872,
0.0526180267,
0.009031659,
0.0519083701,
-0.0308326483,
0.0353709608,
0.0058454028,
0.0006311519,
-0.0305901915,
0.0041444092,
-0.0206831545,
-0.0439157337,
0.0320865326,
0.0346063897,
0.0585458912,
0.0184192322,
0.0519753359,
-0.0405829549,
-0.0409692526,
0.0029727512,
0.0419459157,
-0.0299098119,
-0.0266325157,
0.0155552495,
0.0082891546,
-0.0404295884,
0.0247203447,
0.0543701202,
-0.0222660452,
-0.0144247152,
-0.0071694562,
-0.0313388817,
-0.0053401543,
0.006472805,
-0.0066022123,
0.0241159908,
-0.0425933301,
-0.0359643474,
-0.037286073,
-0.0939165428,
0.0237814356,
-0.0439439677,
0.0255238041,
-0.0000312202,
0.0170713142,
-0.0476980135,
0.0490026809,
0.0254176352,
0.0032907263,
0.0110367304,
0.0355450027,
0.0374272093,
0.0517416596,
0.0389373749,
-0.0143795898,
0.0741015747,
-0.0471552275,
0.0330116674,
0.0027452882,
0.0306539983,
-0.0199572816,
0.0049019991,
-0.0143637201,
-0.0306759495,
-0.0147423092,
-0.0084751518,
0.0400665291,
-0.0142474715,
0.0072248327,
0.0129542407,
-0.0259656496,
0.0529109687,
0.0056912322,
0.0143537093,
0.0090604834,
-0.0210114308,
-0.0462162979,
0.0007288022,
0.0444639698,
0.010377747,
-0.049798049,
-0.0137218134,
-0.0393777862,
0.0247819778,
0.0316346623,
0.0491538234,
-0.0116364649,
0.0492081828,
0.0053360201,
-0.0410949849,
0.0023061174,
0.0286539029,
-0.0067287828,
0.0309388209,
0.0042268224,
-0.0087375175,
0.0061659771,
0.0056160009,
0.0312384088,
-0.0305158272,
-0.0068404665,
-0.0166556574,
0.0226242896,
-0.0155696347,
0.0024183765,
-0.0309866332,
-0.0294959918,
0.0123956306,
-0.0040117558,
-0.0032642409,
-0.028214721,
0.0175471008,
-0.0117122447,
2.499e-7,
0.0869813114,
0.0722039342,
0.0441332236,
0.0396577567,
0.0139177898,
0.0058790338,
-0.0318090022,
0.0113844145,
-0.0252766889,
0.0567276254,
0.0490918085,
0.0091118459,
0.047331553,
-0.0165409911,
-0.0634360909,
0.0440507866,
-0.0587675348,
0.0324645229,
-0.076389268,
0.0783300996,
0.0472934581,
-0.0147823635,
-0.0201313291,
-0.0921764895,
0.0140594831,
-0.0267353598,
0.0122259026,
-0.0048491322,
0.061762277,
-0.04035604,
0.041574385,
-0.0672630146,
0.0273853149,
0.0721905157,
-0.05587795,
-0.020429831,
0.0402064882,
0.0288956799,
-0.0889160037,
0.0086937826,
0.0311325323,
0.0524222143,
-0.0278007239,
0.0119579695,
0.04292484,
0.0452004001,
-0.021719873,
-0.045649197,
0.0168114956,
0.0316542611,
0.0827385858,
-0.013914845,
0.0124489367,
-0.0194229614,
0.0432570316,
-0.0124169579,
-0.000225549,
0.0152077721,
-0.0140120964,
0.0354548357,
-0.0116102686,
0.0358289629,
-0.0190128554,
-0.04073219,
0.0252468009,
-0.0944984034,
-0.0001346902,
2.120628084e-34,
-0.002658797,
0.0155035546,
0.0454720519,
0.0007757879,
-0.0514852777,
0.0034879099,
0.0895070508,
0.0317074582,
-0.03467663,
-0.0140864411,
-0.0016898068
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.02982v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.02982v1 | Efficient Semiring-Weighted Earley Parsing | 2023-07-06T13:33:59 | 2023-07-06T13:33:59 | Andreas Opedal, Ran Zmigrod, Tim Vieira, Ryan Cotterell, Jason Eisner | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.DS, cs.FL | This paper provides a reference description, in the form of a deduction
system, of Earley's (1970) context-free parsing algorithm with various
speed-ups. Our presentation includes a known worst-case runtime improvement
from Earley's $O (N^3|G||R|)$, which is unworkable for the large grammars that
arise in natural language processing, to $O (N^3|G|)$, which matches the
runtime of CKY on a binarized version of the grammar $G$. Here $N$ is the
length of the sentence, $|R|$ is the number of productions in $G$, and $|G|$ is
the total length of those productions. We also provide a version that achieves
runtime of $O (N^3|M|)$ with $|M| \leq |G|$ when the grammar is represented
compactly as a single finite-state automaton $M$ (this is partly novel). We
carefully treat the generalization to semiring-weighted deduction,
preprocessing the grammar like Stolcke (1995) to eliminate deduction cycles,
and further generalize Stolcke's method to compute the weights of sentence
prefixes. We also provide implementation details for efficient execution,
ensuring that on a preprocessed grammar, the semiring-weighted versions of our
methods have the same asymptotic runtime and space requirements as the
unweighted methods, including sub-cubic runtime on some grammars. | [
0.0326134861,
0.0098188668,
0.004182728,
0.0566660389,
-0.0596593767,
0.0415264182,
-0.0238130894,
-0.0138361808,
-0.0304184183,
-0.0347463824,
0.0377054699,
0.0129689714,
-0.0038064856,
-0.013162341,
-0.0141411508,
-0.058209829,
0.0435709022,
-0.0143162683,
-0.0130025949,
0.0560915209,
0.0148741603,
0.0040314649,
-0.0189605746,
-0.0054547628,
-0.0388728082,
-0.0439282507,
-0.0043848101,
-0.0274997409,
-0.0076550012,
-0.0353910588,
-0.0213969052,
0.0102082137,
-0.0675161406,
0.0088549443,
0.0000021816,
-0.0327158906,
-0.033145491,
0.016705744,
-0.0405175164,
0.0711983517,
0.0466897599,
0.0060518361,
-0.017148219,
0.0457116999,
-0.0405304432,
0.0278288908,
0.0212213583,
-0.0169142373,
0.048985038,
0.0707406476,
-0.0275122784,
-0.0356855355,
-0.0312970914,
0.0057873381,
-0.0502402,
-0.0553246625,
0.0307619572,
-0.0137986336,
0.0022222078,
-0.0315290242,
-0.0046488876,
-0.0350756384,
-0.0243710522,
-0.0185973998,
-0.0426058583,
-0.0129373791,
-0.0940112174,
0.0106630176,
-0.0154034551,
-0.0069123926,
0.0091345599,
-0.0243912432,
0.0398309864,
0.0249907672,
0.0063382606,
-0.0639808923,
-0.0269362535,
0.0648791641,
-0.0185782015,
0.0372663625,
0.0787333176,
-0.014214946,
-0.0256180502,
-0.0219838563,
-0.0700891316,
0.0960552022,
0.0209073853,
-0.0527921394,
-0.046164915,
0.0407529436,
-0.0430016555,
-0.071937792,
0.0444327146,
0.0125619723,
0.0246561784,
-0.006993684,
-0.0363821015,
-0.0252705757,
0.0132766142,
-0.0390357934,
-0.0072036916,
0.0431520604,
0.011864638,
0.0327100977,
-0.0177929755,
0.022210855,
0.0071284999,
-0.0412320234,
-0.0392623581,
0.0291115344,
-0.0217761919,
0.0084968917,
-0.0947363898,
0.071532622,
-0.0088216951,
-0.0116134314,
-0.0503706373,
0.0171268247,
0.0193750318,
-0.0046926034,
0.0395842046,
-0.011314705,
0.0021309508,
0.0591667071,
0.0045521283,
0.0364511758,
-0.025254786,
-0.0084662437,
-0.0069707385,
-0.0201882925,
-0.0072254743,
0.0531811938,
0.048817724,
-0.0516192354,
-0.0096039921,
0.02174679,
0.0123629132,
-0.0073935227,
-0.0306392945,
-0.0370866992,
-0.0210653022,
-0.0013502646,
-0.0248584207,
-0.0444179922,
-0.026339082,
0.0337419584,
0.0268288124,
0.0277223662,
-0.0250679795,
0.0197304133,
0.0115842894,
0.0001862066,
-0.0309352409,
-0.0181109216,
-0.0490220822,
-0.0135013824,
0.0279129744,
0.0404982492,
-0.0033113507,
0.0219225474,
0.0025008742,
0.0247730594,
-0.0234244578,
0.0194264743,
-0.0351962149,
-0.0332750119,
0.0152830277,
-0.0237872899,
-0.0193092283,
-0.0325240605,
0.0349427536,
0.076832734,
-0.0284927897,
-0.013039236,
-0.0601271652,
0.0139417723,
0.0374083929,
0.0110998899,
0.0805244222,
0.0247025359,
0.0175405238,
0.0626049638,
0.0064991,
-0.0430032499,
-0.0463206656,
-0.0082232468,
-0.0081926426,
0.0184498765,
0.0276344344,
-0.0414071344,
-0.0108242054,
-0.0056219948,
0.0128933927,
-0.0636746287,
0.009224087,
0.0016285098,
-0.0170142725,
0.000785806,
0.0019236762,
-0.0408207364,
-0.0350155123,
-0.0152252605,
-0.0050389925,
0.0109191248,
-0.0066237422,
-0.0334958732,
-0.0185292028,
0.0094982842,
0.0587676466,
0.0344952233,
0.014041516,
-0.0121679651,
0.0149431657,
-0.026275361,
0.0076451008,
0.0297905002,
0.0012031508,
0.024627395,
-0.0042456281,
0.0224267766,
-0.0000620095,
0.0672990978,
0.0239447653,
0.0415465534,
0.0502397008,
-0.0401009247,
-0.0048408792,
0.0038470898,
0.0740944296,
0.0266323183,
-0.0090161841,
0.0415254906,
0.0180625096,
-0.0281017292,
-0.0082034031,
0.0235810801,
-0.0225593522,
-0.0819318518,
0.0424299017,
0.0102043878,
-0.0153955584,
-0.080901742,
-0.0380547605,
-0.035825748,
0.0430096462,
-0.033536803,
0.0970274881,
-0.0173878651,
0.0335326716,
0.0610866435,
-0.0138080539,
-0.0356039777,
0.0864152014,
0.0131973345,
0.0111331744,
-0.0603130162,
-0.0459791012,
0.0274577513,
-0.0143133923,
-0.0267619118,
-0.0103716394,
-0.0294841193,
-0.0505474731,
0.0214830246,
0.0060228673,
0.0143281668,
-0.0125779454,
-0.0462595522,
-0.0058525656,
-0.0216475762,
0.0702597871,
-0.0056863786,
0.0448929928,
0.0056110402,
-0.0046168575,
0.0028977613,
-0.0211964678,
0.0045586661,
0.0106735639,
0.0349293649,
0.0203797687,
-0.0517670959,
-0.0209165588,
-0.0068950714,
-0.058050666,
0.0277983155,
0.0165322348,
-0.0102990707,
-0.0181877967,
0.0211507045,
-0.0310295485,
0.0107661225,
0.0231761355,
-0.020464519,
0.0340927541,
-0.055358652,
0.0152375968,
0.0276540406,
0.0109099494,
-0.0240625124,
-0.006901456,
0.005623586,
0.0232609082,
-0.0032794133,
0.0253494009,
0.0124375867,
-0.000967772,
-0.0272223931,
0.0456673913,
0.1018677205,
-0.0220457446,
-0.0234000329,
-0.0100429226,
-0.0192946121,
-0.0244202837,
0.0139927585,
0.0242232997,
-0.0479455292,
0.0052351388,
0.0449776798,
-0.0073579312,
0.000035654,
0.0540565588,
-0.0318433903,
0.0086853709,
-0.0486089662,
-0.0063186828,
-0.0674000457,
0.0268162601,
-0.0145186242,
0.0415786356,
0.033062689,
-0.076047428,
0.0602816567,
-0.0032237337,
0.0677500442,
0.0126168234,
-0.0086374618,
-0.0271735154,
0.0597053953,
-0.0280819293,
-0.0788057446,
-0.0223349594,
-0.0018056481,
-0.0276412833,
-0.0119651733,
0.0272142533,
0.0055058971,
0.0368346199,
0.0019230067,
-0.0512510464,
0.0138330879,
0.0265785661,
0.014420189,
0.0215872247,
0.0345338359,
-0.0640051886,
-0.0025630442,
-0.0499103628,
0.0356303602,
0.0276438557,
0.0657824054,
0.0361362621,
0.0339223035,
-0.0279664882,
0.0379383415,
0.0051952554,
-0.0489100441,
-0.043292053,
0.0121114627,
-0.0197391883,
-0.0153264962,
-0.0103108799,
0.1056276932,
0.0746211559,
-0.0440656692,
0.0312359948,
-0.0309362914,
-0.0520100482,
0.0422443524,
0.0258635655,
-0.1263255328,
-0.0322844982,
0.0227954853,
-0.0149223199,
-0.0280855801,
-0.0238286089,
0.0499551184,
-0.1015949473,
0.0267393626,
-0.0079263803,
0.0251553748,
0.0071149617,
-0.0400815755,
-0.0244994462,
-0.0472803116,
-0.0695131198,
0.0552602746,
-0.03579529,
0.0038123005,
0.0307408608,
-0.007429257,
0.0219029821,
-0.017495174,
-0.0021656102,
-0.0207193829,
0.0405949503,
0.0624843352,
-0.004139218,
-0.0039400007,
0.045312196,
-0.0225533545,
-0.0117589496,
-0.0561064295,
-0.0341821462,
0.0160375889,
-0.0279249419,
-0.0397130623,
0.0108114425,
-0.0393761322,
0.0063890968,
0.0277978312,
0.0513235852,
0.0353917517,
0.0075993254,
0.0008717151,
-0.014815418,
0.0082466854,
0.0377662219,
0.0096667875,
0.0308771767,
-0.0664258003,
-0.0640801266,
-0.0508420244,
-0.0089255599,
-0.0127630476,
-0.0221307855,
0.0215268955,
-0.0197864268,
-0.0880091116,
0.0341464169,
0.0552004725,
0.0469278246,
-0.037006624,
-0.0038134758,
0.0405438095,
-0.0247457381,
-0.0328960046,
-0.0104400963,
-0.0380472876,
0.0402994417,
-0.0521082506,
0.015206459,
0.0339722559,
0.0700365454,
-0.0298836716,
0.0212817527,
-0.0121262716,
-0.0526210107,
0.0424011312,
0.0472841747,
0.0223683417,
-0.0345727056,
-0.0231997967,
0.0406649821,
-0.0571750738,
0.0525808893,
-0.0080330027,
0.0245718881,
0.0187262893,
0.019399846,
0.0203121267,
0.0006063482,
0.0720691159,
0.0126905618,
-0.0070370929,
0.0699909255,
-0.0786951706,
0.0111179557,
0.0581533648,
0.0880289599,
0.0006364662,
0.0175411478,
-0.0186084453,
0.0502411239,
-0.0145005761,
-0.0664894357,
-0.01646371,
-0.0403476097,
0.0260196012,
-0.0285112038,
-0.0004068071,
-0.0277019925,
0.0000693364,
-0.0319776684,
-0.0147415781,
-0.0038624008,
0.089508757,
0.0087205069,
0.0158820711,
0.0006496497,
-0.0104125226,
0.0081757326,
-0.0287415665,
-0.0006514101,
0.0517357327,
-0.0388535038,
-0.0332620442,
0.0161931124,
0.0450638756,
-0.0525335819,
-0.0148414439,
-0.0168698262,
0.0847819448,
0.0146300728,
0.0464105718,
0.0422520861,
-0.0219758712,
0.0719576254,
-0.0233659651,
-0.0010521942,
0.0146291498,
0.0189419799,
0.0016142481,
-0.0274947714,
-0.0114479577,
0.0292496122,
-0.0276659764,
-0.0039303284,
0.0878761858,
-0.015744064,
0.0319507979,
0.0459198728,
-0.036957521,
-0.0669479966,
-0.0476341806,
0.0018613397,
0.0149155855,
-0.0132901398,
0.0167088732,
-0.0171957687,
-0.0806178153,
-0.0256034117,
0.0174310673,
0.0740289614,
-0.022086734,
0.0433868095,
0.0378485322,
0.053716749,
-0.0485168323,
-0.0048525007,
0.0183200128,
-0.0316211954,
-0.0678705201,
0.0029804909,
-6.129915043e-33,
-0.0456108674,
0.0030822349,
-0.00738092,
0.0259735957,
-0.0020213106,
-0.0067195399,
-0.0361115076,
0.0451272428,
0.0399023257,
0.0034288953,
-0.0112792337,
0.0180278663,
0.0211795196,
-0.0179186668,
-0.0316156298,
0.0068834927,
0.0078052073,
-0.017429892,
0.0005163091,
-0.010842381,
0.0246090256,
-0.0046279179,
0.0192824267,
-0.0070435796,
-0.0148525815,
0.0058055338,
-0.0504242517,
0.0311456416,
-0.0424042381,
0.0473732315,
0.0020300706,
-0.0334560275,
0.0042029032,
-0.0169267617,
0.0078850295,
-0.0127868187,
-0.088306427,
-0.0469498374,
0.0380339138,
-0.0242455807,
0.0263998527,
-0.0309749898,
0.0023138686,
-0.0072500077,
-0.0349345915,
0.072864309,
-0.0292760581,
0.0047304877,
-0.0246661156,
-0.0366555899,
-0.0555415861,
0.0237191208,
-0.0253522024,
0.0097685652,
0.0474180356,
-0.032400012,
-0.0179215632,
0.0106640719,
0.0399803668,
-0.0180135164,
-0.0020739373,
0.0393050611,
-0.0217247903,
-0.0321731158,
-0.0192365889,
0.0041822162,
0.0408434384,
-0.0149617549,
0.0063572805,
0.0946201086,
-0.0258933436,
0.0134494817,
-0.0180261582,
-0.0193238426,
0.0790413991,
-0.0074873436,
-0.0809759125,
0.0118959686,
0.0320052542,
0.053302668,
0.0007412154,
0.0029121167,
-0.0360896476,
-0.0345953628,
0.0083816564,
-0.0086557725,
-0.0287189931,
0.0381398872,
-0.0127156638,
0.0174231175,
-0.0601946265,
0.0437658615,
0.0106283696,
-0.0344904624,
-0.021748364,
-0.0234877728,
0.0190044828,
0.011308074,
-0.0224645082,
0.0087422058,
0.0331576467,
-0.0402831845,
-0.0128688309,
-0.0196574349,
0.048349198,
-0.0150562944,
0.0314169675,
0.0110202515,
-0.035744261,
-0.0111482767,
-0.0571507253,
0.021516541,
-0.0521602295,
0.0781941712,
0.0218328144,
0.0363928862,
0.0046482123,
-0.0500819683,
-0.0077998373,
-0.0204686169,
-0.0111427708,
-0.0370946378,
0.0203458536,
0.0540942773,
-0.0385210402,
-0.0582833849,
0.0182781108,
0.0014282442,
0.0425130166,
-0.0186661575,
-0.0479694046,
0.0257588774,
2.968e-7,
0.0335479602,
0.0425539985,
0.0989107117,
0.03041129,
0.0150259966,
-0.0222067721,
0.0183782671,
0.0390123129,
-0.0157609507,
0.0365201384,
-0.019774491,
0.0145895435,
-0.0161719397,
-0.0109386779,
-0.0710674226,
0.0156078022,
0.0037009115,
-0.0957300514,
-0.0271926206,
0.0311828982,
0.0417543612,
0.040846128,
-0.0105832871,
-0.0160284247,
-0.0056609656,
-0.0169578549,
-0.0106727621,
0.0452146605,
0.0355313048,
0.0031273409,
0.0495370217,
0.0079867439,
0.0119372774,
0.0056750914,
0.0190341827,
0.0007111089,
-0.0270612109,
0.0503868982,
-0.0302978382,
0.0626488253,
0.0445352159,
-0.0374040157,
0.0205560364,
0.0637934878,
0.0630805716,
0.0198828597,
-0.0313461311,
-0.0161256511,
-0.0273744501,
-0.0041161184,
-0.0715035573,
0.0583401471,
-0.0142758265,
0.0299439933,
0.0582636222,
-0.0367118157,
-0.043072015,
-0.0469628088,
-0.0533813126,
0.0343121253,
-0.0351687111,
-0.0079881512,
0.0217067823,
0.0847886577,
0.0023920925,
-0.0253716037,
-0.0183220096,
2.993552944e-34,
0.0393670239,
0.0045183185,
0.0279478766,
0.0411138386,
0.0242332574,
0.0069626812,
-0.0210043564,
-0.0088425539,
-0.0126681812,
-0.0701891407,
-0.0113130715
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.02971v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.02971v1 | On the Cultural Gap in Text-to-Image Generation | 2023-07-06T13:17:55 | 2023-07-06T13:17:55 | Bingshuai Liu, Longyue Wang, Chenyang Lyu, Yong Zhang, Jinsong Su, Shuming Shi, Zhaopeng Tu | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | One challenge in text-to-image (T2I) generation is the inadvertent reflection
of culture gaps present in the training data, which signifies the disparity in
generated image quality when the cultural elements of the input text are rarely
collected in the training set. Although various T2I models have shown
impressive but arbitrary examples, there is no benchmark to systematically
evaluate a T2I model's ability to generate cross-cultural images. To bridge the
gap, we propose a Challenging Cross-Cultural (C3) benchmark with comprehensive
evaluation criteria, which can assess how well-suited a model is to a target
culture. By analyzing the flawed images generated by the Stable Diffusion model
on the C3 benchmark, we find that the model often fails to generate certain
cultural objects. Accordingly, we propose a novel multi-modal metric that
considers object-text alignment to filter the fine-tuning data in the target
culture, which is used to fine-tune a T2I model to improve cross-cultural
generation. Experimental results show that our multi-modal metric provides
stronger data selection performance on the C3 benchmark than existing metrics,
in which the object-text alignment is crucial. We release the benchmark, data,
code, and generated images to facilitate future research on culturally diverse
T2I generation (https://github.com/longyuewangdcu/C3-Bench). | [
-0.0046891649,
0.0786006674,
0.0170878768,
0.0278575942,
-0.0172086228,
0.0260068048,
0.0439150445,
0.0288368929,
-0.0293142386,
0.0191098526,
-0.0202515647,
-0.0894010812,
0.0529982261,
0.0202836618,
0.0416399576,
-0.0992097631,
-0.0269424263,
0.0024052137,
-0.063502647,
-0.0160571132,
0.0122245625,
0.0264949724,
0.0247005671,
0.000596529,
-0.0565717667,
-0.0326864645,
0.0274094958,
0.0291523989,
0.0505767502,
-0.0462860018,
-0.0133265518,
0.0327521078,
-0.0130894585,
0.0000697006,
0.0000023142,
-0.0206586141,
0.0061125359,
0.0127042271,
0.0597085953,
0.0306921601,
0.1112909168,
-0.042320706,
-0.051765129,
-0.0534937344,
-0.0184680186,
0.0374712832,
0.0975316316,
0.0753912553,
0.0263543595,
0.0562414527,
-0.0161004011,
-0.0270675775,
-0.0458903424,
-0.0410433076,
0.0015611717,
-0.0075159338,
0.0069798422,
0.0563388579,
-0.0312512107,
0.0233202968,
-0.0339016616,
0.0201547332,
0.0094980756,
-0.0015373622,
0.0055507622,
0.0436038114,
-0.0003705306,
-0.0377592593,
0.0158828609,
0.081090726,
-0.0175454225,
0.0122983465,
-0.0106997862,
-0.0185478926,
-0.0460502766,
0.0027383596,
-0.0092662247,
0.0098552909,
-0.0007397473,
0.0376891196,
-0.0502307601,
0.0124797402,
0.0202331748,
-0.0168750323,
0.0144166732,
-0.0351466201,
0.0324035883,
-0.0121428668,
-0.0461694486,
0.0281543434,
-0.025380997,
-0.0350821055,
0.0698458105,
-0.0085935742,
0.0279642642,
-0.009867508,
-0.0662399307,
-0.0461708903,
0.005323282,
-0.0234214328,
0.0321043804,
0.0340303294,
-0.0121007385,
0.027225554,
-0.0419251882,
0.040263664,
-0.0249561332,
0.0198502317,
-0.0662979111,
-0.0180756152,
0.0011196954,
0.0237188172,
0.0351754017,
-0.0338693969,
-0.0441189818,
-0.0390332267,
-0.0824111104,
-0.0231610984,
-0.0117116058,
-0.0186569877,
0.0194660723,
0.0121541023,
-0.0991002843,
-0.0113741783,
-0.0274509378,
0.0194657221,
-0.016534999,
-0.0058349711,
-0.0125863226,
-0.0225813463,
-0.0057015722,
0.0122046135,
0.0335739963,
-0.0270953029,
-0.0003429121,
0.0450083725,
-0.0633543804,
0.0005102705,
-0.0390378535,
0.0219089389,
-0.0440871008,
-0.0218587089,
0.0427644067,
-0.0544191897,
0.0409743488,
-0.0353814103,
0.0097987633,
-0.0334858634,
0.0083679054,
0.0081781019,
-0.010906185,
0.0111931702,
-0.0038832603,
0.0199086461,
0.0516903065,
0.010997545,
-0.0125064654,
0.040602874,
0.0486266389,
0.0295251347,
0.0420839302,
0.0109217502,
-0.0452129804,
0.0462786928,
0.0380977429,
0.0439508185,
-0.0325706825,
-0.011167218,
0.0038218021,
0.0209148694,
0.0834564865,
0.0528456978,
-0.0116892001,
-0.0094616851,
0.0805455223,
0.0245533288,
0.0096058371,
0.0363432467,
0.058911182,
0.0257364176,
-0.0409572087,
0.0248630587,
0.0182732362,
0.0484198332,
0.0245769527,
0.0447414443,
0.0334695242,
0.1003215685,
-0.0435809605,
-0.0193878226,
0.027129164,
-0.0135494908,
0.0250085797,
-0.0393695049,
0.036294274,
0.0185709279,
-0.0440055095,
0.0178922731,
-0.0027901663,
-0.0556258969,
0.0064841332,
-0.0214907043,
0.0473042615,
0.0487670898,
0.0235928092,
0.0350889526,
0.043998681,
0.0242192931,
0.0521950461,
0.0819980353,
0.0206648745,
0.0368535258,
0.0341177732,
-0.0677911565,
-0.0648520216,
0.0201928522,
-0.0231799614,
0.0341347381,
0.0093416236,
0.0832040384,
0.0238224156,
-0.0063072611,
-0.0304460619,
0.0362320356,
-0.022694312,
0.0291995648,
0.005873064,
0.0176447667,
0.0164120384,
-0.0080129597,
-0.0509110726,
-0.0255017132,
-0.0130099393,
-0.0324715264,
0.0084899208,
0.0084977839,
-0.0511393584,
-0.0132235037,
-0.0102896616,
-0.1070887223,
-0.0157267395,
0.0273359511,
-0.0216923989,
-0.0361780822,
-0.0068783071,
0.0019455482,
-0.0277576968,
-0.0321140252,
-0.0102415392,
0.0122883944,
0.0378788412,
0.000002267,
0.0556233488,
-0.0435298011,
-0.0015212327,
-0.0084901592,
0.0399890803,
-0.012817814,
-0.0136913033,
-0.0136627806,
0.0162891131,
-0.0002317506,
-0.0009921675,
0.0292564034,
0.070092015,
-0.0540616661,
-0.0290227011,
-0.0556992441,
-0.0046967878,
-0.0085166888,
-0.0361963175,
-0.0090143187,
0.0054461751,
-0.0046717362,
0.0055494332,
-0.0788356215,
0.013573207,
0.0040965183,
-0.0278973654,
0.0467063338,
-0.0318422914,
0.0335737132,
-0.0193841197,
-0.0103136217,
0.0458685905,
0.0388473384,
-0.004380709,
-0.0262393337,
-0.0474016219,
0.0479954593,
-0.0339564532,
-0.013076935,
-0.0096139601,
-0.0398406424,
-0.0060684769,
0.0405819602,
0.0597513467,
0.0595800579,
0.0366961583,
-0.0491298176,
-0.0071758642,
-0.0054903682,
-0.0237362944,
-0.0102279698,
0.0065550148,
0.0274002701,
0.0411988348,
-0.1217349172,
-0.0045948834,
0.047072202,
0.0014614614,
0.0354272015,
-0.0632610172,
0.0104387496,
-0.0329147391,
-0.0334176086,
-0.01073399,
0.0325646624,
-0.0102571258,
0.0197077487,
-0.0845457613,
-0.0597004145,
0.0575471371,
-0.0488114506,
-0.0142731387,
-0.027966829,
0.0310242455,
0.0029452252,
-0.0144082326,
-0.0075124349,
0.0742816925,
0.0199640952,
0.0300961658,
-0.0574835651,
0.0052947947,
0.0221172106,
-0.0441182777,
0.0219458677,
-0.0166504197,
-0.0210029744,
-0.0534776784,
-0.0142056514,
-0.0145027349,
0.0053785327,
0.0359197855,
-0.0166457761,
0.0182725713,
-0.0111840172,
0.0009948467,
0.0248847008,
0.0102300234,
-0.0138925351,
0.0006444477,
-0.0102335187,
0.0007321179,
0.0353895351,
0.023146661,
-0.0243610684,
-0.0297413561,
-0.0574179068,
0.0206588972,
0.0295158979,
0.0507082753,
0.005943384,
-0.015376403,
0.0192116164,
0.0058258041,
0.0877552181,
-0.0310554374,
0.0007393287,
0.1204276904,
-0.0195982382,
-0.0052307001,
0.0436602309,
-0.0266507138,
-0.0240747873,
-0.0211548414,
0.0284317397,
0.066712983,
-0.0282605123,
0.0086618103,
-0.0836982429,
-0.0019431043,
-0.022546012,
-0.0083459876,
-0.0128308982,
0.0019917148,
-0.0180340391,
-0.1030371413,
0.0469527654,
0.0497018658,
-0.0342571549,
-0.0447731912,
0.0000665229,
0.0017341241,
0.0174205378,
0.0228473675,
-0.0136421537,
0.0096298372,
-0.0025098526,
0.0133979712,
0.0159585103,
-0.0791214705,
-0.0142548922,
-0.0154812522,
0.0138724502,
0.0554429851,
0.0341562554,
0.0514733158,
-0.0689316466,
-0.0143353613,
0.0130773112,
-0.0024582446,
-0.0067340666,
0.0397495739,
0.0425435863,
-0.0355943404,
-0.0126228761,
0.0390778594,
0.0185100101,
0.0155116338,
-0.0084062368,
-0.0025134678,
0.0274269357,
-0.0099751204,
-0.0305098183,
0.0290461667,
0.0214124564,
0.0272747893,
0.020624727,
-0.0700372159,
-0.0334529877,
-0.0301402528,
0.0278392509,
-0.0849047005,
-0.0480490364,
0.032677412,
-0.0427561365,
-0.049350746,
-0.0737911239,
-0.0214792304,
-0.0310085081,
0.0455430076,
0.0038123108,
-0.0284870956,
-0.0352632962,
-0.0018597994,
-0.0257501043,
0.0164215881,
-0.041058585,
0.0343566053,
-0.0185032114,
0.0004282819,
-0.028570991,
-0.0537705012,
-0.0045233923,
0.0218339842,
-0.0901746377,
-0.016671123,
-0.0156706758,
0.0705500394,
0.005435301,
0.0256783757,
0.02447691,
-0.0184412431,
0.0543548241,
0.0096744699,
0.0337645598,
0.0124819698,
-0.0096743712,
-0.0027009926,
-0.0067744073,
0.0231587123,
-0.0457149521,
0.037794821,
0.0338621102,
0.0316018835,
-0.0011828709,
0.0255830977,
-0.0050886315,
-0.0250629559,
-0.0259224754,
-0.058426708,
-0.0024390798,
-0.0336249098,
-0.0175861493,
-0.0132923769,
-0.0241447221,
-0.0630558059,
-0.0216262639,
0.0390463732,
0.0030364993,
0.0263482295,
-0.0014941975,
0.0241947025,
0.033967752,
-0.0419908836,
0.0027619435,
0.0199382771,
0.0621217936,
0.0056637051,
0.0287912842,
-0.0105018904,
0.0222182292,
-0.0170976147,
0.0359459519,
-0.0058967387,
0.0806101859,
0.0000669201,
-0.007327802,
0.0125309918,
0.026907336,
0.006185763,
0.0310375504,
-0.0593091436,
0.0172646493,
0.0729405656,
-0.0312370416,
0.1229763702,
0.0036819295,
-0.000776065,
-0.0145213278,
0.0350992754,
0.015334229,
-0.0243482757,
-0.0073510744,
-0.0191177223,
0.0151613411,
-0.0130891008,
0.0703895092,
-0.0340722948,
-0.0244667474,
-0.0180420522,
-0.0074148676,
-0.0250800606,
-0.0089533795,
0.0385339186,
-0.0429383144,
0.0064630508,
0.0097511047,
-0.0302715655,
-0.0443623699,
0.0053669563,
0.0200661533,
-0.011730249,
0.0158439819,
0.0326763578,
0.0513393022,
-0.0344989114,
0.029185012,
-0.0267268382,
-0.0381901376,
-0.0213018097,
-0.0135004586,
-0.0049359812,
-6.305520675e-33,
-0.0620052516,
-0.005424601,
-0.0199207366,
-0.0331059434,
-0.0431776755,
-0.0059232432,
-0.0444508493,
-0.0099402489,
-0.0095544364,
0.0121037075,
0.017556807,
-0.0182768945,
0.0140415123,
0.0536307842,
-0.0494720638,
0.0667926148,
0.0352271087,
-0.0142682232,
-0.0452701449,
0.0242107864,
0.0232450757,
0.0242456868,
0.0293880664,
-0.0769975632,
-0.0244934838,
0.0035913256,
-0.0215501208,
-0.0448344685,
0.074301064,
0.042016793,
-0.0134818433,
0.0182503164,
-0.00184781,
-0.0173646417,
-0.0130088255,
-0.0111317923,
-0.0413059592,
-0.0053515397,
-0.0563424565,
0.0197004564,
-0.0267708935,
-0.0394915454,
0.0362488069,
-0.0347568467,
-0.0392141342,
-0.0338930599,
0.0585103296,
-0.0588643663,
-0.0180925969,
-0.0128568718,
-0.0571388826,
0.0346212797,
-0.0343449637,
-0.016258508,
0.0012048753,
0.0540590249,
0.0113447765,
0.0316759534,
-0.0552689582,
0.0240405053,
0.0237578321,
0.0273740347,
0.0511983782,
0.0524530225,
0.0256243143,
0.0528389327,
0.0403858535,
0.0279858839,
0.0349200182,
-0.0225486383,
0.0364584699,
0.0404305868,
0.0156231951,
0.0886834785,
0.0382299609,
-0.0139191095,
-0.0603591874,
0.0694950446,
-0.0409366861,
-0.0200567916,
0.0169374198,
0.0095520793,
0.0068331552,
0.0190403294,
-0.0185031034,
-0.0424128324,
-0.0256419014,
-0.0460483432,
0.0238125883,
0.0150284013,
-0.0404973365,
-0.0111382073,
0.0448848717,
0.0108881965,
-0.0013539189,
-0.0249169189,
-0.0653288364,
0.0262326505,
-0.010489706,
-0.0179637019,
-0.0385940261,
-0.0792857558,
0.0382202975,
0.0578882359,
-0.0043362156,
0.0042283521,
0.0252960958,
-0.0049771466,
-0.0499223545,
-0.0119124716,
-0.0281381253,
0.0064142062,
0.0183413997,
0.0271081645,
0.022256203,
-0.0470240563,
-0.0394483022,
0.0092501575,
0.0138459262,
0.0155236265,
-0.0110687977,
-0.0518073402,
-0.0059361458,
0.0205530114,
-0.0434997901,
0.0297338497,
-0.0433903672,
0.0053583742,
0.0630934313,
-0.0625690296,
-0.0442304984,
0.007074506,
2.816e-7,
0.0214159172,
-0.0007154462,
-0.0190448463,
0.0219726469,
-0.0063579851,
0.0272817817,
-0.0426012427,
0.0244700741,
0.0127911717,
-0.0347652845,
0.0031986753,
0.0293539558,
0.0887411609,
0.0168504659,
-0.0242999122,
0.0198770761,
-0.0338173993,
0.0399490073,
-0.0187656209,
0.0208049435,
-0.0085570635,
0.0547408164,
-0.043396797,
-0.0402527563,
0.037662264,
-0.024138527,
0.1100769788,
-0.0342070013,
-0.0033920265,
-0.0034558091,
-0.0259600077,
-0.0415903814,
-0.0302789342,
-0.0066985423,
-0.0205621459,
-0.0053511835,
0.0822115242,
0.0444926098,
-0.0104904426,
0.0093931826,
0.0133214593,
0.0435208715,
-0.0188635178,
-0.0388402194,
0.0447366014,
-0.0097791143,
-0.0181945711,
-0.0236195736,
-0.000332005,
0.0304148942,
0.0526320487,
-0.050371509,
-0.0499921814,
0.0225309301,
0.0528648496,
0.0228512343,
-0.012401145,
-0.0082654897,
-0.0520267971,
-0.0454515219,
-0.0042272368,
-0.035763301,
-0.071224913,
0.0060168877,
0.0128357783,
0.048101265,
-0.0210314263,
2.515473652e-34,
-0.0020312401,
-0.0267601442,
0.0025160715,
-0.0384799093,
0.0216566827,
-0.015606883,
0.0198480655,
-0.0115577206,
-0.0267243441,
-0.0136880344,
-0.0122438082
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.04821v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.04821v1 | Amplifying Limitations, Harms and Risks of Large Language Models | 2023-07-06T11:53:45 | 2023-07-06T11:53:45 | Michael O'Neill, Mark Connor | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | We present this article as a small gesture in an attempt to counter what
appears to be exponentially growing hype around Artificial Intelligence (AI)
and its capabilities, and the distraction provided by the associated talk of
science-fiction scenarios that might arise if AI should become sentient and
super-intelligent. It may also help those outside of the field to become more
informed about some of the limitations of AI technology. In the current context
of popular discourse AI defaults to mean foundation and large language models
(LLMs) such as those used to create ChatGPT. This in itself is a
misrepresentation of the diversity, depth and volume of research, researchers,
and technology that truly represents the field of AI. AI being a field of
research that has existed in software artefacts since at least the 1950's. We
set out to highlight a number of limitations of LLMs, and in so doing highlight
that harms have already arisen and will continue to arise due to these
limitations. Along the way we also highlight some of the associated risks for
individuals and organisations in using this technology. | [
0.0502553508,
0.0505019128,
-0.0463232733,
0.0207539443,
-0.0700931028,
0.0037331996,
0.0130222533,
0.0132294279,
0.0673101097,
-0.0439695753,
-0.0053934944,
-0.0139078507,
-0.0304905698,
0.0560402274,
0.0168640539,
-0.0416464396,
0.0426598005,
-0.0384731889,
0.0152509771,
-0.0224980637,
0.0121302838,
0.0157994088,
0.0198263321,
0.0622320995,
-0.0413336456,
-0.033003781,
0.001240889,
-0.020483816,
-0.0356066637,
0.0058349129,
-0.0272501018,
0.0206984133,
0.0189859048,
0.0567246936,
0.0000020958,
-0.0437566005,
0.0051034992,
0.0293208677,
-0.0689338222,
0.0118822707,
0.0440969095,
0.0478856675,
-0.0268100835,
0.008008807,
-0.0471667908,
0.0497651137,
0.058341831,
0.0017769553,
0.0348887816,
0.0624002703,
-0.0160033852,
-0.0073016589,
0.0663630292,
0.0087419888,
-0.0112238703,
-0.0548415408,
0.0441279933,
0.0230691861,
0.0499305129,
0.0223809537,
0.0118593024,
0.0658831,
0.0236601755,
-0.0321267173,
-0.0365991555,
0.0315854624,
-0.046823848,
-0.0642240569,
-0.0182504114,
0.0052416986,
0.023818763,
-0.0182611737,
0.0089115957,
0.0101395417,
-0.009478814,
-0.033012677,
-0.0311942436,
0.0576651394,
-0.0269644484,
-0.007718537,
0.0415505506,
-0.0139130969,
0.0301433522,
0.0219291542,
-0.011103861,
0.0591173321,
0.0004231567,
-0.0261210408,
0.0011261159,
0.0061833519,
-0.0016854237,
-0.0367710516,
-0.0157794226,
0.0261907205,
-0.019062832,
0.0230420474,
-0.0394410491,
0.0166413486,
0.0313683935,
-0.080490157,
0.0004640776,
0.0259730928,
0.0109224422,
0.023940634,
0.0540999919,
0.0415600352,
-0.0605053231,
0.0238570087,
-0.0129106343,
0.0154767325,
-0.0604412816,
-0.0465365797,
-0.0710557103,
0.0502350181,
-0.0180074088,
-0.0162470993,
0.0053949016,
0.0624242686,
-0.025875818,
0.0100648683,
-0.0263360217,
-0.0163414218,
-0.0198890641,
-0.0085088341,
-0.004335959,
-0.0135275265,
-0.0208631735,
0.0049302191,
0.0004264181,
-0.1314496249,
0.0388856716,
0.0111046443,
-0.0419639498,
-0.0067302985,
-0.0012006019,
0.1250986159,
0.0204340015,
-0.0196591392,
-0.030312622,
-0.0240763593,
-0.0236433018,
-0.0618042462,
0.0106857978,
-0.0442205817,
-0.0093099708,
0.0225936491,
-0.0226774514,
-0.0477393903,
-0.0036656503,
-0.0111742616,
-0.0593774095,
0.0483361371,
-0.0668255836,
0.0208573304,
0.0330774151,
0.0402164422,
-0.0068867495,
0.0443610065,
0.0471284874,
0.0306595247,
0.0514205769,
-0.0087237339,
0.0571308397,
0.0480534695,
-0.040121574,
0.0211357847,
-0.0079440223,
0.0159794241,
-0.0189973526,
-0.0066090222,
-0.0493452847,
0.0959238708,
-0.004005502,
0.0062102717,
0.0504629761,
0.0565653481,
-0.0220851973,
0.0791963935,
0.0453459695,
0.0162696522,
0.0231392384,
-0.0024422049,
-0.035773851,
-0.0154110081,
-0.0348602161,
-0.0118930051,
-0.0202225316,
0.022409467,
-0.0288195293,
-0.0384883024,
-0.0005712225,
-0.0253081247,
0.035882473,
0.0084361611,
0.0439425632,
-0.0195391607,
0.0085530039,
-0.0220716614,
0.009205115,
-0.0330426469,
-0.0207088683,
-0.1284145564,
-0.0031740377,
0.0712303147,
0.0619228929,
-0.0500492789,
-0.0205786284,
0.0006642531,
-0.0100550633,
0.0502215847,
0.0487724878,
0.0060726288,
-0.0339558199,
-0.0078630773,
0.0164453872,
0.0177975148,
-0.014519671,
0.0099622551,
-0.0314714387,
0.0206069723,
-0.0313229561,
0.0244929437,
-0.0326350071,
-0.0005594216,
-0.0389815494,
-0.0231983624,
-0.054755304,
-0.007733434,
0.0339727029,
0.0293775592,
-0.0512195751,
0.0226022881,
0.0452221408,
-0.0053073564,
-0.0390380211,
-0.0056475769,
-0.0072035422,
0.0965925381,
0.0298107322,
-0.044980336,
0.0102920476,
0.0124983368,
0.015023049,
-0.0200911723,
0.0386521295,
-0.0520893,
0.0816688836,
0.0040442566,
0.0379219279,
-0.0481394418,
-0.0022929308,
-0.0487790853,
0.0259185396,
0.0018856181,
-0.0351432301,
-0.0089483997,
-0.0095704803,
0.0268299803,
-0.0382619128,
-0.0373830535,
0.0540658273,
0.018229397,
0.0521988682,
0.0648838356,
0.0039808173,
-0.0156852696,
-0.0238579866,
-0.1023009345,
-0.033912763,
0.0157077704,
0.0080724461,
-0.0047268593,
0.0036181055,
-0.0250634253,
-0.001360688,
-0.014342864,
0.0088874735,
0.0092617245,
0.0446732678,
0.0180957653,
0.012141834,
-0.0595692694,
-0.0309507307,
-0.024594212,
-0.0314541496,
0.012073908,
0.0301412623,
-0.0732995942,
-0.0489586443,
0.0548535436,
-0.0286087561,
0.0238389876,
-0.0208509192,
-0.0378435627,
0.0449524261,
-0.026029557,
0.0036180096,
0.038709648,
-0.0173294768,
0.0683107674,
0.0342133045,
0.007758317,
-0.0019186726,
-0.0011322715,
0.0208845846,
-0.0327706262,
-0.0181223657,
-0.0095789516,
-0.0209806897,
0.0188327413,
0.0026214269,
0.0032213284,
-0.0294278376,
0.066088967,
-0.0443838723,
-0.0391465798,
-0.0095007941,
-0.0569184497,
-0.0321261808,
0.0369814672,
-0.0115244845,
-0.0753786489,
0.0517146736,
-0.0206307825,
0.0015169322,
-0.0278116893,
-0.0447511934,
-0.0105826287,
0.094238162,
0.0063160518,
0.0370525569,
0.0289306585,
-0.0262184497,
-0.0428895392,
-0.0130316643,
-0.0161296185,
-0.0292314813,
0.0281163231,
-0.0500258468,
0.0495927148,
-0.0073354752,
-0.0516190268,
-0.0223805942,
-0.0399117805,
-0.0477200747,
0.0106182816,
0.0336108431,
-0.0231228285,
-0.0360898413,
-0.002803582,
0.0455238409,
0.0204477888,
0.0099856295,
-0.0086511467,
-0.0123572508,
-0.0281792413,
0.0045156199,
-0.030077178,
0.0323181301,
0.008826931,
0.0402543284,
0.0347034261,
-0.0018467184,
0.0058094058,
-0.0083052032,
-0.0032482073,
0.0226724613,
-0.0210785475,
-0.0534442775,
0.0132070435,
0.0354785025,
-0.0564147606,
-0.0230773278,
0.0757461041,
0.0087580215,
-0.0469507724,
0.0374184884,
-0.0128618181,
-0.018343579,
0.0243368391,
0.0320916362,
-0.0979411006,
0.0279077459,
0.0073457514,
0.0007515998,
-0.0466398597,
-0.0286631361,
0.001931214,
-0.057542935,
0.0641392022,
0.0181499235,
-0.0497051254,
-0.022210408,
0.0002123286,
-0.050987944,
0.0074073225,
0.0368681587,
0.0068233013,
-0.0083452165,
-0.0125411237,
0.0143918861,
-0.0628248453,
0.0032857652,
0.0284085255,
-0.021016432,
0.0823963434,
0.0834451467,
0.0321607813,
-0.0458698533,
0.010551787,
0.015476916,
0.0395557024,
0.0169057921,
0.0183061622,
0.0251602251,
0.0315210186,
-0.0215056688,
-0.0417908654,
-0.017921526,
-0.010071557,
0.0018246357,
0.0360992253,
0.0794531778,
-0.0551468655,
-0.0446281657,
-0.0311580226,
-0.039378576,
-0.003529524,
0.0437878184,
-0.0103345187,
-0.038029436,
-0.0398783498,
-0.0350303948,
0.0041577322,
0.0366467163,
-0.0672333464,
0.0283293296,
0.0050336821,
-0.0346682109,
-0.0271207783,
-0.0550238267,
-0.0125029329,
0.0121718561,
0.0506222658,
-0.0118343569,
0.0246624909,
0.0239079446,
-0.00822894,
0.0032503167,
-0.0363786183,
-0.0009604844,
-0.0538362712,
0.0227203071,
0.0156860203,
-0.0173708797,
0.0267038438,
-0.0260308478,
-0.0291833766,
-0.0681883544,
0.0445061401,
0.0599754676,
0.0428905562,
-0.0077955751,
-0.0035012593,
-0.058654353,
0.037167307,
0.018780319,
-0.0391140208,
0.0252135433,
0.0223124623,
0.001618162,
0.0123486351,
0.0231818054,
-0.0459134094,
0.0276380349,
-0.0189383663,
-0.0134999556,
-0.0501381457,
-0.0212465785,
0.0337486304,
0.0720763206,
-0.0288632121,
-0.0172117818,
0.0283238031,
0.0108784614,
-0.0174328294,
-0.0459739827,
-0.0109058293,
-0.0374373831,
-0.0043793302,
-0.0048051542,
0.0260059852,
0.0115516074,
-0.0262305923,
-0.046380613,
-0.0063771522,
0.0083836047,
0.0613841787,
-0.0048995744,
0.0671159998,
0.037670128,
0.0020933973,
-0.0206744354,
0.0656514093,
-0.0448019505,
0.0268136449,
-0.0046539041,
0.0507020615,
-0.0037404154,
-0.0029242071,
0.018537797,
0.0572793372,
-0.0606183223,
-0.1259110719,
0.030697247,
0.08767277,
0.0370182097,
0.0438033603,
0.013080827,
-0.0437740795,
0.0054832227,
-0.0312167127,
-0.0018879577,
0.0245313775,
-0.04004566,
-0.0265878718,
0.0273777321,
-0.0499588288,
-0.0065122582,
0.0700875074,
-0.0230131764,
0.0529051498,
0.0260526463,
-0.0219021309,
-0.03103102,
-0.0610254556,
-0.0029714035,
-0.0193180796,
0.00513124,
-0.0089121144,
-0.0750543475,
-0.0717048272,
-0.0306288917,
0.0212239455,
0.0259786677,
-0.04693041,
0.0156972241,
0.0485581011,
0.0259762611,
-0.018182762,
-0.0411225334,
-0.0000680702,
-0.055641979,
0.004054151,
0.003274081,
-6.109800498e-33,
0.0026103759,
-0.0136980359,
0.0348243602,
0.0295870081,
-0.0447305627,
0.0128709786,
-0.02043516,
0.0328704156,
-0.0518692471,
0.0203132369,
-0.0440342724,
0.0028748016,
0.0100752218,
-0.0218414087,
0.0242394563,
0.014997093,
0.0206908081,
-0.0120524317,
0.0251793507,
0.0367294289,
0.0172406305,
-0.0159591231,
0.0174097829,
-0.0833461285,
0.0453706235,
-0.0182374902,
-0.0083989678,
0.0133967893,
-0.0028609294,
0.041252356,
-0.0039385059,
0.0596773252,
0.0194553193,
-0.0206595547,
-0.0039151441,
0.0375260822,
0.0051421733,
-0.005862793,
0.0096327579,
0.017346533,
0.0296925809,
-0.0585068837,
0.0334493592,
-0.0372771248,
-0.042293448,
0.043976441,
0.001019259,
-0.0348484516,
-0.0089515671,
-0.0017144146,
-0.0753567293,
0.0115222735,
-0.0201068446,
0.019030802,
0.0118800728,
-0.0091033848,
-0.02453834,
-0.0304788556,
-0.0159669016,
0.0213192645,
0.0087709455,
-0.0175906513,
0.0454715267,
-0.0128448503,
0.018293364,
0.0349741541,
0.0490817092,
0.0354699418,
-0.0196183622,
-0.0282349382,
-0.0082060611,
0.052393876,
0.0221509803,
0.0200689416,
-0.0285901912,
-0.0196332298,
-0.0508994572,
-0.0219620727,
0.0511645675,
0.0156379454,
0.0235455148,
0.0163238309,
-0.0958607122,
-0.0459016785,
0.0169541668,
-0.027763566,
-0.0074637048,
-0.0420213342,
0.0191580057,
-0.0512685105,
0.0161720477,
0.012765659,
0.0004073161,
-0.0780417621,
0.0173766967,
-0.0155200446,
0.001375748,
0.0218264796,
0.0002950596,
0.0391419679,
-0.033814393,
-0.0383881852,
-0.0210261829,
0.0268163793,
0.030131992,
0.0475518815,
0.0015269567,
0.0301955044,
-0.0153980879,
-0.0065821069,
-0.0107389018,
0.0285671912,
0.0549280867,
-0.0136119099,
0.0371854641,
-0.0072338763,
0.0204391778,
0.0208297521,
0.0501534529,
0.0194834787,
-0.0361780114,
0.0088681709,
-0.0209295023,
-0.0060990918,
-0.0315311104,
-0.0175611656,
-0.0676646978,
0.0623807386,
0.0557757616,
-0.0801586881,
-0.0167387966,
-0.0217841193,
2.891e-7,
0.0060420241,
0.0557374544,
0.0457186922,
0.0102400137,
0.0222430341,
0.0435909741,
0.0064329905,
0.0406913273,
-0.0299230162,
0.0411754511,
0.0301072802,
0.0351460874,
0.0289294552,
0.0294923224,
-0.0505532399,
-0.016058106,
-0.063381806,
-0.0281313304,
-0.0796014443,
0.0280616209,
0.0460964441,
0.0760670453,
0.0252849013,
-0.0198051743,
-0.028665185,
-0.0541168116,
0.001234003,
-0.0253627561,
0.0171119273,
0.0208775029,
0.0233889837,
0.0664850175,
-0.0117402412,
0.0278556719,
0.0202300809,
-0.0025272223,
-0.021189807,
0.054902669,
-0.0390752368,
0.0147481374,
0.0386953279,
-0.065533258,
0.0015191416,
-0.0328159519,
0.0648334548,
-0.0375461876,
-0.061231751,
-0.0155149698,
-0.0048546344,
-0.0330812968,
0.0117139118,
-0.015396676,
-0.0094263721,
0.0116878059,
-0.0105606448,
-0.0433744304,
0.0258073527,
-0.0468082018,
0.0438135453,
0.0141227618,
-0.030453831,
-0.0734274536,
-0.0023309854,
0.0356137194,
0.0121135628,
-0.0317362845,
0.0309001952,
2.455962184e-34,
0.0256594121,
-0.0302694514,
0.0243381578,
0.0277643129,
0.0336128101,
0.0446144827,
0.002930826,
0.0177704375,
0.0189398415,
-0.0324593931,
-0.0372093804
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.02912v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.02912v1 | LEA: Improving Sentence Similarity Robustness to Typos Using Lexical Attention Bias | 2023-07-06T10:53:50 | 2023-07-06T10:53:50 | Mario Almagro, Emilio Almazán, Diego Ortego, David Jiménez | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Textual noise, such as typos or abbreviations, is a well-known issue that
penalizes vanilla Transformers for most downstream tasks. We show that this is
also the case for sentence similarity, a fundamental task in multiple domains,
e.g. matching, retrieval or paraphrasing. Sentence similarity can be approached
using cross-encoders, where the two sentences are concatenated in the input
allowing the model to exploit the inter-relations between them. Previous works
addressing the noise issue mainly rely on data augmentation strategies, showing
improved robustness when dealing with corrupted samples that are similar to the
ones used for training. However, all these methods still suffer from the token
distribution shift induced by typos. In this work, we propose to tackle textual
noise by equipping cross-encoders with a novel LExical-aware Attention module
(LEA) that incorporates lexical similarities between words in both sentences.
By using raw text similarities, our approach avoids the tokenization shift
problem obtaining improved robustness. We demonstrate that the attention bias
introduced by LEA helps cross-encoders to tackle complex scenarios with textual
noise, specially in domains with short-text descriptions and limited context.
Experiments using three popular Transformer encoders in five e-commerce
datasets for product matching show that LEA consistently boosts performance
under the presence of noise, while remaining competitive on the original
(clean) splits. We also evaluate our approach in two datasets for textual
entailment and paraphrasing showing that LEA is robust to typos in domains with
longer sentences and more natural context. Additionally, we thoroughly analyze
several design choices in our approach, providing insights about the impact of
the decisions made and fostering future research in cross-encoders dealing with
typos. | [
0.0508376248,
0.0373582095,
-0.0013908435,
0.0540245846,
-0.0308066215,
0.0079150451,
-0.0033994154,
0.0105923945,
-0.0236569233,
-0.0674189106,
-0.0278951693,
-0.0005363562,
0.005623111,
0.0058119376,
0.0369959399,
-0.0523413979,
0.0305097215,
0.0180724058,
-0.0365929641,
0.0246350151,
0.0525264479,
0.0217872802,
0.033785563,
0.0400364362,
-0.0019920254,
0.0051052133,
0.0242814478,
0.0376448259,
0.0387537666,
0.0127029428,
0.0521554835,
-0.0018941007,
-0.0089488421,
0.0428557731,
0.0000018781,
-0.0353074819,
-0.043764405,
-0.0086986739,
0.0089214798,
-0.0074606133,
0.0433910675,
-0.0377603918,
0.0235335995,
0.0211509131,
0.0245375745,
0.0028769381,
0.0675806776,
0.0735943466,
0.0538578331,
0.0712733194,
-0.032589037,
-0.0139856692,
0.0414148085,
-0.0313894451,
0.0166680273,
-0.0143020675,
0.0302277356,
-0.0630040243,
-0.0029684941,
0.0140000917,
-0.0146361217,
0.0500042737,
0.0104719205,
0.0188865364,
0.0195724294,
0.0160082802,
-0.032852076,
0.0009696019,
-0.0313133039,
0.0853834748,
-0.0565190539,
-0.0312514603,
0.0051852451,
-0.0071952958,
0.0134129394,
0.0075497879,
-0.0215973295,
0.0108248889,
-0.0191829838,
0.0276032109,
-0.018874703,
0.016487997,
0.0023981687,
0.0002592329,
-0.0033625627,
0.0186313689,
0.0502911545,
-0.0683031678,
-0.0194737799,
0.0290454235,
-0.0097750388,
-0.0309240725,
0.0433818437,
-0.011511785,
-0.0176154934,
-0.0186601728,
-0.0963602737,
-0.0569973066,
-0.0053674793,
-0.0516969413,
0.0031454565,
0.014738692,
-0.0380410664,
0.022393113,
-0.0276650209,
0.0804183036,
-0.017202219,
0.0730942562,
-0.0658723265,
-0.0590673797,
-0.011319234,
0.0061738677,
-0.0494470671,
0.0222450402,
-0.0387419164,
-0.0282026269,
-0.0391587019,
-0.0007686,
-0.0072927293,
-0.0105109764,
0.0119663086,
0.0001545939,
-0.0370377637,
-0.0125917112,
-0.0152949272,
0.0029918118,
-0.0101958141,
0.0311399791,
-0.0009639663,
-0.0444688238,
-0.0374477245,
0.0394035578,
0.0538407937,
-0.063507393,
0.0065022497,
0.0591766983,
-0.0078482991,
-0.0598177202,
-0.0276300851,
0.0101416539,
-0.0207468551,
-0.0130931428,
-0.0304887965,
-0.0274669286,
0.0537826382,
-0.0005255687,
0.0016742061,
-0.040428225,
0.0127490368,
0.0434309207,
-0.0771490335,
0.0940234065,
0.0041486691,
-0.0186517499,
-0.0330314226,
-0.02935596,
0.0151102683,
-0.0081408825,
0.0367252193,
0.019390244,
0.0516030788,
0.0305880625,
0.0376953743,
0.0143438764,
-0.0072501427,
-0.0139348116,
-0.0058186934,
0.0191853289,
0.0016322109,
0.0346712694,
0.0610193536,
0.07406912,
-0.0303250961,
-0.0103048785,
0.075842835,
0.0142095294,
-0.0088695176,
0.0312884115,
0.0294248033,
0.0311007369,
-0.0605288185,
0.0049213385,
-0.0461091213,
0.0133724045,
-0.017180169,
0.0190256443,
0.0608001165,
0.0179283414,
-0.0365233161,
-0.0106583461,
-0.0014609636,
-0.0363865793,
0.0143774105,
-0.0048257322,
-0.0029441784,
0.0294346567,
-0.0610014983,
0.0826857537,
0.0165930465,
-0.0666668862,
-0.0335753039,
-0.0113564711,
-0.0248488411,
0.096851483,
0.0485707633,
0.0024324441,
-0.0240090191,
-0.0398911908,
-0.0091192657,
0.0573578924,
0.0134276766,
0.0208922252,
0.0163855031,
-0.0599913485,
-0.0416951403,
-0.0299033113,
-0.0227075145,
-0.0120346034,
0.0322423838,
0.0330897346,
0.0528205261,
-0.0522865728,
0.0017914684,
0.0429143794,
0.0004987707,
-0.0085326554,
-0.0039123502,
0.022694638,
0.0221992154,
-0.0201572105,
0.0013048688,
0.0260973219,
-0.0093444362,
-0.0564875565,
-0.0445538908,
0.0298825875,
-0.023309553,
-0.0476780348,
0.0357988477,
-0.0928924531,
-0.0328818783,
0.0624947213,
-0.0236598495,
-0.0158514418,
-0.0194706731,
-0.0748799294,
0.059950687,
-0.0501418114,
0.042035576,
-0.0039741602,
0.0529712178,
-0.0272768643,
0.0518151112,
0.0101967156,
0.0097478982,
-0.0228727311,
-0.0319333412,
0.0250724237,
-0.0121124685,
-0.0259029977,
-0.0468356609,
-0.0001308307,
0.0373056829,
0.0355094001,
-0.0016301754,
-0.0180208106,
-0.0301810633,
-0.0386080854,
0.0015322873,
-0.013813708,
0.0152232647,
0.0147393802,
0.0446304716,
-0.0085312482,
-0.0229526814,
-0.0053398954,
0.0059079751,
-0.0075280489,
0.0231382921,
0.0702754557,
-0.0129124569,
-0.014416324,
-0.0350506008,
-0.0009494281,
0.0009395221,
0.0455245748,
-0.003314361,
-0.0231950022,
-0.0787878707,
0.037229903,
-0.0036351392,
0.0090076579,
0.0145143764,
-0.0315480419,
-0.0422665924,
0.0161104091,
0.0344695672,
0.0370541811,
0.0113627473,
-0.0434614681,
0.0278618298,
0.0022499992,
-0.0506909639,
0.0114800045,
-0.0001915652,
0.0054092775,
-0.0243598875,
0.0059742681,
0.0434701554,
0.0346395038,
-0.0313034728,
0.006884322,
-0.0337000526,
-0.0318186842,
0.0321825147,
-0.0116820373,
0.0007826106,
-0.0240316242,
-0.0118887974,
-0.0018747984,
-0.0579070635,
-0.0111672673,
0.0937498882,
-0.0252596606,
-0.0143075464,
-0.0656435117,
-0.003922272,
-0.0395275541,
0.0090700369,
-0.0206098258,
0.0218036212,
0.0240295473,
-0.0458869152,
-0.0359546803,
0.0048915702,
0.0243639424,
0.0015030765,
0.0641545579,
0.019620195,
0.0280620139,
-0.0105429636,
-0.0613282472,
-0.0582809336,
-0.0485830307,
-0.0060018627,
-0.0253965706,
0.0181969721,
0.0022286002,
-0.0935055539,
0.0149412639,
0.0020836452,
0.0424564853,
-0.0074064978,
-0.0063923458,
-0.0297221206,
0.0572304092,
0.0726649165,
-0.0012061164,
0.0292248446,
-0.0472453497,
-0.0233671479,
0.0320947058,
0.0090980725,
-0.0029516774,
-0.0114657199,
-0.0329788737,
0.0266110301,
-0.0511069186,
0.0009613169,
-0.0163995046,
0.0438970141,
-0.0202514045,
-0.0445623808,
0.1058937162,
0.0093020974,
-0.0500754155,
-0.0135798706,
0.0099590458,
0.0346851833,
0.0127176447,
0.0280560218,
-0.0257892888,
-0.0625869483,
0.0213846788,
0.0118730627,
0.0356604904,
-0.0046299268,
0.0100301858,
-0.1210682094,
-0.0083647752,
-0.0014103362,
-0.0263061691,
-0.1234614775,
-0.0190592054,
0.0293222535,
0.001093309,
0.0887856036,
0.0050628367,
-0.039814759,
-0.0160556752,
-0.0122491391,
0.0174468849,
-0.0641245022,
-0.0260036178,
-0.0830606073,
0.0108516673,
0.0349565372,
0.0125072943,
0.0078570927,
-0.0548900701,
0.0118279951,
-0.0157027282,
-0.0391503908,
0.0380568691,
0.0807181299,
-0.0475518927,
-0.0047700037,
0.0074504511,
-0.0058276933,
-0.0502035767,
-0.0014601921,
-0.0054258024,
0.0418248549,
0.0138550894,
-0.0090367738,
-0.0270302221,
-0.0250869449,
-0.0054561836,
0.0893238783,
0.0293726046,
-0.0005224381,
-0.0588475056,
-0.0190280098,
-0.0111328764,
-0.0511796102,
-0.0165949501,
0.0203162897,
0.0014097588,
-0.0290554352,
-0.067144163,
-0.0781660005,
-0.0020041622,
-0.0182144679,
0.0046323105,
-0.0225803554,
-0.021333009,
-0.0079260403,
-0.043331556,
0.0015935933,
-0.0499946028,
0.0311639663,
-0.0136939622,
0.0494298972,
0.0050281677,
-0.0110493088,
-0.0253354907,
0.0108147683,
-0.112942569,
-0.0455286987,
-0.0164674167,
0.010333389,
0.0032298975,
0.0800731629,
-0.0378148593,
-0.0145461177,
0.0390336029,
0.0623554736,
-0.0229339655,
-0.0006508635,
0.0328361392,
-0.0303366017,
0.0221272223,
0.048301585,
-0.0604021922,
0.0038837497,
0.0195831507,
0.0491795689,
-0.0027720202,
-0.06117782,
0.0384112969,
-0.0061028614,
0.0461973511,
-0.0133863445,
0.0313501917,
-0.0207820293,
0.0499082841,
0.0105024735,
-0.0036680233,
-0.0329651982,
-0.0002650128,
0.0069761691,
-0.0056799399,
-0.0031693294,
0.0463107079,
-0.0242041796,
0.003601939,
-0.0640392676,
-0.0043743923,
-0.0287971329,
0.0327442251,
-0.0239828657,
0.001218172,
0.0010362577,
-0.0036218055,
0.0245509595,
0.0256927442,
-0.0340399407,
-0.0218418166,
0.0419005938,
-0.0141979037,
-0.0301055703,
0.0455294959,
-0.0538303107,
0.0060895118,
-0.0476943478,
-0.0035720121,
0.0333538316,
-0.0430970192,
0.0607631169,
0.00832373,
-0.0178891011,
0.0002557719,
0.026001811,
-0.0294083375,
0.0112444069,
0.0105431927,
-0.0090640513,
-0.0113899568,
-0.0085475715,
0.0843977556,
-0.0117039653,
0.0392498635,
-0.0070247776,
-0.0466919839,
-0.0453067087,
-0.019695634,
0.0129520129,
-0.0032388547,
-0.0084372535,
-0.0067036017,
-0.0008075096,
-0.057977125,
0.0302954428,
-0.0210220981,
-0.0048085954,
0.0298130997,
0.0663323328,
0.0516053773,
0.0037750266,
-0.0092456751,
0.0030349093,
0.0029982422,
0.0532836989,
-0.0428705812,
-0.0454105362,
-6.0388697e-33,
0.0088093141,
0.031136293,
-0.0167720951,
-0.0134442309,
-0.0363114402,
0.0116750821,
-0.0326657705,
-0.0407108553,
-0.0136053842,
0.0236418452,
0.0231878646,
0.0307560917,
0.0084542362,
0.0346229225,
0.019768279,
-0.0533715822,
0.0656196475,
0.0387194902,
-0.0014857061,
-0.0018187425,
0.0029905045,
0.0493714511,
0.0732559487,
-0.0488985404,
-0.0058709774,
-0.0124517707,
0.0038665517,
-0.0059694322,
0.062250644,
0.0898304731,
-0.0038537558,
0.0604845062,
0.0118188057,
-0.0078345779,
-0.0256976429,
0.0268361513,
-0.0660772845,
-0.0042119585,
-0.0186153054,
0.0015538094,
-0.0155063244,
-0.0578621961,
0.0794365108,
-0.0232198406,
0.019348532,
0.0004212328,
0.0595059022,
-0.0214654431,
0.0115129268,
-0.0173038114,
-0.0453287885,
0.0059214858,
0.0044141985,
-0.0143303862,
0.0160334613,
0.087350443,
0.0102979736,
0.0764686465,
-0.0351123996,
0.0284633823,
-0.0259460919,
0.0488030724,
0.004506933,
-0.031314034,
-0.0430738516,
0.0469420329,
-0.0293895435,
-0.048386313,
0.0115363672,
-0.0227539614,
0.0035261598,
0.0342981108,
0.0449590795,
0.0714272112,
0.0399777144,
0.0037228984,
-0.0399935395,
0.0470516533,
-0.024457844,
0.0274221376,
0.0198981166,
0.0237590931,
-0.0516510904,
-0.0187944323,
0.0149544682,
0.0129800346,
-0.0469584614,
0.0011396387,
0.0521803387,
0.0213738568,
-0.010385925,
0.0467174947,
0.0196236167,
-0.0417519324,
-0.022849625,
-0.009606488,
0.0025397148,
-0.0063997637,
0.0224208776,
0.0021436187,
-0.0241973326,
-0.0296866372,
0.0235734582,
0.0169184543,
-0.0106907608,
-0.0106575079,
0.0772037432,
-0.0071998728,
-0.0717204586,
0.0087636122,
-0.0099651497,
-0.0196188558,
-0.0575487353,
-0.0152882161,
0.0106023559,
0.0452572815,
0.0003877725,
0.026310958,
0.0196306091,
-0.0192309543,
-0.0320750512,
-0.0016649022,
0.0369167924,
0.044805184,
0.0018502364,
0.0044804574,
-0.0580655113,
0.012660753,
0.0184751488,
-0.0746633932,
-0.0088264626,
0.0079531651,
2.699e-7,
0.0326015428,
0.047484383,
0.0578181222,
-0.0181379002,
-0.0049952385,
0.0289032217,
0.0307650752,
0.0782278106,
-0.0245935023,
0.0262043532,
0.0291030947,
0.0051321839,
0.0547588356,
-0.0296323244,
-0.0937858522,
0.0018058675,
-0.0855536088,
-0.0266579315,
-0.0498187579,
-0.029139448,
0.0567185692,
0.1098394468,
0.0311426632,
-0.0055182539,
-0.0117276143,
-0.0432287417,
0.0515217707,
-0.0430557206,
0.0044012046,
0.0196889434,
-0.0123381801,
0.021031592,
0.0140469875,
0.021163838,
-0.0098402109,
0.014450145,
0.071279712,
0.0028612241,
-0.0101468544,
-0.0346949287,
-0.0404159278,
-0.0153545868,
-0.0176095702,
-0.0710169077,
0.054811269,
-0.0363062844,
0.0307937693,
-0.0431652553,
-0.0484941602,
0.0519085824,
0.0042891288,
0.0112333782,
-0.0534670018,
0.0018126641,
0.0665809512,
0.0325829312,
-0.0403931774,
-0.0647260919,
-0.0098013673,
-0.0145207373,
-0.0139530962,
0.0128567647,
-0.0468982197,
-0.0227938872,
0.0407530516,
-0.0464813262,
0.0017997916,
2.673396726e-34,
0.0390226096,
0.0088669946,
0.0111770919,
0.0181475803,
0.0126755135,
-0.0104677752,
0.0110109001,
-0.0072743259,
-0.0202045757,
-0.0297453236,
0.0031675014
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.02910v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.02910v1 | Agentività e telicità in GilBERTo: implicazioni cognitive | 2023-07-06T10:52:22 | 2023-07-06T10:52:22 | Agnese Lombardi, Alessandro Lenci | cs.CL | cs.CL | The goal of this study is to investigate whether a Transformer-based neural
language model infers lexical semantics and use this information for the
completion of morphosyntactic patterns. The semantic properties considered are
telicity (also combined with definiteness) and agentivity. Both act at the
interface between semantics and morphosyntax: they are semantically determined
and syntactically encoded. The tasks were submitted to both the computational
model and a group of Italian native speakers. The comparison between the two
groups of data allows us to investigate to what extent neural language models
capture significant aspects of human semantic competence. | [
0.0155017478,
0.0562460646,
-0.059347894,
-0.0059346622,
-0.0169553347,
-0.0088402648,
-0.0109148826,
0.0047795419,
-0.0340938717,
-0.0178706143,
-0.0535489954,
-0.0215006024,
0.0306770671,
0.0066787759,
0.0525981449,
-0.0156994481,
0.0187677592,
-0.0221626777,
-0.0330180712,
-0.0091481879,
-0.0579597503,
-0.0131770214,
-0.020601986,
0.0311571769,
-0.010699057,
0.0232487284,
0.0074166493,
-0.059282884,
-0.024799332,
0.0548932999,
-0.0308018699,
0.0342858583,
-0.0153901428,
0.0203656759,
0.0000019213,
-0.04601698,
0.0440524332,
-0.0178013071,
0.0069805668,
-0.0214650221,
0.0608806871,
-0.0195865501,
-0.003924951,
-0.0180438869,
-0.0317514911,
0.0030705116,
0.0608166791,
-0.0234602373,
0.0062005692,
0.0322200991,
-0.0304709692,
-0.0297263432,
0.1026325822,
-0.0167793762,
-0.0199278444,
0.0354904905,
0.0278799869,
-0.0195071865,
-0.0140017541,
0.0064089629,
-0.0183188282,
0.062517859,
0.0182025284,
0.0086396644,
-0.0753301382,
0.0023687952,
0.0043302928,
-0.0323434584,
0.0254510008,
0.00045832,
0.0355565213,
-0.0273970161,
0.0102018444,
0.0541694574,
0.0105700707,
0.0801877081,
-0.0324815288,
0.033524543,
0.0286929421,
0.0065909838,
0.0333465114,
0.0079533914,
-0.0013556364,
0.0084336018,
-0.0306427702,
0.0898357779,
0.0230375119,
-0.054070577,
0.0118690068,
-0.0096639479,
-0.0068754018,
-0.0356115401,
0.0113557791,
0.0453319512,
-0.0201861877,
0.033025153,
0.0241554081,
-0.0167929903,
0.0147939734,
-0.1044306085,
0.0161787421,
0.0018321034,
-0.0169997029,
0.0050338279,
-0.0271283891,
0.0451248325,
-0.021996256,
0.0628333315,
-0.0673208535,
-0.0184412524,
-0.0580848232,
-0.0515875593,
-0.066275768,
0.0316716656,
-0.0143356398,
-0.0043113991,
-0.0342225656,
0.0409791321,
0.0090193823,
-0.0463976674,
-0.032381773,
0.0024010092,
-0.051685933,
0.0112126721,
-0.0785031021,
0.0112275565,
0.0026563406,
0.0175321363,
-0.0371733457,
-0.0610900074,
0.0269793086,
-0.0152183892,
-0.0247516725,
-0.0233875383,
-0.0149555868,
0.0419053212,
-0.0174618661,
-0.0592223927,
0.01460943,
-0.0060367915,
-0.0241823234,
-0.0394498706,
-0.0001928794,
-0.0242113359,
0.0124059217,
-0.0165936276,
-0.0063518281,
-0.0547609851,
-0.0151646808,
-0.000334247,
-0.0146908136,
0.0343496352,
0.0134235593,
0.0215348955,
0.02699662,
-0.0088251559,
0.0205087047,
0.0138335759,
0.0654614419,
0.0000277259,
-0.0086312415,
-0.0263126735,
-0.0042955284,
0.0151130995,
0.0234116595,
-0.0176825933,
-0.029196104,
-0.0355544202,
-0.0279316418,
0.0462751016,
0.0243830476,
0.0495868213,
-0.0040637818,
0.0095858499,
0.0770083368,
0.0791362077,
0.024615271,
0.0314362757,
0.0806947127,
0.0113399271,
-0.0122468276,
-0.0001842322,
-0.0200224221,
-0.0169153698,
-0.0102295829,
0.0119908489,
-0.088139683,
0.034744259,
-0.0395511203,
-0.0222377609,
0.03387006,
-0.0340902768,
0.0525873862,
-0.0301201157,
0.0530841947,
0.0571025088,
-0.0188255962,
0.0308191497,
0.0210087821,
-0.0332769044,
0.0257619862,
-0.067781724,
0.0111996531,
0.0227358323,
0.0092757707,
0.0193000045,
-0.0407375172,
0.0228350274,
-0.0151875429,
0.0747854412,
-0.0288702883,
0.0090274177,
-0.0099528749,
-0.0445787422,
0.0282756593,
0.0277140886,
0.0105489064,
-0.0031214471,
-0.0437768325,
0.0207604356,
0.0159182921,
0.0252660699,
-0.025808854,
0.0430445448,
-0.0950516686,
-0.0088114226,
-0.040010538,
0.017500231,
-0.022442881,
-0.0352101363,
0.0079235872,
0.0363572948,
0.0341203324,
-0.0454607569,
-0.0204934981,
0.0614551827,
-0.0374580696,
0.0360759646,
-0.0087242564,
-0.0312850811,
0.0414027944,
0.0284895655,
0.0517339297,
-0.0521074198,
0.0590076894,
-0.0655334443,
0.0435299277,
-0.0257410314,
0.0565422624,
-0.0279178396,
0.0268968455,
-0.0261253547,
0.0279245917,
-0.0050471593,
0.0291192997,
-0.0112081086,
-0.0040697381,
-0.0094466656,
-0.0320872553,
-0.0586821511,
0.0285103545,
-0.0208600406,
0.0151116373,
0.0019249582,
-0.0058860793,
-0.0024678144,
-0.0550556406,
-0.0737653673,
-0.0110625196,
0.0142105184,
0.0227028262,
0.0195993464,
0.0021507281,
0.0089246053,
0.0216143113,
0.0026411805,
0.0426479205,
-0.0312685892,
-0.0074933432,
0.0302651264,
0.0082171792,
-0.0383777134,
-0.0382792316,
-0.0281771868,
-0.019091513,
0.0367911384,
0.0289474055,
-0.0174895208,
-0.0341837108,
0.0148768136,
-0.0091196233,
0.0288784672,
-0.024093926,
-0.0850222707,
0.0339871272,
0.0314729251,
0.0242361091,
0.0412210189,
0.0245114882,
0.0114013534,
0.0171905272,
-0.0136197004,
-0.0142282061,
-0.0176557899,
-0.073865898,
-0.025341535,
-0.0812509134,
-0.0623433292,
0.0500958674,
0.1278876811,
0.0066607944,
-0.0095482431,
-0.040981371,
0.0028502594,
-0.0503524728,
-0.0224295761,
0.0445166081,
-0.000691398,
-0.0526050664,
0.0519754067,
-0.0317594185,
0.0008127366,
0.051965259,
0.0003878472,
-0.0067877546,
-0.045511093,
0.0049127853,
0.0052355337,
0.0533255935,
0.0218536109,
0.0095218839,
0.021245962,
-0.0400327295,
-0.075844638,
-0.0488708168,
0.0035368055,
-0.0126562808,
0.0619550161,
-0.0715997517,
-0.0063531208,
0.0449780375,
-0.01042319,
-0.0170861073,
-0.0148568153,
0.0313068405,
0.0449717306,
0.0240475051,
-0.0013415784,
-0.0079642208,
-0.0109448479,
-0.0059367716,
0.0536446311,
0.0077253161,
-0.0131813576,
-0.0347229168,
0.0070322291,
0.0206436999,
0.0332536362,
-0.0038174125,
0.0185825974,
0.0007888629,
-0.0096726958,
-0.049101267,
0.0297532212,
-0.0294505134,
-0.0054988354,
0.0231025834,
-0.0602242872,
-0.0761333331,
-0.0154033555,
0.0069515263,
0.0087582739,
-0.0630495697,
0.084145911,
0.0316123851,
-0.013732587,
0.0247073937,
-0.0069912495,
-0.0337609351,
0.0032503917,
0.0276700407,
0.008070183,
0.0467949994,
-0.0150427027,
-0.0273195673,
-0.0293114185,
-0.0078587774,
0.0050283321,
-0.0602773838,
0.0302686803,
-0.0348242708,
-0.0219937321,
0.0075844689,
0.0147494962,
0.0023053,
0.0138110472,
0.0247877855,
-0.00622366,
-0.0066099614,
-0.002560853,
0.028625587,
-0.0108321151,
0.007267457,
-0.0018760705,
-0.0184782855,
0.0409318395,
0.0311426222,
0.0401345342,
-0.0806974024,
-0.079343535,
0.0523800403,
0.0113460897,
0.0116312904,
0.0227744561,
0.0035379147,
0.0265720598,
0.0116405152,
-0.0636526272,
-0.0209748168,
0.0251744874,
-0.0275450721,
-0.0138932643,
0.0615172945,
-0.0280680154,
-0.0053220731,
0.0124644311,
0.0167484041,
-0.0277545433,
0.0361207426,
0.0316750705,
-0.0743192211,
0.0075992299,
0.061070893,
0.0179764293,
0.0207231566,
-0.0846611783,
0.0213905517,
0.0058019855,
-0.0803415179,
-0.0985195562,
-0.0242933631,
0.0110375844,
0.0330137685,
0.0309128743,
-0.0450111516,
0.0649958104,
-0.076085493,
-0.0148171941,
0.0393194668,
0.0283937566,
0.0001776647,
-0.0696838275,
-0.0290939454,
0.0767343119,
-0.0317018479,
-0.0317471772,
-0.0470370352,
-0.0204984732,
-0.0173782259,
0.0439321883,
0.0281845424,
0.0324024856,
0.0193750039,
-0.0450678356,
-0.0524354354,
0.0432695895,
0.0101513583,
-0.039557945,
0.0464789346,
0.0063223899,
0.0109719746,
0.0127299111,
0.0313285254,
0.0030928962,
0.040298488,
0.001118045,
0.0278592799,
-0.0552661791,
-0.0171231329,
0.0227357522,
-0.026345443,
0.075215742,
-0.0074839424,
0.0387501344,
-0.0397552885,
-0.0241462477,
0.0021817288,
0.0333383307,
-0.0211195145,
-0.0130650876,
0.0812623277,
0.0670953542,
0.0164613817,
-0.0763406977,
-0.0657536611,
-0.0082773278,
0.0577261113,
-0.0301194545,
0.0098248245,
0.0067639458,
-0.0130822193,
0.0804740861,
0.005278849,
0.0266720336,
-0.0492355041,
0.0469712466,
-0.0252366103,
0.0496630035,
0.002031801,
0.0023752612,
-0.0578086339,
0.0422618426,
-0.0105319535,
-0.0320534296,
0.0001485735,
0.0080477688,
0.0104700215,
0.0182494875,
0.0068795467,
-0.0324846283,
0.0261885319,
-0.0024329047,
0.0278571509,
0.003740612,
-0.0012719757,
0.0406530425,
0.0078856433,
-0.0002861464,
-0.034248177,
0.0186570808,
-0.0214013159,
0.019636957,
-0.0236942135,
0.0099475868,
0.0181747861,
-0.0189130511,
-0.0068872636,
-0.0058380696,
-0.0726414248,
-0.0141229061,
-0.0534337871,
-0.0595350489,
-0.0092232069,
0.0159883145,
0.0218381751,
-0.0418575369,
0.032971371,
0.0351282507,
0.0110635599,
-0.0158905871,
-0.0519365035,
0.0194638036,
0.0297890659,
0.0150403995,
-0.0505165495,
-5.799596723e-33,
-0.0732470155,
-0.0134784691,
0.048658818,
0.0622341037,
-0.0216783229,
-0.0002757036,
-0.0083629685,
0.0109647866,
-0.0018951332,
-0.0024264045,
0.0010263504,
-0.0128815593,
0.0105315587,
0.0316661969,
0.0298336819,
0.0089438856,
0.0033935048,
0.0022676056,
0.0207547154,
-0.0446572751,
-0.0108008785,
-0.0089079132,
0.0875247717,
-0.0411542654,
0.04545388,
0.0005695006,
0.0228428561,
0.0077548036,
0.0186672993,
0.0406054854,
-0.0084659765,
0.0205899626,
0.0397574641,
-0.0281298496,
0.0091591431,
0.0394184925,
-0.0360745005,
-0.0701074675,
0.0847078487,
0.0381043032,
-0.0544336066,
-0.0456979834,
0.0751604661,
-0.0409271456,
-0.0273608733,
0.0300362781,
0.0218328703,
0.0007657913,
-0.027203057,
0.0298646223,
-0.0905278549,
-0.0292997658,
0.0229458753,
-0.0407414287,
0.0232789423,
0.0188043974,
-0.0520982929,
-0.0446028113,
-0.052910272,
0.0115627749,
-0.0508211255,
0.0160073843,
0.0219305865,
0.0712121129,
0.0357821845,
0.0399301834,
0.0777834058,
0.0075483462,
-0.017001709,
0.0251476914,
0.1038664356,
0.0511572808,
0.0041390974,
0.0123443594,
-0.0011594794,
-0.0450927168,
0.0164993852,
-0.0335199088,
0.058086779,
-0.0025905541,
0.0212126579,
-0.0576164797,
0.0024114123,
-0.0416062474,
-0.0473903455,
-0.0454824604,
0.0068321447,
-0.0429907963,
-0.0033864798,
-0.0303590093,
0.0531018712,
0.0269984771,
0.0158005841,
-0.0474120006,
0.0335197449,
-0.0507744253,
-0.0588761605,
0.0657877102,
-0.0015119455,
0.0351294689,
-0.0161388125,
-0.0445804894,
-0.0167674106,
0.050852634,
0.0116719129,
0.0444833785,
-0.0024959287,
0.0044176234,
0.0125015723,
-0.0111206369,
-0.0251181964,
-0.0273800474,
0.0080933413,
-0.0079300161,
0.0184815284,
0.0379146114,
-0.037702892,
0.0007456482,
0.0146980183,
0.0163277518,
-0.0023156838,
0.0288800634,
0.0176244508,
0.0409239717,
-0.0344006978,
-0.0076826871,
-0.0220583547,
0.0791489258,
0.0295520052,
-0.0026907986,
-0.0214744098,
-0.0072127911,
2.811e-7,
0.0395067707,
0.0453652777,
-0.0011926688,
0.0101541514,
0.021886101,
-0.0036907813,
0.0162281822,
-0.0060529397,
0.021286184,
0.0127840536,
-0.0007347082,
0.0156132579,
0.0039717401,
0.0070781643,
-0.0721458346,
-0.0670519248,
-0.0009728281,
-0.0027607665,
-0.0538704172,
0.0158686917,
0.0442620218,
0.0525518805,
0.0360553712,
-0.0321053863,
-0.0521240234,
-0.0106306085,
0.0566524155,
-0.0355958566,
-0.0190331694,
0.0463575907,
0.0004343737,
0.0167349707,
0.0264333021,
0.0566704832,
0.0176427308,
0.0227081608,
-0.002722854,
0.0471970923,
-0.030738676,
0.012986308,
0.0259850938,
-0.0973222703,
-0.0337609015,
-0.0143893473,
0.0098527595,
-0.1202372462,
-0.0564851277,
0.0037171654,
-0.0575916208,
0.0363200679,
-0.000012764,
-0.0332571715,
-0.0057940092,
0.0207660906,
0.0438557342,
-0.0088181309,
0.0087817702,
-0.0220945273,
0.0309208836,
0.0188407134,
-0.0204796344,
-0.0488045737,
-0.0092298817,
-0.0248631854,
0.0285058189,
-0.0430527553,
0.0323611014,
2.178492941e-34,
-0.0187398605,
0.0665616095,
0.0431215204,
0.0001893429,
-0.0086539891,
-0.0018448443,
0.0299391393,
0.0579702854,
0.0029103665,
-0.0471599065,
-0.0006520823
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.02892v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.02892v2 | The Relationship Between Speech Features Changes When You Get Depressed: Feature Correlations for Improving Speed and Performance of Depression Detection | 2023-07-06T09:54:35 | 2023-07-07T09:31:28 | Fuxiang Tao, Wei Ma, Xuri Ge, Anna Esposito, Alessandro Vinciarelli | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | This work shows that depression changes the correlation between features
extracted from speech. Furthermore, it shows that using such an insight can
improve the training speed and performance of depression detectors based on
SVMs and LSTMs. The experiments were performed over the Androids Corpus, a
publicly available dataset involving 112 speakers, including 58 people
diagnosed with depression by professional psychiatrists. The results show that
the models used in the experiments improve in terms of training speed and
performance when fed with feature correlation matrices rather than with feature
vectors. The relative reduction of the error rate ranges between 23.1% and
26.6% depending on the model. The probable explanation is that feature
correlation matrices appear to be more variable in the case of depressed
speakers. Correspondingly, such a phenomenon can be thought of as a depression
marker. | [
0.0270354729,
-0.0008821079,
-0.0380609222,
-0.0011564,
0.0082545253,
0.008396904,
0.0246113557,
0.004944256,
0.0441560857,
-0.0084102564,
-0.0040690135,
0.0016003585,
0.0180161484,
-0.0181775,
-0.0411584713,
-0.0779145658,
-0.0274866149,
0.0374385379,
0.0379618444,
-0.0209016278,
0.0013998161,
-0.0077988184,
-0.0344633274,
0.0182273015,
-0.0458172932,
-0.0145799201,
0.0181060713,
0.0075508337,
0.0344226807,
-0.0041912305,
-0.0391634963,
0.0165302008,
-0.0033914549,
-0.0247904398,
0.0000017183,
-0.0062799477,
0.0079912571,
0.0011532465,
-0.0051707937,
-0.0536562875,
0.0151499007,
-0.0178659372,
0.0237699058,
0.0381110348,
-0.0435974076,
-0.0407593362,
0.0018401046,
0.0797182694,
0.0667043105,
0.0647622496,
-0.0240289643,
0.0098792091,
-0.0073477323,
0.0012190491,
-0.022784302,
0.0142099587,
0.0368042327,
0.0056047286,
0.0244567152,
-0.0692380816,
-0.0228705965,
0.0023796861,
-0.0422752611,
0.0937511325,
-0.0156102059,
-0.0286737829,
-0.0158287566,
-0.0176663157,
-0.0103295855,
0.0258800499,
0.0480914116,
0.0308026895,
0.0353352763,
0.003900189,
-0.0013586985,
-0.0128619326,
0.0069306279,
-0.0436121635,
-0.0059757787,
0.0421304479,
0.0236905105,
0.0046531116,
0.007183013,
-0.0375815667,
0.0401842557,
0.0332993194,
-0.0085065886,
-0.05204615,
-0.0048682969,
0.007575911,
-0.0249655172,
-0.0174371582,
0.0274168588,
0.0172654949,
-0.0256999116,
0.0085834209,
-0.0427169204,
-0.1373889595,
-0.0449187867,
-0.0074463952,
-0.0611075796,
0.0121954065,
-0.0900832862,
-0.0205838438,
0.0011143601,
0.0674071386,
0.0130435498,
-0.0377956741,
-0.0012400576,
-0.0059962785,
-0.0406391695,
0.0224466026,
-0.0176878907,
0.0265222788,
0.0588883907,
-0.0112635139,
-0.0847359821,
-0.0096074995,
-0.0028642274,
-0.0283065587,
-0.0101824738,
0.01113516,
0.0383265465,
0.0235371627,
0.0288716387,
0.0549385436,
-0.0142513178,
0.0398378335,
-0.0399089009,
-0.0696157068,
0.056793388,
-0.0144567983,
0.0006370011,
-0.0244724415,
0.0607225038,
0.0451970585,
0.072943449,
-0.0308879726,
-0.090635851,
-0.0136415614,
-0.024208568,
-0.0311698224,
-0.0127004059,
-0.0201557614,
-0.0318893678,
0.0400807224,
0.0060500796,
-0.0461957045,
0.0037121212,
-0.0338015072,
-0.0079781711,
0.0282386448,
-0.0498630218,
0.0068307817,
0.0597269535,
-0.0143201416,
-0.0123660173,
0.0598021187,
0.0474982373,
0.0008884599,
0.0104089985,
-0.0720059872,
0.0062428853,
-0.0031318148,
-0.036742121,
-0.035906598,
0.0023332972,
-0.0771402344,
-0.0399226137,
0.0222260728,
0.0256060585,
0.0083625317,
0.0054411562,
0.0164430737,
0.0532537289,
0.0638149157,
0.0511643924,
0.0727155879,
-0.0383728258,
0.0050724237,
0.0144906268,
-0.0008634928,
-0.0004754328,
-0.0003092414,
-0.0327638164,
-0.0124977268,
-0.0206225067,
0.0341148376,
-0.0094924532,
-0.0316684954,
-0.0338076167,
-0.0461845212,
0.0113639589,
0.0108024869,
0.0217998158,
-0.0351031832,
0.0282609016,
0.0675615296,
0.0076635848,
0.005632557,
-0.0513467155,
-0.0310570113,
0.0000475144,
0.0336350612,
-0.0025374077,
-0.0113460822,
0.0185666531,
-0.0225038622,
-0.0154198874,
-0.0139346607,
-0.0284406412,
0.0425313525,
0.0444294959,
-0.0247146562,
0.0233295988,
0.0160231292,
0.0039365082,
0.0124550192,
-0.0311847813,
0.0573663972,
0.0036441446,
0.0128226765,
0.0278291404,
0.020746246,
0.0237722192,
0.004536768,
0.0311673712,
0.0271702968,
0.0513269864,
0.0274604503,
-0.0181891285,
-0.0313729793,
0.0107162138,
-0.053724464,
-0.0183364488,
0.0342146866,
0.0497049429,
-0.033730384,
0.0028086295,
-0.008688556,
0.0319565721,
0.1004060954,
-0.0080821114,
-0.0756878629,
0.0757062212,
-0.0375012942,
0.0325948447,
-0.0013523876,
0.0250232238,
-0.0112777203,
0.0631893128,
0.0100557189,
-0.0085196057,
0.0342828669,
0.031465143,
0.0238870773,
-0.0433184206,
0.0010381155,
-0.0725275353,
-0.0368337892,
-0.0093414709,
-0.0356954671,
0.001685062,
-0.0473643839,
-0.023743825,
-0.0165030565,
0.0028102815,
-0.1267629564,
-0.0134517998,
-0.0059219273,
-0.0301648751,
-0.0322903655,
-0.0025982289,
-0.0368505791,
-0.0279454663,
0.0000580961,
0.0188802015,
0.0353264697,
-0.0024035301,
-0.0038996704,
0.0063219601,
-0.0335554406,
-0.0412923396,
-0.0080268718,
-0.014565967,
-0.0082451561,
-0.0502126031,
-0.0810697377,
-0.0229908917,
0.0117555493,
-0.0007933817,
0.0117075648,
0.0263581853,
-0.0399513394,
-0.0428387001,
0.0017656952,
0.0283131637,
0.0478302836,
0.0251608342,
0.031588722,
0.0196030494,
0.0150989015,
0.0194622427,
0.0391911715,
0.0057923067,
0.0707559288,
-0.0528249219,
-0.0303494167,
-0.0219546482,
0.0289155841,
0.0417806841,
0.0326183029,
-0.0167654138,
-0.0621293373,
-0.003788359,
0.0137541369,
0.0134240417,
-0.0177447256,
-0.0201591272,
-0.0201860201,
0.0117766773,
-0.0421998911,
0.0059355674,
-0.0039132102,
-0.0313525833,
-0.0299670715,
-0.0496581607,
-0.0174335968,
0.0106418235,
-0.0137208067,
-0.0115084229,
0.0225466713,
-0.038000308,
0.0223667845,
0.0064240657,
-0.0092588086,
-0.0514578372,
0.0301594939,
-0.0226334799,
-0.0166661572,
0.0268799979,
-0.0306797102,
-0.0337054245,
-0.0571548045,
-0.0908046365,
-0.0388242789,
-0.0061508263,
-0.0194147006,
0.0194195006,
-0.0311447792,
0.0087844916,
0.0155784991,
-0.0051243673,
0.0061840685,
0.0516278408,
0.0228197295,
0.0553180687,
0.0378083549,
-0.0056987605,
-0.0051643071,
0.0239067227,
-0.029532589,
-0.0151631311,
0.0399251059,
-0.0298533235,
0.0204325635,
-0.0241305493,
0.0303365327,
-0.0622435026,
0.0333506912,
-0.0121643525,
-0.0030833164,
0.0268998165,
0.0853476822,
0.0096305478,
-0.0174129121,
0.0032978803,
-0.0603687428,
-0.0229539722,
0.0151659744,
-0.0317025483,
0.002757197,
-0.0536827855,
-0.0150237046,
0.0416937135,
-0.0290061161,
0.0289181676,
-0.0161601044,
0.0205875635,
0.0131861269,
-0.0126764113,
-0.0103284195,
0.0056331195,
-0.0272424333,
0.0180692449,
-0.0362594016,
-0.0085201738,
-0.052977059,
-0.0123202186,
-0.0047207326,
0.0505909547,
-0.1455647051,
-0.0258386657,
0.0276187994,
0.0001176648,
0.0423785932,
0.0553229116,
0.0346645936,
-0.0269101933,
-0.0223526731,
-0.0858716816,
0.0324150175,
0.0435246639,
0.0009225504,
0.0592146739,
0.0037521196,
-0.0398196243,
-0.0221263524,
0.0554937609,
-0.0674965605,
0.0471753776,
-0.0173048917,
0.0532928817,
-0.025185803,
-0.0347988456,
-0.0141682075,
0.0138749219,
0.010218719,
0.0358204655,
0.0168283097,
-0.0579371154,
-0.0151138538,
0.0683287084,
-0.0069839424,
0.0367387719,
-0.0299798027,
0.0025537766,
0.0237661563,
-0.0612406507,
-0.0538834296,
-0.0573305264,
0.0292941183,
0.0197927468,
-0.0192647614,
0.0563016087,
-0.0318504386,
0.0596791767,
-0.0518876873,
0.0354961082,
0.0974133983,
0.0423921049,
-0.0224801823,
0.0338338539,
0.0243515819,
-0.036608953,
-0.0277509447,
-0.0302940756,
-0.1035355031,
-0.0364622287,
0.0874648541,
-0.0236578118,
0.0163519457,
-0.0138316369,
-0.0039059208,
-0.0652154088,
0.0073543326,
-0.0027126574,
0.0121165141,
0.0337714776,
0.0392787084,
-0.0157742966,
-0.0090444554,
0.0471649505,
0.0066061802,
0.030194575,
0.019999912,
-0.0405332558,
-0.0387855731,
-0.0063640075,
-0.0247316286,
0.0223991703,
0.0772400796,
0.0213461742,
-0.0468834229,
0.0097901281,
-0.0050629657,
0.0281959083,
0.0467132516,
-0.025254501,
-0.0386027433,
-0.009574513,
0.0361755155,
-0.0412027687,
-0.049489364,
-0.0188956615,
-0.0704208463,
0.0251261257,
0.0158604123,
-0.01591116,
-0.0011477172,
0.0054530269,
0.0173508562,
-0.0111810137,
0.0389154926,
0.0235322621,
-0.0266473908,
0.0117691038,
0.0507503264,
-0.0188770164,
-0.0076569673,
0.0294706002,
0.0152874347,
-0.0284607597,
-0.062049035,
-0.0321391597,
-0.0168296769,
0.0597658344,
-0.0013077654,
0.0650489703,
-0.0399182253,
0.0188052412,
-0.0309088565,
0.0088528283,
-0.0422349982,
0.0412451364,
0.0441457555,
-0.021708617,
-0.0304064453,
-0.0062249247,
0.0379641093,
-0.0195807777,
0.00257535,
-0.0083708726,
0.0036759286,
-0.014466079,
0.031654913,
0.0167844258,
-0.0070840796,
-0.0204110835,
-0.0041807573,
-0.0165533703,
-0.0555085465,
0.0929002985,
-0.0676165968,
0.0246027615,
-0.0639493242,
0.0443921685,
0.0318018608,
0.0070415153,
0.0211788043,
-0.0181959607,
-0.0227475595,
-0.0217924733,
-0.019402612,
-0.0463748798,
-5.446417608e-33,
-0.0040630684,
0.0287846774,
-0.0369230248,
0.0200691391,
-0.004231343,
0.0079496261,
0.0115791839,
0.0725902766,
-0.0142945256,
0.0261170696,
0.0149664078,
0.0862491727,
0.0152591467,
0.009650629,
0.0406738073,
-0.0162828919,
0.0324801728,
-0.0060289772,
0.0156671796,
-0.0537156165,
0.0377371944,
0.0862064958,
0.0666629896,
-0.0751440749,
-0.0685112476,
0.030319659,
0.0058395267,
-0.0446560085,
0.0769845843,
-0.0038433708,
-0.012241791,
0.0675237253,
0.0453641787,
-0.0030496118,
0.0183626562,
-0.0225940011,
0.0011878,
-0.01264368,
0.0087764226,
0.0647786111,
-0.0342946239,
0.0165681057,
0.0353371985,
0.0158390477,
0.0000361475,
-0.0032577545,
0.0581487268,
-0.0498186909,
0.0190153942,
-0.0320486911,
0.0187893808,
0.0059068627,
-0.0027031545,
-0.00189622,
0.0205098428,
0.0345182493,
-0.070422098,
0.015913859,
-0.0146110523,
-0.0064128465,
-0.0116925417,
0.0103337858,
0.0102410996,
-0.0374909081,
0.0052433847,
0.057145793,
0.0371283032,
-0.0336626582,
0.0101222051,
-0.0114603639,
-0.0123323528,
0.0713203698,
0.0762761459,
0.0067481017,
0.0754378363,
-0.0488126427,
-0.0361109786,
0.0038976632,
0.0173060354,
0.000719519,
-0.0142815979,
0.0025378342,
-0.0219133273,
0.0032142778,
-0.0006239102,
0.0267239138,
-0.0209732782,
-0.0543957204,
0.0047395355,
0.0120177837,
0.0145691186,
-0.0087490184,
0.0081622731,
-0.0364541188,
0.0194948539,
-0.0235865116,
-0.0306628738,
0.0403082706,
0.0298749991,
-0.0204448346,
-0.0015797294,
-0.0109047918,
0.0431742854,
0.0540016964,
0.0700282902,
-0.0241583493,
-0.003136545,
-0.0031508047,
-0.0344315283,
-0.0176844653,
0.0670204014,
0.0121148936,
-0.0395390578,
0.0362786539,
-0.0076661925,
0.005451248,
-0.0015208763,
0.0449733846,
-0.0344703831,
0.0456217229,
-0.0927779749,
-0.0507852212,
0.0387586951,
0.0228829235,
-0.0013103057,
-0.0335141867,
-0.0024970577,
-0.0318802111,
0.0195293836,
-0.0180907343,
0.0083555682,
-0.0184849184,
2.562e-7,
-0.0388137735,
0.0272467453,
-0.0175480656,
-0.0063875667,
0.044887159,
0.02059846,
-0.0158545375,
0.0152397826,
0.0409763046,
-0.0324696936,
0.0185778849,
-0.0178525634,
0.0839975625,
0.046533104,
-0.0490666665,
-0.0225420073,
-0.0049436996,
-0.0158219989,
-0.0422601663,
0.0226125289,
0.0793261528,
0.0533248223,
0.00745322,
-0.0462363027,
0.0494768545,
0.0421467461,
0.0348949805,
-0.0077368314,
0.0468574725,
-0.0197857209,
0.0631747171,
-0.0268504228,
0.0162194204,
0.0037844942,
-0.0097673368,
0.0436517633,
-0.0279026087,
0.0118165137,
-0.0245096721,
-0.0435922444,
0.0064879539,
0.0929793343,
-0.0395828336,
0.0875986814,
0.0395698622,
-0.0280098245,
-0.0663627386,
-0.056556575,
-0.0115827955,
-0.0396475345,
0.0637901872,
0.0023941128,
0.0045517166,
-0.0036676908,
0.0074623637,
-0.036364492,
-0.002310314,
-0.0717990175,
-0.0098341899,
0.0451735444,
-0.0689557642,
-0.0037086315,
-0.027554363,
-0.0203843433,
0.0299215466,
-0.0463847108,
0.0088693686,
1.663521034e-34,
0.0055687898,
0.0254931189,
0.0195915289,
0.0500892475,
-0.0156582631,
0.001024474,
-0.0396124981,
-0.0023068788,
-0.0188811831,
-0.0683554411,
-0.0044629234
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.02882v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.02882v1 | Contrast Is All You Need | 2023-07-06T09:36:54 | 2023-07-06T09:36:54 | Burak Kilic, Florix Bex, Albert Gatt | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In this study, we analyze data-scarce classification scenarios, where
available labeled legal data is small and imbalanced, potentially hurting the
quality of the results. We focused on two finetuning objectives; SetFit
(Sentence Transformer Finetuning), a contrastive learning setup, and a vanilla
finetuning setup on a legal provision classification task. Additionally, we
compare the features that are extracted with LIME (Local Interpretable
Model-agnostic Explanations) to see which particular features contributed to
the model's classification decisions. The results show that a contrastive setup
with SetFit performed better than vanilla finetuning while using a fraction of
the training samples. LIME results show that the contrastive learning approach
helps boost both positive and negative features which are legally informative
and contribute to the classification results. Thus a model finetuned with a
contrastive objective seems to base its decisions more confidently on legally
informative features. | [
0.0378169939,
0.0363479145,
-0.0236804672,
0.0033653222,
-0.060868796,
0.0360095352,
0.0423051231,
0.0195282791,
-0.0380289666,
-0.0698438212,
-0.0133596268,
0.0071350355,
-0.0198364407,
0.003515139,
0.0102594728,
-0.0722598433,
0.0248382967,
0.0238023289,
0.0461852513,
-0.0095289061,
-0.0020676611,
0.0090771345,
0.0304039605,
0.0060037947,
-0.0105622727,
0.002384146,
-0.0080847796,
-0.0012001216,
0.0394322388,
0.0219788384,
0.0239423979,
0.0575403981,
0.0001762943,
-0.0050444021,
0.0000019983,
-0.0722703561,
-0.028201811,
0.0163223166,
-0.0315585099,
0.0118573802,
0.0499844328,
-0.0607101545,
0.0075973966,
0.0253366977,
-0.036044009,
0.037457779,
0.025830375,
0.0858817995,
0.0182762314,
0.0511090271,
-0.019961359,
-0.0930685923,
0.0057362802,
-0.0333849229,
-0.0141537581,
-0.0217228532,
0.0154969115,
-0.0208352245,
0.0150779141,
-0.0226656981,
-0.0233702082,
0.0235880893,
0.0451645106,
-0.0131139467,
0.0132983513,
0.0118390815,
-0.0536323264,
0.0055518509,
0.0021591035,
0.0322914198,
0.0133245336,
-0.0158153139,
-0.0169190113,
-0.0484009162,
0.0653677583,
-0.0031792712,
-0.0189347826,
0.0598967187,
0.0119000692,
0.0442456007,
0.0383571014,
0.0294217765,
-0.0023162265,
0.0487579182,
-0.0410607941,
0.0247191191,
-0.021897126,
-0.0338675864,
0.0021036717,
0.0143839158,
-0.0136716608,
-0.0364031717,
0.0389490239,
0.0220009889,
0.0031459788,
-0.0045243837,
-0.0300923754,
-0.0039061822,
0.0602925308,
-0.0253828205,
-0.0028602518,
-0.0118751535,
-0.0805961937,
0.0452703126,
-0.0343601704,
0.0145227285,
0.0503708795,
0.0616339333,
0.0033804071,
-0.0227216128,
-0.0208517946,
-0.0071507222,
-0.030150665,
0.0749307349,
-0.0779285952,
0.0394668318,
-0.0356880166,
-0.0336296149,
-0.0272916388,
0.0043592243,
0.0022723537,
0.0221027061,
-0.0248289686,
-0.0255749077,
-0.0552996621,
-0.0487895645,
-0.0434707031,
0.0488507599,
-0.0067256168,
-0.032667879,
0.014096532,
-0.007182668,
-0.0037573474,
-0.0265482273,
0.0089645321,
0.0559758246,
0.0090084309,
-0.051674515,
-0.0740550756,
-0.0286197718,
-0.0445043519,
-0.0443629771,
-0.0533521026,
-0.0321249813,
-0.0441796407,
-0.0079128183,
-0.008058277,
-0.0536915138,
-0.0202803649,
0.0021766583,
-0.0312241837,
0.0824576169,
0.0050717411,
-0.0338742658,
-0.0607510097,
-0.0055932375,
0.0211587828,
0.0092096189,
0.0081281243,
0.0140254209,
0.0101138344,
-0.0276245214,
0.0331356078,
0.0035942646,
0.009559893,
-0.0035745671,
-0.03108068,
0.0056027151,
-0.0316682942,
-0.0213499609,
0.0295768678,
0.0134948399,
0.0171137173,
0.0009002858,
0.0375566669,
0.0364472605,
0.0757406577,
0.0329670906,
-0.0120421015,
0.036712613,
-0.048037827,
0.0252100173,
-0.0604878366,
0.0214263014,
-0.0347114652,
-0.0066188932,
-0.0619171411,
0.0171194468,
-0.0277905874,
-0.0686118007,
0.0109613594,
-0.0022462774,
0.0137324156,
0.0191265177,
0.0523865521,
0.0388940237,
-0.0098677492,
0.0468092747,
0.0396422856,
-0.004567774,
-0.0387528017,
-0.0670110956,
-0.0176466201,
0.0524742603,
0.0098884944,
-0.0387122706,
0.0142006557,
-0.0439697504,
-0.0135118086,
0.0542485639,
0.014000426,
0.0037308671,
0.006320938,
-0.0301391184,
-0.041074004,
-0.0380834416,
0.0492547601,
0.004575077,
-0.0111020599,
-0.0061567207,
0.0502870381,
-0.0567507409,
-0.0235780869,
0.035412427,
0.0279243309,
-0.0497805662,
0.0323497392,
0.0372514389,
0.0014264394,
0.0119326934,
0.0151467659,
-0.0287124049,
-0.0042503485,
-0.0125712277,
0.0042522205,
0.0077059218,
0.0084591946,
-0.0247640591,
0.0144016957,
-0.0148149766,
0.0210812613,
0.0131011019,
-0.0454225242,
-0.0116483159,
-0.0332585312,
-0.003642197,
0.001622219,
-0.0598167591,
-0.0013289651,
-0.0198062882,
0.0125761526,
-0.0401872471,
0.0382884406,
0.0014860438,
-0.01034455,
-0.04953086,
-0.0318141766,
0.0453268774,
-0.0067642103,
0.0089568961,
-0.0070218709,
-0.0580672137,
0.0190525781,
-0.0001660513,
0.0281975325,
-0.0134264743,
-0.010253692,
-0.0242614336,
-0.0007179231,
-0.0379053205,
-0.0062432936,
0.0258882511,
-0.0333199836,
0.0056324084,
-0.0271300282,
-0.0203722287,
-0.0302665699,
-0.0058291419,
0.0121449009,
0.0374227427,
-0.0034866177,
-0.0407690518,
0.012362821,
-0.0105095087,
-0.0130375363,
0.0337213501,
0.0227135457,
-0.0188244022,
-0.0465933122,
0.0564970262,
0.0139638772,
-0.0243269447,
-0.0144403912,
-0.0190891828,
-0.0322005264,
0.0457817949,
-0.0464944094,
0.0099576367,
0.0041823345,
0.0200573597,
0.0240766238,
0.0199506637,
-0.036976248,
-0.0061527286,
0.0065082815,
0.0022645418,
-0.0633224845,
-0.0236731805,
-0.0027327659,
0.0520731397,
-0.0173218753,
-0.0100568263,
-0.0504322834,
0.0153355272,
0.0031933193,
-0.0002548374,
-0.0036338107,
0.0316819996,
-0.0188136529,
0.055809021,
0.0033518323,
-0.0764502585,
0.0603675321,
0.0417620242,
0.0487893745,
-0.0291640088,
-0.0344362371,
-0.0369319618,
0.0533906966,
-0.0052980101,
0.0113294497,
0.0315311253,
-0.0594252981,
-0.0179090295,
-0.0420627072,
0.0766618475,
-0.0093255583,
0.1005429178,
-0.0262804162,
0.0081113391,
-0.0376084819,
-0.0664072037,
-0.0312327836,
-0.1145543978,
0.0041094637,
0.062475957,
0.0392590128,
0.0014278936,
-0.0230994783,
-0.0087958341,
-0.0485375784,
0.0198165569,
-0.0110477488,
-0.0097995205,
-0.007257991,
0.0210919492,
-0.0041112904,
0.021319177,
0.0446020998,
-0.0225976892,
0.0120299552,
-0.0242315717,
-0.0508942306,
-0.0250282083,
0.0334428437,
0.0383553021,
-0.0077130785,
-0.0534613281,
-0.0186354648,
0.0359210148,
0.0145581951,
-0.0600171871,
0.0089101456,
0.0767160729,
0.0271591637,
0.008277392,
0.0122347223,
0.0063546421,
0.0147261582,
0.0392271131,
0.0266940873,
-0.062128935,
-0.0047029885,
0.0066507463,
0.038974192,
-0.0443306565,
-0.008627356,
-0.0165560842,
-0.0622700639,
0.0975596085,
0.0197421927,
-0.0435723364,
-0.0422046781,
0.0123616308,
-0.0211771838,
-0.0413733423,
0.0105404127,
-0.0195745602,
-0.0286444817,
0.0020760137,
0.0267529227,
-0.0260987114,
-0.0255541597,
0.0084032407,
-0.0254486203,
0.0192691591,
0.0496197566,
0.0094483728,
-0.035254281,
-0.0363926515,
0.0128735993,
-0.0470096953,
0.0334524065,
0.0177574437,
0.1066841036,
0.0383161642,
0.0065036472,
-0.0371669233,
0.0457085408,
0.0157141462,
-0.047276523,
-0.0073223822,
0.0275866371,
-0.0407686047,
-0.0137225082,
0.0385491289,
-0.0185981262,
0.0016894318,
0.051332809,
0.0198837891,
-0.0340380184,
-0.0408656336,
-0.0393333063,
-0.038783256,
-0.0396820009,
0.00622134,
0.0285579823,
-0.0202529281,
-0.0489757285,
0.0030742497,
-0.0554349944,
0.0054780757,
0.0480483174,
-0.0043247188,
0.0122196767,
-0.0304456279,
-0.0192831066,
-0.0360248312,
0.0437467061,
-0.0279172007,
0.0160478167,
0.0171864312,
-0.0101799648,
0.0316509381,
-0.0394506454,
-0.0343435705,
-0.0795501545,
-0.0217214879,
-0.003200742,
0.0285331141,
0.0176574849,
0.0246217083,
0.030733211,
-0.0270894822,
-0.0511942059,
0.0582970902,
0.1315324306,
-0.0376209654,
-0.0123840878,
0.1084486023,
-0.0592778251,
-0.0120776882,
0.0142461564,
-0.0101282047,
0.0186468661,
0.0534496382,
-0.0090875737,
-0.0217305031,
0.0151823414,
0.0466137491,
0.0413209945,
0.0596442893,
-0.0207740292,
-0.0506765395,
-0.0240049865,
0.0196738634,
0.0251250975,
-0.0069299876,
-0.0275717583,
-0.0382029526,
0.0424377918,
0.004133516,
-0.0406209938,
0.0781053454,
-0.0318747982,
-0.0255948212,
-0.0470009483,
0.0347273089,
0.0119031817,
-0.0001412532,
0.003723575,
0.0039358721,
-0.0080674309,
0.0331390351,
0.0329967365,
0.0558370277,
0.0051367329,
0.0413254201,
0.018468082,
0.0327477455,
-0.0467398651,
0.0153848864,
-0.0064196684,
-0.005061619,
-0.0374869332,
0.0172674097,
0.0337005109,
-0.0341465697,
0.009386817,
-0.0171291288,
-0.0197882857,
0.0296138041,
0.0473458171,
0.0125566935,
-0.0357150175,
0.0030122446,
-0.0063502216,
-0.0297608282,
0.0194245651,
0.0481237583,
-0.0282280277,
0.0144292274,
-0.0425980464,
-0.007840516,
-0.0204494204,
-0.0050646304,
-0.0060522314,
-0.0168687757,
-0.0146883838,
-0.0125731854,
-0.0972586349,
-0.0328264758,
-0.0016285594,
-0.039818611,
-0.0077402014,
-0.0009802782,
0.0250796918,
0.0432087071,
-0.0036475752,
-0.044291269,
-0.0332249701,
-0.0166892558,
0.028168086,
0.0133303264,
-0.0208827443,
-6.198701299e-33,
-0.0293913856,
-0.0484482832,
-0.0140947457,
0.0379059725,
0.0110925455,
-0.0180061813,
0.008799741,
-0.022208957,
-0.0000917442,
0.0456783287,
0.008334009,
0.0383906066,
0.0218969863,
0.0148527641,
0.0298059061,
-0.0620944574,
0.0455347076,
0.0296210311,
-0.0158526953,
0.0337063484,
-0.0338711403,
0.0507022403,
0.0517225154,
-0.1101490855,
0.0214634705,
0.0556243286,
-0.0394653492,
-0.00922048,
-0.0617254674,
0.0373719595,
0.0198603161,
0.0401342511,
0.0306005757,
-0.0764069036,
-0.0135844853,
0.0002027119,
-0.0674314797,
0.0184639394,
0.0190102067,
0.0232037138,
0.038702786,
-0.0575103685,
0.0405379049,
0.0014773906,
-0.0195240099,
-0.038686011,
0.0469775461,
-0.0592307746,
-0.0224392526,
-0.0614068918,
-0.063856326,
0.0496472046,
-0.0251799803,
0.0073679932,
0.0554802455,
0.0378637575,
0.0014586324,
0.071216628,
-0.0341789834,
-0.0305514075,
0.0759999305,
-0.0325150974,
0.046760451,
-0.0188037548,
-0.0407286547,
0.0459716693,
-0.0011086043,
0.0070408271,
-0.0132342428,
-0.0312245078,
0.0248471461,
0.098923102,
0.0455229469,
0.0750930831,
0.0832247958,
-0.0141992271,
-0.0584226213,
-0.005573947,
-0.0454306565,
0.0043362086,
0.0266240798,
-0.0138043556,
-0.0545211323,
-0.044487495,
-0.0334634371,
-0.0438448489,
0.0014147826,
0.0134917833,
0.0149282198,
-0.0008383149,
0.0130665051,
0.0165412407,
-0.0248867944,
-0.0374290198,
-0.0155711407,
0.0019202782,
-0.0205606874,
0.0159199592,
-0.0249797329,
-0.0202741511,
-0.0427107476,
-0.0299526062,
0.0141168423,
0.0074510537,
0.0371776335,
-0.0060485657,
0.1117557213,
0.0177144594,
-0.0612377487,
0.0201290064,
0.0149540696,
0.0197219849,
0.0321503319,
0.023095021,
-0.010433712,
0.0207081195,
0.0117264912,
0.0587546453,
0.0220401715,
-0.0211991742,
-0.0047435695,
-0.0022529594,
0.0057568853,
0.009911282,
0.0009569219,
-0.0147625599,
0.0354983322,
0.0329166204,
0.0508087017,
-0.011014577,
-0.013470687,
0.0398899019,
2.701e-7,
0.0729729235,
0.0288999137,
-0.0237768851,
-0.0465451479,
-0.0181996319,
0.0678955019,
0.0271181613,
0.0098132426,
0.0056767142,
0.000975202,
0.0416933522,
-0.0091304006,
0.0740041435,
0.0507307462,
-0.0495220795,
-0.0011561507,
-0.0306265261,
-0.0460609198,
-0.0499957874,
0.0429891907,
0.0886336938,
0.0706138089,
0.0373434871,
-0.0289836116,
0.0548233017,
-0.0341496989,
0.0090405149,
-0.0469257832,
0.0123134721,
-0.0256830696,
0.0671548471,
-0.0087101543,
0.0177440122,
0.0628133416,
-0.0172546227,
0.0648507774,
-0.0710735098,
0.0387769789,
-0.0127707329,
0.0262101013,
-0.0419275835,
-0.0310362075,
0.0261079613,
-0.0383496135,
0.0702040419,
-0.0667880028,
-0.0253073052,
-0.0239188634,
-0.0251456313,
-0.0359176062,
0.0127374073,
-0.0021850276,
0.0165378023,
-0.0153644281,
0.0279295091,
-0.0211800281,
-0.0115095731,
-0.0910782963,
-0.0133356107,
0.1060409471,
0.0044876081,
0.0119898152,
0.0047266046,
0.0233657528,
0.0651162341,
-0.0716795921,
0.0236475356,
2.534943006e-34,
0.0340278409,
0.0004126124,
0.0150308432,
0.020096818,
-0.0082044043,
0.0448256768,
0.0047960985,
0.0048438492,
-0.0021396806,
-0.0464740992,
0.0359651186
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.02863v6 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.02863v6 | ValiText -- a unified validation framework for computational text-based measures of social constructs | 2023-07-06T09:03:10 | 2024-06-10T12:51:50 | Lukas Birkenmaier, Claudia Wagner, Clemens Lechner | cs.CL | cs.CL | Guidance on how to validate computational text-based measures of social
constructs is fragmented. While researchers generally acknowledge the
importance of validating text-based measures, they often lack a shared
vocabulary and a unified framework to do so. This paper introduces ValiText, a
new validation framework designed to assist scholars in validly measuring
social constructs in textual data. The framework is built on a conceptual
foundation of validity in the social sciences, strengthened by an empirical
review of validation practices in the social sciences and consultations with
experts. Ultimately, ValiText prescribes researchers to demonstrate three types
of validation evidence: substantive evidence (outlining the theoretical
underpinning of the measure), structural evidence (examining the properties of
the text model and its output) and external evidence (testing for how the
measure relates to independent information). The framework is further
supplemented by a checklist of validation steps, offering practical guidance in
the form of documentation sheets that guide researchers in the validation
process. | [
-0.0068752803,
0.049901966,
-0.0103682503,
-0.0014016514,
-0.0220913738,
0.0266677812,
0.0015872754,
-0.0210312195,
0.002971547,
-0.0202742442,
0.0129790716,
-0.0699346215,
0.0919685289,
0.0432359427,
0.0114141172,
-0.0084730079,
-0.0082246577,
0.0718256757,
0.067161791,
0.0352347605,
0.0168425776,
0.0544668958,
0.0339254439,
0.0180587433,
-0.0022644985,
-0.0034347856,
0.0428313091,
0.0046786908,
0.0519765131,
-0.0553048067,
0.0290377513,
0.0373197794,
-0.0355166905,
-0.0084674777,
0.0000024681,
-0.0528037809,
-0.0197421648,
0.0277438369,
0.0029318433,
0.0144519405,
0.0731863305,
0.0313213766,
0.0295866001,
0.0198834948,
-0.0476199649,
-0.0201049782,
0.0079009105,
0.0326550491,
-0.0094988206,
0.0354527719,
-0.0173157044,
-0.0175894424,
-0.0144649064,
0.0260102693,
-0.0525581203,
0.0606317967,
0.0241902918,
0.0475710854,
-0.0005172895,
0.0518554337,
0.0381570123,
0.0033493582,
0.0021496571,
-0.00967173,
0.0155860167,
0.0014412516,
-0.0047686994,
-0.0593112484,
0.0402828678,
0.0087810056,
0.1535081714,
-0.0251270905,
0.0198775604,
-0.0198749918,
0.0368803144,
0.0536412187,
-0.0090885675,
-0.0037377994,
-0.0052490812,
-0.0090036774,
0.0097399279,
0.0526170284,
0.0073917569,
-0.0069725472,
0.0372308828,
0.0333599336,
0.0081696007,
0.0161558464,
-0.0123053389,
-0.0076259067,
0.0122609651,
-0.0495241247,
-0.0138996243,
-0.00115245,
0.0187569112,
-0.0046779341,
0.0340908132,
-0.0662641823,
0.047513742,
-0.0542656258,
-0.0175182726,
0.0106234839,
0.0015773948,
0.0144097628,
0.0385497287,
-0.0002294814,
0.0324946158,
-0.0287953988,
0.0018926667,
0.0168218128,
-0.0558079481,
0.002459537,
0.0078756483,
-0.0449686646,
0.0161572248,
0.0118936151,
-0.0153539674,
-0.0190568343,
-0.023705909,
0.0338102803,
-0.0630271733,
-0.0044752597,
0.036144916,
0.0184624735,
-0.0307145398,
0.000255712,
-0.0560719706,
0.02219107,
-0.0520413816,
-0.0088759391,
0.0708836764,
0.0234165825,
0.0191898514,
0.00159824,
0.008636496,
-0.0702378005,
-0.0147808949,
0.0038106549,
-0.0252611022,
-0.0436704047,
-0.0734810829,
-0.0310386531,
0.0245295372,
-0.0552428663,
0.0006100736,
0.0540352613,
0.0249944981,
-0.0649150386,
0.0207759906,
0.0111602014,
-0.004354673,
-0.0401420407,
-0.0056858188,
0.0105434684,
0.023050338,
0.046917703,
0.0400356948,
0.0030808183,
0.0356137678,
0.0118262991,
0.0631302148,
-0.0107964557,
-0.0163368508,
-0.0178388078,
0.0057882452,
0.000479117,
-0.0236303229,
0.0388376154,
-0.0017597197,
-0.0359628685,
-0.0559154563,
0.0481908284,
-0.044048503,
0.0540535823,
0.053414546,
0.0626200289,
0.0150131527,
0.0495793633,
0.0017455735,
0.0222225767,
0.0249831863,
-0.0487218983,
-0.0063390159,
-0.0081387237,
-0.0014426423,
-0.0240338687,
-0.0057970616,
0.0270597413,
-0.0024050146,
-0.0668680966,
-0.0358630009,
0.0440899581,
0.0553985089,
-0.0129509345,
0.0219910815,
-0.012221925,
0.0115778437,
-0.0511474051,
-0.0351139382,
-0.0628507733,
0.0036197789,
-0.0049695126,
0.0592746176,
0.0336746424,
0.0248836968,
0.0025931709,
0.0622793771,
-0.027164096,
0.0388897732,
-0.0038809616,
-0.0052703586,
0.0132532297,
-0.0215542223,
-0.0170240384,
0.0122530619,
0.017690124,
0.0307175815,
-0.0210314728,
0.0335390754,
0.0355590917,
0.0201960038,
-0.0163437445,
-0.0438847281,
0.0436808653,
0.0337237902,
0.0021864588,
-0.0358246602,
0.0194271747,
0.0367208868,
0.075121507,
-0.0024802368,
0.0204378925,
-0.0082472749,
0.0442039929,
-0.011032098,
0.0282818917,
0.0101389866,
0.0663573742,
-0.0056040222,
-0.0528782159,
-0.0144228395,
0.0130731836,
0.0526556149,
0.0234383158,
0.0205811709,
-0.0356676467,
0.0381235071,
0.0274878014,
-0.037772432,
-0.0508750044,
-0.0109834848,
0.0314148776,
0.026807325,
0.0008243524,
0.0224673264,
-0.0288252104,
-0.0275394619,
0.0527732223,
0.0197694711,
-0.0311657079,
-0.0493007787,
-0.0347698964,
-0.0086866645,
0.0312667266,
-0.0049338681,
-0.0576504655,
-0.0393666849,
-0.0652290955,
-0.0281324554,
-0.0457365364,
0.0134880347,
0.0334995836,
-0.0334944762,
-0.0321488678,
0.0359248631,
-0.0469902158,
-0.0226304475,
0.0210231058,
-0.0001013372,
0.009915811,
-0.0643018782,
0.0199026484,
-0.0150174843,
0.0090045296,
-0.0547151007,
0.072652556,
0.0511770956,
0.0008914227,
-0.0181945451,
0.0221094377,
-0.068174541,
-0.0446541011,
-0.0232537854,
-0.0239059869,
0.0525748469,
0.0637980774,
0.0636859611,
-0.0052018575,
0.0332449861,
-0.0278546214,
0.0018060419,
-0.0266944878,
0.002686935,
-0.0457203761,
-0.0320257135,
0.0534417517,
-0.0412335731,
-0.1115548834,
0.0111577297,
-0.01749021,
0.0109754037,
-0.0155998766,
-0.0272527672,
0.0257445369,
-0.0388922319,
-0.0180449113,
-0.024111649,
-0.0775080994,
0.0105011435,
0.0325889587,
-0.012956582,
-0.0161343329,
-0.0341655351,
-0.0311832782,
0.0102221211,
-0.0119082788,
-0.0248344317,
-0.0043085003,
0.0555192083,
0.0361694023,
-0.0064065387,
0.0302082784,
0.0635353401,
0.0006971451,
-0.0388395935,
0.0386942625,
-0.031699799,
0.0172934905,
-0.0287364479,
-0.0163914114,
0.0103447074,
0.0305368248,
-0.0152245192,
-0.0132113667,
-0.0405674018,
0.0019777464,
0.019848967,
-0.0257754009,
0.0107668946,
-0.0218750034,
0.0524641834,
-0.013754514,
0.0328554474,
-0.0216530636,
0.0024779646,
-0.0260058623,
0.0000642673,
-0.0044333506,
0.0669086277,
-0.0398458093,
0.004908897,
0.0251699109,
-0.057562463,
-0.0250579901,
-0.0355144627,
-0.0452418961,
-0.021004675,
0.0224330612,
0.0021487505,
-0.0001488255,
0.0658118129,
0.0072653163,
0.00151648,
0.0623203889,
0.0028456154,
0.0533150211,
-0.0126989689,
-0.0208497643,
0.0005943519,
0.0356124528,
-0.0224929228,
-0.0467371419,
0.0460617207,
-0.0048916047,
0.0145066958,
-0.0257303566,
-0.0236595143,
-0.029152466,
-0.0083493581,
0.0096095437,
-0.0111775929,
-0.0181384012,
0.0129393283,
-0.0242270958,
0.0148587245,
-0.0000242037,
-0.0399940088,
-0.0109938448,
0.0175458118,
0.0152608315,
-0.0023476223,
-0.0813180953,
0.0052162735,
0.0191978142,
-0.0342743732,
0.0228638034,
-0.0257958584,
0.0718262792,
-0.003700352,
-0.0259627942,
-0.0527924113,
0.0042435247,
-0.0587038361,
0.056475468,
0.0625936538,
-0.0275940988,
0.0233693849,
-0.0569857694,
0.0234602336,
-0.004255597,
-0.0508762598,
0.0004804227,
0.0146033587,
0.0374206677,
-0.0420851037,
0.0004527032,
0.0165234059,
-0.0208626054,
0.0525168702,
0.0048981351,
0.0219932888,
0.0387481041,
-0.0085833753,
0.0188500527,
0.0247039665,
-0.0529770777,
0.003752745,
-0.0092380913,
-0.0046128151,
-0.0261919983,
-0.0788657665,
0.0507276617,
0.0092248786,
-0.0060238885,
-0.0365116261,
0.059139654,
-0.0595589243,
-0.0712451488,
0.0179412086,
-0.0072951871,
0.0075326259,
0.0269655865,
0.0025976347,
-0.0158130433,
0.0122096082,
-0.0091844788,
-0.0503899343,
-0.0209840797,
0.0159821678,
0.0178012084,
-0.0239237864,
0.0082062846,
-0.0775368214,
-0.0055404585,
-0.0028900893,
0.0436819717,
-0.0251106583,
-0.036135748,
0.0470615327,
0.0083146906,
-0.0156646911,
0.0044904365,
-0.0418342762,
-0.0054138373,
-0.0031665284,
0.0137518356,
-0.0265458338,
-0.0187786911,
0.0181596167,
-0.0236509759,
-0.0123361563,
0.0116080614,
-0.0398112424,
-0.0200918913,
-0.063950412,
-0.0866344571,
-0.0210432541,
-0.0458062701,
-0.0184592903,
-0.000199334,
-0.0051013436,
0.0433618911,
-0.0791338682,
0.0082431138,
-0.0293176509,
0.0505897626,
-0.0170994233,
0.0200064629,
0.017790718,
0.0453692861,
-0.007970918,
-0.0146561349,
0.0077294493,
-0.0361314863,
-0.0668152049,
0.026414087,
0.0224777926,
0.0224096831,
0.0067155813,
0.0049235751,
0.0139367077,
0.0231238585,
-0.0345061235,
0.0241280627,
-0.0691642761,
-0.0176927932,
-0.0533934943,
-0.0290750004,
0.0677165315,
-0.0054668598,
-0.0128005994,
-0.0339769311,
0.0048423968,
-0.0311425552,
-0.0548563451,
-0.0076290285,
-0.0114022912,
-0.0248063244,
0.0076235309,
-0.015608741,
0.0110775586,
-0.0338762887,
0.0112114418,
-0.0417464003,
0.0150258411,
-0.0246540233,
0.0028577934,
0.0160221048,
-0.0378280394,
-0.0355067216,
-0.1023679003,
-0.0731809139,
0.0123958793,
0.0138349514,
0.0253655128,
0.0121884132,
-0.0152089028,
0.0484751649,
-0.0036610623,
-0.0440217033,
-0.0183586255,
0.0155448504,
-0.0262934454,
0.0032745821,
-0.0260860808,
-6.510937578e-33,
-0.007091464,
-0.0804127231,
0.0426010825,
-0.0080480734,
-0.0292893779,
0.0262331627,
-0.0388173722,
0.0223097857,
-0.0091258651,
0.0714273229,
0.0144079821,
0.0381947309,
-0.0184670314,
-0.022341717,
0.0378940664,
0.021357676,
0.0226853546,
-0.0464373082,
-0.0666930601,
-0.0494488478,
-0.0195491314,
-0.0523500256,
0.0611611605,
-0.0900397599,
0.099445127,
0.0022231538,
-0.0035545831,
-0.0464541242,
0.0593888909,
-0.0076536327,
-0.0332525708,
-0.002403161,
0.0554720275,
-0.0203580111,
0.0282338988,
0.1090835035,
-0.0498688444,
-0.0711760372,
0.04512842,
-0.033050444,
-0.0446283706,
-0.0019772397,
-0.0060315481,
0.0365612879,
-0.0382149406,
-0.0171502661,
0.0675778836,
-0.0044005807,
0.051954072,
0.013726973,
-0.0410923995,
0.0291026738,
-0.0278553721,
0.0473808497,
-0.0117744654,
0.0657839328,
-0.0018874517,
0.0448559821,
-0.0594326816,
0.019189734,
-0.0243503302,
-0.0187489782,
0.0131624602,
-0.0134038376,
0.0262174737,
0.0697586462,
-0.0053579174,
0.0255277213,
-0.0560783446,
-0.0272382796,
0.083850123,
0.0018860487,
0.0810458139,
0.1217156798,
-0.0292175375,
-0.0456240997,
-0.0627781227,
-0.0119499229,
-0.0025322726,
-0.0447231568,
0.0176065192,
-0.0186700802,
-0.0634646043,
-0.0422673933,
-0.0434478596,
-0.0600854009,
-0.003671234,
0.0104349665,
0.0153448693,
-0.0127232727,
-0.0417055599,
0.0145230778,
0.0132832807,
-0.0107371537,
-0.0171985514,
0.0029989418,
-0.0008224178,
0.0038802747,
0.0282262154,
0.0014922157,
-0.0615636557,
0.0138673875,
0.03503244,
0.0935212746,
0.064825885,
-0.031767711,
0.0298135113,
-0.0315361433,
-0.0543508045,
-0.0258045215,
0.0201644152,
-0.0131732682,
-0.0033040941,
-0.0351716988,
0.0207291208,
0.0255164765,
0.0193568561,
-0.0024623016,
0.0456891693,
0.0289429165,
-0.0491955467,
-0.0621601939,
0.0029656873,
-0.0426975526,
-0.0023570403,
-0.0213254392,
0.0195071306,
0.0022067672,
0.0944567993,
0.0082700104,
0.0145256557,
-0.041710455,
3.066e-7,
0.0371869802,
0.0843310058,
-0.0115240449,
-0.033972431,
-0.0049199117,
0.0464379303,
0.0172627717,
0.0106755877,
0.0383401997,
-0.0372553281,
0.0393966325,
0.0187760834,
0.0187124424,
0.0650459602,
-0.0029514439,
-0.0343676656,
-0.0481228046,
-0.067197524,
-0.0128591657,
-0.0003832798,
0.0525094047,
-0.0245478526,
0.0265072417,
0.0438265428,
-0.0408066921,
-0.0085004531,
0.006480868,
-0.0252295863,
-0.0041999696,
0.0416241214,
0.0230333451,
0.0132074999,
0.0132973874,
0.0044908165,
0.0009752293,
0.025812434,
0.0368341915,
0.0156482272,
-0.0036955781,
0.0584946573,
-0.016767649,
-0.0475086085,
0.009602095,
-0.0672660992,
0.0597824119,
-0.0053566382,
-0.003696105,
-0.0342764072,
-0.0254319124,
-0.007214427,
0.0743864998,
0.027263552,
-0.041564744,
0.0227915049,
0.0297635403,
-0.010986777,
0.0316833369,
-0.0660982504,
-0.0026060129,
-0.0248232894,
0.0228751376,
-0.0772295296,
-0.0139922341,
0.0423604213,
-0.0161524415,
-0.0012057878,
0.0529091507,
2.672450132e-34,
0.0118219499,
-0.0456095263,
-0.021598924,
-0.0443294831,
0.0876597166,
-0.0143855773,
-0.0552174039,
-0.0229674503,
0.0149264,
-0.0482991934,
0.0274906121
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.02849v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.02849v1 | NatLogAttack: A Framework for Attacking Natural Language Inference Models with Natural Logic | 2023-07-06T08:32:14 | 2023-07-06T08:32:14 | Zi'ou Zheng, Xiaodan Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Reasoning has been a central topic in artificial intelligence from the
beginning. The recent progress made on distributed representation and neural
networks continues to improve the state-of-the-art performance of natural
language inference. However, it remains an open question whether the models
perform real reasoning to reach their conclusions or rely on spurious
correlations. Adversarial attacks have proven to be an important tool to help
evaluate the Achilles' heel of the victim models. In this study, we explore the
fundamental problem of developing attack models based on logic formalism. We
propose NatLogAttack to perform systematic attacks centring around natural
logic, a classical logic formalism that is traceable back to Aristotle's
syllogism and has been closely developed for natural language inference. The
proposed framework renders both label-preserving and label-flipping attacks. We
show that compared to the existing attack models, NatLogAttack generates better
adversarial examples with fewer visits to the victim models. The victim models
are found to be more vulnerable under the label-flipping setting. NatLogAttack
provides a tool to probe the existing and future NLI models' capacity from a
key viewpoint and we hope more logic-based attacks will be further explored for
understanding the desired property of reasoning. | [
0.0266589876,
0.0608582608,
-0.0071540102,
0.0598274991,
-0.0782587975,
0.0107419752,
0.0153361019,
-0.0324355923,
0.0540434904,
-0.0661564618,
-0.0252268594,
0.0287129506,
-0.0007934308,
0.0256217718,
0.0591897815,
-0.0086661521,
0.0409269072,
-0.0114756329,
-0.0126409233,
-0.0165279489,
-0.0249971226,
-0.007674919,
-0.0110993348,
0.0178319681,
0.0285608359,
-0.0337076597,
0.0121205878,
0.0031518014,
0.0157705285,
-0.0121205561,
0.0044552996,
0.0130350627,
-0.0118776774,
0.0402599983,
0.000001928,
-0.015352862,
0.0147657953,
0.0425466821,
-0.037008252,
0.0150219295,
0.0180696025,
-0.007798715,
0.0016296348,
0.0158601031,
-0.0304331612,
-0.0299583748,
0.0171806719,
0.1153241545,
0.0552074164,
0.1050202847,
-0.0111064268,
-0.1027542651,
0.0119034033,
-0.0401792414,
-0.0347540826,
-0.0563137308,
0.0222814865,
0.0002247378,
-0.0107720783,
0.0139032081,
0.0290064234,
0.0221944805,
0.0300015826,
0.0287523251,
-0.0488915332,
0.0442135148,
-0.0229060352,
0.0015352031,
0.008055469,
0.0571972243,
-0.0084499903,
0.0144429822,
-0.0055527706,
0.0137178572,
0.0165731851,
-0.0167272091,
0.0022420327,
0.0170307625,
-0.0198624935,
-0.0070339744,
0.0939962417,
0.0011416055,
0.0546970852,
-0.014507018,
-0.0355023332,
0.0588094778,
0.0215543695,
0.0067968303,
0.0113115106,
-0.0046290406,
-0.0202197172,
-0.0289228018,
0.013313679,
-0.0085303914,
-0.0004507025,
0.0212621596,
-0.0384542495,
-0.01365765,
0.0143048773,
-0.0275446735,
-0.0026958627,
0.0027682933,
0.0264713336,
0.0513588674,
-0.022883229,
0.0021262437,
-0.0309732426,
0.0642077476,
-0.0157413837,
-0.0300112218,
-0.0278679021,
-0.0300174169,
0.0186988618,
0.0338367224,
0.0067222789,
0.0345916227,
-0.0089379167,
0.0140094394,
-0.0400489494,
0.0331805311,
-0.0190145988,
0.0116024148,
0.0056352895,
-0.0262043029,
-0.0029865117,
0.0184127204,
-0.0298718102,
0.0124573661,
-0.0136551531,
-0.0875739455,
-0.0433570072,
0.0020714249,
-0.0575559661,
-0.0119306128,
0.0307659097,
0.1174373478,
0.0261955839,
-0.0318358503,
-0.0526760742,
-0.0432444029,
-0.0053288732,
-0.0291589554,
-0.001224221,
-0.0380588658,
-0.0060485261,
0.0007957075,
-0.0299178604,
-0.0564298369,
-0.0181505978,
-0.0080575598,
-0.0586965531,
0.0814001784,
0.0228330158,
-0.031749513,
0.001332261,
0.0049079526,
-0.0169467721,
0.0384034365,
-0.0227144435,
0.0097934082,
-0.0008655725,
0.0420159101,
-0.0085497629,
0.0021748021,
0.0331258178,
-0.0248742457,
-0.0162634831,
0.0343805701,
0.0006808911,
-0.0073342519,
-0.0317150131,
0.0523687974,
-0.0277029388,
-0.0888714567,
0.0463060401,
0.0203308929,
-0.0371554829,
0.0221639741,
0.0187652875,
-0.048008211,
0.0030527767,
0.0051164343,
-0.0858914331,
0.0154085672,
-0.065045476,
-0.0310447458,
-0.011965245,
0.0342691429,
-0.0290826801,
-0.0733767673,
-0.014541205,
-0.0157334674,
-0.0058474676,
0.009270885,
0.0419930518,
0.0658905208,
0.0037943989,
0.0628139377,
0.0152375493,
-0.0202349611,
-0.009939434,
-0.0566952936,
-0.0001587451,
-0.021815367,
0.0656893104,
-0.0564129241,
-0.0125215976,
-0.0096229138,
-0.0444561467,
0.0120291328,
0.0394456796,
0.0101544969,
0.0063618058,
0.003798435,
0.0153524289,
-0.0713216737,
0.0519861393,
0.0293968525,
-0.0196614228,
0.0220991932,
-0.0000937354,
-0.0181355886,
0.0046041105,
0.0349652879,
0.0028421767,
-0.0102983369,
0.0064663626,
0.012680674,
0.0392211601,
-0.0032673639,
-0.0444217958,
0.034942396,
0.0540435351,
-0.0367742442,
-0.0380872004,
0.0055360007,
0.0195658114,
-0.0631099045,
0.0072856648,
-0.0720334649,
-0.0357126668,
0.0565358438,
-0.0649938062,
0.019275561,
0.0663235039,
-0.057379432,
-0.0190748777,
-0.011399704,
-0.0347820744,
0.0204864852,
-0.0043254266,
-0.003846755,
0.0955273658,
-0.0205569733,
0.0013728357,
-0.025220003,
0.0125806844,
0.0004840968,
-0.0251400508,
-0.0040041255,
0.0348198973,
-0.018987637,
-0.0513796881,
-0.0042495164,
-0.026868023,
0.0075942213,
-0.0274326317,
-0.0149925835,
-0.0156206451,
-0.025261309,
0.0449549481,
0.0226293709,
-0.0087169018,
0.0061235707,
0.0008888029,
-0.0104032541,
-0.0250043683,
-0.0126415323,
0.0219642948,
0.0232161619,
-0.0256703328,
-0.013261715,
0.0011203159,
-0.0047449674,
-0.034334708,
0.0699060783,
0.0130044026,
0.0137093039,
-0.0225499459,
-0.0037543986,
-0.0522620007,
0.0277853105,
-0.0288302582,
-0.0112804687,
0.0280635543,
0.0098871626,
-0.0081061907,
0.1020307988,
0.0149102015,
0.0158422887,
0.0410685204,
-0.0042175525,
0.0045978227,
-0.000962395,
-0.0104750143,
0.0098861,
-0.0332483202,
-0.0346205942,
0.0052995742,
0.0676189661,
0.0154971424,
-0.0185290389,
-0.0081597501,
0.0656589717,
-0.0313080922,
-0.0002841832,
0.0163130537,
0.0056011914,
0.0288444757,
-0.0102440957,
0.0046111401,
0.0048076878,
0.0910527855,
-0.0036252046,
0.0146530075,
-0.0679538399,
-0.0356472656,
-0.019561613,
0.0696718171,
0.0345840827,
0.0055448059,
0.0551104583,
0.008536322,
-0.0199433528,
-0.0410105176,
0.0645071417,
-0.0098906709,
0.0106595019,
-0.0332559645,
-0.0029867035,
-0.0070037399,
-0.0363178886,
-0.0400475226,
-0.0432800017,
-0.058482375,
-0.01258271,
-0.0608780719,
0.0106566977,
-0.0408699289,
-0.0056513706,
0.0130599709,
-0.0162306372,
0.0119282668,
0.003033333,
-0.0195668526,
0.0256987959,
0.0281998888,
-0.0345603712,
0.0164636672,
0.0346196108,
-0.0057478943,
0.0743644908,
-0.0099387001,
0.0516120978,
-0.028597936,
0.0099050589,
-0.0311240498,
0.0194460005,
-0.0254773702,
-0.0209711008,
0.0021670926,
-0.037027888,
0.0030246447,
0.0401634946,
0.0038766169,
0.0383569784,
-0.0025127993,
-0.0215858798,
0.0108504174,
0.0032666863,
-0.0118656103,
-0.0451574847,
-0.061203178,
0.0272180978,
0.0059068417,
-0.0129086217,
-0.0293770581,
-0.0164747313,
-0.0888064802,
0.0031976686,
-0.0023981116,
-0.043452505,
-0.0422845408,
-0.0670943335,
0.002915998,
-0.0317419656,
-0.0089179669,
-0.0202278364,
0.0386298597,
0.0218319986,
-0.0256620124,
-0.0169959981,
-0.0321969539,
0.0405865647,
-0.0367690511,
0.03433384,
0.0243355744,
0.0464318544,
-0.0279259793,
-0.0408358313,
0.0109442854,
-0.0265414231,
-0.0212912261,
-0.0072819977,
0.0469429828,
-0.0099067846,
-0.0203829147,
-0.0036034628,
0.0536175556,
0.0040405975,
-0.0288724396,
0.0023053614,
0.0572068579,
0.0049866461,
-0.0347043388,
-0.0343359858,
0.0171065647,
-0.0108215408,
0.0817686915,
0.0035586776,
-0.0122671369,
-0.070380047,
-0.0686764717,
-0.0147326794,
0.0012241281,
-0.1025931537,
0.0669760853,
0.0337012596,
-0.0990802199,
-0.0442509204,
-0.0286048595,
-0.0257082582,
0.0258681402,
-0.0131846461,
0.0013028102,
0.0093794884,
0.006278804,
-0.0315160044,
0.0239866208,
-0.054372184,
0.03053331,
0.0208878014,
0.0547176786,
0.0405583866,
0.0198046155,
-0.0373314433,
0.0570308901,
-0.0617095083,
-0.0763562098,
-0.0271890499,
0.0376550332,
0.0159569867,
0.0291207433,
-0.057257425,
-0.0147177214,
-0.0024588937,
0.0711204633,
0.011012489,
0.0224975348,
0.0817589313,
-0.0503242761,
0.0392978452,
0.0621418059,
-0.0277713928,
0.0046617328,
0.0523800366,
0.0323115401,
-0.0344870649,
0.0063363858,
0.0089735761,
0.0298948158,
0.0683723465,
0.0800983682,
-0.0111673065,
0.0155661404,
0.0218162145,
-0.0341847353,
-0.0283066276,
0.0039565079,
0.041448798,
-0.0099647539,
0.0230227672,
-0.0130334953,
0.0031971962,
-0.0032589394,
0.0227470454,
0.0439643338,
-0.026371466,
0.0542720892,
0.0400478244,
-0.0083503332,
-0.0341148563,
-0.0432440229,
-0.0372579731,
0.0005006362,
0.0482198969,
-0.0251780096,
0.0258156657,
0.054011263,
-0.0109453313,
-0.0472140461,
-0.0249514468,
-0.0794620514,
-0.0394286513,
0.0608859919,
-0.0096472232,
0.0359787457,
0.0119876964,
-0.0237777196,
-0.0088489447,
0.001136417,
0.0079553854,
0.0058097169,
0.0266563669,
-0.0301019177,
0.0493717305,
-0.0040853797,
0.006619385,
0.0073773777,
0.0279798098,
-0.0202413853,
0.0581337959,
0.0198063776,
-0.0099517619,
-0.0335078053,
-0.0774699822,
-0.0195862018,
-0.0239137076,
0.0014376373,
0.0087176226,
-0.0685418919,
-0.0849274918,
0.0175241269,
0.0349974111,
0.0053828396,
0.0171641614,
-0.0107898479,
0.0598679669,
0.054612115,
-0.0299838316,
-0.0433747433,
0.0633036792,
-0.012938505,
-0.0367907695,
0.0105903419,
-5.935629704e-33,
-0.0094674751,
-0.0073342775,
-0.0130692404,
0.0101613784,
0.0094323233,
-0.0269046966,
-0.0280791819,
-0.024942603,
-0.064048484,
0.0227383375,
0.0183044709,
0.0478603914,
-0.0084901955,
0.0003169444,
-0.0586769059,
-0.0675019324,
-0.0095915077,
0.0012366286,
-0.0063023209,
0.0090173492,
0.0305360202,
-0.0171797052,
0.0442835763,
-0.0746100023,
0.028022645,
0.0071590515,
0.0180685688,
0.0058658863,
-0.0662227347,
-0.0017982002,
0.0098581333,
-0.0017039275,
0.0011775692,
-0.0274398811,
0.037367437,
0.0158102065,
-0.048263289,
-0.0446672291,
0.0141248843,
0.0179134812,
-0.0393462069,
-0.0134745892,
0.0228866767,
0.0322263129,
0.0106594283,
-0.0169304069,
0.0066747353,
-0.0089918738,
0.0311796796,
0.0205661394,
-0.0126153762,
-0.0011465381,
-0.0195703115,
0.0108552566,
-0.0421923846,
0.0577168688,
0.0305483602,
-0.0275048893,
-0.0667541176,
-0.0009226796,
-0.0156931132,
-0.0110218637,
0.034995392,
-0.0176280513,
0.0237573348,
0.0630840361,
0.0544645004,
-0.013532375,
-0.0661674589,
0.0291123446,
-0.0136001604,
0.0494495556,
0.0961685181,
0.0659282506,
0.0470779948,
0.0270500965,
-0.0961148292,
-0.014376658,
0.0165583622,
0.0373499356,
0.0331249572,
-0.0026973833,
-0.0323885716,
0.014881406,
-0.025571445,
-0.0767193735,
-0.044915501,
0.0039874995,
-0.0007286973,
0.0026886889,
-0.0159792975,
-0.0061547449,
-0.0225735474,
-0.0445638448,
0.0059453892,
0.0430237912,
0.0339327529,
-0.045764342,
0.0028240778,
0.0405346453,
-0.0049692737,
0.0112315742,
0.0176900625,
-0.0265485886,
0.0425638109,
-0.0076025319,
0.0328029655,
-0.0088994252,
0.0064566829,
-0.0377071165,
-0.0144071346,
0.0160866305,
-0.0120888492,
-0.0025299266,
0.067296356,
0.0492421389,
-0.008311118,
0.0073584458,
0.0335696191,
0.0198574569,
-0.0312131755,
0.0493304953,
0.0143861063,
0.0057043182,
-0.0118770497,
-0.0447217748,
-0.035641674,
0.0283325575,
-0.0036720436,
-0.0862349868,
-0.0179897007,
-0.0145291872,
2.776e-7,
0.0332888998,
-0.0109806014,
0.0040199328,
0.0563672297,
0.0378627256,
0.0815068483,
0.0109496433,
0.0562630743,
0.0283230711,
-0.0652597174,
-0.0361501388,
0.0306081474,
0.0280438419,
0.0489253737,
-0.075754106,
0.0300562456,
-0.0455007292,
-0.0262492914,
-0.0174410585,
0.0014653783,
0.0918169618,
0.1028602496,
0.0668168589,
-0.009014328,
-0.0107958475,
-0.0701419786,
0.032644894,
0.0235438831,
-0.0086842533,
-0.0517687201,
0.0560661927,
0.0187503826,
0.0071913241,
0.0630145743,
0.011750591,
-0.0046662739,
-0.0139124896,
0.0182193629,
-0.0199880395,
-0.0278571509,
-0.0755948946,
-0.0539833643,
-0.0131849675,
-0.0155262453,
0.1219262183,
-0.0349918045,
-0.0294138584,
0.0113903088,
-0.0261740983,
0.0106723346,
0.0467464626,
0.0221596211,
-0.0410980619,
0.0018637681,
0.0129132336,
-0.0291196927,
0.0069339755,
-0.0785854533,
-0.0001289329,
0.0082311695,
-0.0403225608,
0.0188291222,
0.0278519932,
0.033881288,
0.0676009879,
-0.0105892001,
-0.0352317877,
2.390859312e-34,
-0.0055690962,
-0.0363705531,
0.0075569721,
0.0090710102,
0.0556007586,
-0.0139371548,
-0.0535407402,
-0.0270530302,
0.0101565085,
-0.0544311106,
-0.0266147703
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.02839v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.02839v2 | Enhancing LLM with Evolutionary Fine Tuning for News Summary Generation | 2023-07-06T08:13:53 | 2023-07-08T07:50:44 | Le Xiao, Xiaolin Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | News summary generation is an important task in the field of intelligence
analysis, which can provide accurate and comprehensive information to help
people better understand and respond to complex real-world events. However,
traditional news summary generation methods face some challenges, which are
limited by the model itself and the amount of training data, as well as the
influence of text noise, making it difficult to generate reliable information
accurately. In this paper, we propose a new paradigm for news summary
generation using LLM with powerful natural language understanding and
generative capabilities. We use LLM to extract multiple structured event
patterns from the events contained in news paragraphs, evolve the event pattern
population with genetic algorithm, and select the most adaptive event pattern
to input into the LLM to generate news summaries. A News Summary Generator
(NSG) is designed to select and evolve the event pattern populations and
generate news summaries. The experimental results show that the news summary
generator is able to generate accurate and reliable news summaries with some
generalization ability. | [
0.0489604063,
0.0218815245,
-0.0054940307,
0.0320420638,
-0.0181781873,
-0.0014365988,
-0.0459166355,
0.0077260854,
0.0031452754,
-0.0377507955,
0.0411654562,
-0.0102799106,
-0.0201974902,
0.0578711778,
-0.0047511281,
-0.0668245852,
0.0352367908,
-0.0002306495,
0.0263179671,
0.0207256433,
0.0349236764,
0.0293067172,
0.0090913996,
-0.0106762946,
-0.0026888133,
0.0456811674,
-0.0307594128,
-0.012124978,
0.0478102677,
-0.0545831472,
-0.011999229,
-0.004346122,
0.0494040437,
0.0018567014,
0.0000016158,
-0.0680784956,
-0.0348965563,
-0.0206632875,
0.0432577468,
-0.0165184792,
0.0157300849,
-0.0269498806,
-0.0006574471,
-0.0025510837,
-0.0494242311,
0.012754132,
-0.026875658,
0.0449302569,
0.0636731163,
0.1196413785,
-0.0087268315,
-0.0376546197,
0.0306009278,
-0.0024993808,
0.0260166544,
-0.0392259024,
-0.005563871,
-0.0084092589,
0.0085654361,
-0.0127917584,
0.0195419919,
-0.0245806035,
-0.016465785,
-0.0068713948,
-0.0345524848,
0.0393599533,
-0.0065105315,
0.0107282791,
-0.0175465662,
0.0385290757,
-0.0060865195,
0.0043765195,
0.0522016473,
0.0001794274,
0.0275637861,
-0.0058029317,
-0.0684188381,
0.0639569834,
-0.0519060716,
0.0422895178,
0.0433770157,
0.0060285828,
-0.0340103768,
0.0055502336,
-0.0162012391,
0.0402318016,
0.0099636838,
-0.0225638282,
-0.0554481298,
-0.0230573546,
-0.020897517,
-0.0580359213,
0.0150677329,
0.0765832663,
-0.0422820523,
0.0196796823,
-0.0761630312,
-0.0262193959,
0.0008069556,
-0.0787680373,
-0.0107073579,
0.0219178982,
0.0299721826,
0.0223597512,
-0.0138846468,
-0.0192031823,
0.0099802781,
-0.0317954905,
-0.0491522327,
0.0042954264,
-0.0446775965,
0.016990969,
0.0044536032,
0.0868279338,
-0.0576956272,
-0.0361938253,
-0.0374078006,
0.054458715,
0.0630588457,
0.0070688613,
-0.0249388665,
0.018685529,
-0.0384119861,
-0.0017286093,
-0.0414407551,
-0.0544484518,
-0.0497301631,
-0.0305741243,
0.0281964801,
0.0245663729,
0.0021831833,
0.0297859218,
0.0389926396,
0.0456657074,
-0.0205788314,
0.0611985475,
-0.0380040817,
-0.0158948079,
-0.0989287049,
-0.0254842546,
-0.015560505,
-0.0182706527,
0.0006919052,
-0.0370388962,
0.0166900214,
-0.0059867403,
-0.0540420078,
0.0048902724,
0.0382638164,
0.0228970144,
-0.0445635132,
-0.0120869186,
-0.0733906478,
0.0163921826,
0.0310797747,
-0.009553819,
0.0425234884,
0.0814571902,
0.070691891,
0.0304942448,
0.0550765283,
0.019679876,
0.0115288431,
-0.009911838,
-0.0060893269,
-0.0073160715,
0.0128033841,
-0.0124489376,
-0.0524358712,
0.0017194719,
0.037858285,
0.0183633808,
-0.0106902784,
0.0451977849,
0.0550623126,
0.0348609239,
-0.0024872958,
0.0940976292,
0.0256972797,
0.0257621985,
-0.0088938223,
0.0713101476,
0.0271144286,
0.0323102102,
-0.0814118087,
0.0434383638,
0.0056819781,
0.0291081723,
-0.0154125709,
-0.0428888313,
0.0040262113,
0.0154563738,
0.0253676884,
-0.0214547869,
0.0131234061,
0.0242422801,
-0.0505632237,
0.0509169735,
0.028796941,
-0.0466042608,
0.0132181775,
-0.0264946688,
0.0637006462,
0.0759301335,
0.0474200137,
-0.011394674,
-0.067801401,
0.0220780559,
-0.0061640823,
0.066554375,
0.0316885635,
0.0028581943,
-0.0435810536,
-0.0440366268,
-0.0252914596,
-0.0322983637,
-0.0051443982,
0.0013586492,
0.0131495763,
0.015885612,
0.0358367786,
0.0303680208,
-0.0565352738,
0.0395215563,
-0.018582711,
-0.0058328821,
-0.0025952153,
-0.0453203544,
0.0287433863,
0.0136942994,
0.0141530959,
0.0037281297,
0.0221710019,
-0.0173399039,
-0.0431512669,
0.0567567982,
-0.0251631066,
-0.0291730631,
0.0106179882,
-0.0593400076,
0.0022939914,
-0.0061939545,
-0.0568907857,
-0.0572900251,
0.0139504913,
-0.064921163,
0.0320175774,
-0.0471845753,
0.0212406069,
-0.0000039701,
-0.0209404789,
-0.0170489103,
0.104648754,
-0.0094783204,
-0.0428398773,
0.0092338175,
0.0172053408,
-0.0102910353,
-0.0567457378,
0.003245471,
0.0021298761,
0.0010274701,
-0.0233554076,
0.0562208444,
0.0279891957,
-0.0250892024,
-0.0505968854,
-0.0616063438,
0.0606290959,
-0.0036520702,
0.0319361612,
0.0689233616,
0.0078988886,
-0.0343993567,
0.023319006,
-0.061648421,
0.004417283,
0.0217052549,
-0.0411239192,
0.039703235,
0.0346366204,
0.002862514,
-0.0472798645,
0.0378689542,
-0.0268405192,
0.0431707948,
0.0586747043,
-0.0248293765,
-0.1044772342,
0.0303352382,
-0.0203541741,
0.0071350788,
-0.0125296339,
0.0017535896,
0.0064441795,
-0.0041926871,
0.0325010344,
0.0461809672,
0.0852224603,
0.0255466308,
-0.0017636872,
-0.0252107978,
-0.0146463895,
0.0343072154,
-0.0783981085,
0.0639924407,
-0.0097953174,
-0.0380861312,
0.060281612,
0.022815356,
0.0304185469,
0.0156075647,
-0.0168102607,
0.0179374535,
0.0307408515,
0.0090899421,
0.016040843,
-0.0266472902,
-0.0277958307,
0.0227623619,
-0.029442044,
0.0036395653,
0.0564284287,
0.0168775767,
0.0470883027,
-0.0691128075,
-0.0057106502,
-0.0997300223,
0.0431604646,
-0.0381390192,
0.0429937318,
-0.0295024496,
-0.0265430417,
-0.036652118,
-0.0249008704,
0.0032454322,
-0.0013677814,
0.0495916344,
-0.0691166148,
-0.0109790061,
0.0095495423,
0.0027579919,
-0.0380987898,
-0.0129985707,
0.0147265,
-0.015931664,
0.0546045788,
-0.0059286486,
-0.0417064205,
0.0295158755,
0.0355438292,
0.0161276385,
-0.0332792513,
-0.0152603714,
-0.0127407275,
0.0573744066,
0.0727995038,
0.0162448995,
-0.0042465692,
-0.0058697718,
-0.0064330157,
0.0390466414,
0.0008643303,
0.0281950813,
-0.0001930749,
0.000624214,
0.0111952787,
-0.0807980895,
-0.0208997615,
0.0039073774,
0.0332497098,
-0.0451732278,
0.0337490812,
0.1024561003,
0.0336996876,
0.0155851291,
0.0286262129,
0.0069271368,
-0.0161518585,
0.0061643333,
0.0451717339,
-0.0449072868,
0.0166263245,
-0.0240759514,
0.0200733487,
-0.010154576,
-0.0352624469,
-0.0312579013,
-0.0549462736,
0.0005175979,
0.022114696,
-0.0493546538,
-0.0120104747,
-0.0171674024,
0.0062811607,
0.0017317228,
-0.0305233076,
0.0343699344,
-0.0144376382,
-0.0141759505,
0.0044033164,
-0.0932647362,
-0.0416368283,
-0.0277068801,
-0.0145385657,
-0.0030788137,
0.0693423972,
0.0335959233,
-0.0097971158,
0.0406935662,
0.023378538,
0.0135268383,
0.0289452039,
-0.0252796225,
0.0180017073,
-0.0199385844,
0.0143388156,
-0.0563008152,
0.0682453588,
0.0464473814,
-0.0237139873,
0.041198004,
0.0122004598,
-0.008525339,
-0.0625202283,
-0.0556074269,
0.0207739323,
0.0097504091,
0.0678330213,
0.0350267924,
-0.0326304361,
-0.0018392097,
-0.0266841855,
-0.0234346986,
-0.1211662069,
-0.0303541683,
0.016767066,
-0.0203223955,
-0.0305675697,
-0.0969388857,
-0.0290205237,
0.0095026148,
0.0062098214,
0.0022868244,
-0.007928188,
0.021981651,
-0.0209353361,
-0.0311558023,
-0.0265766326,
-0.0103362575,
-0.0762562826,
-0.0118313935,
-0.039255742,
0.0484809764,
-0.0260581952,
-0.0152319083,
0.0473155826,
-0.0522219352,
-0.0407985337,
-0.023998525,
0.0147612402,
0.0175597128,
0.0605207942,
0.0176032688,
-0.0066100187,
0.0996955931,
0.0257762261,
0.0480397902,
0.0087956637,
-0.054641448,
0.0495897532,
0.0023387,
-0.0160494745,
-0.0428866781,
0.0341853499,
-0.0214418024,
0.0578257963,
-0.0477405563,
-0.0265534353,
0.0096853198,
0.0268683415,
-0.0270675588,
-0.0522085354,
-0.0353082791,
-0.0249896646,
-0.0166367386,
-0.0269175377,
0.0030132604,
-0.0219213814,
0.0199640766,
-0.0376922674,
-0.0253642574,
0.0039324341,
0.0326619297,
-0.0415974259,
0.0335465409,
-0.0620000772,
-0.013074779,
-0.0253807623,
-0.0107397418,
-0.0223482195,
0.0088914717,
-0.0362922996,
0.0074878922,
-0.0238475855,
-0.003945882,
0.0026826139,
0.0116559369,
0.0084225377,
-0.003991283,
0.0095753819,
0.0280172601,
-0.0636256412,
0.0269920938,
-0.0684178323,
0.0573216975,
0.0675062016,
0.0001830006,
0.0275841951,
-0.0051414277,
0.0096871695,
0.0172327794,
0.0344832875,
-0.0027462309,
-0.027356321,
-0.0038204344,
0.0153974388,
-0.0261213928,
-0.0256783292,
0.0718044862,
-0.0199190751,
0.0279363655,
0.0072602103,
-0.025673287,
-0.0780373365,
-0.026128266,
0.0347967707,
0.0208313651,
-0.000031505,
-0.0347837061,
-0.0394311622,
0.0290394183,
0.0510543324,
0.028611958,
0.0592033863,
-0.0140943779,
0.0320191346,
0.0348760374,
0.0047572972,
-0.0078968974,
-0.0300068054,
-0.0163792223,
-0.0371753126,
-0.0348431505,
0.0119939419,
-5.435543184e-33,
-0.0449386761,
-0.0374419428,
0.0247676801,
0.059586741,
-0.0320891552,
-0.0163085591,
-0.0541436188,
-0.0265642758,
0.0206875857,
-0.0372508876,
0.0088662459,
-0.0278945006,
-0.0009181828,
-0.0064038755,
-0.0043350519,
0.0071397391,
0.0240555126,
-0.0051060347,
-0.0066792099,
0.0357841365,
0.0375195034,
0.0338441767,
0.0588356443,
-0.0291361157,
0.0031389082,
-0.0325370543,
-0.0228636544,
-0.0075800358,
0.067393139,
0.0230448376,
-0.0008779621,
0.0004778878,
0.027816657,
-0.0200541001,
-0.0509743281,
0.0325503238,
-0.0151304975,
-0.042950917,
0.0483039469,
-0.0436428189,
-0.0178777687,
-0.0465084165,
0.046071738,
-0.0091545731,
0.015790008,
0.0121330079,
0.0602989681,
-0.0430204049,
-0.0039604884,
-0.0955426767,
-0.0476668663,
0.0251473803,
-0.0121228527,
0.0090082632,
-0.0653930753,
-0.0025532143,
0.0155656245,
-0.0072256499,
0.0068545085,
0.050779622,
0.0314021744,
0.0206429958,
0.0258958414,
-0.0221676528,
-0.0130308596,
0.0455102809,
-0.0283444319,
0.0134713519,
-0.0424291156,
0.0290026963,
-0.0022912843,
0.0574655533,
-0.0062424298,
0.0492177196,
0.0102767739,
-0.0070947716,
-0.0743680149,
0.1107670516,
0.0340258107,
-0.0079371501,
0.025954416,
0.0155530702,
-0.006070991,
0.0160480589,
0.0133998822,
0.0394939035,
-0.0009071162,
-0.0378611721,
-0.0034581046,
0.0198386181,
-0.0286388192,
0.0087770913,
-0.0117604965,
-0.0182647761,
0.0290641263,
-0.0121427784,
-0.0519222505,
0.0083083715,
-0.004807638,
0.0024865901,
-0.0315790959,
-0.0539432094,
0.02573964,
0.0033891294,
-0.0033116327,
0.0105705755,
0.0240286626,
0.0106171621,
-0.0159581266,
0.0263442863,
0.0229903124,
0.0105678169,
0.0007957433,
-0.0546187982,
-0.0204251278,
-0.0045790724,
-0.0030086371,
-0.0148214791,
0.0473082811,
0.0269739218,
-0.0107155712,
0.0085817641,
0.0112597886,
0.0705528334,
-0.0016643383,
0.0443208106,
0.0163422916,
0.0173613951,
-0.0291217193,
-0.0191179998,
-0.0322541893,
0.0487955548,
2.351e-7,
0.0112939021,
0.0447526947,
0.0282974225,
0.03256616,
-0.0002304084,
-0.000545807,
-0.0027988723,
0.0492844917,
0.015109119,
-0.0138782021,
0.0431696922,
0.0313105844,
0.0016962513,
0.054343611,
-0.1041661203,
-0.0104500521,
-0.0445043184,
-0.0196045432,
-0.0682645962,
0.017451087,
0.0881445557,
0.0074010259,
-0.0097051524,
0.0009971957,
0.0122301951,
-0.0256745536,
0.0461006276,
0.0112722721,
-0.0725509822,
0.0454319455,
0.0094615407,
0.0272333976,
-0.0650114268,
-0.0271114055,
-0.0127822552,
0.0051233419,
-0.0290353838,
0.0226244181,
0.0233027283,
-0.0137050943,
0.0710380748,
0.0069259796,
0.0271776617,
-0.0002494369,
0.052903749,
-0.060733594,
-0.0007141299,
-0.0343231373,
-0.0469333939,
-0.0035294273,
-0.0744007826,
-0.0267171338,
-0.011361951,
0.0341942273,
-0.0183750745,
-0.0127153518,
0.0136202686,
-0.0434797741,
-0.0002168803,
0.0168306045,
-0.0551770255,
-0.0290221274,
-0.0215092544,
-0.0137747377,
0.0093043931,
-0.0443316922,
0.0227009673,
2.006855613e-34,
0.0310991909,
0.044691667,
-0.0522012673,
-0.005376996,
0.031438183,
0.0304562412,
-0.042701453,
0.013823675,
0.026238976,
-0.0375917479,
-0.0296126287
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.04532v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.04532v1 | Read, Look or Listen? What's Needed for Solving a Multimodal Dataset | 2023-07-06T08:02:45 | 2023-07-06T08:02:45 | Netta Madvil, Yonatan Bitton, Roy Schwartz | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, eess.AS | The prevalence of large-scale multimodal datasets presents unique challenges
in assessing dataset quality. We propose a two-step method to analyze
multimodal datasets, which leverages a small seed of human annotation to map
each multimodal instance to the modalities required to process it. Our method
sheds light on the importance of different modalities in datasets, as well as
the relationship between them. We apply our approach to TVQA, a video
question-answering dataset, and discover that most questions can be answered
using a single modality, without a substantial bias towards any specific
modality. Moreover, we find that more than 70% of the questions are solvable
using several different single-modality strategies, e.g., by either looking at
the video or listening to the audio, highlighting the limited integration of
multiple modalities in TVQA. We leverage our annotation and analyze the MERLOT
Reserve, finding that it struggles with image-based questions compared to text
and audio, but also with auditory speaker identification. Based on our
observations, we introduce a new test set that necessitates multiple
modalities, observing a dramatic drop in model performance. Our methodology
provides valuable insights into multimodal datasets and highlights the need for
the development of more robust models. | [
-0.0005061296,
0.0541453511,
-0.0266189184,
0.0427040681,
-0.0045445478,
0.0191441681,
0.0387515798,
-0.0083993049,
-0.0293522459,
-0.0623241551,
-0.0532612316,
-0.0276655164,
-0.0164928436,
0.0104052126,
0.0475300625,
-0.0625589713,
0.0163669437,
-0.0377037749,
0.0036024661,
0.0184926689,
0.0413659997,
-0.0188474227,
-0.0328321941,
0.0404628776,
-0.0617936663,
-0.0221534837,
-0.0207578037,
-0.00690166,
0.0250583645,
-0.0159143899,
-0.0156379715,
0.0509616435,
0.0394280329,
0.0106236022,
0.0000017874,
-0.0040539312,
0.0452337638,
-0.0133748483,
0.008805424,
-0.0197751187,
0.0007546903,
0.0237991065,
0.0412309691,
0.033526212,
-0.0361892208,
-0.0158527829,
0.0524792261,
0.0020300387,
0.0531218834,
0.0123620592,
-0.0211469866,
-0.0317237973,
0.0196781643,
0.0228455644,
0.0803992525,
-0.0250332355,
-0.0092797959,
0.0379252881,
0.0348553807,
-0.0080887089,
-0.053604655,
0.056235373,
0.0215632487,
0.010068533,
0.004953871,
0.0093356436,
-0.0276963077,
-0.0371242538,
-0.0102545395,
0.1208383739,
0.0664243847,
0.0330162495,
0.0003947245,
0.0184994824,
0.0220486391,
0.0469617471,
-0.0413708761,
0.0125761181,
-0.0308924057,
-0.030580448,
-0.0775519907,
-0.0078836372,
0.0212440193,
-0.0169863254,
0.0418946445,
0.0070648198,
0.0046806987,
0.0145939086,
-0.0000210254,
0.0027039899,
-0.0176115017,
-0.0313291773,
-0.0113541177,
0.0049852682,
0.0019973605,
-0.0012546625,
-0.0464231446,
-0.0071310564,
0.0058024628,
-0.0285827052,
0.0301176086,
0.0387594625,
-0.0852669254,
0.0678604394,
0.0093936827,
-0.0021946782,
-0.010976309,
0.015263984,
-0.0079484181,
-0.0234388784,
-0.0663373098,
0.0022262668,
-0.0003143134,
-0.0109627154,
-0.0145778507,
-0.0276846569,
0.0095674461,
0.0191051308,
-0.0279143155,
-0.0131642874,
-0.0511281341,
0.0142390961,
0.0051386477,
0.0389754064,
-0.036106091,
0.0614092089,
-0.0631535947,
0.0729743168,
0.0176310092,
-0.0929621086,
0.0262420643,
0.0149328662,
0.0141514195,
-0.0291470271,
0.0181863923,
0.0609885156,
-0.0245442707,
-0.0353253782,
-0.0255642347,
-0.0547590628,
-0.0146988016,
-0.0325856246,
0.0400040336,
-0.0490224697,
0.0714315176,
0.0110621946,
-0.0167563874,
0.0127043473,
-0.0271343738,
0.021786321,
-0.0078264307,
0.11086981,
0.0356055237,
0.0215437524,
0.0438398346,
0.0374736264,
-0.0196350683,
0.0690214932,
0.0230339952,
-0.0161096044,
0.0527583845,
-0.0214880165,
0.0371470116,
0.0462426171,
-0.0119861197,
0.0079711471,
-0.0021236755,
0.0413039438,
-0.016405547,
0.0193676166,
0.0306622703,
0.0201903768,
-0.0439158678,
-0.0742049292,
0.0632084832,
0.0384513885,
-0.0177563801,
-0.039012596,
0.0010518143,
-0.0280166287,
0.0316198319,
0.0135094142,
-0.0057286443,
0.0621945672,
0.0000025247,
-0.0124662546,
0.0461642407,
-0.0093427831,
-0.0561673939,
-0.0170579441,
-0.0299377684,
0.0241911747,
0.0141377151,
0.0454003662,
-0.0013375431,
-0.0140739586,
0.001599999,
0.0095407013,
-0.0025233387,
-0.0480855852,
-0.0101948539,
-0.0313248299,
0.0225201529,
0.0127715068,
0.0064245844,
-0.0313254967,
-0.0250431653,
-0.0081512639,
0.0662569776,
0.0164790936,
0.0201707948,
-0.0353452191,
0.0484060608,
-0.0450670458,
-0.0502275117,
-0.0003913869,
-0.0068238848,
0.0323581621,
-0.0257363003,
-0.0070397286,
-0.0251631644,
-0.0599269867,
0.0595519878,
0.0182271842,
0.020230338,
-0.0021208485,
-0.0093695307,
0.0254228078,
0.0450033396,
0.0184921585,
-0.0047629755,
-0.0053340662,
0.0196952559,
0.0038544449,
0.03981556,
0.0455088206,
-0.022637438,
0.0006512227,
0.048357226,
-0.1088880375,
-0.0341092013,
0.0510067455,
-0.0130457627,
-0.024341736,
0.0094191805,
-0.0682649761,
-0.0147934575,
-0.0425953791,
-0.0386587717,
0.020170128,
0.017602494,
0.0002034533,
0.0238967445,
-0.0201241914,
0.0026745372,
-0.0106162243,
0.0007675517,
0.0400423855,
-0.0395436548,
-0.0301226582,
-0.0027316946,
-0.0242448859,
0.0381632969,
0.0057019228,
-0.0382456742,
-0.0738136396,
-0.0023541246,
-0.1145212799,
-0.025707772,
-0.0122835794,
-0.0013379409,
0.0230723862,
-0.0075543886,
-0.0166115407,
-0.0517896339,
-0.0450130925,
0.0196119733,
0.0039265053,
0.0635885075,
0.0069047301,
0.029861616,
0.0180789027,
-0.0117254229,
-0.0302591827,
-0.0119620692,
0.0369711928,
-0.0049876911,
0.0173244495,
0.003650299,
-0.0315245502,
-0.0483070537,
0.0282080211,
-0.0080217877,
-0.0064454121,
0.0416873284,
0.0009695266,
0.0208452418,
0.0403408222,
-0.0166814867,
0.0088165188,
-0.0024522741,
0.0035508268,
-0.0193003882,
0.0159586351,
0.0267901774,
-0.0066504641,
-0.0055744755,
-0.0621236227,
-0.0406471491,
0.0084780967,
-0.0024985985,
0.0115993926,
-0.0299096256,
0.0305606592,
0.0064330464,
-0.0607224405,
-0.078540802,
0.0093653733,
-0.0101742689,
0.0634147748,
-0.0262624193,
-0.0181347169,
0.0364868082,
-0.0318976976,
-0.0056042476,
0.0161819998,
0.0193242282,
-0.0016475687,
0.0636098757,
-0.0073137241,
0.0065000113,
-0.0308584236,
-0.0270899795,
-0.0667499974,
-0.0222444553,
0.0476739258,
-0.0184984766,
0.0550188795,
-0.0230402853,
0.0018906596,
-0.0198628847,
-0.0419905446,
-0.0190426409,
-0.0287135486,
-0.0327625349,
-0.013421963,
-0.0366850868,
0.0073296069,
-0.0511527136,
0.0101872897,
0.0372093134,
-0.0030985232,
-0.0086921416,
-0.0142014977,
0.0022465766,
0.0738901794,
0.0435999781,
0.0853482038,
-0.0179683529,
-0.0492177568,
0.0092442166,
0.0400575027,
0.0443743542,
-0.02524966,
-0.0161890015,
0.0372576267,
0.0271833949,
0.03769885,
-0.0289044473,
0.0335024744,
0.0648983195,
-0.0367889963,
0.0034824465,
0.0505812913,
0.0006180624,
-0.0430829562,
-0.0259983931,
0.0115357498,
0.0003536912,
0.0400626175,
0.0127951186,
-0.1064517125,
-0.0708946511,
-0.0043258057,
0.0360375531,
0.0209536199,
-0.0195339061,
0.0113614602,
-0.0722549558,
0.0629118383,
-0.0324259922,
-0.0788243562,
-0.0264654066,
-0.0345262811,
0.0112243835,
-0.0387205258,
0.0227597356,
-0.0081570428,
-0.0236471035,
0.0109714121,
0.0314285308,
0.0295025967,
-0.02442169,
0.040946167,
-0.0451301709,
0.0494546443,
0.0348505341,
0.0101663517,
-0.0208260752,
-0.0610458665,
-0.0029194462,
0.0113198915,
0.0016373789,
0.0260145441,
0.0775488392,
-0.022707127,
-0.0246607251,
-0.0127713121,
0.056464754,
0.0062215975,
-0.0453189984,
0.0102485986,
0.0552618913,
-0.0100339912,
0.0377702788,
-0.0540209562,
0.0146646705,
0.0263753682,
0.0662054867,
0.0273932498,
-0.0426245928,
-0.0041910079,
0.0128699765,
0.0008692484,
-0.0321402811,
-0.0368152261,
0.0236247461,
0.0165827405,
-0.0092490669,
-0.0414451472,
-0.048547741,
0.0428933166,
0.0446266681,
-0.0129869441,
-0.012535695,
-0.0240542069,
0.0513639785,
-0.0768309683,
0.0832865462,
-0.0020189756,
0.0184492581,
-0.0641544238,
-0.0298240967,
-0.0021677183,
-0.0627773926,
-0.0188621394,
0.032041695,
-0.0790877566,
-0.0202974752,
-0.0184952468,
0.0360288471,
0.0232613366,
0.0062062345,
0.0343355611,
-0.0806718394,
-0.0074869161,
0.0215935223,
-0.0321356989,
0.0015830492,
0.0155645367,
-0.0058791898,
-0.0252537187,
-0.007044503,
-0.0348634571,
0.0040105944,
-0.0005797435,
0.0068553002,
-0.0188197438,
-0.0096047642,
-0.0131845297,
-0.0113177691,
0.0444254912,
-0.0106494138,
-0.0077575985,
-0.027991984,
-0.0236719474,
0.0279628895,
0.0289153066,
-0.0356064029,
0.0140958624,
0.0169115942,
-0.0020965969,
-0.0139436563,
0.0201368853,
-0.0236727148,
0.0163034424,
-0.0547257103,
0.0200799257,
0.0751203671,
-0.0438244157,
-0.037983153,
0.0162098296,
0.0261370651,
0.0475978591,
0.0122195417,
0.0446498469,
0.033652883,
0.0848823637,
0.0001281496,
-0.0095601575,
0.0160607193,
0.0386370942,
-0.0411162227,
-0.016915461,
-0.0083881002,
0.0439546034,
0.0372305959,
-0.0257318169,
-0.0259698853,
0.020513501,
-0.011598778,
-0.0212902222,
0.0166680161,
0.0033927218,
-0.0235418286,
0.048138883,
0.039104633,
-0.0005454189,
-0.0111531587,
0.0790973827,
-0.0069144801,
0.0206200723,
-0.0474282205,
-0.0128752803,
-0.0300202779,
-0.0014771681,
0.047521513,
0.0481099337,
-0.026869176,
0.0099183591,
-0.0576747842,
-0.081099458,
-0.0354428589,
0.0091846818,
0.0092268456,
0.0451575369,
0.0382227898,
0.0361036509,
0.0133769074,
-0.0245521441,
-0.0359818675,
-0.0043680212,
-0.0479096957,
-0.008648972,
0.0163756479,
-5.776497891e-33,
-0.0109011317,
-0.0072496175,
0.0096655861,
-0.0099653434,
0.0189467501,
0.0203720741,
-0.0120987911,
0.0426328331,
-0.0288243517,
-0.0080672661,
0.0187492091,
0.0012762808,
0.012704731,
0.0251264665,
0.0277950913,
-0.0457199551,
0.0233386774,
-0.0322310552,
-0.036409203,
-0.0149545958,
0.0430245847,
-0.0021028623,
0.0299952365,
-0.0836659446,
-0.0140739018,
0.0173999909,
-0.0245331544,
0.0095876856,
-0.007850159,
0.09136305,
-0.0315599069,
0.0319535807,
0.0229589492,
-0.0238316674,
-0.0203470998,
0.044818338,
-0.0712933689,
0.0044356883,
0.0268150289,
0.0599507987,
-0.0753540024,
-0.0049065761,
0.0364269502,
-0.0335341953,
-0.0179219171,
-0.0521881878,
0.0562750064,
-0.0074853036,
0.0041997028,
-0.0131884152,
-0.0141220232,
0.0146124978,
-0.0252963658,
-0.0712916777,
0.0195212737,
0.0854066834,
0.0247321129,
-0.0165946875,
-0.0717673972,
0.062754184,
-0.0311615095,
-0.0193198565,
0.0888305828,
0.0394277908,
0.0012215293,
0.0602907576,
0.0582296215,
-0.0454676077,
-0.0033999095,
-0.0573593602,
0.0050450992,
0.0693846643,
0.0260413457,
0.0827155933,
0.029570343,
-0.0040474571,
-0.0260761306,
0.054321371,
-0.023000814,
-0.0048024757,
-0.0008569708,
0.0100063207,
-0.0210532136,
0.014856915,
-0.0470984653,
0.0024442684,
-0.0537522845,
-0.0042495732,
0.0603218079,
-0.0158068929,
-0.0131771388,
0.007404678,
0.107656844,
-0.0532537214,
0.0207849499,
0.004048286,
-0.0119006354,
0.0677522346,
0.0272660796,
0.0052179829,
-0.0077386568,
0.0313807875,
0.0667140782,
-0.0135024954,
0.0391521044,
-0.0217942521,
0.0166606959,
0.0410771333,
-0.0568347946,
-0.0304824132,
-0.004438235,
0.0129783591,
0.0092210481,
0.0323677696,
0.0501116626,
0.0020469197,
-0.0413788185,
0.0139215644,
0.0023345358,
0.0239490382,
-0.0411559045,
-0.0685212314,
-0.0421297848,
-0.0162422433,
-0.0147279603,
0.0066150837,
-0.0463985465,
-0.0791154876,
0.0026991931,
-0.0531396009,
0.0005132928,
0.0433194935,
2.548e-7,
0.0158791877,
0.0021415551,
-0.0097406581,
-0.0192259811,
0.048451107,
0.0636092424,
-0.012024371,
0.0307432916,
0.0282605197,
-0.0835315809,
0.007121338,
0.0082257176,
0.0525365099,
0.0566202141,
-0.0465956554,
-0.0276258234,
-0.0228188764,
0.0216113068,
-0.0368784145,
0.0370701477,
0.0264446624,
0.0937017649,
-0.0212062206,
-0.0227376837,
0.0315360948,
-0.029743908,
0.0561394617,
-0.0145664876,
-0.0102650207,
-0.0357414484,
0.0376869664,
0.0118544605,
0.0081047621,
0.0289736763,
-0.0343037993,
-0.0362087451,
0.0564737096,
0.0333042666,
0.0108917877,
-0.0903498307,
-0.0557229146,
0.051116664,
-0.0019569707,
-0.017527353,
0.0786409825,
0.0014531533,
-0.061768692,
-0.0340296701,
-0.0142913572,
0.0000809132,
0.0256631579,
0.0061767926,
-0.0185259301,
0.0020694118,
0.009931338,
-0.0286769681,
-0.0234217476,
-0.0538852625,
-0.0080141351,
-0.0152945463,
-0.074421443,
-0.0419202149,
-0.0207792968,
-0.0480614752,
0.040064618,
-0.0602806509,
-0.0813490897,
1.477953869e-34,
-0.0026811338,
0.0103446729,
0.032537289,
-0.0120631829,
0.0039226729,
-0.0211877637,
-0.0179508254,
-0.0227969941,
0.013312012,
-0.0465281866,
-0.0126479669
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.02830v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.02830v1 | Generative Zero-Shot Prompt Learning for Cross-Domain Slot Filling with Inverse Prompting | 2023-07-06T07:53:46 | 2023-07-06T07:53:46 | Xuefeng Li, Liwen Wang, Guanting Dong, Keqing He, Jinzheng Zhao, Hao Lei, Jiachi Liu, Weiran Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Zero-shot cross-domain slot filling aims to transfer knowledge from the
labeled source domain to the unlabeled target domain. Existing models either
encode slot descriptions and examples or design handcrafted question templates
using heuristic rules, suffering from poor generalization capability or
robustness. In this paper, we propose a generative zero-shot prompt learning
framework for cross-domain slot filling, both improving generalization and
robustness than previous work. Besides, we introduce a novel inverse prompting
strategy to distinguish different slot types to avoid the multiple prediction
problem, and an efficient prompt-tuning strategy to boost higher performance by
only training fewer prompt parameters. Experiments and analysis demonstrate the
effectiveness of our proposed framework, especially huge improvements (+13.44%
F1) on the unseen slots. | [
0.0380258299,
-0.0136980331,
0.0165969487,
-0.0001892799,
0.0088760508,
0.0168292504,
0.0276989397,
0.0035448649,
-0.000215926,
-0.0404939204,
-0.0153382495,
-0.0448058285,
-0.0346261002,
0.0342688896,
0.0240846872,
-0.0174481813,
0.0107753724,
-0.0189817939,
-0.0217907038,
0.029254688,
-0.0331068262,
-0.0188193005,
-0.0568630062,
0.0273267943,
0.0014220949,
-0.053713996,
-0.0427472144,
0.0066806809,
-0.0196894482,
-0.0273178518,
0.0100965817,
0.0635385066,
0.0066804048,
0.006612028,
0.0000020539,
-0.0608063787,
-0.0173961502,
-0.0361996852,
-0.0781891495,
-0.0568505377,
-0.041585613,
-0.0070289057,
0.0204642285,
0.0131271025,
-0.0333556458,
-0.0804954469,
0.0368004553,
0.0593777932,
0.0346775129,
0.0550928824,
-0.0019827269,
0.0105767027,
0.0136871925,
-0.0486612134,
0.0774688423,
-0.0276487004,
0.0182597954,
-0.022516679,
-0.0082462467,
0.0146334758,
-0.0160559751,
0.0051812823,
0.0332557969,
-0.0198966414,
0.0440608896,
0.0266446099,
-0.0125219692,
-0.0022475515,
-0.0279091913,
0.1071507856,
0.0141374459,
-0.0014307292,
-0.0117375413,
-0.0301076379,
0.0466528013,
0.0184716247,
-0.0538540632,
-0.0020651028,
-0.0171535704,
-0.0492061861,
-0.0164135303,
0.0287591442,
-0.0139964167,
-0.0303774439,
0.022081567,
0.0562748536,
0.0175215714,
-0.0485663265,
-0.0234681517,
-0.0105180442,
0.0175468866,
-0.0866234899,
-0.0358981863,
0.0123803234,
-0.0507727005,
0.0019333174,
-0.0224049073,
0.0014858168,
0.0030679002,
0.0667864755,
0.0458035134,
0.037014313,
-0.0378905348,
0.0247005224,
-0.0241236072,
0.0316659287,
-0.0088945199,
0.0108314678,
-0.0728153512,
0.0255285446,
-0.0388070643,
-0.0174000338,
-0.0426037423,
0.0218278561,
-0.0269045886,
0.0112639107,
-0.0131951096,
0.0463181026,
0.0148293599,
0.0489299111,
0.0338399298,
0.0126774563,
-0.0335935727,
-0.0040796218,
-0.0558356307,
0.0436815917,
-0.0473714359,
-0.0032029008,
0.0137225809,
-0.0155784423,
-0.0318064392,
0.0299848672,
0.0070099579,
-0.0296618305,
-0.0357968695,
0.0699393898,
-0.0090720393,
0.0239460692,
-0.0260647349,
-0.0214956105,
0.0080859354,
-0.0597450882,
0.0101161879,
-0.0312352031,
0.0276855063,
0.032723818,
-0.0023803001,
-0.0080723362,
0.005144503,
0.0328446254,
0.0191682838,
0.086355336,
0.0094585456,
-0.0328556038,
0.0467542745,
0.0137560712,
-0.0147484234,
0.0564981624,
-0.0305455904,
0.028708905,
0.0107007194,
-0.0022294351,
0.0414554365,
-0.016464619,
0.0302114915,
-0.0055979434,
0.044472523,
0.0282670818,
0.1189091355,
0.0518891029,
0.0084359767,
-0.0056459801,
-0.0407812446,
-0.0295876227,
-0.0172735844,
0.026445711,
0.0044372366,
-0.0146163944,
0.0945989192,
0.0335316882,
-0.0185243413,
0.0322066583,
-0.0426809937,
0.0474584624,
0.0095745577,
-0.0012806923,
0.0099406829,
-0.0318359099,
-0.042770084,
-0.0245667603,
0.0058633997,
-0.0141506447,
-0.0177674517,
-0.0087951794,
0.0203044731,
0.0034297463,
-0.0788483173,
0.0511778742,
0.0009749034,
-0.0066247466,
-0.0255260784,
-0.016802121,
0.0441102684,
-0.0002255773,
-0.0026003229,
-0.0358878002,
-0.0694209859,
-0.0556222461,
0.034344703,
0.0066502639,
0.0531452335,
-0.0204277448,
0.0057898485,
-0.0336146876,
-0.0566605181,
-0.009570837,
-0.0137560321,
0.0487175323,
-0.023450207,
-0.0032339604,
0.0252834614,
-0.0079388833,
0.0732715577,
0.020428367,
-0.01920023,
-0.0621540695,
0.0375240482,
0.0353847742,
0.0119281607,
0.0053437003,
0.0153287081,
-0.0278755687,
0.0052492339,
-0.0353502035,
-0.0254758205,
-0.0263038315,
-0.0834099948,
-0.0515689142,
-0.0005168983,
-0.0224106517,
-0.0342846774,
-0.0120464098,
-0.0311415549,
-0.021922702,
-0.000528653,
0.0483084284,
0.0154424571,
-0.0560670421,
-0.0283902269,
0.054053057,
-0.0120953526,
-0.0254189484,
0.0776501894,
0.0317867361,
0.025026517,
0.068639867,
-0.0011907242,
0.0516198687,
-0.0638899282,
0.0120501081,
-0.012735364,
-0.0723800361,
-0.0123821599,
-0.0213459209,
0.0026383186,
-0.0634369776,
0.0183524732,
-0.0827550292,
0.0175322313,
0.0073501882,
-0.0098297475,
-0.0054327524,
0.0138819125,
-0.0197579153,
-0.0369271412,
-0.0712147877,
-0.0301803276,
-0.0121859517,
-0.0064490079,
0.0445144251,
0.0374490358,
0.0363766886,
0.0247471482,
0.0288924575,
-0.0355233364,
0.0173473824,
-0.0198738798,
0.0048437975,
-0.0366602391,
0.0250294302,
0.007855041,
0.0088877222,
0.0060082027,
-0.005855557,
-0.0208224878,
-0.0200731289,
-0.0512780845,
0.050524056,
-0.0402573086,
-0.0370900892,
-0.0106391925,
0.0198700596,
-0.0602253005,
0.0623365641,
-0.0072176699,
0.0100755999,
0.0220428109,
0.0632826909,
0.0330426805,
0.052018553,
0.03029266,
0.0004236451,
-0.0556802303,
0.0450279452,
-0.0077345204,
-0.0096336789,
-0.0808888525,
0.0191393327,
-0.0112248948,
0.0399944223,
-0.0240979083,
-0.005586979,
0.0592064895,
-0.0039896793,
-0.0152599802,
-0.0052720886,
0.0173341967,
-0.0312428884,
0.024229385,
-0.0083802994,
0.0126073221,
0.1348471045,
-0.0505220518,
-0.0592481531,
0.004353147,
0.0177273843,
0.0149415433,
-0.0456487983,
0.0109164948,
-0.0013133435,
-0.0450717621,
-0.0705743432,
-0.0761015415,
-0.0587832443,
0.0129180932,
0.006732001,
-0.033220347,
0.0031598723,
-0.0117430491,
0.0035503397,
-0.0048321499,
0.0567138121,
-0.0305757951,
-0.0172001459,
-0.008839963,
0.072399199,
0.044830855,
0.0372307412,
-0.0694471598,
0.0097243199,
0.041532699,
0.0197334494,
-0.0086897137,
0.0419300497,
0.0424976125,
0.0590603016,
0.032561481,
-0.0318963304,
-0.0087991683,
0.0202506781,
0.0429809168,
-0.0227730144,
0.0151718613,
0.0853375122,
0.0447280779,
-0.0351027176,
-0.0377508663,
-0.0062557058,
-0.0063840002,
0.0313173272,
0.0586199053,
-0.1145809963,
-0.0362250507,
-0.0008106643,
0.0207570978,
0.011944443,
-0.0334403627,
-0.0163263772,
-0.1562739313,
0.0335289128,
-0.0315614827,
-0.05553158,
0.0059490846,
-0.0102626812,
0.0042931233,
0.032779064,
-0.0561093576,
0.0040535736,
-0.0043969261,
-0.0263934433,
0.0468381308,
0.0185816791,
-0.0228138193,
-0.0141775422,
-0.0028458901,
0.0534465201,
0.0423251763,
-0.0042582699,
0.0204573628,
-0.0225795768,
-0.0237015262,
-0.0127226096,
-0.0070068557,
-0.0256698709,
0.0433099121,
-0.0171377659,
-0.0164450146,
0.0245359987,
0.0494012423,
-0.0214561764,
-0.0147118596,
0.0250972491,
0.0633755401,
0.0143073639,
0.0274641458,
-0.0116743371,
-0.010590544,
0.045462992,
0.0798056126,
0.0184146333,
-0.0300471596,
0.0097625172,
-0.0637700036,
0.0065971999,
-0.0694666356,
0.0019046197,
0.0086887581,
0.026823489,
-0.011679641,
-0.0577903204,
-0.0223651491,
0.0639754236,
0.0545492135,
0.026093103,
0.0020264562,
-0.0347622633,
0.0182046294,
-0.0281038918,
-0.0190645251,
-0.02877062,
-0.00853536,
-0.0683376938,
-0.021271795,
0.0180635899,
-0.0597628132,
-0.0425167941,
-0.0187293869,
-0.0600101575,
-0.0158519745,
-0.0318155773,
0.0333597176,
0.0137015237,
0.0290394016,
-0.0359598137,
0.0085128192,
0.0515335798,
0.0584462769,
-0.0253991671,
-0.0368391164,
0.0228084344,
0.0187330991,
-0.0145130223,
0.013835907,
-0.053090211,
0.0068576531,
0.0328004546,
0.0141606862,
0.0041523841,
0.0038443781,
0.0540210493,
-0.0044213212,
0.05310883,
0.0106786843,
0.002794323,
-0.0113148112,
0.063997373,
-0.0049857693,
-0.0268230774,
-0.0263797585,
0.0243073031,
0.0135698095,
-0.0197359305,
0.0418355837,
-0.0461873971,
-0.0315236859,
0.0675390959,
-0.0406008288,
-0.0332344025,
0.0390082821,
0.0154798096,
-0.0090109324,
0.0072490531,
-0.0065505463,
0.009819068,
0.0605774149,
0.0259675831,
-0.0054759169,
0.0973361954,
-0.0030672846,
0.0120731499,
0.0018163489,
0.0187157262,
-0.0303964335,
-0.0516814291,
-0.0361908823,
0.0330935009,
0.0080957636,
-0.0027145622,
-0.0884763598,
0.037809208,
0.0109541975,
-0.0064089964,
0.0272642877,
0.0271042772,
-0.0077364491,
0.0463624597,
0.0278676003,
-0.0029239401,
-0.0030492637,
0.0581415854,
0.0011701318,
0.0378196575,
-0.0048935208,
0.0387598574,
-0.0577760078,
0.0302300099,
0.0576137044,
0.0390118845,
-0.0033874398,
0.0336278193,
-0.0582187176,
-0.0374012776,
-0.003941535,
0.0016559191,
0.0062206015,
0.0455923155,
0.0216007475,
0.0420498513,
-0.0184844956,
-0.0208903197,
-0.0407499634,
0.0025207766,
-0.0040345066,
-0.0318722874,
-0.0241921209,
-6.254083246e-33,
-0.0267446004,
0.0188477878,
0.0048442418,
-0.0214287862,
0.0009523241,
-0.006918448,
0.0107568884,
-0.0006356967,
0.0163665712,
-0.0213607978,
-0.0122803496,
-0.0287101083,
0.0166653953,
0.024998216,
0.0163215902,
-0.0254001636,
0.04657536,
-0.0122085037,
-0.0414580479,
0.0208143778,
0.0063415836,
0.039780356,
0.008325248,
-0.0156043768,
0.0355602056,
-0.0266226549,
-0.0000837341,
0.0381365605,
0.0524240658,
0.049925182,
-0.0218107998,
-0.0003135727,
0.0154989604,
-0.0800062269,
0.0311963148,
0.0722196475,
-0.0868883505,
-0.0592756718,
0.0006499083,
-0.0004591119,
-0.014660785,
-0.0335851312,
-0.0518750809,
-0.0206258036,
0.0351844952,
-0.0011856296,
0.0299491417,
0.0297329407,
0.0014112687,
-0.034465313,
-0.0423319116,
-0.0195703823,
-0.0170166697,
-0.0724724308,
-0.0153751327,
0.1092825234,
0.0248836186,
-0.0147934044,
-0.0387487337,
0.0138615649,
-0.0225501172,
0.0352839865,
0.0206164159,
0.0175204445,
-0.0214512721,
0.0441180952,
0.0225183815,
-0.0074854973,
0.0220638588,
0.0004007334,
-0.0364427455,
0.0031624427,
-0.0139761847,
0.043119248,
0.0881586596,
0.0058682738,
-0.0251565985,
0.0589843094,
-0.0012635998,
0.0153411701,
-0.0032156084,
-0.0230201576,
-0.0244697668,
-0.0176312458,
-0.0370927043,
-0.0407750569,
-0.0414287522,
-0.0542333685,
0.0638232008,
-0.0005842621,
-0.0344098806,
0.0077645313,
0.0691887587,
-0.0232645124,
0.0067059346,
0.0023068415,
0.0177311786,
0.0092846155,
-0.0017930125,
-0.015788151,
-0.0229393169,
-0.0296533294,
0.0322243012,
0.0244784318,
0.0144941341,
0.0020774445,
0.0223070569,
0.0183654781,
-0.0659786761,
-0.0081192087,
-0.0372867696,
0.0096199038,
0.0163620394,
0.0693450049,
0.0068203518,
0.0292653944,
-0.031937398,
0.0281248186,
-0.0006748037,
-0.0285001677,
-0.0406691283,
-0.0187719855,
0.0001172893,
0.0109510431,
-0.0133669423,
-0.0149862282,
-0.0015503278,
0.0205026083,
0.0141541995,
-0.043785166,
0.0113432771,
0.0213872083,
2.713e-7,
-0.028033562,
0.0092651984,
-0.0143581508,
-0.0093376813,
-0.0140565792,
0.0431958251,
-0.0027158186,
0.0363450386,
0.0505981594,
-0.0110054482,
0.0033368524,
0.0016941437,
0.0123094516,
0.0183987413,
-0.1915472597,
0.0042326669,
0.0079838503,
0.0157281011,
-0.0404039286,
0.0476062931,
0.0865107328,
0.0957137123,
-0.0018683356,
0.0014866213,
0.0402995124,
-0.0106336484,
0.0134542119,
0.0055425582,
0.0025386903,
0.0215255246,
-0.0188912079,
0.028335683,
0.0090568317,
0.0354134515,
-0.0153129352,
-0.0035792524,
0.0204536431,
0.0310327038,
0.0480358638,
-0.0094832182,
-0.0201574918,
0.0278399829,
0.0442280509,
-0.038846381,
0.0697676241,
-0.0980453417,
0.0052504851,
-0.0216939393,
-0.0350814611,
-0.0058695874,
0.0217196401,
0.0088075344,
0.0004939821,
-0.0055090096,
0.0322835259,
-0.0226931851,
-0.0053538093,
-0.0287480522,
-0.0311606079,
-0.0289499834,
-0.007976179,
-0.0365747735,
0.0004065997,
-0.0824278444,
0.0008684209,
-0.0301202852,
-0.0066965101,
2.344024586e-34,
0.0168249793,
0.0111620491,
0.0301711056,
0.0335580185,
-0.0084329713,
-0.0189917088,
0.0050085699,
-0.0103163794,
0.0404197536,
-0.0547226965,
-0.019934224
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.02796v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.02796v2 | VerifAI: Verified Generative AI | 2023-07-06T06:11:51 | 2023-10-11T03:16:23 | Nan Tang, Chenyu Yang, Ju Fan, Lei Cao, Yuyu Luo, Alon Halevy | cs.DB | cs.DB, cs.CL, cs.LG | Generative AI has made significant strides, yet concerns about the accuracy
and reliability of its outputs continue to grow. Such inaccuracies can have
serious consequences such as inaccurate decision-making, the spread of false
information, privacy violations, legal liabilities, and more. Although efforts
to address these risks are underway, including explainable AI and responsible
AI practices such as transparency, privacy protection, bias mitigation, and
social and environmental responsibility, misinformation caused by generative AI
will remain a significant challenge. We propose that verifying the outputs of
generative AI from a data management perspective is an emerging issue for
generative AI. This involves analyzing the underlying data from multi-modal
data lakes, including text files, tables, and knowledge graphs, and assessing
its quality and consistency. By doing so, we can establish a stronger
foundation for evaluating the outputs of generative AI models. Such an approach
can ensure the correctness of generative AI, promote transparency, and enable
decision-making with greater confidence. Our vision is to promote the
development of verifiable generative AI and contribute to a more trustworthy
and responsible use of AI. | [
0.0175503511,
0.132912606,
-0.0269355476,
0.0183803253,
-0.0239352006,
-0.0154867545,
0.0335544683,
-0.0045134211,
0.0189853217,
0.0351516232,
-0.0028055345,
-0.0140770171,
0.0050688311,
0.0682894737,
0.0154817253,
-0.0215154979,
0.0315801539,
0.0041624629,
0.0110272663,
-0.0004923632,
-0.0140244383,
0.0254544932,
-0.0048212362,
0.0295283496,
-0.063185744,
-0.0284051076,
-0.0091324784,
-0.0186110009,
0.024273077,
0.005754624,
-0.040992111,
0.0744095668,
-0.0187032856,
0.0560070649,
0.0000021521,
-0.0343391038,
-0.0132762957,
0.0433503725,
-0.0410727225,
-0.0073665273,
0.0297579803,
0.008938266,
-0.0264199711,
0.0087981345,
-0.0274933241,
-0.0215380043,
0.0573174842,
0.0103584854,
0.0551256426,
0.0474641807,
-0.013879166,
-0.0128610563,
0.04903543,
-0.0063703991,
0.0353521369,
-0.0063176295,
0.0106689315,
0.0215247385,
-0.0095569091,
-0.023325678,
0.0156573746,
0.0585619435,
0.0249185916,
-0.0435563438,
0.0055455063,
0.0296580642,
0.0363344178,
-0.0416055433,
0.0008509431,
0.0386223309,
0.0445361733,
-0.0393889956,
0.0193218328,
-0.033657819,
-0.0051105977,
0.0204526298,
0.0017480855,
0.0667094886,
-0.0146246711,
-0.0066927578,
-0.0273289587,
0.0055048186,
0.0462152325,
-0.0227995627,
-0.0048659495,
-0.0067019071,
0.0191929974,
-0.0196608715,
-0.0451415479,
0.0134874294,
0.0249331612,
-0.0980985686,
-0.0136761265,
0.0150452005,
-0.024960205,
0.0116310501,
-0.0278563164,
-0.0538836829,
0.0284743737,
0.0103431735,
0.005500908,
-0.0058456301,
-0.0186553616,
0.0025537491,
0.0252496954,
0.0433225967,
-0.0041965656,
0.0286887269,
0.0162007175,
-0.0367048047,
-0.0260062478,
0.0029371339,
-0.007266189,
-0.0227821022,
-0.0142811276,
-0.000304394,
-0.0276978947,
0.030453451,
-0.09233208,
0.0944043472,
0.0161657948,
0.0294055864,
-0.0199595466,
-0.0123158628,
-0.0593113042,
-0.0479791425,
-0.0467720255,
0.0383038819,
0.0213863701,
-0.0692015961,
0.0034416318,
0.0155544318,
0.0154137891,
0.0284900852,
0.0078258524,
0.0517338514,
0.0260646436,
0.0331494808,
-0.0468706861,
-0.0699874759,
0.0138582001,
-0.0729079321,
-0.0134999594,
-0.0283394586,
0.055609148,
-0.0319720842,
-0.0129943239,
-0.0704958811,
-0.0381607898,
-0.004974355,
0.0119822128,
0.042805586,
-0.0403543636,
0.0209993031,
-0.0093957437,
0.0304036811,
-0.0157806817,
-0.0001117819,
0.059704423,
0.050918024,
0.0268119872,
0.0007518627,
0.0804457739,
-0.0187039208,
0.0576720312,
-0.0358613804,
-0.0081247939,
0.0039803525,
-0.0440582074,
-0.0191319101,
-0.0253589563,
0.071891211,
-0.0341438465,
0.0071389927,
0.0519941933,
0.0166948196,
-0.0000623955,
0.0483970493,
0.0462851301,
-0.0347388722,
0.0079266103,
0.0013289031,
-0.0223227292,
0.0355069302,
-0.0051832497,
0.0000540687,
-0.0205168035,
0.0253089368,
-0.0047522495,
-0.0757883489,
0.0096177245,
-0.0265461728,
-0.0080965878,
-0.0009248115,
0.0115262764,
0.0358281694,
-0.014482379,
-0.0628679097,
0.0028281419,
-0.0800739452,
-0.0182379801,
-0.0611293465,
0.0795804039,
0.0897408575,
0.0564621724,
-0.0001559468,
-0.0082693072,
-0.0105089564,
-0.0502711497,
0.0209072679,
-0.0106378458,
-0.0478976518,
0.0095760822,
-0.0182414129,
-0.040874403,
-0.0064562401,
0.0256724935,
0.0233635586,
0.0439569727,
0.0163556654,
-0.0066964799,
-0.0459161736,
0.0021606456,
0.0067402576,
-0.0202666298,
-0.0172656402,
-0.0104146348,
0.023958765,
0.0341048203,
0.0208860207,
-0.0309062153,
0.0122635253,
0.0270961616,
0.0311727393,
-0.0399968885,
0.0290903486,
0.030555388,
0.0836867988,
-0.0159510877,
-0.0580685213,
-0.0175776463,
-0.017246753,
-0.0354475379,
-0.0191299841,
-0.0094882138,
-0.0115071246,
-0.0280949641,
-0.0606388934,
-0.0112174572,
-0.0167658012,
0.0245143287,
0.0420704111,
0.0721824989,
-0.0108793573,
-0.0497782454,
-0.0096868379,
-0.0123066958,
0.0373037495,
-0.021075733,
0.0215693712,
0.0290590487,
-0.0206810683,
0.0366635546,
0.0296438076,
-0.0138277225,
-0.0339751914,
0.0156651102,
-0.048079025,
0.0044779466,
0.0076322248,
0.0383433551,
-0.0071795462,
-0.0252959747,
-0.0081028305,
0.0101444004,
-0.0311831739,
0.012277226,
0.0549130291,
-0.0252796486,
0.0441302098,
-0.0008343674,
0.0002496828,
-0.002193196,
0.0013808587,
-0.013129794,
0.0536473021,
0.0541731119,
0.0010694513,
-0.0333287418,
0.0248632729,
-0.0683469921,
0.0193805695,
0.0215444602,
0.004550376,
0.0353378654,
-0.004556004,
0.0134340376,
0.0011004382,
0.0061873724,
0.0144361928,
0.0456851386,
0.0083314879,
-0.0327254198,
-0.0117277913,
-0.0031614872,
0.0004381903,
0.0312804021,
-0.0235365778,
0.0098769991,
-0.0058940682,
0.0043570148,
-0.0068652821,
-0.0322588608,
0.0723983124,
0.0264514443,
-0.0275736265,
0.0188703891,
-0.0338002481,
0.007674709,
0.0466033407,
-0.0328250378,
-0.0525238328,
0.0532184727,
-0.0325901993,
0.0493284501,
0.0262506399,
0.0031525281,
0.0215644743,
0.0650452599,
0.0067586047,
0.0325743891,
0.0440262742,
0.0189299341,
-0.0194312055,
0.0161253046,
0.0577545986,
-0.0345185287,
-0.0098736705,
-0.0371470153,
-0.0027106148,
0.028809879,
-0.0299148001,
-0.0743265525,
0.0193159543,
0.022093907,
0.0086413166,
0.0552824363,
-0.0492616184,
-0.0164382234,
-0.0477389619,
0.0468074568,
0.0112021388,
0.0197032709,
-0.0387766883,
-0.0283494163,
0.0158654172,
0.0201242976,
-0.007114667,
0.0211382508,
-0.0106039802,
-0.0471907109,
0.0505446829,
-0.0017567888,
0.0073623387,
-0.0356921256,
-0.030242702,
-0.0178436544,
-0.0065534762,
0.0447032824,
0.0314902514,
-0.0157301798,
-0.0232720654,
-0.0058747414,
0.0478404351,
0.0035292723,
0.0000105814,
0.015220264,
0.0417853184,
-0.0349830613,
-0.0148744462,
0.0408225805,
-0.1450871229,
0.0249730553,
-0.0247392561,
0.0310581289,
-0.0488329567,
-0.0298729278,
-0.0034699759,
-0.086957559,
0.1040392816,
0.0051698089,
-0.0161420684,
-0.0404211171,
-0.0534581244,
-0.0070651909,
-0.0146777136,
-0.0232305788,
-0.0379351899,
0.0357176699,
-0.0099714305,
0.0176392738,
0.0230732802,
-0.0614498109,
-0.00639856,
-0.0499345846,
0.0429596566,
0.0785479695,
0.0398408398,
0.011948769,
-0.0624007471,
-0.0566548444,
0.0476003662,
-0.0134857567,
0.0189889763,
0.0543084927,
0.0258628484,
0.0002995596,
-0.0233514123,
0.0128038386,
0.007867421,
-0.0316478647,
-0.0293225199,
0.0692773312,
-0.0261064731,
-0.0715707466,
-0.0180933103,
-0.0274125095,
0.0535886511,
0.0586667471,
0.0151462834,
0.0319463238,
-0.0386107266,
-0.0425933823,
0.0571187176,
-0.061161276,
0.0033282237,
0.0118793137,
0.0207873341,
-0.060653232,
-0.0761033148,
-0.0292751808,
-0.0186998639,
0.0387370698,
0.0016304564,
-0.0633420125,
0.0055649434,
-0.0286217928,
-0.0388529338,
-0.0185521245,
-0.0483631566,
0.0107543841,
-0.0057130405,
-0.0424816646,
-0.0013307648,
-0.0445985496,
-0.0155342454,
0.0591661595,
-0.0470937714,
-0.0067971591,
-0.0115336338,
0.0674668401,
0.0290849991,
0.015283281,
-0.0220170002,
-0.0200551562,
0.0776898786,
0.0988451988,
-0.0322998166,
-0.0135972938,
0.0050375261,
-0.007522766,
-0.0102217961,
-0.0121002616,
-0.0338872373,
0.0421308689,
-0.0032819256,
0.0058358056,
-0.0135687208,
-0.008192257,
0.0008425745,
0.0616565682,
-0.007032644,
-0.0022118685,
-0.0057310155,
-0.0696351752,
-0.0158067606,
-0.0370044522,
-0.018109804,
-0.0300987735,
0.0117196506,
0.0125995446,
0.0125173535,
-0.012733818,
0.0290666316,
-0.0118798437,
0.0064067659,
-0.0636859164,
-0.0311136842,
0.0633428171,
0.0448570698,
0.0039670346,
-0.003343534,
-0.0017384577,
0.0132512078,
-0.0039868969,
0.0570394434,
-0.008248521,
0.0153002106,
0.0193995424,
-0.0195236709,
-0.012401809,
0.0209569298,
-0.0497779809,
-0.0370611288,
-0.0346784741,
0.0454129167,
0.0427628942,
0.0823795944,
0.0077314791,
-0.0602675751,
0.0094802221,
0.0022184837,
0.0219674595,
0.038403824,
-0.0475072823,
-0.0635276586,
0.0044114464,
-0.0234506633,
-0.0279482845,
0.0499454141,
-0.022019567,
0.0613548346,
-0.0782791376,
-0.0338855162,
-0.0389438272,
-0.0861134604,
-0.0606844909,
-0.0159001369,
-0.0050272187,
-0.0376661122,
-0.0393819921,
-0.0795706585,
-0.0169028584,
0.0982837304,
0.0311908126,
0.006244557,
-0.0084110219,
0.0447915792,
0.0105657522,
-0.033294484,
-0.0318551622,
0.0038662755,
-0.0549522676,
-0.0127021987,
-0.0272988696,
-6.392246444e-33,
-0.0194551554,
-0.0679437742,
0.0097175566,
-0.0367974043,
0.0150778927,
-0.0020463329,
-0.0675979778,
-0.0361452699,
0.00346035,
0.0340565443,
0.0025588372,
0.0352613069,
0.0220618229,
-0.0114785265,
0.023803195,
-0.0039563514,
0.0708914697,
-0.0046158414,
-0.0449323766,
0.0486698076,
0.0463119671,
-0.0306438822,
-0.0060244426,
-0.1039980948,
0.0476832427,
-0.0384441875,
-0.0795963258,
0.0129663786,
-0.0625131726,
0.059411712,
-0.0071816649,
0.0227392875,
0.0077236779,
-0.0287777036,
0.0059431344,
-0.0245967805,
-0.0790249705,
-0.0193119533,
-0.031193601,
-0.0323999561,
-0.0626838207,
-0.0365302823,
0.0353907272,
-0.0187854692,
-0.0078550372,
0.0028009019,
0.0245131776,
0.0009655369,
-0.0037629935,
-0.0747509375,
-0.0385857187,
0.0057261097,
-0.0149758775,
0.010710407,
0.0251094252,
0.0037979116,
0.0409260839,
-0.0325152911,
-0.0512438044,
0.0233873185,
0.0298021697,
-0.0640522689,
0.0958157554,
-0.0209807809,
0.0126603208,
0.0535938144,
0.0566081889,
0.0095015327,
-0.0600566827,
0.0164359957,
-0.0208202358,
0.09200041,
0.003848128,
0.0747284815,
-0.010262385,
-0.0330168158,
-0.0242574271,
0.080295682,
-0.0404094793,
0.0075351549,
-0.0036345941,
-0.0405898914,
-0.0617871061,
-0.0007173286,
-0.005917273,
-0.0569902062,
-0.0367901325,
0.0146861728,
-0.0091266548,
0.0153929936,
-0.0268259328,
0.02262008,
-0.0112213474,
-0.0601840876,
0.0123572545,
0.0658182204,
-0.0032183318,
0.016351087,
0.0041672867,
-0.0064475662,
0.0106366631,
-0.0047845375,
0.050948672,
0.0205268953,
0.0459504202,
0.0470948145,
0.0387870669,
0.0355388932,
-0.0248712916,
0.0166185964,
-0.052457545,
0.037942104,
0.0067206626,
-0.0673816875,
0.0092726303,
0.0135146286,
-0.0001180871,
-0.0019151642,
0.0264699645,
0.0788451508,
0.0100928387,
0.028119104,
-0.0201460067,
-0.009033015,
0.0001578587,
-0.0077222465,
-0.0272575468,
-0.022666879,
0.0472532175,
-0.0158074517,
0.0121002905,
-0.0110591017,
2.867e-7,
-0.0080850348,
-0.0043722671,
0.053593196,
0.0442782044,
0.0100045083,
0.0413154103,
0.0029125053,
0.0033727032,
-0.0333835632,
-0.0183338244,
0.0382730775,
0.0262632873,
0.0387443677,
0.0730898082,
0.0123582454,
-0.0236539189,
-0.0277983025,
-0.0119097801,
-0.0525970608,
0.00816142,
0.0490115546,
-0.0009802945,
0.0261413958,
-0.0312958546,
0.0583250672,
-0.0094209397,
0.0203886293,
0.0085240034,
0.0495637879,
0.0400768146,
0.0717537478,
0.0035635668,
0.023700539,
-0.0063680224,
-0.0421849936,
-0.0086923633,
-0.0537157618,
0.0610150099,
0.0006781047,
-0.0048171347,
-0.0196658857,
-0.0524612591,
0.0308031552,
-0.0219903551,
0.0430574752,
0.0270607378,
0.0015087561,
-0.0304211974,
-0.0180993993,
-0.0205991492,
-0.0021633301,
-0.0068224096,
0.0119314585,
-0.0192750078,
-0.0307230614,
0.0100123305,
0.0160650816,
-0.0311962888,
0.0045084972,
-0.0398984291,
-0.0266934317,
-0.0224062763,
0.0298771765,
-0.0086808093,
0.0288621504,
-0.0329297595,
0.044710312,
2.20852797e-34,
-0.0017804971,
0.005886843,
-0.0200123005,
-0.0514163449,
0.0826240629,
0.0296822805,
0.0025106166,
-0.0194589328,
0.0118245315,
-0.0014721362,
-0.0375093333
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.02792v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.02792v2 | What Should Data Science Education Do with Large Language Models? | 2023-07-06T06:07:29 | 2023-07-07T17:56:39 | Xinming Tu, James Zou, Weijie J. Su, Linjun Zhang | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL | The rapid advances of large language models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT, are
revolutionizing data science and statistics. These state-of-the-art tools can
streamline complex processes. As a result, it reshapes the role of data
scientists. We argue that LLMs are transforming the responsibilities of data
scientists, shifting their focus from hands-on coding, data-wrangling and
conducting standard analyses to assessing and managing analyses performed by
these automated AIs. This evolution of roles is reminiscent of the transition
from a software engineer to a product manager. We illustrate this transition
with concrete data science case studies using LLMs in this paper. These
developments necessitate a meaningful evolution in data science education.
Pedagogy must now place greater emphasis on cultivating diverse skillsets among
students, such as LLM-informed creativity, critical thinking, AI-guided
programming. LLMs can also play a significant role in the classroom as
interactive teaching and learning tools, contributing to personalized
education. This paper discusses the opportunities, resources and open
challenges for each of these directions. As with any transformative technology,
integrating LLMs into education calls for careful consideration. While LLMs can
perform repetitive tasks efficiently, it's crucial to remember that their role
is to supplement human intelligence and creativity, not to replace it.
Therefore, the new era of data science education should balance the benefits of
LLMs while fostering complementary human expertise and innovations. In
conclusion, the rise of LLMs heralds a transformative period for data science
and its education. This paper seeks to shed light on the emerging trends,
potential opportunities, and challenges accompanying this paradigm shift,
hoping to spark further discourse and investigation into this exciting,
uncharted territory. | [
-0.0077730422,
0.0674139559,
-0.0593097061,
0.0293847825,
-0.0413950011,
0.0269924365,
0.0059209596,
-0.0569652393,
0.0202902555,
-0.0244717449,
0.0162806865,
0.0025310994,
-0.0304227136,
0.0591380894,
0.0000250185,
-0.0459331796,
0.0461987369,
-0.0486412495,
-0.0019047954,
0.0056757303,
-0.0369147733,
0.0034639311,
-0.0219405666,
0.0427568331,
0.008452232,
-0.0231234767,
0.0010287774,
-0.0216708351,
-0.0155891962,
-0.0254555847,
0.010572385,
0.0560328029,
0.0516897365,
0.0731844455,
0.0000024778,
-0.0772313923,
-0.0038311079,
0.0295326468,
-0.0549929664,
0.0217406098,
0.0448639803,
0.0771677643,
-0.018029213,
-0.0046203472,
-0.0662688538,
0.0197036378,
0.0657940656,
-0.0750609785,
0.0340940729,
0.0154347476,
0.0319294296,
-0.0184062142,
0.0204449371,
0.0129187964,
0.0362123698,
0.0289327893,
0.0406777337,
0.0478130467,
0.0440337397,
0.0115039358,
-0.0237010885,
0.0448118411,
0.019877363,
-0.0258415639,
-0.0001811829,
0.0135892546,
-0.0487740561,
-0.0023790516,
-0.0032186492,
0.0015271574,
0.0283221342,
-0.044704888,
0.005008671,
0.0190614127,
0.0223231483,
0.0306775272,
-0.0894620493,
0.0602723137,
0.0017715992,
-0.0116023002,
0.0227862466,
-0.0316825882,
-0.0084934551,
0.0541087799,
-0.0272690002,
0.0263156947,
-0.0139914285,
-0.0225768331,
0.014666033,
0.02835273,
0.0230508223,
0.0070123221,
-0.0148824742,
0.0552429855,
-0.0267924797,
0.0163782611,
0.0015010376,
-0.0451422818,
0.0090568922,
-0.056741327,
0.0323932879,
0.0336724073,
0.0195234939,
0.0034249523,
0.0210852586,
0.0376204327,
0.038907785,
0.0566152558,
-0.0041397219,
0.0200060327,
-0.0590243675,
-0.0389412716,
-0.0172864888,
-0.0144917993,
0.020078171,
0.0600978807,
-0.0149395596,
0.0354597904,
-0.0393708646,
0.0015445094,
-0.0239815805,
-0.0002352089,
-0.0152778747,
0.0362878628,
-0.0543058664,
0.0170732774,
0.0254255719,
0.0122466832,
0.0000864074,
-0.0503345393,
-0.0005767653,
0.0170024075,
-0.0379852913,
0.0142859546,
0.0538569614,
0.0614720024,
0.0060190405,
0.0092690475,
-0.0538537279,
-0.0279166307,
0.0171152353,
-0.053461317,
0.0166167449,
-0.0777014345,
0.0068521779,
0.0392216817,
-0.0258677043,
-0.0506505705,
0.003106233,
0.021391511,
-0.0017094222,
0.0577994287,
-0.0394548923,
0.0012811249,
0.0170321856,
0.0243218541,
0.0083653117,
0.073868908,
0.051433526,
-0.0113482224,
-0.0157038551,
-0.0464238897,
0.0602547787,
0.0160503313,
-0.0493779257,
0.0450025164,
-0.0549782291,
0.0184305813,
-0.0001837263,
0.015290834,
-0.0154489139,
0.0125811649,
0.0088016046,
0.0554367304,
0.0422232933,
0.0444300696,
0.0044321991,
0.0823626444,
0.019783292,
0.021045588,
0.0471647754,
-0.0410525985,
-0.0081777712,
0.0403820574,
0.0136679569,
0.0152945099,
-0.0357035585,
0.0534461252,
0.0173899867,
-0.0767628178,
0.0201304071,
0.0031305335,
0.0243140589,
0.0400182977,
0.0503288619,
-0.0403203405,
0.022183096,
-0.0144590046,
0.0217251182,
-0.0688464642,
0.0004079549,
-0.0845371187,
0.0259356778,
0.0738171861,
0.0492825061,
-0.0557993986,
-0.0590591356,
-0.0391796827,
0.0285570957,
0.0409943797,
0.0224129315,
-0.0185366627,
-0.0800856873,
-0.0168615468,
-0.01882587,
-0.011102289,
-0.0002557728,
-0.0040439852,
-0.0094178934,
0.0009915621,
-0.0125908349,
-0.0047342521,
-0.0732654482,
-0.0042662416,
-0.0976653397,
-0.0092308586,
-0.015694065,
-0.0019779382,
0.0072053513,
0.0347220786,
-0.01183654,
0.0272789616,
0.027711343,
0.0156627987,
-0.0081564868,
-0.0179661121,
0.036349155,
0.0373439305,
0.0393800773,
-0.0569814518,
-0.0114848604,
-0.0130526256,
-0.0146283396,
-0.0067234924,
0.0601987056,
-0.018307982,
0.0053408486,
-0.0045200698,
0.0050422843,
-0.0671947896,
0.0319721699,
-0.026573319,
0.0033094981,
0.0078093726,
0.0388534516,
-0.0030176379,
-0.0056983856,
0.0368044451,
-0.0139853554,
0.0193644874,
0.0409400836,
0.0101597775,
0.0503785722,
0.0082889656,
-0.0084252823,
-0.0415170714,
0.0163590796,
-0.0260974932,
-0.0097214896,
0.0241076518,
0.019235177,
-0.0039967191,
-0.0241739526,
-0.0557740852,
0.0174905062,
-0.0106101362,
-0.0323153324,
0.0117011033,
-0.0153759187,
0.0135535402,
-0.0210466236,
-0.0523831509,
-0.0293094683,
0.0015134776,
-0.0569033325,
0.0223244019,
0.064215526,
-0.013479555,
-0.03722528,
0.0014171058,
-0.0385227613,
0.0081778066,
-0.0080397027,
-0.021860294,
0.0338598005,
-0.0312938504,
0.0420057699,
0.0426561311,
-0.0273484234,
0.0442205258,
0.0659841895,
-0.0447288789,
-0.0110088727,
0.0094010411,
-0.0027707047,
0.0166727677,
0.0186193381,
-0.0299825761,
-0.025778845,
0.0050233249,
0.0004700176,
-0.034858834,
0.0356438644,
0.0927730799,
-0.0162351392,
0.0013215173,
-0.0310499109,
0.0089387055,
-0.0027216459,
0.0320138149,
0.0130597688,
-0.0583122224,
0.0505766608,
-0.0070627439,
0.0083565172,
-0.0739682913,
-0.05910201,
-0.0402019061,
0.0509676635,
-0.0196951199,
-0.0044145077,
-0.0276402272,
0.0134691531,
-0.0507288612,
0.0139286257,
-0.0069828751,
-0.0808071345,
0.0490503646,
-0.0716911331,
-0.0221734513,
0.0088161249,
0.0068177264,
-0.0293002371,
0.0503572486,
-0.0423411913,
-0.0032094009,
0.0414486453,
-0.0707961768,
-0.0312831812,
-0.0385454744,
0.1075065434,
0.0030370359,
0.0023550843,
-0.0044307839,
-0.0008437279,
-0.0586989298,
-0.0264564585,
-0.007049948,
0.0082864631,
-0.0287292209,
0.0330872983,
0.0279170349,
-0.0134807257,
-0.0009521371,
-0.0205727722,
0.0108218668,
0.0200024787,
0.0067126183,
0.0213136803,
0.0108126421,
0.008534696,
-0.0771587342,
-0.0075048278,
0.0511132143,
0.0131073901,
-0.0068809655,
0.0054020947,
-0.0139151262,
-0.0120964237,
0.046846386,
0.0552880876,
-0.1084600016,
0.0058585545,
-0.016507607,
0.027874345,
-0.0709402934,
-0.0560811162,
-0.0423171669,
-0.0795804411,
0.0795255527,
0.0238683056,
-0.0188343786,
-0.0153552806,
-0.0653992221,
-0.0135434074,
-0.018214535,
0.0073515349,
0.0093070734,
-0.0023986129,
0.0459783413,
0.0446756408,
-0.0070661311,
-0.0260609239,
0.020834934,
0.0097109703,
0.0133684399,
0.0294421669,
0.0330212824,
-0.0585335195,
-0.0121142585,
-0.0120979305,
0.0596137382,
-0.0035540925,
0.0048704934,
0.014417964,
0.0388000719,
-0.0010012166,
-0.0564665236,
0.0220376998,
-0.0385907777,
0.012782786,
0.0375221707,
0.0933626443,
-0.0293845125,
-0.0168657396,
-0.0602672845,
-0.0224098898,
0.001083468,
0.0561078712,
0.0105170114,
-0.0357728563,
0.0161179025,
-0.0978178829,
-0.0187982731,
-0.0094071012,
-0.0688304454,
0.032267008,
-0.0248576291,
-0.0274852626,
0.0292533021,
-0.0225671586,
0.0849553719,
-0.0134670967,
0.0140456147,
0.0066621117,
0.0000276331,
-0.002710243,
-0.0982740968,
0.0128388414,
-0.0433748849,
0.0475318581,
-0.0365878344,
-0.0593079291,
-0.0034176446,
-0.0580544285,
-0.0206636973,
0.0232326631,
-0.0779060498,
-0.0697399378,
0.0043653762,
0.0293428544,
0.0312170815,
-0.0190722104,
0.0422701165,
-0.0451647937,
0.0129623171,
0.0850928351,
0.0126931751,
-0.0037643104,
-0.027458312,
0.0345402174,
0.0200205538,
-0.0322052762,
0.0140306326,
-0.0007308465,
0.0088414121,
-0.0010866279,
-0.0170462579,
-0.0195579939,
0.0300259236,
0.061837092,
0.0425023325,
-0.0136668943,
-0.0466544963,
-0.0179634579,
-0.0208043177,
-0.0212849658,
-0.0353353769,
-0.0199004468,
-0.027335234,
0.0028412344,
0.0287197065,
0.0129687628,
0.0116332583,
-0.0109092006,
-0.0096896682,
-0.0373634174,
0.0941858217,
0.003763739,
0.0141646797,
0.0693012923,
-0.00373158,
-0.0018538056,
0.0195782688,
0.0236841701,
0.0327607021,
0.0261829123,
0.0495978892,
0.0057775648,
0.0014675981,
0.0120837661,
0.0099427151,
-0.0557314269,
-0.0715885833,
-0.0155810192,
0.0379123352,
-0.0068308553,
0.0629901886,
-0.0194372665,
-0.0573342443,
0.007529825,
-0.0130720539,
0.0162939467,
-0.0065058176,
0.0003429103,
0.0218356904,
-0.0002278704,
-0.025854703,
-0.0292893108,
0.0485537536,
-0.020838283,
0.0358850993,
-0.0338339321,
-0.0435793437,
-0.0122003071,
-0.0165811758,
0.0195904672,
-0.0327861346,
0.0427405722,
0.0023211155,
-0.063056238,
-0.0736668557,
-0.0276782587,
0.0204802416,
0.0079744831,
-0.06198176,
0.017568795,
0.0278553665,
-0.0389008224,
0.0175389238,
0.0045443545,
0.0447259098,
-0.0275218952,
-0.0473790653,
0.0137435757,
-6.429565451e-33,
0.0228192154,
-0.0459820181,
0.0481096879,
0.0401479192,
-0.017740218,
-0.0300927795,
-0.0353491418,
0.0279780775,
-0.0105851647,
0.0113197798,
0.0073995786,
0.0110511864,
-0.0031440095,
0.002677676,
0.0478353202,
-0.000522177,
0.0179621652,
0.0031300357,
0.0252100658,
-0.0005247367,
0.00613028,
-0.0143470792,
0.0704138801,
-0.0709101185,
0.0193049926,
-0.0055004628,
0.0111989388,
-0.0115969982,
-0.0422995202,
0.0054220231,
0.0318692736,
0.0749417469,
0.00221569,
-0.0135128815,
-0.0325170197,
0.0287854243,
0.0048601427,
-0.0405049771,
-0.001032069,
-0.0010493974,
0.0471113473,
-0.0450222194,
0.0676445514,
0.0016305915,
-0.072213389,
0.0031467769,
0.0440138653,
-0.0475206524,
0.0099660913,
-0.008943202,
-0.0461357981,
0.0137199145,
-0.043417111,
-0.0038381489,
0.026456736,
-0.0002278164,
-0.0225612875,
-0.0096410131,
-0.0139451418,
0.1062003821,
0.0790655538,
0.0039004472,
0.0774641857,
0.0217611007,
0.0293426551,
0.0208836142,
0.0690835342,
0.0149637051,
-0.02333799,
0.0085725114,
0.0168125965,
0.0477556176,
0.0230824221,
0.0310295168,
-0.0228885077,
-0.0059570102,
-0.0753071681,
0.0285676457,
0.0459887236,
-0.0449156947,
-0.0141381584,
0.0011228699,
-0.0663299188,
-0.0619022436,
-0.0111960284,
-0.0306952577,
-0.0106912525,
-0.0190915596,
-0.0103877662,
-0.0804680884,
-0.022576727,
0.0275922939,
0.0003598486,
-0.0431529246,
-0.0414090455,
-0.0191795621,
-0.0337645486,
0.0331499949,
0.0248207152,
-0.020665912,
-0.0366060287,
-0.0012437456,
-0.0165511779,
0.0331316516,
0.0533774495,
0.0369065963,
-0.0083637489,
0.0316344872,
-0.0275866147,
-0.0119755212,
-0.0529776551,
0.0025319098,
0.0496135913,
-0.0299493466,
0.012723607,
0.0157983582,
0.006293993,
0.015420869,
0.0229903907,
-0.0041173655,
-0.0092732394,
-0.0013744131,
-0.0428602993,
-0.0156111903,
-0.0117609221,
-0.0370006226,
-0.0483595952,
-0.0453116037,
0.0477974489,
-0.0805569664,
-0.009504539,
-0.0413007066,
3.181e-7,
0.025097521,
0.0870606974,
-0.0091306623,
0.015264608,
0.0028178536,
0.0011499344,
-0.0260581076,
-0.0176730026,
0.0467973016,
0.0220955368,
-0.0075412514,
0.0280208774,
0.0372164845,
0.028040681,
-0.0567476004,
-0.0441952311,
-0.0164159816,
-0.0203219149,
-0.0906739011,
0.0368893929,
0.075577341,
0.01359291,
0.0388693549,
-0.0037628743,
-0.0105777783,
-0.0398495421,
-0.0071144165,
-0.0346994027,
0.0342500284,
0.0408247784,
-0.0284428671,
0.0379926562,
0.0340529419,
0.0390746742,
-0.0093848789,
-0.029799886,
-0.011257627,
0.05901853,
0.0268377382,
0.0576226749,
0.0625192448,
-0.0264119077,
-0.0119874617,
-0.0407664292,
0.0432328321,
-0.0587311052,
-0.0430765487,
0.0089748204,
0.0057749096,
-0.0222039446,
-0.0037912142,
-0.0446474813,
0.0228595063,
-0.0024970518,
-0.0188932586,
-0.0360967331,
0.0229682177,
0.0263805799,
-0.0158414412,
0.0077370643,
-0.040656779,
-0.0835870877,
-0.0114172762,
-0.0058028377,
0.0209280811,
-0.0067872889,
0.0544000454,
3.298202738e-34,
0.0429251902,
-0.0119751282,
0.0369503684,
-0.0202285163,
0.0332246535,
0.0122795291,
0.0510212779,
0.0146929855,
0.0218948089,
-0.0161677729,
-0.0461375006
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.05355v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.05355v1 | UniCoRN: Unified Cognitive Signal ReconstructioN bridging cognitive signals and human language | 2023-07-06T05:26:49 | 2023-07-06T05:26:49 | Nuwa Xi, Sendong Zhao, Haochun Wang, Chi Liu, Bing Qin, Ting Liu | eess.SP | eess.SP, cs.CL | Decoding text stimuli from cognitive signals (e.g. fMRI) enhances our
understanding of the human language system, paving the way for building
versatile Brain-Computer Interface. However, existing studies largely focus on
decoding individual word-level fMRI volumes from a restricted vocabulary, which
is far too idealized for real-world application. In this paper, we propose
fMRI2text, the first openvocabulary task aiming to bridge fMRI time series and
human language. Furthermore, to explore the potential of this new task, we
present a baseline solution, UniCoRN: the Unified Cognitive Signal
ReconstructioN for Brain Decoding. By reconstructing both individual time
points and time series, UniCoRN establishes a robust encoder for cognitive
signals (fMRI & EEG). Leveraging a pre-trained language model as decoder,
UniCoRN proves its efficacy in decoding coherent text from fMRI series across
various split settings. Our model achieves a 34.77% BLEU score on fMRI2text,
and a 37.04% BLEU when generalized to EEGto-text decoding, thereby surpassing
the former baseline. Experimental results indicate the feasibility of decoding
consecutive fMRI volumes, and the effectiveness of decoding different cognitive
signals using a unified structure. | [
-0.0507354848,
0.1306563616,
-0.0189502183,
0.0339581557,
-0.0072734146,
0.0402611904,
0.0274695288,
0.0750683695,
-0.0141369486,
0.0124616371,
-0.0350373946,
-0.0386300497,
0.0610103644,
0.0956183001,
0.0094284909,
-0.0374155417,
0.033014968,
-0.0112295393,
0.0237264484,
0.0020964001,
-0.0307125282,
0.0221478622,
-0.0570476279,
0.057593368,
0.0034577767,
-0.0166189596,
-0.0156035284,
-0.0209266245,
0.043080274,
-0.0304717384,
-0.0462168977,
0.0490970537,
0.0330789573,
0.0336632431,
0.0000019423,
-0.0029498346,
-0.0196731836,
-0.0102377851,
-0.0233993437,
-0.0229070317,
0.0458518267,
0.0002971579,
0.0207389537,
-0.0048967903,
-0.0359913073,
-0.0037478986,
0.0502721965,
0.0859931931,
0.0101611456,
0.0185726285,
-0.0349993072,
0.024336528,
0.0466453135,
-0.0251544658,
-0.0012379009,
0.002438219,
0.015778156,
-0.0225654598,
-0.0314199887,
0.0208274648,
-0.0233055241,
0.0336255431,
0.0170183331,
0.0579901375,
-0.0062607289,
0.0646406338,
-0.0102402633,
-0.0139646037,
-0.0324996598,
0.0598267466,
0.0082510468,
-0.0211942866,
-0.0061795972,
0.0128499316,
-0.0248186942,
-0.0027268357,
-0.03092633,
0.0132524688,
0.0048659723,
0.0517880023,
0.0107813096,
-0.0179728158,
0.0277950168,
-0.0224478431,
-0.0256338622,
0.0435443334,
-0.0071603591,
0.0154762501,
0.0566850081,
0.0087699108,
-0.0657801628,
-0.0269930996,
0.0286067687,
0.0253988449,
-0.0206727795,
-0.0247784685,
-0.061944738,
-0.0811692923,
-0.0063223289,
-0.0115465429,
-0.009467857,
0.0348833948,
-0.0303863883,
0.0029463076,
0.0025449416,
0.0274779089,
-0.0578200817,
0.0351981707,
-0.0242064241,
-0.0271275975,
-0.0576190166,
-0.0232023038,
-0.0141618568,
-0.017016558,
-0.0406267382,
-0.0366307721,
-0.0225608461,
-0.0031648236,
0.0273555201,
-0.0571378991,
-0.0127703752,
0.0211085733,
-0.0269332342,
0.0237616654,
0.0221756399,
0.0291930865,
0.0351573229,
0.0363554657,
0.016978519,
-0.0547511056,
-0.0523923598,
0.0367834084,
0.0014484038,
-0.0372253582,
-0.0069680335,
0.0222079568,
-0.022230031,
-0.0163644068,
-0.0166996773,
-0.0175670478,
-0.0275888052,
0.0004142205,
0.0222481042,
-0.0587436371,
0.0304593667,
0.0363602936,
0.0099053187,
-0.0553188473,
0.0046341466,
-0.0345591418,
-0.0361717641,
0.0524859391,
-0.0867549106,
-0.0437261648,
0.0948112383,
0.020423267,
0.0131599437,
0.0218741074,
0.0449575596,
0.0159259532,
-0.0259775296,
0.0078945523,
-0.0284856539,
0.0585276,
0.0038038783,
-0.0587416478,
-0.0628711358,
-0.0413966738,
0.0192932393,
0.0168283805,
0.0438633338,
0.0307718888,
-0.0230529904,
-0.0086359326,
0.0283215698,
0.0718602017,
-0.002014755,
0.017050799,
0.0166946109,
-0.0044252523,
0.0071568205,
-0.0304605849,
0.0157919396,
0.0342202075,
0.0046630935,
-0.0220836345,
-0.0333561637,
-0.0132904416,
-0.0071711494,
0.009536244,
0.0080019468,
-0.0430179052,
0.004605093,
0.0239680782,
0.0809476301,
-0.0210708324,
-0.0290389322,
0.0034175462,
0.053093683,
0.0019911397,
0.0054541132,
-0.0062659145,
0.0116370674,
0.0350226909,
0.0394106768,
-0.0231282748,
0.0319694914,
0.0096303299,
-0.0101400791,
0.0361296535,
-0.0049182246,
0.0152068837,
0.0869882852,
-0.0657379031,
-0.0364703052,
0.0104709882,
-0.0089950627,
0.0091957971,
-0.0133286892,
0.0284210555,
-0.0278948098,
-0.0128865289,
-0.0118189575,
0.0360414945,
-0.0287697949,
-0.0066249873,
0.0207135081,
-0.0254399721,
0.0510930493,
-0.0249877647,
-0.0407771021,
0.0216563195,
0.050169006,
-0.0585724004,
-0.0053125154,
0.0045152404,
-0.0528380163,
-0.0335684456,
0.0036574833,
0.0270999465,
-0.0279600378,
0.0682315975,
-0.0194148514,
-0.0178085305,
-0.0111258514,
-0.0134385694,
0.0072963373,
-0.0288499799,
-0.0208995268,
0.0032430987,
0.0281229746,
-0.0342690609,
0.0235696491,
-0.0196036082,
-0.002947741,
0.0020606185,
-0.0250212885,
0.0218617842,
-0.0552745126,
-0.0071175923,
0.0539277345,
-0.0188040752,
-0.0334816575,
-0.0162660498,
-0.0206392109,
-0.0210045353,
0.0037971656,
-0.1119774207,
-0.0325624757,
0.0142716384,
-0.0040235603,
0.0197368227,
-0.0111577371,
0.0023911349,
0.0009505496,
-0.0028243337,
0.0661141649,
0.0332885198,
0.0146869812,
0.0133488616,
-0.02262225,
-0.0095515577,
-0.0067934338,
-0.0235573761,
-0.0227666534,
0.0553578176,
-0.0238638744,
-0.0569806583,
-0.0268760528,
0.0151008349,
0.0070216306,
-0.0031510487,
-0.0325677097,
0.0370568298,
0.0354055539,
-0.0268128868,
0.0532350466,
0.0637405813,
0.0250310283,
0.0412356406,
0.0375459492,
-0.0350425355,
0.0079234345,
-0.0292557683,
-0.0026136718,
0.0016937981,
-0.032215707,
-0.006891876,
0.0491524898,
0.0529700257,
0.0791150853,
0.0489432216,
-0.0119657638,
-0.0183115453,
-0.0357543528,
-0.0664292723,
-0.0722865239,
0.0186138321,
-0.0274174474,
0.0556580238,
-0.0330558531,
-0.0235218164,
0.0420444161,
-0.0323046856,
-0.0027601735,
0.015524487,
-0.0246155299,
-0.032052651,
0.0384100489,
-0.0145518733,
0.0061868425,
0.0104888249,
-0.0592009872,
-0.0138662383,
0.018784998,
-0.0424591713,
-0.0597518757,
-0.0085627101,
-0.053547021,
-0.0013561196,
-0.0029144562,
-0.0103530996,
-0.0364488587,
0.0258589014,
0.0032711027,
0.0008379877,
0.0060652834,
0.0157266427,
-0.0910782889,
-0.0277044885,
-0.0037100441,
0.0314805731,
-0.0486630425,
-0.0280321334,
-0.0123740742,
0.0973450616,
0.0275521651,
0.0283988714,
0.00611042,
-0.0821103156,
-0.0108695123,
0.0555150248,
0.0031545591,
0.030812826,
-0.0375308655,
0.0536015853,
-0.0222497657,
0.0167881437,
0.0116436761,
0.0229395628,
0.0036817035,
-0.0151721751,
-0.0420831405,
0.1108257324,
0.0235713236,
-0.0678434223,
-0.0173709653,
-0.0024791209,
0.0537304059,
-0.0239543319,
-0.037103992,
-0.0535197295,
-0.0252357516,
-0.006748924,
0.059530206,
0.0418530181,
-0.0201158207,
0.0033640044,
0.0046853367,
0.0484992191,
0.0122732418,
-0.0290226601,
-0.0115637733,
-0.0423584431,
-0.0081876181,
-0.031094661,
0.0197802745,
-0.0299269911,
0.0094249016,
0.0365398079,
0.0153541965,
0.0598767698,
-0.0195838921,
0.0019046982,
0.0157084912,
0.0412702188,
0.0480946861,
0.0217922162,
-0.0144543657,
-0.0074422704,
-0.0495346934,
0.0054383767,
-0.011809146,
-0.0278713554,
0.0751933977,
0.022312114,
0.0046385285,
-0.0437267758,
0.0474404097,
-0.0458274223,
-0.0828947499,
-0.0011997565,
0.0539629906,
-0.0416741781,
-0.0105858892,
-0.0083826408,
-0.0232364759,
0.0292057283,
0.0462868139,
0.0151349632,
-0.0409155078,
-0.0021219696,
0.0173421409,
0.0357761234,
-0.0554816984,
-0.0798519254,
-0.0101007074,
0.0159069896,
-0.0136982724,
-0.0222865567,
-0.0033119791,
0.0610847734,
0.0053803944,
0.0024335864,
0.0077989665,
0.0614880659,
-0.0310358312,
-0.0880169347,
0.0377450362,
-0.0096284328,
-0.0243550446,
-0.0690958649,
-0.0210225321,
-0.0150748137,
-0.0212965421,
-0.0139494035,
0.1012596488,
-0.0736618787,
-0.0187087115,
0.0689095184,
0.0171058066,
0.0190109797,
-0.0006373325,
0.0462293625,
0.020469239,
0.0630156919,
0.0293323882,
-0.0613883659,
0.0517821535,
-0.0208945815,
0.008655522,
-0.0105385389,
0.0125928689,
-0.0400182046,
0.0308971871,
-0.0059079183,
0.0181898884,
0.0172257759,
-0.0057334555,
0.0614971668,
-0.001871389,
0.0714901686,
-0.0202674624,
0.0013010268,
-0.0075969435,
-0.0297495741,
0.0221423935,
0.0710872784,
-0.045716878,
0.0142704332,
0.0421330854,
-0.0106568662,
-0.0117077064,
-0.0063045355,
0.0112304101,
-0.0050065913,
-0.024587905,
-0.0293692593,
-0.0800012201,
0.0119743058,
0.0134200379,
0.01969935,
-0.0000081622,
0.034727674,
-0.0381287411,
-0.0004569573,
0.0011309462,
0.0593292005,
0.0120479688,
0.0459229872,
-0.0219302122,
0.0262934715,
-0.039858751,
-0.0511323847,
0.0344863907,
0.0014687269,
0.0080035916,
0.0099606207,
0.0710059702,
-0.0005755884,
0.0317366458,
-0.0668552071,
0.0528897345,
-0.0262993667,
0.0068771304,
0.043408405,
-0.0183838811,
0.0119720809,
-0.0580773726,
0.0688961968,
-0.0278276317,
-0.0050416673,
0.0096808365,
0.0186309051,
-0.0455857143,
-0.0246371273,
-0.0059118848,
-0.0348942503,
-0.0577289946,
0.000010454,
0.0177920442,
-0.0000950651,
0.0207722485,
-0.0143325478,
0.0154497959,
-0.0164003819,
-0.0030403999,
-0.0000551943,
-0.0307931956,
-0.0201030467,
0.0285171848,
0.0587700717,
-0.0267237984,
-0.0726613551,
-0.0524900146,
-6.11202806e-33,
-0.0432022177,
-0.023607282,
-0.014664948,
0.0256519411,
0.0044743186,
0.0202149022,
-0.0516189635,
0.0278743878,
0.0436647013,
-0.0292735267,
-0.0038018629,
0.0076117814,
0.0241593812,
0.0446497537,
0.0300035961,
0.0449522473,
-0.006581672,
-0.062164057,
-0.0083492175,
0.0227105021,
0.0751033351,
0.0458239056,
0.0855304301,
-0.0775089487,
-0.0177377723,
0.0165570099,
0.0275699291,
-0.0194549486,
0.0031321032,
0.0115428865,
-0.0499669313,
0.0371411107,
0.0507592373,
0.0034386388,
-0.021396393,
0.0240608007,
-0.1086324155,
0.0143326009,
-0.0042328928,
-0.0075285146,
-0.0878769159,
-0.0043832795,
0.0154015692,
-0.0280583054,
0.033831872,
-0.0205543526,
0.0330440216,
-0.0311552417,
-0.0082419347,
-0.0222135056,
-0.0253444444,
-0.010052071,
-0.027938731,
0.0245322455,
0.0585052967,
0.061556302,
-0.035574194,
0.0331339203,
-0.0625787899,
0.0040161833,
-0.0150970621,
0.0066822027,
0.0062175775,
-0.0067779887,
0.0076250904,
0.0707455724,
0.0350051746,
-0.0580896437,
-0.0451461524,
0.0545348041,
0.0424091481,
0.0735915527,
0.0221526325,
-0.0083098104,
0.0699426681,
-0.0531881675,
-0.0593635961,
0.0277880933,
-0.0151059758,
0.0043920549,
-0.0064414474,
0.0023045673,
0.0262171663,
-0.0070152385,
-0.0135631533,
-0.0007155137,
-0.037317194,
-0.0074505298,
0.0480119698,
-0.0222129505,
0.0187777579,
-0.041684147,
0.0720510781,
0.0130826468,
0.0367047638,
-0.004491183,
0.0162370559,
0.0192051288,
0.011398701,
0.0075610685,
-0.0538041256,
-0.0369436406,
0.0863334015,
-0.0101426477,
0.0650295764,
-0.038108252,
-0.0200876407,
0.0235871281,
-0.0083785029,
-0.0219122861,
-0.0002978487,
-0.0023295193,
0.0309078041,
0.0234448891,
0.0265219714,
-0.0250950772,
0.0076616076,
-0.0327506326,
-0.0551236421,
0.0043661147,
-0.0649108812,
-0.049308598,
0.025136508,
0.0478257872,
0.0092995474,
-0.0046761367,
-0.0324947909,
-0.0315411128,
0.0623719171,
-0.0349075198,
-0.0196527615,
0.0340685546,
2.66e-7,
0.0441409051,
0.0390507467,
0.046984259,
0.0442364067,
0.0081462581,
0.0037929337,
-0.0328053683,
0.0211773384,
0.0128704114,
-0.0265004449,
-0.016273573,
0.0511019938,
0.0495267361,
0.0175345819,
-0.0045365761,
-0.0342453718,
-0.0207660943,
0.0061359163,
-0.0450934581,
-0.018466115,
0.086309664,
0.0105133634,
-0.0204209201,
-0.0326187499,
0.0350322649,
0.048854351,
0.079443723,
-0.0274339393,
0.0300536361,
0.0026921891,
0.0002647214,
-0.0516528599,
0.0066289715,
0.0182711966,
0.0134594971,
-0.0081325937,
-0.0016905257,
0.0038510477,
-0.0437534712,
-0.0640999675,
0.033723101,
0.0091127437,
-0.0214255173,
-0.028413374,
0.0181259122,
-0.0588568784,
-0.0807399154,
-0.0290913656,
-0.042381186,
0.0328926928,
0.0580284968,
-0.0053211944,
0.0130423559,
0.0027863444,
0.0025196793,
0.0256938469,
-0.0029611082,
-0.0355331711,
-0.011031298,
0.0389282592,
-0.0841274783,
0.0259397198,
-0.0328752957,
0.0010884143,
0.007120566,
-0.0437844209,
0.0017755339,
1.830506665e-34,
-0.0413132533,
0.0205273684,
0.0113242362,
0.0531167239,
-0.0063674971,
-0.0502832495,
0.033024814,
0.0254958905,
-0.0701610297,
-0.0746791735,
-0.0367534235
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.02768v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.02768v1 | Training Models to Generate, Recognize, and Reframe Unhelpful Thoughts | 2023-07-06T04:40:52 | 2023-07-06T04:40:52 | Mounica Maddela, Megan Ung, Jing Xu, Andrea Madotto, Heather Foran, Y-Lan Boureau | cs.CL | cs.CL | Many cognitive approaches to well-being, such as recognizing and reframing
unhelpful thoughts, have received considerable empirical support over the past
decades, yet still lack truly widespread adoption in self-help format. A
barrier to that adoption is a lack of adequately specific and diverse dedicated
practice material. This work examines whether current language models can be
leveraged to both produce a virtually unlimited quantity of practice material
illustrating standard unhelpful thought patterns matching specific given
contexts, and generate suitable positive reframing proposals. We propose
PATTERNREFRAME, a novel dataset of about 10k examples of thoughts containing
unhelpful thought patterns conditioned on a given persona, accompanied by about
27k positive reframes. By using this dataset to train and/or evaluate current
models, we show that existing models can already be powerful tools to help
generate an abundance of tailored practice material and hypotheses, with no or
minimal additional model training required. | [
0.0761754215,
0.0066815792,
-0.0192420073,
0.0118146045,
-0.0231058821,
0.006774988,
0.017971497,
-0.0091297505,
0.0225142017,
-0.0274275616,
-0.0010610369,
0.0139652593,
-0.0332092606,
-0.0008884819,
0.0004346788,
-0.084898226,
0.0217421595,
0.0439318083,
0.0496959724,
-0.0039424701,
0.0002334764,
0.0237109214,
-0.0213067625,
0.0635674521,
-0.0352360867,
-0.046559304,
0.0449863225,
0.0278494824,
0.0290818587,
-0.0677116215,
0.0550179593,
0.0337408707,
-0.0060349405,
-0.0316830575,
0.0000021168,
-0.0442054532,
-0.000844152,
-0.0478289388,
0.0259754714,
-0.0103501594,
0.0648961067,
-0.0025722554,
0.0232990421,
0.0294554736,
-0.0346862823,
0.0158749558,
-0.02285612,
0.0839803591,
0.0971153304,
0.0765848681,
0.004693313,
0.0016221992,
-0.0286995787,
-0.0105521549,
0.0264545027,
0.000338789,
0.0344495103,
0.0120395441,
-0.0270113908,
-0.046741344,
-0.0337200537,
0.0076294956,
-0.0215739589,
0.0282044169,
0.0322251059,
-0.0375980251,
-0.0330366716,
-0.0220489949,
0.006861425,
0.0474588908,
0.0123867141,
-0.0003377335,
-0.0083750505,
-0.0160831492,
0.0411643162,
0.0327787884,
0.0063937046,
0.0103713255,
-0.0163196251,
0.0016364354,
0.0280663501,
0.0065459926,
-0.0146163302,
0.002628007,
0.0174170658,
0.0098271985,
-0.0300959889,
-0.0567885675,
0.0499762818,
-0.0116824675,
-0.0276718903,
-0.0508789569,
0.0169013962,
-0.0026907474,
-0.0106465984,
0.0184442475,
-0.0439427681,
-0.0072495635,
-0.0019717969,
0.015951965,
0.0628415197,
0.0420326926,
-0.0140510835,
-0.0129627325,
0.0311116353,
-0.0412779152,
0.0195282046,
-0.0048908074,
-0.0430412404,
0.0466273911,
-0.0471374169,
0.0076176659,
-0.0457348153,
0.0256332345,
0.0299323015,
0.0048285765,
-0.0845942646,
0.006471179,
-0.0643960536,
-0.0279871225,
-0.0529036559,
0.0022196849,
0.0311405212,
0.003328112,
-0.0616522878,
0.0200969968,
-0.0111027779,
0.0022847385,
-0.0210134052,
-0.0513683744,
0.0231827069,
0.0010072754,
-0.0047886115,
-0.0336675905,
0.0401164517,
0.015478461,
0.0234330799,
-0.0470134504,
-0.078471303,
-0.0322443582,
-0.0333896615,
-0.0099160746,
0.0146204792,
-0.040786691,
-0.037840452,
-0.0350075997,
0.0534253232,
-0.0752661303,
0.035377793,
0.0208199583,
-0.0313795097,
0.0305437054,
-0.0551546738,
0.0162279103,
0.0436867848,
0.0299491193,
-0.0103175063,
0.0513687395,
-0.0035609822,
-0.0163883381,
0.0351803973,
-0.0439429432,
0.0341576524,
-0.0137476763,
0.0338166505,
-0.0460830182,
-0.010646902,
0.0079580769,
-0.0135703348,
0.0309653003,
-0.0069377711,
-0.0053082914,
-0.0133703826,
0.0569924302,
0.0543518774,
0.0578261688,
-0.0556761138,
0.0354788005,
0.0297844708,
0.0424549617,
-0.0055163922,
-0.0118943304,
-0.0362982526,
-0.0138246454,
-0.037226323,
-0.0344467014,
0.000120548,
0.0203693137,
-0.0434429087,
-0.0519565493,
-0.0272380728,
-0.028027948,
-0.0000636173,
0.0111520272,
-0.0161853489,
0.0186906271,
-0.0085865455,
0.0309572686,
0.0199063923,
-0.0454142131,
-0.0385783575,
-0.0129601536,
0.0291784611,
0.0512173474,
0.0413831435,
-0.0425332636,
-0.0647837296,
-0.0130156875,
0.0232955627,
-0.0014213686,
0.0274782442,
0.0002893659,
-0.0220421441,
-0.0251510777,
-0.0197865218,
0.0155116227,
0.0082433792,
-0.0489904769,
0.0056646252,
-0.0094709853,
0.006904799,
0.0425619781,
-0.0498685911,
0.0518645048,
0.0283125564,
-0.0130999098,
0.0298558306,
0.047331132,
0.0440792888,
0.0211589653,
-0.0061956435,
0.0075548193,
0.0362921134,
-0.0112041542,
-0.0457949825,
0.0619434416,
-0.0520567857,
-0.0113927322,
0.0022438858,
-0.0638315007,
-0.0206827167,
0.0520904548,
-0.0237087365,
-0.0171616133,
0.032755781,
-0.0527748279,
0.0417461395,
0.0125412308,
0.0444625951,
-0.0108890915,
0.00851236,
-0.0136440303,
0.0356224589,
-0.0220013224,
0.0426345617,
-0.0500895865,
-0.0504748709,
-0.0031559661,
-0.0479317047,
-0.0279981513,
-0.0926101431,
-0.031956695,
-0.0098641794,
0.0159543362,
0.0510064922,
-0.0639797524,
0.0103995642,
-0.0808099285,
-0.0362644903,
-0.0054548634,
-0.0113142123,
0.0189938806,
-0.0361735374,
-0.0383311063,
-0.0425671004,
-0.0446211994,
0.0168693699,
0.0051247762,
0.0093635656,
0.0327248126,
-0.0253577568,
-0.0239997003,
-0.0285279807,
0.0063008908,
-0.0339017957,
-0.0159167349,
-0.0287887845,
-0.0052081067,
-0.0252353009,
0.071159251,
-0.0441661216,
0.0159684196,
-0.0180614255,
-0.0283808485,
0.017238941,
0.0317441262,
0.0637131482,
0.0338481963,
0.0360473096,
0.0218347367,
0.0166302621,
0.0429255553,
-0.0215728134,
0.0285268165,
-0.0076429108,
0.0124337617,
-0.028386496,
-0.0817262903,
0.0089601818,
0.0313272253,
0.0563861504,
-0.0083270865,
-0.0776664391,
0.0404215902,
-0.0085920962,
-0.0082432944,
-0.0554199032,
0.0026549804,
0.0205782633,
0.0312953219,
0.0014219147,
-0.0326616541,
0.0700994208,
0.039330557,
-0.0038868873,
-0.000522124,
-0.0230020024,
-0.0083865589,
0.0242626369,
0.0010015393,
0.0079956613,
0.0728977174,
0.02461938,
0.00829612,
-0.0313296095,
-0.0158164855,
-0.0183915347,
0.0512258224,
-0.076387018,
-0.0226900969,
0.0240242854,
-0.0430369973,
-0.0893400535,
-0.0565637052,
-0.0048326268,
-0.0646431446,
0.0093050925,
0.0496303365,
-0.0830390304,
-0.0627394244,
0.026822716,
0.0175064467,
-0.0066184909,
-0.0571153536,
0.0375426225,
-0.0236161295,
0.0542946309,
0.0187113769,
0.0337019749,
0.0243107975,
0.0258773956,
0.0377011299,
-0.0023544661,
0.0181789845,
0.0174112432,
0.0093136793,
-0.0134563427,
0.0040076408,
0.028601069,
0.0548962504,
0.055764623,
0.0166574325,
-0.0644959211,
0.0907112807,
0.0368768647,
-0.0160428248,
0.0437326245,
-0.0265087392,
-0.0140667669,
0.0554171503,
-0.0303082336,
-0.0801721811,
-0.0316936783,
-0.038262926,
0.0347869173,
-0.0422939584,
-0.0246067606,
0.0074797492,
-0.0785289556,
0.0479729511,
0.0152204139,
0.0243466236,
0.0270078052,
0.0290025845,
-0.0180483852,
-0.0068554762,
-0.0334210023,
-0.0250747409,
-0.0245204084,
0.021999279,
0.0013280044,
-0.0741711333,
-0.0539296567,
0.0244468693,
-0.0020344846,
0.0585700981,
-0.0024180193,
0.0291274693,
0.0307645649,
-0.0348255262,
-0.0331500098,
0.0170383994,
0.0097385459,
-0.0021266763,
0.0451234356,
-0.035627719,
0.0001549721,
-0.034598399,
0.0550815836,
-0.0867249593,
-0.0103038568,
0.0882339552,
0.0749789625,
-0.021206582,
-0.0099253263,
-0.0332462043,
0.0525363237,
0.0293830726,
0.0801607743,
0.0095301149,
-0.0380616933,
0.0626048297,
0.0045738048,
0.0194191858,
0.040649116,
-0.0188969988,
-0.0105949743,
-0.0252898466,
0.0857504308,
-0.0551825166,
-0.0913867056,
0.0354018211,
-0.0033059337,
0.0069999495,
-0.0394890606,
-0.0194980502,
0.0625000596,
-0.0810455829,
0.032018993,
-0.0192403961,
0.0024960183,
-0.0435659252,
-0.0361574776,
-0.0088695642,
-0.0200703517,
-0.0290315449,
0.0308141857,
-0.0199505929,
-0.0186934453,
0.0301465802,
0.0409689173,
0.0219796952,
-0.0002956706,
0.0135060661,
-0.0206950344,
-0.0045090918,
0.0316295587,
-0.0437697545,
0.011034796,
0.0101600196,
0.0387091301,
0.0310118124,
0.0353404544,
-0.0079632113,
0.064127624,
0.0284631401,
-0.0068922699,
-0.02100664,
-0.0168434922,
0.0281675141,
0.0244920664,
0.0306232106,
-0.0175683033,
-0.0007165763,
-0.0005905376,
-0.0044216625,
0.003973397,
-0.0516947135,
-0.0111254305,
-0.0033097654,
0.0373492837,
0.0017474083,
-0.0066161598,
-0.0038539409,
-0.0826542974,
-0.0032645203,
-0.0433514416,
-0.0478834994,
0.0085877143,
0.0360529684,
-0.0386204496,
-0.0021607759,
-0.0087584993,
-0.0076937089,
-0.0014157158,
0.0068159867,
-0.0017313312,
0.1089571863,
-0.007889335,
0.0283949263,
0.0094625764,
0.0072311205,
-0.0196088795,
-0.0371692069,
0.0058858837,
-0.0129987681,
0.0484735407,
0.0105306227,
0.0399943851,
-0.0308514237,
0.0033697179,
0.0244017076,
0.0224183816,
-0.0325587541,
-0.0456040315,
0.0376225188,
-0.0034112784,
-0.0283437986,
-0.067526035,
0.0203236528,
-0.0622253157,
0.0293211564,
0.0397211835,
-0.0320499018,
-0.0825708061,
-0.020861268,
0.0383271389,
0.061967656,
-0.007862173,
0.0392499678,
-0.0813821033,
-0.0455295369,
0.0261812452,
0.0032199773,
0.0259438418,
-0.0181097388,
0.0411586128,
0.0024952535,
-0.0038461017,
-0.0420861244,
-0.0309392679,
0.0610276163,
-0.0606457926,
-0.022373002,
-0.0510830358,
-5.629354284e-33,
-0.0118473778,
0.0088332919,
0.0034506144,
0.0175728239,
-0.0031579239,
-0.0045497641,
0.005331479,
0.0421918929,
-0.0024139513,
0.0573322587,
0.0322411694,
0.0424411483,
-0.0091986759,
0.0304215103,
0.0186467171,
0.0330938473,
0.0170452315,
-0.0063387295,
-0.0201580264,
0.0013795322,
0.0325305536,
0.0603694692,
0.0837549493,
-0.0731120482,
0.011353381,
-0.0165717136,
-0.0227419399,
0.0100940978,
0.017010875,
0.0260696355,
-0.0622174181,
0.0504598841,
0.047841657,
0.0327677019,
0.0348759294,
-0.0096765971,
-0.0129246693,
-0.0622125939,
0.0430105701,
-0.0232110247,
-0.0492724553,
-0.0182807781,
-0.0205840003,
0.0063933758,
-0.045038607,
0.0357807465,
0.0339611918,
-0.0186609812,
0.0462481566,
0.0394071564,
-0.0525494032,
-0.0284893941,
-0.0095908651,
-0.0437657274,
-0.0638290122,
0.0355583616,
-0.0246057082,
-0.0032286365,
-0.0378238671,
0.0471138209,
0.0189221948,
0.0093937423,
0.0039332486,
-0.059506271,
-0.0274603032,
0.0749081522,
0.0048132832,
0.0124087175,
0.0123921027,
-0.0136755621,
0.0238780864,
0.0060555581,
0.050698597,
0.0428606197,
0.0492006168,
-0.0398268402,
-0.0274679027,
0.011803424,
0.0283244047,
-0.0025814283,
0.0265941657,
-0.0346041918,
-0.0191174671,
0.0049851071,
-0.0332712457,
-0.0183627736,
-0.0155975465,
-0.004498553,
0.0299372822,
0.0051533603,
-0.006898582,
0.0152592584,
-0.033605285,
-0.004484307,
0.0239891745,
0.0072766757,
-0.0288818479,
-0.0125138443,
0.0122669088,
-0.0333200507,
-0.0809293166,
0.0078902356,
0.0274389479,
0.0112112537,
0.0398144834,
-0.020855682,
0.071285896,
0.0091587817,
-0.0581940934,
-0.023885522,
-0.0185785182,
0.0793123171,
-0.0153920818,
-0.0187982395,
-0.0095650759,
0.0545511469,
-0.0456991419,
0.0236977525,
0.0223197918,
-0.0614189468,
-0.0868783519,
0.0053949105,
0.0143842008,
0.0326795951,
-0.002085103,
-0.0305390153,
-0.014591,
0.011664262,
0.0713532194,
-0.0445233025,
-0.0013421677,
-0.0193992462,
2.69e-7,
0.0057478719,
0.0382939689,
0.0017322624,
0.0272536464,
0.0235934053,
0.0492473878,
-0.0284268688,
0.0518650301,
0.036461059,
0.0026847513,
0.0132486327,
-0.00072032,
0.0249649715,
-0.0185814574,
-0.0199742448,
-0.0286767967,
-0.0136377383,
-0.0319848247,
-0.0236507468,
0.013946984,
0.0785959288,
0.0604665168,
0.0360332467,
-0.0562203862,
0.0201096218,
0.0548852533,
0.0797178596,
-0.0747833326,
0.0099553633,
0.0074635586,
-0.003014745,
-0.0360177644,
-0.0105904248,
0.0191117451,
0.0391774252,
-0.0004544104,
-0.0486371741,
0.0520810001,
-0.0150893917,
-0.0004473923,
-0.0059449682,
0.0917974785,
-0.0340337269,
-0.0334854648,
-0.0137152104,
-0.0876630843,
-0.0150775984,
-0.0007838279,
-0.0373340324,
0.0027827595,
0.0528590307,
-0.0015005858,
-0.0448454209,
0.0222121011,
0.0495297834,
0.0143773798,
0.0010176015,
-0.0567162149,
-0.0186560676,
0.0170998387,
-0.0182688423,
0.0067837168,
-0.0432295576,
0.0118701877,
-0.0377862193,
-0.0887179449,
0.0399390794,
2.214102155e-34,
-0.0151709411,
0.0361311883,
0.0153587963,
-0.0195269939,
0.0133596445,
0.012103484,
-0.0263493191,
0.0335881524,
-0.0409420393,
-0.0238424893,
-0.0143132098
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.03679v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.03679v1 | Undecimated Wavelet Transform for Word Embedded Semantic Marginal Autoencoder in Security improvement and Denoising different Languages | 2023-07-06T04:10:40 | 2023-07-06T04:10:40 | Shreyanth S | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.IR, cs.LG | By combining the undecimated wavelet transform within a Word Embedded
Semantic Marginal Autoencoder (WESMA), this research study provides a novel
strategy for improving security measures and denoising multiple languages. The
incorporation of these strategies is intended to address the issues of
robustness, privacy, and multilingualism in data processing applications. The
undecimated wavelet transform is used as a feature extraction tool to identify
prominent language patterns and structural qualities in the input data. The
proposed system may successfully capture significant information while
preserving the temporal and geographical links within the data by employing
this transform. This improves security measures by increasing the system's
ability to detect abnormalities, discover hidden patterns, and distinguish
between legitimate content and dangerous threats. The Word Embedded Semantic
Marginal Autoencoder also functions as an intelligent framework for
dimensionality and noise reduction. The autoencoder effectively learns the
underlying semantics of the data and reduces noise components by exploiting
word embeddings and semantic context. As a result, data quality and accuracy
are increased in following processing stages. The suggested methodology is
tested using a diversified dataset that includes several languages and security
scenarios. The experimental results show that the proposed approach is
effective in attaining security enhancement and denoising capabilities across
multiple languages. The system is strong in dealing with linguistic variances,
producing consistent outcomes regardless of the language used. Furthermore,
incorporating the undecimated wavelet transform considerably improves the
system's ability to efficiently address complex security concerns | [
0.0137572819,
0.0998380631,
-0.0133122485,
0.032538414,
-0.0359295942,
0.0291845538,
0.0715913177,
0.007529451,
-0.0087039741,
-0.0239064768,
0.0167279299,
0.0112377955,
-0.0040395274,
0.0333560817,
0.0280755907,
0.0029963537,
0.0657512173,
-0.0168861095,
0.0179847404,
-0.0194357224,
-0.014466675,
-0.0038494314,
0.0502491482,
0.0197620541,
-0.0480461828,
0.0102276187,
-0.011129736,
-0.0517534763,
0.0380309336,
0.0043715215,
-0.0395573154,
0.006002659,
0.0179075543,
0.0182963442,
0.0000024791,
-0.047417812,
-0.0571247973,
-0.0089375777,
0.0274857935,
-0.0174489375,
0.037310183,
-0.0418891162,
-0.0032965571,
-0.0168776624,
-0.0221105386,
-0.0367657356,
0.0424477272,
0.0402673706,
0.0844325423,
0.0460429564,
-0.0467058718,
-0.0320655294,
-0.015708914,
0.007695714,
-0.0340093821,
-0.0159947965,
0.0560653657,
-0.0513910204,
-0.0313910842,
0.0044865743,
-0.0101569332,
0.0518325232,
0.0107916975,
-0.0394370146,
-0.0061531044,
-0.0291900132,
-0.04911796,
-0.0551034361,
0.0140182292,
0.0160911903,
-0.053420566,
0.0161036272,
-0.0126214223,
0.012058883,
-0.0190259516,
0.0735901594,
0.0105415732,
0.0196326859,
0.0207944997,
0.0153784519,
0.0149038341,
0.076927714,
0.0175725855,
-0.0064142649,
-0.0190216433,
0.0800128356,
0.0070499154,
-0.0261808559,
-0.0188299194,
-0.0879407004,
0.0099195847,
-0.0031835793,
0.050208658,
-0.0030159294,
0.0516112745,
0.0197951794,
-0.0686010346,
-0.0524500385,
0.0233160313,
-0.0582351126,
-0.0122570088,
0.0053145601,
-0.0263048764,
0.0041550449,
-0.0190552827,
0.0191084929,
-0.0054289736,
-0.0084615238,
0.001657287,
-0.0455860421,
-0.0170323607,
0.0197303463,
0.0094169118,
0.0668683425,
-0.0017455263,
0.0091901226,
-0.052212581,
0.0343908891,
-0.0355884284,
0.0316328183,
-0.0133546693,
0.0047423686,
-0.0152095072,
-0.0052535045,
0.0190369189,
-0.0368573591,
0.0130190607,
0.0057470622,
-0.0540830605,
-0.0208511297,
0.0355858542,
0.0301900394,
0.0583128482,
-0.0299373381,
-0.0248408187,
0.0686322004,
0.040331848,
-0.0004004293,
-0.0715637282,
-0.0645645037,
-0.0090330858,
0.0426290222,
-0.0361228622,
-0.0532133915,
-0.0063066855,
-0.0183766335,
-0.0024455888,
-0.0661647394,
-0.0004174612,
0.0066263876,
-0.0459294356,
0.0827555954,
-0.0458954871,
-0.0359073244,
0.0286888927,
0.0224375166,
0.0484360605,
0.0349534675,
-0.0221926682,
0.0127739804,
0.0290741213,
-0.0279708598,
0.0245220829,
0.0058292896,
0.0018356805,
-0.0034637002,
-0.0513272136,
0.0141306631,
0.0337834097,
-0.0835425481,
0.0282397252,
0.0252606738,
0.0338819958,
-0.0724556744,
0.0480234548,
0.0748759732,
-0.0439642631,
0.0440437794,
-0.0216358975,
0.0229127407,
-0.042864453,
-0.0069513125,
0.0342467465,
-0.0425260477,
-0.0468145683,
-0.0470602252,
-0.0060585532,
0.020439066,
0.0022815075,
-0.0160553344,
-0.014318346,
-0.0588444248,
0.0426888131,
0.0090718213,
0.0245059486,
0.0102400947,
0.0174559299,
0.0412495434,
0.0407095067,
-0.0097806528,
0.0006395748,
-0.032146845,
0.0124234725,
0.0275882222,
0.0102673136,
0.0161090624,
0.043081969,
-0.0815315843,
-0.0704428926,
0.0205724034,
-0.0735025331,
0.0126034217,
0.0290564355,
-0.0445660874,
-0.074423559,
-0.0033323595,
-0.0060646338,
0.0439072289,
-0.0354700051,
0.091486752,
0.0382292382,
-0.0053808889,
0.0070364103,
0.0048965388,
0.0603576638,
-0.0282417033,
0.0495771132,
0.0393270589,
0.0481761023,
0.0319878198,
-0.0249626711,
0.0178970192,
0.0365090184,
-0.0178370085,
-0.0197043438,
-0.0190255158,
-0.0416317172,
0.0201622993,
0.0149776153,
-0.0387664214,
0.037492834,
0.0409913994,
0.0161508992,
-0.0315268785,
0.0458563082,
-0.0246662982,
0.0007028004,
-0.0407047607,
-0.0061618979,
-0.0247893427,
0.0592219122,
-0.0312317479,
0.0331420712,
-0.0103087854,
-0.0278598387,
0.0001147338,
-0.015370057,
0.0713078827,
0.0136057362,
-0.0169734061,
-0.0123833446,
-0.0134251164,
-0.0055008992,
0.074935399,
-0.006034004,
0.0236299895,
0.0002086265,
-0.0230405703,
-0.0502203852,
-0.0164890531,
-0.0036998938,
0.0279657934,
0.0321029574,
-0.0233452786,
-0.0506030768,
-0.0194091182,
0.0050035901,
-0.0277885254,
0.0040956386,
0.0484697893,
-0.001826645,
-0.0047463314,
0.0354043655,
-0.0425670519,
0.0107581438,
0.070451498,
0.0061530247,
-0.0507863387,
-0.0211969912,
0.0174158812,
-0.0229410958,
0.0158128217,
0.0329103172,
-0.0826857537,
-0.0033781857,
-0.0180781502,
-0.001254983,
-0.0394539945,
0.0218122248,
0.0275401156,
0.0678078681,
-0.0031342944,
-0.0011593512,
-0.0184419956,
-0.0319042094,
0.0686023161,
-0.014294547,
0.0173453949,
0.0204476304,
0.0048623383,
0.0677154064,
-0.0004607707,
0.0065903356,
0.0256220363,
-0.0039029045,
-0.0241032559,
-0.071918197,
-0.0495810211,
0.0048734182,
0.0620055534,
-0.0099815223,
0.00025162,
0.045168072,
-0.0091196131,
0.0506586097,
-0.0388449803,
-0.0545424037,
0.0014805679,
-0.0067070276,
-0.003174851,
0.050243035,
-0.0250596218,
-0.0607397333,
0.030308893,
-0.0351662599,
0.0511547253,
0.0017052251,
-0.0263157003,
0.0355889387,
-0.0229669791,
0.0176016781,
0.0024166827,
-0.0678229406,
-0.0434670895,
0.027259754,
0.0077719856,
0.0382932536,
-0.0303277504,
0.0011296396,
0.0362002999,
0.0002896064,
0.0332603119,
-0.0069895419,
-0.0213209335,
-0.0169619359,
0.0528437681,
0.0365991257,
-0.0651701912,
0.0103547135,
0.0457216911,
0.00682595,
0.0258070473,
-0.0032778603,
-0.041702494,
0.0062569208,
0.0434338711,
0.011996353,
0.0037802972,
0.0249699764,
0.0340839587,
0.0180203076,
-0.0273149516,
0.0115027037,
0.0813548639,
0.0096687358,
-0.0413772352,
-0.0192326251,
-0.0157703832,
-0.043464385,
0.0034147317,
-0.0346853733,
-0.0336008109,
0.0244446341,
0.0074764267,
0.0318864025,
-0.0399771109,
-0.0326530039,
0.0020419501,
-0.045441851,
0.0091373269,
0.0265902802,
-0.0012746296,
-0.0546828136,
-0.0639232025,
-0.0025627804,
0.0128990402,
0.0246539991,
-0.0418448262,
0.044046171,
-0.0435117222,
0.0180663131,
-0.0652331263,
-0.0709739774,
-0.0121764746,
-0.0107694976,
0.0179077834,
0.0169823319,
0.0152009185,
-0.0471971743,
-0.0996423215,
0.0151418764,
-0.010239007,
-0.0142623037,
-0.0237117242,
0.0095143039,
0.0026656394,
-0.0400699042,
0.015124769,
0.0323266238,
0.0116797974,
-0.0056878058,
0.011061593,
0.0426782407,
-0.0432084687,
0.0183105581,
-0.0387157351,
-0.0397764184,
0.0192797836,
0.0081704492,
-0.0087845754,
0.0069079706,
0.0086583486,
0.000176239,
-0.0054425527,
0.0154473074,
0.0006648707,
0.0640432015,
-0.0122606773,
-0.1176469177,
-0.0244628638,
-0.0576650538,
-0.0367923751,
0.0262882616,
0.0522997603,
0.0041009756,
0.0582866631,
-0.003107734,
-0.0874901786,
-0.0484340563,
-0.0048588347,
-0.0224409718,
0.0202893689,
0.0295636412,
-0.0140126012,
-0.0156990662,
-0.0114928978,
-0.0201195609,
-0.0076856646,
-0.0197945442,
0.0359750651,
0.0029221403,
0.0088858837,
0.0058480473,
-0.0612027161,
-0.0654767156,
0.1039018109,
0.0145084905,
-0.0700874031,
-0.0755974427,
0.0480590314,
-0.027862981,
0.0031414167,
-0.0003094962,
0.0152310375,
0.0064991917,
0.0226134118,
-0.0885896087,
-0.0472025312,
-0.0074193841,
0.0339581333,
0.0395824276,
0.0364096984,
-0.0037575699,
0.0824943706,
-0.0452442057,
-0.0124978442,
-0.0120464657,
0.0001074074,
-0.0092800576,
0.0219067764,
0.0208461732,
-0.0326659642,
0.0176470596,
0.0373071395,
-0.0172969326,
-0.0732166916,
-0.0076666623,
0.0474202409,
0.0184373632,
0.0406785682,
-0.019340653,
0.0347723924,
-0.0376048498,
0.0528864041,
0.0341787636,
0.0104736155,
-0.0125397723,
0.0067825178,
-0.0147645706,
0.0228822976,
-0.0136312423,
0.0347619876,
-0.0173205175,
0.0138902543,
-0.0274351947,
0.0077522192,
0.013060431,
0.0113199893,
0.034331549,
-0.021670999,
0.0089353733,
-0.0151941404,
0.0235747695,
0.003010134,
-0.0100050708,
0.0204490609,
-0.0203460641,
-0.0395534001,
0.030560445,
0.0444243848,
-0.0255185179,
0.0061605764,
0.0051640021,
-0.0724254549,
-0.050504934,
0.0594950132,
0.1002387553,
0.0549534112,
-0.0424731411,
0.0076393555,
-0.0354733318,
-0.073309496,
-0.0327736661,
-0.0460726582,
0.0161610022,
0.0548890457,
0.0333067514,
0.0579691231,
0.0092922254,
0.0165895857,
-0.0568827838,
-0.0156789161,
0.039051123,
-0.0016505969,
0.0337076783,
-6.976560441e-33,
0.0334999301,
-0.0425146185,
-0.0495861396,
-0.0106796576,
0.0724834874,
0.0139691159,
0.0110370303,
-0.0192150548,
-0.0083456822,
0.0076146061,
0.0169642568,
-0.0269724689,
0.0043931953,
0.0126090981,
-0.0030684255,
-0.0000349305,
0.0219227578,
-0.0017183386,
0.0168740023,
0.0202565193,
0.0931205824,
0.0284010228,
0.069594942,
-0.120504491,
0.0309430361,
0.0370158739,
-0.0225456357,
-0.0463661514,
0.0659329817,
-0.0050392528,
-0.0626890361,
0.0583603159,
0.0013300144,
-0.0103188893,
-0.0531491339,
0.0265737921,
-0.0126895513,
-0.0673377961,
-0.0210301671,
0.0314041972,
0.0226376243,
-0.0903597996,
0.0337792784,
-0.0308767017,
-0.0216643363,
0.0042620399,
0.0382498987,
-0.0137063935,
-0.0168895572,
-0.0922569185,
-0.0162244793,
0.023599349,
-0.0178810228,
0.0199260339,
0.0711809769,
-0.0126677733,
0.0196276829,
-0.0643364713,
-0.0734063983,
0.0577745326,
0.0346358865,
0.0050998307,
0.0175950713,
-0.0408501215,
-0.0228989664,
0.0518852696,
0.0090689827,
-0.0241942424,
0.0497701503,
0.0147048878,
0.0420669578,
0.0200147703,
0.0051097102,
0.0404366665,
0.038374383,
-0.0661932901,
-0.0624863766,
0.0265996233,
-0.0050245263,
-0.0017442391,
0.0141350059,
-0.0202380791,
-0.0290065892,
-0.0333624259,
-0.0025523133,
-0.0307003688,
-0.0410412252,
-0.0192064457,
-0.0019891369,
-0.0345069282,
-0.0599608496,
0.0036776909,
0.0031643852,
-0.0455676578,
0.0072162435,
0.0067691384,
0.0088596325,
-0.0200149491,
0.0261633098,
-0.0227657538,
0.0395225845,
-0.004426721,
0.0221855268,
-0.0045383642,
0.00148232,
-0.0088647474,
0.0104956795,
0.0731566101,
-0.0564171448,
-0.0283055808,
0.0081738969,
0.0126409084,
0.0358716287,
-0.0106799463,
0.0060490677,
-0.012864585,
-0.0214397795,
-0.0033851194,
0.0381628349,
0.0003203072,
0.0225319974,
0.0196508542,
-0.0155481743,
0.0440436713,
0.0003980944,
-0.0005204941,
-0.0358461179,
0.0261000525,
0.0565322302,
-0.0017743579,
0.0228595436,
-0.0132538565,
3.315e-7,
0.0160728227,
0.0137855988,
0.0326032564,
-0.0215344168,
0.0001123619,
0.0285752416,
0.0130476663,
0.0601559393,
-0.0216593314,
-0.0382447764,
0.0099709854,
-0.036350958,
0.0136319902,
0.0390515439,
-0.016080156,
-0.0083314907,
-0.0297383275,
-0.0026959074,
-0.0700262934,
0.0373066999,
0.0863291845,
0.1065557227,
0.0257679783,
-0.0271145571,
-0.0040921792,
0.0073429812,
-0.0112719731,
0.0059761689,
-0.0461245291,
-0.0485602431,
0.0003669625,
0.0547685809,
0.0415659808,
0.0268230755,
-0.0130050974,
0.0193254128,
-0.020829998,
0.0146412095,
-0.012919832,
0.0231546983,
0.0007253485,
-0.0216356385,
-0.0247547477,
-0.0511461645,
0.0643268898,
0.0009699949,
-0.0697503462,
0.0314039588,
-0.0122636743,
-0.0069076992,
0.0969751403,
-0.0030419745,
-0.0018974891,
0.0131605733,
0.0335747674,
-0.0023035582,
0.0006064773,
-0.0439068526,
0.0118759722,
-0.0129491482,
-0.015239439,
0.0272458643,
0.0192964505,
-0.0185181387,
0.0857757032,
0.0235395189,
0.0377896428,
3.267046169e-34,
-0.0150521472,
-0.0060046795,
-0.056548629,
-0.0298636779,
-0.0111448178,
-0.029994186,
-0.0382019356,
0.0282206498,
0.0142583167,
-0.0095952637,
-0.049776461
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.02763v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.02763v1 | Your spouse needs professional help: Determining the Contextual Appropriateness of Messages through Modeling Social Relationships | 2023-07-06T04:06:05 | 2023-07-06T04:06:05 | David Jurgens, Agrima Seth, Jackson Sargent, Athena Aghighi, Michael Geraci | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | Understanding interpersonal communication requires, in part, understanding
the social context and norms in which a message is said. However, current
methods for identifying offensive content in such communication largely operate
independent of context, with only a few approaches considering community norms
or prior conversation as context. Here, we introduce a new approach to
identifying inappropriate communication by explicitly modeling the social
relationship between the individuals. We introduce a new dataset of
contextually-situated judgments of appropriateness and show that large language
models can readily incorporate relationship information to accurately identify
appropriateness in a given context. Using data from online conversations and
movie dialogues, we provide insight into how the relationships themselves
function as implicit norms and quantify the degree to which context-sensitivity
is needed in different conversation settings. Further, we also demonstrate that
contextual-appropriateness judgments are predictive of other social factors
expressed in language such as condescension and politeness. | [
0.0835829899,
0.0581903867,
-0.0287807789,
0.0281565171,
-0.0415800326,
0.008214931,
0.0752926916,
0.037775714,
0.0402133204,
-0.0733979642,
-0.049460534,
-0.0498118401,
0.0184903275,
0.0345948189,
-0.0057435343,
0.0001856283,
-0.0244544633,
0.0593075268,
0.0529173426,
-0.0002857601,
0.0645915717,
0.0220114589,
0.0361953415,
0.0301940832,
-0.0372522771,
-0.0156023027,
0.0462760366,
0.037230514,
0.0200016778,
-0.0027439697,
0.084496662,
0.0709182322,
0.02417247,
-0.0242560618,
0.0000017154,
-0.0579564199,
0.0418568552,
-0.0190464258,
0.0118925087,
0.0201091077,
0.1018675491,
-0.0459610559,
-0.0277014971,
0.0220511165,
-0.0433727726,
0.0408990309,
0.0415818691,
0.036274828,
0.0216724947,
0.0270512179,
-0.0243801381,
0.0063395449,
-0.0548674427,
-0.0146665275,
-0.0395796522,
-0.0324961096,
0.0590069257,
0.0166325588,
-0.0427888893,
0.0050482117,
-0.0127913076,
-0.0087822443,
-0.0374982804,
-0.017673837,
0.0100485114,
-0.009989081,
0.0105995191,
-0.0035022122,
-0.0076389634,
0.0674192458,
0.0320987441,
-0.0136021879,
0.0162663721,
-0.0190067571,
-0.0249038171,
0.0163921248,
-0.0264231712,
0.0141854221,
-0.0070580347,
0.0030430926,
-0.0199246407,
0.0068862075,
0.0388763957,
0.0609932877,
0.085817419,
0.0616244785,
-0.0231398493,
-0.0340938829,
-0.0415932536,
-0.0205593426,
0.0081145419,
-0.0380688086,
0.041374065,
-0.0301500671,
-0.0087775122,
0.0137596754,
-0.019109739,
0.0108180176,
0.0406441353,
-0.0711236224,
-0.0008533124,
0.0194338951,
-0.0289509017,
0.0142747657,
0.0582827441,
0.0054441825,
0.0115185436,
-0.0129844891,
-0.0042626569,
-0.0039001107,
-0.0217845235,
0.0267046187,
0.0286009088,
-0.0263270028,
-0.0459797941,
0.024691876,
-0.0643177181,
0.0081565185,
-0.0964437723,
-0.0329234302,
-0.0008823455,
0.0246757865,
-0.0416804217,
-0.0002929838,
-0.0178885777,
-0.0155440308,
-0.070349291,
0.055769708,
-0.0536963604,
-0.0346888527,
0.0302466601,
-0.0200055055,
0.0111795478,
-0.0068248999,
0.0045015942,
0.0373706073,
0.0099740038,
-0.0058895699,
0.0115856547,
-0.0216557942,
-0.0928121284,
-0.0099702161,
-0.0146996817,
-0.0382969677,
0.0483586192,
0.0192828737,
-0.0334252045,
-0.0502187163,
0.0127665177,
0.0087463101,
-0.0632201433,
0.0456353463,
0.0392304324,
0.0105234524,
0.032246653,
0.0568881519,
-0.0088412957,
0.0308734123,
0.0212841239,
-0.0150384484,
0.0636527613,
0.0152260642,
-0.0148955546,
0.0232590064,
0.013455024,
-0.0037709828,
-0.0500346199,
0.0517813377,
-0.0100655723,
-0.0209193751,
-0.0010693081,
0.0344050676,
-0.0022309485,
-0.033525791,
0.0281072985,
0.0832401961,
-0.0363760926,
0.0660297498,
0.0419635922,
0.0464272387,
-0.0568297692,
0.0115595926,
-0.0316502303,
-0.0282014403,
-0.0365543664,
-0.069592163,
0.0359757282,
0.0401278026,
-0.0201744996,
-0.0341630429,
0.0044100564,
-0.0161360539,
0.080639191,
-0.0352253728,
0.0191392396,
-0.0006408901,
-0.0250608437,
-0.0348850861,
0.0497048609,
-0.035292089,
-0.0059750695,
-0.0094561279,
0.0318213329,
0.1230555698,
0.035911344,
0.0122623341,
-0.0037954058,
-0.0521710999,
0.0451755263,
-0.0227604918,
-0.0092152078,
-0.0032775099,
0.0184272826,
-0.0402486436,
-0.0119191185,
0.0775781646,
0.0214422476,
-0.0037464264,
0.033098463,
0.0039011762,
0.0151411109,
0.0533056483,
-0.0078132795,
0.0146136368,
-0.0147808129,
-0.011946396,
-0.0037045372,
0.010081796,
0.0655348152,
0.0246033128,
0.0010663042,
-0.0611540936,
0.0140916063,
0.0054239202,
-0.0050522634,
0.034368407,
-0.0665339455,
0.0188121572,
0.0025673513,
-0.0434418321,
-0.0048134052,
-0.0135596413,
-0.0151597178,
0.0292723775,
0.0416354351,
0.006129134,
0.0088751437,
-0.0351717435,
-0.03948671,
-0.0276911557,
0.0182149205,
0.0168461259,
0.0076264837,
-0.0468512364,
-0.0128609771,
0.0188159682,
-0.0445441231,
0.002504796,
-0.0027355822,
-0.0163426958,
-0.0468844622,
-0.0386532098,
0.007025368,
0.0103149358,
0.0252552163,
-0.0323272422,
-0.0042518931,
-0.1117142662,
-0.0302117225,
0.0017479197,
-0.0129729472,
0.0245576259,
-0.0080328705,
-0.0093545327,
-0.0108340466,
0.0020943787,
-0.018894393,
0.004660097,
0.0041620894,
0.0254769083,
-0.0347994156,
-0.0264903512,
-0.0319002941,
-0.0423344597,
-0.0420735627,
0.0416060872,
0.0006482595,
-0.0264462046,
0.0153247593,
-0.0151222181,
-0.0435238518,
0.0469687432,
-0.0279206969,
-0.0703627095,
-0.0032272527,
0.036499355,
0.008555118,
0.0416888185,
0.0753491372,
0.0587399267,
0.0332812853,
-0.0158096086,
-0.0285382643,
-0.0090386597,
-0.0218541976,
0.0153925354,
0.0037730746,
-0.0753041878,
-0.0227834657,
0.011050011,
0.0143407099,
0.0014844021,
-0.0492856428,
0.0221631378,
0.0018577343,
-0.0475587621,
-0.0410764664,
-0.067918852,
-0.006208207,
0.0364933498,
0.0133340107,
-0.0701433718,
0.0435694307,
0.0131492298,
0.0078449361,
0.0195824057,
-0.0355455801,
0.0065955287,
0.0489627682,
-0.0066647446,
0.024257699,
0.033588171,
-0.0275058281,
-0.0253428351,
-0.0576176457,
0.060026098,
-0.0165687688,
0.0196078625,
-0.0539525487,
-0.0089783855,
0.0633849576,
-0.0534641296,
-0.0297626089,
-0.0352949388,
-0.0456761532,
-0.0157003328,
-0.0111408541,
-0.0337016545,
0.0100000352,
0.0159694739,
-0.0263746697,
-0.0351497903,
0.0202163905,
0.0105240066,
0.027242953,
-0.0277369004,
0.0270244218,
0.003634857,
-0.0406961218,
0.0190843269,
-0.0178190339,
0.0453949645,
-0.0291227289,
-0.0017331665,
0.0027236552,
0.0282452572,
0.0018276812,
0.0564145781,
0.0278102607,
0.0186649468,
0.0236701015,
0.0076493933,
-0.0239909869,
0.0953388885,
0.0211379342,
-0.0344060771,
-0.0003670217,
-0.0164227225,
-0.0160887707,
0.0094288783,
-0.0217371415,
-0.0907056183,
-0.0090608802,
-0.007019022,
-0.0267007723,
-0.071807377,
-0.0532473326,
-0.0140138408,
-0.0328691341,
0.0099822935,
0.0129840439,
-0.0048061181,
-0.0343057439,
0.0230698846,
0.0272855535,
-0.0057780412,
0.0308563709,
-0.0170953963,
0.0293393042,
-0.0264547523,
-0.008378461,
-0.0309669022,
-0.0552392937,
0.0910840854,
-0.018703578,
0.0726489797,
0.0011165594,
0.0849281922,
-0.0174831282,
-0.0230240282,
0.0333944224,
0.0038049985,
-0.0292037819,
-0.0372506231,
0.0231271405,
-0.0383353606,
0.0192320701,
-0.0497567207,
0.0495488234,
0.0166347735,
-0.0277231727,
0.0068845092,
0.0294475276,
0.0019241855,
-0.0324098654,
-0.0445691682,
0.0685868934,
0.0609114692,
0.0770650804,
-0.0076477546,
-0.0651731715,
0.0310504809,
-0.0164213385,
-0.0152439754,
0.0715123266,
-0.0159965064,
-0.0330544896,
-0.0018564402,
-0.0291089639,
-0.0641615167,
-0.0015163801,
0.0185701717,
-0.0109499348,
0.0254171044,
-0.0718972832,
-0.0063998164,
-0.0135018649,
-0.035833016,
-0.0289072935,
0.0011131576,
0.0008928659,
0.0070443386,
0.0302774869,
-0.019256847,
-0.0153159173,
-0.0327690691,
0.021912951,
0.0089165829,
-0.0434785038,
0.0321109667,
0.0229057521,
0.0154445451,
0.0398993604,
-0.0037889278,
-0.0366029218,
-0.0142173283,
0.0685547367,
-0.0286430493,
0.0125935646,
0.0544172935,
0.0290205088,
0.0187477563,
0.0316411704,
-0.0102917617,
0.0671522394,
0.0038093121,
-0.0085475314,
-0.0496517979,
-0.0806281567,
-0.0314881057,
-0.0453404635,
0.0006707959,
-0.0026024929,
-0.0721001178,
-0.0151520502,
-0.0257129222,
-0.0152453827,
-0.0161721334,
-0.0056288461,
0.0196382981,
-0.0313586183,
-0.0027637121,
-0.0646405369,
-0.0353325307,
-0.0943476483,
0.0404831134,
-0.0321979411,
0.002416352,
0.0418581441,
0.0250212606,
0.0090204775,
-0.0018707758,
-0.0183869097,
0.0046830769,
-0.0279553235,
-0.0025707327,
0.0211365242,
0.0791368634,
0.0235436112,
0.0041389968,
-0.0225629173,
0.0096614528,
-0.0003896347,
0.0478919744,
-0.0101286368,
0.0344880559,
-0.0034536936,
-0.0543982871,
0.0271153674,
-0.0263229292,
-0.0023994585,
-0.0264509097,
0.0627693534,
-0.0362384915,
-0.0607751906,
0.0455494151,
0.0119533278,
-0.026451176,
0.0589299947,
0.0311027393,
-0.0533687398,
0.0148985824,
0.0492185727,
-0.0569395944,
-0.0141613455,
0.0021321578,
0.044661276,
0.0364131033,
0.005429632,
0.0206261557,
-0.07033737,
-0.0247417577,
0.0120786214,
-0.0195156597,
0.037174657,
-0.0322901271,
0.022149073,
0.0799559727,
-0.001720535,
-0.0024500664,
0.0159491301,
-0.0014029399,
-0.0312168784,
-0.0300124455,
-0.0580784455,
-5.173187905e-33,
-0.0045207636,
-0.0682530552,
-0.0261129532,
0.0527526066,
0.0017124066,
-0.0129199093,
-0.0107398247,
-0.0175867155,
0.0021093716,
0.0375166573,
-0.002055885,
0.0508828163,
-0.0023445636,
0.0055406983,
0.02908797,
-0.0388549007,
0.0207815412,
-0.0260875747,
-0.0030679847,
0.0182117019,
0.052675575,
0.0215063877,
0.0139964698,
-0.1194991469,
0.0591125526,
0.0015390152,
-0.0512821823,
-0.0016788271,
0.034198001,
0.0324379988,
-0.0394025519,
0.0694315657,
0.029083075,
0.0535045937,
0.0362412483,
0.0990872756,
-0.0489769392,
-0.0144769205,
0.0319132134,
-0.0312523693,
0.0254373029,
-0.0149219958,
0.0245228019,
0.0207912587,
-0.0297584441,
-0.0281353388,
0.0502205603,
-0.026859913,
0.0459151901,
-0.003679442,
-0.0270569157,
0.0082047256,
-0.0410817824,
-0.0063603013,
-0.0022959318,
0.0389798284,
0.0030481338,
0.0009582963,
-0.0290068854,
0.0381752253,
-0.009755752,
-0.0155671798,
0.0142799364,
-0.0437712148,
0.051844988,
0.0656235144,
0.0114317909,
0.0495595336,
-0.0071993871,
-0.0496110879,
0.0053005819,
0.04028273,
-0.0214371458,
0.0517889336,
0.0027243851,
-0.0665124282,
-0.0743458197,
-0.0370708518,
0.0415016226,
-0.014878639,
0.0424864069,
-0.0154631082,
-0.0931404904,
-0.0567246974,
0.0200373139,
-0.03324062,
-0.0105709853,
-0.0529198237,
0.0281560477,
-0.0141886128,
-0.0073384675,
-0.0268232431,
-0.0309959669,
-0.0585258193,
-0.032543391,
0.0016560109,
-0.0198818091,
-0.0274801943,
0.049018953,
0.0288783889,
-0.034294486,
-0.0210847985,
0.0092995986,
0.01233151,
0.0158926956,
0.0053316089,
0.0372196846,
0.016989829,
-0.0456575193,
-0.0146239391,
0.005217643,
0.0247122087,
-0.0355396606,
0.031467557,
-0.0032026889,
0.0662767887,
-0.0360915735,
0.0391556397,
0.0257776212,
-0.0033942368,
-0.015792517,
-0.0201309565,
-0.0144479237,
0.0077185472,
-0.0522386357,
-0.0088649839,
0.0063633379,
-0.0362579077,
0.0666960478,
0.0084053716,
-0.0085115833,
-0.0609042831,
2.405e-7,
0.0087211998,
0.065209046,
0.0178042743,
0.0207546055,
0.0228122827,
0.0439189225,
0.0273711029,
0.055293791,
0.0388425142,
-0.0100884177,
0.0425018668,
-0.0093991114,
0.0194159672,
0.0148855578,
-0.0080255838,
0.0063341958,
-0.093785435,
-0.0454398431,
0.0176458452,
-0.0171294324,
0.0234377328,
0.019406464,
0.0534438193,
-0.018894868,
-0.0314029828,
-0.0146474363,
0.0156651326,
-0.1095369831,
0.0329424962,
-0.0302421506,
0.0169515274,
-0.054194916,
0.0224886145,
0.0605965555,
-0.001908501,
-0.0008863797,
-0.007132276,
0.0992051065,
-0.0030220514,
0.0113063296,
-0.0248179361,
0.0002230624,
-0.0270682946,
-0.0323606245,
0.0149208698,
-0.0329052135,
-0.0107090957,
-0.0051691197,
0.0012508795,
-0.0316646062,
0.0245953519,
-0.0210051127,
0.0027836973,
0.0020943324,
0.0278494079,
0.0080494136,
0.0257461797,
-0.0543307513,
0.0248862393,
0.0240611173,
-0.0302085783,
-0.0633589476,
0.0107979942,
-0.0097781038,
0.0184342228,
0.0037634254,
0.0619387254,
1.626490666e-34,
0.0450925007,
0.0080944011,
0.0004107093,
-0.014685397,
0.0248669554,
0.0061248806,
0.0112370728,
-0.0035455602,
0.0672456548,
-0.030907575,
0.0017493074
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.02762v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.02762v2 | PRD: Peer Rank and Discussion Improve Large Language Model based Evaluations | 2023-07-06T04:05:44 | 2024-07-03T04:34:03 | Ruosen Li, Teerth Patel, Xinya Du | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Nowadays, the quality of responses generated by different modern large
language models (LLMs) is hard to evaluate and compare automatically. Recent
studies suggest and predominantly use LLMs for reference-free evaluation of
open-ended question answering. More specifically, they use the recognized
"strongest" LLM as the evaluator, which conducts pairwise comparisons of
candidate models' answers and provides a ranking score. However, this intuitive
method has multiple problems, such as bringing in self-enhancement (favoring
its own answers) and positional bias. We draw insights and lessons from the
educational domain (Cho & MacArthur, 2011; Walsh, 2014) to improve LLM-based
evaluations. Specifically, we propose (1) the peer rank (PR) algorithm that
takes into account each peer LLM's pairwise preferences of all answer pairs,
and outputs a final ranking of models; and (2) peer discussion (PD), where we
prompt two LLMs to discuss and try to reach a mutual agreement on the
preferences of two answers. We conduct experiments on two benchmark datasets.
We find that our approaches achieve higher accuracy and align better with human
judgments. Interestingly, PR can induce a relatively accurate self-ranking of
models under the anonymous setting, where each model's name is unrevealed. Our
work provides space to explore evaluating models that are hard to compare for
humans. | [
0.055227235,
0.0734937564,
0.0096482839,
0.0573096238,
-0.0321695358,
-0.0095432997,
0.015977012,
-0.0347842686,
0.0106056239,
-0.0588366501,
-0.0497864261,
-0.0289733037,
-0.0085791443,
-0.0374307334,
0.0060920808,
-0.0272074081,
0.0056232191,
-0.0547285154,
0.0555714779,
-0.0606185831,
-0.019726811,
-0.0189816616,
0.0032037946,
0.0050009633,
0.0762362033,
-0.0222799666,
0.013267817,
-0.0343015008,
0.0051092859,
-0.0071973945,
0.0108214132,
0.0877462924,
-0.0139738545,
0.0270884149,
0.000002011,
-0.0506925508,
0.0011571218,
-0.0141129224,
-0.0120813465,
0.06286107,
0.008896892,
0.086688377,
0.0168801155,
0.0035537335,
-0.0645362288,
0.0069254809,
0.013287059,
-0.0216626283,
0.083095789,
0.0030599816,
0.0356617756,
-0.0220409669,
-0.008924407,
-0.0291654523,
-0.0003314952,
-0.0480508804,
0.0365441702,
0.0435251482,
-0.0035124698,
0.054847762,
-0.020538114,
0.0332917459,
0.0105357245,
-0.0331375375,
0.0732030571,
0.02981182,
-0.0395064391,
-0.0065254387,
0.010827058,
0.0904714465,
0.0221459158,
-0.0275839008,
-0.0038616497,
-0.0027578399,
0.0219883434,
0.0674307719,
-0.0672532916,
0.0337760672,
0.0267205779,
0.0085931737,
0.0052766595,
0.0290037263,
0.0224726684,
0.0424828418,
0.0109435171,
0.1023601145,
0.0085785221,
-0.0330305658,
0.0052800393,
0.018889552,
-0.0327129848,
-0.0535060279,
-0.0084226597,
0.0240557157,
-0.0246331282,
0.0235991143,
0.02676511,
0.0012376111,
0.0396299139,
-0.0600011609,
0.0497986451,
-0.0188615732,
0.0249065347,
0.0530901514,
-0.0260140803,
0.034343943,
0.0107104164,
0.0361273997,
-0.0551830381,
0.0056682867,
-0.0288940556,
-0.0170318261,
-0.0021185686,
0.0388376713,
-0.0071753776,
-0.0000808395,
-0.0348032117,
0.0085733756,
-0.0401434228,
-0.0056932787,
0.0379400067,
0.0617004782,
0.0268632956,
0.0082134707,
-0.0556692481,
0.0352228694,
-0.0350768939,
0.0117528327,
-0.0113130845,
-0.0450734496,
-0.0001209506,
0.0020563961,
-0.0140903993,
-0.0159554034,
0.0203594677,
0.0631901771,
-0.0072024418,
-0.0044123656,
0.0594973676,
-0.004560424,
0.0043282825,
-0.0513037108,
-0.0111796111,
-0.0993824601,
0.0310470294,
0.0303981379,
-0.00099648,
-0.0223392081,
0.0312630646,
0.0085306717,
-0.015149584,
0.032116279,
-0.0076422645,
0.034699861,
0.0472789966,
0.0295216795,
-0.0239356272,
0.0429894887,
0.0210732408,
0.0013673308,
0.0602658242,
-0.0197109524,
0.020513529,
0.016931355,
0.0219370611,
-0.0023283181,
0.0191842262,
0.0601522923,
-0.0014435665,
0.0326574296,
-0.0202500727,
0.0294452813,
-0.0074660187,
-0.0442434736,
0.0698674247,
0.0621081144,
-0.0100630661,
0.0103911636,
-0.0166740511,
0.0047315997,
0.023787953,
0.0249314737,
-0.0041518221,
0.0258235838,
-0.0222445168,
-0.0189520717,
0.0499839708,
0.0134456344,
-0.003913118,
-0.0578778349,
-0.0118784225,
0.0150345052,
-0.0098110875,
0.0529242121,
0.0335875787,
-0.0101557616,
0.0108071798,
0.0526871495,
0.0209853631,
-0.0592918247,
0.0166209508,
-0.0496603064,
0.054774221,
0.0462024026,
0.0412257165,
-0.0026520251,
-0.0277402885,
0.0070602493,
-0.0025349993,
0.0269955117,
0.032623779,
-0.0298010521,
0.009084668,
-0.0211084876,
-0.023364231,
0.0037409312,
-0.0023085268,
0.0174790397,
0.0268638581,
-0.0303567313,
0.0041820505,
-0.0582683682,
-0.0376483724,
-0.0009950985,
-0.0213704221,
-0.0180346165,
0.0096538784,
-0.0206140988,
0.0326093622,
0.0069381087,
-0.0102224611,
0.0331551842,
0.0396536328,
-0.0106359199,
-0.0466182046,
-0.0190061554,
-0.04006318,
0.0064935703,
0.034361288,
-0.058573816,
-0.0113556106,
0.056599468,
-0.0197419543,
-0.0301468465,
0.0187208075,
-0.0177676845,
0.0096401358,
-0.0208167639,
0.0118036782,
-0.0188369658,
-0.0379029103,
-0.0734188408,
0.0775690302,
0.0147933858,
0.0665960684,
0.0465399846,
0.0075792242,
0.0160107296,
-0.037046697,
-0.0435837843,
0.0214540921,
0.0117485616,
0.0089848032,
0.0501361825,
-0.0215529762,
-0.0682402104,
-0.0361145511,
-0.0885408223,
-0.0090976562,
0.0041693528,
0.0296041649,
0.0193666425,
-0.0370421335,
0.0094253272,
-0.0014866708,
-0.0754661262,
-0.0222436786,
0.0228987597,
0.0177180562,
0.0234759971,
0.0192215201,
0.0026401426,
-0.0456259884,
-0.0236763246,
0.0044797789,
0.0650423616,
0.0357866287,
0.0492908061,
-0.042204231,
0.0097887851,
-0.0872204453,
0.0167989433,
0.00092818,
-0.0395793095,
0.0178626608,
-0.001978908,
-0.0136901401,
0.070893392,
0.0278502647,
-0.0228079632,
0.0813999921,
-0.0039314767,
-0.086732015,
-0.0364673845,
-0.0054430347,
-0.0223893393,
-0.0159475487,
-0.0505200401,
-0.0084792757,
0.0565389916,
0.019841807,
-0.0306620635,
-0.0258473158,
0.0625548661,
-0.0323241912,
-0.0158329159,
-0.0668447316,
-0.0270051174,
0.0020198782,
0.025034735,
-0.0128010735,
-0.0437403694,
0.0801761076,
-0.0401839092,
-0.0065502035,
-0.0168246236,
0.000849826,
-0.0637663826,
0.0327493325,
0.001787151,
0.0100959158,
-0.0326943956,
0.0009041028,
-0.0408422798,
-0.011452104,
0.0618035048,
-0.0580487736,
0.0125633217,
-0.0523307249,
-0.0013489684,
-0.0145307416,
-0.0259270333,
-0.0291113146,
-0.0778509974,
-0.0224957187,
0.0242281538,
0.0024624723,
-0.0071845343,
0.0246943682,
-0.0085311197,
0.013526517,
-0.0382070392,
-0.0373496003,
0.0007716699,
0.0018281679,
0.0663817599,
0.0536785163,
0.0053667729,
0.0293434262,
-0.0156705361,
0.0337329954,
0.0764166415,
0.0496896543,
0.0233568419,
-0.0124498289,
-0.0294205397,
0.0414133035,
-0.022369083,
-0.0225715805,
-0.006641204,
0.0276217312,
-0.0259082038,
0.0035229183,
0.110063687,
0.0272193905,
-0.0444318838,
-0.01371112,
-0.0334915742,
0.0233215038,
0.0101155862,
0.0082006017,
-0.0455509946,
0.0021840516,
-0.0290203765,
0.0397884361,
-0.0141326161,
-0.0304736383,
0.0153044583,
-0.1321914196,
0.00104141,
0.000867247,
-0.0126845809,
0.0469910875,
-0.0691712871,
0.0165851191,
-0.0204308089,
-0.0241338406,
0.0248999614,
-0.0095664412,
0.0272661485,
0.0156538635,
-0.0145443445,
-0.0230216868,
0.0609138049,
-0.0244465172,
0.0630436614,
0.03112006,
0.0146664381,
-0.0400936082,
-0.0618170314,
0.0308300313,
-0.0435928516,
-0.0153187104,
0.000242327,
0.0085468795,
-0.0172683243,
0.0073623266,
-0.0505951867,
0.0093438718,
0.0030010697,
0.0060859779,
0.0294790287,
0.0689771101,
0.0100074382,
-0.0025294407,
-0.0165996123,
0.0227916781,
-0.0273475442,
0.0855682418,
0.0253975186,
-0.0462508015,
0.0030246016,
-0.0322415195,
-0.0040942156,
-0.0023685421,
-0.0722209662,
0.0262297392,
0.0416731238,
0.002222091,
-0.0619652905,
-0.01808309,
0.0213468969,
-0.0170391314,
-0.0021502681,
0.0502142236,
-0.0310118031,
0.0305684358,
0.0049276319,
0.0401722863,
-0.0453276299,
0.0022388808,
-0.0497739539,
-0.0077566537,
0.0371321402,
-0.0133914584,
-0.0267411508,
0.0127631677,
-0.0503678918,
-0.0634719729,
-0.0139123807,
0.057811711,
0.0205578879,
-0.0130256005,
0.000929093,
-0.0729858056,
0.0203840248,
-0.0023258296,
0.0016124548,
0.0149400951,
0.0207077898,
0.0004619646,
0.0001847195,
0.0207741503,
-0.0434078611,
0.0083142379,
0.032493867,
0.0164021142,
-0.0277386755,
-0.088916488,
0.0127057293,
0.0371592678,
0.0317047536,
0.0073358626,
-0.0034799757,
0.0021043683,
0.0235005412,
-0.046610821,
-0.0320259333,
-0.0125524718,
-0.0105532818,
0.016166646,
-0.0415067039,
0.0314443,
-0.0080924155,
-0.0124695832,
0.0463523045,
-0.0600936525,
0.0493941829,
0.0261632279,
-0.0345879272,
-0.0097532813,
0.0007043815,
-0.0335242487,
-0.0422336981,
0.0055912794,
0.0624978431,
0.0133526288,
0.0329128839,
-0.0044866498,
-0.0331771746,
0.0254568141,
0.0358420685,
-0.1037572548,
-0.0765290335,
-0.0315179937,
0.0443788022,
0.0297886468,
0.0401994735,
0.056271378,
0.0199341066,
-0.0002808212,
-0.0088685239,
-0.0207724459,
0.0062899925,
-0.0384535529,
0.036622718,
0.026003506,
0.00557415,
0.0429863259,
0.0725216866,
0.0285410937,
-0.0102691855,
0.0060991971,
-0.0179919302,
-0.0270311888,
-0.0258953813,
-0.0296912212,
0.0108261909,
-0.0111699766,
-0.0015563132,
-0.042099867,
-0.0310534276,
-0.0307799447,
0.05506007,
0.0002821983,
-0.0354086272,
0.0275622085,
0.0683752149,
-0.0104412055,
-0.0174911804,
-0.0640215129,
0.0455873199,
-0.0393540673,
0.0035976002,
-0.0476731919,
-6.459678678e-33,
-0.0285827946,
-0.0675225109,
-0.0182782002,
-0.0320606381,
-0.0115979249,
0.002383464,
-0.0098710125,
0.0484151356,
-0.0321972109,
-0.002103532,
-0.016673211,
-0.0116789257,
0.0032848807,
0.0158162266,
0.0410762057,
-0.0408470258,
0.0045658587,
-0.0034700581,
-0.0447092988,
0.0041238554,
0.0033852076,
-0.0239982996,
0.0378472991,
-0.0406732708,
0.0715867877,
-0.0327449068,
-0.0053676558,
0.0338903107,
-0.0687054843,
0.0606284067,
-0.0011611743,
0.0372897498,
0.0214366373,
-0.0430516824,
-0.0032335178,
0.0168055035,
-0.0370564014,
-0.02609534,
0.0486179329,
-0.0347439572,
-0.0518499799,
-0.0191157069,
0.046965301,
0.0191176552,
-0.0445856042,
-0.0160153899,
0.0433487967,
-0.0309516285,
0.0002664673,
0.0229260661,
0.0260461755,
0.0134796025,
-0.0194797814,
-0.0276964288,
0.0103256349,
0.0688509494,
-0.0147129493,
0.0207721759,
-0.0178855322,
0.0467989445,
0.0290599354,
0.0569738746,
0.0754995346,
-0.0143440692,
0.0094377678,
0.0509209372,
0.0128465211,
0.0060820519,
-0.0071465927,
-0.0919300094,
-0.025324937,
0.0452467352,
0.1088698432,
0.0492854118,
-0.0156382658,
0.0351668671,
-0.0627582148,
0.0421409458,
0.0336466469,
-0.0177225452,
0.0380735286,
0.0041411384,
-0.0244902596,
-0.032605309,
-0.0870585665,
-0.0457380302,
-0.0453243591,
-0.0294058397,
0.0197128747,
-0.0117629645,
-0.0586410947,
-0.0383724906,
0.0157920159,
-0.0571908504,
-0.0544757955,
0.0378967747,
0.0066012223,
0.0277254228,
0.0043403613,
0.0032141719,
-0.0413230546,
0.0499180704,
-0.0114051411,
0.0165374018,
0.0007212668,
0.015810959,
-0.0299970489,
-0.0388993882,
-0.0358692519,
0.0008355484,
-0.0449296497,
-0.0273175258,
-0.0189206898,
-0.0153651973,
0.0132893417,
-0.006370218,
-0.0179536492,
0.0563925169,
-0.0038422723,
0.0330795236,
-0.0344013087,
0.0175606776,
-0.019127341,
-0.0107762488,
-0.0163074974,
0.013655887,
-0.0216718763,
0.0489381254,
0.0048109712,
0.0116203502,
-0.0174567271,
-0.0172272287,
2.552e-7,
0.042897176,
0.0454995446,
0.0000144371,
-0.0000814934,
0.0261582341,
0.0393565744,
-0.0124922516,
0.0084491801,
0.0688591227,
-0.0312730037,
-0.0180643685,
0.0145903211,
0.040161442,
0.0617779866,
-0.0597414151,
-0.0325498506,
-0.1095242277,
0.0020429844,
-0.0088784965,
-0.0253080036,
0.0547219031,
0.0292682704,
0.003667857,
0.0208404921,
-0.0673394576,
-0.019592423,
0.0597698204,
-0.0609653778,
-0.0372399054,
0.029952405,
0.0257673617,
-0.0341193713,
0.0205065683,
0.020724358,
0.0114010219,
-0.0048824311,
0.0283763856,
0.0619562902,
0.0144335525,
-0.0374822281,
-0.0194453578,
-0.0036108971,
0.0331572033,
-0.0868322253,
0.0857913569,
-0.0423704833,
-0.0330662802,
-0.0232049339,
-0.0259281788,
-0.018075861,
0.0436136238,
-0.0315345004,
-0.025899021,
0.0115322825,
-0.0071747438,
-0.0073633846,
-0.0033333229,
-0.0219221823,
-0.0613680258,
-0.0356539153,
-0.0443471931,
-0.0800961778,
-0.0044798232,
-0.0143398419,
-0.0290994383,
-0.0390688404,
0.0195235666,
1.905044257e-34,
0.0225800946,
0.0211514086,
0.0237077978,
0.0125536118,
0.0326886661,
0.0062501673,
0.0000901281,
-0.0058822813,
0.0348653682,
-0.0798074603,
-0.0065190843
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.02758v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.02758v2 | Exploring Linguistic Style Matching in Online Communities: The Role of Social Context and Conversation Dynamics | 2023-07-06T03:43:45 | 2023-08-26T16:56:27 | Aparna Ananthasubramaniam, Hong Chen, Jason Yan, Kenan Alkiek, Jiaxin Pei, Agrima Seth, Lavinia Dunagan, Minje Choi, Benjamin Litterer, David Jurgens | cs.CL | cs.CL | Linguistic style matching (LSM) in conversations can be reflective of several
aspects of social influence such as power or persuasion. However, how LSM
relates to the outcomes of online communication on platforms such as Reddit is
an unknown question. In this study, we analyze a large corpus of two-party
conversation threads in Reddit where we identify all occurrences of LSM using
two types of style: the use of function words and formality. Using this
framework, we examine how levels of LSM differ in conversations depending on
several social factors within Reddit: post and subreddit features, conversation
depth, user tenure, and the controversiality of a comment. Finally, we measure
the change of LSM following loss of status after community banning. Our
findings reveal the interplay of LSM in Reddit conversations with several
community metrics, suggesting the importance of understanding conversation
engagement when understanding community dynamics. | [
0.0863668546,
0.0691591874,
-0.0460740812,
0.0247201249,
-0.0322087668,
-0.0259205271,
-0.0087951804,
0.0340201072,
-0.0089221075,
-0.0331606008,
-0.0258268639,
-0.0256485678,
0.0505449399,
0.0067783864,
0.0202806164,
-0.038305603,
-0.0232122652,
0.0425134338,
0.0286051817,
-0.020111043,
0.1059498191,
0.0398166589,
0.002121201,
0.0539044514,
0.0131049287,
0.0071892058,
0.0379458591,
0.0260278415,
0.0178442989,
0.0172107928,
0.046321623,
0.0782891363,
-0.0371799842,
0.0420514569,
0.0000017551,
-0.0516378954,
0.0332655832,
-0.0457983837,
0.0355221666,
0.0109200226,
0.0722523034,
0.0293845721,
0.001332482,
0.0307864156,
-0.0451030955,
0.0040394729,
0.0515838228,
0.0044053616,
0.0425668992,
0.0246685613,
-0.0229620915,
-0.0533616692,
-0.0221347474,
-0.0065815514,
-0.04320205,
-0.01965883,
0.0223405454,
-0.0186331384,
-0.0264450181,
0.0093870917,
0.0359986462,
-0.0003688233,
-0.0468305498,
-0.0624724254,
0.0002733348,
-0.0137002869,
-0.0047092815,
-0.0338440165,
0.0447136499,
0.0705959126,
0.0515572093,
-0.0372308753,
0.0405506082,
0.0383060314,
-0.0140741421,
0.0680000931,
-0.0835118517,
-0.0086066313,
-0.0148857124,
0.0039640567,
-0.0154829267,
0.0041809902,
0.0169826541,
0.0135868723,
0.0310839768,
0.0222040061,
0.004304166,
-0.0000144283,
-0.0508664437,
-0.0114215864,
-0.0058835768,
-0.0764340982,
0.0312539302,
-0.0321481787,
-0.006960873,
0.0261076428,
-0.0029502255,
-0.0033386024,
0.0609895997,
-0.0801930651,
-0.0352765173,
-0.0096915737,
0.0418876074,
0.0472987145,
-0.0034498195,
-0.0488842875,
-0.0101985503,
0.000516782,
0.0425930955,
-0.0225134864,
-0.0597612001,
-0.0056638033,
-0.0072801774,
-0.0373100266,
0.0350166671,
0.0092355208,
0.0109538138,
-0.0129404543,
-0.04149919,
-0.0282435846,
-0.0191236343,
-0.0260606036,
-0.0070809149,
-0.0068329866,
-0.0036995022,
0.0180481542,
-0.0543713048,
0.0189492144,
-0.0115490286,
-0.021057969,
0.0297597516,
0.0018638388,
0.0377416536,
-0.0175084062,
-0.0343735181,
0.0183257554,
0.0122911679,
0.0250304323,
0.0051113921,
-0.0382079594,
0.0096139191,
0.0160777625,
-0.025672093,
-0.0737086311,
0.0286938213,
0.0372916386,
-0.0026161228,
-0.0169959534,
0.0114441272,
0.0380939059,
-0.0321434177,
0.0297586601,
-0.0260620471,
0.0243931506,
0.0653388649,
0.0455711074,
0.0052301884,
0.0207855776,
-0.0172539856,
-0.0324338637,
0.0319119319,
-0.0165651627,
0.0011153691,
0.0489283167,
-0.0165321957,
-0.0043702158,
-0.0192761626,
0.011269086,
0.027713472,
-0.0191826187,
0.0223759618,
0.0376465507,
-0.0398627445,
-0.0318336859,
0.0617948584,
0.0518622734,
-0.0237169806,
0.0437396578,
-0.0279504079,
0.0077106771,
-0.018102603,
-0.0042157564,
0.0369676575,
-0.0377158262,
-0.020060556,
-0.0549436398,
0.0293362029,
0.0114739621,
-0.0059997723,
0.0064785723,
-0.006357417,
0.0220814124,
0.0381969884,
-0.0485713631,
-0.0323303826,
0.0173315592,
0.0144245643,
0.0272528622,
0.0332293734,
-0.0164076723,
-0.0424652174,
-0.0218513627,
0.002267452,
0.0439794511,
0.0162212234,
0.0223327894,
0.0308660381,
-0.0249726791,
0.0836440325,
0.0685782135,
0.0371246934,
0.0220955219,
-0.0520509854,
-0.0307788439,
0.0179604683,
0.0307867099,
-0.0091347611,
0.0103032114,
-0.0036093295,
-0.001725656,
-0.0471128523,
0.0253991913,
-0.0271242522,
-0.0255236514,
0.0323825851,
0.0154488264,
-0.0554188825,
0.0071985656,
0.0285703465,
-0.0189983901,
-0.0088815484,
-0.0297770184,
-0.0453365371,
0.0027978788,
-0.0564269274,
0.0333497897,
-0.033185441,
0.0428847671,
0.0154884309,
-0.0305165648,
-0.0270386897,
0.0047364943,
0.035781242,
0.0044090962,
0.1026608273,
-0.0294934288,
0.0784543976,
0.0128777931,
-0.0315207131,
-0.0409540981,
0.0111870449,
-0.0493460633,
0.0092511345,
0.0015563836,
-0.003815253,
0.0064119715,
-0.0552299581,
-0.0053884066,
0.0393219367,
-0.0176344141,
-0.0197011512,
-0.0042503914,
0.0131678479,
0.0698608235,
-0.0393730886,
-0.0463914275,
-0.0293019339,
-0.0724931657,
-0.0318343006,
-0.0218447838,
0.0115073109,
0.0610415637,
0.0084047886,
0.0064277267,
0.0188907813,
-0.0374426171,
-0.0340985134,
-0.0316019133,
0.027538266,
0.0663299635,
-0.0091068158,
-0.0477577299,
-0.0606154948,
-0.025505146,
-0.0246143993,
0.0507969707,
0.0335012078,
-0.0688729808,
0.0213189553,
0.0397373289,
-0.0613024496,
-0.0137890428,
-0.045427151,
-0.0562914275,
0.0351011865,
0.0231841542,
0.0639538318,
0.0356175117,
0.0771849081,
0.0320878327,
-0.0278060343,
0.0350711308,
-0.053960029,
-0.0540566146,
-0.019212231,
0.0020057608,
-0.0460830182,
-0.0470861048,
0.0154083315,
0.0145786153,
0.0254287254,
0.0270976238,
-0.0208315011,
0.0398129895,
-0.0045539285,
0.002105928,
0.0144423302,
-0.0519837886,
-0.0068209628,
0.0377997085,
-0.0206985977,
-0.0213161446,
-0.0120311277,
0.0035490219,
0.0121744946,
0.0358303785,
-0.037848372,
-0.0170565173,
0.048172947,
0.009342975,
0.0247006789,
-0.0043195593,
-0.0594075583,
0.002192758,
-0.0519230105,
0.1076897606,
-0.0367119648,
-0.0164464116,
0.0058149579,
0.0362074822,
0.0417273268,
-0.0263151005,
0.0101638185,
-0.0740965679,
-0.0356125124,
-0.0121437795,
0.0614702925,
-0.0402990691,
0.0273931175,
0.0140455877,
-0.0136726201,
-0.0220064186,
0.0173768252,
-0.023354562,
-0.0032994396,
0.0108465012,
0.0004796051,
0.0296018235,
0.009728766,
0.000296356,
-0.0074254661,
0.0500147715,
-0.010998534,
-0.0400361568,
-0.0057686334,
-0.0797189698,
0.0280558597,
-0.018421473,
-0.0190154873,
-0.0087078754,
0.0460792072,
-0.0251935236,
0.0065436345,
0.0529418811,
0.0260481536,
-0.0182736944,
-0.0183233712,
-0.0545208864,
0.0512569174,
0.0406094566,
0.0052992157,
-0.11299631,
0.0017632929,
-0.0069350074,
-0.0090458551,
-0.0420248769,
-0.0290065557,
0.0014528694,
-0.0731171519,
-0.0310243685,
-0.0025169062,
-0.0080696288,
0.0390332751,
-0.024837967,
0.0272354018,
0.0152333789,
-0.0308823287,
-0.0015544358,
0.0001865024,
-0.0093266377,
0.0285078976,
-0.1249426827,
-0.0020133534,
-0.0127743194,
-0.0403390527,
0.0533143841,
0.0071270955,
0.0667869747,
0.0032134177,
-0.0200887062,
0.0839448422,
0.029464826,
-0.0312975198,
-0.0150212264,
0.0347182564,
-0.0083727194,
0.0027891225,
-0.0767154321,
0.030080149,
0.0106706955,
-0.0003593547,
-0.0032941042,
-0.0015615503,
0.0106907329,
-0.0516018458,
-0.0111583797,
0.0210239012,
0.0514865927,
0.0201160721,
0.0751447007,
-0.0173054449,
-0.0112786256,
-0.0546997227,
0.0198995639,
-0.0013284459,
-0.0848574266,
-0.0929112583,
0.0501980558,
-0.0106923264,
-0.0794862881,
0.024068905,
-0.0472099856,
0.0017825851,
0.0329681933,
-0.0015234038,
0.0161120612,
-0.0122498302,
-0.0031585593,
-0.0124717578,
-0.0343322419,
0.0086025698,
-0.0085000545,
-0.0209829677,
-0.0107179442,
0.0178397764,
-0.0257108789,
0.0209704544,
-0.0223961323,
-0.0411980934,
0.0172311496,
-0.0141095184,
0.0246318392,
0.0091654472,
-0.0157623682,
-0.0706367865,
-0.0183491688,
0.0376341566,
0.0276159551,
0.0102260849,
0.0449475534,
0.0052882298,
0.0147103779,
0.0341749452,
0.0186046455,
0.0038252424,
-0.0093534337,
-0.0133368969,
-0.0726702809,
-0.0327519812,
-0.0095128724,
0.0032149062,
-0.0033894845,
0.0313033946,
0.0104612438,
-0.0208610184,
-0.0530430824,
-0.032907024,
0.0119516598,
0.0176731683,
-0.0355098806,
-0.0080145653,
0.0063544731,
-0.0121134445,
0.0100880368,
-0.0427061804,
0.054824423,
-0.0277353395,
0.0109495586,
0.004478679,
0.0430286191,
0.0149627142,
-0.009696817,
0.0095118554,
0.0506500974,
0.0244316012,
0.0455068983,
-0.0042054821,
0.0269199777,
0.0127881514,
-0.0286689457,
0.0251483843,
0.013303089,
-0.0538714156,
-0.0711065978,
0.0424943194,
0.0021854264,
0.0136809349,
-0.0347646326,
0.0618118793,
0.0152477287,
0.0000085769,
0.0011524104,
0.0533876978,
-0.0024266227,
-0.0533069298,
0.0035207369,
0.004592821,
-0.0468091108,
0.0215790644,
0.0431859791,
-0.0526164435,
-0.003368591,
-0.0133950943,
-0.0370489247,
0.0182022043,
-0.017955428,
0.0138641102,
0.0332577489,
0.0165955275,
-0.0343285501,
-0.0429044813,
-0.026372496,
0.0028133625,
-0.0136346035,
0.0399762951,
-0.0099105565,
0.0033566058,
0.0380648412,
0.0336731635,
0.0286408961,
-0.0395829119,
0.0331083201,
-0.0187512431,
-0.0131054204,
-0.0282596145,
-5.991078508e-33,
0.0385544784,
-0.068718724,
-0.0424728543,
0.0710056871,
-0.0236512087,
-0.0169819277,
-0.0239754375,
0.0306451414,
-0.0038667787,
0.0239587352,
-0.0170384757,
0.0304097496,
0.0065507777,
-0.0247640852,
0.0296861269,
-0.0305648763,
0.0345434882,
0.0152060911,
0.0012622804,
0.005373498,
0.0634792671,
-0.0205587335,
-0.0006733503,
-0.0572393909,
0.0372403599,
-0.0033100203,
0.010085295,
0.0048128646,
0.0615706481,
0.0022300093,
0.0023161815,
0.0317345634,
0.0094309896,
-0.0307106618,
-0.0089628799,
0.0906181559,
-0.0139252907,
-0.0152447931,
0.0547078252,
-0.0178088639,
0.0039242953,
-0.000757051,
0.0659956411,
-0.0064423331,
-0.0197243467,
0.0027408041,
0.0535001978,
0.0342120379,
0.0401339419,
-0.0185660981,
-0.0240546558,
0.0308909863,
-0.0447566099,
0.0082589621,
-0.0533425957,
0.0099224579,
0.0342582874,
0.0218490306,
-0.052887477,
0.0068258033,
-0.1057292521,
0.0471240133,
0.0067743924,
0.0297769476,
0.0269075464,
0.0904587731,
-0.0274604186,
0.1282650232,
-0.0281121321,
0.0017434049,
0.0136112254,
0.0320139676,
0.0379369855,
0.0739524737,
-0.0093436511,
-0.0716978535,
-0.0536966138,
-0.026244808,
0.0818354413,
-0.0001220775,
0.0154277124,
0.0137613807,
-0.051009208,
-0.0215165857,
-0.0116194254,
-0.0254175756,
-0.0242649559,
-0.015887145,
-0.0410465561,
-0.038725771,
-0.0155972354,
-0.0152401468,
0.0164705347,
-0.0422627144,
-0.0749182925,
-0.0030496679,
-0.0370434932,
0.012766229,
0.0229664464,
0.0038542254,
0.0110589163,
0.0033607702,
-0.0208630394,
0.0254193675,
0.0519607812,
-0.0087469947,
0.0292850155,
-0.0166958589,
-0.0533117019,
-0.0413357317,
-0.0184968486,
0.0021466762,
-0.072567746,
-0.0079567721,
0.0406401046,
0.0675574914,
0.0077193608,
-0.0052997507,
0.0417215452,
0.0516504832,
-0.0371859632,
-0.0162918605,
-0.0354053676,
-0.0150154931,
-0.0501639098,
-0.0365798324,
-0.0230568312,
0.0154437851,
0.0184885245,
-0.0038283099,
-0.0180065129,
-0.0831950083,
2.534e-7,
0.0291965399,
0.0729734525,
0.0091673061,
0.0014895971,
0.0643624961,
0.0104122423,
0.0623245202,
0.0456614271,
0.016435096,
-0.0559446886,
-0.0235810261,
0.0054437811,
0.0451194346,
0.0128539242,
-0.0806215629,
-0.0569798127,
-0.11832349,
-0.0019980324,
-0.0361504704,
-0.0207619835,
0.0170742571,
-0.0092880391,
0.0399785414,
0.0093853604,
-0.0335798115,
0.001490159,
0.0463386513,
-0.0507077985,
-0.0073628053,
0.0308845043,
0.0217485428,
-0.0488653369,
0.0321886577,
0.0018332497,
0.001540954,
0.0016418895,
0.0296515692,
0.0338725075,
0.034479361,
0.0096191978,
-0.0036004477,
-0.020180067,
0.0089859478,
-0.0324716792,
0.0270861164,
-0.021543907,
-0.0319240503,
-0.0980182886,
-0.0475019068,
-0.0647473112,
0.0520108826,
0.0156350508,
-0.0511895455,
0.0249108039,
-0.0207097027,
-0.0038795867,
0.0016866669,
-0.0691611022,
-0.017331183,
-0.0087903347,
-0.03900823,
-0.0266163368,
-0.0141489068,
-0.0032127211,
0.0124925943,
0.0797167942,
0.0596806034,
1.601415788e-34,
0.0146562764,
-0.0079099126,
0.0163023025,
-0.0113424044,
0.0743367076,
0.0301264841,
-0.0219068788,
0.0342316814,
0.0501530841,
-0.0336674191,
0.0094613126
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.02740v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.02740v1 | Dense Retrieval Adaptation using Target Domain Description | 2023-07-06T02:59:47 | 2023-07-06T02:59:47 | Helia Hashemi, Yong Zhuang, Sachith Sri Ram Kothur, Srivas Prasad, Edgar Meij, W. Bruce Croft | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | In information retrieval (IR), domain adaptation is the process of adapting a
retrieval model to a new domain whose data distribution is different from the
source domain. Existing methods in this area focus on unsupervised domain
adaptation where they have access to the target document collection or
supervised (often few-shot) domain adaptation where they additionally have
access to (limited) labeled data in the target domain. There also exists
research on improving zero-shot performance of retrieval models with no
adaptation. This paper introduces a new category of domain adaptation in IR
that is as-yet unexplored. Here, similar to the zero-shot setting, we assume
the retrieval model does not have access to the target document collection. In
contrast, it does have access to a brief textual description that explains the
target domain. We define a taxonomy of domain attributes in retrieval tasks to
understand different properties of a source domain that can be adapted to a
target domain. We introduce a novel automatic data construction pipeline that
produces a synthetic document collection, query set, and pseudo relevance
labels, given a textual domain description. Extensive experiments on five
diverse target domains show that adapting dense retrieval models using the
constructed synthetic data leads to effective retrieval performance on the
target domain. | [
0.0386697017,
-0.008266326,
-0.0199065227,
-0.0363497995,
0.0045802598,
0.0086291619,
0.0194713678,
0.0301191229,
-0.0156642515,
-0.0588707924,
-0.0701011047,
-0.0188670978,
-0.0550500117,
0.0533751585,
-0.0211199634,
-0.0385019369,
0.0430210792,
0.0288217627,
-0.0041834083,
0.0323350206,
-0.0309236627,
0.0080325902,
0.017495716,
-0.0258790683,
0.0439330228,
0.030913109,
-0.0166380852,
0.0536785647,
-0.020047795,
-0.0040122285,
0.0138992202,
0.0278756116,
0.045336321,
0.0005345117,
0.0000017064,
-0.0563657321,
-0.0505702309,
-0.0112829115,
-0.0285372082,
-0.0365221165,
0.0859299675,
-0.0164485667,
0.047766,
-0.0037779061,
-0.0094879391,
-0.0688168108,
0.0321104005,
0.0268348213,
-0.0013633005,
0.0804390013,
-0.037074063,
-0.0067697051,
-0.0213450938,
-0.0210172422,
0.0347940512,
-0.0651049539,
0.0459556431,
-0.0116951559,
0.0286816154,
0.0366872512,
-0.0027945887,
-0.0100915926,
-0.0403375886,
-0.000284924,
0.0585045218,
-0.0183711387,
-0.0576912202,
0.0088897049,
0.0368448049,
0.0122605916,
0.0073974766,
-0.0483359583,
0.0035654826,
0.0098998975,
0.0262780041,
0.037847586,
-0.039602153,
-0.0691589117,
-0.0075921048,
-0.0462873988,
-0.0527352579,
0.0272190273,
-0.0025827796,
0.0032459698,
-0.0262244493,
0.0154170142,
-0.0124400109,
-0.0198664628,
-0.0158264302,
0.0332961604,
-0.0242437404,
-0.0014505591,
-0.0153992018,
0.0129307341,
0.0009927928,
0.0048025539,
-0.0499566682,
-0.0414001532,
0.0244439598,
-0.005990163,
0.0432313532,
0.0078173559,
-0.0341668539,
0.0641730428,
-0.0233197398,
0.0099603012,
-0.0134049691,
-0.0276058372,
-0.0705263168,
-0.0142539022,
-0.0950841755,
0.0117769465,
-0.0383151509,
0.0392867364,
-0.0450142808,
0.0222726949,
0.0064491904,
0.0590924062,
0.0246334281,
-0.0651531965,
-0.0116260285,
-0.0002312942,
-0.0995597616,
-0.0407811888,
-0.0443082266,
0.0422080681,
-0.0091482159,
0.0359764732,
-0.0145006338,
-0.0135655981,
-0.0038594946,
0.0136405788,
0.0498050414,
-0.0402314328,
-0.0061014011,
0.0547683313,
0.0065922444,
-0.0328467302,
-0.0578131601,
-0.0064272606,
0.0489673987,
-0.0021533123,
0.0438487306,
-0.0051229056,
0.0047093341,
-0.0068479492,
-0.0051664012,
-0.0784996301,
-0.0502889529,
-0.0002903388,
-0.0276970156,
0.0605039261,
-0.0103001995,
0.015893884,
0.0661381707,
-0.0217180252,
-0.006269617,
0.0574964918,
-0.0486474223,
-0.0041111284,
0.0317213051,
0.0136087751,
0.0193957966,
-0.0319009013,
0.0260625239,
0.0455945693,
0.0062441989,
0.0585117936,
-0.0275327265,
-0.0084294872,
0.0310012829,
-0.0672369003,
-0.0306313243,
0.0044513582,
-0.0219819322,
0.014049313,
0.0767249092,
-0.0119532822,
0.0284946337,
0.0144475596,
-0.0619082898,
0.0150019927,
-0.0352973193,
0.0318983346,
-0.0359704308,
0.0006057185,
-0.0148701267,
-0.0156690441,
-0.0662873834,
-0.0229287725,
-0.0002272192,
0.0307675581,
-0.0438368395,
-0.004451463,
0.0610488243,
0.0579135269,
0.0139582735,
0.0194479804,
0.0093309814,
0.014685235,
0.0246157926,
-0.0370898843,
-0.0075801634,
0.0146936635,
0.0601445623,
-0.0766867921,
0.0055220863,
0.0023112581,
0.0551466346,
0.0197598226,
0.0327454656,
-0.0336603969,
-0.0251721982,
-0.0208635665,
-0.0840178356,
-0.0194041301,
0.0172388051,
0.0174104646,
0.0218849741,
0.0055647059,
0.0435436815,
-0.1062701046,
0.0080240481,
0.0226662979,
-0.0537150763,
-0.059195675,
0.0521575622,
-0.0043957056,
-0.0140007706,
-0.010578366,
-0.0005124422,
-0.0092436811,
0.0084691672,
0.0377840437,
-0.0341742784,
-0.0409038588,
0.0051595974,
0.0436168537,
-0.0090772072,
-0.0177460965,
0.0751764327,
-0.0123936152,
-0.01061155,
-0.0183824245,
0.0460478887,
0.0218986496,
-0.0200524013,
-0.0105950311,
0.0327852368,
-0.0167351011,
0.0234835036,
-0.064140141,
0.0463102013,
0.0826443359,
-0.0066449959,
0.0066349362,
0.0060174419,
0.0298780333,
-0.0001161459,
0.0243107453,
-0.0035808794,
-0.0269858763,
0.0318066478,
0.0305212177,
-0.0020442265,
-0.0280615091,
0.0303293336,
-0.0265507046,
0.0225145407,
-0.01149181,
0.006654256,
0.0319888517,
0.0365735143,
-0.0228503253,
-0.0054290267,
-0.0180196632,
-0.0143056512,
-0.0263670757,
0.0211297907,
-0.0051556192,
0.017980041,
0.0430419482,
-0.016656464,
-0.0164046213,
0.0161174256,
0.034085881,
-0.0238570962,
-0.0168545023,
-0.0639615357,
0.049559202,
-0.0240428057,
0.0357065983,
0.0190884564,
0.0497902557,
-0.0533614904,
-0.048973877,
-0.0190279521,
0.0353220291,
-0.0069855577,
-0.0032786715,
0.045226559,
0.0253041722,
-0.0667621642,
0.0319820344,
-0.0517669655,
-0.0226515327,
-0.0004994621,
-0.0260098428,
0.0432171635,
-0.0160069931,
-0.0290506706,
-0.0181663614,
-0.0697267205,
0.0390003175,
-0.0081316791,
-0.0115232402,
-0.0467741638,
0.0407509357,
0.0581428781,
0.0599392056,
-0.0130925691,
-0.0202366468,
0.0456262715,
0.0416415371,
0.0421231948,
-0.0693622455,
-0.0119386995,
-0.0458209403,
0.0284205433,
-0.0148626678,
-0.0079839947,
0.0619933866,
0.0326794386,
-0.0258038566,
0.0143824406,
0.0281189159,
-0.006813115,
0.023859458,
-0.0220907517,
0.0433539748,
-0.0034954408,
-0.019559687,
-0.0234044418,
-0.0189939477,
0.0311678313,
-0.0069152522,
-0.0491545312,
-0.0110164089,
-0.1211619079,
0.0270255432,
0.0004641023,
0.0703740492,
-0.00767822,
-0.0517930202,
0.014586661,
0.0250681341,
0.0376596227,
0.0009486919,
-0.0755398422,
0.0396116599,
0.0131768323,
0.0091288472,
-0.0112343514,
-0.0447688848,
-0.0078394087,
0.0221132953,
0.0532569624,
-0.0260422733,
-0.0051570791,
-0.0064921291,
0.0065606614,
0.0263246708,
-0.0629771426,
0.035117086,
0.0330397747,
-0.0567271113,
-0.043786753,
-0.0590343773,
0.0252481606,
0.0450224541,
0.0651058108,
-0.0310101565,
-0.0103448257,
0.0123858582,
0.0589001663,
-0.0082528172,
0.0008722753,
-0.0137722008,
-0.1039867625,
0.0318211578,
-0.0148244277,
-0.0087298928,
-0.0188806448,
-0.069850035,
0.0431064889,
-0.0148263313,
-0.0200961176,
0.0153746624,
-0.0201388411,
-0.0241298396,
0.026002977,
0.049967017,
-0.0641380176,
-0.0338596553,
0.0291226339,
0.0106114242,
0.0424690098,
-0.0068826512,
0.0180043764,
0.0384193882,
0.0079103233,
-0.0435480103,
0.0288451482,
-0.0276242029,
0.094183825,
-0.0068039675,
0.0242592264,
0.0419735722,
-0.0021391488,
-0.0386509486,
-0.0112901032,
0.02262065,
0.033242099,
-0.0408633016,
0.003535117,
-0.0726192668,
-0.0651832148,
-0.0095883198,
0.0179604646,
-0.0115975197,
-0.0031094439,
0.044171229,
0.015144852,
-0.0264239125,
-0.0314706936,
-0.0312434547,
0.0268727578,
-0.0840092897,
-0.0102942409,
-0.0495217852,
-0.010780449,
-0.0108547537,
0.0367324799,
0.0198893137,
0.0025508306,
-0.0470643863,
-0.0141896466,
-0.0641366467,
0.0275390949,
-0.0423377603,
-0.0106053501,
-0.0335725918,
0.0010751148,
0.0709892958,
-0.0591530502,
-0.0210762508,
-0.0335445628,
0.0080293352,
-0.0225935988,
-0.0181126557,
-0.0189313684,
0.0182851348,
0.0636840984,
-0.0339952074,
-0.0647379607,
0.0584922247,
0.0490344837,
-0.0372218117,
0.0027730197,
0.0269291084,
-0.0643064231,
-0.0428581201,
0.0075909626,
-0.0872753337,
0.0637620389,
0.0283803679,
-0.0106520774,
0.0100145973,
-0.0218802653,
0.0379909202,
0.0127395382,
0.0801535547,
0.0209132936,
0.0075653964,
0.0054474613,
0.0055894419,
0.0027487315,
-0.0393036604,
0.0042278874,
-0.018184036,
0.0368509181,
-0.0040109241,
-0.0071366997,
0.0488755181,
-0.0572046041,
0.0847726688,
-0.0676720664,
-0.0133911967,
0.0012203285,
0.0487875938,
-0.0031207784,
-0.0024452973,
-0.0148464404,
0.0174315125,
0.0173173565,
0.056459792,
-0.0465197451,
-0.0023274419,
0.0335302614,
0.0267482512,
-0.0296308305,
-0.0050395955,
-0.0787283853,
0.0324304923,
-0.0582906529,
0.0028083208,
0.0105464477,
-0.046969559,
-0.0173351485,
0.0035805837,
-0.0304113142,
-0.040598236,
-0.0258551184,
0.0564061403,
0.002969797,
0.0086034508,
0.0422972254,
0.0241445359,
0.0213031471,
0.0565921031,
0.0570261963,
0.0584595464,
-0.0624607839,
-0.0122348126,
-0.008784811,
0.0107410271,
0.0242337435,
0.0104617868,
-0.0092603741,
-0.0066556879,
-0.0231605247,
-0.0321185887,
0.0588854551,
-0.0545944758,
0.0147223976,
-0.0308340192,
0.0486837476,
0.0618090779,
0.0018158865,
0.002391224,
-0.023664806,
-0.0009288316,
0.0184499361,
0.0367593989,
-0.0043033687,
-5.839213454e-33,
-0.0126284128,
-0.0003903305,
0.0198663678,
-0.0216986705,
0.0184715223,
-0.0136081111,
0.0126323402,
-0.0260708034,
-0.0115803424,
-0.0314586349,
-0.0172176547,
0.029021658,
0.0186858848,
-0.0166339651,
-0.0222112127,
0.0086678155,
0.0541328788,
-0.0113532813,
-0.0278934371,
0.0184942167,
0.0186020099,
0.0291868523,
0.0130804749,
-0.1065508425,
0.0169346519,
-0.0105189104,
0.0109556718,
0.0108704511,
0.0838327333,
0.069696717,
0.013154164,
0.0788575038,
0.0399504751,
-0.0569714531,
-0.0069118165,
-0.0126008578,
-0.0848308876,
-0.0293546766,
-0.0094247479,
-0.0011093644,
0.0283147302,
-0.0224185102,
-0.0062744208,
0.0163314827,
-0.0101962164,
-0.0247192327,
0.0563079752,
-0.0482735261,
-0.0465147123,
-0.0425609946,
-0.0240436327,
0.025511384,
0.0376914889,
-0.0078901937,
0.0246477406,
0.0761252344,
0.0311262012,
0.0301418398,
-0.01462851,
0.0402375869,
-0.0530059449,
0.0637421981,
0.0266493969,
0.018350739,
-0.0370462388,
0.0189439245,
0.002845359,
0.0350426547,
0.0031179413,
-0.0357841514,
0.0253010597,
-0.0158408955,
-0.0272528604,
0.0850172266,
0.0409509055,
-0.0640334561,
-0.0266829487,
0.0515506007,
-0.0937058926,
0.0136996796,
0.0157298222,
0.0457925275,
-0.0466184393,
-0.0189039446,
-0.0183022488,
0.0322281197,
-0.0644905865,
-0.0035136421,
0.0332390666,
0.0305008851,
-0.0110686477,
0.0247610956,
0.0375140831,
-0.0183112267,
0.0023576173,
0.0326997042,
-0.0138246324,
0.0227537584,
-0.0193250682,
-0.0096298773,
0.0225546397,
-0.0792339593,
0.0635201335,
0.0481355228,
-0.0130826347,
-0.0122531606,
0.0288207065,
-0.0009060836,
-0.0332660787,
-0.0052953935,
0.0242133215,
-0.0149620101,
-0.0120521989,
0.0234310925,
-0.0488317758,
0.0629401729,
0.0002309017,
0.0557684414,
0.0379592031,
-0.0411199853,
-0.0056947898,
0.0311043523,
-0.0083273686,
0.0108411713,
-0.0253904946,
0.0013349778,
0.01514614,
-0.0180765931,
0.0255092159,
-0.0572512522,
-0.0116218552,
0.0194567759,
2.586e-7,
0.0219921358,
0.0261654649,
-0.0075930124,
-0.0187581517,
-0.0052610319,
0.029475281,
-0.0269729421,
0.0440742411,
0.0448859893,
-0.0150526483,
0.0334391892,
0.0098694693,
0.0136115579,
-0.0034413149,
-0.0814251155,
-0.0357387885,
0.0692548752,
0.012723702,
-0.0406078584,
-0.0042161634,
0.0169889126,
0.0538837574,
-0.0301464647,
-0.006429296,
-0.0021175772,
-0.0496494919,
0.0226061326,
0.0221032929,
0.0125164399,
0.0232048146,
0.0241063908,
0.0564587936,
-0.0218542572,
0.0317938998,
-0.0265649538,
0.0411909409,
0.0299067777,
0.0363254994,
-0.0187776461,
0.0138060981,
-0.0046017366,
0.0120871905,
0.021019185,
0.0331027433,
0.0392379276,
-0.0702256709,
0.0185128171,
0.0441946201,
-0.047669746,
0.0518835261,
-0.0455982462,
0.0041945945,
-0.0187688544,
0.0111046378,
0.0246612914,
0.0506759137,
-0.0318610109,
-0.0664751455,
0.0224471483,
-0.0163132828,
-0.0133113805,
0.0224108193,
-0.0054093227,
0.0197953451,
0.0233931001,
-0.0431899317,
0.0333378874,
2.005631216e-34,
0.0226154346,
0.0446610786,
-0.0158560481,
-0.0367286615,
-0.0247446205,
-0.0390178785,
-0.0009339424,
0.0344708748,
0.0411363356,
-0.0782814994,
0.0108809983
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.02738v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.02738v3 | RecallM: An Adaptable Memory Mechanism with Temporal Understanding for Large Language Models | 2023-07-06T02:51:54 | 2023-10-03T01:16:33 | Brandon Kynoch, Hugo Latapie, Dwane van der Sluis | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SC | Large Language Models (LLMs) have made extraordinary progress in the field of
Artificial Intelligence and have demonstrated remarkable capabilities across a
large variety of tasks and domains. However, as we venture closer to creating
Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) systems, we recognize the need to
supplement LLMs with long-term memory to overcome the context window limitation
and more importantly, to create a foundation for sustained reasoning,
cumulative learning and long-term user interaction. In this paper we propose
RecallM, a novel architecture for providing LLMs with an adaptable and
updatable long-term memory mechanism. Unlike previous methods, the RecallM
architecture is particularly effective at belief updating and maintaining a
temporal understanding of the knowledge provided to it. We demonstrate through
various experiments the effectiveness of this architecture. Furthermore,
through our own temporal understanding and belief updating experiments, we show
that RecallM is four times more effective than using a vector database for
updating knowledge previously stored in long-term memory. We also demonstrate
that RecallM shows competitive performance on general question-answering and
in-context learning tasks. | [
0.0344915688,
0.0569376647,
-0.0224027876,
0.0260326453,
-0.0340526402,
-0.0029087437,
-0.0136866616,
-0.0410342962,
0.0381178595,
-0.0266794767,
-0.0096341502,
-0.0820909813,
-0.0091759246,
0.0554854013,
-0.0073416051,
-0.0349755809,
0.0737788007,
-0.0381366611,
0.0073610134,
-0.0149337938,
-0.00894712,
-0.0142910304,
-0.0066487328,
-0.0114233606,
-0.0007769636,
-0.0342834406,
-0.0451375283,
-0.0379515477,
-0.0072549372,
-0.0372911878,
-0.0176750291,
0.0077613476,
0.0428240411,
0.0631511435,
0.000001965,
-0.0505340099,
-0.0305410437,
-0.0149612585,
-0.0661431625,
0.0019238564,
-0.0145832999,
0.0253230482,
-0.0080612963,
0.0033284007,
-0.0541542955,
-0.0094158454,
0.0247065909,
0.0303362738,
0.0570634156,
0.0563041829,
0.0059672897,
-0.0493378527,
0.0490598194,
-0.0259397924,
0.0261110794,
-0.0491514951,
0.034185905,
0.0051768916,
0.0087779928,
-0.0039481786,
-0.0166009814,
0.0314095654,
0.0352877751,
-0.0064547532,
0.0147259235,
0.0429613143,
-0.000765286,
0.0166453179,
-0.0080647739,
0.0306034777,
0.0395231023,
-0.0428892821,
-0.0105786053,
0.0504841059,
-0.0118174981,
0.0065374225,
-0.0540469624,
0.0261174813,
-0.0204762835,
0.0025437237,
0.0291580707,
-0.0321546048,
0.0483297817,
0.0310319103,
-0.0742553473,
0.0659665689,
0.0126619684,
-0.0291593559,
-0.0237679109,
-0.0301626064,
-0.0244251508,
-0.0540218018,
0.015815109,
0.0931393057,
-0.0339586176,
0.0536736585,
-0.0131717464,
0.0140725104,
0.0119079696,
-0.078195028,
0.0098981196,
0.0463223457,
0.0175864268,
0.087252602,
-0.0571253411,
0.064802967,
-0.0277591683,
-0.0245844461,
-0.0221905187,
-0.0282132532,
-0.0695026144,
-0.0362288281,
-0.0062797121,
0.0732644796,
0.0261546597,
-0.0023471378,
-0.047527995,
0.0753160715,
-0.0069753923,
0.0378401466,
-0.0217422247,
0.0011810426,
-0.0155925052,
-0.0193317458,
-0.0819699243,
0.0328748785,
-0.0398475043,
-0.0080157369,
0.0019204523,
-0.0452816151,
-0.011369287,
0.0055675041,
-0.0084831016,
-0.0017350793,
0.0068808966,
0.043803826,
-0.0146297673,
-0.0292927735,
-0.066189751,
-0.0270968452,
-0.0095038535,
-0.075888291,
0.0276426431,
-0.0559637919,
0.0448219664,
0.0100130169,
-0.0209932476,
-0.0247713383,
0.0063838596,
0.0278990604,
-0.0268651787,
0.0659246817,
0.0530204326,
-0.0088551044,
0.052717112,
-0.0029228774,
0.0155741619,
0.042232886,
0.0252060685,
0.0046371669,
0.0105450051,
0.0340914838,
0.0063595474,
-0.00786437,
0.0414788723,
-0.0212192684,
-0.0291729234,
0.0173486955,
0.0288846362,
0.0316617936,
-0.0168543197,
0.0368061699,
0.0068226089,
-0.0258766692,
0.0551619753,
0.031621106,
0.0023564652,
0.0167537723,
0.0335179642,
-0.0510694422,
0.0256774053,
-0.0038532009,
-0.0689705536,
0.0549280122,
-0.0601005852,
0.015760757,
-0.0241527017,
0.0145666003,
-0.0323724821,
-0.0246142056,
-0.0146235134,
0.0067380853,
-0.0079834657,
0.0336156711,
0.0674303025,
-0.010508718,
-0.0127906417,
0.0662113875,
0.0050546308,
-0.0048416136,
-0.0018524845,
-0.0571285076,
0.0600928143,
0.0729573146,
0.0352943689,
-0.0453986414,
-0.023415627,
0.0103145782,
0.0056190593,
0.0306187961,
0.0528880768,
-0.0102341799,
-0.0341629796,
-0.0109318634,
0.0133580212,
-0.0041628084,
-0.0018946721,
0.0455908962,
0.0526672825,
0.0215346217,
-0.0035904364,
0.001108415,
0.0228914693,
0.0229309034,
-0.0196177233,
-0.0185654126,
-0.0308315363,
-0.011258672,
0.0256177187,
0.0051867026,
0.0032613107,
0.0042630676,
0.0541642793,
-0.0125598265,
-0.031183714,
0.0455583744,
-0.084295772,
-0.0301346071,
0.0474972464,
0.0455742814,
0.0009875114,
-0.0307188835,
-0.0154537531,
-0.0569470637,
0.0342512578,
-0.0262285285,
0.0883831978,
-0.0694464669,
0.0350404419,
0.0090825781,
-0.0068469099,
-0.0190887786,
0.0988838449,
-0.0172114149,
-0.038789399,
0.0355962031,
0.0445179567,
-0.0130647179,
-0.0493581407,
-0.0201428365,
0.0460966118,
0.0079281498,
0.0011864607,
-0.0021186189,
-0.0513820872,
-0.0588205643,
-0.0291832648,
-0.0900620371,
0.0178599115,
-0.0047489693,
-0.0012808841,
-0.0208237991,
-0.0078757443,
0.0159721263,
-0.0129729845,
-0.0434659943,
0.0109259272,
0.020063702,
0.0206772368,
0.0037764725,
0.0192744322,
0.0034537665,
-0.0076311938,
0.0037957318,
-0.0105142407,
0.0447974503,
-0.0178602133,
-0.0421946943,
-0.0657427981,
0.0018860168,
-0.0705674291,
0.0501925051,
-0.0213410892,
0.0010880422,
0.0052346014,
-0.0387343802,
0.0724925101,
0.0760966986,
0.0180412158,
0.006851641,
0.0584480725,
-0.0182824433,
-0.0476105958,
0.037891902,
-0.0286420751,
-0.0369796939,
0.0001820584,
0.025306616,
-0.0313400105,
0.0422747061,
-0.011385153,
0.0084919753,
-0.0399140343,
0.0276085641,
-0.0105816033,
-0.0196882114,
-0.0455987379,
-0.0128023764,
-0.0476151705,
-0.0102675213,
-0.0263186619,
-0.0403507948,
0.0793652609,
0.000010148,
0.0194193479,
-0.0041232491,
0.0114063602,
-0.0163131729,
0.0819024667,
0.0096971234,
0.0235269796,
-0.0223352648,
-0.0149326967,
-0.0373875909,
-0.0001840112,
-0.0000705547,
-0.0455472618,
0.0424793884,
-0.0712159723,
0.0370444544,
0.0099707134,
-0.0121281845,
-0.0775848031,
0.0032731059,
-0.032158535,
0.0115724336,
-0.0569813959,
-0.0153558999,
-0.0224149339,
0.0039744829,
0.0422430821,
0.0128069045,
-0.0141713461,
-0.0099028917,
-0.0005884391,
0.0034558459,
0.0393739939,
0.0471302383,
0.0072894287,
-0.0118418392,
0.0316512957,
0.0637075007,
0.0573894419,
-0.0361763984,
-0.0226456765,
-0.0122563588,
0.0045642881,
-0.0412571542,
-0.0010348867,
0.0006526635,
0.0019160946,
-0.0780138075,
-0.0278547946,
0.1090430543,
0.0394555368,
-0.0311019439,
-0.0348645672,
-0.0144731421,
0.0177846067,
0.0153282695,
0.0443470255,
-0.0773049295,
-0.016418729,
0.018049214,
-0.0010264998,
-0.0083249267,
-0.0317605585,
-0.0266214516,
-0.1012551636,
-0.0177406743,
0.0132359946,
-0.0385588706,
-0.0083880369,
-0.0381346345,
-0.0191739593,
0.0325864144,
0.0238988139,
0.0556397066,
0.0098068221,
-0.0281612165,
-0.0056845588,
-0.0163695179,
-0.022626292,
0.0458296612,
-0.0099912919,
0.0531503744,
0.0608858727,
0.0195106063,
0.0095383786,
-0.046207808,
0.0004057275,
-0.0079179453,
0.0327427797,
-0.0269273054,
0.0247727167,
-0.0238032807,
-0.005099908,
-0.0039634155,
0.0218292102,
-0.0223580189,
-0.0389803685,
0.0144236535,
0.1103230268,
-0.0414019339,
0.0007837497,
0.0178309474,
-0.0370801203,
-0.0256910492,
0.1014545187,
-0.0114691276,
-0.0241587944,
-0.0534287244,
-0.0271753985,
-0.0393409282,
-0.0274110436,
-0.0011139596,
0.0101548638,
-0.0048970277,
0.0214993488,
-0.0538534932,
-0.0295524281,
0.012096894,
0.0362423435,
0.0141487923,
0.0060174521,
0.0233515706,
0.0109349275,
-0.0800047666,
-0.0029903585,
-0.0638816282,
0.0081619862,
-0.0355832539,
-0.0038301153,
0.0520657599,
-0.0226615258,
-0.0004476261,
0.0115047842,
-0.0396166071,
-0.0507063977,
0.0383105353,
0.0481687747,
0.0279399697,
0.0810257122,
0.0055127023,
-0.0105677368,
0.0677815527,
-0.0321019255,
-0.0156460162,
0.0549679697,
0.0102992458,
0.0434797443,
-0.0041584033,
0.0362147987,
-0.0501623712,
-0.0220200066,
0.0011223097,
0.0151277874,
-0.0245928541,
0.0143415118,
0.0295620244,
-0.0134846643,
0.0050835996,
0.0362496898,
0.0035237898,
-0.0052362839,
0.0528648719,
-0.0336108543,
0.0026612196,
0.0044789468,
0.0261330325,
0.0173964649,
-0.0107695684,
0.0056056073,
-0.0387414694,
0.0253801513,
0.0030403011,
0.0079988837,
-0.0293262117,
0.0120221339,
-0.0030594205,
0.021765139,
0.0261454321,
-0.041367203,
0.0049712416,
-0.003868171,
0.0590061806,
-0.0220691171,
0.0773251206,
0.0259841718,
-0.0440450385,
-0.0377257764,
-0.0196151081,
-0.0912616253,
-0.0683836043,
0.021611819,
0.0332918316,
0.0551821031,
0.0164506566,
0.0179798808,
-0.0484565049,
-0.0160054695,
-0.0163278505,
-0.0028138731,
0.0537327565,
-0.0437460095,
0.0095470771,
0.0225770157,
-0.015981894,
0.0203689616,
0.0533614233,
-0.0352402627,
0.0526668169,
-0.0199982207,
-0.006743791,
-0.0294799525,
-0.0316901132,
-0.0339480527,
0.0291443784,
-0.0241384599,
-0.0098108109,
-0.0573553704,
-0.0421301089,
0.0202111062,
-0.0015800089,
0.0028099231,
-0.0413515903,
0.0126529187,
0.0495084375,
0.0239564497,
-0.0092480006,
-0.0309929922,
0.0487034395,
-0.0120975794,
0.0008399603,
-0.0069060368,
-6.188269522e-33,
-0.0297849756,
-0.0085748285,
0.0435889587,
-0.0266517401,
-0.0240031406,
0.0013679006,
-0.0556437224,
-0.0005171202,
-0.043262694,
-0.0153146079,
-0.0312475581,
0.0326937288,
0.0125547089,
0.0263474509,
0.0170366708,
-0.037813317,
0.0361521877,
-0.0032784604,
-0.0010836315,
0.03743257,
0.0906441286,
0.0424301922,
0.0322621539,
-0.0209537074,
0.0356602557,
0.0102253091,
0.0384704992,
0.0619160198,
-0.0336283073,
0.0757704973,
-0.0437815562,
0.0180076193,
0.026984483,
-0.0433408022,
-0.004576291,
0.0251509249,
-0.1113044173,
-0.0170225184,
0.0279721394,
0.0136689907,
-0.0462419651,
-0.0347668901,
0.0248505715,
0.0038791543,
0.0097621558,
-0.0063353027,
-0.0001238998,
-0.054175213,
-0.0405582637,
-0.0186718442,
-0.0362811536,
0.0056621912,
0.0356208831,
0.0117404517,
-0.015514669,
-0.0234079044,
0.0160367414,
0.010436493,
-0.0657501593,
-0.0161038376,
-0.0226434283,
0.0101642059,
0.0572210252,
0.0530635156,
0.0276580695,
0.0703806058,
0.0093971379,
0.0122113144,
-0.037212953,
-0.0143651916,
0.0173216444,
-0.0047798627,
0.0352659635,
0.0170299336,
0.0374170169,
-0.0032230478,
-0.0517358035,
-0.0091250623,
0.0608427748,
0.0720969886,
0.052741237,
0.0265685339,
-0.0291783344,
-0.012172617,
-0.0522219725,
0.042610988,
-0.0564403161,
-0.0259379838,
0.0296802446,
0.0354500115,
-0.0098638395,
-0.0150018856,
0.0452578105,
-0.0298126973,
-0.0159943625,
0.0380775258,
0.0047561512,
-0.0097343288,
-0.0096863434,
0.038004078,
-0.0197496712,
0.0172237977,
-0.0221809708,
-0.0054531037,
-0.0167509206,
0.0122037288,
0.0036703958,
0.0224390402,
-0.0443701707,
0.0077677346,
-0.0516229384,
-0.0013565562,
-0.0125637967,
-0.02237905,
0.0325375162,
0.0249751173,
0.009723668,
0.0579784997,
0.0158487633,
-0.0035223598,
-0.0357251093,
-0.0115225008,
0.0211900435,
0.010800506,
-0.0273021758,
-0.0158293732,
-0.0180598032,
0.0430450849,
-0.0002339012,
-0.0774394944,
0.0288214479,
0.0223278981,
2.676e-7,
0.0097607579,
0.0379373096,
0.0157750398,
-0.0009169478,
0.0384870656,
0.0007913826,
-0.0085989544,
0.0023726567,
0.0216260087,
-0.0185471196,
-0.0062874691,
0.0662131682,
0.0302137416,
0.0210566446,
-0.0692500845,
-0.0289183315,
-0.0319666527,
-0.0215776972,
-0.0566460714,
0.0093217092,
0.0496052727,
0.1057674959,
0.0303401574,
-0.0092733437,
0.0036736128,
-0.0738828629,
0.085578844,
-0.0062831799,
-0.0111118667,
0.003921024,
0.0194504205,
0.0390893631,
-0.0123054758,
0.006763685,
-0.003541454,
-0.0008615546,
-0.0687269196,
0.0541500747,
0.0030829494,
-0.0447111912,
-0.0181549694,
-0.0141695142,
0.0080167903,
-0.0444321111,
0.0874151438,
-0.0693705902,
-0.0238536093,
-0.0170656387,
0.0051105144,
-0.025883859,
-0.0390226841,
0.0294299405,
-0.0192272607,
0.0084408009,
-0.0225020237,
0.0194073264,
0.0013652965,
-0.1201456338,
-0.0228125416,
0.0244688541,
-0.0456135683,
-0.0497106798,
-0.0197743345,
-0.0269939676,
0.0251984354,
-0.0726412907,
0.0027220701,
2.349553542e-34,
0.0337312445,
-0.0018330973,
-0.0143199805,
0.0531261452,
0.0310432184,
-0.0157484002,
0.0105587803,
0.0244575161,
0.0609849729,
-0.0940279514,
-0.0299438853
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.02729v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.02729v2 | Text Alignment Is An Efficient Unified Model for Massive NLP Tasks | 2023-07-06T02:28:31 | 2023-11-02T03:49:19 | Yuheng Zha, Yichi Yang, Ruichen Li, Zhiting Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs), typically designed as a function of next-word
prediction, have excelled across extensive NLP tasks. Despite the generality,
next-word prediction is often not an efficient formulation for many of the
tasks, demanding an extreme scale of model parameters (10s or 100s of billions)
and sometimes yielding suboptimal performance. In practice, it is often
desirable to build more efficient models -- despite being less versatile, they
still apply to a substantial subset of problems, delivering on par or even
superior performance with much smaller model sizes. In this paper, we propose
text alignment as an efficient unified model for a wide range of crucial tasks
involving text entailment, similarity, question answering (and answerability),
factual consistency, and so forth. Given a pair of texts, the model measures
the degree of alignment between their information. We instantiate an alignment
model (Align) through lightweight finetuning of RoBERTa (355M parameters) using
5.9M examples from 28 datasets. Despite its compact size, extensive experiments
show the model's efficiency and strong performance: (1) On over 20 datasets of
aforementioned diverse tasks, the model matches or surpasses FLAN-T5 models
that have around 2x or 10x more parameters; the single unified model also
outperforms task-specific models finetuned on individual datasets; (2) When
applied to evaluate factual consistency of language generation on 23 datasets,
our model improves over various baselines, including the much larger GPT-3.5
(ChatGPT) and sometimes even GPT-4; (3) The lightweight model can also serve as
an add-on component for LLMs such as GPT-3.5 in question answering tasks,
improving the average exact match (EM) score by 17.94 and F1 score by 15.05
through identifying unanswerable questions. | [
0.0447976552,
0.0539944358,
0.0230567642,
0.0489253327,
-0.0519398414,
-0.001203398,
-0.0176337063,
-0.0200302564,
-0.0153910052,
-0.0200415459,
0.0035937896,
-0.0180595499,
0.0118465628,
0.0013482954,
0.0193194784,
-0.0267625004,
0.0486335084,
0.0233757608,
0.0025139528,
0.005870515,
0.0766494572,
0.0329734124,
0.0144624375,
0.0428727828,
-0.015324886,
-0.0315609723,
-0.0242248438,
0.0126839988,
0.0460839011,
0.007606681,
0.0446623378,
0.0398437008,
0.0134099461,
0.0581961684,
0.0000016946,
-0.0302138422,
-0.0145292357,
-0.0057349973,
-0.0046406602,
0.0022085893,
0.007784918,
-0.0205437243,
0.028480133,
0.0363249965,
-0.0409477353,
0.0078644613,
0.0584336296,
0.0412786603,
0.0701067075,
0.0654767007,
-0.0040097521,
-0.0263257362,
0.0350391455,
-0.0080569768,
0.0036745074,
-0.05940805,
0.0284179896,
0.0206865352,
-0.015467667,
0.0065121558,
-0.0070604533,
0.0266269334,
-0.0038997207,
0.0306655522,
-0.0147065818,
0.0281964634,
-0.0314084925,
-0.024141103,
-0.0016104158,
0.0896762162,
-0.0378593057,
-0.0858491138,
0.0041930163,
0.0080276979,
-0.0222328659,
0.0111553939,
-0.0273523722,
0.0051083234,
-0.0229845811,
0.0431932993,
0.0629560947,
-0.0034367498,
0.0125523172,
0.0407781601,
0.0215715375,
0.0392772779,
0.0460609384,
-0.0460115932,
-0.0174580626,
-0.0037455077,
-0.043321155,
-0.0685468689,
-0.0039475029,
0.0097131059,
-0.0496176332,
0.0078627029,
-0.1051444933,
-0.0210540593,
0.0372390077,
-0.0248491354,
0.0025352754,
0.0719819665,
0.0310714301,
0.0342553258,
-0.0187876355,
0.0792120099,
-0.0235822871,
-0.0236979369,
-0.0600751825,
-0.0352840982,
-0.0241727848,
0.0030914601,
-0.0377217345,
-0.0050118282,
-0.0162976831,
-0.0514102839,
-0.0282652974,
0.0146747483,
0.0277282186,
0.0422178954,
0.0205548499,
-0.0016920734,
-0.0499721915,
-0.0285910666,
-0.0278204419,
0.0347854905,
-0.0617208146,
0.0096052727,
0.0078723058,
-0.0327306949,
-0.0198549647,
0.0090843076,
0.0172533896,
-0.0445786193,
0.0134444097,
0.0178115051,
-0.0122829573,
-0.0148132527,
0.0066433148,
-0.0126832621,
-0.0146495234,
-0.090925388,
-0.0437513627,
-0.0712530166,
0.0534217916,
0.0088159768,
-0.0242440961,
-0.0241649467,
0.020615723,
0.0852803588,
-0.0419262722,
0.0823187977,
-0.0191931576,
0.0430544652,
0.023631271,
-0.0305175949,
0.0211476553,
0.0152340792,
0.0124312742,
0.0110987034,
0.0340806209,
0.0157941189,
-0.0196863823,
0.0348415487,
0.0160059407,
0.01038012,
0.0296602678,
0.0529241338,
0.0203112084,
0.06498456,
0.0331464037,
0.0684380457,
-0.0077713444,
-0.0262882318,
0.0679403916,
0.0178002398,
0.0141499424,
0.0225132853,
0.0387145318,
0.0350149199,
0.0099368514,
-0.0085642915,
-0.0544716902,
0.0353627577,
-0.0499215536,
0.0500010736,
0.0799820125,
0.0688813627,
-0.0296428092,
-0.0108063566,
-0.0374621488,
-0.0001592479,
-0.0294721685,
-0.0000486761,
-0.0174610242,
-0.0023759156,
-0.0584950075,
0.0352115668,
0.0228322707,
-0.0315339714,
-0.0079906723,
0.0041757957,
0.059713915,
0.0448216461,
0.0510357134,
0.001744465,
-0.0581796691,
0.0027176996,
0.0141291758,
0.0609631427,
0.0614309683,
0.0060461145,
-0.0254169181,
-0.0653426573,
-0.0188672021,
0.0099531608,
-0.0142404148,
-0.0022419584,
0.0491654947,
0.0209778715,
0.035655342,
-0.0477706715,
-0.0288095996,
0.0599491075,
-0.022942964,
-0.0140198516,
-0.0303825233,
0.0144283688,
0.0329541676,
0.0010087551,
-0.0030568815,
0.0196411535,
0.0189530328,
-0.0105803097,
0.0061985697,
-0.034928374,
-0.0331686512,
-0.0553878695,
0.066545397,
-0.0175373387,
-0.0132210972,
0.0614807121,
-0.0497970358,
-0.0595646538,
-0.0422541462,
-0.0336694159,
-0.0114972768,
-0.0487803034,
0.0223596413,
0.036787387,
0.0077730864,
-0.0436450094,
0.0738984942,
0.0174177997,
0.0395432934,
0.0117065422,
-0.0003050461,
0.0342920385,
-0.0431622639,
-0.0317180231,
-0.018119989,
0.0104838423,
0.0154722184,
0.0553752519,
0.0170703363,
-0.0446083695,
-0.0387390777,
-0.087947309,
0.0646711439,
-0.0160668902,
0.0332565568,
0.0581417792,
0.0212372728,
-0.0023008666,
-0.0018987078,
-0.0903350711,
-0.0005281079,
0.0422207043,
-0.0046200687,
0.0567269586,
-0.0131634697,
-0.0276611075,
-0.0758163333,
-0.00677671,
-0.0115241241,
0.0066899238,
0.0262061916,
-0.0036225631,
-0.0538568497,
0.0109117832,
-0.0672514588,
0.0239794627,
0.0060355524,
-0.0463492833,
-0.0412095487,
0.0006056293,
0.054210458,
0.0060644327,
0.0397291929,
-0.0546593815,
0.007488566,
0.023913702,
-0.0430609919,
0.0292740315,
-0.0584386662,
-0.0278616585,
0.0049869101,
-0.0368230194,
0.0194133688,
0.0482956432,
0.0221407916,
0.0019499096,
-0.0740557685,
0.0280352551,
0.024663033,
0.0461911298,
0.0124211721,
0.0095796371,
-0.0247779395,
0.0202259216,
-0.0641420037,
-0.0364494324,
0.0833255723,
-0.0789692476,
0.0063904691,
-0.0603665337,
-0.0160475802,
-0.0400993116,
0.03499455,
0.0177526362,
0.0318633988,
0.0079439189,
0.0157005992,
-0.0470137522,
-0.0020468386,
0.0253142491,
-0.0491155945,
0.0509974733,
-0.0173137076,
0.0540486537,
-0.0196387637,
-0.0570303723,
-0.0525003374,
-0.0698066354,
-0.0263078194,
-0.0010195631,
-0.020758165,
-0.0201944243,
-0.032702636,
0.009203108,
0.0109912558,
0.0203562286,
-0.0205651168,
-0.0032466918,
-0.0423620604,
0.0523341335,
0.1164914817,
0.0158711635,
0.0082570193,
-0.0084236013,
0.0130473441,
0.029198518,
0.0254714638,
0.0437339135,
-0.0140777081,
-0.0371566787,
0.0105684837,
-0.0430406928,
0.0053762924,
0.0193125736,
0.0659775883,
-0.0225362182,
-0.0334526524,
0.1182556897,
0.0269554239,
-0.0106024975,
-0.0189387444,
0.0099489419,
0.0570089333,
0.0127208102,
0.0424152091,
-0.0522088222,
-0.0594730936,
0.0083833039,
0.0069902749,
0.0119583635,
-0.0220130477,
-0.007013333,
-0.1001674905,
-0.0091655031,
0.0173919052,
-0.013378337,
-0.0625463948,
-0.0183854904,
0.0175717361,
-0.0145245995,
0.034939006,
0.022419326,
-0.0098401066,
0.0329645686,
0.006639523,
-0.0203876775,
-0.0098696426,
0.0318171084,
-0.0661340058,
0.0476956628,
0.0502081104,
0.0452232435,
0.0116059529,
-0.0408334397,
0.0022918889,
-0.0375733264,
-0.0393305942,
0.0147524439,
0.052728951,
-0.0424251631,
-0.0025307077,
-0.033644855,
0.0352620147,
-0.0337431766,
0.0136786466,
0.0235537086,
0.0546164177,
0.0027999673,
-0.0000061675,
-0.0089713205,
0.031607464,
-0.0072349678,
0.1078218371,
0.0040144157,
-0.010309496,
-0.0548748784,
-0.0027237446,
0.0098701883,
-0.0398702733,
-0.0168417469,
0.0053216023,
-0.0036670039,
0.0233540684,
-0.0822437853,
-0.031248251,
0.0236502402,
0.012992451,
0.0059883371,
0.0118870297,
0.0016471802,
-0.0328288972,
-0.0473432839,
0.0162468888,
-0.0316620767,
0.0180458352,
-0.0357109793,
0.0263189338,
0.017453393,
-0.035420157,
-0.0176930912,
0.0274609644,
-0.1114627123,
-0.0564621389,
-0.0388131626,
0.0233195014,
0.0186738651,
0.0291939266,
-0.0348827168,
-0.0069250772,
0.0000354195,
0.012192986,
-0.0417700596,
0.0019944422,
-0.0290572606,
-0.0032195551,
0.0021232057,
0.040840704,
-0.0312776938,
-0.0167847443,
-0.0054351152,
0.0699030384,
-0.0053053424,
-0.0743086934,
0.0554108508,
0.0281554721,
0.0250605736,
-0.0010758898,
0.0048215762,
-0.0296007451,
-0.0143736862,
-0.0014464087,
-0.0417045355,
-0.0208210144,
0.0178347286,
0.0309100971,
0.0164600592,
-0.0051067276,
-8.736e-7,
0.0002139743,
0.0182104651,
-0.03733043,
-0.052352231,
-0.0248470474,
0.0172277521,
0.0177203398,
-0.0260307603,
-0.0553661957,
-0.0206271783,
0.0086748553,
0.0372624956,
-0.0348311923,
0.0641491488,
0.0500092283,
0.0091631105,
0.0077858088,
0.024512291,
-0.056020461,
-0.0333244465,
-0.0366931073,
0.0122974692,
0.0524884537,
-0.0137074068,
0.0577833578,
-0.033384949,
-0.0176663585,
-0.0280451216,
0.0475493036,
-0.0064556897,
-0.0115169752,
0.0290266164,
-0.000420408,
-0.0377606973,
-0.0118673351,
0.0639524907,
-0.0006202836,
0.0388918035,
0.0190002173,
-0.0463656671,
-0.0329098962,
-0.0255493261,
-0.0275480114,
0.0195962843,
-0.0215391722,
-0.0035687648,
-0.015461457,
-0.0481404811,
0.0273781288,
0.0214297492,
-0.036883533,
-0.0027815308,
0.0417038985,
0.0561833493,
-0.0263429899,
-0.0224478114,
-0.0449725315,
0.0156462062,
-0.0355862416,
-0.0322713181,
-0.037264999,
-5.992572855e-33,
-0.0229754448,
-0.0153667768,
0.0377007574,
0.0136220232,
-0.0499401502,
-0.0053703361,
-0.0261085238,
-0.0304874852,
-0.046670232,
0.0126550952,
0.0011818939,
-0.0091093341,
-0.0053367615,
0.02990558,
-0.0066878926,
-0.0422981903,
0.0293429345,
0.001295438,
-0.0285356492,
0.0107738627,
0.0238524135,
0.0050202911,
0.029675249,
-0.0130924238,
-0.0060393079,
-0.035208948,
-0.0359000899,
0.0211649984,
-0.0190686695,
0.0467861742,
-0.0324869491,
0.026687488,
0.0341210291,
0.0003711295,
0.0023647177,
0.0423995219,
-0.0750133991,
-0.0300001688,
0.0353036299,
-0.0093486542,
-0.0467223302,
0.0079390481,
0.0291874297,
-0.0266733021,
-0.0119875632,
0.0019658431,
0.0464084595,
-0.0143907145,
0.0013341493,
-0.0187963936,
-0.045225393,
0.0115591185,
0.005522667,
-0.0410705283,
0.0059835892,
0.0524538904,
0.0289392807,
0.0212508477,
-0.0563944206,
-0.0162844695,
-0.0315443911,
0.0540127754,
0.0403719768,
0.004450982,
0.0060385466,
0.0693060309,
-0.0152279912,
-0.0626861751,
-0.014765068,
0.0109676635,
-0.0287092868,
0.0217889734,
0.0367215089,
0.0687525049,
0.0144721223,
0.0267214086,
-0.0483559296,
0.0477107055,
0.0263822656,
0.0331045017,
0.0158639867,
-0.0167556889,
-0.0514515154,
0.0028327785,
-0.0402495153,
0.0303773377,
-0.040327251,
-0.0095185805,
0.0409418382,
0.0298713706,
0.0209365413,
0.0011757788,
0.004520834,
-0.0250446536,
0.0080501027,
0.0224759951,
-0.0389681384,
-0.0368676484,
-0.0271864329,
0.0566963479,
-0.0445557423,
-0.0253465418,
-0.0177238155,
0.0051020044,
-0.0136563359,
0.012138051,
0.0326857083,
-0.0063042757,
-0.0707807243,
0.0236026812,
-0.0489569008,
0.0094499579,
-0.0408016518,
-0.0177298114,
0.047268223,
0.002864361,
0.0084087895,
0.030042408,
0.0409006737,
0.0031676206,
-0.0290363897,
-0.0434521586,
0.0097363982,
-0.0029494895,
-0.0245765001,
0.0328377038,
-0.0513946563,
0.0079973666,
-0.02613331,
-0.0417878628,
-0.0054751765,
0.0463525057,
2.384e-7,
0.0219005588,
0.0220851749,
0.0561745204,
0.0150167942,
-0.0166715793,
0.0351583473,
0.0101282252,
0.0487181768,
-0.0001518906,
-0.0174647123,
0.0292136241,
-0.004633836,
0.0680767819,
-0.0059742574,
-0.0729074031,
0.0126143498,
-0.0951708183,
-0.0044213939,
-0.059913069,
0.0005496569,
0.0662093535,
0.1218908131,
0.0443534814,
0.0169001836,
0.0008345385,
-0.0438501313,
0.0575722978,
-0.0085295904,
-0.0546907261,
0.0241041146,
0.033308439,
-0.0074146069,
-0.020215407,
0.0087951273,
-0.0048838067,
0.0326238573,
0.0360962711,
0.0705275908,
0.0105143227,
0.0091654304,
-0.0430580378,
-0.0195768755,
-0.0016912214,
-0.0815677792,
0.0697674081,
-0.0167264566,
0.0089066215,
-0.0121336877,
-0.0304599628,
0.0234578606,
0.0174473524,
0.0012697123,
-0.0313767828,
0.0224765483,
0.0418315865,
0.0045281914,
-0.0354950316,
-0.0536197461,
-0.036531955,
0.0298464708,
-0.0566875339,
-0.0068880403,
-0.049846895,
-0.0172218475,
0.0494105145,
-0.0805313736,
-0.0056645558,
2.382790645e-34,
0.0153272497,
-0.0303671043,
0.0267341454,
-0.0177227035,
0.0380945019,
-0.0099947685,
0.0086034294,
0.0118264873,
0.0078399638,
-0.0994367152,
-0.0219639298
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.02720v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.02720v1 | On-Device Constrained Self-Supervised Speech Representation Learning for Keyword Spotting via Knowledge Distillation | 2023-07-06T02:03:31 | 2023-07-06T02:03:31 | Gene-Ping Yang, Yue Gu, Qingming Tang, Dongsu Du, Yuzong Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Large self-supervised models are effective feature extractors, but their
application is challenging under on-device budget constraints and biased
dataset collection, especially in keyword spotting. To address this, we
proposed a knowledge distillation-based self-supervised speech representation
learning (S3RL) architecture for on-device keyword spotting. Our approach used
a teacher-student framework to transfer knowledge from a larger, more complex
model to a smaller, light-weight model using dual-view cross-correlation
distillation and the teacher's codebook as learning objectives. We evaluated
our model's performance on an Alexa keyword spotting detection task using a
16.6k-hour in-house dataset. Our technique showed exceptional performance in
normal and noisy conditions, demonstrating the efficacy of knowledge
distillation methods in constructing self-supervised models for keyword
spotting tasks while working within on-device resource constraints. | [
-0.020317426,
-0.0003170451,
0.0225809906,
0.00717371,
0.0161881521,
-0.008204435,
0.0469695069,
-0.0342262462,
0.0129365381,
-0.0263625588,
-0.0468685292,
-0.0033364447,
-0.0239041243,
0.0225919578,
-0.0066090142,
0.0109899966,
0.025249375,
-0.0415237434,
0.0263521168,
-0.0049316846,
0.0449096002,
0.0052164523,
-0.0437930711,
0.0040381723,
-0.0179944858,
-0.0388320982,
-0.0172903948,
0.0154579096,
-0.0147865703,
-0.0007817856,
0.0077044093,
0.0391776934,
0.0580191799,
0.0210924968,
0.0000018359,
-0.0220634546,
-0.0219358988,
0.034070801,
-0.0766375959,
0.020292202,
0.0091697695,
0.0326139852,
-0.0211078841,
0.036109142,
-0.0167924184,
-0.0064127585,
0.0102546094,
0.0294972993,
0.0058983681,
0.0154595003,
-0.0005013341,
-0.0226970818,
-0.0074273366,
-0.0281955991,
0.0144624077,
-0.0219993144,
-0.0435693339,
-0.0147186322,
-0.0081246663,
-0.0147345345,
0.0024137332,
0.0540965721,
-0.0039908262,
0.0153767522,
0.0428639129,
-0.014871371,
-0.0401587188,
-0.0114769749,
-0.032449957,
0.051038336,
-0.0145720243,
0.0024299831,
0.0444949381,
0.0012623846,
0.0003551793,
-0.0140917115,
-0.0274132434,
-0.0544436425,
0.0028179567,
-0.0163337626,
-0.0547091141,
-0.0051302533,
0.0200026501,
-0.0286625568,
-0.0228225049,
-0.0156900305,
-0.0082362583,
-0.0347807109,
-0.0343092345,
-0.0059298617,
-0.0190400891,
0.0198186059,
0.0631850213,
-0.0051946505,
0.021847168,
-0.0236294363,
-0.0223105643,
-0.0414357297,
-0.0343767107,
-0.0169288442,
0.028162064,
0.0025145242,
-0.0224916153,
0.0397621356,
-0.0082897134,
0.0452955514,
-0.0129522644,
0.0261203311,
-0.0164919905,
0.0322590098,
-0.0567509085,
0.0111408569,
-0.0303615648,
0.0473515242,
0.0055430895,
-0.0557942875,
-0.006029835,
-0.0479997657,
-0.0268978942,
-0.0155029343,
0.0174997747,
0.0372556336,
-0.0243887026,
-0.013580217,
0.0466242023,
0.0502621271,
0.022660641,
0.0423789136,
-0.0104097845,
-0.0685349926,
-0.0227818713,
-0.0102803297,
0.038179297,
0.0176218301,
0.0135856383,
0.0213681851,
-0.0179677997,
-0.0730391145,
0.0240981244,
-0.0073824585,
-0.0557543449,
-0.002174892,
0.0222819578,
-0.083110109,
0.0169934221,
-0.0108834226,
0.0159728657,
-0.0498719253,
0.02909231,
-0.0177140348,
0.0300166663,
0.0781525448,
-0.0300095249,
-0.000105756,
0.0041386429,
0.0324940793,
-0.0129750837,
0.0500137173,
0.0930041969,
0.0299124364,
0.0197092481,
-0.0330990888,
-0.0037120041,
0.0104553225,
0.0240397323,
0.0062509193,
-0.0336590409,
-0.0142288841,
-0.0165585876,
0.0288062487,
0.0409629159,
0.0227115341,
-0.0045920499,
0.0159171652,
0.0889996141,
0.0548637658,
0.069241941,
0.0128082596,
-0.0331950635,
0.0343073569,
-0.0048244298,
-0.0121720461,
-0.0016549999,
-0.0242428929,
0.0207298882,
0.0012565082,
0.0358485244,
0.0314003266,
-0.0253375657,
-0.0588403046,
0.0102702193,
-0.0245349798,
-0.0399865098,
0.0682312325,
0.0666614324,
0.0076554837,
0.0295678824,
0.041103147,
0.0039835651,
-0.0694677606,
0.0113699995,
-0.0372442268,
0.0236328542,
0.050910648,
0.0135929557,
-0.0513057858,
-0.0071399002,
-0.0264188778,
0.0076278439,
0.0023185152,
-0.0276600923,
-0.0017789153,
0.0653143153,
-0.031063227,
-0.0551683046,
-0.0266676694,
0.0160937402,
0.0077250469,
-0.0176929012,
0.0284763277,
0.0502081588,
-0.0833287537,
-0.0050773788,
-0.0038422782,
-0.0067090685,
-0.0854872912,
0.0113511514,
0.0456435531,
0.004922966,
0.0314961746,
-0.0379897468,
0.0034247288,
0.035088174,
-0.0786730871,
0.0450415201,
0.0036770839,
-0.0622667633,
-0.0033301858,
0.0436458439,
-0.0415524207,
0.0509229377,
0.0676034242,
0.0179637242,
-0.057791885,
0.0284140632,
-0.0055369763,
0.0554609895,
-0.0077848178,
0.0147076827,
0.022896219,
0.0445791446,
0.0497301258,
0.0059219752,
0.0097877542,
-0.0425393879,
-0.0321613587,
-0.0199625492,
-0.0137421377,
0.0197466183,
-0.0157487262,
-0.0064746235,
-0.0103519801,
0.0325105079,
0.008222037,
-0.0093395533,
-0.0130498521,
0.0106642311,
-0.0484735332,
-0.0157967024,
-0.0494806319,
-0.0021031839,
-0.0032192653,
0.0355809331,
0.0242616013,
-0.0632971227,
-0.0022619234,
-0.0341044515,
-0.028547097,
0.0035136642,
-0.0702234581,
0.001247372,
0.0003253422,
-0.010437998,
-0.0097831013,
0.0078737037,
-0.0194202866,
-0.0201244876,
-0.0064334497,
0.0167607255,
0.0121176718,
0.0384685658,
0.044752948,
0.0232109427,
0.0158958454,
0.0309444796,
-0.0141663309,
-0.0002564834,
0.0415099673,
0.0069651245,
-0.0053906287,
0.0347065255,
-0.0363182053,
-0.0588732436,
0.0284157507,
0.0355719849,
0.0195346922,
-0.0168279484,
0.0515595227,
-0.0460501648,
0.0649332255,
-0.0234097466,
0.0183186233,
-0.0372765958,
-0.0546050034,
-0.0027507059,
-0.0916047692,
-0.0689090192,
0.0198215283,
-0.0245588198,
0.0245122183,
-0.0003036233,
-0.0551849343,
-0.0054850485,
-0.056846723,
0.0023467753,
-0.0329198502,
-0.0479249731,
-0.0084917722,
0.0307870787,
-0.0323391929,
-0.02763661,
-0.0234680828,
-0.0219696984,
-0.0115559213,
-0.0165516101,
0.0457770042,
-0.0586676039,
0.0388384648,
-0.0523846745,
0.0011923981,
0.0047104754,
-0.0614425316,
-0.0171126649,
-0.0164588653,
-0.0264446475,
-0.0267699733,
-0.0076449062,
-0.0021628959,
0.0035815495,
0.0382372364,
0.0072276075,
0.0684129074,
0.0434110798,
0.0074492786,
-0.0350829288,
0.0719026178,
0.0390485786,
0.0216798279,
-0.0152325258,
0.0123888664,
0.0510534905,
0.0243377164,
0.1493374854,
-0.0123076094,
-0.0178628229,
0.0282414947,
0.0485548563,
0.0338033736,
-0.0099540949,
0.0637322068,
0.0503135026,
-0.0659526661,
-0.0316353664,
0.0802983642,
-0.0132751372,
-0.045806583,
-0.0107963216,
0.0225771833,
0.0063486593,
0.0236485265,
-0.0116494689,
-0.0150112025,
-0.0380053557,
0.0261115432,
0.0349652059,
0.0656257868,
0.0145744374,
-0.0250892788,
-0.0816692859,
-0.017264396,
0.0252024718,
0.035432037,
-0.0797654837,
-0.0334167071,
-0.0040057423,
-0.0541817956,
0.0143692857,
-0.0106083769,
-0.0580301359,
-0.0070793671,
0.0282511618,
-0.0696999282,
-0.0562534519,
0.0242896043,
-0.0368617848,
0.0165338907,
0.0501653552,
-0.0021907277,
-0.0267383214,
-0.0073529519,
-0.0565652996,
-0.0093510505,
0.0172574315,
0.0080514271,
0.0214410108,
-0.0169406906,
-0.0271031205,
0.0361938067,
0.0596134104,
-0.0360094942,
-0.0083901696,
0.0323074423,
0.0294063278,
0.0275715552,
-0.0045993431,
-0.015574839,
-0.0079187043,
0.0342299864,
0.0265833344,
0.0269252658,
-0.025880307,
-0.0343940295,
0.0641323552,
-0.0051561361,
-0.0023291525,
-0.0208897144,
0.0117575461,
0.000580014,
-0.0563909113,
-0.0178501531,
-0.0046270597,
0.0474480838,
0.0387880094,
0.0166165326,
0.0634720474,
0.0107142925,
0.0522935912,
-0.0631321073,
0.0014221047,
0.0102446442,
0.0406803936,
-0.0265064314,
-0.0039097439,
0.0096143121,
-0.0351941697,
-0.000840815,
0.0496202968,
-0.0782651231,
-0.0534080118,
0.0310618859,
0.021781601,
0.0174388345,
0.099131763,
-0.059340626,
-0.0135422843,
0.0876239836,
0.0626531616,
-0.071208626,
0.0041963947,
0.0405475944,
-0.0257776771,
-0.0142712761,
0.0204227213,
-0.0487475097,
0.0183918346,
-0.0035150403,
0.0141263241,
-0.073161006,
-0.0323142335,
0.013836097,
-0.0117061809,
0.0835684314,
-0.0233272742,
0.0473634712,
-0.0371746086,
0.0252194665,
0.0446266681,
0.0525497682,
-0.0643303022,
-0.0011169651,
0.0048215948,
-0.0171415359,
0.0064132856,
0.0790661201,
0.0272926297,
-0.0547884591,
-0.0721827298,
0.0455953218,
-0.0255141575,
-0.0064366511,
0.0160491783,
-0.0108149638,
0.0223772377,
0.0811245814,
0.0178075396,
-0.0039930232,
0.0083476417,
-0.0077206194,
-0.0159329325,
0.0277237277,
-0.0061965059,
0.0516210273,
-0.0231229216,
-0.0322860479,
-0.0486926511,
0.0380508713,
0.0208323039,
-0.0387098156,
0.0232867766,
0.0000261585,
-0.0076450217,
-0.036449492,
0.0178384315,
-0.0572809689,
0.0650145486,
0.0041371398,
0.0268534329,
0.0043915985,
0.0038179317,
0.0746182501,
0.0428206772,
0.035636723,
0.0228407234,
0.0234064255,
-0.0602234192,
-0.0407799408,
0.0378402434,
0.0215896778,
0.0017107184,
0.0120154005,
0.005057089,
-0.0783727244,
0.0049166265,
-0.0269573871,
0.0002068489,
-0.0209815223,
0.0217107907,
0.0366510674,
-0.0390214995,
0.002771405,
0.0263912324,
-0.0380273685,
-0.0240131412,
-0.0293093845,
0.0810474604,
-5.585078555e-33,
-0.0058488911,
0.0270362981,
0.0026093354,
-0.0211071577,
0.0161194894,
0.0340706892,
0.048547633,
0.0214100685,
-0.0109665301,
-0.0015416708,
-0.0437771603,
0.0422597863,
0.0368254334,
0.0333613232,
0.01939396,
-0.0057270834,
0.1140232906,
-0.0232301988,
0.0238044094,
0.0250679459,
0.0355221629,
0.0835054964,
0.0455014668,
-0.0568288714,
-0.0599573813,
-0.0037223611,
0.0139715662,
-0.0572463609,
-0.0079437206,
0.0130994739,
-0.0217487328,
0.0445700474,
-0.0203739647,
-0.0151141724,
-0.0431114547,
0.022229258,
-0.0897741988,
-0.0119803464,
-0.0353841856,
0.0269385111,
-0.0268986728,
-0.0082203541,
0.0486645699,
0.0069772741,
-0.020687338,
0.0045335074,
0.0473775417,
0.0079354597,
-0.0548359901,
-0.0393940695,
-0.0062632738,
0.0222582761,
-0.0194883831,
-0.0946534052,
0.0801087096,
0.0095201861,
-0.0138279488,
-0.0642194524,
-0.1186260134,
0.0406565703,
0.0093910201,
0.0508774519,
0.0416456498,
0.0539236031,
0.0190622751,
0.058664389,
0.0256384388,
-0.0551007278,
0.0017433012,
-0.0224230569,
0.0195768587,
0.0742986128,
-0.0118096275,
0.0284606107,
0.0874705911,
-0.0413461588,
-0.0183728766,
-0.0147553151,
-0.0042560673,
0.0330320187,
-0.0320137106,
0.033506915,
-0.0420109741,
-0.0090177627,
-0.0414464101,
-0.0322864838,
-0.042154748,
-0.0109419813,
0.0598282032,
0.0386443809,
-0.0918982252,
0.0007659064,
0.0337993577,
-0.0503786728,
0.0118552539,
-0.00165981,
0.0173285082,
-0.0043619238,
0.0094028339,
0.0050649652,
-0.0874355957,
0.0035298415,
0.0169461444,
0.0431151688,
0.0155600272,
-0.0202655252,
-0.0066238586,
0.0512484051,
-0.0394387841,
-0.0280047692,
-0.0255076829,
0.004964259,
0.0250597354,
-0.0199244395,
0.0647352412,
-0.0246442892,
-0.0422393009,
0.0212421175,
-0.0331024453,
-0.0103646275,
0.0319578648,
-0.0098453686,
-0.0016002295,
-0.0064863344,
-0.0022673334,
-0.0132789696,
-0.0483863875,
-0.0232201107,
0.0445336476,
-0.019824313,
-0.025507817,
0.0292270724,
2.704e-7,
-0.0334736928,
-0.0034098323,
0.0130948555,
-0.0526909605,
0.0195384789,
0.0436555222,
0.0218953621,
0.0375914611,
-0.0223680306,
-0.058763884,
-0.0114360815,
0.056702517,
0.0710121915,
0.0221183375,
-0.0486551933,
-0.0079772584,
-0.0310139246,
0.0615129396,
-0.0082393363,
-0.0264938083,
-0.0090242699,
0.0412218124,
0.0164367631,
-0.0549691916,
0.0243338142,
-0.0118108764,
0.0124672363,
-0.0015141878,
0.034566097,
-0.0272915307,
0.0304136649,
0.0063755875,
-0.0503009334,
0.0122724641,
0.0029542188,
0.0344922841,
0.0209870301,
0.0181450397,
-0.0013306213,
-0.017074652,
-0.043844685,
0.0464366339,
-0.0330720432,
-0.0147825256,
0.0914290398,
-0.0161580369,
-0.0289578494,
-0.052995,
-0.0069589033,
-0.0351952724,
0.0310832635,
0.0143571906,
0.0318495929,
-0.012614931,
-0.024335172,
-0.0392303765,
-0.0543951765,
-0.0520698093,
-0.0027735264,
0.0008189895,
-0.0261958372,
-0.0180682261,
-0.0751103088,
-0.0284603108,
0.0033084271,
-0.0022447198,
0.0262280628,
1.359027131e-34,
-0.0052247345,
-0.0079354215,
0.009722271,
0.0184344817,
-0.0274690818,
-0.0354403369,
-0.0336729661,
-0.0132901669,
0.0273114946,
-0.0522779413,
-0.0281767976
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.02716v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.02716v1 | CFSum: A Coarse-to-Fine Contribution Network for Multimodal Summarization | 2023-07-06T01:46:00 | 2023-07-06T01:46:00 | Min Xiao, Junnan Zhu, Haitao Lin, Yu Zhou, Chengqing Zong | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Multimodal summarization usually suffers from the problem that the
contribution of the visual modality is unclear. Existing multimodal
summarization approaches focus on designing the fusion methods of different
modalities, while ignoring the adaptive conditions under which visual
modalities are useful. Therefore, we propose a novel Coarse-to-Fine
contribution network for multimodal Summarization (CFSum) to consider different
contributions of images for summarization. First, to eliminate the interference
of useless images, we propose a pre-filter module to abandon useless images.
Second, to make accurate use of useful images, we propose two levels of visual
complement modules, word level and phrase level. Specifically, image
contributions are calculated and are adopted to guide the attention of both
textual and visual modalities. Experimental results have shown that CFSum
significantly outperforms multiple strong baselines on the standard benchmark.
Furthermore, the analysis verifies that useful images can even help generate
non-visual words which are implicitly represented in the image. | [
0.0181534383,
0.0300358925,
0.0362809971,
0.0217452943,
-0.0090326276,
-0.0153870266,
-0.0018559382,
-0.0242549367,
-0.0396143124,
-0.0230337288,
-0.0183789674,
0.0067696529,
0.0302236397,
0.0247028712,
0.036387451,
-0.101901792,
0.0219282806,
0.0109688826,
-0.0419863649,
0.0028861668,
0.0586707294,
-0.013242661,
0.0154596129,
0.0275728516,
-0.0298570823,
0.0089386087,
0.0168373585,
0.0110656265,
0.065425165,
-0.0171763133,
-0.0348286442,
0.0009323693,
0.0296810213,
-0.0304362196,
0.0000019338,
-0.0114715332,
0.0053249877,
0.021067623,
0.0603850521,
0.0042051398,
0.0537519604,
-0.0085790595,
0.0201085955,
-0.0328897163,
-0.0214999914,
0.0486095399,
0.0695188046,
0.0756099224,
0.0941411704,
0.0177387204,
-0.037730407,
-0.0285968874,
0.0074802171,
-0.0384801291,
0.0110652428,
-0.0317328833,
-0.0164781138,
0.0109326383,
-0.0000860943,
-0.0262863934,
-0.0669822693,
0.0584685318,
0.0034861173,
-0.0023977957,
0.0170346592,
0.049889572,
-0.014390124,
-0.0036732852,
0.0101427967,
0.0785604194,
-0.0291504413,
0.0415520854,
-0.0245273542,
-0.0110899117,
0.009581401,
0.0043185763,
-0.0813532099,
0.0401567668,
-0.0117659084,
0.0313022509,
-0.0719044358,
0.0700054318,
-0.0242334865,
0.0266513154,
-0.0267406479,
-0.0641456023,
-0.0024950721,
0.0387051478,
-0.0429704674,
0.029163016,
-0.0745569021,
-0.0207059067,
0.0260676425,
0.0223198906,
0.0127536124,
-0.0176347848,
-0.0356803872,
-0.0429906063,
-0.0042751976,
-0.015304002,
0.0342333876,
-0.0003257435,
-0.0379201546,
0.082107842,
-0.0311195198,
-0.0073576514,
0.0019366661,
0.0142570445,
-0.0394447334,
-0.0397213921,
-0.0092812227,
0.0068721664,
-0.0374674574,
0.0351752266,
-0.0310018659,
-0.0645525455,
-0.0287370328,
-0.0038113629,
-0.026825713,
-0.0061001643,
0.0270590931,
0.0534580722,
-0.0168225858,
-0.015647525,
-0.0158683211,
0.0369840451,
-0.0607634895,
0.0121997334,
0.0084179724,
-0.0003545889,
0.0045218486,
0.0251674056,
0.0204645637,
-0.0124865584,
-0.0130106481,
0.0467312038,
-0.0544491597,
-0.0402842201,
0.0000880181,
-0.039859347,
-0.0597433858,
-0.0382448323,
-0.0007790421,
-0.0339245126,
-0.0023442348,
-0.0184149034,
-0.0066240742,
0.0056628343,
-0.0051203403,
0.0070677726,
-0.0506221838,
0.0439946353,
-0.0252621546,
-0.0197305828,
0.0092995465,
0.0172111839,
0.010097486,
0.0486657731,
0.0446012653,
0.0651377141,
0.0111295423,
0.0269194525,
-0.0331174806,
0.035095606,
-0.0067211161,
0.0043309196,
-0.039715033,
-0.064065516,
-0.0491257869,
-0.028903814,
0.0449326821,
0.0444681868,
-0.0304680392,
0.0178760514,
0.084057942,
0.0091888066,
0.0112750735,
0.0207248814,
0.0036108806,
0.0286436938,
0.0141129261,
0.0567128398,
-0.0338966437,
0.1041878909,
-0.023979811,
0.0156989694,
0.101254791,
0.0590214953,
-0.0403761938,
-0.0295011289,
0.0589012615,
-0.0017605032,
0.0141431438,
-0.0007100845,
0.0216907188,
0.0152687784,
-0.0475022271,
-0.0155169712,
-0.0068456326,
-0.0592014156,
0.0446749069,
-0.0106752459,
0.0017060479,
0.01034337,
0.0401517637,
-0.0409400053,
0.0005475571,
0.0144581366,
0.0300466884,
0.0194605738,
-0.001395024,
0.0194694269,
0.0182060041,
-0.0765461326,
-0.0611040741,
-0.0092385579,
-0.0027893393,
-0.0021682829,
-0.0461560339,
-0.0133148022,
0.0082985424,
0.0112195844,
0.0001377761,
0.0244192425,
0.0918875337,
0.0187170543,
-0.0318264626,
0.008208042,
0.0061700139,
0.0115521448,
-0.0092902062,
0.023069879,
0.0016344371,
-0.0333662815,
0.0089917611,
0.0272268113,
-0.0666273534,
-0.033494059,
0.01221311,
-0.0870513618,
0.0096601099,
0.0045721033,
-0.0255871974,
-0.0573861934,
0.0394470617,
-0.0497325249,
-0.0266043339,
-0.0541113801,
-0.0106835384,
0.0450393148,
0.06160108,
-0.0179445501,
0.0528306551,
-0.0230659693,
0.0028894495,
0.0290345717,
0.0027973943,
-0.0077732014,
-0.0088074422,
-0.0188607052,
-0.0196395088,
-0.0012004527,
0.0446988121,
0.0302070398,
-0.0179445073,
-0.0445725694,
-0.0087248133,
-0.0811899453,
-0.0373326093,
0.016883431,
-0.0080856876,
0.0038476088,
0.0145018464,
0.0166304205,
-0.0272982325,
-0.0259277932,
0.0455557816,
0.0226053558,
0.0084557962,
0.0079033924,
0.033591643,
0.0801099464,
-0.039845109,
-0.0183162689,
0.0396964587,
0.0425546691,
0.0059777778,
-0.0454348437,
0.0131079089,
-0.027272569,
-0.0249012373,
0.0049631721,
-0.0047009564,
-0.0359717607,
-0.0044789836,
-0.0285880417,
0.0808758289,
0.031669829,
0.0553947054,
-0.0190070439,
0.0069388649,
-0.0299588852,
-0.0185707211,
0.0020515332,
-0.0004783075,
0.0288991034,
0.0491002277,
-0.0108971158,
-0.0013658473,
0.0184289664,
0.0217828229,
0.0125439391,
-0.0364672691,
0.051814016,
0.0226212665,
-0.0188084692,
-0.0391275659,
0.0261029042,
-0.016721867,
-0.0216921307,
-0.0547503494,
-0.0051524127,
0.0131786149,
-0.0346669219,
-0.0238064602,
0.0031471667,
0.0277634002,
-0.0083524156,
0.0104858,
0.0216608196,
0.034913972,
-0.0114053814,
0.0020341589,
-0.0723305345,
-0.0295406058,
0.0731386766,
0.0007697754,
0.0658255517,
-0.0073798886,
-0.004461945,
-0.0482715666,
0.0250933431,
0.003452054,
-0.0671917647,
-0.0083232764,
0.0274703149,
-0.0094153155,
0.0347672105,
-0.0544101335,
0.0337165296,
0.0425145812,
0.016757464,
-0.0245264228,
-0.0111653302,
0.0022016503,
0.0757720023,
0.0348577425,
0.0762522593,
0.0045987135,
-0.038203951,
0.009656922,
0.0446518511,
-0.0063658413,
-0.0290559251,
-0.0138335964,
0.0301173385,
-0.0028923796,
0.0284062605,
0.0371598415,
0.0260355286,
0.0865631029,
-0.0484343171,
0.0309528373,
0.0201535486,
-0.0146481274,
-0.0639045462,
-0.0418924168,
0.0319892541,
0.0018002944,
0.030871857,
-0.0236813668,
-0.0325746536,
-0.0581609048,
-0.0296051726,
-0.0198210999,
0.0367576778,
-0.0094355624,
-0.049543798,
-0.045608554,
0.0526575819,
0.0273499545,
-0.0630126074,
-0.004459057,
0.021385612,
0.0288938768,
0.0196510889,
-0.0252377968,
-0.0030742944,
0.0011562837,
-0.0166777112,
0.0076305536,
0.0113330586,
-0.0224240925,
-0.0621237978,
-0.0478949957,
-0.0258902255,
0.0629173145,
0.0339557491,
-0.0268069617,
0.005552507,
0.0745346248,
-0.06375999,
0.0181813855,
0.007484233,
0.0882214457,
-0.0037942082,
-0.0329260491,
-0.0287873559,
0.0109102027,
0.0379998311,
-0.0304150507,
-0.0183662344,
0.0139716426,
0.0125217158,
-0.0094065638,
-0.0694678128,
0.0716196075,
-0.0207675844,
0.0096681919,
0.0332378298,
-0.0263900794,
-0.0060783643,
0.0109964777,
-0.0023942725,
-0.0557747073,
-0.0181220639,
-0.0128202597,
-0.0167143829,
-0.001998724,
-0.0667718425,
-0.0180851389,
0.0257075708,
0.0119819278,
-0.0366958492,
0.0112664336,
-0.0301151648,
0.0213602055,
-0.0405447222,
0.0515569746,
-0.0260073319,
0.0120788347,
-0.0353680477,
0.022774877,
0.0150680095,
-0.0644522607,
-0.0156843904,
0.0219366848,
-0.048385188,
-0.0138930241,
-0.0409413874,
0.0915742442,
0.0085847499,
0.0166668817,
0.0290104244,
-0.0575633422,
0.0335794427,
0.045496773,
-0.0007679813,
0.0201529488,
0.009462907,
-0.0169640444,
-0.0458959118,
-0.0037189783,
-0.0611698031,
0.0493178032,
-0.0096796267,
0.047287479,
-0.004884358,
-0.0375924073,
-0.0123016452,
-0.0134723242,
0.0160330497,
-0.0352032296,
0.0528275408,
-0.0429826453,
-0.0544148646,
0.0140089681,
-0.0316406004,
-0.0583068244,
0.0260033347,
-0.0188114718,
0.0102156699,
-0.0107805487,
0.0554990023,
0.0075507229,
0.0067710248,
-0.04350245,
-0.0038160931,
0.0048060301,
-0.0536337495,
-0.0568512343,
0.0316293314,
-0.0179090761,
-0.0244675502,
-0.0272292607,
-0.0241290741,
-0.0205778256,
0.048326917,
0.0103560267,
-0.0093044033,
-0.0351014771,
0.0686220154,
-0.014447609,
0.0519088395,
-0.0764361769,
0.0416020378,
0.0717590749,
-0.0260432102,
0.0298043042,
0.0418399274,
-0.0036982435,
-0.0276651122,
0.0313430838,
0.0126692047,
-0.0103098108,
0.0224473029,
0.010146277,
0.0336622745,
-0.0049655624,
0.0585725009,
-0.0791284889,
-0.012346914,
-0.0055100024,
0.0049687838,
-0.0417700596,
-0.0315619297,
0.0030659775,
0.0608794689,
-0.0073675769,
0.0301390048,
-0.0238798298,
-0.0338370688,
-0.0002251287,
0.013636685,
0.0088326335,
-0.000862884,
0.0681007728,
-0.0231557544,
0.0094174538,
0.0210331734,
0.0127672479,
-0.0255460963,
0.0006814872,
0.0339277051,
0.0258365329,
-6.143190783e-33,
-0.0525764599,
-0.0318704471,
-0.0135955242,
0.0028911056,
-0.0458051041,
0.0233390573,
-0.045354519,
0.0320296437,
0.00290025,
0.0019940687,
0.0129645811,
-0.0171029363,
0.0128011927,
0.0225031842,
-0.0276891701,
0.0569325387,
0.0572573878,
0.0229812451,
-0.0242393538,
0.0378357247,
-0.0151355974,
-0.0143136932,
0.055611413,
-0.0486992002,
-0.0207088012,
-0.0070886975,
-0.0559630617,
-0.0275311731,
0.0405360945,
0.0440125465,
-0.008221522,
0.0132810576,
0.0283878632,
0.0041450411,
-0.0917885602,
-0.0093678748,
-0.0586548559,
-0.0188128967,
0.0355314761,
-0.0235675387,
-0.0768544823,
-0.02379,
0.0740498677,
-0.0459913835,
0.0334813967,
-0.0499529317,
0.0745632574,
-0.0448385924,
-0.0254283436,
-0.0302268453,
-0.0161403045,
0.0355292074,
-0.0375470258,
-0.0518727116,
0.0051612789,
0.0115642156,
0.0337718576,
-0.0055279988,
-0.006543037,
0.0439571328,
-0.0084943762,
0.0300820936,
0.0453168564,
0.0438182503,
-0.0245855749,
0.0477379039,
0.0131043959,
-0.0249678623,
0.0036599953,
-0.0233063903,
0.0278993789,
0.042893406,
0.0589230582,
0.0983545929,
0.0620272085,
0.048397582,
-0.0072054677,
0.0808525234,
-0.0526170023,
0.0482750572,
0.0395142175,
0.0134643521,
0.0668451786,
0.0132028824,
-0.0340935327,
0.0027730013,
-0.0535579249,
0.0210596286,
-0.0240023397,
0.0442367196,
-0.0144878821,
0.0194913093,
0.0864282101,
-0.0102322316,
0.0456683598,
0.0240098312,
-0.0109571982,
0.0496035181,
0.028725652,
-0.0446425341,
-0.02871041,
0.012968245,
0.0616797693,
-0.0246195104,
-0.025955027,
0.040000923,
0.0224487223,
0.011637127,
0.0061002243,
-0.0117898462,
-0.0047689658,
-0.0035550385,
-0.029469138,
0.0550129041,
0.0059167179,
-0.0221293103,
-0.0670120046,
0.0192799922,
-0.0458113067,
0.0083001414,
0.0007772785,
-0.0164984819,
0.0194065049,
0.0248027686,
-0.0160240941,
0.0336330086,
-0.0397899635,
-0.0312811024,
0.0492577739,
-0.0354838036,
-0.0320462175,
0.0415587053,
2.569e-7,
0.051621493,
-0.0232635252,
0.0283861496,
-0.0327367038,
-0.0071620853,
0.0300948359,
-0.0482226014,
0.0271407235,
0.0233550277,
0.0115532242,
0.0406703539,
0.0454508476,
0.0177443679,
-0.0019065291,
-0.0167555753,
-0.0078108921,
-0.0491319932,
-0.0175212789,
0.0128285149,
-0.0111214817,
0.0502450801,
0.0650585666,
-0.0356433392,
-0.0296125021,
0.0181384105,
-0.0549155362,
0.0869000107,
-0.0017514843,
-0.0178035237,
-0.0194926523,
-0.0015213492,
0.0062536532,
-0.0488659069,
-0.0305644572,
0.0086641619,
-0.0133359358,
0.0993481874,
0.0016107688,
-0.0194337461,
-0.0390723608,
0.0062527652,
0.0411373824,
0.0039391657,
0.0239297133,
0.0482074581,
-0.0707098544,
-0.0216042083,
-0.0214851424,
-0.0366016552,
0.0286892969,
-0.0155466693,
-0.0171594229,
-0.067582421,
0.0271635409,
0.0185354538,
-0.0030676113,
-0.0630125329,
-0.0873999149,
-0.0502419993,
0.0073611815,
-0.0173416212,
-0.0412179232,
-0.0385534577,
-0.037803527,
0.0223394148,
-0.0603168048,
-0.0496812649,
1.82886281e-34,
0.0625405237,
-0.0108346865,
-0.0007218963,
-0.0521623045,
0.0077489968,
-0.0046222149,
-0.0559690334,
-0.0066248183,
-0.0007542227,
-0.0556529313,
-0.0599985681
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.02697v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.02697v4 | Strahler Number of Natural Language Sentences in Comparison with Random Trees | 2023-07-06T00:06:14 | 2023-12-06T12:39:33 | Kumiko Tanaka-Ishii, Akira Tanaka | cs.CL | cs.CL, physics.data-an | The Strahler number was originally proposed to characterize the complexity of
river bifurcation and has found various applications. This article proposes
computation of the Strahler number's upper and lower limits for natural
language sentence tree structures. Through empirical measurements across
grammatically annotated data, the Strahler number of natural language sentences
is shown to be almost 3 or 4, similarly to the case of river bifurcation as
reported by Strahler (1957). From the theory behind the number, we show that it
is one kind of lower limit on the amount of memory required to process
sentences. We consider the Strahler number to provide reasoning that explains
reports showing that the number of required memory areas to process sentences
is 3 to 4 for parsing (Schuler et al., 2010), and reports indicating a
psychological "magical number" of 3 to 5 (Cowan, 2001). An analytical and
empirical analysis shows that the Strahler number is not constant but grows
logarithmically; therefore, the Strahler number of sentences derives from the
range of sentence lengths. Furthermore, the Strahler number is not different
for random trees, which could suggest that its origin is not specific to
natural language. | [
0.0222988911,
-0.0046345689,
-0.0274889059,
0.0116374064,
-0.0679491758,
0.0063211164,
-0.0313702039,
-0.0008185454,
-0.0299515408,
-0.0356165171,
0.0276923217,
-0.0931671113,
0.0267088674,
0.0043799025,
0.0012637338,
-0.0550556369,
0.0512088984,
-0.0564072281,
0.074223727,
0.0198952518,
-0.0243314542,
-0.0392513163,
0.0006381295,
-0.0094598606,
-0.0043616756,
-0.0348924771,
-0.0120525677,
-0.0364016965,
0.0065494613,
-0.0739232227,
-0.0636390075,
0.0223680269,
-0.0091368789,
0.0389767177,
0.0000018761,
-0.0690266863,
0.03595962,
0.0010372326,
-0.051555261,
-0.0024474722,
0.0473176725,
0.0059423973,
0.0097705806,
0.0093921851,
-0.0079309549,
0.0066350368,
-0.0168764666,
0.0666034743,
0.0101422183,
0.0662180632,
-0.0036503836,
-0.0691029578,
0.0657442436,
0.0149659226,
0.0217789374,
0.0054250062,
0.0211889539,
-0.0190508906,
0.0087625906,
-0.0097237891,
-0.0696783811,
-0.0046678064,
0.0384972356,
0.0097098835,
-0.0048000212,
0.0390660018,
-0.0720554963,
-0.0239739064,
-0.0051449742,
0.0000705959,
0.0165903177,
0.0121039338,
-0.0126579469,
-0.0083381031,
0.0338556692,
-0.0004583524,
-0.0274777599,
0.0398241878,
-0.0315302722,
0.0045631048,
0.0212181341,
-0.005097901,
-0.0155257676,
-0.077909939,
-0.0308115073,
0.0722834095,
-0.0032393376,
-0.039334286,
0.0503047556,
-0.0056653069,
-0.0287591368,
-0.0313643143,
-0.0216175504,
0.0062499242,
-0.0074504404,
0.0040922971,
-0.0340681151,
-0.024000518,
-0.0017299663,
-0.0570785217,
0.0439089537,
-0.0044332836,
-0.0168620814,
0.0583107285,
-0.0279483702,
0.0540119782,
-0.034816701,
-0.0258642584,
-0.0112829069,
0.000923191,
-0.0364983156,
-0.031065844,
-0.0373225473,
0.0280483849,
-0.0172178559,
-0.0563270338,
-0.045129355,
-0.0093109515,
0.003101273,
-0.0400636569,
-0.0582330935,
0.0065361685,
0.0185143426,
0.0311230123,
-0.0357298478,
0.0234315284,
-0.0451542139,
0.0069183162,
-0.0102099581,
-0.0312458538,
0.0059553026,
0.0382468328,
0.0243704002,
-0.0281749293,
-0.0046004313,
0.0073026186,
-0.001942295,
0.0206621215,
-0.0444521941,
-0.0593017898,
-0.0297706053,
-0.0241612345,
0.030393336,
-0.0683676079,
-0.0282772426,
0.0273817256,
-0.0193618294,
0.014164295,
0.0196445547,
0.0110061187,
-0.0526186042,
-0.005911571,
-0.0040537971,
0.0064771557,
0.0106761595,
-0.0361707099,
0.0704072565,
0.0462175831,
0.0559208766,
0.0346249379,
0.0582282543,
-0.0449087918,
0.0069965413,
0.0058108624,
-0.0603018329,
-0.0596916676,
0.0283378642,
-0.006700932,
-0.0270273071,
0.0126381284,
-0.0085378056,
0.0572257154,
-0.0225675069,
-0.03786714,
0.0070478166,
0.0660620481,
0.0192389693,
0.0640265346,
0.0365373343,
-0.0189525355,
0.0396971889,
0.0655498579,
-0.0128752543,
0.0437734462,
0.0062127695,
0.0192380659,
-0.0285737123,
-0.0067404378,
-0.0045654541,
-0.0350646228,
-0.0084330803,
0.0047814925,
0.0116690202,
-0.0637881458,
0.0284649357,
-0.0070633693,
-0.0246155672,
0.066497393,
-0.0286130551,
-0.0111369388,
-0.0036813957,
0.0247217715,
-0.0315936916,
0.0288123507,
-0.0117129497,
-0.0439845882,
0.0399540141,
-0.0096003618,
0.0289719906,
0.0161184166,
0.029637238,
0.0341434889,
0.0221025832,
-0.0100998925,
0.0131564289,
-0.0439017303,
0.0425565504,
-0.0083848629,
-0.0325830355,
0.0283397455,
-0.0207399055,
0.0041838153,
-0.0218179896,
0.0178965032,
0.0134751843,
-0.0050544674,
-0.0270750169,
-0.0201444793,
0.0260329731,
0.0043135365,
-0.0234951731,
0.0566603914,
0.0334330425,
-0.0492690355,
-0.0028463795,
0.0395993069,
-0.0513455048,
-0.0126751754,
0.0275584962,
-0.0392136127,
-0.0215810705,
0.0541761592,
0.023406025,
-0.0336436145,
0.0262217186,
-0.1026789919,
0.0717329532,
0.0126099242,
0.0682466999,
-0.0255973618,
0.022954667,
0.0175552703,
0.08026357,
-0.0140974885,
0.0586093478,
-0.046681419,
-0.045638524,
0.0367226191,
-0.0373053625,
-0.0094064213,
-0.0532933138,
-0.0168080535,
-0.0339753181,
0.0439034179,
-0.0143459244,
-0.0716629252,
-0.0400167517,
-0.0313895307,
-0.053762909,
-0.0108405687,
0.0603861958,
0.0101862084,
-0.0162637252,
0.011210504,
0.0088491617,
0.002765086,
0.0219964683,
-0.0030872955,
0.0645707175,
0.0651049912,
-0.0247058272,
-0.0685265735,
-0.0150239831,
0.0044335993,
-0.0382675231,
0.0568765402,
0.0650319159,
-0.0917588398,
-0.0347114205,
0.0613228977,
-0.0192600526,
-0.0166420545,
-0.013764956,
-0.0175135843,
0.0435303748,
0.0097270105,
0.0919603482,
0.0777845755,
0.0309053436,
0.0556247681,
0.0211521219,
-0.0074766902,
0.0120906755,
-0.0183875225,
-0.0376680382,
0.0276583601,
-0.0506701767,
-0.0302366745,
0.0554137044,
0.082417883,
0.016654199,
0.0214965679,
0.0109898848,
-0.0258501079,
-0.0227352995,
-0.0192667507,
-0.0051579997,
-0.0173990447,
-0.041271586,
0.0412484929,
-0.0141667007,
0.0070762467,
0.0485635735,
0.0107610151,
-0.0002379997,
-0.0177894514,
0.0132918181,
-0.0381816551,
0.0800481662,
0.052385956,
0.0011168123,
0.0257241987,
-0.0247537047,
-0.0258473605,
-0.0064854501,
0.0347683467,
0.0021129944,
-0.0192114171,
-0.0452287197,
-0.0092156809,
-0.0140800178,
-0.0314012058,
0.0142114526,
-0.0684952289,
-0.0142660672,
0.0150874015,
0.0624301843,
0.0122369966,
-0.0299720429,
-0.0172473621,
0.0769798085,
0.0160602871,
-0.0081535587,
-0.0316636674,
0.0218258072,
0.0746987611,
0.0233721659,
0.0297870841,
0.0635955408,
-0.020532323,
0.0399916396,
0.0521850884,
0.0017808175,
0.0650832281,
0.0156841651,
0.0240879953,
0.0027137548,
-0.0050382214,
-0.0724171549,
0.0384022705,
0.033694528,
-0.0402795523,
-0.0406048223,
0.0867556632,
0.0419179909,
0.0106486501,
0.0188585762,
-0.0757637098,
0.012925854,
0.0409336686,
0.0042371876,
-0.0437527709,
0.0018991943,
-0.0387905464,
-0.0218219683,
-0.0208253786,
-0.0298760217,
-0.0088147148,
-0.1026341021,
-0.0061490913,
-0.0103299962,
-0.0550517589,
-0.0043478706,
0.020317886,
-0.0510176755,
0.0514506474,
-0.0528212264,
-0.007874269,
-0.0220044944,
0.0126225529,
0.027660558,
-0.0902986526,
0.0034632923,
0.00485167,
0.0028177379,
0.006409396,
0.0063079246,
0.0426087193,
-0.0578176118,
-0.0208966695,
0.0642454401,
0.0034613197,
0.0469006449,
0.012342005,
0.0424835645,
0.0408311784,
0.001194399,
-0.0683192909,
-0.0223000776,
-0.0191791616,
0.0221044496,
0.0134615283,
0.0661398843,
0.0241201334,
-0.0795589909,
0.0141533921,
0.0192886703,
-0.0609842874,
0.0440316014,
0.0399403311,
-0.0081086103,
-0.061403852,
-0.0363847576,
0.0325981379,
-0.0272837915,
-0.0197762549,
0.0340967998,
0.0452779382,
-0.0117193982,
-0.0397602096,
-0.0027809509,
0.0138133075,
0.0454227105,
-0.0253484622,
0.04227053,
0.0654146671,
-0.0177608263,
0.0064815981,
-0.0152724721,
-0.0018464063,
0.0084840553,
-0.0692124292,
0.0036814949,
0.026198525,
-0.0051266118,
-0.0115769515,
-0.0408188365,
-0.0521039665,
-0.0508509725,
0.05508551,
0.0024472999,
0.0281386096,
-0.0412212685,
0.029800633,
-0.0210568439,
-0.0674711838,
0.0463114567,
-0.0682907477,
0.0711719766,
0.0062865675,
0.0104172658,
0.0148410294,
0.016429808,
-0.0084156385,
-0.015999293,
0.0044892216,
0.0230359659,
-0.0242850482,
-0.0058160964,
0.0374256335,
0.0691128001,
-0.000509734,
0.0355453566,
-0.0052532689,
0.0124904551,
-0.0017712087,
-0.0206262469,
-0.005867952,
-0.0108507304,
-0.0138710812,
0.0003797907,
0.0173990205,
-0.0617741086,
0.020269921,
0.0476693809,
-0.0088025918,
0.0002240831,
-0.0158862192,
0.0971185192,
-0.0113493651,
-0.0328485817,
-0.0017737912,
-0.0430210084,
-0.0128931887,
-0.0174004827,
0.0777556971,
0.034248963,
0.0352282338,
-0.0161474962,
0.0034269784,
-0.0274224319,
-0.0049998802,
-0.0903689787,
-0.0323754847,
0.0577151105,
0.0006827859,
0.035668131,
0.0031661196,
0.0434586219,
-0.0285447054,
0.0047410177,
-0.0107065178,
0.0101647926,
0.0186790824,
-0.0329869054,
-0.0442639962,
0.0373501368,
-0.0322258249,
-0.0004574317,
0.0688958764,
0.0353779905,
-0.0163886491,
0.0257600471,
-0.0722796395,
-0.014584396,
-0.0091828452,
-0.0314271748,
0.0162218716,
0.0352649987,
0.0044448739,
-0.0965175256,
-0.04834795,
0.0248877816,
0.000794169,
0.0658385009,
-0.0259801764,
0.0063073831,
0.0338855833,
-0.0105421208,
-0.0079927687,
-0.0089505175,
0.0433058925,
-0.0049207811,
0.0485324264,
-0.052435033,
-5.728962002e-33,
-0.0295182355,
-0.0145797245,
-0.011201513,
0.0074075987,
-0.0027292666,
-0.038098745,
-0.0367157124,
0.0308406632,
-0.0265618693,
0.0448898375,
0.0099952603,
-0.0004587417,
0.0121770641,
-0.0147011587,
0.0641483068,
0.0105538182,
0.0032058838,
-0.0244612657,
-0.0417826809,
-0.0205046255,
0.096201241,
-0.0005053272,
0.0528100617,
-0.0067301206,
-0.0091184434,
-0.0070749214,
0.0549864657,
0.014843652,
-0.0007354433,
0.0057959217,
0.0150087336,
0.0456270017,
0.0605268031,
-0.0838744938,
-0.0201752968,
0.00439328,
-0.0535627306,
-0.0955247059,
0.0107300291,
0.0035997387,
-0.0274895988,
0.0006314833,
0.0422577076,
-0.0335157141,
0.0043076677,
0.0029845219,
0.0460753515,
-0.0080282679,
-0.0368079059,
-0.0583807565,
-0.0452318899,
-0.0102771791,
-0.0002357167,
0.0163719002,
-0.0408486873,
0.0081791375,
-0.0274548307,
-0.0264326297,
-0.0155893555,
0.0238671284,
-0.0057796137,
0.0378034674,
-0.0140745454,
-0.0193183441,
0.0252988115,
0.0644972324,
0.0640185252,
0.0136218444,
-0.0131927505,
0.0565670393,
-0.0048843753,
0.034106493,
0.0628272668,
0.0362464562,
0.0882930234,
0.0053189304,
-0.060357701,
-0.0380604938,
0.0497707836,
0.0728947148,
0.0191463046,
-0.0206379611,
-0.0464141518,
-0.0499826372,
0.0281242356,
0.0338562168,
-0.0093909949,
0.0286398195,
0.0246473867,
-0.0199056808,
0.0216208808,
-0.0135891447,
0.009100752,
-0.0022093235,
-0.0322308131,
0.0121330461,
0.026731709,
0.0466544144,
-0.003147336,
0.0193975605,
-0.0296296403,
-0.0216912106,
-0.0589137822,
0.0257420633,
0.0502275638,
0.0095681883,
0.0161256008,
-0.0120673636,
-0.0609439276,
-0.0108541027,
-0.0154963359,
-0.0325426608,
0.0359907001,
0.0175245441,
0.0226026122,
-0.0146306008,
-0.014391426,
-0.0127905915,
0.0040248744,
-0.0043279659,
-0.039698299,
-0.0149172377,
-0.0024779716,
-0.0101688085,
0.018286299,
-0.0357164592,
-0.0483530834,
0.057625372,
-0.0096084978,
-0.0207689051,
-0.009889788,
0.0211883821,
2.718e-7,
0.0306771211,
0.0396158881,
0.016513573,
-0.0096668759,
0.0614376776,
-0.0068790126,
-0.021561075,
-0.0060251853,
-0.0066783065,
-0.0426207557,
-0.0328737237,
-0.0036851848,
-0.0059074,
0.0371453762,
-0.0631508529,
0.0106019489,
-0.0797457173,
0.0221271887,
0.0045791389,
-0.0090863481,
0.0568278953,
0.023161985,
-0.0294695552,
0.0223984085,
-0.049619168,
-0.0508657619,
0.0402842201,
-0.0068816836,
0.0385102481,
-0.0099054882,
-0.0005478627,
-0.0105377706,
-0.021785453,
0.037023358,
0.0257570613,
0.0079824775,
-0.0262725949,
0.01719529,
-0.0067632725,
0.0267550442,
0.0424516425,
-0.0146220308,
-0.0290845521,
-0.002785658,
0.0183292516,
-0.0643697008,
-0.0518145971,
0.0474295393,
0.0095518921,
0.0045692218,
0.0276382938,
0.0476990491,
-0.0063213487,
-0.0520225093,
0.0061111893,
-0.0463138521,
0.0152490642,
-0.0469873808,
-0.0103819259,
-0.0023109352,
-0.0176496636,
-0.0609829836,
-0.0503173247,
0.0454381257,
0.0469166227,
-0.0628945008,
-0.0223673582,
2.382957097e-34,
0.0425663702,
-0.0046659848,
0.0366535336,
-0.0130812582,
0.0139725823,
-0.0111469114,
0.0133008584,
0.0143760266,
0.0364304297,
-0.0776321068,
-0.0340477154
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.02690v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.02690v1 | Scaling In-Context Demonstrations with Structured Attention | 2023-07-05T23:26:01 | 2023-07-05T23:26:01 | Tianle Cai, Kaixuan Huang, Jason D. Lee, Mengdi Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The recent surge of large language models (LLMs) highlights their ability to
perform in-context learning, i.e., "learning" to perform a task from a few
demonstrations in the context without any parameter updates. However, their
capabilities of in-context learning are limited by the model architecture: 1)
the use of demonstrations is constrained by a maximum sentence length due to
positional embeddings; 2) the quadratic complexity of attention hinders users
from using more demonstrations efficiently; 3) LLMs are shown to be sensitive
to the order of the demonstrations. In this work, we tackle these challenges by
proposing a better architectural design for in-context learning. We propose
SAICL (Structured Attention for In-Context Learning), which replaces the
full-attention by a structured attention mechanism designed for in-context
learning, and removes unnecessary dependencies between individual
demonstrations, while making the model invariant to the permutation of
demonstrations. We evaluate SAICL in a meta-training framework and show that
SAICL achieves comparable or better performance than full attention while
obtaining up to 3.4x inference speed-up. SAICL also consistently outperforms a
strong Fusion-in-Decoder (FiD) baseline which processes each demonstration
independently. Finally, thanks to its linear nature, we demonstrate that SAICL
can easily scale to hundreds of demonstrations with continuous performance
gains with scaling. | [
-0.0037019129,
0.0530620404,
0.0223457906,
0.0362960063,
0.0038098067,
-0.0060995547,
0.0323885605,
-0.0235286187,
-0.0126699889,
-0.0399745926,
-0.0473226011,
-0.0203213654,
0.0182282608,
0.0129501866,
0.0331503861,
-0.0667920932,
0.0196269099,
-0.0351297148,
-0.0220599361,
0.0196244773,
-0.0021684084,
-0.018597899,
-0.0279280171,
0.0460535437,
-0.0082851481,
-0.0126822516,
-0.0277608559,
0.008740033,
0.0282865632,
-0.0471249223,
-0.0002845582,
0.0427318364,
0.0684103444,
0.0349053703,
0.0000018688,
0.0085581588,
0.0400302745,
0.0017552471,
-0.0246263184,
0.0419311896,
0.0349211283,
-0.0067583579,
-0.014083405,
0.030193802,
-0.0252823271,
-0.0379917957,
0.0173760448,
0.007745571,
0.0488341674,
0.0767057464,
0.0145324748,
-0.0240197293,
0.0194099229,
-0.0657497272,
-0.0281485934,
-0.0264465138,
-0.0004353345,
-0.0518023483,
0.0416999385,
0.01622908,
-0.0365432836,
0.0601255596,
0.0744667873,
0.024981549,
0.0022586498,
0.0536803752,
-0.0547745563,
0.0257865861,
-0.0377819315,
0.0621508583,
-0.0345315374,
-0.0182937346,
-0.0119192516,
0.0025794937,
0.0195850339,
-0.0415493697,
-0.0383853205,
0.0222917087,
0.0221465789,
0.0059691533,
0.0092790825,
0.0481683798,
0.0398802906,
-0.0047109528,
-0.0250919107,
0.0128755048,
-0.0171129834,
-0.0440037958,
-0.0227425564,
0.0079208333,
-0.0263363756,
-0.0412306413,
-0.0091978917,
0.0127672441,
-0.0745265633,
0.0208931267,
-0.0572284795,
-0.0538064465,
-0.0139788333,
-0.0459894948,
0.0406988487,
0.0294453632,
0.0242617,
0.0676075369,
0.0061896299,
0.0672048181,
-0.019361617,
0.0517484322,
-0.0421059355,
0.0277161226,
-0.0281616915,
0.0176200457,
-0.0484377593,
0.0042801141,
-0.0552261509,
-0.051022619,
0.0000653217,
0.0387934484,
-0.0130167473,
0.0108499927,
-0.0102973366,
-0.0049995156,
-0.049420625,
-0.0240095258,
0.0492422841,
0.0388165154,
-0.0248509981,
0.0164368134,
0.0310818274,
-0.0456543081,
-0.0500279367,
0.0239771102,
0.0019718192,
-0.0067683766,
-0.0101152128,
0.0374727845,
-0.0381848812,
-0.0905442685,
-0.0078337835,
0.0302667748,
0.0089934394,
-0.0518037155,
-0.0070749107,
-0.0524553917,
0.0568136647,
-0.006671357,
0.0123550668,
-0.0208878368,
0.0102519998,
0.0268982146,
0.0102047352,
0.0426697284,
0.0379071161,
0.0185625181,
0.0023011281,
0.0023569739,
-0.029993685,
0.0777452067,
0.0278529339,
0.0206595995,
-0.0160813332,
0.029934546,
0.0008549349,
0.0354646705,
0.0507812425,
0.0493853539,
-0.0282264668,
0.0047831698,
0.0076556373,
0.0524338558,
0.0306686908,
0.0333787501,
-0.046096202,
0.0109146293,
0.0828743055,
0.0441428646,
-0.0081794932,
-0.0216719974,
0.0192948282,
0.0093992501,
0.0112057263,
-0.0317473821,
-0.0882458612,
0.0130070318,
0.0168077704,
0.0119172232,
0.0397159122,
0.0141794924,
-0.0510427244,
-0.02452101,
-0.0097110802,
-0.0093438113,
0.0114511559,
0.041951295,
0.0284268484,
0.0309054647,
-0.0697934628,
0.0264587197,
0.0039581796,
-0.0337090194,
0.0166813284,
-0.0403845459,
-0.0110088112,
0.0562106669,
0.0490115657,
-0.0172767621,
-0.0029292505,
-0.0291111413,
0.0612488687,
0.0640840456,
0.0001239712,
-0.0080326749,
0.0210180376,
-0.031744428,
-0.0146460766,
-0.0196264032,
0.0124948863,
0.0124583039,
0.0400466956,
0.0038407214,
-0.0229584835,
-0.0453652628,
0.0264787469,
0.0244532879,
-0.0387043282,
-0.0470721163,
-0.0154084461,
-0.0006257324,
0.0404901095,
-0.0036421712,
-0.0180320181,
0.00451052,
0.0448747799,
-0.052630417,
0.0473706387,
0.0117441341,
-0.0717750043,
-0.0999309495,
0.0044059101,
-0.0208583605,
-0.0377758332,
0.034324009,
-0.0385290571,
-0.0119765149,
-0.001448829,
-0.0353694409,
0.0837079883,
-0.0214952398,
0.0117012393,
0.0268494058,
-0.0055446182,
-0.0105947293,
0.0575454198,
-0.065515928,
0.0021022721,
0.0782506987,
0.0070549012,
-0.030810209,
-0.0398189276,
-0.0285990201,
0.0041203741,
-0.0067546568,
0.0433444194,
-0.0370555371,
0.024763165,
-0.0153525528,
-0.0166189298,
-0.0895222947,
0.01077569,
-0.0690935776,
0.0126763703,
0.0122043537,
0.0209631268,
-0.00399742,
-0.0341022275,
-0.0123821879,
-0.0437638685,
-0.0282083694,
0.0179565791,
-0.0249729734,
0.0270048715,
-0.0043890174,
-0.0061011314,
-0.0119378027,
0.032111574,
0.0774944201,
-0.0299518537,
0.0119610112,
-0.0504305512,
-0.0156816691,
0.0510973856,
0.0339799672,
-0.0230804421,
-0.0010286168,
0.0323316194,
-0.002591471,
0.0361885093,
0.1041389704,
0.0102716973,
0.038006831,
0.0253902804,
0.0222135913,
-0.0730750784,
0.0366345085,
0.0166421011,
0.0026561194,
-0.0488447696,
0.0174744986,
0.0279141106,
0.0416371077,
0.0052535059,
0.0259144288,
-0.0828857943,
-0.0420520119,
0.0004391804,
-0.0501315445,
-0.0383561812,
-0.0133376261,
-0.0531076789,
-0.0294853728,
-0.0335001573,
-0.0391812585,
0.0525571927,
-0.0134905865,
-0.0275974758,
-0.0295504238,
0.0026019458,
0.0007137434,
0.0333857648,
0.0019131438,
0.012669567,
-0.0576759651,
-0.0445460342,
-0.0244159102,
-0.0009691471,
-0.0217300486,
-0.0326382667,
0.0377707146,
-0.0347781703,
0.0138820866,
-0.009689589,
-0.0685793012,
-0.0520448349,
-0.0132117318,
-0.0178283062,
0.0145585658,
-0.0396644026,
-0.009387238,
-0.0464430787,
-0.0143191358,
0.0249844436,
0.059906844,
-0.0026310615,
0.0082155773,
-0.0319732204,
0.0047581396,
0.0219825301,
0.0252427142,
-0.0329023078,
-0.075412944,
-0.0049848449,
0.0705956519,
0.0741087645,
-0.007690758,
-0.0533896498,
-0.0300098341,
0.0266694278,
-0.0064784042,
0.0203174874,
0.0636213571,
0.0575343296,
-0.0801162347,
-0.0163124893,
0.0749238133,
0.0215516146,
-0.0562188663,
0.0027967154,
0.0368567929,
0.0285290834,
0.0125475507,
0.0229873154,
-0.041004356,
-0.0434785821,
0.0252763517,
0.0382251069,
0.0589359812,
0.0169160962,
-0.0204242058,
-0.1057038009,
0.0179896019,
0.0451991074,
-0.0503196269,
-0.0628969222,
-0.0350770503,
0.0071294159,
0.0181762259,
0.0360875577,
0.0430048481,
0.0010067875,
0.0011492908,
0.0202454906,
0.0157117695,
-0.1012179404,
0.0079942904,
-0.0361387543,
0.0254849717,
0.0355342552,
-0.005316162,
0.022229813,
-0.0772641674,
0.056491714,
-0.0022411656,
0.0038757988,
-0.0094751883,
0.042476669,
-0.0525826253,
0.0102977967,
0.0101697827,
0.0608648136,
-0.0472100526,
-0.0310929287,
-0.0016292275,
0.0948214158,
0.0138180517,
0.0216619167,
-0.0353972204,
-0.043614842,
0.0316171497,
0.0545738675,
0.043196138,
-0.0668212026,
-0.0151133742,
-0.0217897799,
-0.008719353,
-0.0363949835,
0.0136775319,
0.0233817287,
0.0406606607,
-0.0231137834,
-0.0305778738,
-0.0403555073,
0.024078805,
0.045336131,
-0.0214395765,
-0.007227656,
-0.0189506169,
-0.004663032,
-0.0440850519,
0.0502861701,
-0.0145427044,
0.0470330603,
-0.078685604,
0.0183497146,
0.0227066446,
-0.0125154508,
0.0024446102,
0.0379421189,
-0.0988270566,
-0.0598068908,
-0.0103500728,
0.0469450057,
0.0096787196,
0.0686599389,
-0.0203675888,
-0.03766964,
0.0642844215,
0.0290109813,
-0.0147321885,
0.0411244407,
0.0415654369,
-0.0192485563,
-0.007484775,
0.0330274105,
-0.0303860027,
-0.0283857267,
0.0111958683,
0.0348388366,
-0.0499902628,
-0.0039005282,
0.0112320157,
-0.0532394759,
0.0592857487,
-0.0158704408,
-0.0049147583,
-0.0157899782,
0.0313975848,
0.0061529069,
-0.0055090757,
-0.0457835607,
-0.0004897816,
0.0100962892,
-0.0034570212,
0.0028016625,
0.0154431937,
0.0360109247,
-0.0000449068,
-0.0046537733,
0.0388842262,
0.009445861,
-0.023635434,
0.039497368,
0.0114547722,
-0.0276031476,
-0.0179310292,
-0.0271675549,
0.0183273237,
-0.0147328768,
0.0187420193,
0.060037937,
-0.0303083397,
-0.0031925039,
0.0289991554,
-0.0557768829,
-0.0029516921,
-0.0358836986,
0.0227244012,
0.03921514,
0.0230758358,
0.0114757251,
-0.004323747,
-0.0057431399,
-0.0208023321,
0.0322228186,
-0.0376857407,
-0.0550238304,
0.0153102214,
0.0292581283,
0.0302907322,
0.0176647026,
0.0506199151,
-0.0057450454,
0.007726626,
0.0153281474,
0.0295212269,
-0.0575746708,
-0.0314158723,
0.0088376701,
0.0580607839,
-0.0161945913,
0.0397610813,
-0.0299555752,
-0.0429390743,
-0.0115982303,
0.0168541875,
-0.0401390009,
-0.0399567485,
0.0455350243,
0.0076546487,
-0.0277955811,
-0.0506459102,
-0.0076196934,
-0.0123997219,
0.0678195506,
-0.0607259385,
-0.0147166234,
-5.991489196e-33,
-0.0088020125,
-0.009760648,
0.0197583903,
-0.0454886556,
-0.0413640626,
0.0006096767,
-0.0403529741,
0.0169696249,
-0.0103863683,
-0.0047501563,
-0.0434486568,
0.0164413955,
-0.0024043105,
0.0531475991,
-0.0059054135,
-0.0021479565,
0.057286188,
-0.0234059598,
-0.0338841304,
0.0183375012,
0.0094381506,
0.0205038302,
0.0315863118,
-0.0277520791,
-0.0042099725,
0.0111091575,
-0.0310585741,
0.0047768769,
-0.0404262953,
0.0301019177,
-0.0066618826,
0.0291935969,
0.0092961546,
-0.0266252179,
-0.0513070524,
0.0251428615,
-0.0658264831,
-0.0078294622,
-0.0209228229,
0.0430606753,
-0.0763126537,
-0.0004272507,
0.051778134,
0.0088027548,
0.0047448999,
-0.0406561196,
0.0023954911,
-0.0135045825,
-0.0487906523,
-0.0175980274,
0.0109235784,
0.0271684378,
0.0169625171,
-0.0358917005,
0.0257848222,
0.0315207578,
-0.0114807505,
-0.0064419685,
-0.0574764237,
0.0147862211,
0.0332609564,
0.0313373804,
0.0586669333,
0.045451995,
0.0003661927,
0.0416046306,
-0.0280578583,
0.0002872611,
0.0136826644,
-0.0467543192,
0.0244162809,
0.0332208611,
0.0334557332,
0.0260520019,
0.04881249,
0.0223874468,
-0.0213602819,
-0.0144029548,
0.0313879251,
0.0248264782,
0.0513028353,
0.0400736593,
-0.0673403069,
-0.0158198588,
-0.0269797929,
0.0016197375,
-0.0185182411,
-0.0326624922,
0.0754304379,
0.0627725273,
-0.0030707561,
0.0059132581,
0.0670703426,
-0.0399258099,
-0.0149248727,
0.0521400198,
0.0215238445,
0.0627910644,
-0.0013874646,
0.0140193589,
-0.0728125572,
-0.0085784132,
0.0218166076,
0.0153277973,
-0.0164491776,
-0.0134174069,
0.0451410748,
0.0456161499,
-0.0705028921,
-0.0073588821,
-0.0137728825,
0.036468979,
0.0143043054,
-0.0001591804,
0.0745677501,
0.0028426989,
-0.0191015396,
0.0724261925,
-0.0352380499,
-0.0658297911,
-0.0133059835,
0.0174797606,
-0.0226289965,
0.0181377921,
-0.0134695219,
0.0234548971,
-0.0603922345,
0.0447957702,
0.0316616036,
-0.052739393,
-0.0126060145,
0.0341837257,
2.539e-7,
0.0069820764,
0.0070149745,
0.0060369992,
0.0192515608,
0.0337653346,
0.0193721112,
-0.0133965565,
0.0602424331,
0.0024379024,
-0.0089770481,
0.0014453058,
0.0572754294,
0.0564670451,
0.0048798351,
-0.1027903855,
-0.0206147153,
-0.0754183903,
0.0410628989,
-0.0403938368,
-0.0426125936,
0.0010149877,
0.1068327278,
0.0127357719,
0.018496884,
0.0313727446,
-0.0282565523,
0.0598190948,
-0.0062286537,
-0.009802362,
-0.0169139542,
-0.0565579049,
0.0064492198,
-0.0275244154,
-0.0024797779,
-0.0197415724,
0.0288743731,
-0.0000549011,
0.0624104887,
-0.0129751023,
-0.018700283,
0.0142844096,
-0.0024073152,
-0.0192680974,
-0.014929696,
0.0479165465,
-0.0792430788,
0.0082160821,
-0.0064328578,
-0.0113985892,
-0.0169276837,
-0.0012907886,
-0.0031395906,
-0.0103976717,
0.0019491811,
0.0184103251,
-0.0172392931,
-0.0023019912,
-0.0882610604,
-0.0469123535,
0.0010673234,
-0.0694640279,
-0.0239556506,
-0.0625952631,
0.0354879871,
0.0207409672,
-0.0520663485,
-0.0240148772,
2.217085431e-34,
0.0392958038,
-0.0203608125,
0.0323149636,
0.0233560894,
-0.0180696324,
-0.0425254256,
-0.0324203596,
-0.0053705988,
0.0759310126,
-0.0495785438,
-0.0184279773
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.02689v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.02689v1 | Learning Symbolic Rules over Abstract Meaning Representations for Textual Reinforcement Learning | 2023-07-05T23:21:05 | 2023-07-05T23:21:05 | Subhajit Chaudhury, Sarathkrishna Swaminathan, Daiki Kimura, Prithviraj Sen, Keerthiram Murugesan, Rosario Uceda-Sosa, Michiaki Tatsubori, Achille Fokoue, Pavan Kapanipathi, Asim Munawar, Alexander Gray | cs.CL | cs.CL | Text-based reinforcement learning agents have predominantly been neural
network-based models with embeddings-based representation, learning
uninterpretable policies that often do not generalize well to unseen games. On
the other hand, neuro-symbolic methods, specifically those that leverage an
intermediate formal representation, are gaining significant attention in
language understanding tasks. This is because of their advantages ranging from
inherent interpretability, the lesser requirement of training data, and being
generalizable in scenarios with unseen data. Therefore, in this paper, we
propose a modular, NEuro-Symbolic Textual Agent (NESTA) that combines a generic
semantic parser with a rule induction system to learn abstract interpretable
rules as policies. Our experiments on established text-based game benchmarks
show that the proposed NESTA method outperforms deep reinforcement
learning-based techniques by achieving better generalization to unseen test
games and learning from fewer training interactions. | [
0.0573959947,
0.0151063334,
-0.0314137936,
0.0368356258,
-0.0087696798,
0.0284966975,
-0.0117974142,
0.0068043252,
-0.0057902671,
-0.0238332413,
0.0211705938,
0.0118438434,
-0.0257701036,
0.0521808267,
-0.0048115682,
-0.0363424793,
0.0556703769,
0.0050720833,
0.1057201624,
0.014975545,
0.009384864,
0.0077399313,
-0.0130654993,
0.036576584,
-0.0252475496,
0.0054939496,
-0.0274622235,
-0.0435291342,
0.0145973656,
-0.0437245183,
-0.0220264364,
-0.0203398056,
0.0302758627,
0.0638191029,
0.0000017492,
-0.040979743,
-0.0250371378,
-0.0093843415,
-0.0005212882,
-0.0293835308,
0.0471755713,
-0.0574177802,
0.0159029402,
-0.0147226145,
-0.0482743084,
-0.027019795,
0.0392560847,
0.0475749895,
0.07421837,
0.0879406482,
0.0079179555,
-0.0333136171,
0.010967155,
0.001198714,
0.0138879865,
-0.0222932119,
-0.0081835343,
0.0264373682,
-0.0206628665,
-0.0255462285,
-0.0231024548,
0.0031495672,
0.0492738746,
0.0136246616,
-0.0280017704,
0.0716138035,
-0.0038629144,
0.0241780728,
-0.0307732392,
0.0695861056,
-0.0258693062,
-0.0008388865,
0.0193264391,
-0.0142917661,
0.0101833092,
-0.0099145724,
-0.0040271534,
0.0610464662,
0.0076625044,
0.0431414433,
0.0517537221,
0.0234175976,
0.022190664,
-0.010048816,
-0.0386180058,
0.0711494461,
-0.0415522158,
-0.0303633939,
0.0093483869,
0.0014941267,
-0.0236221794,
-0.0261385851,
0.0272863023,
0.0431879051,
-0.0287378561,
0.0320783965,
-0.0248530153,
-0.0166016649,
-0.0031224752,
-0.0416389592,
0.0340009406,
0.0876129195,
0.0333652683,
0.052685339,
-0.0221847426,
0.0127820661,
0.0196964778,
0.0661191791,
-0.0289533678,
0.0169199221,
-0.0607881807,
-0.0046414165,
-0.0541739389,
0.0584224313,
-0.0332232565,
-0.050285209,
-0.004519748,
0.0212584902,
-0.0087818876,
0.0633717105,
0.0042497804,
0.0077531729,
-0.0461110771,
0.0358938575,
-0.0623216592,
-0.015818743,
-0.0621639527,
-0.0137853613,
-0.0116308928,
0.013277553,
-0.0142087545,
-0.048418168,
0.0062789763,
-0.0124417003,
-0.0086678257,
0.0916512012,
0.0014179084,
-0.0120113101,
-0.0130333463,
-0.0434101447,
0.0269903895,
-0.0283434,
-0.0075407694,
-0.0421330482,
0.0403263681,
-0.0318361931,
0.0073239077,
-0.0555118285,
0.0096618459,
0.0178438947,
0.0356186032,
0.0393341482,
0.0075022248,
-0.0556451567,
0.0066516707,
-0.0057881293,
-0.0485436432,
0.0683287382,
0.0647796541,
0.0077770455,
-0.0052177906,
0.0377864912,
-0.0286728088,
0.021544693,
0.02095812,
-0.0107367812,
-0.0090941684,
-0.0074623823,
-0.0293053687,
0.0619250238,
0.008777217,
0.0216902494,
-0.0530971773,
-0.0520373136,
0.0076193283,
0.0520652533,
0.0143769803,
0.0017846731,
0.0983549953,
0.0192586426,
0.0157452468,
-0.0384388044,
-0.069242388,
0.0078062597,
-0.0056197769,
-0.0019694811,
-0.0803310201,
0.0002092631,
0.021177223,
-0.0510860868,
0.031451676,
-0.0240705777,
0.0425753444,
-0.0080878213,
0.036022909,
0.0072811353,
-0.0223877542,
-0.0072776079,
0.0271595083,
0.0020509905,
0.0106688002,
-0.0167142153,
0.0728150979,
0.0787278712,
0.0334234163,
-0.0733256713,
-0.0184842013,
-0.0491763167,
-0.015618315,
0.0684789568,
0.000797508,
-0.0412405804,
0.0335232839,
-0.0379210077,
-0.0107185747,
-0.0318024158,
0.0190409888,
0.0317100622,
-0.027230978,
0.001182753,
-0.0027004872,
0.0027442561,
-0.0197121762,
0.0736751109,
0.0075593698,
-0.0378247797,
0.0052201818,
0.0017304274,
0.0348242894,
0.0107398946,
0.0144646624,
-0.0145979207,
-0.0060450444,
-0.0203623176,
-0.03128222,
0.0147914067,
-0.0458414219,
-0.072436586,
0.0411358513,
-0.0394679569,
-0.020017758,
0.0368714146,
-0.0426180474,
-0.0080692014,
0.0126311937,
-0.0540228039,
0.0458904058,
-0.0088520823,
-0.040538501,
0.0080445558,
-0.043478895,
-0.0155250467,
0.0516928323,
-0.0284977071,
-0.0386137106,
0.0128185451,
-0.004546755,
-0.0003319113,
-0.0259711221,
-0.0145307519,
0.0130766537,
0.0041377842,
-0.0055103386,
0.0139906183,
0.0302751847,
-0.0480298251,
0.0004148547,
-0.0068839449,
0.0274226144,
-0.0032139923,
0.0211609676,
0.0375486873,
-0.0329483934,
0.0155996475,
-0.024064498,
-0.0431640185,
0.0232940167,
-0.0130137233,
-0.0070092608,
0.0624102578,
0.0323900431,
-0.0279605314,
-0.0188927334,
-0.0171930213,
-0.0710665956,
0.0430183411,
0.0077722138,
0.0497095175,
-0.0590647161,
-0.008234038,
-0.0222315751,
0.0441286005,
-0.0173275173,
-0.0323053859,
0.0413748994,
-0.0492384359,
-0.0505279638,
0.05207178,
-0.0154453628,
0.0683286786,
0.0491985381,
0.0029823163,
-0.0814961419,
0.0242347345,
-0.0221586693,
0.0384488665,
-0.076958999,
-0.0316278525,
0.0196964517,
0.079882443,
0.0030115319,
0.0174818058,
-0.0871102884,
0.0333180279,
-0.024017876,
-0.0527784042,
-0.0408479646,
-0.0031693445,
0.001649537,
0.0133325541,
-0.0275816228,
-0.0147857927,
0.1149619892,
0.0272417367,
-0.0214588996,
-0.0613415316,
-0.0264581069,
-0.0654537752,
0.066118747,
0.0158358999,
0.0245744307,
0.0058368933,
-0.0534544177,
-0.0176157914,
-0.0171140078,
0.0374457687,
0.0066459011,
0.0324120373,
-0.0046512024,
-0.0182781946,
0.0186967235,
-0.0069937203,
-0.0146526974,
-0.0511707179,
-0.0276669674,
-0.0044270097,
-0.0264203325,
-0.0042694071,
-0.0040126424,
-0.0368439145,
-0.0063774106,
0.0075140758,
0.006275712,
-0.0541229807,
-0.0541185252,
-0.0279409364,
0.046081569,
0.006869833,
-0.0030838251,
-0.0000484896,
0.0470345169,
0.0429045409,
-0.0229311269,
-0.0523779802,
-0.0544133112,
0.0399639979,
0.003209129,
-0.0802296028,
-0.0056688013,
0.0466923676,
-0.0145215141,
-0.0902222842,
-0.0066684415,
0.0995406583,
0.0526054762,
0.0064679058,
0.0347410813,
-0.0201616064,
0.022912439,
0.0190842245,
0.0539999306,
-0.0981423855,
-0.0334116034,
-0.0104414392,
0.0009011807,
0.0022305783,
-0.0505916812,
-0.0057597193,
-0.0650859475,
-0.0432791375,
-0.0010168633,
-0.0675569624,
0.041376736,
0.0096250465,
-0.0284987818,
-0.0650414303,
-0.0251192451,
0.0240000915,
-0.0063578459,
0.0137896668,
-0.0229547787,
0.018842686,
0.0228098854,
0.0152369011,
-0.0562582873,
0.0222421736,
0.0188248493,
0.0300252512,
-0.0324973054,
-0.0017154007,
-0.0036376638,
0.0183502436,
-0.009811365,
-0.0259452388,
0.0188513957,
-0.0311083123,
0.0186547302,
0.0014588672,
0.054257609,
-0.0131580038,
-0.0240516569,
0.0066566691,
0.0751734748,
0.0079928432,
-0.0273547657,
0.0063248272,
-0.0046620923,
0.025696151,
0.0520235971,
-0.0233890768,
-0.021846151,
-0.0725380108,
-0.0704785138,
-0.0149973901,
-0.0435235538,
-0.021594163,
-0.0152681284,
0.0256864671,
-0.0133924643,
-0.0743840113,
-0.0999676734,
0.0199748445,
0.0106344605,
0.0215027127,
-0.0294364598,
0.0300825201,
-0.0060816403,
0.0034270568,
0.0112601416,
-0.0306207109,
0.0041931667,
0.0283891931,
0.0039652223,
-0.0091122007,
-0.0377354845,
-0.0502734482,
-0.0210839007,
-0.0030225909,
-0.0328680836,
-0.0109161139,
0.0697510093,
0.0074519762,
0.047961697,
-0.0168573335,
-0.0006131003,
0.0335863903,
0.0129303942,
-0.054582864,
-0.0177936945,
0.059559159,
0.0414540283,
0.0534484163,
0.0247563217,
-0.0517016426,
0.0041117244,
-0.0465496741,
0.0573006496,
-0.0238750204,
0.0752732307,
0.0654184669,
-0.0095770294,
-0.0102655245,
0.0086308634,
-0.0437238067,
-0.0228898674,
0.0089007504,
-0.0423240289,
-0.0176771507,
-0.0227313377,
0.0109487185,
0.0108672976,
-0.0132024642,
-0.0134921921,
-0.0159555692,
0.0079826824,
0.0290701613,
-0.0039951024,
-0.0073095243,
0.0843943879,
0.0333283246,
-0.0200644154,
0.0053774132,
-0.0015748562,
0.0074152122,
-0.0191556029,
0.0303689763,
-0.0217446573,
0.0207604785,
0.0688105077,
-0.0269577149,
-0.0731327981,
-0.0207675658,
-0.0562694035,
0.0113389874,
0.0598816462,
-0.0429149941,
0.0413138345,
0.0137843098,
0.0181123838,
-0.0444637798,
0.0345164575,
0.0567488149,
0.0086063882,
-0.0225240234,
-0.0492832474,
0.0106235454,
0.0124599095,
0.0170681477,
-0.0413258895,
0.0369131342,
-0.0100112194,
0.0670560375,
-0.0134124449,
0.0104376953,
-0.039956674,
-0.009812722,
0.0130763091,
0.0753773749,
-0.043163579,
-0.0270044692,
-0.0464212261,
-0.004577009,
-0.0043178257,
0.0739557222,
0.0069471332,
0.0069639445,
0.0222131088,
0.0064552831,
0.0170483813,
-0.0460282825,
-0.0285766665,
-0.0111827273,
-0.0063628415,
-0.0363753214,
-0.0670995712,
-5.195279118e-33,
-0.011760857,
0.0079736244,
0.0661855638,
0.0213991124,
-0.0442245714,
-0.0209275112,
-0.045672711,
-0.0371770449,
0.0349423811,
0.0435738042,
-0.0008100467,
0.0131485192,
-0.0009497314,
0.0048763924,
0.016723847,
-0.0457214601,
0.022711888,
-0.0104420409,
-0.036093656,
-0.0079308702,
0.0578870401,
0.0268580131,
0.0257136878,
-0.0385089591,
0.026139522,
0.0541395135,
-0.0080542983,
0.0273902267,
-0.0153246615,
0.0667567179,
0.0142002339,
-0.0027405694,
0.0192626081,
0.0006536624,
-0.006787857,
0.0170693453,
-0.1104452163,
-0.0813892856,
0.0158544816,
0.0062343432,
-0.0465650856,
-0.0240518786,
0.0296211224,
-0.0302746389,
0.0375910401,
-0.0052687558,
0.0294200983,
-0.0064006485,
0.0036099046,
-0.0355699584,
-0.0717838854,
0.0018162152,
-0.0386857949,
0.0428059436,
0.0077014188,
0.0153414449,
0.0135839405,
0.0296873599,
-0.0497899018,
-0.0004042602,
-0.0352944247,
-0.0106499977,
-0.0073889992,
-0.0115623139,
0.002701072,
0.0476428494,
0.000804233,
-0.0165905375,
-0.0459848009,
0.0192073304,
0.0365239903,
0.0084612295,
0.0171291251,
0.0419205427,
0.0508558638,
0.0114437258,
-0.0697727725,
0.0323399007,
0.0629848018,
0.0789100081,
0.0043525058,
0.0333582871,
-0.06906569,
0.0262500588,
-0.0577354655,
0.0112261707,
-0.0099275373,
-0.0562349558,
0.0285686124,
-0.0043893447,
-0.0043019271,
-0.0189126246,
0.0086232265,
-0.0540354103,
-0.0022410348,
0.0428748205,
-0.00407555,
0.0196552612,
-0.0164201912,
0.0050123297,
-0.0166129172,
-0.0568798408,
0.0141401207,
-0.0285977758,
0.0289369877,
-0.0054564923,
0.0451350398,
0.047310736,
-0.0166849382,
0.0200431254,
-0.0224521719,
-0.0148332231,
0.0173408668,
-0.0055685118,
0.0233613886,
0.0083097909,
-0.0212611053,
0.0143926209,
0.0166875888,
-0.0259996224,
-0.021043472,
0.0438796021,
0.003038286,
0.0140148634,
-0.031885799,
0.0044902558,
-0.0279466081,
0.0588796698,
0.0193201713,
-0.0829601362,
0.007361115,
0.0365719348,
2.397e-7,
0.0207664818,
0.0372788161,
0.0172783341,
0.0555033758,
0.025570007,
0.020489011,
-0.0075991382,
0.0299368557,
-0.0231166761,
-0.0095687006,
0.0461145043,
0.0379501097,
-0.0107076513,
0.034991052,
-0.0731208026,
-0.0144114364,
-0.0382449105,
-0.0138629572,
-0.0299580451,
0.0134591162,
0.0816970915,
0.0852162912,
0.0519209206,
0.0036484636,
0.0206239875,
-0.0210669525,
0.0405765586,
-0.0396131724,
0.0508400388,
-0.0087547898,
-0.009107559,
-0.0072743488,
0.0131551065,
-0.0316429399,
0.0162814818,
0.0741080567,
-0.0404342711,
0.0588512905,
-0.0158176981,
0.0308129266,
-0.0086357892,
-0.0537988171,
-0.0037782812,
-0.0330486521,
0.0443706363,
-0.0791937858,
-0.0218385831,
0.0053469059,
-0.0282425247,
-0.053690698,
-0.0183719788,
-0.0197359938,
-0.0136137763,
0.0056818859,
-0.0071964185,
-0.0049700043,
0.0385230519,
-0.0479435809,
-0.0203561261,
0.0086781429,
-0.0068533085,
0.0214165282,
-0.0178219955,
0.0370406844,
-0.0047534001,
-0.0861510262,
-0.0218844675,
1.866130458e-34,
0.0076147341,
-0.0480226837,
0.0203607045,
0.0411895849,
0.032277856,
0.04146038,
-0.0033525014,
0.021903554,
0.0840445086,
-0.0504147075,
-0.0227033291
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.03691v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.03691v2 | Comparing Apples to Apples: Generating Aspect-Aware Comparative Sentences from User Reviews | 2023-07-05T23:19:18 | 2023-07-23T17:05:06 | Jessica Echterhoff, An Yan, Julian McAuley | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | It is time-consuming to find the best product among many similar
alternatives. Comparative sentences can help to contrast one item from others
in a way that highlights important features of an item that stand out. Given
reviews of one or multiple items and relevant item features, we generate
comparative review sentences to aid users to find the best fit. Specifically,
our model consists of three successive components in a transformer: (i) an item
encoding module to encode an item for comparison, (ii) a comparison generation
module that generates comparative sentences in an autoregressive manner, (iii)
a novel decoding method for user personalization. We show that our pipeline
generates fluent and diverse comparative sentences. We run experiments on the
relevance and fidelity of our generated sentences in a human evaluation study
and find that our algorithm creates comparative review sentences that are
relevant and truthful. | [
0.0550196953,
0.0290248767,
-0.0190903787,
0.0153166996,
-0.0265342295,
0.0065160375,
-0.0128814522,
-0.020202091,
-0.0498661846,
-0.0421924405,
-0.0246373545,
0.0305385198,
0.0042774845,
0.0487400219,
-0.0087305959,
-0.0692270771,
0.0120781884,
0.0123215979,
0.0215162113,
0.013550465,
0.02241081,
0.0336629041,
0.0156461168,
0.0385672636,
0.0087369448,
0.0012201747,
0.0118055576,
0.0000174035,
0.0550150014,
-0.0356255881,
0.0100520048,
0.0393579565,
-0.0397852361,
-0.0264809914,
0.0000019103,
-0.010511199,
0.010777087,
-0.0179785509,
0.0320760645,
-0.0268164463,
0.0952795595,
0.0270238183,
0.0237197559,
0.0083491867,
-0.0515708737,
-0.0402348451,
0.036718566,
0.0702380165,
0.0657041669,
0.0469492748,
-0.0254115723,
-0.0219199043,
-0.0171554908,
-0.0155109419,
-0.014383018,
0.0070614824,
-0.0490802079,
-0.0053987973,
0.0212155133,
0.064902164,
0.0024110356,
0.0084842686,
0.0258275643,
-0.0111531494,
0.0729073212,
0.0210825428,
0.0361416116,
0.0162368249,
-0.0182403047,
0.04831874,
0.0067846337,
-0.0110951914,
-0.0197205599,
-0.0226488318,
0.0304946601,
-0.0095448652,
-0.023853641,
-0.006327163,
-0.0128447721,
0.0308661312,
0.0005934337,
0.0864995047,
-0.0119922645,
-0.0152575737,
0.0149109587,
0.0313662551,
0.0050288653,
-0.0294791069,
-0.0086868266,
0.0498101898,
0.0518925525,
-0.0578719936,
0.0383399241,
-0.0022299825,
-0.0297250561,
-0.0369248204,
-0.035801746,
0.0143677676,
0.0104037998,
-0.0732012466,
0.0622773431,
-0.0107919341,
0.0035771199,
0.0072445441,
-0.021608321,
0.0484826006,
0.0039337543,
-0.0336759873,
-0.0979750305,
0.0264567845,
-0.0762750655,
-0.0230433531,
-0.0056717317,
0.0480400845,
-0.0448406525,
0.0054768394,
-0.07420367,
0.0040712035,
-0.0071842335,
-0.0080648744,
0.039783407,
0.0470362306,
-0.0130790379,
0.0120937461,
-0.0640773401,
0.0218392927,
-0.0750652477,
-0.0076324013,
-0.0027107538,
0.0030664171,
0.016056776,
0.0210206714,
0.0403282717,
-0.0320346691,
-0.0385544933,
0.0247347672,
-0.0173274577,
-0.0182929635,
0.0214737579,
-0.044575002,
-0.0004224532,
-0.0030858717,
-0.0437325127,
-0.0729027465,
0.0414196998,
0.0186008587,
-0.0036690044,
-0.0254275482,
0.0160548054,
0.0430282988,
-0.0334934629,
0.0331130885,
-0.0270837788,
-0.015650114,
-0.0298258942,
-0.0067267269,
0.0492867678,
-0.0071056737,
0.0007437901,
0.0727793872,
-0.0023599684,
-0.0135167204,
0.0365767404,
-0.0288607869,
-0.0635670498,
-0.0406915434,
-0.010480416,
0.0280697271,
-0.0658972114,
0.0343721882,
0.0091476515,
0.0611373074,
-0.0209736004,
0.0099697784,
0.078822501,
0.0223148633,
0.0216037408,
0.0642541796,
0.0472132526,
0.0453194305,
-0.0308364984,
0.0426188707,
0.0257241353,
0.0467363223,
0.0157666653,
-0.01065767,
-0.004793671,
0.0250496697,
-0.0061818101,
-0.0703224391,
-0.0057951463,
-0.0295846201,
0.0303634312,
-0.0237653404,
-0.0035378987,
0.0529117025,
-0.0492766723,
0.0107270712,
0.0190305486,
-0.0545683131,
-0.0120818159,
-0.0232922621,
0.0088656414,
0.135176301,
0.0210862271,
0.0413692631,
0.035093721,
-0.01412958,
-0.0733130798,
0.035308212,
0.0732262805,
-0.0207738187,
-0.0244706981,
-0.044132024,
-0.0262401197,
-0.0454373732,
-0.0113485614,
0.0130018732,
0.0089181066,
0.0238974337,
0.0404860303,
-0.0037924508,
-0.0109103508,
0.0017357593,
0.0314514115,
-0.0169162937,
0.0583074689,
0.0030457994,
-0.0147871003,
0.0446078964,
0.0171155725,
0.0279090889,
0.0006623332,
-0.0428551957,
-0.070280917,
0.0671230704,
-0.0399463437,
-0.0290672965,
-0.0387745574,
-0.0635806695,
0.0105350912,
0.011434867,
-0.0274898764,
-0.030438289,
-0.0218260586,
-0.0183506515,
0.0736700967,
-0.0054145264,
0.0200220607,
0.0241375137,
0.0007506885,
-0.0400665924,
0.0747173056,
-0.0004418347,
-0.0049103452,
-0.0399465598,
-0.0519001074,
-0.008303687,
-0.0155709749,
-0.0131253395,
0.0006435555,
0.0172736868,
0.0074488851,
0.0239981264,
0.0251397491,
-0.0162597764,
-0.0431408025,
-0.1022358909,
-0.0317993425,
0.020767441,
0.0114880875,
0.0290100016,
0.0046681776,
0.0310930721,
-0.0001982238,
-0.0510690473,
-0.0035731504,
0.0024716733,
0.0289170835,
0.0609938204,
0.0329292156,
0.0225421507,
-0.0633302256,
-0.0207395907,
-0.0175524373,
0.0717562214,
0.0220617857,
0.0269823298,
-0.0810814649,
-0.0074064536,
-0.035561651,
-0.0281188805,
0.0415763967,
-0.032029245,
0.0082803108,
0.01515867,
0.0636928678,
0.0248829238,
0.0277404673,
0.057843253,
0.046823781,
0.0045342734,
-0.0528704524,
-0.0094289733,
-0.0360704958,
0.0177115817,
-0.0410932526,
-0.0396253578,
0.0603639521,
0.0317214765,
0.0378260352,
0.031677559,
-0.0694757998,
0.0305368472,
0.0029999961,
-0.0138889886,
-0.0143671213,
-0.0246711187,
0.0137692941,
0.033924222,
-0.0063477918,
0.0059200535,
0.0953324959,
0.001541102,
0.0472076051,
-0.0227272455,
-0.0034956171,
-0.0371748917,
0.0356033854,
0.0087633338,
0.0339347124,
-0.0324936584,
-0.0038543609,
-0.0136198495,
0.0178976059,
0.0212627333,
-0.0332177766,
0.0263385065,
-0.0187013745,
-0.0369198844,
0.0080094133,
-0.0855530575,
-0.0195116159,
-0.0298613962,
-0.0326284654,
-0.0329790674,
0.0271577444,
-0.0095339194,
-0.0426089242,
0.0385836177,
-0.0331385359,
0.0253848638,
-0.0247481316,
-0.0256797336,
0.021268215,
0.0549977124,
0.0384228341,
-0.0404377095,
0.022594111,
-0.0096834255,
0.0478653647,
0.0604675896,
-0.0288898237,
-0.0107037285,
-0.0327686742,
-0.0405348167,
0.0036855729,
-0.0407321677,
-0.0008627056,
-0.0086199725,
0.0286723431,
-0.0296723451,
-0.0284448452,
0.0971818864,
0.0291558187,
-0.0544140562,
0.0163258314,
0.0109314965,
-0.005219894,
0.0078385808,
0.0526639894,
-0.0781173632,
-0.0062691406,
-0.0279938299,
0.0259841476,
-0.0104329884,
0.0198214855,
-0.0060824761,
-0.1033521071,
0.0048921299,
-0.0064705438,
0.0072813965,
-0.04307767,
0.0160174109,
-0.0274247974,
-0.0084945587,
-0.0204320531,
0.0174941253,
-0.0329657458,
0.0496648066,
-0.0273487456,
0.014023345,
-0.0127144102,
-0.0014739694,
0.0058736638,
0.0201330036,
0.0870232955,
0.0286673401,
0.0325669535,
-0.0292461962,
-0.0096557969,
-0.0324148387,
0.0393631123,
-0.0092825498,
0.0468508564,
0.0078536412,
-0.0003396627,
-0.0552823134,
-0.0075754416,
-0.0165153816,
-0.0041528,
0.0289973356,
-0.0005879593,
-0.0009458731,
-0.0230015311,
-0.0315175503,
0.0101570478,
-0.0058574509,
0.0731994286,
0.0252828021,
-0.0710682198,
-0.0242037103,
-0.0439054444,
-0.0130747408,
-0.0905537233,
-0.0620037168,
-0.0014464353,
0.0441363268,
-0.016257517,
-0.1308097243,
-0.0484366603,
-0.0168727115,
-0.0062415772,
0.0033863678,
-0.0394209847,
0.0045690881,
0.0050706198,
-0.0305428356,
-0.0125761172,
0.0139930854,
0.006532582,
-0.0226942338,
-0.0076731467,
0.0639333278,
-0.0262611359,
-0.0017447157,
-0.0138457585,
-0.0588307865,
-0.0022550561,
-0.0142756272,
0.0675081089,
0.0104505578,
0.0369373448,
-0.00738947,
-0.0410126522,
-0.0101619624,
0.0227244832,
-0.0159576312,
-0.0260298196,
0.0119083319,
0.034050297,
0.0088287313,
0.0203867797,
-0.0239050649,
0.0193171781,
-0.0034151243,
0.0293912143,
-0.0087018861,
-0.0646129772,
0.0581053235,
-0.0227859635,
0.0133960471,
-0.0146086179,
0.0359105654,
-0.0050792927,
0.0042119049,
-0.0486168973,
-0.0390995555,
-0.046651002,
0.0067148888,
-0.0198622961,
0.0317857824,
-0.0057281274,
0.0120894732,
-0.0120395496,
0.0715738311,
-0.0780676082,
0.0344467908,
-0.0099145519,
-0.0034121734,
-0.0228080526,
0.0099213915,
-0.0416060798,
0.0079685794,
0.0254581291,
0.0456857197,
-0.0345582925,
0.0456268191,
-0.0083794612,
0.0132213803,
-0.0193521231,
0.0688831359,
-0.0510999821,
0.0309452768,
-0.0464573912,
-0.0041946424,
-0.0390639082,
-0.0117225181,
0.0495450385,
-0.0249269176,
-0.0038203604,
0.0266139172,
0.0307289679,
-0.0442885458,
-0.0029317385,
-0.0081463251,
0.0202105306,
-0.0060405433,
-0.0280717108,
0.0653461814,
-0.078335546,
-0.0285268519,
0.0003208662,
-0.0534833074,
-0.0516935885,
-0.0156948622,
-0.0397942141,
0.0177459288,
0.0056551569,
-0.024904618,
-0.0383387059,
0.0039538997,
0.014393067,
0.0202001575,
0.0548809431,
0.0033089945,
0.0612612404,
0.0413702168,
0.0090136556,
-0.0061749332,
-0.0342604816,
-0.0086011253,
-0.0178794041,
-0.0209055077,
-0.0535943136,
-6.057874137e-33,
-0.0340519063,
-0.024041377,
-0.0311232209,
0.0046503758,
0.0009770637,
-0.0279825702,
-0.0203186199,
0.0226520803,
0.0431668013,
0.0271681361,
0.0093139345,
-0.0211606119,
0.009896216,
0.0209364854,
0.0413619131,
0.01472604,
0.1010850593,
0.0249040574,
-0.0113307927,
0.0554048754,
0.0133765228,
0.0172002241,
0.0314063095,
-0.0525758155,
-0.0004526865,
0.0026688774,
-0.0349898376,
0.000154972,
0.0268553477,
0.0802679956,
0.0027607053,
0.0565637238,
0.0288871676,
-0.016276218,
-0.0043452014,
0.0036982561,
-0.0542392395,
-0.0055934638,
0.0240655262,
-0.0279842988,
-0.001281202,
-0.0613026768,
0.0077294353,
-0.0363080502,
-0.0306908675,
0.0220541302,
0.0496985279,
-0.0536661819,
0.0238206349,
-0.0916706175,
-0.0464891195,
0.0011947693,
-0.0096250856,
0.0212379303,
-0.0113547547,
0.0950902253,
-0.018081639,
0.0477093384,
-0.0284714829,
0.0758691728,
0.0135629894,
0.057484597,
0.0250571761,
0.0001218312,
-0.0215840377,
0.0524801873,
0.010083749,
-0.0281565096,
-0.0079712607,
0.0552549772,
-0.0376386605,
0.0205131937,
0.0453247987,
0.0858968124,
0.0341300406,
-0.032021217,
0.0247047823,
0.0520299785,
-0.0058508096,
-0.0080665126,
0.0504576303,
0.0243265424,
-0.0354843773,
-0.0016884618,
0.0009884943,
-0.031760253,
-0.0453181677,
-0.0573717505,
0.023864096,
0.0161994826,
-0.0557391457,
-0.0211376902,
-0.023498334,
-0.0233669374,
-0.0082583837,
-0.0165643729,
-0.0627881512,
0.0141443107,
-0.0224911273,
-0.0399397463,
0.0030719633,
0.0144843338,
0.0072164461,
0.007596422,
0.0171032939,
0.0070661423,
0.048819378,
-0.0042833327,
-0.098250255,
0.019469317,
0.0003565336,
0.0060939114,
-0.0393182412,
-0.0085313981,
-0.0105158687,
0.0265498292,
-0.0589640029,
0.0825653821,
-0.0124987084,
0.010929876,
-0.0680976659,
-0.0114187486,
0.0356528312,
0.0166942738,
-0.0008228064,
0.0127035612,
-0.0349930562,
0.0096312761,
0.0141870659,
-0.043515157,
-0.0291017033,
0.0646850243,
2.597e-7,
0.0157961473,
0.0412249491,
0.0310528968,
-0.0370778739,
0.0084697874,
0.0433476381,
0.0673977435,
0.0225716196,
0.0062773162,
0.0178743172,
0.0258915182,
0.0216197278,
0.0309085157,
0.0486516021,
-0.0615833364,
0.0251111407,
-0.0867173225,
-0.0469274148,
-0.0486703403,
-0.0305097774,
0.1130087152,
0.0326343775,
0.0289185811,
0.0316344947,
0.0064975214,
0.0097708525,
0.0444449335,
-0.0302047562,
-0.0181905162,
-0.0099986792,
-0.0066149058,
-0.0268139187,
-0.0304365978,
-0.0273305364,
-0.0085558211,
-0.0183954965,
0.0190646872,
0.0427139774,
0.0131500419,
-0.0557440408,
0.0119759627,
0.0159154776,
-0.001442446,
-0.0281743538,
0.0167658273,
-0.0723963901,
-0.0129206087,
-0.0586928241,
-0.0084415423,
0.0256697126,
0.0033559615,
-0.0282925945,
-0.0520190857,
0.0231559817,
0.0224776901,
0.0063184043,
-0.0226921197,
-0.043808151,
-0.0413772389,
0.0225010142,
-0.0233070068,
-0.0181160606,
-0.0329951793,
0.0028069546,
-0.0266350675,
-0.0026542789,
0.0073812045,
2.011119076e-34,
0.0477676466,
0.0473362021,
0.0255562738,
-0.0265248772,
0.0448665395,
0.0254143924,
-0.0399450026,
0.0100159403,
0.0515586212,
-0.0375243537,
-0.0355891883
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.02682v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.02682v2 | Zero-Shot Dense Video Captioning by Jointly Optimizing Text and Moment | 2023-07-05T23:01:26 | 2023-07-11T04:10:49 | Yongrae Jo, Seongyun Lee, Aiden SJ Lee, Hyunji Lee, Hanseok Oh, Minjoon Seo | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Dense video captioning, a task of localizing meaningful moments and
generating relevant captions for videos, often requires a large, expensive
corpus of annotated video segments paired with text. In an effort to minimize
the annotation cost, we propose ZeroTA, a novel method for dense video
captioning in a zero-shot manner. Our method does not require any videos or
annotations for training; instead, it localizes and describes events within
each input video at test time by optimizing solely on the input. This is
accomplished by introducing a soft moment mask that represents a temporal
segment in the video and jointly optimizing it with the prefix parameters of a
language model. This joint optimization aligns a frozen language generation
model (i.e., GPT-2) with a frozen vision-language contrastive model (i.e.,
CLIP) by maximizing the matching score between the generated text and a moment
within the video. We also introduce a pairwise temporal IoU loss to let a set
of soft moment masks capture multiple distinct events within the video. Our
method effectively discovers diverse significant events within the video, with
the resulting captions appropriately describing these events. The empirical
results demonstrate that ZeroTA surpasses zero-shot baselines and even
outperforms the state-of-the-art few-shot method on the widely-used benchmark
ActivityNet Captions. Moreover, our method shows greater robustness compared to
supervised methods when evaluated in out-of-domain scenarios. This research
provides insight into the potential of aligning widely-used models, such as
language generation models and vision-language models, to unlock a new
capability: understanding temporal aspects of videos. | [
-0.0083095105,
0.0370905623,
0.0145280026,
0.0544230603,
0.0050855856,
-0.0080229985,
0.0395071507,
0.0049226242,
-0.0544490479,
-0.0833035633,
0.0121277077,
-0.0577817336,
-0.0002326529,
0.0437749028,
-0.0092464369,
-0.0879303962,
0.0211078133,
-0.0201504882,
-0.0073404047,
0.0201912504,
0.029108014,
0.0228941943,
-0.0086496454,
0.0392481014,
-0.0286260005,
0.0151978228,
0.0020685284,
0.0043459195,
0.075923197,
-0.0570301525,
-0.0310152788,
0.0648996085,
0.0661494136,
0.0352463908,
0.0000017681,
-0.0088272383,
0.0032166496,
0.0216366015,
-0.0272536222,
0.0397976935,
0.0271496866,
-0.0533958562,
0.0043531465,
0.0047771768,
-0.0148314741,
-0.0202726759,
0.0620239414,
-0.0030681621,
0.0190095138,
0.047192961,
-0.0481726974,
-0.0098278029,
-0.0133343888,
-0.0612045601,
0.0188435167,
-0.0231112596,
-0.0253771991,
0.0445863493,
-0.0110822786,
0.0091189174,
-0.0324338973,
0.041764129,
0.0053990232,
-0.0321760252,
-0.0043184152,
0.0878628045,
-0.0521233976,
-0.0052950988,
-0.0184543561,
0.0685576648,
0.0012887127,
0.0401806496,
0.0024428968,
-0.009566565,
-0.0315598845,
-0.046036303,
-0.054114949,
0.0370174237,
0.0660447478,
0.0098346891,
-0.0115481904,
0.0645339116,
0.013555605,
0.008546412,
0.0068590944,
-0.0415523723,
0.0299128443,
0.0500170477,
-0.0733504593,
-0.0124345766,
-0.0637329295,
-0.0514270812,
-0.0052066287,
0.0057354732,
0.0512593538,
-0.0026398185,
-0.0448603667,
-0.005807674,
-0.0191724766,
-0.0412373468,
0.0286939126,
0.0312613994,
-0.0125316856,
0.0584570095,
-0.0224057697,
0.0410792194,
0.0286160093,
-0.0031175001,
-0.0543399416,
0.0104374429,
-0.0245898049,
0.0262943655,
-0.0137823988,
0.0222748425,
-0.040794991,
-0.022047855,
-0.0264854506,
-0.0153294029,
-0.028167244,
0.0035997734,
-0.055801481,
0.0200886037,
-0.0422315784,
-0.0415875241,
-0.0027870615,
0.0333091915,
-0.007135401,
0.0349955782,
-0.0107759126,
-0.0570341013,
-0.0532976426,
0.0700966492,
0.0222270265,
-0.0180122033,
0.0083854916,
0.027220184,
-0.0667375624,
-0.0524107888,
-0.0134809464,
-0.0122830225,
-0.0657909811,
-0.0081819901,
-0.0230054352,
-0.0534117147,
0.0073210932,
-0.0207313467,
0.00258692,
-0.0567972288,
0.0467097722,
-0.016856879,
-0.0000898156,
0.1023975834,
0.0123185897,
-0.0001626218,
0.0160768218,
0.0178035889,
0.0113222674,
0.0645468906,
0.0364133082,
0.0305100922,
0.0046430775,
0.0596641339,
0.0453991033,
0.0368762016,
0.0260136779,
0.0752180591,
-0.0778929219,
-0.0325553939,
0.0277560055,
0.0421149172,
0.050831534,
0.021398887,
-0.0252896547,
0.0356800146,
0.0784546211,
0.0207318123,
-0.0700392872,
-0.0061410693,
0.058628276,
0.0019003581,
-0.0346597768,
-0.0489204451,
-0.0085347658,
0.0636511743,
0.0252627302,
-0.0055512208,
0.0082643302,
-0.0104717687,
-0.0818327889,
-0.0362455286,
-0.0150804194,
-0.0218500122,
-0.0100639258,
0.0091902614,
0.0370822623,
-0.0034051789,
-0.069859378,
0.0765268132,
-0.0270646196,
-0.0105851423,
0.0356708765,
-0.0236960016,
-0.0160054043,
0.0349944644,
0.0165676773,
-0.0014542454,
-0.080810383,
-0.0264785886,
0.0333408266,
0.0398982279,
0.0235556401,
-0.0087532289,
0.0368418954,
-0.0820385292,
-0.0189992785,
-0.019839691,
0.0240507387,
0.0336197503,
-0.0156325288,
0.0469189323,
0.0597836152,
0.0193877425,
-0.0568983629,
0.0192249082,
0.0193416569,
-0.0648164228,
0.0078554368,
-0.0128351217,
0.0198710915,
0.0151610961,
-0.0419320576,
-0.0116300164,
0.0034034278,
-0.0205919873,
-0.0188178718,
0.0700461268,
-0.0444781557,
-0.0595297776,
0.0343266018,
-0.0254740417,
0.0049787168,
0.0008716867,
-0.040930111,
-0.0729669407,
0.029451089,
0.0024861058,
-0.0348538496,
-0.0691434145,
-0.0165554229,
0.0439288244,
0.0165907778,
-0.0207081828,
0.0222428832,
-0.0064326511,
-0.0420666523,
0.03908474,
0.0000618643,
0.0099250795,
-0.0558911413,
-0.0558537804,
-0.0014403525,
0.003515509,
0.0151972389,
0.0220805984,
0.0149790486,
-0.0326918922,
-0.0053161676,
-0.0986248255,
0.0115094325,
-0.021271551,
0.0217394736,
0.0253878329,
0.01676457,
-0.0004190702,
-0.0162674598,
-0.0273390245,
-0.0399989672,
0.0106062964,
-0.0015146476,
0.0146149546,
0.0747704208,
0.0010530717,
-0.0128977923,
0.0149003705,
0.0169554204,
0.0475037247,
0.0080894502,
-0.0367230512,
0.0143284155,
0.042554535,
0.0073889173,
0.0012547589,
-0.0347339138,
-0.0164442267,
-0.0235979836,
-0.0000479983,
0.0192549434,
0.0374316685,
0.0043142689,
0.0516935177,
0.0019785033,
-0.0211242884,
-0.0009392943,
0.0305956248,
-0.0251194593,
-0.0493711978,
0.0078366809,
-0.039359469,
-0.0314503349,
-0.0004078445,
-0.0058570723,
0.0445163138,
-0.0777735561,
-0.0166133419,
-0.0282214396,
-0.0102255251,
-0.0232345294,
0.0338829681,
-0.0340522043,
0.0195743944,
-0.0328255631,
-0.0434992798,
-0.0144132236,
-0.036135383,
-0.0397054404,
0.0065190298,
-0.0027589055,
-0.0213893,
0.1024561673,
-0.0152366161,
0.0260135625,
-0.0235331655,
-0.0378624834,
-0.0297084022,
-0.0448289253,
0.0276810117,
-0.0011602744,
0.0612687096,
-0.0656370521,
0.0055000959,
-0.0353651904,
-0.0019984925,
-0.0112109315,
-0.0304722674,
-0.0202527549,
-0.0002593582,
-0.0492658354,
-0.0039667198,
-0.0341429897,
0.0284737628,
0.0093921497,
0.0689424127,
-0.0195945334,
0.0259307437,
0.0012819211,
0.0567624904,
0.0539149828,
0.0335879177,
-0.0596161,
-0.034554828,
0.0523569882,
0.0456750616,
0.034191668,
-0.003819823,
-0.0561250746,
-0.0052488279,
0.0244070217,
0.0098486077,
-0.0027820533,
0.0395806879,
0.0789434016,
-0.0372759141,
0.0081878696,
0.0989000425,
0.0019923996,
-0.0347123928,
-0.0129147759,
0.0271847025,
0.0296792667,
0.0394905098,
-0.0134312352,
-0.0775125325,
-0.0508240871,
-0.0246513318,
-0.0091479504,
0.029788712,
0.0225170907,
-0.0476822741,
-0.0763845071,
0.0429762229,
0.0454938263,
-0.0187780205,
-0.0245611668,
0.0341412611,
-0.0151008395,
-0.0295025464,
-0.0099343965,
-0.0230525713,
0.0266065691,
0.0244455487,
0.0326688066,
0.0124503346,
-0.0771527961,
0.0203915983,
-0.0251300745,
0.047393918,
0.032473281,
0.038020961,
-0.039673049,
0.0156634487,
0.0128370672,
-0.0503724888,
-0.0067296154,
0.0048899557,
0.0651974827,
-0.0171151441,
-0.0142319221,
0.0335607193,
0.0366884246,
0.0284795966,
-0.046845708,
0.0160827003,
0.0396556109,
-0.0088608619,
0.0385636911,
-0.0050109057,
0.0118309911,
0.0331758857,
0.0463614129,
-0.0167882964,
0.0000409192,
0.008935404,
0.0047257734,
-0.0249328669,
-0.0822123066,
-0.0358899757,
-0.0201180037,
0.0152170146,
-0.0174863283,
-0.0463953316,
-0.0147938877,
0.0633537471,
0.0389083177,
0.0048316014,
0.0041383016,
-0.031490501,
0.0426338948,
-0.0518826582,
0.0554636568,
-0.0399438776,
-0.0036212148,
-0.032335218,
0.0043059718,
0.0754579082,
-0.0170866009,
-0.0047492282,
0.0563153848,
-0.0480056815,
-0.0339265391,
-0.0530453287,
0.0465596281,
0.0144339176,
0.0781599954,
0.025457941,
0.019516902,
0.0489799939,
0.0372160152,
0.0249535497,
0.0085225524,
0.0353130288,
-0.0328726396,
-0.0452651419,
0.0257279687,
-0.0279571917,
0.0297793765,
-0.0321173407,
0.0475201495,
-0.0441924967,
-0.0231845137,
-0.0097861886,
-0.0353949331,
0.0558632091,
-0.0727845281,
0.000436708,
-0.0303312745,
-0.0252224356,
-0.0080694826,
0.0243680626,
-0.0614112914,
0.0101714293,
0.0493654534,
0.0330089033,
-0.0255265869,
0.0334831141,
-0.0168586113,
-0.0107147358,
-0.0055785067,
-0.0051931846,
0.0043644099,
-0.022540912,
-0.0053335815,
0.0446565934,
-0.0030269821,
0.0217761807,
-0.0096238889,
0.0053307442,
-0.0236122664,
0.0326243117,
0.0137422038,
0.0154517973,
-0.0057071499,
0.0280027483,
0.0023587262,
0.0342727341,
-0.0679397956,
0.0069723213,
0.0635376871,
-0.0406959318,
0.0436648726,
-0.0339620002,
-0.0064323288,
-0.016154604,
0.0765508264,
-0.0220214333,
-0.0686712638,
0.0349396616,
-0.0062719723,
0.0007866732,
0.0371230207,
0.0709471479,
-0.0178895462,
0.0471712053,
0.0215202086,
0.0038678914,
-0.0155010456,
-0.0074627679,
0.0038158493,
-0.026232399,
-0.0237436462,
0.0210508853,
-0.0342623219,
-0.0427836478,
0.0246067308,
-0.020156363,
0.000299772,
0.019386204,
0.0704685301,
-0.0174877457,
-0.0074136499,
0.0068856785,
-0.0225535221,
-0.0044146981,
-0.0121007236,
-0.0016757353,
-0.0292092208,
-5.474987999e-33,
-0.0365140997,
-0.046280466,
0.0201062858,
0.0066819382,
-0.0226688031,
0.0598667972,
-0.0426438861,
0.0585486963,
-0.0087410416,
0.017303165,
0.0237652678,
-0.0123214778,
0.022698978,
0.0329741649,
0.0209760293,
-0.039461907,
0.032367412,
-0.0384650789,
-0.0121272448,
0.0361111425,
0.0098606283,
-0.0188559685,
0.0406741984,
-0.0398752131,
-0.0075215474,
-0.0153961517,
-0.0642421916,
0.0247075874,
0.0619995929,
0.0189944953,
0.0143672861,
-0.0017998973,
-0.0096379239,
-0.0608833283,
-0.0241675694,
-0.0567809939,
-0.0282760672,
-0.0136227263,
0.0172482394,
-0.0041000391,
-0.041381903,
-0.0327510722,
-0.0238578152,
-0.0263560954,
-0.0201946441,
-0.043672286,
0.0318938792,
-0.0189194251,
0.0074504456,
-0.0635275915,
-0.0315362997,
0.0422105975,
-0.0338128805,
-0.0462877825,
0.0636176616,
-0.0145441769,
0.0430163443,
-0.0239202827,
-0.0373818725,
0.0039703758,
-0.0215457771,
0.0591177531,
0.0996272117,
0.0375063531,
-0.0318538323,
0.0430381298,
-0.0420477614,
-0.0123323686,
-0.0128072649,
0.0279290136,
0.0274968371,
0.0254100915,
0.0412630737,
0.0426367857,
0.0168744214,
-0.0007363986,
-0.0443747491,
0.0366210788,
-0.062530227,
-0.0166520011,
0.0083388267,
0.0199329965,
0.0152877187,
0.0075646793,
-0.0304353647,
-0.0164787099,
-0.0159619134,
-0.0121995732,
0.008665855,
0.0367776677,
0.0071898089,
0.0402496606,
0.0901202783,
-0.0065348647,
0.0489356667,
-0.0049306769,
-0.0379665568,
0.0566420294,
-0.0004283206,
-0.006062862,
-0.0403568856,
-0.0616035499,
0.0429729819,
0.0297669061,
0.0213732217,
0.0087763229,
0.0501558892,
0.0633803383,
-0.009298238,
-0.0126705403,
-0.0168212317,
0.0077458713,
-0.0249299053,
0.0325881466,
-0.0018289953,
0.0275365505,
-0.04923518,
0.0212437864,
-0.008343312,
0.0210347921,
-0.012845899,
-0.0222317185,
-0.0142054576,
0.0274474155,
-0.0472074151,
0.0585319996,
-0.0183065496,
-0.0136958454,
0.0351776481,
-0.0365304463,
-0.0502356179,
0.0162823889,
2.411e-7,
0.0158307813,
0.0210245214,
0.0215204954,
0.0019985582,
-0.0022694946,
0.0599045195,
-0.015064016,
0.0365046598,
-0.0052746884,
-0.0044926563,
0.0807717741,
0.0166345946,
0.0410661772,
-0.0096724387,
-0.050080426,
0.0026985325,
-0.0204680935,
-0.0029120035,
-0.035701815,
-0.0367109329,
0.0431650504,
0.1027475968,
0.0153254224,
0.02224168,
0.0275001992,
-0.0865191147,
0.0910558254,
-0.0150694037,
-0.0270447899,
0.0161302388,
0.0058847116,
0.0250382107,
-0.0765006989,
-0.0071710376,
-0.0325835533,
-0.0264691506,
0.043322552,
0.0634343401,
-0.039909482,
-0.0317929611,
-0.0348870344,
0.0622893721,
-0.0242364891,
0.0048134248,
0.0610846654,
-0.0375313871,
-0.0281019397,
-0.0329524837,
-0.0200659297,
0.0515598804,
0.0061217295,
0.0021966274,
-0.0181139465,
0.0450912639,
0.0293312352,
0.019847611,
-0.0625690445,
-0.0832016766,
-0.0282224845,
-0.0150813572,
-0.029169783,
-0.0001239987,
-0.0481928922,
-0.0192786139,
0.0198275521,
-0.0164377801,
-0.0214785039,
1.939112241e-34,
0.0332107395,
-0.016597189,
-0.0241769142,
-0.0202247743,
0.000724696,
0.0347137377,
-0.0230544433,
-0.0152708106,
0.0131631568,
-0.0179246385,
-0.0349065475
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.02640v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.02640v1 | Unsupervised Sentiment Analysis of Plastic Surgery Social Media Posts | 2023-07-05T20:16:20 | 2023-07-05T20:16:20 | Alexandrea K. Ramnarine | cs.CL | cs.CL, 68T50 | The massive collection of user posts across social media platforms is
primarily untapped for artificial intelligence (AI) use cases based on the
sheer volume and velocity of textual data. Natural language processing (NLP) is
a subfield of AI that leverages bodies of documents, known as corpora, to train
computers in human-like language understanding. Using a word ranking method,
term frequency-inverse document frequency (TF-IDF), to create features across
documents, it is possible to perform unsupervised analytics, machine learning
(ML) that can group the documents without a human manually labeling the data.
For large datasets with thousands of features, t-distributed stochastic
neighbor embedding (t-SNE), k-means clustering and Latent Dirichlet allocation
(LDA) are employed to learn top words and generate topics for a Reddit and
Twitter combined corpus. Using extremely simple deep learning models, this
study demonstrates that the applied results of unsupervised analysis allow a
computer to predict either negative, positive, or neutral user sentiment
towards plastic surgery based on a tweet or subreddit post with almost 90%
accuracy. Furthermore, the model is capable of achieving higher accuracy on the
unsupervised sentiment task than on a rudimentary supervised document
classification task. Therefore, unsupervised learning may be considered a
viable option in labeling social media documents for NLP tasks. | [
0.0531362444,
0.1074254587,
-0.0035785225,
-0.0219672564,
-0.0230554026,
0.0274712555,
0.0162682515,
-0.0160625577,
0.0223066639,
-0.0252235681,
-0.0204295125,
-0.0151882377,
-0.0153437434,
0.0619294979,
-0.007098115,
-0.0462704636,
0.0182056725,
0.0674626008,
0.0431052633,
-0.0213221647,
0.0196888447,
0.0156367403,
-0.0165468808,
0.0150508722,
-0.0446743444,
-0.0097786169,
0.0527123213,
-0.0069470624,
-0.0076797525,
-0.0140177105,
0.001126376,
0.0566968583,
0.005626068,
0.0207336713,
0.0000020445,
-0.0091397986,
-0.0195320528,
-0.0114104906,
0.0146769136,
-0.0233316738,
0.103100121,
-0.0632868186,
0.0040112999,
0.021467505,
-0.0194966886,
-0.0379116721,
0.0684330761,
0.0760912895,
0.0581429601,
0.0518473387,
-0.0455791131,
-0.0600490198,
0.0034312501,
-0.0100621274,
0.0115475198,
-0.0154739935,
0.0033345851,
-0.0426055193,
-0.0341252945,
-0.0089627542,
0.0033322633,
0.0327998996,
-0.0247285813,
-0.0165579095,
0.0488701165,
0.0135019999,
0.0004217276,
-0.0421308726,
0.0041840039,
0.0670888573,
0.0076381448,
-0.0254031159,
-0.0014685964,
0.0063645504,
-0.0408700071,
0.0383774862,
-0.0230210498,
0.0044084243,
0.0169870462,
0.0197231285,
-0.0364907123,
0.0110620437,
0.0335155316,
0.0227947813,
0.0052361488,
0.0314235464,
-0.0047722394,
-0.0251715742,
0.0239714552,
0.0232056566,
-0.0025917401,
-0.0197211634,
0.0343281403,
-0.0169044174,
0.003656019,
0.00891231,
-0.0218931735,
-0.0525390245,
0.0263001043,
-0.0632298365,
-0.0424932726,
-0.0272649787,
-0.0227981322,
0.058333274,
-0.0049932855,
-0.0569809377,
-0.0232768264,
0.0361502767,
-0.0244724713,
0.0094631976,
-0.0372115523,
0.0061891456,
0.0312363151,
0.0105059231,
0.00211817,
-0.0081107859,
-0.034278851,
0.0052696913,
-0.0364937,
-0.023411395,
-0.0302308369,
0.0748224854,
-0.0222929548,
-0.0291586667,
-0.0291604027,
0.0159881953,
-0.0273281913,
0.0399408825,
-0.0499711297,
0.0204070471,
0.0275371894,
0.0281828269,
0.0612386838,
0.0108636385,
0.0039000085,
0.0420120135,
0.0205737781,
0.0030811282,
-0.0396246873,
-0.0164715201,
-0.0010112103,
-0.0010474474,
0.0148643851,
-0.0865405649,
0.0063955798,
0.0079653682,
-0.0079696914,
-0.0133722443,
0.0107766325,
0.0282560512,
-0.0339719392,
0.0571238212,
-0.0343525372,
0.0203076936,
0.059048377,
0.0038049424,
0.0383847356,
0.004119975,
0.0227608345,
0.0428974293,
0.0477098338,
-0.0171848163,
-0.0053914175,
-0.0352274403,
0.024384452,
-0.0212556422,
-0.0366219804,
-0.0247288886,
-0.0582039095,
0.0234548468,
-0.0072281421,
0.0506519713,
0.0277068242,
-0.0093231052,
0.0140825706,
0.0532248728,
-0.0329327472,
0.0386814289,
-0.0354040265,
0.0315222703,
-0.0128570972,
-0.0372202769,
-0.0114922738,
0.0214743987,
0.0313580483,
-0.0270147063,
0.0217147656,
-0.0155449603,
-0.0401839837,
-0.0186624974,
-0.0130647346,
-0.0391549692,
0.0505260825,
-0.0367146879,
0.0694060698,
-0.005826293,
-0.0084816357,
0.0216274168,
0.0220250972,
-0.0080768624,
-0.0298595093,
-0.0178838279,
-0.0055086496,
0.0565194972,
-0.0258529149,
-0.0585185923,
-0.0096131396,
-0.0188249666,
0.0317738391,
0.0321078114,
0.0251763519,
0.0207204744,
-0.0369433351,
-0.0130753098,
-0.005959875,
0.010948807,
0.0295622163,
-0.0021936509,
-0.0120633328,
0.0556832068,
0.0034632506,
-0.0430081859,
0.0023461787,
0.0095925992,
0.0417777933,
-0.0017211626,
0.0450195596,
0.0306496602,
0.013264657,
0.0641815439,
-0.0402411558,
-0.0184387136,
0.0365182199,
-0.0297360588,
-0.0839578807,
-0.0058789467,
-0.0515202582,
0.0013028187,
-0.0007874314,
-0.0887493193,
-0.0230678096,
0.0689338893,
-0.0384806171,
-0.0262825489,
0.0889275968,
-0.0442659557,
0.0011704591,
-0.0146189425,
-0.0561436266,
-0.0127676008,
-0.026810186,
-0.0287620891,
0.0461879522,
-0.01713828,
-0.0284657236,
-0.0272672158,
-0.0252413675,
0.0055582151,
0.019468125,
-0.0325860493,
-0.0172017924,
0.0060667451,
0.011190827,
0.0380939171,
0.019037053,
-0.0292639807,
-0.0179435723,
-0.1133308634,
0.0064527197,
-0.0463391878,
0.0019111163,
-0.0003157769,
0.0153032262,
0.021136906,
-0.0356119797,
-0.0464159139,
0.0113101574,
0.0260858815,
0.019987056,
0.0366215073,
0.0186027121,
0.0432609394,
-0.0299028549,
-0.0357570238,
-0.0390581489,
-0.0062066368,
0.0564189106,
-0.033998169,
0.0367848985,
0.0320962146,
-0.0659304634,
0.0078308331,
0.0208427664,
-0.0467757955,
0.0158834103,
-0.0139292227,
0.0273948517,
-0.0044959593,
0.0026648706,
0.0386568755,
0.011499526,
0.0713573322,
0.0039250324,
-0.009639252,
-0.0406087413,
-0.0211752709,
-0.000402867,
-0.041120775,
-0.0325897262,
0.0158324167,
0.0260815881,
0.0065064984,
-0.0365117639,
0.002939671,
-0.0002863972,
-0.0005021102,
-0.0477447473,
0.0380734503,
0.0085030813,
0.0477828532,
-0.0028221235,
-0.0422930382,
0.0432030261,
0.0779219195,
0.0142176496,
-0.0444118865,
-0.0522957928,
-0.0259105302,
0.0356300846,
0.0356199667,
0.0302769281,
-0.0489363484,
-0.0086629549,
0.0171373971,
0.0260549448,
-0.0320106447,
-0.0102891978,
-0.0086747846,
-0.0008877798,
-0.0084239589,
0.0216024388,
-0.0118966307,
-0.0177826714,
-0.0701601207,
-0.0175511539,
-0.0632694289,
0.0348284505,
-0.0079520429,
-0.0198551659,
-0.0307892133,
0.0222617369,
0.0195930731,
0.0199063886,
-0.0063506118,
0.0021636956,
0.0471098684,
0.0471293591,
-0.0240205526,
-0.0207245871,
0.0199574772,
-0.0040862705,
0.0616368391,
0.0050317971,
0.0017012496,
-0.0467626005,
-0.0178900305,
-0.0202745926,
-0.0016719538,
0.0301889312,
-0.0337182097,
-0.0313197821,
0.0008790088,
0.0154931154,
0.11085511,
0.0382406935,
-0.0609320551,
0.0066595464,
0.0118243936,
-0.0383935794,
0.0149775557,
-0.0105653545,
-0.0682968497,
-0.0060375794,
-0.0378822833,
0.0215965826,
0.0196561906,
-0.0199343655,
0.0080086682,
-0.0785950869,
0.0251261145,
-0.0395915434,
-0.0116929477,
-0.0520084947,
-0.0716459155,
0.0046974872,
-0.0095416307,
-0.0434002578,
-0.0457532778,
0.0140853347,
-0.0031968099,
-0.0053439429,
-0.0932300985,
-0.0592831187,
0.04350169,
-0.0449345708,
-0.0073406049,
0.041282922,
0.0387767293,
-0.0450970381,
-0.0356504284,
-0.0056365291,
0.0549104251,
0.0062624896,
-0.0142418044,
0.0929525122,
-0.0191346053,
-0.0210246444,
-0.011641101,
0.0321146175,
-0.1214838549,
0.0039172424,
-0.0224666912,
0.0530349128,
-0.014736075,
-0.0138874017,
-0.0531945154,
0.0177073088,
0.0170524996,
0.0392701924,
-0.007085355,
-0.0193016771,
-0.0090355212,
0.0141856391,
0.0465686582,
0.0130951684,
0.0013570704,
-0.0177903008,
-0.0011211846,
-0.0689883679,
-0.0321350358,
-0.0292259976,
0.0255806539,
-0.0123818088,
-0.0042861933,
-0.0020672353,
0.0156711359,
-0.0230832715,
-0.0694711357,
0.030871395,
0.0207752064,
-0.0024188769,
0.01397439,
-0.0666001141,
0.0720174089,
0.0329494923,
-0.0277213752,
-0.030502541,
-0.0192449242,
-0.0130724553,
0.0015461699,
0.0116889402,
0.0056761247,
0.0050409506,
-0.0428356677,
-0.0737728551,
0.0085653905,
0.0990749449,
-0.0662092716,
-0.0458351225,
0.0140522104,
-0.0144872675,
0.0318786427,
0.0288490336,
-0.0184717085,
0.0561206117,
-0.005506726,
-0.0640639067,
-0.060592629,
-0.0157467816,
-0.0282760784,
0.0190017447,
0.1102734804,
0.0227874219,
-0.0017018067,
-0.0471749529,
-0.0359053053,
0.029469924,
-0.0005858512,
-0.0298872124,
-0.0132778334,
0.0378274657,
0.0076709418,
-0.0455381162,
0.0268720668,
-0.0037376315,
0.010386169,
-0.0002609254,
0.0549569242,
0.0146142598,
0.0293793622,
-0.0126135414,
0.0506259315,
-0.0012284415,
-0.0209644269,
0.025416255,
-0.0065332139,
0.0128431646,
-0.0212236736,
0.0107971719,
0.0167517141,
-0.0142047266,
0.0518079922,
-0.0299283303,
-0.0686670467,
-0.0333373696,
-0.0018573573,
0.0249880441,
-0.0380857363,
0.0109188333,
-0.0206738375,
-0.0074743349,
-0.0202171709,
0.0279855654,
-0.0413082093,
0.0035518622,
0.0066512092,
0.0058688549,
-0.0180624351,
0.0288648773,
0.0619901903,
-0.0188580789,
-0.0226436518,
0.0401087292,
-0.0614881068,
-0.041808784,
0.0362367257,
0.0530006476,
0.0402149558,
0.022009965,
0.0374521986,
-0.0027044672,
-0.0591287725,
0.049725052,
-0.0527847335,
-0.0013781349,
0.0024495446,
0.0661031082,
0.0805260092,
-0.0108690765,
0.0693496466,
-0.0468595214,
0.0302609894,
0.0067123668,
-0.064670682,
0.0048027998,
-6.794981829e-33,
0.0440020077,
-0.0341726393,
-0.0303495377,
-0.0061168559,
0.0078503629,
-0.0135236867,
-0.0316894315,
0.0216138959,
0.0525474399,
0.0513239503,
-0.0011975199,
0.0233563222,
-0.0037432939,
0.0173597522,
0.0301473793,
-0.0155814718,
0.030541392,
-0.0143657057,
0.0236793458,
0.0724522546,
0.0018379046,
0.0510526411,
0.0519277304,
-0.1244280413,
0.0025749251,
0.0061082407,
0.0230681151,
0.0111503024,
0.0583913997,
0.0176146347,
-0.0309656393,
0.0869745836,
0.0405904278,
-0.0463949256,
0.0037179759,
0.0415325239,
-0.0140714124,
-0.0265558008,
-0.0669491515,
0.0149108246,
-0.0446890071,
0.0123652555,
0.0443866923,
0.0313093811,
-0.0267008785,
0.0174212642,
0.0809078813,
0.0077579357,
0.0215109941,
-0.0158868246,
-0.0116163455,
0.0356252976,
-0.0314169489,
-0.001290636,
0.0168208349,
-0.0141488975,
0.0162281878,
0.0861122906,
-0.0821493641,
0.0129889213,
-0.0075629451,
-0.0147022605,
0.0190233104,
-0.0682210997,
-0.0090148039,
0.0474636815,
0.0302033667,
0.0217155851,
0.002441898,
0.0139410598,
0.00403381,
0.0600977167,
0.0257912856,
0.0339994691,
0.0487475507,
-0.0445382446,
-0.0711863339,
0.0319950022,
-0.026983887,
0.0203018524,
0.0083291624,
0.0326960124,
-0.0489395894,
0.0037717591,
0.023478264,
-0.0605260693,
-0.024532387,
-0.0248198304,
-0.0496610999,
-0.0068236599,
-0.0537270121,
0.0272402614,
-0.013306899,
-0.0484249182,
0.0149648376,
0.0044753058,
0.0012942652,
0.035691604,
0.013307712,
0.0039569032,
-0.0805501193,
0.0209018476,
-0.0456732884,
0.0493336879,
0.0069664996,
-0.0049727866,
0.0006636161,
0.0068517569,
-0.060112454,
0.0135128302,
0.0114629911,
-0.0213902909,
-0.0355931073,
0.0530641042,
-0.0098271994,
0.0046051606,
-0.0035194978,
0.0714772195,
0.0309227668,
0.0551574528,
-0.0164251477,
-0.0276450384,
-0.0082419803,
-0.0631806403,
-0.0118128704,
-0.0581305623,
-0.0096272724,
-0.0122843329,
0.0462126695,
-0.0866512358,
0.0110238446,
-0.0558995157,
2.979e-7,
0.0451227315,
0.0665169209,
-0.0038818878,
-0.0137929227,
0.083122015,
0.066063121,
0.0315853804,
0.038159281,
-0.0002157937,
-0.0530142002,
0.0284065492,
0.0211652257,
-0.0159349162,
0.0100973528,
-0.0500565879,
0.0563225895,
-0.0430913121,
0.0215447191,
-0.0026938873,
0.0035062248,
0.0178106241,
0.1003100201,
0.0043872413,
-0.0464263037,
0.0010249559,
-0.0113599207,
0.0278325938,
-0.0500105321,
-0.0165113732,
-0.0027409764,
0.022410959,
0.0244856495,
-0.0045463666,
-0.0280330833,
-0.0182075426,
-0.0319338478,
0.0517464951,
0.0446183197,
-0.0310126375,
-0.0101771988,
0.0037698159,
0.0415541567,
0.0016130098,
0.0134113654,
0.042579852,
-0.0616761036,
-0.0610911958,
-0.0516626202,
0.0009234725,
-0.0018142685,
0.0964167789,
-0.0098513858,
-0.0527750067,
0.0142049333,
0.0108217858,
-0.035365779,
-0.0216557626,
-0.0815095529,
0.038259048,
0.0239666328,
-0.0433544964,
-0.0185252912,
0.0425221547,
0.0204243045,
0.0308123007,
0.0191669166,
0.040612407,
2.038758805e-34,
0.0359383337,
0.0207185224,
-0.0095339548,
-0.0457094647,
-0.0267930087,
0.0101818135,
-0.0169014558,
-0.0298504476,
0.0195404664,
-0.0376632847,
0.0075944606
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.02628v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.02628v1 | SkipDecode: Autoregressive Skip Decoding with Batching and Caching for Efficient LLM Inference | 2023-07-05T19:59:09 | 2023-07-05T19:59:09 | Luciano Del Corro, Allie Del Giorno, Sahaj Agarwal, Bin Yu, Ahmed Awadallah, Subhabrata Mukherjee | cs.CL | cs.CL | Autoregressive large language models (LLMs) have made remarkable progress in
various natural language generation tasks. However, they incur high computation
cost and latency resulting from the autoregressive token-by-token generation.
To address this issue, several approaches have been proposed to reduce
computational cost using early-exit strategies. These strategies enable faster
text generation using reduced computation without applying the full computation
graph to each token. While existing token-level early exit methods show
promising results for online inference, they cannot be readily applied for
batch inferencing and Key-Value caching. This is because they have to wait
until the last token in a batch exits before they can stop computing. This
severely limits the practical application of such techniques. In this paper, we
propose a simple and effective token-level early exit method, SkipDecode,
designed to work seamlessly with batch inferencing and KV caching. It overcomes
prior constraints by setting up a singular exit point for every token in a
batch at each sequence position. It also guarantees a monotonic decrease in
exit points, thereby eliminating the need to recompute KV Caches for preceding
tokens. Rather than terminating computation prematurely as in prior works, our
approach bypasses lower to middle layers, devoting most of the computational
resources to upper layers, allowing later tokens to benefit from the compute
expenditure by earlier tokens. Our experimental results show that SkipDecode
can obtain 2x to 5x inference speedups with negligible regression across a
variety of tasks. This is achieved using OPT models of 1.3 billion and 6.7
billion parameters, all the while being directly compatible with batching and
KV caching optimization techniques. | [
0.0173008833,
0.0592074879,
-0.0017889391,
-0.0006932711,
-0.0210052133,
0.0214700028,
0.0105016055,
0.0007132522,
0.0054539028,
-0.0295578428,
0.0276026614,
-0.030096598,
0.0064901025,
0.046535857,
0.0326066464,
0.0125341732,
0.0352117829,
-0.0707645118,
-0.0064277016,
-0.0390837006,
-0.043037381,
0.0214997903,
0.0198675767,
0.0379794985,
-0.0019868743,
-0.0143071748,
-0.0383420214,
0.0159860831,
-0.0119879246,
-0.0265330598,
-0.0045865215,
0.0150751304,
0.0228425432,
0.019531548,
0.0000023982,
-0.0165277887,
-0.0321353823,
-0.0001492395,
-0.0597703755,
0.0394479036,
0.0112980194,
-0.0114000374,
-0.0110786445,
0.0283175185,
0.0201758724,
-0.0327711515,
0.0528808385,
-0.0296455212,
0.0294751935,
0.053706374,
0.006206146,
-0.0238017999,
0.0021394263,
-0.0150951091,
0.0046057762,
-0.0586923957,
0.0113514448,
-0.0162992589,
-0.0115806814,
-0.0332380272,
-0.0235358775,
0.0530094318,
0.0435586646,
0.0150211221,
-0.0079760756,
0.0668832585,
0.0006516287,
-0.0474408306,
-0.0221708566,
0.0243359618,
-0.0398252234,
-0.0497810058,
0.0399207324,
-0.0135794934,
-0.0255873315,
-0.0434423275,
-0.0245710053,
0.0585984364,
-0.013023993,
0.0143335387,
0.056993708,
-0.0000068036,
0.031894695,
0.0060989764,
-0.0451095067,
0.0518955998,
0.0393160619,
0.0136888847,
-0.0443479158,
0.0001239661,
-0.0143648209,
-0.0780366734,
0.0203433856,
0.0300910007,
-0.0311780684,
0.0040500578,
-0.0780630335,
-0.003866622,
-0.0068233144,
-0.002443519,
0.0306745209,
0.0536982641,
0.0051974473,
0.0101401694,
-0.0634873733,
0.0416883603,
-0.0243714079,
-0.0492966771,
-0.0363802686,
-0.023421526,
0.0231910702,
-0.0207303036,
-0.052499596,
0.0621941686,
-0.034485653,
-0.0039971299,
-0.0465857685,
0.0230652802,
0.0311389323,
-0.0018512501,
0.0119014103,
0.0106396405,
-0.0405443199,
-0.0043928586,
0.029952839,
-0.0084970361,
-0.0397358052,
-0.008261418,
-0.002195678,
-0.0719935447,
-0.0286939293,
0.0298383087,
0.0318841226,
-0.0084411204,
0.0147756487,
0.0832356215,
0.003199327,
-0.0076244259,
-0.05195475,
-0.0772214606,
0.0059163622,
-0.0741353333,
0.0131438188,
-0.0784245208,
0.0238916446,
0.0424939878,
-0.0156781618,
0.0103581231,
0.0067198379,
0.0412135199,
-0.0207090713,
0.0138358967,
-0.0111522879,
0.0227770694,
0.0121983299,
-0.0137539422,
-0.0108456397,
0.0738346726,
0.0328657553,
0.0687636361,
0.0161141716,
0.0103357928,
-0.0258231852,
0.0438838787,
0.0524203368,
-0.0212289467,
-0.0080774454,
-0.015160203,
-0.0001535267,
0.0199464317,
0.0484778062,
0.0474242046,
-0.0425700806,
0.0185141116,
0.0213616546,
0.0575555041,
-0.0003375067,
0.0116799735,
0.0571740158,
0.0209490117,
-0.0222390052,
-0.0130236438,
-0.0064837644,
0.0520043038,
0.0196174849,
0.0206035282,
0.0913810208,
0.0579019561,
-0.0256028417,
-0.0145747298,
-0.0079906695,
-0.0137155149,
-0.015671771,
-0.0020790154,
0.0417278148,
0.0218074396,
-0.0706594437,
0.0375573151,
0.0199451223,
-0.0618445687,
-0.0157395806,
-0.0495505892,
0.0266954396,
0.0486545712,
0.057827916,
0.0556819737,
-0.0106787104,
0.0220169406,
0.0024202585,
0.0417003445,
-0.0020819067,
0.0025981921,
0.0176856499,
-0.0769833177,
-0.019187022,
0.0009473017,
0.0056194989,
0.0396221094,
0.0487426482,
0.0220057312,
0.0553594865,
-0.0354156382,
-0.0019995193,
-0.0019134063,
-0.0660961941,
-0.0151207848,
0.0466981493,
0.0191395599,
0.0210074764,
-0.002452391,
0.0099691916,
0.0359313637,
0.0213123839,
-0.0628268868,
-0.0113560166,
0.0107397577,
-0.0554613359,
-0.0939495787,
-0.0102029601,
-0.0176272132,
-0.0092490744,
-0.0192377679,
-0.0140422434,
-0.0456233807,
0.0276382212,
-0.0544465892,
0.0867395476,
-0.0377075635,
0.0255192369,
0.0276287012,
0.0063413656,
0.0142652765,
0.0505294092,
-0.0436847098,
0.0043991948,
0.0097439606,
0.0294010974,
-0.030559985,
-0.0394546725,
-0.010675136,
-0.0033780693,
-0.0144545268,
-0.0245693363,
0.0013435486,
0.0154903159,
-0.0009103235,
-0.0083483998,
-0.0962026492,
0.0199182183,
-0.0134274438,
0.0221367385,
-0.0140367523,
0.0154105937,
0.0025222222,
-0.008652566,
-0.0261408351,
0.0052333819,
0.0200066119,
0.0282131787,
-0.0101407757,
-0.0188503731,
-0.0369278379,
0.0140796285,
-0.0170732141,
0.0145452414,
0.0528784804,
-0.0211617909,
-0.0373971425,
-0.0372675098,
0.0258660279,
-0.0138611961,
-0.0009285799,
-0.0059150145,
-0.0300041139,
-0.0108804638,
-0.0207822826,
0.0527436249,
0.0102275498,
0.0158319864,
0.0028235517,
-0.012007392,
-0.0415704921,
-0.0360918008,
0.0113983592,
-0.0283519626,
0.0091341417,
0.009631509,
-0.0512747765,
-0.0080780331,
0.0631950349,
0.032084845,
-0.0055373949,
-0.0691924468,
0.0005033978,
0.0111704925,
-0.0369231068,
-0.0155636491,
-0.0022507438,
-0.0023062932,
0.0142310252,
-0.0141212298,
-0.0615231209,
0.0579213686,
-0.0503850393,
0.0056087244,
0.0009466902,
0.002043192,
-0.0296174493,
0.0406478047,
0.001092913,
0.0267657898,
-0.0063877227,
-0.0392894559,
-0.0008041161,
0.0734366402,
-0.020470703,
-0.0443471633,
0.0168537125,
-0.0227918867,
0.007343635,
-0.0030910426,
-0.0298169889,
-0.0492635295,
-0.0060654758,
-0.0062009203,
-0.0103051318,
0.0518957414,
-0.013145267,
0.0051223696,
0.0331872366,
-0.0272558816,
0.0495291129,
-0.0309558436,
0.0309364162,
-0.0263866913,
0.0241491124,
0.048780825,
-0.0385051332,
0.0261983629,
-0.0579528585,
0.0164455362,
0.062210802,
0.0646706671,
0.01717286,
-0.0098582907,
0.0185698792,
0.051186122,
0.0091082929,
-0.0200171079,
0.0358876549,
0.0330946445,
-0.0712931678,
-0.0232159439,
0.0977159142,
0.0098884301,
-0.015285857,
0.0103544956,
0.0252014678,
0.0441123657,
-0.0114936,
0.0096846269,
-0.0889802277,
-0.0393284038,
0.0441253595,
0.0347972438,
-0.0301270913,
-0.0267171673,
-0.0370382331,
-0.1337005198,
0.04817985,
0.0200881343,
-0.0128337676,
-0.027637789,
-0.023429472,
-0.0639646798,
0.0315172635,
0.0148857171,
0.0611059591,
0.008701914,
0.0044723353,
0.0200773738,
-0.0107348505,
-0.0092857955,
0.0118043264,
-0.0118562886,
0.0457603857,
0.0410230532,
0.0194633957,
0.0392852128,
0.0078201955,
0.0727202296,
-0.0148494877,
0.0165666342,
-0.0447718091,
-0.0102226697,
-0.0243595894,
-0.0005045757,
-0.0146813365,
0.0407280885,
-0.0157041084,
-0.0158773921,
-0.0031641659,
0.0556398332,
-0.0153339915,
-0.055532448,
-0.0089974413,
0.0016206622,
-0.0188265406,
0.0691128075,
0.0206544325,
-0.0365410857,
-0.064900659,
-0.0290009305,
-0.0199389849,
-0.0815789253,
0.0310909655,
-0.0214147549,
-0.0047421292,
-0.0481087491,
-0.0459830984,
0.0196232349,
0.0227213819,
0.0516473651,
-0.0278358813,
0.0238289628,
0.0083162012,
-0.0209145769,
-0.0675971657,
-0.0133107482,
-0.0277182069,
-0.0022170956,
-0.0772053525,
-0.0063803536,
0.0324895009,
-0.0460175127,
-0.0037624193,
0.0438086316,
-0.1106683016,
-0.084327586,
-0.0214301385,
0.0318978801,
0.0119364923,
0.0852615908,
0.0231239423,
-0.0621334724,
0.1112214923,
0.0574879013,
-0.0388517752,
0.0349781066,
-0.0153018748,
0.0278809574,
0.0015137782,
0.0306748301,
-0.0384127423,
-0.0105701201,
-0.0256968718,
0.0668597519,
0.0166507717,
0.0026417691,
-0.0016898889,
0.0295809302,
-0.0028043969,
-0.0440195017,
0.0134142637,
-0.0089668911,
0.0510485545,
-0.0175306126,
-0.0144196283,
-0.0630259365,
0.0437932573,
-0.0088331159,
-0.0000661899,
-0.0069109341,
-0.0077062328,
0.0456731804,
0.0240008812,
0.0037027176,
-0.0013403762,
-0.0384035818,
0.0336014852,
0.0546709672,
-0.0530226417,
-0.037361104,
0.0154743716,
0.0071996409,
0.0087672854,
-0.0598989055,
0.0160862897,
0.0239598807,
0.0332566611,
-0.025189681,
0.0144547559,
-0.0210973304,
-0.0301220082,
-0.0554425828,
0.0082596829,
0.0436168537,
0.0187160224,
0.0390045941,
-0.040534988,
0.0050522434,
-0.0285375919,
0.0444219224,
0.0015496126,
-0.0469553433,
0.0140315788,
0.0187351983,
-0.0338086672,
-0.0090079335,
0.0695747808,
0.0574985743,
0.0378570035,
-0.0156501364,
-0.001809002,
-0.0235209968,
-0.031307634,
-0.0351577289,
0.0100999903,
-0.0150175737,
0.019880401,
-0.0058549601,
-0.0689620525,
-0.006088133,
0.0037730974,
-0.0068403557,
0.0056244736,
0.0346184075,
0.0465302542,
0.0092649898,
-0.0431254767,
-0.0517619848,
0.0495231189,
0.014481511,
-0.0196319222,
0.0222986396,
-7.578491426e-33,
-0.0318290405,
-0.0563047193,
0.0328447372,
-0.0110607352,
-0.0159687977,
0.0192685518,
-0.0412937999,
-0.0368434153,
0.038384065,
-0.0263791587,
0.0056334669,
0.0103799803,
0.0346533582,
0.0268932506,
-0.0006690967,
0.0183906667,
0.0742624104,
-0.0009978308,
0.0084652603,
0.0409120172,
0.0402833559,
0.049000185,
0.0111204525,
0.011788859,
-0.0367936976,
-0.0203272402,
0.0210661814,
-0.0225865003,
0.0067966538,
0.0057026604,
-0.02403819,
0.0119071165,
0.0122376112,
-0.0143174734,
-0.0303657465,
0.0111122318,
-0.0716853216,
-0.009611465,
0.0221036766,
-0.0009873967,
0.0033888901,
-0.0633753836,
0.0154487547,
0.0244496055,
-0.040546041,
0.0122480886,
-0.0148545047,
0.0082335593,
-0.0386529975,
-0.0703237727,
-0.022854574,
0.0525535382,
0.0156517066,
0.0026758404,
0.0478092097,
0.0409062393,
-0.0106931319,
0.0386100411,
-0.0448400043,
0.0337262824,
0.0013916679,
0.0723475516,
0.0723624378,
0.0297981426,
0.0451463684,
0.0213136207,
0.0677584931,
-0.0261169728,
-0.0423741303,
0.0516228639,
0.0227727313,
0.0127322264,
-0.0513990931,
-0.0047543836,
0.0623698905,
-0.0206969213,
-0.0575123057,
-0.015320899,
-0.0106879724,
0.0279760286,
0.0683929548,
-0.0122182528,
-0.0086646387,
-0.040320687,
-0.0510616526,
-0.0329659209,
-0.0453727804,
-0.0000353364,
0.0425640941,
0.0600184985,
-0.0193812847,
-0.0496390723,
0.0561103038,
-0.0206472352,
-0.002837721,
0.0168628916,
-0.0036398997,
-0.0214835443,
-0.0167820398,
0.0541306771,
-0.02727383,
-0.0505746379,
0.0060481941,
-0.0398555025,
0.0294033326,
0.0084548825,
-0.0392495878,
0.0416210406,
-0.0579771698,
-0.0121185444,
-0.0574992262,
0.0255926866,
-0.0021592507,
-0.005835399,
0.0639097616,
-0.0167587567,
0.0067232512,
0.0634977967,
-0.0051201289,
0.040998172,
-0.0025683451,
-0.0346600823,
0.0323119275,
0.0423004702,
-0.0323291905,
0.0225328486,
-0.0353365168,
-0.0084788399,
0.0306912418,
-0.055844184,
-0.0378834382,
0.0774495751,
3.149e-7,
-0.0147643853,
0.046287179,
0.0737228468,
0.0320434049,
0.0091300048,
0.0180212036,
0.022962112,
-0.0151757086,
0.0131072681,
0.0308143832,
-0.0012036976,
0.0037502078,
0.0652092323,
0.0108215036,
-0.0905750841,
0.0608941503,
-0.0630165488,
0.012815157,
-0.066482991,
-0.053413406,
-0.0075351154,
0.067463696,
-0.0447821021,
-0.0141892564,
0.0358941704,
0.014092356,
0.040932849,
0.0157131497,
-0.0420984067,
0.003463885,
-0.0042270413,
0.008413774,
-0.0012846015,
-0.0027920655,
-0.0252542011,
0.0124417851,
-0.0010587694,
0.0594974123,
0.030611027,
-0.0608201437,
0.0570493229,
-0.0230803825,
-0.0232034326,
-0.0420213863,
0.087049827,
-0.0292614903,
-0.0032334144,
-0.0468979031,
-0.0052677202,
0.0072596697,
-0.0419145375,
-0.0273554437,
0.0022388168,
0.042867668,
0.0347106569,
-0.0071782856,
-0.0009172123,
-0.0742844492,
-0.0323216692,
-0.0225673467,
-0.0772439092,
-0.0564431213,
-0.0696932599,
0.0348478332,
0.0346029475,
-0.0380390473,
-0.0185172185,
3.494139968e-34,
0.0414739735,
-0.0472841598,
-0.008831881,
0.0361952782,
0.0221965294,
-0.0302227214,
-0.0143817402,
0.0487718768,
-0.0115165627,
-0.0664813966,
-0.0864028335
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.02615v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.02615v1 | Human Inspired Progressive Alignment and Comparative Learning for Grounded Word Acquisition | 2023-07-05T19:38:04 | 2023-07-05T19:38:04 | Yuwei Bao, Barrett Martin Lattimer, Joyce Chai | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Human language acquisition is an efficient, supervised, and continual
process. In this work, we took inspiration from how human babies acquire their
first language, and developed a computational process for word acquisition
through comparative learning. Motivated by cognitive findings, we generated a
small dataset that enables the computation models to compare the similarities
and differences of various attributes, learn to filter out and extract the
common information for each shared linguistic label. We frame the acquisition
of words as not only the information filtration process, but also as
representation-symbol mapping. This procedure does not involve a fixed
vocabulary size, nor a discriminative objective, and allows the models to
continually learn more concepts efficiently. Our results in controlled
experiments have shown the potential of this approach for efficient continual
learning of grounded words. | [
-0.0086293397,
0.0599501356,
-0.0138779068,
-0.0051444899,
-0.0366665311,
0.0360377729,
-0.0628735721,
-0.0546526387,
-0.0446866937,
0.0056786733,
-0.0282334164,
-0.0325416625,
0.0622331202,
-0.009271401,
-0.0133235892,
-0.0070601357,
0.0548615642,
0.0395565815,
-0.0285737943,
0.0049465359,
0.0031387387,
0.009205183,
-0.0366802402,
-0.0197343715,
-0.029481316,
0.0130454721,
-0.0200044438,
-0.0536625981,
0.0270580836,
-0.020223882,
-0.0140441507,
0.0572535358,
0.0401077941,
0.0303470697,
0.0000019082,
-0.0374599397,
-0.0057441453,
-0.0259404741,
-0.0087500308,
-0.0688815266,
0.0317960717,
-0.0110407658,
-0.0086191287,
-0.0091724293,
-0.0658642426,
-0.0064961095,
0.0940620154,
0.010778565,
-0.0103108222,
0.0031904364,
-0.0188995078,
-0.053783983,
0.0163041223,
-0.0038185278,
0.0024651131,
0.0054333308,
-0.0215776712,
0.0580605045,
-0.0158645324,
-0.0391490534,
-0.039488785,
0.0180538148,
0.0022319867,
0.037659537,
0.0789321736,
0.069415234,
0.0178860091,
-0.0617609695,
-0.0020808741,
0.0776387453,
-0.0320495702,
-0.0682260841,
0.0054775649,
-0.0056660962,
-0.0067210793,
-0.0087994905,
0.0014680184,
0.0423014686,
-0.0212772638,
0.0789647624,
0.0222372841,
-0.0218597036,
-0.0051410324,
0.0398758128,
-0.0288302004,
0.0530938879,
0.0211807657,
-0.0317979939,
0.0472036153,
0.0227265321,
0.0020317894,
-0.0111900596,
-0.0034659279,
0.0050955247,
0.002662014,
0.0383544862,
-0.0606285855,
0.008307226,
0.0196459424,
-0.0334013887,
0.0438250452,
0.0321091935,
-0.0069394656,
0.0614270158,
-0.0596366823,
0.0186651777,
0.0194929391,
0.0073192166,
-0.0706767738,
0.0203713197,
-0.0509271398,
-0.0240915529,
0.0014079388,
0.0529677458,
-0.0207141098,
-0.0220624134,
-0.0462999009,
0.0223856419,
0.0047964496,
-0.0154216411,
-0.0144505901,
-0.0119174886,
-0.0553173795,
0.0222945008,
-0.0392855294,
-0.007322629,
-0.0764325932,
0.0586718246,
-0.0307966471,
-0.0130560249,
-0.0167119857,
0.0095989611,
0.0129540553,
-0.0257620588,
0.0026145703,
-0.0000598582,
-0.0590469241,
-0.0397171415,
-0.0122434041,
0.0107298968,
0.0150991566,
-0.048970487,
-0.0011165154,
-0.0472830459,
0.044903297,
0.0146652032,
-0.0329701416,
-0.1054657325,
0.0071763601,
0.0313820206,
-0.0173162296,
0.1054289192,
-0.0053715077,
0.0080313655,
-0.0052524321,
-0.0201388355,
0.0258392747,
0.0765985921,
0.0202904288,
-0.0229566991,
-0.0092292242,
-0.029046569,
-0.0675331801,
-0.0200528894,
0.0482942462,
-0.004031464,
-0.0652629659,
-0.0151280109,
0.0436115116,
0.0524052382,
0.0176764913,
0.0206259415,
-0.0196914375,
-0.0083963322,
0.0512324758,
0.0941102579,
-0.0438920781,
0.0031087052,
-0.0113241039,
0.0060612168,
-0.0271196049,
0.010042144,
-0.0376332738,
0.0232063048,
-0.0245785546,
0.0054546231,
-0.0440017544,
0.0493865348,
-0.0144562181,
0.0039662821,
-0.0111768236,
-0.0053042821,
0.0789171606,
-0.0459312238,
0.0200001355,
0.0487849228,
-0.0451582558,
0.0770219117,
0.0756947771,
-0.0283476207,
-0.0156117817,
-0.0019634601,
0.0107230144,
-0.0067907581,
-0.0187087916,
-0.0140785789,
-0.0496762618,
0.0145632643,
0.0313274264,
0.0635224432,
-0.0255890191,
0.0026725936,
-0.035051588,
-0.0469396189,
-0.0138477739,
0.0442828014,
-0.0136046261,
0.0104433121,
0.0089314552,
0.0116969785,
-0.0022364187,
-0.0173205324,
-0.0227015074,
0.0832446143,
-0.0193070844,
0.0016032171,
-0.0155654289,
0.0337431282,
0.0145564741,
-0.0224452149,
0.0311077274,
0.018276915,
0.0445861332,
-0.0082342699,
0.0099687362,
0.0691395402,
-0.0316034295,
0.0110103535,
0.0448270664,
-0.0355266258,
-0.0279383846,
-0.0259862803,
-0.0031744838,
-0.0156368222,
0.0092679812,
-0.0232816208,
0.0529860854,
-0.0173234716,
0.0670350865,
-0.0182334129,
0.0089645218,
-0.0291761961,
0.0810267776,
-0.0049784319,
0.0288160685,
-0.0158507768,
-0.0219764002,
-0.0124118458,
-0.0175641477,
0.0284655672,
0.0013791024,
-0.0102372309,
-0.0255201627,
-0.0168497991,
0.0035273335,
-0.074436076,
0.0000459306,
-0.0551665425,
-0.0103111062,
0.0535386205,
0.0386339761,
0.0441930145,
-0.0290487856,
0.0335506015,
-0.0135480464,
-0.0259482898,
0.0487919562,
-0.0329036303,
0.0308203045,
0.0641833693,
-0.0233424287,
-0.0619929731,
-0.0397671685,
-0.0068934183,
-0.0199672859,
0.0098400069,
0.0243519042,
-0.0117898444,
-0.0238346457,
-0.0083677676,
-0.0339408293,
-0.0009765333,
0.0355421416,
-0.0240773614,
0.0299631115,
0.0197930411,
0.014475272,
0.0696674883,
0.0404863097,
0.0497325659,
0.0337391049,
0.0135768037,
-0.0449879467,
-0.0339236557,
-0.0350797176,
0.0189132467,
-0.0056666536,
0.0182321277,
-0.0330754519,
0.076441355,
0.0048068683,
0.0089869685,
-0.0794812068,
0.0644280985,
-0.025600804,
-0.0118714944,
-0.0693685934,
0.00096691,
-0.0439001098,
0.0003234375,
-0.0663187429,
-0.0492072888,
0.0753526241,
0.0182273872,
0.0112014692,
-0.0607064702,
0.007831159,
0.02327298,
0.056291081,
-0.0022355292,
0.0411070175,
-0.0466634557,
-0.0205678735,
-0.090120703,
0.0319528133,
0.0660276487,
-0.0147766499,
0.064649947,
-0.0530965105,
0.032078933,
-0.0000797545,
-0.0199825596,
-0.064805761,
-0.019905122,
-0.0106654782,
0.0007106664,
-0.0390267,
0.0199084803,
-0.0488904491,
0.0096974233,
-0.0108336173,
0.0143863261,
0.0341274664,
0.0194113664,
-0.0146971643,
-0.0258096606,
0.0187098552,
0.0052301921,
-0.0236543752,
0.0077242893,
0.0308566447,
0.0517203473,
0.0607768111,
-0.01163546,
0.0199803784,
0.0173601527,
0.0335716493,
-0.0494478047,
0.0171664488,
-0.0067373891,
0.0121023571,
0.0234527159,
-0.0380413122,
0.0729214773,
0.0497275852,
0.0230081491,
0.0531550348,
0.0044128359,
0.0430788845,
0.0286663454,
-0.0185016394,
-0.0355939791,
-0.0107929315,
0.0194206145,
-0.0085722273,
0.0344025306,
-0.0449811928,
-0.0085692592,
-0.073928982,
-0.0636221096,
0.0397231653,
-0.090108268,
-0.0340818651,
-0.030966863,
0.0110120466,
0.0116555551,
-0.0368642621,
0.0326518007,
-0.017216824,
-0.0018853798,
-0.012980503,
0.0529271848,
-0.0259565804,
0.0038462444,
-0.056985382,
0.0498675667,
0.0134569993,
0.0475838222,
-0.0043644863,
-0.0544018894,
0.0381042697,
-0.0304208174,
-0.0316874124,
-0.0139063764,
-0.0171821695,
-0.0062309308,
-0.0083999336,
-0.0064764717,
0.0705040395,
-0.0530632176,
-0.0341556221,
-0.022564372,
0.0650111511,
-0.0018797314,
0.0204658695,
0.0258605871,
0.0018299383,
0.0088305147,
0.0861059502,
0.0156782735,
-0.0755605325,
0.0269014221,
0.0725200847,
0.0040027611,
0.0332948491,
-0.0369452611,
0.0330205709,
-0.0441239476,
0.0146027021,
-0.117826879,
-0.0030054788,
0.0098882439,
0.0427088663,
0.0665274933,
-0.0242722966,
0.0269928705,
-0.044071652,
-0.0932103768,
0.0239190981,
0.0182118062,
0.0114524765,
-0.0620222315,
-0.0464572497,
0.0268373899,
-0.0097385123,
-0.0348169506,
-0.033802595,
-0.020946173,
-0.0538910292,
0.0343908332,
-0.0361242928,
0.0166002661,
0.0404943004,
-0.0172582176,
0.0340518914,
-0.0058615231,
0.032219559,
-0.0157982782,
0.0254090987,
-0.0139058437,
-0.0289645735,
0.0206736419,
0.0201995093,
0.0084303822,
0.0209954381,
0.0246547535,
0.0276029799,
0.0177303776,
-0.0209210645,
0.0460305996,
-0.0035203882,
0.0508034416,
-0.0423450544,
-0.0040685218,
-0.0693969801,
-0.0187410675,
0.0110534374,
0.0022988489,
0.0245111007,
-0.0612335987,
0.0243733283,
0.0232582781,
-0.0081570195,
-0.0292827208,
-0.0128916046,
0.0444022901,
0.0001086029,
-0.0009546097,
-0.0214253981,
0.0173791032,
-0.0040582693,
0.0345796458,
-0.0058664591,
0.0176820215,
-0.0250530355,
0.0615350306,
-0.0402730182,
0.0352350213,
0.0207303185,
0.0093110846,
-0.0256708805,
0.0439934209,
0.0259682126,
0.0389791802,
-0.0771202967,
-0.0113052912,
0.0314114206,
-0.0241771732,
-0.0054398002,
-0.0378735736,
-0.0080002705,
0.0233327709,
-0.0109622404,
-0.069731608,
-0.0271672122,
0.0260512345,
0.0245111007,
-0.0113489321,
-0.0070919911,
0.0329320617,
-0.0519248322,
0.0430916436,
-0.0558099821,
0.0110115614,
-0.0137226339,
0.0083701303,
-0.0058703227,
-0.0076341913,
-0.0308786333,
0.0323867053,
-0.0471898727,
-0.0649314001,
-0.0198762007,
0.0225351434,
0.0053140223,
0.0492377467,
0.0781138986,
0.0138677461,
-0.0399168953,
0.0070756651,
0.0105738183,
0.0518498532,
0.0245296117,
-0.0259747375,
-0.0124748768,
-6.372278469e-33,
-0.053632658,
-0.01258846,
0.0118285976,
-0.0226397682,
-0.0282627642,
-0.0109090321,
0.0163726378,
0.0286657549,
-0.0067387787,
0.0152017446,
0.0293743648,
-0.0028537035,
-0.0059813736,
0.0006817123,
0.0322108865,
0.0064375876,
-0.0086238729,
-0.0205820855,
-0.0067216228,
-0.0360534005,
0.0215248764,
0.0089556044,
0.0428262204,
-0.0614141859,
-0.0520247594,
0.0607506298,
0.0044085137,
0.045269683,
0.0341795757,
0.0593121536,
0.0011460341,
0.0045474963,
0.0163682327,
-0.0149601549,
-0.0012097056,
0.0158123914,
-0.1116834283,
-0.0455420315,
0.0505710989,
0.0238822177,
-0.0083789974,
0.0091259833,
0.0129870689,
-0.0313565284,
-0.0211004466,
0.0271878801,
0.0101143513,
-0.0220469907,
-0.0035171146,
0.0307907443,
-0.1185614243,
-0.0048788753,
0.0101417592,
0.0061426871,
0.0178712644,
-0.0347086601,
-0.0206178017,
-0.022135675,
-0.0713298768,
0.0381944813,
-0.0326724946,
0.0285343304,
0.0750283003,
0.042067904,
0.0383475274,
0.0753495768,
0.024768956,
-0.0525936633,
-0.002333648,
0.0026344028,
0.0396794043,
0.0366821922,
-0.0121784452,
-0.0130777722,
0.0345855281,
-0.0298252236,
-0.0300186239,
0.005844452,
0.0251396615,
0.0580039769,
-0.0065527344,
0.0211959891,
-0.0307487901,
0.0039816829,
-0.0506992377,
-0.0008613489,
-0.0435451344,
-0.0139895231,
0.0381241888,
0.0023712348,
-0.0386954211,
-0.0101691196,
0.0002294349,
-0.0150151737,
-0.0187077243,
-0.0331988446,
0.0270899329,
-0.0260134656,
-0.0028982577,
-0.0121375369,
-0.0695650578,
-0.0943628699,
-0.0045181317,
0.0122522581,
0.0573804565,
0.0128779532,
0.019165732,
-0.0147486636,
-0.0493092239,
-0.005276795,
-0.021415785,
-0.0492112227,
0.0100084934,
-0.0526918732,
0.0601258017,
0.029416509,
-0.0185444746,
0.0220159888,
0.0756592453,
-0.0167763624,
-0.0379159823,
-0.0326914787,
-0.0001985534,
0.047277905,
0.0057828273,
0.0050756307,
0.0188152324,
-0.0007125696,
0.0569445342,
-0.0657499284,
-0.003763112,
0.0338707305,
2.914e-7,
0.0144642508,
0.0608727112,
0.0452935249,
-0.0399882533,
0.0229258761,
-0.0058299797,
-0.0020661668,
0.0137692839,
-0.0252342839,
-0.0431189165,
0.0243172571,
0.0140421391,
0.0250931121,
0.0083172508,
-0.0676500797,
-0.0096313739,
-0.0395457819,
0.0123396516,
-0.0406399965,
0.0060498738,
0.0392260179,
0.0713882446,
0.0057054339,
-0.0135292597,
-0.0111792563,
0.0037687211,
0.0207420904,
-0.0073592085,
0.0703216195,
-0.043648202,
-0.0127464244,
-0.0085000107,
-0.0181375332,
0.0567395948,
-0.0237590466,
0.0151816458,
0.0331060067,
-0.0155716678,
-0.0690554678,
0.0119443769,
-0.0255729146,
0.0028973413,
-0.0008243803,
-0.0272171851,
0.056575194,
-0.0908052325,
-0.0337568894,
0.0145116569,
-0.0168026444,
0.0251454301,
-0.0007399214,
0.0359121673,
-0.0444549434,
0.0035045061,
0.0388183333,
0.0485623181,
-0.033464659,
-0.0596330464,
-0.0076825251,
0.0503471233,
-0.0254457537,
-0.0222947374,
0.0089634573,
-0.0301310197,
0.0177410077,
0.0138723748,
-0.0350834951,
2.097188681e-34,
-0.0405831039,
0.0042948714,
0.058966957,
0.0418719389,
0.0010544591,
-0.0230682418,
0.024601683,
0.0205770507,
0.0293075424,
-0.0472673327,
0.0120123038
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.02599v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.02599v2 | Evade ChatGPT Detectors via A Single Space | 2023-07-05T18:48:28 | 2023-10-13T17:01:11 | Shuyang Cai, Wanyun Cui | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | ChatGPT brings revolutionary social value but also raises concerns about the
misuse of AI-generated text. Consequently, an important question is how to
detect whether texts are generated by ChatGPT or by human. Existing detectors
are built upon the assumption that there are distributional gaps between
human-generated and AI-generated text. These gaps are typically identified
using statistical information or classifiers. Our research challenges the
distributional gap assumption in detectors. We find that detectors do not
effectively discriminate the semantic and stylistic gaps between
human-generated and AI-generated text. Instead, the "subtle differences", such
as an extra space, become crucial for detection. Based on this discovery, we
propose the SpaceInfi strategy to evade detection. Experiments demonstrate the
effectiveness of this strategy across multiple benchmarks and detectors. We
also provide a theoretical explanation for why SpaceInfi is successful in
evading perplexity-based detection. And we empirically show that a phenomenon
called token mutation causes the evasion for language model-based detectors.
Our findings offer new insights and challenges for understanding and
constructing more applicable ChatGPT detectors. | [
0.0801541135,
0.0599152558,
-0.0328644291,
0.0586365163,
-0.0569730811,
0.0114534022,
-0.0062259315,
0.0419802219,
0.0391818322,
-0.0333579034,
0.0012759139,
-0.0140177356,
0.0020202845,
0.0349333845,
0.0374558903,
0.0106082521,
0.0396592841,
0.0086856242,
0.034185905,
0.0086641936,
0.0341910534,
0.008649487,
0.0195348673,
0.044829037,
-0.044880148,
-0.0283114724,
-0.0043700044,
0.0295570344,
-0.0093824966,
-0.0207950976,
0.0195527002,
0.061128445,
-0.0596949495,
0.1218377948,
0.0000017032,
-0.0338042974,
-0.0122199599,
-0.0108562075,
-0.0075104926,
0.0263546966,
0.0683799684,
0.0149837043,
-0.0446549915,
0.019450793,
-0.0577722266,
0.0156751312,
0.057987541,
0.0442111865,
0.0358390845,
0.1005093008,
-0.0302176699,
0.0379522145,
0.0434752405,
-0.0090992376,
0.0335739404,
-0.0181288309,
0.0221374109,
-0.0255204737,
-0.0093744341,
0.0207246467,
-0.0044012922,
0.0379280299,
0.005727455,
-0.0227258429,
-0.0077193487,
0.0304258056,
-0.0763886571,
-0.0345993415,
-0.0338280983,
0.0249888208,
-0.0376817323,
-0.0673256218,
0.0360136852,
0.0074195862,
0.0393063016,
0.0114333862,
0.0055527468,
0.0173891764,
-0.0500205867,
-0.0011093087,
0.0195370968,
0.0009836328,
0.0170781519,
0.0111397039,
0.0182294883,
0.0262925681,
0.0269378256,
-0.0480201654,
-0.0555473045,
-0.0028344456,
-0.0268153548,
-0.0780901685,
0.0386923067,
-0.0029359255,
-0.0151235666,
0.0103349136,
-0.0880255252,
-0.0503722355,
0.0272224452,
-0.0665123686,
-0.0012594333,
0.0171912909,
-0.0160395242,
0.0259355549,
-0.0300724357,
0.0548022576,
-0.0194431525,
0.0574506707,
-0.01847619,
0.0319341421,
-0.021494383,
-0.043160785,
-0.0548329093,
-0.0024469669,
-0.0081209959,
-0.0506134443,
-0.0061732293,
0.0513364039,
0.0020234631,
-0.0083797704,
-0.0264365952,
0.0042541577,
-0.0398593768,
0.0298427008,
0.0254863948,
-0.0248439275,
0.0071660187,
0.0006965839,
-0.0036159758,
-0.0908632055,
-0.0211668164,
0.0562436357,
0.007226387,
-0.0129120406,
-0.007485535,
0.0672190562,
-0.0195474066,
-0.0316867754,
-0.0032294169,
-0.0317935422,
-0.0312894844,
-0.0249114279,
-0.0166230779,
-0.0558503121,
-0.0182726122,
0.0059809494,
-0.0183648281,
-0.0270750578,
0.0104018301,
0.0394997746,
-0.0447559319,
0.0571525283,
-0.0190784205,
0.0020955328,
0.0361564979,
-0.0001218218,
-0.0290488787,
0.0580817051,
0.0332890153,
0.0382043533,
0.0925508961,
0.0273927674,
0.0323300809,
0.0502616875,
0.0066380342,
0.0252032038,
0.0082981428,
-0.0281354934,
-0.0048385244,
0.0023252424,
0.0229010582,
0.0544620603,
-0.0157007147,
-0.0353369117,
0.0453130454,
0.0963058099,
-0.0140234325,
0.0357551128,
0.0288245119,
0.0452790707,
0.0013823693,
0.0645502582,
-0.0250344574,
-0.0318146832,
-0.0527775735,
-0.0282222703,
0.0240068827,
0.0061098076,
-0.0021436918,
-0.0098438524,
-0.0201085322,
-0.0048122793,
0.0512330085,
-0.0745631233,
0.0183259193,
0.0329702497,
-0.0459344797,
-0.0017148011,
0.004021632,
-0.0365097448,
0.0078715747,
-0.0831463933,
0.0171967559,
0.05860563,
0.0814511999,
-0.0028797938,
0.0278199222,
0.0086735049,
0.0081617525,
0.0446515083,
0.0204209778,
-0.0004055387,
-0.0290491395,
0.0095869638,
-0.005404837,
0.005241842,
0.0231811162,
0.0120829679,
0.0375852361,
0.0256745759,
0.0081039704,
-0.0404795855,
-0.0067052334,
0.0494389944,
0.0149538601,
0.0088556102,
-0.0214206595,
0.0068116775,
0.0325178728,
-0.0164478831,
-0.0317881107,
0.0256343931,
-0.0273073222,
-0.0233023148,
-0.0398939587,
0.0244317669,
-0.0187625792,
-0.0502073616,
0.029927874,
-0.0458221138,
-0.0260647759,
0.0295231789,
0.0010972833,
-0.0087554595,
0.0217977799,
-0.0651419312,
0.0690774769,
-0.0773127973,
0.0312358569,
-0.020381324,
0.031215176,
-0.0387741588,
0.0619096607,
0.0023961379,
-0.0134912832,
-0.0155247767,
0.0330803357,
0.0674262345,
-0.00853997,
0.0196968075,
0.0227747075,
-0.0223477911,
0.0142684663,
0.0383752845,
0.0486475341,
-0.033069931,
-0.0620390363,
-0.1015432179,
-0.0091019161,
-0.0251067337,
0.0146204419,
0.0453761928,
0.0034531178,
-0.0230052974,
0.0040345881,
-0.0345830694,
-0.0249022115,
0.0149211725,
0.0141594419,
0.0588492416,
-0.0352735296,
-0.0078089191,
-0.0323578529,
0.0055866879,
-0.0409133099,
0.0436667204,
0.0448849872,
-0.0616625138,
-0.0516527928,
0.0287600327,
-0.0042457911,
0.0202167686,
0.0034832745,
-0.0727184489,
0.0105620865,
-0.0234436952,
0.0221715923,
0.0724535957,
0.0534877069,
0.0331292264,
-0.0063233962,
0.0261134487,
-0.0369515195,
-0.0231310353,
0.0231451374,
0.0174085796,
-0.0046989513,
-0.0136806825,
0.0249751005,
0.018110266,
0.0151779419,
-0.0152871292,
-0.0667873621,
0.0360614248,
-0.0228888765,
-0.0392493121,
0.0083816005,
-0.0333816558,
-0.0523978956,
0.020188747,
-0.0473954789,
-0.0600737371,
0.0618910827,
-0.0451044179,
0.0032110012,
-0.0660368055,
0.0142383603,
-0.032493379,
0.0270944461,
0.0038743971,
0.0365319923,
0.0010583149,
-0.0582614951,
-0.0429544151,
0.0306840595,
0.0470804982,
-0.0106045855,
-0.0092642698,
-0.013882379,
0.0053276578,
0.0083416225,
-0.0339952782,
-0.0649870634,
-0.0916251689,
0.0169067457,
-0.0257554688,
0.0446074493,
-0.0594484322,
-0.0059320563,
0.0037936696,
-0.0191784427,
0.0422238111,
-0.0392182171,
-0.0132245002,
-0.0317613222,
0.0633125082,
0.03140397,
-0.0729400218,
0.0063569965,
-0.0288093798,
-0.013413134,
0.0880331919,
-0.0072165998,
0.0297275055,
0.0221573394,
-0.008063253,
0.0167611614,
0.0202755127,
-0.040346697,
0.0167443119,
0.041723974,
-0.0014286967,
-0.0187245701,
0.1049959362,
0.0421363041,
-0.027656002,
0.0176360477,
-0.0182796996,
0.054606095,
-0.005355055,
-0.0026719207,
-0.0753449872,
-0.0187285636,
0.0290972423,
-0.0159161054,
-0.0396846309,
0.0148014454,
-0.0223511402,
-0.071294494,
0.0300993472,
0.0277468655,
-0.0627325773,
0.0125286086,
-0.006688952,
-0.0054280153,
0.0294032581,
-0.0211034548,
-0.0221665036,
-0.0165747628,
0.0284945108,
-0.0182852279,
-0.0200359412,
-0.0113537265,
-0.0365946367,
-0.0349419788,
0.0423473455,
0.0721569732,
0.0455495752,
-0.0049253693,
-0.046970129,
0.0428083986,
0.0137098152,
0.0085480027,
-0.0246795416,
0.058152128,
-0.004307386,
0.0034338923,
-0.0178273078,
0.0279409904,
-0.0256537683,
0.0042084553,
0.0206359681,
0.0193292499,
-0.0068082488,
-0.0421755724,
-0.0165748913,
-0.0045212656,
0.0370268673,
0.0759714618,
0.0307618286,
-0.0295699686,
-0.0736455545,
-0.0444222577,
0.0491515175,
-0.0215848684,
-0.0196517352,
-0.0095655685,
0.0157154091,
-0.0885028616,
-0.0877089202,
-0.0403622799,
-0.0505182594,
0.0325252414,
0.0082563907,
-0.0167060737,
-0.0400174148,
0.0126399184,
-0.035034854,
-0.0398405641,
-0.0279992186,
0.0200670753,
-0.0278307647,
0.0100037623,
-0.0268763434,
-0.0222418848,
-0.0118536642,
0.0102743767,
-0.0918699801,
-0.0532652959,
0.0139870467,
-0.0171038397,
0.02505528,
0.034666542,
-0.0457658842,
-0.0195265636,
0.0490778796,
0.0633382201,
-0.0235561728,
0.039977029,
0.04416053,
-0.0265831165,
0.0055446611,
0.0268336348,
-0.0165867992,
-0.0080376649,
0.0200305469,
0.0016920186,
-0.0297337882,
0.0026778353,
0.0225582365,
0.0343825221,
0.0261001475,
-0.0157589875,
0.0167277027,
-0.0126440506,
-0.0317571498,
-0.0397134349,
-0.009595762,
-0.0381524637,
-0.0130266566,
0.0022777345,
0.0058314553,
-0.0092552882,
0.0104494831,
-0.0404505394,
0.0670850873,
0.0066929641,
-0.0232954808,
0.0100025265,
0.0571701787,
0.0230733622,
0.0038935281,
-0.0000877125,
0.0401876494,
0.0106352465,
0.0156262461,
-0.0144727258,
0.033061333,
0.0273802727,
-0.0481905267,
0.000539715,
0.0503278822,
-0.0807146803,
-0.0009005781,
-0.0181459635,
0.0588035807,
0.0462461226,
0.0141118085,
0.0436469279,
-0.0281441566,
-0.0201047715,
-0.0015569506,
0.0080544446,
0.0028462994,
-0.0448514633,
-0.0441806316,
-0.0147118429,
-0.0360005684,
-0.0142662469,
0.0934219435,
0.0046811039,
0.0274984501,
-0.0183526836,
-0.0454106294,
-0.0332360268,
-0.0104739321,
0.0301150903,
0.0185588412,
0.0338500924,
0.0346834064,
-0.0441608988,
-0.056255769,
-0.0041429494,
0.0090804258,
0.0223570913,
0.0248729009,
-0.0178817883,
0.1026838347,
-0.0206609108,
-0.0215008669,
-0.0455259718,
-0.0098816361,
0.0205846336,
-0.0281643402,
-0.0497469939,
-5.769147378e-33,
0.0050621154,
-0.0752613097,
-0.0479052067,
0.0380167626,
-0.0068807532,
0.0096968645,
-0.0344677493,
-0.0043795039,
0.0182813033,
0.0105489455,
-0.0230592899,
0.0458115004,
0.0030596862,
-0.0006384857,
-0.0134965349,
-0.0202249847,
0.0553041287,
-0.0030079414,
-0.0382744558,
0.0154144336,
0.0137048,
-0.0073919441,
-0.0078813154,
-0.0702661127,
0.019075023,
-0.0347625017,
-0.0410308242,
0.002493639,
-0.0103344945,
0.0614930466,
-0.0030871064,
0.0331733711,
0.015911229,
0.0348434821,
-0.0184909888,
0.0516886972,
-0.0221305583,
-0.0461192839,
0.0020909656,
0.0238586236,
-0.0090684937,
-0.0735216588,
0.0487894863,
-0.0457808971,
-0.0233243629,
0.010236037,
0.0620042868,
-0.0020862941,
0.0160516705,
0.0013251484,
-0.0534395836,
0.0235363059,
-0.0273475703,
0.0017895399,
-0.0044933059,
0.0195747316,
0.0373030677,
-0.0156864151,
-0.0307362229,
0.0445276573,
-0.018070776,
-0.0063693188,
0.0161772538,
0.0088553578,
0.0139870485,
0.0619848445,
0.0429182388,
0.0386714637,
0.0089179948,
-0.0430093184,
0.0181077477,
-0.0122675402,
0.0380066969,
0.0569563024,
0.0184234846,
-0.0345204435,
-0.0384907275,
0.015773382,
0.0174725521,
-0.0214700699,
0.0016056696,
0.0169945434,
-0.0985122547,
-0.0230039898,
0.0139731225,
-0.0703713819,
-0.0279204492,
-0.0361264125,
0.0285682436,
-0.0020725424,
-0.0237301458,
-0.0210026987,
0.0069289724,
-0.0658839867,
-0.0076629007,
0.0200289637,
-0.037091665,
-0.0041363519,
0.0047337897,
0.0375345014,
0.0201210827,
-0.0177030358,
0.0464371219,
0.0307900887,
0.035264492,
-0.0029477431,
0.0498335399,
0.0212277342,
-0.0718982518,
-0.0004818013,
-0.0070744017,
0.0109140771,
0.0079828156,
-0.03581715,
0.0255082231,
-0.0220093466,
-0.0049923616,
-0.0017436834,
0.0643987656,
0.0241396967,
-0.0643031672,
0.0021778306,
-0.0450267941,
0.0015394593,
-0.039547421,
0.0021838697,
-0.0334018394,
0.0089178588,
0.0389047824,
-0.0728899613,
0.0000504069,
-0.0562765859,
2.457e-7,
0.0146819036,
0.0446864069,
0.0570753403,
-0.0242316462,
0.0508756414,
0.0451672226,
0.0119148884,
0.0470163673,
-0.0083319871,
0.04101732,
0.0065813065,
0.0070495298,
0.0467334762,
-0.0068716872,
-0.0637768731,
0.0516227297,
-0.0965116844,
0.0018349893,
-0.056674879,
0.0091727972,
0.0850508958,
0.0475050658,
0.0328327678,
-0.025653908,
-0.0122201005,
-0.0954090655,
0.0376854651,
0.0032741146,
0.0117715076,
0.0312425774,
0.0384044386,
-0.0040818481,
0.0435796455,
0.0240398627,
-0.0224441942,
-0.0237581637,
0.0343074985,
0.052110374,
-0.003494509,
0.0169868767,
-0.0192065518,
-0.0258729458,
-0.0053241267,
-0.0554684401,
0.0628956482,
0.0072865575,
-0.016332699,
-0.0552324392,
-0.0156427231,
-0.047228571,
0.0055048596,
-0.0115188174,
-0.0378016457,
0.0316074528,
0.0109444559,
0.0128873568,
0.0135596301,
-0.0608041212,
-0.0380432494,
-0.0479897223,
-0.0507582091,
-0.0264473613,
-0.0282771215,
0.0369736999,
0.0353955813,
-0.0106201191,
0.0238926709,
2.512806519e-34,
0.0409164838,
-0.0147980349,
0.0187590104,
-0.0085652713,
0.034287177,
0.0207876898,
0.0566734262,
0.024983976,
0.0215230826,
-0.0139704328,
0.0121904677
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.02591v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.02591v4 | ODD: A Benchmark Dataset for the Natural Language Processing based Opioid Related Aberrant Behavior Detection | 2023-07-05T18:41:29 | 2024-03-22T20:01:04 | Sunjae Kwon, Xun Wang, Weisong Liu, Emily Druhl, Minhee L. Sung, Joel I. Reisman, Wenjun Li, Robert D. Kerns, William Becker, Hong Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Opioid related aberrant behaviors (ORABs) present novel risk factors for
opioid overdose. This paper introduces a novel biomedical natural language
processing benchmark dataset named ODD, for ORAB Detection Dataset. ODD is an
expert-annotated dataset designed to identify ORABs from patients' EHR notes
and classify them into nine categories; 1) Confirmed Aberrant Behavior, 2)
Suggested Aberrant Behavior, 3) Opioids, 4) Indication, 5) Diagnosed opioid
dependency, 6) Benzodiazepines, 7) Medication Changes, 8) Central Nervous
System-related, and 9) Social Determinants of Health. We explored two
state-of-the-art natural language processing models (fine-tuning and
prompt-tuning approaches) to identify ORAB. Experimental results show that the
prompt-tuning models outperformed the fine-tuning models in most categories and
the gains were especially higher among uncommon categories (Suggested Aberrant
Behavior, Confirmed Aberrant Behaviors, Diagnosed Opioid Dependence, and
Medication Change). Although the best model achieved the highest 88.17% on
macro average area under precision recall curve, uncommon classes still have a
large room for performance improvement. ODD is publicly available. | [
0.0708323196,
0.0253519081,
0.012319156,
-0.018920457,
-0.0219354257,
0.0328457728,
-0.0300823823,
0.0095117483,
0.0403044075,
-0.0461314209,
0.0163459443,
0.0087302234,
-0.0256871898,
0.0803643465,
-0.0046886243,
-0.0059315381,
0.0405558497,
0.0631573647,
0.0675700903,
0.0409085117,
0.0058329361,
0.0270846803,
-0.0177214649,
0.0232306439,
0.0354170576,
-0.0104768081,
0.0363996886,
-0.0381574631,
0.0425817296,
-0.0587761849,
0.012261142,
0.0798333809,
-0.0204475913,
-0.0203219485,
0.0000016902,
-0.0494268611,
-0.016498914,
0.012885754,
-0.021660151,
-0.0561182648,
0.0339951813,
-0.0354312025,
0.0083503816,
0.0241141543,
-0.064113386,
-0.0136766406,
0.0416148826,
0.0710429698,
0.0158355609,
0.0702289566,
-0.0300624836,
-0.0294162426,
0.0042392826,
0.0037085139,
0.0206248481,
0.0027216147,
0.0554677658,
-0.0301237144,
0.0205127764,
-0.0104909334,
0.0117516443,
-0.0191049166,
-0.0382301211,
0.0550970025,
0.0452555865,
0.0258049443,
-0.0370468274,
-0.0462842472,
0.0012865951,
0.0778832436,
-0.0516227782,
0.0265696384,
0.0433980413,
-0.0156058464,
-0.0540998653,
-0.0008141852,
0.0185268391,
-0.0249458775,
-0.0441859849,
0.0386226662,
0.0245069563,
0.0176651608,
0.0077729835,
0.0169194564,
-0.0068366071,
0.0111083323,
-0.00050731,
-0.0201036744,
0.0230872016,
-0.0277178064,
-0.0460903421,
-0.0200578589,
0.0497143492,
-0.0208934508,
-0.0449089967,
0.0379680283,
-0.0296655316,
-0.0044966065,
0.0911506712,
-0.0745463222,
0.0159140509,
0.0226255022,
-0.0403350107,
0.0232172329,
-0.0029261839,
-0.0111246537,
0.0419592112,
0.0303913336,
-0.0195484571,
0.0225052591,
-0.0525942519,
0.0034238657,
-0.0318363197,
0.0112069044,
-0.0179103501,
-0.0173656698,
-0.0568753555,
-0.0095163789,
-0.0269914772,
-0.0229917988,
-0.0019495785,
0.0549610183,
-0.0087944074,
0.0274886545,
-0.0106677143,
0.0082650259,
-0.0113133285,
0.0117382724,
-0.0086108483,
-0.0042542429,
0.0251501948,
-0.0274407081,
0.0411743447,
-0.0260378923,
0.0262910556,
0.0404777825,
0.0435096994,
-0.0397833437,
-0.028765535,
-0.0314470232,
-0.0200012624,
0.0207573175,
-0.0027395654,
-0.0391412228,
0.0098475264,
0.005415394,
0.000628091,
-0.0556953698,
0.0139996512,
0.0105693405,
-0.0552596599,
0.0642246008,
-0.0386467278,
0.0013810397,
0.022294078,
-0.0151382284,
0.0395753197,
0.0219565406,
0.0095363744,
-0.0097144861,
0.0326951258,
-0.0319651067,
0.0167756863,
0.0090535516,
-0.0215815231,
-0.0737171918,
0.0258305073,
0.0106746741,
-0.0181316175,
0.027354788,
-0.0478710011,
0.0359977931,
0.02671366,
0.0001311585,
-0.0012744854,
0.0579251423,
-0.008291686,
0.0091425152,
0.0109298844,
0.0069387173,
-0.0488914996,
-0.0197538696,
-0.060779959,
-0.0147804432,
0.0112493113,
-0.019000195,
0.0095780278,
-0.0059848325,
0.0037165924,
-0.0194730405,
-0.0464648195,
0.0021977208,
-0.0165995993,
-0.0346029215,
0.014065898,
-0.0255084354,
-0.0482443199,
0.0154629992,
0.0298282746,
-0.0023854871,
-0.0426735245,
-0.0056116385,
-0.012192036,
0.0779813081,
0.0374353305,
-0.0272310451,
-0.0274294615,
-0.0438589677,
-0.0157164745,
-0.0040411828,
0.0146725448,
-0.0191612821,
0.0081761125,
-0.0082633188,
-0.0171026122,
0.0653399006,
0.0050877817,
-0.0597220659,
-0.0233235825,
0.0275299065,
0.0006136809,
0.0053193243,
-0.0370022953,
0.0682073385,
-0.0018981708,
-0.0608864501,
0.007729982,
0.0173121057,
0.036082767,
-0.004629855,
0.020100588,
0.0073146322,
0.0266669951,
-0.0302253161,
-0.0405399986,
-0.0374576896,
-0.0038361608,
0.0038384162,
0.0037030552,
-0.0353598408,
0.0422605053,
-0.0051935199,
-0.0405298807,
-0.0603819527,
-0.0062060067,
-0.0549832135,
0.0197072849,
-0.0424249806,
0.0014369176,
0.01744112,
0.0382252112,
-0.0307431556,
0.0444133617,
-0.0139870821,
0.0487041771,
-0.0448539332,
-0.0626471117,
-0.0139419762,
-0.0203485098,
-0.0023265006,
-0.0280229449,
-0.0439605415,
0.0239571407,
0.0028140866,
0.00520777,
-0.028684957,
-0.0080803558,
-0.0665677488,
-0.0004409509,
-0.0136775542,
0.0232650377,
0.0158299711,
-0.0052227341,
-0.0244522225,
-0.0240271613,
0.0163553301,
-0.0672384873,
0.041021619,
0.0240536109,
-0.0159359779,
0.0514434949,
0.019115679,
-0.0096009588,
0.0112780342,
-0.0447877981,
-0.0036937715,
-0.028836729,
-0.0709028468,
-0.0344082117,
-0.0195834786,
-0.0281383526,
-0.0011631195,
0.0024523402,
-0.0144052971,
0.0248449668,
0.0480386391,
0.0576680824,
0.0247179717,
0.0054061874,
0.0275250655,
0.0433741547,
0.0178756975,
-0.0027220286,
0.0074146581,
-0.0626882389,
-0.0149805686,
0.0093931295,
-0.0547370836,
0.0125052398,
0.0755541101,
0.0337703526,
-0.0055262395,
-0.0131881125,
-0.0276825652,
0.0168193635,
0.0031915668,
-0.0283829123,
-0.0435491912,
-0.0392388962,
0.0071173753,
-0.0159706343,
-0.0525305197,
0.0627602264,
0.0345478021,
0.0476849973,
-0.0860425681,
-0.0152817583,
-0.026657233,
-0.0425686277,
0.0699200556,
0.0205343869,
0.0273183454,
-0.0023037461,
0.0678426996,
0.0149949258,
0.0017470954,
-0.035079319,
0.0215552803,
-0.0313932821,
0.0218215138,
0.0259840507,
-0.0266392268,
-0.0378956124,
-0.0695222691,
-0.0434627868,
-0.0144722434,
0.0364804305,
-0.0182232838,
-0.0016662815,
0.0459887758,
-0.0710774362,
0.0469878912,
0.0116971154,
-0.0095545016,
0.0000445133,
-0.0158601012,
0.0783872381,
-0.0398278423,
0.0234985389,
0.0494150296,
0.023122035,
0.0472120792,
-0.0336261876,
0.0165094994,
-0.0105720237,
0.0397634916,
0.0037955448,
-0.0422903746,
-0.0125523843,
0.0455481224,
-0.0185457394,
0.0050783479,
0.0103774592,
0.0846414864,
0.0581821539,
-0.0478225574,
0.0287799109,
-0.0163623262,
-0.0275019314,
0.0178216789,
-0.0067253294,
-0.0617895201,
-0.0407518893,
-0.0389056653,
0.0371899046,
-0.0845720991,
-0.0494387373,
-0.0123079885,
-0.0563066937,
0.0161916595,
-0.0142739341,
-0.0821913108,
-0.0243888889,
-0.054408256,
0.018566465,
-0.0531824529,
-0.0026130015,
-0.0159398001,
-0.0496084504,
-0.0158713702,
0.0277227778,
-0.0793292895,
-0.0756121874,
0.059746258,
-0.0336486362,
0.0594654791,
0.0161151923,
0.0150062209,
-0.0044438848,
-0.0022933965,
0.0028421483,
-0.0043177595,
0.0312881991,
-0.002447447,
0.0716292113,
-0.0178683996,
0.0033599231,
-0.0940281674,
0.0368860736,
-0.0533890016,
-0.0178863984,
-0.0376740396,
0.1306242496,
-0.0581373535,
-0.0185098294,
-0.035670381,
0.0257180221,
0.0595907718,
0.0505412184,
-0.0042738225,
0.0161639377,
-0.0421506912,
0.0109935887,
0.0148617737,
-0.0441595167,
-0.0126281446,
-0.0061420673,
-0.0075377529,
-0.0457135588,
-0.0513222478,
-0.038961973,
0.0304525848,
-0.0506278425,
0.0026039074,
0.0194729902,
0.0317733362,
-0.0078792013,
-0.0401643999,
0.0712463781,
0.0667036399,
0.0154450182,
-0.0409554839,
-0.0183724426,
0.0158281047,
0.0364571251,
-0.0240014289,
0.0380573906,
-0.0169676039,
-0.021397559,
0.0763128623,
-0.0013299807,
0.0127546517,
-0.0114509985,
-0.0300766733,
-0.0514374673,
-0.0028720717,
0.0425519831,
-0.0148621602,
-0.0567372628,
-0.02323105,
0.0098307319,
-0.0086798193,
0.0032339264,
0.0281837862,
0.0079251248,
0.0132075641,
-0.0129650924,
-0.0654036477,
-0.0041209734,
0.022601055,
-0.012624518,
0.0612074248,
-0.014508008,
0.0247047096,
-0.0439793505,
-0.0116414251,
0.0208872166,
0.0196437873,
0.0227008425,
-0.0283733811,
0.0215751659,
-0.0615775213,
-0.0590880029,
0.0325445794,
-0.1052065045,
-0.0354715958,
-0.0655298382,
0.0410320237,
0.0294139776,
0.0124548338,
0.0373148657,
0.0132112037,
-0.0041484879,
0.0098654311,
-0.0205447413,
0.0556459278,
-0.0115285413,
0.054664392,
-0.0199326947,
0.0136183156,
-0.0084983101,
0.0600130521,
-0.0087635992,
-0.0269051325,
-0.0185924005,
-0.0065220688,
0.0287341289,
-0.0577345602,
0.0095146829,
-0.0233126413,
0.0072115022,
-0.0317448676,
0.0546834692,
-0.0352633633,
-0.0164742917,
0.0317367166,
0.0041799317,
-0.0402492136,
0.0088754771,
0.0746862218,
-0.0123487143,
-0.0037491212,
0.0151753034,
-0.0172245242,
-0.0063456581,
0.0288791843,
-0.0025144857,
0.0269653294,
-0.0576821715,
0.0255118627,
-0.0449766889,
-0.0363101214,
0.0194804166,
-0.0331672467,
-0.0134476433,
0.0271398108,
0.0503525101,
0.0402264297,
-0.0059185764,
-0.0492635146,
-0.0189828593,
0.0021647362,
0.0120752491,
-0.0160850678,
-0.0540636778,
-4.929751842e-33,
0.0119881537,
-0.0413954221,
-0.0099010188,
-0.0270817056,
0.0504740067,
-0.0218256023,
0.012358184,
0.0315890163,
0.0038579677,
0.0110387998,
-0.0310810674,
0.0273527596,
0.0289309118,
-0.0035506731,
0.0428725779,
-0.0541666672,
0.0209767204,
0.0158220213,
-0.0121629564,
0.0004558496,
0.0480283722,
0.0899223834,
0.0998809785,
-0.1009097546,
0.0630244836,
0.0372845381,
0.0187316462,
0.0064058034,
-0.0014176334,
0.0164055955,
-0.0501108989,
0.0743797645,
0.0548509844,
-0.0116256382,
-0.0138022779,
-0.0243983399,
-0.03647976,
-0.0363614336,
0.03419533,
-0.0452498794,
-0.003232806,
-0.0214937776,
0.0937529504,
0.0057843653,
-0.0155974384,
0.0338785835,
0.0582435913,
-0.0380787253,
0.0133643104,
0.0299857985,
-0.032366477,
0.0415360183,
-0.0188370775,
-0.0140340831,
-0.0558066592,
0.0069551193,
-0.029552862,
0.0372285023,
-0.0463501513,
-0.0087992074,
-0.0026931632,
0.0124082454,
-0.0188874714,
-0.0411833823,
0.0040343464,
0.0639094189,
0.0202173386,
0.0009150056,
-0.0385983884,
0.0418688543,
-0.0527703576,
0.1066669822,
0.041885823,
0.0021709471,
0.0739988834,
-0.0052179405,
-0.0407660902,
0.0087156864,
-0.0594228618,
0.0509942323,
0.0202427916,
-0.0494177379,
-0.0805447474,
-0.0145254834,
0.0066635376,
0.0135569125,
-0.034943305,
0.005222457,
-0.0130004482,
-0.0035217763,
0.0113854492,
0.0211943127,
0.0018169933,
-0.0365756229,
0.012779084,
-0.0233980119,
0.0505743995,
0.0199577939,
-0.0002328302,
-0.0193388648,
-0.0456074253,
0.0205295831,
0.019631898,
-0.0366161913,
0.0413004607,
-0.0066308402,
0.0265724752,
-0.0168202296,
-0.0412642583,
0.0067793587,
0.0419395491,
0.0117438091,
0.0314709917,
0.0790971071,
0.0013040327,
0.0407403708,
-0.0054775267,
0.0613306947,
0.0157057811,
0.0065331734,
-0.0305095948,
-0.0456326976,
-0.0224379767,
0.0267083105,
-0.0003220643,
0.0187184624,
-0.0143576991,
0.0219225418,
0.0118253296,
-0.0300878733,
0.0537840426,
-0.0041537979,
2.415e-7,
0.098868385,
0.0489488877,
-0.0100868531,
-0.0164904967,
-0.0273230113,
0.0061582504,
0.0358260721,
0.0504044071,
0.0104358671,
-0.0261657126,
0.0208856445,
0.0080981255,
-0.0049549346,
0.060217876,
-0.0011952592,
-0.011168791,
-0.058553569,
-0.0213285889,
-0.0647556558,
-0.0191213228,
0.0543221161,
0.0868532658,
0.0003183137,
-0.028385086,
0.01617934,
-0.0218445677,
-0.0031621333,
-0.0437758081,
-0.0048790569,
0.0327056609,
0.0381347239,
0.002024855,
-0.0011830409,
0.056153439,
-0.0184412319,
0.0070172506,
-0.0333551764,
0.0647264346,
-0.0853911936,
-0.0193741191,
-0.0043005864,
-0.0452220775,
-0.0177498441,
-0.0067705773,
0.0982655808,
-0.0029460834,
-0.0080762412,
-0.0207140837,
-0.0105542671,
0.0029626675,
0.072080642,
-0.0321425386,
-0.0239515454,
0.0378088132,
0.0352310203,
0.017880097,
0.002105807,
-0.0681005046,
-0.01869753,
0.0437385067,
-0.0337923467,
-0.0021267792,
0.030511206,
0.012431521,
0.0360451899,
-0.075488992,
-0.0112183122,
1.816302469e-34,
-0.0098067466,
0.019219704,
0.0059036543,
-0.0024507656,
0.0392946452,
0.0029936088,
-0.0175384227,
-0.0097651556,
-0.0224808622,
-0.0875530988,
0.0056366501
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.02044v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.02044v1 | Artificial Intelligence in archival and historical scholarship workflow: HTS and ChatGPT | 2023-07-05T18:32:28 | 2023-07-05T18:32:28 | Salvatore Spina | cs.DL | cs.DL, cs.AI, cs.CL | This article examines the impact of Artificial Intelligence on the archival
heritage digitization processes, specifically regarding the manuscripts'
automatic transcription, their correction, and normalization. It highlights how
digitality has compelled scholars to redefine Archive and History field and has
facilitated the accessibility of analogue sources through digitization and
integration into big data. The study focuses on two AI systems, namely
Transkribus and ChatGPT, which enable efficient analysis and transcription of
digitized sources. The article presents a test of ChatGPT, which was utilized
to normalize the text of 366 letters stored in the Correspondence section of
the Biscari Archive (Catania). Although the AI exhibited some limitations that
resulted in inaccuracies, the corrected texts met expectations. Overall, the
article concludes that digitization and AI can significantly enhance archival
and historical research by allowing the analysis of vast amounts of data and
the application of computational linguistic tools. | [
0.0269765649,
0.0753541216,
-0.0277223401,
0.0192787666,
-0.0723058283,
0.0474451259,
0.0169513896,
0.0397474878,
-0.0095949881,
-0.0107168341,
0.030449817,
0.0216171835,
0.0433068797,
-0.0056665284,
-0.0401808843,
-0.0168872904,
0.0271073766,
0.0060476973,
0.0009528224,
0.0209397636,
-0.0023226894,
0.0277408082,
-0.0318526812,
0.0185905695,
-0.029416699,
0.0036489579,
-0.0349513106,
-0.0126857404,
-0.025770152,
0.0319660194,
-0.0385159664,
0.0296583027,
0.0028717171,
0.1054576114,
0.000001668,
-0.0657416061,
-0.0261077844,
0.0101392455,
-0.0200267639,
-0.009132457,
0.1007312611,
-0.0081817815,
-0.0595924668,
-0.0384363495,
-0.0296955109,
-0.0009302651,
0.0598072,
0.0164216142,
-0.009711029,
0.0701542795,
-0.0126211783,
-0.0548357219,
0.066868484,
0.0229382496,
-0.0061696903,
-0.0225557946,
-0.0124143278,
0.0156730581,
-0.0078782542,
0.0449718721,
0.0430676043,
0.0935046673,
-0.0210586842,
-0.0539770536,
-0.0631797165,
-0.0146910893,
-0.008326984,
-0.019060567,
0.0015513464,
-0.0417886227,
0.0817264393,
0.0060271826,
0.0310616046,
0.0444148183,
-0.0347963572,
-0.012633916,
-0.0318012834,
0.0193004347,
-0.048594553,
-0.0184021518,
0.038174767,
-0.0089892019,
0.0048933928,
0.0158181414,
-0.013426777,
0.0276508275,
0.0027585463,
-0.0576269813,
0.041478686,
0.0066719675,
0.0500057302,
-0.0257657692,
0.0258766208,
0.0781418383,
-0.0042963843,
-0.0119450791,
-0.0042067301,
-0.056300547,
0.012882364,
-0.0245915018,
-0.0173692126,
0.0182714611,
-0.0298670791,
0.0443888195,
0.0135511756,
0.0548759028,
-0.0084794099,
0.0209271461,
-0.0091024786,
-0.0085479477,
-0.0658333153,
-0.0310776923,
-0.0625480935,
0.007996696,
-0.043808192,
0.0028925349,
-0.018235404,
-0.0288217086,
0.038733568,
0.0103935562,
0.0117013408,
-0.0353137776,
-0.0442137308,
-0.0323949084,
-0.0298552606,
0.0313610099,
-0.0339445025,
-0.0035819875,
-0.0633702204,
-0.0312737115,
0.041302111,
0.0238395277,
0.041881986,
-0.0307165068,
0.0119439708,
0.0266329106,
-0.0273296274,
0.0014646981,
-0.0392655618,
-0.0157207698,
-0.0002486969,
-0.066828683,
0.0245889127,
-0.0235772301,
0.034574654,
0.0120486272,
-0.0244588908,
-0.0055126175,
-0.0490755588,
0.0051453095,
-0.0281240866,
0.0680810884,
-0.020306401,
-0.0141769862,
0.0884035975,
-0.0294772517,
-0.0194563195,
-0.0209497381,
0.051635813,
-0.0003817973,
0.0262519736,
0.0290750992,
0.0394053347,
0.041393701,
-0.0039508175,
-0.0264233463,
-0.0320398062,
0.0244974457,
-0.03006313,
0.0406796448,
0.0307826437,
0.0860844627,
-0.0078498255,
0.0190195255,
0.0360929333,
0.0576265454,
0.03008168,
0.0714304894,
0.0017774579,
-0.005774999,
0.0594325103,
-0.0102610989,
-0.0204174686,
0.0053556021,
0.0435278825,
-0.0092967143,
-0.0357167237,
0.0197046716,
0.0284412932,
-0.0204312019,
0.0065267612,
-0.017071791,
0.0425452925,
-0.0602696277,
0.0542393476,
-0.0100053204,
-0.0299204569,
-0.0539526306,
-0.0239624418,
-0.0295888521,
-0.0251693632,
-0.0580522902,
0.023440795,
0.0750489235,
0.084826611,
-0.0644416809,
0.0464950502,
0.0017669044,
-0.027455844,
0.0581761077,
0.0262496471,
-0.0295628943,
0.001032226,
-0.0600092337,
-0.0060759853,
0.0480822697,
0.0047182706,
0.0126594827,
-0.0265517179,
0.0659605414,
0.0156032639,
0.0149820196,
-0.0132807782,
0.0320121236,
-0.0079533271,
-0.0264815912,
-0.0490992777,
0.0365010612,
-0.0272331741,
0.066009976,
-0.0105892243,
0.0032495554,
0.0073450715,
-0.015104101,
-0.0237184223,
0.0028507314,
0.0049681165,
0.0642666966,
0.0377498232,
-0.0482488573,
0.0151998857,
0.0099016475,
0.0109839244,
-0.0227976926,
0.0101109212,
-0.0626170486,
0.0185361132,
-0.0008652076,
0.0297734067,
-0.0300428625,
-0.0127910199,
-0.0566500835,
0.0329850577,
0.0224483106,
-0.0214651767,
0.0205630045,
-0.0891852006,
0.0298261959,
0.0310660489,
-0.0127593726,
0.0070389747,
0.0121377055,
0.0226519275,
0.0451752208,
-0.0111431647,
0.0059268144,
-0.0183480568,
-0.0604062192,
-0.0103394659,
-0.0175947845,
0.0117407124,
-0.0119010769,
-0.0021418086,
0.0175409932,
-0.0073933983,
0.0207805298,
0.0024056006,
-0.0164321177,
-0.0168590285,
0.0763786063,
0.0122458357,
-0.0005219954,
-0.0284307022,
-0.0037224693,
-0.0023263951,
0.0041573178,
0.0787283629,
-0.0839657634,
-0.0415301025,
-0.0149252759,
0.0029130895,
0.0085809603,
-0.0134111876,
-0.0088316379,
0.0152570298,
-0.027810365,
-0.0301308967,
0.0396624543,
-0.041631639,
-0.022987375,
0.0129613392,
-0.0164966248,
-0.0058228918,
0.0009123111,
0.0096401013,
-0.0020799991,
0.0106973443,
-0.0164045952,
-0.0008574241,
-0.0479495712,
-0.0081995446,
0.0642264038,
-0.0351593271,
-0.0048649046,
-0.033817187,
0.0161389802,
0.0153711727,
-0.0363147892,
-0.0191515367,
0.0941602066,
0.0107493242,
-0.0052616647,
0.0062346244,
0.0069587678,
-0.0085113496,
-0.0619298257,
-0.0108038215,
-0.0289275814,
0.0756448582,
-0.0229861308,
0.0244917888,
-0.0227035601,
-0.0298185088,
-0.0498456582,
0.0036214539,
0.00738827,
-0.0330499969,
-0.0074501,
-0.009170739,
0.0191469528,
-0.014085236,
-0.0237000827,
0.0106397085,
0.0075118546,
-0.0224617925,
-0.0249355752,
0.0450582877,
-0.0530984625,
-0.0429186001,
0.0433035232,
0.0173080303,
0.1015670523,
0.0055267042,
0.0168497078,
-0.0207832903,
0.0541782193,
0.0087265205,
-0.0010950837,
0.0083573461,
0.0414648615,
-0.0173753444,
0.001818852,
-0.0337867811,
-0.0046986314,
-0.0202492066,
-0.0312832966,
-0.0095309028,
-0.0140820434,
-0.053041365,
-0.0506245531,
-0.0495122969,
-0.0340365395,
0.0159994122,
0.0809354708,
0.0259930342,
-0.0995181128,
-0.0362762213,
-0.067234017,
-0.0801855177,
-0.0398548953,
0.0246419627,
-0.0996747985,
0.0432542972,
0.02214358,
0.0189937521,
-0.0378747433,
-0.0385192446,
0.0102764042,
-0.0525844283,
0.0362960063,
0.0092187626,
-0.0299120899,
-0.0407804996,
-0.0354094431,
-0.0064761061,
-0.023296034,
-0.0081020752,
0.0318776667,
0.0252854843,
0.0017012786,
-0.0117712924,
-0.0596296154,
0.0017973088,
-0.0285599791,
-0.0243924316,
0.0313876048,
0.0586107671,
0.1001784876,
-0.0453231782,
0.0046444749,
0.0142424228,
0.0731293783,
0.0125315702,
-0.030766869,
0.0810606405,
0.0560417548,
0.0104958061,
-0.0281696785,
-0.0195763428,
0.0137858791,
0.0118503552,
0.0495930798,
0.0278614275,
-0.0272548404,
0.034137316,
-0.0091082389,
-0.0424915403,
0.0228208601,
0.0027649316,
-0.0167568829,
-0.0069435746,
-0.0207157638,
-0.0161065999,
0.0638817176,
-0.0291996375,
-0.0067441086,
0.006020824,
-0.0282326601,
-0.0721908659,
-0.0908862129,
-0.0794846192,
-0.0210920926,
0.0355835669,
0.0507183,
-0.0588722453,
0.0211052112,
-0.0054440289,
-0.0836730376,
-0.0325709321,
-0.0375163294,
0.0062360135,
-0.0227168594,
0.0190744363,
-0.023193676,
0.0035357231,
-0.0105753299,
0.0172751341,
-0.0217696745,
-0.0215770714,
0.0738413036,
0.001834296,
0.0334586762,
0.0031688062,
-0.0096899727,
-0.0678784996,
-0.0142921982,
0.0049314289,
-0.0352428816,
-0.0168095995,
-0.0306481551,
-0.0229796469,
-0.0448865443,
0.0101068141,
-0.0184067562,
0.0189743862,
-0.0433280766,
-0.0491845161,
-0.0081154844,
-0.0510048382,
-0.0304921754,
0.0371200144,
0.0093616592,
-0.0145087531,
0.0262157358,
0.0236202963,
-0.0120793227,
-0.0291855242,
0.0074366606,
0.0304784738,
-0.0031377268,
-0.0010862139,
-0.0001397215,
0.0016805434,
-0.0267011318,
-0.0184924901,
-0.0426695012,
-0.0463957824,
0.0180887859,
0.0220177695,
0.1077942029,
0.0093605714,
0.0266780797,
-0.0006854372,
0.0931726098,
0.009451014,
0.0778611824,
-0.0058179684,
-0.009653924,
-0.0040178937,
0.0127586033,
-0.0243599713,
0.0129557606,
-0.0389160886,
-0.0275017489,
-0.0145699196,
0.0471520945,
0.0932566077,
0.0159601606,
0.0359965228,
-0.0297011975,
-0.0192399081,
0.0069423136,
-0.0142653296,
0.0516963005,
0.033052884,
-0.0817954019,
0.0042664721,
-0.0094037298,
0.0435297079,
-0.0198894739,
-0.0501497053,
0.0297906529,
0.0040130131,
-0.0429485701,
-0.0134352185,
-0.0271675382,
-0.0427387506,
-0.0387125164,
-0.0069269268,
-0.032133054,
-0.0209812038,
0.0008784882,
0.0285646431,
0.0473241955,
-0.0269339308,
-0.0455953851,
0.001841084,
-0.0010432845,
0.0029607958,
-0.0050894842,
-0.0203410517,
0.0434298664,
-0.0723644271,
-0.0330946557,
-0.033682391,
-5.016159493e-33,
0.0070283148,
-0.0292691737,
0.0593316406,
0.0238848031,
-0.0439184681,
-0.0277203303,
-0.0131838582,
-0.0288354401,
0.0026104515,
0.0123632057,
-0.071146071,
-0.0121045718,
0.0380971916,
-0.0536723547,
0.0497293808,
0.0282426309,
0.026245879,
-0.0281212609,
-0.033386305,
0.003673027,
0.0297442339,
0.0148201538,
0.0599358454,
-0.1097118556,
0.0633287057,
-0.0368755199,
-0.025675891,
0.0145712625,
0.0531798527,
0.0227752011,
0.0059772814,
-0.0352247581,
0.0118265459,
-0.0181980412,
0.010258452,
0.0504548512,
-0.0739619657,
0.0126778008,
0.0017568183,
0.1119864956,
0.0776288882,
-0.0500802584,
0.0084194997,
-0.0182387438,
-0.059074074,
0.024974985,
0.0220938865,
-0.0177912079,
-0.0018134257,
-0.0381628275,
-0.0552535951,
0.0218670834,
-0.0121007832,
0.0075183222,
0.0725177526,
-0.0009082192,
-0.0165248215,
-0.0160248764,
-0.0373774506,
0.008374894,
0.0005613354,
0.0051827417,
0.0079719191,
-0.0301134773,
-0.0573170036,
-0.0284203067,
0.0339731239,
-0.0220524613,
-0.0330209546,
0.0238816757,
0.0108977826,
0.0054137586,
0.0389629342,
0.066518791,
0.0242320895,
-0.0117667522,
-0.0011289516,
0.0233879481,
0.0326250903,
0.0452632569,
-0.0127475737,
-0.0032454226,
-0.0499985665,
0.007222631,
-0.0032236711,
-0.0250742454,
0.0053681922,
-0.0093799578,
-0.0270385984,
-0.0288606677,
0.0306441281,
0.0280525684,
0.0012753553,
-0.0581204146,
0.0013625314,
0.0114189181,
-0.011042879,
0.0605128706,
-0.022804305,
-0.0021135332,
-0.00756294,
-0.0176647417,
0.0343915001,
0.0710663199,
0.0248123202,
0.013126106,
0.0035621095,
0.0172703993,
-0.0426994972,
0.0120910443,
0.0398065187,
-0.0098774359,
0.003931927,
-0.009406969,
0.0118995188,
0.0017247156,
0.0610299818,
-0.0228908211,
0.0423735045,
0.0225246288,
0.0086712055,
-0.0021324903,
0.0572609641,
-0.0317950211,
-0.0162697658,
0.0058509889,
0.0100170691,
-0.0003283996,
-0.0016934043,
-0.0144820372,
0.0005778701,
-0.0051614633,
2.511e-7,
0.0670461953,
0.0769716576,
0.0741531178,
-0.0052451515,
-0.0027306217,
-0.0092930142,
-0.0108471261,
-0.000461696,
-0.050488092,
0.0578101724,
0.1017884389,
-0.0075386371,
0.0685904101,
0.0372069627,
-0.025486419,
-0.075359799,
-0.0579038598,
-0.03332882,
-0.0753378272,
0.0631099865,
0.0106796399,
0.0247923601,
-0.0113027906,
-0.0651350394,
-0.0254476033,
-0.0000221482,
-0.0252937563,
0.020793587,
0.0034195122,
-0.0031013668,
0.0157913771,
0.0106412247,
0.0038037256,
0.0297073275,
0.028195329,
0.0203478988,
0.0114355329,
0.071413599,
-0.0066536334,
0.0507578962,
0.0342926607,
-0.0091508664,
-0.0124220848,
-0.0155518334,
0.0290684849,
0.0596719719,
0.0266800523,
-0.0563645549,
-0.0430526882,
0.0175619256,
0.0193103477,
-0.0108577767,
0.0046822592,
0.0155155407,
0.0154464813,
0.0362793319,
0.0251333341,
-0.0597793981,
0.0357907005,
0.0092824567,
-0.0041405023,
-0.0359214507,
0.0088374624,
-0.0019559709,
0.013417339,
-0.0253724661,
0.035286881,
1.990387442e-34,
0.0491396673,
-0.0561267249,
0.0001951586,
-0.0009120005,
0.0311084054,
0.0055421563,
0.0260740742,
0.0077224788,
-0.0010631733,
-0.0414130948,
-0.000517792
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.10188v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.10188v1 | Several categories of Large Language Models (LLMs): A Short Survey | 2023-07-05T18:18:23 | 2023-07-05T18:18:23 | Saurabh Pahune, Manoj Chandrasekharan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large Language Models(LLMs)have become effective tools for natural language
processing and have been used in many different fields. This essay offers a
succinct summary of various LLM subcategories. The survey emphasizes recent
developments and efforts made for various LLM kinds, including task-based
financial LLMs, multilingual language LLMs, biomedical and clinical LLMs,
vision language LLMs, and code language models. The survey gives a general
summary of the methods, attributes, datasets, transformer models, and
comparison metrics applied in each category of LLMs. Furthermore, it highlights
unresolved problems in the field of developing chatbots and virtual assistants,
such as boosting natural language processing, enhancing chatbot intelligence,
and resolving moral and legal dilemmas. The purpose of this study is to provide
readers, developers, academics, and users interested in LLM-based chatbots and
virtual intelligent assistant technologies with useful information and future
directions. | [
0.0719779804,
0.0549539253,
-0.0326545909,
0.0342039987,
-0.0535895191,
0.011870956,
0.015997665,
0.033490058,
0.0630005598,
-0.0529342741,
-0.0340134688,
-0.0422516018,
-0.0050461031,
0.0418405086,
0.0324584842,
-0.0481999069,
0.023475565,
-0.0374906361,
0.0257437844,
0.0014648838,
0.0148472292,
0.0079664588,
0.0115508046,
0.0935774222,
-0.0153747816,
-0.0216131061,
0.0140180737,
-0.0023331719,
-0.0060338271,
-0.0067801536,
-0.0247908905,
0.0124114808,
0.0147496732,
0.0424689874,
0.0000020388,
-0.0448646322,
-0.0120519483,
0.0056276335,
-0.0200457983,
-0.0126910061,
0.0698212311,
-0.0450129807,
-0.0233594645,
0.0440408923,
-0.0427358672,
-0.0073549412,
0.0689748824,
0.0304877572,
0.061353799,
0.0874413997,
-0.0271919332,
-0.033061523,
0.0504415259,
-0.021829145,
-0.0205343422,
-0.0534404069,
0.0420745723,
0.0405399576,
0.021652272,
0.0205912516,
-0.0145055139,
0.0397350267,
-0.0041905483,
-0.0363206416,
-0.0136326374,
0.0151759731,
-0.0416418351,
-0.0433262847,
-0.0432184786,
0.051465489,
-0.0111180069,
0.0073262914,
0.0252339486,
0.0092692394,
0.0017291795,
0.0141867548,
-0.0542960316,
0.0546083301,
-0.003888991,
-0.0027909095,
0.0202348661,
-0.0103323888,
0.0042764447,
0.0098431138,
-0.0531966798,
-0.009556652,
0.0253645387,
-0.0141785052,
-0.0249940082,
-0.0096267629,
-0.0353716388,
-0.0555749647,
0.0285938866,
0.0326550454,
-0.0202379804,
0.0384167582,
-0.0194780026,
-0.034232717,
0.0215093642,
-0.0827200413,
0.0262734238,
0.0177484229,
-0.017185472,
0.0670972094,
-0.0039109844,
0.0760414526,
-0.0382070988,
0.0029279939,
-0.0262131114,
-0.0320249014,
-0.0400875397,
-0.023108311,
-0.0530187525,
0.0392109454,
-0.0304932296,
-0.0425017886,
-0.0614311472,
0.0425486378,
0.0029905795,
0.0087129958,
0.0017848117,
-0.0074181785,
-0.0078901611,
-0.0116838599,
-0.0243597757,
0.0315551125,
0.0101300981,
0.0013973423,
-0.0305836648,
-0.0778509825,
0.0415225625,
0.0368753448,
-0.0160142779,
-0.0200859644,
0.0032451178,
0.097201094,
0.0273086354,
-0.047608573,
0.0092222942,
-0.0020092893,
-0.0296230242,
-0.05448642,
-0.0187490992,
-0.0718235672,
0.0239824057,
-0.0099935411,
0.0233790912,
-0.0285155997,
0.0114875929,
0.0184117127,
-0.0523527302,
0.0717232004,
-0.0184500385,
0.0343579017,
0.029403124,
-0.0140292365,
0.0063294405,
0.0630994663,
0.0377823859,
0.0039484799,
0.0461180657,
-0.0234862845,
0.0102608101,
0.0761716291,
-0.0285897274,
-0.0334937759,
-0.0096857157,
-0.0028692856,
0.0217449162,
0.0290278401,
-0.0180563014,
0.0863548145,
-0.0234438907,
-0.0147075448,
0.0541934595,
0.0697808117,
0.0216292106,
0.0354990736,
0.034499716,
0.051428508,
0.0219006203,
-0.0300089717,
-0.0025987907,
-0.003774107,
-0.0247876905,
-0.032508336,
0.0127600702,
0.0349434316,
-0.0327741243,
-0.0475796051,
-0.0145577732,
-0.0473429114,
0.0336159207,
0.0035366444,
0.0790976509,
-0.0111996187,
-0.0301813483,
0.0068662916,
0.0359772705,
-0.0238641724,
-0.0373256505,
-0.0787738189,
0.0097547676,
0.0776785687,
0.0683701485,
-0.017184522,
-0.0114054251,
-0.0194831509,
-0.0180950351,
0.054563988,
0.0216260012,
0.0088844365,
-0.0233424343,
-0.0449313298,
0.0103428569,
0.0321942493,
-0.0097961882,
0.0110754296,
0.0019422441,
0.010635484,
-0.0027829192,
0.014884674,
-0.0267447885,
0.0216767974,
-0.0222949293,
0.0131522818,
-0.0021233377,
-0.0126664788,
0.0474254116,
0.0179960448,
-0.0173031688,
0.0063765612,
0.0135673489,
-0.0434661917,
-0.0251132939,
0.0276257489,
-0.0127291232,
-0.0289533436,
0.0368331,
-0.0254410803,
0.0134806698,
0.04422893,
-0.0024759187,
-0.0191434678,
-0.0104147336,
-0.0757707283,
0.0464609675,
-0.0246169213,
0.0519495942,
-0.0256990474,
0.0303743333,
-0.0366377905,
0.0343831964,
0.0150575554,
0.0069973352,
0.0073292283,
0.0228216238,
-0.0050196839,
-0.0291582756,
-0.026083136,
0.0413165055,
-0.0089024166,
0.0222852509,
0.0548202582,
0.0076697166,
-0.0104496023,
-0.054028675,
-0.1374876648,
-0.0150224399,
-0.0057395753,
-0.0177371576,
-0.0181808807,
0.0147134615,
-0.0110353502,
-0.0134082092,
-0.0458107702,
0.0171505064,
0.030589601,
0.0372018814,
0.0182215422,
-0.0189417526,
-0.0529643372,
-0.0350680016,
-0.0101983007,
-0.0073366808,
0.0504495017,
0.0338246934,
-0.0574051775,
-0.0623010658,
0.0560809933,
-0.0230594594,
0.0223243441,
-0.0202566478,
-0.0421468019,
0.008450496,
-0.0072700637,
0.0665282533,
0.0498843975,
0.0242649037,
0.046416156,
0.0217804071,
-0.0024904078,
-0.0581781976,
-0.0128921736,
-0.0059473165,
-0.0475361757,
-0.0370312631,
-0.0514441319,
0.0212671477,
0.0754118487,
-0.0058648055,
0.0122356331,
-0.0765544996,
0.0110921385,
-0.0167207941,
-0.0206143204,
0.0189560223,
-0.0015540723,
-0.0293920264,
0.0259869825,
0.0019290247,
-0.0604023151,
0.0780993924,
-0.0378839225,
0.0040647686,
-0.0437903367,
-0.0386907123,
-0.0484848134,
0.0573198758,
0.0004985583,
0.0265833251,
0.0006202661,
-0.0369030982,
-0.0036348924,
0.0034829029,
-0.022128202,
-0.0600227006,
0.0397680141,
-0.0275458898,
0.0299774576,
0.0047742799,
-0.0211890973,
-0.0330766328,
-0.0602635704,
-0.0491962247,
0.0048869913,
0.0578527227,
-0.0271957908,
-0.048733782,
0.0425906591,
0.0013293513,
0.0229619648,
0.0078337891,
-0.0041070939,
-0.0161202047,
-0.020230541,
0.0498164073,
0.0058898614,
-0.008626028,
-0.0199895557,
0.0460123084,
0.0362283327,
0.0121102119,
0.0235261153,
-0.0246196296,
-0.0380813293,
0.036801707,
-0.0078643002,
-0.0348463282,
0.0081620999,
0.0246938076,
-0.0408855267,
0.006935813,
0.1172112823,
0.0156513508,
-0.0524160974,
0.0125326989,
-0.0330541618,
-0.0079399459,
0.0001575432,
0.0302847587,
-0.0922277719,
-0.0277108662,
-0.0022318086,
-0.0228842497,
-0.0199874807,
-0.0196089093,
-0.0090454435,
-0.1124292314,
0.0329245254,
-0.00155857,
-0.0052240761,
-0.0523872264,
-0.0332941674,
0.0016880481,
-0.0235254411,
0.0011194389,
-0.0230756663,
-0.0299144387,
-0.0424614996,
0.0029576065,
-0.0686050206,
-0.0117866965,
0.0193363354,
-0.0563141741,
0.0666927472,
0.0845064148,
0.0561874807,
0.0079040881,
0.0141022317,
-0.0239811819,
0.0304543376,
0.0061071492,
0.0030133436,
0.0347017199,
-0.0018164966,
-0.0290077366,
-0.0283647049,
0.0042478759,
-0.002607746,
0.0228165817,
0.025128141,
0.0401473343,
-0.0405812748,
0.0075548245,
-0.0127667105,
0.024856681,
-0.0100201871,
0.0676581338,
0.0014354131,
-0.0655261725,
-0.0291539598,
-0.0113357967,
-0.0045032739,
0.0214874949,
-0.0484524854,
-0.0187775437,
-0.0216357391,
-0.0059827948,
-0.0859834552,
-0.0201861802,
0.0202510282,
0.0033119693,
0.028779909,
0.0295343362,
0.0769385695,
0.0133014815,
0.0075246193,
0.0112778135,
-0.0524235405,
0.0300594848,
-0.0735663995,
-0.0040673539,
0.0527222678,
-0.0354067422,
-0.0038206263,
0.0206655134,
-0.0692328289,
-0.0556289963,
-0.0131575894,
0.0213079173,
0.0145016862,
0.0045262789,
-0.0286222342,
-0.059230119,
-0.0015393632,
0.0207847282,
-0.0554619431,
0.0118928589,
0.0330381468,
0.0517653599,
-0.012210534,
0.0385321304,
-0.0427351072,
0.0148973251,
-0.0133591695,
0.0379854664,
-0.0475055054,
-0.0528432503,
0.0203978177,
0.0347998366,
0.0189017113,
0.0163510963,
-0.001356639,
-0.0097793927,
0.0063701239,
-0.0495117791,
0.0134568205,
-0.0703132525,
-0.0091441656,
0.0362677947,
-0.0061610248,
-0.0046732216,
0.0119701186,
-0.0495095775,
-0.0028365389,
-0.0139574744,
0.0423388481,
-0.0209235363,
-0.0058485675,
0.0332350843,
0.0035268122,
0.0058305971,
0.0208597835,
0.0002716806,
0.0017248144,
0.0018042712,
0.0598399527,
-0.0022987998,
-0.0295764022,
0.0039359019,
0.031968534,
-0.027052518,
-0.0779822394,
0.0274534691,
0.063581042,
0.0613931976,
0.0236198306,
0.059414275,
-0.038213674,
0.0134718707,
-0.0306876656,
0.0374362394,
-0.0039550196,
-0.0458621643,
0.0337481797,
0.011218464,
-0.0322511569,
0.0066400566,
0.0889586285,
0.0152537273,
0.0139703033,
-0.0133010885,
-0.0263567548,
-0.035934709,
-0.0241465028,
0.0414405279,
-0.019533556,
-0.0285503082,
0.023623772,
-0.0476100743,
-0.0486671068,
0.0021279287,
-0.0313332938,
-0.011077825,
-0.0311977919,
0.0245915279,
0.0655149221,
-0.0060326355,
0.0040834681,
-0.0719306096,
0.0037788029,
-0.0187745262,
-0.0257095098,
-0.0102930898,
-6.061220623e-33,
-0.0254882053,
-0.029423276,
0.028423829,
-0.0015608852,
-0.0105717983,
-0.0024425185,
-0.0102691334,
0.0083494401,
-0.0174175873,
-0.0107539911,
-0.0201999582,
0.0177643076,
0.0139366891,
0.0158802215,
0.0040032635,
0.0075954315,
0.050892368,
0.000421658,
0.0044216383,
0.0254669804,
0.0113816839,
0.0368855894,
0.0244043227,
-0.0882395282,
0.0254951715,
0.0040788902,
0.0130661419,
0.0166644398,
0.0323704183,
0.065998219,
-0.0308749229,
0.0506027713,
0.0207035057,
-0.0447919779,
-0.0306375921,
0.0449190438,
-0.0461576991,
0.0145482048,
0.0377787426,
0.030208759,
0.0142465942,
-0.050342232,
0.0402624942,
-0.043931406,
-0.0165491104,
0.0282179583,
0.0394447558,
-0.0508934595,
-0.0112895891,
-0.0097915772,
-0.0866611004,
0.0391982198,
-0.023501968,
-0.0357098915,
0.0277374294,
0.0541949123,
-0.019749267,
0.0511016026,
-0.010943545,
0.0449365638,
-0.0060277879,
-0.0009986908,
0.0372004174,
0.0021246469,
0.0412956439,
0.0635234341,
0.0184437726,
0.0122364173,
-0.0458682217,
-0.0240178686,
0.0178456344,
0.0565436445,
0.0546575375,
0.0239832364,
-0.0388997756,
-0.0179457758,
-0.0519918352,
-0.0222408138,
0.0486771464,
0.0471304804,
0.0389736816,
0.0231002644,
-0.0573676452,
-0.0076005724,
-0.0197533574,
0.0212687794,
-0.0198992547,
-0.0287084449,
0.0200050604,
0.0113096144,
0.002968905,
-0.0088284155,
0.0463630445,
-0.0848552361,
0.0002054506,
0.0202536769,
0.0049346858,
0.0262401029,
-0.0222386308,
0.0439636558,
-0.0562034436,
-0.0355878137,
0.020976264,
-0.0295094904,
0.0187959336,
-0.0071922448,
-0.0115072457,
-0.0029449745,
-0.0523160435,
-0.0061924281,
-0.0115908338,
-0.0117788054,
-0.0085492022,
0.0174587108,
0.0294231288,
0.0082191937,
-0.0194660258,
0.0563730747,
0.0017155787,
-0.0052992716,
-0.0184918232,
-0.0225755796,
-0.0173344985,
0.0140582472,
-0.0452121533,
0.011465339,
-0.0555897132,
0.0395109169,
0.0329647437,
-0.0472707488,
-0.0255901441,
-0.0102523826,
2.781e-7,
0.013089085,
0.0795375481,
0.0024715322,
0.0261699501,
0.01281319,
0.0380756818,
0.0049128453,
0.0175215136,
-0.0059231319,
0.0222083572,
-0.0000306259,
0.0359059162,
0.072767958,
-0.0177351162,
-0.0761179253,
-0.0134491185,
-0.0792532563,
-0.0167050641,
-0.0735893101,
0.0181762837,
0.0539842062,
0.1199989542,
-0.0087040085,
-0.0123015922,
-0.0187510625,
-0.0568270423,
0.0581937917,
-0.0566453896,
-0.0474881306,
0.0418138653,
0.0167875029,
0.0452535003,
0.0039430959,
0.0141185336,
0.04078345,
0.0309586022,
0.0453044809,
0.0765822902,
0.0085715642,
0.0421106853,
0.029348731,
0.0001757083,
-0.0413638912,
-0.0440159999,
0.067334339,
-0.0672490075,
-0.065272063,
-0.0508500971,
0.0142304627,
-0.0226770844,
0.0301116947,
-0.0338849537,
-0.0137227047,
0.0256646667,
0.026490245,
-0.021378994,
0.0056511504,
-0.0484309755,
0.0080947476,
-0.0086163664,
-0.0517834127,
-0.020860415,
-0.0422950201,
-0.0143503621,
0.0244174581,
-0.0386391804,
0.0349484496,
2.30972908e-34,
0.0352671556,
-0.0178601258,
-0.0056663696,
0.0401475616,
0.0420698225,
0.0101743359,
-0.0005246578,
0.0379564054,
-0.0140765952,
-0.1102841273,
0.0111635551
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.02570v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.02570v1 | Named Entity Inclusion in Abstractive Text Summarization | 2023-07-05T18:12:31 | 2023-07-05T18:12:31 | Sergey Berezin, Tatiana Batura | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SI | We address the named entity omission - the drawback of many current
abstractive text summarizers. We suggest a custom pretraining objective to
enhance the model's attention on the named entities in a text. At first, the
named entity recognition model RoBERTa is trained to determine named entities
in the text. After that, this model is used to mask named entities in the text
and the BART model is trained to reconstruct them. Next, the BART model is
fine-tuned on the summarization task. Our experiments showed that this
pretraining approach improves named entity inclusion precision and recall
metrics. | [
0.0295761377,
0.0121733779,
0.0365117379,
-0.0081899287,
0.0324144773,
0.0345506519,
-0.0362672433,
-0.0131824911,
-0.0249258447,
-0.0476960279,
0.0100110685,
-0.0239518527,
0.0167380981,
-0.0034155445,
0.0197656956,
-0.119125165,
0.0340102501,
0.0223768558,
-0.005955948,
0.02798496,
0.0254297853,
-0.016071083,
0.0233900212,
0.0094922865,
0.040421728,
0.0270855259,
-0.0166045073,
-0.0065203719,
0.0566865355,
-0.0300752744,
-0.0042784275,
0.006619636,
0.0116977571,
0.0172229484,
0.0000017865,
-0.0636257753,
-0.0587883294,
0.0127006052,
-0.000567862,
0.0134304846,
0.0259242691,
-0.0255798064,
0.0119876154,
0.0091298036,
0.0202627908,
-0.0207081586,
0.0112699913,
0.0930039957,
0.0568713956,
0.0515733622,
-0.007530326,
-0.0104782516,
0.0654388294,
-0.0128244683,
-0.0233659297,
-0.0141162621,
0.0072826766,
0.0190791525,
-0.0457684137,
0.0091595193,
0.0089727426,
0.0470616408,
-0.0007652444,
0.0259752274,
0.0604428053,
0.054348588,
-0.0728562921,
0.0190224182,
0.0244616754,
0.0562841147,
0.0040196665,
0.001524354,
0.0289416574,
-0.0099386899,
-0.0125624612,
-0.0355445892,
-0.0508813895,
0.0159251783,
-0.0297983605,
0.0154639753,
-0.0057319407,
0.0636504441,
-0.011688049,
0.0288568567,
-0.0237794407,
-0.0034472097,
0.0054737772,
-0.006436991,
-0.0105517283,
0.0246542841,
-0.0448187627,
-0.0737330317,
0.0664307177,
0.0596374944,
0.0276972167,
-0.0023809564,
-0.0595023371,
-0.0881738216,
-0.0005639187,
-0.0531608909,
0.01300989,
0.0296548679,
0.0276208632,
0.0285736267,
-0.0364967547,
0.012109329,
0.0190803055,
0.0124930171,
-0.0236350782,
-0.0089107892,
-0.0109111713,
0.0056485236,
-0.0718276277,
0.0691897348,
-0.0551542938,
-0.0215177219,
-0.0234160554,
0.0024571235,
0.0228851978,
-0.0117174489,
-0.0129258158,
0.0026183352,
-0.018555373,
-0.0076842625,
-0.0055872709,
-0.0016560851,
-0.0326024704,
-0.035000138,
0.0387505852,
0.0067324555,
-0.018655343,
-0.0395503938,
0.0555548109,
-0.0077796909,
0.033333309,
0.0161421075,
-0.0184787232,
-0.0823296756,
-0.0059969346,
-0.031235557,
0.0251714364,
-0.0316951014,
-0.0133470809,
-0.0195101667,
0.0056035742,
-0.0004912638,
-0.0086611621,
0.0162918158,
0.0219952669,
0.0160358362,
-0.0473409556,
0.0258836281,
-0.0516063794,
-0.0037347183,
0.0521490127,
0.0152154779,
0.0440537892,
0.0282061715,
0.0368128605,
0.0241607893,
0.0367227197,
0.0225302726,
-0.0074997605,
0.0024250429,
0.0501137525,
0.0105728982,
0.0727661774,
0.0091597419,
-0.080097504,
-0.0305065122,
0.0360521451,
0.0374208018,
-0.0381962024,
0.0242283717,
0.0547090657,
0.0532794185,
-0.0178030822,
0.052798871,
0.0324457735,
0.0127230529,
0.0470318906,
0.0560458079,
0.0140570868,
0.0286622457,
-0.0671734288,
0.0830940381,
0.0636887178,
0.0285190921,
-0.0197410174,
-0.044465635,
0.0389530361,
-0.0124047799,
0.0116581209,
0.007726084,
0.0475949831,
0.0492415093,
-0.0953051373,
0.0455095172,
0.0011455303,
-0.0692310259,
0.0133296978,
-0.0034344946,
0.0019566983,
0.0297104418,
0.0436287932,
-0.0364477336,
-0.0346147232,
-0.0251896549,
-0.0125895189,
0.0290872734,
0.0407474823,
0.0083963508,
0.0101435278,
-0.0468091741,
-0.0361116678,
0.0088628801,
0.008736765,
0.0240277573,
0.0045866626,
-0.0018081469,
0.054924842,
0.0070406687,
-0.0730520189,
0.0350644477,
-0.0236098319,
-0.0437201522,
-0.038392067,
-0.0025004353,
0.0046113185,
0.0545012504,
-0.0037973018,
0.0040702778,
-0.0054052835,
-0.0194950476,
-0.0214873292,
0.0092174802,
-0.0266032144,
-0.0245509241,
-0.0205996465,
-0.0499381945,
-0.0221356302,
0.0310011711,
-0.0031880164,
-0.0729134381,
-0.0190604124,
-0.0224777181,
0.0396572836,
-0.038079489,
0.0265986789,
0.0358056799,
-0.0038186561,
-0.0278298557,
0.0786763951,
-0.0117270974,
0.0312724598,
0.0371334814,
-0.0126070436,
-0.0001549906,
-0.0436429344,
-0.0315500088,
-0.0287818853,
0.0092661558,
-0.0305702649,
0.0287153479,
-0.0442385226,
-0.0475113653,
0.0164762177,
-0.0745552778,
0.0252159573,
-0.0181212779,
0.024227215,
0.0363490656,
0.0307251792,
-0.0193088148,
-0.0048863022,
0.0120210815,
-0.0327836834,
-0.0106757963,
-0.0012231953,
0.0218131151,
0.0205533914,
0.0238179453,
-0.0317795537,
-0.014833414,
-0.0066630091,
0.0337110087,
0.0238348655,
-0.0609734505,
-0.0277187843,
0.0693817064,
-0.0085692154,
-0.0107965209,
0.0086699873,
0.0068708258,
-0.0367039293,
0.0237021577,
0.0496035554,
0.0485229604,
0.0147956489,
-0.0201365873,
-0.0049567055,
-0.0236324444,
-0.0247894209,
0.026816301,
-0.0211889446,
0.0529193655,
0.0424238965,
-0.040801961,
0.047191482,
0.0843220726,
-0.0155545585,
0.0045266319,
-0.037776079,
-0.0268172733,
-0.0190129466,
-0.0028713739,
-0.0494898669,
-0.0427730791,
-0.0021457493,
-0.0010228691,
-0.0396422893,
-0.0047752992,
0.0579767078,
-0.0404750779,
-0.0193985905,
-0.0539999045,
0.017411584,
-0.0430295803,
0.011300711,
0.0423048399,
0.0365626775,
0.0296074469,
-0.0708090588,
-0.0214591734,
-0.0052366699,
0.0019707833,
-0.0093070185,
0.0611622706,
0.0051419437,
-0.0032043862,
-0.0432902016,
0.0112398127,
-0.0129469065,
-0.0109853083,
-0.0185702499,
0.0386943296,
0.0319438688,
0.0109423762,
-0.035274826,
0.0416236185,
0.0409312248,
0.0660965592,
-0.0095172944,
-0.0312336739,
-0.0432873107,
0.0302250516,
0.061287351,
0.0012938576,
0.0258318372,
-0.0548170097,
0.0117694233,
0.003071666,
0.0102341333,
-0.0484636426,
0.0143552125,
-0.0127147948,
-0.0296632499,
-0.1026012674,
0.0110776899,
-0.0179478135,
0.060485024,
-0.0374500304,
-0.0232259128,
0.1005428657,
0.0121754212,
0.0004260129,
-0.0535786338,
0.0351762101,
0.0257002898,
-0.001331288,
-0.0063711335,
-0.0389086194,
0.0133282188,
0.0186799672,
0.0067227106,
0.0193158817,
-0.0439659767,
0.0096268533,
-0.0876884311,
-0.0098536657,
0.0252112374,
-0.1307347417,
-0.0218755323,
-0.0184957609,
-0.0009315808,
-0.0219898708,
0.0042742933,
0.0171932392,
-0.0431875624,
0.0047285068,
0.0112241916,
-0.0662793368,
0.038464807,
-0.0392502584,
-0.0442304648,
-0.0196736716,
0.0689327493,
0.028519528,
-0.0114214392,
0.0500293784,
0.0275995787,
-0.0646157637,
0.0036125926,
0.0151039883,
0.1114349738,
-0.0320812538,
0.0205506403,
-0.0522801429,
0.0312143657,
0.0406967849,
-0.01931265,
0.006614686,
-0.0082276985,
0.0042916145,
0.0210426673,
-0.0244201124,
0.0297692101,
-0.0105147799,
0.0559452437,
0.0490786992,
0.0127483224,
-0.0240298063,
-0.0145418225,
0.0211430471,
-0.1021993458,
-0.014574416,
-0.0010588509,
-0.083486706,
-0.0280114077,
-0.0711671188,
-0.0602513552,
0.0287277233,
0.0075789317,
0.0163115375,
-0.0157004986,
0.0179243647,
0.0104442136,
-0.0335821062,
0.0226400997,
-0.0234111063,
-0.0107488455,
-0.0112658963,
-0.0419809148,
0.023715049,
-0.0179925747,
-0.025011776,
0.0165564865,
-0.023426326,
-0.0303239785,
0.0106495125,
0.0288192239,
0.0203852039,
0.0709495544,
0.014006461,
-0.0161952674,
0.0718993768,
-0.02100664,
0.0140973059,
0.0267947894,
0.0404262468,
0.0552125573,
-0.0269678272,
0.0056287358,
-0.0354767665,
0.0386777967,
0.0106163351,
0.0153395198,
-0.0311862137,
-0.0078700865,
-0.0046693082,
0.0254673231,
0.0282040257,
-0.0110599035,
-0.0048597087,
-0.0589019582,
0.0125998752,
-0.0073420815,
0.0162680335,
-0.0234702043,
0.023818545,
-0.0032018572,
0.0113586672,
-0.0235228296,
0.0827199444,
-0.0014779951,
0.0259591807,
-0.0485392772,
-0.0119462153,
-0.0157548226,
0.0242082942,
-0.0282434486,
-0.0137338378,
-0.0352540202,
-0.0276078209,
-0.0119406935,
0.0210973937,
0.0080501949,
0.013455729,
0.0052241995,
0.0072756615,
-0.0507152565,
0.0100981444,
-0.0851075575,
0.0315201059,
-0.0861897543,
0.0520509668,
0.0072048889,
-0.0408495255,
0.0691660643,
-0.0088717882,
-0.0204624254,
0.0123693701,
0.0073972996,
0.0108141229,
-0.0115347141,
-0.0352321304,
0.0127304094,
0.0220011678,
-0.0112796202,
0.0464774854,
-0.0262340382,
0.0155621255,
0.0253937561,
0.0002487657,
-0.0401610173,
-0.0276654735,
0.0236771107,
0.0387476683,
-0.0045419591,
-0.0423939936,
-0.0207261182,
-0.0214859676,
0.0387511775,
0.0007883848,
-0.0028357368,
0.0163844954,
0.0275516901,
-0.0318714008,
-0.0095245615,
-0.0438793413,
-0.0316540636,
-0.0060107973,
0.0023262766,
0.0188590083,
-0.0112431115,
-5.766490026e-33,
-0.079312712,
0.0142042218,
-0.0139541095,
0.0400059745,
-0.0654354244,
0.0371847674,
-0.0747688562,
-0.0151592242,
0.0308565777,
-0.0262378007,
-0.0174930263,
0.0227786042,
0.0278687291,
0.0266826376,
-0.0286111683,
0.0271416195,
0.0637775883,
0.0364074633,
-0.0358942486,
0.0340788513,
0.0277351122,
0.0522970669,
0.0515704006,
-0.0471955165,
0.0288056564,
-0.013250215,
-0.0214200281,
-0.0472093672,
0.0466873832,
0.0131745916,
-0.0167558193,
-0.0388120115,
0.0096156159,
-0.0205623787,
-0.0749171451,
0.0367668383,
-0.1309587061,
-0.0147811742,
-0.0023061559,
-0.0093888361,
-0.0423131511,
-0.0480925478,
0.0616210103,
-0.0350159071,
0.036647588,
-0.0309704933,
0.0643759221,
-0.0580144301,
-0.0183872059,
-0.0924108699,
-0.0419390351,
0.0323491618,
-0.0239155889,
0.017766051,
0.0253684837,
0.0044371556,
0.0267696939,
-0.006042799,
-0.0461368971,
0.0086095491,
0.0820353255,
0.0031632984,
-0.0040489393,
0.0375803709,
0.0035409653,
0.0389533453,
0.0330143496,
0.012538489,
0.0121958237,
0.0298640952,
0.0092779165,
0.0127384681,
0.0286276508,
0.024875477,
0.0551546551,
0.0229909979,
-0.050489448,
0.0924056843,
-0.0794576705,
0.0034092101,
0.0049899579,
0.0097535951,
-0.0446973294,
0.0193966646,
0.0022964044,
-0.0142820301,
-0.0231634285,
-0.0132143842,
-0.0137176653,
0.0359618999,
-0.0812424123,
0.0321373083,
0.0259652622,
-0.0338882804,
0.0090423655,
-0.0273535624,
0.0374341197,
0.0215157215,
-0.0195610244,
-0.0297422502,
-0.0312977098,
-0.0230469666,
0.0410567038,
0.0051084943,
-0.0297076721,
-0.0251631197,
0.074811928,
0.002480227,
-0.0690453574,
0.0040326854,
0.001896102,
0.0247748047,
0.0072693443,
0.0476339832,
-0.0067961742,
-0.0133119607,
0.0086169792,
0.0317352265,
-0.0010216021,
-0.0177745651,
-0.030786939,
0.0306300037,
0.0320282988,
0.0409580357,
0.0077356752,
0.0218176097,
0.0128215486,
0.0034010257,
0.0396647602,
-0.0386935025,
-0.0099584414,
-0.0102799609,
2.35e-7,
0.0475051031,
0.0000691613,
0.0790967792,
-0.0230403244,
-0.0370941013,
-0.0046732267,
0.0218229741,
0.056848485,
0.0396733172,
0.0174388532,
0.0650226027,
-0.0063520786,
0.0271423496,
0.0113658272,
-0.1072420701,
-0.0544663817,
-0.0292836223,
-0.0480005369,
-0.0406075157,
-0.0088900644,
0.0104006268,
0.0387861095,
-0.00827133,
0.0270415768,
-0.0022630538,
-0.0224864427,
0.046099104,
-0.0268462468,
-0.0132394135,
0.0503143594,
0.026794916,
0.0566689596,
-0.0478997603,
-0.0198094118,
-0.0419202596,
0.0133612799,
0.0492726304,
0.0266182274,
0.0116767641,
-0.0162863843,
0.0084993625,
-0.0355126821,
0.0146549437,
0.0190596059,
0.0395126827,
-0.0745409876,
0.0065310369,
0.0078531569,
-0.0864359662,
0.0063171173,
-0.0185369067,
0.0341443233,
-0.0264856163,
0.0589264482,
-0.0116797397,
0.0019985039,
0.0011711974,
-0.0930318534,
-0.0213185474,
0.0253328644,
0.0074003111,
-0.0260942541,
-0.0138628455,
-0.0359413885,
-0.0070505496,
-0.0884008929,
-0.0160001796,
2.328846704e-34,
0.0550548695,
-0.0009181817,
-0.0326018222,
0.0126744322,
0.0405394919,
-0.0406327657,
-0.0088565284,
-0.0234896187,
0.0050729234,
-0.0643178821,
-0.0141431903
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.02486v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.02486v2 | LongNet: Scaling Transformers to 1,000,000,000 Tokens | 2023-07-05T17:59:38 | 2023-07-19T12:25:35 | Jiayu Ding, Shuming Ma, Li Dong, Xingxing Zhang, Shaohan Huang, Wenhui Wang, Nanning Zheng, Furu Wei | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Scaling sequence length has become a critical demand in the era of large
language models. However, existing methods struggle with either computational
complexity or model expressivity, rendering the maximum sequence length
restricted. To address this issue, we introduce LongNet, a Transformer variant
that can scale sequence length to more than 1 billion tokens, without
sacrificing the performance on shorter sequences. Specifically, we propose
dilated attention, which expands the attentive field exponentially as the
distance grows. LongNet has significant advantages: 1) it has a linear
computation complexity and a logarithm dependency between any two tokens in a
sequence; 2) it can be served as a distributed trainer for extremely long
sequences; 3) its dilated attention is a drop-in replacement for standard
attention, which can be seamlessly integrated with the existing
Transformer-based optimization. Experiments results demonstrate that LongNet
yields strong performance on both long-sequence modeling and general language
tasks. Our work opens up new possibilities for modeling very long sequences,
e.g., treating a whole corpus or even the entire Internet as a sequence. | [
0.0157962758,
0.0847063735,
0.0025778287,
0.0306170061,
-0.0248316955,
-0.006467009,
0.0293699391,
-0.0025245661,
-0.0290380083,
-0.0208857972,
-0.0142098237,
-0.0592712611,
-0.0062590712,
0.0443807729,
0.0216650274,
-0.0636042878,
0.0335921124,
-0.0116598289,
-0.0164627843,
0.0175394043,
0.0040070978,
-0.0214472227,
0.0075519136,
0.0647063181,
-0.0001472107,
0.0024154831,
-0.0222015232,
-0.0130321626,
0.0249507539,
-0.0439721681,
0.0211661384,
0.0502674729,
0.0422498807,
0.0373492278,
0.0000017861,
0.0006868831,
0.0118472045,
-0.0117947282,
-0.0139003051,
0.0201324672,
0.0268264897,
0.0004176703,
0.0028472522,
0.0290236939,
-0.0335386358,
-0.0077552334,
0.0516998209,
0.0261246227,
0.0553999171,
0.1054368243,
0.0019983873,
-0.029350033,
0.0367794968,
-0.070262298,
-0.0002098456,
-0.0337159485,
0.0131021468,
-0.0350252315,
0.0139434366,
0.024342848,
-0.053273499,
0.0385203287,
0.058049392,
-0.0077542001,
0.0406532437,
0.0400319658,
-0.0590735339,
-0.0319819786,
-0.02189455,
0.0540355593,
-0.0529776104,
-0.0351289324,
0.0153189646,
0.0184183773,
0.0120801944,
-0.0462575629,
-0.036073558,
-0.0059698345,
0.0327801853,
0.002309138,
-0.0190502629,
0.0019747727,
0.0160672106,
-0.0091512594,
-0.0633612499,
0.006965511,
0.0090191467,
-0.0050501446,
-0.0511132032,
-0.0162253026,
-0.0364343077,
-0.0647331178,
0.0291940998,
0.0370641239,
-0.0259857271,
-0.0099068182,
-0.0432055667,
-0.0651531667,
0.0050286134,
-0.0061869128,
0.0455110297,
0.0257336702,
0.0011464574,
0.0394761302,
-0.0332702436,
0.0507510081,
-0.032947477,
-0.0050785886,
-0.0357192829,
0.0100401454,
-0.0425047055,
0.015949117,
-0.0684829429,
-0.0028409683,
-0.0219952296,
-0.0511847138,
-0.0196248889,
0.0106221642,
0.0243018493,
-0.0166334156,
0.0215254631,
0.0225527156,
-0.0370447561,
-0.0085646994,
0.0100233965,
0.0756048858,
-0.0716646016,
-0.0019623414,
0.0560747758,
-0.028224932,
-0.0425876975,
0.0392969847,
0.0128745101,
-0.0174263772,
0.0024676961,
0.0737461522,
-0.0096777016,
-0.0692823976,
-0.0005672819,
-0.0159514919,
-0.0204044115,
-0.049699042,
-0.0029759065,
-0.0692441389,
0.0175981279,
-0.0147018023,
-0.0125019271,
-0.0176191814,
0.0193399284,
0.0102922032,
-0.0067243059,
0.0528319441,
0.0188236665,
-0.0192156862,
-0.017784724,
0.0070094285,
0.0034739133,
0.0393903442,
0.039639581,
0.0504712202,
0.0162932128,
-0.0136450259,
-0.0014573514,
0.0195915084,
0.0556228645,
0.0091628069,
-0.0008333664,
0.0104955873,
-0.0008124171,
0.0409059301,
0.0140644386,
0.0697328001,
-0.0383516513,
-0.0210767426,
0.0692340285,
0.0494319983,
0.0344570652,
0.0355244875,
0.0477243662,
0.0121276835,
-0.0516398661,
-0.0077281222,
-0.0579086915,
0.0615090691,
0.0547987893,
0.0248090513,
0.0373405851,
0.0515126809,
-0.0445182137,
-0.0407212451,
-0.0171414725,
-0.0100075249,
0.0027226955,
-0.004373725,
0.0286968276,
0.0321627744,
-0.0543819666,
0.0949366838,
0.005798853,
-0.0589284785,
0.0061319978,
-0.0281944554,
-0.0102390982,
0.0508981533,
0.0126437042,
-0.0162197724,
-0.0450288095,
-0.0395292901,
0.0167437494,
0.0509692803,
0.0070293536,
0.0128731662,
-0.0286478847,
-0.0588986203,
0.0036020752,
0.0388944112,
0.0038203869,
0.0171360113,
0.0336561501,
0.0253221132,
0.0268936194,
-0.0235533919,
-0.003748887,
0.0160371922,
-0.0352648608,
-0.0303029995,
-0.0255803447,
0.0022376296,
0.0605849698,
-0.0005626151,
-0.0021972021,
0.0192586556,
0.0418516137,
-0.0459134243,
-0.0441528894,
-0.0239688195,
-0.0584003776,
-0.0067622941,
0.0353954062,
-0.0533010326,
0.0025483251,
0.0684679896,
-0.0329098217,
-0.0356694274,
0.0459805168,
-0.0779233277,
0.0552340597,
0.016522279,
0.0196384173,
0.008950999,
0.0520766489,
-0.0166712627,
0.0046234643,
-0.0305075776,
0.0185342468,
0.003655765,
-0.0124589168,
-0.0182689633,
-0.0389660522,
-0.0175143946,
0.016872203,
-0.0115964981,
-0.0049337735,
0.0260305796,
-0.0013867188,
-0.0259271115,
-0.0513566732,
-0.0717671216,
0.0176119264,
-0.0461585969,
0.0617954396,
0.0115491226,
0.035972923,
0.0095905103,
-0.0116841644,
-0.0436992943,
0.007527661,
-0.0380648077,
0.020034261,
0.0199587382,
-0.0055107879,
-0.0513349958,
-0.0400219746,
-0.044551719,
0.0090190889,
0.0463678427,
-0.0189185273,
-0.0003530343,
-0.034541674,
-0.0275722593,
-0.0219058525,
0.0363452248,
-0.016731441,
-0.0603829324,
-0.0077466676,
-0.0191210583,
0.0475650989,
0.0594406836,
0.0566197969,
0.0117855277,
0.017458871,
0.0072885347,
-0.0302608572,
0.0292110518,
-0.0379926264,
-0.0031330846,
-0.0471508503,
0.002322928,
-0.000999865,
0.0993521661,
-0.0564260818,
-0.0185354222,
-0.0683320612,
-0.0122098466,
0.0026591297,
-0.0100964187,
0.017160086,
0.0058068773,
-0.0407933034,
-0.0131374719,
-0.0054995683,
-0.0368870273,
0.0660878867,
-0.0213491078,
-0.018125115,
-0.0342710987,
-0.01104932,
-0.0381475314,
0.0693333149,
0.0337132923,
0.0043618721,
-0.0237863511,
-0.0370968841,
-0.0260790233,
0.0068424032,
-0.0117627177,
-0.0152755519,
0.0643371865,
-0.0096181622,
0.0094969543,
-0.0205341149,
-0.0414785556,
-0.0315866508,
-0.0055508176,
-0.0343958624,
0.0232142713,
0.0557114035,
-0.0482829884,
-0.0865279883,
0.0253718141,
0.0190602411,
0.0631377101,
-0.008712396,
0.0136201102,
-0.0230499599,
0.0303009488,
0.051867824,
-0.0008823684,
0.0223115571,
-0.030243827,
-0.0122575657,
0.0713888183,
0.0482746214,
-0.0094574168,
-0.0331995413,
-0.0191335902,
0.012846793,
-0.053567443,
-0.0016038945,
0.0232166909,
0.0546454713,
-0.0666595474,
-0.0245506912,
0.109887667,
0.0032352922,
-0.0621828027,
0.0366517678,
0.0230099615,
0.0652999133,
0.0219375808,
0.0142266173,
-0.0815220028,
-0.0430579446,
0.0181975197,
0.0155051257,
0.0361598805,
-0.0347940177,
-0.0075252429,
-0.07153254,
-0.0042985417,
0.0293445159,
-0.0300520416,
-0.0332343727,
-0.044622723,
-0.0169643089,
-0.0097477995,
0.0111431107,
0.0411502495,
0.0006126572,
-0.0049585584,
0.0107260467,
0.0201468877,
-0.0198194124,
0.0193682872,
-0.0286549199,
0.0345086046,
0.0283403918,
0.0042588217,
0.0281741899,
-0.0422706529,
0.0082639717,
0.0132556483,
0.0094360616,
0.010275091,
0.0415418744,
-0.0271157268,
-0.0188881494,
0.0043945219,
0.0471425429,
-0.0562722348,
0.0039577628,
0.0083039785,
0.0580916516,
0.0205604713,
-0.0361169465,
-0.0274028722,
-0.0291114822,
0.0100306412,
0.0464958474,
0.0477153808,
-0.05314916,
-0.0421018824,
-0.0048451982,
-0.0280907284,
-0.0393397585,
-0.0492423698,
-0.0318977609,
0.0232443716,
-0.0422746874,
-0.0876426324,
-0.0294575058,
-0.0026117493,
0.0306440629,
-0.0121619198,
-0.0562580414,
0.060491845,
0.0028405809,
-0.0540678874,
0.0237647891,
-0.0153053822,
0.0187534411,
-0.0979930162,
0.0183453262,
0.033963874,
0.0041001835,
-0.0149737652,
0.0433958396,
-0.1480945796,
-0.0611946583,
0.00422691,
0.0457640477,
0.0188779198,
0.0444536619,
-0.0069819996,
-0.0278129689,
0.0461210608,
0.0439655893,
-0.0417123549,
0.0123502929,
0.0294642765,
-0.0323771462,
0.0026255813,
0.0518759638,
-0.0184257105,
0.0369064026,
-0.0011053523,
0.0502220169,
-0.0130625265,
-0.0080025597,
-0.0073779179,
-0.0041202023,
0.0350988135,
0.0053797825,
0.0281318519,
0.0040671872,
0.0481236465,
0.0000076007,
0.0214243643,
-0.0431692712,
0.00528167,
0.004472638,
-0.0157531463,
0.0065662568,
0.0028478839,
0.027807286,
-0.0541377589,
-0.0107474206,
0.0498278998,
-0.0273412317,
-0.0327898934,
0.0542963147,
-0.0060434421,
-0.0117411967,
-0.0386657603,
0.0154501954,
0.038027782,
-0.0247449838,
0.0149209127,
0.0263217464,
0.036290139,
-0.0136163067,
0.0298898965,
-0.0761630014,
-0.0164525453,
-0.01624473,
0.0245738514,
0.0551962927,
-0.0071804691,
0.0366400555,
-0.0112882219,
-0.0041270293,
-0.0218696408,
0.0332928188,
-0.0271640625,
-0.0369463302,
0.0036917399,
0.0399915129,
-0.0082929851,
0.02034338,
0.0850047991,
-0.0124485409,
0.0346714035,
0.0156960748,
-0.0020415413,
-0.0490978472,
-0.0373467244,
-0.0195415057,
0.0065988097,
-0.0145531558,
0.0084128389,
-0.0209273193,
-0.0783056021,
0.0188979097,
-0.0045964858,
0.0136713469,
-0.0254835505,
0.0638779625,
0.0179175716,
-0.0124436449,
-0.0189154129,
-0.0117182564,
0.0293044839,
0.0118091349,
-0.0360844024,
-0.0057665571,
-6.039750953e-33,
0.0007867352,
-0.0149560152,
0.0201138984,
-0.0021479547,
-0.0634024888,
0.019405283,
-0.0401190408,
-0.0004723038,
0.0020332646,
0.006972617,
-0.0242755245,
0.0160476137,
0.0064211679,
0.0696216598,
0.0193701554,
-0.0169523377,
0.071933113,
-0.0031824198,
-0.0273882039,
0.0446429439,
0.0230874196,
0.0267181471,
0.0295374915,
-0.0013686029,
-0.0141040888,
0.0007805045,
0.0179395806,
0.0085649882,
0.0116309598,
0.0526858233,
0.0016279361,
0.0342298336,
-0.0053603943,
-0.0849890336,
-0.0484847091,
0.0163591057,
-0.0755570307,
0.0022957907,
-0.0360799432,
0.0078996737,
-0.0393900238,
-0.0408706069,
0.0546188913,
0.0021600022,
0.0114691956,
-0.0420917794,
0.0267958567,
-0.0021177093,
-0.037711367,
-0.0221117865,
-0.0404844359,
0.0166395977,
-0.0244231075,
-0.028331168,
0.0159534849,
0.0283404849,
-0.0090865968,
-0.0081338538,
-0.0292018317,
0.0009534663,
0.0136094177,
0.1028584987,
0.0483799651,
0.018786354,
0.0103355618,
0.0324647352,
0.0212962627,
-0.0258538947,
-0.0204488505,
-0.0030737992,
0.0240021851,
0.0305629168,
0.0610752255,
-0.0202490576,
0.0293923784,
-0.0158956256,
-0.0553223491,
-0.0520312563,
0.0101923058,
0.0649363324,
0.0318037346,
0.0411761627,
0.0007225435,
0.0119290641,
-0.0054149008,
-0.004921718,
-0.0178486761,
-0.0275304448,
0.0318964943,
0.0560683534,
-0.0048977472,
0.0029586249,
0.0507351272,
-0.0258584656,
0.0105977906,
0.0428188145,
0.0249779727,
0.0084897513,
0.0021447241,
0.0176376551,
-0.0688604414,
-0.0055407998,
-0.0084355166,
0.0232356563,
0.0039472263,
-0.0092266854,
0.0437831022,
0.0228452422,
-0.0754878372,
-0.0264521707,
-0.0486267954,
0.0350862816,
-0.0016221011,
0.0399285741,
0.0646825507,
-0.0114044109,
-0.0135456659,
0.0763744116,
-0.0239442736,
-0.0308888853,
-0.0015372901,
0.0415118635,
0.0194711667,
0.0266535338,
-0.0589571223,
0.0127038807,
-0.0844315588,
0.0674017817,
0.0029024431,
-0.0743760243,
-0.0328004509,
0.0381364785,
2.509e-7,
0.0039865198,
0.0393013023,
0.0614632592,
0.0159342848,
0.0397528671,
0.0088823866,
0.0196076129,
0.0673662797,
-0.0176992305,
0.0160861686,
0.0071528936,
0.0222626645,
0.0330829732,
0.000530865,
-0.1146565676,
-0.0251756124,
-0.0989080667,
0.0378795378,
-0.0370177627,
-0.0377009511,
0.0198515691,
0.1141725183,
0.0230333153,
0.0270907618,
0.0457692742,
-0.0323916301,
0.0356984586,
0.0078182127,
0.0154560599,
0.0094887568,
-0.0027054334,
0.0224027336,
-0.0304664392,
-0.012883665,
-0.0314246304,
0.0123590026,
-0.0031167327,
0.0810675174,
-0.0047409688,
-0.0197313111,
-0.0017934772,
-0.0037026701,
-0.0257130414,
-0.0323098488,
0.0419832841,
-0.0653192326,
-0.0154664693,
-0.0156872459,
-0.016694909,
-0.0178218614,
-0.0139676947,
0.0016328265,
-0.0033818199,
0.0488744341,
0.0312413834,
-0.0059447158,
0.0175719373,
-0.1070476621,
-0.013295061,
-0.0135897724,
-0.0648799464,
-0.0269518029,
-0.0938713625,
0.0074273022,
0.0248398129,
-0.015617108,
-0.0405628718,
2.232103519e-34,
0.0392197333,
-0.0153669612,
0.0130372895,
0.0140422517,
0.0164843798,
-0.0178734064,
-0.0019290332,
0.0008438847,
0.0376505628,
-0.089352116,
-0.0655982941
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.02485v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.02485v2 | Building Cooperative Embodied Agents Modularly with Large Language Models | 2023-07-05T17:59:27 | 2024-02-17T05:27:56 | Hongxin Zhang, Weihua Du, Jiaming Shan, Qinhong Zhou, Yilun Du, Joshua B. Tenenbaum, Tianmin Shu, Chuang Gan | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | In this work, we address challenging multi-agent cooperation problems with
decentralized control, raw sensory observations, costly communication, and
multi-objective tasks instantiated in various embodied environments. While
previous research either presupposes a cost-free communication channel or
relies on a centralized controller with shared observations, we harness the
commonsense knowledge, reasoning ability, language comprehension, and text
generation prowess of LLMs and seamlessly incorporate them into a
cognitive-inspired modular framework that integrates with perception, memory,
and execution. Thus building a Cooperative Embodied Language Agent CoELA, who
can plan, communicate, and cooperate with others to accomplish long-horizon
tasks efficiently. Our experiments on C-WAH and TDW-MAT demonstrate that CoELA
driven by GPT-4 can surpass strong planning-based methods and exhibit emergent
effective communication. Though current Open LMs like LLAMA-2 still
underperform, we fine-tune a CoELA with data collected with our agents and show
how they can achieve promising performance. We also conducted a user study for
human-agent interaction and discovered that CoELA communicating in natural
language can earn more trust and cooperate more effectively with humans. Our
research underscores the potential of LLMs for future research in multi-agent
cooperation. Videos can be found on the project website
https://vis-www.cs.umass.edu/Co-LLM-Agents/. | [
0.0445444249,
0.0245324019,
-0.0268158559,
0.019423401,
-0.0297358707,
0.0024161355,
-0.0172170512,
-0.0199676678,
0.0176615566,
-0.0085678315,
-0.0415565819,
-0.0106536988,
0.0080341985,
0.0312343892,
0.0235894416,
-0.0355267152,
0.0279190075,
-0.0389109813,
-0.0176338516,
-0.0236732904,
-0.0057596802,
-0.0317673497,
-0.0235247016,
0.0475591272,
-0.0295341145,
0.0190430786,
-0.0670937821,
-0.0351281911,
0.025084788,
-0.0280202162,
-0.0326781534,
-0.0190596674,
0.0683744401,
0.0241551884,
0.0000020306,
-0.0501653552,
0.0066700191,
-0.044417277,
0.0089621311,
-0.0568094291,
0.0243419297,
-0.0190044828,
-0.017022416,
0.0033893648,
-0.062107686,
0.0269303676,
0.0454220176,
-0.000141528,
0.0435401239,
0.0471661687,
0.0114111276,
0.01383946,
0.004279613,
0.013031926,
0.0116505772,
-0.0182084367,
0.0025875962,
-0.0099402163,
0.0869727209,
-0.0263754856,
-0.0214684419,
0.0206902232,
0.0508256964,
-0.0239797533,
-0.0198463574,
0.0569420271,
-0.0111676799,
-0.0669877082,
-0.0223242696,
0.0586574189,
0.0447638519,
-0.012361411,
0.0198789015,
0.0150409751,
0.0020633512,
0.0029913245,
-0.0052245706,
0.0584839843,
0.0070652445,
0.0178415813,
-0.020774886,
0.0202369429,
0.002509723,
0.0159738977,
-0.001431753,
0.1047843024,
-0.0165495072,
0.0069984165,
0.0171118788,
-0.0016059863,
-0.0079402523,
-0.0279930439,
0.0284593124,
0.093989253,
-0.0373020433,
0.0245332289,
-0.0509265289,
0.0249773189,
-0.0101658991,
-0.0352484509,
0.0335181095,
0.033515837,
0.0064657917,
0.0232854802,
-0.0081109535,
0.039670974,
0.0102539863,
0.0196981952,
0.0108439093,
0.001239712,
-0.0605481826,
-0.0039986577,
-0.0396549702,
0.0694313422,
-0.0226064604,
-0.0378368199,
0.0052853008,
0.0443622842,
-0.0326297171,
0.0272892453,
-0.0237566307,
0.0063640848,
0.0032026905,
-0.0142565938,
-0.0559286997,
-0.0321641043,
-0.0028459474,
0.0377923958,
-0.002145241,
-0.0367239378,
-0.0070166974,
0.0184937716,
0.0055045257,
-0.0087251263,
-0.0140515165,
0.0636550114,
-0.0227256864,
-0.0259585846,
0.0341141373,
-0.0236604065,
0.0315338485,
-0.0631989464,
-0.014222784,
-0.0483457595,
0.0391930863,
-0.0235477798,
0.0045571807,
-0.035512343,
0.0345892869,
-0.0336393081,
0.0265258066,
0.0746098459,
-0.0198229589,
0.039958816,
0.0262970496,
0.0400380492,
0.0076111834,
0.0531821735,
0.0921732634,
0.0510454848,
-0.0123748397,
0.0442977361,
0.0258869957,
0.0385089777,
-0.0202417914,
-0.0138257034,
0.0391831174,
-0.0256003719,
-0.0097433105,
0.0836316869,
-0.0084131295,
0.0583218075,
-0.0254481118,
0.0115135387,
0.0665770546,
0.0508972891,
-0.060816586,
-0.0459938012,
0.0373881198,
0.0356024541,
0.002431995,
-0.0532443151,
-0.0284882765,
0.0657838508,
0.0048271199,
-0.0201055277,
-0.0310073942,
0.0168249402,
-0.0122280978,
-0.023962196,
0.0143531384,
-0.0237289611,
0.0477578305,
-0.0176260974,
0.0098069822,
-0.0146847283,
-0.0670932233,
0.0016042753,
-0.0207025502,
-0.037003085,
0.0217156019,
-0.0465232618,
0.0596104823,
0.0326047838,
0.0028754792,
-0.0013829235,
-0.0261462759,
0.0202305485,
0.0058523361,
0.0832824185,
-0.0161381029,
-0.0243007522,
0.020439988,
-0.0256017055,
0.0045635886,
0.0128081907,
-0.0183031932,
0.0347213782,
-0.0006573217,
0.0510135256,
-0.0267974176,
0.0603104495,
0.0263786092,
0.0366099104,
0.0038630725,
0.0446616337,
-0.0338455923,
0.0005501345,
0.0665358379,
0.0003416516,
-0.0261985585,
-0.0034362052,
0.0419728421,
-0.0227198601,
-0.0629708245,
0.0777050257,
-0.0145775769,
-0.0168357193,
0.0331812054,
-0.0341594666,
-0.0028769914,
0.0371531509,
0.0120380661,
-0.0573045164,
0.0610401742,
-0.0399979949,
0.0366492271,
-0.0279828086,
-0.0029049406,
0.0136079863,
-0.0318572558,
0.0133217704,
0.0133967586,
-0.013555456,
-0.0610735752,
0.0055959099,
0.0291594863,
0.0240104087,
-0.0475154743,
0.0176628996,
0.0745222047,
0.0226657707,
0.0129075851,
0.0291142613,
0.0180297643,
-0.031033583,
-0.0505967624,
-0.0742380247,
-0.0431462266,
-0.0007315135,
-0.0064311009,
-0.0281484891,
-0.0583406985,
-0.015812628,
0.0163397808,
0.0035562217,
0.0846215039,
0.009439108,
-0.0186949186,
0.032388676,
0.0289907586,
-0.0474786274,
-0.0387516432,
0.0344952419,
0.0129024982,
-0.0263841897,
0.0416148752,
-0.0421738364,
-0.0515341125,
0.0072457204,
-0.0631679669,
0.0393723473,
-0.0200165994,
-0.0603733957,
0.0696221441,
-0.0294272061,
0.0066637611,
0.0307498854,
-0.0229783002,
0.053435985,
0.0956492648,
-0.033100225,
-0.0535717346,
0.0581438839,
-0.0352548659,
0.0016734308,
-0.043354921,
0.0099334409,
0.0137663465,
0.0458254442,
-0.0247393996,
-0.0010869433,
-0.0672948807,
-0.0061441222,
0.0002052565,
-0.0629370138,
-0.0133314058,
-0.009016295,
-0.0441693664,
0.0211166684,
-0.0280341599,
-0.039391838,
0.0674915612,
-0.0141791059,
-0.026222894,
0.0170527827,
-0.0077211955,
-0.0231743176,
0.1107103527,
0.0110138254,
-0.0048715258,
-0.0098522194,
0.0035607277,
-0.0183726661,
0.0123355733,
0.0123829506,
0.0123523939,
-0.0068594795,
-0.0852251053,
0.0278039984,
-0.0074683968,
-0.0270291585,
-0.0138589432,
0.0507046692,
-0.0439307243,
0.0266783219,
-0.0142045999,
-0.0397010595,
-0.0469794683,
-0.0185139831,
0.0344559439,
0.0026056736,
0.0004732518,
0.0056028431,
-0.0654254928,
-0.0608257987,
0.0429603308,
0.0974633023,
-0.0140962321,
-0.0462526456,
0.0329222567,
0.0563732907,
0.0464046374,
-0.0526807643,
-0.0181469377,
-0.012195128,
0.0195724778,
0.0242365189,
0.0175933912,
0.0312259402,
0.0817717016,
-0.034142755,
0.0016791114,
0.084034197,
0.0139909163,
-0.008503397,
0.0088291699,
-0.0319538154,
0.037720453,
0.0039332467,
-0.003463469,
-0.0122046769,
-0.0183759537,
0.0030154597,
-0.0017073414,
0.000264373,
-0.0580634438,
-0.0191373583,
-0.0957661271,
0.0225158837,
0.007157404,
-0.0411904156,
-0.0193642434,
-0.0485497788,
-0.0077222995,
0.0109566273,
-0.0261864197,
0.0178422611,
0.048340641,
-0.0045243623,
-0.0110396706,
0.0031514384,
0.0146025475,
-0.0000934303,
-0.0273041837,
0.0794349834,
0.0298004337,
0.0656610578,
-0.0326766595,
-0.0629238412,
0.006324389,
-0.0213717986,
0.0386687703,
-0.0255172495,
-0.0477818586,
-0.0063611129,
0.0061751651,
0.0151681779,
0.0371540003,
-0.0452884436,
-0.0259188451,
0.0272338316,
0.0851321146,
-0.0600251444,
-0.0418317989,
-0.0235613026,
0.0294369552,
0.0148384627,
0.0561879054,
-0.0278092101,
-0.031773448,
-0.0399215557,
0.0018513065,
-0.0668608546,
0.0077397344,
-0.0316524841,
-0.027346136,
-0.0147975683,
0.0126895253,
-0.0807061568,
-0.0648746714,
0.0575459749,
0.0371971168,
0.0071826549,
0.0122173829,
0.0136807999,
0.0416210815,
-0.022384556,
0.0073090144,
-0.0085943593,
0.0118538383,
-0.0391577743,
0.0070731854,
0.0185205229,
-0.0553649217,
0.0349617638,
0.0318521857,
-0.0498676151,
-0.0981003121,
-0.0160039663,
0.0434543528,
0.0263517108,
-0.0209397394,
0.0084321834,
-0.0527939983,
0.0170102026,
0.0358854197,
-0.03770319,
0.0577023104,
-0.0006098324,
0.0482040457,
0.0161784515,
0.0567563735,
-0.0293577034,
-0.0007300276,
0.0013629303,
0.027246939,
-0.0199899506,
-0.0196818467,
-0.0002987367,
-0.0134476107,
-0.0237745196,
-0.0322662555,
0.0109414598,
-0.0232292954,
0.0026281809,
-0.0274036732,
0.008739179,
-0.0699388087,
0.032289084,
-0.0179327205,
0.0198713914,
0.0427769944,
0.0200151671,
0.0230476782,
0.0329527073,
0.0515071675,
0.0382094905,
-0.0066095917,
-0.000198236,
0.0106572863,
0.024744451,
0.02975302,
0.0201042611,
-0.0474985242,
0.0141785592,
0.0542362407,
0.0612514354,
0.0051025371,
-0.0400415622,
0.0099422922,
0.0161525495,
-0.0399007089,
-0.0806585997,
0.086459972,
0.0593279637,
0.0304475129,
0.0777265131,
0.0411255136,
-0.124677971,
0.0213644262,
0.0028413036,
0.0402956456,
-0.001537481,
-0.0373828895,
0.064231202,
0.0216238946,
-0.0121220211,
-0.0016733406,
0.0347773768,
-0.0170140453,
0.0487690382,
-0.0103705721,
0.001154874,
-0.0330258571,
-0.034838859,
0.0108374804,
0.0161847528,
-0.0128602935,
0.0016573677,
-0.0310010426,
-0.0266247112,
-0.0170945171,
0.0627759099,
-0.0282014739,
-0.0295563731,
0.0581071749,
-0.0318567529,
0.0060647167,
-0.0271715447,
0.0050250501,
-0.0358984768,
-0.0079845292,
-0.0041037188,
0.0171257406,
-5.752657029e-33,
-0.0464165807,
-0.0424204692,
0.0537446886,
0.0052331928,
-0.027274264,
-0.0326108262,
-0.0607200228,
0.0249603502,
-0.0105433967,
0.0030029318,
0.0188657977,
0.016630426,
0.0052756174,
-0.0227331873,
0.0177303664,
0.0147112962,
-0.0212964956,
-0.0216272436,
-0.0354539566,
0.0034537404,
0.027001176,
0.0067002112,
-0.0151167046,
-0.0261163693,
0.0235004555,
0.0202189237,
-0.0390580185,
0.0511636473,
-0.049325604,
0.0196623784,
-0.0288832579,
0.00238444,
0.0006702202,
0.0384256206,
-0.0244025402,
0.0080039632,
-0.0144984182,
-0.0268494301,
0.0138655491,
-0.0158808492,
-0.0846771151,
-0.0317527726,
0.0099867545,
-0.0081787361,
-0.0411872417,
0.0457839109,
0.0073646358,
-0.0187321063,
0.0178173333,
0.0307802074,
-0.0336187594,
0.0096348515,
-0.004597744,
-0.0341143161,
0.0318202376,
-0.0047540409,
-0.0088751847,
-0.0169251543,
-0.0301388446,
0.0251376275,
-0.0506062135,
-0.0376640223,
0.03544496,
-0.0130374813,
0.0492838919,
0.0669436455,
0.0217251051,
0.0021174226,
-0.0655942634,
-0.0001299748,
0.0104162609,
0.0631187037,
0.0387250409,
0.0541396737,
-0.043698214,
-0.0019443092,
-0.0064569521,
0.0420146063,
0.023143243,
0.0487828404,
0.0198704917,
0.0351487398,
-0.015884554,
0.0001541508,
-0.0037220041,
0.0289487839,
0.0006749841,
-0.0313483365,
-0.0108142942,
0.0347591341,
-0.0002912699,
-0.0571801066,
0.0277190991,
-0.0068510696,
-0.0125733586,
-0.0033576649,
-0.0304817427,
0.0409958214,
0.0171678104,
-0.0216417667,
-0.0878166333,
-0.0129681667,
0.0122286705,
-0.0160678178,
0.0067763403,
0.0288956035,
-0.0258261394,
0.0929313004,
0.0123020271,
-0.0035990779,
-0.0274887607,
0.0060218065,
0.0535906516,
-0.0548080727,
0.041157756,
-0.0389092155,
-0.0270262342,
-0.0190313943,
-0.0135176247,
-0.080568321,
-0.0070734723,
0.0347163938,
-0.0463169403,
-0.0069410051,
-0.0258782133,
0.0022257583,
-0.0503732003,
0.0472123325,
0.0222491045,
-0.0612302162,
0.0002621636,
-0.0010673538,
2.89e-7,
-0.0396097302,
0.0005425409,
0.0191962626,
0.0048702429,
0.0561028235,
0.0346334092,
-0.0590949059,
0.0629131123,
-0.074026458,
-0.0552150942,
0.0164428335,
0.0480708517,
0.0408192798,
-0.0225890074,
-0.0650537387,
0.0001741605,
0.0260687806,
-0.0899932384,
-0.0498803034,
-0.0366972163,
0.0459724218,
0.0298766959,
0.0391488224,
-0.0087068938,
0.0063456167,
-0.0096128667,
0.0272688884,
-0.0694271028,
0.0199881997,
-0.0233168956,
-0.0244422201,
-0.024978688,
-0.0466071106,
-0.0178441573,
0.0417432114,
0.0070219869,
-0.0131686451,
0.0509159528,
0.0041669281,
-0.0158515479,
0.0092302822,
0.0083108712,
-0.0239360761,
-0.0246677417,
0.0385769457,
-0.042224355,
-0.004694812,
0.0330906734,
0.0643716976,
-0.0280095693,
-0.055679664,
-0.0156806502,
0.0062850234,
-0.0035452773,
-0.0464242473,
-0.0392543152,
0.0104367891,
-0.0519084558,
0.0166053548,
-0.0290199537,
-0.0712459162,
-0.0683926046,
-0.0409021154,
0.0315078124,
-0.0114452504,
-0.0415725671,
-0.0221768133,
2.04204996e-34,
-0.014632659,
-0.0157958884,
-0.0216782466,
0.0230829623,
0.0325756297,
0.0000768409,
-0.0225301795,
0.0170633625,
0.0610342212,
-0.0039535309,
-0.0469953939
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.02477v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.02477v3 | Reasoning or Reciting? Exploring the Capabilities and Limitations of Language Models Through Counterfactual Tasks | 2023-07-05T17:50:42 | 2024-03-28T23:37:24 | Zhaofeng Wu, Linlu Qiu, Alexis Ross, Ekin Akyürek, Boyuan Chen, Bailin Wang, Najoung Kim, Jacob Andreas, Yoon Kim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The impressive performance of recent language models across a wide range of
tasks suggests that they possess a degree of abstract reasoning skills. Are
these skills general and transferable, or specialized to specific tasks seen
during pretraining? To disentangle these effects, we propose an evaluation
framework based on "counterfactual" task variants that deviate from the default
assumptions underlying standard tasks. Across a suite of 11 tasks, we observe
nontrivial performance on the counterfactual variants, but nevertheless find
that performance substantially and consistently degrades compared to the
default conditions. This suggests that while current LMs may possess abstract
task-solving skills to an extent, they often also rely on narrow,
non-transferable procedures for task-solving. These results motivate a more
careful interpretation of language model performance that teases apart these
aspects of behavior. | [
0.0368181914,
0.0248504877,
-0.0355920233,
0.0269349292,
-0.0625018477,
0.0407942086,
0.0172572006,
-0.0021581675,
-0.0327029303,
-0.0527422614,
-0.0558935553,
-0.0448677465,
-0.0071773352,
0.0136482809,
0.0642340481,
-0.0349013992,
0.050754074,
-0.0567265376,
0.029356245,
-0.0243745614,
-0.0515670665,
-0.01015836,
-0.0293646511,
0.0080515519,
0.0345268734,
-0.0153871747,
-0.0002882006,
-0.0198329892,
-0.0015713463,
0.0099637313,
-0.0085417144,
0.0174977817,
0.0162102412,
-0.0249651596,
0.000001885,
-0.0610249452,
0.0473690964,
-0.0313606635,
-0.0451341458,
-0.007288327,
0.0194537342,
-0.0011121384,
-0.0035491739,
0.0199593306,
-0.0399996713,
0.0012504957,
0.0051183742,
0.0394793823,
0.0099410061,
0.0732200146,
-0.002879275,
0.0068459152,
0.0023352066,
-0.024811456,
0.0237620082,
-0.0360690169,
0.0020852725,
0.0160476025,
0.0058612125,
-0.0251862276,
-0.0108473487,
0.0505242757,
0.0520802066,
0.0149251744,
-0.0325461067,
0.0418774635,
0.0036725022,
-0.0143555151,
-0.0193995256,
0.0089567127,
0.0020314043,
-0.0388194695,
-0.015208846,
-0.0140263503,
-0.0043980782,
0.0062289941,
-0.0452625044,
0.0539057218,
0.0237084329,
0.0329597183,
0.0417711474,
-0.0001849747,
0.0488601066,
0.0139621357,
-0.0261601973,
0.0826172829,
0.0097855907,
-0.0468159281,
0.0396384187,
0.0463118516,
-0.021520935,
-0.0805770829,
0.0015751629,
0.04948074,
0.0007280937,
0.0238872599,
-0.0248289462,
-0.0055181957,
0.0044799452,
-0.0132570816,
0.0827686563,
0.0590915196,
0.0088669667,
0.0177443642,
-0.0421048626,
0.0642202571,
-0.0271539632,
0.052297093,
-0.0398716405,
-0.0072106961,
-0.0426396765,
-0.0538073406,
0.00205063,
0.0243089981,
-0.0233157799,
0.0027418684,
-0.0010576429,
0.0288893916,
-0.0079563959,
-0.023458682,
-0.005763493,
0.0021602088,
-0.0234619994,
-0.0330978371,
-0.0527090803,
0.0191123188,
-0.0080581894,
0.0575635023,
0.0187704861,
-0.0594335049,
-0.0059743039,
0.0059236335,
-0.0487956479,
-0.0550762787,
0.0126296273,
0.0671036541,
-0.041174043,
-0.0169542041,
-0.0333853588,
-0.0049165748,
-0.0027180088,
-0.1253329217,
0.0568152778,
-0.0215536244,
-0.0099454103,
0.023450736,
0.0007697961,
-0.0186629258,
-0.0090823546,
0.0091492562,
-0.0207581148,
0.0524360277,
0.0455681719,
0.0543989576,
0.0189952347,
0.0167568605,
-0.035560593,
0.0598678328,
0.0250422023,
-0.0199551322,
-0.027667135,
-0.0124446321,
0.0161334891,
0.0324142016,
0.0137732951,
-0.0242161378,
-0.0507622659,
-0.0010895751,
-0.0361570939,
-0.0009410524,
0.0716256648,
0.048623804,
-0.0052195997,
-0.0090111615,
0.084466286,
0.0542487837,
0.0032891738,
0.0087883705,
0.0559612326,
-0.0377932824,
0.0083611831,
0.0530114286,
-0.1034839675,
0.0358054526,
-0.0161388423,
0.0265612267,
-0.0328223221,
-0.0161515959,
-0.0331694707,
-0.034915816,
-0.0304598585,
0.0063129184,
0.0231195949,
0.0407734253,
0.0504356213,
0.0488983877,
-0.0229400564,
0.0366601571,
-0.0042022336,
-0.0369744189,
0.0022855692,
-0.0618034862,
-0.0150422091,
0.0428382643,
0.012259773,
-0.0079752309,
-0.0515864864,
0.0253309011,
0.0243553407,
0.0751763135,
0.0838837177,
0.0140537638,
0.0149969561,
-0.0182207488,
0.0203759056,
-0.0497589596,
0.0232469719,
-0.0033153601,
-0.0071057873,
0.0088519482,
0.0013455896,
-0.0429543108,
-0.0031825153,
0.0455816016,
-0.0786542222,
0.0002551189,
-0.0354580358,
0.0172208566,
-0.0058504352,
-0.0091356281,
0.0034672848,
0.0293429047,
0.0389362797,
-0.0333092958,
0.0026654671,
0.0558424182,
-0.0701850876,
-0.030710971,
0.0356307514,
0.0055318768,
-0.0486484952,
0.089585349,
0.0124198217,
-0.0487122834,
0.0498029552,
-0.0160353389,
0.0751936585,
-0.0265066531,
0.0327691063,
-0.0089215608,
-0.0168103371,
0.0022757265,
0.0613840036,
-0.0082128849,
0.0120409876,
0.012274188,
0.0075766989,
-0.0093191192,
-0.0622071214,
-0.0372361764,
0.0074932817,
-0.0009041604,
-0.0251493789,
-0.0463632606,
-0.0060982467,
-0.0318997204,
0.0044882605,
-0.0593950637,
-0.0155238248,
-0.0209508426,
0.0128808022,
0.0637366697,
-0.0408749878,
-0.0066741835,
-0.0026172122,
-0.0211487375,
-0.0150295114,
0.0197921097,
0.0354526304,
0.0204484519,
-0.0075370199,
0.0036100687,
-0.0161776505,
-0.0245399661,
-0.0298936889,
0.0070150495,
-0.014691609,
0.0289282426,
-0.0316584148,
0.0628204197,
-0.0419453494,
0.0058776457,
-0.0299976971,
-0.0045981938,
0.0503331944,
0.0109994886,
0.0308208223,
0.0634251386,
-0.0137598962,
0.0208965316,
0.063715063,
-0.0061154673,
-0.031414438,
0.0174085144,
0.002436657,
-0.0166909434,
-0.0544593707,
-0.0492413305,
-0.0451788642,
0.068499878,
0.0228792559,
0.0093283476,
-0.0500312634,
-0.0109485509,
-0.0149764987,
-0.0436690226,
-0.0230827089,
-0.0372153483,
-0.0446173362,
0.0629119053,
-0.0532502122,
-0.0348356813,
0.0564268529,
0.0026676669,
-0.0265392531,
-0.0342490003,
-0.0127571905,
0.0099699823,
0.0843058303,
-0.0154302111,
-0.014825793,
0.0051347045,
-0.022810597,
-0.0636468083,
0.0148726143,
-0.011089894,
-0.0210143924,
0.0444642603,
-0.0427799411,
0.0011095539,
-0.0075862133,
-0.0311146118,
-0.0504939221,
-0.007126546,
-0.0113057587,
0.0376625508,
-0.02869034,
0.0106849112,
-0.0189779196,
0.0083890287,
0.0123868464,
0.0100040948,
-0.0033823831,
-0.0023325244,
-0.0155426646,
-0.013776117,
0.0337083228,
0.0530930161,
0.0328450948,
-0.0426862799,
0.0114547433,
0.0240002014,
0.0800166354,
-0.0172993895,
-0.0172908939,
0.0477567911,
0.0172117408,
-0.004934276,
-0.0413616896,
0.0134927994,
0.0476029776,
-0.0574804507,
-0.0301450901,
0.1035684347,
0.0323492289,
-0.0053807409,
0.0189278293,
-0.0138912518,
0.0366684906,
0.0460951254,
-0.0024468068,
-0.0457788743,
-0.0139732165,
0.0445884801,
0.0124677131,
-0.0312593579,
-0.0222604293,
-0.0280116815,
-0.1215880066,
0.0200063232,
0.0012815017,
-0.0522388853,
0.0002703755,
-0.0109341294,
0.0084077455,
0.0021168925,
0.0243901368,
0.0404849276,
-0.0124765066,
-0.0198011305,
0.0155074773,
-0.0253256131,
-0.0547339693,
0.046541065,
-0.0212645363,
0.0410547666,
0.0542801768,
0.0002447601,
0.0014890749,
-0.0219592415,
0.0810097456,
-0.0146805486,
0.0323051177,
-0.0021251554,
0.032169424,
-0.0065168701,
-0.0217469912,
-0.0026103642,
0.0065778117,
-0.0328322686,
-0.0362172723,
-0.0247208625,
0.1012610942,
-0.0279052574,
-0.0396788307,
0.0041426481,
0.0098804198,
-0.0022518935,
0.1093485132,
0.049372945,
-0.0494460613,
-0.0571099333,
-0.0100494847,
-0.0331734158,
-0.0333655737,
-0.0232635662,
0.0046536406,
0.0435141176,
-0.0034062376,
-0.0536124595,
-0.0741149038,
0.0255083144,
0.0331968814,
0.0007145922,
0.0017374519,
0.0013079514,
-0.0532917194,
-0.0442653559,
0.0341738202,
-0.0022317136,
0.0235439707,
-0.0253244042,
-0.0387017056,
0.0149519658,
-0.0308566708,
-0.0322027989,
-0.013269797,
-0.0761601701,
-0.0736309364,
0.0087414011,
0.0329568684,
0.0398322679,
0.0220996961,
-0.0074750679,
-0.0457871594,
-0.0052108304,
-0.0328570083,
-0.0407151096,
0.064409554,
0.0488248169,
-0.0094208233,
0.0349289365,
0.049692519,
-0.0057240045,
-0.0005536305,
0.0565656126,
0.0389442518,
0.0027312001,
0.0060958215,
0.0113990325,
-0.0042489595,
0.0385300256,
0.0067227404,
-0.0174868405,
-0.0466876999,
0.0149892997,
-0.0185330696,
-0.0221930128,
-0.0334584117,
-0.033723563,
0.0386649333,
0.0550531894,
-0.0016780521,
-0.0049301828,
-0.0211717524,
0.0510256328,
-0.0227178689,
0.0105980383,
-0.0072340961,
0.009391496,
0.003007143,
0.0363044739,
-0.0218820218,
0.0003777673,
-0.0184778143,
0.0407599621,
0.0115017798,
0.0427324697,
-0.0031814948,
0.0010114666,
-0.0242058989,
-0.0110016484,
-0.1093185619,
-0.0544734821,
0.0211815983,
0.0035686099,
0.0474847108,
-0.0411712527,
0.040524628,
-0.0601539537,
0.0109702628,
-0.0173886959,
-0.0002490146,
0.0106354039,
-0.0204663873,
0.0351266824,
0.0213876553,
0.0003313726,
0.0235680323,
0.0397234373,
-0.0165638402,
0.0736500546,
-0.0207057688,
0.0286810268,
-0.0179826096,
-0.0556975342,
0.0093619442,
0.0081342086,
-0.0027022024,
-0.0005776642,
-0.065987885,
-0.0945619494,
0.0208119079,
0.012040332,
0.0086365361,
-0.0480061583,
0.0094356444,
0.0531568415,
-0.0197724886,
-0.0288451314,
-0.0289184749,
-0.0032469952,
0.0238845181,
0.0277412292,
-0.0684009716,
-6.181919648e-33,
-0.0531756245,
-0.0086378446,
0.0501671545,
-0.0374157801,
0.0006340643,
-0.0154048083,
-0.0609460697,
0.0368672907,
-0.0588566698,
-0.0031785069,
-0.0096957609,
0.0061527635,
0.0256342124,
0.0202521104,
0.0056167711,
0.0052011022,
0.0011497864,
-0.0238706805,
-0.0236624908,
-0.0245021414,
0.0136878099,
0.0210635178,
0.0789438188,
-0.042333737,
0.0163496137,
-0.0053328178,
0.0133012617,
0.0111024268,
-0.0792494044,
0.0511810258,
-0.0295933895,
-0.0022978152,
0.0504094623,
-0.0205017813,
-0.0469870418,
0.0094325198,
-0.042655766,
-0.0231261738,
0.0765200108,
0.0062207966,
-0.0169111677,
-0.0189474896,
0.0536445417,
0.0043882453,
-0.0413289331,
-0.0119892163,
0.002430649,
-0.0368732251,
0.0204154272,
0.0413928814,
-0.0731555745,
-0.0166337937,
0.0040250206,
-0.0104560712,
0.0000072983,
0.0279089026,
-0.0441711321,
-0.0090699065,
-0.0658115223,
0.0173535813,
-0.0057500945,
0.0160071198,
0.0901966766,
0.0118250959,
-0.000102123,
0.0455513522,
0.0522846021,
0.0265524425,
-0.01476142,
0.0087862927,
0.0669994801,
0.0525626093,
0.0344134234,
0.0087523526,
0.0418941565,
-0.0033459931,
-0.0264343768,
-0.0430421941,
-0.0112124886,
0.0315609314,
0.0457427762,
0.0246854834,
0.0000593512,
-0.0182650611,
-0.0496264808,
0.0060600662,
-0.0275755879,
-0.015238584,
0.0555737838,
-0.0144459298,
0.0139126964,
-0.0079890899,
0.0362139344,
-0.0257661361,
0.0025870944,
0.0093108285,
-0.0297234058,
0.0433107913,
0.0035512249,
0.0294219535,
-0.0927355736,
-0.0246471763,
0.0161053818,
0.0449256115,
-0.0001655382,
0.0061128004,
0.0286182743,
0.0355157629,
-0.0265173316,
-0.0099917203,
-0.0606259257,
0.0170135144,
0.0372273363,
0.0230433475,
0.0640495121,
-0.0074124369,
-0.0279626828,
0.0319661349,
-0.0194614716,
-0.0862620622,
-0.0509557128,
0.0448463373,
-0.0128044542,
0.0179607533,
-0.0110839335,
0.0100973444,
-0.0142405452,
0.0352671519,
0.0166641325,
-0.0080651408,
-0.0067360341,
0.0333572738,
2.574e-7,
0.0802037865,
-0.0025387229,
0.0144765312,
0.0503244735,
0.0214856677,
0.0042200624,
-0.0770099461,
-0.0271268692,
0.0543839447,
0.010494316,
-0.012342535,
0.0839826167,
0.069163084,
0.0033763563,
-0.0134750167,
0.0113092577,
-0.0617907941,
-0.0066950307,
-0.026934756,
0.0286659785,
0.0377816074,
0.0382170528,
0.0140275052,
-0.0283398461,
-0.0066079516,
-0.0605899692,
0.0539218374,
-0.0558993556,
0.0230236631,
-0.0299667623,
-0.0092931362,
0.0302555934,
-0.0004526687,
0.0495023094,
0.0116150305,
0.0227153935,
-0.0244820248,
0.0646243095,
0.0004118572,
-0.0785877258,
-0.0436813645,
0.0121272365,
-0.0064475606,
-0.0480172522,
0.0946955904,
-0.0371591225,
-0.0348478556,
0.0097940676,
0.0078682564,
0.0121050412,
-0.008255478,
-0.0012060348,
-0.0273080152,
0.0035012104,
0.036816515,
0.0055726259,
-0.03822634,
-0.0743735358,
-0.0389447175,
0.0470577255,
-0.0684488118,
-0.0582874715,
-0.0531311408,
0.0048572491,
0.0325583555,
-0.0562377796,
-0.0368098132,
2.111030586e-34,
0.0107370028,
0.0187027249,
0.0359867774,
0.0651232973,
0.0040378054,
0.0001471674,
-0.0172777046,
0.0132490452,
0.0070673642,
-0.0423845202,
-0.0316649936
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.02472v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.02472v2 | Deductive Additivity for Planning of Natural Language Proofs | 2023-07-05T17:45:48 | 2023-07-06T02:16:33 | Zayne Sprague, Kaj Bostrom, Swarat Chaudhuri, Greg Durrett | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Current natural language systems designed for multi-step claim validation
typically operate in two phases: retrieve a set of relevant premise statements
using heuristics (planning), then generate novel conclusions from those
statements using a large language model (deduction). The planning step often
requires expensive Transformer operations and does not scale to arbitrary
numbers of premise statements. In this paper, we investigate whether an
efficient planning heuristic is possible via embedding spaces compatible with
deductive reasoning. Specifically, we evaluate whether embedding spaces exhibit
a property we call deductive additivity: the sum of premise statement
embeddings should be close to embeddings of conclusions based on those
premises. We explore multiple sources of off-the-shelf dense embeddings in
addition to fine-tuned embeddings from GPT3 and sparse embeddings from BM25. We
study embedding models both intrinsically, evaluating whether the property of
deductive additivity holds, and extrinsically, using them to assist planning in
natural language proof generation. Lastly, we create a dataset, Single-Step
Reasoning Contrast (SSRC), to further probe performance on various reasoning
types. Our findings suggest that while standard embedding methods frequently
embed conclusions near the sums of their premises, they fall short of being
effective heuristics and lack the ability to model certain categories of
reasoning. | [
0.0131686088,
0.0567781664,
0.0107525252,
0.006324844,
-0.0392888598,
0.0026211692,
-0.0285824928,
-0.0349378623,
0.0259136353,
0.000739946,
0.0474306233,
-0.002804168,
0.0478832908,
0.0113693755,
0.0350649245,
-0.0881110057,
0.0160208661,
0.0134545946,
0.0265375022,
-0.0210527461,
0.0142592462,
0.0025454916,
-0.030348869,
0.0237723961,
-0.0238057468,
0.0125896204,
-0.0329807773,
-0.0114792837,
0.0216618963,
-0.0647040904,
-0.0306015722,
0.0560997277,
0.0321490578,
0.0680220947,
0.0000020316,
-0.0548075996,
-0.0010877859,
0.0179070905,
-0.0489638709,
0.0112440651,
-0.0377356969,
-0.0427719578,
0.0137535259,
0.0208029132,
-0.0355730057,
-0.0374929719,
0.0598663092,
0.0872180238,
0.0660106018,
0.083567597,
-0.0168842599,
-0.0772086978,
0.0118339546,
-0.0118879955,
-0.0365041122,
-0.0184704494,
-0.0073545021,
0.0426822156,
0.0294992775,
0.0181999989,
0.0186379235,
0.0033083337,
0.0416156761,
-0.0018771263,
-0.048392795,
0.0499527007,
-0.0611945875,
-0.00633182,
0.0008157729,
0.0451244004,
-0.0187263768,
-0.0384351462,
-0.0064738491,
0.0015498153,
-0.000943951,
0.0054247645,
-0.0389686115,
0.0782106146,
-0.01235596,
0.0113385795,
0.0384477526,
0.007981061,
0.0478875488,
-0.0076894672,
-0.0247788876,
0.0569738261,
-0.0017715774,
-0.050339289,
0.006014742,
0.0315875635,
-0.051049158,
-0.0790711418,
-0.0053696805,
0.0209536366,
-0.0074528456,
0.0201264434,
-0.0395337828,
0.0249722395,
0.0361520126,
0.0039784033,
0.0597601421,
0.0539654233,
0.0020049633,
0.0360805169,
-0.0792201161,
0.0129004698,
-0.0372786969,
-0.0109370695,
0.0022376187,
0.0128196254,
-0.0343864523,
-0.0023007002,
-0.0449295864,
0.0634464696,
-0.0118078096,
-0.0104820803,
-0.0327842198,
0.0161774289,
-0.0334109515,
0.0362429135,
-0.0091544855,
0.0122842435,
0.0028414694,
-0.024012845,
-0.0331222638,
-0.0187905841,
-0.0672400966,
0.0425943732,
0.0298983362,
-0.0195977576,
-0.025636049,
0.0250389427,
-0.0028033743,
0.0288720373,
-0.0116110286,
0.0348330326,
-0.0078914361,
0.0277164076,
-0.0770924762,
-0.0751117021,
-0.012099674,
-0.0619946681,
0.0186799522,
-0.1052562967,
0.0023872755,
-0.0052718124,
-0.0286704339,
-0.0132084433,
-0.0167685971,
0.0375143848,
-0.0165956039,
0.0517296344,
0.0093279425,
-0.019408511,
0.0143124778,
0.0238880757,
-0.0396839269,
0.0535863973,
0.0298819225,
0.0135852406,
0.0191774946,
0.025519276,
0.0034598918,
0.00681167,
0.0298031233,
0.0114881359,
-0.0075397664,
0.0010073415,
0.0016758038,
0.0194729976,
-0.0051319865,
0.0253374409,
-0.0524859987,
-0.0255947132,
0.0422896966,
0.0657455996,
0.030780144,
0.0072883344,
0.0496543907,
-0.0205540974,
-0.0257750861,
0.0425779931,
-0.0505475663,
0.0220426228,
-0.0674802884,
0.0050899,
0.0645107999,
0.0203872435,
-0.0159577448,
-0.0647619888,
-0.0117801903,
0.033625409,
0.0219326932,
-0.0215182416,
-0.0191934556,
0.0224230476,
-0.0271482207,
0.031427186,
-0.0006208666,
-0.1058218926,
-0.0412723087,
-0.0151123153,
0.0562839508,
-0.0177669711,
0.0416340791,
-0.0122974254,
-0.0033240505,
-0.0107386149,
0.0103547005,
0.0768644363,
0.0659555495,
-0.011491322,
0.0026403742,
-0.0404158719,
-0.0525307879,
-0.054821644,
0.0485693105,
0.000739856,
0.0547107868,
-0.0092867082,
0.0312493984,
-0.0241247341,
0.0448875651,
0.0208386723,
-0.0211357512,
-0.008441925,
0.0088319257,
0.0311319008,
0.035370551,
0.0202537216,
-0.0008542699,
0.0133534698,
0.020013513,
-0.0002920712,
-0.0580517501,
0.0281987935,
-0.0050540748,
-0.0858985782,
0.0324172936,
-0.0680567399,
-0.0196540542,
-0.0028379471,
-0.066167675,
-0.0398479849,
0.0192775168,
-0.0557772256,
-0.0239290148,
-0.0327643864,
-0.0175012834,
0.0333826505,
-0.0092974138,
0.0103337709,
0.0959330425,
-0.0038425629,
-0.0101339919,
0.0053759534,
-0.0074861636,
0.0408454947,
-0.0453961939,
-0.0064641926,
0.0127219018,
0.0164186284,
0.0172976013,
0.0534090623,
-0.0074129263,
-0.0304679256,
-0.0119121037,
-0.1062866002,
0.0173853878,
-0.0228660628,
0.0197976436,
0.0023158761,
-0.0223806705,
0.0186700914,
0.0005793428,
-0.0444297194,
-0.0668568686,
0.0207062494,
0.0284189135,
0.0466290042,
-0.0106516294,
-0.0327098966,
0.0144741395,
-0.0103761647,
-0.0105502121,
0.0173296425,
-0.0009103356,
0.024039723,
-0.0195881687,
0.0255179442,
-0.027086677,
0.0099211736,
0.0048504402,
0.0000571311,
0.0383682251,
0.0078121154,
-0.008834132,
0.042317085,
-0.0138408858,
0.0117828418,
0.0477051884,
0.0028806988,
-0.0055611399,
0.025207568,
-0.0484789126,
0.0564562716,
0.0144490637,
-0.0364495851,
-0.0151624745,
0.0326048806,
-0.0252407528,
-0.025604995,
-0.072941035,
0.0260734167,
0.0222111009,
0.0125022177,
0.0243687294,
-0.0050301221,
-0.0016429772,
0.0566682965,
-0.0100057069,
-0.0540612899,
0.0862572938,
-0.0209526792,
0.0068331822,
-0.0581979081,
-0.0251377746,
-0.0368754081,
0.0440308079,
-0.0148252146,
0.0060410202,
0.0154691618,
0.0179905854,
-0.0235807821,
-0.0525849573,
0.0535588376,
0.0028092894,
0.074983716,
-0.0328565575,
-0.0014948124,
-0.0104565304,
-0.0415041707,
-0.0476927049,
-0.0279147513,
-0.0501519777,
0.033559218,
-0.0631982163,
-0.0279686898,
-0.0594416931,
-0.0171135087,
0.0212398861,
0.063836813,
0.0218371637,
-0.0194631107,
-0.0123712253,
0.0004789226,
-0.0134078078,
0.0458293632,
0.0112198358,
-0.0023052124,
0.008794846,
0.0562271401,
0.0118773524,
0.0232723914,
-0.039780058,
0.0249959715,
-0.0258151181,
-0.0124068148,
-0.0225052852,
0.0092099039,
0.0094526792,
-0.0604493059,
0.0388839133,
0.0835590437,
0.0073032272,
0.0336957462,
0.0218605809,
-0.0137204025,
0.0731662735,
0.0211362336,
0.0047698612,
-0.0998169631,
-0.0393697694,
0.014161177,
-0.0142658902,
-0.0233155787,
-0.0279321745,
-0.0172672961,
-0.1448912919,
0.0494063348,
0.0334627554,
0.0279875044,
-0.015415513,
-0.05076278,
0.0131644523,
0.0136970412,
-0.0353136919,
-0.0245330241,
0.0464617461,
-0.0020604294,
0.0027464938,
-0.0382869132,
-0.02569676,
-0.0067702653,
-0.014404064,
-0.0125109432,
0.0080379909,
0.0266852062,
-0.0268217269,
-0.0580622256,
-0.0018708337,
0.0248513613,
-0.0144881699,
0.0080811083,
0.0228726882,
0.0157695804,
0.0414974764,
-0.0066035604,
0.0424181372,
0.0047101532,
-0.0534332655,
0.03067833,
0.1097560003,
-0.0128195193,
-0.0379684865,
-0.0387238972,
0.0515023321,
-0.010661942,
0.0665094703,
-0.0064813113,
0.0298726019,
-0.0257199649,
-0.0416903459,
-0.0071701566,
-0.0335411169,
-0.0035185977,
0.0070986603,
0.0162613746,
-0.0034770558,
-0.0633864552,
-0.0182526931,
0.0194946881,
0.065550223,
-0.0226924382,
-0.0138513157,
-0.0067650564,
0.0029072359,
-0.024893526,
0.0620663315,
-0.0303988848,
0.0277643371,
0.0243164096,
0.0134738376,
-0.0213474557,
-0.0106473379,
-0.0121298386,
0.0099312235,
-0.007731223,
-0.0972567201,
-0.0553136542,
0.0266063344,
0.0235857386,
0.0507992171,
0.0150124272,
-0.0272105448,
0.0776549056,
0.0038458309,
0.0229848064,
0.0262650326,
0.0822643638,
-0.0164588485,
0.0070815496,
0.0218825266,
0.0053265002,
0.0210920498,
-0.0028760864,
0.0647213086,
-0.0245836265,
-0.0230044369,
0.0333947726,
0.0005027898,
0.0229505934,
-0.003428631,
0.0069592837,
-0.0201801173,
0.0240718201,
-0.0484125763,
-0.0183180105,
-0.0369075537,
0.0342399739,
0.0031070239,
-0.0002474129,
0.0048276694,
-0.0076335613,
-0.0181061924,
-0.0012772349,
0.0193106513,
0.0037112078,
0.0352380313,
-0.0243007895,
0.0072598346,
-0.0148059838,
-0.0352596454,
-0.0168969575,
-0.0533878095,
0.0199083425,
-0.0131066451,
0.0213680472,
0.0618597604,
0.0180727839,
-0.0353339203,
-0.0142445974,
-0.0503494814,
-0.023166649,
0.0123650106,
-0.0136874439,
0.0522177815,
-0.0106367478,
0.018241154,
-0.0345899314,
-0.0173608437,
0.0080168843,
0.0218378361,
-0.0136519177,
-0.0665071979,
0.0327117741,
0.031240629,
-0.0335242637,
-0.0066729398,
0.0481820591,
-0.0336094052,
0.0583207272,
-0.0138895409,
-0.0040413919,
-0.0422326215,
-0.0774151534,
-0.007411466,
0.0662986636,
-0.0020238766,
0.0027312543,
-0.0640178323,
-0.0933841243,
-0.0008789988,
0.0211856831,
-0.005686406,
0.0121785197,
0.0160952657,
0.0339982808,
0.010363834,
-0.0532853827,
0.0248921532,
-0.0088444445,
-0.0398914255,
-0.0179808121,
0.0009059571,
-6.047368891e-33,
0.0053032553,
-0.0350425988,
0.0361950733,
-0.0251164306,
-0.0128515037,
-0.0205730684,
-0.0479860939,
0.0197389945,
-0.0026863171,
0.0940328389,
-0.0171680897,
0.0285477564,
0.0081484197,
0.0426931717,
-0.0392825752,
0.0157435611,
0.0411001816,
0.0171977393,
-0.0792125463,
0.0016891178,
0.0206782818,
-0.0446172245,
0.013018935,
-0.0594268776,
-0.0021413602,
0.0057974276,
-0.015386234,
0.0445802696,
-0.0589569695,
0.0467624553,
0.0059583103,
0.0168773904,
0.0102385161,
-0.0148226256,
-0.0196536761,
0.0572574884,
-0.0343644284,
-0.0390446745,
0.0530253202,
-0.0639101416,
-0.0620113462,
-0.0243589934,
0.0000516245,
-0.0076970598,
0.0008252149,
-0.0557448156,
-0.0074874694,
-0.0244224463,
0.0018965697,
0.0129131023,
-0.0480121858,
0.0524693206,
-0.0085385107,
-0.0109425969,
0.0327742957,
0.017708227,
0.0127842799,
-0.0570543483,
-0.0267795175,
0.0161528401,
-0.018464867,
0.0011829851,
0.0296592005,
-0.0492029972,
-0.0358689465,
0.0607873388,
-0.0168252941,
0.0212724861,
-0.0292741992,
-0.0079087261,
-0.0291128438,
0.0626120046,
0.0546145774,
0.0007797198,
0.053982053,
0.0383425355,
-0.0652753115,
0.0055159386,
0.0025285813,
0.018300049,
0.0648697764,
-0.0060136765,
-0.0235063173,
-0.0208347775,
-0.0730296448,
0.0173067823,
-0.0231246073,
-0.0019048892,
-0.0003755495,
0.0596886463,
-0.0047750031,
-0.0088920584,
-0.0117461206,
-0.047536727,
0.0218488313,
0.0599507838,
-0.0284730345,
-0.0144395865,
0.007849236,
0.0326427519,
-0.0148246065,
0.0178247262,
0.0090755876,
0.0346332267,
0.0027592562,
-0.0001533121,
0.0494350232,
-0.0033176483,
-0.0451130979,
0.0112924185,
-0.0185755361,
-0.0016297078,
-0.0355008692,
0.0129781216,
0.0503483899,
0.0227962732,
0.0015444616,
-0.0291330032,
-0.0212115552,
-0.005256936,
-0.0327065587,
0.0280561727,
0.0175393205,
0.0306003597,
0.0068539074,
-0.0096954526,
-0.0095703751,
-0.0155586936,
0.0525080301,
-0.058561448,
-0.0128969317,
0.0288488064,
2.735e-7,
-0.0076867547,
0.0278213695,
0.0321785733,
0.03032065,
0.0039465227,
0.0564103648,
-0.0019172822,
-0.0008014844,
0.0020209686,
-0.0760059878,
-0.0110019529,
0.04486591,
0.0515369438,
0.0454632528,
-0.047812745,
-0.0308756027,
-0.0406313278,
-0.0411165804,
-0.0152949626,
-0.0196879823,
0.0696660057,
0.0589881986,
0.0343723521,
-0.0016286412,
-0.0197562687,
-0.0293606315,
0.0551094003,
0.032270059,
0.0247551277,
-0.0334535465,
0.076058425,
-0.0011232685,
0.0184683744,
0.0400660038,
-0.0119041745,
0.0590626858,
-0.0288390741,
0.0775182322,
0.0111828502,
0.0105198584,
-0.0481616333,
-0.0359509997,
0.0027534808,
-0.027659243,
0.0587333404,
-0.07790488,
-0.0502917357,
-0.019370446,
-0.0055116997,
-0.0313378312,
0.0179713257,
0.0153954681,
-0.0194144733,
0.0073496597,
0.0259809121,
0.0019120536,
0.0196828395,
-0.1161496043,
-0.0358386226,
0.0670572296,
-0.0498558655,
-0.0136760883,
0.0211167317,
-0.0056378893,
0.0675888211,
-0.048394803,
-0.0161716975,
2.942654038e-34,
0.0509429313,
-0.0184671246,
0.0366776511,
-0.011976622,
0.0655416772,
-0.0149982702,
0.0359765179,
0.0051759044,
0.0541082844,
-0.0974247679,
-0.0317526124
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.02469v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.02469v2 | What Matters in Training a GPT4-Style Language Model with Multimodal Inputs? | 2023-07-05T17:44:28 | 2023-07-30T13:20:39 | Yan Zeng, Hanbo Zhang, Jiani Zheng, Jiangnan Xia, Guoqiang Wei, Yang Wei, Yuchen Zhang, Tao Kong | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Recent advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) such as GPT4 have
displayed exceptional multi-modal capabilities in following open-ended
instructions given images. However, the performance of these models heavily
relies on design choices such as network structures, training data, and
training strategies, and these choices have not been extensively discussed in
the literature, making it difficult to quantify progress in this field. To
address this issue, this paper presents a systematic and comprehensive study,
quantitatively and qualitatively, on training such models. We implement over 20
variants with controlled settings. Concretely, for network structures, we
compare different LLM backbones and model designs. For training data, we
investigate the impact of data and sampling strategies. For instructions, we
explore the influence of diversified prompts on the instruction-following
ability of the trained models. For benchmarks, we contribute the first, to our
best knowledge, comprehensive evaluation set including both image and video
tasks through crowd-sourcing. Based on our findings, we present Lynx, which
performs the most accurate multi-modal understanding while keeping the best
multi-modal generation ability compared to existing open-sourced GPT4-style
models. | [
0.0192924067,
0.082562916,
0.0012370456,
0.0453512184,
-0.0321392193,
-0.0085442159,
0.003978685,
-0.0209836792,
-0.0176490787,
-0.0553142391,
-0.0609229431,
-0.0629950389,
-0.0012939422,
0.0194830392,
0.0637933984,
-0.074030444,
0.0374133252,
-0.0770230293,
-0.0424807146,
-0.0031249942,
0.0277648102,
0.0308463834,
-0.0228129365,
0.0586066246,
-0.0264492016,
0.0011474543,
-0.0523159355,
0.0334286131,
-0.0051893713,
-0.027365448,
-0.004580677,
0.0544838272,
0.0579127558,
0.0502426401,
0.0000019242,
-0.0023658783,
0.0142642809,
-0.0216400474,
0.0138230408,
0.0047046449,
0.053734865,
-0.0491997637,
-0.0140356785,
0.0066785864,
-0.0147969481,
-0.0268771499,
0.0724357441,
0.0367463566,
0.0938841999,
0.0540478155,
-0.0054475856,
-0.0515064299,
0.0241741613,
-0.0329151899,
0.0077987309,
-0.0325845368,
0.0036835133,
-0.0085452087,
0.0439005941,
0.0302369371,
-0.0452399366,
0.0415995046,
0.033366546,
0.0040680324,
-0.0474067368,
0.0474870056,
-0.0045999093,
-0.0484660231,
-0.047855515,
0.1121003255,
-0.0058420827,
0.0188968945,
-0.0145061612,
0.0003814358,
-0.0185299143,
0.0095465789,
-0.0457050912,
0.048062142,
0.0060902941,
0.0289933272,
-0.0492381826,
-0.0299751386,
0.0193902999,
0.0028107592,
0.0191271212,
0.0163529869,
0.0360205323,
-0.0033687628,
-0.0059289178,
-0.0034126143,
-0.0531337596,
-0.0347636864,
-0.0026051842,
0.0286238771,
0.0062738163,
0.0419254825,
-0.051880978,
0.0069487309,
0.0119544305,
-0.0017345464,
0.0577662438,
0.0309626739,
-0.0610011294,
0.0326700322,
-0.0106097851,
0.0412814878,
-0.0487160496,
0.038065102,
-0.0279584397,
0.0062550441,
-0.0512818582,
-0.017327616,
-0.0401349962,
-0.0036923571,
-0.0564349554,
-0.0416946299,
-0.0116213216,
0.0343072005,
0.0175951812,
-0.0173882172,
0.0274393391,
0.0047385613,
-0.0341215581,
-0.0289843846,
0.000736589,
0.0415737927,
-0.0046400493,
0.0326479524,
0.0070592165,
-0.072222501,
-0.0018638353,
0.0211923663,
0.0009924971,
-0.0141850943,
-0.0028404666,
0.0970620587,
-0.0438478589,
-0.0346917734,
-0.0448178947,
-0.0185300093,
-0.0220827181,
-0.0640619695,
0.0169199519,
-0.0366735719,
0.0356844068,
-0.0165895354,
-0.0027760155,
0.0053730519,
0.0091375988,
0.0129069854,
-0.0169489589,
0.0702681616,
0.0096066194,
0.0017916868,
0.0218405873,
0.0064156577,
0.0000677571,
0.0621905066,
0.0319682844,
0.0225029681,
0.0143702384,
0.0090229064,
0.0032570164,
0.0662213117,
-0.0110269934,
0.0314529911,
-0.0096460488,
-0.017187614,
0.0205025151,
0.0427566916,
0.0748796165,
0.081050925,
-0.0381612964,
-0.0138801578,
0.108167544,
0.0162023492,
-0.0055719223,
-0.0213482361,
0.0645318255,
0.0254330263,
-0.0054669417,
0.0097673154,
-0.0844258219,
0.0281480979,
0.0066334638,
0.0260149445,
0.0107101453,
0.0328171216,
-0.0469654202,
0.0039258953,
0.0067733848,
-0.0283527095,
0.0051816171,
-0.0168936308,
0.0542530864,
-0.0142797539,
-0.0782289803,
0.0175470244,
0.0157999415,
-0.0432099812,
0.0127231991,
-0.0330774486,
0.0228700805,
0.0434275232,
0.0026239564,
0.024200948,
-0.0437331088,
-0.0019715573,
0.0320975184,
0.0444442146,
0.0011562345,
-0.0017194168,
0.0457884185,
-0.089628756,
-0.031917423,
0.0010034324,
0.0093696266,
0.0612793565,
-0.033528924,
-0.0142715052,
0.0095536876,
-0.0071892189,
0.0113755511,
0.0519630797,
0.0199937671,
-0.0065459339,
-0.0420949049,
0.0084672924,
0.0203203782,
-0.0015439659,
-0.0101295812,
-0.0067964094,
0.0276700538,
-0.0119854929,
0.0457623936,
0.0278374441,
-0.0812598392,
-0.0338234901,
0.0282318462,
-0.037181247,
-0.0126281092,
0.0577682257,
-0.0553937033,
-0.0505392887,
0.0249439478,
-0.0337887593,
0.0055156872,
-0.0729862303,
-0.0027145508,
0.0616233274,
-0.0022920135,
-0.0153129231,
0.0378619358,
-0.0255073998,
-0.0091329133,
0.0478224084,
0.0262554772,
0.0104624014,
-0.0598626584,
-0.0244324915,
0.0106590791,
0.0199058075,
0.0176412184,
-0.0047642207,
0.0316728465,
-0.0368879884,
-0.023391908,
-0.0978335664,
-0.0038840983,
-0.0360505655,
0.0022680669,
0.0284622926,
-0.001671139,
-0.0032214299,
-0.0430969931,
-0.0327171125,
0.0076747132,
0.0220163818,
-0.0018528613,
0.0115492381,
0.0402169451,
-0.029527979,
-0.0317891166,
-0.0024289803,
0.0052177678,
0.0048278389,
-0.0048021204,
-0.0041696089,
-0.0363110714,
-0.0090152798,
-0.0160175562,
0.0693879947,
-0.0401853435,
-0.0496012233,
0.0221271198,
-0.0249069147,
0.050242316,
0.0241226219,
0.0192759167,
-0.006615581,
0.0250241533,
-0.0111441743,
-0.0231285952,
0.0107736131,
-0.0162997916,
-0.0388216153,
-0.0265413132,
-0.0123719117,
-0.0135809183,
0.0604761653,
0.0154876923,
0.0371363088,
-0.0828906596,
-0.0154176131,
0.004790029,
-0.0233066231,
-0.0551510938,
0.0000727647,
-0.0483919419,
0.0111306589,
-0.0461180508,
-0.0625416115,
0.0455833972,
-0.0694808885,
-0.0442012288,
-0.0040256609,
0.013888875,
-0.005342612,
0.0678899139,
0.0474097468,
0.0346356668,
0.0219178069,
-0.0166999977,
-0.0694604218,
0.0110190762,
0.0153131634,
0.0015980385,
0.0525373109,
-0.0883675516,
0.0195529535,
-0.0317084752,
-0.0161277,
-0.0082753282,
-0.042041067,
-0.0074642054,
0.0081750937,
0.0018789828,
-0.0124123618,
0.0197192989,
0.0393176712,
0.0178206619,
0.045057334,
-0.0200708881,
0.0126628345,
-0.0624561906,
0.0440742001,
0.0656135753,
0.0044229808,
-0.054309696,
-0.0756727159,
-0.0084999828,
0.0342727713,
0.0340125114,
-0.0090178363,
-0.0708427876,
0.0434054323,
0.022523012,
0.0346839875,
-0.026684124,
0.0292043537,
0.0916294232,
-0.0537503511,
0.0143602258,
0.0825208053,
-0.0002316729,
-0.0546724088,
-0.0192194283,
0.0347615965,
0.0386092663,
0.0069316775,
-0.0059655644,
-0.0750271752,
-0.0562225208,
-0.0049189059,
0.0269032624,
0.0272277109,
0.0027178598,
-0.0252618361,
-0.1071139574,
0.0524846204,
0.0061069322,
-0.0486635193,
-0.0179828871,
-0.005931559,
0.0093893204,
-0.0041850409,
0.017743662,
0.0146938572,
-0.0132789323,
-0.0041706515,
0.0315800272,
0.0128264371,
-0.0660519004,
0.0229026545,
-0.0427435972,
0.0592842959,
0.058031112,
-0.0100336866,
-0.0147265708,
-0.0602966137,
0.0638828725,
0.0047720606,
0.0095456364,
0.0102445418,
0.0315585099,
-0.0321664885,
-0.0182129219,
0.0023307174,
0.0470353924,
-0.0247636754,
0.0062863301,
-0.0072711543,
0.0576126464,
-0.0228448324,
0.0116952891,
-0.0137300184,
-0.0002399721,
0.0220483672,
0.0535640009,
0.0140953502,
-0.0385557227,
-0.0289640222,
-0.0132778808,
0.013541433,
-0.0507398658,
-0.0165557377,
0.0077866213,
-0.0199680645,
-0.0010984249,
-0.0507423393,
-0.0359836593,
0.0467167161,
0.0393103026,
0.0049262163,
-0.0215614457,
0.0053369459,
0.0095273061,
-0.0089833643,
0.0623713173,
-0.00850219,
0.0192120485,
-0.0943722725,
-0.0320276022,
0.0349371731,
-0.0421742462,
-0.0083594229,
0.0556497201,
-0.0865715146,
-0.0646532625,
-0.0265893936,
0.0671607554,
0.0171937086,
0.0640940219,
0.0002386473,
-0.0338254571,
-0.0179884005,
0.0078297826,
-0.016832808,
0.0072627957,
0.0260435678,
0.0063826242,
-0.0256898534,
0.0205971487,
-0.0186803285,
0.0351263955,
-0.0229094643,
0.0222012326,
-0.0253576264,
-0.0245711971,
0.0373960882,
-0.012924375,
0.0341473371,
-0.0362975933,
0.0128911035,
-0.0576939099,
-0.0030152281,
-0.0093427161,
0.006645618,
-0.0834347159,
0.0183451697,
0.0267198216,
-0.0140255326,
0.0055419328,
-0.0450185873,
0.0033611793,
0.0341292918,
-0.0375450999,
0.0177623816,
0.0344407931,
0.0095718578,
0.0102470126,
0.0158448908,
-0.0079566268,
0.0144667365,
-0.0209196862,
0.0191079564,
-0.0289861374,
0.0985422879,
0.0071225525,
-0.0298205167,
0.0039888676,
0.055401206,
-0.0334897861,
-0.027254371,
-0.0441216975,
0.0326084197,
0.0473459065,
0.0227311868,
0.0265955944,
-0.0319278613,
-0.005843638,
-0.0290096048,
0.0688650683,
0.0164820626,
-0.0245073847,
0.0737991631,
0.0360686518,
0.0071068043,
0.0077289878,
0.0707883909,
0.021849608,
0.0478534997,
-0.0117646595,
0.0389745757,
-0.0367374755,
-0.0155523829,
0.0275350045,
0.0215298403,
-0.031247953,
0.0254707485,
-0.0084281052,
-0.0546849892,
-0.0537749119,
0.0350300074,
-0.0112105692,
-0.0226951987,
0.0788773075,
0.0399212986,
-0.0092864754,
-0.0101198424,
-0.020195011,
-0.0398892127,
-0.0014217352,
0.0080721658,
-0.0205674153,
-6.049321681e-33,
-0.0442208648,
0.0009294261,
0.0518095158,
-0.0404667631,
-0.034319669,
-0.0038799292,
-0.0307256971,
0.0053936611,
-0.0079324106,
-0.0151946098,
0.0353484862,
-0.0139377257,
0.0097427014,
0.0435831584,
0.0070196684,
0.0187151507,
0.044968009,
-0.0415491126,
-0.0044727544,
0.0300646182,
0.0341948681,
0.0158624668,
0.0406413488,
-0.0159427188,
0.0038619572,
-0.0166949574,
-0.0412510969,
0.0213926043,
-0.0004884652,
0.0674799308,
-0.038881205,
0.0067914189,
0.0067288843,
-0.0277908202,
-0.0359193236,
0.0291791391,
-0.0285861082,
0.0172714256,
0.021956617,
0.0271433815,
-0.1067332849,
0.0003392497,
0.0231065713,
-0.0530147702,
0.0048412015,
0.000408057,
0.028953854,
-0.0019504776,
-0.0127365179,
0.0504859388,
-0.038967602,
0.0145228608,
-0.0074945153,
-0.0555185899,
0.0141862901,
0.0600963533,
0.0032552613,
-0.0025411991,
-0.0194265284,
0.0343367085,
0.0160589051,
0.0335180089,
0.072637558,
0.0505857803,
0.0113172233,
0.0457388312,
0.0238225367,
-0.0610669032,
-0.0150966961,
-0.002269459,
0.0277075544,
0.0704404861,
0.0173882805,
0.0456983745,
-0.018841736,
0.0184692964,
-0.0245304238,
0.0033298805,
0.0183471013,
0.0407352075,
0.0072237528,
0.0151091544,
-0.0013514512,
0.0001426105,
-0.0296697915,
-0.0531889461,
-0.0156994984,
-0.0263800323,
0.0514991395,
0.0368872918,
0.0067184968,
-0.0035054353,
0.099086605,
-0.0133119673,
-0.0011459896,
-0.0052167596,
-0.037081629,
0.0627568066,
0.0059911232,
0.0429463126,
-0.0478991605,
-0.0325163603,
0.0425076261,
0.0028301037,
-0.0044462006,
0.005436304,
0.0061050332,
0.051822193,
-0.0333953276,
0.0066939206,
-0.0509099104,
0.0209027007,
-0.0313186236,
0.0156628713,
0.0577562228,
-0.0201037396,
-0.050539799,
0.0564841218,
-0.0256685037,
-0.0068116309,
-0.0209241156,
-0.044400394,
-0.0220493861,
0.0282512996,
-0.0301588085,
0.0253439974,
-0.0339243375,
-0.038027145,
0.0279864408,
-0.037195988,
-0.0196853392,
0.0516682975,
2.588e-7,
0.0286949575,
-0.0075386628,
0.0234630667,
0.0241647344,
0.0255016685,
0.0261759814,
-0.0546345189,
0.0251719635,
-0.0093054818,
-0.0360754989,
-0.0060419459,
0.035379421,
0.0347974598,
-0.0032475169,
-0.0506649055,
0.0187446792,
-0.0406536758,
0.0127997603,
-0.0472408347,
0.0123016089,
0.0533971973,
0.0925147384,
-0.0532558113,
-0.01485404,
0.0153664397,
-0.0198933203,
0.0857341215,
-0.0195674617,
-0.0322543606,
-0.0276269503,
-0.0057525304,
0.0197587684,
-0.0365479626,
-0.0033593897,
0.0047811382,
-0.0250909068,
0.0119210724,
0.0699826926,
-0.0114609916,
-0.0446881279,
0.0235011484,
0.0138062024,
-0.0452739671,
-0.0560026132,
0.0565507859,
-0.0251097139,
-0.0144654755,
-0.021996215,
-0.0170782208,
-0.021306321,
-0.0218021814,
-0.0347511433,
-0.0419153571,
0.0132781584,
0.0261222012,
-0.0518795475,
-0.0219566505,
-0.0758623108,
0.0101662837,
-0.0225667413,
-0.0613215975,
-0.0340110697,
-0.0551651046,
-0.0211524107,
0.0514681488,
-0.0502370596,
-0.0548281409,
2.000231978e-34,
0.0179706793,
-0.0316422433,
0.0389217846,
0.0069916965,
-0.009394926,
0.0075361631,
-0.0276018884,
0.0072812554,
-0.0005533132,
-0.0757515132,
-0.0465759598
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2308.01404v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.01404v2 | Hoodwinked: Deception and Cooperation in a Text-Based Game for Language Models | 2023-07-05T17:22:09 | 2023-08-04T00:57:06 | Aidan O'Gara | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG | Are current language models capable of deception and lie detection? We study
this question by introducing a text-based game called $\textit{Hoodwinked}$,
inspired by Mafia and Among Us. Players are locked in a house and must find a
key to escape, but one player is tasked with killing the others. Each time a
murder is committed, the surviving players have a natural language discussion
then vote to banish one player from the game. We conduct experiments with
agents controlled by GPT-3, GPT-3.5, and GPT-4 and find evidence of deception
and lie detection capabilities. The killer often denies their crime and accuses
others, leading to measurable effects on voting outcomes. More advanced models
are more effective killers, outperforming smaller models in 18 of 24 pairwise
comparisons. Secondary metrics provide evidence that this improvement is not
mediated by different actions, but rather by stronger persuasive skills during
discussions. To evaluate the ability of AI agents to deceive humans, we make
this game publicly available at h https://hoodwinked.ai/ . | [
0.0569635034,
0.0719197094,
-0.0540344492,
0.0534312092,
-0.0982446223,
-0.009682171,
0.0447255634,
0.0101986146,
0.0495820194,
-0.0078222947,
-0.040885143,
0.0079524824,
0.0458380505,
0.0350703225,
0.0338460803,
0.0004466093,
0.0175749213,
-0.0247092135,
0.1012443677,
-0.0182089303,
0.0286003053,
0.0089825708,
0.0000855698,
0.0121064475,
-0.0032646293,
0.0030150444,
-0.0395487435,
-0.0389894359,
0.0169563927,
0.0152318617,
-0.0197671447,
0.0608330034,
0.0072403559,
0.0648854151,
0.000002147,
-0.0157792605,
-0.0044487771,
-0.0235608667,
-0.0326193683,
0.0256173387,
0.0584342182,
0.0082475394,
-0.0066153975,
0.0071299626,
-0.0618889183,
0.0262836628,
0.0252678785,
0.0192822535,
0.0439532027,
0.0746675059,
-0.0010762018,
-0.0018611423,
0.0367003419,
-0.0306742713,
-0.0123395622,
-0.0296833087,
0.0044685514,
-0.0176934861,
0.0190663673,
-0.0059186895,
0.0291424021,
-0.0074863671,
-0.0130118076,
-0.0298557989,
-0.0665881336,
0.0525650457,
-0.0110844448,
-0.0073276376,
0.0020354413,
0.0277151875,
-0.0408192612,
-0.0391647555,
0.0070043411,
0.0090428488,
0.0387381576,
0.0304130502,
-0.0010347203,
0.0557109155,
-0.0093850615,
-0.0078593967,
0.0132133076,
0.0268926993,
0.0133445142,
0.0110765835,
0.0525497682,
0.0507915206,
-0.009343937,
-0.0095588146,
-0.0046776957,
-0.0095617259,
-0.0361081436,
-0.0707910135,
-0.0192145277,
0.0040940372,
-0.0512058809,
0.0199733302,
-0.037634369,
-0.003063594,
0.052737087,
-0.0519157797,
0.0086793285,
-0.0090078283,
0.049027767,
0.0360579826,
0.0207153372,
0.0348246954,
0.0098141907,
0.039704375,
-0.014401827,
-0.005868969,
0.0159247573,
-0.0324142985,
-0.0320505723,
0.0256570112,
0.0201125536,
0.0176214818,
-0.0041604517,
-0.0064410912,
-0.0552494675,
0.0409837402,
-0.0458558835,
-0.0284254849,
-0.0240823627,
-0.0076658102,
-0.0084470613,
-0.0015375427,
-0.0449345522,
0.0253414661,
0.0050271591,
-0.0593728758,
-0.0311602671,
-0.0180396102,
-0.0200928394,
0.0022906861,
0.0384901427,
0.0483907647,
-0.0175260101,
-0.0140371872,
0.0160302091,
-0.0037752138,
-0.024491908,
-0.0775098354,
-0.0460479371,
-0.0609164909,
0.0249767471,
-0.0295313708,
-0.0129073402,
-0.0336657763,
0.017765671,
0.0183268711,
-0.0383793078,
0.0873164088,
-0.0038874154,
0.0085511617,
0.0271979757,
0.0244970452,
-0.0204177964,
0.0492398366,
0.0094635449,
0.0689194053,
0.0464063287,
0.0081980377,
0.0735332295,
0.0365090221,
0.0124227805,
0.031375587,
0.0451622643,
-0.0043406845,
0.0147581324,
0.0016630461,
-0.0332646146,
0.0213904455,
-0.0270941611,
-0.0450817533,
0.115057379,
0.0839028656,
-0.0405661799,
0.0012580097,
0.0109003074,
0.0227445047,
-0.0038950536,
-0.0061540864,
-0.0453447849,
0.0263093021,
-0.0528781861,
-0.0175404213,
-0.0411424935,
0.0108602932,
-0.009766357,
0.0023533455,
0.0177980773,
-0.0341399647,
0.0334054716,
0.0383860953,
0.0005912278,
-0.0079301558,
-0.0433679409,
-0.0428831913,
0.0460899137,
-0.04706911,
-0.0219884254,
-0.0783595741,
0.0307454336,
0.0335482322,
0.0577126518,
0.0159540437,
0.0015073507,
-0.0378723443,
0.0012215988,
0.0460544489,
0.0112871407,
0.0039493348,
-0.0097814435,
0.0049521406,
0.0141093982,
-0.0163659193,
0.0045881025,
0.0465029702,
-0.0446885079,
-0.0080992486,
-0.0196990278,
-0.0329109803,
0.0258887727,
0.014236914,
0.0219456423,
0.0022976762,
-0.0408604965,
0.0089053418,
0.0291267186,
-0.0174800437,
-0.035033606,
0.0036567978,
0.0443379246,
-0.0056160884,
-0.0287610479,
-0.0086826691,
-0.0115889795,
-0.0068114558,
0.0100304764,
-0.0472946391,
0.0291236788,
0.0452125445,
0.0112840487,
0.0269827396,
0.0563054606,
-0.0598027408,
0.0039007699,
-0.0022327479,
0.0065495996,
-0.063751474,
-0.0025360321,
-0.0094223758,
0.0550289601,
0.0062810346,
-0.0056007542,
-0.0447787009,
-0.032944575,
0.0290326271,
-0.0115263471,
0.004573415,
0.0364827141,
0.023149373,
0.0012663228,
0.0815612599,
0.0143527864,
-0.0220612772,
-0.0761313885,
-0.0758212209,
-0.0222737938,
-0.0156748537,
-0.0117372889,
0.0201773699,
-0.0073627448,
-0.0132939192,
0.0179006401,
-0.0559565574,
0.0016436739,
0.0302239209,
-0.0152813876,
-0.0123631246,
-0.0163591821,
-0.0488780737,
-0.0107451649,
0.0265088733,
-0.0167893209,
0.0327979513,
0.0090246685,
-0.0429585241,
-0.0034168416,
0.0000082841,
-0.0418214314,
0.0358828157,
-0.0372097567,
-0.0458949804,
0.0345442519,
0.0067037665,
-0.0171326213,
0.0779969543,
0.0299311113,
0.0706910715,
0.0403069519,
-0.0106105385,
-0.0429142341,
-0.0075061335,
-0.0107166097,
-0.0089403801,
-0.0606558733,
-0.0943630561,
0.0093139354,
0.0754219219,
0.0443400405,
0.0133810174,
-0.0236094259,
0.0384641141,
-0.0180044957,
-0.0229843613,
0.0145096621,
-0.0931297913,
0.0047028493,
-0.0047299215,
-0.0196354035,
-0.0418177284,
0.090777874,
-0.0307844318,
0.0074130725,
-0.0113842096,
0.0058760303,
0.0142591763,
0.0838789716,
0.0453595854,
0.0013464551,
0.0392241552,
-0.0009521287,
0.005786289,
-0.0724522397,
0.1032773182,
-0.0280501284,
-0.0097555602,
-0.0472610332,
0.0119999982,
0.0350301899,
-0.0223085452,
-0.0190096423,
-0.1078239083,
-0.0468181744,
-0.0201745443,
0.0366092063,
-0.0199046191,
-0.0473532416,
-0.0281522404,
0.0242228732,
-0.0055045411,
0.003193513,
0.0064953822,
-0.0260003265,
-0.0358293876,
0.0265798941,
-0.0313159861,
0.0146291265,
-0.0432894677,
0.0283397641,
0.0475837439,
-0.0350523554,
-0.0062911278,
0.0176884551,
-0.0047752596,
0.0339259766,
0.0114484821,
-0.0102302656,
0.0087484438,
-0.0242168643,
-0.0099259121,
0.0047934875,
0.0842770487,
0.035261523,
-0.0304724518,
0.003654337,
-0.0045762877,
0.050539434,
-0.0066351769,
-0.0080347247,
-0.091042228,
-0.0019462283,
0.0050135679,
-0.002693482,
-0.0608483069,
-0.0368025415,
-0.0201447364,
-0.092350632,
0.033880394,
0.0026894107,
-0.0200120956,
0.0016619916,
-0.0585318729,
-0.0172444172,
-0.0189265031,
0.0258409847,
-0.0219664201,
0.0393991843,
-0.0188722331,
-0.0273227654,
-0.0380276218,
0.0571596511,
0.0134155815,
-0.0188793801,
0.0989904478,
0.063632004,
0.0852184221,
-0.0478775427,
-0.0309764091,
0.0098342244,
0.0544644631,
-0.0306188092,
0.0021128326,
0.073098734,
-0.01480792,
0.0076013166,
-0.0351173319,
0.0102957021,
0.0492400713,
-0.0494683236,
0.0456609428,
0.0288627204,
0.0076662875,
-0.091866225,
0.0456170999,
-0.010086799,
0.0304429736,
0.0473902039,
0.0162127446,
-0.0002926382,
-0.0205623619,
-0.0439126603,
-0.0217460543,
-0.0047920295,
-0.0930141509,
-0.0338227972,
0.0435396433,
0.0016075443,
-0.0161859747,
-0.0459407717,
0.0025479991,
-0.0360268317,
0.0166563652,
0.0149552152,
0.0478067659,
-0.0090471208,
0.0009920794,
-0.0472477712,
-0.042000331,
0.0362923034,
0.0096823936,
-0.0053706854,
-0.0537907183,
-0.0339595899,
0.0141129978,
0.0143699134,
-0.0345749184,
-0.0042867842,
0.0266065765,
0.022701662,
0.0177521426,
0.0201041494,
-0.0397104584,
-0.0296643265,
0.0067152297,
-0.0557345003,
-0.053014528,
0.0265346169,
0.0343482494,
-0.0000323204,
0.0632491186,
0.015247182,
0.0072994572,
0.0184951164,
0.0661450326,
-0.0140566723,
-0.0604877546,
0.0238142181,
0.0479180142,
0.0316834189,
0.0118042305,
-0.0138323195,
0.0295017939,
-0.0051705423,
-0.017395338,
-0.0567674041,
-0.0220072418,
0.0034601905,
-0.0234644059,
0.03407019,
0.017291069,
0.0109922094,
-0.0018347611,
-0.0802316591,
-0.0124613876,
0.0001667197,
0.0017128284,
0.016772842,
0.0168453325,
0.0171867255,
-0.0077825524,
-0.0128490934,
0.0564961433,
-0.008274544,
0.0720357671,
-0.0055313162,
0.0134146893,
0.0194813404,
-0.0643557161,
0.0089279842,
0.0415697545,
-0.0612400062,
-0.0147773856,
0.0433494523,
0.0141895125,
0.0053329696,
0.0056390166,
0.0341017209,
-0.0228087865,
0.0332954712,
0.0052046734,
0.0069495686,
0.0035088239,
-0.0486343503,
-0.0441077277,
0.0104396064,
-0.0341009647,
0.0419292375,
0.041050408,
-0.0053344429,
0.0263940711,
0.0301189888,
-0.0115798227,
-0.00922985,
-0.017499296,
-0.0095969206,
0.0260309074,
-0.0272227339,
-0.0179947745,
-0.0707322434,
-0.0053047836,
-0.052061446,
0.0250849016,
0.0278842915,
0.0083242133,
-0.0234219097,
0.0344716422,
-0.0194170251,
0.0311538987,
-0.0734254941,
0.0695183352,
0.0278234202,
-0.0221378598,
-0.012877102,
-5.954244025e-33,
-0.029033605,
-0.0652089715,
-0.0117816301,
0.0341768861,
0.0034343489,
-0.0176439546,
-0.0147489337,
0.0391447209,
-0.0529778115,
0.0428306423,
-0.0022918908,
0.0237811171,
0.00609376,
-0.0323146768,
-0.0540547818,
-0.0092907725,
-0.0184017271,
-0.0087024989,
-0.0429050513,
0.0045983945,
-0.0193967614,
-0.0338068232,
0.0506023914,
-0.0819873214,
0.0652601272,
-0.0015060297,
-0.0644154027,
0.0096578682,
-0.05565878,
-0.0026422956,
0.0167395007,
0.0215087067,
0.0065602544,
-0.029236244,
-0.0019739314,
0.0511064194,
0.0408723243,
-0.0140472548,
0.0593376234,
-0.0212625023,
-0.00487945,
-0.0248958915,
-0.026638804,
-0.0278728846,
-0.0271740016,
0.005157249,
0.0308216549,
-0.0139988,
0.0070384913,
0.0350165181,
-0.0579743087,
-0.0033791284,
-0.0417793952,
-0.0228664409,
-0.0328256227,
0.0203380827,
0.0121490015,
-0.0044575226,
-0.0615896322,
0.0788743049,
0.006753129,
-0.0122645292,
0.0283128135,
-0.0308345649,
0.0142470337,
0.0633270368,
0.0289077964,
0.0337478928,
-0.0680562109,
-0.0007287034,
0.0394588038,
0.0683975145,
0.1193112284,
0.0580105819,
-0.0013559284,
-0.057343293,
-0.0541413575,
-0.025131952,
0.0634900853,
-0.0011398776,
0.0485478379,
-0.0094546769,
-0.0532839857,
-0.0384538434,
-0.0445358753,
-0.0311769675,
-0.0345878862,
-0.0134083247,
-0.0000244485,
-0.0051929113,
0.0165446792,
-0.0562505499,
0.0122461729,
-0.0396474116,
-0.0102654891,
0.011927289,
-0.0062946756,
0.0143083958,
-0.0131669473,
0.0070268349,
-0.0149208279,
0.0138272531,
-0.0103157647,
0.0204826761,
0.0450793281,
-0.0134469802,
0.0311807394,
0.0139942672,
-0.0137116136,
0.0003901348,
-0.0359128229,
0.0343580432,
0.0288036186,
-0.04071391,
0.0096452497,
-0.0167635288,
-0.0071995757,
-0.0521060526,
0.0125993164,
-0.0494586714,
-0.0396336764,
0.0614990778,
-0.0548816733,
-0.0078733023,
-0.0134588582,
0.0024715448,
-0.0132557908,
0.0320706926,
0.0310903918,
-0.0045339828,
-0.0319045931,
-0.09186773,
2.811e-7,
-0.0059531131,
0.0370777063,
-0.0331879929,
0.0311385356,
-0.0103165684,
0.0996030569,
0.0079233712,
0.0349269658,
0.0162861291,
-0.0505558178,
-0.0087588644,
0.014220695,
0.0657999441,
0.0519910678,
-0.0496930033,
0.0201708376,
-0.012562722,
-0.0442127548,
-0.0443241782,
0.0056071477,
0.0466462523,
0.0350687206,
0.0927706063,
-0.0037131635,
-0.0180900227,
-0.0391303524,
-0.0033035232,
-0.0685701594,
-0.0415849723,
0.0297082327,
0.0208762717,
-0.0533015057,
-0.0198046472,
0.0567953698,
0.0064282026,
-0.0130402911,
-0.0277341697,
0.0065658181,
-0.0361842476,
-0.0149034467,
-0.0072937962,
-0.0744935051,
-0.0090343161,
-0.05058752,
0.0524229333,
0.0017714585,
-0.0567840934,
-0.0267969277,
-0.020715192,
-0.0147431483,
0.0234638061,
-0.0093430951,
-0.0473009422,
0.0089798756,
0.0349911824,
0.0303284787,
0.0107897297,
-0.0140146501,
-0.0327548571,
0.014547226,
-0.0023180386,
-0.0581926703,
0.000034768,
0.0479077026,
0.0154494736,
-0.0104075614,
0.0479412787,
2.591613773e-34,
-0.002009439,
0.003686812,
0.0340661593,
0.0315929726,
0.0962083861,
0.0339138806,
-0.0040523829,
-0.0048545687,
0.048834756,
-0.0400330424,
0.0111962864
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.02443v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.02443v1 | An Exploratory Literature Study on Sharing and Energy Use of Language Models for Source Code | 2023-07-05T17:13:00 | 2023-07-05T17:13:00 | Max Hort, Anastasiia Grishina, Leon Moonen | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.NE | Large language models trained on source code can support a variety of
software development tasks, such as code recommendation and program repair.
Large amounts of data for training such models benefit the models' performance.
However, the size of the data and models results in long training times and
high energy consumption. While publishing source code allows for replicability,
users need to repeat the expensive training process if models are not shared.
The main goal of the study is to investigate if publications that trained
language models for software engineering (SE) tasks share source code and
trained artifacts. The second goal is to analyze the transparency on training
energy usage. We perform a snowballing-based literature search to find
publications on language models for source code, and analyze their reusability
from a sustainability standpoint.
From 494 unique publications, we identified 293 relevant publications that
use language models to address code-related tasks. Among them, 27% (79 out of
293) make artifacts available for reuse. This can be in the form of tools or
IDE plugins designed for specific tasks or task-agnostic models that can be
fine-tuned for a variety of downstream tasks. Moreover, we collect insights on
the hardware used for model training, as well as training time, which together
determine the energy consumption of the development process. We find that there
are deficiencies in the sharing of information and artifacts for current
studies on source code models for software engineering tasks, with 40% of the
surveyed papers not sharing source code or trained artifacts. We recommend the
sharing of source code as well as trained artifacts, to enable sustainable
reproducibility. Moreover, comprehensive information on training times and
hardware configurations should be shared for transparency on a model's carbon
footprint. | [
0.060592968,
0.0749339238,
-0.027569972,
0.0249700192,
-0.0349514559,
0.0045172987,
0.0142454347,
0.0042501511,
-0.0492899232,
-0.0212570038,
-0.0091192564,
0.0873439759,
0.0183069315,
0.0210294817,
0.0032552872,
-0.0305951498,
0.0800054893,
-0.0021405525,
-0.0352814086,
0.005048837,
-0.0041948603,
0.0097064385,
0.0205521751,
0.0623575635,
-0.0114408592,
-0.0046360255,
-0.0115203056,
0.0381554179,
-0.039359577,
0.0358489156,
0.0318220258,
0.0506695956,
0.0025377413,
0.0320889316,
0.0000022628,
-0.0007141784,
-0.0434478745,
0.0335863158,
-0.0052230028,
0.0481825881,
0.0748340636,
0.0080008348,
-0.003930673,
0.0081809061,
0.0149258869,
-0.0122507475,
0.0878301263,
-0.0329629518,
0.0505978875,
-0.0268969648,
0.0196065549,
0.0386987962,
0.0058438862,
0.0095419483,
0.0232799388,
0.0488028042,
-0.0193547383,
0.0755855739,
0.0136420364,
0.0241310652,
0.0148883471,
0.0550260469,
0.0258889087,
-0.0122147771,
0.0298388358,
0.0311815534,
-0.0444898792,
-0.0175520275,
0.0002249868,
-0.0225303341,
0.0039141732,
-0.0293908995,
0.0088819657,
-0.0066266377,
-0.0571441278,
0.0252195392,
-0.0039963787,
0.0427109785,
0.0404853113,
-0.0159483906,
-0.0089638643,
-0.0467551313,
-0.0107617956,
-0.0141408332,
0.0415213443,
0.035816174,
-0.0352937654,
0.0131643722,
0.0019009712,
0.0181907006,
0.0100596109,
-0.0362551436,
0.0115597183,
-0.0077898018,
0.0573627912,
0.0019210791,
-0.0519117564,
-0.0104187913,
0.035280481,
-0.033598002,
0.0017329952,
0.0177218467,
0.01604902,
-0.0095368996,
0.0169148557,
0.010546146,
-0.0142779294,
-0.0319546573,
-0.0221419837,
0.0156527087,
-0.0676524714,
-0.0304063186,
-0.0529838614,
0.0111981612,
0.0175406151,
0.0122390063,
-0.0063795173,
0.0390764028,
0.0038981785,
0.0424221829,
0.024772387,
0.0159073733,
-0.0084643634,
0.01635639,
0.0330447368,
0.0108430916,
-0.0164749995,
-0.0123097645,
-0.0044045867,
-0.0767828003,
0.0280275494,
-0.0136356978,
-0.0557457879,
-0.016121082,
0.0232140012,
0.0431583449,
0.0368135311,
0.0251806695,
-0.0439284071,
-0.0352141336,
0.0454583615,
0.0087292744,
-0.0387963317,
-0.1031547114,
-0.0599572174,
0.017349001,
0.0412278175,
-0.0412232541,
-0.0032337368,
-0.0198294781,
-0.0314958692,
0.0226388518,
-0.0963673964,
0.0626036152,
0.0505988263,
0.0237830319,
-0.0095924577,
0.0654339865,
0.0607395619,
-0.0323410369,
0.0438722745,
-0.0596277043,
-0.0075867632,
0.0106891971,
-0.0475688018,
-0.0006984122,
-0.027756881,
0.0340522379,
0.0142479176,
-0.0340374969,
-0.0153131261,
0.0147527829,
-0.0332615823,
0.0279376712,
0.0279757753,
0.0482763574,
0.0033313402,
0.0301878992,
-0.0056274435,
0.0471088886,
-0.0105319591,
-0.0627773032,
-0.033612825,
0.0415256098,
0.0189249497,
-0.0160535593,
-0.0361310542,
0.0314066112,
-0.0050219591,
-0.0661329404,
-0.0124769099,
-0.0595543273,
-0.0022427859,
0.0095165102,
0.0322039798,
-0.0140286228,
-0.0007829265,
0.093638815,
0.0291780885,
-0.0781193599,
-0.0690037981,
-0.0456337556,
-0.0004369446,
0.0687194094,
0.0461002178,
-0.0347107202,
-0.0094241928,
-0.0181721505,
-0.0054807495,
-0.0815647542,
0.0627802163,
-0.0013787481,
0.0010250928,
-0.0513829589,
-0.0301904269,
-0.0617258511,
-0.0278202072,
0.0469695628,
0.0190696046,
0.0019881197,
0.0181363616,
-0.0175204724,
-0.091785647,
0.0395448729,
-0.0333729684,
0.0289628636,
-0.0288024135,
-0.0148087516,
0.0085210474,
-0.0304489024,
-0.049522873,
0.0042735194,
0.0568522774,
0.0195614211,
-0.0371457376,
0.0126620531,
0.0163080003,
0.0844814852,
-0.0019457268,
-0.0310011376,
0.0113486461,
0.0159095842,
-0.005630787,
-0.0087548969,
0.0184466727,
-0.0134628713,
0.0628510341,
0.0296633448,
0.0356478393,
-0.0702374727,
-0.039530158,
-0.0176453516,
0.0169754438,
0.0258323327,
0.0330706798,
-0.0442225263,
0.0138902292,
0.0528565496,
0.02638443,
-0.0256391503,
0.0187080819,
-0.010216753,
0.0304349307,
0.03346074,
0.0346734375,
-0.0135929557,
-0.0094545754,
-0.0761442408,
0.0061687138,
0.0025868972,
0.0288742911,
0.0092782211,
0.0102499546,
-0.0014264161,
0.0133030498,
0.0142575186,
-0.0154365394,
-0.0501401126,
0.0231969785,
-0.0021418922,
-0.0189373922,
-0.015446539,
-0.0100849643,
-0.0366587825,
-0.0170323439,
0.0484637655,
0.0013697294,
-0.0341861136,
-0.0962571427,
0.0992948562,
0.0176011566,
0.0195365921,
-0.0297567025,
-0.0129291071,
-0.009541708,
0.0128123984,
0.0437373593,
0.0327890739,
-0.0275702905,
-0.0138172479,
0.0591071993,
-0.0023865183,
-0.0802377835,
0.0190888122,
0.0600193441,
-0.0506655574,
0.024287425,
-0.0712741315,
0.0286234003,
0.0363338627,
-0.055070132,
-0.0239210445,
0.0313806124,
-0.0044152364,
-0.0272109695,
-0.0345098637,
-0.0056125983,
-0.0375026464,
0.0321460031,
0.0219449401,
-0.0024897088,
-0.119964771,
0.0326611698,
-0.0568816848,
-0.0258195195,
-0.0372083038,
-0.0625981465,
-0.0449998118,
0.0493172668,
0.0109948674,
0.0276965927,
0.0264905561,
0.0226848908,
-0.0104267411,
0.0223139487,
0.0050380006,
0.0172837097,
0.0163698159,
-0.0240713339,
0.0035580094,
-0.0040440867,
0.0009589374,
0.0195999779,
0.0086272815,
-0.0418487638,
-0.0170121491,
0.0101195797,
-0.0216985326,
-0.0039255875,
0.0424095728,
0.0610953458,
0.0192904323,
0.0477988608,
-0.0446902998,
0.0135819279,
-0.049578093,
-0.0113031045,
-0.0614772364,
-0.0238509327,
-0.0182783417,
-0.0582099631,
0.0388004519,
0.0647973418,
0.0114040934,
-0.0635682866,
-0.0438133553,
0.065758884,
0.009359777,
-0.071665071,
0.0265641827,
0.0346294716,
-0.0410532951,
-0.0097740274,
0.0348549969,
0.0343732946,
-0.064980194,
0.0099320207,
-0.0271779355,
0.0440921001,
0.0484037399,
0.0358215868,
-0.075328283,
-0.008500779,
0.0516486838,
0.0269774534,
-0.0322143249,
0.0079412349,
-0.0155916121,
-0.0314887129,
0.029571848,
-0.0110196555,
-0.0196403693,
0.0154423257,
-0.0705024749,
-0.0161975957,
-0.0240024906,
-0.0722580552,
0.0120363245,
-0.0081078541,
0.0377943069,
0.0387350284,
-0.0584811568,
-0.0109344861,
0.0190021191,
-0.0122684594,
0.0131619899,
0.0977271721,
0.0006519704,
-0.0150348553,
0.0024148247,
0.0513629355,
-0.0120486179,
0.0250636451,
-0.0308733229,
0.0140738012,
0.0185782854,
-0.0082489774,
0.062987566,
0.0017372494,
-0.0557116829,
-0.0032922227,
0.052490972,
0.0455221273,
-0.0053379596,
-0.0148185799,
-0.0229382459,
-0.0458506867,
-0.0047962433,
0.0298289992,
0.0210377127,
-0.0161317103,
-0.0376971997,
-0.057967145,
-0.0050981874,
0.0278282017,
0.0180245843,
-0.0341661796,
-0.0329151973,
-0.0456455238,
0.0031379152,
-0.0188053045,
-0.0252832118,
0.0291970912,
0.0140113691,
-0.0180189013,
0.0443963781,
0.0029543005,
-0.0533620752,
0.0357976034,
-0.0347369798,
0.040318884,
-0.0439712666,
-0.0531738512,
0.0336170122,
0.049947422,
-0.0289069153,
-0.0220743548,
-0.0640083179,
-0.0309830122,
-0.0181056373,
0.0921032429,
0.0310229547,
-0.0100129992,
-0.0012207605,
-0.0430673249,
-0.0877504572,
0.0431547165,
-0.0370017439,
0.0516977869,
0.0049432279,
-0.0216875244,
0.0090005836,
-0.0448368303,
-0.0433178432,
0.0067337849,
0.0145059004,
-0.0512952544,
-0.015376986,
-0.0091629578,
0.0014274444,
-0.002967488,
-0.0147255799,
0.023930978,
0.0139431404,
0.0068186759,
0.0047706245,
0.0334344693,
-0.0125618652,
-0.0816399232,
0.0271117222,
-0.0043791886,
0.0087965345,
0.0410812013,
0.0385491103,
-0.0124059385,
0.02030598,
-0.0260949116,
0.068585068,
0.028649969,
0.0757222399,
0.0324454829,
0.0292402636,
-0.0261983108,
-0.0492512248,
-0.0112221465,
0.0028957536,
-0.0271676891,
0.0278165601,
0.0047318516,
0.0442343019,
0.0184869263,
0.033991497,
-0.0185819361,
-0.096428737,
0.0089058084,
-0.0287252497,
-0.0054295463,
0.0466146134,
0.0013079474,
-0.0336076766,
-0.0023644834,
-0.0347830951,
0.0331727937,
-0.0037923062,
-0.0258780811,
-0.0229051877,
0.0158721283,
-0.0576356649,
-0.0461853109,
0.1128174961,
0.022615755,
0.0288844705,
-0.0483973324,
-0.0408157967,
-0.0052094604,
0.0287595671,
0.0018274533,
-0.0604110472,
-0.0280996598,
-0.0542886443,
-0.0084794695,
-0.0576147921,
-0.0114434166,
0.004440709,
0.0466831401,
0.0033837219,
0.0494349375,
0.1042511836,
0.0036567894,
-0.0514103994,
0.0010970455,
-0.0009580032,
-0.0335442983,
-0.0172537584,
-0.0079222769,
-5.664978375e-33,
0.0267270375,
-0.0060053645,
0.0265368279,
0.0093679084,
0.024745211,
0.0385515727,
-0.0186288599,
0.009762493,
-0.0396243781,
-0.010935734,
0.0014742151,
-0.0003982517,
0.0005785216,
-0.064883776,
0.0922846347,
0.0596382581,
0.0398955271,
0.0201742891,
-0.04072823,
0.0285143573,
-0.0119611183,
0.0358194262,
0.02922884,
-0.0618853346,
-0.0023264938,
-0.0003565717,
0.0372682661,
-0.0348307937,
0.0443202592,
0.004614579,
0.0121482499,
0.00897549,
-0.00730127,
-0.0160733406,
-0.030557612,
-0.0346110202,
-0.0477639847,
-0.0003538287,
0.0083305789,
-0.0029027432,
0.0265154559,
-0.0274449792,
0.0765304267,
0.0270635672,
-0.0238388386,
0.0319489799,
0.0303112399,
-0.0157788955,
-0.0421230346,
0.0123593137,
-0.0232913755,
0.0078169974,
-0.0453929082,
0.0376974717,
-0.0192929357,
0.0417159684,
-0.0123012085,
0.0317453779,
0.0122540575,
0.0125297029,
0.0383112058,
0.0546258092,
0.0705589801,
-0.0217884108,
0.0393494777,
0.0259722508,
0.0293877944,
0.0251276139,
-0.0028791514,
0.0064228447,
0.0709708408,
0.0479616486,
0.0190337449,
-0.0133211389,
0.0226651262,
-0.0502654687,
-0.0041304035,
-0.0157599468,
0.0020029068,
0.0256749596,
-0.0015894118,
0.0359275118,
-0.0178677104,
-0.0354060158,
-0.0294200033,
0.0006989246,
0.0032756261,
-0.0404494181,
0.023351118,
0.0066321515,
-0.0295221433,
-0.0001635069,
0.0012819018,
-0.0223433804,
-0.0050561382,
0.0525722094,
-0.0045115771,
0.0220914222,
-0.0024490156,
0.0401018783,
-0.0607666597,
-0.021687109,
-0.0502512977,
0.017503554,
0.0698115155,
-0.0124225486,
0.036743179,
0.0184567031,
-0.0551542453,
0.0292846616,
-0.0488213375,
-0.0172233414,
-0.0121039953,
-0.0112552103,
-0.0043446291,
-0.0001595223,
0.0380550809,
0.0186226107,
-0.0207667165,
-0.0321549922,
-0.0820408762,
0.0235988423,
-0.0288977996,
-0.0147602521,
0.0084672729,
-0.0418162569,
-0.0598912351,
0.0439217649,
0.0528524965,
-0.0005717406,
-0.06556499,
0.0116449669,
2.968e-7,
0.0101450067,
0.0106098196,
-0.0365519114,
-0.026170861,
0.0211304314,
0.0298009273,
-0.0061576939,
-0.0070941756,
0.0352297835,
0.0428173803,
-0.0524861328,
-0.0117456401,
0.0571534708,
0.0333787724,
-0.0275990348,
-0.0288143791,
-0.0468758419,
-0.0106235715,
-0.0530105121,
-0.0185029749,
-0.0409277901,
-0.0028630716,
0.0354884975,
0.020516105,
-0.0069436901,
-0.0498002693,
-0.018812567,
-0.0773119703,
0.0504527427,
0.0403837487,
-0.0487849936,
0.0380501114,
-0.0015703508,
-0.0503593422,
0.0011007485,
-0.0611637831,
-0.005837251,
0.0401815176,
-0.0005096094,
0.0447984301,
0.0513162874,
-0.0306256246,
-0.0581745058,
-0.0414920077,
0.0338863097,
-0.003508104,
0.0027559211,
-0.043171566,
-0.0148971034,
-0.022191843,
0.0095709758,
-0.0140973562,
0.0496264994,
0.0115038333,
-0.0104052816,
-0.0458926596,
-0.0527505018,
0.0162931252,
-0.0064667077,
-0.0183472503,
-0.0081367409,
-0.0547404736,
-0.0590883121,
0.0201173443,
0.0138907954,
0.0235562902,
0.0356480032,
2.575104735e-34,
0.0220529772,
-0.0572465174,
0.0019309904,
0.0518219955,
0.0393955372,
0.0052035688,
-0.0069919247,
-0.0039536809,
-0.0474608019,
0.0207706988,
-0.0331325606
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.12057v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.12057v2 | External Reasoning: Towards Multi-Large-Language-Models Interchangeable Assistance with Human Feedback | 2023-07-05T17:05:32 | 2023-08-26T19:29:03 | Akide Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Memory is identified as a crucial human faculty that allows for the retention
of visual and linguistic information within the hippocampus and neurons in the
brain, which can subsequently be retrieved to address real-world challenges
that arise through a lifetime of learning. The resolution of complex AI tasks
through the application of acquired knowledge represents a stride toward the
realization of artificial general intelligence. However, despite the prevalence
of Large Language Models (LLMs) like GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 \cite{brown2020language,
leiter2023chatgpt, zaitsu2023distinguishing, OpenAI2023GPT4TR} , which have
displayed remarkable capabilities in language comprehension, generation,
interaction, and reasoning, they are inhibited by constraints on context length
that preclude the processing of extensive, continually evolving knowledge
bases. This paper proposes that LLMs could be augmented through the selective
integration of knowledge from external repositories, and in doing so,
introduces a novel methodology for External Reasoning, exemplified by ChatPDF.
Central to this approach is the establishment of a tiered policy for
\textbf{External Reasoning based on Multiple LLM Interchange Assistance} in
\cref{fig:overall}, where the level of support rendered is modulated across
entry, intermediate, and advanced tiers based on the complexity of the query,
with adjustments made in response to human feedback. A comprehensive evaluation
of this methodology is conducted using multiple LLMs and the results indicate
state-of-the-art performance in \cref{comparison} , surpassing existing
solutions including ChatPDF.com. Moreover, the paper emphasizes that this
approach is more efficient compared to the direct processing of full text by
LLMs. The source code is publicly available at:
\url{https://github.com/AkideLiu/ANLP}. | [
0.0411157534,
0.0283691697,
-0.0369657055,
0.0378233269,
-0.0582167618,
0.0219456144,
-0.0040456341,
0.0203186069,
0.0666340962,
-0.0623605065,
-0.0153886108,
-0.0318010002,
-0.0222538356,
0.0000611074,
0.0278813224,
-0.049104359,
0.049242083,
-0.0617608279,
0.0222722385,
-0.0145188635,
-0.0010631201,
0.0208330378,
-0.0138998758,
0.0279930755,
0.0061833253,
-0.0121013364,
-0.0253431853,
-0.026904935,
0.0188177153,
0.0121197049,
-0.0175653603,
0.0395380855,
0.0278285891,
0.0361139998,
0.0000024664,
-0.0722166002,
-0.0379382856,
0.0128095476,
-0.0143250721,
-0.0203876048,
-0.0059507387,
0.0243146457,
-0.0043234844,
-0.0038538245,
-0.0251284447,
0.0087545672,
0.0215298869,
0.049702283,
0.0700680763,
0.0451370515,
0.0009551438,
-0.0452588238,
0.0323331952,
0.0073052961,
0.0325522237,
-0.0254131369,
0.0261675175,
0.0438862294,
0.0668834895,
-0.0077790837,
0.0063443459,
0.0489510298,
0.0421720482,
-0.0227852929,
-0.0263921302,
0.0379196405,
-0.0165347289,
-0.0140464287,
-0.0227603968,
0.0474537127,
0.0080896746,
-0.0138167441,
0.0020372742,
0.0132492753,
0.0016963867,
0.040181417,
-0.0756808221,
0.045547545,
-0.0381305292,
-0.0065328046,
0.0294828843,
-0.0138597153,
0.003581472,
0.0249459278,
-0.0912968069,
0.0701195896,
0.020803621,
-0.030581031,
0.0396512002,
-0.0201740339,
-0.0472134948,
-0.0704528987,
0.0349122733,
0.0636655539,
-0.0228655003,
0.0393986143,
-0.0169654228,
-0.0044966047,
0.0273819529,
-0.0691872835,
0.0034117757,
0.0626045913,
-0.0370557792,
0.0621386282,
-0.0358113572,
0.0662429258,
-0.061687272,
0.0275519155,
-0.0249723513,
-0.0081309909,
-0.0853763223,
-0.0306007508,
-0.038627483,
0.072166875,
-0.0284190327,
-0.0466774143,
-0.0179629643,
0.0437213257,
-0.0231979191,
0.0189566519,
0.0349483676,
-0.0191354528,
-0.0071343253,
-0.0223032907,
-0.0708740875,
0.0170740504,
-0.0385940298,
-0.027792193,
0.0100649884,
-0.0635569692,
0.0136151444,
0.0233714581,
-0.0218129344,
-0.0219881814,
-0.011174473,
0.1222648546,
-0.0156238256,
0.0132809244,
-0.0356156528,
-0.0530974157,
-0.0083617019,
-0.0721420795,
0.0195463616,
-0.063115783,
0.0230795946,
0.0099536199,
-0.0283482075,
-0.0363603011,
0.011487741,
0.0445871577,
-0.030778626,
0.0682967678,
-0.0259045251,
0.0085690683,
0.0483528003,
0.016769506,
-0.0117344372,
0.0777096748,
0.0149165113,
-0.012264655,
0.0304981042,
0.0104310643,
0.001848471,
0.0471954867,
-0.0105211707,
-0.015004402,
-0.0466275364,
0.0332473293,
0.0123329433,
0.0336851887,
-0.0158882793,
0.0644274503,
-0.0352708735,
-0.0259046778,
0.0360245854,
0.0643430203,
0.0035264771,
-0.0107932622,
0.0526105762,
-0.0009071181,
0.0312507451,
0.0287505034,
-0.0297181197,
0.0474188477,
-0.0279187001,
-0.0035096172,
-0.0058199824,
0.0431433283,
-0.0069944281,
-0.0317257419,
-0.0124466429,
0.0124529619,
-0.0097954366,
0.0303069334,
0.0553267226,
-0.0082938243,
0.0002490452,
0.0324476287,
0.0261238292,
-0.0187725089,
-0.0213928334,
-0.0740823075,
0.0123452628,
0.0851208344,
0.0408410467,
-0.0122760925,
-0.0666731074,
0.0091007259,
-0.0255915597,
0.0424074382,
0.0290431902,
-0.0088125123,
-0.0506229624,
-0.0602663569,
-0.0137628159,
-0.016018685,
-0.0197641179,
0.0403232798,
0.0206443537,
0.0014342893,
0.0044300295,
-0.0036100035,
0.0151130119,
0.0266018435,
-0.0216639247,
0.0189527106,
-0.0562687479,
0.0258323494,
0.0257897116,
0.0348321646,
-0.0001355489,
0.0171672236,
0.0171309691,
-0.0174919236,
-0.040114738,
0.0273524448,
-0.03211613,
-0.0152781857,
0.0388178751,
0.0068930383,
-0.0160728469,
-0.062411312,
-0.0018888235,
-0.0508489273,
-0.001769882,
-0.0435200185,
0.0844897106,
-0.0589198843,
0.010557292,
0.0140152834,
-0.0337378606,
-0.0415282622,
0.0882763565,
0.0010141695,
-0.0238834545,
0.0232983772,
0.0248745084,
0.051171571,
-0.0699689463,
-0.0120571228,
0.0572154559,
0.0001559161,
0.000578684,
0.0061167111,
0.0202282295,
-0.0742078871,
-0.0109878145,
-0.0850862339,
0.0151774641,
-0.0002065506,
-0.0120984912,
0.0050886781,
0.0059131058,
-0.005145622,
0.000065666,
-0.0272396412,
0.0125872102,
0.0333437063,
0.0302777346,
0.0143376961,
0.0448004082,
-0.0452827998,
0.010826502,
-0.0019706504,
-0.0255275946,
0.0330437385,
0.0156513862,
-0.0566389412,
-0.0466483012,
0.0243848674,
-0.0599830225,
0.0404530764,
-0.0122081758,
-0.024391707,
0.036407046,
-0.0454082489,
0.027880758,
0.0713919401,
-0.0139014041,
0.0142549202,
0.0344220363,
-0.0434872322,
-0.078897275,
0.0122234924,
-0.004898001,
-0.0420228876,
-0.0120435776,
0.0198865682,
-0.0344106853,
0.026638817,
0.0143738566,
0.0018320354,
-0.0700826868,
0.0134702884,
-0.0213516168,
-0.0336705744,
-0.0501614846,
-0.0219624955,
-0.012743351,
0.0610068105,
-0.0084159253,
-0.0362861902,
0.0965247676,
-0.0343444012,
0.009479519,
-0.0226703193,
-0.0058458312,
-0.0380709171,
0.0689362288,
-0.0109320367,
0.0319185369,
-0.0123042855,
-0.0159457363,
-0.0492511168,
0.006071453,
0.0151240667,
-0.0173742585,
0.0397321321,
-0.0782811046,
0.0238063,
0.0214736238,
-0.0381361134,
-0.039015945,
0.0220110025,
-0.0229503755,
0.0147702983,
-0.0034502549,
-0.029989779,
-0.0200831648,
0.0232867431,
0.0550836325,
0.0327936113,
-0.0273217838,
-0.0057257414,
-0.0271435119,
-0.0057138768,
0.0178544912,
0.0064055077,
-0.0148169035,
-0.0341563821,
0.0224609133,
0.0471734144,
0.0128008565,
-0.0681176111,
0.0113776159,
0.0342848748,
0.0144302668,
-0.0232206844,
-0.0248728283,
0.0071321554,
0.0071310541,
-0.0858498886,
-0.0236748531,
0.101033479,
0.0368984491,
-0.0543455072,
-0.0159824938,
-0.0582360663,
-0.0233605672,
0.0346017368,
0.0505858921,
-0.0751698464,
-0.0036443006,
0.0228045322,
-0.0110893194,
-0.0176031161,
-0.0209638625,
-0.0030942943,
-0.15521954,
0.064696528,
-0.0055351933,
-0.0357761867,
0.0122825019,
-0.0080659222,
0.0085028559,
0.0368917994,
-0.0405740775,
0.0141479764,
0.0154362097,
-0.0104646208,
-0.007307291,
0.0269941799,
-0.0176301282,
0.0223670006,
-0.0143805966,
0.0256583393,
0.039732568,
0.023677161,
0.0188107435,
-0.0368065313,
0.04641366,
-0.007976912,
0.0248115193,
-0.038143754,
0.0108956341,
0.017839903,
0.0094019072,
-0.0421323478,
0.0199358948,
0.0151511086,
-0.0178179648,
0.0132020367,
0.1162411645,
-0.0373239741,
0.017130062,
-0.0161870737,
0.0097232703,
-0.0187329613,
0.0745311677,
0.003722515,
-0.010828116,
-0.0284100939,
-0.0227997787,
-0.0587873198,
-0.0226273369,
-0.0258487053,
0.0549957007,
-0.0129491761,
-0.0203832984,
-0.0500585623,
-0.0203848723,
0.0454216711,
0.0593378432,
0.022970533,
0.0105798542,
0.0116370218,
0.0182646252,
-0.0136873405,
-0.011581094,
-0.0275205038,
-0.0124671618,
-0.022084197,
-0.0052199787,
0.0184390098,
-0.0417440385,
-0.0243074428,
0.0315741822,
0.0229568277,
-0.0549975596,
-0.0086131264,
0.0500504337,
0.0337158591,
0.0238706581,
-0.005538878,
-0.0311774686,
0.04167201,
0.0236263555,
-0.0430459864,
-0.0002650601,
-0.0296209846,
0.0370436162,
0.0028240408,
0.0271515977,
-0.0261984933,
0.0042883395,
-0.0192754734,
0.0285472032,
0.0188045055,
-0.0152677307,
0.0377278849,
0.0595275499,
-0.0195893552,
-0.0055627027,
-0.0176074579,
-0.0268957168,
0.0310352165,
-0.0590480492,
-0.0458374582,
-0.0281328466,
0.0205991734,
0.0129371574,
-0.0211179014,
0.0206501391,
-0.0092460625,
0.016496582,
0.0027180379,
0.019630529,
-0.0108353393,
0.0323050059,
0.0302795786,
-0.0003056608,
0.0001938267,
-0.0100094443,
0.006903009,
-0.0021967296,
0.0431557223,
-0.049471397,
0.0998319164,
0.0466766432,
-0.0265264865,
-0.0147148371,
0.0122699831,
-0.0784325078,
-0.1105415672,
0.0191906802,
0.0567134619,
0.0481901579,
0.0305998065,
0.0320135392,
-0.0373659842,
-0.0323349573,
0.0240209401,
0.0079757264,
0.0495091975,
-0.0303984433,
0.0141470302,
0.0398491956,
-0.0042262431,
-0.0111157056,
0.031771712,
-0.0462868065,
0.0429482162,
-0.0129819214,
-0.0319485217,
-0.0346060693,
-0.0524611287,
-0.0243384335,
0.0143997492,
-0.0080022411,
-0.0168612879,
-0.0529088862,
-0.0726997629,
-0.0343736932,
0.0386721119,
-0.0124404449,
0.0267105661,
0.0368451737,
0.0599828921,
0.0253319498,
-0.057588838,
-0.0170366503,
0.0291223153,
-0.0624484085,
-0.0209625419,
-0.0003897704,
-6.75902713e-33,
-0.052156508,
-0.0508183427,
0.0649437308,
-0.0405310988,
-0.0239313226,
-0.0182624757,
-0.0304136965,
-0.0359347239,
0.0018535078,
0.0049119829,
-0.0151995262,
-0.0093509732,
0.0105226412,
-0.0171759538,
0.0338676162,
-0.0027189876,
0.0019432218,
0.0031312469,
-0.0015624325,
0.0178036429,
0.0808030888,
0.0139832171,
0.0355194807,
-0.0359640829,
0.0133538013,
0.0140036056,
-0.0122031067,
0.0592506751,
-0.036868494,
0.0683262646,
-0.0316198766,
0.0233113617,
0.0193662457,
-0.0107984683,
-0.0038109506,
0.0027101217,
-0.0535698123,
-0.0204498507,
0.0708520561,
-0.0040621897,
-0.0059618647,
-0.0225540213,
0.0124996975,
-0.0350866504,
0.0100146821,
-0.0026880174,
0.0216930807,
-0.028445581,
0.0337013677,
0.0260007456,
-0.0666423216,
0.0174292009,
-0.0136492392,
0.0174215827,
-0.0044557611,
0.032816004,
-0.0083338525,
0.0392794572,
-0.0193668306,
0.0265860576,
-0.0118503086,
-0.0167519618,
0.0749178156,
0.006749555,
0.0119536677,
0.0348014235,
0.0057367622,
-0.0083528664,
-0.0376760662,
-0.0606683381,
0.0133315818,
0.0806528926,
0.0151869645,
0.0484769642,
-0.0093608554,
0.0216927249,
-0.0652045608,
0.0188454222,
0.0110549377,
0.0619651712,
0.018439807,
0.0265674759,
-0.0391299799,
-0.0119759059,
-0.0273734815,
0.0140924659,
-0.0414803848,
-0.0425536297,
0.0607418306,
-0.0263709519,
0.0246757809,
0.0003416412,
0.023657402,
-0.0454989932,
0.0185308829,
0.0084054004,
-0.0225529131,
0.0209626704,
-0.0160382073,
0.0409423076,
-0.0168741178,
-0.0384850614,
-0.0116259996,
-0.0093186293,
0.0057022395,
0.0336351432,
0.0146502052,
-0.0055283662,
-0.0352277942,
0.0020721308,
-0.0620888062,
0.0075644101,
-0.0039740149,
-0.0315450616,
0.0315984488,
0.0303409882,
-0.0144279292,
0.0552812107,
0.0323134139,
-0.0020719797,
-0.0327159613,
-0.0093203364,
-0.0033473461,
-0.0018707359,
-0.0207999814,
0.0244893655,
-0.0033086878,
0.0057920474,
0.0026537296,
-0.0520945564,
0.0026330661,
0.0446930192,
3.263e-7,
0.035616748,
0.0379725732,
0.0124137551,
0.0387006439,
-0.0017056125,
-0.0116047151,
-0.0122405384,
-0.0220558699,
0.0081406068,
-0.0127490414,
0.0011849232,
0.0733581185,
0.0260519069,
0.0403980762,
-0.0437084064,
-0.0299183708,
-0.0103917103,
-0.0916011184,
-0.0821506307,
0.0206656847,
0.0805332586,
0.0248759408,
0.0029791398,
-0.0069340258,
-0.0150940381,
-0.0578062944,
0.0558988564,
-0.0422698893,
-0.0203042924,
0.0264123362,
0.0290632509,
0.0361027867,
-0.0089189894,
0.0469230488,
0.0159805659,
0.0144164898,
0.0030553436,
0.0607451051,
0.0070736031,
-0.0038962702,
-0.0135222292,
-0.0340822674,
0.0008865783,
-0.1056050956,
0.0757076517,
-0.0629023835,
-0.0353263281,
0.0118780388,
-0.0039979788,
-0.0565198064,
-0.0138295097,
-0.0336863361,
0.0002454146,
0.0194258951,
-0.0072116856,
0.0083348127,
-0.0002393079,
-0.0850961879,
-0.0010450175,
0.0452294238,
-0.048004508,
-0.03145108,
-0.0323167965,
-0.0146804219,
0.0204401612,
-0.044700589,
-0.0107364878,
3.185130513e-34,
0.0325088874,
0.0086471736,
0.0211217776,
0.0241101719,
0.0748143345,
0.0049126064,
-0.005443899,
0.0297027864,
0.0021264995,
-0.0983330011,
-0.0351842679
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.02435v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.02435v1 | Exploring Continual Learning for Code Generation Models | 2023-07-05T16:58:39 | 2023-07-05T16:58:39 | Prateek Yadav, Qing Sun, Hantian Ding, Xiaopeng Li, Dejiao Zhang, Ming Tan, Xiaofei Ma, Parminder Bhatia, Ramesh Nallapati, Murali Krishna Ramanathan, Mohit Bansal, Bing Xiang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.SE | Large-scale code generation models such as Codex and CodeT5 have achieved
impressive performance. However, libraries are upgraded or deprecated very
frequently and re-training large-scale language models is computationally
expensive. Therefore, Continual Learning (CL) is an important aspect that
remains underexplored in the code domain. In this paper, we introduce a
benchmark called CodeTask-CL that covers a wide range of tasks, including code
generation, translation, summarization, and refinement, with different input
and output programming languages. Next, on our CodeTask-CL benchmark, we
compare popular CL techniques from NLP and Vision domains. We find that
effective methods like Prompt Pooling (PP) suffer from catastrophic forgetting
due to the unstable training of the prompt selection mechanism caused by stark
distribution shifts in coding tasks. We address this issue with our proposed
method, Prompt Pooling with Teacher Forcing (PP-TF), that stabilizes training
by enforcing constraints on the prompt selection mechanism and leads to a
21.54% improvement over Prompt Pooling. Along with the benchmark, we establish
a training pipeline that can be used for CL on code models, which we believe
can motivate further development of CL methods for code models. Our code is
available at https://github.com/amazon-science/codetaskcl-pptf | [
0.0161656532,
0.0447170846,
-0.0121305203,
-0.0106744925,
0.0078947265,
0.0092869997,
-0.03287182,
-0.0409668051,
0.0014389026,
-0.0071470826,
-0.0000422796,
-0.0051489696,
0.0063953977,
0.0197354313,
0.0466764085,
-0.0391670614,
0.0269337483,
-0.0416925363,
-0.059797693,
-0.0012974496,
-0.0037229904,
0.0033622067,
-0.0084259929,
0.0536310486,
0.0062106806,
-0.0513422489,
-0.0139056938,
-0.0093165981,
-0.0062093581,
-0.0379458852,
0.0318385363,
0.0558987521,
0.0193841122,
-0.0043830122,
0.0000023359,
-0.0239609927,
-0.0237931535,
-0.0332830027,
0.0152312731,
0.0079346299,
0.0015719316,
-0.0091047063,
-0.0072046006,
0.0285916515,
-0.0457167923,
-0.0297976471,
0.065369539,
-0.0464941971,
0.0942985564,
0.0340447538,
0.0238781646,
0.0005515582,
0.0393024124,
-0.024984261,
0.0321288146,
-0.0277973488,
0.0037668389,
0.0215867665,
-0.0045798458,
-0.0196442027,
-0.0157024879,
0.016957039,
0.0483754277,
-0.0255456921,
0.0533656031,
0.0808480605,
-0.0179366842,
-0.0221187249,
-0.0142341414,
0.021799434,
-0.0462217405,
-0.0523518398,
0.016172953,
0.0128258914,
-0.0194329266,
-0.0380388387,
-0.0487026833,
0.0607682988,
-0.0055716,
0.0071034483,
-0.0006028393,
-0.0200129468,
-0.0108678201,
0.0150228115,
-0.0312265083,
-0.0251647606,
0.0103274407,
-0.0000726396,
-0.0532602072,
0.0003925663,
-0.0157145672,
-0.0538543984,
-0.0188295785,
0.0655246451,
-0.0357984491,
-0.0036485959,
-0.0380464792,
-0.017892357,
0.0199965034,
0.0027903107,
0.0245732386,
0.0475328825,
-0.0401154347,
0.0081545711,
-0.0584404059,
0.0763893574,
0.0179310162,
0.0107529825,
-0.0285099912,
0.0414731167,
-0.0788350031,
-0.0068312269,
-0.0475613885,
0.0499597155,
0.0047096545,
0.0128372852,
-0.0306545738,
0.0579557121,
-0.0032223603,
0.056695573,
-0.0312643908,
0.0077385283,
-0.0681229904,
0.0421556197,
0.0419491045,
0.021225635,
-0.0030168649,
-0.051552698,
0.0182942357,
-0.0558484495,
-0.0299184825,
0.0089618657,
-0.0326221734,
-0.0136235664,
0.0015088092,
0.0403355844,
-0.0240529422,
0.0202548169,
-0.0329165943,
-0.0356951319,
0.0028644102,
-0.0343642458,
-0.0262112394,
-0.0919890404,
-0.0168936104,
0.0006444674,
0.0036665662,
-0.0660403967,
0.0113612926,
0.006420447,
0.0408636369,
0.0386129953,
-0.0115394359,
0.002934189,
0.0340666771,
0.015902156,
-0.0202709977,
0.0530674271,
0.0281841662,
0.0181877743,
-0.0067611714,
-0.0173644181,
0.0257228073,
0.0195415933,
0.018518405,
0.023120258,
-0.0061330409,
0.0057592094,
0.0657485947,
-0.0168614108,
0.046935536,
0.0179138333,
-0.022488581,
0.0451051146,
0.0170359444,
0.0011918203,
-0.0038241833,
0.0355245844,
0.0882645771,
0.0078283986,
0.0060377293,
0.0210704133,
-0.0486328192,
0.0501983985,
-0.0024310197,
0.0363065936,
0.0246277265,
0.0117823398,
-0.0141088665,
-0.0542723089,
0.0224734824,
-0.0051260674,
-0.0264515821,
-0.0077644843,
0.0134304976,
0.0197359063,
-0.0410928838,
0.0442241542,
0.0028608826,
-0.0877644718,
-0.0148730846,
-0.0225920361,
0.0174330305,
0.0466797538,
0.0523038618,
-0.05341525,
-0.0533559881,
-0.0410869718,
0.023941407,
-0.0190612189,
0.0383976512,
-0.0183934011,
0.0260379314,
-0.0432452075,
-0.0037979274,
-0.0335989594,
-0.0015196447,
0.0301183332,
0.026948873,
-0.0288532004,
0.0327183045,
0.0116493674,
-0.0873929188,
0.0645041764,
-0.0392409638,
0.0002720669,
0.015800802,
-0.0133622335,
-0.0209852438,
-0.027664179,
-0.0536298938,
0.0171011742,
0.0318197832,
-0.0308700278,
0.006148749,
-0.0007766453,
-0.080023706,
-0.053986337,
0.040148925,
-0.0272459462,
-0.0248704404,
-0.0014936358,
-0.0332398377,
-0.0275864862,
0.017613858,
-0.0077527622,
0.0199981797,
-0.0109242825,
0.0493372418,
-0.0227310061,
-0.0241306517,
-0.0230593439,
0.052927617,
-0.001289209,
0.021763077,
0.039627701,
0.1052758247,
0.0117515726,
-0.0492331274,
0.0112965666,
0.0066148448,
-0.0243854281,
0.0289282463,
0.0138155008,
0.0589573607,
-0.0408775881,
-0.0475070551,
-0.0991188139,
0.0476454422,
-0.0210755542,
-0.0167581178,
0.0056462404,
0.0230466817,
-0.0000664942,
-0.0145673174,
-0.0327352695,
-0.033720579,
-0.0321898162,
0.0186823867,
0.0178328454,
-0.0027609328,
-0.0183547437,
-0.0421014912,
0.0038640162,
-0.0198696032,
0.0426614806,
-0.0173843801,
-0.0136712641,
-0.0434496701,
0.1148653403,
0.0047717057,
0.0225235783,
-0.0131704444,
-0.0075413142,
0.0165685993,
-0.0626629442,
0.0759289861,
0.0319643617,
0.0166747384,
0.0185488872,
0.0401099287,
0.0152619258,
-0.0458458848,
0.0258960258,
0.0082856854,
-0.0682582781,
0.0308826659,
-0.0098988023,
0.0373655856,
0.0443368964,
0.0126494206,
-0.0086338883,
-0.0662016496,
0.0238746125,
-0.0100125996,
0.0031426095,
-0.0318262354,
-0.0162361525,
-0.0078664916,
0.0349645764,
-0.0312227402,
-0.107466124,
0.0557975471,
-0.0117358342,
-0.0183081366,
-0.0361803882,
-0.0054550949,
-0.0513630435,
0.0528987125,
0.014586797,
0.0125532541,
0.0254655126,
-0.0401158035,
-0.0453814529,
0.0284258332,
0.0256330017,
-0.0085344547,
0.0668471158,
-0.0454429388,
0.0145628788,
-0.0406072251,
-0.0388553739,
-0.0681154355,
-0.0134808989,
0.0163874999,
0.0003158915,
0.006897863,
0.0036970819,
0.0491531156,
0.0005897544,
0.0216599759,
0.0692472532,
-0.009544652,
-0.055229228,
-0.0234217755,
0.0022430059,
-0.006312116,
-0.0246096607,
-0.0051798536,
-0.0349099189,
0.0167856012,
0.0240174271,
0.0733391419,
0.052167058,
-0.0628200099,
0.0220758114,
0.0179844219,
-0.0055377604,
-0.0065618018,
0.0468735285,
0.0626504198,
-0.0493821576,
-0.0391243584,
0.096631214,
0.0557179749,
-0.0743698478,
0.0097974706,
0.0244662091,
0.065723151,
0.0679252371,
0.0303410105,
-0.0661913753,
-0.0297609549,
-0.0030206428,
0.0582409278,
-0.0090730498,
-0.0342971459,
-0.0598421991,
-0.0999381021,
0.0141873397,
0.0310983844,
-0.0244635995,
-0.005539265,
-0.02535557,
-0.038919773,
0.0004108826,
-0.0477849618,
0.0488825068,
-0.0171561707,
0.0524554998,
0.0245548189,
-0.022348918,
0.0119290734,
0.0032826383,
-0.0417584702,
0.028437715,
0.0980278552,
-0.0000652432,
0.0245001484,
-0.0067822137,
0.0768240169,
-0.0406039096,
0.0205200911,
-0.0216297805,
0.0495642722,
0.004090094,
-0.0165498797,
0.0570488162,
0.0320747383,
-0.0465501025,
-0.0214424785,
0.051786799,
0.0209736582,
0.0034045679,
0.0040947106,
-0.0073094619,
-0.0067608063,
-0.0060410271,
0.0272558052,
0.0464813672,
-0.0174600687,
-0.0215763263,
-0.083669506,
0.0151178958,
-0.0728123784,
0.0222575869,
-0.0216561742,
0.0065619764,
-0.0186618157,
-0.0703402162,
0.0212003272,
0.0169001166,
0.049672842,
0.0274246801,
-0.0161236152,
-0.0251712501,
0.0074526276,
-0.0519631468,
0.0114687746,
-0.005814699,
0.0102782482,
-0.0413922593,
-0.0293494798,
0.0068962849,
-0.0352143161,
-0.0067743501,
0.0324861258,
-0.1250059754,
-0.0654153526,
-0.049367819,
0.067461431,
0.0160555448,
0.0563830286,
-0.0285317488,
-0.022486547,
-0.0310539305,
0.0396755822,
-0.0398043618,
0.0243869554,
0.0149537837,
0.0030265611,
0.022586938,
-0.0084211538,
-0.0635308996,
-0.0241799764,
0.016416302,
0.012019394,
0.0194960181,
0.0312775485,
0.056898877,
-0.0044021769,
-0.0183554478,
0.00306135,
-0.022014942,
-0.017401658,
-0.0235896744,
0.0538338758,
-0.0297970995,
-0.0406682752,
0.0446613804,
0.0048512914,
-0.000937223,
0.0376009829,
0.0317159556,
0.0207441077,
0.0581099764,
-0.0145518295,
0.0121589648,
-0.0005074196,
0.025274625,
0.0658991486,
0.0012026216,
-0.053563606,
0.021879971,
-0.0142406244,
0.027918417,
-0.0061782873,
0.0609854646,
0.03855386,
0.0368485972,
0.0181399882,
0.0080512594,
-0.0731315091,
-0.077195622,
-0.0225449018,
0.0152186081,
0.0714249015,
0.0366475806,
0.0346790776,
-0.0202286001,
0.0283446573,
-0.0233677626,
0.0427228771,
0.0210518874,
-0.0541793928,
-0.0138557907,
0.0267844703,
0.0225347932,
-0.0267804004,
0.1116947308,
-0.0355258696,
0.0055919588,
-0.0008634878,
0.0132197263,
-0.0436696783,
0.0225406345,
0.0155160269,
-0.0097208424,
0.0124970954,
0.0081840893,
-0.0074734711,
-0.0292136874,
0.0282824971,
0.0179726873,
0.0231711827,
-0.0156035237,
0.0419511646,
0.0603158139,
-0.0159161165,
0.015881747,
-0.0240126643,
0.0395232886,
0.0440124236,
-0.0276116002,
-0.0415340066,
-5.862938603e-33,
-0.0234900974,
-0.0140217794,
0.0284563471,
0.0331286378,
-0.0426125862,
0.0022608922,
-0.0755996257,
0.005096016,
0.0284643993,
-0.0483803973,
0.0160619374,
0.0155684436,
-0.0166690424,
-0.0181106552,
0.0513490289,
0.016178295,
0.0527573302,
0.030261727,
-0.0630530715,
0.0610795058,
-0.0185412019,
0.0463182107,
-0.02141474,
-0.0117589254,
-0.0175979864,
0.0053623691,
0.0167102646,
0.0142178927,
0.0443163104,
0.0273054074,
0.0096167922,
0.0048753787,
-0.0030888,
-0.0587706231,
-0.0623502433,
-0.0251437444,
-0.0471554846,
-0.0252597891,
-0.0076939752,
0.0044361083,
-0.0406315103,
-0.0758823827,
0.0419105925,
-0.0176847298,
-0.0175486971,
-0.024995368,
0.0232702605,
-0.0266803764,
-0.0316592455,
-0.0448860191,
-0.0632962584,
0.0154309878,
-0.0643688068,
-0.0406365879,
-0.0162130147,
0.0270666294,
-0.0065241051,
0.0251359046,
-0.009245405,
0.0021453158,
0.0400329493,
0.0741800293,
0.0546126999,
0.011954153,
0.0279218033,
0.038353648,
0.0348054543,
0.0142531693,
-0.0120009538,
0.0076513072,
0.0445833281,
0.020526005,
0.0178147703,
-0.0047026579,
0.0270311851,
-0.0134892613,
-0.0211956743,
0.0179746281,
0.0094581228,
0.0328272544,
0.0381464474,
0.0149068097,
0.0040568486,
-0.0369441323,
-0.0572044253,
-0.0218089782,
-0.013516386,
0.0007189465,
0.0609886013,
0.0369681716,
-0.0271712672,
-0.0277412534,
0.0228072498,
-0.0250583217,
0.0073364559,
0.0539274998,
-0.0735784993,
0.0339306667,
-0.0097319661,
0.026177641,
-0.0154185658,
-0.0017726632,
0.0263642799,
-0.0140839973,
0.0528738946,
0.0290430877,
0.0599629506,
0.0286901724,
-0.0331710093,
-0.0036867482,
-0.0740964562,
0.0274678543,
0.0168059506,
0.0491427444,
-0.0072586648,
-0.0100224204,
-0.0016605188,
0.0317387432,
-0.0028692968,
-0.0441731177,
-0.0692840517,
0.0383499525,
0.0240353644,
0.0414404981,
-0.0262608565,
-0.0353584476,
-0.0434015505,
0.0605051406,
0.0263649207,
-0.0662319064,
-0.0617108904,
0.0067037693,
2.838e-7,
-0.0190787278,
0.0027928897,
0.0150201088,
0.0030425834,
0.0252477452,
0.0352151692,
-0.0422687531,
0.0075032166,
0.0231430419,
0.0261878222,
-0.0422274843,
0.0220874883,
0.036419183,
0.0196557511,
-0.0685118288,
0.0199081395,
-0.013919604,
0.0202645753,
-0.0630178154,
0.0040114536,
0.0217081923,
0.0559647456,
-0.0317614824,
0.0096406518,
0.0661606044,
-0.0352325216,
0.037804056,
0.0230033826,
0.031544894,
0.0187684074,
-0.0791137367,
0.0237302184,
-0.022825323,
-0.0207383204,
-0.0202884674,
-0.0417230502,
0.0072218645,
0.0361493714,
-0.0027155988,
0.0375118181,
0.052146893,
0.0088605946,
-0.0019035797,
-0.0769280046,
0.0487343222,
-0.0448977277,
0.0367606841,
-0.0116865737,
0.001147851,
0.0135540096,
-0.0128100989,
-0.0091673173,
0.0017634362,
0.0161624327,
-0.0033602701,
-0.0103393998,
-0.0406883098,
-0.0343445837,
-0.0622429401,
-0.0319767445,
-0.0094079645,
-0.0548752062,
-0.0689408407,
0.0130752297,
-0.0220094565,
-0.0487259068,
0.0012120845,
3.096792342e-34,
0.0273238719,
-0.0499626249,
0.0312523358,
0.0101870317,
0.0133062359,
-0.037424095,
0.0044145747,
0.0073133376,
0.018694872,
-0.0037444963,
-0.0583621599
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.03084v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.03084v1 | OpenDelta: A Plug-and-play Library for Parameter-efficient Adaptation of Pre-trained Models | 2023-07-05T16:30:14 | 2023-07-05T16:30:14 | Shengding Hu, Ning Ding, Weilin Zhao, Xingtai Lv, Zhen Zhang, Zhiyuan Liu, Maosong Sun | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | The scale of large pre-trained models (PTMs) poses significant challenges in
adapting to downstream tasks due to the high optimization overhead and storage
costs associated with full-parameter fine-tuning. To address this, many studies
explore parameter-efficient tuning methods, also framed as "delta tuning",
which updates only a small subset of parameters, known as "delta modules",
while keeping the backbone model's parameters fixed. However, the practicality
and flexibility of delta tuning have been limited due to existing
implementations that directly modify the code of the backbone PTMs and
hard-code specific delta tuning methods for each PTM. In this paper, we present
OpenDelta, an open-source library that overcomes these limitations by providing
a plug-and-play implementation of various delta tuning methods. Our novel
techniques eliminate the need to modify the backbone PTMs' code, making
OpenDelta compatible with different, even novel PTMs. OpenDelta is designed to
be simple, modular, and extensible, providing a comprehensive platform for
researchers and practitioners to adapt large PTMs efficiently. | [
-0.0144352727,
0.07070788,
-0.0106903706,
-0.0057150838,
0.0230169743,
0.0243785772,
0.0124290241,
-0.013717779,
-0.0405092724,
-0.0167828687,
-0.0697547793,
0.0381663442,
-0.0295899864,
0.0674581304,
-0.0077389153,
-0.0803709179,
0.0564711243,
0.005530247,
-0.0098610995,
-0.0079147918,
-0.0261330679,
-0.0115653463,
0.0029797663,
-0.0057455804,
0.0069049466,
-0.0079959435,
-0.0480576865,
0.0590908639,
0.0304660331,
0.0078136297,
0.0521871448,
0.0814723,
0.0124146426,
0.0325991884,
0.0000022741,
-0.0295886956,
-0.0319201052,
0.0051102447,
-0.0116282944,
0.0670982748,
0.0435284115,
0.0251558628,
0.0015127929,
0.0147517696,
-0.0216853004,
-0.0163665004,
0.0494565405,
0.0300243534,
0.0664860457,
0.0916114971,
0.0036805058,
-0.0121151488,
0.0007590759,
-0.0322787464,
-0.0233811606,
-0.0307039581,
0.0352496468,
0.0180738103,
-0.0608077124,
-0.0507641397,
-0.0192203168,
0.0129130734,
0.0190279465,
0.0227247346,
0.0241376795,
-0.0130863264,
-0.0128289107,
-0.0433270149,
-0.0378850698,
0.0412530154,
-0.0816292018,
-0.0260664113,
-0.000452397,
-0.0528509691,
-0.0230615363,
-0.0325009003,
-0.0049108951,
-0.0412747711,
0.0387656391,
-0.0099605387,
-0.0450635701,
-0.0346447416,
0.0237011071,
0.0090696895,
-0.0462050065,
0.0093223015,
0.0184508059,
0.0275034532,
0.0006991223,
-0.0139840674,
-0.0367729403,
-0.0606377423,
0.0411381423,
0.0038758921,
-0.030764157,
-0.025853714,
-0.0712000057,
-0.051208064,
-0.0127090989,
-0.0237495527,
0.0842895135,
0.0386472829,
-0.0654107481,
0.0288031455,
-0.0495590195,
0.0007206424,
-0.0546989702,
0.0667919964,
-0.002357468,
0.0400198475,
-0.0055681602,
0.0371476598,
-0.0376646817,
-0.0291392971,
-0.043825414,
0.013642149,
-0.0200047754,
0.0412467606,
0.0259330049,
-0.071168378,
0.0284968447,
0.018346237,
-0.0230820235,
-0.0009808893,
-0.0105958749,
0.0390385427,
-0.0176231377,
0.017913416,
0.0044738026,
-0.0064086383,
-0.0114132641,
-0.0074390927,
0.0057305689,
-0.0063972506,
0.0662728176,
0.0025797375,
0.0005817735,
-0.0196375698,
-0.0336122885,
0.0175337903,
0.0576450974,
-0.0395158455,
-0.0030584345,
0.0051183864,
0.0175877512,
-0.0022408434,
0.0329034142,
-0.0388567112,
-0.0408837087,
-0.0423950031,
-0.034434177,
0.0557475723,
-0.0288606361,
0.0045269737,
-0.0027669468,
0.0100597329,
-0.0285485089,
0.0674763769,
0.0286401864,
0.0362427011,
-0.0093627721,
-0.021427352,
-0.0597711727,
0.0043391637,
-0.0054992563,
0.0222522151,
0.0009933766,
0.0255978778,
0.0507123582,
0.0137193445,
0.0462955832,
-0.0577845015,
-0.0169833433,
-0.0272425152,
0.0495075658,
-0.0035968157,
0.0699955076,
0.0419444218,
0.0373853743,
-0.0252955053,
0.0342769809,
-0.0580105819,
-0.0755835399,
0.0370484814,
-0.0391775481,
-0.0135444319,
-0.0417940877,
0.106350705,
-0.0417802483,
-0.0485150442,
0.0221219584,
0.0009193042,
-0.0560554005,
0.0241631828,
0.0403934605,
-0.0328633338,
-0.0534799211,
0.0339307226,
0.0482896604,
-0.0319992155,
-0.0186429974,
-0.0631907359,
-0.0121015329,
0.0408493727,
0.0145376353,
-0.0614475422,
-0.0637520254,
0.0135071203,
0.039606858,
0.0051857964,
0.0462667607,
0.0420974083,
0.0433085077,
-0.0130483769,
-0.0205476284,
-0.0086269518,
0.0169259571,
0.0669221804,
0.029682789,
0.0231412705,
0.0117582129,
0.0170201808,
-0.0177701805,
0.0275689531,
-0.0403550491,
0.0016099514,
0.0368803889,
-0.0124778086,
0.0268951319,
-0.0305020809,
-0.0327081718,
-0.0627459884,
0.0211646017,
0.0133395521,
0.0361848585,
-0.0110777589,
-0.0293457303,
0.0675454512,
0.0414143987,
0.0439654142,
0.0504128821,
0.049679324,
-0.0579765961,
-0.0431878977,
0.0435048267,
0.0625252128,
0.0392110161,
-0.0181280337,
0.0236902647,
-0.0360164084,
0.0371416062,
0.0017988476,
0.0078598643,
0.0401072651,
-0.0677001402,
-0.0062524416,
0.0518867336,
-0.0028053271,
0.0035907759,
0.0124960728,
-0.0070889206,
0.0029435414,
0.0249043033,
0.0045261988,
0.0409678891,
-0.002545306,
-0.0029254248,
-0.0703117102,
0.0587107763,
-0.0374595486,
0.0132172406,
0.0453138202,
0.004876791,
-0.0569272712,
-0.0083469823,
0.0213224273,
0.0766374394,
-0.0378829278,
-0.021933876,
-0.025724465,
0.0158402547,
-0.0177730806,
-0.0538032912,
-0.0136288293,
0.0294056311,
0.0137434397,
-0.0060554952,
-0.0405710787,
-0.0178536251,
0.0187144279,
-0.0313430838,
0.0472536497,
0.0072212876,
-0.0341670997,
-0.0399762876,
-0.0100869304,
0.0176706836,
0.0790048167,
-0.0165315717,
-0.0031154258,
0.0357831419,
0.007877537,
-0.0120707704,
0.0332619138,
-0.0376826674,
-0.0587496758,
-0.0313561261,
0.0358447097,
0.0057845735,
0.0455876403,
-0.0568962954,
-0.0215597153,
-0.0496956781,
0.0102650691,
0.0131004239,
-0.045530092,
-0.0199510995,
0.0289581399,
-0.0203830302,
0.0190825071,
-0.0098972823,
-0.0527665764,
0.0103471735,
0.0030900047,
-0.0138819246,
-0.003996545,
-0.0248807389,
-0.0413115472,
0.0160073172,
0.016674662,
0.0226644129,
0.021329267,
0.0135054961,
-0.0403046869,
0.0111722508,
0.0280514937,
-0.0031897703,
-0.0068722479,
0.0065181362,
0.0149383377,
-0.0121476678,
-0.0267271157,
-0.0166758131,
0.0031129268,
-0.0335103795,
0.0089275772,
-0.0169989578,
-0.0782757252,
-0.0285839904,
-0.0049644713,
-0.0126173329,
0.0561010465,
-0.0415520184,
0.0037139726,
-0.0381421857,
-0.0359788612,
0.0066784401,
0.008722024,
0.0449216925,
-0.0072052232,
0.0229884144,
-0.0152428607,
0.0171687417,
-0.0722569749,
-0.084603779,
0.0540834703,
0.0076269372,
-0.0587094352,
-0.0078204693,
0.0018130246,
0.0307098702,
-0.04235515,
0.0108938236,
0.0342661738,
0.0008419364,
-0.0623912401,
-0.0137779452,
-0.030679265,
0.0702307671,
0.0069523309,
0.06095865,
-0.0363148488,
-0.051717449,
0.0004214018,
0.0392777659,
0.0242325682,
0.0171875972,
-0.0095054461,
-0.0044062994,
0.0397614576,
0.0276564434,
-0.0368540585,
0.0174471531,
-0.0337375514,
0.007776822,
-0.067337811,
-0.007645377,
0.0410385616,
-0.0094519407,
-0.0112326741,
0.0091181258,
0.0419368669,
-0.0440857261,
-0.0150088333,
-0.0498158634,
-0.0092077143,
0.0396639407,
-0.0343608111,
0.0117052002,
-0.000476937,
0.0597608015,
-0.0255587921,
0.0172353107,
-0.0511323176,
-0.0001039438,
-0.0148547236,
-0.0098549398,
0.0031938183,
0.0163585749,
-0.0306854174,
-0.0250424016,
-0.0123294499,
0.0421545953,
-0.0051553748,
0.0133405728,
-0.0209356844,
-0.0358242877,
0.0035522522,
-0.0006137122,
0.0139908297,
-0.0201194808,
-0.0189800393,
-0.0048877974,
-0.0470400564,
-0.0122794406,
-0.0058612437,
-0.0482678562,
-0.0645154864,
-0.0588066876,
-0.0061855246,
0.0648744926,
0.0150273452,
0.0341816656,
-0.0022000303,
-0.0415577702,
-0.0226010326,
0.0237271152,
-0.0830819458,
0.0656288564,
-0.0222150683,
-0.0242820736,
-0.073899664,
-0.0739931166,
0.0721675754,
0.0076831621,
-0.0059735645,
0.0095048929,
-0.0607238859,
-0.0333528668,
0.0464031063,
0.095450148,
0.0170066338,
0.043485336,
-0.0173132103,
-0.0365205295,
0.0511039011,
0.0478137247,
-0.0081447661,
0.0606607608,
0.0532447472,
-0.0468763225,
-0.021859182,
0.0012502434,
-0.0562409386,
0.0404668748,
0.0339972228,
-0.0265769046,
0.0293277074,
-0.0868096575,
-0.0475466922,
0.0030155543,
0.0627531856,
0.0285791587,
-0.0278824009,
-0.0364375114,
0.0436918437,
0.0191348381,
0.0193924084,
-0.0516045876,
-0.0059444942,
-0.0089238659,
0.0003826373,
-0.0128565533,
0.0612691119,
0.0401670635,
-0.0019378671,
-0.0242387801,
0.0071686483,
-0.0223146472,
0.0450250804,
0.0099344356,
-0.0000594114,
0.0228606649,
0.0343001746,
0.0122336345,
0.01773615,
-0.0180294383,
-0.0008598868,
-0.0070919194,
0.0245694462,
-0.0547086075,
0.0498356298,
-0.0490893014,
-0.0799411982,
-0.0819744021,
0.0020618055,
0.0589331202,
0.0194226485,
0.0762237236,
-0.0057210084,
-0.0304957069,
-0.0251112711,
0.0199672375,
0.0216526128,
0.0613712482,
-0.010072154,
-0.0247592833,
0.0005199437,
0.0016647273,
0.0189733002,
0.008719448,
0.0698343143,
-0.0032078337,
0.0026527734,
0.0050761485,
-0.022711968,
0.0219988767,
0.0017515414,
-0.0141923763,
-0.024084758,
0.0096932249,
-0.0136946421,
0.0148110241,
0.0197595935,
-0.0081631122,
-0.0175953321,
0.0241368525,
-0.0169912744,
-0.012268113,
-0.0200747438,
0.0071905763,
-0.0511901081,
-0.0333080925,
0.0158856921,
0.0650597513,
-6.716278074e-33,
-0.0521502718,
0.0563809909,
0.0067320163,
-0.0058130682,
-0.0289175697,
-0.0245955419,
-0.010519186,
0.006997487,
0.0141888885,
-0.0097838836,
-0.0198011808,
-0.0067407228,
0.014663592,
-0.0363446735,
-0.0046355869,
-0.0105761001,
0.0518441238,
-0.0313770361,
-0.027390711,
0.0238909014,
-0.0001823939,
0.0652108043,
0.034684591,
-0.0164475683,
-0.0921795219,
0.0493570119,
-0.0216202214,
-0.0174241029,
-0.0362670757,
0.0164951552,
0.0220577996,
-0.0149280205,
-0.0425818115,
0.0097486833,
-0.0575396158,
-0.0200987794,
-0.0650195703,
-0.0092190932,
0.005536214,
0.0295307543,
-0.0205630679,
-0.0177806523,
0.041348625,
0.0419233441,
-0.0366252474,
-0.0184480716,
0.0003196531,
-0.0426793657,
0.0249935258,
-0.0452833138,
-0.0152141042,
0.0334935002,
0.0004520602,
-0.0085785966,
0.0204369612,
0.0091750687,
-0.0078702616,
-0.004655167,
-0.0016130436,
-0.0147695765,
0.1015305519,
0.0243660249,
0.015557006,
0.0675774962,
0.0451915152,
0.0247983616,
0.0452729091,
-0.0321636014,
0.0329446979,
0.0237479508,
0.0615368821,
0.0557286888,
0.0374992788,
0.0035914304,
0.0300830398,
-0.0130722905,
-0.0678242743,
0.0156459473,
-0.0383038707,
0.003164975,
-0.0223390777,
0.0296963919,
0.0438803025,
0.0068845344,
-0.0211727824,
-0.0495884195,
-0.038341254,
-0.046982225,
0.0251575541,
0.0189800244,
-0.0533174835,
0.0286574624,
0.0263620298,
-0.0150622437,
0.0873403624,
0.008951189,
-0.0246496554,
0.0163155738,
0.0306039713,
0.0213269107,
-0.0336711369,
-0.0899776667,
0.0183543526,
-0.0317568108,
0.023657443,
-0.0290848278,
0.0107968617,
0.0618400909,
-0.0296307653,
0.0309037566,
0.0030206074,
0.0146322548,
0.0440521911,
0.0582228377,
-0.0035284106,
-0.0130539006,
0.0192479827,
0.0823974088,
-0.026827516,
-0.022340389,
-0.0465956666,
0.01037692,
0.0577369668,
0.0622922257,
-0.0296006966,
-0.0032748063,
-0.035429962,
-0.0224103462,
-0.0076434859,
-0.0809864476,
-0.022420859,
0.0009451278,
2.971e-7,
0.0225626491,
0.0513604023,
-0.0078971107,
-0.033749938,
0.0237332825,
0.0150450105,
-0.0279863626,
0.0070941057,
0.0125656258,
-0.0019546591,
0.0393235199,
0.0629285797,
0.0231685918,
-0.022317186,
0.0170301422,
-0.022705555,
-0.0100368103,
0.078898102,
-0.0504905842,
-0.0528862923,
-0.038538482,
0.081301406,
0.0441117845,
-0.0013419924,
0.0455594286,
0.0209552161,
0.0321661755,
-0.0550499968,
-0.0013227927,
0.0362307169,
0.0018794211,
0.0427340567,
-0.035175845,
-0.0186664499,
-0.0287664048,
0.0569532886,
-0.0417497344,
0.0905443057,
-0.0081598116,
-0.0212755352,
0.0436062366,
0.0568662807,
0.0263884533,
-0.0288736913,
0.0552977882,
-0.0272002313,
0.0009565728,
-0.0530388393,
-0.026033558,
-0.0548832491,
0.041938249,
-0.0312941894,
0.0147219421,
0.0233698189,
0.0249515995,
0.0018699266,
-0.0669031665,
-0.0646489039,
0.0047025941,
0.0354900286,
-0.0183434691,
-0.0190991461,
-0.0631377399,
-0.0083526615,
0.0528717153,
-0.0174502656,
0.0016825066,
3.010002748e-34,
0.0505533144,
-0.0279548429,
0.0316478573,
0.005589284,
0.009364537,
0.0005921694,
0.0373106785,
-0.0202356335,
0.0171301663,
-0.055872716,
-0.0219606683
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.02394v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.02394v1 | Won't Get Fooled Again: Answering Questions with False Premises | 2023-07-05T16:09:21 | 2023-07-05T16:09:21 | Shengding Hu, Yifan Luo, Huadong Wang, Xingyi Cheng, Zhiyuan Liu, Maosong Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pre-trained language models (PLMs) have shown unprecedented potential in
various fields, especially as the backbones for question-answering (QA)
systems. However, they tend to be easily deceived by tricky questions such as
"How many eyes does the sun have?". Such frailties of PLMs often allude to the
lack of knowledge within them. In this paper, we find that the PLMs already
possess the knowledge required to rebut such questions, and the key is how to
activate the knowledge. To systematize this observation, we investigate the
PLMs' responses to one kind of tricky questions, i.e., the false premises
questions (FPQs). We annotate a FalseQA dataset containing 2365 human-written
FPQs, with the corresponding explanations for the false premises and the
revised true premise questions. Using FalseQA, we discover that PLMs are
capable of discriminating FPQs by fine-tuning on moderate numbers (e.g., 256)
of examples. PLMs also generate reasonable explanations for the false premise,
which serve as rebuttals. Further replaying a few general questions during
training allows PLMs to excel on FPQs and general questions simultaneously. Our
work suggests that once the rebuttal ability is stimulated, knowledge inside
the PLMs can be effectively utilized to handle FPQs, which incentivizes the
research on PLM-based QA systems. | [
0.0767759606,
0.0044568181,
-0.0283316057,
0.0322168469,
-0.0028595868,
0.0142823281,
0.0000747997,
-0.0336581133,
-0.0086567998,
-0.0438386723,
-0.0517925918,
0.0037823792,
-0.0003835944,
0.0208092108,
0.0498616919,
-0.0278330967,
0.0637361705,
-0.0400764383,
0.0318492353,
-0.0350398459,
0.0208449345,
0.0011175297,
-0.0171712376,
0.0166891199,
0.0014666187,
-0.038537588,
-0.0025476688,
-0.0117775109,
-0.0087157814,
-0.0102337282,
0.042356234,
0.040698342,
0.0237075128,
0.0528816469,
0.0000017082,
-0.0597924292,
-0.0062298351,
-0.0175563358,
-0.0710091442,
0.0602732562,
-0.0032148496,
-0.0243911054,
0.0438584387,
0.0292308778,
-0.0528838933,
-0.0599830747,
0.0136144748,
0.0662431717,
0.0736665577,
0.0716183707,
0.0247496665,
-0.0032502937,
-0.0021321417,
-0.0169262402,
-0.004560078,
-0.0559779853,
0.0316230021,
0.0127058495,
-0.0447132252,
0.0141972248,
0.0034962338,
0.007979108,
0.0331862941,
0.0144303543,
-0.0417541377,
0.0211623833,
-0.0552224442,
0.0061575552,
-0.0205816757,
0.0868822187,
-0.003122973,
-0.0746996105,
-0.0148506239,
-0.002494937,
-0.0049581625,
0.0218730029,
-0.0512302071,
0.0355126746,
0.0180611275,
-0.0083129676,
-0.0185759347,
0.0044119954,
0.001884929,
0.028584376,
0.0087346984,
0.0395014361,
-0.0033406059,
-0.0301076733,
0.016492242,
-0.0060456106,
-0.005578069,
-0.0544281602,
-0.0029839599,
0.0718271956,
0.0081301136,
0.0395716913,
-0.0474958904,
0.0043953825,
0.0509089269,
-0.0343698673,
0.0053387475,
-0.0007877019,
-0.0301553272,
0.067378059,
-0.0557882637,
0.0327368937,
-0.0349036083,
0.0396327488,
-0.0221121255,
-0.0414653718,
-0.0190082025,
-0.0495094992,
-0.0470276773,
0.0213768892,
0.0162020586,
0.0280895028,
0.0053023947,
0.0314798653,
-0.0015368586,
-0.0021307752,
-0.0377041921,
0.02807156,
-0.0091141993,
-0.0407336019,
-0.0750029162,
0.0425004065,
-0.0522970557,
0.0548362434,
-0.0298084039,
-0.1103260368,
-0.0492175259,
0.0181298852,
-0.0064094537,
-0.0021758561,
0.0395395011,
0.0082223723,
0.0059651001,
-0.0148474518,
-0.0449233875,
-0.0298873149,
0.0124633433,
-0.0468083993,
-0.0014004445,
-0.0428786054,
0.015000673,
-0.0016462611,
-0.0379240364,
0.0089232167,
0.0239699278,
0.0595504045,
-0.0147329997,
0.0671565384,
-0.0089261476,
0.0259419978,
0.077111043,
0.0138379633,
-0.0256275926,
0.0474466346,
0.0189185385,
0.008738881,
0.0571826436,
-0.0006062413,
0.0514881499,
-0.0145309558,
0.0512544848,
0.0067707407,
0.0397617891,
0.0364016853,
-0.0087913405,
0.0019049881,
0.014205033,
0.0326786563,
-0.008955881,
-0.0616327673,
0.072268337,
0.020724101,
-0.0180720109,
0.0194722209,
0.0418401845,
-0.0058471463,
0.0526506156,
0.0227695312,
-0.0356331728,
0.0268212017,
-0.0840681568,
0.0034144083,
-0.0112923654,
0.0090096239,
-0.0513314717,
-0.0483103953,
0.0118206777,
-0.0002404832,
-0.0121604903,
0.0457346663,
0.0453110784,
0.0325969718,
-0.0219016466,
0.0527945012,
-0.0069864285,
-0.0049178475,
-0.0109938392,
-0.0535677373,
0.0661092773,
-0.0065069855,
0.0327713303,
-0.0493843034,
-0.0447682552,
-0.001466239,
0.0223744251,
0.033864636,
0.0874190852,
-0.0094729066,
0.0214130115,
-0.0015297373,
0.015373229,
-0.0746567622,
0.0104893921,
-0.0093560955,
0.0220319275,
0.0238068309,
0.0227447413,
-0.0394090265,
0.0074392515,
0.0446382463,
-0.0014937287,
-0.0391918011,
-0.0023317074,
-0.0030835215,
0.0042066164,
-0.0075642602,
0.0063622929,
0.0442397371,
0.0594456643,
-0.0080842851,
-0.0102220075,
-0.0137375016,
-0.0027118253,
-0.0456926115,
0.0289013442,
-0.0334403403,
-0.0124391345,
0.055315651,
-0.0544536114,
-0.0135661913,
0.0084665911,
-0.0322808027,
0.022277914,
-0.0524138361,
-0.025555443,
-0.016568087,
0.0068599018,
-0.013020833,
0.063642852,
-0.0035938718,
0.0387787223,
-0.0256872475,
-0.0019456366,
0.0108042536,
-0.0376471467,
0.0266819056,
-0.0520041995,
0.0022234002,
-0.0059199068,
0.0191063695,
-0.018109059,
-0.0435815156,
0.010362898,
-0.1010419354,
0.0045153587,
-0.0130018992,
0.0045523867,
0.0311094318,
-0.0530101322,
-0.0147120273,
-0.0584168658,
-0.0699134469,
0.0064755892,
0.0189479366,
0.0073183388,
0.0546483472,
-0.0071711391,
0.0408841372,
-0.0298489816,
0.0285839178,
-0.0233794395,
0.0392263047,
-0.0084671592,
0.0174510796,
-0.0408014096,
0.0184210557,
-0.0474835373,
0.0263712686,
-0.0105656469,
-0.0227705017,
0.0123565895,
0.0258918852,
-0.0244832952,
0.0788329467,
0.0250534527,
0.0036175796,
0.0380992219,
0.0201017242,
-0.0302687362,
0.0212514829,
-0.0227094069,
-0.0114578372,
-0.00196376,
-0.0405432582,
0.0338249989,
0.0369797796,
0.0182617903,
-0.020431079,
-0.0096552521,
0.0861772224,
0.0081787454,
-0.0323306918,
-0.0199081693,
-0.0108361393,
-0.0139657939,
0.0606984682,
-0.0140039651,
-0.0409466624,
0.0774957314,
-0.0232052747,
-0.0071206139,
-0.0515885055,
-0.0075086835,
-0.0495193191,
0.047498133,
-0.0205506627,
-0.0117584253,
0.056084346,
0.018178314,
-0.0478959791,
-0.0074943625,
0.0071473047,
-0.0527266115,
0.0307706334,
-0.0389156155,
-0.0018689292,
0.0038450193,
-0.0306241531,
-0.0903566852,
-0.0899704993,
-0.0476786979,
-0.028825637,
-0.0815160498,
0.0367817767,
-0.0433934368,
-0.0160593707,
0.0404357612,
0.0242534522,
-0.017215265,
-0.016167907,
-0.002238835,
0.0462177247,
0.0874314308,
0.0591730513,
0.0630546138,
-0.0294794366,
0.0023954497,
0.0384290963,
-0.0238626245,
0.0252109729,
0.0120054577,
-0.0335274898,
-0.0081569711,
0.0033635939,
0.0147454916,
0.0127517385,
0.033603631,
-0.0533198416,
-0.011539638,
0.098822318,
0.0506269522,
0.0187834557,
0.0092146695,
-0.0235531218,
-0.0035839588,
0.026048813,
0.0331998691,
-0.0890055075,
-0.0386598669,
-0.0418189801,
0.0056633763,
-0.0319552608,
0.0122871287,
-0.038084399,
-0.1391825527,
0.0113822566,
0.0030510435,
-0.0312490314,
-0.0249301251,
-0.0253881179,
-0.0179365221,
0.0193397272,
0.0129682533,
0.0082301432,
-0.0066466108,
0.0126397954,
0.0037374769,
-0.0176280215,
-0.0214764383,
0.0334205404,
0.0012636634,
0.0350240059,
0.0400456786,
0.0107018156,
-0.0040220763,
-0.0416289531,
-0.0188050941,
-0.042580992,
-0.0146675762,
-0.0061580841,
0.0260515399,
-0.0137986215,
-0.0103028156,
-0.0295548048,
0.0403337665,
-0.0354500711,
-0.0201177094,
0.0348460339,
0.0425681211,
-0.024357494,
-0.037717931,
0.0023982648,
0.0216100551,
-0.0461437739,
0.0972599015,
0.0420153216,
-0.0043511349,
-0.0233714879,
-0.0365547091,
-0.005154761,
-0.0214357469,
-0.0420431569,
0.0313654728,
0.0323195308,
0.0377912708,
-0.0675347596,
-0.0548410527,
0.0563553423,
0.0195413288,
-0.0376193412,
-0.0228975844,
0.0377910174,
0.0070562353,
-0.0411316268,
0.0198763255,
-0.044259198,
-0.0005255156,
-0.037615303,
-0.0413182639,
0.0215212386,
-0.0418500155,
-0.0209263507,
-0.0114042191,
-0.0686349347,
-0.0359262489,
-0.0226453785,
0.0757249296,
0.0256913304,
-0.0082915667,
-0.0106955711,
-0.0598601364,
0.0370976962,
-0.0043996018,
-0.0447061956,
0.0242838953,
0.0465989411,
-0.0026059006,
0.0037086641,
0.0372249894,
-0.046220459,
0.0174479149,
0.0187550541,
0.0218243822,
-0.0395202748,
-0.0299977288,
0.0435077772,
-0.008884904,
0.0502203107,
0.0609599128,
0.0221390724,
-0.0061811572,
0.0338677764,
-0.0185336675,
-0.0171579383,
-0.0126227355,
0.0122542409,
0.0114037581,
-0.0036081653,
-0.0135117108,
-0.0546746217,
-0.0574963205,
0.0391639918,
-0.0179015994,
-0.0251373053,
0.044243712,
0.0196138863,
-0.0282192342,
-0.0285625122,
-0.0343169048,
0.0331796482,
-0.0183450393,
0.0661920533,
0.0369937792,
0.0736406073,
0.0219753198,
-0.0048808884,
-0.0266853366,
-0.0039131204,
-0.071786806,
-0.0732519552,
0.0110599529,
0.0254702773,
-0.0011506201,
0.0124137271,
-0.0122386198,
-0.0136429304,
-0.011940551,
-0.0142900581,
-0.0214021616,
0.0186908618,
-0.0149106719,
0.0755157322,
0.0267055333,
-0.0329791941,
0.0212801583,
0.1018172428,
-0.0106281014,
0.0287821479,
0.0253548566,
-0.006912319,
-0.0255482774,
-0.0256062448,
-0.0066827005,
0.0163697563,
-0.0006290909,
0.0655535758,
-0.0744980872,
-0.0490950607,
0.0318232886,
0.0092175743,
0.0011433624,
-0.0188911539,
0.0086844619,
0.0488767661,
0.0180670638,
-0.0287333392,
-0.0352179557,
0.0612107888,
-0.0217100084,
-0.0049907737,
-0.0164022334,
-6.31063628e-33,
-0.0170960464,
-0.0432970375,
-0.001961865,
-0.014525434,
0.017185146,
0.028544873,
-0.0375894234,
-0.0030764672,
-0.0543974265,
0.0180685334,
0.0099746222,
0.0325450338,
-0.0145901917,
0.020631291,
-0.0396336243,
-0.0320795365,
0.0073574497,
-0.0264124442,
-0.0399149135,
0.0192751642,
0.0139904078,
-0.0014798086,
0.0259845667,
0.002049854,
0.0088599501,
-0.0486756936,
-0.0093123773,
0.0751187727,
-0.0549896583,
0.0627221167,
-0.0327091701,
0.0246073678,
0.0363323428,
-0.0154915918,
0.0168196261,
0.0525152124,
-0.0510276072,
-0.0468239598,
0.0549795702,
0.0057689236,
-0.0466512628,
0.0021656391,
0.0223625414,
-0.0282087363,
0.0299191773,
0.0039151404,
0.0027821937,
-0.0235189907,
0.0041608736,
-0.0316405892,
-0.0321283825,
-0.0004088739,
-0.0020855365,
-0.0357156806,
-0.0557831936,
0.055680085,
-0.0200956743,
0.0281713586,
-0.0596483909,
-0.0198501833,
0.0309602302,
-0.0274738707,
0.0211379714,
-0.0229491387,
0.0219823737,
0.0405838117,
0.0176279973,
0.0055812565,
-0.0461444408,
0.0134527562,
0.0176306106,
-0.0002100611,
0.0820999295,
0.0476155058,
0.043666102,
0.0119792176,
-0.0810419396,
-0.0222338308,
0.013210793,
0.0110073127,
0.0320824273,
-0.0227308348,
0.0060939202,
-0.001394194,
-0.0816414282,
0.0566670671,
-0.0345728286,
0.0086531453,
0.0397669934,
0.0313100405,
-0.0234290734,
-0.0011989954,
-0.0007184475,
-0.0317596234,
0.0292426404,
0.0105210505,
-0.0043034665,
-0.0192791875,
0.0166837815,
0.0647708923,
-0.0560262278,
0.0402929969,
0.0518849902,
-0.027158862,
0.0159465466,
0.0075646751,
0.0378717259,
-0.0052690054,
-0.0387849472,
0.0084975725,
0.0015888178,
0.0432965495,
-0.0099688284,
-0.0067046103,
0.02336495,
0.0539224036,
-0.0245251674,
0.0131707722,
-0.0120229889,
-0.0369139127,
-0.0717050955,
0.0299651697,
-0.0196935851,
0.04256621,
-0.0481706448,
-0.0099351406,
-0.0098312506,
-0.0078936992,
-0.0310602598,
-0.0784557387,
0.0001536195,
0.0311178546,
2.38e-7,
0.0346287601,
0.041801732,
0.0231678151,
0.0280525088,
0.041981075,
0.0593724214,
-0.0136008365,
0.0360814258,
0.0444236659,
-0.0503525026,
-0.0192163642,
0.0495662987,
0.0394199565,
0.0084155779,
-0.0504446253,
0.0206627548,
-0.0494463071,
-0.0149996774,
-0.0472883135,
-0.0293682963,
0.0314370692,
0.1030087993,
0.0145441778,
0.0058320379,
0.0008735321,
-0.0478687733,
0.0750346035,
0.026414508,
0.0009619433,
0.0049263043,
0.0237067677,
0.0137682194,
-0.0162993949,
0.0438703857,
-0.0027364113,
0.0317924321,
-0.016306702,
0.0407608859,
-0.0046504317,
-0.0858097002,
-0.0257894807,
-0.0217810906,
0.0211765263,
-0.077771239,
0.104383938,
-0.0685787126,
-0.0203019101,
-0.0047292872,
0.0131200105,
-0.0083829211,
0.0020272764,
0.0072004939,
-0.0397567116,
0.0176243708,
0.0267070811,
0.0114199258,
0.0319654383,
-0.0721139908,
-0.0077266931,
0.0175089873,
-0.0220364816,
-0.0186725985,
-0.036578428,
-0.0158653632,
0.042726405,
-0.0211024061,
0.0374295935,
1.883249857e-34,
0.0416167602,
-0.0281973984,
0.0049447259,
0.0340199284,
0.044070825,
0.0070182327,
-0.0221559294,
-0.0209599882,
0.0506339073,
-0.0709730163,
0.0033898614
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.02390v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.02390v1 | Causal Discovery with Language Models as Imperfect Experts | 2023-07-05T16:01:38 | 2023-07-05T16:01:38 | Stephanie Long, Alexandre Piché, Valentina Zantedeschi, Tibor Schuster, Alexandre Drouin | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Understanding the causal relationships that underlie a system is a
fundamental prerequisite to accurate decision-making. In this work, we explore
how expert knowledge can be used to improve the data-driven identification of
causal graphs, beyond Markov equivalence classes. In doing so, we consider a
setting where we can query an expert about the orientation of causal
relationships between variables, but where the expert may provide erroneous
information. We propose strategies for amending such expert knowledge based on
consistency properties, e.g., acyclicity and conditional independencies in the
equivalence class. We then report a case study, on real data, where a large
language model is used as an imperfect expert. | [
0.0063908068,
0.1350766271,
-0.018176822,
0.0278121084,
-0.0259557664,
0.0020895624,
0.0250576623,
0.0184398144,
0.0370826386,
-0.0179650411,
0.0707436502,
0.0442325845,
-0.0140843699,
0.0208205618,
0.0272354316,
0.0198658332,
0.0354088061,
-0.0186965577,
0.0423577726,
-0.0202460773,
-0.0040901378,
-0.00737083,
-0.0309485514,
0.0257421285,
-0.0176835954,
0.0356157385,
0.0186174456,
-0.0391166806,
-0.0051287697,
0.0155565729,
-0.0367250033,
0.058470279,
0.0056565991,
0.0246236715,
0.0000018282,
-0.0186438505,
-0.0155791044,
0.0001094427,
-0.0087822312,
-0.0343597904,
-0.0296129826,
-0.0147470459,
0.0585921146,
-0.004111818,
-0.0330828577,
-0.0155317606,
0.0486018993,
0.0088951318,
0.0028060803,
0.0677391589,
-0.0261213575,
-0.0089125335,
-0.0118463701,
-0.0110989017,
0.0262448564,
0.0087615168,
0.0502083749,
0.0590179563,
0.0081589641,
-0.0340119526,
-0.0276735071,
0.0127537325,
0.0058962586,
-0.0060581365,
0.0301946606,
0.0105395019,
0.0669467598,
0.0182115585,
0.0364024416,
0.0505673513,
0.0677080229,
-0.0528957956,
0.0434542671,
-0.0041132858,
0.0084701711,
0.1502301246,
-0.0161873437,
-0.0083664441,
-0.0377104804,
0.0138412118,
0.0510423817,
0.0104918163,
0.0662425384,
0.0236892551,
-0.0671676323,
0.1278978735,
-0.0109554483,
-0.0133024752,
-0.0043768124,
0.0415289775,
0.0271723624,
-0.0132193491,
-0.0008593031,
-0.0188381132,
-0.0467889495,
0.0178549904,
0.0360896066,
0.0351094492,
-0.0222803168,
-0.041832909,
0.0054941103,
0.0113297319,
0.0249479227,
0.0245110486,
0.010648719,
0.0068470561,
-0.0278677139,
0.0322219059,
-0.0146282464,
0.0328481272,
-0.0606996007,
-0.0034078769,
0.0097182933,
-0.0164512247,
0.0279498845,
0.0367156714,
-0.0351986103,
0.0235027,
-0.0584459789,
0.0041633784,
-0.0293797906,
-0.0218691379,
0.0102725122,
-0.024922099,
-0.06881506,
0.0024507495,
-0.0326256566,
0.0860555544,
-0.0548951365,
-0.0091032349,
0.0253616944,
0.0036219093,
0.0146268643,
-0.0272618253,
-0.0011398792,
0.0824568644,
0.0269654077,
0.0131156771,
-0.0003087171,
-0.0533358045,
-0.0074674762,
-0.0456906483,
-0.0183364898,
-0.0488477275,
0.023726372,
0.0489736348,
0.0005089419,
-0.0520480312,
-0.0096982047,
-0.0644709617,
-0.0852004886,
0.0494620353,
-0.0212942157,
0.0374732353,
-0.037967924,
-0.0342016481,
0.0024627456,
0.0257336982,
0.0139268693,
-0.0305694155,
0.0080639236,
-0.046491269,
0.0448316447,
0.001470858,
0.0113075478,
0.0157216974,
-0.0391759425,
-0.0416016914,
-0.0287779327,
-0.0164255556,
-0.0035060332,
0.0006689864,
-0.0099466816,
-0.0017783381,
0.039645426,
-0.0478706211,
-0.023926964,
0.026349362,
0.02112283,
-0.0488227941,
-0.0117921233,
0.0438042842,
-0.0254388917,
-0.0174547806,
-0.0330481343,
-0.0067533515,
0.0069721923,
-0.0558014624,
-0.0015134347,
-0.0447406843,
0.0092586521,
0.0261722058,
0.0058445479,
0.0112987226,
0.0965349004,
-0.0285134148,
0.0246247817,
-0.0076078209,
0.0288377535,
-0.0130487541,
0.0080618709,
0.0022764211,
-0.0209349133,
0.0835196003,
0.0337703787,
-0.0575903244,
0.0087586604,
0.005776607,
-0.0002883732,
-0.0320113786,
0.0142159713,
-0.0205368232,
-0.0285254903,
-0.0010116466,
-0.0301802885,
0.0446412154,
0.0353524834,
0.0173944291,
-0.0213068184,
0.0175619647,
-0.0257413108,
-0.0361135788,
-0.0112274839,
0.0162514448,
-0.0374331325,
-0.0022205547,
0.0051949276,
0.0181640517,
0.0472691134,
0.0234516636,
-0.0563333854,
0.0193887558,
0.0017973372,
-0.0362562686,
-0.0412034392,
0.074560985,
0.0286695324,
0.0203334875,
0.0097292447,
-0.0894591212,
-0.0068738484,
-0.0097758155,
-0.0191690382,
-0.0467346348,
0.0809211507,
-0.020871779,
0.0377276801,
0.0240101032,
-0.0190646742,
-0.0004882607,
-0.0270664543,
-0.0115236575,
0.0250080097,
-0.002499681,
0.0506752655,
-0.0101030236,
-0.0060992837,
0.0313393958,
-0.0302070528,
0.0281850044,
0.0024869842,
0.0122865504,
0.0038520577,
0.0762596801,
-0.0634849146,
0.0072808196,
-0.0156272501,
-0.0345445648,
-0.0440513454,
0.0095506562,
0.017240433,
-0.0098548057,
-0.0220520217,
-0.005411976,
-0.0119009316,
-0.0150152193,
0.0131993582,
0.0003507642,
0.0229232889,
0.0365141332,
-0.0043462203,
-0.04018493,
-0.0382192135,
-0.0280556753,
-0.0700880215,
0.0504114404,
0.0854760408,
-0.0598539636,
-0.022151107,
-0.0113213221,
-0.0304695312,
0.0231706519,
-0.0528927557,
-0.000968069,
-0.0200713351,
-0.0146945342,
-0.0039275023,
0.0088933632,
-0.0346111804,
0.0473747328,
0.0649603307,
-0.0300677456,
-0.0180654228,
-0.0161723047,
-0.0824019685,
0.0036030263,
-0.0365607888,
-0.0623002276,
-0.042675864,
0.0384499207,
0.0305914283,
-0.032786686,
-0.0313741677,
0.0061591617,
-0.0047312258,
0.0132518252,
-0.0337231122,
-0.0039965068,
0.0360246599,
0.0507661663,
-0.0060516181,
-0.0685794055,
0.0634253472,
0.0331945382,
0.0461776964,
-0.0097951973,
-0.045766972,
-0.0236394908,
0.023258809,
0.0545535646,
0.0081265643,
0.0001912297,
0.0040884851,
-0.0263351612,
-0.0109422645,
0.0689109415,
0.0124039343,
-0.0069571291,
-0.0857300237,
0.0865005702,
0.0641748905,
-0.0437303856,
-0.0368029661,
-0.0298468228,
-0.019432487,
-0.012392031,
0.0464453511,
-0.0422928669,
-0.039045468,
0.0070453314,
0.0125236921,
0.0201343205,
0.0110879289,
-0.0061461455,
-0.0132715637,
-0.0175449438,
0.0014187646,
-0.0640003532,
0.0052274028,
-0.052264668,
-0.019796785,
-0.0233165566,
0.0107679879,
-0.0316859558,
-0.0195665006,
0.0238335729,
-0.0225504003,
-0.0079058101,
0.0183016453,
0.0107784448,
-0.0550231449,
-0.0205967948,
0.0046112575,
0.0474182218,
0.0229821969,
-0.0421446823,
0.0118502956,
0.0490917377,
-0.0365476683,
0.018816378,
-0.000007652,
-0.1033994332,
-0.0027149303,
-0.0130112665,
-0.0127090793,
-0.0405378193,
-0.067470327,
0.0205656216,
-0.0439777374,
0.0039639315,
0.0150693581,
-0.0540703572,
-0.0359629691,
-0.0757253692,
-0.0092566861,
-0.0824299529,
-0.0630933717,
-0.0391374975,
0.0114503894,
0.0200379416,
0.0301895309,
-0.0040225568,
-0.0539360382,
-0.041811116,
0.0240866877,
0.0473668389,
-0.0143616488,
0.0024487476,
-0.0609629117,
0.0071060341,
0.0022926445,
0.0421037786,
-0.0175911523,
-0.0062698079,
0.0362511091,
0.0402968712,
-0.0193340424,
-0.0327406116,
0.0350568928,
-0.0046469625,
-0.0066967411,
-0.0073162573,
0.0709577203,
-0.022107942,
-0.0531266332,
0.013987273,
-0.0126615074,
0.0162842292,
0.0404234156,
-0.0145306764,
-0.0099236453,
-0.0422488637,
-0.039273411,
-0.0157311205,
0.0176534858,
-0.0419263504,
-0.0104618752,
0.0126330368,
-0.0578379333,
-0.0292967949,
-0.0061165923,
0.0090531539,
0.0130812572,
-0.0028245235,
0.0225624889,
0.0458029248,
-0.03687305,
-0.067407541,
0.0440265276,
-0.0091495458,
0.0257728361,
-0.0266615078,
-0.0409055836,
0.0008015216,
-0.0096110264,
-0.0355790965,
0.0020741043,
-0.0206007957,
-0.080047749,
0.0039792163,
0.0300603714,
0.0297348183,
0.0413407199,
-0.0068777986,
-0.0377663709,
0.0013229469,
0.0576325618,
-0.0289532337,
-0.03054028,
0.0107999481,
-0.0197662394,
0.0020346928,
0.0113263447,
-0.0232465714,
0.0227010269,
0.0149461711,
0.0149471303,
-0.0639887825,
0.0000988377,
0.0301634781,
0.0267120842,
0.0599484071,
0.006300143,
-0.0054088067,
-0.0563415363,
-0.002712843,
-0.0039031799,
-0.039137166,
-0.0035587661,
0.0147110205,
0.019220544,
0.0287709534,
0.0107427128,
-0.057232853,
-0.024422599,
-0.0205687843,
0.0166612919,
0.0376752168,
-0.0075804079,
0.0127130561,
0.058535669,
-0.0192862358,
0.0297247209,
0.0438533872,
0.0598859526,
0.0592019148,
0.0091632903,
0.0229940508,
0.0495532118,
0.0079589486,
-0.0569022484,
-0.0746374354,
-0.0573801063,
0.0043382645,
0.0030661903,
0.022401154,
0.0690774545,
-0.023048684,
0.0142639028,
-0.067854166,
0.0119899083,
-0.0101930667,
0.0519917905,
0.043042019,
0.0284749605,
0.0273940563,
0.0164325424,
-0.0334498808,
0.0368031673,
0.0756428167,
0.0517332889,
0.0661053434,
-0.0438885838,
-0.0490932539,
-0.0047838241,
-0.0464796238,
-0.0081009436,
-0.0106736328,
-0.0323682688,
0.0266039427,
-0.0976036638,
-0.0680373088,
-0.0547106266,
-0.0050387373,
0.0200302582,
0.0023654865,
-0.0171826649,
0.0068539828,
0.0054918369,
0.0234778151,
-0.0359216519,
0.0344926827,
-0.0349269658,
-0.010994589,
-0.0287015121,
-6.241565701e-33,
-0.0064245532,
-0.0761243701,
0.0121800788,
-0.0239765327,
0.0580329932,
-0.007726314,
-0.0305905454,
0.0216199327,
-0.0007961779,
0.0639162362,
0.0302224997,
0.0184470415,
0.0234097745,
-0.0224625971,
0.0392498039,
0.006894744,
0.0119795054,
0.0351504087,
0.011418662,
0.006397095,
0.0523545928,
-0.0278780404,
0.0331818014,
-0.1324071884,
0.0499652326,
-0.003167364,
-0.0142706586,
0.0415060669,
-0.0545531474,
0.0180344898,
0.0166719723,
0.0316364095,
0.0183177851,
-0.0305444635,
0.0119866533,
-0.0507148691,
-0.0153779862,
-0.0311088916,
0.0515448004,
0.0118088825,
0.0081752501,
-0.0339105278,
0.0167403761,
0.0213242397,
-0.0195873957,
0.009937915,
0.0530718341,
-0.0168770663,
0.0047312411,
-0.0004222199,
-0.038581077,
0.0244105775,
-0.0552559644,
0.0439897403,
0.0227318052,
-0.0005250461,
-0.0149665587,
-0.0410572402,
0.0221306738,
0.0584631786,
0.03332977,
-0.0017751245,
0.0310728308,
0.0256892685,
0.0092578623,
0.0394737162,
0.0174216181,
0.0242031477,
-0.0093408087,
0.0302084871,
-0.002994156,
0.0662988871,
0.0457686,
0.0401775017,
0.0160305109,
0.0038654206,
-0.09438169,
0.0015768899,
0.0422131829,
-0.0354063511,
0.0206887759,
-0.0158328209,
-0.0703639984,
-0.0633122995,
-0.0450356677,
-0.0148910191,
-0.0409141742,
-0.0101593444,
0.0075137857,
-0.0051738829,
0.0241250694,
0.0031535276,
0.0248880107,
-0.0540188625,
-0.0693633929,
0.0171666387,
-0.0429858305,
0.0012233109,
-0.0112630883,
-0.0234992299,
-0.0443163663,
-0.0338307247,
-0.0314657614,
0.020986408,
0.0454029888,
0.0277856495,
0.0119589735,
-0.0355104692,
-0.0243774429,
-0.015988959,
-0.0310287885,
-0.0350831598,
0.0324257575,
-0.0588159971,
0.0522161573,
0.0287974663,
0.0022312605,
0.0649554506,
0.0275714006,
0.0238723904,
0.0234498139,
-0.0080919415,
-0.0559133142,
0.0240395404,
-0.0225481875,
-0.027641084,
-0.0041702772,
0.0087293526,
0.0053024553,
-0.0158697199,
-0.0164305493,
-0.0241537299,
2.648e-7,
0.0636363551,
0.0855983123,
0.0188709255,
0.0335322544,
0.0104229404,
0.0004534256,
-0.0171735287,
-0.0058866157,
-0.001358138,
0.0159718692,
0.0608170964,
0.0094897365,
0.0429278053,
0.0131274434,
-0.0130214728,
-0.0105587142,
-0.0249109715,
-0.0283091124,
-0.0382278748,
0.0229458511,
0.0643592104,
0.0167574827,
0.0529937297,
0.0385036953,
-0.0012637677,
-0.0433720537,
0.0237638,
-0.0473798364,
0.0109266723,
0.0272129159,
0.0343718864,
-0.0450301394,
-0.0048565893,
0.0908234119,
0.001872334,
-0.0132899601,
-0.0338745974,
0.0380818918,
-0.0191476718,
0.0618332922,
-0.0383175761,
-0.0658899471,
0.0429609418,
0.0087339291,
0.0368582234,
-0.0302047282,
-0.0426911078,
0.0675980896,
-0.0373407304,
-0.0012944351,
0.0188240763,
0.0241557434,
-0.0110397283,
0.0359623246,
0.0012549014,
0.0244873948,
0.0151175121,
-0.0206041802,
-0.0264134668,
0.0525688641,
-0.0218394957,
-0.0667942613,
0.0264644697,
0.0126414439,
0.0365230776,
-0.0287273359,
0.027287107,
2.488299528e-34,
0.0344960168,
0.0514134653,
-0.0108247912,
-0.0180641804,
0.0666139349,
-0.0393581353,
-0.0279481057,
0.0433550254,
0.0472299345,
-0.0824210569,
0.0033685453
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.02358v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.02358v1 | To be or not to be: a translation reception study of a literary text translated into Dutch and Catalan using machine translation | 2023-07-05T15:18:52 | 2023-07-05T15:18:52 | Ana Guerberof Arenas, Antonio Toral | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | This article presents the results of a study involving the reception of a
fictional story by Kurt Vonnegut translated from English into Catalan and Dutch
in three conditions: machine-translated (MT), post-edited (PE) and translated
from scratch (HT). 223 participants were recruited who rated the reading
conditions using three scales: Narrative Engagement, Enjoyment and Translation
Reception. The results show that HT presented a higher engagement, enjoyment
and translation reception in Catalan if compared to PE and MT. However, the
Dutch readers show higher scores in PE than in both HT and MT, and the highest
engagement and enjoyments scores are reported when reading the original English
version. We hypothesize that when reading a fictional story in translation, not
only the condition and the quality of the translations is key to understand its
reception, but also the participants reading patterns, reading language, and,
perhaps language status in their own societies. | [
0.0094614495,
-0.0178216957,
-0.0486623161,
0.034224581,
-0.0577531159,
0.0156756807,
-0.0209069569,
-0.0643614531,
-0.0285483636,
0.0089923656,
-0.0100596743,
0.0303506143,
0.0716069266,
0.0225442965,
-0.0188521557,
-0.007387707,
0.0153407948,
0.0141878678,
-0.0011659857,
-0.0088173039,
0.0150142424,
0.06769678,
0.0328195281,
0.0251639877,
0.0849649236,
-0.0179872047,
-0.0051979781,
0.0169835463,
0.0401115343,
-0.004507571,
-0.0083877034,
-0.0019699342,
0.0293099247,
0.062433701,
0.0000017207,
-0.020194469,
0.0244689304,
-0.0166678987,
0.0569648556,
0.0214072708,
0.1055438146,
-0.0344784856,
-0.0235187802,
-0.0416872092,
0.0232506115,
0.0098970467,
0.020882152,
-0.0021500436,
-0.0112723392,
0.0236027613,
-0.0019002978,
-0.0685332417,
-0.0257558189,
0.0300396159,
0.0172551032,
0.0128554972,
-0.0135752885,
0.017350398,
0.0247977991,
0.0074571711,
-0.0443482511,
0.0405796245,
0.015060409,
-0.0138024651,
-0.0184675734,
0.0002390216,
-0.0016670107,
-0.0385228842,
0.0206392184,
0.0095743937,
0.0432844125,
-0.0263017621,
-0.053158123,
0.0173330419,
-0.011460511,
-0.0308737457,
-0.026209766,
-0.0453456044,
-0.0113827726,
0.0045889327,
0.0106848814,
0.0063991211,
-0.009105918,
0.0020316876,
0.000169141,
-0.0010528878,
-0.0136278486,
0.0161821246,
0.0168483257,
0.0148367854,
-0.0048385342,
-0.0258803163,
0.0080223009,
0.0054730871,
0.0202879831,
0.0176611468,
-0.01967117,
-0.0112080323,
-0.0110003985,
-0.0954508409,
-0.0200291481,
0.0556245074,
-0.0373477563,
0.0147972209,
0.0279095415,
0.02195617,
0.0051144157,
-0.032285437,
-0.0694443583,
-0.0201018844,
0.0137372902,
-0.0014590304,
-0.053811416,
-0.0202536844,
-0.0268039014,
-0.0410723202,
-0.0209446698,
-0.0337869525,
0.1027736738,
0.0085656755,
-0.0733486041,
-0.0036211349,
-0.0430798866,
0.0157397538,
0.009793832,
0.0959850699,
-0.0993861929,
-0.0276534818,
-0.0441763699,
-0.0141863618,
0.0298521742,
-0.0069368752,
-0.0451959632,
-0.0554137379,
0.0136069898,
0.015172842,
-0.0308164116,
-0.0209525246,
-0.0278627463,
-0.0217052028,
-0.0019782598,
-0.0565255061,
-0.0080977008,
-0.0014907891,
0.0279004741,
0.0182906762,
0.0240259133,
-0.0162896141,
0.0027431222,
0.0131329475,
0.0144446772,
0.0142611368,
-0.0058123898,
-0.0197761748,
0.0023025195,
0.0068735918,
-0.0267881155,
0.0279179551,
0.0688129738,
0.0309946816,
0.0178049207,
-0.0402673967,
-0.0141307628,
0.0296638142,
-0.0624589175,
0.0030688667,
-0.0042392132,
0.0144135607,
-0.0112096276,
0.0410431996,
0.0348880179,
0.0128279477,
-0.0276084654,
0.0362874083,
0.0679760426,
0.0213234704,
0.0035624774,
0.0431120619,
-0.0043387273,
0.033863809,
0.0451663285,
0.0615724772,
0.0128881475,
-0.0271419436,
0.0006663122,
0.017274281,
-0.0458941013,
-0.0154658491,
0.0366812907,
-0.0413038768,
0.0552072749,
0.0439331904,
0.1046355963,
-0.0206659995,
0.0143737635,
0.0045168214,
-0.0399567336,
-0.0713529512,
0.0089493822,
-0.027520394,
0.0376460142,
0.0366812013,
-0.0269296411,
0.0628685728,
0.0351008922,
0.0101057105,
0.0622618757,
-0.0205485746,
0.0113737155,
0.0224090833,
0.0232545566,
0.0114404457,
0.0441765077,
-0.0251557343,
0.0423584767,
-0.029661011,
-0.0007138979,
0.0455388986,
-0.077322945,
0.075381428,
-0.0215079226,
-0.0419678278,
-0.0710608289,
-0.0027606217,
-0.0174776651,
-0.0343513563,
-0.0117302993,
-0.0128695741,
-0.0509218276,
0.0228169169,
-0.0280798972,
-0.0322248712,
0.0028739641,
-0.0283182003,
0.0510500409,
0.1151813716,
-0.0205665324,
0.0088214893,
0.0056575034,
-0.0806933418,
0.003512538,
0.008481496,
0.0498466641,
0.0023221336,
0.0297923628,
-0.0476210825,
0.0340300612,
0.0297607593,
0.0178427733,
-0.0631690249,
0.0146783981,
-0.0242901351,
-0.001907867,
0.0228500087,
0.046233993,
-0.0414663553,
-0.0663026571,
0.0498828292,
0.0341257825,
-0.0472450517,
0.0646717474,
0.0192950107,
0.0128323715,
0.0192698594,
-0.0144865606,
-0.0297677107,
-0.0288750287,
-0.0248791557,
0.004429467,
0.0000958334,
0.0215400625,
0.0623074286,
-0.0074739531,
-0.0277793743,
0.0291916952,
0.0159729701,
-0.007790104,
-0.0207607895,
-0.0262652263,
-0.0273264106,
0.0378966965,
0.0229588952,
0.0017281675,
0.0124799712,
0.0237037521,
0.051266104,
0.042956952,
-0.0472654141,
-0.0560162254,
0.011593014,
-0.0279834233,
-0.0669992194,
-0.0247261412,
-0.0430453308,
0.0140439579,
0.029130891,
0.0198068731,
0.0421855897,
0.0123188309,
0.0068858727,
0.0178916063,
-0.0359166302,
-0.0030120355,
-0.0435897298,
0.059038125,
-0.0374382995,
-0.0631682351,
-0.0939962193,
0.0278116502,
-0.0251605064,
0.0183290578,
0.0133557739,
-0.0087740598,
0.003048291,
-0.0457675718,
-0.0580614582,
-0.0059321085,
-0.0209135655,
-0.005084855,
0.0789642558,
-0.0041911644,
-0.0003147778,
0.0398349427,
-0.0127791604,
-0.0214101151,
-0.0742133185,
0.0047429334,
-0.00213823,
0.0534814,
-0.0029674303,
0.0524755158,
0.0034803937,
-0.0415466093,
0.0046211923,
-0.0078367386,
0.0254775081,
-0.0175339393,
0.0228827856,
-0.0072697997,
-0.0539663844,
0.0145569481,
0.0259841736,
-0.0116521111,
-0.0044217031,
-0.0615275875,
-0.0464046858,
0.0366357975,
-0.026182048,
-0.0184283517,
-0.0258065388,
0.0552412868,
-0.0095561231,
0.0191638712,
-0.0301614143,
-0.0185368042,
-0.0049332757,
0.0338726789,
-0.004141198,
0.0315926149,
-0.0481613129,
0.0102902111,
0.023821814,
-0.0700581819,
0.0161117483,
0.0180151481,
-0.0023991931,
0.04520116,
-0.0318689942,
-0.0447248146,
-0.0496304519,
0.023638336,
-0.0809742063,
0.0290511753,
0.0654886439,
0.0013348407,
-0.0351081379,
-0.0034184512,
-0.0789433047,
0.007782192,
0.003387694,
0.035295967,
-0.0798438787,
0.0655254647,
0.022313837,
0.0492497273,
-0.0111214798,
0.0096443193,
-0.0423953384,
-0.0274982285,
0.0198214706,
0.0593082309,
-0.0385193415,
-0.0385466106,
0.0318257399,
-0.0274637584,
0.0310652647,
0.0044865957,
-0.0001908172,
0.0127203781,
-0.0007760966,
-0.0529326014,
0.0477075204,
-0.0021138885,
-0.0012823779,
-0.0078558577,
0.0011926867,
0.0318310261,
0.0529671833,
-0.0306223407,
0.0306892637,
0.0029210623,
-0.0165564623,
-0.0202144627,
-0.0074793054,
0.006185777,
-0.0095671108,
0.0202402193,
-0.0649904311,
0.0165787358,
0.0268863663,
-0.0490544736,
0.0301722661,
0.002303862,
0.0158540774,
-0.0481084511,
0.0114211533,
0.0173892137,
0.0101005463,
0.0106421905,
0.0380205698,
-0.0282824524,
0.0173110142,
-0.058185678,
-0.0046858233,
-0.015025313,
-0.0737996846,
0.0063117919,
-0.0333952643,
-0.0184373204,
-0.0319137163,
-0.1043264195,
-0.0164838582,
0.0412935168,
0.0634058937,
0.0369759612,
0.0007588807,
-0.0337889604,
-0.036461249,
0.0092405872,
0.0235582255,
0.0144084599,
-0.0093155606,
0.0203699246,
-0.023755759,
-0.0804956183,
0.0216214545,
-0.0287906043,
0.0332066193,
-0.0244951732,
0.0346545652,
-0.0297118127,
0.0245451666,
0.0366153456,
-0.0054531619,
-0.0208330546,
-0.0337402038,
-0.0467811115,
-0.0279166419,
0.0567198284,
-0.0040832562,
0.0648972988,
-0.018751055,
-0.0085422089,
0.0628836453,
-0.0146111753,
-0.0147232041,
-0.0047173845,
0.0434755683,
-0.049248293,
0.0066585927,
0.04853075,
-0.0610608608,
-0.0796700567,
0.0125511475,
-0.0458799973,
-0.0588069372,
0.0076559698,
-0.0230924152,
0.0081941653,
-0.0101377433,
0.0410114378,
-0.0259437002,
-0.0352091156,
0.0107948361,
-0.0338954702,
-0.0379435718,
-0.0378447957,
0.0403924547,
0.0296418462,
0.0375195742,
0.0002581008,
0.042462226,
-0.0070957197,
0.0317145549,
0.0046957675,
0.0700311735,
0.0034205313,
0.0202878918,
0.0132649112,
-0.0128949443,
-0.0001483965,
0.0300859753,
0.013486011,
0.0249527674,
0.011709881,
0.0119590294,
0.0346197523,
-0.0217151884,
0.0903679132,
0.0076126982,
0.0080810953,
-0.0051060915,
0.0008002644,
0.02792578,
-0.0123803578,
-0.0682141781,
-0.0016828303,
0.0069689886,
0.0285374671,
0.0085372105,
-0.077684477,
-0.0280208904,
0.0586739928,
-0.017839767,
0.0023478281,
-0.0060767513,
-0.0552929938,
-0.0096310424,
0.0110720098,
-0.0228514876,
-0.0484713614,
-0.0392317437,
0.0212512836,
0.0223503485,
0.0344709605,
-0.0475161895,
-0.0241532382,
0.0726544559,
-0.0187219381,
0.020898344,
-0.0537011586,
0.0872488469,
0.0013286879,
-0.0354910865,
-0.0127001563,
-4.797530768e-33,
0.002441999,
0.0330970995,
-0.0163770877,
0.0085267629,
-0.0943224877,
-0.0378673449,
-0.0333725959,
-0.0002677402,
0.0239738487,
0.0310698338,
0.0149714733,
-0.0091024535,
-0.0008238811,
-0.0722349137,
-0.0066333823,
-0.0020699822,
0.0400440767,
0.0552932769,
-0.070348084,
-0.0377200097,
-0.0122778919,
0.017100051,
0.0661270544,
-0.0433035567,
0.0760403723,
-0.082680434,
-0.0123066017,
-0.0453833677,
0.0731876791,
-0.0154929608,
0.0337736458,
0.0415423661,
-0.0016002697,
0.0197440367,
-0.0166383479,
0.0372732915,
-0.0479246303,
0.0103769377,
0.0798803568,
0.1078822762,
0.0443701409,
-0.0556181036,
0.0273315459,
-0.0327654853,
0.0057161348,
-0.0042611412,
0.025067661,
-0.0431533083,
-0.0055224248,
0.0108543476,
-0.0910248235,
-0.0324859507,
-0.0223585945,
-0.0039279889,
0.0355321951,
0.0840164796,
0.0078803161,
-0.0254277699,
-0.0573247299,
0.0152755566,
-0.0436033532,
0.0200816765,
-0.0114358999,
-0.0512134619,
0.0171215516,
0.0227776375,
0.0440934487,
0.038299825,
-0.016536057,
0.0766110718,
0.0784913152,
-0.0792894959,
0.0181065258,
0.047640156,
-0.0161985327,
-0.0413823873,
0.0096634654,
-0.006859242,
-0.0373640805,
0.0042187362,
0.0250584129,
0.0047680628,
0.0003254241,
-0.0409197547,
-0.0319952518,
-0.032957498,
0.0114120543,
-0.0528847873,
-0.0415379182,
-0.0467042066,
-0.0214526411,
-0.0613019988,
0.0630399585,
-0.0601490773,
0.0165669862,
-0.0364263877,
-0.0589599423,
0.079421401,
0.0023809201,
0.0459547937,
0.0652667731,
0.035061419,
-0.0439427048,
0.0207290277,
0.0415172502,
-0.0249319673,
-0.0118740378,
0.0016118748,
-0.0020794244,
-0.0093831001,
-0.0091711096,
-0.0007711176,
0.0214555245,
0.0619496182,
0.0244073272,
0.0102277566,
0.0106784264,
-0.0409117565,
0.0283094645,
-0.0057142596,
-0.0464304015,
0.0197395049,
-0.0084165167,
0.0404806696,
-0.063072212,
0.0357638597,
-0.0052235639,
0.0291618239,
0.0127655435,
-0.0350386687,
-0.0367313921,
-0.0469714068,
2.577e-7,
0.0410238393,
0.0162522011,
-0.0139281591,
0.0292462967,
-0.0007995149,
0.0065217642,
-0.0166213084,
0.0242634211,
0.0259969402,
-0.0094855875,
0.0260696355,
0.006464533,
0.0140220281,
0.089678295,
-0.0645252466,
-0.0191488974,
-0.0060316632,
0.0582403429,
-0.0321482271,
0.0342494957,
0.0451403372,
-0.0036160534,
-0.0146975033,
-0.0040816306,
0.0307249166,
-0.0128200194,
0.0112404358,
-0.0127838897,
-0.0378362462,
0.0036589808,
0.0082936501,
0.0286983885,
-0.0067515164,
-0.0222882945,
0.0270682257,
-0.0216928143,
0.0521153547,
0.034888126,
0.0174301844,
0.0102724219,
0.0273482259,
-0.0001601924,
-0.0381025039,
-0.0295587573,
0.021205239,
0.0126148192,
-0.0211673062,
0.0425187871,
-0.0199190639,
-0.0325544626,
0.0669469535,
0.0046028262,
-0.0627070293,
0.0450909548,
0.0635878518,
-0.0040424247,
-0.0038445357,
0.0029652864,
-0.0197032429,
0.0293161534,
-0.0079057375,
-0.0123709086,
0.0138814822,
0.0169986375,
-0.0524024554,
-0.0426897258,
0.0093541536,
1.612561632e-34,
0.0562172718,
-0.0351159237,
0.0068673254,
-0.0063778358,
0.0331956446,
0.0215364695,
0.0236783605,
-0.0208237413,
0.0129203349,
0.0214205701,
-0.0354423746
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.02340v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.02340v1 | MuLMS-AZ: An Argumentative Zoning Dataset for the Materials Science Domain | 2023-07-05T14:55:18 | 2023-07-05T14:55:18 | Timo Pierre Schrader, Teresa Bürkle, Sophie Henning, Sherry Tan, Matteo Finco, Stefan Grünewald, Maira Indrikova, Felix Hildebrand, Annemarie Friedrich | cs.CL | cs.CL | Scientific publications follow conventionalized rhetorical structures.
Classifying the Argumentative Zone (AZ), e.g., identifying whether a sentence
states a Motivation, a Result or Background information, has been proposed to
improve processing of scholarly documents. In this work, we adapt and extend
this idea to the domain of materials science research. We present and release a
new dataset of 50 manually annotated research articles. The dataset spans seven
sub-topics and is annotated with a materials-science focused multi-label
annotation scheme for AZ. We detail corpus statistics and demonstrate high
inter-annotator agreement. Our computational experiments show that using
domain-specific pre-trained transformer-based text encoders is key to high
classification performance. We also find that AZ categories from existing
datasets in other domains are transferable to varying degrees. | [
-0.0057885605,
0.0675053149,
0.0119905556,
0.0404038206,
-0.0169485342,
0.0001714552,
0.0692174509,
0.0113201337,
-0.0290513653,
-0.0444135778,
-0.0291471649,
0.0455145389,
-0.0201759003,
-0.0305182859,
-0.0270063132,
-0.0224795882,
-0.0086612534,
0.0001184958,
0.0948913023,
0.0052590305,
0.0041070045,
-0.0256069954,
-0.027030047,
0.0347784944,
0.0160163045,
-0.0288001727,
0.0158478413,
-0.0153002227,
0.0389287397,
-0.0348727778,
0.0472639874,
0.057054393,
0.0233087149,
0.0127367657,
0.0000020399,
-0.041429583,
-0.013413405,
0.0251039695,
0.0185255837,
0.0153884217,
0.0726610646,
-0.0308903195,
-0.0048824861,
0.0241204128,
-0.0059159952,
-0.0152423941,
0.033114884,
0.0853286237,
0.0038833602,
0.0277814567,
-0.032858111,
-0.0377130806,
0.0412070267,
-0.0090837516,
-0.0065549701,
0.0088441307,
0.0372559391,
0.0253289212,
0.0070402725,
0.046270635,
0.0091150347,
0.0424396507,
-0.0092702135,
-0.0286664292,
0.0131384321,
0.0116321091,
-0.0242206883,
0.0031611284,
0.0213723835,
0.040020328,
0.0232833084,
-0.0492926836,
-0.0135045443,
-0.0472168922,
-0.0290356614,
0.0269724037,
-0.0277713072,
0.0384409651,
-0.0065635848,
0.0011993261,
0.0517978817,
0.0576222427,
-0.0005330039,
-0.0005653442,
-0.0046846159,
0.0367964841,
-0.0304973405,
-0.0522731915,
0.0078078429,
0.0360780172,
0.0303583574,
-0.0319798402,
0.0028963655,
-0.0009857696,
0.0464107953,
0.0095493393,
0.000057961,
-0.0410403274,
0.0435319394,
-0.0535588376,
0.0021909378,
0.0113664642,
-0.0116357775,
0.0290764123,
-0.013142637,
-0.0298947934,
-0.0017339127,
0.0421023294,
-0.0109538203,
-0.0201721657,
-0.0349264592,
-0.0444734544,
-0.0509278849,
-0.0198188536,
-0.0123592112,
-0.0263378434,
-0.0139886905,
-0.0264309924,
-0.0118608866,
-0.0189876631,
-0.0103912614,
0.0060960394,
-0.0043902663,
-0.0205066651,
-0.0043311189,
0.048475273,
-0.0120665254,
0.0586509109,
-0.0070774909,
-0.032749746,
-0.0339430384,
0.0128339995,
0.0131603219,
-0.0123235257,
-0.0142150177,
0.0555911623,
-0.0250922013,
-0.0451608114,
-0.0187356062,
-0.0311698895,
-0.0141186444,
-0.0116532808,
0.0348400325,
-0.0264660958,
0.0310438741,
0.0165574048,
0.0270161554,
-0.0840324759,
0.0001239571,
-0.0159554482,
0.0011102812,
0.0534590781,
0.0044673914,
-0.0858295783,
0.0700537264,
0.013439496,
0.0250820909,
0.0237472523,
0.0411315188,
0.023725722,
0.0254231635,
-0.0165768396,
-0.0029668806,
-0.0185263995,
0.014898804,
-0.0252383854,
0.0486582145,
-0.0477906764,
-0.0388369076,
0.0337855369,
-0.0297397133,
-0.0119716376,
-0.0363785774,
-0.0200588796,
0.0008419044,
0.0406319089,
0.0148201548,
0.0106584663,
-0.032706771,
0.0317444019,
0.0251457207,
-0.0417290032,
0.0479930192,
0.0362626761,
0.0200015269,
-0.0302731562,
0.0549546517,
-0.021270074,
-0.0014395227,
-0.0767441764,
-0.0282111075,
-0.0052272808,
0.0123275258,
-0.0449992418,
0.0683563128,
0.0308032446,
-0.0405546725,
0.009314361,
0.0380155109,
-0.0476239845,
-0.0340948179,
0.0244751312,
0.0222918373,
-0.0270530749,
0.0125359697,
-0.0530537069,
-0.0344618261,
-0.035748072,
0.0403204784,
0.0568053164,
0.0008867629,
-0.0077760178,
0.0165972337,
-0.0443617254,
-0.0508417711,
-0.0665552169,
0.0050246492,
-0.0126866233,
-0.0246705059,
-0.0250903517,
-0.0071978914,
-0.0111582652,
-0.0431143753,
0.0446803384,
-0.003738452,
0.005819554,
0.014495926,
-0.0066611976,
0.0652403235,
0.0174976625,
-0.0157151651,
-0.0020177669,
0.0665666163,
-0.0613975562,
-0.02334309,
0.0057149758,
0.0060710884,
0.0085679283,
0.0197581779,
-0.0848860815,
0.0242466703,
-0.0550943501,
-0.0127944099,
-0.0108105512,
0.0164681878,
0.0058098165,
0.0092925932,
0.0056043188,
-0.0315207466,
-0.0016632143,
0.0408325084,
-0.0618534014,
0.0341565013,
0.0376251116,
0.0290700626,
-0.0151114156,
-0.0395558812,
0.0508703999,
0.0071095061,
-0.0058632405,
-0.0148521792,
0.0115290182,
-0.0070138802,
0.0571101643,
-0.0553933382,
-0.0133997286,
-0.0274729375,
-0.0350254178,
-0.0204331242,
-0.0098986747,
0.0079192193,
0.0198827032,
-0.0549798161,
0.0214171764,
0.0076593524,
0.0294677336,
-0.0535093844,
-0.0459540263,
-0.0245526135,
0.0695727766,
-0.0302163921,
0.0477689132,
-0.0075271735,
-0.0228570718,
-0.0389927439,
0.0608941652,
0.0417860523,
-0.0071732299,
-0.0330212861,
0.0093108034,
0.0344316661,
-0.0052205394,
-0.0311518293,
-0.0234073587,
0.0445401035,
0.0260667168,
0.0177278649,
0.0369933806,
0.0521724224,
0.0812163725,
0.0256935898,
0.0197155252,
-0.0409015454,
-0.0299194176,
-0.0286082197,
0.0495213196,
-0.0030048941,
0.0106073227,
0.0477372855,
0.0711999536,
-0.0300813355,
0.0217264816,
-0.012712867,
0.0306593366,
0.006899063,
-0.0310181435,
0.0434982181,
-0.0028844178,
0.0227408018,
0.0517572127,
0.0296369847,
0.0397411883,
0.0639897138,
-0.0486121736,
-0.0099786175,
-0.0598778836,
-0.0043613478,
-0.0150172841,
0.0030184139,
0.0026884582,
0.0194777679,
0.0856168866,
0.0036459945,
0.0203801747,
-0.0299692843,
0.0199865885,
-0.0055164951,
-0.0085765868,
-0.0164874811,
0.0274168346,
-0.0077888053,
-0.0433591492,
-0.0047207465,
0.0003365577,
-0.0094954791,
0.0258055851,
0.0102230767,
-0.0317673013,
-0.0483042896,
0.0204884931,
0.0392416418,
0.0362564251,
-0.0113155227,
0.0000197076,
-0.034435086,
0.059361618,
0.0185247287,
0.0085784802,
0.0057856725,
0.0030802391,
-0.0160328541,
0.0810329169,
-0.0735326409,
-0.0118616,
-0.0583339036,
-0.0411136672,
0.0303778201,
-0.0377698727,
0.0259477105,
-0.0524557419,
0.0150704859,
-0.030176593,
0.0018842883,
0.0594898984,
0.0229833107,
-0.0293884277,
-0.0150235957,
-0.0024601158,
0.0388034284,
-0.0035998614,
-0.0043745828,
-0.114352718,
-0.0155596128,
-0.0312999189,
0.0040301741,
-0.0214335956,
-0.0269902721,
-0.0004338658,
-0.0680914894,
0.0430468954,
-0.0201438032,
-0.0354565941,
-0.0115547311,
-0.0515540205,
-0.0222030096,
-0.023073798,
-0.0413829349,
0.008717658,
0.0089530582,
-0.0103169903,
0.051223401,
-0.0309551936,
-0.0587926172,
-0.00402543,
0.0071680844,
0.0052549685,
-0.0327531807,
0.0423493609,
-0.0372177325,
-0.0325128026,
0.0249767266,
-0.035585165,
-0.0306893159,
-0.0187921524,
0.0549224243,
-0.0043141521,
-0.0030456365,
0.0258593839,
0.0614863038,
-0.0535614043,
-0.0696043894,
0.0199874453,
0.0491894856,
-0.03328491,
0.0296038203,
-0.0442708284,
-0.0040436359,
-0.0051115071,
0.0249859318,
0.0011723549,
-0.0306833144,
-0.0920595676,
-0.0516102836,
0.0248765834,
-0.0610795245,
-0.0178298466,
-0.0329716355,
-0.0207620487,
0.0176059548,
-0.0453956388,
-0.0400296338,
-0.028130509,
0.0439937562,
-0.0171604156,
-0.0252880584,
0.0285943337,
0.0015742084,
-0.0828970969,
0.0092759682,
-0.0137366019,
-0.0169297308,
0.0103953723,
-0.0237950422,
0.0642599538,
-0.0262815468,
-0.0487214215,
0.020369336,
0.0128260935,
-0.0613403507,
-0.0016612078,
0.0011782654,
0.0143871224,
0.0490594469,
-0.0127722966,
-0.0463440418,
0.0805233717,
0.0208607335,
-0.0168216936,
-0.0180781726,
0.0348698236,
-0.0330676101,
-0.0168784149,
-0.0536874793,
0.0257070903,
0.0726287887,
-0.017184997,
-0.0378937162,
-0.0707268566,
-0.0376540385,
0.0171733629,
-0.0154511165,
0.0926386788,
0.0179380719,
-0.013030584,
-0.0267559625,
0.0296182036,
-0.0113883866,
0.0046517132,
-0.0223846566,
0.0114063397,
0.0115778549,
-0.0691445768,
-0.0438146926,
0.0390588418,
-0.0108772237,
0.0647118241,
0.0355834924,
0.0639489293,
0.017762566,
0.0405256413,
0.0023127613,
0.0203920528,
-0.0338174477,
0.0173736308,
-0.0032585612,
0.0709510893,
-0.0125385411,
0.0195354,
0.0484193861,
0.0548574217,
0.0174236335,
0.0240866374,
-0.0833898038,
-0.0130482512,
-0.0575292259,
-0.0377946459,
-0.0128708426,
0.0067184353,
0.0820991248,
-0.0158235505,
-0.0232258104,
-0.0091115832,
0.0675590262,
-0.0119881788,
0.0127974199,
0.0293316226,
0.0033210698,
-0.0204566661,
-0.0197250992,
0.0237832442,
0.022281656,
-0.0239741933,
0.0060769324,
-0.0150132002,
-0.0377683491,
-0.0480900407,
-0.0287035871,
-0.0025905385,
0.0348141901,
-0.0531827547,
-0.0161394142,
0.0280072056,
0.0244668908,
0.0350077823,
0.0025215459,
-0.0218612012,
0.0196859352,
0.0492832549,
-0.0258654151,
-0.0333183371,
-0.0475739948,
0.0036380028,
-0.0107985828,
-0.0365134627,
0.0010683374,
-6.444164356e-33,
-0.0042811702,
-0.0167100374,
-0.0101030385,
0.0465335175,
0.0096414844,
-0.0154895857,
-0.043920666,
-0.0207535122,
-0.0104113761,
0.0603885986,
-0.0068124435,
0.0196713787,
0.0215436686,
0.0242252648,
0.0346796624,
0.0117391255,
0.0357809998,
0.0207332801,
-0.0241688285,
0.0287638083,
0.062118385,
-0.0032873715,
0.0611449108,
-0.1142309234,
0.0440462008,
0.0231052674,
0.0149231572,
-0.0609363355,
-0.0011877908,
0.0501478687,
-0.0283658821,
0.0426567495,
-0.0020969326,
-0.0578928143,
0.0124247018,
0.0043520075,
-0.0839945078,
-0.0113246562,
-0.0187776107,
0.0093373265,
0.006235932,
-0.0204832796,
0.0265396014,
0.0274289828,
-0.045758836,
-0.0471160747,
0.0734093636,
-0.014998165,
0.015690919,
-0.0790386945,
-0.0931561068,
0.0045370124,
-0.0224627368,
0.035484083,
0.0436839014,
0.0437945388,
0.0085771307,
0.1267749369,
-0.0919369906,
0.0428952537,
-0.0099812951,
0.028214002,
-0.0069894949,
-0.0325093158,
-0.0160441417,
0.0322453342,
-0.0205188226,
0.0370245129,
0.0342245139,
0.0353320204,
-0.0069352151,
0.0406524651,
0.0608071722,
0.0560841598,
0.0659767389,
0.0020837334,
-0.1161280423,
-0.0249607638,
-0.005668263,
0.0290766172,
0.0455621295,
0.015074579,
0.0559355393,
-0.015786944,
-0.0223192293,
-0.0321146175,
0.010140826,
-0.0121057648,
-0.0360989198,
-0.0084373103,
-0.0364303514,
0.0485892557,
0.0184284206,
-0.0375800952,
-0.0156156793,
0.0627835542,
-0.0089862151,
0.0599095821,
-0.0043632202,
-0.0171281248,
-0.0741181001,
-0.0297483616,
-0.0021073956,
0.0351681672,
0.0593503043,
-0.0390836112,
0.0315980576,
-0.0200929176,
-0.0459292866,
0.0002965563,
-0.0178859085,
-0.0108600697,
-0.012911302,
0.0576059893,
-0.0201444179,
0.0338392928,
0.007659669,
0.0488122404,
-0.011454721,
0.0218887683,
0.0122102918,
-0.0041537303,
-0.0079737119,
0.0366543159,
0.0000958153,
-0.0329388194,
0.004395755,
0.0212828889,
0.0305454545,
-0.0794157609,
0.0343237594,
-0.0178733431,
2.781e-7,
0.0785517693,
0.0599501394,
0.0650663003,
-0.0511426106,
0.0191570725,
0.0336405933,
0.0001566452,
0.0282659456,
0.0156939104,
0.0048476323,
0.015601512,
-0.0050805821,
0.0332330279,
0.0229751151,
-0.0809583142,
-0.0874466226,
-0.0402262956,
-0.032548897,
-0.0250996202,
0.0306773484,
0.0745457113,
0.0395132229,
-0.0359602943,
-0.0026525881,
-0.0133010158,
0.0010884894,
0.078367278,
-0.0243946332,
0.0297806617,
0.0675736666,
0.0188220609,
-0.0796892643,
-0.0100820344,
0.0239356086,
-0.0366512425,
-0.0115776658,
-0.0075190673,
0.0373636931,
0.0394496471,
-0.0549903698,
-0.007342075,
0.0196745005,
0.0301344469,
-0.0067520528,
0.0038680623,
-0.090470545,
-0.0413301922,
-0.0259254482,
-0.0482557639,
0.0088208644,
0.0357566141,
0.0154177155,
0.01428496,
-0.0286055505,
-0.0107976366,
0.0354654416,
-0.0001958711,
-0.0922638997,
-0.0230745301,
0.0378867052,
-0.0341257118,
-0.0061891228,
0.0015116928,
-0.0508800298,
0.0464525819,
-0.0225685425,
-0.0125718471,
2.292743416e-34,
0.0549497902,
-0.0149778361,
0.0132582821,
0.0443027206,
0.009305926,
0.0060474006,
0.0181891564,
0.0016304349,
-0.0099578546,
-0.0420690328,
0.03389965
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.02313v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.02313v2 | Utilizing ChatGPT Generated Data to Retrieve Depression Symptoms from Social Media | 2023-07-05T14:15:15 | 2023-07-06T11:08:51 | Ana-Maria Bucur | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this work, we present the contribution of the BLUE team in the eRisk Lab
task on searching for symptoms of depression. The task consists of retrieving
and ranking Reddit social media sentences that convey symptoms of depression
from the BDI-II questionnaire. Given that synthetic data provided by LLMs have
been proven to be a reliable method for augmenting data and fine-tuning
downstream models, we chose to generate synthetic data using ChatGPT for each
of the symptoms of the BDI-II questionnaire. We designed a prompt such that the
generated data contains more richness and semantic diversity than the BDI-II
responses for each question and, at the same time, contains emotional and
anecdotal experiences that are specific to the more intimate way of sharing
experiences on Reddit. We perform semantic search and rank the sentences'
relevance to the BDI-II symptoms by cosine similarity. We used two
state-of-the-art transformer-based models (MentalRoBERTa and a variant of
MPNet) for embedding the social media posts, the original and generated
responses of the BDI-II. Our results show that using sentence embeddings from a
model designed for semantic search outperforms the approach using embeddings
from a model pre-trained on mental health data. Furthermore, the generated
synthetic data were proved too specific for this task, the approach simply
relying on the BDI-II responses had the best performance. | [
0.0583352298,
0.0537168309,
-0.0311267171,
0.0063769859,
-0.0219814684,
0.0158669762,
0.0032356845,
0.0177274439,
0.0739164501,
-0.0372635014,
-0.0043805819,
0.0035494734,
-0.0612433068,
0.0087438459,
-0.0090372432,
-0.0331762731,
0.0137430495,
0.0874445811,
0.0166586097,
0.0098012919,
0.0135246357,
0.0263054725,
-0.0070786877,
0.0528689437,
-0.0527960435,
-0.0060644718,
0.0265093464,
0.0429115221,
0.0545347072,
-0.0377200358,
0.0325916,
0.0514423102,
0.0119218165,
0.0178197213,
0.0000019291,
-0.0045299451,
-0.0276320875,
-0.0060777236,
-0.0067063528,
-0.0620601662,
0.068819873,
-0.0060318401,
0.0338703245,
0.0438776724,
-0.0560142398,
-0.0306993537,
0.0510104485,
0.0887738094,
0.0809843168,
0.0902569145,
-0.0401357226,
-0.0104530286,
0.0098310541,
-0.0107350815,
0.0346275643,
0.0333406776,
0.0317417718,
0.0216670986,
0.0504092462,
0.0179795865,
-0.0092209624,
0.0294406582,
-0.0130855488,
0.0352148004,
-0.0005804584,
0.0189838298,
-0.0078552105,
-0.0335728824,
0.0000829018,
0.0818833038,
-0.0019284964,
0.0031194934,
0.0195187069,
0.0058723968,
0.0070366175,
0.0053035831,
-0.041804079,
-0.0158503726,
-0.001319819,
0.0412719473,
-0.0051871696,
0.0187007599,
0.0055325548,
-0.0253114235,
0.0159386601,
0.0220539756,
-0.003687087,
-0.0494904928,
0.004100956,
-0.0010411704,
-0.0503157526,
-0.014026233,
0.030106457,
-0.0110585755,
-0.0007386172,
0.0230041519,
-0.0225864705,
-0.0558260754,
0.0089581003,
-0.0087889601,
-0.0120291552,
0.0526561439,
-0.0459019653,
-0.0064906911,
0.0109382393,
0.0293589924,
-0.0162741393,
0.0347803161,
-0.0572216511,
-0.0351576991,
-0.09095826,
-0.0106014088,
-0.0726948008,
0.0305980667,
-0.0183321927,
-0.0495850705,
-0.0564926453,
0.0255645141,
0.01447553,
-0.0432856604,
0.0200080685,
0.0130262719,
0.0002173249,
0.0523507521,
0.0124494331,
0.0249051768,
-0.0119755752,
-0.0053198128,
0.0350230001,
-0.0609994493,
0.032409668,
-0.0195005126,
0.0302519165,
-0.0366134271,
0.0009635298,
0.0436828136,
0.0361083299,
-0.0397076309,
-0.0182565916,
-0.0272052642,
-0.0126676029,
-0.0144088557,
0.0123469848,
-0.0145495459,
0.0626175031,
0.0221492071,
-0.0045691216,
-0.0196006335,
0.019757282,
0.0251838639,
-0.0448643416,
0.0839226097,
-0.0348962434,
0.0208962597,
0.0082145948,
0.0306229685,
0.0098338863,
0.0732767954,
0.0124215307,
0.0506933965,
0.0746008605,
-0.0340212807,
0.006460933,
-0.0033563836,
-0.0017509119,
-0.0433198996,
0.0138381869,
-0.0013514283,
-0.0277208891,
0.0520616733,
-0.0169642624,
0.0356589705,
-0.0308227316,
0.0050175479,
0.0406883843,
0.0793895647,
0.0472487733,
0.0308476463,
0.0065852455,
0.0403361879,
-0.0220992044,
0.0088545829,
-0.0274779424,
0.0349186547,
-0.0147628244,
-0.0319111757,
0.0273804441,
0.0224200319,
-0.0162070449,
-0.0477186628,
-0.0414660387,
-0.02083675,
-0.0095794639,
0.0048554554,
-0.0265233014,
-0.014329196,
-0.0211603679,
0.0812299028,
0.0369102061,
-0.0569765754,
-0.0548987798,
-0.0391522534,
0.0108050369,
0.0639802963,
0.0206024237,
-0.067244269,
-0.0252590794,
-0.002763618,
0.0183139145,
0.0393720604,
0.0385725535,
0.0166426189,
-0.0065362444,
-0.0455351323,
-0.0087961489,
0.0166693665,
0.0053481292,
-0.0265956521,
-0.0124617862,
0.0232908577,
-0.0101065179,
-0.0128329378,
0.0141349919,
0.0287187174,
0.01183894,
0.0155739216,
0.0128668286,
-0.0019540023,
0.0235884357,
0.010846179,
0.0020248874,
0.0185668003,
0.0297846943,
-0.0373539887,
-0.0894457847,
-0.007331023,
-0.0092080301,
-0.0692455098,
0.0093806302,
-0.0520657413,
0.0206551049,
0.1027847305,
-0.0696408674,
-0.0136263324,
0.0446807854,
-0.0456104428,
0.0417946167,
-0.0142142642,
-0.0484871529,
0.0032801242,
0.0469500758,
-0.0393970348,
0.0406583361,
-0.0268619228,
0.0278503057,
-0.0347788185,
-0.0633718297,
-0.0179297552,
-0.0296284314,
-0.0476850756,
-0.0055089998,
-0.0127186133,
0.0201480761,
-0.0069929804,
-0.0104924329,
-0.0455913767,
-0.0461000726,
-0.1414873004,
0.032402765,
-0.0200005285,
0.0025890728,
0.0336231403,
0.0258721244,
-0.0215743091,
-0.0321391709,
-0.0466148257,
0.0416892841,
0.0390374139,
0.0346067399,
0.0364704467,
0.0018158633,
0.0097306138,
-0.0773680061,
-0.0373000242,
-0.0291465539,
0.0290599093,
-0.0196574703,
-0.038721621,
-0.0321884379,
-0.0052271578,
-0.0729688108,
0.0036226923,
-0.0103546903,
-0.0439066216,
0.0105903875,
-0.0124010742,
0.0625489056,
0.0260271281,
0.0296062697,
0.0691767335,
-0.0087213768,
0.0296520945,
-0.042271208,
0.0253710635,
-0.0529996827,
-0.0060705319,
-0.0227864608,
-0.0480119586,
0.0225544777,
0.027605921,
0.0327751823,
-0.0132634407,
-0.0587896109,
0.0262946393,
-0.0061545586,
0.0125577236,
-0.0160299726,
0.0169680454,
0.0166622959,
0.0007470808,
-0.0232713688,
-0.0458317101,
0.0355198719,
0.0098038325,
-0.0189396683,
-0.0393758491,
-0.0481865853,
-0.0490415804,
0.0379430465,
0.0304782726,
0.0173412152,
0.0022592843,
0.011334464,
-0.0143337874,
0.0001239185,
0.0039529959,
-0.0536278673,
0.0139016956,
0.049226623,
-0.0022550179,
0.0194866396,
-0.0298573021,
-0.0451563932,
-0.0801853761,
-0.0476529151,
-0.0135883549,
-0.0060996516,
0.0038178952,
-0.0352330357,
-0.0338453427,
-0.0038190302,
0.0037729396,
-0.0049197366,
-0.032793276,
0.0086843539,
0.0435643792,
0.0647779778,
0.0104670161,
0.0473134741,
0.0225435682,
0.038075231,
0.0439933911,
-0.0445620306,
0.0009148655,
-0.0058823163,
-0.0003480488,
-0.0240426324,
-0.0028658819,
-0.0079256035,
-0.0343920887,
0.0119663337,
0.0072832867,
-0.0116358884,
0.1081051901,
0.0085164197,
-0.0035713606,
0.0244200975,
-0.042323824,
-0.0073715248,
0.0181554984,
0.010476389,
-0.0593119077,
-0.0435336754,
-0.0409534797,
0.0026600475,
-0.0225959811,
-0.0192588829,
-0.0021060351,
-0.0547629818,
0.0500365123,
-0.0342980772,
0.0156893432,
0.0176879354,
-0.0126532689,
0.0053431061,
-0.0116425166,
-0.0103014382,
-0.0514507666,
-0.0089227129,
-0.0023957069,
0.0051892684,
-0.0347583964,
-0.0584952943,
0.0038325987,
-0.004547982,
0.0447722785,
0.002365665,
0.0693400055,
0.0204931516,
-0.0316811763,
-0.0003754531,
0.0250765812,
-0.0020500282,
-0.0049964255,
0.0992203802,
-0.0044552153,
-0.0039557242,
-0.067772828,
0.0435698815,
-0.0581520423,
-0.0168512668,
-0.0292597413,
0.0986403152,
-0.0277213715,
-0.0214651059,
-0.0484724864,
0.0412728004,
0.0398395285,
0.0677280203,
0.0405552574,
-0.0284017883,
-0.0030946319,
0.0243363678,
0.0216662195,
0.0014619683,
-0.0621967837,
-0.0003718674,
0.0043398514,
0.0099097034,
-0.0925337523,
-0.0465616621,
0.0127618033,
-0.0217620786,
-0.0500767678,
-0.0462212823,
-0.025133932,
-0.0059162849,
-0.082211718,
0.0403071642,
0.0016757112,
-0.006297722,
0.0127733108,
0.0140247373,
0.0393077657,
-0.0089401789,
-0.0184352882,
-0.0217440892,
-0.0827147588,
-0.0308731962,
0.0098551344,
-0.0126072885,
0.0151724136,
-0.022050377,
0.0006019998,
-0.0327220447,
0.0517988354,
0.056593962,
-0.0310563091,
-0.0241010282,
0.0167891625,
0.0292660054,
0.004592116,
0.0439037271,
-0.0126098888,
0.0472108908,
0.0154930362,
-0.0084876372,
0.0242922418,
-0.0163680166,
0.014546114,
0.0342414416,
0.0498146527,
0.0144706191,
-0.0232292246,
-0.0408089794,
-0.0416671149,
-0.0273008458,
0.0010396771,
-0.0611721203,
-0.021600211,
0.0152888894,
0.0179338176,
-0.0434748158,
-0.0420156308,
-0.0310356487,
0.0226824544,
-0.0719185397,
-0.0025237601,
-0.0097627938,
0.0007184625,
0.0042971144,
0.0252883844,
-0.0124387247,
0.0213771481,
0.0086960355,
-0.0099977655,
-0.0428280346,
0.0603115372,
0.0026713191,
-0.0021752105,
0.0354801789,
0.0757103413,
-0.0613195859,
-0.0643415898,
-0.0258725472,
0.0116374232,
0.0559879206,
-0.004630561,
0.0641258508,
-0.0226233862,
-0.0107767759,
0.0119565986,
0.0053499662,
-0.0299780853,
-0.021061996,
0.0376360714,
-0.0069673201,
-0.0297199208,
-0.0270957295,
0.0540559553,
-0.042617064,
0.0219718516,
0.0154595822,
-0.048061192,
-0.0282163192,
0.0030698455,
0.042031046,
0.0049635852,
-0.007682072,
-0.0111568924,
-0.0219299421,
-0.0577038415,
0.043589659,
-0.020917872,
-0.0440060534,
-0.0060147881,
0.0276815221,
0.0355867371,
0.012942669,
0.0085459743,
-0.0300797857,
0.0209633857,
-0.0711561963,
-0.0564341024,
-0.022648992,
-6.033559771e-33,
0.0108429296,
0.0000926672,
-0.0120501136,
0.0144835468,
-0.0487401672,
0.0484772585,
-0.0120194806,
0.006293972,
0.0118447645,
0.0420089029,
-0.0021421053,
0.0420781635,
0.0007074657,
0.0469046347,
-0.0241599418,
-0.0276799612,
0.0282790754,
-0.0154841486,
-0.0034298564,
0.028142307,
0.0336617641,
0.0611082353,
0.0414951071,
-0.0500585064,
-0.0374856517,
0.0016145532,
0.0080697872,
0.0365983285,
0.0454218015,
0.0682714507,
-0.0279676802,
0.0975865424,
0.0547246151,
-0.0210474227,
-0.0022114101,
0.0509533919,
-0.0678436384,
-0.0454268046,
-0.0293663256,
-0.0164379291,
-0.0487642288,
0.0091899475,
0.0363387354,
-0.0501570888,
0.0256582182,
-0.0406935588,
0.0409306847,
-0.0044827145,
0.0420578271,
-0.0247650314,
-0.0154171987,
-0.0008411771,
0.0110757584,
0.0004310863,
-0.0275034849,
0.0757305697,
-0.0032811533,
0.0417360775,
-0.028979037,
-0.0012712772,
-0.0529865138,
0.0047341459,
0.0163111836,
-0.0513122492,
0.0003661975,
0.0693990886,
0.0069868462,
-0.0226565618,
-0.0276656952,
0.0026041458,
-0.0025645299,
0.0416844748,
0.069661364,
0.0492421426,
0.0381614417,
-0.0493292473,
-0.0493083522,
0.0092970543,
0.0047360654,
-0.0120910071,
0.0443755277,
0.007829532,
-0.0162335988,
0.0000617477,
0.0032090559,
0.0222889669,
-0.0337572396,
-0.0540484004,
0.0425725803,
0.0070946603,
-0.0111443335,
-0.0179409012,
0.0087740654,
-0.0532225147,
0.0057609905,
0.0067714471,
-0.0261370484,
0.0316710621,
0.005624291,
0.0033775966,
-0.0097023128,
0.007456921,
0.0436192155,
0.0171041004,
0.0394856967,
0.0045514931,
0.0303126555,
-0.0098757641,
-0.0437336303,
-0.0034922387,
-0.0067679244,
0.0322735608,
-0.0471578985,
0.0232892483,
-0.0304594953,
0.0348758064,
-0.0260458067,
0.024651302,
0.0475012027,
0.0485159457,
-0.0504818968,
-0.0377162807,
0.0141378287,
-0.0026405274,
-0.0023664536,
-0.0022247587,
-0.0309174526,
-0.0095974738,
0.027947614,
-0.0581666417,
-0.0016943419,
-0.0062421872,
2.718e-7,
0.0410383344,
0.0422082283,
0.0042247288,
-0.0288746189,
0.0292056035,
-0.0018272573,
0.0259773061,
0.0569642819,
0.0366691612,
-0.0291683227,
0.0330573954,
0.0347025245,
0.0374593958,
0.0482280515,
-0.0617089085,
-0.0412009209,
-0.0330183432,
-0.0749349743,
-0.0478360914,
-0.0070906305,
0.1258226037,
0.1053572819,
0.0151129989,
-0.0148160802,
-0.0085332775,
-0.0021925101,
0.0506073907,
-0.0377150215,
-0.0081342813,
0.0185248498,
0.0562776178,
0.0132950116,
0.0232225209,
-0.0225359108,
0.002609364,
-0.0182981417,
0.0440787449,
0.0035723087,
0.0108445035,
-0.0481581539,
-0.0002030513,
0.0060447617,
-0.0224985983,
-0.0156710725,
0.0538877659,
-0.1212315261,
-0.0353759006,
-0.0358965732,
-0.0139316376,
-0.0191466771,
0.066248253,
-0.0224062484,
-0.040622931,
0.0365812071,
0.0417209752,
0.0295773614,
0.0024569959,
-0.0955427885,
-0.0077798944,
0.029130334,
-0.0796762556,
-0.0136615457,
-0.0218886286,
-0.0153035996,
0.0179964416,
-0.0243123118,
0.0044281473,
2.342093745e-34,
-0.0037566465,
0.043449115,
0.0350693986,
-0.0213450231,
0.0140915066,
0.0194190834,
0.0208222549,
-0.0162482169,
-0.0078331726,
-0.1084992215,
0.0064959545
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.02301v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.02301v1 | Sumformer: Universal Approximation for Efficient Transformers | 2023-07-05T13:59:35 | 2023-07-05T13:59:35 | Silas Alberti, Niclas Dern, Laura Thesing, Gitta Kutyniok | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML | Natural language processing (NLP) made an impressive jump with the
introduction of Transformers. ChatGPT is one of the most famous examples,
changing the perception of the possibilities of AI even outside the research
community. However, besides the impressive performance, the quadratic time and
space complexity of Transformers with respect to sequence length pose
significant limitations for handling long sequences. While efficient
Transformer architectures like Linformer and Performer with linear complexity
have emerged as promising solutions, their theoretical understanding remains
limited. In this paper, we introduce Sumformer, a novel and simple architecture
capable of universally approximating equivariant sequence-to-sequence
functions. We use Sumformer to give the first universal approximation results
for Linformer and Performer. Moreover, we derive a new proof for Transformers,
showing that just one attention layer is sufficient for universal
approximation. | [
0.0063490593,
0.057785444,
0.0022046799,
0.0355324857,
-0.0438110717,
0.0069546779,
-0.0174086168,
-0.0363433138,
-0.0267652236,
-0.0075380667,
-0.0340028852,
-0.0730833858,
0.0311063416,
0.0286927111,
0.0131185493,
-0.071990259,
0.0085265432,
0.0041839527,
-0.0277095996,
-0.0137383053,
0.0070238588,
-0.023777701,
-0.0361462459,
0.0660760254,
0.021363508,
-0.0207636748,
0.0014577098,
-0.0925202444,
0.0162923504,
-0.0083476426,
0.0022021055,
0.0360343046,
0.0035993247,
0.028127009,
0.0000017374,
-0.0107593909,
0.0061412212,
0.0024551589,
-0.0095388908,
-0.0107375327,
-0.0031867905,
-0.0126192542,
-0.0142292855,
0.0407258496,
-0.0363968611,
-0.0285556428,
0.0616841242,
0.0453231335,
0.05249523,
0.0817332268,
-0.001168416,
-0.0446390845,
0.0298529807,
-0.0394160002,
0.0035930194,
-0.0439968482,
-0.0054317578,
-0.0613681972,
0.0275825206,
-0.0250605345,
-0.0377010927,
0.0539897904,
0.036523018,
-0.0094412155,
-0.0056328173,
0.0303028356,
-0.053897731,
-0.018594509,
-0.0166027676,
0.0562961213,
-0.0569948964,
-0.0188202467,
-0.0051362342,
0.0279856864,
0.0122743826,
-0.0218560938,
-0.0558325723,
0.0348529555,
0.0046638851,
0.0119186938,
-0.0068541565,
-0.0089381654,
0.0086980574,
-0.0402415879,
-0.0365416333,
0.0277539603,
0.0129661616,
0.0025271229,
0.0021676752,
0.0220244955,
-0.0364508964,
-0.0608106367,
0.0016227658,
0.08074788,
-0.0373660438,
-0.0244216509,
-0.0485508516,
-0.050465893,
-0.0336938798,
-0.0714193434,
0.0297282692,
0.0457592271,
0.0029005194,
0.0300460644,
-0.0240374915,
0.0827937648,
-0.0375058763,
0.0258562304,
-0.0250010565,
0.0060226382,
-0.0163279139,
0.0105620781,
-0.0427109078,
0.0493702479,
-0.0368240401,
-0.0200110488,
-0.0509319939,
0.0458232239,
0.0088941185,
-0.0075822719,
0.0210737661,
0.0134079168,
-0.0250804741,
0.0046285074,
-0.0380442366,
0.0532235391,
-0.007631578,
-0.0169561841,
0.014030884,
-0.0499406308,
-0.0348686613,
0.0261777248,
0.0159181729,
-0.0109475516,
-0.0062113763,
0.0764504895,
-0.0025984147,
-0.0615509748,
-0.0026719265,
0.0222529881,
-0.031622164,
-0.0296077393,
0.0045731692,
-0.0610250905,
0.0206645504,
-0.0061924648,
-0.0282659344,
0.0138712581,
-0.0158907808,
0.0234972015,
-0.003697942,
0.0499681458,
0.0529327095,
-0.0288566854,
-0.007093973,
-0.0207223948,
-0.0262098722,
0.0054700724,
0.0439072736,
-0.0183649398,
0.0063767158,
-0.0258701704,
0.0322670713,
0.0373710506,
-0.00610745,
-0.0535701029,
0.026023848,
-0.0127567817,
-0.0253854264,
0.0017009579,
0.0094969422,
0.0704759508,
-0.0264948066,
-0.0424237922,
0.0427243188,
0.0248896815,
0.0411818288,
0.1105979308,
0.0271256287,
0.024323985,
-0.0122184558,
0.0376200229,
-0.0658682063,
0.0641910285,
0.0134653281,
0.0061894064,
0.0268394351,
0.0191706307,
-0.0503582694,
-0.0146228438,
0.0271974746,
-0.0034300911,
0.008123301,
-0.0669798627,
-0.007880114,
0.0163944494,
-0.0548233837,
0.0831870288,
-0.02449679,
-0.0581129342,
0.0282072406,
-0.0338501781,
-0.0238830615,
0.0001362435,
0.0200457256,
-0.0299629234,
-0.029313527,
-0.0128272241,
-0.0237839315,
0.0207160767,
0.0495918207,
0.0096204523,
-0.0019780695,
0.001374936,
-0.0245962385,
0.0103172157,
-0.0102098659,
-0.0031760945,
-0.0065253912,
0.0030413144,
0.0135627538,
-0.0144076999,
0.0063315891,
0.0102123106,
-0.0161621775,
-0.0572434254,
0.0235482752,
0.0229833554,
0.0493106321,
0.018115269,
-0.0080047725,
0.0536511876,
0.0375065915,
-0.0416493006,
-0.065343909,
0.0259411614,
-0.0487017445,
-0.0282188747,
0.0537020564,
-0.0954793617,
0.0301553663,
0.0706204325,
-0.0400399715,
-0.0563816354,
0.0514840521,
-0.0919346884,
0.0424218066,
-0.0249912739,
0.0242341012,
0.008246962,
0.0661427379,
-0.011558081,
0.0338412262,
-0.003125936,
0.0326541699,
-0.0142292436,
-0.0012321366,
-0.0329048112,
-0.0191004295,
-0.0630928129,
0.0168180391,
0.0089525813,
0.0394884571,
0.0515036955,
-0.0259328,
0.0071875183,
-0.0501311049,
-0.0540403537,
-0.0003041918,
-0.0282530598,
0.0596756153,
0.0251255408,
0.0304175038,
0.0170771927,
-0.0000632271,
-0.0646365359,
-0.0132192802,
0.0196486413,
-0.005592681,
0.0512930453,
-0.0117896395,
-0.0730586201,
-0.0134461541,
-0.0258500222,
0.0061574667,
0.0282657631,
-0.0209101122,
-0.0114721768,
-0.0294908304,
-0.0657407939,
-0.0110641671,
0.0820189789,
-0.0044185403,
-0.0309247859,
-0.0028025068,
0.0035352756,
0.0147705497,
0.0390634425,
0.0511545651,
0.0151333371,
-0.0057762167,
0.0177122559,
0.012156642,
0.0315445513,
-0.0889508948,
-0.0217206813,
-0.0109381108,
0.0391636528,
0.0392824002,
0.1117136106,
-0.0479575768,
-0.0382228866,
-0.0537772663,
-0.0315568596,
0.0472989269,
0.0202828553,
0.0388910808,
-0.0067768982,
-0.0346956402,
-0.0400853269,
-0.0360288173,
0.0039208429,
0.0476078093,
-0.0329589918,
0.0050378498,
-0.0179731175,
-0.0069726631,
-0.0435484685,
0.0232019369,
0.0479050465,
-0.0041340562,
-0.0477188863,
-0.0275076851,
-0.0339379609,
0.0363954119,
0.0315882079,
-0.0462777875,
0.0853747055,
-0.0160550866,
0.0361600742,
-0.0248494856,
-0.0387387648,
-0.0496947505,
0.0012927301,
-0.0079900268,
0.0201586019,
0.0379874073,
-0.0560302846,
-0.1158680022,
0.0303283148,
0.0555088669,
0.05904622,
-0.0018349942,
0.0074863671,
-0.0211384855,
0.0416821428,
0.0039857216,
0.0419606604,
0.0430891737,
-0.009028526,
0.0682649612,
0.0638015419,
0.041119054,
0.0389666669,
-0.0193053298,
-0.0074926284,
0.0114534544,
-0.0505303107,
-0.0308199581,
0.0414594598,
0.0100983633,
-0.0180690251,
-0.0066261142,
0.0941438675,
-0.0065082195,
-0.0567657165,
0.0384083316,
0.021100441,
0.0282060485,
0.0248154104,
0.0207505263,
-0.0818007886,
-0.033219669,
-0.0214529987,
0.0031683834,
0.0110637741,
-0.0661576092,
-0.0089063272,
-0.0669765398,
-0.0159524903,
0.003692413,
-0.086649552,
-0.0688387454,
-0.0165302251,
0.0364068002,
-0.0085796397,
0.0296392832,
0.0111860419,
-0.0036081313,
-0.0125212884,
0.0355906002,
-0.0136030763,
-0.0012275426,
0.0023806836,
-0.0051043774,
-0.0120369941,
0.035925515,
0.0284850597,
-0.0050894478,
-0.0481552295,
0.0093811993,
0.0235731062,
-0.0359172896,
0.0545666665,
0.0372290425,
-0.0088304793,
-0.0156336315,
0.0111755254,
0.044441916,
-0.0744646788,
0.032233078,
-0.0154570118,
0.0784231499,
0.0044372929,
-0.0424092636,
-0.01031473,
0.0093941344,
-0.0347526744,
0.0237271376,
0.0211440995,
-0.0436161794,
-0.0387389734,
0.0050490559,
0.0111517468,
-0.0362812616,
-0.0777790621,
0.0304282326,
0.011804319,
-0.0872523636,
-0.0587467365,
-0.0099368431,
0.0042252908,
0.017978346,
-0.0269341227,
-0.0613736473,
0.069214195,
-0.0267623514,
-0.0344711766,
-0.011737451,
-0.0151056657,
0.0145124169,
-0.0419752039,
0.0498440675,
0.0195441209,
0.0133854337,
-0.0427919738,
-0.0107227257,
-0.1146489754,
-0.0538971275,
0.0062296842,
0.0481783524,
0.0139586888,
0.0094741881,
-0.0024519516,
-0.0029715113,
0.0393803641,
0.0688244104,
-0.0228066873,
0.0182803702,
0.0311857518,
-0.0257576313,
0.0290645771,
0.0257423632,
-0.0097795362,
0.0166611578,
0.0037989388,
0.0478772968,
0.0040545603,
-0.050467331,
0.0486439504,
0.0240784679,
0.0200769901,
0.0379730016,
0.0397622436,
0.0411468521,
0.0214764066,
0.0376719087,
0.0217163414,
-0.0572750308,
-0.0038328755,
-0.0228281636,
0.0468547828,
-0.0014403365,
0.0158107243,
-0.0050131078,
0.0029814371,
0.0118614184,
0.0154886348,
-0.0122166723,
-0.0190184396,
0.0122883227,
0.0148317702,
-0.0166994315,
-0.0314279981,
0.034359131,
0.0458368249,
0.0123185003,
0.0084232362,
0.047182668,
0.0754410774,
0.0020872734,
-0.0015095384,
-0.0826368481,
-0.049749203,
-0.0342722796,
0.0222007502,
0.0640877113,
-0.0286994744,
-0.0057375254,
-0.0040998934,
0.0301582925,
-0.0142848603,
0.0296973828,
-0.0165676847,
-0.0228741709,
-0.0029068966,
0.0271004997,
0.0228224602,
-0.0417703502,
0.073944971,
-0.0854341984,
0.0306331888,
0.0026765317,
0.0188028459,
-0.0472736955,
-0.0771050379,
-0.0292532276,
-0.005855849,
0.0097847627,
-0.007665487,
-0.0210742131,
-0.0734430179,
0.0361019708,
0.0075510712,
0.035957586,
-0.03579247,
0.0407956205,
0.0092456071,
0.0014613571,
-0.0162479673,
-0.0039219037,
-0.0136028361,
0.0157197304,
-0.0131800575,
0.0013880915,
-5.552784786e-33,
-0.0103473719,
-0.0031341035,
0.0163148921,
0.053385105,
-0.035790205,
-0.0123751443,
-0.0262527242,
0.0089288047,
0.001620715,
-0.0238469094,
-0.0206029154,
0.0222451538,
-0.0030577483,
0.0499485396,
-0.0134701328,
-0.0226247385,
0.0302441474,
0.0019704273,
-0.0424043126,
0.0206488576,
-0.0070656086,
0.0073359129,
0.0720286593,
-0.0098782545,
-0.0218168832,
-0.0016766489,
0.000954109,
0.0335775241,
0.0045684008,
0.0454951897,
-0.0235840883,
0.0406352058,
0.0189576298,
-0.0405078828,
-0.0244349465,
0.0343565419,
-0.0367712341,
-0.0084372833,
-0.0160419215,
0.0162567273,
-0.0084531792,
0.0107687172,
0.0496575497,
0.0096980957,
-0.0070284181,
-0.0468701795,
0.0298790112,
-0.0163055044,
-0.0172787029,
-0.0106548751,
0.0164393205,
0.0208303053,
-0.0291639511,
-0.010366234,
0.0000176062,
0.077364713,
-0.0191710573,
0.0054205339,
-0.0417058952,
-0.0079649398,
-0.004300558,
0.071163848,
0.0247048736,
-0.0137238605,
0.0091715846,
0.0300197545,
0.0337529518,
-0.0470276363,
-0.0676329657,
-0.0019478011,
0.0070600593,
-0.000238351,
0.0326129161,
-0.0074392664,
0.0620224886,
0.0156853963,
-0.0193146821,
0.0042007132,
0.0080268765,
0.07346306,
0.021039892,
0.0004757861,
0.0213676989,
-0.0031539705,
-0.0323331803,
0.0220103655,
-0.036732126,
0.0030214738,
-0.0014253306,
0.0094686709,
0.0162700843,
-0.0156015977,
-0.0011654111,
-0.0448930338,
0.0058964435,
0.0034150088,
0.0248086993,
0.0178627335,
-0.0099604474,
0.0202660896,
-0.0373805575,
-0.0322622098,
-0.034048073,
-0.0002399526,
-0.012102386,
-0.0310381409,
0.0325994827,
0.0515610091,
-0.0710058212,
-0.0370129831,
-0.0485875122,
0.0454574339,
-0.0087627908,
0.052295506,
0.0461535789,
-0.00522744,
-0.0119992448,
0.0430867262,
-0.0423820205,
-0.0213703085,
0.0053966381,
0.042473603,
0.0367009863,
0.0408336893,
-0.0088233789,
-0.0398967862,
-0.0428068526,
0.0313062966,
-0.0110512376,
-0.1059095263,
-0.0216534045,
-0.0121196192,
2.609e-7,
0.0306791998,
-0.0161801502,
0.0877755284,
0.0438213535,
0.0012562842,
0.0231472272,
0.0389034785,
0.0931243077,
-0.0073011955,
0.0207423456,
0.0293895304,
0.0184832923,
0.0124649024,
-0.0191988386,
-0.086106509,
-0.0235946048,
-0.1072030813,
0.0203179363,
0.0133477543,
-0.0108440863,
0.0310791079,
0.0732359961,
0.0093585346,
0.0085167848,
-0.0043067029,
-0.0168214925,
0.0562763587,
0.0235543624,
0.0341593958,
0.0161373001,
0.025907198,
-0.0003118358,
-0.0100802779,
0.005064622,
-0.0104403999,
0.068193607,
0.0226877667,
0.0464037098,
0.0277689435,
-0.0492487401,
0.0067201913,
0.0003439639,
-0.0213137735,
0.0306206383,
0.0083176065,
-0.0727495998,
-0.0125337932,
-0.0211419463,
-0.0534853078,
0.0223581307,
-0.0362849385,
-0.0028939536,
-0.0077803261,
0.0175219476,
0.0612226538,
-0.0399739221,
0.0408339947,
-0.074787721,
-0.0164666809,
0.0088115437,
-0.043560829,
0.0090644918,
-0.0247993022,
-0.0020680998,
0.0292853713,
0.0178604182,
-0.0391360968,
2.084783312e-34,
0.0452793315,
-0.000299792,
0.0216911305,
0.0296614226,
0.0065001799,
-0.0307858065,
0.0372419581,
-0.0150751462,
0.0368218943,
-0.0647548735,
-0.083153978
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.02288v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.02288v3 | Performance Comparison of Large Language Models on VNHSGE English Dataset: OpenAI ChatGPT, Microsoft Bing Chat, and Google Bard | 2023-07-05T13:40:57 | 2023-07-20T01:13:27 | Xuan-Quy Dao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | This paper presents a performance comparison of three large language models
(LLMs), namely OpenAI ChatGPT, Microsoft Bing Chat (BingChat), and Google Bard,
on the VNHSGE English dataset. The performance of BingChat, Bard, and ChatGPT
(GPT-3.5) is 92.4\%, 86\%, and 79.2\%, respectively. The results show that
BingChat is better than ChatGPT and Bard. Therefore, BingChat and Bard can
replace ChatGPT while ChatGPT is not yet officially available in Vietnam. The
results also indicate that BingChat, Bard and ChatGPT outperform Vietnamese
students in English language proficiency. The findings of this study contribute
to the understanding of the potential of LLMs in English language education.
The remarkable performance of ChatGPT, BingChat, and Bard demonstrates their
potential as effective tools for teaching and learning English at the high
school level. | [
0.0277018026,
-0.0134309847,
-0.0353976227,
0.0207962748,
-0.0558107235,
-0.0071084965,
0.017919274,
-0.0104704341,
0.1001844406,
-0.0530236587,
-0.0500222482,
-0.0386389866,
0.0446449816,
-0.017184373,
0.0001127805,
-0.058685258,
0.0485731885,
-0.0082777189,
0.0065248753,
-0.0158838127,
-0.0024793595,
0.0053433836,
-0.0483013764,
0.0717928931,
0.0060216547,
-0.0403315388,
-0.0229694862,
-0.0072346129,
-0.0246873796,
-0.029712487,
0.0316988267,
0.0465142727,
-0.0091200387,
0.0506397076,
0.000002182,
-0.0447296314,
0.017046215,
-0.0038553206,
0.0368321612,
0.0648331642,
0.0654248819,
0.0593768246,
-0.036570359,
0.0612381212,
-0.0280580055,
-0.0167909786,
0.0452717878,
-0.0033714734,
0.0306918882,
0.0532025807,
-0.0030744416,
-0.0247139074,
0.0213502757,
0.0119061461,
0.0058306544,
-0.0389129817,
0.0147889284,
0.0673278049,
0.0633479282,
-0.0207209028,
-0.0347485244,
0.027634792,
-0.0122952648,
-0.03779817,
-0.0222064871,
0.0416845679,
-0.0357580855,
-0.0309850611,
-0.003821861,
0.0480516776,
0.0078171762,
-0.0105835767,
-0.0160708241,
0.0294155646,
0.0029069004,
0.0168538932,
-0.0798934773,
0.0305401273,
0.0264066588,
0.0265438631,
0.0046183099,
-0.0457977727,
-0.004977983,
0.0108322948,
0.0046138242,
-0.0288765132,
0.0364780053,
-0.0254273359,
-0.0196811892,
0.0208228547,
-0.0101114344,
-0.0068010134,
-0.0064356406,
0.0263664704,
-0.0432669148,
0.046152804,
-0.0102433581,
0.0251361653,
0.0075539635,
-0.0883198157,
0.0116581982,
0.0703627169,
-0.0196153354,
-0.0051116585,
0.0098389415,
0.0590598173,
0.0295694117,
0.0107697416,
-0.0275500137,
0.0008780603,
-0.0628859699,
-0.0089141559,
-0.0550110787,
0.0678565055,
0.0012833658,
-0.0519214123,
-0.0826442167,
0.0058524879,
0.0162392054,
-0.008720885,
0.0440304093,
-0.0256671216,
-0.0249195453,
0.024396779,
-0.0274964124,
0.0499561541,
0.0147974761,
0.0149974879,
-0.0035223723,
-0.0798938125,
0.0635464862,
0.0121678179,
-0.0214956775,
-0.030413378,
-0.0223209076,
0.0233681891,
-0.0391209014,
-0.0332128666,
-0.0604938082,
0.0265341625,
0.0050507826,
-0.0398239568,
-0.0090045342,
-0.0643847212,
-0.0303109717,
0.0083598159,
0.0170483608,
0.0196017511,
0.0137571301,
0.0150781404,
-0.0004119342,
0.0140516777,
-0.0192810297,
0.0262060147,
0.0646679401,
0.0146651333,
0.0088784089,
0.0949147418,
0.0449817367,
-0.0332693718,
0.0163423065,
-0.0629339367,
-0.038160827,
0.0515499189,
-0.0144938538,
-0.0030449713,
-0.0068228496,
-0.0282985792,
0.00961316,
0.0250026304,
-0.0515519045,
0.0596994124,
-0.0085685365,
0.0521189794,
0.069029741,
0.0524646416,
0.0451898016,
0.0332555585,
-0.0147693716,
0.0436111428,
0.0448041856,
0.0056474153,
-0.0059351362,
-0.0083185863,
-0.0398964845,
0.0041980059,
0.0209530741,
0.0369561538,
-0.0164857581,
-0.0483392403,
-0.0223208275,
-0.0321601294,
0.0035208522,
0.0080087241,
0.0384185091,
-0.0362916254,
-0.0131962933,
0.0680824146,
0.044510588,
-0.0267207921,
0.0001637171,
-0.0837043971,
-0.0202542469,
0.0868097991,
0.0426095091,
-0.0093678115,
0.0006219204,
0.0142398328,
-0.0142470449,
0.0465304703,
0.0357346982,
0.0015853234,
-0.0144141698,
-0.0420804471,
0.0315309763,
0.0340580717,
0.0135645494,
-0.0082273707,
0.0249901172,
0.055100143,
-0.0091025652,
0.0164818428,
-0.0390881449,
-0.0026663966,
-0.0325517356,
0.0265774801,
-0.0194588378,
-0.0112646455,
0.0254052561,
0.0514951497,
-0.0223619733,
-0.0145409368,
0.0044006645,
0.0196101442,
-0.0139905242,
-0.0013289085,
-0.0206013955,
-0.0211727507,
0.0558296144,
-0.0348342732,
0.0254114475,
0.0451660119,
0.0118151456,
-0.0481817611,
0.0179240517,
-0.0241944566,
0.0853845477,
-0.0116743352,
0.0495344177,
-0.0601365007,
0.0075265989,
-0.0038065375,
0.0301351454,
0.0134550678,
0.0043672542,
-0.013509104,
0.0516528785,
0.021948332,
-0.0457060933,
-0.0521323383,
0.0757676139,
0.0031462354,
0.0455386788,
-0.0127374223,
0.0326567627,
-0.0633097515,
-0.0376138538,
-0.1389271766,
0.0071142586,
0.0044543976,
-0.0043456447,
0.0429174751,
-0.0056270962,
-0.0263158251,
0.0038110083,
-0.0375978313,
0.0432524532,
0.019789163,
0.0029831771,
-0.0243633278,
-0.0389661081,
-0.0312044453,
-0.0435375385,
-0.0236115661,
0.0058554667,
0.0044117984,
0.024363786,
-0.0789573267,
0.0098012099,
0.0314759612,
-0.0401410945,
-0.0046012304,
0.0121645536,
-0.0917271823,
0.0323477872,
-0.0166313425,
0.0450786054,
0.0352241322,
0.0221088752,
0.0274750385,
0.0261974819,
-0.0221651327,
-0.0428260341,
-0.0126161342,
-0.011782255,
-0.0346285217,
-0.0552342422,
-0.0597549714,
-0.0434208587,
0.021115208,
0.0244173929,
-0.0022343362,
-0.031572964,
-0.0294573996,
-0.0402739272,
0.0337566361,
-0.0349686891,
0.018996818,
-0.0454122871,
-0.0153674548,
0.0044144075,
-0.0398216471,
0.0140242288,
-0.0187837668,
0.0166247059,
-0.0788291991,
-0.0052061337,
-0.0126531497,
0.032401219,
-0.0488204621,
0.0110079236,
-0.0431957133,
-0.0733665675,
-0.0100738788,
0.0025945227,
0.0332378075,
-0.0615452044,
0.0381715856,
-0.0386976935,
0.021506181,
0.0046771239,
0.0180389006,
-0.040595036,
0.0133658852,
-0.0308732316,
-0.0082052732,
0.0171107482,
-0.0034238631,
-0.0089051183,
0.0227917321,
-0.0144032845,
-0.0179266874,
-0.0352310762,
0.0208830368,
-0.00038845,
-0.0052277739,
0.0249188133,
-0.0050487733,
-0.0288310498,
0.0068851295,
0.1002889872,
0.0390032306,
-0.0231211986,
-0.0141852414,
-0.012549147,
0.0014686473,
0.0347501896,
0.0006231176,
-0.0444083847,
0.0466512479,
0.0272025988,
-0.0345091298,
-0.0054964065,
0.1019998044,
0.0268184915,
-0.0472673923,
-0.0291912984,
-0.0230607837,
0.0393416286,
-0.0098895049,
0.0070085372,
-0.0827122107,
-0.0061043431,
-0.0107443789,
0.0027669377,
0.0137159517,
0.019144997,
-0.0102213146,
-0.1249270961,
0.0111197829,
0.014534886,
-0.0517640114,
0.0313358381,
-0.0294902287,
-0.027512027,
0.0050067995,
0.0613963455,
-0.0123606706,
0.0000659098,
-0.0137065602,
0.0174012277,
-0.0396505669,
-0.0693996623,
0.0406150967,
-0.0189623255,
0.0801730305,
0.0134119699,
0.0446979813,
-0.0331642106,
0.0011649608,
0.065143995,
0.0157560855,
-0.013189299,
-0.0101133958,
0.0303527713,
0.0104031358,
0.0064594494,
-0.0294821151,
-0.0196811631,
0.0056281122,
0.0176354256,
0.0471493229,
0.0542212427,
-0.0133433016,
0.0111896452,
0.0110738128,
0.0459421389,
0.0005783525,
0.0546326265,
0.014561425,
-0.0365736559,
0.015209334,
-0.0306624118,
-0.0503052883,
0.0274221785,
-0.0450177155,
0.0659157112,
-0.026287429,
-0.0890389904,
-0.0421593338,
-0.0348513573,
0.0334976614,
0.0091329738,
0.0255883522,
0.0779297948,
0.03029304,
0.0368206725,
0.0412847511,
-0.0080221044,
0.0123959063,
0.0076604495,
-0.1169667989,
-0.0309991185,
0.0105140209,
-0.0335080735,
0.0250805132,
-0.0190576762,
-0.0452054553,
-0.0758167878,
0.0333301462,
0.0095983082,
0.025793368,
0.0028317811,
-0.00141087,
-0.0574220866,
-0.0050795525,
0.0210375134,
0.0036672528,
0.001288215,
-0.0097045638,
0.0086860703,
0.0304990727,
0.0083856899,
-0.0076295659,
0.0140922843,
-0.0147099774,
0.0291433781,
0.0003436843,
-0.0376675054,
0.0122149047,
0.0849040672,
0.0268215518,
-0.0356147662,
-0.0063492479,
-0.0380486473,
0.0088383928,
-0.0545322224,
0.009508987,
-0.0231082216,
-0.0365223438,
0.0398991667,
-0.0055547552,
-0.0070848749,
-0.0017738,
-0.0356796235,
-0.0375413969,
0.0246096607,
0.0649131313,
-0.0070917364,
0.031184284,
0.0325007662,
0.024541419,
-0.0287269186,
-0.024453247,
0.0181126967,
0.031563621,
-0.0010725921,
0.0926375315,
-0.0304770581,
-0.0453939028,
0.0612201132,
0.0055160746,
-0.0120554473,
-0.058165174,
0.0039145038,
0.0711191371,
0.0577681214,
0.0328314155,
0.033104144,
-0.0406098031,
0.0362246707,
-0.0246888734,
0.0382588953,
0.0139772044,
-0.0401814729,
0.0519019291,
-0.0450937338,
-0.0158369895,
0.0208314545,
0.0378446653,
-0.0220069066,
0.0011058059,
0.0198966414,
-0.0036666,
-0.0208205413,
-0.0418529622,
0.0519850738,
0.0419358499,
-0.0315383077,
-0.0117033711,
-0.0294307433,
-0.0451284051,
-0.0440319553,
0.0104541518,
0.0164228976,
-0.0489857756,
0.0054245102,
0.0355122685,
0.0070056836,
0.0212938879,
-0.0603049695,
-0.0152855106,
-0.0419923253,
-0.0064632935,
0.0072429129,
-6.440301388e-33,
-0.0379726626,
-0.0032120987,
0.0604445711,
-0.0202680603,
-0.0113436179,
-0.0168547947,
-0.028490847,
0.0572855398,
-0.0518728942,
-0.0264304429,
-0.0112478454,
0.0527431332,
0.018999787,
0.0254976414,
0.0019433546,
0.0043845475,
0.0041789669,
-0.0018368441,
0.021041004,
0.0035252045,
0.0207252055,
0.0047933576,
0.05717244,
-0.0094119143,
0.0178444888,
-0.0157512538,
-0.0109358933,
-0.0148478113,
-0.0169428848,
0.0421591178,
-0.0201173238,
0.0705998838,
0.0152660608,
0.009016769,
-0.0118523967,
-0.0064815343,
-0.0247764215,
-0.0407597832,
0.0390084274,
0.0466257595,
0.0575124621,
-0.0062648198,
0.018684594,
-0.0053583183,
-0.051840879,
-0.0137895383,
0.0304906685,
-0.0157009643,
-0.0267925411,
0.053121604,
-0.0566095822,
0.0060079009,
-0.008905896,
-0.0006011963,
-0.0068566492,
0.0040998016,
-0.0362004116,
-0.0131274657,
-0.0469288938,
0.0517585427,
0.0307927653,
0.0251751747,
0.0413234085,
0.0080929194,
0.017245831,
0.0339619368,
0.049010314,
0.007496418,
0.0149584571,
-0.0141778244,
0.0736958459,
0.0249908417,
0.0526482612,
0.0163871963,
0.008270761,
-0.0620920882,
-0.0731837526,
0.0126815727,
0.0618806817,
-0.0299151577,
-0.0174130332,
-0.0035672518,
-0.0567929745,
-0.0559406355,
-0.0036192539,
0.031484779,
-0.0193158295,
-0.0694867894,
0.0310520418,
-0.0678289905,
0.0052234596,
-0.0653369129,
0.0438840985,
-0.0526725203,
-0.0195213016,
-0.0179731771,
-0.0385250561,
0.0439448655,
-0.0479251258,
0.0209536869,
-0.063378498,
-0.0441224277,
0.0049367277,
0.0309975967,
-0.0007765646,
0.0352805443,
-0.0133564342,
0.0026064764,
-0.0449440293,
0.013217411,
-0.0313028879,
-0.009382247,
0.0523988456,
-0.031043293,
0.0160938408,
-0.0374022759,
-0.0125374151,
0.0604971275,
-0.0012394951,
-0.0137888733,
-0.0360888615,
-0.0572801903,
-0.0193720609,
-0.0295243543,
-0.0351980552,
0.0468188561,
-0.0835450813,
0.017487593,
0.0150108756,
-0.0477262065,
-0.0234826449,
-0.0035261335,
2.846e-7,
0.0090828864,
0.0302029084,
0.0052709589,
0.0123286843,
0.0003532782,
-0.0165614281,
-0.0281758588,
-0.0007438394,
0.0482778735,
0.0434677489,
0.0127526373,
-0.0014868582,
0.058367826,
0.0427704006,
-0.0675370395,
-0.0375138745,
-0.0770428255,
-0.0019555411,
-0.0641798675,
0.0657642707,
0.0633117259,
0.0718987063,
0.0040964605,
-0.0062386305,
-0.0409243777,
-0.0453925654,
0.0267297588,
-0.0304221567,
-0.0405392349,
0.0241720751,
0.0138174528,
0.0410721861,
0.0009966323,
0.0037227168,
-0.026654724,
0.0029227077,
0.0052513601,
0.0519857258,
-0.0153026078,
0.0404564478,
0.0437371023,
-0.0086190654,
-0.0165334772,
-0.0366982892,
0.0923578218,
-0.0137034906,
-0.0289696399,
0.04300832,
0.0086529553,
-0.0450237468,
0.0072168573,
-0.0376243629,
-0.0184811857,
0.0093639558,
-0.0036560125,
-0.02863455,
0.0167387873,
0.0022967698,
-0.0084965546,
-0.0094564827,
-0.0188422184,
-0.0770499259,
-0.0096348422,
0.0134089952,
-0.0174442176,
0.0049665109,
0.0257799923,
2.172289913e-34,
0.0135188401,
-0.0256589167,
0.0289854947,
0.0203470029,
0.0628053993,
-0.0027819136,
0.0512213968,
0.0276949462,
0.0058380212,
-0.0525269546,
-0.0302685313
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.02269v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.02269v1 | SpaceNLI: Evaluating the Consistency of Predicting Inferences in Space | 2023-07-05T13:08:18 | 2023-07-05T13:08:18 | Lasha Abzianidze, Joost Zwarts, Yoad Winter | cs.CL | cs.CL, 68T50, I.2.7 | While many natural language inference (NLI) datasets target certain semantic
phenomena, e.g., negation, tense & aspect, monotonicity, and presupposition, to
the best of our knowledge, there is no NLI dataset that involves diverse types
of spatial expressions and reasoning. We fill this gap by semi-automatically
creating an NLI dataset for spatial reasoning, called SpaceNLI. The data
samples are automatically generated from a curated set of reasoning patterns,
where the patterns are annotated with inference labels by experts. We test
several SOTA NLI systems on SpaceNLI to gauge the complexity of the dataset and
the system's capacity for spatial reasoning. Moreover, we introduce a Pattern
Accuracy and argue that it is a more reliable and stricter measure than the
accuracy for evaluating a system's performance on pattern-based generated data
samples. Based on the evaluation results we find that the systems obtain
moderate results on the spatial NLI problems but lack consistency per inference
pattern. The results also reveal that non-projective spatial inferences
(especially due to the "between" preposition) are the most challenging ones. | [
0.0498532839,
0.0745868832,
-0.0198947676,
0.0202063061,
-0.0681597888,
0.0121073425,
0.0490116514,
-0.0175580326,
0.0275362022,
-0.0197861809,
-0.0082071433,
0.0025021555,
0.0402484089,
0.0215312615,
0.0179565642,
-0.0554759875,
0.0412330739,
-0.0181429237,
-0.0139973285,
0.0061061755,
-0.0147481682,
0.0120295808,
-0.06068822,
0.0408344679,
-0.044118993,
0.0023463112,
-0.0131018599,
-0.0302684437,
0.0222173613,
-0.0741454735,
0.0166726205,
0.0134508628,
0.0552840531,
-0.0084186597,
0.0000018315,
-0.0280913003,
0.0050080279,
0.0057824822,
0.0216607116,
-0.0118066976,
-0.016329322,
-0.049661424,
0.0567774586,
-0.03050231,
-0.039925918,
-0.0353100151,
0.0538930818,
0.0271903686,
0.032389883,
0.0190188754,
-0.0166968238,
-0.0563672744,
-0.0149685554,
0.0082115326,
-0.0080769993,
0.0121924132,
0.0057312828,
0.0076910467,
0.0336177833,
0.0168229602,
-0.020796407,
0.0216931123,
0.0307139046,
0.0459190048,
-0.0303985979,
0.0410729684,
-0.0478566699,
-0.0003947925,
-0.0126576498,
0.0499871522,
0.0482817702,
-0.0455440618,
0.0024703327,
-0.0052544116,
-0.0267698113,
0.0386625119,
-0.026273923,
0.0353669859,
-0.0462354533,
0.0183818527,
0.0319564454,
0.0091490978,
-0.0152591961,
-0.0033255911,
-0.0201684162,
0.1191687658,
0.0079102097,
-0.0481747948,
-0.0237946901,
0.0147266518,
-0.0464225039,
-0.045493193,
0.0125119844,
0.0183693543,
-0.0604762807,
0.0442691222,
-0.0068517271,
0.0519199446,
-0.0103935059,
-0.0299124084,
0.0289046373,
0.0377014689,
0.0045096236,
0.0580835417,
-0.0129301101,
0.030678397,
0.0053469581,
0.0299629178,
-0.0228010714,
-0.0259837415,
-0.0225908607,
0.0259139072,
-0.0433426648,
0.0366768837,
-0.0176138189,
-0.0255750921,
-0.0071659316,
0.0175895635,
-0.0526152626,
0.0392157212,
-0.0264773592,
0.045293536,
-0.019332841,
-0.007869266,
-0.0343953818,
0.0015038137,
-0.0355086178,
0.0487335511,
-0.0448518433,
-0.0368960239,
-0.0078293104,
0.016036978,
0.0348627865,
-0.0273045208,
-0.0140659856,
0.0636158511,
0.0419836827,
-0.0139726391,
-0.0483102053,
-0.028602235,
0.0021351988,
-0.0543060005,
0.0264171567,
-0.0605358109,
0.0170348287,
0.027028352,
-0.0577588826,
-0.0353318751,
-0.0159077998,
0.0007051626,
-0.0300471019,
0.0767078027,
0.0113885971,
0.0203458462,
0.0240827557,
0.0041066851,
-0.0211686101,
0.0553070456,
0.0115568163,
0.0392456129,
0.0345967039,
0.0280736014,
-0.014538628,
0.0082732514,
0.0259667151,
0.0208958052,
-0.0535756052,
0.0315412171,
-0.013631911,
0.0370448567,
-0.0203972142,
0.0361098722,
-0.0284758862,
-0.0226895288,
0.0131797232,
0.0992091447,
-0.0122328708,
-0.0014205654,
0.0787705556,
0.006011236,
-0.0102479821,
-0.0058542793,
-0.0489422567,
0.0089435484,
-0.029279327,
-0.0129322084,
0.0279663242,
0.0179285891,
-0.0196776856,
-0.0489412881,
-0.0514904037,
-0.020188598,
-0.002031117,
-0.0229504034,
0.0637669489,
-0.0066658109,
-0.0193446465,
0.0523907393,
0.054338038,
-0.0361188687,
-0.0215862449,
0.032584127,
0.0677308887,
0.0020308613,
0.0120122684,
-0.0384229645,
-0.0525623448,
0.0233555529,
0.0093859443,
0.0011576769,
0.0595066175,
0.0046000932,
0.0177414026,
-0.0071229087,
-0.0326117054,
0.0448481627,
0.0386237837,
0.0219791047,
0.0921533853,
0.0465026796,
0.0096355509,
-0.0675746277,
0.0285778064,
0.0319208987,
-0.0013098489,
0.0121636577,
-0.0466074608,
0.0440389253,
0.0377750918,
-0.0353575721,
0.001269547,
-0.0131911272,
0.0143738147,
-0.0014447529,
-0.0164397899,
0.0407333449,
-0.056544438,
-0.077235803,
-0.0024513949,
-0.0728289783,
-0.0451584235,
0.0105152214,
-0.0654141456,
0.0049785976,
0.0372670926,
-0.032191135,
-0.0050550555,
-0.0199726764,
-0.0178439319,
0.0419828705,
-0.0107791675,
-0.0252555665,
0.0463722683,
-0.0024538077,
0.0429176316,
-0.0041581825,
0.0517128855,
0.0616377443,
0.0064628194,
0.0183186084,
-0.0542481206,
-0.0194377154,
-0.0571622886,
0.0104568545,
-0.0003361331,
-0.0399304256,
-0.0078540398,
-0.0616880208,
-0.0059013772,
-0.0117396321,
0.0239292607,
0.0173699763,
-0.0177707113,
-0.0322250687,
-0.0191093385,
0.0004012218,
-0.0142602706,
0.0104626045,
0.0404072069,
0.0634149164,
-0.0309002176,
0.0047188029,
-0.0274651702,
-0.0072106393,
-0.0579180643,
0.0332951061,
0.0225868858,
-0.0208821055,
-0.0357952751,
0.0113730794,
-0.0380866304,
0.0418906622,
0.0133899665,
-0.0199498385,
0.0618598051,
-0.0565570928,
-0.0071122521,
0.0564562604,
-0.03160071,
-0.0262436904,
0.0296182353,
-0.0427172557,
-0.0478466675,
0.0207071938,
-0.0436249636,
0.0286576096,
0.0142577291,
-0.0267961677,
-0.0131104868,
0.0291615147,
0.0106108095,
-0.0170784965,
-0.03398408,
0.0208601151,
-0.0390638784,
0.019316718,
0.0268270671,
0.0371321887,
0.0255671721,
0.0427515209,
-0.0166936684,
-0.0256242305,
0.0816522315,
-0.0160565842,
0.0130580291,
-0.0394243859,
0.00398457,
-0.0435921326,
0.0889757797,
0.0352338031,
-0.0073610716,
0.0213785507,
-0.0098961415,
-0.0073015452,
-0.0318863317,
0.0019437181,
0.0408361778,
0.0180926137,
-0.1144293249,
0.0338519178,
-0.0043834993,
-0.0482992381,
-0.0306876674,
-0.0149655668,
-0.0402334295,
-0.0375045128,
-0.0448475033,
-0.0265030656,
0.0406679325,
0.0388937965,
-0.0153541397,
0.022105163,
-0.0393268429,
-0.0145822782,
-0.0362743139,
0.0094603635,
0.0590269119,
0.0878118351,
-0.0555333607,
0.0397934318,
-0.0937683135,
0.0288566072,
-0.0916271731,
0.0276010484,
-0.0338994376,
0.0656052157,
0.037227463,
0.0068043601,
-0.0157675967,
0.0224079676,
0.0562948808,
-0.0441223979,
-0.0742417276,
0.0761926845,
0.0632563978,
0.0442118831,
0.0167326909,
-0.0029881767,
0.0396401212,
-0.000464253,
-0.0148228444,
-0.0476858057,
-0.0452966094,
-0.0279363114,
-0.0580744483,
0.0032039864,
-0.0300065633,
-0.0078930976,
-0.1124512404,
0.0548634604,
-0.0203397889,
-0.1125828028,
-0.0465939716,
-0.0761200711,
0.0074727046,
-0.0122763123,
-0.0813697428,
-0.0317514539,
0.0287149604,
0.0418766849,
0.0059368848,
-0.0632293373,
-0.0209364966,
0.0065757353,
-0.037381418,
0.0238086935,
-0.0250501279,
0.0294318367,
0.0073568649,
-0.0992269441,
-0.0076633529,
0.03217135,
-0.0006384883,
-0.0387425199,
0.0269446559,
0.0224793311,
0.011570299,
-0.0148830544,
0.0263501443,
-0.0456839167,
-0.0216488391,
0.0212833956,
0.0822271407,
-0.0329751633,
0.0235262197,
-0.0541073903,
0.0469266102,
0.0225337707,
0.0591913275,
0.001404686,
0.0428638943,
-0.0893904865,
-0.0251829047,
-0.0341681242,
-0.0296323169,
0.013618215,
0.0195265468,
0.0080059553,
-0.0030778144,
-0.0287837628,
-0.0302866381,
0.0123703014,
0.0605851524,
-0.0145113049,
-0.0533260293,
0.0283950903,
0.0019920093,
-0.0377246365,
0.0416020043,
-0.0236412492,
0.0210572481,
0.0658819675,
0.0250239167,
0.0386004262,
0.0032607929,
-0.0282098576,
0.0008421784,
-0.0558356084,
-0.0360015891,
0.0082998574,
0.0533064343,
0.0204063673,
0.0294722896,
-0.0072463797,
0.0517594442,
0.0242018867,
0.0070590731,
-0.0132715208,
0.0109882494,
0.0328959376,
0.033503674,
0.0494154841,
0.0271154419,
0.0093449131,
0.0046842252,
0.002796723,
-0.0179376937,
-0.0383891463,
-0.0112018753,
-0.004995232,
-0.0197012611,
0.0620499514,
0.0260915775,
-0.0405914821,
-0.007070994,
0.0065097255,
-0.0521146357,
0.0013410639,
-0.0121132592,
0.0586802401,
0.0175009537,
0.0541651733,
-0.0320151113,
0.0046407408,
-0.0124566751,
0.0216324627,
0.0131671298,
-0.0466014445,
0.103256017,
0.0127079692,
0.0092942361,
-0.0197687875,
-0.0485023707,
-0.0556126758,
-0.0274290014,
0.046790503,
-0.0246083513,
0.0035959429,
0.0744608343,
0.009323705,
-0.0168170575,
0.0164772067,
-0.0518479906,
-0.020441616,
0.0199299399,
0.0256857295,
0.0649359897,
-0.028062433,
-0.0055762585,
-0.0529012419,
0.0242798831,
0.0531414598,
0.0111553334,
0.0158647615,
-0.0244308636,
0.0517445877,
-0.0059911907,
0.0031045298,
-0.0011534406,
0.0185645986,
-0.0293928366,
0.0447193794,
0.0040745931,
-0.0250574686,
-0.0294600166,
-0.0265013166,
-0.0146293826,
0.0236189943,
0.0118736811,
0.0299084019,
-0.0355931111,
-0.0515192747,
0.0005552363,
0.0422554612,
-0.0036113027,
0.0203379337,
0.0365351327,
0.0500737093,
0.023339387,
-0.0483543091,
0.002653291,
-0.0034028471,
-0.0224552266,
-0.0305745024,
-0.060188286,
-6.199096559e-33,
-0.016842762,
-0.0559171028,
0.0530182645,
-0.0097443173,
-0.0130799152,
-0.0360311829,
-0.0353175588,
-0.0296087377,
-0.0308672693,
0.0039481707,
0.0080247214,
0.0001721868,
0.009163362,
0.0215980336,
0.0248690546,
-0.0073496094,
-0.0217945129,
0.0371848717,
-0.0323816575,
-0.0418545306,
0.0279271919,
-0.0217321087,
0.0305120107,
-0.0912573338,
-0.0099714808,
0.0189028345,
0.0101205343,
0.0306884386,
-0.0513890833,
-0.0040608034,
-0.0063281758,
0.0144325448,
0.010745774,
-0.0112119168,
0.0200451165,
-0.0007888247,
-0.0777518526,
-0.0886529237,
0.0198448524,
0.0213976875,
-0.0669229254,
0.0121172993,
0.0099992305,
0.0102464464,
-0.0098138247,
0.0050106719,
0.0462530777,
-0.0023012613,
0.0129890358,
0.0278553087,
-0.0308763441,
0.018275952,
0.0001388188,
-0.0164612159,
-0.0315231122,
0.0052332613,
0.0375599824,
0.0042091138,
-0.0424481481,
0.0240815803,
0.0228044968,
0.0202354882,
0.0325977728,
-0.0190854501,
0.0212922562,
0.0365708768,
0.0381513424,
-0.0339188203,
-0.0187408403,
-0.0214216504,
0.022353882,
0.0334089175,
-0.0030632936,
0.033028271,
0.0502987541,
0.0457914583,
-0.0700770468,
0.0209076442,
-0.0291204304,
0.0367816091,
-0.0150734214,
-0.0135788666,
-0.0474625044,
-0.0164640173,
-0.002431947,
-0.0283234604,
0.0035730449,
-0.0005351722,
0.0027399922,
-0.0135474307,
0.0429547764,
0.0639401525,
-0.0117259789,
-0.0098532261,
-0.0369010232,
0.006648771,
-0.0183562431,
-0.023237342,
0.0101428078,
0.0746266395,
-0.0600234754,
-0.0161659513,
-0.0184817836,
0.0361739509,
0.0163960792,
0.0368639342,
0.029432673,
0.0287071057,
-0.0261497796,
-0.015623223,
-0.0282495264,
-0.0619414337,
-0.0305110887,
-0.0280115008,
0.0571611412,
0.0372683331,
0.0011862766,
0.0672440305,
-0.0051661204,
0.0179562978,
-0.036934182,
-0.0200705789,
-0.019361712,
-0.003628572,
-0.0118442206,
-0.0141527532,
-0.0452383757,
-0.0172524098,
-0.0176486503,
-0.0636257455,
0.0034299239,
0.0292621404,
2.627e-7,
0.0288227182,
0.0272652283,
0.0496819988,
0.0283708088,
0.0068332525,
0.0154010272,
0.0006548389,
-0.0006254636,
-0.0090074372,
0.0337576382,
0.0244926885,
0.0389347076,
0.0026570123,
0.0598431639,
-0.0705835968,
0.0515520647,
-0.0335073657,
-0.0493119061,
-0.0687357336,
0.0285121817,
0.1480151266,
0.0404416509,
0.0375690162,
-0.0043105339,
-0.0095645739,
-0.0282579716,
-0.0082809059,
0.0153043279,
0.0095725944,
0.0034151089,
0.0336892456,
-0.0339978114,
0.0017577766,
0.0121324826,
0.0068519022,
-0.0476389974,
-0.0197156575,
0.0128502892,
-0.0171267986,
-0.0427151658,
-0.0185358692,
-0.0719987825,
-0.0273024421,
-0.0483987518,
0.0944024473,
-0.0826949403,
0.0002819686,
0.0293470453,
0.0093054548,
0.0098530957,
0.0095932204,
0.0375181884,
0.0009777121,
-0.0301644038,
0.0286660772,
-0.0115809897,
-0.0169737767,
-0.0702548698,
-0.0237539634,
0.0291542169,
-0.0132140033,
-0.0172733981,
0.005271323,
-0.015118042,
0.03903988,
-0.0278414302,
-0.0440271795,
2.110583806e-34,
0.0108933682,
0.0255205277,
0.0045016934,
-0.0354911759,
0.041820094,
-0.0221706126,
-0.0114457812,
0.0127545418,
0.0218835641,
-0.0028673671,
-0.0047184215
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.02185v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.02185v3 | Citation: A Key to Building Responsible and Accountable Large Language Models | 2023-07-05T10:25:45 | 2024-03-31T19:47:47 | Jie Huang, Kevin Chen-Chuan Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR | Large Language Models (LLMs) bring transformative benefits alongside unique
challenges, including intellectual property (IP) and ethical concerns. This
position paper explores a novel angle to mitigate these risks, drawing
parallels between LLMs and established web systems. We identify "citation" -
the acknowledgement or reference to a source or evidence - as a crucial yet
missing component in LLMs. Incorporating citation could enhance content
transparency and verifiability, thereby confronting the IP and ethical issues
in the deployment of LLMs. We further propose that a comprehensive citation
mechanism for LLMs should account for both non-parametric and parametric
content. Despite the complexity of implementing such a citation mechanism,
along with the potential pitfalls, we advocate for its development. Building on
this foundation, we outline several research problems in this area, aiming to
guide future explorations towards building more responsible and accountable
LLMs. | [
0.0762508959,
0.0615570657,
-0.0280998219,
0.0281833764,
-0.0525266603,
-0.0085822726,
0.0571919456,
0.0254746992,
0.0485109612,
-0.077809386,
-0.0054378649,
0.0201432072,
-0.0107964128,
-0.0061013666,
0.0315877013,
0.0143766589,
-0.0201767739,
-0.0031295065,
0.0553033277,
-0.0077728508,
0.0180754624,
0.0508021265,
0.0525254384,
0.022709813,
0.017694911,
-0.0046288944,
0.0456449762,
-0.0356265567,
0.0028911754,
-0.0272651203,
-0.029028045,
0.0268898308,
-0.0193057265,
0.0586697496,
0.0000019948,
-0.0728082806,
0.0004611627,
0.0398170203,
-0.0391796492,
0.0492548272,
0.0223660413,
0.0364524312,
-0.0182807539,
-0.006776284,
-0.0128814774,
0.0264877118,
0.0221103355,
0.0116160819,
0.0364760943,
-0.0197396781,
-0.0105310772,
-0.0394436195,
0.0323118865,
-0.0045138281,
-0.0201529488,
0.0084904637,
0.0334440917,
0.0443702564,
0.0316353552,
0.0542008877,
0.0526370518,
0.0910969377,
0.0133830272,
-0.0442764014,
-0.0059429323,
-0.0158465598,
-0.0082369726,
0.0096217208,
0.0315479189,
0.0238643829,
0.0534241609,
-0.0355676599,
0.0554672219,
0.0091953063,
0.001117469,
0.0337628275,
-0.0448922478,
0.0875329673,
0.0036842874,
0.0167300981,
0.005040627,
-0.0449696146,
0.030702116,
0.058518704,
0.0257571489,
0.0220900793,
0.0106638446,
-0.0051884144,
-0.0408408158,
-0.0034976231,
0.027438106,
-0.0693449154,
0.0301620755,
0.0235802848,
0.0326885842,
0.0250928719,
0.0138245765,
-0.0011998338,
0.067712687,
-0.0689712241,
0.008593292,
-0.0371584967,
-0.0036395907,
0.0442923494,
-0.0270277802,
0.0229470413,
-0.0577147938,
0.0232051965,
0.019675754,
-0.0170929339,
-0.0148548167,
-0.0171982367,
0.0077259019,
0.0307538267,
-0.0052921642,
0.0287208296,
-0.0137622114,
0.0638094246,
-0.0179524403,
0.0485269427,
0.004296477,
-0.0238606632,
0.0112823257,
-0.0229136571,
0.002570871,
-0.0040371343,
0.0472041517,
0.03909472,
-0.0312758721,
-0.0712885037,
0.0366945937,
0.0199751053,
-0.0020971857,
0.0163703226,
0.0080604888,
0.1022706926,
0.0483742431,
0.0267916694,
-0.0531100146,
-0.0795422047,
-0.0014689683,
-0.0090558482,
-0.0312168133,
-0.0967873558,
0.0010963859,
0.0572451241,
-0.0266493391,
-0.0758036003,
0.0100505445,
0.0345464945,
-0.0461243801,
-0.0064563537,
-0.0682906881,
0.0233232528,
0.0202599242,
0.0172736999,
0.0381338112,
0.0333019122,
0.0613099188,
0.0171131026,
0.0542171486,
0.0317490436,
0.014682875,
0.0150116999,
-0.0011852595,
0.0460798442,
-0.0294862315,
0.0144559052,
0.0026270314,
-0.0221087635,
-0.0208527464,
0.0825890005,
-0.0270836633,
0.0100654922,
0.097939305,
0.0507692955,
-0.0620938651,
0.0081224991,
0.0095230145,
0.0091101006,
0.0121425847,
-0.0536685623,
-0.012168875,
0.0111072268,
0.0124457022,
0.0009645968,
-0.0122501468,
0.0375213288,
0.00302166,
-0.0229691919,
-0.0219846759,
-0.02844695,
0.0003786991,
0.0467927456,
-0.0017633269,
-0.0199634526,
0.0297199376,
0.0843717381,
-0.0041083284,
-0.0376156047,
0.0262049753,
-0.044324968,
0.0370703936,
0.0320121273,
0.062359672,
0.0142786652,
0.0600701012,
-0.0408879668,
-0.0109542999,
0.0612874441,
-0.012952609,
-0.0234902687,
-0.0176061932,
0.0090940492,
-0.0419569127,
0.0207791775,
-0.016148841,
-0.0142101813,
-0.0301193874,
0.0151245221,
0.0166237783,
-0.0331528783,
-0.055509612,
-0.0039935079,
-0.0277197622,
-0.0088490294,
-0.0741952434,
0.0014512078,
0.0121558085,
0.0393253602,
-0.0075623835,
-0.0019847995,
0.0190338437,
0.0196024049,
-0.0115302196,
0.0119642122,
0.0595850646,
0.097226724,
0.0554931015,
-0.0281919912,
0.0158526059,
-0.0403428115,
-0.0013739256,
-0.0018262875,
0.0224062093,
-0.0465538874,
0.0294352118,
-0.0193595253,
-0.010610682,
-0.0569300167,
-0.0336899683,
-0.0526939742,
0.0012968259,
-0.0053739576,
0.0221983604,
0.0259820744,
-0.0450618751,
0.0291256476,
0.0162211638,
-0.0376983956,
0.0607901625,
-0.0155632636,
0.0456359237,
0.0372748077,
-0.0141645707,
-0.0010893522,
-0.0061843367,
-0.0262973253,
-0.0504615083,
0.0122866472,
0.0216865223,
0.0011339424,
-0.0002214378,
-0.0080614621,
0.0080094254,
-0.0210989546,
-0.0794827193,
-0.0074511082,
0.0061049205,
0.0400524288,
-0.0120030325,
-0.0173421819,
-0.0292209238,
-0.0001586821,
0.0046029072,
0.0247477237,
0.0355154723,
-0.0094119338,
-0.0795657933,
0.0099867499,
-0.0654924437,
-0.0174402129,
0.008812014,
-0.0092217913,
-0.0110853342,
0.0074205897,
-0.0146235414,
0.0052192798,
0.0030783419,
-0.0233195852,
0.0370284282,
-0.0045416085,
-0.0721230134,
-0.0584406815,
0.0142319323,
-0.0331368111,
-0.0394476615,
-0.0430093557,
0.0339826159,
-0.0156502631,
-0.0007408287,
-0.0110657811,
0.012318749,
0.0014242162,
-0.0436125547,
-0.0007268012,
-0.0077245901,
-0.0631241351,
-0.0431952327,
0.0495563112,
0.0277918205,
-0.0470293537,
0.0204833187,
-0.0611671172,
0.0395340621,
-0.0391081609,
-0.0178192314,
-0.0195601489,
0.0352307186,
-0.0101265823,
0.0242872499,
0.0154335191,
-0.0247194953,
-0.0166858863,
0.0116116619,
0.0862342045,
-0.0488228463,
0.0355992988,
0.0056023439,
0.0284288656,
-0.0051697451,
-0.0087257167,
-0.0202945862,
0.0038503634,
-0.0373832546,
0.0229794644,
0.0245490074,
0.031831108,
0.0125754662,
-0.01334076,
0.1057841927,
0.0056695854,
0.0186501145,
-0.0044773892,
-0.0371527374,
-0.0051806653,
-0.010061847,
-0.0233267248,
0.0633043945,
0.0043595298,
-0.0499846078,
0.0379101746,
0.0225436259,
-0.009821211,
0.024882013,
-0.0409226157,
0.034542121,
-0.0363976955,
-0.0195674989,
0.0107582333,
-0.004657655,
-0.0515721887,
0.034342967,
0.0836610049,
0.0252169911,
-0.0603622012,
-0.0403261445,
-0.0412035063,
-0.0604257807,
0.0159105659,
0.0077518057,
-0.1142517477,
0.0420759283,
-0.006037083,
-0.0141121149,
-0.0464675874,
-0.007601676,
0.011576077,
-0.0593275242,
0.0475861356,
0.0038867064,
0.0275483094,
0.0003337784,
-0.0371079557,
0.0009493839,
0.0037390352,
-0.0136211822,
-0.0021859659,
-0.042021554,
-0.02857331,
0.0340735242,
-0.0175849739,
-0.0393729508,
-0.0106580993,
-0.0916570053,
0.0323882215,
0.0426214449,
0.0365291089,
-0.0323812589,
-0.0110160243,
-0.0056505292,
-0.0490575843,
-0.0615321845,
0.0032540502,
-0.0204617921,
0.0174303837,
0.0001937471,
-0.0481160022,
-0.0298978332,
0.0117611866,
-0.0339407586,
-0.0196705256,
0.0963700935,
0.0038558338,
0.0193342008,
-0.0097172018,
-0.0332595371,
0.0149922315,
0.0534263365,
0.0167911295,
-0.0056748493,
-0.0135942344,
-0.0331813619,
-0.0046413532,
0.0140594458,
-0.0387620218,
0.0064445287,
-0.0473049097,
-0.0239112023,
-0.0953013673,
-0.0227767173,
-0.0547183305,
-0.020438781,
0.067833893,
0.0216451082,
0.0798614174,
-0.0537952669,
-0.0072796,
-0.0247502699,
-0.081023775,
0.0130521208,
-0.0421696827,
0.0369890966,
0.0089992341,
-0.016642129,
0.0125605017,
0.0129110739,
0.034765698,
-0.0222165417,
0.0073048258,
-0.0028230178,
0.0246943347,
-0.0171850529,
-0.0153112579,
-0.0724881589,
0.0328746215,
0.0170970447,
-0.0163210426,
0.0070954389,
0.0325239003,
-0.0060058846,
-0.0021234837,
0.0160799138,
-0.0603815429,
-0.0049310429,
0.0080782836,
-0.0238522049,
-0.0266681742,
-0.0218493193,
0.0156075926,
0.0498519838,
-0.0178373326,
-0.0236869901,
0.026670089,
-0.0027120265,
-0.0000105587,
-0.0286365096,
-0.0062465221,
-0.0154876392,
0.0253594369,
-0.0106141325,
0.0119416248,
-0.004532245,
0.0508473888,
-0.0170338321,
0.0248979423,
-0.0220718011,
0.0581725203,
-0.0236305296,
0.0301645808,
0.0015995892,
-0.0153979622,
-0.0321857482,
-0.0071370639,
-0.0182266943,
0.0415375084,
-0.0018154603,
0.045247335,
0.0148378713,
-0.0333023518,
0.0261474717,
0.0277449656,
-0.03586426,
-0.0336120836,
0.0095921103,
-0.014827949,
0.0338434353,
0.0406578146,
0.0734957159,
-0.0409728438,
-0.0133701405,
0.0002406842,
-0.0046266848,
-0.0008981577,
-0.0528411604,
0.0100665642,
0.0106129283,
-0.0454303361,
0.0324295089,
0.0209463704,
0.0419180654,
0.0209927168,
-0.059910588,
-0.0272943787,
0.0100379772,
-0.0634570196,
-0.0238161758,
-0.0108367521,
-0.0437246487,
-0.0590835884,
-0.0575526804,
-0.0758819655,
-0.013948285,
0.0183665063,
-0.0033734997,
-0.0405524559,
-0.0110185277,
0.0215666071,
0.0580490381,
-0.0509905443,
-0.0707262456,
0.0516558699,
0.0013353796,
-0.0316073559,
-0.0056251967,
-5.880492407e-33,
0.0171901006,
-0.0077930205,
-0.0006682415,
0.0019802849,
-0.0027641614,
0.0236467849,
-0.0394632369,
-0.0148130553,
-0.0562716462,
0.0168143157,
-0.0297631379,
-0.008722391,
0.0187274795,
-0.0022706087,
0.0354327038,
-0.0168483611,
0.0218912549,
0.0046193134,
0.0064954744,
0.0353265405,
0.0391514264,
-0.0563326776,
0.0756367296,
-0.1165516898,
0.0726176277,
-0.0408912934,
-0.0366322771,
0.008854554,
0.0107647674,
0.0724763274,
0.0042199171,
0.0301469471,
0.005298723,
-0.0479010232,
0.0120309135,
0.0077961516,
-0.0323872417,
0.033342734,
0.0786335915,
0.0074668578,
0.0225532092,
-0.0395742431,
0.0414761379,
-0.0349283628,
-0.0230608024,
0.0279674679,
0.0368069969,
-0.0478573591,
-0.0216146037,
-0.0629384071,
-0.0432421602,
0.0159495529,
0.0142686078,
0.091651246,
0.0237477832,
0.0071945162,
-0.0118161552,
0.0505033471,
-0.0618860163,
0.0197873786,
-0.0102956546,
-0.0115115857,
0.0453803279,
-0.0169859156,
0.0141204344,
0.0397886895,
-0.0247707311,
-0.0114834681,
0.0092869867,
-0.0218510777,
-0.017009316,
0.0353171304,
0.0588866659,
0.0782505795,
-0.0758788511,
-0.0151004316,
-0.0373526663,
-0.0068199965,
0.0063000089,
0.0359266326,
0.0294351038,
-0.0335311741,
-0.0407765135,
-0.028778011,
-0.0141198076,
-0.0562855564,
-0.0268732458,
-0.0191522427,
0.0033192716,
-0.0164056085,
-0.0138144381,
0.0370877981,
0.0496727936,
-0.0671429485,
-0.0855537131,
0.0579979382,
0.0212196633,
0.0428652987,
0.0237166975,
0.0011199049,
-0.0438102335,
-0.0025345078,
-0.0147672687,
-0.0174430236,
0.0116924066,
0.0129978573,
0.017770486,
0.0103638815,
-0.0296743084,
0.0209086966,
-0.0102946647,
0.0210602116,
-0.004338,
-0.0369532481,
0.0066849818,
0.0094030285,
0.0485952906,
0.0169629771,
0.044840131,
-0.0202382058,
-0.0077283271,
0.0124963941,
-0.0151605038,
0.0051660901,
-0.0308945943,
0.0123600019,
-0.0190035608,
0.0941776633,
0.0382913053,
-0.0211714972,
-0.0016712879,
-0.0216201227,
2.794e-7,
0.0390715301,
0.0145302098,
-0.0200141184,
-0.0240501985,
0.0114361048,
0.0323523208,
0.0481965989,
0.0460854396,
0.0014874665,
-0.0072460673,
-0.0225782227,
-0.0342767276,
0.0307869446,
0.0307110883,
-0.0847155228,
-0.0206656978,
-0.0635126904,
-0.0277249161,
-0.050409805,
-0.0090721855,
-0.0119547928,
0.0072450018,
0.0169910491,
-0.005698632,
-0.0462126769,
-0.035103187,
0.0118278572,
-0.0436167233,
0.010775934,
0.0370445289,
0.0386862829,
0.0223400872,
0.0446393192,
-0.0108260028,
-0.0124576716,
-0.0054835854,
-0.027611183,
0.0568482801,
0.0240461286,
0.0422990732,
-0.0163867995,
-0.1200380325,
0.0576413833,
-0.0818029195,
0.0392812528,
0.0482957847,
-0.0162718762,
-0.0313082077,
-0.0484202206,
-0.0678575858,
-0.0177363995,
-0.0172163937,
-0.0168640241,
0.0266800709,
-0.0581516027,
-0.0028281873,
-0.0045069545,
-0.0477729477,
-0.009345741,
0.0023496943,
0.0030529958,
-0.038989149,
0.0172824822,
-0.0270825922,
0.0125450958,
-0.0370387584,
0.093496047,
2.327929957e-34,
-0.0189998187,
-0.0461874232,
0.0194222499,
0.0440739207,
0.0281923115,
0.0641162544,
-0.0483458452,
0.0171047542,
-0.0019327984,
-0.0108952066,
-0.0010149173
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.02179v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.02179v2 | Open-Source LLMs for Text Annotation: A Practical Guide for Model Setting and Fine-Tuning | 2023-07-05T10:15:07 | 2024-05-29T12:29:08 | Meysam Alizadeh, Maël Kubli, Zeynab Samei, Shirin Dehghani, Mohammadmasiha Zahedivafa, Juan Diego Bermeo, Maria Korobeynikova, Fabrizio Gilardi | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper studies the performance of open-source Large Language Models
(LLMs) in text classification tasks typical for political science research. By
examining tasks like stance, topic, and relevance classification, we aim to
guide scholars in making informed decisions about their use of LLMs for text
analysis. Specifically, we conduct an assessment of both zero-shot and
fine-tuned LLMs across a range of text annotation tasks using news articles and
tweets datasets. Our analysis shows that fine-tuning improves the performance
of open-source LLMs, allowing them to match or even surpass zero-shot GPT-3.5
and GPT-4, though still lagging behind fine-tuned GPT-3.5. We further establish
that fine-tuning is preferable to few-shot training with a relatively modest
quantity of annotated text. Our findings show that fine-tuned open-source LLMs
can be effectively deployed in a broad spectrum of text annotation
applications. We provide a Python notebook facilitating the application of LLMs
in text annotation for other researchers. | [
0.0187991522,
0.039448984,
0.0460612215,
0.012547316,
-0.0375054851,
0.0463046171,
0.0051595536,
0.0046420922,
0.0295949411,
-0.1101755798,
0.0121970791,
-0.0065332507,
-0.0484570079,
0.0021032814,
-0.0319642685,
-0.0163207985,
0.049686607,
0.0132966563,
0.0449253879,
0.0030650159,
0.0271298457,
0.0366076641,
-0.0039021187,
0.0559396632,
0.002773992,
-0.0183294527,
-0.0092203682,
-0.0013224828,
0.0515276231,
-0.0174660198,
0.0118861441,
0.0604240634,
0.0408516861,
0.0782572776,
0.0000017581,
-0.0351672657,
-0.0259157419,
-0.0000404915,
0.0231296849,
0.0364333093,
0.0675601661,
-0.0370257087,
-0.0123549998,
0.02842829,
-0.0404175408,
0.0118018473,
0.0581882447,
0.0226387531,
0.0676784292,
0.0821681321,
0.0006789601,
-0.0218488835,
0.0286706667,
-0.0417088903,
-0.0073706727,
-0.0427791215,
0.056060452,
0.0121847633,
-0.0425972156,
0.070621565,
0.0224135034,
0.0095450245,
0.0108742239,
-0.0172308367,
-0.0051994128,
0.0066951727,
-0.0497975498,
-0.0131599326,
0.0111135328,
0.0236634742,
0.0468311757,
-0.0504164658,
0.023000842,
-0.0362726897,
-0.0088521121,
0.0197800323,
-0.0354312621,
0.0339237414,
-0.0115302419,
0.04888051,
0.0302968044,
-0.0295524579,
0.0290447958,
0.0641742796,
0.0219847821,
0.0601483174,
-0.0237696711,
-0.0276861936,
0.0303803459,
0.0176165644,
-0.0288180355,
-0.0351202786,
-0.0025718648,
-0.0103816343,
0.0415034704,
0.007628547,
-0.0211078152,
0.0047021471,
0.0446904711,
-0.0762553364,
-0.0079441071,
0.0161044188,
-0.0186161101,
0.0823604912,
0.0175488424,
-0.0233126469,
-0.0324481018,
0.0069855987,
0.0073350994,
0.0034312063,
-0.0709037855,
0.007397464,
0.0021109676,
0.0192217678,
-0.0263877232,
-0.0073759626,
-0.0345882103,
0.0028938185,
-0.0052638729,
-0.0075358469,
-0.002873115,
-0.031652838,
-0.0082907546,
-0.008056581,
-0.0301269665,
0.0398389846,
-0.0044012186,
0.01736697,
-0.0257717706,
-0.0042052772,
0.0097609954,
0.0462901108,
0.0006575556,
-0.0251670908,
0.0095863128,
0.0088025657,
0.0109558227,
-0.0452510044,
-0.0241837818,
0.0273146816,
-0.0217400789,
-0.0674511194,
0.0168382153,
-0.0576471239,
-0.0215110332,
0.0127950199,
0.0077728652,
-0.0374798104,
0.0075114169,
0.0367088579,
-0.027093932,
0.0549432263,
0.0065523437,
-0.0190386586,
0.0472513959,
0.0105015943,
0.0271240007,
0.1091488674,
0.0093874512,
0.0432322659,
0.0335134007,
-0.019154096,
-0.0136626773,
0.0320407376,
-0.0089454511,
0.059038002,
-0.0044699707,
0.0507641025,
-0.0194634106,
-0.0017047556,
0.004277173,
0.0308836009,
0.000148339,
0.0031610145,
0.0565078966,
0.059773121,
0.0298247635,
0.0109908935,
0.0023145035,
0.0491932221,
0.0152590498,
-0.0340256169,
-0.009431513,
0.0415747687,
-0.0356037766,
-0.0261059385,
0.0269738249,
0.017207982,
-0.0234075747,
-0.0334958322,
-0.0356195197,
-0.0007181644,
-0.0019266161,
0.0024306891,
0.0582626164,
-0.05366477,
-0.0388614126,
0.0225035995,
0.0468198545,
-0.0460239574,
0.0027596119,
-0.0628939494,
0.0494752154,
0.0171400718,
0.0113483248,
-0.0603776947,
-0.0077825454,
-0.0722802728,
0.0492826216,
0.0701267719,
0.0297289956,
-0.0124274669,
-0.0395868421,
-0.0320642404,
-0.0344153456,
-0.0293449089,
0.0509266295,
0.0423230976,
0.0136381406,
0.009148201,
0.0216043759,
-0.0103240265,
-0.0156558827,
0.0423160493,
0.0082255146,
-0.0232377257,
0.0109522697,
-0.0201762971,
0.0406199656,
0.0544685647,
-0.0159710944,
-0.0332699679,
0.0273500942,
-0.0031598329,
-0.0208135154,
-0.047681652,
0.0061713317,
0.017832946,
0.0261243563,
0.0075598694,
-0.0098334309,
0.0335880183,
-0.0493862219,
-0.0160860326,
0.0212359224,
0.0115143033,
-0.0077128159,
-0.083720766,
-0.0269072037,
-0.0692602023,
0.0003908518,
-0.0623457022,
0.0590694509,
0.012298923,
0.0017713734,
0.0137306629,
-0.0556216985,
0.0502353236,
-0.0107565494,
-0.0503297485,
-0.0054970914,
0.0147166746,
0.0493822619,
0.0451838188,
0.0147783086,
-0.0302490648,
-0.0578113273,
-0.0951990634,
0.040380504,
-0.0465756953,
0.029401036,
0.0206699409,
-0.0092445835,
-0.0133963833,
0.0160320718,
0.0115054641,
-0.02502588,
-0.0238797851,
0.0117673427,
0.0162928738,
-0.0105295675,
0.0302855615,
-0.0389879681,
0.008244494,
-0.0027557423,
0.0148730827,
0.0169352219,
-0.0354468636,
-0.0118833948,
0.0275955405,
-0.0302712899,
-0.0064326241,
-0.0200439617,
-0.0182798747,
0.0066590509,
0.00214917,
-0.0096786283,
0.0483288579,
0.0231088139,
0.0512434058,
0.0205895826,
0.0348782688,
-0.0665702522,
-0.0018822765,
-0.0202708971,
-0.0142785739,
-0.0399680771,
0.0108706439,
0.0170145854,
0.0430713929,
-0.0165265258,
0.0012997914,
-0.0752338544,
0.0398179963,
-0.0313500986,
0.0057255845,
-0.007502987,
0.0181725267,
-0.0139270155,
-0.0164485872,
-0.000128425,
-0.0407123156,
0.016991362,
-0.0111345928,
0.0497027896,
-0.0281330906,
-0.0460836478,
-0.0765769929,
0.0527511425,
-0.0058444291,
-0.0331151411,
-0.0069498676,
0.0336943939,
0.0087105548,
-0.0129214115,
0.020248184,
-0.0252705049,
0.0517936498,
-0.0178867672,
0.054430075,
-0.0567353852,
-0.0161914248,
0.02515723,
-0.0918669105,
-0.0635428801,
0.0170594584,
0.002133104,
-0.0268647708,
0.0012612565,
0.0379755646,
0.0303705409,
0.0232229214,
-0.0143563068,
0.0072249188,
0.0050714109,
-0.007402136,
0.0163573604,
-0.0317474976,
-0.0276310258,
0.0076595205,
-0.0068198736,
0.0213537309,
-0.011958953,
0.0243412573,
-0.04286718,
-0.0294883791,
0.0254627354,
-0.0645455942,
-0.0315543972,
-0.0405485518,
0.051794827,
-0.0471551567,
0.0287434347,
0.1186259091,
0.0299975611,
-0.075830631,
-0.0407608673,
0.0051703169,
0.0189275369,
0.0185557809,
0.000440285,
-0.1142474487,
-0.0214882325,
-0.0151073597,
0.0216848943,
-0.0238479432,
-0.0233469419,
-0.0153347962,
-0.0947218984,
0.0243917275,
-0.0205949992,
-0.0560269803,
0.0123352595,
-0.0853229687,
0.0321435742,
-0.0854017511,
-0.0326463506,
-0.0112198079,
-0.0103765149,
0.0168386493,
0.0450567342,
-0.0527230315,
-0.0576390289,
0.0039652884,
-0.0121614672,
0.0307650361,
0.0329562537,
0.0383292995,
-0.0127466191,
0.0049673682,
0.0607891753,
-0.0089563401,
-0.0201537721,
-0.0328170545,
0.0560179614,
-0.0367570817,
-0.0007111361,
-0.0022802816,
0.0341706127,
-0.0062378258,
-0.0155860344,
0.0065377895,
0.0576831214,
-0.0142093236,
0.0229969453,
-0.0186146926,
0.0012850361,
0.0139258243,
0.0691407546,
-0.0003848805,
-0.0498379059,
-0.0233990271,
-0.0415309854,
0.0115884459,
-0.0428830422,
-0.0270923302,
-0.021195164,
-0.0424869657,
-0.0131399706,
0.0011886882,
-0.0279780347,
0.0156369526,
-0.012809515,
-0.014361741,
0.0332880691,
-0.0096288975,
0.0137229767,
-0.0080672102,
0.0407278463,
-0.0541929565,
-0.0051911953,
-0.0184501708,
-0.0297571216,
0.052704215,
-0.0097486591,
-0.040772628,
-0.0220810026,
-0.0942137837,
-0.0448655114,
-0.01453056,
-0.0027324019,
0.0225728899,
0.0065814089,
0.0026200369,
-0.0619565919,
0.0129966596,
0.0914381072,
-0.0077328007,
-0.0012818155,
0.0261537023,
0.0402608775,
-0.0245049894,
0.0154916095,
-0.0270421281,
0.0280426182,
0.0215935949,
-0.0068456731,
-0.0423065349,
-0.0092063928,
-0.0102066118,
0.001326627,
0.0711249933,
0.0038525148,
-0.0775601417,
-0.0536959171,
-0.014274966,
0.0003099251,
-0.0298813246,
-0.0234257653,
0.0059591597,
0.0321986377,
-0.0611917302,
-0.072298035,
0.0462892838,
-0.0174044911,
0.0819871649,
-0.0805907324,
0.0511542633,
0.0210912172,
0.0047041122,
-0.0105681568,
-0.0223703068,
-0.0362637416,
0.009757353,
-0.0021454308,
-0.0017598287,
-0.0171535406,
0.0382534824,
-0.0156088052,
0.0059783282,
0.0814806744,
-0.0001027086,
-0.0487528294,
-0.0055366699,
-0.0432392955,
0.0552845038,
0.0558465831,
-0.0122729866,
0.0556633733,
-0.0190306678,
-0.0370464437,
-0.0293326285,
0.0346598998,
0.003334186,
-0.0164143704,
0.0266634915,
0.0065384218,
-0.0517358556,
0.0416605808,
0.0442782864,
0.0242321268,
0.0253712479,
0.0551201515,
-0.0348777883,
-0.0356612206,
-0.0264113378,
-0.0016863442,
0.0273159463,
-0.0005820237,
-0.0085145412,
-0.0667875558,
-0.0027360637,
0.0197842624,
-0.0252614878,
-0.0227667745,
-0.0042045307,
0.0008648394,
0.0571262464,
-0.0295311455,
0.0248298347,
-0.0852094889,
-0.0114942361,
-0.0351506695,
-0.0172363613,
-0.0012534439,
-6.228066618e-33,
-0.0065408666,
-0.0147857461,
0.0145093268,
0.0076778014,
-0.0194142107,
0.0157738589,
0.0176219512,
0.0074100168,
-0.026904203,
-0.0062336018,
0.0064744353,
0.0413160585,
0.0048165317,
0.0362077691,
0.0025448154,
-0.0160209313,
0.0090388833,
-0.0141328992,
-0.0274049416,
0.0309113879,
0.0405011997,
-0.0266029704,
0.0454749689,
-0.0540455319,
0.0501614362,
-0.0165808368,
-0.0266078413,
-0.0122329481,
-0.0050628413,
0.0518701524,
-0.0218547918,
0.0333150066,
0.0509842262,
-0.0503148809,
0.0351489112,
0.0427711383,
-0.026952941,
0.0039600111,
-0.0016351384,
-0.034485992,
0.0199942682,
-0.0395070314,
0.0100092338,
0.0326415859,
-0.0384381264,
-0.02605737,
0.048409041,
-0.0201823991,
-0.0095696598,
-0.0389449857,
-0.0375420712,
0.0739747435,
-0.0346015021,
-0.0073148725,
-0.0027450721,
0.0254292842,
0.0344682895,
0.0934104472,
-0.0286332741,
0.0039009268,
-0.0283806827,
0.0070969556,
0.01735688,
-0.0139363445,
-0.0041668401,
0.0673594177,
-0.0294554904,
0.0327409133,
-0.0549361296,
-0.0258120503,
0.0150979264,
-0.0052105663,
0.0515372753,
0.0786611214,
0.0227282178,
-0.008201546,
-0.1100127771,
0.0043966239,
0.0474545434,
0.0062564397,
0.0424805805,
0.0149414791,
0.0174426176,
-0.0043522925,
-0.0573104136,
-0.0459109396,
-0.0268614814,
-0.0137073938,
-0.0089381384,
0.0169610064,
-0.0394937135,
0.0474529453,
0.0347634852,
-0.0218130443,
0.0083754566,
0.0444842577,
-0.0300981104,
0.0422560871,
0.0044003306,
0.0314712077,
-0.0994163305,
-0.0225734916,
-0.007015551,
0.0013195449,
0.0179143865,
-0.0348992348,
0.0572342835,
0.0092678685,
-0.063261196,
-0.0093440441,
-0.0114725856,
0.0322103128,
-0.0541544184,
0.0581480078,
0.0112742577,
0.015508797,
0.0399762616,
0.0576982386,
0.0332524218,
0.0104631968,
0.0258606095,
-0.0542722493,
-0.0195428133,
-0.0190036055,
-0.0051475582,
0.0126118362,
0.0233053397,
0.053694956,
-0.0090498189,
-0.052877564,
-0.0009225514,
0.0080189835,
2.496e-7,
0.0730655044,
0.070599772,
-0.0274362098,
-0.0208939537,
0.0181252435,
0.0353440419,
0.001596615,
0.046725437,
-0.0106768496,
-0.0256894138,
-0.0100104278,
0.0189860091,
0.0657602102,
0.0151690124,
-0.078809455,
0.0038386236,
-0.0822859257,
0.028374454,
-0.0569490008,
0.0319922417,
-0.0031028502,
0.0508919246,
0.0424733348,
0.0147986189,
-0.0159901865,
-0.0410951041,
0.0956609398,
-0.0490496308,
-0.0497497246,
0.0425643623,
0.0484072231,
0.0240664333,
0.0142882122,
0.0112832086,
-0.0150132589,
0.0085819978,
0.0190712828,
0.0955226868,
0.0265874397,
-0.0204163976,
-0.002827513,
-0.0159459542,
0.0201092921,
-0.0344778374,
0.1069613248,
-0.0549805239,
-0.0424362347,
-0.0677894652,
-0.0284679458,
-0.022607496,
0.0581415854,
-0.003605119,
0.0009507367,
0.0023520552,
-0.0294769853,
-0.019265186,
-0.0159204919,
-0.0414431915,
-0.0172689315,
-0.0148591017,
-0.0383043773,
-0.0513373502,
-0.00485441,
0.005227875,
0.0397654697,
-0.0457578525,
0.0195873007,
1.930048537e-34,
0.0513300858,
-0.0415963531,
-0.0121377045,
-0.014491871,
0.0214576107,
0.0506617464,
0.0050930441,
-0.0131043186,
-0.0060635712,
-0.0763297677,
0.0386883505
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2307.02157v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2307.02157v1 | Generative Job Recommendations with Large Language Model | 2023-07-05T09:58:08 | 2023-07-05T09:58:08 | Zhi Zheng, Zhaopeng Qiu, Xiao Hu, Likang Wu, Hengshu Zhu, Hui Xiong | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | The rapid development of online recruitment services has encouraged the
utilization of recommender systems to streamline the job seeking process.
Predominantly, current job recommendations deploy either collaborative
filtering or person-job matching strategies. However, these models tend to
operate as "black-box" systems and lack the capacity to offer explainable
guidance to job seekers. Moreover, conventional matching-based recommendation
methods are limited to retrieving and ranking existing jobs in the database,
restricting their potential as comprehensive career AI advisors. To this end,
here we present GIRL (GeneratIve job Recommendation based on Large language
models), a novel approach inspired by recent advancements in the field of Large
Language Models (LLMs). We initially employ a Supervised Fine-Tuning (SFT)
strategy to instruct the LLM-based generator in crafting suitable Job
Descriptions (JDs) based on the Curriculum Vitae (CV) of a job seeker.
Moreover, we propose to train a model which can evaluate the matching degree
between CVs and JDs as a reward model, and we use Proximal Policy Optimization
(PPO)-based Reinforcement Learning (RL) method to further fine-tine the
generator. This aligns the generator with recruiter feedback, tailoring the
output to better meet employer preferences. In particular, GIRL serves as a job
seeker-centric generative model, providing job suggestions without the need of
a candidate set. This capability also enhances the performance of existing job
recommendation models by supplementing job seeking features with generated
content. With extensive experiments on a large-scale real-world dataset, we
demonstrate the substantial effectiveness of our approach. We believe that GIRL
introduces a paradigm-shifting approach to job recommendation systems,
fostering a more personalized and comprehensive job-seeking experience. | [
0.0827006474,
0.0250786226,
0.0074074292,
-0.0533789285,
0.0158590227,
-0.0338669419,
-0.0131472899,
0.0243135151,
0.0107667893,
0.0008733377,
-0.0221540909,
-0.0069466592,
-0.0200195573,
0.0497250259,
0.0124150552,
-0.0162684638,
-0.0054335766,
-0.0010776342,
-0.001093962,
-0.0057844892,
0.0029886276,
0.0561412871,
0.0182113033,
0.079114981,
0.0286126751,
-0.0051264507,
0.0307071395,
0.0044566495,
0.0392139703,
0.0099825347,
0.0257515237,
-0.0159216374,
0.0163777694,
-0.021940222,
0.0000020059,
-0.0245851595,
-0.0072548417,
0.0166812055,
0.0183321889,
-0.0617062859,
0.0257301908,
0.0211960953,
-0.0030786651,
0.0393394008,
-0.0289257728,
0.0348860212,
0.0463817641,
0.0211856365,
0.023981804,
0.0586791933,
0.0130437687,
-0.0433791652,
0.0040704506,
-0.0469449311,
0.0456917994,
-0.0073534083,
0.0195005871,
-0.0444330163,
0.0489445776,
0.0140983695,
-0.0019978369,
-0.0457547307,
-0.033879362,
-0.0941406861,
0.0492030717,
0.0383490175,
0.0167617332,
-0.0090431375,
0.0362411141,
0.0522236861,
-0.0379795507,
-0.0190127939,
-0.0032663655,
-0.0308303088,
0.0347900949,
0.0295063537,
-0.0090690916,
0.0097202156,
-0.0315534845,
0.0053648287,
0.0165832713,
0.0097277295,
0.0155475549,
0.0002482375,
-0.0081487438,
0.0977395996,
-0.0082644718,
-0.0473981835,
0.0311957505,
0.0059373104,
0.0420055017,
-0.0242080353,
0.029067453,
0.0211553983,
-0.0946525112,
-0.0244945884,
-0.0141945789,
0.0219356902,
0.0094817895,
-0.0066327942,
0.0120200999,
0.0393883102,
0.0066629858,
0.0347749963,
0.0087794019,
0.0277812555,
-0.0062197819,
-0.0196235254,
-0.0431230366,
-0.0309408344,
-0.0834127441,
-0.0225746185,
-0.0231347047,
0.0051230337,
-0.0123100756,
0.0115380082,
-0.0641423687,
0.019131545,
-0.04925837,
0.0410202704,
0.0445625335,
0.0646237135,
-0.0349094905,
0.0145041691,
-0.0946747065,
0.0002482694,
-0.0207249355,
0.0056947623,
0.0051064678,
0.0220688637,
0.0390760563,
0.0326554589,
0.0047476096,
-0.0368682444,
0.03455678,
0.0540007353,
0.0395963937,
0.0097496454,
-0.0213924889,
-0.0321879722,
0.0098405331,
-0.0531507656,
-0.0529488996,
-0.0469877608,
0.0207227692,
-0.0181586202,
-0.0037531313,
-0.0604604036,
0.042088028,
0.0092598852,
-0.0039990824,
0.0376019254,
0.0376831777,
0.0068706772,
0.0352558866,
-0.0171871353,
-0.0170093514,
0.0123300357,
0.0173982903,
0.0828805119,
0.0232796539,
-0.0240398366,
0.0508233532,
0.0439113043,
-0.0297654215,
0.0221891236,
-0.0139162922,
0.0469019711,
-0.0037622915,
0.0450846739,
0.0888549984,
-0.0377047732,
-0.0252578724,
0.0238204747,
0.0369535089,
0.0202677809,
0.0262715816,
0.0435012728,
0.0988507643,
0.0692667589,
-0.0411522649,
-0.0371170454,
-0.0003193505,
0.0607821196,
-0.0004814268,
-0.0194736756,
0.0013276475,
0.0417104177,
-0.0245331842,
-0.0112204617,
0.0566404797,
-0.0190318134,
-0.0207123701,
0.0531381033,
0.0271868464,
0.0147236269,
-0.0432785265,
-0.0167073421,
0.046843797,
-0.0052929465,
0.014873798,
-0.039053157,
0.015055527,
0.1310098618,
0.0491271615,
-0.0098506082,
-0.0120083485,
-0.0454609655,
-0.0446263589,
0.0076547149,
0.0565973669,
-0.0263174903,
-0.0052010664,
-0.02035846,
-0.0440265052,
0.0201387927,
-0.0134351375,
0.0213001072,
0.0255753435,
0.0384366736,
0.0162793975,
0.008509513,
-0.0682110935,
0.0095411325,
-0.0280417427,
-0.0250229798,
0.0775119364,
0.0122406268,
-0.0184203982,
0.0059561483,
-0.00359644,
0.0013979494,
-0.0016113811,
-0.0367128216,
0.0100039076,
-0.0154659227,
0.0056286426,
0.0270677526,
-0.0041757845,
-0.0275258422,
-0.0130832978,
-0.0126288198,
-0.0314404853,
0.0089551257,
-0.0042334422,
0.0050818617,
-0.0183602907,
-0.0177382883,
-0.0032960644,
-0.0148922447,
0.0005529188,
-0.0470654741,
0.0718394741,
0.0350226983,
0.0060247495,
0.0103040664,
0.0180251151,
-0.0137166064,
-0.1281138062,
-0.0106051937,
-0.0109811816,
0.0171551742,
0.0126445284,
0.0318405107,
0.0041195853,
-0.034871541,
-0.0648265108,
-0.0264005233,
0.0430909432,
0.0252791867,
-0.0171683021,
0.0053938809,
0.0129592279,
0.002701706,
-0.0229449086,
-0.05080764,
0.0096563762,
0.0083740568,
-0.0149646588,
0.0106880842,
-0.0045108083,
-0.0391769595,
-0.0422743857,
-0.0115153948,
0.0057391655,
0.006717504,
0.0198802147,
0.0834578276,
-0.0849440172,
0.0125673972,
-0.0553305931,
-0.002303231,
0.0068613924,
-0.0123774381,
-0.0154238511,
-0.016806569,
-0.0052173459,
0.0534139387,
-0.0049398546,
0.010679028,
0.0522441976,
0.0464761034,
-0.0412249081,
0.0065917089,
-0.0232226979,
-0.0127248364,
-0.0402694419,
-0.0339672714,
-0.0179661401,
-0.0216169003,
0.0015917824,
-0.0165433325,
-0.064592354,
0.047045324,
0.0310949013,
-0.0037041742,
-0.0562997051,
0.0274992008,
-0.0001052711,
0.0313630998,
-0.0121994531,
-0.016022047,
0.0394878276,
0.0276569407,
0.0262497105,
-0.0046913014,
-0.1030748561,
-0.0542556494,
0.0076790662,
0.0034113412,
0.0113966977,
-0.0510281026,
0.0169734899,
-0.0517893732,
0.0098148528,
0.0085058175,
-0.0357467942,
-0.0436070077,
0.019879736,
0.000323777,
0.0380613431,
-0.0577705353,
-0.0497798622,
-0.0343973227,
-0.0042778412,
0.0269628372,
0.0139844716,
-0.0137260538,
-0.0619052351,
-0.0269401502,
0.0039335117,
0.026592074,
-0.008877595,
-0.0520229265,
-0.0248890929,
0.0060987538,
0.0743039399,
-0.0017341366,
-0.0124720158,
-0.0005948329,
-0.0177873317,
-0.0139789023,
-0.0281734038,
-0.0040799039,
-0.0074904659,
0.002792018,
0.0444534421,
-0.0658487752,
-0.0124268718,
0.0406435318,
-0.0387204774,
-0.0229388457,
-0.0119786821,
0.0692339763,
0.0008568008,
-0.0874029472,
0.0247831494,
0.0024200748,
0.0210794713,
0.041436363,
0.0970108509,
-0.0390707143,
0.0163292028,
0.0011668755,
0.0526557639,
0.0096770637,
-0.0095143951,
-0.027155254,
-0.1312455535,
0.0863641053,
-0.0209897552,
0.0300068855,
-0.0272000562,
-0.0466148332,
-0.0058085937,
-0.022193566,
-0.0404847153,
-0.0217420571,
-0.0437568761,
0.0180007629,
0.0073423428,
0.0584519729,
-0.0433428735,
0.0558985919,
-0.0579623021,
0.0003172602,
0.0826651827,
0.0532281548,
0.0036041911,
0.0135389073,
-0.0338169299,
0.0270242877,
0.0023134141,
0.0463466085,
-0.011121518,
-0.0257008877,
-0.0102640996,
-0.0037934636,
0.0070712809,
-0.0097436756,
0.0107619949,
0.0292125288,
0.054185532,
-0.0376817845,
-0.0100247255,
-0.0205985326,
0.0134133482,
0.0380322821,
0.0913115218,
-0.0172154848,
-0.1073389128,
0.0113054849,
-0.0303081311,
0.0073865391,
0.0226583648,
-0.058334481,
0.0076434324,
-0.0072041075,
0.0332072563,
-0.0135490829,
-0.0342429467,
0.0092513924,
-0.0138949696,
0.0222813468,
0.0255805477,
-0.0163291711,
-0.0312261246,
-0.0100390343,
-0.0097098416,
-0.0102305077,
0.061509598,
-0.0539136194,
-0.0206360444,
-0.0248737466,
-0.0981154889,
-0.0575762987,
-0.0568819195,
-0.0689089149,
0.0083892671,
-0.0651659071,
0.0314516164,
0.0170933083,
0.0561463125,
-0.0491645373,
-0.0828772187,
0.0268557146,
0.089858532,
-0.0332171656,
-0.015009746,
-0.0430970974,
0.0246104915,
-0.0124184033,
0.0221028663,
-0.0697533339,
-0.0000259758,
-0.0001784303,
-0.032456886,
0.0424433723,
-0.0382872671,
0.00096669,
-0.0075120791,
-0.0162396561,
-0.0123823192,
0.0031060022,
-0.056440901,
-0.0096652629,
-0.0032191507,
-0.0317671262,
-0.0263721272,
-0.0155110145,
0.0928174704,
-0.0051632342,
0.0276217852,
-0.0062532048,
0.0107457563,
0.0502899513,
-0.0522465669,
0.0208460595,
-0.0328109041,
0.0005707544,
0.0440389104,
0.0015434009,
0.0205507129,
0.0236866456,
0.0299195629,
0.0504546762,
-0.0246421956,
0.0134186363,
0.0108358692,
0.0110931359,
0.0052938289,
0.0174859334,
-0.0315463878,
-0.0849403515,
0.0007796874,
0.0404450931,
0.0452884249,
-0.0554109514,
0.0321449414,
-0.0222866945,
-0.0089444835,
-0.0286580529,
-0.0228395481,
0.0073369956,
-0.009916421,
0.0125767738,
0.0073157041,
0.0036351494,
0.0024515237,
0.056946449,
0.0380494744,
0.0297498312,
-0.0411175303,
-0.0204396714,
-0.025046926,
0.0035357305,
-0.0011601013,
0.0554520711,
-0.0108794942,
0.016391322,
-0.0218170974,
-0.035952609,
-0.0146494247,
-0.0299409088,
-0.0147618912,
-0.0365548208,
0.0228614733,
0.0303781778,
-0.0284426082,
-0.0021812806,
-0.0562108606,
-0.0253275018,
-0.0049095126,
-0.0079303086,
-0.0824512392,
-5.986667098e-33,
0.0015067316,
-0.0387165546,
0.0465318449,
0.0168404821,
0.0124833565,
-0.0330964178,
0.0559938066,
-0.0664491877,
0.0352771394,
0.0119621418,
-0.0288396329,
-0.0047995467,
-0.0025579182,
0.0085891532,
0.0232449062,
0.0297735538,
0.0681220889,
0.029907953,
-0.0127898976,
0.0375755616,
-0.0013958509,
0.0293519311,
0.0074367309,
-0.058354944,
0.0020465485,
-0.0189958178,
-0.033174552,
0.0496924557,
0.0060501308,
0.1049559489,
0.0146918306,
0.020780677,
0.0102810264,
-0.0165692084,
0.0230493899,
-0.0152080776,
-0.0664062724,
-0.0237775575,
0.0057256594,
-0.0009816865,
0.022908723,
-0.045481354,
-0.0158582553,
-0.0232259277,
-0.0230148677,
-0.0110470867,
0.0602307953,
-0.0148266582,
0.0005786757,
-0.0181045774,
-0.0109368796,
-0.006633108,
-0.0340176821,
0.0093606925,
-0.0091954097,
0.0186049305,
-0.0093591046,
0.058030609,
-0.071035631,
0.0279668476,
-0.0345188305,
0.0544976778,
0.0059810327,
-0.0147538092,
-0.0272253696,
0.0227291305,
0.0456164032,
0.0275062192,
0.0222608242,
-0.0377510786,
-0.0218866933,
0.0327108838,
-0.0379714184,
0.0279167425,
0.0293748919,
-0.0351472013,
-0.0334253088,
0.0346197039,
0.0048946179,
0.0031062409,
0.0361329913,
0.0149959782,
-0.0208367463,
-0.0432236679,
-0.0399522036,
-0.0423427708,
-0.0387374572,
-0.020028377,
0.039263662,
0.0343552493,
0.0353039019,
0.0164178163,
-0.0352973491,
-0.0600117967,
0.0167746302,
0.0308785643,
-0.0783871189,
-0.0409535579,
0.0423958749,
-0.0271589179,
-0.0830067396,
-0.0175679009,
-0.0030256952,
-0.0645557642,
-0.003395733,
0.0888461396,
0.0131693566,
0.0181314349,
-0.0483149923,
0.0109595219,
-0.0150055885,
0.0221184026,
-0.0327459387,
0.015102922,
0.0167175643,
0.034152206,
-0.0014296653,
0.0308400244,
0.0553252585,
0.0410743803,
0.0257204752,
-0.0639506802,
0.0340981968,
0.0296072923,
0.007215613,
0.0093546342,
-0.0426520556,
0.0016185278,
0.0243902933,
-0.0591395199,
-0.0218025111,
-0.0178919006,
2.705e-7,
-0.0145010259,
0.0261410885,
-0.0504438356,
0.0413472801,
0.03033318,
0.0174200609,
0.0118984599,
0.0315842032,
0.0325984918,
0.0567185394,
-0.0000345676,
0.0111392159,
0.0142534748,
-0.0284972433,
-0.0772421733,
0.0552363433,
-0.048713997,
-0.0453827493,
-0.0661540627,
-0.0015768134,
0.0313862525,
0.0713946149,
0.0696866587,
-0.0317844152,
0.019904701,
-0.0049309214,
0.0635006577,
-0.0259366203,
-0.0158502385,
0.0267539974,
0.025002405,
0.0263597704,
-0.0271362718,
0.01478911,
-0.0177278854,
0.0612018295,
0.0255100559,
0.0496481955,
-0.0247571468,
0.0551715195,
0.00902157,
0.0033744215,
0.0070911488,
-0.0316555239,
0.062082801,
-0.0305284932,
0.0044980212,
-0.0091390666,
-0.0549550094,
-0.0033137151,
0.0289354417,
-0.0408343226,
-0.0252891947,
-0.0215436593,
0.0198490378,
0.0052241539,
-0.0749732107,
-0.008100003,
0.0062004221,
0.00891311,
-0.0145999901,
-0.0654551461,
-0.0095173828,
0.039137654,
0.0196026489,
-0.0317865126,
0.0092889499,
2.413169139e-34,
0.0307093281,
0.0584761016,
-0.015398914,
-0.0533721857,
0.0381000601,
0.0269382764,
-0.0076742256,
0.0121403551,
0.0387555249,
-0.0445431545,
-0.0287275221
] |
Subsets and Splits
No saved queries yet
Save your SQL queries to embed, download, and access them later. Queries will appear here once saved.