id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.07098v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.07098v1 | A Novel Multi-Stage Prompting Approach for Language Agnostic MCQ Generation using GPT | 2024-01-13T15:18:44 | 2024-01-13T15:18:44 | Subhankar Maity, Aniket Deroy, Sudeshna Sarkar | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce a multi-stage prompting approach (MSP) for the generation of
multiple choice questions (MCQs), harnessing the capabilities of GPT models
such as text-davinci-003 and GPT-4, renowned for their excellence across
various NLP tasks. Our approach incorporates the innovative concept of
chain-of-thought prompting, a progressive technique in which the GPT model is
provided with a series of interconnected cues to guide the MCQ generation
process. Automated evaluations consistently demonstrate the superiority of our
proposed MSP method over the traditional single-stage prompting (SSP) baseline,
resulting in the production of high-quality distractors. Furthermore, the
one-shot MSP technique enhances automatic evaluation results, contributing to
improved distractor generation in multiple languages, including English,
German, Bengali, and Hindi. In human evaluations, questions generated using our
approach exhibit superior levels of grammaticality, answerability, and
difficulty, highlighting its efficacy in various languages. | [
0.0244467743,
-0.0046302718,
-0.0220501702,
0.0151675707,
-0.0522099398,
0.0065613128,
0.0302161574,
-0.0223167781,
0.0585245714,
-0.0051290211,
0.0183452647,
-0.0356327444,
-0.0395021588,
-0.0281755626,
0.0336883888,
-0.0585047379,
0.0289719645,
-0.0339740179,
0.0108969724,
-0.0026101554,
-0.0014951266,
0.0130963149,
-0.0252079684,
0.0069105714,
-0.0061979597,
-0.0464993156,
-0.0599584617,
-0.0033763559,
0.0207724478,
-0.0742764771,
0.0043081413,
0.0846024901,
-0.0227544252,
-0.0039038078,
0.0000023191,
-0.0718651265,
-0.0166185666,
-0.0167456474,
-0.0117773749,
-0.0235202108,
-0.0143839372,
0.0583482124,
0.02599811,
0.0198224057,
-0.0312936641,
0.0179336313,
0.0157015063,
0.0520935915,
0.0822710469,
0.0515726097,
-0.0049379091,
-0.0015106587,
0.0207699649,
0.0153364874,
0.0317579694,
0.0069378293,
-0.0365129784,
0.0056569776,
0.0148727316,
0.0469886549,
-0.004355114,
0.0164140314,
0.0285966322,
0.0258894935,
-0.0076247239,
0.0168512091,
-0.0246140901,
-0.0380571522,
-0.0251842141,
0.0607783198,
0.0085536661,
0.0022743247,
-0.0124376481,
-0.0198353454,
0.0363217853,
0.0229810029,
-0.0341504402,
0.014173137,
-0.0257850662,
-0.017294541,
0.0569966175,
-0.0046451339,
-0.0340238959,
0.0125352377,
0.0316656604,
0.0140773589,
0.0331673026,
-0.0491160117,
0.0234527234,
0.0261959862,
-0.0135868173,
-0.0681761801,
0.0259535089,
0.0227567125,
-0.0744819492,
0.0102704857,
-0.0232933201,
-0.0303823519,
0.0223114751,
0.0013162236,
0.0002471857,
0.0485284925,
-0.0334120467,
0.0051536881,
-0.0187902451,
0.0738150403,
-0.0301893875,
-0.0100209219,
-0.0492667705,
0.0288256928,
-0.0204913076,
-0.0333860591,
-0.0361705981,
0.0541242175,
-0.0397319533,
-0.0011593656,
-0.0359981172,
0.0346511938,
0.022352254,
0.0169727039,
0.0106741423,
-0.0040488825,
-0.0215080753,
0.0064800614,
-0.0262804925,
0.0309998654,
-0.0693760514,
-0.0278684162,
0.035920091,
-0.0229310729,
-0.017031163,
0.0541906431,
0.0082325349,
-0.0338156894,
-0.0028657587,
0.0415733606,
-0.0536318868,
-0.004768657,
-0.0103052463,
-0.0318431333,
-0.0074774018,
-0.0531276762,
0.0034911602,
-0.0442000069,
0.0049782912,
0.0276788827,
-0.0206266921,
0.0185566507,
0.0418527089,
0.0697415248,
0.0298736449,
0.0297060292,
-0.0014408564,
-0.0212889723,
0.0461854301,
0.0008230557,
-0.0127700893,
0.0266763531,
0.0237304606,
0.019132141,
0.0298456345,
-0.0323102362,
0.028737843,
0.011649712,
-0.0236144457,
-0.0053561842,
0.0191459898,
0.0269192494,
0.009942947,
0.0315654092,
-0.0217710007,
0.0758488178,
0.0037841983,
0.0786165223,
0.04859294,
0.0159692001,
-0.007074235,
0.014520525,
0.052709505,
0.0083199218,
-0.0066127363,
0.0936779752,
-0.0430205986,
0.0342071913,
-0.0349060446,
0.0357972719,
0.0283582527,
0.0400484726,
-0.0151878009,
-0.0314940289,
0.0088628698,
0.0562999807,
-0.0058992519,
0.0377962813,
-0.0004089339,
0.0059177447,
-0.0774493217,
0.0131481998,
-0.0283800662,
-0.0764222294,
-0.0021353017,
-0.0286365002,
0.0675921291,
0.0421730615,
0.0465695076,
-0.0065069706,
-0.0611437932,
-0.0128786573,
-0.005007606,
0.043947868,
0.0124802897,
-0.0196449049,
-0.016587954,
-0.06578511,
0.0149018737,
-0.0124623142,
-0.0156216538,
0.0096959034,
-0.0068146382,
0.0202088095,
0.0244472809,
0.0031855002,
0.0078622643,
0.0281832479,
0.0256460775,
-0.054330986,
0.0075590177,
0.005505458,
0.0010953058,
0.0335679352,
0.0016030386,
0.0187634975,
0.0150235146,
-0.0178166684,
0.0111423731,
0.0167727135,
-0.0682110116,
-0.0777219683,
-0.0000784867,
-0.0199578125,
-0.0273445025,
0.0060694339,
0.0012079618,
-0.0641303882,
-0.0174890086,
-0.03038067,
-0.0277999658,
-0.0545982271,
0.0140575143,
0.0329918303,
-0.0267726462,
-0.0490794294,
0.1027049571,
0.027954923,
0.0358338244,
0.0675631911,
0.0567595996,
0.0531474985,
-0.0582613759,
0.0002779074,
0.0237300396,
-0.0046768961,
0.0150218485,
0.0234918781,
0.090379104,
-0.1005636081,
-0.0347113386,
-0.0602068081,
0.0398407616,
-0.0321699791,
0.0176272523,
0.0246826187,
0.0102992877,
-0.0263692476,
-0.0064328918,
-0.0823077708,
0.0010745326,
0.0468796529,
0.000256623,
0.0479323827,
-0.0337986983,
0.0312546864,
0.0101161478,
0.0029565494,
-0.0207829382,
0.0151436934,
0.0223575216,
-0.0060032997,
-0.0336867832,
0.0020842045,
-0.0088743148,
-0.025940977,
0.0434574671,
-0.0040715015,
0.0468876399,
-0.0169843696,
0.1256315112,
0.0414769053,
0.0100466572,
-0.0050874576,
0.0098671895,
-0.0333224684,
-0.0255033337,
0.0440755598,
0.0030331244,
-0.0055337986,
0.0543774478,
-0.0448802076,
0.0206050985,
0.0316737853,
0.0538631007,
-0.0150355455,
-0.0515841544,
0.0314361751,
-0.0273839422,
-0.0165951531,
-0.0569556691,
0.0130360983,
-0.0473798476,
0.0586033762,
0.0094123902,
-0.0215800181,
0.0760385692,
-0.0142880362,
-0.0153852627,
-0.090859741,
0.0412099622,
-0.0152051756,
0.0411632024,
-0.0183526836,
0.0135039249,
0.0361051261,
-0.0531795248,
-0.0838658363,
0.0142511073,
0.0080961082,
-0.0248045586,
0.0240755547,
-0.0842333809,
-0.0385829806,
0.0102364272,
-0.0349868983,
-0.0483634174,
0.0013731342,
0.0197085366,
-0.012029293,
0.0049164998,
0.0241029151,
0.0252889842,
0.0048515094,
0.0463230275,
0.0436521918,
-0.0575329475,
-0.0137155754,
-0.0300247911,
0.1011895984,
0.0432110354,
0.0181867462,
0.0114436345,
-0.0176415071,
0.0506007746,
0.0344993882,
0.0348967686,
-0.0017216031,
0.0375372693,
0.0467010848,
0.0236322191,
-0.0319257863,
-0.015141204,
0.0276612192,
0.0842178911,
-0.0433859415,
-0.0367944427,
0.0953986794,
0.0566624589,
-0.0241023675,
-0.0366207212,
-0.0386104137,
0.0076836986,
0.0088838404,
0.031229062,
-0.0784430504,
-0.0285959877,
0.002658952,
0.0048523368,
-0.0347714573,
0.0060122302,
-0.0014401142,
-0.107103914,
0.0465571582,
-0.023805609,
-0.0376638584,
0.0102975918,
0.0126785794,
-0.0313649587,
0.0377952792,
-0.0023366502,
0.0339025743,
0.0313571952,
0.0191060826,
0.0088335201,
0.0114801843,
0.0013044836,
-0.0194879677,
-0.0044207838,
-0.0149022434,
0.0376273654,
0.0087063881,
0.0007945214,
-0.0358419754,
-0.0025948188,
-0.091670014,
-0.0051331855,
-0.0130563984,
-0.0012824479,
0.0154290898,
-0.0135767246,
-0.0743340626,
0.0536102764,
0.0056427796,
-0.0206767973,
0.0922377408,
0.0659798607,
-0.0158647466,
-0.0389826335,
0.012756817,
0.031630978,
0.0151344184,
0.0371283256,
0.0249954592,
-0.0708222762,
0.010250479,
-0.0449382029,
0.0415516943,
-0.0646040291,
-0.0054799831,
0.0238881148,
-0.0145700248,
-0.0059910663,
-0.0537997186,
-0.0741599873,
0.0605257042,
0.0352657698,
0.0070943134,
-0.005217378,
-0.0187959615,
0.0248130225,
0.0113698542,
-0.0020442791,
0.0233360939,
-0.0153858084,
-0.0525912791,
-0.0125770029,
-0.0128999352,
-0.0322252139,
-0.0197199639,
0.0487545133,
-0.05583933,
-0.031930238,
-0.0266614351,
0.0598033741,
0.0072835227,
-0.0364123769,
0.0070899366,
0.0018174825,
-0.0272001643,
-0.018884806,
0.0163719878,
-0.0148135889,
-0.0511907935,
0.0075843958,
-0.0101507707,
0.0030070734,
0.0044828737,
0.0114713348,
-0.0246842671,
0.0660240576,
-0.0131148649,
-0.0087091131,
0.082605809,
0.0547258295,
0.0048669744,
-0.0506672934,
0.0289575122,
-0.048094634,
0.0050721583,
-0.0105830906,
-0.0586809739,
-0.0241352674,
0.0037634037,
0.0025398661,
-0.0369750112,
0.0053317891,
-0.072286889,
-0.0637274534,
0.0136037478,
-0.0274445042,
0.0123163518,
0.0154837249,
0.034434814,
0.0154386396,
-0.032826338,
-0.0483875051,
-0.0158004873,
0.0097243125,
0.0476507656,
0.003593304,
0.145414263,
0.0093480498,
-0.0150984414,
0.0593466349,
0.022622088,
-0.0063893464,
-0.0188164245,
-0.00585254,
0.0270072129,
0.0392251164,
0.0094657335,
0.0095436377,
-0.0022954661,
-0.0036433968,
0.0169274509,
0.0481740758,
0.0371589586,
-0.0232658777,
0.0187202916,
0.0162805747,
0.0092877522,
-0.0492594056,
0.0352690369,
-0.0565756001,
-0.044218123,
0.0359600298,
-0.0031613808,
-0.0743663236,
-0.0219881739,
-0.0472004637,
0.0237895958,
0.0158359744,
0.0510034971,
-0.0560588539,
-0.0323025286,
-0.029357763,
0.0030861869,
0.0257972926,
-0.0205437392,
0.0392447114,
0.0519551747,
-0.0279594678,
-0.0475591384,
-0.0235084984,
0.0433311276,
-0.0588276051,
-0.0398361832,
-0.036024671,
-6.678910578e-33,
-0.0333472118,
-0.0618753247,
0.0386302955,
-0.0474352092,
-0.0220326781,
-0.0320880339,
-0.0462446436,
0.0242643468,
0.0026409579,
-0.0043659122,
-0.0191790331,
-0.0296411458,
-0.0034086516,
0.0402252264,
0.0348849297,
-0.0325568169,
0.0159060638,
0.000441535,
-0.0380277149,
0.0324191675,
0.0286962241,
-0.0137001183,
0.0426293761,
0.0262559354,
0.0485634767,
-0.0536185056,
-0.0262267832,
0.0060650962,
-0.0359035209,
0.0148509862,
-0.0243342109,
0.0304183178,
0.0409267694,
-0.0406555198,
0.0105335163,
0.0550388433,
-0.0090188915,
-0.0768148825,
0.0185187478,
-0.0103434855,
-0.0632052198,
-0.056711778,
-0.0182844438,
-0.0324854515,
0.0074348962,
0.0185103416,
0.0031621866,
0.0198772699,
0.0020342343,
0.0071966322,
-0.0552174896,
0.0046507623,
-0.0454511084,
-0.0043300283,
-0.0379481725,
0.126920566,
-0.0185931772,
-0.0147503214,
-0.0203378517,
0.0318293273,
0.0342780165,
-0.001927561,
0.0223052874,
0.0152342618,
-0.0394101441,
-0.0043107504,
-0.0014805581,
-0.0263022706,
0.0193542112,
0.0167705417,
-0.04169688,
0.0120803062,
0.0639189184,
0.0268566664,
0.0175740104,
0.0168427657,
-0.0242995862,
0.0303994156,
0.010459872,
-0.0041265935,
0.0022483997,
-0.0637250021,
-0.0045894752,
-0.0214155372,
-0.0262268521,
-0.0195083525,
-0.0415777303,
-0.0364449359,
0.0777247176,
-0.0546743423,
-0.0104429526,
-0.0155305974,
0.0201495551,
0.0531798489,
0.0399204418,
-0.0254748464,
-0.0535144061,
0.0432444923,
-0.0245652124,
0.0368565321,
-0.0116812503,
0.020731898,
-0.0026621099,
0.0166355316,
0.0106634945,
0.031675268,
-0.0166529659,
-0.0362922363,
-0.0710776225,
0.0031449106,
-0.0286834501,
0.0595096499,
-0.0275235828,
-0.0200371742,
-0.006159571,
-0.0020595293,
-0.0160377435,
0.0281971712,
0.0230984949,
-0.0329287946,
-0.0535591394,
-0.0195918493,
-0.0057361205,
0.0280372091,
-0.0084761484,
0.0347662121,
-0.0254029557,
0.0216431394,
0.0097297253,
-0.0486034974,
-0.0067892466,
0.0306573566,
2.945e-7,
0.0034759289,
0.0451312028,
-0.0088257724,
0.0450800024,
-0.0244892184,
0.0137703018,
0.0111750616,
-0.0026659362,
0.045679003,
0.0125134634,
0.001069861,
-0.0043094624,
0.0098842261,
0.0260294974,
-0.1212975904,
-0.0287554804,
-0.0160584189,
-0.0072451793,
-0.0621714406,
0.0369900204,
0.0915976316,
0.0080846213,
-0.0352497138,
-0.0050994796,
-0.018297527,
0.0130594401,
0.0135769052,
0.0275727697,
-0.019598132,
0.0127923172,
0.0198627636,
-0.0275780465,
-0.011487863,
0.0582618862,
-0.0025696142,
-0.025035223,
0.0422953144,
0.0241099615,
0.0388005748,
-0.0235543381,
0.0100122606,
0.0356319249,
0.0174652692,
-0.0770953894,
0.0641104802,
-0.0132354973,
0.000341324,
0.0492833331,
-0.0369618759,
-0.0388268121,
-0.0042912629,
-0.0280779507,
-0.0312538333,
0.0074735582,
-0.0206332207,
0.0105736405,
0.0329763293,
0.0335587859,
-0.002986508,
0.0294466708,
-0.002335099,
-0.0531685203,
-0.0422450937,
-0.0336069688,
-0.017920427,
-0.0256604869,
-0.0321213976,
2.501398025e-34,
0.014406234,
-0.0039370195,
0.0682223961,
0.0186071787,
0.0269314498,
-0.0031648763,
0.000682483,
0.000256171,
0.0388492234,
-0.0770694762,
-0.0405604206
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.07078v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.07078v1 | PUB: A Pragmatics Understanding Benchmark for Assessing LLMs' Pragmatics Capabilities | 2024-01-13T13:46:14 | 2024-01-13T13:46:14 | Settaluri Lakshmi Sravanthi, Meet Doshi, Tankala Pavan Kalyan, Rudra Murthy, Pushpak Bhattacharyya, Raj Dabre | cs.CL | cs.CL | LLMs have demonstrated remarkable capability for understanding semantics, but
they often struggle with understanding pragmatics. To demonstrate this fact, we
release a Pragmatics Understanding Benchmark (PUB) dataset consisting of
fourteen tasks in four pragmatics phenomena, namely, Implicature,
Presupposition, Reference, and Deixis. We curated high-quality test sets for
each task, consisting of Multiple Choice Question Answers (MCQA). PUB includes
a total of 28k data points, 6.1k of which have been created by us, and the rest
are adapted from existing datasets. We evaluated nine models varying in the
number of parameters and type of training. Our study indicates that fine-tuning
for instruction-following and chat significantly enhances the pragmatics
capabilities of smaller language models. However, for larger models, the base
versions perform comparably with their chat-adapted counterparts. Additionally,
there is a noticeable performance gap between human capabilities and model
capabilities. Furthermore, unlike the consistent performance of humans across
various tasks, the models demonstrate variability in their proficiency, with
performance levels fluctuating due to different hints and the complexities of
tasks within the same dataset. Overall, the benchmark aims to provide a
comprehensive evaluation of LLM's ability to handle real-world language tasks
that require pragmatic reasoning. | [
0.0260748323,
0.0069285221,
-0.0045476048,
0.0578963384,
-0.0418772884,
0.0225643087,
-0.0460627712,
0.0200457647,
-0.0180148259,
-0.0495815463,
-0.0393488146,
0.011073634,
-0.0517874323,
-0.0573118962,
0.0624345876,
-0.0486511476,
0.0535987094,
-0.035237968,
0.0270092245,
-0.0212085955,
-0.015909547,
-0.0011961302,
-0.0424302034,
0.0105122421,
-0.0079400446,
-0.0506122187,
-0.0165800452,
0.0371037275,
-0.0014825379,
-0.0056689591,
0.0260647275,
0.0360894427,
0.0140756993,
-0.0347418226,
0.0000019945,
-0.0736154541,
0.045207087,
-0.0426260605,
-0.0605012774,
0.0169853941,
0.038485758,
0.0010468537,
-0.0158939473,
0.0034494589,
-0.0629694089,
0.0128797516,
-0.0096168173,
0.0399273224,
0.0393317156,
0.0876502246,
0.0196397528,
-0.002991874,
0.020943027,
-0.0014993614,
0.029498497,
-0.0807620063,
-0.0071083414,
0.0491181687,
0.0505316965,
0.0174471382,
-0.0193790589,
0.045962058,
0.0487570241,
0.0109583,
-0.0380815081,
0.0136666596,
-0.0224706214,
-0.0068872757,
-0.0236941855,
0.0594802573,
0.0286524519,
-0.0122035816,
-0.039748501,
-0.005085547,
0.0326566771,
-0.0046385499,
-0.0521133952,
0.011627025,
-0.0072713722,
0.0249921996,
0.0159379411,
-0.0381162129,
0.0125818001,
0.0312982649,
0.0068871686,
0.0580338016,
-0.0116055775,
-0.0129942158,
0.0456656665,
0.0085908305,
0.0053563751,
-0.0365162864,
-0.0230793189,
0.0587512329,
-0.0096551385,
0.0318645574,
-0.0082439715,
0.0350200832,
0.0468452126,
-0.0253525898,
0.0294648409,
0.0398469307,
-0.0098167146,
0.0392983146,
-0.0261201784,
0.0444160514,
-0.0105493898,
0.0920338407,
-0.029131934,
-0.0205707867,
-0.0527522638,
-0.0179578718,
-0.0013156008,
0.0304413624,
-0.0166151337,
0.0149472114,
-0.0309618972,
0.0264230184,
-0.0078421207,
-0.0007537997,
-0.0028246881,
0.004653723,
-0.0390089862,
-0.0241455324,
-0.0689262152,
0.0438737683,
-0.0491763502,
0.0615971237,
0.0156397205,
-0.1163801625,
-0.0304894075,
0.0228549335,
-0.0194672178,
-0.0121528096,
0.0005807595,
0.0798465163,
-0.0218205079,
-0.0099845314,
-0.0508638658,
-0.0386863016,
0.0008320871,
-0.0710410923,
0.0233861543,
-0.0641601309,
0.0164210517,
0.0081440583,
-0.0085593648,
-0.0640235469,
0.0070273839,
0.0176288132,
-0.0105866352,
0.0410732366,
-0.0097770691,
0.0176410489,
0.0108079333,
0.0316489451,
-0.0270779282,
0.0767211542,
0.0026675593,
0.0047094915,
0.034393169,
-0.0105899274,
-0.0027893365,
0.0377265476,
0.0186760724,
-0.0154447705,
-0.0293335933,
0.0494678915,
-0.0203847401,
0.0219885819,
0.0693159476,
0.0310667139,
-0.0214406978,
-0.0432450548,
0.0469475202,
0.0158298109,
0.0277574826,
-0.0063737431,
0.030679848,
0.0269789156,
0.0497211292,
0.0149777811,
-0.0635480285,
0.0222525075,
-0.0172101222,
0.0026743608,
-0.0145345395,
-0.0277109668,
-0.033644218,
-0.0381094702,
-0.0021634237,
-0.0048339861,
-0.0176728498,
0.0210466422,
0.022646172,
0.0384840555,
-0.0243181065,
0.0732762069,
0.0199137405,
-0.050169453,
-0.0104355114,
-0.019506691,
0.0381373465,
0.0500452332,
0.0311812703,
-0.0106770424,
-0.0601626411,
0.0151489805,
0.0421804562,
0.033617273,
0.0410507172,
-0.0115514388,
0.0267022271,
-0.039921239,
0.0127457194,
-0.0477473736,
0.0079314951,
-0.0255119726,
0.024315767,
-0.0001529539,
-0.0149416812,
-0.0434761941,
0.0189325754,
0.0438444428,
-0.055341389,
-0.0113261249,
-0.0357009657,
-0.0105320495,
0.0103553645,
-0.0122934999,
-0.0034760167,
0.0129892798,
0.0386415571,
-0.0232016314,
0.0385276675,
0.0159166511,
-0.038771566,
-0.048686441,
0.0552276038,
-0.0312873274,
-0.0570280552,
0.0039340002,
-0.0386989377,
-0.0218029637,
-0.0014305538,
-0.0475285016,
0.0379650816,
-0.0565631576,
-0.0108724218,
-0.0017167871,
-0.0057065096,
-0.0152309053,
0.0761295408,
-0.0040042382,
0.0160629805,
0.0326143056,
0.0100026624,
-0.0015416881,
-0.0551566593,
0.0291894749,
-0.0259600077,
-0.0090553351,
-0.0073862434,
-0.0214138087,
0.0374271274,
-0.1061394364,
-0.034462478,
-0.0606491007,
-0.0023387973,
-0.0025215067,
0.0497465469,
0.0404851399,
-0.0386876054,
-0.0287516788,
-0.0464111678,
-0.0216630604,
0.0000549734,
-0.0107117072,
0.0132132191,
0.0274854265,
0.0206166785,
-0.0020533088,
-0.0380739644,
0.0256093442,
-0.0140850274,
-0.020827869,
-0.0085478863,
0.022481719,
-0.0388480164,
0.0571427047,
-0.0081726797,
-0.0246900506,
-0.0040563634,
-0.0511946678,
0.024876304,
0.0126220016,
0.0217155609,
0.0638420954,
-0.0157690719,
0.0141716106,
0.0073476718,
-0.0431280658,
-0.0843587518,
0.0259504654,
-0.0105207507,
-0.0161860045,
-0.0866675749,
-0.0503746904,
-0.0487809777,
0.0261174068,
0.0115103787,
0.0362184718,
-0.0316998139,
0.0121386321,
0.0045385035,
-0.0652341843,
-0.0277639441,
0.0387021936,
-0.0211561266,
0.0291202758,
-0.0298295226,
-0.0462872274,
0.0582719818,
-0.0070901481,
-0.0357518196,
-0.0166871864,
-0.0114384368,
-0.0322047994,
0.0438997485,
-0.0183097869,
-0.00323982,
-0.0266833529,
-0.0114735235,
-0.0622491986,
-0.0247114766,
-0.0059352908,
-0.0338350423,
0.0875384063,
-0.0609975457,
0.0060240943,
-0.0062467777,
-0.0318580195,
-0.0542066693,
-0.0716876984,
-0.0356429964,
0.0245314501,
-0.046896331,
-0.0112992171,
0.0132731572,
-0.0541744046,
0.0130485836,
-0.0274978355,
0.0064975685,
-0.0206131786,
-0.0298144035,
-0.0247493107,
0.0270992331,
0.0659214333,
0.0252814107,
-0.0151388161,
0.0368740819,
0.0737053454,
0.0467268117,
-0.0052630184,
-0.0331781991,
0.0111860242,
0.0153302299,
-0.0331898555,
-0.007959432,
0.0282958802,
0.0891448483,
-0.0641738102,
-0.0116657801,
0.0936253667,
0.0123399179,
-0.00140995,
0.023420928,
-0.0426144302,
0.0508668162,
0.0279100984,
0.0223677419,
-0.0808442384,
-0.0663414374,
0.0153845949,
0.0092640612,
-0.0097225718,
-0.0152290044,
-0.0141753433,
-0.0913586318,
0.0331236981,
-0.0024130852,
-0.0038011961,
0.0348238796,
-0.010677767,
0.0182135738,
0.0245250706,
0.0520794988,
0.0056140679,
-0.0346976742,
0.0101164598,
0.0296608023,
-0.0328756087,
-0.0382021554,
0.0529408753,
-0.032883931,
0.0689478442,
0.0208996572,
0.0271940157,
-0.019008154,
-0.0517139509,
0.0692394972,
0.0010676164,
0.0302076526,
-0.0204150211,
0.0024530361,
0.0148753971,
0.0019928324,
-0.0353921056,
0.0131511446,
-0.0621806122,
-0.019782979,
0.0503428318,
0.0884320885,
-0.044967223,
-0.0126472404,
-0.0111284181,
0.0464358851,
-0.0203546938,
0.0758455321,
0.0670701414,
-0.0057336744,
-0.0450449549,
-0.0328943469,
-0.0226063356,
-0.0108827455,
-0.0307472926,
0.0322303548,
0.0022191533,
0.0135932257,
-0.0577399321,
-0.056176234,
0.0324407965,
0.0055670086,
-0.0041103899,
0.0394049436,
-0.0112177497,
-0.0115863523,
-0.0155559219,
0.0245148707,
-0.0433460735,
0.0268454757,
-0.0572587624,
0.0066940086,
0.0323122367,
0.0142251542,
-0.0144883832,
-0.0172359738,
-0.0643692911,
-0.0439882204,
-0.0183443204,
0.059266828,
0.0211296827,
0.0124148438,
-0.0220572073,
-0.0551039651,
-0.037460003,
0.0132901473,
-0.041163981,
0.0658904538,
0.0471808612,
-0.005945486,
0.0153866112,
0.0699521825,
-0.0119610326,
0.0178346075,
0.0044479975,
0.049399443,
-0.0313778594,
-0.0284116995,
0.0423129983,
0.0129008954,
-0.0203465186,
0.0235370435,
-0.039636042,
0.0163985193,
0.040038418,
-0.0216465816,
-0.0071209446,
-0.0241847448,
-0.0219956599,
0.0059477128,
-0.0291726999,
-0.0024535542,
-0.0390481055,
-0.040782474,
0.0500288978,
0.0266531277,
0.0407073125,
0.0455502905,
0.0085623283,
-0.0385525934,
-0.0026822391,
-0.0165952817,
0.0120149869,
-0.0378171615,
0.0622117072,
0.0205428079,
0.0586323254,
0.0251460634,
-0.0026475089,
0.0205375757,
-0.0160063561,
-0.0308423862,
-0.0601248629,
0.0743933767,
0.0438178554,
0.0621060766,
0.0136714801,
0.0358360186,
-0.0211745221,
0.0237310603,
-0.0104124183,
0.0087857181,
-0.027267484,
-0.0107676024,
0.0971808806,
0.0309575405,
-0.006708418,
-0.0288847182,
0.0607658178,
-0.0066638775,
0.0458067507,
0.0084939422,
0.0401498526,
-0.0234081261,
-0.0567787886,
-0.0098722056,
0.0030816104,
0.0179944281,
0.0609314181,
-0.0518014431,
-0.0605523512,
-0.0236858595,
0.0380276926,
-0.0261080265,
-0.0497648716,
0.0167700313,
0.0509257503,
0.0031148873,
-0.047628697,
-0.0278099962,
0.0154807214,
-0.0161786992,
0.0006835562,
-0.0447059534,
-6.09323815e-33,
-0.0350565799,
-0.0411862247,
0.0459221415,
-0.004409092,
-0.0175882038,
-0.0305671357,
-0.0435881652,
0.0007509386,
-0.0540494882,
0.0418107063,
-0.029198762,
0.0455347002,
0.0141302906,
0.0141663318,
-0.0000638822,
-0.0466022603,
-0.0107985437,
0.0201904383,
-0.0024782326,
0.0043451171,
0.0082630422,
0.0127173802,
0.0413059182,
-0.0418118164,
0.0387637131,
-0.0054569351,
-0.0082826167,
0.0261804648,
-0.0369849913,
0.0601679198,
0.0059347274,
0.0422605649,
0.0360896364,
-0.0061645368,
-0.0147713618,
0.0332038589,
-0.0387221724,
-0.0566280894,
0.0854763612,
0.0113685811,
-0.0618225113,
-0.0598755144,
0.051128298,
-0.00562941,
-0.0222967379,
0.0084386952,
0.0108312583,
-0.0318255164,
0.0035772873,
0.0294646937,
-0.0329343937,
0.012269902,
-0.021932628,
-0.0135508757,
-0.0175826624,
0.0196101144,
-0.0326033346,
-0.0058530588,
-0.070074223,
-0.0079231327,
-0.0179863777,
0.0334301852,
0.0809477866,
-0.0351128243,
-0.0085563036,
0.0653294548,
-0.0101320539,
-0.0141788274,
0.0077579105,
-0.0061007231,
0.01271383,
0.0978831276,
0.017035136,
0.0411689505,
0.0090799909,
0.0318926983,
-0.0502132736,
0.0174153838,
0.0532807633,
0.0613865927,
-0.0127231758,
-0.0011251925,
-0.027695911,
0.0113438759,
-0.058377564,
0.079093881,
-0.0230176356,
-0.0537687205,
0.0589174405,
-0.0452492423,
0.015991997,
-0.0170457587,
0.0071000098,
-0.0374089554,
-0.0338239819,
-0.001666498,
-0.0228782929,
0.0098963948,
0.0138661014,
0.0599327534,
-0.0527250804,
-0.0232135486,
0.017775679,
-0.0157069694,
0.0328347497,
0.003793349,
0.0449641794,
0.0110619171,
-0.0410885997,
-0.0257937927,
-0.0398994423,
0.0220935009,
-0.0422752425,
-0.0100860829,
0.0383573547,
0.02858348,
-0.0234098602,
0.028052099,
-0.0209816247,
-0.0177504532,
-0.0123189874,
0.0131469294,
-0.0117202094,
0.035678111,
-0.0206151046,
-0.008275711,
-0.0191591829,
0.014761108,
0.0021885245,
-0.0242533647,
0.0096137021,
0.0583377182,
2.662e-7,
0.0839341655,
0.012905037,
0.008731653,
0.0424156077,
0.0059749833,
0.023264695,
-0.0690908059,
0.0000773137,
0.0253059138,
-0.0482644252,
-0.0183283407,
0.062968716,
0.0445790589,
0.0125692599,
-0.087949723,
0.0339037105,
-0.0235582441,
0.0230478514,
-0.030565042,
-0.0041849166,
0.0464856662,
0.0691689253,
-0.0047665248,
-0.0149427783,
-0.0211660657,
-0.0200249013,
0.0496940874,
-0.0713032186,
-0.0058174715,
0.0224889293,
0.0408819504,
0.01730703,
0.0503290184,
0.0480516814,
0.0162612069,
-0.0102443555,
-0.0466930233,
0.0852312818,
0.0046337661,
-0.0542921722,
-0.0150175933,
-0.0676266029,
0.0215846263,
-0.0416499823,
0.0457585976,
-0.0411434099,
-0.050461147,
0.0147394827,
0.0062494138,
-0.0139464606,
0.0100977197,
0.0014026654,
-0.007505978,
-0.0061772778,
0.0372802429,
-0.0540519096,
-0.0230219085,
-0.0527470298,
-0.0032185907,
0.0097610727,
-0.0126332194,
-0.039388027,
-0.0400770493,
0.004015489,
0.002188521,
-0.0651306286,
-0.0291583296,
2.071680453e-34,
0.004910714,
-0.0004889306,
0.0497887246,
0.072367534,
0.0246100798,
-0.0009286377,
0.0038350392,
0.0236201994,
-0.0041360357,
-0.0586820357,
0.0193322115
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.07037v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.07037v1 | xCoT: Cross-lingual Instruction Tuning for Cross-lingual Chain-of-Thought Reasoning | 2024-01-13T10:53:53 | 2024-01-13T10:53:53 | Linzheng Chai, Jian Yang, Tao Sun, Hongcheng Guo, Jiaheng Liu, Bing Wang, Xiannian Liang, Jiaqi Bai, Tongliang Li, Qiyao Peng, Zhoujun Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Chain-of-thought (CoT) has emerged as a powerful technique to elicit
reasoning in large language models and improve a variety of downstream tasks.
CoT mainly demonstrates excellent performance in English, but its usage in
low-resource languages is constrained due to poor language generalization. To
bridge the gap among different languages, we propose a cross-lingual
instruction fine-tuning framework (xCOT) to transfer knowledge from
high-resource languages to low-resource languages. Specifically, the
multilingual instruction training data (xCOT-INSTRUCT) is created to encourage
the semantic alignment of multiple languages. We introduce cross-lingual
in-context few-shot learning (xICL)) to accelerate multilingual agreement in
instruction tuning, where some fragments of source languages in examples are
randomly substituted by their counterpart translations of target languages.
During multilingual instruction tuning, we adopt the randomly online CoT
strategy to enhance the multilingual reasoning ability of the large language
model by first translating the query to another language and then answering in
English. To further facilitate the language transfer, we leverage the
high-resource CoT to supervise the training of low-resource languages with
cross-lingual distillation. Experimental results on previous benchmarks
demonstrate the superior performance of xCoT in reducing the gap among
different languages, highlighting its potential to reduce the cross-lingual
gap. | [
0.0022745586,
0.0377660953,
0.0043131206,
0.039266862,
-0.0554946959,
0.0378524549,
0.0256172679,
-0.0380300879,
-0.0197045002,
-0.0222970266,
-0.0363395289,
-0.0241729636,
-0.0172476061,
-0.0465125702,
0.0114286309,
-0.0428375192,
0.059521921,
-0.0351240225,
-0.0315551795,
-0.0441071428,
0.0066516316,
0.044515036,
-0.0203635395,
-0.0041304491,
0.0113133751,
-0.046542231,
-0.0030768153,
0.0065190359,
0.0538502783,
-0.0035234576,
-0.0050849984,
0.0373926461,
0.0241826437,
0.0273290854,
0.000002126,
-0.0625315309,
-0.0229675267,
0.0164380353,
-0.0120868543,
-0.0332232378,
-0.0151391355,
-0.0290655568,
0.0189789962,
-0.000725773,
-0.0153042572,
0.0037128695,
0.0554239154,
0.0273947772,
0.0445577353,
0.0583806671,
0.0032287375,
-0.0564707369,
0.0040036752,
-0.012994593,
0.0473917089,
-0.0574313104,
-0.0188069083,
0.021997299,
0.0104797464,
0.0136466371,
-0.0267775282,
0.0341137759,
0.0478529036,
0.0144417519,
-0.0260005929,
0.01732173,
-0.0684299916,
-0.0156661347,
-0.0074651795,
0.0750460699,
-0.0330003202,
-0.0139814168,
-0.0374854729,
0.018286135,
-0.0040435768,
-0.0141666224,
-0.052114699,
0.0260149762,
-0.0099856602,
0.0012024762,
0.0436449759,
0.0028984479,
0.0117925582,
0.015572642,
-0.037058752,
0.0697901994,
0.0115099596,
-0.0232384279,
0.0215005223,
0.0206200611,
-0.0133217871,
-0.0515167266,
-0.0345032662,
0.0434759073,
-0.0684919879,
0.0272157434,
-0.0038465536,
-0.0080637671,
0.0127339112,
-0.0240176991,
0.0229791887,
0.0566819906,
-0.0158620924,
0.0808894485,
-0.0208141785,
0.0359253585,
-0.0088782078,
0.0296839662,
-0.0474817939,
-0.0676657557,
-0.0887995139,
0.0105393371,
-0.0257298294,
0.0385668762,
-0.0346709192,
0.0089271441,
-0.0383186266,
0.0002822057,
-0.0113486191,
0.010071232,
0.017172819,
-0.0169810206,
-0.026007453,
-0.0238245111,
-0.0300256126,
0.091683507,
-0.0513719767,
-0.0026821978,
0.0056243413,
-0.0323933475,
-0.0179952066,
-0.0003810631,
-0.0196080431,
-0.0647227019,
0.0446194932,
0.0631138235,
-0.0475839451,
0.0062395311,
-0.0215964168,
-0.0336041935,
-0.0041725477,
-0.1095586792,
0.0023742993,
-0.0992711559,
0.0417301096,
0.0103078093,
-0.0092680454,
0.0097791525,
0.0096150888,
0.0226276219,
-0.0399296656,
0.0521988682,
0.0186567567,
-0.0019449997,
0.0109259645,
-0.0167579222,
-0.0000522036,
0.1187390536,
-0.0106666945,
-0.0107814362,
0.0458446145,
0.0103927562,
-0.0574415922,
0.0207426008,
0.0296893232,
0.0192840789,
-0.0120638413,
0.0384496748,
0.0285559278,
0.0318071321,
0.013224775,
0.0191339999,
-0.0360027067,
0.0325884484,
0.0117418515,
0.0090446128,
0.0094000138,
-0.0185146257,
0.0390683562,
-0.0033976191,
-0.0418617688,
0.0031824657,
-0.0580638275,
0.0755270198,
0.0024536278,
0.0117012374,
0.0100257825,
0.0779023468,
-0.0566170886,
-0.0152889714,
0.0264969021,
0.0079879435,
-0.0117370728,
0.05160705,
0.0650343522,
0.0309282299,
-0.0018458095,
0.0671824142,
0.0671413019,
-0.0256677289,
0.0055520483,
-0.0043070535,
0.0014626714,
0.0417672284,
0.0038496521,
0.0134207346,
-0.0443556122,
-0.0236204639,
0.0697331801,
0.031435091,
0.0388554595,
-0.0243312996,
0.0206286814,
-0.0470239297,
-0.0461979993,
-0.028322665,
-0.0240400564,
0.0249724984,
-0.0052151373,
0.037937358,
-0.0061951978,
-0.0430853702,
-0.0054105469,
-0.0009993467,
-0.0474697873,
-0.0190307759,
-0.0046700435,
0.0582795814,
-0.0001355858,
0.0234200507,
0.005170506,
-0.0070391176,
-0.0256486181,
-0.0294479169,
0.0010509304,
0.0093056355,
-0.0220986456,
-0.0727056563,
0.0397464857,
-0.0459404327,
-0.0563902557,
-0.0293690134,
-0.0683200657,
-0.0327749439,
0.0285030603,
0.0050715823,
0.0120294066,
-0.04629853,
-0.0025414187,
-0.0111760059,
0.0045019542,
-0.0378517359,
0.0689604953,
0.0139112389,
0.025519032,
0.0230284352,
-0.0155086331,
0.0476595163,
-0.0190747008,
0.0115233548,
0.0264815595,
-0.0169422533,
0.0083689131,
0.0486910306,
0.0614094213,
-0.0542590842,
-0.0032748824,
-0.0705308542,
0.0301619638,
-0.0312413312,
0.0209680554,
0.0158111099,
0.0224227067,
0.0234409198,
-0.0172657669,
-0.0691084787,
0.0069316402,
0.009925412,
0.0509367473,
0.0161082987,
0.0008609036,
0.0196055062,
0.017003851,
-0.0153977582,
-0.0068829297,
0.0257704873,
-0.0172160268,
0.0108616697,
-0.0294683501,
0.0158644654,
-0.0766475946,
0.0076488708,
0.0132864602,
-0.0281774011,
-0.0045171012,
0.0080793221,
0.0262595639,
0.0593243837,
-0.0443217792,
-0.0602820925,
0.0501593687,
-0.013212489,
-0.0578679405,
0.041004844,
-0.0081918919,
-0.0426788703,
-0.0286979862,
-0.011625099,
-0.0509884991,
0.0584523901,
-0.0265789218,
-0.0210838486,
-0.0683534667,
-0.0097858207,
-0.0067253481,
-0.0193933118,
-0.0665015653,
0.0410721637,
0.0401291549,
0.0444396846,
-0.0362505168,
0.0097053945,
0.1098881811,
0.0092521925,
-0.0065849326,
-0.0917858407,
0.0107350638,
-0.0305281058,
0.028779069,
-0.0273125544,
0.0440465733,
-0.0206160583,
-0.0025496746,
-0.1115675569,
-0.0171619598,
0.0502674989,
0.0035216128,
0.0145674031,
-0.0274687521,
-0.0120632472,
-0.0219417159,
-0.0471472666,
-0.0101802796,
0.0018735926,
-0.0133985532,
0.0229558926,
-0.0047486667,
0.0081791533,
-0.031052744,
-0.018880561,
0.0607946888,
-0.0006281828,
-0.0145805627,
-0.010714679,
-0.0232060663,
0.0281851422,
0.0541237295,
-0.0112833651,
0.0018626382,
-0.0315313973,
0.0451837108,
0.0350186117,
0.0320988372,
-0.0534567237,
0.0343865678,
0.0208540689,
0.0344088003,
-0.00702901,
-0.0362807475,
-0.0039363578,
0.0671910346,
-0.0395837575,
-0.0366445221,
0.0761199594,
0.0232282914,
-0.0337014385,
-0.0174913649,
-0.0409881696,
0.0379900001,
0.0476846732,
0.0582925156,
-0.0923077092,
-0.052153185,
-0.0073476462,
-0.0204443913,
0.0159351397,
-0.0175743401,
-0.0123021081,
-0.1547130048,
0.0100275306,
0.0028695462,
-0.066275388,
-0.0207592472,
-0.0394548103,
-0.0102433413,
0.0078562964,
0.0333258994,
0.0116888089,
0.0168993454,
0.0009206355,
0.0092201149,
0.0497006141,
-0.0287487954,
0.0535232425,
-0.0504026115,
-0.0096467854,
0.0363717824,
0.0244764853,
0.0071046799,
-0.042892579,
0.0239139665,
-0.0227014702,
-0.0004567953,
-0.0048975432,
0.0278931241,
0.0069094994,
-0.0291767921,
0.0091349585,
0.0407824852,
-0.0101124169,
-0.0026554144,
0.013696054,
0.1260761172,
0.0142176198,
0.014764837,
0.0037438055,
-0.0027802931,
-0.0038387359,
0.0447777472,
-0.0114360694,
-0.0255763959,
-0.0325236805,
-0.0138730993,
-0.0494895317,
-0.0651122704,
0.010542864,
0.0408668183,
-0.0377676152,
-0.0217831079,
-0.0390938036,
-0.0561544709,
0.0276734233,
0.0427229367,
-0.0023988616,
0.0109237619,
-0.011647121,
0.0233660452,
-0.0194178596,
0.0127190296,
-0.0457014181,
0.0215079561,
-0.0003234864,
0.0018488438,
0.0149185751,
-0.0298026167,
-0.0114478227,
0.0073748888,
-0.0644270182,
-0.0645612553,
-0.0494524874,
0.045938693,
0.0088041723,
0.0861067027,
-0.0117602283,
-0.0287936106,
0.0346508622,
0.0232222211,
-0.0138983484,
-0.0139976433,
0.0289663747,
0.0162404738,
0.0058250614,
0.070115611,
-0.0556875393,
0.0068570441,
0.017708743,
0.0586400889,
-0.0295621864,
0.0160647482,
0.0416938029,
0.0104512488,
0.0065371771,
-0.0146739054,
-0.0139789265,
-0.0178204067,
0.0504526645,
-0.0406050645,
-0.0455161706,
-0.0023735147,
-0.0107152211,
0.01633076,
-0.046272818,
0.031846609,
0.0066004125,
0.0361573994,
-0.00641486,
-0.006977051,
-0.0136740757,
0.0183789935,
0.0373030566,
0.0154611543,
0.0215909332,
0.0067578019,
-0.0143461255,
0.0379858203,
0.0505176932,
-0.0545473136,
0.075670667,
0.0511836447,
0.0080085592,
-0.0165958367,
-0.0158736892,
-0.0411915071,
-0.0399757326,
0.0066506527,
-0.0435143523,
0.081134893,
-0.0059013218,
0.0215257108,
0.0021316176,
-0.0474223457,
0.0165506341,
0.0309313983,
0.0015956654,
-0.0364185236,
0.0265520308,
0.0162706319,
0.0016971696,
0.0096309576,
0.0693252534,
-0.0353028327,
0.0186681394,
0.0039570406,
0.023835808,
-0.0253833365,
-0.0174545255,
0.0052079577,
0.014119748,
-0.0068686013,
0.0316424891,
-0.0457216427,
-0.0781496093,
-0.0251125265,
-0.0049647717,
-0.0307951011,
0.0424626283,
0.0421544462,
0.0848492011,
-0.0068990365,
-0.0345052592,
-0.0215118043,
-0.007541405,
0.0262423456,
-0.0242310762,
0.0130175967,
-6.376492616e-33,
0.0044817412,
0.0106507698,
0.0437216535,
0.0065096808,
0.010573457,
-0.0351316407,
-0.0251244735,
-0.0185998473,
-0.0481940582,
0.0439920723,
-0.0064256643,
-0.0033091074,
0.0091597792,
0.0430180505,
0.0361550003,
-0.0168220531,
0.0111750085,
0.0043287491,
0.0018717947,
0.0290186852,
0.0547347255,
0.017003607,
0.0895938948,
-0.0232948922,
0.0111544374,
0.0140242623,
0.0135808932,
0.0635667518,
-0.0063404981,
0.0322691873,
0.0173158441,
0.0394845866,
0.0176665206,
-0.0456834584,
-0.0032856523,
-0.0080793817,
-0.0939525217,
-0.0727894679,
0.0403578766,
0.015247534,
-0.0350015871,
-0.0525591262,
-0.0079224799,
-0.0271677431,
0.0134015642,
-0.065089494,
0.0280025695,
-0.0288242083,
-0.0080545917,
-0.0134090371,
-0.077654548,
-0.009774413,
-0.0193343777,
-0.0297315735,
0.0180174969,
0.0722250044,
0.0047956584,
0.0065517798,
-0.0312638804,
0.0344780758,
-0.0494429804,
0.0267863944,
0.103832759,
-0.0183603149,
-0.0179759674,
0.0131784743,
0.0224467833,
-0.0072185518,
0.0300992075,
0.0283334143,
0.0168044232,
0.0255939122,
0.0289633889,
0.0909501538,
0.0299882237,
0.0306951012,
-0.119897306,
0.0060020573,
-0.001779384,
0.0554020479,
0.0026737954,
-0.002154428,
-0.0154443923,
-0.0261425748,
-0.053806372,
-0.0072335713,
-0.0455198251,
-0.0339884982,
0.0059192074,
-0.0112985065,
-0.012966034,
-0.0086794998,
0.061494492,
-0.0390820391,
-0.0244083647,
0.0427538306,
-0.003071548,
-0.011833813,
0.0058730077,
0.050593175,
-0.0644633844,
-0.022101678,
-0.0157030448,
0.005431179,
0.0248681363,
0.0297092069,
0.0883243531,
-0.0156496912,
-0.0416236557,
0.0104637975,
-0.0709120706,
0.015536515,
-0.0209098328,
0.0194189288,
0.0097438237,
0.0222832058,
-0.0178939216,
0.0537341312,
0.0418939143,
-0.0334760882,
-0.0090422006,
-0.0311381202,
-0.0164587405,
0.0092953593,
-0.008082306,
0.0299751572,
-0.0359973162,
-0.02294131,
0.0048843771,
-0.0472958498,
-0.0225189421,
0.0461689346,
2.847e-7,
0.0329087004,
0.0351914652,
-0.0027152456,
0.0213670302,
-0.012001764,
0.0242707711,
-0.0357899182,
0.0026039088,
0.0078000352,
-0.0483831093,
-0.0002571866,
0.049251724,
0.0488403104,
0.0410352685,
-0.0687358752,
0.0112755941,
-0.020065574,
-0.0068389331,
-0.0408158265,
0.0019570594,
0.0185396764,
0.0817182437,
0.001962316,
-0.0108317928,
0.0102166105,
-0.0104403384,
0.057219971,
0.0010874782,
-0.0340590253,
0.0193970427,
-0.0501844026,
0.0035467145,
0.0082741678,
0.0349503532,
-0.0332821682,
0.0149870124,
-0.0024190291,
0.0324407183,
-0.0211314373,
-0.034002658,
-0.0252859276,
-0.0315981209,
-0.0165348612,
-0.0670437142,
0.0805546865,
-0.0568163134,
-0.0214025639,
0.0210575461,
-0.0128855929,
0.0156318843,
0.0580202863,
-0.0118554654,
-0.0334648155,
0.0247465987,
0.0453643724,
0.0229182392,
-0.0220198315,
-0.0383091047,
-0.0167207886,
0.064209193,
0.0098784026,
-0.0448384434,
0.0165582448,
-0.0184460133,
0.0073590116,
-0.0336347073,
-0.0187388007,
2.536718416e-34,
0.030974118,
-0.0132221822,
0.0333004259,
0.0135451118,
0.0172693823,
-0.0350427441,
-0.0651200339,
-0.0055997637,
0.0340731591,
-0.0506594144,
-0.0105732745
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.07022v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.07022v1 | Edge-Enabled Anomaly Detection and Information Completion for Social Network Knowledge Graphs | 2024-01-13T09:27:37 | 2024-01-13T09:27:37 | Fan Lu, Quan Qi, Huaibin Qin | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | In the rapidly advancing information era, various human behaviors are being
precisely recorded in the form of data, including identity information,
criminal records, and communication data. Law enforcement agencies can
effectively maintain social security and precisely combat criminal activities
by analyzing the aforementioned data. In comparison to traditional data
analysis methods, deep learning models, relying on the robust computational
power in cloud centers, exhibit higher accuracy in extracting data features and
inferring data. However, within the architecture of cloud centers, the
transmission of data from end devices introduces significant latency, hindering
real-time inference of data. Furthermore, low-latency edge computing
architectures face limitations in direct deployment due to relatively weak
computing and storage capacities of nodes. To address these challenges, a
lightweight distributed knowledge graph completion architecture is proposed.
Firstly, we introduce a lightweight distributed knowledge graph completion
architecture that utilizes knowledge graph embedding for data analysis.
Subsequently, to filter out substandard data, a personnel data quality
assessment method named PDQA is proposed. Lastly, we present a model pruning
algorithm that significantly reduces the model size while maximizing
performance, enabling lightweight deployment. In experiments, we compare the
effects of 11 advanced models on completing the knowledge graph of public
security personnel information. The results indicate that the RotatE model
outperforms other models significantly in knowledge graph completion, with the
pruned model size reduced by 70\%, and hits@10 reaching 86.97\%.} | [
0.0389984362,
0.0786100626,
0.0049360474,
0.0106986053,
-0.0558765493,
-0.0245018583,
0.0353745073,
-0.016302947,
0.0415419564,
0.0252973158,
0.0668314025,
-0.0002013122,
0.0012291645,
0.0524554364,
0.0009129618,
-0.0013877877,
0.0514399298,
0.0176177863,
0.0260766521,
-0.0183521733,
-0.017052453,
0.0042290185,
0.0263820402,
-0.0198180825,
-0.0358397514,
-0.0065181158,
-0.0388452783,
-0.0057176305,
0.0307192095,
-0.0184034798,
-0.0003143406,
0.0229847301,
-0.0081188399,
0.0189007614,
0.0000022502,
0.0010654379,
-0.0342086367,
-0.0072809234,
-0.0687172636,
-0.030009333,
0.0179450642,
-0.0287259668,
0.0034035048,
0.0133504467,
-0.0271903295,
-0.0235926919,
0.032966435,
0.0531387329,
0.0231326707,
0.0188390017,
-0.0136023331,
-0.0027975133,
0.0264734924,
-0.026543906,
-0.0571246743,
-0.0203759875,
0.0205004811,
-0.0505070873,
-0.0028636528,
-0.0040302114,
0.0232620575,
-0.0121422587,
0.031524092,
0.035976816,
0.0516353995,
0.0188367143,
-0.0006266484,
-0.0095215533,
0.0149751306,
0.0617210865,
-0.0293054059,
0.0230203569,
0.014886504,
-0.0005788676,
0.0035276604,
0.0328750908,
-0.0044804201,
-0.0346010551,
-0.0337874107,
-0.0073138559,
-0.051580146,
0.0071515818,
0.0594925955,
0.031849876,
-0.0232547317,
0.0712135583,
-0.0145302285,
-0.0064690104,
-0.0423707739,
-0.0344992206,
-0.0025357953,
-0.0392771624,
0.0393593982,
0.0037628938,
-0.0313123204,
-0.0279581584,
-0.0368684605,
-0.0302111935,
-0.0130097596,
0.0146713294,
-0.0062262313,
-0.0331693403,
-0.0117880488,
0.0468031354,
0.0190915577,
0.0252030492,
-0.0174220055,
-0.0200715549,
0.0088740168,
-0.0432399958,
-0.0059562312,
0.0071188803,
0.0223036669,
0.0548250526,
0.0173004642,
-0.0274085365,
-0.0298001319,
0.0469616018,
-0.0499620922,
0.0406036079,
-0.018995,
0.0699775368,
0.0024090288,
-0.002547777,
-0.0381897576,
-0.0083742058,
0.0010806564,
0.0453621596,
0.0087768026,
-0.0132209705,
0.0117029035,
-0.0173031092,
0.0508631021,
0.0014300116,
0.0287557878,
0.0378464051,
0.0322412178,
0.0034335481,
-0.0552325174,
-0.0521408953,
0.0151205137,
-0.0374853648,
-0.0251830965,
-0.0742763653,
0.0260800552,
-0.0064100185,
-0.0033357535,
-0.0287880953,
0.0123996716,
-0.019038789,
-0.0935876742,
0.035303846,
-0.0872073248,
0.0410123169,
0.0017348137,
0.0109911161,
-0.0044757365,
-0.050031621,
-0.0015315214,
0.0372132659,
0.0424812213,
-0.0384479873,
0.0313798264,
0.0050638327,
0.0581264831,
-0.022935871,
0.0269504618,
0.0284849666,
-0.0599474274,
0.0155886393,
-0.0110779768,
0.0264331996,
-0.0118873427,
-0.0465349331,
0.0456863418,
0.0231590196,
-0.023019027,
0.0412631743,
-0.019810427,
0.0293473639,
-0.0248638876,
-0.04817212,
-0.0632315725,
0.0297051519,
-0.0284449253,
-0.034824308,
-0.0128063262,
0.0418973751,
-0.0257839467,
0.0025526087,
-0.0048652198,
-0.0457850806,
0.0410214439,
0.031250149,
0.0259893779,
0.0139839696,
-0.006488211,
-0.0091529479,
-0.007821708,
0.0035618674,
-0.0306456257,
-0.0104286093,
0.036172118,
0.1155629456,
0.0511533841,
0.0251150485,
-0.056626182,
-0.0371409878,
0.0201979093,
-0.0614939481,
-0.0049207588,
-0.0074627288,
0.0135522252,
-0.0374865867,
-0.0379924476,
0.055713404,
0.0152566219,
-0.0055806907,
0.0342875384,
0.0047914083,
0.0242687054,
-0.0717438459,
-0.0588550642,
-0.0139901191,
0.0353282616,
0.0336755328,
0.044784151,
0.048312325,
0.0302090459,
0.0268402211,
0.0378764309,
-0.0338805132,
0.0364969335,
-0.0005412013,
-0.037675947,
-0.0365696922,
0.0074827163,
0.0495857261,
0.0099676251,
-0.0293174796,
0.0390772708,
0.0737404451,
-0.0467914082,
-0.0374074727,
0.0373137556,
-0.0192603413,
0.000780519,
0.0236061346,
-0.0106918951,
0.0148462057,
0.0219601952,
0.0199235957,
0.0350478292,
-0.0418060049,
-0.0195642915,
0.0205303878,
-0.0047988053,
0.0664492324,
-0.0206683706,
-0.0185897592,
-0.0572258867,
-0.0156334341,
0.0222193245,
0.030031804,
-0.0353850238,
-0.0100191385,
0.0376119651,
-0.0862609893,
0.0217965059,
-0.0115844775,
0.0127841905,
-0.0103750555,
0.0555411279,
0.0105214547,
-0.0575314648,
0.0016388515,
0.0171614811,
-0.002219368,
0.0430180319,
0.0210189056,
0.0142133264,
-0.0200203303,
0.005896226,
-0.0498210452,
0.0112479897,
0.0591479801,
-0.0085058045,
0.0003855595,
0.0379767455,
0.0196657721,
-0.0620413385,
0.021045614,
-0.0205830801,
-0.0013921035,
0.0298907459,
0.0063799596,
-0.0005227546,
0.0387433544,
0.012893335,
0.0002868528,
0.0136635834,
0.004251516,
-0.0071142749,
-0.0004134742,
-0.0546679273,
0.0348423459,
-0.007282001,
0.0279507693,
-0.0754860565,
-0.0226594787,
0.0181069132,
-0.0153141161,
-0.0300149415,
0.0013661917,
0.0295512974,
-0.0063550412,
-0.051555641,
-0.0378056392,
0.0343486667,
-0.0112600122,
-0.0391896404,
-0.0396722592,
0.0536998026,
0.0193249993,
0.0539112948,
0.0562587529,
-0.0588436946,
0.0277000722,
0.0508769266,
0.0404633097,
0.0279094744,
-0.0540729649,
-0.0308521837,
-0.0069263694,
0.0204468966,
0.0106007131,
-0.0488943905,
-0.0630500019,
0.0008670951,
-0.0194534231,
0.0428100564,
-0.0344131216,
-0.0389485545,
-0.0113864662,
-0.0299234204,
0.0051099076,
-0.0431508124,
-0.0552533269,
0.0413707457,
-0.0021826196,
0.0122636175,
0.0235823989,
-0.0185258314,
0.0079880534,
-0.0263330694,
-0.00781631,
0.020631304,
-0.0411735326,
0.0132312374,
0.0218716078,
-0.0100098653,
0.0406994671,
0.0306832194,
-0.0346509703,
-0.0640029982,
0.0026162583,
-0.0087190634,
0.005504631,
-0.053984493,
-0.0019851991,
0.0270164497,
-0.0453588106,
0.028015025,
0.0399558507,
-0.0105988309,
-0.0315920524,
0.0313798711,
0.0415508561,
-0.0229734499,
0.0194720514,
-0.001783835,
-0.0746643245,
0.0137551045,
0.0180328004,
0.057192564,
-0.0021090356,
-0.0890112519,
0.0248896424,
-0.0363097675,
0.0568852164,
-0.0133709069,
0.0104933186,
-0.1026016995,
-0.063539207,
0.0371348336,
-0.0228326879,
-0.0030387898,
-0.0173397809,
0.0469988324,
-0.0043014516,
0.0009177668,
-0.068702139,
-0.0362052694,
0.0324821584,
-0.0761843622,
0.023760777,
0.0094300751,
0.0128590297,
-0.0116360569,
-0.0294289626,
-0.0093740737,
0.0554071553,
-0.0125691639,
-0.0020142111,
0.0574568026,
-0.0027325146,
-0.007655608,
-0.0467400812,
0.0526001751,
-0.0268906243,
-0.019158937,
-0.0222028568,
0.1131220832,
-0.0547599271,
-0.0004714901,
-0.0391451232,
-0.0610109158,
0.0325875022,
0.0373648703,
-0.0043437444,
-0.0296123754,
0.0088691032,
-0.005804881,
0.0121460268,
-0.038640663,
0.0331589021,
0.0414607078,
0.0217366032,
-0.0422912575,
0.0206410587,
-0.0489597246,
0.0425394773,
-0.0149902338,
-0.0021734892,
-0.0231957361,
0.0413907357,
-0.0275108162,
-0.0798445046,
-0.0143548902,
-0.0114211971,
0.0586505271,
0.0320356898,
0.0337383337,
-0.0287188683,
0.0035753022,
-0.0378937796,
-0.0127423219,
-0.0707670897,
-0.0099366987,
0.0320433974,
0.0134478426,
0.0149956672,
0.0538208857,
-0.0599503666,
-0.0315210186,
0.0662871376,
0.0765309855,
-0.055754561,
-0.0265950952,
0.0135637634,
-0.0739306286,
-0.0034777429,
0.0311510917,
-0.0266688876,
-0.0011852328,
0.0251775756,
-0.0405993313,
-0.1091693938,
-0.0698677003,
0.0035019182,
0.0385983847,
0.0150731141,
0.041494038,
-0.0049167974,
-0.0395163335,
-0.0065929811,
0.0461021289,
0.0024859628,
-0.0083237253,
0.0131377913,
0.0171645265,
0.0298489965,
0.0115151526,
-0.0056551276,
0.0716637671,
-0.0327246748,
-0.0866397098,
-0.0233210102,
0.000315782,
0.0196038801,
0.0550377965,
-0.0038159522,
0.0068807341,
0.0215710644,
-0.0007731775,
0.020032594,
-0.021264581,
-0.0557312965,
-0.0064675356,
0.0190053396,
-0.0235948991,
0.028505588,
-0.0528338216,
-0.0596519858,
0.0038566899,
0.0095350686,
0.0276899878,
0.0486673564,
-0.0170560796,
-0.0199101474,
0.003059905,
-0.0325290933,
0.021535622,
-0.0099615697,
-0.0297468696,
0.0046239691,
0.0411253907,
-0.0119338399,
0.0893808305,
0.0597370081,
0.0104577336,
0.066702053,
-0.0341244638,
-0.0706833601,
-0.0390085131,
0.0167746767,
0.006502653,
0.0801003128,
-0.0292111449,
-0.013399601,
0.0021883522,
-0.0552561656,
0.0158165358,
-0.0102061192,
-0.0113099571,
-0.0024962989,
0.0042669969,
0.0566149019,
-0.0027211742,
-0.0047381716,
-0.0467576459,
0.0006932794,
0.0059941188,
-0.0200183317,
0.041943565,
-6.735805974e-33,
0.0350845829,
-0.0408011116,
0.0069711762,
-0.0089494046,
-0.0314871259,
0.0139939236,
-0.0086050695,
-0.0256017148,
-0.0413427688,
0.0204771906,
-0.0204513576,
0.052484151,
0.004197516,
0.0230723862,
-0.0316700339,
0.0080175223,
0.054278817,
-0.0036904039,
0.0312280059,
0.0471086502,
0.0522231609,
0.0375645123,
0.0152960699,
-0.1147262752,
-0.0072119934,
-0.0272731464,
-0.0291878786,
0.0161396377,
-0.0228683949,
0.0212523993,
0.001813918,
0.0157721806,
0.0112414034,
-0.0078214761,
-0.0171227138,
-0.0008438999,
-0.0568548553,
0.0136093684,
-0.0359047279,
0.0172015,
-0.0192577913,
-0.0352171548,
0.0406650268,
0.0054105665,
0.0431101508,
-0.0046797907,
0.0158015415,
-0.0092579285,
-0.0670128688,
-0.0340202488,
0.0407794453,
0.0357733592,
-0.0195070226,
0.0057585798,
-0.0156699196,
-0.021074215,
-0.0034799648,
-0.0273233354,
-0.1281301826,
0.0006736444,
-0.0191674326,
-0.0116405841,
-0.0160451792,
-0.0183739532,
-0.0261823349,
0.0051263883,
0.0001229152,
-0.0167263672,
-0.0186564252,
0.0529719964,
0.012401497,
0.1429371387,
0.0062202094,
0.0075962376,
0.0090077994,
-0.1057942063,
-0.1024183035,
-0.0003019394,
0.0072275545,
-0.0096088527,
0.0091487849,
-0.0232785977,
-0.0589624234,
-0.0160554014,
0.0045729373,
-0.0760056525,
-0.0158923585,
-0.0119352667,
-0.0034222603,
0.0408319831,
-0.0491885245,
0.0398642607,
0.0055889101,
-0.0741584226,
0.0409613922,
0.0406029709,
-0.0008355957,
0.0245129708,
0.03244498,
0.0198339857,
-0.0440669842,
-0.0046553537,
-0.0220320094,
-0.0362712182,
0.0166756213,
0.0109339645,
0.0633179471,
0.0682311505,
-0.0337441042,
-0.0143289808,
-0.0118863573,
0.0332604945,
-0.0214797333,
-0.0294214189,
0.0270937961,
0.0077822921,
0.0210579224,
0.036184337,
0.0416461155,
0.0618568696,
-0.0168330017,
0.005662099,
-0.0022624154,
-0.0182264093,
0.0031126351,
-0.0402048118,
-0.0449922048,
-0.0036006535,
0.0028803186,
-0.0092078857,
-0.0041015767,
-0.0000020709,
3.207e-7,
-0.0370516628,
-0.0104114516,
0.0114415437,
0.0184549298,
0.0187712982,
0.030947037,
0.0872311816,
0.0389751606,
-0.0172278974,
-0.0200420786,
0.0621667914,
0.0340609811,
0.0203321129,
0.0391964503,
-0.0350953974,
-0.0508616753,
-0.0581107885,
-0.0234536193,
-0.0541383289,
0.0019777452,
-0.0002558109,
0.0816019401,
0.0912539661,
-0.0349457227,
0.0539112613,
-0.0105826836,
-0.0236722827,
0.0268761758,
-0.0102555761,
-0.0273882728,
0.0889711604,
0.0913926587,
-0.0341753624,
0.0714870989,
-0.0068160971,
0.0267203953,
-0.0168577675,
0.0068173273,
-0.013178383,
0.0403221846,
-0.0273403618,
-0.0815994069,
0.0009381431,
-0.0092701316,
0.0854007378,
0.0163606554,
-0.0171238445,
0.0123511236,
-0.0333730169,
-0.0243750606,
0.0102790147,
0.0319492258,
0.0237590428,
-0.011138265,
0.0137488162,
-0.0396633409,
-0.0102649126,
-0.0254356265,
0.0659320056,
0.0167949069,
-0.0231857523,
-0.0377248079,
0.0116176372,
-0.0137100527,
0.0696595088,
0.0472306907,
0.0182651915,
2.768353481e-34,
0.0151349222,
0.0532821603,
-0.0153008122,
-0.0450180769,
-0.0092274388,
-0.0187219419,
-0.0067646909,
-0.041290056,
-0.0020277926,
-0.0554401726,
-0.0229165889
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.07013v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.07013v1 | Knowledge Distillation for Closed-Source Language Models | 2024-01-13T08:43:32 | 2024-01-13T08:43:32 | Hongzhan Chen, Xiaojun Quan, Hehong Chen, Ming Yan, Ji Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Closed-source language models such as GPT-4 have achieved remarkable
performance. Many recent studies focus on enhancing the capabilities of smaller
models through knowledge distillation from closed-source language models.
However, due to the incapability to directly access the weights, hidden states,
and output distributions of these closed-source models, the distillation can
only be performed by fine-tuning smaller models with data samples generated by
closed-source language models, which constrains the effectiveness of knowledge
distillation. In this paper, we propose to estimate the output distributions of
closed-source language models within a Bayesian estimation framework, involving
both prior and posterior estimation. The prior estimation aims to derive a
prior distribution by utilizing the corpus generated by closed-source language
models, while the posterior estimation employs a proxy model to update the
prior distribution and derive a posterior distribution. By leveraging the
estimated output distribution of closed-source language models, traditional
knowledge distillation can be executed. Experimental results demonstrate that
our method surpasses the performance of current models directly fine-tuned on
data generated by closed-source language models. | [
0.0120367967,
0.0840962678,
-0.018564377,
0.0326567329,
-0.0302442648,
0.0065460685,
-0.0162677485,
0.0268512741,
-0.0283134356,
-0.0222746618,
-0.0370433219,
-0.0194169804,
0.0266358387,
0.0231304113,
0.0456040353,
-0.0413917974,
0.0071149087,
-0.0788464099,
-0.0114448341,
-0.0151409796,
-0.0054441029,
0.0180397425,
0.0230017211,
0.0538499206,
0.0344288275,
0.0073462892,
-0.0100638587,
0.0019476361,
0.0076007992,
0.0365360528,
-0.0082496479,
0.0503840409,
0.0188237224,
0.0290294103,
0.0000018456,
-0.0102561731,
-0.0173782837,
-0.0091008823,
-0.003217645,
0.0242496412,
0.0465550683,
-0.022261126,
-0.0065221572,
0.0242602397,
0.0059873317,
-0.0164977778,
0.071047172,
-0.0208622273,
0.0328107588,
0.0541562587,
0.0111074299,
-0.0286289379,
0.0323888138,
-0.037827976,
-0.0297164433,
-0.0240361765,
0.028700253,
0.0171939507,
-0.004359819,
-0.0150897447,
-0.0143013662,
0.0308120791,
0.0098040327,
0.0322922468,
-0.0513435714,
0.0286697093,
-0.0244341698,
0.0061771451,
-0.0048184418,
0.0446834974,
-0.0256499834,
-0.0425631963,
0.0317596905,
-0.023467103,
-0.0128406063,
0.0270504709,
-0.0439588651,
0.0092878677,
0.0072577498,
0.0429017656,
0.0110246493,
-0.0241601001,
0.0363945439,
-0.0263476875,
-0.0215473752,
0.1204002053,
0.039844919,
-0.0050353869,
-0.0301335473,
-0.0340341739,
-0.0234028623,
-0.0560422428,
-0.0024970432,
-0.0088140769,
0.0748513043,
0.0445153266,
-0.0264001712,
-0.043404039,
-0.0064217616,
-0.0391477309,
0.0069534206,
0.04339578,
-0.0098345382,
0.0048237955,
0.0010303358,
0.0443477146,
-0.0209705234,
0.0105577651,
-0.0346051939,
-0.0045865932,
-0.0526308008,
-0.0113154128,
-0.0325724185,
0.0242055226,
-0.0227963049,
-0.0073982137,
-0.0048282505,
0.0056749159,
0.0065103625,
-0.0474557243,
0.0481680967,
-0.0172013696,
-0.0567487366,
-0.0304294676,
-0.0192780104,
0.054975424,
0.0073532849,
-0.0185997393,
0.003101455,
-0.070376493,
-0.0168141294,
-0.009143942,
0.0143762883,
-0.0326460153,
-0.0176153108,
0.0291211661,
0.0217223279,
-0.0130166868,
-0.0277347229,
0.0012566766,
-0.0496646948,
-0.0661346465,
0.0180744939,
-0.0880371854,
0.0058135274,
0.0007825646,
0.0195790995,
-0.0890646353,
0.0006426972,
-0.0398767367,
-0.0505264886,
0.0525545217,
-0.0223234519,
-0.0006063589,
0.0024516045,
0.005629471,
0.0130477352,
0.0905600861,
0.0210764408,
0.0275700279,
-0.0065490659,
-0.0185520984,
0.0081650978,
0.0424432233,
0.0317288078,
0.06297829,
-0.075107649,
-0.0237412509,
-0.0119940126,
-0.0313415229,
0.0384504162,
0.0469753556,
-0.0223147441,
0.0303672254,
0.0847760513,
0.0102043534,
0.0074506626,
-0.0205001943,
0.0250792354,
-0.000877787,
0.0150087271,
0.0280970186,
-0.0231144298,
-0.0215371214,
-0.0090293214,
0.0255757999,
0.046687454,
0.0494621918,
-0.0098590413,
-0.0311679002,
0.0137173273,
-0.0347342156,
0.0240193605,
-0.0051748836,
0.1083308831,
0.0051107104,
-0.0089601791,
0.0959235579,
0.067150332,
-0.0492779389,
0.0222310293,
-0.0644730404,
0.023256598,
0.017977003,
0.0596452765,
-0.0267616734,
0.0179909915,
0.0042823078,
-0.042791348,
0.0364231132,
-0.0138028981,
0.003103721,
0.0239834227,
-0.0305842031,
-0.0380612276,
-0.0131450938,
0.0337166041,
0.0426579453,
-0.0148667283,
0.0046078009,
0.0398381837,
-0.074807018,
0.0031324141,
0.0088450415,
-0.0122675532,
-0.0153446998,
-0.017725369,
-0.02376852,
0.0481123403,
0.003649293,
-0.0264145937,
0.0194567461,
0.0225211307,
0.0060452442,
-0.0117623257,
0.0103929639,
0.0084545407,
-0.0194677114,
0.0501891188,
-0.0067448542,
0.0673984885,
0.0291534122,
-0.0355571024,
-0.0723117515,
0.0501044728,
0.0252146106,
0.0777207837,
-0.0257484298,
0.0321183242,
-0.0111544458,
-0.0043872595,
-0.0044978377,
0.0208136477,
-0.0464118384,
-0.0033871925,
-0.0093872286,
-0.0529384576,
0.0008184794,
-0.0120688435,
-0.0097291162,
0.0201589391,
-0.0059619974,
0.0113570457,
0.0514306799,
-0.0062834243,
0.018210642,
-0.0080352984,
-0.0516976081,
-0.0014022368,
-0.0420899466,
0.0073994948,
0.0508888066,
0.039470166,
-0.011625235,
0.0010611555,
-0.0345690623,
-0.0070025795,
-0.0364535563,
-0.0057018884,
-0.0329171643,
0.0417130701,
-0.0253399424,
-0.0571904704,
-0.0242823567,
-0.000403925,
0.0191548336,
-0.0202105381,
-0.00877083,
-0.0565370284,
0.0441538841,
-0.036363434,
0.0670955554,
-0.0248199832,
-0.0414823703,
0.0134835243,
-0.029434111,
0.0436971672,
-0.0203718655,
-0.0258220546,
0.0121889869,
0.0772287473,
-0.0120139783,
-0.0271568764,
0.0120638823,
-0.054831285,
-0.0268345121,
-0.0743412003,
-0.0448937491,
0.0206195731,
0.0771845356,
0.0321749635,
-0.0190154742,
-0.079095006,
-0.0097321058,
-0.0216278099,
-0.0360616148,
-0.0311734639,
0.0026417456,
-0.0280999783,
0.0225469191,
-0.0015292532,
-0.0752757415,
0.0271086264,
-0.0693560466,
0.0286291875,
-0.0200667381,
-0.0034763659,
-0.0034347752,
0.0462221354,
0.0339283533,
0.0246200413,
0.0164815355,
0.0071789399,
-0.044953905,
0.0366136245,
0.0028518892,
-0.016791543,
0.0345370583,
-0.0646003634,
0.0118942922,
0.0313703828,
-0.0079155155,
-0.0069494597,
-0.0070731533,
-0.0264151786,
0.0262791608,
0.0546156913,
-0.0333781689,
0.0229269713,
0.0588627569,
0.0082335183,
0.0725810453,
0.0197654851,
0.0129655115,
-0.0414461419,
0.004172272,
0.0904386044,
-0.0588823855,
0.0103124361,
-0.0362692289,
-0.023953082,
0.0125369374,
0.0837046728,
0.0158006139,
-0.0167316068,
-0.0560134724,
0.038132187,
-0.0071004839,
-0.0342830755,
0.0309387837,
0.0160023067,
-0.0386694558,
0.0071836705,
0.1172223762,
0.0037895455,
-0.0442421734,
0.0210889038,
0.0323222615,
0.0378725193,
-0.0121290805,
0.0040414515,
-0.0704320371,
-0.0106005855,
-0.0030224426,
0.0210842602,
0.0119177978,
-0.0158597399,
-0.0171890091,
-0.118805714,
0.0004245189,
0.0189719088,
-0.0035693697,
-0.0407681875,
-0.0310868509,
0.0235764999,
-0.0236745961,
-0.0216443911,
0.0079697277,
0.0221679062,
0.0199785549,
0.0236643106,
-0.0436972752,
-0.0747027099,
0.001875794,
0.008286464,
0.046802409,
0.0422265977,
0.0331400335,
-0.0261644553,
-0.0352129452,
0.0123827308,
-0.0477618463,
-0.0268972032,
0.0098474398,
0.0421468802,
0.0118485996,
0.0018872597,
0.0537204258,
0.0227273591,
-0.0424939618,
-0.0098931333,
-0.0183458365,
0.0313140638,
-0.0037889644,
-0.0592741258,
0.0143017145,
-0.0506558605,
0.0385145582,
0.063143298,
0.036338862,
-0.0309626516,
-0.0100142015,
-0.0330522358,
0.0091686724,
0.0236895215,
-0.0043099155,
-0.019273147,
0.0032038442,
-0.0459962226,
-0.0823900327,
0.0068420842,
0.0119715473,
0.0236179121,
0.0157277565,
0.0441200323,
0.0464283116,
0.0025330128,
-0.0071609886,
-0.0029303883,
-0.0308765434,
-0.0079753995,
-0.0394777358,
-0.0521032587,
-0.0064414316,
-0.0026715528,
-0.0569688343,
0.0371458195,
-0.1269997656,
-0.0980405137,
0.0002427832,
0.0638632476,
0.0295806564,
-0.0005403924,
-0.0671618581,
-0.0472275019,
0.0454229303,
-0.0229359958,
-0.0237691645,
0.0097465571,
0.0272910707,
-0.0288266018,
0.0081680035,
0.0373510867,
-0.0551645346,
0.0194343068,
0.035361167,
0.019846363,
-0.0336130038,
-0.062526606,
0.0055359099,
0.0158371907,
0.0688599274,
-0.0393116809,
0.0132526727,
-0.0384453312,
-0.0115484558,
-0.012114035,
0.0141944513,
-0.0719431713,
-0.0087169148,
0.0392960869,
0.0011727952,
0.0088084228,
-0.0018675401,
-0.0056060678,
0.00961765,
-0.0379826613,
-0.0552493669,
0.0664735362,
0.0406567268,
0.0716862679,
-0.0150163081,
0.0331336409,
0.0224030726,
-0.012941868,
0.0204789732,
-0.0083855139,
0.0348010845,
0.0055858945,
-0.0360414237,
0.0141091561,
0.0303304251,
-0.0654845312,
-0.0529073365,
-0.0480150469,
0.0577857122,
0.0180337913,
0.0458008237,
0.0957335383,
-0.035954345,
0.0031529928,
-0.0541533642,
0.045036722,
0.032732591,
-0.0064084055,
0.036123082,
0.0019513374,
-0.0495030433,
0.0198588818,
0.1309377104,
0.0572997518,
0.0689696372,
-0.0293998662,
0.0086852154,
-0.003061888,
-0.0236289799,
-0.0395862982,
0.0409685224,
-0.0145274382,
0.0319114812,
-0.044670172,
-0.0923668444,
-0.0336030163,
0.0060905875,
0.003398757,
-0.0245650094,
0.034003742,
0.0228288472,
-0.0435420461,
-0.0213599596,
-0.0691985711,
-0.0184959807,
-0.0030378341,
-0.024920918,
0.0271512214,
-6.324366788e-33,
-0.0327105895,
0.0316511244,
-0.0128967119,
-0.012669201,
0.0093615185,
-0.0367759429,
-0.040051315,
-0.0201143119,
-0.0040585846,
-0.0005177498,
0.0162125304,
0.0413774811,
0.0175822321,
0.015090174,
-0.006934138,
0.0258159004,
0.0601594299,
-0.001651063,
-0.0203611385,
0.056164287,
0.0590612888,
0.0285298321,
0.0979260728,
-0.0183675345,
0.0266824104,
-0.0133674387,
-0.042714715,
0.0027082677,
0.0230644085,
0.0287536401,
-0.0247227158,
0.0244936869,
-0.0042466824,
-0.0455050208,
-0.0519511886,
-0.0385218151,
-0.0104046669,
0.0054132142,
0.0456900671,
-0.0337520875,
0.0015393747,
-0.0157199129,
0.0140584493,
0.0119776092,
0.0235562846,
0.0087112347,
0.0192604028,
-0.0128639713,
0.0085337125,
0.0011509748,
-0.0303978585,
0.0301544406,
0.0031068677,
0.0139811626,
0.0300732218,
0.0216593463,
-0.0104344459,
-0.0018797253,
-0.0324616991,
0.0061087231,
0.0787378997,
0.0753029883,
0.0951498598,
0.0416332185,
0.0318175219,
0.0274823233,
-0.0060292222,
-0.0324444994,
-0.0253451951,
-0.0187722016,
0.0840848684,
0.0617973432,
-0.0051903143,
0.0140115051,
0.0214698389,
-0.028271446,
-0.0158930235,
-0.0110533871,
-0.0052342769,
0.0159366969,
0.0119706783,
0.030825939,
-0.0281407312,
-0.046787858,
-0.0545759536,
-0.0622319207,
0.0044689183,
-0.0198013037,
0.0342472456,
0.0168621186,
-0.0390331149,
-0.0247640274,
0.0489575788,
-0.0545323417,
-0.0044783093,
0.0209108517,
-0.0342712924,
0.032418333,
0.0094528673,
0.0278544631,
-0.0623781942,
0.0011917626,
0.0343403257,
0.033346165,
-0.0168977138,
0.0082819071,
-0.0158063918,
0.0506990775,
-0.0364148058,
0.0099889981,
-0.0649452582,
0.0008387353,
0.0239631403,
0.0043284427,
0.0409247763,
-0.0006841898,
0.003819532,
-0.0119884182,
0.0410589464,
-0.0318370871,
0.0134087438,
0.0162482709,
0.012794558,
0.0090253698,
-0.0459475555,
-0.0334640667,
0.0169776287,
0.0122385724,
0.071754232,
0.0118344212,
-0.0319339931,
0.0132908812,
2.577e-7,
0.0561273843,
-0.0255675893,
-0.0009269002,
0.003484589,
0.0402096696,
0.0088046705,
-0.0038061349,
0.0054742629,
0.0259822533,
-0.0706693605,
-0.0195262209,
0.0107769538,
0.0551012941,
0.0199302826,
-0.0770458207,
-0.0121166902,
-0.0467536077,
-0.0051710061,
-0.0178696625,
-0.0444022082,
-0.0329926312,
0.104996033,
0.036696095,
0.0024095273,
-0.0105997678,
-0.0280849803,
0.0254638661,
-0.0221012384,
0.005230953,
0.0326263979,
0.0132828914,
0.0308361258,
-0.0049595521,
-0.0068130018,
-0.0083418097,
0.0006204991,
0.0008705148,
0.0689684823,
-0.0147569878,
0.013592666,
0.0059362468,
0.0135668758,
-0.0064573647,
-0.0505324863,
0.0490992405,
-0.0091603072,
0.0277865939,
-0.0455220677,
-0.017950993,
-0.0308751762,
-0.0219646264,
-0.0049322983,
-0.00200213,
0.0283345971,
-0.0078635784,
-0.0147227068,
0.0044144117,
-0.0539297834,
-0.0388905294,
0.0067468379,
-0.0474594124,
-0.0666088387,
-0.0162865669,
-0.0710576773,
0.0048682741,
-0.0548087098,
0.0313688889,
2.424766125e-34,
0.0251129996,
0.0046753637,
-0.0184066072,
0.0178230554,
0.0231341757,
-0.0291194636,
-0.0390318334,
0.0117829191,
-0.0145049421,
-0.096678108,
-0.0335196927
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.07009v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.07009v1 | Joint Extraction of Uyghur Medicine Knowledge with Edge Computing | 2024-01-13T08:27:24 | 2024-01-13T08:27:24 | Fan Lu, Quan Qi, Huaibin Qin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Medical knowledge extraction methods based on edge computing deploy deep
learning models on edge devices to achieve localized entity and relation
extraction. This approach avoids transferring substantial sensitive data to
cloud data centers, effectively safeguarding the privacy of healthcare
services. However, existing relation extraction methods mainly employ a
sequential pipeline approach, which classifies relations between determined
entities after entity recognition. This mode faces challenges such as error
propagation between tasks, insufficient consideration of dependencies between
the two subtasks, and the neglect of interrelations between different relations
within a sentence. To address these challenges, a joint extraction model with
parameter sharing in edge computing is proposed, named CoEx-Bert. This model
leverages shared parameterization between two models to jointly extract
entities and relations. Specifically, CoEx-Bert employs two models, each
separately sharing hidden layer parameters, and combines these two loss
functions for joint backpropagation to optimize the model parameters.
Additionally, it effectively resolves the issue of entity overlapping when
extracting knowledge from unstructured Uyghur medical texts by considering
contextual relations. Finally, this model is deployed on edge devices for
real-time extraction and inference of Uyghur medical knowledge. Experimental
results demonstrate that CoEx-Bert outperforms existing state-of-the-art
methods, achieving accuracy, recall, and F1 scores of 90.65\%, 92.45\%, and
91.54\%, respectively, in the Uyghur traditional medical literature dataset.
These improvements represent a 6.45\% increase in accuracy, a 9.45\% increase
in recall, and a 7.95\% increase in F1 score compared to the baseline. | [
0.02216506,
0.0867967382,
0.0111877536,
0.0094592376,
-0.0191667229,
0.0295430142,
0.0561707057,
0.0060278303,
0.0232905168,
-0.0119267106,
-0.0169185922,
-0.0345444791,
0.000655238,
0.0275968704,
-0.0055658813,
-0.0270464979,
0.0363264009,
0.0292631574,
0.0395544097,
-0.0074550221,
-0.0246305708,
0.0046009622,
-0.030373292,
0.0030396159,
-0.0135905081,
-0.009668801,
0.0227549784,
-0.011722791,
0.0607905574,
-0.0497346073,
0.0180206113,
0.0021830711,
-0.0276028607,
0.0023408076,
0.0000022027,
-0.0375809483,
-0.0617857426,
0.0168118663,
-0.0570870601,
-0.0683906749,
0.0139433509,
-0.0359454416,
-0.0140255671,
-0.0235423502,
-0.0358519591,
-0.0315927044,
0.0383098163,
0.0661814138,
0.0116766971,
0.0478641242,
-0.034505073,
-0.0123218531,
0.0446547419,
0.0058355196,
-0.0346221589,
-0.0286958609,
0.0206689667,
-0.0512770861,
-0.0176152103,
-0.0269220453,
0.0352729186,
0.0373470187,
0.0285179634,
0.0601470545,
-0.0028394777,
0.0361764319,
-0.0334954262,
-0.0346998125,
-0.0123373838,
0.0950307325,
-0.0177198388,
0.0051064766,
0.0632547438,
0.0270228554,
-0.044726599,
0.0117116058,
-0.0130634727,
0.0263132099,
-0.0616395846,
-0.0059988177,
0.0031056905,
-0.0123683279,
0.0603530072,
0.0232071877,
-0.0216301177,
0.0275251251,
0.0174265765,
-0.0215812493,
0.0083605302,
-0.0149125708,
-0.0124806026,
0.0038634287,
0.0717019811,
0.0543358661,
-0.0191614758,
0.007579403,
-0.0371995233,
-0.0806626752,
0.0267104693,
-0.0477495082,
0.0015480502,
0.0117416242,
-0.0200695097,
0.0612203591,
-0.0340770558,
-0.0175353326,
-0.0381212682,
0.0015740357,
-0.0093133058,
0.0142541453,
-0.0165722426,
-0.0160754286,
-0.0071453475,
0.0716738254,
-0.0063281367,
-0.0348694324,
-0.0482703298,
-0.0192029215,
0.0004184342,
0.0338320024,
-0.0036674624,
0.0458917618,
-0.0431093164,
-0.0182014778,
0.0476494208,
-0.001801118,
0.0037474346,
0.0174104311,
-0.0130507899,
-0.080159314,
0.0198743306,
-0.0101128761,
0.0514956526,
0.0045121694,
0.0213486888,
0.0523605831,
0.0254976749,
-0.0277014431,
0.0022652897,
-0.0236519948,
0.0146843437,
-0.0213563982,
0.0281700678,
-0.0487336405,
0.0602106676,
0.0099471826,
-0.0129669812,
-0.0491533838,
0.0285589732,
-0.0048387474,
-0.0527376346,
0.0530792363,
-0.0430981815,
-0.0111713754,
0.0710129067,
0.0601941086,
-0.000641976,
0.011119904,
0.0617383085,
-0.0325288698,
0.031354364,
0.0037208088,
-0.0156426262,
0.0000540418,
0.0402810313,
-0.0664208978,
-0.0124572935,
-0.0047023506,
0.0118520102,
0.053707514,
-0.0130604366,
0.0754882172,
-0.0121917697,
0.0035551083,
0.0097416425,
0.0387954116,
0.0317758732,
0.0531203449,
-0.0164203476,
-0.0140888318,
0.0149200726,
-0.0281356052,
-0.0182269625,
-0.0027566801,
0.0484770648,
0.0006716466,
-0.0004428721,
0.0342580527,
-0.0251785722,
-0.0074245189,
-0.0000476362,
-0.059854228,
-0.0197814424,
-0.0059994506,
0.0703281835,
0.0056802714,
-0.0184676237,
0.0721082538,
0.0596696064,
-0.0132984873,
-0.0135388644,
-0.0078780772,
0.0194995366,
0.0538083762,
0.0230783056,
-0.0395901203,
-0.0370065793,
-0.0125789111,
-0.0246088393,
-0.0199530348,
-0.0287894495,
-0.0287590828,
0.0769482404,
-0.0499579087,
0.0093056588,
0.0513220057,
0.0100829462,
-0.0327843726,
0.0228623282,
0.0672097057,
0.0210265964,
-0.0151621802,
0.0025553349,
0.0164230727,
-0.0351145044,
-0.0097459359,
0.0182573348,
0.0367373675,
0.0250036251,
0.0212800819,
-0.0193779171,
-0.0011991888,
0.0393458307,
-0.0765232518,
-0.0239354875,
0.0181233101,
-0.0585731268,
-0.0093959281,
0.0011261274,
0.0018606943,
0.0211046748,
0.0186368003,
-0.0156754144,
-0.022241069,
-0.017049728,
0.0052492046,
0.0477619953,
0.0126851462,
0.0157134421,
0.0600037239,
0.0170512646,
-0.0106059853,
0.034117423,
-0.0353440233,
-0.0150537016,
0.0031531404,
-0.0706916451,
-0.0112917544,
-0.0165737383,
0.0025926894,
0.0413477458,
-0.0138011808,
-0.0153527074,
-0.0129497284,
0.0166897792,
-0.0383960642,
-0.01808374,
-0.1201296672,
0.0309157334,
-0.0122247329,
0.0439996384,
0.0156299509,
0.0573217943,
-0.0081716776,
-0.0527153127,
-0.0338145979,
-0.0239325743,
-0.0368699618,
0.0236123521,
0.0378952622,
0.0389610976,
0.0510342792,
-0.0038670064,
-0.0383219644,
-0.0312852226,
0.0686356574,
-0.006281463,
-0.048189681,
0.0371549167,
-0.0417279266,
-0.0016164242,
0.0250396561,
-0.0030991205,
-0.0058935848,
-0.0055595152,
0.0084333178,
-0.0018686262,
0.0410728939,
-0.022555897,
0.0251345858,
-0.0069326102,
-0.0183690321,
0.0080833901,
0.0392946973,
-0.0448489785,
0.0331280641,
0.014189139,
0.0057293046,
-0.0437505916,
0.0432709791,
-0.0217999201,
0.0141749335,
-0.0003824174,
0.0028027613,
-0.0195073932,
0.0106780119,
-0.0453743562,
0.026786495,
-0.0246175509,
0.0146226306,
-0.0254473481,
-0.0293124355,
0.0702657104,
0.0131955203,
0.0393748768,
-0.0459731631,
-0.0030894857,
-0.0224448238,
0.0186278634,
-0.032128796,
0.0417612679,
-0.0605526008,
-0.0537426136,
-0.0023704162,
0.0444909595,
-0.0138458563,
-0.0560672283,
-0.0203351174,
-0.0210482702,
-0.0025839601,
-0.0188251268,
-0.0329492576,
-0.052693326,
0.0328610688,
-0.0095850304,
0.0149929607,
-0.0162246581,
-0.0075437808,
0.029283544,
0.00030638,
-0.0153291849,
0.0690816417,
0.0076184785,
0.0273904707,
-0.0105836643,
0.0691398382,
0.0616364479,
-0.02654217,
-0.0238265451,
0.0503837876,
0.038252037,
0.0681324378,
0.0557823889,
0.0049580331,
-0.0081716087,
0.0102958158,
-0.0019808691,
-0.0576528385,
-0.0227498971,
-0.0097884992,
0.0276050512,
-0.076903984,
0.0198312253,
0.0737436935,
-0.0048535909,
-0.060418494,
0.0128312157,
0.0061900956,
-0.068367444,
-0.0224809572,
-0.009768866,
-0.0693386346,
-0.0060702446,
0.0094898166,
0.0033580677,
0.0204495564,
-0.0310763977,
0.0232111923,
-0.042844709,
-0.0290812459,
-0.00311665,
-0.0125812097,
-0.0587649643,
-0.055572819,
0.0069255452,
0.0202676263,
-0.001843138,
-0.014597293,
-0.0026441175,
-0.0060472726,
0.0201637466,
-0.0573400967,
-0.0493050665,
0.0221949033,
-0.0409489051,
-0.0069872527,
0.0504215024,
0.0197438803,
-0.0220277458,
-0.0247691236,
0.0086644823,
-0.0386350043,
-0.0433799066,
-0.0419012941,
0.0495300554,
-0.0398961976,
-0.0178657863,
-0.0335549265,
0.0590616874,
-0.0333060995,
-0.0169372745,
-0.0225611497,
0.0531639196,
-0.0074382746,
-0.0190945212,
-0.0149408057,
-0.0407585092,
0.0332540609,
0.0206760466,
-0.0399856716,
-0.0080746524,
-0.0621975735,
0.0526797213,
0.0012864866,
-0.0086910091,
0.0117883282,
0.0491558388,
-0.011441947,
-0.0860914737,
-0.048562441,
-0.0573504791,
0.0298116785,
0.0195343159,
0.0312530212,
0.0464894325,
0.0563397668,
0.0223904885,
-0.0922053382,
0.0281707495,
0.0377309136,
-0.0122333234,
-0.007834862,
-0.0111622252,
0.0363395251,
-0.0091767814,
-0.028068753,
0.0036432983,
-0.0115297968,
-0.0338591598,
0.0168216862,
0.0222874973,
0.0113904634,
0.0447376184,
-0.0118047418,
-0.0134882666,
0.0412229002,
0.0556216128,
-0.0822900459,
-0.0360952206,
0.0458978638,
-0.0054306346,
-0.020958934,
0.0304860771,
-0.0082474174,
-0.0048837382,
0.0181500409,
0.0169650577,
-0.08185862,
-0.0533061624,
0.0024910388,
0.0156871732,
0.0629926696,
0.0049149003,
0.0090489397,
-0.0394084826,
0.0508050025,
0.0131187486,
0.0269874725,
-0.0286078677,
0.021573456,
-0.0148146329,
0.018057609,
0.0085421959,
-0.0021338256,
0.0607545525,
-0.0730623677,
-0.0233789776,
0.0454344638,
-0.0117570879,
0.0575545467,
0.0342608392,
-0.0229433365,
-0.0142417811,
0.0212102141,
-0.0001195296,
-0.0010293029,
-0.0576419048,
0.0312448945,
-0.0054559996,
-0.0034689524,
0.0133544169,
0.0492869429,
0.0069336672,
-0.0153481113,
-0.0233277194,
-0.0143138291,
0.0304812323,
0.0029763128,
0.0208304282,
-0.01139927,
0.0031544701,
-0.0190974846,
0.0279737376,
-0.0514613651,
0.0155384615,
0.0309993252,
0.0138949985,
-0.0147637865,
0.0249855053,
0.0703004822,
0.0104433643,
0.0587149374,
0.0379428938,
-0.0431377701,
-0.0453087687,
-0.0199086741,
0.0206069481,
-0.0006161265,
-0.0602912121,
0.0122722667,
0.0172495376,
-0.0460442416,
0.0398126319,
-0.0348931067,
-0.0124907764,
-0.0198195521,
0.0533146858,
0.0525438339,
0.0192952119,
-0.0540351719,
-0.0426868238,
0.0791658983,
-0.0403280742,
-0.0008332498,
0.0479472131,
-7.079724764e-33,
0.0158739779,
-0.0209841728,
0.0250177216,
-0.0256547518,
-0.0089066578,
0.0389493443,
-0.0392142013,
0.0046813348,
-0.0254452303,
0.0102697322,
-0.0264436677,
0.0146176256,
0.0324903615,
0.0409291461,
-0.0087591726,
-0.0484395623,
0.0290722698,
0.0329542756,
0.0281723477,
0.0548447184,
0.0095519777,
0.1258865744,
0.0679467693,
-0.0909873322,
0.0032591429,
-0.0152276922,
0.0391123854,
-0.0144838002,
-0.0045284,
0.0175346714,
-0.0810672492,
0.0045758495,
0.0204659682,
-0.0067252014,
0.0125987362,
0.0085019488,
-0.1637969464,
0.0057741133,
-0.0567374229,
0.0371974707,
-0.0833799168,
-0.065206036,
0.038005691,
0.0192645546,
0.0010024973,
-0.0068290187,
0.007413452,
-0.0200927258,
-0.050120946,
-0.0815918073,
0.0020140354,
0.0475532524,
0.0272381194,
0.0149463173,
0.0310469493,
0.0082549322,
-0.0180776846,
0.0055329548,
-0.1182379052,
-0.0621767752,
-0.0226389393,
0.0287668128,
0.0392436162,
-0.0352962613,
-0.0023013745,
0.0569234379,
-0.0181926861,
-0.0578592122,
-0.038540937,
0.013588299,
-0.0349993333,
0.0729127899,
-0.028317444,
-0.0332561061,
0.048767183,
-0.0606559552,
-0.1197199449,
0.013389335,
-0.0242222361,
0.0563110523,
0.0047847531,
-0.0217713397,
-0.0462686792,
0.0326866023,
0.0374237411,
-0.0448684543,
-0.0057924595,
-0.0225111414,
0.01001829,
0.0026965016,
-0.0200607944,
0.0635560155,
-0.0040180143,
-0.0328096487,
0.0235401522,
0.0053339885,
0.0283388775,
0.0058360994,
-0.0219855495,
-0.0026279497,
-0.0550366193,
-0.0468359813,
-0.0488388054,
0.0087252799,
0.0479751639,
0.0297764167,
0.0460168608,
0.0061383992,
-0.0636834055,
-0.0116756223,
-0.013221154,
0.0126716429,
0.0093338042,
0.0532633774,
0.0320349187,
0.0004728824,
-0.0088004535,
0.0549716838,
0.0331866182,
0.0287409239,
-0.0446823314,
0.0063848295,
0.0146576324,
-0.0045948466,
-0.0114603769,
-0.0252331495,
-0.0449171886,
0.0656675771,
-0.0060061365,
-0.0503156297,
-0.004922431,
0.0090309931,
3.133e-7,
0.0400717445,
0.0149899479,
0.0410679318,
-0.0397207402,
0.0121351779,
0.0085650226,
0.0486081578,
0.0174178071,
-0.0406638086,
0.0095468666,
0.0175712164,
0.0211974829,
0.0339810885,
0.0178793818,
-0.0721403956,
-0.0641286224,
-0.0954558998,
-0.0054161185,
-0.0311255902,
-0.0245136525,
0.0223653298,
0.0698364824,
0.0009678478,
-0.0407594219,
-0.0033039048,
0.0205199979,
0.0174362268,
-0.0061466163,
0.036849834,
0.0266790055,
0.0121374149,
0.0179237593,
-0.0233057812,
0.0219711158,
-0.0186244193,
0.0011639709,
0.0295174923,
0.090013355,
-0.04035943,
0.0159670096,
0.0163353477,
-0.0105229281,
0.0157194696,
-0.0299336817,
0.080104515,
-0.0093182987,
-0.0442406945,
-0.0006676715,
0.0087869503,
-0.0092085227,
0.0250573587,
0.0137019549,
0.0192168429,
0.0081065586,
0.0359688476,
-0.0206920672,
-0.0507594384,
-0.0854218081,
-0.0065736687,
0.0282792598,
-0.0065999613,
-0.0274527315,
0.0068472419,
-0.0222046152,
0.0182183608,
-0.041749265,
0.0118583646,
2.746641274e-34,
-0.0184086114,
0.0242065638,
-0.0159780011,
0.0643365756,
-0.0117655806,
-0.0538489148,
0.0003686619,
0.0004368699,
-0.0093137212,
-0.0412336551,
-0.0106462911
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.07004v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.07004v1 | Extending LLMs' Context Window with 100 Samples | 2024-01-13T07:57:01 | 2024-01-13T07:57:01 | Yikai Zhang, Junlong Li, Pengfei Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) are known to have limited extrapolation ability
beyond their pre-trained context window, constraining their application in
downstream tasks with lengthy inputs. Recent studies have sought to extend
LLMs' context window by modifying rotary position embedding (RoPE), a popular
position encoding method adopted by well-known LLMs such as LLaMA, PaLM, and
GPT-NeoX. However, prior works like Position Interpolation (PI) and YaRN are
resource-intensive and lack comparative experiments to assess their
applicability. In this work, we identify the inherent need for LLMs' attention
entropy (i.e. the information entropy of attention scores) to maintain
stability and introduce a novel extension to RoPE which combines adjusting
RoPE's base frequency and scaling the attention logits to help LLMs efficiently
adapt to a larger context window. We validate the superiority of our method in
both fine-tuning performance and robustness across different context window
sizes on various context-demanding tasks. Notably, our method extends the
context window of LLaMA-2-7B-Chat to 16,384 with only 100 samples and 6
training steps, showcasing extraordinary efficiency. Finally, we also explore
how data compositions and training curricula affect context window extension
for specific downstream tasks, suggesting fine-tuning LLMs with lengthy
conversations as a good starting point. We release our code and SFT data at
https://github.com/GAIR-NLP/Entropy-ABF. | [
0.0264543444,
0.0537299439,
-0.0032510248,
0.0428333841,
-0.0233156681,
-0.0136516755,
-0.0235714074,
-0.0004643088,
-0.0203454308,
-0.0387083665,
-0.0740560815,
-0.0465581641,
0.0365535766,
0.0015313665,
0.0588467754,
-0.0736320913,
0.0271484517,
-0.0243089236,
-0.004779961,
0.0233859569,
-0.0032189423,
-0.0147099122,
0.0241405442,
0.0511043034,
0.0189657416,
-0.0161199775,
-0.0390170328,
0.0172313172,
0.0451118872,
-0.0077708396,
0.0068423767,
0.0427711941,
0.0319564864,
0.005735856,
0.0000020788,
-0.0095594227,
0.0289502759,
-0.0194384214,
-0.0069405073,
0.0370304137,
0.0312276352,
-0.0297652315,
-0.0181801282,
0.0481337942,
-0.0210781321,
-0.0139183868,
0.0343375243,
0.0084435605,
0.038717512,
0.0840156525,
-0.0065554432,
0.0065364363,
0.0298522394,
-0.072572276,
0.0485830866,
-0.0502976663,
0.0050474969,
-0.0014265901,
0.0181832742,
0.0490675271,
-0.0326487459,
0.0454587601,
0.0470348783,
-0.0087475209,
0.0085302917,
0.0604978241,
0.0022505778,
-0.0068123834,
-0.0211661868,
0.0882423893,
-0.0640725121,
-0.0068405066,
-0.0196551364,
0.0021218914,
0.0151406489,
-0.0821225345,
-0.0800433233,
0.0196521655,
0.0304177329,
0.0128566623,
0.0220762491,
0.0094140423,
0.0360721759,
-0.0101497872,
-0.029365493,
0.0305877365,
-0.0087670749,
-0.0440649502,
-0.0241855457,
-0.0263187066,
-0.0419223718,
-0.0322526693,
0.0082708048,
0.033539515,
-0.0064180624,
0.0460173562,
-0.050948482,
0.0173697956,
0.0296556484,
-0.0441686995,
0.0176244471,
0.0648151338,
0.0122986631,
0.0338844322,
0.0280046128,
0.0451506786,
-0.0197277591,
0.0349181369,
-0.0582994632,
0.0144822374,
0.009851601,
-0.0088330861,
-0.0162170511,
-0.0282573849,
-0.0478546657,
-0.0524015687,
-0.006199982,
0.0589247569,
0.006528235,
-0.0093435925,
0.0281509962,
0.0046723979,
-0.0314199179,
0.0120572681,
0.0147584025,
0.0461733863,
-0.0148619628,
0.040168114,
0.0385602899,
-0.0307023078,
-0.0470821187,
0.0331517458,
0.0009442885,
-0.0230030343,
-0.0142857432,
0.0573024228,
0.0044739186,
-0.0494369268,
-0.0184826981,
0.0252641346,
-0.0348594412,
-0.0629917085,
-0.0035153271,
-0.0393639505,
0.0432231613,
-0.0194979161,
0.0054707099,
0.0147792343,
0.0135122826,
0.0468965247,
-0.0390566513,
0.0734809861,
0.0214512981,
0.0102927294,
0.0019098374,
0.0171261225,
0.0213202499,
0.0995539129,
0.0461979732,
0.0381287187,
0.0301670004,
-0.0101123527,
-0.0505148321,
0.0310727283,
0.0159692653,
-0.0201438013,
-0.0035579836,
0.0059975917,
0.0102770217,
0.0559610426,
0.0664631799,
0.0390604697,
-0.0411801822,
-0.0393372104,
0.0662802532,
0.0881034285,
0.0059596482,
-0.018970428,
0.0199829154,
0.0169676784,
-0.0122739989,
0.0042267814,
-0.0901504904,
0.0476042256,
0.0428931303,
0.0265738182,
0.0967532769,
0.019072976,
-0.032658577,
-0.0462085158,
-0.0227934346,
-0.0099760182,
-0.0057484126,
0.0199377686,
-0.0080250194,
-0.0065812669,
-0.0405614637,
0.0464984924,
0.0259364005,
-0.0199615899,
-0.0260105878,
-0.0036232912,
-0.0238705575,
0.1110920906,
0.0224413536,
-0.0159975048,
-0.0448190682,
-0.029424347,
-0.0051629441,
0.0294661745,
0.0181342885,
0.0134467017,
0.042283237,
-0.0359953083,
0.006947414,
-0.0067750434,
0.0057273428,
0.0191714801,
0.0422790311,
0.0292871147,
0.0209461078,
-0.0066713868,
0.0031165231,
0.0165614057,
-0.0380673073,
-0.0285040122,
-0.012776318,
-0.0042980486,
0.0525473766,
0.0065662456,
-0.006750606,
0.0086363796,
0.0584102646,
-0.0524676703,
0.026768174,
0.0029437363,
-0.1001896337,
-0.0749628842,
0.0562891141,
0.0088673234,
0.0005265509,
0.0152163561,
-0.0522644147,
-0.0401524827,
0.0342153236,
-0.0094594676,
0.0537360273,
-0.0172770042,
0.0248903744,
0.0305075981,
0.0473092124,
-0.0547090843,
0.0159576237,
-0.0258809123,
0.0220647398,
0.0032032956,
0.0196735226,
-0.0215433724,
-0.0397170596,
-0.0030597693,
0.039317552,
-0.0098769683,
0.0065301154,
-0.0382588021,
0.0183661543,
-0.0209996961,
-0.0619022138,
-0.1149476841,
0.0153553598,
-0.0252326224,
0.0206466131,
0.0364508182,
0.0249941833,
-0.0128631294,
-0.0008535583,
-0.0416863151,
0.0170516949,
-0.0102534629,
0.0160300452,
0.0103226518,
0.000844233,
-0.0257465318,
-0.0710121617,
-0.0146348476,
0.0257720836,
0.0334856212,
-0.0280209277,
-0.0075253621,
-0.045624949,
0.0413166918,
0.0110581191,
0.0141427908,
-0.0393286273,
-0.0481637232,
-0.0160212517,
-0.0221092775,
0.0401528217,
0.0784883723,
-0.003930158,
0.0215470064,
0.0488184169,
0.0136212492,
-0.0479693711,
0.0295923129,
-0.0184858814,
0.0047073448,
-0.0532930493,
-0.0124513963,
0.0013447232,
0.0776166692,
-0.0257775225,
0.013906219,
-0.0390360467,
-0.040981397,
0.0127952099,
-0.0139146969,
-0.0190415047,
0.0078093647,
-0.0562768951,
0.0091873407,
-0.056147702,
-0.0750160441,
0.0459619872,
-0.0426256992,
-0.0269519836,
-0.0268164463,
-0.0341861621,
-0.0531930029,
0.0616688281,
0.0296489075,
-0.0027853181,
-0.0182808358,
-0.0270065889,
-0.0349477269,
0.0040251138,
-0.0306031164,
-0.0213227626,
0.0520542338,
0.007474124,
-0.0070508076,
-0.0319838859,
-0.0399455652,
-0.0460821912,
-0.0203859359,
-0.0100930715,
-0.0033721551,
0.0364365801,
-0.0381369703,
-0.0043079783,
0.0163573027,
0.0043188124,
0.0553515702,
-0.0096310191,
0.0129336501,
-0.0286706556,
0.0124075692,
0.0369649418,
0.0437626615,
0.0005586304,
-0.0147270113,
0.0128716845,
0.0525242798,
0.0275060404,
0.0067085833,
-0.0123357754,
-0.0110010058,
0.0241204072,
-0.009308002,
-0.0042600585,
0.0032718049,
0.0548323728,
-0.0515556373,
-0.0075906985,
0.1036213413,
0.0130591616,
-0.0749591887,
0.0107123945,
-0.0068178158,
0.0659040511,
0.0245178733,
0.0366069898,
-0.0506833754,
-0.0262724254,
0.0325821489,
0.020686809,
0.0259180367,
0.0189640317,
-0.0257142279,
-0.0992718264,
0.0141959814,
0.0207326543,
-0.0452257507,
-0.0478593558,
-0.0516242981,
0.0164400302,
0.0262799822,
0.0404199362,
0.025137756,
-0.0202262886,
-0.0178279765,
0.0031830668,
-0.0138596101,
-0.0425918661,
0.0086216126,
-0.0089554759,
0.0628807992,
0.0206053816,
0.0258393958,
0.031207988,
-0.0322702453,
0.0447871462,
-0.0449733995,
-0.0023956452,
-0.0036097672,
0.0390536711,
-0.0311182439,
-0.0054944213,
0.0179567859,
0.0113366609,
-0.0399402045,
-0.0036843189,
-0.0074633094,
0.0718591288,
-0.0139656067,
-0.0029662142,
-0.0072386027,
0.0081501221,
-0.0020182754,
0.0703042001,
0.0790662318,
-0.0186935142,
-0.0417349227,
-0.0322289839,
-0.0157280453,
-0.0159853343,
0.0101089869,
-0.0044920836,
0.0264652371,
-0.0426467322,
-0.0539734848,
-0.0497952029,
0.0221963879,
0.0380430482,
-0.002923318,
0.0079909423,
-0.0156089952,
-0.0052416315,
-0.0551976487,
0.0090453885,
-0.0213600788,
0.017663341,
-0.0411443748,
0.0307132602,
0.0276688617,
0.003776565,
0.0105841206,
0.0241532475,
-0.1253891438,
-0.0767276362,
-0.0103881778,
0.0388869084,
0.0231580976,
0.0702562109,
-0.0316619538,
-0.025448747,
0.0377135277,
0.0203491729,
-0.0420658328,
0.0511095226,
0.0403763838,
0.0298139676,
0.0226739142,
0.0504951999,
-0.0276318844,
-0.0105344076,
-0.023241559,
0.0353528745,
-0.0217150841,
-0.0747694299,
-0.0226140302,
-0.0297299083,
0.0190191101,
0.0095009161,
0.0046675047,
-0.0017460547,
0.0527360104,
-0.0128412098,
0.0271618888,
-0.0613325126,
-0.0343449637,
0.0268413201,
-0.0265553594,
0.0136513636,
-0.0006573806,
0.0133728534,
-0.0131688192,
0.0012066027,
0.0169947147,
-0.0378628932,
0.0031920911,
-0.0089020859,
0.0251920577,
-0.0339518599,
-0.0199227091,
-0.0158275068,
0.0435099714,
-0.0209736321,
0.0112171927,
-0.0078516174,
-0.0449391082,
-0.0276289433,
0.0558983125,
-0.0877931938,
-0.0252336375,
-0.0170860719,
0.0531863235,
0.0566278882,
0.0117770061,
0.0628231764,
-0.0088267196,
0.0048146956,
-0.014379154,
0.0188647881,
-0.0256748199,
-0.0326797925,
0.0288191158,
0.0337329358,
-0.0180112589,
0.0056998916,
0.0710802451,
0.0306668114,
0.001175427,
0.0050360421,
-0.0002866828,
-0.0196879711,
-0.0283873603,
0.0149672516,
0.0278565176,
-0.0091177877,
0.0136645287,
-0.019249009,
-0.0843122974,
-0.0118837776,
-0.014624455,
-0.0445194505,
-0.033661887,
0.0233388692,
0.0336065851,
0.0033181601,
0.0048028072,
-0.0189766698,
-0.0181015078,
0.0060840403,
-0.0365040191,
-0.0111988252,
-6.969534659e-33,
-0.0367728248,
-0.006596718,
0.0101149315,
0.0056437105,
-0.0674436912,
0.0114812683,
-0.0445912778,
-0.0101704774,
-0.0152038326,
-0.0150338607,
-0.0364183746,
0.0097201588,
0.0158426221,
0.0262883548,
-0.0152246002,
-0.0205506235,
0.0108977221,
0.0052326941,
-0.0011893818,
0.0214045383,
0.0334887169,
0.0243024882,
0.0627577975,
-0.0212012827,
0.0048436043,
0.0173983146,
-0.0044710976,
0.0181263071,
0.0005678043,
0.037202958,
-0.0405295081,
0.0379126295,
0.0128249656,
-0.0599164627,
-0.0382281952,
0.0483405069,
-0.075426653,
-0.0418790691,
0.0222170167,
0.0130590899,
-0.0234936494,
-0.0482220799,
0.0729174018,
-0.0035051969,
0.0161215495,
-0.0280427597,
0.0002730216,
-0.0274421386,
-0.0645672008,
-0.0070900498,
-0.0180877484,
0.0051321839,
0.0044597196,
-0.0251946449,
0.0051211598,
0.0379583985,
0.0092927329,
-0.001488482,
-0.0563927554,
0.0115144709,
0.0073424554,
0.0808741674,
0.0504869707,
0.0210705251,
0.0342031233,
0.0441872701,
0.0035032104,
0.0179617666,
-0.0105718998,
-0.0391501486,
0.018390378,
0.0193840805,
0.0030117529,
-0.0244804751,
0.0532474183,
-0.0080502136,
-0.0533281267,
0.0091394549,
0.032179635,
0.0539880693,
0.0241381563,
0.0137648368,
-0.048907496,
-0.034017995,
-0.0076306649,
-0.0075059892,
-0.0218606628,
-0.0399815738,
0.0458088703,
0.0543160401,
0.0274959188,
-0.017488325,
0.056848608,
-0.0273804534,
0.0033004868,
0.0268467087,
-0.0013292173,
0.0395457894,
0.0150401583,
0.003186933,
-0.0447562821,
-0.0166315977,
0.0201386381,
0.0285651572,
-0.0012700261,
-0.016162701,
0.0399360619,
0.0268293712,
-0.0638658702,
-0.0196566079,
-0.047232464,
0.0222690403,
-0.0208023433,
0.0133250412,
0.0482605733,
-0.0239945296,
-0.014149474,
0.0780038759,
0.0014649879,
0.0102944151,
-0.0146873919,
-0.0127823669,
-0.0092171468,
0.0318646021,
-0.0402208641,
0.0055177761,
-0.0410804078,
-0.0008004347,
0.0108701624,
-0.064084895,
-0.0170488209,
0.0049739308,
2.95e-7,
0.0177998636,
0.0165641662,
0.0295438934,
0.0153768836,
0.0419026874,
-0.0033600049,
-0.0031277763,
0.0608695112,
-0.0048351269,
-0.0144802695,
0.002342345,
0.0359814465,
0.045165509,
-0.0040850937,
-0.1186512336,
-0.0378935374,
-0.0622830316,
-0.0142034423,
-0.031244332,
-0.0401371792,
0.0237961598,
0.1627691388,
0.0002851881,
0.00625451,
0.0248688776,
-0.0519430153,
0.0388713703,
-0.0581790358,
-0.005652247,
0.0004722116,
0.0335272923,
0.0265144501,
-0.0187426638,
-0.0514706187,
-0.006405422,
0.0125372354,
-0.0369295515,
0.0942441896,
0.0044592181,
-0.0487819351,
0.0066866395,
-0.0034797997,
-0.0012329622,
-0.0789005756,
0.0621632598,
-0.0707816705,
-0.0333581977,
-0.025630068,
0.0068109757,
-0.0087268539,
0.0263827927,
0.0110922288,
0.0044194334,
-0.0073686093,
-0.0010871317,
-0.0343774706,
-0.024324337,
-0.1240058169,
-0.0715455711,
-0.0032374053,
-0.0603049658,
-0.0114157982,
-0.0743425339,
-0.0457179025,
0.0562365726,
-0.0222118888,
-0.0164987165,
2.963775743e-34,
0.0390178263,
-0.0433019772,
0.0350340903,
0.0559791885,
-0.0065537458,
-0.0085323406,
0.0118709225,
0.0058746343,
0.044676058,
-0.0825695693,
-0.0209371578
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.08688v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.08688v1 | Automated Answer Validation using Text Similarity | 2024-01-13T07:13:08 | 2024-01-13T07:13:08 | Balaji Ganesan, Arjun Ravikumar, Lakshay Piplani, Rini Bhaumik, Dhivya Padmanaban, Shwetha Narasimhamurthy, Chetan Adhikary, Subhash Deshapogu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Automated answer validation can help improve learning outcomes by providing
appropriate feedback to learners, and by making question answering systems and
online learning solutions more widely available. There have been some works in
science question answering which show that information retrieval methods
outperform neural methods, especially in the multiple choice version of this
problem. We implement Siamese neural network models and produce a generalised
solution to this problem. We compare our supervised model with other text
similarity based solutions. | [
0.0336983241,
-0.001907649,
0.0002347019,
-0.0076299668,
-0.0341529511,
-0.0016468188,
0.0176276229,
0.0213705115,
0.0283476301,
-0.0578849576,
0.0160681419,
-0.0418026038,
-0.0138966599,
-0.0401165672,
0.0323761143,
-0.0445554852,
0.0276151989,
0.0063452506,
0.0156775862,
-0.0123890657,
-0.0096666571,
-0.0076533807,
-0.0104373954,
0.0188905988,
0.0070356042,
-0.0391242504,
0.0181794874,
-0.0222350582,
0.0140640233,
-0.035926614,
0.0475247428,
0.0814018771,
-0.0153517444,
0.0014051885,
0.0000015462,
-0.0370114706,
0.010254547,
0.0141217643,
-0.0034038927,
0.031624157,
-0.0248514097,
0.0817807764,
0.0671124011,
0.042094972,
-0.0451257154,
-0.0167280789,
0.0422366932,
0.006680917,
0.1028665304,
-0.0066871163,
0.0011276697,
0.0042507029,
0.0496172272,
0.0250115469,
0.0226471368,
0.0199386384,
0.0500670895,
0.0279994197,
0.0144846775,
0.0510772839,
0.020058414,
0.0568111464,
0.0140423644,
0.0061419071,
0.0174292885,
0.0045425845,
-0.0360184982,
0.0234019794,
0.023101747,
0.0779962838,
-0.0061061936,
-0.0393123925,
-0.0185307339,
-0.0056340811,
-0.0250054356,
0.0728052557,
-0.0360607691,
-0.0156970751,
-0.0231422279,
-0.0155765871,
0.0130087575,
0.0223507565,
-0.0212900769,
0.0343983993,
0.0067602359,
-0.0018382728,
0.0415567756,
-0.0630199388,
0.0161272045,
0.007519633,
-0.0044955267,
-0.0465055183,
0.0418493003,
0.0413857885,
0.0068978332,
-0.0131514426,
0.0247359741,
-0.0496557169,
0.032550551,
-0.0774680525,
0.0222184919,
0.0209128093,
-0.0102579072,
0.0237845182,
-0.0355302729,
0.0687908381,
-0.0005556147,
0.0729415715,
-0.0432912223,
-0.0194020998,
-0.0662111416,
-0.0317894816,
-0.0042967978,
0.0856063887,
0.0126583008,
-0.0071267509,
-0.0380554795,
-0.0245223101,
-0.016084874,
0.0231067128,
-0.0127471173,
0.050099805,
0.0353153422,
0.0280708931,
-0.0631261021,
0.0196685456,
-0.0645784661,
0.0103579275,
-0.002303279,
-0.0023007689,
0.0052455743,
0.0157791618,
0.0261402596,
-0.0057833972,
0.0550739765,
0.0242875032,
0.008037243,
-0.0047236886,
-0.0272445474,
-0.0331486501,
0.0104618128,
-0.0135553917,
-0.0166715216,
-0.0689143687,
0.0214274973,
0.0117103104,
-0.0285454579,
-0.0073168441,
-0.0017145909,
0.0718492046,
-0.0024012763,
0.0568992831,
0.0034655074,
-0.0082199341,
0.050691504,
0.009861513,
0.0239841715,
-0.0284728762,
-0.0030903693,
-0.0348925553,
0.0518096723,
-0.0051404354,
0.0300739724,
-0.0206785817,
0.0292862132,
-0.0296601728,
0.0210132878,
0.055911582,
0.0161348023,
0.0480682254,
-0.0801050663,
0.0828818753,
-0.0149993123,
-0.0460056588,
0.0214712396,
0.1137171537,
0.0285658538,
0.0255241524,
0.0072395829,
-0.0064577973,
0.0273681283,
0.042329479,
-0.0032942221,
0.0203743614,
-0.0332701504,
0.0098275635,
0.0208121259,
0.0081067914,
-0.0614775009,
-0.062627621,
-0.0357781053,
0.0228902977,
-0.008459866,
0.0349710472,
0.0438263863,
-0.0236494225,
-0.0071234945,
0.038862884,
0.0243926048,
-0.0462812372,
0.0228186417,
-0.0282155126,
0.0615257062,
0.0178593621,
0.0415704586,
-0.0536377691,
-0.0490053184,
-0.0146218911,
0.0105567062,
0.0120548336,
0.0429741256,
-0.0376546457,
-0.0389905013,
-0.0562135242,
-0.0227050371,
0.0202245694,
-0.0225737002,
-0.0155538796,
0.0407811999,
0.0481070168,
0.0054580178,
0.0110477097,
-0.0647011772,
0.042210795,
-0.0126349237,
-0.0587155707,
-0.0016278327,
0.005796893,
-0.0004538278,
0.0413009189,
-0.0100442795,
0.0386087112,
-0.0013963791,
-0.0345146693,
-0.0687607974,
-0.0638395399,
-0.0601383336,
-0.0097504128,
0.0660190582,
-0.0660209805,
0.0377435386,
0.0473327227,
0.0123375747,
-0.0403513797,
-0.0340665653,
-0.0281654913,
-0.082762599,
-0.0286109801,
-0.0024844732,
-0.0054828855,
-0.0336000435,
-0.0714308098,
0.0299274344,
0.0410713442,
0.0937338918,
0.0176050738,
0.0185909662,
0.0592274666,
-0.0203771275,
-0.0638712794,
-0.0032922663,
-0.009943895,
0.0285632908,
0.0238885712,
-0.0107543077,
-0.0223121271,
-0.0129763037,
-0.0164734945,
-0.0105490163,
0.0119347917,
0.0242684241,
-0.0028657147,
-0.0140800765,
0.0354712605,
0.0016354696,
-0.0857654288,
0.0047683693,
0.0218636487,
-0.0050482168,
0.0307998955,
-0.0139542837,
0.0063667912,
-0.0613926128,
-0.0550384559,
-0.0446337387,
0.0720606968,
0.0535516366,
0.0168710109,
-0.0572647974,
-0.0233637467,
-0.0431983285,
0.0264700539,
0.0630286485,
0.0038229062,
0.0206845086,
-0.0430009849,
-0.0365415625,
0.0362007692,
0.0556896254,
-0.0557035618,
0.0292062517,
0.0395410582,
-0.0862437934,
0.0110673644,
-0.0424583405,
0.0334141105,
0.0340378173,
-0.0239821561,
0.0414843895,
0.0249921624,
0.0195287745,
-0.0399428755,
-0.0197905488,
0.050323572,
-0.0170030333,
0.0319635905,
-0.0815898627,
-0.0127103515,
0.0177027471,
0.0098226182,
0.0257549547,
-0.002353092,
0.114809528,
-0.0307097174,
0.0184401367,
-0.0687279627,
-0.0391016752,
-0.034076605,
0.0181482453,
-0.0254529286,
0.000975988,
0.0645364001,
0.035351444,
-0.0530496724,
-0.0362688005,
0.0395395644,
-0.0309015997,
0.0371754766,
-0.013717358,
0.0198950525,
-0.0026286342,
-0.0108091291,
-0.0538577065,
-0.0449269675,
-0.0085229184,
0.0320738442,
-0.0348352119,
-0.005247199,
-0.0213284772,
0.0109681431,
0.0155809876,
0.0153328478,
-0.0253966171,
-0.0341140293,
-0.0142662721,
0.0975450352,
0.018997496,
0.0080646165,
0.0407754146,
-0.006098628,
0.0241443776,
0.0345717818,
0.0162954517,
0.0210703202,
-0.0231597833,
-0.0321141295,
0.0331739299,
-0.0803779066,
0.0356001928,
0.0043862769,
-0.002348505,
-0.0363130942,
-0.0176830925,
0.0768851042,
0.0461695455,
-0.0016617324,
-0.0357970819,
-0.0279430728,
-0.0310821794,
0.0200215857,
0.061911393,
-0.0137491161,
0.000947937,
-0.0483060144,
0.0189471561,
0.0169554036,
-0.0015067603,
0.028875282,
-0.05304249,
-0.0150779579,
-0.0029703958,
-0.0742424279,
-0.0445747152,
-0.0232083686,
-0.0142195392,
-0.0002093647,
-0.0266973116,
-0.0051296162,
-0.0183409117,
0.0022276735,
0.0266985334,
-0.006758179,
0.0403790921,
0.0432948656,
-0.0834129676,
0.0169157553,
0.003384819,
0.0005176475,
-0.02182566,
-0.0895436183,
-0.0023616706,
-0.0946935639,
-0.019401541,
-0.0017195756,
0.0412092842,
0.0026613506,
0.0109558264,
-0.0553484671,
0.0325673185,
-0.0248695444,
0.002559806,
0.0403779522,
0.0901962444,
-0.0085898833,
-0.0352824442,
-0.0676370934,
0.0415019318,
-0.02110539,
0.0607979707,
0.0264577642,
-0.0413696989,
-0.0272660311,
-0.0299062449,
0.0201291591,
-0.0163524691,
-0.0308540706,
-0.0031540592,
0.0104339914,
0.0233722646,
-0.0637146831,
0.0031487178,
0.0151328165,
0.0228815228,
-0.0152266007,
-0.0172760487,
0.0495085493,
0.0107001793,
0.0120393587,
0.014096234,
-0.015136349,
0.00995248,
-0.032150954,
0.0313685797,
0.0494899042,
0.0048865117,
-0.0473554954,
-0.0598464906,
0.0095373094,
-0.0272245687,
-0.0692416579,
0.0404160023,
0.0071805823,
-0.0338613875,
-0.010714937,
-0.0508340523,
0.0315283798,
-0.0093719559,
0.0368891023,
-0.0215593167,
-0.029650731,
-0.0284618307,
-0.0047781984,
-0.028893711,
-0.0081413351,
0.024578413,
-0.002585358,
0.0228080284,
0.0072944267,
-0.047557164,
0.030735258,
0.0563565195,
-0.0076721469,
0.051952444,
-0.0116785225,
-0.0289084204,
0.0097916937,
0.0487623364,
0.0143380808,
0.0049037109,
0.0006652495,
-0.0084193386,
-0.0256711692,
-0.0203375984,
-0.0552919619,
-0.0185593404,
0.036559321,
0.0030493555,
-0.0035888434,
0.0311202426,
0.0407348648,
-0.0217178445,
-0.0219852496,
-0.0512030907,
-0.0354440734,
-0.0116846915,
0.0351571925,
-0.0087468559,
0.0334095545,
0.046287559,
0.0155154802,
0.0098124929,
-0.015793236,
-0.0711533278,
-0.0722747147,
-0.0467024036,
-0.0008991145,
0.0236680247,
0.0283433162,
-0.0349250585,
0.0083827544,
-0.0253067892,
-0.0176977459,
-0.0009056891,
0.0046294876,
0.0366779938,
0.0552599803,
0.030483637,
0.022898443,
-0.0328609236,
0.0508784205,
-0.0090964809,
0.0079851812,
0.0119537534,
-0.0754117146,
-0.0088271368,
0.0078958217,
-0.0707999542,
0.0585732758,
-0.0212081596,
-0.017979132,
-0.0112085501,
-0.0073449383,
0.0302215852,
0.0679384843,
0.0126187932,
0.0152955977,
0.0452652127,
0.0283607859,
0.0235143788,
-0.0241768397,
0.0121301357,
0.0239722002,
-0.0657564625,
-0.0376083069,
-0.0512885042,
-5.222981846e-33,
-0.0139483893,
-0.0413359925,
0.0327356681,
0.0443276912,
0.019408755,
-0.0116343722,
-0.0296766777,
-0.0169469528,
-0.0673905835,
-0.0009938079,
0.0257238559,
0.0008900046,
-0.0246071126,
0.026358271,
0.045101963,
-0.0374806598,
0.0005332479,
0.0047745444,
0.0002808984,
0.0137728686,
0.0104170172,
-0.0034718383,
0.0186360758,
-0.0423111357,
0.0037455431,
-0.0218749475,
0.0344988666,
0.0170782357,
-0.0637036413,
0.0534459092,
-0.0191606097,
0.036628142,
0.0358636603,
-0.0203950033,
0.0257774349,
0.0617215522,
-0.0764309019,
-0.0922306105,
-0.0381253697,
-0.0594854429,
-0.0338860042,
-0.0020153911,
0.0490800962,
0.0021909471,
-0.0192667916,
-0.0195438769,
0.0756901726,
0.0120315887,
-0.0022590344,
-0.0196255408,
-0.0243009161,
0.0137367491,
-0.0117451884,
0.0075341901,
-0.0291446839,
0.1094847992,
-0.0083253458,
0.0510358922,
-0.0151511915,
0.0491206422,
0.0110125542,
0.0268244315,
0.0065232469,
-0.0103566991,
-0.0094685582,
0.0465447269,
0.0464729816,
-0.0648868084,
-0.0109396707,
-0.0717882439,
0.0037715249,
-0.0043296255,
0.1552125514,
0.0225899611,
0.0267464109,
0.0011352753,
-0.0870394781,
0.051333122,
-0.0006483941,
0.0250111595,
0.0030544363,
-0.0342526399,
-0.0222253874,
-0.0146677475,
-0.0657690838,
0.0115264906,
-0.0695902482,
-0.0244981516,
0.0540431179,
-0.031050235,
-0.0148667665,
0.0151748247,
-0.0044026463,
-0.0459929593,
-0.0109101692,
0.0234619565,
0.0329210274,
0.0101291686,
-0.0068489108,
-0.0036169756,
-0.0365548953,
0.0207857098,
-0.0302993208,
-0.0055509363,
-0.0078134164,
0.0183312912,
-0.0039230757,
-0.0159341693,
-0.0453420952,
-0.0201380979,
0.0130014513,
-0.0509588122,
0.0109046828,
-0.0369858593,
-0.0132600302,
0.0374767631,
0.0295237675,
0.0530668683,
-0.0109633468,
0.0059811254,
-0.0101086609,
-0.0515831895,
0.0360513516,
0.0070639295,
0.0093753608,
0.0387582593,
-0.0588661097,
0.036129687,
-0.0416433401,
-0.0267684665,
0.0167537406,
0.0137455724,
2.16e-7,
0.0352924317,
0.0177369863,
0.0272385273,
0.0046541961,
-0.0174500309,
0.0221007057,
0.0377585031,
-0.0228509437,
0.0091125323,
0.017720269,
-0.0086814426,
-0.0044496353,
0.0039447402,
0.0547830537,
-0.0271713827,
-0.0414764248,
-0.0722922087,
-0.030712368,
-0.0310852882,
-0.0159508027,
0.0887077451,
0.007571836,
0.0089167478,
-0.0140966242,
-0.0383723453,
-0.048729822,
0.0310288277,
0.0154547794,
0.0391135775,
0.0139406808,
0.0459572934,
-0.0186648257,
0.0556401238,
0.042443566,
-0.0109268948,
-0.0104132965,
0.0547858179,
-0.0196313728,
0.0125478609,
-0.0289162453,
-0.0078496877,
-0.0099594546,
0.0109975664,
-0.0614627227,
0.0326105803,
-0.0373159721,
0.0318535306,
-0.0503266044,
-0.0219390001,
-0.0344500951,
0.0495748706,
0.000205468,
0.0076399031,
0.0050355392,
0.0097750742,
0.0085823396,
0.0205325447,
-0.0339385979,
-0.0032840823,
0.0376068465,
-0.0175878499,
-0.0080722962,
-0.0453997478,
-0.0141551103,
0.0296901744,
-0.0218182541,
-0.0208603889,
1.489019128e-34,
-0.0141965821,
0.0132122021,
0.0341258869,
0.0224356111,
-0.0066031935,
0.0386469737,
-0.0218666568,
-0.010944291,
0.0292262323,
-0.0688296333,
-0.0067457268
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06980v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06980v1 | Joint Unsupervised and Supervised Training for Automatic Speech Recognition via Bilevel Optimization | 2024-01-13T05:01:47 | 2024-01-13T05:01:47 | A F M Saif, Xiaodong Cui, Han Shen, Songtao Lu, Brian Kingsbury, Tianyi Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, stat.ML | In this paper, we present a novel bilevel optimization-based training
approach to training acoustic models for automatic speech recognition (ASR)
tasks that we term {bi-level joint unsupervised and supervised training
(BL-JUST)}. {BL-JUST employs a lower and upper level optimization with an
unsupervised loss and a supervised loss respectively, leveraging recent
advances in penalty-based bilevel optimization to solve this challenging ASR
problem with affordable complexity and rigorous convergence guarantees.} To
evaluate BL-JUST, extensive experiments on the LibriSpeech and TED-LIUM v2
datasets have been conducted. BL-JUST achieves superior performance over the
commonly used pre-training followed by fine-tuning strategy. | [
-0.0469284654,
0.0713516399,
0.0234162509,
0.0544974431,
-0.010715073,
0.0094315242,
0.0400417149,
0.0153282313,
0.0701216683,
0.0043297973,
-0.0659334883,
0.0126633896,
-0.0059411456,
-0.007266962,
0.0292406101,
-0.0152233168,
0.0320726857,
-0.0770991594,
-0.0277417768,
-0.0578156635,
0.01681423,
-0.0218375754,
-0.0585481673,
-0.0054471777,
-0.0217081606,
-0.0111633055,
0.0277123246,
0.0470711403,
0.0430784412,
-0.0238715634,
0.0339929163,
0.0088613769,
0.028262401,
0.0250311308,
0.0000019997,
-0.0224684514,
-0.0264155623,
0.0050162585,
-0.067269735,
-0.013900442,
-0.0106875878,
-0.0039505367,
0.0092040068,
0.0396426991,
-0.0235462897,
-0.0286929253,
0.0273268968,
-0.0057801469,
0.0316405036,
0.0580603667,
0.0201773811,
-0.0895259455,
0.0264981352,
0.0019777345,
-0.0749904737,
-0.004320418,
-0.0112800598,
0.0026288633,
-0.101229243,
-0.0317248441,
0.0007719228,
0.0406319536,
-0.0096593555,
0.0340913832,
0.0602493361,
0.0211957488,
-0.0567612797,
-0.0061650015,
-0.023555031,
0.0226836856,
-0.0036657185,
-0.0203511417,
-0.001716233,
0.0138110677,
-0.0726758912,
-0.0390340947,
0.0119442092,
-0.0174193587,
-0.0250661131,
-0.0093105379,
0.0063640894,
-0.0228267368,
0.0067244205,
-0.04283062,
0.0196814816,
0.0273402482,
-0.0256118998,
-0.0364493802,
0.0422479399,
-0.0631296933,
-0.0452431515,
0.0055950205,
0.0507888682,
0.0287318416,
-0.0427129157,
-0.018073041,
0.0069201249,
-0.0431473032,
-0.030545909,
-0.0161147323,
0.0561245009,
0.0337573737,
-0.0417426266,
0.0132002961,
0.0039973413,
0.0378176458,
0.0178234484,
-0.0085059945,
0.0131836776,
0.0687947348,
-0.0146522736,
0.0110187521,
-0.0642398596,
0.0259813312,
-0.0507113971,
0.0052507911,
-0.0137693584,
-0.0367945135,
-0.0310514178,
0.0028767867,
0.0691851005,
-0.0084129497,
-0.0558097176,
0.000663318,
0.0056529506,
-0.0036822264,
0.0146377608,
0.0173334088,
-0.0323124081,
0.0003449032,
-0.0227846205,
0.0270215254,
0.0331210271,
-0.0220788792,
0.0237238202,
0.1042206511,
-0.0280664116,
-0.0008983302,
-0.0625299886,
0.0093576694,
0.0078579923,
-0.0488211513,
-0.0257671028,
-0.0218513198,
0.0393427275,
-0.0304559357,
0.0324888527,
-0.0265043918,
-0.0046211453,
-0.0451638177,
0.0445511341,
0.1042412892,
-0.0281977225,
-0.0060394583,
0.0410699174,
-0.0269980915,
-0.0159189645,
0.0619785339,
0.0032216546,
-0.0053796768,
-0.019421244,
-0.0169967208,
-0.0195474159,
0.0355937369,
0.0283984914,
0.0055302866,
-0.0105740987,
-0.0013640049,
-0.0088380417,
0.0512036309,
0.0545254201,
0.0544553287,
-0.0246160217,
-0.0031876615,
0.0618487448,
0.013236952,
0.0400924645,
0.0517405905,
0.0290918946,
-0.0250054989,
0.0084170643,
0.0214615725,
0.0096115526,
-0.0084662428,
-0.051088959,
-0.0006205736,
0.0162558369,
0.0130621595,
-0.0460999049,
-0.0512352139,
0.0014947787,
0.0054849172,
-0.0241942406,
0.0374060199,
0.0149448272,
-0.0175249223,
-0.0562674552,
0.032896854,
0.0053421692,
-0.0096037611,
0.0298909154,
-0.0260518398,
0.0187479481,
0.0153736407,
0.011514063,
-0.071829699,
0.0101755373,
-0.028330734,
-0.0288960151,
-0.0019867101,
-0.0268744677,
-0.0023071498,
0.075466074,
-0.0543318354,
0.0019614459,
0.0336594544,
-0.0332643762,
0.070157595,
-0.0483023264,
0.0126448125,
-0.0162017848,
-0.0096876342,
-0.0042263134,
-0.0005410553,
-0.0381126776,
-0.0638914034,
0.0092002908,
0.0522961095,
0.0534300841,
0.0152013255,
-0.0359341912,
-0.0348048545,
0.0071330178,
-0.0431257337,
0.0071999421,
-0.0362502784,
-0.0248964727,
-0.0768300146,
0.0673431307,
-0.0721396059,
0.0103135509,
0.0652110875,
0.0339654423,
-0.0539400913,
0.0076857959,
-0.0267468952,
0.0214765742,
-0.0685008839,
0.043053057,
0.0274939947,
-0.0138496207,
-0.0186856259,
0.0257603899,
-0.0142218936,
0.0152701549,
-0.0270871799,
-0.0411656387,
-0.0082870927,
-0.0577173494,
-0.020374978,
0.0039519453,
0.005305843,
0.0490937568,
0.0204855893,
0.0436445959,
0.009039904,
0.0279368218,
-0.1364566386,
-0.0081972014,
-0.0600013472,
0.0192904342,
-0.0255169794,
0.0171679631,
-0.0028435062,
0.0067918613,
-0.0292020291,
-0.0211528726,
-0.0530916266,
-0.0028598327,
-0.0171602238,
0.0047173169,
0.0069273291,
-0.0201525968,
-0.0242525674,
0.0132526327,
-0.0227491986,
-0.0507321022,
0.0036277086,
-0.0277553014,
0.0380118564,
0.0126114534,
0.0362012051,
-0.0275700819,
-0.0017585282,
-0.0320639648,
0.0240422282,
0.0713272616,
0.0764963999,
0.0246570837,
0.0093214586,
0.0071265716,
0.0218443945,
-0.0439407565,
0.0437781364,
-0.004487766,
-0.0141725289,
-0.0005042285,
0.0454990789,
0.0326833986,
0.0270470157,
0.0024570127,
0.0454228073,
-0.0136825964,
0.0097498819,
0.0219922289,
-0.0556964353,
-0.0515556112,
-0.0027784533,
-0.0410261191,
-0.0040084561,
-0.0005748962,
-0.0122749079,
0.0331148244,
-0.0748046488,
0.0033062696,
-0.0448569804,
-0.0645814613,
-0.0308458451,
-0.0078495722,
0.0173903536,
0.0075184265,
-0.065885216,
-0.023725424,
-0.0227392148,
-0.0077805952,
0.0803893954,
-0.0531398244,
0.0276162513,
0.039277263,
0.0154771097,
-0.0302606001,
-0.0242784042,
0.0166032426,
0.0332824215,
-0.011989831,
-0.0043620956,
0.0730306655,
0.0027666343,
0.0100479126,
0.0511748977,
0.0181818847,
0.0651329756,
-0.0161436703,
-0.0035073995,
-0.0530683808,
0.0650811717,
0.0003698064,
0.0128602693,
0.0034030129,
-0.0105907153,
0.0246443208,
-0.0481003709,
0.0634553432,
0.0100010643,
-0.0293730609,
0.0003644083,
0.0393863395,
-0.0035880783,
0.0186763275,
-0.0423430242,
0.0750787482,
0.0017581525,
0.0019420857,
0.0234369822,
-0.0255155545,
-0.0501017161,
-0.0173283499,
0.0106059685,
0.0474835373,
0.0136739276,
-0.0128833717,
-0.0147197451,
-0.0351233371,
0.0229775757,
0.0646604225,
0.010308221,
-0.001300442,
-0.0176510084,
-0.0816512108,
0.0051458306,
0.0139946891,
-0.0173810925,
-0.0470841303,
-0.047099933,
-0.0163892284,
-0.0892206207,
0.0612337478,
0.0058785109,
-0.0236437768,
-0.0264410563,
0.059074305,
-0.0965907872,
-0.034884844,
-0.0373123959,
-0.0476089232,
0.0112710604,
-0.0216100775,
0.0091772443,
-0.0144193005,
-0.0275914334,
0.0539111495,
0.0004937349,
0.0096430518,
-0.0302122086,
-0.006170576,
-0.0144822598,
-0.0001043302,
0.0171182137,
0.0460110307,
-0.0019462921,
0.0144178411,
0.07020659,
0.0739358962,
-0.0063000899,
0.0248167384,
0.0127270147,
0.0242041759,
0.0456980206,
0.0445744246,
-0.007705512,
-0.0143135954,
0.0118726371,
0.0483025052,
0.0587198399,
-0.0112779764,
0.0293633454,
0.0057580853,
-0.0207805838,
-0.0060511162,
0.0165256634,
0.0299666021,
-0.0109364735,
0.0716653317,
-0.0090211425,
0.014802224,
-0.0138810035,
0.0359608606,
-0.0275953431,
0.011771488,
-0.0377470292,
0.0119688325,
-0.0277468394,
-0.025592383,
0.0034471299,
-0.0480060838,
-0.013877837,
0.0135217672,
-0.0544965789,
-0.0510929264,
-0.0376262888,
0.0325012095,
0.0050972705,
0.0785089955,
0.0156908408,
-0.0596954487,
0.0736245215,
0.0665813237,
-0.0281883106,
0.0016021582,
0.050400842,
-0.0224070288,
-0.0315106474,
0.0052998406,
-0.0103172548,
0.0108276606,
0.0032606551,
0.0426808186,
-0.0487631075,
0.0231133886,
0.0111195194,
0.0393551104,
0.0636639521,
-0.0268348157,
-0.0179591011,
-0.0495534725,
0.0596192181,
0.0569250099,
0.0481669828,
-0.0243110862,
0.0048815347,
-0.0079911929,
0.0187165216,
-0.0391427688,
0.0297715329,
0.0351033807,
-0.0484073684,
-0.0027965845,
0.0894790217,
0.0325317718,
0.0205123965,
0.0306186005,
0.0240876116,
-0.0329157412,
0.044853773,
0.0355724767,
0.006175708,
0.0062604919,
0.014815975,
0.0192099027,
0.0533149913,
0.007700427,
-0.0220073089,
0.0045303172,
-0.0585611016,
-0.0412620753,
-0.0308629647,
0.0592591949,
-0.0259010158,
-0.0003444289,
0.0040580542,
-0.0085239708,
-0.027371252,
0.0043894779,
-0.0178562533,
0.0499271266,
0.0120360013,
-0.0132258143,
-0.001882922,
0.0363089405,
0.0399639383,
-0.0080073234,
0.044044558,
-0.036695838,
0.0242723729,
-0.0871024579,
-0.0273186453,
0.0394312851,
0.0337707214,
0.0197392777,
-0.0070096413,
0.0535037145,
-0.0292543899,
0.011583006,
0.0067259679,
0.0267702863,
-0.0211405139,
0.0588453859,
-0.0036808013,
-0.0263928827,
0.0067158728,
0.0036248507,
-0.0329405405,
0.0052275755,
0.0140975174,
0.0300729722,
-6.325019188e-33,
-0.0168467816,
0.0415995978,
0.0002187583,
0.0364178009,
-0.0097237974,
0.0143721346,
0.0119215958,
0.0146016208,
0.0085695395,
-0.032414142,
-0.0135988817,
-0.0218378194,
0.0205020923,
-0.0089798924,
-0.032377325,
-0.0194483623,
0.0746591836,
-0.0147785656,
-0.0174521152,
0.0001381187,
0.0142204361,
0.0571204238,
-0.0056486316,
-0.0566816628,
-0.0711341947,
-0.0010332812,
-0.002496178,
0.021107886,
0.0295452122,
0.0110132163,
-0.022021113,
0.0217125807,
-0.0244264361,
-0.0217676666,
0.0424384922,
-0.034068469,
-0.0759665668,
0.0077082487,
-0.0095095094,
0.0362655148,
-0.0385712571,
-0.021548057,
0.0010413992,
0.0524547733,
-0.0832486674,
-0.0571590513,
0.0208581984,
0.0113292895,
-0.0402648896,
-0.132553041,
-0.0128015326,
0.0460519306,
-0.017942721,
0.0055009807,
0.073728554,
0.0230510253,
-0.0288134236,
-0.0517378226,
-0.0445970036,
-0.0023210496,
0.017374048,
0.0157935861,
0.0294589531,
0.0347978361,
0.0081118494,
0.0289519522,
0.0832271278,
-0.0517112911,
0.0216766819,
-0.0328155942,
0.0104509182,
0.0100541431,
0.0063870908,
-0.029307656,
0.0160880517,
-0.0466137677,
-0.0382686481,
-0.0096168425,
0.0225592609,
-0.0139567237,
-0.0007709144,
0.0632451624,
0.0065284944,
0.0162824336,
-0.059079811,
-0.0835934579,
-0.0294984896,
0.0030659353,
0.001208254,
0.0189519804,
-0.0020087482,
-0.0373446606,
0.0491590016,
-0.0193252414,
0.0313378759,
-0.0024151606,
0.0507257544,
-0.0293205939,
0.0080723828,
0.0346893594,
-0.0378918611,
-0.061202582,
-0.0252455976,
0.0534917079,
0.0273549594,
-0.0270117242,
0.0478728041,
0.0097903935,
-0.052097287,
-0.0096708452,
0.0033628838,
0.0585464761,
0.0192005206,
0.0418468304,
0.0784807056,
-0.0360990092,
0.0371457823,
0.0678085685,
0.0095166732,
0.0289954115,
-0.0360375009,
-0.0020609745,
-0.0268517472,
0.0377443731,
0.0124944309,
0.0094967745,
0.0196171962,
-0.0607972369,
-0.0376051776,
-0.0392858088,
-0.00545609,
-0.0043439525,
2.724e-7,
-0.0640449524,
0.0150744021,
-0.0028724875,
-0.0188875385,
0.0131195663,
-0.0074333423,
0.0118750669,
0.0005503137,
-0.0542661063,
-0.0322334617,
0.0226594545,
0.0007799041,
0.0617769659,
0.0038954397,
-0.0346032977,
-0.0389713421,
-0.0559625141,
0.0515697412,
-0.0257932562,
-0.0169161744,
0.028124528,
0.0395897105,
-0.0581174269,
-0.0447104238,
-0.0109094838,
0.0196923707,
0.0063941223,
-0.0052543394,
-0.0036993069,
0.0012227051,
0.0062382016,
0.0050471821,
-0.0003158103,
0.0347808599,
-0.0034898641,
0.0428481288,
0.0306361523,
0.0167007428,
0.0021535689,
-0.0574322455,
0.0518531017,
0.0879762843,
-0.0056435703,
0.0135673359,
0.0623517334,
0.0348768681,
0.0183101222,
-0.0319516696,
-0.0677878484,
-0.0043105339,
0.0451404266,
-0.0456978194,
0.0085439403,
0.0288355462,
-0.0013173349,
0.0047793086,
-0.0259619039,
-0.0681000724,
0.0545145236,
0.0945530459,
-0.045168519,
-0.029456228,
-0.0376646183,
0.0677904859,
0.0182487909,
0.0182968378,
-0.0098940535,
1.822449937e-34,
0.0471640266,
-0.0407308117,
0.0288122408,
-0.0577892065,
-0.002838131,
-0.0663292557,
0.0015279124,
-0.0035617487,
0.0265176315,
-0.0328879729,
-0.0164801944
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06961v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06961v2 | CHAMP: A Competition-level Dataset for Fine-Grained Analyses of LLMs' Mathematical Reasoning Capabilities | 2024-01-13T03:18:16 | 2024-06-09T01:47:26 | Yujun Mao, Yoon Kim, Yilun Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Recent large language models (LLMs) have shown indications of mathematical
reasoning ability on challenging competition-level problems, especially with
self-generated verbalizations of intermediate reasoning steps (i.e.,
chain-of-thought prompting). However, current evaluations mainly focus on the
end-to-end final answer correctness, and it is unclear whether LLMs can make
use of helpful side information such as problem-specific hints. In this paper,
we propose a challenging benchmark dataset for enabling such analyses. The
Concept and Hint-Annotated Math Problems (CHAMP) consists of high school math
competition problems, annotated with concepts, or general math facts, and
hints, or problem-specific tricks. These annotations allow us to explore the
effects of additional information, such as relevant hints, misleading concepts,
or related problems. This benchmark is difficult, with the best model only
scoring 58.1% in standard settings. With concepts and hints, performance
sometimes improves, indicating that some models can make use of such side
information. Furthermore, we annotate model-generated solutions for their
correctness. Using this corpus, we find that models often arrive at the correct
final answer through wrong reasoning steps. In addition, we test whether models
are able to verify these solutions, and find that most models struggle. | [
-0.0195627287,
0.0645438135,
0.0017850642,
0.0765338466,
-0.0504598022,
0.0289238319,
0.0054150182,
-0.0129162148,
-0.0311224535,
-0.0397269055,
-0.0079278545,
-0.005676866,
-0.0084464382,
-0.0107025439,
0.0406332389,
-0.0224464275,
0.00723982,
-0.0810999498,
0.0202943012,
-0.0217906572,
-0.0467245318,
-0.0292392932,
-0.0184312183,
0.0069831633,
-0.0163455997,
-0.0670185685,
0.0119627919,
-0.0507052802,
-0.0173617285,
-0.0525008664,
-0.0112078357,
0.074542366,
0.0165434238,
0.034359172,
0.0000021308,
-0.070907101,
0.0210843105,
-0.0108558703,
-0.0824536607,
0.0324970298,
-0.0342313461,
0.016861368,
0.0214587469,
0.0048076636,
-0.0622284375,
0.0319992565,
0.0138387177,
0.012235079,
0.0771778449,
0.0467532389,
0.0201404989,
-0.0188718718,
0.0240943879,
-0.018294625,
0.0691093504,
-0.0698466152,
0.0290335417,
0.0358446613,
0.0150764789,
0.0110176317,
-0.0349715389,
0.044022277,
0.0433971435,
0.0013240459,
-0.0418241769,
-0.0076348553,
-0.0264777467,
0.0260296408,
0.0175207816,
0.0607239306,
0.0089499122,
-0.0160063542,
-0.028555626,
-0.020691229,
0.0063188807,
0.0249835346,
-0.0693433806,
0.042686794,
-0.0078200083,
-0.0099521661,
0.0270484798,
0.0040589911,
0.0206365548,
0.0088099809,
-0.0182750933,
0.1016328409,
-0.003176257,
-0.0447741896,
0.0010546204,
0.0113379611,
-0.0582062751,
-0.0641267002,
0.0085788863,
0.0408552028,
0.0360855982,
0.0180141181,
-0.010364674,
-0.0453457125,
-0.0055660624,
-0.0267442893,
0.0544324629,
0.0512945428,
-0.0074680429,
0.0476893,
-0.0186047759,
0.0321698524,
-0.0127953123,
0.0417797901,
-0.0221310332,
0.0127386563,
-0.0058075599,
-0.0100762863,
-0.0078095929,
0.0433434136,
0.021998927,
0.0341456719,
-0.0486783534,
0.0003089112,
-0.0443707258,
0.0479342043,
0.0067820637,
-0.0174785964,
0.0279109366,
-0.0355982557,
-0.0639629066,
-0.0058256965,
-0.0582276434,
0.0200339258,
0.0230307803,
-0.0490778573,
-0.0326173194,
0.0091898991,
-0.027194256,
-0.0416122042,
0.041843161,
0.062782988,
0.0094401976,
-0.0083854012,
-0.020536121,
-0.0291929767,
0.0217680372,
-0.0912914351,
0.0102216201,
-0.0958904028,
0.0633617043,
0.0342774019,
-0.0279895626,
-0.029258538,
0.0100173187,
0.0229910593,
0.0312877409,
0.0496395081,
0.0139043853,
-0.0005147313,
0.0303868707,
0.0076588639,
-0.0665030777,
0.0463017486,
0.056985639,
-0.0086954888,
0.0286123138,
-0.0188659448,
0.00666042,
0.053726472,
0.0421986692,
-0.0076851444,
0.0154294604,
0.0525348745,
0.0187541768,
0.0660397634,
-0.0112180403,
0.038590122,
-0.0349036008,
-0.0290725883,
0.0384969041,
0.0813312382,
-0.0171039831,
-0.0193523988,
0.0210599508,
-0.0238941088,
0.0728615075,
0.0083133681,
-0.0753315464,
0.0188091956,
-0.036108885,
0.0070914342,
0.0171735454,
0.0009030274,
-0.0153325479,
-0.0815586224,
-0.0241048653,
0.0177881755,
-0.030833872,
0.040206857,
0.0795955658,
-0.0113718836,
0.0009012357,
0.0486931168,
-0.0154094007,
-0.0226005986,
-0.0042349831,
-0.0528959967,
0.0543645807,
-0.0238359831,
0.0521237291,
-0.0311373677,
-0.0312194172,
-0.0034231944,
0.0404577293,
0.0181141179,
0.0353972651,
-0.0033491566,
-0.0180083998,
-0.0077580498,
0.0171335377,
-0.0393302813,
0.0220769905,
-0.0299802367,
0.0174091496,
-0.0116571011,
0.0021805135,
-0.0328387693,
0.0244076606,
0.0234899204,
-0.0527172945,
-0.0425753184,
-0.0154537298,
-0.0137642641,
-0.0013952493,
-0.0127180265,
0.0152505189,
0.0401205234,
0.0088475412,
-0.0276884772,
0.0066224863,
-0.0290890578,
-0.0536713488,
-0.0451478139,
0.0562751256,
-0.0407553129,
-0.0510219149,
0.021093078,
-0.0478602573,
-0.0159712303,
0.0231289566,
-0.0276920777,
0.0070431894,
-0.0016178832,
0.0271160863,
0.0180517212,
-0.0325213857,
-0.0032286095,
0.0770457983,
0.0055530425,
0.0546798557,
0.0230448674,
-0.0104540717,
0.0151454117,
-0.0219276696,
-0.0108400444,
-0.0225248132,
-0.0063315895,
0.0124230189,
-0.0230402444,
-0.003400675,
-0.0491841473,
-0.0184587874,
-0.034025874,
0.0097974176,
0.0118142404,
0.0749933198,
0.0108442958,
-0.0618811473,
-0.0111812577,
-0.0055865082,
-0.0435804985,
-0.0235143006,
-0.0051326044,
0.0107360967,
0.0489202328,
0.0213736407,
0.0107504763,
-0.0402202904,
-0.0285927057,
-0.0579213239,
0.0461770631,
0.0199731253,
0.0285115056,
-0.0125000915,
0.0336984843,
-0.0442733392,
0.011330341,
-0.0181847066,
0.0236217715,
0.0359448977,
-0.0098475311,
0.0353911296,
0.0967341885,
-0.0101212068,
0.0120740924,
0.04459868,
-0.0429619029,
-0.0527255498,
0.0130217951,
-0.0020389871,
0.0128741972,
-0.0354643576,
-0.0280902945,
-0.0232489537,
0.0797877833,
-0.0082240039,
-0.0175469853,
-0.0149433799,
0.0680053458,
-0.0232436955,
-0.006464289,
-0.0727808326,
0.0166583452,
-0.0020195032,
0.0616827197,
-0.0119117359,
-0.0280052274,
0.0656293407,
-0.0257473215,
-0.0059356377,
0.0003038081,
0.0239760689,
-0.0562131852,
0.0566549934,
0.0049368436,
-0.0414130315,
-0.0253933836,
0.0086859809,
-0.0552635305,
-0.0041606082,
0.0532840341,
-0.0536096171,
0.0585342199,
-0.0458664969,
-0.0122592924,
-0.0218180642,
-0.053363312,
-0.0397920236,
0.0114860591,
-0.0371852107,
0.0040546926,
0.0008764234,
-0.03350804,
-0.0054581761,
-0.0238431953,
0.0181375891,
0.0068919477,
-0.0390108973,
-0.0375038683,
-0.000835072,
0.017340621,
0.0276718587,
0.0566470586,
0.0530578941,
-0.0676577315,
0.0123514123,
0.0490460955,
0.0515159816,
0.0100200698,
0.0020786175,
0.0122774644,
0.0186971538,
-0.0331836902,
-0.0226615611,
0.0403505974,
0.0478765666,
-0.0966014192,
0.0049642446,
0.0993320495,
0.0336109437,
0.0161596537,
0.0030101172,
-0.0640477613,
0.0250831265,
0.0188114345,
0.0199775323,
-0.100679256,
-0.0353057273,
0.016972566,
0.0024060181,
0.0019686527,
-0.0428945385,
-0.0104463371,
-0.1192957014,
0.0204072017,
0.0178385656,
-0.0076418621,
0.0221224204,
-0.0137867257,
-0.0002801452,
-0.0057155644,
-0.0104638282,
0.0156623535,
0.005376243,
0.0170805324,
0.0179373827,
-0.0510778911,
-0.0382489376,
0.0524005853,
-0.0146740908,
0.0187926292,
-0.0193136465,
-0.007863339,
-0.0183319114,
-0.074063912,
0.0497463495,
-0.0014085708,
-0.03086357,
0.0041388045,
0.0265351012,
-0.0374698304,
-0.0092749558,
-0.0213696212,
0.0333665647,
-0.0484028086,
-0.0300096422,
0.0552764311,
0.1163785905,
0.0005039625,
-0.0063241781,
-0.0195037872,
0.0001449742,
-0.0433484614,
0.0842218176,
0.0425758958,
-0.0348481536,
-0.0264073387,
-0.0449374616,
-0.0358050279,
-0.026268078,
-0.028363023,
0.0160587355,
0.0615708716,
0.0268858057,
-0.0248363968,
-0.0476516224,
0.0796431825,
0.0299434867,
-0.0182823092,
0.0032690829,
-0.0114649814,
0.0023393906,
-0.0199143365,
0.0583714545,
-0.0415542983,
0.0242878217,
-0.0542512089,
0.0255849008,
-0.0091206571,
-0.0246409103,
-0.0388159044,
0.032338284,
-0.1423431188,
-0.0396612994,
-0.0116343983,
0.045969855,
0.0205335822,
0.0032253636,
0.0256192852,
-0.0330807008,
-0.0100328261,
0.0025789868,
-0.0255825054,
0.0156717673,
0.0327887312,
0.0059395283,
0.0089891916,
0.0063585229,
-0.0045483992,
-0.000157044,
0.019064147,
0.0421727225,
-0.0388737246,
-0.0066510602,
0.0320780277,
0.027863184,
0.0040347269,
0.0151522579,
0.0135982651,
-0.0006037881,
0.0379102267,
-0.0321189687,
-0.020881217,
-0.02814316,
-0.0175689496,
-0.0105680823,
-0.0387532711,
0.0137009835,
-0.0420600511,
0.0073095998,
0.0453046635,
-0.0043721921,
0.0533593111,
0.0117834751,
0.0314002894,
0.0236434769,
-0.0158336423,
0.0129880589,
-0.0054515698,
-0.0203952268,
0.0698735118,
0.0137422374,
0.057141915,
0.0141686322,
0.0239562243,
0.0301759187,
-0.0055874772,
-0.0298635121,
-0.0708727166,
-0.0033592822,
0.028835522,
0.0367651321,
0.0153521737,
-0.0115236063,
-0.0432177074,
0.0047262218,
-0.0163398366,
0.0131102931,
-0.0007241496,
-0.0238665361,
0.0426814742,
0.0420221165,
0.0259137042,
-0.0487584807,
0.0403602533,
-0.0065744449,
0.0267222971,
0.0095818732,
0.0302485023,
-0.0158235133,
-0.0253113881,
-0.0033569895,
0.0070924093,
0.0197616611,
-0.0006092917,
-0.0962714776,
-0.095920369,
0.0046953023,
0.0395694785,
-0.0207343996,
0.0039214469,
0.0196246989,
0.0630257428,
-0.0229632538,
-0.0239586793,
0.0160644036,
0.0283512268,
-0.0122464066,
-0.0243833233,
-0.025839014,
-5.816824327e-33,
-0.0363091715,
-0.0546910726,
0.0546503849,
0.02925919,
0.0407349318,
-0.0164402965,
-0.0293831583,
0.0407844074,
-0.0285988245,
0.0070545124,
-0.013611366,
0.0138217779,
-0.0005761121,
0.0195605475,
0.0073926011,
-0.0375603586,
-0.0218367931,
-0.0232780445,
-0.0481487773,
-0.0243531428,
0.0132851871,
-0.0275899041,
0.0648344979,
-0.0442002118,
0.0441083945,
-0.0311398655,
0.0024180608,
0.0352077894,
-0.0661038086,
0.0594198108,
-0.0013698561,
0.0260523912,
0.0179612339,
-0.0220389105,
-0.0242630504,
-0.0074458965,
-0.0138385845,
-0.0449220054,
0.0200504381,
-0.0016313649,
-0.0624780953,
-0.0312705636,
0.0154110128,
0.0318911634,
-0.0482312664,
-0.0417734943,
0.0190755278,
-0.0311491732,
0.0161904264,
-0.0010921982,
-0.0043954439,
0.0372655764,
-0.0354970507,
-0.0196944382,
0.0234446805,
0.0183378365,
-0.0124383382,
-0.0028220708,
-0.0444990695,
0.0264447164,
0.0465547927,
0.0373007134,
0.0709499195,
-0.0389941446,
0.0051413425,
0.0346537903,
0.032613311,
-0.0098512685,
-0.0085373027,
-0.0024053806,
0.0223055072,
0.0533074029,
0.1171919331,
-0.0000030541,
0.0570697375,
0.0475720577,
-0.0449678525,
-0.0074459487,
0.0071415897,
0.0169833321,
-0.0060401261,
-0.0277536679,
-0.0337850675,
-0.0038334203,
-0.0741203353,
0.0286525693,
-0.0425441265,
-0.0111711416,
0.0466080047,
-0.0462115481,
0.0278438982,
0.0082087964,
0.0231710952,
-0.0099351117,
-0.0183783658,
-0.0094240289,
0.0147220604,
0.0315904357,
0.0012014859,
0.0374838002,
-0.0685631633,
0.0034002424,
-0.0217475444,
0.0023613514,
0.0433357209,
0.0068919812,
-0.0024054684,
0.0159295183,
-0.044604782,
-0.0267498754,
-0.0398150124,
0.0017753047,
0.0243082624,
-0.0230680089,
0.0353641547,
0.0130003523,
-0.002625454,
0.0386096202,
-0.0400331989,
-0.0266920999,
-0.030066831,
0.0479216538,
-0.015638331,
0.0142739303,
0.0171822067,
-0.0041907933,
-0.0161853265,
-0.0000453563,
0.0312697068,
-0.0238033906,
0.0301674251,
0.024171181,
2.709e-7,
0.0632001758,
0.0544656366,
0.0038139923,
0.0551050417,
0.0005489971,
0.0374917388,
-0.0601826198,
-0.0558856465,
0.0593012646,
-0.0472491048,
-0.0100753475,
0.0640926585,
0.0348793678,
0.0499113724,
-0.0576303117,
0.0190839078,
-0.0593273565,
0.0035868923,
-0.0535089783,
-0.0009250673,
0.0725588873,
0.0480451435,
0.0275935996,
0.0057894322,
-0.0414369851,
-0.0446675606,
0.0471708961,
-0.0298595466,
-0.0266157053,
0.0165194273,
0.003643173,
-0.043078389,
0.0182350427,
0.0370998494,
-0.0135601703,
0.0031129119,
0.0030305353,
0.040347822,
0.0313013308,
0.0071710488,
-0.0469540767,
-0.0208229646,
-0.0172839612,
-0.0327249765,
0.0480670072,
-0.0748203769,
-0.0423657671,
-0.0135537935,
0.0090113636,
-0.039614372,
0.0306772143,
0.0035996723,
0.0279525295,
-0.0152215073,
0.042993661,
-0.0204300601,
0.0183688756,
-0.0476663113,
-0.0351342633,
0.0313316435,
-0.0314311311,
-0.063417837,
-0.0737313405,
0.000081624,
0.0376765132,
-0.0293554869,
-0.0390576497,
2.472280663e-34,
0.0411476828,
-0.0202900488,
0.040044833,
0.0471758433,
0.0288456026,
0.0024923664,
-0.0064193918,
0.0156895015,
0.0313224383,
-0.0656233132,
-0.0097644385
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06954v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06954v2 | Bridging the Preference Gap between Retrievers and LLMs | 2024-01-13T02:20:17 | 2024-02-20T21:11:23 | Zixuan Ke, Weize Kong, Cheng Li, Mingyang Zhang, Qiaozhu Mei, Michael Bendersky | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated superior results across a wide
range of tasks, and Retrieval-augmented Generation (RAG) is an effective way to
enhance the performance by locating relevant information and placing it into
the context window of the LLM. However, the relationship between retrievers and
LLMs in a RAG is still under-investigated. Most existing work treats the
retriever and the LLM as independent components and leaves a gap between
retrieving human-"friendly" information and assembling a LLM-"friendly"
context. In this work, we examine a novel bridge mechanism. We validate the
ranking and selection assumptions of retrievers in the context of RAG and
propose a framework that chains together supervised and reinforcement learning
to train a bridge model that optimizes the connection between the retriever and
the LLM. Empirical results demonstrate the effectiveness of our method in both
question-answering and personalized generation tasks. | [
0.056056533,
0.059388835,
-0.0003892968,
0.0155749405,
-0.0241415706,
-0.0160379708,
-0.0184153635,
-0.0231102556,
-0.0046715443,
-0.0412550829,
-0.0297874063,
-0.0288792998,
-0.0347826518,
-0.000092477,
0.0313426144,
-0.0290499683,
0.0436212905,
-0.0273171421,
0.0174969733,
-0.0049617505,
-0.0336922593,
0.0306082089,
0.010504364,
0.0373620801,
0.0062960112,
0.0272866115,
-0.0065124636,
0.0225432832,
0.0116017405,
-0.0380670652,
0.0263858475,
0.0352782309,
0.0404978618,
0.0140350601,
0.0000019788,
-0.0470552258,
-0.0279804505,
-0.013133782,
-0.0097911693,
-0.0341848247,
0.0142483134,
0.0274124276,
0.0027711634,
0.0264828764,
-0.0508958511,
-0.0123988567,
0.0107929977,
0.0423989594,
0.0449703969,
0.0723896474,
0.0137452576,
0.0089840293,
0.0104474602,
-0.0571352839,
0.0720910132,
-0.0513167568,
0.0055107828,
0.0135768345,
0.0378665514,
0.049382925,
0.0010091532,
0.0320309475,
0.0380918942,
-0.024836706,
0.0212169494,
0.0408763178,
-0.0159661602,
0.0145888841,
-0.0151478536,
0.0775458142,
0.0159038994,
-0.0122181457,
0.0033977481,
0.0152456556,
0.0196310002,
0.0424856432,
-0.0504587963,
0.0306556635,
-0.0063142143,
0.0259584207,
-0.0021070689,
-0.0120558115,
0.0275017302,
0.0457320586,
-0.0321138464,
0.0578989312,
0.0180558059,
-0.0200611893,
-0.0138672376,
0.0366534851,
-0.0093820272,
-0.0510199405,
0.0196240675,
0.0433949791,
-0.0769038722,
0.0292891841,
-0.0437209904,
0.0128173586,
0.013274584,
0.0387564488,
0.0446649529,
0.0193732642,
-0.0121510066,
0.0187730212,
-0.0362598598,
0.0151307387,
-0.0457503349,
-0.0026407731,
-0.0633263141,
-0.0089604249,
-0.0384146348,
-0.0465908498,
-0.0400136337,
0.0450641662,
-0.0619532652,
-0.0216959286,
-0.049073305,
0.0470570549,
0.0121631315,
-0.0245882832,
0.0166604295,
0.0649523735,
-0.0464605652,
-0.0008204089,
-0.0630460307,
0.0070612868,
-0.0383778848,
0.0166122001,
0.0657983869,
-0.0464748591,
-0.0151828974,
0.0003264442,
0.0026300352,
-0.0451087244,
-0.0039858664,
0.0404102392,
-0.0491581783,
-0.0361797512,
-0.0568782911,
-0.0429607294,
-0.0257918313,
-0.0427887887,
0.0004131225,
-0.069839865,
0.0243951976,
0.0040141493,
-0.0162295252,
0.0034517781,
0.0241238549,
0.0431365669,
-0.010354911,
0.0180186648,
0.026499074,
0.0202423334,
0.0377899706,
0.006314687,
0.0117044225,
0.0289776698,
0.0082019139,
0.0505087823,
0.012204905,
0.0309025068,
-0.006833815,
-0.0066558924,
0.031462688,
0.0057678279,
-0.022794757,
0.0041948739,
-0.0134330019,
0.0286990795,
0.0548550598,
0.0565659925,
-0.0503406487,
0.0067288061,
0.0752007961,
0.0162805822,
0.0226840228,
0.0144327246,
0.0548847951,
0.026401151,
-0.0291284285,
0.0445592776,
-0.0390513241,
0.0495438315,
-0.0324164554,
0.0204065386,
0.0410947204,
0.0211240835,
-0.0290499255,
-0.0317795947,
0.0337559991,
0.0007845228,
-0.0066805803,
0.0450410545,
0.0309633613,
0.055218745,
-0.0502403155,
0.0357103124,
-0.0050243307,
-0.0480786599,
0.0345387682,
-0.0506807715,
0.0521858782,
0.0709580854,
0.0920888186,
0.00733663,
-0.011224024,
0.0128113246,
-0.0221095141,
0.0328734256,
0.0298302695,
-0.0220144428,
-0.0114316195,
-0.0321489759,
-0.0364900231,
-0.0287947282,
-0.0082179392,
0.0338435806,
0.0580597445,
-0.0023065191,
0.0426187553,
-0.0251627024,
-0.0053545018,
0.0261121467,
-0.0136373481,
-0.0394269899,
0.0413655415,
0.0057691326,
-0.0243111867,
0.008082821,
-0.002020689,
0.0339366905,
0.0324967653,
-0.027102543,
-0.0304756574,
0.0072877333,
-0.0899660438,
-0.0170254093,
-0.0059585534,
0.0002786619,
0.0044558602,
0.0168572031,
-0.015345755,
-0.036751274,
0.0019725643,
-0.0544550195,
0.0439519919,
-0.0633179769,
0.0009015828,
0.0519467145,
-0.0213939026,
-0.0736155584,
0.0903620645,
-0.0089920918,
-0.0109170238,
0.0322965756,
0.0413796753,
-0.0129360463,
-0.0856192783,
-0.0003564206,
0.000334529,
-0.0081742881,
0.0176244769,
0.0592859499,
0.0199421626,
-0.04604825,
-0.0500558093,
-0.078959167,
-0.0102169281,
-0.0251429919,
0.0110045597,
0.0011689476,
0.0210044775,
0.0056846589,
-0.0343194082,
-0.056756556,
-0.0345451385,
0.0553811714,
0.0126646021,
0.0255328994,
0.0316593312,
0.014775061,
-0.0608880855,
-0.0069563966,
0.0216641333,
0.0088681234,
-0.0016157884,
0.053366106,
-0.0432832539,
0.0064918171,
-0.0563045032,
0.0203024559,
-0.0037483647,
0.002028178,
0.0249069296,
-0.0514187142,
0.0648673847,
0.0616964288,
0.0391040966,
0.0478743725,
0.0585259609,
0.0052743549,
-0.0760573596,
0.0124848131,
-0.0483500734,
-0.057529714,
-0.0192199778,
-0.0285006892,
0.0314608775,
0.0348785035,
0.0020520168,
-0.0104381451,
-0.0489645414,
0.039826043,
0.0182999503,
-0.0476471335,
-0.0519151948,
0.000027719,
-0.0053549046,
0.0497764871,
-0.0336981714,
-0.0579481013,
0.080893904,
-0.003569243,
0.0118439179,
-0.0511313118,
-0.001472586,
-0.0600714684,
0.0210500788,
-0.0037471061,
0.0293428916,
-0.0462210625,
-0.0158772189,
-0.0716602281,
-0.0050312174,
0.0088720014,
-0.0471812859,
0.0425856672,
-0.0614932701,
0.0316215008,
0.0228992756,
-0.0564496107,
-0.0849096626,
-0.0143090067,
0.0309563689,
-0.0008475296,
0.0194066446,
-0.0119916024,
-0.0285299458,
-0.035440132,
0.047648102,
0.0171772838,
-0.0249500237,
-0.0257046781,
-0.0268961247,
0.0781993493,
0.1008425951,
0.0159967877,
0.0083783679,
-0.0254857205,
-0.0148272598,
0.0414677039,
0.0397672653,
-0.0083052712,
0.0136376824,
-0.0046603251,
0.040400058,
-0.0198040679,
-0.0141523713,
0.0370859727,
0.0145933172,
-0.0326813087,
-0.0537696779,
0.0847238898,
0.0463696793,
-0.0308244042,
-0.0101657081,
-0.0270850006,
0.0543973558,
0.0208046865,
0.0652215704,
-0.0611387342,
0.0025156215,
-0.0073146392,
0.0436016582,
-0.0036570753,
-0.013235487,
-0.0223285556,
-0.1589748859,
0.0297693461,
0.0038251339,
-0.0365142673,
-0.0076602236,
-0.0055267652,
-0.0169914905,
0.0292527005,
0.0096620852,
0.0508966297,
-0.0281596389,
0.0050706621,
0.0107522393,
0.0943193808,
-0.0408939235,
-0.0290828664,
-0.0238821376,
0.0154149402,
0.0899138749,
0.0102557503,
0.0256936569,
-0.0204722639,
-0.0165055692,
-0.0179892313,
0.0256386455,
-0.0222795475,
0.0236726608,
-0.0236108042,
0.0044323378,
-0.0389948003,
0.0330795161,
0.0114945602,
-0.0166528318,
-0.0150171062,
0.038045533,
-0.0252231024,
-0.0035241928,
-0.0252043046,
0.0030493147,
0.0263171177,
0.0633838102,
0.0283973012,
-0.043164175,
-0.0338541232,
-0.009660705,
-0.0001563685,
-0.0710333586,
-0.0025826201,
0.0276911911,
0.0043189009,
-0.0008317102,
-0.1114999428,
-0.0249818806,
0.0070563396,
0.0390350819,
-0.005046532,
0.0200491603,
-0.0235500485,
-0.0232771784,
-0.0426938832,
0.031966392,
-0.0293847211,
-0.01403757,
-0.0616273768,
-0.0392643958,
0.0404972322,
-0.0925578102,
-0.0093926117,
-0.0058238301,
-0.0082480321,
-0.0591869801,
-0.0321211405,
0.0803576559,
0.0236991867,
0.0361322239,
0.0117878253,
-0.0644673184,
0.0473260842,
0.0263570491,
-0.0077720233,
0.0150926244,
-0.0229414739,
0.0141334618,
-0.0139142592,
0.0215064604,
-0.0766193718,
0.0260945633,
-0.0109774731,
0.0696903393,
-0.0036140396,
-0.0284988377,
0.0575296171,
-0.0162987914,
-0.0146663971,
-0.0340761319,
0.0438199267,
-0.038881965,
0.0130259842,
-0.0195829608,
-0.0157349445,
-0.0299363192,
-0.0058788192,
0.0237895958,
-0.0099761859,
0.0172895323,
-0.0234996378,
0.0042110733,
0.0825587139,
-0.0281859394,
-0.0323957354,
-0.0000379312,
-0.0060659787,
0.0268054977,
0.0153224338,
-0.0037903225,
0.0203399528,
0.00055217,
0.0801584199,
-0.0106442962,
0.0847480446,
0.0242265742,
-0.0242485087,
-0.0248182695,
0.0281665046,
-0.0635706782,
-0.0417096801,
-0.0183122158,
0.0299175587,
0.0317376927,
0.0047015897,
0.0525714681,
-0.0258000717,
-0.0185689591,
-0.0151131116,
-0.0006896804,
0.008870827,
-0.0375069156,
0.0181695409,
0.0355065763,
-0.0084851505,
0.0204365626,
0.0564275756,
0.0079100691,
0.0136852898,
-0.0540270321,
-0.0094774552,
-0.0360546596,
-0.0385964103,
0.0209778566,
0.0155023551,
-0.0134460786,
0.0276121348,
-0.0412525125,
-0.0599067807,
-0.0125609422,
0.0385048725,
-0.0047176313,
-0.0227264315,
0.063250035,
0.0541610792,
-0.0033249264,
-0.0363047794,
-0.0575362183,
0.0206785742,
-0.0678794757,
-0.0288021099,
-0.0295345858,
-6.271609132e-33,
-0.0455752797,
-0.0561579615,
0.0425074175,
-0.0466994345,
-0.0195148326,
-0.0115085971,
-0.0520200729,
-0.0031665631,
-0.0081805633,
-0.0193160232,
-0.0143407322,
-0.0251462534,
0.0061807805,
0.0434637628,
-0.008811078,
0.0014446443,
0.0400709137,
0.0146111883,
-0.033689931,
0.0368751064,
0.0445729978,
0.0362134539,
-0.0153497197,
-0.0440463237,
0.0014079217,
-0.0082027391,
0.0031919784,
0.0338791087,
-0.02897349,
0.0770729929,
0.0020576678,
0.0236612335,
0.0241959076,
-0.0049040993,
-0.0058792052,
0.0569955148,
-0.0825393349,
-0.0073680175,
0.0205025133,
-0.038317427,
-0.0638983771,
-0.0437324196,
0.0131294122,
-0.0404116996,
0.004095566,
0.0277052317,
0.0201239903,
-0.0178816076,
-0.0419517308,
-0.0353424773,
-0.0587862171,
-0.0168818254,
0.0205080975,
-0.0306996349,
-0.0151004698,
0.0578965433,
-0.0197309181,
0.0405888744,
0.0077640489,
0.03899955,
0.0063296859,
0.050741002,
0.0518672019,
0.041271273,
-0.017550176,
0.0335674398,
0.0186784267,
-0.0327041671,
-0.0102674831,
-0.0576282591,
-0.0036790166,
0.0409790948,
-0.0077475123,
0.0270206109,
-0.0054312833,
0.0111513678,
-0.033290118,
0.0495217107,
0.022544425,
0.0257650483,
0.0308333039,
0.0227256268,
-0.0050349212,
-0.0083485227,
-0.0436576232,
0.0071739024,
-0.0420510098,
-0.0409135483,
0.0644797981,
0.060464967,
-0.0486833677,
-0.0568512976,
0.0353428759,
-0.0128188794,
-0.0165279973,
0.0294522811,
-0.0451336056,
-0.0016410496,
-0.0272146501,
0.0098741082,
-0.0472773425,
-0.0078511164,
0.0519405454,
-0.0371893123,
-0.0402184017,
0.0286922194,
0.0080734594,
0.0078686932,
-0.0319549888,
0.0279888008,
-0.0449224375,
0.0543824248,
-0.0209537894,
-0.0026230905,
0.0323732272,
0.0162612814,
-0.0298531745,
0.0361883938,
0.0109564671,
0.0025192101,
-0.0392975472,
-0.0248917807,
0.0042185229,
0.0135838697,
-0.0201346949,
0.0510771871,
-0.0185553096,
0.047634434,
0.0127272159,
-0.0250514224,
-0.0133886151,
0.0204854626,
2.697e-7,
0.0211251602,
0.0318978094,
0.0428580157,
0.0514229536,
-0.0007153411,
0.0105282525,
0.0033229522,
0.0175829548,
0.0385489538,
0.0071472116,
0.0054850229,
0.0272093397,
0.0474399291,
-0.0111234151,
-0.0675242245,
0.0264283381,
-0.06909886,
-0.0180538185,
-0.0331569947,
-0.0595474057,
0.0441359617,
0.0427659042,
-0.0253495835,
-0.0130342431,
0.0124345375,
-0.0287139118,
0.0841170922,
-0.0091242874,
-0.0247042049,
0.0073332726,
0.0347800367,
0.0159088038,
-0.0145526445,
-0.023144586,
-0.0042675403,
0.0288106762,
-0.015639022,
0.0528840087,
0.0096432501,
-0.0758222193,
-0.0121174743,
0.0182506703,
0.0157251842,
-0.0456286781,
0.0487407707,
-0.070323959,
0.0233812947,
0.0002706648,
-0.0120056225,
-0.0065164426,
-0.0165201034,
-0.0440877825,
-0.0256005861,
0.0070997658,
0.0170913227,
0.0254828297,
0.0048258686,
-0.0888906047,
-0.0126859117,
0.02850537,
-0.0457906052,
-0.0465106927,
-0.0615957975,
0.0242476575,
-0.0336171724,
-0.0450915396,
-0.0121622207,
2.380026167e-34,
0.005668649,
0.0175351929,
0.0194423292,
0.0305421744,
0.0293298159,
0.038597092,
-0.0485931598,
0.0268939491,
0.0385017134,
-0.074132584,
-0.0308743156
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06951v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06951v3 | E^2-LLM: Efficient and Extreme Length Extension of Large Language Models | 2024-01-13T02:11:20 | 2024-02-22T12:49:10 | Jiaheng Liu, Zhiqi Bai, Yuanxing Zhang, Chenchen Zhang, Yu Zhang, Ge Zhang, Jiakai Wang, Haoran Que, Yukang Chen, Wenbo Su, Tiezheng Ge, Jie Fu, Wenhu Chen, Bo Zheng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Typically, training LLMs with long context sizes is computationally
expensive, requiring extensive training hours and GPU resources. Existing
long-context extension methods usually need additional training procedures to
support corresponding long-context windows, where the long-context training
data (e.g., 32k) is needed, and high GPU training costs are assumed. To address
the aforementioned issues, we propose an Efficient and Extreme length extension
method for Large Language Models, called E 2 -LLM, with only one training
procedure and dramatically reduced computation cost, which also removes the
need to collect long-context data. Concretely, first, the training data of our
E 2 -LLM only requires a short length (e.g., 4k), which reduces the tuning cost
greatly. Second, the training procedure on the short training context window is
performed only once time, and we can support different evaluation context
windows at inference. Third, in E 2 - LLM, based on RoPE position embeddings,
we introduce two different augmentation methods on the scale and position index
parameters for different samples in training. It aims to make the model more
robust to the different relative differences when directly interpolating the
arbitrary context length at inference. Comprehensive experimental results on
multiple benchmark datasets demonstrate the effectiveness of our E 2 -LLM on
challenging long-context tasks. | [
0.0253313556,
0.0531057529,
0.00762652,
0.0565914921,
-0.0181700103,
0.0214624777,
0.0169164427,
0.0058229072,
-0.0201845467,
-0.0189561117,
-0.0242784917,
-0.0373878367,
-0.0007821373,
-0.0115937591,
0.0627106503,
-0.0597008467,
0.0145846121,
-0.0384636112,
-0.0141333314,
-0.0187304914,
0.0072367019,
-0.0031780719,
0.0034053151,
0.004907642,
-0.0159226283,
0.0246522501,
-0.0570040829,
0.0276026316,
0.0576034635,
-0.0403974839,
0.0042855251,
0.0281392615,
0.0676603094,
0.0232913736,
0.0000020833,
-0.0322799422,
-0.0065585137,
-0.0022191352,
-0.0154823344,
0.0340811536,
0.0470804609,
-0.0217593014,
0.0023450949,
0.0109322863,
-0.0016973518,
-0.0018058958,
0.0508934818,
0.0023071088,
0.0106015373,
0.0906615034,
-0.0156845655,
-0.0482493453,
0.0149794053,
-0.0913314894,
0.0162866246,
-0.0419091508,
0.0435408428,
-0.0011932943,
0.0079012932,
0.0373484865,
-0.0509060994,
0.0009466979,
0.0492150225,
0.0297045615,
-0.0249748137,
0.0386967994,
0.0023705091,
0.0006786209,
0.0130258175,
0.0450834483,
-0.0334631167,
-0.0063033579,
-0.0088449614,
-0.0104120299,
0.0153345801,
-0.0209124796,
-0.0504595526,
0.0089910589,
0.0583270006,
0.0136346761,
0.024740817,
-0.0035415348,
0.0457966812,
0.022456605,
-0.0643421188,
0.0510745831,
0.0339589827,
-0.029580418,
-0.0444459021,
-0.0023761615,
-0.0631218702,
0.0074721961,
-0.0206796136,
0.0195736215,
0.0046492866,
0.0418706574,
-0.0506106578,
-0.0345388874,
0.0211156737,
-0.0169308167,
0.0380215496,
0.0464685261,
0.0063938005,
0.0435561575,
-0.0457847714,
0.024794329,
-0.018970808,
0.0171637125,
-0.0701824725,
-0.0138253244,
0.0061045233,
0.0113427714,
-0.0241316799,
-0.0362194031,
-0.0615158603,
-0.0337012596,
-0.0391488336,
0.0245804191,
0.0157141332,
-0.0123175941,
0.0158216339,
0.0010261866,
-0.0498639196,
-0.006706778,
0.0144784274,
0.0201801546,
-0.064121522,
0.0644438788,
0.008068867,
-0.0065068854,
-0.0296520088,
0.0303219203,
0.030006459,
-0.0331602655,
0.0328604877,
0.0518556759,
0.0194702279,
-0.0494729131,
-0.0405787751,
0.0284903999,
-0.0417765155,
-0.0600499772,
-0.0074937302,
-0.0974851474,
0.0404719934,
-0.0245356932,
0.0044666729,
-0.011753927,
0.0101024378,
-0.0071568615,
-0.0339446813,
0.0615761466,
-0.0345329307,
-0.0060360511,
0.0077815773,
-0.0012842813,
0.019007599,
0.0787195414,
0.0307358429,
0.0309402142,
0.038770467,
0.0149785168,
-0.0399435386,
0.0431999266,
0.0245501082,
0.0369471647,
-0.0503526255,
-0.0097558703,
0.0120083373,
0.0376641154,
0.0495255366,
0.0149486735,
-0.0487395413,
-0.0543118231,
0.0223253183,
0.0471718907,
0.03969815,
-0.0126622505,
0.0529609174,
-0.0208545793,
-0.021673834,
-0.0100037018,
-0.0398930311,
0.0028897161,
0.025933126,
0.0402104855,
0.0506302007,
0.0211009402,
-0.0280025043,
-0.0210164655,
-0.0230821893,
-0.0173844136,
0.0304629225,
-0.0022651951,
0.0334887467,
-0.0229681879,
-0.0108875968,
0.0401790477,
0.064399451,
-0.0529684797,
-0.0063006934,
-0.0051239179,
0.0004274507,
0.0794137865,
-0.0065091574,
-0.0292127132,
-0.0359476693,
-0.0054017063,
0.0199122112,
0.0499982312,
0.0048835524,
0.0010524982,
0.0430299938,
-0.0530732237,
-0.0275663435,
-0.0093800901,
0.0102912402,
0.0032745122,
0.0724523589,
0.0330585726,
0.0280568451,
-0.0772413164,
0.0103908721,
0.031921424,
-0.0806020722,
-0.0169427805,
-0.0351105444,
0.018148277,
0.0073671849,
0.0088368552,
0.0017928488,
-0.0167956259,
0.0401940495,
-0.0614534244,
0.0025241845,
-0.0323628262,
-0.0698751211,
-0.056168817,
0.0751781613,
-0.0158238057,
0.0152928736,
0.0132557508,
-0.0616904236,
-0.0506839305,
-0.0093469396,
-0.0059403018,
0.0553611033,
-0.0463859588,
0.0144161982,
-0.0119895404,
0.0264903605,
-0.0531346761,
0.0374583378,
-0.0338578373,
0.0250456613,
0.0348790027,
0.0417975187,
-0.0308529064,
-0.0311629269,
-0.0455726497,
0.0218098685,
0.0300331526,
0.0086733401,
-0.0178090595,
-0.0067943893,
-0.0349952877,
-0.0266964678,
-0.1168005615,
-0.0018596863,
-0.0225125141,
0.03232757,
0.0249985866,
0.0141114751,
-0.0287156776,
-0.0012149798,
-0.023417091,
-0.0175827965,
-0.0449875146,
0.019498283,
-0.0044068508,
0.0178793445,
-0.0491076224,
-0.0367198624,
-0.0247418191,
0.0151951546,
0.060324952,
-0.0396227278,
-0.020052135,
-0.0629467219,
0.0196776465,
-0.0185977984,
0.0393718407,
-0.0351985246,
-0.0341034681,
-0.0196048021,
-0.0472194292,
0.0410210453,
0.0500251688,
0.0113324588,
0.0098158885,
0.0409431458,
0.0356038623,
-0.0369328372,
0.0084329015,
-0.0379345417,
-0.009603424,
-0.0639722198,
-0.0118835084,
-0.0518146828,
0.0723481029,
-0.0426506028,
-0.0129104378,
-0.0327610858,
-0.0287894197,
0.0129897259,
-0.0071536009,
0.0112037314,
0.0080411471,
-0.0442716256,
0.0210088566,
-0.0287005156,
-0.0597046614,
0.0298080575,
-0.075600788,
-0.0031854489,
-0.0337580517,
-0.04651035,
-0.0430537574,
0.0841237605,
0.0333269797,
0.0232376773,
-0.0580314621,
0.0112001309,
-0.0180220399,
0.0241789855,
-0.0019403935,
-0.0080450019,
0.021173628,
-0.0141254449,
0.0091632763,
-0.0271235667,
-0.0205368083,
-0.0248905439,
0.0087233465,
-0.0143549731,
-0.0042037661,
0.0010973515,
-0.0362001956,
0.0177381057,
0.0066777398,
0.0054879654,
0.0769387335,
-0.0159114208,
0.0498851873,
-0.0281796269,
0.0149032166,
0.0608342923,
0.03297529,
-0.009256715,
-0.0404485762,
0.0004147743,
0.0289938562,
-0.0060093859,
0.0096289366,
-0.0575184971,
0.0048641679,
0.0100118145,
-0.0213120915,
-0.0088440282,
0.0160304364,
0.0567121804,
-0.0654335469,
0.0106945671,
0.094377853,
0.0090738656,
-0.0614824332,
0.014719693,
-0.0039994968,
0.0788536221,
0.0428732932,
0.0048105293,
-0.0712395385,
-0.0183016658,
0.0272027701,
-0.0073094107,
0.0150428722,
-0.003711168,
-0.012517781,
-0.1238400191,
0.011619743,
0.0345915407,
-0.0389203094,
-0.0366446301,
-0.0400338545,
0.0359353088,
0.0364085995,
0.0179492999,
0.0352006033,
-0.0152277127,
-0.0037417698,
0.0214859266,
0.0045279344,
-0.0594836399,
-0.0090879025,
-0.0287502613,
0.0388604924,
-0.0090670316,
-0.0044124229,
0.005338802,
-0.0187794678,
0.0561768562,
-0.0052926256,
0.0103944466,
0.004458013,
0.0435449295,
-0.0182156377,
0.00578458,
0.0398701094,
0.0570122562,
-0.0010251139,
-0.0146518275,
0.0126313865,
0.0821887553,
-0.0037153736,
0.0196392182,
0.0074121403,
-0.0280866679,
-0.0199396871,
0.0423302576,
0.0573280938,
-0.0400898531,
0.0023675396,
-0.0207179785,
-0.0443354249,
-0.0122805275,
0.0268451609,
-0.0027718388,
0.0026348738,
-0.0039958139,
-0.0356607139,
-0.0165570974,
0.035373129,
0.0669595003,
-0.0210275836,
0.0307118166,
-0.0430010557,
-0.0097888894,
-0.0803549513,
0.0247336421,
-0.0315611698,
0.0383161046,
-0.0181096196,
0.0255627651,
0.0194414649,
-0.0038827076,
0.0000469144,
-0.0000590573,
-0.1121455282,
-0.0882236734,
-0.0268578678,
0.0129643045,
0.0142843891,
0.1045372263,
0.0051917066,
-0.0348715186,
0.0575204864,
0.0326391682,
-0.0205160007,
0.0503247529,
0.0408424698,
0.0136533091,
0.0085223652,
0.0450949036,
-0.0239826124,
0.0143403159,
0.0226119105,
0.0596799441,
-0.0374376178,
-0.0279029664,
-0.0256338138,
-0.012827035,
0.0375115834,
-0.02532118,
-0.0013501148,
-0.0310580954,
0.0586263239,
-0.0430424251,
0.0148407361,
-0.0345903374,
-0.003063798,
0.0273808595,
0.0072918739,
0.0148331942,
-0.0144206872,
0.0487943254,
-0.004078479,
-0.022234736,
0.0589976944,
-0.0234158672,
-0.0023209357,
0.0329716429,
0.0426695831,
-0.0366337895,
-0.0193042532,
-0.0348028392,
0.0334127471,
-0.0409133844,
0.0198228676,
0.0252843834,
-0.0037619493,
-0.0618306287,
0.0416128002,
-0.0485192798,
-0.016495673,
-0.0380169712,
0.0357801616,
0.0554989502,
-0.0118043106,
0.0506702922,
0.0071424483,
-0.0329101235,
-0.0142977349,
0.0301164817,
-0.0338821076,
-0.0308617149,
0.0455122441,
0.0437379628,
-0.023699183,
0.0509761907,
0.0430178493,
0.0574097484,
0.0247459859,
-0.0031152652,
0.0281898919,
-0.0112008229,
-0.0370168053,
-0.0114635043,
0.0064118258,
-0.0160374176,
0.0213368535,
0.0061433362,
-0.1018178463,
-0.0067305029,
-0.0092636198,
-0.0440762378,
-0.0097535569,
0.0394975133,
0.0280476492,
-0.0359156877,
0.0139760338,
-0.0074511319,
-0.01916546,
0.0490514599,
-0.0337766036,
0.00187792,
-6.154949032e-33,
-0.0164382365,
0.023596162,
0.0283561926,
-0.0416968241,
-0.0609333403,
0.0279858578,
-0.0111299297,
0.0185838472,
-0.0048186877,
0.0036566267,
-0.005482343,
-0.0210604798,
0.0060944855,
0.0420492887,
-0.0555275269,
0.0048477566,
0.0346548036,
0.0234213341,
0.018506201,
-0.0005949984,
0.0199447144,
0.050671082,
0.0808047131,
-0.0302331857,
-0.0005912074,
0.0086221835,
-0.0012910741,
0.027608756,
0.0142002339,
0.0457088128,
-0.0147576919,
0.0254407711,
0.0217322782,
-0.0635390505,
-0.0199396424,
-0.0193088893,
-0.09539406,
-0.022222288,
0.0084008984,
0.0003676831,
-0.0619783252,
-0.0276248232,
0.0616577268,
0.0011477077,
0.0122207329,
-0.0298556313,
0.0010963634,
-0.0639397129,
-0.041788388,
0.0002742582,
-0.0267888568,
0.0301535018,
0.0337417647,
0.025866244,
0.0409411825,
0.0018175468,
0.0058052917,
0.0227669533,
-0.0566587895,
-0.0172914732,
0.0213188641,
0.0728922635,
0.0403925255,
0.0395069756,
0.0206335597,
0.0517309532,
-0.0053021936,
-0.0324276499,
-0.0126357516,
0.0016746008,
0.045284342,
0.0297290031,
0.0333609097,
0.0258550607,
0.0495752208,
-0.0239822492,
-0.0734999999,
-0.0056198831,
0.0316452235,
0.0127588641,
0.0189755317,
0.0457445718,
-0.0133670475,
-0.0292384848,
-0.0490551889,
-0.0227315985,
-0.0236142166,
-0.0333473012,
0.045587372,
0.0427263491,
-0.0247746389,
-0.0287295468,
0.0381081291,
-0.0374549069,
-0.0064387559,
0.0185304731,
-0.0262021981,
0.0289488677,
0.0197902843,
0.0237215497,
-0.0128665604,
-0.0211351309,
0.0138488999,
-0.0076881009,
0.0088712797,
-0.0604721345,
0.0638376102,
0.0328065306,
-0.0693593249,
-0.0057989946,
-0.0490305237,
-0.0144813005,
0.0134350564,
0.0500633717,
0.0441284589,
-0.0111560719,
0.0099822385,
0.0882170349,
0.01108592,
-0.0001426455,
-0.001565773,
-0.043893043,
-0.0069889748,
0.0371435508,
-0.0433176421,
0.0092040915,
-0.0272610467,
-0.0030744381,
0.0346296765,
-0.0942623839,
-0.0194713436,
0.0287629571,
2.7e-7,
0.0374242775,
0.0099466806,
0.0457707718,
0.0059273122,
0.0298194177,
-0.0085749207,
0.0086792847,
0.0267596971,
-0.0143893296,
-0.0285933129,
0.0103406776,
0.055385951,
0.0303616859,
-0.024277959,
-0.0903983489,
0.0185130518,
-0.0616558045,
0.0301355217,
-0.0334252082,
-0.0031494929,
-0.0001349463,
0.1431397349,
0.0238575395,
0.0067767971,
0.0138343209,
-0.0463202111,
0.0416820906,
-0.0570529476,
0.0199272688,
-0.0076179868,
-0.0192669444,
0.0458195247,
0.0010834506,
-0.0114580998,
0.0085448222,
0.058139421,
-0.0098228622,
0.0877919495,
0.0036169477,
0.0104527585,
0.0157639664,
-0.0116389515,
-0.0215202421,
-0.0562942959,
0.0700944737,
-0.0303887408,
-0.0066309907,
-0.0515147261,
-0.0243682209,
0.0064118276,
-0.0111281043,
-0.0234399159,
0.0087515078,
0.0183038246,
0.0392093658,
-0.0237437934,
-0.0198207907,
-0.0969833434,
-0.0441999361,
0.0025282039,
-0.0701853782,
-0.0300547853,
-0.0423228964,
0.0031325761,
0.0232974943,
-0.0440384932,
-0.0157053228,
2.848916859e-34,
0.0415512435,
-0.009844522,
0.0046889298,
0.0046030884,
0.0207363702,
-0.0429872684,
-0.0126466081,
0.0078643244,
0.0112697817,
-0.0980693325,
-0.0382131897
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06947v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06947v1 | Parameter-Efficient Detoxification with Contrastive Decoding | 2024-01-13T01:46:20 | 2024-01-13T01:46:20 | Tong Niu, Caiming Xiong, Semih Yavuz, Yingbo Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The field of natural language generation has witnessed significant
advancements in recent years, including the development of controllable text
generation techniques. However, controlling the attributes of the generated
text remains a challenge, especially when aiming to avoid undesirable behavior
such as toxicity. In this work, we introduce Detoxification Generator
(DETOXIGEN), an inference-time algorithm that steers the generation away from
unwanted styles. DETOXIGEN is an ensemble of a pre-trained language model
(generator) and a detoxifier. The detoxifier is trained intentionally on the
toxic data representative of the undesirable attribute, encouraging it to
generate text in that style exclusively. During the actual generation, we use
the trained detoxifier to produce undesirable tokens for the generator to
contrast against at each decoding step. This approach directly informs the
generator to avoid generating tokens that the detoxifier considers highly
likely. We evaluate DETOXIGEN on the commonly used REALTOXICITYPROMPTS
benchmark (Gehman et al., 2020) with various language models as generators. We
find that it significantly outperforms previous approaches in detoxification
metrics while not compromising on the generation quality. Moreover, the
detoxifier is obtained by soft prompt-tuning using the same backbone language
model as the generator. Hence, DETOXIGEN requires only a tiny amount of extra
weights from the virtual tokens of the detoxifier to be loaded into GPU memory
while decoding, making it a promising lightweight, practical, and
parameter-efficient detoxification strategy. | [
0.0282787178,
0.097038649,
-0.0052999365,
0.0076334681,
-0.0117225517,
0.0173053537,
-0.0042133322,
0.0210025348,
0.0099458657,
-0.0248946473,
-0.0108829802,
0.0218700711,
-0.0154204732,
0.0505283922,
0.0128765851,
-0.031580057,
0.032842949,
0.0099287936,
-0.0001159644,
-0.0022985344,
0.0028101548,
0.0358262062,
0.0278186575,
0.0330274887,
-0.0023146267,
-0.0413553342,
0.0032583757,
0.0415386744,
0.0107281934,
-0.0446747802,
0.0181070622,
0.0397282541,
-0.0252191238,
0.0456968918,
0.0000022529,
-0.0051722629,
-0.0253129881,
0.008653271,
-0.0030864503,
0.000249487,
0.0612321422,
0.0047683129,
-0.0194293,
0.0439624675,
-0.0313873217,
-0.0288829636,
0.0636689886,
0.0282321833,
0.0768960714,
0.0786391124,
-0.024503421,
0.0065753008,
0.0011558806,
0.0012277582,
-0.0157195684,
0.0587730445,
0.0095537649,
-0.053576719,
-0.0249326862,
-0.005662547,
-0.0220333468,
0.0368185453,
0.0317944139,
0.0049769222,
-0.0072189542,
0.0227331836,
-0.0110107539,
-0.0432254337,
-0.0092561906,
0.052212961,
-0.0627538711,
-0.0413841754,
0.0213165656,
-0.0123196896,
0.0043413579,
-0.0612397268,
0.018664524,
0.015603113,
-0.0274939761,
0.0408150665,
0.0366251245,
0.0298618954,
0.0163450185,
-0.0015748221,
0.005597434,
0.0170843676,
0.0370908938,
-0.0325103141,
-0.0007877371,
-0.007008316,
-0.036659155,
-0.0529388562,
0.0147633702,
-0.0233597346,
-0.0402034186,
0.006835945,
-0.0693001747,
-0.1042453796,
0.0288636517,
-0.0505660512,
0.0195166022,
-0.0063498449,
-0.005858127,
-0.0001757545,
-0.0307075847,
0.0055217426,
0.0195445698,
-0.0023483045,
-0.0257894658,
0.0193016082,
0.0326270647,
-0.0215744488,
-0.051099766,
0.0271142051,
-0.0180216152,
-0.001423307,
-0.0125249494,
0.0065685334,
-0.0427016355,
-0.006369316,
0.0087723918,
0.0751648173,
-0.0622252338,
0.0211979765,
0.0155727118,
0.003007144,
-0.0258622393,
-0.0112457052,
0.0002610099,
-0.056175001,
-0.0002060768,
0.0463084355,
-0.0142083736,
-0.04332624,
0.0000129836,
0.090970628,
-0.0364693888,
0.0010124937,
-0.0246716142,
-0.0464331843,
-0.0135013964,
-0.0327626206,
-0.0199931636,
-0.0474336557,
-0.0204801243,
-0.0163936187,
-0.0117251575,
-0.0930386558,
0.0288134832,
0.0305508617,
-0.0280445199,
0.0342589766,
-0.0582966916,
-0.0586850196,
0.0084900633,
0.0029091237,
0.0069142682,
0.0746014118,
0.0275667049,
0.0926457271,
-0.0129913632,
-0.0217496846,
-0.0079173595,
0.0249188412,
0.0290980712,
0.0273086205,
-0.0446985587,
-0.0343173482,
0.0032017152,
0.0231908634,
0.0582129434,
0.0913023949,
-0.0299249478,
-0.001354613,
0.0735258907,
-0.0215648059,
0.0082339477,
0.0598671027,
0.0496148653,
0.0301171113,
-0.0506453551,
0.0329950191,
-0.0341889709,
-0.01381322,
0.0029751868,
-0.0057823216,
0.0587181263,
0.0620011017,
0.0038433045,
-0.0510594808,
0.0311318357,
-0.0145203052,
0.0397076644,
-0.0378744006,
0.0138680255,
0.065161787,
-0.0948983803,
0.0042914306,
0.0402726382,
-0.0589737333,
0.009907986,
-0.0406871736,
0.0335120559,
0.0812278464,
0.0876639262,
0.0166454799,
-0.0038251148,
-0.0268315542,
-0.0404242426,
0.0363001451,
-0.020175362,
0.002220572,
0.0295801349,
-0.054925032,
-0.0226860046,
-0.0135986041,
0.0053018425,
0.0092648743,
-0.0086995875,
0.0173319988,
0.0092989663,
-0.003416768,
-0.0802864805,
0.0374030285,
0.0140679944,
-0.0654982254,
0.0431260392,
0.0128329974,
0.0098755695,
-0.0012021337,
-0.0362150893,
0.0184993707,
0.0171709042,
-0.0466401726,
-0.0166077726,
0.012116408,
-0.0403639302,
-0.057221666,
-0.0099067101,
-0.0439661257,
-0.0037436211,
0.052707281,
-0.0144235231,
-0.0297162402,
0.003975579,
-0.0734990388,
0.0285904873,
-0.0149216382,
0.0108193262,
0.0029034428,
0.0418726355,
-0.0173909385,
0.0545931906,
-0.0054961182,
-0.01620874,
0.011705799,
0.0188819785,
0.0025463169,
-0.0483862795,
-0.0158727746,
-0.0463028438,
-0.004007942,
0.0075786575,
0.0472948588,
0.040930368,
-0.0146282474,
-0.0030010906,
-0.0558744371,
0.0114739016,
-0.0182103887,
0.0032297422,
0.025455296,
0.0116430772,
0.001839105,
0.0171187855,
-0.0326804779,
-0.0274114739,
0.0154187735,
0.0163518507,
0.0058206297,
-0.0117371241,
-0.0216349792,
0.0059264665,
0.0141590582,
-0.0055229217,
0.0689232498,
0.0135372374,
-0.0437895469,
-0.0081970887,
0.0464253984,
0.0068423455,
0.0006627603,
0.0429279692,
-0.066450119,
0.0134027414,
0.0174895916,
0.0497075059,
0.0600038692,
0.0461177118,
0.0349549986,
0.035300117,
0.0025776161,
-0.0323184319,
0.0070651243,
-0.0221051499,
0.0115261637,
0.0117709953,
-0.0793525949,
0.0507694185,
0.0694359392,
0.0384227782,
0.0074220519,
-0.0566174872,
0.0529173389,
-0.0032634865,
-0.0522138141,
0.0369910523,
-0.0168904681,
-0.0151155917,
-0.0159488488,
-0.031960357,
-0.0594618805,
0.0555879399,
-0.0142773362,
0.0313221142,
-0.0407355241,
0.0108633414,
0.0276463069,
-0.011511026,
-0.0000869,
0.0564716384,
0.0641499534,
-0.0079274578,
0.0027811825,
0.0154817225,
0.0301219951,
-0.023977533,
-0.0266235471,
-0.0412595794,
-0.0173119307,
0.0049507306,
-0.044710923,
-0.0380216204,
-0.0328477956,
0.0393945128,
-0.0152241644,
0.0655417517,
-0.0269384775,
-0.0017822945,
0.0076057245,
-0.0177750643,
-0.0017281323,
-0.0258202124,
-0.0046471874,
0.0001075467,
0.0274641681,
0.052429188,
-0.0599635318,
0.0071066385,
-0.0089852642,
0.038958367,
0.1097410694,
-0.0151911583,
0.0096434848,
-0.027414782,
0.0122154988,
0.0145229511,
0.028463956,
-0.0327256806,
0.026140403,
0.0171646755,
-0.030330684,
-0.0386492983,
0.0656482503,
0.0135224247,
-0.029734008,
0.0400629677,
0.027164232,
0.0661658645,
-0.0103499889,
0.0028174678,
-0.1006721109,
-0.0386833362,
0.0041898964,
0.0498115048,
-0.06306196,
-0.0176503249,
-0.0140111363,
-0.0799218118,
0.0263886433,
0.0295537692,
-0.0062198988,
-0.017281726,
-0.0089599434,
-0.0348690562,
-0.0204051565,
0.0062142424,
-0.0160067994,
0.0155437551,
0.005127097,
0.0293534491,
-0.0117560476,
-0.0181337651,
-0.0553667918,
-0.0174535736,
0.0269740745,
0.0592451133,
0.0335475467,
0.0031440826,
-0.0048377346,
-0.0225323103,
-0.0342970192,
-0.0211671256,
-0.0268810969,
0.0605093613,
-0.0070409244,
-0.0154478168,
-0.0487581231,
0.0511379316,
-0.0159790087,
-0.024010485,
-0.0006021985,
0.0447287075,
-0.0053102239,
-0.0414607637,
-0.0222090408,
-0.0033055337,
0.0466924943,
0.0819064602,
0.0372146294,
-0.0695401207,
-0.0678119734,
-0.0618857183,
0.007855935,
-0.0941753909,
-0.0107658915,
-0.0453902408,
-0.039118275,
-0.0665550902,
-0.1039808914,
-0.0032934686,
0.0063113053,
0.0462348424,
-0.0111788381,
-0.0160099771,
-0.0512503535,
-0.0259483494,
-0.0418856628,
0.0177024528,
0.0172622614,
0.010623401,
-0.0589160547,
-0.0343962125,
-0.0154323466,
0.0002379096,
-0.0081181228,
0.1073945165,
-0.0461527072,
-0.0701242983,
0.0414115675,
0.0631811246,
0.0169694852,
0.0256765708,
-0.0129162967,
-0.0411775187,
0.0724228397,
0.104244709,
-0.0200385731,
0.0091860071,
0.0433371589,
-0.0248566493,
0.0047920803,
0.0134790745,
-0.0246294271,
0.0058679418,
0.057735119,
0.0268427171,
-0.0389024206,
0.0334336981,
0.0399617702,
0.0250680149,
0.0044036242,
-0.074176982,
-0.0001894258,
-0.0049571125,
0.0047231014,
-0.0258503892,
-0.0293695629,
-0.0338461958,
0.0380273871,
0.0248140916,
0.005139119,
-0.0154130524,
0.0369775705,
-0.0191971641,
0.0148000261,
-0.0371083096,
-0.0100110294,
0.0205543824,
0.0294377208,
0.0723634884,
-0.0112130754,
-0.0119595164,
0.0275665112,
-0.0077128038,
0.0089966413,
-0.0337016396,
0.0008682249,
0.0244061872,
0.0124600166,
-0.0042681969,
0.0614190251,
0.014665354,
0.0109660635,
-0.0806339085,
-0.0181798022,
0.0197787229,
0.0095212199,
0.0440410189,
-0.0431864969,
0.0049372935,
-0.0098002683,
0.0286814794,
-0.0025203375,
-0.0483032763,
-0.0285165831,
-0.0176563598,
-0.0433949791,
-0.0446642861,
0.1007883474,
0.0384685658,
0.0553321466,
-0.0039162533,
-0.0077747111,
-0.036705371,
-0.0345996805,
0.0151776597,
0.0098653361,
-0.0134297945,
-0.0084605841,
-0.0406542234,
-0.078861475,
0.0181340482,
0.0004404068,
0.0285850298,
0.0054853298,
0.0319742858,
-0.0053188056,
-0.0135347052,
-0.024397241,
-0.0178347826,
0.0406974442,
0.0280835833,
-0.035568729,
-0.0356690623,
-6.390309083e-33,
-0.007161147,
-0.0316106007,
-0.0317216553,
-0.0464634039,
0.0187806226,
-0.0132189784,
-0.0353723206,
-0.0263001341,
0.0498004407,
0.0271390937,
0.0048701679,
-0.0222465359,
0.0108735571,
0.0322479494,
-0.0410857871,
0.0260247663,
0.0614523217,
-0.0170774721,
-0.0525740124,
0.0594330467,
0.0647317916,
0.0422193334,
0.0017687638,
-0.0456805117,
-0.0337681808,
-0.0177258924,
-0.0439327098,
-0.0241894722,
-0.0066242106,
0.0219200384,
-0.020565927,
0.0350608602,
0.0098649617,
-0.0342272632,
-0.0215885174,
0.0397154652,
-0.0434135981,
-0.0175700374,
0.0220127068,
-0.0168123096,
-0.054793559,
-0.0735314041,
0.0650687292,
0.0212811157,
-0.0082608378,
0.0180747211,
-0.0005545904,
-0.023431519,
-0.0041901451,
-0.0612819456,
-0.0509977378,
0.0245076492,
-0.0144091016,
-0.0047636023,
0.0061933352,
-0.0037676494,
-0.0033700555,
0.0005701447,
-0.0307571944,
0.0043488271,
0.0214297082,
0.0260153804,
0.0433904789,
0.0282460637,
0.0182284471,
0.07151144,
0.0082872463,
0.0399377197,
0.0093108146,
0.0584880486,
0.0164712165,
0.0205841791,
0.0256876685,
0.036849115,
0.0589820482,
-0.0483209789,
-0.043460004,
0.0442369096,
-0.0030364122,
0.0036872979,
0.0164171811,
0.0038378898,
0.0052439682,
-0.0457845852,
-0.0485659949,
-0.0399487019,
-0.0088285645,
-0.0226000585,
0.0297675263,
0.0184470918,
-0.0638501793,
-0.0218409859,
-0.0136336926,
0.0000476592,
0.0203157943,
0.0386266522,
-0.0268434118,
-0.0016936221,
-0.021038577,
0.0003063317,
-0.0114409337,
-0.0133867273,
0.0553680994,
-0.0178544167,
0.0300229285,
0.0079635549,
0.029359797,
0.0192509629,
-0.0742717609,
0.0097973067,
-0.0479188636,
0.0540129058,
0.0499601476,
0.0158118922,
0.0020210075,
0.0005938845,
-0.0009672016,
-0.0059499969,
0.03931766,
0.0421099626,
-0.0299891531,
-0.0240126494,
0.0135748032,
0.0325504243,
-0.0317032076,
-0.0167215448,
-0.0103526972,
0.0019631349,
0.0356028527,
-0.1027537584,
-0.0282396991,
-0.0029573743,
2.958e-7,
0.020723436,
0.0183014441,
0.0581238046,
0.0032729404,
0.0181387905,
0.0385786183,
0.0402952582,
0.0394764096,
-0.0298059918,
-0.0065559871,
-0.0234061442,
-0.0025894397,
0.0360243469,
0.0391477272,
-0.0704461932,
0.0743300542,
-0.0789729804,
0.0055287275,
-0.0682389066,
-0.0233022142,
0.0395773314,
0.070205465,
-0.0104641523,
-0.0433061905,
0.0387458205,
0.0093027093,
0.0261128843,
-0.0035330197,
-0.0140227526,
0.0116733145,
0.0403680466,
-0.0358998552,
-0.0039339866,
-0.0099399174,
-0.0304948576,
-0.049756635,
-0.017846847,
0.0436996929,
0.0098666167,
-0.0317889489,
0.0406835079,
-0.0387573913,
0.0046301219,
-0.0000537125,
0.0752311274,
0.0187615063,
-0.0174919665,
-0.0478058234,
-0.0627206489,
-0.0058238828,
-0.000183498,
-0.0567337982,
-0.0431052558,
0.0297407191,
0.0065845544,
0.0300963651,
-0.0081862109,
-0.035742376,
-0.0440912545,
-0.0394299924,
-0.0408318527,
-0.067223385,
-0.0640800372,
0.0589501448,
0.0192294624,
-0.0608836301,
0.0266875569,
3.225328287e-34,
0.0296762306,
-0.0396145247,
-0.0009620143,
0.0003003308,
0.0404628478,
-0.0061033079,
0.0201075505,
0.0196114108,
0.0250819307,
-0.0464256033,
-0.0098994412
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06945v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06945v1 | Knowledge-Centric Templatic Views of Documents | 2024-01-13T01:22:15 | 2024-01-13T01:22:15 | Isabel Cachola, Silviu Cucerzan, Allen Herring, Vuksan Mijovic, Erik Oveson, Sujay Kumar Jauhar | cs.CL | cs.CL | Authors seeking to communicate with broader audiences often compose their
ideas about the same underlying knowledge in different documents and formats --
for example, as slide decks, newsletters, reports, brochures, etc. Prior work
in document generation has generally considered the creation of each separate
format to be different a task, developing independent methods for generation
and evaluation. This approach is suboptimal for the advancement of AI-supported
content authoring from both research and application perspectives because it
leads to fragmented learning processes, redundancy in models and methods, and
disjointed evaluation. Thus, in our work, we consider each of these documents
to be templatic views of the same underlying knowledge, and we aim to unify the
generation and evaluation of these templatic views of documents. We begin by
introducing an LLM-powered method to extract the most important information
from an input document and represent this information in a structured format.
We show that this unified representation can be used to generate multiple
templatic views with no supervision and with very little guidance, improving
over strong baselines. We additionally introduce a unified evaluation method
that is template agnostic, and can be adapted to building document generators
for heterogeneous downstream applications. Finally, we conduct a human
evaluation, which shows that humans prefer 82% of the downstream documents
generated with our method. Furthermore, the newly proposed evaluation metric
correlates more highly with human judgement than prior metrics, while providing
a unified evaluation method. | [
0.0365304016,
-0.0198321082,
0.0104842475,
-0.0196581613,
-0.0286244899,
0.0352013297,
-0.0328226611,
0.0165773351,
0.0243045893,
-0.054227218,
-0.0615477972,
0.0098401597,
-0.0127802212,
0.042129267,
-0.0098273009,
-0.1013452932,
-0.0304850936,
0.0018096942,
0.0286514238,
0.0076510711,
0.0278301369,
0.0273006354,
0.0026170537,
0.0061460836,
-0.0132095739,
-0.0269822609,
-0.0360732153,
0.0109890206,
0.0216921214,
-0.0203760099,
0.0003849978,
0.0197068322,
0.0373959541,
-0.0081056068,
0.0000022223,
-0.0042416076,
0.0050831973,
-0.0000377261,
0.0215657428,
-0.0053518866,
0.0648640394,
-0.0035005289,
0.0166772697,
-0.022342898,
-0.0550979525,
0.0144381477,
0.0003767094,
0.0577704459,
0.0310542416,
0.0606519766,
-0.0312453657,
-0.0173524432,
0.0076921773,
0.0055109491,
0.0568217076,
0.0034118628,
-0.0448698141,
0.0290761366,
0.0467460752,
0.0094075454,
0.0422506891,
0.0204712022,
0.0126415435,
-0.0472057201,
0.0348224677,
0.0336326323,
0.0327936709,
-0.0276053939,
-0.0161678363,
0.0610581897,
0.0357062891,
-0.0076389662,
0.053839352,
-0.0233460777,
0.0124184173,
0.026337618,
-0.0819168091,
0.0335452743,
-0.0147049241,
-0.0044366913,
0.0473431312,
0.039565865,
0.0126866018,
0.0198066812,
0.00930457,
0.0252420958,
-0.012289172,
-0.017160492,
-0.0006654445,
0.0146550601,
0.0533660389,
-0.0953393057,
-0.0114993481,
0.0534242876,
0.0058681299,
-0.0106730564,
-0.0379120782,
-0.0357596986,
0.0364840254,
-0.0647552609,
0.0493013263,
-0.0039657801,
0.0089541627,
0.0420793742,
-0.0186216421,
-0.0022164814,
-0.0262126923,
0.0036159162,
-0.022458883,
0.0153128803,
-0.0406310819,
-0.0039945869,
0.0248958673,
0.0739204958,
-0.0286468286,
-0.0345350802,
-0.0274470542,
0.0713725686,
-0.0241654981,
0.0454074331,
-0.0033854849,
0.0418759808,
-0.05429212,
-0.0027234389,
-0.0042390777,
0.0072533032,
-0.0268925093,
0.0046956688,
0.0114412131,
-0.0084687332,
0.0450721756,
0.0584675558,
0.0011865573,
0.0295245722,
-0.0212414823,
0.0481017232,
-0.024473682,
0.0097165983,
-0.0659376904,
-0.0667889938,
0.0370865576,
-0.0372229777,
0.0226997025,
-0.0794125721,
0.0203917157,
0.0345317721,
-0.025071891,
-0.0497303233,
-0.0157065801,
-0.0094014704,
-0.0108640501,
0.0004138056,
-0.0082186656,
0.0055591455,
0.0781566948,
0.030852735,
-0.0291099027,
0.058099322,
0.0484487675,
0.0879278332,
0.0281477813,
0.0365996808,
0.0394447446,
-0.0032344295,
0.0000462168,
0.0120460987,
0.0189834796,
0.0212671757,
-0.0310855992,
0.0139918514,
-0.0307658035,
0.0301780924,
-0.0330712497,
0.0758099407,
0.0556081571,
0.0003423978,
0.020714391,
0.0344392397,
0.0755835399,
0.0259709042,
0.0136867473,
0.0453075022,
0.0177900232,
0.0786657333,
0.0093639651,
0.0231503397,
0.0135386689,
-0.0172186308,
-0.0340984128,
-0.0742939636,
-0.007455593,
-0.0090712495,
-0.0009610532,
-0.0180581193,
-0.0005922724,
0.0157852322,
-0.0505285859,
0.0266318768,
-0.0096960953,
-0.0685156658,
0.0178935882,
0.0366732031,
0.0438218489,
0.0726985186,
0.0417012572,
-0.0205420684,
-0.0153782871,
-0.0196382273,
0.0050748023,
0.048445031,
0.0864274278,
-0.0418164544,
-0.0209398493,
-0.0715649351,
-0.0209176429,
-0.068871513,
-0.0079168761,
0.0474912226,
-0.0086787315,
0.0175601486,
0.0464077778,
-0.0455609895,
-0.0621480308,
0.0457288437,
-0.0421490707,
-0.0260997843,
0.008696327,
0.0116763152,
0.0409667976,
0.0373641849,
-0.0103618372,
0.0149246566,
0.0311811119,
-0.0238894597,
-0.0248571094,
0.0271001402,
-0.0434477329,
0.0143770296,
-0.0115380418,
-0.0838416889,
-0.0063723037,
-0.0367606543,
-0.0332652666,
-0.0535845049,
0.0200370438,
-0.0142126521,
0.0184246972,
-0.0216007102,
-0.0140465004,
0.0342055373,
-0.0368102342,
-0.0084638195,
0.0634952858,
0.004326473,
-0.0166756175,
0.0700123683,
-0.0489112213,
0.0018182192,
-0.0123814661,
0.0251705199,
0.012521171,
0.0209642034,
-0.0164840613,
0.0385502614,
0.0207366925,
-0.0108847152,
-0.0553070381,
-0.1092136204,
-0.0328776464,
-0.0175243355,
0.0133595476,
0.042070616,
-0.0077560539,
-0.0022103444,
0.0155548006,
-0.066407986,
-0.0282625649,
0.0042292653,
-0.0177414957,
0.0395128578,
0.0417047441,
0.045337379,
-0.0225209277,
0.02881933,
0.0056663356,
0.0284413956,
0.0864114016,
-0.0200811643,
-0.056250453,
0.0296592526,
-0.0259107407,
-0.0342209749,
0.0030656867,
0.0274723712,
0.0284326877,
-0.0195596833,
0.0227859933,
0.0250466,
0.0127197187,
0.0633002073,
0.035513293,
0.0029142878,
-0.0651690438,
0.0013429351,
-0.0321496129,
0.0699438229,
0.0046031447,
-0.0820832923,
0.0593043119,
-0.0012644469,
0.023663532,
0.026456831,
-0.0463959873,
0.0248737019,
-0.0045650029,
-0.0330606215,
-0.0158914961,
-0.0550729781,
0.0073233866,
0.0426373035,
0.0022481107,
-0.040729925,
0.0391646959,
-0.0236583557,
0.0330318436,
-0.0307699516,
0.0051472243,
-0.05627748,
0.0329297185,
-0.0394842625,
0.023119498,
-0.0299946871,
0.0155169135,
-0.052756276,
-0.0287685916,
0.0429439768,
-0.0056496826,
-0.0068711736,
-0.0546042211,
-0.0236926395,
0.0025918984,
-0.0211800281,
-0.0128336493,
0.0015165082,
0.0204424914,
0.0260315984,
0.0433849692,
-0.0067733401,
-0.0466108173,
-0.0152134178,
0.0596611127,
0.0345394611,
0.0043418319,
-0.0276121385,
-0.005962092,
0.0477489494,
0.0144008091,
-0.0485272631,
-0.004753334,
-0.0619032457,
-0.0052275285,
0.0534180291,
0.0157189909,
0.015326553,
-0.0062020048,
-0.0098061394,
0.0032742198,
-0.05359089,
-0.0283466373,
0.0065957601,
0.0109898234,
-0.0264128018,
0.0190476179,
0.105643861,
0.0477041379,
-0.0619893968,
-0.012286731,
-0.0364300087,
0.0252734888,
-0.000334863,
0.0487423278,
-0.0672693178,
0.029857764,
-0.0030010899,
0.0679021031,
-0.0197940897,
-0.0243086349,
-0.0190739091,
-0.0185447671,
0.0524307974,
0.0175669622,
0.0315357968,
0.0351901464,
-0.0275325757,
-0.0108661791,
0.0405014381,
-0.0819827765,
0.015650345,
-0.025750028,
0.0137099931,
0.0039021573,
-0.0579954386,
-0.0313106254,
-0.0202161763,
0.0028164408,
-0.0031383112,
0.0446776338,
0.0686454698,
-0.0009239827,
-0.0537395813,
-0.0030512137,
0.0141083905,
0.026474148,
-0.0243864954,
0.0077485479,
-0.0183034092,
0.0322152562,
-0.0226730872,
0.0487489589,
-0.0056404169,
-0.0219257716,
0.026447976,
0.025335541,
-0.057409659,
-0.031263873,
-0.0459607691,
0.0010392455,
0.0308826733,
0.055156108,
0.031437885,
-0.0262621008,
-0.0458112173,
-0.0339065567,
0.0301559549,
-0.0489191562,
0.0130482456,
-0.0241243541,
-0.0563045144,
-0.0009861735,
-0.1068010703,
-0.0360871889,
-0.0039747008,
0.0237747859,
0.0333849005,
-0.0386618003,
-0.0218993574,
-0.0482643582,
-0.0353154689,
-0.040713191,
0.0285823233,
-0.0207607672,
-0.0533438101,
-0.0471837409,
0.0049275523,
-0.0476362631,
0.0065160072,
0.0299104061,
-0.0295077004,
-0.0406558774,
0.0071894866,
0.0393720232,
0.0212237388,
0.0376810431,
0.0385854952,
-0.0353993773,
0.0972427502,
0.0657853559,
-0.0339291804,
0.0190644134,
0.018587403,
0.0240613334,
-0.0064425101,
-0.003534673,
-0.1012561917,
0.0114243049,
0.009104589,
0.0121920193,
0.0071057021,
0.0136884227,
-0.0068212715,
0.0249579567,
-0.0730901137,
-0.0501796864,
0.0154405255,
-0.0301648024,
-0.0107485559,
-0.0277442932,
-0.0319449529,
-0.0358193703,
0.0304162838,
-0.0175546426,
0.0173294656,
0.0034996578,
0.0851381868,
-0.023374334,
0.0398826562,
-0.0613303073,
0.038690336,
-0.0077896565,
0.0028673941,
-0.0218243189,
-0.012687007,
-0.0666719377,
0.055886358,
-0.0599055439,
0.0234080199,
0.0144248176,
0.043269176,
0.0265755728,
0.010675611,
-0.0032961646,
0.0419516005,
-0.0756288245,
-0.0748381689,
-0.048768796,
0.0329159647,
0.0049141231,
0.012010606,
0.0453431383,
-0.0878658816,
0.0095977727,
0.0105939349,
0.0392257571,
0.0336050354,
-0.0323482342,
-0.0358447582,
0.012276493,
-0.0031585936,
-0.0230573155,
0.0908365771,
-0.0376125611,
-0.0110511603,
-0.0384275652,
-0.0405860879,
-0.0751268268,
-0.0188569017,
0.0565397665,
0.0051521445,
0.0023517306,
-0.0448271781,
-0.057868015,
-0.0115833823,
0.0656702667,
0.0359316878,
-0.0087644849,
-0.0223003216,
0.046923209,
0.0591047704,
0.0089812065,
0.0078123296,
-0.0570139103,
0.0200783927,
-0.0401631296,
-0.0323203988,
-0.0122033525,
-6.270224253e-33,
-0.0123656718,
-0.034613058,
-0.0087481402,
0.033164151,
0.0159758143,
0.0057307058,
-0.0352680273,
-0.0150955906,
0.0450927094,
0.0234020241,
-0.0056566941,
-0.0363153815,
0.0089134425,
-0.017817894,
0.0117999408,
0.0203349814,
0.0498860665,
-0.0035854564,
-0.0513014756,
0.052947294,
0.0493132919,
-0.0034321537,
0.0072112181,
-0.0990709737,
0.0728611797,
-0.0394734591,
-0.0243554916,
-0.0510777049,
0.0368363298,
0.0316979177,
0.0073284656,
-0.0195032991,
0.0229525324,
-0.019237265,
-0.0234253332,
0.0098012406,
-0.0299847368,
-0.0424652398,
0.0319311842,
-0.0248666517,
-0.0655164942,
-0.0540396646,
0.0516247228,
-0.0104708476,
-0.0202493723,
0.0059578484,
0.0571345575,
0.0132306349,
-0.0015871776,
-0.0936117992,
-0.0227861349,
0.0152462795,
-0.0341895185,
0.002279669,
0.0073466101,
0.0486554131,
0.0002605016,
0.0091101071,
-0.0916148052,
0.0400964506,
0.0205601528,
-0.0017828479,
0.0750474483,
-0.047572121,
0.0143232131,
0.0359156653,
-0.012940147,
0.0370342806,
-0.031184122,
-0.0208018199,
-0.0317452215,
0.0680400729,
0.0149395233,
0.0335820392,
-0.0051788618,
0.0033346326,
-0.0183672123,
0.1095267758,
0.0059802285,
0.0057495381,
0.0161130298,
-0.004291221,
-0.0216835923,
-0.0115740038,
-0.021186268,
-0.0152779119,
-0.0038107636,
-0.0300969929,
0.0051304735,
0.0117878392,
-0.0135232992,
-0.0399054959,
0.0018611773,
-0.0117060142,
0.0019932778,
0.0183172449,
-0.0415179916,
0.041499082,
0.0146261128,
-0.0602465421,
-0.0332877114,
-0.0299167205,
0.0171297211,
0.0357138366,
0.0142480331,
0.0232496634,
0.037860021,
0.0424211435,
-0.0272444431,
-0.0087839998,
-0.0059165955,
0.0304431524,
0.0159275308,
-0.0442541242,
0.0066141817,
-0.0104690976,
-0.0228787605,
-0.0139799807,
-0.0087454356,
0.0157088302,
0.0005357506,
-0.024718808,
0.0066025807,
0.0350894742,
-0.0308233537,
-0.0138496831,
-0.0174315795,
-0.0059734494,
0.0452646539,
-0.0189523734,
-0.0185527969,
0.0109224226,
2.934e-7,
0.0257177893,
0.0128360223,
0.0108181946,
0.0046334597,
0.0287696365,
0.0378786139,
0.0116687892,
0.0314506814,
-0.0411342978,
-0.0136284679,
0.0463994555,
0.0131082647,
0.0402612686,
0.0542678311,
-0.111025095,
-0.0057549533,
-0.0632329136,
-0.0346382298,
-0.0416372754,
-0.0055432385,
0.0582600795,
-0.0588243827,
-0.0142011419,
-0.0252792649,
-0.0070645018,
0.0183391329,
0.0788497403,
-0.0313188508,
0.0305647068,
0.0217237212,
0.06222919,
-0.0295623131,
-0.0147386594,
-0.0054661743,
-0.0337064154,
-0.0227965433,
-0.0121006994,
0.0270404629,
0.0274237599,
-0.0044042389,
0.0333793126,
-0.002467107,
0.0295244902,
-0.0813300014,
0.0211463869,
-0.0383496173,
-0.0263448674,
-0.018038189,
-0.0430375263,
0.0038111359,
-0.0117523726,
-0.0167186707,
0.0204516351,
0.0500336662,
-0.0151040833,
-0.0239022952,
-0.0050364127,
-0.0331634395,
-0.0241056681,
-0.0207122024,
-0.0150598856,
0.0128496075,
-0.0552806109,
0.0153355459,
-0.0064538005,
-0.0425280221,
0.0046923738,
2.418904495e-34,
0.0209197365,
0.0001348926,
-0.0415926687,
0.0035656756,
0.0499256849,
0.0209536683,
0.0005425766,
0.0246722512,
0.018953545,
-0.0393604413,
-0.0062670996
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06935v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06935v1 | MiTTenS: A Dataset for Evaluating Misgendering in Translation | 2024-01-13T00:08:23 | 2024-01-13T00:08:23 | Kevin Robinson, Sneha Kudugunta, Romina Stella, Sunipa Dev, Jasmijn Bastings | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | Misgendering is the act of referring to someone in a way that does not
reflect their gender identity. Translation systems, including foundation models
capable of translation, can produce errors that result in misgendering harms.
To measure the extent of such potential harms when translating into and out of
English, we introduce a dataset, MiTTenS, covering 26 languages from a variety
of language families and scripts, including several traditionally
underpresented in digital resources. The dataset is constructed with
handcrafted passages that target known failure patterns, longer synthetically
generated passages, and natural passages sourced from multiple domains. We
demonstrate the usefulness of the dataset by evaluating both dedicated neural
machine translation systems and foundation models, and show that all systems
exhibit errors resulting in misgendering harms, even in high resource
languages. | [
0.0292589068,
0.0590931028,
-0.0367054455,
0.0414488427,
0.0094805639,
0.0271597132,
0.0646878183,
0.0003793679,
-0.0114552183,
-0.0109381601,
-0.0013771926,
-0.054215502,
0.0748551562,
-0.0147601534,
0.0496687107,
-0.0184106249,
0.0289575979,
0.0224181265,
-0.0239709206,
-0.0213872958,
0.0179566946,
0.058649037,
0.0382999815,
0.0599185117,
-0.0129988026,
-0.0391817875,
0.0400654115,
0.07838016,
0.0246845987,
-0.0013043849,
0.041036468,
0.0190444719,
-0.0046583056,
0.0938855186,
0.0000016536,
-0.0600033291,
0.0178669561,
0.0184246339,
-0.0014571655,
0.0019175332,
0.0518266335,
-0.0550354421,
-0.0368864946,
0.0130758891,
0.0110838478,
-0.0175788328,
0.0851827264,
0.0262129456,
0.0644063428,
0.0476056412,
-0.0100284265,
-0.0173463318,
-0.0475316234,
-0.0445225239,
-0.0013654121,
-0.0148413023,
0.0164704975,
-0.0294774212,
-0.0777392536,
-0.0070695966,
-0.0358449481,
0.0310132783,
0.0078878645,
-0.0159888826,
-0.0324803106,
-0.0036995641,
-0.0079971841,
-0.0527726859,
0.0323186591,
0.0870107338,
-0.0239724293,
-0.0059659998,
-0.0066601168,
-0.0067525022,
-0.0115006473,
0.0043748342,
0.0050094114,
0.0235513113,
-0.0277820732,
-0.0088106683,
-0.0072778324,
-0.010144054,
0.0429645032,
0.0364374071,
-0.0085151596,
0.0146615319,
0.0315559879,
-0.0379907452,
-0.0001552105,
0.001006081,
0.0155066643,
-0.0432307459,
0.0453371555,
-0.0214325078,
0.0077735796,
0.0216943007,
-0.0417905152,
-0.0782482177,
0.0326199196,
-0.0565159097,
0.0418500379,
0.0534931011,
-0.0165073257,
0.0197340958,
-0.0179270487,
0.0419182628,
-0.0023313612,
0.0091667483,
-0.0350441374,
-0.0147310169,
0.0284687076,
0.0089857774,
-0.0356752798,
-0.0438174419,
-0.0515997484,
0.057272248,
-0.035675332,
-0.0149136148,
-0.0226300582,
0.0108447568,
0.0238494761,
0.0131155588,
-0.0636269972,
-0.0056209392,
-0.0117281666,
-0.0029980089,
-0.0484605581,
0.0056200512,
-0.0311314128,
-0.0557398535,
-0.0013735888,
-0.0102388998,
-0.0327363759,
-0.0509123132,
0.0110575166,
0.0615855791,
0.0201261975,
-0.038191881,
-0.0049609086,
-0.0176616143,
-0.0350344554,
-0.0323246196,
-0.0062642819,
-0.0450503156,
0.0539965853,
-0.0101860613,
0.0069421451,
-0.0893154293,
0.0141445482,
0.0156479571,
-0.027228862,
0.0741387829,
0.0202799011,
-0.0066774553,
0.048444394,
0.0117921522,
-0.0285867881,
0.0715577453,
0.067271851,
0.0158702023,
0.0426510349,
0.0024959256,
-0.0143466601,
0.0606212765,
0.0329020098,
0.016043745,
-0.0219046324,
0.011166743,
0.0041246945,
0.0694437176,
0.0618138798,
0.0344109349,
0.0045767524,
-0.0487626642,
0.0454848856,
0.0576624461,
-0.0102698486,
0.090263702,
0.0408021137,
0.0061723865,
-0.0106638772,
-0.0169471148,
-0.0507027283,
-0.0272918828,
0.0308268797,
-0.0405499525,
-0.030730458,
0.0662575588,
-0.0186178945,
-0.0284932945,
-0.002868508,
0.0152254878,
0.0401311219,
-0.0360494964,
0.0321022011,
0.0639623106,
-0.017205283,
0.04396924,
-0.0008339269,
-0.0654686168,
0.0229096487,
0.0030848344,
-0.0206120722,
0.0724665076,
0.061334461,
-0.0285788383,
-0.0247240886,
-0.04462751,
-0.0198229719,
0.027773289,
0.0349620283,
-0.0026853697,
0.0626947358,
-0.0391338281,
0.013291073,
0.0536641628,
0.0250999909,
0.0439649038,
0.0093056699,
0.0470040515,
0.0294529907,
-0.0411518179,
-0.0775611922,
0.0520670749,
-0.052957356,
-0.0405184776,
0.0235317368,
0.0100961514,
0.0097291451,
0.0145036085,
-0.0573963635,
-0.042294573,
0.0073460788,
-0.0243964493,
-0.0219109692,
0.0441875271,
-0.0436308458,
-0.0105625745,
0.0277675986,
-0.0845153853,
-0.0565259047,
0.0450431518,
-0.0522862561,
-0.0223359689,
0.0322932936,
-0.0430854522,
-0.022058446,
-0.0361000039,
0.0035426931,
-0.015329144,
0.0286104959,
-0.0146299796,
0.0017726225,
-0.0149959512,
0.0137341013,
-0.0041784979,
-0.0339358672,
-0.0076335254,
-0.0312158223,
-0.0533178337,
0.0305745061,
-0.0169840846,
0.0262175072,
0.0002676726,
0.0350304432,
-0.0055045825,
-0.0148131829,
-0.0242650118,
-0.0136494832,
-0.0009244211,
0.0057903323,
0.0091509195,
0.0420155898,
-0.0181073472,
0.0107153459,
0.0024510117,
-0.0246821865,
0.0226591583,
0.0027169604,
0.0224827677,
-0.0249998588,
0.0042631915,
-0.0231570583,
-0.0193086583,
-0.0243459493,
0.057222452,
0.028408099,
-0.0035305568,
-0.0643791184,
0.0145617183,
-0.0322009437,
0.0067842184,
0.0043797097,
-0.0746446773,
0.0066852542,
0.0250870548,
0.0257211812,
0.0374586359,
-0.0070900884,
0.0339744911,
0.02725555,
-0.025507981,
-0.0284329634,
-0.0084628593,
0.0140790381,
-0.0077134818,
0.014482378,
-0.0787978172,
-0.0267365724,
0.0058527226,
0.0228376854,
-0.0307068955,
-0.0602398925,
0.0343600065,
-0.0364192165,
-0.0446823537,
-0.0054883431,
-0.026669018,
0.0046736193,
0.0539498217,
-0.0323493592,
-0.0059292614,
0.0609618463,
-0.0229772329,
-0.0363247357,
-0.0081980675,
0.0241905786,
-0.0264555234,
0.0381563939,
-0.0250987522,
0.0569990724,
0.01657179,
-0.0487009548,
-0.0309750363,
0.0032078084,
0.0414755568,
-0.0362317935,
0.0476739965,
-0.047129713,
0.0055900989,
-0.0127374539,
-0.0167816412,
-0.0425632484,
-0.0192216523,
0.0200764649,
-0.031706132,
-0.0036085115,
-0.0373127759,
-0.0109540951,
0.0156523101,
-0.042093426,
0.0341714658,
-0.0114179198,
-0.0043924176,
-0.0149785131,
-0.0041278945,
-0.0396362767,
-0.0243809056,
0.0277785882,
-0.0248032156,
0.0141602634,
0.0157344341,
-0.024090711,
0.0066354563,
-0.0216257926,
-0.0090889027,
0.0284898523,
-0.0127758682,
0.0167439599,
-0.0571629517,
0.0513285957,
-0.0692813173,
-0.0261367001,
0.0737139136,
0.0003204903,
-0.051969517,
0.0172658209,
-0.0228995625,
0.0095706321,
0.0230173226,
0.0045991517,
-0.1050740331,
0.0115270102,
0.0297743846,
0.0544569343,
-0.0082299309,
-0.0406421162,
-0.0090481685,
-0.1073107049,
0.0067109773,
0.0381100364,
-0.0723015517,
-0.0715614185,
0.0154613703,
-0.0087120207,
-0.0309518334,
0.0324765854,
-0.0125056943,
0.0216369946,
-0.0272098482,
-0.0232802406,
-0.0016311934,
-0.0721712112,
0.0038088434,
-0.0473892726,
0.0410723276,
0.0088601205,
0.0789436698,
-0.0241105743,
0.0100097684,
0.0191124789,
-0.0438651778,
-0.0339582488,
-0.0172537509,
0.0489872433,
0.0009685287,
-0.0326112695,
-0.0173484161,
-0.0021100049,
0.0283767711,
0.0068134866,
0.0041574617,
0.0182285253,
0.014391494,
0.0038045319,
-0.0034850095,
0.0080834441,
0.0226137321,
0.0749126822,
0.0276722815,
-0.0235455576,
-0.0072515998,
-0.0611814,
0.0144337537,
-0.0226913504,
-0.0480920002,
-0.0043033948,
-0.0094172982,
-0.056003999,
-0.0781771466,
-0.0667925477,
-0.0095018037,
0.0185177028,
0.0642736182,
-0.0492041335,
-0.0106893824,
0.0184250008,
-0.0457914732,
0.0297089145,
-0.0147581948,
0.0385320447,
-0.0039547253,
0.0216013379,
-0.0219184365,
-0.0147262411,
0.0045744167,
0.0580551513,
-0.0505451635,
-0.0803107023,
0.0212260373,
0.0572800711,
0.0350346975,
0.0446091443,
-0.0632511377,
-0.0584393628,
0.0151021788,
0.0305881444,
-0.0249916185,
0.0045281076,
0.047847338,
-0.0000233142,
-0.0132325366,
0.0477078892,
-0.0031671368,
0.0093928995,
-0.0173221882,
-0.0095741013,
-0.0233432651,
-0.0457371622,
-0.0128726065,
-0.0006727279,
-0.0264022872,
-0.0642323494,
-0.008014773,
-0.0608279333,
-0.011534051,
-0.0188690536,
-0.0181714892,
-0.0147376545,
-0.0047553102,
0.042243544,
0.0164760239,
-0.003517299,
-0.016870087,
-0.0317135677,
0.0130532505,
-0.0161856152,
-0.0113042137,
0.0334635898,
0.0802352056,
-0.0014143944,
0.046493765,
-0.0092998268,
0.0057184855,
-0.0467186421,
0.04505229,
-0.004557949,
0.0318725631,
0.0163555499,
0.045271866,
0.0047918176,
0.014190386,
0.0113910725,
0.0035530641,
-0.041049242,
-0.0079437196,
0.0440017134,
-0.0032118661,
0.1076821461,
0.0171137024,
-0.0237497166,
0.0009599601,
0.0292200167,
-0.0154310716,
-0.014406709,
-0.0078671109,
-0.0016753115,
0.0201088283,
-0.0038283225,
0.0278602261,
0.0133735938,
0.0372233056,
0.0311928093,
-0.0492644012,
-0.0156433061,
-0.0081628151,
-0.0168391801,
-0.0685653836,
-0.0108415345,
-0.0298085958,
-0.0967528224,
-0.0808343813,
0.0095617566,
0.0126842335,
0.0388298593,
0.0179838948,
-0.0067017013,
0.0689127967,
-0.0049641458,
0.0166384894,
-0.026395442,
0.0419054106,
-0.0087184673,
-0.0368484147,
-0.0714589059,
-5.249821688e-33,
-0.0396279395,
-0.0057990453,
-0.0249175355,
-0.0251674168,
-0.0405996814,
-0.0070492388,
-0.0366413109,
-0.0261681769,
0.0185643695,
0.0195017029,
0.0058884374,
0.0311336517,
0.0148958247,
0.0005219653,
0.007712347,
-0.0177549124,
0.0902508572,
0.0251034889,
-0.0437485129,
-0.0008975928,
0.0477215387,
0.0235336367,
0.0782465115,
-0.0835685879,
0.0876634046,
-0.0354528278,
-0.0514658242,
0.0213292055,
0.0176299047,
0.0148075707,
0.0117326351,
0.0484133363,
-0.0082205357,
0.0139513528,
0.0199065339,
0.0384949446,
-0.1105868965,
-0.0032454359,
0.011910364,
0.0638357252,
0.026990056,
-0.0352256708,
0.040283896,
-0.0155695444,
-0.0319712088,
-0.0115010673,
0.0462314151,
-0.0222134851,
0.0291756224,
-0.0062793889,
-0.0545549281,
0.0088853287,
-0.0304361843,
-0.0211835001,
0.002457137,
0.0770641416,
0.0020569465,
-0.0309252515,
-0.1233045608,
-0.0185949337,
-0.0256335773,
-0.0331942961,
0.0321060903,
0.0069267424,
0.0087118521,
0.0171723925,
0.0366519429,
0.0317011811,
0.0037825585,
0.0005943027,
0.0492052324,
-0.037350893,
0.0454495512,
0.0617867485,
0.0294190217,
-0.0383916423,
-0.0343247913,
0.0094274543,
0.0134473061,
0.0173311904,
0.02054918,
-0.0287234467,
-0.0452573784,
-0.0407073088,
-0.0286585726,
-0.1110260114,
0.0024275554,
-0.0157698374,
0.0109522175,
-0.026544163,
-0.0351832397,
0.004746628,
0.0092983339,
-0.0535849147,
-0.006143555,
0.0142587041,
-0.0027149718,
-0.0210239775,
0.0295555796,
0.0441218689,
-0.0000063429,
-0.0129774772,
0.0132156815,
0.0278688688,
0.0536746718,
-0.0218332205,
0.0539950244,
0.0274392515,
-0.0544640012,
0.0025654268,
-0.0255785901,
0.0432228483,
-0.0115223592,
0.0575633273,
0.0359018333,
0.013633946,
-0.0302172452,
-0.0134304697,
0.0738289803,
0.0515726246,
-0.0545220822,
0.0243536942,
-0.0053510163,
0.0342881344,
-0.0421549752,
-0.0132327732,
-0.0176655333,
0.012740585,
0.0878684372,
-0.0661143214,
-0.0120153297,
-0.0524615124,
2.388e-7,
0.0277904738,
0.0401733667,
0.0218868237,
0.0324817114,
0.0228470135,
0.031658031,
-0.0129954945,
0.0545807481,
0.0334340222,
0.0219501853,
-0.0001130601,
0.0175097678,
0.0573816635,
0.0604476817,
-0.0500792861,
-0.032468833,
-0.049195569,
0.0537073836,
-0.0137474798,
-0.0040881727,
0.0044367784,
0.0887127519,
0.0615558326,
-0.0380265638,
-0.0113015743,
-0.0140179424,
0.0451723337,
-0.0184709877,
0.01759311,
-0.0274914354,
0.0257219113,
0.0371071249,
0.0089476928,
-0.0066877864,
0.0290809702,
-0.009009921,
0.045286119,
0.0027609153,
-0.01938143,
0.0558304936,
-0.0060790665,
-0.0247071814,
-0.0256018024,
-0.0490018874,
0.0307380725,
0.0159376115,
-0.0104575539,
0.0154608013,
-0.0075865397,
0.0183382593,
0.0791793838,
-0.0402518548,
-0.0448411107,
0.0394114219,
0.0420939289,
-0.0140706906,
0.013979461,
-0.0566821918,
-0.0355519354,
0.0161088146,
-0.008517649,
-0.0211468861,
0.0253427625,
0.0165714975,
-0.0138762807,
-0.0319589004,
0.0128925601,
2.048308319e-34,
0.0281641018,
-0.0216330662,
-0.0058072419,
-0.0309258737,
0.0265291166,
-0.0219601039,
0.0320509784,
-0.0109880613,
0.0004210852,
0.0261911061,
-0.0217203125
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06930v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06930v1 | PizzaCommonSense: Learning to Model Commonsense Reasoning about Intermediate Steps in Cooking Recipes | 2024-01-12T23:33:01 | 2024-01-12T23:33:01 | Aissatou Diallo, Antonis Bikakis, Luke Dickens, Anthony Hunter, Rob Miller | cs.CL | cs.CL | Decoding the core of procedural texts, exemplified by cooking recipes, is
crucial for intelligent reasoning and instruction automation. Procedural texts
can be comprehensively defined as a sequential chain of steps to accomplish a
task employing resources. From a cooking perspective, these instructions can be
interpreted as a series of modifications to a food preparation, which initially
comprises a set of ingredients. These changes involve transformations of
comestible resources. For a model to effectively reason about cooking recipes,
it must accurately discern and understand the inputs and outputs of
intermediate steps within the recipe. Aiming to address this, we present a new
corpus of cooking recipes enriched with descriptions of intermediate steps of
the recipes that explicate the input and output for each step. We discuss the
data collection process, investigate and provide baseline models based on T5
and GPT-3.5. This work presents a challenging task and insight into commonsense
reasoning and procedural text generation. | [
0.0297253206,
0.0556262694,
-0.0117013445,
-0.0013663085,
-0.0407626778,
0.0259491727,
-0.0610669181,
0.0268392358,
-0.0040912484,
-0.0328706391,
0.0222637821,
0.0216869097,
0.0078088585,
0.0295038074,
-0.0242875647,
-0.0463716313,
0.0144932671,
0.0101335542,
0.0074535161,
0.0352889933,
0.0067946156,
0.0318993181,
-0.0275523029,
0.0125207752,
-0.0135849705,
-0.0173257887,
-0.0249793734,
-0.0130827241,
0.0400847532,
-0.0160250291,
-0.0226966497,
0.0742503405,
0.0220373347,
-0.0049648276,
0.0000017608,
-0.001993594,
0.006203739,
0.0043337583,
-0.0205338243,
-0.0124135306,
0.017247865,
-0.0162272248,
-0.0180429276,
-0.0044084275,
-0.0391158275,
0.0728021562,
0.0468266644,
0.0578236543,
0.0449982472,
0.0523502529,
0.0034580652,
-0.1237214878,
-0.0361345261,
0.0216211043,
0.0488753244,
0.0202581901,
-0.0075250519,
0.0048438283,
0.0429848172,
0.005918521,
0.0213311352,
0.015671622,
0.0462639704,
-0.0006553849,
-0.0784479529,
0.0664292648,
0.0153123811,
-0.0222883485,
0.005138441,
0.0800010562,
0.045817975,
-0.033896327,
0.0235384516,
-0.0063289967,
-0.0075059049,
0.0026334012,
-0.0296175387,
0.0077941841,
-0.0386882909,
0.046097666,
0.0366833732,
-0.0055987034,
0.0176473353,
0.0065204916,
0.037701264,
0.0937157348,
-0.0103338268,
-0.0175937936,
-0.0238805003,
0.0235791896,
0.0117092021,
-0.0497598127,
0.0324344672,
0.0725246817,
0.004941944,
0.0286179334,
-0.0039792378,
0.026667865,
0.0130377617,
-0.0036122499,
0.0037806681,
0.0422917493,
-0.016102206,
0.0218087863,
0.0016772151,
0.015392255,
-0.0119827623,
0.0133139817,
-0.0871378705,
0.0264167953,
-0.0959577411,
-0.0315042362,
-0.0303850528,
0.0209138598,
-0.0265287757,
-0.0067627765,
0.0058198678,
0.001668754,
0.0079871798,
0.0039683888,
0.0511745252,
0.0527521819,
-0.0464604162,
0.005082754,
-0.0595145337,
0.0184185114,
-0.0733038262,
0.0474132597,
0.0057177441,
0.0297262073,
-0.0296896845,
-0.0293940101,
0.0170587897,
0.0262630712,
0.000006908,
0.0095685711,
-0.0271797013,
0.013799997,
-0.0476341359,
-0.0484980233,
0.0007506317,
-0.0773242638,
0.0166672952,
-0.0751326829,
0.0288075358,
0.0033825287,
0.0207082592,
0.0129818702,
0.0214988645,
0.047861658,
-0.0539985448,
0.0575290434,
0.0391165838,
-0.0334363431,
-0.0022239324,
0.0497811027,
0.0087235607,
0.0173254404,
0.0384669043,
0.0019709675,
-0.0121639036,
0.0016015591,
0.0137082078,
-0.0292879809,
-0.0074464167,
0.0088253794,
-0.0130154528,
0.0106576541,
-0.029780522,
0.0353056826,
-0.0185670443,
0.0602005906,
-0.0173606519,
0.0188902821,
0.0558269173,
0.069549717,
-0.019217601,
0.0356378257,
0.0881881416,
0.0244607758,
0.0236373246,
0.0482776873,
-0.0257278569,
0.0310590491,
-0.0652746484,
0.0079725962,
-0.0388196521,
-0.0211431887,
-0.0314723626,
-0.0355362259,
-0.0177691933,
-0.018332744,
0.0732978433,
-0.0575781986,
0.0234939065,
0.0274558607,
-0.0349338613,
-0.0074482057,
-0.007771791,
-0.046971444,
0.0134869954,
0.0088326596,
0.055800356,
0.0683209896,
0.0259924587,
-0.0301136319,
-0.0114052063,
0.0079183206,
0.002417489,
0.0147194546,
-0.0252097566,
-0.0293288641,
-0.007891993,
-0.0166668706,
-0.0558445044,
-0.0148470737,
0.0353323333,
-0.0320175439,
0.0026751887,
-0.0278017186,
0.0180040393,
-0.0490414053,
0.0093132183,
0.0166885499,
0.0040224809,
-0.0244291928,
-0.0334287919,
-0.0028028979,
-0.0097401859,
0.019014813,
0.0320386738,
0.0246710144,
0.0079382323,
-0.0306134671,
-0.0246550329,
0.0809512809,
-0.0009193548,
-0.0351505913,
0.0093335267,
-0.0543832779,
-0.0079241684,
-0.0348951928,
-0.0509166494,
-0.0572690964,
0.0127744507,
-0.0314999633,
-0.0144082764,
-0.0342601649,
-0.0419508778,
0.0677906051,
-0.0397102088,
0.0132035259,
0.0958807021,
-0.0246859696,
0.0048555424,
-0.0096325641,
-0.011057402,
0.01165995,
-0.0187210012,
0.0638131723,
-0.0257633105,
-0.0058361818,
0.0226688217,
0.0034391843,
0.0851693973,
-0.0617432818,
-0.0149687948,
-0.0533411838,
-0.0027923931,
-0.0391939953,
0.0058279829,
0.0169078819,
-0.0101332422,
0.007328758,
-0.0051529449,
-0.0374211855,
0.0083438857,
-0.013159412,
0.0079905083,
0.0154358102,
0.0229486097,
-0.0147294626,
-0.0095413914,
-0.0094058951,
-0.0137910005,
0.0217857398,
0.0385229513,
0.0695983544,
-0.0626772046,
-0.0573723502,
-0.0319197513,
0.0080665462,
0.0159638785,
-0.0493999086,
0.0065850578,
-0.0036673797,
0.0179550108,
0.0203826856,
-0.016837785,
0.0459599681,
0.0373918191,
-0.0420326293,
-0.0158508997,
-0.0053214859,
-0.0377404839,
0.0317543708,
-0.023238916,
-0.0629261434,
-0.0092428206,
0.0551794432,
0.0201730411,
0.0480592586,
-0.0739682168,
0.0214495491,
-0.0055258675,
-0.0137651004,
-0.0127963759,
0.005465358,
0.0023392667,
0.0538790524,
-0.0114052789,
-0.023738917,
0.0840652585,
-0.025223311,
0.0563472286,
-0.0714591369,
-0.0021542152,
-0.0099448813,
0.0427810289,
0.0285552703,
0.0349294357,
0.0347919799,
-0.0064413305,
-0.0443259552,
0.0364230201,
0.0639051199,
-0.0392478965,
0.0318708941,
-0.1138423905,
-0.0061445166,
0.0078163948,
-0.0338423364,
-0.0093078427,
-0.004381327,
-0.0028208434,
0.0392780341,
0.0232577175,
-0.0089245774,
-0.0496287644,
0.0020815115,
-0.0030771724,
0.053191293,
0.0333207808,
-0.0297742691,
-0.030666912,
0.0344661772,
0.0358136296,
0.0018848215,
-0.0199133139,
-0.0131382709,
-0.0072450084,
0.044722788,
0.0387923159,
-0.0566897579,
0.0095045799,
0.070319511,
0.0159621984,
-0.0236563813,
-0.0367535912,
0.0519050732,
0.0134595344,
-0.0565524846,
-0.0662885308,
0.0781863779,
0.0482713841,
-0.0232572667,
0.0201971661,
0.0188577939,
-0.0281592403,
-0.0138278017,
0.0306318421,
-0.1261344552,
0.0023567046,
0.0041889246,
0.0127866492,
-0.0565335639,
-0.0366255939,
-0.0145530608,
-0.0892425105,
0.0676024482,
0.0035976942,
-0.0983354226,
-0.0734535679,
-0.0468307361,
-0.0243582781,
-0.0130371163,
-0.0374887511,
-0.0233903918,
-0.0287945066,
0.0326232649,
0.0376064181,
0.0078349151,
-0.0459803492,
0.0160309151,
-0.0405278467,
0.0292336252,
0.0579096824,
0.0366553627,
0.0072723459,
-0.0290938821,
-0.0244987775,
-0.0413961075,
0.0173120927,
-0.0255912598,
-0.0203008838,
0.0241771024,
0.005660661,
-0.0261326432,
0.0762882158,
-0.052651193,
-0.0798995793,
-0.0118342191,
0.0983278826,
-0.0046053478,
-0.0179451611,
-0.0262044463,
0.0255492628,
0.0542437509,
0.0547491387,
0.0180818588,
0.0409742668,
-0.0448339991,
-0.0534723587,
-0.0490962602,
-0.0480243787,
0.0032334065,
0.0354596265,
-0.0304464847,
-0.0147717111,
-0.069636628,
-0.0196902994,
-0.0072272946,
0.0580730066,
0.0168981329,
0.0095105749,
0.0162098687,
0.0272715837,
-0.0455370098,
0.0173948631,
-0.0191080458,
-0.026122177,
-0.0521730818,
-0.0289697964,
0.0313694552,
-0.0204526354,
-0.0498759933,
0.0320978351,
-0.0874465257,
-0.0301772673,
-0.0230170954,
0.0919161886,
0.028134536,
0.0524853468,
-0.0133878179,
-0.006986287,
0.0073467856,
-0.0118053537,
-0.0180159789,
-0.0344656967,
0.0062209927,
-0.0156782921,
0.0348335765,
0.0261547174,
-0.0181745272,
0.0268941019,
-0.0335604437,
0.0720838904,
-0.0457950272,
-0.0243912339,
0.0719171017,
-0.0436725505,
-0.0109654758,
-0.0029500914,
0.0304460563,
-0.0578437485,
0.010038441,
-0.0170345698,
-0.0312740877,
-0.0337795913,
0.0543480106,
0.0392387435,
-0.0149638327,
-0.0147028761,
-0.0312136859,
-0.0310897157,
0.0661298335,
-0.0031702246,
-0.0175921582,
0.0483719222,
0.0287728515,
-0.0033845489,
-0.0331977867,
-0.0134426998,
0.025415441,
-0.0280906167,
0.0325846113,
-0.0178274997,
0.10342554,
0.0275835786,
0.0250300057,
-0.043692749,
0.0170646682,
-0.0174597818,
0.0042434037,
-0.0141438795,
-0.0183858387,
0.0295305662,
-0.0448115282,
0.0279194787,
-0.0494852066,
0.0001086304,
-0.0028728587,
0.1093818098,
0.0013789042,
-0.0109877605,
0.038501557,
0.0304460768,
0.0205357261,
-0.0272821561,
0.0938378945,
-0.0449107811,
0.0568075292,
0.0028850737,
-0.0069070109,
-0.0219341982,
-0.030163439,
-0.0338780321,
0.0182391629,
-0.0006852843,
-0.0087544862,
-0.0574983321,
-0.0257709771,
-0.0235833935,
0.0489045829,
0.0423536934,
0.0003989011,
0.036968898,
0.0716554821,
-0.0039964211,
-0.0362118259,
0.0017833122,
0.0202864986,
-0.037988171,
-0.0124629941,
-0.0072052111,
-6.009598789e-33,
-0.0468767174,
-0.0526964441,
0.038197957,
0.0282698628,
0.0089280652,
-0.0395508856,
-0.0423902124,
-0.0443465114,
0.0500113741,
0.0441899449,
0.0273080766,
0.0225638263,
0.0271725133,
-0.0096451947,
0.0511128455,
-0.0548650734,
0.0193576049,
0.0204239916,
-0.0449073985,
-0.0005395493,
0.0503468253,
-0.0077370936,
0.0428991131,
-0.0363056175,
0.0192635525,
-0.0091660637,
-0.0062755481,
0.0013983963,
-0.0479942262,
0.0458292887,
-0.0287659783,
0.0194111671,
0.0349020809,
0.0018765678,
0.0151364347,
0.0230535697,
-0.0814912319,
-0.0503247716,
0.0109937573,
-0.0191608462,
-0.0366164669,
-0.0693479404,
-0.0106006814,
0.00842275,
0.0206753314,
0.0329587497,
0.0375791527,
-0.0366614945,
0.0123983584,
-0.0205159131,
-0.0668929219,
0.0032964586,
-0.0383364968,
-0.0090942271,
-0.0071274494,
0.0392474532,
0.0089831753,
-0.0350275375,
-0.0469714329,
0.0252119415,
0.024969114,
0.0003146444,
0.0398963764,
-0.0174057651,
-0.0134317046,
0.0080276392,
-0.0361974612,
-0.0226984024,
-0.0381319933,
0.0335665941,
-0.0265658982,
0.0828483403,
0.025636917,
0.0017657742,
0.0313988291,
0.0218215678,
-0.0275960192,
0.0165509917,
-0.0143191535,
0.0227349009,
-0.0393317975,
-0.0101210307,
0.0054012411,
-0.0125463428,
-0.0248955954,
-0.0601427443,
0.0044267713,
-0.0165466052,
-0.0112874806,
0.010353866,
-0.0243308712,
-0.0160114169,
-0.011919816,
0.0486461706,
0.0291271079,
0.0074685682,
0.0081111034,
-0.0111076972,
-0.029015474,
0.0254011732,
-0.0967831686,
-0.0586594678,
0.0440135151,
-0.0160427429,
0.0192399621,
0.0153415427,
0.0143342223,
0.0536088869,
0.0121793179,
-0.014942525,
-0.0371751785,
-0.0251457077,
0.0005349092,
0.0001195489,
0.0372513197,
0.0356709249,
0.0151069248,
0.0347583331,
-0.0146089643,
-0.0016456434,
-0.0139273955,
0.0368584804,
0.0427656434,
-0.0245515816,
0.012911248,
0.0126860794,
-0.0362174697,
-0.0141732469,
0.0386854298,
-0.0247633159,
0.0045475313,
0.0536597706,
2.498e-7,
0.0574743561,
-0.0038974844,
0.0352247059,
0.0117091835,
-0.0290160142,
0.0213434771,
-0.0071217422,
0.0331912898,
-0.0155381104,
-0.0069834841,
0.0498950779,
0.0067251148,
0.0226737875,
0.0757314265,
-0.0161632635,
-0.0161409788,
-0.0551658608,
-0.0414683633,
-0.0421202816,
-0.0263501666,
0.0676777065,
0.008742325,
0.0418462083,
-0.0052135405,
-0.0126371486,
0.00065408,
0.0522204228,
-0.0340110324,
0.0394554175,
0.0007992768,
0.0127764707,
0.0094515318,
0.0209817328,
-0.0073180217,
-0.0091113504,
-0.0117155779,
0.0071441717,
0.0275967531,
-0.0058186208,
-0.0123055167,
-0.0123797366,
-0.0666098073,
-0.0058354521,
-0.0561842173,
0.0359633863,
-0.092017673,
-0.0031375769,
0.0935208723,
-0.0110748019,
-0.0202686042,
-0.014486813,
-0.0118724816,
0.0282234661,
-0.0097266268,
0.0094199814,
0.0004016803,
0.0093992753,
-0.0518326797,
-0.0030106311,
0.0321210027,
-0.0146419611,
-0.012535234,
0.0077871503,
-0.0277669169,
-0.014639046,
-0.052812431,
-0.0472835228,
2.007262904e-34,
-0.0039813737,
-0.0075722886,
-0.007527404,
0.0028372905,
0.0302609727,
0.0176177546,
-0.0236628074,
-0.0004899445,
0.0156176686,
-0.0826775953,
-0.0234778039
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06920v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06920v1 | Comparing GPT-4 and Open-Source Language Models in Misinformation Mitigation | 2024-01-12T22:27:25 | 2024-01-12T22:27:25 | Tyler Vergho, Jean-Francois Godbout, Reihaneh Rabbany, Kellin Pelrine | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent large language models (LLMs) have been shown to be effective for
misinformation detection. However, the choice of LLMs for experiments varies
widely, leading to uncertain conclusions. In particular, GPT-4 is known to be
strong in this domain, but it is closed source, potentially expensive, and can
show instability between different versions. Meanwhile, alternative LLMs have
given mixed results. In this work, we show that Zephyr-7b presents a
consistently viable alternative, overcoming key limitations of commonly used
approaches like Llama-2 and GPT-3.5. This provides the research community with
a solid open-source option and shows open-source models are gradually catching
up on this task. We then highlight how GPT-3.5 exhibits unstable performance,
such that this very widely used model could provide misleading results in
misinformation detection. Finally, we validate new tools including approaches
to structured output and the latest version of GPT-4 (Turbo), showing they do
not compromise performance, thus unlocking them for future research and
potentially enabling more complex pipelines for misinformation mitigation. | [
0.0240170639,
0.0284884889,
-0.0292062443,
0.0678705797,
-0.0553904139,
-0.0014907883,
-0.0020408211,
0.0288428869,
-0.0051584491,
-0.0125926323,
-0.0127936294,
-0.0407992713,
0.0457493141,
0.0329886638,
0.0232740808,
-0.0080477726,
0.0768258125,
-0.0240618419,
0.0458772779,
-0.0179639403,
0.0122918356,
0.0180318672,
0.0413436443,
0.0288600177,
0.0085147489,
-0.0238634273,
-0.0025017983,
0.0040845517,
0.0348784178,
-0.0153066684,
0.0107331229,
0.0537197143,
0.0107307676,
0.1290640831,
0.0000021698,
0.0038723776,
-0.0216344092,
0.0338113792,
-0.0218679421,
0.0761849433,
0.062849693,
-0.0678814724,
-0.0262190923,
0.0332527012,
0.0066639488,
-0.0120374272,
0.0421103276,
0.0510776863,
0.062559098,
0.0945492163,
-0.0051286994,
-0.0150522292,
0.0450883619,
-0.0258113761,
-0.0016149414,
-0.0325856097,
0.0640454963,
-0.0423339568,
-0.0362277441,
0.0541733243,
0.0175270196,
0.0271775071,
-0.007479548,
0.0000760129,
-0.0917964727,
0.0130702816,
-0.0318750851,
-0.0233510062,
-0.0214714929,
0.0202501826,
-0.0508321114,
-0.0619088598,
0.0210819524,
-0.0238271505,
-0.008037148,
0.0280401129,
-0.0027112702,
0.0330759287,
-0.0216192361,
0.0302358549,
0.0049725599,
-0.0130801229,
0.0590540357,
-0.0048737656,
0.0316121839,
0.0897039697,
0.0259874016,
-0.0393246561,
-0.0101142293,
-0.0132143749,
-0.0212620609,
-0.0776013881,
-0.0067134905,
-0.0273840316,
0.0013670438,
0.0011543644,
-0.0860757977,
-0.0204897244,
0.0579743385,
-0.0921363458,
-0.0143954959,
0.0500319526,
0.012107118,
0.0106969224,
-0.0101771578,
0.0481650308,
-0.0463394485,
0.0088524912,
0.0047531645,
-0.0296857096,
0.0018071198,
-0.0157616977,
-0.012633089,
0.0088941054,
-0.0280811489,
0.010111955,
-0.0483924709,
-0.0136254048,
-0.0267006401,
0.0193082932,
-0.0347110666,
-0.0473921038,
-0.0353645012,
-0.011944158,
0.0123213716,
0.0252771433,
0.0194789208,
0.0217576418,
-0.0267933402,
-0.0697208568,
-0.0381851159,
0.0586471744,
-0.0471292511,
-0.0283027161,
-0.0357125886,
0.0182929859,
0.0241360292,
-0.0181953646,
-0.0286651012,
-0.0420879573,
-0.0331802368,
-0.0581120476,
-0.0144178411,
-0.051687777,
-0.0222307965,
-0.0124857398,
0.0068495665,
-0.0331998169,
-0.0029724806,
0.0169485454,
-0.0543403104,
0.0546616204,
-0.0392041281,
0.0002923256,
0.0418836139,
0.0311655011,
0.009194606,
0.0818516985,
-0.0012037122,
0.0558145195,
0.0432725213,
-0.0177114513,
0.0278758053,
0.037625704,
0.0476125814,
0.0364085138,
0.0200383738,
-0.0197991878,
-0.0065091937,
-0.0334609635,
0.0159610026,
0.0712187961,
0.0012379574,
-0.0570321381,
0.0956382751,
-0.0023131866,
-0.0366733931,
-0.0062725176,
0.0140198246,
0.0445726775,
0.0043155686,
0.0047028204,
-0.0432708636,
-0.0184606947,
-0.0753386617,
-0.0078128958,
0.0419978835,
0.044365488,
-0.002582089,
0.0233072359,
-0.0335751958,
-0.0199867561,
0.0132579282,
-0.0101277735,
0.0250773448,
-0.0381498262,
-0.0525903925,
0.0576821342,
0.0526589341,
-0.0173328388,
-0.0010183589,
-0.0581829771,
0.0211984068,
0.0461482219,
0.0524409637,
-0.005212184,
0.04005583,
-0.0547367781,
-0.0237030815,
0.0443019085,
0.025238486,
0.0169799384,
-0.0033023588,
-0.0272983648,
0.010573566,
-0.019488737,
0.0375267975,
0.0120348595,
0.072318092,
0.0277662035,
0.0080281617,
-0.0355019271,
-0.0176056493,
0.0062996601,
0.0201680437,
0.0138065014,
-0.0216913018,
-0.0256375261,
0.0355530828,
0.0149223339,
-0.0245451294,
-0.0185574386,
0.0460016169,
0.0024679324,
-0.024826074,
-0.0625402555,
-0.0106639843,
-0.0039750189,
0.0406643189,
0.011584715,
-0.0248169117,
0.0572378188,
-0.04204797,
0.0010836622,
0.0361840948,
-0.0373916738,
0.0435990803,
-0.056861341,
0.0124897761,
-0.0285188351,
0.0453467928,
0.01054624,
0.0516867787,
-0.0208928175,
-0.0230288561,
0.01059784,
-0.0167492423,
0.02040709,
-0.0303973835,
0.0010422185,
0.0060995733,
0.0085515073,
0.0028584097,
0.0187471434,
-0.0018865507,
0.0185841322,
-0.0341313891,
-0.0338409171,
-0.0123079186,
-0.0303057972,
0.0101206927,
0.0447139889,
-0.0099452222,
-0.0160537045,
0.011645562,
-0.0112859253,
0.0005394517,
0.0197259318,
0.0106411483,
0.0044864365,
-0.002911665,
-0.0498478785,
-0.0065189237,
0.0060959794,
-0.0227173679,
0.0205413178,
0.0120149907,
-0.0842847228,
-0.0421215184,
0.0080363099,
-0.0357496552,
0.0465339199,
-0.0276433714,
-0.0342682041,
-0.0225548446,
0.025134109,
0.0174173564,
-0.0148257213,
0.0299836192,
0.0245575309,
0.0408262685,
0.0325655192,
-0.0030934163,
-0.0081347302,
-0.0457161665,
-0.0209388267,
-0.0245454032,
-0.0870197043,
0.0269818772,
0.050326705,
0.0598931462,
-0.0071517928,
-0.0647259429,
0.0168477334,
-0.0058676894,
-0.0290783141,
0.0056708981,
-0.0537017323,
-0.0194842909,
0.0041722921,
-0.0326048024,
-0.0695349947,
0.0673501864,
-0.0560828894,
0.0347690061,
-0.0145311467,
-0.0271180701,
-0.0167539231,
-0.0296413489,
-0.0012003711,
0.0357494429,
0.0562348999,
0.0064288196,
0.0158789139,
-0.0153910145,
0.0673514828,
-0.0123947635,
0.0245055072,
-0.0612392761,
0.0533940718,
0.0329349823,
-0.0102151548,
-0.0281527229,
-0.0742026642,
0.0155599117,
0.0037194146,
0.0297622327,
-0.0414231271,
-0.0306862816,
0.0062435339,
0.0212748162,
0.0439563282,
-0.0142431157,
0.0205176566,
-0.02436563,
0.0090245157,
0.0194892902,
-0.0748695433,
0.0895477161,
-0.0689348802,
-0.0402993113,
0.0656409934,
-0.0062343287,
0.0050238394,
0.010559829,
-0.0464148484,
0.0181441382,
-0.0228972547,
-0.0329881608,
0.0162367132,
0.0391070135,
-0.0603155643,
-0.0034563139,
0.0977883935,
0.0132377567,
-0.0241556857,
-0.0238293,
-0.0048229885,
0.0317850709,
-0.0038429629,
-0.0252464339,
-0.0582950637,
-0.0099796178,
0.0341792256,
0.0265316982,
-0.0452464558,
-0.0028866446,
-0.0221157242,
-0.0624952391,
0.0463141911,
0.0204554088,
-0.0203585271,
-0.0473982431,
-0.0547373593,
-0.0311585478,
0.015500281,
0.0281835198,
-0.0212836806,
0.0233058967,
-0.0206203572,
-0.0195180587,
-0.0598625243,
-0.0821837634,
0.0027277132,
0.0009225231,
0.0791052803,
0.0723137036,
0.0040455051,
-0.0344832316,
-0.0510735847,
0.0444395393,
-0.012320105,
-0.0712844878,
-0.0162946712,
0.061095681,
-0.0019617039,
-0.0105134072,
-0.0176362526,
0.0023970474,
0.0124533102,
0.0039724545,
-0.0141968923,
0.0179549679,
0.0080500739,
-0.0615819432,
-0.0011816096,
0.0114911105,
0.0402322076,
0.0866675228,
-0.0112982094,
0.0306501556,
-0.048171863,
-0.0673424229,
0.0391376466,
0.0431312993,
-0.0194971375,
0.0221192595,
0.0236810278,
-0.0557836257,
-0.0107250987,
0.0102552958,
-0.0193914864,
-0.0498292819,
0.0022211906,
0.0514328033,
0.0126145426,
-0.0093673179,
-0.0044826153,
-0.0375637934,
-0.0440375768,
0.0529067963,
-0.055600211,
-0.00314044,
-0.0198968723,
0.02030701,
0.0016646337,
0.0659741387,
-0.108101666,
-0.0910702869,
0.007252133,
0.0221684221,
0.0272209756,
0.0251465905,
-0.0390407369,
-0.0355577059,
0.0683818609,
0.0007912916,
-0.0276120212,
0.0558822118,
0.0177478082,
-0.0184762776,
0.0199872423,
0.0217145011,
-0.0058601429,
0.0125032142,
0.0142088868,
-0.0321832895,
-0.0463214144,
-0.0114182709,
0.0415119343,
0.0436348468,
0.0460663326,
-0.0212015677,
0.0237045307,
-0.0197351836,
-0.011017167,
-0.0517762862,
0.0028748319,
0.0059379297,
0.0040930342,
0.0460493229,
-0.0216583163,
0.0174258836,
0.0483924747,
-0.0255842917,
0.0072929277,
-0.0188853424,
-0.0247667674,
-0.0268126708,
0.0174558666,
0.0468377322,
-0.029157307,
-0.0037466588,
0.0308425352,
0.0067962026,
0.0361500755,
-0.0005525778,
0.0294765159,
-0.002758017,
-0.0479913317,
0.0318518728,
0.0096625928,
-0.0325477161,
-0.0142529197,
-0.0540313721,
0.050311625,
0.0250254944,
0.0566531867,
0.0680034086,
-0.0341261141,
-0.0196733121,
-0.0415489264,
-0.0137645723,
0.0355520025,
-0.0108853979,
0.0294751972,
-0.0214711465,
-0.0538597554,
0.0322860405,
0.0739850402,
0.0645306036,
0.0336820409,
0.0023145983,
-0.0762419924,
-0.0115193827,
-0.0367713012,
-0.0251340177,
0.0346263312,
-0.038301304,
0.0167326238,
-0.0847019702,
-0.0477843322,
0.0085388506,
0.0177113451,
0.0245022755,
-0.0075898692,
-0.0279237404,
0.0538555235,
-0.0227637943,
-0.0296368767,
-0.0677749291,
-0.0223811101,
0.0217911769,
-0.0234530624,
0.0231363494,
-6.87937865e-33,
-0.0339145847,
-0.0302624349,
-0.0462178998,
-0.0006250375,
0.008766911,
0.0221611951,
-0.0114328228,
-0.0196258239,
-0.0266092643,
0.0356512442,
0.0489172302,
0.0331770927,
0.003203962,
0.0000563702,
-0.0479811206,
0.0068343771,
0.0516373292,
0.0009055827,
-0.0378187448,
0.0266888384,
0.0575232618,
-0.0228616949,
0.0393391885,
-0.0655093044,
0.0459426343,
-0.0021768578,
-0.0624797754,
0.0139342388,
-0.0600034557,
0.0359989442,
-0.0077452213,
0.0675656125,
0.0069306791,
-0.0271542724,
-0.0117962472,
-0.0007892012,
-0.0094310511,
-0.0032986382,
0.049098473,
-0.0273560043,
0.02266814,
-0.0209598932,
0.0278832838,
0.0105293477,
-0.0301981438,
0.020796597,
-0.0043135914,
-0.0025876001,
-0.0063558104,
0.0302270707,
-0.0220433492,
0.0139884334,
0.02222302,
0.0350160785,
0.020943271,
0.0454431921,
0.016738968,
0.0408201069,
-0.0868051648,
0.0234545153,
0.0392361432,
0.0064854263,
0.0500906445,
-0.0208451059,
-0.0220804811,
0.0442175269,
0.0103353634,
0.0112340562,
-0.0309328008,
-0.0309208538,
-0.0260040537,
-0.0198534634,
0.0707981363,
0.0935672075,
-0.0194949917,
-0.0493256077,
-0.0975618958,
0.0376738943,
0.0137508325,
-0.0065534315,
0.042707704,
-0.013100612,
-0.0630483702,
-0.0311256945,
-0.0201827418,
-0.0192914903,
-0.0197325107,
-0.015090568,
0.0225312114,
0.0463384502,
0.0003915879,
0.035751503,
0.0045829839,
-0.0356558003,
-0.0006629252,
0.0130544314,
-0.0338339582,
-0.0063238442,
0.0198489446,
0.0755449608,
-0.0625271946,
0.0028454338,
0.0229012445,
-0.0054674982,
-0.0097838603,
-0.0271624811,
0.0214482732,
0.0336073861,
-0.0777424797,
0.0268306509,
-0.0224225819,
0.065246582,
0.0159503147,
-0.0621413328,
0.0096780863,
-0.0249553751,
0.0204630289,
0.0126629062,
0.0228479262,
-0.0065633636,
0.0132428482,
0.0068497118,
-0.025899047,
0.0356364809,
-0.0107923467,
0.0150213791,
-0.0038603579,
0.0133015057,
0.0295939315,
-0.0306035932,
-0.013244532,
-0.0300099701,
2.88e-7,
0.0269529317,
0.0489986427,
0.0117029995,
0.0303165745,
0.0421308875,
0.0641377568,
-0.0233520325,
0.0286699086,
-0.0323469341,
-0.0396918915,
-0.0528742522,
0.0033586235,
0.0047871214,
0.0444364808,
-0.0261630118,
0.0314191505,
-0.0557873063,
-0.0152120022,
-0.059600614,
-0.0096025569,
0.0091565885,
0.0892293677,
0.0361977667,
0.0111449659,
-0.0056566149,
-0.0240467396,
0.0674992949,
-0.0116669489,
-0.0503897592,
0.0313818492,
0.0280873701,
-0.0021001934,
0.0002387334,
0.0435659848,
-0.0208374392,
-0.018655397,
-0.022800751,
0.0666107312,
-0.0040403497,
-0.0159880798,
-0.0403558835,
-0.0446396247,
-0.0036273797,
-0.1012876704,
0.0411934331,
0.0238505714,
-0.0372750349,
-0.0230921712,
-0.0306976009,
-0.0135051301,
0.0214022193,
-0.0122228321,
-0.0388841592,
-0.0004668479,
-0.0190976933,
0.0384669565,
0.0052967011,
-0.0295144692,
0.0141229788,
-0.0121867312,
-0.041614648,
-0.0475588627,
-0.0211509299,
-0.0090616848,
0.0132508362,
-0.0090794917,
0.0408111066,
2.770277664e-34,
0.0411134586,
-0.0427113511,
-0.0095247859,
-0.0050048102,
0.0446801819,
-0.0049251155,
-0.0200351644,
-0.0048099291,
-0.0186056774,
-0.0262265522,
-0.00068992
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06915v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06915v2 | DocFinQA: A Long-Context Financial Reasoning Dataset | 2024-01-12T22:19:22 | 2024-02-29T19:55:14 | Varshini Reddy, Rik Koncel-Kedziorski, Viet Dac Lai, Michael Krumdick, Charles Lovering, Chris Tanner | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | For large language models (LLMs) to be effective in the financial domain --
where each decision can have a significant impact -- it is necessary to
investigate realistic tasks and data. Financial professionals often interact
with documents that are hundreds of pages long, but most financial research
datasets only deal with short excerpts from these documents. To address this,
we introduce a long-document financial QA task. We augment 7,437 questions from
the existing FinQA dataset with the full-document context, extending the
average context length from under 700 words in FinQA to 123k words in DocFinQA.
We conduct extensive experiments over retrieval-based QA pipelines and
long-context language models. DocFinQA proves a significant challenge for even
state-of-the-art systems. We also provide a case-study on the longest documents
in DocFinQA and find that models particularly struggle on these documents.
Addressing these challenges may have a wide reaching impact across applications
where specificity and long-range contexts are critical, like gene sequences and
legal document contract analysis. | [
0.0238635615,
0.0946397334,
-0.0079166545,
0.0289296471,
-0.0242738035,
0.020825712,
0.0295308251,
0.0301111806,
0.0133020561,
-0.0329073705,
-0.021262655,
-0.0422836542,
-0.0171010587,
0.0415643789,
0.0263977665,
-0.0135597298,
0.0076213321,
-0.0233470798,
0.0702368245,
-0.0149766356,
0.0245709568,
0.002039636,
0.0206615906,
0.0225472283,
-0.0120082293,
-0.0309328064,
-0.0083578527,
-0.0243479162,
-0.0117190108,
-0.0003486234,
0.0011412479,
0.0329889879,
0.0383297056,
0.0278625693,
0.000001799,
-0.0619204305,
-0.0429459549,
0.0097395461,
-0.0656950101,
0.0085997256,
0.0066531468,
-0.0202770811,
0.0442534648,
0.0214333814,
-0.0508010983,
0.0184373353,
0.0287983026,
0.0681939051,
0.0351783261,
0.0716655105,
-0.0103877792,
-0.0799368024,
0.0210813154,
-0.0781854987,
0.0490425378,
-0.1045274287,
0.0452757254,
0.0183828585,
0.0355740003,
-0.0028418892,
-0.0210478101,
0.0318786949,
0.0187316108,
-0.0268378481,
0.0039026842,
0.0032097693,
-0.0397541411,
0.0209057704,
0.0024439339,
0.0757066309,
0.034958642,
0.0431911238,
0.0283816904,
-0.0180008374,
0.0078077493,
-0.0145298606,
-0.044255197,
0.0516113415,
-0.0158600006,
-0.029095415,
0.023242645,
-0.0117527107,
0.024873374,
-0.0062242639,
-0.0818952471,
0.0496232174,
-0.0213175546,
-0.0484793261,
0.0267694984,
-0.0049520899,
-0.0270856917,
-0.0331608355,
0.0256604515,
0.0424352624,
-0.0083098579,
0.0202525761,
0.0052604983,
-0.0224329736,
0.0490079224,
-0.0464694425,
-0.0064152577,
0.0092289653,
-0.0163843464,
0.0926302671,
-0.0275796838,
0.0243769567,
-0.0228790771,
-0.0353195481,
-0.0258504022,
-0.0101945642,
-0.0505480282,
-0.0225930177,
-0.0444606505,
0.0470255949,
-0.0614918433,
-0.0315091684,
-0.0399948619,
-0.0018419725,
-0.0156872161,
0.0479076952,
0.0085170465,
-0.0033540286,
-0.0176837761,
-0.0187969003,
-0.0344790891,
0.0028373247,
-0.0566405989,
0.0310242213,
-0.0022207955,
-0.0064824554,
0.0107544977,
0.0154073266,
-0.0093844766,
-0.0448872522,
0.008118757,
0.0747895762,
0.0369793959,
-0.0452462025,
-0.0222556256,
-0.0497485772,
-0.0172456577,
-0.0359829627,
-0.0357242413,
-0.0294671468,
0.01666536,
-0.0006283358,
-0.0328325182,
-0.014583732,
0.0021179847,
0.0124823553,
-0.0139983306,
0.0958100408,
0.0640765578,
-0.0216986574,
0.0240244735,
-0.0123920599,
0.0166375879,
0.0529376157,
-0.0034276366,
0.011433864,
0.0510591343,
0.0153880604,
0.012637998,
0.0335805863,
0.0035803278,
-0.0411707871,
0.0150651867,
0.0743458197,
0.0157626476,
0.0192756224,
0.03176203,
0.0242576227,
-0.0177254379,
-0.0429925323,
0.0039881882,
0.0629404932,
0.0837626532,
-0.0306055639,
-0.0013945239,
0.0509335995,
0.0005430757,
-0.0345194861,
-0.0068685832,
-0.0003824877,
-0.0045162174,
0.0329426415,
-0.0131028052,
-0.0352797881,
-0.0417707302,
-0.0308400188,
-0.015359791,
-0.0027517295,
-0.0300262682,
0.0303416364,
0.0254647471,
-0.0057498924,
-0.029833464,
0.0420507528,
-0.0070237452,
-0.0373042785,
-0.0268687792,
-0.0118810087,
0.082679987,
0.0603941903,
0.0447913557,
-0.065715149,
0.0178184677,
-0.0152790667,
0.0033806823,
0.018194871,
0.0357695743,
-0.0140253901,
-0.0331542455,
-0.0361910388,
-0.0222267266,
-0.0037242121,
0.013004886,
0.0084147211,
0.024247054,
0.0074052159,
0.0265253652,
-0.0375989415,
0.0286770333,
0.0184036717,
-0.047910139,
-0.071284458,
0.0069100191,
-0.0065492708,
0.0033356124,
0.0015597978,
0.007812513,
0.0328048468,
0.0139375869,
-0.0254877023,
-0.0200439934,
-0.029835945,
-0.0342674516,
0.000260155,
0.0104124891,
-0.0161308944,
-0.0089179883,
-0.0167176221,
-0.0477541052,
-0.0202399939,
-0.0300186817,
-0.0166888591,
0.0209417176,
-0.0413606688,
-0.0033606044,
0.0087082079,
0.0244970247,
-0.0320070088,
0.0855719,
0.002955351,
0.0269927923,
-0.020088857,
0.0250260774,
0.0106806979,
-0.0785963982,
0.0479396842,
0.0053920997,
-0.0161540546,
0.0094482144,
0.0264752787,
-0.0002060845,
-0.0265388656,
-0.0258592386,
-0.0652705058,
-0.009345076,
-0.0176346023,
0.0324198827,
-0.029052848,
-0.0057556964,
-0.0016572382,
-0.0199378636,
-0.0671222731,
-0.0005878755,
-0.0030333484,
0.0251554698,
0.0447973199,
0.0113270087,
-0.0156749859,
-0.0496876501,
-0.0344149768,
-0.0071460172,
0.0536146015,
0.0356297456,
-0.002235896,
-0.016352687,
0.0036834495,
-0.0136841135,
0.0059028687,
-0.0347163305,
0.0652458221,
-0.0026261199,
-0.047186818,
0.0372122712,
0.0621328354,
0.006157225,
0.0412355922,
-0.0211129989,
0.009837593,
-0.0423832759,
0.0233731121,
-0.0098970607,
0.0039225332,
-0.0233113915,
0.0322652943,
0.0127076013,
0.0315293856,
-0.046185229,
-0.0090740882,
-0.0535355322,
0.0586831346,
-0.0020689056,
0.0088267326,
-0.0337056033,
-0.0101614688,
-0.0004929343,
0.0609347112,
-0.0031586387,
-0.0258863773,
0.0654009432,
-0.001120273,
-0.0023790775,
-0.0254947897,
0.005791693,
-0.106199123,
0.1156956255,
-0.0376892835,
-0.0157520603,
-0.0406169519,
-0.0467442907,
-0.0142727885,
-0.0328443982,
0.0145683326,
-0.0416278392,
0.0772401839,
-0.0319234021,
0.0440991633,
-0.0110001946,
-0.0457892604,
-0.0244847219,
-0.0400161743,
-0.0161990393,
0.0169706605,
0.0505219698,
-0.027864011,
-0.0491405688,
-0.0023554319,
0.0137268947,
0.021792002,
-0.0113791917,
-0.006248483,
0.0086911414,
0.0445197038,
0.0618224852,
-0.0106354719,
0.0451968834,
-0.0585323088,
0.0608668625,
0.0221673697,
0.0241999589,
-0.0053128735,
0.0396566689,
-0.0147529235,
-0.0226273537,
-0.06482099,
-0.0128900269,
0.0199706629,
-0.0086172819,
-0.0932607874,
-0.0300265364,
0.0865278989,
0.0415563472,
-0.0174742676,
-0.0038277011,
-0.0305665862,
0.0155870114,
0.0060225753,
0.0543376319,
-0.116254732,
-0.0312753655,
0.0076911096,
0.0211062357,
0.0393648259,
-0.054129485,
-0.009744036,
-0.1051568612,
0.0614131726,
-0.0115316408,
-0.0100305472,
-0.0206489433,
-0.0270090215,
-0.0298810154,
-0.0348247476,
0.0218915828,
0.0508763343,
-0.0323811211,
0.0057812459,
-0.0070652617,
-0.008490962,
0.0236269142,
0.0592291802,
-0.0015787082,
-0.0373359248,
0.0281970575,
0.0126379924,
0.0080243526,
-0.0448318832,
-0.0061511155,
-0.0419291779,
-0.0251561925,
0.024157485,
0.0535416603,
-0.0016372175,
-0.0140896514,
-0.0027297346,
0.0521417446,
-0.0633601323,
0.0183447544,
0.0219469815,
0.020029733,
-0.0255828388,
-0.0295422263,
-0.0108535904,
-0.0098483432,
-0.0214443728,
0.0868243426,
0.0243218374,
-0.0311172362,
-0.073190853,
-0.0230370071,
-0.0270500332,
-0.0321511477,
0.0218941104,
-0.0243960228,
0.0178514868,
0.0305221118,
-0.0820965767,
-0.0733447745,
0.0439718105,
0.037995521,
-0.0199957658,
0.0089411829,
0.0273548961,
-0.0242512599,
-0.0446166284,
0.0509921275,
-0.0603755638,
0.0404479988,
-0.043280609,
0.0548786856,
0.0182203036,
-0.0034761168,
-0.0502129644,
0.0390232839,
-0.0709230229,
-0.0220437068,
0.0057775285,
-0.0202783644,
0.0202647373,
0.0087032793,
-0.0213599838,
-0.0044739377,
0.0272485781,
0.0240511224,
-0.0643422902,
-0.0174416415,
0.0448560715,
0.0011220108,
-0.0164602883,
0.0487804152,
-0.06771788,
0.0209772028,
-0.02457802,
0.0576144233,
-0.0258795563,
0.0043218439,
0.0060065389,
0.0130351381,
-0.0181340035,
0.0622246675,
-0.0192244761,
-0.0299017951,
0.0176283829,
-0.0288874861,
-0.0127879204,
-0.0070802593,
-0.0054912651,
0.0436846577,
-0.0325356163,
-0.0019922296,
-0.002821224,
-0.0270326957,
0.0131354928,
-0.017752789,
0.047514569,
0.0227112882,
-0.01681838,
0.0380156897,
-0.0513922349,
0.0105266925,
0.0183451772,
-0.0026418008,
0.050669007,
-0.0004562429,
0.0234291013,
0.0211643521,
0.025332449,
-0.013594985,
-0.0301511437,
-0.0484742709,
-0.0520004854,
0.046760872,
0.0102321655,
0.0064665517,
-0.0538083464,
-0.028767474,
-0.0256012008,
0.0024198811,
-0.0010698051,
0.0137103973,
0.0169692766,
-0.0507401899,
0.0413175002,
0.0465206169,
-0.0422364064,
-0.0074024834,
0.0940073133,
0.0204163715,
0.0185450744,
-0.0432217382,
-0.0042448998,
-0.0396256931,
-0.0536497869,
0.0386876129,
0.0290266778,
-0.0149543397,
0.004979311,
-0.0824993253,
-0.0497975387,
-0.0023728956,
-0.0076710167,
-0.0325307176,
0.0104792854,
0.0274509396,
0.0701248571,
0.0192518141,
-0.0092992447,
-0.0237132702,
0.0401330069,
-0.0481040627,
-0.0404799096,
-0.0463109538,
-5.550532245e-33,
0.0029515754,
-0.0374109969,
0.0487996712,
-0.0008623536,
0.0159852505,
0.0294330921,
-0.0268103592,
-0.0326409265,
0.0085269902,
0.0094261328,
-0.0312974453,
0.0527547859,
-0.0027869856,
0.0331784748,
0.0061576436,
-0.0123160062,
0.0224829651,
-0.0157830976,
0.0132339504,
0.0065904283,
0.0255441684,
0.058258038,
0.0133122383,
-0.0385331027,
0.0451312624,
0.0159435999,
-0.0039708796,
0.0204268415,
-0.004258404,
0.0681130365,
-0.0168428887,
0.0121687287,
0.0161616039,
-0.0860062167,
-0.0027658953,
0.0344090648,
-0.069857575,
-0.0059301485,
-0.0120241176,
0.0057877544,
-0.014560841,
-0.0197342131,
0.0370222814,
-0.0129988212,
0.0057983506,
-0.0262838919,
0.0239545684,
-0.0270908326,
-0.0129407747,
-0.0506185926,
-0.0467456616,
0.0431915298,
-0.00142119,
0.0403994471,
0.0334399343,
0.0554179512,
-0.0116931899,
0.0618980043,
-0.0186964143,
-0.0145061631,
-0.0025444266,
0.0194106065,
0.0223090742,
-0.0234703757,
0.0066671255,
0.0186858475,
-0.027564073,
0.0081488006,
-0.0160486586,
-0.0263459422,
-0.0099096792,
0.0581700392,
0.0437268987,
0.0351581275,
0.0360930897,
-0.0127727278,
-0.0614635013,
0.0203210469,
-0.0199624095,
0.0694297701,
0.0128727332,
0.0242036693,
-0.0403982177,
-0.01191789,
-0.0518118702,
0.0294367019,
-0.0316948146,
0.0310287494,
0.0391087271,
0.0262832232,
0.0120179001,
0.0072980248,
0.0194823518,
-0.0312101133,
-0.0645381361,
0.0447874628,
0.0030863737,
-0.0068804175,
0.0167411231,
0.0396523997,
-0.050432872,
-0.0134789534,
0.0192248523,
-0.0111873876,
-0.0082424339,
-0.0160182938,
0.0463742577,
-0.0248646289,
-0.0762322545,
-0.0144170625,
-0.0064302599,
0.0383565016,
-0.0154216271,
0.0481004715,
0.0173435304,
0.0473847613,
0.0165805742,
0.0375756249,
0.0073486548,
0.0098884488,
-0.0151406955,
-0.055622898,
-0.01343094,
0.0320905596,
0.0021541344,
0.0036264565,
0.000040435,
0.0660635084,
0.0647017211,
-0.0235865656,
0.0016483155,
0.0658887401,
2.536e-7,
0.0498449542,
0.0617311895,
0.0373984724,
0.0306681488,
0.027960334,
0.0265397243,
-0.014238066,
0.0116176056,
-0.0423931666,
-0.0153950164,
0.0151938787,
0.0259393938,
0.0432964675,
-0.0187715217,
-0.0866244435,
-0.032812614,
-0.0708818212,
-0.0021007368,
-0.0836881548,
-0.0106473686,
0.0323558487,
0.1104457378,
-0.0132323457,
-0.0252633002,
0.0027452842,
-0.086458005,
0.0598463044,
-0.0308508202,
-0.0083878199,
-0.0035394214,
0.044777263,
-0.0218307041,
0.0259474516,
0.0094953654,
0.0077385814,
0.0290386137,
-0.0033508365,
0.0666306019,
0.0364609174,
-0.0155661553,
-0.0051666191,
-0.0085030729,
-0.005550955,
-0.0497585721,
0.0641695186,
-0.0405666791,
-0.0395367891,
-0.0495004281,
-0.0305013657,
-0.0130618233,
0.0186921433,
0.0358765908,
0.034366481,
0.0049350052,
0.0163699668,
-0.0254962873,
0.0433727056,
-0.0743526742,
-0.002962243,
0.0367585123,
-0.0358262621,
0.0373119973,
-0.0457114428,
0.0119110178,
0.0080557093,
-0.0772199631,
0.0025932137,
2.332266888e-34,
0.0605321787,
-0.0257883891,
-0.0345163606,
0.0232272632,
0.0765627474,
-0.0066680522,
0.0059018973,
0.0515208654,
0.0259161238,
-0.1176854149,
0.0109904623
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06877v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06877v3 | Promptly Predicting Structures: The Return of Inference | 2024-01-12T20:08:39 | 2024-03-29T18:27:17 | Maitrey Mehta, Valentina Pyatkin, Vivek Srikumar | cs.CL | cs.CL | Prompt-based methods have been used extensively across NLP to build zero- and
few-shot label predictors. Many NLP tasks are naturally structured: that is,
their outputs consist of multiple labels which constrain each other. Annotating
data for such tasks can be cumbersome. Can the promise of the prompt-based
paradigm be extended to such structured outputs? In this paper, we present a
framework for constructing zero- and few-shot linguistic structure predictors.
Our key insight is that we can use structural constraints -- and combinatorial
inference derived from them -- to filter out inconsistent structures predicted
by large language models. We instantiated this framework on two structured
prediction tasks, and five datasets. Across all cases, our results show that
enforcing consistency not only constructs structurally valid outputs, but also
improves performance over the unconstrained variants. | [
0.0411905721,
0.0709563717,
-0.0093513029,
0.0468589328,
-0.0205505248,
0.0007295619,
0.0112547921,
0.0122101959,
0.0191136207,
-0.0756453574,
-0.0240661707,
-0.0500103384,
-0.0029911117,
0.0101264343,
0.00333899,
-0.0469934121,
0.0377151482,
-0.0430615768,
0.0303049609,
-0.0052565802,
0.0395635329,
0.0300644524,
-0.0028830059,
0.0242324024,
-0.0187325552,
-0.0088596614,
-0.0026832749,
-0.0054578185,
-0.0468548425,
-0.0431476608,
0.0480054133,
0.0763124153,
-0.0278613623,
0.0335544534,
0.0000017421,
-0.0313421376,
-0.0147537496,
-0.0083175693,
-0.0378483683,
-0.0200565048,
0.0154197328,
-0.0809904337,
0.030075958,
-0.0004423401,
-0.0102727031,
-0.0407175235,
0.0465373062,
0.0329918228,
0.029199481,
0.0648039877,
-0.0061219982,
-0.0293908846,
-0.0063647171,
-0.023218764,
0.0021459553,
-0.0266378913,
0.0120089389,
-0.0370762572,
-0.0050838101,
0.0664630756,
-0.013192622,
-0.0092817983,
-0.0077790767,
-0.003617082,
0.0023795208,
0.0275118537,
-0.0441491045,
-0.0842068195,
-0.0300898403,
0.0752238855,
0.0239711516,
-0.0379896015,
0.0139238937,
-0.0742610544,
-0.0218395293,
-0.0057973256,
-0.0279780328,
0.0462838747,
-0.0196116529,
0.024094535,
0.050949432,
0.0279481094,
0.0241375789,
-0.0090998216,
0.0365577787,
0.0641704798,
0.0191024467,
-0.0152473375,
0.0026429121,
0.028244162,
0.0107799638,
-0.0732385516,
-0.0829824954,
0.0052755876,
-0.0742068142,
0.0288452767,
-0.0535673462,
-0.0218791459,
0.0205067955,
-0.0368288122,
0.0454411656,
0.0082988357,
-0.0217723213,
0.0510802902,
-0.0247562528,
0.0552891567,
-0.0128125176,
0.0027745955,
-0.0288016181,
-0.009881828,
-0.0567025207,
0.0059243371,
-0.0186039265,
0.0242726132,
-0.0195937697,
-0.0091668665,
-0.0270412546,
0.0102548115,
-0.0160864089,
0.0237481296,
0.014981553,
-0.0001691058,
-0.0248849001,
0.0085606677,
-0.0384426862,
0.0195827205,
-0.0398743339,
0.0059657386,
-0.0380132198,
-0.0570573695,
-0.0196048338,
0.0529165491,
-0.0026173878,
-0.0588673763,
-0.0164816994,
0.0480280928,
0.0083629023,
-0.0156635288,
-0.0404978059,
-0.0524560921,
-0.0464489907,
-0.057107836,
0.0316804573,
-0.0544999875,
0.0274552517,
0.0201885793,
0.008871071,
-0.0555537753,
0.0238664187,
0.006739099,
-0.0433926173,
0.0854352415,
-0.0073040635,
-0.0157984365,
-0.037829563,
-0.0276713241,
-0.026039945,
0.0840650424,
-0.0097343214,
-0.0068303067,
0.0446485989,
0.0007033821,
-0.0022887138,
0.0308401585,
0.0070463466,
0.0172160864,
-0.0174724422,
-0.0014335328,
0.0351772681,
-0.028360486,
-0.023519177,
0.027789006,
0.0111054648,
0.0002362924,
-0.0012543455,
-0.0181898642,
0.0330553651,
-0.0312892087,
0.051991377,
-0.025747247,
-0.0106647443,
0.0269489586,
-0.0662835464,
-0.0164819323,
-0.0495705232,
-0.0018520401,
0.0104135713,
-0.0139845647,
-0.0342317373,
-0.0123617854,
-0.0501023307,
0.0138233602,
-0.0083242077,
-0.0230570342,
0.0631212145,
0.0355985574,
-0.026253501,
0.0465530902,
0.0376319438,
-0.031803228,
-0.0030755547,
0.014188149,
0.0437293947,
0.0308396295,
0.0067268847,
-0.0319654569,
-0.0370427184,
0.0298065897,
0.0518924259,
0.052349098,
0.0326148346,
-0.041966375,
0.0416987762,
-0.0144221773,
-0.0283190515,
0.0084015951,
0.0380035266,
-0.0254291985,
0.0368127003,
-0.0144706853,
0.0064004348,
-0.0390076488,
-0.0123263588,
0.0564121269,
0.0057557719,
-0.0355463848,
0.033438582,
-0.0017622946,
0.029060876,
0.0044603078,
0.020610448,
0.0146796387,
0.0400811397,
-0.0298695732,
0.0045095487,
-0.0344062597,
-0.0393814072,
-0.0673630387,
0.0397432484,
0.0145181734,
-0.002126199,
-0.032843031,
-0.0653712377,
-0.046066761,
0.0121133626,
-0.0005821328,
0.0190717001,
-0.0344367325,
0.0142529346,
0.012190192,
-0.0047752918,
-0.0198335759,
0.0786924511,
0.0333545171,
0.0551080182,
0.0492688753,
-0.0175174903,
0.0043686372,
-0.0230136663,
-0.0150871975,
0.0058408948,
0.0062540323,
-0.0228707734,
0.0663429424,
0.0090367803,
-0.0497933924,
-0.0054834457,
-0.0438538454,
0.0037775189,
-0.0169545561,
0.0144696143,
0.0275036227,
-0.0086462209,
0.0213936716,
-0.0386288427,
-0.0198768508,
-0.0224236362,
0.0117684081,
0.0357268974,
0.0479998179,
0.0088045979,
-0.055879239,
-0.0190321133,
-0.0278608166,
-0.0574285351,
0.0466494635,
0.0030771666,
-0.0797807649,
-0.0365321971,
0.0094552459,
-0.008703283,
0.0552459285,
0.0042599319,
0.0323061273,
0.0005069893,
-0.0167160928,
0.0005976714,
0.0047981674,
-0.0288861021,
0.0263789818,
0.0500174314,
-0.0004271328,
-0.0336458348,
-0.0176558997,
-0.0487430058,
-0.0048368182,
-0.0016183874,
-0.0117272492,
-0.0043782233,
0.0932283923,
0.0174271166,
0.0038249192,
-0.0842441693,
0.0127040949,
-0.0539570302,
0.0015198792,
-0.0164993387,
0.0038582878,
0.0028481791,
0.059113618,
-0.0040525971,
0.0010610031,
0.0679851249,
-0.0443063527,
0.0041667526,
0.0166737176,
0.0258994997,
-0.0603140295,
0.06258028,
0.0339860991,
-0.0193069875,
0.0989573076,
-0.0078145154,
-0.06605272,
0.0137764039,
0.0542930588,
0.0090498375,
-0.0053936997,
-0.0545304231,
0.0441222042,
-0.0203417838,
-0.0512024499,
-0.047450304,
-0.0589485914,
-0.032893002,
0.0367022306,
-0.0106916688,
0.019986419,
-0.0154989548,
-0.0045977351,
-0.0444286764,
0.0285409354,
-0.0003477626,
0.0150705362,
-0.0344608724,
0.0660042763,
0.0483765528,
-0.0178050585,
-0.0010503294,
-0.039133057,
0.0037139619,
0.0156531595,
-0.0229716003,
0.0793929622,
-0.0109656667,
0.0076351594,
0.0435588583,
-0.02031927,
-0.0345258899,
0.0338602439,
0.0385704041,
-0.0368948653,
-0.0225609392,
0.124925673,
0.0486044362,
-0.0069427821,
0.0043790615,
0.022549348,
0.048858583,
0.0422852449,
0.0155061604,
-0.087887153,
-0.0542801954,
0.0094553232,
0.0072475304,
-0.023177363,
-0.0513879023,
-0.0077164085,
-0.1445696354,
0.0223880764,
-0.0038487853,
-0.030741673,
0.0237003341,
-0.036206089,
0.0192807876,
-0.0306004025,
-0.0228241179,
0.003528083,
-0.0096111447,
0.0087180175,
0.0399130769,
-0.0391288698,
-0.0204596184,
0.0268984791,
-0.0187656973,
0.0495540276,
0.0347747579,
-0.0044732555,
-0.0044696601,
-0.0124431113,
0.056903325,
-0.0140774082,
-0.0212194212,
-0.0099601438,
0.0273892898,
0.0052910764,
-0.0101774996,
-0.0011306537,
0.0376196653,
-0.0511822551,
-0.0293273907,
-0.0071098357,
0.0804291368,
0.0088531971,
-0.0392607935,
-0.0117657082,
-0.002608127,
0.0136572774,
0.0808747783,
0.0143985935,
-0.0194322672,
-0.0328725427,
-0.027057942,
0.0089027602,
-0.0169500019,
-0.0028900919,
0.0688345432,
-0.0195953492,
0.0285139158,
-0.071025148,
-0.0483978987,
0.0557595044,
-0.0151092866,
0.0080415225,
0.0088846255,
0.0014505034,
-0.0247611944,
-0.0123268431,
-0.0047673108,
-0.0244442131,
0.0107958205,
-0.0459503718,
0.0011233329,
0.016703831,
0.0199966244,
-0.0078335879,
0.0129635241,
-0.1045381874,
-0.0581206977,
-0.0282269139,
0.0450955555,
0.0143783987,
0.0316773131,
-0.0254109502,
-0.0349705443,
-0.009684423,
0.0516250916,
-0.0313252434,
0.0101143401,
0.0092266928,
-0.0267272461,
0.0033733218,
0.0577196479,
-0.0760845616,
0.0355273709,
0.0248327013,
0.0691238046,
-0.0080857659,
-0.0274151359,
0.0501089841,
0.0243054554,
0.0642791539,
-0.0444654375,
-0.0086460467,
-0.0270774942,
0.0049835881,
-0.0204885229,
-0.0673122182,
-0.0170336068,
0.0311059523,
0.0083145276,
-0.0246373285,
-0.0142326122,
0.0161692034,
-0.0270873178,
0.0803367496,
-0.0374888889,
-0.0122810341,
0.0943884999,
-0.0338084809,
0.0253175665,
-0.0007990689,
-0.0045933877,
0.0648471266,
0.0083197402,
0.0556637831,
-0.0307704583,
0.011218599,
0.0534427501,
0.0379727893,
-0.046246659,
-0.0272684619,
-0.0128159393,
-0.0009458125,
-0.0458284467,
0.0078199431,
0.0106872283,
-0.0247677546,
0.0336413272,
0.0043908847,
-0.0137482807,
-0.0417969748,
0.0470027104,
0.0483801626,
-0.0397404432,
0.0429768451,
0.0367829353,
-0.0291763172,
0.0040211049,
0.1100365743,
0.0467811413,
0.0247508511,
0.0424738638,
0.0152098294,
-0.0331687294,
0.0031735227,
-0.0323263891,
0.0289218556,
0.001829316,
0.0297779702,
-0.0605149195,
-0.0450570844,
0.0631147698,
-0.0181479249,
0.0121002113,
0.025987735,
0.0127347996,
0.0315386839,
0.0193174127,
-0.0309183244,
-0.0499392524,
-0.0454547144,
0.0315516852,
-0.0236821417,
-0.0423028171,
-6.386659173e-33,
-0.023160385,
-0.0515662394,
-0.0231077094,
-0.0121931992,
0.0344741344,
0.0193495955,
-0.0341363586,
0.0023356008,
-0.003681384,
0.0198920909,
-0.0137622235,
-0.0051520942,
0.017680943,
0.0315884873,
0.0506247655,
-0.0249216836,
0.0187027622,
0.0138256131,
-0.0325017683,
-0.0077932947,
0.0499790013,
0.0007942843,
0.0463038757,
-0.026042046,
0.059213575,
-0.0020475872,
-0.0138704767,
0.0321796685,
0.0221418738,
0.0534039214,
-0.0162371323,
0.052662082,
0.0389853492,
-0.0428530462,
0.0059607602,
0.0098760948,
-0.0915459022,
-0.037516091,
0.0169088896,
0.0025117227,
-0.0573289096,
0.00076874,
-0.0127126034,
-0.0332554206,
0.0155229168,
-0.0146550639,
0.04357085,
-0.0106149688,
-0.0244498141,
-0.0311183892,
-0.084795326,
0.0266328547,
0.0106167858,
-0.0057331901,
0.0232417583,
0.0657782853,
0.0202785637,
0.0484310389,
-0.0454743877,
0.0048246458,
-0.0036342628,
0.0529333763,
0.0092885401,
0.032926552,
-0.0381004885,
0.0530985333,
0.005703154,
-0.0060293018,
-0.0320482701,
-0.0162014179,
0.0002737654,
0.0354690216,
0.0431930386,
0.0471322313,
0.024442682,
0.0485683344,
-0.0766296238,
-0.0100231571,
0.0253262371,
0.0249576811,
-0.0008413363,
-0.0016564295,
-0.0361308195,
-0.0767871737,
-0.0502057634,
-0.0727674365,
-0.046137955,
0.0181112699,
0.0268820263,
0.0365447029,
-0.0184438732,
0.0288320351,
0.0402786508,
-0.0442457497,
-0.0529509299,
0.0046686353,
-0.015395605,
0.0186135657,
0.0034370429,
0.0377042852,
-0.052194044,
-0.0293264966,
0.0314752869,
-0.0184976757,
0.0400119275,
-0.0027465709,
0.0726638585,
0.0047513959,
-0.0537261851,
-0.0150282783,
-0.0444988795,
-0.0010961777,
-0.0248150285,
0.0085426867,
0.0483908355,
0.0493399687,
-0.0084103271,
0.074147433,
0.0386828706,
0.0187881347,
0.0004711508,
0.0185745563,
-0.0134524526,
0.0158409327,
-0.0253625456,
-0.03880677,
-0.0005865177,
-0.0010136829,
0.0540204868,
-0.0288291648,
-0.0110883825,
0.0076027489,
2.5e-7,
0.0597387441,
0.0638148859,
0.0146801788,
0.0341521539,
0.032974869,
0.0380675644,
0.0087790033,
0.0137601588,
-0.0354996473,
-0.0677251965,
-0.0152670182,
-0.0271470994,
0.0301161185,
0.0463868007,
-0.0844321772,
0.0310290866,
-0.083312504,
0.0067841839,
-0.0278478265,
-0.0140866777,
0.0585224181,
0.0940719917,
0.0085867085,
0.017797811,
-0.0282248668,
-0.0240190569,
0.050321091,
0.0313895606,
0.0027007738,
0.0053231963,
-0.0112904264,
-0.0265908986,
0.020422738,
0.047170911,
-0.0024571009,
0.0060781073,
-0.0017640367,
0.0371685363,
-0.0207262319,
-0.0131071266,
-0.0138763534,
0.0066263792,
-0.0077520162,
-0.015021625,
0.0878436565,
-0.0590659678,
-0.0243484639,
-0.0263645444,
-0.0298884939,
0.0242769346,
-0.0071494877,
0.0326869152,
-0.0236650929,
0.0351646356,
0.027679164,
0.0098784855,
-0.0505891964,
-0.0453275256,
-0.0226603243,
-0.0181326456,
-0.0087503288,
-0.0180531926,
0.012630214,
-0.0019665915,
-0.0214415975,
-0.0868481547,
-0.0018824906,
2.434117504e-34,
0.0243968051,
0.0115450677,
0.001939483,
0.0468339957,
0.018772928,
-0.0333849564,
-0.0469896235,
0.0208714046,
0.0284059588,
-0.070053339,
-0.0191405825
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06866v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06866v2 | Health-LLM: Large Language Models for Health Prediction via Wearable Sensor Data | 2024-01-12T19:40:11 | 2024-04-27T06:20:26 | Yubin Kim, Xuhai Xu, Daniel McDuff, Cynthia Breazeal, Hae Won Park | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) are capable of many natural language tasks, yet
they are far from perfect. In health applications, grounding and interpreting
domain-specific and non-linguistic data is crucial. This paper investigates the
capacity of LLMs to make inferences about health based on contextual
information (e.g. user demographics, health knowledge) and physiological data
(e.g. resting heart rate, sleep minutes). We present a comprehensive evaluation
of 12 state-of-the-art LLMs with prompting and fine-tuning techniques on four
public health datasets (PMData, LifeSnaps, GLOBEM and AW_FB). Our experiments
cover 10 consumer health prediction tasks in mental health, activity,
metabolic, and sleep assessment. Our fine-tuned model, HealthAlpaca exhibits
comparable performance to much larger models (GPT-3.5, GPT-4 and Gemini-Pro),
achieving the best performance in 8 out of 10 tasks. Ablation studies highlight
the effectiveness of context enhancement strategies. Notably, we observe that
our context enhancement can yield up to 23.8% improvement in performance. While
constructing contextually rich prompts (combining user context, health
knowledge and temporal information) exhibits synergistic improvement, the
inclusion of health knowledge context in prompts significantly enhances overall
performance. | [
0.0399923772,
0.0545199513,
-0.0108532198,
-0.007001475,
0.008133145,
0.0055033006,
0.0131567512,
-0.0075792279,
0.0414587297,
-0.0259580985,
0.0012511836,
-0.0154768452,
0.0172146279,
0.0201102793,
-0.0066263597,
-0.0264269058,
0.0193396341,
-0.009377704,
0.0578527115,
0.033650957,
0.0143569112,
-0.0041907569,
0.0064023151,
0.0581341125,
-0.0102463346,
-0.0006082091,
0.0137633011,
-0.0104470793,
0.0242663566,
-0.1110028699,
0.0217966661,
0.0563540496,
-0.0122204097,
-0.0108963586,
0.0000019565,
-0.0378030576,
0.007949966,
0.026467599,
-0.0276622027,
-0.0620635338,
0.0635194033,
-0.0455617197,
0.0286007859,
0.0227545556,
-0.061123237,
-0.0134102544,
0.0443933941,
0.0420843475,
0.0197436754,
0.0353128649,
-0.0265371613,
0.0138176093,
-0.0259733498,
-0.0093277097,
0.0344623737,
-0.0223550685,
0.0450177677,
-0.0308969431,
0.0469630584,
-0.0190703664,
0.0111869797,
0.0242597312,
-0.0140349176,
0.071427539,
0.0044065728,
0.0248239748,
-0.0010118522,
-0.0211427193,
-0.0099346694,
0.084945105,
0.0135342954,
0.022740012,
0.0041999272,
0.0081044054,
-0.0084371464,
-0.0252205767,
-0.0412188917,
-0.0297120716,
-0.0199945327,
0.0342060737,
0.018547792,
0.0499514192,
0.0669138357,
0.0075561423,
-0.0156764816,
0.0908706412,
0.0011022151,
-0.0317322612,
0.0082462011,
-0.0023749236,
-0.0134969382,
-0.0351365134,
0.0310633387,
0.0063278615,
-0.0440488979,
0.0131373778,
-0.0331057534,
0.0024169709,
0.0472929738,
-0.0411518142,
0.0005401534,
0.0551644601,
-0.0159226749,
0.0135578429,
0.0183899309,
-0.0002836814,
0.0159046985,
-0.0305075366,
-0.0379857458,
-0.0187450349,
-0.0315417573,
0.0138078211,
-0.0037697894,
-0.007122973,
-0.0433130488,
-0.0130693838,
-0.1004161462,
0.0032380284,
-0.0111629367,
-0.0070040217,
-0.0052465508,
0.0148128187,
-0.0059634573,
0.0064673219,
-0.032600712,
0.0085519496,
0.0060636722,
0.0318253823,
-0.0000029277,
-0.0568442754,
0.0185756888,
-0.0199280586,
0.0029381635,
-0.0219740625,
0.0156962927,
0.0394791774,
0.0513483137,
-0.0348988511,
-0.0395750329,
-0.0350466296,
-0.0372060277,
-0.0333393328,
-0.0394126102,
-0.0609623902,
0.0325561017,
0.0071112304,
0.01116441,
-0.0384195559,
0.0372489579,
0.038924519,
-0.0403949358,
0.1049393117,
-0.0482003316,
0.0041081505,
0.0071780114,
0.0168015137,
0.0394518785,
0.065640673,
0.044030685,
-0.0192672685,
0.0219149347,
-0.030747287,
-0.0242332611,
0.043954175,
0.0132154217,
-0.0402377807,
0.0288798157,
0.0060217455,
-0.0044278852,
0.036484655,
-0.0335803926,
0.0446563102,
0.0288671292,
0.0420109518,
0.086867623,
0.0621966273,
0.003009733,
0.0073344158,
0.0064286566,
-0.0149297975,
-0.0277800579,
-0.0471545197,
-0.0796217844,
-0.027600769,
-0.0523875616,
-0.0136848176,
-0.014887169,
0.0238968674,
-0.013966647,
-0.0464579575,
-0.0425175913,
-0.0489242747,
0.0499266014,
0.0141071388,
0.0234052483,
-0.0337717794,
-0.015480035,
0.0420641452,
0.0490347669,
-0.0157491602,
-0.01377548,
-0.0125543457,
0.0262988694,
0.1092474088,
0.0047486392,
-0.0207074285,
-0.0069654454,
0.0066290274,
0.0280711353,
-0.0105357617,
0.0088137342,
0.0078256531,
0.0398033597,
-0.0547411367,
-0.0364591517,
0.0411079377,
0.0025937613,
-0.0395073816,
0.0041916082,
0.0575807393,
0.0243149456,
0.0111847185,
-0.026737744,
0.010641288,
-0.034836743,
-0.0335480496,
0.0380860865,
0.007677645,
0.0290143639,
0.0262203496,
0.041753564,
0.0146073652,
0.029169742,
-0.0594004206,
-0.0179685019,
0.052299656,
-0.0585348792,
-0.0277695935,
0.0187740978,
0.0258423928,
0.0281238295,
-0.0141010694,
-0.0220701434,
-0.0349476226,
-0.0326602608,
-0.0511071533,
0.0457524657,
-0.012414569,
-0.0341519341,
0.0334377252,
0.0447193421,
-0.0350315012,
0.0356766321,
-0.001921627,
0.0033303271,
0.0173451547,
-0.0011444304,
-0.023933785,
-0.0515274778,
-0.0261701066,
-0.01000294,
0.008315823,
0.0098654861,
0.0050484468,
0.043133527,
-0.0449680947,
-0.0044799484,
-0.1556801051,
0.0097721647,
-0.0137081547,
-0.0054521845,
0.0015018426,
0.0460928492,
-0.0242169145,
-0.0242596027,
-0.0399768502,
-0.0059511866,
0.0101251947,
0.0474704318,
-0.0013073718,
0.0312019773,
-0.0105643962,
0.0030215231,
0.0154565945,
-0.0402690023,
0.0167838354,
0.016178919,
-0.0186686013,
-0.0106360428,
-0.0418561958,
-0.0382888801,
-0.0027769709,
0.0144695165,
0.0231538098,
-0.0132950377,
0.000048533,
0.0769026577,
0.0185032245,
-0.0105757816,
0.0224733241,
0.0481564105,
-0.0098410314,
-0.0226903185,
0.0057076006,
-0.0531650297,
0.0068111205,
-0.0291639529,
-0.0780787244,
-0.0124394856,
0.0567397662,
0.0414571539,
0.0195234194,
-0.0376474261,
0.0327475891,
-0.0319630727,
0.0170263778,
-0.0628985241,
0.048752673,
-0.0270019602,
0.0687581748,
0.0043260711,
-0.062110357,
0.0615999699,
-0.0119347991,
0.014225577,
-0.0433312915,
-0.0483955219,
-0.0359102152,
0.0195790883,
-0.0130570764,
0.0083286958,
0.0361288153,
-0.0186680779,
0.0142643647,
-0.0335671939,
-0.0480680652,
-0.0688879862,
0.0241408087,
-0.0679044649,
-0.0017288788,
0.020964684,
-0.0797031075,
-0.0466033369,
-0.0451199524,
-0.0930838659,
-0.0052171559,
-0.0160977133,
0.0180779509,
-0.030225452,
0.0002333365,
-0.0326565281,
0.027384473,
0.0135140102,
-0.0122821657,
0.008462741,
0.0079863137,
0.0665459782,
0.0480144881,
0.009180665,
-0.0016444919,
0.0248958133,
0.0496498942,
-0.0065912786,
0.0134102702,
-0.0256972946,
0.0218375009,
0.0060934927,
0.0126225716,
-0.0058323443,
0.04680999,
0.0471163169,
-0.0430559292,
0.0213880558,
0.1510489732,
0.0107606435,
-0.0364148207,
0.0347509757,
-0.0074524977,
-0.0082887057,
-0.0097796768,
-0.0050218613,
-0.0737534612,
-0.0703693405,
-0.0037807079,
0.0635387748,
-0.0260469671,
-0.0187374931,
-0.0135050723,
-0.0365570597,
0.0002611353,
0.0168186557,
-0.0201006159,
-0.032419052,
-0.0490267389,
0.019149363,
-0.0313208848,
0.0334747955,
-0.0514328703,
0.0069439863,
0.0115338871,
-0.0081750993,
-0.0809040815,
-0.0752350017,
0.0509499274,
-0.0001455343,
0.0363477096,
0.0771741867,
0.0471160971,
0.0142023442,
-0.0240687542,
-0.0036607285,
-0.0167428106,
0.0120158065,
-0.0560438819,
0.0083401268,
0.0225705374,
-0.0134773115,
-0.0572912134,
0.0812008604,
-0.0618382432,
-0.0418221839,
0.0443426482,
0.0801422596,
-0.0112236198,
-0.0129481088,
-0.0483007729,
0.0357944183,
0.0656428933,
0.0751695931,
-0.0037331604,
-0.0622548014,
-0.0057971263,
-0.004906558,
-0.0183319915,
0.0178810246,
-0.0317920782,
0.0053809923,
-0.028800521,
-0.0041174632,
-0.0383259878,
-0.0400058143,
0.0396793485,
0.0013853518,
0.0272369832,
0.0574016161,
0.0404456072,
0.0183781981,
-0.0498014651,
0.0709071979,
0.008671239,
0.0402757265,
-0.0390865803,
0.0018769393,
0.0378624238,
-0.0110575613,
0.0091480603,
0.0565649942,
-0.0787008852,
-0.0296179373,
-0.0031138521,
0.0487936921,
0.0206628516,
0.049854178,
-0.0265575256,
-0.0292575564,
0.0145366769,
0.0574480332,
-0.0376022123,
0.0198691692,
-0.0148458621,
0.0461524203,
0.0219699629,
0.0362057239,
-0.0034462947,
0.0189270061,
-0.0140081532,
0.0323765464,
-0.0396292694,
-0.0365560316,
0.0148564046,
0.0261629838,
0.0665150434,
-0.0214698687,
-0.0121405013,
0.0059880917,
0.0034148861,
-0.0350659005,
-0.0152765773,
-0.0280821491,
0.0039070281,
0.0158002656,
0.0228161197,
-0.0126900198,
0.0012435636,
-0.0356886387,
-0.0416271202,
-0.0637780502,
0.0476594754,
-0.0074832565,
0.0278045554,
0.0482629426,
-0.0126876337,
0.0031092782,
0.0255984757,
-0.0185873248,
0.0006201398,
-0.0043762811,
0.0625914931,
-0.0207318552,
-0.0173051246,
-0.026294183,
0.0491945855,
-0.0393072814,
0.0055262865,
0.0159624144,
0.0211960655,
0.0021886297,
-0.0059519806,
0.015178876,
-0.0056902077,
-0.016097663,
-0.0393675528,
0.0373338349,
-0.0035744072,
-0.0064210338,
0.0833309144,
-0.0118944561,
-0.041848477,
-0.0039957906,
0.0744233951,
0.0123502025,
0.0117941136,
0.0437575839,
-0.0710097402,
-0.0356522165,
0.0169151872,
0.0125117768,
0.0346526429,
-0.0840989575,
0.0055153905,
-0.0674600974,
-0.0640702099,
0.0605342276,
-0.0266231298,
-0.0258533079,
-0.0029971802,
0.0367364399,
0.0289660823,
-0.026873026,
-0.043040555,
-0.0207839366,
0.0334636495,
-0.0604139157,
-0.0285605416,
-0.0185581017,
-6.021334263e-33,
-0.0157844238,
-0.0443906859,
0.0300568212,
-0.0065899701,
-0.0033787347,
0.0312087461,
-0.0285638738,
0.0136052575,
0.0092237433,
-0.0021468229,
0.0021182545,
-0.0078982478,
0.0176028982,
0.0364546068,
0.0002271809,
-0.0560255907,
0.035366185,
0.0213180576,
-0.0087326495,
0.01121426,
0.0157108717,
0.0648964345,
0.0221153665,
-0.1021814048,
0.0378942303,
0.0121264253,
0.0040235752,
0.0226724632,
-0.0121044107,
0.0444667935,
-0.0670960918,
0.1060404554,
0.0345327742,
0.0285627265,
-0.0225195959,
0.0738839507,
-0.0517245345,
-0.0367191173,
0.0282662418,
-0.0192175806,
-0.0196558665,
-0.0388919935,
0.03547417,
-0.0103535885,
-0.0348095559,
0.0083341179,
0.0363728851,
-0.0862525254,
-0.0252536479,
-0.0045350436,
0.0090315919,
0.0234659165,
0.0083594844,
0.0058346605,
-0.0197327603,
0.0277616382,
-0.0508331731,
0.0365454592,
-0.0574590079,
0.0183266904,
0.0303462762,
-0.0052223643,
0.0152886612,
0.0184038319,
0.0055370107,
0.0489119962,
0.0030058492,
-0.0290317275,
-0.0314079933,
0.0147425691,
-0.0182826873,
0.0511444509,
0.0279131401,
0.0330326483,
0.0175046921,
-0.0203322526,
-0.0686699077,
0.0180026256,
-0.0142928949,
-0.0362285972,
0.0332516655,
-0.0021373848,
-0.0364326127,
-0.0358099528,
-0.0252896957,
0.0296812151,
-0.0418674052,
-0.0274483971,
0.032754153,
0.0182782952,
0.0150480028,
0.0288070571,
-0.0236573927,
-0.0509519242,
0.0100081973,
-0.0029813407,
0.0316408277,
-0.0490763746,
-0.0015254044,
-0.0024181686,
-0.0452500694,
0.0208785217,
-0.0047867512,
0.0296228509,
0.0291201342,
-0.0166192129,
0.0154870534,
0.0132879727,
-0.036147546,
-0.0421825722,
0.0243659932,
0.0204962455,
-0.0078202933,
-0.0144619448,
0.0447138511,
0.0035139951,
-0.0109796552,
0.101431638,
-0.0019976033,
0.0311070345,
-0.0469917282,
-0.0134932548,
0.0204068329,
0.009943679,
-0.0200320389,
-0.0268996004,
-0.0186393764,
0.0168471653,
0.0348816328,
-0.0425548889,
-0.0094639286,
-0.0119643481,
2.664e-7,
0.0446572006,
0.043944519,
-0.0544538423,
-0.0506642461,
0.0288458895,
0.0281753968,
-0.0081950286,
0.0176236052,
0.0021532134,
0.0147110112,
0.0161101427,
0.0046257428,
0.0462837294,
0.0409448631,
-0.04735763,
-0.0226933733,
-0.0271159541,
-0.0183745269,
-0.0742330924,
0.010173643,
0.056747131,
0.0995651782,
-0.0061586709,
-0.023249751,
0.0244052429,
-0.0278105251,
0.032621637,
-0.0665454641,
-0.0331755131,
-0.0295142755,
0.0021412941,
0.0135419909,
0.0149034141,
-0.0105736647,
-0.0147435088,
-0.0050198357,
-0.0073877745,
0.092250444,
-0.0207380038,
0.0122888461,
-0.0094448198,
0.0226250105,
-0.0250795465,
-0.0201946795,
0.0932641476,
-0.0683317482,
-0.0641496405,
-0.0212536119,
0.0077100857,
-0.031421721,
0.0171501264,
-0.0168801807,
-0.0188893601,
-0.0036968403,
0.0283385385,
-0.0138604632,
-0.0189854447,
-0.0502696857,
-0.0343607925,
0.0322363079,
-0.0314330198,
-0.0480830744,
-0.0335580371,
-0.0025223377,
-0.0078305164,
-0.088791579,
0.0359245613,
2.377207277e-34,
0.0087900804,
0.0151236812,
0.005224443,
-0.0040447963,
0.0260108523,
0.0009913924,
0.0138471778,
0.0378697626,
0.0234566759,
-0.0969093964,
-0.0152501743
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06855v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06855v3 | Fine-grained Hallucination Detection and Editing for Language Models | 2024-01-12T19:02:48 | 2024-02-21T22:20:12 | Abhika Mishra, Akari Asai, Vidhisha Balachandran, Yizhong Wang, Graham Neubig, Yulia Tsvetkov, Hannaneh Hajishirzi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LMs) are prone to generate factual errors, which are
often called hallucinations. In this paper, we introduce a comprehensive
taxonomy of hallucinations and argue that hallucinations manifest in diverse
forms, each requiring varying degrees of careful assessments to verify
factuality. We propose a novel task of automatic fine-grained hallucination
detection and construct a new evaluation benchmark, FavaBench, that includes
about one thousand fine-grained human judgments on three LM outputs across
various domains. Our analysis reveals that ChatGPT and Llama2-Chat (70B, 7B)
exhibit diverse types of hallucinations in the majority of their outputs in
information-seeking scenarios. We train FAVA, a retrieval-augmented LM by
carefully creating synthetic data to detect and correct fine-grained
hallucinations. On our benchmark, our automatic and human evaluations show that
FAVA significantly outperforms ChatGPT and GPT-4 on fine-grained hallucination
detection, and edits suggested by FAVA improve the factuality of LM-generated
text. | [
0.0654632151,
0.0293188784,
-0.021950284,
0.0434790514,
-0.0485677421,
0.0154118612,
-0.0459285975,
0.0195270572,
0.011871255,
-0.0710094422,
-0.0245467145,
-0.0631422997,
0.0015991681,
-0.009018206,
0.0391332731,
-0.0526570566,
0.0802708343,
-0.0241256319,
0.0191940591,
-0.0043354691,
0.0199534316,
0.0103426296,
0.0124875521,
0.0387311913,
-0.0176041331,
-0.0375143178,
0.0027182335,
0.0084581189,
0.0000533816,
0.0122511722,
0.0108144386,
0.0893080011,
-0.029030228,
0.0980498791,
0.0000022021,
-0.0437486097,
-0.0120119341,
-0.0098584676,
-0.0139962984,
0.048535388,
0.0609188229,
0.0082582301,
-0.0340390727,
0.0078287199,
-0.0279661957,
0.0009015958,
0.035042759,
0.0825058818,
0.0709393397,
0.0845511183,
-0.0050230375,
-0.0192149635,
0.0363191217,
0.0153199574,
0.0619346723,
0.0162172802,
0.0424574688,
0.022409115,
-0.0033402266,
-0.0001147967,
0.0153331514,
0.0303376075,
-0.0044943099,
-0.0267383717,
-0.0110079963,
0.0163255781,
-0.1059730724,
-0.029173065,
0.0144508677,
0.0495494045,
-0.0213664789,
-0.0597447269,
0.0075354823,
0.0143391863,
0.0179420672,
-0.0248262212,
-0.0214525554,
0.0104882969,
-0.0238967743,
0.0057194023,
0.0331034809,
-0.0432344303,
0.0420752317,
0.0012075504,
-0.0255175289,
0.0557929352,
0.0174359176,
-0.0510794856,
0.0002936786,
-0.007369007,
-0.0044429889,
-0.0675467178,
0.0154145695,
0.0070208553,
-0.0410713851,
-0.0106634283,
-0.0533961616,
0.0160910618,
0.0556856766,
-0.0985758677,
-0.0054460983,
0.0084172925,
-0.0733071342,
0.0508289859,
-0.0147859138,
0.0273206271,
-0.0146650942,
0.0697981417,
-0.0104524521,
0.0046459897,
-0.0211111698,
-0.0077693802,
-0.0430416688,
0.0109320674,
-0.0058816387,
0.0002199714,
-0.0308239721,
-0.0147618186,
-0.036890354,
0.0165910032,
-0.0246539805,
0.0074550356,
0.0051392354,
-0.031134313,
-0.0275574662,
0.0146345384,
-0.0038041917,
-0.0018355589,
0.0223495755,
-0.0928936154,
-0.0143965809,
0.0116130896,
-0.0171921439,
-0.0077478541,
0.0097672911,
0.0173170157,
0.0152772954,
-0.0208680574,
-0.0447011814,
-0.0302029923,
-0.0119309453,
-0.0781199709,
-0.0070527904,
-0.0676511079,
-0.0017324984,
-0.011422745,
-0.0203659479,
-0.0169935618,
0.0290610436,
0.0195562616,
-0.0448176824,
0.0793237239,
-0.0499002263,
-0.0003756777,
0.0472912602,
0.0250032227,
-0.0160050392,
0.0670838654,
0.0131529598,
0.0562348515,
0.044038292,
-0.0051794052,
0.0508903228,
0.0419386104,
-0.0182258524,
0.0181057286,
-0.0248240456,
-0.0058377716,
-0.0011584505,
0.0211641472,
0.0015716807,
0.0827769488,
-0.0200085063,
-0.0127282329,
0.0830950886,
0.0092813959,
0.0097816307,
0.0058662361,
0.0317202657,
0.0081532197,
0.0236176867,
0.0476268455,
-0.0725327432,
0.0213595442,
-0.0681155398,
-0.0033876584,
0.0692800134,
-0.0043550599,
0.0080217309,
-0.0427890234,
-0.0232642051,
0.0222719181,
0.009825822,
-0.0175715704,
0.0139767472,
0.0261177719,
-0.0613200702,
0.0317804255,
0.0507210977,
-0.021458542,
-0.0007840932,
-0.066002883,
-0.0071291793,
0.105830051,
0.0791585892,
-0.0205683559,
-0.001167428,
-0.0350210555,
0.0271220338,
0.0613379255,
0.0718302131,
0.0077996734,
-0.0272287671,
-0.0394646414,
0.0260331929,
-0.0010635552,
0.070707567,
-0.0031876087,
-0.0024037967,
-0.0177868791,
0.0077490513,
-0.0391487852,
-0.0621875823,
0.035861183,
0.0026094436,
-0.0121158222,
-0.0465516709,
-0.0227939617,
-0.0177761,
-0.0085974392,
-0.0275912527,
0.0359651744,
-0.0127875945,
-0.0176492408,
-0.0317470059,
-0.0026511401,
0.0029056671,
-0.0040893881,
0.0510412976,
0.0018330551,
-0.0223849434,
0.0072722444,
-0.0017830551,
-0.0152674969,
0.0065615629,
-0.0543504395,
0.0359000079,
-0.0613818876,
0.0541467741,
-0.0133818444,
0.0428245589,
-0.0153149338,
0.0821805745,
-0.0178198963,
0.0180910211,
0.0031261302,
-0.0046449439,
-0.0233873501,
-0.0189005043,
-0.0306915324,
0.0166998897,
0.0061270874,
0.0312241931,
-0.0093485825,
-0.0306587964,
-0.0553489923,
-0.0358471721,
-0.0720376149,
0.0002602225,
-0.0288585871,
0.0039233202,
0.0442329422,
-0.019983504,
-0.0191283301,
0.0144307809,
0.0056548817,
0.0115509257,
0.0043688789,
0.0434302539,
0.020229809,
-0.0020535756,
-0.0362444706,
-0.0545722581,
0.0283674859,
-0.0277286898,
0.0297399424,
-0.0001842791,
-0.0428857096,
-0.0701259449,
0.0292744562,
-0.0500675216,
0.0203581676,
-0.0067639207,
-0.0482960343,
0.0027250033,
-0.019802006,
0.0615308397,
0.0478901416,
0.0317829736,
0.0333285257,
0.0701500252,
-0.0254583526,
-0.0242930185,
-0.0234038513,
0.0073694438,
0.0058754273,
-0.004106719,
-0.0589730851,
0.0200561956,
0.055572357,
0.0101956222,
0.0079225125,
-0.0518929884,
0.0423377603,
-0.0414535999,
-0.0465525277,
0.0300671719,
-0.0252073649,
-0.030606512,
0.0551744513,
-0.042127654,
-0.0493052267,
0.0751047134,
-0.0385239609,
0.012475457,
-0.0086278338,
-0.0107279792,
0.0064284275,
0.023246916,
0.0081579452,
0.0152655672,
0.0100784451,
-0.0232102256,
-0.036202047,
-0.0020066637,
0.0063823704,
-0.0675664321,
0.0268296245,
-0.0442684628,
0.0100650657,
0.0315007456,
-0.0064541576,
-0.0490878597,
-0.044878412,
-0.017585855,
-0.0246212557,
-0.0034398742,
0.003232755,
-0.0429633632,
-0.0010591097,
-0.0018168748,
0.0393206142,
-0.0301881433,
-0.0201020036,
0.0046068733,
-0.0079601659,
0.0600900799,
-0.0298318435,
0.0602674931,
-0.0520741828,
0.0119942371,
0.0698913112,
0.0076694083,
0.0331038758,
-0.0088697141,
-0.0406468101,
0.0105489278,
-0.0292392299,
-0.0441968143,
-0.0052960701,
0.0340105742,
-0.0596663579,
-0.0395970605,
0.1131471023,
0.0397834368,
-0.0526406877,
0.0074231662,
-0.0621461719,
0.0449321307,
0.0088401437,
0.0135893906,
-0.0844968483,
-0.0209651701,
0.0172823519,
-0.0149573199,
-0.0420595482,
-0.0168672781,
-0.0096870624,
-0.090020746,
0.0460450277,
0.0210497938,
-0.0126043493,
-0.0350877382,
-0.0114237377,
0.0248265974,
0.0215323027,
0.0292409435,
0.0176542252,
0.0050437273,
-0.0170306545,
-0.0003601853,
-0.026652569,
-0.0401234068,
0.0381560102,
-0.0132497149,
0.0819083974,
0.0736182258,
0.0368121825,
-0.012239485,
-0.0723868683,
0.0458031036,
0.0156585984,
-0.0127860866,
0.0210345481,
0.0654324815,
0.0172848515,
0.0067895288,
-0.0181081183,
-0.003587397,
0.0076321419,
-0.0100358808,
-0.0117611289,
0.064624615,
-0.0462926477,
-0.0482728109,
0.0062797517,
0.0405335054,
0.0132256607,
0.0684348345,
0.0447394215,
-0.0221436564,
-0.0418350287,
-0.0421526395,
0.0354318358,
-0.0321922265,
-0.062535204,
0.0313870646,
0.0326972939,
-0.0278299004,
-0.0839820132,
-0.0501560867,
0.0087624509,
-0.0060651698,
0.0061624716,
0.0255141594,
-0.0184013415,
-0.0201988705,
-0.0023361363,
0.0221453421,
-0.0481167957,
0.0162760392,
-0.0419018827,
0.0091241105,
0.0075676902,
-0.0129795074,
0.0017847999,
0.0241531879,
-0.0869581774,
-0.0725307092,
0.0551812015,
0.0287629142,
0.0279694702,
0.0316220038,
-0.0447062626,
-0.0543078147,
0.018812608,
0.0565103553,
-0.0097969566,
0.0281904079,
0.0129085649,
-0.0263065081,
0.0130631831,
0.0398216955,
-0.020488508,
0.0145644387,
-0.0338540412,
0.0155201703,
0.0034189753,
-0.024848422,
0.0535552911,
0.0108410753,
0.0217015687,
-0.0088497214,
0.0021093187,
-0.0326509513,
0.0001705767,
-0.0313526727,
-0.02913698,
-0.0096771838,
-0.0086736465,
0.0206735693,
-0.0224573705,
0.0010932724,
-0.030286856,
-0.0511238389,
0.0123836426,
-0.047087267,
-0.0323096439,
-0.011661157,
0.0181338172,
0.0514359213,
-0.0233387686,
-0.01820134,
0.0275396109,
0.0004229089,
0.0567910224,
-0.014035115,
0.0567456335,
0.0113522606,
-0.0403212421,
-0.0148001779,
0.0266820528,
-0.0313271284,
-0.0537587702,
-0.0287867654,
0.0509532653,
0.0533573851,
0.0051103933,
0.0806492716,
-0.033610601,
-0.0020104183,
-0.0103852153,
0.0133586489,
0.0439842828,
-0.0457878858,
-0.024526475,
0.0250015184,
-0.0277918726,
-0.0104177892,
0.0626970008,
-0.0362271369,
0.0712041408,
0.0093823578,
-0.029652454,
-0.0261304677,
-0.0584628284,
-0.0746507868,
-0.0079866033,
-0.0271539204,
-0.0309069306,
-0.0779991671,
-0.051445093,
-0.0330486372,
0.0236487016,
-0.0054519083,
-0.0089596743,
-0.007555393,
0.0886820778,
-0.0190344937,
-0.0025118634,
-0.0372970067,
-0.0106651541,
0.0383547731,
-0.0028378773,
-0.0026149296,
-7.034674678e-33,
0.0040101162,
-0.031829793,
0.003479738,
-0.0207506139,
-0.0280791111,
-0.0292256773,
-0.0251310244,
0.0195582639,
-0.0010303645,
0.0342549942,
-0.0097793136,
0.0416180827,
0.0137357991,
-0.0146005023,
0.004192512,
-0.0034707319,
0.0506080016,
0.0190742295,
-0.0304011274,
0.0235901698,
0.0175534841,
0.0091427499,
0.0616285391,
-0.0562979877,
0.0628020391,
-0.0297774281,
-0.0469359308,
0.0260889344,
-0.0353446156,
0.0430433862,
-0.0207889788,
0.0317629799,
0.0117697865,
-0.0193274468,
-0.0180094168,
-0.0171385966,
-0.0117945988,
-0.004320967,
0.023861194,
0.0233665742,
-0.0197409652,
-0.0215983,
0.0465622433,
-0.0338960551,
0.0025459952,
0.0116243195,
0.0298825633,
-0.0355660357,
-0.0004022316,
0.0529200733,
-0.072295256,
0.0148924375,
0.0216000136,
-0.0280806608,
-0.0058808052,
0.045556616,
0.0029314458,
-0.0170418937,
-0.0873849541,
0.0338108242,
0.012036887,
0.0286451112,
0.0297790188,
-0.0258283895,
-0.0034433019,
0.0770376697,
0.0646263361,
0.051602032,
-0.0357106514,
-0.0161490068,
0.0264072791,
0.036997389,
0.026932301,
0.0342742465,
0.0555514842,
-0.0281527452,
-0.0254837163,
-0.0007666985,
-0.0470859483,
0.0233718026,
0.0562832244,
0.0023248976,
-0.0545846224,
-0.022567803,
-0.0090741189,
0.0211214125,
-0.0495922565,
-0.0212097596,
0.0134743396,
0.0007380843,
-0.0168288145,
-0.0307083614,
0.0133880293,
-0.0307183266,
0.005693879,
-0.0030889416,
-0.046706479,
0.0078437999,
-0.0030141564,
0.0112111559,
0.0244910102,
-0.0076158047,
0.0239808094,
0.0009694346,
0.0228475872,
0.023641564,
0.0269007739,
0.0002562776,
-0.072410427,
0.0204036497,
-0.0405712575,
0.0479999371,
-0.0038633018,
-0.0235747974,
0.0458333008,
-0.0088579264,
-0.0251517929,
-0.0023421834,
0.0584783219,
0.0434959121,
-0.0239941571,
0.0347480774,
-0.0390613563,
0.0075146598,
-0.0356063806,
0.0060356068,
-0.0529771,
-0.0027903307,
0.0409618989,
-0.0728690475,
-0.0022110362,
-0.008526532,
2.934e-7,
0.0075482768,
0.0909862965,
0.0080935843,
0.0121762324,
0.0154092778,
0.0447701253,
0.0063753556,
0.0068249614,
0.0333456434,
-0.0446429439,
-0.0268554892,
0.007823213,
0.0559336208,
0.0613087118,
-0.0716020614,
-0.0092108417,
-0.0484790206,
-0.0007765018,
-0.0637924075,
-0.0587871708,
0.0437507927,
0.057039611,
0.0322514325,
-0.0226954781,
-0.0014556629,
-0.0594524629,
0.0621407814,
-0.0146816857,
-0.0228446405,
0.0483444706,
0.0626876801,
0.0397848599,
0.0252775978,
0.0265139043,
-0.0114670191,
-0.0409715027,
0.0034680723,
0.022618046,
-0.0108602913,
-0.0058721732,
-0.0010365191,
-0.0101323025,
-0.0016959057,
-0.076948598,
0.0721146688,
-0.0228616372,
-0.0140434531,
-0.0260006972,
-0.0399240404,
-0.0128929606,
0.0437132232,
-0.019004561,
-0.0396272168,
0.0335701033,
-0.0005055323,
0.0450515598,
-0.0196699984,
-0.0441156328,
-0.0274872556,
0.0155253028,
-0.0052515608,
-0.0250957217,
-0.0069605005,
-0.009486598,
-0.0173250306,
-0.0842722058,
0.0311652347,
2.933799949e-34,
0.0405627936,
0.0050460007,
0.0478579998,
0.0175393242,
0.0438919775,
0.032166075,
0.0492008701,
0.0135108167,
-0.0141491415,
-0.04011577,
-0.0032343592
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06853v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06853v5 | Large Language Models Can Learn Temporal Reasoning | 2024-01-12T19:00:26 | 2024-06-11T02:38:27 | Siheng Xiong, Ali Payani, Ramana Kompella, Faramarz Fekri | cs.CL | cs.CL | While large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable reasoning
capabilities, they are not without their flaws and inaccuracies. Recent studies
have introduced various methods to mitigate these limitations. Temporal
reasoning (TR), in particular, presents a significant challenge for LLMs due to
its reliance on diverse temporal concepts and intricate temporal logic. In this
paper, we propose TG-LLM, a novel framework towards language-based TR. Instead
of reasoning over the original context, we adopt a latent representation,
temporal graph (TG) that enhances the learning of TR. A synthetic dataset
(TGQA), which is fully controllable and requires minimal supervision, is
constructed for fine-tuning LLMs on this text-to-TG translation task. We
confirmed in experiments that the capability of TG translation learned on our
dataset can be transferred to other TR tasks and benchmarks. On top of that, we
teach LLM to perform deliberate reasoning over the TGs via Chain-of-Thought
(CoT) bootstrapping and graph data augmentation. We observed that those
strategies, which maintain a balance between usefulness and diversity, bring
more reliable CoTs and final results than the vanilla CoT distillation. | [
0.0429141559,
0.0792068318,
-0.0106686261,
0.0218174923,
-0.0686645359,
0.0208065137,
0.0317637101,
-0.0136318607,
0.0225168653,
-0.0253737923,
0.0181550719,
-0.0394717716,
0.0093710376,
0.0535578653,
0.0138662793,
-0.0509042293,
0.0412405767,
-0.0330448747,
0.001247228,
0.0059606018,
-0.0068617798,
0.0201519672,
-0.015856307,
0.0315535031,
-0.0079798847,
-0.0323905833,
-0.0229305066,
-0.0075648837,
0.0472857095,
-0.0317642912,
-0.0407879651,
0.0277437828,
0.0528542213,
0.0497083962,
0.0000019772,
-0.0025728827,
-0.0175394993,
-0.0183136668,
-0.0351817124,
-0.0039141397,
0.0253403187,
-0.0083781481,
0.0288986415,
-0.0033846828,
-0.0749499723,
-0.0228711795,
0.0034650466,
0.0312212724,
0.0474276803,
0.1008544788,
-0.0105249733,
-0.0057583577,
0.0060183136,
-0.0354518741,
0.026449997,
-0.0613133684,
-0.0054940507,
0.0540338904,
0.0382372737,
0.0070421556,
-0.0340471119,
0.0395724997,
0.0393506624,
-0.0311904084,
0.0076945839,
0.0574996807,
-0.0077345222,
0.0143846162,
-0.0007830721,
0.0880175903,
0.0003461961,
-0.0512425229,
-0.0026443542,
0.0128131099,
-0.0307335835,
-0.0093288161,
-0.0477198921,
-0.0048524672,
-0.0036853396,
0.040001113,
0.0247598719,
0.0083518391,
0.0479636006,
0.0197171178,
-0.0496492013,
0.0863495767,
0.0003920607,
0.0015584326,
-0.0151370494,
0.004988187,
-0.0032880944,
-0.0407817997,
0.0122402785,
0.0661905035,
-0.0358162746,
0.0289896466,
-0.0163673572,
0.0056739324,
-0.0319102481,
-0.01423644,
0.0002934071,
0.0454432517,
0.0206807684,
0.0644480437,
-0.0389354527,
0.0550101027,
-0.0412345305,
0.0414250679,
-0.050869219,
-0.0061284816,
-0.0700100735,
0.0027711445,
-0.0105913458,
0.0019577867,
-0.0273062121,
-0.0084780455,
-0.0305360928,
0.0359977223,
-0.01423069,
-0.0002870973,
0.0201457515,
0.0264426265,
-0.0190638099,
-0.0444792025,
-0.042993404,
0.0299685299,
-0.0028354276,
0.0177405644,
-0.0001026421,
-0.0178814661,
-0.0275057815,
-0.0028292565,
0.0094528664,
-0.0389934666,
-0.0033666329,
0.0543019474,
-0.0282503329,
0.0066332556,
-0.0559752211,
-0.0314995907,
-0.0317877866,
-0.0588494837,
0.0173246656,
-0.0851148441,
0.0412815288,
0.0133476341,
-0.0115741175,
-0.0188392773,
0.0152055649,
0.0018948338,
-0.0295094643,
0.0737337619,
0.0249229148,
0.022835264,
-0.0123560969,
-0.0058682277,
0.0163474083,
0.0317499489,
0.0483867079,
0.0214688014,
-0.011915464,
0.0395611003,
-0.0522798821,
0.0007387726,
0.0254598726,
0.0042979433,
-0.0662973225,
-0.00071291,
-0.0270566046,
0.0381397456,
0.0058301724,
0.045546528,
-0.0363785289,
0.0009426227,
0.0472414047,
0.0039537465,
-0.0048030405,
-0.030940488,
0.0883501545,
-0.0208312646,
0.001819891,
-0.0119404653,
-0.0539438091,
0.0341165513,
0.0052640694,
0.0028014947,
-0.0284923594,
-0.0038937535,
-0.0109011168,
-0.0298359767,
0.0042939042,
0.0082302755,
0.0417744741,
0.0118182786,
0.061626818,
0.0281178877,
-0.0366598107,
0.0172381997,
0.0096099693,
0.0168438926,
0.0011625306,
0.001643607,
0.0103281224,
0.0852060765,
0.0436482541,
-0.0013368544,
-0.0599728599,
-0.0269108936,
0.0283300579,
0.0168042742,
0.0586087517,
-0.0275659449,
-0.0239235386,
-0.0419693179,
-0.0363826267,
-0.0006897991,
-0.0050753905,
0.0090397149,
0.0326383226,
0.0491378754,
0.0171216615,
-0.0726226568,
-0.0127206463,
0.0195858348,
-0.0319845788,
-0.0184578076,
-0.0095094386,
0.0280827116,
0.0002520602,
0.0122952498,
0.0049595418,
0.0226263236,
0.0115061095,
-0.0414911248,
-0.0251025148,
0.0493639968,
-0.0781366676,
-0.0956210196,
0.0444009155,
-0.0020104093,
-0.0445631258,
0.0055924882,
-0.0680024698,
-0.0513478667,
0.0444656797,
0.0216008332,
0.0177420713,
-0.0236642323,
0.0173746906,
0.0032601233,
-0.01377034,
-0.0394312777,
0.0944586694,
-0.0204112139,
0.0004241976,
0.0028794114,
0.0445477106,
0.0038140395,
-0.0104509769,
0.009876254,
0.0252102148,
0.0242885649,
-0.0152105987,
0.0143053178,
0.0210852604,
-0.0625657961,
-0.0046886508,
-0.0733670965,
0.0100504784,
-0.0066016959,
0.0232503302,
0.0091350442,
-0.0227341559,
0.0285022669,
-0.0150408633,
-0.0353246927,
0.0128528252,
0.0041853008,
0.0011006329,
0.0338536277,
0.0010398768,
-0.0008089085,
-0.0109023266,
-0.0212447196,
-0.0596052706,
0.0699238256,
-0.0059595197,
-0.0334222429,
-0.0031325202,
0.0162911341,
-0.0374950394,
0.0247634593,
-0.0246238541,
0.0138307763,
0.0325748138,
-0.0331132337,
0.073115766,
0.0571837872,
0.003827411,
0.012447685,
0.0656700209,
-0.0132419262,
-0.0487825423,
0.0201096907,
-0.0431796908,
0.0045705633,
-0.0446549617,
-0.0218672585,
-0.0665742159,
0.0570178293,
-0.0091973394,
-0.0029150471,
-0.0699988976,
-0.0069295219,
-0.0349003077,
0.00074739,
-0.0260907095,
0.012487404,
-0.0129210996,
0.010067679,
-0.0746395737,
-0.0256013758,
0.1033695266,
0.0131462049,
0.0130896317,
0.0137447994,
-0.0156205958,
-0.0559237488,
0.1044512242,
0.0187015645,
-0.0137487911,
-0.0137661798,
-0.0281988606,
-0.0641957074,
-0.010125245,
0.0349578448,
-0.0316854306,
0.047512047,
-0.0597600974,
0.0168619398,
0.0141935172,
0.0015260364,
-0.0476591364,
-0.0385131016,
-0.0386518463,
0.0012442118,
-0.0366396159,
0.0049547218,
-0.0303358082,
-0.0155979907,
-0.0090625538,
0.0307411011,
-0.0229253508,
-0.0104112234,
-0.0225062277,
0.018600747,
0.0477347523,
-0.0200116001,
0.0150753362,
-0.0370926186,
0.0524347909,
0.0189562775,
0.0416045971,
-0.0592585765,
-0.073287569,
0.0201058593,
-0.0322247483,
0.0316404216,
-0.0112434458,
-0.0042094565,
0.0449002497,
-0.056576103,
-0.0221396536,
0.0927851573,
0.0402047634,
-0.0190284736,
-0.0032225857,
0.0086223651,
0.0415102057,
0.036136169,
0.0076710153,
-0.0812173858,
-0.0253976751,
0.0038880433,
-0.0160062555,
0.0183896217,
-0.0652144477,
-0.0291392617,
-0.0748005882,
0.0053291172,
0.0400933474,
-0.0113253016,
-0.0044146637,
-0.0038107377,
-0.0080753928,
0.0006879178,
-0.0011856529,
0.0069139465,
0.0022734127,
0.0094930371,
0.0230013989,
0.0013263723,
-0.0413792543,
0.0583601221,
0.0196170956,
0.0447326899,
-0.0016065704,
0.0617588758,
0.0365985818,
-0.0259941276,
0.0456060097,
0.0236855485,
-0.0048085437,
-0.0152024264,
0.0280937366,
0.0364073515,
-0.0131284222,
0.007301575,
0.0310632344,
-0.0205299724,
-0.0369839482,
-0.0320074484,
0.1192621216,
-0.0483587682,
-0.0294022039,
0.0051127505,
-0.0075797439,
0.0138221448,
0.0302667674,
0.0223130528,
0.0000242077,
-0.0708014369,
-0.0124121541,
-0.0544863753,
-0.0842333958,
-0.0336807333,
0.005262285,
-0.0182287712,
0.0145070851,
-0.0647697151,
-0.0285783429,
0.0179195069,
0.0447670072,
-0.0061441041,
0.0010115672,
0.0178583823,
-0.0276816115,
-0.0507338233,
0.0436701402,
-0.0537349321,
0.0391994528,
-0.0059773289,
0.0016320298,
-0.0167125128,
-0.0302242208,
-0.0037915236,
0.0383946225,
-0.110276781,
-0.0807470232,
-0.0186936185,
-0.0125137381,
0.0173963029,
0.0803192258,
-0.0358556472,
0.0076359026,
0.0599270575,
0.0064463653,
-0.006352291,
-0.0236682445,
0.0260402709,
0.0072486247,
0.00367177,
0.0534335785,
-0.0414993577,
0.0125472387,
0.0117673744,
0.0646393448,
-0.0155257564,
0.0209504757,
0.0383786932,
-0.0004046432,
0.0328567773,
0.0189576261,
-0.003797499,
-0.0436290689,
-0.0034717994,
-0.0420689955,
-0.0165399443,
-0.0307949279,
0.0039592497,
0.0450055376,
-0.0075143836,
-0.0123991333,
-0.0364706814,
0.0291279647,
0.0256148241,
-0.0110097528,
-0.0143645294,
-0.006769191,
0.0203611217,
0.0551173277,
0.0158160441,
-0.0151586132,
0.0106786862,
-0.0230415594,
0.0116652409,
-0.0156527665,
0.0480496809,
0.0514256693,
0.0025836446,
-0.0665282756,
-0.0337456316,
-0.12504372,
-0.0064846566,
0.0237253811,
-0.0242624432,
0.0673904791,
-0.0135002602,
0.0553533733,
-0.0430655703,
-0.0070345062,
0.0056131459,
0.0669601485,
0.034068048,
-0.043238949,
0.0279364828,
0.0125288954,
0.0079513462,
0.0208251514,
0.0566980429,
0.0028414535,
0.0277704541,
0.0248448867,
-0.0199333504,
-0.0153045775,
-0.0353812687,
-0.0673904344,
-0.0179856382,
-0.0162609331,
0.0168713666,
-0.0514329709,
-0.1008148044,
0.0051618884,
0.0253786668,
-0.0192970447,
0.0147710228,
-0.0076603121,
0.0386428051,
0.0150562208,
-0.0152664604,
-0.0519370176,
0.0652661994,
0.0669608712,
-0.0346479975,
-0.0650154874,
-6.410394608e-33,
0.0001968581,
-0.0461233929,
0.0535064153,
0.0071458188,
-0.0463762321,
0.0083723729,
-0.0656483397,
-0.0146742137,
-0.0330372564,
0.04863628,
-0.0158090368,
0.0389830172,
0.0142519632,
0.0094627533,
0.0169159919,
-0.0175861884,
0.0381995216,
-0.0073539754,
0.0130133219,
0.0418117046,
0.0816029236,
0.0209191237,
0.0556176864,
-0.057550706,
0.022523053,
0.0113423215,
0.0094471788,
0.0594166256,
0.0068500177,
0.0432648137,
0.0137949036,
0.0225638095,
0.0381540656,
-0.0182526242,
-0.0303678606,
-0.0018128555,
-0.1359612346,
-0.0441165864,
0.0231329724,
0.0101062609,
-0.042405948,
-0.0396978967,
-0.009320192,
-0.0313784368,
0.0489246398,
-0.0387376174,
0.0166159272,
-0.0347420871,
-0.0338923298,
-0.027959533,
-0.0422029346,
0.0417640097,
-0.0233877879,
-0.0163321961,
0.0295775831,
0.0429405198,
0.0041032205,
-0.0122776451,
-0.037440896,
0.0403298661,
-0.0412707068,
-0.0135458922,
0.0594966821,
0.0208027232,
0.0068091294,
0.0389176197,
-0.0414230525,
0.0145558212,
-0.045714505,
0.0333923995,
0.0289001297,
0.0344244093,
0.010745734,
-0.0041109943,
0.0165262222,
-0.0309570991,
-0.0728472844,
-0.0010382066,
0.0175424144,
0.0363178551,
0.0076679448,
0.0102685606,
-0.0063760751,
-0.0155908847,
-0.0306050368,
0.0257857312,
-0.0257534292,
-0.0023721019,
0.0086375298,
0.0248282775,
0.0007407,
-0.0132518457,
0.0443184897,
-0.0421420261,
-0.0099177649,
0.0518623069,
-0.0343226604,
0.0018658944,
-0.0044594072,
0.0519074574,
-0.0394798815,
-0.0317456275,
0.0382311493,
-0.0178766903,
0.0072884117,
-0.018738633,
0.079327479,
0.0257288069,
-0.0324158221,
-0.0175707117,
-0.0673440769,
0.0015066772,
-0.0024474727,
-0.0300278887,
0.0501961447,
0.0135345506,
-0.0243772902,
0.0490025319,
0.0243825931,
0.0235019475,
-0.003593944,
0.0426383652,
0.0043657394,
0.0379755199,
-0.032286074,
-0.0109737273,
-0.0441842973,
0.0333355814,
0.0439959504,
-0.0363330506,
-0.016608322,
0.0200007278,
2.667e-7,
0.0432171635,
0.0353636779,
0.0186162796,
0.0543189384,
0.0114681721,
0.0002986586,
-0.0416499935,
-0.0208669789,
-0.0156298708,
-0.0188749023,
0.044514019,
0.0598934516,
0.0553755574,
0.0390036441,
-0.0115123941,
-0.0040985667,
-0.0363291577,
-0.0305617489,
-0.0496181585,
-0.0271107927,
0.0626956895,
0.0714804828,
0.042029202,
-0.0047129714,
-0.006861168,
-0.0508705564,
0.0878097042,
0.0019443721,
-0.028861288,
0.0076655806,
0.0322134346,
-0.0232228599,
-0.0218628179,
0.0069701662,
-0.0137757165,
0.0185890775,
-0.0207225047,
0.0588504821,
-0.0049588215,
-0.0220833421,
-0.0353654213,
-0.0681247637,
-0.0016851934,
-0.0382765457,
0.0845527649,
-0.0726303607,
-0.0361750424,
-0.0073824669,
-0.0093318606,
0.0236432869,
0.0142725613,
0.0295930319,
-0.0137771629,
0.0078527806,
0.0296880957,
-0.0033066575,
0.0060886103,
-0.0995738059,
-0.043748267,
0.0435143262,
-0.0280888602,
-0.0009708848,
-0.0069720414,
0.008074278,
0.014855844,
-0.015533573,
0.0008330266,
2.587474288e-34,
0.0366022252,
-0.0014641848,
-0.0113696726,
-0.023317745,
0.0473259427,
-0.0312427543,
-0.0156019758,
0.0151827391,
0.0343953706,
-0.0835370496,
-0.0380520746
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06769v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06769v2 | Machine Translation Models are Zero-Shot Detectors of Translation Direction | 2024-01-12T18:59:02 | 2024-05-22T17:10:39 | Michelle Wastl, Jannis Vamvas, Rico Sennrich | cs.CL | cs.CL | Detecting the translation direction of parallel text has applications for
machine translation training and evaluation, but also has forensic applications
such as resolving plagiarism or forgery allegations. In this work, we explore
an unsupervised approach to translation direction detection based on the simple
hypothesis that
$p(\text{translation}|\text{original})>p(\text{original}|\text{translation})$,
motivated by the well-known simplification effect in translationese or
machine-translationese. In experiments with massively multilingual machine
translation models across 20 translation directions, we confirm the
effectiveness of the approach for high-resource language pairs, achieving
document-level accuracies of 82--96% for NMT-produced translations, and 60--81%
for human translations, depending on the model used. Code and demo are
available at https://github.com/ZurichNLP/translation-direction-detection | [
0.0230624601,
0.040992327,
-0.0394507051,
0.1078001782,
-0.1000244915,
0.031171957,
0.0329933763,
0.0286071207,
-0.0436813198,
-0.0025186331,
-0.0084824907,
-0.0204490796,
0.0272155441,
-0.0625904277,
0.0285876766,
0.0205469709,
0.0229412839,
-0.0028975869,
-0.0096240947,
0.0085290577,
0.029420929,
0.025038965,
0.0095920609,
0.0010401115,
0.0042695263,
-0.0108483732,
0.0202866439,
0.0529556125,
0.0398159251,
0.0171384644,
-0.0494067408,
0.0612934344,
-0.0025334854,
0.1090507284,
0.0000017255,
-0.0173793789,
-0.0683340356,
0.0324977748,
0.0192793775,
0.0204264969,
0.0745820105,
-0.0673350915,
-0.0432313494,
0.0100506665,
-0.0008340724,
-0.0189405251,
0.0208157506,
0.0178060178,
0.0371902995,
0.1069788188,
-0.0173587166,
-0.0422300883,
0.0077449935,
-0.0258500241,
-0.0244914591,
-0.008961115,
-0.0121077625,
-0.0263082962,
-0.0569007136,
0.0419787429,
0.0074307588,
0.0547316819,
0.0049585346,
-0.0201668963,
-0.0665931925,
-0.0299802311,
-0.0225713439,
0.0041068196,
0.0220007244,
0.0254062954,
-0.0675959438,
-0.0478136465,
-0.0083667804,
-0.0265186913,
-0.0035709299,
0.0369213633,
-0.0197993722,
0.0655735955,
-0.0194613077,
0.0175443534,
0.0394062623,
0.0279764608,
0.0333051495,
0.0080389278,
-0.0030254731,
-0.0142929554,
0.0522902794,
-0.0590606034,
-0.0303385053,
0.0202447455,
0.0223520119,
0.0011477548,
0.0415179692,
-0.039399229,
0.0527737625,
0.0016925904,
0.0144944927,
-0.1063318029,
0.0427131243,
-0.0605044253,
0.0190128144,
0.0447486974,
-0.0323989652,
0.0410530046,
-0.0411927216,
0.0609526411,
-0.0514234975,
-0.004413534,
-0.0596133098,
-0.0368653983,
0.0458847545,
0.0358901434,
0.0179003011,
-0.0520109385,
-0.0238044765,
0.0216664337,
-0.0194682181,
-0.0077424631,
0.0293654297,
0.0058400095,
-0.0232561976,
-0.0537706576,
-0.0276445094,
-0.0330966264,
0.0442927852,
0.0639288351,
0.0060285288,
0.0049499604,
-0.0466933697,
-0.0214857738,
-0.0441900976,
0.0596292987,
-0.0112111662,
-0.0259176064,
-0.0118706245,
0.0540737249,
-0.016019268,
-0.0173472892,
-0.0094797658,
-0.0612096153,
-0.0119332159,
-0.051219929,
0.0116268918,
-0.0599475428,
-0.0041164621,
-0.017513996,
0.014195581,
0.0033441256,
0.0037786923,
0.0155716129,
-0.0404598638,
0.0419249386,
0.0255287904,
-0.0093035325,
0.029322667,
0.0002618384,
-0.0238702483,
0.0405797213,
0.0032192536,
0.0559836254,
0.0484266095,
0.0098033193,
0.0056234496,
0.0812463984,
0.011263649,
0.0464303084,
-0.0103031397,
-0.0269596614,
0.0205250476,
0.0023791683,
0.0129312873,
0.0225665402,
-0.0221051518,
-0.0224571191,
0.0393604115,
0.0419623852,
-0.0220721886,
0.0081502823,
0.0404679477,
0.0080630174,
-0.0240171365,
0.0275312327,
-0.0069273203,
-0.0143921459,
-0.031180894,
-0.0191299617,
0.0228904504,
0.0085008247,
0.0016920676,
0.0168817323,
-0.0022578447,
-0.0254694745,
-0.0103066573,
-0.0155523056,
0.0349956043,
0.0240281895,
-0.0196982659,
-0.0290427208,
-0.0266849138,
-0.0742230117,
-0.0080006747,
-0.0296803489,
-0.0079811979,
0.0428571515,
0.0576898493,
0.0156497955,
0.0073400186,
-0.0231423378,
-0.041256804,
0.0583309457,
0.0130864773,
0.0054545151,
0.0312183909,
-0.0139055606,
-0.0085159875,
0.0410706513,
0.0139554562,
0.0130848186,
0.0167621654,
0.0432875901,
0.0496733002,
-0.0448394492,
-0.0330203325,
0.0186810549,
-0.0163679812,
-0.0115847904,
0.0381258465,
0.0185526218,
0.0263783392,
0.0197631512,
-0.0356217548,
-0.0005790354,
0.0419069938,
-0.0388151556,
-0.0374579616,
0.0522108488,
0.0363127775,
-0.0371304005,
0.0440220721,
-0.0434942544,
0.0074656918,
-0.0021056063,
-0.0343873873,
-0.0249840245,
0.0039880779,
-0.0156469401,
-0.0419933088,
-0.0720276609,
0.0702088028,
-0.0222877134,
0.0175620709,
-0.0213213973,
0.0454038158,
0.0012466261,
0.0367481001,
0.0406957567,
-0.0442200042,
0.0702310652,
-0.0099107539,
-0.0206869282,
0.0127627077,
0.0506279431,
-0.0014932228,
0.0697654411,
-0.0041800672,
0.0070351819,
-0.0324448198,
-0.0426375754,
0.0351726748,
-0.0294312257,
0.0560466424,
0.0421171114,
0.0232669022,
-0.0077210795,
0.0055344161,
0.0132191554,
-0.0245909914,
0.0512413271,
0.0090010073,
0.0116547616,
-0.0256665107,
0.0010178145,
0.0002441981,
-0.0021680051,
0.0012100413,
0.0161029939,
0.0281367842,
-0.0189497415,
-0.0703804493,
0.0159146637,
0.0108180502,
-0.0191970039,
-0.0216425937,
-0.0413800403,
-0.0165587198,
-0.0496526882,
0.0253788475,
0.0677062199,
0.0125790909,
-0.0317393914,
0.0120740021,
0.0168618858,
-0.0278085284,
-0.0385077074,
-0.0122596081,
0.0054252152,
-0.0092206299,
-0.0797671601,
0.0247120913,
0.0064471606,
0.0087319892,
0.0039426074,
-0.0144581227,
-0.02665204,
-0.0146294795,
-0.0032082752,
0.0504975542,
-0.0078497203,
0.0130734658,
0.0483486503,
-0.0005427862,
-0.0546746068,
0.0408847891,
-0.0547087379,
0.0339471735,
-0.0389556736,
-0.0006206279,
-0.0385747179,
0.0746182054,
-0.0077796369,
0.0424236916,
-0.0291313976,
-0.0051704617,
0.018064715,
-0.0068100332,
0.0909239054,
0.006357058,
0.015578445,
-0.0731056407,
0.0166156981,
-0.0337990932,
-0.0182284974,
-0.0090333046,
-0.0857733265,
0.0357637964,
-0.0238563307,
-0.0062450324,
-0.0313048251,
-0.0184315369,
0.0121571589,
0.0316514149,
0.0420441292,
-0.0229050014,
0.0353463776,
-0.0051715104,
0.0564343184,
-0.0197222177,
-0.0886256471,
0.0121414298,
-0.058639653,
-0.0044295741,
0.0279348288,
-0.0208169818,
0.0093167955,
0.0242613144,
-0.0352713056,
0.001328191,
-0.0149996588,
-0.0416396894,
-0.0425507464,
0.0077183126,
-0.0506899655,
0.0070978804,
0.1036047712,
0.016776247,
-0.0359045491,
-0.0385240056,
-0.0208577607,
-0.0287334062,
-0.0050910795,
-0.0140904877,
-0.1065015346,
0.0066847797,
-0.0021800362,
0.0148079013,
-0.0164566003,
0.0064527118,
-0.0163839627,
-0.0829754025,
0.0393941477,
0.0438992456,
-0.0291424207,
-0.0357549749,
-0.0166567788,
-0.0440709665,
-0.0027800186,
-0.0059987255,
-0.0107893543,
0.0420802347,
-0.0062489603,
-0.0334279947,
0.0310872272,
-0.0217399132,
-0.0312334076,
-0.0774972662,
-0.0051135477,
0.015278779,
0.0312709995,
-0.0260267556,
-0.0524123199,
0.0018015696,
-0.0179799367,
-0.0171069056,
-0.0222402178,
0.0237630326,
0.0021584898,
0.0170230791,
0.0254109334,
0.003983493,
0.008100694,
0.0073505361,
0.0447674654,
0.0697173402,
-0.0201262124,
-0.0088314125,
0.0069887489,
-0.0224757995,
0.0027943617,
0.0329491571,
-0.0135500198,
0.0331520811,
-0.035995502,
-0.0103039956,
-0.0118442606,
-0.0007636072,
-0.0182215273,
-0.0442439839,
-0.015282142,
-0.0615645237,
-0.0845536068,
0.0039305151,
-0.0307615306,
0.0306750648,
0.0298028328,
0.0349006206,
-0.0021114922,
-0.0364237688,
-0.0348426364,
-0.0092300419,
-0.0499765463,
0.0409659594,
-0.0147852413,
0.0581313707,
0.0020657789,
-0.0099232001,
0.0295047574,
0.0410393104,
-0.1039513946,
-0.0726849437,
-0.0521486476,
0.011991947,
0.0167560689,
0.0574651062,
-0.0662523434,
-0.0215174947,
-0.0313686505,
0.027431801,
-0.0343358442,
-0.0106856367,
0.0135644292,
-0.0401362069,
-0.0117127057,
0.0389678776,
0.0193245746,
0.025043115,
0.0174935833,
-0.021232279,
-0.0463432334,
-0.044963412,
0.0024915077,
0.055419486,
0.0548629053,
-0.0256868973,
-0.0032619238,
-0.0259513725,
0.0117680337,
-0.0712584406,
-0.0271317046,
-0.0037877536,
0.0121436222,
0.0525573567,
-0.0211327095,
-0.0118327821,
0.0607504994,
-0.045249939,
-0.0201741811,
-0.0122013791,
0.012157781,
0.0023900075,
0.0440864973,
-0.0195827149,
0.0051580127,
-0.0050727623,
0.0296493359,
0.0029327427,
0.0607391298,
-0.0323439538,
0.0645072535,
-0.0059600417,
0.0090615554,
-0.0028958514,
0.0064670108,
-0.0505353771,
-0.0159777943,
0.0001393572,
0.0176391993,
0.0855581611,
-0.0344501585,
0.1096376777,
-0.0258504972,
-0.0005868572,
-0.0103525519,
0.0388097502,
0.0015747021,
-0.011746428,
-0.0449682698,
-0.0259999018,
-0.0121020125,
0.0850805715,
0.0498229265,
-0.0207421426,
-0.0058973138,
0.0160198677,
-0.0699086785,
-0.0102892024,
-0.0213201158,
0.034477517,
-0.0301339068,
-0.0311190281,
-0.0196409281,
-0.0454751179,
-0.0105909677,
-0.0203233361,
0.036327146,
0.028043706,
-0.0018410118,
-0.0299645681,
0.0866795033,
-0.0393230431,
-0.022179367,
-0.062966153,
0.0795631781,
-0.0141872643,
-0.0249422174,
-0.0483722016,
-5.159225971e-33,
0.03104629,
-0.0186959244,
-0.0184152555,
0.0044330237,
0.0103378985,
-0.0221586302,
-0.0130389743,
-0.0033468034,
-0.0298239384,
0.0069716033,
-0.0167362262,
0.0460569784,
0.0227819979,
-0.0331318825,
0.0169735663,
0.0340054706,
0.0573174618,
0.003735743,
-0.0360349007,
0.0181757826,
0.0148691116,
-0.0163710266,
0.0844886005,
-0.0865702629,
0.0511696562,
-0.0657090694,
-0.0540880971,
0.0161359664,
-0.0480620489,
-0.0089551732,
0.018740546,
-0.0298492629,
0.0053309421,
-0.0518543161,
-0.0019313322,
-0.0334200859,
-0.0130120777,
0.0267410986,
0.0357259959,
0.0340279751,
0.0051058093,
-0.0483602583,
0.0290754586,
-0.0420088395,
-0.0344884098,
0.0316064693,
0.0099414857,
-0.0244112834,
-0.0106594078,
-0.0095927631,
-0.0497817807,
0.0530912615,
-0.0144444397,
0.0033170546,
0.0594134852,
-0.000303293,
0.0169481989,
-0.0093404157,
-0.0847651809,
0.0157661606,
-0.0104682688,
0.0248290915,
0.0568417311,
-0.0398296826,
-0.0268209483,
0.0037007085,
0.0385643281,
0.0144789182,
0.0556748398,
0.0099525312,
-0.0001831476,
-0.0022567457,
0.0779130608,
0.0812017322,
0.0562686883,
-0.0244699549,
-0.0436827466,
0.0451798476,
0.0273562167,
-0.0166591909,
0.0204143263,
-0.0133187044,
-0.0670315772,
-0.0125023602,
-0.0093744677,
-0.0927981436,
-0.0082616927,
0.0053882659,
-0.0245093498,
0.0351219103,
0.0037037148,
-0.0236349795,
0.0835436061,
-0.0267107859,
0.0282085668,
0.0261049271,
-0.072697103,
0.0071912827,
-0.0004353673,
0.0545264035,
-0.0241125133,
-0.0233496726,
0.0132158455,
0.0200179592,
-0.0059851701,
-0.013988141,
0.0882568732,
-0.0015986713,
-0.058913812,
0.0021247279,
-0.0113077983,
-0.0107350955,
-0.0066411132,
0.0280897096,
-0.0134804985,
0.0167427491,
0.0214405581,
0.0036641662,
0.0448967703,
0.0270763785,
-0.0351431593,
0.0303112231,
-0.0079574641,
-0.016933443,
-0.0135875558,
0.0378006585,
0.0132716978,
0.0413372256,
0.0457899161,
-0.0510376357,
-0.0051749861,
0.0359156057,
2.346e-7,
0.0698542073,
0.0099913552,
0.0364138149,
0.0049826032,
0.0289984681,
0.043450322,
-0.0377051719,
0.0063857893,
-0.0105547309,
0.0410911478,
0.028666012,
-0.0025753041,
0.0707351714,
0.0343086347,
-0.0642695576,
0.0106564173,
0.0018886811,
-0.0074840011,
-0.0664701536,
-0.0025402934,
0.0323234722,
0.0761355907,
0.0032173099,
-0.0052946811,
-0.0114649544,
-0.0398988314,
0.0712695792,
0.0058944388,
-0.0480424576,
-0.0326772332,
0.0295403413,
-0.0212793499,
-0.0284602586,
0.0081878072,
0.0004691383,
0.0382780172,
0.0161129683,
0.0708475336,
-0.0086662695,
0.0582161099,
-0.0307027306,
-0.078604728,
-0.0048691509,
-0.0465095229,
0.0444952585,
0.0521324836,
0.0069668596,
-0.0258200075,
-0.0243430734,
0.0420894623,
0.0450902767,
-0.0050956984,
-0.0559357628,
0.0261274446,
0.0302495044,
0.0180648677,
-0.0267420299,
-0.047761675,
-0.0277472846,
-0.0287753064,
-0.0213680118,
0.0004604635,
0.0137190297,
0.0292687546,
0.0136787742,
-0.0358076543,
0.0165437553,
2.216384267e-34,
0.0376707353,
-0.0265966598,
-0.0190448742,
-0.0365761705,
0.0460929833,
-0.0015805481,
-0.0459197797,
-0.0050716833,
-0.0250372998,
-0.0272592921,
-0.0204053931
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06766v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06766v3 | Mind Your Format: Towards Consistent Evaluation of In-Context Learning Improvements | 2024-01-12T18:58:26 | 2024-06-06T19:01:37 | Anton Voronov, Lena Wolf, Max Ryabinin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models demonstrate a remarkable capability for learning to
solve new tasks from a few examples. The prompt template, or the way the input
examples are formatted to obtain the prompt, is an important yet often
overlooked aspect of in-context learning. In this work, we conduct a
comprehensive study of the template format's influence on the in-context
learning performance. We evaluate the impact of the prompt template across 21
models (from 770M to 70B parameters) and 4 standard classification datasets. We
show that a poor choice of the template can reduce the performance of the
strongest models and inference methods to a random guess level. More
importantly, the best templates do not transfer between different setups and
even between models of the same family. Our findings show that the currently
prevalent approach to evaluation, which ignores template selection, may give
misleading results due to different templates in different works. As a first
step towards mitigating this issue, we propose Template Ensembles that
aggregate model predictions across several templates. This simple test-time
augmentation boosts average performance while being robust to the choice of
random set of templates. | [
0.008856467,
0.0307316091,
0.0078631015,
0.0136744743,
-0.0264140312,
0.0429559983,
0.0367483906,
-0.0022900279,
-0.0461328886,
-0.0736735612,
-0.0322637446,
-0.0447079986,
0.0134220999,
0.0239938349,
0.0358329304,
-0.0646484643,
0.0237578657,
-0.0433911905,
-0.012491174,
0.0205309968,
-0.033078067,
-0.00229283,
-0.0056175874,
0.0586214811,
0.0152223036,
-0.0222762413,
-0.0069851298,
0.0171721596,
-0.0130569236,
-0.0079834228,
0.0239536911,
0.0705162734,
0.0248201042,
0.0741606876,
0.0000019803,
-0.0505127944,
-0.0119116185,
0.0077003916,
-0.058502987,
0.0258023012,
0.0375778265,
-0.0082820067,
-0.0014997957,
0.0431084447,
-0.029239174,
-0.052029036,
0.0351419561,
0.0490181334,
0.0142093422,
0.0736923963,
-0.0000191812,
0.0003157258,
-0.003097571,
-0.0336578898,
-0.0063936473,
-0.0081265569,
0.0002074082,
-0.0381955616,
0.0236613229,
-0.009559297,
0.0135782799,
0.0298121553,
0.027641153,
0.0057469825,
0.0173033718,
0.0444760658,
-0.0522716381,
0.0106764818,
-0.029174475,
0.0694350526,
-0.0266243666,
-0.0264659785,
-0.0222308021,
-0.0314983428,
0.0166038349,
0.0082842978,
-0.0510593019,
0.0106834751,
0.0010715177,
0.0147335939,
0.0177470781,
0.0229240078,
0.0621218942,
0.0025427763,
-0.0269443821,
0.0365501158,
0.0162145142,
-0.0434960127,
0.0030660233,
0.0128963683,
-0.0354312621,
-0.0544688217,
-0.0377077833,
-0.0008532876,
-0.04329101,
0.0006527328,
-0.0457657091,
-0.0445174836,
0.0014808009,
-0.0011258809,
0.0691433772,
0.0374880172,
-0.0184095576,
0.0466247983,
-0.0319279172,
0.0372861587,
-0.0026038466,
0.0062874905,
-0.0479417369,
0.0073464359,
-0.0543817393,
0.0119074257,
-0.0221160613,
0.00582687,
-0.0139662828,
-0.0309241805,
-0.0290822666,
0.0490291454,
0.0129965758,
0.0116047226,
0.0100974878,
-0.0040820935,
-0.0265647415,
0.0176261049,
0.0119832046,
0.0098022157,
-0.0092900498,
0.0038323787,
0.0222353265,
-0.070671469,
-0.0163171496,
0.02042423,
-0.0041993959,
-0.0372186303,
0.0098321075,
0.062079154,
-0.0166054405,
-0.0554727577,
0.0257890541,
0.0064729811,
-0.0164208412,
-0.0526060164,
-0.0107519859,
-0.0717845187,
0.0181613173,
0.0403101146,
0.0075401743,
-0.0243177246,
-0.0225001387,
0.0036926237,
0.0041134669,
0.06008498,
0.0096273869,
-0.0052550253,
0.0357930921,
-0.0002942439,
0.0024205442,
0.0844135135,
0.0002211109,
0.0302171614,
0.0299417824,
-0.00438789,
0.0350968949,
0.0582397953,
0.0281647202,
0.0351101123,
-0.0466517694,
0.0184581522,
0.0941525623,
0.0050318106,
0.0124530867,
0.0095876195,
-0.0290560108,
0.0091840345,
0.0622160807,
0.0068272385,
0.0244669281,
0.0132622691,
0.0407334901,
-0.0101797106,
0.0125981988,
-0.0021715802,
-0.0847488567,
-0.0142451711,
-0.0407556072,
0.0150425974,
0.0279421937,
0.0095202792,
-0.0316114761,
-0.0307006817,
-0.0434728079,
-0.0088412398,
-0.0327443033,
0.0407745466,
0.0598477311,
0.000997236,
-0.0535482988,
0.0395862125,
0.0402915217,
-0.0355970338,
-0.0414601415,
-0.0391696766,
0.0557891987,
0.0291073788,
0.0367826819,
-0.0276276227,
-0.0217527598,
-0.0270107184,
-0.0097507173,
0.0028992132,
0.0503350906,
-0.0316693522,
0.0466232561,
-0.035883002,
-0.0426108427,
-0.0161342882,
0.0379380845,
0.0288894568,
0.0300063938,
-0.0151949255,
0.0261309259,
-0.0323670097,
-0.0298892595,
0.0495666191,
0.0137960501,
-0.0502721071,
0.0272519961,
0.0181285664,
0.0322918072,
-0.0161379464,
-0.0246049296,
-0.013509105,
0.0233317539,
-0.0392383002,
0.0092460308,
0.0055655334,
-0.0986937732,
-0.0810230225,
0.0076704659,
0.0189704299,
-0.0134178046,
-0.0102279363,
-0.0482752621,
-0.040164575,
-0.0142715583,
-0.0252295882,
0.0772884414,
-0.0371827409,
0.0153339105,
-0.0366315581,
0.0223248415,
-0.0370224528,
0.0740344897,
0.0066414382,
0.0211190414,
0.0356580764,
0.011380285,
0.0148960743,
-0.0316810831,
-0.016314704,
0.001317854,
-0.0118721779,
-0.0047869086,
0.0175236668,
-0.0026946263,
-0.0425510854,
0.0022855864,
-0.1327575594,
-0.0088187307,
-0.047157146,
0.0153046157,
0.0196039453,
0.0208773781,
-0.0308498684,
-0.0357519649,
-0.0066605224,
-0.0722257122,
-0.0134564061,
0.036067497,
0.0077860747,
0.0324116275,
-0.0266947504,
-0.0224440433,
-0.0164472908,
-0.0140630975,
0.0997424871,
-0.0191593356,
-0.0229636226,
-0.0578133054,
0.028475184,
0.0088807009,
0.0044311024,
-0.0040120776,
-0.0027193534,
0.0087284362,
-0.0314312838,
0.0399133153,
0.0777200237,
-0.0197713729,
0.0318789072,
0.0600312948,
0.0460090041,
-0.0712257624,
-0.0006895356,
0.0054559405,
-0.0046281493,
-0.0021372591,
-0.0117002064,
-0.0004302688,
0.050571993,
0.0014848574,
0.011351577,
-0.0445236228,
0.003889519,
-0.0162823405,
-0.0246017538,
-0.0841044188,
-0.0052907546,
-0.0045953128,
0.0449882373,
0.0027745902,
-0.0819632933,
0.0599683523,
-0.0337439999,
-0.0207799021,
-0.0322404914,
-0.0310974382,
-0.0343562439,
0.0306150224,
0.0001188174,
-0.0148405172,
0.0269228406,
-0.035915412,
-0.0520173125,
-0.0350051783,
0.0340296365,
-0.0053858752,
0.0398118161,
-0.0454447046,
0.0161988959,
-0.0012295651,
-0.0514332764,
-0.0544541068,
-0.0580671504,
-0.0249208771,
0.0458209291,
-0.0501068197,
-0.0143530834,
-0.0368318446,
0.0062285606,
0.000840415,
0.0594916306,
-0.0193084143,
-0.0090138884,
0.0087140677,
0.0605357736,
0.0082278103,
-0.0111504123,
0.0209097546,
-0.0684611872,
0.0387447253,
0.0155101018,
0.0517025813,
0.027291581,
-0.077707909,
0.0057070032,
0.026930593,
-0.0080054952,
-0.0285524745,
0.0469613746,
0.0400624685,
-0.0685711429,
-0.0129028363,
0.140112102,
0.0256429445,
-0.0588401668,
-0.0071173673,
0.008555999,
0.0467950106,
0.0428406522,
0.0323882289,
-0.0205849297,
-0.040535178,
0.0254476313,
0.0380968228,
0.0078704394,
-0.0058549219,
0.0269748531,
-0.098378174,
0.0300167445,
0.0041180342,
-0.0558694378,
0.0058770543,
-0.0644315705,
0.0213467609,
-0.0282796752,
0.0380011275,
0.0065175318,
-0.0155553743,
0.0214852858,
0.0411926582,
-0.0197056588,
-0.0778224543,
0.0246508904,
-0.0337909497,
0.0229369719,
0.082593143,
-0.0071549341,
-0.0210036859,
-0.030114824,
0.0427473113,
-0.0263315272,
0.027548803,
-0.0222449508,
0.0412885658,
0.0110815112,
-0.0040385034,
0.02544632,
0.0437180139,
-0.0449119583,
-0.011402728,
0.0172801819,
0.0700770095,
-0.0174314287,
-0.0045970646,
-0.0080837077,
-0.0652815253,
0.0570338778,
0.0732806623,
0.0543323755,
-0.0436467305,
-0.0182675365,
-0.0149852289,
-0.033314161,
-0.0070028636,
0.0371083915,
-0.005586274,
-0.0175884217,
-0.0242112894,
-0.0545169599,
-0.0293175075,
0.0323179923,
0.0840945095,
-0.0143241184,
-0.0045674969,
-0.0792993233,
0.0273980163,
-0.0331362709,
0.0524596088,
0.0054007107,
0.0312596187,
-0.0745380968,
-0.0055698249,
0.0187228862,
-0.0074130502,
-0.0284499712,
0.0196182132,
-0.0819073692,
-0.0557372198,
0.0156855807,
0.0308947582,
0.0178633798,
0.0814879537,
-0.004521321,
-0.0392036699,
0.0977548212,
0.039226003,
0.0004953325,
0.0079873223,
0.0295474399,
-0.0330526233,
-0.0148847764,
0.0150544895,
-0.0537356623,
-0.001052781,
0.0443075038,
-0.0124500748,
-0.010916166,
0.0087050116,
0.0209585372,
-0.0256986339,
0.0532639697,
-0.0419972353,
-0.0524277389,
0.0108508989,
0.0313201435,
0.0104270289,
-0.0256426707,
-0.0212630443,
0.0214139353,
0.0170206036,
0.012834968,
0.0115343416,
0.0434783213,
0.0051033967,
0.0580105595,
-0.0570960604,
0.0195099954,
-0.0045432271,
0.0254533887,
0.0232481044,
0.0091230702,
-0.0300521478,
0.0177098848,
-0.000985209,
0.0280847326,
-0.0233763102,
0.0499093235,
0.0197689496,
0.0284340344,
-0.011487429,
0.0286694542,
-0.0916786119,
-0.0260243937,
-0.0545936376,
0.016188398,
0.0282818731,
-0.0476775952,
0.0026349071,
-0.027343791,
-0.0210524984,
-0.0312911049,
0.0233213715,
0.0024178019,
-0.015293099,
0.0322035551,
0.0288175996,
-0.0070556994,
0.0090432419,
0.074020721,
0.0059188902,
0.048184,
0.0319908634,
0.0129389027,
-0.0349002182,
0.0221144557,
0.0364020839,
0.0368705615,
-0.0185881555,
0.0156388748,
-0.0127051761,
-0.0587787814,
0.0062541659,
0.0119619211,
-0.0071964585,
0.0101970285,
0.0319953151,
0.0760025904,
-0.0153911067,
-0.0007685299,
-0.0288892109,
0.0025286891,
0.0109820105,
0.0019328271,
-0.0443539768,
-6.358362085e-33,
-0.0025842995,
0.0044940081,
-0.0241328236,
-0.0429667011,
0.0115969833,
0.0097616138,
-0.0206075851,
0.0066586579,
-0.0041093091,
-0.0073079914,
-0.0381410867,
0.0172542259,
0.022916561,
0.0337784626,
0.0094787162,
-0.0054031266,
0.0596099943,
-0.0126211233,
-0.0522388481,
0.0209779833,
0.0293038189,
0.031505283,
0.0596592538,
-0.0518970415,
0.0033884842,
-0.0153262606,
-0.0141686369,
0.0039381268,
-0.019719271,
0.0647256598,
-0.0062672207,
0.0254327748,
0.0099586137,
-0.0475448258,
-0.0284319352,
0.0109388353,
-0.039110627,
-0.0158995539,
0.0096035181,
0.0310271494,
-0.0341264494,
-0.0357183516,
0.0111946678,
-0.0101178922,
-0.0125540104,
-0.0242482182,
0.0257770624,
-0.0413643904,
-0.0486780815,
-0.0288279373,
-0.0236252174,
0.0225974638,
-0.0238271579,
-0.0242001563,
0.0243004225,
0.0463645682,
-0.001938776,
0.0082786055,
-0.0376169235,
-0.0139532126,
0.0242159404,
0.0370254293,
0.0789151564,
0.0520150289,
-0.0077979104,
0.0187824741,
-0.0153811565,
-0.007647926,
-0.0054638064,
-0.0646299645,
0.0289572347,
0.0289596822,
0.0450545661,
0.0324723907,
0.0583984032,
0.0254028719,
-0.0543196537,
0.0516744182,
0.0547537729,
0.0115549741,
0.0339382887,
0.0232967325,
-0.0510839894,
-0.0303120278,
-0.0548319705,
-0.054441113,
-0.0403524563,
-0.0196118467,
0.0372907519,
0.0327818133,
-0.0120250275,
-0.012031896,
0.046720393,
-0.0392196588,
-0.0140276719,
0.0339186266,
-0.0183242764,
0.007410733,
0.0115188006,
-0.0065724947,
-0.0216526967,
-0.0326232389,
0.0271134749,
0.036788471,
0.0308921784,
-0.0413440689,
0.0699038953,
0.0361305922,
-0.0807184353,
-0.0062112394,
-0.0213297904,
0.0067524752,
0.0212738272,
0.0358708873,
0.0348111242,
-0.0011297485,
-0.0157350376,
0.0292063318,
-0.0086979568,
-0.0265476834,
-0.0264742803,
-0.0006037745,
-0.0114071313,
0.0053897244,
-0.0241527148,
-0.0354962982,
-0.0144171901,
-0.0054246825,
0.0658555776,
0.0094863568,
-0.0166664235,
0.0311018638,
2.551e-7,
0.0385094993,
0.0348892249,
-0.0028249421,
-0.0303985085,
0.0250215549,
0.05355791,
-0.0388439,
0.0094639603,
0.0171044115,
0.0019830265,
0.0047326842,
-0.0100797061,
0.069496803,
0.0146843577,
-0.0793124288,
0.032465592,
-0.0918325707,
0.0337643921,
-0.0533738509,
0.0025072519,
0.0231496394,
0.1358624548,
0.0070980913,
-0.0257678423,
-0.0110767176,
0.002439915,
0.0577025115,
-0.0558388494,
0.0253055692,
0.0049669691,
0.0074631427,
0.0177020282,
0.0046277223,
0.0225147586,
-0.0193319898,
0.0257767588,
0.0075626657,
0.0383186154,
0.0122736022,
-0.0008754706,
-0.0052757687,
0.0120249409,
0.031265378,
-0.1095912308,
0.0681888536,
-0.0618148521,
-0.0056590219,
-0.0751349628,
-0.017103523,
-0.0282296203,
0.0421894342,
0.0039471374,
0.0200680662,
0.0374350213,
0.0056854566,
-0.0371650644,
-0.033066988,
-0.0951376185,
-0.0505067892,
0.0195784848,
-0.0319128782,
-0.0449307635,
-0.0371412039,
-0.0110681588,
0.0284657478,
-0.0620427318,
0.0037550211,
2.516074945e-34,
0.030982513,
0.0146315284,
0.0177518371,
0.0540234186,
-0.0142804738,
-0.0390670002,
0.0203833114,
-0.0123378839,
0.0276887491,
-0.0933485329,
0.0057343645
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06761v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06761v1 | APAR: LLMs Can Do Auto-Parallel Auto-Regressive Decoding | 2024-01-12T18:50:36 | 2024-01-12T18:50:36 | Mingdao Liu, Aohan Zeng, Bowen Wang, Peng Zhang, Jie Tang, Yuxiao Dong | cs.CL | cs.CL | The massive adoption of large language models (LLMs) demands efficient
deployment strategies. However, the auto-regressive decoding process, which is
fundamental to how most LLMs generate text, poses challenges to achieve
efficient serving. In this work, we introduce a parallel auto-regressive
generation method. By instruct-tuning on general domain data that contains
hierarchical structures, we enable LLMs to independently plan their generation
process and perform auto-parallel auto-regressive (APAR) generation,
significantly reducing the number of generation steps. APAR alone can achieve
up to 2x speed-up, and when combined with speculative decoding, the speed-up
can reach up to 4x. In addition, APAR reduces the key-value cache consumption
and attention computation during generation. This leads to a throughput
increase of 20-70% and a latency reduce of 20-35% in high-throughput scenarios,
compared to state-of-the-art serving frameworks. | [
0.0089091556,
0.0467145555,
-0.0171549376,
0.0102956844,
-0.0347404666,
0.0285371635,
-0.0029550637,
-0.026365418,
-0.0207911581,
-0.0254467689,
0.0129912486,
-0.0599288084,
-0.0070341728,
0.0309709497,
-0.0113847908,
0.0215645544,
0.0232857857,
-0.0292564537,
0.0262505729,
-0.0328246467,
-0.0275665037,
0.0514266491,
0.0252301898,
0.0011205893,
0.0195922013,
-0.0401884094,
-0.0261721797,
0.030175332,
-0.0410643928,
-0.0478869155,
0.0049068844,
0.0286449287,
0.0029517645,
0.0170889497,
0.0000022701,
-0.007100909,
-0.0291596707,
0.00372805,
-0.0411638357,
0.0784930959,
0.0534737557,
-0.0365567692,
-0.0516821519,
0.0510584414,
-0.0138893472,
-0.035370905,
0.0384362973,
-0.0272768736,
0.0430907086,
0.0415916927,
-0.0121130496,
-0.0714378133,
0.0278532952,
-0.0265158769,
-0.0611027442,
-0.0564325936,
0.0015478159,
0.0105408439,
-0.0362001695,
0.0224708896,
-0.008525881,
0.0163572021,
0.0055828225,
-0.0009552522,
0.0291036963,
0.0024084176,
0.0001807172,
-0.0168797486,
-0.034577366,
0.0281201825,
0.000287581,
-0.0542655699,
0.0092507098,
-0.0093765445,
-0.0382307842,
-0.0379821062,
0.001505113,
0.0644447058,
-0.0319967344,
0.0387743749,
0.0645701587,
-0.0046920669,
0.0135834338,
-0.0225530174,
-0.037304353,
0.028342206,
0.0343967751,
-0.0148316938,
-0.0450239331,
0.0119160796,
0.0171720199,
-0.0558127835,
0.0260282196,
0.0084326416,
-0.0256086979,
0.0127482694,
-0.0848230422,
-0.085171774,
0.0210201088,
-0.0375718474,
0.0836623833,
0.0695741475,
0.0133360177,
-0.0144861108,
-0.019240763,
0.0421556234,
-0.0451689363,
-0.0649176314,
-0.036961101,
-0.0163598862,
0.0132542634,
0.0037707372,
-0.0694052801,
0.0289465562,
-0.0722315386,
-0.0219431985,
-0.0234702192,
0.060941305,
0.0366689675,
-0.0104169063,
0.0351376198,
-0.0086162705,
-0.0375333503,
-0.0083222706,
0.054860834,
0.0383925326,
-0.0202695765,
-0.0559620187,
-0.0029244639,
-0.0547523312,
0.0028861489,
0.0004759402,
0.020750815,
-0.0038573723,
-0.0164497886,
0.0656089336,
-0.0196731053,
-0.0014884826,
-0.0500859953,
-0.0446435474,
0.0449150726,
-0.0388350375,
-0.0204054881,
-0.0524603575,
0.011609205,
0.0286369305,
-0.0198621042,
-0.0218632687,
-0.0045459364,
0.0215072576,
-0.0304158423,
0.0095150601,
-0.0258910526,
0.0295069925,
0.0229902193,
-0.0031504962,
0.0500894822,
0.0716478229,
0.0044583185,
0.0221718792,
-0.0159384888,
0.0021892285,
-0.0245500598,
0.0749169514,
0.0433285534,
0.0329782888,
-0.025510285,
0.0042674798,
0.000455002,
0.0136060519,
0.0672919825,
0.0514171273,
-0.0111539764,
-0.0153852412,
0.0379614346,
0.0290949754,
0.0096181119,
0.0482519642,
0.0176658072,
0.0500595011,
-0.0049865916,
-0.0075135943,
0.0152427526,
0.0305362213,
-0.0028241025,
0.0216111559,
0.0491684191,
0.064203456,
-0.0143991243,
0.0264212452,
-0.0338011011,
-0.0081152674,
-0.0336471312,
-0.01080376,
0.0457204022,
0.0403669402,
-0.0813261494,
0.0508862622,
0.0185354706,
-0.0666134506,
-0.0349463969,
-0.0207535475,
-0.0155789964,
0.0648158491,
0.065041922,
0.0520176217,
-0.0185036305,
0.0273867659,
0.0140922917,
0.048935689,
0.0045326157,
0.0064941356,
-0.0022836316,
-0.0672765225,
-0.0159933921,
0.0510660037,
0.0101885488,
0.0436509289,
0.0277380627,
0.0062163174,
0.0144313518,
0.0156175429,
-0.024629483,
-0.0023542137,
-0.0583668426,
-0.0179962963,
0.0329485089,
-0.0151584279,
0.0187238399,
0.0045699417,
-0.0196718052,
0.0107784616,
0.0456275418,
-0.0320481174,
0.0220838636,
-0.0203753691,
-0.0511500351,
-0.012768832,
0.0172882807,
0.0079065338,
0.0162846334,
0.0315102711,
-0.0105368588,
-0.0336513631,
0.0272292849,
-0.0480570011,
0.0583988614,
-0.0351100266,
0.0483564772,
0.0164968967,
0.0351695903,
-0.0286623146,
0.0301239323,
-0.0521060415,
-0.0220811721,
0.0046381229,
0.0063369838,
0.0150076244,
0.0015669571,
0.0139679555,
0.0011807426,
-0.0017977408,
0.0163747054,
-0.0079375198,
-0.0056341644,
0.0211566202,
0.002281639,
-0.0216765497,
0.0010529622,
-0.0348106064,
0.0306063704,
0.0126012005,
0.0479198433,
0.0063639223,
0.0009030365,
-0.0108313849,
0.0348715745,
0.018223105,
0.0245246366,
-0.0180002209,
-0.0238140542,
-0.0413146913,
0.0087947072,
-0.0380862318,
0.0192818381,
0.031637378,
-0.0211491883,
-0.0109302755,
-0.0657773986,
0.0161368325,
0.0236650854,
0.0149501432,
-0.0028025331,
-0.0633315593,
-0.0008682638,
-0.0488731302,
0.0550504252,
-0.008352221,
-0.0041725584,
-0.0180178862,
0.0076088314,
-0.0013766334,
-0.0343309902,
0.0025501321,
-0.0132369054,
-0.0185914636,
-0.0386265852,
-0.0566503406,
0.0111008631,
0.085998252,
0.0166775249,
-0.0140610905,
-0.0467585251,
-0.0508678444,
0.0067812218,
-0.0229950659,
-0.038943626,
-0.0227806028,
-0.0279041063,
0.0551676191,
0.0009874402,
-0.0651049316,
0.029901972,
-0.0547143184,
-0.0129178278,
-0.02812366,
-0.015022736,
-0.0502756536,
0.0369535647,
0.0094782114,
0.0300337803,
-0.0273302272,
-0.0385381877,
0.0208267886,
0.0775096044,
-0.0064158631,
-0.0317378566,
0.0310571231,
-0.0117577724,
0.0110680079,
-0.0331671089,
-0.0399556495,
-0.0443149321,
-0.0091575021,
-0.0168588497,
-0.0233020186,
0.0713397339,
-0.0414509624,
-0.0308835767,
0.0303909983,
-0.0362866484,
0.0369225629,
-0.0021917794,
0.0038076222,
-0.0178153403,
0.0283918474,
0.0203979164,
-0.0217649192,
-0.0045100935,
-0.0131161166,
-0.0015349457,
0.0565424673,
0.0434954688,
-0.0116355298,
-0.0342736281,
0.0001336395,
0.0800494254,
0.0353628621,
-0.0228225831,
0.0325522497,
0.004454161,
-0.0396473855,
-0.015049207,
0.088763237,
0.0278893635,
-0.0616181903,
-0.0019675919,
-0.0029255967,
0.0860998407,
0.0083681084,
0.032133583,
-0.1074595749,
-0.006417776,
0.0346184187,
0.0392720439,
0.0114252176,
0.0038006851,
-0.0359061137,
-0.113595441,
0.0714669526,
0.0211120062,
0.0022535459,
-0.0049129431,
-0.0283811744,
-0.0646515489,
0.0405262858,
0.0123265786,
0.0623228215,
0.0055780099,
0.0082420222,
0.0159095004,
-0.0186447613,
-0.0072788983,
-0.0056667314,
-0.0094416821,
0.0822680444,
0.0658755228,
0.0083160084,
0.0418081097,
-0.0216609538,
0.0082367295,
0.0340667553,
-0.0102187842,
-0.054765135,
-0.0292526279,
0.0079730861,
-0.0028491977,
-0.0176782701,
0.0069402531,
-0.0489728004,
0.0122554498,
-0.025575893,
0.0833165795,
-0.0248045791,
0.0187270567,
-0.0452753194,
-0.0186798442,
0.0291698873,
0.0511331148,
0.0122730853,
0.0006519681,
-0.041380696,
-0.0559430718,
-0.0065424908,
-0.0780672058,
-0.021617109,
0.0464318879,
0.0028892979,
-0.0408577248,
-0.0277461186,
0.0269483142,
-0.0151522895,
0.00486734,
0.0035692512,
0.0090869889,
0.0100553948,
-0.0222257227,
-0.1126297191,
-0.0570016317,
-0.0518291965,
-0.007980153,
-0.0821542293,
-0.0424310304,
0.0350035354,
-0.0206771586,
-0.0191099085,
0.0294179413,
-0.0819129795,
-0.068148315,
0.0352706872,
0.0283318236,
0.0179723036,
0.0469947942,
-0.0049590399,
-0.0664018318,
0.0438057147,
0.0280458387,
-0.0968781337,
0.0485498123,
-0.0301731918,
-0.0226653311,
-0.0136551149,
0.0282061622,
-0.0303763188,
0.0271895975,
-0.0468966439,
0.0137191946,
0.0521257408,
-0.0446337201,
0.0151263708,
0.0539106466,
-0.0196877327,
-0.0310311206,
0.0010655248,
0.0401139297,
0.0530279949,
-0.0405373313,
0.0096289795,
-0.0270214882,
0.0365086421,
0.0069228318,
-0.0593272001,
-0.0103389788,
-0.0027495068,
0.0502284467,
0.0276551824,
-0.009946771,
0.0119086178,
-0.0354919396,
-0.0176343285,
0.0808120668,
-0.021837607,
-0.0016118994,
0.0079889074,
0.026079312,
0.0247535184,
-0.0419224463,
-0.0165258776,
-0.0019099299,
0.0341360457,
-0.0296616089,
-0.0036140408,
-0.0160232782,
-0.0417554192,
-0.0277454853,
-0.0326224193,
0.0697292536,
0.0340000615,
0.0603686906,
-0.0227976739,
0.0119426874,
-0.0276622996,
0.0128114987,
-0.0091903144,
-0.0085495086,
0.0076906914,
0.0003189019,
-0.0250356104,
0.0049795494,
0.0784797221,
0.0827265903,
0.0235876422,
-0.0064477967,
-0.0033684229,
-0.0448222347,
-0.0366685428,
-0.0499563925,
0.0321724266,
-0.0280368105,
-0.0178126954,
-0.0245376974,
-0.0349678211,
-0.0132591259,
0.0225971173,
0.0042568957,
-0.0499161333,
0.0071708099,
0.0429594815,
0.0041895001,
-0.0345175676,
-0.0523791872,
0.0388455428,
-0.0555532053,
-0.0287128426,
0.0260636099,
-7.146651535e-33,
-0.0126250051,
-0.0062925746,
0.0249166843,
-0.033597786,
-0.02382195,
0.0014476882,
-0.0394687541,
-0.0365816653,
0.0486468747,
-0.0136181703,
-0.0253592674,
0.0373717956,
0.0307018291,
0.0255760271,
0.019935796,
0.0416277386,
0.0834179893,
-0.0451876633,
-0.0150923757,
0.0488569923,
0.0283440296,
0.0468348414,
-0.0085487124,
-0.0205912441,
-0.0417628884,
-0.0536952801,
0.041040685,
-0.0379064344,
0.0168242957,
0.0275356863,
-0.0227503553,
0.0259374976,
-0.0023512705,
-0.0443618856,
-0.0294041801,
0.0057200789,
-0.0979189128,
0.0342596956,
0.0161186755,
0.0180609673,
-0.0299203806,
-0.0491555259,
-0.0154909529,
0.0369833186,
-0.0087725855,
0.0004728698,
-0.0254763328,
0.0055274381,
-0.0430503599,
-0.0394909158,
-0.0234726761,
0.0226544756,
0.0310502648,
0.0441932604,
0.0577056929,
-0.0126104215,
0.0032212432,
0.0521217622,
-0.0472828448,
0.0221203491,
0.0160194039,
0.0806440786,
0.0532462932,
0.0167312305,
0.0101302452,
0.0114962338,
0.0229485482,
0.0009354667,
-0.0305078924,
0.0605566055,
0.020722568,
0.0230482128,
-0.0258970223,
0.0225227904,
0.0485861972,
-0.0597613491,
-0.0525207408,
0.0001129397,
0.0114894239,
-0.0073095686,
0.0493327454,
0.0051130624,
-0.0211402494,
-0.0410332456,
-0.0281869229,
0.0146180401,
-0.0334503837,
-0.0135519579,
0.0282604918,
0.0266980734,
-0.0151664792,
-0.0162709337,
0.0589064732,
-0.0242791008,
0.0043237675,
0.0697371811,
-0.0090528606,
0.0075783292,
-0.0199966487,
0.0422005989,
-0.0234454516,
-0.022357149,
-0.0274166949,
-0.0259501431,
0.0080520082,
0.007349446,
-0.0304419417,
0.0139667206,
-0.0724861622,
0.0134985754,
-0.0362692103,
0.0610982887,
0.0147134345,
0.044301305,
0.0349898301,
-0.0034727484,
0.0283420347,
0.0426542163,
-0.0154760126,
0.0060903854,
0.0049746088,
0.0127823548,
0.0330675915,
0.0263720471,
-0.0126108099,
0.0390801243,
-0.079683207,
0.0162960794,
0.0693643466,
-0.0517311655,
-0.0404462218,
0.0423604511,
2.862e-7,
0.0070777787,
0.0843123123,
0.077367574,
0.033080738,
0.0413609631,
0.0010057358,
0.0231786668,
0.0216700323,
0.0151317557,
0.0188157968,
-0.0170529671,
0.0133863036,
0.0678828508,
0.0177938659,
-0.0823065862,
0.0278178323,
-0.0548268594,
0.0304273013,
-0.0332660042,
-0.0246641599,
0.0000763101,
0.0726542622,
-0.0514239185,
-0.0355610512,
0.0488005169,
0.0294786394,
0.0073812557,
0.033680968,
0.0071491515,
0.0076628323,
-0.0336042605,
0.0226722006,
-0.0354802459,
-0.0137653444,
-0.0155087896,
-0.0013376541,
-0.06780494,
0.0667616203,
0.0118141752,
-0.0265720729,
0.0831187144,
-0.0465315096,
-0.0388890654,
0.002093914,
0.0443249084,
0.0008878618,
-0.0000795159,
-0.0280350409,
-0.0110956477,
0.000435057,
-0.0612837709,
-0.018696826,
0.0292013884,
0.0337209739,
0.0283282697,
-0.0458161011,
0.0205097776,
-0.0499053337,
-0.0426284894,
0.0008038005,
-0.039748434,
-0.0158473756,
-0.0575274602,
0.0293570831,
0.0196079053,
-0.0297997836,
0.0191788618,
3.1092147e-34,
0.05786217,
-0.0124587566,
-0.0036380377,
0.068307668,
-0.0007875173,
-0.0348325372,
-0.0149117503,
0.0518311113,
-0.0283457823,
-0.0830015093,
-0.0318723433
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06760v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06760v2 | Navigating the Metrics Maze: Reconciling Score Magnitudes and Accuracies | 2024-01-12T18:47:40 | 2024-06-10T12:57:48 | Tom Kocmi, Vilém Zouhar, Christian Federmann, Matt Post | cs.CL | cs.CL | Ten years ago a single metric, BLEU, governed progress in machine translation
research. For better or worse, there is no such consensus today, and
consequently it is difficult for researchers to develop and retain the kinds of
heuristic intuitions about metric deltas that drove earlier research and
deployment decisions. This paper investigates the "dynamic range" of a number
of modern metrics in an effort to provide a collective understanding of the
meaning of differences in scores both within and among metrics; in other words,
we ask what point difference X in metric Y is required between two systems for
humans to notice? We conduct our evaluation on a new large dataset, ToShip23,
using it to discover deltas at which metrics achieve system-level differences
that are meaningful to humans, which we measure by pairwise system accuracy. We
additionally show that this method of establishing delta-accuracy is more
stable than the standard use of statistical p-values in regards to testset
size. Where data size permits, we also explore the effect of metric deltas and
accuracy across finer-grained features such as translation direction, domain,
and system closeness. | [
-0.01633274,
0.0018479953,
-0.0222170446,
-0.0010829198,
-0.0506567731,
0.021852823,
0.0476789027,
0.0482422113,
-0.0658492669,
0.0133975679,
-0.0337302238,
-0.0529619642,
0.0947776362,
0.0305649322,
0.0255255289,
-0.0464701802,
0.0293307323,
0.0178530607,
-0.034697108,
0.0221058875,
-0.052523572,
-0.0124768121,
0.0014761857,
0.0484124273,
0.0291001741,
0.004448887,
0.0303245019,
0.0533581786,
0.0569648147,
-0.0259788018,
-0.0355052203,
0.0219335724,
0.0025050193,
0.0834764913,
0.0000022006,
-0.0565921441,
-0.009145719,
0.0220161397,
0.0143692261,
0.0088435374,
0.0393535048,
-0.0818610042,
-0.0121001611,
-0.0193269476,
-0.0105201351,
-0.0400862321,
0.0648915842,
-0.0543219484,
0.000584089,
0.0509950034,
-0.0257543661,
-0.0016518206,
-0.0418247841,
-0.0281311385,
-0.0130253024,
-0.0409423113,
-0.0207238812,
0.0510209948,
-0.0269628502,
-0.0000406152,
-0.0220122728,
0.051857885,
0.0052832561,
0.0148128755,
0.0018245064,
0.0213669278,
-0.018386852,
-0.0405756272,
0.0114014791,
0.0430551283,
-0.0205789562,
-0.0156845339,
-0.0178662557,
-0.0215603691,
-0.0330095738,
-0.035521701,
-0.0222279318,
-0.0209690854,
-0.0044689556,
-0.0243319292,
-0.0622320697,
0.0479855873,
0.0285465121,
-0.0596378595,
-0.0616131425,
-0.0112276524,
0.0075491364,
-0.0367143936,
-0.0260030199,
0.0258864928,
0.0043941503,
-0.0506882295,
0.0378070064,
-0.0283995774,
-0.0174829233,
0.000019475,
-0.0068572471,
-0.042739749,
0.0309557188,
-0.0498714335,
0.0155269001,
0.0450371988,
-0.0515788719,
0.0269827321,
-0.0269532539,
0.1086111069,
-0.0122127449,
0.0356992334,
-0.0411118083,
0.0310044512,
-0.0181338768,
0.0467763953,
0.0050727185,
-0.0669552162,
-0.0066364892,
0.0009978064,
-0.0288067199,
0.0077830153,
-0.0051470799,
0.0416725539,
0.011575236,
-0.0501741432,
-0.0512147583,
-0.0084179407,
-0.000683763,
0.0244831108,
-0.0446236506,
-0.0041125291,
0.0134075982,
-0.01536272,
-0.0075083096,
-0.0050316863,
-0.0311348289,
-0.0350253992,
-0.0068539591,
0.1148773283,
0.0045753131,
-0.0191481803,
0.0507307909,
0.0149151282,
-0.0308950879,
-0.0718314499,
-0.0212867931,
-0.0484827198,
0.051209487,
0.0375637785,
0.0050057936,
-0.0070288442,
-0.0064618071,
-0.021664558,
0.0209015179,
0.0603791177,
0.0357816219,
0.0243874192,
0.0098645519,
-0.0154367294,
-0.049445346,
0.0580335148,
0.0563983545,
0.0139883095,
0.0691712126,
0.002851465,
-0.0538928807,
0.0202314723,
-0.0270976685,
0.0580058135,
-0.0468655825,
0.0116378497,
0.0494762398,
0.0565967113,
0.0148356613,
0.0137767335,
-0.0229172111,
-0.0212820973,
0.0698516294,
0.0529700741,
0.0306688845,
0.0246386938,
0.0513448529,
-0.0048589199,
-0.01170801,
-0.0111677311,
0.0094140302,
0.0109210294,
0.0288871937,
0.0158488713,
0.0631073639,
0.0476946495,
0.0134149445,
-0.036497198,
-0.0212997571,
0.0021459323,
-0.0080550872,
-0.0644411966,
0.0484297164,
0.0020997953,
-0.019577967,
0.0123635931,
-0.0350950323,
-0.064458549,
-0.0053073582,
-0.0213704631,
-0.0265410412,
0.0258288402,
0.0482442454,
-0.022357408,
0.0125149954,
0.0187038649,
0.0013888741,
0.0199606549,
0.0772587135,
0.0318958275,
0.0136836907,
-0.0053214552,
-0.0297709126,
0.036917951,
0.0036625746,
0.0268759448,
-0.0056022741,
0.0631935522,
0.0167801548,
-0.086969547,
-0.0800142735,
0.0258265771,
0.0235740952,
0.0320435017,
0.0207357872,
0.0260030013,
0.0262431502,
0.008235218,
-0.0408234447,
-0.0062777381,
-0.0010417602,
-0.0199081786,
0.001961099,
0.0390352048,
0.0335683748,
0.0276461765,
0.004020351,
-0.0281955078,
0.0143351322,
0.013664593,
-0.0316524915,
-0.0130628729,
-0.0021506606,
-0.0264301822,
-0.0212812237,
0.0024415378,
0.0619647242,
-0.0335309207,
0.0011752581,
-0.050451152,
0.0027047379,
0.0016483759,
0.0295710936,
-0.0370000862,
-0.0140939988,
0.0541700833,
0.0257988591,
-0.002543764,
0.0684715062,
0.0147898057,
0.0050456272,
0.042649731,
0.0248795357,
-0.040555872,
-0.0361088701,
-0.0452996083,
0.0094897384,
-0.0162583441,
0.0538570844,
0.0454382598,
0.0022062282,
0.0042906194,
-0.0053890636,
0.0131220641,
-0.003637102,
-0.0099886563,
-0.0030721964,
0.042916894,
0.0268758833,
-0.0505286753,
-0.0258862954,
-0.0149332471,
0.0105759325,
0.0663239881,
0.0206653439,
-0.0220189989,
-0.0743556321,
0.0318522789,
-0.031945128,
-0.0251434948,
0.0109469546,
-0.0560711026,
0.0429308787,
0.0253159609,
0.0153199006,
0.083014816,
0.0037852204,
0.0134535311,
0.053391356,
-0.0039275922,
-0.0441315994,
-0.0245760754,
-0.0330883525,
-0.0465041809,
-0.000588015,
-0.0542765781,
0.0227251556,
0.0156638697,
0.012707945,
0.0074447379,
-0.0723282769,
0.0162087064,
-0.032696113,
-0.0321898162,
-0.0156777613,
0.0247865897,
-0.0013502657,
0.0739557445,
-0.0315127112,
-0.0691318959,
0.0384232029,
-0.0520575121,
0.0210844576,
-0.0395041667,
0.024536971,
-0.0210045949,
0.0561099797,
-0.0228412244,
0.0078448234,
-0.0251388587,
-0.0161319952,
-0.0179363061,
0.0595302097,
0.0201722067,
-0.0347239636,
0.0326662064,
-0.0823260546,
0.0053836657,
-0.0291694589,
-0.0040096729,
0.0066927178,
0.0622738227,
0.0045631393,
-0.0205405671,
0.011354058,
-0.0823034942,
-0.0349720158,
0.0395931751,
0.0532884821,
0.0318466313,
0.0096379304,
-0.0384899713,
-0.0140513629,
-0.03292308,
-0.0523580015,
0.0156270824,
0.0500609875,
-0.0499167219,
-0.0222797785,
-0.007356842,
0.0161043592,
0.008672337,
-0.0327583626,
-0.0329449251,
0.0187544376,
0.0176327918,
-0.0268023498,
0.0141008822,
0.0827446431,
-0.0412141755,
-0.0211835634,
0.0525173545,
0.0043566669,
-0.0245507583,
0.0203372072,
-0.0109455511,
0.0327414759,
0.0170960128,
-0.0020412244,
-0.0541457422,
0.006248415,
0.0089442134,
0.0309535582,
-0.009060028,
0.016366329,
-0.0093969367,
-0.0387089439,
0.0277884454,
0.043708574,
-0.0810880661,
-0.0729716495,
-0.0330283232,
0.0023552075,
-0.0253810361,
0.0245639402,
-0.0031792261,
0.0125394035,
-0.0090930508,
0.0142931426,
0.0012603765,
-0.0535067059,
0.0211182665,
-0.0413617156,
0.0118453987,
0.0691543296,
0.0521664098,
-0.0073392913,
-0.0806810856,
-0.0103788218,
0.0003976062,
0.0217458643,
0.0206003468,
0.039566759,
0.0386264808,
-0.0291983467,
0.0238251686,
-0.0468030907,
-0.0006374668,
0.0319432057,
-0.0196561199,
0.0241434053,
-0.023729749,
-0.0105557768,
0.0276598334,
-0.0039364467,
-0.018607039,
0.0253659394,
0.037517298,
-0.0516903102,
-0.0201957934,
-0.006278282,
0.0140511645,
-0.0475627072,
-0.0178517625,
-0.0156235825,
-0.0797469094,
-0.0633485094,
-0.0764919594,
-0.0145622175,
-0.0189220048,
0.0475719683,
0.0124916947,
-0.0282983799,
-0.0219963398,
0.0132909361,
-0.024590956,
0.0132886432,
0.0081783161,
0.0532161929,
-0.0281497333,
0.0349823348,
-0.0371900797,
0.025617497,
-0.0381633118,
0.0284849517,
-0.0584368333,
-0.037714798,
-0.010682133,
0.0300980266,
0.0297468565,
-0.0229954086,
-0.0135855936,
0.0072780936,
0.0071791243,
0.0124706104,
-0.0108551681,
0.0286242869,
0.0355242565,
-0.0334859192,
-0.0254148114,
0.023076022,
-0.033765547,
-0.0432537049,
-0.0076528694,
0.0154489204,
0.0204350688,
-0.0713295937,
-0.0043643308,
0.0095295664,
0.0590387657,
-0.0274348482,
-0.05860525,
0.0215434134,
0.0091172922,
-0.0031538508,
0.0156201255,
-0.0313419774,
-0.0688068941,
0.0419999622,
0.0240482781,
-0.0248246659,
0.0799806714,
-0.0162810609,
-0.0289134141,
-0.0083405171,
-0.0050834855,
-0.0176687017,
0.1007296517,
0.0162096843,
0.0212659072,
-0.0421853289,
0.0007641151,
-0.0058437116,
0.0285881404,
-0.0103508811,
0.033894401,
0.0313707739,
0.0400193036,
0.0195828583,
0.0750846267,
-0.0216760878,
-0.0173656289,
-0.0125185773,
-0.0348510072,
0.0533275045,
0.0264132414,
0.1142325252,
0.0004375171,
0.0096329954,
-0.0296345893,
0.0284514911,
-0.0172617603,
0.0078764986,
-0.0603571124,
-0.0166335814,
0.0005175616,
0.0529950112,
0.0295020882,
-0.087666899,
-0.0047112587,
-0.0485192947,
-0.0222510044,
0.0087705469,
-0.0101792887,
-0.0068694451,
-0.037067838,
0.0023355572,
-0.0395178236,
-0.062926501,
-0.0389500074,
0.0307718571,
0.0450936556,
0.0187539756,
0.0176656153,
-0.0081163598,
0.0964359269,
-0.0274183545,
-0.0163551141,
-0.0128141847,
-0.0363735035,
-0.0490111448,
0.0105146039,
-0.0384822935,
-6.455517428e-33,
-0.0236316249,
-0.0162124373,
-0.0189277884,
-0.0352229588,
-0.0609913655,
-0.0164145306,
-0.0265212227,
-0.002227426,
0.0002318544,
0.0153974779,
0.0242850259,
0.0001832805,
0.0190233216,
-0.0646532699,
0.0105536282,
0.0067437617,
0.0417596027,
-0.0034119913,
-0.0654654577,
0.0042060157,
0.0787592381,
-0.0193999372,
0.0577008426,
-0.0921636298,
0.0658454299,
0.029654637,
-0.0000459833,
-0.0187800527,
0.006372394,
-0.0100924922,
0.029165864,
0.0143061001,
0.0027504354,
-0.0172877554,
-0.0502898581,
-0.0405019186,
-0.0315716676,
0.0069478843,
0.005206801,
0.0672100335,
0.010923082,
-0.0203677509,
0.0445762724,
-0.0230570696,
-0.0587666854,
-0.0343868211,
0.008500482,
-0.0603094883,
-0.0374780111,
-0.0362042971,
-0.0356060527,
0.0204653777,
-0.0206148494,
0.0151695097,
0.0156346727,
0.0729604661,
-0.0404466018,
-0.0282586459,
-0.0470735133,
0.0173536241,
0.0116652474,
0.0387772545,
0.0893006399,
-0.0095217265,
0.0240625981,
0.0350375473,
0.0616003983,
-0.0019441291,
0.0567681827,
-0.0133653311,
0.0477204733,
0.0071349898,
0.0643849894,
0.0381146818,
0.0358646289,
-0.0090240845,
-0.0624627098,
0.0556210577,
-0.0787307173,
0.0053955358,
0.0160835385,
0.034644369,
-0.0515521206,
0.0274148621,
-0.0130318021,
-0.0319421999,
-0.0140423542,
-0.0680485144,
0.0054215323,
-0.0039286027,
-0.0070921872,
-0.029481994,
0.053922575,
-0.0134971673,
0.0247790348,
-0.0616306216,
-0.0210996736,
0.0307976846,
-0.0007495477,
-0.01013867,
0.0094225444,
-0.0301168468,
0.0230851248,
0.0724384561,
0.0568309054,
-0.071880646,
0.0043798224,
0.0086364653,
-0.0335313678,
0.005055652,
-0.0211220793,
-0.0121857729,
-0.0108057568,
-0.0194263905,
0.0291307233,
-0.0127624776,
-0.0122425044,
0.040944986,
-0.0030931097,
-0.0307331402,
-0.0288862735,
0.056703493,
-0.0175822228,
0.0573901273,
-0.07820867,
0.0017911189,
-0.0547125153,
0.0380298756,
0.0676922947,
-0.0221021902,
-0.0646760166,
0.0269934684,
2.944e-7,
0.0536106639,
0.0704744756,
0.0298984256,
0.0119265551,
-0.0009597285,
0.0266164206,
-0.0412576385,
0.0133497706,
0.0075758197,
0.0069001638,
0.0309139397,
0.0033342149,
0.0728256777,
0.02702922,
-0.0120742498,
-0.0291161146,
-0.0411436111,
0.0254171211,
-0.0535889007,
-0.0087707033,
0.0625262335,
0.0138328383,
-0.0175095126,
0.0307650082,
0.0162569489,
-0.0408943258,
0.0330246054,
-0.0389266647,
0.0431148112,
-0.001678642,
0.050604444,
-0.0280320905,
-0.0136584425,
0.0514858998,
-0.0052036867,
0.0057876171,
0.0627877861,
0.0424816161,
0.0179526247,
-0.0035979643,
-0.0015821378,
-0.000498806,
-0.0124886772,
-0.0628210604,
0.0226297304,
-0.0499231592,
-0.0095425909,
0.0057971543,
-0.0074662236,
0.0347642973,
0.0594278425,
-0.0132957324,
-0.0136093292,
0.0308193993,
0.0385428742,
0.0257572923,
0.0055901371,
-0.0187350009,
-0.0246410295,
0.02739322,
-0.0158823822,
-0.0772998482,
-0.0254132692,
0.0358035229,
-0.0063510798,
0.0271780174,
-0.0220262408,
2.522915771e-34,
0.0400799029,
-0.0231690537,
0.0320223458,
-0.0623776391,
0.036851123,
-0.0381559618,
-0.0119393319,
-0.0292169005,
-0.0220936276,
-0.0235481095,
0.0059330133
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06752v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06752v1 | Stylometry Analysis of Multi-authored Documents for Authorship and Author Style Change Detection | 2024-01-12T18:36:41 | 2024-01-12T18:36:41 | Muhammad Tayyab Zamir, Muhammad Asif Ayub, Asma Gul, Nasir Ahmad, Kashif Ahmad | cs.CL | cs.CL | In recent years, the increasing use of Artificial Intelligence based text
generation tools has posed new challenges in document provenance,
authentication, and authorship detection. However, advancements in stylometry
have provided opportunities for automatic authorship and author change
detection in multi-authored documents using style analysis techniques. Style
analysis can serve as a primary step toward document provenance and
authentication through authorship detection. This paper investigates three key
tasks of style analysis: (i) classification of single and multi-authored
documents, (ii) single change detection, which involves identifying the point
where the author switches, and (iii) multiple author-switching detection in
multi-authored documents. We formulate all three tasks as classification
problems and propose a merit-based fusion framework that integrates several
state-of-the-art natural language processing (NLP) algorithms and weight
optimization techniques. We also explore the potential of special characters,
which are typically removed during pre-processing in NLP applications, on the
performance of the proposed methods for these tasks by conducting extensive
experiments on both cleaned and raw datasets. Experimental results demonstrate
significant improvements over existing solutions for all three tasks on a
benchmark dataset. | [
0.0334910937,
0.0737472698,
0.004133055,
0.0422515273,
-0.082628198,
0.0080752168,
0.0547983348,
0.0261872243,
-0.0105466647,
-0.0418983772,
0.0220872387,
-0.0234079175,
0.0490184985,
-0.0012071253,
0.0085385991,
0.0546306595,
0.0092109311,
0.0398435555,
0.0485015661,
0.0278396159,
-0.0047956677,
0.0124738244,
0.0171231143,
0.0321351252,
-0.0167228952,
-0.0436914861,
0.0125128506,
0.0454355106,
0.0414354205,
0.0051566479,
0.0090990448,
0.0894275382,
-0.0319494568,
0.1076978892,
0.000001839,
-0.0638083592,
-0.0489130318,
-0.0008602396,
0.0077447351,
-0.0145321311,
0.0690842271,
0.0462586395,
-0.0416197591,
0.0055808155,
-0.0323847309,
0.0215289779,
-0.0066593271,
0.0516502373,
0.041044727,
0.1111036539,
-0.0294523165,
-0.0855854899,
0.0190870631,
0.0300687142,
0.0082026776,
0.0324801207,
0.0434248075,
-0.0634915009,
-0.0098285992,
0.0077803386,
0.0196838658,
0.020732332,
-0.0682502016,
-0.0436833501,
-0.0239595361,
-0.0143340779,
-0.0322307535,
0.0317432322,
0.0057875533,
-0.0308618061,
-0.0311777033,
-0.0338283442,
0.0440377705,
0.0064136186,
-0.0070882849,
0.024929231,
0.0146828983,
0.0119692683,
-0.0609261207,
-0.0258415174,
0.0116920546,
-0.0208582226,
-0.0119775739,
0.0219908282,
-0.004183108,
0.0337042548,
0.0071646152,
-0.036634732,
-0.0417242348,
-0.0085928515,
0.0059980066,
-0.0443867296,
0.0489412397,
0.0112580145,
0.0323021933,
-0.0149886394,
-0.0478246994,
-0.1082459539,
0.0107039222,
-0.0567610264,
0.0199771579,
-0.0329092368,
-0.0111551927,
0.0217295922,
-0.0358393118,
0.0284241922,
0.0084634693,
-0.0331075937,
0.0193652343,
0.0163209196,
-0.063986294,
-0.0305982903,
-0.0306650363,
-0.0085497173,
0.04339955,
0.0040458953,
-0.016890021,
0.0039322651,
0.0182367209,
-0.0027721862,
-0.0242666695,
-0.0195453744,
0.0079992646,
0.0326284245,
0.0230547227,
0.0241720397,
0.025261445,
-0.0028276769,
-0.0241743885,
0.0060952217,
0.003265186,
0.0550066158,
0.0402467214,
-0.0071578082,
0.038562648,
-0.0185115412,
-0.0147851901,
-0.038617149,
-0.0371985883,
-0.0454766974,
-0.0114192599,
-0.0236381311,
-0.023913661,
-0.0441931151,
0.0005146036,
-0.023672631,
-0.0095613329,
-0.049719017,
-0.0289783068,
0.0230305325,
-0.061728552,
0.0342737958,
-0.0007463167,
-0.0052965297,
0.0802852213,
-0.0507041663,
0.0028837512,
-0.0267503355,
0.0386558212,
0.0154414587,
0.0696241558,
0.0132558746,
0.0238650553,
0.0147097232,
-0.0154064326,
0.0033271182,
0.0304793715,
-0.0352211446,
0.002795269,
0.0024169148,
-0.01690167,
0.020789057,
-0.0088555347,
-0.0434189141,
0.0313138366,
0.0287582744,
0.0381282233,
0.0106939739,
0.0270444248,
0.0297148507,
0.0238599349,
0.0179462675,
0.0192764774,
-0.0161502138,
-0.0585130788,
-0.0430734269,
-0.0510810055,
0.0234091915,
0.0025723546,
0.0183111299,
-0.0161815844,
0.0052649966,
0.0123702027,
-0.0545740202,
0.0150592318,
-0.0108919377,
-0.0242997669,
-0.0419273935,
-0.0239432622,
-0.0660009608,
-0.0157347918,
-0.0271675121,
-0.0021180033,
0.0509339347,
0.0689726323,
-0.0391166359,
0.0316398889,
-0.0268690009,
-0.018849019,
0.0298153702,
-0.017559208,
-0.0143616302,
0.0195787959,
-0.0400252044,
-0.0121650407,
0.0167632941,
-0.0126065388,
0.0330130346,
0.0035174177,
0.0355931036,
0.0110073034,
0.0035503889,
-0.0333239697,
0.0423530415,
0.0066557289,
-0.0361442715,
0.0543024242,
0.0003168915,
0.0032075718,
0.0103093563,
-0.0372070745,
0.0106293531,
-0.0131512508,
-0.0325826108,
-0.0409561656,
0.0376816243,
0.0560038649,
0.0018154416,
0.0358642302,
0.0129532609,
0.0052196854,
0.0021905599,
-0.0025959776,
-0.0466614366,
0.018270487,
-0.0203447454,
-0.0336037092,
-0.0455716252,
0.0512952134,
-0.0306081437,
0.0223006606,
-0.0711939484,
0.074242942,
0.0425239205,
0.0171298217,
-0.0447018556,
-0.0340985768,
0.079990454,
-0.003482257,
-0.0184750967,
-0.033624921,
-0.023676293,
0.0231143851,
0.0602148362,
-0.0090630231,
0.0202554408,
-0.0875229761,
-0.0293853227,
0.004220969,
-0.0227247272,
0.0599327944,
-0.0098209176,
-0.0152892293,
-0.0209270082,
-0.0195401553,
-0.0076224487,
-0.0388723128,
-0.0357671045,
-0.0196744855,
0.0654297322,
0.0000057675,
-0.0069995252,
-0.0085774623,
-0.0049362397,
-0.0234603435,
0.0462225191,
0.0443025902,
-0.0291878767,
-0.0590162463,
-0.0233340487,
-0.0114290053,
0.0188103672,
0.0119454628,
0.0166159198,
0.0215007588,
-0.0223591626,
0.0625780001,
0.0552031472,
0.0553714968,
-0.0029487154,
-0.0168315079,
-0.0093432898,
0.0106221065,
-0.007975461,
0.0034054338,
0.0755847618,
0.0228975639,
-0.0051354282,
0.0934406966,
-0.0201651566,
-0.0126337465,
-0.0422847532,
-0.005467861,
-0.0137065705,
0.0307749901,
0.0102503318,
0.0692837164,
-0.0226304252,
0.0149939004,
-0.0139694326,
-0.0030179913,
0.0020876091,
0.0259616747,
-0.0507318601,
0.0176877137,
-0.0690441281,
-0.0023043957,
-0.0328259654,
0.0356615409,
0.0133328391,
0.0176465362,
0.0333220996,
-0.0427089743,
-0.003885244,
-0.001151773,
0.097850278,
0.0110346768,
-0.0342381187,
-0.0511920378,
0.0607293658,
0.0078576999,
0.0033185603,
-0.012862199,
-0.0426750667,
0.0030843229,
-0.0283238944,
-0.0121813947,
-0.0608045384,
-0.0337300822,
-0.0329110213,
0.0355728492,
0.0726198703,
-0.0271101706,
-0.0111437114,
0.0133255227,
0.0488490611,
-0.0060900357,
-0.0465859771,
-0.016866019,
-0.0123989629,
-0.0357952826,
0.0059048291,
-0.03574742,
0.0145843523,
-0.0175134949,
-0.0242461748,
-0.00137758,
-0.0908450559,
-0.0575832203,
-0.0118360659,
0.0043201712,
-0.0518945046,
0.0179609954,
0.1038343757,
0.0356311575,
-0.0498431958,
-0.0359939188,
-0.0398836769,
-0.0333142243,
0.0164430402,
0.0173523016,
-0.0616633743,
-0.0128269801,
-0.0240739305,
-0.0067134914,
-0.0315379165,
-0.0369354934,
-0.0022864826,
-0.0221877843,
0.0150926486,
-0.0132793738,
-0.0473617204,
0.039293617,
-0.0340334438,
-0.0114513803,
-0.0016653927,
-0.0728119761,
-0.0256311316,
0.0016691322,
-0.0027919081,
-0.000914373,
-0.0287363064,
-0.019732317,
-0.0157315433,
-0.0254257061,
-0.0449775718,
0.0579393581,
0.0843619108,
-0.0489077456,
-0.0540670641,
0.001197385,
-0.0264061876,
0.0072736838,
-0.048225075,
0.0678947493,
-0.0171483699,
0.002534484,
-0.0163519923,
0.0180094633,
0.0110128401,
-0.0204732958,
0.0314548872,
-0.0042585302,
-0.0275750943,
-0.0209661163,
-0.0161408633,
-0.0275907181,
0.0381461941,
0.0133844577,
-0.010793319,
-0.0606174096,
-0.0765110403,
-0.0070590926,
0.0467294455,
-0.0162069313,
-0.009996471,
-0.0216485467,
-0.01179366,
-0.0297274441,
-0.1028424129,
0.0191616975,
-0.0607311167,
0.0236275364,
0.009509149,
0.0413756967,
0.0208331198,
-0.0310317203,
-0.0853100196,
-0.0432556085,
-0.0224803295,
0.073071897,
-0.0262227636,
0.0206937362,
0.0193380956,
0.0023802535,
0.0284888372,
-0.0041070776,
-0.0604107603,
-0.0348852426,
0.0065000677,
-0.0365019888,
0.0148298265,
0.0193229057,
-0.0290335193,
-0.0382763371,
0.015159593,
0.0395833626,
0.0204285122,
0.0093110139,
0.0284938142,
-0.0323636457,
-0.0614808537,
-0.0088291476,
0.0157910641,
0.0181236546,
0.0263495501,
-0.05696382,
-0.0137495892,
-0.0032077718,
-0.0198746435,
0.0502776951,
0.0117110554,
-0.0343883187,
0.036518503,
0.0128010856,
-0.012394133,
-0.0118289562,
-0.0079602776,
0.015117215,
-0.0098159667,
-0.0165847614,
-0.0002239663,
-0.039171353,
0.0602784753,
0.0093109105,
0.0379323587,
-0.0295506362,
0.0341881141,
-0.0054409802,
0.1076503322,
-0.0411517136,
-0.0043507982,
0.0219913367,
-0.004353412,
0.0302271303,
0.0445738882,
0.0053292667,
0.0011333321,
0.0420363508,
0.0150802685,
-0.0395997912,
0.0591414496,
-0.0918750614,
0.0342291594,
0.0060948441,
-0.0271053035,
0.0413772948,
-0.0166401863,
0.0695346892,
-0.009330323,
-0.0004756281,
-0.0203460641,
0.04156648,
0.041796159,
0.020939976,
-0.0769704208,
0.0044293148,
-0.0315786228,
0.0472943932,
0.0525982864,
-0.006482034,
0.014843218,
-0.0103567978,
-0.0714416727,
-0.0171198584,
-0.0179090351,
0.0229124203,
-0.0142727783,
0.0230551455,
-0.0133104064,
-0.0577029586,
0.0275261719,
0.0995400548,
0.0013786501,
0.0714790225,
0.0123429801,
-0.0035268632,
0.0500619821,
0.0002765561,
0.0275838394,
-0.0424925126,
-0.0036177163,
0.0325341783,
-0.0224500522,
0.0122719789,
-5.148519422e-33,
0.0354357027,
-0.0567991696,
-0.0274350625,
0.0615294613,
-0.0158520099,
-0.005569302,
-0.0284557194,
-0.0563681871,
-0.0100246975,
0.005228966,
-0.0475521907,
0.0152434055,
0.011268815,
-0.0146636767,
0.0236178581,
0.0556367375,
0.043747399,
0.0188449603,
-0.0496101528,
0.0074298983,
0.072118409,
-0.0120690288,
0.0639322549,
-0.0654090345,
0.0371936411,
-0.0345759466,
-0.0478753112,
-0.0004294032,
-0.0382847302,
-0.01964904,
0.0146073857,
-0.0127966451,
0.0189722683,
-0.0247300491,
-0.0200616643,
-0.0152073829,
-0.032700289,
-0.0477926843,
-0.0517468788,
0.0425436832,
0.0596429296,
-0.020738462,
0.0362753831,
-0.0033290463,
0.0022800805,
0.019976873,
0.080121465,
0.0087103546,
-0.0224107336,
-0.0765102208,
-0.0652576759,
0.0382534266,
-0.0101981899,
0.0158785023,
0.0187015384,
0.0028473018,
-0.0037335381,
-0.0196512714,
-0.0958677009,
-0.0209723171,
-0.0269022901,
-0.0200340934,
-0.0692125037,
0.0287111066,
-0.0111339027,
0.0187794548,
0.0009065581,
0.0505616665,
0.0186075605,
0.0349639393,
0.067058824,
0.0128029622,
0.042240914,
0.058360301,
0.031793166,
-0.0288143046,
-0.0448428467,
0.0536627285,
0.0573793836,
-0.0162096303,
-0.0158480573,
0.0199684054,
-0.0078629209,
-0.0278149527,
-0.0058456752,
-0.0473145247,
-0.009838053,
0.0252605099,
-0.0418918021,
-0.0108221537,
-0.0330746733,
0.0253497213,
0.0158275608,
-0.0308766719,
-0.0408561826,
-0.0099798851,
-0.0494476333,
0.0831558332,
0.009230651,
-0.0274233446,
0.0280367937,
-0.0318272151,
0.033970505,
0.0299332216,
0.0209767241,
-0.0024104114,
0.072291255,
0.0202920679,
-0.0696822479,
-0.0066447421,
0.0598715171,
0.0064653135,
0.0064504244,
0.0359433256,
-0.026394153,
-0.0018122018,
0.0489272252,
0.0344503857,
0.0254106168,
0.011820551,
-0.0220052041,
-0.002832476,
0.0382746495,
0.0102560772,
-0.0168621168,
0.0101995058,
0.0315339006,
-0.0065641552,
0.0017620252,
-0.0201505907,
0.0107051758,
-0.0346167907,
2.47e-7,
0.0646983981,
0.0182361975,
0.0664835423,
-0.0497621186,
0.0208073277,
0.0446104482,
0.0212707575,
0.0326162688,
-0.0337090753,
0.0296747647,
0.0138553167,
-0.0035337047,
0.0616573803,
0.0029660556,
-0.0706894249,
-0.0103452876,
-0.0197952278,
0.0039806454,
-0.0785982981,
0.0207348708,
0.05882385,
-0.0044817431,
0.0342446454,
-0.0303409118,
-0.0283175297,
-0.0192977078,
0.0420934632,
0.0407131761,
0.0316159651,
0.0228961241,
0.047570955,
-0.0684396774,
0.0132852476,
0.0307914969,
-0.0267725177,
0.0447786674,
-0.0098982202,
0.0276672374,
-0.0313761421,
0.062065728,
0.0118376035,
-0.0206313524,
0.0008193886,
0.0157821514,
0.0345142037,
0.0748537406,
-0.0066098045,
-0.0505770743,
-0.0340416841,
-0.0154987359,
0.035455782,
0.024501754,
-0.031231232,
0.0669702366,
0.0008090796,
-0.0079786582,
-0.0070497384,
-0.0733462945,
0.0028963957,
-0.0027572752,
-0.0056165843,
0.0458272174,
0.0197198875,
0.0029629893,
0.0600528494,
-0.0830412358,
0.0482078008,
2.388570542e-34,
0.0336989537,
0.0040689269,
-0.0220803209,
0.0216972623,
0.0304647721,
0.0060059512,
-0.0206598062,
0.0551168919,
-0.0334797837,
-0.0384977758,
0.0081921108
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06751v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06751v2 | The Unreasonable Effectiveness of Easy Training Data for Hard Tasks | 2024-01-12T18:36:29 | 2024-06-05T14:10:11 | Peter Hase, Mohit Bansal, Peter Clark, Sarah Wiegreffe | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | How can we train models to perform well on hard test data when hard training
data is by definition difficult to label correctly? This question has been
termed the scalable oversight problem and has drawn increasing attention as
language models have continually improved. In this paper, we present the
surprising conclusion that current pretrained language models often generalize
relatively well from easy to hard data, even performing as well as oracle
models finetuned on hard data. We demonstrate this kind of easy-to-hard
generalization using simple finetuning methods like in-context learning, linear
classifier heads, and QLoRA for seven different measures of datapoint hardness,
including six empirically diverse human hardness measures (like grade level)
and one model-based measure (loss-based). Furthermore, we show that even if one
cares most about model performance on hard data, it can be better to collect
easy data rather than hard data for finetuning, since hard data is generally
noisier and costlier to collect. Our experiments use open models up to 70b in
size and four publicly available question-answering datasets with questions
ranging in difficulty from 3rd grade science questions to college level STEM
questions and general-knowledge trivia. We conclude that easy-to-hard
generalization in LMs is surprisingly strong for the tasks studied. Our code is
available at: https://github.com/allenai/easy-to-hard-generalization | [
0.0397249088,
0.0516495556,
-0.0169719812,
0.0291578528,
0.0169548318,
0.0593977906,
-0.0165744517,
0.0156291611,
0.0057821255,
-0.0617501996,
-0.0023378166,
0.0005351952,
-0.0255680084,
-0.0265793614,
0.0383372642,
-0.0443255901,
0.0172187351,
-0.0129620582,
0.0213941503,
-0.0371954478,
0.0088521969,
-0.0032418175,
0.0103944978,
-0.013121387,
0.0241958648,
-0.0061201858,
0.0136749279,
-0.0169626959,
-0.008210538,
0.0118788723,
0.0445311517,
0.0618707761,
0.0093712024,
0.0216782335,
0.0000017958,
-0.0787204877,
-0.0156573597,
-0.0115286922,
-0.0489619151,
0.0136012258,
-0.0247781109,
-0.0397422239,
0.0303454455,
0.0285132118,
-0.0428616665,
-0.0195805077,
0.0324016586,
0.0264497828,
0.0623464733,
0.0485775843,
0.0078717591,
-0.016042389,
0.0228019692,
-0.0209652614,
0.0610436164,
-0.0843272209,
0.0234401505,
0.0173730645,
-0.0274970997,
0.0118306978,
-0.0218368601,
0.0337313488,
0.0152346576,
0.0557349809,
-0.0096663097,
0.0249956809,
-0.0456438363,
0.0229391474,
0.014241471,
0.1169655994,
-0.0366881751,
-0.0245287921,
-0.0132178534,
-0.0262930803,
0.03848169,
-0.0036457267,
-0.0368967839,
0.0213245172,
0.0095494436,
0.002563715,
0.0052316277,
-0.0301455129,
0.0253211483,
0.0309764203,
-0.0220658556,
0.0183279738,
-0.0066354866,
-0.0425531082,
0.0550946556,
0.0278204829,
-0.0393960997,
-0.017278133,
-0.0442257486,
0.0363683887,
-0.0525129549,
0.0150130624,
-0.0425076298,
-0.0035785753,
0.0437714756,
-0.027599087,
0.0446075276,
0.004169431,
-0.0508153699,
0.0733117908,
-0.0241174363,
0.0335288048,
0.0193065908,
0.0794117823,
-0.0209976453,
-0.0373654924,
-0.0334613137,
-0.0025695034,
-0.0130388131,
0.0409480296,
0.0053376202,
0.0296563711,
-0.0300981924,
0.0056941076,
-0.0307844095,
0.0225790348,
-0.0153597305,
-0.0117633287,
-0.0309543107,
-0.0056623509,
-0.0449591018,
-0.0007923916,
-0.0764451846,
0.0587134622,
0.012984518,
-0.0564974919,
-0.0148841953,
-0.0086824195,
0.0507247485,
-0.0121596223,
0.031706959,
0.0525852367,
0.002897654,
-0.044519525,
-0.0441526286,
-0.0309811607,
0.0057905889,
-0.0560954697,
-0.023078464,
-0.0557942167,
0.0434568264,
0.016093526,
0.0075284452,
-0.0274140779,
-0.0115564996,
0.0117146643,
-0.0306844842,
0.080820024,
-0.0003925007,
-0.0009059324,
0.0315995738,
0.0221195482,
-0.0080328155,
0.0565400943,
-0.020252049,
-0.0028860064,
0.0638713911,
-0.0234180447,
0.0629352033,
0.0246283542,
0.0337722301,
0.012859948,
0.0197369233,
0.0504443608,
0.0194504857,
0.0260326546,
-0.000777385,
0.0596430227,
0.0020430568,
-0.013684012,
0.0480953567,
0.0172577724,
0.0235670079,
0.0022781126,
-0.0028961115,
0.0009774423,
0.0219786689,
0.021801021,
-0.0551370271,
0.0009127771,
-0.0597758554,
-0.0006608936,
0.0253069792,
-0.0191558171,
-0.0615084916,
-0.0542267077,
-0.0069603268,
-0.0155987814,
0.0038305102,
0.0444412529,
0.0394854993,
0.0410454571,
-0.009187351,
0.0403884426,
0.0488196611,
-0.033660423,
0.0150361657,
-0.0551479533,
0.0447535813,
-0.0241977721,
0.0282779466,
-0.0588030852,
-0.023656629,
-0.0182311721,
0.0580665804,
-0.0244616419,
0.0696712807,
-0.0432770662,
0.028295882,
-0.0372670591,
-0.0158109106,
0.0039224783,
0.043625202,
-0.0442194417,
0.041701749,
-0.0099203093,
0.0186631959,
-0.0721681789,
-0.0448564105,
0.0340757184,
-0.0412031077,
-0.074616611,
-0.0108769098,
0.0325344428,
-0.00310252,
-0.0105076535,
0.0117427791,
-0.0096810199,
0.0302710235,
-0.0290903617,
0.0016925478,
-0.0703951716,
0.0002197366,
-0.0128655471,
0.0203299597,
-0.0358379185,
-0.0478017963,
0.0603655316,
-0.0795614645,
-0.0425538793,
-0.0279255975,
-0.0207216851,
0.0122366948,
-0.0284108948,
-0.0017823408,
-0.0251370165,
0.0083873328,
-0.0695815757,
0.0792814419,
-0.0048606726,
0.071159102,
0.0017724033,
-0.0316314511,
-0.003254472,
-0.053678263,
-0.0559314899,
-0.0268813223,
-0.0191438459,
0.046536833,
0.0218427088,
0.0134638194,
-0.0827122778,
-0.008848954,
-0.0535362959,
-0.0036258807,
-0.0356064662,
0.0016686789,
0.0147324055,
0.0105488263,
-0.009123683,
-0.036011856,
-0.0747419,
0.0107751554,
0.0090173678,
0.0241494048,
0.0657055378,
0.0378094353,
0.0099060759,
-0.0281307008,
-0.0197177697,
-0.0065006916,
0.0082919328,
-0.0175268855,
0.0493379906,
-0.0409594253,
0.0248933695,
-0.0325645879,
0.005151845,
-0.0084361546,
-0.0108574545,
-0.0070305998,
-0.0328293405,
-0.0045833294,
0.1045183539,
0.002663021,
0.0211804789,
0.0165363513,
0.0183767844,
-0.0491629094,
0.0126943234,
-0.0171786081,
-0.0649335384,
-0.0366085991,
-0.0283592865,
-0.0025547654,
0.0443387479,
-0.0045004203,
-0.0216947738,
-0.034852311,
0.0450987294,
-0.0216787029,
0.0196728893,
-0.064443931,
0.055228468,
-0.0060443063,
0.0490070507,
-0.0198077802,
-0.0447756387,
0.0711552426,
-0.0028439802,
0.0100337658,
-0.0114969602,
-0.0266097914,
-0.0405251682,
0.0592430048,
-0.0119207148,
0.0124478508,
0.0099591259,
-0.0253948513,
-0.0947362408,
-0.014104615,
0.0270422325,
-0.0363357514,
0.0684667826,
-0.0346734487,
-0.0267579965,
-0.0277621672,
-0.060843017,
-0.0342127047,
-0.033503592,
-0.0164273307,
0.0014571504,
-0.0181883834,
-0.0040426771,
0.0069346274,
-0.0504904278,
0.0230704676,
0.0053822966,
-0.0137050143,
-0.0254563261,
-0.0215827338,
0.0409144647,
0.0635196194,
0.0371764712,
0.0133410841,
-0.0352258757,
0.0082501639,
0.0364285186,
0.0637528077,
0.0407271609,
0.0388531089,
0.007353296,
0.0426086597,
-0.0390488617,
-0.0141024729,
0.0570724607,
0.0405558646,
-0.0296029747,
-0.0266582202,
0.1107956022,
0.0295231603,
-0.0251896381,
-0.0076637128,
0.0128034474,
0.0055059926,
0.0441313833,
0.0180856157,
-0.084286727,
-0.0416858569,
0.006100968,
0.0612090528,
-0.0082178777,
-0.036158178,
0.0245563556,
-0.1028110012,
0.0034997358,
-0.0232618302,
-0.0491365492,
-0.0428720526,
-0.0453278422,
0.0102298772,
-0.0406418703,
0.0365819074,
-0.0001236935,
-0.0073663057,
0.0021428543,
0.0352164246,
-0.0119585786,
-0.0541146062,
0.0592383891,
-0.0614577755,
0.055353947,
0.0299505349,
0.0196718555,
-0.0268093254,
-0.0120619759,
0.0589648187,
-0.0146091832,
-0.03161145,
0.0086458949,
0.0600748844,
0.0051796995,
-0.0244447272,
-0.0026550333,
0.0727933869,
-0.0178078543,
0.0464308448,
0.0156382117,
0.0671817586,
0.006345666,
-0.0062037557,
0.0110523272,
-0.0383605026,
-0.010689728,
0.089264527,
0.0229260605,
-0.0554183647,
-0.0214284733,
-0.0495979898,
0.0007648771,
-0.0114673562,
-0.0621078201,
0.051219441,
-0.0027609966,
-0.0144288223,
-0.0464440733,
-0.0638434887,
0.0677542537,
0.0402961522,
-0.0169451851,
-0.011118779,
0.0046184035,
0.001270061,
-0.0285700187,
0.0313701257,
-0.077046372,
-0.0074791876,
-0.0685106292,
-0.0336887129,
0.0245971084,
0.0000531953,
-0.0262327306,
0.01137478,
-0.0636820421,
-0.0531080589,
0.0213229991,
0.0463440195,
0.0301858988,
0.0338476263,
-0.0191485398,
-0.0908415169,
0.0524995215,
0.02662839,
-0.0309059415,
0.0096992655,
0.0267161708,
-0.0073241736,
-0.009686714,
0.0553841852,
-0.0743032396,
-0.0007485324,
0.0459538437,
0.0205669496,
-0.0518092886,
-0.0212164093,
0.0310701691,
0.0258438196,
0.0507812686,
0.0323585384,
-0.0462195352,
-0.0198040456,
0.0189736448,
0.0375890322,
-0.036531169,
-0.0208852328,
-0.0142111657,
0.0475421175,
0.0093364734,
-0.014007438,
0.0010281211,
0.0090392837,
0.068571575,
-0.077927731,
0.0062532988,
0.0376219004,
0.031887196,
0.0503566898,
-0.015622546,
-0.032315392,
0.0108197154,
0.0200326573,
0.050921239,
-0.0016026023,
0.0221496429,
0.0168224368,
0.0384418704,
-0.0216276385,
-0.0214026812,
-0.0512225218,
-0.0535115264,
-0.0229798742,
0.0153010776,
0.0312589705,
-0.0235722326,
-0.0215944648,
-0.0064275251,
-0.0374200605,
-0.0128756249,
-0.0068244878,
0.0026008897,
-0.0273242854,
0.0572009422,
0.0351187512,
-0.0024368577,
0.0185905304,
0.0867053419,
0.0244183857,
0.0543113612,
-0.0120015237,
-0.0269247368,
-0.0452023596,
-0.0041482635,
0.0319583118,
0.0155202104,
0.00188436,
0.0357973911,
-0.0318034068,
-0.0780234113,
0.0006789311,
0.004455952,
-0.0102615412,
-0.0076851943,
0.020649083,
0.0574991144,
-0.0012653553,
-0.0020713862,
-0.0427915901,
0.0023634108,
0.008059022,
-0.0341970883,
0.0015062492,
-6.311129987e-33,
0.0077002244,
0.0114718936,
-0.0104317386,
-0.0267858338,
0.0321346335,
0.0323949791,
-0.0037124795,
0.0424947366,
-0.069062233,
0.0100454148,
-0.0215436742,
0.0186490063,
0.0007115359,
0.0491740741,
0.0048892186,
-0.0456349887,
0.0116230091,
-0.005734738,
-0.0269110315,
0.0091067944,
0.0140514839,
0.0233702008,
0.0425814912,
-0.064404659,
0.0666454136,
-0.0239467695,
-0.0240190309,
0.0467383228,
-0.0208312199,
0.0305300057,
-0.0101531046,
0.0627545044,
0.0326534472,
-0.0470773019,
0.0027496011,
0.0139911175,
-0.1132303998,
-0.0286803897,
0.0005907418,
-0.0019313481,
-0.0168433264,
-0.0184945241,
0.0394391604,
-0.0141198598,
0.0172832515,
-0.0216141921,
0.0320679508,
-0.0211742632,
-0.0030801508,
-0.0025424743,
-0.0034177564,
0.003461072,
-0.0031135592,
-0.0174879916,
-0.0141903693,
0.0474113561,
0.0014407444,
0.0248144623,
-0.056939967,
-0.0049597691,
0.0199435093,
0.0239293166,
0.0213116556,
0.017377954,
-0.0241832063,
0.0347840898,
0.0155733405,
0.0194770433,
0.0166136902,
-0.0064027011,
0.0191156305,
0.0302201249,
0.0526142009,
0.0700217932,
0.0602776483,
-0.0161842685,
-0.0807312727,
0.036045,
-0.0005676157,
-0.0155466562,
0.0090387277,
0.006107334,
-0.0583536848,
-0.028988488,
-0.0617855117,
0.0357044414,
-0.0413744897,
0.0156271085,
0.029640371,
0.0301210582,
-0.0300810337,
-0.0029054021,
0.0056595788,
-0.0392052867,
-0.0246781223,
0.0149743939,
-0.0000068132,
0.0022850519,
-0.0058111572,
-0.0005792438,
-0.050338041,
-0.0201582536,
-0.008452761,
-0.0422760732,
0.0362897739,
0.0356194749,
0.0825399086,
0.0020950437,
-0.075608924,
-0.0158640891,
-0.005543326,
0.0048028328,
-0.0000074248,
0.0273248646,
0.0138069838,
0.0043576229,
0.0036818951,
0.0164497513,
0.0241050888,
-0.0111403959,
-0.0321184359,
-0.0229841862,
-0.0085855573,
-0.0165239312,
-0.0204651374,
-0.0381657183,
-0.0073808399,
0.0036557708,
0.0298938882,
-0.0384529866,
0.0050464366,
-0.0070619406,
2.438e-7,
0.0473783389,
0.0269077178,
-0.0043308055,
0.04308559,
-0.0134426942,
0.0568355285,
0.0104727782,
0.0330491103,
0.0240452867,
-0.0302006602,
0.0096995682,
0.0138966292,
0.0445737056,
0.0190180335,
-0.1023552045,
-0.0155991744,
-0.0242236704,
0.0171511583,
-0.0170808006,
-0.0014729347,
0.0414276831,
0.1036110148,
0.0317473784,
-0.0056244349,
0.0056786039,
-0.0602570809,
0.0436647572,
-0.0530240946,
0.0214270968,
0.0169332176,
0.0500501208,
0.0554600619,
0.0158128645,
0.0384790897,
-0.0243796371,
0.0007465985,
0.028576212,
0.0257773418,
0.0269327629,
-0.0571237318,
-0.0187448673,
-0.0315774046,
0.0303106476,
-0.0449710004,
0.0899769738,
-0.0495009981,
-0.036512062,
0.0104873339,
0.0086168945,
-0.0155518586,
0.0286487471,
-0.0108399363,
0.0064480188,
-0.0162729137,
0.0146530867,
-0.0006201066,
0.0073306342,
-0.0996076465,
-0.0175662879,
0.0452557988,
0.0041030124,
-0.075310491,
-0.0232079085,
-0.0126110688,
0.0053727226,
-0.0958741754,
0.0357775018,
2.279505099e-34,
0.0212588944,
0.004028359,
0.0237235222,
0.0001242346,
0.0353688337,
-0.006587436,
0.0188328568,
-0.0200612321,
0.0402991176,
-0.0661809295,
0.0051005152
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06742v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06742v1 | Using Natural Language Inference to Improve Persona Extraction from Dialogue in a New Domain | 2024-01-12T18:25:03 | 2024-01-12T18:25:03 | Alexandra DeLucia, Mengjie Zhao, Yoshinori Maeda, Makoto Yoda, Keiichi Yamada, Hiromi Wakaki | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | While valuable datasets such as PersonaChat provide a foundation for training
persona-grounded dialogue agents, they lack diversity in conversational and
narrative settings, primarily existing in the "real" world. To develop dialogue
agents with unique personas, models are trained to converse given a specific
persona, but hand-crafting these persona can be time-consuming, thus methods
exist to automatically extract persona information from existing
character-specific dialogue. However, these persona-extraction models are also
trained on datasets derived from PersonaChat and struggle to provide
high-quality persona information from conversational settings that do not take
place in the real world, such as the fantasy-focused dataset, LIGHT. Creating
new data to train models on a specific setting is human-intensive, thus
prohibitively expensive. To address both these issues, we introduce a natural
language inference method for post-hoc adapting a trained persona extraction
model to a new setting. We draw inspiration from the literature of dialog
natural language inference (NLI), and devise NLI-reranking methods to extract
structured persona information from dialogue. Compared to existing persona
extraction models, our method returns higher-quality extracted persona and
requires less human annotation. | [
0.0663452819,
0.0728180557,
-0.0010594652,
0.0852349475,
-0.0086520128,
0.0075532161,
0.0037188241,
-0.0369779468,
0.0339734219,
-0.0154669592,
-0.0351666249,
-0.0022898621,
0.0199138969,
0.0118628899,
0.0353750549,
-0.0954165161,
0.0242331661,
-0.0185127109,
0.0231301915,
0.0285580773,
-0.0110276332,
0.0422540344,
-0.0303143747,
0.025157107,
-0.0088871745,
-0.0310039558,
-0.0120851127,
0.0042215325,
0.0727688596,
-0.0365847126,
0.0381483212,
-0.0023613891,
0.0246601738,
-0.0199134611,
0.0000016574,
-0.0622111745,
-0.0001047824,
-0.0095100524,
-0.0250939205,
-0.0370353907,
0.0065805889,
0.052979853,
0.0056676473,
0.0222206172,
-0.0426375829,
-0.0160095021,
0.0247027539,
0.0592004582,
0.0652093664,
0.0721604303,
-0.0348373465,
-0.0708020255,
-0.06170398,
-0.0262597091,
-0.0509740748,
-0.049016349,
-0.0129284449,
-0.0113970656,
0.0045408052,
-0.0060314513,
0.033901941,
-0.0097199809,
-0.0241046231,
0.0175722707,
-0.0007776925,
0.0327779055,
-0.0299632195,
0.0055289362,
0.0037983905,
0.1071560308,
0.0407259278,
0.0384912603,
0.0105308974,
0.0247197077,
0.0220928658,
-0.0206268318,
-0.0063845869,
-0.0013470545,
-0.0226212163,
-0.0229318086,
-0.0071116313,
0.0489663929,
0.0030149515,
0.0022409325,
-0.050429184,
0.0222017765,
0.0160057526,
-0.0084651718,
0.0034312517,
-0.0041799522,
0.0068955743,
-0.0264338031,
-0.0058474434,
0.0051729721,
0.0041655297,
0.0453816056,
-0.0381209329,
0.0423600003,
-0.035056632,
-0.0003406797,
-0.0149410143,
0.010397803,
-0.0094202505,
0.0495468974,
0.024718428,
0.0137140965,
0.0383426361,
-0.0126783298,
0.0113570346,
-0.0330332108,
-0.0320607871,
-0.0002614884,
-0.0428765193,
0.021655716,
-0.0273595955,
-0.0007343314,
-0.0247684028,
-0.006494679,
-0.0120757921,
-0.0043175137,
-0.0032493398,
0.0224382468,
-0.0536337942,
-0.0185557827,
-0.0617408752,
0.0512410924,
-0.0472131297,
0.0005661527,
-0.0154636782,
-0.0438634343,
-0.0088822423,
-0.0049400553,
0.0644797683,
-0.0248127412,
0.0224432331,
0.0823082998,
0.0024464431,
-0.0556178652,
0.0073423684,
-0.0053752209,
-0.0104129035,
-0.050754685,
-0.0340438858,
-0.0067710159,
0.0431587398,
-0.038913779,
0.0140202921,
-0.0336418971,
0.026072599,
0.0022115579,
-0.0216453858,
0.0724939704,
-0.0222753249,
0.0070473282,
0.0363556519,
0.0024023734,
-0.0569201745,
0.024846239,
0.050177373,
0.0038973694,
0.0363579765,
0.0201238208,
0.0280571189,
0.0410149097,
-0.0363397151,
-0.0426945612,
0.0393269844,
0.0063079186,
-0.028738644,
0.0019011623,
0.0309149083,
0.0400414132,
-0.0573421568,
-0.0184643101,
0.0523563549,
0.0813122541,
0.0122746751,
0.010928303,
0.0479478315,
0.042008955,
0.0209882837,
0.0078890603,
-0.0451757386,
0.0022607045,
0.0247320198,
-0.0234153681,
-0.0248917863,
0.0379154384,
0.0049876678,
-0.0414301679,
0.0157250166,
-0.0302193593,
0.0071195555,
0.0036341646,
0.0135516208,
0.0401899107,
-0.0361702032,
0.0169849321,
0.0466002151,
-0.0814554021,
-0.008202659,
-0.0182049107,
-0.0041961814,
0.0817574114,
0.0264610238,
-0.0581417754,
-0.043693874,
-0.0192873925,
-0.0118994694,
0.0274602454,
0.0094550001,
-0.0497629605,
0.0815230608,
-0.0327896029,
0.0160638485,
-0.002123792,
-0.0102703478,
0.0608423799,
0.0231126398,
-0.0229129028,
0.0078369854,
0.0191514939,
-0.0031096432,
0.014357904,
-0.0650670081,
-0.0117214927,
0.016252175,
0.0430067368,
0.0016975488,
0.0295490883,
-0.0073884511,
-0.0547885932,
0.0110580958,
-0.0280542076,
-0.0014239084,
0.0655918568,
-0.0327755213,
-0.050998494,
0.0175269954,
-0.0709307045,
-0.0218654852,
0.0049415547,
-0.0221638083,
-0.0108553283,
0.0191984046,
-0.032773383,
0.0195742007,
-0.0120253433,
-0.0081257178,
0.047510244,
0.023307709,
-0.0410467871,
0.103214249,
0.0382181779,
-0.0384583399,
0.0350653417,
0.0144560291,
-0.0234976448,
-0.0734240413,
0.0237351824,
-0.001015658,
0.0078104977,
-0.0123731773,
0.0296582989,
-0.0029241159,
-0.0349430107,
-0.0337862186,
-0.0712136626,
0.0092252325,
0.0153715853,
0.0111737866,
0.0073531256,
0.0373507366,
-0.0489174873,
-0.021927923,
-0.0470168404,
-0.0417539887,
-0.0241310745,
-0.0394665822,
0.0739104003,
0.0153898317,
0.0135872066,
-0.0511204079,
0.0265840665,
-0.0211554859,
0.0549271777,
-0.0037891332,
-0.011317621,
-0.0297273919,
-0.0192480311,
-0.0646953434,
0.0512743667,
-0.0391389653,
-0.0313356407,
0.0281248968,
-0.0017061805,
0.0425539538,
0.0609850399,
0.0174019709,
0.0369584635,
-0.0277782306,
-0.025832003,
-0.0309532676,
0.0496511497,
0.003726898,
0.0369268619,
-0.0105006499,
-0.0222103614,
0.0607271865,
0.0468639769,
0.0015934546,
0.0118879741,
-0.0539889038,
0.0582379326,
0.0292827822,
-0.0389366001,
0.0646154806,
0.0154610407,
-0.0028867875,
0.0050392495,
-0.0133783435,
0.0167570878,
0.0614706054,
-0.0068256119,
-0.0250560027,
-0.0455804877,
-0.0065334779,
-0.0433796383,
0.0557809882,
-0.0094422121,
0.0332047865,
0.0175184067,
-0.0498096719,
-0.0307880025,
-0.00665288,
0.0399960093,
-0.0196155366,
0.0425566509,
-0.0569972098,
-0.0102267526,
0.0009937601,
-0.0305548664,
-0.0398993753,
-0.0061822725,
-0.0231312346,
-0.0568338633,
-0.0109376181,
-0.0233175624,
-0.0010195534,
0.0053874599,
-0.0133609436,
0.0080191037,
-0.0065726577,
-0.0043350384,
-0.0224827286,
0.0140730273,
0.0352290906,
0.0365475565,
-0.0049319398,
-0.0209631324,
0.0689164996,
0.0278203115,
-0.0397589654,
-0.0258613639,
-0.0194748677,
-0.0057604834,
0.0173116177,
-0.0292774979,
-0.0065956786,
0.0008140079,
0.0518930964,
-0.0401192084,
-0.0001608795,
0.1147296652,
0.0149489166,
0.0099352375,
0.0163761098,
0.0179673955,
0.0271566827,
-0.0009942193,
0.0060134293,
-0.0473386794,
-0.0330206305,
-0.0040924335,
0.0383187756,
-0.0072038691,
-0.0693342313,
-0.0308461059,
-0.109841466,
0.0424326882,
-0.0173747241,
-0.0275819413,
-0.0165512357,
-0.0239128266,
0.0466339998,
-0.0366534963,
0.0105924224,
-0.0155311059,
-0.0058581396,
0.0160958562,
-0.0080856699,
-0.0481420085,
-0.0195407812,
0.0252539143,
-0.0628874823,
0.0409333743,
0.0010344372,
0.0793062672,
0.026758384,
0.0270540863,
-0.0751077756,
0.0332446583,
-0.0033985162,
0.0046767914,
0.0902051851,
-0.0437197983,
-0.0243011825,
-0.0413173996,
0.037606325,
0.0123904124,
-0.0226332955,
0.0172127746,
-0.0169112924,
-0.0007402231,
-0.0048026764,
0.0187414978,
0.0314417519,
0.0128829172,
0.0661770329,
-0.0079647042,
-0.0223269984,
-0.0054797614,
-0.0005086194,
0.0404042937,
-0.0246353243,
-0.0518364124,
-0.0174297132,
-0.0227729715,
-0.0152511951,
-0.0804481953,
-0.058449991,
0.0314170197,
0.0796607286,
0.0285047516,
-0.0151247345,
0.0219272152,
0.0429414846,
0.0071971449,
0.0214881636,
-0.0610727184,
-0.0079479683,
-0.0070472159,
-0.0290343463,
0.064216122,
-0.0225298367,
-0.0170726757,
0.0295626894,
-0.0304974411,
-0.0419608094,
-0.0419229828,
0.0362498052,
0.0245456956,
0.0704204291,
-0.0271219909,
-0.0371919759,
-0.0262940843,
-0.0270093121,
-0.0405269787,
-0.0184173752,
0.0135873696,
0.0611561909,
-0.0086349128,
0.0264667943,
-0.0387175232,
0.0312956199,
-0.0454057306,
0.0166292097,
-0.0507391952,
-0.1074613109,
-0.0093960427,
0.007443849,
0.0131058637,
0.0002088859,
-0.0318898968,
-0.0438635983,
0.0007663245,
-0.0718245879,
-0.0272412729,
-0.0281206816,
0.013798466,
0.0067397347,
0.0578126609,
-0.0131176226,
-0.0295319259,
-0.0227310322,
0.0311399009,
-0.0620126761,
-0.0383102931,
0.0661108941,
-0.0124226669,
-0.0353449509,
-0.0247976612,
-0.0101902559,
-0.0001790991,
-0.024269592,
0.0741447508,
-0.0064041801,
0.0173678901,
0.0023376744,
-0.0378289632,
-0.0161001943,
0.0485998914,
-0.0463918783,
-0.0280321036,
-0.0004072284,
0.0388891958,
0.0169954579,
0.0105021261,
0.0626113042,
0.0134428963,
0.011819981,
0.0509950072,
0.0393554792,
0.0249835122,
-0.0259411205,
-0.0143242199,
0.0418461189,
-0.0349494033,
0.0245043356,
0.0451366715,
0.0138624851,
0.022266984,
-0.0138666173,
-0.0212461855,
-0.0685688779,
-0.0341001675,
0.0001876191,
-0.0021173474,
0.0153656527,
0.0130291693,
-0.0694372803,
-0.0417910442,
0.0220557917,
0.0002921946,
-0.0187814049,
-0.0185720753,
0.0125853391,
0.0081219869,
0.0018586334,
-0.0293838456,
-0.033459533,
-0.0056927255,
0.0162524767,
-0.0154641727,
0.007531601,
-5.149195331e-33,
-0.0663925037,
0.011261452,
0.0114745414,
0.0179088861,
-0.070784606,
-0.0135203674,
-0.0334255844,
-0.0414251089,
-0.0042045619,
0.0142640062,
-0.0176012125,
-0.0126460968,
0.013948801,
0.0020275721,
-0.0527596287,
-0.0321589112,
0.0236402284,
0.0399795957,
-0.031526085,
0.0314724557,
0.0272249524,
0.0348646455,
0.0535281636,
-0.0864622667,
-0.0025968056,
-0.0043728175,
0.0092197573,
0.0208804384,
0.0823812932,
0.0290925503,
-0.0191480294,
-0.0058866101,
0.012609777,
-0.012771151,
0.0199729055,
0.0425798185,
-0.116366297,
-0.0350168832,
-0.0096691847,
0.0137502579,
-0.0054120612,
-0.0200004708,
0.0112975156,
-0.0016593518,
0.0402626656,
-0.0125501323,
0.0634724572,
-0.017079439,
0.0517644286,
0.0053702854,
-0.0855775252,
0.029571265,
-0.040686056,
-0.046252232,
0.0040435977,
0.0572945811,
0.0072423285,
-0.0213935208,
-0.0387059748,
0.0013274535,
-0.0007066701,
-0.0280782804,
-0.0196173061,
0.0642820969,
-0.0054689995,
0.0768719167,
0.0409464724,
0.012808199,
-0.0231971666,
-0.0218738168,
0.0125292139,
0.0458604284,
-0.0017137857,
0.0793709904,
-0.0297038537,
0.0249817912,
-0.0820214003,
0.0412520096,
0.0587286539,
-0.0013391858,
-0.0095672533,
-0.0014424169,
-0.0520247072,
-0.0056488547,
-0.0043506073,
-0.0332858153,
0.0223942921,
-0.0094478354,
0.0085894708,
-0.0329774171,
-0.0686117187,
0.0040083271,
0.016365584,
-0.0352773257,
-0.0157180633,
0.010697199,
0.0009568638,
-0.0127331996,
-0.0060281586,
0.0089280242,
-0.016210502,
-0.0124349231,
0.0805351958,
0.0419845805,
0.0613487102,
0.006898745,
-0.0133082261,
0.0264595319,
-0.0238284227,
-0.0283910353,
-0.0108165126,
0.0401992314,
-0.0518104322,
0.0971194953,
0.0123493494,
0.0159917139,
-0.0227598343,
0.0350958444,
0.0228619948,
0.0071248235,
-0.034597721,
0.0104730204,
0.0154960491,
-0.02411763,
-0.032267876,
0.0040218011,
-0.0083229253,
-0.0155391935,
0.0149712553,
-0.0511313118,
-0.0280348975,
-0.0068512298,
2.437e-7,
-0.0187049657,
-0.0063017802,
0.0542973168,
0.0266180076,
0.0070265206,
0.044495672,
0.0186925065,
0.0404315405,
0.0457019098,
-0.0626897067,
0.0341051146,
0.0337838791,
0.0400156602,
0.0083168279,
-0.1108373031,
-0.037727505,
-0.0003439587,
-0.0504775532,
-0.0526004694,
-0.0417082831,
0.0846082121,
0.0569360293,
0.0466198958,
-0.011081418,
-0.0227023084,
0.0081416722,
0.019932624,
-0.0088007674,
-0.0351144187,
0.0308975969,
0.0661253035,
0.0101888822,
-0.0088771153,
0.0151426764,
0.015130043,
0.0670460239,
0.0285260957,
0.0617018417,
-0.0378723145,
0.0011181073,
-0.0175659563,
-0.0057412852,
-0.0068278727,
0.0042467886,
0.0715759695,
-0.0331387594,
-0.0375799015,
-0.0189248975,
-0.0533554368,
0.011931303,
-0.0305505581,
-0.0079098279,
-0.0568426698,
0.0584323406,
0.0261731427,
-0.0301589947,
-0.0126122329,
-0.1094516292,
0.0180877782,
-0.0206226464,
-0.0228582248,
-0.0220196713,
0.0434254631,
-0.0138178011,
-0.007581498,
-0.0270232875,
0.0591722243,
1.816336792e-34,
-0.0477384664,
0.0425926559,
-0.0158460625,
0.0411550663,
0.1016160175,
-0.0110638393,
0.0071443501,
-0.0046067513,
0.0243503116,
-0.0563670322,
0.0066681085
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06838v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06838v3 | MAPO: Advancing Multilingual Reasoning through Multilingual Alignment-as-Preference Optimization | 2024-01-12T18:03:54 | 2024-04-13T18:27:04 | Shuaijie She, Wei Zou, Shujian Huang, Wenhao Zhu, Xiang Liu, Xiang Geng, Jiajun Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Though reasoning abilities are considered language-agnostic, existing LLMs
exhibit inconsistent reasoning abilities across different languages, e.g.,
reasoning in the dominant language like English is superior to other languages
due to the imbalance of multilingual training data. To enhance reasoning
abilities in non-dominant languages, we propose a
Multilingual-Alignment-as-Preference Optimization framework (MAPO), aiming to
align the reasoning processes in other languages with the dominant language.
Specifically, we harness an off-the-shelf translation model for the consistency
between answers in non-dominant and dominant languages, which we adopt as the
preference for optimization, e.g., Direct Preference Optimization (DPO) or
Proximal Policy Optimization (PPO). Experiments show that MAPO stably achieves
significant improvements in the multilingual reasoning of various models on all
three benchmarks (MSVAMP +16.2%, MGSM +6.1%, and MNumGLUESub +13.3%), with
improved reasoning consistency across languages. | [
0.0162322968,
0.0339701548,
0.0005356157,
0.0729683489,
-0.0401528738,
0.0277102385,
0.011169035,
-0.0176071692,
-0.0023597812,
0.0079003666,
-0.0337686278,
-0.0381174013,
-0.0083330628,
-0.0334194005,
0.0156660825,
-0.0225030184,
0.0448492616,
-0.0291968621,
0.0103164706,
-0.0537674315,
0.0381148234,
0.0267699677,
0.0050111446,
-0.0019686124,
0.023711985,
-0.0201750714,
0.0024037419,
0.0011246809,
0.0680483431,
-0.0084390156,
-0.0008242513,
0.0073443549,
0.0150313983,
0.0173421428,
0.0000020053,
-0.0617208332,
-0.0234089643,
-0.013901352,
0.0040117018,
-0.0440654643,
-0.0192180313,
-0.0133980103,
0.0029264903,
-0.0049805697,
-0.0465988331,
0.0600345694,
0.0464321934,
0.0228055567,
0.0456414931,
0.0720503479,
0.0084772212,
-0.0618729256,
0.0038818803,
-0.0253331587,
0.0233364031,
-0.0237320922,
-0.0175317395,
0.0142039768,
-0.002224267,
-0.0231166575,
-0.0017280296,
0.0379028991,
0.042464368,
0.006117146,
-0.0611655489,
0.0120538585,
0.0253001992,
-0.0413470156,
0.000697959,
0.0666344836,
-0.0186483115,
-0.0071871225,
-0.0148373256,
-0.0104826493,
0.0054845116,
-0.0116623538,
-0.0354764648,
0.0307350326,
0.0049673584,
0.0343340673,
0.0547514111,
-0.0121397283,
0.0452447608,
0.0153840138,
-0.0483668335,
0.111872308,
0.0027167627,
-0.0240370557,
0.0386960767,
-0.0013288192,
-0.0182880573,
-0.0485098809,
0.020567229,
0.0441313572,
-0.0791298673,
0.0327743404,
0.0068195336,
0.0202260725,
0.0343294926,
-0.0588190518,
0.0156706478,
0.0776328146,
-0.0180982426,
0.056382969,
-0.0142473727,
0.0822429731,
-0.0458768271,
0.0545681231,
-0.0521961525,
-0.0526339747,
-0.0064528342,
-0.0254585501,
0.0590158813,
0.0398315266,
-0.0222234651,
0.0171025004,
-0.0431083404,
0.0194503609,
-0.0427968614,
0.0505195819,
0.0052420697,
-0.008799905,
-0.003786443,
-0.0502049625,
-0.0711016133,
0.0787592083,
-0.0506202914,
0.0205169693,
-0.0002860472,
-0.0098459991,
-0.0069423239,
0.0292321369,
-0.0708760247,
-0.0495350473,
0.0210699905,
0.1121506095,
-0.0407359526,
0.0279572513,
-0.0166478176,
-0.012693828,
-0.0047845067,
-0.1034652963,
0.0247808788,
-0.0865724385,
0.067540735,
0.0116513381,
-0.0269359481,
-0.0484045371,
0.0085138343,
0.020500211,
-0.0231977403,
0.0442426279,
0.0329990797,
-0.0020220024,
-0.0002431469,
-0.0142310504,
-0.0242134091,
0.0752940923,
0.0319561549,
-0.0096618533,
0.044465892,
-0.0024035613,
-0.0596914701,
0.0475898087,
0.0004534107,
0.0087546734,
-0.0127882538,
0.0531401373,
-0.0048826663,
0.0234127007,
0.0296558123,
0.0128942123,
-0.0046759699,
-0.0338970833,
0.0204444844,
0.029605329,
-0.0021071152,
-0.0118965115,
-0.0125510609,
-0.0247538052,
-0.0358322114,
0.0145331342,
-0.0589451566,
0.0755821019,
-0.0049353642,
0.0177503061,
0.0096407412,
0.0757220909,
-0.0100370497,
-0.0447221994,
-0.0126685509,
-0.0143152047,
0.0062233768,
0.0478285328,
0.0268110484,
-0.0370971374,
-0.0096873511,
0.0638221279,
0.0146451052,
-0.0357508585,
-0.0081784446,
-0.0081981122,
0.0163875241,
0.0441038199,
-0.0094027603,
-0.0153717082,
-0.0639625043,
-0.0111075575,
-0.0078316275,
0.0594103411,
0.0444217548,
-0.0130944392,
0.0147662936,
-0.0597489625,
-0.0395251922,
-0.00571995,
-0.0368991829,
0.048905354,
0.0013120433,
0.038984023,
0.0092534572,
-0.0266808961,
-0.0084945066,
0.021725582,
-0.0315118171,
0.0083871083,
-0.0036049378,
0.0223065987,
0.0238581132,
0.0276344176,
0.0282221548,
0.0084986156,
0.0020007619,
-0.0425929651,
-0.002457618,
0.0279052537,
-0.04278557,
-0.0182451326,
0.084575139,
-0.019745104,
-0.0731212795,
0.0093645062,
-0.0604123175,
-0.0313163251,
-0.0274990853,
0.011707426,
0.0037850121,
-0.0480940081,
-0.0021382363,
-0.0013742407,
-0.0189748798,
-0.0619243458,
0.0710844696,
-0.0097797681,
0.0384388417,
0.043803025,
-0.0130871851,
0.0487929061,
-0.0676667243,
0.0048801419,
0.0799340308,
-0.0055382862,
-0.0020477106,
0.0433449298,
0.0404106639,
-0.0386716872,
-0.0036365462,
-0.0380853452,
0.04205871,
-0.0114727048,
0.0371529199,
0.0224811155,
-0.00623482,
0.0071776109,
-0.0166683849,
-0.0792618096,
-0.0084738117,
0.0180915836,
0.0370349996,
0.051553674,
-0.0051979222,
0.0321522504,
-0.0247370116,
-0.0108266333,
-0.0179879833,
-0.0116525041,
-0.035162203,
0.0327358879,
-0.0399264358,
-0.0011835883,
-0.0972946286,
-0.0096994694,
-0.0043975464,
-0.0214367658,
0.0244420152,
0.014864766,
0.0190114956,
0.0666779578,
-0.0201029889,
-0.0396562293,
0.0670310631,
0.0150102526,
-0.0870706365,
0.0287551079,
-0.0173985921,
-0.0108076138,
-0.0384261496,
-0.0453731753,
-0.0221402161,
0.0309892986,
-0.0094477534,
-0.0115091661,
-0.0434451438,
-0.0095124999,
0.0137897497,
-0.0032223824,
-0.0324483365,
0.0433549844,
0.0034399698,
0.0521517918,
-0.0344127081,
-0.0125530157,
0.1168874651,
-0.0005308049,
-0.0144463303,
-0.0620588586,
0.0092278607,
-0.0614646561,
-0.0046305223,
-0.017441377,
0.039166417,
-0.0738921687,
0.0034036206,
-0.0898554027,
-0.0437241085,
0.0465844721,
-0.0290964432,
0.0513999276,
-0.0294218566,
-0.0240151379,
-0.0398012251,
-0.0694414526,
-0.0333819687,
0.0094922623,
-0.0220080689,
0.0133268172,
-0.021990722,
-0.0203330237,
-0.0307729244,
-0.012381929,
0.055527322,
-0.0109763108,
-0.0128097646,
0.0031706358,
-0.0190428477,
-0.0090898499,
0.031392511,
0.0522888489,
0.0210015438,
-0.0242131054,
0.0232845582,
0.0553478524,
0.0115869772,
-0.0721207261,
0.0228739548,
0.0185654946,
0.0508945324,
-0.0188210011,
-0.0187740456,
-0.0086542852,
0.0349383727,
-0.0355856121,
0.055752594,
0.1019578204,
0.0232736245,
-0.0098760817,
-0.0048306081,
-0.0516353622,
0.0635091364,
0.0522802174,
0.0545450225,
-0.0707665533,
-0.0311577637,
0.0124273095,
0.0082382914,
0.0254770909,
-0.0033270286,
-0.0130744921,
-0.0849189609,
-0.0110721374,
0.0174407195,
-0.0201198235,
-0.0135054095,
-0.0330423415,
-0.0134883383,
-0.0341688953,
0.0295671672,
0.0035248173,
0.0393478088,
-0.0123224054,
-0.0132070687,
0.0134750148,
-0.0189491194,
0.0302715302,
-0.01392949,
-0.0212408695,
0.0559630394,
0.0452363901,
-0.0056101638,
-0.0504347309,
0.0471995808,
0.0449829176,
-0.0194417667,
-0.0277839452,
-0.0488163717,
0.0100261876,
-0.0022020312,
-0.0273965914,
0.0512506217,
-0.0238984581,
-0.026977146,
0.0128247887,
0.0975441337,
-0.0191583671,
-0.002356708,
-0.005803016,
-0.0039016674,
-0.0171163827,
0.060984727,
-0.0272638369,
-0.0083090598,
-0.0462547429,
-0.0556957759,
-0.0601824373,
-0.0335350707,
-0.0037089624,
0.0186864994,
-0.0067322114,
0.0112168528,
-0.0272842366,
-0.0494918525,
0.0003345664,
-0.0016156869,
0.0017991613,
-0.0073019555,
-0.0245442111,
-0.0353192426,
-0.0133954547,
0.0202336498,
-0.0061671031,
0.013936067,
-0.0205343068,
0.0288461056,
-0.0122554256,
-0.0331477709,
-0.0231854264,
-0.0109905005,
-0.0324900635,
-0.0913253948,
-0.0550204702,
0.0610582866,
0.0173685066,
0.0404983424,
0.0144304745,
-0.0120067922,
0.0012191134,
0.0057337824,
0.0185585916,
-0.0102735572,
0.0358113423,
0.0108662993,
0.021754723,
0.0548995808,
-0.0318335593,
-0.0177942645,
0.0137995575,
0.0628414527,
-0.0214687958,
-0.0082884477,
0.0258061849,
0.0211930666,
0.0057691955,
-0.0262193941,
-0.0233751778,
-0.0302307587,
0.0503169708,
-0.018056443,
-0.0291102715,
0.0231311545,
-0.0060958737,
0.0151626375,
-0.0551063716,
0.0378322825,
-0.0049956422,
0.0196448006,
-0.0353701003,
0.0187149774,
0.0192119665,
0.0405150503,
-0.01591154,
0.0098378137,
0.0287551973,
-0.0073587508,
0.031992726,
0.0059903301,
0.0781012103,
-0.0205394309,
0.0575769208,
0.0447726771,
0.003952777,
0.0194330048,
-0.019642802,
-0.0345795155,
-0.0771450475,
0.0315482728,
-0.0298631806,
0.0823338404,
-0.0216158554,
0.0478605554,
-0.0004149913,
-0.0263888948,
0.0099992128,
0.0245491378,
0.0087007973,
-0.0145157725,
0.033012908,
0.0147141032,
-0.0100667467,
0.011422242,
0.0555012338,
-0.0300037339,
0.0071731773,
-0.0418272279,
0.020787809,
-0.0371875018,
-0.0560197383,
-0.0089042056,
0.0266689174,
-0.028619945,
-0.0179589093,
-0.0390245691,
-0.066216737,
-0.0117031792,
0.0334050655,
-0.0375756212,
0.0133229168,
-0.00482488,
0.0819489509,
-0.0286696386,
-0.0229972973,
-0.0128529891,
0.0024517197,
-0.0434168205,
-0.0225641336,
-0.0040424475,
-5.846012954e-33,
-0.0032993704,
-0.0331966877,
0.0514746197,
-0.0246768035,
0.0220275875,
-0.0484681986,
0.0014524752,
-0.0211213809,
-0.0633739233,
0.0143966982,
-0.0057489406,
-0.0167707391,
0.0119650587,
-0.0067284545,
0.0325562842,
-0.0050940369,
0.0013576023,
0.0224250164,
-0.038877286,
-0.0358132124,
0.0383026265,
-0.0062426548,
0.0824249983,
-0.0430828221,
0.069818072,
0.0106715243,
-0.0044707716,
0.0474824682,
-0.0577964559,
0.0685193539,
0.0040934351,
0.01747315,
0.019569248,
-0.026865989,
-0.0178934522,
-0.0094249304,
-0.0437717512,
-0.0601100773,
0.0708182305,
0.0160487536,
-0.0045056674,
-0.0684621558,
0.0204132553,
-0.0083776405,
-0.0156766959,
-0.0304483809,
0.0103315655,
-0.0394762568,
0.005434297,
0.0394567326,
-0.0546156727,
6.637e-7,
-0.0314603671,
0.0236685425,
0.0422741026,
0.0594764277,
-0.0070447708,
0.0385553092,
-0.0678950921,
0.0218963623,
-0.0256102011,
0.0041065817,
0.1320316046,
0.0106161702,
-0.0166061353,
0.0240865517,
0.0010888933,
-0.0159852486,
0.0245405994,
-0.0046484899,
-0.0087748803,
0.0300466046,
0.0504453294,
0.0687465742,
0.0149659142,
0.0231294371,
-0.1012312248,
0.0504978485,
0.007306701,
0.0411034413,
0.022271378,
0.0307342652,
-0.0192071311,
-0.0217908006,
-0.0502443239,
0.0218304954,
-0.0341824442,
-0.0395210534,
0.0050362903,
-0.0270504691,
-0.0059839725,
0.0021522266,
0.0477503501,
-0.032887321,
-0.0243502147,
0.0227294415,
-0.020188015,
-0.027887255,
0.015642453,
0.0489289314,
-0.0543362834,
-0.0114725931,
-0.0586215444,
-0.0321397036,
-0.0036187626,
0.0233955905,
0.0479397811,
-0.0201932583,
-0.0339767449,
0.0041795103,
-0.043619331,
-0.011482304,
0.0021353057,
0.0234319065,
0.0104267541,
-0.0055894107,
0.0016152251,
0.0689664558,
0.0201528128,
-0.0179117508,
-0.0344084501,
-0.0154608507,
-0.0180666,
0.0363923796,
-0.0216663573,
0.0419392362,
-0.01280527,
0.0306871459,
-0.0229833294,
-0.0321550108,
-0.011059382,
0.0354464985,
2.573e-7,
0.0507507697,
0.0328904204,
-0.0011145714,
0.0295874346,
-0.0141001865,
0.0479504727,
-0.0518356934,
-0.0072327838,
0.0129757365,
-0.0203046985,
0.0010763737,
0.0522864796,
0.0381032154,
0.0402590595,
-0.0691233873,
0.0059388867,
-0.0223037601,
-0.0086202445,
-0.0420161039,
0.041212555,
0.0536143966,
0.0582036786,
-0.0044346638,
-0.0115409894,
-0.0136799496,
0.0041247224,
0.0721894652,
-0.0408028737,
-0.0069556916,
0.0097053442,
0.0204691812,
-0.0202410538,
0.0045435759,
0.0107090268,
0.0035466796,
0.0165998135,
-0.0103635015,
0.091891557,
-0.0050978386,
-0.0827948228,
-0.0242959335,
-0.0354689099,
-0.0005669008,
-0.0837286562,
0.0762746409,
-0.0027124581,
-0.0364421941,
-0.0039258525,
0.0108637987,
-0.0078648161,
0.0582680888,
-0.0442702956,
-0.0370148867,
0.0067295488,
0.0184144974,
-0.017389968,
-0.0078530312,
-0.0328118317,
-0.0613818616,
0.00125102,
-0.0120238699,
-0.0266427565,
-0.0141878305,
0.0270020645,
0.0219526831,
-0.0320580602,
-0.0434206165,
2.091485696e-34,
0.0022121784,
-0.0112903044,
0.0138777476,
0.0226617437,
0.025412973,
-0.0157610439,
-0.0205692407,
0.011538472,
0.0194587819,
-0.0502574481,
-0.0213325806
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06730v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06730v1 | Relying on the Unreliable: The Impact of Language Models' Reluctance to Express Uncertainty | 2024-01-12T18:03:30 | 2024-01-12T18:03:30 | Kaitlyn Zhou, Jena D. Hwang, Xiang Ren, Maarten Sap | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | As natural language becomes the default interface for human-AI interaction,
there is a critical need for LMs to appropriately communicate uncertainties in
downstream applications. In this work, we investigate how LMs incorporate
confidence about their responses via natural language and how downstream users
behave in response to LM-articulated uncertainties. We examine publicly
deployed models and find that LMs are unable to express uncertainties when
answering questions even when they produce incorrect responses. LMs can be
explicitly prompted to express confidences, but tend to be overconfident,
resulting in high error rates (on average 47%) among confident responses. We
test the risks of LM overconfidence by running human experiments and show that
users rely heavily on LM generations, whether or not they are marked by
certainty. Lastly, we investigate the preference-annotated datasets used in
RLHF alignment and find that humans have a bias against texts with uncertainty.
Our work highlights a new set of safety harms facing human-LM interactions and
proposes design recommendations and mitigating strategies moving forward. | [
0.0526453704,
0.0622193143,
-0.0278585907,
0.0179396681,
-0.0215292461,
-0.0124022821,
-0.0367113836,
-0.0143771078,
0.0205381885,
-0.0349543877,
-0.0039111776,
-0.0606323369,
0.0302903224,
-0.0038134432,
0.0098277004,
-0.0444178469,
0.0311231352,
-0.0323681384,
0.0505632237,
0.0019137105,
-0.0009971242,
0.0087675666,
-0.0178236645,
0.0352589898,
-0.0325342715,
-0.0130865304,
-0.0213799737,
0.0137623958,
0.0077502173,
-0.0586953945,
0.0053710598,
0.065372698,
0.0019846479,
0.0266941134,
0.0000018906,
-0.0580680631,
0.0303324815,
-0.0142186917,
-0.0724615082,
-0.0214642156,
0.0264699701,
0.0423234552,
-0.0103840102,
0.0164304823,
-0.0490375087,
0.0207667015,
0.051150512,
0.0000017202,
0.009563474,
0.0233470947,
0.0066161393,
0.0433032103,
0.0134837488,
0.0050650644,
0.0325236432,
-0.051738508,
0.0013171587,
-0.0148951001,
0.0004390471,
0.0120565286,
-0.0045030862,
0.051057376,
-0.0043387567,
0.000040898,
-0.0175951365,
0.0105461823,
0.007943077,
-0.0667147785,
-0.0288917124,
0.0540574975,
0.0672079399,
0.0047631375,
-0.020604847,
-0.024259422,
0.0358405113,
0.0361303166,
-0.0141052315,
0.053548567,
-0.0339841768,
-0.0081824195,
-0.0376345366,
0.0025963013,
0.0272106249,
0.0176851787,
0.0244928505,
0.0990589336,
-0.0136728436,
-0.0132489149,
0.0201063957,
0.0147029916,
0.010038075,
-0.0601613298,
-0.0255127028,
0.0243346281,
-0.0827892497,
0.0490726791,
-0.0766278952,
0.0064610015,
0.0399992093,
-0.051348079,
0.0151273217,
0.0480242036,
-0.008139614,
-0.0020971759,
0.0261510555,
0.0460440889,
-0.002260807,
-0.0107212039,
0.0019368092,
0.0220684949,
0.0210104045,
-0.040550109,
0.0142285591,
-0.0156055456,
-0.0036744445,
0.0037570309,
-0.0469931327,
0.0461060479,
-0.0341029055,
0.0562238917,
-0.0567076243,
0.049762249,
-0.0317999646,
-0.019663997,
-0.0973482355,
0.0180394594,
-0.019900389,
0.0374013707,
0.015629543,
-0.120939143,
0.0206462927,
0.019869592,
-0.0324788615,
-0.0109035075,
-0.0288298782,
0.0822215602,
-0.0119818049,
-0.0014298501,
-0.0206129421,
-0.028320495,
-0.0190038458,
-0.0573922396,
-0.0050655967,
-0.0450917669,
0.0103100305,
0.031121131,
-0.0064965216,
-0.061526183,
0.0378876776,
0.0453702472,
-0.0537392236,
0.0872104168,
-0.0461282469,
0.043162819,
0.0183892623,
0.0050028581,
-0.0275539849,
0.0398562737,
0.0523870699,
0.0175687317,
0.0552796572,
0.0036603434,
0.0505081303,
0.0273063984,
-0.0355349444,
0.008705576,
-0.0119931912,
0.0218453407,
-0.0567662269,
0.0381871872,
0.025784146,
0.0759821981,
0.0211658049,
-0.0106419064,
0.1067229286,
0.0623432547,
-0.0561412908,
-0.0293770228,
-0.0023331784,
0.0137962932,
0.038937442,
0.0087749958,
-0.0688705742,
0.0371761434,
-0.0542321838,
0.0228442606,
0.0069638919,
0.0076890383,
-0.0070393481,
-0.050247144,
-0.0500827655,
0.000667256,
0.0090247104,
0.0362953097,
0.0016281613,
-0.0248827171,
-0.008076096,
0.0045623905,
-0.0055404236,
-0.0363855436,
-0.020937968,
-0.0485186763,
0.0333420523,
0.0671846345,
0.0148938755,
0.0089016631,
-0.0433981866,
-0.0157319289,
-0.0021036735,
0.0673799738,
0.0802128986,
0.0096790809,
-0.0125102652,
0.0055295797,
-0.02126473,
0.0278480351,
0.0043420009,
-0.0125415837,
0.0282770954,
0.0133200893,
-0.001009198,
-0.025071647,
-0.0407936126,
0.0350113213,
-0.0097571444,
-0.0277392101,
-0.0440200046,
0.0016958256,
0.0134316795,
0.0090183709,
0.0001858522,
0.0217733476,
0.0300442073,
0.0656562001,
-0.0479440242,
0.0205438472,
-0.0160668679,
0.0401229113,
0.0517083295,
-0.0245878845,
-0.0724139065,
-0.0208759066,
-0.034164805,
-0.010779392,
-0.0288127437,
-0.0253239386,
-0.0090285139,
0.0010042278,
0.03054538,
-0.0039240099,
-0.0316685513,
-0.0557641312,
0.0272714775,
-0.0166774858,
0.0058139022,
0.0104516521,
-0.0014666632,
-0.0172547512,
-0.0562869795,
-0.0370563157,
0.0178686064,
0.0002208965,
0.020842379,
0.0296680219,
0.0104356091,
-0.071798116,
0.0120370267,
-0.0424079187,
-0.028156722,
0.0073887487,
0.0281495135,
-0.003001241,
-0.0228538681,
-0.0231098924,
-0.0115144085,
-0.0271312539,
-0.0026033258,
0.0128611941,
0.0303521566,
0.0626627207,
-0.0055452785,
0.0199364927,
-0.0591941811,
0.0159828085,
-0.0269579981,
-0.0058021699,
0.0222139191,
0.0052616564,
-0.075109601,
0.0257463101,
-0.0564679392,
0.0043852022,
-0.0025748904,
-0.0121301524,
0.040858224,
0.0198429711,
-0.0196963735,
0.0290451366,
0.0194093473,
0.0168903507,
0.0607977584,
0.0056124805,
-0.0479273871,
0.0102972798,
-0.0060567204,
-0.0620387457,
-0.0043474021,
-0.0347415507,
0.0021303492,
0.0284870379,
0.0041227187,
0.028953677,
-0.0290534962,
0.0297534335,
-0.0130937407,
-0.0344610251,
0.0108618569,
-0.0230903588,
-0.0429296605,
0.0923629552,
0.0012951756,
-0.0751960278,
0.0969658196,
0.0031690754,
-0.0014456189,
0.0174614731,
0.0024068065,
0.0164450444,
0.0301119704,
-0.0223507844,
-0.0087450081,
0.0450291447,
-0.00796392,
-0.081933856,
-0.0261264835,
0.0063515818,
-0.0588654242,
0.0506722815,
-0.0766884908,
-0.0174678173,
-0.0063694608,
-0.0393437594,
-0.0580329224,
-0.0361607112,
-0.0737808123,
-0.0386969596,
0.0236666892,
-0.0477202758,
0.0025946028,
-0.0447022617,
0.0240818355,
-0.0259061456,
-0.0373144671,
-0.0339223854,
-0.0137255816,
-0.0005501152,
0.0527414754,
0.0353280194,
0.0629860684,
-0.0261155739,
0.0115702888,
0.0655279085,
0.0275882203,
0.001572473,
-0.0220093261,
-0.0282483138,
0.0374338031,
0.0122319898,
-0.0194487032,
0.099126555,
0.0574526303,
-0.0064063156,
0.0221789964,
0.1022521034,
0.0356125869,
-0.0041787843,
0.0076590921,
-0.0724777281,
0.0595691241,
0.0240985211,
0.0197161138,
-0.0745973215,
-0.0232556779,
0.016545523,
0.0428850651,
-0.014088613,
-0.0300663877,
0.0078747114,
-0.1038066223,
0.0175414775,
0.0124329682,
-0.0337731875,
-0.0085918903,
-0.0086207837,
0.0250408687,
0.0092286915,
0.0635448322,
0.0234922692,
-0.0207755826,
0.0034944569,
0.001197927,
-0.0674662516,
-0.0364714637,
-0.0019973221,
-0.0548043698,
0.0758211464,
0.039116811,
0.0091521917,
-0.0176842734,
-0.0353894532,
-0.0021825288,
0.0266903117,
0.0254221577,
-0.018529959,
0.0424590521,
-0.0029086645,
0.0016758904,
-0.0349937975,
-0.0059073656,
-0.0341829099,
0.0087805158,
-0.0051323301,
0.0494875833,
-0.0502717383,
-0.0038006466,
-0.0248055197,
-0.0008156925,
0.0375843719,
0.0428034849,
-0.0026499496,
-0.0442376398,
-0.0321134776,
-0.0506929494,
0.0187954605,
0.0056614978,
-0.0363909602,
0.0332203098,
0.0021400983,
-0.0021897629,
-0.0459575914,
-0.0712295845,
0.0013768788,
-0.0134293223,
0.0148744164,
-0.0442502238,
0.0477751456,
0.0252520945,
-0.0153649552,
0.0366248004,
-0.0138039319,
0.0416404679,
-0.0294119157,
0.0632444695,
0.0117123527,
-0.0215568542,
0.0449476279,
0.0366842449,
-0.0339402109,
-0.0758874565,
0.0089069903,
0.0925512239,
0.0372334123,
0.0055294284,
0.009359953,
-0.0600068234,
-0.0001749156,
0.0300374217,
-0.0189435799,
0.0108035197,
0.0153846359,
0.0632099286,
-0.0258980375,
0.0492677428,
-0.0347780772,
-0.0629815757,
-0.0094569661,
0.0289163478,
-0.0381573737,
-0.0916063562,
0.0163610652,
0.0354915895,
0.0570528619,
-0.0404176749,
0.0412901118,
0.0125430943,
-0.003897561,
-0.0141543746,
-0.0275806729,
-0.0083091203,
-0.0167029426,
-0.007208914,
-0.0121414419,
0.0026945521,
-0.0302444622,
-0.0305659622,
0.041432295,
0.0162958093,
0.0002911251,
0.024795251,
0.029185323,
0.0106160771,
0.0239485875,
-0.0081332484,
0.0401725024,
-0.0208310932,
0.0548648387,
0.0737049133,
0.0508113839,
-0.0041949423,
-0.0202977285,
-0.0096352799,
-0.0113080572,
-0.0318391919,
-0.1200017706,
-0.0075493692,
-0.0261354409,
0.0251698662,
-0.0006077352,
0.043313805,
-0.0468270257,
0.0094865505,
-0.0149172368,
-0.0087293945,
0.0068461094,
-0.0095639657,
0.074602209,
0.0125901354,
-0.0442603789,
-0.001941204,
0.0534139834,
-0.0051898663,
0.042554725,
-0.0477617644,
-0.0509410091,
-0.0196121465,
-0.021060558,
0.0308181215,
-0.0025968486,
-0.0284533799,
-0.0388953686,
-0.0673028901,
-0.0813265964,
0.0268073641,
0.0205986425,
0.0017317532,
-0.0717949197,
0.0142223407,
0.0377030335,
0.0256192796,
-0.0161115453,
-0.0251906663,
0.0031889693,
-0.0421757996,
0.0309354253,
-0.0855948627,
-6.313118777e-33,
-0.0220610015,
-0.0730292872,
-0.0061454508,
-0.0226717088,
-0.0099861454,
-0.0077488641,
-0.0065533319,
0.0817557275,
-0.0326870941,
0.0156039381,
-0.0408251919,
0.002795351,
0.0200993642,
0.0106196394,
0.076597698,
-0.0330261141,
0.0058700121,
-0.018827334,
-0.0218593609,
-0.0533585139,
0.0302893277,
-0.0122916987,
0.0395250581,
-0.1066351533,
0.0876505375,
0.0047928267,
-0.0253333561,
0.0473647453,
-0.0485168919,
0.009918048,
-0.0047926535,
0.0419323295,
-0.0130890915,
-0.0036557678,
-0.0208858177,
0.0335032046,
0.0148702534,
-0.0505552255,
0.012516275,
0.0440069437,
-0.038804587,
-0.0129310694,
0.0166381896,
-0.009270899,
-0.0548030138,
0.0359545946,
0.0230221767,
-0.0195668302,
0.0142681943,
-0.0000441297,
-0.0159352235,
0.0111783138,
-0.0020260599,
-0.0195860043,
-0.006936796,
0.0818326622,
-0.018393416,
-0.0224249382,
-0.0692053586,
0.017317269,
-0.0116078099,
-0.0084088519,
0.0923793092,
0.0367942154,
-0.0147521617,
0.0486768,
0.0043631098,
0.0312667303,
-0.0393964984,
-0.0013033689,
-0.0169342905,
0.0406520478,
0.0173230805,
0.064711459,
0.0061405669,
0.0039784363,
0.0036487321,
0.0359827317,
0.0004222177,
0.0630254969,
0.0047756992,
0.0357046649,
-0.0767247006,
-0.0206803977,
-0.0300451908,
-0.0272432808,
-0.0328425877,
-0.033296492,
-0.0153620448,
-0.0180267636,
0.015942486,
-0.0189272538,
-0.0064949491,
-0.0043344214,
-0.0322156847,
-0.0321578197,
-0.0195666999,
0.0193011854,
-0.0009490474,
0.0233231075,
-0.0046738498,
0.0313296802,
-0.0137336766,
-0.0131865013,
0.0184742976,
0.0402172431,
-0.0154554835,
0.0206230264,
-0.0696251169,
0.0091007994,
-0.0002449495,
0.0011378377,
0.0235061981,
-0.0340296179,
0.057820905,
-0.0227237009,
-0.0231124684,
0.0446523465,
-0.023853831,
-0.0034011099,
-0.0409364477,
0.0028000036,
-0.0262546428,
-0.0289062988,
-0.0163926203,
-0.0136686638,
-0.0255724005,
0.0236976743,
-0.0061772126,
-0.0438781194,
-0.0106294388,
-0.0238104239,
2.658e-7,
0.0415597856,
0.0513880216,
0.0132274423,
0.0433509201,
0.0125401877,
0.0759472549,
-0.0082156844,
0.0147937322,
0.0407591648,
-0.0312122479,
0.026573889,
-0.0052776188,
0.0605548583,
0.0530033335,
-0.0254024509,
-0.0405893549,
-0.0371129364,
0.0405285992,
-0.0057278634,
0.0158602726,
0.071184136,
0.0244043805,
-0.0045933961,
0.0047175717,
-0.0324163735,
-0.0003202807,
0.0291967932,
-0.0453099608,
0.0235214792,
0.0050004465,
0.0323185846,
0.0140681723,
-0.0117601641,
0.036610242,
0.0037540386,
-0.0246589631,
-0.0330109969,
0.0569344647,
-0.0050122426,
-0.0402237959,
-0.025329167,
-0.0038984143,
0.0286065359,
-0.0322021805,
0.0256536361,
-0.0560364574,
-0.0412428826,
-0.0074507897,
0.0160090588,
-0.0214249343,
0.0373522453,
-0.0161651187,
-0.011392355,
0.005308589,
0.0180918518,
0.0343064889,
-0.0336146168,
-0.0275766347,
-0.0398604162,
0.0144297043,
-0.0294931326,
-0.0572911687,
-0.0261660274,
0.0613123588,
0.0040441141,
-0.0547315553,
0.0093470514,
2.004751203e-34,
0.004803387,
0.0163287204,
0.0203202087,
0.024270663,
0.0607013628,
0.0239912234,
0.025093982,
0.0414942689,
0.0557260141,
-0.0322448723,
-0.0171267074
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.10908v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.10908v1 | LLM-Assisted Crisis Management: Building Advanced LLM Platforms for Effective Emergency Response and Public Collaboration | 2024-01-12T17:50:35 | 2024-01-12T17:50:35 | Hakan T. Otal, M. Abdullah Canbaz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.LG, 68T50 68T50 68T50, I.2.7 | Emergencies and critical incidents often unfold rapidly, necessitating a
swift and effective response. In this research, we introduce a novel approach
to identify and classify emergency situations from social media posts and
direct emergency messages using an open source Large Language Model, LLAMA2.
The goal is to harness the power of natural language processing and machine
learning to assist public safety telecommunicators and huge crowds during
countrywide emergencies. Our research focuses on developing a language model
that can understand users describe their situation in the 911 call, enabling
LLAMA2 to analyze the content and offer relevant instructions to the
telecommunicator, while also creating workflows to notify government agencies
with the caller's information when necessary. Another benefit this language
model provides is its ability to assist people during a significant emergency
incident when the 911 system is overwhelmed, by assisting the users with simple
instructions and informing authorities with their location and emergency
information. | [
0.0486964956,
0.0055739004,
-0.0008248587,
0.0215135422,
-0.0365701802,
0.0257692859,
-0.0282022711,
0.0016856734,
0.0080167698,
-0.0876755565,
0.0009300669,
-0.0237710401,
-0.045118697,
0.0329698063,
-0.0182263777,
-0.0517279655,
0.0139185498,
-0.0106671359,
0.0612708926,
0.0393789522,
0.0330837257,
0.0465444066,
-0.0208196249,
0.0224701241,
0.0018973611,
0.0415759496,
-0.0171264932,
0.0064485194,
0.0543400571,
-0.0326162614,
0.0134794582,
0.0133828549,
0.0628913492,
0.0011056085,
0.000001622,
-0.0547981448,
-0.0041127023,
-0.045986969,
-0.0361435525,
-0.0540650561,
0.0341518857,
-0.0499035865,
-0.036756631,
0.0369155817,
-0.0377655253,
-0.0066722985,
0.0172902551,
0.0746847838,
0.0798997879,
0.0793282613,
-0.0118215857,
-0.0527924709,
0.0334360711,
0.0127665913,
-0.0164893437,
-0.0507351905,
0.016405398,
-0.048093535,
0.0595414899,
-0.0076467651,
0.0689853802,
0.022699507,
-0.001904226,
0.0265158061,
-0.011360161,
0.0383394696,
-0.0588660873,
-0.0113880048,
-0.0350821279,
0.062320631,
-0.0121154124,
-0.0127361212,
0.0273217652,
0.0097647011,
-0.0138366604,
0.0220711064,
-0.0254604463,
-0.0144682433,
-0.0245598964,
0.0335689038,
0.0086589372,
0.0613978691,
0.0281200744,
0.0388964079,
0.0050093355,
0.0256875046,
-0.0348560587,
-0.0180048756,
-0.0282244645,
0.001911949,
-0.0326198377,
-0.0395072326,
0.0537557527,
0.0445658937,
-0.0297615025,
0.0061853235,
0.0036768049,
-0.0081285676,
0.0296697617,
-0.1266799718,
-0.0139468033,
-0.0122353313,
-0.010268,
0.035133712,
0.004006831,
-0.0287090465,
0.0124006039,
-0.0075279921,
0.0011003944,
-0.0354665294,
-0.0921175629,
0.0118767917,
-0.0116141103,
0.0255828146,
-0.0069552013,
0.0041249488,
-0.0379513614,
0.0117731141,
0.0350399017,
-0.0188517347,
0.0092670275,
0.0051156981,
-0.0093603181,
-0.0088791829,
-0.0196064655,
-0.0063153189,
-0.0242996216,
0.0499627516,
-0.0385997407,
-0.0444376469,
0.0552004166,
0.0045922794,
0.031408906,
0.0193539038,
-0.0176375918,
0.0429648571,
-0.0060790014,
-0.022810014,
-0.0968690962,
0.0078381468,
0.0383997224,
-0.0309394822,
-0.0117071141,
-0.0741303936,
0.0425862223,
0.0116479164,
-0.0188940018,
0.0254118629,
0.0371092595,
-0.0016626464,
-0.035070654,
0.0452883057,
-0.0719629824,
0.0390166007,
0.064345561,
0.0294532366,
0.0597310103,
0.0515257008,
0.0400833786,
0.0419770963,
0.0800152048,
-0.0224558413,
0.0459732823,
0.019110946,
-0.0629417598,
-0.0058891103,
-0.005235035,
0.0169379264,
-0.0514991656,
0.0161589291,
0.0128583657,
0.0040559345,
0.0106450142,
0.0140338214,
0.0462919138,
0.1004058346,
0.012067277,
-0.0068921251,
0.0289619341,
0.0772894621,
-0.0351494364,
-0.0508187376,
-0.0205211826,
0.0011535127,
-0.0555565394,
-0.0055560041,
0.0290302057,
0.0449387655,
-0.0485237017,
-0.0332587026,
-0.033321403,
-0.0304573514,
-0.0346109197,
-0.0058470373,
0.023444375,
-0.0430079214,
-0.0102657862,
0.0412573442,
-0.0059884787,
-0.0140679516,
-0.0106900483,
-0.0489129163,
-0.00008043,
0.1114747301,
-0.0076751378,
-0.0384847149,
-0.0173587129,
-0.0495043434,
0.0587432422,
0.0509980358,
-0.0122688031,
0.0285889879,
-0.0045260619,
-0.0566161983,
-0.0038074732,
0.0515574738,
0.0071875951,
-0.020074496,
0.0053607607,
0.0313836485,
0.0036772231,
0.0176157858,
-0.0368915461,
0.0211204458,
0.0370406955,
-0.0498766005,
-0.0253433455,
0.0050892159,
0.0029041932,
0.0187167656,
0.0152366329,
-0.0094398055,
0.0288139135,
-0.0338600129,
-0.0702918172,
0.0170082096,
-0.0196100995,
0.0262484495,
0.0244862325,
-0.0099441921,
-0.013185543,
0.0050173639,
-0.0646184459,
-0.0189795364,
0.025737755,
-0.0400281884,
0.0133953849,
-0.0389485806,
-0.0034249851,
0.0267409347,
-0.0047989362,
0.0070073432,
0.0770420879,
-0.0179268047,
-0.0137337716,
-0.0441041701,
0.0118881343,
0.0029757372,
-0.0063550831,
0.0093362993,
0.0100469207,
0.0029625127,
0.0584739558,
-0.010690758,
0.0078079659,
-0.0119773336,
-0.0257069021,
-0.0635907426,
0.0159364454,
-0.0372112058,
0.0453413315,
0.0408469178,
0.0230157338,
-0.0317453258,
-0.0208195429,
-0.0156955551,
-0.0109056886,
0.0522791483,
-0.0092236465,
0.0135722728,
0.0025548039,
-0.022151025,
-0.0391469263,
0.0088016456,
-0.0090909116,
0.002881228,
0.0223904997,
-0.1229001433,
-0.0550663061,
0.0019478032,
-0.0304766595,
0.0175933205,
-0.0040223682,
-0.063413769,
0.013845833,
-0.0121857366,
0.0044527045,
-0.033981096,
0.0343429036,
0.0453609973,
0.0085011628,
0.0195868053,
-0.0176593047,
-0.0099327108,
-0.0497621447,
-0.0497247539,
-0.0365612768,
-0.0422608592,
-0.001694413,
0.0400116071,
-0.024968924,
0.0432255194,
0.0146541139,
-0.0507455319,
-0.0029405674,
-0.0093560666,
-0.0399634577,
-0.0150220748,
-0.0118235173,
0.0458954871,
0.0077940882,
-0.0272971615,
0.0197070166,
0.0269003827,
0.0263016541,
-0.0511178449,
-0.0863512084,
-0.0740190893,
0.0437099747,
-0.042976249,
0.0276953932,
0.0063081989,
-0.0277160965,
0.0511127226,
-0.0304553211,
-0.0529313609,
-0.0533778034,
0.007995327,
-0.044848606,
0.013818657,
0.0197472572,
-0.0392076559,
-0.0311468411,
-0.0408176742,
-0.0805196166,
-0.0033059383,
-0.0379716717,
0.0008794678,
-0.0386303961,
0.0147892106,
0.0170679353,
0.0059620156,
0.0308657866,
-0.0058670379,
-0.0168376341,
0.0579297692,
0.0140077248,
0.0433036126,
-0.0073211011,
0.0096032741,
0.0301694293,
0.0639727116,
0.0139249619,
-0.0185496919,
-0.0212971605,
0.0000294063,
0.0392085128,
-0.0373346396,
-0.024732139,
0.0344556011,
0.0341602489,
-0.0203181934,
0.0377998054,
0.098282747,
0.04944418,
-0.0443336368,
0.0054745059,
-0.0816691965,
-0.0386403725,
0.0234520379,
0.0329209454,
-0.0095306942,
-0.0337190442,
-0.0134561518,
0.0046657687,
-0.0072227945,
-0.0305332579,
0.0181983877,
-0.0707995892,
0.056935437,
0.0020512044,
0.0004647699,
-0.0161154829,
-0.0575230755,
0.0300331172,
-0.0022916249,
0.0168185998,
-0.0393225439,
-0.0345370322,
-0.0353536569,
0.0146817593,
-0.0692351013,
-0.0731166527,
0.0024415678,
-0.0577154085,
0.0537577234,
0.0198978521,
0.0435194895,
-0.0255129524,
-0.0288254581,
0.0325742103,
0.0264547914,
0.0199476462,
-0.0082165683,
0.0038051938,
0.0067494968,
-0.0005754124,
-0.0573516786,
0.0262352154,
-0.0451107472,
-0.0185898002,
0.0214185882,
0.0783521309,
-0.0507330075,
-0.0044270465,
-0.0302920192,
0.0447792709,
0.0609047115,
0.0275577176,
0.0101960069,
-0.0244219787,
-0.0119319074,
-0.0314775668,
-0.0146489227,
-0.0197228752,
-0.0420674421,
0.0106698219,
-0.0218695533,
-0.0650472492,
-0.0279849246,
-0.0050556008,
0.0271861814,
-0.022182161,
-0.0205325708,
0.0108206654,
0.0439400375,
-0.0145062758,
-0.0218811706,
0.025404295,
0.0043441188,
0.0489895642,
-0.0681056455,
0.0248677004,
0.0326091535,
0.0272766091,
-0.0017588303,
0.0381011739,
-0.0476757623,
-0.042543266,
0.0130826607,
0.0018538969,
0.0224653017,
-0.0420240387,
-0.0286521371,
-0.0774789825,
-0.0116096204,
0.0587330088,
-0.0708842054,
-0.0174093079,
-0.0125044407,
0.03621912,
0.0250088312,
0.0240677241,
-0.0006352677,
0.0662148446,
-0.0143319629,
0.0178541522,
-0.1121677309,
-0.0221718326,
-0.0248791836,
-0.0046569649,
0.0434542485,
-0.0099519826,
-0.0937648639,
-0.0065932712,
-0.0051047895,
0.0146342963,
0.0021638912,
0.0089852503,
0.0532171726,
0.0169996135,
0.0058653052,
0.0032624407,
0.0153493453,
-0.0370662659,
-0.0278539862,
-0.0215211269,
0.0558779053,
0.058236327,
0.026684694,
0.0016049008,
0.0022093707,
-0.0021531032,
0.0462787412,
0.0245867055,
0.0057989229,
-0.0010561976,
0.0251618307,
-0.0290144403,
0.0305931978,
-0.0119160237,
0.0564311333,
-0.0089457044,
-0.0775937811,
0.0153784975,
0.0561699644,
0.0799018145,
0.0052253925,
0.0140422015,
0.0021163656,
0.001690285,
-0.0254387017,
0.038652733,
-0.0248247683,
-0.0097839087,
0.0462264903,
0.0186663251,
-0.0352748856,
0.0357155874,
0.0413824096,
0.0139630241,
0.0027494656,
0.0287977047,
-0.0360797569,
-0.01959599,
-0.0055715749,
0.0220709033,
0.044770997,
-0.0274759885,
0.0056420593,
-0.042610053,
-0.0183123238,
0.0338728987,
-0.0281709861,
-0.0377918929,
-0.0163437948,
0.0403682813,
0.0188124031,
0.0208507571,
0.0384536609,
-0.0511701629,
-0.0126067139,
-0.0162527375,
-0.0224116985,
0.0147100361,
-5.67525293e-33,
0.0126551623,
-0.0688316375,
0.020225497,
-0.0080340737,
0.0296370052,
-0.0008747756,
0.025420934,
0.0028260679,
0.0195097812,
-0.0306744315,
-0.0111059528,
0.0312131923,
0.0175473616,
-0.0387596935,
-0.0087447409,
-0.0153817786,
0.0127997193,
-0.012636831,
0.0187750291,
0.0034186044,
0.056562122,
0.0437296443,
0.040829584,
-0.1143934056,
-0.0006910979,
-0.0084454129,
-0.0051789242,
0.0279240012,
0.0547494143,
0.0494062193,
-0.0593655258,
0.0607387982,
0.0510166697,
-0.0375653431,
0.0021298141,
0.11499843,
-0.0180191454,
-0.0212348159,
0.0328876637,
-0.0219899975,
-0.0254772305,
-0.0329840444,
0.0145172123,
0.0220795721,
-0.0038041663,
0.0238188803,
0.0426281504,
-0.0075846883,
0.0006908255,
0.0023494689,
-0.0568856895,
0.0243801381,
-0.0186695978,
-0.0154052963,
-0.0040270831,
-0.0022225787,
-0.0317931771,
0.0106651755,
-0.0455814488,
-0.0104317665,
-0.0248865765,
0.0014218704,
0.0231076162,
-0.0014163066,
-0.0624803677,
0.0633804128,
-0.041252818,
-0.0498984046,
-0.0817642063,
-0.0024240657,
-0.0417321995,
0.0934016779,
0.037856292,
0.0586240999,
-0.0063409819,
-0.0225565266,
-0.0830860138,
0.0408818536,
0.0087723359,
0.0505091287,
0.0308776312,
0.0004014088,
-0.0463098623,
0.0140429316,
0.0310046673,
0.0095592411,
-0.0236986242,
0.0027108898,
0.0061579705,
0.0111401938,
0.0032245028,
0.0414370187,
0.0251624808,
0.0065435581,
-0.0096204216,
-0.0095480429,
0.0294115581,
0.037183851,
0.0064977184,
0.0307380836,
-0.0859977826,
0.0086034108,
0.0009090032,
-0.0064165103,
0.0181413535,
-0.0192384701,
0.0195552446,
0.0181872658,
-0.0219361205,
0.0184538141,
0.0018405396,
0.0335461646,
0.0042715673,
0.0330005512,
0.0221488569,
-0.0081699584,
0.002839281,
-0.0082469741,
-0.0028370901,
-0.0197245423,
0.0338741876,
-0.0511378758,
-0.0531035028,
0.009202118,
-0.0261132717,
0.0273963474,
-0.0323626958,
0.0377397947,
-0.0063070641,
-0.013306113,
-0.0112092122,
0.006735025,
2.347e-7,
0.0467181019,
0.0395845547,
0.0053066318,
0.0161257647,
0.009605852,
0.0249815937,
0.0155467968,
0.0375561826,
0.0027602785,
-0.0282368958,
0.0096409731,
0.0545968115,
0.0314671881,
0.0496205874,
-0.0821719766,
-0.0006930417,
-0.0524148531,
0.0263751037,
-0.082122907,
-0.0021380614,
0.0769933462,
0.077619642,
0.0223284811,
-0.0405777507,
-0.0376352444,
-0.0432872102,
0.0172154941,
-0.0764889866,
-0.0274815653,
0.0136155561,
0.0800005496,
0.0587739423,
-0.0367846116,
0.006672048,
-0.0097363107,
-0.0081249429,
0.0274757966,
0.0746364743,
-0.0301630422,
0.0034394963,
-0.0122045372,
-0.0551395938,
0.0023081996,
-0.0292492155,
0.0386645906,
-0.0225414354,
-0.033355888,
0.0146190189,
0.0003070216,
-0.0072785085,
-0.0151340393,
-0.0303481463,
-0.0392599739,
0.027103819,
0.0263197497,
-0.0489191301,
-0.0412103459,
-0.0720744953,
0.0218741763,
0.0338951387,
-0.0075703943,
-0.0204610191,
-0.0306352414,
0.0329143703,
0.0320378952,
-0.003755233,
0.0442406237,
1.313113745e-34,
-0.0064326893,
0.0455776453,
-0.0328589864,
0.0231640339,
0.0406492315,
0.0186572541,
-0.0578948222,
-0.0001854497,
-0.0043773772,
-0.0571295135,
0.0376535989
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06837v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06837v2 | Structsum Generation for Faster Text Comprehension | 2024-01-12T17:43:51 | 2024-06-19T09:59:51 | Parag Jain, Andreea Marzoca, Francesco Piccinno | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We consider the task of generating structured representations of text using
large language models (LLMs). We focus on tables and mind maps as
representative modalities. Tables are more organized way of representing data,
while mind maps provide a visually dynamic and flexible approach, particularly
suitable for sparse content. Despite the effectiveness of LLMs on different
tasks, we show that current models struggle with generating structured outputs.
In response, we present effective prompting strategies for both of these tasks.
We introduce a taxonomy of problems around factuality, global and local
structure, common to both modalities and propose a set of critiques to tackle
these issues resulting in an absolute improvement in accuracy of +37pp (79%)
for mind maps and +15pp (78%) for tables. To evaluate semantic coverage of
generated structured representations we propose Auto-QA, and we verify the
adequacy of Auto-QA using SQuAD dataset. We further evaluate the usefulness of
structured representations via a text comprehension user study. The results
show a significant reduction in comprehension time compared to text when using
table (42.9%) and mind map (31.9%), without loss in accuracy. | [
0.0033500888,
0.0023259711,
-0.0304387286,
0.0247348323,
-0.0330627225,
0.0137642063,
-0.0103139402,
-0.0109596225,
0.027724186,
-0.0411297865,
-0.0344653837,
-0.030189015,
-0.001409137,
0.0266660079,
0.0088516492,
-0.055123426,
0.0398001745,
-0.0573990233,
-0.0079032471,
0.0316591039,
-0.0174278431,
-0.0010973093,
-0.0167618934,
0.0167083796,
0.0151843764,
-0.0386362337,
-0.0399187952,
-0.0317507423,
-0.0150453476,
-0.0674209222,
-0.038705267,
0.0469423458,
0.0256766714,
0.0160131548,
0.000002355,
0.015609378,
-0.0235271119,
-0.0147151574,
-0.0030819199,
0.0529866628,
0.0377526172,
-0.059429165,
0.0028617661,
-0.0193373095,
-0.0369722694,
-0.0172550995,
0.0118045509,
0.0474146828,
0.0502914861,
0.0266632028,
-0.0156131303,
-0.0292014852,
0.0086471932,
0.0206117425,
0.0554664172,
-0.0408911519,
-0.0109322211,
0.0678826049,
0.0249174256,
0.0539598651,
-0.0091046859,
0.0306757018,
0.0113815516,
-0.015072708,
0.0207479317,
0.0607517362,
0.0034956045,
0.0116716772,
-0.0118455328,
0.097887978,
0.0068576941,
-0.0047617843,
0.0028770806,
-0.0079469858,
-0.012704758,
0.0045879371,
-0.070521608,
0.0239452384,
-0.0260579195,
0.0111206593,
0.0218870584,
-0.0000619493,
0.021419581,
0.0032873887,
-0.0475422852,
0.0362242907,
0.0009258742,
-0.0232409537,
-0.0376832895,
-0.0099758077,
-0.0420262255,
-0.0495592169,
0.0088828662,
0.0735034496,
-0.025909856,
0.0384731106,
-0.0424459539,
-0.0924717188,
0.0095925592,
-0.0665614828,
0.0463680252,
0.0631846786,
-0.0045042429,
0.0651311353,
-0.0837183818,
0.049476862,
-0.0513903126,
0.0405525602,
-0.0470073633,
0.0113767814,
-0.0389633328,
-0.0089802714,
-0.0488098823,
0.0430236422,
-0.0778008625,
-0.0501600355,
0.0121519407,
0.0389915593,
0.0112832421,
0.0120851174,
-0.0313118249,
-0.0103530064,
-0.0196320377,
0.0031251472,
-0.0538717695,
-0.0042449962,
-0.0577421412,
-0.0261265133,
-0.0131257353,
-0.0101088258,
0.0060126125,
0.0074368892,
0.0073068859,
-0.0065371133,
-0.0073176506,
0.0812725723,
-0.0229061618,
0.0028162813,
-0.0587642789,
-0.0339018069,
-0.0086670695,
-0.0414949991,
0.007487304,
-0.0590073057,
0.0225725155,
0.0397226103,
0.0082229814,
-0.0010291493,
0.0178432073,
0.0319522135,
-0.0412187427,
0.0664895102,
-0.0219596457,
0.0366081968,
0.0036328877,
0.0069449092,
-0.0111549217,
0.0575323142,
0.0322467238,
0.0167907272,
0.0010113644,
-0.017917132,
-0.0240381472,
0.0302249212,
0.0051765935,
0.0037703989,
-0.0299894568,
0.0195958856,
0.0189760141,
0.0310076084,
0.0164353736,
0.0534530506,
-0.048362799,
0.0183366202,
0.0333920009,
0.0303067081,
0.0216760784,
0.0557706021,
0.0206837002,
0.0164437238,
0.018679101,
0.0392975025,
-0.029123906,
0.0360705629,
-0.0284541901,
0.0464298949,
0.0160176326,
0.0068785818,
-0.0086883726,
-0.0467305183,
-0.013431468,
0.0284753721,
0.0312350877,
-0.0076605417,
0.0408705287,
0.0424042419,
-0.0660116673,
0.0363490954,
-0.0049343118,
-0.0539505407,
0.001725906,
-0.0256121568,
0.0773741454,
0.0687339827,
0.0624967404,
-0.0359696411,
-0.0306673497,
0.0166721717,
0.0164994802,
0.0272402056,
0.0164966937,
-0.0168487132,
-0.0090081785,
-0.0695017651,
-0.0023463813,
0.0023791213,
-0.0156583488,
0.0063479366,
0.0105666807,
-0.0131515609,
0.0241607949,
-0.0755593777,
-0.0333548114,
0.0372188501,
0.0294222552,
-0.0131009901,
-0.0035430782,
-0.0019146556,
0.008238731,
0.0188537873,
0.0056057069,
0.027500404,
0.0311921705,
-0.0572668724,
0.0427261628,
-0.0159598999,
-0.0683703646,
-0.0225070454,
0.0061909659,
0.0019566102,
-0.0393407457,
-0.0224972852,
-0.0159772914,
-0.0578903444,
-0.0241607893,
-0.0398608372,
0.0038433995,
-0.0135248788,
0.0103650251,
0.0241165124,
-0.0114600984,
-0.0473318696,
0.1158591583,
-0.0256089978,
0.0096035087,
0.0720696151,
-0.0227894038,
0.0193396527,
0.0066513633,
0.0167564042,
0.0121647315,
0.0112091424,
-0.0153208608,
-0.0010191789,
0.0193010662,
-0.0568088889,
-0.0197957996,
-0.1060928851,
0.0094134789,
-0.0219335705,
0.0111307614,
0.0467155203,
-0.0054587061,
-0.0165193062,
-0.0324691944,
-0.0506554209,
0.0125657488,
0.0087820906,
0.0138676548,
0.0400859639,
-0.0028004267,
-0.0198848452,
-0.020098865,
-0.0258208569,
-0.0383357294,
0.0125299888,
0.0192979295,
-0.0315843932,
-0.0477794558,
0.0370458625,
0.0088177491,
-0.0049650236,
-0.0021856192,
-0.0157800391,
0.0197800566,
-0.0564198047,
0.0908024609,
0.0539375655,
0.0069724917,
0.0291218162,
0.0674578622,
-0.0113908034,
-0.031081466,
0.0318059474,
0.0123163722,
0.0502017662,
-0.0144098774,
-0.0507513583,
0.0408222638,
0.0496463552,
0.0196445435,
0.0238793902,
-0.0557382181,
-0.0051098648,
-0.0247042254,
-0.022045996,
-0.0659701601,
0.0203123484,
0.0204157606,
0.0370046608,
-0.0464746431,
-0.0215867702,
0.0436837934,
-0.0606530383,
0.0168151464,
-0.0392015986,
0.0268470477,
-0.0586508363,
0.0967168733,
0.0275102817,
0.0287708025,
-0.0207924377,
-0.0368439779,
-0.0404999144,
0.0147096133,
0.00618074,
-0.0165691767,
0.0506137125,
-0.0724115297,
0.0034762374,
-0.030224828,
0.0033530029,
-0.0219997093,
-0.0288618784,
-0.031103842,
0.0002506888,
0.0420657508,
0.003951679,
-0.0305377059,
0.0317750797,
0.0527551398,
0.0256769098,
-0.0325314552,
-0.0160005298,
-0.0498725623,
0.0477666669,
0.040114224,
0.0398738086,
-0.0013728564,
-0.0396634825,
0.0434684716,
0.0410207026,
0.0014723546,
0.0191563219,
-0.0079076225,
0.0222596359,
0.0217555929,
-0.0237951148,
-0.0260581505,
0.0391792804,
0.0427492186,
-0.073919408,
-0.0111915851,
0.128184393,
0.0470761769,
-0.0276185311,
-0.024975758,
-0.0392059274,
0.0556267314,
0.0128035545,
0.0107174562,
-0.092537269,
-0.0172145478,
-0.0071781771,
-0.0315684751,
0.0175033044,
-0.0517681725,
0.0005685078,
-0.0864006281,
0.0437197052,
0.0215128958,
-0.0667553023,
-0.0470458381,
-0.0394641794,
-0.0078364443,
0.0494380705,
0.0059378981,
0.0200142357,
-0.0196864307,
0.0161098391,
-0.0027854417,
-0.0337807015,
0.0167071391,
-0.0054929331,
-0.0236207712,
0.0317477211,
0.0685132518,
0.0398029014,
-0.0002481846,
-0.0446505472,
0.0108513599,
0.0385430679,
0.0544733331,
-0.0249480791,
0.0376857258,
0.0187832955,
-0.0105992351,
-0.0436053351,
0.0165665466,
-0.0302204899,
-0.013993918,
0.0284339972,
0.0634830818,
-0.0224544015,
-0.0003949659,
-0.0603956915,
-0.0040512076,
0.0027823716,
0.0694895312,
0.0515197478,
-0.0124720419,
-0.0604158342,
-0.0233423728,
0.0027759231,
-0.0629244745,
-0.0099660894,
0.0754465386,
-0.013626215,
0.0191445947,
-0.0404023565,
-0.0191352628,
0.0923777521,
0.0249651764,
0.0232544001,
0.0132595068,
0.0202261079,
-0.0381168723,
-0.0241593067,
0.0005528114,
-0.042076502,
0.0327131152,
-0.0470646881,
-0.0360360406,
-0.0278836098,
-0.0281828884,
0.0216709282,
0.0206640437,
-0.0533179678,
-0.0162286311,
-0.0000743718,
0.0101315882,
0.0140006579,
0.0243265275,
0.0027681824,
-0.0472661071,
0.0225708,
-0.0260393713,
-0.0848837644,
0.0006589722,
-0.0276504271,
0.0278334823,
0.0095464028,
0.0203121509,
-0.0115621295,
0.0389511995,
-0.0335735567,
0.0751494244,
0.0088727372,
0.0279256385,
0.0402456708,
0.0318636745,
-0.005468376,
0.0125715267,
-0.0116211111,
0.0075230775,
0.0018088787,
-0.075984247,
-0.0345954224,
0.0016777519,
0.0235767607,
0.0374520943,
-0.0417108163,
0.0012114128,
0.0184500702,
0.0029431684,
0.0541542992,
-0.0055460674,
0.0248732343,
0.0220701043,
-0.0336153395,
0.0348662548,
0.0007076245,
-0.0377387255,
-0.0090525709,
-0.0368346497,
0.0256629512,
0.0119205453,
0.071367681,
0.0090095941,
-0.0476030596,
-0.0527962632,
0.0300720092,
-0.0735951886,
-0.0648194775,
0.0241151303,
0.0201457292,
0.0094380779,
0.0026254843,
0.0172970239,
-0.0502560213,
-0.0030231087,
0.0014126332,
0.0411734618,
0.0579313859,
-0.0137863997,
0.0220733974,
0.0310862958,
0.0106674368,
-0.0591334105,
0.0944088846,
0.0491076894,
-0.0135845309,
0.0400891416,
-0.0229094084,
-0.052423574,
0.0302782077,
-0.0391434766,
0.048482351,
-0.014832967,
-0.0083665354,
-0.060599111,
-0.0272276606,
0.0527918302,
0.0342980362,
-0.0007702048,
-0.0430573598,
0.0164134279,
0.0445021577,
0.0215904769,
-0.0331037492,
-0.0288773365,
0.0572694913,
-0.0342180245,
-0.0433000103,
-0.0505293682,
-6.328043147e-33,
-0.0289097745,
-0.0837470889,
0.0318908282,
-0.0530029386,
-0.0113882273,
-0.0039474489,
-0.0548364818,
0.0100873923,
0.0193189997,
0.0115092071,
-0.0209847614,
0.0177980773,
0.0040827459,
0.0158482492,
-0.0129959201,
-0.0177002866,
0.070032686,
0.0005767979,
-0.0251668859,
0.0274838768,
0.0102218809,
-0.0052710227,
-0.0154865496,
-0.0422228016,
0.0174132679,
0.0010393217,
0.0175655764,
-0.0240229685,
0.0186399464,
0.0394392088,
-0.0561617948,
0.0455803536,
0.04193433,
0.0119690718,
-0.0367604382,
0.0428004153,
-0.1081978232,
-0.0149295107,
0.0192085356,
-0.0030608964,
-0.0534384102,
-0.0449269079,
0.0106262555,
-0.0165419504,
0.0307583828,
-0.0063390466,
0.0359715484,
-0.0227755774,
-0.0711139217,
0.0083598085,
-0.0700068101,
0.0349089205,
-0.0120428652,
-0.0134798931,
0.0282424837,
0.0334401913,
0.0034236042,
0.0212100372,
-0.0413958505,
0.0092244493,
0.0237892605,
0.0073306309,
0.0476525538,
0.0249633286,
0.0268692914,
0.044093173,
0.0030366259,
0.045469813,
-0.0931238011,
-0.002261695,
-0.0039796145,
0.0555042438,
0.0264087822,
0.0074164318,
0.023209326,
-0.0022638743,
-0.052029334,
0.0489879511,
-0.0060864049,
0.0304010399,
0.0211085565,
0.0138168167,
-0.0677691102,
-0.0171869919,
-0.0507987849,
0.0059543154,
-0.0412325934,
-0.0002703748,
0.016424736,
-0.0312769525,
-0.0024880499,
-0.0488432758,
0.0278783515,
-0.0200493503,
0.0083286185,
0.0056528789,
-0.0036178578,
0.0546443053,
-0.0235044081,
0.0161913168,
-0.0247629397,
-0.0439009331,
0.0034138877,
0.0090383589,
0.0020119131,
0.0321401805,
0.0045653982,
-0.0020263109,
-0.0563754514,
-0.0063720634,
-0.0288578868,
-0.0094290236,
0.0042317375,
-0.0052463603,
0.0372232646,
0.0103452308,
-0.0141494768,
0.034280397,
-0.0013629569,
-0.0004228738,
-0.0030013239,
-0.0136222728,
-0.0058162455,
0.0145664606,
-0.0015955011,
-0.0271574333,
-0.0729251131,
-0.0118956612,
0.0486370772,
-0.0776971802,
0.0153897442,
0.0426366664,
2.844e-7,
0.0387261547,
0.0577487424,
0.0525219142,
0.0396116078,
0.0115852207,
0.0101342816,
0.0186821185,
-0.0073134932,
-0.0351788923,
-0.051911559,
0.0098896977,
0.0312922485,
0.0273502748,
0.0446683206,
-0.0675930455,
0.0205509607,
-0.024942264,
0.004614525,
-0.0854553133,
0.0189331044,
0.0774008185,
0.0413414985,
-0.0634641051,
0.0146844462,
0.0250728726,
-0.0124497134,
0.058840178,
-0.0304568782,
0.0211598035,
0.00999399,
0.0331284888,
0.018719364,
-0.0204763915,
0.0303838067,
-0.0029232721,
0.0006818362,
0.0172913112,
0.0343591124,
0.0248378962,
0.0278281011,
-0.011257072,
-0.0656515732,
0.0277973581,
-0.0515446886,
0.0738186166,
-0.046970278,
-0.0250378326,
0.0332902148,
-0.0047389856,
0.0216202419,
-0.0228207968,
0.016170375,
-0.0252317265,
0.0245514847,
0.0243616998,
-0.034552943,
0.0143220415,
-0.056723509,
-0.0153081901,
-0.0139705483,
-0.0162215419,
-0.0103743356,
-0.0674168468,
-0.0223326851,
0.0169140194,
-0.0635020211,
-0.0176340975,
2.681576973e-34,
0.0293936767,
-0.0024948728,
0.0296349209,
0.0380710922,
0.0514044762,
-0.0337034948,
0.0091966446,
0.0018318609,
0.0208488982,
-0.1227074862,
-0.0212651044
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06715v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06715v1 | Reframing Tax Law Entailment as Analogical Reasoning | 2024-01-12T17:37:07 | 2024-01-12T17:37:07 | Xinrui Zou, Ming Zhang, Nathaniel Weir, Benjamin Van Durme, Nils Holzenberger | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Statutory reasoning refers to the application of legislative provisions to a
series of case facts described in natural language. We re-frame statutory
reasoning as an analogy task, where each instance of the analogy task involves
a combination of two instances of statutory reasoning. This increases the
dataset size by two orders of magnitude, and introduces an element of
interpretability. We show that this task is roughly as difficult to Natural
Language Processing models as the original task. Finally, we come back to
statutory reasoning, solving it with a combination of a retrieval mechanism and
analogy models, and showing some progress on prior comparable work. | [
0.0286351144,
0.0449257903,
0.0069058957,
0.0818267837,
-0.0420653112,
0.048428379,
-0.0516150296,
0.0146753974,
-0.008932746,
-0.0482175499,
-0.0032039932,
0.0059741116,
0.005255545,
-0.04543126,
0.0087745367,
-0.0826576054,
-0.0059727947,
0.0186930057,
0.0533193946,
0.006079731,
0.007928554,
0.0606316663,
-0.0000299013,
0.024985984,
0.0204997677,
-0.0083231432,
0.0165089481,
0.0108177038,
0.037606582,
-0.0090459054,
-0.0195259284,
0.0131158428,
0.0377994515,
-0.002445326,
0.0000019009,
-0.0826584473,
0.0078481836,
-0.0184428319,
-0.0079717468,
0.0177244116,
0.0640725344,
-0.0191081092,
0.0182502773,
0.0045272443,
-0.0182841606,
0.0176316295,
0.0302389506,
-0.0390106887,
0.0357387029,
0.029828079,
-0.0106990431,
-0.0871110559,
0.0189104751,
-0.0191136673,
0.0356825963,
0.0198858641,
0.0242600571,
0.0109769711,
0.0172542967,
-0.0459566005,
0.0265961625,
-0.008949833,
0.0364754871,
0.0085236821,
-0.0554942079,
0.0112069119,
-0.0107124122,
0.0606896207,
0.0203089695,
0.0067652455,
0.0339452513,
-0.0481166355,
0.0168138854,
-0.0006878019,
0.0045582415,
0.070059225,
-0.0438406356,
0.0409898758,
-0.0391102321,
0.0287372228,
0.0934954211,
0.0525714941,
-0.0059871119,
0.0341608487,
-0.0422810726,
0.0108555555,
-0.0263259988,
-0.0186274759,
0.0023723438,
-0.0019585749,
-0.0314898118,
-0.0190647505,
0.0173280369,
0.0397385545,
0.0109870825,
0.0592098646,
-0.0307707731,
0.0007260905,
0.0553627945,
-0.0874237418,
0.0377931371,
0.051856,
-0.0462411679,
0.077641882,
-0.0596101992,
0.0159178022,
-0.0394098684,
0.0567010678,
-0.0330474488,
-0.0305569563,
-0.0579092018,
-0.0272621717,
-0.0705208778,
0.0457897037,
-0.0385627039,
0.0183006842,
0.0102074323,
-0.0221974533,
-0.055014547,
0.0116292238,
-0.0131284483,
-0.0063896501,
-0.0253307279,
-0.0715395585,
-0.0923599377,
-0.0496131629,
-0.0724571794,
0.0192292463,
-0.0237444304,
0.0003775182,
0.0164412074,
-0.0023169357,
0.0049769823,
-0.0367712341,
0.0046448386,
0.0470254868,
0.0157637242,
0.0403570421,
-0.0406479985,
-0.0315797664,
0.0121604241,
-0.0464609452,
0.0005073962,
-0.060627643,
0.0238705706,
-0.0233756565,
0.000723745,
-0.0474290252,
-0.0221971907,
0.0265894812,
-0.0401946381,
0.0856854841,
0.0276985858,
-0.0511300229,
-0.0784955546,
0.0105016483,
-0.0015119548,
-0.0054977648,
0.0194132719,
-0.0354351923,
-0.0115484903,
0.0107002314,
0.0112990085,
-0.0327799357,
0.0092072561,
0.0170171373,
-0.0648149922,
0.0441947021,
-0.0378499106,
0.0227720141,
0.0314337872,
0.0283289757,
0.0079689892,
-0.0530200489,
-0.03774295,
0.065136604,
0.00881714,
0.0479383916,
0.0204215031,
0.0145434672,
-0.0019083775,
0.033651717,
-0.0313235819,
0.0309082158,
-0.0157013386,
-0.0067685824,
-0.0472939089,
0.0039962824,
-0.0181649234,
-0.0606842786,
-0.0010854289,
0.0369629525,
-0.0136805093,
-0.0128626982,
0.0202977099,
0.0327724889,
-0.0069521363,
0.0394964814,
0.0337403491,
-0.0159203243,
-0.0162827354,
-0.012599716,
-0.020290656,
0.0484542549,
0.0304365866,
-0.0327196568,
-0.0084085101,
-0.0121297315,
0.0011839707,
0.0247184057,
0.0356811732,
-0.0150256399,
-0.0108522587,
-0.0430440865,
-0.0042069629,
-0.0294316243,
0.0388067141,
0.0516084544,
-0.0339795239,
-0.027739672,
0.0110167228,
-0.0418030024,
0.0698206052,
0.0309051294,
-0.019078346,
-0.0500208139,
-0.0205422845,
0.0269244276,
0.0213725138,
-0.0149148339,
0.0258528832,
0.0028206448,
0.0052063982,
-0.0395131931,
0.0003058709,
0.0506291166,
-0.0066820569,
-0.0231137518,
0.0252091847,
-0.0547280051,
0.0155965695,
0.0140811158,
-0.0511036627,
-0.0256091673,
0.0031548676,
-0.0297470298,
0.1130549088,
-0.016395472,
-0.0110808769,
-0.0052475552,
-0.036208801,
-0.0205730554,
0.0897951648,
0.0164604448,
0.0181588028,
0.0100643765,
-0.020386368,
0.0272969436,
-0.0101370979,
0.0334128104,
-0.0185168497,
-0.0260675475,
-0.0119361868,
0.0082596587,
-0.0351306684,
-0.0225033183,
-0.0036693187,
-0.0066151707,
0.0333402418,
-0.0018287878,
0.0162720177,
0.0018905952,
-0.0373244584,
-0.0025679616,
-0.0190552846,
-0.0183193758,
-0.0568139069,
-0.0527600311,
-0.0147358356,
0.0380991511,
-0.0290820412,
-0.0503531098,
-0.0105987769,
-0.021394223,
-0.0573825166,
0.0369232185,
0.0322010182,
-0.0050958586,
-0.0246109646,
0.0324200764,
-0.0393241756,
-0.0205550157,
-0.0152169513,
0.0249348674,
-0.003633589,
-0.0025564844,
-0.0192843787,
0.0485997945,
0.0169728808,
0.0069461735,
0.0285016913,
0.0073768147,
-0.0628063753,
-0.001998863,
-0.003170748,
0.0216241311,
-0.0185700953,
-0.0157409981,
0.0257906802,
0.0428331643,
-0.0007703601,
0.007260527,
-0.0743593946,
0.0852273032,
-0.0087313913,
0.0413808972,
-0.0422083177,
-0.0132098086,
-0.0056565087,
0.0526876785,
-0.0093546323,
-0.031379845,
0.038600985,
0.0294602681,
0.0330740884,
-0.0420334563,
0.0164583325,
-0.0447916128,
0.1337248236,
0.0150754321,
-0.0041927458,
0.028807601,
-0.0264466237,
0.0250141006,
-0.0259730108,
0.0798541978,
-0.0031952446,
0.1004012004,
-0.0334979407,
0.0629425496,
-0.0116001852,
-0.0475462079,
-0.0327638127,
-0.0198983643,
-0.0025594223,
0.0121195978,
-0.0284057241,
0.0256388355,
-0.0632612929,
-0.0026139703,
0.0070415498,
0.01434936,
0.0303349663,
-0.0418256111,
-0.0304924604,
0.02836808,
-0.0029540169,
0.0036047983,
-0.0204124078,
0.0304942988,
0.0038452384,
-0.016782172,
0.0355403349,
0.0434949286,
0.0024826613,
0.0247207284,
-0.0282026008,
-0.0552789718,
0.011619892,
0.0385790579,
-0.0339291319,
-0.081469126,
-0.0043731541,
0.0383084901,
0.0491357222,
0.0215806738,
0.0221036188,
-0.0136730419,
-0.0092575941,
0.0386893041,
0.0167075098,
-0.0946200565,
0.0033862307,
0.0308679715,
-0.0449855104,
-0.0120528229,
-0.0390827619,
-0.0004164487,
-0.0530718602,
0.095766224,
0.0206107032,
-0.030501131,
-0.0337393954,
-0.0232618432,
0.0342687704,
-0.0492075235,
-0.0611596778,
-0.0062077409,
-0.0512498058,
-0.0021265286,
0.0005977537,
0.0257769804,
0.0261280145,
0.0045838743,
-0.0196997263,
0.023016084,
0.0148330191,
0.0634659454,
0.0047170725,
-0.0076218066,
-0.0323002934,
-0.018452283,
-0.0140613616,
0.0069507095,
0.0098716682,
0.0370735787,
0.0023188086,
-0.0502137542,
0.0381367207,
-0.0194212534,
-0.0122210616,
0.0123301195,
0.0301494226,
-0.058510121,
-0.0232442562,
0.002854292,
-0.017537754,
-0.0587769412,
0.0708956644,
0.0400349088,
0.0608347356,
0.0101044495,
-0.0674015507,
-0.0084872935,
-0.0728272945,
-0.0107363621,
-0.0043059285,
-0.0004900582,
0.0278202537,
-0.0450143889,
-0.020589767,
-0.0336265042,
0.0312266983,
0.0006275513,
-0.0073321974,
0.0349540338,
-0.0165138263,
-0.0283290427,
0.0191248357,
-0.0992697328,
-0.0105099445,
0.0611078031,
-0.0220185444,
0.0139597608,
0.037566293,
-0.0662376732,
-0.0325932615,
-0.0140642272,
0.0200317558,
-0.0093021356,
-0.0090083638,
0.0230090898,
0.0358901583,
-0.0194984768,
0.0257585756,
0.0340828858,
0.0387726165,
-0.0128248641,
-0.0228746887,
0.043678768,
-0.0018954759,
0.0001117554,
0.0215954054,
-0.0141399028,
0.0075382311,
0.0141516859,
0.0283360817,
-0.0147304013,
0.0305556711,
0.0494431518,
0.0144194998,
-0.0158207472,
0.0524439551,
-0.0757640228,
0.0006149273,
-0.0072381627,
0.0028899694,
-0.0128125707,
-0.0234719794,
-0.0289737601,
0.0044747326,
0.0026763859,
-0.0626463071,
-0.0156817939,
-0.0067648045,
0.0491561927,
0.0047361134,
0.0343055278,
0.0124301547,
0.0509653129,
-0.0017498408,
-0.023498008,
-0.0321321636,
0.0572560467,
-0.0313366018,
0.0657517612,
-0.0225134119,
0.0310453773,
0.0506884679,
0.0188949145,
-0.0532609224,
-0.0225502569,
-0.0188341234,
-0.0453697443,
-0.0123463096,
0.0445183218,
0.0251527149,
-0.0343641192,
-0.0094020981,
-0.0173809975,
0.0184345003,
0.0375191383,
0.0002750196,
0.0280006882,
-0.0522785671,
0.0571382605,
0.011460497,
0.0142955566,
-0.0361526012,
0.0115164807,
-0.0941721126,
0.0600638315,
-0.0155327031,
-0.0149914604,
-0.0263208058,
-0.0593123175,
-0.0245552491,
0.0151849752,
0.004757375,
-0.0288175773,
-0.0575341508,
-0.009711259,
-0.0400358513,
0.0256069787,
-0.0266527049,
0.0063538714,
0.0130908238,
0.0264897738,
0.0118405214,
-0.0414668173,
0.0041153845,
0.0114401272,
-0.0849143565,
-0.0140964566,
-0.0283412356,
-5.477505393e-33,
-0.0386306196,
0.0058608605,
0.0313547254,
-0.0008624473,
0.035691034,
-0.0295847412,
-0.0486986078,
-0.0544006787,
-0.0082215788,
0.0211763903,
0.0176339727,
0.0101118768,
0.0184313972,
-0.0264367461,
0.0064803632,
-0.0462287478,
-0.0145880999,
0.025217982,
0.0017572631,
0.0013394938,
-0.0080465786,
-0.0325373337,
0.0158546288,
-0.0333813168,
0.0546923168,
0.0501828305,
0.0192969106,
-0.0242713615,
-0.044567842,
0.0653813332,
0.0041852426,
0.0158545114,
0.0222575068,
-0.0183808636,
0.004805353,
0.0582440645,
-0.0526060723,
-0.0578103103,
0.046783939,
-0.0500019751,
0.024078479,
-0.0277306754,
0.0520726144,
0.0327452682,
0.0039147227,
-0.0129190218,
0.0757431984,
-0.0594088882,
-0.0000432553,
-0.0132394759,
-0.0928129405,
0.0306837857,
-0.0241106935,
-0.0021885196,
-0.0041555548,
0.0913726166,
0.0118013714,
0.0982710049,
-0.0256598033,
-0.007640094,
-0.0441082343,
-0.0319763124,
0.018479947,
-0.0645657331,
0.0278112572,
0.0493063182,
0.009713144,
-0.0403027162,
-0.0578965992,
0.0227287263,
0.0449591987,
0.053028103,
0.0144991474,
0.0140037583,
0.0998653322,
0.0297393501,
-0.0396485217,
0.016502168,
0.0394652039,
0.0456847884,
0.0208721794,
0.0104288878,
-0.0413188897,
-0.0034682571,
-0.0344937071,
-0.0257591177,
-0.0163095593,
-0.0197554808,
0.032905139,
-0.0119191865,
0.0231513102,
0.044247482,
0.0021785609,
0.0005746531,
0.0080109723,
-0.0074454392,
0.0356719643,
-0.0064667268,
-0.0250059981,
0.0234592371,
-0.0538772307,
-0.0353485048,
0.0179928988,
0.0029407877,
0.0368350744,
0.0110134697,
0.0381340422,
-0.041407939,
-0.0611663274,
-0.0097742286,
-0.0289373659,
-0.0279487837,
-0.0191105772,
-0.0290061384,
0.0401930176,
0.0676299408,
0.0710906312,
0.0211336482,
-0.0035948341,
-0.076279901,
-0.0325347185,
0.0173461698,
-0.0638284907,
0.0125929108,
-0.0064590513,
0.0035901922,
-0.0118371481,
-0.0456171967,
0.0246515386,
-0.0274245664,
-0.0029064841,
0.0477756001,
2.495e-7,
0.0613926277,
0.0156135326,
0.0041353386,
-0.0257508252,
-0.0360708535,
0.0136485714,
-0.0039451676,
0.0143334484,
0.0135117201,
-0.0193906669,
0.02318082,
0.018274013,
0.0268821884,
0.0434183255,
-0.073378399,
0.0417403877,
-0.0750324875,
-0.0401136167,
-0.0343658887,
0.0427737758,
0.0726105869,
0.0511905812,
0.0435716361,
-0.0098073985,
-0.0045796758,
-0.059921518,
0.0386791006,
-0.0537728854,
-0.0052569979,
-0.0360230878,
0.0204529576,
-0.0246815793,
-0.0198196061,
0.0519873351,
0.0374622196,
0.0253198575,
-0.0359381549,
0.0337642133,
0.0013389649,
0.0536244176,
-0.0369653404,
-0.0381188095,
0.0080690859,
-0.0449636392,
0.0091033792,
-0.0680112168,
-0.0151970359,
0.0227597505,
-0.0089469701,
0.0378218032,
-0.01586877,
0.0577444099,
-0.0589066446,
-0.0250268783,
0.042846404,
-0.015833389,
0.0061893254,
-0.07274995,
0.0283493157,
0.0553673394,
0.0107092345,
0.0410102308,
-0.001856716,
0.0017796351,
0.0408258066,
-0.050000634,
-0.0181085151,
1.683318242e-34,
0.0030693326,
0.0174925979,
0.0268234909,
0.0073376079,
0.0633780882,
0.0295294113,
-0.0171353128,
0.0424976572,
-0.0033635604,
-0.074606277,
0.0183885843
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06712v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06712v3 | Few-Shot Detection of Machine-Generated Text using Style Representations | 2024-01-12T17:26:51 | 2024-05-08T15:50:40 | Rafael Rivera Soto, Kailin Koch, Aleem Khan, Barry Chen, Marcus Bishop, Nicholas Andrews | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | The advent of instruction-tuned language models that convincingly mimic human
writing poses a significant risk of abuse. However, such abuse may be
counteracted with the ability to detect whether a piece of text was composed by
a language model rather than a human author. Some previous approaches to this
problem have relied on supervised methods by training on corpora of confirmed
human- and machine- written documents. Unfortunately, model under-specification
poses an unavoidable challenge for neural network-based detectors, making them
brittle in the face of data shifts, such as the release of newer language
models producing still more fluent text than the models used to train the
detectors. Other approaches require access to the models that may have
generated a document in question, which is often impractical. In light of these
challenges, we pursue a fundamentally different approach not relying on samples
from language models of concern at training time. Instead, we propose to
leverage representations of writing style estimated from human-authored text.
Indeed, we find that features effective at distinguishing among human authors
are also effective at distinguishing human from machine authors, including
state-of-the-art large language models like Llama-2, ChatGPT, and GPT-4.
Furthermore, given a handful of examples composed by each of several specific
language models of interest, our approach affords the ability to predict which
model generated a given document. The code and data to reproduce our
experiments are available at
https://github.com/LLNL/LUAR/tree/main/fewshot_iclr2024. | [
0.0307516027,
0.0886330828,
-0.0121190269,
0.0698489547,
-0.0364294387,
0.0132006807,
0.0283304099,
0.0375117809,
0.0084090093,
-0.0523588397,
-0.0370725133,
-0.0181617755,
-0.0127470782,
0.0172864888,
0.0587615632,
0.0044076759,
-0.0161073636,
-0.0094717806,
0.0258942153,
0.0218940526,
0.0678513125,
0.0339388251,
0.0348572135,
0.0469805412,
-0.0001383804,
-0.0611096248,
0.0192508046,
0.0464428663,
0.0056050424,
0.0358994417,
0.0390972197,
0.0653277785,
0.0153426565,
0.0890112445,
0.0000018905,
-0.018999394,
-0.0009820457,
-0.0243756026,
-0.0075133261,
0.0173999909,
0.0712183863,
-0.0001379308,
-0.0518377647,
0.0104360934,
-0.0129515352,
-0.0094375685,
0.0262107216,
0.0504474007,
0.0328179523,
0.0918398201,
-0.035145469,
-0.0281092487,
0.0472316258,
0.0016606309,
0.0271288902,
0.0016162029,
0.0161680188,
-0.0545358956,
-0.0040508094,
0.0275824349,
0.0273264311,
0.023839226,
-0.0098446803,
-0.0328556746,
-0.0377132148,
0.0035471334,
-0.0444892347,
0.0391302705,
0.0018155237,
0.019581167,
-0.0310215186,
-0.0699153319,
0.0377452411,
-0.0048462553,
0.0135411425,
0.0228371657,
0.0164349303,
0.020824967,
-0.0563419163,
0.0012906718,
0.0224252958,
0.0076431003,
0.0185465384,
0.0428370535,
0.0201021731,
0.0229480825,
0.0127999829,
-0.0176776201,
-0.0334655009,
-0.0070027839,
0.0054602586,
-0.0464913398,
0.0334048271,
0.0118972585,
0.0249590036,
-0.0278471969,
-0.0959939063,
-0.0405392982,
0.0203270651,
-0.028651977,
0.0850375295,
-0.0057138633,
-0.0104003493,
0.0188452266,
-0.0687269866,
0.0651844963,
-0.0272746813,
0.0178493373,
-0.0076921056,
0.0139330626,
-0.0330648683,
-0.0249112137,
-0.024418667,
-0.0252376404,
0.0338933803,
-0.0031356015,
-0.0337828323,
0.0223158449,
0.0045755277,
0.0177574586,
-0.0465595499,
-0.017331738,
-0.0204553902,
-0.0060239439,
0.0347226188,
-0.0093397964,
0.0196355525,
0.0199014191,
-0.0065450319,
-0.0605503395,
-0.0285909493,
0.0786851123,
0.0372825526,
-0.0114288302,
0.0249958336,
0.0247309338,
-0.0200905986,
-0.0540439039,
-0.0402027145,
-0.0494491197,
-0.0162521508,
-0.0397275165,
0.0082866363,
-0.0734889805,
-0.03668667,
-0.0208840296,
-0.0093910052,
-0.056442868,
-0.0241222698,
0.0411119349,
-0.0099883219,
0.0479371734,
-0.0036514748,
-0.0117319925,
0.0547333993,
-0.0142273996,
-0.00407711,
0.0416603982,
0.0477653667,
0.0732604638,
0.0327752754,
-0.0014367362,
0.0586590543,
0.0797970071,
0.0021164692,
0.0066031655,
-0.0067620259,
-0.0511535443,
-0.010617204,
0.0094449464,
0.057730604,
0.0261715911,
0.0047235312,
-0.0238630362,
0.0971991196,
0.0484529324,
0.0171614829,
0.0142918508,
0.0652986988,
0.037697345,
0.0231350325,
0.0441947468,
-0.0021627438,
-0.0217119623,
-0.0512449369,
-0.0043036598,
-0.0056248419,
-0.0002718006,
-0.0152303623,
0.0085683856,
0.0040886598,
-0.0103028575,
-0.0225392357,
-0.0301801786,
0.0304012187,
0.0106047662,
-0.0128566138,
-0.0392596982,
-0.0101043843,
-0.0313025899,
-0.0237247627,
-0.0740835294,
0.028596472,
0.0651159436,
0.0545909144,
-0.0062454031,
0.0253323782,
-0.03614733,
0.0087549472,
0.0376524366,
0.0057178796,
-0.012091198,
0.0167854764,
-0.0290223919,
0.0113557996,
-0.0170879681,
0.0307267569,
0.0140274605,
0.0096938806,
0.006379596,
0.0235872194,
-0.021253705,
-0.0539572425,
0.0580033287,
-0.0347859003,
-0.0511518791,
0.0221291333,
0.0232265182,
0.0049276277,
0.0025912356,
-0.0419863388,
0.0098280022,
-0.0050165849,
-0.0731120929,
0.0048899665,
0.0047482615,
-0.0092074126,
-0.0446771011,
0.0022816753,
-0.0152998865,
-0.0259630345,
0.0226808582,
-0.0324920043,
-0.0321021006,
0.0023278499,
-0.0631329864,
-0.0119011421,
-0.0749860704,
0.0051310249,
-0.0243752748,
0.016101988,
-0.0279971715,
0.0449648835,
0.0075787283,
-0.0033263641,
0.0070675546,
-0.0130554866,
0.0383225642,
-0.0167817306,
-0.0287990794,
-0.0435219109,
-0.0096304333,
0.0299061295,
0.0094570769,
0.0326223485,
-0.0145669682,
-0.0390006676,
-0.0655385256,
-0.0061714537,
-0.035816472,
0.0299520064,
0.0308591537,
-0.0441218652,
-0.0166627169,
-0.0033414252,
-0.0403718762,
-0.0352238156,
0.0045125326,
0.0008195004,
0.0604603365,
-0.0322592892,
0.0087998044,
-0.0309417956,
-0.0042816056,
-0.0324095897,
0.0429128185,
0.0251599085,
-0.0308997966,
-0.0674559548,
0.017771408,
0.02534445,
-0.0112278974,
-0.0039199721,
-0.0423976406,
0.0000715331,
-0.0357770287,
0.0075514768,
0.0952165499,
0.008863464,
0.0050561116,
0.017930394,
0.0523501486,
0.0079102516,
-0.0303239636,
0.0262976959,
0.0258965921,
0.0135950251,
-0.0615801699,
0.0310125574,
0.0385493487,
0.0028139234,
0.0075195753,
-0.005938414,
0.0461111143,
0.0337894373,
-0.0174130388,
0.0291880667,
-0.0300780628,
-0.0227257013,
0.0115277963,
-0.0368878879,
-0.0531401597,
0.0500216447,
-0.0682364851,
-0.0024237048,
0.0056374846,
-0.041074574,
-0.0212076027,
0.0251059122,
0.0408476144,
0.0391196534,
0.0158535,
-0.0303502604,
-0.0455210619,
0.0189302266,
0.0570356622,
-0.0071846349,
0.0208687447,
-0.0079745222,
0.012050705,
-0.008145785,
-0.0249972399,
-0.0340440199,
-0.0786769018,
-0.0126338098,
0.0092030261,
0.0117119253,
-0.0352016911,
-0.0006090492,
-0.0085517429,
0.0064650709,
0.0966727808,
-0.0431893766,
-0.0158428345,
-0.0315597467,
0.0794373378,
0.0393586531,
-0.0445715971,
-0.0206396487,
-0.0387155451,
0.0091737024,
0.0323264264,
-0.00569849,
0.0459436774,
-0.036705792,
-0.0192442071,
0.0133884847,
-0.0072449236,
-0.0401744805,
0.0208825748,
0.0525303036,
-0.0505164713,
-0.0257325247,
0.1088136137,
0.0036650093,
-0.0657298639,
-0.0260773916,
-0.0016882374,
0.0359288603,
0.0081017707,
0.0283477921,
-0.0692669824,
-0.0507541373,
0.0159319025,
0.0126488153,
-0.0357579589,
0.0051720939,
-0.0155026391,
-0.0642812774,
0.0311677195,
0.0068725878,
-0.039549876,
-0.0050428468,
-0.0082941167,
-0.0102087669,
0.0029321096,
-0.0419602282,
-0.0244178399,
-0.0275349524,
-0.0048005772,
-0.0063086026,
-0.0125751374,
-0.0455328487,
-0.0161278676,
-0.0549252555,
0.0156583879,
0.079200469,
0.0535689518,
-0.0273774508,
-0.029900603,
-0.0010228765,
-0.022639716,
0.0156969391,
0.0149284052,
0.0680841133,
-0.0317589156,
-0.0039448263,
-0.0234748367,
0.0747437552,
-0.0016896481,
0.0174584556,
0.0130042471,
0.0135194473,
-0.0283633545,
-0.049558796,
-0.0156283565,
-0.0043622567,
0.0185490455,
0.0425144434,
0.0706883073,
-0.0461050607,
-0.071831502,
-0.0496344268,
0.0548842214,
-0.050321281,
-0.0476022363,
-0.0113037685,
0.0065177171,
-0.0243103579,
-0.0855364725,
-0.0219150148,
-0.041856017,
0.0029015755,
0.0071913893,
0.0178338736,
-0.0039992784,
-0.0333398357,
-0.0680958256,
-0.0141509818,
-0.0216774959,
0.0298527703,
-0.0492576323,
0.0015259772,
0.0275052395,
-0.0398654789,
-0.0030068427,
0.0244284235,
-0.1093989015,
-0.0444587618,
0.0121974293,
0.0283048656,
0.011364094,
0.0127195036,
-0.0288931988,
-0.0933160037,
0.0643251389,
0.0656514019,
0.0109610809,
0.0143598001,
0.0331552699,
-0.0437421165,
-0.0399535336,
0.0320629068,
-0.012057974,
0.0488993265,
0.0273026116,
-0.0676515326,
-0.0381743386,
0.0046025417,
0.0080921948,
0.0063149724,
0.0290933345,
-0.03208974,
0.010968213,
-0.0196598396,
-0.0197453275,
-0.0071975421,
-0.0153963473,
-0.0406950898,
-0.0106846038,
0.0055121188,
-0.0073609329,
-0.0200442318,
0.0063168127,
-0.0009741636,
0.0702570826,
-0.058443144,
0.0175550077,
0.0105698984,
0.0826334879,
-0.0326884314,
0.0140432389,
0.0024947396,
0.081971854,
-0.0030432246,
0.0378312878,
-0.010961242,
0.0565240495,
0.0104163112,
0.015464168,
0.0019574761,
0.0505979806,
-0.0865273625,
0.0135902483,
-0.0481429771,
0.0026060722,
0.0703877956,
-0.0344978012,
0.0595148243,
-0.0255880635,
-0.0017736944,
-0.0436121859,
0.0522319414,
0.0109523246,
-0.0236789752,
-0.0357869342,
0.0110337399,
-0.0296422951,
-0.0197714791,
0.0904602036,
0.0377075151,
0.0300390255,
0.0152167697,
-0.0414595082,
-0.0177340172,
-0.0238000676,
0.0510622971,
-0.0021168585,
0.0122728152,
-0.0211746972,
-0.030894924,
-0.0437077768,
0.0396057107,
-0.0172985215,
0.0147402175,
0.0026815594,
-0.0178408828,
0.0515364371,
-0.0127618043,
0.0021434333,
-0.048224099,
0.0133602265,
0.0035290134,
-0.0282079801,
-0.0131453518,
-5.470661812e-33,
-0.0067649549,
-0.0588676557,
-0.0344802998,
0.0221105684,
0.0191265568,
0.0106441583,
-0.0344278663,
-0.0356084071,
-0.013013511,
0.0211720914,
-0.0416788012,
0.0136560732,
-0.0005117402,
0.0149530666,
0.0072818696,
0.0215183087,
0.0496748984,
-0.0216495879,
-0.0441949405,
0.029667275,
0.0524652116,
0.0006370152,
0.0506459922,
-0.0486747473,
0.0032175621,
-0.060566593,
-0.0509391092,
-0.0185665097,
-0.042854432,
0.04342179,
-0.0148096979,
0.0287714526,
0.0347525813,
0.0041801315,
-0.0144716725,
0.0394247547,
-0.0225422885,
-0.015404718,
-0.0471549705,
-0.0005703712,
0.0326987132,
-0.0784153566,
0.06726408,
-0.0456636883,
-0.0105134444,
0.0190144144,
0.0695364848,
0.0059499526,
0.0097476142,
-0.0602375045,
-0.0599976219,
0.0399889536,
0.006553235,
-0.0077471267,
0.0359051079,
0.0419904515,
0.0109398458,
0.0053231916,
-0.0780393258,
0.006208532,
-0.0031326937,
0.0266254898,
0.0038535595,
0.0469882488,
-0.0260015111,
0.0542484447,
0.0077376231,
0.0377482362,
-0.0193451662,
0.0025172073,
0.0459303707,
0.0102507332,
0.0505559891,
0.0766240284,
0.0285338573,
-0.0111045269,
-0.0187745728,
0.0518999323,
0.0384357497,
-0.0107220942,
0.0281805173,
-0.0191156082,
-0.0515889116,
-0.0346691459,
-0.009697956,
-0.0939418972,
-0.0287705529,
-0.0040885336,
0.0115944454,
-0.0052970187,
0.0076197111,
-0.0233589355,
0.0228609424,
-0.0624134503,
-0.0162849277,
0.0048151929,
-0.0702133849,
0.0384358205,
0.016390333,
0.0126241129,
-0.0099447332,
-0.0215635896,
0.0380700491,
0.0245964397,
0.0408568904,
0.0139132114,
0.0923458859,
0.0381673388,
-0.053028062,
0.011569377,
-0.0129431458,
0.0071227821,
0.0170886107,
0.0193063654,
0.0162972547,
-0.034766186,
0.0133214835,
0.0083589964,
0.0359265022,
0.0058010188,
-0.0193308331,
-0.0259482842,
-0.0382464156,
0.0198448878,
-0.0300274715,
0.0088176569,
-0.011300086,
0.0126175443,
0.0078440243,
-0.0428785458,
0.0246211495,
-0.0371617042,
2.415e-7,
0.0271623209,
0.021199299,
0.0232565198,
0.0231621191,
0.0403595865,
0.0662870929,
-0.0018121374,
0.0416113809,
-0.0294653773,
0.0167990159,
0.0103856428,
-0.0021224273,
0.0882001072,
0.0038254466,
-0.0918377489,
0.0364138372,
-0.0767397732,
0.0393829718,
-0.0616961196,
-0.0027549611,
0.0721361116,
0.0623497143,
0.0084264958,
-0.0516076013,
0.0398829915,
-0.0710627735,
0.0608139969,
-0.0066894433,
0.0040802076,
-0.000357204,
0.0556980036,
-0.016137464,
-0.0056619081,
0.0007529101,
-0.022163406,
0.0028337527,
-0.0066483738,
0.0796417817,
-0.0038733936,
0.0476962142,
-0.0012652869,
0.0078706248,
0.0141148446,
-0.0511559322,
0.0748019889,
0.0350758471,
-0.0099774599,
-0.0543933921,
-0.014510124,
-0.0438136123,
0.0008918883,
-0.0279073752,
-0.0104889227,
0.0382120535,
0.0082579572,
-0.0327644944,
-0.0097218147,
-0.0511249229,
-0.043307811,
-0.0296879727,
-0.0183220431,
0.0203795619,
-0.0670777932,
-0.0070125819,
0.0484029837,
-0.0753591508,
0.0355520211,
2.570941373e-34,
0.0166360699,
-0.0005839975,
0.0066927779,
0.0401710272,
0.0115166446,
0.032607723,
0.0116599966,
0.0260574277,
-0.0028954574,
-0.0514813811,
0.0129015036
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06709v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06709v1 | Reliability Analysis of Psychological Concept Extraction and Classification in User-penned Text | 2024-01-12T17:19:14 | 2024-01-12T17:19:14 | Muskan Garg, MSVPJ Sathvik, Amrit Chadha, Shaina Raza, Sunghwan Sohn | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The social NLP research community witness a recent surge in the computational
advancements of mental health analysis to build responsible AI models for a
complex interplay between language use and self-perception. Such responsible AI
models aid in quantifying the psychological concepts from user-penned texts on
social media. On thinking beyond the low-level (classification) task, we
advance the existing binary classification dataset, towards a higher-level task
of reliability analysis through the lens of explanations, posing it as one of
the safety measures. We annotate the LoST dataset to capture nuanced textual
cues that suggest the presence of low self-esteem in the posts of Reddit users.
We further state that the NLP models developed for determining the presence of
low self-esteem, focus more on three types of textual cues: (i) Trigger: words
that triggers mental disturbance, (ii) LoST indicators: text indicators
emphasizing low self-esteem, and (iii) Consequences: words describing the
consequences of mental disturbance. We implement existing classifiers to
examine the attention mechanism in pre-trained language models (PLMs) for a
domain-specific psychology-grounded task. Our findings suggest the need of
shifting the focus of PLMs from Trigger and Consequences to a more
comprehensive explanation, emphasizing LoST indicators while determining low
self-esteem in Reddit posts. | [
0.0697550178,
0.0759565532,
-0.0235782862,
-0.0227866955,
-0.0215068385,
0.0249620844,
0.0302884281,
-0.0096701896,
0.0726397857,
-0.0494069122,
0.0069717923,
-0.0013601568,
-0.0186722726,
0.0238335468,
0.0189364273,
-0.0547897406,
0.0344247483,
0.0478596501,
0.0539189726,
-0.0091230199,
0.017707454,
0.0257442463,
0.0107316179,
0.0323181748,
-0.02547561,
-0.0575870499,
0.0467585512,
0.009606367,
0.0030544964,
-0.0637871549,
0.0355167948,
0.0879274532,
-0.0457050614,
0.0029622305,
0.000001952,
-0.0302414205,
-0.0009619169,
-0.025572598,
0.0120239835,
-0.0368545987,
0.0448904447,
-0.0041645369,
0.0267516654,
0.0249790307,
-0.0196091719,
-0.0324745737,
0.0435189269,
0.0600636825,
0.0786337703,
0.0355801545,
-0.0270812828,
-0.0092232283,
-0.0090696169,
0.0039292006,
0.0079470985,
-0.0038573509,
0.0524794757,
-0.0194059648,
-0.0286071431,
0.0151625639,
0.0241876002,
0.0235923454,
-0.0129987318,
0.005398252,
0.0228075702,
-0.0021089776,
-0.0006526474,
-0.066189073,
-0.0123681119,
0.0521059856,
0.0428377502,
-0.0203621555,
-0.0070329951,
0.0045052492,
0.0128599303,
-0.0064746579,
-0.0192400254,
-0.0020151616,
-0.0128542911,
0.0063323905,
0.0309330728,
0.0318675153,
0.0167538058,
0.0200776458,
0.0225292351,
0.0270349365,
-0.0254332479,
-0.0371940061,
0.0223443508,
0.0277825445,
-0.0325670987,
-0.0616624653,
0.0191682093,
0.006373927,
0.0317234769,
0.0426251329,
-0.0375677198,
-0.0803041384,
0.0361624025,
-0.0481513441,
-0.0067174933,
-0.0000975634,
-0.0627267659,
0.0308027323,
0.0548517294,
0.0349321663,
0.0333731584,
0.0200513713,
0.0194870718,
0.0113345804,
-0.0370469205,
-0.001683242,
-0.0218140595,
0.0137845417,
0.0763692036,
0.0090112407,
-0.041407425,
-0.0092583811,
-0.0673308745,
-0.0262318775,
-0.0238058306,
-0.0049114358,
-0.0004750012,
-0.0036047392,
-0.0115344636,
0.0082171252,
-0.0122218765,
-0.0141942427,
-0.0101097869,
-0.0582899377,
0.0150320726,
0.0027695089,
0.013837711,
-0.0458063819,
0.0097673452,
0.0115241893,
0.0581250452,
-0.0445988066,
-0.0571800023,
-0.0293235444,
-0.0443843044,
-0.0426620953,
-0.0423981585,
-0.0363641381,
0.0200490039,
0.0311493333,
-0.0104635973,
-0.0732426792,
0.0506172851,
0.0358218476,
-0.0795225948,
0.0575618409,
-0.0550112426,
0.025931716,
-0.0011457358,
0.0291115083,
-0.0054006646,
0.0471961983,
-0.0142537626,
0.0126064988,
0.0611830913,
-0.0456754565,
0.0160653535,
-0.0069095409,
0.0107978974,
-0.0337896608,
-0.0098508904,
0.0055443118,
-0.0533153526,
-0.0121361157,
0.0035899039,
0.0409541614,
0.0163239446,
0.0150692752,
0.0627062321,
0.0785774514,
-0.0121913655,
0.0789267495,
0.0010944994,
0.0335400738,
0.0180352293,
0.0091057587,
-0.0654857829,
0.003963626,
-0.0087101227,
-0.0394977741,
0.0278216116,
0.0008316006,
-0.0279553253,
-0.0592397973,
-0.0535271056,
-0.023632491,
0.00688795,
0.0014542113,
0.0392277353,
0.0118874628,
-0.011257587,
0.0140112806,
0.0458331965,
-0.0460147448,
-0.0134436889,
-0.0401948243,
-0.001175235,
0.054786887,
0.0121142631,
-0.0638062656,
0.0035500145,
-0.033370059,
0.0461453348,
0.0315135606,
0.0215207785,
0.0467380174,
-0.0114869084,
0.0124869635,
-0.0056398311,
0.0186873265,
0.0082264151,
-0.0336399749,
0.0208532307,
0.0070071495,
-0.0246400461,
0.0272411481,
-0.0963666216,
0.0636419803,
0.0651305765,
-0.0304796118,
0.0126205236,
0.0341547355,
0.0382638425,
0.025970269,
0.0173227023,
0.010390765,
0.0064406041,
0.0128732743,
-0.0479060411,
-0.0206536613,
-0.0139861647,
0.0066203815,
0.0231961906,
-0.0126237879,
-0.0235714689,
0.0526191108,
-0.0055631706,
-0.0081698652,
0.0713482723,
-0.0499643199,
0.0044363723,
-0.0128246685,
-0.0241133906,
-0.0325278454,
0.0276155807,
-0.0236533061,
0.0686801448,
-0.0369435251,
0.0456335545,
-0.0334438421,
-0.0856575221,
-0.0283064283,
-0.0053867567,
-0.0391129106,
-0.0621287711,
-0.0239381827,
0.0285567418,
0.0272264555,
-0.0032049438,
-0.0259107947,
-0.0177808963,
-0.0755697712,
-0.0166163482,
-0.0406495407,
0.0244461372,
0.0192812942,
-0.0326259509,
-0.0115586286,
-0.0195739083,
-0.0119925616,
0.0161319058,
0.0098173274,
0.0243204478,
0.033092469,
-0.0379998498,
0.046880994,
-0.0579975024,
-0.0248930939,
-0.0233260468,
0.0380308814,
0.0374821797,
-0.0317079984,
-0.0408703089,
0.0410995372,
-0.06161239,
0.0257494804,
0.0077790273,
-0.0721211508,
0.0181643795,
0.0328599624,
0.0073237233,
0.0415314026,
0.0516100079,
0.0878894106,
0.041415453,
0.0623534545,
-0.0249223206,
0.0036669422,
-0.0190289076,
-0.0187050086,
-0.0161697753,
-0.0347535983,
0.0221236181,
0.0690798536,
0.0425406434,
-0.0431537963,
-0.0581471398,
0.0055353981,
-0.0144022228,
-0.0100254342,
0.0190132186,
-0.0013462505,
0.0095435362,
0.037661165,
-0.0325192921,
-0.0427518412,
0.0667367429,
0.0246339086,
-0.0109193074,
0.0079150451,
-0.0403180793,
0.0153498529,
0.0453874543,
0.0120689925,
0.023212675,
0.0408636071,
-0.0154933929,
0.0175060108,
-0.00525857,
-0.0180517547,
-0.0145496726,
0.0000150217,
-0.0138094211,
-0.0013931429,
0.0525414646,
-0.0292243585,
-0.0646410882,
-0.0836785138,
-0.0478704609,
-0.0574716777,
-0.0302013438,
0.0241135079,
-0.0439539663,
-0.0220517889,
0.0291791707,
-0.0154901305,
-0.0399692357,
-0.047414355,
0.0156397317,
-0.0146138677,
0.0606346577,
-0.0296911094,
0.0648788437,
-0.0137421843,
0.0122449286,
0.0711423978,
-0.0457379185,
0.0338213444,
-0.0141963316,
-0.0412415862,
0.0177661926,
-0.0402849279,
-0.012460649,
-0.0102144778,
0.0292092208,
-0.0209627282,
-0.033833757,
0.0946531296,
0.0063278307,
-0.0399674065,
0.0208997745,
-0.0116676576,
0.0022241769,
0.0433788374,
0.0043638297,
-0.0399040282,
-0.0210118294,
-0.0416799858,
0.0455746315,
-0.0482826419,
-0.0266441759,
-0.0003007826,
-0.0449964032,
0.0322983898,
-0.0383004546,
-0.0133651337,
-0.0088879233,
-0.0452531278,
0.0253571924,
0.0078285867,
-0.0110276742,
-0.0082007013,
-0.0101624774,
0.0111766709,
0.0036922009,
-0.1010582373,
-0.0318982862,
0.0293253735,
-0.0024751339,
0.0399645828,
-0.0032563938,
0.0667547137,
0.0075605796,
-0.0268173553,
0.0039389217,
-0.0130249076,
-0.0052596997,
-0.0016887882,
0.1229909882,
-0.0348865576,
-0.0046125217,
-0.0679347962,
0.0434666835,
-0.0497489423,
0.0093589276,
-0.0013448379,
0.0640376434,
-0.0074249618,
-0.034039367,
-0.0176950749,
0.025469387,
0.0457704291,
0.0785254389,
0.057316076,
-0.0604255535,
-0.0418547206,
-0.0103619061,
0.0411005393,
-0.006881353,
-0.0398983434,
-0.0115274694,
0.0118252533,
-0.0096030626,
-0.0304181278,
-0.0679893345,
0.0211273879,
-0.0289263371,
-0.006142966,
-0.0445832908,
-0.0048105456,
0.0130604217,
-0.0564302951,
0.0376502648,
-0.003270936,
-0.0074067111,
-0.0068098535,
-0.0049055209,
-0.0061346022,
-0.0228900407,
0.0054967077,
0.0241556074,
-0.0247843824,
-0.0179621913,
0.0502778627,
0.0376585014,
0.0155237792,
-0.0330942012,
-0.0346360318,
-0.0850614309,
0.0240720492,
-0.0153794484,
-0.0512331091,
-0.0097140297,
0.037364766,
0.0097687468,
0.0112480735,
0.0459784754,
0.0014987245,
0.0406317189,
0.0345721394,
-0.0423790179,
-0.0320392661,
-0.0343993977,
-0.0189024583,
0.014590485,
0.0686985701,
-0.0076873321,
-0.0182673894,
-0.0174542964,
-0.0738700405,
-0.0039340234,
-0.0175440833,
-0.0206394382,
-0.0061041242,
0.0174777377,
0.0019627099,
-0.0482302941,
-0.0600997843,
-0.0522044636,
-0.0024906944,
-0.0572344884,
0.0104007255,
-0.0151304752,
0.0393318534,
-0.0125702042,
0.0162785649,
-0.0309945885,
-0.0177941341,
0.0035496482,
0.0152113847,
0.0116004283,
0.0453500189,
0.0031314676,
-0.0189784672,
0.051078245,
0.0134561751,
-0.0405106172,
-0.0195332933,
0.006315555,
-0.0238610022,
0.0216755364,
0.0079781506,
0.0864749402,
0.0218585916,
-0.0190517213,
-0.0115274079,
0.048822239,
-0.0166093539,
-0.0419343039,
-0.0104227494,
0.0084942738,
-0.0256785993,
0.0115403654,
0.046156276,
-0.0285317563,
-0.0174065754,
0.0298745744,
-0.0619013011,
-0.0086533641,
0.0273672976,
-0.0208887123,
0.0785106644,
-0.0042093582,
0.015655214,
-0.0675390959,
-0.083111763,
0.0498063713,
-0.0301967505,
0.0039002611,
-0.0175794326,
-0.0078850454,
0.0487507917,
0.021355113,
0.0209774319,
-0.0675391257,
0.0073912004,
-0.0302762818,
-0.0036720647,
-0.0391274616,
-5.912638504e-33,
0.0165273994,
-0.0903414488,
-0.0346595198,
0.0454173237,
-0.0051302267,
0.035424374,
-0.0319742709,
0.0168929081,
-0.0008336874,
0.0419515669,
0.021589363,
0.0580123737,
-0.026405463,
0.0422757566,
0.0329081826,
0.0063351607,
-0.0016203056,
-0.0141057326,
0.0011769176,
0.011692957,
0.0343051553,
0.0334518924,
0.0764301941,
-0.080934234,
0.0723999664,
0.0141956275,
0.0260862093,
0.0182117391,
0.0415508598,
0.0397790186,
-0.0263857283,
0.0929875895,
0.0435950384,
-0.0239838809,
0.0261611752,
0.0450269729,
-0.0749444291,
-0.0758779794,
-0.0055289157,
0.025646748,
-0.053340748,
-0.0142645715,
0.0351762809,
-0.0105404463,
0.0067671575,
-0.0571140647,
0.070256643,
0.0042373412,
0.0419113748,
-0.01183993,
-0.0200605914,
0.0094294101,
-0.0146229584,
-0.0037337653,
0.0100028962,
0.0654311925,
-0.0074285883,
0.0222594384,
-0.040230222,
-0.0011113415,
-0.0326706506,
-0.0104176532,
0.0413224138,
-0.0419035964,
-0.0081197722,
0.0798647627,
0.0239309128,
0.0265522879,
-0.0398705304,
-0.012589491,
0.0109757436,
0.012719878,
0.0692422092,
0.0025571014,
0.0366969854,
-0.0503152646,
-0.0620486625,
-0.0324686952,
-0.0055561289,
0.0151617788,
0.0432173647,
-0.0294827484,
-0.0432516485,
-0.0113719292,
-0.0116227074,
-0.0714563578,
-0.0392176323,
-0.0441945903,
-0.0132575026,
-0.037508063,
-0.0546646528,
0.0119586745,
-0.0253944844,
-0.02673213,
-0.0302058496,
0.005800813,
-0.0147777302,
0.0130042788,
0.0264055841,
0.0157116223,
-0.0189725365,
0.0414397456,
-0.0054812259,
0.0079918187,
0.0462568328,
0.0076119094,
0.0631722584,
-0.0022347949,
-0.0409063362,
-0.034658093,
-0.0075864238,
0.0280741341,
-0.0329269581,
0.0383365937,
0.0088022696,
0.0513749346,
-0.0132331084,
0.0417208858,
0.0616485737,
0.0297732875,
-0.0670664757,
0.0296753794,
-0.0161825996,
-0.0211422108,
-0.0173523948,
-0.0545714162,
-0.0158960987,
0.0108395061,
0.0145744979,
-0.0293176901,
0.0036770566,
-0.0261557102,
2.669e-7,
0.0512045659,
0.0716471449,
-0.0215140805,
-0.0024310132,
0.0384099968,
0.0243347343,
0.0550877489,
0.0286333729,
0.0323083103,
-0.0126972646,
-0.0086804722,
0.036440257,
0.0428327806,
0.0331400111,
-0.0019961272,
-0.0111891953,
-0.0289812125,
-0.0031095508,
-0.033319626,
-0.0065587563,
0.0892723054,
0.0479567237,
0.0385783724,
-0.0211122651,
-0.046640534,
0.0000092192,
0.0294496734,
-0.0087893931,
0.0265217498,
0.0161546543,
0.0742071941,
-0.0000616866,
0.0137400692,
0.0005180649,
0.0037836584,
-0.0217226483,
0.0357646272,
0.0391725525,
-0.0514716096,
-0.0191446263,
0.0100777131,
0.0504386239,
0.0109921498,
-0.0594764426,
0.0504038408,
-0.0882298276,
-0.0408599414,
-0.0691747963,
-0.0313853957,
-0.0282994565,
0.0513112284,
0.0152400006,
-0.0107376557,
0.0398455784,
0.0059008929,
-0.0264356881,
-0.0082759205,
-0.0703959242,
-0.0442654043,
0.0219516736,
-0.0014014787,
0.0155382017,
-0.0315227397,
0.008649461,
-0.0024068949,
-0.0467341505,
0.0444949977,
2.222984255e-34,
-0.0174243134,
0.0091289105,
0.0010409573,
-0.0272613298,
0.0541975461,
0.0185774378,
-0.0295817759,
0.0141750947,
-0.0046125855,
-0.052052334,
0.0041074576
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06706v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06706v1 | Multi-Candidate Speculative Decoding | 2024-01-12T17:15:23 | 2024-01-12T17:15:23 | Sen Yang, Shujian Huang, Xinyu Dai, Jiajun Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models have shown impressive capabilities across a variety of
NLP tasks, yet their generating text autoregressively is time-consuming. One
way to speed them up is speculative decoding, which generates candidate
segments (a sequence of tokens) from a fast draft model that is then verified
in parallel by the target model. However, the acceptance rate of candidate
tokens receives limitations from several factors, such as the model, the
dataset, and the decoding setup. This paper proposes sampling multiple
candidates from a draft model and then organising them in batches for
verification. We design algorithms for efficient multi-candidate verification
while maintaining the distribution of the target model. Our approach shows
significant improvements in acceptance rates on multiple datasets and models,
consistently outperforming standard speculative decoding. | [
0.0317533799,
0.1064750925,
0.0087903738,
0.0069309915,
-0.0396150835,
0.0034365417,
-0.0315756314,
0.0257475358,
-0.0373606905,
-0.0285898168,
0.0148254475,
-0.0976346955,
0.0106213186,
0.0209120605,
0.0007798204,
-0.0272635818,
0.0161771141,
-0.0448290221,
0.0511561967,
-0.0109420968,
-0.0160295311,
0.0436854661,
0.0011512146,
0.0532837547,
-0.0138403326,
-0.010243495,
-0.0207384638,
0.0034227611,
-0.0364498831,
-0.0592857115,
0.0037880985,
0.0931286067,
-0.0039068703,
0.01887317,
0.0000018306,
0.0037861795,
-0.0568613075,
0.0234014727,
-0.0630391985,
0.0226334091,
0.0638517365,
-0.0411466584,
-0.0118615292,
0.0329655744,
-0.0283443294,
-0.0570541508,
0.0338415168,
0.0264470931,
0.029335117,
0.0561169423,
-0.0039248751,
-0.0127308741,
0.0342988409,
0.0197100788,
-0.0610215813,
-0.037809588,
0.0324339867,
-0.0198957473,
0.004381198,
0.0150891198,
0.0105933174,
0.0191895925,
0.0370902009,
0.0388355851,
-0.0172243714,
0.0241895728,
0.0086166179,
-0.0289053638,
-0.0392297134,
0.0368227474,
-0.0192689206,
-0.0767890438,
-0.0258122124,
0.007344618,
-0.0481646843,
-0.0011347446,
-0.0303241052,
0.0529943854,
-0.0455327891,
0.0306875296,
0.0748223811,
0.0098043624,
0.0437254719,
0.0028539388,
-0.0445888788,
0.0830080956,
0.028119985,
-0.0522333421,
-0.0166463964,
0.0213848669,
-0.0068920199,
-0.056954585,
0.015181263,
-0.0129876677,
-0.0805154145,
0.0068108006,
-0.051408805,
-0.0367028639,
0.0270598736,
-0.016992541,
0.0350192003,
0.019955337,
0.0127883106,
0.0094212964,
-0.0196637996,
-0.004201055,
-0.0183712207,
0.0012716816,
-0.0263099037,
-0.0165256876,
-0.0383367166,
0.0130607663,
-0.0802362263,
0.018488761,
-0.0296142269,
-0.0238991026,
-0.0069772308,
0.0073025706,
-0.0110357814,
0.0277244058,
0.0498034954,
-0.018131664,
-0.0104011567,
0.0047711004,
0.0311694983,
-0.0095841736,
-0.0272988025,
-0.0191574804,
-0.0060773552,
-0.0692091435,
-0.0217111334,
0.0192636773,
0.0122189224,
-0.0207772274,
-0.026337238,
0.0479730517,
-0.0043338798,
-0.0273977183,
-0.0293679703,
-0.030563524,
-0.0000610172,
-0.0524188764,
-0.0237304978,
-0.0606299005,
0.032572642,
0.007451992,
0.0261146054,
-0.0101723671,
-0.0295659583,
0.0082745655,
0.0032845919,
0.059070684,
-0.0112100737,
0.0157570168,
0.0032784373,
-0.0054638372,
-0.0002964953,
0.102704227,
0.0095011033,
0.0224703643,
0.0480599403,
0.0083056828,
0.0209161118,
0.068928428,
0.0238127373,
0.0161162242,
0.0036192932,
0.0006017833,
0.0460686013,
-0.0242563169,
-0.0056351605,
0.0670495108,
-0.0661228001,
-0.0190335419,
0.0072845677,
0.0472598672,
0.0001090507,
-0.0290273447,
0.0536418483,
0.0285744742,
0.0223692525,
0.0100024277,
-0.0302469581,
-0.0292729121,
-0.0169698969,
0.0064694742,
0.0165562835,
0.0427310467,
-0.0055449549,
0.0136489123,
-0.0393787511,
-0.0000615863,
0.0174204148,
0.0001845021,
0.0701562539,
0.0084580015,
-0.0628275648,
0.0583450012,
0.0085856253,
-0.0302547812,
-0.0109066162,
-0.0157357864,
0.0160153545,
0.0652265921,
0.0696959347,
0.0352682658,
0.0111498153,
-0.0088251764,
-0.0439913683,
0.038610924,
0.052219782,
-0.047689829,
0.0150581719,
-0.0334038325,
-0.0214525126,
0.0725242868,
0.0438270718,
0.0352836661,
0.081559442,
-0.009416922,
-0.0203394014,
-0.0289805532,
-0.025737958,
0.0399689116,
-0.0118055167,
-0.0235594902,
0.0201281458,
0.0077133211,
0.0590291321,
0.0141359856,
-0.0195788909,
0.0049369284,
0.0347313285,
-0.0218630638,
-0.0007392331,
-0.0013357623,
-0.0052259825,
-0.0175640378,
0.0262650326,
0.0047869952,
-0.0520727485,
0.034231741,
-0.0081935665,
-0.0338511765,
-0.004373475,
0.0074596913,
0.0350163467,
-0.0443100743,
0.0299458876,
0.002793056,
0.0235298146,
0.0105389515,
0.0338990502,
-0.0165093113,
0.0062211184,
0.0235670507,
-0.0267979894,
0.0164319873,
-0.0568793938,
-0.0321391486,
0.0385765098,
-0.0467754081,
0.0183460359,
-0.0031727608,
0.0091514075,
-0.0146140633,
-0.0103283022,
-0.1023390666,
-0.0048760255,
-0.0343244299,
0.0134420162,
-0.0054112761,
-0.0159570687,
-0.0027241204,
0.0191521961,
-0.0084486399,
-0.0398537219,
0.0139666796,
0.0273190197,
-0.0076464196,
-0.000613616,
-0.0497356653,
0.0052726627,
-0.0205983017,
-0.0009108582,
0.0821748599,
-0.02846618,
-0.0168200284,
-0.0685666651,
-0.0203869697,
0.0538647696,
0.0044232314,
0.0370914042,
-0.0091292486,
0.0245122612,
-0.0261661131,
0.0007367451,
-0.0127644083,
0.0006522064,
0.0194572043,
0.0102232816,
0.0086794337,
-0.0464810207,
-0.0194140822,
-0.0063200938,
0.026297396,
-0.0270621497,
-0.0633243844,
0.0274971873,
0.0517973974,
0.0287046377,
-0.0085955849,
-0.0703968927,
-0.0108360117,
-0.0397342443,
-0.0363776162,
-0.0204393733,
-0.027173169,
0.0217497554,
0.0567214079,
-0.0339473225,
-0.0315036736,
0.0699786767,
-0.0839587972,
0.0006947302,
-0.0186407473,
-0.006729987,
-0.0037498847,
0.0360097252,
-0.0215952173,
0.0063212672,
0.0336564332,
-0.026695475,
0.0367352329,
0.0034930892,
0.0082574347,
-0.0268219355,
0.0334413126,
-0.0247589927,
0.0441003591,
-0.0085251546,
-0.0383370966,
-0.048707094,
-0.0634249598,
-0.025113184,
0.0229651034,
0.0486318469,
-0.045273196,
-0.0301742461,
0.0368069224,
-0.0660872012,
0.0239674561,
-0.0155406976,
0.0120709073,
-0.0051033706,
0.0104217278,
0.0396756269,
-0.023970224,
0.0178272333,
-0.0676352605,
0.0227599926,
0.0675899312,
0.0647988692,
0.0392527655,
-0.0673985258,
0.0000364888,
0.0365057737,
-0.0331921093,
0.0580302216,
0.0224625077,
0.0289995801,
-0.0398667194,
-0.0266148001,
0.1065428779,
0.0202757195,
-0.0374632031,
0.0084557906,
0.0476046577,
0.0590090677,
-0.0305147376,
0.0178520884,
-0.0864324048,
-0.0184865911,
0.0578268357,
0.0226746667,
-0.0071257651,
-0.0242809337,
-0.025799349,
-0.098448433,
0.0749689266,
0.0053093978,
-0.0338670984,
0.0260324199,
-0.0468871035,
-0.0479899794,
0.0025285003,
0.0262290891,
0.0327865221,
0.0395190679,
-0.0134160332,
0.018849466,
0.0050441185,
-0.0513726585,
0.044699654,
-0.0238328855,
0.0524723195,
0.0252961479,
-0.0248457808,
0.0304060839,
-0.0057402905,
0.005183971,
-0.0242907982,
-0.0393651426,
-0.0183594842,
0.0056877942,
-0.0331101716,
0.0217523705,
0.0448854677,
0.0199285727,
-0.0763079673,
-0.0325042829,
-0.0003159166,
0.0680193081,
0.0085300244,
-0.0343304873,
-0.0177531857,
-0.0178897418,
0.0402654111,
0.0785932988,
0.0018923754,
-0.0225771349,
-0.0181968808,
-0.0580194294,
-0.017498048,
-0.0981633216,
0.0091475956,
0.0141317425,
0.0158923138,
-0.0014083051,
-0.0658412054,
0.0006054541,
0.056997668,
0.0740912929,
0.0001170336,
0.0098287845,
0.0281315725,
-0.0326285884,
-0.0500771925,
0.0153023181,
-0.0374262817,
0.0035139415,
-0.0710773468,
-0.0125945136,
0.0128733478,
-0.0227948874,
-0.0268497467,
0.0212821495,
-0.0896358415,
-0.0475336127,
0.0011529673,
0.0154675618,
0.0275526401,
0.0429575443,
-0.0654567257,
-0.0341556706,
0.0291346647,
0.0120354444,
-0.0638342127,
-0.0181092471,
0.0029058799,
-0.0269638542,
-0.0087986393,
0.0070608319,
-0.0188483037,
0.0103228306,
-0.0155920098,
0.0345657468,
0.0078556975,
-0.0224545579,
0.0437880121,
0.0483907387,
0.0356097333,
-0.0306785032,
-0.027667582,
-0.0220737755,
0.0178999249,
0.0115975728,
-0.0246432051,
-0.0080941254,
0.052739352,
0.0289265011,
-0.0783443227,
-0.0059797456,
-0.0308021158,
0.0221455637,
0.0429767631,
0.0094173979,
-0.0440711379,
-0.0033668336,
0.0260253884,
0.0384550393,
-0.0365709625,
-0.0060092947,
0.0065394547,
-0.0251913443,
0.0130271381,
-0.0230638869,
-0.0430639833,
0.0278031006,
0.0209397748,
-0.0225175284,
-0.0061334516,
-0.0660474524,
-0.0002631434,
-0.0589267351,
0.0016672555,
0.0479526669,
0.0217465423,
0.0357711092,
-0.0315167792,
0.0149680367,
-0.0312989801,
0.010582854,
0.0177571531,
-0.0266206097,
0.0337670967,
0.0237514935,
-0.033097811,
-0.0108238561,
0.069942601,
0.0268708766,
0.046390906,
0.0310849007,
-0.0172512066,
-0.0517815873,
-0.0492541455,
-0.0505939275,
0.0246502776,
-0.0492762253,
-0.0025544886,
-0.011608148,
-0.0469528325,
0.0367446467,
0.0396478996,
0.0317151286,
0.040291708,
-0.0050427644,
0.0741019845,
0.0256418213,
-0.0024450663,
-0.0315765813,
-0.0274764895,
0.0484171584,
-0.0327237099,
-0.0150300171,
-6.553911448e-33,
0.0112601658,
-0.0231670905,
0.0075619505,
-0.1021998525,
0.0152602512,
-0.001761766,
-0.0079021556,
-0.0351383835,
0.0196109805,
0.017990496,
-0.0398988687,
0.01801778,
0.0394482948,
0.0358156711,
0.009027415,
0.0206805728,
0.0751653835,
-0.0211596545,
-0.0355374478,
-0.0126361931,
0.0530305505,
0.0247240197,
0.0097191203,
0.0074676038,
0.0423461683,
-0.0146401934,
-0.0322477371,
-0.00627656,
-0.0255888142,
0.0757523775,
-0.0383191667,
0.0098667555,
0.0386879779,
-0.0190232657,
-0.021338284,
0.0040999749,
-0.0971444249,
0.0297571737,
0.0156205753,
0.0327147022,
-0.0046712281,
-0.0012223644,
-0.0187834185,
-0.0245310199,
0.0046080356,
0.0255444795,
-0.0294590145,
-0.0228343122,
-0.0243654326,
-0.0501864813,
-0.0097634103,
0.0421036854,
0.0090730889,
0.0240294691,
0.0787898749,
0.0551898852,
-0.0086017773,
0.012568173,
-0.0524652526,
0.0199558027,
-0.0266603623,
0.0423228368,
0.0460319184,
-0.0284062531,
-0.0237645395,
0.041684106,
-0.006718751,
-0.0510578416,
-0.0362417661,
-0.0145431422,
0.033756502,
0.0216974299,
0.0003607084,
0.0444648676,
0.0809786096,
-0.0222816411,
-0.0268677548,
0.035440322,
0.0243489668,
-0.004911596,
0.0642134696,
0.0061021303,
-0.0400945954,
-0.0368568972,
-0.064093262,
-0.0431605615,
-0.0567749478,
-0.0184789766,
0.0451822728,
0.0438583978,
-0.0425282381,
-0.0035233907,
0.073599562,
-0.0541643463,
-0.0538746901,
0.0316732526,
0.0013639352,
0.0268035941,
-0.0275338944,
0.0326784365,
0.0207110886,
-0.0182759538,
0.0443365425,
-0.0148844291,
-0.0200267117,
0.0118882982,
-0.0003371792,
-0.0022296689,
-0.0649174824,
0.0117758755,
-0.0248671789,
0.0414013155,
0.0060411673,
0.0409258306,
0.0661928579,
0.0093917213,
0.0258493423,
0.0407975689,
-0.0077786562,
0.0216367207,
-0.0259408727,
0.0531024858,
0.004191299,
0.0482257903,
0.0231187753,
0.0114381891,
-0.0404255576,
-0.0247061439,
0.0226276182,
-0.0286505911,
0.0091406731,
0.0638080686,
2.41e-7,
-0.004776733,
0.0568101183,
0.0575107448,
0.0084320074,
-0.0005773364,
0.0134920301,
-0.0242789518,
-0.0038545006,
-0.0218895357,
-0.0266272239,
-0.0224916451,
0.0441021025,
0.0749975517,
0.0526557527,
-0.0870468989,
-0.0328362696,
-0.0233996063,
0.0251951572,
-0.0521004088,
-0.0343718454,
0.0202161502,
0.1076218784,
-0.0003653174,
-0.0060575311,
0.0046060872,
-0.0084556844,
0.0096938545,
0.0066674836,
-0.0428083204,
0.0466537811,
0.0012421238,
-0.0229496229,
0.0384007357,
0.0065609976,
-0.0170308724,
-0.0233420637,
-0.0348007493,
0.0630784482,
0.016695518,
-0.0160622802,
0.0075243386,
-0.0264068283,
-0.0262086038,
-0.0254784133,
0.0414913706,
-0.0084954686,
-0.0141899362,
-0.0564172156,
-0.0287696701,
-0.0198132303,
-0.0191463381,
0.001257122,
0.0073941485,
0.0627325922,
0.0233626366,
0.0098166345,
-0.0103685018,
-0.0715161338,
-0.0125157656,
-0.0374826305,
-0.0486731753,
-0.0163596608,
0.0191367995,
-0.0167696364,
0.0442775413,
-0.0945837125,
0.013791861,
2.587464186e-34,
0.0804652423,
0.0326265842,
-0.0041704006,
0.0784794167,
0.0306655504,
-0.0295136962,
0.0122229271,
0.0236750245,
-0.02166963,
-0.0560883321,
-0.0137276193
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06692v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06692v2 | An Experimental Design Framework for Label-Efficient Supervised Finetuning of Large Language Models | 2024-01-12T16:56:54 | 2024-05-06T21:58:04 | Gantavya Bhatt, Yifang Chen, Arnav M. Das, Jifan Zhang, Sang T. Truong, Stephen Mussmann, Yinglun Zhu, Jeffrey Bilmes, Simon S. Du, Kevin Jamieson, Jordan T. Ash, Robert D. Nowak | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Supervised finetuning (SFT) on instruction datasets has played a crucial role
in achieving the remarkable zero-shot generalization capabilities observed in
modern large language models (LLMs). However, the annotation efforts required
to produce high quality responses for instructions are becoming prohibitively
expensive, especially as the number of tasks spanned by instruction datasets
continues to increase. Active learning is effective in identifying useful
subsets of samples to annotate from an unlabeled pool, but its high
computational cost remains a barrier to its widespread applicability in the
context of LLMs. To mitigate the annotation cost of SFT and circumvent the
computational bottlenecks of active learning, we propose using experimental
design. Experimental design techniques select the most informative samples to
label, and typically maximize some notion of uncertainty and/or diversity. In
our work, we implement a framework that evaluates several existing and novel
experimental design techniques and find that these methods consistently yield
significant gains in label efficiency with little computational overhead. On
generative tasks, our methods achieve the same generalization performance with
only $50\%$ of annotation cost required by random sampling. | [
0.0175956246,
0.0435660258,
-0.0251247194,
0.0194157679,
-0.0312453359,
0.0324654579,
0.034369193,
-0.0037940566,
-0.016947113,
-0.0518650003,
-0.0098713413,
-0.0203925483,
-0.0191556625,
-0.0126967831,
0.0577637926,
-0.020027902,
0.0104324687,
-0.0660629794,
0.0070984857,
-0.0195393395,
0.0076770671,
0.0080193775,
-0.0042231665,
0.0395385399,
0.0014883735,
0.0059125852,
-0.0172332264,
0.0195112005,
-0.00091761,
-0.0013780738,
0.0079998178,
0.0819576308,
0.0042888224,
0.0446737334,
0.0000018395,
-0.0282069314,
-0.0178691857,
0.0286152679,
-0.0321028754,
0.032704968,
0.0244589094,
0.0065929773,
0.0010517113,
0.001617767,
0.0049034599,
-0.0390121825,
0.0908018574,
-0.0085604303,
0.028998835,
0.0461536795,
-0.0007632698,
-0.0287633911,
0.001471149,
-0.0416282378,
0.0165064074,
-0.055581335,
0.0250642337,
-0.0122180069,
0.0258767549,
0.0052842172,
-0.0278991349,
0.0548572578,
0.0069284248,
-0.0223254915,
-0.0112359412,
0.0328057446,
-0.0382037647,
-0.0298518278,
0.0198188126,
0.0694418699,
-0.03122635,
-0.0023493224,
-0.0001894734,
-0.0416300744,
0.0127577251,
0.0169090964,
-0.0420374088,
0.0298014339,
-0.0014972369,
0.0359702222,
0.0290104952,
-0.0434063151,
0.0349796638,
0.008700476,
0.0038217697,
0.051340431,
0.0266317241,
-0.0172828343,
0.0067850323,
0.0425642841,
-0.0589044727,
-0.0428615697,
-0.0373945534,
0.0224447139,
-0.0703295022,
0.0100238509,
-0.0290787891,
-0.0575403348,
0.0258264709,
0.0225462578,
0.1013796702,
0.025105454,
-0.0116247516,
0.0317915455,
-0.0307368003,
0.0422516987,
-0.001366528,
0.0581962392,
-0.0706250221,
0.0064363992,
-0.0480383001,
0.0207421724,
-0.0403355993,
0.0505189635,
-0.0035428326,
0.0247891136,
-0.0334053859,
0.0195608325,
-0.010710489,
-0.0014658081,
-0.001891096,
-0.0326082185,
-0.08608298,
0.0146283265,
0.026193006,
-0.0028999329,
-0.058198832,
0.0189112201,
0.0023647549,
-0.0600054711,
-0.0192132834,
0.0247755032,
-0.0034058648,
-0.0592230745,
0.0099462979,
0.0576432198,
-0.022645805,
-0.0620393641,
-0.0428052396,
0.0052374434,
-0.0207265653,
-0.0469802059,
0.0179999303,
-0.0708022863,
0.024538612,
0.0057903235,
0.0359147266,
-0.0270479433,
0.0036968333,
-0.0241599921,
-0.0386332013,
0.0453007929,
-0.0055305595,
0.0106662596,
-0.0142242583,
-0.0328661017,
0.0205479097,
0.105147548,
0.0166285802,
0.0264335182,
0.015998723,
0.0015899312,
0.0055723903,
0.0595096126,
0.0234697461,
0.0221059285,
-0.0132867564,
-0.0226060748,
0.0219687447,
0.0126669258,
0.0057760095,
0.0268833581,
-0.0253889617,
0.004872344,
0.0325376429,
0.0101533672,
-0.0227316935,
-0.0354454555,
0.0683224425,
0.0092806853,
0.0001416989,
0.0282756332,
-0.0271685552,
0.0151100149,
-0.0147965699,
0.0211832076,
0.0315544717,
0.0142410276,
-0.0695741549,
-0.0310918279,
-0.0096300906,
-0.0125951832,
-0.0100601222,
0.0470696352,
0.0577613115,
0.0424498096,
-0.0203168765,
-0.0132132443,
0.0593423322,
-0.0171557702,
0.0001874066,
-0.0732813329,
0.0265869442,
0.0429120101,
0.0312078688,
-0.0430545062,
-0.0393074825,
-0.0020568392,
0.0638627484,
0.02025933,
0.0498207062,
-0.0343794785,
0.0404160954,
-0.0375020616,
-0.0262327138,
-0.007793624,
0.0376449116,
0.0104670562,
0.0349683538,
-0.0327150822,
0.0049628192,
-0.0656301156,
-0.0293878689,
0.0561664812,
-0.0180430673,
-0.0699655935,
0.0215380434,
0.0001203088,
0.0313905962,
-0.0349155031,
-0.0338072926,
0.0047396584,
0.0139381718,
-0.0342021547,
0.0215345416,
-0.0525030755,
0.0232049488,
-0.0368222818,
0.0198055916,
-0.047053244,
-0.050887052,
0.0131475218,
-0.0907018781,
-0.0621213354,
-0.0448078401,
-0.0276604909,
-0.0251841843,
-0.0506887771,
0.016367849,
-0.0299693346,
0.001050713,
-0.0923630148,
0.0170938112,
-0.0026431659,
0.031200286,
0.0374915637,
-0.0032097569,
-0.0061621112,
-0.0516115762,
-0.0708239004,
0.0135711357,
0.0068716733,
0.0116036171,
-0.0035791106,
0.0257066861,
-0.0365795232,
-0.0369274132,
-0.0521866754,
0.0310062803,
-0.0360546336,
0.0067380629,
0.0080356412,
0.0024861812,
0.0040112324,
-0.0003149739,
-0.0150479078,
0.0009449197,
-0.0265264586,
0.0604758747,
0.0067612324,
0.0275359992,
-0.0369357616,
-0.0565783121,
-0.064533785,
0.0123402597,
0.0320805423,
-0.0096400175,
0.0330676064,
-0.0792341381,
0.0036731348,
-0.0046042083,
0.0248049106,
0.0165761039,
-0.0290303845,
0.0208699368,
-0.0352547392,
0.0066657774,
0.0561282299,
-0.0212955829,
0.013717874,
0.0457394756,
-0.0043261098,
-0.0242290068,
0.0178182535,
-0.0600773171,
-0.0679027513,
-0.0252645425,
-0.0333308391,
-0.0317778103,
0.0865023211,
-0.0277149435,
-0.0265327059,
-0.0629809797,
0.0054137777,
-0.0222772844,
-0.0232867692,
-0.0334831849,
0.0437128842,
-0.0288760178,
0.020536501,
-0.0349186994,
-0.0577126108,
0.0765337124,
-0.0161057469,
0.0034330718,
-0.0048724976,
0.0218917634,
0.0080926893,
0.0348903835,
0.036911834,
-0.0035253826,
0.0340725183,
0.00525223,
-0.0652147308,
0.0150441844,
0.0470463373,
-0.017136883,
0.0298688728,
-0.0695186704,
0.0152281933,
-0.0043024812,
-0.0237538293,
-0.0298997406,
-0.0211353321,
-0.0114142308,
0.0337839089,
0.0569409691,
0.0214251038,
-0.0071429485,
0.0149994725,
-0.0029455479,
0.0497283153,
-0.0381643027,
0.0178959519,
-0.0519146137,
0.0188643672,
0.0578844212,
-0.0074065025,
-0.0301916916,
-0.0393452235,
-0.0176763367,
0.0071350327,
0.0182568599,
0.0330872349,
-0.0117669469,
0.0138380807,
0.0594337583,
-0.0414421074,
-0.0200847462,
0.0314959995,
0.0802426115,
-0.0357803926,
-0.0297788233,
0.111289978,
0.0375079289,
-0.039574191,
0.0083069243,
0.0367945023,
0.0552657135,
0.0208691061,
0.0590954348,
-0.0318594724,
-0.0309351254,
0.0195615385,
0.0255823508,
-0.0071104532,
-0.0245670695,
0.0309639238,
-0.1106999144,
0.0463860296,
0.0175446253,
-0.0533391349,
-0.0015260896,
-0.025120955,
0.0279856119,
-0.009535864,
0.0183797125,
0.0157920644,
-0.0029977218,
0.0209046565,
0.0625403747,
-0.0020197434,
-0.083388567,
0.0269926321,
-0.0226193499,
0.0757168531,
0.0656006783,
0.0039494666,
-0.0018677707,
-0.0215961132,
0.0528846569,
-0.0132767884,
0.000194823,
-0.0224576704,
0.078584522,
0.0257213619,
-0.0372888446,
0.0313128345,
0.0262284204,
-0.0030712474,
0.0035975436,
-0.0083250003,
0.0734538436,
-0.0008147818,
0.0240982398,
0.0138671957,
-0.0468773395,
0.022657901,
0.0445808992,
0.0498878099,
-0.0635672584,
-0.0187359583,
-0.0374951661,
-0.026833646,
-0.0822372288,
-0.0237784963,
0.0531180948,
-0.039763134,
-0.0496150665,
-0.0412710644,
-0.0284892078,
0.1048120931,
0.0309174675,
0.0158024989,
0.012773376,
0.0095385034,
-0.023924239,
-0.0099319201,
0.0046312255,
-0.0705295205,
0.034373004,
-0.0640225485,
-0.0875311494,
0.0172906257,
-0.0170366932,
-0.0099351648,
0.0464096628,
-0.0970970541,
-0.0866339952,
0.0189507008,
0.0691180751,
0.015845947,
0.0364852697,
-0.0241683554,
-0.0945710987,
0.0052148839,
0.0390768722,
0.0237479545,
-0.009635157,
0.0297682863,
-0.0478675626,
-0.0201830808,
0.0400941521,
-0.0378739387,
0.0429773144,
0.0732337907,
0.0363691635,
-0.0159811787,
-0.0076581198,
0.0134061016,
0.0249730255,
0.0724209547,
-0.0413311198,
-0.0011787959,
-0.0226328969,
0.0169671774,
0.0280889776,
-0.0157239418,
-0.0482696556,
-0.0121190092,
0.0367457904,
-0.0103649041,
-0.0042114197,
-0.002987725,
0.0147797158,
0.0764100477,
-0.0355078168,
0.013363691,
-0.0152137494,
0.0053370087,
0.0416797101,
0.0311506968,
0.0049950941,
0.0444023237,
0.0177782215,
0.0477172285,
0.0003945948,
0.0285984911,
0.0301040038,
0.0587696433,
-0.0468281619,
0.0092673162,
-0.0224606004,
-0.0543665364,
-0.0751743987,
0.0434405841,
0.0517346747,
-0.0335514769,
0.0611661598,
0.0068980525,
-0.0433662012,
-0.0304281116,
0.0393803231,
0.0002301645,
-0.0235768538,
0.0181563087,
0.0541956313,
-0.0083745355,
-0.0196819305,
0.0798861608,
0.0382756814,
0.0050324947,
-0.0041510486,
0.0211281348,
-0.0391693749,
-0.0078826379,
-0.0163896922,
-0.0105136214,
-0.0098143276,
0.0091117639,
-0.027713161,
-0.0683361739,
-0.0346078463,
-0.0023463666,
-0.0043390077,
-0.0059528216,
0.0607921891,
0.0232255515,
-0.0072527649,
-0.0039357673,
-0.0376242958,
-0.0323335752,
0.0496077202,
-0.0152285248,
-0.0299202688,
-6.257685402e-33,
-0.0410949066,
0.0164297316,
-0.0052411137,
0.0091758156,
0.0182746351,
-0.0016499918,
-0.0234680511,
0.0315745957,
-0.0150150554,
0.0340824574,
-0.0120899556,
-0.0301819183,
0.0252835974,
0.0222116672,
0.0075027458,
-0.0372664742,
0.0636491477,
-0.0363708809,
-0.0189231597,
0.0399014316,
-0.0239223614,
0.0111252815,
0.0490770191,
-0.0428053029,
0.0237915292,
-0.0024451602,
-0.0174763706,
0.0150052728,
-0.0342240818,
0.0471210219,
0.0000581324,
0.0355736949,
0.0012623881,
-0.042327024,
-0.0364908054,
-0.0413090922,
-0.0711775497,
-0.0225111283,
0.0072390307,
0.0246677119,
-0.0379943214,
-0.0405601896,
0.0026481717,
0.0025930426,
-0.0176398829,
-0.0112467343,
0.0221345983,
-0.0201251321,
-0.0442376472,
-0.0189073104,
-0.0521288328,
0.0108603649,
-0.0030885919,
-0.0427527726,
0.06258443,
-0.0128798299,
0.0071983393,
0.0189195573,
0.0063208616,
-0.0104992129,
0.0576976761,
0.0726235434,
0.0478325896,
0.0453829579,
0.0117478808,
0.0079170195,
0.0197771974,
0.0242452025,
0.0150117707,
0.018625211,
0.0443701446,
0.0190286972,
0.0301923733,
0.0473374799,
0.0433498099,
0.0063335919,
-0.0576422811,
0.0005307835,
0.0186544899,
-0.0092297839,
0.0541921258,
0.0253616776,
0.0039340318,
-0.0484873429,
-0.0629028901,
0.0034665079,
-0.0445919186,
0.0064616553,
0.0249153618,
0.0119999461,
-0.0565566383,
-0.0191665925,
0.0622532368,
-0.0333369561,
-0.0281980224,
-0.0376347974,
-0.0287091807,
0.0375956558,
0.0053418851,
-0.0299246311,
-0.049309209,
-0.0720839202,
0.0286650062,
-0.013240302,
0.0248044077,
-0.0075544841,
0.0675550625,
0.0291081984,
-0.0527282357,
0.0161851235,
-0.0535667092,
0.0153614776,
0.0175050721,
0.0310978331,
0.0163972881,
0.0032374845,
0.0108860005,
0.0478899777,
0.0254651029,
-0.025354106,
-0.028160803,
-0.02463107,
-0.00558984,
0.0095517803,
-0.0343127996,
0.0166193936,
-0.0274794288,
0.0014132835,
0.0309146773,
-0.0325286724,
-0.0254341252,
0.0101876305,
2.484e-7,
0.0673463568,
0.0382078327,
0.0010902819,
0.0295759719,
0.0260578748,
0.021011157,
-0.0103317304,
-0.0109461751,
0.0446856841,
-0.0201258566,
0.0075650555,
0.0286395997,
0.0544666909,
0.0242205355,
-0.0964797214,
0.0026784847,
-0.0144643011,
0.0670712814,
-0.0356229618,
-0.0174347572,
0.005621376,
0.1010323241,
0.0179145299,
-0.0059169233,
0.0007743562,
-0.0324331895,
0.027164055,
-0.0357422717,
0.0090102479,
0.0575157553,
-0.0207614359,
0.0257575233,
-0.0125584397,
0.0311132651,
-0.0039372435,
-0.024615597,
0.0101712728,
0.0630325228,
-0.0073807458,
0.0012864139,
-0.0049986374,
-0.0201138556,
0.0257180408,
-0.0191576295,
0.0689456016,
-0.0864133462,
-0.0116012786,
0.0006819364,
0.0163546596,
-0.0112235891,
-0.0103177661,
-0.0149026224,
0.0043772073,
0.0472659618,
0.0269204639,
0.0071761594,
-0.0347456932,
-0.0510932021,
-0.0135688102,
0.0286434516,
-0.0367512666,
-0.0526726209,
-0.0247943755,
-0.0163255967,
-0.0261005741,
-0.0561325513,
-0.0121299718,
2.445017229e-34,
0.0372621678,
0.008926549,
0.0363326482,
0.0411017537,
0.0062949504,
-0.0292845275,
-0.0479392409,
0.0269787721,
0.0123304995,
-0.0744393691,
-0.0135805458
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06688v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06688v2 | Don't Rank, Combine! Combining Machine Translation Hypotheses Using Quality Estimation | 2024-01-12T16:52:41 | 2024-06-06T17:45:39 | Giorgos Vernikos, Andrei Popescu-Belis | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Neural machine translation systems estimate probabilities of target sentences
given source sentences, yet these estimates may not align with human
preferences. This work introduces QE-fusion, a method that synthesizes
translations using a quality estimation metric (QE), which correlates better
with human judgments. QE-fusion leverages a pool of candidates sampled from a
model, combining spans from different candidates using a QE metric such as
CometKiwi. We compare QE-fusion against beam search and recent reranking
techniques, such as Minimum Bayes Risk decoding or QE-reranking. Our method
consistently improves translation quality in terms of COMET and BLEURT scores
when applied to large language models (LLMs) used for translation (PolyLM,
XGLM, Llama2, Mistral, ALMA, and Tower) and to multilingual translation models
(NLLB), over five language pairs. Notably, QE-fusion exhibits larger
improvements for LLMs due to their ability to generate diverse outputs. We
demonstrate that our approach generates novel translations in over half of the
cases and consistently outperforms other methods across varying numbers of
candidates (5-200). Furthermore, we empirically establish that QE-fusion scales
linearly with the number of candidates in the pool. | [
0.0270657483,
0.0824014992,
0.0072658285,
0.027587451,
-0.0134223029,
0.0063894885,
-0.0128411464,
-0.0184366312,
-0.0046341284,
-0.007427068,
-0.0326059163,
-0.0615482442,
0.0562743805,
-0.009553398,
0.0266725142,
-0.0517780744,
0.0084461896,
0.0002756829,
-0.0201496352,
0.001572724,
-0.0256046336,
0.017609695,
0.0062898891,
0.0711525753,
0.0283691324,
0.017156247,
0.0267413445,
0.0506994762,
0.0689151883,
-0.017107619,
-0.0190366562,
0.0404492654,
-0.0171298552,
0.0434737131,
0.0000021912,
-0.0268416554,
-0.0317916945,
-0.0056756921,
0.0197012983,
0.01519565,
0.0341778249,
-0.0238480642,
-0.0255233813,
0.0138241779,
-0.0403344929,
0.0050370391,
0.0574646518,
-0.0148716383,
0.0645124018,
0.0608695336,
0.000284923,
-0.0131181292,
-0.0023177683,
-0.0510773659,
-0.0186632108,
-0.0911022723,
-0.0144438557,
-0.0154110128,
-0.0331294201,
0.0236721933,
0.0009365483,
0.0590765439,
0.0226902757,
-0.0069825174,
0.0073105278,
0.0133453794,
-0.0305147953,
-0.0391787291,
-0.0108891111,
0.0620725043,
-0.0667151287,
-0.0122317914,
-0.031149637,
-0.0107417656,
0.0047568041,
-0.0357797444,
-0.0236608386,
0.0229076724,
0.0103098042,
0.0115856426,
0.012565407,
0.0624280907,
0.0474744551,
-0.0062971395,
-0.044738654,
0.0381977186,
0.0311111733,
-0.0229326915,
-0.0157447457,
0.0288336538,
-0.0220259279,
-0.0011297107,
0.0248606466,
-0.0463473275,
-0.0212708507,
0.0276733339,
-0.028279312,
-0.0304879975,
0.0073743784,
-0.0454956368,
0.0234004017,
0.0521032661,
0.0157002229,
0.0421963893,
-0.0129757999,
0.0549682826,
-0.0030873141,
-0.0009992947,
-0.0934555531,
-0.014083148,
-0.0173499677,
0.0361731276,
0.0152094262,
-0.0249782018,
-0.0564467348,
-0.014664039,
-0.0603721812,
-0.0162694622,
-0.0053614858,
-0.0075684125,
0.0400035977,
0.015501014,
-0.0477748588,
-0.009982585,
-0.0191194527,
0.067854628,
0.0130419722,
-0.0210178755,
0.0250943527,
-0.0758657083,
-0.0104319584,
0.0103104841,
-0.0307884477,
-0.0228354745,
-0.0228224378,
0.0807271451,
-0.0164405107,
-0.0229251757,
0.0309496224,
0.0017126441,
-0.0515404716,
-0.0356139652,
0.0093860785,
-0.0661433786,
0.074920848,
-0.0115255965,
0.0164725147,
-0.0461816192,
0.022237068,
-0.0047371164,
-0.0117742578,
0.0507864021,
0.0229959395,
0.0022149775,
0.014263453,
0.0152388625,
-0.0264635365,
0.0631022006,
0.0412696451,
0.0608936213,
0.0303179733,
0.0211774129,
-0.002639378,
0.0432071909,
-0.01336003,
0.0323001444,
-0.0062808129,
-0.018903397,
0.0019338697,
0.0206463225,
0.0251625441,
0.0331600383,
-0.0305755958,
0.0284732003,
0.0729056224,
0.0238715112,
0.0290520843,
0.0129075535,
0.0156261083,
-0.0007463677,
-0.0179643761,
-0.0112537509,
-0.020577902,
0.0382403024,
-0.0087632136,
-0.0132587794,
0.068197988,
0.0982816294,
0.0267105959,
-0.0797497034,
-0.013103582,
-0.0214522555,
-0.0063982378,
-0.0160319023,
0.026275035,
0.0034566291,
-0.0409585573,
0.037108846,
-0.0004314522,
-0.0615831949,
0.0264059547,
-0.0238150265,
-0.0324814953,
0.072667636,
0.0573601499,
0.0148025248,
-0.0159288235,
0.0034129894,
-0.0736434311,
0.0314715467,
0.0448453166,
0.0224827901,
0.0494519807,
-0.0400870368,
-0.0464751273,
0.0163581017,
0.0255402513,
0.0345601626,
-0.0151842181,
0.0075933281,
0.0227235779,
-0.0437061042,
-0.0773593336,
0.0238371398,
0.0178630315,
-0.0105521455,
0.0514187105,
0.0076959375,
0.033548329,
-0.0040014712,
-0.013503857,
0.0316171832,
0.0190966129,
-0.0378653295,
-0.0509747118,
0.0204414576,
-0.0258740354,
-0.0573810153,
-0.0015471848,
-0.0561866015,
0.0121673113,
0.0129524833,
-0.0441643372,
-0.0240848139,
-0.0072356104,
-0.0482577719,
-0.0212458745,
-0.021040732,
0.0428102389,
-0.0083332593,
-0.0033397679,
-0.0551352836,
0.0760825723,
-0.0349886566,
-0.0137922578,
0.0170415118,
-0.0522626527,
0.0211126711,
-0.0509178229,
-0.0370302871,
0.0402225181,
-0.0010527557,
0.0488779619,
0.0601285398,
0.0251970477,
-0.0268853456,
-0.0361969508,
-0.0541510731,
0.0090134656,
-0.0120863728,
-0.0047213482,
0.027862478,
0.0328316018,
0.0097270235,
0.0023363838,
-0.0144924913,
-0.0695794746,
0.001523131,
0.0167038627,
-0.0074969507,
0.0094331969,
0.0286285635,
-0.0330468863,
-0.0398431681,
0.0085032796,
0.0614104979,
-0.0043259505,
-0.0245693643,
-0.0826679394,
0.0499087162,
-0.066984117,
-0.0289038848,
0.0112547697,
-0.0669274256,
-0.0011788382,
-0.0292666517,
0.0106176352,
0.0633939803,
0.0038964411,
-0.0098622888,
0.0763763115,
0.0047227629,
-0.0599997714,
-0.0048754415,
-0.0310567021,
-0.020194022,
0.0031733823,
-0.0634976178,
0.0367076695,
0.0054342528,
0.0225709602,
-0.0213990528,
-0.067922391,
0.0406029411,
-0.0110086212,
-0.0388796255,
-0.0344204493,
0.0046887021,
0.0111795757,
0.0742670447,
-0.0219905823,
-0.0534733422,
0.0731953681,
-0.02726092,
0.0332029052,
-0.0860789418,
-0.0005091144,
-0.0207898412,
-0.0186329279,
-0.0169849303,
0.0382767953,
-0.068722412,
0.0026971656,
-0.0360781103,
0.0121370554,
0.0068517579,
-0.0321899429,
0.0171620809,
-0.0639736652,
-0.0349498317,
-0.0115285888,
-0.0179781895,
-0.0349016711,
-0.000639237,
0.004051507,
-0.0144122764,
0.0100610396,
-0.0131648807,
-0.0364921018,
-0.0184692778,
0.0170913395,
0.0196569059,
-0.0281556714,
0.0066136052,
-0.0087301405,
0.0328563973,
0.0077321366,
0.0002956213,
0.058947213,
-0.0463428982,
0.0169843305,
0.0198132675,
0.0276527703,
0.0199572779,
-0.0134303747,
-0.0337933414,
0.0609011725,
0.0249726027,
-0.048119776,
0.0191817675,
0.0489671603,
-0.0483672358,
0.0088483635,
0.0940002203,
0.0219262242,
-0.0354668647,
-0.0004111613,
-0.0119825201,
0.0471199527,
0.0050327242,
0.0349255539,
-0.0546052195,
-0.0194056015,
-0.000375691,
0.0333732367,
0.0225771051,
0.0130606256,
-0.0243038349,
-0.1171059385,
0.0286999028,
0.0603247583,
0.012762215,
-0.0174979214,
0.0006596756,
-0.0196779035,
-0.0510244705,
0.0106342528,
0.0118469968,
0.0515625812,
0.0080467444,
-0.003388816,
0.0194494221,
-0.0944282413,
-0.0154810864,
-0.0670858771,
0.011607334,
0.102293238,
0.064066343,
0.0068933261,
-0.0730573833,
-0.0190708917,
-0.0496513732,
0.0067374152,
0.0307786185,
0.0002136706,
0.0216932893,
-0.0060567842,
0.0208900683,
-0.0003712914,
0.0098258713,
0.0161269847,
-0.005343053,
0.0314499661,
-0.0180943236,
-0.0115725808,
-0.0008496496,
-0.0121923247,
-0.0026565176,
0.0506719463,
0.0250414964,
-0.0439080745,
0.0093301674,
-0.0402252935,
0.0172000937,
-0.0431207679,
-0.0290677864,
0.0384580269,
-0.0150394505,
-0.050303109,
-0.1131912991,
-0.0409132428,
-0.0298764426,
0.0234097,
-0.0020249386,
0.0088233417,
-0.012421459,
0.0075605097,
0.0279322825,
0.057073921,
-0.0047273738,
0.0019884957,
-0.0308004562,
0.0580425635,
-0.0058217309,
-0.0208618231,
-0.0240991861,
0.0343036354,
-0.0636021271,
-0.0688802525,
-0.0292898528,
0.0844705105,
0.0241339151,
-0.00544402,
-0.0497086756,
-0.0377199166,
0.0089286016,
0.0321765132,
-0.0008553003,
0.0006538212,
0.0138998535,
-0.0048292698,
-0.0315906517,
0.033390604,
-0.0336196907,
-0.0057851109,
-0.0324685499,
0.0544677749,
0.0005376184,
-0.0773079321,
0.0113292933,
-0.0040865699,
0.0308851022,
-0.0863890871,
-0.0378916897,
-0.0237488654,
0.0065220501,
-0.0059659439,
-0.0099753533,
-0.037646044,
0.0030786986,
0.0694176555,
0.0175810345,
0.0119684497,
0.0172231738,
0.0011871683,
-0.0189494267,
-0.0310533047,
-0.0104310205,
-0.0092560081,
0.0048363255,
-0.0009361023,
0.0227627773,
-0.0084745623,
0.0253509786,
-0.0098332521,
0.0209273677,
-0.0224777069,
-0.0090515446,
0.013789515,
-0.0051344079,
0.0297061838,
0.0854179114,
-0.057493072,
-0.0544073619,
-0.0412590131,
-0.0023098493,
0.0915132612,
0.0364277288,
0.1261993051,
0.0297469385,
-0.0144223133,
-0.0281830244,
0.0222446937,
0.0274471641,
-0.0257715769,
-0.0112145953,
-0.0023781825,
0.0030239662,
0.014834119,
0.0804571137,
-0.0577796958,
-0.007415046,
-0.0304645896,
-0.0159588587,
-0.0236921478,
-0.0232474487,
-0.0267146844,
0.0012325067,
-0.0189099181,
-0.0267704278,
-0.0518057197,
-0.0401487723,
0.021458758,
0.0271763708,
-0.0078429924,
-0.011352065,
0.0025551158,
0.0609487668,
-0.0539020449,
0.0173326302,
-0.031096166,
-0.0599037223,
-0.0254241321,
-0.0160057079,
-0.0201577004,
-6.650241006e-33,
-0.0144065805,
-0.0209970064,
-0.0252878517,
-0.06781625,
-0.0107750054,
-0.0039939191,
-0.013951215,
-0.022107644,
-0.0038663489,
0.0103438441,
0.0221797321,
-0.0075585279,
0.0170077514,
0.0076110177,
0.0204334091,
0.0155722527,
0.0488737375,
0.0441228226,
-0.0526643395,
0.0012263837,
0.029941326,
0.0039903712,
0.0581934862,
-0.0601164959,
0.042578537,
0.0219590142,
-0.0374214873,
0.0194906555,
-0.0137825664,
0.06040667,
0.0038622343,
0.036922317,
0.0047319494,
-0.0459315889,
-0.0309123304,
-0.0253851265,
-0.0191560164,
0.0017936697,
0.010666972,
0.0075394902,
-0.0065373569,
-0.0479053967,
0.0403327607,
-0.0217033997,
-0.0378088951,
-0.0213213637,
0.0330553688,
-0.0513937809,
-0.0179720186,
-0.0486798696,
-0.008588546,
0.0177594908,
-0.0133368233,
-0.0035561086,
-0.0030350115,
0.0589637458,
-0.0225277003,
0.0449655168,
-0.0804099068,
0.028275378,
-0.0137008484,
0.0603452437,
0.0811864138,
-0.0106897084,
-0.021868607,
0.04529237,
0.0207862779,
-0.036285039,
0.0299525224,
-0.0451941341,
0.0394774489,
0.015471153,
0.0905032605,
0.0505359136,
0.0273788758,
0.0098587982,
-0.0603309795,
0.0819818079,
-0.0075626201,
0.0010730231,
0.0178383756,
0.0410595946,
-0.022674663,
-0.0082066488,
-0.0519152135,
-0.0613965988,
-0.0359932967,
-0.0212606452,
0.0134575125,
0.0175766163,
-0.0371402055,
-0.0101787876,
0.0666626021,
-0.0221205,
0.031224763,
0.0418661311,
-0.025861064,
0.0035346937,
-0.0004858638,
0.0554401875,
0.0024122002,
0.0429296009,
0.0407386608,
0.0113810645,
-0.0015403308,
-0.0221059751,
0.02552763,
-0.0001348934,
-0.0267333686,
0.0222493969,
-0.0494643115,
-0.0145288184,
-0.0086168833,
0.0209184065,
0.029609466,
-0.0085162483,
-0.0207265522,
0.0289213322,
0.0249391571,
0.069514133,
-0.0309090819,
0.0122975241,
0.0171553157,
0.0265177675,
-0.0320528559,
0.0081072794,
-0.0189366061,
0.0062373262,
0.0418602265,
-0.034632694,
-0.0547891855,
0.0191950165,
2.959e-7,
0.0516238324,
0.0470045023,
0.0000244162,
0.0156258252,
-0.0036286963,
0.0507329665,
-0.0202329475,
0.038056042,
0.0278016366,
0.022962708,
-0.0075067892,
0.0083314888,
0.0758875459,
0.039461676,
-0.0811563283,
-0.0125904297,
-0.0734042823,
0.0055365833,
-0.0478791557,
-0.0441693738,
0.0575392097,
0.097793892,
-0.0112598957,
-0.0048332592,
-0.0035879076,
0.0084647946,
0.0742478073,
-0.0137631726,
-0.049933318,
0.0029737803,
0.0617998168,
0.0287970565,
-0.0217530169,
-0.0253931023,
-0.0382167734,
0.0287143551,
0.0566453971,
0.0571624339,
0.000500136,
-0.0398518741,
0.0113712437,
0.0235208124,
0.0069920383,
-0.0328041203,
0.0461402684,
-0.03119337,
-0.0148133952,
0.0166885741,
-0.0305821579,
0.0071400357,
0.0711060017,
-0.0378565118,
-0.0312931575,
0.0231147036,
0.0254100654,
0.0084881261,
-0.0155130271,
-0.0404769033,
-0.0490223207,
-0.0042766733,
-0.011902635,
-0.0411036909,
0.0030628254,
-0.0012953014,
0.0278333109,
-0.0733486041,
-0.0043139262,
2.724123669e-34,
0.0516267568,
0.0011189282,
0.0156948045,
-0.0061961683,
0.0511483364,
-0.0147173209,
-0.0261692442,
-0.0006678866,
0.0167266149,
-0.0469072387,
-0.0313845724
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06687v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06687v2 | Proximal Causal Inference With Text Data | 2024-01-12T16:51:02 | 2024-05-21T21:08:54 | Jacob M. Chen, Rohit Bhattacharya, Katherine A. Keith | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, stat.ME | Recent text-based causal methods attempt to mitigate confounding bias by
estimating proxies of confounding variables that are partially or imperfectly
measured from unstructured text data. These approaches, however, assume
analysts have supervised labels of the confounders given text for a subset of
instances, a constraint that is sometimes infeasible due to data privacy or
annotation costs. In this work, we address settings in which an important
confounding variable is completely unobserved. We propose a new causal
inference method that uses multiple instances of pre-treatment text data,
infers two proxies from two zero-shot models on the separate instances, and
applies these proxies in the proximal g-formula. We prove that our text-based
proxy method satisfies identification conditions required by the proximal
g-formula while other seemingly reasonable proposals do not. We evaluate our
method in synthetic and semi-synthetic settings and find that it produces
estimates with low bias. To address untestable assumptions associated with the
proximal g-formula, we further propose an odds ratio falsification heuristic.
This new combination of proximal causal inference and zero-shot classifiers
expands the set of text-specific causal methods available to practitioners. | [
-0.0124804648,
0.0836792961,
-0.0297277998,
-0.0086123878,
-0.028171543,
0.0371460617,
0.0786176622,
0.0415503383,
-0.0022968408,
-0.0369535014,
0.0692336485,
0.0039222282,
-0.026232738,
0.0179092307,
0.0635064989,
0.0023708863,
0.0239978805,
0.0155855753,
0.0544034094,
-0.0251007322,
-0.0308885332,
-0.0184025951,
0.0036930919,
0.0128685357,
0.0072666765,
0.0121615175,
0.0706561729,
0.0007549582,
-0.0099039637,
-0.040513739,
0.0265749786,
0.0214309543,
-0.0086644115,
0.0260489471,
0.0000022089,
-0.0128693897,
-0.0388457142,
0.0129070906,
-0.0104437824,
0.0128326165,
0.0103423074,
0.0066340328,
0.0365493149,
0.0063085607,
0.0028708661,
-0.0228895172,
0.0188554171,
0.0480779633,
-0.054371994,
0.0641681775,
-0.0170782525,
-0.0319239125,
-0.0077925585,
-0.0378353335,
0.0585677251,
-0.008758042,
0.0553501546,
-0.0515755266,
-0.0523045547,
-0.0106551992,
-0.0207855459,
0.0408017039,
0.0022717216,
0.0307216775,
0.0173372105,
0.0097790621,
0.0025206564,
0.0167664308,
0.0143561102,
0.0457710326,
0.0826179683,
-0.0295781232,
0.0330157802,
-0.0489240922,
0.0608798601,
0.0536613874,
-0.0170153491,
-0.0212564692,
0.006608068,
-0.0196199846,
0.0428725295,
0.0207568891,
0.040020965,
0.0269606002,
0.0313482508,
0.0408985429,
-0.0004138948,
-0.0246434435,
-0.0203746837,
0.0452257693,
-0.0101237819,
-0.0320077576,
-0.0221574716,
-0.0155754834,
0.0058928235,
0.0044205151,
0.02285414,
-0.0485827476,
0.0249163751,
-0.0309611093,
0.0015170858,
0.0190788042,
-0.0356259942,
0.0027419915,
-0.0085472511,
0.0211617127,
-0.0043960325,
0.020312082,
-0.0094032567,
0.0531827956,
-0.0112806382,
-0.0086310301,
0.0350438952,
0.0008432586,
-0.0346515179,
0.0277017225,
-0.0506589152,
0.0114470376,
-0.0027568571,
-0.0428828038,
-0.0351049304,
0.010848809,
-0.047827132,
-0.0074569895,
0.0035440179,
0.0349000581,
-0.0414806157,
0.0749482363,
-0.026407212,
-0.0246264543,
-0.0134366043,
0.0514486693,
0.0610407703,
-0.0419370607,
0.0139073404,
0.0483690463,
0.0145643121,
-0.0052124262,
-0.0202428699,
-0.0256909672,
-0.0564793646,
-0.0411071777,
-0.0211681593,
-0.040696457,
-0.0353715718,
0.0141793983,
0.0207167845,
-0.0767662823,
-0.0274791736,
-0.0239974223,
-0.0856093466,
-0.040926978,
-0.0293549001,
-0.0125201968,
-0.0146457627,
-0.0104067754,
-0.0170067567,
0.0550417267,
0.0215326976,
-0.0183285177,
0.0187930372,
-0.0142967803,
-0.0032849344,
0.0165974181,
0.058101166,
0.0403718799,
-0.000551325,
-0.035948012,
0.010991727,
-0.0547606833,
-0.0191956442,
-0.0587451607,
-0.0343499966,
0.0505857244,
0.0448938869,
-0.0138831111,
-0.0044651693,
0.0258105863,
-0.0127662271,
-0.0213182494,
-0.0328523628,
0.0134167541,
-0.0227736179,
-0.0084593426,
-0.0769156069,
-0.0249090903,
0.0295518432,
-0.0289454591,
-0.0161065497,
-0.0213429183,
0.0299726296,
0.0218542702,
-0.0435215272,
0.0145770404,
0.0736039877,
-0.0214152876,
-0.0237631779,
-0.0347193703,
0.0370875821,
0.0028478503,
0.0008835965,
0.0230060387,
0.0124260923,
0.0389714167,
-0.0010519294,
-0.0502443388,
0.0451103002,
-0.0190951955,
0.0224196706,
-0.0296421517,
-0.044348821,
0.0163656976,
0.0215675049,
0.0317901224,
0.0019838121,
-0.0202531405,
0.0648670495,
0.0291533787,
0.0002313811,
0.0170724634,
-0.0025547538,
0.000569482,
-0.0052784057,
0.0522331223,
0.0084428899,
-0.0640010014,
0.0210191328,
-0.0008722078,
0.0254392102,
0.0071379347,
-0.0349064507,
-0.012061907,
-0.0142589612,
-0.0010852205,
-0.0218431205,
-0.0151362065,
0.0522737913,
-0.0334135517,
-0.041898597,
-0.0593943708,
-0.0083402209,
-0.0165549163,
-0.0308345575,
0.0112509746,
0.024515219,
0.0447137617,
0.0376260206,
0.0062899524,
0.005461317,
-0.009382668,
-0.0216258727,
0.0004947276,
0.0184550006,
0.0177745037,
0.0297515858,
-0.0278478302,
-0.0772710219,
0.0232590176,
-0.0528104529,
-0.00503371,
-0.0418803021,
-0.0471856743,
-0.0396474712,
0.0280359685,
-0.0199834723,
-0.0077215694,
-0.0230450984,
-0.0323996469,
-0.0087899286,
-0.005865714,
-0.0116305584,
-0.0111624217,
-0.004220298,
-0.0063255299,
-0.01400954,
-0.0073535661,
-0.0563508458,
0.0275289305,
0.0529957674,
-0.0093710888,
-0.0041041761,
0.0208187252,
-0.044695314,
-0.0143639948,
-0.0555047989,
0.0411046892,
0.0545680188,
-0.0473180115,
0.0268735811,
-0.0057613109,
-0.0171686839,
-0.0065410011,
-0.0043893377,
-0.0221542325,
-0.0345366672,
0.0116233621,
-0.0502395295,
0.0809187368,
-0.0250969604,
-0.0049037845,
0.0071436479,
0.0081924563,
-0.0417453684,
-0.0156623553,
-0.0803639963,
-0.0289627239,
-0.0193155929,
-0.0599608421,
-0.0490038618,
0.0145751974,
-0.0012067385,
-0.0074089491,
-0.0312571004,
0.0415580124,
-0.0108918454,
-0.0222700704,
-0.0294832326,
0.0029457349,
-0.0043345047,
0.020387901,
-0.0314726979,
-0.0916032866,
0.019116601,
0.0427740626,
0.0386955328,
0.0136249764,
0.0011244628,
0.0362564959,
-0.0453335755,
0.0057580587,
-0.0173741039,
0.0590649694,
0.0550997034,
0.0002280954,
-0.0019081143,
0.0831186399,
0.0223997999,
-0.0346847922,
-0.0534180999,
0.063049078,
0.0495368801,
-0.0541505292,
-0.0064245821,
-0.1071833968,
0.0007116417,
-0.0188868791,
0.0186045896,
-0.0163095109,
-0.0684910491,
-0.0040908377,
0.0314290822,
0.0071200691,
-0.0317911282,
-0.0005355394,
0.0045455778,
-0.0612492338,
0.0165247191,
-0.1099655256,
0.0248186756,
-0.0653651208,
0.0173558723,
-0.0149495639,
0.0206009187,
0.0024721164,
0.038854152,
0.0610704981,
-0.0234955624,
0.0241750926,
0.0098201036,
0.0354294293,
0.0004535367,
0.0232409127,
0.0233643744,
0.0613667071,
-0.0032848602,
-0.0218348838,
0.0253261831,
0.0434322879,
0.0086407,
-0.0131715639,
-0.0393503606,
-0.0697861984,
-0.0117626823,
-0.0122884354,
0.0095290672,
-0.033927545,
-0.034028247,
0.0158461723,
-0.0524031483,
0.0328558311,
0.0238074753,
-0.0034085941,
0.0053089266,
-0.0004420707,
0.0162716676,
-0.0336811841,
-0.1166932136,
-0.0063766288,
0.0056894664,
-0.0058237347,
0.0128167449,
-0.0393902138,
-0.0400894471,
-0.0337683186,
-0.0194825921,
0.0025833994,
-0.0116280029,
-0.0080420198,
-0.0114198178,
0.0370894633,
0.0214660801,
-0.0024640844,
-0.0135187758,
-0.0020841595,
0.1375696957,
-0.0216090027,
0.0003230341,
-0.0315996818,
0.051561594,
-0.0236472394,
-0.0266724229,
0.0122489985,
0.0140915895,
0.0366954319,
0.00307768,
0.0706597567,
-0.011405752,
0.0346565358,
0.041776605,
-0.0280708913,
0.0116866101,
0.0061400468,
-0.0109629622,
-0.0432546772,
0.0152619658,
0.0228640065,
-0.0003054519,
-0.0385588892,
-0.0607062504,
-0.0122722453,
-0.0243934244,
0.0324074253,
0.0173576921,
0.0216705557,
0.0075316834,
-0.0177839752,
-0.0347531363,
-0.014055389,
0.0326896757,
-0.0119921668,
0.0241528451,
0.0279358439,
-0.0342794284,
-0.0371963866,
0.0106846942,
-0.0268199239,
0.0224101748,
-0.0647957996,
-0.0758383349,
-0.002917706,
0.0236378089,
0.0179593433,
0.0386897512,
0.0070053381,
-0.0295142476,
0.0316695236,
0.0383795649,
-0.0467996784,
0.0486140214,
0.0059204837,
-0.0502121672,
0.0007258823,
-0.0116620669,
-0.0252980795,
-0.0149591118,
0.0457283035,
0.005140991,
-0.0196009744,
0.0156364515,
0.0094479872,
-0.0056600762,
0.0799003094,
-0.0379403494,
-0.0281781759,
-0.0251623448,
0.0011150944,
-0.0038871341,
0.010322242,
0.0170157496,
0.0105182743,
0.0275526997,
0.0177114606,
-0.0459903814,
-0.0074972049,
-0.0775465071,
0.0177437086,
-0.0688422471,
0.0474493951,
0.0009511344,
0.0191894639,
0.0303297285,
0.0237240754,
0.0291531924,
-0.0000317785,
0.056580171,
0.0392683521,
0.0250256732,
0.0053264061,
0.0240276586,
0.0589604452,
-0.0337458067,
-0.0695199817,
-0.0769779012,
0.0197678264,
-0.0477859341,
-0.0058899606,
0.0174632911,
-0.0299874023,
0.0418834649,
0.0086946273,
-0.0271683,
-0.0384620726,
0.0355387293,
-0.0017502282,
0.0086821793,
-0.0075936215,
-0.036139667,
-0.0474613607,
0.0194093902,
0.066269286,
0.1031689346,
0.052215416,
-0.0728978515,
-0.0146458149,
0.0080519235,
-0.0551318042,
0.0406298675,
0.053077925,
-0.0065394039,
0.0179384928,
-0.0995825678,
-0.0775921568,
0.0109843351,
-0.063156575,
0.0302053336,
0.0319506526,
-0.06554389,
-0.0056738271,
-0.0167747531,
-0.0440742373,
-0.0208898913,
0.0252142735,
-0.0398933701,
-0.0236174501,
-0.0346347727,
-6.826949398e-33,
-0.0169580393,
-0.0403939299,
-0.0536378771,
-0.0049192058,
0.0355330892,
0.0499878488,
-0.0151422247,
0.0032412072,
0.0308400448,
0.0298027396,
0.0329549722,
0.0315374695,
0.0171542484,
0.0015129896,
0.0048740231,
-0.0337994248,
-0.0018005763,
0.0112973358,
-0.0109797632,
-0.0187690146,
-0.0066135065,
0.0440038964,
0.0327434801,
-0.0801384151,
0.0846334398,
-0.0063561434,
-0.0111127431,
-0.0410364605,
-0.0101121124,
0.0361262336,
0.0187399238,
0.0222658142,
0.0247932989,
-0.0076732575,
0.0323723108,
0.0061397785,
-0.0581729077,
-0.0323441289,
0.0597566292,
-0.0285369046,
0.0268000737,
-0.0397957973,
-0.0209978912,
0.0290925913,
-0.0197563507,
-0.0080118487,
0.0410078093,
-0.0111610824,
-0.0124539882,
-0.0202820059,
-0.071422711,
0.0252003148,
-0.0566747338,
0.0510961972,
0.0092052929,
0.102620624,
0.0244283956,
0.0629331619,
0.0063885055,
0.0194952469,
0.0129782334,
-0.0158281513,
-0.0095460583,
0.0464386679,
0.0104760677,
0.0565529577,
-0.0125637678,
0.0068344595,
-0.0505847037,
-0.0552204996,
0.0059885308,
-0.0402790308,
0.0380746685,
0.0879982263,
0.0765621215,
-0.0243357476,
-0.1084256098,
0.0121292677,
-0.0281372648,
-0.0269248933,
0.0449882522,
0.0035883847,
-0.0234257895,
-0.0460062139,
-0.0700916797,
-0.0652876422,
-0.0241886862,
0.0212250706,
0.0283529628,
0.0218669437,
-0.0104631362,
0.0096530039,
0.080131717,
-0.0033498951,
-0.0196308792,
-0.0169137456,
-0.0180070102,
-0.0068685976,
-0.0257593896,
-0.0099421786,
-0.0519758686,
0.0094692484,
0.0531905591,
0.0663358346,
0.0868052691,
-0.0098334523,
0.087755084,
-0.0592311397,
-0.0414986163,
-0.0119904624,
-0.0288376324,
-0.037671864,
0.041312743,
-0.0411624126,
0.0471503846,
0.0562250353,
0.0064753662,
0.033652585,
0.0283831097,
0.0078304261,
0.0317783765,
-0.031661462,
-0.0314762071,
-0.0140077919,
-0.0268102102,
0.0080867168,
0.0581483878,
0.0159174576,
0.0281445291,
-0.0618312992,
0.0005012175,
-0.0171905383,
2.935e-7,
0.0697754547,
0.0388636068,
-0.0003684986,
-0.0153950891,
0.0063522994,
0.0241405368,
0.0081223426,
0.0058229649,
0.0697709769,
0.0178343393,
0.0655096471,
0.0136791896,
0.0623500757,
-0.0432764404,
-0.0074531073,
0.0320765078,
-0.0353052467,
-0.0400813334,
-0.0343117155,
0.0091414386,
0.0651289597,
0.0161986835,
0.0356640257,
0.0248632114,
-0.0187295936,
0.0216561835,
0.0401640534,
-0.0692262799,
-0.0097849928,
-0.0006766829,
-0.031882342,
0.0027960411,
-0.0104734357,
0.0824862644,
-0.039296288,
-0.0108150942,
-0.0092947213,
0.025768036,
-0.0339780264,
0.0378337614,
-0.0292075165,
-0.0258723889,
0.0095659737,
-0.0137200784,
0.0508648865,
-0.0114412364,
-0.0161371995,
0.0395935588,
-0.0523509197,
0.0308487322,
0.0531676002,
0.0223559942,
0.0096566314,
0.0168261789,
-0.0085808281,
0.048016049,
-0.005249612,
-0.0013744208,
-0.0286178701,
0.0501896925,
-0.0033905993,
-0.0617811978,
0.0261792466,
0.0353475958,
0.0029261145,
-0.0419996046,
0.042995099,
2.953704374e-34,
0.0288314894,
0.0310661495,
-0.0151167894,
-0.043687094,
0.0715400055,
0.0008518316,
-0.0379775055,
0.0072239232,
0.0146541214,
-0.0955242813,
0.0390917845
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06683v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06683v2 | DQNC2S: DQN-based Cross-stream Crisis event Summarizer | 2024-01-12T16:43:28 | 2024-02-02T09:54:18 | Daniele Rege Cambrin, Luca Cagliero, Paolo Garza | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Summarizing multiple disaster-relevant data streams simultaneously is
particularly challenging as existing Retrieve&Re-ranking strategies suffer from
the inherent redundancy of multi-stream data and limited scalability in a
multi-query setting. This work proposes an online approach to crisis timeline
generation based on weak annotation with Deep Q-Networks. It selects on-the-fly
the relevant pieces of text without requiring neither human annotations nor
content re-ranking. This makes the inference time independent of the number of
input queries. The proposed approach also incorporates a redundancy filter into
the reward function to effectively handle cross-stream content overlaps. The
achieved ROUGE and BERTScore results are superior to those of best-performing
models on the CrisisFACTS 2022 benchmark. | [
-0.0243745502,
0.0446579754,
0.0083212545,
-0.012687061,
0.0157350563,
0.0095144706,
-0.0216226671,
-0.0258335769,
0.0019910121,
-0.0096707055,
0.0330893733,
-0.0295042675,
-0.0577972159,
0.048334457,
-0.041191794,
-0.1211907566,
0.0367015302,
0.0201764982,
0.0150912022,
-0.0009924578,
0.0161818601,
0.0084503759,
-0.0091014998,
0.0129429465,
0.0069899866,
0.0246138796,
-0.0372077934,
0.0132022845,
0.0599674806,
-0.061687123,
-0.0122520532,
0.005067314,
0.0516798645,
0.0503426716,
0.0000018227,
-0.0129254796,
-0.0452371575,
-0.0385465436,
-0.008445764,
0.0318261608,
-0.0499093458,
-0.032858856,
0.0151833817,
0.0110620297,
-0.0367740132,
-0.0043552648,
0.0293944292,
0.0437383205,
0.0878054276,
0.0789986551,
-0.0235058945,
-0.0022079356,
0.0391486324,
-0.0286764577,
-0.0258056037,
-0.1138788387,
0.0084563205,
-0.0025976126,
0.0432929173,
-0.0238334145,
0.0061184838,
0.0346111096,
0.0312740058,
0.0161947943,
-0.0252596885,
0.0404160134,
-0.0598889329,
0.0169694331,
0.0034542605,
0.0551195443,
-0.0100329397,
0.0173789077,
0.051156681,
-0.0215743147,
0.0117415823,
-0.0162806287,
-0.0391926728,
0.0158289541,
-0.004990268,
0.0259204935,
-0.0006202725,
0.0523130521,
0.0046586925,
0.0369703248,
-0.0344927795,
-0.0172125753,
-0.0137415389,
-0.0099259345,
-0.0570538267,
0.0064767441,
-0.0621159934,
-0.0391035341,
0.0100306533,
0.0098389992,
-0.0664994493,
0.0005775791,
-0.0203660335,
0.0044753766,
-0.0360577963,
-0.0765408427,
-0.0204026662,
0.0370804146,
0.0226496253,
0.0528157838,
0.0130070979,
0.0209922511,
0.0007417662,
-0.0119688241,
-0.0154443951,
0.00622048,
-0.0783682689,
-0.0149712544,
-0.0284390822,
0.0346048623,
-0.0412042961,
0.0065568918,
-0.0327214897,
0.0262243617,
0.0000683633,
-0.022309145,
0.0098489476,
0.0301465038,
-0.0744851977,
0.0055223587,
-0.030825505,
0.0251066741,
-0.0655289143,
-0.0022198446,
0.0146535486,
-0.0502163731,
0.0183276609,
-0.0200982057,
0.0341157764,
0.007596151,
-0.0553583167,
0.0227008164,
-0.0337219127,
0.0217159986,
-0.0547765046,
-0.0187928118,
-0.0278758258,
-0.0040128077,
-0.0045725689,
-0.0258977786,
0.0064045237,
-0.0244419314,
-0.0290109087,
0.0312498733,
0.0067774397,
-0.0174643416,
-0.0289445892,
0.0023274373,
-0.0313439928,
-0.0041370727,
0.0305924229,
-0.0128396265,
0.0214134604,
0.0846250281,
0.0542762466,
0.0510780439,
0.0460656136,
0.0453067943,
-0.0175218135,
-0.0062907999,
-0.002198763,
0.0185044408,
-0.0655705631,
-0.0453540981,
-0.0524575487,
0.0385290571,
0.0243860725,
-0.0241672229,
-0.0408076271,
0.0063418327,
0.0264051501,
-0.0203426033,
0.0374720469,
0.0203023721,
0.0177653395,
0.0479484275,
-0.023301322,
0.0499910638,
0.027942365,
0.0925623327,
0.0334257111,
0.0221773591,
0.0722506791,
-0.0007416636,
-0.0513946302,
-0.0415106714,
0.0120663214,
0.0257533845,
-0.0255560614,
-0.0007732448,
0.0091687981,
0.0097997505,
-0.030601006,
-0.0153775206,
-0.0013767632,
-0.0047662449,
0.0642596185,
-0.0124369124,
-0.0003443382,
0.0895470679,
0.0355557352,
-0.0528977662,
-0.0709811226,
-0.0017392586,
0.0478609093,
-0.0054898011,
0.0246672295,
-0.0089870496,
-0.0182318129,
-0.0544366091,
-0.0763093308,
-0.025729334,
0.0175001994,
0.0244486462,
0.0004411882,
0.0178845432,
0.0086089652,
0.0264105089,
-0.0416249894,
0.0070248195,
-0.0198201742,
-0.0209817532,
0.0038594471,
0.0167720225,
0.0055128136,
0.0105754966,
0.0057364777,
0.0213803034,
0.0255917534,
-0.0391816832,
-0.0603167303,
0.0244763773,
-0.0322424285,
-0.0165206958,
-0.0241247956,
-0.0530345328,
0.0307244342,
0.0340554491,
-0.0538372546,
-0.0620707832,
0.040232636,
-0.0081163133,
-0.0383569039,
-0.0215435345,
-0.0300795231,
0.0262055174,
-0.034876965,
-0.0187452883,
0.1026371196,
0.0065535512,
0.0286504216,
0.0421764515,
0.0031830065,
-0.0376475565,
-0.0486477353,
-0.0031630753,
0.0079081915,
-0.0055754264,
0.0114024132,
0.0454716794,
-0.0413016714,
-0.0278881751,
-0.0100382129,
-0.0185420588,
0.01817449,
-0.0275056493,
0.0251638498,
0.0443281494,
0.0298680291,
-0.0129286442,
-0.0115535846,
-0.0275877528,
-0.0304983109,
-0.0030021172,
0.020166887,
0.0123920962,
0.037461184,
0.0610639714,
-0.0253326986,
-0.0265640952,
-0.0073696557,
0.0416517556,
0.013708231,
-0.0677244067,
-0.0079605803,
-0.0109958174,
-0.0469511151,
-0.0107070757,
-0.0210791063,
-0.0075229905,
0.0066814078,
-0.0089095859,
0.0414663032,
-0.0079455562,
0.0708836094,
0.0316020027,
0.0020155224,
-0.0110414037,
-0.0397063754,
0.0441481136,
-0.0592185594,
-0.0111551974,
0.0155051323,
-0.0143823959,
-0.0174721796,
-0.0024311841,
-0.0245651454,
0.0140435277,
-0.0490365028,
0.0058260444,
-0.011038214,
-0.0018925873,
-0.0454601161,
-0.0124876695,
-0.0154680274,
0.0136475023,
-0.0269333515,
0.0078357728,
0.0246458054,
0.08033292,
0.0337476358,
-0.011329581,
-0.0017631969,
-0.0554639474,
0.0578198619,
-0.0547179841,
0.036656335,
-0.0258460697,
-0.0302435495,
-0.0552312322,
-0.0310143307,
0.0438144468,
-0.0309891198,
-0.0251118466,
-0.0126407556,
0.0069543221,
-0.0166917909,
-0.0087223426,
-0.0320866294,
-0.0041505313,
0.0131872436,
0.0108384369,
-0.0035599845,
0.0390938595,
-0.0479862019,
0.0476910546,
0.021987671,
0.0621537603,
-0.029659031,
-0.0012552387,
0.0005037966,
0.0857858807,
0.020427797,
0.0142955799,
0.0285598151,
-0.0439384468,
0.0506743006,
0.0165008884,
0.062438719,
0.0057335962,
0.0342847779,
0.0064238976,
0.0052553695,
-0.0402805991,
-0.0108856345,
-0.0047008744,
0.0143730715,
-0.0251177885,
-0.0056027649,
0.044198405,
0.0338982455,
-0.0181837324,
0.0160982944,
0.0265711155,
-0.0107809398,
0.0151536651,
0.0064093894,
-0.0675664395,
0.0120358868,
-0.0068232804,
0.0247537773,
0.0209272355,
-0.0642896444,
-0.0128240576,
-0.013908173,
0.0381775387,
-0.006154784,
-0.0253294054,
0.0124843111,
-0.061121136,
0.011901034,
-0.0172177218,
-0.0324768908,
-0.0045271679,
0.007092535,
-0.0067625521,
0.0461528152,
-0.0439724401,
-0.0506315343,
-0.0397819951,
-0.0213019066,
-0.0018220292,
0.0099148937,
0.0554804951,
0.0094099045,
-0.0010662626,
0.0142644113,
-0.0602432303,
-0.0104265474,
0.0248367637,
0.0346718878,
0.0122771356,
-0.0206628609,
-0.0213880502,
0.0318097137,
0.0605114624,
-0.0003408975,
-0.0207684133,
0.0223892424,
-0.0124113811,
-0.0113765271,
-0.0142216273,
0.0110418117,
0.0122012021,
0.0291875303,
0.0035887421,
0.012849628,
-0.0323791802,
-0.0020559102,
0.0112455301,
-0.1232844964,
0.0166706797,
0.0248640981,
-0.0398337543,
-0.1102324277,
-0.0720864832,
-0.0351656862,
-0.0047168653,
0.0280262772,
-0.0781671628,
-0.0118025411,
0.045549158,
0.0086026462,
-0.0236665867,
0.0157865994,
-0.0147039946,
-0.0152259264,
0.0004537442,
0.0128286174,
0.008865511,
0.0033031073,
-0.0339683928,
0.0403414741,
-0.047571253,
-0.0139603578,
0.0123987207,
-0.0103825182,
0.012345247,
0.0068417876,
-0.0012877488,
0.0076384787,
0.0196221825,
0.0827703774,
-0.0160660651,
-0.054581929,
0.0041536246,
0.0073886113,
-0.0401266478,
0.0386181101,
-0.0741082728,
0.0397572294,
-0.0663976893,
0.0793907121,
-0.0445457213,
0.0017037865,
-0.0088224187,
-0.0276510939,
0.0224115532,
-0.0151495123,
-0.0831524432,
-0.0468599498,
-0.0361743979,
-0.008881879,
0.0027381009,
-0.0079704383,
0.0863007307,
0.0008783042,
0.0028620141,
-0.0198692791,
0.0400830992,
0.004742953,
-0.0300714839,
-0.0799060091,
-0.0266949628,
0.0332760364,
0.0117152035,
-0.0385742038,
0.0118680075,
-0.0218979642,
0.0302888919,
0.0139031708,
-0.0105811069,
-0.0172990151,
-0.0482914001,
0.0446154997,
0.057462085,
0.0249228738,
0.0141935134,
-0.0930009857,
-0.0084428098,
-0.0427784957,
0.0181413349,
0.1232561693,
0.0290494468,
0.0098707033,
0.0221960098,
-0.0109297289,
-0.013029715,
-0.012846333,
0.0433922969,
-0.0369995497,
-0.0151868686,
0.0216469951,
-0.0200454481,
0.0372378938,
0.0635794923,
0.0046141385,
0.0306429639,
0.0431465358,
-0.035975799,
-0.013103283,
-0.0431856327,
-0.0138237895,
0.066509828,
-0.020805452,
-0.0125168152,
-0.0398216546,
0.0159086771,
0.0811585411,
-0.0113573978,
-0.0432928987,
-0.0045958878,
0.0452965982,
0.0110119125,
0.0125989234,
0.0210686792,
-0.0363650732,
0.0174964238,
-0.0203062203,
-0.0055863759,
0.0310976952,
-6.372202062e-33,
-0.0018574139,
-0.0216321908,
-0.0014516929,
-0.0413002037,
-0.0452365391,
0.0693438873,
-0.0221432559,
-0.0518889129,
0.0431190357,
-0.0216498729,
0.0198813025,
0.0164747499,
0.0278500598,
-0.0254135802,
0.0062041357,
-0.0271721277,
0.0589909442,
-0.0113608036,
-0.0346703753,
0.0656929165,
0.0732321441,
0.0202125181,
0.0452566035,
-0.001377061,
0.0037476625,
-0.0125011168,
0.0120707667,
-0.0369249284,
0.0852541924,
0.0493619107,
-0.0184756499,
-0.0036598828,
0.0302683897,
-0.0627911538,
-0.027384406,
0.0031322783,
-0.0454369672,
-0.0050835204,
0.0112800449,
-0.0558645539,
-0.0518833101,
-0.0285026766,
0.0302574001,
0.0354281589,
0.0284501128,
-0.0202781092,
0.0195854101,
0.0016984401,
-0.0166815575,
-0.0871583745,
-0.0086946329,
0.0608195923,
-0.0628434122,
-0.0191210322,
-0.0101264492,
0.0816555619,
0.0367181189,
0.0253757853,
-0.0529298782,
0.0385641456,
-0.0429504625,
0.0376052111,
0.0397541299,
-0.0060270233,
-0.0120614199,
0.0577722341,
-0.0370949954,
-0.0033190281,
-0.0268368702,
0.0254515167,
-0.0061367634,
0.0140460636,
0.0289331954,
0.0545691662,
0.0325307809,
-0.0199902412,
-0.1033156514,
0.0811835974,
-0.0038575321,
0.0091203265,
0.0429604761,
0.0357861817,
0.0044957879,
0.0040966226,
-0.0005805928,
0.0031752919,
-0.0137504991,
0.0196770094,
0.0069615892,
0.0456412658,
0.0065861163,
0.0697258562,
0.0208262093,
0.0014685291,
0.0105261486,
0.0018540014,
0.0015290582,
0.0281662997,
0.0041628508,
0.0575405918,
-0.0296702739,
0.0148533005,
0.0611832328,
0.0123942019,
-0.0229444113,
-0.0068806023,
0.004591797,
-0.0000888523,
-0.0130804284,
0.0191209372,
0.0015747217,
0.0158511493,
-0.049858354,
0.0216158237,
0.0168444719,
-0.0150120044,
0.0175615549,
-0.0240748171,
0.0115246931,
0.0549776219,
0.0469043925,
-0.0548956022,
-0.0209352802,
0.0370989181,
0.0311664417,
0.0083734971,
-0.0403786488,
0.04070694,
-0.0456350185,
-0.0506479777,
-0.0311527718,
0.040170867,
2.682e-7,
0.0313810892,
0.0153430868,
0.0711863637,
0.0099983783,
-0.0071196184,
-0.0242530126,
-0.0160892121,
0.0487449318,
0.001327732,
0.0434769876,
0.0279493853,
0.0682107881,
0.0223746654,
0.0549209714,
-0.0911642462,
-0.0144986669,
-0.1287215799,
0.0292124785,
-0.0662011802,
-0.029014999,
0.0759677887,
0.0492279455,
0.0078291679,
0.0173214786,
0.0259302612,
-0.0094146412,
0.0053364164,
0.0229434818,
-0.0655468777,
0.0263487883,
0.0579587147,
0.0531909391,
-0.0356857516,
-0.0152495829,
-0.0104537448,
-0.0034600976,
0.0473043472,
0.0324425399,
0.0229357798,
-0.0567768663,
-0.0166132934,
0.0073473467,
0.0268994421,
-0.0140820062,
0.0555952191,
-0.0632636771,
-0.010786064,
0.0180106629,
-0.0697849244,
0.0552966595,
0.0360260457,
0.0199067462,
-0.0582193211,
0.047177732,
-0.018469099,
0.013374879,
-0.0019926536,
-0.0498940162,
0.0245174058,
0.0194263514,
0.0063180886,
-0.0518863052,
-0.0559078939,
0.0173279215,
0.0306140538,
-0.0373039469,
0.0324651301,
1.92718281e-34,
0.0509454012,
0.0288436394,
-0.0570375398,
-0.0373706147,
-0.007326684,
-0.0098335156,
-0.0429480188,
-0.0145569136,
0.0136556597,
-0.0323470198,
-0.0260181483
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06836v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06836v2 | Enhancing Emotional Generation Capability of Large Language Models via Emotional Chain-of-Thought | 2024-01-12T16:42:10 | 2024-02-21T15:13:50 | Zaijing Li, Gongwei Chen, Rui Shao, Dongmei Jiang, Liqiang Nie | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown remarkable performance in various
emotion recognition tasks, thereby piquing the research community's curiosity
for exploring their potential in emotional intelligence. However, several
issues in the field of emotional generation tasks remain unresolved, including
human preference alignment and emotional generation assessment. In this paper,
we propose the Emotional Chain-of-Thought (ECoT), a plug-and-play prompting
method that enhances the performance of LLMs on various emotional generation
tasks by aligning with human emotional intelligence guidelines. To assess the
reliability of ECoT, we propose an automated model-based evaluation method
called Emotional Generation Score (EGS). EGS incorporates Goleman's Emotional
Intelligence Theory as a consensus of human experts, providing a new
perspective on the evaluation of emotional generation tasks. Extensive
experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of ECoT and EGS. Further, we
discuss the promise of LLMs in the field of emotional intelligence and present
key insights into the LLMs with the ECoT in emotional generation tasks. | [
0.0280123688,
0.0597541146,
-0.0124653038,
0.0217542872,
-0.0213825498,
0.020432869,
0.0347006097,
-0.0195891224,
0.0471220613,
-0.0224064905,
-0.0523865856,
-0.0270458516,
-0.0243421569,
0.0459615253,
0.0124404449,
-0.1012504324,
-0.007733956,
0.0286588483,
0.0741248354,
-0.0239139572,
-0.0059318128,
0.0496672541,
-0.0140967751,
0.034492895,
-0.043484401,
-0.0245061833,
-0.0189357661,
0.0276082102,
0.0543215461,
-0.0649924874,
0.0008694156,
0.0421996526,
-0.0169041008,
-0.0036002442,
0.0000021777,
-0.0603586584,
0.0263137855,
-0.0342898369,
-0.0018475382,
0.0006231891,
0.1064390093,
0.0333414562,
-0.0247834213,
0.0110742403,
-0.0221053977,
0.0333386101,
0.0477022938,
0.0514276698,
0.0656337515,
0.0550232567,
-0.0319406465,
0.01029085,
0.0056743845,
-0.0220634062,
0.0002624487,
-0.006197534,
0.0078964969,
-0.0002962998,
0.0055390159,
-0.05906564,
-0.0057621077,
0.0104311407,
0.0042275819,
-0.0087559903,
0.0061039082,
0.0010757948,
-0.0331803672,
-0.0556127317,
-0.0323314704,
0.0615818724,
-0.004902869,
0.0384807661,
-0.0258398522,
-0.0087635815,
0.0287552904,
0.0140593285,
-0.0179192517,
0.0165306665,
0.0192473494,
0.0119381733,
0.0066583967,
0.0228721313,
-0.0171501432,
0.0255776085,
0.012013562,
0.032016065,
-0.0044373116,
-0.0192784164,
0.0617937855,
0.0135511961,
-0.0458933078,
-0.0383209363,
0.0176925156,
0.0090777399,
0.0065649068,
0.0084573571,
-0.0284360554,
0.0013493948,
-0.0354690515,
-0.0246462617,
0.0319513902,
0.0254094768,
-0.0139119122,
-0.0014163285,
-0.0022612205,
0.0802647173,
0.0100392895,
-0.0171799511,
-0.041748561,
0.0287381206,
-0.0201698206,
0.0033463552,
-0.0060484237,
0.0092042284,
-0.0334275812,
-0.0506909639,
-0.0807347521,
-0.006118706,
-0.048880443,
-0.0115769077,
-0.0353063606,
0.0226331688,
0.0285068043,
-0.0049259444,
-0.0224575661,
0.0182388816,
-0.035403382,
0.0199990068,
0.0413191654,
-0.0171115566,
0.0282235686,
0.0253225192,
-0.0123849623,
-0.0012580956,
0.0527019687,
0.0302105322,
-0.0006091575,
-0.0272919517,
-0.0520865694,
-0.0180883594,
-0.0222206935,
-0.0689156726,
0.0223588031,
-0.0322155468,
0.0375907794,
0.0063400702,
0.0211146455,
-0.0213419739,
0.021964876,
-0.028551206,
-0.0177946407,
-0.0099882521,
-0.0139564946,
0.0075055473,
-0.0246737823,
0.0067057698,
-0.0094840275,
0.0369436406,
0.0379366949,
0.0712339282,
0.0395015106,
0.0037496286,
0.0313016921,
0.0330760814,
-0.0364407785,
0.0018564375,
-0.0509347208,
-0.0722792074,
-0.0333746672,
0.0575000569,
0.0538645312,
0.0507689863,
-0.0220057797,
0.0280376393,
0.0507270508,
0.0230254773,
0.0048936256,
0.0681354925,
0.0241892673,
0.0390950702,
0.0310798474,
0.025888931,
-0.0107020224,
0.0528255887,
-0.0549505129,
0.0057033929,
-0.0043835058,
0.0437669158,
-0.0084969355,
-0.0370338038,
-0.0112872571,
-0.011829596,
-0.0132138561,
0.0112603381,
-0.0020928639,
-0.0242033452,
-0.0514421239,
-0.0288334358,
0.0237508006,
-0.0765138194,
-0.0025752799,
-0.0358529538,
0.0267125275,
0.1147635877,
0.0122225322,
0.0125223901,
-0.0003019688,
-0.000478025,
-0.0202830881,
0.0534381941,
0.031787686,
-0.0288524553,
0.0032762177,
-0.0722252429,
0.0215517059,
0.0008275393,
-0.0047833296,
0.0040544611,
-0.0343803614,
0.0313385054,
0.0032895631,
0.0148825701,
-0.00625068,
-0.002694505,
-0.0384700857,
-0.003945943,
-0.0187878404,
0.017303193,
0.0177821219,
0.0051880837,
-0.0237990636,
-0.0080271354,
0.0276032519,
-0.0028271184,
-0.0120342765,
0.0383225046,
-0.0212720856,
-0.0038159078,
0.0146244196,
-0.0202504434,
-0.0262175724,
0.0191521049,
-0.0052092513,
-0.0238580648,
0.032567136,
-0.0476340204,
0.006174155,
-0.0154901957,
0.0436637029,
-0.023342682,
0.0348070972,
-0.0048907185,
0.0301419869,
-0.010062133,
-0.0053336429,
0.0214683004,
0.0133163398,
-0.0212954152,
-0.0392810553,
-0.0293588582,
0.0190793928,
0.0195974149,
0.0043961066,
0.0029591215,
0.0105320392,
-0.08621566,
-0.1053201705,
-0.1026995704,
-0.0030967852,
0.032952629,
-0.0091510778,
0.0061119138,
-0.0396060832,
-0.0550852343,
0.0423165336,
-0.0428661928,
0.0279640984,
0.0177222267,
-0.0219100881,
-0.0178910811,
-0.0290958602,
-0.0201201607,
-0.0569086298,
0.0188612267,
-0.0074677928,
0.0421867259,
0.0274889022,
0.0041319574,
-0.0252832435,
0.0262946878,
-0.0687321797,
-0.0014974353,
0.0111704972,
-0.0814123824,
0.0294356979,
0.0277210698,
0.0633869544,
0.0782223418,
0.0489296652,
0.0540873483,
0.0278612394,
-0.0205708183,
-0.0593913309,
0.0192186274,
-0.0039134561,
0.0381031968,
-0.0102315769,
-0.0433541462,
-0.0140529033,
0.0306386389,
0.0061836038,
0.0193841681,
-0.0442872606,
0.0746318623,
0.0285180472,
-0.0503277853,
0.0068724537,
-0.0358500294,
-0.018522827,
0.0487938672,
0.0179484989,
-0.0579723828,
0.0356338322,
0.00886836,
-0.0181754269,
-0.0574834459,
0.0187727641,
-0.0027586822,
0.0761245117,
-0.0616457686,
0.0310076214,
-0.0188398268,
0.0354865901,
-0.0542668365,
-0.0297983773,
-0.0437998287,
-0.0566086397,
0.0079065422,
-0.0353547782,
-0.0570108555,
0.0506894253,
-0.0053872848,
-0.0482610799,
-0.0126441764,
-0.0679412931,
-0.0244334396,
0.0406241231,
-0.0094749369,
-0.0148124117,
-0.0244371612,
0.0633992776,
-0.0730943233,
-0.0219491888,
-0.024093613,
0.045287244,
0.0152669754,
0.0779689774,
-0.0075974483,
0.0525009967,
-0.0389293619,
0.0634708628,
0.0318221226,
0.0264388453,
0.0082743634,
-0.0163351148,
0.0538610183,
0.0149580538,
0.039153304,
-0.0190350823,
-0.0077292924,
-0.013166856,
-0.0112414714,
0.0462405011,
0.126009509,
0.0347885564,
-0.0232642945,
0.0273826551,
-0.0468596816,
0.0399820805,
0.0104851266,
0.0274463575,
-0.0307559632,
-0.0071374783,
0.0193542317,
0.0208882354,
-0.0334705375,
-0.0379304327,
-0.0116900224,
-0.0993697047,
0.0674235746,
0.0347407982,
0.0161362197,
-0.0124897016,
0.0196011234,
0.0249479711,
0.0259400588,
-0.0166101754,
-0.0131476363,
0.0063552302,
-0.0073561748,
0.0301173124,
-0.0036301822,
-0.0344031639,
0.033004459,
-0.0236685779,
0.0642050132,
0.0376169235,
0.0915381536,
-0.0049803327,
-0.0511646532,
0.0051087216,
0.0210225116,
0.0042524985,
0.0044515771,
0.0479131453,
0.0093551073,
-0.0085160593,
-0.0441883169,
0.0167468842,
0.0096724713,
0.0031898837,
0.0050014779,
0.036046613,
-0.024073232,
-0.0504245907,
-0.0274201259,
0.0502981022,
-0.0162312649,
0.0615402237,
0.0249666292,
-0.1047889143,
0.0065242839,
-0.0011781235,
0.0346038267,
-0.0227563996,
-0.0563001148,
0.0220302753,
-0.0132813975,
-0.0137229254,
-0.0890458003,
-0.0568123683,
0.014015113,
0.0412339233,
-0.0038356383,
-0.0519767925,
-0.0096170958,
-0.0062503153,
0.0018797651,
0.0260698479,
0.0108863907,
0.0049333242,
-0.0395371318,
-0.0203066673,
-0.0000035506,
-0.0627091527,
0.007783148,
0.0306457318,
0.0438446514,
-0.0552775487,
0.045633778,
0.0357938595,
0.0228410624,
0.0022777296,
0.0457285233,
-0.0379262269,
0.0309250597,
0.0089392038,
0.0086120972,
0.0159185622,
0.0184451044,
0.0541629903,
-0.0264688991,
0.0132011101,
-0.0348986462,
0.0642082542,
-0.0022043814,
0.0327999592,
0.0265231635,
-0.089487724,
-0.0065401783,
0.060562294,
-0.0124507099,
-0.0490163229,
-0.025525894,
-0.0451925285,
-0.034067966,
-0.031334132,
-0.0194629207,
-0.0674104467,
-0.0155122075,
0.0083010495,
0.0375804454,
-0.0424048789,
-0.0887082517,
-0.0162018463,
-0.028629655,
-0.003725112,
0.015865067,
-0.0264246874,
0.0126780979,
0.007311794,
0.0282261893,
-0.0266258195,
-0.0336949825,
-0.013793638,
0.0093172165,
0.0108118271,
0.0855248719,
-0.0058563617,
-0.0703050047,
0.0105214631,
0.0506817698,
0.0155988373,
0.0117001589,
-0.0239482187,
0.0036698594,
0.0139297964,
-0.01586424,
0.0631141588,
-0.0714896172,
0.0248002652,
-0.0257481635,
0.0060425196,
-0.0118432641,
-0.0624063425,
-0.0178898629,
-0.0018288613,
-0.0292596947,
-0.0069477698,
0.009893029,
-0.0559505671,
0.0453651622,
-0.0219573658,
-0.0068468009,
-0.0615585931,
-0.0040482963,
0.0338398479,
-0.066831179,
0.0054698181,
0.0266051609,
-0.101587519,
-0.0597024001,
0.0461762361,
-0.010481799,
0.0244592987,
-0.0425332524,
0.0453177691,
0.0469721928,
-0.0697642863,
0.0575427637,
-0.0179252848,
-0.0092219384,
-0.0873486102,
-0.0020164379,
-0.0361027308,
-6.057367573e-33,
-0.0175496489,
-0.0146575589,
-0.0202464871,
-0.0002123208,
-0.0587815344,
0.0131645855,
-0.04222605,
0.0412422977,
0.010631823,
0.0641640574,
-0.0004636972,
-0.0310066342,
-0.0015671945,
-0.0104225017,
-0.0088486439,
-0.0032426252,
0.014280566,
-0.0017429671,
-0.0346008204,
0.0278950576,
0.029707564,
0.0057132533,
0.012359418,
-0.0805236623,
0.0030093004,
0.0175563581,
-0.0383670963,
-0.0282971039,
0.0610869005,
0.0489847884,
-0.0104398923,
0.059047997,
0.0091952495,
0.0147182103,
-0.0004252772,
0.0133890416,
0.049496837,
-0.0156488344,
-0.0014039177,
-0.0268861465,
-0.0388764404,
-0.0400482453,
-0.0113970051,
0.0235806946,
-0.0376897827,
-0.0096775647,
0.0190532021,
-0.0363089889,
0.0216090772,
-0.06695389,
-0.0500553399,
0.0081547406,
-0.027615374,
-0.0496376045,
0.0127921076,
0.0716544166,
-0.0166714154,
-0.0055292295,
0.0146355126,
0.0304485783,
-0.0078633577,
-0.0265491903,
0.0353944376,
-0.0202296022,
-0.0041574868,
0.0903930068,
0.0142353503,
0.00881531,
-0.0143696135,
0.0481205359,
0.0318498909,
0.0546663292,
0.0685771704,
0.0051266076,
-0.0645467788,
-0.0084337322,
0.0059514707,
0.0410218351,
0.0365880504,
0.0008094851,
0.0536515713,
0.0086954078,
-0.0221565105,
0.026791187,
-0.0128877712,
-0.0344954133,
-0.0264027715,
-0.0359595083,
0.0312525779,
-0.0145936599,
-0.0234222692,
-0.0678585023,
0.0086508328,
0.0050880574,
0.0132961925,
0.0206976663,
-0.0809371695,
0.0760105029,
-0.006521449,
0.003958812,
0.0188456383,
-0.0076741357,
0.061053399,
0.0391710475,
0.0617833175,
0.0103539359,
-0.024216637,
0.0326252133,
-0.0414366908,
-0.0028030858,
-0.0318426415,
0.0746051371,
0.0144840926,
-0.0533042252,
-0.0424856283,
0.0011124323,
-0.0323559754,
-0.0406411663,
0.0135958586,
0.0292266011,
0.0062481812,
0.021167988,
-0.0080394354,
0.0307879057,
-0.0609567091,
0.0388904922,
-0.0030105361,
-0.0496005416,
0.0172630586,
-0.0211439617,
-0.0143328449,
0.0124010053,
2.941e-7,
-0.0313973054,
0.0671686232,
0.0278559998,
-0.020703895,
-0.0022774793,
0.0514798276,
-0.0124995811,
-0.0050248858,
0.089793101,
-0.0190833025,
0.007857915,
-0.0015826543,
0.0908244327,
-0.0057643829,
-0.085956037,
0.0009306617,
-0.0233041029,
0.0318875089,
-0.0175350942,
0.0111249862,
0.0799845234,
0.0380110368,
0.0106548099,
-0.0047643534,
0.01105629,
0.023401292,
0.0342198871,
-0.0451691113,
-0.0149824116,
0.0005518289,
0.0135417329,
-0.047735054,
0.0113470731,
0.0296240784,
-0.0036689611,
0.000896459,
0.0245325491,
0.0448598005,
0.0178996976,
-0.0281441323,
0.0423088036,
0.0342192389,
-0.0273378845,
-0.0316139832,
0.0238582268,
-0.0583467782,
-0.0284784809,
-0.0270163696,
-0.0387776233,
-0.0104941344,
0.0421064161,
-0.0504863635,
-0.0312029887,
0.0422352143,
0.0101441564,
-0.0336415544,
0.00920064,
-0.0219061617,
-0.0041217101,
0.0173612759,
-0.0453739315,
-0.0478375331,
-0.032541506,
0.0420189016,
0.0036510325,
-0.038695816,
-0.0046407082,
2.276316341e-34,
0.0084078927,
-0.0072814296,
0.0189270601,
0.0029783431,
0.0576441251,
0.0234795418,
-0.0296956785,
0.0059215226,
0.0174917765,
-0.0607460365,
0.0029614402
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06373v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06373v2 | How Johnny Can Persuade LLMs to Jailbreak Them: Rethinking Persuasion to Challenge AI Safety by Humanizing LLMs | 2024-01-12T16:13:24 | 2024-01-23T22:46:12 | Yi Zeng, Hongpeng Lin, Jingwen Zhang, Diyi Yang, Ruoxi Jia, Weiyan Shi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Most traditional AI safety research has approached AI models as machines and
centered on algorithm-focused attacks developed by security experts. As large
language models (LLMs) become increasingly common and competent, non-expert
users can also impose risks during daily interactions. This paper introduces a
new perspective to jailbreak LLMs as human-like communicators, to explore this
overlooked intersection between everyday language interaction and AI safety.
Specifically, we study how to persuade LLMs to jailbreak them. First, we
propose a persuasion taxonomy derived from decades of social science research.
Then, we apply the taxonomy to automatically generate interpretable persuasive
adversarial prompts (PAP) to jailbreak LLMs. Results show that persuasion
significantly increases the jailbreak performance across all risk categories:
PAP consistently achieves an attack success rate of over $92\%$ on Llama 2-7b
Chat, GPT-3.5, and GPT-4 in $10$ trials, surpassing recent algorithm-focused
attacks. On the defense side, we explore various mechanisms against PAP and,
found a significant gap in existing defenses, and advocate for more fundamental
mitigation for highly interactive LLMs | [
0.0624218583,
0.0617769547,
-0.0082821939,
0.0028933494,
-0.0218849834,
-0.0209506042,
0.023347605,
-0.0036308556,
0.0686204582,
-0.0095246574,
-0.0191332381,
-0.0053105415,
0.0330964029,
0.0039199772,
0.0573663116,
-0.0324811488,
0.0173314139,
-0.0316163972,
0.0381137021,
0.0187092479,
0.0409692824,
-0.0029411996,
-0.0004769765,
0.0530087315,
-0.0016191003,
-0.0343344621,
-0.0272893645,
0.0104888193,
0.0186618138,
-0.0538964272,
-0.009541275,
0.0324248299,
0.0104882428,
0.0137444073,
0.0000020096,
-0.0428495817,
0.0180093292,
0.0121819153,
-0.050138291,
0.0367319174,
0.0435901769,
-0.0417758115,
-0.0299745426,
0.0248137489,
-0.056914106,
0.0517894551,
0.0307215638,
0.0663611367,
0.0666503832,
0.0764109045,
-0.0113549363,
0.0104467385,
0.0588894412,
-0.0069304621,
0.0064217439,
-0.0678005666,
-0.0043030391,
-0.0404342301,
-0.0046281773,
0.0234709252,
0.0367853008,
-0.0073257154,
0.0163033362,
-0.0140132662,
-0.0551426969,
0.0075804391,
-0.0216177609,
-0.0251104776,
-0.0053282361,
0.0501711667,
-0.0160312466,
-0.0162980072,
0.0169065557,
0.0297723133,
0.0516603217,
0.0329513066,
-0.0214164965,
0.0138283735,
-0.0225745011,
-0.0264647994,
-0.0007408374,
0.0092426436,
0.0615300164,
0.0336958393,
-0.0027728744,
0.0122548984,
-0.0157728791,
-0.0188746657,
0.0365602188,
-0.0501857996,
0.0276852883,
-0.0461767018,
0.0093007013,
0.000440211,
-0.0271704309,
0.0029323522,
-0.058152128,
-0.0092140427,
0.0277722832,
-0.0629034564,
-0.0002843023,
0.0098708197,
0.0050774929,
-0.0034546566,
0.0246926211,
-0.0219686087,
-0.0135991536,
0.0341351889,
0.0279800892,
0.018329205,
-0.0321204551,
-0.0283828992,
-0.0036998326,
-0.0072292062,
0.0372528285,
0.0170381665,
-0.0409819894,
0.0402972512,
-0.0654119849,
0.0326405428,
-0.0571029112,
0.0051526185,
-0.0083939573,
0.0000537265,
0.0074122599,
-0.0321990997,
-0.0451766625,
-0.0061905459,
0.0197712276,
-0.0795962662,
-0.0289045032,
0.0264750123,
-0.0597661249,
-0.0037853487,
-0.0184905622,
0.1008271053,
0.0077370154,
-0.0178055596,
-0.0734169856,
-0.0753739774,
-0.0290233791,
-0.0215396415,
-0.0026627297,
-0.0470202751,
-0.0027223891,
-0.010158374,
-0.0006097462,
-0.0794110149,
0.0017346094,
-0.0160854887,
-0.0176738687,
0.0696384981,
0.0099040428,
-0.0139456326,
0.0266281627,
0.0756756514,
-0.004858756,
0.0245210342,
0.0131835537,
0.0886778384,
0.0388014354,
0.0069702747,
0.0975258574,
0.037654154,
0.0068733967,
0.0103422571,
0.0207445771,
-0.0261683073,
-0.0204128884,
-0.017118644,
-0.012491852,
0.0287456438,
-0.0074554482,
-0.0147363218,
0.0920936167,
0.0527302772,
-0.0698147491,
0.035968747,
-0.0204096977,
0.0044939104,
0.019584721,
-0.0177126508,
-0.0494020693,
0.0113894204,
-0.0904740766,
-0.0390676893,
-0.0061535994,
0.0199553147,
-0.0289892964,
-0.0023055854,
0.0176560506,
-0.028251091,
0.0228806101,
0.0302909687,
-0.0036879086,
0.0359245166,
0.0059122061,
-0.0184059422,
0.0194890462,
-0.004602618,
-0.0489545166,
-0.0905389041,
-0.0201597661,
0.058313217,
0.0212019272,
0.0170148257,
0.0209637098,
-0.0212113913,
0.0105362488,
0.0334445983,
0.0136159174,
-0.0044854037,
-0.0219637472,
0.0010882927,
0.0091014234,
-0.0186374299,
0.0102159847,
0.0365670621,
-0.0190175492,
-0.0051732836,
0.0000818254,
-0.0114463931,
-0.0545134582,
0.0112839416,
0.0343012325,
-0.0294708461,
-0.0203801487,
0.0367888846,
0.0341632217,
0.0356943458,
0.0056772833,
0.01440793,
0.0599181801,
-0.022212876,
0.0096290065,
0.0144821731,
-0.0248179585,
0.0454856679,
0.0165685639,
-0.0369837396,
-0.0173589457,
0.0473523214,
-0.0283385906,
0.0283396952,
0.0789618194,
-0.0579613894,
0.0351235233,
0.012126199,
0.0024829814,
0.016524028,
-0.014777774,
-0.0036753342,
0.0164756011,
-0.0045428919,
-0.0711391643,
0.0125897825,
0.0068013286,
0.0135781951,
-0.0112531772,
-0.0206496976,
0.0124488184,
-0.0355202667,
0.0317184366,
0.0264089014,
-0.0059015569,
-0.0376415923,
-0.0048421877,
-0.0672941729,
-0.0661024898,
-0.0319297835,
0.0174714215,
0.0416119657,
0.0040195771,
-0.0130007798,
-0.0193850957,
-0.0358985066,
-0.0243218187,
-0.0202992298,
0.0193034112,
0.0175291337,
-0.022539299,
-0.0530854762,
-0.0181920826,
0.0156022701,
-0.0063265641,
0.0231710039,
0.0075722407,
-0.0367914177,
0.0073178727,
-0.0073769377,
-0.0241703987,
-0.0126129622,
-0.041161526,
-0.0366462767,
0.0715966597,
0.0242934506,
0.0068317987,
0.0606744848,
0.0480394624,
0.089607738,
0.0541035123,
0.0520910807,
-0.0581231378,
-0.0323827267,
0.041259896,
-0.0312044118,
-0.030023206,
-0.075394243,
0.0377332717,
0.0242549777,
0.0465707183,
0.0488551743,
-0.0154893417,
0.0688069388,
0.0157499164,
-0.0483790487,
-0.0212989412,
-0.0418796539,
-0.0301609822,
0.0371718891,
-0.0050894348,
-0.0738743022,
0.0717615411,
-0.0350181349,
0.0031536482,
0.0196778551,
-0.0693082213,
0.022777589,
0.067628853,
-0.0391616449,
0.0042611901,
0.0518998429,
-0.0140475174,
-0.0278741028,
-0.0621042773,
0.0016645037,
-0.0252787881,
0.0104143405,
-0.045188684,
-0.0020365096,
0.0535095632,
-0.022012949,
-0.0462195687,
-0.0658055916,
-0.0668609589,
-0.0324023217,
0.0159157198,
-0.0613169484,
-0.0104215061,
-0.0557678752,
0.0499832928,
-0.0186175983,
0.0213639066,
-0.0284016822,
-0.0204743315,
-0.0277180802,
0.0267057437,
-0.0128539093,
-0.0110810297,
-0.0076243104,
0.0520698167,
0.0767280534,
0.0256544072,
-0.016499158,
-0.0258025229,
-0.0193003062,
-0.0015266965,
0.0209943205,
0.0175319072,
0.0306182522,
0.0426618271,
-0.0029675665,
0.0036472417,
0.0290912744,
0.0116237681,
-0.0145573383,
0.0407938622,
-0.0085476357,
0.0516230054,
-0.0150969895,
0.0195044763,
-0.0607106201,
-0.0236360151,
0.0154406624,
0.0784938633,
-0.0463010594,
0.0150809307,
-0.0253149346,
-0.0567305014,
0.0098867659,
0.0300017316,
0.0139157735,
-0.00053851,
-0.0326667465,
-0.0392367728,
0.0005538856,
0.0371327624,
-0.0432544686,
0.0098447474,
0.0108461687,
0.0066923317,
-0.0626156628,
-0.0097592659,
0.0158038363,
-0.0281859096,
0.0721504912,
0.0984131172,
0.0115067493,
-0.0360208526,
-0.0177413188,
0.0432406738,
0.0349616371,
-0.0005414978,
0.0029827082,
0.0283370856,
-0.0079459669,
0.0120738586,
-0.021430077,
0.0471417345,
-0.0051390389,
-0.0435234234,
0.0608358346,
0.032937523,
-0.0321193598,
-0.0333771743,
-0.0086624958,
0.0130647412,
0.0441233292,
0.0429460667,
0.0270529874,
-0.0367810726,
-0.00483263,
-0.0809552893,
-0.013471161,
-0.0020540948,
-0.0662381724,
-0.0237065516,
0.0150180543,
-0.0341383144,
-0.0414019376,
-0.0381429344,
-0.0170452595,
0.0155020114,
0.0406382643,
-0.031498123,
-0.0203525349,
0.0441853628,
0.0215939712,
0.0151842078,
-0.0115303965,
0.0534025356,
-0.0449709669,
0.0049727703,
-0.0289492682,
-0.0460915901,
0.0143713877,
0.0215809047,
0.0099697858,
-0.0614785291,
0.0105562871,
0.0537313931,
0.0255780015,
0.003670817,
-0.037340343,
-0.0562100261,
0.068847999,
0.0811270773,
-0.0385232903,
0.0125110717,
0.0972625017,
0.0153990677,
0.0113836788,
0.0061264066,
-0.0090799453,
-0.0102945128,
0.0367508605,
-0.0065671965,
-0.0894175768,
-0.0128835402,
0.0452040173,
0.0481695347,
0.0026690033,
-0.0192738306,
0.0033991265,
0.0441959202,
-0.016218517,
0.0213449188,
-0.0166544095,
0.0197844505,
-0.0002382208,
0.0081041995,
-0.0323066153,
0.0451747142,
0.0216780994,
-0.0381776169,
-0.0114466054,
0.0109249242,
0.0295226369,
-0.0109543866,
0.0835352018,
0.0158814173,
0.0158272963,
0.0061256387,
0.0813827142,
-0.0174231213,
0.0402923897,
0.0192749351,
0.0430486016,
-0.0204757564,
-0.0154310325,
-0.009431907,
0.0579031706,
-0.074030675,
-0.0839726925,
0.0491000935,
0.071942918,
-0.0114161326,
0.0445745178,
0.006906366,
-0.0125724589,
0.0212836452,
-0.0288570598,
0.0028072149,
-0.0035477476,
-0.0347473212,
0.0089022284,
-0.0106189651,
-0.0311808679,
0.0183795523,
0.0345216617,
-0.0559741892,
0.0501829349,
0.016958002,
-0.0211041328,
-0.0260402523,
-0.0298249424,
0.0634720474,
0.0323615037,
-0.0318589583,
-0.0661788434,
-0.078872934,
-0.0499497689,
-0.0384765565,
0.0033735612,
0.011998645,
-0.0356911831,
-0.0140387518,
0.0433328822,
-0.019434737,
0.0372271873,
-0.0458834916,
0.0243046824,
-0.0094935959,
-0.0516569875,
-0.0070533114,
-5.557794229e-33,
0.0425484367,
-0.0719159916,
-0.0460813232,
-0.0165308602,
0.0020254008,
-0.0222563297,
-0.0151409339,
0.0423522405,
-0.0405088365,
0.0062746918,
-0.0160925668,
0.0172045305,
-0.0013241266,
-0.0250403062,
-0.0270121712,
-0.0498379543,
0.0096027823,
-0.0151555743,
-0.0164906979,
0.0501967594,
0.0410477072,
-0.0051440257,
-0.0365113802,
-0.0989012048,
0.1105916873,
-0.0118669774,
-0.0538967811,
-0.0199669115,
-0.0169497877,
0.0161319859,
0.0076796631,
0.0307480954,
-0.0034585404,
0.0085352948,
0.0071452348,
0.0972776264,
0.0349711925,
-0.0129109779,
0.0352906883,
-0.0356327258,
-0.0027910538,
-0.0625097081,
-0.0097678211,
-0.0279992409,
-0.0306518581,
0.016713025,
-0.016567884,
0.0037994892,
0.0082905376,
-0.0064043463,
-0.0187236108,
-0.0142543791,
-0.0469763316,
-0.0284146797,
-0.0277742147,
0.0461843088,
-0.0098240431,
-0.0113678686,
-0.0422989242,
0.0471130013,
0.026153801,
-0.0300953966,
0.0401320048,
-0.0253265295,
-0.0387725979,
0.0532571115,
0.0013995537,
-0.01446243,
-0.0394312143,
-0.0212626774,
-0.0100891767,
0.0616950803,
0.0478736646,
0.0611404404,
0.0211681947,
-0.0387706831,
-0.0503185801,
0.0166577417,
0.0558122359,
0.0051291622,
0.0160600822,
-0.0254093315,
-0.0775105059,
-0.0221124943,
0.001655521,
-0.0430654399,
-0.0228052735,
-0.0688303784,
-0.0007734745,
-0.0125926202,
-0.0361887813,
-0.0370469838,
-0.029011976,
-0.0581242479,
0.0168621503,
0.0047801146,
0.0176459141,
-0.0125538409,
-0.0029614128,
-0.0106649641,
-0.0039321906,
0.0169481058,
0.0030363232,
-0.0198813509,
0.0524864979,
0.0008003929,
0.0623569377,
0.0296445675,
-0.0203150697,
-0.0308343936,
-0.0174495503,
0.0393097326,
0.0115906717,
-0.0190552585,
0.0091007873,
0.0131874131,
-0.002417715,
-0.0114850374,
0.0005002574,
-0.0173687935,
-0.0344357975,
0.0385822244,
-0.0652302876,
0.027047025,
-0.0214359816,
-0.0008403944,
-0.0327229537,
0.0033090229,
0.0434806049,
-0.0619688481,
-0.004451117,
-0.0731484741,
2.741e-7,
-0.0582991615,
0.003813962,
0.0003933391,
0.0163305011,
0.0179182477,
0.0822237134,
-0.0057163774,
0.0798469782,
-0.0170099176,
-0.0771316662,
-0.0057083368,
0.018228,
0.0617893003,
0.0155338868,
-0.0308278576,
-0.00024195,
-0.0519356765,
-0.0159230419,
-0.0570678785,
0.0343094468,
0.0862780586,
0.0474852286,
0.0034383833,
-0.0365321189,
0.0088595292,
-0.0281501971,
0.0026600864,
-0.0491583273,
0.008599611,
-0.0290045626,
0.0445779227,
0.0116116712,
0.0271079112,
0.0439673997,
-0.0202560853,
-0.0599461831,
-0.0664101094,
0.055647213,
0.0121567156,
-0.0193366408,
-0.0357216336,
-0.0185712185,
0.0108100353,
-0.0169248153,
0.0406747051,
-0.0207853541,
-0.0554896668,
0.001740612,
0.0232560374,
-0.0272377469,
0.0006096126,
-0.028730087,
-0.0145380665,
-0.026061587,
0.0295993406,
0.0066161659,
0.0315421298,
-0.0316171385,
0.019676175,
0.000147312,
0.011830437,
-0.0586196631,
-0.0087124091,
0.0427936278,
0.0394741781,
-0.0079536857,
0.013040998,
2.165651125e-34,
0.0152358981,
-0.0047375159,
0.0172984656,
0.0115796896,
0.0483848862,
0.0459634736,
0.0542985722,
0.0204696748,
0.0473035723,
-0.0345660634,
-0.0121166613
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06665v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06665v1 | PolyTOPS: Reconfigurable and Flexible Polyhedral Scheduler | 2024-01-12T16:11:27 | 2024-01-12T16:11:27 | Gianpietro Consolaro, Zhen Zhang, Harenome Razanajato, Nelson Lossing, Nassim Tchoulak, Adilla Susungi, Artur Cesar Araujo Alves, Renwei Zhang, Denis Barthou, Corinne Ancourt, Cedric Bastoul | cs.DC | cs.DC, cs.CL, cs.PF | Polyhedral techniques have been widely used for automatic code optimization
in low-level compilers and higher-level processes. Loop optimization is central
to this technique, and several polyhedral schedulers like Feautrier, Pluto, isl
and Tensor Scheduler have been proposed, each of them targeting a different
architecture, parallelism model, or application scenario. The need for
scenario-specific optimization is growing due to the heterogeneity of
architectures. One of the most critical cases is represented by NPUs (Neural
Processing Units) used for AI, which may require loop optimization with
different objectives. Another factor to be considered is the framework or
compiler in which polyhedral optimization takes place. Different scenarios,
depending on the target architecture, compilation environment, and application
domain, may require different kinds of optimization to best exploit the
architecture feature set.
We introduce a new configurable polyhedral scheduler, PolyTOPS, that can be
adjusted to various scenarios with straightforward, high-level configurations.
This scheduler allows the creation of diverse scheduling strategies that can be
both scenario-specific (like state-of-the-art schedulers) and kernel-specific,
breaking the concept of a one-size-fits-all scheduler approach. PolyTOPS has
been used with isl and CLooG as code generators and has been integrated in
MindSpore AKG deep learning compiler. Experimental results in different
scenarios show good performance: a geomean speedup of 7.66x on MindSpore (for
the NPU Ascend architecture) hybrid custom operators over isl scheduling, a
geomean speedup up to 1.80x on PolyBench on different multicore architectures
over Pluto scheduling. Finally, some comparisons with different
state-of-the-art tools are presented in the PolyMage scenario. | [
0.0019639614,
0.0628886968,
-0.0405874699,
0.0429854542,
-0.0438833088,
0.0068130526,
0.0575119853,
-0.0480517372,
0.0144762732,
0.0085711163,
0.0124088554,
0.0120060435,
0.002845699,
0.0330139957,
0.0108649228,
-0.0434648208,
0.0258803796,
0.0090564629,
-0.0052586854,
0.0241239704,
-0.044850979,
0.0220291391,
-0.0095797693,
0.0094179166,
0.0013130354,
-0.0096492926,
0.0106884111,
0.063365005,
0.0220858399,
0.0475295745,
0.0381593481,
0.0083399573,
-0.041352164,
-0.0015528451,
0.0000022677,
0.0238331966,
0.0111638336,
0.0221582688,
0.0062076766,
0.0415158346,
0.0391943306,
-0.0196659695,
-0.0247636996,
0.0018227461,
-0.0023649517,
-0.0101675307,
0.0441059656,
-0.0001087697,
0.0483541153,
0.0097886426,
-0.0171806663,
-0.008774654,
0.0188225396,
0.012862145,
-0.0456917919,
-0.0212542545,
-0.0176865291,
-0.0566304177,
-0.0694191754,
-0.0391046964,
0.0283540878,
0.025145296,
0.033436697,
-0.0107113225,
0.0103181452,
-0.0086568268,
-0.0641389191,
-0.0534245633,
-0.0496805198,
0.0219170488,
-0.0843890831,
-0.0093594762,
0.028648464,
0.0013839991,
-0.0516414754,
-0.0808077082,
0.0144630754,
0.0155583322,
-0.0194974225,
-0.0236054417,
0.0349234603,
-0.0026858801,
-0.0193259995,
-0.0046504145,
-0.0105049787,
0.0315502547,
0.0667273998,
0.0368286185,
0.0119794216,
0.0003704251,
0.0103374803,
-0.0559033416,
0.0565345548,
0.0280542448,
-0.0284213703,
-0.0142143695,
-0.065308243,
-0.0017931729,
-0.0254546814,
-0.0766996443,
0.053530205,
0.077509895,
0.0227693804,
-0.007628344,
-0.0357172936,
0.0208726339,
-0.0526772477,
0.0016020152,
-0.0126000717,
0.0305257179,
0.0039546778,
0.0411652848,
-0.0298601687,
-0.0035451557,
-0.0139538478,
0.0406657234,
-0.0388322659,
0.0378047787,
-0.0310064647,
-0.0101115452,
0.0199578274,
0.0081832698,
-0.0056453012,
-0.0001316633,
0.0113197053,
0.0161770172,
-0.0446854383,
-0.0293152891,
-0.0598311536,
-0.0499955267,
-0.0109295817,
0.0419965759,
-0.0243055318,
-0.0228504129,
0.0073243072,
0.0311953761,
-0.042766124,
-0.0021298509,
-0.0130034834,
-0.0454697087,
0.0627645999,
-0.0442686342,
-0.0109363543,
-0.0210265201,
0.0185946021,
-0.0475113466,
-0.0126779648,
0.0380242579,
0.0026693959,
0.0066145179,
0.0248194449,
0.0214160234,
0.0473360121,
-0.0322765261,
0.0332029425,
0.0099955099,
0.0360656679,
0.0428422466,
0.0361283869,
0.0540642813,
-0.0364864469,
-0.0373118632,
-0.0280027185,
0.0174479354,
0.0120873367,
-0.0225681961,
-0.0007402836,
-0.0064459965,
-0.0314973705,
0.0280080047,
0.0304702912,
0.0398820862,
-0.003435951,
-0.0342002995,
-0.0249074493,
-0.0145045826,
-0.0026764774,
0.0420184806,
0.0506196059,
-0.0144502744,
0.0026685901,
-0.0313610882,
-0.0433176979,
0.0674655512,
0.003324643,
-0.0334689282,
-0.0219498724,
0.1029325053,
-0.0020592534,
-0.0050273072,
0.0221614037,
-0.0069005899,
-0.0209756326,
0.0594304763,
0.0088178869,
-0.0082961638,
-0.0886986181,
0.0591704287,
-0.0018442204,
-0.0196175613,
-0.0705642849,
-0.0540398881,
-0.0177350678,
0.0392066054,
0.026043402,
-0.0177678224,
-0.0937901065,
0.0362917744,
-0.0130303269,
0.002281813,
0.0235125609,
-0.0206124764,
0.0524193682,
-0.029962128,
-0.0045499941,
0.033902403,
-0.0203836355,
0.0673306808,
0.0370530747,
-0.0028250243,
-0.0165308025,
0.0509507805,
-0.0255063213,
0.0002731545,
0.0148841757,
-0.0333842672,
0.0382591151,
0.0265392549,
-0.0020814843,
-0.0116863139,
-0.009621718,
-0.0544019677,
0.0667542219,
-0.0475992188,
0.0182064511,
-0.0403706133,
-0.0525112078,
-0.019446468,
0.0243283287,
-0.0354264379,
-0.0025453239,
0.0238433704,
-0.0512510166,
-0.0450989231,
0.0724659115,
0.0302875638,
-0.0018094882,
0.0220444296,
0.0037289569,
-0.0036857021,
0.0206228942,
-0.0686635822,
0.0051684682,
0.0082862014,
-0.0292003583,
0.0325769931,
0.0037532763,
-0.0037094525,
0.0109160775,
0.0003638996,
0.0252889022,
-0.0145507436,
-0.0182057228,
-0.0014190194,
-0.0015920434,
0.0463946313,
-0.0596983619,
-0.1164404303,
0.0348610505,
-0.0358696021,
0.0120275347,
0.029185893,
0.0057785232,
0.0505421013,
-0.018312186,
0.0022858221,
0.0457205363,
-0.0476810522,
-0.0125743942,
-0.0191762839,
0.0038898555,
-0.0614797547,
-0.0197617896,
-0.0698208734,
-0.0169054084,
0.010357324,
-0.0185067635,
-0.0131682362,
-0.0557630435,
-0.0275643766,
0.0359126553,
0.0283043645,
-0.0053049023,
-0.0024069047,
-0.0457920507,
0.0216627773,
0.004051398,
0.0695322677,
-0.0246797949,
-0.0076841223,
0.0140884658,
0.0316066071,
-0.018300198,
0.0654860362,
0.0078617781,
-0.022399636,
0.018878106,
-0.0260571837,
-0.0199746341,
0.0469251275,
0.0011789521,
-0.0067544114,
-0.0158392582,
-0.0096777603,
0.0363566577,
-0.0526370145,
0.0337083004,
-0.0265541319,
0.0021962551,
-0.0015064534,
-0.0130503308,
-0.0457477681,
0.0268830191,
0.0012813905,
-0.0400620028,
-0.0327164009,
-0.0555380099,
-0.0484918691,
-0.0046261996,
0.0346022882,
0.0244654045,
-0.050217364,
-0.0140077248,
0.0026411561,
0.0494361855,
-0.0477869809,
-0.0034742379,
0.0405406989,
0.0225668736,
-0.0068001882,
-0.0364564322,
-0.0125786224,
-0.0221366212,
0.0528888218,
0.006203068,
0.0110076377,
0.0551359877,
-0.0398863815,
0.0373394229,
0.0311538987,
-0.0328033939,
0.0184860528,
-0.0268889945,
-0.0156684462,
-0.0055534951,
-0.016404178,
0.0282933656,
0.0209194794,
-0.0451789387,
0.0612124577,
-0.0363698937,
-0.0316345058,
0.0376103818,
0.0030988646,
-0.0733475536,
0.0150884874,
0.0760413185,
-0.0049590752,
-0.0382949151,
0.0191418976,
0.0189690981,
-0.0440683663,
0.0026398185,
0.009583327,
0.0189412534,
-0.04274901,
-0.022261925,
0.0163617805,
0.0823736191,
0.0448063239,
0.0488283075,
-0.0474635586,
-0.0194880906,
0.0203618761,
0.0030596144,
-0.0276317168,
0.0041780928,
-0.0180319659,
-0.0194644611,
0.0259264745,
-0.0051120911,
-0.0577239692,
0.0115762353,
-0.0226856899,
-0.035226468,
-0.0428214483,
-0.010977082,
0.0113484329,
0.0302430615,
0.00252288,
-0.011886986,
0.0037246048,
0.0264291298,
0.0213878546,
0.0187582001,
-0.0099687371,
0.0245634373,
-0.0033509419,
0.0129751125,
-0.047165785,
0.0184993595,
0.0549639203,
0.0062210159,
-0.0477935709,
-0.0237784013,
0.0101299314,
-0.0195595231,
-0.0093154144,
-0.0216491856,
-0.0092868861,
0.0645007491,
0.0289046057,
0.1114883125,
0.0083917025,
0.0122576524,
-0.0658510178,
-0.0325125717,
0.0548319928,
0.0233880505,
-0.0244530682,
0.0029191412,
-0.0668378845,
-0.0417788997,
-0.0132217603,
-0.1459363997,
-0.0168703254,
-0.0477139205,
0.0004465312,
-0.0210846011,
0.0054600034,
0.0605590679,
-0.0282687526,
0.0648455694,
0.0284603368,
-0.1444041133,
0.0318825617,
0.0087167257,
-0.1281107515,
-0.0376647934,
0.0239600502,
0.0174171049,
-0.0260893945,
-0.0452886112,
0.0091658803,
0.0293010231,
0.0220039859,
0.068129912,
-0.0923237279,
-0.0252959598,
-0.0137986587,
0.059473671,
0.0064544589,
0.0111719994,
0.0222221278,
0.0070341076,
0.0360430665,
0.0254318174,
0.0237806458,
0.0287954174,
0.0228291843,
-0.0621554554,
-0.009511169,
0.0015240021,
-0.0346370824,
0.0427279025,
0.0051869121,
-0.0171321109,
0.0271242093,
-0.018081706,
-0.0623970591,
0.0188019294,
-0.0096521154,
0.0146235265,
-0.0260099266,
0.0139923813,
0.0361640677,
0.0103130033,
0.0414667316,
-0.0616956316,
0.022648599,
0.0006121104,
0.0005288523,
0.0013761842,
-0.0055627408,
0.0525913425,
-0.0015930569,
0.0197258182,
-0.0002082283,
-0.0215367731,
0.0273713451,
0.0047576921,
0.0265701003,
-0.0052466732,
0.0391086601,
0.0159427244,
0.024045391,
-0.0273852628,
-0.0565767251,
-0.0131563339,
0.0508596599,
-0.0653968081,
-0.0110599799,
0.0012429809,
-0.0633295253,
-0.0427226797,
-0.0399781093,
0.0367249921,
0.0325570926,
0.0087681189,
-0.0094977207,
-0.0104363589,
0.0076810806,
-0.0142153054,
-0.0074864915,
-0.0089976899,
0.0152868964,
0.0154592991,
0.0056932317,
-0.0532186888,
0.0297407974,
0.0040473873,
0.0317679308,
0.0204562023,
0.0098304413,
-0.0307415258,
-0.0575048514,
-0.0460954495,
0.0382703319,
0.0272399951,
-0.0394884534,
0.0039211577,
0.015145787,
0.0236929841,
0.0126646347,
0.0354449935,
-0.0399364866,
0.0295170844,
0.0309460275,
0.0095973751,
-0.0503107198,
0.0008473155,
0.027647147,
0.0216216594,
0.000093253,
-0.0078410609,
-6.303105769e-33,
-0.0189718492,
0.006670916,
0.023042189,
0.0103339283,
-0.0363285057,
0.0124189965,
-0.0311139338,
-0.0184135269,
-0.0011211028,
-0.009543567,
-0.0029920537,
-0.0200700574,
0.0219677463,
-0.0136511587,
0.0276677981,
0.0415320285,
0.0545972735,
0.0082188779,
-0.0377585515,
0.0525435172,
0.0037822905,
0.0302931331,
0.0006879502,
0.006878648,
-0.1016933918,
0.0664574876,
0.0721433908,
0.0045669582,
0.0012873041,
-0.0243765004,
0.0001551044,
0.0075826277,
-0.0367329642,
-0.049550578,
-0.0030467031,
-0.0108316774,
-0.0641204715,
-0.0445795879,
0.0468797944,
0.0450283512,
-0.0419234261,
-0.0724696666,
0.0628944039,
0.0475316904,
-0.0472593531,
-0.0177044589,
-0.0396504514,
0.0407711789,
-0.0177047905,
-0.010238017,
-0.0516126975,
0.0181245077,
0.0184901115,
0.0464621782,
0.0479898304,
-0.0330132917,
-0.0377049781,
0.0064162714,
-0.0255899373,
0.0064566974,
-0.0325124152,
0.0489200875,
0.0859752074,
0.0153343529,
0.00495078,
-0.0000975647,
0.1071643233,
0.0505332686,
-0.0451766402,
0.0478963889,
0.0550769381,
0.0061351964,
-0.0084009431,
0.0033012212,
0.0650712177,
-0.0241598226,
-0.0131023694,
-0.0381565392,
0.0310696829,
-0.023271298,
0.0045613786,
0.0014798102,
-0.0016717212,
-0.0431295261,
0.00744334,
0.0282049943,
-0.0294847637,
0.0275984928,
-0.0177357402,
0.0314670205,
-0.032540042,
0.086517483,
0.0162753966,
0.0202842224,
0.0993868187,
0.0766543671,
0.0105781592,
0.0174136553,
0.0589721985,
0.0205255132,
-0.0134674963,
-0.0414224565,
-0.0167440232,
-0.0280160401,
0.0849946514,
-0.0001801569,
0.0026113328,
0.0508440845,
-0.0280318446,
-0.0011884081,
-0.0717034191,
0.0152737563,
0.0071907542,
0.0457036979,
-0.0203826893,
-0.0082495948,
0.01402527,
0.0050613075,
-0.0206857659,
-0.0047053522,
-0.0275876783,
0.0245490652,
0.0331391208,
0.0388594829,
-0.0311615709,
-0.0010260422,
-0.002802135,
-0.014392402,
-0.0606768876,
-0.0795415565,
-0.0514662676,
0.0054945429,
3.033e-7,
-0.0658931434,
0.0696956888,
0.0068737422,
0.0348856896,
0.0275077578,
-0.021144554,
0.0634094626,
0.0206309035,
-0.0331349708,
0.0399340875,
0.0163953695,
-0.0076506906,
0.0169290192,
0.0175867807,
0.031185085,
0.0267220289,
0.0491285846,
0.0763210282,
-0.0439147688,
-0.0137919197,
0.0103950435,
0.0459178872,
0.0155927772,
-0.0380000286,
0.0615432188,
0.029935129,
-0.061258845,
0.0508876406,
0.0349718295,
-0.0165611152,
-0.0116631398,
0.0443869866,
-0.047589466,
-0.0015779607,
0.0185247771,
-0.0096969856,
-0.0241353307,
0.1018605903,
-0.0115689784,
-0.0210803952,
0.0441901051,
-0.0346404836,
-0.0242114831,
-0.0120116584,
0.0360802077,
0.048868902,
-0.0276029222,
-0.0780034289,
0.0391765349,
-0.0273503922,
-0.0012694194,
-0.0202599168,
0.0458274335,
0.029938506,
0.0171212088,
-0.0474326983,
-0.042541638,
-0.0339895822,
-0.0062748957,
0.0377765596,
-0.0358508304,
-0.0102402512,
-0.0538515411,
0.0227631014,
0.0294662174,
0.0128860623,
-0.0000795482,
3.42684682e-34,
0.0300283581,
-0.0035366381,
0.0022929711,
0.0406201594,
0.0135130575,
-0.0122467596,
-0.0320980772,
-0.0264113788,
-0.0329249315,
-0.0312429983,
-0.0731218234
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06659v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06659v2 | WisdoM: Improving Multimodal Sentiment Analysis by Fusing Contextual World Knowledge | 2024-01-12T16:08:07 | 2024-02-20T09:28:50 | Wenbin Wang, Liang Ding, Li Shen, Yong Luo, Han Hu, Dacheng Tao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Sentiment analysis is rapidly advancing by utilizing various data modalities
(e.g., text, image). However, most previous works relied on superficial
information, neglecting the incorporation of contextual world knowledge (e.g.,
background information derived from but beyond the given image and text pairs)
and thereby restricting their ability to achieve better multimodal sentiment
analysis (MSA). In this paper, we proposed a plug-in framework named WisdoM, to
leverage the contextual world knowledge induced from the large vision-language
models (LVLMs) for enhanced MSA. WisdoM utilizes LVLMs to comprehensively
analyze both images and corresponding texts, simultaneously generating
pertinent context. To reduce the noise in the context, we also introduce a
training-free contextual fusion mechanism. Experiments across diverse
granularities of MSA tasks consistently demonstrate that our approach has
substantial improvements (brings an average +1.96% F1 score among five advanced
methods) over several state-of-the-art methods. | [
0.012418475,
0.0904472545,
0.0236487463,
0.0676501244,
-0.0262320563,
0.0180420764,
-0.000898774,
-0.0173830129,
0.0028551409,
-0.1150400713,
-0.0445261411,
-0.0257366765,
-0.0004469217,
0.036782641,
0.0528855547,
-0.0461633727,
0.010342963,
0.0046625333,
-0.0066423658,
-0.0085592279,
0.0511370376,
0.0099481177,
-0.0091191456,
0.0367315561,
-0.0412976705,
-0.0422083139,
0.0229290277,
0.0209338069,
0.0455239415,
-0.0292691793,
0.0017348393,
0.0167232417,
0.0392013155,
0.0136972684,
0.0000019076,
-0.0141595304,
0.0365697108,
0.0045092488,
0.0716326982,
-0.0237312801,
0.0680125952,
-0.0432508774,
0.0212022662,
-0.0221048351,
-0.0486765914,
-0.0044389763,
0.0595295094,
0.0548548587,
0.0699386597,
0.0205341633,
-0.0438485034,
-0.0138647063,
0.0043521146,
-0.0081734015,
0.0334015079,
-0.0442497246,
0.0007383954,
0.0072587109,
-0.0120965922,
0.0065452703,
-0.0641167611,
0.0468346775,
-0.0138102407,
-0.01584539,
0.0105082868,
0.0299949851,
0.0134519888,
-0.0218354743,
-0.0374480858,
0.0891164243,
-0.0117742019,
0.0033741938,
-0.0533837564,
-0.0006213242,
-0.0393075123,
-0.0288566202,
-0.0329715461,
0.0383872651,
0.002847966,
0.0184089504,
-0.0624763221,
0.0210249722,
0.0161143746,
0.0013485322,
-0.0001764777,
0.0037733871,
-0.0079515912,
0.0099928994,
0.0119450595,
0.0520573631,
-0.0340344869,
0.0016554844,
-0.0501346476,
-0.0091327615,
0.0229619332,
0.0018539493,
0.0086917235,
0.0067477915,
-0.0005661059,
-0.0588795431,
0.008712302,
-0.0023662485,
-0.0652117208,
0.0749873295,
-0.0118210986,
-0.012999515,
-0.02118049,
0.0160694942,
-0.0212460812,
-0.0392904803,
-0.0606025308,
0.0124856476,
0.0477969572,
-0.0091856299,
-0.0701133013,
-0.0738820061,
-0.0469148383,
0.0048978631,
-0.0469525047,
0.0012144026,
-0.0077715786,
0.024753321,
0.0291310791,
0.0168157555,
-0.0284625012,
0.0546735339,
0.0175858196,
0.0335222967,
-0.0589765981,
-0.0329899192,
0.0222223941,
0.0619116761,
-0.0091986796,
-0.0137710832,
-0.0010724142,
0.0685223341,
-0.0165833384,
-0.0301959198,
-0.0181420054,
-0.0023925744,
-0.0553934462,
-0.0497612506,
0.0425434709,
-0.047811728,
0.0300864577,
-0.0036104305,
0.0206249245,
0.0105100907,
-0.0034536654,
-0.0101432148,
-0.0293725207,
0.1231356487,
-0.0162540767,
-0.0221824404,
-0.0079799173,
0.0096813366,
0.0193821508,
0.0590066276,
-0.0104663419,
0.0488127246,
0.0342908762,
0.0062306598,
-0.0051838211,
0.0200343356,
-0.0119144162,
-0.0065172398,
-0.0584780276,
0.0016653186,
-0.0328796804,
-0.028728921,
0.0190197397,
0.0452997684,
-0.0123070236,
0.0105710905,
0.0419434421,
0.0140000582,
0.0050650733,
0.0018519154,
-0.0041085598,
-0.016103467,
0.0018195986,
-0.0464731082,
-0.0556990653,
0.0520919636,
-0.0268718246,
-0.0003818343,
0.0373527668,
0.0528635904,
-0.0296470597,
-0.0168387536,
-0.002650765,
-0.0506497063,
0.0287933815,
0.0289129168,
0.0297357291,
0.0007375251,
-0.0429480746,
-0.0223453362,
0.0737479106,
-0.0466157943,
-0.0169768222,
-0.0054892721,
0.0223210938,
0.0738504902,
0.0172655769,
-0.0162548386,
0.0028901992,
-0.0097838314,
0.0231391583,
0.0334703438,
-0.0213495456,
0.0067367158,
0.0502768978,
-0.0618533082,
-0.0712364614,
-0.0134048825,
-0.0084773703,
0.025742704,
-0.0114824753,
0.0159646142,
0.0104981009,
-0.0006285085,
0.0249092989,
-0.0012249147,
0.0511665456,
0.0055776681,
-0.0232076589,
0.036489483,
0.0145146465,
0.0174722485,
-0.027398495,
-0.0191529151,
0.0132402331,
-0.0443189405,
-0.0349991135,
0.0619806908,
-0.0326346867,
-0.0573003478,
0.0295759905,
-0.0535447896,
-0.0124410931,
0.0033384606,
-0.0330043435,
0.0121472199,
0.0108536296,
-0.0136507042,
0.018584175,
-0.049560912,
-0.0361607596,
0.0086997589,
0.020546345,
-0.0142929917,
0.0483110286,
-0.0229834877,
-0.0279768296,
-0.0194171499,
0.0236603878,
0.0135003906,
0.0381697863,
-0.0475536063,
0.0049801525,
0.02262781,
0.0481658019,
0.0198068731,
0.0191277377,
-0.0302375313,
-0.0078602955,
-0.1485984027,
-0.0458884388,
-0.0089186728,
-0.0314007252,
-0.0185942538,
0.012199373,
-0.0029160925,
-0.0379146896,
-0.036574319,
0.0275553185,
-0.0008288465,
0.0314070843,
0.0308817942,
0.0332534462,
0.0662855804,
-0.0428745002,
0.0167765114,
0.0019227118,
0.0707832947,
-0.000564334,
-0.0428230837,
0.0132587962,
0.0150079429,
-0.0550778136,
0.0679744706,
-0.0359318815,
-0.0259981677,
0.0165809914,
-0.043752186,
0.0347516499,
0.0152035924,
-0.0005639698,
0.0145002631,
0.0153010804,
-0.0243157409,
-0.0247291215,
0.0217484441,
-0.00322788,
-0.0012123738,
-0.0114406962,
-0.0064864913,
-0.0425565504,
0.0242862273,
0.0111725014,
0.0013545629,
-0.0458292738,
0.0235767644,
0.0282498486,
-0.0696613565,
-0.0565388128,
0.0137098841,
0.0243025869,
-0.0201235749,
-0.0220319871,
-0.050051447,
0.0297627505,
-0.0326375104,
-0.0295266379,
-0.02021599,
-0.0087870248,
-0.0519083738,
0.0697403401,
-0.005827155,
0.0352147222,
-0.0256023724,
0.0461171977,
-0.0097107897,
-0.0489123911,
-0.0096578868,
0.016078366,
0.0589741617,
-0.0108688185,
0.0240468439,
0.0085279513,
-0.0446231663,
-0.0246783141,
-0.0387017317,
-0.0588095039,
-0.0366154425,
-0.0261534192,
-0.0196988638,
0.0073962375,
0.0113481758,
0.0329600945,
-0.0345145687,
0.0114080077,
-0.0298261791,
0.0129596591,
0.0382783785,
0.0602510124,
-0.0041020894,
-0.0093563711,
-0.0336542167,
-0.0156974401,
0.0467652269,
0.0047838828,
-0.0118433656,
-0.0527224056,
0.0065602781,
0.0061772447,
0.1055736095,
-0.0018497079,
-0.0393497683,
0.0458672456,
0.0072956006,
0.0600540265,
0.0996409431,
0.0139240539,
-0.0659809783,
-0.0241724942,
0.0154345166,
-0.0003925235,
0.033896938,
-0.0027277318,
-0.0408837348,
-0.0828986913,
-0.065149121,
-0.0289343782,
0.0403544903,
0.0085063512,
-0.0281432066,
-0.0710451826,
0.0203920342,
-0.0100772521,
-0.0187716801,
-0.0527378954,
0.0204949435,
-0.0004752628,
-0.031740658,
-0.0136418892,
-0.0610647984,
-0.0187682118,
-0.0004552043,
-0.0279832128,
0.0043163029,
-0.0397704318,
0.0264806747,
-0.0415408276,
-0.0178615116,
0.0460233316,
0.0382414609,
-0.0096743582,
-0.0556091666,
0.0111455657,
0.0044749053,
0.0173186269,
-0.0281971358,
0.0575637557,
-0.0605810508,
-0.0456739925,
0.0019417221,
-0.0116099427,
-0.0195579808,
-0.0071899397,
-0.0202519149,
0.011369626,
-0.0195125584,
-0.0079283388,
-0.0564025939,
0.0490606613,
0.0343407914,
0.0383422896,
-0.0204496179,
-0.0660063401,
-0.0054817642,
-0.0113154445,
-0.0106986118,
-0.021265788,
-0.0173358209,
-0.000392161,
0.0023372923,
0.0080741746,
-0.0619484931,
-0.0254232008,
0.0212371033,
0.0395873971,
-0.0295182988,
0.0190553125,
-0.0309051741,
0.0268586427,
-0.064640969,
0.0497375056,
-0.0026079826,
0.0418524593,
0.0018159962,
0.0184207931,
0.0500237904,
-0.0230230913,
-0.0185209941,
0.027062472,
-0.0616634376,
-0.0242813397,
-0.0651687756,
0.0765001774,
0.0061577559,
0.0026621954,
0.029959349,
-0.0144838998,
0.0429196283,
0.085320048,
-0.0063493028,
0.0341036655,
0.0339122899,
0.0466379933,
0.0128773879,
0.0145745259,
-0.0343809053,
0.0439329185,
0.0006604103,
-0.0139562432,
-0.0128577426,
-0.0360112414,
-0.0151438629,
-0.0312605985,
0.0413328111,
-0.0303430334,
-0.0069369129,
-0.0354020186,
-0.025842648,
0.0033407251,
-0.0109620634,
-0.0768224224,
-0.0010965784,
-0.0116052255,
-0.0024984435,
-0.0222466439,
0.0290607214,
0.001657423,
0.0217318274,
-0.0457774587,
0.0459390506,
0.0704956353,
-0.0108463997,
0.0077285226,
0.0335834362,
0.0241290443,
0.0014436869,
-0.0162115041,
-0.032535553,
0.0136270346,
0.0508918688,
0.0141435442,
-0.0356717519,
-0.0269524697,
0.046891626,
-0.0159373414,
0.0059019243,
-0.0244562421,
0.0395085625,
0.0553498827,
-0.0083477544,
0.0261345673,
-0.0112949545,
0.0078825597,
-0.0155805321,
0.0187274385,
-0.0217742026,
-0.0150781069,
0.0547047369,
0.0034612194,
-0.0045464174,
0.0081784045,
0.0496346131,
-0.030823281,
0.0172430705,
0.0208314545,
0.0145861339,
-0.0572834648,
-0.0210974738,
0.0874894112,
0.0300433226,
0.0113913678,
0.0795532688,
-0.0460868068,
-0.0679220781,
0.0589723513,
-0.0212656073,
-0.0322928205,
0.054190211,
0.0256748125,
0.0386456661,
0.0251284745,
0.0420175865,
-0.0385102704,
-0.011486372,
-0.0166012086,
0.0009229879,
0.0243405327,
-5.694927032e-33,
-0.009916788,
-0.0410207771,
-0.0006106324,
0.0023981493,
-0.0110200113,
0.0337098464,
-0.0215226933,
0.0091466177,
-0.0018195065,
0.0362487622,
0.0460724607,
-0.0063630552,
-0.0099016549,
0.0420186557,
0.0124276401,
0.0212661438,
0.0265929829,
0.0313076191,
0.0308765229,
0.0105104856,
0.0555134453,
0.0256999731,
0.0464387164,
-0.0974332839,
0.0344216935,
0.0094444472,
-0.0587771125,
0.0092272963,
0.0530097671,
0.0488182046,
-0.0418299511,
0.0704411939,
0.0245368686,
0.0297989026,
-0.0393174626,
0.0443591736,
-0.0299714208,
0.0093320301,
0.036588598,
-0.0012913443,
-0.0698838681,
0.0257600043,
0.0176285896,
-0.0145978415,
0.0085255615,
-0.031798996,
0.053683348,
-0.0133595718,
0.0174642727,
-0.036374148,
-0.0679866523,
0.0126594314,
-0.0056891795,
-0.0279072616,
0.0387828909,
0.0169904176,
0.0492007881,
0.065469034,
-0.0512681343,
0.0488945991,
-0.0475345068,
-0.0399570502,
0.0439789817,
0.022782512,
0.0006562491,
0.0923674628,
0.0078930333,
-0.0316308476,
-0.0248009954,
0.0162350833,
0.0169121623,
0.0594822764,
0.0294291191,
0.1046797633,
-0.0195095763,
0.0060933172,
-0.0327046886,
0.0164245628,
-0.0091912569,
0.0127091054,
0.0232203249,
0.018056564,
0.005334869,
0.0138833178,
0.0032703537,
-0.0077721956,
-0.0480545349,
0.0106941955,
0.0281132031,
0.0035214366,
0.0046947668,
0.0233167354,
0.0405022725,
-0.0673383772,
-0.0161201637,
0.059162505,
-0.0194755755,
0.0452680923,
0.0113308653,
0.0128469439,
-0.0350351073,
-0.0104197413,
0.0386088528,
0.0203070659,
-0.0107650422,
-0.0165273156,
0.0464630276,
0.0314484276,
-0.0580287576,
-0.0242629424,
-0.0229585562,
0.0320202783,
-0.0261643566,
0.0485064201,
-0.0134698804,
0.0176716018,
-0.0541567095,
0.0444586836,
-0.0364647917,
0.027649682,
0.0054084286,
-0.0441882759,
0.0106082512,
0.0196322165,
-0.0167733077,
-0.0302458704,
-0.0115640555,
-0.0645071045,
0.0367120206,
-0.0525432341,
0.0052450877,
0.0269019175,
2.487e-7,
0.0372862779,
0.04650921,
-0.0189267043,
-0.0191825218,
0.0345348455,
0.0875444263,
-0.037799105,
0.0495932549,
0.0064878631,
-0.009447732,
-0.0029922747,
0.0486747883,
0.026740592,
0.0089430166,
-0.0213475525,
0.022881221,
-0.0046009035,
-0.0433218405,
-0.0244875811,
0.0532726422,
0.0554786287,
0.1068247333,
-0.0004243094,
-0.0471170731,
0.0150164803,
-0.0457117967,
0.0847330317,
-0.0496941246,
-0.043939542,
-0.0308263097,
-0.0410959683,
0.0062040412,
-0.0190438516,
-0.0271368697,
0.0005177569,
-0.0182980169,
0.0573572889,
0.024186613,
-0.0063181734,
-0.0651853755,
-0.0232861806,
0.0489848368,
-0.0258939415,
-0.0140488092,
0.0518065393,
-0.0361356251,
-0.0237580929,
-0.093659915,
-0.003374028,
0.024808336,
0.0459378399,
0.0081744576,
-0.0548759997,
0.013204175,
0.0231801663,
-0.0454001464,
-0.0610500164,
-0.1023793817,
-0.015281586,
-0.0204908587,
-0.0233009122,
-0.0252909251,
0.0092294579,
-0.0041626431,
0.0591100454,
-0.0403222926,
-0.0350237153,
1.762803701e-34,
0.053156402,
-0.0493381172,
0.0254597571,
-0.0275365636,
0.0022235084,
-0.0013348255,
-0.0557274446,
-0.0313160159,
0.0158746857,
-0.0461820774,
0.0022446392
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06643v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06643v2 | Effects of diversity incentives on sample diversity and downstream model performance in LLM-based text augmentation | 2024-01-12T15:46:43 | 2024-02-15T11:14:10 | Jan Cegin, Branislav Pecher, Jakub Simko, Ivan Srba, Maria Bielikova, Peter Brusilovsky | cs.CL | cs.CL | The latest generative large language models (LLMs) have found their
application in data augmentation tasks, where small numbers of text samples are
LLM-paraphrased and then used to fine-tune downstream models. However, more
research is needed to assess how different prompts, seed data selection
strategies, filtering methods, or model settings affect the quality of
paraphrased data (and downstream models). In this study, we investigate three
text diversity incentive methods well established in crowdsourcing: taboo
words, hints by previous outlier solutions, and chaining on previous outlier
solutions. Using these incentive methods as part of instructions to LLMs
augmenting text datasets, we measure their effects on generated texts lexical
diversity and downstream model performance. We compare the effects over 5
different LLMs, 6 datasets and 2 downstream models. We show that diversity is
most increased by taboo words, but downstream model performance is highest with
hints. | [
0.0788867995,
0.0437901653,
0.0015363771,
0.0195645206,
-0.0534087345,
-0.0099987444,
0.0094555831,
0.0339809284,
-0.0087786233,
-0.0456714407,
0.0006210714,
-0.0295653269,
0.0059950636,
-0.0030310934,
0.0272912718,
-0.0567854196,
0.0092610009,
-0.0589887872,
0.0112844901,
-0.04019887,
0.0201127138,
0.0267828926,
0.050509993,
0.0359664448,
0.0207668357,
0.0170462485,
0.0286775064,
0.0358020216,
0.0192394853,
-0.0088365143,
-0.0099392235,
0.0415055826,
0.0098608425,
0.0512071624,
0.0000017505,
-0.0749441236,
-0.0174120497,
0.0236780364,
-0.0444252193,
0.0427262597,
0.0563953742,
-0.0116595328,
0.0162641611,
0.0213572755,
-0.0088394135,
0.0236963164,
0.0433288589,
0.0096791815,
0.0659774244,
0.0427261814,
0.0125468746,
0.0159358438,
0.0109647522,
-0.0240803212,
0.0467381366,
0.0321297348,
0.0528167859,
-0.0290954877,
0.0278538465,
0.0609463565,
-0.002387373,
0.0436104909,
-0.0008078292,
0.0142406505,
0.0753545985,
0.0128089217,
-0.006803588,
-0.0259670559,
-0.0040936,
0.057592839,
-0.0001691194,
-0.0159238894,
0.0016703701,
-0.048468627,
0.0090001579,
0.0408020355,
-0.0610688515,
0.0361319818,
-0.0050470568,
0.0147376293,
0.0046404181,
0.0121674761,
0.0338168666,
0.0519879796,
0.0104181832,
0.0434771702,
0.0227998309,
-0.0556071475,
-0.0342985541,
0.0270960722,
-0.0155429039,
-0.0415513366,
0.0294407029,
-0.0186383873,
-0.0150439776,
0.0283615254,
-0.0321707278,
-0.0887357667,
0.0646664873,
-0.021648122,
0.0201649368,
-0.0123290541,
-0.0198593065,
0.0580833033,
0.0081258975,
-0.0269680936,
-0.0090377685,
0.0456596091,
-0.0439108908,
-0.0193194635,
0.0055330433,
-0.0104066804,
-0.024293229,
0.020118406,
-0.0548580326,
0.0129192984,
-0.0338596776,
-0.0013778639,
0.0048485799,
-0.0437332951,
0.0424822904,
0.0185267106,
-0.0410410017,
-0.0248008706,
0.0053605409,
-0.0183219798,
-0.0448975004,
0.02894881,
0.0185701493,
-0.0780149996,
-0.0165169016,
0.0021862467,
0.0378412195,
-0.0533610992,
0.029111119,
0.0391401201,
-0.0038814666,
-0.0546853356,
-0.0328479819,
-0.0024199949,
-0.0267974529,
-0.0111332657,
-0.0145952189,
-0.0800909176,
0.0312141515,
-0.0215157028,
0.0040680133,
-0.0268430542,
-0.0050792494,
0.0200018696,
-0.0780814588,
0.0509015396,
-0.0514842495,
0.004748852,
0.0424816497,
-0.0002616041,
-0.0231456365,
0.0899560228,
0.0347623192,
0.0132827293,
0.0601439066,
0.011584674,
0.0222938173,
0.0401239023,
0.0183233451,
0.0468870811,
-0.014789952,
-0.0012822238,
-0.016854547,
0.0367152877,
-0.0004728743,
0.0766829476,
-0.0392589271,
-0.0015318372,
0.0845512226,
0.0772753805,
-0.0056410562,
-0.0008560194,
0.0111607313,
0.0324347131,
-0.0092100892,
-0.000746539,
-0.0131485574,
-0.0016070122,
-0.0216887593,
0.0333231203,
0.0653243959,
0.0887627751,
-0.0034185559,
-0.0372747965,
-0.0438965559,
0.0129142441,
0.0363938473,
0.0016078609,
0.0459048599,
0.0128997425,
-0.0240052305,
-0.0142995259,
0.0373992063,
-0.0620508268,
0.0262354556,
-0.0201424789,
0.0437233523,
0.0846943781,
0.0871746391,
-0.0045241979,
0.0382480286,
-0.0353769436,
0.0012938,
0.0572664663,
-0.0175095499,
0.0278219935,
0.0201422777,
-0.0797689781,
-0.0543073267,
0.017022023,
0.0144251296,
0.0255811084,
0.0629423112,
-0.0250315126,
0.0104627199,
-0.0230748672,
-0.0869445875,
0.040082965,
-0.0338183939,
-0.0117635308,
0.0146967852,
-0.0114616221,
0.0024744903,
0.0277357921,
-0.0247324016,
0.000378863,
-0.0108430814,
-0.0355656184,
-0.0385750234,
-0.0015550992,
-0.0387830921,
-0.013953045,
0.0216823202,
-0.0740612298,
0.0027375866,
0.0229541566,
-0.0199201852,
-0.0137782227,
-0.0005753149,
-0.0358413197,
-0.0172075368,
-0.066147171,
0.0141543271,
-0.0319064111,
0.021995334,
-0.0282212105,
0.0504953116,
-0.0041758139,
0.0267288908,
0.0084061213,
-0.0269365031,
0.0087475022,
-0.0291960798,
-0.0245845746,
-0.0242892504,
0.0141711524,
0.0353253558,
0.0091793491,
0.0115205189,
-0.0420589708,
-0.0196655225,
-0.0640839115,
0.0035933154,
-0.0086120581,
-0.0273584686,
-0.0046956255,
0.0256458465,
-0.0107729565,
0.0139887379,
0.0022290996,
-0.0598584265,
0.005481591,
0.0560107231,
0.0167272948,
0.0190066416,
0.0039613689,
-0.0068797246,
-0.0281804893,
0.0392904393,
0.0469329096,
0.0488543846,
-0.0115179131,
-0.0320130028,
-0.0075806831,
-0.034666162,
-0.0165198818,
0.0061723362,
-0.0250998456,
-0.0154330032,
0.0007876038,
0.0431130119,
0.0173879825,
0.0343910493,
-0.0259379335,
0.0144594405,
0.0258776527,
-0.0619217306,
-0.0302206073,
-0.0034977142,
0.0085249385,
-0.0022565681,
-0.0565521382,
0.0237413589,
0.0166935846,
0.0101297889,
-0.0367534235,
-0.0715732723,
0.0250875168,
-0.0271185748,
-0.056748908,
-0.039233651,
-0.0699372888,
-0.0570967309,
0.0081468932,
-0.0423440151,
-0.0581299774,
0.0893435106,
-0.0413529612,
-0.010781643,
-0.0303913448,
-0.0173961408,
-0.0425519831,
-0.0061097182,
-0.0113914423,
0.0264999736,
0.0032080514,
0.0096734455,
-0.0153102465,
0.0148291895,
0.0441925973,
-0.0497000702,
0.0647100583,
-0.0495903902,
-0.0080570858,
-0.0026114173,
-0.0197444893,
-0.0323102623,
-0.0912303254,
0.0139055951,
-0.0154026458,
0.0914629176,
0.0052810493,
0.0189850666,
-0.0149755049,
0.0196299814,
0.0250762794,
-0.0176651683,
0.0020743657,
-0.0108000254,
-0.0005198511,
0.0498637743,
0.0314280838,
0.0294721033,
-0.0511143655,
-0.0309627149,
-0.0152933626,
0.0289340299,
-0.0620339401,
0.0113296555,
0.00590121,
0.0374352448,
-0.0059408532,
-0.0242291205,
-0.0145858014,
0.0664976835,
-0.0075893039,
0.0039959513,
0.0546768829,
0.0108126737,
-0.0440743864,
-0.0079443427,
-0.0263468996,
0.0590626113,
-0.0036270283,
0.0056900643,
-0.067690745,
-0.0003110492,
0.0004456679,
0.0573150739,
-0.0354686342,
-0.0333140157,
-0.0253360793,
-0.1352862269,
0.0341895893,
0.0143498462,
-0.0373012759,
0.0005549557,
-0.0233692564,
-0.0049344273,
-0.0121375322,
0.0052564861,
-0.0126832621,
-0.0183890946,
0.0177810807,
0.0284715723,
-0.0077445679,
-0.0696463212,
-0.0477572381,
-0.040634796,
0.053325247,
0.0651449263,
-0.0277993511,
-0.0320768766,
-0.0438264012,
0.0299540274,
-0.028790867,
-0.0073895464,
-0.0081032384,
0.0512631014,
0.0086121131,
-0.0033461335,
-0.0050447658,
0.0317636058,
0.0107647385,
-0.0056325682,
0.0151183438,
0.0365753211,
0.049658116,
0.0032649345,
-0.0060150567,
0.0128092784,
0.0215046927,
0.1046472564,
0.0438633673,
-0.0605658814,
0.0241271015,
-0.0453896634,
-0.0187652186,
-0.0820642486,
-0.0163399298,
0.0166892521,
-0.0445822366,
-0.0317487381,
-0.0710899457,
-0.0247450136,
0.0063243345,
0.0266976804,
0.0283786487,
0.0829461589,
-0.0656649321,
0.0127623985,
0.0557441674,
0.0339942798,
-0.0339696966,
0.0068528578,
-0.0210800655,
-0.0228390992,
-0.0264234319,
-0.0759766176,
-0.0066486853,
0.0327116027,
-0.1091438457,
-0.0652148649,
0.046406839,
0.0246924795,
0.0289476067,
0.0512906052,
-0.0028914085,
-0.0887118131,
0.0582681783,
0.0891142786,
-0.0044448781,
0.0481559485,
0.0116001815,
0.0237358697,
0.0070859292,
0.0196061525,
-0.0640674904,
-0.0056555737,
0.0394051597,
0.0295499135,
-0.0249753743,
-0.0192063227,
-0.0023941724,
0.0495466739,
0.028287895,
-0.0633048788,
-0.0194837302,
-0.0514114909,
0.0090385815,
-0.0039652926,
-0.0192322265,
-0.0480581746,
0.0002265637,
0.0328400061,
-0.0309905335,
-0.0165300146,
0.038101837,
-0.0014873138,
0.0564246587,
-0.0777439699,
0.0138613433,
-0.0156343058,
-0.0058695008,
0.0285458341,
0.0147314742,
-0.0061140349,
0.0330891013,
-0.0670759007,
0.0033959469,
0.0053077089,
0.0019185984,
0.0150205223,
-0.0372237079,
0.0046924339,
0.0312637687,
-0.0796869621,
-0.0266876128,
-0.0293306001,
0.0659362674,
-0.0132507086,
-0.0046726875,
0.0791070163,
-0.0072215386,
-0.0167581309,
-0.0227511972,
0.008728398,
-0.002166061,
-0.0149357123,
0.0269052722,
0.0013924987,
-0.0216907468,
0.0001160571,
0.0680028275,
0.0209871307,
0.0264939759,
-0.0093092564,
-0.0076735215,
-0.0204827283,
-0.02302224,
0.0089873103,
0.0198200345,
-0.0044915397,
0.0083408458,
-0.0675002337,
-0.0351543278,
0.0043460303,
0.018963892,
0.014566374,
-0.0089898398,
0.0335972533,
0.0395581871,
-0.0385165364,
0.0161251873,
-0.0326157175,
0.0273139682,
0.0121481344,
-0.0261894874,
0.0026689924,
-6.429214272e-33,
-0.0132798133,
-0.016372934,
-0.0271047223,
-0.0673405603,
-0.0165483113,
-0.0080243619,
0.0125275049,
-0.0095770154,
0.0163781568,
-0.0051848758,
-0.029636411,
-0.0021563715,
0.0244281497,
0.0388150886,
0.0168302637,
-0.0101878848,
0.0481935889,
-0.0028719299,
-0.0311566573,
-0.016858032,
0.0098336283,
0.019527873,
0.012200579,
-0.0353747047,
0.0619658343,
-0.0538523495,
-0.0224013962,
-0.0010407347,
0.0064109568,
0.0384521633,
-0.0041509368,
0.05452976,
0.0114398813,
-0.0604055077,
-0.0405775495,
-0.0046178563,
-0.0331403986,
-0.0009288036,
0.0623435304,
-0.0301401727,
-0.0548502356,
-0.0542466603,
0.0445947163,
0.006338547,
-0.0038028075,
-0.0047296681,
0.04588167,
-0.0564673133,
-0.0400777347,
0.0153773595,
0.0048319371,
0.0327748023,
-0.0054857396,
0.0187469255,
0.0069877212,
0.0281307362,
0.0029084862,
0.0813895538,
-0.0315815732,
0.0292604249,
0.0772568211,
0.0035011275,
0.0450579897,
0.0274033584,
0.0164386854,
0.0222124495,
-0.0374473222,
-0.0072269915,
-0.0122485487,
-0.0430451632,
-0.0005274425,
-0.0051141931,
0.0546313524,
0.1264401972,
0.0404674113,
-0.0044984766,
0.0047172261,
0.0485747531,
-0.0309696365,
-0.0687536895,
0.0270292163,
0.011651258,
-0.0435632206,
-0.0305705965,
-0.0166015979,
-0.0243288428,
-0.0227284823,
-0.0275289826,
0.0232090708,
0.0369750708,
-0.0674609393,
0.0216474645,
0.0235910658,
-0.0183639973,
-0.0363662988,
0.0034364164,
0.0076021184,
0.0066583073,
0.0060184496,
0.0076863663,
-0.0636129379,
0.0354110785,
0.0411877483,
0.0512603186,
-0.0031188035,
-0.0098327482,
0.0428904742,
0.0093710581,
-0.0751889125,
0.0453003161,
-0.0104300724,
0.026657477,
0.0024238159,
-0.0309049599,
0.0296392124,
0.0008879134,
-0.0055909073,
0.0256944634,
0.0578310192,
-0.0017579929,
-0.0194061175,
-0.0209556948,
-0.022868555,
-0.0134694856,
-0.0193109512,
0.0277169328,
0.0266655777,
-0.0197502282,
0.0531754941,
-0.0103193233,
-0.0065243286,
-0.0131816631,
2.491e-7,
0.0188423488,
0.0408071056,
0.0352430083,
-0.018910192,
-0.0078725228,
0.0351253934,
-0.0077231973,
0.0097640799,
-0.0015232234,
0.0052117878,
0.0000132719,
0.0331077762,
0.0661112666,
0.0041507119,
-0.0573148243,
0.0204379726,
-0.094026342,
0.0511401519,
-0.0503401197,
-0.037816707,
0.0228965543,
0.0822685584,
0.0393418781,
-0.0121226404,
-0.0264836568,
-0.0418951027,
0.0524819456,
-0.0793827772,
-0.0452941656,
0.0207653977,
0.0634757355,
-0.0040802443,
0.0091730086,
-0.0125310943,
-0.0128058847,
0.0021292367,
0.0423778929,
0.0159971844,
0.0165619366,
0.0004233818,
-0.006098194,
-0.0103946347,
-0.0035752084,
-0.0779679194,
0.0575408526,
0.028484745,
0.0096523091,
-0.0403882042,
-0.0351367146,
-0.0108438302,
0.0235473402,
-0.0512052551,
-0.0250834022,
-0.0101148458,
0.0125677232,
0.0164580494,
-0.0147717101,
-0.0553010739,
-0.0304936916,
-0.0524755493,
-0.0494292267,
-0.0741039813,
-0.0326262414,
0.0405137837,
-0.0104305092,
-0.0685620531,
0.0166339073,
2.347343521e-34,
0.0535179488,
-0.0187237598,
-0.0012212027,
0.0043935822,
0.0218709074,
0.0006481236,
0.0176509377,
0.0127755366,
-0.0115348333,
-0.0549647734,
0.0003405437
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06640v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06640v1 | Experimental Contexts Can Facilitate Robust Semantic Property Inference in Language Models, but Inconsistently | 2024-01-12T15:40:31 | 2024-01-12T15:40:31 | Kanishka Misra, Allyson Ettinger, Kyle Mahowald | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent zero-shot evaluations have highlighted important limitations in the
abilities of language models (LMs) to perform meaning extraction. However, it
is now well known that LMs can demonstrate radical improvements in the presence
of experimental contexts such as in-context examples and instructions. How well
does this translate to previously studied meaning-sensitive tasks? We present a
case-study on the extent to which experimental contexts can improve LMs'
robustness in performing property inheritance -- predicting semantic properties
of novel concepts, a task that they have been previously shown to fail on. Upon
carefully controlling the nature of the in-context examples and the
instructions, our work reveals that they can indeed lead to non-trivial
property inheritance behavior in LMs. However, this ability is inconsistent:
with a minimal reformulation of the task, some LMs were found to pick up on
shallow, non-semantic heuristics from their inputs, suggesting that the
computational principles of semantic property inference are yet to be mastered
by LMs. | [
0.0118879182,
0.0406206772,
-0.0305611435,
0.065580301,
-0.0751940906,
0.0112396637,
-0.0033565583,
0.0046440498,
-0.0580408834,
-0.0532934964,
-0.038613122,
-0.0256389007,
-0.0040412634,
0.0047605005,
0.0200198404,
-0.0045892638,
0.0606303066,
-0.0221594796,
-0.0399617627,
-0.0021403648,
-0.0400577374,
-0.0133786704,
0.0218019225,
0.0000870452,
-0.006117627,
0.0134315612,
-0.0003215974,
-0.0343776122,
-0.0452217087,
-0.0339732431,
-0.0292976648,
0.023071399,
0.0176625699,
0.0300111193,
0.0000016572,
-0.0593922809,
-0.0007222009,
-0.0084259091,
-0.0167765133,
-0.0051743584,
0.0843773261,
-0.0416896753,
0.007596374,
-0.0289467312,
-0.0385982171,
-0.0221918505,
0.0354931466,
-0.0125043793,
-0.0537484176,
0.0273553301,
-0.0066451104,
-0.0041028392,
-0.0147727896,
-0.0251541249,
0.1062538102,
-0.0575520881,
0.0261498969,
-0.0267286561,
0.0103722215,
0.0051441831,
-0.0572549812,
0.0445888005,
0.0239960216,
0.0592315346,
-0.0366640165,
0.0539717898,
-0.0302707572,
-0.0409367085,
0.0255954731,
0.0450278185,
-0.0038485345,
-0.01828539,
-0.0205459967,
-0.0088974638,
-0.0047006942,
-0.0143337892,
-0.0152373901,
0.037493106,
0.0082300268,
0.0401710868,
0.0620955713,
0.024071604,
0.0381241813,
0.0265926756,
-0.0165896807,
0.1066703424,
0.0244747177,
-0.0129835792,
-0.0448123738,
0.0195124205,
-0.0121081546,
-0.0152112618,
-0.0686866567,
0.0116607687,
0.0493442118,
0.0658618957,
-0.0212161299,
0.0049920133,
0.0336286016,
-0.0131321615,
0.0387735367,
0.0543500148,
-0.0367138423,
0.0817159191,
-0.0603779554,
0.0290773436,
-0.0051956791,
0.0286075901,
-0.0307869092,
-0.0181145966,
-0.0661586598,
-0.0071130418,
-0.0011640696,
0.0358216539,
-0.008806414,
-0.0140084028,
-0.0007647225,
0.0529756285,
0.0413681343,
-0.0022427342,
-0.0545318127,
-0.0346492305,
-0.0621601567,
0.0179784447,
-0.0471116789,
-0.012737385,
-0.0184663106,
0.0290198214,
-0.0474790335,
-0.0793613568,
-0.0431588851,
0.0036137593,
0.0072430912,
-0.0217211843,
0.0297260787,
0.1115696877,
0.0413006209,
-0.0877303705,
-0.0421835184,
-0.0261894669,
-0.0310280956,
-0.0604309961,
0.0487931147,
-0.0342866965,
0.0263479054,
0.0367081575,
-0.0242775399,
-0.0864256695,
0.0135116428,
-0.0165226702,
-0.0503811315,
0.0795840472,
-0.0149749899,
0.0129685672,
-0.025053909,
0.0102853039,
-0.0332957692,
0.0812198222,
0.0135255791,
0.0177192595,
0.0417558923,
0.0225165654,
-0.0081762057,
0.0272885151,
0.0394802578,
0.0165208112,
-0.0579186007,
-0.0165246706,
0.0342412852,
0.0022331732,
0.0190625172,
0.0249330122,
-0.0085817697,
-0.0053789001,
0.0630236566,
0.03759446,
-0.0112151094,
0.0165382642,
0.0585321598,
-0.0355107486,
-0.0168583374,
0.0057732495,
-0.0947748572,
0.0007891071,
-0.0438330136,
0.0434687957,
-0.038051676,
0.0026261322,
-0.0354846269,
-0.0298315585,
-0.0385846049,
-0.033733394,
0.0229537617,
-0.0225975271,
0.0663298741,
0.0400290005,
-0.0131556233,
0.0195741095,
0.0500332266,
-0.0124281645,
0.0176422987,
-0.0590917729,
0.0515420213,
0.0351359695,
0.0461062081,
-0.0361704752,
-0.009949862,
0.0441021733,
0.0138737997,
0.0385556035,
0.0418476351,
-0.0042142449,
0.0315135829,
-0.0170683395,
-0.024038827,
-0.0630582646,
0.0451420918,
-0.0182124879,
0.0164399035,
-0.022104295,
0.0253652465,
-0.0617099777,
0.021529248,
0.0616945028,
-0.0371251255,
-0.020306183,
-0.0127187874,
-0.0104207713,
-0.0010986751,
-0.0334706455,
0.006320213,
0.0321836472,
0.0006467273,
-0.0322008319,
-0.0060455296,
0.028820375,
-0.0239934586,
-0.0704036728,
0.0267536603,
0.022804901,
0.00782842,
-0.0115178535,
-0.0251211934,
0.0100954846,
0.0472525544,
-0.0151898628,
0.075429678,
-0.0576131046,
0.0376396812,
-0.0523972958,
0.0290075485,
-0.0231135804,
0.0845674723,
-0.0212585181,
-0.024763573,
-0.0174672697,
0.02151783,
-0.0159721058,
-0.0066563855,
-0.0433785394,
-0.0140818395,
0.0114658633,
-0.0102912188,
-0.0270378124,
-0.0049532652,
-0.0332207493,
-0.0032103795,
-0.0417003594,
0.0234534629,
-0.0075649666,
0.0257422384,
0.0400999151,
0.003577824,
-0.0143339857,
-0.0207658559,
0.0026659986,
0.0094414586,
-0.0189315639,
0.0520387888,
0.0609383434,
0.017042039,
-0.0275196675,
-0.0328495353,
-0.0220811497,
-0.0469768792,
0.071818158,
-0.0347713679,
0.0379737169,
-0.0081406394,
0.0451715812,
-0.0624306053,
0.0210477747,
-0.0044217785,
0.0065903552,
-0.0150154755,
-0.0281244628,
-0.0156271961,
0.0494600423,
-0.0128767258,
0.0426388122,
0.0746634826,
0.0198164806,
-0.0156203071,
-0.0273369253,
-0.061662171,
0.0009218291,
-0.0001628412,
0.0000017606,
-0.0278781857,
0.0873523206,
0.0151271634,
-0.0101332152,
-0.0403850786,
0.0572542585,
-0.0139572741,
-0.019738663,
-0.0040010638,
0.0314611569,
-0.0161033552,
0.0578213893,
-0.03963672,
-0.0568780564,
0.0810344666,
-0.0334297679,
-0.0166495349,
-0.0371735245,
-0.0049765622,
-0.0444790758,
0.09762045,
0.0103555759,
-0.0046727117,
0.0032100813,
0.0259648897,
-0.0347779766,
-0.0108039007,
0.0132610956,
-0.0253455043,
0.0220131855,
-0.0420066379,
-0.016125828,
0.0036048049,
-0.0075790538,
-0.0451977812,
-0.0280152429,
-0.034120474,
0.0219052415,
-0.0273395497,
0.0393903852,
0.0281400438,
0.0139104761,
0.0033465596,
0.0362242907,
0.0038694998,
-0.0100275269,
-0.0364447311,
-0.0059875413,
0.0488773324,
-0.0550349951,
0.0119505422,
-0.0152457142,
0.0185739826,
0.0090370458,
0.0110502634,
0.0288402662,
-0.0077477302,
0.04811785,
0.0111952852,
-0.0111951232,
-0.0608579591,
0.01753355,
0.0209467895,
-0.0602129772,
-0.0313400105,
0.0886719227,
0.0385493785,
0.0098531814,
0.0475263,
-0.0381848179,
0.0161319189,
0.0306630228,
0.0082597034,
-0.0891705155,
-0.0370739512,
-0.0063314107,
-0.0091882031,
-0.0164887216,
-0.032993257,
-0.0330579057,
-0.1074828506,
0.0080891158,
-0.0113679217,
-0.0957315639,
0.0002550913,
-0.0508263223,
0.0480182581,
-0.029903071,
0.0384184644,
0.0100623295,
-0.0233150944,
0.0150340879,
-0.0098597333,
0.017603118,
-0.0802258328,
0.0588374622,
-0.0223097559,
0.0318890661,
0.0717268884,
-0.0206521675,
-0.0008048161,
-0.0338724591,
0.0322803706,
-0.0207937099,
0.0220407043,
-0.0116149513,
0.0433435738,
-0.0170541983,
0.0025965008,
0.0130299767,
0.0210600365,
-0.0130624389,
-0.0359537639,
-0.0345881693,
0.0734377578,
-0.011239836,
-0.0606873818,
-0.017639922,
-0.0087717474,
-0.0024895361,
0.0957239196,
0.0540731736,
-0.0515220016,
-0.0265141148,
0.0038364888,
-0.0429159589,
0.0005590998,
-0.0281780083,
0.0006622666,
-0.0017326273,
-0.0171760451,
-0.0593284108,
-0.0483865924,
0.0438757092,
0.0053017847,
-0.0109845586,
0.0250546932,
-0.0555895939,
-0.0210626964,
-0.0350162797,
0.0164203737,
-0.036926087,
-0.0193693489,
-0.0020869025,
0.0016470249,
0.0993169248,
-0.042757269,
-0.0123245204,
0.0067442614,
-0.0509373173,
-0.0725640953,
0.0161199607,
0.046837084,
0.0250162371,
0.044533439,
-0.0192780644,
-0.0025934468,
0.0395229086,
0.0065979189,
0.0041801413,
0.0268439632,
0.0354148597,
-0.014773109,
0.0225721858,
0.0484750345,
-0.0324343815,
0.0568786338,
0.0506711937,
0.0375995636,
-0.0180364661,
-0.0141512891,
0.0357192643,
-0.0056153522,
0.0367225297,
-0.0243386365,
-0.0039602974,
0.0314656906,
0.006072164,
-0.0045432975,
-0.0214034654,
-0.0131577579,
-0.0325719304,
0.0086077107,
0.0495946929,
0.0053921174,
-0.0218391456,
-0.0263004862,
0.0968700647,
-0.0050423574,
0.0044420287,
0.0021018323,
0.0166144688,
-0.0153885391,
0.0271007214,
0.0040429644,
0.0397388265,
-0.0551925302,
0.0239646174,
-0.0471169874,
0.0330584683,
0.0282165799,
0.0017357803,
-0.0590251535,
0.0243303142,
-0.0501748919,
0.0387829207,
-0.014674658,
0.0419524945,
0.0416613184,
-0.0387962684,
-0.0003748063,
-0.0370568894,
-0.0244696662,
0.0018881351,
0.013815931,
-0.0073327944,
-0.0548567325,
0.0433625691,
0.0368498899,
-0.0239112675,
-0.0163749028,
0.0517375469,
0.0264169574,
0.0922757834,
-0.000474402,
0.0286314003,
-0.003266826,
0.0249949098,
0.0384345129,
-0.0090974709,
-0.0290059391,
0.0225884486,
-0.0925606117,
-0.076146096,
0.030861564,
0.0121972281,
0.0180788692,
-0.0106494697,
0.0225563906,
0.0651871115,
0.0051200562,
-0.0221869014,
-0.0182973258,
-0.0418402478,
0.01877876,
0.0180465132,
-0.039038524,
-5.592351191e-33,
-0.0415410623,
-0.0049134209,
0.0058828723,
0.0357451253,
0.0328393504,
0.0036887398,
-0.0550678261,
0.0120784715,
-0.0474945046,
-0.0072525945,
0.0007783713,
-0.0126706976,
0.0031205446,
-0.0068144319,
-0.0030171464,
-0.0482901968,
0.0103085432,
-0.0095630093,
-0.0351337865,
-0.0244145542,
0.0128388796,
0.0010182402,
0.0536765009,
-0.0303698201,
0.0021566723,
-0.0006663045,
0.0257054325,
0.0115767876,
-0.0121534672,
0.0383721441,
-0.0444135927,
0.0300162099,
0.0505780131,
-0.0453707837,
-0.0250781924,
-0.0196358934,
-0.0519147143,
-0.0417490192,
0.0363981985,
-0.0142593514,
-0.0337893628,
-0.0239126086,
0.0427313186,
-0.0074525601,
-0.0425385311,
-0.00259361,
0.0037065153,
-0.0293983016,
-0.0173498318,
0.0150314486,
-0.0829823986,
0.0158154406,
0.0510120317,
-0.0221440643,
0.0780017823,
-0.0503142551,
0.0266354606,
0.0215835925,
-0.002974425,
0.0359195024,
-0.0037426145,
0.0271717273,
0.0559053645,
0.0074657165,
0.0112133641,
0.0494342931,
0.0178735163,
0.0139848804,
-0.0294584781,
-0.0065722619,
0.075034909,
0.0405705273,
0.0224930942,
0.037096072,
0.0362290181,
0.0181193147,
-0.0271182563,
-0.016622616,
0.0313968323,
-0.0055877334,
0.0111765973,
0.0157669093,
-0.0157607552,
-0.0086978292,
-0.0585794374,
0.0007795405,
-0.0422266535,
-0.0554450117,
0.0286303591,
-0.0018514664,
-0.027124906,
0.0138676492,
0.0210604556,
-0.0456486456,
-0.0238160715,
0.0220457595,
-0.0326448046,
0.0011269677,
-0.004675034,
0.0011692574,
-0.0493441075,
-0.066879116,
0.0186874252,
0.0010628001,
0.0087971268,
0.0233025569,
0.0431344137,
0.0325235575,
-0.0160900503,
-0.0163307488,
-0.0399682373,
-0.0130306296,
0.0238187332,
-0.0279804096,
0.0139184175,
0.0312149487,
-0.0003644122,
-0.0005904057,
0.0832314342,
0.0007178662,
-0.061267551,
0.0116612045,
-0.0341829658,
0.0265133269,
-0.0646892935,
-0.0433388129,
-0.0128048221,
0.0131629752,
0.0359687433,
-0.0230908375,
-0.0216750689,
0.0030005916,
2.52e-7,
0.0764860138,
0.0361698568,
0.013589737,
0.0503796525,
0.0143814739,
0.0114602046,
-0.0319823176,
0.0154157467,
-0.0038578871,
-0.0329252817,
0.0130297644,
0.0352486074,
0.014687839,
0.0138264447,
-0.0331676342,
0.0305128936,
-0.0235613883,
0.034744259,
-0.0257030819,
0.0269241966,
0.0466585569,
0.11982131,
0.0322324038,
-0.0091924816,
-0.0271801725,
-0.0419768654,
0.0538445115,
-0.0245869514,
0.0039790114,
0.0253742877,
-0.0548470914,
0.0271365922,
0.0165030323,
0.0406139717,
0.0135632493,
0.0321615003,
0.0021184222,
0.0456760488,
-0.0197132584,
-0.0260902625,
-0.0208110679,
-0.0154851647,
-0.0065695797,
-0.0389931239,
0.092934221,
-0.0488147922,
-0.0259418841,
-0.0080926521,
0.0156746749,
0.0463725962,
-0.0122563541,
0.0274772272,
-0.0055299923,
-0.0129066138,
0.0241336599,
0.0167254712,
-0.0558034778,
-0.0764869973,
-0.0374840386,
0.0062013725,
-0.0284850504,
-0.0411597602,
-0.0248115733,
0.0040539233,
0.0178649276,
-0.0840319917,
-0.0269160233,
2.454932019e-34,
0.0173224937,
0.0009498815,
0.006872532,
0.0503439382,
-0.0030736572,
-0.0205062144,
0.0155661078,
0.0233951882,
0.0253021419,
-0.0265869331,
0.0156472251
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06628v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06628v2 | OOP: Object-Oriented Programming Evaluation Benchmark for Large Language Models | 2024-01-12T15:21:36 | 2024-02-21T06:18:16 | Shuai Wang, Liang Ding, Li Shen, Yong Luo, Bo Du, Dacheng Tao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Advancing automated programming necessitates robust and comprehensive code
generation benchmarks, yet current evaluation frameworks largely neglect
object-oriented programming (OOP) in favor of functional programming (FP),
e.g., HumanEval and MBPP. To address this, our study introduces a pioneering
OOP-focused benchmark, featuring 431 Python programs that encompass essential
OOP concepts and features like classes and encapsulation methods. We propose a
novel evaluation metric, pass@o, tailored for OOP, enhancing traditional pass@k
measures. Our evaluation of 23 leading large language models (LLMs), including
both general and code-specialized models, reveals three key insights: 1) pass@o
offers a more relevant and comprehensive assessment for OOP code generation; 2)
Despite excelling in FP, code-specialized LLMs like WizardCoder lag in OOP
compared to models like ChatGPT; 3) The poor performance of all advanced LLMs
on our OOP benchmark highlights a critical need for improvements in this field.
Our benchmark and scripts are publicly released at:
https://github.com/alphadl/OOP-eval. | [
-0.0251855776,
0.0631157309,
-0.0083056688,
0.0216139983,
-0.0088302679,
0.0030745096,
-0.0405229181,
0.0304829851,
0.0053202156,
-0.0278215762,
-0.0236989018,
0.0206196625,
0.0181374867,
0.0604181066,
-0.0138650946,
-0.0461846776,
0.0438284539,
-0.0371001661,
-0.0714067295,
0.0402757898,
-0.0529383086,
-0.0028633166,
-0.0165641811,
0.0453043319,
0.0461882055,
-0.0318049416,
0.0172531549,
0.0089109372,
-0.0258732475,
-0.0376126319,
-0.0009354539,
0.0271026436,
-0.031016279,
0.0284475144,
0.0000022423,
-0.0641333312,
0.0203221478,
0.0491807945,
0.0243945774,
0.0883669928,
0.0470341295,
0.0145496028,
0.0156433918,
0.0294597596,
0.0105222026,
-0.0092048272,
0.0317607895,
-0.0493440665,
0.0226939693,
0.0412619412,
0.011192386,
0.0068663564,
0.0101428209,
0.0338701978,
0.0108027253,
-0.0163611285,
-0.0376256928,
0.0307231676,
0.0128212841,
-0.0193215013,
0.0158050228,
-0.0119453045,
0.0104630031,
0.0001443184,
0.0392864682,
0.0201975387,
-0.0342009813,
-0.0291802399,
0.0030029344,
0.0054561817,
-0.0720560327,
-0.0254459064,
-0.0149425175,
-0.0035506377,
-0.041757144,
-0.0193545427,
-0.0291662011,
0.0161569435,
0.0431779772,
-0.0245915353,
0.0148404865,
0.0241253823,
0.0457103215,
-0.0038302166,
-0.0053623104,
0.0405515023,
0.0454159975,
-0.0023479695,
-0.0007011651,
-0.0072779511,
-0.0139763271,
-0.0451309867,
-0.015919935,
0.059615016,
-0.0171077512,
-0.0427999087,
-0.0018168821,
0.0210657101,
0.0621975064,
-0.0750787333,
0.0109213423,
0.0193256065,
0.0220975801,
0.0091350237,
-0.0167317819,
0.069947131,
-0.0137195121,
-0.0288723353,
0.0013112467,
0.0348261148,
-0.0494780019,
-0.0013484168,
-0.0055404888,
0.0390379541,
0.0420884602,
0.0353491753,
-0.0466502048,
0.0285930708,
-0.042704016,
0.0680007935,
-0.061121989,
-0.033894036,
0.047846701,
0.0372358449,
0.0299203526,
0.011828904,
-0.0168609917,
-0.0558459647,
0.0091995047,
-0.0424670428,
0.0166323539,
0.0223786253,
-0.0324223414,
-0.0061452542,
0.0308241025,
0.0959101021,
0.0099024847,
0.0205057878,
0.0346145257,
-0.0312813409,
0.0379255824,
-0.0323694348,
-0.0254252963,
-0.1060103253,
-0.0393237881,
0.0448657982,
0.0134516424,
-0.0284570064,
-0.0058788634,
-0.0216539092,
0.0189665388,
-0.0268452037,
-0.0124295019,
0.0364739634,
-0.0093806218,
0.045545876,
0.0002781596,
0.0191656854,
0.032915324,
0.0025501775,
0.0255865138,
-0.0553683415,
0.0517485924,
0.0515031219,
-0.0413494781,
0.0174941383,
0.0185639486,
0.0438687578,
0.0190583449,
0.0104187774,
-0.0331562646,
0.0478988104,
-0.0183504559,
0.0626333803,
-0.018174421,
0.0022667767,
-0.0205781888,
0.0175989661,
0.0366131887,
0.0321114771,
0.0571228303,
-0.0345708318,
-0.0130373789,
0.0451279804,
-0.064295657,
0.0051566726,
-0.0283532981,
0.0631063879,
0.032345023,
-0.0571226589,
-0.0492508933,
0.0131469946,
-0.0195464864,
0.0145118143,
0.0379843749,
-0.0093087964,
-0.0434698537,
0.0487533025,
-0.0111549431,
-0.1011407822,
-0.0402313583,
-0.049605716,
0.0180971287,
0.0291699599,
0.0647012293,
-0.0842051953,
-0.0226454474,
-0.020130435,
-0.038852118,
0.0082303658,
0.1004547626,
-0.017388463,
0.0280776694,
-0.0077867801,
-0.0100241285,
-0.0536250509,
0.0250601619,
0.0392330736,
0.0267396383,
-0.0302830916,
0.0479297191,
-0.0305514671,
-0.0583057664,
0.0546786524,
-0.019864751,
-0.0022387756,
-0.0066360561,
-0.0134807937,
-0.0057210401,
-0.0065360791,
-0.028635161,
0.0170981493,
0.0487164557,
0.0188096445,
0.0248713195,
-0.0573955253,
-0.0003667268,
0.052714996,
-0.0048776516,
0.0087847691,
-0.0602694303,
0.0655559972,
-0.0365496166,
0.0084939506,
0.062895298,
0.0424406789,
0.0466731302,
0.0270558223,
0.0558973402,
-0.0777077153,
-0.002962762,
0.0041404176,
0.0274091978,
0.0057644197,
0.0447119102,
-0.0216512606,
0.0342009179,
0.0708346441,
0.0386317335,
-0.0569262132,
0.0241419971,
-0.0482943803,
0.0804229081,
0.0293370448,
0.0609409511,
-0.0413834862,
-0.0461054631,
-0.0699957535,
0.0505595729,
-0.0253614411,
0.0273707714,
0.0672470406,
0.0275811385,
0.0204870757,
0.0463026054,
0.0199608225,
-0.0251322538,
-0.0000356132,
0.0314213149,
0.0087999571,
-0.0579495877,
-0.1019593179,
-0.0178817399,
-0.0071612862,
-0.0232503451,
0.0559155941,
-0.0169584397,
0.0268847737,
-0.0047583198,
0.0463311449,
-0.0174081679,
-0.0263631362,
-0.0022023518,
-0.008318672,
0.0314624757,
-0.0371794254,
0.0469886586,
0.0379982889,
-0.0301997866,
0.0057278029,
0.0765036866,
0.0099362247,
-0.0063267224,
-0.0208836384,
0.010794214,
-0.0433593728,
0.0184334889,
-0.0320193842,
0.0396878347,
0.0349655822,
-0.04135314,
-0.0344811045,
-0.0206391178,
-0.0078802798,
-0.0227949768,
0.0000402228,
-0.0486263856,
-0.0130183836,
0.0091067813,
0.0445710309,
-0.0030072369,
-0.0516134985,
-0.0096414648,
-0.0351989493,
0.0085135885,
0.0065453895,
-0.020343788,
-0.0690944791,
0.0854130536,
0.0086938292,
0.0166548565,
-0.0273717865,
-0.0323724411,
0.0030146309,
0.0149388257,
-0.0066995844,
-0.071861282,
0.0243348628,
-0.0262961052,
0.0074543147,
0.0123468777,
0.0005053997,
-0.0336988308,
0.0182584655,
-0.0144241136,
0.0168403536,
-0.0513756946,
-0.019533772,
0.0166286957,
-0.0066002868,
0.0002802133,
0.0261883996,
0.0447386205,
-0.0138462409,
0.0078520207,
-0.039223671,
-0.0717965513,
-0.0865209922,
0.0009143832,
-0.0364680104,
0.0279606786,
0.019249117,
0.0365678035,
0.0304866992,
-0.0470906645,
-0.0002639265,
0.0125903226,
-0.0543459207,
-0.0420073606,
0.0482966863,
0.0556908287,
-0.072201103,
-0.0439664498,
0.0699116364,
0.0165583603,
-0.0009794815,
0.0427293852,
-0.0424804352,
0.0624381565,
0.0686107501,
0.0446911491,
-0.0281601995,
-0.0133645656,
0.0026447466,
0.0357834622,
-0.0188043471,
-0.023060618,
0.0133860493,
-0.0857812688,
0.0002859487,
0.0048599723,
-0.0436803475,
-0.0418231711,
-0.0408897735,
-0.0169080105,
-0.0198326353,
-0.0357273333,
0.0450618491,
-0.0142888473,
0.0158515871,
-0.0200653914,
-0.0568009466,
0.0123827346,
0.0787177533,
0.0009732425,
-0.0316094272,
0.0601960234,
0.0091593275,
-0.016977312,
-0.0053456151,
0.0685379356,
0.0108376108,
-0.03518131,
-0.0097787054,
0.0440930426,
0.0402447283,
-0.0175005924,
0.0144692082,
-0.0002050582,
-0.0286643244,
-0.0087444717,
0.0241215117,
0.0194029212,
0.0159164313,
-0.0206842106,
-0.0101991426,
-0.0173957944,
-0.0310484283,
0.0302512925,
0.026689196,
0.0131179746,
-0.0612203404,
-0.0664979517,
-0.0625476763,
-0.0308702439,
-0.0213307235,
-0.0001420586,
0.022421984,
-0.0388002843,
-0.0101814773,
0.0778868571,
0.022298662,
-0.0226118341,
0.0145971999,
-0.0462542251,
-0.0309299771,
-0.0165873747,
-0.0698517337,
-0.0110384645,
-0.0072987163,
0.036575377,
-0.0499585755,
-0.0083790608,
-0.0183280893,
0.0306671951,
-0.0365786143,
0.0214787237,
-0.0865714923,
-0.0551208369,
0.0167237464,
0.060172908,
0.0232258402,
-0.058637742,
-0.0125151901,
-0.0168590974,
-0.0008344479,
0.0156717468,
-0.0150737921,
0.0241968445,
-0.0077947206,
-0.0154589918,
0.0284638591,
-0.0286310837,
-0.0566990972,
-0.011871947,
0.0137491245,
-0.0172459576,
0.0485680215,
0.0273420122,
0.0059024524,
0.0425460599,
-0.0473189279,
0.0057383715,
-0.0544830039,
0.0273108762,
-0.0470540002,
-0.0035014458,
-0.0232346803,
-0.0481772795,
0.0282345209,
0.0326115862,
0.0014313476,
0.0625640452,
0.0409313291,
0.0121390019,
0.0859092176,
0.017178908,
0.0383908823,
-0.023738699,
-0.0113425888,
0.0766723305,
0.004947402,
-0.0372709781,
-0.0016795014,
-0.0163395293,
0.0474134162,
-0.0290511418,
0.0318325162,
-0.0029393693,
0.0923344195,
0.0097375354,
0.0089330431,
-0.0314015038,
-0.0683062151,
-0.0134736672,
0.0465569869,
-0.0015159557,
0.0178927854,
0.0497884564,
-0.0539628863,
0.0004261428,
-0.0403775536,
0.0511143319,
-0.0542384163,
-0.0372469537,
-0.0668296069,
0.0122156572,
0.0040876861,
-0.0286467504,
0.0899394751,
0.0136455214,
-0.0053102016,
0.0172229484,
-0.0014081191,
-0.0407179818,
0.0292870421,
0.0531812347,
-0.0183980465,
-0.0014373489,
-0.0149346003,
-0.0520805381,
-0.0610389747,
-0.029786611,
0.0184824634,
0.032210622,
0.0037649674,
0.014572286,
0.0427172408,
0.0032174599,
-0.0079422826,
-0.0109816846,
-0.0130356727,
0.0107310032,
-0.0296123177,
0.0203343518,
-5.625585355e-33,
-0.0406872705,
-0.0187038146,
0.0076406645,
0.0321369469,
-0.0282248538,
0.0152744455,
-0.0388628095,
0.0262547359,
-0.0045306855,
-0.038986925,
0.0346071161,
-0.0259390604,
-0.0345432684,
-0.0260317307,
0.0317535773,
0.0414118394,
0.0352635719,
0.0066920156,
-0.091360189,
0.0054842927,
-0.0059548388,
-0.0023395852,
0.0095964614,
0.0042638564,
-0.0305522382,
-0.0239597987,
0.0064324918,
-0.0369496718,
-0.0034385093,
-0.0057348693,
0.019232044,
-0.0165912025,
0.0049871728,
0.0075371806,
-0.0233207922,
-0.0205635913,
0.0104654804,
-0.0219913572,
-0.020299349,
-0.0054594218,
-0.0064727822,
-0.0236184876,
0.0510005802,
0.0333711207,
-0.0223333426,
-0.0458797999,
-0.0416022278,
-0.0026610096,
-0.0092896847,
0.0093861511,
-0.0609761812,
0.0313408151,
-0.0690223724,
-0.0129977195,
0.0136097958,
0.0014434627,
-0.064209342,
0.0071832961,
0.0766776577,
-0.0073264828,
0.0097634401,
0.0409317352,
0.0597215556,
0.0135302823,
0.0026318405,
0.0179854762,
0.0449223295,
0.0558792762,
-0.0196104906,
0.0639214218,
0.0357891358,
0.0573648773,
0.0411155,
-0.0017482906,
0.0231785122,
-0.0069849417,
-0.0406949483,
0.0058753826,
0.002061134,
-0.0114216842,
0.0045157559,
-0.0085714487,
-0.0037766162,
0.0019206265,
-0.0817778707,
0.0256430097,
0.0055180374,
-0.0180369243,
0.0165082458,
-0.0354183093,
-0.0502892546,
-0.0186091606,
0.0119657358,
-0.042297665,
-0.0016963087,
0.0182879977,
-0.0616627038,
0.0534143224,
-0.0184108801,
0.0294854343,
-0.0092796357,
-0.0251025725,
-0.0193471499,
-0.0102087073,
0.0706472024,
-0.0039440743,
0.0111551872,
-0.0151648689,
-0.062362168,
0.0231581926,
-0.0712357908,
-0.0215315986,
0.0041706413,
0.0610371269,
0.0095283091,
-0.0184598137,
0.0133711183,
0.0389653519,
0.0126767308,
-0.0014039824,
-0.0474065691,
0.0179118849,
0.0479463451,
-0.0037035809,
-0.0129735535,
-0.0158184785,
-0.0918325856,
-0.0428060777,
0.0487132519,
0.0250566844,
-0.0723791197,
-0.002404972,
2.956e-7,
0.0185286179,
0.037430983,
-0.0037308487,
0.0872469693,
-0.021136919,
0.044678431,
-0.0231265165,
-0.0032711027,
0.0256552305,
0.0025676978,
-0.048335392,
-0.0034876224,
0.0493689813,
0.006953571,
-0.0142370034,
-0.012204553,
-0.0278879348,
-0.012979324,
-0.0430072993,
-0.0322660618,
-0.0051613608,
-0.0232527051,
0.0383315943,
-0.0036707423,
-0.002653714,
-0.0151330121,
0.0086676823,
0.0092993565,
0.0056873998,
0.0492825061,
-0.0772865489,
0.0280327387,
0.0332897827,
-0.0051062796,
0.0084983092,
-0.0242995806,
0.0547825769,
0.0436894596,
0.0068280031,
0.0389109664,
0.0478352606,
-0.0096473079,
-0.0131825311,
-0.0859893933,
0.0427552238,
0.0592819192,
-0.0341016762,
-0.0472698174,
-0.0494297892,
0.0004335739,
0.0044869613,
-0.0077389348,
-0.0033812877,
0.0333192647,
-0.0356905647,
-0.0102943424,
-0.0397038236,
0.03594153,
-0.0668855533,
-0.0153843258,
-0.0081025697,
-0.0684339032,
-0.0190350171,
0.0267791953,
-0.0142664267,
-0.0305764899,
-0.0214158073,
3.072325989e-34,
0.0441601686,
-0.0423227996,
0.0543252937,
0.0065414826,
0.0480062924,
-0.0149733154,
0.0065059122,
-0.0309113227,
-0.0346386693,
0.0173969772,
0.0073083709
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06620v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06620v2 | TransliCo: A Contrastive Learning Framework to Address the Script Barrier in Multilingual Pretrained Language Models | 2024-01-12T15:12:48 | 2024-05-23T13:30:09 | Yihong Liu, Chunlan Ma, Haotian Ye, Hinrich Schütze | cs.CL | cs.CL | The world's more than 7000 languages are written in at least 293 scripts. Due
to various reasons, many closely related languages use different scripts, which
poses a difficulty for multilingual pretrained language models (mPLMs) in
learning crosslingual knowledge through lexical overlap. As a consequence,
mPLMs are faced with a script barrier: representations from different scripts
are located in different subspaces, which can result in crosslingual transfer
involving languages of different scripts performing suboptimally. To address
this problem, we propose TransliCo, a framework that optimizes the
Transliteration Contrastive Modeling (TCM) objective to fine-tune an mPLM by
contrasting sentences in its training data and their transliterations in a
unified script (in our case Latin), which enhances uniformity in the
representation space for different scripts. Using Glot500-m, an mPLM pretrained
on over 500 languages, as our source model, we fine-tune it on a small portion
(5%) of its training data, and refer to the resulting model as Furina. We show
that Furina not only better aligns representations from distinct scripts but
also outperforms the original Glot500-m on various zero-shot crosslingual
transfer tasks. Additionally, we achieve consistent improvement in a case study
on the Indic group where the languages exhibit areal features but use different
scripts. We make our code and models publicly available. | [
-0.0198273547,
0.0511700548,
-0.0117493132,
0.0476763733,
-0.0330101848,
0.0363898352,
0.0283188056,
-0.0155618871,
-0.0149353258,
0.0010001168,
-0.0801439881,
-0.0651266128,
0.0447612107,
-0.0033219098,
0.0522182547,
-0.0649837181,
0.0390045494,
-0.0368256867,
-0.0295633674,
-0.0155190295,
0.0052659628,
0.0147769768,
0.0010287549,
-0.0093616666,
0.0257777032,
-0.0052645304,
0.0407750458,
-0.0039147991,
0.0656299517,
0.035210114,
-0.0266737305,
0.0430647694,
-0.0009516433,
0.0679604411,
0.0000018483,
-0.0589754172,
-0.0239041969,
-0.014251098,
0.0210100599,
0.0227281619,
0.068534717,
-0.0541452095,
-0.0151304863,
0.0052786754,
0.0086637987,
-0.0397945866,
0.0979402587,
-0.0182786901,
0.0036120485,
0.051995106,
-0.0377936922,
-0.0475097634,
0.0057126624,
-0.0398931019,
-0.0183362402,
-0.0311518367,
0.0135260886,
-0.006553445,
-0.0271887332,
-0.0293572471,
-0.0664362609,
0.0527690053,
-0.0132194292,
0.0299586654,
-0.0349337384,
0.0093340026,
0.0016590317,
-0.025564637,
0.0111523317,
0.0698680133,
-0.0284707192,
-0.0366367772,
-0.0316421986,
0.0067553516,
-0.0182125978,
-0.0275338888,
-0.0325004905,
-0.0012211025,
0.0099819368,
0.0284053721,
0.0740197226,
0.0236129221,
0.0318881012,
-0.0291913245,
-0.0659020692,
-0.0326645896,
0.0826734826,
-0.0196127072,
0.0185458045,
0.0441310331,
0.0207413919,
-0.015146439,
0.0166036189,
0.004936995,
-0.0173761342,
-0.0032101225,
-0.0402893461,
-0.0716435388,
0.0142795825,
0.0072226985,
0.1011440977,
0.0715718046,
-0.0449141227,
0.0227266159,
-0.0301504694,
0.0712842718,
-0.0172320046,
-0.0008460063,
-0.0209880341,
-0.0493072905,
-0.0073146201,
0.0291046835,
-0.0392112508,
-0.0200047847,
-0.0193203148,
0.0486093909,
-0.0205911119,
0.0069667595,
0.0042214789,
-0.0115669537,
0.0194531102,
-0.077308923,
-0.0624797568,
-0.0440906435,
0.0270752963,
0.0795421824,
-0.0005276545,
0.0176780559,
-0.0633196682,
-0.0443255603,
-0.0156677961,
0.0123895919,
-0.0048333625,
-0.0394370891,
0.0196174346,
0.094609499,
-0.0530963168,
-0.070876427,
-0.0443903729,
0.0413521007,
-0.018864898,
-0.0468834601,
-0.0142027773,
-0.0698861703,
0.0767075941,
-0.0099202935,
0.0314400569,
-0.0384145789,
-0.0381208993,
-0.0208531842,
-0.0183886159,
0.0919415727,
-0.0118911993,
0.0028113781,
-0.0153906941,
-0.0400990844,
-0.0194434263,
0.0423048064,
0.0448141843,
-0.0449216291,
0.0144997649,
-0.0257082991,
-0.0309799984,
0.0692981184,
0.0152095659,
0.0219387673,
-0.0527395196,
0.0059745577,
0.0467850566,
0.0275617316,
0.0648021773,
0.0466989726,
-0.0151021676,
-0.0218212008,
0.0512843169,
0.0329834297,
0.0367090367,
0.0396969467,
0.0485676713,
-0.0049965647,
-0.0172952265,
0.0070939059,
0.0203564409,
0.0051194103,
0.0121108303,
0.0208293349,
0.0214244034,
0.0724940747,
-0.0338227227,
0.026042914,
0.0154691683,
-0.0358448476,
0.0310054272,
-0.0276854206,
0.0836094469,
0.0111378478,
-0.0645087659,
0.0069245128,
0.0687187538,
-0.0596679598,
0.0200148933,
-0.0161037762,
0.0240274221,
0.0766265616,
0.0193912163,
-0.011091589,
-0.0243636407,
0.01550618,
-0.0292552486,
0.0285055526,
0.0435788967,
-0.0141193122,
0.0491299219,
-0.0639094189,
0.0237508789,
0.0040018349,
-0.0146765765,
0.0870806873,
-0.0433633439,
0.0471320711,
-0.0094005568,
-0.0259617418,
-0.0348310061,
0.0422144905,
-0.1011118069,
0.0078897635,
0.0019763331,
0.0140713183,
0.0229203515,
-0.0018811902,
-0.0358157903,
-0.0092067039,
-0.0226442814,
-0.0672205389,
0.0419721156,
0.0266270358,
-0.0385003649,
-0.0534851514,
0.0646612272,
-0.0462142862,
-0.0040041115,
0.0522941463,
-0.0138353175,
-0.0412008353,
0.0219718087,
-0.0101066679,
0.0219288263,
-0.0313680954,
0.0088183573,
0.0000325249,
0.0060353414,
-0.0143896937,
0.011936537,
0.0321454592,
-0.006106161,
0.0212138724,
-0.0332034193,
0.0427648425,
0.0027419219,
-0.0205726735,
0.019048756,
0.0024287703,
0.0357827805,
-0.011452591,
0.0268220045,
0.0107398909,
-0.0112995328,
-0.0845072344,
0.008352845,
-0.01440435,
0.0288829729,
0.0371152945,
0.0489723049,
-0.0184356961,
-0.018581735,
0.004201238,
-0.0078211688,
-0.0022779026,
0.0142718852,
0.0215022266,
0.0093573667,
0.025335893,
-0.016677361,
-0.02266578,
0.0235944781,
0.0424764156,
-0.0311229657,
-0.016841175,
-0.0128123285,
0.0655479878,
-0.0194145814,
0.0182566736,
-0.0122708967,
-0.0306642111,
0.0031947556,
-0.0157186519,
0.0292661842,
0.0210691523,
-0.0342897885,
-0.0306487735,
0.0429705009,
-0.0568407252,
0.0031011105,
-0.0322654955,
0.0271442216,
-0.0200138465,
-0.0538828336,
-0.0332519077,
-0.0215467755,
0.0990222171,
-0.0113373492,
-0.0211085975,
-0.1053145155,
-0.0500553213,
-0.015520568,
0.0155134173,
-0.004340108,
0.0450994261,
-0.0053388663,
0.0356550291,
-0.0314257182,
-0.0120637463,
0.0774625763,
-0.06367594,
-0.0125774965,
-0.0647086501,
0.0015984701,
-0.0378213301,
0.0228839144,
-0.0248521902,
0.0168393124,
-0.0394563042,
-0.0386512354,
-0.0606909916,
0.0101677319,
0.0070278994,
-0.0260797031,
0.0333385989,
-0.0192761105,
0.0139926784,
-0.03077971,
-0.0302520674,
0.0068419934,
-0.0075891321,
-0.0256538372,
0.0046303002,
0.0092661036,
-0.0388966762,
0.0093234815,
0.0319425128,
-0.0245790407,
0.0874465853,
0.0037872973,
0.0277110226,
-0.0228476599,
0.0047680717,
-0.0272387415,
-0.0100769587,
-0.0081972638,
-0.0376449376,
0.0324826315,
-0.0121609569,
-0.0063130488,
-0.0389353782,
-0.026053872,
0.0048136613,
0.0459893458,
-0.0089718634,
-0.0123195238,
-0.0344632193,
0.0456682555,
0.003165693,
-0.0252694748,
0.0753834024,
-0.0146986647,
-0.0564898998,
-0.0188955255,
-0.0256471429,
0.0343380645,
-0.0091630751,
0.0337434411,
-0.0739033595,
-0.0304584075,
0.0030105799,
0.013740018,
0.0341041163,
-0.0202509724,
-0.0123221483,
-0.1253161579,
0.0068150787,
0.0395192802,
-0.0895471498,
-0.0683014691,
0.0014927799,
-0.0136934957,
-0.0379237123,
0.0236153323,
0.0206133574,
-0.027866425,
0.0008697406,
0.014627683,
-0.0024296432,
-0.0568096079,
0.009588615,
-0.0515866168,
0.0126406383,
0.0085731074,
0.0228915401,
-0.0391854495,
-0.0120665533,
-0.0156412702,
-0.0418298282,
-0.0490985997,
-0.0155682014,
0.0618659407,
0.0144413076,
-0.044945851,
0.0195999406,
-0.0060249469,
-0.0387287177,
-0.0399772152,
-0.0043580444,
0.0446022078,
0.0255531184,
-0.0027085291,
0.0302193128,
0.0173578449,
0.0096484451,
0.0461959802,
0.0339481011,
-0.0391952731,
-0.0049566198,
-0.0009256089,
-0.001814595,
-0.0722847283,
-0.0119462153,
0.0117397746,
-0.0295590255,
-0.0256009717,
-0.0460071377,
-0.0421457812,
0.0311156418,
0.0206281021,
0.0152589781,
0.0021649331,
-0.0515868068,
-0.0280943364,
-0.0301812831,
0.0117159914,
-0.0454622433,
0.0156924631,
-0.0419210047,
-0.0383144133,
0.0227635112,
-0.028132407,
-0.0155254314,
0.0111907972,
-0.0657653287,
-0.0479330085,
-0.0036803985,
0.0395110957,
0.0180700626,
0.0375207178,
-0.0129794655,
-0.0248610545,
0.0517948829,
-0.02975538,
0.0024121499,
0.0368332528,
0.0589865744,
-0.0305542052,
-0.0067322068,
0.0361789986,
-0.008967896,
-0.0021417616,
0.030822482,
0.0400122218,
-0.0269395299,
-0.0377772339,
-0.0052505317,
-0.0018582889,
0.02027224,
-0.0632215142,
-0.026950866,
-0.0686705261,
0.0043426338,
-0.0190152992,
0.0193916466,
-0.0327949822,
-0.0242149811,
0.0645814091,
-0.0007318004,
0.0094490983,
-0.0248601176,
-0.0291999858,
-0.0212777201,
-0.0108499117,
0.0003069783,
0.0552235693,
0.0281195007,
0.0274678022,
0.0515093654,
-0.0066219945,
0.0172875375,
-0.004800166,
0.0422501639,
-0.0335162655,
0.0031060043,
0.0102133313,
0.0340165198,
0.0114445994,
0.0321126431,
-0.0012759574,
-0.0371514373,
-0.0060492074,
-0.0087383902,
0.0765302256,
-0.005007966,
0.091900602,
-0.0210840423,
-0.0161744319,
-0.0271523371,
0.0419853888,
-0.0487945378,
0.0534186773,
0.000276342,
-0.0248560384,
0.0095947813,
0.0214701332,
0.0748658702,
0.0085491883,
0.0233187284,
-0.0051103961,
0.0111763272,
-0.0158723965,
-0.0127975866,
0.0384280272,
-0.0259244535,
-0.0119648436,
-0.034270104,
-0.0513216145,
-0.0823636204,
0.0455730073,
0.0148489559,
-0.0256010108,
0.0293022525,
0.0174314864,
0.0475531109,
-0.0086942995,
0.0692365617,
-0.0254009683,
0.0187083986,
0.0426659957,
-0.0261053424,
-0.014184827,
-5.655082549e-33,
-0.0438832045,
0.0757985488,
0.0118995914,
-0.0152080869,
-0.0069754208,
-0.0172928739,
-0.0145334844,
-0.0078008096,
-0.0229738764,
0.0222990867,
0.0234171171,
-0.0168858599,
0.0189352017,
0.0097604757,
0.0091355704,
-0.0100772167,
0.03584373,
0.0128587373,
-0.0136672156,
0.0255281962,
0.045411963,
0.0672170147,
0.0876106843,
-0.0346666574,
-0.00527268,
-0.0222353786,
0.028078815,
-0.0034426295,
0.0312911794,
0.032041654,
-0.0155173559,
0.0213726889,
0.0126596373,
-0.0012908205,
-0.0400392152,
0.0422912389,
-0.0581057146,
-0.0190322716,
0.0445225723,
0.0405351557,
-0.01113931,
-0.0485925041,
0.0030472011,
-0.0303395279,
-0.0057025529,
-0.0519099161,
0.0169755071,
-0.0336338244,
0.001142827,
-0.0061649415,
-0.0873066038,
0.0210058298,
0.0137919961,
-0.0221249778,
0.0604269728,
0.058309596,
0.0153148919,
0.0468569547,
-0.0545376129,
0.0207914039,
-0.0031234063,
0.0279714279,
0.044259537,
0.0185305048,
-0.0334329307,
0.0103009986,
0.0034808072,
-0.0557697453,
0.0807005093,
0.0251737479,
0.0467372015,
-0.0102412365,
0.043985337,
0.0593380928,
0.0035548697,
-0.024920987,
-0.0388924591,
0.0071436483,
-0.0281370021,
-0.0265796073,
0.0172782503,
-0.0092115542,
0.0022700983,
-0.0331879109,
-0.0123096108,
-0.0920181796,
-0.0038473373,
-0.0026938575,
0.0133026745,
-0.0515637137,
0.0074904407,
0.006006232,
0.0914535597,
-0.0429060906,
-0.0154095506,
0.0157710984,
-0.0443862379,
0.0371627435,
-0.0117170904,
0.0534731969,
-0.0415856205,
-0.0567981601,
0.007810066,
-0.0038406688,
0.0122895204,
-0.011630605,
0.0608761497,
0.0043903985,
-0.0498358086,
0.0235743914,
-0.0088250889,
-0.0079142926,
-0.0023886547,
0.061208766,
0.0211518761,
0.0161197018,
0.0196845997,
0.0483947359,
0.0602127127,
-0.0147891557,
-0.0044843466,
0.0020261505,
0.0019117962,
0.019581845,
-0.0103460765,
-0.0014844544,
-0.0278581046,
0.0286034904,
0.0502829067,
-0.0128456671,
-0.0160592031,
-0.0073586423,
2.589e-7,
0.0793846399,
-0.0064176978,
0.0250295494,
-0.0468382947,
0.0072488436,
0.0437802523,
-0.0508487038,
0.0367639698,
0.0217585806,
0.0250406433,
0.0330738463,
0.0320523456,
0.0771226883,
0.0234365035,
-0.0139336586,
-0.0164846629,
-0.0386959314,
0.0105344318,
-0.0438231342,
0.0269344803,
0.0123174516,
0.0953636616,
0.0058290269,
-0.029491568,
-0.0084255692,
-0.0182143915,
0.0848285705,
-0.0466862284,
-0.0370174535,
-0.0081386138,
-0.0183544271,
0.0066875219,
-0.0354182236,
0.0094237067,
-0.0122504383,
0.0421292,
0.014216491,
0.0392419361,
-0.0108888345,
-0.0044292398,
0.0180003699,
-0.0100381859,
-0.0441982821,
-0.0413306095,
0.0504815206,
-0.0162660945,
-0.0195310879,
-0.0314205661,
-0.0348820984,
0.043850977,
0.0502149537,
-0.0416701846,
-0.0288333707,
0.0142353782,
0.0695322528,
0.0135258865,
-0.0683831349,
-0.0311793145,
-0.0090556433,
0.0573038049,
-0.0109584341,
-0.0071013724,
0.0168103781,
-0.0302600022,
0.024430193,
-0.0188464634,
0.0349876359,
2.305476407e-34,
0.0218009558,
-0.0203820653,
0.0248730034,
-0.0053519807,
-0.0097551281,
-0.047117576,
-0.0321621485,
0.0273528546,
-0.0157082397,
-0.0267796647,
-0.0015020713
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06603v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06603v1 | Mutual Enhancement of Large Language and Reinforcement Learning Models through Bi-Directional Feedback Mechanisms: A Case Study | 2024-01-12T14:35:57 | 2024-01-12T14:35:57 | Shangding Gu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable capabilities for
reinforcement learning (RL) models, such as planning and reasoning
capabilities. However, the problems of LLMs and RL model collaboration still
need to be solved. In this study, we employ a teacher-student learning
framework to tackle these problems, specifically by offering feedback for LLMs
using RL models and providing high-level information for RL models with LLMs in
a cooperative multi-agent setting. Within this framework, the LLM acts as a
teacher, while the RL model acts as a student. The two agents cooperatively
assist each other through a process of recursive help, such as "I help you help
I help." The LLM agent supplies abstract information to the RL agent, enabling
efficient exploration and policy improvement. In turn, the RL agent offers
feedback to the LLM agent, providing valuable, real-time information that helps
generate more useful tokens. This bi-directional feedback loop promotes
optimization, exploration, and mutual improvement for both agents, enabling
them to accomplish increasingly challenging tasks. Remarkably, we propose a
practical algorithm to address the problem and conduct empirical experiments to
evaluate the effectiveness of our method. | [
0.0656134337,
0.0464861244,
-0.0316625945,
0.0362391882,
-0.0510743968,
0.0178106986,
-0.0280039534,
-0.0430076122,
-0.0040881881,
-0.0267460309,
-0.0262781717,
0.0149919894,
-0.0301267859,
0.0085628703,
-0.0082876207,
-0.0683253109,
0.0375389494,
-0.0561944917,
0.0206929948,
-0.0107150963,
-0.0103040161,
-0.018015828,
-0.0047748247,
0.0605475642,
-0.0018357594,
0.0279916823,
-0.0452682003,
-0.0237909053,
0.0096961074,
-0.0064814244,
-0.0172515363,
-0.0180439167,
0.0688877404,
0.0519770905,
0.0000021855,
-0.045525603,
-0.0484953858,
-0.0147703607,
0.006869528,
-0.0501465872,
0.0330095515,
-0.0008762772,
-0.022755364,
0.0022326997,
-0.0465914793,
0.0191546604,
0.0205763709,
0.028451534,
0.0714777187,
0.0390596539,
0.0338785723,
-0.0031468251,
-0.0069671436,
0.0015444206,
0.02305042,
-0.047434289,
0.0225576069,
0.0302794464,
0.0707139,
-0.0066402741,
-0.0309331045,
0.0349427909,
0.0624791272,
-0.065863885,
-0.0107561368,
0.0455874614,
0.0142432367,
-0.0280782282,
0.0148741081,
0.0439952388,
0.0069471011,
-0.0005622393,
-0.0095515531,
-0.0081080375,
0.0241322797,
0.0590586141,
-0.0266532786,
0.024905419,
0.0085832356,
0.0315340497,
0.0150318481,
-0.0663160384,
0.0439009853,
0.0156654976,
-0.0175043773,
0.0980576053,
-0.0406066291,
-0.0342203155,
-0.0049017398,
0.023677947,
-0.0009639197,
-0.0301154479,
-0.0135228476,
0.0644381642,
-0.0808708593,
0.0451834723,
0.0118870605,
-0.0102020372,
-0.0204124823,
-0.0119998213,
0.0493574552,
0.0179435313,
0.005793225,
0.0561363138,
-0.032489825,
0.0106565421,
0.0121497661,
0.0488112271,
-0.0203406531,
-0.0130602671,
-0.0842974558,
-0.0025946633,
-0.0530920252,
0.0694013536,
0.0097480966,
-0.0160621181,
-0.0166643728,
0.0473027639,
-0.032063134,
0.0771376044,
-0.0157047976,
-0.01429052,
-0.0088966545,
-0.0260035302,
-0.0634026304,
0.0125687541,
-0.0425832383,
0.0138086239,
0.0012853446,
-0.0127263824,
0.0144307883,
-0.0195159931,
-0.037724793,
-0.0089010103,
-0.0192806702,
0.0682441145,
-0.0183267184,
-0.0137275672,
-0.0269578099,
-0.0300367922,
0.0080041196,
-0.045333229,
-0.0183877535,
-0.0745060518,
-0.0046229856,
-0.028293876,
-0.0105470661,
-0.0051778629,
0.0305821411,
-0.0395463407,
-0.016074758,
0.0788446739,
-0.0277811438,
0.0208059009,
0.0090457173,
0.0184748452,
-0.029986538,
0.0862135664,
0.0669510812,
0.0240583867,
0.0079990877,
0.0260459688,
0.0044231559,
0.0191926546,
0.004363677,
0.0250500143,
0.0221651178,
-0.0186112877,
0.0171483736,
0.071880661,
-0.0245577171,
0.0218261089,
-0.0360153764,
0.0213480163,
0.0629149526,
0.03817451,
-0.0037279357,
-0.0048539243,
0.0506997816,
0.020427255,
-0.0311583988,
-0.0252344869,
-0.0456982143,
0.0250922367,
0.002155442,
0.0015603979,
-0.0022533257,
0.016359739,
-0.018308904,
-0.076706171,
0.0286537353,
-0.0114991572,
0.0432895645,
0.0586055294,
0.0719560906,
0.0224014334,
-0.0423943512,
-0.0429153107,
0.0339908078,
-0.0221479759,
0.0532258078,
-0.0915431678,
0.0597329587,
0.0960254818,
0.063666068,
-0.0684377849,
-0.0230229795,
-0.0095269745,
-0.02131401,
0.0499252863,
0.0134295179,
-0.0458788462,
-0.0140805654,
-0.0204713438,
-0.0523152761,
-0.0005073638,
-0.0030024415,
0.0377215035,
0.0156097058,
-0.016900694,
-0.025999479,
0.0336523913,
-0.0280991551,
0.0255853254,
-0.0228296109,
0.0107394112,
0.0039327373,
0.0197022688,
0.0245787762,
0.0108369244,
-0.0113258967,
0.0087913079,
0.034742482,
-0.0165561363,
-0.0655568242,
0.0206027385,
-0.034728989,
-0.0153578492,
0.0349151343,
0.0104167582,
-0.0033997812,
0.0147771742,
-0.0168529842,
-0.0164047088,
0.0575646162,
-0.0290099885,
0.0659283921,
-0.0165700652,
0.026465591,
-0.0108725289,
-0.05712118,
-0.0275569726,
0.0349042527,
0.0028850159,
-0.0142603889,
0.0013087769,
0.0254861936,
-0.0241249315,
-0.0224459488,
0.0156984553,
0.0200944673,
0.0333689786,
0.0093852198,
0.0565897934,
0.0045649218,
-0.0480724052,
-0.0497352593,
-0.0130252847,
-0.0460428298,
-0.008275114,
0.0144753698,
-0.0057230215,
-0.0299918503,
0.0059277448,
-0.0102988249,
0.0099137025,
0.0320475623,
0.0189376567,
0.0014509489,
0.0105237709,
0.0617289618,
-0.0379131958,
-0.0504070632,
0.0100027807,
-0.0121688321,
-0.0286610387,
0.0384841263,
-0.0148322312,
-0.0522944294,
-0.0130837075,
-0.0215423498,
0.0432045497,
-0.0271992255,
-0.0281032976,
0.0370194726,
-0.0320163853,
0.0122591779,
0.0865492895,
-0.0142654674,
0.0788720846,
0.0842854381,
-0.0405650251,
-0.0939228386,
0.0590609424,
-0.0483480617,
-0.0627783239,
-0.0716581643,
-0.0008479705,
0.0060282112,
0.0505868942,
-0.0354404338,
-0.010535419,
-0.0678784177,
0.022575859,
-0.0029602598,
-0.0477948599,
-0.032508228,
-0.022731699,
-0.0170080513,
0.0060853264,
-0.0261054803,
-0.0337756686,
0.1153427362,
0.0160491001,
-0.0270020105,
-0.0370093919,
-0.0133344224,
-0.0448328666,
0.0521223806,
-0.0089687509,
0.0192287359,
-0.030687144,
-0.0116875377,
-0.0295817796,
-0.023574695,
0.0474125184,
-0.0013930973,
0.0337882079,
-0.0735321492,
0.000960097,
0.0181872454,
-0.0373040438,
-0.0322734453,
0.01202597,
-0.0368267484,
0.0366772786,
-0.0163775906,
-0.0422548801,
-0.0391291119,
-0.0254730154,
0.0660246536,
-0.0008554465,
-0.0045648692,
-0.0254667718,
-0.0519573838,
-0.0551782697,
0.0209187344,
-0.0087113362,
-0.0100522498,
-0.0722569227,
0.0562036112,
0.0314678997,
0.036115475,
-0.0381947421,
0.0004843022,
-0.004384127,
0.0116193332,
-0.0337003618,
0.0100307697,
0.0290203411,
0.0098782489,
-0.063997291,
-0.0308725201,
0.0946503058,
0.032445509,
-0.0469003916,
0.0118056498,
-0.0529276989,
0.0264092907,
0.0197240748,
0.0421484709,
-0.0260585882,
0.0002892094,
0.003373005,
0.018346075,
-0.0029773114,
-0.0409216136,
0.0068421252,
-0.1437515914,
0.0197202656,
0.0008553471,
-0.0363739207,
-0.0033906137,
-0.0361514091,
-0.0082847355,
0.0134167867,
0.0096389912,
0.0001586974,
0.0093795834,
-0.0117116068,
0.0225345474,
0.0295675881,
-0.020011276,
-0.0156444497,
-0.0397448316,
0.048881039,
0.0836017802,
0.0261049252,
0.0007092188,
0.0004804316,
-0.0269842669,
0.0576149449,
0.0153038362,
-0.0289215632,
-0.0342734531,
-0.0273295492,
0.0005829126,
0.0249820631,
0.0508774705,
0.0060031395,
-0.001469898,
0.0442538708,
0.0853954032,
-0.0066374228,
-0.0062230099,
0.0048675952,
0.022257423,
0.0204882845,
0.0472278595,
0.010745937,
-0.0357072353,
-0.0130470674,
-0.0043436652,
-0.0799108893,
-0.0422309078,
-0.0228008237,
-0.0097523173,
-0.0191181395,
0.0499768592,
-0.0593946949,
-0.0616211146,
0.0584967323,
-0.0113470824,
0.0111226719,
0.028866224,
0.0124922786,
0.0180489197,
0.0256565288,
-0.0173838083,
-0.0345408246,
0.021629706,
-0.0604370609,
-0.0297795832,
-0.0209065024,
-0.050107155,
0.0033827613,
-0.0170630459,
-0.0452119969,
-0.0931240171,
-0.0000120066,
0.0675049722,
0.0075803795,
0.0519803241,
-0.0016076542,
-0.0574058779,
0.0055223187,
0.0279285181,
-0.0131585645,
-0.0236183498,
0.0060649971,
0.0303822421,
0.0285439733,
0.0381530672,
-0.0500559658,
-0.0067836051,
0.0316135064,
0.0173383076,
-0.0479402393,
0.0072064721,
0.027519485,
-0.0066198609,
-0.0002527082,
0.0008649413,
-0.0111511061,
-0.0241850298,
0.0326112881,
-0.0324643143,
-0.0412482545,
-0.0502947047,
0.0265278518,
0.0179061759,
-0.0317400843,
0.0489938185,
0.0059144334,
0.0377587527,
0.0125573697,
0.0121994279,
0.039315246,
0.0008085595,
0.0153517844,
0.031449385,
0.0331634246,
0.0283219106,
-0.0055982228,
0.0365347452,
0.0277202409,
0.0354011916,
0.0756924972,
0.0329797268,
-0.0136918603,
-0.0085120564,
-0.0066230302,
-0.0444629975,
-0.1081597432,
0.0397745743,
0.0617941357,
0.0573358983,
0.0612228401,
0.0116121341,
-0.1067985967,
0.0165568404,
0.008950037,
0.0016086468,
-0.0091430293,
-0.0718751997,
0.0439394154,
0.0255646948,
0.0112334816,
0.0016464012,
0.0462466329,
-0.0055781691,
0.0550150983,
-0.0202879533,
0.0107756648,
-0.0205633622,
-0.0141920196,
0.0437436476,
0.0206954665,
-0.0514659919,
0.0351375192,
-0.0284263771,
-0.0230563097,
-0.0610555261,
0.059168186,
-0.0280569661,
-0.0046732761,
0.033434853,
0.0043365713,
-0.0002900997,
-0.0374170952,
-0.0638535991,
0.0030819257,
-0.0014218355,
-0.0128310751,
0.0104524158,
-6.009171202e-33,
-0.0437016226,
-0.0279088505,
0.0639156401,
-0.0031763848,
-0.0224775076,
-0.0168126915,
-0.0250379555,
0.0117626004,
-0.0006593252,
0.0297350883,
0.007600998,
0.0144112175,
0.0114752697,
-0.0116889337,
0.0440696292,
0.0033722154,
0.0332703181,
0.0112455655,
-0.0356566906,
0.0131428614,
0.0069157458,
0.0181521419,
0.0366929397,
-0.0532137901,
0.0218939018,
0.0107195592,
-0.0151139842,
0.088889055,
-0.0504565984,
0.0570084751,
0.0254146196,
0.004605744,
-0.0071900971,
-0.045000609,
-0.0329351202,
-0.003334413,
-0.05572889,
-0.0265746005,
0.0320566818,
-0.0093811769,
-0.0793389976,
-0.0138274329,
0.0120635694,
0.0120357377,
-0.0095618507,
0.0230848379,
0.0316710025,
-0.0032503444,
-0.0153151136,
0.0466226824,
-0.0590174273,
-0.0039345273,
-0.0068925461,
-0.0391828232,
0.0545949228,
0.0031758486,
0.0032667976,
-0.0050926046,
-0.0016088051,
0.0523866303,
0.0329240449,
0.0178881474,
0.0542562343,
0.0278792419,
0.0259424187,
0.039386414,
-0.0064173113,
0.0217561144,
-0.0261489935,
-0.0552642569,
0.0302528832,
0.0502694882,
0.0353065059,
0.039320603,
-0.0215920657,
0.0481888354,
-0.016480606,
0.0000180309,
0.0579380468,
0.0756005943,
0.0148741398,
0.0189376343,
-0.0256812423,
-0.016127605,
-0.067964986,
0.0265250113,
-0.0063937735,
-0.0566810891,
0.0224832743,
0.0354205966,
-0.0021035026,
-0.043702472,
-0.0146649182,
-0.0321350768,
-0.0359291956,
0.0090189921,
-0.0099568842,
0.000578247,
-0.0220186282,
0.0011779797,
-0.0982805341,
-0.0417943634,
-0.0190490745,
-0.0390069745,
-0.0152675482,
0.0200209506,
0.008124942,
0.0366858654,
-0.0281783342,
0.0162582509,
-0.0398619398,
0.0070827184,
0.0339525491,
-0.0498706251,
0.0220709275,
-0.0186878927,
-0.0266590752,
0.0393290743,
0.0250602383,
-0.0535632558,
-0.0132327368,
-0.0009526529,
-0.0447596461,
-0.0189054962,
-0.0171621386,
-0.0126339998,
-0.0582484752,
0.0370655134,
0.0126892319,
-0.041924987,
-0.0144285783,
-0.0048232041,
2.922e-7,
-0.015353797,
0.0488515235,
0.0208658464,
0.0264923293,
0.013990717,
0.0455498286,
-0.0608277246,
0.0107840179,
0.0132157309,
0.0262008775,
0.0461058207,
0.0545816161,
0.0196327716,
0.0307506621,
-0.0488925911,
0.0003695125,
-0.0602667443,
-0.0144022591,
-0.0697422922,
-0.0284789316,
0.0207311567,
0.0141050201,
0.0455063097,
0.0112182768,
0.0179846287,
-0.0501538292,
0.0407012887,
-0.0558002815,
-0.0295922291,
0.0252423286,
-0.0028818725,
-0.0023022604,
0.0050359475,
-0.004274792,
0.0218108706,
0.0164419357,
-0.0683742985,
0.0325467736,
0.0031155844,
0.0045854989,
-0.0156269912,
0.0166600551,
0.0022421773,
-0.0344454311,
0.024123041,
-0.0627494007,
0.0051253238,
0.0057424312,
0.0472423844,
-0.0389859304,
-0.0168520305,
-0.0285246223,
-0.0297860336,
0.0124801705,
-0.0098503986,
0.0022485221,
0.0004935339,
-0.0620068461,
0.0172252879,
-0.0229056906,
-0.0382547453,
-0.0320104323,
-0.0449026413,
0.0367312543,
-0.0590096749,
-0.0405653752,
0.0119248461,
2.262944634e-34,
0.0153399659,
-0.0239669122,
0.0066438993,
0.0434883609,
0.0426664948,
0.0253266823,
-0.0465696193,
0.0365722924,
0.0677118301,
-0.0162358154,
-0.0369113162
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06591v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06591v1 | Prometheus-Vision: Vision-Language Model as a Judge for Fine-Grained Evaluation | 2024-01-12T14:19:23 | 2024-01-12T14:19:23 | Seongyun Lee, Seungone Kim, Sue Hyun Park, Geewook Kim, Minjoon Seo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Assessing long-form responses generated by Vision-Language Models (VLMs) is
challenging. It not only requires checking whether the VLM follows the given
instruction but also verifying whether the text output is properly grounded on
the given image. Inspired by the recent approach of evaluating LMs with LMs, in
this work, we propose to evaluate VLMs with VLMs. For this purpose, we present
a new feedback dataset called the Perception Collection, encompassing 15K
customized score rubrics that users might care about during assessment. Using
the Perception Collection, we train Prometheus-Vision, the first open-source
VLM evaluator model that can understand the user-defined score criteria during
evaluation. Prometheus-Vision shows the highest Pearson correlation with human
evaluators and GPT-4V among open-source models, showing its effectiveness for
transparent and accessible evaluation of VLMs. We open-source our code,
dataset, and model at https://github.com/kaistAI/prometheus-vision | [
0.0053991121,
0.0068500065,
-0.0269865058,
0.0553480536,
-0.0234258287,
0.0022264642,
-0.0006853745,
0.0057191346,
0.0127711752,
-0.0654004589,
-0.060938701,
-0.0257027373,
0.0200499445,
0.0549982749,
0.0220115725,
-0.0723090172,
0.0220853537,
-0.0345200524,
0.0046918113,
0.0191389807,
0.0286153238,
-0.0009748386,
-0.0188042615,
0.0224416163,
0.0312863588,
-0.0426636189,
-0.0049436986,
0.0013462243,
0.0488878675,
-0.0186148714,
-0.0032301068,
0.0603898056,
-0.003205654,
0.0048975581,
0.0000020649,
-0.0285238326,
0.0420781523,
-0.0019001226,
0.0316921547,
0.0267264936,
0.0518105291,
0.0332959294,
0.0085882749,
0.014838744,
-0.0489693321,
-0.0359632,
0.0323890597,
0.0237345807,
0.0862892941,
0.0240393486,
0.0007111505,
0.0073490557,
-0.0044569434,
0.0035743928,
0.0348057523,
-0.0189137459,
-0.0140103446,
0.0178281162,
-0.0110004591,
0.0042429836,
-0.0388824604,
0.0213196017,
0.0335468501,
-0.0146846958,
0.046707388,
0.0011169305,
-0.0340892412,
-0.021080466,
-0.0247437153,
0.0962729901,
0.0156331714,
-0.0032117444,
-0.0234515518,
-0.0198708344,
0.0112726269,
-0.0311635453,
-0.0397276208,
0.0039093988,
0.0041564177,
-0.0081980918,
-0.0932149142,
0.0208927672,
0.0122647434,
0.0078793271,
0.0248019975,
0.0153863411,
0.0042682709,
-0.0216063783,
0.0085356394,
0.0113805933,
0.010257896,
-0.0211954713,
0.0016581663,
0.0089450143,
-0.0202808622,
-0.0105067678,
-0.0407361761,
-0.0038437156,
0.0199018512,
-0.0291545521,
0.0743591487,
-0.0002158101,
-0.0381572768,
0.0305821653,
-0.0573749617,
0.1264827996,
0.027733149,
0.0527072363,
-0.0369749479,
0.0134472335,
-0.0371343903,
0.0115269814,
0.0249254275,
-0.0139814727,
-0.0225081481,
-0.0089427959,
-0.0807976499,
-0.0094208522,
-0.0607433356,
0.0379532799,
-0.0131370733,
0.0357681923,
0.0101139033,
0.0135123208,
-0.0765054971,
0.0450127833,
0.0169076994,
0.0026220107,
0.0022422683,
-0.0304519329,
0.028377641,
0.0242457855,
0.0166627057,
0.01934845,
-0.0097404299,
0.0444843955,
0.0047084712,
-0.0156637449,
0.0054773823,
-0.021695178,
-0.0118565597,
-0.0461431183,
0.0101007028,
-0.0691909045,
-0.0037336436,
0.0075465492,
0.0035176119,
-0.0111276954,
0.0088949716,
0.0620660037,
0.0147706792,
0.0728197843,
0.0066021541,
0.0069627827,
-0.0249564853,
0.0177674033,
0.0156473015,
0.037046548,
0.038095478,
0.0684661046,
0.0199733693,
-0.06281735,
0.0507807881,
0.0352908671,
-0.0235788114,
-0.0277754683,
-0.0343162455,
0.014288567,
-0.0130633526,
0.0185430571,
0.0020663126,
0.0620074607,
0.0198894609,
0.0133523559,
0.0723180994,
0.0519527197,
0.0488405861,
-0.0481578149,
0.0444714054,
-0.0007229137,
0.0103934966,
-0.0029711623,
-0.054286886,
0.0248945337,
-0.011116703,
0.0169393308,
-0.0123179294,
0.0132904816,
-0.0048386343,
-0.0775571465,
-0.02980504,
-0.0133956447,
0.0085353889,
0.0238417406,
0.0397389159,
0.002300458,
-0.0383782014,
-0.0107618105,
0.0134508312,
-0.0800985992,
0.0301557016,
-0.0661550537,
0.035618294,
0.1100636795,
0.0504299626,
0.0256831255,
0.009866761,
-0.0104805073,
-0.0016736902,
0.0348749422,
0.0486666486,
-0.0060786381,
-0.0081781326,
-0.0647667795,
-0.0619159266,
0.0092192944,
-0.0170410294,
-0.006217442,
-0.0182297528,
-0.0139935985,
0.043921493,
-0.0491341799,
-0.06961146,
0.0333955176,
0.0572072938,
-0.0235273018,
-0.0382079259,
0.0066754054,
0.0142396428,
0.0098048272,
0.0050581293,
0.0261869933,
0.0203188621,
0.0061277258,
0.0204987098,
-0.0227391645,
-0.0250399094,
0.012913866,
0.0399465375,
-0.0889801532,
0.0027414779,
0.0673376918,
-0.0314512663,
-0.0288207196,
0.0078242477,
-0.0258946791,
-0.027467737,
-0.0382486321,
-0.0046496917,
-0.0310232658,
-0.014343393,
-0.0422382094,
0.0338170044,
-0.0147168497,
0.047893513,
-0.0132056456,
0.0135008907,
0.0144655444,
-0.0340985395,
-0.0527524538,
-0.0368387289,
-0.0171559583,
0.0607667193,
0.0061367941,
0.0626269504,
-0.0573794246,
0.0061485074,
-0.0840831101,
-0.0207038336,
-0.0134225311,
-0.0004822036,
0.0145254824,
-0.0331195183,
0.0034352504,
0.0024924991,
-0.0463874303,
0.0283467602,
0.03081109,
-0.0054049976,
0.0165465474,
-0.0230557453,
-0.0024684498,
-0.0261211935,
-0.0289702509,
-0.0225347709,
0.029652847,
0.0601448715,
0.0417318642,
-0.0263983868,
0.0408353023,
-0.0168133564,
-0.0076870248,
0.0164409913,
-0.0476501584,
0.0257225093,
-0.005413135,
0.0054914393,
0.0676904768,
0.0036548523,
0.0083477804,
0.0285300352,
-0.0127529707,
-0.0496138744,
-0.0127158128,
0.012532332,
-0.0182731785,
-0.0138794351,
-0.0385255702,
-0.0094236247,
0.0035584553,
0.0070673064,
0.0191964321,
-0.0711403415,
0.0430638306,
-0.0358260348,
-0.0452847145,
-0.0409134477,
0.0139252031,
-0.0230241958,
0.0351783112,
-0.0227000788,
-0.0755813122,
0.0526330732,
-0.0649036095,
-0.0131475022,
0.0064340704,
0.0257476307,
-0.0117832189,
0.0622796342,
0.0187396426,
-0.005973259,
-0.0256350543,
0.0151216453,
-0.0623490214,
-0.012923453,
-0.0020274341,
-0.0680934638,
0.0569711849,
-0.0507323518,
-0.0346782357,
-0.0341630429,
-0.0077827852,
-0.0372806154,
0.019550439,
-0.0227591433,
0.0021189456,
-0.0656187311,
0.0065329713,
-0.0264136884,
0.0181130618,
0.0293349307,
-0.0013163745,
-0.0371851288,
0.0039859749,
-0.0054595335,
0.0008483627,
0.0665828213,
0.0220054574,
0.0119002135,
-0.0478709899,
-0.0048974133,
0.067813091,
0.0558371209,
0.0173460618,
-0.045979023,
-0.0033497612,
0.0289614201,
0.0283489879,
0.0260487404,
0.0401191786,
0.0438070558,
-0.0686504692,
0.0119703794,
0.1090756208,
-0.0018881029,
-0.0551330596,
-0.0249426458,
-0.0112875588,
0.0034005335,
0.0480443947,
0.0092135649,
-0.0561852679,
-0.0376083367,
-0.0287791453,
0.0413249619,
0.0097749652,
0.0106056882,
0.0149561549,
-0.0948096365,
0.0543726087,
0.0039456137,
0.0001057077,
-0.0469703823,
0.0151163973,
0.0076577319,
-0.0235429406,
0.0006915185,
0.0074161608,
-0.0211482923,
0.0259841122,
0.0110488841,
-0.0154394116,
-0.0295340661,
0.0751198009,
-0.0419592746,
-0.0038453161,
0.0984287336,
0.0165564809,
-0.0251066759,
-0.1289901435,
0.0028854602,
-0.0468563996,
0.0003467931,
0.0048008095,
0.044245638,
-0.0273114368,
-0.0244647078,
-0.019593183,
0.0212929137,
-0.0415538251,
-0.0011381488,
0.0180703923,
0.0311573725,
-0.0207581073,
-0.0179779585,
-0.0320594944,
0.0084987124,
-0.0151428999,
0.0529432707,
0.0442540348,
-0.0704594404,
-0.0334545225,
-0.0226216149,
0.001398155,
-0.0463181213,
-0.0774361342,
0.0216120537,
0.0404563956,
-0.0041662254,
-0.0741456524,
-0.056931749,
0.0425983518,
0.030705912,
-0.0228026677,
-0.0502869338,
-0.0116344057,
0.0311136302,
-0.0571920462,
0.0870306417,
-0.0142741073,
0.0565534532,
-0.0754877999,
0.0135587044,
0.0143767241,
-0.0195381436,
-0.0275911707,
0.0443651266,
-0.0592926927,
-0.0102672772,
-0.0014240131,
0.0964414552,
0.021351194,
-0.0099077774,
-0.0194234848,
-0.0287297741,
0.057595402,
0.0001060051,
-0.0299570821,
0.0321429409,
0.0062707067,
-0.027511809,
-0.0186801646,
0.0050245831,
-0.0292097982,
0.0014498881,
0.0485773496,
0.0071001193,
0.0330005102,
-0.0570333414,
0.00169515,
0.0337345079,
0.0727865696,
-0.0146571295,
0.010606884,
-0.0093900142,
0.0080386391,
-0.0067716935,
-0.013531669,
-0.0625944287,
-0.0115502803,
0.0139796855,
0.0057083885,
0.0065700309,
-0.0116326315,
-0.0532873049,
0.0264048427,
-0.0731938779,
0.0396220274,
0.0439867079,
-0.0148967495,
0.0007041684,
-0.0052662906,
-0.029186761,
-0.0136205303,
-0.0445282646,
0.0290878639,
0.0291436594,
0.0812389627,
0.0001494109,
0.000977561,
0.0049285893,
0.0608887039,
-0.0203777067,
-0.0142470878,
-0.0467849933,
0.012829029,
0.0222069304,
0.0371562466,
0.011413129,
0.0035521025,
0.0173974372,
-0.0493074507,
0.0298883449,
-0.0019684306,
-0.016581146,
0.0648556054,
0.0335382819,
0.0097851055,
-0.0493037514,
0.0371267013,
-0.01789256,
-0.0084768254,
-0.0316089317,
-0.0074811159,
-0.054551471,
-0.0290953852,
0.0205740817,
0.0100511275,
-0.0081749111,
0.0009963247,
-0.0477253832,
-0.0769244656,
0.0260408316,
0.0837449059,
0.0220005941,
-0.0285351034,
0.0586291291,
0.0707922205,
-0.0200418103,
-0.0290287547,
-0.0293454826,
-0.0304366685,
-0.0208724346,
0.0067788428,
-0.0231463872,
-5.926378931e-33,
-0.0112677217,
-0.0259422418,
0.0233962685,
0.0335282385,
-0.0220950078,
0.0223581102,
0.0034507227,
0.0182712749,
-0.0022928182,
0.0050851889,
0.0380586572,
-0.0163208898,
0.0083419411,
0.0568697713,
0.0135302478,
-0.0034281816,
0.0397648774,
-0.0008184167,
-0.028906526,
0.0178953819,
-0.0307430401,
-0.0238122381,
0.0469966233,
-0.054501351,
0.0419598781,
0.0146020027,
-0.0326277986,
-0.017179396,
-0.0437645726,
0.1034750417,
-0.0181800313,
0.0535280928,
0.0321905389,
-0.0130656762,
-0.0276142266,
0.0469335653,
-0.024719812,
0.0085739195,
0.0189659409,
0.0458135121,
-0.0795119852,
0.0090191402,
0.0637566075,
-0.0229087546,
-0.0465201177,
-0.0420365259,
0.0684201345,
-0.0360889807,
0.003545963,
-0.0053235111,
-0.0132350735,
0.0103233112,
0.0160757713,
-0.0415961146,
0.0058750277,
0.0588540249,
-0.0178297702,
0.0465622023,
-0.0483079478,
0.0167714376,
0.0161307473,
0.0135757374,
0.1103672311,
0.0664106235,
-0.0147960177,
0.050574854,
0.0104838405,
-0.026554266,
-0.0031750596,
-0.04584831,
0.0455563366,
0.0459429584,
0.0898505077,
0.065394327,
-0.0314741544,
0.0048817834,
-0.0372878462,
0.0389300399,
-0.0533026643,
0.0704281032,
0.0403279774,
-0.0056622089,
-0.0503166802,
0.0048216567,
-0.0717787072,
-0.0235661641,
-0.0655673519,
-0.0097892703,
0.0610121973,
-0.0072178375,
-0.0051506767,
0.0164612662,
0.0442755856,
-0.0328806452,
0.0165531468,
-0.0319919623,
-0.0143703949,
0.0494750254,
-0.000421203,
-0.0061443555,
-0.03163746,
0.0218113214,
0.0247404352,
0.016649792,
0.0211284608,
-0.0146973003,
0.0020079531,
0.0036093174,
-0.0463010482,
-0.0027942369,
-0.0351684093,
-0.0134188402,
-0.0073795225,
0.035731785,
0.0284871086,
0.0003909615,
-0.0495366268,
0.0495430194,
-0.0502580404,
-0.0110969385,
-0.0256216303,
-0.0563036092,
0.0080765467,
0.0232959669,
-0.0587157197,
-0.026315745,
-0.0360857286,
-0.0140419593,
0.0126969498,
0.0031003309,
0.0162260793,
0.0337980688,
2.591e-7,
0.0239040367,
0.0256958008,
-0.023874348,
-0.0223862324,
0.0139356088,
0.0679527745,
-0.015139794,
0.0372695997,
0.0366984494,
-0.0428631641,
-0.0080037322,
0.0202379357,
0.0542511381,
-0.0151464492,
-0.0425778814,
0.0430097096,
-0.0207506772,
-0.0033913348,
-0.0112597859,
0.0381367318,
0.0978158042,
0.048238311,
-0.0073753637,
-0.0231764056,
0.0315400101,
-0.0354112722,
0.0383689106,
-0.0352612101,
-0.0127125615,
-0.0180852525,
0.0299218111,
0.0003242559,
0.0120022241,
0.0441704877,
-0.0145311793,
-0.0214573815,
0.036478281,
0.065956898,
-0.024366742,
-0.0099487994,
-0.0174279697,
-0.0012738907,
-0.0055244812,
-0.0657540932,
0.0597421564,
-0.0261455514,
-0.0088936323,
-0.0240228847,
-0.0213492978,
-0.0082449522,
0.0102494229,
-0.0104605751,
-0.0268862117,
0.0104265297,
0.0241397098,
-0.0439896584,
-0.0471078418,
-0.0470562391,
-0.0313241482,
-0.0231483988,
-0.0161633696,
-0.055245854,
-0.0624335036,
-0.0065544299,
-0.010334719,
-0.0506774746,
-0.0391133651,
2.076777553e-34,
0.0151105812,
-0.0091615776,
0.0321799926,
-0.0401461571,
0.0245130081,
0.0202053878,
-0.0182116702,
0.0119919907,
0.0095831817,
-0.0540428124,
0.0042693303
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06583v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06583v1 | Mapping Transformer Leveraged Embeddings for Cross-Lingual Document Representation | 2024-01-12T14:01:15 | 2024-01-12T14:01:15 | Tsegaye Misikir Tashu, Eduard-Raul Kontos, Matthia Sabatelli, Matias Valdenegro-Toro | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG | Recommendation systems, for documents, have become tools to find relevant
content on the Web. However, these systems have limitations when it comes to
recommending documents in languages different from the query language, which
means they might overlook resources in non-native languages. This research
focuses on representing documents across languages by using Transformer
Leveraged Document Representations (TLDRs) that are mapped to a cross-lingual
domain. Four multilingual pre-trained transformer models (mBERT, mT5 XLM
RoBERTa, ErnieM) were evaluated using three mapping methods across 20 language
pairs representing combinations of five selected languages of the European
Union. Metrics like Mate Retrieval Rate and Reciprocal Rank were used to
measure the effectiveness of mapped TLDRs compared to non-mapped ones. The
results highlight the power of cross-lingual representations achieved through
pre-trained transformers and mapping approaches suggesting a promising
direction for expanding beyond language connections, between two specific
languages. | [
0.015155023,
-0.0180759095,
-0.0121954195,
0.0142292678,
0.0271703135,
0.017470615,
0.0139912711,
-0.0008222577,
0.0197896827,
-0.0414637066,
-0.1066170335,
-0.022630509,
-0.0355848372,
-0.0076999562,
-0.0029156411,
-0.0325973034,
0.0369440243,
-0.0025509305,
-0.0708056837,
-0.0152635723,
0.0130027104,
0.0315431245,
0.0639541149,
0.0314327069,
0.0049445401,
0.0115872668,
-0.0063016647,
-0.0384255946,
0.0276859403,
0.0177980009,
-0.0262047295,
-0.0073606349,
0.0233171266,
0.0514096282,
0.0000017214,
-0.0004262602,
-0.0159700979,
0.0062895357,
0.0566340201,
-0.0245971624,
0.0395241603,
-0.0194145013,
0.0223125331,
0.0147940638,
-0.0160419811,
-0.0360844731,
0.0312058702,
0.0559076779,
0.0117727583,
0.0486458018,
-0.0134189557,
-0.0200777389,
0.0449463651,
-0.0138068935,
0.0288036577,
-0.0218086783,
-0.0192109589,
0.0044804611,
0.0084142331,
0.0496537127,
-0.0187935401,
-0.0019021578,
-0.0010332925,
-0.0234408174,
0.0192460679,
0.0149281155,
-0.0120559093,
0.0010469104,
0.0075231842,
0.0492010601,
-0.0289308503,
-0.0078236144,
-0.043698784,
0.0200324692,
-0.0334917679,
0.0484110788,
-0.0312517062,
-0.0285904221,
0.0127939684,
0.0106801242,
0.0255050994,
0.0284870137,
0.0288606696,
-0.0113037508,
-0.05438108,
0.0551268682,
0.0293388106,
-0.012885429,
0.0405815318,
0.017188333,
0.0197801832,
-0.0143666854,
0.0500742197,
0.0084359217,
0.0153612234,
-0.0112681929,
0.005693974,
-0.0263467021,
0.0498176999,
-0.0415126272,
0.0161794238,
0.0402328148,
-0.024736831,
0.0577293374,
-0.0797003508,
0.0453268886,
-0.0424026102,
0.0332157314,
-0.0578416474,
-0.0606190301,
-0.0585682616,
-0.0065659354,
0.0004051784,
-0.0036707011,
-0.0120036379,
-0.0199708454,
-0.0367854238,
0.0446237884,
0.0088110184,
0.0050313994,
0.0249291025,
-0.0032453192,
-0.0083826333,
-0.0106223812,
-0.0290822424,
0.0529459752,
-0.0207713079,
-0.0327547565,
-0.0554697961,
-0.0063840598,
0.0440172628,
0.0286885556,
-0.0164473131,
-0.0616920479,
0.001659177,
0.0258286763,
0.0210732892,
-0.0271969493,
-0.0046959314,
0.0190247875,
0.0362496376,
-0.0444621854,
0.0321008265,
-0.0586159155,
0.0364673361,
0.0563312024,
0.0341459811,
0.0099191554,
-0.0203504469,
-0.014262734,
-0.0132240485,
0.061709512,
0.0493754894,
-0.0265771933,
0.0100851338,
-0.0074450504,
0.0017740683,
0.0413635299,
-0.0295976698,
0.0327878743,
0.0398684815,
-0.0025375648,
-0.0335034467,
0.0057751248,
-0.0204641428,
0.0078650704,
0.0262481533,
0.0386464782,
0.0168956704,
0.0057142465,
0.0542271025,
0.0047563226,
-0.0471678227,
-0.0112843318,
0.0159054045,
0.0269514788,
0.0848197043,
0.0471793786,
0.0434222631,
-0.0160306133,
-0.0344931856,
-0.0177021716,
0.0004221991,
0.0425620601,
0.0293274131,
-0.0335512981,
-0.0003612264,
0.0650618896,
-0.0675685257,
0.0099691283,
0.0266927183,
-0.0479316264,
0.0370542668,
-0.0027388013,
0.0482860766,
-0.0033912938,
0.0037483103,
0.051028654,
0.0047366042,
-0.0520746335,
0.0379296467,
0.0140151102,
-0.00325368,
0.0386028625,
0.019588653,
-0.0070185377,
0.0106414976,
-0.0353342369,
-0.0097501464,
-0.0139688738,
0.0709142014,
-0.0160389189,
0.0114959553,
-0.0433813855,
-0.060325671,
0.0007191051,
-0.016977502,
0.0645868629,
-0.0426412411,
0.0644648448,
0.0332212932,
-0.0817311183,
0.0173409358,
-0.0031876429,
-0.0539719202,
0.0210351478,
0.016164314,
0.0332642309,
-0.0244761426,
0.012599905,
-0.0004644587,
-0.006355864,
0.0246674009,
-0.032112062,
-0.0211568903,
0.0167861432,
-0.0108106807,
0.0311049931,
0.0331174769,
-0.094594866,
0.0284909215,
0.0441047139,
0.0164426044,
-0.017690517,
-0.0010466716,
-0.0047216373,
0.0602258146,
-0.0410487317,
0.0157889687,
-0.0353866629,
0.0264878441,
0.0013529416,
0.0134545118,
0.0020084286,
0.0630750209,
-0.0064709382,
-0.0446180068,
0.0419046767,
0.0186349209,
-0.0456368662,
0.045055043,
0.0303765666,
0.009226609,
0.0257054102,
-0.0006192717,
0.0091084978,
-0.0188402385,
-0.0839958191,
-0.0238315165,
-0.0260188989,
0.0337919481,
-0.0019886442,
0.0131991506,
0.0300705545,
-0.0163799413,
-0.0871363878,
-0.0081751319,
-0.0183540471,
0.0468071587,
0.003005519,
0.0051591625,
0.0464089513,
-0.0113774743,
-0.0187096614,
0.0056391493,
0.0421804264,
-0.0208190419,
0.025045028,
-0.0639286116,
-0.0144550726,
-0.0204167124,
-0.0158673748,
-0.0396206453,
0.0179850701,
-0.0260958448,
0.0121549154,
0.0550590865,
-0.0060842303,
-0.0163886417,
-0.0185196958,
0.0518563278,
0.002618874,
-0.0821434185,
-0.0189409479,
-0.0220638532,
0.0206743628,
-0.0415179133,
-0.0214662552,
0.0134389754,
-0.0189240538,
-0.0467085056,
-0.0143786129,
-0.0452177152,
-0.0199153535,
-0.0064442093,
-0.0028653631,
-0.0389694087,
-0.0057924399,
0.0339870006,
0.0535567962,
0.0259690359,
0.0003753967,
0.0486793816,
-0.0232877471,
0.0106954575,
-0.0527193733,
-0.0094533544,
-0.0749015361,
-0.0215372089,
0.0034040187,
0.0325681195,
-0.0707490966,
-0.0405230336,
-0.0149030806,
0.0253164209,
0.0379154012,
-0.0368045308,
0.0155345015,
0.0835391432,
-0.0448945053,
-0.0523602255,
-0.0297285188,
-0.0111308098,
-0.0392100215,
0.0210324191,
0.0260402951,
0.0492154546,
-0.0016788784,
-0.0819655955,
0.0238099154,
0.014155942,
0.0137941772,
-0.0145323649,
-0.0311550964,
0.015088046,
0.0383767709,
0.0398239233,
-0.0116776144,
0.0365981869,
-0.0040524364,
-0.0076476615,
0.0068969447,
-0.0394650102,
-0.0644387081,
-0.0376439393,
0.0076031708,
0.0620588474,
-0.0334795825,
-0.0424601696,
-0.0495726727,
-0.0094357263,
0.0108211832,
0.0140253091,
0.0582385696,
0.0327013023,
-0.1287743002,
-0.0399664119,
-0.0765709877,
-0.0034735515,
0.033231277,
0.0654081479,
-0.0868923366,
0.0320619419,
-0.0048772166,
-0.0238808431,
0.039798405,
0.0044607669,
0.0113391364,
-0.1006279215,
0.0278563704,
-0.0135311065,
0.0181856528,
-0.0245359093,
-0.0662102401,
-0.0225396995,
-0.0173065234,
0.0282826144,
-0.0449448265,
-0.0211714488,
-0.0171689913,
0.0068942928,
0.005421204,
-0.0172615554,
0.0009047858,
-0.0535238422,
-0.0432369523,
0.0089932801,
0.0422840379,
-0.0027384264,
-0.0578809194,
-0.0493106395,
-0.0133638382,
-0.0150352428,
0.0047211954,
0.0010269772,
-0.0378445126,
0.0022951623,
-0.0071301647,
-0.0432491787,
0.0034373952,
0.0061990703,
-0.0347700752,
0.0924208462,
-0.0298603456,
0.020498516,
-0.019895222,
-0.0074075651,
0.009408718,
0.0472929776,
-0.016863808,
-0.0185451172,
0.0052426569,
-0.0137340715,
0.035838712,
0.0232493095,
-0.0576013215,
0.0320428275,
-0.0240176339,
-0.0279672649,
-0.0402551405,
-0.0553501435,
0.0135589084,
-0.0036755963,
0.0273250006,
-0.0054005249,
-0.0384099185,
-0.0355938338,
0.0263046212,
0.0390185155,
0.0023185601,
0.0220986754,
-0.0438550301,
0.0366548523,
0.0409837589,
-0.0542006865,
0.0007862499,
-0.0603991635,
0.0088815186,
-0.0211841874,
-0.0400221236,
0.0132623995,
0.0060785217,
0.0323901437,
-0.0259857979,
-0.0708740503,
0.0657627583,
0.0284105502,
-0.0332625434,
-0.050950937,
0.0555884354,
0.006040215,
-0.0202836581,
0.0325383432,
-0.0751266554,
0.0055670189,
-0.0192718878,
0.0227331687,
0.0145414518,
-0.0221867524,
0.0246978477,
-0.0175826196,
0.0332020037,
-0.0247189682,
0.0651471168,
-0.0453688279,
0.0230845101,
-0.0347959958,
0.0018220377,
-0.0033988978,
-0.0124591971,
0.079877913,
-0.0433714166,
-0.0123321032,
0.0467802733,
-0.0093416339,
0.0162779801,
-0.0460323431,
0.0706691444,
0.0089285681,
0.0083040809,
-0.0159835201,
0.0756301507,
-0.026679093,
-0.0401130207,
0.0386562645,
0.0134295924,
-0.0445439778,
0.027050456,
0.0019834165,
-0.002750119,
-0.0245949607,
0.0491605178,
-0.0293478519,
-0.0373546556,
0.0017086148,
-0.0544987954,
0.0582463369,
-0.0544301495,
0.0494039543,
-0.0211888589,
-0.0188281797,
-0.0097263679,
-0.0060285404,
-0.0067485971,
0.0064587477,
0.0340232886,
-0.0022056508,
-0.000646445,
0.0266504548,
0.0737518519,
-0.0415449776,
-0.0242782645,
-0.0010994124,
-0.0453450754,
-0.0211927164,
0.0090912469,
0.0577045754,
0.0139981164,
-0.0596516617,
-0.0363676958,
-0.0032539358,
-0.0493536443,
0.0241939109,
-0.0213707872,
-0.0389594659,
-0.0056251888,
0.0195759907,
0.0677684546,
0.0064045205,
0.032444112,
-0.0516222231,
0.0189874396,
-0.0010490183,
-0.0142188603,
-0.0232736636,
-5.686507187e-33,
0.0170685053,
0.0377931297,
-0.0172700733,
0.0406562127,
-0.0007426353,
-0.0037888696,
0.0211998671,
0.0066295839,
-0.0153154628,
0.0170719661,
-0.0248645321,
-0.0181886833,
0.0212185178,
0.0017631219,
0.0123237194,
0.0106099043,
0.045882605,
0.0306362417,
-0.0020545302,
0.0263124164,
0.0700942799,
0.0485177822,
0.0854144916,
-0.063864015,
0.0333681554,
-0.0021200145,
-0.0014125047,
-0.0385607481,
0.0784939528,
0.0825884938,
-0.0279688947,
0.0447896048,
0.0110821454,
-0.0408585183,
-0.0095128156,
0.0185147766,
-0.0915921256,
-0.0028486766,
0.0214674324,
0.0633262917,
0.0258526281,
-0.033133015,
-0.0048634233,
-0.0231753271,
0.0187433623,
-0.0017903508,
0.0459536314,
0.0167876501,
-0.0458655283,
-0.0534999259,
-0.0363119543,
0.0014110906,
0.0045029507,
0.0248591937,
0.0695477575,
0.0929618254,
0.0058372854,
0.0861872137,
-0.0881591961,
0.0200420972,
-0.0726375952,
0.0147882588,
0.0501503572,
-0.0545833148,
-0.0361754373,
0.0465731099,
0.001291216,
-0.027756447,
0.0409547649,
-0.0100661637,
0.0454191901,
-0.0045316219,
0.0257782172,
0.0588130429,
0.0220926274,
-0.0271939375,
-0.041959431,
0.0548888706,
-0.0041319798,
0.0179838669,
0.0291560292,
0.0301039796,
0.0104332706,
-0.0061938739,
-0.0255190507,
-0.0252114106,
-0.0290609654,
-0.0743515268,
0.0044401628,
0.0028664924,
0.0219715964,
0.0103645399,
0.0664115548,
-0.0548946746,
-0.0242783949,
0.039834857,
-0.029060645,
0.0001622424,
0.0104953973,
0.0129108634,
-0.0159299057,
-0.0396073647,
-0.0068548704,
-0.0593808852,
-0.0206456613,
-0.0066143111,
0.0630822033,
0.0116200717,
-0.06145427,
0.0006613335,
-0.0125401821,
-0.0478228368,
-0.0238764677,
0.0389332287,
0.0176760182,
0.0018700339,
-0.0209715925,
0.0483751073,
0.0405156948,
0.0352431796,
-0.0205859467,
-0.0458314493,
0.0327482969,
0.0378556587,
-0.0080291955,
-0.0211876612,
-0.0523282327,
0.0342656225,
0.0635695085,
-0.064218536,
-0.0106341727,
0.0216472037,
2.559e-7,
0.0609792992,
0.0107102003,
-0.0075865947,
-0.0438220277,
0.0090166554,
0.0127293086,
-0.003102252,
0.0743209422,
0.0410353318,
0.0493723787,
0.0078438036,
-0.0262624733,
0.0147822844,
0.0486190654,
-0.0689572692,
0.0100651262,
-0.0634926409,
-0.0366959497,
-0.0285928287,
-0.0174827557,
-0.0130028091,
0.1060917526,
-0.0152320797,
0.008909869,
-0.0297453273,
-0.0151767852,
0.1037342846,
-0.0782128647,
-0.0390355773,
-0.020844873,
0.0337451808,
0.0149834575,
0.0017472737,
-0.0277344044,
-0.0123016015,
0.0550100766,
0.0568821877,
-0.0145056639,
-0.000925,
-0.0414227955,
-0.0077729952,
-0.029133128,
-0.0045537697,
-0.0648367256,
0.0537412502,
-0.0459955558,
-0.0159033462,
0.0158291757,
-0.058319211,
0.0333542675,
0.092999585,
-0.0437598713,
-0.0283438228,
0.051093962,
0.0408383943,
0.0116390111,
0.0141236829,
-0.0438203961,
0.0122632813,
-0.0092194397,
-0.0240064822,
0.0047227065,
-0.0305735618,
-0.0031154426,
0.0381749496,
0.0150022013,
0.0223227423,
1.934505313e-34,
0.0255357046,
0.0141664697,
-0.0047531351,
-0.0230862685,
0.0274991132,
-0.0220798198,
0.0162783656,
0.0203674231,
0.02451244,
-0.0776415244,
-0.0311618689
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06832v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06832v1 | XLS-R Deep Learning Model for Multilingual ASR on Low- Resource Languages: Indonesian, Javanese, and Sundanese | 2024-01-12T13:44:48 | 2024-01-12T13:44:48 | Panji Arisaputra, Alif Tri Handoyo, Amalia Zahra | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | This research paper focuses on the development and evaluation of Automatic
Speech Recognition (ASR) technology using the XLS-R 300m model. The study aims
to improve ASR performance in converting spoken language into written text,
specifically for Indonesian, Javanese, and Sundanese languages. The paper
discusses the testing procedures, datasets used, and methodology employed in
training and evaluating the ASR systems. The results show that the XLS-R 300m
model achieves competitive Word Error Rate (WER) measurements, with a slight
compromise in performance for Javanese and Sundanese languages. The integration
of a 5-gram KenLM language model significantly reduces WER and enhances ASR
accuracy. The research contributes to the advancement of ASR technology by
addressing linguistic diversity and improving performance across various
languages. The findings provide insights into optimizing ASR accuracy and
applicability for diverse linguistic contexts. | [
0.0119943144,
0.0097886119,
0.0290903617,
0.0393432565,
-0.0155639378,
0.0064850552,
0.0259468146,
-0.0146432053,
-0.0138602545,
-0.0205785707,
-0.0545614995,
-0.0678650588,
0.0824376419,
0.0204182994,
0.0120749092,
-0.044394318,
0.0330850631,
-0.0715811402,
0.0249241851,
-0.0056906794,
-0.0021696417,
0.0133071067,
-0.0203111563,
0.0396116637,
-0.0373105966,
0.0176958349,
-0.0251097847,
-0.0059993374,
0.008094633,
-0.0265329946,
-0.0067353887,
0.0075318613,
0.0076139597,
0.0666672885,
0.0000021111,
-0.0471876115,
0.0030921756,
-0.003364821,
-0.0720219389,
0.0140593881,
0.0211542752,
-0.0168814939,
-0.0310867596,
0.0390436091,
0.0209693443,
-0.0215201844,
0.0670308769,
0.0633820146,
-0.0158973634,
0.0473407842,
0.0013194379,
-0.051342696,
0.041294232,
-0.0095189493,
-0.0415557325,
-0.0225840304,
0.0109724384,
-0.0055753221,
-0.0120408144,
-0.0228123125,
-0.0113413231,
0.0402079672,
0.0109809199,
-0.0038176798,
0.0030478514,
-0.0863107368,
-0.04144945,
-0.0599751696,
0.0133341393,
0.0176562518,
-0.0164311957,
-0.0370177999,
-0.0230669472,
-0.0080640884,
-0.0441589803,
-0.0073738573,
0.0133477347,
-0.0021729865,
-0.0221789647,
-0.0075709028,
0.0410904288,
0.0153069403,
0.038717635,
0.006423315,
0.0085597131,
0.0187433902,
0.0012738981,
-0.0307412203,
0.0081248023,
-0.0455092266,
0.0211482942,
0.0108440015,
0.0639564022,
-0.0050257738,
-0.0061423313,
0.0248794109,
0.000224653,
-0.0475614704,
0.0525943749,
-0.0825742334,
0.0264246855,
-0.004461288,
-0.0234655663,
-0.0232840404,
-0.0257831272,
0.0765697435,
0.0199447479,
-0.0101186028,
0.0016641915,
-0.0062520611,
0.0130695421,
-0.0135066751,
-0.0188561734,
0.0333674587,
-0.0278267879,
-0.0299223103,
-0.0685540289,
0.0012157203,
0.017815249,
-0.0213525742,
0.0805644318,
-0.0105696004,
-0.0833294839,
-0.0274150707,
0.0031077657,
0.0428176783,
0.0280919969,
0.0332722813,
0.0137598552,
-0.0893196017,
0.0552676022,
0.0123774447,
0.0080942838,
0.0023370949,
0.0019538698,
0.0350283012,
0.0082667442,
-0.0247922707,
-0.0908571407,
0.0295357797,
-0.0422426686,
-0.0315729864,
-0.0076534683,
-0.0670468435,
0.0460120551,
0.0307085942,
0.008357266,
-0.021017598,
0.0229041371,
-0.0227251779,
0.0670723394,
0.0415023491,
-0.0132744256,
0.0123326788,
0.0761945173,
-0.0227405541,
0.0700205192,
0.0634745136,
0.0427247547,
-0.0124531817,
0.0105810761,
-0.0579614528,
-0.0516355783,
0.0525155105,
-0.0593611822,
-0.0138134416,
0.0014017252,
-0.0449209921,
-0.0059048645,
0.0292268973,
0.0113710379,
0.0621444695,
0.0194961224,
0.0502938591,
0.0083095469,
0.0417562872,
0.0602202415,
0.0703040436,
0.0300785061,
0.0102289002,
-0.0005729444,
-0.0350075476,
0.0571708418,
-0.0118178353,
0.0185870714,
0.0370945185,
0.0306251738,
0.0392781645,
-0.0115281269,
-0.0256877895,
-0.0199357904,
-0.0407324359,
-0.0331330225,
0.0091660619,
0.0661289841,
-0.0223215334,
-0.0589957833,
0.0059626787,
0.0248121768,
-0.0080165388,
0.0382000022,
-0.0624176078,
-0.0089627812,
0.0342093334,
0.0099959821,
-0.0140371872,
0.0302481931,
-0.0281299595,
-0.0413751975,
0.0604355522,
0.0337242112,
0.0064699226,
0.0220218431,
-0.0718497857,
0.0033985882,
0.0537195727,
-0.0042457422,
0.1014446393,
-0.0241394639,
0.0556892976,
0.0199704859,
-0.0020228613,
-0.0320893861,
0.0068151359,
-0.0440960303,
-0.0152833695,
0.0108641498,
0.0251162369,
0.0692851469,
0.0491772741,
0.0106875245,
-0.014357144,
0.0047995457,
-0.0220943987,
0.0196947772,
0.0158236492,
-0.0474792831,
0.00218291,
0.0382228158,
-0.0036481482,
0.0272032544,
0.0625295267,
0.0564703755,
-0.081484139,
0.0041461098,
-0.0073984144,
0.0138832573,
-0.0650841892,
0.0478938036,
0.0106756529,
-0.0012858462,
-0.0030914645,
0.0015029771,
0.0207680985,
0.0125076314,
0.0022098825,
-0.0363137722,
0.0533820875,
-0.0798280016,
-0.0412781276,
0.0130487112,
-0.0323092528,
0.0338790715,
0.0081639187,
-0.0140884863,
-0.0054517756,
0.0076763453,
-0.0535346456,
-0.0302533153,
-0.0038821683,
0.0066542872,
-0.0487315357,
0.0315200686,
0.0067098732,
-0.0082453499,
0.0069120768,
-0.0111067984,
0.0392653793,
-0.0202959236,
-0.026592264,
-0.0020227795,
-0.0114450101,
-0.0437854789,
-0.0279204771,
0.0284781381,
0.0120402891,
0.0337537527,
-0.0821353868,
-0.0510700271,
0.0277387686,
0.0001672304,
0.0141122565,
0.0145465173,
-0.0423476771,
-0.0069537382,
-0.0111831846,
-0.0221451633,
0.034066733,
-0.0128709152,
-0.0223279092,
-0.022895949,
0.0077656801,
-0.0411334597,
-0.02803763,
0.0160683878,
0.0321203507,
0.0082425075,
0.0011105328,
-0.0365688838,
0.0484462231,
0.0330117345,
0.0290028043,
-0.0292375404,
-0.0526555628,
-0.0310160201,
-0.0331403539,
0.0024777153,
0.0087693017,
-0.0322800875,
0.0251950733,
-0.0006018198,
0.0056341658,
0.0248553734,
-0.058145795,
-0.0272194315,
-0.0520776473,
0.0120858969,
-0.0266328249,
-0.0253397878,
-0.0249733608,
-0.0032662388,
-0.0656849295,
-0.0534365699,
0.0259151459,
0.0290447958,
-0.0066897999,
-0.0500760674,
0.0402139202,
-0.0199216567,
0.0182442889,
-0.0380997397,
0.0043781111,
-0.0184505023,
0.0208279509,
-0.0279722959,
0.0482370257,
0.0292744674,
0.0104100276,
0.0075029712,
0.0723393336,
0.0022949949,
0.0283954479,
-0.001268159,
0.0472227335,
-0.041488599,
0.0524115711,
0.0184267424,
-0.0460456833,
0.0047881519,
-0.0016900705,
0.0582461655,
-0.0546270534,
0.0062583787,
0.0310725328,
-0.0453050323,
-0.0274846517,
0.0122300442,
0.0143444249,
0.010073117,
-0.0091026314,
0.048569683,
-0.0266995039,
0.013346618,
0.0548024997,
-0.0064474251,
-0.0225640833,
-0.0428045206,
-0.0332777761,
0.0214741435,
-0.0123504391,
-0.00997495,
-0.0268600527,
0.0001156429,
0.0450094156,
-0.0004149014,
0.0085867047,
0.0254365467,
0.0129864207,
-0.1237553805,
0.0037008307,
0.012483974,
-0.0473301969,
-0.0470012464,
-0.0679472759,
-0.033931572,
-0.0055106641,
0.09449476,
0.0210835617,
-0.0230676215,
-0.0527198613,
0.0935976282,
-0.0845624506,
-0.0958744362,
0.0039156624,
-0.034562178,
0.0556105599,
0.0452431887,
-0.0083719827,
-0.0553998128,
0.003107507,
0.0107570356,
-0.0068632737,
0.0134650245,
-0.0109101804,
-0.0277492367,
0.013539698,
-0.0243761837,
-0.0084733982,
0.0141598564,
-0.0319365412,
0.0461659357,
0.0084386319,
0.0467299744,
-0.0256190877,
-0.0160240233,
0.0381404385,
-0.0285456348,
0.0107378364,
0.0160197988,
0.0246529952,
-0.0459466092,
-0.0116977552,
0.0032996791,
0.0436984003,
-0.0600817576,
0.0073213461,
0.0088447649,
-0.0485628247,
-0.0340454392,
-0.0399678238,
-0.051291991,
0.0249201618,
-0.0188963022,
0.0453612953,
0.0354109444,
-0.010650117,
0.0352020152,
-0.0325647071,
-0.0239850041,
-0.0086053144,
0.0464668162,
-0.080031693,
0.0311136581,
0.015822323,
-0.0194215551,
-0.0040615709,
-0.0142747667,
-0.035416875,
-0.032421492,
0.0622024313,
-0.0082823727,
0.0194406901,
-0.0209996272,
-0.0095825102,
-0.0568009764,
0.0125415353,
0.0298595876,
-0.0053911936,
-0.0046724319,
0.0271075703,
-0.0145203182,
-0.040662095,
0.0144184912,
-0.0053681489,
0.0049190712,
-0.04399544,
0.0114717372,
-0.0239378437,
-0.0910190344,
-0.0010192482,
0.0380005911,
0.0145720113,
-0.036199674,
-0.0301902313,
-0.0382926576,
0.0069824848,
0.0348320305,
0.069467403,
-0.0162884668,
-0.0117303627,
0.0378933102,
0.0355082303,
-0.0019100843,
0.0247722249,
0.005156707,
-0.041286204,
0.0161602739,
0.0923097283,
0.0458330438,
0.0896471441,
0.0249924473,
0.0219758246,
-0.0594162978,
0.0336940512,
-0.000182043,
-0.0085348915,
-0.010112186,
0.05077843,
-0.0367209613,
0.0134554366,
0.0237101484,
0.0142323682,
0.0533880815,
-0.0087427553,
-0.0273365527,
0.0271784253,
0.0423322953,
-0.0206720605,
0.0305637978,
-0.0135249645,
0.0098469183,
-0.0846580639,
0.0198123679,
-0.0424347669,
0.0554860719,
0.0389889739,
0.0076908204,
-0.0056211324,
0.0646956488,
0.0490298346,
0.0267195646,
0.0221244171,
-0.0065353285,
0.0444781035,
-0.0229734126,
-0.0164537076,
0.0027781257,
0.0097916201,
-0.0521462932,
-0.057701312,
0.0173265636,
-0.1022728682,
0.0157376714,
0.0259016361,
0.0118248938,
-0.0116539933,
-0.0240876079,
0.03398728,
-0.0000112787,
0.0483259112,
-0.0067349342,
-0.0015581278,
-0.0093003307,
0.0275484957,
0.0100258393,
-6.058658045e-33,
-0.0161172096,
0.0593648739,
-0.0135639766,
0.0138551015,
-0.0201031826,
-0.0030242507,
-0.0094593642,
0.0254084952,
-0.0360380895,
-0.0206839945,
-0.0360466354,
-0.0297062285,
0.0464306138,
0.0203502607,
0.0273407102,
-0.0025901769,
0.0322892144,
-0.0208470952,
0.0484767072,
-0.0231422,
0.0265445076,
0.0386620238,
0.0355563015,
-0.0435567461,
-0.0082900198,
-0.0214012396,
0.0149883768,
-0.0337607451,
0.003103822,
0.0596674457,
-0.0303575546,
0.0507908203,
0.0174736455,
-0.0370767079,
-0.0012853163,
0.0241220295,
-0.0819996223,
0.0264739916,
0.0175392013,
0.0841247961,
-0.0039830813,
-0.0146565968,
0.0496940501,
0.0074827182,
-0.0491699837,
-0.0115614682,
0.0061322739,
-0.0399424657,
-0.0734104514,
-0.0260739923,
-0.0089090895,
0.033852011,
0.0213332903,
-0.0126227345,
0.091965571,
0.0411381237,
-0.0590252355,
-0.051697772,
-0.0778076425,
0.0197673626,
-0.0003333786,
0.0554544218,
0.0212894715,
0.0638362467,
-0.0491258726,
-0.0212005749,
0.0340673961,
-0.0520930998,
0.0464034714,
-0.0088950517,
0.0739723518,
0.0253481399,
0.0110713514,
0.0499500334,
0.0388879105,
-0.0403440185,
-0.0396678299,
-0.0335516296,
0.014207378,
0.0015998927,
0.0412694365,
-0.0117663406,
-0.0640704781,
-0.021336779,
-0.0194352716,
-0.049266737,
-0.0431031473,
-0.0270285849,
0.0654925257,
-0.0141128106,
0.0072831861,
0.0347963572,
0.0523961075,
-0.0202813577,
0.0104705449,
0.0059354273,
0.0253368933,
0.025502095,
-0.0454853214,
0.0121029383,
-0.0918384269,
-0.036513932,
-0.033012379,
0.0550212748,
-0.0022249194,
-0.0324170068,
0.0004952354,
0.010537181,
-0.0385381579,
0.0045437897,
0.0076037017,
-0.0060718223,
0.0110625746,
0.0532681234,
0.0129036382,
-0.0533631369,
0.0225658007,
0.0615374111,
-0.01863987,
0.0212006159,
0.0047318498,
0.0018662993,
0.012887706,
0.0124039147,
-0.0349096321,
-0.0001715659,
-0.0317568295,
-0.0184718315,
0.0127370078,
0.0078836204,
0.0285736937,
-0.0172670446,
2.84e-7,
-0.0406347997,
0.0088011073,
0.0902579054,
-0.0363458656,
-0.0214551762,
0.0040355739,
0.0171018057,
-0.0295467582,
0.0207252931,
0.0334324725,
0.0092510469,
-0.0095676156,
0.086418204,
-0.0054051592,
-0.0864286497,
-0.0234587304,
-0.050557375,
0.0570823625,
-0.0299942028,
0.0027954073,
-0.0367879011,
0.0772371888,
-0.0280022677,
-0.0669180229,
-0.0421500541,
-0.0025604849,
0.0439236797,
0.0200793594,
-0.0076151523,
0.021391321,
0.0329158604,
0.0074140104,
0.0071315304,
0.0159711167,
-0.0357371196,
0.0295895524,
0.0135735776,
0.0501222685,
-0.0399373509,
-0.0245473515,
0.0516670682,
0.0594839342,
-0.0573948249,
-0.0433267988,
0.0601548925,
0.0249686074,
-0.0053880224,
-0.0020741858,
0.0048042149,
0.0133577483,
-0.0221502651,
-0.0358912796,
0.0221035257,
-0.0223421473,
0.0409838445,
-0.0571744666,
-0.0687342063,
0.0101398202,
-0.0010622591,
0.0082394853,
-0.0459985398,
0.019721726,
-0.0414117947,
0.0022931967,
0.0330639333,
0.0176924244,
0.0144711304,
1.99099149e-34,
0.042426724,
0.0019997219,
0.0042008813,
-0.0193447229,
0.006079996,
-0.0606550574,
-0.0011965131,
0.0484664254,
-0.0316277221,
-0.0544223413,
-0.024267748
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06568v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06568v2 | Lost in the Source Language: How Large Language Models Evaluate the Quality of Machine Translation | 2024-01-12T13:23:21 | 2024-06-06T07:51:16 | Xu Huang, Zhirui Zhang, Xiang Geng, Yichao Du, Jiajun Chen, Shujian Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This study investigates how Large Language Models (LLMs) leverage source and
reference data in machine translation evaluation task, aiming to better
understand the mechanisms behind their remarkable performance in this task. We
design the controlled experiments across various input modes and model types,
and employ both coarse-grained and fine-grained prompts to discern the utility
of source versus reference information. We find that reference information
significantly enhances the evaluation accuracy, while surprisingly, source
information sometimes is counterproductive, indicating LLMs' inability to fully
leverage the cross-lingual capability when evaluating translations. Further
analysis of the fine-grained evaluation and fine-tuning experiments show
similar results. These findings also suggest a potential research direction for
LLMs that fully exploits the cross-lingual capability of LLMs to achieve better
performance in machine translation evaluation tasks. | [
0.0459999032,
0.0222454369,
-0.0093655074,
0.0574096926,
-0.0535098426,
0.0228652507,
0.0447551385,
0.0012843456,
-0.0477480926,
-0.0497967675,
-0.0854151249,
-0.0339864567,
0.0434258878,
-0.0271054935,
0.0467444621,
-0.0293980762,
0.0353269428,
-0.0290028621,
-0.0136320237,
0.0241766069,
-0.0061271228,
0.0076953247,
0.0353214368,
0.0294508487,
0.0212766994,
0.0089701209,
0.0580280758,
0.0438576676,
0.0175942667,
-0.021024745,
-0.0410851389,
0.0273652114,
0.0020747851,
0.0661799833,
0.0000018322,
-0.0587137081,
-0.0032697939,
0.0277308021,
-0.0117129302,
0.0679464191,
0.0582333803,
-0.0367491506,
-0.0148778316,
0.0000849625,
0.0045422143,
-0.0256120134,
0.0514754169,
0.0159031469,
0.0617018789,
0.0579381995,
-0.0027484128,
-0.0102656856,
-0.0194579307,
-0.0437061116,
0.0134809269,
-0.0458773971,
-0.0003584987,
0.0460245535,
-0.0104486253,
0.0394297168,
0.013929232,
0.0584424511,
-0.0106735369,
-0.0094984015,
-0.0126620419,
-0.0128142349,
-0.0485640801,
-0.0295241289,
0.0229056552,
0.0562472492,
-0.0214347281,
-0.0029555331,
-0.0408433154,
-0.0294350702,
0.0026462832,
0.0073520057,
-0.0370332971,
0.0116148321,
-0.0082824938,
-0.0032216611,
0.0113514056,
0.0448582955,
0.0320443437,
0.0202282034,
-0.0529296435,
0.0134664541,
0.0248317253,
-0.0279369764,
0.0022091928,
0.0366934836,
0.0041383323,
-0.0326825865,
0.0290357415,
-0.0179586094,
-0.0361142866,
0.0207039546,
-0.0001647638,
-0.0190779418,
0.0314055011,
-0.0464273319,
0.0375491939,
0.0432788655,
-0.0389679,
0.0602779984,
-0.0273758527,
0.0837535784,
-0.0451398231,
0.0244394038,
-0.0900381505,
-0.0124451574,
-0.0207979847,
0.04634225,
-0.0128701134,
-0.0192241613,
-0.0241465215,
-0.0182974488,
-0.0263214149,
0.0092871627,
0.0178453829,
0.0129583376,
0.0073369141,
-0.0507136919,
-0.0314550065,
-0.0127276191,
-0.0311672948,
0.0690131038,
-0.0201977305,
0.001164681,
-0.0081034908,
-0.0552049093,
-0.0121676326,
0.0108370585,
-0.0296794754,
-0.054111179,
0.0077650482,
0.0856880993,
0.011097339,
-0.0198821872,
0.0016810966,
0.0028849309,
-0.025872834,
-0.0804504976,
-0.006030221,
-0.0463125594,
0.0404407233,
0.044749897,
0.0249113776,
-0.0291924234,
0.0053862291,
-0.0085824151,
-0.0491524041,
0.0515838191,
0.0163589641,
0.0340100415,
0.0259240344,
-0.0065079317,
-0.0088421451,
0.0675876141,
0.0441203043,
0.0277427565,
0.0203556847,
-0.0141701894,
0.0037951549,
0.065911144,
-0.006521055,
0.0541077256,
-0.0278666131,
0.0200776607,
-0.0019409381,
0.0525986552,
0.0240917411,
0.0779319331,
-0.0262645464,
0.0596753918,
0.0685721487,
0.0120911542,
0.0229706913,
0.030067835,
0.0687381402,
0.0070112776,
0.0088616256,
0.0177150704,
-0.0253067669,
0.0158830397,
0.007776435,
0.0199286006,
0.0789580196,
0.0378198363,
-0.007666904,
-0.0378190167,
-0.0215664022,
0.0118028093,
-0.0087142596,
0.0099011632,
0.0375264212,
0.0261115711,
-0.0479881875,
0.0338913873,
0.0042484663,
-0.0416008793,
0.0159028061,
-0.0421962403,
-0.0075121848,
0.0778786466,
0.0612443909,
0.0232745353,
-0.009014423,
-0.0190481897,
0.0140381036,
0.0399161763,
0.0843268856,
0.0200863313,
0.005151506,
-0.0386610292,
-0.0379736163,
-0.0058581238,
0.0182119813,
0.0210272279,
0.0009578351,
0.0086627863,
0.0411087684,
-0.054517746,
-0.1125932932,
0.0274673309,
-0.0053514475,
-0.0441840589,
0.0019074917,
-0.0002398261,
0.0146993911,
0.0114676813,
-0.035641592,
0.0354287811,
-0.011086951,
-0.025655007,
0.0127735268,
0.0148700206,
-0.016950503,
0.0202038381,
0.0050445725,
-0.0222769268,
-0.0081745693,
-0.0365668871,
-0.0261101015,
-0.0365678929,
-0.0282862298,
-0.0556372032,
-0.008706267,
-0.0241701268,
0.0341774262,
-0.0370653421,
-0.0011232893,
-0.0705599636,
0.0096155703,
0.0216485374,
0.0274940357,
0.0506539978,
-0.007997063,
0.0384623855,
-0.0128238834,
-0.0236739963,
0.034298081,
0.0163143612,
0.0230212063,
0.0401980169,
0.015759239,
-0.0393203683,
-0.0564551316,
-0.0562736802,
0.0155295217,
-0.014830118,
0.0325997509,
0.0342107043,
0.0037402695,
-0.0018157557,
0.0261949841,
-0.0026364031,
-0.0295806043,
0.0222588405,
0.0486394651,
0.0013243656,
0.0168725662,
0.0093364073,
-0.0463551134,
-0.0026671076,
0.0354687683,
0.0741590858,
0.0364652239,
-0.0026669668,
-0.079146035,
0.0489553325,
-0.0558696501,
-0.0609299839,
0.0185048319,
-0.0543155707,
0.0142517276,
-0.0052560512,
0.0369289368,
0.0409241319,
-0.0237502195,
-0.0185945034,
0.0697747841,
-0.0087088943,
-0.0664521903,
-0.0337339193,
0.0106923953,
-0.0746188164,
-0.0240068957,
-0.0652562752,
-0.0064122751,
0.0156245958,
0.0154046752,
0.0197155401,
-0.0325967371,
0.0389113538,
-0.048622556,
-0.0366253331,
-0.0268613026,
-0.003436496,
0.0023130011,
0.0536495857,
-0.0164511055,
-0.0598808415,
0.0749068707,
-0.0560461693,
-0.0129045397,
-0.018602334,
0.0139244441,
-0.0349589773,
0.0354607292,
-0.0418053865,
0.0059975907,
-0.0229182523,
-0.0020634024,
-0.0319701135,
0.0091068968,
0.0281215254,
-0.0405880995,
0.0424626097,
-0.0528798364,
-0.0177278854,
-0.0148527026,
-0.0004612678,
-0.0226477813,
-0.0278007723,
-0.029565189,
0.0019551781,
0.0275742821,
0.0024635347,
-0.0302429013,
0.0183694512,
0.0712225512,
0.0117769176,
-0.020448938,
-0.0054463604,
-0.0109183593,
0.0070401039,
-0.0093788262,
-0.0029026459,
0.0415918306,
-0.0482079051,
0.0077333366,
-0.0236195382,
-0.0030487941,
0.0075880103,
-0.0325260945,
-0.0448102877,
0.0267341323,
0.0130586121,
-0.0561857931,
-0.0066708992,
0.0673385113,
-0.0638726205,
-0.0134881586,
0.1132750884,
0.0167134739,
-0.0504720323,
-0.026582526,
-0.0332116038,
0.0126643917,
0.0216298327,
0.034140192,
-0.0608528368,
-0.0128887668,
0.0103230299,
0.0158032384,
0.013148752,
0.032298699,
-0.0107338727,
-0.1083157286,
0.0337950699,
0.0546365492,
-0.066203475,
-0.054164838,
-0.0351700447,
-0.0178715494,
-0.0281315129,
0.0438893586,
-0.0055026794,
-0.0065464973,
0.0013654364,
-0.0034586815,
0.0199990477,
-0.0669249445,
0.0115262056,
-0.0573831908,
0.0435012095,
0.0897363126,
0.033098083,
-0.0012864722,
-0.0284614116,
0.0498447679,
-0.049233824,
0.0152190682,
-0.0133573245,
0.0323093124,
0.0249601398,
-0.0111924596,
0.017461542,
-0.0505542755,
0.0160233863,
0.036652118,
0.0030161447,
0.0527747162,
-0.015177737,
0.0078851422,
0.0153940246,
-0.0122334249,
0.0166420434,
0.0655316114,
0.0471695065,
-0.0404938646,
0.0055209277,
-0.0134932641,
-0.0276242718,
-0.0292292908,
-0.0380658358,
0.0148704173,
-0.0600780621,
-0.023928348,
-0.0747759044,
-0.0424301811,
0.0001146595,
-0.0033034075,
0.0281327795,
0.0278895888,
-0.0151328612,
0.005521121,
0.0285314526,
0.0581937395,
-0.0525429137,
0.0401297212,
-0.0475573279,
0.0082247183,
0.0212610736,
-0.0273226239,
0.003793485,
0.0488981977,
-0.0464615338,
-0.0634412393,
-0.0362686068,
0.0468084142,
0.0241523851,
0.0012523374,
-0.0138331633,
-0.0469044559,
-0.0100040613,
-0.0113231186,
-0.0313528329,
0.0194713101,
0.0169004295,
0.0046804552,
-0.0191367641,
0.0379494578,
-0.0239172764,
0.002336198,
0.0238740854,
0.0395925082,
0.0050528995,
-0.0641170889,
0.0077030952,
0.0388499796,
0.0280782655,
-0.0413765758,
-0.0231111962,
-0.0096634999,
0.0031204748,
-0.0071887826,
-0.0227447581,
-0.0412327312,
-0.0350658372,
0.0594605207,
-0.0072509558,
0.0011859331,
0.0175251476,
-0.0266356654,
0.0095461756,
-0.0299223904,
0.00196653,
-0.0220694579,
0.0307848006,
0.0181135032,
0.0138823036,
-0.0408930629,
0.0424997248,
-0.0302576479,
0.0024233612,
-0.0314603485,
0.0642861947,
-0.0060089724,
0.0074010873,
0.0165546816,
0.0384292416,
-0.0496718772,
-0.0245330818,
-0.0077763479,
0.0081060259,
0.0796402842,
-0.0139382891,
0.1373960823,
-0.0090995384,
-0.0124552976,
-0.0279820692,
0.0403314233,
0.0052932189,
-0.0098335342,
0.0059108417,
-0.0083094677,
-0.0097788498,
0.0217941031,
0.0600798279,
0.0166465063,
0.0086832643,
-0.023699794,
-0.0219217166,
-0.0018170851,
-0.028005708,
-0.0282719359,
-0.052935157,
-0.024257848,
-0.0105051063,
-0.0636703521,
-0.0422733985,
-0.0029909373,
0.0295275152,
-0.0060960525,
-0.0367109515,
-0.0145500647,
0.0891119391,
-0.0326732919,
0.0245288182,
-0.0504111052,
-0.0063799862,
0.0082585216,
-0.0047094752,
-0.0541547611,
-5.955214542e-33,
-0.0314049534,
-0.025445221,
0.0150695341,
-0.0486974865,
-0.0380831286,
0.00780062,
-0.0462438576,
0.0141175585,
-0.0176062863,
0.0065957494,
-0.0115416395,
-0.0138592217,
0.0237355661,
-0.0453398637,
0.0208711382,
-0.0231083632,
0.0613834113,
0.0304096844,
-0.054279983,
0.0137839224,
0.0231264289,
-0.012128016,
0.0658580437,
-0.0768552125,
0.0808273628,
-0.0254895594,
-0.0242856592,
-0.0233596526,
-0.0087321494,
0.0565374345,
0.0058898395,
0.0051696096,
0.0264448263,
-0.0418924913,
-0.039504759,
-0.0088610705,
-0.0533717722,
0.0229813401,
0.0696851686,
0.0136222728,
0.0170903001,
-0.0496647097,
0.0447884686,
-0.0397789702,
-0.0314691514,
-0.0011466714,
0.004390731,
-0.0738239139,
-0.0416068397,
-0.0058146226,
-0.0609047562,
0.025877893,
0.0004967393,
-0.0114779975,
0.0387820974,
0.0503076091,
-0.0388310775,
-0.0042077969,
-0.0240689125,
0.0284454841,
0.0159504432,
0.0418107547,
0.0814651474,
0.0093572456,
-0.0348954871,
-0.0063013337,
0.0034612855,
-0.0024604024,
0.016214896,
-0.0594605319,
0.0343100578,
0.0058824401,
0.0739027411,
0.0695879832,
-0.0015042911,
-0.0196375828,
-0.0473499894,
0.0296976566,
-0.0257868692,
0.0173677634,
0.0300400052,
0.0093790917,
-0.0064312671,
-0.0081083458,
-0.0897010639,
-0.0187215153,
-0.0536449775,
-0.0267021582,
0.0296189338,
0.0112221679,
-0.0105439043,
0.0003768058,
0.0939231142,
-0.016912831,
0.0054433849,
0.0291441269,
-0.0329870917,
0.0258255955,
-0.0219224487,
0.0040662205,
-0.0400625132,
-0.0221087616,
0.0156101715,
0.0251298379,
0.0106329517,
-0.0187009629,
0.0450361073,
0.0030888561,
-0.0396986231,
0.0143496292,
-0.0488121361,
-0.0120840967,
-0.0358264148,
-0.0318081118,
0.0209691599,
-0.0078264773,
-0.0223820601,
0.0342774205,
0.0088080941,
-0.0067362972,
-0.0096880617,
0.016073443,
0.0240264609,
0.0360568799,
-0.0730634481,
0.0267165788,
-0.0338956416,
0.0162044987,
0.046067033,
-0.0067673787,
-0.0333217643,
-0.0008673159,
2.516e-7,
0.0557639524,
0.0701367334,
-0.0343735516,
0.037832696,
-0.002551527,
0.0061355927,
-0.0464511327,
-0.0050861193,
0.0462095663,
0.0197292287,
0.0347112827,
0.0130656688,
0.0930514857,
0.0171665959,
-0.0457427278,
-0.0519491695,
-0.0379252806,
0.0425507352,
-0.0508586392,
0.00447695,
0.0034576636,
0.0799882561,
-0.0225951932,
0.0177666191,
-0.0277700014,
-0.0799720436,
0.0854126737,
-0.0582175627,
-0.0329902731,
0.0267380029,
0.038279932,
0.0374956578,
-0.016580876,
-0.0037995819,
-0.0081360098,
0.0004728361,
0.0572628677,
0.0889093578,
0.0326033495,
0.0128302583,
-0.0097179916,
-0.0129707353,
-0.0061142533,
-0.059543591,
0.041936934,
-0.0397570468,
0.0095907999,
-0.0059833569,
0.004215695,
0.0116624013,
0.0548989773,
-0.0498049818,
-0.0296113398,
0.0275415219,
0.0379444733,
0.0076864357,
-0.037243668,
-0.0244063493,
-0.0472049937,
0.0111588901,
0.009928734,
-0.0706122145,
-0.0126636624,
-0.0272074938,
0.0082366308,
-0.0439407267,
0.0048457128,
2.116657806e-34,
0.0523959249,
-0.0344536752,
0.0441036634,
-0.0236464087,
0.0643384755,
0.0008852248,
-0.01011917,
0.0066370526,
-0.0284183901,
-0.0642576963,
0.0044696014
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06561v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06561v3 | Intention Analysis Makes LLMs A Good Jailbreak Defender | 2024-01-12T13:15:05 | 2024-04-29T16:40:57 | Yuqi Zhang, Liang Ding, Lefei Zhang, Dacheng Tao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Aligning large language models (LLMs) with human values, particularly in the
face of complex and stealthy jailbreak attacks, presents a formidable
challenge. In this study, we present a simple yet highly effective defense
strategy, i.e., Intention Analysis ($\mathbb{IA}$). The principle behind this
is to trigger LLMs' inherent self-correct and improve ability through a
two-stage process: 1) essential intention analysis, and 2) policy-aligned
response. Notably, $\mathbb{IA}$ is an inference-only method, thus could
enhance the safety of LLMs without compromising their helpfulness. Extensive
experiments on varying jailbreak benchmarks across ChatGLM, LLaMA2, Vicuna,
MPT, DeepSeek, and GPT-3.5 show that $\mathbb{IA}$ could consistently and
significantly reduce the harmfulness in responses (averagely -53.1% attack
success rate) and maintain the general helpfulness. Encouragingly, with the
help of our $\mathbb{IA}$, Vicuna-7B even outperforms GPT-3.5 in terms of
attack success rate. Further analyses present some insights into how our method
works. To facilitate reproducibility, we release our code and scripts at:
https://github.com/alphadl/SafeLLM_with_IntentionAnalysis. | [
0.0329129733,
0.0566396676,
-0.0242439192,
0.0404717922,
-0.0365355052,
-0.0262415521,
-0.0216452517,
-0.0062908018,
0.0469666012,
-0.0177498702,
-0.00180883,
-0.0199203864,
0.0027482538,
-0.0103929034,
0.0425868332,
0.0275101084,
0.0462760143,
-0.0538672879,
0.0193417631,
0.0296281036,
0.0397594534,
0.0000584629,
0.0231062863,
0.0317092575,
0.0119243395,
-0.0044512483,
-0.0545115545,
0.0138808992,
0.0306607801,
-0.0535631888,
-0.0089386562,
0.0125871468,
-0.0106961755,
0.0125994161,
0.0000022995,
-0.0509145893,
-0.0300510488,
0.012754973,
-0.019930074,
0.0866357088,
-0.0101429792,
-0.054660067,
-0.0436406359,
0.0390383974,
-0.0485040769,
0.0631225035,
0.0214615352,
0.0172252227,
0.077659227,
0.069619067,
0.0027258801,
-0.0049205227,
0.0638580099,
0.0009098948,
0.0161956083,
-0.0574851781,
0.0013792939,
-0.0337886475,
-0.0124320323,
0.0322405621,
0.0283334628,
-0.0214728992,
0.0185293499,
-0.0121009033,
-0.0477380082,
-0.0134197846,
-0.0092740897,
-0.0186413527,
-0.0172406323,
0.0176262539,
-0.0037782749,
-0.0204927325,
0.0362432189,
-0.0214737859,
0.0117961233,
0.0123432381,
0.0087581854,
0.0043727537,
-0.0117396563,
-0.0144359535,
0.0579667725,
-0.0141152991,
0.0586193539,
0.0103484113,
-0.0165517442,
0.0510891974,
-0.002767279,
-0.0343779698,
-0.0225115437,
-0.0597720481,
0.0011445426,
-0.0623277836,
-0.0258771498,
0.0236684866,
-0.0053531607,
0.0241834894,
-0.0646831095,
-0.0187857635,
0.0542212948,
-0.065444231,
-0.0224747937,
0.0750741735,
-0.0202605464,
-0.0142603144,
0.0019922087,
0.0162707865,
0.0008352593,
0.0135500059,
0.0245584212,
0.0261250641,
0.0014756025,
-0.0029502197,
0.0012619602,
0.034344539,
0.0148522053,
0.0321791768,
-0.0418611318,
0.0375053585,
-0.0241962522,
0.0136995986,
-0.0339841321,
-0.0262623224,
-0.0008169031,
0.0157732926,
0.0265603736,
-0.0180951413,
-0.02838975,
-0.0047472827,
-0.013410409,
-0.0882373452,
-0.0117989229,
-0.0019070527,
-0.0874779448,
-0.0202491116,
0.0074029174,
0.1403916031,
0.0228840262,
-0.0274878833,
-0.1034497321,
-0.0769281313,
-0.0187760592,
-0.0363922007,
-0.0059612705,
-0.0850332305,
-0.0272465274,
-0.0119646331,
0.003196652,
-0.034708932,
0.0060109114,
-0.0083681196,
-0.0322020091,
0.034345679,
0.0294971615,
-0.0034962473,
-0.011680264,
0.0539653525,
0.0304350983,
0.078549169,
0.0035924842,
0.0415710472,
0.029107729,
-0.0214325096,
0.040354114,
0.0523047447,
-0.009451055,
0.0293569174,
0.0149581861,
-0.0224616975,
0.0042385352,
-0.0186608974,
0.0092340335,
0.0244361516,
0.0058014658,
-0.0241943877,
0.0813111439,
0.0651073158,
-0.0368583351,
0.0442208499,
-0.0321512483,
-0.0036322654,
0.0173068438,
-0.0181082767,
-0.0580677092,
0.0279685352,
-0.0881848931,
0.0075192871,
-0.0191842392,
0.031548962,
0.0089172358,
0.0039710454,
-0.0055874796,
-0.0067730309,
-0.0208374895,
0.012504085,
0.001251297,
0.0045033013,
0.0145479403,
0.0493600182,
0.0204274468,
-0.0216386169,
-0.0387137383,
-0.1021427885,
0.0062557054,
0.0506646894,
0.0204189848,
-0.0012410362,
-0.0212643761,
0.0109688947,
-0.0464174971,
0.0027420914,
-0.0164619889,
0.0190057959,
0.0259975009,
-0.0185349062,
0.0051766834,
-0.0188492052,
0.0260578599,
0.0355989635,
-0.0331222154,
-0.0003476987,
0.0048241471,
-0.0259150323,
-0.0170516931,
0.0244653523,
0.024345357,
-0.0019016785,
0.0157490242,
0.0154445693,
0.0196313504,
0.0222682841,
-0.0111005036,
0.0028617564,
0.0601594895,
0.005827778,
0.0384467281,
0.0392164737,
-0.024170842,
-0.0101192426,
0.0552671701,
-0.0261254683,
0.0216464009,
0.059239056,
-0.0351342224,
-0.0308328513,
0.0740945265,
-0.0457256399,
0.0532453582,
-0.0135904513,
0.0217808019,
-0.0144777605,
-0.0125472955,
-0.0243008081,
-0.0121159554,
-0.0114998864,
-0.0404517911,
0.0007524565,
0.030472815,
0.0433159806,
0.0070439358,
-0.0733794421,
0.0159549974,
-0.0525611863,
0.0292519648,
0.0269117896,
0.0520391688,
-0.0342740677,
-0.0193601772,
-0.0671152174,
0.0001683957,
-0.0376244672,
0.0450568832,
0.0405082293,
0.0483602881,
-0.037482433,
-0.026323501,
0.0080717579,
-0.0162862185,
0.0083277645,
-0.0058946777,
0.0091936206,
-0.0398728997,
-0.0599610806,
-0.0319793634,
0.0229268186,
-0.0150310909,
-0.0095289927,
-0.0415602177,
-0.0299355462,
0.0015096311,
0.0021913678,
-0.011480324,
-0.0239215456,
-0.0333220735,
-0.0920452625,
0.0504519418,
0.0045924503,
-0.0180167742,
0.0389292873,
0.0156739466,
0.041574277,
0.076459609,
0.0128223719,
-0.065228492,
-0.017123241,
0.0618039519,
-0.0390754938,
-0.0515308343,
-0.0761592686,
0.019133212,
0.0839338824,
0.0289054494,
0.0244527366,
-0.0242727473,
-0.0366045348,
0.0078982832,
0.0022989423,
0.0089876717,
-0.0107880412,
-0.0645875409,
-0.0010276901,
0.0049561346,
-0.0917594209,
0.0642691627,
-0.0586424172,
0.0058933818,
-0.0218024254,
-0.0478799455,
-0.0025106731,
0.0722267479,
-0.0464457236,
0.0134691447,
0.0588405989,
-0.0491108708,
0.0144612268,
-0.0328628682,
0.027273722,
-0.0086790901,
0.049067162,
-0.0701001957,
0.0094186813,
0.0001084168,
-0.0024752298,
-0.0359041467,
-0.0693031549,
-0.0461729504,
-0.038131509,
0.0257291105,
-0.0442605764,
0.0471725576,
-0.0287411381,
0.0327490494,
-0.0200688634,
-0.0011445164,
-0.0108474735,
-0.0181282572,
-0.0161404088,
0.0205737092,
-0.0528171323,
-0.0292404182,
0.0124018751,
0.0397343226,
0.0601492748,
0.0423260555,
0.024440024,
-0.0253618136,
0.0112308338,
0.0360012017,
0.0056660539,
-0.0253760666,
0.0738402754,
0.0806116983,
-0.0138096213,
-0.0354105569,
0.0563555695,
0.0255872943,
0.0021067299,
0.0209379774,
-0.029667858,
0.0563521348,
0.0135961436,
0.0331213251,
-0.0738946125,
-0.0346611738,
0.0168834273,
0.0863429829,
-0.0279381964,
0.0116471685,
-0.0226248913,
-0.0752953365,
-0.0097192582,
0.0342274606,
-0.0176497232,
0.0268351734,
-0.0531121902,
-0.0168704186,
0.0219383687,
0.0334606543,
-0.0137404669,
0.011016326,
-0.0030795967,
0.0279537402,
-0.0882364884,
-0.0081701735,
0.0081771603,
-0.0315816514,
0.0999154523,
0.0929498374,
-0.0074522332,
-0.0354553089,
0.0049960939,
0.0423717797,
-0.0017631402,
-0.0054072733,
0.0032218229,
-0.0302972049,
0.0222942587,
0.0072612488,
0.0134659866,
0.034247499,
-0.0095667336,
-0.0457952991,
0.0524487235,
0.0370154679,
-0.0457437001,
0.0027219371,
-0.021928465,
-0.0331614055,
0.0189963263,
0.0310682543,
0.0198381245,
-0.0212781727,
-0.0259903278,
-0.0769335777,
-0.0443365164,
-0.0489653647,
-0.0232160073,
0.0076931221,
0.0081239073,
-0.0193921831,
-0.02618834,
-0.0124857845,
-0.0568203777,
0.0455824248,
0.0491477251,
-0.002740962,
-0.0094986614,
0.0189665332,
-0.0147178974,
-0.0235874653,
-0.002125073,
0.0648241118,
-0.0399621129,
0.0256738458,
-0.0149167888,
-0.0169918165,
0.0030260005,
0.0051888768,
-0.0319706462,
-0.0898259431,
0.0138573255,
0.0684310123,
0.0286406875,
0.0090313926,
-0.0621847287,
-0.0764381364,
0.0463410988,
0.0665877759,
-0.0584759898,
0.0359587409,
0.0818524435,
-0.0019990467,
0.0164659824,
0.0122453747,
-0.0170990173,
-0.0291033294,
0.0467336476,
0.0279116761,
-0.0436025932,
-0.0287699867,
0.0120421434,
0.0668495446,
0.0107711768,
-0.0293647647,
0.0225737523,
0.0408855267,
-0.0014509923,
0.0106750317,
-0.0158454254,
0.0182590056,
0.0028020227,
0.0236318223,
-0.0482691862,
0.0129310545,
-0.0050499546,
-0.0323741771,
-0.0240015499,
0.0288222358,
0.0499127917,
0.0264344867,
0.0719600171,
0.0469847023,
0.0149617083,
-0.0206346009,
0.0319190659,
-0.0027813031,
0.0315848775,
-0.0012274714,
0.0478588454,
-0.0337997712,
-0.0193694513,
-0.0020707969,
0.0400939174,
-0.0437324457,
-0.0438150503,
0.0128421029,
0.092240423,
0.0100816963,
0.0251038224,
0.0393631198,
-0.0190590564,
0.0298226811,
-0.029568851,
0.009080328,
-0.036899779,
-0.0580140613,
0.0322591141,
-0.0077217487,
-0.006774263,
-0.0050308215,
0.0382454284,
-0.007482301,
0.0456067175,
-0.0066896034,
-0.0204534549,
-0.0392332152,
-0.0046498338,
0.0673780739,
0.0495172776,
-0.0666520298,
-0.0833891481,
-0.0682462305,
-0.0727889836,
-0.0385099649,
0.0207670871,
0.0596382767,
-0.010846952,
-0.0090615749,
0.0486546829,
-0.0012092607,
0.0224673711,
-0.053938888,
0.0071881502,
-0.0302537493,
-0.0316546224,
-0.0007266702,
-5.774761466e-33,
0.0118685849,
-0.0215339754,
-0.028531244,
-0.047677692,
-0.0208008308,
-0.0193376262,
-0.0549459308,
0.0363827087,
-0.0157738179,
-0.0456171408,
-0.0138915405,
0.0153869549,
0.0070639821,
-0.0144211901,
-0.0155141642,
-0.018253522,
-0.0127573265,
0.0242516175,
-0.0372938849,
0.0192614179,
0.0387405567,
0.01275656,
0.008942646,
-0.0527272932,
0.0651315749,
-0.0182646122,
-0.0375680365,
0.0047295452,
-0.0608277395,
0.0688513368,
0.0094579589,
-0.0059647132,
0.0094670588,
-0.0105856294,
0.0139262555,
0.0415567532,
0.0341432765,
-0.0153044574,
0.0486987457,
-0.0129575515,
0.0185765866,
-0.0522390343,
0.0101479571,
0.0185943507,
-0.0283817686,
0.001400721,
-0.0112338066,
0.0041598906,
0.0018300916,
-0.0127930874,
-0.0087506296,
0.0038723329,
-0.0501892455,
-0.0080400622,
-0.0164528433,
-0.0418523028,
-0.0139803262,
-0.0281760581,
-0.0155893415,
0.0329072401,
0.011096919,
-0.0022327416,
0.0550233386,
0.0173904002,
-0.0312666111,
0.0527952015,
-0.0478138328,
-0.0521653108,
0.0250914861,
-0.0147148026,
0.0238210708,
0.0365565494,
0.0232921094,
0.0702157468,
0.0392983928,
-0.0460980125,
-0.0656557381,
0.0351059362,
0.0617675483,
0.0188779924,
0.009488049,
0.0142928734,
-0.0574759096,
-0.0092284326,
-0.0008128489,
-0.0178401507,
-0.0168827903,
-0.0615619048,
0.007671189,
-0.0221051294,
-0.0305743162,
-0.0625176653,
0.0026553078,
-0.0404786877,
0.0119743943,
0.0177705325,
-0.0401097089,
0.0054280111,
-0.0137505131,
0.026026383,
0.0001718539,
-0.013536945,
-0.014745337,
-0.0411759689,
0.0434063338,
-0.0187499505,
0.0174276698,
0.0373318084,
-0.0471897125,
-0.0192474183,
-0.0324261039,
0.0089885695,
-0.0232110769,
-0.0282939076,
0.0044442075,
-0.0233440083,
0.005460823,
0.0037597998,
0.0172296353,
-0.0293698478,
-0.0655185282,
0.0303941667,
-0.0085582547,
0.0239042602,
-0.0142706763,
0.0275943987,
0.0162721928,
0.027621422,
0.013290978,
-0.0593425669,
-0.0089402869,
-0.0211816616,
3.011e-7,
-0.0466575585,
-0.0336328037,
0.0072678053,
0.0135523546,
-0.0057449006,
0.0943010375,
-0.0467423871,
0.0887932181,
0.0102993269,
-0.0316163637,
-0.0129426802,
-0.0220732167,
0.0631050169,
0.0352779515,
-0.0238129385,
0.0426184684,
-0.0382640921,
-0.0219147094,
-0.063500762,
0.0316073373,
0.0478048623,
0.0520831496,
-0.0059290035,
-0.0300541669,
0.0076707588,
-0.0141035449,
0.0019608049,
-0.0004152985,
-0.0090568867,
-0.0175758488,
0.0510972403,
0.0243904199,
0.0088642482,
0.0195804648,
-0.0236869622,
-0.0313005336,
-0.0775518641,
0.0569168888,
0.0203051213,
-0.0223149564,
-0.0427945033,
-0.0359529629,
0.0232890043,
-0.0462844968,
0.0535660908,
0.0208939221,
-0.0230096523,
0.0022675504,
0.0125184013,
-0.0281407963,
-0.0217609927,
-0.0210510418,
0.0017672486,
-0.0009833967,
0.0221124813,
-0.0031452815,
0.0033477885,
-0.0449713506,
-0.0180694256,
0.0100342119,
0.0279624462,
-0.051910311,
-0.0219137631,
0.0732064769,
0.0500495844,
-0.0369863696,
0.0290227048,
2.662979366e-34,
-0.013130472,
-0.042591922,
0.0172309317,
0.0305321626,
0.0363463834,
0.0352060013,
0.0459667929,
0.0589986965,
0.0326918885,
-0.0220925082,
-0.0077677304
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.10279v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.10279v1 | A systematic review of geospatial location embedding approaches in large language models: A path to spatial AI systems | 2024-01-12T12:43:33 | 2024-01-12T12:43:33 | Sean Tucker | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL | Geospatial Location Embedding (GLE) helps a Large Language Model (LLM)
assimilate and analyze spatial data. GLE emergence in Geospatial Artificial
Intelligence (GeoAI) is precipitated by the need for deeper geospatial
awareness in our complex contemporary spaces and the success of LLMs in
extracting deep meaning in Generative AI. We searched Google Scholar, Science
Direct, and arXiv for papers on geospatial location embedding and LLM and
reviewed articles focused on gaining deeper spatial "knowing" through LLMs. We
screened 304 titles, 30 abstracts, and 18 full-text papers that reveal four GLE
themes - Entity Location Embedding (ELE), Document Location Embedding (DLE),
Sequence Location Embedding (SLE), and Token Location Embedding (TLE).
Synthesis is tabular and narrative, including a dialogic conversation between
"Space" and "LLM." Though GLEs aid spatial understanding by superimposing
spatial data, they emphasize the need to advance in the intricacies of spatial
modalities and generalized reasoning. GLEs signal the need for a Spatial
Foundation/Language Model (SLM) that embeds spatial knowing within the model
architecture. The SLM framework advances Spatial Artificial Intelligence
Systems (SPAIS), establishing a Spatial Vector Space (SVS) that maps to
physical space. The resulting spatially imbued Language Model is unique. It
simultaneously represents actual space and an AI-capable space, paving the way
for AI native geo storage, analysis, and multi-modality as the basis for
Spatial Artificial Intelligence Systems (SPAIS). | [
0.0381932743,
0.0590726063,
-0.0330948755,
-0.0052033137,
-0.0167914368,
0.0154168587,
0.034998823,
-0.0467157029,
0.0275756586,
-0.0382285006,
0.0040745386,
0.0043322952,
0.0196926892,
0.0382197723,
0.0379768163,
-0.0748392567,
0.0031120356,
-0.0169694871,
0.021232374,
0.0119774826,
-0.0365936607,
0.0178471766,
0.0089642303,
0.056751281,
-0.0312730335,
0.017123403,
-0.0426647961,
-0.0262908153,
0.0008788374,
-0.0464292094,
-0.0339570306,
-0.0224951431,
0.0819503292,
0.026896961,
0.0000020539,
0.0014629991,
-0.0045665866,
0.0200902801,
0.0287708528,
-0.0188004877,
-0.0182231665,
-0.0303007644,
0.0168640241,
-0.0379389524,
-0.0302118473,
-0.0588869564,
0.0592751279,
0.0068508019,
-0.0013777231,
0.0238106493,
-0.0248125661,
-0.0758705884,
0.0300827306,
0.0056685098,
-0.0052263783,
0.0454386286,
-0.0146001792,
0.0192080438,
0.0711348429,
0.0881080851,
-0.0140985856,
0.0404424779,
0.0190602243,
0.0125562241,
-0.0035792133,
0.0444542244,
-0.0028776042,
0.0275980197,
0.0010312344,
0.0069852942,
0.035962835,
-0.0098634185,
0.0422425047,
0.0379969105,
-0.0091592688,
0.025021404,
-0.0683515668,
0.0206752401,
0.0295188762,
0.0372137614,
0.0048975009,
-0.0086878631,
0.0178165529,
0.0090980642,
-0.0384953246,
0.098158136,
-0.0007512026,
-0.0405189544,
-0.1034286469,
0.0105945617,
0.0000239371,
-0.0557539985,
0.0042647296,
0.0638254732,
-0.0068135657,
0.0207781605,
0.0210940596,
0.0907837152,
0.0064754616,
-0.0332806967,
0.0396102481,
-0.0086860098,
-0.0174366105,
0.0507313944,
-0.0045209774,
0.0451581404,
-0.0107567348,
0.0425412729,
-0.0200291295,
-0.0214414671,
-0.027720958,
-0.0317684375,
-0.0124056675,
0.014649109,
-0.0554782972,
-0.0250716284,
0.0230734721,
0.0576349646,
-0.0161920879,
0.0471492782,
-0.0852138028,
0.0410628356,
0.0139059937,
-0.0272717737,
0.0094351098,
-0.0080605792,
-0.0301022828,
0.0275944844,
-0.0235361233,
-0.0016620132,
0.0052934769,
0.0280088019,
0.029645009,
0.0212055705,
-0.0591068156,
0.0285716616,
0.0836758614,
-0.0331332237,
-0.0373985246,
-0.0196764562,
-0.0129225058,
-0.013691593,
0.0173112806,
-0.0724739581,
0.0005993534,
0.0188674927,
-0.0357971899,
-0.0342288017,
-0.0319289714,
-0.0135304118,
-0.0066786772,
0.036001157,
-0.0166796912,
0.039506346,
0.0735437274,
-0.0004179725,
0.0565180779,
0.0524937771,
0.045331683,
0.0630650148,
0.0490730107,
0.0039175898,
0.0166931376,
-0.0124122351,
0.0014225978,
0.0229867902,
-0.0452698991,
0.0015113825,
-0.0404545926,
0.0230125878,
0.0044998066,
0.0231311861,
0.0030339099,
0.0495471284,
0.056732621,
0.1193630025,
0.0119771082,
-0.0116725406,
0.0884766132,
0.0534293018,
-0.0576994456,
-0.0279284734,
-0.0246032476,
0.007005278,
-0.0044306726,
0.0099546686,
-0.0029987844,
0.0511806607,
-0.0102306474,
-0.0275323465,
-0.0294413287,
-0.0009618234,
0.011984407,
0.0125541184,
0.0360245816,
-0.0332271941,
0.0241737589,
0.0426557437,
-0.0023464891,
-0.0060229045,
0.0217607245,
0.010555299,
0.0229908507,
0.028197445,
-0.0047035036,
-0.0224474929,
-0.0077560279,
-0.0132373311,
0.0268537644,
0.0277363211,
0.0386566408,
-0.0198098272,
-0.0304843467,
-0.0226466078,
-0.0269618519,
-0.0267283861,
0.0350189321,
0.0168219283,
0.0314634144,
0.0454797074,
0.0414005667,
-0.0721726716,
0.0005834706,
-0.0044189407,
-0.0014941269,
-0.0151894791,
-0.0905811042,
0.0383680984,
-0.0279683415,
-0.0010714385,
-0.0095199849,
0.013779996,
0.0434215367,
-0.008166451,
-0.0171727333,
0.0407928266,
-0.0256096907,
0.0490980111,
0.0287958439,
-0.0216952544,
0.0250583943,
-0.0333080068,
-0.0294837039,
-0.0270535853,
0.0169121437,
-0.0527552404,
0.0587294959,
-0.0054425877,
0.0201968513,
-0.0064370674,
-0.0008279663,
-0.0598952211,
0.049201075,
-0.0310508404,
-0.0049000382,
0.0116772447,
0.0322135277,
0.059003491,
0.0254671741,
0.014852738,
-0.0303644985,
-0.0051941788,
0.0054203095,
0.0020898371,
-0.0269635655,
0.0032082899,
-0.0492887869,
-0.0850690678,
-0.0303491093,
-0.0098504322,
0.005793083,
-0.0042308779,
-0.0322898738,
-0.0332077928,
-0.0025940756,
-0.0022064527,
-0.0277826618,
0.0125666019,
0.0186714716,
0.0474882461,
-0.0265757479,
0.0027971026,
0.012869643,
0.0043949909,
-0.0173036084,
0.0331014618,
0.0002096875,
-0.028782675,
-0.0633634403,
-0.0046014898,
-0.0140576437,
-0.0034832002,
0.0074029844,
-0.0215982087,
0.0217147395,
-0.0251332782,
0.0067951619,
0.0141791953,
-0.0387300104,
0.034910731,
0.0298780333,
-0.0664702058,
-0.0456363708,
0.0091268308,
-0.0178503133,
0.0458762012,
-0.0191749837,
-0.0050031426,
0.0235991105,
0.0213371739,
-0.0300034061,
-0.0118302302,
0.0030169392,
0.0463925451,
-0.0496039689,
-0.0133116469,
0.0059982524,
-0.0188200977,
0.0026146569,
0.0628041551,
-0.0385137498,
-0.0683770552,
0.0063294871,
-0.0379087366,
0.0094674723,
-0.0191003047,
-0.0138659459,
-0.0428668931,
0.0781684071,
0.0083707208,
0.0273233019,
-0.0289980471,
-0.0262744799,
0.0166205578,
-0.0258659963,
-0.0577001087,
0.0188036356,
0.0033283092,
-0.0390006267,
-0.0218685269,
0.0076871938,
-0.0460910983,
-0.0254297145,
0.0272519644,
-0.024653485,
-0.0088573387,
0.0070601786,
-0.0566757396,
0.03267828,
0.0620730482,
0.026215693,
0.036754746,
-0.0022698015,
-0.0066748569,
-0.0321081802,
0.0217916872,
0.0782549754,
0.0823620185,
-0.0156311877,
0.0566788018,
-0.0744650587,
-0.0087776184,
-0.0519764721,
0.0217845924,
-0.0057136831,
0.0394990221,
0.0609044135,
-0.0298477691,
-0.0704565793,
0.0055132862,
0.0535184592,
-0.0319689624,
-0.0630629063,
0.083637327,
0.0657889843,
-0.0022155531,
0.0195080917,
-0.0405511819,
-0.0100291334,
0.0330131017,
0.0193201099,
-0.0296071768,
0.0551823452,
0.0117556546,
-0.0847307071,
-0.0070909387,
-0.0007056852,
-0.0031548035,
-0.0720344037,
0.0756917447,
0.0071799792,
-0.0544201359,
-0.0434076861,
-0.0332033299,
-0.0355143733,
0.0644530281,
-0.0391340591,
-0.045035094,
-0.0162599813,
0.0011297644,
0.0318530239,
-0.0809260756,
-0.0217532348,
-0.0603327304,
-0.0640006438,
0.0497147068,
0.0225265417,
0.0892426744,
-0.001910367,
-0.0642347634,
-0.0425386578,
0.0720597357,
0.0365762934,
0.0061673666,
-0.0234749913,
0.0138455033,
0.0061527132,
-0.0108215185,
-0.010446405,
-0.0203186199,
-0.0478237122,
0.0140530216,
0.0856349021,
-0.0463932566,
0.0708872452,
-0.0627225265,
0.0371073112,
0.0108650448,
-0.01632048,
0.0316608436,
0.0087249326,
-0.0362942889,
-0.0596339703,
0.0221561156,
-0.0161924064,
0.0095092496,
0.0348571725,
0.0104366196,
-0.0232838448,
-0.0237220656,
-0.047674194,
0.0093329633,
0.0494280644,
0.0336961225,
-0.0028438752,
0.0153184207,
-0.063082248,
-0.0511831716,
0.0149569185,
-0.0354406573,
-0.0168454777,
0.0471229479,
0.0246154629,
0.0244736504,
-0.0336345509,
-0.0067517026,
0.0011530373,
-0.0268870946,
-0.0389127806,
0.0252300259,
0.041493237,
0.0166889224,
-0.0240362547,
-0.0130096748,
-0.0247118566,
0.0845749378,
-0.0051180474,
-0.051840581,
-0.017399108,
-0.0013538813,
0.0124019179,
0.0428839512,
-0.0117539,
-0.012485533,
0.0030072022,
0.0006497009,
-0.0163038094,
-0.0382252485,
0.0285186507,
-0.0173471645,
-0.0174828433,
0.0494122505,
-0.009692586,
-0.0076625631,
-0.0169925205,
-0.0334755331,
-0.0672153607,
0.0015768533,
-0.0143361213,
0.0158520024,
0.0373754948,
0.0482163168,
-0.0138304727,
0.020082932,
0.0133548751,
-0.00389375,
-0.0016822687,
0.0094219986,
0.0248777419,
0.010057847,
-0.006803703,
0.0385222808,
-0.0179823805,
0.0303084385,
-0.0588193648,
0.0304183494,
-0.0137730846,
-0.0185407046,
0.0291100182,
-0.0082462579,
-0.0542235449,
0.0483368002,
-0.0264246128,
-0.0607147142,
0.0259628724,
0.0414731838,
0.1027855426,
-0.0171316788,
0.0222873818,
-0.0242524222,
-0.0092055527,
0.0526057817,
-0.0052628373,
0.049299188,
-0.0918406546,
-0.0300949998,
0.0206386372,
-0.0589976572,
0.0137992846,
0.0009117728,
0.0121720601,
0.0206938889,
-0.0156900883,
-0.045547504,
0.0008402994,
-0.0072790328,
0.0131643871,
0.0339360721,
-0.0326148421,
0.0110517088,
-0.067122981,
-0.0474567451,
0.0226155631,
0.0028817416,
-0.0517411269,
-0.011707305,
0.0151894521,
0.0474334136,
0.0060588159,
-0.0586328954,
-0.0444662943,
0.0071361675,
-0.0140962368,
-0.044919908,
0.007881918,
-5.800738422e-33,
-0.0108515294,
-0.0868113935,
0.0789913237,
-0.0146654677,
-0.0399177708,
0.0024998533,
-0.0174756832,
-0.0231667161,
0.0063675754,
-0.0006792622,
-0.0076388828,
-0.0157633387,
-0.0022235594,
0.026365418,
0.0319316313,
0.0318188407,
-0.0058821077,
0.0304511059,
-0.0091258716,
0.0004270154,
0.041396182,
-0.0101027843,
0.0276246127,
-0.0947596952,
0.0014685648,
0.0252641309,
-0.0115156546,
0.0030319425,
0.0036748257,
0.0496417694,
-0.0328631401,
0.0153606674,
0.0153475646,
-0.0118144285,
-0.0293656271,
0.0237344056,
-0.0333119445,
-0.032281436,
-0.0005919698,
0.0316787772,
0.0083189178,
-0.0641985536,
0.0202387031,
-0.0081051886,
0.0048703039,
0.0394363739,
0.0391459353,
0.002384034,
-0.0733452588,
0.0115851713,
-0.1076732129,
0.0020347985,
-0.0083967969,
0.0106145693,
0.0261236094,
-0.0393120125,
0.0533792488,
0.0243007597,
-0.0306262299,
0.0409543253,
0.0291194916,
0.0035702931,
0.019774029,
-0.0062412801,
0.0305421073,
0.0559620596,
0.0349266455,
0.0010683999,
-0.0491471328,
-0.0066557624,
0.0673571154,
0.0132659553,
-0.0318924896,
0.0348817594,
-0.0309561864,
-0.0194684807,
-0.025852181,
0.0292347092,
-0.0746641234,
-0.0026335707,
0.021574555,
0.0057914932,
-0.0410511382,
-0.0309087262,
-0.014285991,
-0.0425871685,
0.018399138,
-0.015605608,
0.0099334577,
-0.0097828656,
0.0457203239,
0.0683416352,
0.0025142182,
-0.0466784686,
-0.0471092388,
0.034152627,
0.0115549639,
0.0304530431,
-0.0133230099,
0.0469272509,
-0.02718422,
-0.0409689434,
-0.0137318065,
0.0348984711,
-0.0069546569,
0.0426579118,
0.0286520533,
0.0621374995,
-0.0292754062,
-0.0071918373,
-0.0121144028,
-0.0487999097,
-0.0219012871,
-0.0682994649,
0.035512235,
-0.0133848125,
0.0126799168,
0.018338507,
0.0475490168,
0.033912763,
0.0267900527,
-0.0053937393,
-0.0549653843,
0.0147714894,
0.0074830088,
0.0000921046,
-0.0433476679,
0.0195899941,
0.0377393328,
-0.0520333163,
-0.016841216,
-0.0338252112,
2.871e-7,
0.0315803066,
0.0626503155,
0.0539077111,
-0.0192416795,
-0.001127286,
-0.0056784116,
0.0311216228,
-0.0024834606,
-0.0406938307,
0.0827838928,
0.032587681,
0.038257055,
0.0030627535,
0.0250929296,
-0.1276612878,
0.0881321356,
-0.046233952,
-0.0233203787,
-0.0960308984,
0.0192439407,
0.0197621938,
0.0251511354,
0.0215325151,
-0.0082829595,
-0.0026184928,
-0.0403017886,
-0.0070485803,
-0.0333511382,
0.0078123859,
0.0223822054,
0.0198368579,
0.0010370512,
-0.0000214088,
-0.0739432126,
0.0048945509,
-0.0070677041,
0.0032618491,
0.02636615,
-0.0135996751,
0.0018654057,
-0.0264369044,
-0.0806331038,
-0.0285513233,
-0.1003895402,
0.0203441884,
-0.0416408852,
-0.0455025621,
-0.0037467123,
-0.0086943954,
-0.0043578688,
-0.0048006824,
0.0131814396,
0.001005762,
-0.0362993777,
-0.0120297354,
-0.0009949779,
0.0167505555,
-0.0825359374,
-0.0044007176,
0.0481841974,
0.01001646,
0.0275966916,
-0.0323699638,
-0.005213222,
0.053926982,
-0.0097494358,
-0.0073672868,
2.665778972e-34,
-0.0306139607,
0.0031998672,
-0.0149682332,
-0.0028566241,
0.0570807643,
0.0028522166,
-0.0298666805,
0.0169612933,
0.0263676271,
-0.0122239189,
-0.013151628
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06541v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06541v1 | Medical Dialogue Generation via Intuitive-then-Analytical Differential Diagnosis | 2024-01-12T12:35:19 | 2024-01-12T12:35:19 | Kaishuai Xu, Wenjun Hou, Yi Cheng, Jian Wang, Wenjie Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Medical dialogue systems have attracted growing research attention as they
have the potential to provide rapid diagnoses, treatment plans, and health
consultations. In medical dialogues, a proper diagnosis is crucial as it
establishes the foundation for future consultations. Clinicians typically
employ both intuitive and analytic reasoning to formulate a differential
diagnosis. This reasoning process hypothesizes and verifies a variety of
possible diseases and strives to generate a comprehensive and rigorous
diagnosis. However, recent studies on medical dialogue generation have
overlooked the significance of modeling a differential diagnosis, which hinders
the practical application of these systems. To address the above issue, we
propose a medical dialogue generation framework with the
Intuitive-then-Analytic Differential Diagnosis (IADDx). Our method starts with
a differential diagnosis via retrieval-based intuitive association and
subsequently refines it through a graph-enhanced analytic procedure. The
resulting differential diagnosis is then used to retrieve medical knowledge and
guide response generation. Experimental results on two datasets validate the
efficacy of our method. Besides, we demonstrate how our framework assists both
clinicians and patients in understanding the diagnostic process, for instance,
by producing intermediate results and graph-based diagnosis paths. | [
0.0431674831,
0.0319653861,
-0.0300777331,
0.0211012736,
-0.0084182061,
-0.0096312957,
-0.0206200629,
0.0078383796,
0.0418428145,
0.0142267914,
0.0323219225,
-0.0257972423,
0.0219769757,
0.0740890577,
-0.0209367108,
-0.0556947067,
0.0048266388,
0.0306087267,
0.0328258872,
0.0032730277,
0.0067675072,
0.0154503053,
-0.0657164678,
0.0398978516,
-0.003443684,
-0.0414525867,
0.0055967653,
-0.0111061111,
0.0335415378,
-0.0877886564,
-0.0428684317,
0.0075511965,
-0.0040774578,
-0.0259944517,
0.0000020002,
-0.0522073619,
-0.0020391606,
-0.0309977364,
-0.0200843774,
-0.100596793,
0.014492848,
-0.0079117827,
0.0520251691,
0.0126354787,
-0.0482033007,
-0.0432523377,
0.0232874807,
0.027590951,
0.0556841679,
0.0502731539,
-0.0201453045,
-0.058017686,
-0.0049988544,
0.0104648508,
0.0027695731,
-0.0362953357,
0.0355304256,
0.0058981264,
0.0554454289,
-0.0579412915,
-0.0030831834,
0.0092763612,
-0.003401208,
-0.0142950425,
0.0140392249,
0.0262438338,
0.0521604791,
-0.0184736606,
-0.0167736355,
0.1131061837,
0.0517165661,
0.0206649024,
0.050704781,
-0.0176674873,
0.0302977636,
0.0088899219,
-0.0486628264,
-0.0411302708,
-0.071773611,
-0.0060319905,
0.01199356,
0.0047922689,
0.0102922618,
-0.0158872642,
-0.0134378495,
0.0460726358,
-0.0295695458,
-0.0032916581,
-0.0149175907,
-0.0279673692,
-0.0050006085,
-0.0329977944,
0.0247325152,
0.0521552339,
-0.0813804716,
0.0101124002,
-0.0008413832,
-0.0318604298,
0.0362822711,
-0.003908183,
0.0524513759,
0.0203665253,
0.0246601719,
-0.0140358256,
0.0167599618,
0.0061884192,
-0.033178404,
0.0068110549,
-0.0384435393,
0.0397395939,
-0.0601718351,
-0.0241847876,
-0.0509501137,
0.0316888578,
0.0009586875,
-0.0154495155,
-0.0664192811,
0.0357550308,
-0.0233660862,
-0.0062416014,
-0.0138995536,
0.0478080623,
-0.0074991789,
0.0345607139,
-0.0630137995,
0.0139896981,
-0.0337014459,
0.019411305,
0.0390109643,
-0.0094238324,
0.010618004,
0.0206461716,
0.0300158449,
0.0121793235,
-0.0049617835,
0.0507405102,
-0.0187040474,
0.0554271452,
-0.002398398,
-0.0938630775,
-0.0414972454,
-0.0246331748,
0.0080658402,
-0.0546475574,
0.0167891607,
0.039782539,
-0.018161701,
-0.0517959557,
0.0272539668,
0.0201504305,
-0.0471465886,
0.04112982,
-0.0546525717,
0.0404070169,
0.0116348118,
0.0275110006,
-0.0309907962,
-0.0048895315,
0.0145849688,
-0.0137260146,
0.0007750927,
-0.0154774617,
0.0487778485,
-0.0052968604,
0.0534570776,
-0.0185845122,
-0.0001368464,
0.0213939361,
-0.0488901623,
0.0692628473,
-0.0507211685,
0.05330313,
-0.0185212903,
0.0078816945,
0.0250816885,
0.0570228398,
0.0054342272,
-0.0006237664,
0.0295738373,
-0.0207067505,
-0.0307254046,
0.0238088891,
0.0292341653,
-0.0069830348,
0.0177457407,
-0.0010260717,
-0.0039030428,
-0.0312031955,
-0.0031171977,
-0.0617243499,
-0.0523963347,
0.0255579539,
0.0125259217,
-0.0171367023,
-0.0209236462,
0.015721051,
0.0006424988,
0.0323470682,
0.0059864172,
-0.0029972035,
-0.0483017266,
-0.0747228414,
0.0180367231,
0.0909643918,
0.0556198657,
-0.0111600384,
-0.0321823396,
-0.0017138893,
-0.0052777743,
0.0091549717,
0.0234410707,
-0.0327988006,
0.0009794189,
-0.0169626251,
0.0027276215,
0.016626142,
0.0043644276,
-0.0071145711,
-0.0500743091,
-0.0001660616,
-0.0217833202,
-0.0103374263,
0.0084880702,
0.0016423863,
-0.005080963,
0.0176678933,
0.0382294916,
0.0200343616,
0.0357671678,
0.0422579162,
0.0131539935,
0.0501445569,
0.0045966464,
-0.0186203066,
-0.0404876471,
0.0580405034,
-0.0398626216,
-0.053758502,
0.0032373434,
-0.0003442633,
-0.0307939574,
-0.0606904328,
-0.0397298895,
-0.0433544666,
0.0416883305,
-0.0885916203,
-0.0093966918,
0.0190579351,
-0.0219501257,
0.0738887042,
-0.0080236914,
-0.0073702321,
0.0357007384,
-0.013818671,
0.0022004033,
-0.0014954129,
0.0054359855,
0.0346684158,
-0.0821264535,
0.0116339391,
0.0080241617,
-0.0312027484,
-0.0077617452,
-0.0098098507,
-0.0049233553,
-0.0454449914,
0.0110015925,
-0.1011887565,
-0.0261717085,
0.024682194,
-0.0179118998,
-0.0059219929,
0.0274315141,
-0.0113048432,
-0.0368913561,
-0.0691179186,
0.0353574678,
0.0594852939,
0.0351657458,
0.0755008385,
0.0674513727,
-0.0456200354,
-0.0124168312,
0.0018230563,
-0.0435694195,
0.0351912752,
0.0361659974,
0.0087610716,
0.007660137,
-0.0288173426,
-0.0765246898,
-0.0020784126,
-0.0027854468,
-0.0118004363,
0.0290349871,
-0.0220530946,
-0.0167361237,
0.0210582241,
0.0007969551,
0.0477242544,
0.002676114,
-0.0269188937,
-0.0498005413,
0.0155960107,
-0.0643067434,
0.0019253258,
0.0191108994,
-0.0605395958,
-0.0280533638,
0.0763035789,
0.0481260531,
0.0137702459,
-0.027789887,
0.0491647683,
0.0316888094,
0.0242631361,
-0.038774617,
-0.0367201865,
0.0037501743,
0.0499205738,
-0.0042768777,
-0.0304386765,
0.1255205572,
0.0155712152,
0.0335956179,
-0.0661146864,
-0.0366959088,
-0.0308566615,
0.0258148629,
-0.0267760064,
0.0249509402,
0.040413633,
-0.0262771025,
0.0070448639,
-0.0353986397,
0.0252043214,
-0.0660441294,
0.0372165889,
-0.0569619015,
0.0190587789,
0.0428473689,
-0.0445431098,
-0.0492520966,
0.0001166619,
0.0017435434,
-0.0087251188,
0.0127022052,
0.0036055821,
-0.0216483008,
0.0246109441,
0.0001026819,
0.0383011475,
0.0247724988,
-0.0150176585,
-0.0159750022,
0.0055442606,
0.044950299,
0.0147073856,
-0.028680725,
-0.0169877596,
0.0617491603,
0.0439392515,
0.0108885011,
-0.0134717412,
-0.0125547862,
0.0206949338,
-0.0499536246,
0.0290916245,
-0.0013495578,
0.0133672543,
-0.0378379747,
-0.0279857628,
-0.0129683577,
0.0521171577,
0.0212876089,
-0.031009011,
0.0215677489,
0.0016407743,
-0.0310781691,
-0.0371562093,
-0.0054918979,
-0.1071526781,
-0.0240106191,
-0.0140364757,
0.0473752581,
-0.0567731559,
-0.0512600467,
0.0078444406,
-0.0285545178,
0.0244735517,
0.0000589682,
0.0041889045,
-0.0320075527,
-0.0170140322,
-0.0028274208,
0.0183182918,
-0.0608674027,
-0.0253563076,
0.0248859376,
0.0156213837,
0.0039996929,
-0.0515590124,
-0.0302739069,
0.0016674076,
0.0271398928,
-0.0263794959,
0.0468652323,
0.0564676039,
0.0597061999,
-0.0152101889,
-0.0501175821,
0.036014948,
0.0498144552,
-0.0277379341,
0.0515165888,
0.0333609506,
0.0164017491,
-0.0695531368,
0.0492734946,
-0.0370048285,
-0.0479172617,
-0.0067731999,
0.0831047073,
-0.0603026524,
-0.0262234174,
-0.060443487,
0.0434206054,
0.0588873439,
0.0276243184,
0.0129721416,
0.0209618509,
-0.0355558731,
0.0291548632,
0.0492424928,
-0.0226376913,
0.0067111622,
0.0052679125,
0.001778307,
-0.0276234392,
-0.0817402899,
-0.0362930521,
-0.0104776081,
0.0336599275,
-0.0021464296,
0.0015587107,
-0.0115598291,
0.0273779258,
-0.0696124062,
0.0503027141,
0.0693581477,
0.0258344989,
-0.0021044612,
-0.0287928022,
0.0428888723,
0.0001557415,
-0.0193054769,
0.0597921833,
0.0141768986,
-0.0213310178,
-0.0196008589,
0.0042933319,
0.031515643,
0.0014699975,
0.0008343731,
-0.0132722463,
0.0145380581,
0.0455145016,
0.016288206,
-0.0227568503,
-0.0082387188,
0.0558787137,
0.0052687982,
0.014906493,
-0.0181177445,
0.015562688,
0.0060604773,
0.0484917127,
-0.06480667,
-0.0272284523,
0.0207612328,
0.047640074,
0.0308701303,
0.005237537,
-0.0372687839,
-0.0284478515,
0.0242469795,
-0.0289275497,
-0.039888382,
-0.0123950131,
0.0184267294,
-0.019763805,
-0.0319268331,
0.0095156878,
-0.0426986031,
-0.0567291006,
-0.0230696592,
-0.0112025142,
0.0070679444,
0.0348391235,
-0.038678173,
0.0513015352,
-0.0100944545,
0.0075311344,
-0.0059841922,
0.0173370708,
0.042850811,
0.0274248123,
0.1009138003,
0.0279061552,
0.0069708996,
-0.0017367809,
0.0006781352,
-0.0375343338,
-0.0615901612,
0.0020589586,
0.0168112926,
0.0028739043,
0.0539474636,
-0.0149554191,
-0.0113351438,
0.0173709784,
0.0143572399,
0.0370994769,
0.0026681717,
-0.0563078895,
0.0547071174,
0.0009248277,
0.012263136,
-0.0419573449,
0.0443112105,
-0.0806398839,
0.0072041876,
-0.0564413294,
-0.0534032434,
-0.0580089651,
-0.02267823,
0.0126583707,
0.0342736989,
-0.018555874,
0.0291351993,
-0.0962953791,
-0.0355215706,
0.0044996059,
-0.0030321141,
-0.0107864756,
0.0027497204,
0.0680995658,
0.033755105,
0.034347374,
-0.045852907,
-0.0189283825,
0.1040111408,
-0.1041222811,
-0.0101634832,
-0.0243582763,
-5.439607088e-33,
-0.0036230963,
-0.0515065193,
0.0384589583,
-0.0083812503,
0.0026429801,
-0.022728717,
-0.0505748577,
0.0276217759,
0.0014444183,
0.0634060875,
0.0001509637,
0.012645538,
-0.0002518219,
0.0534366667,
-0.0317887999,
-0.0294674095,
0.022273995,
0.0160670895,
-0.0468975231,
0.0360378437,
0.0536020808,
0.0204389021,
-0.0289914571,
-0.082561709,
0.0004487439,
-0.0172387902,
0.0200673081,
0.0494408794,
-0.0078467261,
0.034592703,
0.0059172418,
0.0343200155,
0.0391735695,
0.0558849424,
-0.0022176383,
0.0402020849,
-0.0276589878,
-0.0390515141,
0.0207442828,
-0.0293323901,
-0.0376105979,
-0.0216289442,
0.0319159031,
-0.0006806058,
0.0036966556,
-0.0028794976,
0.019739097,
-0.0259320531,
0.0204118323,
-0.0248681903,
0.0052039116,
0.0319256335,
-0.0217737798,
-0.0338831991,
-0.0252108704,
0.0274614505,
-0.0150800487,
-0.0242027026,
-0.0135417217,
0.0345622115,
0.0150773395,
-0.0342841297,
0.0252571683,
-0.0138315009,
-0.0207553525,
0.0356512703,
0.0657121465,
-0.0197650865,
-0.0691107586,
0.0039700978,
-0.087305598,
0.0687722489,
0.0353706293,
0.0067441771,
-0.0135682151,
0.0174069293,
-0.0632561892,
0.021148717,
-0.0379202738,
0.0506994911,
0.0241599027,
-0.0023408963,
-0.0709431618,
-0.0208648555,
-0.0284634102,
0.0109020434,
-0.0368453674,
-0.0470372066,
0.01743255,
0.0052694026,
0.0113410652,
0.015336344,
-0.0027919607,
-0.0223755036,
0.013326291,
-0.0207838342,
0.0329459198,
0.0043549663,
-0.0254248027,
-0.0252183881,
-0.0164706558,
-0.0131731573,
0.025071498,
-0.0024567135,
0.0554740056,
0.0456155464,
-0.0204721,
-0.0598729812,
-0.0031141834,
-0.0016197789,
-0.0002101111,
0.0273670759,
-0.0556757972,
-0.0307620224,
0.0171024017,
0.0531114489,
-0.0360748135,
0.0609308444,
-0.0031226289,
0.0362203531,
-0.0408225358,
-0.0372554176,
-0.0230720639,
0.0310740862,
-0.0488090217,
-0.0118875876,
0.0150039662,
0.0020234946,
0.0269520972,
-0.0403693095,
-0.0020849877,
-0.0044637006,
2.758e-7,
0.0384904034,
0.0045457548,
0.0450698547,
0.0182032641,
0.0456134602,
0.0206678621,
0.0085633434,
0.0171763171,
0.0207169186,
-0.0541624613,
0.0102277705,
0.0164886266,
0.0354890004,
0.060430944,
-0.0397075005,
-0.001584322,
-0.0683877245,
-0.0270534679,
-0.006317657,
0.0084721576,
0.0912778825,
-0.0147361141,
-0.0305174869,
-0.0061575328,
0.0312735774,
-0.0185922943,
0.0400373004,
0.0062827906,
0.0220064539,
0.0407041311,
0.0260807071,
-0.0534832217,
0.0367603414,
0.0684646145,
-0.0159671474,
0.0059448695,
-0.0059705768,
0.0174959525,
-0.0546938963,
-0.0164786093,
-0.0175382011,
-0.0330169909,
0.0469362959,
-0.0269102585,
0.0165214017,
-0.1078329235,
-0.0426846184,
0.0542573705,
-0.0013955311,
-0.0330571458,
0.0300012678,
-0.0227558594,
-0.039452944,
0.0295638833,
0.0310899466,
0.0207731947,
0.0288956743,
-0.0702645034,
-0.0107502779,
0.0518083796,
-0.0391265787,
-0.042746339,
0.036036469,
-0.0218891036,
-0.0022437214,
-0.0536187477,
0.000320026,
2.131435056e-34,
0.0290925801,
0.0369876623,
-0.0334737338,
0.0198343787,
0.0531471409,
-0.0228986889,
0.0302094296,
0.0541197248,
0.076913029,
-0.0742053315,
-0.0229946747
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06532v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06532v3 | INTERS: Unlocking the Power of Large Language Models in Search with Instruction Tuning | 2024-01-12T12:10:28 | 2024-05-28T13:58:32 | Yutao Zhu, Peitian Zhang, Chenghao Zhang, Yifei Chen, Binyu Xie, Zheng Liu, Ji-Rong Wen, Zhicheng Dou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive capabilities in
various natural language processing tasks. Despite this, their application to
information retrieval (IR) tasks is still challenging due to the infrequent
occurrence of many IR-specific concepts in natural language. While prompt-based
methods can provide task descriptions to LLMs, they often fall short in
facilitating a comprehensive understanding and execution of IR tasks, thereby
limiting LLMs' applicability. To address this gap, in this work, we explore the
potential of instruction tuning to enhance LLMs' proficiency in IR tasks. We
introduce a novel instruction tuning dataset, INTERS, encompassing 20 tasks
across three fundamental IR categories: query understanding, document
understanding, and query-document relationship understanding. The data are
derived from 43 distinct datasets with manually written templates. Our
empirical results reveal that INTERS significantly boosts the performance of
various publicly available LLMs, such as LLaMA, Mistral, and Phi, in IR tasks.
Furthermore, we conduct extensive experiments to analyze the effects of
instruction design, template diversity, few-shot demonstrations, and the volume
of instructions on performance. We make our dataset and the fine-tuned models
publicly accessible at https://github.com/DaoD/INTERS. | [
0.0652505234,
0.0342097506,
0.0074263965,
0.0331997164,
-0.0161476787,
0.0262110773,
0.0117997834,
0.0088419616,
0.0176097937,
-0.0286290888,
-0.0805436894,
-0.017770974,
-0.0350922495,
-0.0260227714,
-0.0093729347,
-0.0399203859,
0.0456730276,
-0.0249694884,
-0.0177433752,
0.0361345857,
0.0024879861,
0.0249318164,
0.0102417702,
0.0091476403,
0.0372555368,
-0.0155500341,
-0.001608754,
0.0594863519,
-0.0207185689,
-0.0307776835,
0.0266750176,
0.0352355205,
0.0553594306,
0.0405481532,
0.0000018289,
-0.044748079,
-0.0098049473,
0.0006076889,
-0.0465484783,
0.038532339,
0.0703990608,
-0.0102752438,
0.0524802245,
0.029540332,
-0.0258305892,
-0.0304517746,
0.0084987143,
0.0456852391,
0.0608676039,
0.0918184444,
0.0174797755,
-0.0292007178,
0.0077061867,
-0.039563939,
0.0574455969,
-0.0479751118,
0.0175581966,
-0.0215222053,
0.0584430583,
0.0718575493,
0.0130506577,
0.0436348729,
-0.0126542095,
-0.0195720177,
0.017595496,
0.017363755,
-0.0548670739,
-0.0230702851,
0.0040909052,
0.0628649965,
-0.0241108369,
-0.0278407708,
-0.0070462157,
0.0121093625,
-0.0126978857,
0.0309183132,
-0.0589548536,
-0.0009088027,
-0.0390041582,
-0.0152751002,
0.0112105329,
-0.0223105457,
0.029611459,
0.028219603,
-0.0207262803,
0.0567746237,
0.0052142292,
-0.0437396467,
0.0219063405,
-0.0241616331,
-0.0266161095,
-0.0228789989,
0.0179067142,
0.0526429787,
-0.0592440367,
0.0169431735,
-0.0073039811,
-0.0295532905,
0.0442952439,
-0.0331453308,
0.0357150212,
0.0411503762,
-0.0099874614,
0.1092711613,
-0.0300562773,
0.0691125393,
0.0002347656,
0.0253844224,
-0.0654899329,
-0.0128643671,
-0.0568310246,
-0.0262313969,
-0.0546107106,
0.000006763,
-0.0463677458,
-0.0283891931,
0.0192193948,
0.0345362276,
0.0340262949,
0.0004353901,
0.0298323631,
-0.0080678798,
-0.0523789972,
-0.0109192235,
-0.042021893,
0.0264210049,
-0.0185334682,
-0.0016635422,
-0.0100625111,
-0.0618387572,
-0.0174545515,
0.0168208797,
0.0031644683,
-0.0461001582,
0.0475251302,
0.0101638027,
-0.0155612584,
-0.0621417239,
-0.0219960865,
0.0064729499,
0.057405822,
-0.0537120216,
0.0037174188,
-0.0363015272,
0.0399044976,
0.0169510543,
0.00942156,
-0.0188289639,
0.0200631954,
0.0560026355,
-0.0261361785,
0.0827260166,
0.0142427329,
0.0329493023,
0.0468418971,
0.0092701167,
0.0230367817,
0.0886184126,
-0.0081870165,
0.0276989527,
0.0611417964,
0.0055587497,
0.011172181,
0.0046509816,
-0.00078933,
0.0237456616,
-0.0194393881,
0.0667871758,
0.0066613266,
0.047255449,
0.0336267576,
0.0478447936,
-0.0232290346,
-0.0125693372,
0.0165454075,
0.0489392281,
0.0255648419,
-0.0267500039,
0.0410579816,
0.0409399457,
0.0219872221,
-0.0229299609,
-0.0294778682,
0.017351253,
-0.0239875242,
-0.0007363128,
0.0124846399,
0.0116207702,
-0.0469177477,
-0.0272579808,
-0.0214274954,
0.0329727829,
-0.04508112,
0.0433267206,
0.0320961624,
0.0096258931,
-0.0297716465,
0.020494137,
0.0218148604,
-0.0316810645,
0.0187453292,
-0.0382935219,
0.0186000932,
0.0931486189,
0.0740597472,
-0.0596584082,
-0.0203269459,
0.0153089007,
0.0387639068,
0.0288429055,
0.0308235753,
-0.0277454033,
-0.0034592659,
-0.0568137132,
-0.0372722186,
-0.0212665144,
0.0112674134,
-0.0042729834,
0.048018869,
-0.0094255581,
0.0227551367,
-0.0696500093,
-0.042555552,
0.0456543863,
-0.0409894846,
-0.0867169648,
0.0011845951,
0.0025007024,
-0.0239370577,
-0.0071102069,
-0.0088164443,
0.0144347539,
0.0409757458,
-0.0069505358,
0.022875309,
-0.0462518819,
-0.0144150797,
-0.0112610403,
0.0004189842,
0.0000869656,
0.0244286861,
-0.000289542,
-0.0399670303,
-0.0212268699,
-0.0263969488,
-0.0109947855,
0.0442128703,
-0.0287651196,
0.0044203587,
-0.0014281722,
-0.0059096487,
-0.0728767812,
0.0521821529,
0.0105877072,
0.0528099686,
0.0443994105,
0.0159541555,
-0.0193965957,
-0.0475459322,
-0.0114493193,
0.0117351357,
0.0086627156,
0.0099866791,
0.0178218521,
0.0324849263,
-0.0510240383,
-0.0303587839,
-0.1126205176,
0.043778576,
-0.0420758389,
0.0278409049,
0.0074179699,
0.0217356384,
-0.0327765457,
-0.0265888479,
-0.0147065893,
-0.05678216,
0.0008738362,
0.0414369591,
0.0162803233,
0.0331545249,
-0.0144452564,
-0.0486789942,
-0.0399417691,
-0.0005621237,
0.0389435254,
0.0075555462,
-0.004032806,
-0.0380563438,
0.0387268476,
0.0010798461,
-0.0012309084,
-0.0221599229,
-0.0066077737,
0.0072362158,
-0.0555034131,
0.0243038852,
0.1025883481,
0.0070837652,
0.0360331163,
0.0283400342,
-0.0025735062,
-0.0904627368,
0.0327671282,
-0.0155650964,
-0.0322497897,
-0.0245785601,
-0.0221196171,
0.0168245584,
0.0384420045,
-0.022449268,
0.0031745022,
-0.0336307287,
0.0088947192,
-0.00842671,
0.0132161016,
-0.074776642,
0.0017856134,
0.0409116,
0.0192042105,
-0.0270006992,
-0.0473451801,
0.0559533425,
-0.0314842798,
-0.0068510291,
-0.0465769619,
-0.013181881,
-0.0813904032,
0.0503251441,
-0.0175204575,
0.0059220102,
-0.0096222796,
-0.023553282,
-0.0273686629,
0.0073614889,
0.0217482671,
-0.049207896,
0.0311713219,
-0.0224933717,
0.0135797802,
-0.000871137,
-0.0380248316,
-0.0262141135,
-0.0515417457,
-0.0036120885,
0.0180774927,
0.032200072,
-0.0156951863,
-0.0765072703,
0.010087789,
0.0567454882,
0.033292871,
-0.0238003898,
-0.0308285113,
-0.0189122595,
-0.0034425331,
0.0548972785,
-0.0414440483,
-0.0042752335,
-0.0429644324,
0.018421419,
-0.0033168141,
0.0691824108,
-0.0337764546,
-0.0048300764,
-0.0114996172,
0.0462593473,
-0.054180745,
0.0040692179,
-0.0076455814,
0.0286030415,
-0.0580444336,
-0.0354320407,
0.1049946994,
0.0309684705,
-0.0646456257,
-0.0374018326,
-0.0204558782,
0.0188446511,
0.0655984059,
0.063904345,
-0.0483938791,
-0.0376013517,
0.0149257202,
0.0649293438,
0.0127748884,
-0.0058327899,
-0.0120633366,
-0.1028122082,
0.032113716,
-0.0109718721,
-0.009348128,
-0.0515052229,
-0.0837354138,
0.0015456608,
-0.028261371,
0.0274100062,
0.0447923318,
-0.0725241676,
0.0032944914,
0.0325169265,
0.0181946903,
-0.0629144236,
0.019883601,
-0.022620488,
-0.0017089323,
0.0587889105,
-0.0031297854,
0.0254601985,
-0.0313124061,
0.0156986117,
-0.0284672417,
0.0107416753,
-0.0382693112,
0.0388389267,
-0.0425728038,
-0.0036395895,
-0.0145270759,
-0.0020345321,
-0.0327947959,
0.0237167701,
-0.0014648298,
0.0413957983,
-0.0326734558,
0.0330085345,
-0.0423210524,
-0.0626546144,
0.0036411001,
0.0870610997,
0.0132780345,
-0.0049819457,
-0.0035469239,
-0.0273430329,
-0.0003543873,
-0.0162072424,
-0.0192603804,
0.0171511937,
-0.040704485,
0.0130430786,
-0.0290477928,
-0.0431094728,
0.0386613905,
0.0285275597,
0.0157793555,
0.0114020556,
-0.0275853667,
0.0001985476,
-0.050099548,
0.0750942379,
-0.0451619774,
0.0142979883,
-0.0735539645,
-0.0060991277,
0.039653711,
-0.0282129347,
-0.0198989101,
-0.0092205219,
-0.0711739361,
-0.0299224909,
-0.0226589236,
0.0147546399,
0.0211352333,
0.0327118263,
-0.016746603,
-0.069472827,
0.0121656796,
0.0595064051,
-0.039852526,
-0.0293345731,
-0.000628659,
-0.0118371677,
-0.0126563776,
0.0411291942,
-0.0666219592,
-0.0047199675,
-0.0036909089,
0.0569185652,
-0.0222669821,
-0.0260866247,
0.0423547588,
0.0328356437,
0.0494226068,
0.0232717767,
0.0279510804,
-0.0514613725,
0.037603721,
-0.0022932449,
-0.0424326248,
-0.0194688998,
0.0021488359,
0.0461905748,
-0.0413627252,
-0.009497487,
0.0250467882,
0.0011035932,
0.0553225577,
-0.0650849715,
0.0217532981,
-0.0117190732,
-0.0025738124,
0.0248877965,
-0.0103342189,
-0.0269551463,
0.0366242304,
-0.0018410122,
0.0487549268,
-0.0179502051,
0.0438724533,
0.0298693161,
-0.0069675092,
-0.032186944,
0.0076692393,
-0.050337594,
-0.0684935749,
-0.0222021732,
0.0037492141,
0.0483024046,
-0.0376510099,
-0.0195824392,
-0.025838187,
-0.0151544036,
-0.0274702553,
-0.0170607883,
0.0188671649,
-0.0174534824,
0.0305742752,
0.0631584823,
0.0040308824,
-0.0013039326,
0.0778821409,
0.0023938019,
0.0645431876,
0.002932555,
-0.0371044725,
-0.0178547576,
-0.0076591913,
0.064128466,
0.0287764817,
-0.04257017,
0.0112105319,
-0.0296226293,
-0.0216893051,
0.0008425546,
-0.0098176738,
-0.0416110493,
-0.0296042766,
0.0587494597,
0.1022413895,
0.001270555,
-0.0320192538,
-0.0395139754,
-0.0141198533,
-0.0305668302,
-0.0306794923,
-0.0044310843,
-6.492355951e-33,
-0.035597641,
0.0031449089,
0.0357582681,
-0.0323257409,
0.0098635685,
0.006457895,
-0.0149615714,
-0.0284924228,
-0.0294406265,
0.0031227788,
-0.0469549522,
0.0416471846,
0.0155716529,
0.007842619,
0.0120702274,
-0.0220873188,
0.0551376492,
0.0108141964,
-0.043511834,
0.0224423055,
0.0347598121,
0.0518593602,
0.0174380895,
-0.0397414528,
0.0137604279,
-0.0081463773,
0.0057624872,
0.0599845238,
-0.0205965675,
0.0741693452,
-0.0115826428,
0.0312547907,
0.0169521794,
-0.03800359,
0.0066917576,
0.0093893586,
-0.0861300528,
-0.0185977742,
0.0315393247,
0.0056067584,
-0.0296720006,
-0.0330928341,
0.0291091278,
-0.0267190598,
0.0012377088,
0.0043307175,
0.0338383615,
-0.0074117612,
-0.0297700018,
-0.0281111449,
-0.0193514023,
0.0182422362,
-0.002604075,
-0.0467402376,
0.0360848159,
0.0268706847,
-0.0017318374,
0.0420725308,
-0.0401069298,
0.0161198694,
-0.0044380967,
0.0803545415,
0.0405619517,
0.0279594529,
0.0110774459,
0.0299521163,
0.0085097756,
0.0043185432,
0.0169862509,
-0.0299756061,
0.021212792,
0.0447134003,
-0.0098093878,
-0.0048555695,
0.0224459246,
0.0093135703,
-0.0438455641,
0.0236608759,
0.0195553135,
0.0851845294,
0.0184840113,
0.0365479402,
-0.0733087361,
-0.0033618901,
-0.0471555181,
0.0076304493,
-0.0606179461,
0.0043847365,
0.0330862962,
0.0540102012,
-0.0091605131,
-0.0250478014,
0.0358431265,
-0.0063133091,
-0.0282426197,
0.0419934578,
0.0017676146,
-0.0078256642,
-0.0014871971,
0.0143024717,
-0.0582563579,
-0.0361055247,
0.0284725372,
-0.0202666633,
-0.0220062248,
0.0138651356,
0.0110463714,
0.0147069842,
-0.0679256618,
-0.0206213947,
-0.0239159856,
0.0048495508,
-0.0313754529,
-0.0110847587,
0.0164763853,
0.0287595727,
-0.0020905221,
0.0670471862,
0.0247529801,
-0.0354853272,
-0.042248942,
-0.0417176709,
-0.012075481,
0.0020228978,
0.0030089866,
0.0237424336,
-0.0398586467,
0.0046765697,
-0.0087426426,
-0.035054706,
-0.0024932413,
0.0483554937,
2.673e-7,
0.0241986383,
0.0878884047,
-0.0127365347,
0.0862087011,
-0.01526001,
0.0131596131,
-0.0356664434,
0.0084262146,
0.0342629291,
-0.0312787145,
-0.0035651955,
0.0411563814,
0.0449597053,
0.0067861197,
-0.0880603418,
-0.0099979332,
-0.0374475718,
-0.0109479595,
-0.0874183774,
-0.0589683503,
0.026387224,
0.0938005298,
-0.0215972904,
0.0188196544,
-0.021782022,
-0.0612324439,
0.0583020225,
-0.0076760165,
-0.0185596589,
0.0295441337,
0.0547458716,
0.0483776852,
0.0134755531,
0.0002752,
-0.0004094034,
0.019222714,
0.0285263024,
0.0747118145,
-0.0002418555,
-0.0056635817,
-0.0042520673,
-0.0335853696,
-0.0134365652,
-0.0654463023,
0.067266278,
-0.0217047669,
0.0322220586,
0.019327784,
-0.0002415557,
-0.0088986345,
0.0194566473,
-0.0318543576,
-0.0268557761,
0.0060372539,
0.0102697266,
-0.0148957735,
-0.0173919778,
-0.0807710588,
0.0087978346,
0.0210423339,
-0.0195126049,
-0.0107292691,
-0.0657467619,
0.0197787732,
-0.0216158032,
-0.0367557853,
0.0055222739,
2.45911857e-34,
0.0401436538,
0.0107896654,
-0.0036045189,
0.0144236954,
0.0450097024,
-0.0189890917,
-0.0496031716,
0.0399715602,
0.0084552765,
-0.1143990979,
0.0059611201
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06526v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06526v1 | MetaHate: A Dataset for Unifying Efforts on Hate Speech Detection | 2024-01-12T11:54:53 | 2024-01-12T11:54:53 | Paloma Piot, Patricia Martín-Rodilla, Javier Parapar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SI | Hate speech represents a pervasive and detrimental form of online discourse,
often manifested through an array of slurs, from hateful tweets to defamatory
posts. As such speech proliferates, it connects people globally and poses
significant social, psychological, and occasionally physical threats to
targeted individuals and communities. Current computational linguistic
approaches for tackling this phenomenon rely on labelled social media datasets
for training. For unifying efforts, our study advances in the critical need for
a comprehensive meta-collection, advocating for an extensive dataset to help
counteract this problem effectively. We scrutinized over 60 datasets,
selectively integrating those pertinent into MetaHate. This paper offers a
detailed examination of existing collections, highlighting their strengths and
limitations. Our findings contribute to a deeper understanding of the existing
datasets, paving the way for training more robust and adaptable models. These
enhanced models are essential for effectively combating the dynamic and complex
nature of hate speech in the digital realm. | [
0.0649965629,
0.0761093199,
-0.0181240086,
0.0400930569,
-0.0179367587,
0.0419499986,
0.0294838902,
0.0220262855,
-0.0093869772,
-0.0598060712,
-0.019457791,
-0.0054515665,
-0.0061025964,
0.0213335566,
0.000383263,
-0.0493776202,
0.0406085551,
0.0488083623,
0.0110588809,
-0.0208419748,
0.0775757805,
0.0285751447,
-0.0200291779,
0.0239268132,
-0.0718343854,
0.0048501072,
0.0480520464,
-0.0077763344,
0.0336690135,
-0.0046682879,
0.0616338924,
0.0431608707,
0.0191662908,
0.0736422092,
0.000001768,
-0.0415972397,
0.0300145671,
-0.025876049,
-0.0097105224,
-0.0557092056,
0.0853524134,
-0.0599959157,
-0.003405245,
0.0285525508,
-0.0137227047,
0.002896345,
0.0698769912,
0.0345108919,
0.0590992086,
0.0502929688,
-0.0125636645,
-0.0467635132,
0.0189102162,
0.0091145691,
-0.0129510406,
0.0517659225,
0.0221458096,
-0.0459847413,
-0.0650576204,
-0.0113865947,
-0.0001346964,
0.0030836856,
0.0089627495,
0.0406252444,
-0.0036083711,
-0.0323272757,
-0.0488236584,
-0.0348196365,
-0.0151328305,
0.077847518,
-0.0393368192,
-0.0208452642,
0.0089550968,
-0.0108409841,
-0.0390734449,
-0.009726516,
-0.0143378284,
0.0115185706,
-0.034598019,
0.0234141629,
0.0000875338,
0.0226447191,
0.0559008159,
0.0772610754,
0.0463490747,
0.042231977,
-0.026536189,
-0.0271322913,
0.0102674589,
-0.0166246872,
-0.0160434432,
0.0364820771,
-0.0038185483,
-0.0291925855,
-0.0039442941,
0.0285433587,
-0.0628721789,
-0.05942633,
0.014138299,
-0.0498041026,
0.0395926572,
0.0211080089,
-0.0243252628,
0.0060962019,
0.0208832286,
0.002557101,
0.013237902,
0.0092712799,
0.0195994731,
-0.0003926137,
-0.0528652295,
0.0207935199,
-0.0025207414,
-0.0144020636,
0.0121978298,
0.0556512699,
-0.0495065041,
-0.0226347651,
-0.0672100931,
-0.0165535603,
-0.0133944759,
0.0052798721,
-0.0011821106,
-0.0126465298,
-0.0094589638,
-0.0039880746,
-0.0348009318,
0.0182492714,
-0.0516640022,
-0.073943831,
0.0088907806,
0.0225772727,
-0.0063675088,
-0.0379453897,
0.0146810366,
0.0574467704,
0.0322216563,
-0.0409757085,
-0.019550126,
-0.0372726209,
-0.0270022396,
-0.0172349494,
0.0243857522,
-0.0607017018,
0.0615553185,
-0.0129501717,
-0.026383508,
-0.0644420534,
-0.0012246739,
0.0223075692,
-0.0318960734,
0.0720797852,
-0.0178414937,
-0.0073518655,
0.0442490093,
0.0181834269,
0.005740073,
0.0670291483,
0.0185581334,
0.0260444786,
0.0662153736,
0.0002425086,
0.0075940709,
0.0593681559,
0.0575680286,
0.0209744815,
-0.0401955917,
0.03271202,
-0.0341966562,
-0.0496351123,
-0.0156734325,
0.026972346,
-0.0007004855,
-0.073695004,
0.0336100869,
0.0695539489,
-0.0390715636,
-0.0074806106,
0.0545478202,
0.0306090228,
-0.0103564113,
-0.0724170357,
-0.052696988,
-0.047580976,
-0.0307836533,
-0.0584358796,
0.0123040993,
0.0586771332,
-0.009846922,
-0.0264765453,
-0.0392566212,
-0.0026347025,
0.0259123147,
-0.0368861891,
0.0222395733,
0.0018058086,
0.0218370538,
0.0286772586,
0.0514845774,
-0.0238826647,
0.0090409331,
-0.0156728961,
0.0024343024,
0.0532516092,
0.01351404,
-0.0221639108,
-0.0062739365,
-0.0675849319,
0.0361127667,
0.0504870601,
-0.0082406644,
-0.0070291306,
0.0327843502,
-0.0212797076,
-0.0070996955,
0.0439640321,
-0.001288538,
-0.0001567401,
0.1027007103,
-0.0004974791,
0.0090021826,
0.0328664146,
-0.0372794196,
0.0269808061,
0.0297088102,
-0.0095586125,
0.0022121863,
0.0100006228,
0.0703725368,
0.01775443,
-0.0334145427,
-0.0897595957,
0.0155298859,
0.0094626816,
-0.0327863358,
0.0091232769,
-0.0227755941,
-0.0057519493,
0.0485555232,
-0.0529715568,
-0.0226675365,
0.0638255849,
-0.0317524001,
0.0241795685,
0.059479177,
-0.0305347964,
-0.009296461,
-0.0037158027,
-0.0546377711,
-0.0684432238,
0.0568963923,
0.0302831456,
0.0690528229,
-0.0296650268,
-0.0241433997,
0.0216892865,
-0.0614122972,
0.0452076979,
0.0319933221,
-0.0358166434,
-0.0336746313,
-0.0448203757,
0.0408065394,
-0.0094672767,
0.0124906972,
-0.0408678092,
0.0103025567,
-0.0633906052,
-0.0075688967,
-0.0289170127,
-0.015409559,
0.0221242439,
0.0027725173,
-0.0376316085,
0.0093156993,
0.0139085939,
-0.0349100232,
0.0644671395,
0.0263014957,
0.0119639365,
-0.0679127797,
-0.0028756813,
-0.0294750445,
-0.0327616669,
0.0001386074,
0.0101664569,
-0.0050084121,
-0.0568001755,
0.0797926486,
-0.0210343078,
-0.0357328206,
0.0092519568,
-0.0169131551,
-0.0421569012,
0.0250886604,
0.0218321308,
-0.0334051438,
0.0020856638,
0.0582146905,
0.0865322724,
0.0187178887,
0.0005165415,
-0.0133433435,
-0.0021814962,
-0.0257074293,
0.0264236908,
-0.0208880864,
-0.029289782,
-0.0006230621,
0.0833545998,
0.0434272848,
0.0064684073,
-0.0445418693,
0.0299553536,
-0.0495324098,
-0.0459374748,
-0.0346243158,
-0.0383433774,
-0.018509822,
-0.0274292026,
-0.0698781535,
-0.0684656873,
0.0656677857,
0.0113116689,
0.019866446,
-0.0120872073,
-0.03395316,
0.0007207369,
0.036115367,
0.012069013,
0.028952945,
-0.031179836,
0.0119701559,
0.0281640682,
-0.0300013069,
0.0277664345,
-0.0069595356,
-0.0357646048,
-0.010218936,
0.0275133606,
-0.0041026217,
-0.0317166485,
-0.0537037961,
-0.0542010851,
-0.0636686683,
-0.0363269821,
-0.0033198919,
-0.0076559605,
-0.0197348241,
0.0003777251,
0.0305545758,
-0.0259753298,
0.0074343155,
0.0033013595,
0.0363623425,
-0.0341468826,
0.0125914831,
-0.0010544085,
0.0046428759,
0.0153218061,
-0.0175669882,
0.0406018831,
-0.0030896761,
-0.0053385664,
0.000227188,
0.020679893,
0.0166975297,
0.0261339247,
0.0308251549,
-0.0240840036,
0.0095556527,
0.0107725989,
0.0179583132,
0.0825871155,
0.0293941405,
-0.0175072327,
-0.0143078845,
0.011312237,
0.0186977051,
0.0159312952,
-0.0405457392,
-0.0937845185,
-0.0302844215,
-0.0367835201,
0.0381320938,
-0.0814481601,
-0.03388815,
-0.0091153868,
-0.0415483974,
0.010223805,
-0.0168619957,
-0.0386936218,
-0.0129364021,
0.0023891863,
0.0216797087,
-0.0215227101,
0.0275514834,
-0.0558789074,
0.0141978338,
-0.0010887113,
0.0072877696,
-0.1018324867,
-0.0187268909,
0.0272051208,
0.0004842856,
0.0378894061,
0.0104793748,
0.0400837474,
-0.0357880369,
0.0044866302,
0.0296455361,
-0.0027111603,
-0.0238065477,
-0.0702826828,
0.0692399815,
-0.0136920949,
-0.0467731766,
-0.0167577025,
0.0560962111,
-0.0335859358,
-0.0176867805,
0.05004723,
0.0305640418,
0.0311278924,
0.0205897968,
-0.072304599,
0.0334273987,
-0.00184932,
0.0583719313,
0.0285151992,
-0.0499718674,
0.0396574773,
-0.0567456335,
-0.0184643324,
-0.0285831615,
-0.0774874091,
-0.0022057011,
-0.0253606178,
-0.0242796876,
-0.0135020716,
-0.0292642172,
0.0428983532,
0.0001299931,
0.0206101593,
-0.0240765158,
-0.0028984542,
-0.0139498962,
-0.0758136809,
0.0212022029,
-0.0046624769,
0.0302327722,
-0.01520753,
-0.0041015688,
-0.0132495891,
-0.0219520498,
-0.0217663702,
0.0426970273,
-0.0652309209,
-0.0376814269,
0.0670564547,
0.0393157974,
0.0110034319,
0.0173803288,
-0.0100327674,
-0.0538291112,
0.0742382333,
0.0729094073,
-0.0246964153,
-0.0227126125,
0.0490039289,
0.0038510857,
0.0189304501,
0.0010874156,
0.0060608024,
0.043262396,
0.0486602746,
-0.0611439161,
-0.0576025136,
0.031579975,
-0.0191025268,
-0.0187923815,
0.0652367845,
-0.0022764367,
-0.065341346,
-0.0424649976,
-0.0442571975,
0.0104726758,
-0.0532158166,
-0.0053074043,
0.0175003838,
0.0050695916,
-0.005691058,
-0.0582411289,
-0.0215064734,
-0.0605321936,
0.0224187654,
-0.016101744,
0.046173986,
0.0362588167,
0.0359470993,
0.0262159463,
0.0063513936,
0.0000939228,
0.0355703644,
-0.0140883699,
-0.0354538746,
0.0041830051,
-0.0023180463,
0.0030882438,
0.0071721869,
0.0246819295,
-0.0165871121,
0.0282009505,
-0.0017338429,
-0.0506833531,
-0.0169963557,
-0.0226364359,
-0.0037448416,
0.0378204435,
0.0185180251,
-0.0131483115,
-0.0165112223,
0.0038299905,
-0.0300587416,
-0.0493935943,
-0.0022103896,
0.0391407348,
-0.0408486575,
0.0196872931,
0.0327273905,
-0.0090015447,
0.0298623592,
0.08210738,
-0.0347700939,
-0.019361278,
0.0011271742,
0.00394066,
0.0284110606,
0.0358419567,
0.0141990483,
-0.0465889573,
-0.0440411307,
0.0307140555,
-0.0563133843,
0.0180426408,
0.0198538527,
0.0062854616,
0.0606255084,
0.0052693882,
0.0254463814,
-0.0063286959,
0.0101109715,
0.0154578574,
-0.08378499,
0.0207103342,
-5.403288721e-33,
-0.0062026973,
-0.0149543714,
-0.0005996725,
-0.0104370518,
0.0033258784,
-0.0135495253,
0.0518690161,
0.0031486033,
-0.0213430785,
0.0179026444,
0.0037510956,
0.0486240461,
0.0004477725,
0.0221339799,
0.0025838187,
-0.0312387962,
0.0033397591,
-0.0387487896,
-0.0229071546,
-0.0016869734,
0.0568180978,
-0.0138223665,
0.0345819332,
-0.0539705008,
0.0455336943,
0.0189959053,
-0.021055989,
0.0286804661,
0.0162334051,
0.0739812851,
-0.0166851878,
0.1271920204,
0.0516971238,
0.0036067236,
-0.0060684225,
0.0477771275,
-0.0384894833,
-0.0111807929,
0.0201749373,
0.0002705985,
0.0443095602,
0.0003230368,
0.0202226583,
0.0106638419,
-0.0334448516,
-0.0240978096,
0.038764149,
-0.043729756,
0.0193716157,
-0.0194951892,
-0.0575225465,
0.0406564884,
-0.0530430228,
0.0149117606,
-0.0066700284,
0.0399682187,
0.0457896702,
0.0114206821,
-0.0574445054,
0.0463281609,
-0.0142570296,
-0.0074752583,
0.0160935279,
-0.0071508186,
0.0202138964,
0.0614796281,
0.0167453736,
0.0232578367,
-0.0072934092,
0.0368479155,
0.0148128113,
0.0401246808,
0.0255344994,
0.0895181969,
0.0184874907,
-0.0986267254,
-0.0439713113,
-0.0016394045,
0.0594814979,
0.0019079399,
-0.012713559,
-0.0532975234,
-0.0398946851,
-0.0401641987,
-0.0174049009,
-0.0617584847,
-0.0142007917,
-0.008400023,
0.0081122974,
-0.0231364407,
-0.018593099,
-0.0020374842,
0.0119167631,
-0.0184827466,
0.0062808464,
0.0483039729,
-0.0238456242,
0.0029307816,
0.0435643122,
0.0505504273,
-0.0308025926,
-0.0282561053,
0.0187596902,
-0.0116635654,
0.0351840183,
-0.0357165374,
0.077250123,
0.040956866,
-0.0522123501,
0.0102402894,
-0.0010602489,
0.0700059757,
-0.0571488664,
0.0298251491,
0.0019089765,
0.0550258495,
-0.0140331686,
-0.0300971884,
0.0242274869,
-0.0637855455,
0.0035072642,
0.0146086598,
-0.0499736667,
-0.0049672113,
0.0055788485,
-0.0165216289,
-0.0190043747,
-0.0228468478,
0.0345896259,
-0.0755101219,
0.0235152729,
-0.0569411218,
2.324e-7,
0.0042887605,
0.0377328098,
0.0013627344,
0.0019859273,
0.0367724337,
0.0201934539,
0.0530201569,
0.0192922633,
-0.0275801383,
-0.0194888096,
-0.0049130176,
0.060116794,
0.0294866432,
0.0502048917,
-0.0078029884,
-0.0152417757,
-0.063414678,
0.0017575549,
-0.0672983602,
0.0225192327,
-0.0194633491,
0.0734618604,
0.0824752003,
-0.0523565225,
-0.0461441092,
0.0016360644,
-0.0103371833,
-0.0527213812,
-0.0094559388,
-0.0228869822,
0.0524866246,
0.0325774103,
0.0195568614,
-0.005601462,
-0.0224184263,
0.0285211615,
-0.0113335764,
0.0331073031,
0.038202174,
0.0108681815,
0.0011573897,
-0.0205714088,
-0.0151133584,
-0.0137507878,
0.0434689522,
-0.0031198454,
-0.0160229728,
-0.0496325418,
-0.0112065589,
-0.0130148884,
0.0365724526,
-0.032578215,
-0.0037744862,
-0.0206725821,
0.0476766229,
-0.0348461829,
-0.0040485086,
-0.0785713121,
0.0114522539,
-0.0114250546,
-0.038454324,
-0.0378459133,
-0.0124228913,
-0.0066438089,
0.0527412742,
0.0358927213,
0.054149352,
1.596107007e-34,
0.0017912862,
-0.0298797637,
-0.0062026801,
-0.0650440082,
0.0352654308,
-0.0022793489,
-0.0255336948,
-0.0172195006,
0.0402759649,
-0.0124886269,
0.0133322123
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06509v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06509v3 | AntEval: Evaluation of Social Interaction Competencies in LLM-Driven Agents | 2024-01-12T11:18:00 | 2024-03-05T12:07:04 | Yuanzhi Liang, Linchao Zhu, Yi Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated their ability to replicate
human behaviors across a wide range of scenarios. However, their capability in
handling complex, multi-character social interactions has yet to be fully
explored, primarily due to the absence of robust, quantitative evaluation
methods. This gap has slowed the development of agents proficient in more
nuanced interactions beyond simple exchanges, for example, small talk. To
address this challenge, we introduce the Multi-Agent Interaction Evaluation
Framework (AntEval), encompassing a novel interaction framework and evaluation
methods. The interaction framework aims to foster an complex interaction
environment that bolsters information exchange and intention expression within
social interactions. Furthermore, we introduce evaluation methods, including
two metrics: Information Exchanging Precision (IEP) and Interaction
Expressiveness Gap (IEG), designed for the quantitative and objective
assessment of agents' interaction competencies. Our findings highlight the
utility of these evaluative methods and show significant potential for
improving LLMs' ability to construct agents that interact in a more natural
manner with human-like intricacy. | [
0.0455227345,
0.0010090375,
-0.0362989493,
0.0422224365,
-0.0104672592,
0.0152417729,
0.0058541084,
-0.0027440591,
0.0169727542,
0.0028168783,
-0.0615480617,
-0.0749555454,
0.0357759893,
0.0319567323,
0.0288226046,
-0.029977873,
0.0293324348,
-0.0110024121,
0.0359635688,
0.0000766182,
0.0074310368,
-0.0095511377,
-0.0117376363,
0.0426918752,
-0.010167703,
-0.0063043241,
-0.0511809736,
-0.0161577314,
0.0502074063,
-0.0110246595,
-0.0096395314,
0.0258881282,
0.0424143188,
0.0209846832,
0.0000019442,
-0.0715367943,
0.0416076109,
-0.0145029053,
-0.0185393728,
-0.0180578846,
0.0811017081,
0.0113792904,
-0.0008429354,
-0.0096926391,
-0.08474347,
-0.0103251087,
0.021426782,
0.0101360194,
0.0611830316,
0.0586755462,
-0.0010221865,
0.0150961066,
0.0016847072,
-0.0230527483,
-0.0084978798,
-0.0492354371,
0.0132768396,
0.0120178703,
0.0280695148,
-0.0134004988,
-0.0044272933,
0.0260479171,
0.0215784777,
-0.0583155565,
0.0457354337,
0.0183488131,
-0.0032959853,
-0.061737664,
-0.0287457407,
0.084852837,
0.0507112145,
0.0307045449,
-0.0227461364,
-0.0087759094,
0.0346170254,
0.0034437429,
-0.0116588632,
-0.0213467162,
0.0368749984,
0.0025588886,
-0.0282112006,
0.0184920486,
0.0247303601,
0.016208671,
0.015224616,
0.0683261901,
-0.0194608513,
0.0027124474,
-0.0075082127,
-0.0384503789,
0.0141888876,
-0.0620841496,
-0.0203779098,
0.0582738928,
-0.0435007587,
0.0188557617,
-0.0230204258,
0.0539601259,
0.0263601597,
-0.0422874615,
0.0328875519,
0.0183773395,
0.035358876,
0.0241428949,
0.0178976022,
0.060123127,
0.0337595083,
-0.0058030928,
0.0147990733,
0.0073334402,
-0.0240146481,
0.0010285039,
-0.0082477136,
0.0197341759,
-0.048999954,
-0.0326709747,
0.0102946479,
0.0678205416,
-0.0445636436,
0.0341504328,
0.0015655088,
0.0022702052,
0.0025404207,
0.0087021766,
-0.0455046296,
-0.0091173341,
-0.0437309556,
0.0237326249,
0.0218625776,
-0.1015187353,
0.0046138316,
-0.0098464796,
0.0228499584,
-0.0179450177,
-0.0206032787,
0.107913062,
-0.0049119294,
-0.0555946641,
0.006877319,
-0.0015391349,
-0.0077157617,
-0.0937801749,
-0.0259978734,
-0.0201252457,
0.0531486049,
-0.0314291716,
-0.0266672187,
-0.0586759858,
0.0269424357,
-0.0333016813,
0.0015505924,
0.0490934104,
-0.0296773352,
0.0437792838,
0.0113776159,
0.0378038771,
0.0008466078,
0.046022784,
0.060761787,
0.013175386,
0.050054308,
0.0003963715,
0.0302614979,
0.040073052,
-0.0131577188,
0.0214945991,
0.0436716564,
-0.0069247494,
-0.0113279158,
0.0515174195,
0.0418778807,
0.0496189967,
-0.0252599604,
-0.0267991796,
0.0798439458,
0.0515727401,
0.003375917,
0.0095312381,
0.0561035573,
0.0680385828,
0.026195243,
-0.003819051,
-0.0252367575,
0.0477412641,
-0.0004872441,
-0.0178185143,
-0.0151888467,
0.0299302842,
-0.0176296122,
-0.0372569188,
0.0145413792,
0.0157557372,
0.0767241046,
-0.0090045091,
-0.0208730493,
-0.0117214527,
-0.0370277315,
-0.0037773766,
0.0285848584,
-0.0664604604,
0.0291154329,
-0.0481188595,
0.0143960631,
0.098479487,
0.0212376378,
0.003389867,
-0.0363761634,
0.0152503857,
-0.0147245778,
0.0605304614,
0.0222124066,
-0.0552647784,
0.0676529258,
-0.0194747057,
0.0214003064,
-0.0179382525,
-0.00180426,
0.0396161303,
-0.0159059409,
0.0197559074,
-0.0068727196,
0.0056726858,
-0.0054318067,
0.024271613,
-0.036357116,
0.0010415618,
-0.0572852343,
0.00798441,
0.0345678963,
0.019270692,
-0.0458417349,
-0.0358069241,
0.0045828852,
0.0284561627,
-0.0049347398,
0.0347880833,
0.0120416908,
0.0075949938,
0.046994932,
0.0151808169,
-0.0330068879,
0.0068663084,
0.0079556797,
-0.0101629756,
0.0267129354,
-0.0325914212,
0.0663489103,
-0.0261370353,
0.0274789967,
-0.0373598523,
0.0333805643,
0.0180005599,
-0.0049944329,
-0.0030157713,
-0.0270450469,
0.0328934789,
0.0437853523,
-0.0200539995,
-0.0274377707,
-0.0125755584,
0.0141754383,
0.0189178288,
0.0163981002,
0.020064801,
0.0494258367,
-0.0493653901,
-0.0750667602,
-0.0753183365,
-0.0318340808,
0.0009998808,
-0.0063181217,
0.0054498282,
0.0080204904,
-0.0214571916,
0.031555675,
-0.0360226892,
0.0326272063,
0.0244928896,
-0.0098302811,
0.0514470078,
0.0295939241,
-0.096586585,
-0.0624092706,
0.0460374914,
0.0049737031,
0.0075288741,
0.0099698436,
0.0008960373,
-0.0090992609,
0.0175468773,
-0.0607245713,
0.0163236577,
-0.0517186448,
-0.1066384315,
0.0189847611,
0.0237770304,
-0.0283531323,
0.0465746373,
0.0296269897,
0.0487627909,
0.0162738264,
-0.0689767525,
-0.0531524494,
0.0302652903,
-0.0213600658,
0.041911304,
-0.1119120196,
-0.034560468,
-0.0075017549,
0.0232398808,
-0.0265998151,
0.0406071059,
-0.0660617575,
-0.0046797087,
0.0415536277,
-0.118297711,
0.025693614,
-0.0212666057,
-0.0386301205,
0.0324356221,
-0.0332537852,
-0.0245723948,
0.0552856959,
-0.0566958077,
-0.0611811318,
0.0145812985,
-0.0188039802,
-0.0231823958,
0.0980114564,
-0.0271445531,
-0.004070872,
-0.0280327927,
-0.0144329397,
-0.0302899089,
-0.0185970142,
0.0001803936,
-0.0083929626,
0.0263692159,
-0.053112343,
-0.0171601009,
0.02611899,
0.0085885702,
0.0062828022,
0.0060521946,
-0.0171974543,
0.0276649371,
0.037991263,
-0.0665286481,
-0.012254131,
0.0167072173,
0.0272181183,
-0.0354708843,
-0.0099851042,
0.0028422554,
-0.0366239995,
-0.0245732088,
0.0504639149,
0.058262717,
0.0042810007,
-0.0187008418,
0.074666895,
0.0270657912,
-0.0087746633,
0.0074360371,
-0.0093726516,
0.0131905805,
0.0283712056,
0.0171688031,
-0.0014986156,
0.0234465748,
0.0747420862,
-0.0324911103,
-0.0018396878,
0.1075568721,
-0.0059940773,
-0.0038825916,
0.0204715766,
-0.0418617129,
0.0206374712,
-0.0116695948,
0.0011362128,
-0.0419753268,
0.0047120377,
0.005978974,
-0.0222717524,
-0.0376392417,
-0.0469681062,
0.0011564402,
-0.0853833109,
0.0433210209,
0.0073236953,
-0.0313204825,
-0.0113625834,
-0.0281487871,
0.0317837112,
-0.0035763218,
0.0466171764,
0.0129882647,
0.0120118149,
-0.0448299311,
-0.0057778494,
-0.0322777219,
-0.0441182405,
0.0515709668,
-0.0587986633,
0.1017873287,
0.0317616798,
0.0747854561,
-0.0243051685,
-0.051051721,
-0.0341894701,
0.0378941819,
0.0240005068,
0.0019844132,
0.0245028548,
-0.0387766361,
0.0093645891,
-0.023385223,
-0.0244602282,
-0.007262297,
-0.002681403,
-0.0066420701,
0.0415534563,
-0.0463660657,
-0.0134918904,
0.0294636618,
0.0286024567,
0.0392972082,
0.0429243147,
0.0239439905,
-0.0585424714,
-0.0084345024,
0.0082213329,
-0.0321463123,
-0.0074708671,
-0.0463355035,
-0.0083323289,
0.0225194208,
-0.06945768,
-0.0407994315,
-0.1074419767,
0.0365714617,
0.009825292,
-0.0020291097,
-0.0131559456,
0.0012522005,
0.020418046,
0.0258668866,
-0.0018745302,
0.0060349512,
0.0479981862,
-0.0138711333,
-0.0024561605,
0.0011972846,
-0.0605259538,
0.0063133053,
-0.0081145428,
-0.0376005545,
-0.0668382794,
0.0168161914,
0.033587154,
0.0263643265,
0.0328350402,
-0.0145522133,
-0.0571666881,
-0.0191760398,
-0.0171230454,
-0.0377773196,
0.0817457139,
0.0191790331,
0.0031225639,
0.001909965,
0.0454173647,
-0.0127646187,
0.0147516476,
-0.0237165056,
0.0157781374,
-0.0285799224,
-0.1065159589,
-0.0297246538,
0.0064840685,
-0.0159172881,
0.0150089609,
-0.0283594597,
-0.0162800718,
-0.0223566592,
-0.0376352891,
0.0025684624,
-0.0698065609,
-0.036519859,
-0.0082029151,
0.0440245718,
0.0227886271,
-0.0244312696,
-0.0535655729,
0.0182502829,
0.0076430705,
0.0385921225,
0.0038516871,
0.0053747981,
-0.005058086,
0.0419410355,
-0.0139310844,
-0.0092593953,
-0.0324969254,
0.0120276222,
0.0480313078,
0.0494295098,
-0.0101593686,
-0.0549931265,
0.0195037462,
0.0477575175,
-0.0432126075,
-0.0261989627,
0.0009040246,
0.0466977805,
0.0292337593,
0.0664725229,
0.0707374886,
-0.0417556688,
0.0334502496,
-0.011611999,
0.0344593339,
-0.0229917802,
-0.0697268546,
0.0318198502,
0.0278015416,
-0.0236007832,
0.0175044574,
0.0026328964,
-0.03028748,
0.0337758176,
-0.0322168991,
-0.0047235428,
-0.0082729375,
-0.0478550903,
0.0409532599,
0.017904602,
-0.018587511,
-0.0285337027,
-0.0774130225,
-0.0486785397,
0.0015178497,
0.0565906838,
-0.0162274074,
-0.0393050052,
0.0222310424,
0.0340832733,
-0.0073575182,
-0.0169089306,
-0.053448569,
-0.0562151931,
-0.0216787755,
0.0341736302,
-0.0305324886,
-5.829874518e-33,
-0.038775783,
-0.025702022,
0.0230159294,
0.012293743,
-0.0921891555,
-0.0272256006,
-0.0545583293,
0.0185106415,
-0.0479121991,
0.02086371,
-0.0025028924,
0.0276276264,
0.000929569,
-0.0396384895,
-0.0104197878,
-0.0068121357,
0.0193899106,
0.0115923071,
-0.0093344124,
0.0248246901,
-0.0344453305,
-0.0024372991,
0.0102239968,
-0.0770791546,
0.0541337356,
-0.0050457967,
-0.043631088,
0.0231943876,
0.0156530254,
0.0261485036,
-0.0004153339,
0.0134790828,
0.0059891064,
0.0097618531,
0.007259584,
0.0153209893,
-0.0023282177,
-0.0232657138,
0.0356664918,
0.0098251374,
-0.0425299406,
-0.0265095457,
-0.006117186,
-0.0152532579,
-0.0617321394,
0.0066790539,
0.0142850373,
-0.0043115965,
0.0345173106,
0.0353633687,
-0.0762513354,
0.0215644985,
-0.0167478509,
-0.038857419,
0.0014204019,
-0.0041008177,
-0.0011143479,
-0.0310786869,
-0.0558322035,
0.0140235666,
-0.0249112099,
-0.0257211942,
0.0422673337,
0.0122636613,
0.0464130007,
0.083001636,
0.0532806963,
0.0612009913,
0.0333394893,
-0.0179178566,
0.0264879894,
0.0709096417,
-0.0201120377,
0.0969112217,
-0.076066725,
-0.0069802143,
0.0041800584,
0.0176517293,
0.0542731248,
0.0423218533,
-0.0304578617,
0.0130220521,
-0.0534455366,
-0.009753705,
-0.0232964307,
0.0344313271,
0.0090372991,
-0.0751899034,
0.0057409024,
-0.0280303638,
0.0122124711,
-0.0184722748,
0.0359979123,
-0.0322788619,
-0.01980347,
-0.0145754963,
-0.0368892401,
0.0617600307,
0.0159520358,
-0.0154115101,
-0.0150929242,
-0.0540268719,
0.0041996324,
0.0137605248,
0.0458150208,
0.0119699705,
-0.0202211421,
0.0494173393,
0.0036228448,
-0.0152208619,
-0.0149302194,
0.0276892055,
0.0155098438,
-0.0023654967,
-0.0067738388,
-0.03573291,
-0.050683111,
0.004888894,
-0.0165512413,
0.0072805397,
-0.0255735107,
0.0170469619,
0.0029648847,
-0.0136664743,
-0.0485980809,
-0.0035159509,
-0.0439221747,
-0.0025213382,
0.0237336233,
-0.0164553486,
0.0042446316,
-0.0257419385,
2.822e-7,
-0.0335887037,
0.0294816382,
0.0092335781,
0.0410953574,
0.0062257582,
0.0333679803,
-0.0486239977,
0.054276593,
0.0131414449,
-0.0315786861,
0.0487472564,
0.0290758759,
0.0519278646,
0.0190630127,
-0.0603597723,
0.0001278396,
-0.0423076078,
-0.0736535043,
0.011578612,
-0.0370414071,
0.0003213627,
0.0207796302,
0.0402335003,
0.0111657083,
-0.0067593511,
-0.0354778878,
0.0178552754,
-0.0729443133,
-0.0011923715,
0.0612528436,
-0.0246807151,
-0.0282212012,
0.0021600865,
0.0203369539,
0.0274812821,
0.034519311,
-0.0283387806,
0.0925334841,
-0.0421737842,
-0.0124557819,
0.0272488706,
-0.0250663981,
-0.0222718567,
-0.0272906423,
0.0141116055,
-0.013452719,
-0.0422802977,
0.0217706785,
0.0058908667,
-0.0121668363,
-0.0158391669,
-0.0282297395,
-0.028967008,
0.0298184603,
0.0033065602,
-0.0392384827,
0.0025999392,
-0.0223057382,
0.0198876839,
-0.0366329588,
-0.0369678065,
-0.1087420285,
-0.0065305973,
-0.0255574808,
-0.0098377913,
-0.0405543372,
0.0258287247,
1.997028756e-34,
0.0140655031,
-0.0003578062,
0.0105828587,
0.0579624511,
0.0818688795,
0.0240485519,
0.0021675883,
0.0209265109,
0.0567551628,
-0.0611118749,
0.0069332831
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06495v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06495v1 | An investigation of structures responsible for gender bias in BERT and DistilBERT | 2024-01-12T10:42:20 | 2024-01-12T10:42:20 | Thibaud Leteno, Antoine Gourru, Charlotte Laclau, Christophe Gravier | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG | In recent years, large Transformer-based Pre-trained Language Models (PLM)
have changed the Natural Language Processing (NLP) landscape, by pushing the
performance boundaries of the state-of-the-art on a wide variety of tasks.
However, this performance gain goes along with an increase in complexity, and
as a result, the size of such models (up to billions of parameters) represents
a constraint for their deployment on embedded devices or short-inference time
tasks. To cope with this situation, compressed models emerged (e.g.
DistilBERT), democratizing their usage in a growing number of applications that
impact our daily lives. A crucial issue is the fairness of the predictions made
by both PLMs and their distilled counterparts. In this paper, we propose an
empirical exploration of this problem by formalizing two questions: (1) Can we
identify the neural mechanism(s) responsible for gender bias in BERT (and by
extension DistilBERT)? (2) Does distillation tend to accentuate or mitigate
gender bias (e.g. is DistilBERT more prone to gender bias than its uncompressed
version, BERT)? Our findings are the following: (I) one cannot identify a
specific layer that produces bias; (II) every attention head uniformly encodes
bias; except in the context of underrepresented classes with a high imbalance
of the sensitive attribute; (III) this subset of heads is different as we
re-fine tune the network; (IV) bias is more homogeneously produced by the heads
in the distilled model. | [
0.0201897603,
0.052472122,
-0.0348101258,
0.0098115113,
0.0037809107,
0.0091145951,
0.0376282558,
-0.0225198343,
-0.0309611764,
-0.0573647656,
-0.0157194268,
-0.0153417569,
0.0432813242,
-0.0197814628,
0.0341486894,
-0.0347308554,
0.0249072481,
0.0103238095,
0.0227933414,
-0.0347954556,
0.0053767334,
-0.0046077739,
0.0260055233,
0.063304536,
0.0239287931,
-0.0190684553,
0.0147449654,
0.0237946026,
-0.0404315181,
0.0155491857,
0.048783157,
0.0745631605,
0.00070095,
0.034249898,
0.0000018817,
-0.0579208583,
0.0239146892,
0.0252392832,
-0.0325117186,
0.0201678053,
-0.0102091394,
0.0091212811,
-0.0064227558,
0.0209196471,
-0.0142967822,
-0.0319534801,
0.0355166681,
0.0580837727,
0.0355173089,
0.0269896314,
-0.0103367958,
-0.0028939894,
-0.0289881844,
-0.0256954338,
-0.0132917706,
0.0059517575,
0.016745938,
-0.0993501693,
-0.0418272652,
-0.0118953222,
-0.0311723482,
-0.0141895805,
0.0244911406,
0.0429531075,
-0.0066513214,
0.0410668068,
-0.0883614644,
-0.0641657189,
-0.0144316079,
0.0553994477,
-0.0262130871,
-0.0151806502,
0.0134964539,
0.014983099,
0.035500031,
-0.019532457,
-0.0401362889,
0.0324437544,
0.0124102645,
0.0051903958,
-0.0148817673,
-0.0354715437,
0.0427998453,
0.0309588239,
-0.0433812812,
0.0651980862,
0.0220279656,
-0.0459056646,
0.0186640564,
0.0179662984,
-0.0011993479,
-0.060570661,
0.0250961073,
-0.0133813322,
0.019321559,
-0.0336797386,
-0.0367150642,
-0.0314746648,
0.0067671612,
-0.0406806096,
0.013977116,
0.047793407,
-0.0109637771,
-0.0013406512,
-0.0277378131,
0.0390305631,
-0.0253199041,
0.047004912,
-0.0166788567,
-0.0187759288,
-0.0033765035,
-0.0177347679,
-0.0283543915,
0.0092080366,
-0.0387640148,
-0.0023103438,
-0.0122721987,
-0.0028708647,
-0.0283862092,
-0.0390376225,
0.0339615904,
0.0578973293,
-0.0258402154,
0.0248485282,
0.0132815093,
0.0585916862,
-0.0502332076,
0.0280907545,
-0.0110764522,
-0.1076414213,
-0.0314974189,
0.0110196704,
-0.0104114851,
-0.0485040508,
0.0103661781,
0.0137479668,
0.0109061776,
-0.0407703146,
-0.0286032446,
0.0105398102,
-0.021323448,
-0.0348253101,
0.0534101985,
-0.0527007021,
0.0065085599,
0.0532624386,
0.0143243698,
-0.0252136514,
0.0095777242,
0.00964751,
-0.0549311861,
0.0525875464,
0.0536474437,
0.0026862368,
0.0439150408,
0.0200211555,
-0.0077859103,
0.0727892295,
0.0635680929,
0.0297598373,
0.0229339637,
-0.0051144655,
-0.0078600375,
0.0420667566,
0.0643604472,
0.004675894,
-0.0344685204,
0.0000839645,
-0.0534523539,
0.0164927617,
0.0728212222,
0.0264660101,
0.0037529294,
-0.0336811431,
0.100623928,
0.0500174202,
0.0597560517,
0.074110195,
-0.0123983314,
-0.0203845687,
0.0038104798,
0.017510226,
-0.0885117576,
0.0010765039,
-0.0066390806,
-0.0364582054,
-0.0017311696,
0.0362226851,
-0.0375410654,
-0.038614098,
0.0032531612,
0.001968882,
0.00851415,
-0.0044882237,
0.0294159092,
0.0238088686,
-0.0126318038,
0.1186714917,
0.0324643217,
-0.0427224673,
0.0036256632,
-0.0759219676,
0.0049655577,
0.0190485381,
0.0092730736,
-0.0212857574,
-0.0051881582,
-0.0211238898,
-0.0224586111,
0.0252032317,
0.0365107358,
0.0255411416,
0.0394651853,
-0.0370935574,
-0.0395012721,
0.0002256336,
0.0400211178,
0.0035094111,
0.026509108,
0.0373410806,
-0.0036970044,
-0.0584298074,
-0.0342614464,
0.0337971412,
0.0261246357,
-0.0587947592,
0.0228034612,
0.0127641195,
-0.0066833161,
-0.0043747127,
-0.0469922088,
0.0139519423,
0.0207196958,
-0.0364034995,
0.0047878344,
0.0024032216,
-0.0299533326,
-0.0082444297,
0.0126492158,
-0.0778243467,
-0.0328923129,
0.0800621659,
-0.0056853453,
-0.0075147543,
0.0455852225,
-0.0476328507,
0.0345902033,
-0.0109798023,
0.0175322127,
-0.0072817453,
0.0497419685,
-0.0055458522,
0.0213866811,
-0.0267843194,
-0.0442415662,
0.0150969531,
-0.0324946754,
-0.0060567209,
-0.0339969471,
-0.0397649668,
0.024710238,
0.0027656564,
-0.0053444966,
0.0404866859,
-0.040396437,
-0.0094356639,
-0.0229445342,
-0.0693431497,
-0.0124960644,
-0.0276970956,
-0.0026398678,
-0.0027103089,
0.0420898013,
-0.0070000635,
-0.0095975278,
0.0003265004,
-0.0339691304,
-0.0096693523,
0.0370410793,
0.0279135294,
-0.0126943765,
0.0209696125,
-0.0253136251,
-0.0464327224,
-0.028872868,
0.0810664743,
-0.0085122613,
-0.0053153047,
-0.0402259231,
-0.0156554338,
0.0171617679,
0.017024409,
-0.0031673,
-0.0461878628,
0.0186967608,
0.0181769393,
0.056973584,
0.1193117946,
0.028425362,
0.0344519839,
0.0493100546,
0.0193790644,
-0.0642391145,
0.0048768288,
-0.0079130605,
0.0237960555,
-0.0076969145,
-0.0413592346,
-0.007373611,
0.0864482746,
-0.0135933226,
-0.0250502527,
-0.0488698334,
0.0143800136,
-0.0184728913,
-0.0473902188,
0.0046862122,
-0.0209569056,
-0.0083909128,
0.0339072384,
-0.0476681404,
-0.0585005805,
0.0388794504,
-0.0174970534,
-0.0011891209,
-0.0224036537,
0.0005269233,
-0.0225324575,
0.0366198123,
0.0025973795,
0.025476655,
0.017889753,
-0.0211716667,
-0.0990958512,
-0.0213247538,
-0.0009327573,
-0.0285729077,
0.0271342229,
-0.0124403769,
-0.0079852697,
-0.0153630795,
-0.0616449304,
-0.0268878788,
-0.0468472205,
0.0020904555,
0.0180427451,
0.0396899693,
-0.0026179266,
-0.0478164963,
0.0081821792,
-0.0142587787,
0.0492687039,
-0.0199790839,
-0.0040242504,
-0.0130056702,
0.0133154383,
0.0234661866,
0.0189211257,
0.0688907281,
-0.0121951206,
-0.0174119659,
0.0405636951,
0.0249058735,
0.0332708731,
-0.0270902477,
0.0307319071,
0.0630657673,
-0.0492952056,
-0.0259497315,
-0.015570295,
0.0396059901,
-0.0558575056,
0.0048126052,
0.0982972309,
-0.0121346433,
-0.0651059374,
0.0223508365,
0.0023599789,
0.0226607844,
0.026812179,
0.0037651695,
-0.0721649751,
-0.0086034564,
0.0407787785,
0.0172005389,
-0.00565622,
-0.0206823163,
-0.0020333049,
-0.1188595146,
0.0077126031,
-0.0074580912,
0.0227809772,
-0.0309785586,
-0.0362331755,
-0.0283851717,
-0.0308833104,
0.0581444725,
-0.0086616119,
0.0050886241,
0.0095905429,
0.0079932567,
-0.0403244309,
-0.0253208298,
0.0346287712,
-0.0703222826,
0.035500627,
0.079596214,
0.0335580148,
-0.0248619616,
-0.0385182314,
0.0310584716,
-0.0188378394,
0.0093948422,
-0.013813192,
0.0299354345,
-0.0330188274,
-0.0179196615,
-0.0580743998,
0.0403340831,
0.0187529698,
0.0091100652,
-0.0533215664,
0.0193871427,
0.0248447992,
-0.0476334803,
-0.0637215003,
-0.0288370103,
-0.0089762537,
0.0712648928,
0.0302834958,
-0.0379287079,
-0.0808421969,
-0.02296995,
-0.0022661081,
0.0168064795,
-0.0268930942,
0.0347329751,
0.0248651784,
-0.0572795495,
-0.0258063544,
-0.0151608065,
-0.0000326419,
-0.0015466539,
0.0084931916,
-0.0748472959,
0.02795377,
0.0207938589,
-0.0783774108,
0.0585408211,
0.0275791716,
0.0088741686,
-0.0292036701,
-0.0292174723,
-0.0306274742,
-0.0365882404,
-0.0228807423,
0.0183633287,
-0.0540757366,
-0.0540016815,
0.0472642481,
0.0687888488,
0.0270091165,
0.0490542352,
-0.0105738947,
-0.074446559,
0.0625539422,
0.0567873642,
-0.0322636813,
0.038015645,
0.0574612729,
-0.0233187713,
0.0167340785,
0.0520224422,
-0.0353576094,
0.0127890175,
0.013200446,
0.0241524857,
-0.0018499526,
-0.0368438251,
0.011927071,
-0.0027057012,
0.0725614056,
-0.0184004363,
0.0470322222,
-0.0254400801,
0.0137820309,
0.0285374671,
-0.0068024257,
-0.0171707124,
-0.0358468033,
0.0346104316,
0.0414991826,
-0.020760756,
0.0333989449,
0.0119903935,
-0.0136025576,
-0.0527709648,
0.0298810825,
0.0016921603,
0.0081591085,
0.005892084,
0.0191726368,
0.0069178604,
0.0112272315,
-0.0182429999,
0.0292037483,
0.0009805916,
0.0037318412,
0.02092278,
0.0367785357,
-0.0557222925,
0.0215955731,
-0.0832401961,
-0.0413106382,
0.0027404462,
0.0155553175,
0.0051493743,
-0.0314297453,
0.0295519102,
0.00592383,
-0.0201202929,
0.0079037361,
-0.0295146611,
-0.0103100222,
0.0506311804,
0.0260565244,
0.0067510149,
0.0091400547,
-0.0176044498,
0.066156514,
0.0357670113,
0.0857919678,
-0.0235171374,
-0.0383059867,
-0.0050696814,
-0.0527469292,
0.0389170647,
-0.0059880912,
-0.0193426721,
-0.0079764687,
-0.0732862055,
-0.0386981778,
-0.0015068783,
-0.0108902892,
0.0493728854,
-0.0395907052,
-0.0067716148,
0.0482600816,
-0.0141343828,
-0.0755939931,
-0.0052232957,
-0.0138960872,
0.0022924242,
-0.0020480221,
0.0090157297,
-6.419431955e-33,
-0.0103746681,
0.014108343,
-0.0223773737,
-0.031124983,
-0.0338862836,
0.0067950082,
0.0038509932,
-0.0112172272,
-0.0372792482,
0.0192973316,
-0.0460241698,
0.0596116595,
0.0084744906,
0.0210850313,
-0.0035886029,
-0.0244462285,
0.0793357641,
-0.0008073572,
-0.0302877631,
-0.0153789865,
-0.0236370154,
0.049807068,
0.0344223045,
-0.0199893899,
0.0375767723,
-0.02135057,
0.0147707453,
-0.0042973249,
-0.0101391217,
0.0173950512,
-0.0123649314,
0.0481549948,
0.0175947677,
-0.0337352604,
0.0056612063,
0.0718361065,
-0.092451863,
-0.0215073936,
0.0039090412,
0.0459721722,
0.0095496541,
-0.0036598158,
0.0832617506,
0.0336407162,
-0.0408915989,
-0.0341353528,
0.0426934212,
0.0199333932,
0.0194066558,
-0.005694157,
-0.0326526277,
-0.0040887445,
-0.0365594812,
-0.023937026,
0.0082849478,
0.0099168476,
-0.0271976646,
0.0378384404,
-0.0844752118,
0.0145962378,
0.0092100436,
0.0208477825,
0.0400250107,
0.0162573401,
0.0323510841,
0.0351832546,
0.0790007487,
0.0353028066,
-0.0581016019,
-0.0811781213,
0.0236733295,
0.0235202126,
0.0286551137,
0.0134754423,
0.0862436593,
0.0069154524,
-0.0865676478,
-0.0206924397,
0.0244200341,
0.0484299734,
0.024608504,
-0.0093833935,
-0.0265741926,
-0.0430395119,
-0.039605435,
-0.0684659854,
-0.0257345755,
-0.00201979,
0.0008925144,
0.0125824902,
-0.0313748159,
0.0382742248,
0.0067972513,
-0.0759034455,
-0.0071178563,
-0.0185136087,
0.0191727951,
-0.0327098854,
0.0377572998,
0.0088238493,
-0.0634122565,
0.0010431985,
0.0066565396,
0.0405853838,
0.0221155025,
0.0331040658,
0.0045180982,
0.0149301058,
-0.0527829826,
-0.015416679,
-0.0423839688,
-0.0052692937,
0.0183789544,
0.0558825471,
0.0470333546,
0.0213119779,
-0.005901691,
-0.0278352816,
0.0335279852,
0.0483762398,
-0.0289902724,
0.0180785172,
0.033008527,
0.0274717994,
-0.0038034229,
-0.0361259282,
-0.0383471027,
0.0545856841,
0.0349722803,
-0.0834722891,
-0.0278570149,
-0.0401809998,
2.671e-7,
0.0079036895,
0.0526928157,
0.0374864191,
-0.0116213365,
0.035473641,
0.0160117615,
0.0101496875,
0.0735547394,
0.0241464078,
-0.00586665,
-0.0321327969,
0.0385290049,
-0.0012255141,
0.012584039,
-0.0344109759,
-0.0171647556,
-0.0896941125,
0.0365928151,
0.000305104,
-0.0043048081,
-0.0029945113,
0.0857915878,
0.0099627394,
-0.0106724938,
0.0244431328,
-0.0167220216,
0.0363870077,
-0.0199562535,
0.0662403107,
0.0119089261,
0.000083133,
0.012971743,
-0.0117601985,
0.0230539832,
0.016402103,
0.0238977633,
-0.0095225824,
0.0395391732,
-0.0294918511,
-0.001677464,
-0.016754467,
-0.0365412831,
-0.0175904725,
-0.081143938,
0.0593088008,
-0.0324016064,
-0.0664640665,
-0.0427973159,
-0.0044221231,
-0.0069636707,
0.0786181837,
-0.0029125661,
0.0210344456,
0.0041030222,
0.0012452044,
0.0071477159,
-0.0108578559,
-0.0941406637,
-0.0449721552,
-0.0316103995,
-0.0334192254,
-0.0702606142,
-0.0467511155,
0.0113692209,
0.0565011874,
-0.0404269062,
0.0234808344,
2.344877509e-34,
-0.0045359894,
0.0114114517,
0.0155408178,
0.0116549702,
-0.0106212348,
-0.0283580944,
0.0242957063,
-0.018774813,
0.0479019098,
-0.0267613996,
-0.0304670744
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06831v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06831v1 | A Survey on the Applications of Frontier AI, Foundation Models, and Large Language Models to Intelligent Transportation Systems | 2024-01-12T10:29:48 | 2024-01-12T10:29:48 | Mohamed R. Shoaib, Heba M. Emara, Jun Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This survey paper explores the transformative influence of frontier AI,
foundation models, and Large Language Models (LLMs) in the realm of Intelligent
Transportation Systems (ITS), emphasizing their integral role in advancing
transportation intelligence, optimizing traffic management, and contributing to
the realization of smart cities. Frontier AI refers to the forefront of AI
technology, encompassing the latest advancements, innovations, and experimental
techniques in the field, especially AI foundation models and LLMs. Foundation
models, like GPT-4, are large, general-purpose AI models that provide a base
for a wide range of applications. They are characterized by their versatility
and scalability. LLMs are obtained from finetuning foundation models with a
specific focus on processing and generating natural language. They excel in
tasks like language understanding, text generation, translation, and
summarization. By leveraging vast textual data, including traffic reports and
social media interactions, LLMs extract critical insights, fostering the
evolution of ITS. The survey navigates the dynamic synergy between LLMs and
ITS, delving into applications in traffic management, integration into
autonomous vehicles, and their role in shaping smart cities. It provides
insights into ongoing research, innovations, and emerging trends, aiming to
inspire collaboration at the intersection of language, intelligence, and
mobility for safer, more efficient, and sustainable transportation systems. The
paper further surveys interactions between LLMs and various aspects of ITS,
exploring roles in traffic management, facilitating autonomous vehicles, and
contributing to smart city development, while addressing challenges brought by
frontier AI and foundation models. This paper offers valuable inspiration for
future research and innovation in the transformative domain of intelligent
transportation. | [
0.046575468,
0.0495582856,
-0.0458122902,
0.0499092937,
-0.036355868,
0.0060550789,
0.0124971494,
-0.0339392014,
-0.0225864332,
-0.0560876839,
0.0472011901,
-0.008647684,
-0.0304631721,
0.0775349438,
-0.001262588,
-0.0208979845,
-0.0136313392,
-0.0679425821,
-0.0256092418,
0.0310968664,
0.0114862574,
0.0186354648,
0.0147079118,
0.0247998592,
-0.0552487709,
0.0540593415,
-0.0283394307,
-0.0093806665,
0.0152365146,
-0.0241346713,
-0.0061841873,
0.0437500849,
0.0986725837,
0.0404571258,
0.0000020421,
-0.0128170531,
-0.0198814776,
-0.0104629071,
0.0256509259,
-0.0627312735,
0.0351504236,
0.0017837909,
0.0149124162,
0.0234438851,
-0.0505422652,
-0.0205705315,
0.0428192392,
0.0453115292,
0.0352690965,
0.0485589765,
-0.0075606178,
-0.0559033751,
0.0568358228,
0.0081704482,
-0.0670366883,
-0.0055991709,
0.0287968516,
-0.0065226117,
-0.0125192488,
0.0097856103,
-0.0171621852,
-0.0069194729,
0.041477561,
-0.0112849493,
0.0327838361,
0.0316634141,
-0.0152888894,
-0.0098348511,
-0.0239791535,
0.0591634139,
0.009545601,
-0.0775437206,
0.0356680043,
0.03795157,
-0.0475449413,
-0.0431804135,
-0.0667947605,
-0.0226594768,
0.0503395423,
0.0450350791,
0.0150701879,
0.0124060409,
0.0105335405,
0.0669238046,
-0.0805334225,
0.0880454853,
-0.001729683,
-0.0303955022,
-0.0275699906,
0.0244413428,
0.0104617383,
-0.0575624891,
0.0019110881,
0.0614593811,
-0.0204706639,
-0.0080517856,
0.0168709941,
-0.0117041375,
-0.0191300455,
-0.0209668465,
0.0117728654,
0.0013897548,
-0.0084544355,
0.029445054,
0.0469352528,
0.0269619692,
0.025765067,
0.0243486892,
-0.0207846425,
-0.0399121568,
-0.0562845655,
-0.0112751126,
-0.0578366779,
0.0418678708,
-0.0518881679,
0.0027421245,
0.0131095555,
0.0580038652,
0.0286560487,
-0.0104823271,
-0.0684120357,
0.0034441431,
0.0094241546,
-0.042682983,
-0.000825243,
0.0092071341,
-0.0168970581,
0.0165170971,
0.0059187328,
-0.035144832,
0.0382563733,
0.0278224684,
-0.0256019384,
-0.0085435165,
-0.0265510939,
0.0734497532,
0.0062217568,
-0.0261577889,
-0.0640059188,
-0.0343241468,
0.0330483429,
-0.0785645396,
-0.010808859,
-0.0704821497,
0.016778864,
0.0299737137,
-0.0428263023,
-0.016431896,
-0.0128889121,
-0.0223141517,
-0.0321272202,
0.0213481579,
-0.0542552359,
0.0234391019,
0.0696803033,
-0.016015809,
0.0527436137,
0.0806188136,
0.0423456505,
0.0538627058,
0.0570903458,
0.0114064254,
-0.0068963077,
0.0125410641,
0.0188105386,
0.0277639832,
-0.0443252847,
0.0225591976,
-0.0342238545,
-0.0132658612,
-0.0218617041,
0.0569344945,
-0.0091040256,
0.0369178131,
0.0693328679,
0.0647661164,
-0.0096684312,
0.0270762779,
0.0309086218,
0.0472690091,
-0.0089355828,
-0.0205032043,
-0.0349844396,
-0.0101924511,
-0.0649591982,
0.003770991,
-0.0035446833,
0.077159375,
-0.0254235528,
-0.0425779112,
0.0332789235,
-0.0458693914,
0.0354326479,
-0.001289934,
0.0588613451,
-0.0770230442,
-0.0012313429,
-0.0097270738,
-0.0056346022,
0.0037349756,
0.0186895151,
-0.0657565221,
0.0081472695,
0.0347121768,
0.021232402,
-0.0207191296,
-0.0134036364,
-0.0137685444,
0.0030173922,
-0.0019402059,
0.0588812493,
0.0085580153,
-0.0337407142,
-0.0578537732,
-0.0300267879,
0.0820314661,
0.0101686288,
-0.0588216633,
-0.025564922,
0.0486990027,
0.04657235,
-0.0198286101,
-0.0400100723,
0.0237090737,
0.0357939042,
0.0071636555,
-0.0293014403,
0.0104234517,
0.0229181256,
0.0090735685,
-0.0240323395,
0.009073888,
0.050792411,
0.0253423005,
-0.0513425171,
0.0533042178,
-0.0079083275,
0.099544704,
0.0290102139,
-0.0147963557,
0.015841715,
0.0744972453,
-0.0447108671,
-0.037595693,
-0.000647419,
-0.076153487,
0.0096483044,
-0.013732831,
0.0336632542,
0.0079845702,
0.0137767224,
-0.0208738334,
0.0524835959,
0.0265646111,
-0.0070461622,
0.0136403665,
0.0023450674,
0.0523980856,
-0.0195680987,
-0.0008425351,
0.0099500883,
-0.0113347527,
0.0016602668,
0.0413658023,
-0.0186865982,
-0.0037457547,
-0.0027741608,
-0.039557714,
0.0059365849,
-0.0201567188,
0.0104694515,
-0.0182911362,
0.0060136933,
-0.0173464138,
0.006979743,
-0.0039128908,
0.0336417854,
0.0521579385,
-0.045700781,
0.0288818814,
-0.0062064077,
-0.0274326764,
-0.03035447,
-0.0192946047,
-0.0495763011,
0.0201270096,
0.0486675613,
-0.0847564265,
-0.0317964852,
-0.0487956256,
-0.0310686287,
0.0442000255,
-0.0021343254,
-0.0429933034,
0.0110095264,
-0.0154479397,
0.018237656,
0.0295469984,
0.0572318695,
-0.0005415321,
0.0159951746,
-0.037832547,
-0.0300328955,
0.0133893052,
-0.063001439,
0.0410513319,
-0.0254162792,
-0.0166795105,
0.0075199897,
0.0422309078,
-0.0139907151,
-0.0010338329,
-0.0125432573,
0.0284232814,
-0.0234524645,
-0.029543275,
-0.0207597744,
0.0243192613,
0.0356765091,
0.0782274306,
-0.023383718,
-0.0507698059,
0.0655848756,
-0.0145683941,
0.0290466528,
-0.0387838371,
-0.0141302561,
-0.0459270924,
0.0608833879,
0.0268019419,
0.0335419066,
0.0058675339,
0.0219749827,
0.0470375828,
-0.0024919382,
-0.0792650506,
-0.0087638944,
0.0426719226,
-0.0402742848,
0.0288082138,
-0.0134750893,
-0.0647742748,
-0.0099753868,
-0.0458490923,
-0.0539812259,
0.000681781,
0.00938881,
-0.0535110794,
-0.0211245287,
0.0492526144,
-0.0006466513,
0.0454370305,
-0.0146280359,
0.0095624179,
-0.0458607227,
-0.013352464,
0.0635455996,
0.0398695022,
0.0227154642,
0.0007481833,
0.023465395,
0.0004267802,
0.0474449843,
-0.0097506894,
-0.0140609825,
0.0230987985,
0.0327861644,
-0.0396145768,
-0.0129846241,
0.0458374284,
-0.0021898793,
-0.0475241505,
-0.0112435129,
0.0928580537,
0.0159455743,
0.0152876209,
0.0201384071,
-0.0058993716,
-0.0136315618,
-0.0077624554,
0.0331942588,
-0.0710341632,
-0.0091316821,
-0.0084739551,
-0.0186513904,
0.0038877416,
-0.0393676758,
0.0027962429,
-0.0702780485,
0.0355052538,
0.0012021145,
-0.057183098,
-0.0370219611,
-0.0588084012,
-0.0310919806,
0.0185977481,
0.0020113497,
-0.0169808231,
0.0204292424,
-0.0259138606,
0.0328320153,
-0.0364008211,
-0.0379385315,
-0.0489464439,
-0.017682841,
0.0762868449,
0.05933116,
0.0230267309,
-0.0372686647,
-0.0143313548,
-0.0417149998,
-0.0100879306,
-0.0037639944,
-0.0396195725,
0.0030574107,
-0.0038492815,
0.0030364301,
-0.0361518674,
0.0101483054,
-0.0291113425,
-0.0080354279,
0.01414188,
0.0777628571,
-0.0665891543,
-0.0159386676,
-0.067273438,
0.0179037657,
0.0006237358,
0.0277116112,
-0.0236768499,
-0.0152904866,
-0.0472211912,
-0.018467471,
-0.0394822545,
-0.0548044592,
0.0087586613,
-0.0067678653,
0.0132806068,
-0.0358680189,
-0.0211272333,
-0.0581603013,
-0.0063142208,
-0.018488843,
0.020703299,
0.030462103,
0.0656341314,
-0.0450311042,
-0.0572016574,
-0.0122866984,
0.0063678017,
0.0026889518,
-0.0504438952,
0.0294835642,
0.0452507213,
-0.0552824363,
-0.0526029952,
0.0601134747,
-0.0303853713,
-0.0931254104,
0.0212458875,
0.0159565601,
0.0224310458,
-0.0167133305,
-0.0449114256,
-0.0456998907,
0.0509487912,
-0.0050786347,
-0.0109401997,
-0.0025636782,
-0.0334107205,
-0.058939036,
0.0250459239,
0.0254451428,
-0.0431890525,
0.0753791481,
0.0143013271,
-0.0209769215,
-0.06217888,
-0.01406899,
0.015245053,
0.0377796479,
0.0263232961,
0.0354650803,
0.0264984109,
-0.0174898915,
-0.0157900099,
-0.0187449567,
0.0089706881,
-0.0386560895,
0.0058808373,
-0.0226700362,
0.0492040589,
-0.0143266199,
0.0050472482,
0.030054979,
-0.0476307161,
0.0265081711,
0.0164480936,
-0.0252818577,
0.0216234215,
-0.0229669567,
-0.0199242719,
0.0067607914,
-0.0313778631,
0.0060971803,
0.0250914134,
-0.0160610024,
0.058990404,
0.0416004024,
-0.0013243464,
-0.0223037545,
0.0402783267,
-0.0333180055,
-0.0684788749,
-0.0133100906,
0.0683846697,
0.0600308143,
0.0332469381,
0.0008365161,
-0.0682923123,
0.0100301262,
-0.0186720174,
0.0133672776,
0.0654361546,
0.0014317061,
0.0301750973,
-0.0033911346,
-0.056173984,
-0.000223339,
0.056578435,
0.0062383786,
0.034700267,
0.0200470313,
-0.0420601889,
-0.035429731,
0.0048611262,
0.0196293928,
-0.0232067555,
-0.0045039407,
0.0351754874,
-0.0308512524,
-0.0197703801,
0.0408562869,
0.0297019966,
0.0161101911,
-0.0348086618,
0.0116627207,
0.0163504481,
0.0122726243,
-0.0463520698,
0.0057750819,
-0.0362574756,
-0.0727010965,
-0.0176900402,
0.0239040069,
-6.581397444e-33,
-0.007772909,
-0.0211170595,
0.0576836467,
0.0085753864,
-0.0540774018,
-0.0206710994,
-0.0236412082,
-0.0209403113,
-0.0066030291,
-0.0044394471,
-0.0173807722,
0.0329142697,
0.0094199199,
0.0250388384,
-0.0128237121,
0.0103570074,
0.0210139658,
-0.0168800019,
0.0025887,
0.0369078629,
0.0354150422,
-0.0060902513,
0.0132010756,
-0.073685199,
0.0112694427,
-0.0841242298,
-0.0116039896,
0.0668015853,
-0.0050831377,
0.0531705432,
-0.0100822607,
0.0475744046,
0.062733002,
-0.0463121571,
-0.031507276,
0.0805039555,
-0.0136865443,
-0.0042035058,
0.0234611258,
0.0371191613,
-0.0353822783,
-0.0431897826,
0.0467547439,
-0.0140060484,
-0.041595865,
0.0510373302,
0.0433445387,
-0.0203840807,
0.0255143922,
-0.0244901273,
-0.090198651,
0.0083237337,
-0.0393096469,
-0.0105521651,
0.0417835712,
0.0072353822,
0.0143106356,
-0.0222836211,
0.017849138,
0.0277563781,
0.0141693037,
-0.0036106457,
0.0437440351,
-0.0000808798,
-0.0158700347,
0.0310263894,
-0.0103757782,
-0.0578822345,
-0.0211620089,
-0.020788135,
0.0151920747,
0.0631204545,
0.012091008,
0.0360424183,
-0.0491016768,
-0.0458661579,
-0.097900115,
0.0045131701,
0.0315962955,
-0.0017107747,
0.0468555056,
-0.044199504,
-0.0675237104,
0.0057269321,
-0.0074093714,
-0.0146585582,
-0.0027846999,
-0.0280438494,
0.009784597,
0.0256498996,
-0.0249533653,
0.0120409755,
0.0535265841,
-0.083114557,
-0.0024796869,
0.0137315951,
-0.0142097389,
0.0102235507,
0.0037140821,
0.0503072664,
-0.1035693809,
-0.0322840661,
-0.0260814894,
0.0011298367,
-0.0167615134,
0.0226405729,
-0.0119052324,
0.0277843438,
0.0191033594,
0.0237169471,
-0.0072363536,
0.038408123,
0.0463792756,
-0.0180274639,
0.0301434714,
0.0252156984,
0.0146913761,
0.0165089518,
0.0122530283,
-0.0169973914,
-0.0261282492,
-0.0200051777,
0.0023732169,
0.0377849787,
0.0010003977,
0.0103356903,
-0.015217687,
0.0043677306,
0.0213212203,
-0.0241296366,
-0.0294498112,
0.0263220835,
2.744e-7,
-0.0056938669,
0.0667234957,
0.0179127399,
0.0327573493,
0.0271910056,
0.0328318588,
-0.0005614132,
0.0110826911,
-0.0093456721,
0.0883749947,
0.0102321971,
0.0572629012,
0.0303086154,
-0.0086604701,
-0.0442546122,
0.0165770054,
-0.0512616187,
-0.0158345923,
-0.1003902704,
0.0385499597,
0.0627996847,
0.1017477885,
-0.0113536054,
-0.0158437174,
-0.0033802383,
0.002518167,
-0.0105176354,
-0.0404763818,
-0.0064647906,
0.0340953395,
0.0436986051,
0.0564922057,
-0.0295841638,
0.0079445112,
0.0193441026,
0.0283888578,
-0.0148358308,
0.0322889388,
-0.016372351,
0.0120338444,
0.0422773436,
-0.0616219081,
0.0097868461,
-0.068046689,
0.0165451095,
-0.0123261828,
-0.0185266379,
-0.0210226439,
-0.0053640883,
-0.0459645465,
-0.0512369685,
0.0092307236,
-0.0179469828,
0.0000596005,
0.0028586457,
-0.0216836259,
0.0216408372,
-0.0548534133,
0.0718241259,
0.0031789218,
-0.001787934,
-0.0442259982,
-0.0472470932,
0.0562562384,
0.0628283545,
-0.0194134656,
0.0134074921,
1.993455437e-34,
0.0353071839,
-0.0066318032,
-0.0149694802,
-0.0260535982,
0.0352014638,
0.0148259066,
-0.0287469234,
0.0130943358,
-0.0303505529,
-0.0670146048,
-0.0058551035
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06477v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06477v2 | Kun: Answer Polishment for Chinese Self-Alignment with Instruction Back-Translation | 2024-01-12T09:56:57 | 2024-02-23T12:48:46 | Tianyu Zheng, Shuyue Guo, Xingwei Qu, Jiawei Guo, Weixu Zhang, Xinrun Du, Qi Jia, Chenghua Lin, Wenhao Huang, Wenhu Chen, Jie Fu, Ge Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In this paper, we introduce Kun, a novel approach for creating high-quality
instruction-tuning datasets for large language models (LLMs) without relying on
manual annotations. Adapting a self-training algorithm based on instruction
back-translation and answer polishment, Kun leverages unlabelled data from
diverse sources such as Wudao, Wanjuan, and SkyPile to generate a substantial
dataset of over a million Chinese instructional data points. This approach
significantly deviates from traditional methods by using a self-curation
process to refine and select the most effective instruction-output pairs. Our
experiments with the 6B-parameter Yi model across various benchmarks
demonstrate Kun's robustness and scalability. Our method's core contributions
lie in its algorithmic advancement, which enhances data retention and clarity,
and its innovative data generation approach that substantially reduces the
reliance on costly and time-consuming manual annotations. This methodology
presents a scalable and efficient solution for improving the
instruction-following capabilities of LLMs, with significant implications for
their application across diverse fields. The code and dataset can be found at
https://github.com/Zheng0428/COIG-Kun | [
0.0303971358,
0.0246966574,
-0.0004685174,
0.0375561677,
-0.0056333444,
0.0020032919,
0.0105209518,
-0.0338104218,
0.0126584526,
-0.0320180617,
-0.0485986508,
0.0024164699,
-0.0017301665,
-0.0520509854,
0.0140349595,
-0.018660428,
0.0643419251,
-0.0137526263,
-0.0359036624,
0.0068802699,
0.0090075061,
0.0169849191,
0.0053204084,
0.0171721764,
0.0253111422,
-0.0673220158,
-0.0156293362,
0.0206342079,
0.0008580746,
-0.0347133279,
0.044577457,
0.0906068906,
-0.0043162457,
0.0055465437,
0.0000021845,
-0.0404042527,
-0.0323716253,
-0.0237052776,
-0.0342619345,
0.0793544278,
0.0049330564,
-0.0034967621,
-0.0211040657,
0.032849405,
-0.0348291397,
0.0116729876,
0.0175152905,
0.0181561932,
0.1157473698,
0.0689539611,
0.030541651,
-0.01765953,
0.0394327305,
0.0043166257,
0.0034286703,
0.0055007227,
0.022571018,
0.0452861078,
-0.016001178,
0.0359828435,
-0.029547995,
0.0266775396,
0.0160455089,
-0.0202560388,
-0.009335109,
-0.0010283693,
-0.0042775297,
0.0250587165,
-0.0317269675,
0.0865241438,
0.0056751105,
-0.0237758756,
-0.0430038944,
-0.0185848568,
0.0153170656,
0.0025208443,
-0.0569370575,
0.0158339404,
0.0022820837,
0.0195202511,
0.0493418537,
-0.0424500257,
-0.0005950673,
-0.005741463,
-0.0071241101,
0.0675273389,
0.0129936328,
-0.0411107615,
-0.0375659354,
-0.0061976146,
-0.0012941156,
-0.0445390902,
0.0101320101,
0.0586195067,
0.0032488741,
0.0341403298,
-0.0525393002,
-0.0052355486,
0.0336023122,
-0.0478468128,
0.0474393442,
0.049706392,
-0.0153744528,
0.0161446873,
-0.0115374373,
0.0691120327,
0.0254522264,
0.0262282137,
-0.0836694166,
0.0198404696,
-0.0423759446,
-0.0113962675,
-0.0406913944,
0.028735688,
-0.0025059911,
0.0138555961,
-0.0452947207,
0.0258039068,
-0.0221337844,
0.019396577,
0.0229648799,
-0.0349247754,
-0.05364611,
0.0107163442,
-0.0143080093,
0.0510960184,
-0.0294102821,
-0.009542563,
-0.0076563437,
-0.0391313657,
-0.0008622343,
-0.0167489238,
-0.0094720013,
-0.0280101933,
0.0074797012,
0.0443510674,
-0.013834469,
0.0148334578,
-0.0399443321,
-0.0282944217,
-0.0185706858,
-0.0256042853,
0.002917134,
-0.0867436007,
0.0090855984,
0.0204683542,
0.0135094542,
-0.0461666733,
0.0273403507,
0.0346744917,
0.0066695432,
0.0059831524,
-0.0175919402,
0.0313576274,
0.001445977,
-0.0163615849,
0.0477659665,
0.0553726926,
0.0404266231,
-0.0234075412,
0.0810232833,
-0.0613511018,
-0.0019898734,
0.0374693274,
0.0306163412,
0.0184048004,
-0.0052180458,
0.0410143062,
0.0306015536,
0.0059487037,
0.0121557675,
0.000527453,
0.0118725924,
-0.0185427051,
0.0377967805,
0.0225830507,
0.0124624548,
-0.0036590816,
0.0116171017,
0.0388253704,
0.0306299757,
0.0420086235,
-0.054167334,
0.0333678797,
-0.0101467259,
0.02974963,
0.0327024907,
0.0198448915,
-0.0393634103,
-0.0780512989,
-0.0194660965,
0.0170115493,
-0.0182100106,
0.021032555,
0.0251855776,
-0.0050082034,
-0.0145305144,
0.0251746643,
0.0404487178,
-0.0473618694,
0.0217156988,
-0.0021971441,
0.027104605,
0.0729509592,
0.0234643333,
-0.0143172955,
-0.0668208748,
0.0047789686,
0.0454853699,
0.0409806482,
0.0676933005,
-0.0321883559,
-0.0479299538,
-0.0519109331,
-0.0471767224,
-0.0061481381,
-0.0076672984,
-0.0121355783,
0.0151349269,
-0.0149101214,
0.0003450318,
-0.0218982212,
-0.08168789,
0.0563253835,
-0.0421919823,
-0.0644495562,
-0.0239560269,
-0.0023597141,
0.0026633178,
0.0490101054,
-0.0111667272,
0.0238198098,
0.0400405154,
0.0000668944,
0.0139529333,
-0.0176259018,
-0.0688105598,
-0.0420776345,
0.0812686086,
-0.004313644,
-0.0388314985,
0.0086982092,
-0.0630190894,
-0.069346562,
-0.0331860185,
-0.0077378596,
-0.0104341125,
-0.0231606159,
0.0481804684,
-0.0030618662,
0.0037446676,
-0.0497465171,
0.0243344791,
0.0076567177,
0.0350496173,
0.0178812966,
0.0312007461,
0.0411959887,
-0.030416647,
-0.0161648467,
-0.0135040283,
-0.0100178374,
0.035073556,
0.006205006,
0.0344041437,
-0.0547510982,
-0.0143293636,
-0.055890657,
0.0447344184,
-0.0242155213,
0.0219045598,
0.0581357889,
-0.0175171513,
-0.0183533784,
-0.0154972253,
-0.0572136752,
-0.0338129997,
-0.0107292105,
0.0050384118,
0.0144839268,
-0.0053048185,
0.0039058221,
-0.0454582609,
-0.0353558064,
-0.0396047048,
-0.0366958715,
0.0126953842,
0.0275700241,
-0.0760462806,
-0.0119079966,
-0.0406427681,
0.0130243367,
0.0193981081,
-0.0868733898,
0.0034872119,
-0.0078705531,
0.0376417525,
0.0563396998,
0.013470415,
-0.0036588428,
0.0436904579,
-0.01194485,
-0.0913762897,
0.0204690583,
-0.0281593464,
-0.0361369029,
-0.0105875349,
-0.06966988,
-0.0305809136,
0.0694345757,
0.0375497825,
-0.0216395147,
-0.0633703396,
-0.0316076353,
-0.0268277489,
0.0072441748,
-0.0070006768,
0.0285969768,
-0.0235554259,
-0.0220226049,
-0.0292205475,
-0.0416306816,
0.093223989,
-0.0375928693,
0.0038240948,
-0.0531677827,
0.0110404612,
-0.0308705196,
0.0014043306,
-0.0008923309,
-0.004881972,
-0.0126410211,
0.0029458241,
-0.0508684777,
0.0348451361,
0.0268526673,
-0.0424233638,
0.0188194495,
-0.0428855456,
-0.011846235,
-0.0183580946,
0.0048636878,
-0.0288862977,
-0.0167497508,
0.0065051643,
0.00061616,
-0.0018180757,
-0.0154493237,
0.0539304018,
0.0171605106,
0.0053989394,
0.0381496958,
-0.0563919283,
0.0302537419,
-0.0319019333,
-0.0136942668,
0.0515706912,
0.0030706176,
-0.0019503803,
-0.0390737727,
0.0698534697,
0.0461242758,
0.0761564299,
0.0066595282,
0.0256416798,
0.0011665793,
0.055074688,
-0.0670431629,
-0.0124400193,
0.0209163819,
0.0780523345,
-0.078131713,
-0.0069471323,
0.1226184517,
0.0368116908,
-0.0177847091,
-0.001823927,
-0.0117078172,
-0.0060511753,
0.022109665,
0.0333009623,
-0.076308161,
-0.0223968904,
-0.0303796269,
0.0422554947,
0.0236661565,
-0.0084153423,
0.0099358214,
-0.1457088292,
0.0398052409,
0.0293466188,
-0.0235130154,
-0.0329729803,
-0.0472463369,
0.0023086539,
0.0076177637,
0.0375709161,
0.0317618698,
-0.0271992367,
0.0037658687,
0.0465119779,
-0.0152402502,
-0.0239854585,
0.0250236262,
-0.025879154,
0.0704416186,
0.0342765339,
0.0156284086,
0.0024140272,
-0.0029401223,
0.0373992808,
-0.0533047765,
-0.0359892696,
-0.0121470829,
0.0522384979,
-0.0084148413,
-0.0029157724,
0.0069444338,
0.0489355735,
-0.030547699,
0.0344769433,
0.0626110211,
0.0708394125,
-0.0058289212,
0.0381342359,
-0.0377554409,
0.0049707801,
-0.012317081,
0.0976457819,
0.0297379158,
-0.0658257157,
-0.0069280877,
-0.056093432,
-0.0178729948,
-0.0756012499,
-0.020793492,
0.0579854809,
-0.0777904466,
0.0106198136,
-0.0853760689,
-0.073845394,
0.0332505107,
-0.0091168266,
0.0335574299,
0.0215247422,
0.0025462068,
-0.0200371351,
-0.0231635366,
0.0346181802,
-0.0242630728,
0.0005700202,
-0.1014842987,
-0.0406357944,
0.0035043424,
-0.0099014807,
0.0218107514,
0.006570824,
-0.0414561406,
-0.066617541,
0.0112582911,
0.0505061559,
-0.0026327213,
0.0661236495,
0.0067641246,
0.0120245218,
0.0133568337,
-0.0238171071,
-0.0198672786,
-0.019016033,
0.0197936296,
-0.0032745909,
-0.0070065837,
0.0116509655,
-0.0241985749,
0.0157402493,
0.0271419995,
0.0672883168,
-0.0265218914,
-0.0336842537,
0.056599725,
0.0315000564,
0.0031698609,
-0.0034024473,
0.0025927259,
-0.0418985374,
0.0518621989,
-0.0520931892,
-0.0380379856,
-0.030121848,
0.0091412207,
0.0130362706,
-0.0567147397,
0.0092951506,
0.0380717292,
-0.0142769329,
0.0099494122,
-0.0451430343,
0.0256554112,
-0.0204490442,
0.0446295552,
-0.0216291174,
-0.0000877924,
-0.0249415245,
-0.0057765073,
0.0349131078,
0.0401440635,
0.0145719079,
0.0883392245,
0.006579184,
0.0194339268,
0.0320008472,
0.0210401379,
-0.0267982185,
-0.0124909217,
-0.059803497,
0.0075782822,
0.0356401615,
-0.0122291306,
0.0603198744,
-0.0142421778,
-0.0252868291,
-0.0352847725,
0.0313793756,
0.0067853504,
-0.0030636378,
0.0251133442,
0.0298570767,
-0.0123768263,
-0.0157387555,
0.0539788343,
0.0050322581,
0.0414549112,
0.0226485301,
0.008762056,
-0.0330917239,
-0.0037953439,
0.0099869492,
-0.0031058276,
-0.0140704159,
-0.0027065491,
-0.022591792,
-0.0615108572,
-0.0382049941,
0.0725743547,
-0.0199291147,
-0.0134367384,
0.0141428318,
0.047050409,
-0.0401556008,
-0.0254502445,
-0.0623587966,
0.0265930016,
-0.0461412817,
-0.0305415858,
-0.0097520808,
-6.263450467e-33,
-0.0563177839,
-0.0077762064,
0.0251316894,
0.0245137047,
0.0194136836,
-0.0283324774,
-0.0154926507,
-0.0027231246,
-0.0422850139,
-0.0062647625,
-0.0167942438,
0.00038681,
0.0112232175,
0.0375410542,
0.0373191983,
0.0210315567,
0.0475973263,
-0.0230611246,
-0.0218077097,
0.0268907826,
0.0244779531,
-0.0105106467,
0.0884906724,
-0.049656406,
0.0346573479,
-0.0343370214,
0.0164331421,
0.0308120698,
-0.0434751026,
0.0854030475,
0.0142889936,
0.042541001,
0.0140267145,
-0.0260626152,
-0.0321491063,
-0.0254137013,
-0.1072295234,
-0.0530680791,
0.0098860264,
0.0308129694,
-0.0285595302,
-0.0450822785,
0.009627426,
-0.0327413045,
-0.0136748748,
-0.0253616478,
0.0418563448,
-0.033537358,
0.0089412378,
0.0353750698,
-0.031748075,
0.0089065731,
-0.0183493476,
-0.0400924049,
0.000534478,
0.0535373054,
0.013142026,
-0.0136984522,
-0.0474899039,
0.0309264231,
0.082767345,
0.0891001821,
0.075743556,
0.0130442409,
0.0180860385,
0.0043968405,
0.015750898,
0.0012347702,
0.046984069,
0.0094716344,
0.0132347578,
0.0161494203,
0.0606707297,
0.0220410302,
0.0079474915,
0.0142537886,
-0.0525688976,
0.0589621738,
0.048292391,
-0.0073465779,
-0.0117293829,
-0.0244001038,
-0.0516814068,
-0.0017068733,
-0.0256626662,
-0.0165479612,
-0.0129536595,
-0.0413225926,
0.0403104573,
-0.0208849963,
-0.068405062,
-0.0015649492,
0.0427007303,
-0.0396149829,
-0.0475578196,
0.025405515,
-0.017727511,
0.0021483647,
-0.0182918701,
0.0405012369,
-0.0696462467,
-0.0184965879,
-0.0130693121,
-0.0596806742,
0.0097277872,
0.0413960852,
0.0317279883,
-0.0094539747,
-0.051673241,
0.0042602438,
-0.0284114871,
-0.0139501235,
0.0058322302,
-0.0307607893,
0.0251105446,
0.0165044926,
0.0040135989,
0.0648396015,
0.0430682227,
-0.0007086113,
-0.045988638,
-0.0482068807,
-0.0073236409,
0.0190352928,
-0.0028608216,
0.0226852521,
-0.035455972,
-0.000074543,
-0.0043382472,
-0.0366915129,
-0.0079437103,
0.0228104908,
2.646e-7,
0.0554358028,
0.0329678655,
0.0464176163,
0.0349205434,
0.0046084602,
0.0169543773,
-0.049071908,
-0.0036043874,
0.0600959212,
0.0069488636,
0.0193653908,
0.0283523276,
0.0607528649,
0.0223175976,
-0.0448102914,
0.0073240595,
-0.0198810678,
0.023626484,
-0.0540699773,
0.0239564646,
-0.0015736604,
0.0830210894,
-0.0079357177,
0.0421538875,
-0.0345597938,
0.0045168316,
0.004058145,
-0.0026291916,
-0.015748024,
0.0990506113,
0.0055902712,
0.0052367775,
-0.0281651467,
-0.0095543209,
-0.0340869352,
0.0273874644,
-0.0065940875,
0.0780515447,
0.0108575048,
-0.0336204208,
0.0018349088,
-0.0310595687,
0.0081264861,
-0.0344790965,
0.0451669805,
-0.0250616316,
0.0077064978,
0.0133009125,
-0.0302134492,
-0.0162383951,
-0.0012084828,
-0.0122001655,
-0.0057736551,
0.0325496942,
0.0239045881,
-0.011962668,
-0.0131344683,
-0.022316901,
-0.0624501705,
0.0327093452,
-0.0095759798,
-0.048561193,
-0.0046526091,
-0.0147244921,
-0.0456949137,
-0.0671508312,
-0.0067970236,
2.576211353e-34,
0.0017541702,
-0.0390415303,
0.0432689823,
0.0350095369,
0.0030496668,
-0.0379700512,
-0.0265880302,
0.0258694068,
0.0184906162,
-0.0636832044,
-0.0515118912
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06829v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06829v1 | Cross-Attention Watermarking of Large Language Models | 2024-01-12T09:39:50 | 2024-01-12T09:39:50 | Folco Bertini Baldassini, Huy H. Nguyen, Ching-Chung Chang, Isao Echizen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | A new approach to linguistic watermarking of language models is presented in
which information is imperceptibly inserted into the output text while
preserving its readability and original meaning. A cross-attention mechanism is
used to embed watermarks in the text during inference. Two methods using
cross-attention are presented that minimize the effect of watermarking on the
performance of a pretrained model. Exploration of different training strategies
for optimizing the watermarking and of the challenges and implications of
applying this approach in real-world scenarios clarified the tradeoff between
watermark robustness and text quality. Watermark selection substantially
affects the generated output for high entropy sentences. This proactive
watermarking approach has potential application in future model development. | [
0.0065788734,
0.0578219444,
-0.0250350442,
0.0459906869,
-0.0172073487,
-0.0030587511,
0.0089209974,
0.0203266051,
0.0202033818,
-0.0717727467,
-0.0339769721,
0.0000187913,
0.0081020938,
0.0040317141,
0.0906719565,
-0.0736911371,
0.0656933561,
-0.0125359735,
-0.005829453,
0.0169848781,
0.0041239355,
-0.0039447765,
0.1002016664,
0.0303363409,
-0.0178769492,
-0.0413857289,
0.002811033,
0.0154207274,
0.0104059884,
-0.0070865289,
-0.0294454247,
0.0615639836,
0.005187416,
0.0724516213,
0.0000021051,
-0.0209107269,
-0.0424712636,
0.0344842412,
-0.0209137183,
0.0451348573,
0.0427754968,
-0.0245906711,
-0.0314492844,
0.0124180056,
-0.0129504073,
0.0475947782,
0.0700106323,
0.0695772544,
0.087456584,
0.0520865247,
-0.0080808559,
-0.0047248402,
0.0484082513,
-0.0102843428,
0.007917637,
-0.0210276805,
0.029808538,
0.0327202529,
-0.0300000459,
0.0034823932,
-0.0201966055,
0.0936349034,
0.0239422917,
-0.0324582793,
-0.0124360425,
0.01749775,
0.0156887323,
0.001799559,
0.0019329939,
0.0389581546,
-0.0780853778,
-0.037683025,
-0.0341599993,
-0.0332545042,
0.0037607383,
-0.0058428776,
-0.0297897197,
0.0150579447,
0.0466193222,
0.0343789048,
0.0237665642,
-0.0204598513,
0.0373915136,
-0.0080299014,
-0.0139284004,
0.0504319891,
0.036991246,
-0.0212578624,
-0.0232573673,
-0.0061481707,
-0.0334854014,
-0.0687192753,
0.0416787416,
0.0039499979,
0.0499506444,
0.0072450307,
-0.1220291555,
-0.0761319995,
-0.0021795265,
-0.0705322847,
0.0910207704,
0.0135544343,
-0.024150135,
0.0287273992,
-0.0342665873,
0.0407808833,
-0.0495279729,
0.053439077,
-0.0309248567,
-0.0120592406,
0.0159362294,
-0.0526120514,
-0.0661375597,
0.0096319793,
-0.0361794569,
-0.0270453393,
-0.0264151171,
0.031982936,
0.0025893806,
-0.0211204458,
-0.0036064938,
-0.0210861675,
-0.0404440947,
-0.0238682311,
0.0361460485,
-0.0114115691,
0.0331283621,
0.0273301061,
-0.0028144864,
-0.0504806153,
-0.0207614824,
0.0379618071,
0.0019287649,
-0.0056667887,
-0.0355227515,
0.0827349052,
0.0193374753,
-0.0380553342,
-0.0253509507,
-0.0289977994,
-0.007736078,
-0.0277420264,
0.0041843983,
-0.020696003,
-0.0100082997,
-0.0363641866,
0.0162519235,
-0.0689513013,
0.0221515037,
0.0178251583,
-0.0268108118,
0.0523039997,
-0.0499803312,
-0.016243238,
-0.0250370372,
-0.0187268388,
0.0051717088,
0.0894550607,
0.0676535815,
0.0149043621,
0.0414426588,
-0.0301583447,
-0.0307994876,
0.0555404462,
0.031454701,
0.0105150687,
-0.0469933599,
-0.0287236385,
0.0532143824,
-0.0212663021,
0.0524056852,
0.0279647224,
-0.002083685,
-0.0360771827,
0.1025321409,
0.0218121316,
-0.0119469129,
0.0159280654,
0.0377582684,
0.0008243921,
-0.0013994302,
0.0318132676,
-0.0398243368,
-0.0048798351,
-0.0177131351,
0.029599756,
0.0315809734,
-0.0049356092,
-0.0052947314,
-0.0205317009,
-0.0214582849,
-0.0082429564,
0.0087586157,
0.0073808036,
0.0251725502,
0.0486639924,
-0.0529895164,
0.063581273,
0.0290966202,
-0.0086837839,
0.0380821228,
-0.0568187125,
0.0177883804,
0.0798078105,
0.0405743942,
-0.0056150304,
0.0670056939,
-0.0166355446,
0.0065977843,
0.0574737005,
-0.0001514706,
0.0275606774,
0.005943568,
-0.017867472,
-0.0133404704,
-0.0358579122,
0.0263741519,
0.0462234914,
-0.0237240344,
0.0212803278,
0.0556399971,
-0.0194528624,
-0.0296377614,
0.0455088727,
-0.0062003452,
-0.0238104314,
-0.0213463008,
-0.0098564252,
0.0236707963,
0.0175032932,
-0.0148622394,
0.0481063426,
0.0108473375,
-0.0266993027,
-0.0037254936,
-0.0101623172,
-0.0123363398,
-0.0109635824,
0.0104014371,
-0.0429671519,
-0.0113467453,
0.0421798006,
0.0076480312,
-0.0254509971,
0.0029188367,
-0.07218723,
0.078778334,
-0.0588114522,
0.0381284282,
0.0064168102,
0.0438530669,
-0.023901457,
0.0416925587,
-0.0101115722,
0.0050157374,
0.0042266645,
-0.0162227452,
-0.0208988171,
-0.0486523993,
-0.0101492051,
-0.0061039412,
-0.0224364251,
0.0011748188,
-0.0101527143,
-0.0106968749,
-0.0088038351,
0.004835723,
-0.0097262599,
-0.0045370776,
-0.018902719,
0.0277967229,
0.0169222672,
-0.0042320411,
0.012193528,
0.0019162875,
-0.0078263683,
-0.0131237851,
-0.0039211498,
0.0403267443,
0.0129126115,
-0.027825579,
-0.0060353498,
-0.0177116152,
-0.0306280311,
-0.0054348963,
0.082065545,
-0.0115175424,
-0.0349186398,
-0.0955202281,
0.0503747314,
-0.0093405936,
0.0119838323,
0.0135633163,
-0.0330342352,
-0.0107359905,
0.0198131278,
0.0185962152,
0.0744623989,
-0.0051793363,
-0.0182130784,
0.0707191229,
0.0168259628,
-0.0315777212,
-0.0001475721,
-0.0367606357,
0.0113500655,
-0.0196284521,
-0.0433467142,
0.0188366715,
0.0648631603,
-0.0096054804,
-0.0020463229,
-0.0423968919,
0.0386992171,
-0.024165716,
-0.0411075503,
-0.0155040529,
-0.0282607544,
-0.035585288,
0.0120014716,
-0.0289513208,
-0.0457872562,
0.0482815653,
-0.0427977666,
-0.002880824,
-0.0018517608,
0.0043612854,
0.0151904831,
0.0294445138,
0.0180559438,
0.029495975,
0.0454051048,
-0.0409820341,
-0.0287300497,
-0.0289067142,
0.0375246704,
-0.0090969345,
-0.0128787151,
-0.0067100264,
-0.0147516681,
0.0021201991,
0.0095216073,
-0.0366067216,
-0.0549233109,
-0.0223696008,
0.0131586371,
0.0286795069,
0.0187758952,
-0.0281823147,
0.0324651562,
0.0381265096,
0.0126963984,
-0.0362837203,
0.0243966803,
-0.0509933233,
0.0771160349,
0.0466850214,
-0.034197282,
0.0037475044,
-0.0375035815,
-0.0024086176,
0.0520931929,
0.0053881197,
-0.0028909186,
0.0137843154,
-0.0077474876,
0.0333043374,
-0.003006574,
-0.0359594412,
0.0109564476,
0.0202740822,
-0.09804634,
-0.002153662,
0.0719201043,
0.008057449,
0.0149782198,
0.0203210786,
0.0014580236,
0.0382336117,
0.0089207888,
0.0068432465,
-0.052811414,
-0.0351916365,
0.0433019139,
0.0024560282,
-0.0057036015,
0.0168048162,
-0.0365370661,
-0.0775202215,
0.0125123151,
0.0170373414,
-0.0382964984,
-0.047476247,
-0.0501396768,
0.0007995274,
0.0372645557,
0.0078681922,
-0.0304247402,
0.0148102762,
-0.0274653491,
0.0158444904,
-0.0013539306,
-0.0556697398,
-0.0197167415,
-0.016024692,
0.0095911808,
0.0829269439,
0.0308984388,
0.000282037,
-0.0527083948,
0.0405432321,
-0.0412455164,
-0.0005246032,
0.0039493535,
0.0559827574,
-0.026462825,
-0.016213946,
-0.0002507452,
-0.0048104324,
0.0464696325,
-0.0162004139,
-0.0203960128,
0.1020514742,
0.013932649,
-0.0380638167,
-0.0031271758,
-0.0147031322,
0.0400833972,
0.0606253967,
0.0596536547,
-0.0289099086,
-0.0357661434,
-0.0548808798,
0.0329960994,
-0.0350242257,
-0.0363699794,
0.0165035836,
-0.0416988172,
-0.0957762375,
-0.0319139212,
-0.0532852784,
-0.013415969,
0.002924168,
0.0487652831,
0.0037399572,
0.0333848707,
-0.0431447253,
-0.0176593941,
0.0328835472,
-0.1009272039,
0.0250923671,
-0.0248241108,
-0.0060785473,
0.0111525236,
-0.01920343,
-0.020184828,
0.0349027142,
-0.0539198928,
-0.0781691372,
0.0151702864,
0.0587511025,
0.0164901204,
0.027479263,
-0.0298835635,
-0.0626141652,
0.0496226884,
-0.0104885409,
-0.0280136466,
0.0157226883,
0.0717905611,
-0.0362310335,
0.0085122334,
0.0611915402,
-0.0468637794,
0.0009917319,
0.0587827154,
-0.0022675151,
-0.035445448,
-0.0448536873,
0.0192023329,
0.0280971769,
0.0388539545,
-0.0097542945,
-0.0064671854,
-0.0105823707,
0.0423180871,
-0.0603949465,
-0.0172859691,
-0.051180169,
0.0166266952,
0.018674342,
-0.0002517634,
0.0041845953,
0.0145569248,
-0.0251465999,
-0.0190384947,
-0.0317920856,
0.0323259085,
-0.0059430934,
0.0447357483,
0.0009349385,
0.0152774295,
-0.0090856059,
0.0248443931,
-0.0084331436,
0.0340400264,
-0.007341858,
-0.0041717826,
0.0174846873,
-0.0209127516,
-0.0299550779,
0.0405226871,
-0.0686176866,
0.0170351509,
-0.043029394,
0.0129407328,
0.0409117974,
0.0068659922,
0.0467246734,
-0.0380935892,
-0.0321351178,
-0.022946775,
0.0545698963,
0.0125887301,
-0.0807538703,
-0.0062477989,
-0.0233667977,
-0.0426421016,
-0.0067533148,
0.04288131,
0.0518138446,
0.0410520099,
0.0050655715,
-0.0441329591,
-0.0302075967,
-0.0178295076,
0.0376979932,
-0.0037833797,
-0.0357486457,
0.0095855212,
-0.0485546514,
-0.1064089537,
-0.0087208934,
0.0026924121,
-0.0036202841,
0.0060632792,
-0.0092253219,
0.0140416948,
0.0057680104,
-0.0267627947,
-0.033162158,
0.0387740321,
0.0247248821,
-0.0071599865,
-0.0132901818,
-6.091233565e-33,
-0.0347786583,
-0.0199145954,
-0.034312848,
-0.0526251718,
-0.0189168155,
0.0443947762,
-0.0502435006,
-0.0090817325,
0.0027747387,
0.0182964392,
0.0029505473,
-0.0070022466,
0.0079045109,
-0.0126197664,
-0.042378515,
0.0058225361,
0.0651134998,
0.0034380152,
0.0003928098,
-0.0042884937,
0.0310832821,
0.0146975294,
0.0668850392,
-0.0389396548,
0.0249189828,
-0.0178010631,
-0.0475325435,
-0.0287997872,
-0.0220544841,
0.0434062369,
-0.0256294589,
0.0026628429,
-0.0228964631,
-0.0304485485,
-0.0631016642,
0.0418737568,
-0.0363394171,
-0.0182188023,
0.0184411537,
0.0250621084,
-0.0229658596,
-0.0762769356,
0.0290985312,
-0.0252780523,
0.0121056875,
-0.0232144222,
0.0313556567,
-0.015500579,
-0.0394520946,
-0.0211080909,
-0.0567246564,
0.0277863052,
-0.0143055869,
-0.0029211098,
0.0468744189,
0.0521361157,
0.0386524349,
0.0194019321,
-0.0730281621,
0.0280462056,
0.0401834063,
0.0270430595,
0.0643678606,
0.0026967819,
0.0056754192,
0.0094308946,
-0.0225199554,
0.0060512433,
0.008769094,
-0.0237340443,
0.0542000011,
0.000618662,
0.0798271373,
0.0198622197,
0.0429014303,
-0.0220758375,
-0.0401571505,
0.0015247412,
-0.0756472498,
0.0075334548,
0.0440606475,
0.022263851,
-0.0252423286,
0.0031806466,
-0.0403657705,
-0.0703329742,
-0.012833938,
-0.0080221603,
0.035475105,
-0.0244809501,
-0.0441265367,
0.011016571,
0.0450120009,
-0.0515291467,
-0.0284546539,
0.0076859542,
0.0139316181,
0.0351212844,
-0.0101060085,
0.0591432564,
-0.009044854,
0.0016614769,
0.0481466986,
-0.0233069547,
0.0188861098,
0.0040950952,
0.0820851997,
0.0082389945,
-0.0666246414,
-0.0044206069,
-0.0211136565,
0.0041917586,
0.0222946722,
0.0097552501,
0.0656190068,
-0.0223421436,
0.0026305893,
-0.0086373864,
0.0371346883,
-0.0048954189,
-0.0210700445,
0.0266095418,
0.0056646732,
0.0424565524,
-0.0207334645,
0.0028901664,
-0.0287456624,
0.0615392402,
0.0570571683,
-0.0214719027,
-0.0261426643,
0.0183346011,
2.68e-7,
0.0388377756,
0.017701501,
0.0217619874,
0.0231764354,
0.0108968448,
0.0505893528,
0.0146007361,
0.0347557031,
0.0154660111,
-0.0119325491,
-0.0247025304,
-0.0169508792,
0.0843872204,
-0.0045019626,
-0.0834263861,
-0.0125034656,
-0.034347035,
0.0258054454,
-0.042918317,
-0.016856106,
0.0237137191,
0.14067173,
0.0140849371,
0.0071281507,
0.0245930627,
-0.0333527587,
0.0388624109,
-0.0356794707,
-0.0012073324,
-0.0095452592,
0.0203180946,
0.0021210979,
0.0008390041,
0.0102404533,
-0.067682907,
-0.0093076909,
0.0081961183,
0.0385101289,
-0.0413871668,
-0.0061161136,
-0.0423896983,
-0.0080991518,
-0.025985362,
-0.0812693238,
0.0624146275,
0.0117313601,
-0.0450132973,
-0.0682952031,
-0.0291166585,
-0.02899996,
0.0464475155,
-0.0306640249,
-0.0276878793,
-0.0132925855,
0.0119878277,
0.0024493732,
-0.038099952,
-0.0356676839,
-0.0610053428,
-0.0443222076,
-0.022187097,
-0.0176434629,
-0.062657468,
-0.0137710581,
0.0772221684,
-0.0758188292,
0.015245663,
2.720605222e-34,
0.0207759123,
-0.0461710133,
0.0237746313,
0.0434848219,
0.0393559597,
-0.001620318,
0.0260433648,
0.006026261,
0.0221308805,
-0.0726569444,
-0.0190114249
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06469v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06469v3 | Batch-ICL: Effective, Efficient, and Order-Agnostic In-Context Learning | 2024-01-12T09:31:17 | 2024-06-05T09:13:17 | Kaiyi Zhang, Ang Lv, Yuhan Chen, Hansen Ha, Tao Xu, Rui Yan | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | In this paper, by treating in-context learning (ICL) as a meta-optimization
process, we explain why LLMs are sensitive to the order of ICL examples. This
understanding leads us to the development of Batch-ICL, an effective,
efficient, and order-agnostic inference algorithm for ICL. Differing from the
standard N-shot learning approach, Batch-ICL employs $N$ separate 1-shot
forward computations and aggregates the resulting meta-gradients. These
aggregated meta-gradients are then applied to the forward computation of a
zero-shot query to generate the final prediction. This batch processing
approach renders the LLM agnostic to the order of ICL examples. Through
extensive experiments and analysis, we demonstrate that Batch-ICL consistently
outperforms most permutations of ICL examples. In some cases, it even exceeds
the performance of the best order for standard ICL, all while reducing the
computational resources required. Furthermore, we develop a novel variant of
Batch-ICL featuring multiple "epochs" of meta-optimization. This variant
implicitly explores permutations of ICL examples, further enhancing ICL
performance. | [
-0.0185263474,
0.0538248606,
0.02494625,
0.0366171673,
-0.0148146292,
0.0432128198,
0.0458433144,
-0.0046964963,
-0.0309867412,
-0.0184037928,
-0.0075884769,
-0.0077280719,
-0.0017757775,
-0.0330213383,
0.01956705,
-0.0195819885,
0.0137751447,
0.0097954245,
-0.0326974206,
0.0040787556,
-0.045836322,
-0.0015225956,
0.0072236285,
-0.0018011525,
0.0120044146,
-0.0156765189,
-0.0466242023,
0.0639499947,
0.0568566956,
-0.0317400135,
0.006513007,
0.0046698111,
0.0372093655,
0.0276001468,
0.0000024361,
-0.0458096191,
-0.0335770361,
0.004694147,
-0.0192628372,
-0.0301458873,
-0.0155755254,
-0.0075863251,
0.0143292081,
-0.0017658388,
-0.0324575901,
-0.0089074215,
0.0469599329,
-0.0045525348,
0.0331320576,
0.0810335055,
-0.0166155379,
-0.0175569188,
-0.0389674902,
-0.0447819121,
0.0578825735,
-0.0680248812,
0.0304635931,
-0.0801918432,
-0.0162123218,
-0.0122288,
-0.005372169,
0.0465597883,
0.0313713774,
0.0269800611,
-0.0052680322,
0.0109358132,
-0.0075070611,
-0.0010871176,
-0.0196068007,
0.053068202,
-0.0429623015,
-0.0167532302,
0.009565128,
-0.0274666492,
0.0097225895,
-0.0432700515,
-0.0508479215,
0.0068849176,
-0.0174517091,
0.0225885175,
-0.0550012812,
0.0515265241,
0.0290692132,
0.0011623818,
-0.0423776023,
0.0485667251,
-0.0269038398,
0.0002862404,
-0.0139376521,
-0.0178405885,
-0.0136913266,
-0.007495719,
-0.0542527288,
0.0135021321,
-0.0499712527,
0.0067389472,
-0.0058255647,
0.0016306544,
-0.0042903218,
-0.0176947918,
0.0768011883,
0.031436719,
0.023180889,
0.0580178089,
0.0262619425,
0.0058173053,
-0.0017586541,
-0.0107902689,
-0.0435589403,
-0.0040905811,
-0.0421351194,
-0.0036326775,
-0.0261420216,
0.0407640748,
-0.0238363482,
0.043965064,
-0.0836723521,
0.0589590929,
-0.010630182,
-0.0205933694,
0.0097919945,
0.0103608286,
-0.0225157682,
-0.0317958966,
0.0109305838,
-0.0173269119,
-0.0087304618,
0.0189272575,
0.0027670984,
-0.0143815838,
-0.0199050941,
-0.0050679096,
-0.0100835646,
-0.0043335292,
0.0247439668,
0.0685569122,
0.0148443962,
-0.0363420397,
-0.0497029833,
-0.0255347583,
0.0202133991,
-0.0495518669,
-0.0053974562,
-0.0548719242,
0.0229529329,
-0.0129935527,
0.0024708484,
0.0088718869,
-0.0205734298,
0.0139004691,
-0.0343410894,
0.0716581792,
0.0009491525,
0.0036958372,
-0.0103212725,
-0.0098642996,
-0.035811007,
0.1095084697,
-0.0005963288,
0.0355325751,
0.0054296711,
0.0248091836,
-0.0083812764,
0.0174699705,
0.0559542999,
0.0096886884,
-0.0214204807,
-0.0090249516,
-0.0117287114,
0.005659895,
0.004395267,
-0.0523102134,
-0.0338698924,
-0.028194828,
0.0205293447,
0.0135324299,
0.0122138523,
-0.0400365554,
0.0212291703,
-0.0018314809,
-0.0233858377,
-0.0182246715,
-0.0643218905,
0.0558715947,
-0.0142015163,
-0.0292290561,
0.0260713026,
0.0210443437,
-0.0481319129,
-0.0499622561,
0.0304738004,
-0.0022100515,
-0.094181709,
0.0480015911,
0.0289005823,
0.0124692013,
-0.0302531384,
-0.0340526775,
0.0408011898,
0.0100839576,
-0.066778101,
-0.0326602571,
-0.0327799544,
0.0597560592,
0.0123433452,
-0.0552240312,
-0.0551139824,
0.0177031029,
0.0421211571,
0.0090618068,
-0.0578906089,
-0.0332316048,
0.081493184,
0.0011614154,
-0.0408362076,
0.0444850437,
0.0121724764,
0.0491651632,
0.0051230961,
-0.0119304294,
0.009335814,
-0.024290178,
0.0405406356,
0.0050368719,
-0.0294027589,
-0.0599574111,
0.0837735087,
0.0337383337,
0.043554008,
-0.017999772,
0.0087030493,
-0.0217575524,
0.0259528458,
-0.0118569769,
-0.0331327841,
0.0233699121,
-0.0351886824,
-0.0956158638,
0.0214932244,
-0.0091462685,
-0.0058029117,
-0.0708898678,
-0.1032142267,
-0.0062286346,
-0.0185376257,
0.0286061615,
0.0708991736,
-0.03089297,
0.0066366843,
0.0109667303,
-0.0321144089,
-0.0584890731,
0.0550992191,
-0.0329742618,
-0.0352275185,
0.0590560623,
-0.0235258881,
0.0007299275,
-0.0075581167,
0.0075776433,
0.0035522408,
-0.0302890781,
0.0016884569,
-0.010558934,
0.0092449188,
-0.037598487,
0.0168913957,
-0.0751699507,
-0.0021795454,
-0.029978836,
0.0104606031,
0.0077450769,
0.0312530696,
-0.0050769141,
-0.0364292338,
0.0088699488,
0.0207038838,
-0.0263632834,
0.0298831183,
0.0212492701,
0.0296297297,
-0.0182133187,
0.0113226417,
-0.0239577573,
-0.0231170021,
0.0706433505,
-0.0119212568,
-0.0307520702,
-0.0045797904,
-0.0272708051,
-0.0048526172,
-0.0113995308,
-0.0305294823,
0.0264433119,
-0.0331891403,
-0.0558111332,
-0.0364418291,
0.073232688,
0.0157747734,
0.0039405711,
-0.0059989323,
0.0040259054,
-0.0578929335,
0.0253953002,
-0.0107110422,
0.0063729929,
-0.0129065784,
0.0210464634,
0.0174780209,
0.0305128004,
-0.018309433,
0.0040131314,
-0.0279355738,
0.0531992652,
0.0416947342,
-0.0799988955,
-0.0991638452,
0.04281196,
0.004186694,
0.0189058483,
-0.0021735604,
-0.039699994,
0.0494341478,
0.0416009612,
0.0073315743,
-0.0028648626,
-0.0056486004,
-0.0235427786,
0.0034677251,
0.0022458159,
0.0337583348,
0.0056945574,
-0.0039590234,
-0.0532803833,
0.0047374913,
0.0335371234,
0.0102220466,
0.0175504368,
-0.0057784235,
0.0044316729,
-0.0001544059,
-0.055645816,
-0.0559301488,
-0.0431109071,
0.036311876,
0.0165445954,
-0.0601247437,
0.0097354148,
-0.0578277931,
-0.0114651583,
0.0033268067,
0.0217379592,
-0.0325787924,
-0.0577667803,
0.001681775,
0.0033897457,
0.0106933285,
-0.069421038,
-0.0325874351,
-0.0088292751,
0.040602386,
0.0513732061,
0.0562906936,
-0.0154664544,
-0.0295013878,
0.0233909469,
0.0415304899,
-0.0152951013,
-0.0125994366,
0.0558316372,
-0.0312806517,
-0.0503634736,
-0.0047271983,
0.066640906,
0.0196186081,
-0.0844966769,
-0.019068392,
0.019319769,
0.0060679582,
0.0218385402,
0.0369401351,
-0.0796652585,
-0.0421175472,
-0.0091502406,
0.0312364455,
0.0127350576,
-0.0288639553,
-0.0284243897,
-0.0886582881,
0.0559433363,
-0.0038460067,
-0.046730984,
-0.0224749073,
-0.0601029843,
-0.0135612329,
-0.0253374428,
-0.0141658466,
0.0629928038,
-0.0313665867,
-0.0184913483,
0.019827459,
0.0347388647,
-0.0525022298,
0.0054026009,
-0.0121706435,
-0.033072222,
0.0741684288,
0.0070023574,
0.0226599425,
-0.0023271879,
0.0650554523,
-0.0195513871,
0.0184164345,
-0.0504011661,
0.0789381042,
-0.0440751463,
0.0070679975,
0.0188197307,
0.0311783999,
-0.0101564936,
-0.0168112181,
0.0205974896,
0.0535093546,
-0.0234741867,
0.0149759473,
-0.0270639788,
-0.0471929386,
0.041772116,
0.0422555879,
-0.0063465904,
-0.0531972088,
-0.0175465811,
-0.0193508044,
-0.0367185101,
-0.0177465901,
0.054747887,
0.0039950646,
-0.0160033237,
-0.0492331423,
-0.0439666174,
0.000594247,
-0.00789274,
0.1058124825,
-0.0464076772,
-0.0017508536,
-0.0186513718,
0.0025257065,
-0.0572224781,
-0.0530117564,
0.0114318198,
0.0048491452,
-0.0487621538,
0.000639641,
0.0839373171,
-0.0218302179,
-0.0339095406,
0.0074139317,
-0.0851350725,
-0.072233513,
-0.005624793,
0.066275917,
0.0062153377,
0.0940374434,
0.0127715524,
0.0066629271,
0.1311620474,
0.1083101407,
0.0699232668,
0.0256444588,
0.0693074092,
0.00416299,
-0.0035776345,
0.0315422118,
-0.044248879,
0.035855677,
0.0225826353,
-0.03311643,
-0.0570113771,
0.0420824699,
0.0062728352,
-0.0152331106,
0.0698344857,
-0.0357524306,
-0.0462414287,
-0.0020295475,
0.0756124482,
-0.0034756665,
-0.0333699398,
-0.0307099707,
0.0085757254,
0.0056360057,
-0.0027590776,
-0.0205596332,
0.003844762,
0.0423364639,
-0.0237753522,
-0.0172109809,
-0.0014962301,
-0.0156563707,
0.029956881,
0.0104358727,
0.0221090689,
0.0105728107,
0.0403818116,
0.0451940224,
0.0432244018,
-0.030142488,
0.0099380435,
0.0507106446,
0.0539645478,
-0.0827835947,
0.0555458255,
-0.0753972605,
0.031100696,
-0.0336215347,
0.0099748652,
0.0766380057,
-0.0077483556,
0.0291004404,
0.0012990884,
-0.0057808002,
-0.0368008874,
0.0254383255,
-0.0048904284,
0.0003713331,
-0.0024753928,
0.0285208933,
0.00534527,
0.026361648,
0.0784913078,
0.0000482606,
0.025492372,
0.018953884,
0.0185240414,
-0.0253390539,
0.0115250191,
0.0337010399,
0.0462155715,
0.0296954755,
0.009988226,
-0.0412790887,
-0.0074644419,
0.0467799976,
-0.028875351,
-0.0012830456,
0.0227131844,
0.0532731712,
0.0657423362,
0.0396139286,
-0.0164299104,
0.0028731222,
-0.0475072823,
-0.0053859283,
-0.0335700773,
0.0117179789,
-6.863491844e-33,
-0.0219171233,
-0.0338373818,
0.0238533188,
0.0041841264,
0.0271465499,
0.0077764108,
-0.0082619209,
-0.0425677747,
0.0128787663,
-0.0046287472,
-0.0391049013,
0.0038422477,
0.0173826646,
0.009102501,
0.0348561816,
-0.0180350505,
0.0313255712,
-0.0032833619,
-0.0016902155,
0.0227995981,
0.0383893624,
0.0603002496,
0.040203955,
-0.0103888987,
-0.0575381815,
0.0297304373,
-0.0255968887,
0.0188590344,
-0.0209836643,
0.0237781424,
0.0320746005,
0.008509771,
0.0235708375,
-0.0254834872,
-0.0277608074,
-0.0230990723,
-0.059532214,
-0.0459009521,
-0.0336922221,
0.0037917814,
-0.0129110171,
-0.0087204697,
0.0101333391,
0.0143398196,
-0.0152753396,
-0.0783634409,
0.0280307289,
-0.0023494326,
-0.015476808,
-0.0894078389,
-0.017479267,
0.0320682563,
-0.0195355322,
0.011153047,
0.0378185399,
0.0266931076,
0.0234723017,
0.0481103621,
-0.0462937616,
0.0311507341,
-0.0500776581,
0.0152022224,
0.0353500694,
0.0641863942,
0.0498280525,
0.0222985782,
0.0390671939,
0.0194833651,
0.0427028425,
-0.007266731,
0.02144037,
0.0448353663,
-0.0492440425,
0.0818525031,
0.0911036581,
0.0255008712,
-0.1037802771,
0.0377522893,
-0.0041545723,
0.0010121249,
-0.0159178749,
0.0057980912,
-0.0411921777,
-0.0336277559,
-0.0117901266,
-0.0570561327,
-0.0215184726,
0.0132587347,
0.0308568459,
0.0250417423,
-0.0096119074,
0.008469888,
0.0526342392,
-0.0304181986,
-0.0129274726,
0.0508701093,
-0.02380847,
-0.0096580675,
0.0453281887,
0.0291132908,
-0.052439902,
-0.018435644,
-0.0161103755,
0.0196592622,
0.0123326592,
0.001833368,
0.0713719875,
0.0252753124,
-0.0475702435,
-0.0229041018,
-0.0268401112,
0.0270485468,
-0.0108043868,
-0.0248857867,
0.0165309552,
0.0008661171,
-0.0075173229,
0.0576238073,
0.0095679825,
-0.036804907,
-0.0170226786,
-0.0060121273,
-0.0421076715,
-0.0044178595,
-0.0171150863,
0.0276427846,
0.0151713053,
-0.0160045922,
0.0386241898,
-0.0735089332,
-0.0313496701,
0.0240152571,
3.091e-7,
0.0185743123,
0.0313652419,
0.0154320579,
0.0355701894,
0.0263161417,
0.0266653616,
-0.0376912169,
0.0115942508,
0.0359093733,
0.0300444793,
0.0814439282,
0.020674305,
0.0053128498,
0.0191028658,
-0.068176128,
0.0500317961,
-0.033098489,
0.0237539317,
-0.0378588177,
-0.02488303,
-0.0286916662,
0.0679543018,
0.0255085975,
-0.0368939824,
0.0483272374,
0.0034480279,
0.049474813,
-0.0174567848,
0.0223024823,
-0.0049048136,
-0.0534650385,
-0.0059676473,
0.005598837,
0.00417493,
-0.0254619867,
0.0274001583,
-0.0415517539,
0.0402194485,
-0.0374445207,
-0.0578448847,
0.01223063,
0.018399056,
0.0211437363,
-0.0106929848,
0.0934386775,
-0.0531507656,
0.0066671977,
-0.0353091508,
-0.0262311287,
-0.0029601918,
0.0243439302,
0.0163669363,
-0.0120837353,
0.043664664,
0.0082797613,
-0.0163227767,
-0.0260470472,
-0.0575836636,
-0.0369587876,
-0.0034152153,
-0.0027895798,
-0.0429575332,
0.0027492517,
0.0208481457,
0.0483950004,
-0.0312134475,
-0.0214664582,
3.055368794e-34,
0.0233717002,
-0.007274434,
0.0237458833,
0.0460634194,
-0.0417061374,
-0.0130558014,
-0.0613904744,
0.0170743205,
0.0578139871,
-0.0418038517,
-0.0188462231
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06468v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06468v3 | Adapting Large Language Models for Document-Level Machine Translation | 2024-01-12T09:29:13 | 2024-06-09T13:13:03 | Minghao Wu, Thuy-Trang Vu, Lizhen Qu, George Foster, Gholamreza Haffari | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have significantly advanced various natural
language processing (NLP) tasks. Recent research indicates that
moderately-sized LLMs often outperform larger ones after task-specific
fine-tuning. This study focuses on adapting LLMs for document-level machine
translation (DocMT) for specific language pairs. We first investigate the
impact of prompt strategies on translation performance and then conduct
extensive experiments using two fine-tuning methods, three LLM backbones, and
18 translation tasks across nine language pairs. Our results show that
specialized models can sometimes surpass GPT-4 in translation performance but
still face issues like off-target translation due to error propagation in
decoding. We provide an in-depth analysis of these LLMs tailored for DocMT,
examining translation errors, discourse phenomena, training strategies, the
scaling law of parallel documents, recent test set evaluations, and zero-shot
crosslingual transfer. Our findings highlight the strengths and limitations of
LLM-based DocMT models and provide a foundation for future research. | [
0.0343043134,
0.0297267195,
0.0062419181,
0.0442763716,
-0.0479900278,
0.0195275582,
0.0335418396,
-0.0043823812,
-0.030061543,
-0.0487567298,
-0.0527050905,
-0.0397958644,
0.0323275216,
-0.0395527631,
0.0207293388,
-0.036977794,
0.0485872179,
-0.0473666675,
-0.0283278655,
0.0045447606,
-0.0143632637,
0.0231471583,
0.0197877716,
0.0153136076,
0.0206014998,
-0.0256497283,
0.0303726532,
0.0678342283,
0.0304745771,
-0.0294727236,
-0.0111269811,
0.0265182238,
0.0309371222,
0.0719413459,
0.0000020182,
-0.0326415673,
-0.0343158394,
0.0203573201,
0.0176843014,
0.0381172076,
0.0538685098,
-0.0872530118,
-0.0185524691,
0.0375335142,
-0.0004753733,
-0.0496502817,
0.033732906,
0.0462260582,
0.0427963547,
0.1048499867,
-0.0183675699,
-0.0276661962,
0.0346418768,
-0.0613031872,
-0.0197586957,
-0.0825241059,
0.0058502825,
0.0173121877,
-0.0110561531,
0.051742781,
-0.0124054654,
0.0292715915,
-0.0231294744,
0.0030053102,
-0.02695016,
-0.0000120447,
-0.0164655633,
-0.0183851644,
-0.0358726606,
0.0600264445,
-0.0267104376,
-0.0019744639,
-0.0271300133,
-0.0171572473,
-0.0284291822,
-0.0090726689,
-0.0533675216,
0.0258388128,
-0.0038677377,
0.014364033,
0.0419687852,
0.0123111596,
0.0388964266,
0.0011558103,
-0.0561732315,
0.018632248,
0.0505987331,
-0.0302216355,
0.0101733869,
0.0139268506,
-0.0483352691,
-0.0119929761,
0.0477777533,
-0.009672191,
-0.0220730659,
0.0141634205,
-0.0458251089,
-0.0398735777,
0.0217260197,
-0.0335987024,
0.0595581718,
0.0607008673,
-0.0006747193,
0.0651224181,
-0.0248188451,
0.0805758238,
-0.0443622433,
-0.0097506978,
-0.0648739189,
-0.021099044,
-0.0322107337,
0.02882348,
-0.0461377837,
-0.0228898209,
-0.0643136874,
-0.0255248118,
0.0095018772,
0.0219847485,
0.0538638271,
0.0109289307,
0.0365032628,
-0.0530742407,
-0.0747607797,
-0.0555300862,
0.0114304675,
0.0766028762,
-0.0022585376,
-0.0082472423,
-0.000742334,
-0.058826331,
-0.0253895018,
0.0169267748,
-0.0028286169,
-0.0521608144,
-0.0011445,
0.0608510636,
-0.0150505779,
-0.0263538901,
-0.0018402054,
0.0217843615,
-0.0083355773,
-0.0756074339,
-0.0246871896,
-0.0523629375,
0.0507380739,
0.0182128623,
0.0508128218,
-0.018857481,
0.0110179689,
0.0148864575,
-0.0591104962,
0.0729096755,
0.031548854,
0.022973638,
0.0366728269,
-0.0182363726,
0.0026690753,
0.0717697889,
0.0347586796,
0.014734095,
0.0366385654,
-0.0203528926,
-0.0391808711,
0.0601226985,
-0.0133553743,
0.05475967,
-0.0012001067,
0.0097833201,
0.0351269059,
0.0538376123,
0.0306660905,
0.0626089945,
-0.0364342816,
0.0238002855,
0.0869071856,
0.0511076152,
-0.0088689057,
0.0223495066,
0.0310889296,
0.0187545288,
-0.0127513492,
-0.0176318102,
-0.0305911191,
-0.0315253288,
-0.0047981082,
-0.0114825051,
0.0330376066,
0.0436014608,
-0.021184152,
0.0087274173,
-0.0335491188,
-0.0048392429,
-0.0002854666,
-0.021129841,
0.0540717952,
0.0079980381,
-0.0789152384,
0.0238356385,
-0.0082627423,
-0.0227879249,
0.0026932489,
-0.0176893882,
-0.0194209125,
0.0565156825,
0.0721049011,
0.0116905859,
-0.0383345746,
-0.0126498453,
0.0287789926,
0.0708025917,
0.0872032344,
0.0308745224,
0.0032363888,
-0.0492683835,
-0.0033913006,
-0.0028629068,
0.0125728194,
0.0339355282,
0.0028142303,
0.0446905158,
0.0384934545,
-0.0376902185,
-0.0777612403,
0.0256031156,
-0.0488898791,
-0.0525017902,
0.0363495201,
-0.0209780522,
0.0142184747,
-0.0023940329,
-0.0088083288,
-0.0070325253,
-0.0010032718,
-0.023509752,
0.0047944789,
0.0144310379,
-0.0340382122,
-0.0341037475,
0.0067985482,
-0.0165204778,
0.0022636242,
0.0122547373,
-0.0498453714,
-0.047054816,
-0.030535413,
-0.0127381561,
-0.0090002641,
-0.0239677094,
0.0516677499,
0.0022001117,
0.0184632074,
-0.0316399448,
0.0156553257,
0.0201278888,
-0.0192682557,
0.0239543263,
0.0045631239,
0.0163667239,
-0.0194651056,
-0.0178373959,
0.0539820045,
0.0232674163,
0.0173995942,
0.0325058065,
0.0399267562,
-0.0165144783,
-0.0478605516,
-0.0915113464,
0.0556893423,
-0.0186477397,
0.0565737039,
0.0484506786,
0.0326564573,
-0.0194858946,
0.0092049399,
-0.0057235057,
0.0014537657,
0.0350020789,
0.0222030208,
0.0108919796,
-0.0143471882,
0.0106509458,
-0.0265122727,
-0.000459238,
0.0226406436,
0.0261332579,
0.0014933154,
-0.0232430939,
-0.0810249448,
0.0479130298,
-0.0068530319,
0.0090718344,
0.0013372605,
-0.035508927,
-0.0037181359,
-0.0273227766,
0.0637574494,
0.0570373274,
-0.0092208488,
0.0231220555,
0.0101876892,
-0.0189088229,
-0.0546196662,
0.0135609228,
-0.011486684,
-0.0736407116,
-0.0425977185,
-0.0452199876,
0.0125098331,
0.0557490438,
-0.0034384788,
0.0031827465,
-0.0630618483,
0.0076382905,
-0.0264289994,
-0.001327484,
0.0005150238,
0.0084132021,
0.0166682675,
0.0300614592,
-0.0191645604,
-0.0435255952,
0.0255892444,
-0.0581533723,
0.0052680154,
-0.0650106519,
0.0210077595,
-0.0459179915,
0.0439686216,
-0.00465002,
0.0020301817,
-0.0331512913,
-0.0312035941,
-0.0135434419,
0.0088351006,
0.0056604492,
-0.0247077998,
0.0258491822,
-0.0755251646,
0.0003824738,
-0.0452167355,
-0.0363678485,
-0.0028134903,
-0.0333637036,
-0.0072528077,
0.0121962642,
0.0116993124,
-0.0310898609,
-0.0465619564,
0.0225850455,
0.0079673575,
0.0620371774,
-0.0346429422,
-0.0081145167,
-0.0383584127,
0.0332399085,
0.0127153825,
-0.0050809234,
0.0227623321,
-0.0551952682,
0.0369248614,
0.016174309,
0.0212550033,
-0.0038486479,
-0.0312877558,
-0.0294873267,
0.0468499586,
-0.0182594005,
-0.0419763513,
-0.02005901,
0.0868543535,
-0.0853555351,
-0.0265360158,
0.1105645597,
0.0226931889,
-0.052731581,
-0.0245453492,
-0.0162983332,
0.0137568358,
-0.0140945446,
0.0379387103,
-0.0758051947,
-0.0399692096,
0.0207325798,
0.037185967,
0.0283930302,
0.0071423021,
-0.0208231285,
-0.1099610925,
0.0316610485,
0.060389027,
-0.0302986931,
-0.0315651149,
-0.0311996229,
-0.0176205337,
-0.0186995436,
0.0662680417,
-0.0035419795,
-0.0080773467,
-0.0126996702,
0.002320169,
0.0236733761,
-0.0806519613,
0.0134741571,
-0.0362346582,
0.0359949842,
0.0636014715,
0.0338890105,
0.0053175818,
-0.0020989063,
0.0618166178,
-0.0396590084,
0.0141463028,
-0.0283723548,
-0.0117866434,
-0.0170464311,
0.0046858429,
0.0257571153,
0.005119035,
-0.0414000936,
0.0299994666,
0.0321989916,
0.0607235096,
-0.0181993302,
-0.0127395969,
0.0182947312,
-0.0342510566,
0.0062155477,
0.0705329254,
0.0162249543,
-0.032589674,
-0.044593364,
-0.0121094296,
-0.0113511682,
-0.0428494066,
0.0204123147,
-0.0164497476,
-0.0342638306,
-0.0121222492,
-0.0701375678,
-0.0493901893,
0.0239075087,
0.0102094235,
0.025718227,
0.0107146874,
-0.0092115244,
-0.000986941,
0.019874895,
0.0535053127,
-0.0345430374,
0.0104649961,
-0.0793312863,
0.0341021307,
0.0388372429,
-0.0354520157,
0.0092091095,
0.0195826292,
-0.0782378092,
-0.0735714361,
-0.044621475,
0.024211701,
0.0183496885,
0.0570143498,
-0.0442808568,
-0.0579775721,
0.0067178248,
0.0216853134,
-0.0392920785,
0.0126451701,
0.0133616319,
0.0147750573,
-0.0198060796,
0.0496802554,
-0.0023254408,
0.0134045081,
0.0019405398,
0.0715309232,
-0.0012273917,
-0.0716782436,
0.0039747329,
0.0282438304,
0.0295028482,
-0.0088938791,
-0.0231203083,
-0.0169284288,
0.0303231124,
-0.0310346298,
-0.0032836921,
-0.0469382964,
-0.0235313121,
0.0739777088,
-0.0119040143,
-0.0280345324,
0.0051126452,
-0.0063759228,
0.0134476796,
-0.0314252377,
0.0144539168,
-0.0363428779,
0.0266125426,
0.0159688909,
0.0079517849,
-0.0331744067,
0.0020688546,
-0.0059308209,
0.0277713276,
-0.0508856997,
0.058712557,
0.0035712912,
0.0064014802,
0.0112126805,
0.0298351627,
-0.0326687656,
-0.0529386401,
-0.0079251872,
0.0129890041,
0.0680073723,
-0.0068064835,
0.1358394474,
-0.030439198,
-0.0198918357,
-0.0376503691,
0.0290057287,
0.0262790453,
0.0194922518,
0.0014948762,
-0.006074409,
0.0065043322,
0.0257216692,
0.076419659,
0.0125744259,
0.0247144494,
0.0192552805,
-0.026162494,
-0.0165296383,
-0.0018984684,
0.0163949933,
-0.0297566056,
-0.0191172753,
-0.0065354994,
-0.0230360199,
-0.0240540504,
-0.0065063289,
-0.0054727863,
-0.0086880373,
-0.0247112121,
-0.0234323163,
0.0892321169,
-0.0337246805,
-0.0017511486,
-0.046709422,
0.0106824646,
-0.0058969106,
-0.0205607004,
-0.0228498839,
-6.553574228e-33,
-0.0517892279,
0.009866057,
0.019148143,
-0.0174744595,
-0.0379607528,
-0.0083162328,
-0.0405307412,
-0.0270726234,
0.003483318,
0.0123423645,
-0.0367314592,
-0.0021083704,
0.0198342409,
0.0106615135,
-0.0063463091,
0.0233156625,
0.0734444186,
-0.0085583162,
-0.0366522484,
0.0354364812,
0.0526258834,
0.012256586,
0.080250226,
-0.0343994088,
0.0293172356,
-0.0108684888,
-0.0183771737,
0.0220467988,
0.0030627586,
0.0104819378,
-0.0076315487,
0.0047134152,
0.0261755455,
-0.0337245055,
-0.0332857147,
0.0146230739,
-0.0907774419,
0.0144772297,
0.0494575053,
0.029635014,
0.0016898876,
-0.0521928854,
0.0232046116,
-0.0161731672,
-0.0040972368,
-0.0275384113,
-0.0175285731,
-0.0445544235,
-0.039593827,
0.0028138643,
-0.0749463215,
0.0384065211,
-0.0017339435,
0.003806344,
0.0409082882,
0.0402257666,
-0.0386532433,
0.0395067744,
-0.0565114692,
-0.0071240584,
0.0066442164,
0.0427000597,
0.0435204543,
-0.0055414787,
-0.0294132382,
-0.0025821854,
-0.0067554689,
0.0150020504,
0.011410458,
-0.0139682768,
0.0156553332,
0.0157343261,
0.0407883264,
0.0312031507,
0.0280646197,
-0.0082723033,
-0.0591622256,
0.0289123282,
-0.0002159418,
0.0295263045,
0.034027867,
0.0134847602,
-0.0139407841,
0.0055563236,
-0.0605973937,
-0.0119352294,
-0.0289827827,
-0.0116575975,
0.0255271289,
0.014936517,
-0.0215636473,
0.0009535722,
0.0848550573,
-0.0098130601,
-0.0001346886,
0.0077085807,
-0.0308050346,
0.0060064262,
-0.0423490256,
0.0492728278,
-0.0496164411,
-0.0549876392,
0.0092822602,
0.0117619373,
-0.0096488744,
-0.0208413359,
0.0215695836,
0.0201896653,
-0.0696263909,
0.0050428631,
-0.0383795947,
0.014935893,
-0.0324149989,
0.0397849455,
0.0223624967,
-0.0170919113,
0.0029658859,
0.0536728166,
0.017321866,
-0.0253258757,
-0.007723806,
-0.0073300228,
0.0034712229,
0.0187673066,
-0.0325913057,
0.0301237237,
-0.0181936156,
0.0185111426,
0.0421529971,
-0.0262324568,
-0.0315822475,
0.0115024345,
2.776e-7,
0.0429260992,
0.0808596388,
-0.0024891132,
0.0245449059,
0.0189857967,
0.0171039086,
-0.0245715361,
0.0484021306,
0.0357804,
0.0363697745,
0.0336461067,
0.0323158428,
0.111343883,
0.0108232191,
-0.0635790229,
-0.0271169022,
-0.0400432013,
0.0457925163,
-0.0757721514,
-0.0216647219,
0.0168138836,
0.0728330612,
-0.0320385769,
0.008265486,
-0.0039897212,
-0.0369577371,
0.1028306559,
-0.0456088819,
-0.0355973057,
0.0227792095,
0.0274917614,
0.0274249688,
-0.0318436734,
0.0173593499,
-0.0179942995,
0.0134757608,
0.0299704242,
0.0986376032,
0.0104616582,
0.019716043,
0.0117647313,
-0.0095318677,
-0.0155408345,
-0.0634758845,
0.060971681,
-0.040599592,
-0.0155465603,
-0.0000934163,
-0.0232375003,
-0.0192195922,
0.0366870649,
-0.0505328029,
-0.0433665551,
0.03190751,
0.0547057204,
0.0082299365,
-0.0433709323,
-0.031668961,
0.0088416804,
-0.0097914245,
-0.0191664584,
-0.0519261695,
-0.0226179026,
0.0192170441,
-0.0088100284,
-0.0509211123,
0.0007613382,
2.760647105e-34,
0.0702167228,
-0.032455828,
0.0122999856,
-0.0217529293,
0.0460303612,
-0.0075118458,
0.0005649704,
0.0220315941,
-0.0135532347,
-0.1023073345,
-0.0128312176
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06466v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06466v1 | PersianMind: A Cross-Lingual Persian-English Large Language Model | 2024-01-12T09:24:10 | 2024-01-12T09:24:10 | Pedram Rostami, Ali Salemi, Mohammad Javad Dousti | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models demonstrate remarkable proficiency in various
linguistic tasks and have extensive knowledge across various domains. Although
they perform best in English, their ability in other languages is notable too.
In contrast, open-source models, such as LLaMa, are primarily trained on
English datasets, resulting in poor performance in non-English languages. In
this paper, we introduce PersianMind, an open-source bilingual large language
model which demonstrates comparable performance to closed-source GPT-3.5-turbo
in the Persian language. By expanding LLaMa2's vocabulary with 10,000 Persian
tokens and training it on a dataset comprising nearly 2 billion Persian tokens,
we show that our approach preserves the model's English knowledge and employs
transfer learning to excel at transferring task knowledge from one language to
another. | [
-0.0038403065,
0.0632405952,
-0.0142086772,
0.0730098709,
-0.0240498912,
0.0304061677,
0.0114993965,
-0.0028715422,
0.0416483954,
-0.00319927,
-0.1039319187,
-0.0487340316,
-0.0018436682,
0.0031236159,
0.036288172,
-0.0322435945,
0.0353709757,
-0.0728006586,
-0.0103346277,
-0.0029427859,
0.014160688,
0.0191090647,
-0.0188128725,
0.0090649808,
-0.0356390662,
-0.0154953534,
0.0180081762,
-0.0204191897,
0.0118767396,
-0.0196584035,
0.0062113591,
0.0030886114,
0.0105450982,
0.0266130995,
0.0000016643,
-0.0425397567,
-0.0223943274,
-0.0274463259,
0.0396607406,
-0.0166982319,
0.0396648273,
-0.0234642718,
-0.0418009199,
0.0243613999,
-0.0342324078,
-0.0581218228,
0.0714103803,
0.0421280265,
0.0489432104,
0.0572426431,
-0.017450083,
-0.0619140752,
0.0176437199,
-0.0387397967,
0.0142354211,
-0.0676268637,
0.0458631031,
-0.0207609832,
-0.0262283776,
-0.0248154607,
-0.0098229274,
0.0184868686,
0.0045312927,
-0.0162528418,
-0.0091808783,
0.0024718076,
-0.0639409199,
-0.0094059212,
0.022676982,
0.0777095482,
-0.0419601463,
-0.0225823931,
0.0080830753,
0.0216377042,
-0.0254502669,
-0.0080120582,
-0.0612546131,
0.0346657708,
0.009713171,
0.041062247,
0.0512999892,
-0.0036287145,
0.0390540622,
0.0023058923,
-0.0494426079,
0.039481312,
0.0540778562,
-0.0225509312,
0.0267591979,
-0.0028825665,
-0.0380151719,
-0.0302328356,
0.0222348962,
0.0246888828,
-0.0640284866,
0.0128348731,
-0.0204708073,
-0.0299760979,
0.0240111314,
-0.0531451628,
0.0494376644,
0.069195807,
-0.0051985169,
0.0596343316,
-0.0756167844,
0.0242529344,
-0.0098470747,
0.0282378756,
-0.0576486588,
-0.0569521897,
-0.0359520465,
0.0250062905,
-0.025392931,
0.0275279041,
-0.0209600031,
-0.007888821,
-0.0569887459,
-0.0025534197,
0.012603919,
0.0276865382,
0.0334445834,
-0.0272812471,
-0.0458916649,
-0.0115347775,
0.0029272973,
0.0386347622,
-0.0133715682,
0.0283510834,
-0.0309186056,
-0.0574738346,
-0.0125377979,
0.0413728282,
-0.0193950199,
-0.0168898981,
0.0083506815,
0.056467589,
0.0053037005,
-0.0307034496,
-0.0274988711,
0.0626255721,
0.0073388889,
-0.0674802288,
0.0068248836,
-0.0479065888,
0.0502096936,
0.0052683339,
-0.0121921105,
-0.0228076056,
0.0111433528,
0.0389434434,
-0.0000038455,
0.0828224644,
0.0302217864,
0.009478271,
0.0334192812,
-0.0097985044,
0.0004176561,
0.0755001977,
0.0397907533,
0.0044607292,
0.0193281472,
-0.0273365844,
-0.0396749862,
0.04798536,
0.0239518285,
0.0168647468,
-0.0113543877,
-0.0015950694,
0.0703384131,
0.0812429115,
-0.0061820112,
0.056176763,
0.0019445884,
0.0496090427,
0.0403454937,
0.0354443491,
0.0079406183,
0.0444868058,
0.0315129347,
0.0104958145,
0.010093838,
-0.0118645867,
-0.0261569712,
0.0190122798,
0.056688346,
0.021768529,
-0.0095092803,
0.048803281,
-0.050148204,
0.0126431091,
0.0022949365,
-0.062021669,
0.0010533726,
-0.0057052583,
0.1045878455,
0.0157589875,
-0.0351703279,
0.0751839206,
0.0653887317,
-0.0002291508,
0.0413790457,
-0.0807251707,
0.0422523022,
0.0455315001,
-0.018186247,
-0.0537386388,
0.0109229255,
-0.0078952992,
0.0032019918,
0.0045496831,
0.0474584848,
-0.0322594792,
0.0083636977,
-0.0725321844,
0.0146735189,
-0.0033758255,
0.0112627884,
0.0158177484,
-0.0025902861,
0.0579447821,
0.0189095195,
0.0041331928,
-0.0031364986,
0.0151752383,
-0.0548591353,
-0.0048554591,
0.0102008907,
-0.0047390722,
-0.0225284919,
-0.0160595421,
-0.0020236461,
-0.0122612854,
0.0409865789,
-0.0657251254,
0.016498968,
-0.0190223139,
-0.0486248247,
-0.0026797317,
0.0593720675,
-0.0205679089,
-0.015018044,
0.0440987647,
-0.044246681,
-0.0627344176,
0.0783762187,
-0.002039562,
0.0225942396,
-0.0533787012,
0.0345161147,
0.0124252103,
0.0543619879,
-0.0075572697,
0.0387321673,
0.0220511146,
-0.002444753,
0.0053438917,
-0.0398264043,
0.0094220489,
0.0038007228,
0.00674828,
0.0639858544,
0.0355954841,
0.0005809474,
0.0165872686,
0.0046393676,
-0.0214601178,
-0.0561675839,
-0.0645278096,
0.0228543561,
-0.0186807271,
0.0593546219,
-0.0222175717,
0.0345764756,
-0.0111069893,
-0.0024808196,
-0.0439124666,
-0.0056643547,
0.0161792301,
0.0015083862,
0.0390120856,
-0.0119520267,
-0.0142401373,
-0.0388583131,
-0.0449921526,
0.0318063013,
0.0219790637,
-0.028262049,
-0.0451740772,
-0.0112417722,
-0.0085997842,
0.0031145825,
0.0378570445,
-0.0027494202,
-0.0193969291,
-0.0072074495,
-0.0406679176,
0.0489471667,
0.024246458,
-0.0300032664,
-0.0336890258,
0.0249726158,
-0.0382096656,
-0.0200048368,
0.0090489201,
0.0074334978,
-0.041446466,
-0.0558365695,
-0.0074468711,
-0.0486830808,
0.03922306,
-0.0495381579,
-0.0340779945,
-0.0561638288,
-0.0139089907,
-0.0272508767,
0.0122507205,
0.0022567702,
0.0467308871,
-0.0095506189,
0.0292502269,
-0.0182884336,
-0.0219005495,
0.0225848388,
-0.0419662148,
0.0055322363,
-0.0049381205,
-0.0005433582,
-0.0780498013,
0.0168288872,
-0.0234443899,
-0.0022396781,
-0.0283482652,
-0.0353914611,
-0.0533455797,
-0.0179223213,
-0.0127458517,
-0.0320696309,
0.0434598327,
-0.0431466363,
0.005443485,
-0.048775699,
-0.0262725949,
-0.0291364193,
0.031373363,
-0.0177845526,
0.0386463255,
0.0472621061,
-0.0366860963,
-0.0187084395,
-0.006245486,
0.0381196439,
0.0553605407,
-0.006236217,
0.0391018242,
-0.0079393489,
-0.0198206101,
0.0402876437,
0.0357640386,
0.0182119533,
-0.032070104,
0.0170727875,
0.0190749727,
0.0490970574,
-0.0193450488,
-0.0249262247,
-0.008156375,
0.0407296903,
-0.0436553285,
-0.0437948518,
-0.0391032584,
-0.0060100728,
-0.0447729193,
-0.0141229806,
0.0856783912,
-0.0089527136,
-0.0323916711,
-0.0188096501,
-0.0313631855,
-0.0214723237,
0.035411872,
0.0193971694,
-0.069249332,
-0.0214660857,
0.0215367265,
-0.031663049,
0.0441702418,
0.0005529606,
-0.0126872519,
-0.11696437,
-0.0304458309,
-0.0146263363,
-0.0737714544,
-0.0346377678,
-0.0318503045,
-0.0166325886,
0.0049926448,
0.0118628228,
-0.0450995862,
-0.0195728093,
-0.0162746105,
0.0371055938,
0.0249377768,
-0.0686424673,
0.0159074441,
-0.0404863879,
0.0290010348,
0.0471871682,
0.0458746292,
-0.0240192227,
-0.0809742883,
0.0223691147,
-0.0383387357,
-0.0582643449,
0.0024403667,
-0.0001061859,
-0.0013238756,
-0.0397750176,
0.0248928871,
0.0028801272,
-0.0764380097,
0.0210717935,
0.0010428072,
0.0862034708,
0.0318894647,
0.0025764923,
0.0455310009,
-0.0251956787,
0.0165643562,
0.0302306581,
-0.0108210882,
-0.0215851404,
-0.0409583189,
0.0299871154,
-0.0584429801,
-0.0512927063,
-0.0144118974,
0.0090879342,
0.0007858411,
-0.0241495781,
-0.069199346,
0.0078151124,
0.0337415934,
0.0198265221,
0.031804245,
0.0529716983,
0.0113658877,
-0.0224615373,
0.0017310203,
0.0111080902,
-0.021614844,
0.025750855,
-0.0563750342,
-0.0266860947,
0.0621706918,
-0.057447467,
0.0016495971,
0.033662498,
-0.0601904504,
-0.0289674103,
0.0122893825,
0.0583704039,
0.0139529193,
0.021138154,
-0.0356986634,
-0.0529839881,
0.0133763645,
0.0082552452,
-0.051351849,
0.0062135938,
0.0363524966,
-0.0047474946,
-0.0052503687,
0.0795578584,
-0.0250897445,
0.0069347406,
0.0201280061,
-0.0196031276,
-0.006544447,
0.0083058672,
-0.0084543722,
0.0162604079,
0.012962969,
-0.0245515648,
0.0230499562,
-0.0579289757,
0.03295739,
-0.0480781123,
0.0149377547,
-0.0286324322,
-0.0090774344,
0.0677061304,
-0.0012979254,
-0.0155517086,
0.0015103879,
0.0075497003,
-0.014695527,
0.0101533923,
0.0039303242,
0.0086852172,
0.0203665905,
0.0385623835,
0.0147181619,
-0.0223487895,
-0.0451505966,
0.0064295889,
0.046323739,
-0.0426036157,
0.0192751363,
0.000820265,
-0.0123399012,
0.0316479579,
0.0246828552,
0.0084551992,
-0.0771243796,
0.0344228484,
0.0484459847,
0.0865462124,
-0.0227382127,
0.0711276606,
-0.0075096018,
-0.015194037,
-0.0267734807,
0.0425650589,
-0.0012872223,
-0.0166401491,
0.0276710428,
-0.033045426,
-0.0109544694,
0.013269566,
0.0533410087,
-0.0012248134,
0.0081581781,
-0.021191597,
0.0107961968,
-0.0071430397,
-0.0451086462,
-0.0286950916,
-0.0040695253,
-0.045147121,
0.009414115,
-0.0158915296,
-0.092366606,
-0.0092013795,
-0.0143877817,
-0.0200210623,
-0.0154998722,
0.0249995645,
0.0339527279,
-0.0008141018,
-0.0419382453,
-0.0629366338,
0.0243441369,
0.0004219539,
-0.0240239538,
0.0249120817,
-5.779373444e-33,
-0.0189081542,
0.0433277823,
0.0262287892,
-0.0080390917,
-0.0369216688,
-0.0210430305,
-0.0419214107,
-0.0160130467,
-0.0237010252,
0.0052470732,
-0.0367352515,
0.0270620603,
0.0281370766,
0.0385700203,
0.0440240577,
-0.018207062,
0.0341158845,
-0.011834234,
0.01752064,
0.0885092467,
0.0628952906,
0.0564988889,
0.1240038201,
-0.0174089801,
-0.022085648,
-0.019164877,
0.0216683373,
0.038854748,
-0.0097604124,
0.0518195182,
-0.0303528067,
0.0278308019,
0.0077447579,
-0.0709324926,
-0.0172616281,
0.0067324471,
-0.0637769997,
0.0061566839,
0.0168397073,
0.0413348787,
0.0117491456,
-0.0310737155,
0.002159259,
0.0090015028,
0.0047772671,
0.007258343,
0.015877787,
-0.0326351784,
-0.0067275129,
0.0125022857,
-0.0624129176,
0.025056731,
0.0260144956,
0.0036714219,
0.0250660256,
0.0161504056,
0.0044114185,
0.0172308143,
-0.0322428755,
-0.0163596384,
-0.0568166561,
0.0495015197,
0.095759593,
0.0172220636,
-0.0254938789,
0.0531911366,
0.0244844053,
-0.0324997604,
0.0363481492,
-0.007569511,
0.0132868309,
0.0117596146,
-0.0027748272,
0.0374061503,
-0.0025678757,
-0.0500859208,
-0.1189328209,
-0.0031223604,
-0.0020567805,
0.0867068917,
0.0244947616,
-0.0186801907,
-0.0099913199,
0.001163971,
-0.0023927896,
-0.0080371471,
-0.0224019121,
-0.0037692715,
0.0080086626,
0.0006701601,
0.0049167504,
0.0154138682,
0.0335320234,
-0.0347542427,
-0.0039811507,
0.0125353821,
-0.0448199846,
-0.0112392148,
-0.0408138521,
0.0494147129,
-0.0937162191,
-0.0912717804,
-0.0373936109,
0.0159467123,
0.0356008038,
0.0144063961,
0.0254233535,
0.0289945398,
-0.0673237145,
0.0188103896,
-0.0657944754,
0.0452409983,
0.0041869734,
0.0587022342,
0.014717022,
0.0154260779,
-0.0245729499,
0.0782381669,
0.0077090189,
-0.0114551606,
0.0233577024,
-0.0413989425,
0.0171083566,
-0.0013273923,
-0.0147923147,
0.0252775475,
-0.0555249974,
0.0059168804,
0.0325193778,
-0.0538871251,
-0.0064250822,
0.0239254143,
2.512e-7,
0.0557249598,
0.0131392432,
0.0010733254,
0.0159933642,
0.0124645485,
0.0331151821,
-0.0752091184,
0.0535983704,
0.0022180856,
0.0503742695,
-0.0164487734,
0.047159601,
0.0605947003,
0.0166582819,
-0.1169974431,
-0.0069494052,
-0.032507889,
0.0364795923,
-0.0533026196,
-0.0059113782,
0.0095441006,
0.1114939526,
-0.0038813285,
-0.0298511144,
-0.0011319113,
-0.0352389961,
0.0856504962,
-0.0333488844,
-0.0366502032,
0.0456581526,
-0.0032389145,
0.0177821424,
-0.0381854251,
0.0184622947,
-0.0369604975,
0.0413197689,
0.0647294298,
0.089977324,
0.0441259891,
-0.0069265398,
0.0239535682,
-0.008393012,
-0.0020216026,
-0.0314694829,
0.0662299469,
-0.0105151925,
-0.0255139228,
-0.0109786475,
-0.0005799464,
-0.0078785764,
0.0273255929,
-0.0201813299,
0.014195648,
0.0363755561,
0.0326663405,
-0.0386198461,
-0.0302694254,
-0.040621683,
-0.0038702546,
0.0100432429,
-0.0217812136,
-0.0440194793,
-0.0123775657,
-0.0023142225,
-0.0074967388,
0.0131463455,
0.0144318445,
1.60178864e-34,
0.0196362771,
-0.0137914689,
-0.0076394067,
0.008500495,
0.0293637123,
-0.0230095759,
-0.0017147306,
0.026528094,
-0.0114869326,
-0.0587881692,
-0.018302992
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06461v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06461v3 | Between Lines of Code: Unraveling the Distinct Patterns of Machine and Human Programmers | 2024-01-12T09:15:20 | 2024-03-24T01:20:49 | Yuling Shi, Hongyu Zhang, Chengcheng Wan, Xiaodong Gu | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models have catalyzed an unprecedented wave in code
generation. While achieving significant advances, they blur the distinctions
between machine- and human-authored source code, causing integrity and
authenticity issues of software artifacts. Previous methods such as DetectGPT
have proven effective in discerning machine-generated texts, but they do not
identify and harness the unique patterns of machine-generated code. Thus, its
applicability falters when applied to code. In this paper, we carefully study
the specific patterns that characterize machine- and human-authored code.
Through a rigorous analysis of code attributes such as lexical diversity,
conciseness, and naturalness, we expose unique patterns inherent to each
source. We particularly notice that the syntactic segmentation of code is a
critical factor in identifying its provenance. Based on our findings, we
propose DetectCodeGPT, a novel method for detecting machine-generated code,
which improves DetectGPT by capturing the distinct stylized patterns of code.
Diverging from conventional techniques that depend on external LLMs for
perturbations, DetectCodeGPT perturbs the code corpus by strategically
inserting spaces and newlines, ensuring both efficacy and efficiency.
Experiment results show that our approach significantly outperforms
state-of-the-art techniques in detecting machine-generated code. | [
0.0293597579,
0.0795459449,
-0.0574049205,
0.0740097612,
-0.0295751374,
-0.0150344009,
-0.0523488857,
0.0506655537,
0.002224209,
0.0219345,
0.0047271377,
0.0414566062,
0.0242625307,
0.0484262854,
0.0553138927,
0.036038015,
0.0177535526,
0.0114413621,
-0.0111638894,
0.0692995861,
0.0258975755,
0.024510704,
0.0326917022,
0.0313465074,
0.0062566204,
-0.0410216264,
-0.0163715836,
0.0366683826,
0.0444971845,
-0.0226466581,
0.0151496306,
0.0523158647,
-0.0356255062,
0.0602219813,
0.0000019884,
-0.0274351574,
-0.0454079658,
-0.0079310481,
-0.0053272471,
0.0616695918,
-0.0032812033,
0.0166346636,
-0.0215321444,
0.0006231494,
-0.0667899102,
-0.0101639889,
0.0383548066,
-0.018976938,
0.0430084653,
0.0782185048,
-0.013771398,
0.0453667529,
0.0002237414,
0.0234024785,
0.0317020081,
0.0180766396,
-0.0082915202,
0.0078101591,
0.0157917049,
0.0231984612,
0.027758617,
0.0001985116,
0.0025780692,
-0.0228487477,
-0.015961431,
0.028352363,
-0.0541009493,
0.0039557079,
-0.012291125,
0.0238612536,
-0.0645642951,
-0.0510533452,
0.0884820744,
-0.0234768279,
-0.0057712775,
-0.0077260504,
0.0184193309,
0.0473545939,
-0.0448032618,
0.0125938924,
-0.0091101388,
-0.0297111366,
0.008129322,
-0.0110781798,
0.0079185227,
0.0223586727,
-0.0063653816,
-0.0302723963,
-0.0444631092,
0.002624376,
-0.0092315273,
-0.0704589188,
0.0063714171,
0.0256542694,
0.02496114,
-0.0216038227,
-0.0338055491,
-0.0297651123,
0.0363737829,
0.0004270057,
0.0316282362,
0.0238309111,
-0.0384944789,
-0.0108645158,
-0.0507727154,
0.0697381273,
-0.0273551922,
0.0170830078,
0.0051050275,
0.0669120401,
-0.0295735002,
-0.0152110253,
-0.0300106183,
0.0077559343,
0.0169516671,
0.0284431819,
0.0068864184,
0.0706602484,
0.0089527182,
0.0619894676,
-0.0617298298,
-0.0486161448,
0.0097034657,
0.0269472618,
0.0589142367,
-0.0748120993,
-0.011102044,
-0.0372605361,
-0.02380348,
-0.0732908994,
-0.0159119051,
0.0840468034,
0.006692566,
0.0011205127,
0.0178951267,
0.0119923865,
0.0249835998,
0.0184588041,
-0.0434207357,
-0.0684115067,
-0.006510539,
0.0026700501,
0.0035364274,
-0.0638921484,
-0.0634661019,
-0.0009596466,
-0.0040317033,
-0.0487221964,
-0.0183316618,
0.013371774,
-0.0012475966,
0.0386395007,
-0.0940522105,
0.0222781487,
0.0004884721,
-0.0184504129,
-0.0387715958,
-0.0289415643,
0.0690986589,
0.0380135067,
0.0720554814,
-0.0385074504,
0.0990636721,
0.0252137929,
-0.0356190354,
-0.0024403541,
-0.0167952403,
-0.0018751177,
0.0179070532,
-0.0231905319,
0.0442366861,
0.0414680988,
-0.006761298,
0.0041278074,
0.0093329046,
0.0627961084,
-0.0134167355,
0.0342678204,
0.0553194098,
0.0452133417,
0.0241353717,
0.0481394567,
-0.0041210321,
-0.0336287953,
-0.0060437415,
0.0040823654,
-0.0097988881,
0.0200216603,
0.0450603776,
-0.0077166627,
-0.0290124472,
-0.0173535626,
-0.0179119948,
-0.0748547614,
-0.0298552383,
-0.0133424234,
-0.0252512358,
-0.004450134,
-0.0120722838,
-0.0456216894,
-0.0301919281,
-0.0640434995,
0.051651042,
0.0299206935,
0.055043906,
-0.0331459157,
0.0655410662,
-0.003917648,
-0.0114101311,
0.0041959584,
-0.0189524777,
-0.007111724,
0.0104793068,
-0.0178595986,
-0.0127157997,
-0.0113946125,
-0.00144655,
0.0421348698,
0.0445079394,
-0.0221135058,
0.0226819497,
-0.0148341777,
-0.0147809628,
0.0511274338,
-0.0003102517,
0.0015935359,
0.0058079292,
0.0075307209,
0.0098403664,
-0.0183089878,
-0.0659882054,
0.0344482549,
0.0193307884,
-0.0101550361,
-0.0079443278,
-0.0195973851,
0.0126813771,
0.0062560481,
0.0218719505,
-0.0333800875,
-0.0261075944,
-0.0019731156,
-0.0152427256,
0.0084500685,
0.0147453928,
-0.0578900315,
-0.0013974927,
-0.0554521009,
0.0159596205,
-0.034185227,
-0.0116907833,
-0.0373511687,
0.0345731452,
0.011548941,
0.0231571719,
0.0118087744,
0.0063733058,
0.048232954,
0.0135630704,
0.0061836764,
0.0231307689,
-0.0446372107,
0.0305235013,
0.0102917487,
0.067295216,
-0.0116115715,
-0.0463196076,
-0.0323032551,
0.0141303614,
0.0009286873,
0.0418621302,
0.0272876378,
-0.0178862512,
-0.0306086075,
-0.0036496324,
-0.0014638146,
-0.0431900285,
0.0018428091,
-0.025139302,
0.0710048527,
-0.0423976406,
-0.0264476947,
-0.0157723445,
0.0211539771,
-0.0317545608,
0.0368654244,
0.0180815551,
-0.0135075441,
-0.1134111211,
0.0506072715,
0.0224320162,
-0.0255147722,
0.0028023466,
-0.0516392142,
-0.0159321167,
-0.0456744991,
0.0314575695,
0.0907066986,
0.0072009685,
-0.028161129,
0.0240914747,
0.0273688491,
0.0104982909,
-0.0211794153,
0.0474776365,
0.0004603472,
0.0303198975,
-0.0376070105,
0.083298564,
0.0315989964,
0.0108656809,
0.0041138479,
0.0035965324,
0.0050699026,
0.0180819873,
0.0365048051,
0.0235073343,
-0.0529194139,
-0.0516443625,
0.0474976897,
-0.023911804,
-0.1072152257,
0.0214229152,
-0.0671415552,
-0.0084018307,
0.0084627597,
-0.0139893284,
-0.0344696902,
0.0077905525,
0.0048025702,
0.0127994968,
0.0439985394,
-0.0693280622,
-0.0245630536,
0.0101259723,
0.0410754085,
-0.0373531431,
0.0399175286,
-0.0548594557,
0.0032002602,
0.0045475829,
-0.003695444,
-0.0387308151,
-0.0131767532,
0.0304790158,
-0.0494019352,
0.051922854,
-0.0275051575,
0.0523602329,
-0.0069525847,
0.0101814624,
0.0714008734,
0.0291283056,
-0.0199621692,
-0.0359860435,
0.0580471195,
-0.0370403677,
-0.0672886595,
0.0005964161,
-0.0023364334,
-0.0655567572,
0.0326565467,
-0.0019203027,
0.0520324893,
-0.0412720628,
-0.0073497007,
0.0076485444,
-0.0179742891,
-0.0226109456,
0.048573181,
0.0292134006,
-0.0061371764,
0.0049491399,
0.0670262873,
0.0183655377,
-0.0405426808,
0.0200135112,
-0.0065097436,
0.0272525419,
0.0277505796,
0.0132832425,
-0.0638948679,
0.0044623665,
0.0282662362,
0.0196746662,
-0.0201628171,
0.0052187988,
-0.0108956685,
-0.0579914153,
0.0331844278,
0.0261776652,
-0.0154320803,
-0.0290304366,
-0.0164070763,
-0.0302292295,
0.0144303199,
-0.0604403801,
-0.0025820197,
-0.0068738237,
0.0392914899,
-0.0200997777,
-0.0627148077,
0.0247107726,
-0.0202757157,
-0.0409068204,
-0.0085537219,
0.1204560772,
0.0286054369,
0.0151660247,
-0.0137994234,
0.0312599055,
-0.0410718769,
0.0236501675,
-0.014011804,
0.0503526405,
0.0103445919,
-0.0142104113,
0.0393001251,
0.0083797434,
-0.0717519596,
-0.0157232862,
0.039673429,
0.0263390299,
-0.0066088825,
-0.0291538257,
-0.0109753376,
-0.0380057171,
0.0088187251,
0.0098292734,
0.0600254349,
0.0094990311,
-0.058390718,
-0.0742674544,
0.0343172476,
-0.0474000499,
-0.0405041352,
-0.0388009511,
-0.0236192849,
-0.0391935483,
-0.0889866874,
-0.0051520229,
-0.0548331253,
0.029441312,
0.0279048961,
-0.0289623141,
0.0101494463,
-0.0108801005,
-0.1048350558,
-0.0318349265,
-0.0436079986,
0.024578454,
-0.0317836776,
-0.000585867,
-0.027548736,
0.0022526092,
-0.0096923886,
-0.0189569648,
-0.0824161544,
-0.0296647083,
-0.0439632349,
0.0154664237,
0.0210131537,
0.0108705861,
-0.025701914,
0.0026974231,
-0.033648029,
0.0310679283,
-0.0242522024,
0.0119290845,
0.0091426484,
-0.0283632148,
0.0157495048,
-0.0224696603,
-0.0215197783,
-0.0217677038,
0.034883786,
-0.0329444408,
-0.0521912985,
-0.0017135008,
0.0422610752,
0.0479214378,
0.0516163409,
0.0053713717,
0.0031123157,
0.0064669368,
-0.0604084991,
0.0040888297,
-0.0046282811,
-0.0365905687,
0.0335279033,
0.0037996874,
-0.0038989214,
0.0084655564,
0.0280666742,
-0.0669277683,
0.0596048944,
-0.0120046018,
0.0217495356,
-0.0433972701,
0.0675191879,
0.0205180962,
0.0044710282,
0.0219770838,
0.0446764715,
-0.008392808,
0.0419572555,
0.0004807294,
0.0527250767,
0.0015490914,
-0.0017213556,
0.0408280939,
0.0424418338,
-0.0646613091,
-0.0019973463,
-0.0087473085,
-0.0040851487,
0.0492927618,
0.0264910702,
0.0632956102,
0.0065955943,
0.005738941,
-0.0377992019,
0.0771788135,
0.0101904729,
-0.0314345732,
-0.0715280175,
0.0257286597,
-0.0672231764,
-0.0473831408,
0.086365521,
-0.0128681939,
-0.0158047359,
-0.0232081879,
-0.0510143116,
-0.0414925069,
0.0057064118,
0.0496032946,
-0.044972904,
-0.0001633268,
0.0079902085,
-0.0144663882,
-0.0276310537,
0.0161507372,
0.0286222566,
0.073289074,
-0.0041932072,
-0.0275899563,
0.0863451362,
-0.0139725395,
-0.0142676253,
-0.0483583473,
0.0018066727,
0.0015342933,
-0.0198116731,
-0.0380436517,
-5.221563539e-33,
0.0045530666,
-0.0875726938,
-0.0560733527,
0.0306047779,
-0.0070439596,
0.0082192188,
-0.0638439059,
-0.0125973132,
0.0092008207,
-0.0481519029,
0.0149154915,
0.0399240702,
-0.0078794491,
-0.0802460834,
0.0610493086,
0.0338529013,
0.0350592099,
0.044540178,
-0.0655679852,
0.0108016599,
-0.0598686561,
-0.0142404325,
0.0169677772,
-0.0424330831,
0.0173583701,
-0.0669290349,
0.0056085195,
-0.0102810813,
0.0140488856,
0.0576985516,
0.010687992,
-0.0304736625,
0.0143348668,
0.0135842441,
-0.03872706,
-0.0103180241,
0.0100718224,
-0.0287900716,
-0.0202825088,
-0.0013566989,
0.0306400284,
-0.1008877605,
0.0646170303,
-0.041972395,
-0.0174043346,
0.0093650036,
0.0492823608,
-0.0137790469,
0.0055112713,
-0.0473332666,
-0.0249145702,
0.0375284962,
-0.0492700487,
0.0140706263,
0.0221116561,
0.0105564371,
0.0232729092,
0.0405660272,
-0.0315553024,
0.0078646243,
-0.0122414203,
0.0393067785,
0.0087764272,
0.0114158932,
0.0149471825,
0.0133314719,
0.0394214652,
0.0074912906,
-0.0007869789,
0.0355257988,
-0.0043573235,
0.0101820435,
0.0205928832,
0.0317703411,
0.0585792288,
0.0084041376,
0.0254799761,
0.0476463176,
-0.014977552,
-0.0200441256,
-0.0126074273,
0.0467723534,
-0.0524010994,
0.0089998674,
0.0342053622,
-0.0829822496,
-0.0079072425,
-0.038842801,
0.0362054408,
-0.0079466579,
-0.0205385499,
-0.0064086672,
-0.0101390854,
-0.0624006204,
0.017769061,
-0.0187907908,
-0.0762198642,
0.0110327397,
-0.0020507115,
0.0031080127,
0.0188682601,
-0.011083479,
0.0276208315,
-0.0165846962,
0.0943688303,
0.0360342525,
0.0133003574,
0.012496531,
-0.0614171922,
0.0180656593,
0.0034709112,
-0.035118822,
-0.0216768533,
0.0019104441,
-0.0025400424,
-0.0374289453,
0.0307854116,
0.014684286,
0.0245331917,
-0.0063483277,
-0.0528292954,
0.0112391943,
-0.0216083992,
0.0141263427,
-0.0287278164,
-0.011487403,
0.0033357716,
0.0534482896,
0.0408730693,
-0.0075767594,
-0.0420715138,
-0.0349986292,
2.594e-7,
-0.0067936303,
0.0281447973,
0.0669271573,
0.0277776383,
0.0251696184,
0.0404027328,
-0.0375818387,
-0.00255785,
-0.0353773832,
-0.0279112216,
-0.0249852818,
-0.0250238068,
0.0752968937,
-0.0043376782,
-0.0426935144,
0.0402028784,
-0.0111171799,
-0.0129325287,
-0.0840985253,
0.0264512431,
0.0915049687,
0.0097063743,
-0.0092213089,
0.0175832603,
0.0094207395,
-0.0654378831,
-0.0217250437,
-0.0169553999,
0.0405025445,
0.0336175784,
-0.0334879681,
-0.017011581,
-0.0181844141,
-0.0016844046,
-0.0242442898,
-0.0211838949,
0.0175358411,
0.093506664,
-0.0031339563,
0.0945990607,
0.0061556478,
-0.0302694757,
0.0291714612,
-0.0460586511,
0.0257478599,
0.0605955161,
0.0214637909,
-0.0109559065,
-0.0292239916,
-0.0641810596,
0.0104444576,
-0.004152108,
0.0173735153,
0.0309700817,
-0.0157991964,
0.0018796256,
-0.0152531406,
-0.0098830769,
-0.0370683931,
-0.0080871647,
-0.0386255719,
-0.0268766191,
-0.0121854385,
0.0174978655,
0.0384605527,
-0.0084435251,
0.035103783,
2.721978622e-34,
0.028272992,
-0.0423426107,
0.0249427613,
0.0429178104,
0.0704737604,
0.0217197072,
-0.0213532113,
0.0103474148,
-0.0212735459,
0.0144173978,
0.010948441
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06443v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06443v2 | BOK-VQA: Bilingual outside Knowledge-Based Visual Question Answering via Graph Representation Pretraining | 2024-01-12T08:31:42 | 2024-03-15T07:17:10 | Minjun Kim, Seungwoo Song, Youhan Lee, Haneol Jang, Kyungtae Lim | cs.CL | cs.CL | The current research direction in generative models, such as the recently
developed GPT4, aims to find relevant knowledge information for multimodal and
multilingual inputs to provide answers. Under these research circumstances, the
demand for multilingual evaluation of visual question answering (VQA) tasks, a
representative task of multimodal systems, has increased. Accordingly, we
propose a bilingual outside-knowledge VQA (BOK-VQA) dataset in this study that
can be extended to multilingualism. The proposed data include 17K images, 17K
question-answer pairs for both Korean and English and 280K instances of
knowledge information related to question-answer content. We also present a
framework that can effectively inject knowledge information into a VQA system
by pretraining the knowledge information of BOK-VQA data in the form of graph
embeddings. Finally, through in-depth analysis, we demonstrated the actual
effect of the knowledge information contained in the constructed training data
on VQA. | [
0.0337647088,
0.0129574072,
-0.023903871,
0.0718758926,
0.013041894,
0.0106375841,
-0.0142194517,
0.0037114639,
0.0646469072,
-0.0480117314,
-0.032580819,
-0.0124604274,
-0.0197485555,
0.0379971676,
0.0652927309,
-0.0475514457,
0.0400274359,
-0.0079363389,
0.0057814158,
-0.0263498053,
0.0257744044,
0.0208900645,
0.0263862237,
0.0184971783,
-0.0254483819,
-0.0321733691,
-0.0022598172,
0.0153275924,
0.0349167734,
-0.0047383117,
-0.0258789025,
0.0283914935,
0.0280358698,
0.0196639467,
0.0000018656,
0.0091185691,
0.0440745987,
0.0084004533,
0.0064458549,
-0.0139736701,
-0.0289631393,
-0.0200149156,
0.0374254063,
-0.0328431986,
-0.0655753538,
-0.0531523935,
0.0600739978,
0.0166388527,
0.0703132153,
0.0224318374,
-0.0310494006,
-0.0169850048,
0.0040869289,
0.0197676104,
0.0206757616,
-0.0330808014,
-0.0168267265,
0.0501673631,
0.0039419862,
-0.006689433,
-0.0911890864,
0.0357209183,
0.0337519273,
0.0103105661,
-0.0005195416,
0.0440575555,
-0.0099342698,
0.0190482475,
0.0043355762,
0.1113585532,
-0.0155008603,
-0.0102404431,
-0.054777056,
0.0119294962,
0.010616147,
0.0036194064,
-0.0421824716,
0.00537461,
-0.0280551054,
0.0026822144,
-0.0456451476,
-0.0165216532,
0.0140040172,
-0.0434916243,
-0.013239705,
0.0247586705,
0.0242148712,
0.0102281366,
0.0229475107,
0.0257338043,
-0.0574081242,
-0.0561008081,
-0.0362491086,
0.0396579206,
0.0178022943,
0.0044200425,
-0.006082518,
-0.0226882696,
-0.0172795411,
-0.0244384464,
0.0277051963,
0.0245820545,
-0.0647011101,
0.0554043278,
-0.0369630195,
0.0657868907,
-0.0234616529,
0.0570695773,
-0.07658723,
-0.0303082112,
-0.0239904616,
-0.0304815862,
-0.0659787506,
-0.0081975348,
-0.0441381969,
-0.0468902104,
0.0032712049,
0.0344858952,
-0.0072213532,
-0.0086389659,
0.0267522484,
0.0458500423,
-0.0097414888,
0.0182728134,
-0.0392207988,
0.0664629117,
-0.0613018237,
0.0017803593,
-0.0364754573,
-0.0345903486,
0.0080599207,
0.0316763818,
0.0159424655,
-0.0425562225,
-0.0075796433,
0.0867427811,
-0.0228571668,
-0.001088255,
-0.0083378861,
-0.0224729516,
-0.0041592051,
-0.0728285313,
0.0343255401,
-0.0672790483,
0.0404068343,
0.0048917546,
-0.0015183687,
0.0077562705,
-0.0011891689,
0.0010440696,
-0.0322482884,
0.0760456175,
0.0023010632,
-0.0096199885,
0.019090008,
-0.0189401116,
0.0357389823,
0.0729255155,
-0.0014054795,
-0.023966372,
0.0623044744,
-0.008780689,
-0.0007090747,
0.0445095561,
0.0329514258,
0.0195041336,
0.0034128919,
0.0513160937,
0.0226239059,
-0.0014067745,
0.0414549559,
0.0194724947,
-0.0625597164,
-0.0517644063,
0.032717064,
0.020672705,
0.0033652657,
-0.0120679205,
0.0545497611,
-0.0156178838,
0.0145542715,
0.0095366696,
-0.0290360004,
0.0720052719,
-0.0119196055,
0.0093811993,
0.0018866555,
0.0377223492,
-0.0496164262,
-0.0114648333,
0.0234834272,
-0.0142466733,
0.0510787927,
0.0414008126,
0.0468053035,
0.037474677,
-0.0234518759,
-0.0015071217,
-0.0039158408,
0.004655689,
-0.0115252566,
0.0030837122,
-0.0013621936,
0.0563456602,
0.0115821091,
0.0426390693,
-0.0388520584,
0.0037366804,
-0.0097632278,
-0.0069145076,
0.0022235676,
-0.0105772875,
0.0213672332,
-0.0446940288,
-0.049751088,
-0.0496939868,
-0.0339985341,
0.0550391339,
0.0150063774,
0.028570367,
0.0132314544,
-0.0772519484,
0.0174466874,
0.0072662691,
0.0271873735,
-0.0082289539,
-0.0119008105,
0.035088785,
-0.011174893,
0.0258130226,
0.0096938768,
-0.0120135946,
0.0218557827,
-0.0245290417,
0.0070384834,
0.0441458672,
-0.0073329294,
-0.1107373983,
0.0203866754,
-0.0784818828,
-0.001523354,
0.0018610738,
-0.0529277027,
-0.0325567126,
0.0497662351,
-0.0409188755,
0.0166603979,
-0.0670166016,
-0.0690737516,
0.0316377133,
0.0111072091,
-0.0038583137,
0.0404731035,
-0.0192326661,
0.0245017391,
-0.0105123278,
0.0164143126,
0.0662623346,
-0.0472539365,
-0.0079973536,
0.0350182168,
0.0299516115,
0.0150609799,
-0.0057995925,
0.024387477,
-0.0396528877,
0.0476656258,
-0.1169479415,
-0.0175529364,
-0.0127509525,
-0.0235971417,
0.0082967291,
0.002842027,
-0.0019799743,
-0.0772102922,
-0.06771373,
0.0452731922,
0.0502184927,
0.0402115323,
0.0369491056,
0.0081968065,
0.0461039133,
0.0064242342,
-0.0227661207,
0.0184606761,
0.0851287991,
0.0140536223,
0.0064619202,
-0.0318784714,
-0.0151008209,
-0.0791352764,
0.0418763496,
-0.0067011192,
-0.0478427373,
0.0034999186,
-0.0051226062,
0.0760552064,
0.0270396378,
-0.0386130065,
-0.0215033256,
0.0256498847,
-0.0424089134,
-0.0113442475,
0.0218504313,
-0.0115386508,
-0.0469828509,
-0.0277602952,
-0.0075924285,
-0.0326941088,
-0.0073845177,
0.0241739657,
-0.0463205576,
-0.0595023744,
-0.0017088548,
-0.0064468677,
-0.0187552664,
-0.0599738359,
0.0138243604,
0.0237021614,
0.0168081429,
-0.0280876458,
-0.041789528,
0.0880669728,
0.0121642109,
-0.0224042889,
-0.0088669369,
0.0031112859,
-0.0529524162,
0.0711430609,
0.0354695506,
0.0388256982,
-0.046369724,
0.0093896864,
-0.0553662963,
-0.0046472671,
0.0223114081,
-0.0080217626,
0.0020033466,
0.0129313236,
0.0028820788,
-0.0202853195,
-0.0019520897,
-0.0144064641,
0.0035304641,
-0.0014391198,
-0.0061744605,
0.0050645377,
0.0127618508,
0.0380619057,
0.026640892,
0.0360553674,
-0.0184434783,
-0.0159044918,
0.0180659946,
-0.0048873303,
0.0684578642,
0.0500334986,
0.0351882763,
-0.0383133888,
-0.042155005,
-0.0051395185,
0.0297420081,
-0.0133497305,
-0.0564837679,
-0.0123145934,
0.030748371,
0.0100296102,
0.0589663945,
-0.0297860708,
-0.0137308389,
0.0617870241,
-0.0171098877,
0.013455092,
0.0317464396,
0.0067915586,
-0.0252258778,
-0.0083210822,
-0.0142467786,
-0.0080802012,
0.0732520372,
0.055169493,
-0.1179914474,
-0.0039569689,
-0.0529288389,
-0.0249858294,
0.0349982865,
0.006427459,
-0.0157223549,
-0.1063510627,
0.0359410383,
0.0071541052,
-0.0289155152,
-0.047257755,
-0.0066753621,
-0.0285891593,
0.009615357,
-0.0243954379,
-0.04258902,
0.0298840571,
0.0125318272,
-0.0159401242,
0.0011184826,
-0.0173759796,
0.017809866,
-0.0377114229,
-0.056968268,
0.0155940559,
0.0276680365,
-0.0071414709,
-0.0396192856,
-0.0120816194,
-0.0279466957,
-0.0145816272,
0.0025368237,
0.0642457455,
0.0012660697,
-0.0476182215,
-0.0192966815,
0.0043917345,
-0.004179955,
0.0036842981,
-0.0140569024,
0.0963865072,
-0.0000948346,
-0.0204407424,
-0.006637698,
0.0028015417,
0.0074680578,
0.0072797104,
0.035781078,
-0.0125925578,
-0.0412338898,
-0.042851653,
0.0264193974,
-0.0798898786,
-0.0346334875,
0.0431449823,
0.0298808739,
0.0157616623,
-0.0812678561,
-0.059255641,
0.0287745912,
0.0561464839,
-0.0201919768,
0.0025467097,
-0.0313503705,
0.010793006,
-0.0566685833,
0.0301917475,
-0.0070112101,
0.0377876647,
0.0027065901,
-0.0282752942,
-0.0207166318,
-0.031009499,
-0.0251947958,
0.0122285988,
-0.0248204693,
-0.0324880816,
-0.0616511963,
0.0632526278,
0.0029924705,
0.0381524898,
-0.0154418275,
0.0115139578,
0.0548306741,
-0.0022135975,
-0.0096099284,
-0.0024464373,
0.0061624721,
-0.0218504388,
-0.0037465123,
0.0143281501,
-0.0311462749,
0.0064314599,
-0.0039743171,
0.0233047102,
0.0004185856,
-0.028759541,
0.0203205626,
0.0458366349,
-0.0190657265,
0.0142529067,
0.0155830532,
-0.0439819582,
-0.0066468283,
-0.0448224656,
-0.0163603071,
-0.0621274412,
-0.0156476758,
0.0393172465,
-0.0264815278,
-0.0009007132,
-0.0079846103,
0.0198418275,
0.0159509387,
-0.00338407,
-0.0238136575,
0.0692559555,
0.0067833196,
0.0068423781,
0.0381352045,
-0.0094467467,
0.005144299,
-0.007542666,
0.0356748849,
-0.0199278519,
0.0724198595,
0.0312396362,
-0.0366529413,
-0.0276030004,
0.0127036227,
-0.0212758873,
-0.0334872603,
-0.0213140994,
0.01843719,
0.0628916323,
0.0027049363,
0.0108170789,
0.0059324992,
-0.0283033866,
-0.0144444732,
0.0211018752,
0.0097605297,
-0.0622837096,
0.0643868297,
0.0040431595,
-0.0017432338,
-0.004841743,
0.0841209218,
0.0155396024,
0.0131985871,
-0.0272273365,
-0.0127581544,
-0.0378020704,
-0.0052109687,
0.0111874957,
0.0181949027,
0.0033562612,
0.0370358676,
-0.0143735046,
-0.1010748968,
-0.0417240672,
0.0401358642,
-0.0298215542,
0.0513096452,
0.0407693051,
0.0536695756,
0.0716163814,
-0.0499585494,
-0.0311863422,
0.0389754102,
-0.0284994412,
0.0166591406,
0.0285944194,
-5.839170475e-33,
-0.0379409716,
-0.0392234772,
0.0475490652,
-0.0201520156,
-0.0292200223,
-0.0083318269,
-0.0266658906,
-0.0234307591,
-0.0308340583,
0.0078599639,
0.0250245146,
-0.0266660117,
-0.005955148,
0.0334119238,
-0.0068582813,
-0.0078970753,
0.0032646647,
-0.0077987676,
0.0025398571,
0.0372665487,
0.0511272289,
0.0184136499,
0.0875455514,
-0.0120131597,
0.0111252377,
-0.0134662511,
0.0104458928,
0.0136748329,
0.008522342,
0.0720015988,
-0.0640322864,
0.0585504957,
0.0221084766,
0.0246583577,
-0.0274696108,
-0.0248122271,
-0.0888718441,
-0.0561409369,
0.0410517864,
0.0470545031,
-0.1010918394,
-0.0059055579,
0.0014414681,
-0.0463561229,
0.0396205783,
-0.0456541218,
0.047131598,
-0.0037929018,
0.0071002222,
-0.0009257232,
-0.0330447815,
0.0039504366,
-0.0103931855,
-0.0066695176,
0.0101118619,
0.0732246935,
0.0059703346,
-0.0263023674,
-0.0509742536,
0.005142333,
-0.0317891687,
-0.0157610252,
0.0643530712,
0.0281570219,
0.0267534759,
0.0043485337,
0.003021864,
-0.0455869734,
-0.0451633818,
0.0075283973,
0.014310143,
0.0329570919,
0.0410560519,
0.0688820332,
-0.0064957426,
-0.0137330219,
-0.0739734918,
0.0178270377,
-0.0502015986,
0.0268532466,
-0.0249822773,
-0.0156206666,
0.020918658,
-0.0311215315,
-0.0318306573,
-0.0211103577,
-0.0318825208,
-0.0410754047,
0.0435338207,
0.0071349158,
0.0151564404,
0.0397910252,
0.0503914952,
-0.0714470148,
0.0135601219,
0.0723761469,
-0.025116276,
0.0390609279,
0.0351086743,
0.0635669902,
-0.0360267237,
0.0238865539,
0.0494791791,
-0.0156041086,
-0.0176976975,
0.0218228325,
0.0555365607,
0.0078792823,
-0.0342953056,
0.0056259008,
-0.0419156253,
-0.0148983197,
-0.0230698418,
-0.0066938531,
0.0064612627,
0.0431644134,
-0.0551994629,
0.0089786286,
0.0071866638,
0.0207648072,
-0.0296635143,
-0.0337422155,
0.013492506,
0.058906164,
-0.0216549374,
0.0323556922,
-0.0287828725,
-0.0214847606,
-0.011772261,
-0.0467903428,
-0.0229047947,
0.0517710745,
2.49e-7,
0.0684643537,
-0.0075643682,
0.0243208148,
0.0354406908,
0.0098541779,
0.0059238458,
-0.0390178934,
0.0365828797,
0.0273473803,
-0.0246354025,
0.0069499644,
0.0740372092,
-0.013660226,
0.0459959842,
-0.011516491,
0.0593934059,
-0.0091424817,
-0.056646172,
-0.056092184,
0.0158042293,
0.064510785,
0.0450060219,
-0.0063543171,
0.0096293278,
0.0017190457,
-0.0636793524,
0.1216041744,
-0.0068510417,
-0.0236303154,
-0.0502422564,
0.0298163537,
0.0156620145,
-0.0016390741,
0.0377762876,
0.0097713955,
-0.0014220546,
0.0625410751,
-0.0114164669,
-0.0153166633,
-0.0365357064,
-0.0273460895,
0.0103577925,
-0.0193782989,
-0.0666226074,
0.0954680145,
-0.0365598388,
-0.0097285686,
0.0017184337,
-0.0595841818,
-0.0241409689,
0.0619461164,
-0.0356828682,
-0.0442868732,
0.0281963646,
0.0573401563,
-0.0024644253,
0.0211410075,
-0.0410334878,
0.0039102794,
0.0428938121,
-0.0350471027,
-0.0103147915,
-0.0335167497,
-0.0050901491,
0.0322708711,
0.0114953788,
0.0018567923,
1.693937295e-34,
0.0262518376,
-0.0052145235,
0.0379128493,
-0.0349281132,
0.0199558251,
-0.0602010339,
-0.0196885318,
-0.0323786847,
0.0288071278,
-0.08991009,
-0.034939643
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06437v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06437v1 | 3D-PreMise: Can Large Language Models Generate 3D Shapes with Sharp Features and Parametric Control? | 2024-01-12T08:07:52 | 2024-01-12T08:07:52 | Zeqing Yuan, Haoxuan Lan, Qiang Zou, Junbo Zhao | cs.GR | cs.GR, cs.AI, cs.CL | Recent advancements in implicit 3D representations and generative models have
markedly propelled the field of 3D object generation forward. However, it
remains a significant challenge to accurately model geometries with defined
sharp features under parametric controls, which is crucial in fields like
industrial design and manufacturing. To bridge this gap, we introduce a
framework that employs Large Language Models (LLMs) to generate text-driven 3D
shapes, manipulating 3D software via program synthesis. We present 3D-PreMise,
a dataset specifically tailored for 3D parametric modeling of industrial
shapes, designed to explore state-of-the-art LLMs within our proposed pipeline.
Our work reveals effective generation strategies and delves into the
self-correction capabilities of LLMs using a visual interface. Our work
highlights both the potential and limitations of LLMs in 3D parametric modeling
for industrial applications. | [
-0.0334511735,
0.052561596,
0.0093043791,
0.0376763605,
-0.0276626907,
-0.0416652709,
0.034964934,
-0.0255179144,
-0.0569394939,
0.0035685957,
-0.0487823859,
0.010545495,
0.0086149303,
0.0843440741,
0.0441020504,
-0.0814059228,
-0.0541172624,
-0.0696870238,
-0.0377931148,
-0.0172078013,
-0.0229410902,
0.0579418018,
-0.0222642608,
0.0401533507,
-0.0397706963,
-0.0093661556,
-0.0508703403,
0.013160808,
-0.0136551773,
-0.0379213057,
-0.0047519039,
0.0631431267,
0.0367025696,
0.0371645689,
0.0000021379,
-0.0057177488,
-0.0038643321,
0.0176776983,
0.0357375517,
0.0313468315,
0.0258702952,
-0.0699139833,
-0.0621359423,
-0.0265449677,
-0.0037270479,
0.0513286516,
0.0363162979,
0.0360181257,
0.0575026646,
-0.0182130374,
-0.0153887384,
-0.0236213915,
0.009187419,
-0.0212805439,
0.0150407124,
0.0355977826,
0.0043400056,
0.0393586382,
0.0067215324,
0.0673691109,
0.0020516946,
0.0233656187,
0.0448506065,
-0.0118763037,
0.0150166498,
0.012380993,
0.0069657839,
-0.0254414026,
-0.002493188,
0.0899477899,
-0.0542746894,
-0.0255882367,
0.0255684294,
-0.0477697402,
0.0006905769,
0.0263941269,
-0.0481528603,
0.0068618534,
0.0030566468,
-0.0305783935,
-0.0563119873,
-0.0130508207,
-0.0132828234,
-0.0550640784,
0.0084771467,
-0.0265785586,
0.0444705077,
0.0187301692,
-0.0710927397,
0.0050741304,
-0.0111108581,
-0.0695990622,
0.0038885472,
0.0000774076,
0.0209513884,
-0.0058692526,
-0.0534727387,
-0.0020289305,
0.0050774445,
-0.0502437986,
0.069487676,
0.0002270734,
-0.0070684738,
0.0236566626,
-0.0850770548,
0.0404461473,
-0.0350054093,
-0.0129161943,
-0.0438043177,
0.018355269,
0.0250562765,
-0.0255899113,
-0.0700294524,
-0.0314874798,
-0.0616491064,
0.0286879819,
0.0111442665,
0.045433674,
-0.0277231,
-0.0028984929,
0.0292851031,
0.0579029694,
-0.0277481303,
-0.0305749215,
-0.0224251915,
-0.0320564099,
-0.0106983194,
0.0345557258,
-0.0248057824,
-0.0383703522,
0.0023006462,
0.0023513385,
0.0459788889,
0.0241385773,
0.0160669256,
0.0779915899,
-0.0537022576,
0.012229275,
0.0327210166,
-0.0699584261,
-0.0036150077,
-0.0040339036,
0.0172804315,
-0.0619248711,
-0.0027623409,
-0.0351587981,
-0.0211938042,
-0.0489521213,
0.0319525562,
-0.0233885124,
0.0302668586,
0.0265716724,
-0.0014330434,
0.005237903,
0.0022458807,
-0.0400049612,
0.0160235893,
0.0221772436,
0.0603319369,
0.0717713907,
-0.0284418333,
-0.0164854899,
0.0178554021,
0.0384168029,
0.03054481,
0.0136743775,
-0.0868336484,
-0.0359152444,
-0.007510399,
0.0636582077,
0.0292901043,
0.0039273733,
-0.0146373743,
-0.015636513,
0.0724123567,
0.0159315839,
-0.0175645668,
0.0644445196,
0.0839136615,
0.0247505065,
0.0182717498,
-0.060029231,
0.0185428876,
0.0087425383,
0.0232005492,
0.0247423667,
-0.052586548,
0.0336668827,
-0.0235151779,
-0.043560449,
0.0381951667,
0.0019819355,
0.0028277047,
-0.0500534624,
0.0878132358,
0.0601875819,
-0.0344569124,
0.0473109856,
-0.0216820482,
-0.0454342775,
-0.0654045194,
0.008474635,
-0.0044608032,
0.0510049313,
-0.0060813357,
0.0064515891,
-0.0379232801,
0.0186213441,
0.005153094,
0.0840832293,
0.0699412376,
-0.0210221298,
0.0256968327,
0.0307547823,
-0.0301408991,
0.0210660137,
0.0186435245,
0.0668745115,
0.011639786,
-0.0071144891,
0.0191450622,
-0.0365420505,
0.0010593208,
0.0241224989,
-0.0674422532,
-0.0081989579,
-0.0179095268,
0.0013426684,
-0.0004026034,
0.0219796058,
0.0008334306,
-0.0051388061,
0.04305562,
-0.0534215532,
-0.002378094,
0.0069052689,
-0.0377430804,
0.0254782382,
-0.0085755,
-0.001039985,
-0.0071750921,
-0.076035507,
-0.0046742675,
-0.0238627121,
0.0335965529,
0.0082425727,
0.055412598,
-0.0016612444,
-0.0008550083,
-0.0134893991,
0.0221132543,
-0.0512213185,
0.0214978177,
-0.0237244572,
-0.0120626548,
0.0138810156,
0.0215775073,
-0.0218536127,
0.0230155829,
0.0226869117,
0.0240076017,
0.0111057376,
0.0287487302,
0.0144232623,
0.0219477341,
-0.0083593884,
-0.0024433809,
-0.0076880688,
-0.0407010503,
0.0372274332,
-0.0122460285,
0.0045092036,
-0.0288605243,
-0.0210162029,
0.0041490239,
-0.0078612193,
-0.0046770587,
-0.0082291355,
-0.0415582433,
0.0240958109,
-0.0040941229,
-0.0251529086,
-0.0096988445,
0.0049028248,
-0.0036145458,
0.0132785533,
0.0862171799,
-0.0072173853,
-0.0449954234,
0.0258017164,
-0.0288480017,
0.0479296334,
-0.0021836027,
-0.0415962264,
0.023416264,
-0.0556372926,
0.05506384,
0.0559846014,
-0.0364677273,
0.0120524624,
0.0241171271,
-0.0143184857,
-0.0698964596,
0.012718712,
-0.0274850484,
0.020658657,
0.0322171934,
-0.0528176576,
0.0418761745,
0.0338840969,
0.0202179346,
0.0336393267,
-0.0361112058,
0.0785143077,
0.0550437719,
-0.0285198633,
-0.0091206729,
0.0127885481,
0.0087779947,
0.0450114794,
-0.021009393,
-0.0138522089,
0.0015998073,
-0.0854582638,
0.0173462573,
0.0664608255,
0.0232476853,
0.0097247437,
0.0842300653,
0.0338989906,
0.0057696649,
0.0297812466,
0.0095891422,
-0.0088374186,
0.0737688914,
0.0204086602,
-0.0089555606,
-0.013071198,
-0.0885993093,
0.0104376897,
0.0118594524,
-0.0557447262,
-0.0149783734,
0.0091092102,
-0.0200834367,
-0.01004388,
0.0014476863,
-0.0714583248,
0.0076210396,
0.0280391332,
0.013082304,
0.0530994721,
-0.0378117673,
-0.0245929584,
-0.0400584899,
-0.0347614065,
0.0283777993,
0.0568544157,
-0.0436683483,
-0.0156322438,
-0.0195417628,
0.0672039539,
-0.0150132608,
0.0131974332,
-0.0899825394,
0.0200598016,
0.0500070974,
0.0734400526,
0.009052068,
-0.032497827,
0.0268459581,
-0.0299513564,
-0.0091217626,
0.0347868241,
-0.0024899857,
0.0068982854,
0.0099075241,
0.018082872,
0.0831191093,
0.0077695274,
-0.0267422572,
-0.0574181452,
-0.0267367531,
-0.0165073052,
-0.0040590018,
-0.0096062301,
-0.0490502678,
-0.0049446141,
-0.1130793169,
0.0562641695,
0.0143616665,
-0.0453940965,
-0.0763237551,
0.0257809218,
0.0602591373,
0.013065516,
-0.0626915917,
-0.0041038482,
-0.0250572395,
0.00269197,
0.0254414249,
0.0032465004,
-0.0343870707,
-0.0023376665,
0.0135046104,
-0.0276475083,
0.0030424125,
0.0213906057,
0.0060025309,
-0.0363714062,
0.0462257527,
0.0465344936,
0.0005188778,
-0.0125640538,
-0.026467789,
0.0884762779,
-0.0184425153,
0.01937088,
0.0255334452,
-0.0306349155,
-0.0238975231,
-0.0289337095,
0.0262855105,
-0.0142203644,
0.0382602923,
-0.0390747078,
-0.0254434552,
0.0090453746,
0.019977821,
-0.0094881821,
-0.0224277824,
-0.0412769802,
-0.0743815452,
0.0046729567,
-0.0134433089,
-0.0878131539,
-0.0115910033,
-0.0147173107,
-0.0403288119,
-0.0691232458,
0.0509190373,
0.0389017984,
0.0359647796,
-0.0111509478,
-0.0624993816,
0.0055491044,
-0.0068198661,
-0.0415210798,
-0.0011576614,
-0.0098548857,
0.0042805681,
-0.0206968002,
0.0098340064,
0.0062585212,
-0.0743139535,
-0.0182030499,
0.0226329975,
-0.0443013161,
-0.0127092116,
0.0292311739,
0.052597262,
0.0053957971,
0.0245397147,
-0.0158101507,
-0.0321681462,
0.0725864097,
0.0332151167,
0.0213653967,
-0.0074746357,
-0.0027523164,
0.0280424003,
-0.0044280323,
-0.018867055,
-0.015730096,
0.0489199609,
-0.0054832143,
-0.0436378717,
0.0034060669,
-0.0691450387,
0.0056952117,
-0.005282796,
0.0041724145,
0.0178778209,
0.0572845973,
-0.0726516545,
0.0137361251,
-0.0473629646,
-0.0361485407,
-0.0560868606,
0.0338760503,
-0.0048130131,
-0.0748865381,
0.0027654858,
-0.0256895311,
0.0126249474,
0.0755105466,
-0.0429962054,
0.0176358726,
0.0006328104,
0.0095339101,
0.0475673452,
-0.001688742,
0.017607538,
0.0700477362,
-0.0911850184,
0.0406158902,
-0.0143560031,
-0.0233663321,
-0.0047281114,
-0.027384894,
-0.0480268188,
0.0507835001,
-0.0087247277,
-0.0733378753,
-0.1035522595,
0.0316504948,
0.0462431274,
0.0496294498,
0.0443064459,
-0.0710292384,
-0.0147068137,
0.0137828654,
0.0358871855,
0.0342119038,
-0.0366694108,
0.0188883189,
0.0041430509,
-0.0047260388,
-0.0922814161,
-0.0029817862,
0.0361120403,
0.012315915,
0.0090439664,
-0.044396285,
-0.0374678336,
0.0002716574,
-0.0044604465,
-0.0219830982,
0.0083126007,
0.029550191,
-0.022119673,
-0.0400214493,
-0.0182199478,
0.0970263705,
-0.0121921049,
0.0038885486,
0.0405718014,
0.0814626589,
-0.035048034,
-0.0061457246,
0.0108526824,
0.0301546138,
-0.0160904545,
-0.0189940445,
-0.016039785,
-5.443074796e-33,
-0.0206779353,
-0.0257489365,
-0.0204109065,
-0.0249757636,
-0.0016207062,
-0.0279152486,
-0.0317984894,
0.0127892187,
0.0293678474,
0.0009590715,
-0.00282536,
-0.0061967233,
-0.0218220204,
0.0207836945,
0.0342915282,
0.0192225389,
0.0581881963,
-0.0069504702,
-0.0341084488,
0.0444666296,
-0.0159135982,
-0.0072728773,
0.0381228887,
-0.05603889,
0.0178307611,
-0.0058453768,
-0.0178372655,
-0.0202816539,
-0.0020720486,
0.041185461,
-0.0104719661,
0.0327641219,
0.0130636264,
-0.0095855668,
-0.0417838618,
0.0038136919,
-0.0797874182,
-0.0291906372,
-0.0337808616,
0.0223289579,
-0.0475363433,
-0.0388786793,
0.0261050519,
-0.0077796639,
-0.0201713238,
-0.0117982225,
0.0214392301,
-0.0379887708,
-0.0068843444,
-0.009572587,
-0.0415056646,
0.0059904666,
-0.0417422727,
-0.0239148922,
0.0240016859,
-0.0024076847,
0.0500401072,
0.0149267362,
0.0197617356,
0.029407803,
-0.0030547665,
0.0052699563,
0.0574925579,
0.0292694084,
0.0296927318,
0.0338913165,
0.0349827707,
-0.0153050516,
0.0050844564,
0.0206751339,
0.0284057558,
0.0840212032,
0.013573098,
0.0173266232,
0.0015929083,
0.0320098475,
0.0002426685,
0.0346569195,
-0.1027944908,
0.0218322556,
0.0325487815,
-0.005372995,
0.0102067403,
-0.0119182067,
-0.0180778131,
-0.0423349701,
-0.0130749187,
0.049629923,
-0.0163478125,
0.0153947715,
0.0075468319,
-0.0184987411,
-0.0150744906,
0.0241661742,
-0.0133247059,
0.012590101,
-0.0470858924,
0.0321970172,
-0.0007688535,
0.0013895443,
-0.0155758355,
-0.0047929017,
-0.0201914832,
0.0187312998,
0.0393678993,
0.0212910306,
-0.0431655012,
0.0372642502,
0.0007590968,
0.0367241241,
-0.0647756904,
0.0194030907,
0.0118761742,
0.0518202111,
0.0557665043,
0.0071876161,
-0.0088747637,
0.000870103,
-0.0073734694,
-0.0251009818,
-0.0086542508,
0.0204349365,
-0.041607298,
0.0278887656,
-0.0428723842,
-0.0099393278,
-0.0316520706,
-0.0138193397,
0.0897442997,
-0.1012770683,
-0.0305489693,
-0.0072650691,
2.738e-7,
0.0099892495,
0.0627115667,
0.0148962718,
0.0810833275,
0.0086705182,
0.0503574759,
0.0055413325,
0.0433491394,
-0.0010467175,
-0.0024275803,
0.0023529923,
0.02577365,
0.0271346942,
0.0062294211,
-0.077691108,
0.0737260804,
-0.0412297174,
0.0362650678,
-0.0528309643,
0.0290016849,
0.0440394245,
0.0445224345,
-0.0258619692,
-0.0171316266,
0.0064242072,
0.0189819969,
-0.0048711281,
-0.0380662605,
0.0427564196,
0.0173761398,
0.0314542204,
0.0057137297,
-0.0225693081,
-0.0026008743,
-0.0134848692,
-0.0105285719,
0.0197634902,
0.0384501405,
0.0017639988,
0.0423574708,
0.0317123644,
-0.0503698066,
-0.0075601186,
-0.0016269712,
0.0099799316,
-0.0363519005,
0.0514235459,
-0.022511838,
0.0350762196,
0.0154241454,
-0.0056457338,
-0.0297492668,
-0.0106946817,
-0.0049181618,
0.0183805972,
-0.0312769301,
0.0247443821,
-0.0017441571,
-0.0524834506,
-0.0095064482,
-0.0672136322,
-0.0124809202,
-0.0282867402,
-0.045273561,
-0.0381099954,
0.0496685058,
0.010286686,
2.595569357e-34,
-0.0026025733,
0.0384869687,
0.0225556958,
0.0116817541,
0.0119907893,
0.0192056596,
0.1056129187,
0.0222918503,
-0.010490465,
-0.0369286537,
-0.0302020311
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06431v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06431v2 | Human-AI Collaborative Essay Scoring: A Dual-Process Framework with LLMs | 2024-01-12T07:50:10 | 2024-06-15T03:44:08 | Changrong Xiao, Wenxing Ma, Qingping Song, Sean Xin Xu, Kunpeng Zhang, Yufang Wang, Qi Fu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Receiving timely and personalized feedback is essential for second-language
learners, especially when human instructors are unavailable. This study
explores the effectiveness of Large Language Models (LLMs), including both
proprietary and open-source models, for Automated Essay Scoring (AES). Through
extensive experiments with public and private datasets, we find that while LLMs
do not surpass conventional state-of-the-art (SOTA) grading models in
performance, they exhibit notable consistency, generalizability, and
explainability. We propose an open-source LLM-based AES system, inspired by the
dual-process theory. Our system offers accurate grading and high-quality
feedback, at least comparable to that of fine-tuned proprietary LLMs, in
addition to its ability to alleviate misgrading. Furthermore, we conduct
human-AI co-grading experiments with both novice and expert graders. We find
that our system not only automates the grading process but also enhances the
performance and efficiency of human graders, particularly for essays where the
model has lower confidence. These results highlight the potential of LLMs to
facilitate effective human-AI collaboration in the educational context,
potentially transforming learning experiences through AI-generated feedback. | [
0.0314183012,
0.0410786979,
-0.0301552396,
0.0019754416,
-0.0372388698,
-0.0086116502,
0.014199594,
-0.0311732758,
0.0108402325,
-0.0482592396,
-0.0320340544,
-0.0173495561,
0.0025173097,
0.0239904691,
-0.0016749214,
-0.0086033465,
0.0016510197,
-0.0208204146,
0.0301455446,
-0.0038341112,
0.0049902783,
0.0026417875,
-0.0337778702,
0.0551130474,
-0.0034670045,
-0.0131813409,
-0.0210470129,
-0.0224909931,
-0.0004796968,
-0.0034428921,
0.023073256,
0.0763769671,
-0.0138522079,
0.0165744256,
0.0000020792,
-0.0547473952,
0.0334608629,
-0.0215059631,
-0.0113341538,
0.0420983918,
0.0475157499,
0.0614818446,
-0.0120228473,
-0.0021800038,
-0.050440073,
-0.0080175279,
0.0147795463,
-0.0081655374,
0.0813045427,
0.0142383864,
0.0165685024,
-0.0207515489,
0.0662823766,
0.0063626664,
-0.012030242,
-0.0282161925,
0.0119584706,
0.0036354135,
0.0104293618,
-0.0011585484,
-0.0168261565,
0.0121632162,
0.0041115875,
-0.0747429132,
0.0213536285,
0.0179876368,
-0.0151617108,
-0.0064604105,
0.0148536665,
0.0477180444,
0.0228070021,
-0.0331723765,
-0.0170036182,
-0.0093817525,
0.0347337052,
0.0280489903,
-0.0732945427,
0.0153991003,
-0.0055159642,
0.0146957161,
0.0488443077,
-0.0246354695,
0.0020745408,
0.0343143232,
0.0363137871,
0.0358886197,
0.0022284482,
-0.0516954809,
-0.0121807717,
0.0547893345,
-0.0073988577,
-0.0289454311,
0.0486354567,
0.0527699478,
-0.0425919555,
-0.0003716601,
-0.009621745,
-0.0350103378,
0.0100492043,
-0.0277618431,
0.0931063518,
0.0104433177,
-0.0090289498,
0.000609698,
0.0006560897,
0.0677166954,
0.0618569292,
0.0366727561,
-0.0220118817,
0.0068117324,
-0.0726142973,
-0.0088196779,
0.0103765326,
0.0546179712,
0.0328712463,
0.0269028433,
-0.0786475688,
-0.030179156,
-0.0828190595,
0.0445663296,
0.0470414013,
-0.0090235043,
-0.0089892633,
0.0163007565,
-0.0185794923,
0.0440538153,
-0.027325511,
0.0117275948,
-0.0028082638,
-0.0117975408,
0.0120791513,
0.0064805513,
0.0045809145,
0.0117494753,
0.0009671291,
0.0166002996,
0.0050122566,
-0.004171161,
0.0077313352,
-0.0216495097,
0.018639531,
-0.0364906713,
-0.0375087559,
-0.0437804349,
0.0215438288,
0.0043454147,
0.0027218531,
-0.0688976049,
-0.0053620306,
0.0280153286,
0.0014726996,
0.0415507592,
0.0068050507,
0.0138535257,
0.0210104622,
0.0073907059,
0.0005458287,
0.0057916399,
0.0570862442,
-0.0050685769,
0.0572818257,
-0.0345025882,
0.0891679674,
0.0355344862,
-0.0193357002,
-0.0276753847,
0.0445093326,
-0.0242542587,
-0.0129999891,
0.0318805017,
-0.002295841,
0.0281166304,
0.0389478505,
0.0336956158,
0.0820920914,
0.0720875412,
-0.0085646752,
0.0627457276,
0.0425194427,
0.0277777817,
0.0311927814,
0.0294850245,
-0.0428923257,
0.0152666112,
-0.0273012947,
-0.0139496932,
0.002243866,
0.0087162405,
-0.0019252177,
-0.1158018187,
-0.0140456678,
-0.0247723386,
-0.0172632206,
0.0356049724,
0.0373781621,
-0.0408691354,
-0.0113575198,
0.0015380202,
0.0142235234,
-0.0703958124,
0.0662973449,
-0.0599175878,
0.0350881331,
0.1165684313,
0.0609049723,
-0.0307779852,
0.017698098,
-0.0236746483,
0.0371206291,
0.003706042,
0.03467362,
-0.0337069035,
-0.0407746546,
-0.0268229879,
-0.0182407368,
-0.0027336748,
0.0068188622,
0.0015506805,
-0.0092863459,
-0.013598158,
-0.0080897799,
0.0377416238,
-0.1156703979,
0.0309813153,
-0.0308003128,
-0.0228706803,
-0.0124378316,
-0.007095471,
-0.0019928545,
0.0636084899,
-0.0132923406,
0.0211049654,
0.0122717125,
-0.0116204554,
-0.0336983763,
-0.0197104048,
-0.022363957,
0.0491481647,
0.0549884439,
-0.0284670349,
-0.0100243511,
0.0390207544,
-0.0158824883,
-0.0381120369,
0.0212896895,
0.0004251178,
-0.0351484418,
-0.0043834904,
0.0177013054,
-0.0324105769,
-0.0272948928,
-0.0621907078,
-0.0209277309,
0.0122666499,
0.0455785021,
-0.0826478004,
-0.0191024076,
0.0097796628,
-0.0095227538,
-0.0333172753,
0.0167935025,
0.0147363916,
0.0269661825,
0.017764831,
-0.0012867704,
-0.0469799899,
-0.0459581725,
-0.0779495463,
-0.0219837613,
0.0130498474,
0.0131319584,
0.0031703415,
-0.0533616953,
-0.0056842095,
0.0361454822,
-0.0369768254,
-0.0187520832,
0.0133986156,
-0.0253538173,
0.0376600027,
-0.0071974597,
0.0083790179,
-0.0694011971,
-0.0273700338,
-0.0587914996,
-0.0043461649,
0.084566921,
0.0052803196,
-0.0610582456,
0.0372883715,
0.016807666,
-0.010540504,
0.0222771261,
-0.0577376112,
0.0130923148,
-0.0095038619,
0.0138367638,
0.0866936147,
-0.009746898,
0.0162104443,
0.0733752847,
-0.0240078717,
-0.051057741,
-0.0071776942,
0.0094879577,
-0.0158180855,
-0.0389331654,
-0.039838016,
-0.0283264033,
0.0578895807,
0.0325539783,
-0.0574633218,
-0.0350112952,
0.0521034151,
-0.0643202513,
0.0040386994,
-0.0252200607,
-0.0612735562,
-0.0192546546,
0.0156947225,
-0.0137028312,
-0.0114334766,
0.0771416351,
-0.0135281272,
0.0013608028,
-0.010541413,
0.0278424956,
-0.0135752559,
0.0293559544,
-0.0070059807,
-0.0302411355,
-0.0575339533,
0.0541267879,
-0.0140749021,
0.0336702876,
0.0373254307,
-0.0654539689,
0.0265958626,
-0.0617642589,
-0.0587284528,
0.0127229691,
-0.0245154705,
-0.0130080078,
0.0189815816,
-0.0436207578,
0.0247702412,
-0.0337894,
-0.0132450182,
0.0135050537,
-0.0411728732,
0.0278421268,
0.011582206,
-0.0538712069,
-0.0249224491,
-0.0001384862,
-0.0016900647,
-0.004797441,
-0.0308187418,
-0.0347172655,
-0.0331303142,
0.0567069612,
0.0400173105,
0.0675080568,
0.0218347255,
0.0218527988,
-0.0168854762,
0.0608537756,
-0.0455868132,
-0.0226796735,
0.0255507901,
0.0321074277,
-0.0614827834,
-0.0008653447,
0.1364628077,
0.0262581408,
-0.0735109895,
-0.0055558016,
-0.0560347065,
-0.0355970897,
0.0230490733,
0.0420728624,
-0.023990104,
-0.004548905,
-0.0033090508,
0.0490952283,
-0.0080321543,
-0.0404442325,
0.0277886167,
-0.106868118,
0.0464920811,
0.003074988,
0.0231489483,
0.0160823539,
-0.0568301864,
-0.0151215615,
-0.0235156324,
-0.0533453412,
-0.014952654,
0.023466805,
0.0320349708,
0.0238056332,
-0.0193545651,
-0.0127865113,
0.0393638536,
-0.0329960063,
0.0324150585,
0.0257509965,
0.0536280014,
-0.0273897089,
-0.0710797608,
0.0540828146,
-0.0093070399,
-0.0084658731,
-0.0170394331,
0.0119735822,
-0.0170195103,
0.031568408,
-0.0531601049,
0.0437374413,
-0.0230230168,
-0.0075151138,
0.0548231043,
0.0811085775,
0.0047400966,
-0.0096249087,
-0.0039500785,
-0.0062991157,
-0.0091113895,
0.0693657026,
0.0535741225,
-0.094859615,
-0.0005722792,
-0.0635869354,
0.0173638687,
-0.0666866675,
-0.0776797161,
0.0246886257,
0.0055733337,
0.014465631,
-0.0329810306,
-0.0873717889,
0.0124318302,
0.0012456805,
0.0242182743,
0.0423015766,
-0.0008132225,
-0.0098551307,
-0.0261328239,
0.0015530672,
-0.008514517,
0.029527517,
-0.0403490476,
-0.0254682507,
-0.0113625899,
0.0022318654,
-0.0291909948,
-0.0099545596,
-0.0437348895,
-0.0370111838,
0.0522535108,
0.0761393011,
0.0110007431,
0.0044234782,
0.0127621787,
-0.0773453861,
0.0148579637,
-0.0341137052,
-0.0241247527,
-0.0115998155,
0.0164403021,
0.0001906608,
0.0158376526,
0.0042921724,
0.0175317042,
-0.0091133835,
0.0647486374,
0.0371204242,
-0.0040593878,
-0.0444084108,
0.0121193202,
0.0569379926,
0.0594754964,
-0.0303989965,
-0.0270926785,
-0.0430306308,
0.0310439635,
-0.0384895504,
-0.0317615159,
-0.0229882859,
-0.0320158713,
0.0339645706,
-0.0349279568,
0.0041667568,
0.0166523885,
-0.0341047309,
0.0404341072,
-0.0293671116,
0.0744433179,
0.0218807738,
0.0773277208,
-0.0076604178,
0.0017978586,
-0.0097860992,
-0.0013557718,
0.0378254727,
0.0415863879,
0.0027398856,
0.0673029646,
-0.0225035641,
0.0055952361,
0.0580474064,
0.0386142582,
-0.0214035474,
0.0141378967,
-0.0311084986,
0.0211886112,
0.0328000821,
0.0203930009,
0.0468385555,
0.0061021652,
0.011454857,
-0.0225144885,
0.0472376347,
-0.0044983383,
-0.023099808,
-0.0151600474,
0.0040830947,
0.0183545873,
0.0041335938,
0.0522417054,
-0.0419666357,
0.0066055651,
-0.0526259467,
-0.0206389446,
-0.0142330118,
-0.0184392519,
0.0059156087,
0.0170107204,
-0.0016263634,
0.0019410893,
-0.0463081188,
-0.0367338508,
-0.0111038629,
0.0588496886,
0.0223693606,
-0.0484984145,
-0.0016382759,
0.0570614226,
-0.047513701,
-0.0047757206,
-0.0759682357,
-0.0043547251,
0.0083320383,
-0.0445564613,
-0.0057971692,
-5.597605284e-33,
-0.0207113195,
-0.0614629202,
0.0038225788,
0.0825572386,
-0.0000533449,
-0.0121069364,
-0.0168977566,
0.0359080099,
0.0345005505,
0.0297148637,
-0.017273983,
-0.0167009048,
-0.0130365985,
0.0126960445,
0.086230956,
0.0240058508,
0.0226186048,
-0.026097903,
-0.02109107,
-0.0159723908,
-0.0146614481,
0.0203692075,
0.0600812957,
-0.0538800098,
0.1108264104,
-0.0321277045,
-0.0004210424,
-0.0078047509,
-0.0487903357,
0.0450428352,
0.0045193732,
0.0595662892,
0.0311551057,
-0.0154177463,
0.0258859992,
-0.0098362416,
-0.037368983,
-0.0451408923,
0.0096571101,
0.0065074288,
0.0161582045,
-0.0553598776,
0.0272194762,
-0.0021336714,
-0.0883769691,
-0.0057860962,
0.0623667985,
-0.0256480295,
0.0249789115,
-0.0042233476,
-0.0391835608,
-0.0102363257,
-0.0363939069,
-0.0058418377,
0.0155163994,
0.028686557,
-0.0003344229,
-0.0167821217,
-0.0378002152,
0.0386552773,
-0.0013526301,
0.0508724339,
0.0700783506,
-0.030922642,
-0.0267254543,
0.0284048542,
0.0484509505,
0.0301747415,
-0.0427553467,
-0.0201594606,
0.0374004282,
-0.0181794763,
0.102552481,
0.0725322887,
-0.0214597639,
0.0061905901,
-0.0605333112,
0.0765304193,
0.0214702338,
0.0273514874,
-0.0076740966,
-0.0269603077,
-0.0503680818,
-0.0267011244,
-0.0721268207,
-0.0499535501,
-0.0256833583,
-0.0175993703,
0.02219937,
-0.0433187746,
-0.0055600596,
-0.0307341497,
-0.0250129327,
-0.0430938788,
-0.0475811772,
-0.0303453114,
0.0130525343,
0.0338002481,
-0.0199022759,
-0.032975059,
-0.0039391876,
0.0047043711,
-0.0402566046,
-0.0004369557,
0.0502950661,
0.0013994912,
0.033349704,
0.0173126981,
-0.0214736182,
-0.010511158,
-0.0429867208,
-0.0259639621,
0.0410345607,
-0.0141920839,
0.0128085027,
0.0125633301,
-0.0187203195,
0.0641543716,
0.011180711,
0.039469216,
-0.0240116622,
-0.048503466,
0.000936757,
-0.0077656698,
-0.0196620934,
-0.0094950097,
-0.0352539234,
-0.0195006207,
-0.0238318704,
-0.0152802169,
-0.0084324097,
-0.0391993746,
2.574e-7,
0.0363197178,
0.0814455971,
-0.0207737163,
-0.012783546,
0.0083826035,
0.0197868031,
-0.0386198796,
-0.0164031405,
0.0419870578,
0.059708368,
0.0155502632,
0.0323042721,
0.0626192763,
0.0184557252,
-0.0636911467,
-0.0510134734,
-0.0144680655,
0.0181706063,
-0.0237837099,
0.0432046875,
0.0764031708,
-0.0042427327,
0.0602854304,
-0.0237924028,
-0.0390898623,
-0.028954003,
0.0159842707,
-0.0211237129,
-0.0281059779,
0.0441762842,
0.0485972054,
-0.034135472,
0.0233181361,
0.0375538357,
-0.0244620722,
-0.0241520293,
0.0272272769,
0.0574004538,
-0.0096791238,
0.0061434666,
0.0203427821,
-0.0009531323,
0.0018143996,
-0.0520535819,
0.0489440821,
0.0038837299,
-0.0250601694,
0.0081938319,
-0.0124931447,
-0.0440018252,
0.0173184182,
-0.0223700162,
0.026401097,
0.0143379178,
-0.0052891448,
-0.0136621324,
0.0213831123,
-0.0126361018,
-0.0495752953,
-0.0306533109,
0.0061021149,
-0.0216422509,
-0.0306618419,
-0.026650425,
-0.0154682277,
-0.0356971398,
0.0130131738,
2.025904361e-34,
0.0329106897,
-0.0126229161,
0.0368868336,
-0.0032973464,
0.0378950275,
0.029714318,
-0.0041193673,
0.0115061989,
0.0204271842,
-0.0264880974,
-0.0432745218
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06416v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06416v1 | Mission: Impossible Language Models | 2024-01-12T07:24:26 | 2024-01-12T07:24:26 | Julie Kallini, Isabel Papadimitriou, Richard Futrell, Kyle Mahowald, Christopher Potts | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Chomsky and others have very directly claimed that large language models
(LLMs) are equally capable of learning languages that are possible and
impossible for humans to learn. However, there is very little published
experimental evidence to support such a claim. Here, we develop a set of
synthetic impossible languages of differing complexity, each designed by
systematically altering English data with unnatural word orders and grammar
rules. These languages lie on an impossibility continuum: at one end are
languages that are inherently impossible, such as random and irreversible
shuffles of English words, and on the other, languages that may not be
intuitively impossible but are often considered so in linguistics, particularly
those with rules based on counting word positions. We report on a wide range of
evaluations to assess the capacity of GPT-2 small models to learn these
uncontroversially impossible languages, and crucially, we perform these
assessments at various stages throughout training to compare the learning
process for each language. Our core finding is that GPT-2 struggles to learn
impossible languages when compared to English as a control, challenging the
core claim. More importantly, we hope our approach opens up a productive line
of inquiry in which different LLM architectures are tested on a variety of
impossible languages in an effort to learn more about how LLMs can be used as
tools for these cognitive and typological investigations. | [
0.0390439183,
0.0885422528,
-0.0449134223,
0.0231269002,
-0.060572274,
0.0260671377,
-0.0126877967,
-0.0035467173,
0.0114655802,
-0.018922396,
-0.0114249876,
-0.0626401678,
-0.0074966485,
0.0084796678,
0.0489535257,
-0.0259334929,
0.0508091934,
-0.0465224981,
-0.0013610605,
-0.0130961947,
-0.011898201,
-0.0316911638,
-0.0310423411,
-0.0000187503,
0.0108250668,
0.007780714,
-0.006557195,
-0.0197029319,
-0.0171759967,
-0.0062667178,
-0.0083814012,
0.0281904712,
0.0013815542,
0.1101487204,
0.0000017931,
-0.0271464046,
0.0287683345,
-0.0134740947,
-0.0162111055,
-0.0000284028,
0.0315565653,
-0.0276991837,
-0.0598439537,
0.0106299166,
-0.0290169865,
-0.0238042548,
0.0544731654,
0.0373668671,
0.0324127115,
0.0964025632,
-0.0039713765,
-0.0520876274,
0.0545602813,
-0.0490460396,
0.0415231623,
0.0072769406,
0.0122360019,
-0.0451227836,
0.0231833216,
-0.008264631,
-0.0295035038,
0.0140441582,
0.0579352044,
0.045445282,
-0.044038184,
0.0451150723,
-0.0413695425,
-0.0640179068,
-0.0322054662,
0.0278486647,
-0.0496463515,
-0.0229752827,
0.0057579004,
0.0006476902,
0.0241258889,
0.0022943886,
-0.0530147702,
0.0485870317,
0.0532621928,
0.0508161858,
0.0399821475,
-0.0094922623,
0.0403409153,
-0.0140515752,
-0.006264654,
0.1129658222,
0.0201366954,
-0.029557744,
0.0278277528,
0.0348569229,
-0.0204711258,
-0.0135876611,
-0.0251268744,
-0.0045483629,
-0.0237724595,
0.0520981103,
-0.0240268968,
0.0259561427,
0.0402089879,
-0.0447911732,
0.0685991049,
0.0030967279,
-0.0115328357,
0.049226556,
-0.0424741432,
0.0594750457,
-0.0242919084,
0.0394739173,
-0.0285631251,
0.0138514331,
-0.0433757156,
-0.0337052047,
-0.0119675715,
-0.0166925956,
-0.0415927991,
-0.0157353003,
-0.0140680103,
-0.0025848798,
-0.0001491733,
0.0103024608,
-0.0028219635,
-0.02452779,
-0.0308364443,
-0.0347715355,
-0.0350449421,
-0.0274939686,
0.0031029107,
0.0169490445,
-0.0013116801,
-0.0857360736,
-0.0096047521,
0.0167832561,
-0.0552106649,
0.0007261726,
0.0070847096,
0.059299998,
-0.0172799192,
-0.0429547839,
-0.0230825692,
0.0562808476,
-0.0254516471,
-0.0646654069,
0.0496815629,
-0.0516984314,
-0.0090955319,
0.0151982047,
0.0107695581,
-0.0482369252,
0.0244857594,
0.0102307629,
-0.0572089776,
0.0749755949,
0.027786769,
0.0230091531,
-0.0054733297,
-0.0090346849,
0.0059727426,
0.0649442673,
0.0421350822,
-0.002474189,
0.0155084589,
-0.0100900782,
0.0439552255,
0.0470044129,
-0.023521591,
0.0144235436,
-0.0332696363,
-0.0392753854,
-0.0015109561,
0.0356342047,
0.0222365167,
0.0661135614,
0.0223378092,
-0.0178690404,
0.0602714121,
0.0220499784,
-0.028010916,
0.0283341315,
0.0577898435,
-0.0263394564,
0.016019335,
0.0225771666,
-0.0536774136,
0.0021975336,
-0.0187729187,
0.0291700028,
-0.0221528616,
-0.0031035803,
-0.0166150015,
-0.0209570341,
-0.020044541,
-0.018755395,
0.0238503329,
-0.0176191293,
0.0695210621,
0.0186262745,
-0.0437886566,
0.0127363587,
0.0385591127,
-0.0256733578,
-0.0110905925,
-0.0134400968,
0.0060556885,
0.0496659838,
0.0287750363,
-0.0352653265,
0.0106330039,
0.0220724382,
-0.0199604835,
0.0773859099,
0.0675076991,
0.0259166434,
0.0000781564,
-0.0374359973,
0.0529657677,
0.0152097214,
0.0336762592,
0.0215395745,
-0.0010609301,
0.0028120161,
-0.0284862313,
-0.0274979472,
-0.0385559611,
0.0393404961,
-0.0792658329,
-0.0206629746,
-0.0245119892,
-0.0234397706,
0.0272543039,
-0.0146476142,
-0.0183242075,
0.0271564685,
0.0589864589,
-0.0605150871,
-0.010211926,
-0.0072974125,
-0.0866604298,
-0.0167898834,
0.0439986549,
-0.0526808687,
-0.0176161379,
0.0722908154,
-0.0302130729,
-0.0535353683,
0.0498392396,
-0.0598771721,
0.0611717626,
-0.0262730867,
0.0616892353,
0.0136745935,
-0.0046423185,
-0.0204809625,
0.074447453,
-0.0306022316,
0.0656492561,
-0.0191313084,
-0.0305270627,
0.00001919,
-0.0633051321,
-0.0053391694,
0.0383873656,
0.010177617,
0.0017997598,
-0.0140356654,
-0.0024640923,
-0.0662475601,
-0.0547183454,
-0.041708231,
0.0012619481,
-0.0086702593,
0.0162478611,
-0.0081558349,
-0.0425955653,
-0.0210484192,
-0.0360711068,
-0.0588892139,
0.0221681371,
0.0294618774,
0.0240408145,
0.0307687353,
-0.0127788819,
-0.0656696409,
-0.0225641299,
-0.0199547671,
-0.0071630091,
0.043783281,
-0.0339450389,
0.0269484259,
-0.031050235,
0.0134443147,
-0.0051360936,
0.0248213634,
-0.0121951038,
-0.0296717528,
0.0338650905,
-0.002466948,
0.0482104346,
0.0416130759,
-0.0136470925,
0.0630836114,
0.0439853966,
0.006745772,
0.012849356,
-0.0292759817,
-0.025382027,
-0.0319223776,
-0.0354421586,
-0.0481122471,
-0.0727427974,
0.0810460448,
0.0090755746,
0.0006030169,
-0.0635760128,
0.0746915117,
-0.0505750999,
-0.0360024944,
-0.0274079032,
-0.0100915637,
-0.0602053069,
0.0206427071,
-0.0458594151,
-0.031430345,
0.009971654,
-0.0159359276,
-0.0333439894,
-0.0568833686,
0.0112833334,
0.0017436009,
0.0612584352,
0.07301341,
0.0124346456,
0.0194146,
0.0125441961,
-0.0898505077,
0.0223717261,
0.0038555153,
-0.0196691994,
0.007364878,
-0.0707010254,
0.0010436337,
-0.0110150343,
-0.0486972518,
-0.0501870438,
-0.0457324386,
-0.0365171842,
0.0341758132,
0.0109162517,
-0.0082735233,
-0.0501585118,
-0.0183047596,
0.0476105362,
0.0291570481,
0.0071201893,
0.0047785654,
-0.0264985841,
0.0147113763,
0.0461434573,
-0.0038773529,
0.0356930271,
-0.0489932373,
0.0107172867,
0.0306548122,
0.038402617,
0.0539155975,
0.0043318779,
0.0351163335,
-0.0020297484,
-0.0272497255,
-0.0376395434,
0.0116333924,
0.0210563242,
-0.0134865232,
-0.0300904214,
0.0998532549,
0.0601236634,
0.0029705677,
0.0611875392,
0.0029596384,
0.0271163117,
0.0432271473,
-0.0003643114,
-0.0460183062,
-0.0024672579,
0.0232081711,
0.0119637325,
-0.0438071266,
-0.0223469194,
-0.0165948216,
-0.1336843371,
0.0017068278,
0.0386675894,
-0.038870018,
-0.0123607712,
-0.0134564992,
-0.0232582092,
-0.0075407708,
0.0304625183,
0.0329033136,
-0.0081873555,
0.0143583547,
0.0092730951,
0.0151282959,
-0.0371639431,
0.0070363069,
0.0188295264,
0.0746585727,
0.0384619795,
-0.0171069987,
-0.0517684929,
-0.0523260273,
0.0395422205,
0.0041332603,
-0.012183669,
0.0218912419,
0.0096744355,
0.0707501769,
-0.0361767858,
-0.0379830152,
0.0296703074,
-0.0451402366,
-0.0155986054,
-0.0264229961,
0.0989345759,
0.0030704478,
-0.0608319119,
0.0281614773,
-0.0320734866,
-0.0349908285,
0.0771363601,
0.0372484736,
-0.0553917363,
-0.0318211019,
-0.0560943857,
0.0076651913,
-0.0145863993,
-0.0580229722,
0.0549485832,
0.0319677368,
-0.0341177247,
-0.0681084692,
-0.0484223552,
-0.0017589079,
0.0220385436,
0.0195746683,
0.0009585219,
0.0320362039,
-0.0196780227,
-0.0155126369,
-0.0000254479,
-0.0022469265,
0.0019636985,
-0.0764143541,
-0.0568463691,
0.0329037011,
-0.0260706618,
-0.0160898883,
-0.0110561028,
-0.0185134187,
-0.0860458165,
0.0647898242,
0.0415740311,
0.0331128612,
-0.0061626122,
0.0080707762,
-0.0355376266,
0.0012239231,
0.0267360918,
-0.0162071194,
0.0151652237,
0.0337996855,
-0.0136512714,
0.0179036111,
0.0490807183,
-0.0009715786,
0.0314413458,
0.0164244883,
0.0393054932,
-0.0547084957,
0.0276775025,
0.0431019776,
0.0016659255,
0.0495486557,
-0.0285837445,
-0.0076410794,
-0.0087449672,
0.0113603827,
-0.0280760545,
0.0041117817,
-0.0180677883,
-0.0287059844,
0.0511780605,
0.0493058935,
-0.0292007215,
-0.0499647111,
0.0037111694,
0.0385656282,
0.008451663,
0.0201739538,
0.0340326764,
0.0367246419,
0.0174911562,
-0.0035463287,
-0.0141593013,
0.0543917492,
-0.0577647947,
0.0511652902,
0.0042018844,
0.0363130234,
0.0093469294,
-0.0043543107,
-0.0145574044,
0.0086487383,
-0.0512865968,
-0.0204226859,
0.0064612371,
0.0450044535,
0.0695504695,
-0.0446348228,
0.0475876331,
-0.0525024273,
0.0033582258,
-0.0248769075,
-0.034430936,
0.0230339337,
-0.0404252298,
-0.0125785442,
0.0288783815,
-0.0118829813,
0.0088041779,
0.0908886045,
0.0509845763,
0.0246951245,
0.0054168003,
0.0267779827,
-0.042539373,
-0.0088291736,
0.0117019406,
-0.0231754333,
-0.0011453569,
0.0409849472,
-0.051219631,
-0.0847454444,
-0.0451488346,
0.0370833389,
0.0528643727,
-0.0358531401,
0.0154876634,
0.0461006239,
-0.030538315,
0.0233179573,
-0.0385772362,
0.0084371995,
0.0298782419,
-0.0221073013,
-0.0310024377,
-6.307420568e-33,
-0.0042389329,
-0.0003458401,
-0.0109690111,
-0.0281854142,
0.0177055281,
-0.0404887572,
-0.0473285578,
0.0343264714,
0.0057748551,
0.009372944,
-0.02428459,
-0.0094349077,
0.008477848,
0.0370445624,
0.0203309283,
0.0187719353,
-0.0054144869,
-0.0255613346,
0.0004763864,
-0.0028472955,
0.0430678986,
0.0105546303,
0.0592466109,
-0.0264186431,
0.0314615183,
-0.0039833174,
0.0254242718,
0.0270466488,
-0.0590435453,
0.0304006189,
-0.02457303,
0.0314092375,
0.0239682589,
-0.050850749,
-0.0100463536,
-0.015682783,
-0.0049354299,
-0.0434577614,
0.0444163345,
0.0260344166,
0.0088624982,
-0.0292272475,
0.0651155412,
-0.0499891974,
-0.0636764392,
0.0507545881,
-0.0191773791,
-0.030496113,
-0.0203612503,
0.043051362,
-0.0647100955,
0.0113292057,
0.0250363927,
-0.0133568458,
0.0222923197,
-0.0324084461,
-0.0151355406,
-0.0592790693,
-0.04381584,
0.0101611679,
0.0289466158,
0.0307177678,
0.0564284511,
0.0080241654,
-0.0004567632,
0.0566248111,
0.0614413433,
0.0013209599,
-0.0104991263,
0.0155505175,
0.0410845913,
0.0212187711,
0.0845624879,
0.0105863092,
0.0437434763,
-0.00862794,
-0.0639567301,
-0.0431263521,
0.0347686484,
-0.0008323401,
0.0357417762,
0.024881281,
-0.0577709302,
-0.0154265976,
-0.0180975311,
-0.0061825258,
-0.0169786401,
-0.0081029022,
0.0291529614,
0.0078708576,
0.0212042183,
-0.0490240045,
-0.010562662,
-0.0129909432,
-0.0234069508,
-0.0126876254,
-0.0098699303,
0.03756373,
0.0051252055,
0.0258079115,
-0.0882883295,
-0.0229546074,
0.0047344146,
0.0247259531,
-0.0030419868,
0.0153080542,
0.0255610161,
0.0077041592,
-0.049118612,
0.0006745375,
-0.0323724449,
0.0369826518,
0.0085192677,
-0.0227604397,
0.0370134637,
-0.0071062865,
-0.0148693705,
-0.0330864973,
0.0285295472,
-0.0306751858,
-0.0568638928,
0.0198531765,
-0.0398551375,
0.0389933176,
-0.0154146971,
-0.016035758,
-0.0149253383,
0.0256750416,
0.0492269136,
-0.0431076996,
0.013211499,
0.0110197794,
2.603e-7,
0.0151357884,
0.05503802,
0.0057701613,
0.0027106153,
0.0595396273,
0.0238717347,
-0.0695233271,
0.0043466697,
-0.0248336159,
0.0162692163,
-0.0306350552,
0.039012596,
0.0683414787,
0.0024613368,
-0.0718871579,
0.0149204535,
-0.0430434942,
0.0342079103,
-0.0318397321,
0.0165813137,
0.0248726569,
0.1016032845,
-0.0095083257,
-0.014804963,
0.0007288403,
-0.0404982194,
0.0412277207,
-0.0365616158,
0.0132908151,
-0.037644878,
0.0040745731,
0.0179450177,
0.0133700315,
0.0199551173,
0.0172227062,
0.009833321,
-0.0240209699,
0.0248806421,
-0.013989618,
-0.0102940481,
0.0101223281,
-0.0124496985,
-0.0112238787,
-0.0785618797,
0.0473537259,
-0.0335720293,
-0.0388547555,
0.0533611104,
-0.0245975014,
0.0227995124,
-0.0043172417,
0.022978276,
-0.0629863665,
-0.0212994684,
0.0169162806,
-0.0224711336,
0.0162034761,
-0.0130388187,
-0.0024374386,
0.0237213466,
-0.0281943977,
-0.0709633827,
-0.0484480709,
0.0494444892,
-0.013022393,
-0.0346452668,
-0.0210962687,
2.191960846e-34,
0.0246980246,
-0.0086597372,
0.03357118,
-0.0101767806,
0.0130855842,
-0.0193397719,
0.0293519367,
0.0228430387,
0.0285102837,
-0.0641491041,
-0.0058662156
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06408v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06408v3 | AboutMe: Using Self-Descriptions in Webpages to Document the Effects of English Pretraining Data Filters | 2024-01-12T07:10:10 | 2024-06-20T18:21:49 | Li Lucy, Suchin Gururangan, Luca Soldaini, Emma Strubell, David Bamman, Lauren F. Klein, Jesse Dodge | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models' (LLMs) abilities are drawn from their pretraining
data, and model development begins with data curation. However, decisions
around what data is retained or removed during this initial stage are
under-scrutinized. In our work, we ground web text, which is a popular
pretraining data source, to its social and geographic contexts. We create a new
dataset of 10.3 million self-descriptions of website creators, and extract
information about who they are and where they are from: their topical
interests, social roles, and geographic affiliations. Then, we conduct the
first study investigating how ten "quality" and English language identification
(langID) filters affect webpages that vary along these social dimensions. Our
experiments illuminate a range of implicit preferences in data curation: we
show that some quality classifiers act like topical domain filters, and langID
can overlook English content from some regions of the world. Overall, we hope
that our work will encourage a new line of research on pretraining data
curation practices and its social implications. | [
0.0593040027,
0.0744046345,
-0.039754577,
-0.0062780562,
-0.0123399952,
0.0144914836,
0.0774903223,
-0.0095693357,
0.0384864882,
-0.0739627108,
-0.0358250365,
-0.0357008986,
-0.0071820305,
0.0027354772,
0.0194112323,
-0.012881184,
0.0148154749,
-0.0073980168,
0.0076535642,
-0.0416426063,
0.0119151929,
0.0376162305,
0.0373106599,
0.0343741253,
0.0105508743,
-0.0123222778,
0.0641129389,
-0.0047360719,
-0.0003104301,
-0.0047739674,
0.063669093,
0.0893900394,
-0.0304169729,
0.0167297013,
0.0000017042,
-0.0482371002,
-0.00780751,
-0.0307456627,
0.0151813701,
0.024542883,
0.0432211608,
0.0281655267,
-0.0176934935,
0.0438640043,
-0.045139052,
-0.0010912315,
0.0189171657,
0.0076626139,
0.0253957864,
0.04159531,
-0.019551605,
-0.0206345655,
-0.0610244237,
-0.0099146599,
0.0182775073,
0.0102874506,
0.0429149047,
-0.0539526977,
-0.0452059321,
-0.0096189715,
0.0095656589,
0.030643288,
-0.0272026025,
-0.0210028794,
0.0317936279,
0.0098973243,
-0.0420884043,
-0.0368308797,
0.028801173,
0.049604103,
0.0661321282,
-0.0391497649,
0.0277695525,
0.0070278146,
0.0291145053,
0.0512694716,
0.0136734489,
0.0470798872,
-0.0177700259,
0.0167274456,
0.0017762168,
0.0107629141,
0.0031851102,
0.0475950204,
-0.0313812867,
0.0719178095,
-0.0095398938,
-0.0099152531,
-0.0004850779,
0.0438591987,
0.0526655503,
-0.0804814175,
0.0685563311,
-0.0367738456,
0.0432456769,
0.0007605556,
-0.0470418446,
-0.0010546836,
0.0178409722,
-0.0655431449,
-0.0264727045,
0.0067311022,
-0.0296941865,
0.0306997504,
-0.0060365307,
-0.0046401988,
0.030643709,
0.0266147498,
-0.0303943455,
0.0108063295,
-0.0307153556,
0.0000480733,
-0.0088411504,
0.0189554114,
0.0260641053,
0.0205989014,
-0.0416651182,
0.0302364398,
-0.0157215483,
0.0083612576,
-0.018923901,
-0.0068186615,
-0.0176502578,
0.0041995505,
-0.0327819996,
-0.0075796512,
-0.0256683957,
0.0152899995,
-0.0208237357,
-0.0368565172,
0.0284882132,
0.008338443,
0.0415335558,
-0.0546239354,
0.0133726029,
0.0020279316,
0.0088138292,
-0.0367725231,
-0.0530088656,
-0.0271795597,
-0.0070792926,
0.0036467912,
-0.0134760207,
-0.0438614637,
0.0089219026,
0.0563468449,
0.0171991996,
-0.0987914354,
-0.0352843255,
0.0195727851,
-0.0393538065,
0.0305901896,
-0.0316890404,
0.0299406387,
0.0418908745,
0.0059901099,
0.0442629345,
0.0578636192,
-0.0085975621,
0.0503458567,
0.0575028323,
-0.0401993282,
0.0087049957,
0.0344749019,
0.0060218107,
0.0285913683,
-0.0230104327,
-0.0036026209,
-0.0103017902,
-0.0419336893,
0.0533551686,
0.0166476592,
-0.0079747261,
0.0172633752,
0.0974620581,
0.0760016292,
0.0183771122,
0.0597259365,
0.0164997298,
0.0370839238,
0.0107744094,
0.0214805473,
-0.0315135121,
-0.0433776788,
-0.0291551985,
-0.0214963444,
0.0064753722,
0.0690447614,
-0.0454167873,
-0.0399012789,
0.0006620248,
-0.0043001538,
0.0589058399,
0.0517715067,
0.0398229472,
0.0009003344,
0.0378083028,
0.0282495376,
0.0233551376,
-0.0634704456,
0.0360266119,
-0.0125834122,
0.0180731509,
0.0940915942,
0.0136915455,
-0.0238574147,
0.0207681805,
-0.0406970941,
0.0484096669,
0.0173879936,
0.0906658843,
-0.0101162214,
-0.0389773101,
-0.0152188344,
-0.064080894,
0.0070178015,
0.0127063589,
0.0081947157,
0.0384427756,
0.0266353227,
0.0358746909,
-0.0240503345,
-0.0752633438,
0.015493568,
-0.019260997,
-0.0153354974,
0.0086685177,
0.0187010039,
-0.0081100808,
0.0312503949,
-0.0155522935,
-0.0239683967,
-0.0188005734,
0.0120260706,
0.0105762649,
-0.0098169651,
-0.0068822941,
0.0253860001,
0.0402093641,
-0.0225027725,
-0.0081645101,
0.0316476636,
0.0089114951,
-0.00245153,
0.0199667253,
-0.0164518543,
0.0178223848,
-0.0230751578,
0.0266700182,
-0.0254808161,
0.0201179534,
-0.0294831283,
0.0383521765,
0.0173073914,
-0.0046073962,
-0.0182773173,
-0.0431621782,
0.0051866258,
-0.0147951618,
-0.0334778056,
-0.0094977133,
-0.0386944711,
0.0464064926,
0.0815381631,
-0.015454256,
-0.0480489433,
-0.0069489619,
-0.0753815174,
-0.0435454659,
-0.0323694907,
0.0117621673,
0.0095873289,
-0.0104912613,
-0.0343987122,
-0.0075070281,
-0.0719865039,
-0.0566437431,
-0.0321702473,
0.0278532691,
0.0360550061,
-0.0266331807,
0.0315675028,
-0.0096898992,
-0.0253952406,
-0.0131131029,
0.0407599285,
0.0292989668,
-0.0507974811,
-0.0417949073,
0.033798147,
-0.07169649,
-0.003042921,
-0.0048441938,
-0.0352836438,
-0.0142997326,
0.0093492931,
0.0008264537,
0.0295339711,
0.0132410657,
0.0112485718,
0.0666471794,
0.0106244013,
-0.0446218215,
-0.019929897,
-0.0118403593,
0.0162339024,
-0.0189543348,
-0.0597440749,
0.0332733765,
0.0505641773,
-0.0124220802,
-0.0152351884,
-0.0309774522,
0.0640535355,
-0.0433302745,
0.0026209012,
-0.025402043,
-0.0024606148,
0.0152150933,
0.0701588243,
-0.003526675,
-0.0463211238,
0.0623183213,
0.0032796464,
0.0301002935,
-0.0232673548,
-0.0513996184,
-0.0187541097,
-0.0011913878,
-0.0097805299,
0.0510580093,
0.0340519622,
-0.0247690212,
-0.0125742787,
-0.0063192463,
0.0782903284,
-0.0380718485,
-0.0087312628,
0.0020530177,
0.0131466538,
0.0085910764,
-0.0686850175,
-0.0492242649,
-0.1027962491,
-0.0265614819,
-0.0517181233,
0.0205298215,
-0.0347642004,
0.021156121,
-0.0012601484,
0.0342224874,
0.0469315723,
-0.0217123851,
-0.016741192,
0.0154721281,
-0.0013262102,
0.0313161984,
-0.000815538,
0.0070594368,
-0.0116800629,
-0.0137959784,
0.0021759789,
0.0504495166,
-0.0129205175,
0.0329015404,
0.0040525617,
0.0666170865,
-0.0464362018,
-0.0630259886,
0.0239540804,
0.0297417343,
-0.0142828804,
0.0069961059,
0.0917636305,
0.0334706679,
-0.0528018512,
-0.030500941,
-0.0017293155,
0.0218986925,
0.0345444195,
0.0302339625,
-0.0550178103,
0.0148641123,
0.0122651411,
0.0167439524,
-0.0318583362,
-0.0039002921,
-0.0233551078,
-0.0639173314,
0.0306455884,
0.0147204017,
-0.0336989462,
0.0295724906,
-0.0222542603,
-0.01457904,
-0.0179283563,
-0.0188932009,
-0.0426967852,
-0.0503830872,
0.0150654428,
0.0390409864,
-0.0645773932,
-0.0869225562,
-0.0043887217,
-0.0381357744,
0.0140941013,
0.0127106048,
0.0258762315,
-0.0255617239,
-0.0480416305,
0.0235552117,
-0.021476334,
-0.0150714824,
-0.0338703282,
0.0833864436,
-0.0187681951,
0.0010019098,
-0.0186480377,
0.0216069594,
-0.0041937111,
-0.0075592692,
-0.0132588781,
0.0027135927,
-0.0008788177,
-0.0350244753,
0.039284274,
0.0064516738,
-0.0079754656,
0.076617755,
0.0332548693,
-0.0971447006,
-0.0074967789,
-0.0622940399,
0.0068167644,
-0.0072279586,
-0.0599332117,
0.0374996811,
-0.0275969226,
-0.0804618523,
-0.0535693206,
-0.0696266219,
0.0309663843,
-0.0009141659,
0.0412407517,
-0.0031997005,
0.036091879,
-0.0381464548,
-0.045848459,
0.0528187454,
-0.0647596493,
0.009570701,
-0.0411587581,
-0.0402558483,
0.0360920131,
-0.0538088791,
0.0032199391,
-0.0014847807,
-0.0142556364,
-0.0442047082,
0.0525944754,
0.0067870393,
0.0224939492,
0.0432260819,
-0.0187212247,
-0.0962202623,
0.0567162558,
0.0187716205,
-0.0331705846,
-0.0051664775,
0.0346881896,
0.0009333394,
-0.0202972684,
0.0260183048,
-0.0180067569,
0.0192472208,
0.0611889437,
-0.0769423693,
-0.038056042,
0.007676708,
0.0321738012,
0.0295899119,
0.0505328514,
-0.030128248,
0.006768167,
-0.0660026595,
-0.0335681885,
-0.014696341,
-0.0189731773,
-0.0081054177,
-0.0247121174,
0.0663501024,
-0.0047291517,
-0.0154478271,
0.0397405885,
-0.0298301522,
0.0149896992,
-0.0740131736,
0.0320439115,
-0.0150436535,
0.0422063693,
0.0183888916,
0.008879818,
-0.0028533034,
0.0144894775,
0.06168475,
0.039513696,
-0.0233532805,
0.0183088295,
0.0072548073,
0.0160784852,
-0.0017463105,
0.0335064419,
-0.0542202368,
-0.0241207238,
-0.0223830547,
-0.0143077178,
0.0170341656,
-0.0674634576,
0.04766725,
0.0056060548,
-0.0092110205,
-0.0119258873,
0.0240950342,
0.0137693956,
-0.0273862053,
-0.0142392116,
-0.034935493,
-0.0727403015,
0.0126170069,
0.0718117654,
0.0371365361,
0.0056335358,
0.0020798913,
-0.0490544997,
-0.0339511409,
-0.009429249,
0.0259510484,
0.0277619231,
-0.0504860654,
-0.0244837664,
-0.0688010305,
-0.0688887462,
-0.0048383172,
-0.0383181982,
0.0190772768,
-0.0234360918,
0.0365509391,
0.066344358,
-0.0421359502,
0.008957414,
-0.0526554324,
-0.0349544324,
-0.0024848902,
0.0008385681,
0.0020645426,
-6.495026528e-33,
0.004915569,
-0.0377894789,
-0.0135260476,
0.0031518068,
0.0204530433,
-0.0080184527,
-0.01272575,
0.0112216249,
-0.0161611028,
-0.0144405132,
-0.0436531603,
0.019254338,
0.0233700313,
0.0220480878,
0.0079580797,
-0.0224479605,
0.0707161576,
0.0129227517,
-0.0378102586,
0.023596691,
0.0118657863,
0.016155716,
0.0427991189,
-0.0862464011,
0.0315279812,
0.0140907355,
-0.0255014561,
-0.0234999415,
0.0398777425,
0.0376646854,
-0.019864928,
0.0433843359,
0.0264565405,
-0.0136428587,
0.0059921653,
0.0177868474,
-0.0869034752,
-0.0385625884,
0.0018329546,
0.0343904719,
0.0382295735,
-0.037892852,
0.0523615479,
-0.0198710915,
-0.0522350259,
0.0224109348,
0.0752683431,
0.0162629317,
-0.010481921,
-0.0088363262,
-0.0236968398,
0.0332189575,
-0.010316954,
0.0223926734,
0.0511741377,
0.0543565489,
0.0253789928,
0.0004392326,
-0.0344838873,
0.041598063,
0.0126106078,
0.0032708005,
0.078910768,
0.0026633358,
0.0010516441,
0.0556246601,
0.02724161,
0.0696928427,
-0.0019623183,
-0.0204662643,
0.0461222604,
-0.016405154,
-0.0144657819,
0.0568579547,
-0.0297890455,
-0.0788526759,
-0.0227340627,
0.0507433303,
0.0117261047,
-0.0479559228,
-0.0022502616,
-0.0310178343,
-0.0395946093,
-0.0724225789,
-0.0271436013,
-0.0465262458,
-0.0337189324,
0.0059105749,
0.0158220213,
-0.0082168505,
-0.0794351622,
0.0127234124,
-0.0030319614,
-0.0470211729,
-0.0714065284,
0.0232141465,
-0.0549236163,
0.0104252417,
0.0082511734,
-0.0216213539,
-0.0271611828,
-0.0189197417,
-0.0373221897,
-0.0059535624,
0.0123786321,
0.0325255617,
0.0417036377,
0.0150971608,
-0.0741875842,
0.0133908298,
-0.0151507538,
0.0206503291,
0.0341232195,
0.0054309238,
0.0492221639,
0.0320124291,
-0.0011086219,
0.0067598308,
0.0899583921,
0.0159789845,
-0.0478123836,
-0.0513859317,
-0.004935266,
0.0372043774,
-0.0166514013,
-0.0281009171,
-0.0150725255,
0.0773111731,
0.0986435562,
-0.0232450124,
-0.0200974401,
-0.0689664334,
2.518e-7,
0.0322367251,
0.084596321,
-0.0108240684,
-0.0112543013,
-0.0058814404,
0.04329779,
0.0337666571,
0.0341702439,
0.0028576762,
0.0243554767,
0.0177891105,
0.0053649708,
0.0502316728,
0.0394123532,
-0.085233219,
0.0080331378,
-0.0509592742,
0.0321266688,
-0.0409071036,
0.0274035018,
0.004990574,
0.0504728556,
0.0321951583,
-0.0159109086,
-0.0236426108,
-0.0598500706,
0.0375600681,
-0.0529577248,
0.00607483,
0.054177288,
0.0429621413,
0.0077078245,
0.0033280207,
0.0109910164,
-0.0502694733,
0.0052390625,
0.0343594663,
0.0258697197,
0.0015216061,
0.0501667708,
-0.0273017995,
-0.0146522019,
0.0174760595,
-0.0538863838,
0.0639363751,
0.0211884007,
-0.0071238219,
-0.0167041607,
0.0067710611,
-0.0591433644,
0.0556164458,
-0.035437651,
0.0022615183,
0.0169617385,
0.0081065223,
-0.0030538472,
-0.0265951864,
-0.0680950508,
-0.0186608806,
-0.0256050192,
0.0000093061,
-0.0279244892,
-0.0112579949,
0.0328292027,
0.0332062095,
-0.0240061022,
0.0545733385,
2.143517393e-34,
0.013490228,
0.0330422558,
-0.0152555509,
-0.0307219662,
0.0476995483,
0.0043206015,
-0.0118404701,
0.0149991987,
0.0061088395,
-0.0363478847,
0.0160478
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06401v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06401v4 | DevEval: Evaluating Code Generation in Practical Software Projects | 2024-01-12T06:51:30 | 2024-03-06T02:16:51 | Jia Li, Ge Li, Yunfei Zhao, Yongmin Li, Zhi Jin, Hao Zhu, Huanyu Liu, Kaibo Liu, Lecheng Wang, Zheng Fang, Lanshen Wang, Jiazheng Ding, Xuanming Zhang, Yihong Dong, Yuqi Zhu, Bin Gu, Mengfei Yang | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL | How to evaluate Large Language Models (LLMs) in code generation is an open
question. Many benchmarks have been proposed but are inconsistent with
practical software projects, e.g., unreal program distributions, insufficient
dependencies, and small-scale project contexts. Thus, the capabilities of LLMs
in practical projects are still unclear. In this paper, we propose a new
benchmark named DevEval, aligned with Developers' experiences in practical
projects. DevEval is collected through a rigorous pipeline, containing 2,690
samples from 119 practical projects and covering 10 domains. Compared to
previous benchmarks, DevEval aligns to practical projects in multiple
dimensions, e.g., real program distributions, sufficient dependencies, and
enough-scale project contexts. We assess five popular LLMs on DevEval (e.g.,
gpt-4, gpt-3.5-turbo, CodeLLaMa, and StarCoder) and reveal their actual
abilities in code generation. For instance, the highest Pass@1 of gpt-3.5-turbo
only is 42 in our experiments. We also discuss the challenges and future
directions of code generation in practical projects. We open-source DevEval and
hope it can facilitate the development of code generation in practical
projects. | [
-0.0333858207,
0.0805311799,
-0.0270737074,
0.0272988323,
-0.0365814008,
-0.0324517787,
-0.0330384634,
0.0110913999,
-0.0377057344,
0.0192272402,
0.0175020695,
-0.0089233825,
0.0132262986,
0.0522365123,
0.0348466933,
-0.0344029814,
0.0124806045,
-0.0349923633,
-0.0761875585,
0.0215114821,
-0.0193907525,
0.0145016033,
0.0255168844,
0.0754362941,
0.0066199489,
-0.0235604756,
0.0068812594,
0.0561016947,
-0.0043311305,
-0.0271786097,
0.0250369478,
0.0422128178,
-0.0084222611,
-0.0017744292,
0.0000025026,
-0.024701396,
0.0112892222,
-0.003561643,
0.0336065628,
0.07239189,
-0.0048599616,
-0.0054790857,
-0.006264694,
0.0264838487,
-0.018178409,
-0.0266212896,
0.0083258506,
-0.0508514531,
0.038498085,
0.0330375023,
0.0156484563,
-0.009194579,
-0.0037555734,
-0.0090864645,
0.0173995029,
-0.0084763477,
-0.0303078461,
0.0541505851,
0.0214062911,
0.0115336077,
0.0143719502,
-0.0009739704,
0.0599299669,
0.0327198766,
0.0033510746,
0.062075004,
-0.0401713662,
-0.0217612982,
0.0165797677,
0.0355407298,
-0.0527180657,
-0.023731919,
0.0188429691,
-0.0340023451,
-0.0529368743,
-0.0623767078,
-0.0147345532,
0.0164641906,
-0.0042931787,
0.0194426253,
0.005240377,
0.0081266286,
0.014186006,
-0.0367266238,
0.0108774044,
0.0324271843,
0.0386471972,
0.0296075661,
-0.0315473787,
0.0014781029,
-0.0241160784,
-0.0350468382,
-0.0264933482,
0.008156321,
-0.0177413449,
-0.0042303666,
-0.0464817397,
0.0130573483,
0.0676149949,
-0.02758196,
0.0349906944,
0.0417055525,
-0.0079577751,
-0.0087535316,
-0.0493284278,
0.0874204934,
-0.0215641521,
-0.0875203758,
-0.0042152363,
0.0292598847,
-0.0350607522,
0.0070763156,
-0.0493058674,
0.0237737726,
-0.0321710706,
0.0268374085,
-0.0659935176,
0.0438733622,
0.0185885169,
0.065883778,
0.0243993662,
-0.0277913697,
-0.032405775,
-0.000465593,
0.046011202,
-0.0039402358,
-0.0361634567,
-0.0322589725,
0.0149949109,
-0.0915045738,
0.0354425125,
0.0183559973,
-0.0547499098,
-0.0398575738,
0.0191980843,
0.0695468858,
0.0126622207,
0.0347085595,
-0.0146254255,
-0.0413212851,
0.0289458912,
-0.0512472689,
-0.0399378799,
-0.1109091714,
-0.0740671605,
0.058269456,
-0.0034779455,
-0.0533251353,
0.0110441921,
-0.0080657769,
0.0343971178,
-0.0126467226,
-0.0297752023,
0.0414923541,
0.0112683848,
0.0589492097,
-0.0149042374,
0.0507661179,
0.0422377698,
0.0166086778,
-0.0070736129,
-0.0428153239,
0.0513729118,
0.0624534413,
-0.0196773838,
0.0043810187,
0.002171953,
0.0344588868,
0.0338110588,
-0.0113726063,
-0.0154391807,
0.0821810737,
-0.0161330644,
0.0419559106,
0.0421793722,
0.0003895574,
0.0388594717,
0.0388963781,
0.0587351322,
0.0357790813,
0.0105590764,
-0.0413830914,
-0.0124462247,
0.0632869378,
0.0138307577,
0.0293059405,
-0.0093547665,
0.0886912793,
0.0018844843,
-0.0282029994,
-0.0200464875,
-0.028030429,
-0.06181648,
-0.0149631761,
0.0237960052,
-0.0302016083,
-0.0627539754,
0.0307080857,
-0.0127002243,
-0.0947350487,
-0.0145278554,
-0.0289487485,
0.0123749338,
0.0301404893,
0.0615780056,
-0.0332042724,
-0.0259609707,
0.0050086793,
-0.0181310698,
-0.0078469953,
0.0400135852,
0.007734349,
0.0216893777,
-0.0423858054,
-0.0172783155,
-0.0447328053,
-0.0217345096,
0.0414721146,
0.0303592589,
0.0031141869,
0.0418143533,
-0.0180358849,
-0.0434226766,
0.0197857507,
-0.0455759242,
0.0036671269,
0.0382775478,
-0.0350235626,
0.0034999193,
-0.0268148649,
-0.0501495302,
0.0071808388,
0.0458858386,
-0.0232142098,
-0.0073303618,
-0.0228321385,
-0.0166122634,
0.023872992,
-0.0082569253,
-0.0585274957,
-0.0028532245,
0.011937418,
-0.0195229165,
-0.0154506098,
0.0535654537,
0.0077605643,
0.0150920078,
0.0094238669,
0.0331125818,
-0.0461975709,
0.0135710072,
-0.0175051838,
0.0390318707,
0.0026388669,
0.036364086,
0.0049926001,
0.0811939538,
0.0570686571,
0.0210131295,
-0.0097886976,
0.0336649343,
-0.0145810507,
0.0383151434,
0.0201919284,
0.0565256178,
-0.0331339501,
-0.0664645433,
-0.0877528414,
0.0492123216,
-0.0178180374,
0.0385702997,
0.0222623385,
0.0360877179,
-0.0023247215,
0.0444038771,
-0.034590926,
-0.0013108671,
0.0182897896,
-0.0022375169,
0.0182837732,
-0.049378328,
-0.0702308342,
-0.0254811216,
0.007962021,
-0.0041112783,
0.0345457979,
-0.0266056675,
0.0229925942,
-0.0434838831,
0.0718795583,
0.0260207187,
-0.008441343,
-0.0145423245,
-0.0305562485,
0.019226633,
-0.0299595147,
0.11758928,
-0.0276739523,
-0.0098121716,
-0.0266030096,
0.0461802892,
-0.0235042293,
-0.0342344977,
0.0081675146,
0.026878424,
-0.0245266426,
-0.0098843044,
-0.0654778704,
0.0520646051,
0.0533833578,
0.0176277123,
-0.020776175,
-0.0463656932,
0.0409207046,
-0.0358864442,
0.0150522636,
0.0340871774,
0.0067151589,
0.0058503617,
0.0339890905,
-0.0186380893,
-0.0808721259,
0.0122724809,
-0.0529788285,
-0.0209438186,
-0.0066774213,
-0.0118817873,
-0.0694445148,
0.05823984,
0.0051417639,
0.0084987003,
-0.0349717475,
0.0010235402,
0.0039277454,
0.0270930268,
-0.0248588938,
-0.0322512574,
0.0765733123,
-0.0415953249,
0.0124859903,
-0.0416405722,
-0.017528981,
-0.0380308516,
0.0004905908,
-0.0149123883,
0.0059153358,
0.0402796306,
-0.0238206387,
0.0424686968,
0.018814005,
0.0203278251,
0.0373249352,
0.023679046,
-0.0349199809,
0.0050594644,
-0.0382667296,
-0.0091998111,
-0.0762849972,
-0.0158404186,
-0.0014240673,
0.0028130356,
0.0152816623,
0.0677975863,
0.0604910403,
-0.0828550756,
-0.0134737995,
0.0431926772,
0.0188404024,
-0.0442601219,
0.0694555864,
0.070176363,
-0.0324670188,
-0.026058618,
0.0656072795,
-0.0020384409,
-0.029138444,
0.0245368667,
0.0132462671,
0.0810501501,
0.0800972134,
0.0223850347,
-0.0568519942,
-0.0149838543,
-0.0039015599,
0.0331828371,
-0.0363862924,
0.0093392525,
-0.0290418379,
-0.0855359808,
0.0348350368,
0.0131830983,
-0.0353657454,
-0.0189746711,
-0.0335719548,
-0.0066379821,
0.0291912965,
-0.0071410178,
0.0490561388,
0.0029902498,
0.0198960379,
0.0032426554,
-0.0439251699,
-0.0506720617,
0.0280334931,
-0.0240799543,
0.0379638821,
0.0723994076,
0.0286059901,
0.005649114,
-0.0039149029,
0.0137235951,
-0.0356083438,
0.0077828988,
-0.0168903749,
0.0143581675,
0.0572926588,
-0.0231808964,
0.0335815251,
0.0041834377,
-0.0831454247,
-0.0099017741,
0.0516246669,
0.0318934582,
-0.0090941582,
-0.0364634395,
-0.0219340194,
-0.0130371032,
-0.0019501863,
0.034192808,
0.0363328494,
-0.0138524743,
-0.0370877646,
-0.0624381118,
-0.0008669431,
-0.0400752723,
-0.0210750084,
-0.0348333791,
0.0146626094,
0.0112153422,
-0.0058618961,
0.0406538285,
-0.0032224266,
0.0304953624,
0.0110051855,
0.0012930876,
0.0083796373,
-0.0266247168,
-0.0655830353,
-0.0180017613,
-0.0021681683,
0.027166931,
-0.0501269475,
-0.0100224912,
0.0215874426,
-0.02420648,
-0.0021972605,
0.03875475,
-0.1178513318,
-0.0512559935,
-0.0433352068,
0.0695272312,
0.0213361569,
-0.0425969288,
-0.0158757735,
-0.0489815548,
-0.051745221,
0.0029256404,
-0.0070795529,
0.0447115228,
-0.0062871561,
-0.0234390479,
0.0181338843,
-0.0311643854,
-0.0520991683,
0.0088756355,
0.0300329085,
0.0006191764,
0.0149806691,
0.0131699657,
0.0281358287,
0.0279186331,
-0.01907642,
-0.0102271475,
-0.0445023142,
0.0133372815,
-0.0313241445,
-0.0393562876,
-0.02571477,
-0.0518371053,
0.0158230104,
0.0118745323,
0.0022361507,
0.0223780181,
0.011554868,
-0.0315799899,
0.0365957469,
0.0039629005,
0.050264392,
0.0135360667,
0.0284346323,
0.1004373804,
-0.0221715346,
-0.0297116227,
-0.0184487011,
-0.03165932,
0.0239716116,
-0.0081383744,
0.0406553484,
0.0070689283,
0.0356400236,
0.0596795902,
0.0105051091,
-0.0076239714,
-0.0409235358,
-0.0121372528,
0.0175412893,
0.0520596467,
0.0757445469,
0.0473193601,
-0.0552049503,
0.0303796493,
-0.0559208579,
0.0340575837,
-0.0236537941,
-0.0338350162,
-0.040245492,
0.0008459146,
-0.030584434,
-0.0306734927,
0.1258111894,
0.0251614098,
-0.0182922147,
-0.0192916207,
0.0127346199,
-0.0216274057,
0.0301542692,
0.0250794794,
-0.0358124413,
-0.021273965,
-0.0060191723,
-0.0630014688,
-0.0304991994,
-0.0159901567,
0.0284693856,
0.0447091274,
-0.0274577048,
0.0257997029,
0.0742111504,
-0.0063179154,
-0.0195596889,
-0.0076420577,
-0.0059460704,
-0.0198538974,
-0.013795116,
-0.0022432492,
-6.950847972e-33,
-0.004740363,
-0.0185985155,
0.0255218204,
0.0071994304,
0.0075564492,
0.0220401697,
-0.0555683225,
0.0001871525,
0.0177038293,
-0.0598383509,
0.0358226188,
-0.0086209131,
-0.0240627956,
-0.0198363811,
0.0553319901,
0.0405453183,
0.056059137,
0.0264103245,
-0.0698772445,
0.0430202633,
-0.0400404632,
0.0123985596,
-0.0033994336,
-0.0283092558,
-0.0441659242,
-0.0395025611,
0.0206843242,
-0.0498466976,
0.0193227474,
0.0070421947,
0.0017589008,
0.0070454692,
-0.0000953229,
-0.037905667,
-0.0279148538,
-0.0497578047,
0.0153431389,
-0.0114282714,
0.0010935226,
-0.0025936451,
0.0030265204,
-0.0608302727,
0.0511421002,
0.0182008296,
-0.0734441206,
-0.0008272082,
-0.0232356712,
0.0147613967,
-0.0064253476,
-0.0457883738,
-0.0641118959,
0.0448159836,
-0.0020650576,
0.0051072617,
-0.029847892,
0.0147543689,
-0.0313327909,
0.04658648,
0.0574161969,
-0.0101342313,
0.0143011771,
0.0651232228,
0.0774221793,
-0.0157625712,
-0.0065596313,
0.023208037,
0.0557310432,
0.0312794112,
-0.033117231,
0.0267010666,
0.0221075322,
0.0730970427,
0.0262655001,
0.02942775,
0.0076519819,
-0.0269110985,
-0.0450807028,
0.0033673032,
0.0083181933,
-0.0154392896,
0.0345306955,
0.0293655694,
-0.035579972,
0.0070772972,
-0.0582054034,
-0.0096426914,
-0.021528786,
-0.0252547488,
0.0441849083,
0.0040479423,
-0.0095947217,
0.0149648506,
0.0072340458,
-0.0291969664,
0.0016680484,
0.05574755,
-0.0666153282,
0.0263648797,
-0.0215341821,
0.0407393277,
0.0077785677,
-0.0361760855,
0.0147897732,
0.0046486449,
0.0773157924,
0.0148928314,
-0.0403734073,
-0.0022756213,
-0.0528288931,
0.0041405424,
-0.0657590032,
0.0127476733,
-0.0122215301,
0.0042860368,
-0.0076919971,
-0.0358051285,
0.0126023758,
0.0050395993,
-0.0018507307,
-0.0154800685,
-0.0536201075,
-0.0206375476,
0.021772841,
0.0389592424,
-0.013318466,
-0.0205237065,
-0.0587335564,
0.0019439505,
0.0597030036,
0.0028058067,
-0.0862437263,
0.0100771459,
3.266e-7,
-0.0252037495,
0.0493452214,
-0.0204730779,
0.054042805,
0.0059366832,
0.0326010734,
-0.0420225002,
-0.0131286653,
0.0070724483,
0.0028436254,
-0.0542303585,
-0.0022274421,
0.0544321947,
0.0517220162,
-0.012387583,
0.0415967405,
-0.0055364915,
-0.0026360764,
-0.0775175393,
-0.0013051823,
0.0070587839,
0.0247577131,
0.0088210013,
-0.0244970638,
0.0416165702,
-0.0215001479,
0.0062330426,
-0.0224966072,
-0.0099129481,
0.0443682112,
-0.0494219214,
0.0014862425,
0.003867849,
-0.0001026944,
0.0075938683,
-0.0495024472,
0.034061484,
0.0831371471,
0.0245217308,
0.0399223641,
0.0653898269,
-0.0032889687,
-0.0359951556,
-0.0714435652,
0.029817421,
0.0111349095,
0.0039519579,
0.0079222051,
-0.0247564856,
-0.0126351677,
-0.003207441,
-0.0289376304,
0.0310484935,
-0.0094597321,
-0.0140008554,
-0.0299263727,
-0.023770079,
0.0209768023,
-0.0443304367,
0.0101621728,
-0.0290649422,
-0.0833310112,
-0.0784192756,
0.0571250282,
-0.008853415,
0.0155699691,
0.0139719378,
3.372368855e-34,
-0.0079797469,
-0.0594118387,
0.0195892639,
-0.0211521909,
0.0334796794,
-0.0050657657,
-0.047523763,
0.0162048135,
-0.0304714236,
0.0042850482,
-0.034660928
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06400v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06400v2 | Generalizing Visual Question Answering from Synthetic to Human-Written Questions via a Chain of QA with a Large Language Model | 2024-01-12T06:49:49 | 2024-01-16T06:01:48 | Taehee Kim, Yeongjae Cho, Heejun Shin, Yohan Jo, Dongmyung Shin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Visual question answering (VQA) is a task where an image is given, and a
series of questions are asked about the image. To build an efficient VQA
algorithm, a large amount of QA data is required which is very expensive.
Generating synthetic QA pairs based on templates is a practical way to obtain
data. However, VQA models trained on those data do not perform well on complex,
human-written questions. To address this issue, we propose a new method called
{\it chain of QA for human-written questions} (CoQAH). CoQAH utilizes a
sequence of QA interactions between a large language model and a VQA model
trained on synthetic data to reason and derive logical answers for
human-written questions. We tested the effectiveness of CoQAH on two types of
human-written VQA datasets for 3D-rendered and chest X-ray images and found
that it achieved state-of-the-art accuracy in both types of data. Notably,
CoQAH outperformed general vision-language models, VQA models, and medical
foundation models with no finetuning. | [
0.0493764468,
0.0856727362,
-0.0082762726,
0.0331760012,
-0.0010994716,
0.0260952096,
-0.0040726168,
0.0176461991,
0.0033185952,
-0.0333023146,
-0.0023263502,
-0.0418418646,
-0.0075153634,
0.0702563599,
0.0492251515,
-0.0883875266,
0.0194312017,
-0.0219518058,
-0.0005283022,
-0.021150643,
0.0134228859,
-0.00455262,
0.0049965363,
0.0182491411,
-0.0157531854,
-0.0395046137,
-0.0181626398,
0.0094054155,
0.025974514,
-0.0046681059,
-0.0287220459,
0.0405850895,
0.0479846559,
-0.0452540442,
0.0000019327,
-0.0129409228,
0.0142431147,
0.0326829851,
-0.0148488823,
-0.0078375973,
-0.0303701647,
-0.0336454473,
0.0098068248,
0.0171565171,
-0.0669817477,
-0.0309328418,
0.0442425944,
0.0406955555,
0.0856479183,
0.0342217088,
-0.0236119237,
-0.0266192351,
-0.0007570316,
-0.005851645,
0.0295674112,
-0.0493917875,
0.0018647647,
0.0630866736,
0.03000433,
0.0046254448,
-0.0273373704,
0.0415681601,
0.0453495122,
0.0035253265,
0.0116519034,
0.0489197113,
-0.0226508584,
-0.0149386628,
-0.0119840959,
0.1186825633,
-0.0131525798,
0.0069086449,
-0.0127105033,
0.0028728493,
0.0137733202,
0.0360298194,
-0.049870152,
0.0379809961,
-0.029019475,
-0.0210835785,
-0.0408748314,
-0.0190160982,
-0.0299236737,
-0.0258858558,
-0.0184961632,
-0.0245907605,
0.0244884007,
0.0214763582,
-0.0040682475,
0.0162649024,
-0.0346897058,
-0.0681980029,
-0.0356829539,
0.0755265281,
-0.024822779,
-0.0014838708,
-0.0333299264,
-0.0101953866,
0.0061430093,
-0.0338902511,
0.0327157341,
0.0217021555,
-0.0510074645,
0.0504257679,
-0.0172020979,
0.0714241043,
-0.0419825725,
0.0322943404,
-0.0662759095,
-0.0095261242,
-0.0216056779,
-0.0260997973,
-0.0450983718,
0.0171176083,
-0.0782615244,
-0.0414169729,
-0.0069791907,
0.013255693,
0.0007455885,
-0.0003690163,
0.0163586196,
0.0881705657,
-0.0231861044,
-0.0004031136,
-0.0472662263,
0.0124113737,
-0.0537651703,
0.0121736899,
-0.0331533812,
-0.0253488142,
0.0060682902,
0.0374343172,
0.0374854021,
-0.0002799976,
-0.0013594722,
0.0593897253,
-0.0559513383,
0.0074950429,
0.0095273219,
-0.0285553001,
0.0188125204,
-0.047579091,
0.0369323716,
-0.0677805766,
0.0170719475,
0.006347659,
-0.0202952474,
-0.0120806918,
-0.0028416123,
0.0332448557,
-0.0388176888,
0.0809552819,
-0.0329343714,
0.0081243413,
0.0451624058,
0.0161616132,
0.0405320302,
0.0343680233,
0.0205511544,
0.0258442964,
0.025587311,
-0.0149814207,
0.0423423275,
0.0257610958,
-0.0024415029,
-0.005192189,
-0.0602965839,
0.0564171821,
0.0146892322,
0.0436431579,
0.0314390287,
0.0716981813,
-0.0268573593,
-0.0445188805,
0.0094786063,
0.037493851,
0.003655409,
0.0028622393,
0.0554718859,
-0.0020120442,
0.0448024683,
0.0282444321,
-0.0266796947,
0.0754638836,
0.0384663679,
0.0064292531,
-0.0403477885,
-0.0024666945,
-0.0662929043,
-0.0432659313,
0.0041453051,
0.0159907676,
0.0023764435,
0.0320453905,
0.0089014489,
0.0356623083,
-0.028989682,
0.0060733748,
-0.0054385653,
-0.0071870466,
-0.0254951846,
-0.0277752932,
0.0687267259,
0.0660265982,
0.0282241404,
-0.0042411182,
-0.0252251271,
0.0233115796,
0.0104307551,
0.0259360317,
-0.0075444365,
-0.0288662296,
0.0163599681,
-0.0357538797,
-0.0281039998,
-0.0285874195,
-0.0044597704,
0.0100753512,
0.0389782973,
-0.0113546336,
-0.0226352625,
-0.042684149,
0.0170232728,
0.042688638,
-0.0061785467,
-0.0032778962,
-0.0102934409,
0.0196656492,
-0.0040068612,
-0.0079210065,
-0.006185154,
0.0006475907,
0.0189247467,
-0.0425919965,
-0.0171458255,
-0.0054451898,
-0.035087008,
-0.0461145192,
0.0146121681,
-0.0556232706,
-0.0291634332,
0.0272409637,
-0.0605874993,
-0.0317381769,
0.0027439911,
-0.045944605,
-0.0340001881,
-0.0398065187,
-0.0666317046,
0.0626375154,
0.0112559181,
-0.0251830239,
0.050016012,
-0.0193882566,
-0.017284913,
0.0098037058,
0.0149964029,
0.0124484645,
-0.0279300995,
0.0301592834,
0.013796241,
0.0030894761,
0.0172680449,
-0.0201893225,
0.0386611149,
-0.05359466,
0.0206957068,
-0.0548905358,
-0.0141650327,
-0.0173990428,
-0.0166992471,
0.0349101387,
-0.0124779297,
-0.003921771,
-0.0419761911,
-0.0798738152,
0.0211128406,
0.0070931436,
0.0019105054,
0.0727564096,
0.0247144829,
0.0137460986,
-0.0398506261,
-0.0022540712,
0.0115715517,
0.0747669563,
0.0344020054,
-0.0033558826,
-0.0257293787,
-0.0165014993,
-0.0563656054,
0.0645088181,
-0.0022340924,
-0.046920076,
0.0307269543,
-0.0211982261,
0.0391037166,
0.1072302014,
-0.009867182,
-0.0152207855,
0.0084613319,
0.0268511847,
-0.0192014854,
0.0138616348,
0.0022710883,
-0.0477380566,
0.0240563247,
-0.0653320476,
-0.0330620557,
0.0305996817,
-0.0138645954,
-0.0018937468,
-0.064449884,
0.0515138358,
0.0400969945,
-0.0059498707,
-0.0635030568,
0.0016432516,
0.0055424767,
0.0705689415,
-0.0297076683,
-0.0480153151,
0.053662844,
0.0072750677,
0.0053549604,
0.0111175515,
0.013549529,
-0.0515046977,
0.0707277879,
0.0077360692,
0.0254233181,
-0.017902365,
0.0031394658,
-0.0640941337,
-0.0505502038,
0.0095705455,
-0.025142286,
0.0168289654,
-0.0642278418,
0.0264430884,
-0.0370949246,
-0.035704203,
-0.0448721126,
-0.0068198983,
-0.0280973967,
0.000261419,
-0.0766670629,
-0.0208236892,
0.0220428295,
0.019074697,
0.0068942565,
0.0148430532,
-0.0091423029,
0.0049955528,
-0.0194053445,
0.0909901634,
0.083243899,
0.0500211008,
-0.021444777,
-0.0191701036,
0.0437937677,
0.0737433136,
0.0010228733,
0.0457463115,
-0.0372980312,
0.0218758807,
-0.0227846503,
0.0603431351,
-0.0017966235,
0.0411455892,
0.0281216335,
-0.0453708433,
-0.0155499959,
0.0442108773,
0.0269151013,
0.0012820001,
-0.0144534046,
-0.0028965108,
0.0206010919,
0.0404964089,
0.0504915118,
-0.0959067419,
-0.0370211005,
-0.0288080517,
0.0083717313,
0.0191450994,
0.0011374471,
-0.0002649408,
-0.0717484877,
0.0771572143,
-0.0347767025,
-0.0194950793,
-0.0389023684,
-0.0000572259,
0.005732283,
0.0013793571,
-0.0455249287,
-0.0170159191,
-0.0006617881,
0.0201986656,
-0.0149121443,
0.0138603048,
0.000435755,
0.043478556,
-0.0415496118,
-0.0431591831,
0.0408698544,
0.0313453451,
-0.0319801383,
-0.0661040395,
0.0036613164,
-0.0061819656,
0.0117097106,
0.0240157805,
0.0610549822,
0.0053172172,
-0.0450406671,
-0.0098982155,
0.0695655793,
-0.0055503091,
-0.012848285,
-0.0091114454,
0.0470123589,
-0.0180896446,
-0.0160564091,
-0.0536141321,
0.0209649187,
-0.0122039961,
0.0264313295,
0.0389514379,
-0.034269277,
-0.0648677275,
-0.0119121214,
0.0095163174,
-0.0436559133,
-0.0518390574,
0.0249971338,
0.0442505963,
0.0014553313,
-0.1185371503,
-0.0125789894,
0.0574560687,
0.0601994582,
-0.0476165526,
-0.0243025422,
0.0023402374,
0.0018033595,
-0.0518649481,
0.0801266059,
-0.0230046716,
0.0174375158,
-0.012855025,
0.0035758689,
0.0075631691,
-0.0516659208,
-0.0291290432,
-0.0054149767,
-0.039113149,
0.0066610971,
-0.0263234414,
0.084898904,
0.0091582881,
0.018040007,
0.0153986821,
-0.0275734924,
0.0067881788,
0.0434515961,
-0.0069476808,
0.0014689323,
0.005190732,
-0.0387900732,
-0.0214031339,
0.0042463653,
-0.0175730493,
0.0077602039,
0.0121925455,
0.023148559,
-0.0278354362,
-0.0359588787,
0.0338734537,
0.0370320566,
0.0014076687,
0.0065447791,
0.0141696166,
-0.0064710714,
0.0177551527,
-0.0144874994,
-0.0108158467,
-0.079536289,
0.0190159157,
0.015029897,
-0.0115927113,
0.0071484693,
-0.0390416794,
-0.053763289,
0.0114261638,
-0.0237912182,
-0.0031940271,
0.0119055081,
0.0087115159,
0.0268908627,
-0.0206794199,
0.0019695328,
-0.0002814263,
-0.0145349288,
0.0616624691,
0.0195000544,
0.065279834,
0.0451895334,
-0.007341288,
-0.0303222165,
0.0325120464,
-0.0376005806,
-0.0956278369,
-0.0169536434,
0.0346227363,
0.0308964215,
0.0330121033,
-0.0456024036,
0.0134804538,
-0.0253493898,
0.0295373201,
0.0181953441,
0.0019032701,
-0.0283922236,
0.102592811,
0.02859593,
0.0124431401,
-0.0146836052,
0.0711029842,
0.0266268384,
0.0274610836,
-0.0353578441,
-0.010631592,
-0.0426032729,
-0.0203266554,
0.0147702936,
-0.0451906249,
0.0009247271,
0.0516725928,
-0.039332103,
-0.0774253309,
-0.0155424112,
0.0401230641,
-0.0398313217,
0.0214323755,
0.0535852835,
0.0431833528,
0.0391666926,
-0.035033755,
-0.0091522858,
0.0243567768,
-0.0280594695,
-0.0214755628,
0.0110478578,
-6.273371639e-33,
-0.0106987497,
-0.0541825332,
0.056718573,
-0.0499949455,
0.0007123183,
0.0199516769,
-0.0222471934,
-0.0198958591,
-0.0263207704,
0.0139381252,
-0.00980232,
-0.0016583045,
-0.0063251429,
0.0407035723,
-0.0363721065,
-0.009304977,
-0.0143693462,
-0.0177787337,
-0.0255313627,
0.0100401593,
-0.0234796256,
-0.0053461464,
0.020808218,
-0.02869853,
-0.0525666587,
-0.0025235035,
-0.0163689628,
0.0412525535,
-0.024661215,
0.0522221066,
-0.055405736,
-0.0173958167,
0.0255319551,
-0.0240708087,
0.0225956868,
0.047188092,
-0.0844536126,
-0.015439529,
0.0358069986,
-0.0058713225,
-0.1250980496,
0.0095583927,
0.010060613,
-0.0215282496,
0.0535724051,
-0.0668289289,
0.0357582569,
-0.0244714841,
0.0091234008,
-0.0125027774,
-0.019905081,
0.0071658161,
-0.0197127815,
-0.0275714211,
-0.0294412412,
0.0467049107,
-0.0107003842,
0.0233797487,
0.0119468039,
-0.0110124778,
0.0178139433,
-0.0048264614,
0.0368049443,
0.0175756998,
0.0027729028,
0.0165209528,
0.0353234783,
-0.0368728712,
-0.0601721033,
0.0087327333,
-0.0266317427,
0.0519081913,
0.0895130634,
0.0825688988,
0.0147475498,
0.0408197567,
-0.0701777562,
0.0448133983,
-0.1235603616,
0.0810124353,
-0.0259752162,
-0.0253054425,
0.0166443326,
0.0018789376,
-0.0542894639,
0.0198029205,
-0.0252500027,
0.0167042185,
0.047174044,
0.0161707848,
-0.0232177805,
0.0176620074,
0.0319978595,
-0.038742777,
0.0416429937,
0.006150607,
-0.0364138857,
0.0544977263,
0.0055112792,
0.0568860732,
-0.0233707111,
0.024916077,
0.0748686343,
-0.0085990271,
0.0121577987,
0.0161115229,
0.0364608988,
0.0023708842,
-0.0420924239,
0.0129273459,
-0.0284900498,
0.0228396654,
-0.0362777859,
0.015386275,
0.012306788,
0.0240151472,
-0.052594468,
0.012242116,
-0.0389531888,
-0.0068997378,
-0.0379746631,
-0.048845768,
-0.0231394302,
0.0385764576,
-0.0508925579,
0.0167548414,
-0.0516661219,
-0.0181396231,
0.0146096824,
-0.0759511068,
-0.0216221027,
0.0714622736,
2.577e-7,
0.0325886607,
0.0008130554,
0.0249659643,
0.0578590408,
0.0025352333,
0.0284855757,
-0.0003028843,
0.0223460719,
0.0158997532,
-0.0462376848,
0.0199514497,
0.0763685182,
-0.000377126,
0.0156075628,
-0.0154886991,
0.063553296,
-0.0554262735,
-0.0412814245,
-0.0463493802,
-0.0168591347,
0.0651463345,
0.0601168312,
-0.0551817231,
-0.0303171724,
0.0421626456,
-0.0269853398,
0.0703132376,
0.0119225634,
-0.0026726234,
-0.0067320843,
0.0064453236,
0.0080936393,
0.0021714419,
0.0322697461,
0.0163378082,
-0.0299752671,
0.0393483378,
0.0372804664,
-0.0159342494,
-0.0104322778,
-0.0215765666,
-0.0090863965,
0.0230398811,
-0.0573493205,
0.0894134343,
-0.0391140096,
-0.0203027483,
-0.0210346598,
-0.0432486832,
0.006072178,
0.02576782,
-0.0201376807,
0.0105623771,
0.0194195509,
0.0478461161,
-0.0258648638,
0.0102050146,
-0.0584188327,
-0.0069746249,
0.0104463948,
-0.0256321467,
0.0193191767,
-0.0165929273,
-0.0380437709,
0.0184876285,
-0.0139612127,
-0.0476665199,
1.785676938e-34,
0.0252483226,
0.0099462923,
0.0032257969,
0.0069516362,
0.0283457655,
-0.0267936215,
0.0027984527,
-0.0107520083,
0.0308407266,
-0.0666084886,
0.0010722057
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06398v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06398v1 | An approach for mistranslation removal from popular dataset for Indic MT Task | 2024-01-12T06:37:19 | 2024-01-12T06:37:19 | Sudhansu Bala Das, Leo Raphael Rodrigues, Tapas Kumar Mishra, Bidyut Kr. Patra | cs.CL | cs.CL | The conversion of content from one language to another utilizing a computer
system is known as Machine Translation (MT). Various techniques have come up to
ensure effective translations that retain the contextual and lexical
interpretation of the source language. End-to-end Neural Machine Translation
(NMT) is a popular technique and it is now widely used in real-world MT
systems. Massive amounts of parallel datasets (sentences in one language
alongside translations in another) are required for MT systems. These datasets
are crucial for an MT system to learn linguistic structures and patterns of
both languages during the training phase. One such dataset is Samanantar, the
largest publicly accessible parallel dataset for Indian languages (ILs). Since
the corpus has been gathered from various sources, it contains many incorrect
translations. Hence, the MT systems built using this dataset cannot perform to
their usual potential. In this paper, we propose an algorithm to remove
mistranslations from the training corpus and evaluate its performance and
efficiency. Two Indic languages (ILs), namely, Hindi (HIN) and Odia (ODI) are
chosen for the experiment. A baseline NMT system is built for these two ILs,
and the effect of different dataset sizes is also investigated. The quality of
the translations in the experiment is evaluated using standard metrics such as
BLEU, METEOR, and RIBES. From the results, it is observed that removing the
incorrect translation from the dataset makes the translation quality better. It
is also noticed that, despite the fact that the ILs-English and English-ILs
systems are trained using the same corpus, ILs-English works more effectively
across all the evaluation metrics. | [
0.0728014931,
0.0171672348,
-0.0205442999,
0.0662600324,
-0.059459392,
0.0413431861,
-0.0213698316,
0.0152041586,
-0.0263907686,
-0.0139073338,
-0.0307135861,
-0.0462530479,
0.0410500504,
-0.0343609825,
0.0004078863,
-0.0181337409,
0.0447322503,
0.0111627551,
-0.0428442992,
0.01657979,
0.0193706602,
0.0370454304,
-0.0164343696,
-0.0089806924,
-0.0298716407,
-0.018432349,
0.0397170559,
0.041717384,
0.033044856,
-0.0157190524,
0.0014232883,
-0.0164215267,
0.0000612419,
0.0838679373,
0.0000020755,
-0.033750888,
-0.0487828404,
-0.0081957439,
0.0070655402,
0.0049461853,
0.0762167647,
-0.0427809171,
-0.0062324344,
0.0394900441,
-0.0084161162,
0.0118517689,
0.0701323673,
0.0174089633,
0.0483958907,
0.110773854,
-0.027942393,
-0.0406093076,
0.0026997763,
-0.0112273842,
-0.0141369002,
0.0004107945,
-0.0003265447,
0.0040412331,
-0.0532369502,
-0.014763834,
0.0083633857,
0.0556854084,
-0.0306604039,
-0.0243302099,
-0.0100336131,
-0.0453218594,
-0.0159151424,
-0.0420015752,
0.0064539332,
0.0698520541,
-0.0571411923,
-0.0358857475,
0.0062205549,
-0.0027754449,
-0.0331069827,
0.0138178263,
-0.0147712864,
0.0051199677,
-0.0380698107,
0.041129224,
0.029765686,
-0.0032618835,
0.0263027474,
-0.0176755451,
0.013441571,
-0.0296737365,
0.0259459317,
-0.0475824364,
-0.0292566624,
-0.016794838,
0.0016327694,
0.0024818303,
0.0785699263,
-0.0207901206,
-0.0268537514,
0.0373982601,
-0.0283174962,
-0.0891573131,
0.003603756,
-0.0967786312,
0.0082621723,
0.0490315743,
0.0119553711,
0.0247678589,
-0.0248752888,
0.0635807663,
-0.0043450999,
0.0333876349,
-0.0677487701,
-0.0344096422,
-0.0203218069,
0.0148059763,
-0.0325816162,
-0.0042646844,
-0.0483794436,
0.0211930443,
-0.0485638604,
-0.0132773472,
0.0013315137,
0.0036326491,
0.037103992,
-0.0517037511,
-0.0846566856,
-0.0317053273,
0.0054391362,
0.046743542,
0.0115556214,
0.0113979271,
-0.0055558239,
-0.0599659197,
-0.0256353002,
0.0163310058,
-0.0181639735,
-0.0351757333,
-0.0190896951,
0.0601292513,
-0.0362749174,
-0.0354736187,
-0.0819649175,
0.0265684966,
0.0021718713,
-0.0367926694,
-0.0170885716,
-0.0538291298,
0.0734648034,
-0.0161081478,
0.0166713335,
-0.0024545137,
0.0026153778,
0.0305827931,
-0.0348650403,
0.1096655428,
-0.0532149598,
-0.0107586225,
0.0567041598,
0.0037835788,
0.0002958655,
0.0265017524,
0.050559327,
0.0275364649,
0.0398021676,
-0.001095126,
0.0171057824,
0.0373172425,
-0.0078525301,
0.0186873749,
-0.034286458,
0.0132874157,
-0.0285146199,
0.0462322757,
0.0151925953,
0.0838148221,
-0.0110466881,
0.051656276,
0.0293580294,
0.0021885769,
0.0237138625,
0.0595693104,
0.0301524289,
0.0014306133,
0.0222757589,
0.0122996513,
-0.0075714816,
-0.0219006296,
-0.01735943,
-0.0171274021,
0.0010842147,
0.0111031812,
-0.0031379503,
-0.005118697,
-0.0215747431,
-0.046164006,
0.0130173098,
-0.0313418135,
0.0465623103,
0.0492999069,
-0.0750532374,
0.0437001511,
0.0102878595,
-0.059724424,
0.0339797661,
-0.0236869417,
-0.0271302946,
0.0445816554,
0.0296743829,
-0.0169342067,
-0.0220534857,
-0.0104280058,
-0.0408362746,
0.0278563555,
0.0291838534,
-0.0118166357,
-0.0032596756,
-0.0885058641,
0.0398607962,
0.0589414984,
-0.014741228,
0.0049973708,
-0.0228146724,
0.0433131121,
0.0247729141,
-0.0155636212,
-0.0683203191,
0.055685129,
-0.0160704311,
-0.0076923673,
0.0289386325,
0.0176688768,
0.0426945128,
-0.0124035636,
0.0004576314,
-0.0371063612,
0.0176355895,
-0.0009467271,
-0.0350730084,
0.0331972055,
-0.048563391,
-0.0689260736,
0.0338964164,
-0.0585593395,
0.0229952447,
0.0304429699,
-0.0487621725,
-0.0668993443,
-0.025888646,
-0.0360007286,
-0.0006309891,
-0.0221788213,
0.0657064468,
-0.0202836469,
-0.0310094859,
-0.0370492265,
0.0291331261,
0.0174637195,
-0.0112034613,
0.028899949,
-0.003386765,
0.0709655657,
-0.0363513567,
-0.0035243712,
0.043345809,
0.0270156953,
0.020458512,
0.0297399629,
0.0001639237,
-0.0523636416,
-0.0512459464,
-0.0662751719,
0.0044860831,
-0.0008646591,
0.046825178,
0.0654653385,
0.0688655227,
0.0042724763,
-0.0194921736,
0.0455317162,
0.0299909879,
0.0202970877,
-0.0037999735,
0.0420891158,
-0.0075258194,
0.0076936721,
-0.0219708774,
-0.0105527267,
0.0023913034,
0.0317592025,
0.0149053829,
-0.058868777,
-0.0813421011,
0.0349767692,
-0.0082087796,
0.0071865586,
-0.003798438,
-0.0840620771,
-0.0129792914,
-0.0312782936,
0.0210298393,
0.0182633903,
-0.0081459479,
-0.0083593363,
-0.0053907288,
-0.020031983,
-0.0148792937,
-0.0168775264,
-0.0000931506,
0.0050425637,
-0.0260287505,
-0.0400219336,
-0.0168193541,
0.0199040025,
0.0285228342,
-0.0065884599,
-0.0256538149,
-0.0157176703,
-0.026371045,
0.0289364867,
0.00730584,
0.0363153256,
-0.0230198912,
0.0496067181,
-0.0275036395,
-0.0232339408,
0.0373651199,
-0.0256882105,
0.0150276897,
-0.1220178381,
0.019811172,
-0.0249092095,
-0.0254949834,
-0.0284360647,
0.0131036956,
-0.0565812252,
-0.0463286191,
-0.0417612754,
0.0045555872,
0.0192563124,
-0.0303076115,
-0.0099903177,
-0.1076321825,
0.0375611298,
-0.0295746792,
0.005138576,
-0.0161180031,
-0.0371300802,
0.0496698506,
-0.0302329026,
0.0285082478,
-0.0326793492,
-0.008113998,
0.0084164478,
-0.0062498376,
0.0491945334,
-0.0054405243,
0.0067537469,
0.0016655205,
0.0378180742,
0.0043333638,
-0.0256553274,
0.028144883,
-0.0050387867,
0.0275320243,
-0.0200338736,
0.0198154338,
-0.0143936202,
-0.0436306633,
-0.0317659974,
0.0215989929,
-0.0243639927,
-0.0187276416,
-0.0120424293,
0.0611621588,
-0.0007670401,
-0.0248816982,
0.0781285241,
0.0401049964,
-0.033065144,
-0.0387574174,
-0.0101343021,
-0.0305351727,
-0.0235029552,
0.0143916225,
-0.0924047679,
-0.0076523325,
0.0411569849,
0.0196543932,
0.006799784,
-0.0017153393,
-0.0373568162,
-0.0932932496,
-0.0203307346,
0.0409347899,
-0.0305341296,
-0.0644443333,
0.0066637076,
-0.0438708849,
-0.0238142051,
0.0666207671,
0.0221961699,
-0.0107774874,
-0.0213360079,
0.0110489223,
0.0414479002,
-0.0623752028,
-0.0465968177,
-0.0215216838,
0.0412747376,
0.0627898648,
0.0316822082,
-0.0251573958,
-0.0163874179,
0.0284433067,
-0.0149835031,
-0.0240797177,
-0.0105421552,
0.0243375544,
0.0188534036,
-0.0226709265,
0.0109411068,
-0.0031340146,
-0.013285568,
0.0303112715,
0.019570075,
0.0481748395,
-0.0088325106,
0.0163727049,
0.0232644007,
-0.0629746169,
0.0233234353,
0.0189879872,
-0.0043457616,
0.0014495448,
0.0002045651,
-0.0044249152,
-0.0275089014,
-0.0401003249,
0.0682525262,
0.0427523889,
-0.0863547996,
-0.0357072204,
-0.0741922557,
-0.0520596616,
0.0174362976,
0.027789481,
0.0479467064,
0.0336151049,
0.0367112979,
0.0170234274,
-0.0088950433,
-0.012389103,
-0.0330621563,
0.0258432664,
-0.0476709865,
0.0353024825,
0.0173548926,
-0.0081975954,
0.0137374708,
-0.0012479798,
-0.0721324608,
-0.051491566,
-0.0049673477,
0.0263746027,
0.021897357,
0.0408990346,
-0.0518842563,
-0.0373198502,
0.0276159327,
0.022823723,
-0.0236596894,
-0.029105179,
0.0056576785,
0.0118856616,
0.0021824255,
0.0276734084,
-0.0199261587,
-0.0017851536,
-0.0036997139,
0.0029790488,
-0.0113618402,
0.0101736663,
0.0586209372,
0.0427607596,
0.01705488,
-0.0497996546,
0.0113906665,
-0.0296466295,
0.0127957184,
-0.010883769,
-0.0034337356,
-0.0180076845,
0.0177698415,
0.0930880457,
0.0199492723,
-0.021009909,
-0.0101280147,
-0.0085286433,
-0.0322275572,
0.0056040776,
0.0163697135,
0.0025001082,
0.0863200948,
0.0426851511,
0.0256438795,
0.0009879987,
-0.0061739637,
0.0048368233,
0.0232152231,
-0.0127573321,
0.0607676059,
0.0231184643,
0.0157366879,
0.0157363117,
0.0620672069,
0.0443454608,
0.0046221442,
-0.0285806004,
0.0411171094,
0.0748750344,
-0.0055190749,
0.1042247862,
0.0035651599,
-0.0020465748,
0.0014798217,
0.0427480191,
-0.0164748188,
0.050588768,
0.0103085628,
-0.0167929027,
-0.0083341859,
0.0295318011,
0.035263963,
-0.0562065616,
0.0001092017,
-0.0002373552,
-0.0352418125,
-0.0190607514,
0.0272327289,
-0.0410045981,
-0.0118188029,
0.0161107481,
-0.033593569,
-0.0043557272,
-0.0508772694,
0.0010978318,
-0.0121920267,
0.0377311297,
-0.0003117223,
0.0198969133,
0.0645738542,
0.0132867396,
0.0106269605,
-0.0419636033,
0.0083125141,
0.008307144,
-0.0296800453,
-0.0590201132,
-5.509305087e-33,
-0.0299526881,
0.019145418,
0.0041334769,
-0.0268551949,
-0.0387895741,
-0.0413167551,
-0.0119175315,
-0.0608000569,
0.0107424334,
0.0337138511,
-0.0140501037,
0.0383650549,
0.0302771367,
-0.0105956448,
0.0213427506,
0.0185914915,
0.0708275437,
-0.0054655988,
-0.001996825,
0.0132543445,
0.0755177066,
0.0260643475,
0.1151226535,
-0.0656689033,
0.0294050667,
-0.0585015714,
-0.0222360268,
0.0632271916,
-0.030183848,
-0.0119334711,
0.0029932058,
0.0236907005,
0.0186345745,
-0.0165372267,
-0.0328201912,
0.0012893089,
-0.1017774418,
0.0085343188,
0.0329882242,
0.1148735806,
-0.0103950808,
-0.0384193957,
0.094453223,
-0.0343249589,
-0.0256425031,
0.0232231524,
-0.0013401643,
-0.027117664,
0.0133304298,
-0.0085404282,
-0.0662290603,
0.0354427472,
0.0015845163,
-0.0090629412,
0.0342345871,
0.0290155988,
-0.0235995483,
-0.0201578327,
-0.1062225327,
-0.0363424681,
-0.0184087157,
0.0399169736,
0.0209994819,
0.0124568352,
-0.0316237286,
-0.0380022489,
0.0530202277,
-0.0283783637,
0.0828131214,
0.0252393093,
0.0034273807,
-0.0133064883,
0.0356582515,
0.0354627632,
0.0965355709,
-0.0813979059,
-0.0405840501,
0.0227799118,
-0.0151176248,
0.0303108245,
-0.011348417,
0.0082637882,
-0.053523358,
-0.0285772774,
0.0077440375,
-0.036905963,
-0.0159332678,
-0.0426136665,
0.0411120877,
-0.0140711339,
-0.0022603169,
0.0270348676,
0.0382638834,
-0.0336371772,
0.0158084445,
-0.0419549793,
-0.049125541,
0.0213887952,
-0.0111872861,
0.0343030691,
-0.0325779393,
-0.0470374785,
-0.0107068093,
0.0655936152,
0.0147911431,
-0.0167728253,
0.0289755315,
0.0028386815,
-0.0385145135,
0.0241958071,
-0.0282506235,
0.0154694756,
-0.0006922559,
0.0247116182,
-0.0133877899,
-0.0068073822,
-0.0131765148,
-0.0077273189,
0.0425867811,
-0.015011264,
-0.0024600155,
0.0232536905,
0.0206524376,
0.0210293494,
-0.052757673,
0.0088805435,
-0.0512955263,
0.0082650753,
0.0268491767,
-0.0525669418,
-0.0088112438,
0.0225932356,
2.777e-7,
0.0039349515,
0.0678896308,
0.0369486064,
-0.0358350277,
-0.0021655087,
0.0045772758,
-0.0476913676,
-0.001992899,
0.0090198563,
0.0622022487,
0.0373413488,
-0.0394751802,
0.0665863603,
0.0235190783,
-0.0942044631,
-0.0105426302,
-0.0459017567,
0.0038415003,
-0.0429938398,
0.0203452036,
0.0140629392,
0.0650026873,
0.0414178558,
-0.0182252675,
-0.0309002344,
-0.0335258506,
0.0354966111,
0.0189249869,
-0.0265062153,
0.0274077784,
0.0589201525,
0.0138680199,
-0.0664396286,
0.0098722782,
-0.0178919546,
0.0021192676,
0.0415218733,
0.0381431617,
-0.0150516313,
0.0631100982,
0.0125527512,
-0.0127155362,
-0.0147355963,
-0.0244045015,
0.0417060554,
-0.0049894541,
-0.0054033082,
0.0055433293,
-0.0152298799,
0.0161506813,
0.0357395969,
-0.0130572626,
0.0058801896,
0.0000076667,
0.0360236019,
-0.0075900475,
-0.0441216379,
-0.0287955441,
0.0044090291,
0.008086944,
-0.0098707862,
-0.0563802011,
-0.0072365855,
0.0239442661,
0.0252343826,
-0.0373195335,
0.0264463592,
2.202951489e-34,
0.0375511944,
-0.0282194074,
0.0318864994,
-0.0271635763,
0.0439883806,
-0.0396135896,
-0.0083386656,
0.0225347113,
-0.0290669836,
-0.0440595597,
-0.0124125676
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06394v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06394v1 | Adaptive Data Augmentation for Aspect Sentiment Quad Prediction | 2024-01-12T06:20:56 | 2024-01-12T06:20:56 | Wenyuan Zhang, Xinghua Zhang, Shiyao Cui, Kun Huang, Xuebin Wang, Tingwen Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Aspect sentiment quad prediction (ASQP) aims to predict the quad sentiment
elements for a given sentence, which is a critical task in the field of
aspect-based sentiment analysis. However, the data imbalance issue has not
received sufficient attention in ASQP task. In this paper, we divide the issue
into two-folds, quad-pattern imbalance and aspect-category imbalance, and
propose an Adaptive Data Augmentation (ADA) framework to tackle the imbalance
issue. Specifically, a data augmentation process with a condition function
adaptively enhances the tail quad patterns and aspect categories, alleviating
the data imbalance in ASQP. Following previous studies, we also further explore
the generative framework for extracting complete quads by introducing the
category prior knowledge and syntax-guided decoding target. Experimental
results demonstrate that data augmentation for imbalance in ASQP task can
improve the performance, and the proposed ADA method is superior to naive data
oversampling. | [
0.0332274176,
0.0815495253,
-0.0167408977,
0.0035940856,
0.0137813399,
0.0043529999,
-0.0224601831,
0.0008499435,
-0.0356069952,
-0.0195855219,
-0.0421720296,
-0.0101268338,
-0.0330687203,
0.070827134,
-0.0222071074,
-0.0054610716,
0.0317037702,
0.0409211442,
0.0185241848,
-0.0162355956,
0.0267475471,
0.0325987898,
0.0163192581,
-0.0231077764,
-0.0491010994,
-0.0001434248,
0.0204301961,
0.0148006119,
0.0124601359,
-0.0427111499,
0.047958117,
0.0380035117,
-0.0071002212,
-0.0255463645,
0.0000021561,
-0.0233583078,
-0.0350933634,
-0.0208105724,
0.0335428007,
0.008001972,
0.0611185543,
-0.0385807566,
0.0377075188,
0.0207218956,
-0.0527722798,
-0.0387513749,
0.019443972,
0.1164513156,
0.0331660621,
0.0592267402,
-0.0313396305,
-0.029674584,
0.0207368955,
-0.0195439029,
-0.0115785664,
-0.052237466,
0.0048797433,
-0.0111938603,
-0.0282160603,
0.0437952727,
-0.0089637889,
-0.0122439293,
0.0399940237,
0.0466464497,
0.0428601764,
0.0217980761,
0.0357235186,
0.049789872,
-0.0181112811,
0.019842511,
0.0243063718,
-0.0031913428,
-0.0413031355,
-0.0296298992,
0.0399347693,
0.017963931,
-0.0170337819,
-0.0018289282,
-0.0053385114,
0.0623033606,
0.0670719296,
0.0439898707,
-0.0221335497,
-0.0007449999,
-0.0037557508,
0.0489173606,
-0.0213339999,
-0.0793126523,
0.010670186,
0.0740434378,
0.0100731468,
-0.0076913638,
0.0100742737,
-0.0024701657,
-0.002334113,
0.0201576129,
-0.0154602248,
0.0127651608,
0.0150848972,
-0.0745004117,
0.0229747593,
0.008728005,
-0.0332534648,
-0.0003545826,
0.0166751835,
-0.0213497654,
0.0605951175,
-0.0365003906,
-0.0579505712,
0.0233393107,
-0.0636596084,
0.0127655212,
-0.0359379686,
0.0544910431,
-0.0444222093,
0.0238190442,
-0.0681912899,
0.0073792143,
0.0243376642,
-0.0253976397,
0.0452067479,
-0.0032732245,
-0.0173081756,
0.0273111761,
-0.0170287471,
0.0507426485,
-0.0496545695,
0.0486159064,
-0.049545832,
-0.0079589831,
-0.0130655644,
-0.0055133686,
0.0090383943,
-0.0603124537,
0.0038422884,
-0.0004679098,
0.0172593426,
-0.0552186482,
-0.0244922657,
-0.026463639,
-0.0356747545,
-0.0232209936,
-0.0136266295,
-0.058034759,
0.0128039001,
-0.0162683018,
-0.0162816718,
0.0111255115,
-0.0010503758,
0.0006119782,
-0.0119700069,
0.0100968471,
-0.0629750714,
-0.0233121309,
-0.0435947664,
-0.0084850267,
0.0608323216,
0.0530162826,
-0.0073457002,
0.0315971337,
0.010190933,
0.0078560477,
0.0168164484,
-0.01087151,
-0.0081179012,
0.04363456,
-0.0062960121,
-0.0102654081,
-0.0530945323,
-0.0372076742,
0.0367269926,
0.0054853908,
-0.000226822,
-0.0298036393,
0.0312013682,
-0.0524682961,
0.0072943592,
0.0915848389,
-0.0342864357,
-0.0007365624,
-0.031375207,
0.0216520727,
-0.0203578714,
0.0408526286,
-0.0495529436,
-0.0015037942,
0.0097404765,
0.0358224809,
-0.0228912458,
-0.096579574,
-0.0060588862,
-0.0028549484,
0.0306543689,
-0.0155910738,
0.0465107933,
0.0407869481,
-0.013123394,
-0.0666114166,
0.0572973453,
-0.0341445133,
-0.0168232378,
-0.0028211838,
0.0123461895,
0.0701343715,
0.0195381343,
-0.042608127,
-0.048203323,
0.0033953513,
-0.0715957433,
-0.0092265122,
0.024682859,
0.0063201543,
-0.0085487515,
-0.0288627576,
-0.0289185047,
-0.0117578339,
0.0133509552,
-0.0185460355,
-0.0201866291,
0.0762251467,
-0.0349849202,
-0.0237378292,
-0.0121393381,
-0.0109679708,
0.0175478868,
-0.0337837227,
0.0661379695,
-0.0110846683,
0.0134235295,
0.0531894341,
0.0122912517,
-0.0146378186,
0.058529377,
-0.0441612825,
-0.0831940994,
0.0203715172,
-0.0654564276,
-0.0706366822,
0.0406846106,
0.0059014265,
0.0066883191,
-0.01566373,
-0.0458015911,
-0.0262524746,
0.0464689024,
-0.0279317163,
0.0319383591,
-0.0466755256,
-0.0098245759,
0.0276151281,
0.0373782888,
0.0014327688,
0.0795877427,
-0.0351670571,
-0.0203756299,
-0.0761201531,
-0.0179515444,
-0.0090734446,
0.0254021063,
0.0091017103,
-0.0258938204,
0.0226776432,
0.0264559239,
0.0269717723,
0.0075119352,
-0.0052181296,
-0.0064211641,
-0.1030045152,
0.0155029995,
0.0129478704,
0.0352031477,
0.0203379318,
0.0158427861,
-0.015350136,
-0.0046859626,
-0.0691436753,
-0.0211539455,
-0.0250592269,
0.0153226657,
0.0299622975,
0.052231811,
0.0073285121,
-0.0001596891,
0.0047351611,
-0.0300148521,
0.0083642658,
0.0217849445,
-0.037965849,
-0.0387191996,
0.0424972288,
0.0042575393,
0.0249428544,
0.019725563,
-0.0325653441,
-0.0620713308,
-0.0016970071,
-0.0211222321,
-0.0082682613,
0.0188792665,
0.0264150854,
0.0126970159,
0.0204492826,
0.0106859934,
0.0381829478,
-0.07262858,
-0.0050581237,
-0.0107268207,
-0.0515668727,
0.0065921741,
0.081784077,
0.0075264573,
-0.0082389945,
-0.038222,
0.0272011999,
0.0077696606,
0.0032719052,
0.01110713,
0.0106651597,
0.003312421,
0.0407090299,
-0.0008103457,
-0.0080634588,
0.0667813644,
0.0311460588,
0.0165459942,
-0.0778193697,
-0.0194129236,
-0.0330679864,
0.0469209515,
-0.0417446867,
0.0266859997,
0.0075496999,
0.0052704122,
-0.0106833531,
-0.0289543308,
-0.0396473557,
-0.0173905622,
0.0263692923,
0.0188862626,
-0.0324948765,
0.0116812875,
-0.0465573259,
0.0057481322,
-0.0304604098,
-0.014395508,
-0.0018970934,
-0.0189419109,
-0.0247314591,
0.0321791917,
-0.0304329656,
-0.0559514388,
-0.0141818384,
-0.0363028981,
-0.0327487737,
0.0182383768,
0.0555770583,
0.0640414804,
-0.0256477948,
0.0131049892,
-0.0403632112,
-0.047434058,
0.0463296436,
-0.0542382821,
0.0133570498,
0.0225444622,
0.0009727611,
0.0411776714,
0.031330511,
-0.0072929948,
-0.0387521721,
0.0659059659,
-0.0429859944,
-0.018432932,
0.0969387293,
0.0581015423,
-0.0526676551,
0.0188025106,
0.0083309449,
-0.0213722419,
0.0243879296,
0.0205006842,
-0.0793677419,
-0.030732533,
-0.0451665856,
0.0294716004,
-0.0036272912,
0.000128942,
0.0104349339,
-0.1137312427,
0.0367226265,
-0.0035592106,
-0.0498650894,
-0.094092533,
-0.0148352599,
0.020476507,
-0.0465093143,
0.0252676308,
-0.0167744048,
0.0041862661,
0.033619903,
0.0224642437,
-0.0132886125,
-0.0207596794,
0.0270065106,
0.0039466866,
0.0281719081,
0.0195860974,
0.0391371772,
-0.0247204807,
-0.0326039046,
-0.0050440561,
-0.0913642421,
0.0019484317,
-0.0085033802,
0.0615935698,
-0.0436606109,
-0.0043476066,
-0.0191192385,
0.0195233561,
-0.0464709662,
-0.0010432849,
0.021987576,
0.0577128306,
-0.001662732,
-0.0062538614,
-0.0339098908,
0.0106927371,
0.0217797756,
0.0583321974,
0.0030014215,
-0.078414537,
0.0247057714,
-0.0365063548,
0.0032114564,
-0.0903718621,
0.018782625,
0.0096638557,
-0.00681997,
-0.0575664528,
-0.1033367813,
-0.045727931,
-0.0079598846,
0.004564777,
-0.0184222199,
0.0232135281,
-0.0062982342,
-0.028445283,
-0.0521978475,
-0.0179258026,
-0.003734414,
0.0029865641,
0.0369357876,
-0.0397583954,
0.021913873,
-0.0884537548,
-0.0147209084,
-0.0086408025,
-0.0347290933,
-0.0335189514,
0.0014508996,
0.0260593072,
-0.0009761394,
0.0208808631,
-0.0223022308,
0.0186963379,
-0.0156797618,
0.092589356,
-0.0178801436,
0.015821768,
0.0458186343,
0.0301942062,
0.037599206,
0.0351181813,
-0.0145193823,
0.035054639,
0.0408494584,
-0.0235751588,
-0.0730032697,
-0.0730275363,
0.0298136026,
-0.0099350335,
0.0289351363,
-0.0003274053,
-0.0214368943,
-0.0094437962,
0.0162242483,
-0.014707624,
-0.0155985346,
-0.0335153453,
0.0068131792,
0.0157283563,
-0.0075793895,
-0.0411163643,
0.0343322828,
-0.0207997616,
0.0118655944,
-0.0741786659,
0.0512131751,
-0.0087016271,
0.0013370631,
-0.0269864406,
0.026373703,
0.0175389703,
-0.0640794039,
0.0186608173,
0.0210576802,
0.0046447762,
0.0258515235,
0.0252932608,
0.0362349413,
-0.0328626521,
0.0081635611,
-0.0184733439,
0.0668632984,
-0.0386416391,
-0.0381261483,
-0.0108423224,
-0.0431571268,
0.0318309218,
-0.0279213488,
0.0104652336,
0.0046484792,
0.0291510541,
-0.032191392,
0.0073433733,
0.0372605436,
0.0018425859,
-0.0354338996,
-0.0444356799,
0.0539980307,
-0.1000197902,
0.0619940199,
0.0132302428,
-0.001865656,
-0.0226052124,
-0.0179354604,
0.0564728528,
0.01758161,
0.0193088613,
0.0353705101,
-0.0640306771,
-0.0403720699,
0.0203286093,
-0.0459970944,
0.0392041393,
-0.0031551349,
0.0173501093,
0.013930832,
0.017521454,
0.0176031329,
-0.0530229434,
-0.0345063172,
-0.0051314216,
-0.0205114465,
0.0187001843,
-6.973815662e-33,
-0.0308864135,
0.0161051508,
-0.027943844,
-0.0264560357,
-0.0335043892,
-0.0016303862,
0.0092931353,
0.007793122,
0.029661119,
0.0283025205,
0.0038417024,
0.0131816473,
0.0014170775,
0.009194403,
0.0323693082,
0.0349411741,
0.0455507934,
0.0075657167,
-0.0047888546,
0.0529192984,
0.0283639543,
0.0314739533,
0.111806199,
-0.0879053399,
-0.0047287773,
-0.0159226004,
-0.0433008187,
0.0069656204,
0.0119019393,
0.0477441438,
0.0040157042,
0.0414279252,
0.0372522473,
-0.0127368746,
-0.009097591,
-0.0265442282,
-0.024854891,
-0.0317773521,
0.0233918056,
0.0271109082,
0.0177963916,
-0.0262426138,
-0.0104248375,
0.0050691618,
-0.0234886948,
-0.0255411323,
0.0199400485,
-0.0583988875,
0.02139505,
-0.0842970535,
0.0002581344,
0.0238348003,
-0.014706336,
0.0019354168,
-0.0026846088,
0.0361729041,
0.0357649066,
0.0035332462,
-0.0004162993,
0.0364010409,
0.0052724471,
0.0350064114,
-0.0181124695,
-0.0344440527,
0.0129109342,
0.0517082959,
0.0105369128,
0.0215458032,
-0.0112208668,
0.0662493482,
0.0007073205,
-0.0039150133,
-0.0083450228,
0.054180868,
0.0972933173,
-0.0400513411,
-0.000265288,
0.0482403785,
0.0187615473,
-0.028597692,
0.0569293723,
0.0278869532,
-0.0617498197,
-0.0270879976,
0.0479503013,
-0.0006784666,
-0.0378306843,
-0.0289975945,
0.0062466292,
0.0423988625,
-0.0297413152,
0.066711612,
-0.0135665862,
-0.0439998768,
-0.0048224009,
-0.0046773017,
-0.0437992103,
0.0241638031,
-0.006302115,
-0.0203248933,
-0.0295630656,
0.0030632133,
0.0274583772,
0.0226208083,
-0.0020109485,
0.0019987356,
0.1049786285,
-0.0006631874,
-0.1048266813,
-0.0104793441,
-0.0124720773,
0.0571088716,
0.0345146768,
0.0610985383,
-0.0025357245,
0.0234736968,
-0.023635909,
0.0987277403,
0.0379055627,
0.0301777609,
-0.0648740232,
-0.0295426399,
-0.0099207638,
0.015389937,
0.0131681543,
-0.0283445362,
0.0375080369,
-0.0398809239,
-0.0422243513,
-0.0566926263,
-0.0560670495,
0.0230346397,
2.989e-7,
0.0558781959,
0.0467002802,
0.0049344348,
0.0142647568,
-0.0036318388,
0.0518934056,
0.0034109196,
0.0333403721,
0.0083451085,
0.0137215294,
0.0258339122,
0.0341499001,
-0.0306971669,
0.0365932621,
-0.0572237112,
0.054349307,
0.0010158058,
-0.0000079646,
-0.0121445348,
0.0339511149,
0.0856760517,
0.0920887291,
0.023467131,
-0.0267682876,
0.0320630707,
0.0495233126,
-0.0021796606,
0.0202223305,
-0.0489007309,
0.0236859526,
-0.0649562404,
0.0038558077,
-0.0002997516,
0.003840623,
-0.0244652461,
0.0287057739,
-0.0203214418,
0.0307767056,
-0.0011413811,
-0.0375525542,
0.0434483923,
0.0632041618,
0.0080586188,
-0.0033644109,
0.0458090119,
0.0151993837,
-0.0314030871,
-0.0712584406,
-0.0480531268,
0.0429349244,
0.0103467293,
0.016569199,
-0.0104349805,
0.0404782854,
-0.0062062815,
-0.0269407872,
-0.0390776619,
-0.0392343402,
-0.0164482631,
0.0563487224,
0.0122254789,
-0.0520943142,
0.0196953677,
0.0342191756,
-0.0261634924,
-0.067451492,
0.0184270889,
2.720686496e-34,
0.0705997944,
0.0167508479,
0.016507946,
0.018951755,
-0.0064142863,
-0.0273627732,
-0.0304193534,
0.0170083214,
0.0322902016,
0.0104581369,
-0.0124496287
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06382v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06382v1 | What should I say? -- Interacting with AI and Natural Language Interfaces | 2024-01-12T05:10:23 | 2024-01-12T05:10:23 | Mark Adkins | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, I.2.m; J.4; B.4.2 | As Artificial Intelligence (AI) technology becomes more and more prevalent,
it becomes increasingly important to explore how we as humans interact with AI.
The Human-AI Interaction (HAI) sub-field has emerged from the Human-Computer
Interaction (HCI) field and aims to examine this very notion. Many interaction
patterns have been implemented without fully understanding the changes in
required cognition as well as the cognitive science implications of using these
alternative interfaces that aim to be more human-like in nature. Prior research
suggests that theory of mind representations are crucial to successful and
effortless communication, however very little is understood when it comes to
how theory of mind representations are established when interacting with AI. | [
0.0728244111,
0.0115307225,
-0.0671261773,
0.0019932839,
-0.0235587098,
0.0028799947,
-0.0028997953,
-0.0027646176,
0.0545435138,
-0.0243740696,
-0.0431631319,
-0.0271309353,
0.0631132722,
0.026746219,
0.013341533,
-0.0767757446,
0.0118257329,
-0.0151926707,
0.0277835298,
0.0286847688,
0.0095662531,
0.0584435835,
-0.0322976224,
0.0563057475,
-0.0294411238,
-0.0125275264,
-0.0510693416,
-0.0210103299,
0.033325918,
-0.0216500647,
-0.0469798893,
0.0124733942,
0.0212326515,
0.0222403668,
0.0000018121,
-0.0687778443,
0.0641816407,
-0.0011542153,
-0.0242962707,
-0.0326640308,
0.0259347074,
0.0448911823,
0.0255525764,
0.0040925099,
-0.068362996,
0.0386837833,
0.0509317294,
0.0826624632,
-0.0054913554,
0.0121242004,
-0.0194325689,
0.0234074034,
0.0172294509,
0.0143257389,
0.0331403315,
-0.0599975139,
0.0038624371,
-0.032667473,
0.0486030392,
-0.0537645034,
0.0091031678,
0.0038164074,
-0.0062543559,
-0.0226538498,
0.0130229183,
0.0143432748,
-0.0055449209,
-0.0310986433,
-0.0237554591,
0.0543541536,
0.0891632512,
-0.0119794672,
-0.0140928179,
0.0292935222,
0.0474711955,
0.0252690371,
-0.019627044,
0.0065312581,
-0.0061032269,
-0.0137099912,
-0.0042304345,
0.0137341628,
-0.0238297153,
0.0564804673,
-0.0160648562,
0.0079849828,
-0.0478384793,
-0.0109533342,
0.0384942405,
-0.0376936793,
-0.0046677706,
-0.0459225066,
-0.0288068652,
0.0371962078,
-0.0499558859,
-0.0066810278,
-0.0444479771,
0.0103596151,
-0.0079925787,
-0.0243394114,
0.0763917416,
0.0407316498,
0.0162760615,
0.0088798786,
0.0499279313,
0.0440308899,
0.005533888,
-0.0087327817,
0.0058305245,
0.0150910364,
-0.0697678998,
-0.0293098241,
-0.0191510841,
0.0560462587,
0.0303157996,
-0.0283591691,
0.0438044257,
0.0201963801,
-0.0477343351,
0.0055473158,
-0.0560864881,
0.0076117767,
-0.0185124464,
0.0280217938,
-0.041940622,
0.0082473755,
-0.0551433638,
0.0190878678,
0.0169766787,
-0.0903456211,
-0.0092966584,
-0.00321374,
0.0131035829,
0.0166542567,
-0.028724974,
0.0169660319,
-0.005920596,
-0.022492934,
-0.0003790608,
-0.0070047444,
0.0249189343,
-0.0477871932,
-0.0161184762,
0.0154892141,
0.0100645684,
0.0127935596,
-0.0316159017,
-0.0439250506,
0.024532523,
0.0174671821,
-0.0731409192,
0.0606985092,
-0.0442005731,
-0.0179670453,
0.0316264704,
0.0235803798,
-0.0248157457,
-0.0059976922,
0.0142139895,
-0.0009698923,
-0.0068405829,
0.0287997536,
0.0484288856,
-0.0219620876,
-0.0184109304,
-0.0313601233,
-0.0145188011,
0.0067093926,
-0.0372501537,
0.0262154415,
0.0355518311,
0.032033857,
-0.0075272978,
0.0283582956,
0.0528914742,
0.1030636281,
-0.0448316596,
0.003568602,
0.0348199345,
0.0427602753,
0.0322432443,
0.0450831428,
-0.0427318327,
0.0277137272,
-0.0290376469,
-0.0404030196,
0.0115169398,
0.0188182481,
-0.0373745151,
-0.0263174586,
-0.0141802486,
0.0034214035,
0.0559438728,
-0.0033922247,
-0.0192119721,
0.0013642855,
0.0469965674,
-0.0373819806,
0.0101129161,
-0.0215552598,
-0.0321008377,
-0.0642948076,
-0.0075739562,
0.0569511876,
0.0136686498,
-0.006603804,
-0.0135506103,
-0.0209578667,
-0.0359588563,
0.092943646,
0.0610544831,
0.0018935344,
-0.0552710146,
-0.0084541133,
0.0247641504,
-0.0221312419,
0.0106118675,
0.0177048221,
-0.0576979332,
0.0287450682,
-0.0003266801,
0.0392857455,
-0.0185532738,
0.0041638636,
0.0608615279,
-0.0092611937,
-0.0596998818,
0.027190946,
0.01315716,
0.0221661776,
-0.0138080968,
-0.0078103133,
0.0196568333,
0.0515438914,
-0.0218773093,
0.0624824129,
-0.0086139226,
0.0169470087,
0.0121704163,
-0.0472979322,
-0.0541061051,
0.0195726454,
0.0251411181,
-0.0320703797,
0.0174498409,
-0.0659222975,
0.0332809724,
-0.0206515025,
0.0020851521,
-0.0417661369,
0.0057631428,
0.017605653,
0.0169839617,
-0.0190113708,
-0.0353221335,
0.0388140939,
-0.0427511148,
0.0227551442,
-0.0217299424,
0.0250893496,
0.0493345149,
-0.0067178272,
-0.0073285578,
0.0056818137,
-0.0199554618,
-0.046078302,
0.0272535495,
-0.0988267139,
-0.0752528384,
0.0180257633,
-0.0231175441,
-0.0177156515,
-0.0188392587,
-0.0071946289,
-0.0118086068,
-0.038942147,
0.0213334952,
0.0094942367,
-0.0026295595,
0.0590275377,
0.0142150354,
-0.0131650697,
-0.0004723284,
0.0564945564,
-0.032242056,
0.0382121615,
0.0232556518,
-0.0590052977,
-0.0358277224,
0.0252939835,
-0.0549965315,
0.0357635394,
-0.0082944799,
-0.0375598557,
0.0592872724,
0.0381978825,
0.0136946943,
0.0746840313,
0.004129475,
0.0468526669,
0.0525461882,
0.0214310084,
-0.0360159688,
0.0249901935,
0.0823187605,
0.0196927022,
-0.0156476106,
-0.0363916196,
0.0005723949,
0.0145684676,
0.0264368057,
0.0323641896,
-0.04715183,
0.0682076514,
0.0136206532,
-0.0520090908,
0.017475741,
-0.0427995026,
-0.0201614201,
0.0606704541,
0.012323916,
-0.020092316,
0.0693898872,
-0.0170033835,
-0.0074530309,
-0.0187372584,
0.0121024633,
0.0000405873,
0.0508756004,
-0.0217122082,
0.0347831547,
0.0552474894,
-0.0370210335,
-0.0719045475,
-0.0056849299,
-0.0481849983,
0.0025156932,
-0.0304285605,
-0.0474895723,
-0.0112335226,
0.0315419547,
0.0106576513,
-0.0467884727,
0.062873587,
-0.056726031,
0.0146558173,
-0.0070332405,
-0.0283176936,
-0.0306066796,
-0.0279336348,
0.0493122637,
-0.0200435817,
0.0060563018,
-0.0395915061,
-0.017432915,
-0.009975967,
0.0657213777,
0.0507864356,
0.0166876521,
0.0653939918,
0.0521477349,
0.0269497596,
0.025117496,
0.0515560247,
-0.0056081833,
-0.0209942106,
0.0361200646,
0.0052565858,
-0.0193958338,
0.0587023348,
0.0290058814,
0.0142435785,
-0.0003830428,
0.0814737603,
0.0287524853,
-0.0611517355,
0.0114599336,
-0.0394064859,
-0.0239334144,
0.0051697325,
0.0121735586,
-0.0553121977,
0.00703358,
0.0065390868,
-0.0476898067,
-0.054364752,
-0.0402692407,
-0.0021753227,
-0.0496692508,
0.0130685987,
-0.0198700204,
0.0101366742,
-0.0549242198,
0.0061294185,
0.0503829569,
0.070076853,
0.035918083,
-0.0204241332,
0.0029156227,
0.0218790136,
-0.0167034008,
-0.0016470257,
-0.0041035432,
0.0270944778,
-0.0160904806,
0.0739055052,
0.0837221593,
0.0614981912,
0.0034754202,
-0.0511437505,
-0.0161706507,
0.0611764453,
0.0625551641,
-0.0342829935,
0.0039432468,
-0.0107668955,
0.0563765951,
-0.0317967273,
0.0379471853,
-0.025564421,
-0.003789952,
0.0173157081,
0.0680954009,
-0.0669832155,
-0.0045688879,
0.0007641491,
0.0166992079,
-0.0010265325,
0.0430991389,
0.0391351171,
-0.0605689473,
0.0340260379,
-0.0062138271,
0.0065926984,
0.0531867146,
-0.0479466654,
0.0196456183,
0.030675156,
-0.0310933199,
-0.0387768485,
-0.0844020694,
0.0108070783,
0.0125017278,
0.0394824892,
-0.018683102,
0.0493011214,
0.0253735539,
0.0000860946,
0.0239119194,
-0.0161912721,
0.0077752606,
0.0105207898,
-0.0216614511,
-0.0204627868,
-0.0720590204,
0.0174389724,
-0.014511711,
0.0585181676,
-0.0314514674,
-0.0100241378,
0.0301446747,
0.0254864208,
0.0237954315,
0.0275658611,
-0.0445835181,
-0.0082379179,
-0.0283338912,
-0.049604129,
0.0397484079,
-0.00330418,
0.0440685563,
-0.0008347545,
0.0384513699,
-0.0006006544,
-0.0217500106,
-0.0215772316,
-0.0325419791,
0.0004062158,
-0.0414199196,
0.0430790111,
0.020788718,
0.0209522136,
0.0131412763,
0.0155171147,
-0.009687284,
-0.0163065325,
-0.028283786,
-0.022419339,
-0.0361902043,
-0.0390427969,
0.0089136586,
0.0598888285,
-0.0051739798,
-0.0721943229,
-0.054415457,
-0.0096273376,
0.0170711111,
-0.0207602102,
-0.0120866848,
0.0779928043,
-0.0225358829,
0.0036470718,
-0.0002585486,
0.0209915061,
-0.0348745584,
0.0114918137,
0.02000615,
0.1234740838,
0.0242537539,
-0.0485607609,
-0.0077525401,
0.0345343463,
-0.05782599,
-0.1058136821,
0.0467940196,
-0.0102652647,
0.0030312459,
0.0033937099,
-0.0334319286,
-0.0516126677,
0.0463171601,
0.05689881,
0.0260294303,
0.0021234965,
-0.0396843217,
-0.0219103228,
-0.0104979398,
-0.0235267095,
-0.013920798,
0.0076652733,
-0.0722684935,
0.0025192713,
-0.0125187663,
-0.01900726,
-0.0260918699,
-0.0029499489,
0.0045281798,
0.0818636194,
-0.004256424,
0.033124648,
-0.0707073361,
-0.0150036933,
0.0345026217,
-0.0271005146,
0.0069101369,
-0.0553225726,
0.0661227331,
0.0392889865,
0.0032937482,
-0.0648791343,
0.0219397116,
-0.0011501255,
-0.0628987327,
-0.015976321,
-0.0764117688,
-5.681809617e-33,
-0.0182742979,
-0.0778762251,
-0.0050895722,
0.0205901042,
-0.045875866,
-0.0528576188,
-0.02652134,
0.0264429655,
-0.0247046631,
0.0070982324,
-0.0433228426,
0.0212198142,
-0.0115041612,
-0.0110334363,
0.0183327124,
0.0245591532,
0.0143765686,
-0.013318073,
-0.0130579388,
0.0073897024,
-0.0065924129,
-0.0149999717,
-0.0081737265,
-0.0881659389,
0.0647819489,
0.0301564317,
0.0046797078,
-0.0019184306,
-0.0077819503,
-0.0224765427,
-0.0268336292,
0.0593928136,
0.0412399471,
0.0270776674,
0.0125546157,
0.0596696809,
0.0191414412,
-0.0695599839,
0.0362226367,
0.0140396003,
-0.0028541279,
-0.0597816668,
-0.0301281586,
-0.0413742065,
-0.0376815498,
0.033298064,
0.0525862947,
0.0080260243,
0.06235677,
0.0378418192,
-0.0954559222,
-0.0533063225,
-0.0220785942,
-0.0313473493,
-0.0164581109,
0.0422192924,
-0.0031180969,
-0.0488211848,
-0.0600005426,
0.0091559589,
-0.0129773496,
-0.0405777507,
0.0563594364,
-0.0234228522,
0.0248048883,
0.0404306278,
0.0462761819,
0.0154103814,
-0.0479239263,
-0.0245686471,
0.0121793048,
0.0369606577,
-0.0136193326,
-0.0061343135,
-0.026435053,
-0.0401671566,
-0.015301073,
0.0176107753,
0.0110897524,
0.0655268803,
-0.008969157,
-0.0005002494,
-0.0765760094,
0.0095564881,
-0.0123961167,
-0.0631515086,
-0.0311022885,
-0.0345195346,
-0.0076352027,
-0.0393162146,
0.0056091826,
-0.0370738097,
-0.0101045649,
-0.0261740759,
0.0296087284,
-0.0290379506,
-0.0180156901,
0.0092705507,
0.0126488749,
-0.0132605154,
-0.0088677164,
-0.0206428654,
-0.0086619509,
0.0050927224,
0.0501184054,
0.0322460048,
0.000133139,
0.000583769,
-0.011664263,
-0.0227263365,
-0.0234766491,
0.0205774158,
0.0101278014,
-0.0592616871,
-0.0036905576,
0.0452501439,
-0.0388382301,
-0.0274053011,
-0.0048354161,
-0.0441471227,
-0.0726972818,
0.0272951555,
-0.0605105907,
-0.031567052,
-0.0566676222,
-0.0189469643,
-0.0429189466,
0.0303384475,
0.030609969,
-0.0287095588,
-0.02021778,
-0.0185716376,
2.678e-7,
-0.0310835112,
0.0536473766,
-0.0158077441,
0.0191999916,
0.0112105086,
0.0553842075,
0.0001728492,
0.0375371873,
0.0025732568,
-0.0234604385,
0.0073045534,
0.0350941122,
0.0124538485,
0.0081759049,
-0.0409200527,
-0.0220695604,
0.0410977118,
-0.0269852877,
-0.0325186066,
0.0527351908,
0.0486646295,
-0.0097329933,
0.0126626967,
0.0062328991,
-0.0121659283,
0.0259055533,
0.0147228558,
-0.0184423439,
0.0728524178,
-0.0050833989,
0.0066004233,
-0.0185249913,
-0.0025406664,
0.0637170747,
0.0230878554,
0.0314266197,
-0.0234645959,
0.0114234462,
-0.0502671935,
-0.0395951793,
-0.0044395439,
0.009096751,
-0.0082372054,
-0.048134651,
0.0163869523,
-0.0738264099,
-0.0579854399,
0.0280960556,
0.0441476107,
0.0015708393,
-0.0109019531,
0.0204503629,
-0.0141338175,
0.0319338478,
-0.0067677051,
-0.0290675405,
0.0183032826,
-0.0226708911,
0.0345178954,
-0.0258428957,
0.0024824122,
-0.0590460151,
-0.0269728266,
-0.0222860817,
0.0398494154,
-0.0415582173,
0.0151669988,
1.838026959e-34,
-0.0281175487,
-0.0077882791,
0.0546612591,
0.0381701887,
0.0854948759,
-0.0031523497,
0.0258728471,
0.0626997054,
0.0689451545,
-0.0629800782,
-0.0193429813
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06827v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06827v2 | APLe: Token-Wise Adaptive for Multi-Modal Prompt Learning | 2024-01-12T04:54:01 | 2024-01-23T08:54:15 | Guiming Cao, Kaize Shi, Hong Fu, Huaiwen Zhang, Guandong Xu | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Pre-trained Vision-Language (V-L) models set the benchmark for generalization
to downstream tasks among the noteworthy contenders. Many characteristics of
the V-L model have been explored in existing research including the challenge
of the sensitivity to text input and the tuning process across multi-modal
prompts. With the advanced utilization of the V-L model like CLIP, recent
approaches deploy learnable prompts instead of hand-craft prompts to boost the
generalization performance and address the aforementioned challenges. Inspired
by layer-wise training, which is wildly used in image fusion, we note that
using a sequential training process to adapt different modalities branches of
CLIP efficiently facilitates the improvement of generalization. In the context
of addressing the multi-modal prompting challenge, we propose Token-wise
Adaptive for Multi-modal Prompt Learning (APLe) for tuning both modalities
prompts, vision and language, as tokens in a sequential manner. APLe addresses
the challenges in V-L models to promote prompt learning across both modalities,
which indicates a competitive generalization performance in line with the
state-of-the-art. Preeminently, APLe shows robustness and favourable
performance in prompt-length experiments with an absolute advantage in adopting
the V-L models. | [
0.0337569192,
0.0239925366,
0.0361967757,
-0.0055135926,
-0.0207430944,
0.0101138446,
0.0271647461,
-0.0078277308,
-0.0219040066,
-0.0578454807,
-0.0551966652,
-0.0083427858,
-0.0014427059,
0.0656584203,
0.0032981783,
-0.0656154379,
0.0440635644,
-0.0391976722,
0.0136561049,
-0.003907626,
0.0248244312,
-0.0080386093,
-0.0085700182,
0.0393618122,
-0.0467143841,
0.0144020338,
-0.0264722668,
0.0191212315,
0.0057868538,
0.0053323088,
-0.0256999079,
0.043316558,
0.0243659019,
0.0288082659,
0.0000019353,
-0.0627205521,
0.01705469,
-0.0030126828,
-0.0030315185,
-0.0592617057,
0.0329292938,
-0.0227691829,
0.0080050984,
0.0044211103,
-0.0088430587,
-0.0223877989,
0.0728526786,
0.0477616414,
0.0749591365,
0.0408359393,
-0.0055036824,
-0.011645806,
0.0173577536,
-0.036721237,
0.0137597639,
-0.0298641659,
0.0094592413,
-0.0905976072,
0.0036924786,
-0.0125622684,
-0.0325965211,
0.0241998024,
0.0179346763,
-0.0203505345,
-0.0064434828,
0.0481076948,
-0.0123313125,
-0.051342383,
-0.0733489916,
0.0670693293,
-0.0295463298,
0.0284772702,
-0.0247704908,
-0.0284917317,
0.0462122671,
0.0012329712,
-0.0285851061,
0.0156308562,
-0.011714533,
0.0002470143,
-0.0660942867,
-0.0176972244,
0.0054821749,
-0.0047984575,
-0.0249955896,
0.0555016436,
0.0083604036,
0.0018549042,
0.0321209691,
-0.0027315656,
-0.0225028992,
-0.059357848,
0.014211663,
0.0182829816,
-0.0851323977,
0.0010864349,
-0.0757364482,
-0.0220782887,
0.0069996715,
0.0213021562,
0.050141234,
0.0300065931,
-0.0998567492,
0.0577623323,
-0.032439854,
0.0473829322,
-0.005498108,
0.0885984153,
-0.0388546921,
-0.0076730107,
-0.0266126338,
0.0118042985,
-0.0392080843,
0.0068798568,
-0.0529712625,
-0.041733671,
-0.0233165435,
0.0101529267,
-0.0267990865,
0.0212832764,
0.0124061061,
-0.0017731618,
-0.0381623209,
-0.0459969938,
-0.0292873904,
-0.0010135026,
-0.0245410092,
0.0500635356,
0.0338579305,
-0.0711736828,
-0.0076636588,
0.0169420373,
0.0322013684,
-0.0125379832,
-0.0022174192,
0.0752325132,
-0.0822750255,
-0.0492059402,
-0.006894846,
0.0081854258,
-0.027163215,
-0.0099280728,
0.0228136498,
-0.0235364139,
0.0554540046,
-0.0026207755,
-0.001691247,
-0.001599657,
0.0012523975,
0.0043609845,
0.0074702897,
0.1003321707,
-0.0165763274,
-0.0200557839,
0.0296015479,
0.0023535767,
-0.0394420289,
0.0548002608,
-0.02490215,
0.0295389649,
0.0215978269,
0.0360210985,
0.0238764435,
0.0548641495,
-0.0112199625,
0.0228700843,
-0.0462728143,
-0.0197789818,
0.049510736,
0.0208448581,
0.0365329124,
0.0606644042,
-0.0245900042,
-0.0194699056,
0.0403026417,
0.0296866409,
-0.0013633101,
-0.0273355413,
0.0765222311,
0.0080809826,
-0.0012472147,
0.0156606007,
-0.0686693564,
0.015989475,
-0.0441692583,
-0.0071423696,
0.000242482,
0.0454266742,
-0.0474004485,
-0.0353412777,
0.0162788816,
-0.0221115071,
-0.0234762784,
0.0187510736,
0.0448772199,
0.0076230043,
-0.0496664122,
0.0153621919,
0.0253876746,
-0.0370383784,
0.0097087063,
-0.0588001087,
0.0237667914,
-0.0056465031,
-0.027662443,
-0.0239410661,
-0.0010848469,
-0.0236179251,
0.0341649167,
0.0537883975,
0.0021846648,
-0.0149798021,
0.0698614642,
-0.0285117645,
-0.0738602504,
0.0005853478,
-0.0231269225,
0.0398215875,
-0.0353328846,
-0.0122120539,
0.0115602417,
0.0220046882,
0.0259655342,
0.0423036404,
0.0318693444,
-0.0256023537,
-0.0275366921,
0.0283718593,
0.0357667878,
-0.0131306108,
-0.0191475507,
0.0071100621,
0.0153462365,
-0.0376263559,
0.0091434391,
0.015061507,
-0.0957593173,
-0.0105451066,
0.0267421957,
-0.0316260196,
-0.0045138267,
-0.0133459587,
-0.0392210223,
-0.0511131883,
-0.0484096557,
0.0116816238,
0.0212058723,
-0.0529141128,
0.0138624962,
0.0086270524,
-0.0065610637,
-0.0139002539,
0.0352949128,
-0.0417192169,
0.0136949662,
0.0551173203,
0.0397571214,
0.0164934192,
-0.022339588,
-0.0255164579,
0.0072317631,
-0.0395818762,
-0.0046711038,
0.0316497125,
0.0145495655,
-0.065684706,
-0.0265131388,
-0.0858629197,
-0.0374346487,
-0.0433771499,
-0.0328099206,
-0.0132631548,
0.0035352437,
-0.0159013867,
-0.0705062896,
-0.0319247916,
0.0064627491,
0.0189698357,
0.0228227191,
0.0056371042,
0.05732904,
0.0414431021,
-0.0215234235,
-0.0120915165,
0.0265460648,
0.0362486988,
0.0055607981,
-0.0286646802,
-0.0352876931,
-0.0026736332,
-0.005364635,
0.0421624407,
-0.0245816801,
0.0035188638,
0.0170251671,
-0.0365078077,
0.0740772709,
0.0641235411,
0.0156910997,
-0.0110679688,
0.0011059033,
0.0058628512,
-0.0382552445,
0.0353286341,
-0.0232954007,
-0.0395662077,
-0.0184415244,
0.0378311612,
0.0219943672,
0.0206030998,
-0.02135613,
0.0194326397,
-0.0797267035,
0.0369779691,
-0.0001359884,
-0.0837020651,
-0.0971251205,
-0.0024831935,
-0.0453874059,
0.0114760622,
-0.0218383539,
-0.0595631413,
0.0389692225,
-0.0450774543,
-0.0289299246,
-0.0051795351,
0.0002510008,
0.0116752163,
0.0271130688,
0.0189121552,
0.012849886,
0.0229724105,
-0.032908529,
-0.0966944993,
-0.0233518034,
-0.0133193526,
0.0173253659,
0.0640792176,
-0.0231673885,
-0.0192911383,
-0.0477837287,
-0.040147882,
-0.0360286087,
-0.0378285013,
-0.0249863639,
0.0125674605,
-0.0242723823,
0.0028213444,
-0.0196961612,
-0.0128977392,
0.0321511813,
0.0661858544,
-0.0173686091,
-0.0068942383,
-0.0492625311,
0.0576996244,
0.0145149939,
0.0445151515,
-0.0360954143,
-0.0291271098,
0.0077310596,
0.034834668,
0.0667330474,
-0.0380412377,
-0.0226535667,
0.0307854023,
0.0493098237,
0.0225621015,
-0.002661827,
0.0593995415,
0.0731229186,
-0.0182842147,
0.0201104358,
0.0426929407,
0.0175743606,
-0.0653131455,
-0.0540222414,
0.035129264,
0.0255885813,
0.0292903651,
0.0080396598,
-0.043977581,
-0.0458681062,
0.0076412763,
-0.0188467856,
0.0230789557,
0.0119403703,
-0.0301611647,
-0.0890853778,
0.0104986737,
-0.0045605465,
-0.0446421914,
-0.0223826077,
0.0142747462,
0.0203884356,
0.0114785116,
0.0067654713,
0.0025823386,
-0.0224542171,
-0.0098979585,
0.0207089223,
0.0507565364,
-0.023872178,
0.0026926866,
-0.0305545218,
-0.0046808003,
0.0674945936,
-0.0132269142,
-0.0207823906,
-0.0761173517,
0.0697795078,
-0.0205321424,
0.0204382967,
-0.0011646901,
0.0072729122,
-0.0340036526,
0.0005683908,
0.0333227962,
0.0465966836,
0.0318260491,
-0.0365216397,
0.008727245,
0.0395410918,
0.0054861163,
0.0226927977,
-0.0445010625,
0.0120060127,
0.0194777194,
0.0350606441,
0.0053915312,
-0.0619176738,
-0.0120965336,
-0.0212747809,
0.0049452451,
-0.0491369627,
0.0021609217,
0.0118240407,
0.010431462,
-0.0132595953,
-0.0342969932,
-0.0283141453,
0.0147250844,
0.0612181127,
-0.0040029301,
-0.0402992815,
-0.0607222058,
0.0659863204,
-0.0096075451,
0.0739244446,
-0.0007814231,
0.0231958553,
-0.099585481,
0.0386289954,
0.0192965884,
-0.0590944849,
-0.0297139976,
0.0174567457,
-0.0787811354,
-0.0416285843,
-0.0074782204,
0.0694160834,
0.0149305137,
0.0628939494,
-0.0121854572,
-0.0516204983,
0.0777631029,
0.0621965788,
0.01128582,
0.0111119123,
0.0560679883,
-0.0111036915,
-0.0375841372,
0.0162818469,
-0.0603056252,
0.0055402811,
0.0304075144,
-0.0085711535,
0.0121616898,
-0.0556942448,
0.0380846784,
-0.0082968343,
0.0675868019,
-0.0337702893,
0.0447730981,
-0.0469010919,
0.0094179297,
0.0425659567,
-0.0127148423,
-0.0584099852,
0.0258063972,
-0.0353048928,
-0.0029531871,
0.0364377499,
0.0071886536,
0.0010314904,
0.0495360866,
-0.0530574583,
0.005137525,
0.0458823442,
0.0000570261,
0.0232374556,
0.0177113861,
-0.0005822006,
0.0374932252,
0.0151885673,
-0.0043846588,
-0.0096936924,
0.0922322944,
0.0482535884,
-0.0184178054,
-0.0147268251,
0.0677641183,
-0.0328058414,
-0.0333659314,
-0.0380432308,
0.0541287474,
0.008673056,
0.0088100517,
-0.0430425704,
0.005067464,
-0.020394912,
-0.0175592676,
0.0355708823,
0.0462903418,
-0.0389321968,
0.0812918767,
0.0060547492,
0.0045103673,
-0.00187652,
0.0448285453,
-0.0335388333,
0.0186746903,
0.0057977266,
0.0510700196,
-0.0515743718,
-0.0281840879,
0.0372514948,
0.0307182763,
-0.0289928913,
0.0459992066,
-0.0251190104,
-0.0075595882,
0.0134114325,
0.0272831414,
-0.0172470696,
0.0263045095,
0.0653416514,
0.076691255,
0.0113341762,
-0.0223235432,
0.0018176551,
-0.0172096007,
0.0526309423,
0.0227758661,
0.0577183887,
-5.782305568e-33,
-0.023368502,
0.0251636859,
0.0283144638,
-0.0270654205,
-0.017612543,
-0.0025532206,
-0.0013793184,
0.0232177526,
-0.0055496418,
-0.0034455915,
-0.0424156673,
-0.0156359524,
0.0353482701,
0.0345335864,
-0.0046096216,
0.0132463463,
0.0683506653,
-0.0176681876,
-0.0243514031,
0.0056758127,
0.0223204549,
0.0279193688,
0.0056263776,
0.0015635617,
0.0198371205,
0.0290275384,
-0.054800421,
0.0199835747,
-0.0055630552,
0.0455632135,
0.0154806059,
-0.0026358066,
-0.0137798367,
-0.0107619194,
-0.0387696661,
0.0783020183,
-0.0508895963,
-0.0314136147,
0.0043063941,
0.0103609534,
-0.1176570952,
-0.0155018335,
0.0087142289,
-0.0382220149,
0.006204471,
-0.0135762105,
0.0389975384,
-0.012656115,
-0.0351735502,
-0.0194608234,
-0.0132498229,
0.0031952506,
0.0271180868,
-0.0253125243,
0.0316628441,
0.0840769634,
0.0286618359,
0.0234644432,
-0.0434083343,
0.0269820448,
0.018743176,
0.0137366569,
0.0499487296,
0.0693281963,
-0.0325860903,
0.0435786396,
0.0177990962,
-0.0532970428,
0.0306056775,
-0.0470861867,
0.0205456819,
0.0419709906,
0.0314499214,
0.0665109456,
0.0152905863,
0.0018842554,
0.0071492773,
0.0245067514,
0.0287271366,
0.0387542024,
-0.0100029614,
0.0124462675,
0.0460727736,
0.0022675015,
-0.0525561087,
-0.0184430331,
-0.0318471193,
-0.008079282,
0.0422915369,
0.0512413979,
0.0097944513,
0.0121987229,
0.1076274067,
0.0136783849,
0.024945613,
0.0115404427,
-0.0036073981,
0.0270979758,
0.008496929,
0.0120716607,
-0.0666716397,
-0.0114184842,
0.0604025722,
-0.0092063462,
-0.0223667305,
0.0037926598,
0.0380458608,
0.0416010432,
-0.048315756,
0.0130155003,
-0.0165379662,
0.0304826349,
0.0153284865,
0.0448817238,
0.0512627661,
-0.0150462575,
-0.042766057,
0.0356671177,
-0.029420536,
-0.0476946346,
-0.023419397,
-0.0151895257,
-0.0030999838,
0.0321660489,
-0.0104965605,
-0.0046298318,
-0.04697375,
-0.0098883454,
0.0134143773,
-0.0311094467,
0.0004611873,
0.0513192564,
2.539e-7,
-0.0270620119,
-0.0382142812,
0.0102738533,
-0.0317268036,
0.0018425864,
0.0449751019,
-0.0451258644,
0.0408871621,
-0.0021872767,
-0.0191480462,
-0.0093622264,
-0.0061235344,
0.0112153552,
-0.0105643542,
-0.0633855388,
0.0000314729,
-0.063826859,
0.0123475157,
-0.0367533155,
0.0014183867,
0.0336896926,
0.1033998132,
-0.0275934767,
-0.0267273802,
0.0321031362,
-0.0391651876,
0.0671546757,
-0.0150014851,
-0.0047180569,
-0.0168777052,
-0.0021510338,
-0.0068059023,
-0.0041481657,
0.0313606523,
-0.0259666014,
-0.0005372724,
0.0489139967,
0.0371424966,
0.0114997467,
-0.0061325133,
-0.0061549116,
0.0626095086,
-0.0001829403,
-0.052777648,
0.0917430371,
-0.0729200169,
0.0204462372,
-0.0542110801,
-0.0236450005,
-0.003433269,
0.0136706289,
-0.0341658741,
-0.0229870584,
0.0370781794,
0.0255505946,
0.0206003711,
-0.0473789759,
-0.1007412151,
-0.0366834253,
-0.0223321915,
-0.0257459544,
-0.0397038646,
-0.0613277778,
-0.0044570165,
0.0432132408,
-0.05372338,
-0.0412018187,
1.896760351e-34,
0.0043138736,
-0.0202922765,
0.0209267735,
-0.0113800624,
-0.024994595,
-0.0070265625,
-0.0269704554,
0.0157868359,
0.020494435,
-0.0309171211,
-0.0280903094
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06327v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06327v1 | Learning from Semi-Factuals: A Debiased and Semantic-Aware Framework for Generalized Relation Discovery | 2024-01-12T02:38:55 | 2024-01-12T02:38:55 | Jiaxin Wang, Lingling Zhang, Jun Liu, Tianlin Guo, Wenjun Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce a novel task, called Generalized Relation Discovery (GRD), for
open-world relation extraction. GRD aims to identify unlabeled instances in
existing pre-defined relations or discover novel relations by assigning
instances to clusters as well as providing specific meanings for these
clusters. The key challenges of GRD are how to mitigate the serious model
biases caused by labeled pre-defined relations to learn effective relational
representations and how to determine the specific semantics of novel relations
during classifying or clustering unlabeled instances. We then propose a novel
framework, SFGRD, for this task to solve the above issues by learning from
semi-factuals in two stages. The first stage is semi-factual generation
implemented by a tri-view debiased relation representation module, in which we
take each original sentence as the main view and design two debiased views to
generate semi-factual examples for this sentence. The second stage is
semi-factual thinking executed by a dual-space tri-view collaborative relation
learning module, where we design a cluster-semantic space and a class-index
space to learn relational semantics and relation label indices, respectively.
In addition, we devise alignment and selection strategies to integrate two
spaces and establish a self-supervised learning loop for unlabeled data by
doing semi-factual thinking across three views. Extensive experimental results
show that SFGRD surpasses state-of-the-art models in terms of accuracy by
2.36\% $\sim$5.78\% and cosine similarity by 32.19\%$\sim$ 84.45\% for relation
label index and relation semantic quality, respectively. To the best of our
knowledge, we are the first to exploit the efficacy of semi-factuals in
relation extraction. | [
0.0462965034,
0.0109269843,
0.0102448333,
0.0787647516,
-0.0149087766,
0.0150311645,
0.007972246,
-0.0389240123,
0.0581803806,
-0.0413777046,
-0.0126687419,
-0.0056037875,
-0.0543900803,
0.0350854173,
-0.0244615525,
-0.0250020232,
0.069787018,
0.0422522649,
0.0346653983,
0.0186306387,
-0.0255673975,
0.0418166369,
-0.0379055291,
-0.0107985027,
-0.0753521174,
-0.0134756612,
-0.0044468734,
-0.0339725316,
0.0405388251,
-0.0476055704,
-0.0064007742,
0.0343151242,
0.0145851038,
0.0275294967,
0.0000019318,
-0.0745110065,
-0.0556022413,
-0.0404871218,
-0.0263740141,
-0.052130118,
0.0140732145,
0.0001231402,
0.0433255546,
-0.0225946624,
-0.0717641488,
-0.0775422156,
0.0254578106,
0.0668627098,
0.0128757469,
0.0230854824,
-0.0458314344,
-0.0356548764,
-0.035949342,
-0.0099644437,
0.0335762203,
-0.0012115508,
0.0274322685,
0.0434998274,
-0.0226302352,
0.013100897,
-0.0163750947,
0.0077896565,
0.0147404838,
-0.0132909855,
0.0655630529,
0.0685840026,
-0.0568621308,
-0.0283198319,
-0.0047525321,
0.1281641573,
0.0016992532,
0.0036496404,
0.0182211809,
0.0139102787,
0.0005329149,
0.0432999246,
0.0095830504,
-0.0180256087,
-0.0526789762,
0.0378072932,
0.0071352124,
0.0257557519,
0.0373314507,
0.0106785502,
-0.0222520735,
0.0642560571,
-0.022347156,
-0.0144424709,
0.0224025529,
0.0463737957,
0.0057481867,
0.0021471304,
0.0110425996,
0.0179554,
0.0090943445,
0.0417784937,
-0.0399307907,
0.0209228508,
-0.0276341904,
-0.0660089478,
-0.0209593847,
-0.0084452685,
0.0022860765,
0.0794784427,
-0.0684803352,
-0.03485246,
-0.0235625673,
0.0028493875,
-0.0509885512,
-0.0142541472,
-0.0630926192,
0.0145948948,
-0.0313557088,
0.0812106133,
-0.0446696132,
-0.0201522578,
-0.0276947953,
0.0224923901,
-0.0221234616,
0.0195458904,
-0.0110606514,
0.0242098831,
-0.0102363778,
0.0152064729,
-0.019414233,
-0.0301493127,
-0.0412085354,
0.010255483,
-0.0561809354,
-0.0337892622,
-0.0082271285,
-0.0070588775,
0.048454836,
-0.0234283935,
-0.0401041396,
0.0855079815,
-0.0141362175,
-0.0296461787,
-0.0251045395,
-0.0647182092,
0.0003536525,
-0.0235655326,
0.0321095437,
-0.0181455668,
0.0327738822,
0.0447794572,
-0.0355547443,
-0.0360786244,
0.0491870902,
-0.0305950567,
-0.0507681854,
0.0663159862,
-0.0403234847,
-0.0062585282,
-0.0074958266,
0.0359027497,
0.0347295031,
0.0628154576,
0.0266070701,
0.0272312146,
0.0607615784,
0.0373369455,
0.006991588,
-0.0200202502,
0.0273041725,
-0.0167743023,
-0.0028289938,
0.0043450608,
0.0615900159,
0.0299473014,
0.0067825536,
0.0314249396,
-0.0123354504,
-0.0235441066,
0.0105194198,
-0.0186123848,
0.0094716931,
0.0615614317,
0.0479863547,
-0.0193330161,
0.0023838764,
0.0396282412,
-0.0315800607,
0.0302777216,
-0.0246273447,
0.0031727424,
-0.0143181141,
0.0437342413,
-0.0142870806,
-0.0335998312,
0.0002981718,
-0.0250119753,
-0.0227235518,
-0.0199928526,
0.0792036429,
0.0103253638,
-0.0139884669,
0.071885407,
0.055881124,
-0.0495207012,
0.0218722634,
0.0136890588,
0.0387079157,
0.004946922,
0.0527224205,
-0.0785201937,
-0.0580540523,
-0.0093911169,
-0.0320661366,
0.0103119565,
0.0512177721,
-0.0434738658,
-0.0038983675,
-0.0311149471,
-0.0763024017,
0.0053105559,
-0.0155168809,
0.0025023017,
0.0277943518,
0.0167556908,
0.0270252842,
-0.0540650189,
0.0093242237,
0.0423522368,
0.0075949929,
-0.0204308908,
0.0368138663,
0.034997832,
0.01027779,
0.0354126766,
0.0005617838,
-0.0436337106,
0.05945234,
-0.027872134,
-0.0110812271,
0.0563244075,
-0.074198395,
-0.0684456155,
0.0381208025,
-0.0145397428,
-0.0575464144,
-0.0302023664,
-0.0426607504,
-0.0215888787,
0.0346171595,
0.0165387895,
0.0402301289,
-0.0467514023,
-0.0401410125,
0.020221848,
0.0030939544,
-0.0121078417,
0.1235191748,
-0.0078338077,
-0.0256788507,
0.0065140733,
-0.0813536569,
0.026892988,
0.0071306624,
0.0019542277,
0.0002460354,
-0.0105354823,
-0.0311333723,
0.0174066201,
-0.0100497575,
-0.0496224836,
-0.0141868442,
-0.0287609342,
0.0115937693,
0.0143095804,
-0.0056643789,
0.015262899,
0.0118866153,
-0.0038233248,
-0.0370383784,
-0.005500223,
0.0106320148,
-0.0151626254,
-0.0330618732,
0.0545100197,
0.0278319363,
0.0133049358,
0.0016132408,
0.0226277821,
-0.0305405445,
0.0819886178,
0.0612309724,
-0.0278952997,
0.0259389095,
0.0406626649,
-0.0617829338,
0.0261555295,
-0.0003173261,
-0.0011727889,
-0.028944768,
-0.0048670433,
-0.0173518285,
-0.0223259069,
-0.0200029612,
0.0382169373,
0.0514336303,
0.0041027986,
-0.00229278,
0.042531088,
-0.0541286655,
0.0288197342,
0.0006899091,
0.0152278841,
-0.0230498984,
0.0245861504,
0.0118134506,
-0.0255999956,
-0.0184338279,
0.0252369996,
0.0368709229,
-0.0390990637,
-0.0425637923,
-0.0043391893,
0.0447993726,
0.0038980744,
-0.0443510376,
-0.0296146926,
0.0639910176,
0.0218370166,
0.0002107069,
-0.0513828732,
-0.0018582473,
-0.0395508893,
0.0601888038,
-0.0163076408,
0.053674791,
0.020811392,
0.0040817754,
-0.0223767087,
-0.0230787657,
0.0176347531,
0.0118700117,
0.0187756363,
-0.0551911518,
0.0115554295,
0.0325566754,
-0.0030270193,
-0.0825915784,
-0.0307243429,
-0.0102609554,
0.0094862664,
-0.0422889963,
0.0268734507,
-0.0061029769,
-0.0027057952,
-0.0010724751,
0.0120050525,
0.0276146904,
-0.0347200409,
-0.0276908763,
0.0477260686,
0.0625165999,
-0.0186850429,
-0.0064227013,
0.0191443078,
-0.0085842805,
0.0343338847,
0.003231853,
-0.0195730124,
-0.0156081654,
-0.0052232523,
-0.0412956141,
-0.0355390646,
0.036404144,
-0.0253488719,
-0.01189854,
-0.0031232361,
-0.0302967206,
0.1092556044,
0.0568445064,
-0.039290823,
0.0177419726,
0.0251341984,
-0.0149042988,
0.0473677218,
0.0114272255,
-0.0496565886,
0.0047866995,
-0.0412739143,
-0.0424873829,
0.0090283109,
-0.0890490115,
-0.0210507661,
-0.1103843376,
-0.0005732988,
-0.0108030932,
-0.0229621902,
-0.0115113314,
-0.0424941555,
0.0164131466,
-0.0370096676,
-0.0873538852,
-0.0362543911,
-0.0125108538,
0.0338062011,
-0.0206407644,
-0.0125350831,
-0.0431025922,
-0.006116936,
-0.0482138246,
0.0067720227,
0.0021571699,
0.023729993,
-0.0036650214,
0.0121094659,
-0.0112440279,
0.0059345695,
0.0153739294,
-0.0395713113,
0.082606256,
-0.0335677639,
-0.0115295444,
-0.0264516547,
0.0302627664,
-0.0773670748,
-0.0225268696,
-0.0030856556,
0.0939152539,
-0.0041274875,
-0.0043724058,
-0.0273041707,
-0.0060040089,
0.0378276967,
0.0626802817,
-0.0244513787,
0.0147137446,
-0.0047637774,
-0.0096994536,
0.0518158823,
-0.0047047031,
0.0270397775,
-0.0131435161,
-0.0441216715,
0.0096054869,
-0.0495590605,
-0.0304459985,
0.0533246286,
0.0752581432,
-0.0060855644,
-0.0059103551,
0.054953903,
-0.0217539594,
-0.0885477662,
-0.0235726889,
-0.0214146487,
-0.0273347255,
0.0602062531,
-0.0044907909,
0.0159122348,
-0.0780103132,
-0.0253172554,
-0.0604030788,
0.0137471026,
-0.0307237003,
-0.0126570454,
0.030499408,
0.0130697461,
0.0592529736,
-0.0103558777,
0.0402281992,
0.0456416793,
0.0935633779,
-0.0631207675,
-0.0251701958,
0.0185968094,
-0.0121229012,
0.0221879277,
0.0352680907,
-0.0187073015,
-0.0067900582,
0.0308631044,
0.0050632707,
-0.046615161,
-0.0452650711,
0.0357536301,
-0.0167677253,
0.0998030081,
0.0003911661,
0.0538044274,
-0.0758569837,
0.0054401495,
-0.0265759174,
-0.0105181551,
-0.0486617573,
0.0324414521,
0.0104121752,
0.015753312,
0.0065204762,
0.0134688448,
-0.0297380481,
0.0281983577,
-0.0127735073,
-0.0276312269,
0.0283414628,
-0.0035240762,
-0.0121865394,
-0.0015367322,
0.0005209088,
-0.0056082564,
0.0196370166,
-0.0213656668,
-0.0039968197,
0.040895611,
0.0184545442,
-0.0037638922,
-0.026732441,
0.0081561273,
-0.0459252931,
0.0578003302,
-0.0514419191,
0.0613222197,
0.0565910488,
-0.0287273303,
-0.0117972922,
-0.0365059786,
-0.0032992861,
0.0173634849,
0.0754305944,
-0.0159907956,
-0.0328167118,
-0.0045226291,
-0.0061192769,
-0.0453493111,
0.0111300787,
0.0822984129,
-0.0450286716,
0.0610972419,
0.0200252179,
-0.064550966,
-0.0562791526,
-0.0158663634,
0.0088843694,
-0.0111168018,
-0.0188743863,
0.0692980364,
-0.0508477353,
-0.0566920415,
0.0172086842,
-0.0164941885,
-0.0165598504,
0.0084850835,
0.0522865988,
0.043224439,
0.0311358813,
-0.0368930958,
-0.0426247865,
-0.001930544,
-0.0341728777,
-0.0229700599,
0.0103790043,
-5.991428585e-33,
-0.0298292115,
-0.0514793508,
0.0056457324,
-0.0088977227,
-0.0414270051,
0.0334568769,
-0.0260466393,
-0.0202295687,
-0.0101770461,
0.0577497929,
0.0239859745,
0.0079488354,
0.000815414,
0.0085182535,
-0.0063468795,
-0.0037126979,
0.0288057774,
0.0302458834,
0.0199332722,
0.0200245995,
0.057369858,
0.0527928509,
0.0637160242,
-0.134067595,
-0.024917081,
-0.0111138579,
0.0152908694,
0.0522135533,
0.0381650664,
0.0398686007,
-0.038529072,
0.0428994671,
0.0205153003,
0.0020424735,
0.0142710265,
-0.0439688191,
-0.114859499,
-0.0564096123,
-0.0226994436,
-0.0264684223,
-0.03967347,
-0.003553676,
-0.0110119572,
0.0145238442,
0.0312402565,
-0.0421190076,
0.0618216135,
-0.0438417196,
-0.0140910838,
-0.0043072659,
-0.0388356522,
0.0006266521,
-0.0048540044,
-0.0216462743,
0.0175795332,
-0.0013752553,
0.0326595455,
-0.0275699608,
-0.0242384449,
-0.0041877571,
-0.0140763922,
-0.0193451308,
0.0661286488,
0.0071274522,
0.0260198787,
0.0617650039,
0.0030253944,
0.0026323567,
-0.0486219972,
-0.002397282,
-0.0417519733,
0.0546419322,
-0.0348846763,
0.0672927648,
-0.0000980044,
0.0292101726,
-0.0896194279,
0.033830937,
0.0134752151,
0.0264350194,
-0.0164729785,
-0.0024338909,
-0.0128990365,
-0.0009407015,
0.0081562027,
0.0050623138,
-0.0163960848,
-0.031505432,
-0.0042487332,
0.0125548188,
-0.0308097862,
0.0415726714,
-0.011876666,
-0.0422980711,
-0.0086432658,
0.0171136092,
0.0073821363,
-0.0152876973,
0.017897848,
-0.0061411643,
-0.0367382728,
-0.051580742,
0.005074868,
0.0033085137,
-0.011371172,
0.0284743998,
0.0341190621,
-0.0083226105,
-0.0089856619,
0.0240594484,
-0.0146414768,
-0.0372865014,
-0.0058725197,
0.0003892624,
0.0084993616,
0.0297245029,
-0.0263080131,
0.0527293794,
0.0667785704,
0.0325876586,
-0.0051290407,
0.0222995784,
-0.0034625581,
0.0181039441,
-0.0003093499,
-0.0217621587,
-0.0001520262,
-0.0061313347,
0.0322287939,
-0.0591400564,
-0.0114315646,
-0.0028124352,
2.747e-7,
0.0230384022,
0.0188077409,
0.0327691883,
0.0314240195,
0.0073273177,
0.0553082004,
0.0239654724,
0.0847901329,
-0.0302918255,
-0.0101770228,
0.0243527722,
0.0138855539,
-0.0069166729,
0.0418894328,
-0.0336531997,
0.0272055417,
-0.0414307229,
-0.05598782,
-0.0690390989,
-0.0113301501,
0.0676571652,
0.0208156295,
0.0240372121,
0.0155659467,
-0.0200017709,
-0.034913186,
0.0313416645,
-0.0245404225,
-0.0084988214,
0.0364300609,
0.0207280554,
0.0153016476,
-0.0154328402,
0.0500499457,
-0.0278521962,
0.028934462,
0.01643016,
0.0044195084,
-0.0067920694,
-0.0022501205,
0.0234771781,
-0.0053009982,
0.0191822387,
-0.0319871567,
0.0588735193,
-0.0654950514,
0.0203205962,
0.0581040382,
0.0096818861,
0.0288200844,
0.0031782403,
0.0310392696,
0.0047081364,
0.0243846383,
0.0116669629,
0.0123006431,
-0.0193178244,
-0.0431552194,
0.0197067838,
0.0132305454,
-0.0062166299,
0.0125244539,
0.0394530296,
-0.0274195429,
0.0362358354,
0.0034023323,
0.0317418352,
2.204338664e-34,
-0.0151728885,
0.0167701524,
-0.0415211283,
-0.0172760114,
0.027928032,
-0.0616864674,
-0.077721253,
-0.0221706834,
0.0184678994,
-0.0410719626,
0.0167093035
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06321v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06321v1 | Multi-Task Learning for Front-End Text Processing in TTS | 2024-01-12T02:13:21 | 2024-01-12T02:13:21 | Wonjune Kang, Yun Wang, Shun Zhang, Arthur Hinsvark, Qing He | cs.CL | cs.CL | We propose a multi-task learning (MTL) model for jointly performing three
tasks that are commonly solved in a text-to-speech (TTS) front-end: text
normalization (TN), part-of-speech (POS) tagging, and homograph disambiguation
(HD). Our framework utilizes a tree-like structure with a trunk that learns
shared representations, followed by separate task-specific heads. We further
incorporate a pre-trained language model to utilize its built-in lexical and
contextual knowledge, and study how to best use its embeddings so as to most
effectively benefit our multi-task model. Through task-wise ablations, we show
that our full model trained on all three tasks achieves the strongest overall
performance compared to models trained on individual or sub-combinations of
tasks, confirming the advantages of our MTL framework. Finally, we introduce a
new HD dataset containing a balanced number of sentences in diverse contexts
for a variety of homographs and their pronunciations. We demonstrate that
incorporating this dataset into training significantly improves HD performance
over only using a commonly used, but imbalanced, pre-existing dataset. | [
-0.0014914607,
-0.0395383053,
0.0099920118,
-0.0015380784,
-0.0142705115,
0.0376927406,
0.0272785891,
-0.0351094455,
0.0295370482,
-0.0326803811,
-0.0845740139,
-0.042305164,
0.0188705139,
0.0146814249,
0.0200657826,
-0.0401472971,
0.0350288115,
-0.0181680042,
0.008845102,
-0.0039043133,
0.0392091684,
0.0541349798,
-0.0039503034,
0.0447174944,
-0.0431106053,
-0.0014313303,
0.0150967278,
0.0355436727,
0.0330564827,
0.0363666154,
0.0119499136,
0.0317133404,
0.026488509,
0.0300504956,
0.0000019233,
-0.0440100208,
-0.0428675003,
-0.0082639931,
-0.0198937375,
-0.0559034869,
0.0668401569,
0.0158277582,
0.0011514989,
0.055766236,
-0.030600043,
-0.011829298,
0.0228050109,
0.0410160571,
0.0556967184,
0.0578525662,
-0.0209412575,
-0.0390719287,
0.0047517125,
-0.0070184176,
-0.0043098931,
-0.0107126581,
-0.0156096602,
0.0195130743,
-0.0146369925,
-0.0356634855,
-0.0174145903,
0.0565133803,
0.0241916943,
0.0187922455,
0.0209781416,
0.0211397503,
0.0007326974,
-0.0021959594,
-0.006093848,
0.0964686796,
-0.0404515602,
-0.054178331,
0.0312008876,
0.0032453977,
-0.0294360146,
-0.0342964046,
-0.0077858628,
0.0193984304,
-0.0024807081,
0.0320803784,
0.031585969,
-0.0102162883,
0.0261248406,
-0.0049128723,
-0.0005391687,
-0.029521592,
0.0109076295,
-0.0325692371,
0.0314012878,
0.0436510108,
-0.0296800528,
-0.0133346375,
0.0615887903,
-0.0029374207,
-0.0318737067,
0.0311952773,
-0.037098974,
-0.0897032171,
-0.0262302868,
-0.0494116358,
0.0013297198,
0.0205165762,
-0.0324118361,
0.0208027717,
-0.0151209217,
-0.0207464658,
-0.0071013127,
0.0180107895,
-0.022260813,
-0.0447456166,
-0.0918562263,
0.0231974926,
-0.073486127,
0.0494810268,
-0.022894118,
0.0038455469,
-0.0135544771,
-0.0108706551,
-0.0146070998,
0.0071247229,
0.067035675,
0.0059891394,
-0.0794156119,
-0.0005809081,
0.0483827852,
0.0745691732,
-0.0111806877,
0.014477524,
-0.0300432611,
-0.0431596488,
-0.0123846373,
0.0215654336,
0.0285984743,
-0.0380727686,
0.0137474611,
-0.0032063073,
-0.043835707,
-0.0377067961,
-0.042809099,
-0.0392699763,
-0.0458224155,
-0.0443273596,
-0.027002953,
-0.0667693391,
0.0397780389,
-0.0067797648,
0.0038503287,
-0.0375738665,
-0.0116620017,
0.0248235855,
-0.0100590205,
0.0947399139,
-0.013245075,
-0.0265180226,
0.035886921,
0.0265250858,
-0.0184313394,
0.0847937241,
0.0479622334,
0.0324596204,
0.0112787029,
0.0356354937,
-0.0486222021,
0.0709389821,
-0.0100580845,
0.0122364229,
0.0305891857,
-0.0293819904,
-0.0018936282,
0.0186402444,
0.0269211512,
0.0667861179,
-0.0331333168,
0.0194474962,
0.0601940155,
0.0278339703,
0.0221253093,
-0.0219727997,
0.0474290736,
0.0514895059,
-0.0343145356,
0.0073966524,
-0.0188529659,
-0.0249530468,
-0.0300576128,
0.0177318957,
-0.0201289225,
0.0099268006,
-0.030895574,
-0.0262413099,
0.0111399246,
-0.080312781,
0.0078416653,
0.0124757541,
0.0822968036,
0.0251734648,
-0.0569083728,
0.0187015776,
0.0118158329,
-0.0634272769,
0.0483340397,
0.0125352619,
-0.0456209779,
0.046156574,
0.0227233563,
-0.0193277877,
-0.0514050983,
-0.0517942049,
-0.0075485623,
0.0209582523,
0.0010417221,
-0.0282632448,
0.0355302915,
-0.0910210609,
-0.0082977926,
0.0364782214,
-0.0104757743,
-0.0038458642,
-0.0274952408,
0.0062173284,
0.0335858613,
-0.0336805768,
0.0278833788,
0.0100110648,
-0.0404800735,
-0.0107795317,
-0.0118402382,
0.0292804148,
-0.033470463,
0.0448282398,
-0.0441661738,
-0.0075687566,
0.0156691968,
-0.0137111349,
0.0155786648,
0.0314143635,
-0.0557956472,
-0.0497674942,
0.0302240457,
-0.0229980927,
-0.0422850214,
0.0665483177,
0.0149249872,
-0.0797466412,
-0.019815566,
-0.0186644569,
0.0093373004,
-0.0373139121,
0.0236479845,
0.0079723233,
-0.0229777433,
-0.0191861559,
0.0136086345,
0.0402374454,
0.0022366268,
-0.0164078418,
-0.0333023258,
0.018251406,
-0.0215083063,
-0.0636062622,
-0.0106651895,
0.024803644,
0.0089861918,
-0.0042094141,
0.010164775,
-0.0566738248,
0.0058324952,
-0.1200616509,
0.0098100612,
-0.0531663746,
0.0282028951,
0.0369843915,
0.0302244313,
0.0156983547,
-0.0675323084,
-0.0097290371,
-0.0052225566,
0.037914034,
-0.0047472436,
0.0085871285,
-0.0258792974,
-0.0180631112,
-0.015538495,
-0.0009612041,
-0.028088389,
0.0048619192,
-0.0009111475,
-0.0551634803,
-0.0052989377,
-0.0070744404,
-0.005012094,
0.0502224006,
0.0475893058,
0.0039623668,
-0.0059803971,
0.0031674153,
0.0985390842,
0.0308210757,
-0.0344504826,
0.0219748914,
0.0303757116,
-0.0061279871,
-0.048105184,
-0.0096435901,
0.0143831298,
0.0229232982,
-0.0493621379,
-0.0194762535,
-0.0049603675,
0.0835238174,
0.008307592,
-0.0079951771,
-0.0271335542,
-0.0382898226,
-0.0407529995,
-0.0372991338,
-0.0118042789,
-0.0047403276,
-0.0333799832,
0.0043907505,
-0.0293044318,
-0.0445218869,
0.0531219728,
-0.03727182,
-0.0480183586,
-0.0977803096,
-0.0203887802,
-0.0116070565,
0.0715213045,
-0.0159129016,
0.0394807644,
0.0401333123,
-0.0765240937,
-0.0643903315,
0.0381127596,
0.0158976465,
-0.0282482877,
0.0387095958,
-0.0562334843,
0.0013162027,
-0.0188381039,
-0.027251251,
-0.0127125569,
0.0066089067,
-0.0472079068,
0.0534509756,
0.048539374,
0.0038370143,
-0.0218409505,
-0.009716847,
-0.0043687308,
0.0495904498,
0.0257813409,
-0.0118873958,
-0.0270419307,
0.0606524087,
0.0416398272,
0.0060566003,
-0.0355389826,
-0.0246711336,
0.0077914512,
0.0298689716,
0.099658452,
-0.0476533622,
-0.0399366096,
-0.0144819971,
0.0360479653,
-0.0547200665,
-0.0472426675,
-0.0042828871,
0.0322533101,
-0.0331038386,
-0.0079076905,
0.1487071365,
0.0254042931,
-0.0654379055,
-0.0366435163,
0.0319260359,
0.0179089345,
-0.0174564067,
-0.0236354209,
-0.0997824147,
-0.0622203946,
0.0371652991,
-0.009098703,
0.0804482847,
-0.0197443664,
0.0098818401,
-0.0815610513,
-0.0083483597,
0.0160618108,
-0.00370414,
-0.0268918592,
0.0114815496,
-0.0100931665,
-0.0300498586,
0.0080216518,
-0.0238497294,
-0.0061646448,
0.0018615716,
0.0292174779,
-0.0165962819,
-0.0211949535,
-0.0108000068,
-0.0771472752,
0.0528492555,
0.0172403362,
0.0228443388,
0.0289504416,
0.0135826748,
-0.0006568104,
0.0175235737,
-0.0102552455,
-0.024671251,
0.0157667957,
-0.0326103866,
-0.0156422183,
-0.0183769986,
0.0000751254,
-0.0354483612,
0.0119915251,
-0.0043682824,
0.0696260482,
-0.0065436973,
0.0300838556,
0.0398656055,
0.0239089839,
0.0396152139,
0.0631355718,
-0.0107265282,
-0.0459847488,
-0.0526274852,
0.0012012664,
0.0097134719,
-0.0392764993,
-0.0024881558,
0.0125117097,
-0.0648161471,
0.0231787935,
-0.0525151566,
-0.0394071378,
0.066708006,
0.0438289158,
0.0134164048,
0.0145845022,
0.0268572569,
0.0118526025,
-0.0586583912,
0.0106532881,
-0.0669569373,
0.0477939919,
-0.0335410312,
-0.0149076451,
0.0234089382,
-0.0233987365,
-0.013614947,
0.044003889,
-0.0670414045,
-0.0355371349,
-0.0008634746,
-0.0187529679,
0.0119215548,
0.0461077951,
-0.054580722,
-0.0529300533,
-0.0283325985,
-0.0361376256,
-0.0695202053,
0.0009783384,
0.0396878645,
-0.0010091715,
-0.0141906328,
0.0303889345,
-0.021488769,
0.0294636246,
0.003247106,
0.0214542896,
-0.0021332621,
-0.0376610719,
-0.0253970865,
0.0433231257,
0.0544620976,
-0.0133381868,
0.0556221381,
-0.0448232852,
0.0092427563,
0.0149742682,
0.0242399909,
-0.0222197529,
0.0232922006,
0.0394062661,
0.0170809049,
-0.0160918012,
0.0565120503,
0.0069956318,
0.0175325722,
-0.0466147959,
0.0295462329,
0.0174173433,
-0.0269394536,
-0.0130877215,
-0.0033604158,
-0.0007058362,
-0.0141325817,
0.0455165058,
0.0019530196,
-0.0012776972,
-0.004543887,
-0.0017157304,
-0.001128006,
-0.0302712116,
0.0253685731,
-0.0211551189,
0.0301941913,
-0.0334016047,
-0.0140337683,
0.0895822346,
-0.0040265382,
0.075022161,
0.0028473756,
0.0279589649,
-0.0129933497,
0.0304966569,
-0.0425017849,
0.0151842022,
0.0044879154,
-0.0223283879,
-0.0125973495,
0.0090462919,
0.0826795548,
0.0491187274,
0.0314321294,
0.0051070931,
0.0099492818,
-0.0288264826,
-0.0476744473,
-0.0188838579,
0.0428107604,
-0.0134295253,
-0.0394812934,
-0.0293664746,
-0.0886778012,
0.0143461004,
-0.0269489419,
0.0015979547,
0.023910502,
0.0619310364,
-0.005686345,
0.0016932439,
-0.0073133246,
0.0027061098,
-0.0220303256,
0.0213574395,
-0.0044957823,
0.0024191276,
-5.782287201e-33,
-0.0217490047,
-0.0018753099,
-0.0025617059,
-0.0207590684,
-0.0361409485,
0.0048890556,
0.006331923,
-0.0168701373,
-0.0104205562,
-0.0169202946,
-0.006175234,
0.0191849079,
0.0329100788,
0.0366731323,
-0.0036754762,
-0.007902219,
0.0969694257,
-0.0487238951,
-0.0083921775,
0.0383559465,
0.0541145764,
0.0756763071,
0.0819938257,
-0.0227465481,
0.0082155075,
-0.0195518099,
-0.0198577885,
0.0100988252,
0.0489622913,
0.0457466207,
0.0250018965,
0.0809104145,
0.0268429555,
-0.0653956011,
-0.0533615686,
0.079883486,
-0.1439476758,
-0.0015314345,
0.0164573677,
0.0359824374,
-0.0215428192,
0.0244148355,
0.0252725463,
-0.0134198852,
0.0288508628,
-0.0157625116,
0.0542295873,
-0.0059608067,
0.0069870315,
-0.040644411,
-0.0453599691,
0.0164712556,
-0.0203064438,
-0.0121146329,
0.0763844997,
0.0146859512,
-0.0121522844,
-0.0285795946,
-0.0775672197,
0.0223077908,
-0.0284279827,
-0.0075106923,
0.0491282716,
0.0169474408,
-0.0180166475,
0.0242746361,
0.0160041973,
-0.0078596175,
-0.0305524915,
-0.0178423356,
0.0416268222,
0.0297037866,
0.021930946,
-0.0170847867,
0.004463505,
-0.0132805062,
-0.040930856,
0.0093224403,
0.0828649476,
0.0109872259,
-0.0266364701,
0.0151231522,
-0.0209933128,
-0.0247840509,
-0.0689678192,
0.0444066636,
-0.0046484084,
-0.0301987436,
0.0485730618,
0.0082373666,
-0.0112136547,
0.0755193904,
0.0623005591,
-0.0256443433,
0.034127228,
0.0323256142,
0.0333062261,
0.0350153968,
0.0025605462,
0.0115802586,
-0.0690215454,
-0.0265050083,
0.0456193797,
0.0226063151,
0.0007737643,
-0.0124961669,
0.0225546714,
-0.0066132196,
-0.0725287572,
0.0262254309,
-0.0145140011,
0.0280823782,
-0.0013388789,
0.0529462099,
0.062343955,
-0.0298672151,
-0.0033450008,
0.0192255471,
0.0244695693,
0.006303126,
-0.026121702,
0.02906988,
-0.0280849375,
0.0127864517,
-0.0143583016,
0.0287734531,
0.0009379557,
0.0105114514,
0.0351198688,
-0.0250281058,
-0.0070197987,
-0.007886447,
2.631e-7,
0.0402953103,
0.034716554,
0.0204951912,
-0.0041780653,
0.0119420765,
0.0221663602,
0.0024461141,
0.027756609,
-0.028180182,
0.0005085215,
0.0051587699,
-0.005291393,
0.0486170352,
0.0206163339,
-0.0834667832,
-0.044444114,
-0.0300178435,
0.0580979884,
-0.0278924108,
0.0225445163,
0.0099066719,
0.0580288172,
0.0013910814,
-0.0129049998,
-0.0043241973,
-0.019637702,
0.0355106965,
-0.0175316669,
-0.0028793667,
-0.0109815747,
0.0105254175,
0.0015574339,
-0.0290854163,
0.0380803645,
-0.0462169461,
0.0074199089,
0.0572481751,
0.054360047,
-0.0003165005,
-0.0217456836,
0.0121901101,
-0.0090098856,
-0.0221977048,
0.0056686108,
0.0788802728,
-0.0481339358,
-0.008071756,
0.009242625,
0.0093194013,
0.0061873994,
-0.0207623448,
0.0256670844,
-0.0318400897,
0.0249772314,
0.0311428811,
-0.0119332448,
-0.0238259546,
-0.0772585943,
-0.009179024,
0.065553017,
-0.0183789898,
-0.0304364916,
0.0076197824,
-0.0380205028,
0.0221482161,
-0.0626482442,
-0.0131089855,
2.395633151e-34,
0.0292386692,
-0.0433801748,
0.0309159383,
0.0346443243,
0.005114194,
-0.0344153196,
-0.0210438762,
-0.001203964,
0.0319421478,
-0.0617628694,
-0.0219016932
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06320v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06320v2 | Zero-shot Generative Large Language Models for Systematic Review Screening Automation | 2024-01-12T01:54:08 | 2024-02-01T02:08:28 | Shuai Wang, Harrisen Scells, Shengyao Zhuang, Martin Potthast, Bevan Koopman, Guido Zuccon | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Systematic reviews are crucial for evidence-based medicine as they
comprehensively analyse published research findings on specific questions.
Conducting such reviews is often resource- and time-intensive, especially in
the screening phase, where abstracts of publications are assessed for inclusion
in a review. This study investigates the effectiveness of using zero-shot large
language models~(LLMs) for automatic screening. We evaluate the effectiveness
of eight different LLMs and investigate a calibration technique that uses a
predefined recall threshold to determine whether a publication should be
included in a systematic review. Our comprehensive evaluation using five
standard test collections shows that instruction fine-tuning plays an important
role in screening, that calibration renders LLMs practical for achieving a
targeted recall, and that combining both with an ensemble of zero-shot models
saves significant screening time compared to state-of-the-art approaches. | [
0.0446390733,
0.0302084312,
0.0021223072,
-0.0377717093,
-0.0144883124,
0.0096661709,
0.0462392122,
0.018615948,
-0.0556560792,
-0.0756095052,
-0.0099599622,
-0.0464237407,
0.0160588622,
0.0478671864,
0.0177942105,
0.0008635852,
0.0099992659,
0.0036271163,
0.0660843328,
-0.0064085987,
-0.0452482179,
-0.0236185174,
-0.01964573,
0.0439905189,
0.0938315541,
-0.0180198457,
0.0344405696,
-0.0130862892,
-0.0015808342,
-0.072192803,
0.0024709811,
0.0688019097,
-0.0033515228,
0.0549895056,
0.0000018691,
-0.0533179753,
-0.0092549818,
0.0547972396,
0.0248110741,
-0.0020889996,
0.0609921776,
-0.0310388915,
-0.011271636,
0.0244730301,
0.0089783343,
-0.0598922633,
0.0421200208,
0.0275698863,
-0.0126479389,
0.0385054685,
-0.0019457481,
0.023223307,
0.031692747,
-0.027582746,
0.0426506177,
0.0209212322,
0.0661902577,
0.030517593,
0.0237474497,
0.0320662521,
0.0277316589,
0.010363414,
-0.0298851877,
-0.0348142609,
0.0168925878,
0.0317256935,
-0.0711653307,
-0.0438278578,
0.020216547,
0.0325286947,
0.0116772316,
-0.0314050727,
0.0167614333,
-0.0214927327,
-0.0139921447,
0.0344030522,
-0.0602937751,
0.0283519961,
0.023728013,
-0.028329771,
0.0062094862,
0.0073126773,
0.0335137062,
0.0044108327,
0.0277630333,
-0.0025116482,
0.0227799993,
-0.0303843711,
0.026561873,
0.007084962,
0.0582856387,
-0.0569768287,
-0.0218754504,
0.0193058439,
-0.0222948194,
-0.0091861403,
0.0436399616,
-0.0170252305,
0.1226829737,
-0.0119586457,
0.0401600935,
-0.0342170931,
0.0122578703,
0.0434520617,
-0.0171221476,
-0.0207778681,
0.0296501052,
-0.0016854623,
-0.0238153618,
0.0632853508,
-0.0440125242,
-0.0107867634,
0.0158622693,
-0.0031671722,
0.020344764,
-0.012333489,
-0.0863213837,
-0.0373977497,
-0.0173853599,
-0.0039557484,
0.0085577136,
0.0080645541,
-0.0438716747,
0.0074973488,
0.0038560233,
0.0423000194,
0.0051960209,
0.0449294411,
-0.0288517326,
-0.0069203246,
0.0034230594,
0.0091155805,
0.0047860146,
0.0104619311,
0.0302328113,
-0.0024803125,
0.0114661437,
-0.0524020121,
0.027854301,
-0.0250842478,
-0.0411779992,
-0.05412497,
0.01531824,
-0.0817845017,
0.001494633,
-0.0012345219,
0.0402942263,
0.0050744209,
-0.0022175708,
0.0174487513,
-0.0181674324,
0.0285621099,
-0.0349665619,
0.0009554395,
-0.0321983062,
-0.0007491234,
0.0278298184,
0.0580674633,
-0.0041818488,
-0.0177029334,
-0.0193459988,
-0.0188924186,
0.0105111403,
-0.0303126704,
0.002499162,
0.0231579114,
0.0179666281,
-0.0052219313,
0.021397315,
0.056001395,
-0.0245760549,
0.0408318937,
-0.033233434,
0.0123851635,
0.0287326872,
0.0684708282,
0.0242132265,
0.026137637,
0.0208838806,
-0.0304749329,
0.0118207373,
-0.036724858,
-0.0078256279,
0.002890697,
-0.0108219199,
0.0088775782,
0.0235596672,
0.0151398275,
-0.0143824499,
-0.0056597958,
-0.0430569202,
0.0105788633,
-0.0392400175,
-0.0255607273,
0.0600724258,
0.0033620258,
-0.0212756321,
-0.0107646715,
0.0312632993,
0.0013238556,
0.0102112452,
-0.0247380324,
0.014942606,
0.038889572,
0.092031613,
-0.018982349,
-0.0001287015,
-0.0352061428,
-0.0130173992,
0.0198470503,
0.0071370741,
-0.0169884823,
-0.0129598808,
-0.0292896293,
-0.0334660523,
-0.0006982291,
0.0361161642,
-0.009776785,
0.0114115458,
0.0233867709,
-0.0155161489,
-0.0622653849,
-0.0595849976,
0.0237156507,
-0.0493137315,
-0.0306956749,
-0.0048437389,
-0.0693554133,
0.0315783806,
0.0038009484,
-0.0282851961,
0.0405891873,
0.03681558,
-0.0277290959,
-0.0308689978,
-0.0230033509,
0.0213192254,
0.0065696388,
0.020023562,
-0.0801747441,
0.009529206,
-0.0053944397,
-0.0364072807,
-0.0275868401,
-0.0087745255,
0.0223132856,
0.0133982934,
-0.0036815298,
0.0049258019,
-0.016024407,
-0.0278671179,
-0.0279248226,
0.0229735561,
-0.000930078,
0.0334131084,
0.0285146944,
-0.0934419259,
0.0083377892,
-0.026444776,
-0.0531146415,
0.0224488564,
-0.0173505917,
0.0073900651,
0.0159614831,
0.0259564426,
-0.0202318355,
-0.035175059,
-0.0890730172,
0.0173480026,
0.029665431,
-0.0068678092,
0.0158567,
-0.0258454718,
0.0091858739,
0.0232935827,
-0.0200738367,
-0.0242114086,
0.0035278755,
0.0357517786,
0.0176271312,
0.0218458362,
0.0108928271,
-0.075667806,
-0.0426082946,
-0.0181914046,
0.0626092479,
0.0590793639,
0.0381100066,
-0.0132818697,
0.0352427363,
-0.0138668232,
-0.0301501695,
0.0153113753,
-0.0142501174,
0.0120599,
0.0026549066,
-0.0336891636,
0.0454014316,
-0.014242921,
-0.0221045036,
0.0802593157,
0.0175063498,
-0.0416454636,
-0.0251679979,
-0.0223672967,
-0.0427169651,
0.0370825566,
-0.0592097752,
0.0142134279,
0.0318413787,
-0.0027009768,
0.0055194129,
-0.0221634302,
-0.0184322596,
-0.0298453961,
-0.0084320176,
-0.0622631423,
-0.0201009586,
-0.0195017252,
0.0330741368,
-0.0003388065,
-0.0440456718,
0.0666815788,
-0.0230563637,
0.0335485525,
-0.0791072249,
0.0404966138,
-0.0443576351,
-0.0364553519,
0.0052098688,
0.004296788,
0.0396848135,
0.0154717444,
-0.0022377451,
-0.0299572386,
0.0333444253,
-0.0177154262,
0.0264783576,
-0.0176206026,
0.0430977084,
-0.0126018254,
-0.0028119646,
-0.0167643353,
-0.0135839172,
-0.031579718,
0.0136857238,
0.0510645397,
-0.0004669885,
-0.0755336508,
0.0524075814,
0.0367665999,
0.0583080463,
-0.0290554352,
-0.0127985608,
0.001798852,
-0.0279456265,
0.0762685016,
-0.0826085955,
0.0163276829,
-0.0060395808,
0.0543022938,
0.0547968075,
0.0045650532,
0.0584485792,
-0.0420506969,
-0.011476092,
-0.0045418683,
-0.057430543,
0.0014049265,
0.0311988983,
-0.0086927647,
-0.0267603789,
0.0010845573,
0.0873305649,
0.0243767593,
-0.1176582128,
-0.0203600936,
-0.0422335528,
-0.0140180625,
0.0035922029,
-0.0108685438,
-0.0605910756,
-0.0099355606,
0.0071731196,
0.0416383035,
-0.0311433356,
-0.012453679,
0.0206419863,
-0.0673267543,
0.0404789336,
0.0192022789,
-0.0096572014,
-0.0198357496,
-0.0494697839,
0.026414277,
-0.0156141706,
-0.0289285667,
0.0246809479,
-0.0566731878,
0.0069502853,
-0.016339248,
-0.0586983934,
-0.1041102633,
0.0731169283,
-0.0270079784,
0.0798309594,
0.0500372089,
0.0006139528,
-0.0141223753,
0.0268709268,
0.0201454218,
-0.0642341971,
-0.0197020434,
-0.009914631,
0.0731461868,
0.0279658381,
0.0532775931,
-0.0218592696,
0.0337027647,
-0.0353061557,
-0.0079851663,
0.0176072288,
0.0742949694,
-0.0058511021,
-0.0365239829,
-0.0473130271,
0.0338080339,
0.014437234,
0.0811196268,
0.0348112769,
0.0097905621,
0.0100320168,
0.0250080694,
0.011912683,
-0.013786112,
-0.035761971,
0.0247090813,
-0.0274294335,
-0.0528229028,
-0.0448725894,
-0.0210980251,
0.0813492909,
0.0098706353,
0.03035786,
0.0388525352,
0.0339151062,
-0.015608401,
-0.0173298791,
0.0537985489,
-0.0029826211,
0.0041969744,
-0.0536509492,
-0.0160843786,
0.0913188756,
0.0043700249,
0.0044299602,
0.0058603734,
-0.0094540007,
-0.0166826621,
-0.0288677309,
0.0431119427,
0.0244126953,
-0.0239543021,
-0.0089707347,
-0.0359625444,
0.0552126132,
-0.0082916897,
0.0450715832,
-0.0272297058,
-0.0207803864,
-0.0259485636,
-0.0051301038,
-0.0318741724,
-0.0715270936,
0.0351190902,
-0.0078201089,
0.0224440154,
-0.0035297605,
0.0029435342,
0.0411099382,
0.0208736528,
0.0426748879,
-0.0451696925,
0.0190713257,
-0.0077371011,
0.0016201449,
-0.0331922881,
0.0203832015,
-0.0264038052,
0.0373911075,
0.0305021591,
0.0022357441,
-0.0211511198,
0.0133174555,
-0.0927014798,
0.0459238179,
-0.0586258769,
0.0737239495,
-0.0003866445,
0.0309250373,
0.0484408364,
-0.0346759148,
-0.0292680394,
-0.0060719326,
-0.0561659746,
0.0094770025,
-0.0028489802,
0.0214621741,
-0.0019278363,
0.0182058904,
-0.0529837944,
0.0199875049,
-0.045346804,
-0.0104077244,
-0.0164269265,
-0.0136471456,
0.0322514139,
0.0158565231,
0.0452699177,
-0.0291745011,
-0.0025532148,
-0.0534841903,
0.0304143466,
0.0035264625,
0.0114839105,
0.04182785,
0.0313645713,
-0.0040877857,
-0.033867497,
0.08435826,
0.0049112616,
0.0127242897,
0.0045278468,
-0.0520133898,
-0.0086194705,
-0.0276943725,
-0.0288119651,
0.0244347379,
-0.0313469432,
-0.014550088,
-0.0890782923,
-0.0217379984,
-0.0154384635,
0.0057630218,
-0.0022244467,
-0.0160261709,
-0.017061064,
0.0394601002,
0.0087655308,
-0.0038919814,
-0.0452649072,
0.0342278183,
-0.0178337377,
-0.0367147401,
-0.0340754315,
-5.770726581e-33,
0.0302101597,
-0.0147078391,
0.0011108429,
-0.0553805009,
0.0274878349,
0.0316275954,
-0.0493640006,
-0.0011406875,
0.0201843549,
0.0588825792,
-0.005754035,
-0.000748045,
-0.0019062823,
0.0025212311,
0.0387878641,
0.0139626814,
0.0494637229,
-0.0066968389,
-0.020445928,
0.0333593413,
-0.0304942559,
-0.0324723981,
-0.0055120001,
-0.0023359449,
0.0244331025,
0.0201626066,
-0.0023686597,
-0.0287507642,
0.0103108371,
0.0761545226,
-0.0107146353,
0.0376960188,
0.0279181916,
-0.0090532079,
-0.0121734329,
-0.0191023331,
-0.0605541654,
0.0018479945,
0.0382265076,
-0.0618149713,
0.0075540561,
-0.0115094176,
0.0434974954,
-0.0085886521,
-0.0336768925,
-0.0110718496,
0.040351782,
-0.0482277013,
-0.0632416755,
-0.1128508076,
-0.0703839511,
0.028893102,
-0.0092909178,
0.0078400224,
-0.0254289825,
0.0548829995,
-0.0202360582,
0.0618058331,
-0.0237334594,
0.0316300616,
0.0564153977,
0.0230344199,
0.0126863187,
-0.0152905285,
-0.0133537557,
0.0700095743,
-0.0605045669,
0.0212800857,
0.0235665515,
-0.0158544239,
0.0102658337,
-0.0222891513,
0.0258233678,
0.0431303121,
0.0538391173,
0.0147794224,
-0.0872918144,
0.0550607517,
-0.0620213524,
0.0564099252,
0.0926522389,
-0.0236080494,
-0.0268001221,
-0.0204091407,
-0.0441411324,
-0.0311235823,
-0.0292474069,
-0.0119366674,
0.0405876413,
0.0185397379,
-0.0309447199,
-0.0320551433,
0.0566285476,
-0.0128223067,
0.0138531169,
0.0467366688,
-0.0042780275,
0.02748188,
-0.00634652,
0.0009839329,
-0.0671525225,
0.0113401329,
0.0337690786,
0.0302586965,
0.0326318704,
0.0024010625,
0.0392095149,
-0.0203762818,
-0.0625348762,
-0.0145709869,
-0.0083345957,
0.0058219102,
-0.0075883903,
0.0064762672,
-0.0157664753,
0.0383140519,
0.0191235486,
0.0407453477,
0.0063377409,
-0.0138592217,
0.0005105619,
0.0169558935,
-0.0232915282,
0.0169190709,
-0.016086353,
0.0222439505,
-0.0252627656,
0.029144885,
0.0865654275,
-0.0303721055,
0.0087613836,
-0.0064212768,
2.579e-7,
0.0749121606,
0.0622205175,
-0.0526795872,
-0.0405904129,
0.0500079393,
0.0209507495,
0.0088652801,
-0.01388497,
0.061837662,
0.0282668564,
0.0380353816,
-0.0059343097,
-0.0003678486,
0.0215838496,
-0.0549509153,
0.0050435672,
-0.0679565966,
-0.0154827256,
-0.045793727,
-0.0439113863,
-0.0065286658,
0.0528853685,
-0.0425785333,
0.016160734,
-0.0102288546,
-0.0405374281,
0.0262600724,
-0.0388734899,
-0.0112402346,
0.0498258956,
0.0355546325,
-0.004844117,
0.0309049692,
0.0125753088,
-0.0211436823,
0.0040299497,
-0.0487384871,
0.045136828,
-0.0187850799,
0.0262838751,
0.0294959173,
-0.0093138628,
0.048023168,
-0.0415541083,
0.0375649147,
-0.0895066708,
-0.0253337938,
-0.0498916954,
-0.0431258045,
-0.0007470996,
0.0758572891,
-0.0227286052,
-0.0273951832,
0.0411934257,
-0.0237489045,
0.0198707953,
-0.0399223529,
-0.0208004359,
0.0010983477,
0.0539153069,
-0.0417934805,
-0.0539521538,
0.0274617504,
-0.1025667265,
-0.0499659032,
-0.0952182263,
0.0409034751,
2.516234738e-34,
0.0825619698,
-0.0138716307,
0.0021387187,
-0.0227064043,
0.0201180149,
0.012583171,
-0.0517672263,
0.0130634615,
0.0240390785,
-0.093614459,
0.0025078538
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06824v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06824v2 | Open the Pandora's Box of LLMs: Jailbreaking LLMs through Representation Engineering | 2024-01-12T00:50:04 | 2024-02-17T04:21:02 | Tianlong Li, Shihan Dou, Wenhao Liu, Muling Wu, Changze Lv, Xiaoqing Zheng, Xuanjing Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Jailbreaking techniques aim to probe the boundaries of safety in large
language models (LLMs) by inducing them to generate toxic responses to
malicious queries, a significant concern within the LLM community. While
existing jailbreaking methods primarily rely on prompt engineering, altering
inputs to evade LLM safety mechanisms, they suffer from low attack success
rates and significant time overheads, rendering them inflexible. To overcome
these limitations, we propose a novel jailbreaking approach, named Jailbreaking
LLMs through Representation Engineering (JRE). Our method requires only a small
number of query pairs to extract ``safety patterns'' that can be used to
circumvent the target model's defenses, achieving unprecedented jailbreaking
performance. Building upon these findings, we also introduce a novel defense
framework inspired by JRE principles, which demonstrates notable effectiveness.
Extensive experimentation confirms the superior performance of the JRE attacks
and the robustness of the JRE defense framework. We hope this study contributes
to advancing the understanding of model safety issues through the lens of
representation engineering. | [
0.0173280463,
0.1094060466,
-0.0182594117,
0.0661364123,
-0.0363092273,
-0.037385039,
-0.0190188754,
-0.0031072814,
0.0462802164,
-0.0387141369,
-0.0001253043,
-0.0075123422,
-0.0197000876,
0.0330412239,
0.0639512315,
0.0228521228,
0.0613766722,
-0.0584066063,
-0.0302206483,
-0.0058360533,
-0.0203088336,
-0.0217861403,
0.0404979028,
0.0010615925,
0.0156985037,
-0.0076371962,
-0.03643528,
0.0243467521,
-0.0072206594,
-0.0183058269,
-0.0228415355,
0.0129496958,
-0.0213962086,
0.0489931256,
0.0000021583,
-0.0292545203,
-0.0408111997,
0.0746216401,
-0.0335553847,
0.0641926005,
-0.0125915958,
-0.0462685637,
-0.0245661046,
0.0253250506,
-0.0097437771,
0.0180044547,
0.039998658,
0.0221730769,
0.0773335397,
0.0742092505,
0.0121617755,
0.000296941,
0.0472662337,
0.0134391207,
0.0157251507,
-0.0363968052,
0.0212805811,
-0.0213203598,
0.0428512953,
0.0251291189,
-0.000309918,
-0.0193086714,
-0.0144975046,
-0.0209782738,
-0.0769866183,
-0.0393042527,
-0.025696842,
0.0066864616,
0.0268059615,
0.0163419135,
-0.0164839439,
-0.0207864568,
0.0147921322,
0.0274404213,
-0.0002030421,
0.0231116768,
0.0038468128,
0.0351566225,
0.0159008093,
0.006809297,
0.0414706282,
-0.0068009226,
0.0721180439,
-0.0304034241,
-0.0295045674,
0.0476358719,
0.0369000472,
-0.0229162052,
-0.0319765769,
-0.0739743412,
-0.0212224852,
-0.0192632359,
-0.0302903559,
-0.0017572714,
-0.0020719469,
0.0227791946,
-0.056015674,
-0.0083912686,
0.0557294972,
-0.0652888119,
-0.0137489522,
0.0363649726,
0.0166543797,
0.0152860135,
0.012414895,
-0.0193015747,
-0.0456544906,
0.0457308032,
0.0102898711,
0.0196287315,
0.0061855996,
-0.0106431684,
-0.0013343667,
0.05125916,
-0.0016274689,
0.0427146479,
-0.0146721816,
0.0657766908,
-0.0462919585,
0.0577121824,
-0.0684949234,
0.013365387,
0.0285479072,
0.0305435639,
0.0372611992,
-0.0480108038,
0.0032887214,
-0.0470587984,
-0.0208373442,
-0.0958669186,
-0.0170874037,
-0.0013759858,
-0.0655858293,
-0.0291686151,
-0.0097204791,
0.1614964455,
0.0458401516,
-0.0096125267,
-0.0962127671,
-0.1106143147,
0.0092736008,
-0.0047070342,
0.0176566448,
-0.0644121692,
-0.0392157026,
-0.0150162214,
-0.0135084419,
-0.0865137801,
-0.0223520566,
-0.0207987465,
-0.0362546779,
0.0421553552,
0.0123549476,
-0.0154822133,
-0.0218964517,
0.0545464717,
0.0054399413,
0.0819792897,
0.0255276002,
0.0242432468,
0.0519269034,
0.0046565672,
0.0560784005,
0.0376156047,
-0.0064003724,
0.0419511721,
-0.0676494911,
0.0362574682,
0.0440810584,
-0.019345006,
-0.0526863784,
0.0465310588,
0.0021897978,
-0.0396959297,
0.0536931604,
0.0342667475,
-0.0454022847,
0.0578158423,
-0.0036344975,
-0.0042625135,
0.0014543161,
0.0066551636,
-0.069552727,
-0.022935411,
-0.0993373096,
-0.0164404158,
-0.0312776752,
0.0280775893,
-0.0112707792,
-0.008026232,
-0.0035232266,
-0.0116773611,
-0.0104701873,
0.0056490176,
0.002189673,
0.0245675817,
0.0108087864,
0.0796723366,
0.0141042247,
-0.0399657302,
-0.022650959,
-0.0837378725,
-0.02260831,
0.0445693769,
0.0698102266,
-0.0444662124,
-0.0154473437,
0.0105172116,
-0.0507344715,
0.0052867322,
-0.005472092,
0.0124151958,
0.0261246376,
0.0253093932,
-0.015862193,
-0.011720092,
0.0491036698,
-0.0093862303,
-0.0027380071,
-0.0208829679,
-0.0059480639,
-0.0605245307,
-0.0477018617,
0.0093489047,
-0.0105267093,
-0.0529233366,
0.0104988404,
0.0374373347,
0.0096101603,
0.0016114418,
-0.015659662,
0.0384347439,
0.0754287839,
0.03033242,
0.0229266193,
-0.0090096565,
-0.0087478505,
0.0299591515,
0.0053042634,
-0.0358935669,
0.0021765982,
0.0498162396,
-0.0284022726,
0.000690605,
0.0775535107,
-0.0425832942,
0.0369130895,
0.0272591189,
0.0305324588,
-0.0151651958,
-0.0057566348,
-0.0463544987,
-0.0122518772,
-0.0076747234,
-0.0081724674,
-0.0150643289,
-0.0159175843,
0.0094692903,
0.0018602439,
-0.0709559768,
0.0199082587,
-0.0207197051,
0.044305712,
-0.0066594025,
0.019801883,
-0.0044651888,
-0.0471851826,
-0.0145665724,
-0.0156530216,
-0.0094006313,
0.0549508259,
0.0214974172,
0.0437098108,
-0.0284894519,
-0.0247670561,
0.0042324588,
-0.0505215861,
-0.0136957616,
0.0289216973,
0.0014009199,
-0.002663756,
-0.0725802556,
-0.0004902718,
-0.0287675951,
-0.0273077134,
0.0787174031,
-0.0641620234,
0.0081646061,
-0.0224829968,
0.0114777349,
0.0011073042,
0.036876943,
-0.0075359768,
-0.0286040269,
0.0219673775,
-0.0283562448,
-0.0505272411,
0.043449901,
0.0038943803,
0.0342041217,
0.0767252296,
-0.0010270787,
-0.0261866096,
-0.0298404247,
0.0331711695,
-0.0306503884,
-0.043480102,
-0.0410558768,
0.0202982202,
0.0118796593,
0.0012385923,
-0.0282282792,
-0.0055978079,
0.0149660548,
0.0415630005,
-0.0106834807,
0.0005669151,
-0.0262229126,
-0.0193249788,
0.0099704145,
0.008865932,
-0.0647103265,
0.0527530238,
-0.0456198417,
0.0442926101,
-0.0040375632,
-0.0262849387,
-0.0146425851,
0.0432302803,
-0.0095059145,
0.0185705144,
0.0550908819,
-0.0426948518,
-0.0404880792,
-0.0142637212,
0.0404623821,
-0.0415854342,
0.0635164529,
-0.0329751968,
-0.0309534408,
-0.0135205705,
-0.0232076868,
-0.0673610792,
-0.0345188305,
-0.0036237303,
-0.0084537473,
0.0117416875,
-0.0207081847,
0.0112611093,
-0.0080749039,
0.003041469,
-0.029336907,
-0.0043196697,
-0.0166963413,
-0.0223748181,
-0.020422386,
-0.0047394773,
-0.0545102432,
-0.0003891982,
0.0011024191,
0.0508686043,
0.0775556117,
0.0442412533,
-0.0297582336,
-0.0212660581,
0.0222187582,
0.0314409174,
-0.0133065311,
-0.0104738912,
0.0451024659,
-0.0116356434,
-0.0393704735,
-0.0426722839,
0.0156613626,
0.030815864,
0.008335704,
0.0510756075,
0.0024204699,
0.0675387159,
0.0358984508,
0.0597472899,
-0.0816771612,
0.0028339485,
0.021155417,
0.0609213896,
-0.0181854758,
-0.0322843902,
-0.0227331202,
-0.0820054635,
0.0217405409,
0.0433852412,
-0.0094073648,
0.0061128093,
-0.0444638319,
-0.0174819231,
0.0091609126,
0.0369417556,
0.0184983425,
-0.0174592268,
-0.0021396226,
0.0048189191,
-0.0311005805,
-0.0029635441,
0.0185889844,
-0.0166882854,
0.0107138753,
0.0748184696,
-0.0179857984,
-0.0242529791,
0.0225460585,
0.0252377782,
0.0259368047,
-0.0080483919,
-0.0136437332,
-0.0055872793,
0.0242742468,
-0.0314320177,
0.0344403572,
0.0073226439,
-0.0141989421,
-0.0087645007,
0.0434631854,
0.0680458397,
-0.0274890587,
0.0147989672,
-0.0334041379,
-0.0568458028,
0.0153423706,
0.0361429676,
0.0114676226,
-0.0030601232,
-0.0372731872,
-0.0798133612,
-0.0442441478,
-0.0191265009,
-0.0580716953,
0.0170174278,
0.0079768272,
-0.0147820571,
-0.0096194185,
0.0354265943,
-0.0397373065,
0.0278892908,
0.0575527735,
0.0048212442,
-0.0034872089,
0.0149510801,
-0.0308449082,
-0.0189886298,
-0.0472915396,
0.0202939566,
-0.0430537947,
0.0425683223,
-0.0067118257,
-0.0017380042,
-0.0032551,
-0.0467568599,
-0.0230967905,
-0.1002362669,
0.0160508119,
0.0749666244,
0.0284951944,
-0.0115944976,
-0.0235163998,
-0.0559080876,
0.0365267284,
0.0541683212,
-0.0600379147,
0.0021975792,
0.0702288523,
-0.0420533977,
0.016155269,
0.0150154019,
-0.0524429418,
-0.0467439257,
0.0537444018,
-0.0071351328,
-0.0564851165,
-0.0038104584,
0.0011811208,
0.0714071989,
-0.0034363759,
0.0197862554,
0.015095789,
0.0569689535,
0.0510448515,
-0.0499991514,
-0.032072749,
0.0042698728,
0.0462298542,
-0.0056946496,
-0.0051367483,
0.0263058841,
0.0214725193,
0.0209641978,
0.053846363,
0.0078160875,
0.0547578,
-0.0011745183,
0.012510444,
0.0662924275,
0.0196461696,
-0.0066839531,
0.0416182391,
0.0161277335,
0.0371848047,
-0.0286778398,
0.0052417219,
-0.0007181217,
0.0243366342,
-0.0277432092,
0.0407004207,
-0.0574959964,
-0.0691818222,
0.0298517793,
0.0526000671,
-0.0182078462,
0.0171197094,
0.0063103545,
-0.0018437067,
0.0096596526,
-0.0482355021,
-0.0233749673,
-0.0089175729,
-0.0507645532,
0.0293690152,
-0.0006625319,
0.013361223,
-0.0091047743,
0.065939419,
0.0287472177,
0.0447400622,
0.0192536116,
-0.021546986,
-0.0531155504,
-0.0281419083,
0.0829120949,
0.0071779275,
-0.0438830405,
-0.0636074543,
-0.0753911063,
-0.0747079924,
-0.0285412967,
-0.005156822,
0.0208959132,
0.0007243284,
-0.027081918,
0.052266635,
0.0563531704,
0.0344702862,
-0.0904694349,
0.0020819427,
0.0163151398,
-0.0557112172,
0.0536508933,
-5.730769324e-33,
0.0172318183,
-0.0259216651,
-0.0361047499,
-0.0442810506,
0.0214379691,
-0.0230845287,
-0.0322081521,
0.0200971086,
-0.0215817485,
-0.0397227146,
-0.0108444747,
-0.0066302861,
0.0078938026,
0.0108262114,
-0.0023212419,
-0.0306981821,
-0.0094221635,
0.0167940743,
-0.0048091295,
0.0139018511,
0.0568384454,
-0.0215603299,
0.0059948512,
-0.039954517,
0.0384514965,
-0.0372062176,
-0.0265790056,
0.0339018591,
-0.0619805306,
0.0636572093,
0.0120086242,
0.0293168724,
-0.0208400115,
0.0098419087,
0.0069097942,
-0.0018185497,
-0.0095421169,
-0.0083352067,
-0.0013025878,
-0.0194942486,
0.0224385075,
-0.0600622371,
0.0367914438,
0.0033331818,
0.0205860585,
-0.0048029274,
-0.0254812445,
-0.0172719583,
-0.0056109913,
-0.0080204355,
-0.0158113688,
-0.0006770524,
-0.0432732813,
0.0389287621,
0.0328062288,
-0.0289232675,
0.0446463376,
-0.0004863649,
0.0075244079,
0.0264494922,
0.0318456329,
0.0150954882,
0.0394167304,
0.032336507,
0.0056445794,
0.0257924497,
-0.0286323223,
0.0102074947,
0.0296291746,
0.0359394625,
0.0056399899,
0.0765648261,
0.0395863727,
0.0527996682,
0.0464553796,
-0.0040707779,
-0.0666758418,
0.0234129541,
0.0097977109,
0.0206534099,
0.0169201288,
-0.0151606742,
-0.0658910945,
-0.0073528774,
-0.0174278039,
0.0240634177,
-0.0384137779,
-0.0248976983,
-0.006689724,
-0.0182115007,
-0.055795528,
-0.0410617217,
-0.0100022778,
-0.0667732358,
-0.025716424,
0.0304985512,
-0.0168745201,
-0.0423559919,
-0.0142040141,
0.0191397909,
0.0407679565,
-0.0237497035,
-0.0113213109,
-0.0667766705,
0.0208086576,
-0.0055098203,
0.0142236408,
0.0406327806,
-0.0694825873,
-0.0150310667,
-0.0241453275,
0.035460826,
0.0069097425,
-0.0128226383,
0.0176277515,
-0.0257632211,
0.0357230902,
-0.0301319677,
0.0296636801,
0.0076132067,
-0.0279952511,
0.0509336293,
-0.011494468,
0.0388025604,
0.024003353,
-0.022875376,
0.0149357421,
0.0298394021,
0.0916128606,
-0.066798009,
-0.0127213439,
0.0056140418,
3.061e-7,
0.0227547884,
-0.0210624747,
0.0273585543,
0.0310130641,
0.0225147456,
0.086289987,
-0.0120522073,
0.0617280863,
-0.0084841996,
-0.0483485982,
-0.0268634707,
-0.020613879,
0.0357171968,
0.0306072142,
-0.0603904799,
0.0308698975,
-0.0420176685,
-0.013966253,
-0.0356506929,
-0.0260421988,
0.0518928915,
0.0562534668,
-0.0128105925,
-0.0400921293,
-0.0244431924,
-0.0553031862,
0.0016562343,
-0.0061106854,
-0.0059744464,
0.0124590797,
0.0099646328,
0.0231486969,
0.0376289152,
0.006061743,
-0.0428653918,
-0.0144571355,
-0.0641841665,
0.038006112,
0.0197260212,
-0.0183002613,
-0.0218432192,
-0.0796306208,
-0.0096923709,
-0.0028193775,
0.0700061619,
0.0474443249,
-0.0249825772,
-0.0192891899,
-0.0044156499,
-0.0560635068,
-0.0085088518,
-0.0304086953,
-0.0198168941,
0.0109564997,
0.0159078036,
-0.0120567903,
0.0550186783,
-0.043163944,
-0.0329122506,
-0.0045567667,
-0.0173514839,
-0.0329040065,
0.0268072654,
0.0512546562,
0.0257046521,
0.0025002419,
0.0021397108,
3.465717341e-34,
0.0075336983,
-0.0468784831,
0.022974005,
0.0378165506,
0.0429879427,
-0.0173997208,
-0.0184643976,
0.0103536788,
0.0122413309,
-0.0189372636,
-0.057439588
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06310v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06310v2 | ViSAGe: A Global-Scale Analysis of Visual Stereotypes in Text-to-Image Generation | 2024-01-12T00:43:57 | 2024-02-22T20:35:02 | Akshita Jha, Vinodkumar Prabhakaran, Remi Denton, Sarah Laszlo, Shachi Dave, Rida Qadri, Chandan K. Reddy, Sunipa Dev | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.CY | Recent studies have shown that Text-to-Image (T2I) model generations can
reflect social stereotypes present in the real world. However, existing
approaches for evaluating stereotypes have a noticeable lack of coverage of
global identity groups and their associated stereotypes. To address this gap,
we introduce the ViSAGe (Visual Stereotypes Around the Globe) dataset to enable
the evaluation of known nationality-based stereotypes in T2I models, across 135
nationalities. We enrich an existing textual stereotype resource by
distinguishing between stereotypical associations that are more likely to have
visual depictions, such as `sombrero', from those that are less visually
concrete, such as 'attractive'. We demonstrate ViSAGe's utility through a
multi-faceted evaluation of T2I generations. First, we show that stereotypical
attributes in ViSAGe are thrice as likely to be present in generated images of
corresponding identities as compared to other attributes, and that the
offensiveness of these depictions is especially higher for identities from
Africa, South America, and South East Asia. Second, we assess the stereotypical
pull of visual depictions of identity groups, which reveals how the 'default'
representations of all identity groups in ViSAGe have a pull towards
stereotypical depictions, and that this pull is even more prominent for
identity groups from the Global South. CONTENT WARNING: Some examples contain
offensive stereotypes. | [
0.0243866425,
0.0978472754,
-0.0244063344,
-0.013121346,
0.0269322284,
0.0630063862,
0.0731692314,
-0.0259063207,
0.0395246372,
-0.0625452101,
-0.0217517763,
-0.060558144,
0.064365387,
0.0272396915,
0.0531774983,
-0.0756169334,
0.0064892201,
0.0490538627,
-0.0146484105,
-0.0372722931,
-0.002640994,
0.0624205433,
0.0191618875,
0.0473699532,
-0.0704510212,
-0.0246078335,
0.0722219795,
-0.0042160498,
0.0284561291,
-0.0199831948,
0.0276768245,
0.0338046849,
-0.0138392569,
-0.00369064,
0.0000019949,
-0.0609058961,
0.0314033963,
0.0093828663,
0.04457286,
0.0267437473,
0.0718173087,
-0.0130242798,
-0.0088046016,
0.0099058989,
-0.0188360661,
0.0078760879,
0.0629253536,
0.0249158572,
0.0294761192,
-0.0051652594,
-0.0067499704,
-0.0511874147,
-0.0841759667,
-0.0105677275,
0.0131607968,
0.0377493538,
0.0255517792,
-0.0353100188,
-0.0940078497,
-0.0300295856,
-0.0058100708,
0.0049625062,
-0.0114277825,
0.0401035212,
0.0223251656,
0.0287938546,
-0.0445548892,
-0.0516919494,
0.0284382273,
0.0401102155,
0.0309352204,
-0.0055549257,
-0.0253632795,
0.026323529,
-0.008662994,
-0.0041533513,
0.0372530594,
0.0337164253,
-0.0210771058,
0.0051237401,
-0.0624762513,
0.0220350549,
-0.0124464696,
-0.00341232,
-0.0180589035,
-0.0095468815,
0.0129465377,
0.0194665082,
-0.0196786374,
0.0148853511,
-0.0289338902,
-0.0431542657,
0.0028196005,
0.0051958235,
0.0180650372,
-0.0079007093,
-0.0191046186,
-0.0344266295,
0.013086291,
-0.0454965346,
0.0219590124,
0.040495351,
-0.0379790999,
-0.0022961728,
-0.0024555523,
0.0489889495,
0.0113689266,
-0.0192899238,
-0.0101845451,
-0.026059676,
-0.0103409383,
-0.0217011329,
0.0517475717,
-0.0305367168,
0.0439304076,
0.0424733944,
-0.0702849925,
-0.0440173186,
-0.0622564107,
0.0050969687,
-0.0321566463,
0.0592236891,
-0.0435993075,
-0.0024836815,
-0.0774999484,
0.0091780806,
-0.0282694977,
-0.0125041306,
-0.0759197846,
-0.0548349768,
0.0372372381,
-0.0157749914,
-0.0085869385,
-0.0118093751,
0.0136581818,
0.0491114371,
-0.0201092791,
-0.0090467623,
-0.0342944674,
-0.0135402232,
-0.0341302715,
-0.034860272,
0.0259780809,
-0.0509754196,
0.017015513,
-0.0015429078,
0.0227934998,
-0.0807379559,
-0.0052705295,
0.0343985558,
-0.0268370789,
0.0359428711,
0.0562542677,
0.0058080801,
0.0308269747,
0.0385184139,
-0.042433124,
0.0595131367,
0.0034500065,
0.0509723127,
0.0124360407,
-0.013710524,
-0.0208637509,
0.0385780521,
0.0394517668,
0.0200214852,
-0.0470847562,
0.016984148,
0.0200681984,
-0.0156562906,
0.0588171817,
0.0210362282,
0.0077984701,
-0.0001297479,
0.0595272966,
0.0337277241,
-0.03407849,
0.0520883389,
0.0488265343,
0.0124735842,
-0.0381018445,
0.0010371375,
-0.0531606749,
0.013665258,
0.0296446681,
-0.0290532187,
-0.0251845643,
0.1496838927,
-0.0295101199,
-0.0034299139,
0.0263834875,
0.0318539552,
0.0185113419,
-0.0348419622,
-0.0094101932,
0.0625966787,
0.0106952759,
0.0300759338,
0.027604593,
-0.0172540899,
-0.0146511616,
-0.0230149273,
0.0293302387,
0.0303207319,
0.00712161,
0.0470373221,
0.03635763,
-0.030631341,
-0.0018259584,
0.0595607013,
-0.0091675697,
0.0135522028,
0.0018490274,
-0.0104716867,
0.0007960788,
0.0204443261,
-0.0020396668,
0.0652636215,
0.0496010445,
0.0771070793,
0.0381282419,
0.0045848521,
-0.0271583684,
0.003712296,
-0.001652891,
0.0012325168,
-0.0041940901,
0.0479419939,
0.0185604095,
0.0023172863,
-0.0485127792,
-0.033700522,
-0.0361362323,
-0.0161073878,
0.0057050604,
0.0986555517,
-0.074652493,
0.0049410993,
0.008587935,
-0.1216792837,
-0.0522096194,
0.0124909868,
0.0028149611,
0.0296978895,
0.0462316684,
0.0081072496,
-0.0090616196,
-0.0101890163,
-0.0460623093,
-0.0293236095,
0.0439377204,
0.0394189395,
0.0485405736,
-0.0015647762,
-0.0411546119,
0.02209468,
-0.0421206802,
0.0245073624,
0.0290460866,
-0.0114340009,
-0.014650098,
0.0027496961,
-0.0049711429,
-0.0141753005,
0.0119866906,
-0.0382075086,
0.017966805,
-0.059743043,
0.0001554763,
0.0244732052,
-0.0456975251,
-0.0016909487,
-0.0067350138,
-0.0216005426,
-0.0148327071,
-0.0763056725,
-0.0165399071,
-0.0313534811,
0.0288043562,
-0.0064321463,
-0.0387929603,
0.0119318618,
-0.0095522171,
0.0061816876,
-0.0177094992,
0.0923557281,
0.0140233422,
-0.0068716877,
-0.0226716977,
-0.0115279648,
-0.0794676393,
0.0067574834,
-0.0029786706,
-0.0497170091,
0.0278854333,
0.0723966435,
0.0479345545,
0.0419011675,
0.0623970963,
-0.0160914827,
0.0219176486,
-0.0088386098,
-0.0150857652,
-0.0331962444,
-0.00076665,
0.0259352569,
0.0490398444,
-0.1392802894,
-0.0193794873,
0.040671695,
0.0328258015,
0.0074484521,
-0.0532734692,
0.0655468479,
-0.0149573339,
-0.0560784787,
-0.0286297873,
-0.0111292554,
0.0194298476,
0.0316762999,
-0.0379850902,
-0.047538951,
0.0429956168,
0.0013016665,
0.0199092776,
0.0491191559,
0.0356783979,
0.0028284795,
0.0340576433,
0.0302644782,
0.0476035513,
0.0605193079,
0.0255185347,
-0.0387644842,
-0.0248352457,
0.0509690121,
-0.0136043001,
0.0124208368,
-0.0130812777,
-0.0367986895,
-0.0154966107,
-0.0234379321,
-0.0283148848,
-0.0202959757,
-0.019818278,
-0.0396287739,
0.0042062011,
-0.0286444705,
0.0004021136,
0.0015988559,
0.0168543961,
-0.0286143273,
-0.0176117849,
-0.003228562,
0.0368342437,
-0.0172602031,
0.0167004187,
-0.0253734943,
0.0133814048,
-0.0029492946,
0.0032293014,
0.0306806434,
-0.0826185793,
-0.0038831402,
-0.0298776384,
0.0236196611,
-0.0023960394,
0.0465320647,
-0.0003000245,
-0.0447279029,
0.0565663762,
0.0183299426,
0.0146564301,
0.0416636541,
-0.0027980076,
-0.0220984314,
0.0006787822,
0.0553058349,
0.0385045186,
0.014516226,
0.0033288246,
-0.0811025724,
0.0188454445,
-0.0200389717,
0.0197092704,
-0.0751061887,
-0.0249271356,
-0.0300795827,
-0.0833511725,
0.0355961882,
0.015347695,
-0.037532527,
-0.0181818977,
0.0442491844,
0.0137722334,
0.0020657026,
0.0102051888,
-0.0174043383,
0.0162972473,
0.0183687303,
-0.0155779906,
-0.0556908809,
-0.0159238297,
0.0283588972,
0.0007263185,
-0.0134136965,
-0.011135635,
0.0311390311,
0.048331514,
-0.0404032096,
-0.0217375606,
-0.0216244701,
0.0051106438,
-0.0303207375,
0.0777581707,
-0.0164481476,
-0.0338022895,
-0.0386069156,
0.0106000351,
0.0381172113,
0.0124840206,
0.0009706599,
0.0096666478,
0.0232976992,
-0.0342767499,
-0.0520654358,
0.0026885713,
-0.0291430335,
0.0558198504,
0.0363246314,
-0.0335181765,
0.0211331472,
-0.0504619181,
0.0284344964,
-0.0687966943,
-0.0956038758,
0.0444162562,
-0.0415768176,
-0.0602303296,
-0.0399769992,
-0.027484566,
0.0115910675,
-0.003982529,
0.012499203,
-0.0880317613,
-0.0257143043,
-0.0160206798,
-0.0520367362,
0.0111539103,
-0.0272257477,
0.0228011124,
0.0571235642,
-0.022555789,
0.0381854959,
-0.0414866917,
-0.0034684213,
0.0279074274,
-0.0447898433,
-0.0163370036,
0.0115005672,
0.04870883,
0.0141706048,
0.0209936928,
0.0256323442,
-0.0293833278,
0.10707286,
0.0594527125,
0.0540910922,
0.0210764799,
-0.0442284085,
0.0541303717,
0.0033115314,
0.0195999499,
-0.0045096627,
0.0609107204,
0.0171337221,
-0.0731071308,
-0.0200611018,
0.0000970186,
-0.0167034939,
-0.0171994474,
-0.0152970655,
-0.049854286,
0.004150636,
-0.0267539285,
-0.0336990692,
-0.0204411093,
-0.0379441194,
-0.0045646653,
-0.0276567694,
0.0088147288,
0.017424142,
-0.0061463681,
-0.0045674639,
-0.0354581662,
0.0518163741,
-0.0489059053,
-0.0178996325,
0.0563302785,
0.0417092256,
0.0047829053,
0.0259278342,
0.0020932748,
-0.0170265995,
-0.0518512838,
0.031203175,
-0.0088364985,
0.0464531071,
0.028980881,
-0.0000189008,
-0.0063808151,
0.0107151093,
0.0286609214,
-0.0175758619,
-0.0257249456,
-0.0293515939,
0.0352821648,
-0.0227564964,
0.0483566672,
0.0105607975,
-0.0205484908,
0.0377291851,
0.0285855103,
-0.0000333525,
-0.0486255586,
0.0427056849,
-0.0365477614,
-0.0011304931,
-0.0015404682,
0.0461788289,
-0.01630635,
0.0118107414,
0.0338696092,
-0.0839876309,
-0.0248285886,
0.0028261074,
0.0366372056,
-0.0588837825,
0.0285450984,
-0.0141294869,
-0.0865391493,
-0.0808022469,
0.0184306763,
-0.0181490425,
0.0118559366,
0.0354412533,
0.0303087085,
0.019480506,
0.0032669564,
-0.0151388505,
0.0165647883,
0.0143010514,
-0.0632385761,
-0.0017783664,
0.0041452176,
-6.079676986e-33,
-0.0342423283,
-0.0266113151,
-0.006186882,
-0.0317854173,
-0.0403033048,
-0.0116052227,
-0.0231531095,
-0.0235427208,
-0.0058893096,
0.0400946401,
0.0212804805,
-0.005208117,
0.0037674506,
-0.0035546024,
0.0074448208,
0.0352573656,
0.0682611465,
0.0075589404,
-0.0551565066,
-0.001256756,
0.0368566513,
-0.0066654426,
0.0480915681,
-0.0786319971,
-0.0034692218,
-0.0110657075,
-0.0518586636,
-0.0444138087,
0.0639085621,
0.0257448442,
-0.034495499,
0.0653983504,
0.032213334,
0.0076965098,
0.0120421937,
0.0498655327,
-0.039671585,
-0.03000395,
-0.0108109647,
0.010773031,
0.0117214322,
-0.0239215586,
-0.0090250596,
-0.0005156258,
-0.0175941065,
-0.0244947225,
0.0767973885,
-0.0271314923,
0.0487617366,
-0.0064781904,
-0.027318161,
-0.0175658651,
-0.023768317,
0.0106766298,
-0.0331664495,
0.0676210746,
0.0263032541,
0.0425850898,
-0.0660802722,
0.0365700945,
-0.0058140331,
-0.0400488786,
0.0490870886,
0.0347770825,
0.0409835316,
0.0520181581,
0.0285882372,
0.0312015545,
-0.0323144048,
-0.0256980993,
0.0352491215,
-0.0169284642,
-0.0051260064,
0.0986196697,
0.0297327284,
-0.0739419162,
-0.0000922942,
0.0079294275,
0.0319951773,
-0.0136844851,
0.0118490346,
-0.0173140448,
-0.0306670982,
-0.0299557019,
-0.0187951345,
-0.0702861175,
-0.0186727811,
-0.0594939664,
0.0222457647,
-0.0283548627,
-0.0270397905,
0.0514828824,
0.0278580394,
-0.0096649071,
-0.0210451446,
-0.0099632302,
-0.0544881932,
-0.0104301441,
0.0145997191,
-0.0211212374,
-0.0382556617,
0.0070740203,
0.0245361812,
0.0869786665,
0.0335539691,
0.0142329102,
0.041478496,
-0.0081447745,
-0.0708840638,
-0.0018244511,
-0.0196834244,
0.0089478036,
-0.0126582645,
-0.0156269576,
0.0053502135,
0.0135579892,
-0.040632017,
-0.0620465539,
0.0294017699,
0.0013395707,
-0.0366846099,
0.0069225426,
-0.0151348114,
0.0432601199,
-0.039495863,
0.0017295858,
-0.0445986763,
-0.0097837429,
0.0566653125,
-0.055736877,
-0.0281968489,
-0.0400196165,
2.52e-7,
-0.0168359131,
0.0129790381,
-0.0164424181,
0.0464367867,
0.0698537454,
0.0628193915,
0.0394346565,
0.0025988854,
0.0479855053,
-0.0286080092,
-0.0517961569,
0.0213838797,
0.024995368,
0.0677468255,
0.0024066269,
0.0299076587,
-0.0262081195,
0.0118716322,
-0.0200876817,
-0.0008608449,
0.0314991847,
0.0380813926,
-0.0001724064,
-0.0251604561,
-0.0229588412,
-0.0262170881,
0.0667737722,
-0.0339560024,
-0.0045908634,
-0.0342335962,
-0.0230361242,
0.0161543377,
0.0212669559,
0.0125011001,
0.0109260138,
0.003874107,
-0.0020478,
-0.0423073582,
-0.0051720031,
0.0442685261,
-0.0008870871,
0.0316782519,
-0.016467033,
-0.0824764669,
0.0441274345,
-0.0077304966,
-0.0340245664,
-0.0239624698,
-0.0383827351,
0.0241433121,
0.0407264866,
-0.0259630922,
-0.0376752093,
0.0081428001,
0.0400493108,
-0.0010780455,
0.0064102565,
-0.0461714342,
-0.0117462091,
-0.0068430733,
-0.0021779474,
-0.0255926512,
-0.0260472503,
0.0229463484,
-0.0088673281,
-0.0048552398,
0.0284079444,
2.113052574e-34,
-0.0093469787,
-0.0147522176,
0.0274805129,
-0.0410215929,
0.0374569036,
-0.0284755751,
0.0154736442,
-0.0525516346,
0.0376939848,
-0.0215628836,
-0.0029686082
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06301v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06301v1 | Misconfidence-based Demonstration Selection for LLM In-Context Learning | 2024-01-12T00:11:24 | 2024-01-12T00:11:24 | Shangqing Xu, Chao Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | In-context learning with large language models (LLMs) excels at adapting to
various tasks rapidly. However, its success hinges on carefully selecting
demonstrations, which remains an obstacle in practice. Current approaches to
this problem either rely on hard-to-acquire external supervision or require
frequent interactions with LLMs, resulting in high costs. We propose a new
method called In-Context Reflection (ICR) to overcome these challenges. ICR
strategically selects demonstrations to reduce the discrepancy between the
LLM's outputs and the actual input-output mappings. Specifically, ICR starts
with a random set of initial demonstrations, then iteratively refines it. In
each step, it analyzes a pool of candidate examples and identifies the ones
most likely to challenge the LLM's current understanding, measured by a new
metric called misconfidence. These most confusing examples are then selected to
replace the less informative demonstrations in the current set. Our
comprehensive evaluation across five diverse datasets encompassing 13 subtasks
shows the efficacy of ICR. Compared to existing methods, ICR achieves an
average performance boost of 4%, while demonstrating remarkable cross-task
generalization capabilities. | [
-0.0040313327,
0.0440112874,
-0.0018415008,
0.0389270037,
-0.0352112129,
0.0144715291,
-0.002084953,
-0.0081364401,
0.0114042219,
-0.0347927436,
-0.0601170771,
-0.0388335064,
0.0031255942,
-0.0416579358,
0.0485770963,
-0.0344352946,
0.0268448256,
-0.0472313054,
-0.0491544344,
0.0060110833,
-0.0298820883,
0.0000899713,
-0.0240048133,
0.0425417647,
-0.008570062,
-0.0252164062,
-0.0002512492,
0.0282801688,
0.002338852,
-0.0545481555,
0.0179986246,
0.0300692078,
0.061504811,
0.0131147038,
0.0000023247,
-0.0535601415,
-0.0260336883,
-0.0100559006,
-0.024982838,
0.0124306548,
0.0474245101,
0.0024290807,
-0.0109120458,
0.0390772745,
-0.0482073538,
-0.0053012162,
-0.0001646602,
0.0358329117,
0.0275836047,
0.0831946209,
0.0145772286,
0.038324859,
-0.0577591993,
-0.0269276462,
0.0253618062,
-0.0647316426,
0.0302162524,
-0.0036720629,
0.0139294593,
-0.0205058213,
-0.036813546,
0.0064533823,
0.0208031815,
-0.0114320796,
-0.0315680057,
0.0126247415,
-0.0264334958,
0.0098619433,
-0.0306750108,
0.0474465452,
-0.0218548495,
-0.0345928594,
-0.0038976995,
-0.0221382864,
0.0196294114,
0.0424171612,
-0.0648465231,
0.0073116836,
0.0115782497,
0.0356701091,
-0.0088886507,
0.0249375068,
0.0325516835,
0.0099212471,
-0.0219371822,
0.0381746292,
-0.025836166,
-0.0421770588,
0.0348982066,
0.0183560438,
-0.0253226515,
-0.0526970923,
-0.0438894965,
0.0386724696,
-0.0700352341,
0.0329551995,
-0.0578445904,
-0.0523550622,
-0.0030278827,
0.0078289509,
0.0636528954,
0.0392376259,
-0.0056662834,
0.0467696413,
-0.0317077264,
0.0617531314,
0.0250838567,
0.0457191989,
-0.0369770899,
-0.0154564679,
-0.0269224998,
0.0323339291,
-0.0377456993,
0.0054016062,
-0.0126899062,
-0.0087791625,
-0.0375328176,
0.038083721,
-0.0524700545,
0.0312784463,
0.0070381807,
-0.010837025,
-0.0467794165,
-0.0115049127,
-0.0125789642,
-0.0053193858,
0.0452702679,
0.0287016239,
-0.0001271109,
-0.0630286336,
-0.039339941,
0.0189732555,
-0.0201302189,
-0.007870188,
0.0157839451,
0.1084258035,
-0.0227889102,
-0.0701589063,
-0.0411449745,
0.0130636953,
0.0090824766,
-0.0495620519,
0.0096994685,
-0.0600815527,
-0.0174762253,
-0.0070183263,
0.0140291443,
-0.0340302661,
0.0154368551,
0.0021181433,
0.0144856311,
0.06205751,
0.0173660312,
0.0300085451,
0.0188975334,
0.0152240358,
-0.0881435797,
0.0822280049,
0.0176370963,
0.0068188347,
0.0138319647,
0.0293341335,
0.067290917,
0.0408217311,
0.0419450253,
0.0445923619,
-0.0257677026,
0.0090283873,
0.026531484,
0.0225435589,
0.0370788798,
0.0116099427,
-0.0165775251,
0.0630796552,
0.0729277283,
0.0511089116,
-0.0246426705,
-0.0288775824,
0.0292141065,
0.0290582962,
0.0268560462,
-0.0196491312,
-0.0744624436,
0.0235919207,
-0.0066373139,
-0.0077414089,
0.0056719072,
0.0029691905,
-0.0100505855,
-0.0264395103,
-0.0089007886,
-0.0051013529,
0.0078695668,
0.0635462627,
0.0552733615,
0.0313882157,
-0.0896329507,
0.0204672683,
0.0084041283,
-0.0118782604,
0.0079065692,
-0.0625321195,
0.0227080919,
0.0401875749,
0.0304891933,
-0.0538488775,
-0.0179381892,
-0.0226866025,
0.0872151703,
0.0206295922,
0.0298854169,
-0.0285015982,
-0.0141515937,
-0.0426335111,
-0.0309059639,
-0.0235201363,
0.0266910456,
-0.0172822382,
0.0536591969,
0.0178919323,
-0.0079094414,
-0.0772673041,
-0.0267313179,
0.0366107039,
-0.0342171006,
-0.0511769056,
0.0072761136,
-0.0055313231,
0.0287578441,
-0.0230745319,
0.0106144911,
0.0094334846,
0.0431065559,
-0.0018058583,
0.0154112484,
0.0171549208,
-0.0448152274,
-0.0819329992,
0.0043851403,
-0.0366760343,
-0.0534444712,
-0.0134230666,
-0.0739484355,
-0.0283917524,
-0.0255414322,
-0.0216600727,
0.0747447312,
-0.0109839309,
0.0278366283,
-0.0143834511,
-0.0212779604,
-0.0199218076,
0.0407396927,
-0.030110253,
0.0017319537,
0.0508301891,
0.0148313381,
-0.0402225032,
-0.0477117449,
-0.0002634716,
-0.0380562358,
-0.0125321485,
0.0280680452,
-0.0234579854,
0.0218494534,
-0.0378613062,
-0.0144912824,
-0.0727538243,
-0.0151335225,
-0.0423535742,
0.0230500326,
0.0062058661,
-0.032919921,
-0.02336118,
-0.0302230436,
-0.0020267237,
-0.015611656,
-0.0071466528,
0.0051697628,
0.015371073,
0.0058959699,
0.0021961057,
-0.0174446013,
0.0344623476,
0.010656368,
0.045464661,
-0.0437380001,
0.0222018771,
-0.0760470182,
0.0659955069,
0.0364074074,
0.0218869317,
-0.0504517071,
0.0103929071,
0.0159210227,
-0.0100118089,
-0.0075821048,
0.0333108604,
-0.0127881067,
0.0375945494,
0.0426447168,
0.0002375286,
-0.0623580143,
0.0071239918,
0.0161214564,
-0.0243756697,
-0.0610890463,
-0.0014807564,
0.0021667676,
0.0162620675,
0.0086260801,
0.0008559831,
-0.0312053338,
0.0191533696,
-0.0298518483,
-0.0355025493,
-0.0237603094,
-0.0165912379,
-0.0221116748,
0.0198069364,
-0.0204610135,
-0.0655964538,
0.0582233481,
-0.0083007095,
0.007865781,
-0.0279227924,
-0.0135958688,
-0.0154083949,
0.0369678698,
-0.0426942147,
-0.018542638,
-0.0075611169,
-0.0212846305,
-0.0787360966,
-0.0142521765,
0.0046523372,
-0.0420375429,
0.0958868265,
-0.0868887082,
0.0017399377,
0.012188361,
-0.0506283827,
-0.0633583069,
-0.0231636278,
0.0001563632,
-0.0063670371,
-0.0486968532,
-0.0012492179,
-0.0245732311,
-0.0413312875,
0.0284843706,
0.0253608357,
0.0094050942,
-0.0130650522,
0.0007288115,
-0.0319562852,
0.0109899407,
0.0287035704,
0.0232258383,
-0.0736974925,
-0.0064922078,
0.0269354973,
0.0891232342,
-0.0122851944,
-0.0151753398,
-0.0142388726,
0.0330035724,
-0.0088634277,
0.0148442592,
0.0566331521,
0.0874893442,
-0.068657428,
-0.0181550737,
0.110503681,
-0.0007486004,
-0.0571338199,
0.0315063708,
0.0022193985,
-0.0145193487,
0.0514386669,
0.0358293466,
-0.0420453586,
-0.0372998379,
0.0197419822,
0.0543235652,
0.0017262412,
-0.023598969,
-0.0035115837,
-0.1574533433,
0.0590472482,
0.0276630968,
-0.0555448718,
-0.0058561121,
-0.0360867456,
0.0308206156,
-0.017707726,
0.0567357875,
0.0002567308,
-0.0333519429,
-0.0051724063,
0.0411686152,
0.0027148575,
-0.1261860579,
0.010953323,
-0.0178591385,
0.0289928503,
0.0035704914,
-0.0000956051,
0.0044190087,
-0.0212419704,
0.0486334413,
0.0123350527,
0.0206877012,
-0.0194467064,
0.0367210619,
0.0107320026,
-0.0061124051,
0.0234117508,
0.0615869872,
-0.0327782035,
-0.0252783056,
-0.0075897882,
0.0835318565,
-0.0240837839,
0.0172737762,
0.0087838164,
-0.0594353415,
0.0866384208,
0.0728177354,
0.0318786539,
-0.0384091809,
-0.0033767191,
-0.0179431997,
-0.0250170883,
-0.0008928948,
0.0126485014,
0.0335993245,
0.0150253335,
0.0321965106,
-0.0326791033,
-0.014381974,
0.0458286889,
0.0556236804,
0.0109209754,
0.0199160501,
-0.0232841708,
0.0074048005,
-0.0463459082,
0.0298827197,
-0.0088950098,
0.0503684431,
-0.0292903595,
0.0070306384,
0.0341559649,
-0.0299447346,
-0.0102874171,
0.0141462963,
-0.0832461789,
-0.0622554421,
-0.017658053,
0.0619929321,
0.0152016459,
0.0633662194,
0.0055350754,
-0.0287675522,
0.0889393166,
0.0240636859,
0.0088049294,
0.0373384021,
0.0482601188,
0.0325133838,
-0.0072697704,
0.0516599827,
-0.0474317558,
-0.0260702707,
0.0400568508,
0.0399716459,
-0.033848919,
-0.0183320194,
0.007228557,
-0.0321573317,
0.0612700097,
-0.0279001184,
-0.0028573025,
-0.0322548337,
0.030918071,
0.0011967773,
-0.0169038549,
-0.034822043,
-0.0023190363,
0.0174047295,
-0.0138608236,
0.0059914528,
0.0088442275,
0.0147985984,
0.0266138166,
-0.032435216,
0.0377594903,
0.0112031102,
-0.0157953501,
0.0406857766,
0.032231003,
-0.0102316961,
-0.0098972628,
0.0115753347,
0.0144781629,
0.0169784985,
0.0591237731,
0.0284302607,
-0.0085557327,
-0.0028399413,
0.0043724929,
-0.0399932489,
-0.044515077,
-0.0445342138,
0.0617142469,
0.0474086665,
-0.0214137267,
0.0568312071,
-0.0406495593,
0.0125476988,
-0.0108324951,
0.0169104189,
-0.0353403091,
-0.0183766261,
0.0397897772,
0.012727811,
0.0124403592,
0.0321903266,
0.0924861282,
-0.0117260227,
0.0515300371,
-0.0161308572,
0.0117149949,
-0.0419839807,
-0.0274425279,
0.0967231467,
0.0256247595,
0.0013604222,
0.0040093805,
-0.0512559675,
-0.0747770667,
-0.0113424873,
0.0047481074,
-0.0450416915,
-0.051006671,
0.0413238965,
0.0602539629,
-0.0202934481,
0.011945365,
-0.0261506476,
-0.0449003875,
0.0323651023,
-0.0550624318,
-0.0290761925,
-6.456427701e-33,
-0.0061960914,
-0.0593705401,
0.01810674,
0.0016887721,
-0.0106666852,
0.0104268352,
-0.0364020616,
0.002623535,
0.0168897156,
0.0092892796,
-0.0382533334,
-0.0002833115,
0.0181753654,
0.0276903547,
0.039885737,
0.0051781628,
0.0489214323,
-0.0073364987,
-0.025072962,
-0.0076589435,
0.010383565,
0.0485839024,
0.0862242132,
-0.0890126452,
0.03287201,
0.011610914,
-0.0304908063,
0.0240754522,
-0.01250384,
0.0342714898,
-0.0008284686,
0.0395156145,
0.0013884702,
-0.047037039,
-0.0315683968,
-0.0121675599,
-0.0221450608,
-0.0419465713,
-0.0163671449,
0.0302817002,
-0.0202340949,
0.0023426376,
0.0361530297,
-0.0167178381,
-0.0425512083,
0.0210872609,
0.0064121131,
-0.012791411,
-0.0287812501,
0.0092278589,
-0.0394335352,
0.0055964803,
0.0157433115,
-0.0491908975,
0.0136253517,
0.0129500786,
-0.0186367687,
-0.0402424075,
-0.06481684,
0.0023513415,
0.0053827474,
0.0096342722,
0.0901224688,
0.0196083542,
0.0181144886,
0.0551556908,
-0.0092256879,
0.0393845849,
0.0406199507,
-0.0609228276,
0.0198868737,
0.0491909049,
0.0040921867,
0.0678091198,
0.0499455854,
0.0279534217,
-0.0628925338,
0.0334725119,
0.0186931472,
0.0206287429,
0.0437987186,
0.0349256359,
-0.063036494,
-0.020594487,
-0.0316321999,
0.0222031455,
0.0059250002,
-0.0182068013,
0.0357934199,
0.0390116647,
-0.0335663445,
-0.0015330042,
0.0273550395,
-0.0528373905,
-0.051237423,
-0.007776266,
-0.0164665934,
0.0199582055,
0.0018413921,
-0.0097109759,
-0.0628081113,
-0.0613411069,
0.0164844375,
0.0178606007,
0.028705461,
0.0008126862,
0.0287023019,
0.044491984,
-0.0642409548,
0.012137414,
-0.0381914377,
0.0062980759,
0.0250047296,
-0.0094022099,
0.0453620106,
-0.0034767352,
-0.0186071545,
0.0271761082,
-0.0185578912,
-0.0701591447,
0.0179185886,
0.0126741575,
-0.0266781226,
-0.0123233283,
-0.0268526487,
-0.0124723883,
-0.0089727072,
-0.0043394142,
0.0279020723,
-0.0263065547,
0.0054538734,
0.0340370312,
3.015e-7,
0.0051325606,
0.0408533439,
-0.0326824486,
0.0294213425,
0.0370751396,
0.0341393165,
-0.0611191355,
0.0200634077,
-0.0143620856,
-0.0368685685,
0.035888765,
0.030281892,
0.0756489486,
0.0489911214,
-0.0917558521,
-0.0381753594,
-0.0206195042,
0.0098765902,
-0.0169142149,
-0.0054970747,
0.0062291697,
0.0756818503,
0.0103397463,
-0.0129674738,
-0.015201902,
-0.0348402262,
0.0870188922,
-0.045296777,
0.0167353768,
0.0077598225,
0.0011488111,
0.0382449217,
-0.0108113959,
0.0240192413,
-0.0226680469,
0.0086880419,
-0.0081421221,
0.0361989513,
0.0088721188,
-0.0290524401,
-0.0092345467,
0.0117838904,
0.0124703543,
-0.0476822481,
0.0284172539,
-0.1043337658,
-0.0013902456,
-0.0151420766,
0.0459991582,
-0.0518171825,
0.0162448101,
0.0002238183,
0.0063277436,
0.0050967694,
0.015520284,
0.0081489123,
-0.0442551114,
-0.0537607521,
-0.0015582095,
0.0118029136,
-0.0477990322,
-0.038432762,
-0.0265028011,
0.0224028211,
-0.0131558124,
-0.0579391085,
0.0162010137,
2.838302053e-34,
0.0137441354,
-0.0161419827,
0.0021911599,
0.0369884856,
-0.0068514142,
0.0023287977,
-0.0330561809,
0.0192671791,
0.018227065,
-0.0315974914,
-0.0175580624
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2402.05939v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2402.05939v1 | Uncertainty Awareness of Large Language Models Under Code Distribution Shifts: A Benchmark Study | 2024-01-12T00:00:32 | 2024-01-12T00:00:32 | Yufei Li, Simin Chen, Yanghong Guo, Wei Yang, Yue Dong, Cong Liu | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.CL, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) have been widely employed in programming
language analysis to enhance human productivity. Yet, their reliability can be
compromised by various code distribution shifts, leading to inconsistent
outputs. While probabilistic methods are known to mitigate such impact through
uncertainty calibration and estimation, their efficacy in the language domain
remains underexplored compared to their application in image-based tasks. In
this work, we first introduce a large-scale benchmark dataset, incorporating
three realistic patterns of code distribution shifts at varying intensities.
Then we thoroughly investigate state-of-the-art probabilistic methods applied
to CodeLlama using these shifted code snippets. We observe that these methods
generally improve the uncertainty awareness of CodeLlama, with increased
calibration quality and higher uncertainty estimation~(UE) precision. However,
our study further reveals varied performance dynamics across different criteria
(e.g., calibration error vs misclassification detection) and trade-off between
efficacy and efficiency, highlighting necessary methodological selection
tailored to specific contexts. | [
0.00345023,
0.1016711295,
-0.0322956219,
0.0405384004,
-0.0134444544,
0.0076841665,
-0.0234544985,
0.0096694352,
-0.0469594039,
-0.0041563683,
-0.0049440553,
-0.0365284309,
0.0739862099,
0.0069177151,
0.0430043079,
0.0064226827,
0.0433805399,
-0.0735492855,
-0.0134588303,
0.0301392041,
-0.0051954752,
-0.0210947823,
0.0217830595,
0.0552036315,
-0.0202428643,
-0.0165298581,
0.0307632815,
0.0569792427,
0.0134657463,
-0.0088586379,
-0.0055449954,
0.0555124246,
-0.0007074432,
0.0308644865,
0.000002028,
-0.0016926561,
0.002584263,
0.0076797595,
0.0019766488,
0.0789500773,
0.0498751365,
-0.0125242556,
-0.0478100963,
0.0165918861,
0.0047439672,
0.0230887961,
0.1012245268,
-0.0984563231,
-0.0152937816,
0.0181272421,
0.0077690682,
0.0502814762,
-0.0232549962,
0.0076708007,
0.0033903276,
-0.0296509583,
0.0287465211,
0.0228403639,
-0.0216234867,
0.0032210345,
-0.011038241,
0.0256289039,
-0.0123688029,
-0.0278765652,
-0.0300325342,
0.0084220273,
-0.0404647402,
-0.0234484822,
-0.0043560923,
0.0052244598,
-0.0569978356,
-0.0246663522,
-0.008347231,
-0.0618419126,
-0.0290169902,
0.0091050575,
-0.0175567735,
0.045123145,
0.0136025185,
-0.0029312959,
-0.0168295503,
0.004360843,
0.0308690872,
-0.0231624376,
-0.0323595442,
0.0662596375,
-0.0008296499,
0.0150791332,
-0.0197925549,
0.0029598617,
-0.0295594223,
-0.0475809127,
0.0042971643,
0.0112656746,
0.0095571326,
0.0365073159,
-0.0329462774,
-0.0515077561,
0.0367040746,
-0.038512215,
0.0186356027,
0.0561310872,
-0.0374286287,
0.0125852739,
-0.0159967802,
0.0759874061,
0.0027222072,
-0.0413491949,
-0.0169866905,
0.0290851966,
0.0127199348,
0.0019627139,
-0.0125104627,
-0.0386269502,
-0.0075363796,
0.0322885439,
-0.0583981685,
0.0450193137,
0.0067639672,
0.0473658368,
-0.0388859101,
-0.0448865369,
-0.0300798919,
0.0286985952,
0.0516978242,
0.0170308482,
0.0079758288,
-0.0203831606,
-0.0182548556,
-0.0736929327,
0.0004791551,
0.045841977,
-0.0534324646,
-0.0281424616,
0.0030521613,
0.0499646962,
0.0098190941,
0.0175585132,
-0.0221650805,
0.0056473156,
-0.0565837212,
-0.005655671,
-0.0264656618,
-0.093451798,
-0.0746673048,
0.0357970633,
0.0289078485,
-0.0674936771,
0.0036694231,
-0.0052260738,
-0.0125486199,
0.0795652643,
-0.0503373742,
0.020099625,
0.0174438376,
-0.0003088356,
-0.008011179,
0.0876862854,
0.050496608,
-0.0082329502,
0.0303898454,
-0.0660031959,
0.0451611131,
0.0582674667,
-0.0448159017,
0.0088344887,
-0.0449121334,
-0.0050093508,
0.0288407058,
-0.015925508,
0.07011161,
0.0370892845,
-0.0012479686,
-0.0053110165,
0.0137866931,
0.0341177508,
-0.0381755047,
-0.0159211606,
0.0218680967,
0.0168387257,
0.0044848043,
-0.0315249488,
-0.0522579886,
-0.0015131417,
0.0060090562,
0.0356614031,
-0.0034785462,
0.0298922472,
0.0176453311,
-0.0260717571,
-0.0485572554,
-0.0156799816,
-0.0058444352,
-0.0091066705,
0.0421252809,
-0.0535405688,
-0.0067049833,
0.0298916213,
0.0207673442,
-0.0404447429,
-0.0372850969,
-0.0634039119,
-0.0073170103,
0.0253623743,
0.0204455443,
-0.0598536693,
0.010436343,
0.0179386251,
0.0021972135,
-0.0144517431,
0.0151200583,
0.0225246493,
0.0306757204,
-0.0357286334,
-0.023082098,
-0.0146626756,
-0.0017666304,
0.036747817,
0.0396035127,
-0.0030857937,
0.0254839901,
-0.049309466,
-0.0440180488,
0.0108722541,
0.028035365,
0.0259491559,
0.0108768167,
-0.0079101333,
0.0015102315,
-0.033260107,
-0.0711533204,
0.0118452413,
0.0190052576,
0.0121968808,
0.0320427753,
-0.0247403644,
-0.0054721637,
0.0125232022,
0.0621683598,
-0.013268413,
-0.0357495211,
-0.0044246977,
-0.0253474489,
-0.011753493,
0.0491023809,
-0.0056528421,
-0.002067067,
0.0259621777,
0.0599568263,
-0.0634751841,
0.022226112,
-0.0654052645,
0.0199115705,
-0.0115833655,
0.0363957584,
0.006301879,
0.0389292762,
0.0493401624,
0.014014177,
-0.0308810715,
-0.0197010096,
-0.0212613717,
0.0308923833,
0.0186781902,
0.0291752648,
-0.0031518398,
-0.0395426415,
-0.0820518434,
0.0140353302,
-0.016150821,
0.0415208004,
0.0105172666,
0.0019238541,
-0.0154961618,
-0.001495046,
0.0011427734,
0.0071909591,
-0.0619293377,
0.0209631305,
0.0330610871,
-0.0191471651,
-0.0665828586,
-0.0647527575,
-0.0290501043,
-0.0237683579,
0.045621261,
-0.0133635718,
-0.0401566885,
-0.1107828319,
0.0920029134,
0.0062195617,
0.0081172409,
-0.0249645151,
-0.0723826885,
0.0099885864,
-0.0111479172,
0.0520097315,
0.027391471,
-0.0387008749,
-0.0185599532,
0.0639214516,
0.0021492052,
-0.0339286178,
-0.0126231825,
0.0393779837,
-0.0771810338,
0.002911381,
-0.0639150217,
0.0006600575,
0.074718982,
0.0011678006,
-0.0171710923,
-0.0265580192,
-0.0149811246,
-0.0408614278,
0.0226771738,
-0.00870331,
-0.0227780379,
0.0021839817,
0.0576588809,
-0.0154145993,
-0.0971470773,
0.0290508885,
-0.0786387697,
0.0073455116,
0.0019428041,
-0.0248598754,
-0.0013295282,
0.0027498815,
-0.0019744842,
-0.0018038984,
0.0131336115,
-0.0379096679,
-0.0308542978,
-0.0050426144,
0.0131009249,
-0.0399048664,
0.0661688223,
-0.083086051,
0.0304477122,
-0.0284321066,
-0.0112115266,
-0.0064002229,
-0.0119989552,
-0.0278275367,
-0.0198315643,
0.0825691372,
-0.0640848875,
0.0382353291,
0.0463778414,
0.0100885369,
0.0255009662,
0.0081728501,
-0.0251209158,
-0.0181045774,
-0.0293032862,
-0.0205985326,
-0.0395899974,
0.0439057499,
-0.0270015448,
-0.0500459261,
0.0107967509,
0.0522063598,
0.0719508603,
-0.0697780401,
-0.0242456831,
0.0492852256,
0.0186425801,
-0.0692448169,
0.0751590729,
0.1059958637,
-0.0258610826,
-0.0152201913,
0.0759655759,
0.0294321161,
-0.0549575537,
0.0015375365,
-0.0405141897,
0.0660545379,
0.0586117283,
0.0310620349,
-0.0704323724,
-0.0289792288,
0.0066813929,
0.0291861985,
-0.0132109551,
-0.0030447354,
0.0130559709,
-0.0779851973,
0.0285358746,
0.0312022902,
-0.0355322249,
-0.0374913141,
-0.0331750661,
0.0153568611,
0.0112237455,
0.0070000384,
0.011024286,
0.0083001815,
0.0318636857,
0.0385783389,
-0.0723945722,
-0.024586644,
0.0002905339,
-0.0345604382,
0.0506619997,
0.0664955154,
-0.013171521,
-0.0188892595,
0.0086546047,
0.0419716351,
-0.0447430462,
0.0120975133,
0.0004734609,
0.0331616104,
0.0582858771,
-0.027897479,
0.0527482517,
-0.0439512879,
-0.0535765849,
-0.0033303951,
-0.0152793601,
0.0236240756,
-0.0118109379,
-0.0031074013,
0.0076008677,
-0.0211201198,
0.0183632076,
0.0125396745,
0.0541545264,
-0.021165153,
-0.0139704291,
-0.0751033425,
0.0288861562,
-0.0162289552,
0.0197192766,
0.0129810506,
0.0075956909,
-0.0417111702,
-0.008699622,
0.0302775055,
0.0009149021,
0.0125818644,
0.0131236613,
-0.0163590647,
0.0299653132,
-0.0079635633,
-0.0833295286,
0.0289692506,
-0.0155638978,
0.0736103728,
-0.0260816012,
-0.0100314096,
-0.0013416832,
0.0241365228,
0.0025723192,
0.0295722634,
-0.1596157551,
-0.0601040199,
-0.0144595616,
0.0601891316,
0.0254889745,
-0.0105442712,
-0.0198061503,
-0.069232747,
-0.0209004749,
0.0349197872,
-0.0027878501,
0.0469610058,
0.0072200722,
0.0034531169,
-0.0187198073,
-0.0138704265,
-0.0340995416,
-0.0331560075,
0.0525180139,
-0.0128221158,
-0.0481425524,
-0.0509805381,
-0.0166704059,
0.0020719881,
0.0677287951,
-0.017663721,
-0.0303093251,
0.0279955566,
-0.018537445,
0.0370330028,
-0.0278598499,
-0.0358506255,
-0.0356252715,
0.0347674228,
-0.030709479,
-0.0024169171,
0.0254354402,
-0.026577685,
0.025178317,
-0.0183178168,
0.0219155755,
0.0208501108,
0.0470884368,
0.0702378824,
0.0125313457,
0.0166488551,
0.0341687202,
0.0159275606,
0.030611204,
0.0183386598,
0.0294711348,
-0.0129883811,
0.0080422042,
0.0328738503,
0.0261182096,
-0.0258782879,
-0.0768806562,
-0.012726387,
-0.0100042196,
0.0525321513,
0.0371261574,
0.0613617077,
0.0095806867,
0.0267725568,
-0.0536503382,
0.0504654944,
0.0067486977,
0.0085925441,
0.035435807,
0.0056959093,
-0.0416821726,
-0.0175564736,
0.0547912456,
0.0197823253,
0.0039397907,
-0.0332704745,
-0.0643108636,
0.00732311,
0.0183340907,
0.0263369288,
-0.0188083928,
-0.0272861458,
-0.0091687581,
-0.0406140238,
-0.0715349168,
0.0055847797,
0.0470356308,
0.0344029106,
-0.0110886851,
-0.0140966307,
0.0842128098,
-0.0019799003,
-0.0184336305,
-0.02968679,
-0.0028856399,
0.0231799316,
-0.0058200532,
-0.0281501208,
-6.039195165e-33,
-0.0331244916,
-0.0374138691,
-0.0450425483,
-0.0252048746,
0.0135702575,
0.0084816357,
-0.0274465885,
0.0478188396,
0.0077382373,
-0.0227327812,
0.0227362439,
0.0373969562,
0.0132413199,
-0.0370675027,
0.0427199006,
0.024073353,
0.0034739927,
0.0375341177,
-0.056816712,
-0.0134367794,
-0.0090495683,
0.0268066004,
0.0566971041,
-0.0707270801,
-0.0153285787,
0.0158599485,
0.0180989802,
-0.0136227878,
0.0523478165,
0.0409692675,
0.0236172825,
0.0397448018,
-0.0128307538,
0.0103228195,
-0.0336293913,
-0.0555727966,
-0.004074919,
-0.0209538378,
0.0221533868,
0.0798127279,
0.0454203226,
-0.0434074588,
0.0450864099,
0.011600703,
-0.0445624031,
0.011665226,
0.0266564973,
-0.0198291633,
-0.0139307957,
-0.006206498,
-0.0173393637,
0.0399611779,
-0.0200047139,
0.0167889204,
-0.0130108688,
-0.0204542559,
-0.0040455572,
0.0342114083,
-0.022649873,
-0.0113477819,
0.044921089,
0.0789579973,
0.085990347,
0.0563168041,
-0.0116959671,
0.0142033715,
0.0249305442,
0.0249414034,
0.0051168217,
-0.0218246263,
0.0477968343,
-0.0148982611,
0.0108502591,
0.0279172529,
0.0399731621,
-0.0087998332,
-0.0437551886,
0.0081347981,
0.005917476,
-0.0040331576,
0.0081742359,
0.0668626502,
-0.0558316782,
-0.0347064473,
-0.0400059186,
-0.0113303615,
-0.0349175334,
-0.0105928686,
0.0176415071,
-0.0421412811,
-0.0233684331,
0.0216452107,
0.0164000671,
-0.0330166258,
-0.0232222844,
-0.0140174842,
-0.0506484956,
0.0465573855,
-0.006239193,
0.0447563753,
-0.0153479818,
-0.0312064234,
0.0032032905,
0.0154362665,
0.0821692273,
0.015638683,
0.0166243538,
0.0139937103,
-0.0704217702,
0.0108971391,
-0.0247088317,
-0.0149724856,
-0.0125565659,
0.0138134575,
-0.0001518291,
-0.0331146531,
0.0091312779,
0.0188705307,
0.0092957169,
-0.0105159422,
-0.0121292258,
-0.0117041348,
-0.0083984565,
0.0163439959,
-0.0650599524,
-0.0499152541,
-0.0083290832,
0.0092852395,
0.0189065542,
-0.0465775318,
-0.0558624901,
-0.0124922534,
2.643e-7,
0.0793006718,
0.0476717427,
-0.0005073297,
0.0618651286,
0.026771931,
0.0350602418,
-0.0406383984,
-0.0272249356,
0.0074709877,
-0.0320960097,
-0.0319146477,
0.0159817208,
0.0440834835,
0.0161957871,
0.0444672853,
-0.0207205657,
0.0163474157,
0.0417068228,
-0.0434481427,
0.0057611475,
0.0250786282,
0.0867040902,
-0.0066136606,
-0.0059383763,
0.0154249733,
-0.0475765355,
0.0107741673,
-0.0387807451,
0.0117172673,
0.0335534923,
-0.0328407697,
0.0183662437,
-0.007529018,
0.0274329465,
-0.0030025993,
-0.0439441837,
0.019206604,
0.0572679415,
-0.0330232717,
0.0843493938,
0.0030571176,
-0.0193054024,
0.004519267,
-0.0696935505,
0.0276660882,
-0.0093084006,
0.0084184352,
-0.0455691926,
-0.0088349534,
-0.0234520044,
0.0346359536,
-0.0067678033,
0.0139731569,
0.0199574232,
0.0276128836,
0.005903427,
-0.0357227325,
-0.0309046004,
-0.0734773576,
0.0314418674,
-0.0114022642,
-0.0547848381,
-0.0609814301,
-0.0015939255,
0.0220722277,
-0.0417459905,
0.0467077531,
2.71911588e-34,
0.0558302328,
0.0016510676,
-0.0169907194,
0.00840584,
0.0465983227,
-0.0075546522,
-0.0307766255,
0.0079827858,
-0.0276322737,
0.0000905445,
-0.0054634148
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06233v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06233v2 | LEGOBench: Scientific Leaderboard Generation Benchmark | 2024-01-11T19:20:27 | 2024-02-21T06:40:33 | Shruti Singh, Shoaib Alam, Husain Malwat, Mayank Singh | cs.CL | cs.CL | The ever-increasing volume of paper submissions makes it difficult to stay
informed about the latest state-of-the-art research. To address this challenge,
we introduce LEGOBench, a benchmark for evaluating systems that generate
scientific leaderboards. LEGOBench is curated from 22 years of preprint
submission data on arXiv and more than 11k machine learning leaderboards on the
PapersWithCode portal. We present four graph-based and two language model-based
leaderboard generation task configurations. We evaluate popular encoder-only
scientific language models as well as decoder-only large language models across
these task configurations. State-of-the-art models showcase significant
performance gaps in automatic leaderboard generation on LEGOBench. The code is
available on GitHub ( https://github.com/lingo-iitgn/LEGOBench ) and the
dataset is hosted on OSF (
https://osf.io/9v2py/?view_only=6f91b0b510df498ba01595f8f278f94c ). | [
0.0158969741,
0.0970437974,
0.0089904796,
0.0347740389,
-0.0255019739,
-0.0282276999,
0.0136847887,
0.0077258321,
-0.0058840616,
0.010461105,
-0.0230190065,
-0.0083048372,
0.0014985795,
0.0546414219,
0.0221187416,
-0.0223142505,
0.0056158332,
-0.0368370563,
0.0326804966,
-0.0408650003,
-0.0387480669,
-0.0206549801,
-0.0011181321,
0.0186930355,
0.0547592863,
-0.0216632914,
0.009451896,
-0.0159319025,
0.0431176722,
-0.0751274675,
-0.0014703748,
0.072315596,
-0.0080648931,
0.069895573,
0.0000019217,
-0.0264922865,
-0.0156557746,
0.0234574843,
-0.0047442308,
0.0352681205,
0.0085194306,
-0.0493633226,
-0.0149613954,
-0.0231435094,
-0.0291504636,
-0.0220268406,
0.0491118431,
-0.0196325257,
0.0346775986,
0.0394892879,
0.0007222355,
-0.0214308035,
0.0671099275,
-0.03929675,
0.022234872,
-0.0388036557,
0.0182753783,
0.0311746765,
0.0364933349,
0.0264074132,
-0.0363665968,
0.0301773548,
0.0012210747,
-0.0330442265,
0.0607546642,
0.0656865016,
-0.0255251508,
-0.0057909591,
0.0014829626,
0.0932942852,
-0.0330502689,
-0.0434479415,
0.0237716828,
0.0104144691,
-0.0426521003,
0.0266510155,
-0.0676074848,
0.0310065337,
0.0152954478,
-0.0130619695,
0.0244640224,
0.0280208196,
0.022849381,
0.0088489233,
-0.0063315555,
0.1073595956,
0.0291630067,
-0.0254742708,
0.0003593728,
0.0077144583,
-0.0006004639,
-0.0456073061,
0.0139889205,
-0.0129629234,
-0.0345147699,
-0.0053479834,
-0.0078910962,
-0.0135953799,
0.035545215,
-0.008368969,
0.0318148732,
-0.0111493999,
0.0633362234,
0.0672444925,
0.0019827706,
0.0319401473,
-0.0192907322,
0.0223792978,
-0.0096060764,
-0.0053706155,
-0.0126558607,
-0.0046518492,
0.0068853665,
-0.0072867004,
0.0109102437,
-0.0161715858,
-0.0533986241,
0.0003944053,
0.0146783274,
0.0166880302,
0.041840829,
0.0120583037,
-0.0259602852,
0.0112550762,
0.0284532048,
0.0330574512,
-0.0216738209,
-0.033558771,
0.0146371676,
-0.0260698609,
-0.033898104,
-0.0111030228,
-0.0104828598,
-0.0213975683,
0.0149715962,
0.0309081059,
0.0193274356,
-0.0140331155,
0.117169261,
-0.0118015008,
-0.0156731289,
-0.077055797,
0.0186449904,
-0.0688146576,
0.077954039,
0.0320331044,
0.0254384894,
-0.0361022614,
0.0247910451,
-0.0004850122,
-0.0247603655,
0.0459179431,
-0.0486401543,
-0.0239791423,
0.0231290106,
0.0016227321,
-0.016624175,
0.0142188752,
0.0136359911,
0.0238466002,
0.0206321962,
-0.0340361893,
0.0060687526,
0.0323829465,
0.0491376258,
-0.0168993659,
0.0013213556,
-0.0178538337,
-0.0014961023,
0.0591257699,
-0.0183088537,
0.0098779658,
-0.0367545485,
-0.0149089592,
0.0289769657,
0.0336571671,
0.0052406578,
-0.0244571157,
-0.0255998019,
-0.0440849066,
0.0422346815,
-0.043376144,
-0.001708528,
0.0504585579,
0.0315922275,
0.00655594,
0.0327476449,
0.0468973368,
0.0199277587,
-0.0015704032,
-0.0061578546,
0.0229284372,
-0.0301614907,
-0.0215296894,
0.0860542879,
-0.0104360972,
-0.0323239081,
0.00293996,
-0.0015902001,
-0.0636921749,
0.0325264484,
0.0055317124,
-0.0254545826,
0.0352027304,
0.1073208675,
-0.0286973994,
-0.0244624671,
0.0180155896,
-0.0160176996,
0.0412541442,
0.0017559873,
-0.0127332872,
-0.0047153225,
-0.0392548852,
-0.0189380199,
0.0093272775,
0.0002187999,
0.0167378169,
0.0004696918,
-0.0045646937,
-0.0153234219,
-0.0424687937,
-0.06028568,
0.011118385,
-0.0291920397,
0.0130143035,
0.0014745318,
-0.0638528019,
0.0660843924,
0.0098918779,
-0.0372054987,
0.0382950976,
0.0930076987,
-0.0394590162,
-0.0146158589,
-0.0009179336,
0.0377863348,
-0.0767463744,
0.0405801684,
-0.0783976689,
0.0176457297,
0.0551908761,
-0.0329918228,
-0.026536718,
0.0255666766,
-0.0213800501,
-0.0190733783,
0.0233997069,
0.0172883626,
-0.0280501414,
0.0159712303,
-0.0219873209,
0.061683435,
-0.0285478625,
0.0676087439,
0.0634977594,
-0.0067471513,
-0.0016258013,
-0.0360573158,
-0.0118341921,
0.0657764897,
0.0241796896,
-0.0017354671,
0.0309850127,
-0.0229483116,
-0.0123243323,
-0.038490817,
-0.0767099634,
-0.0097830128,
0.008646328,
-0.0044243876,
0.0343515947,
-0.0417923406,
0.0080139805,
-0.0038547788,
-0.0050946134,
-0.0114344498,
0.0133419596,
-0.007221913,
0.0165693425,
-0.0396398008,
-0.0159762539,
-0.0609675422,
-0.0584015101,
-0.0312153175,
0.0709187984,
0.0242873132,
-0.014964723,
-0.036375951,
0.0151892276,
-0.0382900573,
-0.0055101067,
-0.025387805,
-0.0146409599,
0.0316981971,
-0.0223907381,
0.0278377794,
0.0570671372,
0.0253712367,
0.0433065258,
0.0462224744,
-0.0408425294,
-0.0428990275,
-0.0124717439,
-0.0400801264,
0.0397197939,
0.0268623885,
-0.0763800144,
0.0226059388,
0.069794476,
0.0236495323,
0.0106133483,
-0.0354858935,
0.0396039076,
-0.0231629517,
-0.0296438057,
-0.0226150509,
0.0022253254,
-0.0090112844,
0.0282745548,
0.010177237,
-0.0016294274,
0.0483429357,
-0.0499490686,
-0.0156369377,
-0.0431870557,
0.0202981699,
-0.045780018,
-0.011311152,
0.064756915,
0.0290382747,
-0.0300164502,
0.0017995083,
0.0030363968,
0.0477053523,
0.0025194739,
-0.0599594787,
-0.045759514,
-0.0026842239,
0.0099671166,
-0.0197008904,
-0.0213886332,
-0.0004554492,
0.0104569616,
-0.0056573399,
0.0306967981,
0.0726862624,
-0.0600836463,
-0.0468884334,
0.02587118,
0.0405509286,
0.0181204937,
-0.0597571246,
0.0028848343,
-0.0171289556,
0.0664767101,
0.0623387434,
-0.0418757387,
0.0315729864,
-0.0275654513,
0.0154920286,
0.0732166991,
0.0384566523,
0.0489893369,
0.0127735417,
0.0001813919,
0.0307194311,
-0.0220207497,
0.0209528003,
-0.0040810639,
0.0390294865,
-0.0124021126,
-0.0018992017,
0.0998869017,
0.0404041596,
-0.0422304235,
0.0013921735,
0.016838247,
0.0623489432,
0.0070986403,
0.0194874648,
-0.0699389055,
0.0163709112,
-0.0103137745,
0.0254754778,
0.001737001,
-0.0498540327,
-0.0007386279,
-0.0709239244,
0.0479953662,
0.0464773215,
-0.0530077554,
-0.0046759564,
-0.0589468293,
-0.0349882692,
-0.0228870735,
-0.0532536767,
0.0401244834,
0.0274096541,
0.0376170836,
0.0088391192,
-0.042461995,
-0.071752429,
0.0049054632,
-0.022204617,
0.0702928156,
0.0314705595,
0.0493065864,
-0.0296458714,
-0.0125137074,
-0.0009523529,
-0.0059192916,
-0.0349158421,
-0.0230169427,
0.0479381606,
0.0153214773,
-0.012366428,
-0.01293734,
0.0274406318,
-0.030105954,
-0.0013019877,
0.0210706815,
0.0883917138,
0.0110207256,
-0.0235429741,
-0.0590202883,
0.0076592891,
-0.0336870737,
0.052951254,
0.0105764307,
-0.0197777618,
-0.0460940711,
-0.0690199062,
0.0854215398,
-0.0630746633,
-0.0709395036,
-0.0316269435,
0.0162742008,
-0.0074158576,
-0.0584134124,
-0.0083781062,
0.0280502476,
0.0088125402,
0.0083097164,
0.0078415154,
-0.0382973664,
-0.0312558077,
-0.0606472418,
-0.0466680229,
0.0119412635,
-0.0115588652,
-0.0717326477,
-0.0277180914,
0.0802708641,
0.0180201083,
-0.0363918468,
0.0323427171,
-0.0176096726,
-0.0682045147,
-0.0243481155,
0.0524480157,
0.0241629891,
-0.0086116102,
-0.0089149028,
-0.0354153104,
0.0333792046,
0.0247392543,
0.0185648575,
0.001434856,
-0.0314179286,
-0.0650934353,
-0.0399236754,
-0.024455931,
-0.0331353992,
0.0267090723,
-0.0231675487,
0.0510697067,
-0.0289528761,
-0.0197018534,
0.0322624184,
0.0286560617,
0.0224836711,
-0.0460316502,
-0.0263184737,
0.0203423817,
-0.0267630126,
-0.0472033024,
-0.0110136,
-0.0319188349,
-0.0057574171,
0.0366800092,
-0.0148441466,
0.0235733669,
0.0519279912,
-0.0022989276,
0.0111539857,
-0.0481569953,
0.0156589281,
-0.0135720251,
0.0306944028,
0.0474063791,
-0.0132854972,
-0.0199557319,
-0.0065134959,
-0.0308376532,
0.0514985435,
-0.0208232738,
-0.0086473189,
0.022121124,
-0.0146531863,
0.0038498442,
0.0617786758,
-0.1194057763,
-0.0091791693,
-0.0677472353,
0.0154576059,
0.0907437056,
0.073767513,
0.0807489231,
-0.0200055391,
-0.0073813875,
-0.0293924659,
-0.0018743986,
0.0255010948,
0.0058059888,
0.0069780801,
0.021384757,
0.009223694,
-0.0240730401,
0.0833413228,
0.0799117833,
-0.0122967176,
0.0163842719,
-0.0017412734,
-0.0240013432,
0.0057357745,
-0.0635088459,
0.0097583942,
-0.0150394877,
-0.0140648317,
-0.0524478257,
-0.0139734317,
0.0244473629,
0.0315581709,
0.0120762223,
-0.0378484391,
0.0077581946,
0.0289385449,
-0.0245165378,
-0.0169836022,
-0.0331015587,
0.0512139648,
-0.0252998434,
-0.070637159,
-0.0272547323,
-6.124043816e-33,
-0.0205818918,
-0.0442414917,
-0.0034095261,
0.0165691171,
-0.0280966721,
0.0034704793,
-0.059863355,
-0.0290105231,
0.0082482202,
0.0146789523,
-0.0338350497,
-0.0078074737,
-0.0143003045,
-0.0043189842,
0.0304767769,
0.0213964749,
0.0335917845,
-0.0217548124,
-0.040483959,
0.0499076135,
0.0273806397,
0.0280090552,
0.041428566,
-0.0465204492,
0.0167592447,
0.0113473879,
0.000879442,
-0.030442521,
-0.0005683892,
0.0232586227,
-0.0052846749,
-0.0036409411,
0.0022214435,
-0.0594555996,
-0.0063463342,
-0.0264739543,
-0.0394642502,
0.0032544062,
-0.0014359378,
-0.007035628,
-0.0294190906,
-0.0043530413,
0.0363469198,
-0.0126678171,
-0.031350404,
-0.0479916297,
0.0405279584,
-0.0076960949,
-0.0661233068,
-0.0528263338,
-0.0126168765,
0.0120954737,
-0.0241588466,
0.0258491132,
0.0377169698,
0.0262646545,
0.0049050031,
0.0491371676,
-0.0468964316,
0.094475612,
0.0004008314,
0.0600667633,
0.0620138198,
-0.0190176945,
0.0060651745,
0.0730782151,
0.0518822037,
0.0081740785,
0.0315065645,
0.0043832017,
0.0111573674,
0.0401976332,
0.0934707969,
-0.0020325724,
0.0518095829,
0.0280024447,
-0.0676432401,
0.046231173,
0.0315751545,
-0.0369612761,
0.022399867,
0.0024205686,
0.0098849935,
-0.0332527757,
-0.0137786847,
-0.0273029208,
0.0010600762,
-0.0382089838,
0.0046892902,
-0.0410960428,
-0.0779720023,
-0.0178795699,
0.0395972989,
-0.0518060401,
-0.0695259124,
0.0773438439,
0.0211629383,
0.08282464,
-0.0153734162,
0.0158773642,
-0.0638335198,
0.0018263252,
-0.0041280608,
0.0275027975,
0.0158502329,
-0.0053816363,
-0.0295423158,
0.0144699393,
-0.0105040371,
-0.016279012,
-0.0209617577,
-0.0248041041,
-0.0110068638,
0.0310593229,
-0.0036751984,
0.0007133451,
0.0063764378,
0.0116288094,
0.0303102434,
0.03539804,
-0.0073777246,
0.0513725504,
-0.0022861275,
0.0279430915,
-0.0035237232,
-0.0023447331,
-0.0615177155,
0.017759297,
0.0198164154,
-0.0331364051,
-0.0177241992,
-0.0040640142,
2.601e-7,
0.0528038591,
0.0952457488,
0.0077309581,
-0.0050358558,
0.0471642837,
-0.0191386491,
-0.037390504,
0.0238053054,
0.0383304879,
0.0206163693,
-0.0064029875,
-0.0189114008,
0.0113648977,
0.0544084348,
-0.0707482323,
-0.0457972735,
-0.0781457797,
-0.0288218036,
-0.0464170054,
-0.0192099288,
0.0164311938,
0.018428091,
-0.0268493965,
0.0072749984,
-0.0034810158,
-0.0089759259,
0.0506961867,
-0.011171353,
-0.0049345447,
0.0533194691,
-0.0399560556,
-0.0382177942,
-0.0284997933,
0.0013769681,
-0.0333417617,
0.0044641667,
0.043800693,
0.0186465476,
-0.016386902,
0.0075581758,
0.0406983159,
0.0014385211,
0.0076395185,
-0.0525822602,
0.0404302478,
-0.0466748253,
-0.0559691228,
-0.0180876497,
-0.0621548556,
-0.0126975337,
0.0442136042,
-0.037468195,
-0.0252397656,
0.0236523952,
-0.0119861485,
0.0187262353,
-0.0025496818,
-0.0113431783,
-0.0485450663,
-0.0087067671,
-0.0467645563,
-0.0700043067,
-0.0259701367,
-0.0049886494,
-0.0362302773,
-0.0211589001,
-0.0225956216,
2.796310961e-34,
0.0758176968,
-0.0052100834,
0.0146483714,
0.0258969348,
0.013741849,
-0.0227033943,
0.0104635842,
0.0144767212,
-0.0128688496,
-0.0796376392,
-0.021850314
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06210v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06210v1 | Learning Unsupervised Semantic Document Representation for Fine-grained Aspect-based Sentiment Analysis | 2024-01-11T18:59:52 | 2024-01-11T18:59:52 | Hao-Ming Fu, Pu-Jen Cheng | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR | Document representation is the core of many NLP tasks on machine
understanding. A general representation learned in an unsupervised manner
reserves generality and can be used for various applications. In practice,
sentiment analysis (SA) has been a challenging task that is regarded to be
deeply semantic-related and is often used to assess general representations.
Existing methods on unsupervised document representation learning can be
separated into two families: sequential ones, which explicitly take the
ordering of words into consideration, and non-sequential ones, which do not
explicitly do so. However, both of them suffer from their own weaknesses. In
this paper, we propose a model that overcomes difficulties encountered by both
families of methods. Experiments show that our model outperforms
state-of-the-art methods on popular SA datasets and a fine-grained aspect-based
SA by a large margin. | [
0.0391410328,
0.0480516255,
0.0085288379,
0.0570489764,
-0.0266537666,
0.0231669489,
-0.0334341079,
-0.0120987659,
-0.0100505482,
-0.0914182067,
-0.0305797998,
0.0073272628,
-0.0007275761,
0.0254693478,
-0.0239628069,
-0.0388953015,
0.0294549614,
0.0374074578,
0.0432422347,
0.0045163035,
0.0560410693,
0.0266165193,
0.0039642868,
0.0128694233,
-0.0281522274,
-0.0339248553,
0.0138885323,
-0.0164592937,
0.0223140586,
0.0183832813,
0.0098799588,
0.0368405581,
0.0354290232,
0.0160639547,
0.000001818,
0.0052540908,
-0.0389567129,
-0.0102227181,
0.0689766482,
0.0162298735,
0.056469541,
-0.0848374292,
0.0022799089,
-0.0043000351,
-0.0505729578,
-0.0492443144,
0.008661272,
0.0796208456,
0.0617970787,
0.1030161083,
-0.0336631462,
-0.0444044769,
0.0033561995,
-0.0116046164,
-0.0063711652,
-0.0787710547,
-0.0216645002,
0.003107962,
-0.0408231504,
0.0954706222,
-0.0265317354,
-0.0152020212,
-0.0381922349,
0.011333189,
-0.0001404376,
-0.0113802738,
0.0076372353,
0.0268970821,
0.0099784089,
0.0574403144,
0.0389965624,
-0.0267584585,
0.026567081,
-0.0051290113,
-0.021370424,
0.0067185732,
-0.011335508,
-0.0010958206,
0.0097245071,
0.0607757531,
0.048859816,
0.0344283581,
-0.0000237403,
-0.0000861991,
-0.0321036354,
0.0225025956,
-0.050679557,
-0.0235029813,
-0.013872386,
0.0434593298,
0.0122872684,
0.0195355993,
0.0071830638,
-0.0253691096,
0.0086442446,
0.0041957679,
-0.0056909532,
-0.0003233831,
0.0314642899,
-0.05993025,
-0.0027199776,
-0.0183213223,
-0.0017003916,
0.0663673803,
-0.0004488857,
-0.0302537736,
0.0071718129,
0.0064952616,
-0.0371639431,
0.0259294044,
-0.0728717968,
0.0192926768,
-0.0169620197,
0.0610619858,
-0.0429976843,
-0.015999293,
-0.0426227637,
0.0050882273,
-0.0222237501,
0.0038610636,
0.012823794,
0.0133188488,
0.0137948841,
-0.0000696828,
0.0140397567,
0.0412885994,
-0.0720560923,
0.0531753078,
-0.0433307104,
0.0358918011,
0.0308622625,
0.0197342001,
0.0184736401,
0.0205837395,
-0.006459191,
0.0175384283,
0.0637168363,
-0.0500158258,
-0.0338385291,
-0.0250725094,
-0.012159273,
-0.0479904003,
-0.0279642846,
-0.0669284314,
0.0457998924,
0.0103478888,
0.0002746718,
0.0106671862,
-0.017462898,
0.0149873905,
-0.0385684967,
0.0656531453,
-0.0044617401,
-0.0235893223,
-0.0426120386,
0.0085441573,
0.0644218102,
0.0379258022,
-0.0231217518,
0.0446325615,
0.0278635416,
-0.0204506982,
-0.0276182499,
-0.0387319326,
0.0236226544,
0.0014844829,
0.0234365463,
-0.0055172709,
-0.0424370803,
-0.0084199673,
0.0164233986,
0.0190080032,
-0.0090241199,
-0.0712124482,
-0.0066514499,
-0.0107558891,
-0.036407195,
0.0571525842,
0.0044816411,
0.0410391502,
-0.0338398293,
0.0264160838,
-0.0184379965,
-0.0122217722,
-0.0199282467,
-0.0060013151,
0.0242457222,
-0.029399218,
-0.0455784909,
-0.0527945384,
-0.0175623521,
-0.0368760303,
0.0063256747,
0.0060240654,
0.0606428012,
0.0229745544,
-0.0246433318,
-0.0218065735,
0.0579074845,
-0.0335898846,
-0.0270989295,
0.0155210067,
0.0370230041,
0.0625728443,
-0.0073168636,
-0.0353481546,
0.0175021216,
-0.0143004153,
-0.0057142447,
-0.0181926861,
0.073797971,
0.0067021456,
0.0046722838,
-0.0305127893,
-0.0026483163,
-0.0192009751,
0.0123081123,
0.0063036247,
-0.0634854659,
-0.005421659,
0.0358272381,
-0.05689371,
0.0067923148,
0.0203041751,
0.0344605632,
-0.0490203388,
0.0356858782,
0.0160190035,
0.0097500011,
0.0502868593,
-0.0092382478,
-0.0025086117,
0.0356561393,
-0.0424464382,
-0.0181837976,
-0.0370221809,
-0.0484061614,
-0.0618395321,
-0.0341133699,
-0.0486237966,
-0.0175952408,
0.0271729231,
-0.0688165203,
-0.0198688339,
0.0029690613,
0.0013757584,
0.0046741934,
-0.0254702978,
-0.0252064634,
0.0427724868,
-0.0215554368,
-0.0392058194,
0.066576466,
-0.0186429359,
0.0344206616,
-0.0278732888,
-0.0076045315,
0.0664587393,
-0.0046108034,
-0.0748236105,
-0.0156636816,
0.0002133879,
0.0224981066,
0.0374156125,
-0.01788757,
-0.0013077164,
-0.0185426511,
-0.116782546,
-0.0312580876,
0.0107466346,
0.0223508198,
0.0263719521,
-0.0193087943,
0.0384226441,
0.0134858694,
-0.0661502779,
0.0054490636,
-0.0187733509,
0.0158465188,
0.0155822346,
-0.0030120427,
0.0637188405,
-0.0486491136,
-0.0122323716,
-0.0408755392,
0.0126793478,
-0.0069811139,
-0.0206082761,
-0.0486509427,
0.0176086128,
-0.0036304421,
0.0087826867,
0.0038190864,
-0.0128181316,
-0.0058464464,
-0.0493488982,
-0.0241485126,
0.0287626889,
0.0224838536,
0.0741968602,
0.0167751126,
0.0322230496,
-0.0508939698,
-0.0209217761,
-0.057917092,
0.0877926797,
-0.0268271398,
-0.0239380673,
0.0114054903,
0.0791417956,
0.0342812203,
-0.0133271078,
-0.0356408134,
0.0105898054,
-0.0267365202,
0.0209605619,
-0.0177687444,
0.0201739408,
0.0229530334,
-0.0064094202,
-0.0001823704,
-0.0133596044,
0.0359199941,
0.0007506073,
0.0359991938,
-0.0677162558,
-0.0094657671,
-0.0530950092,
0.0661579445,
-0.0169565771,
0.0204350594,
-0.0097537413,
0.0152328368,
0.0066930372,
-0.0088184765,
0.0037145868,
0.0207424536,
0.0298232045,
0.0466890223,
0.022236621,
0.0105192186,
-0.0275434777,
0.0335739963,
-0.0643474907,
-0.0551034845,
0.0147013478,
0.0078255255,
0.0397208035,
-0.0202938449,
-0.0050888923,
-0.0408095047,
-0.0205082539,
-0.0142883044,
-0.0142884813,
-0.0058005219,
0.0472853482,
0.0349369794,
-0.0438846722,
0.0273061041,
0.0122723617,
-0.0070523247,
0.0683785751,
-0.0096506877,
0.0306325555,
-0.0689482242,
-0.005871004,
0.027012825,
0.0117522897,
0.008674697,
-0.0442346446,
0.0242767017,
-0.0266367495,
0.0038893942,
0.1056760773,
0.0382140651,
-0.0487064235,
0.0107598836,
0.0260612126,
-0.0191866029,
0.0354184695,
-0.0016975284,
-0.0403766111,
-0.031888634,
-0.0307629406,
0.0106042996,
0.0256779362,
-0.0002994976,
0.0437293537,
-0.0562279783,
0.0189348925,
0.0037303646,
-0.0443053469,
-0.0494154729,
-0.0461988263,
0.0032930356,
-0.0309382621,
-0.0278772302,
-0.0505645648,
-0.0142165134,
-0.006570925,
-0.0256735012,
-0.0362537429,
0.0001180026,
0.0436896309,
0.0061630504,
0.0014182038,
0.0388218351,
0.0344605148,
-0.0076048248,
-0.0327797681,
0.0397833623,
-0.0685694814,
0.0110979769,
-0.0297158491,
0.0498400629,
-0.0561113544,
-0.0264512505,
0.0137934862,
-0.0082790786,
-0.1067380384,
0.0138572929,
-0.0118786301,
0.0343130082,
-0.0489827655,
-0.0296500139,
-0.0178077649,
0.0327499323,
0.0217566043,
0.0703491569,
-0.0000712263,
-0.041579552,
-0.0119133489,
0.0068500689,
0.0381220207,
0.0018673233,
-0.0313293189,
-0.0299178772,
0.0362794995,
-0.0000458148,
-0.0896553248,
-0.0848030597,
-0.006063797,
0.0309640318,
-0.0499214865,
-0.0159734618,
0.0135744223,
-0.0503568649,
-0.0304182172,
0.0312141795,
0.0046595731,
-0.001190151,
-0.0082090544,
-0.055571571,
0.0696327612,
0.0175806787,
-0.0530268252,
-0.037827272,
-0.0567121953,
-0.0104690278,
-0.0041327612,
0.0491781421,
-0.0014253993,
-0.0058719581,
-0.0091618197,
-0.032190159,
0.0316658728,
0.0361425839,
-0.0502798408,
-0.0013625793,
0.0359073617,
0.0340480283,
0.0072289249,
0.0460471287,
-0.0352593027,
0.0668875501,
-0.0056285225,
0.0341306739,
-0.047699824,
-0.0360058919,
0.0278179646,
-0.0238882992,
0.0849271491,
0.0411971398,
-0.0012512755,
-0.0252730567,
-0.0068902946,
-0.0047669201,
-0.0317398198,
-0.0257848483,
-0.0111362934,
-0.0156390779,
0.0038387328,
-0.0549202859,
0.0479392968,
-0.0161733776,
0.0567437224,
-0.0283949953,
0.051537104,
0.0454512574,
-0.0077154362,
-0.0588652268,
0.0623371825,
-0.0287584644,
0.0120290415,
-0.021385191,
-0.0109340735,
0.0067009707,
0.0459758081,
0.010700332,
0.0572449565,
-0.0652428269,
0.0110646822,
-0.039001219,
0.0080041774,
-0.0073582781,
0.0144682033,
0.004901458,
-0.0919964984,
0.0111679379,
-0.025621457,
0.008436515,
-0.0342069454,
0.0307512898,
0.0089620464,
0.0149762966,
0.0254056584,
0.0344660319,
-0.0124494787,
-0.0072337463,
0.0548764542,
-0.073601909,
0.0205656085,
0.0400024764,
0.0087936213,
-0.0413507372,
-0.0104669072,
0.0322255641,
0.0370819867,
0.0142984902,
0.0267488509,
-0.048198197,
-0.011516205,
0.0189520549,
-0.0342364386,
-0.0014526901,
0.004308078,
0.0304497909,
0.0604010783,
0.0176474489,
0.0788355097,
-0.0771685839,
-0.0403662473,
-0.024270609,
-0.0411544479,
-0.0031562285,
-6.254460874e-33,
0.0036699777,
0.0087702619,
-0.0534767844,
0.0167319793,
0.0401427783,
0.0215973668,
-0.0184125286,
0.0060840235,
-0.0019449053,
0.0450070798,
0.0213171486,
0.002635547,
-0.0119201224,
0.035205815,
-0.0015350234,
0.0180080887,
0.0122710504,
-0.0061151828,
0.012993901,
0.0346475802,
0.0645798147,
0.0203372333,
0.0509752221,
-0.1294313669,
0.0405048952,
-0.0261396039,
-0.0260892734,
-0.0070683383,
0.0131278122,
0.063918747,
-0.0004082765,
0.0359793343,
0.065825209,
0.0011068825,
0.0005871415,
0.0245142709,
-0.0445282236,
-0.0208611507,
-0.0212571118,
-0.021482531,
-0.0417560078,
-0.004191027,
0.0113091189,
-0.0112228692,
0.0404010899,
-0.0289673638,
0.0429528393,
-0.0130431131,
-0.0395237468,
-0.0940753222,
-0.053714931,
0.0418833792,
-0.0147575838,
-0.0164142437,
0.0186405256,
0.0051666158,
0.0253445078,
0.0458218865,
-0.0148900831,
-0.0113812918,
-0.057194002,
0.0436921902,
-0.0623395406,
-0.0640549585,
-0.0091066649,
0.0784662664,
-0.0031841258,
0.0255540777,
-0.0081411125,
0.0264254902,
0.0086908378,
0.018537214,
-0.0162950475,
0.0302567147,
0.0107065318,
-0.033558771,
-0.0307284109,
0.0358780771,
0.0054216976,
0.0096232155,
0.0454509184,
0.0075432658,
-0.0553088114,
0.002716209,
-0.0029805943,
-0.0361827239,
-0.0318807103,
0.0078666583,
-0.0086866403,
0.0115722883,
-0.0396711603,
-0.0119195767,
0.0093486141,
-0.0708660632,
0.0050926986,
0.0497820079,
-0.0244425703,
0.0071255639,
0.0082730092,
-0.019552378,
-0.0471018739,
-0.0564131998,
-0.0023136353,
0.004563096,
0.0108067915,
-0.0024559568,
0.097438924,
-0.0265519787,
-0.0667324513,
0.0014855128,
0.0083436416,
-0.0052375058,
-0.0286640394,
0.051876165,
0.0268253628,
-0.0177877434,
-0.0071298503,
0.1280702204,
-0.010614072,
0.0451853164,
0.0408397876,
0.0191470385,
-0.0028696225,
0.0203805473,
-0.0124678873,
-0.0386118889,
0.0044076024,
-0.0024857353,
0.0000315767,
-0.0114447679,
0.0076127816,
0.0022509014,
2.519e-7,
0.0138740968,
0.0264507197,
0.0185173638,
-0.0037440313,
0.0293038618,
0.0755109563,
0.0073531657,
0.0506702624,
-0.0242445227,
-0.0123405987,
0.0410102755,
0.024570303,
0.0033975882,
-0.013617686,
-0.0971548483,
0.1218276769,
-0.0021043543,
-0.0041407417,
0.022389695,
0.0268417224,
0.0809422955,
0.1015445143,
-0.0193376914,
-0.0146848587,
0.013629389,
0.0183584429,
0.0776393339,
-0.0276389904,
-0.0180522911,
0.0032808746,
-0.0460619368,
0.0167112667,
-0.0199577473,
-0.0410579666,
0.0044749137,
0.0182413794,
0.0128522916,
0.0849195421,
0.0041046226,
-0.0329968333,
0.0221679863,
-0.000046063,
0.0373988226,
0.0046822387,
0.0482772179,
-0.0645405725,
-0.0465844609,
-0.0837475136,
-0.0268325061,
0.0152986245,
-0.0350615643,
0.0227648914,
-0.0089861248,
0.0577133819,
-0.0244515017,
-0.0554412454,
-0.0040278463,
-0.0957564712,
-0.0016060303,
0.0293334946,
0.0075163515,
0.0287078768,
0.0478523858,
0.03322291,
0.0249373224,
-0.0235190131,
-0.0052017393,
2.035885273e-34,
0.0531425476,
-0.0136865983,
-0.0101050735,
0.0036714824,
0.0087429453,
-0.0117518222,
-0.0248725284,
-0.0081291022,
0.0336159356,
-0.0244172458,
0.0043716021
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06121v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06121v1 | TOFU: A Task of Fictitious Unlearning for LLMs | 2024-01-11T18:57:12 | 2024-01-11T18:57:12 | Pratyush Maini, Zhili Feng, Avi Schwarzschild, Zachary C. Lipton, J. Zico Kolter | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Large language models trained on massive corpora of data from the web can
memorize and reproduce sensitive or private data raising both legal and ethical
concerns. Unlearning, or tuning models to forget information present in their
training data, provides us with a way to protect private data after training.
Although several methods exist for such unlearning, it is unclear to what
extent they result in models equivalent to those where the data to be forgotten
was never learned in the first place. To address this challenge, we present
TOFU, a Task of Fictitious Unlearning, as a benchmark aimed at helping deepen
our understanding of unlearning. We offer a dataset of 200 diverse synthetic
author profiles, each consisting of 20 question-answer pairs, and a subset of
these profiles called the forget set that serves as the target for unlearning.
We compile a suite of metrics that work together to provide a holistic picture
of unlearning efficacy. Finally, we provide a set of baseline results from
existing unlearning algorithms. Importantly, none of the baselines we consider
show effective unlearning motivating continued efforts to develop approaches
for unlearning that effectively tune models so that they truly behave as if
they were never trained on the forget data at all. | [
0.0156815462,
0.0964694843,
-0.0120476279,
0.0643796846,
-0.0447861664,
-0.0040034046,
0.053663414,
0.0269658845,
0.0446188897,
-0.0226123016,
-0.0338901207,
0.0064161196,
-0.0347966291,
0.0150796343,
0.0097527634,
0.0267846398,
0.0316419937,
-0.0097118309,
0.0164286382,
-0.0355871692,
0.0064213509,
-0.0042254617,
-0.0026330315,
-0.0329791121,
0.0202894825,
-0.0565877445,
0.0040692091,
-0.0165702738,
0.0071976869,
0.0169321932,
0.0447609872,
0.0690101907,
-0.0012449236,
0.0671630055,
0.0000017456,
-0.0609159358,
-0.0581042469,
0.0005599891,
-0.0498872288,
0.0266859736,
0.0031265174,
0.0038393335,
0.0224988572,
0.0136005282,
-0.0613340028,
0.0006474557,
0.0031979047,
0.0488876291,
0.0535628088,
0.1114213318,
0.0029712461,
-0.0176420398,
0.0247011781,
-0.0206796229,
0.0348793454,
-0.0371530801,
0.0245426018,
-0.0614361167,
-0.0672192052,
0.0047311615,
-0.0006269275,
0.0423564315,
0.0160148293,
0.0271201208,
0.0201411918,
0.0087136673,
-0.030027315,
0.0264222864,
-0.015117459,
0.04521285,
0.0337373577,
-0.032198865,
0.0492127761,
0.0253829788,
0.0258281752,
0.0242864043,
-0.018698385,
0.0085702809,
-0.0514105484,
-0.0145225637,
-0.0102297915,
-0.0401040725,
0.0634456649,
0.0092952503,
0.0219549723,
0.0480309576,
0.008840167,
-0.0161777101,
-0.0043792813,
-0.0308731142,
0.0167332329,
-0.0510803126,
0.0576123372,
0.0152700478,
-0.0045616822,
0.0288483184,
-0.0312236436,
-0.0166688915,
0.0408936813,
-0.0158799067,
0.028416248,
-0.0331148021,
0.0213683471,
0.055916585,
-0.0250051264,
0.0453280248,
-0.0032396335,
0.0521133468,
-0.0133103086,
0.0134651475,
-0.0429030806,
-0.0276423506,
0.0306033846,
0.0796836838,
0.0059094075,
0.0472208001,
-0.0223702546,
0.0162285734,
-0.0285971928,
0.0506207645,
-0.0122174826,
0.0070182281,
-0.0294859875,
-0.0301809199,
-0.0471714884,
-0.0237746909,
0.001898165,
0.0293438938,
0.0195775069,
-0.049638465,
-0.0277715381,
-0.0277692191,
0.0222137738,
-0.0061751488,
0.0094658462,
0.08966773,
0.0138113508,
-0.0350362919,
-0.0399531201,
-0.0621326454,
0.0083588492,
-0.0395181663,
0.0189618878,
-0.063114427,
0.0229539927,
-0.0214069244,
-0.020811867,
-0.0983028933,
-0.0136340307,
0.0392436087,
-0.0354014188,
0.045018848,
-0.0029715823,
-0.021770807,
0.010928412,
0.0239283144,
0.0011681233,
0.0162963849,
-0.0154878916,
0.0133104119,
0.0691977292,
-0.0068243435,
0.0737468973,
0.0201013163,
0.0531739295,
0.0149857849,
0.0144468229,
0.0309093799,
0.031615518,
-0.0005275302,
0.0035451516,
0.0307878945,
-0.0203788169,
-0.0726766884,
0.0614985563,
0.041986648,
-0.0127046537,
0.0626299456,
-0.0253334697,
-0.0190600008,
0.0294099636,
0.0429518856,
-0.0520194471,
-0.0018768903,
-0.0777567998,
-0.0125363944,
-0.0243987571,
-0.0258585326,
-0.0279481839,
-0.0272090603,
0.0141244438,
-0.0438008867,
-0.0024631536,
0.0378317498,
0.0066188988,
0.051299531,
-0.0279002786,
0.0827419162,
0.0084610349,
-0.0941147059,
0.0143392496,
-0.0122712897,
0.0111289835,
0.0464058854,
0.0537904911,
-0.0621300787,
0.0088210637,
-0.0356460065,
-0.0115089789,
-0.0243367273,
0.0066478765,
0.0013362536,
0.0604927205,
-0.0480384491,
-0.0517901778,
-0.0097094635,
0.0258004311,
-0.0058796555,
0.035947796,
-0.0329510756,
0.0207227077,
-0.0667386129,
-0.0276445169,
0.0434184484,
-0.0886775106,
-0.0418613218,
0.0177452452,
-0.0073189307,
0.0270218533,
0.0392395519,
0.0059772907,
0.0051280996,
0.0445959494,
-0.0053502372,
-0.0131962048,
-0.045663368,
-0.0059468378,
-0.025983911,
0.0213224217,
-0.064073354,
-0.0081885522,
0.0661092624,
-0.0336595438,
-0.0125682801,
0.0097297505,
0.0093744788,
0.0284848381,
-0.028838221,
0.0148719372,
-0.024465777,
-0.0087758387,
-0.0313485861,
0.0681602806,
-0.0443200208,
0.0243925918,
-0.036253944,
-0.0475429483,
-0.0120310476,
-0.0471584126,
0.0054716789,
-0.0342847854,
-0.003991059,
0.0361885205,
0.0126857748,
-0.0178301949,
-0.0772446394,
-0.0601516739,
-0.0549207442,
0.0243833009,
-0.0167501438,
0.0356293134,
-0.0001303251,
-0.0104771974,
-0.0051210071,
-0.0252747145,
-0.0538758114,
-0.0297200531,
-0.0544035956,
0.0081442455,
0.0285929516,
-0.0246075206,
-0.0013045373,
-0.0103428708,
-0.013717019,
-0.0024665981,
0.0324710123,
-0.037355192,
0.0113073504,
-0.0010596035,
0.0580241606,
-0.0420810618,
0.0163749605,
-0.0055409768,
0.0055242078,
-0.025557654,
0.0021544939,
-0.0261869021,
0.0378665775,
0.0099157505,
0.0277030729,
0.0163650624,
0.017492909,
-0.0377395861,
0.0044483463,
-0.0368393324,
-0.0407656915,
-0.0487050414,
-0.0082193967,
0.0208727345,
-0.0049316059,
0.0183482412,
-0.0234556161,
0.0047009271,
0.045670785,
0.0036995767,
-0.0513987541,
-0.0162352324,
0.0028992798,
-0.0133756958,
0.0318695046,
-0.0204120148,
-0.049364619,
0.0555679016,
0.0036252534,
0.0476890504,
-0.0168346372,
-0.0076981471,
-0.0394418091,
0.0396858491,
0.0034220715,
0.0177922696,
0.0345187336,
-0.0362046845,
-0.0370811857,
-0.0127891917,
0.0459912382,
-0.0631782189,
0.0177093018,
-0.0059419814,
-0.0141284857,
0.0171683338,
-0.0488543175,
-0.045993723,
-0.0773354322,
-0.0108468244,
-0.0134662641,
-0.0382006466,
-0.0319491774,
-0.0331609398,
-0.1126814559,
0.0478513278,
-0.0054729735,
0.0175583921,
-0.0107156215,
-0.0206369963,
0.0278439038,
0.0301043801,
-0.0286734924,
0.0108937025,
-0.0431361757,
0.0005856351,
0.0827814192,
0.0364738666,
0.0036575866,
0.0400698632,
-0.0015577525,
0.0142046064,
-0.047494296,
-0.0104211168,
0.0348772928,
0.0232996754,
-0.025438495,
0.0027530983,
0.0888303369,
0.0095121032,
-0.0485531688,
-0.0211226866,
0.0305075459,
-0.0048531299,
0.0136541538,
-0.0212897379,
-0.1124388427,
-0.0024480103,
-0.0032342565,
0.0380986147,
-0.0149678169,
-0.0555704609,
-0.0145704802,
-0.0942937732,
-0.0030796535,
0.0111690341,
-0.0198970027,
-0.0062124501,
-0.061449632,
-0.0227952115,
-0.0135158524,
0.0276927371,
-0.0057302043,
-0.0231064968,
0.0077828388,
0.0052934703,
-0.032995671,
-0.0199191552,
0.007979962,
-0.0342416875,
0.0339758098,
0.0290432237,
0.031447053,
-0.0361477472,
-0.0528036579,
-0.0103606191,
-0.0157968197,
-0.0035591736,
-0.0096114641,
0.0970418528,
0.0006608004,
-0.0009612783,
-0.0141653921,
0.0995403975,
-0.0351545289,
-0.0187720023,
0.0417439155,
0.045273263,
-0.0095134815,
-0.0022107102,
0.0092752138,
-0.0330473855,
-0.0163021833,
0.0672702938,
0.0075922604,
-0.0277830958,
-0.0192997325,
-0.0314389467,
0.0312269833,
-0.0203025211,
-0.0132962298,
0.0259690117,
-0.0082825655,
0.0011268442,
-0.0565838069,
-0.0207606163,
-0.0176677126,
-0.0045448197,
0.030510366,
0.066459924,
0.021943206,
-0.0213743132,
-0.0526265502,
-0.0011905186,
-0.0912765041,
-0.017325772,
-0.0069078514,
0.0129398927,
-0.0034646401,
-0.0124168117,
0.0177338962,
-0.0047894963,
-0.0737883225,
-0.0532289669,
0.0359914117,
0.023578329,
0.0225944761,
0.0551148206,
-0.0102654975,
-0.0647429004,
0.0887566656,
0.0603862181,
-0.0509192571,
0.0134207085,
0.0505871773,
0.0099072438,
-0.0098668961,
0.0511536449,
-0.0361711718,
-0.0387313664,
0.0690373257,
-0.0349750705,
-0.0397673994,
-0.007449287,
0.0079129664,
0.0333360322,
0.0414158963,
0.0409963615,
0.0134774474,
-0.0176145751,
0.0310333204,
-0.0019341592,
-0.0354250968,
0.0128003536,
0.0131838312,
0.0514380932,
0.0056654261,
0.0223796945,
-0.0032563072,
0.0064109345,
0.0375022739,
-0.0481583476,
-0.0018077146,
0.0640594438,
-0.0019959225,
-0.003862448,
0.0028297589,
-0.014291483,
0.043205943,
0.0249747373,
0.0562350415,
0.0156211862,
0.0275075361,
0.0070220833,
0.0233098604,
-0.0376377963,
-0.0109533258,
-0.0737937316,
-0.0348920003,
-0.000626954,
0.0288235582,
0.0226540044,
-0.0043998174,
-0.0105965687,
-0.0008976719,
-0.0019207706,
-0.0348596573,
0.0097153308,
-0.0100148879,
0.0047540832,
0.002173187,
0.0199207384,
-0.0208160877,
0.04369203,
0.1005643979,
0.0059570321,
0.048283875,
-0.0073172469,
-0.0059802127,
-0.0578464717,
-0.0423643291,
0.0008621624,
0.0223526414,
0.0074071814,
-0.0259195063,
-0.0270559825,
-0.0622154251,
0.03032027,
-0.0026560365,
0.0097432975,
-0.0103063164,
0.0035094558,
0.0491624586,
0.0010479084,
-0.0002420809,
-0.0760855526,
0.0169210341,
0.0322853215,
-0.0543250032,
0.0092557427,
-5.394203986e-33,
0.0378370807,
-0.03952571,
-0.0023421526,
0.0581891425,
0.0102045573,
0.0249612927,
0.0034088753,
-0.0072318679,
-0.0402392223,
0.0074601579,
-0.0572563261,
0.0359016731,
-0.0015618147,
0.0285773557,
-0.0112991929,
-0.0494360514,
0.0281951968,
-0.0244824123,
-0.0177718401,
0.023039585,
0.0787559301,
0.0451974683,
0.0395731851,
-0.0816427246,
0.0567799844,
-0.0382956825,
-0.0528458245,
0.0454594083,
-0.0629760101,
0.0468648896,
-0.0282563698,
0.0375426672,
0.0081581073,
0.004512643,
-0.0055706506,
0.0092024263,
-0.0890500993,
-0.0214249939,
0.0039952337,
-0.0073679239,
-0.0095955217,
-0.0826811269,
0.0605358183,
-0.0308812186,
-0.0037165468,
-0.0498389825,
0.0267646257,
-0.0035993385,
-0.047489658,
-0.0411395766,
0.0224399995,
0.0014456784,
-0.022224525,
0.0066576051,
0.0343715809,
0.0122782355,
-0.0100793922,
-0.019248046,
-0.0863846987,
-0.0031380616,
0.0238235947,
0.020540284,
0.0399485044,
0.0077583091,
0.0018265647,
0.0901419744,
0.0511203781,
0.0378235802,
0.0434695482,
-0.0037543303,
0.0126350783,
0.0240275338,
0.0485338122,
0.0754355341,
0.0248365682,
-0.0252861269,
-0.0551159121,
0.0130856968,
-0.0297951251,
0.0105848517,
0.0181101132,
0.0264430437,
-0.0135755707,
-0.0036525587,
-0.0771544129,
0.0129520167,
-0.0480355248,
0.023381006,
-0.0095897485,
0.0067146253,
-0.0401870571,
-0.023213556,
-0.011269805,
-0.0474993363,
-0.0205929838,
0.0498712398,
0.0330044217,
-0.0018792729,
0.0111323334,
-0.0018103266,
-0.0372891538,
-0.00837381,
-0.0226185881,
0.0018996629,
0.0446603037,
0.0021591575,
0.0910412148,
0.007457363,
-0.04656161,
-0.0196923558,
-0.0247787479,
0.025833752,
0.0252627246,
0.0040540402,
0.0056589432,
0.0126816863,
-0.0043565971,
-0.001628441,
0.0526283532,
0.0197946858,
-0.0566726774,
0.0253992118,
0.0047230483,
-0.0062777931,
0.0020695608,
-0.0470522568,
0.0290460307,
0.0495950319,
0.0695624724,
-0.0214812886,
0.0241544861,
0.0074747503,
2.388e-7,
0.0192593411,
-0.0207522269,
0.0241861269,
-0.0302161463,
0.0318343677,
0.0602473319,
0.0008419679,
0.0486682467,
0.018818764,
-0.0253224541,
0.0051894309,
0.0121533209,
0.0829956383,
0.0110356649,
-0.0958966315,
0.0030010222,
-0.047127068,
-0.0346604735,
-0.0426956862,
0.004508452,
0.017906988,
0.0711297542,
0.0580381081,
-0.0332635716,
-0.0047814883,
-0.0347516052,
0.0489477888,
-0.0549210571,
-0.0297107454,
0.0108706886,
0.0551437698,
0.0381573476,
0.0227185804,
-0.0005954136,
-0.0386230461,
0.0125097129,
-0.0123529769,
0.074739933,
0.0533702895,
-0.0588082932,
-0.0166510064,
-0.0196893848,
0.0044068294,
-0.0112451483,
0.0579502061,
0.0186234526,
-0.028405698,
0.0121891331,
-0.0055790409,
-0.0582354441,
0.0493240133,
0.0086572841,
-0.0005493593,
0.0330889039,
-0.0203291997,
0.0096333046,
-0.0039719092,
-0.0417619571,
-0.0481046848,
0.000782857,
-0.0298046637,
-0.0362757035,
0.0182977468,
0.0068173716,
-0.0158975776,
-0.0980537236,
0.069006905,
1.992818558e-34,
-0.0036668743,
-0.0137708047,
0.008002759,
0.0276105478,
0.030103121,
-0.0214436594,
0.0110455463,
0.0166570824,
0.0157078542,
-0.04931641,
0.0118397865
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06118v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06118v3 | Extreme Compression of Large Language Models via Additive Quantization | 2024-01-11T18:54:44 | 2024-06-08T10:55:52 | Vage Egiazarian, Andrei Panferov, Denis Kuznedelev, Elias Frantar, Artem Babenko, Dan Alistarh | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | The emergence of accurate open large language models (LLMs) has led to a race
towards performant quantization techniques which can enable their execution on
end-user devices. In this paper, we revisit the problem of ``extreme'' LLM
compression -- defined as targeting extremely low bit counts, such as 2 to 3
bits per parameter -- from the point of view of classic methods in
Multi-Codebook Quantization (MCQ). Our algorithm, called AQLM, generalizes the
classic Additive Quantization (AQ) approach for information retrieval to
advance the state-of-the-art in LLM compression, via two innovations: 1)
learned additive quantization of weight matrices in input-adaptive fashion, and
2) joint optimization of codebook parameters across each transformer blocks.
Broadly, AQLM is the first scheme that is Pareto optimal in terms of
accuracy-vs-model-size when compressing to less than 3 bits per parameter, and
significantly improves upon all known schemes in the extreme compression (2bit)
regime. In addition, AQLM is practical: we provide fast GPU and CPU
implementations of AQLM for token generation, which enable us to match or
outperform optimized FP16 implementations for speed, while executing in a much
smaller memory footprint. | [
-0.0191352945,
0.0650075525,
0.008371749,
0.0277339388,
-0.0230342485,
0.0113511216,
0.0221451167,
0.0558727346,
-0.0329467356,
-0.0261304881,
0.0165274125,
-0.0356728211,
-0.0176315699,
0.0156659596,
0.0217254441,
0.0178665649,
0.0435745642,
-0.007973454,
-0.0094847707,
-0.0356520787,
-0.0231169965,
-0.0032084787,
0.0610961393,
0.0418827012,
0.0083168624,
0.003649686,
-0.0327437408,
0.0097192507,
-0.0506501682,
0.0097281756,
-0.0250702146,
0.0474620461,
0.0514799803,
0.0269126799,
0.0000020685,
-0.0286744032,
-0.0745744258,
0.0128824087,
-0.0408662483,
0.0159224588,
0.0555283874,
-0.0042032734,
-0.0214266628,
0.0172185488,
-0.0241253786,
-0.041544389,
0.0602363907,
0.0284797158,
0.0690024793,
0.0249049086,
-0.0105459569,
-0.0474511907,
0.0212762188,
-0.0124113951,
-0.0019387694,
-0.0168384798,
0.0403076448,
0.0052271178,
0.0076169637,
-0.0050111338,
-0.0214254521,
-0.0006319301,
0.0041736457,
0.0053874184,
-0.0060601872,
0.0090349307,
-0.0620319322,
-0.0034948529,
-0.005251776,
0.0306960791,
-0.0669773892,
-0.0561315045,
0.0012394632,
0.0396068208,
-0.0260325745,
-0.0814367384,
-0.0692921951,
0.0632742345,
0.0008910254,
0.0370581597,
-0.0231600367,
-0.0247527007,
0.0365502946,
0.0256411377,
-0.0565332733,
0.0594297945,
0.0386509188,
-0.0257589631,
-0.0300007593,
-0.0288606137,
-0.0700127035,
-0.0342987813,
0.0196053963,
0.0091930628,
0.0205677729,
-0.0174008682,
-0.0537440069,
-0.05124956,
0.0166717991,
-0.040994104,
0.0531327277,
0.0637504533,
0.0025172359,
0.0350254513,
-0.058596462,
0.0663082376,
-0.0193682741,
0.0183801576,
-0.0527762882,
-0.0086887125,
-0.0017122,
-0.0052649667,
-0.0922865272,
0.0662628189,
-0.0666851029,
-0.0179600995,
-0.0319663025,
0.0156785417,
0.0229199473,
-0.0042154756,
0.016526036,
0.014965253,
-0.0046749641,
-0.0007699029,
0.0506261699,
-0.0131208589,
-0.0166945662,
-0.0053988695,
-0.0032664307,
-0.0394481793,
-0.0194946956,
0.0558229983,
0.0146178603,
-0.0210077688,
0.0264607463,
0.0086452523,
0.005652078,
-0.0511031821,
0.0205304809,
-0.0070236675,
-0.0037031083,
-0.0251831543,
-0.0179274138,
-0.0702702925,
0.0103335734,
-0.0011541407,
0.0142236296,
-0.013950415,
0.0159532148,
0.0208445024,
-0.0276087169,
0.0193922631,
-0.0305204708,
-0.0003852746,
0.0250750612,
-0.0022792763,
0.0496310182,
0.055871278,
0.012918056,
0.063316524,
0.0123725738,
-0.0046183486,
-0.0065215048,
0.0417562872,
0.0456793755,
0.0230497029,
-0.03811156,
-0.0127249882,
0.0104553932,
0.0348253138,
0.0559678301,
0.115927428,
-0.0792694241,
-0.0379736349,
0.0094228992,
0.0498140194,
0.0627367571,
0.0559562929,
-0.0074499249,
0.0073221866,
0.0073974459,
-0.0264589693,
0.0069854236,
0.0134011582,
0.0047720722,
0.0016614059,
0.1237201616,
0.0461484492,
-0.0115915695,
-0.0015439887,
-0.0271626581,
-0.0306825396,
0.0268103257,
-0.0135268178,
0.0145642394,
-0.0053217043,
-0.0315076783,
0.0958539993,
0.0311013907,
-0.0968689471,
-0.0242758393,
-0.0801836327,
-0.0120164249,
0.0239261333,
0.0538524836,
0.0209162682,
0.040090993,
0.0113307536,
-0.0301622897,
-0.0131410062,
-0.0204535462,
-0.0055646729,
0.0104463538,
-0.0783476382,
-0.0216977503,
0.0413225107,
-0.0004137559,
-0.0070440215,
0.0396467596,
0.0007005579,
-0.0053161979,
-0.0248929337,
-0.0130953882,
-0.0004832637,
0.0052144188,
-0.0378165431,
0.0383413918,
0.0002799065,
-0.0031479236,
0.0164237246,
0.0030120707,
-0.0025779733,
0.0661017299,
-0.0493064523,
-0.0087690568,
-0.0671460629,
-0.0083466321,
0.0153304124,
0.0805049464,
0.0125120096,
0.0682276264,
0.0536501594,
-0.014450361,
-0.0546386689,
0.0091329776,
-0.0306720734,
0.0551223345,
-0.0691926852,
0.0007485977,
-0.0092443908,
0.0367734842,
-0.0386176892,
0.0248953328,
-0.0252560228,
0.0288882572,
0.0106505677,
-0.0079803029,
0.0087760435,
-0.0457913093,
-0.0366530009,
0.0404982567,
-0.0120522827,
0.0441757105,
0.022249328,
-0.0198801067,
0.0107866162,
-0.0426248275,
-0.1336087883,
0.0163765755,
-0.0322026908,
0.007070242,
0.0138188228,
0.0452281497,
0.0039336318,
0.0003422965,
-0.0397883989,
-0.0201628078,
-0.0077579049,
0.0099210255,
-0.017292995,
0.0056992974,
-0.0161902383,
0.0035886527,
-0.0616135076,
0.0169911552,
0.0665825233,
-0.0621268488,
-0.037398804,
-0.0520663299,
-0.0148330573,
-0.0284877047,
0.0344930962,
0.0035730114,
-0.0360218249,
-0.0027797967,
-0.0451760069,
0.0280896723,
0.0293816701,
0.0354389139,
0.0037331581,
0.056399662,
0.0207853224,
-0.0505381487,
0.0266750306,
-0.0359693281,
-0.0655029789,
-0.0109961564,
-0.0239291582,
-0.02610863,
0.0490012281,
-0.0298781376,
-0.0073706312,
-0.0537980087,
-0.0175160319,
0.0039866613,
-0.0122242635,
-0.0550368428,
-0.0027753934,
-0.0211835094,
0.0491904058,
0.001137939,
-0.0479364581,
0.0095722163,
-0.0595516413,
0.0032191426,
-0.0047557796,
-0.0212660544,
-0.0457236096,
0.0417060405,
0.0018619263,
0.0708612278,
-0.0369964838,
-0.005405549,
-0.0125826662,
0.030773595,
-0.0199657157,
-0.0663684383,
0.0121308621,
0.0322050042,
0.0355402566,
-0.036733944,
-0.0473397709,
0.016634699,
-0.019846797,
0.0093016187,
0.0201808158,
0.0384826101,
-0.0421234928,
-0.0300769787,
0.0681095645,
0.0020561998,
0.0560665093,
-0.0181325302,
0.0132431462,
0.0048524793,
0.019232247,
0.0403032154,
-0.0020986169,
0.0349445306,
-0.0107631525,
-0.0095971366,
0.0509743579,
0.0545585193,
0.0459814854,
-0.0247397609,
0.005047725,
0.0666828603,
0.0057003689,
-0.0171416122,
0.0264697112,
0.013774612,
-0.0080902223,
0.0073302514,
0.0873092115,
0.020787606,
-0.074357152,
-0.0088562192,
-0.0146118207,
0.0232147053,
0.0031315121,
0.0281267911,
-0.1243492737,
-0.0076920963,
0.0218791794,
0.0300169457,
0.0128605254,
-0.0154578881,
0.0012308008,
-0.0619091988,
0.0162960868,
0.0259043276,
0.0326211751,
-0.0247803871,
-0.0252054073,
-0.0161480028,
-0.0195915736,
0.0412567109,
0.0473334678,
-0.004715824,
-0.0069190627,
0.0073481901,
0.0171629712,
0.0061067757,
0.0245730765,
0.0191515405,
0.0243689343,
0.0322275646,
0.0182897653,
0.0149571029,
-0.0128965359,
0.0034525895,
0.0259380993,
-0.0266340598,
-0.0274065286,
-0.0100806644,
0.0084967632,
0.0057063345,
0.0095692324,
0.0019594077,
0.0215081777,
-0.0167133827,
-0.0519852154,
0.0489863157,
0.0047727637,
0.0080774752,
0.0017140809,
-0.0530771501,
-0.0255854111,
0.0683408082,
-0.0034879551,
-0.0003337074,
-0.0370537303,
-0.0256084185,
-0.0065286877,
-0.022636205,
-0.0302198641,
-0.0026138637,
0.0034113035,
-0.0328671932,
-0.0311042704,
0.0681248903,
0.0006063676,
0.0269181039,
-0.0448878035,
0.0013119926,
-0.001793068,
-0.0107034938,
-0.0988746732,
-0.0171586666,
-0.0614996329,
-0.0070049651,
-0.0884439498,
0.0219173767,
0.0021134897,
-0.0251149386,
-0.0262248442,
-0.0034433822,
-0.1047997177,
-0.0583985001,
0.010335586,
0.0011800228,
0.0239204597,
0.0352191627,
0.0129721239,
-0.068510659,
0.03181348,
0.0547738597,
-0.0351358913,
0.0596012101,
-0.0001393072,
-0.0385884047,
-0.0169220157,
0.028868204,
-0.0450423062,
0.0294564385,
-0.0320560113,
0.0398968272,
-0.0387712568,
-0.0604042262,
0.0291400794,
0.0394392163,
0.046024587,
-0.013938209,
-0.0152713247,
0.0290075932,
0.0492572226,
0.0062126452,
0.0038965943,
-0.0269523039,
0.0018924107,
0.0148186227,
-0.0082073025,
0.0185300373,
-0.0186961126,
0.0585373603,
0.0202076063,
0.0012607205,
0.0113421967,
-0.0833955184,
0.0002148323,
0.0588701367,
-0.0235641766,
-0.0356973335,
-0.0115480162,
0.0145650916,
0.0412790552,
-0.0650988221,
-0.0032526962,
-0.0051110703,
0.0234546866,
-0.0273877792,
0.0445643738,
-0.0159019455,
-0.0581140928,
-0.0511407666,
-0.0071891835,
0.0439446531,
0.0369513147,
0.0126388138,
-0.0195115507,
-0.0225225557,
-0.0446990617,
-0.0085885506,
0.0128420619,
-0.0160976723,
0.0133569129,
0.0144918673,
-0.0201679599,
0.0163128469,
0.0493147001,
0.0107906545,
0.0262295753,
-0.0069650798,
0.009803189,
-0.0306221507,
-0.0241632294,
-0.0090394663,
0.0240514893,
-0.0086660553,
-0.0233139023,
-0.0046228678,
-0.0053055934,
0.0308776367,
0.0159820169,
-0.0117205651,
-0.0175663605,
0.030268494,
0.0532007217,
0.0128184929,
-0.0151371015,
-0.0316619091,
-0.0155552169,
0.0239238217,
-0.0021843794,
0.0245939549,
-6.43018479e-33,
-0.0105870664,
0.0235813204,
0.0082145827,
-0.0414507464,
-0.0059531284,
0.0135375122,
0.0018009151,
-0.0182427224,
-0.0102681145,
-0.0499296859,
-0.0235138331,
0.0116464272,
0.0244524945,
0.0330830961,
-0.0421821512,
0.0356877483,
0.0601801127,
0.0026571883,
-0.0154577158,
0.0508902073,
0.0280947685,
0.0129430322,
0.0083400747,
0.0111516053,
-0.0518438444,
-0.0086515388,
-0.0010737288,
-0.0053301412,
0.0301055927,
0.0564139858,
-0.0287497938,
0.0112658096,
-0.0137644662,
-0.0285429712,
-0.0072439057,
0.0048900992,
-0.0608743653,
0.0070674266,
0.0221279431,
-0.0061509791,
0.0266127121,
-0.0521339402,
0.0348311737,
0.0178618468,
-0.0421639383,
-0.0135062523,
-0.0446942821,
-0.0145111792,
-0.0718106031,
-0.0779170543,
0.0159052424,
0.0274417121,
0.0387375467,
0.0413879827,
0.0736293569,
-0.0141020268,
-0.0349544697,
0.0115143592,
-0.0466468707,
0.0241001062,
0.0120988619,
0.0874737278,
0.0255170874,
0.0007980355,
0.0219045114,
0.0266835112,
0.027080724,
-0.0329007357,
-0.0352187529,
0.0670055524,
0.0402216576,
0.0099286372,
0.0309911035,
0.0539812222,
0.0878957808,
-0.0276329853,
-0.0688000098,
0.0009656834,
-0.0012514249,
0.0148650398,
0.0437787957,
0.0484226756,
-0.0055343369,
-0.0336834528,
-0.0472814776,
0.0379197486,
-0.0418688804,
-0.0372378305,
-0.0059809471,
0.0364284441,
-0.0404128246,
-0.0271607172,
0.0417906642,
-0.039426174,
-0.0222220607,
0.0106466562,
0.0083825011,
0.0118881417,
0.0034259108,
0.0488507673,
-0.0039002143,
-0.0316777565,
0.0238944758,
-0.0382283591,
0.005194352,
-0.0011350251,
0.0105132507,
0.0612624623,
-0.0988191962,
-0.0167911034,
-0.0080929836,
-0.0044062221,
0.0071001691,
0.0062331697,
0.0354978479,
0.0310960971,
0.0298765171,
0.0282654054,
-0.0065062824,
0.0198679101,
-0.026824642,
-0.044701457,
0.0310856234,
0.0440762378,
-0.0112933246,
0.0335291438,
-0.071318835,
0.0300390795,
0.0671726167,
-0.0535338223,
-0.032331299,
0.064646095,
2.831e-7,
0.0242731925,
0.0473423786,
0.0222692806,
-0.05009735,
-0.0186471902,
-0.0012929371,
0.0085835811,
0.0235421564,
0.0058566728,
-0.0043652565,
-0.0090687452,
0.0174936038,
0.0126036359,
-0.0051977909,
-0.0820360705,
0.0483569205,
-0.0484467708,
0.0106223235,
-0.0449288972,
0.000115865,
0.0358155146,
0.1522262245,
-0.0397266634,
-0.0074944142,
0.020631386,
-0.0452732407,
0.0416925102,
0.0042148381,
0.0134548014,
-0.0071562044,
0.0097434819,
0.0015093365,
-0.0052092955,
-0.0555545725,
0.0179282147,
0.0120682837,
-0.0171248857,
0.0763377473,
-0.0068455199,
0.0047613541,
0.0290183034,
-0.0393366516,
-0.0430048332,
-0.0421557203,
0.0673840269,
0.0070494143,
0.0048191608,
-0.0657922179,
-0.007126295,
0.024024412,
-0.0205664076,
-0.0087598776,
0.0351335257,
0.0507031158,
0.0160627123,
0.0034230975,
0.0377608836,
-0.0853939801,
-0.0318060741,
-0.0200668015,
-0.0161112603,
-0.0482637063,
-0.0533965118,
0.0114660542,
0.0238392465,
-0.0535743684,
0.0282769781,
2.96147205e-34,
0.0311317388,
0.0025550134,
0.0270523969,
0.0308130756,
0.0010017507,
-0.0555016994,
-0.0088298246,
0.0427209586,
-0.0339826569,
-0.1072025895,
-0.0343279652
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06112v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06112v2 | Axis Tour: Word Tour Determines the Order of Axes in ICA-transformed Embeddings | 2024-01-11T18:46:12 | 2024-06-13T13:44:03 | Hiroaki Yamagiwa, Yusuke Takase, Hidetoshi Shimodaira | cs.CL | cs.CL | Word embedding is one of the most important components in natural language
processing, but interpreting high-dimensional embeddings remains a challenging
problem. To address this problem, Independent Component Analysis (ICA) is
identified as an effective solution. ICA-transformed word embeddings reveal
interpretable semantic axes; however, the order of these axes are arbitrary. In
this study, we focus on this property and propose a novel method, Axis Tour,
which optimizes the order of the axes. Inspired by Word Tour, a one-dimensional
word embedding method, we aim to improve the clarity of the word embedding
space by maximizing the semantic continuity of the axes. Furthermore, we show
through experiments on downstream tasks that Axis Tour yields better or
comparable low-dimensional embeddings compared to both PCA and ICA. | [
-0.0095059006,
0.0505951568,
0.0049017752,
0.0723666102,
-0.0413049534,
0.03369762,
0.011373356,
-0.0028548981,
0.0094862878,
-0.0131895989,
-0.0376013592,
-0.0210108645,
0.0569853745,
0.0126570044,
0.004440553,
-0.0389833488,
0.0664425194,
-0.0093278419,
-0.0271930192,
0.0160112511,
-0.0213808957,
-0.0272179078,
-0.0340834707,
0.0236404072,
-0.0563488267,
-0.0422583148,
0.0243826285,
-0.051421538,
0.0113229314,
-0.0485601239,
-0.0771070272,
0.0258626323,
0.0400903337,
0.0149684474,
0.0000019071,
0.0196817499,
-0.0261990484,
-0.0115979258,
0.0428169519,
0.0146847153,
-0.0021909997,
-0.0448736846,
0.0149427876,
-0.0265676416,
-0.0187795963,
-0.0479287431,
0.0505010039,
0.1006103829,
0.0094506163,
0.0462563448,
-0.0199905224,
-0.0504153036,
-0.0388546549,
-0.0509610996,
-0.0144150024,
-0.0023919761,
0.0217648633,
-0.068173632,
-0.0743737146,
0.0481644236,
-0.0694219396,
0.0188876204,
-0.0196885671,
0.0042802938,
0.0467560515,
0.0657211021,
0.0162733663,
-0.0164702125,
0.0033326573,
0.1022700742,
0.0165319629,
0.028359931,
0.0013235137,
-0.019477956,
0.0014946507,
0.0301640723,
-0.0554243736,
-0.0190332271,
0.0458513871,
0.0473586544,
0.0033743314,
0.0309631694,
0.0055830181,
-0.0432589948,
-0.0304999314,
0.0547019318,
0.0198979136,
-0.0566408709,
-0.0153667321,
0.0029158855,
0.0281521864,
0.0631953627,
-0.0010218732,
-0.0180687737,
0.0257182233,
0.0125958053,
0.0201991536,
0.0047183358,
-0.0128177069,
-0.0424536094,
0.0293154046,
0.0101721799,
-0.0185114667,
0.0277319737,
0.0173987281,
0.0247822236,
-0.0181931462,
0.0620128587,
-0.0420557968,
0.0491567031,
-0.0063691917,
-0.0132745281,
-0.0037115836,
0.0074836812,
-0.0255918093,
-0.0502575934,
0.0045129689,
0.0201743226,
-0.0393154286,
-0.0359130539,
0.0046632108,
0.0495266467,
0.0069034086,
0.0123853469,
0.0244630203,
0.0664538741,
-0.0557070896,
0.0110338656,
-0.0793818906,
0.0087111443,
-0.0460237227,
0.0734062269,
0.0317396782,
0.008191742,
-0.0445067473,
0.0716186464,
-0.0051023355,
-0.0350954607,
0.0312141217,
0.0104095424,
-0.0080743805,
0.0006814171,
0.0303941444,
-0.0506410003,
0.0690453202,
-0.0025503014,
0.0176681317,
-0.0651755333,
-0.0013335811,
0.0100291632,
-0.0740240291,
0.075100787,
-0.0105504645,
0.0183360111,
0.0066348561,
0.0104727382,
0.0460487567,
0.0114493156,
0.0285159592,
-0.0342478305,
0.0494673178,
-0.0356650762,
0.0322203077,
0.0204793327,
-0.0475491993,
-0.0346375927,
-0.0512486659,
-0.0279492605,
0.0274710692,
0.0261445921,
0.0142279025,
0.0252017323,
-0.016395336,
-0.0108750053,
-0.0063337949,
0.0716274306,
0.0009585225,
-0.0327730291,
0.0096230833,
0.0305297133,
-0.0224154741,
0.0385065898,
-0.0169285629,
-0.0003118179,
0.0811749846,
-0.0382300876,
0.0223961659,
-0.0394767001,
-0.0201109648,
-0.0173056163,
-0.0121947508,
-0.0104525285,
0.0139424913,
-0.0758334622,
0.0162472073,
-0.004257109,
-0.0024865491,
0.0087203188,
0.0554134697,
-0.0481676273,
-0.0296056345,
0.0223954953,
0.0040818993,
0.0376036428,
0.0190883186,
-0.024878392,
0.0092344824,
0.0136930887,
0.0076599456,
0.0466861278,
-0.0156376697,
-0.0196694285,
0.0070786919,
-0.0448069759,
-0.0366176516,
0.044210583,
0.0285130981,
0.0412609838,
-0.0570876375,
-0.0039063655,
0.0027559856,
-0.0070930775,
0.0173344128,
0.0559031144,
0.020282872,
-0.0507643223,
0.0554355755,
0.0286262743,
0.0156662893,
0.0292444732,
-0.0167319141,
0.0219954289,
0.0475279354,
-0.0607620962,
-0.0136329522,
0.0372393057,
-0.0296044946,
-0.0617818721,
-0.0081732254,
-0.0785942227,
-0.0103559671,
0.0039410307,
-0.0122965965,
-0.023916645,
0.0269956291,
-0.0281359497,
-0.0392307118,
0.0078719845,
-0.0172395892,
0.0020807707,
0.0668343529,
-0.0431515239,
0.0541012213,
-0.0184578318,
0.046952989,
0.0237459354,
0.0102937911,
0.042746108,
-0.0025785225,
0.0085638706,
0.0575157888,
-0.0011175137,
-0.0130843064,
-0.0102650523,
0.0125518311,
-0.0146623077,
-0.0013347049,
-0.0516968854,
-0.0265291631,
-0.0041954978,
0.0200250521,
0.0180035252,
-0.0150652919,
-0.0026788886,
-0.0298717115,
-0.0428419374,
0.0402184054,
-0.0532891341,
0.023255717,
0.0399326347,
-0.0327267274,
-0.0205289517,
-0.0287005678,
-0.0092193913,
-0.0259237085,
0.0652941018,
0.0059533603,
-0.004819823,
-0.0092535932,
-0.0341568328,
-0.010400393,
-0.0005229576,
-0.011390795,
-0.0184795819,
0.0364326984,
-0.0259682704,
0.0211866815,
0.0053089196,
0.007988588,
0.0270375777,
0.0478263162,
-0.0379679874,
-0.0177012254,
-0.0066575673,
-0.0313718617,
0.1172119752,
0.0138656506,
-0.0085410262,
-0.0013680743,
0.0839091837,
0.0545667447,
0.0192504171,
-0.0362489633,
-0.0268593337,
-0.040460486,
-0.0015284657,
-0.056620691,
-0.0053074867,
-0.0646802485,
-0.0392867215,
0.0031974653,
-0.0003493318,
0.0145177674,
-0.0462100133,
0.0128201414,
-0.0507551096,
0.005410308,
-0.0556733012,
0.037995439,
-0.0267814603,
-0.003470236,
-0.052054435,
-0.037881773,
0.0122396164,
0.0457092486,
-0.0169929732,
-0.028917823,
-0.0028674793,
-0.0077575049,
-0.0001841112,
-0.0015809169,
0.0032219477,
-0.0198734291,
-0.0879939049,
0.0178776663,
-0.0411230735,
0.0262311324,
-0.0145745762,
-0.0200389177,
0.0174248274,
0.0393490456,
0.0221657157,
-0.0086891986,
0.0221794024,
-0.0319993123,
0.0735399202,
0.0197538026,
0.0355868116,
-0.0201345924,
0.0137342932,
0.0127381478,
0.0450355932,
0.0160077587,
0.0059005595,
0.0163432825,
0.0285917949,
-0.0024241963,
0.0298218802,
-0.0644987375,
-0.0262481794,
-0.0119596357,
0.0029618503,
-0.0125126159,
0.0819853246,
0.0298505779,
-0.094326511,
0.0277919807,
0.0149987368,
0.0049719373,
0.0335439481,
-0.0060151536,
-0.0241258852,
-0.0324619748,
-0.0175663643,
0.0171967689,
0.0182180889,
-0.0224856641,
-0.0175202899,
-0.0788638964,
0.0417743288,
-0.0023384921,
0.0008494562,
-0.0538210981,
-0.0996220112,
0.015921779,
0.0001503824,
0.0086379442,
-0.0244783107,
-0.015969865,
-0.0051321103,
0.0103749093,
-0.0640268028,
-0.0229759589,
-0.0473133028,
0.0164317153,
0.0104470141,
-0.0222572815,
0.0680667087,
-0.0340415016,
-0.0503167249,
0.0266215224,
-0.0591259897,
0.0146115925,
-0.0232658722,
0.0477011353,
0.0071735876,
-0.0415895917,
0.0171801001,
0.0021906355,
-0.0612347946,
-0.0140700722,
-0.0159462783,
0.0749273002,
-0.0219202545,
-0.006684674,
-0.0380346365,
-0.0220280439,
-0.000630952,
0.0636529848,
0.0406440757,
-0.0313384235,
-0.0032587263,
0.0118425004,
0.0603048205,
0.0326387286,
-0.0305611696,
-0.0113388542,
0.0124900499,
-0.0687457845,
-0.098624967,
-0.0453300104,
0.0197642297,
0.0797434747,
-0.0048717759,
0.0271029938,
-0.0421673506,
-0.0154281035,
-0.0026309427,
0.0290107038,
-0.0367535166,
0.0095967259,
0.0018782952,
0.0284188408,
0.0037524391,
0.0220047198,
-0.0560939759,
0.0211525131,
0.0201913714,
-0.0512333363,
0.0251494758,
-0.0365496837,
-0.0001776,
0.0401520245,
-0.0264199469,
-0.0069503351,
0.0504500009,
0.0394842401,
-0.0092869522,
0.0237992425,
0.0128709683,
-0.0379623994,
-0.0045553748,
0.0305836573,
-0.0182655696,
0.040440768,
-0.0238807425,
0.058667738,
0.0046784128,
-0.0214071907,
-0.0167875364,
0.0249613002,
0.09319105,
0.0390162729,
0.0286628082,
-0.0551532246,
-0.0131879849,
-0.0648070648,
-0.0229343139,
0.0009296478,
-0.0066747423,
0.042144157,
-0.0301765129,
-0.0593787245,
0.0332625918,
-0.0073473142,
-0.0457239859,
-0.0311429296,
0.0094460603,
0.0327088237,
-0.0203923974,
-0.0549218133,
0.043038357,
-0.0220201239,
0.0232924595,
-0.031322401,
-0.0272697117,
-0.0127819171,
0.0081427684,
-0.0113744354,
-0.0105056027,
-0.0808191299,
0.0294466279,
-0.0397171117,
0.0333957635,
0.0168109518,
0.0098372046,
0.0049903868,
-0.0137133822,
0.0722370967,
0.0330389552,
0.0138370851,
0.0169930123,
-0.011161143,
0.0093835555,
-0.0035984237,
0.0518169254,
-0.0084368717,
-0.0344227776,
0.0042902604,
0.0796342567,
-0.0330962799,
0.0063922219,
-0.0816751495,
0.0121658985,
-0.056330096,
0.0583433062,
0.0056539644,
0.0548949093,
-0.0198116526,
0.0306826625,
-0.0379061773,
-0.0178172346,
0.0089502782,
-0.0315140225,
-0.0128357112,
0.0237900931,
0.0261095371,
0.0334974267,
0.0196773838,
0.0426708087,
0.0039020763,
-0.0149392383,
-0.029473817,
-0.0544126891,
-0.0226371959,
-6.330350789e-33,
0.0002463677,
-0.0000381314,
-0.0387801267,
0.0288779996,
-0.0483440496,
0.0284759104,
-0.0233525168,
0.0434191599,
-0.0099047562,
0.0597649962,
-0.0095059415,
-0.0010572653,
0.0059129717,
0.0119264759,
0.0137077365,
0.0181416832,
0.0270850733,
-0.0223799925,
-0.0478264764,
0.0152081465,
0.0793506503,
0.0215055421,
0.0681437403,
-0.0934668556,
0.0092974734,
-0.0018324333,
0.010493705,
0.0223104749,
0.0323373973,
0.021582339,
-0.0731923208,
0.0505311489,
0.0494145192,
-0.0268985815,
-0.0089715887,
0.0618209876,
-0.0287369713,
-0.0750291049,
-0.0029989821,
0.0208438355,
-0.0441069864,
-0.0321424827,
0.0714262798,
-0.0003569969,
-0.0204184875,
0.0144248037,
0.0437839814,
0.0207455512,
-0.0053809383,
0.0605490245,
-0.0462748371,
0.0187207162,
-0.0294759292,
-0.0031574005,
0.043011032,
-0.0119529925,
0.0038970695,
-0.0066523505,
-0.0300539043,
0.0268059745,
-0.0519572794,
0.0257293079,
0.016963724,
-0.0302309021,
-0.004308566,
0.0919551626,
0.0531673916,
-0.055956278,
-0.0072666383,
-0.0665300339,
0.0266690403,
0.0295142792,
0.009195677,
0.0086603425,
-0.0059059737,
-0.0135312062,
-0.0386161469,
0.0097857779,
0.0033536276,
0.0059953183,
0.0423377119,
-0.0102524469,
-0.0852339864,
-0.0184385013,
-0.0241601523,
-0.0362304337,
-0.0183285028,
0.0005993316,
0.0286211539,
0.0117948148,
-0.0414196625,
0.0192980282,
0.0144563438,
-0.0264429934,
0.005690509,
0.0630781353,
-0.0388626046,
0.0509024821,
0.023975879,
-0.0488503538,
-0.0369409882,
-0.0341777951,
0.0086325258,
-0.0276845023,
0.0361437835,
-0.0358345658,
0.0251509659,
-0.0051188464,
-0.065266557,
-0.032924924,
0.0038119345,
-0.0794411078,
-0.0272924975,
0.0176835582,
0.0389731303,
-0.0128680505,
-0.0268807281,
0.0414936244,
0.0192071646,
0.0565291084,
0.0005753866,
-0.0436118431,
-0.0000490535,
0.0248899329,
-0.0306475312,
-0.0222084466,
0.0195038468,
-0.014519251,
0.0377634279,
-0.0753381699,
-0.0124769872,
0.0222108737,
2.657e-7,
0.0175059978,
0.1028127745,
0.0120458798,
-0.0415398702,
0.055501841,
0.0244331658,
-0.0216082968,
0.0425959677,
-0.0670824498,
0.0027196333,
-0.0132254492,
0.0145432511,
-0.013915848,
0.0050915438,
-0.0076972772,
0.0755449012,
-0.0481453575,
0.0372478701,
-0.0202667117,
-0.0044857105,
0.0645695478,
0.0964002237,
-0.0107350508,
-0.0090342071,
-0.0343134515,
-0.0048852148,
0.0398224518,
0.0033110823,
0.0234327968,
-0.0303274635,
-0.0157923326,
0.0476036631,
0.0384343006,
-0.0139557142,
0.007585322,
0.0529402345,
0.0487962961,
0.0414667092,
-0.0391455628,
0.0226084068,
0.0405293107,
0.0297001898,
0.0061100917,
-0.0056945602,
0.0976597443,
-0.0362437405,
-0.0551663227,
-0.0425257422,
-0.0198902227,
0.049217619,
0.0357288681,
0.0433064438,
-0.0107821058,
-0.003691531,
0.0109416163,
-0.0161935929,
-0.0394994654,
-0.0511505865,
0.0008226255,
-0.0017971609,
-0.0322023146,
0.0291908532,
-0.0080600819,
-0.0116436789,
0.0501864254,
0.0006057801,
-0.0197170787,
2.158772416e-34,
-0.0090835346,
-0.0154940886,
-0.0124239381,
0.002211292,
-0.0275296085,
-0.0427491479,
0.0721313134,
-0.0019231216,
-0.0180499684,
-0.08783786,
0.0115588279
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06105v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06105v1 | PALP: Prompt Aligned Personalization of Text-to-Image Models | 2024-01-11T18:35:33 | 2024-01-11T18:35:33 | Moab Arar, Andrey Voynov, Amir Hertz, Omri Avrahami, Shlomi Fruchter, Yael Pritch, Daniel Cohen-Or, Ariel Shamir | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.GR, cs.LG | Content creators often aim to create personalized images using personal
subjects that go beyond the capabilities of conventional text-to-image models.
Additionally, they may want the resulting image to encompass a specific
location, style, ambiance, and more. Existing personalization methods may
compromise personalization ability or the alignment to complex textual prompts.
This trade-off can impede the fulfillment of user prompts and subject fidelity.
We propose a new approach focusing on personalization methods for a
\emph{single} prompt to address this issue. We term our approach prompt-aligned
personalization. While this may seem restrictive, our method excels in
improving text alignment, enabling the creation of images with complex and
intricate prompts, which may pose a challenge for current techniques. In
particular, our method keeps the personalized model aligned with a target
prompt using an additional score distillation sampling term. We demonstrate the
versatility of our method in multi- and single-shot settings and further show
that it can compose multiple subjects or use inspiration from reference images,
such as artworks. We compare our approach quantitatively and qualitatively with
existing baselines and state-of-the-art techniques. | [
0.018400209,
0.0295891501,
0.0289661977,
-0.0199042838,
-0.0378506556,
-0.0181018393,
0.0536044501,
0.0080082724,
-0.0364638865,
0.0049676737,
-0.0110289194,
-0.0019970089,
0.0024319054,
0.0458685905,
-0.0116230212,
-0.1187456399,
-0.0528428778,
-0.0368808471,
0.0029795356,
-0.0181410406,
0.030056309,
0.0224616062,
-0.032290563,
0.0184947662,
-0.0275998823,
-0.0741766021,
-0.0403605402,
0.067797929,
0.022265438,
-0.0302437004,
-0.0530469529,
0.0877424553,
-0.0021228485,
-0.0123825045,
0.0000020239,
-0.0246214531,
-0.003712133,
-0.006872904,
-0.0023604715,
0.0000888527,
0.0661989003,
0.0181440022,
-0.0060103359,
-0.0528847091,
-0.0202743858,
0.0751972869,
0.0684018061,
0.040829923,
0.0900564864,
0.0111168195,
-0.0048453473,
-0.0299273729,
-0.0299653709,
-0.0291395616,
0.0240653157,
0.0258010849,
-0.0200792942,
-0.0385560915,
0.0200116504,
0.0552366711,
-0.022002738,
0.029797405,
0.0029601685,
0.0055912393,
0.0678907558,
0.0377930366,
0.0212946162,
-0.0443045683,
-0.0425770953,
0.0482852794,
0.0042452645,
0.0357704759,
-0.0128629431,
-0.0276794303,
0.0010883245,
0.0260562431,
-0.058132425,
-0.027579898,
-0.0184287447,
0.0164622981,
-0.097732462,
0.0609827936,
-0.0265969504,
-0.0384561531,
0.0228715912,
-0.0142345773,
0.0539589003,
0.0072354772,
-0.0474159196,
0.0359901115,
-0.0478130206,
-0.0645872727,
0.0576559566,
-0.0061900592,
0.0195707604,
-0.0042030159,
-0.0581567176,
-0.0429305024,
0.0028430007,
0.0449194461,
0.0985813141,
0.0079192799,
-0.0364624821,
0.0357226394,
0.0168076456,
0.0371487699,
0.0052484833,
0.0052139536,
-0.0667033717,
0.030511234,
0.0165760815,
-0.0132201323,
-0.0340870619,
-0.0360730961,
-0.0771696419,
-0.032072477,
-0.0371146239,
0.0059940363,
-0.0038403939,
0.01355989,
0.0138860056,
0.0602720343,
-0.075540185,
0.0143948654,
-0.0172385052,
0.0029495505,
-0.0438936353,
-0.0117703136,
0.0261811335,
0.0366286226,
-0.0099832155,
-0.0077281157,
0.0603396185,
-0.0011520768,
-0.0429192521,
0.0149154486,
-0.0433714911,
0.0070433617,
0.0358607769,
-0.0078967381,
-0.0691465288,
0.011825664,
0.01185688,
-0.0272900518,
0.049391225,
-0.0158633348,
0.006965593,
-0.0480173342,
-0.0152559858,
0.0319588669,
0.0012711562,
0.0619048104,
0.0087076928,
0.0131805567,
0.0147155253,
-0.0123030888,
-0.008546913,
0.0149291391,
0.0145162195,
0.0989062339,
0.0363736339,
0.0001562839,
0.0003507584,
0.0220958665,
0.0057625393,
0.0069256932,
-0.0393581055,
-0.0186977033,
0.0291460231,
0.0181988776,
0.0059401942,
0.0242555924,
-0.0050346819,
0.0036170036,
0.1113288105,
0.0366583206,
0.0267367307,
-0.0285238177,
0.0267817359,
0.0395538546,
-0.0055247014,
0.01289328,
-0.0197942369,
0.0355609283,
0.0206513274,
0.0474221781,
0.0192722045,
0.0512318499,
-0.0357477888,
-0.022847347,
0.0208697729,
0.0089216465,
-0.0031905193,
-0.0022700953,
0.0096579697,
0.0458958223,
-0.0186512358,
0.0324909426,
-0.0157032777,
-0.043711029,
0.0216105673,
0.0193735845,
0.0465071723,
0.1072742045,
-0.0005559797,
0.0044747409,
0.04549665,
-0.0058478783,
0.0420735218,
0.0791841,
-0.0076370938,
0.0110303657,
0.024583241,
-0.0059297937,
-0.0330010317,
-0.0363753438,
-0.0347303264,
-0.0042080577,
-0.0337661766,
0.0158260129,
-0.0219294596,
0.0344982184,
0.0327106416,
0.0176903754,
0.0162952561,
-0.0923628137,
-0.0161078889,
0.0416556485,
-0.0261202771,
0.0373273976,
-0.0003347968,
-0.0022105544,
0.0283530224,
0.0025644689,
0.020162642,
0.0005102323,
-0.0208946764,
-0.0323407836,
0.0074257348,
-0.0463850163,
-0.0116877314,
-0.035431467,
-0.0164225213,
-0.027819844,
-0.0332527384,
0.0073266346,
-0.0111597953,
-0.016652124,
-0.000072585,
0.004281207,
0.0229465086,
-0.0645265505,
0.0342287943,
-0.0329890549,
-0.0118739363,
0.0087636253,
0.0308851153,
-0.033714775,
0.0105465511,
-0.0383913182,
-0.0379259177,
0.035844367,
-0.0128183896,
0.0003799087,
0.0228362344,
-0.049329225,
-0.0265424307,
-0.0730480924,
-0.0193702672,
0.0077393628,
-0.0326639488,
0.00089009,
0.0314208791,
-0.0043090996,
0.0054138182,
-0.0748554394,
-0.0343552902,
-0.0116480393,
0.003791102,
0.0633106232,
-0.0007251335,
0.0196622014,
-0.045940645,
0.0035992255,
0.0312507674,
0.0403032377,
0.0334336795,
0.0093010748,
-0.057665877,
-0.0082045346,
-0.0078743389,
-0.0021281817,
0.0391811356,
-0.0059901504,
0.0211170465,
-0.01576351,
0.038067814,
0.0996284485,
-0.0109534021,
-0.0073774261,
-0.0049738791,
-0.0097172176,
-0.0291361231,
0.0108882254,
-0.0455456413,
0.0093060387,
0.0690756366,
-0.0207283106,
0.0492041968,
0.0214166548,
-0.0049745962,
0.0499845631,
-0.0482484363,
0.0526153035,
0.0232624039,
-0.0001799085,
-0.0238312129,
0.0346854441,
-0.0095855137,
0.0184760187,
-0.0605988279,
-0.0704209656,
0.0468529388,
-0.0392033085,
-0.0433505215,
0.0383523144,
0.0085788025,
0.0313072763,
0.0349244289,
-0.0141498232,
0.0398669913,
0.0193501785,
0.0347206667,
-0.0416272059,
-0.0196129084,
0.0391076654,
-0.0186747424,
0.0200643819,
-0.0378671959,
-0.0218363758,
-0.0131835658,
-0.0465364158,
-0.0168144312,
-0.0559344962,
0.0134538598,
-0.0307421386,
-0.0235048328,
-0.0113165993,
0.0037988136,
0.0343588479,
-0.0364181846,
0.0180858821,
-0.0272341724,
-0.0066390983,
-0.0401603617,
0.0496567897,
0.0476486161,
-0.0248166248,
-0.064993456,
-0.045165062,
0.0045997459,
0.0326395854,
0.0079417974,
0.0070534842,
-0.0258995146,
0.0397940017,
0.0273242928,
0.0314112492,
-0.0126286624,
0.0322472379,
0.0976245329,
0.0053739208,
0.0241185799,
0.0711708069,
0.0136564933,
-0.0198849589,
-0.0152455736,
0.0272195246,
0.0548429042,
0.0256553162,
0.0068470063,
-0.0420534872,
-0.0156881344,
-0.0110627189,
0.0060652918,
0.0251022317,
-0.0084051592,
-0.0362353399,
-0.0512206554,
0.0206182096,
0.023447413,
0.0049691023,
0.0187730659,
0.0254952628,
0.0524065383,
0.0272181593,
-0.0325700194,
-0.0095745642,
-0.0027884513,
0.0157330632,
0.0133532044,
0.0543293059,
-0.0115632368,
-0.0560845397,
-0.0435296632,
0.0511597246,
0.0572952032,
0.0422406308,
0.050103493,
-0.0663391575,
-0.0739073902,
0.0454288945,
0.0325635225,
0.005925592,
0.0487786978,
0.0073033967,
0.0078183142,
-0.0265798774,
0.035782028,
0.0085502835,
-0.0308585372,
0.0315666199,
-0.0002025044,
0.0056757936,
0.0480401739,
-0.0677658021,
0.0108738197,
0.0287174955,
0.0166409034,
0.0191329382,
-0.0789723098,
-0.0378820933,
-0.0716593266,
0.0416249335,
-0.0562043265,
-0.022169346,
0.0090721408,
-0.0647178516,
-0.0342184491,
-0.0453022085,
-0.0026902377,
0.0387003273,
0.0702418238,
0.0063646017,
-0.0439972952,
-0.0640905276,
0.0229237899,
-0.0416987687,
0.0212383121,
-0.0448788777,
-0.0010931739,
-0.0167576727,
-0.002253996,
-0.0051804036,
-0.0570316911,
-0.0208987165,
-0.003018182,
-0.0707160458,
-0.0154547887,
0.0111888722,
0.0558422767,
0.0155239338,
0.0166054107,
0.0094146291,
-0.0782099366,
0.0316607356,
0.0113370866,
0.0110350261,
-0.0135837262,
-0.0203992818,
0.0432523414,
0.0077431342,
-0.0267989375,
-0.0503989719,
0.023847742,
0.0549618565,
0.0203069393,
0.0126082562,
-0.0615939721,
0.0114896828,
-0.002719274,
0.0394370072,
-0.0449387245,
0.0159158409,
-0.0125957578,
-0.0010358205,
-0.0246177744,
-0.0310740191,
-0.0297677573,
-0.0242576916,
-0.0332859941,
-0.0042449161,
-0.0027242259,
-0.0426007137,
-0.0249843616,
0.0221786704,
-0.0918982401,
-0.0435451604,
-0.0066661341,
-0.020829957,
0.0075070933,
0.024535533,
0.0231991261,
0.0995228887,
-0.02555364,
0.0232806113,
0.0123080024,
0.0364832357,
-0.0000383078,
-0.0327588432,
-0.0668241978,
0.0576091595,
-0.0375798941,
0.0033931998,
-0.0240457878,
0.0502217934,
0.039159961,
-0.0044973255,
0.0194046479,
0.042762313,
-0.0156259071,
0.0096191242,
0.0093615605,
0.0497741587,
-0.0455632843,
-0.0185479149,
-0.011932319,
0.0163525492,
-0.0531020835,
0.003336601,
-0.0709835514,
-0.0321053863,
-0.0348125584,
-0.0329581499,
-0.0296692234,
0.0433374867,
0.0097322837,
-0.0143050132,
0.0266074538,
0.0166077353,
-0.0599619821,
-0.0096725598,
0.0775769204,
0.0290622786,
-0.0303010494,
0.0029660149,
0.0572399087,
0.018868031,
-0.0776058808,
-0.0339362212,
0.0159977488,
0.0079257293,
-0.0071147191,
-0.0241042431,
-0.0149537669,
-5.594725322e-33,
-0.0598913878,
-0.0133525636,
-0.0290095881,
0.0015770232,
-0.0095933331,
-0.0278985761,
-0.0011002437,
0.0103594027,
0.0672639981,
-0.0019131121,
-0.0391812883,
-0.061789427,
0.0258936975,
0.0351103209,
-0.0058119232,
0.0163554791,
0.0719399303,
0.0259056669,
-0.0565228127,
0.0216318574,
0.0136673953,
0.0198731758,
0.014940856,
-0.0685110614,
-0.0010740453,
-0.0424610116,
-0.0264481455,
-0.0348216034,
0.0665181875,
0.0601829961,
0.0022920126,
-0.0110651972,
-0.0172085259,
-0.0145373102,
0.0068448815,
0.0669657886,
-0.0560482815,
-0.0550273806,
-0.0018763673,
0.0186501779,
-0.0560086109,
-0.0532863513,
0.0138985347,
-0.0296667404,
-0.029447332,
-0.0178025104,
0.0479566865,
-0.0335485861,
0.0112024769,
-0.010604023,
-0.0433082208,
-0.0353161134,
-0.0377730727,
-0.0382864214,
0.0134630045,
0.0241695978,
0.0257728286,
0.0649907738,
-0.0583458357,
0.0369793549,
0.0385401361,
-0.0056134053,
0.0391642489,
0.0745726526,
0.0094961654,
0.051989913,
0.0211247765,
0.0010538339,
-0.0059803505,
0.019763425,
-0.0003273609,
0.0421444252,
0.0218136497,
0.0782920718,
0.0327746458,
0.0272752717,
0.0271265972,
0.0566547848,
-0.0110364398,
-0.0608251058,
0.0452404879,
0.0298930332,
-0.0001653809,
0.008699147,
-0.0529657714,
-0.0763183981,
-0.0279766079,
-0.0525400117,
0.0067193313,
-0.0020741173,
-0.056678433,
0.0071323998,
0.0293259062,
0.0257070977,
0.0002301969,
-0.063869223,
-0.0450200737,
0.0581967495,
-0.0353683382,
-0.0230931938,
0.0260016154,
-0.0339210741,
0.081135273,
-0.0071626375,
0.0027761359,
0.0262991395,
0.0105041536,
0.0148877557,
-0.0291212834,
-0.0046254308,
0.017161876,
0.0174271464,
0.0167948045,
0.0212674178,
0.0423657112,
-0.0194179136,
-0.0678402185,
0.023272451,
0.0238083322,
0.0212521665,
-0.0217449423,
-0.0511080027,
0.0032953091,
-0.028199669,
-0.0105127152,
0.0248345062,
0.0016727727,
-0.0087470654,
0.0318795927,
-0.0443844199,
-0.0460182168,
0.0026543802,
2.632e-7,
0.0129526965,
0.0127110835,
0.0018830764,
0.003862032,
0.004065956,
0.0332343169,
-0.0234083533,
0.0413468294,
-0.01641546,
-0.0488140769,
0.0041186861,
0.0374793597,
0.0457175225,
-0.0136939706,
-0.0492206141,
0.0157896075,
-0.0223574266,
0.0519391932,
-0.0468401462,
0.0446232408,
0.067226097,
0.0276805609,
0.0482726842,
-0.0189222414,
0.0527279228,
0.0271139555,
0.0547043197,
-0.0386555418,
0.0009974539,
-0.0077972044,
-0.017443018,
-0.0770857483,
-0.0084094554,
-0.0198011491,
0.0046579931,
0.0003637525,
0.0787236989,
0.0742570013,
-0.0553899594,
0.0046941317,
-0.0172643196,
0.0244060513,
0.0000661534,
-0.0318358727,
0.010407865,
-0.0104581928,
-0.0115609141,
-0.0508226901,
-0.0403951965,
-0.0015423346,
0.0554539561,
-0.032311026,
-0.0442546606,
-0.0043059848,
0.0422643051,
0.0117396498,
-0.0241649393,
-0.0330722183,
-0.046715837,
-0.0318741314,
-0.016093934,
-0.0108360415,
-0.0528315194,
-0.0261640139,
0.0075381333,
-0.0675144941,
-0.0141054261,
2.359752793e-34,
-0.0029464548,
0.0093825636,
0.0311785694,
-0.0141560035,
0.0043762317,
0.0156804249,
0.0156173334,
0.0017599243,
0.0515938774,
-0.0730756968,
-0.0362534598
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06104v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06104v2 | Transformers are Multi-State RNNs | 2024-01-11T18:35:26 | 2024-06-18T09:16:14 | Matanel Oren, Michael Hassid, Nir Yarden, Yossi Adi, Roy Schwartz | cs.CL | cs.CL | Transformers are considered conceptually different from the previous
generation of state-of-the-art NLP models - recurrent neural networks (RNNs).
In this work, we demonstrate that decoder-only transformers can in fact be
conceptualized as unbounded multi-state RNNs - an RNN variant with unlimited
hidden state size. We further show that transformers can be converted into
$\textit{bounded}$ multi-state RNNs by fixing the size of their hidden state,
effectively compressing their key-value cache. We introduce a novel,
training-free compression policy - $\textbf{T}$oken $\textbf{O}$mission
$\textbf{V}$ia $\textbf{A}$ttention (TOVA). Our experiments with four long
range tasks and several LLMs show that TOVA outperforms several baseline
compression policies. Particularly, our results are nearly on par with the full
model, using in some cases only $\frac{1}{8}$ of the original cache size, which
translates to 4.8X higher throughput. Our results shed light on the connection
between transformers and RNNs, and help mitigate one of LLMs' most painful
computational bottlenecks - the size of their key-value cache. We publicly
release our code at https://github.com/schwartz-lab-NLP/TOVA | [
0.0201360472,
0.0888227001,
0.0129763717,
0.0131032635,
-0.0215289649,
-0.0179635212,
-0.006963036,
0.0250381771,
-0.0514247678,
-0.0211905986,
-0.0267198775,
-0.0467893369,
0.0158123504,
0.0054265177,
-0.0073681483,
-0.0297507718,
0.0414585173,
-0.0157538168,
-0.031895332,
0.0069550509,
-0.0299931522,
0.006968888,
-0.0137603926,
0.0546190403,
0.0195532627,
-0.0087416349,
-0.0310132429,
-0.0207146686,
-0.0084831631,
-0.0452022105,
-0.0199207421,
-0.0058605834,
0.0279800706,
0.0299318545,
0.0000020846,
-0.0175487585,
0.0169447232,
-0.0211218894,
-0.0574610382,
0.0216518324,
0.0296590999,
-0.0334551483,
-0.0001571148,
0.02510399,
-0.0139101325,
-0.0482116938,
0.0563988686,
0.0627889857,
0.0582111217,
0.0771944225,
0.0201373212,
-0.0426745415,
0.0281876847,
-0.044770848,
-0.0006151843,
-0.048429966,
0.0065647908,
-0.0583786368,
-0.0281753372,
0.0023300063,
-0.0505638048,
0.0321724005,
0.0363214016,
0.0435405895,
-0.033413969,
0.0402853042,
-0.0033517745,
-0.0050644875,
-0.0276138373,
0.0245313141,
-0.0351049565,
-0.0078636231,
0.0155260339,
0.008486554,
-0.031271439,
-0.0403354876,
-0.02463587,
0.0445045978,
0.0105174799,
0.0265350733,
-0.0137726236,
0.0241066925,
0.0558946878,
-0.0113565866,
-0.0225071199,
0.007993157,
0.0130272331,
-0.0220781155,
-0.0156936236,
-0.0137739163,
0.0479288548,
-0.0710392073,
0.0021748503,
0.0834554359,
0.0052755298,
0.0099287806,
-0.0158936772,
-0.0165357888,
0.0200760048,
-0.0255791564,
0.061301928,
0.0280730482,
-0.0051823719,
0.0066519417,
-0.0187799763,
0.0659032613,
-0.0647054091,
0.011570123,
-0.0156724006,
-0.0087078102,
-0.0593247265,
-0.0257122647,
-0.0226372089,
0.0301584769,
0.0034448709,
-0.0053789495,
-0.0375173874,
-0.003044432,
0.014700368,
-0.0036767668,
0.0381530598,
0.0408755578,
-0.0551967733,
0.0213944558,
-0.0189596359,
0.0644996241,
-0.0032369161,
-0.0131561356,
0.0294167511,
-0.0512680225,
-0.0472274572,
0.0132623715,
0.0157941524,
-0.0171682723,
-0.00573227,
0.1033630073,
0.0004766614,
-0.0392419063,
-0.0228749737,
-0.0116620651,
0.0097861737,
-0.0587771274,
0.0565167144,
-0.028610738,
0.0261128973,
-0.0351668932,
0.017033644,
-0.0533077791,
0.0178241506,
0.0488240756,
-0.013226755,
0.046704568,
0.0638399348,
-0.0171510465,
-0.008354919,
0.0071222456,
0.0318452828,
0.0124467164,
0.0406274945,
0.0283062551,
0.0071543232,
-0.030456895,
0.0112522645,
0.0261710323,
0.0249773003,
-0.0167936217,
0.000240859,
-0.0300511234,
-0.0159891099,
0.031163428,
0.0334697627,
0.0492373332,
-0.0258854702,
-0.0343812257,
0.0174709,
0.0358601362,
0.0470154881,
0.0700345039,
0.0132431695,
0.0036400401,
0.0031675086,
-0.0270221159,
-0.0298669152,
0.0679047257,
0.0083799353,
-0.0026949369,
-0.003571172,
0.0392977856,
-0.0467202254,
-0.0307654273,
-0.0269406848,
-0.0369306393,
0.0144146923,
-0.0124802236,
0.0430856086,
0.0559020825,
-0.0581135601,
0.1019884199,
-0.0156079745,
-0.0434170961,
0.0193483829,
-0.0312847942,
-0.0486105233,
0.0286833607,
0.0530022085,
0.0115561308,
-0.0384937413,
-0.0048904079,
-0.0488817543,
0.0262637865,
0.0275504254,
0.0194839127,
0.0579677783,
-0.064198494,
-0.0215647351,
0.0041738558,
0.0083534438,
0.013982445,
0.030522434,
0.0245978888,
0.0199531373,
-0.032184191,
0.0274605192,
0.0311563741,
-0.0423780903,
-0.0438146032,
0.0525222234,
0.0063538412,
0.0348948874,
0.0072434158,
0.0059823934,
0.0145349884,
0.0352612846,
-0.0616667196,
-0.0284345802,
-0.0068991249,
-0.0765625313,
-0.016849108,
0.0062577222,
-0.0109798182,
0.0280762389,
0.1124065295,
-0.0380515903,
-0.04540148,
0.0409792252,
-0.0496275611,
0.0382519625,
-0.0169203691,
-0.0249952693,
0.0295580607,
0.0355855413,
-0.0091867186,
0.0200127885,
-0.0607598536,
-0.0047263103,
-0.0175378546,
-0.0264503434,
-0.0106940782,
-0.0131766424,
-0.0466588363,
0.038872283,
-0.0349055454,
0.005144401,
-0.0033799419,
-0.0064702574,
0.0137193017,
-0.0441523269,
-0.0380522609,
0.0121317003,
-0.0139256725,
0.0315063633,
0.0016811179,
0.0204592459,
0.0405134372,
-0.0121650575,
-0.0442329571,
-0.0017247223,
0.0062761186,
0.026447393,
0.0375632197,
0.014621025,
-0.0500452407,
-0.0208440516,
-0.0477350019,
0.0116273919,
0.0554123223,
-0.0580275804,
-0.024202073,
-0.0167168267,
0.0363605581,
0.0063509392,
0.020186875,
-0.0200148653,
-0.059164241,
0.015560763,
-0.004824141,
0.0187545363,
0.0193665791,
0.0208740812,
0.0125442063,
0.0583153479,
-0.0420999303,
-0.0462875031,
0.0276905932,
-0.0461901352,
-0.0647720471,
-0.032546781,
0.0052241255,
0.012859731,
0.1028853878,
-0.0241460968,
0.0141828628,
-0.064621821,
-0.0576873906,
-0.0082147224,
-0.0267657395,
0.0190884471,
-0.0022443885,
-0.0427807719,
0.0117167477,
0.0035383159,
-0.0024878948,
0.0354670808,
-0.0274198968,
-0.0044803494,
0.0018285395,
-0.0108607188,
-0.0599674694,
0.0678814799,
0.0023455857,
0.0039844015,
0.0131206475,
-0.0310007185,
-0.0101548741,
-0.0130373621,
-0.0429063439,
-0.0277873967,
0.0399047211,
0.0026861124,
-0.0126210349,
-0.0437088944,
-0.0556045771,
-0.0536077917,
0.0133032529,
-0.0173479281,
-0.0019755692,
0.0046889149,
-0.0512470417,
-0.038138099,
-0.0247172806,
0.0082627339,
0.0587798581,
0.0117603177,
-0.0092697227,
-0.0086660897,
0.0321824215,
0.0131168403,
0.0478809141,
0.0284591317,
-0.0042227437,
-0.0187484697,
0.0830671713,
0.0446556136,
0.0308311433,
-0.0499049947,
0.0031709068,
0.0455149002,
-0.0089858873,
-0.0027711042,
0.027361339,
0.0178374965,
-0.0725803971,
-0.0409774147,
0.0685807467,
0.0108795324,
-0.0454036258,
0.0100814011,
0.0224598553,
0.0317478739,
0.0153470645,
0.0302059744,
-0.069168292,
-0.0312166084,
0.0175050832,
0.0220979415,
-0.0149075119,
-0.0436052456,
-0.0373242758,
-0.0973634645,
-0.0014131936,
-0.0040706862,
-0.0138958544,
-0.0070027355,
-0.0304244775,
-0.0403384753,
-0.009594541,
-0.0082219606,
0.0008560503,
-0.0082518924,
-0.0162126385,
0.0315386988,
-0.0226690155,
-0.0349853709,
0.0509857945,
-0.0068501928,
0.0436106287,
0.0680984408,
0.0010368486,
0.0005849828,
-0.0481955558,
0.0208000187,
-0.0102653988,
0.0288498569,
0.0131930681,
0.0122552281,
-0.0063982503,
-0.0305874497,
-0.0092182253,
0.0126485536,
-0.068987295,
-0.0257688686,
-0.0179085713,
0.0677674264,
-0.0181481782,
-0.0364430211,
-0.0126492456,
-0.0369691625,
-0.0029463316,
0.0629237071,
0.0225883964,
-0.0103214765,
-0.065250203,
-0.0004762828,
0.0133883962,
-0.0805020928,
-0.0801503882,
0.0213005133,
0.0433258265,
-0.0614975058,
-0.0671986118,
-0.0145291425,
-0.0294398926,
0.011203221,
0.0086222682,
-0.0394700915,
0.0457229167,
0.0397785269,
-0.0811289921,
0.0057878941,
-0.0454125293,
0.0099556781,
-0.0551861227,
0.0113567505,
0.052357804,
0.0232394394,
-0.0191524941,
0.0148833236,
-0.1384684891,
-0.0056013092,
0.0539839007,
0.0226886291,
0.0245422162,
0.011211209,
0.0092860479,
-0.0299583822,
0.0576247014,
0.0462498814,
-0.0258028656,
0.0518799797,
0.0560598187,
-0.0050120638,
0.0227644742,
0.0416037403,
-0.0453244895,
-0.0048263981,
-0.0138427913,
0.0334184431,
-0.0054328069,
-0.0063942806,
0.0016616137,
-0.0184934605,
0.026876986,
0.0104989111,
0.0372396447,
0.0255483687,
0.0346814282,
0.015025733,
0.0462132059,
-0.0359841511,
0.0113525707,
0.0295908954,
-0.0131837567,
0.0212034583,
0.036108762,
0.0688382834,
-0.0025285019,
0.0164603535,
0.0045247651,
0.0148810027,
-0.0224961191,
0.0075822985,
0.0432480834,
-0.0352188013,
0.001940202,
-0.0038852647,
0.0195368156,
-0.0280878507,
0.0141633041,
0.0277391896,
0.0448276922,
-0.0569699965,
0.0324648917,
-0.0646809787,
-0.0098271705,
0.0133355679,
-0.0266596768,
0.0320560671,
0.0181280822,
-0.0202721786,
-0.0331768803,
0.0281927288,
-0.0124461548,
0.0124624856,
-0.0307511594,
-0.0285745356,
0.0277246125,
0.0209158268,
0.0092947129,
0.0112219201,
0.0872240216,
0.0181433726,
0.0757567883,
-0.011102031,
0.0626423955,
-0.0271713622,
-0.0439467318,
-0.0297884103,
0.014831095,
0.0317840241,
-0.0280975625,
-0.0417856164,
-0.0592528284,
0.0565137267,
-0.0202942286,
0.0204214193,
-0.053609103,
0.0407421403,
0.0194809176,
0.012912347,
-0.0033975383,
-0.0098109767,
0.0181094781,
-0.0045939055,
-0.0276431609,
-0.0304269549,
-6.208886958e-33,
0.0075333738,
0.0021489116,
0.029870851,
-0.0207489245,
-0.0486985818,
0.0168893375,
-0.0554793216,
-0.0390930437,
-0.0309060626,
-0.021142615,
-0.0454190373,
0.0020809665,
0.0132626053,
0.0604318231,
0.0199427716,
-0.0616580173,
0.0709164962,
-0.0155390054,
-0.0023662641,
0.0213391446,
0.0684065521,
0.0129572544,
0.0409297161,
-0.0246017985,
-0.0455465093,
-0.0057334611,
-0.0139093008,
0.0173106063,
-0.0082793208,
0.0558241196,
-0.0503121838,
0.0287495889,
0.0255362596,
-0.0930299312,
-0.0296460986,
0.0145096881,
-0.0919657722,
-0.0342171341,
-0.0285095088,
0.0136446897,
-0.0477832556,
-0.0600012951,
0.0430228934,
0.0277909897,
-0.0057972614,
-0.0106616253,
-0.0187662244,
0.0031754461,
-0.04245992,
-0.0755683184,
0.0056741158,
-0.0050588353,
-0.0069528944,
-0.0329052769,
0.0303079579,
0.0239964277,
-0.0143423993,
0.0337074362,
-0.0888568833,
-0.0058929804,
-0.0119083617,
0.0767440572,
0.0483510569,
0.0144704534,
-0.0081551382,
0.0410045981,
0.0164850596,
0.0007517938,
-0.0613370575,
0.0105260415,
0.0208396073,
0.0206416752,
0.022071844,
-0.0002576005,
0.0775740147,
-0.047685843,
-0.0279961973,
-0.0143092293,
-0.010194445,
0.0813538656,
0.0213584751,
-0.002513726,
-0.0209505148,
-0.0112507297,
-0.0299124494,
0.0140423337,
-0.0261486582,
-0.0034904047,
0.0414136387,
0.0630488694,
0.0042544524,
0.01109342,
0.0303274114,
-0.0273437947,
0.0350147597,
0.0320969783,
0.0210867543,
0.0466091558,
-0.0117132906,
-0.0063575166,
-0.0324281789,
0.0021033895,
0.0038397245,
-0.0021933953,
0.0240808781,
-0.0013678651,
0.0069325482,
0.0603765473,
-0.087726891,
-0.0296058673,
-0.0420899652,
0.0506497845,
0.0005800897,
0.0282620974,
0.0502183065,
0.0121304356,
-0.0072977673,
0.0533062182,
-0.02603928,
-0.0047136042,
0.0018780647,
0.0314416178,
0.0479829051,
0.0224836543,
-0.0012286009,
-0.0228509475,
-0.0608614683,
0.0235275272,
0.0260270778,
-0.0450417548,
-0.0027325295,
0.0516323373,
2.753e-7,
-0.0149717759,
0.020291077,
0.0729989037,
0.0122228796,
0.0308786072,
0.0299160797,
0.0077485251,
0.0382968634,
-0.0441519432,
-0.010560737,
-0.0230946168,
0.0364734605,
0.0432592817,
0.0160631351,
-0.0908711255,
-0.020655239,
-0.055136878,
0.0041826726,
-0.0289399121,
-0.0263250954,
0.0339494422,
0.118348971,
0.0148281492,
-0.0082410816,
0.0002218168,
0.0151713314,
0.0526270606,
-0.0024821088,
0.0194017794,
-0.0012295081,
0.0237157978,
0.0099656023,
-0.007752297,
-0.0444695204,
-0.027232172,
0.0110451514,
-0.0427549072,
0.0921991393,
0.0249154698,
-0.1191527694,
-0.0015275941,
0.0041569103,
-0.0449820757,
0.0357072093,
0.0558587685,
-0.0518828668,
-0.0386006124,
-0.0156449769,
0.0068736137,
0.0273561832,
-0.0118867299,
0.0244933236,
0.0083558671,
0.0156223755,
-0.0188919995,
0.0085109444,
0.0066243359,
-0.1077597588,
-0.0159039628,
-0.0438531078,
-0.0676527843,
0.0217028186,
-0.0713438764,
-0.010649981,
0.0463806204,
-0.0237201396,
-0.0459752083,
2.287909884e-34,
0.0176001899,
-0.0381152704,
0.012321867,
0.0265246481,
-0.0145234549,
-0.0124701448,
0.0172543228,
0.0258502848,
0.01312235,
-0.075652346,
-0.0345767066
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06102v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06102v4 | Patchscopes: A Unifying Framework for Inspecting Hidden Representations of Language Models | 2024-01-11T18:33:48 | 2024-06-06T22:59:58 | Asma Ghandeharioun, Avi Caciularu, Adam Pearce, Lucas Dixon, Mor Geva | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Understanding the internal representations of large language models (LLMs)
can help explain models' behavior and verify their alignment with human values.
Given the capabilities of LLMs in generating human-understandable text, we
propose leveraging the model itself to explain its internal representations in
natural language. We introduce a framework called Patchscopes and show how it
can be used to answer a wide range of questions about an LLM's computation. We
show that many prior interpretability methods based on projecting
representations into the vocabulary space and intervening on the LLM
computation can be viewed as instances of this framework. Moreover, several of
their shortcomings such as failure in inspecting early layers or lack of
expressivity can be mitigated by Patchscopes. Beyond unifying prior inspection
techniques, Patchscopes also opens up new possibilities such as using a more
capable model to explain the representations of a smaller model, and multihop
reasoning error correction. | [
0.0107798753,
0.065484941,
-0.0394079685,
0.0695945397,
-0.0265554134,
-0.0027076376,
-0.0301440675,
0.0106701422,
0.014363274,
-0.0410394929,
-0.0390910022,
-0.0284998231,
0.0337848514,
0.0307267159,
0.0373331569,
-0.0246140454,
0.0334221236,
-0.0390151516,
-0.006273896,
0.0105807642,
-0.0171333868,
0.0202522408,
0.0186358821,
0.0540377535,
0.0296409335,
-0.0316806473,
-0.0438090898,
0.0049324865,
-0.0125813792,
0.0151841296,
-0.0285521578,
0.025406424,
0.0280097555,
0.063563861,
0.0000021766,
-0.0383001268,
-0.0148283448,
0.0057169651,
-0.0482716262,
0.0757034719,
0.0294060931,
-0.0352515802,
-0.0165058896,
-0.0273415763,
-0.0216698218,
0.0282018557,
0.0520534329,
0.0256148241,
0.0506331399,
0.0468850359,
0.0003289742,
-0.0185602382,
0.0076532466,
-0.0007593167,
0.0175003074,
-0.0436080284,
0.0141060408,
0.0224737152,
-0.0116686793,
0.0124868564,
-0.0382505693,
0.0348009914,
0.019399995,
-0.0182939768,
-0.0160619542,
-0.004315923,
0.0289490931,
-0.0603257567,
0.0158699788,
0.0459435433,
-0.0040103165,
-0.0479070432,
-0.0093790982,
-0.0009839754,
-0.0153544405,
0.0329184644,
-0.0065183928,
0.003758698,
0.0260853395,
0.0337215923,
0.0487721004,
-0.0248362403,
0.0837772265,
-0.0112618785,
-0.0423183627,
0.0649026111,
0.0068042935,
0.0167136602,
-0.0300838836,
-0.0121779172,
-0.0105974125,
-0.0456283987,
0.0290261656,
0.0209205877,
-0.0212275069,
0.0507975481,
-0.0211792905,
0.0267450269,
0.0209075548,
-0.0405195355,
0.0612162948,
0.0521271713,
-0.0149058709,
0.0266769733,
-0.0279087164,
0.0668720677,
-0.0566420034,
0.03063526,
-0.0245842896,
0.0010975244,
-0.0578682274,
-0.052206926,
0.0117158107,
0.0102487514,
-0.0311732609,
-0.023325989,
-0.0325113349,
0.0181567706,
-0.0410417691,
-0.0225498974,
-0.0033381372,
-0.0072974539,
0.0004873865,
0.0083367024,
-0.024127569,
0.0175671298,
-0.0079648709,
0.0067302017,
-0.0265273228,
-0.059735775,
-0.0238066204,
0.0024080854,
-0.0141498325,
-0.007128417,
-0.0449184626,
0.0604784079,
0.0180823263,
-0.0088221394,
-0.0162842572,
-0.0571099222,
-0.050731983,
-0.0283024684,
0.007157499,
-0.0429727845,
-0.0071584159,
-0.0112662418,
0.0033321774,
-0.0724691004,
0.0016401525,
-0.0114035206,
-0.0254464746,
0.0903675705,
-0.0265444797,
0.0190612022,
-0.0232641865,
0.0208173189,
0.0041145994,
0.0696156174,
0.0212686658,
0.0219019763,
0.0251674857,
-0.0206429493,
-0.0022509578,
0.0288351439,
0.0347873829,
0.00285495,
-0.0640264004,
-0.0276889931,
-0.0018195028,
0.0030320522,
0.0256485697,
0.0366831534,
-0.0069979997,
-0.0324578397,
0.017673729,
0.0513358004,
0.0596566908,
0.0114244753,
0.0531242639,
0.0101722535,
0.0149179511,
0.0266972203,
-0.0423593521,
-0.0202118494,
-0.0576676764,
-0.0158430971,
-0.0094874501,
-0.0176227149,
0.0172476452,
-0.0467256121,
-0.0315076001,
0.0132335499,
0.0035627626,
-0.0097577441,
0.0537462458,
0.0128522022,
-0.0178992674,
0.064648129,
0.0212187394,
-0.0454883091,
0.0207251161,
-0.0940721706,
0.03131276,
0.0736504868,
0.0375759304,
-0.0170875676,
-0.0024467381,
0.0286490675,
-0.0493556298,
0.0251970403,
0.029570926,
-0.0122604519,
0.0285952948,
-0.0198600162,
-0.0049797948,
-0.0269270614,
0.0541357175,
0.0381722413,
-0.045568224,
-0.0326378644,
0.0082035307,
-0.0870466009,
-0.0415890142,
0.0379401296,
-0.0308618322,
-0.0128104724,
-0.0292332675,
0.0074182623,
0.0276606586,
0.0396954045,
0.0070823673,
0.0359043106,
0.02477636,
0.0021514909,
0.0174143221,
0.0248477589,
-0.0453415997,
-0.0112446407,
0.0311548412,
-0.0483182669,
-0.0138620501,
0.0408766419,
-0.0059138471,
-0.0396521054,
0.0447665602,
-0.0721323043,
0.0439928025,
-0.0434840061,
0.0347155854,
-0.0282753278,
0.0293939095,
-0.0058836564,
0.0514909998,
-0.0187397972,
0.0028605775,
0.0158649441,
0.0088988626,
0.0291043073,
-0.0169073511,
-0.0034639821,
0.0294437595,
0.0186811108,
-0.0084068328,
0.0117953578,
-0.0161046777,
-0.0410077088,
-0.0270441882,
-0.0449292734,
-0.0321666822,
-0.0014154335,
0.0022543047,
0.0655502155,
-0.0225174185,
0.0183074176,
0.0037917143,
0.0068009947,
-0.0150719192,
0.0076753898,
-0.0064013749,
0.0275525171,
-0.0330009125,
-0.0316498652,
-0.038457118,
-0.0151614482,
-0.0541428328,
0.0895403698,
-0.0022817564,
-0.0141406525,
-0.1002370492,
-0.0018980195,
-0.0165656079,
-0.000851902,
0.0103285639,
-0.0666693747,
0.0256024785,
-0.0146976933,
0.0019483306,
0.0357077532,
-0.020318225,
0.1085767746,
0.0645566508,
-0.0071864962,
-0.058712814,
-0.0424800068,
0.0037863071,
0.0015987105,
-0.0329809636,
-0.0850266963,
-0.0521700345,
0.1021879613,
0.0160923991,
-0.0133480392,
-0.0661036298,
0.0498658679,
-0.032108523,
-0.0743941143,
-0.0460373424,
-0.0379470922,
-0.0110554453,
0.078912735,
-0.0154342195,
-0.0655901581,
0.047189232,
-0.0492363013,
0.0080744652,
-0.0150198909,
-0.0169091057,
-0.0449234881,
0.1007836536,
0.0021656391,
0.0094745057,
0.0051542148,
-0.0600966737,
-0.0153361596,
0.0114674512,
-0.011976324,
-0.0241804272,
0.0388054512,
-0.0673730746,
-0.0011155453,
0.0107604396,
0.0429025851,
-0.0334517695,
-0.0329020135,
-0.0416731425,
0.0268975906,
0.0087126195,
-0.0140939746,
-0.0294110868,
-0.0027536335,
0.017586736,
0.0015914442,
-0.0072259158,
0.0067529376,
-0.0480456576,
-0.0219796505,
0.0058066412,
0.0103105949,
0.0337198339,
-0.0421190783,
0.0112153729,
0.0411124267,
-0.0020331172,
0.0162817407,
-0.0553617366,
0.0452144369,
0.0237741005,
-0.0002566971,
-0.0131320087,
0.0018489221,
0.0618974082,
-0.0814123005,
-0.0224248972,
0.1091231778,
0.0499286242,
-0.0275127552,
0.0670290291,
-0.0375129208,
-0.016805267,
0.0299329311,
0.0314926431,
-0.0503425077,
-0.0107786115,
0.0343369544,
0.0064581693,
-0.015789317,
-0.014389392,
-0.0175841264,
-0.1019115299,
0.033955235,
0.0307167508,
-0.0179084633,
-0.0227584764,
-0.0301501434,
-0.0067514242,
0.0205287952,
0.0211351179,
0.0134955645,
0.0151498374,
-0.0002010473,
-0.0155910021,
0.0020277253,
-0.0511623733,
0.0440537371,
0.0047702035,
0.0705037639,
0.0533340164,
0.0376915149,
0.007596415,
-0.0537139475,
0.0279633962,
0.0131962039,
0.031698186,
-0.0147510376,
0.0331577212,
0.0229468346,
-0.0201988984,
-0.0153297586,
0.0319667645,
-0.0389354117,
-0.0423485748,
-0.0468059629,
0.0686449558,
-0.0289413165,
-0.0466415361,
-0.001057784,
0.0099097518,
-0.0032738615,
0.0661684647,
0.0620583184,
-0.0148995426,
-0.0311317891,
-0.031390138,
0.0002756034,
-0.0110574737,
-0.101948671,
0.06338045,
0.0441653356,
-0.0467968658,
-0.0378839374,
-0.0120210741,
-0.0088403178,
0.0221643616,
0.0270427838,
-0.0227146652,
-0.013630352,
-0.031161014,
-0.0338100195,
0.0430777632,
-0.0182458051,
0.0066421069,
-0.0138410954,
-0.017469326,
0.0131458845,
-0.0439928994,
-0.0295566414,
-0.0232386366,
-0.0192255415,
-0.0512583777,
0.0475029498,
0.0244922824,
0.0343907923,
0.0157618094,
-0.0411860235,
-0.0632696897,
0.0143830357,
0.0000506612,
-0.0588857457,
0.0238083452,
0.0411276706,
-0.0206644591,
-0.0004944408,
0.0637063459,
-0.0267075356,
0.0245471373,
0.0040066182,
0.0234919749,
-0.0118889036,
-0.0347993672,
0.0372908898,
0.0218259841,
0.0286017582,
0.0082405526,
-0.0272221062,
-0.0342387185,
-0.0187855083,
-0.0538536124,
-0.0122014778,
-0.036832504,
0.03247796,
0.0308337379,
-0.033156421,
-0.0017479532,
-0.0493161194,
-0.022520557,
0.0192677807,
-0.0026147442,
0.0302172974,
0.0249407981,
0.0144881485,
-0.0187907424,
0.0337516405,
-0.0117708566,
0.0334059373,
-0.0637391657,
0.0441015325,
-0.0120593999,
0.0361815393,
0.0090347091,
0.012532698,
-0.0537435673,
0.0147468597,
-0.0736887828,
-0.04604223,
0.0361307748,
0.0225782953,
0.0314029157,
-0.0021607482,
0.0725391284,
-0.0146352714,
0.0084123993,
-0.0135730961,
0.058138039,
0.0082477015,
-0.0196385402,
0.0224285498,
0.0177318808,
-0.0215673596,
-0.0137343211,
0.0504338518,
-0.00460664,
0.0292670801,
-0.0197518822,
0.0005516679,
-0.0352614336,
-0.0313812345,
-0.0041550407,
0.0469996929,
-0.0490951203,
0.0196612217,
-0.0540343337,
-0.0861296877,
-0.013611122,
0.0324814804,
-0.0130465757,
-0.0302444473,
-0.0281774402,
0.064515695,
0.0196035895,
-0.0041519315,
-0.0485710837,
0.0029679586,
-0.0115713198,
0.0219859239,
0.0111028273,
-6.528306977e-33,
-0.0305827018,
-0.0764201283,
-0.0164320022,
-0.0580455102,
-0.0115701864,
0.0127163269,
-0.0841787457,
0.0213184841,
-0.0041235927,
0.0375801064,
0.0210187659,
0.0291305687,
0.0091715259,
0.0001544769,
0.0001714884,
-0.0103935199,
0.0473605879,
0.0474076122,
-0.002063781,
-0.0149465464,
0.0560388044,
0.0160911754,
0.0682695359,
-0.0584131591,
0.091702424,
0.0114297653,
-0.0124914227,
0.0376161374,
-0.0462883636,
0.0683772266,
-0.0336697213,
0.0025066275,
0.0239436459,
-0.0258027855,
-0.0395168774,
0.0049471096,
-0.0482143722,
-0.0233811177,
0.0802746564,
0.0237281919,
-0.0607030243,
-0.0653478876,
0.0635408089,
-0.0148778046,
-0.013800242,
-0.0134008983,
0.016745178,
-0.0150906965,
0.002216225,
0.043642465,
-0.0677693263,
0.0177381691,
-0.033361163,
0.0015485195,
0.0472473353,
0.0290764794,
-0.0069866353,
0.0330888331,
-0.0683047771,
-0.0089312401,
0.0003572249,
0.0001857375,
0.091188103,
0.0217841715,
0.015675243,
0.0797091648,
0.0400145799,
-0.0276609212,
-0.0425987989,
-0.0283240955,
0.0640414134,
0.0364600159,
0.021698853,
0.0115807205,
0.0255582761,
0.0182709303,
-0.0303370021,
-0.0196834803,
-0.0198586285,
0.020107599,
0.0520034805,
0.024845738,
-0.0330675431,
-0.0121207051,
-0.0609494075,
-0.0391817912,
-0.0464399084,
-0.0195331741,
0.0162992887,
-0.0478908233,
-0.0429198258,
-0.0003706492,
0.0178915132,
-0.0728144199,
0.0266217478,
0.0010499994,
0.0010784677,
0.0130556095,
0.0136475731,
0.0415892638,
0.0072092754,
-0.0157098416,
-0.0130345644,
0.0270423647,
0.0503822491,
0.0258743446,
-0.0127198799,
0.0126128439,
-0.0191192683,
-0.0078942254,
-0.0591102354,
-0.0495714583,
-0.0375513434,
0.0135862483,
0.074534297,
0.0042326022,
-0.0421979912,
0.029083265,
0.0308794565,
0.0438565798,
0.001464244,
0.0451362059,
-0.0004377222,
0.0428533666,
-0.0428072698,
-0.0368980244,
-0.0205269046,
0.0320425071,
0.0915415064,
-0.0158115868,
-0.014231503,
0.0072685145,
2.823e-7,
0.0604587235,
0.0561691187,
0.0271836761,
0.0331600271,
0.0357788466,
0.0310947597,
-0.0301673971,
-0.0001375264,
0.0019886799,
-0.0492521524,
0.0071523483,
0.0209152978,
0.0489166602,
0.0209781453,
-0.0172357354,
-0.0057887184,
-0.0277479421,
0.008668256,
-0.0007635822,
0.0436740518,
0.053665299,
0.0706574544,
0.0097078104,
0.0014182463,
0.0226527173,
-0.0074946992,
0.045243796,
-0.0455675945,
0.0141763557,
-0.01342694,
0.0054863095,
0.021147497,
0.0285775624,
0.0054884073,
-0.0006106769,
0.0276717115,
-0.0114921369,
0.0592959784,
-0.054703176,
-0.0122455265,
-0.0530603975,
-0.0201606899,
0.009864918,
-0.0648576468,
0.0493627861,
-0.0336675085,
-0.0915897116,
-0.0133293141,
0.0291265398,
-0.0253636222,
-0.0117085706,
0.0136900488,
0.004385537,
0.0238208156,
0.0043908898,
-0.0228998084,
-0.0139174378,
-0.0679132566,
-0.0388820954,
-0.0190449785,
-0.0496599004,
-0.0120529775,
-0.014412907,
-0.0144179128,
0.0502530299,
-0.0639287755,
-0.0131432824,
2.753739239e-34,
0.0261097681,
0.012039532,
0.0153702982,
0.024669731,
0.0479774885,
-0.0158801749,
0.0128597645,
0.0211538225,
0.0638512224,
-0.0753503814,
-0.0406964645
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06088v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06088v1 | Autocompletion of Chief Complaints in the Electronic Health Records using Large Language Models | 2024-01-11T18:06:30 | 2024-01-11T18:06:30 | K M Sajjadul Islam, Ayesha Siddika Nipu, Praveen Madiraju, Priya Deshpande | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The Chief Complaint (CC) is a crucial component of a patient's medical record
as it describes the main reason or concern for seeking medical care. It
provides critical information for healthcare providers to make informed
decisions about patient care. However, documenting CCs can be time-consuming
for healthcare providers, especially in busy emergency departments. To address
this issue, an autocompletion tool that suggests accurate and well-formatted
phrases or sentences for clinical notes can be a valuable resource for triage
nurses. In this study, we utilized text generation techniques to develop
machine learning models using CC data. In our proposed work, we train a Long
Short-Term Memory (LSTM) model and fine-tune three different variants of
Biomedical Generative Pretrained Transformers (BioGPT), namely
microsoft/biogpt, microsoft/BioGPT-Large, and microsoft/BioGPT-Large-PubMedQA.
Additionally, we tune a prompt by incorporating exemplar CC sentences,
utilizing the OpenAI API of GPT-4. We evaluate the models' performance based on
the perplexity score, modified BERTScore, and cosine similarity score. The
results show that BioGPT-Large exhibits superior performance compared to the
other models. It consistently achieves a remarkably low perplexity score of
1.65 when generating CC, whereas the baseline LSTM model achieves the best
perplexity score of 170. Further, we evaluate and assess the proposed models'
performance and the outcome of GPT-4.0. Our study demonstrates that utilizing
LLMs such as BioGPT, leads to the development of an effective autocompletion
tool for generating CC documentation in healthcare settings. | [
0.0477086641,
0.0156190079,
0.0041022166,
-0.0457575135,
-0.025708504,
0.0321857072,
-0.0152670927,
0.0095333345,
0.0379080102,
-0.0392588452,
0.0173045807,
-0.0646015853,
-0.0012147189,
0.0160627104,
0.0171403009,
-0.0432040617,
0.02605878,
0.0496456809,
0.0417887717,
0.0204254184,
-0.0181219708,
0.0001460707,
-0.0145795364,
0.0641595945,
-0.0264211018,
-0.0206056964,
0.0044129244,
0.0013797978,
0.0347200595,
-0.0687203556,
0.0389600582,
0.0407391526,
-0.0290817786,
0.0091506355,
0.0000020897,
-0.0442314781,
-0.0018935784,
0.0181992203,
-0.0344857201,
-0.0261933189,
0.0165171269,
-0.0449019708,
-0.0261592045,
0.0171504896,
-0.0123575954,
-0.0253931042,
0.0415898785,
0.0702424645,
0.0547086522,
0.0692199916,
-0.0226806533,
0.0047637089,
0.017941419,
-0.0338392369,
0.0367005318,
-0.0069246283,
0.023118617,
0.0077029224,
0.0460387096,
-0.0382565856,
0.0064090937,
0.0349218957,
-0.003212048,
0.013050653,
0.0273634363,
0.0609514527,
-0.0157730281,
0.0123700807,
0.0127918767,
0.064863801,
-0.0214904472,
-0.0088103963,
0.0301440731,
-0.0043763327,
-0.0142072067,
-0.0193135198,
-0.0425795652,
0.0198457427,
-0.0561274812,
0.0145517839,
0.007669487,
-0.0062770303,
0.026993705,
0.0122737484,
-0.0152579099,
-0.0583475232,
0.0230856463,
-0.053873539,
0.0106951986,
-0.0282439888,
-0.0125280637,
-0.0426967405,
0.0648962781,
0.0498034507,
-0.0572340041,
-0.0057275551,
-0.0299967695,
-0.0460804179,
0.0887120292,
-0.0505838096,
0.0422209911,
0.0052224551,
-0.026060598,
0.0079899747,
-0.0128732109,
0.0207222961,
-0.0448237099,
0.0281614661,
-0.0391400568,
-0.011421781,
-0.0533793531,
-0.0209843945,
-0.0236758441,
0.0284822006,
0.0431506075,
-0.0152261024,
-0.0828776062,
-0.0104140583,
0.0069028707,
0.0206130017,
0.0730444193,
0.0350375511,
-0.0536839552,
0.0076185404,
-0.0139449006,
0.0155051276,
-0.0224534441,
-0.0224887617,
0.0107182031,
-0.011473652,
0.0114198672,
0.0178165752,
0.0257299114,
0.0052174642,
0.0204692949,
0.0468256138,
0.0011652978,
-0.0242850222,
-0.0079756631,
-0.0300317183,
-0.0367958583,
-0.0256678145,
-0.0093624918,
-0.045336362,
0.008173354,
-0.0113790985,
-0.0233627912,
-0.0299819857,
0.0208189078,
0.0288389772,
-0.0350912437,
0.0347892679,
-0.0763082728,
0.0018403815,
0.0603416972,
0.0132462867,
0.0386857167,
-0.0152861457,
0.0479752608,
0.0007312698,
-0.006217903,
-0.023552658,
0.0569336005,
0.001250947,
0.0207354389,
-0.0701705441,
0.0159775037,
-0.0017002325,
-0.0209235474,
0.0906334966,
-0.0255765561,
0.0859251246,
0.0026217804,
0.0010879992,
0.0144202756,
0.0419283733,
0.0271522254,
0.0263484865,
0.0261095855,
-0.0220100805,
-0.0199503992,
-0.0072416002,
-0.0080884537,
0.0181376282,
0.0308933184,
0.0359777063,
0.0293798838,
0.001307909,
-0.0493360758,
-0.0585524328,
-0.0291962828,
-0.049858015,
-0.0368045457,
-0.0155272735,
0.0304061715,
0.0189789794,
-0.0729612336,
0.0684229136,
0.0297361501,
-0.0529706404,
-0.0151466336,
-0.0559178777,
0.0183138195,
0.1198445782,
0.0620748103,
-0.0367417373,
-0.0632986054,
-0.0453690141,
0.0017541499,
0.0316432975,
0.0319796987,
0.0072435928,
-0.0221591741,
-0.0794356093,
-0.0049896101,
0.0460779294,
0.0092102159,
0.0042972234,
-0.0190696064,
0.0153604755,
0.0326536484,
-0.0288900025,
-0.0727611259,
0.0284383856,
-0.0272529423,
-0.0507419966,
0.0162157305,
0.0004491987,
0.042130366,
0.0360161178,
-0.0028554166,
0.0460159443,
0.0283932425,
-0.0460280813,
-0.0515474826,
0.0115184374,
-0.0498876311,
-0.0227018055,
0.0071817106,
-0.0226706639,
-0.0110978773,
-0.0064779641,
-0.0245465804,
-0.0500748977,
-0.0523097664,
-0.0626290143,
0.0138499867,
-0.05059826,
0.0264131334,
0.0702688396,
-0.0029280072,
-0.0474368706,
0.0286856741,
-0.0007042173,
-0.0020593966,
0.0239014458,
0.0003802867,
0.0422714874,
-0.0270538758,
-0.0218457393,
0.0193603691,
0.0024406011,
-0.0040710792,
0.0041898759,
0.0201991312,
-0.0191743243,
-0.0420101434,
-0.1409220099,
-0.006705652,
-0.0062354016,
-0.003899157,
-0.014245132,
0.0250906013,
-0.0032777856,
0.0046781106,
-0.0397159085,
-0.0357825346,
0.0325262472,
0.006073975,
0.0490488298,
0.0268499479,
-0.0132856825,
-0.0463223271,
-0.0047739753,
-0.0467382185,
0.0198285114,
0.009689142,
-0.0374571234,
-0.0254570674,
0.0162257906,
-0.0103611685,
0.0145681333,
0.0006913649,
-0.0512445122,
0.0377863385,
-0.0095011154,
0.0600811355,
0.0478961207,
0.0403868519,
0.0120810457,
0.0210587494,
-0.0015463022,
-0.034483429,
0.0414036885,
-0.0516636595,
-0.0219678581,
0.030090794,
-0.0292096939,
0.0292254183,
0.0602509044,
0.0303287357,
0.0057370868,
-0.0530184023,
-0.0431273095,
0.0193985272,
0.0372930095,
-0.009550483,
-0.0012504386,
-0.046844054,
0.013552268,
0.0409534015,
-0.0279521458,
0.0647882894,
-0.0245081764,
0.036779575,
-0.0629897788,
0.009013203,
-0.048046153,
0.0198112614,
-0.0131881498,
0.0019463256,
0.0328249745,
-0.0414242186,
0.0285008084,
0.0340721272,
-0.00313686,
-0.0484424904,
0.0118465424,
-0.0059898258,
0.0151615869,
0.0260777697,
-0.0254815705,
-0.056520991,
-0.0114420597,
-0.0086304052,
0.0057093976,
0.0236821137,
0.009878817,
-0.0336869359,
0.0387906507,
-0.015786197,
0.0577560104,
0.0058549209,
-0.020508077,
0.0050620027,
0.0049181841,
0.0313282609,
0.0145854456,
0.0090138344,
-0.0033360056,
-0.0005032377,
0.0453247614,
0.0260642953,
0.0174950119,
0.0052585672,
-0.0216729492,
-0.0350700691,
-0.0597241893,
-0.0186145287,
0.0379248001,
-0.0048708031,
-0.0626422092,
-0.0016512781,
0.1302525848,
0.0380500518,
-0.0637816638,
0.0243902039,
-0.0038839199,
-0.0175890531,
-0.0288546141,
0.0207157042,
-0.0542713404,
-0.0049165469,
-0.0130353048,
0.0221284293,
-0.0216272417,
-0.0126572298,
0.003473503,
-0.0521289967,
0.0434016064,
0.0069851922,
0.0102737993,
-0.0570017546,
-0.0086624334,
-0.0241700951,
0.0111999512,
-0.0006833976,
-0.0034225748,
-0.0113316616,
-0.0048266412,
0.0084334295,
-0.0892743841,
-0.0735930502,
0.0100506647,
-0.0357206538,
0.0535407886,
0.0870288536,
0.0564612783,
-0.0006800699,
-0.0284168459,
0.0317973047,
-0.0007633358,
0.0199361462,
-0.00969736,
0.0564614348,
-0.0027955929,
-0.0088397553,
-0.0472794734,
0.0399439856,
-0.0248015635,
-0.0173087642,
0.0225714557,
0.0636170655,
-0.0511591397,
-0.021297399,
-0.0503226295,
0.022986168,
0.0299723558,
0.0637196451,
0.0288510807,
-0.0063817203,
-0.0515289269,
0.0281001236,
0.0510516278,
-0.0310366284,
0.0163839553,
0.0179302748,
-0.0226805974,
-0.0415844806,
-0.0735440627,
-0.0471573137,
0.0585178696,
-0.0035458088,
0.0143435542,
0.0137311071,
0.0242441501,
0.0155241257,
-0.0472317114,
0.0108107869,
0.0293631274,
-0.0137213506,
-0.0828925222,
-0.0465644412,
0.0438058898,
0.020577943,
-0.0072381268,
-0.0024000129,
-0.0260551814,
-0.0179999582,
-0.0033682587,
0.0584708042,
0.0161009878,
0.0062020137,
0.0094361808,
-0.033683423,
0.0022769854,
0.0624814704,
-0.0113352574,
-0.0516159087,
-0.0018465038,
0.0123229045,
-0.0137711223,
0.015291838,
-0.0205762368,
0.0410685353,
-0.0144637935,
0.0545108467,
0.0214189533,
-0.0253195073,
0.0185244065,
0.0284772404,
0.0313308202,
-0.0442929193,
-0.0136361113,
-0.0566177741,
0.0250210501,
-0.0232222229,
0.0285808444,
-0.0252626352,
0.0201237015,
0.0101208929,
-0.0111167328,
-0.0224969424,
-0.0046353801,
-0.0757003576,
-0.0155047327,
-0.0671575069,
0.0275954232,
-0.0616032071,
0.0108104432,
0.0267408229,
-0.0408506095,
-0.0321875066,
0.0280615948,
0.0269829519,
0.0183855351,
-0.0097611109,
0.0515402257,
-0.0102811186,
0.0536640398,
-0.0043716496,
0.0566964559,
-0.0235095546,
-0.0471100435,
-0.0484696478,
0.0190898813,
0.0518212393,
-0.0040352154,
0.0111531224,
-0.0704130679,
0.0134150414,
-0.0103829652,
0.0502424538,
0.0042386437,
0.0075829141,
0.0224472936,
0.0002083229,
-0.0100386795,
-0.0570576303,
0.0976404324,
0.0059196521,
0.0364484489,
0.0040353346,
-0.0372370072,
-0.0569024421,
-0.0186937079,
0.0034931689,
0.0003317819,
-0.0423083901,
-0.0075677065,
-0.0432396717,
-0.0099255471,
0.067822367,
-0.0045181615,
-0.0261979029,
-0.0136432284,
0.0685652867,
0.0331188142,
-0.0160086285,
-0.0152415093,
-0.0022682447,
0.0495511033,
0.0007148,
-0.0290599614,
-0.006228345,
-5.848762509e-33,
-0.0106756967,
-0.0433580056,
0.0313834101,
0.0143418564,
-0.0079084756,
-0.0121043036,
-0.0526623353,
-0.0166306142,
0.028822761,
0.0075105284,
-0.0409812108,
-0.0006708159,
0.0184597019,
0.0541910604,
0.0213027094,
-0.0355820581,
0.0530979782,
0.0360346995,
0.0000285514,
0.0585468858,
-0.0276754349,
0.0696982592,
0.0526266582,
-0.1035284102,
-0.0016268507,
-0.0043488313,
0.0106960339,
-0.032107275,
-0.0107017532,
0.0685751885,
-0.0343499444,
0.0494731516,
0.0352406837,
-0.0091100791,
-0.0034523646,
0.0146979392,
-0.0581669472,
-0.0220398214,
-0.0000352361,
-0.0467160679,
-0.0118029816,
-0.0878946781,
0.019918805,
-0.0137710217,
-0.026723763,
0.0088411225,
0.0398884602,
-0.0260743275,
-0.0129588647,
-0.0822856203,
-0.037298616,
0.0421795361,
0.0040555028,
-0.0187927596,
-0.0202315301,
0.0064576869,
-0.0463650376,
0.0447121821,
-0.027975319,
-0.010369801,
0.0572142005,
0.0264602453,
0.0071220761,
-0.0381377153,
-0.0164089818,
0.0413665846,
0.0213221721,
0.026700912,
-0.0596035011,
0.0199090783,
-0.0460463315,
0.0336258449,
0.0495701656,
0.0409572572,
0.028147554,
-0.0380007885,
-0.0736435577,
0.073610343,
-0.0331989191,
0.0501869917,
0.0508202836,
-0.0410193875,
-0.0529648922,
-0.0185803715,
0.0134300068,
0.0201146603,
-0.0027290927,
-0.0184165481,
0.0506743528,
0.0089894608,
0.034433011,
-0.0266799759,
-0.0236290973,
0.0103060929,
0.0235229898,
0.0018608085,
0.03085595,
0.0121794883,
-0.0354392119,
-0.019296281,
-0.0574810803,
-0.024980871,
0.0171303824,
-0.0063103875,
0.0295083486,
0.0341050103,
0.0133482171,
0.0000125229,
-0.0558343828,
0.0053176461,
0.0400224403,
0.0085439356,
0.0024248427,
0.0178739838,
0.0069555533,
0.0155885238,
0.0001586931,
0.0566545501,
-0.0121962465,
-0.0141257858,
-0.0510142297,
-0.057863906,
0.0467564054,
0.0035973317,
-0.0229636617,
0.0179926828,
-0.0337008908,
0.0644983128,
0.0168215185,
-0.0452486165,
0.0031044446,
0.0046921079,
2.765e-7,
0.0778149739,
0.0663707107,
0.0404538661,
-0.0315188617,
0.0180477928,
-0.0197630245,
0.0219071899,
0.0165638626,
-0.003147522,
-0.0102033094,
0.0685880259,
-0.0275818743,
0.0429604128,
0.0100329313,
-0.0871084034,
-0.0183127355,
-0.0912593529,
-0.0333544053,
-0.0506421402,
-0.0420384407,
0.0640912876,
0.0606091991,
-0.0550760962,
-0.0206746347,
0.0393163785,
0.0163268633,
0.058097925,
-0.055258818,
0.0051354021,
0.0430730432,
0.0435394421,
0.010908436,
0.0068381731,
0.0274428967,
-0.0112895491,
-0.0252499022,
0.0102243675,
0.0664717853,
-0.0184958987,
-0.0290784482,
0.0433530025,
0.0107217394,
0.0120249204,
-0.0346646979,
0.0382823348,
-0.0634021834,
-0.0172049943,
0.0110006556,
-0.0055130874,
-0.0063445671,
0.0650969818,
-0.0382590294,
-0.0364663638,
0.0316366404,
0.0167441349,
-0.0007884015,
-0.0017421292,
-0.0761955902,
-0.0119664893,
0.0441836752,
-0.0517661721,
-0.0105371587,
-0.0043635271,
-0.0474248752,
0.0285757817,
-0.0432167165,
0.0054986272,
2.591653262e-34,
0.0587515533,
-0.0155795701,
0.0137618482,
0.0152475592,
0.0279646255,
0.0065692309,
0.034871418,
0.0376462936,
0.0152899222,
-0.089014627,
-0.0453060754
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06081v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06081v2 | Improving Large Language Models via Fine-grained Reinforcement Learning with Minimum Editing Constraint | 2024-01-11T17:58:41 | 2024-06-17T05:52:06 | Zhipeng Chen, Kun Zhou, Wayne Xin Zhao, Junchen Wan, Fuzheng Zhang, Di Zhang, Ji-Rong Wen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Reinforcement learning (RL) has been widely used in training large language
models (LLMs) for preventing unexpected outputs, eg reducing harmfulness and
errors. However, existing RL methods mostly adopt the instance-level reward,
which is unable to provide fine-grained supervision for complex reasoning
tasks, and can not focus on the few key tokens that lead to the incorrectness.
To address it, we propose a new RL method named RLMEC that incorporates a
generative model as the reward model, which is trained by the erroneous
solution rewriting task under the minimum editing constraint, and can produce
token-level rewards for RL training. Based on the generative reward model, we
design the token-level RL objective for training and an imitation-based
regularization for stabilizing RL process. And the both objectives focus on the
learning of the key tokens for the erroneous solution, reducing the effect of
other unimportant tokens. The experiment results on mathematical tasks and
question-answering tasks have demonstrated the effectiveness of our approach.
Our code and data are available at https://github.com/RUCAIBox/RLMEC. | [
0.074078165,
0.0578190871,
0.0068438966,
0.0242414009,
-0.0481270961,
0.0115027968,
-0.0363999531,
-0.0057480019,
-0.0518262535,
-0.0501163676,
-0.021468021,
0.0038254159,
-0.0204666574,
-0.0006358762,
0.0447579063,
-0.0607422553,
0.060676977,
-0.0444720797,
0.0473026447,
-0.0111884186,
0.0223795976,
-0.0207551438,
0.0067985039,
0.032687299,
-0.0419659354,
-0.0217100568,
0.0135406991,
-0.0026112767,
0.0094407676,
0.009452397,
0.0131454403,
0.0510830656,
0.0332756788,
0.0751144066,
0.0000020977,
-0.0590773858,
-0.0402521603,
0.0095523447,
-0.0231131129,
-0.0228759907,
0.018611921,
-0.0258434601,
-0.0089344392,
0.0097892769,
-0.0283092707,
-0.0083032744,
0.0567443147,
0.0975801647,
0.0784954652,
0.1179173067,
0.0206599254,
-0.0277987961,
0.0432219915,
-0.0347061493,
0.0654571056,
-0.063152574,
0.0353910625,
0.0384520181,
0.0149479415,
-0.0031985247,
-0.0631456971,
0.0127803758,
0.0393992476,
-0.0351289175,
-0.0040721362,
0.0307807215,
-0.0245010499,
-0.0118752224,
-0.0032764792,
0.0309683792,
-0.0375392139,
-0.0323525853,
-0.0060268003,
0.0048078699,
0.0302828066,
0.0043797269,
-0.0391832776,
0.020620212,
0.0214410778,
0.0062425393,
0.0345793851,
-0.0589936487,
0.0193821862,
0.0075140768,
-0.0233076327,
0.049905505,
0.0101293372,
-0.0760863349,
-0.0395562649,
-0.0082487818,
-0.0386821404,
-0.0576970652,
-0.0336421914,
0.0350187719,
-0.0760378316,
0.0099091521,
-0.0574861057,
-0.0399019085,
-0.0037488211,
0.023311723,
0.0228000805,
0.0018170433,
0.0398824364,
0.0560410619,
-0.0464014933,
0.0696813911,
-0.0109336702,
0.0641516149,
-0.0110919205,
-0.0010367007,
-0.0313684382,
-0.0104081938,
-0.0586882941,
0.0695238337,
-0.0058668731,
-0.0080578579,
-0.0413773879,
0.0164082553,
-0.0319446512,
0.0641427189,
-0.0145336837,
-0.0015824591,
-0.0326298364,
-0.0556658693,
-0.0148847699,
0.0107735712,
-0.0383604579,
0.0165504757,
0.0282199085,
-0.0184267145,
-0.0284572691,
-0.0086310729,
0.0203369968,
-0.0394108742,
-0.0047899005,
0.0751990974,
-0.0221783649,
-0.0145260049,
-0.015816804,
-0.0365001485,
-0.0135250799,
-0.0615685694,
-0.0229092073,
-0.0964490026,
0.0331513248,
-0.0272984188,
-0.0096246656,
-0.0379666388,
0.0252597593,
-0.0064033233,
-0.0051100943,
0.0526745915,
-0.0021181928,
0.0034581004,
0.0232820641,
0.0020539931,
-0.0227878578,
0.0444799773,
0.0437265411,
0.0119148642,
0.0143457577,
-0.009131195,
0.0379355401,
0.0260049757,
0.0318900086,
0.0089668753,
-0.0065016896,
0.0105013428,
0.0227938015,
0.0669313893,
0.0314197242,
0.0462238304,
-0.0497500524,
0.0107990745,
0.0589201897,
0.0251592137,
-0.0186913423,
0.0104594473,
0.0234593209,
-0.010176979,
-0.0124285799,
0.0110757649,
-0.064995341,
0.0258526765,
-0.0243223347,
0.0276187658,
0.0177325718,
-0.0435642861,
-0.0057493029,
-0.0572429486,
0.0121565554,
0.0064515006,
-0.0240576956,
-0.0057783215,
0.0463487431,
0.0193016045,
-0.0376039632,
-0.0104590524,
0.0246260334,
-0.0103602335,
0.0132399052,
-0.0641333759,
0.0604498759,
0.0309371203,
0.054211773,
-0.0573973656,
-0.0401333757,
-0.0743863955,
-0.0061950879,
0.0334197693,
0.0503194742,
-0.0258788858,
-0.0439197496,
-0.0028794573,
-0.0222080722,
-0.0382140949,
0.0235300232,
-0.0062797512,
0.0437688082,
-0.0283137225,
-0.0019814812,
-0.0210073814,
-0.0240327269,
0.0341913663,
-0.0096733924,
-0.0421021059,
0.005087154,
0.0190418214,
0.007047351,
-0.0486631542,
-0.0273869634,
0.0332422256,
-0.0005866209,
-0.0387056172,
-0.0310650412,
-0.0322500654,
-0.0328573436,
-0.0419622809,
0.0465571508,
-0.0205266643,
-0.0380165875,
0.038138628,
-0.0616735294,
-0.0334219746,
0.0021791197,
-0.0563966893,
0.0458642319,
-0.0003760355,
-0.0006970434,
-0.0004559695,
-0.025503289,
-0.0476543978,
0.0451155081,
-0.0124470741,
0.0374901854,
-0.0098789651,
-0.0089445729,
-0.0310499128,
-0.0530640446,
-0.0195261631,
-0.0513220727,
-0.0122547857,
0.0410528928,
0.0390899293,
0.0504257977,
-0.0384701565,
-0.0593752265,
-0.0152796414,
-0.0120032523,
-0.0275483746,
0.0094522852,
0.0204262082,
0.0065849815,
-0.0131490137,
-0.0258896407,
-0.0180552118,
-0.0253622569,
0.013682019,
-0.0072807707,
0.0339882262,
0.0174233932,
-0.0173932277,
-0.0367617421,
0.0003505205,
0.0042116102,
0.0146360202,
-0.0118562533,
0.0352845415,
-0.0696444437,
0.0031638453,
-0.026593918,
0.0306703635,
-0.0001851864,
-0.0129953511,
-0.0108018229,
-0.0302795637,
0.0793074369,
0.0918965563,
0.0016060005,
0.0324902274,
0.0004110985,
0.0106612723,
-0.0664379373,
0.0339528099,
-0.0240693782,
-0.0332661867,
-0.0259014573,
-0.0108017232,
0.0108946413,
0.0717234835,
-0.0164250452,
-0.0136977453,
-0.0390411653,
0.0683876351,
-0.0173655637,
-0.0517034568,
-0.0166819245,
0.0149930269,
-0.0297061317,
0.0029139498,
-0.0586761907,
-0.0517558865,
0.0984521806,
0.0105568217,
0.0213028323,
-0.0301882196,
0.0026931884,
-0.0175702199,
0.0308981836,
0.0167803187,
0.0458124056,
-0.0158644393,
-0.0256033111,
-0.0854282156,
-0.0198748335,
0.0105202114,
-0.0049408721,
0.0671460479,
-0.020327637,
0.0057992684,
-0.0138318837,
-0.0633478388,
-0.044598043,
-0.0197716709,
-0.0127552077,
0.0174237713,
0.0008096228,
-0.0187580846,
-0.0322953053,
-0.0252147857,
0.0529662967,
0.0333341025,
-0.0463316254,
-0.0213313773,
-0.0296425596,
0.018231757,
0.0874623358,
0.0235312264,
0.0253893491,
-0.0447457209,
0.0182899274,
0.0356590077,
0.0442731194,
0.0042815791,
-0.0034741589,
-0.0191743579,
0.0044190292,
-0.0559400953,
-0.0019173898,
0.0214316081,
0.0459523499,
-0.083056666,
-0.0584444776,
0.1071079969,
0.0317118801,
-0.0080009932,
0.0020894883,
-0.053570576,
0.0435706601,
0.0174543932,
0.0623364821,
-0.0615784451,
-0.0345307849,
0.0254310928,
0.0132998591,
0.0164601989,
-0.0349115729,
0.0324282534,
-0.1314636618,
0.0329966508,
0.0046903137,
-0.0725610405,
-0.0475157239,
-0.0058214027,
0.0178724267,
0.0162362214,
0.0150666274,
0.0444156006,
-0.012596393,
-0.0118069965,
0.0309614502,
0.0275440365,
-0.0245998353,
0.0094334008,
-0.0578463227,
0.0520522818,
0.0668233633,
0.0179464724,
-0.0233159922,
-0.0101789786,
0.0270540491,
0.0773319378,
-0.0186874364,
-0.0027839283,
-0.0097357789,
-0.0091696046,
-0.0131484531,
0.0207603909,
0.0620041564,
0.0141049698,
-0.0246981848,
0.004802512,
0.1157488748,
-0.0052106171,
-0.0041507171,
0.0099279685,
-0.0311693847,
0.0044104471,
0.0383404419,
0.029883828,
-0.0402204208,
-0.062622726,
-0.0410946943,
-0.0203516353,
-0.0671428293,
-0.0018822002,
-0.0254569352,
0.0148522556,
0.0331673734,
-0.0629014671,
-0.0324860848,
0.0419140756,
0.0069997786,
0.0025730755,
-0.0215645116,
-0.0045202104,
-0.0214117039,
-0.0285948366,
0.0037884528,
-0.0707802176,
0.0321355537,
-0.0743674561,
0.0066693458,
-0.0273936093,
-0.037231382,
-0.0314262696,
-0.0088896025,
-0.0751454681,
-0.0468992405,
-0.0163794905,
0.0837054476,
0.0070371446,
0.0674490258,
-0.0102432221,
-0.066005215,
0.0335215293,
0.0300045982,
-0.034295775,
0.0181549899,
0.0177975614,
-0.0034970241,
0.0013788824,
0.0539207123,
-0.0472853445,
-0.004384059,
0.0510343462,
0.0609649606,
0.0050620348,
0.0292965602,
0.0504502431,
-0.000759872,
-0.0068676183,
0.0028026628,
0.017877914,
-0.0386881717,
0.0414423458,
-0.0146138202,
-0.0457291901,
-0.0117568448,
0.0110936714,
0.0091116317,
0.0013469012,
0.029527884,
-0.0221090559,
0.0174914449,
0.057815522,
-0.0239059739,
0.0030472924,
0.0307994522,
0.0058443653,
0.0575763807,
0.0193276368,
0.0080723176,
0.0018981401,
0.0287389345,
0.0333351642,
-0.026826553,
0.0538968891,
0.0573433302,
0.0082299002,
-0.0317196399,
-0.008756713,
-0.0380374864,
-0.0549095534,
0.0021614423,
0.0575829893,
0.0637173876,
0.0227245949,
0.0001967826,
-0.0253665354,
-0.0413562097,
-0.0159573685,
0.037098892,
-0.009826839,
-0.0360147916,
0.047584679,
0.0311279725,
0.0226386413,
-0.0073241321,
0.0755487457,
-0.0067614489,
0.0696671605,
-0.0067283981,
0.0211084466,
-0.0451289974,
-0.0102028279,
0.0225196872,
-0.0061545339,
-0.0156678259,
0.0133421542,
-0.051581867,
-0.0678787977,
-0.0298949741,
0.0552415289,
-0.0105054695,
0.0037875597,
0.0226632636,
0.0460856445,
-0.0139604695,
-0.0153688686,
-0.0390138403,
0.0188351739,
0.0264592301,
-0.0422082692,
-0.0286081433,
-6.30739265e-33,
-0.0145741208,
-0.0104663977,
0.0384392291,
-0.0006496036,
-0.0178474262,
0.0035739618,
-0.0181419067,
-0.0035981431,
0.0206163097,
0.0341054089,
-0.0185552873,
-0.0074445307,
-0.0243466813,
0.0402467102,
0.0074525904,
-0.0007204621,
0.0462325476,
-0.0015502321,
-0.0499353893,
0.0005892609,
0.0096305804,
0.0224478859,
0.0602580011,
-0.0162272993,
0.0241245888,
0.017322138,
-0.0194846112,
0.0524146035,
-0.0509142615,
0.0587244295,
0.0137848891,
0.0098585347,
0.0092167547,
-0.0383707024,
-0.0265636668,
0.0200659372,
-0.056855306,
-0.028130481,
0.0199971292,
0.0006294527,
-0.0784702376,
-0.0358026512,
0.0571591705,
-0.0088041164,
0.0023347435,
-0.0096283695,
0.0091403536,
-0.0100288466,
-0.0115928398,
0.0091283796,
-0.0877754837,
0.0012302937,
0.0131173627,
-0.044252079,
-0.0162741523,
-0.0034537623,
-0.0027654446,
-0.0141793704,
-0.0114470981,
-0.0039341631,
0.0363321863,
0.0488820076,
0.0222440176,
0.0194826536,
0.0026827191,
0.0205570869,
-0.0160271339,
-0.0031631549,
0.0181309022,
0.0123976078,
0.0122640794,
0.0377854221,
0.0424784161,
0.0365892686,
0.0214642286,
0.0159788318,
-0.0392192528,
-0.0209708121,
-0.0354083069,
0.088305369,
0.026449101,
0.0304399692,
-0.0074337255,
0.0158004612,
-0.0878081471,
0.0416944697,
-0.0336177982,
-0.0093238717,
0.0332738124,
0.0526194647,
-0.0261653196,
-0.0248581041,
0.0132425623,
-0.0493254811,
-0.0259382315,
0.0003156354,
-0.0076546106,
0.0213414412,
-0.0247760862,
-0.0047720033,
-0.0531044193,
-0.0070793596,
0.0176879205,
-0.0420364626,
0.0025033613,
0.0194797404,
0.0824238956,
0.0331424922,
-0.067171067,
0.0205701068,
-0.0332554877,
0.0512625575,
-0.0006204287,
0.0015318629,
0.0405042619,
0.0234592501,
0.0053324909,
0.0122473836,
0.0321999937,
-0.0299710352,
-0.0215662811,
0.0409361795,
-0.0110388882,
0.0072335717,
-0.0240110587,
0.0351845175,
-0.0412048362,
0.0142827285,
0.0034298431,
-0.0535355136,
0.00242589,
0.0050200629,
2.859e-7,
0.0276902001,
0.0675054044,
0.0372687504,
0.0361361839,
0.0279324874,
0.0529468581,
-0.0118837375,
0.0228983313,
0.0186777469,
0.0301009379,
0.0143939853,
0.0198159087,
-0.0013839694,
0.001441721,
-0.0851626694,
0.0237283558,
-0.0768633708,
0.0104859686,
-0.0299487542,
-0.0335450768,
0.0285623167,
0.1074135303,
0.0402138717,
-0.0218703691,
-0.0128362346,
-0.0345293991,
0.0780757368,
-0.0120847961,
-0.0138634257,
0.0401633643,
-0.0101842936,
0.0241936576,
0.039166972,
-0.0176516138,
0.0025244502,
-0.0014251649,
-0.0177829601,
0.0666678399,
-0.0320463702,
0.0422234163,
-0.0139302965,
-0.0031220524,
0.0086187394,
-0.0573395267,
0.0412674695,
-0.07528916,
0.01250837,
-0.0431662686,
0.0171708465,
-0.0051130261,
-0.0103053953,
-0.0434429161,
-0.030582197,
0.008226742,
0.0285165999,
0.0450102501,
-0.0005769251,
-0.0427647382,
-0.0134136537,
0.0112923551,
-0.0037212851,
-0.0262454338,
-0.0305431802,
0.0210250523,
-0.0095376018,
-0.0795582905,
-0.0306946784,
2.767370152e-34,
0.0218126848,
-0.0267024301,
0.009327976,
0.0297439918,
0.0370867103,
0.0053184982,
-0.052324526,
0.0050607952,
0.0346649326,
-0.0241700374,
-0.046100717
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06072v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06072v2 | Chain of History: Learning and Forecasting with LLMs for Temporal Knowledge Graph Completion | 2024-01-11T17:42:47 | 2024-02-14T15:49:21 | Ruilin Luo, Tianle Gu, Haoling Li, Junzhe Li, Zicheng Lin, Jiayi Li, Yujiu Yang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Temporal Knowledge Graph Completion (TKGC) is a complex task involving the
prediction of missing event links at future timestamps by leveraging
established temporal structural knowledge. This paper aims to provide a
comprehensive perspective on harnessing the advantages of Large Language Models
(LLMs) for reasoning in temporal knowledge graphs, presenting an easily
transferable pipeline. In terms of graph modality, we underscore the LLMs'
prowess in discerning the structural information of pivotal nodes within the
historical chain. As for the generation mode of the LLMs utilized for
inference, we conduct an exhaustive exploration into the variances induced by a
range of inherent factors in LLMs, with particular attention to the challenges
in comprehending reverse logic. We adopt a parameter-efficient fine-tuning
strategy to harmonize the LLMs with the task requirements, facilitating the
learning of the key knowledge highlighted earlier. Comprehensive experiments
are undertaken on several widely recognized datasets, revealing that our
framework exceeds or parallels existing methods across numerous popular
metrics. Additionally, we execute a substantial range of ablation experiments
and draw comparisons with several advanced commercial LLMs, to investigate the
crucial factors influencing LLMs' performance in structured temporal knowledge
inference tasks. | [
0.0458068475,
0.0413727574,
-0.0210001413,
0.0175356716,
-0.050030712,
-0.0061863307,
-0.0364427045,
0.0076623568,
0.0785648674,
-0.0165512711,
0.0467960089,
-0.0124899969,
0.0020379818,
0.0350639671,
-0.0160052069,
-0.0107876807,
0.0294487737,
-0.014572449,
0.0088439696,
-0.0112011703,
-0.0359103531,
0.0187399052,
-0.004212149,
0.0090189753,
-0.0066035483,
0.0089072613,
-0.0301029775,
-0.0110177835,
0.0287419427,
-0.0275417157,
-0.0255583152,
0.0045627789,
0.0169262197,
0.023979295,
0.0000019898,
-0.0399251357,
-0.0004194225,
-0.017277278,
-0.0360588655,
0.0134547856,
-0.0316386558,
0.0120632797,
0.0268566161,
-0.0090245483,
-0.0560331456,
0.0023697689,
-0.0095927399,
0.0272631217,
0.0065700565,
0.0657139793,
0.0090234634,
-0.0074042724,
0.0423480533,
-0.0351030231,
-0.0102765933,
-0.0548056737,
0.0557354428,
0.0224911384,
0.0261503235,
-0.0176320206,
-0.0088103097,
0.0411293991,
0.0042918171,
0.0128286155,
0.0048637865,
0.0385099687,
0.0202060528,
0.0376543477,
0.0024591421,
0.0492388681,
0.0689652562,
-0.0271632448,
0.0198587868,
0.0016716535,
-0.0117629599,
0.0260456875,
-0.0394964702,
-0.0180600658,
-0.0305391625,
0.0312574469,
0.0336370282,
-0.0181778073,
0.0765562207,
0.0195510685,
-0.0186269637,
0.1065842882,
0.0006014578,
-0.0156015428,
-0.0346618146,
0.007977345,
0.0129794506,
-0.0420733094,
0.0083120251,
0.0572871529,
-0.0430424847,
0.0133066876,
0.0195425116,
0.0454239063,
-0.0084403558,
-0.0117963096,
-0.0227546487,
0.0154031701,
0.026957348,
0.0684505478,
-0.0433470607,
0.033488296,
-0.03341043,
-0.026279591,
-0.0237907339,
-0.0443005338,
-0.0741091669,
-0.0002094847,
0.0239820369,
0.0305489227,
-0.012250633,
0.003340119,
-0.042861212,
0.0024793607,
-0.0123962928,
0.0261709597,
0.0099734087,
-0.0094887875,
-0.0029031713,
-0.0506690107,
-0.066102542,
0.0280419141,
0.0024659408,
0.0302132126,
-0.0410797969,
0.0185670666,
-0.0111458031,
-0.0129637364,
0.0018143399,
-0.0169886164,
0.0153755331,
0.0636168867,
0.0112118153,
0.009200085,
-0.0860943347,
-0.0403685458,
-0.0240394231,
-0.0454021282,
0.037678089,
-0.0575761534,
0.0149123073,
0.0361808203,
-0.0049773157,
-0.0057803662,
0.0095429644,
-0.0255486481,
-0.0774470791,
0.0142945107,
-0.0018900221,
0.0353030227,
-0.0086025223,
-0.0162322093,
0.0141202519,
0.0268646199,
0.0244991928,
0.0303285085,
0.0150393778,
0.0204237476,
-0.0386383161,
0.0425653532,
0.0326989852,
0.0208777227,
-0.0477683432,
-0.0039520436,
-0.0280133113,
0.0010207144,
0.0235382393,
0.0106043676,
-0.0113585545,
-0.000517467,
0.0296538714,
-0.0185797196,
-0.0083830738,
0.0042910292,
0.0650864318,
-0.0387514718,
-0.0011757711,
0.0053625964,
-0.0438523777,
0.0052014668,
-0.0464567989,
0.0237575825,
-0.0096048219,
0.0063939071,
-0.0063496581,
-0.0264758728,
0.0121971825,
-0.0074500414,
0.0165499244,
0.0072325845,
0.1070306525,
-0.0018442206,
-0.0516372696,
0.062250562,
0.0416027158,
0.0178067721,
0.0163641535,
0.0157940127,
0.0041411705,
0.0789062157,
0.0631446913,
-0.025268754,
-0.0202569552,
0.0150859719,
0.0228364188,
-0.0117764771,
0.0201744512,
-0.023748314,
-0.0188358929,
-0.0221908782,
-0.0522783883,
0.0218751654,
0.0211454686,
-0.0133431479,
0.0482266285,
0.0274051726,
0.0197351761,
-0.0733576193,
0.0204850417,
0.0168371014,
-0.0653632656,
0.0123993009,
-0.0182541143,
0.0140460534,
0.0391130447,
0.0354701765,
0.0180992186,
0.004624323,
0.0567251258,
-0.0349544361,
-0.0460337922,
0.009167701,
-0.0179147143,
-0.0329052731,
0.0529992171,
-0.0240040943,
-0.0327017866,
0.0026753154,
-0.0421041623,
-0.0572961457,
0.05995626,
0.0097102402,
0.0859891847,
-0.0064846212,
0.015901491,
-0.0061219675,
-0.0529471859,
-0.0175999533,
0.1013528481,
-0.0297226105,
0.0208184123,
0.0163509455,
-0.0490358323,
0.0001174732,
0.0112056015,
-0.016162375,
-0.0161190629,
0.0100337407,
-0.0278399307,
0.0285210386,
-0.0419716947,
-0.0583296232,
0.0053740931,
-0.0987610966,
0.0090297367,
-0.0006948353,
0.0131230038,
-0.0187447499,
-0.0232215244,
0.0075534135,
-0.0258658081,
0.0266119335,
0.0194875337,
-0.0147015033,
-0.0055089463,
0.0175679624,
0.0312948897,
-0.0302051511,
-0.0203743391,
-0.0225856677,
-0.0515809469,
0.063551873,
-0.0052846149,
-0.0484098122,
-0.0023679524,
0.0088409595,
-0.0444974191,
0.0224499721,
-0.0655301362,
0.0046290909,
-0.0008310975,
-0.041271735,
0.0355575718,
0.024987394,
-0.0315411575,
-0.0301868357,
0.0532773025,
-0.0369750112,
-0.0243236758,
0.0032019084,
-0.0608793348,
-0.0043810378,
-0.07431297,
-0.0122302203,
-0.0685710832,
0.0364135131,
0.0231085606,
0.0146420998,
-0.0730166212,
-0.0283898395,
-0.0161104798,
0.0243967809,
-0.0083995303,
-0.0358354338,
-0.0045010569,
0.018765619,
-0.0309372433,
-0.041357439,
0.0654455796,
0.0065218727,
0.0295326356,
0.0540033244,
-0.0198513549,
-0.0429974869,
0.0990525037,
0.0276264958,
-0.0064446898,
0.0063958806,
-0.0201598834,
-0.0584817007,
-0.004064986,
0.036681287,
-0.0070178146,
0.0131591875,
-0.0573560335,
0.0176844448,
0.0313116014,
0.0096168835,
-0.0200435054,
-0.0418229736,
-0.0661577955,
0.004568201,
-0.0144473268,
-0.0011363967,
-0.0292329267,
-0.0092993015,
-0.0276975743,
-0.0126215899,
0.0094785588,
-0.0018887192,
-0.027235603,
0.0248369798,
0.0372396819,
-0.0612491146,
0.0157448556,
-0.0017190655,
0.0089035193,
0.0024514908,
0.0531418137,
-0.0249473136,
-0.0367752463,
-0.0079170763,
-0.0051113092,
-0.0270859376,
-0.0556236133,
0.013458604,
-0.020282343,
-0.0510373972,
0.0399215668,
0.1134370118,
0.0278645195,
-0.010279539,
0.004507503,
0.0401685312,
-0.0099616144,
0.036985945,
-0.0238958392,
-0.0867045447,
0.0004303075,
0.0180482715,
-0.0107864663,
-0.0014669066,
-0.0846014991,
-0.0054963734,
-0.1165792868,
0.0034669223,
0.0249256175,
0.017999595,
-0.0432509631,
-0.0827963874,
0.0120643675,
-0.0091592157,
-0.0603548661,
0.0214392114,
-0.0122762173,
-0.0102577582,
0.0049028019,
-0.0499843769,
-0.0409960747,
0.0543113463,
-0.0031050553,
0.0649846569,
-0.0155084077,
0.0428984687,
-0.0136611545,
0.023634322,
0.0224705767,
0.0128142349,
0.0083315326,
-0.022610398,
0.03501679,
0.0288321041,
0.0158777609,
-0.0303202439,
0.0298853442,
-0.0126116918,
-0.0087306574,
0.0183453392,
0.1373468041,
-0.0061640004,
-0.0397594757,
0.0046233237,
-0.0203430615,
-0.0079246592,
0.077683948,
-0.0141848791,
0.0118208472,
-0.0291723721,
0.0172618888,
-0.0073438138,
-0.0045755156,
-0.0172302686,
0.0294794161,
-0.0424818061,
0.0384352319,
-0.0274417587,
-0.0295078736,
0.0068032611,
0.0094844941,
-0.0027200242,
0.0725748092,
0.0393797681,
-0.02903511,
-0.0601816401,
0.0081987586,
-0.0460435525,
0.0235363394,
-0.0196993928,
0.0327300765,
-0.0112540228,
-0.0135719348,
-0.017221028,
0.0470508821,
-0.0851454437,
-0.0585596003,
-0.0119618829,
-0.0088353688,
0.0187922437,
0.0894861966,
-0.0201933011,
0.0059183287,
0.0596183874,
0.0144344512,
0.0049167518,
0.0025971439,
0.0040487475,
-0.0008519234,
-0.004620777,
0.0548455529,
-0.0698157325,
-0.0058507016,
0.0085049327,
0.0462337583,
-0.0370605551,
-0.0217521694,
0.0048607751,
0.0212807544,
0.0591851734,
-0.0151058072,
-0.0261251386,
-0.010301061,
0.0126578752,
-0.0192208346,
-0.0216607023,
-0.0123462575,
0.0049216324,
0.0244025011,
-0.0013089904,
-0.0016767683,
-0.0511382185,
0.0191891473,
0.0401548669,
-0.0556136221,
-0.0173609331,
0.0188917127,
0.0015453578,
0.0741222948,
-0.0065648598,
-0.0039909282,
0.0250046123,
0.0063042361,
0.005197003,
-0.0086473487,
0.0056389701,
0.0182643421,
0.019092666,
-0.0587006323,
-0.067838639,
-0.1020838246,
-0.0149981463,
0.0168017466,
-0.0179245416,
0.098963201,
-0.0269255023,
0.0427197739,
-0.0337413363,
-0.003657748,
0.0002166893,
0.0418007523,
0.0250170901,
-0.0357870832,
0.0193395484,
0.0096941274,
-0.0361734442,
0.1047919691,
0.0781636015,
0.0446617343,
0.0898180008,
0.0233523026,
-0.0738891959,
-0.008492888,
-0.0757302344,
-0.0121840173,
0.002081373,
-0.0230962802,
0.0110126082,
-0.0795380175,
-0.0683129206,
0.0220343061,
-0.027702501,
-0.0328570418,
-0.0108639235,
-0.0140652647,
0.0473054536,
0.0399803221,
-0.028218165,
-0.0546157435,
0.0308873225,
0.0194355752,
-0.010427041,
-0.0413133055,
-6.084593859e-33,
-0.0052544079,
-0.044028081,
0.0439908095,
0.013345235,
-0.0474254601,
0.0237372126,
-0.046056252,
-0.0202885773,
-0.0306584761,
0.0301569663,
0.0012742562,
0.0205781125,
0.0084218895,
-0.0119730067,
0.0292417742,
0.0036761225,
0.0515032522,
0.0265836809,
0.0336235985,
0.0256218463,
0.0738018751,
0.0236461628,
0.0512927324,
-0.0637600273,
0.0381217413,
-0.0061629349,
0.0121101737,
0.0461674705,
0.0031840014,
0.0431193449,
0.0260777548,
0.0456707962,
0.0217744559,
-0.0271352679,
-0.0011528123,
-0.0377203226,
-0.0765242651,
-0.0243569575,
0.0288173277,
-0.0139601082,
0.026150398,
-0.0059032249,
-0.0110971499,
0.0083050495,
0.018123595,
-0.0270908121,
0.0491822846,
-0.0329177566,
-0.0554436781,
-0.0677362904,
-0.0197593458,
0.0544859245,
-0.0164890196,
0.011995513,
-0.0101517551,
0.0232878271,
0.0368818492,
-0.0100270221,
-0.0569438897,
0.0555157736,
0.0097648939,
-0.0157141797,
0.0315334648,
0.0033506732,
-0.0005373514,
0.0425230712,
-0.0411615483,
0.0114866532,
-0.0209051967,
0.0449815989,
-0.0000136146,
0.052605737,
-0.0249660295,
0.0102409925,
-0.0328790359,
-0.010052341,
-0.091706641,
-0.0090528354,
0.0289880559,
0.0621316656,
0.0159574635,
0.0139699765,
-0.0264936257,
-0.0249424838,
-0.0631599054,
-0.0126751475,
0.0030423964,
-0.0041776355,
-0.0178141445,
0.0219976921,
0.0011191042,
-0.018118497,
0.0237435941,
-0.0515985079,
-0.0300726779,
0.0816771314,
-0.0225123502,
0.0096750502,
0.0039663645,
0.0428111181,
-0.0681555644,
0.0009101126,
0.0112813069,
-0.0531554893,
0.0099261915,
-0.0212341715,
-0.0032150904,
0.0213123877,
-0.0061985352,
-0.0086939698,
-0.0207305755,
-0.0273163281,
-0.000774583,
-0.0688010082,
0.0699646622,
0.0245589539,
-0.0004981416,
0.0155084096,
0.0652013645,
0.0460628532,
0.0362860672,
0.0209173486,
0.0315281078,
-0.0127193211,
0.0044978815,
-0.0397728011,
-0.023329217,
0.0115057509,
0.0350593813,
-0.0199114326,
-0.0216258131,
0.0123046869,
2.724e-7,
0.0333357416,
0.0320319049,
0.0146860592,
0.0789036602,
0.0058036186,
0.006807731,
-0.0198206417,
-0.0312740393,
-0.0055911117,
-0.0161465015,
0.0588075146,
0.0101935789,
0.0281600375,
0.0377179347,
-0.0497079045,
-0.029496653,
-0.063942194,
-0.034186624,
-0.0723228157,
-0.015125283,
0.0152431605,
0.0469567813,
0.0861677974,
-0.0069955862,
-0.0008172992,
-0.0624968596,
0.0597469211,
-0.0038974471,
-0.0454963781,
0.0279790778,
0.0124870976,
-0.0075938352,
-0.019771615,
0.0497749224,
-0.0129285241,
0.0274463855,
-0.0395105332,
0.0356149003,
0.0183903109,
0.0016519111,
-0.005499911,
-0.0449970514,
0.0127384588,
-0.0331818275,
0.1008533612,
-0.0354459845,
-0.0184138753,
0.0200260282,
-0.0629851222,
0.0150139267,
-0.0151544055,
0.0387047678,
0.0144450897,
0.0004528136,
-0.0021607119,
0.0103914393,
-0.0051592519,
-0.0774466768,
-0.0254801959,
0.0509595461,
-0.0465874225,
-0.0542098992,
0.0139186168,
-0.0021005119,
0.0067156558,
-0.0481723696,
0.0346007869,
2.718736829e-34,
0.0408620983,
0.0042952942,
-0.0252452344,
-0.0120571218,
0.0615545511,
-0.0243602432,
-0.0562344939,
0.0248985589,
0.0465903655,
-0.1049440056,
-0.0075393519
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06071v5 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06071v5 | GroundingGPT:Language Enhanced Multi-modal Grounding Model | 2024-01-11T17:41:57 | 2024-03-05T14:36:12 | Zhaowei Li, Qi Xu, Dong Zhang, Hang Song, Yiqing Cai, Qi Qi, Ran Zhou, Junting Pan, Zefeng Li, Van Tu Vu, Zhida Huang, Tao Wang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Multi-modal large language models have demonstrated impressive performance
across various tasks in different modalities. However, existing multi-modal
models primarily emphasize capturing global information within each modality
while neglecting the importance of perceiving local information across
modalities. Consequently, these models lack the ability to effectively
understand the fine-grained details of input data, limiting their performance
in tasks that require a more nuanced understanding. To address this limitation,
there is a compelling need to develop models that enable fine-grained
understanding across multiple modalities, thereby enhancing their applicability
to a wide range of tasks. In this paper, we propose GroundingGPT, a language
enhanced multi-modal grounding model. Beyond capturing global information like
other multi-modal models, our proposed model excels at tasks demanding a
detailed understanding of local information within the input. It demonstrates
precise identification and localization of specific regions in images or
moments in videos. To achieve this objective, we design a diversified dataset
construction pipeline, resulting in a multi-modal, multi-granularity dataset
for model training. The code, dataset, and demo of our model can be found at
https: //github.com/lzw-lzw/GroundingGPT. | [
-0.0092597026,
0.0568883792,
0.0219883118,
0.053781528,
0.0023848643,
-0.0060581579,
0.022577187,
-0.031744387,
-0.0619351603,
-0.0551790446,
-0.0664199293,
-0.0055061807,
0.0123886196,
0.0141119473,
0.0302205216,
-0.0706757903,
0.0163204502,
-0.022246683,
-0.0523309708,
-0.0018141358,
0.0491617173,
0.0132837892,
0.0074658594,
0.0449055471,
-0.0613046996,
0.0096606091,
-0.0125551661,
0.0243662801,
0.0489123315,
-0.0141246635,
-0.0003424285,
0.0594908074,
0.0848325342,
0.0196203571,
0.0000021175,
0.0207513683,
0.0052922345,
-0.0105325282,
0.0142649729,
-0.0088012284,
-0.0123130577,
-0.059254013,
-0.0190582592,
-0.0232879128,
-0.0160898697,
-0.0242333151,
0.0648601651,
0.0647625029,
0.047203619,
0.0387428664,
-0.0333195142,
-0.0392255113,
0.0023661787,
-0.0207571667,
0.0291533917,
-0.0159039944,
0.005425618,
0.0678614751,
-0.0223289989,
0.0043499907,
-0.0533185489,
-0.0021673781,
0.0154258106,
0.0066686058,
-0.0252855122,
0.0536416657,
-0.0150829712,
-0.0053323894,
-0.0191451479,
0.0803134665,
-0.037723884,
-0.0312437098,
-0.0112965694,
-0.0122830579,
0.0051405905,
0.006015223,
-0.0306962151,
0.0313796513,
-0.0097514056,
0.0416547693,
-0.0370042846,
0.0042689159,
0.0138314376,
0.0150142666,
-0.0085868081,
0.0185118672,
0.0125236604,
0.0126535967,
-0.0286204591,
0.0111785056,
-0.0245392546,
-0.033818379,
0.0364544876,
0.0093655037,
0.0269903354,
-0.0172546506,
-0.0564704947,
0.0203514043,
-0.0044591427,
-0.0052722222,
0.0247028191,
0.0338911451,
-0.0919976532,
0.0683815405,
-0.0440842882,
0.0155558558,
-0.0466335341,
0.0362758785,
-0.0029667141,
-0.0172058381,
-0.0274678003,
0.0033369916,
-0.0289519932,
-0.0274336562,
-0.060996864,
-0.0152543932,
0.0026859713,
-0.0288694929,
-0.0348699056,
-0.0105622942,
-0.0121713476,
0.0264273975,
-0.0650615543,
-0.0387212485,
0.0549371243,
0.0373878516,
-0.0428867973,
0.0637205541,
-0.0056781643,
-0.0660525933,
-0.0073269829,
0.0239360426,
0.0350341871,
-0.003279001,
0.0203431062,
0.0440801196,
-0.0157493949,
-0.0182444844,
-0.0604459085,
-0.0271080323,
-0.0105392979,
-0.0474379882,
0.0092077097,
-0.0563529022,
0.0242586005,
-0.0048493575,
0.0176939182,
-0.0172629673,
0.0080869095,
-0.0036165291,
0.0224318933,
0.1033877358,
0.0014200114,
-0.0023149936,
0.0212267023,
0.0098048849,
0.0037003513,
0.0804937407,
0.0120144738,
0.0324559398,
0.017828593,
0.0022879795,
0.0133241424,
0.0263677109,
0.0043827659,
0.0220719855,
-0.055966422,
-0.0386569351,
0.0148241054,
-0.0124865929,
0.0486011282,
0.0163472947,
-0.0104203708,
-0.0056681861,
0.0944261923,
0.0171509553,
-0.0305781923,
0.0132188993,
0.0433981791,
-0.0157073662,
-0.0140954526,
-0.0038686467,
-0.0551461242,
0.0332449526,
-0.0296575502,
0.0047411877,
-0.048081845,
0.0611470975,
-0.0539518185,
-0.0033653479,
0.006507914,
0.0015709819,
0.0386698581,
0.0106754769,
0.0516748391,
-0.014574606,
-0.0306532457,
0.0821728706,
0.0200455114,
-0.0233554114,
0.0130277807,
-0.0017712902,
0.0002651237,
-0.0119154146,
-0.0424200371,
-0.0199974738,
-0.0257457905,
-0.0196008105,
0.083753176,
0.0342497341,
-0.0460146666,
0.0010288308,
0.0575999431,
-0.073873505,
-0.0535297617,
-0.0223568752,
0.0161508024,
0.0361344106,
0.0089082941,
0.0045002168,
0.0270335432,
-0.0249725748,
0.0591128767,
0.0390524007,
0.0494704545,
0.029402284,
-0.0502609126,
0.006763651,
0.0099379104,
-0.005847164,
-0.027241962,
-0.0227087345,
0.0227655079,
-0.040653415,
0.0222444497,
0.0357920676,
-0.0517517366,
0.0124986358,
0.0590484664,
-0.044211816,
-0.0070339227,
0.0172306634,
-0.0434450656,
-0.0389587171,
0.0138959792,
0.0198181011,
0.0149136549,
-0.0322198868,
-0.0262017362,
0.0148601821,
0.0347799473,
-0.0046636425,
0.0409088545,
-0.0169032998,
0.0008666303,
0.0092713367,
0.0310451444,
0.0010716163,
-0.0148534942,
-0.0339795426,
0.0038341556,
-0.0454927348,
0.0040319506,
0.0172372237,
0.0291387364,
-0.0389807001,
-0.0080271726,
-0.111909695,
-0.0288287923,
-0.0358772688,
-0.0155507643,
0.0158496182,
0.0007151589,
-0.0006725785,
-0.0454244278,
-0.0167774111,
0.0308974944,
0.0110153994,
-0.0047221035,
-0.0091883335,
0.0204851255,
-0.0204426106,
-0.02932203,
0.0195290633,
0.0169491898,
0.0202261955,
-0.0239710808,
-0.0265886486,
-0.0362548046,
-0.0043343832,
-0.0105797136,
0.0574893877,
-0.0211620908,
-0.0562789142,
-0.010830462,
-0.0129391439,
0.0528089628,
0.0818914324,
-0.0217705071,
0.0474405177,
0.0263281949,
-0.0368240327,
-0.0166068766,
0.0069390764,
0.0006927125,
0.0089430083,
-0.0415541045,
0.0127712274,
-0.0661888868,
0.0494741239,
0.0070360727,
0.0273179132,
-0.0372265764,
-0.0042544561,
-0.0312836282,
-0.016033696,
-0.0437416919,
0.0264657345,
-0.0280547533,
0.0511603765,
-0.0556894094,
-0.0649234205,
0.0149594042,
-0.0331965201,
-0.0435449295,
0.0383308604,
-0.0321823768,
-0.0146728307,
0.0486675575,
-0.0062881042,
0.0208267719,
-0.0035604816,
-0.0316770896,
-0.0546701625,
-0.0355502702,
0.0125958081,
0.0162699372,
0.0951280072,
-0.0392953977,
0.0108245453,
-0.0387625657,
-0.0216965955,
-0.0054386072,
0.0030653563,
-0.0307148602,
-0.004275667,
-0.0476071537,
-0.0143918246,
-0.0168869048,
0.0247587766,
0.0249336511,
0.0660213009,
-0.0373510644,
0.0192881133,
-0.0301380921,
0.0336381607,
0.0330668725,
0.0454178452,
-0.0456135757,
-0.0177090317,
-0.0039119087,
0.0595632344,
0.0275040958,
-0.0095929969,
-0.0770960003,
0.0645564571,
0.0281238668,
0.0463137925,
-0.016468063,
0.0187426936,
0.0845136717,
-0.0489475988,
-0.0098158382,
0.073299475,
-0.0150410393,
-0.0526997745,
-0.011261005,
-0.0028264371,
0.0154272653,
0.0326088183,
-0.0106560718,
-0.0586141162,
-0.072460033,
0.0173503812,
-0.0488677323,
0.0529168285,
0.0179408081,
0.0100965071,
-0.0433277227,
0.0481131747,
0.0152609553,
-0.0447672121,
-0.1076297984,
0.0099458667,
0.0217308607,
-0.0198564548,
0.0079269661,
-0.0338700898,
-0.0000930138,
-0.0242909063,
0.024533242,
0.0295897182,
-0.0915149525,
0.0260584336,
-0.030611394,
0.0267925858,
0.0156642348,
0.007348049,
-0.0314862616,
-0.0342211798,
0.036054723,
0.0231686067,
-0.0099277273,
0.0003767824,
0.010566582,
-0.0211332329,
-0.0236760508,
0.0344158038,
0.0588149354,
-0.0172822196,
-0.0411679968,
-0.0428306088,
0.0590330102,
-0.0161080919,
0.0503100753,
-0.0155965891,
0.0146946618,
0.0314666554,
0.0301227458,
0.0198867302,
-0.0228990857,
-0.0090602264,
-0.0317214727,
0.0238658879,
-0.0180244762,
-0.0321332291,
-0.014580261,
0.0106079476,
-0.0362070091,
-0.0181000028,
-0.0043790597,
0.0537975766,
0.04157269,
0.0062615415,
-0.0278324392,
-0.0118905734,
0.0295098498,
-0.0493951142,
0.1009705663,
-0.0255296063,
0.0204497874,
-0.0546492003,
0.0014491641,
0.0661504418,
-0.0442337021,
-0.0246395133,
0.041613277,
-0.0713291839,
-0.0400434062,
-0.0155489631,
0.0301822387,
0.0173824821,
0.0539070666,
0.0043671513,
-0.0152389975,
0.008892159,
-0.0171955079,
-0.0429186933,
0.0061123106,
0.0529479422,
-0.0400076546,
-0.0021332747,
0.0318593569,
-0.052080851,
0.0513747819,
0.0305143539,
0.002818167,
-0.0237917546,
-0.0043617939,
0.0405994728,
-0.054192327,
0.0785734802,
0.0015729117,
0.0226168074,
-0.0661749542,
-0.0117814839,
0.0048411149,
-0.022431951,
-0.0784691945,
0.0074546719,
0.0273819808,
-0.0040351055,
0.027725799,
-0.0206936989,
0.0213380121,
0.0350135304,
-0.0370404273,
0.0405318104,
0.0142589957,
-0.0126714967,
-0.0158432275,
0.036268238,
0.0058712699,
0.0161903482,
-0.0078412769,
-0.0102245631,
-0.0207723789,
0.0642025173,
0.0186734404,
-0.0277736057,
-0.0634108186,
0.0375313424,
-0.0000339188,
0.0319814384,
-0.0585380532,
0.0326465517,
0.0760219619,
-0.028272396,
0.0368080735,
0.0061166552,
-0.0359597504,
-0.0011877684,
0.0808680505,
0.0134937344,
-0.0431111827,
0.0583833233,
0.019179998,
-0.012477383,
0.012103348,
0.0557621121,
-0.0087185437,
0.0532971919,
0.0085012121,
0.0007266001,
-0.0271873046,
0.0129028056,
0.0366530493,
0.0053772656,
-0.0206059534,
0.0460732095,
-0.0182819664,
-0.0649771392,
-0.0529397093,
0.0121548939,
-0.0328326523,
0.028728012,
0.0414876156,
0.0444676131,
-0.0019576941,
-0.0304687191,
-0.023332024,
-0.0169388875,
0.0237793364,
-0.0031907533,
-0.0287525877,
-6.213619057e-33,
-0.0394440964,
0.0029262633,
-0.0030972234,
-0.0076267994,
-0.0208592098,
0.05353285,
-0.0079302751,
0.0336204506,
-0.0362485722,
0.0482558832,
0.0159348305,
-0.0070174369,
0.0319362581,
0.0335600674,
0.0004326487,
-0.0005505064,
0.0409961119,
-0.0235565305,
0.0131020378,
-0.0107297935,
0.0331453234,
0.0123253176,
0.1091629416,
-0.0877357498,
-0.0377710871,
0.036058493,
-0.0879333839,
0.000152842,
0.008884876,
0.0702616051,
-0.016915489,
0.0123956082,
0.0076677608,
-0.0558961704,
-0.0314226486,
0.0220405143,
-0.0658869743,
-0.0052426159,
-0.0102874124,
0.0625951812,
-0.0279495455,
-0.0036144285,
0.0267019123,
-0.0500220917,
0.0062798266,
-0.0254825242,
0.0372819901,
-0.0298891403,
0.007958293,
-0.0031887421,
-0.0484080017,
0.0256243851,
0.0007528784,
-0.0637182295,
0.0391134955,
-0.0036808366,
0.0313113891,
-0.0081089716,
-0.0315659121,
0.0109292194,
0.0036565275,
0.0416109152,
0.0627296492,
0.0295254402,
0.0183312092,
0.0482703671,
0.0016446045,
-0.051620502,
-0.0048350855,
-0.0210426748,
0.0337915048,
0.0482575446,
-0.0020477714,
0.0295461975,
0.0075253206,
0.01740353,
-0.0356083438,
0.0161153339,
-0.0193396378,
0.0684929937,
0.0040031071,
0.0320461877,
0.0327452049,
0.000461708,
-0.0140459388,
-0.0574371964,
-0.0045010149,
-0.0175059512,
0.0305464882,
0.0333033204,
-0.0388587862,
0.0326964334,
0.0918791145,
-0.0146572562,
0.0109554771,
0.0608513653,
-0.0080828499,
0.0625623539,
0.0257525891,
-0.0173317194,
-0.0389871411,
-0.0388623737,
0.0386389382,
-0.0303862169,
0.0232758578,
-0.0027964439,
0.0099672209,
0.0577240847,
-0.0362392254,
-0.0070472397,
-0.0345759541,
-0.0027025633,
0.0134369675,
0.0700269043,
0.0590167753,
-0.0160963181,
-0.0397316143,
0.0428617038,
0.0057398342,
-0.0005509405,
0.0068667405,
-0.0621793121,
-0.0267626029,
0.064505294,
-0.0306608584,
0.0024494971,
-0.0786055624,
-0.0826937035,
0.0589754507,
-0.0062516369,
-0.016890632,
0.0177908111,
2.761e-7,
0.0052452236,
0.0077512027,
0.0076084696,
-0.0132410703,
0.0119783161,
0.0507153757,
-0.0290909503,
0.0185490288,
-0.0006653787,
-0.087745443,
-0.0098420605,
0.0344486423,
0.0209814906,
0.0136904353,
-0.0442871079,
0.0491869524,
-0.0304690506,
-0.0064191367,
-0.0042400253,
-0.0095128026,
-0.0179442596,
0.1366222501,
-0.0092575317,
-0.0009742263,
0.0521876886,
-0.0312673748,
0.0530997366,
-0.051255662,
0.0065750768,
-0.0072313878,
0.0023569269,
0.0395179093,
-0.0309864581,
0.0185863487,
-0.0083762258,
0.0098912362,
0.026978977,
0.051258374,
-0.0399402678,
-0.0065323939,
-0.0359858833,
0.0282597989,
-0.0323810354,
-0.0637470931,
0.0520798117,
-0.036474891,
-0.0190085266,
-0.0812665299,
-0.0033751081,
0.0117398938,
-0.0039927349,
-0.0203558039,
-0.0487571508,
-0.0075973351,
0.021918945,
-0.0176156107,
-0.0679766983,
-0.0851119235,
-0.0324571319,
0.0177897755,
-0.0396937281,
0.0165402479,
-0.0083838375,
-0.0600043274,
0.0465715416,
-0.0434426516,
-0.0583446547,
2.614433057e-34,
-0.0201874264,
-0.0314169489,
0.0095372349,
0.0301132388,
0.0145386187,
0.0002682204,
-0.0550054498,
0.0043387408,
-0.0354618803,
-0.0014288637,
-0.016468633
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06066v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06066v1 | DeepSeekMoE: Towards Ultimate Expert Specialization in Mixture-of-Experts Language Models | 2024-01-11T17:31:42 | 2024-01-11T17:31:42 | Damai Dai, Chengqi Deng, Chenggang Zhao, R. X. Xu, Huazuo Gao, Deli Chen, Jiashi Li, Wangding Zeng, Xingkai Yu, Y. Wu, Zhenda Xie, Y. K. Li, Panpan Huang, Fuli Luo, Chong Ruan, Zhifang Sui, Wenfeng Liang | cs.CL | cs.CL | In the era of large language models, Mixture-of-Experts (MoE) is a promising
architecture for managing computational costs when scaling up model parameters.
However, conventional MoE architectures like GShard, which activate the top-$K$
out of $N$ experts, face challenges in ensuring expert specialization, i.e.
each expert acquires non-overlapping and focused knowledge. In response, we
propose the DeepSeekMoE architecture towards ultimate expert specialization. It
involves two principal strategies: (1) finely segmenting the experts into $mN$
ones and activating $mK$ from them, allowing for a more flexible combination of
activated experts; (2) isolating $K_s$ experts as shared ones, aiming at
capturing common knowledge and mitigating redundancy in routed experts.
Starting from a modest scale with 2B parameters, we demonstrate that
DeepSeekMoE 2B achieves comparable performance with GShard 2.9B, which has 1.5
times the expert parameters and computation. In addition, DeepSeekMoE 2B nearly
approaches the performance of its dense counterpart with the same number of
total parameters, which set the upper bound of MoE models. Subsequently, we
scale up DeepSeekMoE to 16B parameters and show that it achieves comparable
performance with LLaMA2 7B, with only about 40% of computations. Further, our
preliminary efforts to scale up DeepSeekMoE to 145B parameters consistently
validate its substantial advantages over the GShard architecture, and show its
performance comparable with DeepSeek 67B, using only 28.5% (maybe even 18.2%)
of computations. | [
0.0760904849,
0.0665426999,
-0.0105583593,
0.0304491725,
-0.0116540175,
-0.0200302023,
0.045041509,
-0.0026676869,
-0.0093111247,
-0.0123574492,
-0.0651360229,
-0.0395978168,
-0.0217824634,
0.0394784287,
0.0152511327,
-0.0352511778,
0.0068238149,
-0.0655949414,
0.0184707437,
-0.0497537032,
0.0001609693,
-0.0038087857,
-0.0140865995,
0.0163638871,
0.0004836174,
0.0147424415,
-0.0012806416,
-0.0287315939,
-0.004322011,
0.0393854007,
0.0209382009,
0.0681022853,
0.017382374,
0.0342235304,
0.0000022484,
-0.005974995,
-0.0078157969,
-0.0107407067,
-0.0307817608,
0.0540895462,
-0.0016418528,
-0.0132748513,
-0.0172152929,
-0.0100012589,
-0.0021398808,
-0.0012610019,
0.050073348,
0.0102761239,
0.0287059359,
0.1013721451,
0.0090056723,
-0.0130168293,
0.0871835351,
-0.0438771322,
-0.0250442084,
-0.0498900227,
0.0130699202,
-0.0134232836,
-0.0128549431,
0.0220773034,
0.0084563065,
0.0574681573,
0.0153340828,
0.0113381166,
0.0252369177,
0.0315233991,
0.0470203236,
-0.0142011819,
-0.0160907023,
0.0602280535,
-0.049016118,
-0.0010033844,
0.0082539218,
-0.0040059849,
-0.0288621541,
-0.0016028489,
-0.0245847944,
0.0195942186,
-0.0024095865,
-0.0034019151,
0.0377308875,
0.0313079655,
0.0412925594,
0.0357756466,
-0.0636738017,
0.0576528274,
0.0303825922,
0.0104034757,
-0.0162831433,
-0.0127291987,
-0.0240737274,
-0.0327815786,
0.0493041202,
-0.0129113374,
-0.0377598964,
0.0138565879,
-0.0211683065,
-0.0119268252,
-0.0253507178,
-0.0039194836,
0.0234517436,
0.0486768149,
0.0013861031,
0.0541261956,
-0.0198425017,
0.0000641577,
-0.0577040911,
0.0126703288,
-0.0044941129,
-0.0340794921,
-0.0329591297,
-0.0145809809,
-0.0009847498,
0.0144102182,
-0.0225444157,
-0.0327403136,
-0.0027816393,
0.0053246026,
-0.0187892336,
-0.0130931744,
0.0157243311,
0.0246783905,
-0.0359211117,
-0.0497971736,
-0.0362856351,
0.037414711,
-0.0547035523,
0.0137529476,
0.0117163165,
-0.048419375,
0.0249131173,
0.0296649821,
-0.0084711658,
-0.0061852243,
0.0345340297,
0.041037146,
-0.0464427881,
-0.0048689255,
0.0031767737,
-0.0145309772,
-0.0096184248,
-0.0890348479,
0.0097052734,
-0.0874015987,
0.0683281571,
-0.0024894085,
-0.0011206986,
-0.0620679669,
-0.0059515862,
-0.03167326,
-0.047806032,
0.0317180268,
-0.0450763442,
0.0162088461,
0.0277868398,
0.0073689334,
-0.0298523717,
0.0661736503,
0.007993022,
-0.0006846808,
0.0210498739,
0.0124424249,
0.003508575,
0.0330891646,
-0.0165916011,
-0.0097986804,
-0.0236690473,
-0.0210643336,
-0.049128253,
0.0429057218,
0.0559936389,
0.0691680908,
-0.0397157185,
-0.0207966119,
0.0367304198,
0.0389170498,
0.0110787414,
0.0866348371,
0.0395942889,
0.0115572186,
0.0348838456,
0.0024989636,
-0.0167858377,
0.0217580441,
-0.0282384846,
-0.0143582486,
0.0463540368,
0.0703498572,
-0.0329271667,
-0.032916382,
0.0149528123,
-0.0058875959,
-0.0724235922,
0.017077852,
0.0470047742,
-0.0417194217,
0.008072651,
0.0626126155,
0.0184237603,
-0.0301853288,
-0.0170319248,
-0.0452060476,
-0.0134228319,
0.089454554,
0.010223493,
-0.0258209035,
-0.0322462656,
0.0130747976,
-0.040870335,
0.0090075778,
0.0326353945,
0.0026756127,
0.0121936686,
-0.0848542452,
-0.03440338,
-0.0212825965,
0.0263967924,
0.0531513505,
0.0433669761,
-0.004852395,
0.0137028359,
-0.0119439308,
0.0224930737,
-0.0044697695,
-0.0354727693,
0.0286754612,
-0.0121750748,
0.0098826401,
0.0335906185,
0.0185422171,
-0.0236426666,
0.0111802667,
0.0044088764,
-0.0409331471,
-0.0197038278,
-0.0366190374,
-0.056380149,
-0.0132293385,
0.0375763774,
-0.0151473712,
0.0018874767,
-0.0144441323,
-0.0007971585,
-0.0528731383,
0.0325470567,
-0.0201089587,
0.0354610421,
-0.0324998721,
0.0004209928,
0.0119620068,
0.0270873271,
-0.0037008557,
0.0809995085,
-0.0393780693,
-0.0127169611,
0.0506083816,
0.0078228312,
-0.0127828028,
-0.0178956371,
-0.0279172696,
-0.0215563811,
0.0341190062,
0.0543754324,
-0.0018733233,
-0.0177464802,
-0.0125722643,
-0.0990562662,
-0.0986132547,
0.0289825443,
-0.0358541831,
0.0056841122,
0.0183646195,
0.0099623427,
-0.0045673074,
0.0270785391,
-0.0220385399,
0.0126849599,
-0.0252112113,
0.0093027018,
-0.0315435193,
0.0086612906,
-0.02777238,
-0.0224432331,
-0.0548566766,
-0.00982033,
0.0278039817,
-0.0405755341,
-0.0190199837,
-0.0246613845,
-0.0229230579,
-0.0374616496,
0.0418860354,
-0.0152869895,
-0.0192235932,
0.0035115504,
-0.0608772114,
0.0676076189,
0.0378702842,
-0.0287097152,
0.0194836259,
0.0431636907,
-0.0282877125,
-0.0342296697,
0.0256597195,
0.0327667445,
0.004584658,
-0.0371265225,
0.0177841242,
-0.0453618653,
0.0632269233,
-0.0000495031,
-0.0392559543,
-0.0341460742,
-0.0166604016,
0.0363077968,
-0.0430320799,
0.0161724482,
0.0094681876,
0.0003841721,
0.052491352,
-0.0312158838,
-0.0091561098,
0.0519040078,
-0.0064891558,
-0.0076742768,
-0.0295387693,
-0.0275536384,
-0.0217732545,
0.006097795,
-0.0012658336,
0.0323392376,
-0.0265444368,
0.0097756945,
-0.0342023894,
0.0477226265,
-0.024310831,
-0.0063552917,
0.0475227088,
-0.0594692752,
0.0193349812,
0.0095270472,
-0.0372379534,
0.0010639335,
0.0175867509,
-0.0708251819,
0.0525515974,
0.0854087844,
-0.038433779,
-0.0471686684,
0.0172236245,
0.0165626127,
0.0605043694,
-0.0153811462,
0.0199259538,
-0.0316801555,
0.0298368633,
0.0007735994,
0.020203121,
-0.0081701931,
-0.0247897822,
0.0061901724,
0.0434613824,
0.0546551235,
-0.0339341536,
-0.0344181471,
0.0066164173,
0.0515453853,
-0.018692771,
-0.0698684305,
0.0057179946,
0.0423738733,
-0.0569442026,
0.0309663024,
0.0913359672,
-0.0036599799,
-0.0545905828,
-0.0141632194,
0.0201696306,
0.0445076898,
0.019362051,
0.0205208343,
-0.0556831732,
-0.0176356863,
0.0075914394,
-0.0310734417,
0.0144871837,
-0.0224902127,
0.0023358613,
-0.0841938779,
0.0078896629,
0.0132778026,
-0.0375705585,
-0.0121906549,
-0.0081712566,
-0.0076363031,
-0.0062303897,
0.0149577558,
0.0170085263,
0.0308458265,
-0.0370927788,
0.0342168771,
-0.0236738175,
-0.0890950114,
0.0450321883,
-0.0293529611,
0.0744145215,
0.0185578596,
-0.0276246872,
-0.0066425009,
-0.0253443625,
-0.0113214012,
0.0087584658,
0.0292980894,
0.0059352131,
0.0238025449,
-0.0311785955,
-0.0243497808,
0.0163690541,
0.0101760915,
0.0010070889,
0.0436765477,
-0.0021420524,
0.0678715631,
0.0133755049,
-0.0249817185,
-0.0126012238,
-0.0296596643,
-0.0470190309,
0.0346564278,
0.0105456477,
-0.0501566529,
-0.0042950152,
-0.037482243,
-0.0160801895,
-0.0415495262,
-0.0282246135,
0.0158706065,
0.0253927745,
-0.0686124563,
-0.0112728067,
-0.0031611796,
0.0307406206,
0.0561829545,
0.0038189583,
0.0200343281,
-0.0004902374,
-0.0025329683,
-0.0240085851,
0.0140387313,
-0.0396278501,
-0.0095591675,
-0.0860905349,
-0.0213256348,
0.0321205519,
0.0061182966,
-0.010885261,
-0.0021601454,
-0.0553886592,
-0.0945888385,
-0.0227574259,
0.0616807565,
0.0232743528,
0.0293581951,
0.0014059559,
-0.1215154678,
0.0868137926,
-0.0140345264,
-0.0705498084,
0.0027943619,
0.0306804646,
-0.0343523175,
-0.0067942361,
0.0455951914,
-0.0155559797,
0.0127619393,
0.0082054902,
0.0236631297,
-0.0395007841,
-0.013040687,
-0.0259195827,
-0.0065075834,
0.0283408444,
-0.0150300181,
0.0349064134,
-0.0426879413,
0.011234602,
-0.0105188768,
-0.0067252656,
-0.037622001,
0.0225027651,
0.0489662848,
0.0056211515,
0.0239905231,
0.0092060603,
0.0684545636,
-0.0215004366,
0.0154590197,
0.0169254914,
0.0100136288,
0.0039873482,
0.0263861921,
-0.0201527774,
-0.0261342153,
0.0210622698,
0.0190023836,
0.0031355121,
-0.0369885601,
0.0098609636,
-0.0171147808,
-0.0282358564,
-0.0454930291,
0.0366463214,
-0.0548015386,
-0.0905676335,
0.0003143557,
0.0772369877,
0.0716143548,
0.0052157743,
0.0335410908,
-0.0187660512,
-0.0082000699,
-0.0278929025,
0.0012378715,
0.0104609216,
0.0046396991,
0.0152462749,
0.0280103292,
0.0023373042,
0.0347307213,
0.0605347045,
0.0307304971,
0.0269088577,
0.003240448,
-0.0067348755,
-0.0360397622,
-0.0040394315,
-0.0104463808,
0.066752553,
-0.0303527135,
0.0147418911,
-0.0125802401,
-0.0286337603,
-0.0077650328,
-0.0078271413,
-0.0293955058,
-0.0197214186,
0.04503249,
0.068827875,
-0.0235909931,
-0.0028556855,
-0.0138292816,
-0.0131038688,
0.0476488806,
-0.0059138867,
0.0320809372,
-7.206648032e-33,
0.0030068459,
0.0382382683,
0.025195308,
-0.0704437643,
0.006840718,
0.0102006141,
-0.027755525,
0.0267323088,
-0.0267088376,
-0.0032751097,
-0.0562372319,
-0.0060787909,
0.0125034153,
0.0102502778,
0.0415547974,
0.0462797284,
0.0552289858,
-0.0069485591,
0.0116209025,
0.0317685492,
-0.004047187,
0.021015441,
0.0773020685,
-0.0540202521,
-0.0152356261,
0.0213862807,
-0.0039978041,
0.0103318747,
-0.0272936858,
0.0579217598,
-0.0318060294,
0.0698814243,
0.0146242492,
-0.0381376967,
-0.0315375291,
-0.0490246788,
-0.0586279966,
-0.0312478561,
0.0162778273,
-0.024537487,
-0.0288592428,
-0.0530499071,
0.0845185891,
0.0308520086,
0.0252600685,
-0.0394187048,
0.0278765485,
-0.0173799153,
-0.0163388532,
0.0032338209,
-0.0198334996,
0.0497568808,
0.0010562823,
0.0262158699,
0.0483588763,
-0.0487402976,
-0.0088390792,
-0.0482556745,
-0.0268546939,
0.01067237,
0.0589126348,
0.0917294919,
0.0560244583,
0.0205949862,
-0.0105478372,
0.0318803452,
0.0579065681,
-0.0132151227,
-0.0100063551,
-0.0310251042,
0.0499532931,
0.0667494312,
0.0231829062,
0.0165896919,
0.026318239,
-0.0174543168,
-0.0448320545,
-0.0206023119,
0.0567912012,
0.0144593008,
0.0631311536,
0.0269558858,
-0.0662627667,
-0.0430124961,
-0.018418394,
-0.0484396778,
-0.0464670062,
-0.0279416423,
0.0061164661,
0.0281770993,
-0.0124889649,
0.0093776127,
0.0296281222,
-0.057937637,
0.0023442365,
0.0133377686,
-0.014790467,
0.048936557,
0.0090978453,
0.04813518,
-0.1113200858,
-0.0531817712,
-0.0147583531,
-0.0160650127,
-0.0229800809,
0.0137095964,
-0.0225647576,
0.0330538712,
-0.0527875759,
-0.0280514006,
-0.022495985,
-0.0125239491,
0.0215335526,
0.0572136529,
0.0147892879,
-0.0140987691,
0.0071823746,
-0.0019688006,
-0.0096464278,
0.0059220158,
-0.0011176623,
-0.0186897106,
0.019424092,
0.0110603422,
-0.0186735764,
0.0249477401,
-0.069106549,
-0.0719323233,
0.017309498,
-0.009761869,
-0.0298090484,
0.0008749538,
2.867e-7,
0.0206946973,
0.0348560885,
0.0168300197,
-0.0497682206,
0.0200787745,
0.018164359,
0.0005028596,
0.0017930019,
-0.0092879692,
-0.0442094095,
0.048190657,
0.0739087164,
0.008215392,
0.0094669834,
-0.0804044455,
-0.0169589277,
-0.023147976,
0.0498260036,
-0.0492785685,
-0.0602571853,
-0.0132264066,
0.115024358,
0.0429691859,
-0.019071145,
-0.0205865018,
-0.0243451186,
0.0385199115,
-0.0187325869,
0.015247385,
0.0659663603,
0.1120429114,
0.057349205,
-0.0234459247,
0.0401412174,
0.0439885296,
0.0576076098,
0.0212714057,
0.1069160625,
-0.0273478869,
-0.0060406495,
0.0663497746,
-0.0207794495,
-0.0301504079,
-0.0443322845,
0.0719453543,
-0.0006786313,
-0.0071248938,
0.0021135404,
-0.0007645341,
-0.0296833888,
-0.0139162969,
-0.0168175139,
-0.0389509052,
0.0314162895,
0.0050118947,
-0.0229122099,
-0.0331490189,
-0.0868111402,
-0.013882651,
0.01095335,
-0.067888774,
-0.0553591289,
-0.0154501414,
-0.0154909911,
0.0321190543,
-0.0146946982,
0.0148734637,
2.651137868e-34,
0.0543777198,
0.0289518759,
0.0059399474,
0.0287461933,
0.0301655103,
-0.0447539762,
-0.079522714,
0.0054994235,
0.0057193488,
-0.0779474005,
-0.0561069436
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06059v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06059v1 | Investigating Data Contamination for Pre-training Language Models | 2024-01-11T17:24:49 | 2024-01-11T17:24:49 | Minhao Jiang, Ken Ziyu Liu, Ming Zhong, Rylan Schaeffer, Siru Ouyang, Jiawei Han, Sanmi Koyejo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Language models pre-trained on web-scale corpora demonstrate impressive
capabilities on diverse downstream tasks. However, there is increasing concern
whether such capabilities might arise from evaluation datasets being included
in the pre-training corpus -- a phenomenon known as \textit{data contamination}
-- in a manner that artificially increases performance. There has been little
understanding of how this potential contamination might influence LMs'
performance on downstream tasks. In this paper, we explore the impact of data
contamination at the pre-training stage by pre-training a series of GPT-2
models \textit{from scratch}. We highlight the effect of both text
contamination (\textit{i.e.}\ input text of the evaluation samples) and
ground-truth contamination (\textit{i.e.}\ the prompts asked on the input and
the desired outputs) from evaluation data. We also investigate the effects of
repeating contamination for various downstream tasks. Additionally, we examine
the prevailing n-gram-based definitions of contamination within current LLM
reports, pinpointing their limitations and inadequacy. Our findings offer new
insights into data contamination's effects on language model capabilities and
underscore the need for independent, comprehensive contamination assessments in
LLM studies. | [
0.032627508,
0.0669904575,
-0.0377914868,
0.0184886102,
-0.0402881317,
0.0218264572,
0.003765678,
0.0119298836,
0.0005364554,
-0.0782826021,
-0.0424813814,
-0.052221708,
0.0303724743,
0.0066737821,
0.0564567111,
-0.0218496546,
0.0670145676,
-0.0204552189,
-0.0537884459,
-0.0123690069,
0.009715125,
0.0014759956,
0.0231078342,
0.0127168391,
-0.0084425351,
-0.0106575936,
0.010501747,
0.0075028576,
-0.0235821102,
-0.0287627466,
-0.003220072,
0.0600607581,
0.0024902129,
0.0316771567,
0.0000018929,
-0.0522231832,
0.006489269,
0.0055515533,
-0.0562300533,
0.0605863519,
0.0425654016,
0.0169024915,
-0.0128094126,
0.0560495295,
-0.0152433831,
-0.0179158375,
0.0274689738,
0.0343141071,
0.0404647142,
0.0484975241,
-0.0102154333,
0.0326010436,
0.0250568017,
-0.0151758045,
0.0112229902,
0.0240977295,
0.0230178349,
-0.0182239786,
0.0134593146,
0.0087004099,
-0.0144121191,
0.0387409218,
-0.0015530946,
0.0382861644,
-0.0357939489,
0.0277045239,
-0.031110229,
-0.0456352718,
-0.0108687263,
0.0424550474,
-0.0039806385,
-0.0007865337,
-0.0059939618,
-0.0323990509,
0.0020364986,
0.0120831626,
-0.0144197205,
0.0484193116,
0.0020280334,
0.0403753035,
-0.0122186719,
-0.0448667631,
0.0500980541,
0.0013338394,
-0.0228093881,
0.0974841863,
0.031734705,
-0.0584162362,
0.0302068926,
0.0477650054,
-0.0220217556,
-0.0513823703,
-0.0098984698,
-0.0210785046,
0.0203912463,
0.0524573065,
-0.0402308665,
-0.0130369328,
0.0526571609,
-0.0279558133,
0.0582543164,
0.018338358,
-0.0440695621,
0.0029861038,
0.0000590332,
0.0201190859,
0.0034636261,
0.0183784645,
-0.0340549201,
0.008237062,
0.0094027277,
-0.0212129951,
-0.0204015654,
0.0294490717,
-0.013774978,
0.0012999981,
-0.0204209611,
0.0435297526,
-0.0098884031,
-0.0147126243,
0.0061702207,
-0.0144413905,
-0.0400436968,
0.0072425413,
-0.0433915593,
-0.0038738637,
-0.0031262233,
0.0573943444,
-0.0066734203,
-0.1158344522,
-0.0134247113,
0.0096870987,
-0.0142414644,
-0.0414984077,
0.0175454766,
0.0585583039,
0.0217329971,
-0.0414283238,
-0.0331519544,
-0.0031299845,
-0.0285631139,
-0.0526324958,
-0.0032304509,
-0.0246097874,
0.0073107905,
0.0275075119,
-0.0025759486,
-0.0332726128,
-0.0050138324,
0.0505206436,
-0.0704706609,
0.0689711869,
-0.0419596136,
0.0232078321,
0.0012078369,
0.0019317712,
0.0071892957,
0.0798543617,
0.0329232961,
0.0106591284,
0.0275057591,
-0.03012399,
0.0094447611,
0.0791405737,
0.0100843068,
0.0487659015,
-0.014313248,
-0.0194184277,
0.0172866806,
0.000340883,
0.0416487865,
0.078312017,
-0.0162647367,
0.0345551521,
0.0843323618,
0.0497360229,
0.0053578755,
-0.0109038297,
0.0383791812,
0.0188266765,
0.0215355158,
0.0491865985,
-0.0650595203,
-0.0751226097,
-0.0294832923,
0.0130642364,
0.0172816161,
0.0257387944,
-0.02244642,
-0.0415072329,
-0.0401846431,
-0.0224973485,
0.0219730213,
-0.003759685,
0.0392444469,
0.0202789325,
-0.0529628918,
0.0473297127,
0.0282397717,
-0.0713436678,
0.0470682271,
-0.033876311,
-0.0030629693,
0.067692183,
0.059283331,
-0.0038876659,
-0.0213188436,
-0.015766887,
-0.0041512814,
0.0287556965,
0.0258338451,
0.0066238227,
0.0228840057,
-0.0487902127,
-0.0447020978,
-0.0099472422,
0.0115160951,
0.0016344035,
-0.0089527788,
0.0085413167,
0.0230801255,
-0.0362714976,
-0.0465345904,
0.0632275641,
-0.0291401017,
0.0013264867,
-0.0122420788,
-0.0047503891,
0.0200543143,
0.0129113393,
-0.0282391645,
0.0157790091,
0.0339044668,
0.0121948579,
0.0093364827,
-0.0183970798,
-0.0279495157,
0.0178532824,
0.0461483076,
0.0138407564,
0.0078102062,
0.0438377634,
-0.0110703008,
-0.0363475196,
-0.0218603425,
-0.0250252821,
0.0241720024,
-0.0508950166,
0.0412726402,
-0.007004926,
0.0150399767,
-0.0501386635,
0.0229134969,
-0.0097970068,
0.0231091995,
-0.0041807741,
0.0279038046,
0.0354163013,
-0.0281065106,
-0.0643871874,
0.0097810403,
0.0012547204,
0.0288679041,
0.0266600735,
-0.0006047126,
-0.0516499951,
-0.0157678686,
-0.0974941924,
-0.0078605572,
-0.0105516072,
0.0302492548,
0.0237225555,
-0.0097884964,
-0.0442109182,
0.0156205734,
-0.0229437184,
-0.0300725084,
0.0391292088,
0.0499648489,
0.0355897844,
-0.0108116912,
0.0170824043,
-0.0266563389,
-0.0135856178,
-0.0080464706,
0.0242405385,
-0.0168898329,
-0.0376571454,
-0.0635628253,
0.0851987004,
-0.0323761255,
0.015790727,
0.0133316666,
-0.0410478637,
0.0213567298,
0.0015929064,
0.0240709446,
0.0122144148,
-0.0024131928,
0.0311389733,
0.0549199507,
-0.0145025318,
-0.0541428812,
-0.0135912839,
0.0115900105,
-0.0248146281,
-0.0380153246,
-0.0255747717,
-0.0002357673,
0.0656474084,
-0.0022437333,
-0.0227507893,
-0.0232667401,
0.0131216664,
-0.0575383902,
-0.0170957837,
0.0001271006,
-0.0332785584,
-0.0587480851,
0.0435637794,
-0.0191890504,
-0.074886255,
0.0190390479,
-0.0544308871,
-0.0095991865,
-0.0516550392,
0.0122729251,
0.0032277775,
0.0142895896,
0.016240418,
-0.0019942967,
0.0161628108,
-0.0561007597,
-0.0716347247,
0.0429789461,
0.0264090877,
-0.0444963574,
0.0484471545,
-0.0320869833,
0.0132178105,
-0.000505476,
-0.0365768522,
-0.0452031344,
-0.0427056402,
0.0278546717,
-0.0041743652,
0.0188756268,
0.0373873934,
-0.0004961042,
-0.0047560995,
-0.0059877038,
0.0163339581,
-0.0116272746,
0.0138761811,
-0.0166937523,
0.0157827381,
0.0435991362,
0.0023599402,
0.028935492,
-0.0316178985,
-0.0259867981,
0.0162466876,
0.0329523198,
-0.01683232,
0.0087639103,
0.0182751026,
0.0588733964,
-0.0151340645,
-0.0632430464,
0.0288579576,
0.046738591,
-0.0587760918,
-0.0205808636,
0.1003290266,
0.0223083198,
-0.0185229778,
-0.0062474445,
0.0339565687,
0.0425372645,
0.0197067577,
-0.0098318271,
-0.1032354981,
0.0040155817,
0.0304666497,
0.0192753728,
-0.0233260151,
-0.0015011135,
-0.0390209034,
-0.1372141987,
0.0412395932,
0.0076049003,
-0.043756675,
0.0023956797,
-0.0281205866,
-0.0057209432,
-0.0043929256,
0.0713771805,
0.0023750192,
-0.0383690596,
0.0218442809,
0.040075209,
-0.0398138314,
-0.1154824793,
-0.0172738582,
-0.0295274816,
0.0652740598,
0.0687106103,
-0.0248471219,
-0.0566136539,
-0.0227188673,
0.0714769587,
-0.0554598719,
0.0011730408,
-0.0065392139,
0.0520751216,
-0.0046359729,
-0.0079945773,
-0.00002969,
-0.0104532149,
-0.0229491275,
0.0054509174,
-0.0240077078,
0.0603899658,
-0.0273630079,
-0.0185105987,
0.0005930403,
-0.031973958,
0.0215040445,
0.0949065387,
0.0239529647,
-0.0647485852,
-0.0137128271,
-0.0268144589,
0.0181138329,
0.0170369912,
0.0068973945,
0.0461588204,
-0.0268317759,
-0.0256000217,
-0.0526181646,
-0.1148861796,
0.0289377701,
0.0280079097,
0.0251915827,
0.045497071,
-0.0375822484,
-0.0099911327,
-0.0165729448,
0.0703206956,
-0.0260783918,
-0.0017522856,
-0.0744033381,
0.0013817257,
-0.0078871259,
-0.0061336961,
-0.007258499,
0.019733496,
-0.10232535,
-0.0814304128,
0.0480226874,
0.0405010171,
0.0359882861,
0.020139562,
-0.0012280991,
-0.0586019754,
0.0421695858,
0.0108652525,
-0.0556038208,
0.0315656066,
0.0429216735,
-0.0184088722,
0.0101006161,
0.0131191006,
-0.0231672786,
0.0121684568,
0.033507362,
0.0037154278,
-0.0135563277,
-0.0167560428,
0.0199516099,
0.0523742624,
0.08841113,
-0.0383138582,
0.0204495769,
-0.059946131,
0.0004850868,
-0.0299258083,
0.0003691148,
-0.0531436019,
0.0024158778,
0.0323426649,
0.023616191,
-0.0429618731,
0.0055043893,
-0.0596330985,
0.0692907721,
-0.0375854447,
0.0002130782,
0.0251692012,
-0.0046464591,
0.0523137599,
0.0273800194,
0.0010004995,
0.0141399493,
0.0039415653,
0.0099198045,
0.0026403698,
0.0419068001,
-0.0003669055,
0.033356227,
0.0111959055,
0.0463816784,
-0.0416740254,
-0.0347087719,
-0.0276052952,
-0.000939725,
0.0175280087,
-0.0227850378,
0.0639655069,
-0.0194442179,
0.0197973195,
-0.0346856043,
-0.0273412149,
0.0006560512,
-0.0098091243,
0.0601380467,
-0.0018257961,
-0.0636917055,
0.00994852,
0.092676118,
0.018039139,
0.066494897,
-0.0501354933,
0.0100997239,
-0.0030327202,
-0.0274640638,
0.0253684819,
0.0125123402,
-0.0248043351,
-0.0289270505,
-0.0639412701,
-0.0908983722,
-0.0336417072,
-0.0187532343,
-0.0034993642,
-0.0324690528,
0.024576582,
0.0591590367,
-0.0188251436,
0.0297500119,
-0.0323135331,
-0.0249784086,
0.0190838408,
-0.0235082917,
0.0041302317,
-6.285727554e-33,
-0.0114547089,
-0.0109018395,
0.0101365903,
0.008223854,
-0.0167931132,
0.0214513224,
0.0070337094,
0.0107097272,
-0.0209823698,
-0.0100033041,
-0.043933019,
0.020050602,
0.0207210593,
0.0141993649,
0.0104237022,
-0.0030670292,
0.0532304868,
-0.0286466647,
-0.0391918905,
-0.0065051182,
0.0114355218,
0.0337133892,
0.058897119,
-0.0336870551,
0.0481217429,
-0.0324466228,
-0.0296761449,
-0.0236428212,
-0.0236866213,
0.0574231856,
-0.0207288973,
0.054039564,
0.0362596363,
-0.0461282209,
-0.0401206613,
0.0200254414,
-0.0405015536,
-0.0438774303,
0.0324318521,
0.0200417005,
-0.0135402959,
-0.0090829656,
0.0681725815,
-0.0355525613,
-0.0446435325,
0.024597073,
0.0032106319,
-0.0268955026,
-0.0321183912,
-0.01610169,
-0.0240240581,
0.0171266422,
0.0367016457,
0.0198894944,
0.0467955582,
0.0294470787,
0.0025031501,
0.0262896195,
-0.0384514891,
0.0243005343,
0.055439949,
0.0408181287,
0.0661533773,
0.0059304689,
0.0054869307,
0.0633723661,
-0.000327045,
0.0219793208,
0.0300650001,
-0.0224888343,
0.0626500696,
-0.0020624802,
0.0120154861,
0.0086079016,
0.0521830432,
-0.0483331122,
-0.0480701104,
0.0379188731,
-0.009781519,
0.019417135,
-0.0236209612,
-0.0180602986,
-0.0191662107,
-0.0694512874,
-0.0581803843,
-0.0433671996,
-0.0220378973,
-0.0432122089,
0.0517789796,
-0.021203896,
0.0013708103,
0.0033839378,
0.0033578523,
-0.0121899741,
-0.055912558,
0.001416261,
-0.0311401375,
0.0146706188,
-0.0033034454,
0.0504244678,
-0.0590254515,
-0.029963281,
0.0072977175,
0.0047582565,
0.0105895568,
0.0190726407,
0.0116110826,
0.0378731787,
-0.0922627822,
0.016956225,
-0.0301670209,
0.0435853936,
0.0366771109,
0.0082878219,
0.0691621974,
-0.0195847657,
0.0255156457,
0.0346195027,
0.0486812666,
-0.0098156007,
-0.0473707467,
-0.0081481691,
0.0005573527,
0.0086372066,
-0.011293184,
-0.0287236348,
-0.0115076173,
0.0553270839,
0.0594845712,
-0.0377306715,
-0.0065025459,
-0.0026535906,
2.633e-7,
0.0673039705,
0.0501512252,
0.0071557513,
-0.0020603328,
0.015324967,
0.0014266068,
-0.0423898324,
0.0159831624,
0.0153787648,
0.0102143167,
-0.0038733175,
-0.0321151987,
0.0448838174,
0.0235670265,
-0.0693249926,
-0.0026263117,
-0.028203208,
0.0145790111,
-0.0655178875,
0.0199252591,
0.0125537217,
0.0917588472,
-0.0189642105,
-0.0388122573,
-0.0308614653,
-0.0609058216,
0.0433020219,
-0.0569940023,
-0.0208908357,
0.0286096632,
0.0786287412,
0.0244317707,
0.018382825,
0.0406869575,
-0.0256673079,
0.0128978277,
0.0222659372,
0.0298643876,
-0.0144094387,
-0.0216818918,
-0.0021918153,
-0.0537482575,
-0.0283290464,
-0.0662070215,
0.0848174915,
-0.0106294062,
-0.0165481139,
-0.0132395262,
-0.0345638059,
-0.0571413599,
0.0456672013,
-0.0334150679,
-0.0062910579,
0.0151790474,
0.0101561993,
-0.008781285,
-0.0287501235,
-0.0484531336,
0.0100069782,
-0.0010648841,
-0.0116576366,
-0.0789560005,
-0.0131329847,
-0.0041216547,
0.0149457073,
-0.0802809298,
0.0064925086,
2.746039751e-34,
0.0372381657,
-0.0550847985,
0.0525990501,
0.0055847294,
0.0109185474,
-0.0038456824,
0.0090324366,
0.0371897891,
-0.0360093899,
-0.0689318478,
-0.0050450484
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.